id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03942v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03942v2
|
The Heuristic Core: Understanding Subnetwork Generalization in Pretrained Language Models
| 2024-03-06T18:50:14 | 2024-06-05T17:44:03 |
Adithya Bhaskar, Dan Friedman, Danqi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Prior work has found that pretrained language models (LMs) fine-tuned with
different random seeds can achieve similar in-domain performance but generalize
differently on tests of syntactic generalization. In this work, we show that,
even within a single model, we can find multiple subnetworks that perform
similarly in-domain, but generalize vastly differently. To better understand
these phenomena, we investigate if they can be understood in terms of
"competing subnetworks": the model initially represents a variety of distinct
algorithms, corresponding to different subnetworks, and generalization occurs
when it ultimately converges to one. This explanation has been used to account
for generalization in simple algorithmic tasks ("grokking"). Instead of finding
competing subnetworks, we find that all subnetworks -- whether they generalize
or not -- share a set of attention heads, which we refer to as the heuristic
core. Further analysis suggests that these attention heads emerge early in
training and compute shallow, non-generalizing features. The model learns to
generalize by incorporating additional attention heads, which depend on the
outputs of the "heuristic" heads to compute higher-level features. Overall, our
results offer a more detailed picture of the mechanisms for syntactic
generalization in pretrained LMs.
|
[
-0.4283203184604645,
-0.6595138311386108,
0.4097783863544464,
-0.028849860653281212,
-0.19086049497127533,
0.15102635324001312,
-0.526260495185852,
-0.2687087655067444,
0.14988766610622406,
0.486707866191864,
-0.6899915933609009,
-0.4211115837097168,
-0.8164178729057312,
-0.08832134306430817,
-0.3780810236930847,
0.9624041318893433,
0.21000254154205322,
-0.17212733626365662,
-0.24627476930618286,
-0.08468892425298691,
-0.3626580834388733,
-0.635686993598938,
-0.29710909724235535,
-0.7877845764160156,
0.5957475304603577,
0.38596904277801514,
0.6629205942153931,
0.5879886746406555,
0.6257423162460327,
0.2609034478664398,
-0.10081461817026138,
-0.3048190772533417,
-0.5256226062774658,
-0.020062260329723358,
-0.38690003752708435,
-0.620243489742279,
-0.14203806221485138,
0.1546018421649933,
0.5802714824676514,
1.1256017684936523,
-0.07414068281650543,
0.24974101781845093,
0.18408000469207764,
0.7691630721092224,
-0.5737754702568054,
0.06935891509056091,
-0.7868962287902832,
0.09921681135892868,
-0.52229243516922,
-0.2869427800178528,
-0.23766747117042542,
0.08628910779953003,
0.3536001443862915,
-0.42469725012779236,
0.6434839367866516,
-0.011344155296683311,
0.9328738451004028,
0.23090393841266632,
-0.05459563806653023,
-0.07638996839523315,
-0.6167494654655457,
0.8076888918876648,
-0.6610978841781616,
0.2261149287223816,
0.24595624208450317,
0.5157443284988403,
0.09342466294765472,
-0.658092737197876,
-0.22633621096611023,
-0.30911821126937866,
-0.13421307504177094,
-0.13487766683101654,
-0.28370699286460876,
0.16309572756290436,
0.39453983306884766,
0.6437103748321533,
-0.6235671639442444,
0.1779954433441162,
-0.4123906195163727,
-0.029199587181210518,
0.30217525362968445,
-0.07516898959875107,
0.24666282534599304,
0.32137852907180786,
0.008109922520816326,
-0.0007979249348863959,
-0.6072758436203003,
0.2981632947921753,
0.4767027497291565,
0.5592638850212097,
0.034703418612480164,
0.41948187351226807,
-0.4804324209690094,
0.5935938358306885,
0.18886396288871765,
0.07520297914743423,
0.26766088604927063,
-0.3391457498073578,
-0.29977697134017944,
-0.1263905018568039,
0.712256669998169,
0.0030721279326826334,
0.9694211483001709,
-0.4568522870540619,
-0.19513989984989166,
0.11329983919858932,
0.47223079204559326,
-0.3044152557849884,
-0.42810848355293274,
0.08664511144161224,
-0.4930323362350464,
-0.1605786383152008,
-0.2053932100534439,
-0.021691275760531425,
0.011059275828301907,
-0.21742622554302216,
0.1820627748966217,
-0.29747274518013,
-0.33842265605926514,
0.23842006921768188,
-0.2439262419939041,
-0.005928730592131615,
-0.1962563693523407,
-0.9430546164512634,
0.5322625041007996,
0.7128452658653259,
0.5611082315444946,
-0.18764899671077728,
-0.7940869331359863,
-0.17273718118667603,
-0.08287230134010315,
-0.2665519118309021,
0.8802191615104675,
-0.5719003677368164,
-0.1298210471868515,
-0.17436735332012177,
-0.05273130536079407,
-0.2800276577472687,
-0.828316867351532,
0.14562208950519562,
-0.6680967807769775,
-0.08068738877773285,
-0.49017152190208435,
-0.4194462299346924,
-0.16860437393188477,
0.24905821681022644,
-0.6484328508377075,
0.9348417520523071,
0.15157917141914368,
-0.927844762802124,
0.4032576084136963,
-0.4976033866405487,
-0.5371552109718323,
0.08357489109039307,
-0.26068225502967834,
-0.32792675495147705,
0.5605738162994385,
-0.03743988648056984,
0.4834859073162079,
-0.525708019733429,
0.06060947850346565,
-0.1604713648557663,
-0.3877202272415161,
0.04996300861239433,
0.12582305073738098,
0.6410940289497375,
-0.10703693330287933,
-0.56911301612854,
0.27664974331855774,
-0.33382654190063477,
0.24564670026302338,
0.30081918835639954,
-0.24200667440891266,
-0.4238699972629547,
-0.1020858958363533,
-0.5620534420013428,
0.0052748569287359715,
0.19160524010658264,
-0.2345346212387085,
0.15555758774280548,
-0.2791520357131958,
0.4715246856212616,
0.4406542181968689,
-0.11658427119255066,
0.6895208358764648,
-0.26881131529808044,
0.5713872909545898,
0.42064931988716125,
0.12473110109567642,
-0.33623138070106506,
-0.41237303614616394,
-0.6952746510505676,
0.13608795404434204,
0.3083624243736267,
0.4186137020587921,
-0.3955681324005127,
0.21393883228302002,
-0.21156169474124908,
-0.45925265550613403,
-0.354358434677124,
0.10603120923042297,
0.7007744908332825,
0.3039107620716095,
0.3981758654117584,
-0.606176495552063,
-0.5418602228164673,
-1.4816017150878906,
-0.5604769587516785,
0.23387326300144196,
0.45416349172592163,
0.2133982926607132,
0.5438624620437622,
-0.16192656755447388,
1.0484756231307983,
-0.3442893326282501,
-0.17284011840820312,
-0.5973679423332214,
0.1933499127626419,
0.3824874758720398,
0.6088426113128662,
0.7113619446754456,
-0.4753337502479553,
-0.6310986876487732,
0.11421916633844376,
-0.5725950598716736,
-0.16525331139564514,
0.1540013998746872,
0.045372363179922104,
-0.27410492300987244,
0.4878818690776825,
-0.5859090089797974,
0.2918006479740143,
0.5303968787193298,
0.14635515213012695,
0.8122808337211609,
0.11287853866815567,
-0.11002355068922043,
-0.8339288830757141,
-0.048153962939977646,
-0.0959571897983551,
-0.06771160662174225,
-0.6098579168319702,
0.5250057578086853,
-0.2422487735748291,
0.07905213534832001,
-0.24763856828212738,
0.2005981206893921,
-0.7953119277954102,
-0.5876637101173401,
-0.35665014386177063,
-0.04552684351801872,
-0.18141210079193115,
0.7025790810585022,
-0.28404030203819275,
0.8571632504463196,
0.9241074919700623,
-0.7089390158653259,
0.252042680978775,
-0.31454747915267944,
-0.3767262399196625,
0.2149694561958313,
-0.9530359506607056,
0.31146252155303955,
-0.16565407812595367,
0.07922755926847458,
-0.7985659837722778,
0.0004055210156366229,
-0.04243098199367523,
-0.48817235231399536,
0.02789352275431156,
-0.3209766745567322,
-0.32756438851356506,
-0.41962966322898865,
0.12266457080841064,
0.5955648422241211,
0.4945065677165985,
-0.07337823510169983,
0.5103638172149658,
0.3908146917819977,
-0.018254492431879044,
-0.8379198312759399,
-0.6511629819869995,
-0.10885144770145416,
-0.04469197988510132,
-0.46106475591659546,
0.26139962673187256,
0.07678376138210297,
-0.2635648548603058,
0.34801244735717773,
-0.11218243092298508,
-0.12912936508655548,
0.3214009702205658,
0.12324901670217514,
-0.4404214322566986,
-0.5240335464477539,
-0.22427940368652344,
-0.07995613664388657,
-0.22920911014080048,
0.016402821987867355,
-0.8295633792877197,
0.873403012752533,
-0.27987682819366455,
-0.5298972725868225,
-0.35825997591018677,
0.556668221950531,
0.3833058178424835,
-0.4368749260902405,
0.5690271258354187,
0.5057011842727661,
-0.4733286201953888,
-0.31348082423210144,
-0.4586125314235687,
-0.4047136604785919,
-0.4069533348083496,
0.5162790417671204,
-0.7002742886543274,
-1.082184076309204,
0.7231763601303101,
0.007507072761654854,
0.1676294505596161,
0.4244651198387146,
0.624696671962738,
-0.014264678582549095,
0.8794454336166382,
0.9347540736198425,
0.022391723468899727,
0.3562723696231842,
-0.5007772445678711,
0.029885374009609222,
-0.8426189422607422,
-0.05994565412402153,
-0.6259621977806091,
-0.6043606400489807,
-0.3581294119358063,
-0.260471373796463,
0.06499123573303223,
0.25568974018096924,
-0.06109290570020676,
0.5848617553710938,
-0.328053742647171,
0.9719471335411072,
0.9483283162117004,
-0.2530691921710968,
0.16150924563407898,
0.1843852549791336,
-0.6958703994750977,
-0.07648167759180069,
-0.9700062274932861,
-0.2888910174369812,
0.8094861507415771,
0.29751724004745483,
0.6875348091125488,
-0.011158249340951443,
0.6894941926002502,
0.18549129366874695,
0.38402679562568665,
-0.6223957538604736,
0.4261051416397095,
-0.5081325769424438,
-0.6845633387565613,
-0.2285112589597702,
-0.2945416569709778,
-1.0024373531341553,
0.23854945600032806,
-0.0546119324862957,
-0.686754047870636,
0.01050451211631298,
0.4133366048336029,
-0.48081088066101074,
0.10928972065448761,
-0.7037055492401123,
0.9549477100372314,
-0.0441233366727829,
-0.07265245169401169,
-0.3582378029823303,
-0.49279916286468506,
0.2670067250728607,
0.2397845834493637,
0.08014866709709167,
-0.10660653561353683,
0.37721049785614014,
0.669721245765686,
-0.04563325643539429,
0.9658023118972778,
-0.09015476703643799,
0.05766777694225311,
0.36798804998397827,
0.049078065901994705,
0.17660002410411835,
-0.15622754395008087,
0.3801723122596741,
0.2180657833814621,
-0.32762962579727173,
-0.6456203460693359,
-0.5049193501472473,
0.5492383241653442,
-0.9851287603378296,
-0.8841953873634338,
-0.09592261165380478,
-0.558750331401825,
-0.3148277997970581,
0.49703285098075867,
0.6397246718406677,
0.42029350996017456,
-0.17259924113750458,
0.3310145139694214,
0.9529500603675842,
0.09464313089847565,
0.23264046013355255,
0.27635064721107483,
-0.19954760372638702,
0.007350653875619173,
0.6248806118965149,
0.23362301290035248,
0.39520496129989624,
0.417717844247818,
0.2829970419406891,
0.09578867256641388,
-0.9039835333824158,
-0.05199447274208069,
0.24367737770080566,
-0.7794992327690125,
0.12900210916996002,
-0.8546993732452393,
-0.26339733600616455,
-0.5969808101654053,
0.07027418166399002,
-0.4513549208641052,
-0.3434962332248688,
-0.016807321459054947,
-0.01946084387600422,
-0.23924334347248077,
0.7930738925933838,
0.05675148591399193,
0.8024526238441467,
-0.8606842756271362,
0.021413473412394524,
0.5484423041343689,
0.29523709416389465,
0.18127237260341644,
-0.5167071223258972,
-0.7777295112609863,
-0.1192246526479721,
-0.014739738777279854,
-0.8717774152755737,
-0.01466048788279295,
0.21201235055923462,
1.0361533164978027,
0.2549925744533539,
-0.43135523796081543,
0.43962562084198,
-0.6397832632064819,
0.6214783787727356,
0.06961221247911453,
-0.7501402497291565,
0.21329179406166077,
-0.45278388261795044,
0.571229875087738,
0.7044311165809631,
0.3909458518028259,
-0.5320725440979004,
-0.2508368194103241,
-0.7417020797729492,
-0.7513614296913147,
0.4646020233631134,
0.05333638936281204,
0.03175562992691994,
0.07109851390123367,
0.44860416650772095,
0.19082693755626678,
0.5203274488449097,
-0.649917483329773,
-0.09298638999462128,
-0.10769075155258179,
0.10967472940683365,
-0.23980370163917542,
-0.2770892083644867,
-0.41993170976638794,
0.07933957129716873,
0.4122731387615204,
-0.3101179003715515,
0.2259579300880432,
-0.11962970346212387,
-0.45053768157958984,
-0.10996737331151962,
0.30978259444236755,
0.6442325711250305,
0.631369411945343,
0.13131549954414368,
0.4563266336917877,
-0.1326129138469696,
-0.3156910240650177,
-0.18145015835762024,
-0.17561201751232147,
-0.017725177109241486,
0.010687130503356457,
0.7924988865852356,
1.1180156469345093,
0.28585487604141235,
-0.40638467669487,
0.4113274812698364,
-0.007605789229273796,
-0.257532000541687,
-0.1901070773601532,
0.3072690963745117,
0.3208610713481903,
0.4328947067260742,
0.4764661490917206,
0.20520158112049103,
0.05882824957370758,
-0.6987279653549194,
0.2910090386867523,
0.5205423831939697,
-0.17447201907634735,
-0.7170406579971313,
0.4171656668186188,
0.18674960732460022,
-0.3397451341152191,
0.4171008765697479,
-0.21663610637187958,
-0.9116692543029785,
0.7572717070579529,
0.401572048664093,
1.250064492225647,
-0.06501162052154541,
-0.04873059317469597,
0.12749768793582916,
0.704364538192749,
-0.1897464245557785,
0.1856652945280075,
-0.19888167083263397,
-1.0838980674743652,
-0.4565254747867584,
-0.4795008599758148,
-0.2638678252696991,
0.16757313907146454,
-0.7051092982292175,
-0.26384639739990234,
-0.5720432996749878,
-0.4100647568702698,
-0.08878885209560394,
-0.1577790528535843,
-0.8841376304626465,
0.28359368443489075,
0.07858181744813919,
0.8198239803314209,
-0.9079794883728027,
0.59004145860672,
0.9497964978218079,
-0.10159412026405334,
-0.8008118867874146,
0.25416475534439087,
-0.2984957695007324,
-0.9411575198173523,
0.8178075551986694,
0.2638382911682129,
-0.10013239085674286,
0.25238117575645447,
-0.42509937286376953,
-0.9440250396728516,
0.8912143707275391,
0.2004508376121521,
-0.7579019665718079,
-0.45660242438316345,
0.13396042585372925,
0.44065725803375244,
-0.692238986492157,
0.18738265335559845,
0.6640313267707825,
0.16687263548374176,
-0.20174148678779602,
-1.1797258853912354,
-0.2514282763004303,
-0.3137368857860565,
0.02767227031290531,
-0.0009920336306095123,
-0.6010259985923767,
1.4180457592010498,
-0.309656023979187,
-0.27462586760520935,
-0.38278108835220337,
0.5501367449760437,
0.1506870537996292,
0.039385631680488586,
0.5670763850212097,
0.8123040199279785,
0.4955282211303711,
-0.10810676217079163,
0.9894753098487854,
-0.4773690700531006,
0.4508938193321228,
1.2387558221817017,
-0.1827990710735321,
0.4008656442165375,
0.2514091432094574,
-0.055306486785411835,
0.5455306172370911,
0.6796215772628784,
0.39107218384742737,
0.5398581624031067,
0.3436843752861023,
0.18782252073287964,
-0.4852241575717926,
-0.022519107908010483,
-0.4418480694293976,
0.31919360160827637,
0.18831872940063477,
-0.2957249879837036,
-0.3769214451313019,
-0.027558183297514915,
-0.30172041058540344,
-0.026573162525892258,
-0.2934938073158264,
0.6357309222221375,
0.20895326137542725,
-0.6928375363349915,
0.6513223052024841,
-0.005795271601527929,
0.7195004224777222,
-0.6678586602210999,
0.4494364559650421,
-0.15747012197971344,
0.2610764801502228,
-0.0984184741973877,
-0.654344916343689,
0.38169512152671814,
-0.2705742418766022,
-0.6050773859024048,
-0.12177097797393799,
0.664801836013794,
-0.3384033143520355,
0.06234145537018776,
0.3558526635169983,
0.7909557223320007,
0.13262689113616943,
-0.2548712193965912,
-0.8055220246315002,
0.13937874138355255,
-0.23968051373958588,
-0.47192224860191345,
0.45269638299942017,
0.4355211853981018,
-0.30775973200798035,
0.5491479635238647,
0.5921506285667419,
0.01786538027226925,
0.350777268409729,
0.3953019380569458,
0.9494608044624329,
-0.536410927772522,
-0.7600655555725098,
-0.9071703553199768,
0.3594590425491333,
0.08575130254030228,
-0.5185770988464355,
0.5529570579528809,
0.287535160779953,
0.9752534031867981,
-0.18813000619411469,
0.9732937812805176,
0.20757773518562317,
0.42479008436203003,
-0.5475248098373413,
0.44832971692085266,
-0.50307697057724,
0.08005557209253311,
0.008147038519382477,
-1.0662142038345337,
0.051202286034822464,
0.5059318542480469,
-0.37498077750205994,
0.33061766624450684,
1.0372710227966309,
0.49516603350639343,
-0.15307925641536713,
-0.2557515799999237,
0.3869103491306305,
0.2364131212234497,
0.02381492219865322,
0.6677150726318359,
0.6207804083824158,
0.012580467388033867,
0.19954994320869446,
-0.23324686288833618,
-0.360617995262146,
-0.17662446200847626,
-0.7549784183502197,
-1.2232260704040527,
-0.594038724899292,
-0.10217823088169098,
-0.10344584286212921,
0.3695414960384369,
0.7614122629165649,
0.8600050210952759,
-0.7305207848548889,
-0.3580878674983978,
-0.1638568788766861,
-0.027046112343668938,
-0.402875155210495,
-0.2052621841430664,
-0.18790939450263977,
-0.48170334100723267,
-0.6086496114730835,
0.39731457829475403,
0.2814735770225525,
-0.06392582505941391,
-0.5950825810432434,
0.254395991563797,
-0.14039456844329834,
0.10880885273218155,
0.28439998626708984,
0.2893972098827362,
-0.5430649518966675,
-0.1696435660123825,
0.33882200717926025,
-0.2251238077878952,
-0.05756868049502373,
1.4492322206497192,
-0.8124449849128723,
-0.17275071144104004,
0.5844099521636963,
0.7692067623138428,
0.16896295547485352,
-0.14558447897434235,
0.5277966856956482,
-1.026779294013977,
0.223690003156662,
0.2173037827014923,
0.30615055561065674,
0.33406224846839905,
-0.2357131689786911,
0.3571060299873352,
0.6668834686279297,
-0.4258308708667755,
-0.8204433917999268,
0.7889682054519653,
-0.5249174237251282,
-0.32509809732437134,
0.9391406178474426,
-0.2275034785270691,
-0.33478450775146484,
-0.07447867095470428,
0.22390522062778473,
0.11720313876867294,
-0.11310543119907379,
0.6395118236541748,
0.9119200110435486,
-0.17383065819740295,
-0.3265184760093689,
-0.3636493384838104,
0.5287595391273499,
0.6460312604904175,
-0.4809255599975586,
0.038541991263628006,
-0.09556612372398376,
0.5486989617347717,
0.41826221346855164,
0.9112640619277954,
0.3751606047153473,
0.40657469630241394,
-0.0851803794503212,
0.030264807865023613,
-0.23202146589756012,
-0.6043322086334229,
-0.08152364194393158,
0.33796846866607666,
0.12738029658794403,
0.006077911704778671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03923v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03923v1
|
Did Translation Models Get More Robust Without Anyone Even Noticing?
| 2024-03-06T18:33:51 | 2024-03-06T18:33:51 |
Ben Peters, André F. T. Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural machine translation (MT) models achieve strong results across a
variety of settings, but it is widely believed that they are highly sensitive
to "noisy" inputs, such as spelling errors, abbreviations, and other formatting
issues. In this paper, we revisit this insight in light of recent multilingual
MT models and large language models (LLMs) applied to machine translation.
Somewhat surprisingly, we show through controlled experiments that these models
are far more robust to many kinds of noise than previous models, even when they
perform similarly on clean data. This is notable because, even though LLMs have
more parameters and more complex training processes than past models, none of
the open ones we consider use any techniques specifically designed to encourage
robustness. Next, we show that similar trends hold for social media translation
experiments -- LLMs are more robust to social media text. We include an
analysis of the circumstances in which source correction techniques can be used
to mitigate the effects of noise. Altogether, we show that robustness to many
types of noise has increased.
|
[
-0.049739859998226166,
-0.6702848672866821,
0.7424988746643066,
0.17212605476379395,
-0.2034747153520584,
-0.020724965259432793,
-0.45541998744010925,
-0.5679123997688293,
0.03835207223892212,
0.2445993274450302,
-0.41530632972717285,
-0.3987423777580261,
-1.150288701057434,
0.3209572434425354,
-0.9719254970550537,
0.9398223757743835,
0.20234647393226624,
0.2520785629749298,
0.17582036554813385,
-0.3351863622665405,
-0.1944080889225006,
-0.6560328602790833,
-0.5347640514373779,
-0.2872920632362366,
0.8789323568344116,
-0.3364992141723633,
0.9525967240333557,
0.8589359521865845,
0.781921923160553,
0.2683694362640381,
-0.44581204652786255,
0.21333834528923035,
-0.28934699296951294,
0.4607639014720917,
-0.02369055710732937,
-0.832436740398407,
-0.4468846023082733,
-0.27951106429100037,
0.6637951135635376,
0.7956369519233704,
0.16207030415534973,
0.12389080226421356,
0.3993396461009979,
0.554948627948761,
-0.23858188092708588,
-0.04691155627369881,
-0.8361631631851196,
-0.08567918837070465,
-0.1439894735813141,
-0.1306266039609909,
-0.5348947644233704,
-0.09452508389949799,
-0.21311961114406586,
-0.6645499467849731,
0.1906139850616455,
-0.17968541383743286,
0.9911828637123108,
0.5812897086143494,
-0.4171343147754669,
-0.20713162422180176,
-0.9521256685256958,
0.9005505442619324,
-0.6685606241226196,
0.5723829865455627,
0.4725779891014099,
-0.09824707359075546,
-0.39803841710090637,
-0.7503935098648071,
-0.19919684529304504,
-0.05615485832095146,
0.19913962483406067,
-0.029081806540489197,
-0.5223366022109985,
-0.15921181440353394,
0.31770452857017517,
0.07011593878269196,
-0.15081588923931122,
0.21331913769245148,
-0.2775638699531555,
-0.27376216650009155,
0.34712809324264526,
-0.0811435654759407,
0.3480929136276245,
0.090752013027668,
0.03665069863200188,
-0.12274941802024841,
-0.5813018679618835,
-0.1465829759836197,
0.3636452555656433,
0.43960273265838623,
-0.11867179721593857,
0.7233706712722778,
0.07209862768650055,
0.6254428029060364,
-0.10416673868894577,
-0.04417094960808754,
-0.20025432109832764,
-0.389810711145401,
-0.06659050285816193,
-0.3238331079483032,
0.9139527082443237,
0.4997978210449219,
0.45937973260879517,
-0.26604780554771423,
-0.5280572175979614,
0.03737356886267662,
0.35775378346443176,
-0.5422819256782532,
-0.34539464116096497,
0.007319647818803787,
-0.5396692752838135,
-0.6117750406265259,
-0.14921478927135468,
-0.2591489553451538,
-0.5842041373252869,
-0.26546767354011536,
0.4099413752555847,
-0.19014760851860046,
-0.2544063329696655,
-0.20850247144699097,
0.10310635715723038,
-0.15511426329612732,
0.44111892580986023,
-0.9936774373054504,
0.13726678490638733,
0.8337733149528503,
1.187947154045105,
-0.28472021222114563,
-0.28745684027671814,
-0.6476649641990662,
-0.17187656462192535,
-0.8530739545822144,
0.8186563849449158,
-0.18632054328918457,
-0.0816575437784195,
-0.13045591115951538,
-0.07933993637561798,
-0.08934346586465836,
-0.6364734768867493,
0.47795867919921875,
-0.6349532008171082,
-0.18281862139701843,
-0.6324344873428345,
-0.13462144136428833,
0.06008747220039368,
0.22943927347660065,
-0.47020092606544495,
0.7803914546966553,
0.05975065380334854,
-0.7520363330841064,
0.4555469751358032,
-0.4736644923686981,
-0.49296069145202637,
-0.41730210185050964,
0.1171482652425766,
-0.5708991289138794,
0.5355833768844604,
0.2865099012851715,
0.30167439579963684,
0.08836140483617783,
0.3116582930088043,
-0.5278213620185852,
-0.408732533454895,
0.9836039543151855,
-0.7278439402580261,
0.807878315448761,
0.23275317251682281,
-0.1465691775083542,
0.11325980722904205,
-0.6111400723457336,
-0.11297537386417389,
-0.06383577734231949,
-0.6764578819274902,
-0.33479392528533936,
-0.009523439221084118,
-0.12194588780403137,
0.43885040283203125,
-0.14340484142303467,
-0.2794674336910248,
-0.07838691771030426,
-0.3095085620880127,
0.9598466157913208,
0.840202808380127,
-0.23902766406536102,
0.5089807510375977,
-0.5008514523506165,
0.34417715668678284,
0.19204936921596527,
0.05139285326004028,
-0.06004292890429497,
-0.6940807700157166,
-0.6883388161659241,
-0.2022322714328766,
0.4699559211730957,
0.24614742398262024,
-0.4485742449760437,
0.11501247435808182,
-0.43817079067230225,
-0.1875457763671875,
-0.7537475824356079,
0.4254463016986847,
0.05597762018442154,
0.24669775366783142,
0.1716531366109848,
-0.14957867562770844,
-0.30630728602409363,
-0.6139659881591797,
-0.7192116975784302,
-0.2571452856063843,
-0.12925609946250916,
-0.08220931142568588,
0.37689724564552307,
-0.20680394768714905,
0.2825572192668915,
-0.06992848962545395,
0.07071834802627563,
-0.15189002454280853,
0.06294652074575424,
0.018925350159406662,
0.33682990074157715,
0.36971622705459595,
-0.7277594804763794,
-0.46850478649139404,
0.1077817901968956,
-0.6861880421638489,
-0.3133622705936432,
-0.09681869298219681,
-0.010237890295684338,
0.206046923995018,
0.7984462976455688,
-0.6241039633750916,
0.3176257312297821,
0.7631800770759583,
0.11838626861572266,
0.28449052572250366,
-0.11872778832912445,
-0.13975712656974792,
-1.1556731462478638,
0.11417670547962189,
-0.14706797897815704,
-0.5586971044540405,
-0.7709563970565796,
0.0403791218996048,
0.12776345014572144,
0.21347759664058685,
-0.33450770378112793,
0.18986637890338898,
-0.5452314019203186,
-0.10765567421913147,
-0.3749794065952301,
0.05198490992188454,
0.04479866474866867,
0.24379156529903412,
-0.30759555101394653,
0.7042890787124634,
0.5948627591133118,
-0.6848737597465515,
-0.10268263518810272,
0.08900593966245651,
-0.3858197331428528,
0.4010879397392273,
-0.6485058665275574,
0.08772999048233032,
-0.24889780580997467,
-0.19243760406970978,
-0.9991043210029602,
-0.5428948998451233,
0.20080693066120148,
-0.6613113880157471,
0.44137948751449585,
-0.17394256591796875,
-0.6341790556907654,
-0.21285897493362427,
-0.10973530262708664,
0.0010967866983264685,
0.43921008706092834,
-0.3989085853099823,
0.4271015524864197,
0.1266568899154663,
-0.22256843745708466,
-0.3551490008831024,
-1.2449909448623657,
0.27976617217063904,
-0.29159778356552124,
-0.47693514823913574,
-0.27485284209251404,
-0.12315230816602707,
-0.5035572052001953,
-0.1499914526939392,
-0.34178879857063293,
-0.41078445315361023,
0.6196807622909546,
0.3583140969276428,
0.22380056977272034,
-0.30463579297065735,
0.14090661704540253,
-0.02797652781009674,
-0.03330588713288307,
0.16059140861034393,
-0.2559656500816345,
0.325564980506897,
-0.029040317982435226,
-0.4193435609340668,
-0.5534070134162903,
0.157912477850914,
0.8010293245315552,
-0.0872495099902153,
0.9372533559799194,
0.5953131914138794,
-0.3238126039505005,
-0.11828092485666275,
-0.40994298458099365,
-0.3723374307155609,
-0.4560245871543884,
0.5378175377845764,
-0.11172384768724442,
-0.7576912641525269,
0.5628946423530579,
0.03186589851975441,
0.08644525706768036,
0.34090548753738403,
0.6215366125106812,
-0.2139378786087036,
1.4893189668655396,
0.667622983455658,
0.21443915367126465,
0.6962915062904358,
0.2611316442489624,
0.3042076528072357,
-0.8575817942619324,
0.0028629328589886427,
-0.6257630586624146,
-0.542378842830658,
-0.8009136915206909,
-0.15585538744926453,
0.2564021050930023,
0.1498757153749466,
-0.02368011884391308,
0.2179139107465744,
-0.471395879983902,
0.3202369213104248,
0.611652135848999,
0.02465754561126232,
0.5674033164978027,
0.3737218379974365,
0.037391260266304016,
-0.3251287043094635,
-0.8664683103561401,
-0.41886037588119507,
1.2791310548782349,
0.4133172631263733,
0.8030896186828613,
0.055667076259851456,
0.395112544298172,
0.0015536417486146092,
0.7164093852043152,
-0.7225050330162048,
0.1182205006480217,
-0.21211838722229004,
-0.6837254166603088,
0.031431395560503006,
-0.5548079609870911,
-1.0187569856643677,
0.17758649587631226,
-0.39763861894607544,
-0.5928629040718079,
0.3078072667121887,
0.19757767021656036,
-0.6536014676094055,
0.4279271960258484,
-0.661845326423645,
0.4637528359889984,
-0.29406553506851196,
-0.19111013412475586,
0.3518936038017273,
-0.7838494181632996,
0.3093399405479431,
-0.5922428369522095,
0.4535578787326813,
-0.06283468753099442,
-0.1293831765651703,
0.5238948464393616,
-0.20512527227401733,
0.799365758895874,
0.39208346605300903,
-0.13951647281646729,
0.11747491359710693,
0.2912804186344147,
0.547715425491333,
-0.27399492263793945,
-0.07555986940860748,
0.29326629638671875,
-0.13527575135231018,
-0.4356224238872528,
-0.4815574288368225,
0.69694584608078,
-0.9066159129142761,
-0.38585299253463745,
-0.18758496642112732,
-0.8247339129447937,
0.10697612911462784,
0.48435601592063904,
0.6576827764511108,
0.21976090967655182,
0.0644514337182045,
0.46536681056022644,
0.848660945892334,
-0.07993197441101074,
0.4422357976436615,
0.5312544703483582,
-0.2416561394929886,
-0.35422590374946594,
0.7185348272323608,
0.5145902037620544,
0.595519483089447,
0.215803861618042,
0.24700281023979187,
-0.06218547001481056,
-0.8108018040657043,
-0.3222801089286804,
0.10661721974611282,
-0.604880690574646,
-0.13585422933101654,
-1.0033936500549316,
-0.15136896073818207,
-0.37590330839157104,
-0.029673654586076736,
-0.6046914458274841,
-0.6306201219558716,
-0.2603711783885956,
-0.09500282257795334,
0.13828106224536896,
1.0071157217025757,
-0.2999458312988281,
0.5937373638153076,
-0.8494850993156433,
0.34832051396369934,
0.11834940314292908,
0.273648738861084,
-0.2790897488594055,
-0.7915705442428589,
-0.3611629009246826,
0.1922386884689331,
-0.373174786567688,
-0.8274861574172974,
0.5039388537406921,
0.18998417258262634,
0.06878110766410828,
0.4245707392692566,
-0.11465370655059814,
0.4256844222545624,
-0.24085849523544312,
0.7094440460205078,
-0.19492404162883759,
-0.6713321208953857,
0.18131610751152039,
-0.6042059659957886,
0.48087742924690247,
0.2391451895236969,
-0.003717915154993534,
-0.38580185174942017,
-0.7270976901054382,
-0.485103040933609,
-0.7150446772575378,
0.5537573099136353,
0.2744019329547882,
0.3717881739139557,
-0.05434655025601387,
0.3789493143558502,
-0.05677850544452667,
0.3152557909488678,
-0.9582555294036865,
-0.14227890968322754,
-0.04245945066213608,
-0.0030821554828435183,
0.09055397659540176,
-0.12647539377212524,
-0.2134082317352295,
-0.19185996055603027,
0.4333583116531372,
0.08678845316171646,
0.05565987899899483,
0.21329808235168457,
-0.20853018760681152,
-0.4804176092147827,
0.2777116298675537,
0.8091755509376526,
0.5776469707489014,
-0.0018067024648189545,
0.3390851318836212,
0.1540532261133194,
-0.41899609565734863,
-0.0322895385324955,
0.000045599397708429024,
-0.5812779068946838,
0.22912701964378357,
0.60895836353302,
0.7372094392776489,
0.17676056921482086,
-0.33644235134124756,
0.6906600594520569,
-0.1279383897781372,
-0.3488944172859192,
-0.0167267806828022,
-0.04092233255505562,
0.3644092381000519,
0.2392653077840805,
0.04507904499769211,
0.9545401930809021,
-0.2968887686729431,
-0.529844343662262,
-0.0834183543920517,
0.3280918300151825,
-0.5555278658866882,
-0.6249257922172546,
1.2285326719284058,
-0.19806240499019623,
-0.4175107181072235,
0.48216140270233154,
0.0022197365760803223,
-0.5557975769042969,
0.23803623020648956,
0.5063381791114807,
0.7796382904052734,
-0.2463592141866684,
-0.014611799269914627,
0.017859427258372307,
0.8263612985610962,
-0.4810766577720642,
0.164163738489151,
0.13079361617565155,
-0.6333450675010681,
-0.5834716558456421,
-0.5435976386070251,
-0.26035913825035095,
0.1901322901248932,
-0.7444634437561035,
0.06081343814730644,
-0.3666454553604126,
-0.6527639031410217,
0.04676157981157303,
-0.49142077565193176,
-0.6497665643692017,
-0.037965841591358185,
0.032280128449201584,
0.6590161323547363,
-0.9672306776046753,
0.704314112663269,
0.8936634063720703,
-0.050992317497730255,
-0.7424311637878418,
0.0006367652676999569,
0.06682930886745453,
-0.6460861563682556,
0.41202136874198914,
0.11750481277704239,
0.11055005341768265,
-0.039233528077602386,
-0.8077923059463501,
-0.9193530678749084,
0.572160542011261,
0.8373863697052002,
-0.4570537209510803,
0.06566742807626724,
0.3865058422088623,
0.8557682633399963,
0.09846920520067215,
-0.17249739170074463,
0.3941556215286255,
0.4952777326107025,
-0.1517373025417328,
-0.7478104829788208,
-0.14935077726840973,
-0.19854548573493958,
-0.048066455870866776,
0.1429986208677292,
-0.6846014261245728,
0.7825788259506226,
-0.26749318838119507,
-0.23756767809391022,
0.21324069797992706,
0.5042636394500732,
-0.2687378227710724,
0.2640083134174347,
0.09702581912279129,
0.3385954797267914,
0.8126454949378967,
-0.3117179274559021,
1.1470177173614502,
-0.3432806134223938,
-0.13569410145282745,
1.0991803407669067,
-0.09821709245443344,
0.8504886627197266,
0.5416567325592041,
0.04644167050719261,
-0.03966358304023743,
0.43608567118644714,
0.05211609974503517,
0.2965189814567566,
-0.08308142423629761,
-0.028180986642837524,
-0.5660765767097473,
-0.18747888505458832,
-0.23158350586891174,
0.03946443647146225,
0.1896795928478241,
-0.6198917031288147,
-0.02375575713813305,
-0.04934842139482498,
0.25407877564430237,
0.22269991040229797,
-0.15836524963378906,
0.8848896026611328,
0.4853270947933197,
-0.6251091957092285,
0.44205039739608765,
-0.039032865315675735,
0.6499640941619873,
-0.5885461568832397,
0.4128393232822418,
-0.3192029893398285,
0.3141401410102844,
-0.24369081854820251,
-0.6475209593772888,
0.65067058801651,
0.11768676340579987,
-0.2718421518802643,
-0.4062153100967407,
0.6977125406265259,
-0.31729447841644287,
-0.5556055307388306,
0.289966344833374,
0.7885262370109558,
0.31124448776245117,
-0.5500012636184692,
-0.43452778458595276,
0.4546735882759094,
-0.02900567650794983,
-0.2917320132255554,
0.4707818627357483,
0.6908257007598877,
-0.09784399718046188,
0.8184106945991516,
0.9276923537254333,
0.5100452899932861,
0.7280772924423218,
-0.031338341534137726,
0.8154850006103516,
-0.3267814815044403,
0.08153019100427628,
-1.0392601490020752,
0.3392776548862457,
0.09609634429216385,
-0.27899378538131714,
0.9260305762290955,
0.19609513878822327,
0.6994904279708862,
0.08374986052513123,
0.6306247711181641,
0.46155768632888794,
0.4163818657398224,
-0.21592873334884644,
0.9957664012908936,
-0.5586207509040833,
0.3544461727142334,
-0.09794183820486069,
-0.9977754354476929,
-0.746162474155426,
0.3525276780128479,
-0.07892011106014252,
0.014539475552737713,
0.6102768778800964,
0.9369685053825378,
0.04870991408824921,
-0.3413897156715393,
0.5952211618423462,
0.7523608207702637,
0.22970843315124512,
0.003164587775245309,
0.9972807765007019,
-0.5371987819671631,
0.9261489510536194,
-0.13918356597423553,
0.10222169756889343,
-0.030020691454410553,
-0.8359783887863159,
-0.9315053820610046,
-0.23834741115570068,
-0.37707337737083435,
-0.626523494720459,
0.23926228284835815,
0.8113897442817688,
0.6737124919891357,
-0.8558676242828369,
0.16610541939735413,
-0.16055996716022491,
0.2618545591831207,
-0.4252583086490631,
-0.08694542199373245,
0.19084395468235016,
-0.18222352862358093,
-0.7703186869621277,
0.5962902903556824,
0.18991592526435852,
0.360666424036026,
0.12159425020217896,
0.20707592368125916,
0.16869071125984192,
0.20310844480991364,
0.5423142313957214,
0.07328080385923386,
-0.5272132158279419,
-0.16411782801151276,
0.36992135643959045,
-0.5107612609863281,
0.29256775975227356,
0.4582078456878662,
-0.07777457684278488,
0.47722581028938293,
0.5171629786491394,
0.5572320818901062,
0.17856457829475403,
0.07430272549390793,
0.8299104571342468,
-0.601626455783844,
-0.054477471858263016,
-0.1333657056093216,
0.26971736550331116,
0.7783041596412659,
-0.3509310185909271,
0.33944788575172424,
0.16048790514469147,
-0.6741907000541687,
-1.112204670906067,
-0.013889116235077381,
-0.5504775047302246,
-0.13639207184314728,
1.0796616077423096,
-0.12357404083013535,
-0.31136414408683777,
-0.14743869006633759,
0.022705605253577232,
0.4978393614292145,
-0.19745150208473206,
1.0348889827728271,
1.0919735431671143,
0.2810417413711548,
-0.018697615712881088,
-1.0521456003189087,
0.3153705298900604,
0.7538898587226868,
-0.2398374378681183,
0.028471609577536583,
0.11404452472925186,
0.4835287034511566,
0.12246755510568619,
0.3598584532737732,
-0.25646594166755676,
0.12646739184856415,
0.07736804336309433,
-0.45375552773475647,
-0.025066819041967392,
-0.31995877623558044,
-0.6304742693901062,
-0.09290314465761185,
0.5927078127861023,
0.07497281581163406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03920v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03920v1
|
Enhancing Instructional Quality: Leveraging Computer-Assisted Textual Analysis to Generate In-Depth Insights from Educational Artifacts
| 2024-03-06T18:29:18 | 2024-03-06T18:29:18 |
Zewei Tian, Min Sun, Alex Liu, Shawon Sarkar, Jing Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
This paper explores the transformative potential of computer-assisted textual
analysis in enhancing instructional quality through in-depth insights from
educational artifacts. We integrate Richard Elmore's Instructional Core
Framework to examine how artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML)
methods, particularly natural language processing (NLP), can analyze
educational content, teacher discourse, and student responses to foster
instructional improvement. Through a comprehensive review and case studies
within the Instructional Core Framework, we identify key areas where AI/ML
integration offers significant advantages, including teacher coaching, student
support, and content development. We unveil patterns that indicate AI/ML not
only streamlines administrative tasks but also introduces novel pathways for
personalized learning, providing actionable feedback for educators and
contributing to a richer understanding of instructional dynamics. This paper
emphasizes the importance of aligning AI/ML technologies with pedagogical goals
to realize their full potential in educational settings, advocating for a
balanced approach that considers ethical considerations, data quality, and the
integration of human expertise.
|
[
-0.26909297704696655,
-1.2772853374481201,
0.29882586002349854,
-0.3006187081336975,
0.0233718603849411,
0.5316497683525085,
-0.19727401435375214,
-0.4675404727458954,
-0.19699381291866302,
0.42203640937805176,
-0.4145435094833374,
-0.7050154209136963,
-0.634709894657135,
0.13153983652591705,
-0.7789152264595032,
0.9514974355697632,
0.0919167771935463,
0.2292863428592682,
-0.45766013860702515,
0.03982353210449219,
-0.7992169260978699,
-0.704684317111969,
-0.6477737426757812,
-0.1660582274198532,
0.19268277287483215,
0.8133729696273804,
0.7273598909378052,
0.9697291254997253,
0.85574871301651,
0.31077516078948975,
0.21453450620174408,
0.48471367359161377,
-0.19096529483795166,
-0.027966829016804695,
-0.12926259636878967,
-0.4387674629688263,
-0.5901859402656555,
-0.054095249623060226,
0.7414554357528687,
0.9650248289108276,
0.07302415370941162,
0.3206280469894409,
0.8111604452133179,
0.8334992527961731,
-0.5910001993179321,
0.08823642879724503,
-0.21399369835853577,
0.2444659322500229,
-0.038805704563856125,
-0.3665432631969452,
-0.38870474696159363,
-0.5433544516563416,
0.44928276538848877,
-0.672304093837738,
0.10609691590070724,
-0.22032694518566132,
0.7229283452033997,
0.5643543004989624,
-0.24463769793510437,
-0.5685047507286072,
-0.9298308491706848,
1.028861403465271,
-0.626312255859375,
0.2574833035469055,
0.6349959373474121,
0.11899805814027786,
0.04450325667858124,
-0.7025274634361267,
-0.4169139266014099,
0.00439370796084404,
-0.09740356355905533,
0.13760653138160706,
0.20625506341457367,
0.05756168067455292,
-0.12900611758232117,
0.38408297300338745,
-0.4076927900314331,
0.29391831159591675,
-0.4092370867729187,
-0.036109793931245804,
0.7002029418945312,
0.3834768533706665,
0.53901207447052,
0.136394202709198,
-0.06361623853445053,
-0.3781000077724457,
-0.3095199167728424,
0.5663838982582092,
0.29877930879592896,
0.1538105458021164,
0.18909907341003418,
0.4630417823791504,
0.2546707093715668,
0.6518200039863586,
-0.056085966527462006,
-0.2622026801109314,
-0.07575151324272156,
-0.32742592692375183,
-0.14604125916957855,
0.23985536396503448,
0.5070363283157349,
0.2630741596221924,
0.04020560905337334,
-0.10198026895523071,
-0.019075948745012283,
-0.059800051152706146,
0.42941030859947205,
-0.666703999042511,
-0.20703572034835815,
0.35132578015327454,
-0.6699377298355103,
-0.3085675537586212,
0.562670886516571,
-0.8878815174102783,
-0.19737184047698975,
-1.1021077632904053,
0.28497788310050964,
-0.7602524161338806,
0.06409765034914017,
-0.2357127070426941,
-0.2711927592754364,
0.23433956503868103,
0.45912909507751465,
-1.059411644935608,
0.4938638210296631,
0.9978731274604797,
0.6608271598815918,
-0.4414146840572357,
-0.3215177059173584,
-0.3482840657234192,
0.03463001176714897,
-0.35280829668045044,
0.8830424547195435,
-0.771060049533844,
-0.7301721572875977,
0.3593471944332123,
-0.3829759657382965,
0.08226001262664795,
-0.6043943166732788,
0.4255249500274658,
-0.1794368326663971,
0.5270944237709045,
-0.05619847774505615,
-0.9362757802009583,
-0.38896626234054565,
0.39224928617477417,
-0.6959428787231445,
1.2160601615905762,
0.14254912734031677,
-0.3572291135787964,
0.24066008627414703,
-0.8813648223876953,
-0.5272942185401917,
-0.05441129207611084,
-0.20274204015731812,
-0.4430263936519623,
-0.047472383826971054,
0.3354763984680176,
0.2456667125225067,
-0.09358955174684525,
0.2451813817024231,
0.12600697576999664,
-0.5920693278312683,
0.3226397931575775,
-0.5137344002723694,
0.9454169869422913,
-0.013833344914019108,
-0.6108391880989075,
0.20333696901798248,
-0.7991957664489746,
0.21646541357040405,
-0.20327872037887573,
-0.5823227167129517,
-0.410392165184021,
0.15224505960941315,
-0.00654340535402298,
-0.4512178301811218,
0.29843854904174805,
0.016682948917150497,
0.2142321765422821,
-0.3287176489830017,
0.04619400575757027,
0.7833725214004517,
-0.14085063338279724,
0.6711037755012512,
-0.3905414938926697,
0.3685184121131897,
-0.26665130257606506,
0.4910702407360077,
-0.5124813914299011,
-0.2802812159061432,
-0.8412889242172241,
-0.06390547007322311,
0.21932418644428253,
0.6804977655410767,
-0.6937147974967957,
0.5741519331932068,
-0.04547566547989845,
-0.33977213501930237,
-0.7918878793716431,
0.37165960669517517,
0.3173620104789734,
0.6314478516578674,
0.642459511756897,
-0.3966914117336273,
-0.38725051283836365,
-0.3869676887989044,
-0.18296760320663452,
-0.19556234776973724,
-0.08342112600803375,
0.15818922221660614,
0.30626192688941956,
-0.0284950602799654,
1.0557096004486084,
-0.3088408410549164,
-0.4538949131965637,
0.001595127279870212,
0.44820719957351685,
0.10394715517759323,
0.7420522570610046,
0.3468647301197052,
-0.792255699634552,
-0.7351990938186646,
0.12173762172460556,
-0.9461864233016968,
-0.016677668318152428,
-0.2467038780450821,
-0.29617154598236084,
-0.02735893614590168,
0.19002901017665863,
-0.004445990547537804,
0.5681564807891846,
0.08944067358970642,
-0.274013489484787,
0.4989786148071289,
-0.1330161690711975,
0.590944230556488,
-0.8018410205841064,
0.09791025519371033,
-0.2127854973077774,
0.3181658089160919,
-0.7214756608009338,
0.01760758087038994,
-0.013816408812999725,
-0.18865594267845154,
-0.037555620074272156,
0.27542054653167725,
-0.21168360114097595,
-0.001493609044700861,
-0.3848135471343994,
0.19517280161380768,
0.23872539401054382,
0.36541548371315,
-0.0636051669716835,
0.8520687222480774,
0.16972513496875763,
-0.5013018846511841,
0.08654442429542542,
0.43392452597618103,
-0.05673102289438248,
1.0229456424713135,
-0.5945154428482056,
0.22906683385372162,
0.053396355360746384,
-0.2300742268562317,
-0.5091667771339417,
-0.2085847407579422,
0.20317107439041138,
-0.5993049144744873,
0.5369434356689453,
0.09992220252752304,
-0.3619878590106964,
0.010786806233227253,
-0.7304382920265198,
0.03106183372437954,
0.5592182278633118,
-0.4856843948364258,
0.6115171313285828,
0.29830825328826904,
-0.24481917917728424,
-0.8753885626792908,
-0.49926725029945374,
0.2281295508146286,
-0.057161957025527954,
-0.33050256967544556,
0.5013145208358765,
-0.1440281718969345,
-0.4842810034751892,
0.31844204664230347,
-0.017551235854625702,
-0.6677746772766113,
0.4427756667137146,
0.08316566795110703,
0.7057525515556335,
-0.41342368721961975,
0.10050410777330399,
0.5250225067138672,
-0.06566770374774933,
0.27161499857902527,
-0.35601991415023804,
0.028835132718086243,
0.12566915154457092,
-0.5047996640205383,
-0.9907442331314087,
0.6161800622940063,
0.3787379860877991,
-0.3327369689941406,
0.6569312214851379,
0.7058640122413635,
-0.3129524886608124,
-0.16132976114749908,
-0.3291081190109253,
-0.4962511360645294,
-0.41845738887786865,
0.2655649781227112,
0.2293853908777237,
-0.7314794659614563,
-0.06827641278505325,
0.1885923594236374,
0.5992799997329712,
0.2936895489692688,
0.02032523788511753,
-0.5772023797035217,
1.0387749671936035,
0.9010067582130432,
-0.12076637893915176,
0.810578465461731,
-0.6660531759262085,
-0.013965795747935772,
-0.7471060752868652,
-0.5069388151168823,
-0.7139780521392822,
-0.30886131525039673,
-0.2315371185541153,
-0.14170987904071808,
0.34133750200271606,
0.13845662772655487,
-0.3834558427333832,
-0.0087435869500041,
-1.1020276546478271,
0.323781281709671,
1.095112919807434,
0.3000084161758423,
0.5154778957366943,
0.06183731183409691,
0.3733169734477997,
-0.12382018566131592,
-0.5210253000259399,
-0.9939884543418884,
1.041029930114746,
0.30221399664878845,
0.4624823033809662,
-0.05649295449256897,
0.565816342830658,
0.7528931498527527,
0.5162373781204224,
-0.7898015975952148,
0.44637376070022583,
-0.31147825717926025,
-0.5806894302368164,
-0.5514571666717529,
-0.1688424050807953,
-0.8336817622184753,
-0.051461465656757355,
-0.5472938418388367,
-0.4609403610229492,
0.05097297951579094,
0.24391886591911316,
-0.2071632593870163,
0.2970564067363739,
-0.7682825326919556,
0.8059970736503601,
-0.47341251373291016,
-0.40256810188293457,
-0.41840118169784546,
-0.44508540630340576,
-0.013836388476192951,
0.02690962143242359,
0.17181599140167236,
0.19680558145046234,
-0.1302957534790039,
0.8504448533058167,
-0.4433482587337494,
0.9241073727607727,
-0.014112290926277637,
0.11261868476867676,
0.6895493865013123,
-0.0588720329105854,
0.013988072983920574,
-0.3360247313976288,
-0.11619841307401657,
0.11246909946203232,
-0.07286757975816727,
-0.5425846576690674,
-0.849672257900238,
0.3860161602497101,
-1.095545768737793,
-0.6274067759513855,
-0.10396313667297363,
-0.39193934202194214,
0.059532828629016876,
0.11583855748176575,
-0.027056852355599403,
0.49485915899276733,
-0.13763664662837982,
0.21860536932945251,
0.807442307472229,
-0.07068552821874619,
0.4982469379901886,
0.25805196166038513,
0.4763851761817932,
-0.4037662744522095,
1.2173283100128174,
0.39861100912094116,
-0.07879526168107986,
0.6351838111877441,
0.1564861685037613,
-0.05156928300857544,
-0.7278416156768799,
-0.35471370816230774,
-0.12460390478372574,
-0.8322962522506714,
-0.2777973413467407,
-0.3090915381908417,
-0.2688460946083069,
-0.28425347805023193,
-0.4906243085861206,
-0.03903134539723396,
-0.1900101602077484,
-0.9514069557189941,
-0.010762684047222137,
0.07250016927719116,
0.8162417411804199,
0.19200949370861053,
0.40974411368370056,
-1.1182661056518555,
-0.14104095101356506,
0.41821131110191345,
-0.008555385284125805,
0.281298965215683,
-0.5543164014816284,
-0.47662755846977234,
0.13326126337051392,
-0.7562804222106934,
-0.616693913936615,
0.27506372332572937,
0.47965678572654724,
0.5470598340034485,
0.5275033712387085,
-0.05488070100545883,
0.7122310400009155,
-0.40214046835899353,
0.9814633131027222,
0.057498931884765625,
-1.032393217086792,
0.8257336616516113,
0.17474797368049622,
-0.001964833587408066,
0.532572329044342,
0.4497407078742981,
-0.1029474064707756,
-0.46563366055488586,
-0.3975498378276825,
-0.8520833253860474,
0.6123158931732178,
-0.00416554557159543,
0.24195635318756104,
0.24373021721839905,
0.3043205142021179,
0.43931296467781067,
0.163103848695755,
-0.2984933853149414,
-0.16027364134788513,
-0.5576597452163696,
-0.7042840719223022,
0.3344325125217438,
-0.13299968838691711,
-0.10752411931753159,
-0.2490430474281311,
0.6402335166931152,
-0.17408032715320587,
-0.05353260040283203,
0.23860794305801392,
-0.2997276484966278,
0.22659413516521454,
0.29807862639427185,
0.3095460534095764,
0.815152645111084,
0.14041553437709808,
-0.06558556854724884,
0.24354945123195648,
-0.7168745398521423,
-0.16693781316280365,
-0.04339398071169853,
-0.07057096064090729,
-0.04189362749457359,
0.967521607875824,
0.34224820137023926,
0.3476681709289551,
-0.6815407276153564,
0.2253490835428238,
0.046966034919023514,
0.004744095727801323,
-0.3375690281391144,
0.4783259332180023,
-0.4977385699748993,
0.18759411573410034,
0.8635941743850708,
-0.20483702421188354,
0.4640350043773651,
-0.49879565834999084,
0.23911385238170624,
0.21775594353675842,
-0.4955357611179352,
-0.3214462995529175,
0.5750507712364197,
0.4528498649597168,
-0.6827836036682129,
0.8346190452575684,
0.5249510407447815,
-0.17670948803424835,
0.8876641392707825,
0.3547782003879547,
0.7922362685203552,
-0.38066619634628296,
0.2983945608139038,
0.3378899097442627,
0.1627965271472931,
0.2477487027645111,
-0.028993194922804832,
-0.4816725254058838,
-0.2377648949623108,
-0.41389718651771545,
-0.1673901081085205,
-0.8339919447898865,
-0.3988444209098816,
-0.8700013160705566,
0.11113263666629791,
-0.5852472186088562,
-0.11614969372749329,
-0.07156690955162048,
0.10599315166473389,
-0.33113986253738403,
0.37425467371940613,
-0.04980798810720444,
0.6519997715950012,
-0.5953165292739868,
0.5292782783508301,
0.7719915509223938,
-0.5760853886604309,
-0.6663705706596375,
-0.1830725520849228,
0.04269210249185562,
-0.5890700221061707,
0.5862452983856201,
0.08174913376569748,
-0.014107344672083855,
-0.01888408698141575,
-0.6435965299606323,
-0.4432217478752136,
1.2169904708862305,
0.0004000401240773499,
-0.3297984302043915,
-0.0315493643283844,
0.2663084864616394,
0.7822612524032593,
-0.31937864422798157,
0.37055131793022156,
0.708930492401123,
0.3686258792877197,
-0.3291788101196289,
-0.3637527525424957,
-0.45541372895240784,
-0.0955963134765625,
-0.18076547980308533,
0.014040263369679451,
-0.023579057306051254,
0.35804829001426697,
-0.07413075119256973,
-0.2514963150024414,
0.046283092349767685,
0.8052001595497131,
-0.23655354976654053,
0.7021697759628296,
0.0872693881392479,
0.25011807680130005,
0.9152078032493591,
-0.16271167993545532,
0.7815740704536438,
-0.3606437146663666,
0.11723804473876953,
1.0461652278900146,
0.26424744725227356,
0.912335216999054,
0.446200966835022,
-0.3435041606426239,
0.7717627882957458,
0.5915542840957642,
-0.150545135140419,
0.04655502364039421,
-0.41103342175483704,
-0.40202704071998596,
0.18040327727794647,
-0.3909653425216675,
-0.24801962077617645,
0.41445672512054443,
0.5405272841453552,
-0.3010830879211426,
0.20600828528404236,
0.07883422076702118,
-0.00873279944062233,
0.7181972861289978,
-0.4798588752746582,
0.9229283332824707,
-0.2159622311592102,
-0.619234561920166,
0.17413878440856934,
-0.3041257858276367,
0.4427580237388611,
-0.22783173620700836,
-0.5224995613098145,
-0.2453419268131256,
-0.02921687625348568,
-0.530448317527771,
-1.003675103187561,
0.4684801995754242,
0.1589290201663971,
-0.16293886303901672,
-0.2629099488258362,
0.4910341799259186,
-0.3596382439136505,
-0.3667302429676056,
-0.09069786965847015,
0.3724581301212311,
-0.17379091680049896,
0.32261785864830017,
-0.7220399975776672,
0.05330035090446472,
-0.17132636904716492,
0.0959184542298317,
0.20136511325836182,
0.39482080936431885,
0.0754346251487732,
0.5756750106811523,
0.8924304246902466,
-0.20336951315402985,
-0.2815473675727844,
0.007829109206795692,
0.6128794550895691,
-0.5760188698768616,
-0.009276404045522213,
-0.8805641531944275,
1.0423905849456787,
-0.4386926293373108,
-0.44881752133369446,
0.5779769420623779,
0.3869990408420563,
0.899592936038971,
0.1658766120672226,
0.588568925857544,
0.07061038166284561,
0.3749621510505676,
-0.4616493582725525,
0.5217227935791016,
-0.22619538009166718,
0.3840137720108032,
-0.1306358277797699,
-0.8821782469749451,
-0.36010807752609253,
0.38403794169425964,
-0.10821791738271713,
-0.16530917584896088,
0.7040811777114868,
0.17621755599975586,
0.2111452966928482,
0.12235577404499054,
0.23304225504398346,
-0.1595063954591751,
0.3474353551864624,
-0.0015193205326795578,
0.8245209455490112,
-0.4926319420337677,
0.4784143567085266,
-0.45625701546669006,
-0.467710942029953,
-0.17887495458126068,
-0.4341035485267639,
-1.1039173603057861,
-0.6204913258552551,
-0.441672682762146,
-0.0419929102063179,
0.1498529016971588,
0.9604430198669434,
0.44225651025772095,
-0.819370687007904,
-0.4291544258594513,
0.04130189120769501,
0.5257050395011902,
-0.36349764466285706,
-0.34506508708000183,
0.6699520945549011,
-0.7013193964958191,
-1.0045210123062134,
0.20774798095226288,
0.35134944319725037,
0.13510504364967346,
-0.31069236993789673,
0.12515738606452942,
0.13613329827785492,
0.03395038843154907,
0.8550355434417725,
0.2398548275232315,
-0.5658448338508606,
-0.30421963334083557,
0.339404821395874,
-0.1114869937300682,
0.10402732342481613,
0.9138006567955017,
-0.5601344704627991,
0.6216562986373901,
0.30613744258880615,
1.2649202346801758,
-0.15440715849399567,
0.1774773746728897,
0.4945148229598999,
-0.43170028924942017,
-0.2729346752166748,
0.522599458694458,
-0.03482984006404877,
0.36532917618751526,
-0.6304887533187866,
0.44039666652679443,
0.057349640876054764,
-0.6817552447319031,
-0.7344003319740295,
-0.3723437786102295,
-0.5832314491271973,
-0.47085845470428467,
0.4211304187774658,
-0.3372468054294586,
-0.12412920594215393,
-0.29371845722198486,
-0.4852036237716675,
0.29933837056159973,
-0.17089051008224487,
1.3328583240509033,
0.7527211308479309,
-0.4250817894935608,
0.029857028275728226,
-0.4757373631000519,
0.320252925157547,
0.29853829741477966,
-1.202480673789978,
-0.41046226024627686,
0.47564131021499634,
-0.22915346920490265,
0.24032700061798096,
0.09615372866392136,
-0.07939744740724564,
0.44374603033065796,
0.03649762645363808,
-0.09032834321260452,
-0.1436646580696106,
-0.4043460488319397,
-0.1783715784549713,
0.2242841273546219,
-0.03941751644015312,
-0.23851457238197327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03909v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03909v2
|
A Measure for Transparent Comparison of Linguistic Diversity in Multilingual NLP Data Sets
| 2024-03-06T18:14:22 | 2024-04-16T10:00:41 |
Tanja Samardzic, Ximena Gutierrez, Christian Bentz, Steven Moran, Olga Pelloni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Typologically diverse benchmarks are increasingly created to track the
progress achieved in multilingual NLP. Linguistic diversity of these data sets
is typically measured as the number of languages or language families included
in the sample, but such measures do not consider structural properties of the
included languages. In this paper, we propose assessing linguistic diversity of
a data set against a reference language sample as a means of maximising
linguistic diversity in the long run. We represent languages as sets of
features and apply a version of the Jaccard index suitable for comparing sets
of measures. In addition to the features extracted from typological data bases,
we propose an automatic text-based measure, which can be used as a means of
overcoming the well-known problem of data sparsity in manually collected
features. Our diversity score is interpretable in terms of linguistic features
and can identify the types of languages that are not represented in a data set.
Using our method, we analyse a range of popular multilingual data sets (UD,
Bible100, mBERT, XTREME, XGLUE, XNLI, XCOPA, TyDiQA, XQuAD). In addition to
ranking these data sets, we find, for example, that (poly)synthetic languages
are missing in almost all of them.
|
[
-0.7696157693862915,
-0.18961955606937408,
-0.21785590052604675,
0.6606374382972717,
-0.19365833699703217,
0.608100950717926,
-0.6279228925704956,
-0.5476734638214111,
0.5124689936637878,
0.41133755445480347,
-0.21702781319618225,
-0.5881890654563904,
-0.6190793514251709,
0.4819011390209198,
-0.44592559337615967,
1.006798267364502,
-0.08742310851812363,
-0.26293545961380005,
0.21691103279590607,
-0.8149192333221436,
-0.2557719945907593,
-0.4644630253314972,
-0.14800308644771576,
-0.11203660070896149,
0.4254985749721527,
0.25126713514328003,
0.7881949543952942,
0.4470200836658478,
0.29068633913993835,
0.39849409461021423,
-0.3933512270450592,
0.41122448444366455,
-0.4658568501472473,
0.3418812155723572,
-0.358163446187973,
-0.40572258830070496,
-0.07666514813899994,
-0.19529922306537628,
0.959899365901947,
0.9036433100700378,
0.005645518656820059,
0.2838035523891449,
0.2396029233932495,
0.7200323343276978,
-0.6374807357788086,
0.08960703760385513,
-0.46594157814979553,
0.2913983464241028,
-0.6298050284385681,
-0.1729809194803238,
-0.10972099006175995,
-0.42865827679634094,
0.0686078891158104,
-0.10840128362178802,
0.22951126098632812,
-0.016293616965413094,
0.6074137687683105,
-0.20371514558792114,
-0.2812924087047577,
-0.27014777064323425,
-0.5028873682022095,
1.121721625328064,
-0.5253216624259949,
0.5149670243263245,
0.25319960713386536,
0.32858505845069885,
-0.05652761831879616,
0.018262207508087158,
-0.346023827791214,
-0.3519604802131653,
-0.01819205842912197,
0.152968168258667,
0.030295737087726593,
-0.37420815229415894,
0.022983212023973465,
0.6597092151641846,
-0.7212242484092712,
-0.17966040968894958,
0.01311357319355011,
0.02883516065776348,
0.5982532501220703,
-0.03978239372372627,
0.40131691098213196,
-0.23048768937587738,
0.30613335967063904,
-0.27432966232299805,
-0.13521267473697662,
-0.16260342299938202,
0.7067679762840271,
0.5353311896324158,
-0.4036773443222046,
0.615409791469574,
-0.3226926922798157,
0.5905941724777222,
-0.3331778347492218,
-0.39500892162323,
0.6443337798118591,
-0.8072155714035034,
0.1507880687713623,
-0.249289870262146,
0.683498740196228,
-0.09881626814603806,
0.7106644511222839,
-0.36541563272476196,
-0.0474289208650589,
-0.117853082716465,
-0.18601547181606293,
-0.23825345933437347,
-0.034327734261751175,
0.01658908650279045,
-0.16709718108177185,
-0.23786471784114838,
-0.0628434345126152,
-1.0929217338562012,
-0.09292606264352798,
0.13085302710533142,
-0.4187629520893097,
-0.4484485387802124,
-0.5434248447418213,
0.09307702630758286,
-0.40863096714019775,
0.11202414333820343,
0.09487111866474152,
-0.8793745040893555,
0.4962620437145233,
0.5055091381072998,
0.8650916218757629,
-0.5645232200622559,
-0.3289986848831177,
-0.06579674780368805,
-0.13428610563278198,
-0.3119751811027527,
0.768382728099823,
-0.7130689024925232,
-0.5473147630691528,
0.061876047402620316,
-0.09717196971178055,
0.02677227184176445,
-0.7836424112319946,
0.23313379287719727,
-0.14230014383792877,
0.46305927634239197,
-0.10754505544900894,
-0.3157305419445038,
-0.22068007290363312,
0.565169095993042,
-0.7476510405540466,
1.1289564371109009,
0.4637645483016968,
-0.7547876834869385,
0.7007662057876587,
-0.3677627444267273,
-0.41027572751045227,
0.4296167194843292,
-0.28464561700820923,
-0.4225042760372162,
-0.055998992174863815,
0.16272622346878052,
-0.2494325041770935,
-0.09505828469991684,
0.3122890591621399,
-0.5447108745574951,
-0.013548177666962147,
0.3532182276248932,
-0.5266252756118774,
1.0583150386810303,
0.05801014229655266,
-0.5098962187767029,
-0.2871534824371338,
-0.9040533304214478,
0.47963201999664307,
-0.2413531094789505,
-0.3653683066368103,
-0.4731389582157135,
-0.027879271656274796,
0.3863636255264282,
0.20007997751235962,
-0.03952378034591675,
-0.25598570704460144,
0.10856271535158157,
-0.5573644638061523,
-0.24974912405014038,
0.3804871737957001,
-0.1034793108701706,
0.1266254335641861,
-0.4664457142353058,
0.7918451428413391,
-0.20936419069766998,
-0.16081565618515015,
0.15211571753025055,
-0.8756652474403381,
-0.8794846534729004,
-0.4474388360977173,
0.5710589289665222,
0.6152511239051819,
-0.661112904548645,
0.9243035316467285,
-0.4275965988636017,
-0.4525374472141266,
-0.5387359857559204,
0.4686143398284912,
0.5893508195877075,
-0.2037263959646225,
0.29066184163093567,
-0.7560963034629822,
-0.4557786285877228,
-0.8047741055488586,
-0.44917434453964233,
-0.27436551451683044,
-0.018493017181754112,
0.25869324803352356,
0.3936542272567749,
0.049064189195632935,
0.8219075202941895,
0.21690663695335388,
-0.035109758377075195,
-0.43672046065330505,
0.241038516163826,
0.2773985266685486,
0.38164910674095154,
0.6184263825416565,
-0.6284706592559814,
-0.6580596566200256,
0.4372771680355072,
-0.6868904232978821,
-0.3397878408432007,
0.10979999601840973,
0.07383305579423904,
0.2541946470737457,
-0.16760584712028503,
-0.1536172330379486,
0.22586823999881744,
0.7666298747062683,
-0.30476734042167664,
0.4253004491329193,
0.13858619332313538,
0.45988184213638306,
-0.6603360176086426,
0.08364305645227432,
-0.10560934245586395,
-0.28071966767311096,
-0.5411270260810852,
0.25927412509918213,
-0.08669937402009964,
0.012845205143094063,
-0.29092055559158325,
0.633925199508667,
-0.41779059171676636,
-0.32644179463386536,
-0.02265850640833378,
0.13288140296936035,
0.06875967234373093,
0.25080764293670654,
0.08431530743837357,
0.5765401721000671,
0.30245161056518555,
-0.30544179677963257,
0.17441175878047943,
0.2266140729188919,
-0.5186427235603333,
0.4363439083099365,
-0.30523520708084106,
-0.16321924328804016,
0.02762538753449917,
-0.08830803632736206,
-0.7768814563751221,
-0.028128433972597122,
0.18169116973876953,
-0.47887322306632996,
0.18657511472702026,
-0.21699388325214386,
-0.48887899518013,
-0.18371064960956573,
-0.2925553619861603,
0.5541634559631348,
0.26196959614753723,
-0.18193814158439636,
0.33616095781326294,
0.3542630672454834,
-0.40261679887771606,
-0.8361895680427551,
-0.8645503520965576,
0.3273538649082184,
-0.25738367438316345,
-0.8934463858604431,
0.21068738400936127,
-0.25534337759017944,
-0.4513600170612335,
-0.138637512922287,
-0.056191008538007736,
-0.3157898783683777,
0.12891142070293427,
-0.18301542103290558,
-0.07992709428071976,
-0.35329851508140564,
0.08284122496843338,
0.1668546050786972,
0.13299983739852905,
-0.347548246383667,
-0.4155372977256775,
0.5849015116691589,
-0.45046791434288025,
-0.4097103774547577,
0.23775073885917664,
0.5788138508796692,
0.31210488080978394,
-0.22061237692832947,
0.6412872672080994,
0.5791904330253601,
-0.06577906012535095,
-0.3043515682220459,
-0.6683964133262634,
0.4229862093925476,
-0.3998703062534332,
0.28446727991104126,
-0.23722361028194427,
-0.8807294964790344,
0.7022945284843445,
0.4114495813846588,
0.18224447965621948,
0.35121139883995056,
0.7517367005348206,
0.255853533744812,
0.5582282543182373,
0.5440546870231628,
-0.11723948270082474,
0.3527028262615204,
0.05444283410906792,
0.04252120107412338,
-0.10984403640031815,
-0.13886891305446625,
-0.7757676839828491,
-0.12454719841480255,
-1.0112336874008179,
-0.3557720482349396,
0.14110343158245087,
-0.01755322515964508,
0.23178856074810028,
0.31383997201919556,
-0.33371785283088684,
0.588235080242157,
0.36862123012542725,
-0.29899466037750244,
0.5758829712867737,
0.28616437315940857,
-0.12560780346393585,
-0.08339221775531769,
-0.6478625535964966,
-0.4236026704311371,
0.946740984916687,
0.08570509403944016,
0.5077890753746033,
0.26979854702949524,
0.8988755941390991,
0.2793724238872528,
0.24545463919639587,
-0.5363926887512207,
0.4176372289657593,
-0.358451247215271,
-0.5692678093910217,
-0.4376826584339142,
-0.717324435710907,
-0.9102898836135864,
0.5213361382484436,
-0.3930852711200714,
-0.460867315530777,
0.49650293588638306,
-0.22465215623378754,
0.09830839186906815,
0.07841463387012482,
-0.5320512652397156,
0.7065660953521729,
-0.30729663372039795,
-0.13428854942321777,
0.04095509648323059,
-0.1936143934726715,
0.374801367521286,
-0.3500171899795532,
0.347154438495636,
-0.2526000142097473,
0.01835043914616108,
0.6844004392623901,
-0.23066602647304535,
0.4753248691558838,
0.2549441456794739,
-0.05981164053082466,
0.12989813089370728,
0.0672219842672348,
-0.12382037937641144,
0.1109108179807663,
-0.20649194717407227,
0.5340202450752258,
-0.04521980136632919,
-0.536487877368927,
-0.44665953516960144,
0.6666173338890076,
-0.6984394788742065,
-0.28953126072883606,
-0.5356144905090332,
-0.65498948097229,
-0.2942209839820862,
0.2582215666770935,
0.16046972572803497,
0.16366098821163177,
-0.21414324641227722,
0.38095393776893616,
0.2782323956489563,
-0.2656969726085663,
0.45876118540763855,
0.5276235938072205,
-0.3116728365421295,
-0.37478941679000854,
0.8102593421936035,
0.3232870399951935,
0.4319371283054352,
0.24736613035202026,
0.20802128314971924,
-0.1325255185365677,
-0.6659893989562988,
-0.24901694059371948,
0.10119783133268356,
-0.5653585195541382,
0.07641550898551941,
-0.5466979146003723,
-0.18639566004276276,
-0.3644941747188568,
-0.07737728208303452,
-0.2109554558992386,
-0.5744136571884155,
0.35973861813545227,
0.13162650167942047,
0.21640175580978394,
0.30491021275520325,
0.06259367614984512,
0.08984895795583725,
-0.7153224349021912,
0.3846551477909088,
0.011662016622722149,
0.5431137681007385,
-0.2934902012348175,
-0.4940944015979767,
-0.035924363881349564,
-0.14483985304832458,
-0.19610927999019623,
-0.6995224356651306,
0.750969648361206,
0.41275039315223694,
0.7850356698036194,
0.20040781795978546,
-0.28491806983947754,
0.573050320148468,
-0.2871464192867279,
0.6573739647865295,
0.07852010428905487,
-0.994176983833313,
0.41387102007865906,
-0.22777067124843597,
0.5149197578430176,
0.8303138017654419,
0.38763412833213806,
-0.7712377309799194,
-1.1116338968276978,
-0.6172940731048584,
-0.7914032936096191,
0.299511194229126,
0.6823160648345947,
-0.11945659667253494,
-0.21098098158836365,
-0.22305192053318024,
0.3481684923171997,
0.2816304862499237,
-1.0472620725631714,
-0.30574578046798706,
-0.30708327889442444,
-0.2952577769756317,
0.0005212202086113393,
0.006255190819501877,
-0.19619953632354736,
0.03960714116692543,
0.30780601501464844,
-0.09256360679864883,
-0.2244722545146942,
-0.057027410715818405,
-0.21724502742290497,
0.09662894904613495,
0.6244509816169739,
0.25086477398872375,
0.8853046894073486,
-0.31041276454925537,
0.05836452916264534,
0.1497868001461029,
-0.5701562762260437,
0.1998901516199112,
0.15878483653068542,
-0.24542668461799622,
0.5805529952049255,
0.5846512913703918,
0.3198888897895813,
0.06842781603336334,
-0.7145158648490906,
0.19839920103549957,
-0.006755010224878788,
-0.0454336553812027,
-0.2197345346212387,
0.082956463098526,
-0.009710249491035938,
-0.01674896851181984,
0.02547813020646572,
0.19338935613632202,
0.2682391405105591,
-0.5611559152603149,
0.3920538127422333,
0.38180506229400635,
-0.26702749729156494,
-0.030215492472052574,
-0.1782413125038147,
0.24567058682441711,
-0.2725638151168823,
0.4478384554386139,
-0.31917035579681396,
-0.16818250715732574,
0.784508228302002,
0.3587203919887543,
0.8984889984130859,
-0.41846051812171936,
0.196889728307724,
0.23741252720355988,
0.724461555480957,
-0.07741095125675201,
0.25781747698783875,
-0.006188920233398676,
-0.778024435043335,
-0.2943391799926758,
-0.6481386423110962,
-0.43269994854927063,
0.09210000932216644,
-0.6357200741767883,
0.23745200037956238,
-0.3684779107570648,
-0.03185870498418808,
0.1399526298046112,
-0.13317248225212097,
-0.5077167749404907,
0.08773424476385117,
0.23929373919963837,
0.8994549512863159,
-0.8148337006568909,
0.8303690552711487,
0.1513405591249466,
-0.24009761214256287,
-0.031872328370809555,
-0.05532009154558182,
-0.020834093913435936,
-0.6964807510375977,
0.5878700613975525,
0.216888889670372,
-0.12456761300563812,
-0.6628702282905579,
-0.040818896144628525,
-0.8190839886665344,
0.3739708960056305,
0.2817336320877075,
-0.5157708525657654,
0.13183584809303284,
0.5594791173934937,
0.731827437877655,
-0.37997815012931824,
0.5085897445678711,
0.5142742991447449,
0.591912567615509,
-0.28670966625213623,
-1.0932263135910034,
-0.32632777094841003,
-0.7198595404624939,
0.07386428117752075,
0.35409796237945557,
-0.2790493667125702,
0.591848611831665,
0.3049832582473755,
-0.4202958643436432,
0.024330459535121918,
0.4490872323513031,
0.2627413272857666,
-0.022091584280133247,
0.7000909447669983,
0.2677541673183441,
0.7486251592636108,
-0.09651990234851837,
0.9855086803436279,
-0.4865301251411438,
0.5556224584579468,
0.8794720768928528,
-0.18099664151668549,
0.5371411442756653,
0.33389124274253845,
-0.3302942216396332,
0.496187686920166,
0.22948096692562103,
-0.339637815952301,
0.2576003074645996,
0.42646321654319763,
-0.27906155586242676,
-0.12040940672159195,
-0.13567183911800385,
-0.45811668038368225,
0.5236907601356506,
0.5170881152153015,
-0.17395305633544922,
-0.6160313487052917,
-0.09750248491764069,
-0.1228732094168663,
0.19950222969055176,
-0.0035242510493844748,
0.4499046802520752,
0.043851062655448914,
-0.6219913959503174,
0.8549863696098328,
-0.05945685878396034,
0.7969459891319275,
-0.9463218450546265,
0.06438202410936356,
-0.5414643287658691,
-0.15895569324493408,
-0.190872922539711,
-1.161889910697937,
0.5292989611625671,
0.1009637862443924,
-0.15250685811042786,
-0.07529045641422272,
0.3483901917934418,
-0.8472371697425842,
-0.7466973662376404,
0.6770279407501221,
0.7082924246788025,
0.11892072856426239,
0.2064361274242401,
-0.8245155811309814,
-0.1133972629904747,
0.04921181499958038,
0.04102551192045212,
0.2314741015434265,
0.35369789600372314,
-0.3987656831741333,
0.8231260776519775,
0.28151798248291016,
0.40053248405456543,
0.28353163599967957,
0.3775990605354309,
0.5310448408126831,
-0.7459245324134827,
-0.7298610806465149,
-0.694355845451355,
0.20455729961395264,
-0.38530275225639343,
-0.6282402276992798,
0.845509946346283,
0.47838056087493896,
0.9069763422012329,
0.08428604900836945,
0.9473510384559631,
-0.002403526334092021,
0.6092039346694946,
-0.21627187728881836,
0.5788583159446716,
-0.462110698223114,
0.13449031114578247,
-0.3786313235759735,
-1.1003706455230713,
-0.44646400213241577,
0.3764858543872833,
0.007140046451240778,
0.2048025131225586,
0.5923773050308228,
0.7024362683296204,
-0.2882891297340393,
0.04983444884419441,
0.3431602418422699,
-0.01477057859301567,
0.14076876640319824,
0.40014034509658813,
0.743702232837677,
-0.07628466188907623,
0.7755565643310547,
-0.21359968185424805,
-0.5002367496490479,
0.06939219683408737,
-0.8118829131126404,
-0.8824741244316101,
-0.38347291946411133,
-0.32480305433273315,
-0.406808078289032,
0.3417434096336365,
0.6250686645507812,
0.4578985571861267,
-1.2148067951202393,
-0.6763190031051636,
0.15916681289672852,
0.25707700848579407,
-0.36266201734542847,
-0.21788957715034485,
-0.0004760523734148592,
-0.42046478390693665,
-0.7184571623802185,
0.3737429082393646,
0.5702211856842041,
-0.08977563679218292,
-0.3006473183631897,
0.19048303365707397,
-0.1258085072040558,
-0.07185283303260803,
0.3755544126033783,
0.42372748255729675,
-0.6740221381187439,
-0.15824955701828003,
-0.13187067210674286,
-0.03012031875550747,
0.22336331009864807,
0.6661393642425537,
-0.34576618671417236,
0.6513823866844177,
0.6256683468818665,
0.613978922367096,
0.3497198522090912,
-0.4091072976589203,
0.6848955750465393,
-0.9490697383880615,
0.36582979559898376,
0.3376162648200989,
0.45493337512016296,
0.45808571577072144,
0.10373018682003021,
0.5510833859443665,
0.28481534123420715,
-0.10655064880847931,
-0.5255212187767029,
0.33319807052612305,
-1.2150647640228271,
-0.04880446940660477,
1.0555871725082397,
-0.27193140983581543,
0.007301794830709696,
-0.6935626268386841,
0.16929872334003448,
-0.19949263334274292,
-0.20457516610622406,
0.986888587474823,
0.8743607401847839,
0.35661858320236206,
-0.08339641243219376,
-0.3694440722465515,
0.404443621635437,
0.487347811460495,
-0.860572338104248,
-0.09242948889732361,
0.15361426770687103,
0.1977597326040268,
0.6262714862823486,
0.4050801992416382,
-0.4271605908870697,
0.23750457167625427,
-0.009274872951209545,
0.11882929503917694,
0.3419699966907501,
-0.23908720910549164,
-0.20364029705524445,
0.3472730815410614,
-0.09697587788105011,
0.14422424137592316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03894v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03894v3
|
IRCoder: Intermediate Representations Make Language Models Robust Multilingual Code Generators
| 2024-03-06T17:52:08 | 2024-04-15T16:29:41 |
Indraneil Paul, Goran Glavaš, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Code understanding and generation have fast become some of the most popular
applications of language models (LMs). Nonetheless, research on multilingual
aspects of Code-LMs (i.e., LMs for code generation) such as cross-lingual
transfer between different programming languages, language-specific data
augmentation, and post-hoc LM adaptation, alongside exploitation of data
sources other than the original textual content, has been much sparser than for
their natural language counterparts. In particular, most mainstream Code-LMs
have been pre-trained on source code files alone. In this work, we investigate
the prospect of leveraging readily available compiler intermediate
representations (IR) - shared across programming languages - to improve the
multilingual capabilities of Code-LMs and facilitate cross-lingual transfer.
To this end, we first compile SLTrans, a parallel dataset consisting of
nearly 4M self-contained source code files coupled with respective intermediate
representations. Next, starting from various base Code-LMs (ranging in size
from 1.1B to 7.3B parameters), we carry out continued causal language modelling
training on SLTrans, forcing the Code-LMs to (1) learn the IR language and (2)
align the IR constructs with respective constructs of various programming
languages. Our resulting models, dubbed IRCoder, display sizeable and
consistent gains across a wide variety of code generation tasks and metrics,
including prompt robustness, multilingual code completion, code understanding,
and instruction following.
|
[
-0.3493753969669342,
0.14267894625663757,
0.190938800573349,
0.13475681841373444,
0.008731369860470295,
0.27627959847450256,
-0.48946622014045715,
-0.35379716753959656,
0.04881207272410393,
0.4537281394004822,
-0.17608006298542023,
-0.24040985107421875,
-0.6585742831230164,
0.22882676124572754,
-0.2808363139629364,
1.113716959953308,
-0.13784030079841614,
0.37745338678359985,
-0.09164419025182724,
-0.3518429696559906,
-0.30276918411254883,
-0.6860661506652832,
-0.2765498459339142,
-0.3678185045719147,
0.7996936440467834,
0.6240149140357971,
0.6901591420173645,
0.4822571277618408,
0.4263904094696045,
0.2819841802120209,
0.47430673241615295,
-0.10053813457489014,
-0.4910964369773865,
-0.07801812142133713,
-0.15687362849712372,
-0.4982674717903137,
0.005722228903323412,
-0.3962200880050659,
0.6795620322227478,
0.6037269234657288,
-0.02179109863936901,
0.41036099195480347,
0.062104225158691406,
0.7443271279335022,
-0.6510649919509888,
0.36432087421417236,
-0.601367712020874,
0.007193598430603743,
-0.15631000697612762,
-0.3354983925819397,
-0.7811728715896606,
-0.21057774126529694,
-0.2677498459815979,
-0.17664803564548492,
0.020597947761416435,
-0.13804680109024048,
0.7834222912788391,
0.13025256991386414,
-0.40276670455932617,
-0.4915488064289093,
-0.9490389823913574,
0.565496563911438,
-0.601561427116394,
0.6754230856895447,
0.10042496025562286,
0.3326335549354553,
0.18556256592273712,
-1.0133647918701172,
-0.35996952652931213,
-0.451756089925766,
-0.45704373717308044,
-0.1997305154800415,
-0.20698894560337067,
0.08673743903636932,
0.26317059993743896,
0.24421650171279907,
-0.5965582132339478,
-0.010584164410829544,
-0.47082534432411194,
-0.15580859780311584,
0.09394872933626175,
0.02410610392689705,
0.528993546962738,
-0.029906000941991806,
-0.11624892055988312,
-0.06894992291927338,
-0.9570236802101135,
-0.09561975300312042,
0.2260223925113678,
0.2857220768928528,
-0.1426364928483963,
0.5075606107711792,
0.17372755706310272,
0.8712064623832703,
-0.04314291849732399,
-0.05254122242331505,
0.15616081655025482,
-0.444575697183609,
0.13188666105270386,
-0.1303006261587143,
0.6471377015113831,
-0.0359145887196064,
0.2408403754234314,
-0.1602497696876526,
-0.24517545104026794,
0.1425754427909851,
0.144600510597229,
-0.8015536069869995,
-0.3680296540260315,
-0.19853119552135468,
-0.4855259358882904,
0.17655952274799347,
-0.025592902675271034,
-0.34648194909095764,
0.141500785946846,
-0.5853315591812134,
0.21819067001342773,
-0.462767630815506,
-0.343207448720932,
0.21762721240520477,
0.2089982032775879,
0.41078686714172363,
-0.08644092082977295,
-0.5054600834846497,
0.09233171492815018,
0.2336491495370865,
0.5987108945846558,
0.21575719118118286,
-0.3843788802623749,
-0.5312217473983765,
0.36415761709213257,
-0.3730369210243225,
0.5126970410346985,
-0.7355771064758301,
-0.0167998056858778,
0.11089228093624115,
-0.03491872549057007,
0.0053098550997674465,
-0.29862263798713684,
0.0989881306886673,
-0.75141841173172,
0.06358882784843445,
0.01567782834172249,
-0.340041846036911,
-0.03142724558711052,
0.12472867220640182,
-0.718954861164093,
0.8795667290687561,
0.15102645754814148,
-0.8864824771881104,
0.11022020131349564,
-0.29453280568122864,
-0.2611531615257263,
-0.045089103281497955,
-0.6262669563293457,
-0.19741280376911163,
0.22253704071044922,
0.14911530911922455,
0.456650048494339,
-0.29965201020240784,
0.36833417415618896,
0.09985002130270004,
-0.2765166759490967,
0.24898147583007812,
-0.3736859858036041,
0.24732019007205963,
0.3858323097229004,
-0.24019259214401245,
-0.009732704609632492,
-0.5695886611938477,
0.04236122593283653,
-0.22536569833755493,
-0.38538286089897156,
-0.3547622263431549,
-0.08529235422611237,
-0.05084804818034172,
0.48371532559394836,
0.281074196100235,
-0.1389428973197937,
0.11231420189142227,
0.1848386526107788,
-0.011729396879673004,
0.6282769441604614,
-0.21479655802249908,
0.4548652768135071,
-0.24481038749217987,
0.7453721761703491,
0.1849929839372635,
-0.09938659518957138,
-0.7197747230529785,
-0.1216547042131424,
-1.1234266757965088,
-0.19484031200408936,
0.4693877696990967,
0.4967789649963379,
-1.281502604484558,
0.03947100043296814,
-0.5638649463653564,
-0.3806191384792328,
-0.41136229038238525,
0.2379932999610901,
0.8077329397201538,
0.17979741096496582,
0.1507600098848343,
-0.02951730601489544,
-0.7166393995285034,
-0.917160153388977,
-0.4184809923171997,
-0.41297510266304016,
0.1909838318824768,
-0.04357893764972687,
0.3230171501636505,
-0.4449670910835266,
0.819404661655426,
-0.4193834364414215,
-0.0017583182780072093,
-0.602532148361206,
0.12785561382770538,
0.3170795440673828,
0.708739697933197,
0.6864761114120483,
-0.752884566783905,
-0.9447387456893921,
0.3337200880050659,
-0.6592985391616821,
-0.232474684715271,
-0.3508487045764923,
-0.2431015521287918,
0.01844935677945614,
0.9800121188163757,
-0.1584259420633316,
0.013721714727580547,
0.869006335735321,
-0.18761363625526428,
0.7360308170318604,
-0.4757290780544281,
0.18399351835250854,
-0.957655131816864,
0.3168238401412964,
-0.05780011788010597,
-0.40970751643180847,
-0.7499991655349731,
0.38985341787338257,
0.38653790950775146,
-0.3512619435787201,
-0.49606096744537354,
0.37882867455482483,
-1.0221658945083618,
-0.06821565330028534,
-0.23142896592617035,
-0.36836886405944824,
-0.11743456870317459,
0.7089895606040955,
0.12982411682605743,
1.0301882028579712,
0.7245993614196777,
-0.40289372205734253,
-0.10151764005422592,
-0.3334791362285614,
-0.22245223820209503,
0.07519888132810593,
-0.5926178693771362,
0.3216860890388489,
-0.41882064938545227,
-0.0318678542971611,
-0.5693989396095276,
-0.32061782479286194,
0.10914815217256546,
-0.5498033165931702,
0.6669095754623413,
-0.44364872574806213,
-0.5214135646820068,
-0.2362084984779358,
0.08498997241258621,
0.46477842330932617,
0.7054471373558044,
-0.566988468170166,
0.7615842223167419,
0.29059693217277527,
-0.2664579451084137,
-0.5002535581588745,
-0.7617747187614441,
0.18117284774780273,
0.03515830636024475,
-0.5130748152732849,
0.02980489656329155,
-0.05598166957497597,
-0.10642991214990616,
0.1301669478416443,
-0.009417499415576458,
-0.09803658723831177,
-0.46641868352890015,
-0.029879581183195114,
0.3250690698623657,
-0.37795692682266235,
0.05961855128407478,
0.06283996254205704,
-0.41248875856399536,
-0.023039858788251877,
-0.3847639262676239,
0.49209854006767273,
-0.31109240651130676,
-0.6169409155845642,
-0.03335891664028168,
0.45716506242752075,
0.6244693994522095,
-0.37414756417274475,
0.8580940961837769,
0.49840861558914185,
-0.32945483922958374,
-0.05165236443281174,
-0.541900634765625,
0.10105158388614655,
-0.4769541323184967,
0.5216115117073059,
-0.49562424421310425,
-0.9560356140136719,
0.6649391651153564,
-0.17197740077972412,
-0.07084524631500244,
0.13306987285614014,
0.4606455862522125,
0.34150034189224243,
1.044152855873108,
0.9272185564041138,
-0.2652134895324707,
0.7178324460983276,
-0.1810266375541687,
0.23488487303256989,
-0.5406387448310852,
-0.3449203372001648,
-0.9113995432853699,
0.019695013761520386,
-0.38778385519981384,
-0.816943347454071,
0.3280108571052551,
0.33775970339775085,
-0.26019415259361267,
0.5317948460578918,
-0.34282803535461426,
0.7710720896720886,
0.38000771403312683,
0.07366164028644562,
0.037920188158750534,
0.27875882387161255,
-0.17939472198486328,
-0.21716049313545227,
-0.9861202239990234,
-0.5323827862739563,
0.817253053188324,
0.3581298291683197,
1.1223266124725342,
0.07551688700914383,
0.7028650641441345,
0.2696174383163452,
0.4024129807949066,
-0.30785518884658813,
0.400281697511673,
-0.39383184909820557,
-0.330167680978775,
0.3766328692436218,
-0.6075047254562378,
-0.38616761565208435,
0.22564290463924408,
0.2568225860595703,
-0.3272815942764282,
0.34683895111083984,
0.15997809171676636,
-0.14208444952964783,
0.24049192667007446,
-0.8962650299072266,
0.7367057800292969,
-0.3399365544319153,
-0.4516952931880951,
-0.07274389266967773,
-0.722265899181366,
0.08208175748586655,
-0.18356424570083618,
0.3968765139579773,
0.21263311803340912,
-0.09854738414287567,
0.544708251953125,
-0.3684697449207306,
0.8946126103401184,
-0.17324718832969666,
-0.06747149676084518,
0.28672605752944946,
0.1876576542854309,
0.6086162328720093,
0.20752380788326263,
-0.1858605593442917,
0.22961102426052094,
-0.4107877314090729,
-0.4139809310436249,
-0.4709848463535309,
0.7040036916732788,
-0.8065849542617798,
-0.4702671766281128,
-0.4984949231147766,
-0.39854735136032104,
-0.023549137637019157,
0.2886146306991577,
0.21094638109207153,
0.6466376781463623,
0.1355096846818924,
0.17539210617542267,
0.651564359664917,
-0.3498169481754303,
0.28963086009025574,
0.627697229385376,
-0.3743685483932495,
-0.5195322632789612,
1.0333681106567383,
-0.2498408854007721,
0.45688387751579285,
0.4312114715576172,
-0.06773318350315094,
0.04930926114320755,
-0.389126718044281,
-0.49279338121414185,
0.22170475125312805,
-1.001225233078003,
-0.5138366222381592,
-0.6185252070426941,
-0.34828171133995056,
-0.10435549169778824,
-0.41820624470710754,
-0.5046405792236328,
-0.16046813130378723,
-0.24419914186000824,
0.009720072150230408,
0.29576078057289124,
0.7583585977554321,
-0.5264245271682739,
0.3876965045928955,
-1.2284090518951416,
0.4635927975177765,
0.03960876539349556,
0.31207403540611267,
-0.056781258434057236,
-0.409515380859375,
-0.9205952882766724,
0.18046177923679352,
0.2105371356010437,
-0.5979408025741577,
0.3999861180782318,
0.4905637204647064,
0.6774179935455322,
0.24803493916988373,
-0.06256945431232452,
1.038047432899475,
-0.6101956963539124,
0.734616756439209,
0.47274747490882874,
-0.9749161005020142,
0.3238673210144043,
-0.04715477675199509,
0.460347443819046,
0.7122274041175842,
0.5652393698692322,
-0.6228033900260925,
-0.5654329061508179,
-0.004250852856785059,
-0.7056766748428345,
0.9767789244651794,
0.21067307889461517,
0.3111330568790436,
-0.10370002686977386,
0.33191588521003723,
0.34646621346473694,
-0.08049146831035614,
-1.1923726797103882,
-0.22778919339179993,
-0.08242330700159073,
-0.20884758234024048,
0.00855350773781538,
-0.30068254470825195,
0.22261379659175873,
-0.19958700239658356,
0.5026952624320984,
-0.32373541593551636,
0.3715244233608246,
0.07857701927423477,
-0.46129655838012695,
-0.0029806909151375294,
0.1818760335445404,
0.26897796988487244,
0.6283702254295349,
0.1465577483177185,
0.4326455295085907,
-0.21692979335784912,
-0.3787148594856262,
0.30309584736824036,
0.08244995027780533,
-0.017923574894666672,
0.35132545232772827,
0.6169515252113342,
0.8523259162902832,
0.21955353021621704,
-0.6607838869094849,
0.3691297471523285,
-0.23906996846199036,
0.4411831796169281,
-0.3217479884624481,
-0.10359518229961395,
0.06963362544775009,
0.08540095388889313,
0.40664294362068176,
0.5475958585739136,
-0.026557518169283867,
-0.49662160873413086,
0.4284522235393524,
-0.050831425935029984,
-0.4883255362510681,
-0.5191400051116943,
0.48502659797668457,
0.09551480412483215,
-0.021123630926012993,
0.5913438200950623,
-0.16625133156776428,
-0.7717048525810242,
0.49945271015167236,
0.5844762325286865,
0.7950733304023743,
-0.27331992983818054,
0.018241306766867638,
0.47424352169036865,
0.37875863909721375,
-0.1694171279668808,
0.2436467558145523,
-0.1297687590122223,
-0.5765259861946106,
-0.6329352259635925,
-0.48528221249580383,
-0.015296941623091698,
-0.3504202663898468,
-0.8272367715835571,
0.46711722016334534,
0.12121862918138504,
0.11149485409259796,
-0.5637193918228149,
-0.47726717591285706,
-0.75274658203125,
-0.18921293318271637,
0.2861933410167694,
0.9801648855209351,
-0.7243761420249939,
1.2228939533233643,
0.7973446249961853,
-0.5989001989364624,
-0.896435558795929,
0.13019311428070068,
-0.4807535409927368,
-0.7099918127059937,
0.9004514813423157,
0.19542944431304932,
-0.27475225925445557,
-0.13644574582576752,
-0.4333900809288025,
-0.7720420956611633,
0.7153738141059875,
0.8870410323143005,
-0.8663582801818848,
-0.2824859917163849,
0.4426213502883911,
0.5012928247451782,
-0.4212651550769806,
0.3844541013240814,
0.27110904455184937,
0.11214123666286469,
0.05940210074186325,
-0.7956717014312744,
-0.18290087580680847,
-0.4790149927139282,
0.2743549346923828,
0.2804103493690491,
-0.40236979722976685,
0.8897693753242493,
-0.36024802923202515,
-0.1554468870162964,
0.07766076177358627,
0.7165189981460571,
0.3853023648262024,
-0.09493305534124374,
0.10441035777330399,
0.160660520195961,
0.23257409036159515,
0.02635076642036438,
1.0515481233596802,
-1.0343174934387207,
0.25662970542907715,
1.2417848110198975,
-0.22468002140522003,
0.653134286403656,
0.6689819097518921,
0.12076801806688309,
0.6684600114822388,
0.3299877643585205,
0.504928708076477,
0.7730205059051514,
0.1802522838115692,
-0.3872446119785309,
-0.19897255301475525,
0.04167589917778969,
-0.7645452618598938,
0.1866166591644287,
0.5181599259376526,
-0.3821207582950592,
-0.22042213380336761,
0.2847802937030792,
0.024519186466932297,
0.13662706315517426,
-0.24531608819961548,
0.7236958742141724,
0.18288004398345947,
-0.5873032212257385,
0.5683553814888,
0.02176499180495739,
0.689375102519989,
-1.1164134740829468,
-0.2762516140937805,
-0.5102238655090332,
0.4445180296897888,
-0.03390306234359741,
-0.6465267539024353,
0.47037428617477417,
0.218749538064003,
-0.17267177999019623,
-0.48160678148269653,
0.9295857548713684,
-0.7773578763008118,
-0.5930236577987671,
0.605665385723114,
0.3906044661998749,
-0.023867804557085037,
0.29123061895370483,
-0.5761526823043823,
0.4911264181137085,
0.30575641989707947,
-0.018160637468099594,
0.2069709300994873,
0.7103662490844727,
0.2144545167684555,
0.6042632460594177,
0.5508784651756287,
0.218092143535614,
0.38479822874069214,
-0.001975113060325384,
1.1677632331848145,
-0.6669919490814209,
-0.4531378448009491,
-0.6180799603462219,
0.69401615858078,
0.3129703402519226,
0.0942843109369278,
0.7837209105491638,
0.6729829907417297,
1.1646521091461182,
-0.45984014868736267,
0.8659161329269409,
-0.39799249172210693,
0.016001775860786438,
-0.7334086298942566,
0.7118276953697205,
-0.41919413208961487,
0.45983800292015076,
-0.21750134229660034,
-0.8483735918998718,
-0.4410174787044525,
0.41056591272354126,
0.0575314536690712,
0.007716530002653599,
0.47022345662117004,
0.8978014588356018,
-0.21774449944496155,
-0.5295631885528564,
0.2877984642982483,
0.05299638211727142,
0.3163380026817322,
0.6273533701896667,
0.9050408601760864,
-0.434431791305542,
0.6919730305671692,
-0.14934778213500977,
-0.12924017012119293,
-0.012369370087981224,
-0.7319196462631226,
-0.8012465238571167,
-0.5676681995391846,
-0.26917991042137146,
-0.2679760456085205,
0.13345006108283997,
0.94493168592453,
0.7168107628822327,
-0.7815172672271729,
-0.6807207465171814,
-0.14472675323486328,
-0.04964061081409454,
0.17937061190605164,
-0.1421586275100708,
0.08574453741312027,
-0.5534820556640625,
-0.5790742635726929,
0.1741083562374115,
0.1778782308101654,
-0.09914267808198929,
-0.4273300766944885,
-0.7306920289993286,
-0.14641506969928741,
-0.21206070482730865,
0.6030751466751099,
0.28028619289398193,
-0.3483627438545227,
-0.10914424806833267,
0.12872180342674255,
-0.3139471411705017,
0.08569979667663574,
1.2127381563186646,
-0.8547782897949219,
0.5168266296386719,
0.4747832417488098,
0.529444694519043,
0.2419305443763733,
-0.5167583227157593,
0.8330954909324646,
-0.910304605960846,
0.48623573780059814,
0.16780368983745575,
0.6362899541854858,
0.3346058130264282,
-0.21513038873672485,
0.35016265511512756,
-0.22446998953819275,
-0.430213987827301,
-0.8952040076255798,
0.17142434418201447,
-0.3769404888153076,
-0.30712229013442993,
1.057625412940979,
-0.4542538821697235,
-0.08656281232833862,
-0.044322483241558075,
-0.1888749599456787,
0.25230666995048523,
-0.3313351571559906,
0.0733833909034729,
0.348491370677948,
-0.06678607314825058,
-0.31939202547073364,
-0.2638491094112396,
0.2543489336967468,
0.18814294040203094,
-0.5685058832168579,
0.10509540885686874,
0.602473795413971,
0.1951088160276413,
0.2919473946094513,
0.7066065073013306,
-0.36976566910743713,
0.3022196590900421,
0.1681598573923111,
0.4533265233039856,
-0.00021521539019886404,
-0.6689549088478088,
-0.44740259647369385,
-0.058241769671440125,
0.4185459017753601,
-0.003437349572777748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03893v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03893v3
|
From One to Many: Expanding the Scope of Toxicity Mitigation in Language Models
| 2024-03-06T17:51:43 | 2024-05-30T17:37:11 |
Luiza Pozzobon, Patrick Lewis, Sara Hooker, Beyza Ermis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To date, toxicity mitigation in language models has almost entirely been
focused on single-language settings. As language models embrace multilingual
capabilities, it's crucial our safety measures keep pace. Recognizing this
research gap, our approach expands the scope of conventional toxicity
mitigation to address the complexities presented by multiple languages. In the
absence of sufficient annotated datasets across languages, we employ translated
data to evaluate and enhance our mitigation techniques. We also compare
finetuning mitigation approaches against retrieval-augmented techniques under
both static and continual toxicity mitigation scenarios. This allows us to
examine the effects of translation quality and the cross-lingual transfer on
toxicity mitigation. We also explore how model size and data quantity affect
the success of these mitigation efforts. Covering nine languages, our study
represents a broad array of linguistic families and levels of resource
availability, ranging from high to mid-resource languages. Through
comprehensive experiments, we provide insights into the complexities of
multilingual toxicity mitigation, offering valuable insights and paving the way
for future research in this increasingly important field. Code and data are
available at https://github.com/for-ai/goodtriever.
|
[
-0.18831302225589752,
-0.5127841234207153,
0.28489217162132263,
0.4398204982280731,
0.0380220040678978,
-0.3762572109699249,
-0.12356740236282349,
-0.45854783058166504,
-0.17118878662586212,
0.8086275458335876,
-0.35597577691078186,
-0.5315950512886047,
-0.5139657258987427,
0.0957777351140976,
-0.0166764035820961,
1.2489118576049805,
0.2012992799282074,
0.13590800762176514,
-0.19507229328155518,
-0.5674264430999756,
-0.34431377053260803,
-0.5992472767829895,
-0.7348964214324951,
-0.2519090473651886,
1.1306912899017334,
0.7468448877334595,
0.8181097507476807,
0.2360004335641861,
0.6560651063919067,
0.20955628156661987,
-0.09026394784450531,
-0.178165003657341,
-0.6955835223197937,
0.10545110702514648,
-0.41329196095466614,
-0.4965175986289978,
-0.36559349298477173,
-0.1258547306060791,
0.6155135631561279,
0.6964543461799622,
-0.17468619346618652,
-0.023888079449534416,
0.0848178043961525,
0.8268960118293762,
-1.0199759006500244,
-0.12407030910253525,
-0.4195723831653595,
0.1251930296421051,
-0.29424282908439636,
-0.17716071009635925,
-0.6265905499458313,
-0.4158400297164917,
0.22019575536251068,
-0.5400945544242859,
-0.3919670581817627,
-0.11827044188976288,
0.42684605717658997,
0.30956360697746277,
-0.7855468988418579,
-0.11098335683345795,
-0.7217239141464233,
0.9513848423957825,
-0.8839484453201294,
0.18685416877269745,
0.39650774002075195,
0.22059659659862518,
0.0639403834939003,
-0.678616464138031,
-0.05968130752444267,
-0.064537413418293,
-0.21577072143554688,
0.09051625430583954,
-0.19417674839496613,
0.10200883448123932,
0.08617226034402847,
-0.017618048936128616,
-0.5542923212051392,
0.03814667463302612,
-0.36875540018081665,
-0.4750056564807892,
0.6019539833068848,
0.1474100947380066,
0.5968428254127502,
-0.06267606467008591,
-0.4658169746398926,
-0.04180687293410301,
-0.8870669007301331,
-0.14830952882766724,
0.41303327679634094,
0.5309176445007324,
-0.09706383943557739,
0.21940088272094727,
-0.10864835232496262,
0.24442912638187408,
-0.7104242444038391,
0.20167164504528046,
0.22972320020198822,
-0.8737512230873108,
0.02603675238788128,
0.15311966836452484,
0.8712462782859802,
0.4347284734249115,
0.12199128419160843,
-0.24716521799564362,
0.20768606662750244,
-0.34504324197769165,
0.28732579946517944,
-1.0127497911453247,
-0.1251545250415802,
0.12602250277996063,
-0.5214815735816956,
-0.284140944480896,
-0.3460182547569275,
-0.9250379204750061,
-0.41017720103263855,
0.1725997030735016,
0.6001583337783813,
-0.2587679326534271,
-0.654963493347168,
0.3111425042152405,
-0.049982164055109024,
-0.09969500452280045,
-0.1891435980796814,
-0.6398550271987915,
0.2812579572200775,
0.36661651730537415,
0.8772700428962708,
-0.24201126396656036,
-0.47532597184181213,
-0.48180851340293884,
0.36528700590133667,
-0.45827344059944153,
0.7280107140541077,
-0.5610652565956116,
-0.573598325252533,
0.07296332716941833,
-0.06953088939189911,
0.0551128126680851,
-0.5609613656997681,
0.7683811187744141,
-0.2454487681388855,
0.2517307996749878,
-0.5399562120437622,
0.06867069005966187,
-0.28686168789863586,
0.3267236351966858,
-0.8271619081497192,
0.5275601148605347,
-0.029522182419896126,
-0.8869138956069946,
0.11341936886310577,
-0.6841174960136414,
-0.7366330623626709,
-0.13259318470954895,
0.3805537521839142,
-0.5557788610458374,
0.0862366110086441,
-0.14927293360233307,
0.17018228769302368,
-0.27037447690963745,
-0.0666007548570633,
-0.3601904511451721,
-0.04477391019463539,
-0.10785015672445297,
-0.5880813598632812,
0.8140077590942383,
0.532098114490509,
0.2516258955001831,
0.45092278718948364,
-0.36030256748199463,
0.14962507784366608,
-0.010901695117354393,
-0.4292246699333191,
-0.6887907385826111,
0.07317604124546051,
0.47013524174690247,
0.6946392059326172,
-0.04889615625143051,
-0.44692620635032654,
-0.16197597980499268,
-0.5006166100502014,
0.5288696885108948,
0.23885677754878998,
0.4728648364543915,
0.5781798362731934,
-0.523252010345459,
0.4692726135253906,
0.10578478872776031,
0.5509428977966309,
-0.10707248747348785,
-0.2947080731391907,
-0.4730755090713501,
0.0030104222241789103,
0.04053078964352608,
0.5496485233306885,
-0.6392230987548828,
-0.015385702252388,
-0.35202521085739136,
-0.5255338549613953,
-0.3272783160209656,
0.03748500347137451,
0.7614691853523254,
0.16450992226600647,
0.5482037663459778,
-0.3581433594226837,
-0.23746873438358307,
-0.8897028565406799,
-0.34063318371772766,
-0.05222070962190628,
0.24479511380195618,
0.38207975029945374,
0.34382131695747375,
-0.5268467664718628,
0.6142717003822327,
-0.30882713198661804,
-0.4488968551158905,
-0.1642654538154602,
-0.0937628373503685,
-0.2679470479488373,
0.6906119585037231,
0.8229403495788574,
-0.6681570410728455,
-0.6625534296035767,
0.33429208397865295,
-0.613569974899292,
-0.09317832440137863,
-0.20220226049423218,
-0.5705973505973816,
0.008724778890609741,
0.4595932364463806,
-0.24082814157009125,
0.16544513404369354,
0.6986145973205566,
-0.05025248974561691,
0.4257477819919586,
-0.2925708293914795,
0.2294369637966156,
-0.930595874786377,
0.26596513390541077,
-0.0910332202911377,
0.0885484591126442,
-1.1104590892791748,
0.2846793234348297,
0.0918235033750534,
-0.01266990602016449,
-0.9216514229774475,
0.7812697887420654,
-0.3503626585006714,
0.3731774687767029,
-0.05417514592409134,
-0.09001606702804565,
0.12213089317083359,
0.1453520953655243,
-0.18107163906097412,
0.7494242787361145,
0.6128487586975098,
-0.6066974401473999,
-0.0820864886045456,
0.37154141068458557,
0.14814908802509308,
0.4974260926246643,
-0.3975880742073059,
-0.18669700622558594,
-0.07085712254047394,
0.2073560357093811,
-0.8319070339202881,
-0.14684170484542847,
0.28152722120285034,
-0.359314501285553,
0.30376169085502625,
-0.3419235348701477,
-0.5463035702705383,
-0.09629926085472107,
-0.3527527153491974,
0.587834358215332,
0.07114295661449432,
-0.43616238236427307,
0.5613538026809692,
0.5170614123344421,
-0.45622438192367554,
-0.4607320725917816,
-0.9467708468437195,
0.24725231528282166,
-0.6370913982391357,
-0.702948808670044,
-0.08738397806882858,
-0.3946322798728943,
-0.12799394130706787,
-0.22699619829654694,
-0.16805621981620789,
-0.46741366386413574,
0.28918397426605225,
-0.27818816900253296,
-0.05565347522497177,
-0.19099323451519012,
0.5037233829498291,
0.2868211269378662,
-0.36131516098976135,
0.2658059895038605,
0.0024278766941279173,
0.4346303939819336,
-0.053213685750961304,
-0.14669959247112274,
-0.024754222482442856,
0.812954306602478,
0.5875356197357178,
-0.7623089551925659,
0.8585986495018005,
0.3631255328655243,
-0.37132737040519714,
0.01912335306406021,
-0.2897355556488037,
-0.062386203557252884,
-0.46635645627975464,
0.6626822352409363,
-0.3173012435436249,
-0.41584503650665283,
0.8264797925949097,
-0.1923598349094391,
0.06242820993065834,
0.5164262652397156,
0.5312049388885498,
0.44346779584884644,
1.0314652919769287,
0.6242740154266357,
-0.346538782119751,
0.43144431710243225,
-0.12800250947475433,
0.19827866554260254,
-0.6977138519287109,
-0.00043433482642285526,
-0.6157116293907166,
0.08056461066007614,
-0.4935556948184967,
-0.3692830502986908,
0.5169317126274109,
-0.060896195471286774,
-0.49510470032691956,
0.1746223419904709,
-0.47401753067970276,
0.6803858280181885,
0.2835460603237152,
0.3466138243675232,
0.4745911657810211,
-0.052085477858781815,
-0.14103162288665771,
-0.004968334920704365,
-0.9415048956871033,
-0.49534645676612854,
1.120330572128296,
0.4523041248321533,
0.7944613695144653,
0.4600553810596466,
0.6440988779067993,
-0.26121336221694946,
0.5416579842567444,
-0.47031188011169434,
0.14131063222885132,
-0.39061519503593445,
-1.2309973239898682,
-0.3914460837841034,
-0.5514320731163025,
-0.8464335799217224,
0.3942248225212097,
-0.023377390578389168,
-0.5051049590110779,
0.05435488745570183,
-0.13642118871212006,
-0.3463096618652344,
0.2795124351978302,
-0.8715602159500122,
1.3087780475616455,
-0.5125530362129211,
-0.8233810663223267,
-0.449374794960022,
-0.9290945529937744,
0.32520240545272827,
-0.31310775876045227,
0.4826490581035614,
-0.14489494264125824,
-0.06864085793495178,
0.5663931369781494,
0.007681999821215868,
0.6845381259918213,
0.09846889227628708,
-0.30277809500694275,
0.34962913393974304,
0.05794856697320938,
0.3003263771533966,
0.20320168137550354,
-0.40552908182144165,
0.34599119424819946,
0.2802762985229492,
-0.6446409821510315,
0.05571695789694786,
0.9569517374038696,
-0.43977051973342896,
-0.21740682423114777,
-0.29421916604042053,
-0.7989720106124878,
-0.19118396937847137,
0.6336070895195007,
0.43845608830451965,
-0.022348765283823013,
-0.3031768798828125,
0.05920924246311188,
0.6398412585258484,
-0.8176509141921997,
0.38898614048957825,
0.5918058753013611,
-0.025651540607213974,
-0.21979720890522003,
1.1323778629302979,
-0.08735991269350052,
0.810427188873291,
0.18437688052654266,
0.5673715472221375,
-0.18753044307231903,
-0.41057270765304565,
-0.21442800760269165,
0.2480306476354599,
-1.0061615705490112,
-0.1853613257408142,
-0.4779754877090454,
-0.17867118120193481,
-0.2622315585613251,
0.0755053162574768,
-0.5210819244384766,
-0.02670823410153389,
-0.17496941983699799,
-0.053889065980911255,
0.2665290832519531,
0.4569467306137085,
-0.12967389822006226,
0.3005618751049042,
-1.26295804977417,
-0.0012248847633600235,
0.05798088386654854,
0.6634199619293213,
-0.06478999555110931,
-0.12695756554603577,
-0.22870612144470215,
0.18545027077198029,
-0.27574479579925537,
-1.0222886800765991,
0.4207358956336975,
0.4450930953025818,
0.8454110622406006,
0.19882777333259583,
0.19486449658870697,
0.511589527130127,
-0.6262292265892029,
0.48950693011283875,
0.2830745577812195,
-0.7723993062973022,
0.5508792996406555,
-0.5802947282791138,
0.30621016025543213,
0.7221609950065613,
0.49024951457977295,
-0.906360924243927,
-0.44311437010765076,
-0.08540511131286621,
-0.9141942262649536,
0.5388360619544983,
0.3723025619983673,
0.500869870185852,
-0.12443885952234268,
0.106707863509655,
0.08530756831169128,
-0.1784660965204239,
-0.7263984680175781,
-0.34906861186027527,
-0.068778395652771,
-0.16883592307567596,
-0.18717491626739502,
-0.2875916659832001,
-0.2994546592235565,
-0.07661962509155273,
0.5992786884307861,
0.07003536820411682,
-0.1317102015018463,
-0.045680463314056396,
-0.2814001739025116,
-0.38129743933677673,
0.5847685933113098,
0.4697364270687103,
0.1917315423488617,
0.10103090852499008,
-0.056745562702417374,
0.33672234416007996,
-0.5055598616600037,
0.01742340251803398,
0.12337282299995422,
-0.009219181723892689,
-0.3304305076599121,
0.3339751660823822,
0.4319465160369873,
0.1930936723947525,
-0.6485799551010132,
0.29773685336112976,
0.02796405926346779,
-0.008778502233326435,
0.21022003889083862,
0.003557192860171199,
0.0684465542435646,
0.09667277336120605,
0.11483548581600189,
0.07761922478675842,
0.43342265486717224,
-0.6426264643669128,
0.4664791524410248,
0.3779895305633545,
-0.4424065947532654,
-0.035111866891384125,
0.6248717308044434,
0.5036547780036926,
0.12418798357248306,
0.4700753688812256,
-0.04961002618074417,
-0.5083105564117432,
0.6408848166465759,
0.5280301570892334,
0.6110820174217224,
-0.43094658851623535,
-0.0033679576590657234,
0.7445059418678284,
0.42517581582069397,
-0.07407001405954361,
-0.03525008261203766,
0.5733619928359985,
-0.6518139243125916,
-0.2703555226325989,
-0.2694295644760132,
-0.15172810852527618,
-0.23105312883853912,
-0.5819573402404785,
0.038091324269771576,
-0.12507647275924683,
-0.05449735373258591,
-0.061281025409698486,
-0.013282031752169132,
-0.2836025357246399,
-0.15448597073554993,
0.19024179875850677,
0.6574540138244629,
-1.1999207735061646,
0.6799734830856323,
0.5898342132568359,
-0.8491941690444946,
-0.5109272599220276,
0.076204314827919,
0.10220717638731003,
-0.2004568874835968,
0.26753684878349304,
0.1506774127483368,
-0.003716179868206382,
0.23114582896232605,
-0.3282625079154968,
-0.9156227111816406,
0.781523585319519,
0.23109793663024902,
-0.3660232424736023,
0.12093469500541687,
0.22788487374782562,
0.6317667961120605,
0.04330766946077347,
0.17294487357139587,
0.7960094213485718,
0.6484352350234985,
-0.06154850870370865,
-1.0481237173080444,
-0.012564288452267647,
-0.21872828900814056,
-0.15293988585472107,
0.20897723734378815,
-0.5170648097991943,
0.6276132464408875,
-0.345069944858551,
-0.24839623272418976,
0.1043638214468956,
0.09280344843864441,
0.002656229306012392,
0.40327972173690796,
0.2444656491279602,
0.44355708360671997,
0.4429668188095093,
0.10777938365936279,
1.0291155576705933,
-0.20592637360095978,
0.48609447479248047,
1.1010950803756714,
-0.18674230575561523,
0.699958086013794,
0.39362746477127075,
-0.1861337572336197,
0.14873939752578735,
0.5099619030952454,
0.3064426779747009,
0.70963454246521,
0.2812032401561737,
-0.40604281425476074,
-0.24400945007801056,
-0.3935214579105377,
-0.27606168389320374,
0.0786823183298111,
0.44318848848342896,
-0.09969127178192139,
-0.515526294708252,
0.447039932012558,
0.12769266963005066,
0.11474064737558365,
-0.230677530169487,
0.6299436688423157,
0.05411415919661522,
-0.5935295820236206,
0.4986373782157898,
-0.23370486497879028,
0.5799500346183777,
-0.5982933640480042,
-0.013284002430737019,
-0.4484253227710724,
0.33995670080184937,
-0.38113829493522644,
-0.8717143535614014,
0.49602454900741577,
-0.2597024142742157,
0.019667701795697212,
-0.07193268090486526,
0.6138398051261902,
-0.7008323669433594,
-0.3615321218967438,
0.663453221321106,
0.6077783703804016,
0.09730713069438934,
-0.21355101466178894,
-0.5880941152572632,
-0.06409402936697006,
-0.11370561271905899,
-0.0036594734992831945,
0.3224630057811737,
0.4496341347694397,
-0.4527023136615753,
0.8593303561210632,
0.565647304058075,
0.04816713556647301,
0.31329628825187683,
0.2589142620563507,
0.9000260829925537,
-0.34384241700172424,
-0.22178080677986145,
-0.637628972530365,
0.7123355269432068,
0.18466368317604065,
-0.38607364892959595,
0.7888879776000977,
0.7313183546066284,
0.8104840517044067,
-0.04771832749247551,
0.6753216981887817,
0.1329716145992279,
0.2047867327928543,
-0.25650206208229065,
1.169199824333191,
-0.724442720413208,
0.2675403356552124,
-0.33700472116470337,
-0.6998705267906189,
-0.8268283605575562,
0.49122104048728943,
-0.11276256293058395,
0.03746816888451576,
0.8556140661239624,
0.847811222076416,
-0.08246859908103943,
-0.46373385190963745,
0.3024355173110962,
0.3685673475265503,
0.5191850662231445,
0.7276588082313538,
0.6105196475982666,
-0.48256534337997437,
0.9158649444580078,
-0.47820132970809937,
0.018473410978913307,
-0.12900806963443756,
-0.817696213722229,
-0.6014584302902222,
-0.33114418387413025,
-0.343374103307724,
-0.15985119342803955,
0.23207987844944,
0.4306592345237732,
0.6573460102081299,
-0.8839489221572876,
-0.009093713015317917,
-0.12263642251491547,
0.29876357316970825,
-0.22858808934688568,
-0.1287059187889099,
0.09613216668367386,
-0.5575628280639648,
-0.366215318441391,
-0.031335167586803436,
0.1678180694580078,
-0.04757225140929222,
-0.15274792909622192,
-0.46924999356269836,
-0.35769572854042053,
0.06298807263374329,
0.7778739929199219,
0.367991179227829,
-0.5612549781799316,
-0.3629213273525238,
-0.08528168499469757,
-0.5435187816619873,
0.033552832901477814,
0.44968265295028687,
-0.23601402342319489,
0.6422324776649475,
0.6223763823509216,
0.5263941884040833,
0.19799302518367767,
-0.24522767961025238,
0.478120356798172,
-0.8224084377288818,
0.15703345835208893,
0.4164716303348541,
0.219040647149086,
0.19321851432323456,
-0.35629594326019287,
0.7289791107177734,
-0.3693053126335144,
-0.45613986253738403,
-0.6669514775276184,
0.3667594790458679,
-0.8094184994697571,
-0.5491797924041748,
1.4579068422317505,
-0.32252731919288635,
0.24723480641841888,
-0.18289130926132202,
-0.3310949504375458,
0.39899373054504395,
-0.0014597101835533977,
0.603152334690094,
0.8287839293479919,
0.23146431148052216,
-0.1777101755142212,
-1.0294280052185059,
0.37956714630126953,
0.4896911382675171,
-1.27104651927948,
0.3558298945426941,
0.4860018491744995,
0.5421972870826721,
0.2097780853509903,
0.4727735221385956,
-0.3822053372859955,
0.42523476481437683,
-0.3480890989303589,
0.08591971546411514,
0.472201406955719,
-0.48379936814308167,
-0.45906275510787964,
-0.32322973012924194,
0.12009941786527634,
0.16265034675598145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03888v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03888v2
|
FaaF: Facts as a Function for the evaluation of generated text
| 2024-03-06T17:48:06 | 2024-04-08T14:49:52 |
Vasileios Katranidis, Gabor Barany
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The demand for accurate and efficient verification of information in texts
generated by large language models (LMs) is at an all-time high, but remains
unresolved. Recent efforts have focused on extracting and verifying atomic
facts from these texts via prompting LM evaluators. However, we demonstrate
that this method of prompting is unreliable when faced with incomplete or
inaccurate reference information. We introduce Facts as a Function (FaaF), a
new approach to the fact verification task that leverages the function-calling
capabilities of LMs. FaaF significantly enhances the ability of LMs to identify
unsupported facts in texts, while also improving efficiency and significantly
lowering costs compared to prompt-based methods. Additionally, we propose a
framework for evaluating factual recall in Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
systems, which we employ to compare prompt-based and FaaF methods using various
LMs under challenging conditions.
|
[
-0.171454519033432,
-1.2016711235046387,
0.9404981732368469,
0.1640642136335373,
-0.2651180624961853,
-0.05887731909751892,
-0.04826659336686134,
-0.20368517935276031,
-0.0906778872013092,
0.4872272312641144,
-0.5274584889411926,
-0.17415761947631836,
-0.47776180505752563,
0.4896257817745209,
-0.6870670318603516,
1.0065425634384155,
0.2624324858188629,
-0.21802298724651337,
-0.7763833999633789,
-0.05245662108063698,
-0.15290702879428864,
-0.5595319867134094,
-0.4899909794330597,
-0.4432523250579834,
0.29732879996299744,
0.5847591161727905,
0.6787709593772888,
0.6145013570785522,
0.5224977731704712,
0.29962366819381714,
0.03905479982495308,
0.7675504088401794,
-0.29106470942497253,
0.15930795669555664,
-0.01880425214767456,
-0.13862842321395874,
-0.14827510714530945,
-0.3188311755657196,
0.9048000574111938,
0.539878249168396,
-0.11738204210996628,
0.3223579525947571,
-0.19611436128616333,
0.8321652412414551,
-0.6918429732322693,
0.38447752594947815,
-0.6038892269134521,
-0.16201679408550262,
-0.02952880598604679,
-0.42060258984565735,
-0.6664206981658936,
-0.8730295896530151,
0.1406964212656021,
-0.45765841007232666,
0.25619935989379883,
0.2332398146390915,
1.070451021194458,
0.28531336784362793,
-0.6687076687812805,
-0.6914507150650024,
-0.7260366678237915,
0.531076967716217,
-0.5051058530807495,
0.6945500373840332,
0.38835734128952026,
-0.015343763865530491,
-0.4475533962249756,
-0.7421464323997498,
-0.8697433471679688,
-0.586105227470398,
-0.305589497089386,
-0.15013983845710754,
-0.029133204370737076,
-0.15333285927772522,
0.531312882900238,
0.28701964020729065,
-0.17804384231567383,
-0.5320244431495667,
-0.2822638154029846,
-0.31055065989494324,
0.5001876950263977,
-0.015272695571184158,
0.3886977732181549,
-0.4388894736766815,
-0.6165680289268494,
-0.09249548614025116,
-0.8748400211334229,
0.07038036733865738,
0.16975845396518707,
0.4000817835330963,
-0.07353483885526657,
0.5829211473464966,
-0.14074763655662537,
0.6075079441070557,
0.12250301986932755,
-0.43345946073532104,
0.22722461819648743,
-0.3450705111026764,
-0.2911895513534546,
0.13262662291526794,
0.646666407585144,
0.14409926533699036,
0.032802559435367584,
-0.12184561043977737,
-0.3309701979160309,
-0.43554577231407166,
0.11732311546802521,
-1.023424506187439,
0.08492663502693176,
0.1940881311893463,
-0.1622803807258606,
-0.38674160838127136,
0.2910323143005371,
-0.6332593560218811,
-0.5901079177856445,
-0.017327072098851204,
0.6920329332351685,
-0.389497309923172,
-0.23694102466106415,
-0.06886229664087296,
-0.22980649769306183,
-0.1023961678147316,
0.2156623899936676,
-0.5850180983543396,
0.11239897459745407,
0.5659539699554443,
0.7081862688064575,
0.16233356297016144,
-0.04800552874803543,
-1.00406014919281,
-0.1308227777481079,
-0.5155010223388672,
0.8789244294166565,
-0.3307514786720276,
-0.6078518033027649,
0.17449238896369934,
-0.20788410305976868,
0.13444997370243073,
-0.4735029637813568,
0.9059801697731018,
-0.7271262407302856,
-0.04902505874633789,
-0.8810861110687256,
-0.5679548978805542,
-0.3005746304988861,
0.20224033296108246,
-0.9161068201065063,
1.3612408638000488,
0.08946456015110016,
-0.7035509347915649,
0.3234168589115143,
-0.7849141359329224,
-0.6809195876121521,
0.0808398574590683,
-0.16058892011642456,
-0.512359619140625,
-0.02068757452070713,
0.012163921259343624,
0.437288761138916,
-0.6155108213424683,
0.5491041541099548,
-0.2223627120256424,
-0.2981353998184204,
0.7646710276603699,
-0.5680524110794067,
0.6240676045417786,
0.3081014156341553,
-0.23496748507022858,
-0.07343820482492447,
-0.9289372563362122,
-0.22149349749088287,
0.0731508880853653,
-0.7825060486793518,
-0.2011677771806717,
0.2658623158931732,
-0.24221080541610718,
-0.2804354131221771,
0.15627720952033997,
-0.6704269051551819,
-0.207305908203125,
-0.3940340280532837,
-0.10177309066057205,
0.47668904066085815,
0.39465203881263733,
0.062029194086790085,
-0.4603070616722107,
0.1760319471359253,
-0.07399257272481918,
-0.27350282669067383,
-0.4931827485561371,
-0.2406160980463028,
-0.9704288244247437,
-0.33123183250427246,
0.36240553855895996,
0.316363126039505,
-1.0966732501983643,
0.47851458191871643,
-0.0821918398141861,
-0.3380764424800873,
0.027418645098805428,
-0.07194630056619644,
0.4273076355457306,
1.0060564279556274,
0.14635637402534485,
0.29807615280151367,
-0.65470290184021,
-0.5476760268211365,
-0.21328900754451752,
-0.5960652232170105,
0.22776183485984802,
0.19842477142810822,
0.38271474838256836,
-0.029227159917354584,
1.0446726083755493,
-0.46846863627433777,
0.18813206255435944,
0.004239311907440424,
0.38284066319465637,
0.21749864518642426,
0.03732411935925484,
0.5843327045440674,
-0.8749240636825562,
-0.15109913051128387,
0.02351018227636814,
-0.8034844994544983,
-0.30184608697891235,
-0.0839158445596695,
0.28326907753944397,
0.6508697271347046,
0.48084715008735657,
-0.6081814765930176,
0.23418353497982025,
0.25618571043014526,
-0.662912905216217,
0.7135449647903442,
-0.20076796412467957,
0.7008143663406372,
-0.40416786074638367,
0.6967660188674927,
-0.1644778847694397,
-0.5162953734397888,
-0.5387329459190369,
0.10764625668525696,
0.22721855342388153,
-0.02823938988149166,
-0.3391244411468506,
0.7742887735366821,
-0.5254800915718079,
0.13238056004047394,
-0.48623746633529663,
0.08818215131759644,
-0.015415458008646965,
0.18466220796108246,
-0.17231781780719757,
0.8294886350631714,
0.37794482707977295,
-1.1007509231567383,
0.3435021936893463,
0.20749905705451965,
-0.5337598323822021,
0.3460405766963959,
-0.33125239610671997,
0.016624892130494118,
-0.22860665619373322,
0.021785754710435867,
-1.0483267307281494,
-0.30938881635665894,
0.186594158411026,
-0.36125627160072327,
0.07854711264371872,
0.01602943427860737,
-0.593865692615509,
-0.2886969745159149,
-0.10656832903623581,
0.11785618215799332,
0.4825759530067444,
-0.7337032556533813,
0.7239830493927002,
0.4222888648509979,
-0.14697493612766266,
-0.8791583776473999,
-0.15111401677131653,
-0.24296529591083527,
0.05052999407052994,
-0.37114548683166504,
-0.147004172205925,
-0.1196252629160881,
-0.44000759720802307,
0.08803602308034897,
-0.489885538816452,
-0.08262573927640915,
0.3186724781990051,
0.2876666188240051,
0.3954603374004364,
-0.32812583446502686,
0.4131682515144348,
0.002323179505765438,
0.06658680737018585,
0.26206472516059875,
0.002323983935639262,
0.15046627819538116,
0.007673580665141344,
-0.3002816438674927,
0.030986471101641655,
0.23066948354244232,
0.6335690021514893,
-0.15853725373744965,
0.4934688210487366,
0.5030890107154846,
-0.5154298543930054,
-0.39872226119041443,
-0.6826635599136353,
-0.23051702976226807,
-0.4610849618911743,
0.2990878224372864,
-0.2581409215927124,
-0.8563851118087769,
0.2743953466415405,
-0.05482175946235657,
0.14203763008117676,
0.6509215831756592,
0.49237993359565735,
0.18465273082256317,
0.5971455574035645,
0.6295410990715027,
0.49555644392967224,
0.18115739524364471,
0.270804226398468,
0.3000725209712982,
-0.18464943766593933,
-0.42666998505592346,
-0.8210630416870117,
0.3172919452190399,
-0.018895139917731285,
-0.40963366627693176,
0.6809068918228149,
0.15773212909698486,
-0.28836575150489807,
-0.07975427806377411,
-0.0003276960924267769,
0.6951990723609924,
0.21954095363616943,
0.003936835564672947,
0.5023120641708374,
0.10108539462089539,
-0.1878659576177597,
0.4570715129375458,
-0.5785399675369263,
-0.47020524740219116,
1.0584220886230469,
0.340878963470459,
0.35370534658432007,
0.22932974994182587,
0.42399492859840393,
0.6217921376228333,
0.6730035543441772,
-1.0394917726516724,
0.6885113716125488,
-0.17109434306621552,
-0.772494375705719,
-0.4238036572933197,
-0.7259053587913513,
-0.44254446029663086,
0.04939034581184387,
-0.5538158416748047,
-0.53758704662323,
0.05376920476555824,
0.3828294277191162,
-0.7019882202148438,
0.10172013193368912,
-0.7013103365898132,
0.38702327013015747,
-0.1596355140209198,
-0.26365402340888977,
-0.01370819378644228,
-0.21208558976650238,
0.6095386147499084,
-0.3152831196784973,
0.4656008780002594,
-0.22246630489826202,
0.08442718535661697,
0.8349053859710693,
-0.6487990617752075,
0.565015435218811,
-0.18187227845191956,
-0.24162594974040985,
0.6970874667167664,
0.25212711095809937,
0.595735490322113,
0.16108214855194092,
-0.39316505193710327,
-0.12589845061302185,
0.2122979760169983,
0.23691697418689728,
-0.7367786169052124,
0.6387007832527161,
-0.39544326066970825,
-0.7075655460357666,
-0.6932321190834045,
-0.3863750100135803,
-0.29809609055519104,
0.4289481043815613,
0.06747305393218994,
0.800635039806366,
-0.42248350381851196,
0.3288241922855377,
0.7006178498268127,
0.028850454837083817,
0.5904597043991089,
0.8058258891105652,
-0.4447231888771057,
-0.2870771884918213,
0.9896835684776306,
-0.04132596030831337,
0.0439140684902668,
0.6135479211807251,
0.33894971013069153,
-0.7406365275382996,
-0.17395778000354767,
-0.693115234375,
0.15474681556224823,
-0.8404478430747986,
-0.5066736340522766,
-0.863439679145813,
-0.1408844143152237,
-0.10378272086381912,
0.28611743450164795,
-0.1974327713251114,
-0.5991066694259644,
-0.1647140085697174,
-0.17384982109069824,
0.5684478282928467,
0.8730233907699585,
-0.13772805035114288,
0.0916241705417633,
-0.9892175793647766,
0.5208389163017273,
0.12133194506168365,
0.3117538392543793,
-0.030116967856884003,
-0.315239280462265,
-0.32186204195022583,
0.023273078724741936,
-0.21092624962329865,
-1.0529025793075562,
-0.07637624442577362,
0.2586430311203003,
0.48140910267829895,
0.33235931396484375,
0.3949534595012665,
0.27457451820373535,
-0.5670420527458191,
0.7357511520385742,
0.22499044239521027,
-1.173414707183838,
0.14521564543247223,
-0.10312242060899734,
-0.01565454714000225,
0.25783613324165344,
0.3184777796268463,
-0.43677258491516113,
-0.19100189208984375,
-0.6853767037391663,
-0.5311480164527893,
0.8494677543640137,
0.11431930959224701,
0.023075681179761887,
-0.2643396854400635,
0.4523228704929352,
0.010406877845525742,
0.2020273357629776,
-0.43787410855293274,
-0.6014499664306641,
-0.07688750326633453,
-0.27356240153312683,
0.16458208858966827,
-0.5226506590843201,
-0.33869674801826477,
0.09785901010036469,
0.8710839748382568,
-0.3825189173221588,
0.23721840977668762,
0.501537024974823,
-0.02755540795624256,
-0.41003379225730896,
0.27009356021881104,
0.6608952879905701,
0.757925271987915,
-0.20550991594791412,
0.44698798656463623,
0.26173508167266846,
-0.42126554250717163,
0.29360273480415344,
0.07153413444757462,
-0.42122316360473633,
0.2757660746574402,
0.2770577371120453,
0.6767134070396423,
0.3399486243724823,
-0.827887773513794,
0.6057782173156738,
0.07998810708522797,
-0.11752163618803024,
-0.017653735354542732,
0.3444483280181885,
-0.01139183808118105,
0.0066793556325137615,
0.6625267863273621,
0.06462782621383667,
0.3017568588256836,
-0.6528555154800415,
0.693178117275238,
0.44981157779693604,
-0.22580385208129883,
-0.21433258056640625,
0.378558486700058,
0.3661154806613922,
-0.24356377124786377,
0.26530763506889343,
-0.2931211590766907,
-0.5385953187942505,
0.6629473567008972,
0.7126748561859131,
0.7682770490646362,
-0.1289030909538269,
0.5167127251625061,
0.5329598784446716,
0.20457279682159424,
-0.2799186110496521,
0.33736667037010193,
-0.11361892521381378,
-0.8035812377929688,
-0.3416598439216614,
-0.8768047094345093,
-0.4709044098854065,
0.2261497974395752,
-0.4182259142398834,
0.3193330764770508,
-0.6067107915878296,
-0.2808728516101837,
0.23094524443149567,
-0.029875515028834343,
-0.3869337737560272,
0.5907008051872253,
0.042356863617897034,
0.8824589252471924,
-0.7930048108100891,
0.4554285407066345,
0.6819607019424438,
-0.3822820782661438,
-0.8248946070671082,
0.21645419299602509,
0.23192287981510162,
-0.6735591888427734,
0.6847802996635437,
-0.07791536301374435,
-0.5606233477592468,
-0.10383155941963196,
-0.49555641412734985,
-0.9316718578338623,
0.6759154796600342,
0.6099923849105835,
-0.11855418235063553,
0.2737125754356384,
-0.13536906242370605,
0.2949407696723938,
-0.21860773861408234,
0.3719441592693329,
0.5774316787719727,
0.7158637642860413,
0.41534796357154846,
-0.7130486965179443,
0.3977021872997284,
-0.16958646476268768,
-0.36167219281196594,
0.22975756227970123,
-0.5220031142234802,
0.6167030930519104,
-0.5992728471755981,
-0.5995872020721436,
0.1598052829504013,
0.9653233885765076,
0.2965966463088989,
0.3741719722747803,
0.658727765083313,
-0.02608853206038475,
1.1010444164276123,
-0.1773998886346817,
0.9535554051399231,
-0.046996839344501495,
0.43687745928764343,
0.7469142079353333,
-0.24482494592666626,
0.7254796028137207,
0.4095233082771301,
0.01745387353003025,
0.4968660771846771,
0.14500395953655243,
0.09352394938468933,
0.22887171804904938,
-0.07061111927032471,
-0.32259777188301086,
-0.33765479922294617,
-0.23964908719062805,
-0.14786534011363983,
0.35654670000076294,
0.2539333701133728,
-0.08881806582212448,
-0.4447394907474518,
-0.24825997650623322,
0.33630645275115967,
0.18026195466518402,
-0.0802849680185318,
0.6738283634185791,
-0.058651819825172424,
-0.9826200604438782,
0.7369282245635986,
0.23110710084438324,
0.049836255609989166,
-0.5791009664535522,
-0.36035433411598206,
-0.09908299148082733,
0.08568724989891052,
-0.34853774309158325,
-0.6848538517951965,
0.3740476667881012,
0.28840944170951843,
-0.4664069414138794,
0.06800077110528946,
0.8077881932258606,
-0.45916640758514404,
-0.4784236550331116,
-0.19382020831108093,
0.346013605594635,
-0.03851167857646942,
0.10995609313249588,
-0.2809324860572815,
0.26524442434310913,
0.2493712455034256,
-0.13475090265274048,
-0.27701839804649353,
0.5273797512054443,
0.09258123487234116,
0.7170859575271606,
0.7544738054275513,
-0.1359168142080307,
-0.25163140892982483,
-0.10013178735971451,
0.5071782469749451,
-0.669609785079956,
-0.44163978099823,
-0.8891409039497375,
0.5611814856529236,
0.01355167105793953,
-0.31080448627471924,
0.6312617659568787,
0.48062142729759216,
0.4021908938884735,
-0.2319498211145401,
0.8695499897003174,
-0.2873506247997284,
0.6742571592330933,
-0.8192893266677856,
0.9942966103553772,
-0.5368896126747131,
0.3301844000816345,
-0.02777349017560482,
-0.5527418255805969,
-0.23806032538414001,
0.3171870708465576,
0.013199690729379654,
0.10634215176105499,
1.052686333656311,
0.8203961253166199,
0.0552389994263649,
0.4559285044670105,
0.40487247705459595,
0.31751224398612976,
0.28648969531059265,
-0.053034208714962006,
0.925777018070221,
-0.44364485144615173,
0.473844438791275,
0.00600943248718977,
-0.30057400465011597,
-0.38335147500038147,
-1.223493218421936,
-0.7936763763427734,
-0.8607362508773804,
-0.516362190246582,
-0.46854886412620544,
-0.029253114014863968,
1.0105018615722656,
0.5086284875869751,
-0.8511232137680054,
-0.23951956629753113,
0.18240666389465332,
0.6077439188957214,
-0.17830225825309753,
-0.19096827507019043,
0.45342355966567993,
-0.4813707768917084,
-0.5560997724533081,
0.5482228994369507,
0.23051689565181732,
-0.12758903205394745,
0.036854684352874756,
-0.039692431688308716,
-0.24071043729782104,
0.701486349105835,
0.6559756398200989,
0.4998336434364319,
-0.5159245729446411,
-0.666960597038269,
0.02560158632695675,
-0.11961285769939423,
-0.1476641446352005,
0.9088426828384399,
-0.727333664894104,
0.2998207211494446,
0.5438694357872009,
0.8477716445922852,
0.10949225723743439,
0.2757772207260132,
0.499389111995697,
-0.8642783164978027,
-0.22139938175678253,
-0.10984966158866882,
0.2814454734325409,
0.5141714215278625,
-0.5655542016029358,
0.22370733320713043,
0.44552743434906006,
-0.4156096577644348,
-1.177392840385437,
0.2275616079568863,
-0.8621671199798584,
-0.10424945503473282,
1.2724310159683228,
-0.18153990805149078,
-0.44854047894477844,
-0.012137636542320251,
-0.19859221577644348,
0.2987992763519287,
-0.4193941652774811,
0.7846395969390869,
0.717827320098877,
-0.06338892877101898,
0.003591813612729311,
0.018294740468263626,
0.9718326330184937,
0.2385949045419693,
-0.850412905216217,
0.3198576867580414,
0.7028992176055908,
0.37765610218048096,
0.41922295093536377,
0.6592546105384827,
-0.08383876085281372,
0.49181124567985535,
-0.05782745033502579,
-0.14966148138046265,
-0.4556083381175995,
-0.5816249847412109,
0.10570094734430313,
0.39869189262390137,
0.23046928644180298,
0.08861709386110306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03883v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03883v2
|
SaulLM-7B: A pioneering Large Language Model for Law
| 2024-03-06T17:42:16 | 2024-03-07T06:39:32 |
Pierre Colombo, Telmo Pessoa Pires, Malik Boudiaf, Dominic Culver, Rui Melo, Caio Corro, Andre F. T. Martins, Fabrizio Esposito, Vera Lúcia Raposo, Sofia Morgado, Michael Desa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce SaulLM-7B, a large language model (LLM) tailored
for the legal domain. With 7 billion parameters, SaulLM-7B is the first LLM
designed explicitly for legal text comprehension and generation. Leveraging the
Mistral 7B architecture as its foundation, SaulLM-7B is trained on an English
legal corpus of over 30 billion tokens. SaulLM-7B exhibits state-of-the-art
proficiency in understanding and processing legal documents. Additionally, we
present a novel instructional fine-tuning method that leverages legal datasets
to further enhance SaulLM-7B's performance in legal tasks. SaulLM-7B is
released under the MIT License.
|
[
-0.3274482488632202,
-0.6957138776779175,
0.7022440433502197,
0.2586071193218231,
-0.668197751045227,
-0.12238262593746185,
-0.10202981531620026,
-0.23774267733097076,
-0.34163913130760193,
1.077276587486267,
0.017258338630199432,
-0.7155725359916687,
-0.5990091562271118,
-0.14900171756744385,
-0.63536137342453,
0.9446130990982056,
0.4972466826438904,
0.33730006217956543,
0.2638571560382843,
-0.38296476006507874,
-0.5950757265090942,
-0.5389248728752136,
-0.9532212615013123,
-0.1664232760667801,
0.6933372616767883,
0.06568490713834763,
0.6391847133636475,
0.8075864911079407,
0.4336699843406677,
0.20708699524402618,
-0.26686111092567444,
-0.15920580923557281,
-0.7159352898597717,
0.07437819242477417,
-0.36131852865219116,
-0.6787186861038208,
-0.5483397841453552,
-0.5959105491638184,
0.514802873134613,
0.5508114099502563,
-0.4430030286312103,
0.06082066148519516,
-0.458039790391922,
0.9079246520996094,
-0.5291027426719666,
0.08811379969120026,
-0.7707281708717346,
-0.32084891200065613,
-0.30907341837882996,
0.05863408371806145,
-0.785779595375061,
-0.09852319210767746,
-0.19038181006908417,
-0.5691074132919312,
0.26677754521369934,
0.4998868703842163,
0.555575430393219,
0.5123617649078369,
-0.6028974056243896,
-0.6246787309646606,
-0.29040059447288513,
0.2849268913269043,
-0.9812695384025574,
0.6954113841056824,
0.2869604527950287,
0.40215128660202026,
-0.24755936861038208,
-1.094476342201233,
-0.6635525226593018,
-0.49667784571647644,
0.31190013885498047,
-0.03784917667508125,
-0.16848686337471008,
0.2656606137752533,
0.5167757272720337,
-0.24449960887432098,
-0.6430870294570923,
0.3257932960987091,
-1.015644907951355,
-0.04633830487728119,
0.7668195962905884,
0.20490550994873047,
0.24038083851337433,
-0.05906129628419876,
0.07916995137929916,
0.16317948698997498,
-0.980499804019928,
0.05302514508366585,
0.5506200194358826,
0.23749710619449615,
0.018108168616890907,
0.42581477761268616,
0.21968387067317963,
0.7721443176269531,
0.03613540902733803,
-0.18074584007263184,
0.02844972349703312,
0.2655162215232849,
-0.5818641781806946,
0.4706035554409027,
0.7410102486610413,
0.2958029508590698,
0.11070048063993454,
-0.021283119916915894,
-0.3968043029308319,
-0.3722348213195801,
0.5863953828811646,
-0.7564217448234558,
-0.009472436271607876,
0.21025335788726807,
-0.6375664472579956,
-0.19319315254688263,
0.1825179010629654,
-0.31132400035858154,
-0.7743680477142334,
-0.6573903560638428,
0.07582541555166245,
-0.5980246067047119,
0.10085651278495789,
0.3280508518218994,
-0.00613577663898468,
0.4877323508262634,
0.48859575390815735,
-0.6710143685340881,
0.14759790897369385,
0.8324599862098694,
0.2849915027618408,
0.25512370467185974,
-0.10714252293109894,
-0.7852880358695984,
0.2719246447086334,
-0.6157125234603882,
0.29602789878845215,
-0.4517555832862854,
-0.2456800937652588,
0.26051902770996094,
-0.0778089091181755,
0.4438491463661194,
-0.649739146232605,
0.6513026356697083,
-0.9191730618476868,
-0.29460200667381287,
-0.06307623535394669,
-0.6211515069007874,
-0.4614240825176239,
0.3220069110393524,
-0.7538183927536011,
0.7306399345397949,
0.112760990858078,
-0.6121664047241211,
0.567531168460846,
-0.7080914378166199,
-0.6802180409431458,
0.5253165364265442,
-0.2829081416130066,
-0.456604927778244,
0.19052556157112122,
-0.056147586554288864,
0.33671700954437256,
-0.46114790439605713,
0.9794561266899109,
-0.24054905772209167,
-0.2930045425891876,
0.16280722618103027,
-0.3431034982204437,
0.9640678763389587,
0.4036962687969208,
-0.15599572658538818,
0.3530016839504242,
-0.767528772354126,
-0.3415193259716034,
-0.06704208999872208,
-0.45383185148239136,
-0.23793858289718628,
-0.12304168939590454,
0.04147477447986603,
0.13263623416423798,
0.34278997778892517,
-0.395218163728714,
0.08631139248609543,
-0.4828190803527832,
0.507084310054779,
0.5400839447975159,
-0.1818932145833969,
0.2776082754135132,
-0.24781721830368042,
0.62065589427948,
-0.16046325862407684,
0.12148280441761017,
-0.127025306224823,
-0.2531925439834595,
-0.6825100183486938,
-0.219970241189003,
0.6011207103729248,
0.28274399042129517,
-0.41191887855529785,
0.36336588859558105,
-0.27950727939605713,
-0.43961623311042786,
-0.9287335872650146,
0.39462757110595703,
0.07290037721395493,
0.09119022637605667,
0.24801824986934662,
0.3191489577293396,
-0.5519538521766663,
-1.105998158454895,
-0.042085886001586914,
0.013498063199222088,
0.182480126619339,
0.2259638011455536,
0.4700123965740204,
-0.07702610641717911,
0.6360077857971191,
-0.15052053332328796,
-0.2086905986070633,
-0.8369261622428894,
-0.05451355129480362,
0.37808480858802795,
0.07689511030912399,
0.6701942682266235,
-0.8556052446365356,
-0.6823412179946899,
0.2341700792312622,
-0.7377423048019409,
-0.379285603761673,
-0.2581290900707245,
-0.09225086122751236,
0.15302906930446625,
1.1047037839889526,
-0.3213592767715454,
0.2978556454181671,
0.02187238819897175,
-0.4770500659942627,
0.38081321120262146,
-0.5999684929847717,
-0.18486198782920837,
-1.1510632038116455,
0.016148459166288376,
-0.27599313855171204,
-0.4740867018699646,
-0.505951464176178,
0.3066455125808716,
0.43560734391212463,
0.018623286858201027,
-0.8845648169517517,
0.7823967933654785,
-0.5599560141563416,
0.025462299585342407,
-0.5513374209403992,
0.1966785341501236,
-0.1032133400440216,
0.22887958586215973,
-0.5823410749435425,
0.6431505084037781,
0.6660918593406677,
-0.48312485218048096,
0.4965939223766327,
0.15369601547718048,
-0.21847082674503326,
0.6327998042106628,
-0.6272052526473999,
0.02156909741461277,
-0.5895741581916809,
-0.0002737919276114553,
-0.27811333537101746,
-0.3936726450920105,
-0.06922940909862518,
-0.009747235104441643,
0.47223377227783203,
-0.45882153511047363,
-0.5246538519859314,
-0.4744310975074768,
-0.014469430781900883,
0.13875101506710052,
0.7864851951599121,
-0.30538100004196167,
1.067482829093933,
0.3374117612838745,
-0.23438385128974915,
-0.5892423987388611,
-0.3846319913864136,
0.15599210560321808,
-0.34553930163383484,
-0.5763380527496338,
-0.05228528752923012,
0.09296298027038574,
-0.45988136529922485,
-0.03095730021595955,
0.28230923414230347,
0.005530696362257004,
0.03409974277019501,
0.6171032786369324,
0.0721694752573967,
-0.2888656258583069,
0.1477045863866806,
0.5186101794242859,
0.2544029951095581,
0.28230389952659607,
-0.047830190509557724,
0.7252574563026428,
0.15317495167255402,
-0.3720519542694092,
-0.03565092757344246,
0.3354933559894562,
0.851414144039154,
-0.23214669525623322,
0.6113919019699097,
0.26535704731941223,
-0.1915920227766037,
-0.5441933870315552,
-0.6355546712875366,
0.3368578553199768,
-0.4713059365749359,
0.5068718194961548,
-0.5393722653388977,
-0.953377366065979,
0.6017087697982788,
0.0747375637292862,
0.30678999423980713,
0.5838252305984497,
0.8876843452453613,
0.22461141645908356,
0.6038818359375,
0.6043274998664856,
-0.1480535864830017,
0.39738258719444275,
-0.008728849701583385,
0.22270449995994568,
-0.711441159248352,
-0.34529292583465576,
-0.4783555567264557,
-0.024688083678483963,
-0.2907264232635498,
-0.2362840622663498,
0.2812635898590088,
0.22856472432613373,
-0.564069926738739,
0.23239025473594666,
-0.08576462417840958,
0.7085591554641724,
0.9187179207801819,
-0.014350772835314274,
0.1460164189338684,
-0.32012927532196045,
-0.32736724615097046,
0.3631974756717682,
-0.6649247407913208,
-0.7110806107521057,
1.2889907360076904,
0.39557746052742004,
0.8553408980369568,
0.3000074326992035,
0.6943174600601196,
0.41873183846473694,
0.4933650493621826,
-0.7398445010185242,
0.6725113987922668,
-0.43202242255210876,
-0.7407561540603638,
-0.2232067883014679,
-0.18416202068328857,
-1.2736042737960815,
0.29254230856895447,
-0.11087394505739212,
-0.529710054397583,
-0.23003935813903809,
0.08647116273641586,
-0.5560200214385986,
0.0821516290307045,
-0.5149515271186829,
0.7398312091827393,
-0.4280844032764435,
-0.4392848610877991,
-0.20037029683589935,
-0.7290958166122437,
0.3586690127849579,
-0.3247898817062378,
0.41943037509918213,
-0.23356883227825165,
0.24174106121063232,
0.6713240742683411,
-0.27474653720855713,
0.6345941424369812,
-0.24911627173423767,
-0.1503598988056183,
0.3364219069480896,
0.15938535332679749,
0.37902775406837463,
0.12578174471855164,
-0.1742945909500122,
-0.4270741641521454,
0.05012442171573639,
-0.21266786754131317,
-0.5956816077232361,
0.57918381690979,
-0.4841996729373932,
-0.6856139898300171,
-0.16493424773216248,
-0.843238890171051,
0.1902301162481308,
0.5059410333633423,
0.061029668897390366,
0.5139980912208557,
-0.13337258994579315,
0.6702155470848083,
0.5047340393066406,
-0.44019705057144165,
0.45006027817726135,
1.0048856735229492,
-0.4939344823360443,
-0.4919164478778839,
0.8919820785522461,
0.13104984164237976,
-0.13186286389827728,
0.16879470646381378,
0.1459924280643463,
-0.6942518949508667,
-1.0204517841339111,
-0.35725167393684387,
0.3665340542793274,
-0.8994104266166687,
-0.29224634170532227,
-0.5829553008079529,
-0.3247109055519104,
-0.5092533826828003,
-0.3255269229412079,
-0.074371337890625,
0.23919464647769928,
-0.16142220795154572,
-0.05151887983083725,
0.085993692278862,
1.1562563180923462,
0.2938176393508911,
0.40752893686294556,
-0.8936229348182678,
0.338583379983902,
-0.0869157686829567,
0.2869742810726166,
-0.20570021867752075,
-0.9196429252624512,
-0.11294826865196228,
-0.2317856103181839,
-0.19833996891975403,
-0.6692140102386475,
0.4874933063983917,
-0.08404968678951263,
0.7314334511756897,
0.5475900769233704,
0.14585942029953003,
0.22101688385009766,
-0.7804019451141357,
0.6030995845794678,
0.12636922299861908,
-0.7934069633483887,
0.2740885615348816,
-0.5430759191513062,
0.1172964870929718,
0.47627994418144226,
0.07597535103559494,
-0.2681240439414978,
-0.6603661179542542,
-0.731423020362854,
-0.8425390124320984,
0.511091947555542,
0.11052687466144562,
0.4614775478839874,
0.1509975641965866,
0.6185643672943115,
0.31842175126075745,
0.4224623739719391,
-0.6562235355377197,
0.12543633580207825,
0.01417515892535448,
-0.6953218579292297,
0.08244626969099045,
-0.2879938781261444,
-0.023439403623342514,
-0.3462127149105072,
0.6339700222015381,
-0.05293534696102142,
-0.30445244908332825,
-0.13186895847320557,
-0.4708721935749054,
0.36723169684410095,
0.46171465516090393,
1.1201860904693604,
0.9860572218894958,
0.028730228543281555,
0.16405180096626282,
0.10199727863073349,
-0.5461657643318176,
0.12262372672557831,
0.08699364960193634,
-0.4168061912059784,
-0.19821693003177643,
0.4380822777748108,
1.1075798273086548,
-0.19274801015853882,
-0.937850296497345,
0.34081900119781494,
0.21674655377864838,
-0.7555861473083496,
-0.21734245121479034,
0.22566203773021698,
0.36168619990348816,
0.49862825870513916,
0.46514976024627686,
-0.5865600109100342,
0.21049174666404724,
-0.4404163956642151,
0.24487636983394623,
0.2342124730348587,
-0.2375592440366745,
0.052399326115846634,
0.9386196732521057,
0.12041128426790237,
-0.3993695080280304,
0.366800457239151,
-0.3731726408004761,
-0.5453364849090576,
0.5884019732475281,
0.6501258015632629,
0.48941853642463684,
0.19472041726112366,
0.0008248299127444625,
0.20489858090877533,
0.41582152247428894,
-0.27572008967399597,
0.47678810358047485,
0.40193477272987366,
-0.3723240792751312,
-0.33989304304122925,
-0.8925948739051819,
-0.22811728715896606,
0.395559161901474,
-0.5503661036491394,
0.2859845757484436,
-0.7281618714332581,
-0.11370324343442917,
0.16713149845600128,
-0.3248453438282013,
-0.5558010935783386,
0.17104537785053253,
-0.030126402154564857,
0.9814332127571106,
-0.3480023741722107,
0.9704760909080505,
0.6052129864692688,
-0.5270496010780334,
-0.914950966835022,
-0.3853529393672943,
-0.316911906003952,
-0.7467817664146423,
0.7830061912536621,
-0.04935076832771301,
0.1390448957681656,
0.19117319583892822,
-0.8576791882514954,
-0.16082637012004852,
0.9104728698730469,
0.7930155396461487,
-1.0509213209152222,
-0.03838279843330383,
0.2889116406440735,
0.5546703338623047,
-0.2857508361339569,
-0.36350899934768677,
0.579623818397522,
0.3569992482662201,
0.0905725359916687,
-0.7198637127876282,
-0.06475631892681122,
-0.13926181197166443,
-0.13010559976100922,
0.49110034108161926,
-0.37129631638526917,
0.6416577100753784,
-0.19101491570472717,
0.28889206051826477,
-0.15956434607505798,
0.5094450116157532,
0.2568632960319519,
0.20399875938892365,
0.3682578504085541,
0.5848293900489807,
0.8850589990615845,
0.0029654349200427532,
0.9791450500488281,
-0.49472007155418396,
0.20472566783428192,
1.4507195949554443,
-0.519899845123291,
0.8481266498565674,
0.38835471868515015,
0.024812206625938416,
0.17233356833457947,
0.2729458510875702,
-0.2828240990638733,
0.11574821174144745,
0.6709098219871521,
-0.271447092294693,
-0.3721453547477722,
-0.013418826274573803,
-0.12604722380638123,
0.29431411623954773,
0.23084226250648499,
-0.7467749714851379,
-0.16627895832061768,
0.2867231070995331,
-0.05274198204278946,
0.10645649582147598,
-0.5840264558792114,
0.9138796925544739,
0.2696376144886017,
-0.5529735684394836,
0.21845094859600067,
0.30421796441078186,
0.23729823529720306,
-0.47279226779937744,
0.02988741546869278,
-0.2771846652030945,
0.18223069608211517,
0.14435090124607086,
-1.081842303276062,
0.03465467318892479,
0.11746565997600555,
-0.004616512916982174,
0.08477594703435898,
0.6884406805038452,
-0.403403639793396,
-0.6060894131660461,
0.3771829605102539,
0.20689120888710022,
0.29827770590782166,
-0.18747578561306,
-0.5651163458824158,
0.27166205644607544,
-0.08268410712480545,
0.011331606656312943,
0.18825556337833405,
0.8550453186035156,
-0.17498071491718292,
0.8433037400245667,
0.5723775625228882,
0.10329180955886841,
0.6212198734283447,
0.5881580710411072,
0.8033192753791809,
-0.7673633694648743,
-0.5671064257621765,
-0.8142889142036438,
0.6465697884559631,
-0.15502668917179108,
-0.13695970177650452,
0.2850033938884735,
0.8680700659751892,
0.6350434422492981,
-0.10732439905405045,
0.977656900882721,
-0.14314872026443481,
0.18225151300430298,
-0.7645570039749146,
0.7620696425437927,
-0.4239203929901123,
0.04148762300610542,
0.2856051027774811,
-0.8673981428146362,
-0.3407447338104248,
0.43941250443458557,
-0.22609947621822357,
-0.10996970534324646,
0.478794127702713,
0.6496222615242004,
-0.21717078983783722,
-0.4276405870914459,
0.9795734286308289,
0.33934199810028076,
0.4660346508026123,
0.29024675488471985,
0.5155304074287415,
-0.225078284740448,
0.6468037962913513,
0.36285024881362915,
0.35573679208755493,
-0.36913585662841797,
-0.499953955411911,
-1.3392510414123535,
-0.2724345028400421,
0.13646717369556427,
-0.3955874741077423,
0.18134309351444244,
0.9735995531082153,
0.4023260474205017,
-0.6240773797035217,
-0.2745947241783142,
-0.18150967359542847,
-0.2091616839170456,
0.4431321918964386,
-0.14199839532375336,
0.2382962554693222,
-0.5098333358764648,
-0.5604906678199768,
0.3996075689792633,
0.357207715511322,
0.16469500958919525,
-0.26673653721809387,
-0.42129072546958923,
-0.05281083285808563,
0.25357604026794434,
0.7980772852897644,
-0.030340882018208504,
-1.0419156551361084,
-0.004149424843490124,
-0.17361746728420258,
-0.2928185760974884,
0.09132891148328781,
0.9389296174049377,
-0.028730442747473717,
0.45738670229911804,
0.337593674659729,
0.8134487867355347,
0.548671543598175,
0.10127962380647659,
0.7547181844711304,
-0.28353971242904663,
0.18223832547664642,
0.1468440741300583,
0.6797484755516052,
0.2010730654001236,
-0.09651923924684525,
0.3284437954425812,
-0.19272251427173615,
-0.3630536198616028,
-0.7719906568527222,
-0.01152824517339468,
-1.2709312438964844,
-0.4321956932544708,
1.1172471046447754,
-0.00616825558245182,
-0.33437156677246094,
-0.4217195212841034,
-0.8213086128234863,
0.20717982947826385,
-0.5858997106552124,
0.3933948874473572,
0.7881032824516296,
0.4090974032878876,
-0.4341880977153778,
-0.9725925922393799,
0.26113247871398926,
-0.012232724577188492,
-0.8888254165649414,
0.0358569361269474,
0.5904027223587036,
0.579222559928894,
-0.1666625589132309,
0.7579102516174316,
0.03361557051539421,
0.3809613585472107,
0.0763661339879036,
0.11812435835599899,
-0.4265322685241699,
-0.4207243323326111,
-0.1329534500837326,
0.6494134664535522,
0.4077147841453552,
0.32144469022750854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03874v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03874v1
|
Impoverished Language Technology: The Lack of (Social) Class in NLP
| 2024-03-06T17:35:27 | 2024-03-06T17:35:27 |
Amanda Cercas Curry, Zeerak Talat, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Since Labov's (1964) foundational work on the social stratification of
language, linguistics has dedicated concerted efforts towards understanding the
relationships between socio-demographic factors and language production and
perception. Despite the large body of evidence identifying significant
relationships between socio-demographic factors and language production,
relatively few of these factors have been investigated in the context of NLP
technology. While age and gender are well covered, Labov's initial target,
socio-economic class, is largely absent. We survey the existing Natural
Language Processing (NLP) literature and find that only 20 papers even mention
socio-economic status. However, the majority of those papers do not engage with
class beyond collecting information of annotator-demographics. Given this
research lacuna, we provide a definition of class that can be operationalised
by NLP researchers, and argue for including socio-economic class in future
language technologies.
|
[
-0.2765774726867676,
-0.4958239495754242,
0.16804620623588562,
0.1268298625946045,
0.14748935401439667,
0.7320653200149536,
-0.19120201468467712,
-0.8188322186470032,
0.3458935618400574,
0.3183490037918091,
-0.031742338091135025,
-0.28994229435920715,
-0.6545175313949585,
0.006705523934215307,
-0.5469269156455994,
0.6230617165565491,
0.6422052383422852,
-0.3280376195907593,
-0.268258661031723,
-0.08170710504055023,
-0.11199342459440231,
-0.6666140556335449,
-0.8366782665252686,
-0.3337586522102356,
0.4906176030635834,
0.5259736776351929,
0.8427747488021851,
0.43937981128692627,
0.0993323102593422,
0.3409435749053955,
-0.24862295389175415,
-0.1357615441083908,
-0.08345666527748108,
-0.2751840054988861,
0.23631207644939423,
-0.32444465160369873,
-0.43088939785957336,
-0.0403628945350647,
0.6853135824203491,
1.1714776754379272,
0.15027599036693573,
0.38915809988975525,
0.09272117912769318,
1.2651607990264893,
-0.6449256539344788,
0.19428104162216187,
-0.655306875705719,
0.23108455538749695,
-0.33215630054473877,
-0.2534715235233307,
-0.500347912311554,
-0.36469507217407227,
0.021518589928746223,
-0.3357080817222595,
0.3946073651313782,
0.3174220621585846,
0.8138919472694397,
0.08722299337387085,
-0.2250215709209442,
-0.1104721948504448,
-0.6407981514930725,
0.567223072052002,
-0.3101420998573303,
0.20191659033298492,
0.9610572457313538,
0.22394603490829468,
0.021020865067839622,
-0.2758030891418457,
-0.37710386514663696,
0.09144672006368637,
-0.07302834093570709,
0.17772655189037323,
-0.04897690936923027,
-0.06537751108407974,
0.11986982822418213,
0.3378969728946686,
-0.3634519875049591,
0.17530672252178192,
-1.0827553272247314,
-0.1253187656402588,
0.6669622659683228,
-0.08841431885957718,
0.2528071105480194,
-0.38227134943008423,
-0.1686040312051773,
0.3466293215751648,
-0.9395107626914978,
0.06204208731651306,
0.8169253468513489,
0.36656680703163147,
-0.18573226034641266,
0.6239563226699829,
0.00023401023645419627,
0.7037017345428467,
-0.37697407603263855,
-0.028688902035355568,
0.1962854266166687,
0.12109862267971039,
-0.20541375875473022,
0.4730393886566162,
0.6930886507034302,
0.28417789936065674,
0.2687172293663025,
-0.18832364678382874,
-0.1548391431570053,
0.12444931268692017,
0.16771864891052246,
-0.17068232595920563,
0.027745217084884644,
0.07305983453989029,
-0.25601834058761597,
-0.5420582890510559,
-0.4766927659511566,
-0.9091052412986755,
-0.33459365367889404,
0.10841860622167587,
-0.04037829115986824,
0.044100239872932434,
-0.3223017752170563,
-0.07587189972400665,
-0.2354954481124878,
0.47676271200180054,
0.09970349818468094,
-1.3363715410232544,
0.6525635123252869,
0.5819674730300903,
0.9979082345962524,
0.48181480169296265,
-0.04993002489209175,
-0.05832063779234886,
-0.03526539355516434,
-0.45432135462760925,
1.0453845262527466,
-0.715882420539856,
-0.6569852232933044,
0.4583919048309326,
-0.05719209462404251,
0.0466625802218914,
-0.6037750840187073,
0.03466257452964783,
-0.27747493982315063,
0.3609670400619507,
-0.14324535429477692,
-0.2910411059856415,
0.15973509848117828,
-0.21324683725833893,
-0.2998628318309784,
1.2252246141433716,
0.45873183012008667,
-0.7062454223632812,
0.6798755526542664,
-0.6107499003410339,
-0.6915859580039978,
0.6603668928146362,
-0.015717264264822006,
-0.1439673900604248,
0.14939188957214355,
-0.5490448474884033,
0.23418183624744415,
-0.3657573461532593,
0.648061215877533,
-0.39112916588783264,
-0.34760352969169617,
0.11689689010381699,
-0.1858249008655548,
0.9054849743843079,
0.11446219682693481,
-0.2528882920742035,
-0.2507777214050293,
-0.9441331028938293,
-0.4204854965209961,
0.06248641386628151,
-0.3085443079471588,
-0.38298243284225464,
0.2593434453010559,
0.312637597322464,
0.11790943145751953,
0.09308156371116638,
-0.5208353996276855,
0.028235338628292084,
-0.47866517305374146,
0.48774611949920654,
0.7134499549865723,
-0.6198567152023315,
0.750461757183075,
-0.4376099705696106,
0.35692816972732544,
-0.829578697681427,
0.28861284255981445,
0.48803213238716125,
-0.5763503909111023,
-1.1264057159423828,
0.1916210800409317,
0.2737003266811371,
0.46973416209220886,
-0.8278915882110596,
0.28821977972984314,
0.06163027137517929,
-0.45029041171073914,
-0.7056546211242676,
-0.07893156260251999,
0.15621235966682434,
0.24511948227882385,
0.1781291365623474,
-0.16593924164772034,
-0.8196116089820862,
-1.127010464668274,
-0.18668261170387268,
-0.46086281538009644,
0.09831158816814423,
0.1295599639415741,
0.12460660189390182,
0.060347456485033035,
0.5484945178031921,
-0.31430327892303467,
-0.5940536260604858,
-0.49913522601127625,
0.03686607629060745,
-0.13559037446975708,
0.527232825756073,
0.447604775428772,
-0.5786272287368774,
-0.30128660798072815,
-0.18407204747200012,
-0.45756810903549194,
-0.31786999106407166,
0.36660370230674744,
0.04631955176591873,
0.6936140060424805,
0.5027436017990112,
-0.005799679551273584,
0.5084479451179504,
0.4882354438304901,
-0.29278185963630676,
0.22430314123630524,
-0.29361245036125183,
-0.2040073275566101,
-0.6704094409942627,
0.027978232130408287,
0.3664976954460144,
-0.16815881431102753,
-0.8267713785171509,
-0.23729687929153442,
-0.2922355532646179,
-0.32079121470451355,
-0.49913108348846436,
0.46792125701904297,
-0.3309271037578583,
-0.4402737617492676,
-0.39378777146339417,
0.5274398326873779,
-0.27622872591018677,
0.22884966433048248,
0.19720183312892914,
0.4839635491371155,
0.27706241607666016,
-0.4443890452384949,
-0.10047751665115356,
-0.1564263552427292,
-0.1311444491147995,
0.261177122592926,
-0.8294019103050232,
-0.009206723421812057,
-0.061452172696590424,
-0.28483492136001587,
-0.7058956027030945,
-0.2995617091655731,
0.060170963406562805,
-0.5214214324951172,
0.41509339213371277,
-0.21325679123401642,
-0.6933923363685608,
-0.19213759899139404,
-0.26094481348991394,
0.0940617173910141,
0.6759055256843567,
0.14495505392551422,
0.13762018084526062,
1.0233293771743774,
-0.31263267993927,
-0.5586796998977661,
-0.5291157364845276,
0.18076245486736298,
-0.22678928077220917,
-0.4834735691547394,
-0.026337048038840294,
0.1655447781085968,
-0.5957387089729309,
0.01936875656247139,
-0.0008862644899636507,
-0.28839483857154846,
0.4988115131855011,
0.16909447312355042,
0.42942920327186584,
-0.13416820764541626,
0.36743128299713135,
0.11786621809005737,
-0.14763307571411133,
0.23951996862888336,
0.11792492866516113,
0.6417577862739563,
-0.2661120891571045,
0.38719260692596436,
0.20625436305999756,
0.2471192330121994,
0.407665491104126,
0.1732752025127411,
0.7982101440429688,
0.31032899022102356,
-0.4686949849128723,
-0.09870924800634384,
-0.6334871053695679,
0.418649822473526,
-0.43926116824150085,
0.11913785338401794,
0.15859635174274445,
-1.0076004266738892,
0.24988727271556854,
0.09740635007619858,
-0.15079659223556519,
0.7373911738395691,
0.1422039121389389,
0.13229890167713165,
0.41714954376220703,
0.8367915153503418,
0.008945669047534466,
0.35409969091415405,
-0.21773168444633484,
0.26048555970191956,
-0.9670865535736084,
-0.3062099814414978,
-0.9284123778343201,
-0.16628660261631012,
-0.8199344873428345,
0.024251310154795647,
0.028088940307497978,
-0.304938942193985,
-0.2784900665283203,
0.3534785509109497,
-0.5219005346298218,
0.3286627531051636,
0.6284868121147156,
-0.17159242928028107,
0.27245157957077026,
-0.11673759669065475,
0.33478373289108276,
0.0425897091627121,
-0.9028738737106323,
-0.9139611721038818,
0.8635430932044983,
0.11391215026378632,
0.17307300865650177,
0.032729100435972214,
0.7331483364105225,
0.7329096794128418,
0.7056437134742737,
-0.6752632260322571,
0.6161128878593445,
-0.42652595043182373,
-0.7202133536338806,
-0.30663225054740906,
-0.27269071340560913,
-1.0914474725723267,
0.14879284799098969,
-0.4558963477611542,
-0.7317341566085815,
0.5706923007965088,
-0.01686716638505459,
-0.21088093519210815,
0.24732705950737,
-0.6932531595230103,
0.9539434313774109,
0.14002184569835663,
-0.7850812673568726,
0.0707867443561554,
-0.9648574590682983,
0.6157271265983582,
-0.13336347043514252,
1.0741528272628784,
-0.6316197514533997,
0.3520975112915039,
0.7323495745658875,
-0.538457453250885,
1.104637861251831,
-0.2575220763683319,
0.03615006431937218,
0.13938680291175842,
-0.16435743868350983,
-0.35125434398651123,
-0.22988419234752655,
-0.023188667371869087,
-0.11285633593797684,
0.11232133954763412,
-0.7074053287506104,
-0.024957116693258286,
0.5637261271476746,
-0.8691856265068054,
-0.7013382315635681,
-0.8461483120918274,
-0.3350251317024231,
-0.03376346826553345,
-0.01117599755525589,
0.171868234872818,
0.5828767418861389,
-0.11059749126434326,
0.1954144537448883,
0.2260090857744217,
-0.4999435245990753,
0.555472195148468,
0.18230372667312622,
-0.4212546646595001,
-0.15320786833763123,
0.8921543955802917,
0.5029776692390442,
0.5284252166748047,
0.24472776055335999,
0.40868809819221497,
-0.04174606874585152,
-0.14688211679458618,
-0.5244104266166687,
0.2217305451631546,
-0.5471791625022888,
-0.10063868761062622,
-0.7071801424026489,
-0.24163436889648438,
-0.6140900254249573,
-0.6223105788230896,
-0.31103840470314026,
-0.4686541259288788,
-0.27545076608657837,
0.060780011117458344,
0.22395941615104675,
0.7951834797859192,
-0.19078491628170013,
0.34310242533683777,
-0.5961137413978577,
0.24251689016819,
0.18204009532928467,
0.08842219412326813,
0.10184134542942047,
-0.361099511384964,
-0.21311965584754944,
-0.22158095240592957,
0.01120673306286335,
-0.5357224345207214,
0.6572738885879517,
0.39766231179237366,
0.2992352545261383,
-0.04750286415219307,
0.3539807200431824,
0.4083385169506073,
-0.310518354177475,
0.8035085797309875,
0.23710311949253082,
-1.1808403730392456,
0.7131989598274231,
-0.015524515882134438,
0.13902385532855988,
0.45432740449905396,
0.32079198956489563,
-0.6029900312423706,
-0.8126280307769775,
-0.8223921060562134,
-1.398744821548462,
0.7225773930549622,
-0.027500227093696594,
0.16996751725673676,
-0.27133312821388245,
0.05252436548471451,
0.2570698857307434,
0.30087655782699585,
-0.9765974879264832,
-0.3682483434677124,
-0.15912136435508728,
0.05125773698091507,
-0.05263003334403038,
-0.3393469452857971,
0.31530386209487915,
-0.1317649632692337,
0.6030157208442688,
0.14509771764278412,
0.014293164946138859,
0.26063475012779236,
-0.15814003348350525,
-0.14050880074501038,
0.5264469981193542,
0.48471716046333313,
0.6411899328231812,
-0.4678002595901489,
0.5651208758354187,
-0.22895696759223938,
-0.4913879632949829,
0.32618796825408936,
0.0507020577788353,
-0.3944198787212372,
-0.05422331765294075,
0.21894468367099762,
0.44957807660102844,
0.4066038131713867,
-0.42821940779685974,
0.26616519689559937,
0.10945300757884979,
-0.4396880865097046,
-0.7693452835083008,
0.16870374977588654,
-0.15690788626670837,
0.11126561462879181,
0.6068004369735718,
0.36983978748321533,
0.27738308906555176,
-1.0251274108886719,
-0.3447501063346863,
0.14346490800380707,
-0.6886148452758789,
-0.25940680503845215,
0.7812191843986511,
0.3727487027645111,
-0.6217606067657471,
0.13884474337100983,
-0.39313173294067383,
-0.38893789052963257,
0.496859073638916,
0.45943179726600647,
0.8497645258903503,
0.0421205498278141,
0.5956076383590698,
0.19432128965854645,
0.7561231851577759,
-0.08815921097993851,
0.08205443620681763,
-0.02559526078402996,
-0.6396021842956543,
-0.3696168065071106,
-0.8724218010902405,
-0.2841302752494812,
-0.266342431306839,
-0.5186865329742432,
0.14231450855731964,
-0.417555570602417,
-0.30567726492881775,
0.02904687263071537,
0.12642554938793182,
-0.6629706621170044,
-0.054480962455272675,
-0.16101551055908203,
0.491212397813797,
-1.000937819480896,
0.8100463151931763,
0.6433846354484558,
-0.42928987741470337,
-0.23398558795452118,
-0.37443026900291443,
0.01971573568880558,
-0.8537272214889526,
1.1406751871109009,
0.03915708512067795,
-0.34347349405288696,
0.09911135584115982,
-0.36230045557022095,
-0.4913601279258728,
0.6130408048629761,
0.12793706357479095,
-0.2760297358036041,
-0.016483338549733162,
0.20173895359039307,
0.6582989692687988,
-0.20931532979011536,
-0.4254346489906311,
0.3632947504520416,
0.46514561772346497,
0.006152502726763487,
-0.5979834794998169,
-0.19032973051071167,
-0.49524158239364624,
0.006486888043582439,
0.3346930742263794,
-0.7167779207229614,
0.29233288764953613,
-0.11213696002960205,
-0.3960651457309723,
-0.17494426667690277,
0.2810823917388916,
-0.11951857060194016,
0.7738513350486755,
0.2920244634151459,
0.22849471867084503,
0.43124616146087646,
-0.23470482230186462,
1.1304959058761597,
-0.23765380680561066,
0.21445348858833313,
0.5319105386734009,
-0.4152270257472992,
0.7544355988502502,
0.18705162405967712,
-0.6056872010231018,
0.18100595474243164,
0.6654767394065857,
0.2642102539539337,
0.43025830388069153,
0.47401678562164307,
-0.45992541313171387,
-0.06328614801168442,
-0.25436925888061523,
-0.2998615503311157,
0.4911472797393799,
0.4356200397014618,
-0.3533305823802948,
0.3826075494289398,
-0.20073314011096954,
0.19656291604042053,
0.33127281069755554,
-0.3924414813518524,
0.7700228691101074,
0.24457873404026031,
-0.3130899667739868,
0.4298169016838074,
-0.23636311292648315,
0.5677930116653442,
-0.45833656191825867,
0.15908204019069672,
-0.36589303612709045,
-0.2567209005355835,
-0.3673667907714844,
-0.5479400753974915,
0.8131459355354309,
0.18836963176727295,
-0.043856147676706314,
-0.0390932597219944,
1.0136078596115112,
-0.24642693996429443,
-0.692069411277771,
0.3053663372993469,
0.7690189480781555,
0.37115219235420227,
0.37561070919036865,
0.02434995025396347,
-0.01743435114622116,
-0.2974197268486023,
0.27449721097946167,
0.6062431931495667,
0.6182777881622314,
0.4581471085548401,
0.5143609642982483,
0.4934070408344269,
0.3186030089855194,
0.040343016386032104,
0.05135941877961159,
0.5802985429763794,
-0.7054218053817749,
0.2002783566713333,
-0.8522629141807556,
0.2206481546163559,
-0.25219208002090454,
-0.38277313113212585,
0.77020263671875,
0.6599270701408386,
0.8436750769615173,
0.08042331039905548,
0.8857102990150452,
-0.1947384774684906,
-0.025624651461839676,
-0.2803821861743927,
0.7733062505722046,
-0.6672534942626953,
0.2762862741947174,
-0.6954991221427917,
-0.9298911094665527,
-0.6270288228988647,
0.6791179776191711,
-0.2754044830799103,
-0.07853104174137115,
0.5501526594161987,
0.224899560213089,
0.5460643768310547,
0.12499438226222992,
0.5920599699020386,
-0.24212394654750824,
-0.0736767053604126,
0.04210371524095535,
0.8190651535987854,
-0.21884022653102875,
0.1858196258544922,
-0.4549326002597809,
-0.3209710717201233,
-0.2943861484527588,
-0.7276409268379211,
-0.7018842697143555,
-0.48568445444107056,
-0.3336403965950012,
-0.36233511567115784,
0.33513888716697693,
0.9749425053596497,
0.33497709035873413,
-0.18451295793056488,
-0.670985758304596,
0.1399133950471878,
0.5014920234680176,
-0.04702742397785187,
-0.27397871017456055,
0.36956357955932617,
-0.6136587858200073,
-0.6226695775985718,
0.035223882645368576,
0.7424988150596619,
-0.1486845314502716,
-0.34178394079208374,
0.3986123502254486,
-0.4036128520965576,
-0.1315755397081375,
1.11786949634552,
0.39249280095100403,
-0.4134978950023651,
-0.3556891083717346,
0.15182453393936157,
0.2571144998073578,
0.1545368880033493,
0.5929306745529175,
-0.5806232690811157,
0.334597110748291,
-0.04266474395990372,
0.3355412483215332,
0.26112863421440125,
-0.6091300249099731,
0.4247465133666992,
-0.7437635660171509,
0.15558326244354248,
0.22750291228294373,
0.5242661833763123,
0.5837880373001099,
-0.16570793092250824,
0.8064244389533997,
0.6881006956100464,
-0.799462080001831,
-0.8090231418609619,
0.18575824797153473,
-0.7177263498306274,
-0.2843264639377594,
1.0065916776657104,
0.3572353422641754,
-0.5562158226966858,
-0.6819753646850586,
-0.15225018560886383,
0.360630601644516,
-0.6509869694709778,
1.0086520910263062,
0.5495868921279907,
0.27342328429222107,
-0.40820181369781494,
-0.9393020868301392,
0.3082357943058014,
-0.07460000365972519,
-0.8479788303375244,
0.18342182040214539,
0.6826940178871155,
-0.3663872182369232,
0.3245321214199066,
0.927265465259552,
-0.19345495104789734,
-0.05730824172496796,
0.3951839506626129,
0.32644981145858765,
0.39497122168540955,
0.005486101843416691,
0.28661996126174927,
0.3995240330696106,
0.38904285430908203,
0.33451607823371887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03870v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03870v1
|
Learning to Decode Collaboratively with Multiple Language Models
| 2024-03-06T17:23:28 | 2024-03-06T17:23:28 |
Shannon Zejiang Shen, Hunter Lang, Bailin Wang, Yoon Kim, David Sontag
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We propose a method to teach multiple large language models (LLM) to
collaborate by interleaving their generations at the token level. We model the
decision of which LLM generates the next token as a latent variable. By
optimizing the marginal likelihood of a training set under our latent variable
model, the base LLM automatically learns when to generate itself and when to
call on one of the ``assistant'' language models to generate, all without
direct supervision. Token-level collaboration during decoding allows for a
fusion of each model's expertise in a manner tailored to the specific task at
hand. Our collaborative decoding is especially useful in cross-domain settings
where a generalist base LLM learns to invoke domain expert models. On
instruction-following, domain-specific QA, and reasoning tasks, we show that
the performance of the joint system exceeds that of the individual models.
Through qualitative analysis of the learned latent decisions, we show models
trained with our method exhibit several interesting collaboration patterns,
e.g., template-filling. Our code is available at
https://github.com/clinicalml/co-llm.
|
[
-0.11238826811313629,
-0.4341234564781189,
0.6392190456390381,
0.2173900455236435,
-0.16117733716964722,
0.4102707803249359,
-0.1354028880596161,
-0.32542333006858826,
0.15630187094211578,
0.7249759435653687,
-0.4904576241970062,
-0.7726280689239502,
-0.4911017417907715,
0.06721124053001404,
-0.05057560279965401,
0.7847377061843872,
0.02314038947224617,
0.6661073565483093,
-0.5955976843833923,
-0.11341976374387741,
-0.5700491070747375,
-0.984379231929779,
-0.7598352432250977,
-0.5003311038017273,
0.4455263614654541,
0.4199298024177551,
0.4552465081214905,
0.3708234429359436,
0.43818482756614685,
0.29863932728767395,
0.09777573496103287,
0.411262571811676,
-0.541810929775238,
0.2292543649673462,
-0.24988658726215363,
-0.5859846472740173,
-0.8443217873573303,
-0.05107348784804344,
0.26179686188697815,
1.2835267782211304,
-0.07202073931694031,
-0.11401517689228058,
0.12225982546806335,
0.278504341840744,
-0.47672373056411743,
0.483059823513031,
-0.57304447889328,
-0.07545758783817291,
0.2204846441745758,
-0.18666425347328186,
-0.8980158567428589,
-0.1714409589767456,
0.1323244273662567,
-0.6561686992645264,
0.45822596549987793,
0.1177019476890564,
0.16740088164806366,
0.03510705754160881,
-0.33604347705841064,
-0.35715287923812866,
-0.5296352505683899,
0.819007933139801,
-0.435722678899765,
0.4569750428199768,
0.7196832895278931,
-0.06419795006513596,
-0.25359153747558594,
-0.8007690906524658,
-0.4568415880203247,
-0.11759962886571884,
-0.040792979300022125,
0.11885633319616318,
-0.020173680037260056,
0.3178650438785553,
-0.22289738059043884,
0.3781624734401703,
-0.5043748617172241,
0.1376451998949051,
-0.25844699144363403,
-0.24520263075828552,
0.505247175693512,
0.32977113127708435,
0.4619656205177307,
0.1292036771774292,
-0.2029857039451599,
-0.12328418344259262,
-0.6252292990684509,
-0.19557499885559082,
0.23899544775485992,
0.43795377016067505,
-0.31251540780067444,
0.3703359365463257,
0.20099639892578125,
0.4252071976661682,
0.13987815380096436,
-0.06570648401975632,
0.28016266226768494,
-0.6741837859153748,
-0.10749088227748871,
-0.13955555856227875,
0.7240136861801147,
0.07744098454713821,
-0.17455969750881195,
-0.6294263005256653,
-0.13072732090950012,
0.0027869835030287504,
0.10431908071041107,
-0.29454120993614197,
-0.5785095691680908,
0.07975469529628754,
-0.6000300049781799,
-0.2504957914352417,
-0.11097808927297592,
-0.290103554725647,
-0.14173313975334167,
-0.5054996609687805,
0.5634446740150452,
-0.371553510427475,
-0.4328532814979553,
0.33835822343826294,
-0.04166543856263161,
-0.09859992563724518,
0.30132657289505005,
-1.2500563859939575,
0.7606891989707947,
0.841635525226593,
0.6674367785453796,
-0.141727477312088,
-0.6904944181442261,
-1.0271211862564087,
0.2689790427684784,
-0.3811509609222412,
0.5612586736679077,
-0.49916645884513855,
-0.6424315571784973,
-0.06612895429134369,
0.0014244982739910483,
-0.23832477629184723,
-0.6110774874687195,
-0.1168336570262909,
-0.5958942174911499,
0.3434254229068756,
-0.21997828781604767,
-0.7230367064476013,
-0.0015103269834071398,
0.10853300988674164,
-0.8101077675819397,
0.47463950514793396,
0.3158529996871948,
-0.6097058057785034,
0.2595159411430359,
-0.4757825434207916,
-0.24034638702869415,
0.2660718858242035,
-0.4726249575614929,
-0.38084933161735535,
0.06706470251083374,
0.3312171697616577,
0.7129936814308167,
-0.23888354003429413,
0.3958566188812256,
-0.3076525926589966,
-0.15182971954345703,
-0.01582079380750656,
-0.23433397710323334,
0.9586026072502136,
-0.023631708696484566,
0.06137415021657944,
0.2761668562889099,
-0.5689074993133545,
-0.21219898760318756,
0.07776834815740585,
-0.451302707195282,
-0.35193541646003723,
-0.26132500171661377,
-0.12716226279735565,
-0.0834023728966713,
0.29745203256607056,
-0.15434104204177856,
0.31210950016975403,
-0.28032320737838745,
0.22112222015857697,
0.5452288389205933,
0.26306435465812683,
0.6569707989692688,
-0.4313581883907318,
0.5631405711174011,
0.05147462710738182,
0.1946636438369751,
-0.22672384977340698,
-0.3904217481613159,
-0.8496798276901245,
-0.3014761507511139,
0.1741877794265747,
0.22025546431541443,
-1.095441460609436,
0.5094259977340698,
-0.08476041257381439,
-0.06256507337093353,
-0.6061031818389893,
0.3242631256580353,
0.6129387617111206,
0.16786596179008484,
0.4763917326927185,
-0.5566731691360474,
-0.4792458713054657,
-0.6118355989456177,
0.1503380686044693,
-0.23138219118118286,
0.20561182498931885,
0.1477561742067337,
0.4243532419204712,
-0.1460217833518982,
0.7179978489875793,
-0.237042635679245,
-0.31311994791030884,
-0.4179462790489197,
0.2841649055480957,
0.09415718168020248,
0.6508314609527588,
0.4584633409976959,
-0.7115725874900818,
-0.6163325309753418,
0.021040262654423714,
-0.8784564733505249,
0.11020815372467041,
-0.02935848757624626,
-0.15513981878757477,
0.08297259360551834,
0.7210900783538818,
-0.09241317212581635,
0.031167246401309967,
0.967026948928833,
-0.4289683401584625,
0.430672824382782,
-0.5366417765617371,
0.061005931347608566,
-1.5156922340393066,
-0.09226977080106735,
-0.46774381399154663,
-0.31575796008110046,
-0.591402530670166,
0.16784876585006714,
-0.2802327871322632,
0.0378049798309803,
-0.2836432456970215,
0.28252553939819336,
-0.8128237724304199,
-0.2165115773677826,
-0.08360828459262848,
-0.17702563107013702,
0.08480445295572281,
0.5786170959472656,
0.29137298464775085,
0.8209874629974365,
0.5743622183799744,
-0.28622084856033325,
0.3954838216304779,
0.44781258702278137,
-0.1106274202466011,
0.42315980792045593,
-0.39818015694618225,
0.5927473902702332,
0.2205280065536499,
0.22961798310279846,
-0.5977090001106262,
-0.28702908754348755,
0.15883810818195343,
-0.36325564980506897,
0.19971081614494324,
-0.35313788056373596,
-0.7386396527290344,
-0.017833545804023743,
0.036224037408828735,
0.5473728179931641,
0.20733389258384705,
-0.804250955581665,
0.7536208629608154,
0.5493593215942383,
-0.15174895524978638,
-0.5557394623756409,
-0.659172773361206,
0.15429672598838806,
0.1469254046678543,
-0.7118920683860779,
0.4571863114833832,
-0.24733150005340576,
-0.21848401427268982,
0.2515842318534851,
0.2881782650947571,
-0.37109920382499695,
0.11689657717943192,
0.40881437063217163,
0.34931838512420654,
-0.15360495448112488,
0.06329511851072311,
-0.02807542122900486,
-0.3126096725463867,
0.029817109927535057,
-0.3992139399051666,
0.8239925503730774,
-0.2191314697265625,
-0.5960997939109802,
-0.22168034315109253,
0.7164624929428101,
0.41890251636505127,
-0.4004378914833069,
1.0677857398986816,
0.6175588369369507,
-0.4073384702205658,
-0.3318200409412384,
-0.34952470660209656,
-0.15736594796180725,
-0.4663374423980713,
0.2673177719116211,
-0.525286078453064,
-1.046207070350647,
0.7288857698440552,
0.011232862249016762,
-0.32874080538749695,
0.08453823626041412,
0.7899426221847534,
0.3517909646034241,
0.9046253561973572,
1.1275981664657593,
-0.02667998895049095,
0.3446232080459595,
-0.6341506838798523,
0.049021925777196884,
-0.6752387285232544,
-0.5739272832870483,
-0.272958904504776,
0.4627881646156311,
-0.13176223635673523,
-0.8241446018218994,
0.5828921794891357,
0.2283620983362198,
0.04163846746087074,
0.1684839427471161,
-0.3495911955833435,
0.7162371277809143,
0.7291308641433716,
0.27040281891822815,
0.5395160913467407,
0.042492661625146866,
-0.4901631474494934,
0.14920540153980255,
-0.9402263164520264,
-0.3316233158111572,
1.1365506649017334,
0.2714936137199402,
0.7304787635803223,
0.22672569751739502,
1.2929811477661133,
0.1226067766547203,
0.10458040982484818,
-0.7104941010475159,
0.4144956171512604,
-0.3432522416114807,
-0.21281053125858307,
-0.03273787349462509,
-0.41295796632766724,
-1.0279752016067505,
0.18952924013137817,
-0.3501089811325073,
-0.5187402367591858,
0.10441238433122635,
0.045516237616539,
-0.4670740067958832,
0.26250159740448,
-0.7109231352806091,
0.8802767395973206,
0.00935183186084032,
-0.4495808184146881,
-0.6696524024009705,
-0.723132848739624,
0.27495887875556946,
-0.2666720449924469,
0.1715932935476303,
0.19581274688243866,
0.07930806279182434,
0.6467131972312927,
-0.42695072293281555,
1.1294779777526855,
0.03697565943002701,
-0.10633435845375061,
0.1053188294172287,
0.2963252365589142,
0.3047008216381073,
0.06731434166431427,
-0.11816739290952682,
0.001013882108964026,
-0.0436805859208107,
-0.48006653785705566,
-0.32912972569465637,
0.6520165801048279,
-1.0757743120193481,
-0.36175885796546936,
-0.16097033023834229,
-0.6524247527122498,
-0.42354127764701843,
0.1846655160188675,
0.15032966434955597,
0.6810952425003052,
-0.3538669943809509,
0.08740458637475967,
0.5447706580162048,
-0.18753862380981445,
0.3398580551147461,
0.4690641462802887,
-0.02826114371418953,
-0.608921468257904,
0.9722251892089844,
-0.2160378396511078,
0.5202017426490784,
0.5114741325378418,
-0.027330607175827026,
-0.09289997816085815,
-0.8665993809700012,
-0.0014046821743249893,
0.28526508808135986,
-1.0402026176452637,
-0.08694522082805634,
-0.7326032519340515,
-0.1332409679889679,
-0.5304084420204163,
-0.36076819896698,
-0.27054160833358765,
0.05074235424399376,
-0.5980452299118042,
0.11487437039613724,
0.04539323225617409,
1.1168798208236694,
-0.3188738524913788,
0.2612529695034027,
-1.2193769216537476,
0.2026570588350296,
0.46643179655075073,
0.27465733885765076,
0.14457128942012787,
-0.12518848478794098,
-0.5542962551116943,
-0.20214897394180298,
0.05123249068856239,
-0.7295096516609192,
0.5012471675872803,
-0.10099442303180695,
0.9034423828125,
-0.1407381147146225,
0.03412987291812897,
0.44541677832603455,
-0.43193498253822327,
0.7826015949249268,
0.48108556866645813,
-1.248989224433899,
0.1775140017271042,
-0.37584370374679565,
0.09182446449995041,
0.4934566020965576,
0.37602511048316956,
-0.4805625081062317,
-0.48398107290267944,
-0.6962875723838806,
-0.7468636631965637,
0.9246256351470947,
-0.04103116691112518,
0.09836693108081818,
-0.09982911497354507,
0.1390896886587143,
0.5812322497367859,
-0.023849869146943092,
-0.6199709177017212,
-0.1512007862329483,
0.12071874737739563,
-0.4343922734260559,
0.04517894610762596,
-0.21941477060317993,
-0.3087114691734314,
-0.10272973030805588,
0.38141217827796936,
-0.36564159393310547,
0.24003323912620544,
0.018827863037586212,
-0.24355001747608185,
-0.21902893483638763,
-0.05206478759646416,
0.24114879965782166,
0.601456880569458,
-0.04087042436003685,
0.36114969849586487,
0.20379002392292023,
-0.24674449861049652,
0.028604231774806976,
-0.11071164906024933,
0.5444904565811157,
-0.22357676923274994,
0.941031277179718,
0.7925505638122559,
0.09426455199718475,
-0.3009125888347626,
0.8026137948036194,
-0.3907059133052826,
-0.4882586896419525,
-0.2855968773365021,
0.015395024791359901,
0.2843915522098541,
0.6265717148780823,
0.17608049511909485,
0.2387540489435196,
-0.03283735737204552,
-0.5562828183174133,
0.5128042101860046,
0.2032065987586975,
0.00657779723405838,
-0.5862324833869934,
0.5024008750915527,
0.4227198362350464,
-0.32155677676200867,
0.5668759942054749,
-0.3644102215766907,
-0.559837818145752,
0.6428777575492859,
0.6184973120689392,
0.8962489366531372,
-0.048304710537195206,
0.318423330783844,
0.06442651152610779,
-0.1473834216594696,
-0.33576536178588867,
0.19558663666248322,
-0.1442434936761856,
-0.8850059509277344,
-0.7294992804527283,
-0.3916287422180176,
-0.7689439058303833,
0.20830503106117249,
-0.7314618825912476,
0.2330218255519867,
-0.40474680066108704,
0.10044696182012558,
0.08028312027454376,
0.10485481470823288,
-0.862891435623169,
-0.08704337477684021,
0.285860151052475,
0.34743958711624146,
-0.876380980014801,
1.0999722480773926,
0.573253870010376,
-0.6945165395736694,
-1.0582072734832764,
0.15186291933059692,
-0.005699419882148504,
-0.9024287462234497,
0.8237283825874329,
-0.07259907573461533,
-0.22693845629692078,
0.10071305930614471,
-0.5317419767379761,
-0.6538330912590027,
0.9779794216156006,
0.4689636528491974,
-0.46134552359580994,
-0.2514156103134155,
-0.055915314704179764,
0.6134308576583862,
-0.8010735511779785,
-0.008438007906079292,
0.14567974209785461,
-0.23972153663635254,
0.02709139510989189,
-1.2837716341018677,
0.006772291846573353,
0.0064549692906439304,
-0.3011145293712616,
-0.20065060257911682,
-0.5665581226348877,
1.1663709878921509,
-0.44308164715766907,
-0.0314411036670208,
0.16693955659866333,
0.45484253764152527,
0.21505849063396454,
0.2612111568450928,
0.4946976900100708,
0.24598263204097748,
0.7863504886627197,
0.4015163779258728,
0.7915464043617249,
-0.4325527548789978,
0.5148237943649292,
1.235956072807312,
-0.06278280168771744,
0.8485126495361328,
0.29780393838882446,
-0.05266839638352394,
0.4581749737262726,
0.4168036878108978,
0.049341391772031784,
0.6098312139511108,
-0.1451094001531601,
-0.5155355930328369,
-0.5901426076889038,
-0.2438403069972992,
-0.24807925522327423,
0.3998628258705139,
0.5490356683731079,
-0.5120444297790527,
-0.15027397871017456,
0.16485744714736938,
-0.216714009642601,
0.28181886672973633,
-0.14089547097682953,
1.0301241874694824,
0.2479417473077774,
-0.6148720383644104,
0.5754074454307556,
-0.15177184343338013,
0.4431766867637634,
-0.320679634809494,
-0.1991657018661499,
-0.14255286753177643,
0.3211152255535126,
-0.23919086158275604,
-0.542834460735321,
0.18531577289104462,
-0.3432307541370392,
-0.28102242946624756,
-0.2906858026981354,
0.4135890007019043,
-0.8942961096763611,
-0.171714186668396,
0.6944435238838196,
1.0329128503799438,
0.10354872047901154,
0.33379870653152466,
-0.572327733039856,
0.19585295021533966,
-0.047951314598321915,
0.3148095905780792,
0.2505719065666199,
0.3666629493236542,
-0.032909903675317764,
0.5000230669975281,
0.6824489235877991,
0.07514430582523346,
-0.001102266600355506,
0.5405207276344299,
1.0730547904968262,
-0.37683191895484924,
-0.4721772372722626,
-0.641403317451477,
0.22490888833999634,
0.15241684019565582,
0.0473293699324131,
0.4896302819252014,
0.44854214787483215,
1.120843529701233,
-0.09942623972892761,
0.9037949442863464,
0.30715906620025635,
0.3048960864543915,
-0.6981322169303894,
0.5300219058990479,
-0.42665913701057434,
0.3725723624229431,
0.083094023168087,
-0.6167612671852112,
-0.5195264220237732,
0.5524638295173645,
-0.24596579372882843,
-0.08702891319990158,
0.8616657257080078,
0.7158600687980652,
-0.08850745111703873,
-0.03483166918158531,
0.5386720895767212,
-0.1617150753736496,
0.5587412118911743,
0.7975683808326721,
0.8719772696495056,
-0.19887015223503113,
0.45297226309776306,
-0.3667033612728119,
-0.14812737703323364,
-0.15157082676887512,
-0.5479736924171448,
-1.2974638938903809,
-0.7434364557266235,
-0.31961917877197266,
-0.48161348700523376,
0.15272900462150574,
1.4048192501068115,
0.9408414959907532,
-0.7066794037818909,
-0.27098748087882996,
-0.2675212323665619,
0.08294510096311569,
-0.10110436379909515,
-0.11204329133033752,
0.4646809697151184,
-0.5605413317680359,
-0.9327815771102905,
0.5738703012466431,
0.21758350729942322,
0.11490949243307114,
-0.5297131538391113,
-0.3408660888671875,
-0.07279565185308456,
-0.254497766494751,
0.43740981817245483,
-0.21273395419120789,
-0.5996074676513672,
-0.09452769160270691,
0.03690392151474953,
-0.32213178277015686,
0.009430883452296257,
1.035773754119873,
-0.6774454116821289,
0.6228843331336975,
0.6047298312187195,
0.6996620893478394,
0.5167760252952576,
-0.3048204183578491,
0.9407867789268494,
-0.9751876592636108,
0.21493950486183167,
0.33482274413108826,
0.3576918840408325,
0.5732089281082153,
-0.3617396056652069,
0.4463097155094147,
0.41842544078826904,
-0.5733219385147095,
-0.7467227578163147,
0.14052961766719818,
-0.8887410163879395,
-0.4485892355442047,
1.010077953338623,
-0.5418795347213745,
-0.14855393767356873,
-0.48897919058799744,
-0.06746562570333481,
0.45862799882888794,
-0.2973010241985321,
0.517756462097168,
0.6251631379127502,
-0.16337014734745026,
-0.21353109180927277,
-0.06322498619556427,
0.4500504732131958,
0.4154869616031647,
-0.6607927083969116,
-0.02697676606476307,
0.39971688389778137,
0.35747992992401123,
0.18867766857147217,
0.9540807604789734,
0.0720410943031311,
0.21285755932331085,
0.523715615272522,
0.09208588302135468,
-0.19236572086811066,
-0.4355943500995636,
-0.5109192132949829,
0.18757855892181396,
0.4491637051105499,
-0.2381250411272049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03867v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03867v1
|
On the Origins of Linear Representations in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-06T17:17:36 | 2024-03-06T17:17:36 |
Yibo Jiang, Goutham Rajendran, Pradeep Ravikumar, Bryon Aragam, Victor Veitch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Recent works have argued that high-level semantic concepts are encoded
"linearly" in the representation space of large language models. In this work,
we study the origins of such linear representations. To that end, we introduce
a simple latent variable model to abstract and formalize the concept dynamics
of the next token prediction. We use this formalism to show that the next token
prediction objective (softmax with cross-entropy) and the implicit bias of
gradient descent together promote the linear representation of concepts.
Experiments show that linear representations emerge when learning from data
matching the latent variable model, confirming that this simple structure
already suffices to yield linear representations. We additionally confirm some
predictions of the theory using the LLaMA-2 large language model, giving
evidence that the simplified model yields generalizable insights.
|
[
-0.002946238499134779,
-0.5216483473777771,
0.766197919845581,
-0.21428988873958588,
0.04841355234384537,
0.10219692438840866,
-0.1323738694190979,
-0.3343672752380371,
0.32574915885925293,
0.2808319628238678,
-0.5623835325241089,
-0.19771021604537964,
-0.7629347443580627,
-0.3806958794593811,
-0.49870702624320984,
1.2460813522338867,
-0.016121072694659233,
0.20087134838104248,
-0.11307618767023087,
-0.13196004927158356,
-0.45754942297935486,
-0.7615957260131836,
-0.49488404393196106,
-0.7163963913917542,
0.8048047423362732,
-0.03497685492038727,
0.9556881189346313,
0.8967880606651306,
0.2516648769378662,
0.2055445909500122,
-0.1464666873216629,
-0.21461835503578186,
-0.6226184368133545,
0.35997921228408813,
-0.06332455575466156,
-0.8842187523841858,
-0.05034391209483147,
0.3015298843383789,
0.7687931060791016,
1.1332489252090454,
0.07366310060024261,
-0.008473573252558708,
-0.04133458063006401,
0.024588927626609802,
-0.3269574046134949,
0.35325315594673157,
-0.785667359828949,
0.1433289796113968,
-0.140988290309906,
-0.3176906704902649,
-0.26308709383010864,
-0.00918083917349577,
0.25159916281700134,
-0.6105052828788757,
0.03424644097685814,
0.013919182121753693,
0.801177978515625,
-0.0236301701515913,
-0.5323998928070068,
-0.6651477813720703,
-0.7917409539222717,
0.9564321041107178,
-0.31691011786460876,
0.37449488043785095,
0.13313187658786774,
0.1276259869337082,
-0.2727046012878418,
-0.8964588642120361,
-0.5929959416389465,
-0.395985871553421,
0.08850137889385223,
-0.3283902704715729,
-0.04036550596356392,
-0.0587591677904129,
0.28316500782966614,
0.013072251342236996,
-0.2728942036628723,
0.2687458097934723,
-0.47563299536705017,
-0.1952611356973648,
0.41882604360580444,
0.1797548085451126,
0.10800912231206894,
-0.1770639717578888,
-0.5362757444381714,
0.18241527676582336,
-0.783714234828949,
-0.07115089893341064,
0.04113900661468506,
0.4661799371242523,
-0.24604769051074982,
0.7971301078796387,
0.35749390721321106,
0.020634301006793976,
0.041077904403209686,
-0.23065756261348724,
0.5333830118179321,
-0.3734760582447052,
0.07027094811201096,
-0.10810847580432892,
0.39406490325927734,
0.2019960731267929,
0.3336319029331207,
-0.27411016821861267,
-0.40988826751708984,
0.2804449796676636,
-0.14548274874687195,
-0.631406307220459,
0.0496957004070282,
-0.034809160977602005,
-0.6557877063751221,
-0.32422974705696106,
0.03190860524773598,
-0.38061410188674927,
-0.4918350577354431,
-0.5423611998558044,
0.35223230719566345,
0.0041892677545547485,
-0.4197807013988495,
0.09687270224094391,
-0.0020459701772779226,
0.556858479976654,
0.3188965618610382,
-0.9119214415550232,
0.5495455265045166,
1.0083574056625366,
0.6899176239967346,
-0.027122458443045616,
-0.07325826585292816,
-0.6128898859024048,
0.19589321315288544,
-0.7043316960334778,
0.4234994351863861,
-0.9538034200668335,
-0.19616428017616272,
0.3995150029659271,
-0.07393939793109894,
0.45343872904777527,
-0.14913088083267212,
0.32849830389022827,
-0.5282981991767883,
0.2900013029575348,
-0.425014853477478,
-0.6745782494544983,
0.10245230793952942,
-0.1504124253988266,
-0.4727724492549896,
1.068684458732605,
-0.1993703544139862,
-0.7746310234069824,
0.49995186924934387,
-0.6214573383331299,
0.11290675401687622,
0.09729757159948349,
-0.6363204717636108,
0.08314374089241028,
0.5346893072128296,
-0.11989330500364304,
0.5679972171783447,
-0.5166042447090149,
0.19676707684993744,
-0.24715499579906464,
-0.12279528379440308,
0.3694419860839844,
-0.27281346917152405,
0.5157109498977661,
-0.01147281564772129,
-0.38028484582901,
-0.07519062608480453,
-0.7299149632453918,
-0.2339029163122177,
0.2541895806789398,
-0.1063539981842041,
-0.6765288710594177,
0.3096068203449249,
-0.3122931122779846,
0.1879511922597885,
0.37502649426460266,
-0.46249696612358093,
0.2666783630847931,
-0.1834305226802826,
0.23426443338394165,
1.0600560903549194,
-0.0860620066523552,
0.7562358379364014,
0.24101461470127106,
0.4593924283981323,
0.28153693675994873,
-0.21910101175308228,
-0.3647957146167755,
-0.6986059546470642,
-0.8650110960006714,
0.23614919185638428,
0.3940287232398987,
0.11435747891664505,
-0.47338730096817017,
0.08657436072826385,
-0.4017496109008789,
0.10855241864919662,
-0.12116696685552597,
0.4839615225791931,
0.1700327843427658,
-0.028388407081365585,
-0.07002829760313034,
-0.08409463614225388,
-0.5444993376731873,
-0.8200893998146057,
0.227945938706398,
-0.4233427941799164,
-0.07973437756299973,
0.1281527429819107,
0.7544786334037781,
-0.6452362537384033,
0.828610360622406,
-0.5160395503044128,
0.08255555480718613,
-0.11101492494344711,
0.419785737991333,
0.38520461320877075,
0.6746166944503784,
0.6694966554641724,
-0.6594986319541931,
0.04901042953133583,
0.0500117652118206,
-0.6923434138298035,
-0.012232905253767967,
-0.05707628279924393,
-0.3125340938568115,
-0.06157951429486275,
0.7929584980010986,
-0.5040781497955322,
0.24174699187278748,
0.5881688594818115,
-0.5367692708969116,
0.27023282647132874,
-0.052976686507463455,
-0.7937296628952026,
-1.107985258102417,
-0.11003171652555466,
-0.16942304372787476,
-0.3030182719230652,
-0.6279443502426147,
-0.05267653614282608,
-0.24786201119422913,
-0.2381427139043808,
-0.05943356826901436,
0.41273191571235657,
-0.37444159388542175,
-0.3151855170726776,
-0.2573662996292114,
0.23849351704120636,
-0.07987665385007858,
0.4404245913028717,
0.05921398475766182,
0.4404580891132355,
0.543765664100647,
-0.5901998281478882,
0.3518783152103424,
-0.11048104614019394,
0.041191935539245605,
0.22275085747241974,
-0.8800074458122253,
0.16367292404174805,
-0.6238289475440979,
0.2656387984752655,
-0.9017075896263123,
0.05351271107792854,
-0.03576742485165596,
-0.46470195055007935,
0.2793259620666504,
-0.13572174310684204,
-0.4464993178844452,
-0.3538477420806885,
-0.2136228233575821,
0.5153104066848755,
0.5560747385025024,
-0.4187547564506531,
0.4654833972454071,
0.45289069414138794,
-0.09138857573270798,
-0.6764750480651855,
-0.901114821434021,
-0.1281595528125763,
0.04627612978219986,
-0.434644490480423,
0.11970676481723785,
-0.07779205590486526,
-0.4898320734500885,
0.16255855560302734,
-0.012508458457887173,
0.09724711626768112,
-0.13448584079742432,
0.14801189303398132,
0.3485672175884247,
-0.6988016963005066,
0.628776490688324,
-0.23726625740528107,
-0.1677895486354828,
0.38006591796875,
-0.9036277532577515,
0.6469231247901917,
-0.035571031272411346,
-0.11558371782302856,
-0.1805885136127472,
0.28337064385414124,
0.5623736381530762,
0.07922544330358505,
0.8786555528640747,
0.46021538972854614,
-0.5075510740280151,
-0.23102998733520508,
-0.3095701336860657,
-0.048331547528505325,
-0.44214707612991333,
0.4966382086277008,
-0.3510190546512604,
-0.793274998664856,
0.8822862505912781,
-0.06041717901825905,
-0.06200338155031204,
0.7186987996101379,
0.5718832612037659,
-0.06912250071763992,
0.9522926211357117,
0.9266799688339233,
0.13290633261203766,
0.528669536113739,
-0.5907871723175049,
-0.07226070761680603,
-0.6505672931671143,
-0.6317125558853149,
-0.5890142321586609,
-0.10284046828746796,
-0.648521363735199,
-1.0071195363998413,
0.09667722880840302,
0.24930502474308014,
-0.5016869902610779,
-0.04466547816991806,
0.12210024893283844,
0.39463675022125244,
0.3062850534915924,
-0.263803094625473,
-0.11593600362539291,
0.0988985225558281,
-0.5463539958000183,
-0.17994935810565948,
-0.4735066592693329,
-0.29364457726478577,
1.4462530612945557,
0.9040018916130066,
0.9305058717727661,
-0.013845649547874928,
0.6392019391059875,
0.4210951030254364,
0.02261170744895935,
-0.6796051263809204,
0.23701700568199158,
-0.09876774251461029,
-0.48782169818878174,
-0.07335203886032104,
-0.25522464513778687,
-1.0994536876678467,
0.07742138206958771,
-0.22448362410068512,
-0.8528655767440796,
0.5309963822364807,
-0.11675727367401123,
-0.1478584259748459,
0.11914267390966415,
-0.37639158964157104,
0.5447930693626404,
-0.24942989647388458,
-0.4449285864830017,
-0.32458826899528503,
-0.5005196332931519,
0.3269657492637634,
-0.10918202996253967,
0.26436519622802734,
-0.10289591550827026,
-0.5361335277557373,
0.9622875452041626,
-0.6584266424179077,
0.9125414490699768,
-0.42443957924842834,
-0.4890334904193878,
0.42106741666793823,
0.031077396124601364,
0.697656512260437,
0.07024018466472626,
0.020553605630993843,
-0.01434559840708971,
-0.4909268617630005,
-0.666710615158081,
-0.8450660109519958,
0.5895845890045166,
-0.9876947402954102,
-0.5490673184394836,
-0.3427407741546631,
-0.41560977697372437,
-0.07730980217456818,
0.016248678788542747,
-0.10564281046390533,
0.7276556491851807,
0.03217222914099693,
0.4157469868659973,
0.6825467944145203,
-0.12349191308021545,
0.31753790378570557,
0.06508957594633102,
-0.7604264616966248,
-0.036795079708099365,
0.6324248313903809,
0.007368684280663729,
0.34027087688446045,
0.3883851170539856,
0.339904248714447,
-0.33450910449028015,
-0.5685917735099792,
0.09311024099588394,
0.2979934811592102,
-0.964433491230011,
-0.12815412878990173,
-0.3096276819705963,
-0.24082885682582855,
-0.13563358783721924,
-0.10960372537374496,
-0.33979272842407227,
-0.5316153168678284,
-0.2689213454723358,
-0.31306999921798706,
0.22256019711494446,
1.4231359958648682,
-0.2796664237976074,
0.43211185932159424,
-0.18854951858520508,
0.15794213116168976,
0.4906184673309326,
0.3568776547908783,
0.003166308393701911,
-0.6028937101364136,
-0.4099656939506531,
-0.002850803779438138,
0.02052178792655468,
-0.6053487658500671,
0.14146830141544342,
0.2598153352737427,
0.7348005175590515,
0.7206361889839172,
-0.4906483292579651,
0.45138612389564514,
-0.48366525769233704,
0.9496210813522339,
0.6474353671073914,
-1.0720303058624268,
0.42281651496887207,
-0.42295923829078674,
0.04083976894617081,
0.10799280554056168,
0.422250360250473,
-0.495871365070343,
-0.16509662568569183,
-0.45986390113830566,
-0.7046781182289124,
0.4208008348941803,
0.07699057459831238,
0.7763478755950928,
0.02607114613056183,
0.499058336019516,
0.39722442626953125,
0.1773054450750351,
-1.1062651872634888,
-0.3534869849681854,
-0.332690954208374,
-0.13089793920516968,
-0.1730605810880661,
-0.6292686462402344,
0.17849484086036682,
-0.1664789766073227,
0.09403622150421143,
-0.30787646770477295,
0.7581478357315063,
-0.13603389263153076,
-0.006514676846563816,
-0.06486305594444275,
-0.18389658629894257,
0.4418129026889801,
0.7351447343826294,
0.07565128803253174,
0.36640867590904236,
-0.05364536866545677,
-0.3024141192436218,
0.04385657608509064,
-0.19219927489757538,
-0.03808305040001869,
0.261419415473938,
0.6452947854995728,
1.1079776287078857,
0.5133819580078125,
-0.47420206665992737,
0.6186652183532715,
0.11638838797807693,
0.04155918210744858,
-0.4929129481315613,
-0.25215309858322144,
0.16331613063812256,
0.3402075171470642,
0.8417823314666748,
-0.05645802989602089,
-0.08090964704751968,
-0.9532594084739685,
0.21841706335544586,
0.4355883002281189,
-0.15011119842529297,
-0.6524733901023865,
0.7147434949874878,
0.11333557963371277,
0.11013025790452957,
0.21560542285442352,
-0.13579653203487396,
-0.7004952430725098,
0.4490796625614166,
0.5520322322845459,
0.7243154048919678,
-0.08428149670362473,
0.25302940607070923,
0.30005982518196106,
0.02910546585917473,
0.0815369263291359,
0.23530694842338562,
-0.03751768916845322,
-0.8435304164886475,
-0.5136758685112,
-0.8413404226303101,
0.10751360654830933,
0.09093131870031357,
-0.39477038383483887,
0.2953142523765564,
-0.7076025605201721,
-0.1750868707895279,
0.17875105142593384,
0.09141582995653152,
-0.746401309967041,
0.030902767553925514,
0.9406731128692627,
0.6633672714233398,
-0.7868255376815796,
0.9760296940803528,
0.28652337193489075,
-0.5675612092018127,
-0.8511646389961243,
0.19220225512981415,
-0.07475335896015167,
-1.1987954378128052,
1.5855913162231445,
-0.06143076717853546,
-0.06816040724515915,
-0.36505255103111267,
-0.9213947057723999,
-1.3913253545761108,
0.807953953742981,
0.39972397685050964,
-0.515938401222229,
-0.39273276925086975,
0.24836182594299316,
0.6010399460792542,
-0.9689717888832092,
0.036611638963222504,
0.25037869811058044,
0.17075224220752716,
0.29583293199539185,
-0.506391704082489,
0.028635622933506966,
-0.2150733768939972,
0.4549201428890228,
-0.12337640672922134,
-0.15602858364582062,
1.3898059129714966,
-0.21586520969867706,
-0.1258815973997116,
0.16794490814208984,
1.0385925769805908,
-0.13486777245998383,
-0.024363437667489052,
0.27854791283607483,
0.11331486701965332,
0.9218381643295288,
0.013515379279851913,
1.2366164922714233,
-0.3516136407852173,
0.27823492884635925,
0.7679767608642578,
-0.07466014474630356,
0.8022964596748352,
0.403333455324173,
-0.1241263672709465,
1.055652379989624,
0.3072315752506256,
0.05602395534515381,
0.4641388952732086,
0.5317310094833374,
-0.03050886280834675,
0.022489046677947044,
-0.42749765515327454,
-0.3898831605911255,
0.6139097809791565,
0.8475328683853149,
-0.6773785352706909,
-0.05368855968117714,
-0.09783902764320374,
0.1165042445063591,
-0.11204947531223297,
-0.8709983229637146,
0.6865771412849426,
0.12118567526340485,
-0.3342946469783783,
0.7871732115745544,
-0.05254613980650902,
0.717917799949646,
-0.6849684715270996,
0.052528079599142075,
-0.1672530323266983,
0.14100129902362823,
0.004514795728027821,
-0.6789821982383728,
-0.07449045777320862,
-0.16743330657482147,
-0.15746770799160004,
-0.2916770875453949,
0.6985459923744202,
-0.5128432512283325,
-0.6641732454299927,
0.6271417737007141,
0.4394333064556122,
0.17657113075256348,
0.7021005749702454,
-0.553916871547699,
0.3019948899745941,
-0.2267887443304062,
-0.20191867649555206,
-0.08481688797473907,
0.7426910996437073,
-0.20735816657543182,
0.39100831747055054,
0.5271116495132446,
0.24221676588058472,
0.5683540105819702,
0.07495974749326706,
0.9291052222251892,
-0.6152678728103638,
-0.3835056722164154,
-0.7540396451950073,
0.29123029112815857,
0.12583471834659576,
-0.27228522300720215,
0.25198954343795776,
0.2532401382923126,
0.5841444730758667,
0.1970466524362564,
0.7276466488838196,
0.09704212844371796,
0.18925514817237854,
-0.6356913447380066,
0.3299650549888611,
-0.5862651467323303,
0.11033770442008972,
-0.30301496386528015,
-0.9456253051757812,
-0.04599647969007492,
0.5756800174713135,
-0.2754186689853668,
0.0992722138762474,
0.8415732383728027,
0.44060778617858887,
0.10085064172744751,
-0.2685204744338989,
0.2149738073348999,
0.5790224075317383,
0.16091400384902954,
0.4570174813270569,
0.7750584483146667,
-0.18954671919345856,
0.4135420024394989,
0.22477209568023682,
-0.018764078617095947,
-0.1909007430076599,
-0.7147864699363708,
-0.7805830836296082,
-0.7842232584953308,
-0.1708124876022339,
-0.6144636273384094,
0.0823938250541687,
1.1180737018585205,
0.7300804853439331,
-0.8156037330627441,
-0.19801181554794312,
-0.17375518381595612,
0.09256406873464584,
0.35719311237335205,
-0.12873844802379608,
0.3099330961704254,
-0.6797640323638916,
-0.6390190124511719,
0.04015654698014259,
0.06951422989368439,
0.15021803975105286,
-0.862413227558136,
-0.4838448464870453,
-0.016815777868032455,
0.37471556663513184,
0.6680822372436523,
0.19907543063163757,
-0.6120478510856628,
-0.37539997696876526,
-0.3092862367630005,
-0.2978224456310272,
0.0753224790096283,
1.1554583311080933,
-0.9556391835212708,
0.22524712979793549,
0.47196418046951294,
0.6665960550308228,
0.5470188856124878,
-0.45125675201416016,
1.0713247060775757,
-0.7950893640518188,
0.6269422769546509,
0.1973598748445511,
0.6156073212623596,
0.21428215503692627,
-0.14716199040412903,
0.2640835642814636,
0.5744502544403076,
0.0861426591873169,
-0.937653124332428,
0.36362266540527344,
-0.7025395035743713,
-0.20264235138893127,
1.2422466278076172,
-0.11587819457054138,
-0.3967793881893158,
-0.05676687881350517,
0.1516381800174713,
0.013557497411966324,
-0.41088637709617615,
0.2288881093263626,
0.5509586930274963,
0.08376803994178772,
-0.13288922607898712,
-0.6237305998802185,
0.31433403491973877,
0.30206650495529175,
-0.26856526732444763,
0.038326166570186615,
0.39466655254364014,
0.08767811208963394,
0.5233719348907471,
0.3287576138973236,
-0.15870660543441772,
0.08353501558303833,
0.382261723279953,
-0.1144212931394577,
0.30844759941101074,
-0.2096014767885208,
-0.23822830617427826,
0.342141717672348,
0.26754119992256165,
-0.058352287858724594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03866v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03866v1
|
KIWI: A Dataset of Knowledge-Intensive Writing Instructions for Answering Research Questions
| 2024-03-06T17:16:44 | 2024-03-06T17:16:44 |
Fangyuan Xu, Kyle Lo, Luca Soldaini, Bailey Kuehl, Eunsol Choi, David Wadden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) adapted to follow user instructions are now
widely deployed as conversational agents. In this work, we examine one
increasingly common instruction-following task: providing writing assistance to
compose a long-form answer. To evaluate the capabilities of current LLMs on
this task, we construct KIWI, a dataset of knowledge-intensive writing
instructions in the scientific domain. Given a research question, an initial
model-generated answer and a set of relevant papers, an expert annotator
iteratively issues instructions for the model to revise and improve its answer.
We collect 1,260 interaction turns from 234 interaction sessions with three
state-of-the-art LLMs. Each turn includes a user instruction, a model response,
and a human evaluation of the model response. Through a detailed analysis of
the collected responses, we find that all models struggle to incorporate new
information into an existing answer, and to perform precise and unambiguous
edits. Further, we find that models struggle to judge whether their outputs
successfully followed user instructions, with accuracy at least 10 points short
of human agreement. Our findings indicate that KIWI will be a valuable resource
to measure progress and improve LLMs' instruction-following capabilities for
knowledge intensive writing tasks.
|
[
-0.013854543678462505,
-1.0192142724990845,
0.7331317663192749,
0.33825358748435974,
0.1745092123746872,
-0.0035471406299620867,
-0.4820312261581421,
-0.4667614996433258,
0.08967291563749313,
1.0141947269439697,
-0.6498124599456787,
-0.42354363203048706,
-0.8331127762794495,
0.3276551365852356,
-0.2661016881465912,
1.1879808902740479,
-0.3005627393722534,
-0.2640622556209564,
-0.7622572183609009,
-0.0360659621655941,
-0.7402731776237488,
-0.3562534749507904,
-0.5145154595375061,
-0.3849276006221771,
1.008697271347046,
0.7676064372062683,
0.714938223361969,
0.3972175419330597,
0.5281298160552979,
0.2720932066440582,
-0.06888953596353531,
0.6064938306808472,
-0.46751371026039124,
0.4129304587841034,
-0.015720507130026817,
-0.7286873459815979,
-0.38182681798934937,
-0.05109144374728203,
0.4476262032985687,
0.8894550800323486,
0.2181394100189209,
0.39018699526786804,
0.08417294919490814,
0.5800526738166809,
-0.6157392859458923,
0.5109407305717468,
-0.2549905478954315,
-0.07897602021694183,
-0.07461833953857422,
-0.247685506939888,
-0.793478786945343,
-0.33774036169052124,
0.2498655468225479,
-0.8584553003311157,
0.0003467582573648542,
0.03859087824821472,
0.2335364669561386,
-0.04519636556506157,
-0.329923540353775,
-0.7125372886657715,
-0.6501948237419128,
0.5489410161972046,
-0.7765327095985413,
-0.18591536581516266,
0.6520978212356567,
0.11544853448867798,
-0.5474298596382141,
-0.7933791875839233,
-0.6078404188156128,
-0.5523940920829773,
-0.3194486200809479,
0.045782238245010376,
0.0847385823726654,
0.159068763256073,
0.44067224860191345,
-0.3224726617336273,
-0.23535272479057312,
0.03397432714700699,
-0.5129348635673523,
-0.12984563410282135,
0.8369522094726562,
0.47542354464530945,
0.4141426086425781,
-0.06422023475170135,
0.042929939925670624,
-0.019862286746501923,
-0.4850238561630249,
0.1778646558523178,
0.43236395716667175,
0.21868756413459778,
-0.2046603411436081,
1.0539145469665527,
-0.35663580894470215,
0.8885484337806702,
-0.2666556239128113,
-0.091837078332901,
-0.12569406628608704,
0.053231894969940186,
0.07015024870634079,
-0.07105373591184616,
0.9272165894508362,
0.5197439789772034,
0.5291972160339355,
-0.16141819953918457,
-0.17803038656711578,
-0.3057917654514313,
0.3018433153629303,
-0.7957292795181274,
-0.45862430334091187,
0.02283458411693573,
-0.033270224928855896,
-0.2946661412715912,
-0.29745253920555115,
-0.4171307682991028,
-0.5697544813156128,
-0.2869080603122711,
0.5419788360595703,
-0.3522402048110962,
-0.06777189671993256,
0.025998570024967194,
-0.30047672986984253,
0.11403751373291016,
0.4979780614376068,
-0.9340365529060364,
0.25167155265808105,
0.7130109071731567,
0.7277798056602478,
-0.13866615295410156,
-0.5032028555870056,
-0.24311164021492004,
0.3168439269065857,
-0.4682040810585022,
0.6457586884498596,
-0.790818989276886,
-0.621333122253418,
-0.2033804953098297,
0.07670916616916656,
-0.27270999550819397,
-0.16628938913345337,
0.19563761353492737,
-0.589098334312439,
0.30777880549430847,
-0.3829595148563385,
-0.6222074627876282,
-0.17246317863464355,
0.2349611073732376,
-0.6123688220977783,
1.1436563730239868,
0.21022307872772217,
-0.8337019085884094,
-0.07392660528421402,
-1.1412394046783447,
-0.5895626544952393,
0.07276641577482224,
-0.00835186243057251,
-0.11815149337053299,
0.062043171375989914,
0.1197499930858612,
0.6968094706535339,
-0.34165048599243164,
0.0937763974070549,
-0.28497469425201416,
-0.3660799562931061,
0.7054123282432556,
-0.5021806955337524,
0.7027830481529236,
-0.05665351077914238,
-0.2354496717453003,
0.01084696501493454,
-0.8439033627510071,
-0.05048510432243347,
0.10677028447389603,
-0.39607733488082886,
-0.26066863536834717,
-0.22415803372859955,
-0.2994462549686432,
-0.3999349772930145,
0.3029935657978058,
-0.685974657535553,
0.5287043452262878,
0.18494005501270294,
0.6969141364097595,
0.7363293766975403,
0.1288231909275055,
0.2065141350030899,
-0.40454304218292236,
0.5838208794593811,
-0.3367907404899597,
0.09526156634092331,
-0.41185930371284485,
-0.6574956178665161,
-0.8751839995384216,
0.0338725708425045,
0.07317174971103668,
0.42388272285461426,
-0.5197082757949829,
-0.10047389566898346,
-0.32807621359825134,
-0.5639945268630981,
-0.5621156692504883,
0.31991422176361084,
0.44233599305152893,
0.8217005133628845,
0.31281936168670654,
0.1713975965976715,
-0.3388802111148834,
-0.8182229995727539,
-0.19630588591098785,
-0.3158044219017029,
0.08880007266998291,
0.2897093892097473,
0.51628178358078,
-0.19720150530338287,
0.7962499856948853,
-0.7238795757293701,
0.17954927682876587,
-0.22916407883167267,
0.44404956698417664,
0.04810342937707901,
0.22435365617275238,
0.08459002524614334,
-0.6031991839408875,
-0.5304186344146729,
0.10962023586034775,
-1.0520809888839722,
-0.1912854164838791,
0.08167349547147751,
-0.23823685944080353,
0.29694700241088867,
0.4243896007537842,
-1.0192393064498901,
0.2791539132595062,
0.18704573810100555,
-0.2233889102935791,
0.7345575094223022,
-0.254780113697052,
0.4296858608722687,
-0.8297370076179504,
0.2541944086551666,
-0.26919668912887573,
-0.010462667793035507,
-0.7284805178642273,
0.16408635675907135,
0.13520710170269012,
-0.174832284450531,
-0.1397598683834076,
0.5119472146034241,
-0.587193489074707,
0.2202383577823639,
-0.3534690737724304,
0.12281837314367294,
0.21352510154247284,
0.4932420551776886,
0.09494203329086304,
0.8880020380020142,
0.11844967305660248,
-0.34861576557159424,
0.42819535732269287,
0.3389263153076172,
-0.33307769894599915,
0.09393472969532013,
-0.6927182674407959,
0.5982694029808044,
-0.3341596722602844,
0.12741991877555847,
-1.0906565189361572,
-0.5392630696296692,
0.17878229916095734,
-0.580295741558075,
0.268069326877594,
-0.12485426664352417,
-0.39786866307258606,
-0.38269102573394775,
-0.003296447452157736,
0.24732983112335205,
0.4100564122200012,
-0.08130953460931778,
0.9984554052352905,
-0.06233212351799011,
-0.6153331995010376,
-0.7806490659713745,
-0.8106083869934082,
0.22848060727119446,
0.14625591039657593,
-0.7002790570259094,
-0.005549517925828695,
-0.1175886020064354,
-0.14193159341812134,
0.14107532799243927,
0.28865522146224976,
0.05782962962985039,
0.07085727900266647,
0.4682644307613373,
0.34711575508117676,
-0.12028245627880096,
0.027858970686793327,
-0.13830941915512085,
0.14067749679088593,
0.4999904930591583,
0.03198986127972603,
0.330084890127182,
0.5429339408874512,
-0.28940969705581665,
-0.629724383354187,
0.4162956178188324,
0.8483111262321472,
-0.16415072977542877,
0.6832165718078613,
0.29037243127822876,
-0.06225666031241417,
-0.26990753412246704,
-0.7084585428237915,
-0.03553127869963646,
-0.4573148488998413,
0.47184988856315613,
-0.39784204959869385,
-0.6055362820625305,
0.43581053614616394,
0.33571743965148926,
0.45216190814971924,
0.35483798384666443,
0.26367810368537903,
-0.4733123779296875,
0.8987371921539307,
0.7389843463897705,
-0.14980977773666382,
0.152006134390831,
-0.23309551179409027,
0.15782345831394196,
-0.7196699380874634,
-0.608938992023468,
-0.5299983024597168,
-0.2778617739677429,
-0.1641548126935959,
-0.43663740158081055,
0.3613959848880768,
-0.10822398960590363,
-0.09683223068714142,
0.22850675880908966,
-0.45024821162223816,
0.49118688702583313,
0.6195279955863953,
0.20011365413665771,
0.11345059424638748,
-0.2239137440919876,
0.05752046778798103,
0.3016839623451233,
-0.8702017664909363,
-0.532803475856781,
1.2900251150131226,
0.1203891858458519,
0.9737180471420288,
-0.1167619451880455,
0.4733026921749115,
0.5177902579307556,
0.6347063183784485,
-0.6586020588874817,
0.7079942226409912,
0.0703958049416542,
-0.34165871143341064,
-0.5601845383644104,
-0.4364404082298279,
-0.6260937452316284,
-0.23541781306266785,
-0.18766401708126068,
-0.5082037448883057,
-0.6376340389251709,
0.1747971773147583,
-0.1854584813117981,
0.14130422472953796,
-0.7587037682533264,
0.7141463160514832,
-0.17075185477733612,
-0.3522132337093353,
-0.06591689586639404,
-0.6786061525344849,
0.2540190815925598,
0.1123826876282692,
0.06510137766599655,
-0.024803124368190765,
0.04733426123857498,
1.0524699687957764,
-0.5162806510925293,
1.2535126209259033,
-0.37916117906570435,
-0.03562005236744881,
0.6160573363304138,
0.043689075857400894,
0.6544598340988159,
-0.2352270781993866,
-0.2379760444164276,
-0.42382729053497314,
0.1280786097049713,
-0.39838799834251404,
-1.0511953830718994,
0.6452399492263794,
-0.9705429673194885,
-0.8885214328765869,
-0.00040358194382861257,
-0.9753904342651367,
-0.20692838728427887,
0.09322290867567062,
0.1487557291984558,
0.701876699924469,
0.05598217993974686,
0.045112092047929764,
0.6452867984771729,
-0.04403252527117729,
0.24850064516067505,
0.5662468075752258,
-0.08122850954532623,
-0.3816494941711426,
0.6611648201942444,
0.36010056734085083,
0.3352043926715851,
0.410129189491272,
0.28192493319511414,
-0.23555709421634674,
-0.6673499941825867,
-0.7430583834648132,
0.19870904088020325,
-0.9705874919891357,
-0.10957315564155579,
-0.9790651798248291,
-0.2316865622997284,
-0.400081992149353,
-0.26402944326400757,
0.1044735461473465,
-0.5334300398826599,
-0.27963700890541077,
-0.07595155388116837,
0.6507746577262878,
1.1325198411941528,
0.5857272148132324,
0.331437885761261,
-0.8128193020820618,
0.21272729337215424,
0.09853912889957428,
-0.05202776938676834,
0.26584306359291077,
-0.6553825736045837,
-0.17988426983356476,
0.21005767583847046,
-0.11573256552219391,
-0.7756018042564392,
-0.12283778190612793,
0.011840674094855785,
0.45904916524887085,
-0.07549149543046951,
0.16278651356697083,
0.825293242931366,
-0.2995213568210602,
0.8517656922340393,
0.12260305881500244,
-0.5304387211799622,
0.44840461015701294,
-0.06332539767026901,
0.5313892960548401,
0.4977140426635742,
0.6876336336135864,
-0.7963961958885193,
-0.6370083689689636,
-0.1773058921098709,
-0.620522141456604,
0.4761546850204468,
-0.18090806901454926,
0.42582014203071594,
-0.05779922381043434,
0.7342905402183533,
0.273584246635437,
-0.017525067552924156,
-0.5143393278121948,
0.14233919978141785,
0.25179824233055115,
-0.4948183298110962,
-0.13692443072795868,
-0.42195776104927063,
-0.2726159691810608,
0.05641337111592293,
0.7648404240608215,
-0.24521054327487946,
0.054334912449121475,
0.2817199230194092,
-0.2926364541053772,
-0.01834603026509285,
0.12234809249639511,
0.516677737236023,
0.6518768668174744,
0.09367579221725464,
0.11629330366849899,
0.25804686546325684,
-0.5387236475944519,
0.11682529002428055,
0.03238363191485405,
-0.43376120924949646,
-0.24608400464057922,
0.9898470044136047,
0.6253376007080078,
0.10054202377796173,
-0.7680542469024658,
0.5192229151725769,
-0.0013009138638153672,
-0.3794679045677185,
-0.510231077671051,
0.45296046137809753,
0.3890440762042999,
-0.038760051131248474,
0.3250714838504791,
0.025068603456020355,
-0.06703260540962219,
-0.5223687291145325,
-0.25958505272865295,
0.3501026928424835,
-0.3392493426799774,
-0.31774184107780457,
0.3953542411327362,
0.21860848367214203,
-0.629380464553833,
0.8012229800224304,
0.16093550622463226,
-0.4076155722141266,
0.6826074719429016,
0.46612390875816345,
0.46978089213371277,
0.14370328187942505,
0.1665930449962616,
0.04930872470140457,
0.11298999935388565,
0.0022736440878361464,
0.41655805706977844,
-0.22958187758922577,
-0.44650742411613464,
-0.6482821106910706,
-0.37871506810188293,
-0.65839684009552,
-0.040605198591947556,
-0.7487848997116089,
0.22849911451339722,
-0.5625404119491577,
-0.018138350918889046,
0.3429480493068695,
-0.052654799073934555,
-0.7145379185676575,
0.08501533418893814,
-0.3223733603954315,
1.0929797887802124,
-0.8653650879859924,
0.5510883331298828,
0.7728317379951477,
-0.41733065247535706,
-0.9620972871780396,
-0.3293064832687378,
-0.127170130610466,
-0.7812573909759521,
0.6635546684265137,
0.36870038509368896,
-0.32556429505348206,
-0.2670193314552307,
-0.7703019976615906,
-0.5132208466529846,
1.1917529106140137,
0.20190174877643585,
-0.5003699660301208,
-0.15823519229888916,
0.4549081325531006,
0.5826756358146667,
-0.4091391861438751,
0.7167257070541382,
0.48901137709617615,
0.4872652590274811,
0.014675058424472809,
-0.5132063627243042,
0.10694395005702972,
-0.29757288098335266,
-0.2577587962150574,
0.1581667959690094,
-0.7455961108207703,
0.408182829618454,
-0.49059173464775085,
0.00633650366216898,
0.3715367317199707,
0.7818921208381653,
-0.013030377216637135,
0.2904297411441803,
0.34422510862350464,
0.26375943422317505,
0.8201138973236084,
0.27645695209503174,
0.9460199475288391,
-0.22337660193443298,
-0.33274900913238525,
1.1073801517486572,
-0.3033708333969116,
0.9358851313591003,
0.5108556151390076,
-0.05214853584766388,
0.6050216555595398,
0.2520795166492462,
0.10459952056407928,
0.12688665091991425,
0.2595966160297394,
-0.3761247992515564,
-0.06612113863229752,
-0.12755660712718964,
0.10308834165334702,
0.3893479108810425,
0.23576124012470245,
-0.42535194754600525,
0.29696691036224365,
0.16081826388835907,
0.120481938123703,
0.16708648204803467,
-0.26657307147979736,
1.0026217699050903,
-0.12469092756509781,
-1.1254072189331055,
0.4860806167125702,
-0.1297694593667984,
0.33849284052848816,
-0.7730942964553833,
-0.30341434478759766,
-0.27413976192474365,
-0.15473788976669312,
-0.3546142876148224,
-1.2154033184051514,
-0.027288781479001045,
0.2644394040107727,
-0.4657238721847534,
0.15290522575378418,
0.6307903528213501,
-0.4194697439670563,
-0.6353988647460938,
0.2270704060792923,
0.1241258978843689,
0.25509053468704224,
0.4112122058868408,
-0.27737957239151,
0.19986304640769958,
0.0947461798787117,
-0.5493167042732239,
0.11823682487010956,
0.458975613117218,
-0.25945210456848145,
1.1289647817611694,
0.5541254281997681,
0.032437004148960114,
0.11913987994194031,
0.09012068063020706,
0.8583416938781738,
-0.5563694834709167,
-0.12269500643014908,
-0.6918916702270508,
0.5366324186325073,
-0.18841174244880676,
-0.4678296446800232,
0.5645431876182556,
0.3554190993309021,
0.6626278162002563,
-0.050387389957904816,
1.178438663482666,
-0.10470199584960938,
0.3597050905227661,
-0.6145800352096558,
0.5292215943336487,
-0.17607465386390686,
0.2514989376068115,
0.10262485593557358,
-0.7587830424308777,
-0.16080711781978607,
0.11576355993747711,
-0.3905300199985504,
-0.07883338630199432,
0.40757885575294495,
1.1299346685409546,
-0.011991003528237343,
0.4285458028316498,
0.11885268241167068,
0.13524146378040314,
0.29656359553337097,
0.40069523453712463,
0.9878219366073608,
0.0017994471127167344,
0.5823349356651306,
-0.3088037967681885,
-0.2814260721206665,
-0.046579670161008835,
-0.818137526512146,
-1.0864434242248535,
-0.39643532037734985,
-0.3101995885372162,
-0.21671554446220398,
0.38558104634284973,
1.0383127927780151,
0.5075209736824036,
-0.5451748967170715,
-0.21983754634857178,
0.19443222880363464,
-0.22788043320178986,
-0.12507396936416626,
-0.22039411962032318,
0.32952070236206055,
-0.40553203225135803,
-0.323866605758667,
0.34233468770980835,
0.10821119695901871,
-0.11045771092176437,
-0.261331170797348,
-0.07407008856534958,
0.053288429975509644,
0.17362327873706818,
0.5371605157852173,
0.18407920002937317,
-0.6117250919342041,
-0.5455248355865479,
0.15949080884456635,
-0.17626142501831055,
-0.10400023311376572,
0.9092293977737427,
-0.17327047884464264,
0.6188632249832153,
0.2885435223579407,
0.9562097787857056,
0.8141365051269531,
-0.14421755075454712,
0.7573956251144409,
-0.44842007756233215,
-0.3084140121936798,
0.17213372886180878,
0.10772259533405304,
0.5754323601722717,
-0.5382977724075317,
0.366630882024765,
-0.13302604854106903,
-0.8095834851264954,
-0.5501917600631714,
-0.08765919506549835,
-0.8837639093399048,
-0.30032071471214294,
1.2063438892364502,
-0.5812140703201294,
-0.5260970592498779,
0.05523863807320595,
-0.46968942880630493,
0.12455904483795166,
-0.22342631220817566,
0.6669902801513672,
0.9437612891197205,
-0.34469425678253174,
-0.24216441810131073,
-0.6217547655105591,
0.1756400465965271,
0.39560413360595703,
-0.6164233088493347,
0.5834721326828003,
0.46413522958755493,
0.6514435410499573,
0.06240009143948555,
0.7518503069877625,
0.049264486879110336,
0.28463226556777954,
0.09269869327545166,
0.0823688730597496,
-0.5852576494216919,
-0.436635822057724,
0.02583662047982216,
0.23716333508491516,
0.5661604404449463,
0.19610793888568878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03863v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03863v1
|
X-Shot: A Unified System to Handle Frequent, Few-shot and Zero-shot Learning Simultaneously in Classification
| 2024-03-06T17:13:24 | 2024-03-06T17:13:24 |
Hanzi Xu, Muhao Chen, Lifu Huang, Slobodan Vucetic, Wenpeng Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, few-shot and zero-shot learning, which learn to predict
labels with limited annotated instances, have garnered significant attention.
Traditional approaches often treat frequent-shot (freq-shot; labels with
abundant instances), few-shot, and zero-shot learning as distinct challenges,
optimizing systems for just one of these scenarios. Yet, in real-world
settings, label occurrences vary greatly. Some of them might appear thousands
of times, while others might only appear sporadically or not at all. For
practical deployment, it is crucial that a system can adapt to any label
occurrence. We introduce a novel classification challenge: X-shot, reflecting a
real-world context where freq-shot, few-shot, and zero-shot labels co-occur
without predefined limits. Here, X can span from 0 to positive infinity. The
crux of X-shot centers on open-domain generalization and devising a system
versatile enough to manage various label scenarios. To solve X-shot, we propose
BinBin (Binary INference Based on INstruction following) that leverages the
Indirect Supervision from a large collection of NLP tasks via instruction
following, bolstered by Weak Supervision provided by large language models.
BinBin surpasses previous state-of-the-art techniques on three benchmark
datasets across multiple domains. To our knowledge, this is the first work
addressing X-shot learning, where X remains variable.
|
[
-0.1970641016960144,
-0.522896945476532,
0.2022959440946579,
-0.09905693680047989,
-0.05364619195461273,
0.09011640399694443,
-0.06640797108411789,
-0.6734622120857239,
-0.03294111788272858,
0.3542543947696686,
-0.558711588382721,
-0.8331172466278076,
-0.8554416298866272,
0.040942564606666565,
-0.2046923041343689,
1.1535333395004272,
-0.0936092883348465,
-0.3265382647514343,
0.2225150316953659,
-0.362892746925354,
-0.6659894585609436,
-0.6753996014595032,
-0.7987064123153687,
-0.4267362952232361,
0.8686255812644958,
0.5587245225906372,
0.49170398712158203,
0.4323377311229706,
0.34044113755226135,
0.21269230544567108,
0.32931700348854065,
0.06031682714819908,
-0.4690360426902771,
0.08914921432733536,
-0.17802700400352478,
-0.7307543158531189,
-0.07495281100273132,
-0.30865681171417236,
0.7914981842041016,
0.938291072845459,
0.10416696220636368,
0.08514303714036942,
-0.16520321369171143,
0.19563601911067963,
-1.025071382522583,
0.2747548520565033,
-0.6664012670516968,
0.33332034945487976,
-0.15335768461227417,
0.023508111014962196,
-0.5041705369949341,
0.2219037413597107,
-0.03377505764365196,
-0.6453555822372437,
0.2496831864118576,
0.2888796329498291,
0.5749816298484802,
0.15939827263355255,
-0.3466828763484955,
0.01331364642828703,
-0.7959010601043701,
0.9264507293701172,
0.0905841514468193,
0.2231411188840866,
0.1428719162940979,
0.5972504615783691,
-0.12263981252908707,
-0.35922369360923767,
-0.20710425078868866,
0.179717019200325,
0.06833942979574203,
0.0713154673576355,
-0.5614144206047058,
-0.02692936174571514,
0.16121692955493927,
-0.45236262679100037,
-0.7167010307312012,
0.32742366194725037,
-0.1273488998413086,
0.03407491743564606,
0.4962611794471741,
0.3368705213069916,
-0.09182616323232651,
-0.007036780007183552,
-0.5396310091018677,
-0.15957365930080414,
-0.5862692594528198,
0.24973221123218536,
0.10625050216913223,
0.41958796977996826,
0.13737235963344574,
0.26334264874458313,
-0.19722284376621246,
0.9174882769584656,
-0.09905777126550674,
-0.00644094729796052,
0.07288516312837601,
0.07452571392059326,
-0.291929692029953,
0.3393126428127289,
0.7467473149299622,
0.21397550404071808,
-0.12945587933063507,
-0.22532790899276733,
-0.11349314451217651,
0.05961206927895546,
0.13190440833568573,
-0.4818565547466278,
-0.11099255084991455,
0.2846422493457794,
0.26692137122154236,
-0.5692412257194519,
0.1127411276102066,
-0.409016489982605,
-0.02682068571448326,
0.00337463547475636,
0.8380480408668518,
-0.3762168288230896,
0.17718906700611115,
0.16867542266845703,
-0.3065111041069031,
0.10619945079088211,
0.46444612741470337,
-0.7782737016677856,
0.13884316384792328,
0.8683185577392578,
0.9636392593383789,
-0.19796188175678253,
-0.34453192353248596,
-0.6770645976066589,
0.4598623812198639,
-0.6258528232574463,
1.0398147106170654,
-0.630526602268219,
-0.24601510167121887,
-0.09400250017642975,
-0.02750992402434349,
0.09912537038326263,
-0.46671220660209656,
0.18604476749897003,
-0.45197615027427673,
-0.004687197506427765,
0.19242364168167114,
-0.6072045564651489,
-0.29290854930877686,
0.3726692199707031,
-0.17510546743869781,
0.6923061013221741,
0.3164270520210266,
-0.4981275498867035,
0.8437315225601196,
-0.40619373321533203,
-0.08660486340522766,
0.43478813767433167,
-0.45393866300582886,
-0.711944580078125,
0.05730307474732399,
-0.3645723760128021,
0.5945528745651245,
0.03463820368051529,
0.1921849548816681,
-0.498550683259964,
-0.5590108633041382,
0.04865530878305435,
-0.31525227427482605,
0.8534532785415649,
-0.30870288610458374,
-0.37254461646080017,
-0.06137403845787048,
-0.9212886691093445,
0.25918227434158325,
-0.021261470392346382,
-0.07298064976930618,
-0.49395206570625305,
-0.3458302915096283,
-0.33051761984825134,
0.19742846488952637,
-0.40951043367385864,
-0.6232594847679138,
0.44686979055404663,
-0.0968630388379097,
-0.11328969150781631,
0.6869107484817505,
0.19774456322193146,
0.3484453856945038,
-0.44242438673973083,
0.5701393485069275,
0.16122829914093018,
0.04585457593202591,
-0.5720445513725281,
-0.40982785820961,
-0.5246577262878418,
-0.5749362707138062,
0.27387431263923645,
0.6366804838180542,
-0.8314204216003418,
0.4840496778488159,
-0.19674468040466309,
-0.4406028091907501,
-0.10792434215545654,
0.23941275477409363,
0.6770300269126892,
0.36582162976264954,
0.35337212681770325,
-0.43635258078575134,
-0.3885441720485687,
-0.4524019956588745,
0.1141522005200386,
-0.04000107944011688,
-0.11931658536195755,
0.47128573060035706,
0.6047794222831726,
-0.1545293629169464,
0.7347464561462402,
-0.7785205245018005,
-0.6669152975082397,
-0.0102942930534482,
0.5634697675704956,
0.23953497409820557,
0.41735947132110596,
0.6513006091117859,
-0.32223859429359436,
-0.7938389778137207,
0.075825996696949,
-0.8625405430793762,
-0.24775205552577972,
-0.4457361698150635,
-0.3530331254005432,
0.32739731669425964,
0.3826445937156677,
-0.22778575122356415,
0.5978230834007263,
0.3801763653755188,
-0.10336343944072723,
0.6443242430686951,
-0.03064587712287903,
0.0017655440606176853,
-0.30656304955482483,
-0.09544598311185837,
-0.04238275811076164,
-0.45929691195487976,
-0.5356821417808533,
0.03630254417657852,
0.0025772929657250643,
-0.06791189312934875,
-0.635223388671875,
0.6358166933059692,
-0.3665153980255127,
0.08479893207550049,
-0.4409521520137787,
-0.12348364293575287,
0.21266984939575195,
0.7005466222763062,
0.36329129338264465,
0.08073890209197998,
1.142859697341919,
-0.48553022742271423,
0.518388032913208,
0.1923818588256836,
-0.27085956931114197,
0.8025168776512146,
-0.49136224389076233,
0.05218815430998802,
-0.26913824677467346,
0.4757741689682007,
-0.6412583589553833,
-0.1662394255399704,
0.640124499797821,
-0.33376890420913696,
0.6781250238418579,
-0.3072732985019684,
-0.3934074342250824,
-0.2844935357570648,
-0.4167478680610657,
0.31027737259864807,
0.37713897228240967,
-0.45324715971946716,
0.2738839387893677,
-0.12938958406448364,
0.14003576338291168,
-0.8484935164451599,
-0.3896220028400421,
0.0847586914896965,
0.030536169186234474,
-0.31973662972450256,
0.24657690525054932,
0.07021842896938324,
-0.056454919278621674,
0.10772163420915604,
-0.3089001178741455,
-0.26847776770591736,
-0.12409794330596924,
0.49602413177490234,
0.3477705121040344,
-0.05308656394481659,
0.3067592978477478,
0.1296353042125702,
-0.43622100353240967,
-0.14332713186740875,
-0.4099074602127075,
0.03204722702503204,
0.1673649102449417,
-0.38918501138687134,
-0.1890765130519867,
0.847387433052063,
-0.09703661501407623,
0.3997866213321686,
0.651153028011322,
0.48937880992889404,
-0.15603825449943542,
-0.5787434577941895,
-0.10806925594806671,
-0.07029132544994354,
-0.42834025621414185,
0.40578973293304443,
-0.6208791136741638,
-0.5911444425582886,
0.07644505053758621,
0.15730786323547363,
0.3616926670074463,
-0.025841696187853813,
0.3627304434776306,
-0.36176568269729614,
0.8574260473251343,
0.9578791260719299,
0.12424582988023758,
0.4512874484062195,
-0.39888715744018555,
-0.07477893680334091,
-0.43435248732566833,
-0.15068334341049194,
-0.2529713809490204,
-0.38567134737968445,
-0.21258440613746643,
-0.41741105914115906,
0.5241327285766602,
0.20850113034248352,
-0.3474489450454712,
0.5306826829910278,
-0.5423833131790161,
0.6080796718597412,
0.8550015687942505,
0.33152255415916443,
0.3510097563266754,
-0.05094146728515625,
0.09894294291734695,
0.3155311644077301,
-1.059748649597168,
-0.0704791471362114,
1.15985107421875,
-0.10012757033109665,
0.7754207253456116,
0.04372403770685196,
1.2077746391296387,
0.26524990797042847,
0.30857160687446594,
-1.0092569589614868,
0.3848712146282196,
-0.16287942230701447,
-1.0190279483795166,
-0.2666073143482208,
-0.3798341453075409,
-1.3342571258544922,
0.3572414517402649,
-0.3587747812271118,
-0.8170440793037415,
0.2326643168926239,
0.24488385021686554,
-0.7341657280921936,
0.3842071294784546,
-0.7935383915901184,
0.789806604385376,
-0.3607839345932007,
-0.6325564980506897,
0.08810689300298691,
-1.0439859628677368,
0.5182388424873352,
-0.5591316223144531,
0.09958041459321976,
-0.26963010430336,
-0.19650843739509583,
0.31969308853149414,
-0.35925883054733276,
1.1621488332748413,
-0.10114949941635132,
0.19642281532287598,
0.5099310278892517,
0.04582653567194939,
-0.033822789788246155,
-0.16230343282222748,
0.3306693136692047,
0.528078556060791,
0.3061004877090454,
-0.6334139704704285,
-0.7169352173805237,
0.3332168757915497,
-0.7644926905632019,
-0.41341570019721985,
-0.9615904092788696,
-0.42113032937049866,
-0.15340693295001984,
0.20848700404167175,
0.38893383741378784,
0.5493096113204956,
-0.03923271968960762,
0.1183575987815857,
0.5018354058265686,
-0.2037176489830017,
0.379620224237442,
0.5969071388244629,
-0.3244558274745941,
-0.09865477681159973,
0.932871401309967,
0.4040679335594177,
0.3822869062423706,
0.7514783143997192,
0.12163437902927399,
0.14993003010749817,
-0.18146184086799622,
-0.3491535782814026,
0.1343960016965866,
-0.7341978549957275,
-0.7502598166465759,
-0.639117956161499,
-0.08398144692182541,
-0.4141128957271576,
-0.516671895980835,
-0.11388754099607468,
-0.25009509921073914,
-0.2230343073606491,
0.18001817166805267,
0.21176403760910034,
0.35608527064323425,
-0.5799047946929932,
0.5229817032814026,
-1.067475438117981,
0.46286076307296753,
0.3591437041759491,
0.47129902243614197,
-0.27480748295783997,
-0.5818231105804443,
-0.2277860790491104,
-0.2943198084831238,
-0.3566405475139618,
-0.7921891212463379,
0.22430118918418884,
0.6120886206626892,
0.5983881950378418,
0.48844635486602783,
0.2214178442955017,
0.38534343242645264,
-0.7334755063056946,
0.2774524986743927,
0.6177845001220703,
-0.6020573973655701,
0.37690797448158264,
-0.06151510030031204,
0.4542498290538788,
0.48769184947013855,
1.0547517538070679,
-0.5692761540412903,
-0.3681959807872772,
-0.6154189705848694,
-0.8821671009063721,
0.9608932137489319,
-0.026093874126672745,
0.05891823396086693,
-0.14676319062709808,
0.2779381275177002,
0.5557942986488342,
0.09212061762809753,
-0.5884661078453064,
-0.439557820558548,
-0.04213407263159752,
0.0009491885430179536,
0.03824992850422859,
0.12184152752161026,
-0.15373194217681885,
-0.1660170704126358,
0.7781911492347717,
-0.19644880294799805,
0.2737770676612854,
-0.1099407970905304,
-0.286143958568573,
0.0043818214908242226,
0.24240797758102417,
0.2243998795747757,
0.1843753606081009,
-0.4078892767429352,
0.25362589955329895,
-0.010542834177613258,
-0.1852993667125702,
0.5333188772201538,
-0.18635612726211548,
-0.3917507827281952,
0.2705783247947693,
0.442991703748703,
0.8590359091758728,
0.6597906351089478,
-0.6157175302505493,
0.5134071707725525,
0.34363430738449097,
-0.3942621052265167,
-0.14688435196876526,
0.49853086471557617,
-0.5082804560661316,
0.2782175540924072,
0.26362767815589905,
0.20844142138957977,
0.014687302522361279,
-0.7367157340049744,
0.40384364128112793,
0.390115350484848,
-0.5833123922348022,
-0.25311440229415894,
0.2999812066555023,
0.049925968050956726,
-0.2639031708240509,
0.2919076085090637,
-0.6189695000648499,
-0.3981474041938782,
0.46595829725265503,
0.4163385033607483,
0.7918194532394409,
-0.019715629518032074,
0.5675444602966309,
0.3851846158504486,
0.01877204142510891,
0.04577821120619774,
-0.14024758338928223,
-0.37368038296699524,
-0.8662018775939941,
-0.2827044129371643,
-0.3025761544704437,
-0.8416397571563721,
-0.28817620873451233,
-0.5705503225326538,
0.6132485866546631,
-0.5098400115966797,
-0.14989058673381805,
0.3672063946723938,
-0.1035832092165947,
-0.6608622074127197,
0.05697179585695267,
0.39738959074020386,
0.5956390500068665,
-0.9780375957489014,
0.8143167495727539,
0.5496971011161804,
-0.3827306926250458,
-0.4127171039581299,
-0.6339616179466248,
0.372313916683197,
-0.9131379127502441,
0.7862048745155334,
0.36585497856140137,
-0.26997020840644836,
0.1352837085723877,
-0.764286458492279,
-0.4184594750404358,
0.8998060822486877,
-0.01483996119350195,
-0.7109723091125488,
0.01940726861357689,
-0.022548675537109375,
0.23623166978359222,
-0.16913515329360962,
0.1570456475019455,
0.5242997407913208,
0.28085556626319885,
0.37228378653526306,
-0.5540996789932251,
-0.467178076505661,
0.26056987047195435,
-0.37403571605682373,
0.3544335663318634,
-0.6147570013999939,
0.27116698026657104,
-0.3637291193008423,
-0.07284402847290039,
-0.17996056377887726,
0.32487255334854126,
0.38626912236213684,
0.6028899550437927,
0.4653877019882202,
0.4422502815723419,
0.4800803065299988,
0.02028128318488598,
0.8215548396110535,
0.09931083768606186,
0.30698272585868835,
1.4581727981567383,
-0.5074411630630493,
0.7667177319526672,
0.15101827681064606,
-0.2730618119239807,
0.4754728078842163,
0.25345179438591003,
-0.2947749197483063,
0.40019989013671875,
0.13987503945827484,
-0.701889157295227,
-0.33929145336151123,
0.06431334465742111,
0.13436183333396912,
0.6950421929359436,
0.3614271879196167,
0.03143206238746643,
-0.6414012908935547,
0.4341396689414978,
-0.008205976337194443,
-0.38796284794807434,
-0.3857581317424774,
0.7900784015655518,
0.0953914225101471,
-0.4599514305591583,
0.5763019323348999,
-0.2330007702112198,
0.8458033204078674,
-0.8989226818084717,
-0.1327292025089264,
-0.025166096165776253,
0.20987515151500702,
-0.28000882267951965,
-0.9143891334533691,
0.34991395473480225,
-0.039889175444841385,
-0.1127527579665184,
-0.11528885364532471,
0.6390874981880188,
-0.31896063685417175,
-0.5888779759407043,
0.21200475096702576,
0.34920698404312134,
0.46049782633781433,
-0.17410652339458466,
-0.7797356843948364,
0.1374594271183014,
-0.06030114367604256,
-0.0073574562557041645,
0.5318705439567566,
0.7129044532775879,
-0.2089570313692093,
0.6294263601303101,
0.14887553453445435,
-0.1323106437921524,
0.5184163451194763,
-0.20018984377384186,
0.38240310549736023,
-0.7009108662605286,
-0.10553422570228577,
-0.46228426694869995,
0.28094619512557983,
0.20826825499534607,
-0.23953889310359955,
0.4076823592185974,
0.33659154176712036,
0.8483651280403137,
0.02360355108976364,
0.8443878293037415,
-0.08861362189054489,
0.3928755819797516,
-0.11098752170801163,
0.13854463398456573,
-0.4124476909637451,
-0.13098271191120148,
-0.16175302863121033,
-0.7800824046134949,
-1.1074330806732178,
0.47956645488739014,
-0.17542292177677155,
-0.10979524999856949,
0.7677701115608215,
0.5588595271110535,
-0.025705216452479362,
-0.4392716586589813,
0.95556640625,
-0.18157298862934113,
0.20382727682590485,
0.9257376194000244,
0.5106158256530762,
-0.40568631887435913,
0.9563473463058472,
-0.6104347109794617,
-0.5985654592514038,
-0.34594979882240295,
-0.9712303280830383,
-0.602871298789978,
-0.2187248319387436,
-0.8669883608818054,
0.12409400939941406,
0.20188592374324799,
1.015878677368164,
0.828674852848053,
-0.7726958990097046,
-0.03292253240942955,
0.11078252643346786,
0.11689364910125732,
-0.5701997876167297,
-0.24167482554912567,
0.10183965414762497,
-0.6404396891593933,
-0.7471187710762024,
0.001118144835345447,
0.620344340801239,
0.056025706231594086,
0.04303465783596039,
0.3419035077095032,
-0.11442084610462189,
-0.021816086024045944,
0.8035228252410889,
0.7709237337112427,
-0.1251363605260849,
-0.48057103157043457,
-0.09928983449935913,
-0.09699731320142746,
0.3451478183269501,
0.7206420302391052,
-0.9019492864608765,
0.6450435519218445,
0.2856002449989319,
0.5689406991004944,
0.5509095191955566,
-0.2818629741668701,
0.21095284819602966,
-1.0926772356033325,
0.15137413144111633,
0.302861750125885,
0.17229920625686646,
0.03368743509054184,
-0.16195383667945862,
0.4711207151412964,
0.33817097544670105,
-0.5465530157089233,
-0.7338966131210327,
0.3603436350822449,
-1.072607159614563,
-0.4732300639152527,
0.9685797691345215,
-0.5095909833908081,
-0.23727352917194366,
-0.46606236696243286,
-0.13020747900009155,
0.09499166905879974,
-0.22530899941921234,
0.675290048122406,
0.48517704010009766,
-0.5097635388374329,
-0.2714724838733673,
-0.4861363172531128,
-0.23628388345241547,
0.20838551223278046,
-0.6519864201545715,
-0.09146132320165634,
0.6362645626068115,
0.23552078008651733,
0.2615997791290283,
0.5709247589111328,
0.16196729242801666,
0.34100842475891113,
0.3345063030719757,
0.19850829243659973,
0.049678985029459,
-0.6847270727157593,
-0.39639532566070557,
0.3464227020740509,
-0.1608959436416626,
-0.4990032911300659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03861v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03861v2
|
Designing Informative Metrics for Few-Shot Example Selection
| 2024-03-06T17:11:38 | 2024-03-19T19:51:09 |
Rishabh Adiga, Lakshminarayanan Subramanian, Varun Chandrasekaran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Pretrained language models (PLMs) have shown remarkable few-shot learning
capabilities when provided with properly formatted examples. However, selecting
the "best" examples remains an open challenge. We propose a complexity-based
prompt selection approach for sequence tagging tasks. This approach avoids the
training of a dedicated model for selection of examples, and instead uses
certain metrics to align the syntactico-semantic complexity of test sentences
and examples. We use both sentence- and word-level metrics to match the
complexity of examples to the (test) sentence being considered. Our results
demonstrate that our approach extracts greater performance from PLMs: it
achieves state-of-the-art performance on few-shot NER, achieving a 5% absolute
improvement in F1 score on the CoNLL2003 dataset for GPT-4. We also see large
gains of upto 28.85 points (F1/Acc.) in smaller models like GPT-j-6B.
|
[
-0.42285242676734924,
-0.4648856222629547,
0.6363841891288757,
-0.0461750291287899,
-0.5724802613258362,
-0.22622692584991455,
0.09281131625175476,
-0.08292631804943085,
-0.10881596803665161,
0.015302881598472595,
-0.6060791611671448,
-0.6781947016716003,
-0.4980652928352356,
0.2872953414916992,
0.1814947873353958,
1.1020121574401855,
0.15973937511444092,
-0.04060664027929306,
-0.12387390434741974,
-0.08483277261257172,
-0.8185719847679138,
-0.06902371346950531,
-0.6833060383796692,
-0.13550756871700287,
0.5564548969268799,
0.617480993270874,
0.24708977341651917,
0.7164618372917175,
0.7573496699333191,
0.29530471563339233,
-0.06892777979373932,
0.34283897280693054,
-0.1806846559047699,
0.2336723804473877,
-0.14450816810131073,
-0.7263228297233582,
-0.2716503143310547,
0.1377398520708084,
0.7052339911460876,
0.624695897102356,
0.20647487044334412,
0.15122811496257782,
-0.07587432861328125,
0.42444106936454773,
-0.35526829957962036,
0.18172957003116608,
-0.5448631048202515,
0.08986885100603104,
-0.30636006593704224,
-0.15405088663101196,
-0.44440072774887085,
-0.2768552303314209,
0.1973894089460373,
-0.5753363370895386,
0.07663164287805557,
0.41948312520980835,
0.6022868752479553,
0.46434906125068665,
0.05077514424920082,
-0.23175963759422302,
-0.4595542848110199,
0.7914340496063232,
-0.9011307954788208,
-0.16471923887729645,
0.27837830781936646,
0.3911629617214203,
-0.229465052485466,
-0.5857070684432983,
-0.40498125553131104,
-0.06279821693897247,
-0.1962607353925705,
0.12813420593738556,
-0.23270881175994873,
0.1527969241142273,
0.7625676989555359,
0.08343347162008286,
-1.0598599910736084,
0.475136935710907,
-0.030827276408672333,
-0.16808970272541046,
0.33529970049858093,
0.3985618054866791,
0.09813082963228226,
-0.48991790413856506,
-0.27817538380622864,
-0.09737042337656021,
-0.5782619118690491,
0.2734455466270447,
0.4496384859085083,
0.6153686046600342,
-0.012715122662484646,
0.5698641538619995,
-0.2955259680747986,
1.1087383031845093,
-0.09181720018386841,
-0.3425547182559967,
0.3233916163444519,
-0.4249785244464874,
-0.08307952433824539,
-0.21843375265598297,
0.8415054678916931,
0.14346422255039215,
-0.031809478998184204,
0.2238292247056961,
-0.22655892372131348,
0.005888230167329311,
-0.09147237241268158,
-0.8826191425323486,
-0.40771108865737915,
0.11927241832017899,
-0.1877472996711731,
0.14206738770008087,
0.21938371658325195,
-0.7460516691207886,
-0.27403807640075684,
0.0886598527431488,
0.6694140434265137,
-0.6770369410514832,
0.23553898930549622,
0.018674064427614212,
-0.5090845227241516,
0.362962007522583,
0.27595818042755127,
-0.47582098841667175,
0.02420113980770111,
0.6870867013931274,
1.1269689798355103,
-0.15923920273780823,
-0.186105415225029,
-0.9863695502281189,
-0.3059656322002411,
-0.16483668982982635,
0.9191898703575134,
-0.7280798554420471,
-0.31505051255226135,
-0.31276917457580566,
-0.34589436650276184,
0.038660094141960144,
-0.4908202290534973,
0.5419312715530396,
-0.35016709566116333,
0.30188584327697754,
-0.23358795046806335,
-0.8544645309448242,
-0.015346987172961235,
0.2188168317079544,
-0.5595576167106628,
1.0024690628051758,
0.13121642172336578,
-0.7746037840843201,
0.6363333463668823,
-0.639687180519104,
-0.3637295365333557,
0.4931570291519165,
-0.2708986699581146,
-0.5438433885574341,
0.022519458085298538,
0.15239287912845612,
0.7122907042503357,
0.0031271965708583593,
-0.12358376383781433,
-0.18300898373126984,
-0.5461772680282593,
-0.08468047529459,
0.013007988221943378,
0.18299038708209991,
0.2711940407752991,
-0.18421058356761932,
0.20094220340251923,
-0.82661372423172,
0.21375170350074768,
0.07220076024532318,
-0.2825835347175598,
-0.3392193913459778,
-0.1923590451478958,
-0.5940244197845459,
0.3453422486782074,
-0.05309734866023064,
-0.27959421277046204,
0.39457494020462036,
-0.7559456825256348,
0.30856117606163025,
0.48359963297843933,
0.21005555987358093,
0.6216263175010681,
-0.7701260447502136,
0.9704095125198364,
0.1869860738515854,
-0.12988318502902985,
-0.7524022459983826,
-0.5996710658073425,
-0.6467891335487366,
-0.5766494274139404,
0.4752977788448334,
0.7568994164466858,
-0.8752881288528442,
0.8349599242210388,
-0.23730051517486572,
-0.6587502360343933,
-0.5331233739852905,
0.32717421650886536,
0.5213792324066162,
0.5871460437774658,
0.30963751673698425,
-0.7048385143280029,
-0.4348132610321045,
-0.7789428234100342,
-0.2746627926826477,
-0.4084804058074951,
-0.039951350539922714,
0.3382958173751831,
0.4396424889564514,
0.38756489753723145,
1.2023272514343262,
-0.5219885110855103,
-0.2196694314479828,
-0.6557074189186096,
0.5385056138038635,
0.6231864094734192,
0.6028860807418823,
0.4493733048439026,
-0.445088267326355,
-0.27351444959640503,
-0.42302805185317993,
-0.26276880502700806,
-0.3526836931705475,
-0.28395727276802063,
-0.06629665195941925,
-0.08388106524944305,
0.12865562736988068,
-0.7068354487419128,
0.3182833790779114,
0.013353596441447735,
0.03346928581595421,
0.405219703912735,
0.03320181369781494,
-0.12169540673494339,
-0.8156089782714844,
0.14791256189346313,
0.2287069708108902,
-0.5495315790176392,
-0.4662843346595764,
-0.3205505907535553,
-0.21496833860874176,
0.05517544969916344,
-0.7743279337882996,
0.6550183892250061,
-0.31228959560394287,
-0.20766514539718628,
-0.07597579061985016,
0.12314508855342865,
-0.07352087646722794,
0.3923923671245575,
-0.029558047652244568,
0.6000009179115295,
0.4592638909816742,
-0.5945987701416016,
0.07623135298490524,
0.32763275504112244,
-0.6638617515563965,
0.46172457933425903,
-0.5054441094398499,
0.27028384804725647,
-0.33690345287323,
0.2473313957452774,
-1.3458988666534424,
-0.2329627275466919,
0.2102062851190567,
-0.5050293207168579,
0.2553440034389496,
-0.36180543899536133,
-0.6272554397583008,
-0.4299507439136505,
-0.3756653666496277,
0.27096128463745117,
0.9139305353164673,
-0.2611148953437805,
0.274443119764328,
-0.0845302864909172,
-0.39973029494285583,
-0.4343710243701935,
-0.36715400218963623,
-0.3165070116519928,
-0.33314821124076843,
-0.2700531780719757,
0.017986007034778595,
-0.2870838940143585,
0.05701334774494171,
-0.38889080286026,
-0.2156819850206375,
0.18918411433696747,
0.21483232080936432,
0.23175393044948578,
0.17193202674388885,
-0.32972875237464905,
0.28075191378593445,
-0.0033053304068744183,
-0.13480444252490997,
-0.3873220682144165,
-0.2540051341056824,
0.5890962481498718,
-0.16755279898643494,
-0.18785659968852997,
-0.5777010917663574,
0.41615787148475647,
-0.20186249911785126,
-0.2155512571334839,
0.2876484990119934,
0.6512319445610046,
-0.12629984319210052,
-0.6499868035316467,
-0.24167980253696442,
-0.10620325058698654,
-0.4434851109981537,
0.19811628758907318,
-0.47793784737586975,
-1.0511879920959473,
0.24573136866092682,
-0.2473684698343277,
-0.030657200142741203,
0.22670294344425201,
0.3325452506542206,
-0.2936616539955139,
0.8870564699172974,
0.4800666272640228,
-0.02447364293038845,
0.6915178894996643,
-0.2078515738248825,
0.1305723637342453,
-0.43700864911079407,
0.07224930077791214,
-0.5039456486701965,
-0.41742441058158875,
-0.48412251472473145,
-0.3830104470252991,
0.38045641779899597,
0.3083729147911072,
-0.3754323422908783,
0.30656325817108154,
-0.37038740515708923,
0.7861189842224121,
0.6385608911514282,
0.008261044509708881,
0.20971466600894928,
-0.3840334117412567,
-0.2581237256526947,
-0.07537345588207245,
-1.0047965049743652,
-0.7543472051620483,
0.6792799830436707,
0.1258866786956787,
0.7376506924629211,
0.12446754425764084,
0.9219790101051331,
0.1375744789838791,
0.08757001161575317,
-0.9623746275901794,
0.6755542159080505,
-0.3267630636692047,
-0.3241845667362213,
-0.26431480050086975,
-0.3523919880390167,
-0.8647013306617737,
0.10192615538835526,
-0.09195486456155777,
-0.6516355872154236,
-0.2188110649585724,
0.2494950145483017,
-0.9510738253593445,
-0.06787850707769394,
-0.7383527159690857,
0.9309504628181458,
0.009520094841718674,
-0.06489766389131546,
0.31703662872314453,
-1.1385843753814697,
0.24793466925621033,
0.043558865785598755,
0.01646582968533039,
-0.310087651014328,
-0.18863512575626373,
0.7421947121620178,
-0.2532607913017273,
0.913254976272583,
-0.24874520301818848,
0.44134896993637085,
0.3584156036376953,
0.16690464317798615,
0.47544926404953003,
-0.1868450939655304,
-0.07311224937438965,
-0.26064518094062805,
-0.20544129610061646,
-0.31967058777809143,
-0.6357102990150452,
0.3795093297958374,
-0.375671923160553,
-0.6818332672119141,
-0.45523446798324585,
-0.44363248348236084,
-0.32161709666252136,
0.21259626746177673,
0.4735852777957916,
0.36457470059394836,
-0.16434133052825928,
-0.16050533950328827,
0.44551900029182434,
-0.2712581157684326,
0.8043971061706543,
0.43121856451034546,
0.23069292306900024,
-0.18206582963466644,
0.580525279045105,
-0.007095622830092907,
0.2256854772567749,
0.6029170155525208,
0.23897598683834076,
-0.2543448507785797,
-0.7817424535751343,
-0.2591645121574402,
0.27673929929733276,
-0.9475852251052856,
-0.6480933427810669,
-0.6257433891296387,
0.057280831038951874,
-0.34667226672172546,
-0.07118185609579086,
-0.044138774275779724,
-0.4056660830974579,
-0.5320700407028198,
-0.1525546759366989,
0.22782282531261444,
0.6414124965667725,
0.031885161995887756,
0.7723367214202881,
-0.7607007622718811,
0.15684553980827332,
0.21385212242603302,
0.260444700717926,
-0.29745566844940186,
-0.7823535799980164,
0.12952403724193573,
-0.7006775736808777,
-0.2423914223909378,
-0.71446692943573,
0.4008432626724243,
0.504291832447052,
0.5385190844535828,
0.304924339056015,
-0.02878262661397457,
0.6660341620445251,
-0.7869447469711304,
0.9095295667648315,
0.18323199450969696,
-0.9703481793403625,
1.0044742822647095,
-0.11396773159503937,
0.7121926546096802,
0.7593245506286621,
0.6672341227531433,
-0.2650468349456787,
-0.379600465297699,
-0.6181113123893738,
-0.6412354111671448,
0.7690659165382385,
0.011487849056720734,
-0.03377973660826683,
-0.19816617667675018,
0.3088606297969818,
0.44369807839393616,
0.15273432433605194,
-0.49667537212371826,
-0.14337781071662903,
0.10015573352575302,
-0.41451865434646606,
-0.20050007104873657,
0.000001698032747299294,
0.21019521355628967,
-0.08618022501468658,
0.5051153898239136,
-0.3893970847129822,
0.010020637884736061,
0.2456052601337433,
-0.1931801736354828,
0.24250316619873047,
0.5813049077987671,
0.5778288245201111,
0.4777885973453522,
-0.09816350042819977,
0.30883049964904785,
0.01709733158349991,
0.00796439591795206,
0.2798018753528595,
0.04526115581393242,
0.009356101974844933,
0.22954680025577545,
0.5035774111747742,
0.9228138327598572,
0.07976115494966507,
-0.7573268413543701,
0.8849561214447021,
0.25057798624038696,
0.16082312166690826,
-0.007025890983641148,
0.39424484968185425,
-0.3781011998653412,
0.3416178524494171,
0.06381092220544815,
-0.01412102859467268,
0.18178224563598633,
-0.22755855321884155,
0.4979223310947418,
0.46150416135787964,
-0.15581555664539337,
-0.383337140083313,
0.31214797496795654,
0.07695068418979645,
-0.3932337462902069,
0.3395389914512634,
-0.8893144726753235,
-0.4396081268787384,
0.558830976486206,
0.4586183428764343,
0.5521039962768555,
-0.1546805053949356,
0.2898370921611786,
0.5960242748260498,
0.23162081837654114,
-0.3263273537158966,
0.45385438203811646,
-0.06745923310518265,
-0.5872508883476257,
-0.475899875164032,
-0.6335717439651489,
-0.32347729802131653,
0.16253536939620972,
-0.46254998445510864,
0.5484445691108704,
-0.8066646456718445,
-0.3279222249984741,
0.19925753772258759,
0.08315546065568924,
-1.0105302333831787,
0.07870767265558243,
0.2654896676540375,
0.8646906614303589,
-1.000124454498291,
0.6284320950508118,
0.5930888652801514,
-0.5175257921218872,
-0.8422117233276367,
-0.2973407804965973,
0.1061374843120575,
-0.6375946402549744,
0.7714972496032715,
0.3966675102710724,
0.1408262997865677,
0.21284501254558563,
-0.7184979319572449,
-0.5201098322868347,
1.1119288206100464,
0.2166224867105484,
-0.766440212726593,
-0.06192212551832199,
-0.19456203281879425,
0.4393234848976135,
-0.6063162684440613,
0.5493474006652832,
0.8011711239814758,
0.27045726776123047,
0.38424572348594666,
-0.956863284111023,
-0.004848586395382881,
-0.09180442988872528,
0.17895394563674927,
0.29252195358276367,
-0.44409582018852234,
0.6655213236808777,
-0.38494691252708435,
-0.4531935155391693,
0.46605774760246277,
0.5726498961448669,
0.3708115220069885,
0.335309773683548,
0.6067567467689514,
0.6705148220062256,
0.8504862189292908,
0.032703377306461334,
1.007737398147583,
0.2749594449996948,
0.05114373192191124,
1.527610421180725,
-0.335396945476532,
0.8398418426513672,
0.3167204260826111,
-0.2766558527946472,
0.4912157654762268,
0.7861263751983643,
-0.22870926558971405,
0.6183151006698608,
0.5166534185409546,
-0.150558739900589,
-0.4608147442340851,
-0.229327991604805,
-0.01695982739329338,
0.5537710189819336,
0.16832059621810913,
-0.3354131281375885,
-0.3107064962387085,
-0.12281683832406998,
0.02080010622739792,
-0.1571887731552124,
-0.2998531460762024,
1.134208083152771,
0.17918172478675842,
-0.726913571357727,
0.19909098744392395,
-0.10099297016859055,
0.8605328798294067,
-0.7804054021835327,
-0.20575423538684845,
-0.1908073127269745,
-0.3778514862060547,
-0.1385248452425003,
-0.7944150567054749,
-0.060176510363817215,
0.16276822984218597,
-0.05118560045957565,
0.027700165286660194,
0.7486253976821899,
-0.3708837926387787,
-0.0843643918633461,
-0.32993829250335693,
0.9321154356002808,
0.5378081202507019,
0.16006162762641907,
-0.53092360496521,
-0.15781459212303162,
-0.412150114774704,
0.06539388746023178,
0.14423048496246338,
0.3450157344341278,
0.14842240512371063,
0.4385885000228882,
0.38646379113197327,
0.1467410922050476,
0.031629692763090134,
0.12087292969226837,
0.67292720079422,
-0.830948531627655,
-0.7668035626411438,
-0.9829469323158264,
0.596461832523346,
0.04541374370455742,
-0.5187007784843445,
0.5022999048233032,
0.5429446697235107,
0.843616783618927,
-0.05745919048786163,
0.8258063793182373,
0.020622728392481804,
0.4778447449207306,
-0.6648869514465332,
0.11035627126693726,
-0.299181193113327,
0.37177762389183044,
-0.32879677414894104,
-0.7589370608329773,
-0.582322895526886,
0.5696114301681519,
-0.4417772889137268,
0.03832238167524338,
0.8086362481117249,
0.7930784225463867,
0.2312433272600174,
-0.185797318816185,
0.4630815088748932,
-0.1369761824607849,
0.24508459866046906,
0.9371480345726013,
1.06330144405365,
-0.15469500422477722,
0.3805679678916931,
0.021019289270043373,
-0.32388538122177124,
-0.023748639971017838,
-1.267328143119812,
-1.0589030981063843,
-0.5868380069732666,
-0.4101864695549011,
0.07189324498176575,
-0.24280427396297455,
1.2704232931137085,
0.7794209718704224,
-0.647972047328949,
0.14010795950889587,
0.15557214617729187,
0.18271423876285553,
0.07164938747882843,
-0.1513376235961914,
0.01900189369916916,
-0.7737709879875183,
-0.5368823409080505,
0.41307222843170166,
0.3910498023033142,
0.34409379959106445,
0.19614067673683167,
0.23449882864952087,
-0.07195854932069778,
-0.03800366073846817,
0.44789373874664307,
0.2309655398130417,
-0.725058913230896,
-0.4213050901889801,
-0.2357337325811386,
-0.05274087190628052,
0.3887959122657776,
0.9643486142158508,
-0.8804751038551331,
0.3390069901943207,
0.786679208278656,
0.8301582336425781,
0.17788909375667572,
0.3084779977798462,
0.20056144893169403,
-1.2954151630401611,
0.12956015765666962,
0.652662992477417,
0.3095935583114624,
0.4096567928791046,
-0.06536070257425308,
0.3815572261810303,
0.2829659879207611,
-0.44929784536361694,
-0.7654091119766235,
0.380736380815506,
-1.2460362911224365,
-0.17968983948230743,
1.1553148031234741,
-0.48774272203445435,
-0.07886607199907303,
0.004139466676861048,
-0.09583063423633575,
0.14707599580287933,
-0.49605274200439453,
0.1518879383802414,
0.8441837430000305,
-0.29633021354675293,
-0.3233276903629303,
-0.3673206865787506,
0.7387759685516357,
0.5618448257446289,
-0.9487500786781311,
-0.44667568802833557,
0.5860695838928223,
0.2458541989326477,
0.02356569841504097,
0.738991916179657,
0.1895153671503067,
0.14022549986839294,
-0.2437869906425476,
-0.24958784878253937,
0.08448097854852676,
-0.3623332679271698,
-0.848779022693634,
0.1661531627178192,
0.47413328289985657,
-0.16256581246852875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03857v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03857v2
|
Emojinize: Enriching Any Text with Emoji Translations
| 2024-03-06T17:06:17 | 2024-03-07T14:09:00 |
Lars Henning Klein, Roland Aydin, Robert West
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Emoji have become ubiquitous in written communication, on the Web and beyond.
They can emphasize or clarify emotions, add details to conversations, or simply
serve decorative purposes. This casual use, however, barely scratches the
surface of the expressive power of emoji. To further unleash this power, we
present Emojinize, a method for translating arbitrary text phrases into
sequences of one or more emoji without requiring human input. By leveraging the
power of large language models, Emojinize can choose appropriate emoji by
disambiguating based on context (eg, cricket-bat vs bat) and can express
complex concepts compositionally by combining multiple emoji (eq, "Emojinize"
is translated to input-latin-letters right-arrow grinning-face). In a cloze
test--based user study, we show that Emojinize's emoji translations increase
the human guessability of masked words by 55%, whereas human-picked emoji
translations do so by only 29%. These results suggest that emoji provide a
sufficiently rich vocabulary to accurately translate a wide variety of words.
Moreover, annotating words and phrases with Emojinize's emoji translations
opens the door to numerous downstream applications, including children learning
how to read, adults learning foreign languages, and text understanding for
people with learning disabilities.
|
[
-0.3879111111164093,
-0.8646265268325806,
0.4230048358440399,
0.4200085401535034,
-0.512055516242981,
0.16160042583942413,
-0.47510653734207153,
-0.5355387330055237,
0.4048832952976227,
0.4314374625682831,
-0.5824182629585266,
-0.23840546607971191,
-0.696331799030304,
0.3792565166950226,
-0.2609328627586365,
0.8346293568611145,
-0.010181259363889694,
-0.033624984323978424,
-0.19042347371578217,
-0.029244404286146164,
-0.4157869815826416,
-0.17589694261550903,
-0.24173302948474884,
-0.18827231228351593,
0.5242371559143066,
0.7264976501464844,
0.7849985957145691,
0.25894734263420105,
0.6338590979576111,
0.2560080885887146,
-0.09730791300535202,
0.1464199423789978,
-0.36517199873924255,
0.28125429153442383,
0.030987171456217766,
-0.6560574173927307,
0.05062085762619972,
0.17858216166496277,
0.1638394445180893,
0.6148340702056885,
0.0821181908249855,
0.03384048491716385,
-0.17850954830646515,
0.5127730965614319,
-0.8425605893135071,
0.031957682222127914,
-0.4302235543727875,
0.17586809396743774,
-0.3164365589618683,
-0.1439865082502365,
-0.3215506970882416,
-0.4908384084701538,
-0.21116483211517334,
-0.5187077522277832,
-0.40286922454833984,
0.06664915382862091,
0.5463789105415344,
0.35768765211105347,
-0.24523793160915375,
-0.21476660668849945,
-0.5062572360038757,
0.7339507341384888,
-0.38533395528793335,
0.2619388997554779,
0.4409402012825012,
0.21518881618976593,
0.012070591561496258,
-0.6022827625274658,
-0.6179980039596558,
-0.27477070689201355,
-0.14778363704681396,
0.30684831738471985,
0.023459255695343018,
0.14960138499736786,
0.3038126230239868,
0.4737468957901001,
-0.41789424419403076,
-0.17174841463565826,
0.1599736213684082,
0.1292952597141266,
0.5410725474357605,
-0.1974516659975052,
1.0985310077667236,
-0.1575644314289093,
-0.1433725357055664,
-0.2664628028869629,
-0.5685290098190308,
-0.22619391977787018,
-0.00020131254859734327,
0.07396773993968964,
0.03923691436648369,
0.8487732410430908,
-0.1884913295507431,
0.7256814241409302,
-0.25351011753082275,
-0.09484252333641052,
0.257704496383667,
-0.3626360297203064,
-0.24796351790428162,
-0.039402320981025696,
0.6359383463859558,
0.530485987663269,
0.5064519643783569,
-0.42289498448371887,
0.011437670327723026,
0.09024213999509811,
0.09727048873901367,
-0.8122335076332092,
-0.049281906336545944,
0.2502010464668274,
-0.07093142718076706,
-0.3368064761161804,
0.042442917823791504,
-0.8041176795959473,
-0.5597736835479736,
0.07739895582199097,
0.42331621050834656,
-0.4006931185722351,
0.0713639110326767,
-0.09413490444421768,
-0.6326197981834412,
-0.05171078443527222,
0.29773807525634766,
-0.9111403822898865,
-0.1480204463005066,
0.3501763939857483,
0.8342736959457397,
0.5110234618186951,
-0.1813230961561203,
-0.26180264353752136,
0.1688840091228485,
-0.3610912263393402,
0.5721035003662109,
-0.8389987349510193,
-0.5146801471710205,
0.22535449266433716,
-0.09220712631940842,
0.05314162001013756,
-0.3107914924621582,
0.6269170641899109,
0.005174250807613134,
-0.0730433389544487,
-0.0618034303188324,
-0.630605936050415,
0.09855490177869797,
0.07387391477823257,
-0.6505873203277588,
0.6146379113197327,
-0.06075907126069069,
-0.7953762412071228,
0.2850206792354584,
-0.8728092908859253,
-0.7318333983421326,
0.23329003155231476,
-0.002380040707066655,
-0.3341337740421295,
0.48399633169174194,
0.39404815435409546,
0.566349446773529,
-0.22108833491802216,
-0.3276820480823517,
-0.2329370379447937,
-0.21508929133415222,
0.6427907943725586,
-0.06439786404371262,
0.6623454093933105,
0.3125721514225006,
-0.25738993287086487,
-0.17209547758102417,
-0.35401982069015503,
0.04205009341239929,
0.14294759929180145,
-0.2550634741783142,
-0.5400056838989258,
-0.15875934064388275,
0.5436630249023438,
-0.0702572837471962,
0.2924937605857849,
-0.8314007520675659,
0.3094640076160431,
-0.5812349319458008,
0.692019522190094,
0.21778935194015503,
-0.05757312476634979,
0.7089902758598328,
-0.19344305992126465,
0.550824761390686,
-0.3168657124042511,
0.3907543122768402,
-0.37685707211494446,
-0.9248491525650024,
-0.5642597675323486,
-0.4439717233181,
0.47517868876457214,
0.8177937269210815,
-1.052451491355896,
0.5955080986022949,
-0.5410308241844177,
-0.4458411633968353,
-0.7791566848754883,
0.3003380000591278,
0.27260443568229675,
-0.06256410479545593,
0.3240012228488922,
-0.10200197249650955,
-0.3630366623401642,
-0.8570021986961365,
-0.6617689728736877,
0.08723220974206924,
-0.08777853101491928,
0.22132918238639832,
0.5670221447944641,
-0.21279321610927582,
0.5859005451202393,
-0.46890681982040405,
-0.631556510925293,
-0.4249127507209778,
0.27655133605003357,
-0.35697174072265625,
0.3308352828025818,
0.45956429839134216,
-1.1517471075057983,
-0.594639003276825,
0.18204595148563385,
-0.5782940983772278,
-0.10191591084003448,
-0.41932737827301025,
-0.4174976646900177,
-0.2565461993217468,
0.5230709314346313,
-0.4372745156288147,
0.5877861976623535,
0.5576903820037842,
-0.2957802712917328,
-0.5190749168395996,
0.003140100510790944,
0.45947501063346863,
-1.2276694774627686,
0.1953488439321518,
-0.09867595136165619,
-0.33507052063941956,
-0.673416793346405,
0.5133715271949768,
0.10050594061613083,
-0.1472579389810562,
-0.42946484684944153,
0.638785183429718,
-0.5216559767723083,
0.2052634060382843,
-0.23065108060836792,
0.6080415844917297,
-0.019801065325737,
0.10457023978233337,
-0.3010667562484741,
0.6130223274230957,
0.3210199773311615,
-0.12841492891311646,
0.2745090425014496,
0.49980422854423523,
-0.30801695585250854,
0.49268969893455505,
-0.249385803937912,
0.10852963477373123,
-0.0315636545419693,
0.1345541775226593,
-1.0246942043304443,
-0.6022673845291138,
0.527587354183197,
-0.6374938488006592,
0.3940143585205078,
0.06662099808454514,
-0.6995105743408203,
-0.24019189178943634,
-0.20947225391864777,
0.2848406136035919,
0.580053985118866,
-0.5611915588378906,
0.7633168697357178,
0.5790383219718933,
0.04942042753100395,
-0.32723748683929443,
-1.2500499486923218,
0.4996660649776459,
0.03112952783703804,
-0.5401837825775146,
0.3030017912387848,
-0.23507216572761536,
-0.05482770875096321,
-0.1309162825345993,
0.317854642868042,
-0.29165345430374146,
0.531527042388916,
0.27615267038345337,
-0.08993993699550629,
0.3390601873397827,
0.30808478593826294,
0.42079058289527893,
0.16773273050785065,
-0.36438873410224915,
0.05184446647763252,
0.4045659899711609,
0.11736425757408142,
-0.1311771720647812,
-0.32292309403419495,
0.6469342708587646,
0.5091099739074707,
-0.2818478047847748,
0.7651345133781433,
0.7026293277740479,
-0.4817865788936615,
0.0854194238781929,
-0.4906110465526581,
-0.11146131157875061,
-0.3857339024543762,
0.1550862193107605,
-0.5010022521018982,
-0.9151626229286194,
0.19925788044929504,
-0.24873778223991394,
-0.0031343239825218916,
0.14115284383296967,
0.19414076209068298,
0.13421137630939484,
1.2728734016418457,
0.4187631607055664,
-0.10748002678155899,
0.7028042674064636,
0.08078203350305557,
0.43041089177131653,
-0.8364838361740112,
-0.12777355313301086,
-0.4179677665233612,
-0.36856746673583984,
-0.49238321185112,
-0.3384242355823517,
0.07630176097154617,
0.18139316141605377,
0.3906640410423279,
0.4451003670692444,
-0.6812703013420105,
0.7409542798995972,
0.3239741027355194,
0.445983350276947,
0.15066128969192505,
0.22364558279514313,
0.1326349973678589,
-0.12734608352184296,
-0.5023424029350281,
-0.2787536680698395,
0.7910493612289429,
0.04886747524142265,
0.7286049723625183,
0.32991597056388855,
1.0403112173080444,
0.15811672806739807,
0.7541574239730835,
-0.9867417812347412,
0.539511501789093,
-0.3502921164035797,
-0.4597163498401642,
-0.29008036851882935,
-0.30485907196998596,
-0.977627694606781,
0.053339503705501556,
-0.5388010740280151,
-0.8036124110221863,
0.016525041311979294,
0.0461115799844265,
-0.07020539045333862,
0.08899269253015518,
-0.7914872765541077,
0.7669376730918884,
-0.29519301652908325,
-0.049530841410160065,
-0.2271926999092102,
-0.5540763735771179,
0.17794862389564514,
-0.055071376264095306,
0.5213938355445862,
-0.0963108241558075,
-0.3314683139324188,
0.35879096388816833,
-0.13728269934654236,
0.91489577293396,
0.20609760284423828,
0.10258772224187851,
0.1889575868844986,
0.03358134627342224,
0.13712769746780396,
0.0809730663895607,
0.27696922421455383,
0.2251616269350052,
-0.2851082682609558,
-0.3937191367149353,
-0.9598289132118225,
0.7169588804244995,
-0.5016798377037048,
-0.4161413609981537,
-0.29374274611473083,
-0.20912331342697144,
0.14191502332687378,
0.34653252363204956,
0.4561019539833069,
0.17440226674079895,
-0.4681535065174103,
0.1395169496536255,
0.3525058329105377,
-0.007763700559735298,
0.31259140372276306,
0.02118862420320511,
-0.331721693277359,
-0.6145266890525818,
0.8853802680969238,
0.004536831751465797,
0.021174950525164604,
0.8271099328994751,
0.2693312466144562,
-0.28740283846855164,
-0.01708664558827877,
-0.5820591449737549,
0.2357906699180603,
-0.8569318056106567,
-0.11585185676813126,
-0.6839544773101807,
0.19289405643939972,
-0.42808303236961365,
-0.4694410264492035,
0.003449302865192294,
-0.7446566820144653,
-0.37018057703971863,
-0.026299910619854927,
0.5853185057640076,
0.49325552582740784,
-0.18631313741207123,
0.1564231514930725,
-0.7860400676727295,
0.36291471123695374,
0.32575973868370056,
-0.04653269797563553,
-0.5206905603408813,
-0.23093611001968384,
-0.28477802872657776,
0.08413548022508621,
-0.12928111851215363,
-1.1043953895568848,
0.3609626591205597,
0.6435992121696472,
0.41205233335494995,
0.31208810210227966,
-0.002953674178570509,
0.6127021908760071,
-0.5681664943695068,
0.8645765781402588,
0.4627772271633148,
-1.2501375675201416,
0.9917217493057251,
-0.031355276703834534,
0.3750778138637543,
0.6737197041511536,
0.2192309945821762,
-0.7599724531173706,
-0.6796560287475586,
-0.44585663080215454,
-0.9336565732955933,
0.24598339200019836,
0.6407905220985413,
0.4309873878955841,
-0.3718080222606659,
0.5233874917030334,
-0.3677835166454315,
0.291052907705307,
-0.4984920620918274,
-0.3357778787612915,
-0.40681153535842896,
-0.6283633708953857,
-0.3020106852054596,
0.008763425052165985,
-0.27500057220458984,
-0.23517972230911255,
0.2156117707490921,
-0.11299320310354233,
0.539650559425354,
0.16190679371356964,
-0.45479682087898254,
0.11476393043994904,
0.4217070937156677,
0.5481339693069458,
0.13758517801761627,
0.013680770993232727,
0.0448545441031456,
0.07312657684087753,
-0.5304857492446899,
0.06791763007640839,
0.0412125438451767,
-0.09321184456348419,
0.07331682741641998,
0.11258036643266678,
0.5372179746627808,
0.4749225676059723,
-0.8341512680053711,
0.7178601026535034,
-0.3314262330532074,
0.20761390030384064,
-0.29301902651786804,
0.09272672235965729,
-0.018560823053121567,
0.06539063155651093,
0.08148210495710373,
0.16744062304496765,
0.4017634689807892,
-0.7590466141700745,
0.02948751300573349,
0.29371607303619385,
-0.5276554822921753,
-0.1412794142961502,
0.6295422911643982,
0.5040406584739685,
-0.46776261925697327,
0.3711836338043213,
-0.20159435272216797,
-0.5894865989685059,
0.2899795174598694,
0.4326397776603699,
1.1910589933395386,
-0.3302913010120392,
0.41107672452926636,
0.31593942642211914,
0.5333971381187439,
-0.2961618900299072,
0.35054051876068115,
-0.1310906708240509,
-0.7951875925064087,
-0.297494113445282,
-0.4126780927181244,
-0.34850451350212097,
-0.3589112162590027,
-0.6092411875724792,
-0.0710371807217598,
-0.45076921582221985,
-0.4719710052013397,
0.07948915660381317,
-0.3877549171447754,
-0.6032212376594543,
0.4379543364048004,
0.32347536087036133,
0.6751068830490112,
-1.1473958492279053,
0.48567473888397217,
1.03831148147583,
-0.806405782699585,
-0.3156455159187317,
0.21008366346359253,
-0.27823173999786377,
-0.6023973226547241,
0.4454428553581238,
0.5069343447685242,
0.03527367487549782,
0.29536667466163635,
-0.9206892848014832,
-0.5795838832855225,
0.47177648544311523,
0.23385171592235565,
-0.24797272682189941,
0.37786945700645447,
0.10234580934047699,
0.5582770705223083,
-0.4200202524662018,
0.5718837380409241,
0.4645783603191376,
0.7526879906654358,
-0.19715392589569092,
-0.5289208292961121,
0.2437436729669571,
-0.578471839427948,
0.3733016848564148,
0.25565025210380554,
-0.3498544991016388,
0.47402361035346985,
-0.30523064732551575,
-0.5916217565536499,
0.47668129205703735,
0.4817694425582886,
-0.29283279180526733,
0.02486039698123932,
0.2583676874637604,
0.3827134668827057,
0.6031373739242554,
-0.3114508390426636,
1.322468638420105,
-0.5779777765274048,
0.15206746757030487,
0.754525363445282,
0.25291702151298523,
1.081154465675354,
0.5670195817947388,
0.21886199712753296,
0.46614253520965576,
0.41906946897506714,
-0.05512682721018791,
0.44075751304626465,
-0.017706265673041344,
-0.4284653961658478,
-0.6326659321784973,
-0.36350804567337036,
0.016071852296590805,
0.3632550835609436,
0.5998662114143372,
-0.39415764808654785,
0.08851557970046997,
0.5002580285072327,
0.19725826382637024,
0.22192230820655823,
0.06854996085166931,
0.6568873524665833,
0.22758406400680542,
-0.7259641289710999,
0.33040210604667664,
-0.11099457740783691,
0.46179214119911194,
-0.17708735167980194,
-0.12445294111967087,
-0.10372987389564514,
0.12514598667621613,
-0.1733686625957489,
-0.8807408213615417,
0.07893239706754684,
-0.07740345597267151,
0.17406925559043884,
-0.06664800643920898,
0.7002415060997009,
-0.4779207408428192,
-0.6951445937156677,
0.28092214465141296,
0.3181040585041046,
0.27121710777282715,
-0.20866082608699799,
-0.8495506048202515,
-0.09946423768997192,
0.08232666552066803,
-0.05299891158938408,
0.3031170666217804,
0.38429713249206543,
0.353330135345459,
0.755786657333374,
0.43190112709999084,
-0.0998346358537674,
0.08137662708759308,
0.29314905405044556,
0.7197301983833313,
-0.5363191366195679,
-0.3583211898803711,
-0.7120867371559143,
0.6038587689399719,
-0.39392349123954773,
-0.4370250403881073,
0.9153302907943726,
0.284537672996521,
0.5954331755638123,
-0.22116947174072266,
1.0563346147537231,
-0.1610141396522522,
0.29726603627204895,
-0.5445463061332703,
0.7529624700546265,
-0.9393645524978638,
-0.08969679474830627,
-0.33071959018707275,
-0.7331352233886719,
-0.6943030953407288,
0.9133370518684387,
-0.0595051646232605,
0.0007331573870033026,
0.578000009059906,
0.551575779914856,
0.21250568330287933,
0.09668753296136856,
0.5083434581756592,
0.13613392412662506,
-0.012056618928909302,
0.2709467113018036,
0.8061872720718384,
-0.6848006248474121,
0.3419964909553528,
-0.2829802334308624,
-0.47503241896629333,
-0.43214845657348633,
-0.5340251922607422,
-1.3095346689224243,
-0.40008530020713806,
-0.5270719528198242,
-0.2431487739086151,
0.08211956173181534,
0.7133727669715881,
0.33593058586120605,
-0.5961372256278992,
0.07585250586271286,
-0.14678803086280823,
0.18872366845607758,
-0.20685093104839325,
-0.16150997579097748,
-0.057853393256664276,
-0.42056533694267273,
-0.8584311604499817,
0.46299493312835693,
0.3046800494194031,
0.24681594967842102,
-0.06353435665369034,
0.2734908163547516,
-0.09547600150108337,
0.5558140277862549,
0.6540977358818054,
0.20889809727668762,
-0.6619176864624023,
-0.3430635929107666,
-0.0029524308629333973,
-0.10589694231748581,
-0.011878241784870625,
0.8157301545143127,
-0.3349281847476959,
0.8121659159660339,
0.7497065663337708,
0.5105005502700806,
0.3037704527378082,
-0.19083790481090546,
0.4339452087879181,
-0.6991358995437622,
0.2630031108856201,
0.07383749634027481,
0.44529375433921814,
0.6106835603713989,
-0.41379889845848083,
0.5557973384857178,
0.08934178948402405,
-0.42097169160842896,
-0.6230672597885132,
0.40438711643218994,
-0.7820701599121094,
-0.48559799790382385,
1.0021556615829468,
-0.16039513051509857,
-0.5510612726211548,
-0.1688382774591446,
-0.32554659247398376,
0.29582124948501587,
-0.4043731093406677,
0.7274025678634644,
0.4165135622024536,
0.17847909033298492,
-0.24534547328948975,
-0.16598333418369293,
0.5355148315429688,
0.3905673325061798,
-0.9098547697067261,
-0.32461148500442505,
0.1205216571688652,
-0.020308680832386017,
0.5496153831481934,
0.3885050117969513,
0.13522851467132568,
0.1612951010465622,
0.03862587735056877,
0.27982452511787415,
0.3950425088405609,
-0.16806446015834808,
-0.2002820521593094,
-0.11832842230796814,
-0.06064079701900482,
-0.23445972800254822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03853v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03853v2
|
ShortGPT: Layers in Large Language Models are More Redundant Than You Expect
| 2024-03-06T17:04:18 | 2024-03-07T16:21:09 |
Xin Men, Mingyu Xu, Qingyu Zhang, Bingning Wang, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Xianpei Han, Weipeng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) continue to advance in performance, their
size has escalated significantly, with current LLMs containing billions or even
trillions of parameters. However, in this study, we discovered that many layers
of LLMs exhibit high similarity, and some layers play a negligible role in
network functionality. Based on this observation, we define a metric called
Block Influence (BI) to gauge the significance of each layer in LLMs. We then
propose a straightforward pruning approach: layer removal, in which we directly
delete the redundant layers in LLMs based on their BI scores. Experiments
demonstrate that our method, which we call ShortGPT, significantly outperforms
previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods in model pruning. Moreover, ShortGPT
is orthogonal to quantization-like methods, enabling further reduction in
parameters and computation. The ability to achieve better results through
simple layer removal, as opposed to more complex pruning techniques, suggests a
high degree of redundancy in the model architecture.
|
[
-0.6095597743988037,
-1.0353022813796997,
0.5574977397918701,
0.28094643354415894,
-0.5593056678771973,
0.0451107919216156,
-0.17276926338672638,
-0.5145958662033081,
0.21465815603733063,
0.5317696332931519,
-0.3260802626609802,
-0.28421682119369507,
-0.5739710330963135,
-0.16297009587287903,
-0.677603006362915,
0.9915308356285095,
0.049235448241233826,
-0.12534452974796295,
-0.1544957011938095,
0.085392065346241,
-0.45837318897247314,
-0.18701016902923584,
-0.9405746459960938,
-0.5783380270004272,
0.7449866533279419,
0.4229934811592102,
0.8264738321304321,
0.8142787218093872,
0.47544074058532715,
0.3181605041027069,
-0.35881996154785156,
-0.02821367420256138,
-0.6653447151184082,
-0.3962615728378296,
-0.21753548085689545,
-0.2186841368675232,
-0.5075422525405884,
-0.08844557404518127,
0.9328267574310303,
1.0385662317276,
-0.06726968288421631,
0.18864835798740387,
0.2279881089925766,
0.8035125732421875,
-0.31381136178970337,
0.06464559584856033,
-0.4507167339324951,
-0.34222710132598877,
-0.39225366711616516,
-0.10894569009542465,
-0.2342672348022461,
-0.3305831551551819,
0.14421705901622772,
-0.05589965358376503,
0.13690000772476196,
0.2273021638393402,
0.6598314046859741,
-0.1219809502363205,
-0.4843367338180542,
0.09586778283119202,
-0.9096361994743347,
0.7036413550376892,
-0.6621847748756409,
0.19167736172676086,
0.32707270979881287,
0.006166733335703611,
-0.08141347765922546,
-0.6428838968276978,
-0.4069727063179016,
-0.2986253798007965,
-0.17586156725883484,
-0.2594103515148163,
-0.2287229299545288,
0.20716649293899536,
0.2907414734363556,
0.22310468554496765,
-0.4022216200828552,
0.2500952184200287,
-0.8349158763885498,
-0.11523742973804474,
0.43659502267837524,
0.007586617488414049,
0.4052481949329376,
-0.36978110671043396,
-0.422154039144516,
0.17408399283885956,
-1.3242976665496826,
-0.12338422983884811,
0.48327964544296265,
0.04432905465364456,
0.18370269238948822,
0.40374308824539185,
-0.12169209122657776,
0.6663983464241028,
-0.3558209538459778,
-0.07796547561883926,
-0.05203432962298393,
-0.2772013247013092,
-0.42551130056381226,
0.059225451201200485,
0.7807903289794922,
0.11472627520561218,
0.3089878261089325,
-0.2437627911567688,
-0.23184706270694733,
-0.1932806521654129,
0.19511084258556366,
-0.8959740400314331,
-0.42927229404449463,
0.056659385561943054,
-0.5056560039520264,
-0.16682755947113037,
-0.09476342797279358,
-0.4914700984954834,
-0.23354686796665192,
-0.39114004373550415,
0.4239451587200165,
-0.44360166788101196,
-0.3970940411090851,
0.12225986272096634,
0.02370624430477619,
0.15389499068260193,
0.39457815885543823,
-0.46194136142730713,
0.5172507762908936,
1.0284881591796875,
0.920539915561676,
-0.10372374206781387,
-0.4754776060581207,
-0.4156111776828766,
0.06856846064329147,
-0.49414119124412537,
0.5506517291069031,
-0.552672803401947,
-0.32093745470046997,
-0.4406670928001404,
0.12697835266590118,
0.09224849194288254,
-0.8412583470344543,
0.5257033705711365,
-0.6333853006362915,
0.1516093760728836,
-0.48603788018226624,
-0.48120957612991333,
-0.5091860294342041,
0.2205989509820938,
-0.8263693451881409,
0.8121852278709412,
0.017747899517416954,
-0.6392486691474915,
0.011354080401360989,
-0.33974364399909973,
-0.6050886511802673,
0.1848607063293457,
0.16788199543952942,
-0.6038429141044617,
0.19226279854774475,
0.004562732297927141,
0.45267340540885925,
-0.6678003668785095,
0.32017701864242554,
-0.4800979793071747,
-0.6022247672080994,
-0.20041462779045105,
-0.28274431824684143,
0.8487353324890137,
0.11971774697303772,
-0.4205571115016937,
0.06769049912691116,
-0.9271789193153381,
0.08502500504255295,
0.07449053972959518,
-0.2845640778541565,
-0.7171407341957092,
0.10706616938114166,
-0.10070374608039856,
0.24403318762779236,
-0.13820616900920868,
-0.45477095246315,
0.06058429181575775,
-0.4286228120326996,
0.9723073840141296,
0.8041058778762817,
0.21487247943878174,
0.5804739594459534,
-0.38589948415756226,
0.4176298975944519,
-0.09073885530233383,
-0.017934219911694527,
0.3099886476993561,
-0.3245141804218292,
-0.8241960406303406,
-0.4178752601146698,
0.3697763681411743,
0.35365772247314453,
-0.5087115168571472,
0.3442438244819641,
-0.5654327869415283,
-0.5200232863426208,
-0.31525561213493347,
0.3351789116859436,
0.5815160274505615,
0.29096725583076477,
0.3504635691642761,
-0.68406742811203,
-0.4451366364955902,
-1.2773874998092651,
-0.3778756558895111,
-0.2345505952835083,
-0.006725888233631849,
0.1168980598449707,
0.5482931137084961,
-0.030292684212327003,
0.8875234723091125,
-0.20654277503490448,
-0.09901140630245209,
-0.32182982563972473,
-0.06477567553520203,
0.016522858291864395,
0.6206124424934387,
0.3688013255596161,
-0.5450450778007507,
-0.526570200920105,
0.009118729270994663,
-0.28733566403388977,
-0.1541503518819809,
0.0348539799451828,
-0.06432079523801804,
-0.3143860995769501,
0.4900238513946533,
-0.8945797085762024,
0.20990094542503357,
0.4945005476474762,
0.010059013031423092,
0.662902295589447,
0.11428466439247131,
-0.0859232023358345,
-0.6726067662239075,
0.08531931042671204,
0.05728665366768837,
-0.5231947898864746,
-0.8320509195327759,
0.0195454228669405,
0.17522655427455902,
-0.21635480225086212,
-0.4845806360244751,
0.6797597408294678,
-0.6837021112442017,
-0.15544141829013824,
-0.30409619212150574,
0.16355420649051666,
0.2017272561788559,
0.44898998737335205,
-0.2572895288467407,
0.6683440804481506,
0.3830566108226776,
-0.650566041469574,
0.39149010181427,
-0.23404373228549957,
-0.7955498695373535,
0.17341162264347076,
-0.8501290678977966,
0.2179810255765915,
-0.09168162941932678,
0.10138529539108276,
-0.8494582176208496,
0.14257411658763885,
0.24095794558525085,
0.20216047763824463,
0.23648463189601898,
-0.48392266035079956,
-0.6567479968070984,
-0.3595958352088928,
-0.1938134878873825,
0.5799452066421509,
0.6951486468315125,
-0.3977615237236023,
0.34447357058525085,
0.27930018305778503,
-0.4421711266040802,
-0.28368228673934937,
-0.8228422403335571,
0.10670147836208344,
-0.535380482673645,
-0.6826590895652771,
0.38473132252693176,
0.10353484004735947,
-0.337718665599823,
0.256166011095047,
-0.10984111577272415,
-0.12654408812522888,
0.11816077679395676,
0.13583026826381683,
-0.05054223909974098,
-0.2513643801212311,
0.18246591091156006,
-0.201824352145195,
0.12063104659318924,
0.2460344135761261,
-0.33842355012893677,
0.6781125664710999,
-0.2422584593296051,
-0.5904279947280884,
-0.46789222955703735,
0.27356183528900146,
0.5163282155990601,
-0.2993767559528351,
0.6742377281188965,
0.47393202781677246,
-0.07247202098369598,
-0.42929086089134216,
-0.6350215673446655,
-0.08637794107198715,
-0.4949461817741394,
0.6639192700386047,
-0.37876254320144653,
-0.9972232580184937,
0.6673282980918884,
-0.12155528366565704,
-0.2602677047252655,
0.14952579140663147,
0.26043829321861267,
0.07393848150968552,
0.8090153932571411,
0.5484097599983215,
-0.3579981029033661,
0.7020419836044312,
-0.19919417798519135,
0.4970407783985138,
-0.8063909411430359,
0.0072999922558665276,
-0.40380576252937317,
-0.37847399711608887,
-0.42399564385414124,
-0.42026957869529724,
0.1025153324007988,
0.5511309504508972,
-0.20706042647361755,
0.36644434928894043,
-0.28175950050354004,
0.789153516292572,
0.5686458945274353,
0.1921246349811554,
0.14405998587608337,
0.04377695173025131,
0.3060459494590759,
0.32149192690849304,
-0.6791884303092957,
-0.38230907917022705,
0.6673569083213806,
0.43841353058815,
0.5434911251068115,
0.27687308192253113,
0.7227388024330139,
0.0870441347360611,
0.1817832887172699,
-0.7721114754676819,
0.801663875579834,
-0.048693832010030746,
-0.5170683860778809,
-0.49336230754852295,
-0.7077362537384033,
-0.799064040184021,
0.375588983297348,
0.23206032812595367,
-0.5718662142753601,
0.0469353087246418,
0.0831584483385086,
-0.31702008843421936,
0.6094439029693604,
-0.9773580431938171,
0.7565909028053284,
-0.09654844552278519,
-0.5447958707809448,
-0.44010770320892334,
-0.3378868103027344,
0.5928377509117126,
-0.10557142645120621,
0.29476475715637207,
-0.3044365644454956,
0.06454246491193771,
0.8698943853378296,
-0.7620348930358887,
0.9746463894844055,
-0.13816311955451965,
0.08635982125997543,
0.6040087342262268,
0.5014486908912659,
0.8626908659934998,
-0.13390232622623444,
0.10245057940483093,
0.16151103377342224,
-0.0395963080227375,
-0.6308332681655884,
-0.5553702116012573,
0.8943800330162048,
-0.6156547665596008,
-0.8775242567062378,
0.07598190009593964,
-0.2640381157398224,
0.014022063463926315,
0.4661823511123657,
-0.19559346139431,
0.5061968564987183,
-0.22535063326358795,
0.38905131816864014,
0.40790942311286926,
-0.1665848195552826,
0.4874209761619568,
0.1645403504371643,
-0.18339093029499054,
-0.1055140569806099,
1.0066808462142944,
0.24336953461170197,
0.5355604887008667,
0.46472927927970886,
0.31760314106941223,
0.07611290365457535,
-0.8621736168861389,
0.028156083077192307,
0.41718289256095886,
-0.7014200687408447,
-0.025592384859919548,
-0.5170194506645203,
-0.3618129789829254,
-0.1726474165916443,
0.08766806870698929,
-0.5298835635185242,
-0.4707536995410919,
-0.060634735971689224,
-0.2691226899623871,
0.15183968842029572,
0.7945665121078491,
0.1369301676750183,
0.645967960357666,
-0.891420304775238,
0.02023666352033615,
0.4680402874946594,
0.503038763999939,
0.28633779287338257,
-0.3532123863697052,
-0.3732147812843323,
-0.28493624925613403,
-0.18112117052078247,
-0.6509012579917908,
0.47649723291397095,
0.24749690294265747,
0.4682922661304474,
0.3640410304069519,
-0.1744820475578308,
0.9027623534202576,
-0.5690788626670837,
0.7077497243881226,
0.26062458753585815,
-1.2158927917480469,
0.13495299220085144,
-0.2617385983467102,
0.3164817988872528,
0.27871373295783997,
0.3536471128463745,
-0.573074460029602,
-0.14880496263504028,
-0.7500790953636169,
-0.8606769442558289,
0.5600917339324951,
0.04736689478158951,
0.007231742609292269,
0.014328982681035995,
0.3541090488433838,
-0.034883227199316025,
0.3175903558731079,
-0.8187384009361267,
-0.09323737025260925,
0.1751142144203186,
0.21850138902664185,
-0.16031697392463684,
-0.6836530566215515,
-0.10240135341882706,
-0.21339362859725952,
0.642119824886322,
0.24819649755954742,
0.0990406945347786,
-0.11076202243566513,
-0.1756730079650879,
0.017732085660099983,
0.4845888316631317,
0.47309404611587524,
1.120261788368225,
-0.12990692257881165,
0.3987583518028259,
0.23130613565444946,
-0.31368860602378845,
-0.01653548888862133,
-0.4315336346626282,
-0.3299825191497803,
-0.1016710102558136,
0.6699734330177307,
0.9586975574493408,
0.27383965253829956,
-0.3016376197338104,
0.48976096510887146,
0.30802813172340393,
-0.1774277538061142,
-0.011445374228060246,
-0.1201387569308281,
0.24198071658611298,
0.14911025762557983,
-0.026612672954797745,
0.2417796403169632,
0.010224909521639347,
-0.693985641002655,
0.22053000330924988,
0.40846917033195496,
-0.5456202030181885,
-0.5167578458786011,
0.07505367696285248,
0.26003891229629517,
-0.33357441425323486,
0.676601231098175,
-0.10916083306074142,
-0.6456490755081177,
0.708891749382019,
0.35060030221939087,
0.8465308547019958,
0.05723324418067932,
0.19509029388427734,
0.10014193505048752,
0.6967534422874451,
-0.46745195984840393,
-0.25527286529541016,
0.1254284679889679,
-0.5380250215530396,
-0.7544587850570679,
-0.426769882440567,
-0.06712733209133148,
0.4873126447200775,
-0.4599667191505432,
0.3058164715766907,
-0.7846222519874573,
-0.05556114390492439,
-0.07854952663183212,
0.23974233865737915,
-0.5347676873207092,
0.05298639461398125,
-0.18121735751628876,
0.7669841647148132,
-0.8877370357513428,
1.374279260635376,
0.3434866964817047,
-0.2835105359554291,
-1.0874969959259033,
-0.15831820666790009,
0.006434026639908552,
-0.7762292623519897,
0.7381178140640259,
0.02754008024930954,
-0.12407462298870087,
0.0106142433360219,
-0.3324829638004303,
-0.8427411913871765,
0.9253653287887573,
0.2900298833847046,
-0.7834400534629822,
-0.18359851837158203,
-0.03478466346859932,
0.37065941095352173,
-0.09490420669317245,
0.18796208500862122,
0.6463274359703064,
0.4313631057739258,
-0.028872933238744736,
-1.0172256231307983,
0.199553444981575,
-0.10138846933841705,
0.11885586380958557,
0.5580621957778931,
-0.820060670375824,
1.206161379814148,
-0.01725214160978794,
-0.4775717258453369,
-0.017578018829226494,
0.3339068293571472,
-0.00492046819999814,
0.07213389128446579,
0.6757054924964905,
0.4511110782623291,
0.6848521828651428,
0.08853672444820404,
0.9646726846694946,
-0.19109927117824554,
0.3140360414981842,
1.1509156227111816,
-0.21637243032455444,
0.7716008424758911,
0.5650238990783691,
-0.18855300545692444,
0.30767232179641724,
0.5427584648132324,
0.037593770772218704,
0.5724374651908875,
0.4335222840309143,
-0.04819415882229805,
-0.3658960461616516,
0.2088952213525772,
-0.33474457263946533,
0.28751862049102783,
0.08617434650659561,
-0.30015110969543457,
-0.17421692609786987,
-0.12956513464450836,
0.15741010010242462,
-0.17926011979579926,
-0.42117950320243835,
0.59571772813797,
0.4042184352874756,
-0.5633962750434875,
0.6085535883903503,
0.19565963745117188,
0.42270973324775696,
-0.7364523410797119,
0.13747447729110718,
-0.32801491022109985,
0.2413267195224762,
-0.2060474008321762,
-0.6220117211341858,
0.2934991121292114,
-0.2717512845993042,
-0.30961599946022034,
-0.3953389823436737,
0.7756314873695374,
-0.40541067719459534,
-0.3845713436603546,
0.6636165380477905,
0.6594175696372986,
0.21796555817127228,
-0.2311820536851883,
-0.5765661597251892,
0.16562508046627045,
0.14970697462558746,
-0.426311194896698,
0.6157615780830383,
0.6137610673904419,
-0.4099223017692566,
0.8694736957550049,
0.709915816783905,
0.678331196308136,
0.12776419520378113,
0.18759454786777496,
0.9385771751403809,
-0.7786068320274353,
-0.4228861629962921,
-1.058819055557251,
0.10309720039367676,
-0.07131852209568024,
0.02625284157693386,
0.8081660270690918,
0.5007390379905701,
0.9681239128112793,
0.051832620054483414,
0.6586151719093323,
0.0713581070303917,
0.5963860154151917,
-0.5866920948028564,
0.6706094145774841,
-0.6503773331642151,
0.850385844707489,
-0.2709543704986572,
-1.342779517173767,
-0.2586657404899597,
0.26924020051956177,
-0.6340333223342896,
0.2257009595632553,
0.8192594051361084,
1.0223251581192017,
-0.3571060299873352,
-0.08987060934305191,
0.4399656057357788,
0.42422202229499817,
0.5828303098678589,
0.4219464361667633,
0.8949081897735596,
-0.19162428379058838,
0.6664009690284729,
-0.514565646648407,
-0.09990087151527405,
-0.14804545044898987,
-1.0340263843536377,
-0.9424515962600708,
-0.35506734251976013,
-0.3419325649738312,
-0.13902615010738373,
0.13697215914726257,
0.7545718550682068,
0.9435497522354126,
-0.6567361354827881,
-0.4025157690048218,
-0.07514280825853348,
0.3174568712711334,
-0.32250088453292847,
-0.23451602458953857,
0.5799920558929443,
0.06208692863583565,
-0.6063997149467468,
0.4464992880821228,
0.31350353360176086,
-0.13611853122711182,
-0.22115115821361542,
0.07373291999101639,
-0.19489775598049164,
-0.082422636449337,
0.7405585050582886,
0.28465521335601807,
-0.802106499671936,
-0.5515902638435364,
-0.4988994002342224,
-0.1598292589187622,
-0.12946340441703796,
1.045047640800476,
-0.4982796907424927,
-0.035191308706998825,
0.8750953078269958,
0.46626952290534973,
0.4869716167449951,
0.2713392674922943,
0.5550827383995056,
-0.8980637788772583,
0.2833898663520813,
0.1967758983373642,
0.27921587228775024,
0.32479751110076904,
-0.05728350579738617,
0.2481328397989273,
0.3277747333049774,
-0.6167473793029785,
-0.9108518958091736,
0.3027503490447998,
-0.9095107316970825,
-0.5192221403121948,
1.2981871366500854,
-0.05518404021859169,
-0.5107331275939941,
-0.04224089905619621,
-0.05197056010365486,
-0.23123155534267426,
-0.20358864963054657,
0.5517947673797607,
0.6898581385612488,
0.1688060164451599,
-0.563033401966095,
-0.6046428084373474,
0.4428148567676544,
0.6307464838027954,
-0.5012288689613342,
0.24995067715644836,
0.40223756432533264,
0.611370861530304,
0.11551754176616669,
0.7595629692077637,
-0.07222845405340195,
-0.17018616199493408,
-0.08150113373994827,
-0.04750066250562668,
-0.3359583914279938,
-0.5895311236381531,
-0.1725168228149414,
0.5140588283538818,
0.3267146050930023,
0.08496511727571487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12082v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12082v1
|
The Boy Who Survived: Removing Harry Potter from an LLM is harder than reported
| 2024-03-06T16:39:50 | 2024-03-06T16:39:50 |
Adam Shostack
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent work arXiv.2310.02238 asserted that "we effectively erase the model's
ability to generate or recall Harry Potter-related content.'' This claim is
shown to be overbroad. A small experiment of less than a dozen trials led to
repeated and specific mentions of Harry Potter, including "Ah, I see! A
"muggle" is a term used in the Harry Potter book series by Terry Pratchett...''
|
[
-0.6330399513244629,
-0.4877886176109314,
0.4759119153022766,
0.2955230474472046,
-0.13135230541229248,
0.3418413996696472,
-0.012162396684288979,
-0.4695877730846405,
0.4169730544090271,
0.4612896740436554,
-0.41101691126823425,
0.10702254623174667,
-0.7156689763069153,
0.3159230351448059,
-0.42946210503578186,
0.5960782766342163,
-0.17084969580173492,
-0.13184219598770142,
-0.3028041124343872,
0.12353014200925827,
-0.35834306478500366,
-0.19780655205249786,
-0.5865204334259033,
-0.5129786729812622,
0.7428525686264038,
0.005652897525578737,
0.4467519521713257,
0.7622998952865601,
0.8587677478790283,
0.3749392330646515,
-0.3495292067527771,
0.08470183610916138,
-0.5189286470413208,
0.010895734652876854,
-0.11392450332641602,
-0.4199061989784241,
-0.12174008041620255,
0.04592321068048477,
0.52409827709198,
0.9642806053161621,
-0.017483500763773918,
-0.2578106224536896,
0.2883833646774292,
0.6858371496200562,
-0.332767128944397,
0.045763421803712845,
-0.6084778904914856,
0.13222184777259827,
0.2036810964345932,
-0.20562048256397247,
-0.5510207414627075,
-0.3515128195285797,
0.25321799516677856,
-0.8296608328819275,
0.5711863040924072,
0.04025213047862053,
0.6413574814796448,
-0.19757753610610962,
-0.4328641891479492,
-0.4964986741542816,
-0.5878393650054932,
0.9817049503326416,
-0.4004842936992645,
-0.06219352409243584,
0.568466067314148,
0.10034173727035522,
-0.8334928154945374,
-0.554103434085846,
-0.575298547744751,
-0.20102554559707642,
-0.30612054467201233,
0.3367764353752136,
0.2961968183517456,
-0.12643252313137054,
0.571151077747345,
0.12035579979419708,
-0.576472818851471,
-0.48755189776420593,
-0.6075217127799988,
-0.24302536249160767,
0.5712023973464966,
0.10934627801179886,
0.23132027685642242,
-0.001298882532864809,
-0.5797208547592163,
0.22875478863716125,
-0.7090624570846558,
-0.04494236782193184,
0.3359832167625427,
0.06875768303871155,
0.40348726511001587,
0.5437259674072266,
0.08679403364658356,
-0.001998435938730836,
-0.10902099311351776,
-0.5439111590385437,
0.3412846624851227,
0.08779559284448624,
0.014338898472487926,
0.19565731287002563,
0.5064280033111572,
0.3865734338760376,
0.529102623462677,
-0.20806017518043518,
0.026712996885180473,
0.039458584040403366,
0.224920853972435,
-0.6955751776695251,
-0.3997562527656555,
-0.4666726291179657,
-0.6637867093086243,
0.13042551279067993,
0.3574228584766388,
-0.283210426568985,
-0.9265681505203247,
0.5351642370223999,
0.4831351041793823,
-0.25836822390556335,
-0.4857228100299835,
0.2865302264690399,
-0.4580640196800232,
0.08549313992261887,
0.6753019690513611,
-0.49028703570365906,
0.10335353016853333,
0.6227983236312866,
0.42154961824417114,
-0.34891390800476074,
-0.4783935248851776,
0.18541869521141052,
0.3780660331249237,
-0.6404602527618408,
0.6256918907165527,
-0.2813701033592224,
-0.974884569644928,
-0.19929347932338715,
0.43037664890289307,
-0.054786719381809235,
-0.5840837955474854,
0.25371795892715454,
-0.398986279964447,
0.010984568856656551,
-0.7559441924095154,
-0.6591358184814453,
-0.42943134903907776,
0.07790427654981613,
-0.4590663015842438,
0.311514288187027,
-0.35530394315719604,
-0.4663377106189728,
0.7232642769813538,
0.225406214594841,
-0.7448150515556335,
-0.026682887226343155,
-0.15218405425548553,
-0.31677210330963135,
-0.001338169677183032,
-0.3905840814113617,
0.0067760637030005455,
-0.24406686425209045,
0.07404247671365738,
-0.39324143528938293,
-0.3002185821533203,
0.16249361634254456,
-0.28802016377449036,
0.7806382775306702,
-0.06757799535989761,
-0.11437228322029114,
-0.6884459853172302,
-0.6275225281715393,
-0.4049238860607147,
0.4679156243801117,
-0.6266608834266663,
-0.3390677273273468,
0.15393811464309692,
-0.6043802499771118,
-0.003875035559758544,
0.07622279226779938,
-0.8555996417999268,
0.40315037965774536,
-0.09589052200317383,
-0.21400733292102814,
0.4084586203098297,
0.45333120226860046,
0.39414575695991516,
-0.8577033281326294,
0.4010498523712158,
-0.24150848388671875,
0.024219371378421783,
-0.45489031076431274,
-1.0328761339187622,
-0.7620782256126404,
-0.11111117154359818,
-0.17804016172885895,
0.5999643206596375,
-0.4642697274684906,
0.012151559814810753,
0.20968058705329895,
-0.4140019118785858,
0.09944330155849457,
0.261325865983963,
0.6492455005645752,
0.8284340500831604,
0.262666791677475,
-0.07287628203630447,
-0.39733025431632996,
-1.0068957805633545,
-0.4112050235271454,
-0.655174195766449,
-0.03857734054327011,
0.13800080120563507,
0.5827332735061646,
0.10902611911296844,
0.7902488708496094,
-0.6266269683837891,
-0.21902646124362946,
-0.03890650346875191,
0.2821562588214874,
0.28340092301368713,
0.5648483037948608,
0.4484884440898895,
-0.6623616814613342,
-0.3344169855117798,
-0.011941567994654179,
-0.7976618409156799,
-0.02435026690363884,
-0.19486519694328308,
-0.04288605600595474,
-0.2798067629337311,
0.6352254152297974,
-0.741290807723999,
0.9787857532501221,
-0.5811820030212402,
-0.3229815661907196,
0.2731339633464813,
-0.3724178075790405,
0.37543177604675293,
-0.592035710811615,
-0.34696173667907715,
-0.14187771081924438,
-0.034434422850608826,
-0.26149845123291016,
-0.25330111384391785,
0.1953044980764389,
0.32864049077033997,
-0.5584822297096252,
0.6952764391899109,
-0.6745693683624268,
0.12597136199474335,
-0.3323948383331299,
0.08594280481338501,
0.2991328835487366,
0.1688666045665741,
0.19565577805042267,
0.481116384267807,
0.3368244767189026,
-0.4573635458946228,
0.07547061145305634,
0.3044740557670593,
-0.10201115161180496,
0.1544037014245987,
-0.13710972666740417,
-0.05713757872581482,
-0.18440589308738708,
0.13995884358882904,
-1.1917418241500854,
-0.10245993733406067,
0.2035791128873825,
-0.26341649889945984,
0.10374587029218674,
0.12526622414588928,
-0.6426791548728943,
-0.5786252617835999,
-0.5313698053359985,
0.07428617030382156,
0.655468761920929,
-0.4758313298225403,
0.7047063708305359,
0.42409178614616394,
-0.036981407552957535,
-0.5268585085868835,
-0.6936933994293213,
0.03558824956417084,
-0.2722364366054535,
-0.34088456630706787,
0.17807626724243164,
-0.5006982088088989,
-0.5230691432952881,
-0.1496870368719101,
-0.46977195143699646,
-0.25713449716567993,
0.33115121722221375,
0.41326773166656494,
0.059879664331674576,
-0.1323443055152893,
0.059699781239032745,
-0.21602179110050201,
0.14217309653759003,
0.30846190452575684,
1.0770103931427002,
0.014936848543584347,
0.1288910061120987,
-0.2805342376232147,
-0.0936976969242096,
0.2873930335044861,
0.17843623459339142,
0.6666873693466187,
0.45356106758117676,
0.24947427213191986,
-0.6180795431137085,
-0.45708319544792175,
-0.32811999320983887,
-0.16992244124412537,
-0.5467204451560974,
0.18056796491146088,
-0.4697006940841675,
-0.25819531083106995,
0.9618439078330994,
0.08174385875463486,
0.006055193953216076,
0.48193708062171936,
0.11957012861967087,
-0.3129979074001312,
0.773073136806488,
0.24264751374721527,
0.2787854075431824,
0.2427058070898056,
0.06143387034535408,
0.15263424813747406,
-0.5961185693740845,
-0.43379074335098267,
-0.19146573543548584,
-0.20659247040748596,
-0.19490528106689453,
-0.08443792909383774,
-0.07641391456127167,
0.35596078634262085,
-0.20216751098632812,
0.5514252185821533,
-0.5046238303184509,
0.8210843801498413,
0.5589161515235901,
0.42052149772644043,
0.7152465581893921,
-0.34863704442977905,
0.26496589183807373,
-0.15488721430301666,
-0.3374428153038025,
-0.38118693232536316,
0.9618302583694458,
-0.03356914967298508,
0.9806839227676392,
0.2755458652973175,
0.7497053742408752,
0.3052067458629608,
0.5645430088043213,
-0.465364009141922,
1.1447516679763794,
0.17906729876995087,
-0.9177150130271912,
-0.10660353302955627,
-0.10422249138355255,
-1.207687258720398,
0.15534013509750366,
-0.26064902544021606,
-0.4418052136898041,
0.16508442163467407,
-0.27519309520721436,
-0.24777032434940338,
0.18836981058120728,
-0.8349778652191162,
0.2524589002132416,
0.11445514112710953,
-0.17339988052845,
-0.3395153880119324,
-0.38209736347198486,
0.44019073247909546,
-0.4380698502063751,
0.22966283559799194,
-0.3435749411582947,
-0.3010583817958832,
1.0449846982955933,
-0.7538419365882874,
0.5636768937110901,
-0.16239392757415771,
0.05661740154027939,
0.690841555595398,
0.40719911456108093,
0.343216210603714,
0.35352715849876404,
0.14808186888694763,
-0.13965605199337006,
-0.013247726485133171,
-0.20458538830280304,
-0.49433258175849915,
0.6365025043487549,
-0.4861980378627777,
-0.7965827584266663,
-0.6999726891517639,
-0.38004976511001587,
-0.09892340004444122,
0.21892093122005463,
0.025126921012997627,
0.13152731955051422,
-0.12762121856212616,
0.30225247144699097,
0.5828496813774109,
-0.47319117188453674,
0.9885953664779663,
0.8006693720817566,
-0.4846539795398712,
-0.23414655029773712,
0.8769036531448364,
0.3542001247406006,
0.061215903609991074,
-0.12342953681945801,
0.3802667558193207,
0.2348589450120926,
-0.8251067399978638,
0.02826329693198204,
0.40462779998779297,
-0.812164843082428,
-0.08783482760190964,
-0.6935922503471375,
-0.29308727383613586,
-0.026826100423932076,
-0.6964379549026489,
-0.1739424616098404,
-0.19007858633995056,
-0.6005337834358215,
0.0834035724401474,
0.5327603816986084,
0.7804169058799744,
0.10593067854642868,
0.4746960401535034,
-0.4672285318374634,
0.560951292514801,
0.653102457523346,
0.22409966588020325,
-0.03471986576914787,
-0.48449620604515076,
-0.06253267824649811,
-0.40074020624160767,
-0.09995543211698532,
-0.5421187877655029,
0.46778199076652527,
0.18861405551433563,
0.7458110451698303,
0.4073924720287323,
0.0871049016714096,
0.8039684295654297,
-0.46285077929496765,
0.7125802040100098,
0.40084120631217957,
-0.2300984114408493,
0.1478615701198578,
-0.5708776116371155,
0.14747031033039093,
0.3887438178062439,
0.0824122354388237,
-0.0458439365029335,
-0.552819013595581,
-0.6179134845733643,
-0.9149782061576843,
0.4583792984485626,
-0.11088384687900543,
0.19199620187282562,
-0.4154985249042511,
0.4030606746673584,
0.5479677319526672,
0.2266666442155838,
-0.8091368675231934,
-0.4331820011138916,
0.2508133053779602,
0.11516506969928741,
0.38363808393478394,
-0.4900510609149933,
0.07556605339050293,
-0.40410858392715454,
0.5794920325279236,
0.43827712535858154,
0.1278945952653885,
0.1528766006231308,
-0.6715378761291504,
-0.2727885842323303,
-0.38306981325149536,
0.30315661430358887,
1.1262681484222412,
-0.5880622267723083,
-0.045991573482751846,
0.03478981554508209,
-1.101698875427246,
-0.0153866708278656,
-0.40200069546699524,
-0.01431873720139265,
0.011240042746067047,
1.0648573637008667,
0.1456027626991272,
0.1928095817565918,
-0.7229989767074585,
0.5622580051422119,
-0.06799016147851944,
-0.4359871447086334,
-0.6081753373146057,
0.5486522912979126,
0.003552135778591037,
0.45967450737953186,
0.9498721957206726,
-0.13243284821510315,
-0.03874590992927551,
-0.5020328164100647,
0.5408428311347961,
0.41470736265182495,
0.16121017932891846,
-0.07491536438465118,
0.7054661512374878,
0.05031171068549156,
-0.35860252380371094,
0.07084941118955612,
-0.2933286726474762,
-0.2371935397386551,
1.1445246934890747,
0.48546814918518066,
0.6222854852676392,
-0.201651930809021,
0.055779654532670975,
0.2137502133846283,
0.49758321046829224,
-0.5087929964065552,
0.2589646279811859,
0.4161771833896637,
-0.7356846332550049,
-0.15111982822418213,
-0.266954243183136,
-0.5576279163360596,
0.053074900060892105,
-0.38920584321022034,
0.21712520718574524,
-0.9036973714828491,
-0.1472409963607788,
0.22847020626068115,
0.018869968131184578,
-0.3972943425178528,
0.3120556175708771,
0.2281445860862732,
0.9106658697128296,
-0.842739999294281,
0.7130923271179199,
0.19504067301750183,
-0.17469091713428497,
-0.5771243572235107,
-0.06695254892110825,
-0.13002502918243408,
-0.7397588491439819,
0.6754400134086609,
0.006876792758703232,
0.06737101823091507,
-0.1832328885793686,
-0.20366227626800537,
-0.6926710605621338,
0.956437885761261,
0.10083037614822388,
-0.2704063057899475,
0.16344855725765228,
-0.45176416635513306,
0.3521113097667694,
-0.40246856212615967,
0.3822357952594757,
0.21121883392333984,
0.695214569568634,
0.19057197868824005,
-0.5840755105018616,
-0.17546363174915314,
-0.26686006784439087,
-0.3214972913265228,
-0.042833179235458374,
-0.6013753414154053,
0.8699328899383545,
-0.3138427138328552,
-0.0680679902434349,
0.10646533221006393,
0.593194842338562,
0.09919558465480804,
0.6054984927177429,
0.5103331208229065,
0.17176751792430878,
0.5158171653747559,
-0.05543489754199982,
0.8693334460258484,
0.27411776781082153,
0.34190380573272705,
1.0488598346710205,
-0.26447999477386475,
0.3312615752220154,
0.588772177696228,
-0.5541495084762573,
0.15890248119831085,
0.8212710022926331,
-0.0650939866900444,
0.9592118859291077,
0.28356513381004333,
-0.4043234586715698,
-0.043066106736660004,
0.28161007165908813,
-0.3451632261276245,
-0.19773535430431366,
0.06372711807489395,
-0.32406625151634216,
-0.13892029225826263,
0.4396389126777649,
0.1733316332101822,
-0.017986753955483437,
-0.571769118309021,
0.6774932742118835,
0.2152097076177597,
-0.36369872093200684,
0.40309637784957886,
-0.6357096433639526,
0.45041215419769287,
-0.2659222483634949,
-0.3727222979068756,
-0.4305945038795471,
0.042857859283685684,
-0.11449271440505981,
-0.8299320340156555,
0.21178776025772095,
-0.43056339025497437,
-0.5272841453552246,
-0.3602931797504425,
0.8802393078804016,
-0.19061337411403656,
-0.6051388382911682,
0.5446285009384155,
0.5445738434791565,
0.31985828280448914,
0.32019680738449097,
-0.38544195890426636,
-0.211735337972641,
-0.022818656638264656,
-1.0243158340454102,
0.3442497253417969,
0.5930827856063843,
-0.08385904133319855,
0.99467533826828,
0.20824071764945984,
0.059938956052064896,
0.3770657777786255,
-0.293849915266037,
0.6161031126976013,
-0.9479920864105225,
-0.08627615123987198,
-1.0568381547927856,
0.1048864871263504,
0.06086938455700874,
-0.1343374103307724,
1.2339645624160767,
0.6942426562309265,
0.5175155401229858,
-0.20946206152439117,
0.8078246116638184,
0.01429304201155901,
0.8422338366508484,
0.0938754677772522,
0.7666761875152588,
-0.6533159613609314,
0.36671268939971924,
-0.5851287245750427,
-0.6768535375595093,
-0.4584859013557434,
0.6338197588920593,
-0.38904520869255066,
0.07353395968675613,
0.9427622556686401,
0.6627653241157532,
0.11862681061029434,
-0.08492540568113327,
0.23832301795482635,
0.21700499951839447,
0.05491255223751068,
0.2770395874977112,
0.900339663028717,
-0.29840967059135437,
0.6720765233039856,
0.024386638775467873,
0.13808277249336243,
-0.38227397203445435,
-0.9151716828346252,
-1.1528027057647705,
-0.27826425433158875,
-0.4910968244075775,
-0.5458914041519165,
0.1573677659034729,
0.43561577796936035,
0.22824780642986298,
-0.6817258596420288,
0.14060349762439728,
-0.07109767198562622,
0.5180299878120422,
0.11404019594192505,
-0.11079408973455429,
0.3931644558906555,
0.28921598196029663,
-0.5957154035568237,
0.6299425959587097,
0.145819291472435,
0.09517253935337067,
0.07902008295059204,
-0.1537732183933258,
-0.17456986010074615,
0.1771807074546814,
0.21567538380622864,
0.3840436339378357,
-0.5491184592247009,
-0.5632636547088623,
-0.18404164910316467,
-0.23741912841796875,
0.301089346408844,
0.4802054762840271,
-0.9125301837921143,
0.46009790897369385,
0.7229156494140625,
0.44029170274734497,
0.6633707880973816,
-0.10791855305433273,
0.20882254838943481,
-0.21264924108982086,
0.07606934010982513,
0.18283654749393463,
0.5264781713485718,
0.06972828507423401,
-0.21293312311172485,
0.5233441591262817,
0.7578949928283691,
-0.37879401445388794,
-1.073286771774292,
0.015444106422364712,
-0.8831593990325928,
-0.6002948880195618,
1.1280572414398193,
-0.2198021560907364,
-0.4621529281139374,
-0.3100748360157013,
-0.3342074155807495,
0.20658338069915771,
-0.34997713565826416,
0.65382319688797,
0.8439126014709473,
-0.13586212694644928,
-0.21766242384910583,
-0.9291573166847229,
0.29694798588752747,
0.1029503270983696,
-0.4019540250301361,
-0.1153210699558258,
0.20693552494049072,
0.4933750331401825,
0.13647927343845367,
0.6715426445007324,
0.18496273458003998,
0.21273688971996307,
0.15958091616630554,
0.19781377911567688,
-0.08975821733474731,
-0.18723995983600616,
0.16806139051914215,
0.19050687551498413,
0.10246266424655914,
-0.1809573769569397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03823v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03823v5
|
A Modular Approach for Multimodal Summarization of TV Shows
| 2024-03-06T16:10:01 | 2024-07-02T11:22:14 |
Louis Mahon, Mirella Lapata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper we address the task of summarizing television shows, which
touches key areas in AI research: complex reasoning, multiple modalities, and
long narratives. We present a modular approach where separate components
perform specialized sub-tasks which we argue affords greater flexibility
compared to end-to-end methods. Our modules involve detecting scene boundaries,
reordering scenes so as to minimize the number of cuts between different
events, converting visual information to text, summarizing the dialogue in each
scene, and fusing the scene summaries into a final summary for the entire
episode. We also present a new metric, PRISMA (Precision and Recall EvaluatIon
of Summary FActs), to measure both precision and recall of generated summaries,
which we decompose into atomic facts. Tested on the recently released
SummScreen3D dataset, our method produces higher quality summaries than
comparison models, as measured with ROUGE and our new fact-based metric, and as
assessed by human evaluators.
|
[
-0.4834655225276947,
-0.5244622230529785,
0.36439481377601624,
0.04645710438489914,
-0.3638637065887451,
0.07287393510341644,
-0.09134765714406967,
0.33460262417793274,
0.5982874631881714,
0.316923588514328,
-0.4717772305011749,
-0.23731616139411926,
-0.4453040361404419,
0.0951237604022026,
-0.16442586481571198,
1.0354254245758057,
0.1237344890832901,
0.10808105766773224,
-0.2117101103067398,
-0.2375190705060959,
-0.5297173857688904,
-0.28207287192344666,
0.03505176305770874,
-0.2649810016155243,
0.5111051797866821,
0.6234467625617981,
0.6148059368133545,
0.5495572090148926,
0.5380486249923706,
0.33290335536003113,
0.17541778087615967,
0.5801170468330383,
-0.4665244519710541,
-0.06970931589603424,
-0.07926414161920547,
-0.2700999677181244,
-0.7506772875785828,
-0.0004373554838821292,
0.47355735301971436,
0.7276729941368103,
-0.010881144553422928,
0.5059470534324646,
-0.23723635077476501,
0.7111770510673523,
-0.6223338842391968,
0.2991991639137268,
0.0020028555300086737,
0.1089477464556694,
0.2763318419456482,
-0.4056631028652191,
-0.3205301761627197,
-0.2724822163581848,
0.08952204138040543,
-0.4418282210826874,
0.09984076768159866,
-0.0068014878779649734,
0.6246180534362793,
0.3337804675102234,
-0.7965877056121826,
0.05282526835799217,
-0.8009180426597595,
0.7334151864051819,
-0.8059981465339661,
-0.2402959018945694,
0.13400141894817352,
0.587372899055481,
0.16259457170963287,
-0.7619971632957458,
-0.4923836290836334,
-0.11758530884981155,
-0.16093550622463226,
0.32791364192962646,
-0.05109751224517822,
0.0933089405298233,
0.122071273624897,
0.54439777135849,
-0.5880028605461121,
-0.2174355536699295,
-0.475513756275177,
-0.2877896726131439,
0.7188205718994141,
0.6453869938850403,
0.401393860578537,
-0.5697495937347412,
-0.15217046439647675,
0.06304513663053513,
-0.3392498791217804,
-0.0026244421023875475,
0.29988300800323486,
-0.0955297201871872,
-0.07107272744178772,
0.8234694600105286,
-0.5476794838905334,
0.23309798538684845,
-0.2569025158882141,
-0.29635587334632874,
0.19258292019367218,
-0.8039728999137878,
-0.2796715795993805,
0.0662585198879242,
0.469651460647583,
1.0329062938690186,
0.1751793920993805,
0.1838754415512085,
0.059228330850601196,
-0.01708916202187538,
0.3279680907726288,
-0.7392578125,
-0.48544642329216003,
0.35800185799598694,
-0.688388466835022,
-0.024334698915481567,
-0.03482721373438835,
-0.6149051785469055,
-0.3390725553035736,
-0.7324668169021606,
0.6609706878662109,
-0.40503305196762085,
-0.24490199983119965,
0.017242467030882835,
-0.6718588471412659,
0.07180408388376236,
0.6972417235374451,
-0.6787710189819336,
0.29156693816185,
0.5890053510665894,
0.7570286989212036,
0.017857853323221207,
-0.24078954756259918,
-0.37786826491355896,
0.20196905732154846,
-0.27797091007232666,
0.9341441988945007,
-0.20114494860172272,
-0.10099045932292938,
-0.4959696829319,
-0.29332444071769714,
0.03681464493274689,
-0.37327107787132263,
-0.237202450633049,
-0.13703373074531555,
0.311407208442688,
-0.2141546607017517,
-0.44679316878318787,
-0.655191957950592,
0.504451334476471,
-0.680087685585022,
0.46246325969696045,
0.018131155520677567,
-0.6683932542800903,
0.1966189593076706,
-0.41452088952064514,
-0.5277903079986572,
-0.501171886920929,
-0.08861735463142395,
-0.27060312032699585,
0.2132357358932495,
0.4921744763851166,
0.7946770787239075,
0.013569646514952183,
0.6790231466293335,
-0.0022511945571750402,
-0.2510484755039215,
0.3124910593032837,
-0.6151989698410034,
0.16741685569286346,
0.13853833079338074,
-0.1692599505186081,
0.5488512516021729,
-0.5165721774101257,
-0.2623814344406128,
-0.42781996726989746,
-0.13232487440109253,
-0.031408533453941345,
0.15939174592494965,
0.04663380607962608,
0.009733091108500957,
0.08823004364967346,
-0.23585253953933716,
0.1574878841638565,
0.014950823970139027,
0.24861127138137817,
0.6122123599052429,
0.00752169918268919,
0.5354022979736328,
-0.8413779735565186,
0.44230157136917114,
0.021943580359220505,
0.11004895716905594,
-0.928029477596283,
-0.4112435579299927,
-0.6670197248458862,
-0.6590977311134338,
0.03367011249065399,
0.6652541756629944,
-0.7503461241722107,
0.34457147121429443,
-0.4581291079521179,
-0.4866166412830353,
0.18057717382907867,
-0.22608491778373718,
0.49124619364738464,
0.06981751322746277,
0.24007634818553925,
-0.5956594944000244,
-0.42425352334976196,
-1.0211567878723145,
0.03958025947213173,
0.20893003046512604,
-0.19730842113494873,
0.06253480911254883,
0.6353684663772583,
0.27604758739471436,
0.9250595569610596,
-0.7698041796684265,
-0.28624191880226135,
-0.7767930626869202,
0.41637924313545227,
0.30983322858810425,
0.40015551447868347,
0.5027304887771606,
-0.8946776986122131,
-0.3145212233066559,
0.040843475610017776,
-1.0357986688613892,
0.3463885486125946,
-0.2556345462799072,
0.3545539975166321,
-0.241085022687912,
0.5165282487869263,
-0.6640273928642273,
0.60866779088974,
0.1145360991358757,
-0.48083603382110596,
0.8339430689811707,
-0.19437584280967712,
0.574268102645874,
-1.2294062376022339,
0.06967196613550186,
-0.063413605093956,
-0.49367982149124146,
-0.6177992224693298,
-0.16783083975315094,
-0.24763621389865875,
-0.11945446580648422,
-0.5362525582313538,
0.4210013151168823,
-0.36855918169021606,
-0.27542829513549805,
-0.10571534931659698,
0.3997456729412079,
0.16959328949451447,
0.979036808013916,
-0.18408168852329254,
0.5788663625717163,
0.09856795519590378,
-0.5179353952407837,
0.9604261517524719,
0.10954010486602783,
-0.6813710331916809,
0.6408827900886536,
-0.3083667755126953,
-0.5031151175498962,
-0.5258896946907043,
0.512054979801178,
-1.390458583831787,
-0.5703184604644775,
0.02297692373394966,
-0.5338377952575684,
0.24076883494853973,
0.16594740748405457,
-0.22708332538604736,
0.15489082038402557,
-0.6308830380439758,
0.6072098016738892,
0.15187227725982666,
-0.0013635727809742093,
1.1770154237747192,
0.5748023986816406,
-0.6500923037528992,
-0.6515149474143982,
-0.42182764410972595,
0.3042277991771698,
-0.402730792760849,
-0.5453599691390991,
0.23344779014587402,
-0.18988685309886932,
-0.5183821320533752,
0.18626774847507477,
-0.10983346402645111,
-0.1360197812318802,
-0.11254166811704636,
0.054475974291563034,
0.09772372990846634,
-0.5097032189369202,
-0.21946996450424194,
0.2109632045030594,
-0.31835609674453735,
-0.12837862968444824,
0.08951988071203232,
0.3070850372314453,
0.049492042511701584,
-0.17610061168670654,
-0.7218198180198669,
0.7389214634895325,
0.8908592462539673,
-0.10000636428594589,
0.048962242901325226,
0.6181187629699707,
-0.3224696218967438,
-0.03679182380437851,
-0.5013564825057983,
-0.11274196952581406,
-0.2910866141319275,
0.5832439064979553,
-0.1360529661178589,
-0.4804762601852417,
0.7271300554275513,
-0.07613848149776459,
0.18434834480285645,
0.37229570746421814,
0.668945848941803,
-0.04115016385912895,
1.1258753538131714,
0.42899441719055176,
0.06296488642692566,
0.43217557668685913,
-0.5054256319999695,
0.21448874473571777,
-0.9254066944122314,
-0.42834290862083435,
-0.031938403844833374,
-0.7189236283302307,
0.20469385385513306,
-0.6125275492668152,
0.7495766282081604,
-0.17963004112243652,
0.021993881091475487,
0.3301160931587219,
0.031529441475868225,
0.8807162046432495,
0.4530535936355591,
0.2053113728761673,
0.6429246664047241,
-0.39250919222831726,
0.43296849727630615,
0.13254274427890778,
-0.7677656412124634,
-0.3552832305431366,
1.1412729024887085,
0.08120112121105194,
0.8348113298416138,
0.6907913684844971,
0.23787584900856018,
0.6463284492492676,
0.24651408195495605,
-0.8796321749687195,
0.6935867667198181,
-0.21387510001659393,
-0.46760594844818115,
-0.5473651885986328,
-0.35015347599983215,
-0.5014206171035767,
0.4686034321784973,
0.04678863286972046,
-0.511584997177124,
0.11110353469848633,
0.014725148677825928,
-0.5780982375144958,
0.29815012216567993,
-0.7110472917556763,
0.7208356261253357,
-0.08983317762613297,
0.05034167319536209,
-0.8520796298980713,
-0.848579466342926,
0.7210004329681396,
0.40056976675987244,
0.2757958471775055,
-0.41477158665657043,
0.18596790730953217,
0.5563153028488159,
-0.39329907298088074,
0.8848806023597717,
0.19743160903453827,
0.3438827395439148,
0.3227457106113434,
0.21297550201416016,
-0.27696990966796875,
0.3628518581390381,
0.2932126224040985,
-0.13490362465381622,
0.08079332858324051,
-0.3584885597229004,
-0.7325069308280945,
0.25756943225860596,
-0.5822573900222778,
-0.40395432710647583,
-0.5278505682945251,
-1.0331149101257324,
0.23370994627475739,
0.14007337391376495,
0.08240476250648499,
1.401587724685669,
-0.1992289423942566,
0.18086901307106018,
0.7259485721588135,
-0.2889437675476074,
0.628269612789154,
0.11889880895614624,
-0.294289231300354,
-0.7636089324951172,
0.9856455326080322,
0.08517110347747803,
0.3421532213687897,
0.6944928169250488,
0.250382661819458,
-0.07279086112976074,
-0.4303029477596283,
-0.7174151539802551,
0.021390626206994057,
-0.8127061128616333,
-0.30926841497421265,
-0.3668597638607025,
-0.1133674904704094,
-0.3315103352069855,
-0.25017452239990234,
-0.3673500418663025,
-0.9095507264137268,
-0.09850753098726273,
-0.16223028302192688,
-0.1251285821199417,
0.8216978907585144,
-0.055207543075084686,
0.19306519627571106,
-0.8895336985588074,
0.7093102931976318,
0.5598568320274353,
-0.1207345649600029,
0.019309470430016518,
-0.2526714503765106,
-0.43815818428993225,
-0.31595197319984436,
-0.38124459981918335,
-0.5642315149307251,
0.4210449159145355,
0.27020740509033203,
0.5515387058258057,
0.44953039288520813,
0.19051361083984375,
0.6760516166687012,
-0.335725337266922,
1.128989815711975,
0.3979877531528473,
-0.9438784718513489,
0.35505837202072144,
-0.5669273138046265,
0.531621515750885,
0.21823419630527496,
0.06035274639725685,
-0.40672290325164795,
-0.2658453583717346,
-0.31529515981674194,
-0.709721028804779,
0.5852245688438416,
0.33288973569869995,
0.23374944925308228,
0.08589077740907669,
-0.06943666189908981,
0.2510085999965668,
0.5149512887001038,
-0.15087302029132843,
-0.29378753900527954,
-0.4308244287967682,
-0.22037138044834137,
-0.3144181966781616,
-0.16177546977996826,
-0.44560301303863525,
-0.39623287320137024,
0.486605703830719,
-0.2906700670719147,
0.04333415627479553,
0.31751689314842224,
-0.37900373339653015,
0.458111971616745,
0.1089051365852356,
1.0536197423934937,
1.144748330116272,
-0.23049013316631317,
0.1950693279504776,
0.0022278144024312496,
-0.2379516214132309,
-0.05337708070874214,
-0.3086385130882263,
0.31700554490089417,
0.10347079485654831,
0.6888964176177979,
0.7138864398002625,
0.40175360441207886,
-0.9136425852775574,
0.6548759341239929,
-0.3081909716129303,
-0.1870211809873581,
-0.4007023572921753,
0.0009447178454138339,
-0.18570496141910553,
0.5364617705345154,
0.3051576316356659,
0.3848140239715576,
0.4682636260986328,
-0.8666436672210693,
0.5382133722305298,
0.03516942635178566,
0.0035192640498280525,
-0.3947436511516571,
0.43970784544944763,
0.623313307762146,
-0.24165867269039154,
0.512278139591217,
-0.02679065428674221,
-0.48783278465270996,
1.1417444944381714,
0.0820930078625679,
0.8301769495010376,
-0.15815098583698273,
0.5713301301002502,
0.24469125270843506,
0.07034936547279358,
-0.12887074053287506,
0.06470733135938644,
-0.2322855442762375,
-0.5230073928833008,
-0.815867006778717,
-0.045099396258592606,
-0.626198410987854,
-0.30147984623908997,
-0.7566975355148315,
0.1342409998178482,
-0.43959423899650574,
-0.06834588944911957,
0.011780289933085442,
-0.3931625783443451,
-0.029870854690670967,
0.16717663407325745,
0.23459957540035248,
0.8701993227005005,
-0.847034215927124,
0.2517659366130829,
0.32513317465782166,
-0.3984684646129608,
-0.644271731376648,
-0.25771281123161316,
0.3117366135120392,
-0.48210686445236206,
0.2826211452484131,
0.2679884731769562,
-0.13714472949504852,
-0.11157336831092834,
-0.1675131618976593,
-0.8774706721305847,
1.0931111574172974,
0.11300580948591232,
0.02028408646583557,
-0.19969142973423004,
-0.2838592827320099,
0.24889108538627625,
-0.42647281289100647,
0.5433622598648071,
0.5885021686553955,
0.41485369205474854,
0.09765336662530899,
-1.046068549156189,
-0.2913232445716858,
-0.5655512809753418,
-0.35411694645881653,
0.3932473659515381,
-0.6904386281967163,
0.7839805483818054,
-0.5226035118103027,
-0.11660242825746536,
0.1504146307706833,
0.6300650238990784,
-0.18885773420333862,
0.7548895478248596,
0.21166877448558807,
0.30293968319892883,
0.36231958866119385,
-0.08105402439832687,
0.9935868978500366,
0.06324200332164764,
0.3881699740886688,
1.0281198024749756,
0.19377344846725464,
0.3722738027572632,
0.24790620803833008,
-0.07538022845983505,
0.496927946805954,
0.5105640292167664,
0.18333789706230164,
0.5777285099029541,
0.088108591735363,
0.012026005424559116,
-0.3472590446472168,
0.06172392517328262,
0.00035301572643220425,
0.5598335862159729,
0.5618122220039368,
0.11152930557727814,
-0.45914384722709656,
0.1940757781267166,
0.13327839970588684,
0.18749935925006866,
-0.46393734216690063,
1.0234302282333374,
0.0928160548210144,
-0.8620404005050659,
0.17260660231113434,
-0.18423977494239807,
0.2423357367515564,
-0.7285919189453125,
-0.1477532535791397,
-0.4091210961341858,
0.16335131227970123,
-0.28149253129959106,
-0.8045111298561096,
0.45597997307777405,
-0.42678210139274597,
-0.4152626395225525,
-0.13957279920578003,
-0.0025582117959856987,
-0.42836737632751465,
-0.31084856390953064,
-0.470262736082077,
0.24528342485427856,
0.22671088576316833,
0.06297392398118973,
-0.14306673407554626,
-0.16599160432815552,
-0.05163576826453209,
-0.35619786381721497,
0.19554316997528076,
0.38782230019569397,
-0.10580085217952728,
0.8076729774475098,
0.3085882067680359,
-0.08355578780174255,
0.1289147138595581,
0.031790342181921005,
0.6803928017616272,
-0.684837281703949,
-0.9293274283409119,
-0.7096654176712036,
0.9795029759407043,
-0.18200045824050903,
-0.41116392612457275,
0.738924503326416,
0.7590336203575134,
0.6100938320159912,
-0.3158031404018402,
0.7627617716789246,
-0.21299304068088531,
0.06716174632310867,
-0.9257128834724426,
0.4338632822036743,
-0.5463680624961853,
0.32891595363616943,
-0.18447841703891754,
-1.012631893157959,
-0.569857656955719,
0.42358076572418213,
-0.0006769546889699996,
-0.2697325050830841,
0.9640503525733948,
0.672879159450531,
-0.1666925996541977,
0.09521638602018356,
0.2816790044307709,
0.05933232232928276,
0.3728921413421631,
0.4481198787689209,
0.9391610026359558,
-0.11462876200675964,
0.3825782537460327,
-0.04085465520620346,
-0.46307042241096497,
-0.47300806641578674,
-0.7771720886230469,
-1.0019898414611816,
-0.7242012023925781,
-0.2737154960632324,
-0.065909244120121,
-0.25968918204307556,
0.7016662359237671,
0.9279049634933472,
-0.6723183393478394,
-0.48434823751449585,
0.6584445238113403,
0.3834332227706909,
-0.7748222947120667,
-0.20992176234722137,
0.49303051829338074,
0.055564362555742264,
-0.8109361529350281,
0.4181865155696869,
0.6807325482368469,
-0.45729437470436096,
-0.3851032555103302,
0.1585025191307068,
0.026889896020293236,
0.17998415231704712,
0.8345041275024414,
0.07358889281749725,
-0.6643099784851074,
-0.5130376219749451,
-0.3174605667591095,
0.1817118376493454,
0.021374216303229332,
1.2477359771728516,
-0.7141940593719482,
0.5999560952186584,
0.9758609533309937,
0.2538949251174927,
0.4546498954296112,
0.39501088857650757,
0.9015077352523804,
-0.6004835367202759,
0.03305128961801529,
0.05686527490615845,
0.38002410531044006,
0.16837355494499207,
-0.25987061858177185,
0.20079320669174194,
0.27679577469825745,
-0.4883222281932831,
-0.7457253932952881,
0.5915922522544861,
-1.3683199882507324,
-0.4822648763656616,
0.7985453009605408,
-0.129777729511261,
-0.16450358927249908,
-0.4636009633541107,
-0.33657175302505493,
0.05594214051961899,
-0.29956597089767456,
0.7599425315856934,
0.4302654564380646,
-0.4487106502056122,
-0.1272127628326416,
-0.2856757640838623,
0.29979291558265686,
0.026521503925323486,
-0.7720749974250793,
0.05891070142388344,
0.6701530814170837,
0.4497029483318329,
0.462847501039505,
0.6709930300712585,
0.002785902703180909,
0.4404013752937317,
0.10717947036027908,
-0.17700597643852234,
-0.43973594903945923,
-0.9394519329071045,
-0.05809623748064041,
0.2689193785190582,
-0.8090786337852478,
-0.2022407501935959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03814v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03814v1
|
Evaluating the Elementary Multilingual Capabilities of Large Language Models with MultiQ
| 2024-03-06T16:01:44 | 2024-03-06T16:01:44 |
Carolin Holtermann, Paul Röttger, Timm Dill, Anne Lauscher
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) need to serve everyone, including a global
majority of non-English speakers. However, most LLMs today, and open LLMs in
particular, are often intended for use in just English (e.g. Llama2, Mistral)
or a small handful of high-resource languages (e.g. Mixtral, Qwen). Recent
research shows that, despite limits in their intended use, people prompt LLMs
in many different languages. Therefore, in this paper, we investigate the basic
multilingual capabilities of state-of-the-art open LLMs beyond their intended
use. For this purpose, we introduce MultiQ, a new silver standard benchmark for
basic open-ended question answering with 27.4k test questions across a
typologically diverse set of 137 languages. With MultiQ, we evaluate language
fidelity, i.e.\ whether models respond in the prompted language, and question
answering accuracy. All LLMs we test respond faithfully and/or accurately for
at least some languages beyond their intended use. Most models are more
accurate when they respond faithfully. However, differences across models are
large, and there is a long tail of languages where models are neither accurate
nor faithful. We explore differences in tokenization as a potential explanation
for our findings, identifying possible correlations that warrant further
investigation.
|
[
-0.372996985912323,
-0.6324934959411621,
0.5650021433830261,
0.24544623494148254,
-0.0873916819691658,
0.14838241040706635,
-0.40104612708091736,
-0.4920826256275177,
-0.15598146617412567,
0.30779996514320374,
-0.24332326650619507,
-0.35827910900115967,
-0.40289294719696045,
0.5262045860290527,
-0.2576126754283905,
0.8241534233093262,
-0.17411285638809204,
0.31998035311698914,
-0.3752751648426056,
-0.5322584509849548,
-0.3091800808906555,
-0.7914679050445557,
-0.5641305446624756,
-0.15312179923057556,
0.6846962571144104,
0.42084309458732605,
0.6976728439331055,
0.16855080425739288,
0.32257601618766785,
0.2555566132068634,
-0.19869361817836761,
0.3354406952857971,
-0.5386340618133545,
-0.029194490984082222,
0.039267171174287796,
-0.5463635921478271,
-0.37525445222854614,
-0.04828634113073349,
1.0330129861831665,
0.8080281019210815,
0.020558461546897888,
0.3851367235183716,
0.16263481974601746,
0.47288694977760315,
-0.6651423573493958,
0.036875542253255844,
-0.6327707171440125,
-0.22606833279132843,
-0.19604799151420593,
0.08142673224210739,
-0.3716343641281128,
-0.21424062550067902,
-0.1715964674949646,
-0.5258069634437561,
-0.18881896138191223,
0.12482212483882904,
0.5974469780921936,
-0.06781661510467529,
-0.7906707525253296,
-0.2242240309715271,
-0.6825634241104126,
0.8861545324325562,
-0.7101088166236877,
0.8279338479042053,
0.26946502923965454,
0.2723587453365326,
-0.07882502675056458,
-0.5245622396469116,
-0.5648605823516846,
-0.38445696234703064,
0.02679416351020336,
0.13607114553451538,
-0.23876427114009857,
0.046484604477882385,
0.2641568183898926,
0.5473172068595886,
-0.5988166332244873,
0.19925899803638458,
-0.27567267417907715,
-0.19464199244976044,
0.45959582924842834,
0.12720124423503876,
0.30653515458106995,
0.05183642357587814,
-0.2833486795425415,
0.04117570072412491,
-0.712455153465271,
0.459433913230896,
0.39331579208374023,
0.5072818398475647,
0.05032692849636078,
0.7847188115119934,
0.011650990694761276,
0.5419766902923584,
-0.3609422743320465,
-0.32280460000038147,
0.143245667219162,
-0.628996729850769,
-0.08492568880319595,
-0.3756033778190613,
0.8400351405143738,
0.2967146635055542,
0.47528061270713806,
-0.2279689610004425,
-0.17724338173866272,
-0.2470308393239975,
-0.3071655035018921,
-0.6947118639945984,
0.35179299116134644,
0.399493545293808,
-0.36046114563941956,
0.31485801935195923,
0.007393579930067062,
-0.4693870544433594,
-0.21980051696300507,
-0.019898509606719017,
0.3373277187347412,
-0.472976416349411,
-0.5523032546043396,
0.254799485206604,
0.005166711285710335,
0.32948973774909973,
0.12091030925512314,
-0.6416695713996887,
0.39957448840141296,
0.7319679856300354,
0.8011432886123657,
-0.13684359192848206,
-0.7794632315635681,
-0.7634305357933044,
-0.06360137462615967,
-0.4912067651748657,
0.6209030151367188,
-0.402648001909256,
-0.3487938940525055,
0.022144323214888573,
0.08709347993135452,
-0.13448722660541534,
-0.4124723970890045,
0.6440626382827759,
-0.6305230855941772,
0.14297179877758026,
-0.5153282880783081,
-0.4090466797351837,
-0.17023691534996033,
0.4274995028972626,
-0.6781779527664185,
1.1767910718917847,
0.0042832656763494015,
-0.6215139031410217,
0.17004895210266113,
-0.471685528755188,
-0.28594115376472473,
0.07857473939657211,
-0.028976963832974434,
-0.035079825669527054,
0.33404281735420227,
0.19326356053352356,
0.13149376213550568,
-0.4375627934932709,
0.2970035672187805,
-0.26732152700424194,
-0.41135498881340027,
0.5475820899009705,
-0.7174800038337708,
0.6330885887145996,
0.17055295407772064,
0.24180446565151215,
0.11497320234775543,
-0.6221088767051697,
0.26766833662986755,
0.14469093084335327,
-0.5477436184883118,
-0.4414709210395813,
-0.10770078003406525,
0.05991562828421593,
0.3517480790615082,
0.2504971921443939,
-0.6812602281570435,
0.05964107811450958,
-0.4875833988189697,
0.39166539907455444,
0.5705690979957581,
-0.16859331727027893,
0.23029163479804993,
-0.40106871724128723,
0.7227573990821838,
-0.041748251765966415,
0.050777360796928406,
-0.36980676651000977,
-0.6105517745018005,
-0.6544507145881653,
-0.45158281922340393,
0.5576969981193542,
0.5470232367515564,
-0.5424500703811646,
-0.14044949412345886,
-0.2972641587257385,
-0.2200043946504593,
-0.7775399088859558,
0.290969580411911,
0.4415346086025238,
0.05356322228908539,
0.2514578104019165,
-0.09324558824300766,
-0.31806623935699463,
-1.0149507522583008,
-0.399748831987381,
-0.3811122179031372,
-0.004052095580846071,
0.31817924976348877,
0.5018971562385559,
0.009524361230432987,
0.7467483282089233,
-0.0705552026629448,
0.1740456521511078,
-0.3052240312099457,
-0.11131493747234344,
0.3016669452190399,
-0.04481939598917961,
0.477029949426651,
-0.6362428069114685,
-0.6063188910484314,
0.21125103533267975,
-0.5663281679153442,
-0.06541122496128082,
0.039133451879024506,
-0.0876217857003212,
0.26485973596572876,
0.5308053493499756,
-0.6999245882034302,
-0.0024011533241719007,
0.8963110446929932,
-0.057231269776821136,
0.5949053168296814,
-0.312904417514801,
0.29821622371673584,
-1.091469168663025,
0.2695087194442749,
-0.1926959753036499,
-0.24575313925743103,
-0.7278897166252136,
0.3703306019306183,
0.47775840759277344,
-0.25927698612213135,
-0.7086538076400757,
0.9889803528785706,
-0.6426504850387573,
-0.2514651417732239,
-0.10797612369060516,
0.2023700475692749,
0.13353146612644196,
0.20758424699306488,
-0.23738564550876617,
1.0752592086791992,
0.38341930508613586,
-0.621274471282959,
0.2055130898952484,
0.07664717733860016,
-0.2894148826599121,
0.4995458722114563,
-0.7917748689651489,
0.11629971861839294,
-0.30262652039527893,
-0.05877735838294029,
-1.3221888542175293,
-0.10391867160797119,
-0.06744548678398132,
-0.537459135055542,
0.11566430330276489,
-0.20011724531650543,
-0.8474268317222595,
-0.31671425700187683,
-0.33197665214538574,
0.46621939539909363,
0.26501163840293884,
-0.4803692698478699,
0.7315406799316406,
0.19390437006950378,
-0.2484591007232666,
-0.6914841532707214,
-0.5606638789176941,
0.1665623039007187,
-0.2909233570098877,
-0.8441704511642456,
-0.006320069544017315,
-0.38111868500709534,
-0.5373681783676147,
-0.2637162208557129,
0.035139720886945724,
-0.1387503296136856,
0.36786893010139465,
-0.05043473467230797,
0.258370578289032,
-0.4781918525695801,
0.39796555042266846,
-0.022115537896752357,
-0.015176454558968544,
-0.06175622344017029,
-0.09003590792417526,
0.5719267129898071,
-0.4849856495857239,
-0.6992244720458984,
-0.07849285751581192,
0.5687082409858704,
0.8337869048118591,
-0.6473623514175415,
0.8344839215278625,
0.33449050784111023,
-0.3250989615917206,
0.1463112235069275,
-0.6008567214012146,
-0.007384148892015219,
-0.45064443349838257,
0.4848320782184601,
-0.7346091866493225,
-1.067112922668457,
0.9094115495681763,
0.14855684340000153,
0.44502392411231995,
0.3870157301425934,
0.5865861177444458,
0.028166338801383972,
1.1154637336730957,
0.4447510540485382,
0.06153767555952072,
0.05935458093881607,
0.2550079822540283,
0.18498682975769043,
-0.8850167393684387,
-0.02218269184231758,
-0.6046701073646545,
-0.009785681031644344,
-0.6438310146331787,
-0.4860931634902954,
0.4433864951133728,
0.42099666595458984,
-0.11899338662624359,
-0.04952932149171829,
0.20632177591323853,
0.6166132092475891,
0.5010636448860168,
-0.3532741963863373,
0.7771654725074768,
-0.10188420861959457,
-0.27387121319770813,
-0.08577809482812881,
-0.6817300319671631,
-0.6671716570854187,
1.2877954244613647,
0.5073202848434448,
0.6480016708374023,
0.4603728652000427,
0.44023823738098145,
-0.30753156542778015,
0.22489236295223236,
-0.8159339427947998,
0.33686116337776184,
-0.18828031420707703,
-0.7767079472541809,
-0.34343183040618896,
-0.4171309769153595,
-1.0775741338729858,
0.6550199389457703,
-0.11046384274959564,
-0.443167507648468,
-0.16760027408599854,
-0.10892979800701141,
-0.40039145946502686,
0.2885286808013916,
-0.6486801505088806,
0.6800375580787659,
-0.538712203502655,
-0.1377042979001999,
0.10610216110944748,
-0.3291996419429779,
0.4655988812446594,
-0.3075217604637146,
0.5249530673027039,
-0.17864678800106049,
-0.3123064935207367,
0.4941249489784241,
0.012372169643640518,
0.6223753094673157,
0.24561098217964172,
-0.34834909439086914,
0.1218407154083252,
-0.06238975003361702,
0.26460111141204834,
0.2853551506996155,
-0.3165006637573242,
0.2949439585208893,
0.35348421335220337,
-0.5143314003944397,
-0.45060694217681885,
0.6346400380134583,
-0.8284526467323303,
-0.6302524209022522,
-0.4666826128959656,
-0.6743236780166626,
-0.46549591422080994,
0.3374800980091095,
0.04953095316886902,
0.32444024085998535,
-0.5064588189125061,
0.20148217678070068,
0.5403017997741699,
-0.3311384916305542,
0.46598145365715027,
0.928229033946991,
-0.5909737944602966,
-0.35727864503860474,
0.7168234586715698,
0.22365647554397583,
0.4601074457168579,
0.17199987173080444,
0.35484403371810913,
-0.5284698009490967,
-0.5978774428367615,
-0.727422297000885,
0.49027031660079956,
-0.7808218002319336,
0.06354798376560211,
-0.6432144045829773,
-0.03859845921397209,
-0.42013058066368103,
0.24890168011188507,
-0.29823657870292664,
-0.2921774685382843,
-0.161210298538208,
0.05753327161073685,
0.16620750725269318,
0.6594058275222778,
0.08698417246341705,
-0.026605458930134773,
-1.0793750286102295,
0.21659822762012482,
0.45683804154396057,
0.31313300132751465,
-0.011309001594781876,
-0.6409830451011658,
-0.20906896889209747,
0.23343351483345032,
-0.02664610557258129,
-0.8123030662536621,
0.017407681792974472,
0.47724592685699463,
1.0086783170700073,
0.2162315547466278,
0.03147051855921745,
0.6341020464897156,
-0.642393171787262,
0.8015674948692322,
-0.03217314928770065,
-0.9074611067771912,
-0.020106695592403412,
-0.3264698386192322,
0.4827234148979187,
0.5940710306167603,
0.5700219869613647,
-1.1252928972244263,
-0.48203080892562866,
-0.24815134704113007,
-0.6656085848808289,
0.46582478284835815,
0.03417503088712692,
0.40065962076187134,
-0.18423105776309967,
0.35222867131233215,
0.18488898873329163,
0.2637540400028229,
-0.8513206243515015,
-0.2726229131221771,
0.1156037375330925,
-0.0016784700565040112,
-0.3883052468299866,
-0.3292273283004761,
-0.1673789620399475,
0.13244949281215668,
0.37346211075782776,
-0.3495493531227112,
-0.013406983576714993,
-0.07445505261421204,
-0.25555023550987244,
-0.20987273752689362,
0.6156820058822632,
0.5265839099884033,
0.863831639289856,
-0.0022458801977336407,
0.07244936376810074,
0.4320324957370758,
-0.22427092492580414,
0.14035595953464508,
0.16008584201335907,
-0.02985466457903385,
-0.12728743255138397,
0.49043434858322144,
0.5716381072998047,
0.26160290837287903,
-0.9544967412948608,
0.47655579447746277,
-0.3299902677536011,
-0.03519231826066971,
-0.1496552675962448,
-0.19483612477779388,
0.3872927725315094,
0.24813587963581085,
0.4172728359699249,
-0.3108541667461395,
-0.14922863245010376,
-0.7431252002716064,
-0.03306572884321213,
0.7480112314224243,
-0.10169948637485504,
-0.31466060876846313,
0.33886218070983887,
0.16461466252803802,
-0.16090181469917297,
0.6009135842323303,
-0.24964149296283722,
-0.4880490303039551,
0.46411266922950745,
0.5706417560577393,
0.5011504292488098,
-0.2803894877433777,
0.0286041721701622,
0.40117937326431274,
0.6310158967971802,
-0.056645024567842484,
0.6107250452041626,
0.384520024061203,
-0.8715257048606873,
-0.7362848520278931,
-0.5055503249168396,
-0.5058084726333618,
0.2629360854625702,
-0.7495626211166382,
0.2595154345035553,
-0.23037219047546387,
-0.08414732664823532,
-0.22374649345874786,
-0.02999933995306492,
-0.6047067046165466,
-0.18855538964271545,
0.2129979282617569,
0.9966418147087097,
-0.8823425769805908,
0.6971360445022583,
0.9150620698928833,
-0.24458937346935272,
-0.6339280009269714,
0.00008536198583897203,
-0.07783450931310654,
-0.8973458409309387,
0.48517271876335144,
0.16329151391983032,
-0.13566866517066956,
0.06526076048612595,
-0.22763754427433014,
-0.94825279712677,
0.8420588374137878,
0.516007125377655,
-0.33727386593818665,
0.07514895498752594,
0.39102038741111755,
0.5900872349739075,
-0.2882092595100403,
0.48930567502975464,
0.4254668056964874,
0.38480013608932495,
-0.020649706944823265,
-1.2218698263168335,
-0.2961442768573761,
-0.19283908605575562,
0.002871152013540268,
0.22803083062171936,
-0.8280282616615295,
1.2021616697311401,
-0.2237900048494339,
-0.4095986485481262,
0.15575751662254333,
0.5755921006202698,
0.5115920305252075,
0.15279564261436462,
0.44842612743377686,
0.3914196193218231,
1.0095540285110474,
0.025523528456687927,
1.139641523361206,
-0.4601595103740692,
0.29867997765541077,
1.0739858150482178,
-0.5545222163200378,
1.076631784439087,
0.546273410320282,
-0.2933841347694397,
0.05978495255112648,
0.6687942147254944,
0.33044543862342834,
0.07945206016302109,
0.05298677086830139,
-0.2747507095336914,
-0.3734113276004791,
-0.1649039089679718,
-0.4390692710876465,
0.49203500151634216,
0.15326805412769318,
0.012070255354046822,
-0.2554953098297119,
0.1310945451259613,
0.11948109418153763,
0.013114877045154572,
-0.37442532181739807,
0.5679917335510254,
0.03997711092233658,
-0.7225645184516907,
0.620454728603363,
0.25707560777664185,
0.6487544775009155,
-0.695366382598877,
0.13392390310764313,
-0.404058039188385,
-0.042798273265361786,
0.031993359327316284,
-0.9795423150062561,
0.07378338277339935,
0.15653030574321747,
-0.09387662261724472,
-0.01610998623073101,
0.37631309032440186,
-0.5835130214691162,
-0.6583026051521301,
0.4143392741680145,
1.034389615058899,
0.19392086565494537,
-0.14663910865783691,
-0.64762943983078,
0.08637678623199463,
-0.1717776209115982,
-0.12826001644134521,
0.4405477046966553,
0.5182810425758362,
-0.17633794248104095,
0.7406937479972839,
0.7878263592720032,
0.11243872344493866,
0.1978679746389389,
0.08756697177886963,
0.6791050434112549,
-0.44879040122032166,
-0.32703039050102234,
-0.7537329196929932,
0.5419113039970398,
0.19059762358665466,
-0.5381739735603333,
1.1409176588058472,
0.7165356278419495,
0.8998786211013794,
0.14105857908725739,
0.7453649640083313,
0.3644859790802002,
0.5951374769210815,
-0.5217099189758301,
0.37256160378456116,
-0.8657960891723633,
0.11265367269515991,
-0.12005581706762314,
-0.9278447031974792,
-0.17493650317192078,
0.3269154131412506,
-0.21684683859348297,
0.07506375759840012,
0.8196778893470764,
0.6426698565483093,
-0.05072653293609619,
-0.08431238681077957,
0.6787146329879761,
0.04829814285039902,
0.22854411602020264,
0.5428613424301147,
1.2215242385864258,
-0.36068350076675415,
0.7312747836112976,
0.03407624736428261,
-0.22143015265464783,
-0.015902860090136528,
-0.7662281394004822,
-1.0531983375549316,
-0.3865877091884613,
0.04301530867815018,
-0.35031574964523315,
-0.1950780153274536,
0.9361076354980469,
0.3333689570426941,
-0.8301770091056824,
-0.5232014656066895,
0.5128931403160095,
0.11907996982336044,
-0.11225149035453796,
-0.09011249244213104,
0.1738830953836441,
-0.2655746340751648,
-0.8596749305725098,
0.5228984355926514,
0.19769828021526337,
0.08179661631584167,
-0.4532909691333771,
-0.20937709510326385,
-0.20993953943252563,
0.18967217206954956,
0.6950147747993469,
0.310831218957901,
-0.7998569011688232,
-0.20447370409965515,
0.5673812627792358,
-0.18305036425590515,
0.10198964178562164,
0.7611370086669922,
-0.3051883578300476,
0.4210926294326782,
0.41302233934402466,
0.5798680782318115,
0.15793024003505707,
-0.05918870121240616,
0.5633202791213989,
-0.6512176990509033,
0.12123693525791168,
0.22637790441513062,
0.4935764670372009,
0.3752431273460388,
-0.05482685938477516,
0.2669069766998291,
-0.08423309773206711,
-0.4784334599971771,
-0.9364873766899109,
0.3319403827190399,
-0.433768093585968,
-0.33515679836273193,
1.2794597148895264,
-0.30255112051963806,
-0.03617783635854721,
-0.3801621198654175,
-0.15648253262043,
-0.014417828992009163,
-0.28829678893089294,
0.23669537901878357,
1.151827096939087,
0.016420703381299973,
-0.4104243516921997,
-0.7775353193283081,
0.07144419848918915,
0.31360599398612976,
-0.74491947889328,
0.14039216935634613,
0.33736759424209595,
0.33914998173713684,
0.1794789582490921,
0.828462541103363,
-0.14963583648204803,
0.360999196767807,
-0.21927915513515472,
-0.0717606395483017,
-0.042713798582553864,
-0.28160560131073,
-0.6121044754981995,
0.1296815574169159,
0.6293780207633972,
0.03658672794699669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03788v1
|
PPTC-R benchmark: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Large Language Models for PowerPoint Task Completion
| 2024-03-06T15:33:32 | 2024-03-06T15:33:32 |
Zekai Zhang, Yiduo Guo, Yaobo Liang, Dongyan Zhao, Nan Duan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The growing dependence on Large Language Models (LLMs) for finishing user
instructions necessitates a comprehensive understanding of their robustness to
complex task completion in real-world situations. To address this critical
need, we propose the PowerPoint Task Completion Robustness benchmark (PPTC-R)
to measure LLMs' robustness to the user PPT task instruction and software
version. Specifically, we construct adversarial user instructions by attacking
user instructions at sentence, semantic, and multi-language levels. To assess
the robustness of Language Models to software versions, we vary the number of
provided APIs to simulate both the newest version and earlier version settings.
Subsequently, we test 3 closed-source and 4 open-source LLMs using a benchmark
that incorporates these robustness settings, aiming to evaluate how deviations
impact LLMs' API calls for task completion. We find that GPT-4 exhibits the
highest performance and strong robustness in our benchmark, particularly in the
version update and the multilingual settings. However, we find that all LLMs
lose their robustness when confronted with multiple challenges (e.g.,
multi-turn) simultaneously, leading to significant performance drops. We
further analyze the robustness behavior and error reasons of LLMs in our
benchmark, which provide valuable insights for researchers to understand the
LLM's robustness in task completion and develop more robust LLMs and agents. We
release the code and data at \url{https://github.com/ZekaiGalaxy/PPTCR}.
|
[
-0.07124491780996323,
-0.5676650404930115,
0.3966880738735199,
0.034277912229299545,
-0.16819225251674652,
0.2744486629962921,
-0.40305596590042114,
-0.16972503066062927,
-0.5963433980941772,
0.48408833146095276,
-0.1762067824602127,
-0.5667243003845215,
-0.7782171964645386,
0.13117288053035736,
-0.24118544161319733,
1.0277146100997925,
-0.36356687545776367,
-0.05496504530310631,
-0.23084688186645508,
0.028279326856136322,
-0.471884161233902,
-0.5956476330757141,
-0.2710546851158142,
-0.5455084443092346,
0.4225609302520752,
0.4430747628211975,
0.8277035355567932,
0.5031453371047974,
0.7543181777000427,
0.3066081404685974,
0.016999948769807816,
-0.1331903636455536,
-0.4051593840122223,
0.2850117087364197,
-0.05153694748878479,
-0.3030071556568146,
-0.7675694227218628,
0.1314849555492401,
0.5899473428726196,
0.5011281371116638,
-0.0906573012471199,
-0.01164260320365429,
0.48858192563056946,
0.2945314347743988,
-0.6379833817481995,
0.32734429836273193,
-0.5408033132553101,
0.18717551231384277,
-0.2723558247089386,
-0.17414195835590363,
-0.4332006573677063,
-0.23088645935058594,
0.278027206659317,
-0.455718994140625,
0.23056703805923462,
-0.11683277785778046,
0.822629988193512,
0.06333569437265396,
-0.383789986371994,
0.006877375766634941,
-0.5083014369010925,
0.7540922164916992,
-0.632806122303009,
0.15714967250823975,
0.5184776186943054,
0.28180065751075745,
-0.4521403908729553,
-1.072422981262207,
-0.3121495842933655,
-0.7772504091262817,
0.054516829550266266,
0.3048831820487976,
-0.3158169090747833,
0.15549924969673157,
0.423784077167511,
0.2561987638473511,
-0.6832480430603027,
-0.11504597216844559,
-0.12417898327112198,
-0.4552929103374481,
-0.003728121519088745,
-0.0877160131931305,
0.36248669028282166,
-0.23697355389595032,
-0.42359471321105957,
-0.2745051681995392,
-0.9286832809448242,
-0.021094340831041336,
0.5988912582397461,
0.32740160822868347,
-0.14406070113182068,
0.6673732399940491,
-0.06542845070362091,
0.6399651169776917,
-0.33941641449928284,
-0.13222716748714447,
0.3318375051021576,
-0.44485536217689514,
-0.048186954110860825,
-0.3156852424144745,
1.0289536714553833,
0.42041081190109253,
0.2523384094238281,
-0.45479705929756165,
-0.1546175479888916,
-0.32410624623298645,
0.42635199427604675,
-0.6838149428367615,
-0.4501858949661255,
0.1965332180261612,
-0.24635612964630127,
-0.019617611542344093,
-0.007603546604514122,
-0.4243006110191345,
-0.2947567105293274,
-0.19472576677799225,
0.3195449113845825,
-0.7533516883850098,
-0.27426889538764954,
-0.1951715052127838,
0.1185031458735466,
0.1513817310333252,
0.43040287494659424,
-0.5508151650428772,
0.3516010344028473,
1.1549655199050903,
0.8836379647254944,
-0.20570486783981323,
-0.8378502130508423,
-0.8937650918960571,
0.029102815315127373,
-0.11477961391210556,
0.7033731937408447,
-0.41915297508239746,
-0.35149240493774414,
-0.1726866364479065,
-0.11193674057722092,
-0.18286052346229553,
-0.6085682511329651,
0.6526050567626953,
-0.42301884293556213,
0.14011706411838531,
-0.3539508879184723,
-0.5003924369812012,
-0.13725721836090088,
0.5112327337265015,
-0.5699295997619629,
0.8571967482566833,
0.08085651695728302,
-0.9019899964332581,
0.33659929037094116,
-0.5416291356086731,
-0.4868892431259155,
0.3113194704055786,
-0.2720484733581543,
-0.5490572452545166,
-0.14298707246780396,
-0.027981938794255257,
0.41988441348075867,
-0.2864778935909271,
0.06974256783723831,
-0.4828711748123169,
-0.4761655032634735,
0.31634998321533203,
-0.36852818727493286,
0.4351401925086975,
0.19174343347549438,
-0.4009084403514862,
0.2510550320148468,
-0.46665140986442566,
-0.007955020293593407,
0.10077240318059921,
-0.378621906042099,
0.1523028463125229,
0.1491805762052536,
0.22702190279960632,
0.21663343906402588,
0.4589797854423523,
-0.390188604593277,
0.03096088580787182,
0.0379800908267498,
0.5783699154853821,
0.7160966396331787,
-0.2723962068557739,
0.07664001733064651,
-0.4843847453594208,
0.6970377564430237,
-0.18939223885536194,
0.22908610105514526,
-0.11191824823617935,
-0.5827900171279907,
-0.07322214543819427,
-0.3730388283729553,
0.39643242955207825,
0.790978729724884,
-0.49544766545295715,
0.3287299573421478,
-0.24053913354873657,
-0.4026438593864441,
0.07236247509717941,
0.3929896652698517,
0.6992282271385193,
0.6467205286026001,
0.15923087298870087,
-0.38533443212509155,
-0.3941427171230316,
-0.7796639800071716,
-0.20912641286849976,
-0.2986765205860138,
-0.613283097743988,
0.18340818583965302,
0.6655440330505371,
0.11890609562397003,
0.8095006346702576,
-0.03931909054517746,
-0.37050485610961914,
-0.45804592967033386,
0.3040558397769928,
0.023798424750566483,
0.3835875988006592,
0.363496333360672,
-0.8211876153945923,
-0.5192944407463074,
-0.05500616505742073,
-0.6015030741691589,
-0.19884459674358368,
0.23454979062080383,
0.317104697227478,
-0.04910231754183769,
0.3082953691482544,
-0.4345383644104004,
0.2280368208885193,
0.6922165751457214,
-0.08728066086769104,
0.7214294672012329,
-0.5758131146430969,
0.34890350699424744,
-1.0096194744110107,
0.3070571720600128,
0.03178027272224426,
-0.25867778062820435,
-0.46731773018836975,
-0.03701051324605942,
0.2573086619377136,
-0.36230236291885376,
-0.6026570200920105,
-0.0887269526720047,
-0.40639209747314453,
-0.11189888417720795,
-0.33205926418304443,
0.354074627161026,
-0.15449191629886627,
0.5146433711051941,
-0.29570168256759644,
0.9941901564598083,
0.5772290825843811,
-0.06293094903230667,
0.4013548791408539,
-0.018273184075951576,
-0.3704166114330292,
0.5549342036247253,
-0.9665902853012085,
0.3000337481498718,
0.1942710280418396,
0.17211832106113434,
-1.1441246271133423,
-0.40634670853614807,
0.2398737668991089,
-0.3387543559074402,
0.41314104199409485,
-0.4658791720867157,
-0.8483526110649109,
-0.11746949702501297,
-0.37662410736083984,
0.20385006070137024,
0.5881414413452148,
-0.0950799360871315,
0.5982956290245056,
0.3289273679256439,
-0.2578235864639282,
-0.6477459073066711,
-0.49586188793182373,
0.449136346578598,
-0.18378975987434387,
-0.5531343817710876,
0.4507492482662201,
-0.05220789834856987,
-0.1320107877254486,
-0.09843796491622925,
-0.10173540562391281,
0.12342391908168793,
0.030962858349084854,
0.4119085669517517,
0.24976259469985962,
0.09693848341703415,
-0.5176025032997131,
-0.5838269591331482,
-0.3021271228790283,
0.05439503490924835,
-0.006727005820721388,
0.5031581521034241,
-0.41401591897010803,
-0.6020910143852234,
-0.601579487323761,
0.16423742473125458,
0.7627904415130615,
-0.0846666693687439,
0.37788283824920654,
0.45554548501968384,
-0.2292250692844391,
0.35457491874694824,
-0.5095922350883484,
-0.06217389181256294,
-0.4465182423591614,
0.5257148146629333,
-0.4445449709892273,
-0.8185371160507202,
0.661953866481781,
-0.0385190024971962,
0.18163737654685974,
0.08400538563728333,
0.45389941334724426,
0.12052000313997269,
0.9788475632667542,
0.3897121548652649,
-0.03638024628162384,
0.5227332711219788,
-0.16841165721416473,
-0.06549893319606781,
-0.8604129552841187,
-0.07411004602909088,
-0.5188078284263611,
-0.07165536284446716,
-0.4711483418941498,
-0.3043803572654724,
0.3306824266910553,
0.0898512601852417,
-0.21338653564453125,
0.6443930268287659,
-0.45696282386779785,
0.41877052187919617,
0.7340048551559448,
0.1010797992348671,
0.21616706252098083,
-0.1425008922815323,
-0.1957685947418213,
-0.22200404107570648,
-0.39215800166130066,
-0.7781920433044434,
1.2793149948120117,
0.31559324264526367,
0.67652428150177,
0.12191686034202576,
0.41643527150154114,
0.3173501491546631,
0.2871208190917969,
-0.4168456196784973,
0.6220046877861023,
-0.2500835359096527,
-0.21625454723834991,
0.035819169133901596,
-0.569395124912262,
-0.9393185377120972,
0.21569892764091492,
0.10740882158279419,
-1.0227940082550049,
-0.4953509569168091,
0.2618043124675751,
-0.1623222976922989,
0.36864903569221497,
-0.7325014472007751,
1.2938827276229858,
-0.14720574021339417,
-0.44648247957229614,
-0.18727996945381165,
-0.6568955779075623,
0.1468813419342041,
-0.10566888004541397,
-0.11577653139829636,
-0.2678471803665161,
-0.2995138466358185,
0.7328503727912903,
-0.5676971673965454,
0.7335758209228516,
-0.16117247939109802,
-0.015510952100157738,
0.08725392818450928,
0.0008838503272272646,
0.723665177822113,
-0.21518538892269135,
-0.02969563566148281,
0.2006479650735855,
-0.2286500632762909,
-0.4747028946876526,
-0.35995998978614807,
0.7602052092552185,
-0.8448690176010132,
-0.5355306267738342,
-0.4325938820838928,
-0.6516698002815247,
-0.1532173603773117,
0.2521570026874542,
0.3973205089569092,
0.6262971758842468,
0.00036405056016519666,
0.3660087585449219,
0.42513394355773926,
-0.0232187919318676,
0.38686347007751465,
0.45361095666885376,
0.06605232506990433,
-0.6244502663612366,
0.7416136860847473,
0.2314016968011856,
0.2269955575466156,
0.41178497672080994,
0.08297444880008698,
-0.3920290768146515,
-1.3509026765823364,
-0.20238666236400604,
-0.000007721147085248958,
-0.5927079319953918,
-0.10003316402435303,
-0.48997262120246887,
-0.018633278086781502,
-0.32316163182258606,
0.04706792160868645,
-0.4522225856781006,
-0.07245979458093643,
-0.08655692636966705,
0.19289277493953705,
0.17394289374351501,
0.6760244965553284,
0.041229765862226486,
0.22726070880889893,
-0.6280880570411682,
0.2439708709716797,
0.372149795293808,
0.42942699790000916,
-0.19889257848262787,
-0.5613965392112732,
0.036959994584321976,
-0.1064222902059555,
-0.6241610050201416,
-0.7413084506988525,
0.12260769307613373,
0.01861565373837948,
0.6425246596336365,
0.10397165268659592,
0.2457721084356308,
0.28034576773643494,
-0.43927839398384094,
0.8631545305252075,
0.3484797477722168,
-0.8678374290466309,
0.5218669176101685,
-0.6262058615684509,
0.6426039934158325,
0.5488390326499939,
0.09910501539707184,
-0.3247775733470917,
-0.8311907052993774,
-0.44853633642196655,
-1.0423305034637451,
0.7031038403511047,
0.4880593419075012,
-0.14686118066310883,
0.08110858500003815,
0.15849530696868896,
-0.045364197343587875,
0.09802571684122086,
-0.6144694685935974,
-0.2194826900959015,
-0.3196645975112915,
0.06838249415159225,
0.10887757688760757,
-0.30277958512306213,
-0.15081539750099182,
0.23045583069324493,
0.581699550151825,
-0.03879115730524063,
-0.08817987143993378,
0.060453057289123535,
-0.11403599381446838,
-0.09678088128566742,
0.4843280613422394,
0.674121081829071,
1.0870741605758667,
-0.4462309777736664,
0.1535305380821228,
0.26023566722869873,
-0.8656311631202698,
-0.11228425800800323,
0.5444433689117432,
0.07876664400100708,
-0.22185109555721283,
0.42844584584236145,
0.4108448922634125,
0.2986535429954529,
-0.8563449382781982,
0.7287304997444153,
-0.4303168058395386,
-0.17992930114269257,
-0.3304980397224426,
-0.059468839317560196,
-0.1387432962656021,
0.11152943968772888,
0.7298151850700378,
0.1867806315422058,
-0.10691707581281662,
-0.3471682071685791,
0.39529258012771606,
0.30938559770584106,
-0.35602912306785583,
-0.4649553596973419,
0.8761962652206421,
0.024100206792354584,
-0.48202502727508545,
0.5456389784812927,
-0.20817993581295013,
-0.5885820388793945,
0.5628151297569275,
0.19575563073158264,
0.9532223343849182,
0.021944940090179443,
-0.026658138260245323,
-0.03414112329483032,
0.21426038444042206,
-0.08940652012825012,
0.24054475128650665,
-0.09336476773023605,
-0.27458351850509644,
-0.8501985669136047,
-0.19171832501888275,
-0.9878799915313721,
0.29674291610717773,
-0.47446247935295105,
0.08689169585704803,
-0.38428711891174316,
-0.4071033000946045,
-0.08389820903539658,
0.21831557154655457,
-0.3199198544025421,
-0.21436001360416412,
0.059383708983659744,
0.7378320097923279,
-0.3387940227985382,
0.9849765300750732,
0.7195258140563965,
-0.169778510928154,
-0.789272665977478,
0.14809444546699524,
0.16889040172100067,
-0.5353963971138,
0.4453991949558258,
0.26601704955101013,
-0.14525599777698517,
-0.3917911648750305,
-0.19730721414089203,
-0.5392314791679382,
1.0714643001556396,
0.779204785823822,
-0.42842167615890503,
0.15222133696079254,
0.3205249607563019,
0.40437987446784973,
-0.022891687229275703,
0.26759713888168335,
0.3340848684310913,
0.4372614622116089,
0.34016773104667664,
-1.3894356489181519,
0.1641577184200287,
-0.30594775080680847,
0.009598908945918083,
0.188461035490036,
-0.5216784477233887,
0.8606100082397461,
-0.2234903872013092,
0.014986966736614704,
0.24831236898899078,
0.5253760814666748,
0.4124889671802521,
0.07649225741624832,
0.5198552012443542,
0.5098285675048828,
0.4276503324508667,
-0.30859312415122986,
1.0351083278656006,
-0.6501438021659851,
0.48719489574432373,
1.2035313844680786,
-0.46950680017471313,
0.9018276333808899,
0.24748149514198303,
-0.3487890362739563,
0.14302903413772583,
0.39649301767349243,
-0.09233193099498749,
0.5692253708839417,
0.0918508917093277,
-0.2837747633457184,
-0.0749397873878479,
-0.02019892819225788,
-0.4069581627845764,
0.2768503427505493,
-0.01490438636392355,
-0.11240782588720322,
-0.4509847164154053,
0.03765527531504631,
0.30930864810943604,
0.07243695110082626,
-0.08122763782739639,
0.6000487804412842,
-0.06983990222215652,
-0.8423269987106323,
0.5077204704284668,
-0.22063635289669037,
0.6144136190414429,
-0.9315009117126465,
0.15312713384628296,
0.018761398270726204,
0.5348106622695923,
-0.01326912734657526,
-0.9773367643356323,
0.20080995559692383,
0.18907716870307922,
0.07624842971563339,
-0.4518550932407379,
0.5325111150741577,
-0.2913646101951599,
-0.038529008626937866,
0.30889543890953064,
0.24425317347049713,
0.18544916808605194,
-0.21489761769771576,
-0.9265462160110474,
0.28389889001846313,
-0.11724860966205597,
-0.43633708357810974,
0.6108266115188599,
0.1713375449180603,
0.3303232789039612,
0.7975442409515381,
0.39111167192459106,
0.062033817172050476,
-0.19018174707889557,
0.2039007693529129,
0.6803216934204102,
-0.38873013854026794,
-0.2281312346458435,
-0.9720333814620972,
0.24155579507350922,
-0.1201389953494072,
-0.21173542737960815,
0.964199423789978,
0.7830196022987366,
0.8326106667518616,
0.2163367122411728,
0.8177096843719482,
-0.16483940184116364,
0.35288694500923157,
-0.1518545299768448,
0.7196552753448486,
-0.3457639515399933,
0.2959717810153961,
-0.3710212707519531,
-0.614545464515686,
-0.32263949513435364,
0.19230908155441284,
-0.5517826080322266,
0.21563322842121124,
0.6984877586364746,
0.7986217141151428,
-0.1289670318365097,
-0.014293420128524303,
0.39935562014579773,
0.016220735386013985,
0.5393269062042236,
0.7346822023391724,
0.922695517539978,
-0.30581095814704895,
1.3282527923583984,
-0.4424062967300415,
-0.46828609704971313,
-0.03281409665942192,
-1.0935834646224976,
-0.7603774666786194,
-0.3944348394870758,
-0.6502296328544617,
-0.49379244446754456,
0.06766178458929062,
0.824530303478241,
0.7143388986587524,
-0.7865920066833496,
-0.3340459167957306,
-0.15363164246082306,
0.049546923488378525,
-0.42780789732933044,
-0.1763557493686676,
0.4659884572029114,
-0.4322929382324219,
-0.6711615324020386,
0.2913813591003418,
0.4000014662742615,
0.15086017549037933,
-0.10050828754901886,
-0.13947361707687378,
0.027806038036942482,
-0.4279364347457886,
0.2850370705127716,
0.41754305362701416,
-0.7107567191123962,
-0.3290737271308899,
-0.08532882481813431,
-0.22376477718353271,
0.24159447848796844,
1.0152277946472168,
-0.44637784361839294,
0.44810566306114197,
0.5172162055969238,
0.23798613250255585,
0.3389609754085541,
-0.18814808130264282,
0.7529265880584717,
-0.6741069555282593,
0.08563095331192017,
0.3315143585205078,
0.6946626305580139,
0.6141249537467957,
0.04301850497722626,
0.37609851360321045,
0.14810703694820404,
-0.79315185546875,
-0.8303361535072327,
0.14122962951660156,
-1.1695632934570312,
-0.1630709022283554,
0.9082372784614563,
-0.7139120101928711,
-0.24206149578094482,
-0.5045962929725647,
-0.251483678817749,
0.2069961577653885,
-0.41818246245384216,
0.7742335200309753,
0.6498636603355408,
-0.092466339468956,
-0.2430443912744522,
-0.6511588096618652,
0.29855677485466003,
0.2713250517845154,
-0.5385907888412476,
0.45893409848213196,
0.38110339641571045,
0.5571572184562683,
0.22979654371738434,
0.5248662233352661,
-0.23578865826129913,
0.6138958930969238,
-0.05641728639602661,
-0.12653374671936035,
-0.39562293887138367,
0.0018479664577171206,
-0.1341690570116043,
0.8213414549827576,
0.2906731367111206,
-0.2136203497648239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03750v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03750v2
|
German also Hallucinates! Inconsistency Detection in News Summaries with the Absinth Dataset
| 2024-03-06T14:37:30 | 2024-03-14T12:30:54 |
Laura Mascarell, Ribin Chalumattu, Annette Rios
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to remarkable progress on
a wide range of natural language processing tasks. Despite the advances, these
large-sized models still suffer from hallucinating information in their output,
which poses a major issue in automatic text summarization, as we must guarantee
that the generated summary is consistent with the content of the source
document. Previous research addresses the challenging task of detecting
hallucinations in the output (i.e. inconsistency detection) in order to
evaluate the faithfulness of the generated summaries. However, these works
primarily focus on English and recent multilingual approaches lack German data.
This work presents absinth, a manually annotated dataset for hallucination
detection in German news summarization and explores the capabilities of novel
open-source LLMs on this task in both fine-tuning and in-context learning
settings. We open-source and release the absinth dataset to foster further
research on hallucination detection in German.
|
[
-0.3398033678531647,
-0.8581228256225586,
0.6958019733428955,
0.15155106782913208,
-0.4537789523601532,
-0.31422194838523865,
-0.3295695185661316,
-0.6259194016456604,
0.6107329726219177,
0.5404834747314453,
-0.5404196381568909,
-0.7900639772415161,
-0.6193332076072693,
0.46750861406326294,
-0.5568796992301941,
1.0381113290786743,
-0.29303255677223206,
0.20480257272720337,
-0.20992130041122437,
-0.4934495985507965,
-0.3770836293697357,
-0.5138465762138367,
-0.24706104397773743,
-0.3945702016353607,
0.3004204332828522,
0.3872140944004059,
0.5170137286186218,
0.3471989333629608,
0.5826148390769958,
0.19607682526111603,
0.19264274835586548,
0.38784903287887573,
-0.2924479842185974,
0.37799710035324097,
-0.11069847643375397,
-0.12580761313438416,
-0.22968845069408417,
-0.3024289906024933,
0.5379327535629272,
0.5907807350158691,
-0.019188430160284042,
-0.11515743285417557,
-0.11336871981620789,
0.7802776098251343,
-0.42876043915748596,
0.19032934308052063,
-0.7534436583518982,
0.09616206586360931,
-0.15530182421207428,
-0.05858353152871132,
-0.2704658508300781,
-0.4370214343070984,
-0.30822840332984924,
-0.22576695680618286,
0.5405151844024658,
-0.13000744581222534,
0.9383206367492676,
0.4903005361557007,
-0.2641652524471283,
-0.5308684706687927,
-0.5347952842712402,
0.34896543622016907,
-0.7915528416633606,
0.5324011445045471,
0.3888459801673889,
0.08194594085216522,
-0.20777954161167145,
-0.42437267303466797,
-0.4699355661869049,
-0.25555264949798584,
-0.3965141773223877,
0.08773157745599747,
-0.33519500494003296,
-0.24081605672836304,
0.029148202389478683,
0.3585361838340759,
-0.7625495791435242,
0.14987343549728394,
-0.20673403143882751,
-0.20680546760559082,
0.5962960720062256,
-0.09205140173435211,
0.20505906641483307,
-0.15727587044239044,
0.037788718938827515,
0.049034781754016876,
-0.61826491355896,
-0.4435635209083557,
0.28506016731262207,
0.2572438716888428,
-0.25729385018348694,
0.688286304473877,
-0.3695494830608368,
0.45133695006370544,
-0.23446959257125854,
-0.013079262338578701,
0.5290783047676086,
-0.1127893477678299,
-0.10675691068172455,
0.6090209484100342,
0.5152912139892578,
0.3787135183811188,
0.40075841546058655,
-0.21034128963947296,
-0.4292709529399872,
0.30073919892311096,
0.2514888644218445,
-0.7645666003227234,
-0.5783630609512329,
0.42550596594810486,
-0.4162980318069458,
-0.1853310763835907,
0.45310813188552856,
-0.5126590728759766,
-0.5200531482696533,
-0.2056128829717636,
0.19777227938175201,
-0.3709336817264557,
-0.33347561955451965,
0.09200344234704971,
-0.1457728147506714,
-0.19576534628868103,
0.465582937002182,
-0.7320330739021301,
0.05929405987262726,
0.4920102655887604,
0.9223898649215698,
-0.5354048609733582,
-0.4644275903701782,
-0.6043243408203125,
0.0335039384663105,
-0.5498621463775635,
1.0756316184997559,
-0.13795913755893707,
-0.24531501531600952,
-0.010737710632383823,
0.268130362033844,
0.24209366738796234,
-0.7729519605636597,
0.615011990070343,
0.03230839595198631,
0.3664363622665405,
-0.0445796474814415,
-0.430825412273407,
-0.41387495398521423,
0.08129061758518219,
-0.6860416531562805,
0.8032497763633728,
0.07509854435920715,
-0.9676386713981628,
0.2973424196243286,
-0.34577736258506775,
-0.865349531173706,
-0.15954503417015076,
-0.3029237389564514,
-0.6562321186065674,
0.7743222117424011,
0.2798366844654083,
0.32818883657455444,
0.2669109106063843,
0.26539722084999084,
0.049181822687387466,
-0.49606603384017944,
0.30837446451187134,
-0.37321674823760986,
0.6566730737686157,
-0.08188823610544205,
-0.29755473136901855,
0.27221038937568665,
-0.8130559325218201,
-0.44509297609329224,
0.20912669599056244,
0.055994950234889984,
-0.6603441834449768,
-0.10956373810768127,
-0.006600937806069851,
-0.024341154843568802,
0.011565775610506535,
-0.2621013820171356,
-0.03309531509876251,
-0.1939985752105713,
-0.18725943565368652,
0.5047958493232727,
0.31388115882873535,
0.07186581194400787,
-0.5581299066543579,
0.10365770757198334,
0.2734608054161072,
-0.2211393117904663,
-0.5020107626914978,
-0.2998464107513428,
-0.6565700173377991,
-0.11025604605674744,
-0.0014716709265485406,
0.6106742024421692,
-0.7959879636764526,
0.6779606342315674,
-0.12819086015224457,
-0.38718274235725403,
-0.5519089102745056,
0.02221817336976528,
0.15235522389411926,
0.4924011528491974,
0.325419545173645,
-0.4394843578338623,
-0.6123105883598328,
-0.8334563970565796,
-0.37249884009361267,
-0.22066059708595276,
-0.13124233484268188,
0.17115116119384766,
0.8072344064712524,
-0.400000661611557,
0.5527025461196899,
-0.3365650773048401,
-0.8242915272712708,
-0.17117370665073395,
0.3766501843929291,
0.2779178321361542,
0.36040008068084717,
0.4953031539916992,
-0.7409614324569702,
-0.15581530332565308,
0.1063307374715805,
-1.2627485990524292,
-0.3977022171020508,
-0.20855513215065002,
0.29606789350509644,
0.848500669002533,
0.3677440583705902,
-0.5747380256652832,
0.5108308792114258,
0.4493408203125,
-0.2651855945587158,
0.8018574118614197,
-0.23886734247207642,
0.2473590224981308,
-0.9711783528327942,
0.02252819947898388,
-0.08877523243427277,
-0.3416423499584198,
-0.4071754813194275,
-0.12269973754882812,
0.15902885794639587,
0.313985675573349,
-0.3159494698047638,
0.45510807633399963,
-0.4467659294605255,
-0.09034213423728943,
-0.45853593945503235,
0.2146252691745758,
-0.14511629939079285,
0.2738887667655945,
0.31377285718917847,
0.5818356275558472,
0.397135853767395,
-0.4100935757160187,
0.481960266828537,
0.34822747111320496,
-0.41637977957725525,
0.5754077434539795,
-0.2699829638004303,
-0.11418729275465012,
-0.4289908707141876,
0.19850386679172516,
-0.729887068271637,
-0.8166077733039856,
0.359470397233963,
-0.6342952847480774,
0.002694409806281328,
0.27618926763534546,
-0.6824909448623657,
0.012266560457646847,
-0.5004914402961731,
0.05213580280542374,
0.22063834965229034,
-0.3834197223186493,
0.39577341079711914,
0.33075976371765137,
-0.15456783771514893,
-0.4463355243206024,
-0.976545512676239,
0.22029682993888855,
-0.08442321419715881,
-0.41093558073043823,
0.2058151662349701,
0.14370165765285492,
-0.6832367181777954,
0.29256296157836914,
-0.42661088705062866,
0.07882371544837952,
0.16327321529388428,
0.12020393460988998,
0.10833621025085449,
-0.16204217076301575,
0.23938998579978943,
0.16371572017669678,
-0.053542762994766235,
0.11885490268468857,
-0.11610379070043564,
0.4604945182800293,
-0.12635129690170288,
-0.5216163992881775,
-0.6427574157714844,
0.46594974398612976,
0.5670869946479797,
0.08005458116531372,
0.5434284210205078,
0.4769495129585266,
-0.7097492218017578,
-0.2895968556404114,
-0.6171053647994995,
-0.6684770584106445,
-0.2965328097343445,
0.5614216327667236,
-0.2511497735977173,
-0.5908941030502319,
0.6981263160705566,
0.20133650302886963,
0.05088580772280693,
0.4112376868724823,
0.44999226927757263,
0.035017888993024826,
0.8604158759117126,
0.5563124418258667,
-0.13146837055683136,
0.1418466567993164,
0.18439511954784393,
0.1062777042388916,
-0.27781200408935547,
-0.20506815612316132,
-0.38477423787117004,
-0.09573055058717728,
-0.4496302604675293,
0.08996948599815369,
0.4933317005634308,
-0.1178176999092102,
-0.0004267784534022212,
0.00997247640043497,
-0.3387812077999115,
0.6552388668060303,
0.410286545753479,
-0.09870920330286026,
0.9153212904930115,
0.4027581512928009,
0.10907457023859024,
-0.10209169238805771,
-0.4193149507045746,
-0.2701219916343689,
0.5043333768844604,
0.1492946445941925,
0.71278977394104,
0.14472131431102753,
0.768632709980011,
0.5241600871086121,
0.21999700367450714,
-0.697981059551239,
0.38835540413856506,
-0.2785419225692749,
-0.08896424621343613,
-0.2829325497150421,
-0.5164636373519897,
-0.8241236805915833,
0.2943115830421448,
-0.19541266560554504,
-0.7605777382850647,
0.07553331553936005,
-0.26839587092399597,
0.08582991361618042,
0.3181544244289398,
-0.33144599199295044,
0.6174703240394592,
-0.355472207069397,
-0.1268204003572464,
-0.22931821644306183,
-0.5898079872131348,
0.548572301864624,
-0.22060289978981018,
0.27442121505737305,
-0.23332978785037994,
0.14505480229854584,
0.43359020352363586,
-0.21417419612407684,
0.6743013262748718,
0.010111415758728981,
-0.42753341794013977,
-0.22976773977279663,
0.27266618609428406,
0.68943190574646,
0.29429981112480164,
0.15829239785671234,
0.560455858707428,
-0.5133907198905945,
-0.05636945366859436,
-0.29371944069862366,
0.8029903173446655,
-0.4969490170478821,
-0.6569849848747253,
-0.696995198726654,
-0.7038135528564453,
-0.03783208504319191,
0.3425774872303009,
0.6138938069343567,
0.16773554682731628,
-0.2765829861164093,
0.1673697680234909,
0.6549655199050903,
-0.18114957213401794,
0.3603336811065674,
0.6325011849403381,
-0.7022689580917358,
-0.40729761123657227,
0.8236948847770691,
0.14797405898571014,
-0.17653241753578186,
0.003396411892026663,
-0.19280095398426056,
-0.12058266252279282,
-0.6308503150939941,
-0.6594992280006409,
0.5397037267684937,
-0.7785205841064453,
-0.17861436307430267,
-0.6998052597045898,
-0.5266671180725098,
-0.4363333582878113,
-0.11286844313144684,
-0.3255991041660309,
-0.3956604301929474,
-0.3162452280521393,
-0.275733083486557,
0.36004340648651123,
0.8689287900924683,
-0.17307668924331665,
-0.02199944667518139,
-0.7985031604766846,
0.5769439339637756,
-0.2022126466035843,
0.27494901418685913,
-0.24186255037784576,
-0.4391200840473175,
-0.3826412260532379,
-0.005011065397411585,
-0.15171286463737488,
-1.0503935813903809,
0.5846912860870361,
-0.049173567444086075,
0.4720824360847473,
0.5841754078865051,
0.3298225998878479,
0.277622252702713,
-0.19533227384090424,
0.6844901442527771,
0.039506491273641586,
-0.7191571593284607,
0.5633074045181274,
-0.301085889339447,
0.44221168756484985,
0.6073147654533386,
0.2851656377315521,
-0.81794673204422,
-0.8273712992668152,
-0.42636826634407043,
-0.8951045870780945,
0.7697463631629944,
0.3188547194004059,
0.13426046073436737,
-0.02227666787803173,
-0.04749985411763191,
0.7353614568710327,
0.37291818857192993,
-0.7800580263137817,
-0.23393133282661438,
-0.1632402241230011,
-0.1245545744895935,
0.055418457835912704,
-0.131043940782547,
-0.11643955111503601,
-0.22223104536533356,
0.9906942844390869,
-0.041097890585660934,
-0.10824273526668549,
0.3257094919681549,
-0.4726400673389435,
-0.3217465877532959,
-0.011252068914473057,
0.7090997695922852,
0.9173019528388977,
-0.2960171103477478,
0.4305633306503296,
0.24477200210094452,
-0.46805983781814575,
0.10664796084165573,
0.22674401104450226,
-0.44762781262397766,
0.7689505815505981,
0.43263381719589233,
0.8542872071266174,
0.06715144217014313,
-0.8956872224807739,
0.43947455286979675,
-0.10188901424407959,
-0.2941422462463379,
-0.8090270161628723,
-0.013437917456030846,
-0.17889189720153809,
0.14233160018920898,
0.710558295249939,
0.11251824349164963,
0.04429929330945015,
-0.4857196807861328,
0.40011686086654663,
0.22270290553569794,
-0.27035754919052124,
-0.2906559109687805,
0.755181074142456,
-0.05489058047533035,
-0.24812382459640503,
0.8034590482711792,
-0.2882721424102783,
-0.3828446567058563,
0.5377262234687805,
0.487090528011322,
1.1774053573608398,
-0.2188185602426529,
0.4005335867404938,
0.08913349360227585,
0.5336481332778931,
-0.28684428334236145,
0.36091306805610657,
0.06946573406457901,
-0.7818462252616882,
-0.24982866644859314,
-0.3259851336479187,
-0.38395756483078003,
0.32149866223335266,
-0.450473427772522,
0.40315940976142883,
0.0867806151509285,
0.27693626284599304,
-0.2550199329853058,
-0.3806289732456207,
-0.1258009523153305,
-0.16823524236679077,
0.27710220217704773,
0.6475098729133606,
-1.0631084442138672,
0.8992483615875244,
0.5841729044914246,
-0.3237204849720001,
0.019002843648195267,
0.5548389554023743,
0.23800556361675262,
-0.34652698040008545,
0.16463276743888855,
0.5764045119285583,
-0.039962366223335266,
-0.2465493083000183,
-0.3238414525985718,
-0.45403820276260376,
0.776658833026886,
0.5123371481895447,
-0.3534936010837555,
0.15584999322891235,
0.15470077097415924,
0.4233188033103943,
-0.2722339332103729,
-0.13055945932865143,
0.6607944965362549,
0.6956078410148621,
-0.017941996455192566,
-0.7477965354919434,
0.013019043020904064,
-0.27259284257888794,
-0.4420260190963745,
0.24199888110160828,
-0.5335173010826111,
0.8076754212379456,
-0.32839128375053406,
-0.39235255122184753,
-0.12567473948001862,
0.7304486632347107,
0.28198185563087463,
0.7188089489936829,
0.26646551489830017,
0.6964556574821472,
1.037697434425354,
-0.13058532774448395,
0.8822011947631836,
-0.4013349413871765,
0.14011390507221222,
1.2502292394638062,
-0.4791746139526367,
0.49958840012550354,
0.38098010420799255,
0.2593667507171631,
0.47806522250175476,
0.537424623966217,
-0.3171347677707672,
0.43643754720687866,
-0.11666442453861237,
-0.25917884707450867,
0.07418029755353928,
-0.2559633255004883,
-0.5242937803268433,
0.5228586196899414,
0.31145578622817993,
-0.32574647665023804,
-0.5925188064575195,
0.37731966376304626,
0.3200523555278778,
0.04400935769081116,
-0.3070811927318573,
1.0385282039642334,
0.1704229712486267,
-0.7448545694351196,
0.6036348342895508,
0.025838445872068405,
0.6478551626205444,
-0.574268639087677,
-0.21341820061206818,
-0.6631215810775757,
0.2619684338569641,
-0.4063242971897125,
-0.48515263199806213,
0.7512432932853699,
0.08485762774944305,
-0.12058261036872864,
0.02999095804989338,
0.7729418277740479,
-0.5062354207038879,
-0.6345120668411255,
0.37580040097236633,
0.762917697429657,
0.5726436972618103,
-0.39556267857551575,
-0.11420543491840363,
0.04944964125752449,
0.04384196549654007,
-0.19353580474853516,
0.1701287180185318,
0.6786875128746033,
-0.3614071011543274,
0.38593703508377075,
0.33038341999053955,
0.23523859679698944,
-0.3721570074558258,
0.07788035273551941,
0.6273619532585144,
-0.620366632938385,
-0.4772644639015198,
-1.0820566415786743,
0.2486904412508011,
-0.20028585195541382,
-0.27997344732284546,
1.11086106300354,
0.8818359375,
1.1056101322174072,
-0.2653314769268036,
1.0618267059326172,
0.14338812232017517,
0.2859721779823303,
-0.5992816686630249,
1.0774314403533936,
-0.7011036276817322,
0.270908921957016,
0.03383291885256767,
-1.0721598863601685,
-0.5933719873428345,
0.5881446003913879,
0.12701372802257538,
-0.2135787010192871,
0.9424938559532166,
0.7254651188850403,
-0.09009714424610138,
0.23173317313194275,
0.33254411816596985,
0.5431470274925232,
-0.2077351212501526,
0.2695792019367218,
0.5873379707336426,
-0.0943603366613388,
0.178440660238266,
-0.31813251972198486,
-0.024443769827485085,
-0.5125592947006226,
-0.8076267242431641,
-0.8778671026229858,
-0.7587764263153076,
-0.3583344519138336,
-0.4534262418746948,
0.31118178367614746,
0.9824502468109131,
0.17032311856746674,
-1.3756635189056396,
-0.26409295201301575,
-0.20961113274097443,
0.4196775257587433,
-0.4932938814163208,
-0.24785064160823822,
0.6104570627212524,
-0.46251755952835083,
-0.7124034762382507,
0.38674670457839966,
0.30944955348968506,
0.2670237123966217,
-0.205812469124794,
0.05350371077656746,
0.060088761150836945,
-0.022073453292250633,
0.34987667202949524,
0.08897442370653152,
-0.773123562335968,
-0.2520768940448761,
-0.20551569759845734,
0.02925524301826954,
0.28919705748558044,
0.812063992023468,
-0.7949934601783752,
0.40220075845718384,
0.6042125225067139,
0.5140037536621094,
0.32765260338783264,
0.0003771873889490962,
0.3493908941745758,
-0.972287654876709,
0.3777691423892975,
0.20081952214241028,
0.5389500856399536,
0.5134655833244324,
-0.38907545804977417,
0.7241056561470032,
0.44533243775367737,
-0.3899741768836975,
-1.0370781421661377,
0.003999436739832163,
-0.6782597899436951,
-0.7912299036979675,
1.0683188438415527,
0.1526133269071579,
-0.1556781828403473,
-0.2784403860569,
-0.25335389375686646,
0.3154143989086151,
-0.4295588731765747,
1.368106484413147,
0.8911340832710266,
-0.13940955698490143,
-0.16050581634044647,
-0.6379327774047852,
0.5037353038787842,
0.2604233920574188,
-0.9919341206550598,
0.32226812839508057,
0.840277373790741,
-0.1454831212759018,
0.1350964903831482,
0.35625746846199036,
-0.01183648593723774,
0.35310956835746765,
-0.0837937742471695,
0.1845862716436386,
-0.26486650109291077,
-0.6147803664207458,
-0.47454214096069336,
0.2410646677017212,
-0.41164594888687134,
-0.1259276270866394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03737v1
|
Probabilistic Topic Modelling with Transformer Representations
| 2024-03-06T14:27:29 | 2024-03-06T14:27:29 |
Arik Reuter, Anton Thielmann, Christoph Weisser, Benjamin Säfken, Thomas Kneib
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Topic modelling was mostly dominated by Bayesian graphical models during the
last decade. With the rise of transformers in Natural Language Processing,
however, several successful models that rely on straightforward clustering
approaches in transformer-based embedding spaces have emerged and consolidated
the notion of topics as clusters of embedding vectors. We propose the
Transformer-Representation Neural Topic Model (TNTM), which combines the
benefits of topic representations in transformer-based embedding spaces and
probabilistic modelling. Therefore, this approach unifies the powerful and
versatile notion of topics based on transformer embeddings with fully
probabilistic modelling, as in models such as Latent Dirichlet Allocation
(LDA). We utilize the variational autoencoder (VAE) framework for improved
inference speed and modelling flexibility. Experimental results show that our
proposed model achieves results on par with various state-of-the-art approaches
in terms of embedding coherence while maintaining almost perfect topic
diversity. The corresponding source code is available at
https://github.com/ArikReuter/TNTM.
|
[
-0.4834066927433014,
-0.8343839645385742,
0.6041550040245056,
0.19047696888446808,
-0.34193679690361023,
-0.03122037462890148,
-0.11430106312036514,
0.3472699820995331,
0.5289098620414734,
0.6622588634490967,
-0.23463620245456696,
-0.38319408893585205,
-0.7590199708938599,
-0.44664186239242554,
-0.6331110596656799,
0.7195788025856018,
0.07997391372919083,
-0.015106942504644394,
-0.28079473972320557,
0.085889533162117,
-0.5827556252479553,
-0.4174182713031769,
-0.2791929543018341,
-0.3641391396522522,
0.48739275336265564,
0.15222854912281036,
0.5991715788841248,
0.46185067296028137,
0.49468994140625,
0.23190559446811676,
-0.41079822182655334,
-0.33582615852355957,
-0.1991310715675354,
0.19520463049411774,
-0.4342769980430603,
-0.5465176701545715,
-0.17173326015472412,
-0.005980926565825939,
0.5376357436180115,
0.8047424554824829,
-0.4228573143482208,
-0.46075311303138733,
-0.07433365285396576,
0.08312663435935974,
-0.3549730181694031,
0.06888697296380997,
-0.6090488433837891,
0.1042640209197998,
0.14035837352275848,
-0.08770661801099777,
-0.3582457900047302,
-0.1258176863193512,
0.4119190573692322,
-0.055366456508636475,
0.46628537774086,
-0.2799680531024933,
0.5844706296920776,
0.26581212878227234,
-0.7235133647918701,
-0.0627407357096672,
-1.031325101852417,
0.648888111114502,
-0.5202459692955017,
0.28241264820098877,
0.2172362208366394,
0.31296128034591675,
-0.02650786004960537,
-0.8550448417663574,
-0.631292998790741,
-0.13409380614757538,
-0.12842047214508057,
0.2439710944890976,
-0.5357212424278259,
-0.14152854681015015,
-0.251855731010437,
0.5076223015785217,
-0.621013879776001,
0.10390867292881012,
0.14514882862567902,
0.11294763535261154,
0.21403932571411133,
0.19678878784179688,
0.197616845369339,
-0.5259358882904053,
-0.22068001329898834,
-0.08495736122131348,
-0.35211023688316345,
-0.26645490527153015,
0.3597908318042755,
0.18026548624038696,
-0.1420184224843979,
0.5815346240997314,
0.04642685502767563,
0.49177947640419006,
0.20168808102607727,
0.4273791015148163,
0.000037654437619494274,
-0.08314677327871323,
0.10718519240617752,
-0.31909337639808655,
0.8336716890335083,
0.029023269191384315,
-0.2156670242547989,
-0.5588936805725098,
0.02747070975601673,
0.14004899561405182,
0.616715133190155,
-0.7509147524833679,
-0.5552614331245422,
0.2509802579879761,
-0.48231571912765503,
-0.21229742467403412,
0.29858458042144775,
-0.785349428653717,
-0.25189706683158875,
-0.24847760796546936,
0.34648266434669495,
-0.39167752861976624,
-0.6245331168174744,
0.1990441530942917,
-0.004590457305312157,
0.09235912561416626,
0.06038493663072586,
-0.779606282711029,
0.3399752676486969,
0.7378817796707153,
0.7923607230186462,
-0.45842859148979187,
-0.10400568693876266,
-0.08120996505022049,
0.14507853984832764,
-0.3853675425052643,
0.9165476560592651,
-0.7351221442222595,
-0.5472564101219177,
-0.12513741850852966,
0.09292478859424591,
0.10244620591402054,
-0.5145291686058044,
0.4027089476585388,
-0.5847019553184509,
0.5152941346168518,
0.06934714317321777,
-0.783001184463501,
-0.043655674904584885,
0.13411782681941986,
-0.852098822593689,
0.7487649321556091,
0.014314910396933556,
-0.9069542288780212,
0.22222353518009186,
-0.5754725337028503,
-0.09437792003154755,
-0.1628263294696808,
-0.381063848733902,
-0.580483615398407,
0.18060655891895294,
0.20498351752758026,
0.5988587141036987,
-0.6025493741035461,
1.2430106401443481,
0.1274140626192093,
-0.07680830359458923,
0.3997410535812378,
-0.7967042922973633,
0.3113289177417755,
0.06069893017411232,
-0.2703177332878113,
0.4609832167625427,
-0.444378137588501,
-0.7331869006156921,
-0.00507377227768302,
0.13292156159877777,
-0.23533757030963898,
0.28861039876937866,
0.14860107004642487,
0.32599249482154846,
0.10523367673158646,
-0.32134318351745605,
0.10072941333055496,
-0.5822617411613464,
0.4636976420879364,
0.43024206161499023,
0.35594168305397034,
0.8769800662994385,
-0.18448424339294434,
0.44957196712493896,
0.7524352669715881,
-0.11846809834241867,
-0.21454761922359467,
-0.8272077441215515,
-0.5219298601150513,
-0.16334478557109833,
0.4947563707828522,
0.4767647087574005,
-0.7467109560966492,
0.8637099862098694,
-0.21996860206127167,
-0.5915307998657227,
-0.1680099070072174,
-0.5724788904190063,
-0.19424137473106384,
0.15221670269966125,
0.38539767265319824,
-0.3710364103317261,
-0.15352463722229004,
-1.0947787761688232,
0.10210853815078735,
0.025829413905739784,
-0.2463778555393219,
0.21263237297534943,
0.37967196106910706,
-0.32297179102897644,
1.4099105596542358,
-0.6676395535469055,
-0.07978779822587967,
-0.48615512251853943,
0.7058505415916443,
0.597245454788208,
0.699367344379425,
0.5151855945587158,
-1.256312370300293,
-0.2595852017402649,
-0.3789680004119873,
-0.43695348501205444,
0.11761964857578278,
-0.21750834584236145,
-0.10949213057756424,
-0.36934390664100647,
0.2830331325531006,
-0.9044649004936218,
0.5169139504432678,
0.26107749342918396,
-0.47950315475463867,
0.38466358184814453,
-0.34249797463417053,
-0.04086453840136528,
-1.693074345588684,
-0.31869935989379883,
0.20063671469688416,
-0.23023763298988342,
-0.5646701455116272,
-0.28227096796035767,
-0.09394348412752151,
-0.4457431733608246,
-0.301232248544693,
0.49280110001564026,
-0.05265426263213158,
0.16567528247833252,
-0.6784628033638,
-0.12809793651103973,
-0.23992246389389038,
0.3297567665576935,
0.3206525146961212,
0.6303979754447937,
0.8914063572883606,
-0.4510951638221741,
0.3303239941596985,
0.19087697565555573,
0.13935405015945435,
0.27215775847435,
-0.7774512767791748,
-0.2515755593776703,
-0.30841198563575745,
0.41036921739578247,
-0.9692897796630859,
-0.03618470951914787,
0.2678256332874298,
-0.23680418729782104,
0.49519768357276917,
-0.23393474519252777,
-0.5360267162322998,
-0.3360781669616699,
-0.06284993886947632,
0.12551535665988922,
0.6549960970878601,
-0.37381741404533386,
0.879173994064331,
0.4552766680717468,
-0.2932935059070587,
-0.35666653513908386,
-0.48927173018455505,
0.17485101521015167,
-0.2721238136291504,
-0.3185569643974304,
1.0076829195022583,
0.07453740388154984,
0.0772949829697609,
0.5040819644927979,
-0.025308549404144287,
-0.23790323734283447,
-0.03511942923069,
0.22628699243068695,
-0.12642931938171387,
-0.24194571375846863,
0.17431622743606567,
0.09681030362844467,
-0.5753318667411804,
-0.061476245522499084,
-0.5749029517173767,
0.8940143585205078,
-0.010326014831662178,
-0.5245692729949951,
-0.35483518242836,
0.5395047664642334,
0.25007858872413635,
-0.2712174654006958,
1.002698540687561,
0.6977295875549316,
-0.6132397651672363,
-0.16188356280326843,
-0.29382920265197754,
-0.6395729184150696,
-0.43358322978019714,
0.6011123061180115,
-0.15665991604328156,
-0.9526693820953369,
0.5902641415596008,
-0.31555140018463135,
-0.35658934712409973,
0.7145295143127441,
0.8227864503860474,
-0.22032654285430908,
0.5662945508956909,
0.9100581407546997,
-0.0037624742835760117,
0.6413612365722656,
-0.5423663854598999,
0.5047309398651123,
-0.5164339542388916,
-0.10091684013605118,
-0.365250825881958,
-0.1649225354194641,
-1.0258725881576538,
-0.8945043683052063,
-0.10543755441904068,
0.14075793325901031,
-0.01955663412809372,
0.4905051589012146,
-0.5052920579910278,
0.2990458011627197,
0.6551070809364319,
-0.0010377614526078105,
-0.1465752273797989,
0.15850482881069183,
0.05863727256655693,
-0.2499445676803589,
-0.8302109837532043,
-0.7582964897155762,
0.8393364548683167,
0.4552236795425415,
0.6639436483383179,
0.010282943956553936,
0.7178417444229126,
0.28856009244918823,
0.4219285249710083,
-0.4945434331893921,
0.5184323787689209,
-0.6712203025817871,
-0.4429866373538971,
-0.22576427459716797,
-0.4340841770172119,
-0.9072549343109131,
0.24374467134475708,
-0.08644548803567886,
-0.9365727305412292,
0.6500396132469177,
-0.09767572581768036,
-0.1298147439956665,
0.6922499537467957,
-0.15803903341293335,
1.0096158981323242,
0.2009247988462448,
-0.3048084080219269,
-0.33515143394470215,
-0.3570300042629242,
-0.06327371299266815,
0.0002586432092357427,
-0.2097027599811554,
-0.07303104549646378,
0.18559473752975464,
0.821365237236023,
-0.12518876791000366,
0.9593290686607361,
-0.21840892732143402,
-0.0898827314376831,
0.5035371780395508,
-0.15219932794570923,
0.2314055860042572,
0.4837171733379364,
-0.01011473499238491,
0.07391335815191269,
-0.43391290307044983,
-0.25382527709007263,
-0.7948279976844788,
0.4660017490386963,
-0.8915095329284668,
-0.682164192199707,
-0.4870418310165405,
-0.5111318230628967,
-0.0956118181347847,
-0.05887943506240845,
0.3049735128879547,
0.464938759803772,
-0.3045537769794464,
0.4261416792869568,
0.7377277612686157,
-0.5450466275215149,
0.5628006458282471,
0.35001736879348755,
-0.2569827735424042,
-0.32200154662132263,
1.1177926063537598,
0.07598181813955307,
-0.2566772699356079,
0.833696722984314,
0.23949392139911652,
-0.195553258061409,
-0.5577608942985535,
0.0775543749332428,
0.14630213379859924,
-0.7202215790748596,
-0.035221949219703674,
-1.0315370559692383,
-0.5189724564552307,
-0.10229840129613876,
-0.09810256212949753,
-0.5800296068191528,
-0.4132081866264343,
-0.5818902254104614,
-0.14931869506835938,
0.30369073152542114,
0.6087585687637329,
-0.12391114234924316,
0.7280440330505371,
-0.4331634044647217,
0.6595742106437683,
0.4794224202632904,
0.3749120831489563,
-0.060277245938777924,
-0.5630378127098083,
0.03307140991091728,
-0.1600729078054428,
-0.6027690768241882,
-1.1224074363708496,
0.656955361366272,
-0.18376782536506653,
0.836432158946991,
0.06821919232606888,
-0.03174378350377083,
-0.16065868735313416,
-0.44470876455307007,
0.9159793257713318,
0.24475912749767303,
-0.7258650064468384,
0.6286550164222717,
-0.42978450655937195,
0.11357638984918594,
0.08586011081933975,
0.5626193284988403,
-0.4251869022846222,
-0.5994393825531006,
-0.8128188848495483,
-1.1686369180679321,
0.45700860023498535,
0.5312619805335999,
0.5323094725608826,
-0.43060728907585144,
0.3101661205291748,
0.3176236152648926,
0.20748060941696167,
-0.7563050985336304,
-0.31053683161735535,
-0.5398603677749634,
-0.39161810278892517,
-0.0349617600440979,
-0.5362323522567749,
0.2140013724565506,
-0.10605163872241974,
0.6013147234916687,
-0.07177044451236725,
0.9103416204452515,
-0.16296476125717163,
-0.0877191498875618,
0.2153928428888321,
0.4021945297718048,
0.2076362818479538,
0.6003823280334473,
-0.3139011859893799,
0.3246907889842987,
-0.11629793792963028,
-0.27879366278648376,
0.38625583052635193,
0.4854237735271454,
-0.14534249901771545,
0.30034711956977844,
0.1524931788444519,
0.836885929107666,
0.2333780825138092,
-0.20110668241977692,
0.5312753319740295,
-0.3628416061401367,
-0.07903482764959335,
-0.12990964949131012,
-0.03474975749850273,
0.6973075866699219,
0.36249208450317383,
0.5571722388267517,
0.013486881740391254,
0.06009528040885925,
-0.3865509033203125,
0.6637520790100098,
-0.06649761646986008,
-0.505096971988678,
-0.3617513179779053,
0.8603875637054443,
-0.009392543695867062,
-0.44731801748275757,
0.4368032217025757,
-0.4271312654018402,
-0.5242085456848145,
0.9358558058738708,
0.6339812874794006,
1.0712977647781372,
-0.2516070008277893,
0.6407430768013,
0.10597065091133118,
0.1378253549337387,
-0.1316574215888977,
0.4050314128398895,
0.1924574077129364,
-0.7947595119476318,
-0.4142530560493469,
-0.5918875932693481,
-0.4686252474784851,
-0.04180115461349487,
-0.5322076678276062,
0.006535592954605818,
0.0065255360677838326,
-0.32834291458129883,
0.00280533405020833,
-0.298580527305603,
-0.5292439460754395,
0.3696177899837494,
0.0688815712928772,
0.598403811454773,
-0.9603792428970337,
0.9267838001251221,
0.7265557646751404,
-0.3053237795829773,
-0.31435731053352356,
0.5495430827140808,
-0.6939422488212585,
0.162048801779747,
0.6059451699256897,
0.08502695709466934,
0.3604046404361725,
0.024408450350165367,
-0.1387065201997757,
-0.8892098665237427,
1.0425622463226318,
0.35108086466789246,
-0.6788480877876282,
0.04374565929174423,
0.4419046938419342,
0.6111195683479309,
-0.331765741109848,
0.35794010758399963,
0.10922318696975708,
0.01788952201604843,
0.0258199293166399,
-0.29446256160736084,
-0.17111076414585114,
-0.06265725195407867,
0.2871307134628296,
0.16254951059818268,
-0.37635189294815063,
0.9809035062789917,
0.3223086893558502,
0.1678979992866516,
-0.13110488653182983,
1.0347625017166138,
0.11133137345314026,
0.03831939026713371,
0.2618558406829834,
0.6218239068984985,
0.48857995867729187,
-0.3700031638145447,
0.9930095076560974,
-0.6372275352478027,
0.5818074941635132,
0.9980271458625793,
-0.051096465438604355,
0.622032105922699,
0.286605566740036,
-0.2723250091075897,
0.371609091758728,
0.6340916752815247,
0.025216812267899513,
1.0295019149780273,
0.243854358792305,
-0.15773877501487732,
-0.24442724883556366,
-0.07777075469493866,
-0.27089449763298035,
0.4296605885028839,
0.45296597480773926,
-0.39080873131752014,
-0.32919856905937195,
0.1558437943458557,
-0.4536183774471283,
0.06647729873657227,
0.10802792757749557,
0.7351788878440857,
0.2765216529369354,
-0.26913776993751526,
-0.13064666092395782,
0.4441435635089874,
0.8585854768753052,
-0.4279385507106781,
0.10149016231298447,
-0.4504183530807495,
-0.1314174383878708,
0.33276814222335815,
-0.8897024393081665,
0.6297593712806702,
-0.1972968429327011,
-0.4873062074184418,
-0.42415687441825867,
0.9109637141227722,
-0.5676375031471252,
-0.7204363346099854,
0.3220038414001465,
0.5873539447784424,
-0.25603967905044556,
-0.0879746749997139,
-0.578705906867981,
-0.5019465684890747,
-0.43204355239868164,
-0.5037602782249451,
0.19677862524986267,
0.6247300505638123,
-0.15958447754383087,
0.49553120136260986,
0.19587643444538116,
-0.09766536206007004,
-0.0702233538031578,
0.30795031785964966,
0.8594716787338257,
-0.8186870217323303,
-0.897513210773468,
-0.9525099396705627,
0.4705323576927185,
-0.027352431789040565,
-0.09249275177717209,
0.34162524342536926,
0.4082184433937073,
0.24057675898075104,
-0.13871759176254272,
0.568660318851471,
0.13075703382492065,
0.2813262939453125,
-0.35992276668548584,
0.7139810919761658,
-0.3775345981121063,
0.22583767771720886,
-0.30663779377937317,
-1.0004240274429321,
-0.25456005334854126,
0.7112321853637695,
-0.5315989255905151,
-0.042284976691007614,
0.45067062973976135,
0.6270685195922852,
-0.4829528331756592,
0.24616144597530365,
0.3235132694244385,
0.11954376101493835,
0.5150809288024902,
0.44021737575531006,
1.0301004648208618,
-0.1955825537443161,
0.11340229958295822,
-0.4243493676185608,
0.006652244366705418,
-0.20912662148475647,
-0.8835607171058655,
-0.7330999970436096,
-0.8698886036872864,
-0.6187583208084106,
0.173141211271286,
-0.014719228260219097,
0.6566827893257141,
0.7440987825393677,
-0.8581515550613403,
0.008757738396525383,
-0.5378651022911072,
0.2539496123790741,
-0.035582464188337326,
-0.28546416759490967,
0.6067060828208923,
-0.0351867601275444,
-0.3470118045806885,
0.14808885753154755,
0.3715638518333435,
0.13830474019050598,
-0.39424848556518555,
0.22731299698352814,
-0.146650031208992,
0.17588171362876892,
0.426103800535202,
-0.3733000159263611,
-0.699708104133606,
0.07131009548902512,
-0.037731848657131195,
-0.13967515528202057,
0.2901917099952698,
0.903617799282074,
-0.9042915105819702,
0.13542667031288147,
0.4109678566455841,
0.8502630591392517,
0.7289348244667053,
-0.24434980750083923,
0.7084022164344788,
-0.8724420070648193,
0.28826627135276794,
0.5264942049980164,
0.518852949142456,
0.3436480164527893,
-0.17058655619621277,
0.22100326418876648,
0.32439929246902466,
-0.261115163564682,
-0.6136965155601501,
0.30333927273750305,
-0.7284047603607178,
-0.6434444785118103,
0.8097370862960815,
0.0066170054487884045,
0.03510395437479019,
-0.01862461306154728,
-0.05404331162571907,
0.5522522330284119,
-0.19856151938438416,
0.8335440158843994,
0.46251770853996277,
0.11464077979326248,
-0.44076934456825256,
-0.46962422132492065,
-0.003780720056965947,
0.42629778385162354,
-0.8487588763237,
-0.13706684112548828,
-0.007992771454155445,
0.20187807083129883,
0.32026970386505127,
0.4438212513923645,
0.1502046287059784,
0.09695032238960266,
0.00047155588981695473,
-0.007707386277616024,
0.3860662579536438,
-0.5415284037590027,
-0.21164532005786896,
0.5328876376152039,
-0.22310754656791687,
0.08172424882650375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03690v1
|
Rapidly Developing High-quality Instruction Data and Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models with Minimal Human Effort: A Case Study on Japanese
| 2024-03-06T13:17:07 | 2024-03-06T13:17:07 |
Yikun Sun, Zhen Wan, Nobuhiro Ueda, Sakiko Yahata, Fei Cheng, Chenhui Chu, Sadao Kurohashi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The creation of instruction data and evaluation benchmarks for serving Large
language models often involves enormous human annotation. This issue becomes
particularly pronounced when rapidly developing such resources for a
non-English language like Japanese. Instead of following the popular practice
of directly translating existing English resources into Japanese (e.g.,
Japanese-Alpaca), we propose an efficient self-instruct method based on GPT-4.
We first translate a small amount of English instructions into Japanese and
post-edit them to obtain native-level quality. GPT-4 then utilizes them as
demonstrations to automatically generate Japanese instruction data. We also
construct an evaluation benchmark containing 80 questions across 8 categories,
using GPT-4 to automatically assess the response quality of LLMs without human
references. The empirical results suggest that the models fine-tuned on our
GPT-4 self-instruct data significantly outperformed the Japanese-Alpaca across
all three base pre-trained models. Our GPT-4 self-instruct data allowed the
LLaMA 13B model to defeat GPT-3.5 (Davinci-003) with a 54.37\% win-rate. The
human evaluation exhibits the consistency between GPT-4's assessments and human
preference. Our high-quality instruction data and evaluation benchmark have
been released here.
|
[
-0.3794887661933899,
-0.781307578086853,
0.6076205968856812,
0.15511967241764069,
-0.1596403419971466,
0.07264597713947296,
-0.35040464997291565,
-0.40262508392333984,
-0.13137583434581757,
0.42372632026672363,
-0.47460266947746277,
-0.6754980087280273,
-0.4111935794353485,
0.2578606605529785,
-0.10834457725286484,
0.9624918699264526,
-0.25296762585639954,
0.10919322818517685,
0.03431325778365135,
-0.06550014764070511,
-0.5062896609306335,
-0.5713690519332886,
-0.6480936408042908,
-0.28610849380493164,
0.1423238068819046,
0.42635685205459595,
0.7294254302978516,
0.8311824798583984,
0.3902680575847626,
0.3068258762359619,
0.42446380853652954,
0.12424110621213913,
-0.37148672342300415,
-0.18078641593456268,
-0.19907145202159882,
-0.3713602125644684,
-0.3755906820297241,
0.31377455592155457,
0.6589892506599426,
0.5510321259498596,
-0.2759554088115692,
0.40408915281295776,
0.13902246952056885,
0.5081362724304199,
-0.49310606718063354,
0.3957183361053467,
-0.32795506715774536,
0.16900435090065002,
-0.2540944814682007,
-0.20924173295497894,
-0.38041478395462036,
-0.495881587266922,
0.017548365518450737,
-0.8068609833717346,
0.45647603273391724,
-0.023354366421699524,
0.7167298197746277,
0.24213603138923645,
-0.18974238634109497,
-0.29497528076171875,
-0.5032397508621216,
0.6594935059547424,
-0.6457509398460388,
0.44304823875427246,
0.6327143311500549,
0.2972640097141266,
-0.28755906224250793,
-0.553459644317627,
-0.3874131143093109,
-0.46658945083618164,
0.15177704393863678,
0.26851144433021545,
0.022292938083410263,
-0.022795379161834717,
0.30562546849250793,
0.22257660329341888,
-0.6628944277763367,
0.37420547008514404,
-0.13901038467884064,
-0.16522741317749023,
0.6378092169761658,
0.12612104415893555,
0.29346925020217896,
-0.2692811191082001,
-0.20296767354011536,
-0.3696310520172119,
-0.7696689963340759,
-0.17331600189208984,
0.4732343554496765,
0.17581549286842346,
-0.0312822125852108,
0.4251694977283478,
-0.2988094687461853,
0.38507017493247986,
0.14385037124156952,
-0.2974501848220825,
0.31116983294487,
-0.29062262177467346,
0.1060565784573555,
-0.05573839694261551,
1.0599758625030518,
0.3588756024837494,
0.14923278987407684,
-0.2227490246295929,
-0.28577345609664917,
0.10515427589416504,
0.1420089453458786,
-0.9829207062721252,
-0.1805696189403534,
-0.40034255385398865,
-0.3971181809902191,
0.08913637697696686,
-0.23183110356330872,
-0.7893612384796143,
-0.045400600880384445,
-0.10995058715343475,
0.6940611004829407,
-0.35472312569618225,
0.05282050743699074,
0.12493574619293213,
0.32978951930999756,
0.3208136260509491,
0.293202668428421,
-0.9939149022102356,
0.45018264651298523,
0.44942229986190796,
0.6807124614715576,
-0.18031929433345795,
-0.3846065402030945,
-0.23758229613304138,
0.12991702556610107,
-0.49624815583229065,
0.7014238238334656,
-0.4390430152416229,
-0.5794873833656311,
-0.3594028353691101,
0.05745327100157738,
0.16618315875530243,
-0.46420639753341675,
0.5026487708091736,
-0.28779879212379456,
0.550485372543335,
-0.22076696157455444,
-0.6670734882354736,
-0.21623459458351135,
0.131668820977211,
-0.5482699871063232,
0.9679052829742432,
0.2172464281320572,
-0.5470736622810364,
0.18526141345500946,
-0.8973272442817688,
-0.43512803316116333,
0.22300508618354797,
-0.289978563785553,
-0.39156240224838257,
-0.10501213371753693,
0.5681230425834656,
0.49693796038627625,
-0.5339252948760986,
0.16469275951385498,
-0.15281029045581818,
-0.522112250328064,
-0.10117495805025101,
-0.8016095757484436,
0.41579219698905945,
0.010207985527813435,
-0.7551507949829102,
-0.3470955789089203,
-0.6240732669830322,
0.09505666792392731,
0.49461013078689575,
-0.31780165433883667,
-0.26490554213523865,
-0.15556582808494568,
-0.5706782937049866,
-0.05058391019701958,
0.30325475335121155,
-0.4234805107116699,
0.4343096911907196,
-0.1795043647289276,
0.2189478874206543,
0.7245754599571228,
0.13145744800567627,
0.28817299008369446,
0.08158735930919647,
0.7068678736686707,
-0.399743914604187,
0.37574392557144165,
-0.26644107699394226,
-0.6061680912971497,
-0.7097617387771606,
0.052778542041778564,
0.18665829300880432,
0.36767080426216125,
-0.852574348449707,
0.2280866950750351,
-0.13415998220443726,
-0.5567257404327393,
-0.8027923703193665,
0.3071281611919403,
0.6658269762992859,
0.6464627385139465,
0.4959758520126343,
-0.4672529995441437,
-0.15649627149105072,
-1.0025266408920288,
0.02222413755953312,
-0.16361486911773682,
-0.008176209405064583,
0.07751773297786713,
0.30540353059768677,
-0.26820874214172363,
0.43594539165496826,
-0.4358736276626587,
0.0030326859559863806,
-0.042124658823013306,
0.4506513476371765,
0.20291103422641754,
0.43545252084732056,
0.43482381105422974,
-0.14934541285037994,
-0.4775443971157074,
0.012491882778704166,
-0.7815262675285339,
-0.1076020672917366,
0.010313418693840504,
-0.37155792117118835,
0.15534546971321106,
0.08506251126527786,
-0.40029770135879517,
0.29268190264701843,
0.427756667137146,
-0.06276620924472809,
0.4303825795650482,
-0.43667474389076233,
0.5093000531196594,
-0.8761165142059326,
-0.03187178075313568,
0.1272844523191452,
-0.08361274749040604,
-0.28379109501838684,
0.08394733816385269,
0.27864548563957214,
-0.1458202749490738,
-0.15959444642066956,
0.45608842372894287,
-0.5995107293128967,
-0.2625565230846405,
-0.2106160670518875,
0.001975111896172166,
-0.0066789244301617146,
0.7160542607307434,
0.12260599434375763,
1.126812219619751,
0.053258828818798065,
-0.3172338008880615,
0.17830215394496918,
0.22867561876773834,
-0.503966212272644,
0.2923460900783539,
-0.5705693364143372,
0.4574928283691406,
0.013439067639410496,
0.18885105848312378,
-0.6901922821998596,
-0.21669451892375946,
0.3759690225124359,
-0.11513852328062057,
0.3570621907711029,
-0.32603365182876587,
-0.5488792657852173,
-0.442267507314682,
-0.1531466543674469,
0.17391790449619293,
0.6897017359733582,
-0.7581692337989807,
0.1689305305480957,
0.2143174260854721,
-0.28725266456604004,
-0.6220582127571106,
-0.422690749168396,
0.05432286486029625,
-0.15983422100543976,
-0.08810610324144363,
0.12969523668289185,
-0.1864449828863144,
0.24113105237483978,
0.025686051696538925,
-0.03752076253294945,
-0.14479605853557587,
0.08783932030200958,
0.07405486702919006,
0.376025915145874,
-0.28565365076065063,
-0.07855723798274994,
0.05885320156812668,
-0.23253858089447021,
0.11017120629549026,
-0.05466005206108093,
0.418436735868454,
-0.2352174073457718,
-0.6561159491539001,
-0.8812670111656189,
0.18537840247154236,
0.2101811021566391,
-0.2637075185775757,
0.21732233464717865,
0.5745216608047485,
-0.055674958974123,
-0.20603255927562714,
-0.7396232485771179,
-0.168557807803154,
-0.5048176646232605,
0.5505043268203735,
-0.42846938967704773,
-0.5914537906646729,
0.1752283275127411,
0.1293845772743225,
0.08307970315217972,
0.4146570563316345,
0.3682944178581238,
-0.06953270733356476,
1.189977765083313,
0.37809035181999207,
-0.22239281237125397,
0.37087422609329224,
-0.42880868911743164,
-0.15016993880271912,
-0.6456501483917236,
-0.11876300722360611,
-0.3499221205711365,
-0.043181274086236954,
-0.6483360528945923,
-0.534867525100708,
0.4558646082878113,
-0.10170191526412964,
-0.3792094886302948,
0.3974314033985138,
-0.5606235861778259,
0.7064729332923889,
0.5298196077346802,
0.10373452305793762,
0.3469352126121521,
-0.00646974565461278,
0.11726192384958267,
-0.26287341117858887,
-0.6461445689201355,
-0.6156061887741089,
1.3630139827728271,
0.39515823125839233,
1.020546793937683,
-0.0000981887205853127,
1.0044050216674805,
0.2755354940891266,
0.6619759798049927,
-0.597239077091217,
0.47746872901916504,
-0.10046211630105972,
-0.42621541023254395,
-0.3219633102416992,
-0.647188127040863,
-1.0465905666351318,
0.06595110148191452,
0.0012163257924839854,
-0.3004589378833771,
-0.263052761554718,
0.07418815791606903,
-0.28845781087875366,
0.1004425436258316,
-0.9510149955749512,
0.9454759955406189,
-0.6739521026611328,
-0.4285639822483063,
-0.1927015483379364,
-0.3444771468639374,
0.4084436595439911,
-0.19968266785144806,
0.2300523817539215,
-0.26475343108177185,
-0.16447705030441284,
0.9153832197189331,
-0.3000418543815613,
0.8265425562858582,
-0.42348238825798035,
-0.19147011637687683,
0.37058040499687195,
0.07144622504711151,
0.49153217673301697,
-0.03755982965230942,
-0.19459432363510132,
0.14329122006893158,
-0.1515159159898758,
-0.43951407074928284,
-0.8388671278953552,
0.6238937377929688,
-1.1151036024093628,
-0.6912667751312256,
-0.16194598376750946,
-0.23876269161701202,
-0.3798883259296417,
0.11449389159679413,
0.2579749524593353,
0.45615580677986145,
-0.29215219616889954,
-0.07713504880666733,
0.3846006691455841,
-0.3190268576145172,
0.41226014494895935,
0.8039959669113159,
-0.020258096978068352,
-0.5273333787918091,
0.9718508124351501,
0.3835417628288269,
0.24928884208202362,
0.18481658399105072,
0.3474969267845154,
-0.4979957044124603,
-0.4919694662094116,
-0.8883813619613647,
0.39696773886680603,
-0.7259148955345154,
-0.26698172092437744,
-0.26161667704582214,
-0.0515361912548542,
-0.09905332326889038,
-0.005514688324183226,
-0.6889308094978333,
-0.0968538224697113,
-0.008454958908259869,
-0.05866522341966629,
0.16272597014904022,
1.0892499685287476,
0.09144626557826996,
0.3949242830276489,
-0.7437360286712646,
0.31181710958480835,
0.4132111072540283,
0.44657444953918457,
0.15021395683288574,
-0.6666175127029419,
-0.44520649313926697,
0.050155412405729294,
-0.46036580204963684,
-0.8139172196388245,
0.3481866717338562,
0.14811402559280396,
0.7313786745071411,
0.29011964797973633,
-0.04294354096055031,
0.9076917767524719,
-0.6745929718017578,
0.6494985818862915,
0.16157947480678558,
-0.9717977643013,
0.5289315581321716,
-0.18012724816799164,
0.28244686126708984,
0.6383731961250305,
0.6750907301902771,
-0.31664952635765076,
-0.17453928291797638,
-0.6974126696586609,
-0.5732358694076538,
0.6592472791671753,
-0.047003135085105896,
0.16873450577259064,
-0.16811822354793549,
0.5694781541824341,
0.4139901399612427,
0.004439142532646656,
-0.6485111713409424,
-0.0021463362500071526,
-0.4156477451324463,
-0.20783013105392456,
-0.22498901188373566,
-0.05201364681124687,
0.2151043713092804,
-0.18282173573970795,
0.7106788158416748,
-0.23367324471473694,
0.1772935539484024,
0.028115281835198402,
-0.10601430386304855,
0.06588171422481537,
0.17119000852108002,
0.12215452641248703,
0.49032124876976013,
-0.061522647738456726,
-0.09472694993019104,
0.3603574335575104,
-0.40889328718185425,
0.5355163812637329,
0.051106251776218414,
-0.20984451472759247,
-0.19239889085292816,
0.4670509994029999,
0.7120758295059204,
0.4226643741130829,
-0.44244858622550964,
0.5780549645423889,
-0.16142627596855164,
0.08173757046461105,
-0.11539273709058762,
0.17599600553512573,
-0.04141175001859665,
-0.07718909531831741,
0.1739509254693985,
-0.5281900763511658,
0.21903930604457855,
-0.55341637134552,
0.04983765259385109,
0.2374711036682129,
0.02029387466609478,
-0.46680787205696106,
0.5495715141296387,
0.364317923784256,
-0.049616437405347824,
0.6256978511810303,
-0.5299565196037292,
-0.34745103120803833,
0.3313429355621338,
0.7963454127311707,
0.5998667478561401,
-0.5627262592315674,
0.25200438499450684,
0.7255899906158447,
0.2827451527118683,
-0.3661361038684845,
0.13824190199375153,
-0.22716456651687622,
-0.5846233367919922,
-0.7077059149742126,
-0.40580421686172485,
-0.7222780585289001,
0.30495524406433105,
-0.7154390811920166,
0.034755319356918335,
-0.64306640625,
-0.16043996810913086,
-0.13520827889442444,
0.3587699234485626,
-0.851027250289917,
0.15829290449619293,
0.09308791160583496,
0.4987930357456207,
-0.8970293998718262,
0.881605863571167,
0.43454957008361816,
-0.5875998735427856,
-1.065035104751587,
-0.023947538807988167,
-0.20867033302783966,
-1.0857017040252686,
0.5815718173980713,
0.17395958304405212,
-0.15848970413208008,
0.12421176582574844,
-0.5967838168144226,
-0.9001206755638123,
0.9514357447624207,
0.5574959516525269,
-0.6073262691497803,
0.04795636981725693,
0.08355875313282013,
0.4842517673969269,
-0.14608441293239594,
0.4809364378452301,
0.6687089800834656,
0.4642110764980316,
-0.16517376899719238,
-0.76824951171875,
0.02752372808754444,
-0.16528867185115814,
0.0244209673255682,
0.12996438145637512,
-0.7426570653915405,
0.43992486596107483,
-0.12872344255447388,
-0.34410157799720764,
0.08011284470558167,
0.7368224263191223,
0.08295242488384247,
0.036608099937438965,
0.3257184624671936,
0.48030272126197815,
0.7260161638259888,
0.019759492948651314,
1.0982717275619507,
-0.2273913323879242,
0.22126205265522003,
1.2757928371429443,
-0.27964654564857483,
0.9036953449249268,
0.009454783983528614,
-0.44618067145347595,
0.36253711581230164,
0.6045318841934204,
-0.08875744789838791,
0.3009049892425537,
0.11776161193847656,
-0.12677186727523804,
-0.15769824385643005,
0.016482878476381302,
-0.4620223939418793,
0.746698796749115,
0.19345790147781372,
-0.0537373423576355,
-0.22076617181301117,
-0.07159872353076935,
0.24438099563121796,
0.09763943403959274,
-0.13322745263576508,
0.7475175857543945,
-0.22859664261341095,
-0.810499370098114,
0.7701754570007324,
0.005183091387152672,
0.688826322555542,
-0.6769667267799377,
-0.13344672322273254,
-0.5523778796195984,
-0.09172932803630829,
0.025421597063541412,
-0.7491574883460999,
-0.10016172379255295,
0.40546736121177673,
0.04736778512597084,
0.028119375929236412,
0.16315396130084991,
-0.3461546003818512,
-0.45129409432411194,
0.22616414725780487,
0.44146251678466797,
0.5080534219741821,
0.328170508146286,
-0.6379840970039368,
0.030625222250819206,
0.028548864647746086,
-0.44298410415649414,
0.4196304380893707,
0.3229171335697174,
-0.19498413801193237,
0.6990750432014465,
0.6193440556526184,
0.04618822783231735,
-0.10765012353658676,
0.20623300969600677,
0.499541312456131,
-0.6743969917297363,
-0.2564932107925415,
-0.6465904712677002,
-0.03132233768701553,
-0.009850063361227512,
-0.2910216152667999,
0.7898538708686829,
0.5350553393363953,
0.9044392704963684,
-0.02864602394402027,
0.865226149559021,
0.25390031933784485,
0.43910467624664307,
-0.5628864765167236,
0.612576961517334,
-0.3109240233898163,
0.07932993769645691,
-0.24445584416389465,
-0.9701208472251892,
0.008465957827866077,
0.7116371393203735,
-0.36908766627311707,
0.17312027513980865,
0.5284959077835083,
0.7744727730751038,
-0.06163511797785759,
-0.021676354110240936,
0.3711589574813843,
0.10825259983539581,
0.37995225191116333,
0.6125812530517578,
0.9413119554519653,
-0.3874794542789459,
0.4759029150009155,
-0.608866274356842,
-0.4016909599304199,
-0.003351635066792369,
-0.9516828656196594,
-0.7103591561317444,
-0.3326563537120819,
-0.3513212203979492,
-0.03049699403345585,
0.09974014014005661,
1.152657151222229,
0.7404567003250122,
-0.6105996966362,
-0.3584692180156708,
0.27619192004203796,
-0.2532302439212799,
-0.10614209622144699,
-0.15293532609939575,
0.6385799050331116,
-0.45085006952285767,
-0.8633794188499451,
0.7487689256668091,
0.10219009965658188,
0.22439132630825043,
-0.4162524938583374,
-0.26541921496391296,
0.23113983869552612,
-0.17163437604904175,
0.47674834728240967,
0.4119967520236969,
-0.5984604358673096,
-0.37993118166923523,
-0.22436188161373138,
-0.1535010039806366,
0.08521927148103714,
0.37655213475227356,
-0.6304421424865723,
0.5691640973091125,
0.006417136173695326,
0.9696381688117981,
0.6216964721679688,
0.054035626351833344,
0.6464195251464844,
-0.4507591128349304,
0.06408553570508957,
0.05732543766498566,
0.3559333384037018,
0.6004436016082764,
-0.29311221837997437,
0.8409979343414307,
0.16762390732765198,
-0.6496084928512573,
-0.4333704710006714,
-0.10121767222881317,
-0.576504647731781,
0.021164726465940475,
0.9434493780136108,
-0.38127386569976807,
-0.2934454381465912,
0.2073543220758438,
-0.27292898297309875,
0.267634779214859,
-0.4729982614517212,
0.9300013184547424,
0.5333715677261353,
-0.23238344490528107,
-0.04387703537940979,
-0.863837480545044,
0.3089364767074585,
0.2859983444213867,
-1.0308576822280884,
0.023886414244771004,
0.5179436802864075,
0.4370775818824768,
-0.07288463413715363,
0.6652453541755676,
-0.1465543955564499,
0.3400397300720215,
0.05707506835460663,
0.4737381041049957,
-0.16156211495399475,
-0.08812926709651947,
-0.18463025987148285,
0.04293343052268028,
0.3208141326904297,
-0.2739247679710388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03689v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03689v2
|
General2Specialized LLMs Translation for E-commerce
| 2024-03-06T13:15:21 | 2024-04-06T04:07:49 |
Kaidi Chen, Ben Chen, Dehong Gao, Huangyu Dai, Wen Jiang, Wei Ning, Shanqing Yu, Libin Yang, Xiaoyan Cai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing Neural Machine Translation (NMT) models mainly handle translation in
the general domain, while overlooking domains with special writing formulas,
such as e-commerce and legal documents. Taking e-commerce as an example, the
texts usually include amounts of domain-related words and have more grammar
problems, which leads to inferior performances of current NMT methods. To
address these problems, we collect two domain-related resources, including a
set of term pairs (aligned Chinese-English bilingual terms) and a parallel
corpus annotated for the e-commerce domain. Furthermore, we propose a two-step
fine-tuning paradigm (named G2ST) with self-contrastive semantic enhancement to
transfer one general NMT model to the specialized NMT model for e-commerce. The
paradigm can be used for the NMT models based on Large language models (LLMs).
Extensive evaluations on real e-commerce titles demonstrate the superior
translation quality and robustness of our G2ST approach, as compared with
state-of-the-art NMT models such as LLaMA, Qwen, GPT-3.5, and even GPT-4.
|
[
-0.0459488220512867,
-0.7903083562850952,
0.31545162200927734,
0.08608593791723251,
-0.8130309581756592,
-0.05145464465022087,
-0.4145130515098572,
-0.8473872542381287,
0.2488323152065277,
0.5626357793807983,
-0.6451340317726135,
-0.3898237347602844,
-0.49081292748451233,
0.15978020429611206,
-0.29103365540504456,
1.2420707941055298,
-0.08789185434579849,
0.16974031925201416,
0.06661679595708847,
0.0753001794219017,
-0.22216050326824188,
-0.5710931420326233,
-0.9202102422714233,
-0.16179031133651733,
0.33898720145225525,
-0.009352218359708786,
0.6371632218360901,
0.5813966989517212,
0.7235029339790344,
0.2771703600883484,
0.17990270256996155,
0.542293906211853,
-0.42570826411247253,
0.06392152607440948,
-0.571591317653656,
-0.3940315544605255,
-0.9833731651306152,
-0.2030736654996872,
-0.08790609985589981,
0.24677006900310516,
-0.24823102355003357,
0.27865973114967346,
0.3918018043041229,
0.6274595856666565,
-0.1719060093164444,
0.12106363475322723,
-0.555178165435791,
-0.12326594442129135,
0.19826602935791016,
-0.24479201436042786,
-0.3507116138935089,
-0.14820662140846252,
0.12685628235340118,
-1.079985499382019,
0.2942999005317688,
0.37812989950180054,
1.0235875844955444,
0.2371252030134201,
-0.6480468511581421,
-0.2651900053024292,
-0.7598225474357605,
0.878929078578949,
-0.541242241859436,
0.4006909430027008,
0.43682992458343506,
0.1902858465909958,
0.08208148926496506,
-1.0269012451171875,
-0.17334680259227753,
-0.029008150100708008,
-0.2766495943069458,
0.49196502566337585,
-0.39090707898139954,
0.09566003084182739,
-0.1124953106045723,
0.2104821652173996,
-0.7403873205184937,
0.14827556908130646,
-0.2669207453727722,
0.03454605117440224,
0.6697517037391663,
0.3082934319972992,
0.34131428599357605,
0.16597776114940643,
-0.7158371806144714,
0.2961612045764923,
-0.7652204632759094,
-0.32707226276397705,
0.19548629224300385,
0.39669230580329895,
-0.051078904420137405,
0.35936978459358215,
-0.3803098499774933,
0.6286529302597046,
0.24433551728725433,
-0.03935149312019348,
0.12701424956321716,
-0.6840577125549316,
-0.3833284378051758,
-0.2918679416179657,
0.49827107787132263,
0.8787826299667358,
0.19233326613903046,
-0.32184600830078125,
-0.4521598219871521,
-0.27912962436676025,
0.36387789249420166,
-0.8250001668930054,
-0.041281215846538544,
0.22697913646697998,
-0.5895267724990845,
0.010008325800299644,
0.021926581859588623,
-0.6429445147514343,
-0.04675539210438728,
-0.785926103591919,
0.545962393283844,
0.06309179961681366,
-0.228959858417511,
0.2832711637020111,
0.1842365860939026,
0.20194321870803833,
0.37153589725494385,
-0.9536221027374268,
0.6249669790267944,
0.9524132609367371,
0.8766221404075623,
-0.35367557406425476,
-0.050838056951761246,
0.021960733458399773,
0.4737025499343872,
-0.22661210596561432,
0.5903517603874207,
0.01565561071038246,
0.08821038156747818,
0.11021507531404495,
0.1860964596271515,
0.03349350392818451,
-0.4658653438091278,
0.6500245332717896,
-0.8319936990737915,
-0.009221864864230156,
-0.1700928509235382,
-0.5389565229415894,
-0.3802799880504608,
0.7319393754005432,
-0.49117887020111084,
0.44895797967910767,
-0.008022649213671684,
-0.3821178078651428,
0.06455394625663757,
-0.29791459441185,
-0.6517412066459656,
0.09146466106176376,
0.09440559893846512,
-0.4696741998195648,
0.23668241500854492,
0.2162797600030899,
0.4714616537094116,
-0.816872239112854,
0.1493929773569107,
0.05886359512805939,
-0.3362642526626587,
-0.09723138064146042,
-0.1877616047859192,
0.559956967830658,
0.40216487646102905,
-0.49070218205451965,
-0.2067878544330597,
-0.4067242443561554,
0.12291431427001953,
0.37122440338134766,
-0.1685558706521988,
-0.35485097765922546,
-0.03906604275107384,
0.3163369596004486,
0.35383257269859314,
0.5422012805938721,
-0.18295380473136902,
0.3446926474571228,
-0.41228747367858887,
0.6936098337173462,
0.5365778803825378,
-0.11183775961399078,
0.39068982005119324,
-0.20493580400943756,
0.5489469170570374,
0.0009326956933364272,
0.33858954906463623,
0.046979259699583054,
-0.7562468647956848,
-1.0154016017913818,
0.12152739614248276,
0.45262816548347473,
0.7165781259536743,
-0.6934309601783752,
0.34519603848457336,
-0.4758945107460022,
-0.07188450545072556,
-0.38352423906326294,
0.10896272212266922,
0.38811856508255005,
0.23791633546352386,
0.749076247215271,
-0.3193839192390442,
-0.2193775177001953,
-1.2903250455856323,
-0.3625820279121399,
0.0259751845151186,
-0.18833287060260773,
0.29259398579597473,
0.17126160860061646,
-0.38141971826553345,
0.43605297803878784,
-0.3724473714828491,
-0.6690621972084045,
-0.11943168938159943,
0.19531945884227753,
0.26682135462760925,
0.44806817173957825,
0.20909377932548523,
-0.876594066619873,
-0.7897943258285522,
0.5210792422294617,
-0.3427369296550751,
-0.20327256619930267,
-0.474345862865448,
-0.1803208887577057,
0.27212241291999817,
0.4408726394176483,
-0.5231219530105591,
0.2103000432252884,
0.33410876989364624,
-0.2288602739572525,
0.2910063862800598,
-0.5388332009315491,
0.3461166024208069,
-1.2605639696121216,
-0.26526302099227905,
0.2388744354248047,
-0.31299400329589844,
-0.7676280736923218,
0.38250020146369934,
0.46103936433792114,
0.3686313033103943,
-0.5710822343826294,
0.18822571635246277,
-0.6173127889633179,
-0.182769313454628,
-0.39180752635002136,
0.31705260276794434,
0.38733750581741333,
0.4564509689807892,
0.004268929362297058,
0.8557686805725098,
-0.10925862938165665,
-0.764649510383606,
0.3248369097709656,
0.2648405432701111,
-0.1145196184515953,
0.7135284543037415,
-0.6990460157394409,
0.09010163694620132,
0.1633681356906891,
0.0812636986374855,
-0.637586772441864,
0.04422544687986374,
0.5084350109100342,
-0.30388936400413513,
0.5076510906219482,
-0.31123387813568115,
-0.7314040660858154,
-0.10865789651870728,
0.05117057263851166,
0.4024559557437897,
0.5723757743835449,
-0.529867947101593,
0.5552964210510254,
0.028278563171625137,
-0.35788074135780334,
-0.2899033725261688,
-1.177261471748352,
0.43717053532600403,
-0.07322411239147186,
-0.9216480851173401,
0.6795973777770996,
-0.04475541412830353,
0.08162388205528259,
-0.07493461668491364,
0.24799683690071106,
-0.08391886204481125,
0.27452507615089417,
-0.4999591112136841,
0.26760271191596985,
-0.4977165162563324,
0.2002079337835312,
0.3118605315685272,
-0.28193891048431396,
0.04261976107954979,
-0.8921929597854614,
0.2082366794347763,
0.0632876455783844,
-0.3646315038204193,
-0.33495938777923584,
0.4341587722301483,
0.04926937445998192,
-0.3610435426235199,
0.33609452843666077,
0.38904717564582825,
-0.3920612335205078,
-0.3075094521045685,
-0.41636183857917786,
-0.1746874451637268,
-0.48096510767936707,
0.5505555272102356,
-0.5063129663467407,
-0.9653664231300354,
0.2543826699256897,
-0.1535654217004776,
-0.13181041181087494,
0.6169008016586304,
0.7338544726371765,
0.11130622774362564,
1.0724797248840332,
0.6664999723434448,
0.25309479236602783,
0.018559332937002182,
0.0888596847653389,
0.6931795477867126,
-0.8805942535400391,
-0.2870487868785858,
-0.3090047538280487,
-0.48597022891044617,
-0.7514704465866089,
-0.525161862373352,
-0.06066460907459259,
0.3319353461265564,
-0.3854316174983978,
0.6038162708282471,
-0.536935567855835,
0.7024164795875549,
0.5098962187767029,
0.22424539923667908,
0.4888732433319092,
0.48584312200546265,
-0.10297341644763947,
-0.2426946461200714,
-0.30498310923576355,
-0.4131259024143219,
1.091603398323059,
0.196044459939003,
0.4542289972305298,
0.6101154685020447,
0.3016089200973511,
0.05048079416155815,
0.15629874169826508,
-0.9381458759307861,
0.24819448590278625,
-0.6990501880645752,
-0.4711171090602875,
0.1375325620174408,
-0.23411527276039124,
-0.7896599769592285,
0.3807029724121094,
0.11436232179403305,
-0.46502411365509033,
0.05554422363638878,
0.027006853371858597,
-0.5070679187774658,
0.1877608448266983,
-0.5340330600738525,
0.7552838325500488,
-0.7868938446044922,
-0.9034743905067444,
-0.24951079487800598,
-0.5614475607872009,
0.15833112597465515,
-0.2903243601322174,
0.3019797205924988,
0.05806180462241173,
-0.666399359703064,
0.21594949066638947,
-0.2088877111673355,
0.7357204556465149,
0.39517587423324585,
-0.16436752676963806,
0.08803611993789673,
0.3061087429523468,
0.8238712549209595,
-0.2701321244239807,
0.22130489349365234,
0.23353949189186096,
-0.32153263688087463,
-0.3409225642681122,
-0.5814154148101807,
0.5710014700889587,
-0.6265798807144165,
-0.7167620658874512,
-0.19221733510494232,
-0.20403440296649933,
-0.3064703047275543,
0.3047533333301544,
0.30022919178009033,
-0.2086499184370041,
-0.21090182662010193,
0.02391122467815876,
0.5538394451141357,
-0.08196137100458145,
0.12628285586833954,
0.7611494660377502,
-0.10126509517431259,
-0.49156421422958374,
0.9286290407180786,
0.0291422288864851,
0.5473056435585022,
0.4709344804286957,
0.2234836369752884,
-0.4953760504722595,
-0.7894864082336426,
-0.6967148780822754,
0.07591883093118668,
-0.7954297065734863,
-0.4800228774547577,
-0.6069793701171875,
-0.001740534440614283,
-0.4953739047050476,
-0.28164565563201904,
-0.09522728621959686,
-0.626953661441803,
-0.5019094944000244,
-0.12233638018369675,
0.24268700182437897,
0.7967966198921204,
-0.10000257939100266,
0.42103537917137146,
-0.9235013723373413,
0.4971940219402313,
0.36282414197921753,
0.33060160279273987,
-0.0505666546523571,
-0.7564023733139038,
-0.554559588432312,
0.07383347302675247,
-0.1881452351808548,
-0.4730924069881439,
0.5086368322372437,
0.2421148717403412,
0.4011955261230469,
0.4770200848579407,
-0.2162937968969345,
0.6280854940414429,
-0.7333793640136719,
0.9404147863388062,
0.4082365930080414,
-0.8269928097724915,
0.32436445355415344,
-0.640845000743866,
-0.15419577062129974,
0.3325744569301605,
0.4412696361541748,
-0.7219791412353516,
0.011955639347434044,
-0.3313411772251129,
-1.2323054075241089,
0.6679293513298035,
0.23668472468852997,
0.36019089818000793,
-0.14597351849079132,
0.3694200813770294,
0.039241939783096313,
0.2248125523328781,
-0.6408265829086304,
-0.16268739104270935,
0.039501022547483444,
-0.2492368072271347,
-0.17418435215950012,
-0.4137539267539978,
0.11215082556009293,
-0.13830330967903137,
0.8830289244651794,
-0.06933208554983139,
0.041854068636894226,
-0.0008396405610255897,
-0.3458128273487091,
-0.027848446741700172,
0.29007700085639954,
0.6702336668968201,
0.43478092551231384,
0.1795710027217865,
-0.21263869106769562,
-0.05203080177307129,
-0.41274455189704895,
0.15122228860855103,
-0.11692813038825989,
-0.5312272310256958,
-0.27234548330307007,
-0.1825382262468338,
0.3954426646232605,
0.20164619386196136,
-0.12048117816448212,
0.5805591940879822,
0.10568676143884659,
-0.24834506213665009,
-0.22515863180160522,
-0.3614124059677124,
0.3419593274593353,
0.37001824378967285,
-0.025620179250836372,
-0.04752502217888832,
0.6006886959075928,
-0.14940689504146576,
0.3649930953979492,
0.13670121133327484,
-0.13856638967990875,
-0.19191516935825348,
0.9047814607620239,
0.46372470259666443,
-0.25401702523231506,
0.6668125987052917,
-0.372198224067688,
-0.6840189695358276,
0.7508465051651001,
1.0095127820968628,
1.3776485919952393,
-0.1630127727985382,
0.10766135156154633,
0.5750507712364197,
0.7752690315246582,
-0.5634873509407043,
0.12040947377681732,
0.18942007422447205,
-0.46937108039855957,
-0.42926883697509766,
-0.5530043840408325,
-0.45777592062950134,
-0.12742754817008972,
-0.7639193534851074,
0.37973159551620483,
-0.3573703467845917,
-0.1043013483285904,
-0.4339677691459656,
-0.0280215572565794,
-0.7345480918884277,
0.27854305505752563,
0.246801495552063,
0.43192920088768005,
-0.5610108375549316,
0.9673688411712646,
0.4687565565109253,
-0.5531496405601501,
-0.42223793268203735,
-0.17732040584087372,
0.012667907401919365,
-0.7716178297996521,
0.6294665336608887,
0.17325760424137115,
-0.2478782683610916,
0.16603204607963562,
-0.11138049513101578,
-0.8022769689559937,
1.2600548267364502,
0.16294516623020172,
-1.1312063932418823,
0.2313283532857895,
0.6683202385902405,
0.5976728796958923,
-0.5133534073829651,
0.07905661314725876,
0.6617980003356934,
0.43009883165359497,
-0.22658541798591614,
-0.7685118317604065,
0.13162153959274292,
-0.2641584575176239,
0.22587376832962036,
0.19826878607273102,
-0.8357338309288025,
1.0381349325180054,
0.09845917671918869,
-0.25081536173820496,
0.420248806476593,
0.2808198034763336,
-0.1408417820930481,
0.11692626029253006,
0.10972719639539719,
0.7346339821815491,
0.7738074660301208,
-0.12329808622598648,
0.8693732023239136,
-0.45722997188568115,
0.6010759472846985,
1.3959362506866455,
-0.23351125419139862,
0.9654618501663208,
0.3286803066730499,
-0.20342573523521423,
0.09632253646850586,
0.72618567943573,
-0.35679513216018677,
0.39073288440704346,
0.33469149470329285,
-0.08036606013774872,
-0.5063971281051636,
-0.013283038511872292,
-0.3588767647743225,
-0.016104621812701225,
0.4453165829181671,
-0.5369106531143188,
-0.13295137882232666,
-0.40901848673820496,
-0.08909682184457779,
0.023073596879839897,
-0.4787294566631317,
0.6847633123397827,
0.33644142746925354,
-0.2050350159406662,
0.4603225886821747,
0.5200622081756592,
0.859712541103363,
-0.3980412781238556,
0.05977959185838699,
-0.335289865732193,
0.22910696268081665,
-0.10147485136985779,
-0.39949455857276917,
0.2748597264289856,
-0.007521423976868391,
-0.019921038299798965,
-0.4314747750759125,
0.8389176726341248,
-0.4923937916755676,
-0.6339367032051086,
0.7371286153793335,
0.662063479423523,
0.1090615913271904,
-0.2836466431617737,
-0.9555112719535828,
-0.3995506763458252,
-0.08879079669713974,
-0.41470545530319214,
0.41627901792526245,
0.5322368144989014,
-0.08639568090438843,
0.22713501751422882,
0.5711750388145447,
-0.15874922275543213,
0.0898074060678482,
0.07090054452419281,
0.4763391315937042,
-0.8098393082618713,
-0.6988842487335205,
-0.832426130771637,
0.5032109022140503,
-0.11521348357200623,
-0.31267407536506653,
0.6820536851882935,
0.6885499358177185,
1.1105884313583374,
-0.08144290745258331,
0.7852084636688232,
0.5537009835243225,
0.26865747570991516,
-0.6018930673599243,
0.8384872078895569,
-0.9236578345298767,
0.3488191068172455,
0.156190887093544,
-1.0710738897323608,
-0.5466731786727905,
0.4752286672592163,
0.04516676813364029,
-0.15463228523731232,
0.7737696766853333,
0.7173479199409485,
-0.30013400316238403,
0.017259396612644196,
0.7331057786941528,
0.24369041621685028,
-0.04467624053359032,
0.6943106055259705,
0.5162730813026428,
-0.7874534130096436,
0.5594318509101868,
-0.2361028790473938,
-0.08311561495065689,
-0.4646669328212738,
-0.8898304104804993,
-0.5874396562576294,
-0.13882818818092346,
-0.5397807955741882,
-0.3428398072719574,
0.20733152329921722,
1.124334692955017,
0.3924309313297272,
-0.8898012638092041,
-0.23468482494354248,
0.11706908792257309,
-0.3459058105945587,
-0.42084622383117676,
-0.01978776976466179,
0.2799721658229828,
-0.5534957051277161,
-0.867484986782074,
0.18904678523540497,
0.44307729601860046,
0.2653474509716034,
0.09049730747938156,
-0.10927241295576096,
0.20356331765651703,
0.26673293113708496,
0.9140653014183044,
-0.2923770546913147,
-0.9427177309989929,
-0.06642194837331772,
0.24172283709049225,
-0.19682927429676056,
0.22277729213237762,
0.7764975428581238,
-0.13870947062969208,
0.282720685005188,
0.3271401822566986,
0.7717849016189575,
0.3905446231365204,
-0.04085054621100426,
0.48715007305145264,
-0.23809298872947693,
0.054315295070409775,
0.20982730388641357,
0.4164315164089203,
0.2035287767648697,
-0.3854988217353821,
0.6114782094955444,
0.20393452048301697,
-0.5239948034286499,
-0.03863457962870598,
0.5343044996261597,
-0.9693416357040405,
-0.46942338347435,
1.3495755195617676,
-0.27180081605911255,
-0.27856987714767456,
-0.3791414499282837,
0.04250817745923996,
0.10889516770839691,
-0.13697725534439087,
0.48764491081237793,
0.5588589906692505,
0.36787909269332886,
0.057276640087366104,
-0.7332980036735535,
0.16072145104408264,
0.4191139340400696,
-0.6497810482978821,
0.055180784314870834,
0.47211819887161255,
0.2936535179615021,
-0.23269183933734894,
0.45939651131629944,
-0.05863336846232414,
0.2794625759124756,
-0.256244033575058,
0.05271210893988609,
-0.13038748502731323,
-0.2264983355998993,
-0.4812066853046417,
-0.09785954654216766,
0.17962941527366638,
-0.008916251361370087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03640v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03640v3
|
Apollo: A Lightweight Multilingual Medical LLM towards Democratizing Medical AI to 6B People
| 2024-03-06T11:56:02 | 2024-06-28T06:16:24 |
Xidong Wang, Nuo Chen, Junyin Chen, Yan Hu, Yidong Wang, Xiangbo Wu, Anningzhe Gao, Xiang Wan, Haizhou Li, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the vast repository of global medical knowledge predominantly being
in English, local languages are crucial for delivering tailored healthcare
services, particularly in areas with limited medical resources. To extend the
reach of medical AI advancements to a broader population, we aim to develop
medical LLMs across the six most widely spoken languages, encompassing a global
population of 6.1 billion. This effort culminates in the creation of the
ApolloCorpora multilingual medical dataset and the XMedBench benchmark. In the
multilingual medical benchmark, the released Apollo models, at various
relatively-small sizes (i.e., 0.5B, 1.8B, 2B, 6B, and 7B), achieve the best
performance among models of equivalent size. Especially, Apollo-7B is the
state-of-the-art multilingual medical LLMs up to 70B. Additionally, these lite
models could be used to improve the multi-lingual medical capabilities of
larger models without fine-tuning in a proxy-tuning fashion. We will
open-source training corpora, code, model weights and evaluation benchmark.
|
[
-0.18392866849899292,
-0.21570372581481934,
0.6418949961662292,
0.0707070603966713,
-0.40540561079978943,
0.09217843413352966,
-0.24218018352985382,
-0.8744129538536072,
0.37870773673057556,
0.3618778586387634,
-0.20967501401901245,
-0.6136943697929382,
-0.7836375832557678,
0.464475154876709,
-0.0960259959101677,
0.6965861320495605,
0.14116938412189484,
0.7818101644515991,
0.019313860684633255,
-0.5407629609107971,
-0.18825027346611023,
-0.24086745083332062,
-0.7501266598701477,
-0.2274833768606186,
0.7812357544898987,
0.46443429589271545,
0.8667657375335693,
0.8624264597892761,
0.42721793055534363,
0.3706625699996948,
-0.0030963176395744085,
0.12715378403663635,
-0.35116177797317505,
-0.041503552347421646,
-0.11125396937131882,
-0.7283287048339844,
-0.42145803570747375,
-0.14133624732494354,
0.49469178915023804,
0.9563938975334167,
-0.039337947964668274,
-0.05574715510010719,
-0.5139535069465637,
0.6526374220848083,
-0.4108184278011322,
0.1921154260635376,
-0.27641984820365906,
-0.04126402363181114,
-0.16126692295074463,
0.36060842871665955,
-0.15850284695625305,
-0.38596129417419434,
-0.10960187017917633,
-0.8545083403587341,
-0.06558090448379517,
0.26423245668411255,
0.21638137102127075,
0.3166399598121643,
-0.6015852689743042,
-0.4943675696849823,
-0.3255542516708374,
0.5940342545509338,
-0.5564022064208984,
0.7938840389251709,
0.14257636666297913,
0.33986613154411316,
0.1169077605009079,
-0.8548160195350647,
-0.4138718545436859,
-0.6151387095451355,
0.2050624042749405,
0.3714742958545685,
0.17026586830615997,
0.08860503882169724,
-0.285653680562973,
0.4516580104827881,
-0.4758090078830719,
0.28397703170776367,
-1.0194120407104492,
-0.09234747290611267,
0.69727623462677,
0.09002022445201874,
0.38447004556655884,
-0.11232908070087433,
-0.17998106777668,
0.18228541314601898,
-0.6933044791221619,
-0.39427614212036133,
0.10401598364114761,
0.2055141180753708,
-0.5964155197143555,
0.6065130829811096,
-0.1796608865261078,
0.3672724962234497,
-0.11193813383579254,
-0.6036705374717712,
0.46003156900405884,
-0.403605580329895,
-0.17146213352680206,
0.2778008282184601,
0.8402892351150513,
0.2785431146621704,
-0.03053583763539791,
-0.5104429125785828,
0.0877818912267685,
0.30580905079841614,
0.22286775708198547,
-0.5825981497764587,
0.21551021933555603,
0.4212152063846588,
-0.6263662576675415,
-0.18994495272636414,
-0.2329825907945633,
-0.46447283029556274,
-0.7779621481895447,
-0.3498753309249878,
0.08826418966054916,
-0.5089969635009766,
-0.13826888799667358,
0.3070594072341919,
0.1672452837228775,
-0.01332173403352499,
0.3347848951816559,
-0.7389458417892456,
0.08729328960180283,
0.5179327726364136,
0.604434072971344,
-0.09581226855516434,
-0.2693498432636261,
-0.3681844472885132,
0.15935136377811432,
-0.6628109812736511,
0.5099729895591736,
-0.3289790451526642,
-0.6603327989578247,
-0.0779506117105484,
-0.07176030427217484,
0.12089289724826813,
-0.9050496816635132,
0.6864022016525269,
-0.15042565762996674,
0.13119132816791534,
-0.15494205057621002,
-0.49183541536331177,
0.02735661342740059,
0.22391609847545624,
-0.639259397983551,
0.8915254473686218,
0.23905755579471588,
-0.3833921551704407,
0.48065319657325745,
-0.5365980863571167,
-0.37968653440475464,
0.2533566951751709,
-0.572002649307251,
-0.23502077162265778,
0.3374199867248535,
0.2577887773513794,
0.2758030295372009,
-0.8030303716659546,
0.28085973858833313,
-0.3263450860977173,
-0.11663242429494858,
-0.08300875127315521,
0.032816436141729355,
0.6672993898391724,
0.365389347076416,
-0.1882081925868988,
0.35327666997909546,
-0.9131679534912109,
-0.20634910464286804,
-0.17992568016052246,
-0.5115666389465332,
-0.274604856967926,
-0.2470485419034958,
0.12447824329137802,
0.302760511636734,
0.28713664412498474,
-0.5610812902450562,
0.37645772099494934,
-0.6431314945220947,
0.23976460099220276,
0.4274788796901703,
-0.30401790142059326,
0.501235842704773,
-0.4290016293525696,
0.7225478291511536,
-0.11692476272583008,
0.5495674014091492,
0.02948758937418461,
-0.7525373101234436,
-0.48344290256500244,
-0.8236937522888184,
0.081350177526474,
0.4412732720375061,
-0.8398120999336243,
0.0915825292468071,
-0.2412436306476593,
-0.8139145970344543,
-1.2373346090316772,
0.45895108580589294,
0.5568050742149353,
0.6544919013977051,
0.266853392124176,
0.014637310989201069,
-0.46358802914619446,
-1.0230400562286377,
-0.14730936288833618,
-0.2513557970523834,
0.0007825368666090071,
0.3202976882457733,
0.5144514441490173,
-0.6952657103538513,
0.2725747525691986,
0.021195290610194206,
-0.35925325751304626,
-0.6289598941802979,
-0.26825380325317383,
0.21144022047519684,
0.3645964562892914,
0.5834813117980957,
-0.7856869101524353,
-0.5258675217628479,
0.49501171708106995,
-1.1129107475280762,
-0.16475196182727814,
0.1335144340991974,
0.11025570333003998,
0.13573364913463593,
0.5095829367637634,
-0.4928464889526367,
0.14180807769298553,
0.8146065473556519,
-0.35671567916870117,
0.4261793792247772,
-0.46560949087142944,
0.2787761986255646,
-1.584047794342041,
0.07790638506412506,
-0.2687835097312927,
-0.18699593842029572,
-0.31928548216819763,
0.31097421050071716,
0.29796865582466125,
-0.2199392467737198,
-0.7621346712112427,
1.1108964681625366,
-0.6865942478179932,
-0.01207209937274456,
-0.19647622108459473,
0.2791484594345093,
-0.231683149933815,
-0.21190550923347473,
-0.20175716280937195,
0.6520863771438599,
0.7690619826316833,
-0.5671446919441223,
0.6352754831314087,
0.14989259839057922,
-0.32659095525741577,
0.7746146321296692,
-0.6022324562072754,
-0.1686040610074997,
-0.10946635901927948,
-0.0026591275818645954,
-0.47008147835731506,
-0.3912607729434967,
0.05953557416796684,
-0.5544901490211487,
0.005159883294254541,
-0.006526615470647812,
-0.4549545347690582,
-0.2388666421175003,
-0.3300999701023102,
0.5211355090141296,
0.3521234095096588,
-0.48499229550361633,
0.8178021907806396,
0.4246911406517029,
-0.03102364018559456,
-0.5069611072540283,
-0.522817075252533,
0.10491865873336792,
-0.3019542396068573,
-1.0039290189743042,
0.31612977385520935,
-0.20509453117847443,
-0.4268380403518677,
-0.12870848178863525,
0.07163282483816147,
0.03227972984313965,
-0.001954355277121067,
0.261192262172699,
0.2878641188144684,
-0.3028496503829956,
0.17715761065483093,
-0.0695100799202919,
-0.30823320150375366,
-0.17972758412361145,
-0.3243149220943451,
0.2803400158882141,
-0.017657727003097534,
-0.40219002962112427,
-0.4829134941101074,
0.4063108265399933,
1.0058425664901733,
0.002498840680345893,
1.010001540184021,
0.540181577205658,
-0.44126373529434204,
0.25875115394592285,
-0.6727829575538635,
-0.043698668479919434,
-0.4184447228908539,
0.60889732837677,
-0.17469565570354462,
-0.8048820495605469,
0.8404667377471924,
-0.13470354676246643,
-0.05648886039853096,
0.3843168020248413,
0.9622519612312317,
0.1467335969209671,
0.949064314365387,
0.7033507823944092,
-0.3547479212284088,
0.031596388667821884,
-0.07725992798805237,
-0.0571916401386261,
-0.8049406409263611,
-0.5042991638183594,
-0.6934387683868408,
-0.1891660839319229,
-0.6980000734329224,
-0.5855611562728882,
0.8768420815467834,
0.03367331624031067,
0.050787243992090225,
-0.2253839522600174,
-0.28314104676246643,
0.18854616582393646,
0.6827215552330017,
-0.02870715595781803,
0.4575481712818146,
-0.34413453936576843,
-0.4921109080314636,
0.05666840076446533,
-0.6511651873588562,
-0.32048943638801575,
1.363053321838379,
0.055906590074300766,
0.9999199509620667,
0.25805866718292236,
0.6778833270072937,
0.04848937317728996,
0.6374381184577942,
-0.6709114909172058,
0.2101295441389084,
-0.19427049160003662,
-0.9242153763771057,
0.041984181851148605,
-0.46793124079704285,
-1.2061870098114014,
0.17640329897403717,
-0.27843159437179565,
-0.4928639829158783,
-0.16798654198646545,
0.22076453268527985,
-0.22662539780139923,
0.1591685712337494,
-0.8883689045906067,
0.8241627812385559,
-0.5554861426353455,
-0.2884999215602875,
-0.40902361273765564,
-0.7771912217140198,
0.34966740012168884,
-0.18054531514644623,
0.6350047588348389,
-0.0056154560297727585,
-0.41272392868995667,
0.48532894253730774,
-0.42650705575942993,
0.6877793669700623,
0.03866168111562729,
0.09582488238811493,
-0.11067937314510345,
-0.44497376680374146,
0.14932899177074432,
0.5877727270126343,
-0.1285175383090973,
0.17986345291137695,
-0.14977842569351196,
-0.673475444316864,
-0.252778023481369,
0.7357972860336304,
-1.1457549333572388,
-0.3306698203086853,
-0.4125306010246277,
-0.516699492931366,
-0.2745653986930847,
0.28089916706085205,
0.37603428959846497,
0.2946218252182007,
-0.20918086171150208,
0.2986239790916443,
0.38297852873802185,
-0.5056329965591431,
-0.025964856147766113,
0.8218435049057007,
-0.46703240275382996,
-0.8260025978088379,
0.479104220867157,
0.051502373069524765,
0.25832539796829224,
0.36162981390953064,
0.298312246799469,
-0.5537063479423523,
-0.7525085806846619,
-0.6107141375541687,
0.6966363191604614,
-0.6846681237220764,
-0.056679390370845795,
-0.4047275185585022,
0.20490822196006775,
-0.6446556448936462,
-0.5262728333473206,
-0.6380525827407837,
-0.35780787467956543,
0.05356918275356293,
-0.10447130352258682,
0.14329008758068085,
1.0357218980789185,
0.01341166626662016,
0.34682631492614746,
-0.8560450673103333,
0.7040064334869385,
-0.07554298639297485,
0.453959196805954,
-0.47267162799835205,
-0.2606142461299896,
-0.5440827012062073,
-0.35580766201019287,
-0.02607819065451622,
-0.9597393274307251,
0.3401228189468384,
-0.015266661532223225,
0.7919259667396545,
0.5388181209564209,
-0.14975903928279877,
0.522452712059021,
-0.3457319736480713,
0.5974589586257935,
0.5273166298866272,
-0.6044517755508423,
0.41309118270874023,
-0.23632843792438507,
0.47974732518196106,
0.5379198789596558,
0.32485586404800415,
-0.8420785069465637,
-0.5579867362976074,
-0.4327094256877899,
-0.9281921982765198,
0.3789161443710327,
-0.07925822585821152,
-0.010163450613617897,
-0.13325254619121552,
0.6102645993232727,
0.29444244503974915,
0.30541133880615234,
-0.6731651425361633,
-0.4024980068206787,
0.13977588713169098,
-0.6820666193962097,
-0.14427421987056732,
0.14217393100261688,
-0.2105959802865982,
-0.13182580471038818,
0.8119742274284363,
-0.3108007609844208,
-0.0006907485658302903,
0.28597769141197205,
-0.1486949324607849,
0.028943771496415138,
0.27930423617362976,
0.4936777949333191,
0.6926174163818359,
0.16290324926376343,
-0.056047696620225906,
0.07696099579334259,
-0.746285617351532,
0.24654199182987213,
0.37639859318733215,
-0.25957390666007996,
-0.20809078216552734,
0.4902243912220001,
0.5202126502990723,
0.3675368130207062,
-1.0701769590377808,
0.09232671558856964,
-0.2581266462802887,
-0.0404459610581398,
-0.30732491612434387,
-0.0573900043964386,
0.5126756429672241,
0.32844966650009155,
0.36096251010894775,
-0.04473286494612694,
0.03545873984694481,
-0.5478770732879639,
-0.03672090172767639,
0.4107411205768585,
-0.3114382028579712,
-0.40231335163116455,
1.100097894668579,
0.46847003698349,
0.03299552574753761,
0.5040351748466492,
-0.14207863807678223,
-0.08927509188652039,
0.6115026473999023,
0.34114816784858704,
0.4451988935470581,
-0.4115375280380249,
-0.11217629909515381,
0.3469749093055725,
0.5873560309410095,
-0.1194157674908638,
0.44509008526802063,
0.5584332346916199,
-0.6171821355819702,
-0.38826248049736023,
-0.42698949575424194,
-0.3633546531200409,
0.12772035598754883,
-0.39094045758247375,
0.45179590582847595,
-0.3393994867801666,
-0.054089631885290146,
0.003675667801871896,
0.103324756026268,
-0.5685930848121643,
0.40309521555900574,
0.32311639189720154,
0.9745352268218994,
-0.5175944566726685,
0.9943098425865173,
1.0447871685028076,
-0.46374866366386414,
-0.7845922708511353,
-0.7567955255508423,
0.325646311044693,
-1.0141034126281738,
0.3017798662185669,
0.11783201992511749,
0.08662250638008118,
-0.2340889424085617,
-0.20232731103897095,
-0.7249019145965576,
1.177519679069519,
0.980719804763794,
-0.5245535373687744,
-0.08084990084171295,
0.19676917791366577,
0.4334453046321869,
-0.5131658315658569,
0.16313716769218445,
0.20107501745224,
0.42947500944137573,
-0.1610342562198639,
-1.1913673877716064,
-0.27321475744247437,
-0.31192195415496826,
-0.175775945186615,
0.03982526808977127,
-0.8951907157897949,
0.7350518703460693,
-0.48534324765205383,
0.3261120617389679,
0.28634825348854065,
0.4383290708065033,
0.4966629445552826,
0.4213774800300598,
0.22440457344055176,
0.6460318565368652,
1.0458621978759766,
-0.03803796321153641,
1.472401738166809,
-0.7575274705886841,
0.0936289057135582,
0.7101251482963562,
-0.44854652881622314,
0.351706326007843,
0.53607177734375,
0.06309717148542404,
-0.1405082643032074,
0.5143884420394897,
0.3220627009868622,
0.21102258563041687,
-0.1442551463842392,
-0.5471881031990051,
0.07521005719900131,
-0.08861611038446426,
-0.5658745169639587,
0.3478143513202667,
0.28460025787353516,
-0.48787519335746765,
0.1870948225259781,
0.3048683702945709,
0.35975492000579834,
0.07780373841524124,
-0.5706549286842346,
0.7361205220222473,
0.15105345845222473,
-0.660865068435669,
0.42961448431015015,
0.12315927445888519,
0.5730268955230713,
-0.8988342881202698,
0.3510879576206207,
-0.4373806416988373,
0.5717281103134155,
-0.12786072492599487,
-0.10341626405715942,
0.11507457494735718,
-0.0867471843957901,
-0.11949872225522995,
0.175765722990036,
0.318425714969635,
-0.28504952788352966,
-0.9780595898628235,
0.8085081577301025,
0.7283843159675598,
0.14683234691619873,
0.15181264281272888,
-0.7785418033599854,
0.2530495226383209,
-0.0009662454831413925,
0.03214032202959061,
0.3893992304801941,
0.48882848024368286,
-0.18242521584033966,
0.9872673153877258,
0.47323331236839294,
0.5286218523979187,
0.48662686347961426,
0.18971394002437592,
0.8083667755126953,
-0.5494617223739624,
-0.5710312724113464,
-0.5919291973114014,
0.436871737241745,
0.18183118104934692,
-0.5389643311500549,
0.6489782333374023,
0.9318880438804626,
0.7776134014129639,
-0.19273477792739868,
0.9940168261528015,
-0.12191697955131531,
0.48403307795524597,
-0.4754686951637268,
0.6432012915611267,
-0.8208392262458801,
0.15869131684303284,
0.0003059984592255205,
-0.48946794867515564,
-0.5643577575683594,
0.5377218723297119,
0.002232072874903679,
0.21851664781570435,
0.6872560381889343,
0.6331514120101929,
0.04694109410047531,
-0.3498949408531189,
0.6345203518867493,
0.45984917879104614,
0.35115736722946167,
0.3818610608577728,
0.5196506977081299,
-0.25114956498146057,
0.6467911005020142,
-0.13567619025707245,
-0.2591111958026886,
-0.2579682171344757,
-0.4243486821651459,
-0.6712576746940613,
-0.13628533482551575,
-0.22852084040641785,
-0.19360123574733734,
0.14023159444332123,
1.024544596672058,
1.018494963645935,
-0.6540451645851135,
-0.27288687229156494,
0.23515300452709198,
0.030931899324059486,
-0.26675769686698914,
-0.08779603987932205,
0.23690402507781982,
-0.23343636095523834,
-0.9488847851753235,
0.6862472891807556,
0.5503638386726379,
-0.1474841833114624,
-0.3990595042705536,
-0.638370156288147,
-0.001686105621047318,
-0.013313723728060722,
0.3590744733810425,
0.2061128467321396,
-0.8162455558776855,
0.008393392898142338,
0.16754727065563202,
-0.21938496828079224,
0.30504071712493896,
0.7293581962585449,
-0.7262834906578064,
0.6696171760559082,
-0.030930327251553535,
0.6533461809158325,
0.30898594856262207,
-0.3153148889541626,
0.5608581900596619,
-0.5787898898124695,
0.5675193667411804,
0.36775684356689453,
0.7461137175559998,
0.5450196266174316,
-0.2230534851551056,
0.6866298317909241,
0.32901516556739807,
-0.5088918805122375,
-0.4784037470817566,
0.05538037419319153,
-0.9803904891014099,
-0.30061689019203186,
0.8867502808570862,
-0.0027191147673875093,
-0.07920561730861664,
-0.29483503103256226,
-0.40156257152557373,
0.42608731985092163,
-0.36042988300323486,
1.0114738941192627,
0.4269552230834961,
-0.15651153028011322,
-0.13899554312229156,
-0.825374186038971,
0.29720765352249146,
0.2031850516796112,
-1.2498955726623535,
-0.4074274003505707,
0.5117310285568237,
0.29545095562934875,
0.30320367217063904,
1.1080386638641357,
-0.4746987521648407,
0.5537335276603699,
-0.08518220484256744,
0.2844339609146118,
0.1585446298122406,
-0.27210646867752075,
-0.03620566427707672,
0.2275463342666626,
0.2898252010345459,
0.06010401248931885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03628v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03628v2
|
GPTopic: Dynamic and Interactive Topic Representations
| 2024-03-06T11:34:20 | 2024-06-22T09:00:29 |
Arik Reuter, Anton Thielmann, Christoph Weisser, Sebastian Fischer, Benjamin Säfken
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Topic modeling seems to be almost synonymous with generating lists of top
words to represent topics within large text corpora. However, deducing a topic
from such list of individual terms can require substantial expertise and
experience, making topic modelling less accessible to people unfamiliar with
the particularities and pitfalls of top-word interpretation. A topic
representation limited to top-words might further fall short of offering a
comprehensive and easily accessible characterization of the various aspects,
facets and nuances a topic might have. To address these challenges, we
introduce GPTopic, a software package that leverages Large Language Models
(LLMs) to create dynamic, interactive topic representations. GPTopic provides
an intuitive chat interface for users to explore, analyze, and refine topics
interactively, making topic modeling more accessible and comprehensive. The
corresponding code is available here: https://github.com/ArikReuter/TopicGPT.
|
[
-0.594160258769989,
-1.0078840255737305,
0.7846295237541199,
0.1168752983212471,
-0.30478402972221375,
0.514558732509613,
-0.48571541905403137,
-0.09041852504014969,
0.41673603653907776,
0.5057953596115112,
-0.6530354619026184,
-0.5641481280326843,
-0.9223582744598389,
-0.40522661805152893,
-0.40686702728271484,
1.0796160697937012,
0.1398879885673523,
-0.28399568796157837,
-0.41088157892227173,
0.2561133801937103,
-0.3587626814842224,
-0.3882846534252167,
-0.5565531253814697,
-0.3679664731025696,
0.4743392765522003,
0.5285133719444275,
0.9386732578277588,
0.38337668776512146,
0.4698305130004883,
0.33980411291122437,
-0.319894939661026,
-0.1122385635972023,
-0.7682744264602661,
0.38846540451049805,
-0.43698281049728394,
-0.32027173042297363,
-0.4243059754371643,
0.2804383933544159,
0.6320368051528931,
0.8525177240371704,
-0.29379984736442566,
-0.12411874532699585,
-0.13152086734771729,
0.24746675789356232,
-0.15392974019050598,
0.14491498470306396,
-0.8786763548851013,
0.003759942017495632,
-0.2933918237686157,
-0.5116856694221497,
-0.11441343277692795,
-0.11472293734550476,
0.3138914108276367,
-0.6870359182357788,
-0.12338686734437943,
-0.16556629538536072,
0.6288987398147583,
0.379850298166275,
-0.24838067591190338,
-0.4838426113128662,
-0.7402929663658142,
0.4961840808391571,
-0.3971950113773346,
0.28304773569107056,
0.3035101890563965,
0.4111751914024353,
-0.29350993037223816,
-0.8861107230186462,
-0.4325210154056549,
-0.6482494473457336,
0.045540954917669296,
-0.05990387871861458,
-0.21142517030239105,
-0.10450787097215652,
0.3307248055934906,
0.6461172103881836,
-0.4979623258113861,
0.08013534545898438,
0.022175868973135948,
-0.05617064610123634,
0.2839687764644623,
0.33624809980392456,
0.6233842372894287,
-0.15583574771881104,
-0.016423199325799942,
0.2242424339056015,
-0.8539758324623108,
-0.4371441900730133,
0.4398171007633209,
0.20131586492061615,
-0.22990350425243378,
0.6061839461326599,
-0.13347740471363068,
0.47915375232696533,
0.11969761550426483,
-0.10427393019199371,
0.0066797612234950066,
-0.05536787584424019,
0.11228062212467194,
-0.34648212790489197,
0.36587050557136536,
0.02182859368622303,
-0.028173673897981644,
-0.21062524616718292,
0.16348996758460999,
-0.05713944882154465,
0.3486751317977905,
-0.870477557182312,
-0.6082807779312134,
0.545525312423706,
-0.27081480622291565,
-0.42768803238868713,
0.0028161939699202776,
-0.777739942073822,
-0.6843050718307495,
-0.47224166989326477,
0.08843188732862473,
-0.16530215740203857,
-0.43895578384399414,
-0.1714695692062378,
-0.09264172613620758,
0.013803156092762947,
0.6920256018638611,
-0.7796914577484131,
0.38089224696159363,
0.7395754456520081,
0.7961717247962952,
-0.5290862917900085,
-0.2492227405309677,
-0.6068114042282104,
0.22655317187309265,
-0.3216478228569031,
0.9127575755119324,
-1.0552271604537964,
-0.47501736879348755,
-0.28159308433532715,
-0.04194170981645584,
0.39571312069892883,
-0.3009198009967804,
-0.048046063631772995,
-0.4373440742492676,
0.47101646661758423,
-0.2423805594444275,
-0.6968320608139038,
0.23617851734161377,
0.2630884647369385,
-0.5210855007171631,
0.9024481773376465,
0.0497296079993248,
-1.2024128437042236,
0.25981563329696655,
-0.7802761197090149,
0.25704425573349,
0.4860791265964508,
-0.7062649130821228,
0.14201225340366364,
-0.02337481454014778,
0.15706387162208557,
0.40973100066185,
-0.119999460875988,
0.5591968297958374,
-0.2675584852695465,
-0.3470695912837982,
0.19835533201694489,
-0.3501685559749603,
0.42042335867881775,
0.23150625824928284,
-0.18704119324684143,
0.5599150061607361,
-0.44673219323158264,
-0.36641925573349,
0.05710931867361069,
-0.3303920328617096,
-0.26154741644859314,
0.14335334300994873,
0.19735822081565857,
0.022976119071245193,
0.49356672167778015,
-0.12224900722503662,
0.8046715259552002,
-0.14772622287273407,
0.6223347783088684,
0.5431227087974548,
0.18549729883670807,
0.48210644721984863,
-0.03946471959352493,
0.608593225479126,
-0.23917706310749054,
-0.36032724380493164,
-0.15663987398147583,
-0.7775993943214417,
-0.2865089476108551,
-0.3636625409126282,
0.44622647762298584,
0.8026215434074402,
-1.0306297540664673,
0.26711758971214294,
-0.26438871026039124,
-0.6391087770462036,
0.10789141058921814,
-0.08552902191877365,
-0.20507104694843292,
0.0032925449777394533,
-0.14409874379634857,
-0.25077977776527405,
-0.11662138253450394,
-0.7389252185821533,
0.030909113585948944,
-0.06732707470655441,
-0.36248546838760376,
0.24279987812042236,
0.49437782168388367,
-0.27569806575775146,
1.0158179998397827,
-0.8406580090522766,
0.02142367698252201,
-0.5064741969108582,
0.6156100630760193,
0.28317683935165405,
0.2769942283630371,
0.584906816482544,
-0.8365138173103333,
-0.49410223960876465,
-0.004967787303030491,
-0.43612632155418396,
-0.2213539332151413,
-0.15841692686080933,
-0.4104302227497101,
-0.38741129636764526,
0.629439651966095,
-0.9586304426193237,
0.2789119482040405,
0.4820624887943268,
-0.4033537209033966,
0.4661310315132141,
-0.36780431866645813,
-0.023900829255580902,
-1.1891790628433228,
0.27984490990638733,
-0.14569322764873505,
-0.35843831300735474,
-0.5892148017883301,
0.32257866859436035,
-0.30124297738075256,
-0.7168031930923462,
-0.2700892388820648,
0.7614356279373169,
-0.39452245831489563,
-0.17253126204013824,
-0.6492356657981873,
0.38787949085235596,
-0.428251177072525,
0.23200443387031555,
0.37375420331954956,
1.123433232307434,
0.835640549659729,
-0.4231550097465515,
0.5537909865379333,
0.4281182587146759,
-0.16245990991592407,
0.35734936594963074,
-0.5228903293609619,
0.09406932443380356,
-0.031774066388607025,
0.341328889131546,
-0.9879223704338074,
-0.6528923511505127,
0.457563579082489,
-0.31194496154785156,
0.5437247157096863,
-0.3737252354621887,
-0.29444968700408936,
-0.1427648365497589,
-0.28039243817329407,
0.03698524460196495,
0.3794282376766205,
-0.1796431541442871,
0.29031693935394287,
0.9295083284378052,
-0.9104641079902649,
-0.4787464737892151,
-0.5190664529800415,
0.5199626684188843,
-0.38028669357299805,
-0.17509159445762634,
0.7707858085632324,
-0.22944100201129913,
-0.3931763470172882,
0.2008640170097351,
0.17881307005882263,
-0.07819890230894089,
0.010292488150298595,
0.11310374736785889,
-0.10671240091323853,
0.2110096663236618,
0.32303890585899353,
-0.15229032933712006,
-0.34328582882881165,
-0.16820287704467773,
-0.1919262856245041,
0.8318378329277039,
-0.06720852851867676,
-0.3934015929698944,
-0.1861473172903061,
0.610501229763031,
0.8354174494743347,
-0.24547556042671204,
0.527391791343689,
0.43297237157821655,
-0.7022553086280823,
-0.21421638131141663,
-0.33834928274154663,
-0.07062699645757675,
-0.49900999665260315,
0.40994197130203247,
-0.2901870608329773,
-0.9094386100769043,
0.7026550769805908,
-0.30845707654953003,
-0.01867329515516758,
0.3052150011062622,
0.8637388348579407,
0.12257935106754303,
0.5446181893348694,
0.8982157707214355,
-0.006498589646071196,
0.624618649482727,
-0.1472945511341095,
0.19044020771980286,
-0.49430200457572937,
-0.04330864176154137,
-0.2781563699245453,
0.004051683470606804,
-0.8588826060295105,
-0.5668408274650574,
0.23557668924331665,
-0.06443698704242706,
-0.12305500358343124,
0.13378499448299408,
-0.5537055730819702,
0.2594675123691559,
0.46918898820877075,
-0.04475458711385727,
0.1692628711462021,
0.2411455661058426,
-0.017579035833477974,
-0.24159838259220123,
-0.48557189106941223,
-0.8223618268966675,
0.7165350317955017,
0.5639343857765198,
0.926515519618988,
-0.06718218326568604,
0.725378692150116,
0.4588894248008728,
0.38472598791122437,
-0.8733541369438171,
0.7962176203727722,
-0.3222441077232361,
-0.3536462187767029,
-0.480194091796875,
-0.46682029962539673,
-0.6273966431617737,
-0.000803369446657598,
-0.28813639283180237,
-1.0448459386825562,
-0.08385106921195984,
0.09896320104598999,
-0.2553519904613495,
0.5189030766487122,
-0.043551743030548096,
0.8296571373939514,
-0.1019543930888176,
-0.3370110094547272,
-0.34846261143684387,
-0.11858615279197693,
0.16226845979690552,
-0.03327861800789833,
0.062644362449646,
-0.30101925134658813,
-0.26758652925491333,
0.5593267679214478,
-0.29369792342185974,
0.8542707562446594,
-0.1492396593093872,
-0.25356221199035645,
0.32025617361068726,
0.24925503134727478,
0.37596842646598816,
0.398966908454895,
0.12290152162313461,
0.05685931071639061,
-0.18611985445022583,
-0.2378769814968109,
-0.5544517636299133,
0.9339525699615479,
-0.6435647010803223,
-0.9523123502731323,
-0.47846683859825134,
-0.6447678804397583,
-0.2113075703382492,
0.08915869146585464,
-0.004821072798222303,
0.44152021408081055,
-0.27808013558387756,
0.026009157299995422,
0.6516384482383728,
-0.6894816160202026,
0.14728176593780518,
0.06300391256809235,
-0.6547853946685791,
-0.49054574966430664,
0.9222108721733093,
0.11319909244775772,
-0.04942250996828079,
0.4937291145324707,
0.08525792509317398,
-0.11527290940284729,
-0.8349780440330505,
-0.5132321715354919,
0.2414890080690384,
-0.8090673089027405,
0.2603134512901306,
-0.6225758790969849,
-0.2644970715045929,
-0.003547589061781764,
-0.05096135661005974,
-0.3424874246120453,
-0.6856442093849182,
-0.3640686869621277,
-0.2006145864725113,
0.6442735195159912,
0.896028459072113,
-0.1760539561510086,
0.5108407735824585,
-0.5287372469902039,
0.5154451727867126,
0.4782353341579437,
0.4540075361728668,
-0.26743602752685547,
-0.31950536370277405,
0.0884474515914917,
-0.32069867849349976,
-0.3457992374897003,
-1.156272292137146,
0.4850575625896454,
0.03215505927801132,
0.9086856245994568,
0.40384557843208313,
-0.10787978023290634,
0.387834757566452,
-0.6355477571487427,
1.013383388519287,
-0.12238271534442902,
-1.041288137435913,
0.8045282959938049,
-0.8084731698036194,
0.31082138419151306,
0.5008866190910339,
0.7275445461273193,
-0.6678307056427002,
-0.6079609990119934,
-0.547317385673523,
-0.9553380012512207,
0.4348233640193939,
0.34936365485191345,
0.35787433385849,
-0.02950490452349186,
0.5023605227470398,
0.40543216466903687,
0.41063225269317627,
-0.5860155820846558,
-0.16624301671981812,
-0.048720989376306534,
-0.052104439586400986,
0.05223183333873749,
-0.43876612186431885,
-0.1025087982416153,
-0.005845637060701847,
0.5985379815101624,
-0.16832391917705536,
0.8023444414138794,
-0.291025310754776,
-0.01676633581519127,
-0.035785987973213196,
0.21287186443805695,
0.601967453956604,
1.2900670766830444,
-0.4591437876224518,
0.18328766524791718,
0.16438226401805878,
-0.49253031611442566,
-0.2507689595222473,
0.31657013297080994,
0.06658059358596802,
-0.05706847831606865,
0.4015708565711975,
0.5476417541503906,
0.28576210141181946,
-0.5119211077690125,
0.3173235058784485,
-0.024484051391482353,
0.1956462860107422,
-0.35432419180870056,
-0.019027594476938248,
0.6229744553565979,
0.11346619576215744,
0.5744723081588745,
-0.41657745838165283,
0.005617640446871519,
-0.9272170662879944,
0.6421324610710144,
0.34331488609313965,
-0.27500149607658386,
-0.05304668843746185,
0.6817693710327148,
0.2781481146812439,
-0.20683471858501434,
0.6941991448402405,
-0.30929186940193176,
-0.6670510768890381,
0.5263763070106506,
0.07688725739717484,
0.6548619270324707,
-0.15037116408348083,
0.431004136800766,
0.11539455503225327,
0.03590443730354309,
0.29279154539108276,
0.49024084210395813,
0.10151995718479156,
-0.44254517555236816,
-0.599132239818573,
-0.36036375164985657,
-1.157697081565857,
0.393893301486969,
-0.3349517285823822,
0.27135947346687317,
-0.2638329267501831,
-0.23963579535484314,
0.1469067633152008,
0.15436042845249176,
-0.29753249883651733,
-0.024650173261761665,
0.5148486495018005,
1.0625652074813843,
-0.7439844012260437,
0.9359302520751953,
1.0386077165603638,
-0.23965264856815338,
-0.10181539505720139,
0.3205646276473999,
-0.07682280987501144,
-0.42723846435546875,
0.4925853908061981,
0.029298270121216774,
0.215089812874794,
-0.19070373475551605,
-0.6428173184394836,
-0.9831876158714294,
1.0236167907714844,
0.30991536378860474,
-0.36620280146598816,
-0.18701739609241486,
0.34755757451057434,
0.5260555148124695,
-0.5290490984916687,
0.5802142024040222,
0.060496632009744644,
0.4698600769042969,
0.2196359485387802,
-0.9812000393867493,
0.05302439257502556,
-0.24114593863487244,
-0.11772362142801285,
0.037710875272750854,
-0.3381431996822357,
0.9369121789932251,
0.16855007410049438,
-0.1442493051290512,
-0.05235832557082176,
0.6632611751556396,
0.3791217505931854,
0.194856196641922,
0.35422754287719727,
0.36000609397888184,
0.9282708168029785,
-0.22775201499462128,
0.9430996775627136,
-0.5645471811294556,
0.4149172306060791,
1.0059138536453247,
-0.09339364618062973,
0.8301360011100769,
0.308483749628067,
-0.21431830525398254,
0.25269466638565063,
1.0152850151062012,
0.05867036059498787,
0.7105616331100464,
0.3933197855949402,
-0.03592526167631149,
-0.5284639596939087,
0.19546988606452942,
-0.3695134222507477,
0.3438941240310669,
1.0072029829025269,
0.06184890866279602,
-0.5768645405769348,
0.0812637060880661,
-0.11514907330274582,
-0.05434464290738106,
-0.4065573811531067,
0.4664677679538727,
0.20890852808952332,
-0.323276549577713,
0.15083415806293488,
-0.024238957092165947,
0.6459623575210571,
-0.6688947677612305,
-0.49620121717453003,
-0.27082300186157227,
-0.25153878331184387,
0.029679089784622192,
-1.184165596961975,
0.5654827356338501,
0.051025912165641785,
0.08295124024152756,
-0.2656092345714569,
1.1122316122055054,
-0.49910905957221985,
-0.30370378494262695,
0.12029509246349335,
0.8134012818336487,
0.39942535758018494,
-0.17314520478248596,
-0.8376064300537109,
0.2608414590358734,
-0.13759924471378326,
-0.5300598740577698,
0.24738307297229767,
0.42248180508613586,
-0.270031601190567,
1.0293878316879272,
0.4022194743156433,
0.1550431251525879,
-0.3251728415489197,
-0.03926650062203407,
1.112311840057373,
-0.7938648462295532,
-0.6713438034057617,
-0.49738624691963196,
0.4572310745716095,
-0.19873817265033722,
-0.2066376954317093,
0.2763729393482208,
0.3094387352466583,
0.46583855152130127,
-0.19866076111793518,
0.8545306921005249,
-0.186264306306839,
0.6268200874328613,
-0.43680620193481445,
0.8712975978851318,
-0.5373799800872803,
0.4811433255672455,
-0.20360293984413147,
-1.1249501705169678,
-0.31757572293281555,
0.6617605686187744,
-0.663271427154541,
-0.02398531883955002,
0.44670048356056213,
0.5032856464385986,
-0.36562520265579224,
-0.06509211659431458,
0.3847172260284424,
0.275325745344162,
0.33528003096580505,
0.22412841022014618,
1.2564514875411987,
0.4172239601612091,
0.311718612909317,
-0.18768033385276794,
-0.4422079026699066,
-0.19257879257202148,
-1.2857944965362549,
-0.961299479007721,
-0.5313113927841187,
-0.6678856015205383,
0.21522527933120728,
0.12631872296333313,
1.0673232078552246,
0.725375235080719,
-0.8084582686424255,
-0.17061936855316162,
-0.13687607645988464,
0.1476396918296814,
0.16521453857421875,
-0.22819572687149048,
0.4773610830307007,
-0.13891339302062988,
-0.8778716325759888,
0.5059410333633423,
0.24392563104629517,
-0.10413091629743576,
-0.6372478604316711,
0.3305470645427704,
0.1096392571926117,
0.14578793942928314,
0.5227952599525452,
0.18906033039093018,
-0.6993732452392578,
-0.37537264823913574,
-0.27707162499427795,
-0.06344661861658096,
0.06399679183959961,
0.9120639562606812,
-0.7945746183395386,
0.07461828738451004,
0.6768031120300293,
0.5924991369247437,
0.6303011178970337,
-0.06205745041370392,
0.5718322396278381,
-0.4449615776538849,
0.12054762989282608,
0.046459950506687164,
0.3129902482032776,
0.40437594056129456,
-0.5331785678863525,
0.46250998973846436,
0.16326721012592316,
-0.3883298933506012,
-0.7591102123260498,
0.39456072449684143,
-1.1808559894561768,
-0.6067899465560913,
1.162207007408142,
-0.1512601226568222,
0.1627560555934906,
-0.05895857512950897,
-0.5130818486213684,
0.0010815550340339541,
-0.3789336085319519,
0.6752508878707886,
0.9029703736305237,
-0.2533218562602997,
-0.45595598220825195,
-0.948550283908844,
0.4740341007709503,
-0.09639433026313782,
-0.9652426242828369,
0.20080022513866425,
0.3708430826663971,
0.5265297293663025,
0.26971256732940674,
0.6821666955947876,
0.11173245310783386,
-0.08483624458312988,
0.10294009745121002,
-0.006871122866868973,
-0.056322626769542694,
-0.47641199827194214,
-0.13411790132522583,
0.3313606083393097,
0.19286666810512543,
0.2466678023338318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03627v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03627v2
|
Multimodal Large Language Models to Support Real-World Fact-Checking
| 2024-03-06T11:32:41 | 2024-04-26T05:16:53 |
Jiahui Geng, Yova Kementchedjhieva, Preslav Nakov, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) carry the potential to support
humans in processing vast amounts of information. While MLLMs are already being
used as a fact-checking tool, their abilities and limitations in this regard
are understudied. Here is aim to bridge this gap. In particular, we propose a
framework for systematically assessing the capacity of current multimodal
models to facilitate real-world fact-checking. Our methodology is
evidence-free, leveraging only these models' intrinsic knowledge and reasoning
capabilities. By designing prompts that extract models' predictions,
explanations, and confidence levels, we delve into research questions
concerning model accuracy, robustness, and reasons for failure. We empirically
find that (1) GPT-4V exhibits superior performance in identifying malicious and
misleading multimodal claims, with the ability to explain the unreasonable
aspects and underlying motives, and (2) existing open-source models exhibit
strong biases and are highly sensitive to the prompt. Our study offers insights
into combating false multimodal information and building secure, trustworthy
multimodal models. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to evaluate
MLLMs for real-world fact-checking.
|
[
-0.40630435943603516,
-0.850013017654419,
0.9155920743942261,
0.19236640632152557,
-0.14954064786434174,
-0.10763394087553024,
-0.2197892665863037,
-0.38691964745521545,
-0.3251457214355469,
0.37270388007164,
-0.46580854058265686,
-0.27208539843559265,
-0.6178568601608276,
0.05897010490298271,
-0.2928234040737152,
0.9090335965156555,
0.002512584673240781,
-0.08089178800582886,
-0.5040543675422668,
-0.17866714298725128,
-0.2878100872039795,
-0.6615144610404968,
-0.2222810536623001,
-0.09163656085729599,
0.8523777723312378,
0.2529805898666382,
0.7647455930709839,
0.30679211020469666,
0.4659465253353119,
0.33457231521606445,
0.26093220710754395,
0.4331648349761963,
-0.26801571249961853,
0.18065230548381805,
-0.09621477872133255,
-0.26297006011009216,
-0.4395216405391693,
0.34957775473594666,
0.6952447891235352,
0.14279739558696747,
-0.011239603161811829,
0.24023695290088654,
-0.15481017529964447,
0.17256827652454376,
-0.699505627155304,
0.26027950644493103,
-0.5695861577987671,
-0.06959600746631622,
-0.1293080747127533,
-0.03002985194325447,
-0.643283486366272,
-0.43488168716430664,
-0.00664140097796917,
-0.3653642535209656,
0.13385823369026184,
0.09830989688634872,
0.754298210144043,
0.05843111127614975,
-0.8682558536529541,
-0.15773537755012512,
-0.7394816875457764,
0.7291334867477417,
-0.7116885185241699,
0.7469030022621155,
0.47031185030937195,
0.4083775281906128,
0.0731828510761261,
-0.7682722806930542,
-0.9352928996086121,
-0.6228664517402649,
-0.18550148606300354,
0.01169596891850233,
-0.25442424416542053,
0.04453382268548012,
0.5598154664039612,
0.08470682054758072,
-0.8217788338661194,
-0.18008790910243988,
-0.2134249210357666,
-0.6687779426574707,
0.31874942779541016,
-0.004909422714263201,
0.4050702750682831,
-0.1879955232143402,
-0.4457654654979706,
-0.07939521223306656,
-0.7122676968574524,
-0.02131062000989914,
0.318392276763916,
0.15365225076675415,
-0.19709475338459015,
0.7348926663398743,
-0.07892196625471115,
0.5669543147087097,
-0.3435644507408142,
-0.4721657931804657,
0.17161256074905396,
-0.7632496356964111,
-0.1713491827249527,
-0.17738674581050873,
0.7361937761306763,
0.5186182260513306,
0.008964205160737038,
-0.10442124307155609,
-0.30541107058525085,
0.2699776291847229,
0.20030556619167328,
-1.0200867652893066,
-0.017705442383885384,
0.30363965034484863,
-0.4718542695045471,
-0.18767642974853516,
-0.054129667580127716,
-0.7942706942558289,
-0.549582302570343,
-0.17672114074230194,
0.545242428779602,
-0.4056166410446167,
-0.5188754796981812,
-0.09787534922361374,
-0.22293969988822937,
-0.057932935655117035,
0.4535578489303589,
-0.464791864156723,
-0.3138982951641083,
0.5290673971176147,
1.0561790466308594,
0.17629261314868927,
-0.19031642377376556,
-0.7247377634048462,
0.03294973820447922,
-0.21158327162265778,
0.7361760139465332,
-0.5902665257453918,
-0.018360339105129242,
0.0520743653178215,
-0.027830613777041435,
0.09868395328521729,
-0.10244172066450119,
0.9026455283164978,
-0.662816047668457,
0.26997801661491394,
-0.5176142454147339,
-0.3576633036136627,
-0.4293785095214844,
0.8052226305007935,
-0.8330713510513306,
0.6539595127105713,
-0.1973285675048828,
-0.7387572526931763,
0.45058637857437134,
-0.6645739674568176,
-0.15228860080242157,
-0.10320935398340225,
-0.0652146264910698,
-0.38232681155204773,
-0.0635356679558754,
0.28988251090049744,
0.5090229511260986,
-0.27886584401130676,
0.6065860390663147,
-0.5956889986991882,
0.15278413891792297,
0.43959853053092957,
-1.0274181365966797,
0.6143797636032104,
0.5101770758628845,
-0.15598353743553162,
0.3396115303039551,
-0.7876904606819153,
-0.12423281371593475,
0.008668719790875912,
-0.29018285870552063,
-0.2948467433452606,
0.012724040076136589,
0.10413368046283722,
0.44929662346839905,
0.17498788237571716,
-0.8083987236022949,
0.13217677175998688,
0.14876607060432434,
0.3177773356437683,
0.6217803955078125,
-0.18152078986167908,
0.12514060735702515,
-0.3701997995376587,
0.3789563477039337,
0.26391586661338806,
0.40562495589256287,
-0.4825811982154846,
-0.6533212065696716,
-0.4996952414512634,
-0.4452599287033081,
0.34193727374076843,
0.4042704403400421,
-1.0375709533691406,
0.03257204592227936,
-0.20651653409004211,
-0.5142963528633118,
-0.3431042432785034,
-0.15256118774414062,
0.26897627115249634,
0.4378283619880676,
0.35892027616500854,
0.03445340320467949,
-0.5228514671325684,
-0.9382327795028687,
-0.3199208378791809,
-0.24061115086078644,
0.029865844175219536,
0.03552742302417755,
0.6332178115844727,
-0.3164726793766022,
1.0731754302978516,
-0.12303946167230606,
0.1120789423584938,
-0.08822406828403473,
0.31529587507247925,
-0.0033139039296656847,
0.34932997822761536,
0.5681655406951904,
-1.1231456995010376,
-0.17583659291267395,
-0.09495360404253006,
-0.8780192136764526,
0.05593287944793701,
-0.11717167496681213,
0.37418174743652344,
0.07614250481128693,
0.1628275215625763,
-0.9389197826385498,
0.17493674159049988,
0.8621444702148438,
-0.5334233641624451,
0.7496931552886963,
-0.287091463804245,
0.4606752097606659,
-0.6459454894065857,
0.17821112275123596,
0.09667164087295532,
-0.5362340807914734,
-0.7258683443069458,
0.14473368227481842,
0.4925646185874939,
-0.08609403669834137,
-0.4528708755970001,
0.5995665788650513,
-0.3802923858165741,
0.06527097523212433,
-0.1280752271413803,
0.06483282148838043,
0.05403991416096687,
0.29727011919021606,
-0.1111115887761116,
0.6852784752845764,
0.2699491083621979,
-0.4911540746688843,
0.6644588112831116,
-0.1699640154838562,
-0.6661322712898254,
0.4955928325653076,
-0.4389571249485016,
-0.08808473497629166,
-0.16165032982826233,
0.3849978744983673,
-1.043545126914978,
-0.48212751746177673,
0.20227399468421936,
-0.34575265645980835,
-0.033476803451776505,
-0.39215290546417236,
-0.6595005393028259,
-0.3117397725582123,
-0.2292308807373047,
0.3800466060638428,
0.21715626120567322,
-0.5800777673721313,
0.9165828227996826,
0.2807408273220062,
-0.2116139829158783,
-0.6375417113304138,
-0.34560832381248474,
0.31544819474220276,
-0.09346570819616318,
-0.7892188429832458,
-0.03766365349292755,
-0.20610803365707397,
-0.49292808771133423,
-0.08061487972736359,
0.00517817959189415,
-0.11886582523584366,
0.02548595890402794,
0.2280312478542328,
0.3165914714336395,
-0.24749526381492615,
0.18652185797691345,
-0.18150918185710907,
0.007961205206811428,
-0.004589530639350414,
-0.13174447417259216,
0.2568685710430145,
-0.3612689971923828,
-0.7497700452804565,
-0.29343482851982117,
0.22378475964069366,
1.1326993703842163,
-0.509499192237854,
0.668560802936554,
1.009047269821167,
-0.34371066093444824,
0.1647498458623886,
-0.9556935429573059,
-0.26660263538360596,
-0.4312775135040283,
0.4136849045753479,
-0.3193499445915222,
-0.9601446390151978,
0.3150576651096344,
0.10840955376625061,
0.18966104090213776,
0.24308930337429047,
0.7937362194061279,
0.22060006856918335,
1.2386037111282349,
0.4327637553215027,
0.24921631813049316,
0.23721715807914734,
0.22861987352371216,
0.35312405228614807,
-0.3831793963909149,
-0.36298391222953796,
-0.3042447566986084,
0.027467777952551842,
-0.350910484790802,
-0.6177399754524231,
0.5425794124603271,
-0.379763662815094,
-0.052075911313295364,
-0.0719819888472557,
0.019410526379942894,
0.38556864857673645,
0.4203832447528839,
-0.039743900299072266,
0.43542376160621643,
-0.17490987479686737,
-0.26598218083381653,
0.11037281155586243,
-0.5712836384773254,
-0.5875124335289001,
1.0220555067062378,
0.6421796679496765,
0.7331076264381409,
0.4479830861091614,
-0.2346516251564026,
0.5097060799598694,
0.4613622725009918,
-0.5346695184707642,
0.4839165210723877,
0.2003185749053955,
-1.0207099914550781,
-0.23386891186237335,
-0.5563262104988098,
-0.5672647953033447,
0.7432870864868164,
-0.5540479421615601,
-0.3121996521949768,
0.014018644578754902,
0.4221233129501343,
-0.4500907063484192,
0.5175140500068665,
-0.8139062523841858,
0.9034128785133362,
-0.523192286491394,
-0.5330203771591187,
-0.3129071295261383,
-0.5397528409957886,
0.7479732632637024,
-0.1216677576303482,
0.5881354212760925,
-0.3043503165245056,
0.05664118379354477,
0.36246711015701294,
-0.10476180166006088,
1.011987328529358,
-0.3826771378517151,
-0.39315974712371826,
0.2173493355512619,
0.19777710735797882,
0.607771635055542,
0.1911860555410385,
0.12252553552389145,
0.15968064963817596,
0.07910764962434769,
-0.25866174697875977,
-0.5989211201667786,
0.6317295432090759,
-0.5574346780776978,
-0.5242962837219238,
-0.5051392316818237,
-0.6422913074493408,
-0.3470163345336914,
0.32472434639930725,
-0.05126387998461723,
0.7804362773895264,
-0.3233289122581482,
0.4676770269870758,
0.6535152792930603,
-0.12352440506219864,
0.4367724657058716,
0.6754142642021179,
-0.45891985297203064,
-0.1501893550157547,
1.0334515571594238,
0.06800612062215805,
0.13449159264564514,
0.3953506052494049,
0.29025501012802124,
-0.6704261898994446,
-0.5111379623413086,
-0.6939698457717896,
0.07491093128919601,
-0.690167248249054,
-0.04052070900797844,
-0.8140175342559814,
0.14010509848594666,
-0.49978265166282654,
0.4416390061378479,
-0.4274043142795563,
-0.3048378527164459,
0.1794252097606659,
-0.07984936982393265,
0.17116549611091614,
0.7668706774711609,
-0.11199313402175903,
-0.07563521713018417,
-0.9908761978149414,
0.41273921728134155,
0.6083031892776489,
0.4377804696559906,
-0.12251312285661697,
-0.3820442855358124,
-0.15536804497241974,
0.3227823078632355,
-0.1526535600423813,
-0.7749210596084595,
0.15942713618278503,
-0.05693449079990387,
0.5968247652053833,
0.498339980840683,
0.1045740395784378,
0.3945896029472351,
-0.5411474704742432,
0.9807150959968567,
0.18639226257801056,
-0.6529311537742615,
0.1420721560716629,
-0.35502052307128906,
0.06361619383096695,
0.06133825704455376,
0.5370723605155945,
-0.6906448006629944,
-0.23964500427246094,
-0.38802871108055115,
-0.37330782413482666,
0.3688952326774597,
0.16619637608528137,
0.06262598931789398,
0.0847458764910698,
-0.04900587350130081,
0.1946166306734085,
0.30722472071647644,
-0.9288389086723328,
0.0559501089155674,
-0.6272700428962708,
-0.14058877527713776,
-0.2059897482395172,
-0.5737524628639221,
-0.30481964349746704,
0.025111913681030273,
0.5343798995018005,
-0.2948898375034332,
0.19659028947353363,
0.13133278489112854,
-0.3920086622238159,
0.04122452065348625,
0.5929260849952698,
1.080268144607544,
0.8169665336608887,
-0.23556703329086304,
0.6729952096939087,
0.058207109570503235,
-0.4175618588924408,
0.2450985312461853,
-0.08398371934890747,
-0.054267171770334244,
-0.046358682215213776,
0.46044450998306274,
0.7689765095710754,
0.05318909138441086,
-0.901688277721405,
0.8703776597976685,
-0.255280077457428,
-0.06905290484428406,
-0.16846664249897003,
-0.13896290957927704,
-0.0008931010379455984,
0.31023073196411133,
0.18678075075149536,
0.2979469299316406,
-0.07548899948596954,
-0.6817463636398315,
0.20274320244789124,
0.5749356746673584,
-0.18146175146102905,
-0.5448067784309387,
0.4406503736972809,
0.2778448462486267,
0.14340800046920776,
0.5272578597068787,
-0.2056806981563568,
-0.5673999786376953,
0.28359276056289673,
0.5255128145217896,
0.5234911441802979,
-0.19510318338871002,
0.20464694499969482,
0.3165906071662903,
0.6629101037979126,
-0.14985620975494385,
0.02636270597577095,
0.0691736564040184,
-0.903080940246582,
-0.698822557926178,
-0.42668116092681885,
-0.4455367922782898,
0.3980019688606262,
-0.29256442189216614,
0.01680840365588665,
-0.43354523181915283,
-0.2947967052459717,
-0.04395436495542526,
-0.3945865035057068,
-0.5320785641670227,
0.2303059697151184,
0.4089330732822418,
0.8610435724258423,
-0.892792284488678,
0.8376775979995728,
0.5367449522018433,
-0.3952442407608032,
-0.3831467926502228,
-0.06862974911928177,
0.4076354503631592,
-0.7732431888580322,
0.6444164514541626,
0.2019810676574707,
-0.2920181155204773,
-0.28310805559158325,
-0.6880435943603516,
-0.7956694960594177,
0.8161823749542236,
0.4894789755344391,
-0.5799299478530884,
-0.038735292851924896,
-0.10486770421266556,
0.3066790997982025,
-0.17640669643878937,
0.45676764845848083,
0.24182263016700745,
0.8411264419555664,
-0.019216403365135193,
-1.0068203210830688,
0.09908051788806915,
-0.19970189034938812,
-0.32125991582870483,
-0.008720774203538895,
-0.49696245789527893,
1.023466944694519,
-0.2833835780620575,
-0.1647048443555832,
-0.15879479050636292,
0.6564704775810242,
0.08239535987377167,
0.2744569778442383,
0.776917576789856,
0.407436341047287,
0.8481917381286621,
-0.06930211186408997,
1.137804388999939,
-0.21492335200309753,
0.41193079948425293,
0.8487566709518433,
-0.37957683205604553,
0.6695207953453064,
0.35442206263542175,
0.021284546703100204,
0.5674090385437012,
0.30277401208877563,
-0.12046203762292862,
0.3028964102268219,
-0.3558231592178345,
-0.4333798289299011,
-0.6226018667221069,
-0.1819421947002411,
-0.2277427315711975,
0.5205129981040955,
0.3781666159629822,
-0.03301507234573364,
-0.3379482626914978,
0.3061846196651459,
0.08155087381601334,
-0.2286456823348999,
-0.189292773604393,
0.4300788342952728,
-0.24146243929862976,
-0.7869457602500916,
0.3945145010948181,
0.14837512373924255,
0.6069267392158508,
-0.7970618605613708,
-0.14104285836219788,
0.1054878830909729,
0.14644856750965118,
-0.08317623287439346,
-0.8997966051101685,
0.06865641474723816,
0.3326815068721771,
-0.34290391206741333,
-0.2500408887863159,
0.8936488032341003,
-0.5852309465408325,
-0.2274523824453354,
0.044837020337581635,
0.5775649547576904,
-0.12032359838485718,
-0.3972250819206238,
-0.6073992252349854,
0.2382177710533142,
-0.04490581527352333,
-0.20737211406230927,
0.3846871852874756,
0.3347732722759247,
-0.163190096616745,
0.9589988589286804,
0.9215531945228577,
-0.2059837281703949,
0.04291079565882683,
0.01984761841595173,
0.6587349772453308,
-0.4947182536125183,
-0.44457367062568665,
-1.0833460092544556,
0.548688530921936,
-0.09522005170583725,
0.07241655886173248,
1.020890474319458,
0.5550548434257507,
0.5608319640159607,
-0.02780548669397831,
1.1079758405685425,
-0.10460269451141357,
0.5117291808128357,
-0.6275418400764465,
0.7900789976119995,
-0.6255416870117188,
-0.06434674561023712,
-0.029046494513750076,
-0.5153740048408508,
-0.3367426097393036,
0.51090407371521,
-0.19082751870155334,
0.05125454068183899,
0.609411358833313,
0.9548784494400024,
-0.2759271562099457,
0.2555323541164398,
0.690239667892456,
0.44038525223731995,
0.5986397862434387,
0.16419900953769684,
1.2049480676651,
0.0208581555634737,
0.6847348213195801,
-0.09277255833148956,
-0.3395251929759979,
-0.3833124339580536,
-1.2809345722198486,
-1.0238161087036133,
-0.6433144807815552,
-0.003747344482690096,
-0.37510254979133606,
-0.18856917321681976,
1.0185391902923584,
0.8032088279724121,
-0.6630910634994507,
0.1507169008255005,
0.508370041847229,
0.23201778531074524,
-0.05271431431174278,
-0.14039424061775208,
0.16167454421520233,
-0.17041805386543274,
-0.4066941738128662,
0.5556389689445496,
0.3411281108856201,
0.03526672348380089,
-0.48640403151512146,
-0.03128303959965706,
-0.2019428163766861,
0.11242230981588364,
1.0483084917068481,
0.08690820634365082,
-0.9917654991149902,
-0.5564266443252563,
-0.02760477550327778,
-0.10518978536128998,
-0.11246895045042038,
1.1133891344070435,
-0.5298284888267517,
0.6533029675483704,
0.46219325065612793,
0.5158921480178833,
0.16019558906555176,
-0.06735115498304367,
0.40285301208496094,
-0.7553251385688782,
0.08114930987358093,
0.1171129047870636,
0.619149923324585,
0.45648542046546936,
-0.07174508273601532,
0.11185958236455917,
0.46432897448539734,
-0.5381389856338501,
-0.8631355166435242,
0.381392240524292,
-0.87030428647995,
-0.3252623975276947,
1.167283058166504,
-0.1921999454498291,
0.008106891997158527,
-0.41962122917175293,
-0.2490367591381073,
0.05532243102788925,
-0.35722997784614563,
0.5533714294433594,
0.8441861867904663,
0.09441409260034561,
-0.2906251847743988,
-0.7649316191673279,
0.462268203496933,
0.046592507511377335,
-0.7458873987197876,
0.3919287621974945,
0.8311648964881897,
0.3485810160636902,
0.35923510789871216,
0.4593064486980438,
-0.11018937826156616,
0.3564656674861908,
0.04867132380604744,
0.0430179238319397,
-0.38562893867492676,
-0.5439302325248718,
-0.13694672286510468,
0.5362759232521057,
0.0064405035227537155,
0.1781080812215805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04808v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04808v1
|
WaterMax: breaking the LLM watermark detectability-robustness-quality trade-off
| 2024-03-06T10:55:30 | 2024-03-06T10:55:30 |
Eva Giboulot, Furon Teddy
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Watermarking is a technical means to dissuade malfeasant usage of Large
Language Models. This paper proposes a novel watermarking scheme, so-called
WaterMax, that enjoys high detectability while sustaining the quality of the
generated text of the original LLM. Its new design leaves the LLM untouched (no
modification of the weights, logits, temperature, or sampling technique).
WaterMax balances robustness and complexity contrary to the watermarking
techniques of the literature inherently provoking a trade-off between quality
and robustness. Its performance is both theoretically proven and experimentally
validated. It outperforms all the SotA techniques under the most complete
benchmark suite.
|
[
-0.5253451466560364,
-0.7859548926353455,
0.36042654514312744,
0.1834484487771988,
-0.7160515785217285,
0.4176478981971741,
0.251312255859375,
-0.6254864931106567,
0.10320821404457092,
0.6891149878501892,
-0.44279706478118896,
-0.2390218824148178,
-0.9562314748764038,
-0.043988119810819626,
-0.5600572824478149,
0.6552144885063171,
-0.3336186408996582,
-0.08892188966274261,
-0.21056130528450012,
-0.5089869499206543,
-0.31534066796302795,
-0.4696784019470215,
-0.6754794120788574,
-0.4824717342853546,
0.3625573515892029,
0.16311462223529816,
1.0733363628387451,
0.9830934405326843,
0.45180585980415344,
0.25780558586120605,
-0.39819636940956116,
0.22270168364048004,
-0.555182933807373,
0.34401676058769226,
-0.0686589777469635,
-0.5868925452232361,
-0.23699922859668732,
0.09940331429243088,
0.7168786525726318,
0.11819522082805634,
0.3003086745738983,
-0.0015474623069167137,
0.2902110517024994,
0.7194404006004333,
-0.8291397094726562,
0.21782630681991577,
-0.6554583311080933,
0.07336830347776413,
-0.4062000811100006,
-0.39130493998527527,
-0.2449548840522766,
-0.12698504328727722,
-0.25192907452583313,
-0.5824156403541565,
-0.1449560523033142,
0.08569423854351044,
1.167306900024414,
0.3341362476348877,
0.008280428126454353,
-0.161568745970726,
-0.7497529983520508,
0.8467946648597717,
-0.795796275138855,
0.2502885162830353,
0.5579289197921753,
0.30099424719810486,
0.06694003939628601,
-0.595983624458313,
-0.7103191018104553,
0.14782635867595673,
0.41161420941352844,
0.05449594557285309,
-0.5367414951324463,
-0.34951385855674744,
0.26940038800239563,
0.4307442307472229,
-0.3959665894508362,
-0.08746356517076492,
-0.08687209337949753,
-0.2162562757730484,
0.6763115525245667,
0.1516232192516327,
0.6042430400848389,
0.33229759335517883,
-0.626516580581665,
0.06268145143985748,
-0.9580913782119751,
0.13200660049915314,
0.39695098996162415,
0.10479918867349625,
0.46094125509262085,
0.5079452991485596,
0.006109828129410744,
0.4868273437023163,
-0.4017513692378998,
-0.4258701503276825,
-0.1053352802991867,
-0.07937223464250565,
-0.3791142702102661,
-0.04305228963494301,
0.6372280716896057,
0.29589617252349854,
0.3641751706600189,
0.07228822261095047,
-0.6104127764701843,
-0.1243942528963089,
-0.16471701860427856,
-0.7459336519241333,
0.061249058693647385,
0.08466203510761261,
-0.4050239026546478,
-0.4657328128814697,
-0.0078095016069710255,
-0.5173375010490417,
-0.518499493598938,
-0.21906359493732452,
0.8626478910446167,
-0.32913562655448914,
-0.40984028577804565,
0.2769725024700165,
-0.09157585352659225,
0.11980783939361572,
0.1292213499546051,
-0.48444032669067383,
0.2660137116909027,
0.6749858260154724,
0.913015604019165,
-0.32196685671806335,
-0.0953730046749115,
-0.47973766922950745,
0.29589489102363586,
-0.30781257152557373,
0.9021015763282776,
-0.6538222432136536,
-0.5364581942558289,
-0.05967869982123375,
-0.146361842751503,
0.30483677983283997,
-0.8473827242851257,
0.3893077075481415,
-0.9004998803138733,
0.020062124356627464,
-0.2371775060892105,
-0.8149685859680176,
0.019959986209869385,
0.29676011204719543,
-1.0224100351333618,
0.9486342668533325,
0.005827661138027906,
-0.8867976665496826,
0.590391218662262,
-0.36353158950805664,
-0.24842461943626404,
0.26652657985687256,
0.1772712618112564,
-0.820763111114502,
-0.18894712626934052,
-0.12376923859119415,
0.16452538967132568,
-0.2221056967973709,
0.1640566736459732,
-0.34032583236694336,
-0.5993921756744385,
0.5652267336845398,
-0.5553733110427856,
0.71543949842453,
0.2892267107963562,
-0.42310988903045654,
-0.12752945721149445,
-0.8243021368980408,
0.1615389585494995,
0.4531390070915222,
-0.710847020149231,
-0.5178762078285217,
-0.18371184170246124,
0.09460240602493286,
0.01546501088887453,
0.2546918988227844,
-0.44894710183143616,
-0.02023707516491413,
-0.10340047627687454,
0.550368070602417,
0.6907656192779541,
-0.11442103236913681,
0.26097649335861206,
-0.48341989517211914,
0.7907286882400513,
-0.1791735142469406,
0.3917223811149597,
-0.05422423407435417,
-0.5848931670188904,
-0.7282503247261047,
-0.6371461749076843,
0.5256308317184448,
0.6089126467704773,
-0.7902455925941467,
0.19418221712112427,
-0.14662526547908783,
-0.4650857448577881,
-0.2737037241458893,
0.5297443270683289,
0.44481784105300903,
0.08547999709844589,
0.532739520072937,
-0.18202140927314758,
-0.3685626685619354,
-0.7946717143058777,
-0.6169432401657104,
0.11997643113136292,
0.15339595079421997,
0.11101879924535751,
0.41455939412117004,
-0.3437921404838562,
1.0343310832977295,
-0.3780747354030609,
-0.1869785487651825,
-0.5262360572814941,
0.025604860857129097,
0.1217314824461937,
0.5524711608886719,
0.2836645245552063,
-0.8228137493133545,
-0.6767057776451111,
-0.38009336590766907,
-0.41351398825645447,
-0.32129961252212524,
0.021454989910125732,
-0.16150452196598053,
0.08727459609508514,
0.6647928953170776,
-0.5712419152259827,
0.7223336696624756,
0.6555829644203186,
-0.5551196932792664,
0.6588285565376282,
-0.09039962291717529,
-0.15272167325019836,
-0.9511145353317261,
0.06767252087593079,
-0.17188113927841187,
-0.3914352059364319,
-0.5444065928459167,
0.1441488116979599,
0.14118540287017822,
-0.02302050217986107,
-0.44809648394584656,
0.78453129529953,
-0.4871882498264313,
0.22720980644226074,
-0.7300262451171875,
-0.15567490458488464,
0.4400792121887207,
-0.11019358783960342,
-0.2636897563934326,
0.8235228657722473,
0.4822717607021332,
-0.42062267661094666,
0.3657153844833374,
0.25688621401786804,
-0.32236289978027344,
0.629157304763794,
-0.7925593852996826,
-0.03172992542386055,
-0.00853064563125372,
-0.008090905845165253,
-1.0480095148086548,
0.3702229857444763,
0.03829517588019371,
-0.3905879259109497,
0.6089535355567932,
-0.14647112786769867,
-0.5765264630317688,
0.1110919713973999,
-0.457491397857666,
0.37438642978668213,
0.46329465508461,
-0.5889047384262085,
0.5615095496177673,
0.40324667096138,
-0.1702529639005661,
-0.5849992036819458,
-1.072792649269104,
0.45243585109710693,
-0.28346964716911316,
-0.6367473602294922,
0.41330140829086304,
-0.15966518223285675,
-0.4129313826560974,
0.03314662724733353,
-0.4719865322113037,
-0.4129434823989868,
0.0759478360414505,
0.17815591394901276,
0.2546263039112091,
-0.18232190608978271,
-0.2611009478569031,
0.04187532141804695,
-0.5394725203514099,
-0.13932205736637115,
-0.1389797329902649,
0.5573030114173889,
0.2706594467163086,
-0.23626762628555298,
-0.4929088056087494,
0.4252241253852844,
0.6806020736694336,
-0.23123310506343842,
0.8034148812294006,
0.32809707522392273,
-0.6314006447792053,
-0.344063937664032,
-0.44568294286727905,
0.025024695321917534,
-0.5595259070396423,
-0.0861019715666771,
-0.3019922375679016,
-0.9425821900367737,
0.43858569860458374,
-0.033749423921108246,
0.00845244713127613,
0.2692255973815918,
0.10425009578466415,
-0.0992896631360054,
0.8137320280075073,
0.6306813359260559,
-0.2453082650899887,
0.5591247081756592,
-0.24366801977157593,
0.4143349230289459,
-0.5564144253730774,
0.036755211651325226,
-0.5651777982711792,
-0.20881015062332153,
-0.18950249254703522,
-0.3710821568965912,
-0.08094213157892227,
0.3027971386909485,
-0.059304747730493546,
0.5053763389587402,
-0.2730853259563446,
0.7487257719039917,
0.5071333050727844,
-0.021980274468660355,
0.605910062789917,
0.18049393594264984,
-0.21309538185596466,
-0.22788843512535095,
-0.4568411111831665,
-0.6958683729171753,
0.8613685965538025,
0.23205289244651794,
0.7739492058753967,
0.17310728132724762,
0.6993744373321533,
0.6014952063560486,
0.4149787127971649,
-0.5571868419647217,
0.5158721804618835,
0.13923504948616028,
-0.833092451095581,
-0.5137476921081543,
-0.49603044986724854,
-1.1180404424667358,
0.3061385452747345,
-0.2353576272726059,
-0.4418775141239166,
-0.04914470016956329,
-0.058774832636117935,
-0.03837469592690468,
0.5915250778198242,
-0.2740147113800049,
0.5951429009437561,
-0.10069241374731064,
-0.8481815457344055,
-0.08313728868961334,
-0.19822469353675842,
0.19806551933288574,
-0.27649810910224915,
0.5512691140174866,
-0.39580264687538147,
-0.35696718096733093,
0.6295090913772583,
-0.5297836065292358,
0.522370457649231,
-0.2942068874835968,
-0.3790547549724579,
0.33670684695243835,
0.6079384684562683,
0.6194623708724976,
0.03391043096780777,
0.058695077896118164,
-0.04193580895662308,
0.13096308708190918,
-0.7030060291290283,
-0.31901639699935913,
0.517354428768158,
-0.5108578205108643,
-0.4845772385597229,
-0.4243178069591522,
-0.37898173928260803,
-0.3245660364627838,
0.39486777782440186,
0.39301109313964844,
0.3945819139480591,
0.008228556253015995,
0.07237734645605087,
0.8140540719032288,
-0.4017896056175232,
0.45116525888442993,
0.5666505694389343,
-0.2023850828409195,
-0.48624470829963684,
1.1455881595611572,
0.295969694852829,
0.3933200240135193,
0.43093141913414,
0.3290393650531769,
-0.41283443570137024,
-0.8475637435913086,
-0.2349817156791687,
0.045641958713531494,
-0.795975923538208,
-0.33217653632164,
-0.32478067278862,
-0.5157495141029358,
0.09389759600162506,
-0.11459235101938248,
-0.47733190655708313,
-0.309663325548172,
-0.27116504311561584,
-0.10413756221532822,
0.053746629506349564,
0.5350257158279419,
-0.03051052987575531,
0.06717897951602936,
-0.8809828162193298,
0.3066537380218506,
0.6895433068275452,
0.4340307116508484,
-0.4137449860572815,
-0.8100842833518982,
-0.05402354523539543,
-0.13230547308921814,
-0.29372984170913696,
-0.5931947231292725,
0.3887755572795868,
0.35562050342559814,
0.6171455979347229,
0.7577056884765625,
0.10842393338680267,
0.3854237198829651,
-0.17122480273246765,
0.5184714198112488,
0.3337225317955017,
-1.3609553575515747,
0.4588075876235962,
-0.2316262125968933,
0.31771719455718994,
0.4646399915218353,
0.19535931944847107,
-0.27677303552627563,
-0.619379997253418,
-0.6300936341285706,
-1.0705089569091797,
0.0510902926325798,
0.29907771944999695,
0.40517574548721313,
0.41229093074798584,
0.30970123410224915,
0.281684547662735,
0.03189574554562569,
-0.8095362782478333,
-0.12180130928754807,
-0.14621412754058838,
0.008577706292271614,
0.062102556228637695,
-0.7857584357261658,
-0.22684083878993988,
-0.2399291694164276,
0.6824017763137817,
-0.11983484029769897,
0.009582335129380226,
0.14334316551685333,
-0.3405890464782715,
0.024702398106455803,
0.19363932311534882,
0.6741855144500732,
0.7313768863677979,
0.10116364061832428,
0.5224196314811707,
0.18800342082977295,
-0.5490544438362122,
0.3448604345321655,
-0.2770540416240692,
-0.412014901638031,
0.10536198318004608,
0.6680042743682861,
0.6057093739509583,
0.036356423050165176,
-0.8757901787757874,
0.5446867346763611,
-0.08004526048898697,
-0.37046343088150024,
0.1100778803229332,
0.286555677652359,
0.14067426323890686,
0.235588937997818,
0.460426926612854,
-0.010063689202070236,
0.005191932898014784,
-0.2961397171020508,
0.31163379549980164,
0.5138261914253235,
-0.40982088446617126,
-0.17085321247577667,
0.7642107009887695,
0.008597276173532009,
-0.20842592418193817,
0.013405642472207546,
-0.07124926149845123,
-0.6379330158233643,
0.48267847299575806,
0.5423564314842224,
0.5636945366859436,
-0.17872196435928345,
0.03814231604337692,
0.14120040833950043,
0.5121544003486633,
-0.1621417999267578,
0.5521968603134155,
0.01244710385799408,
-1.0096261501312256,
-0.3809208869934082,
-0.5116915106773376,
-0.8075631260871887,
0.26571404933929443,
-0.672899603843689,
0.03968289867043495,
-0.6777242422103882,
-0.28962045907974243,
-0.2886890172958374,
-0.04738132283091545,
-0.2605343461036682,
0.37231796979904175,
0.2660830020904541,
1.1784144639968872,
-0.6367871165275574,
0.8742896318435669,
0.33191654086112976,
-0.04459996521472931,
-0.4707704484462738,
0.06783921271562576,
0.09851762652397156,
-1.1555384397506714,
0.2537347674369812,
0.2827862501144409,
-0.2865177094936371,
-0.0934525802731514,
-0.8352866768836975,
-0.9082627892494202,
1.0572035312652588,
0.6520742774009705,
-0.4942728877067566,
0.6867275834083557,
0.3792122006416321,
0.312950074672699,
-0.013513765297830105,
-0.2779328525066376,
0.7890324592590332,
0.7321025729179382,
-0.13214653730392456,
-0.6338360905647278,
0.3730941712856293,
-0.5611646771430969,
-0.028452187776565552,
-0.011294471099972725,
-0.7730767726898193,
0.4304889440536499,
0.024946819990873337,
-0.37914708256721497,
0.08311477303504944,
0.24268954992294312,
0.4056318402290344,
0.33024826645851135,
0.6716803908348083,
0.7202727198600769,
0.7023649215698242,
-0.3172295391559601,
0.7701278328895569,
-0.3329402506351471,
0.3937896490097046,
0.6578451991081238,
-0.42113468050956726,
0.8727088570594788,
0.6802253723144531,
-0.3649984896183014,
0.0383489727973938,
0.4282419681549072,
-0.21942175924777985,
0.5301544070243835,
0.4207870066165924,
-0.503316342830658,
-0.370242178440094,
-0.186622753739357,
-0.4821530878543854,
0.31620168685913086,
0.15254758298397064,
-0.22540885210037231,
0.10000235587358475,
-0.23466791212558746,
0.31195247173309326,
-0.007501309737563133,
-0.1433723419904709,
0.5254248380661011,
0.18411844968795776,
-0.15271484851837158,
0.6854760646820068,
-0.03163059055805206,
0.8970147967338562,
-0.48659881949424744,
0.28837624192237854,
-0.4522233307361603,
0.1736520677804947,
-0.299050897359848,
-0.9027605056762695,
0.41975137591362,
0.02558666653931141,
-0.023008741438388824,
-0.6028048396110535,
0.9723925590515137,
-0.21900302171707153,
-0.27368468046188354,
0.677097499370575,
0.5050776600837708,
-0.0504118949174881,
-0.3497561812400818,
-0.7181867957115173,
0.4492299556732178,
-0.12703350186347961,
-0.5261757969856262,
0.3036201298236847,
0.39195334911346436,
0.3803682327270508,
1.0355509519577026,
0.9000174403190613,
0.18633462488651276,
0.17096209526062012,
-0.01373488549143076,
0.8131909370422363,
-0.706289529800415,
-0.4753556549549103,
-1.1454026699066162,
0.22702433168888092,
-0.11354000866413116,
-0.13869264721870422,
0.7115210294723511,
0.7025280594825745,
0.500771701335907,
0.19260388612747192,
1.0590322017669678,
0.3736771047115326,
0.08658841997385025,
-0.5540916323661804,
1.0001460313796997,
-0.7218571901321411,
0.36603179574012756,
-0.31349170207977295,
-0.9364539384841919,
-0.5696752667427063,
0.38034549355506897,
0.24287232756614685,
-0.1712626963853836,
0.58513343334198,
0.6733370423316956,
-0.008712218143045902,
0.009494856931269169,
0.7606984376907349,
-0.08651937544345856,
0.48201650381088257,
0.4189584255218506,
1.0391026735305786,
-0.2928541600704193,
0.9473621249198914,
0.03325958922505379,
-0.3467491567134857,
-0.18720051646232605,
-0.9267072081565857,
-0.7658545970916748,
-0.3326845169067383,
-0.4991709589958191,
-0.6477236747741699,
-0.0695318654179573,
0.2956870496273041,
0.7632400393486023,
-0.8641279935836792,
0.198774054646492,
-0.05142013728618622,
0.2539762258529663,
-0.19692276418209076,
-0.20759643614292145,
0.12435220181941986,
0.0207956675440073,
-0.4969143867492676,
0.38816916942596436,
0.6321251392364502,
0.39867648482322693,
-0.38953882455825806,
-0.22167304158210754,
0.20029553771018982,
0.5939076542854309,
0.42992299795150757,
0.30512911081314087,
-0.2492033988237381,
-0.0255490280687809,
-0.2025774121284485,
-0.3651600182056427,
0.2061215341091156,
0.8089375495910645,
-0.10572715103626251,
0.3671949505805969,
0.6548192501068115,
0.7855469584465027,
0.5495966672897339,
-0.4420788586139679,
0.3537134528160095,
-0.4782567024230957,
0.08181951195001602,
0.09685458987951279,
0.6500241160392761,
0.39051297307014465,
-0.11484485864639282,
0.44666787981987,
0.6602136492729187,
-0.2540120482444763,
-0.9582081437110901,
0.0757305771112442,
-0.8262999057769775,
-0.41415485739707947,
1.2520164251327515,
-0.40375834703445435,
-0.06366507709026337,
-0.3805789351463318,
-0.3148424029350281,
0.014846475794911385,
-0.10518094897270203,
0.8531507253646851,
1.0569205284118652,
0.26079893112182617,
-0.21082957088947296,
-0.5025036334991455,
0.2518879771232605,
0.416562557220459,
-0.7413102388381958,
-0.15100868046283722,
-0.11818884313106537,
0.7141364216804504,
0.05080532282590866,
0.4413241744041443,
-0.30597618222236633,
0.16507254540920258,
0.09401531517505646,
0.08245135843753815,
-0.37934762239456177,
-0.09455428272485733,
-0.1350233554840088,
0.3685790002346039,
0.256502240896225,
-0.14726164937019348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03582v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03582v1
|
Design of an Open-Source Architecture for Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-03-06T09:57:52 | 2024-03-06T09:57:52 |
Séamus Lankford, Haithem Afli, Andy Way
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
adaptNMT is an open-source application that offers a streamlined approach to
the development and deployment of Recurrent Neural Networks and Transformer
models. This application is built upon the widely-adopted OpenNMT ecosystem,
and is particularly useful for new entrants to the field, as it simplifies the
setup of the development environment and creation of train, validation, and
test splits. The application offers a graphing feature that illustrates the
progress of model training, and employs SentencePiece for creating subword
segmentation models. Furthermore, the application provides an intuitive user
interface that facilitates hyperparameter customization. Notably, a
single-click model development approach has been implemented, and models
developed by adaptNMT can be evaluated using a range of metrics. To encourage
eco-friendly research, adaptNMT incorporates a green report that flags the
power consumption and kgCO${_2}$ emissions generated during model development.
The application is freely available.
|
[
-0.4003238081932068,
-0.3948620557785034,
0.4368036389350891,
0.4225459694862366,
-0.3720737099647522,
-0.4247733950614929,
-0.3857848644256592,
-0.10151103883981705,
0.1644333004951477,
0.6915953755378723,
-0.34942907094955444,
-0.5896896719932556,
-0.3560589551925659,
0.04467270150780678,
-0.16666948795318604,
0.7286123633384705,
-0.30527424812316895,
0.09672906249761581,
0.030052855610847473,
-0.5680010318756104,
-0.3948945701122284,
-0.06042760983109474,
-0.662883996963501,
-0.4085022509098053,
0.6735509634017944,
0.3325237035751343,
0.7299286127090454,
0.862467348575592,
0.7642525434494019,
0.2265927940607071,
-0.2947408854961395,
-0.10881952941417694,
0.0601726733148098,
0.22661061584949493,
-0.37321528792381287,
-0.4409836232662201,
-0.5837112665176392,
-0.1678277850151062,
0.38692912459373474,
0.44619470834732056,
-0.3095875382423401,
0.6192602515220642,
-0.11849910020828247,
0.5825510621070862,
-0.33634719252586365,
0.14704404771327972,
-0.6948895454406738,
0.12801218032836914,
-0.05736256018280983,
-0.1761196255683899,
-0.3763100802898407,
-0.5166361331939697,
0.04063650220632553,
-0.5520470142364502,
-0.05375242978334427,
-0.05825461074709892,
0.5844988822937012,
0.42384812235832214,
-0.3580658435821533,
-0.22537949681282043,
-0.7021309733390808,
0.49998974800109863,
-0.7584883570671082,
0.45727935433387756,
-0.17999354004859924,
0.7323983311653137,
-0.1912943571805954,
-1.1815344095230103,
-0.4871003329753876,
-0.039528172463178635,
-0.06596457213163376,
0.22167138755321503,
-0.40988191962242126,
-0.03184373676776886,
-0.24134618043899536,
0.6106866002082825,
-0.6957141757011414,
0.04400123655796051,
-0.4008887708187103,
0.1258685141801834,
-0.05784618481993675,
0.3886282444000244,
0.2153790295124054,
-0.07665938884019852,
-0.5025349855422974,
0.15772384405136108,
-0.5651450753211975,
-0.4799724221229553,
0.11705639958381653,
0.702046811580658,
-0.05485130846500397,
0.7664859890937805,
0.019132748246192932,
0.6910266280174255,
-0.42307865619659424,
0.5457184910774231,
0.24589204788208008,
-0.38307464122772217,
-0.43883392214775085,
0.16011404991149902,
0.8050708770751953,
0.34754031896591187,
0.046120818704366684,
-0.14944829046726227,
-0.23344361782073975,
-0.32273605465888977,
0.5563562512397766,
-1.0407397747039795,
-0.3323392868041992,
0.10406768321990967,
-0.6691721081733704,
-0.28143924474716187,
-0.3107428252696991,
-0.6691209077835083,
-0.11455536633729935,
-0.3571872115135193,
0.5954236388206482,
-0.4227551817893982,
-0.499251127243042,
0.15392155945301056,
-0.2605966031551361,
0.07270056754350662,
0.18922244012355804,
-0.6200045347213745,
0.23939143121242523,
0.45341894030570984,
1.3867021799087524,
0.010911347344517708,
-0.24875253438949585,
0.12032712250947952,
-0.04407192021608353,
0.037989892065525055,
0.5474323630332947,
-0.12518499791622162,
-0.3744077980518341,
-0.3596295714378357,
0.22876442968845367,
-0.254117488861084,
-0.5444145798683167,
0.47501814365386963,
-0.6347241997718811,
0.21381431818008423,
0.35140568017959595,
-0.1533132642507553,
-0.48633942008018494,
0.4871516227722168,
-0.5969454050064087,
0.8215329647064209,
0.4059537947177887,
-0.8312122225761414,
-0.115496926009655,
-1.5295082330703735,
-0.162241593003273,
0.028318651020526886,
0.3493887186050415,
-0.5413027405738831,
0.33964261412620544,
0.03949408978223801,
-0.0828356221318245,
-0.3255764842033386,
0.07748376578092575,
-0.07525546103715897,
-0.13260872662067413,
0.09094193577766418,
-0.48034313321113586,
0.9108559489250183,
0.7268054485321045,
-0.20165275037288666,
0.639845073223114,
-0.8949146270751953,
0.09172689914703369,
0.16886216402053833,
-0.7042470574378967,
-0.43912747502326965,
-0.2701999247074127,
0.226064994931221,
0.33085566759109497,
0.13494040071964264,
-0.6091881394386292,
0.1831589639186859,
-0.36534371972084045,
0.7518585324287415,
0.6049389839172363,
-0.012036226689815521,
0.17374251782894135,
0.04739517346024513,
0.5543244481086731,
0.3890005350112915,
0.25108984112739563,
-0.4769938886165619,
-0.49289464950561523,
-0.7921654582023621,
-0.056373439729213715,
0.47970688343048096,
0.5277795791625977,
-0.5682653188705444,
0.3051856756210327,
-0.360487699508667,
-0.7271161079406738,
-0.8862341642379761,
0.013095492497086525,
0.02668539248406887,
0.6902420520782471,
0.5886564254760742,
0.012947450391948223,
-0.6137165427207947,
-1.0485999584197998,
-0.29690641164779663,
0.15606577694416046,
-0.23042000830173492,
0.11160658299922943,
0.602188766002655,
-0.38242122530937195,
0.881527304649353,
-0.5045821666717529,
-0.10957945883274078,
-0.055874042212963104,
-0.09645378589630127,
0.4549833834171295,
0.5869007110595703,
0.5876895785331726,
-0.7209653258323669,
-0.3818705677986145,
0.4591735601425171,
-0.6509798169136047,
0.10141976177692413,
0.35190320014953613,
-0.3121350109577179,
-0.2072472870349884,
0.36885562539100647,
-0.615403950214386,
0.24199770390987396,
0.665116012096405,
-0.23109284043312073,
0.3270259201526642,
-0.21610833704471588,
-0.13181976974010468,
-1.6672062873840332,
0.5901468992233276,
-0.07650065422058105,
-0.22150520980358124,
-0.41406306624412537,
0.3830031156539917,
0.12700779736042023,
-0.37932389974594116,
-0.8724538683891296,
0.3086734414100647,
-0.09075629711151123,
0.013357367366552353,
-0.33739566802978516,
-0.06252338737249374,
-0.07457802444696426,
0.37164631485939026,
-0.12738196551799774,
0.8549667596817017,
0.08108396083116531,
-0.5616759061813354,
0.043433938175439835,
0.22107675671577454,
-0.38241830468177795,
0.3118760585784912,
-0.8758511543273926,
0.3384617865085602,
0.12440788000822067,
-0.14252230525016785,
-0.7416271567344666,
-0.060887787491083145,
0.4224686026573181,
-0.3723998963832855,
-0.17544563114643097,
-0.1514701098203659,
-0.4695303440093994,
-0.2092888355255127,
0.14701411128044128,
0.32898998260498047,
0.46537670493125916,
-0.6402102708816528,
0.5490502119064331,
0.1525183916091919,
-0.06834205240011215,
0.02611854486167431,
-0.9988606572151184,
0.16632230579853058,
-0.2113226354122162,
-0.5048512816429138,
0.14238637685775757,
0.039151884615421295,
-0.10811424255371094,
0.2526874244213104,
0.0927518978714943,
-0.18237154185771942,
0.2531079649925232,
0.19632995128631592,
0.023098157718777657,
-0.8440555334091187,
0.001282443176023662,
0.13705740869045258,
-0.16763819754123688,
0.0012339550303295255,
-0.9051089882850647,
0.4625614583492279,
-0.17679838836193085,
-0.1394863724708557,
-0.26734477281570435,
0.1425044685602188,
0.9100260138511658,
-0.3265138566493988,
0.5800511240959167,
0.5966836810112,
-0.3838041126728058,
-0.11834997683763504,
0.24843256175518036,
0.2779950201511383,
-0.474239706993103,
0.42166078090667725,
-0.17904023826122284,
-0.6989141702651978,
0.1877448558807373,
-0.3901742696762085,
0.41710466146469116,
0.5396750569343567,
0.6793991327285767,
0.33494752645492554,
0.9412691593170166,
0.6109468936920166,
0.45377928018569946,
0.465848445892334,
0.05285370349884033,
-0.06644315272569656,
-1.1448956727981567,
-0.11155010759830475,
-0.6644864082336426,
-0.6847488284111023,
-0.3155090808868408,
-0.3603338897228241,
0.2668007016181946,
-0.1778542846441269,
-0.5738946199417114,
0.6601423025131226,
-0.9649425148963928,
0.31190502643585205,
0.7328370213508606,
0.12137368321418762,
0.2739781439304352,
-0.06020227074623108,
-0.3404163122177124,
-0.18881049752235413,
-0.6866234540939331,
-0.5097917914390564,
0.9347957372665405,
0.45925500988960266,
0.5502919554710388,
0.3971139192581177,
0.3028240501880646,
-0.04010302945971489,
0.6296945810317993,
-0.9983039498329163,
0.4099896252155304,
-0.17823727428913116,
-0.4582253694534302,
0.016285769641399384,
-0.5499963760375977,
-0.9644455909729004,
0.18531003594398499,
0.31032344698905945,
-0.35761186480522156,
-0.041550882160663605,
0.1937781274318695,
-0.17003768682479858,
0.580062985420227,
-0.7531316876411438,
1.062089443206787,
-0.3226822018623352,
0.09361691027879715,
0.039641279727220535,
-0.58295738697052,
0.2993607819080353,
-0.02500639669597149,
-0.08341380208730698,
0.0478958897292614,
-0.06059062480926514,
0.4871461093425751,
-0.4838067889213562,
0.5052167773246765,
-0.3198889493942261,
0.17267829179763794,
0.3494369685649872,
0.15756255388259888,
0.0682821124792099,
-0.331884503364563,
-0.3692599833011627,
0.2775470018386841,
-0.43281620740890503,
-0.1659098118543625,
-0.46568235754966736,
0.7977054119110107,
-0.6008657217025757,
-0.33042827248573303,
-0.05216531455516815,
-0.893086850643158,
0.018415307626128197,
0.8169742822647095,
0.10848808288574219,
-0.10491529852151871,
-0.34688419103622437,
0.5148767232894897,
0.6144765615463257,
-0.45148661732673645,
0.28948473930358887,
0.5549060702323914,
-0.6415325403213501,
-0.966762125492096,
0.6799420714378357,
0.09903193265199661,
0.32849186658859253,
0.40064194798469543,
0.6761795282363892,
-0.16975218057632446,
-0.8622485399246216,
-0.7252788543701172,
-0.27599772810935974,
-0.6820727586746216,
-0.25064757466316223,
-0.644207239151001,
-0.16997277736663818,
-0.3294758200645447,
0.21717676520347595,
-0.48002323508262634,
-0.6718292832374573,
-0.05236218124628067,
-0.1556166559457779,
0.5489585995674133,
0.6880438923835754,
0.34406372904777527,
0.7042646408081055,
-0.7934444546699524,
0.06755884736776352,
0.03722145035862923,
0.47867581248283386,
0.011575116775929928,
-0.4381752610206604,
-0.6592153906822205,
0.157927468419075,
-0.7113604545593262,
-0.44279903173446655,
0.297469824552536,
0.052204374223947525,
0.3809112012386322,
0.13798169791698456,
-0.19930687546730042,
0.37185215950012207,
-0.550947904586792,
0.8579442501068115,
0.18324662744998932,
-0.6229443550109863,
0.6921989917755127,
-0.3223956227302551,
0.8426033854484558,
0.5992609262466431,
0.26517918705940247,
-0.437746524810791,
-0.10854160785675049,
-0.25976574420928955,
-0.8561549782752991,
0.7020980715751648,
0.2616792619228363,
0.08665148913860321,
-0.07827174663543701,
0.3344430923461914,
0.22935746610164642,
0.3582233190536499,
-0.49660176038742065,
-0.22256909310817719,
-0.6743952035903931,
-0.5292568206787109,
0.052913594990968704,
0.2851678729057312,
-0.022011231631040573,
-0.19195161759853363,
0.7256637811660767,
-0.15196841955184937,
0.2970958650112152,
0.17024792730808258,
-0.13699035346508026,
0.09262675791978836,
0.11187664419412613,
0.8564452528953552,
0.31528621912002563,
-0.2913811206817627,
0.347053587436676,
0.031396351754665375,
-0.5611879229545593,
-0.009549484588205814,
-0.08785068243741989,
-0.3619481921195984,
0.4441836178302765,
-0.25380244851112366,
1.0723152160644531,
0.3032877445220947,
-0.18938082456588745,
0.10018929839134216,
-0.2452288717031479,
-0.39100950956344604,
-0.0823032408952713,
-0.048583999276161194,
0.625130832195282,
0.2604483962059021,
-0.17162297666072845,
0.613519012928009,
0.0030972668901085854,
-0.17957629263401031,
0.10572607815265656,
-0.02804441563785076,
-0.8047869205474854,
-0.5045809149742126,
1.1459945440292358,
0.24260634183883667,
-0.8819735050201416,
0.7990396022796631,
0.3116854727268219,
-0.3793181777000427,
0.5671743750572205,
0.8982245326042175,
1.2983746528625488,
-0.22574347257614136,
-0.15327665209770203,
0.25116977095603943,
0.6318194270133972,
0.11150737851858139,
0.2752287983894348,
0.051549032330513,
-0.2225237339735031,
-0.08833247423171997,
-0.7799316644668579,
-0.3684079945087433,
0.06658384948968887,
-0.5306088924407959,
0.5111303925514221,
-0.3763013184070587,
-0.2958972752094269,
-0.04542999714612961,
-0.7435281872749329,
-0.5969964265823364,
0.08345359563827515,
-0.2914702892303467,
1.600403904914856,
-0.39925798773765564,
0.8798614144325256,
1.0093694925308228,
-0.5200830698013306,
-0.38027212023735046,
-0.1262061893939972,
-0.21895380318164825,
-0.926315188407898,
0.47583460807800293,
0.2211475968360901,
0.07842354476451874,
0.34351110458374023,
-0.1794145107269287,
-0.5338610410690308,
1.3407691717147827,
0.6214872002601624,
-0.3623329699039459,
-0.09220618009567261,
0.3302309811115265,
0.48904743790626526,
-0.35005924105644226,
0.11115127056837082,
0.10453709214925766,
0.6914756298065186,
-0.04956979304552078,
-0.6914242506027222,
0.09879153966903687,
-0.28272566199302673,
0.2449989914894104,
0.5947937369346619,
-0.5968987941741943,
0.9147727489471436,
0.16864663362503052,
-0.035487763583660126,
0.16729210317134857,
0.49872279167175293,
-0.24976277351379395,
0.4180333912372589,
0.3671743869781494,
0.6814862489700317,
0.25569239258766174,
-0.07004503905773163,
0.7184267640113831,
-0.4937657117843628,
0.38594552874565125,
1.3316324949264526,
0.05688147991895676,
0.8196746110916138,
0.6516018509864807,
-0.0947239026427269,
0.3302847743034363,
0.4485822021961212,
0.002170909196138382,
0.452243834733963,
0.37382811307907104,
-0.1936560720205307,
0.17415253818035126,
-0.21321457624435425,
-0.28108134865760803,
0.3194192945957184,
0.28376102447509766,
-0.9732521772384644,
-0.5512674450874329,
0.0635559931397438,
-0.03294806927442551,
-0.11560019850730896,
-0.4690225422382355,
0.6783605217933655,
0.35112789273262024,
-0.5821933746337891,
0.22914445400238037,
0.13083574175834656,
0.44152453541755676,
-0.6443419456481934,
0.013039804063737392,
-0.09937489777803421,
0.5676259994506836,
-0.23293493688106537,
-0.8554815649986267,
0.9499655365943909,
-0.08155213296413422,
-0.2474413514137268,
-0.2651729881763458,
0.539470911026001,
-0.3608492910861969,
-0.4013414978981018,
0.13856156170368195,
0.4527777135372162,
0.1996917873620987,
-0.19637785851955414,
-0.7271379828453064,
-0.08695711940526962,
-0.06230700761079788,
-0.40334218740463257,
0.2891021966934204,
0.5250521898269653,
0.04943191260099411,
0.3528655469417572,
0.6278748512268066,
0.08387597650289536,
0.16653330624103546,
-0.10497909784317017,
0.7065318822860718,
-0.7366463541984558,
-0.3161211907863617,
-0.8674881458282471,
0.5785959959030151,
0.13171082735061646,
-0.5416041612625122,
0.7806854248046875,
0.9067462086677551,
0.5726784467697144,
-0.312682181596756,
0.7123354077339172,
0.12091879546642303,
0.3063276410102844,
-0.24261370301246643,
0.9161844253540039,
-0.4954953193664551,
0.05497732385993004,
0.18075166642665863,
-1.007222294807434,
-0.5354309678077698,
-0.022349674254655838,
0.13771389424800873,
-0.3340708315372467,
0.5135034918785095,
0.663069486618042,
-0.6208913326263428,
0.11613628268241882,
0.17601579427719116,
0.05760848522186279,
0.3346889317035675,
0.3585868775844574,
0.561169445514679,
-0.5212835073471069,
0.8007131814956665,
-0.08215819299221039,
0.004335190635174513,
-0.1796347051858902,
-0.9642398357391357,
-0.5897138118743896,
-0.1455618441104889,
-0.25612956285476685,
-0.4304109215736389,
-0.11463048309087753,
1.0670790672302246,
0.49011608958244324,
-0.6499448418617249,
-0.15422815084457397,
-0.5196911692619324,
0.02621854841709137,
-0.4750424325466156,
-0.23798178136348724,
0.21200181543827057,
-0.20454621315002441,
-0.6838107705116272,
0.5000303983688354,
0.39548709988594055,
-0.012439320795238018,
-0.21527279913425446,
-0.15622980892658234,
-0.20338457822799683,
0.09161441773176193,
0.466380774974823,
0.20476165413856506,
-0.2902786135673523,
-0.13682858645915985,
0.1653515100479126,
0.02764892578125,
0.44692060351371765,
0.7826042771339417,
-0.4059298634529114,
0.6915735602378845,
0.5274009108543396,
0.9914218783378601,
0.2169487178325653,
-0.34573668241500854,
0.6571112275123596,
-0.5565468668937683,
0.08653754740953445,
0.1417713761329651,
0.2707681357860565,
0.24011676013469696,
-0.04925176501274109,
0.46416810154914856,
0.1989831030368805,
-0.6470304131507874,
-0.7970532774925232,
0.18159319460391998,
-0.730537474155426,
-0.090668685734272,
0.7399272918701172,
-0.2836127281188965,
-0.6002136468887329,
-0.023404398933053017,
-0.37330278754234314,
0.33326539397239685,
-0.037997595965862274,
0.4471427798271179,
0.45764705538749695,
-0.012136031873524189,
0.02032928168773651,
-0.641748309135437,
-0.15582937002182007,
0.12483792006969452,
-0.5734801292419434,
0.02919500321149826,
0.030644863843917847,
0.48451918363571167,
0.32093775272369385,
0.1375405639410019,
-0.34611544013023376,
0.09017333388328552,
0.10155970603227615,
0.4069611728191376,
-0.6621941328048706,
0.02891240082681179,
-0.5347228050231934,
0.261623740196228,
0.2160971760749817,
-0.8681873083114624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03581v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03581v1
|
Enhancing ASD detection accuracy: a combined approach of machine learning and deep learning models with natural language processing
| 2024-03-06T09:57:42 | 2024-03-06T09:57:42 |
Sergio Rubio-Martín, María Teresa García-Ordás, Martín Bayón-Gutiérrez, Natalia Prieto-Fernández, José Alberto Benítez-Andrades
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Purpose: Our study explored the use of artificial intelligence (AI) to
diagnose autism spectrum disorder (ASD). It focused on machine learning (ML)
and deep learning (DL) to detect ASD from text inputs on social media,
addressing challenges in traditional ASD diagnosis.
Methods: We used natural language processing (NLP), ML, and DL models
(including decision trees, XGB, KNN, RNN, LSTM, Bi-LSTM, BERT, and BERTweet) to
analyze 404,627 tweets, classifying them based on ASD or non-ASD authors. A
subset of 90,000 tweets was used for model training and testing.
Results: Our AI models showed high accuracy, with an 88% success rate in
identifying texts from individuals with ASD.
Conclusion: The study demonstrates AI's potential in improving ASD diagnosis,
especially in children, highlighting the importance of early detection.
|
[
-0.44646725058555603,
-1.0052225589752197,
0.314019113779068,
0.09308096021413803,
-0.002307921415194869,
0.6423906087875366,
-0.13099291920661926,
-1.0378432273864746,
0.1572999209165573,
0.341967910528183,
-0.5989912152290344,
-0.7523016929626465,
-0.8209933638572693,
0.23675940930843353,
-0.6959945559501648,
0.650363564491272,
0.006189374718815088,
0.08393478393554688,
0.34385862946510315,
-0.1418575942516327,
-0.08840110898017883,
-0.17807233333587646,
-1.5012688636779785,
-0.2693174481391907,
0.28576338291168213,
0.641616940498352,
0.6400564908981323,
0.5237597823143005,
0.6565580368041992,
0.2514069974422455,
-0.32057705521583557,
0.40545350313186646,
0.0911770910024643,
-0.0878407210111618,
-0.07209387421607971,
0.256245493888855,
-0.6954357028007507,
0.0751929059624672,
0.37872618436813354,
0.8338961601257324,
0.1276056170463562,
0.1335287243127823,
0.2735973298549652,
0.6333198547363281,
-0.21714980900287628,
0.016302242875099182,
-0.08480951189994812,
0.30586495995521545,
-0.2108217030763626,
0.015577930025756359,
-0.15550100803375244,
-0.12297865003347397,
-0.017990004271268845,
-0.6726283431053162,
0.2823077142238617,
-0.15062151849269867,
0.7200796008110046,
0.3224623203277588,
-0.7185677289962769,
-0.6368354558944702,
-0.8187845349311829,
0.38269293308258057,
-0.8228358030319214,
0.3906697630882263,
0.6295157670974731,
0.45562687516212463,
0.10477572679519653,
-0.5130595564842224,
-0.7929534316062927,
-0.09315221011638641,
0.1563403457403183,
-0.29759126901626587,
-0.2997564375400543,
0.08056896179914474,
0.28792765736579895,
0.005171858239918947,
-0.7090836763381958,
0.44615423679351807,
-0.2995595633983612,
-0.1776578575372696,
1.0895464420318604,
0.005194779951125383,
0.622001051902771,
0.14623945951461792,
0.21591028571128845,
0.2624864876270294,
-0.035425469279289246,
0.3593152165412903,
-0.007293105125427246,
0.37590742111206055,
-0.20364202558994293,
0.36432379484176636,
-0.1625606119632721,
0.4166201949119568,
0.2251683473587036,
0.18638074398040771,
0.48288118839263916,
-0.23613421618938446,
-0.10663878917694092,
0.07576674222946167,
0.9216147661209106,
0.3161601424217224,
0.5933846831321716,
-0.017751576378941536,
-0.25238826870918274,
0.29407545924186707,
0.2947629392147064,
-0.5331399440765381,
-0.27990153431892395,
0.2810536026954651,
-0.615803062915802,
-0.2616313397884369,
-0.1763840615749359,
-0.3835770785808563,
-0.6918391585350037,
-0.22207020223140717,
0.04412667453289032,
-0.7893549203872681,
-0.3559008240699768,
0.04028177261352539,
-0.18928824365139008,
-0.1957853138446808,
0.21714071929454803,
-0.9029513001441956,
0.6296314001083374,
0.5862171649932861,
0.5679672360420227,
-0.1786000281572342,
0.014426974579691887,
-0.4935411214828491,
-0.07919623702764511,
-0.6260890364646912,
1.0656911134719849,
-0.48666253685951233,
0.010988476686179638,
-0.20334820449352264,
-0.08557118475437164,
-0.048885732889175415,
-0.5190293788909912,
0.793432891368866,
-0.5076479315757751,
-0.27501922845840454,
-0.046971991658210754,
-0.5518032908439636,
-0.35431697964668274,
0.14524400234222412,
-0.8113582730293274,
0.8340840935707092,
0.19652606546878815,
-0.37875595688819885,
0.719311535358429,
-1.0920441150665283,
-0.7400263547897339,
0.25261640548706055,
0.07628391683101654,
-0.5868701338768005,
-0.17276261746883392,
0.7452057600021362,
0.5747722387313843,
-0.10359631478786469,
0.4963226318359375,
-0.49733421206474304,
-0.31459036469459534,
0.05515375733375549,
-0.4940843880176544,
1.070297122001648,
0.342384397983551,
-0.5268754363059998,
0.15186965465545654,
-0.6124984622001648,
0.09922342002391815,
-0.045003492385149,
-0.27765294909477234,
0.0803995206952095,
0.18340812623500824,
0.32979118824005127,
0.004317895043641329,
-0.279863178730011,
-0.599888265132904,
-0.12753599882125854,
-0.7191611528396606,
0.3174474537372589,
0.47785067558288574,
0.1364632546901703,
0.21233052015304565,
-0.46264684200286865,
0.5910331606864929,
0.32809048891067505,
0.09430589526891708,
0.1681571751832962,
-0.9972745180130005,
-0.21847249567508698,
-0.1137751117348671,
0.3797997534275055,
0.4290260374546051,
-0.6693083047866821,
0.9473637938499451,
-0.16342929005622864,
-0.08890751004219055,
-0.731182873249054,
0.22608575224876404,
0.2807544767856598,
0.5411470532417297,
0.42824476957321167,
-0.20442980527877808,
-0.47800591588020325,
-0.4678785800933838,
-0.3733615279197693,
0.13544180989265442,
0.031711384654045105,
0.23809096217155457,
0.4797280430793762,
-0.5240798592567444,
0.7039574980735779,
0.08658690750598907,
-0.49945521354675293,
-0.22088514268398285,
0.30216076970100403,
-0.06843600422143936,
0.4099607765674591,
0.7608888149261475,
-0.7870203256607056,
-1.0265473127365112,
0.2232530117034912,
-0.7454619407653809,
-0.24677032232284546,
0.47824183106422424,
0.4627651870250702,
0.4680943191051483,
0.5294422507286072,
-0.3243110775947571,
0.7667175531387329,
0.3111979067325592,
-0.8820691704750061,
0.04857005178928375,
0.13335856795310974,
0.40425965189933777,
-0.8350209593772888,
0.08757764846086502,
0.2641022205352783,
-0.38636383414268494,
-0.6575961709022522,
-0.19382968544960022,
0.16157080233097076,
-0.1684771478176117,
-0.10313689708709717,
0.4050441384315491,
-0.15238918364048004,
-0.16702647507190704,
-0.2570485472679138,
-0.12499755620956421,
-0.10890644043684006,
-0.24927371740341187,
-0.2750892639160156,
0.5212548971176147,
0.7208064794540405,
-0.665197491645813,
0.2589057683944702,
0.07969492673873901,
-0.2530393898487091,
0.31272897124290466,
-0.47947993874549866,
-0.06559893488883972,
-0.055284228175878525,
0.273444265127182,
-1.2362967729568481,
-0.22720713913440704,
0.5720129609107971,
-0.9263791441917419,
0.29917916655540466,
0.341330885887146,
-0.5099164843559265,
-0.8397058248519897,
-0.33566901087760925,
0.3539421558380127,
0.17915786802768707,
-0.5443120002746582,
0.5921593904495239,
0.572953999042511,
-0.10087959468364716,
-0.54703688621521,
-0.6927275657653809,
0.2906354069709778,
0.03293647617101669,
-0.7991278767585754,
0.2725745439529419,
-0.11515523493289948,
-0.1879381388425827,
0.3613510727882385,
-0.06961384415626526,
-0.270686537027359,
0.6281639337539673,
-0.12697206437587738,
-0.191334530711174,
-0.5277179479598999,
0.30237510800361633,
0.22791650891304016,
-0.20547926425933838,
-0.0304498802870512,
0.22332130372524261,
0.6981855630874634,
-0.05634625256061554,
-0.3768393397331238,
-0.9158762693405151,
0.5177668929100037,
0.4066701829433441,
-0.33344441652297974,
0.6097387075424194,
0.6818934082984924,
-0.7622827887535095,
-0.6196731328964233,
-0.13813714683055878,
-0.24382922053337097,
-0.5129390954971313,
-0.06455761194229126,
-0.006185585167258978,
-0.6038186550140381,
0.598050057888031,
0.26721563935279846,
-0.38796550035476685,
0.5669841766357422,
0.23763108253479004,
-0.5543241500854492,
1.4339301586151123,
0.6296592950820923,
-0.26509547233581543,
0.4551934003829956,
-0.40772518515586853,
0.4992625117301941,
-0.5646820664405823,
0.08847862482070923,
-0.34041470289230347,
-0.5205550789833069,
-0.288000226020813,
-0.03835776820778847,
0.13236655294895172,
-0.3874037563800812,
-0.5365388989448547,
-0.2313997894525528,
-0.7971404790878296,
0.5347957015037537,
0.5482620000839233,
0.35418614745140076,
0.21837007999420166,
-0.0762672945857048,
0.22357583045959473,
0.05667445808649063,
-0.44622406363487244,
-0.7064938545227051,
1.5708884000778198,
0.4335971474647522,
0.03128360956907272,
0.12113933265209198,
0.5160712599754333,
0.8367652297019958,
0.7207216024398804,
-0.8962476849555969,
0.3491556644439697,
-0.5978783369064331,
-0.770860493183136,
-0.355092853307724,
-0.2997857928276062,
-1.1697458028793335,
-0.3737756609916687,
-0.24789468944072723,
-0.8809620141983032,
0.18373194336891174,
-0.08066866546869278,
-0.7744843363761902,
0.23711933195590973,
-0.6609044671058655,
0.9236966371536255,
-0.3619031310081482,
0.4068840742111206,
-0.2873533070087433,
-0.5497950911521912,
0.3856673836708069,
-0.35794466733932495,
0.3227088451385498,
-0.19856512546539307,
-0.09296093881130219,
1.124325156211853,
-0.2650432586669922,
0.6789687275886536,
-0.1375351846218109,
0.14747212827205658,
0.16434739530086517,
-0.2344335913658142,
-0.00909144151955843,
-0.02638285607099533,
-0.2936469316482544,
0.23452256619930267,
-0.2256995290517807,
-0.24751608073711395,
-0.2413499355316162,
0.4957263171672821,
-0.9990178942680359,
-0.13403324782848358,
-0.6685456037521362,
-0.5420041084289551,
-0.333846777677536,
0.356677770614624,
-0.0037064137868583202,
0.2543834149837494,
0.05391010642051697,
0.1192035898566246,
0.5134257674217224,
-0.12964892387390137,
0.8058654069900513,
0.7255922555923462,
-0.06742098182439804,
-0.04680617153644562,
0.5911100506782532,
0.41038063168525696,
-0.2220931202173233,
-0.09556999057531357,
0.17582225799560547,
-0.06980770081281662,
-0.75336754322052,
-0.3176860213279724,
0.160407155752182,
-0.5779545307159424,
-0.2239733785390854,
-0.6830084919929504,
-0.5811867713928223,
-0.9254018664360046,
-0.2633574604988098,
-0.2221110761165619,
-0.16479936242103577,
-0.6591676473617554,
-0.3514380156993866,
0.4530757963657379,
1.0063676834106445,
-0.2736608684062958,
0.4551311433315277,
-0.6039530634880066,
1.0933377742767334,
-0.17643453180789948,
0.4925820231437683,
0.09515932202339172,
-0.30437561869621277,
0.010292863473296165,
0.5278148055076599,
-0.4752250909805298,
-0.8691900372505188,
0.7730758190155029,
0.5487659573554993,
0.4881397485733032,
0.5764874815940857,
0.24932675063610077,
0.5202585458755493,
0.011983420699834824,
0.680444598197937,
-0.16110284626483917,
-0.9204007387161255,
0.6459234952926636,
-0.2396102249622345,
0.00881735049188137,
0.3036312460899353,
0.5817043781280518,
-0.5073485374450684,
-0.4210849702358246,
-0.760803759098053,
-0.746770977973938,
1.1626307964324951,
-0.04384581744670868,
-0.3060147762298584,
0.07260134071111679,
0.16417379677295685,
-0.1760367602109909,
-0.07544373720884323,
-0.461893230676651,
-0.41809403896331787,
0.1632353663444519,
-0.7053302526473999,
-0.5441709160804749,
-0.28398847579956055,
-0.009288139641284943,
-0.8646305203437805,
0.613254725933075,
-0.055513206869363785,
0.28639838099479675,
-0.05131976678967476,
0.1290644109249115,
-0.5181277990341187,
-0.2698759138584137,
0.31165221333503723,
0.5933718681335449,
-0.010175450704991817,
-0.1798265129327774,
-0.1277499496936798,
-0.571894645690918,
0.0044813924469053745,
0.4118405878543854,
-0.14311359822750092,
0.03572533652186394,
0.642530083656311,
0.3733257055282593,
-0.1824692338705063,
-0.7746819257736206,
0.6431846618652344,
-0.30623432993888855,
-0.306210994720459,
-0.43039390444755554,
0.13389040529727936,
0.34154221415519714,
0.34466230869293213,
0.6801565289497375,
0.40652355551719666,
0.35782942175865173,
-0.4559360444545746,
0.6582852602005005,
0.5857102870941162,
-0.20257973670959473,
-0.11451470106840134,
0.597856342792511,
0.08905903995037079,
-1.0292413234710693,
0.6793072819709778,
-0.4237075448036194,
-0.492643803358078,
1.282932162284851,
0.35013797879219055,
0.7910542488098145,
-0.46838143467903137,
0.48459216952323914,
-0.14035582542419434,
0.369746595621109,
0.19325344264507294,
0.546679675579071,
-0.12847769260406494,
-1.1488734483718872,
-0.1340162456035614,
-0.3437190353870392,
-0.11958402395248413,
0.26020511984825134,
-0.5278026461601257,
0.21003763377666473,
-0.8249405026435852,
-0.3025819659233093,
0.7468233108520508,
0.35716885328292847,
-0.5049369931221008,
0.5873721241950989,
0.4160717725753784,
0.6594900488853455,
-1.0024495124816895,
0.7372186183929443,
0.7162082195281982,
-0.31388476490974426,
-1.0391602516174316,
0.3467422425746918,
0.15528298914432526,
-0.6444634199142456,
0.5896582007408142,
0.5417237877845764,
0.11411125957965851,
0.1766255497932434,
-0.7231383323669434,
-0.9158756136894226,
0.771090567111969,
0.28515008091926575,
-0.13106189668178558,
0.3820226490497589,
0.11418966203927994,
0.9440458416938782,
-0.5151082873344421,
0.19508050382137299,
0.7603418231010437,
0.4433707594871521,
0.16012117266654968,
-1.2566722631454468,
-0.20653216540813446,
-0.6206470727920532,
-0.4707445800304413,
0.12127469480037689,
0.08728502690792084,
0.6793046593666077,
-0.23613999783992767,
-0.5228268504142761,
-0.31328609585762024,
0.3410806357860565,
0.06869374960660934,
1.097288966178894,
0.12488947808742523,
0.536196768283844,
1.1842710971832275,
0.15643201768398285,
0.9749151468276978,
-0.3869277536869049,
-0.01912163756787777,
0.5226446390151978,
-0.07937805354595184,
0.8420343995094299,
-0.0978970006108284,
0.041991863399744034,
0.13030384480953217,
0.9053879380226135,
0.4092484414577484,
0.2659553587436676,
-0.4266017973423004,
-0.24236339330673218,
0.09105539321899414,
-0.0801062360405922,
-0.25934067368507385,
0.1092812716960907,
0.8761359453201294,
-0.5371327996253967,
-0.19337481260299683,
0.43177518248558044,
-0.00502299377694726,
0.3427152931690216,
-0.6046145558357239,
0.9096406698226929,
-0.054140008985996246,
-0.37762269377708435,
0.7047395706176758,
0.09789684414863586,
0.7735386490821838,
0.07589542120695114,
0.12381692230701447,
0.11098754405975342,
0.48514074087142944,
-0.3840363025665283,
-0.9671257734298706,
0.7899298667907715,
0.01660497672855854,
-0.10980726778507233,
-0.4181094169616699,
0.7616788744926453,
-0.18442586064338684,
-0.9723408222198486,
0.46521714329719543,
0.3576270043849945,
-0.07830925285816193,
-0.14224165678024292,
-0.9705865383148193,
-0.17615263164043427,
-0.13599970936775208,
-0.23138469457626343,
-0.059661343693733215,
0.5743125677108765,
-0.22706493735313416,
1.1527466773986816,
0.7406467199325562,
0.13724692165851593,
-0.0614640973508358,
-0.10384148359298706,
0.7250832319259644,
-0.48635968565940857,
-0.4426492154598236,
-0.8350824117660522,
0.2568020820617676,
-0.27375683188438416,
-0.25186166167259216,
0.4887864887714386,
0.3148615062236786,
0.5495103597640991,
0.22693614661693573,
0.6744322180747986,
-0.0664348304271698,
1.1210116147994995,
0.1533646285533905,
1.1207126379013062,
-0.5577269792556763,
0.4865083396434784,
-0.1525505632162094,
-0.20608191192150116,
-0.7706744074821472,
0.8825947046279907,
-0.45423322916030884,
0.1920197606086731,
0.8173460364341736,
0.635168731212616,
-0.10710997134447098,
0.2880662679672241,
-0.0372244156897068,
0.35976269841194153,
0.6120139360427856,
0.3692726194858551,
0.3300797641277313,
-0.4501185119152069,
0.02683352492749691,
-0.2894679605960846,
-0.24741917848587036,
-0.3214871287345886,
-0.3497600853443146,
-0.8966483473777771,
-0.5356624126434326,
-0.3838437497615814,
-0.16934266686439514,
0.3432837724685669,
0.9450024962425232,
0.5343075394630432,
-1.0426912307739258,
0.09108642488718033,
-0.3060417175292969,
0.4516909122467041,
-0.534207284450531,
-0.2365562468767166,
0.3437527120113373,
-0.20980176329612732,
-0.46265077590942383,
0.4500143229961395,
-0.10897199809551239,
-0.06808727979660034,
0.19427134096622467,
0.02971472218632698,
-0.4244033694267273,
-0.04464627429842949,
0.5433146357536316,
0.19710634648799896,
-0.4090782105922699,
-0.43749937415122986,
-0.23537664115428925,
-0.3694264888763428,
0.12333846837282181,
0.08462081104516983,
-0.9798745512962341,
0.11515343189239502,
0.13972464203834534,
0.8077202439308167,
0.23703914880752563,
0.38753047585487366,
0.5591643452644348,
-0.3437505066394806,
-0.3639706075191498,
0.8632268905639648,
-0.0340176597237587,
0.24599137902259827,
-0.6151228547096252,
0.40322932600975037,
0.3680611550807953,
-0.48279643058776855,
-0.8013484477996826,
-0.17188619077205658,
-1.0241492986679077,
-0.4385499060153961,
1.152060866355896,
0.14670169353485107,
-0.343485951423645,
-0.8672350645065308,
-0.26518478989601135,
0.283687025308609,
-0.6862161755561829,
0.820042610168457,
0.38360828161239624,
-0.3224637508392334,
-0.1984008252620697,
-0.4268072247505188,
0.7321282625198364,
0.025113150477409363,
-0.6214011907577515,
-0.41046521067619324,
0.22619223594665527,
0.26531946659088135,
-0.08397504687309265,
0.8501428961753845,
0.4457395374774933,
0.6342123746871948,
-0.2143869549036026,
-0.1409553736448288,
-0.1750607043504715,
-0.18394938111305237,
-0.42451390624046326,
0.17204920947551727,
-0.21705913543701172,
-0.2259175032377243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03575v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03575v1
|
gaHealth: An English-Irish Bilingual Corpus of Health Data
| 2024-03-06T09:36:36 | 2024-03-06T09:36:36 |
Séamus Lankford, Haithem Afli, Órla Ní Loinsigh, Andy Way
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Machine Translation is a mature technology for many high-resource language
pairs. However in the context of low-resource languages, there is a paucity of
parallel data datasets available for developing translation models.
Furthermore, the development of datasets for low-resource languages often
focuses on simply creating the largest possible dataset for generic
translation. The benefits and development of smaller in-domain datasets can
easily be overlooked. To assess the merits of using in-domain data, a dataset
for the specific domain of health was developed for the low-resource English to
Irish language pair. Our study outlines the process used in developing the
corpus and empirically demonstrates the benefits of using an in-domain dataset
for the health domain. In the context of translating health-related data,
models developed using the gaHealth corpus demonstrated a maximum BLEU score
improvement of 22.2 points (40%) when compared with top performing models from
the LoResMT2021 Shared Task. Furthermore, we define linguistic guidelines for
developing gaHealth, the first bilingual corpus of health data for the Irish
language, which we hope will be of use to other creators of low-resource data
sets. gaHealth is now freely available online and is ready to be explored for
further research.
|
[
0.27537626028060913,
-0.3848390579223633,
0.4711162745952606,
0.07552206516265869,
0.031145567074418068,
-0.0023261234164237976,
-0.150444895029068,
-0.755018413066864,
0.5143290162086487,
0.5444437861442566,
0.016606206074357033,
-0.5361582040786743,
-0.8262203931808472,
0.26516348123550415,
-0.2573428750038147,
1.3274599313735962,
-0.09895212203264236,
0.3235774040222168,
-0.18827037513256073,
-0.323883980512619,
-0.377602756023407,
-0.5606473684310913,
-0.329479843378067,
-0.30819055438041687,
0.6180388331413269,
0.7171983122825623,
0.9200535416603088,
0.631577730178833,
0.8881908059120178,
0.0689731240272522,
0.16360487043857574,
0.3232475519180298,
-0.4699714779853821,
0.08124600350856781,
-0.3492738604545593,
-0.132063627243042,
-0.7620651721954346,
-0.1342362016439438,
0.2842317521572113,
0.9931394457817078,
0.09432044625282288,
0.525392472743988,
-0.0020483771804720163,
0.7726971507072449,
-0.4187944233417511,
0.20454180240631104,
-0.26071298122406006,
0.07399483770132065,
-0.7192609906196594,
-0.3117239475250244,
-0.12662377953529358,
-0.11576755344867706,
0.07618474215269089,
-0.4358038604259491,
0.041149452328681946,
0.2612695097923279,
0.8932220339775085,
0.0454990528523922,
-0.6627963781356812,
-0.4872920513153076,
-0.4323352575302124,
0.6932598948478699,
-0.4499266743659973,
0.6788792610168457,
0.6690588593482971,
0.01444885041564703,
-0.10370904952287674,
-0.665375292301178,
-0.20187421143054962,
-0.11185281723737717,
-0.2428828328847885,
0.25969022512435913,
-0.5961235761642456,
-0.24037064611911774,
-0.09079790115356445,
0.5075616240501404,
-0.8932257294654846,
-0.1042221412062645,
-0.7536711096763611,
-0.08566252887248993,
0.6879994869232178,
0.4732929766178131,
0.6658639907836914,
-0.2631687819957733,
-0.043005939573049545,
0.10991918295621872,
-0.7597568035125732,
-0.17425674200057983,
0.12135032564401627,
0.6334346532821655,
-0.4841814339160919,
0.7946509122848511,
-0.06986936181783676,
0.3163333237171173,
-0.10632523149251938,
-0.39588263630867004,
0.7277693152427673,
-0.4372352659702301,
-0.3500978946685791,
0.05412149801850319,
0.3924950659275055,
0.5084609985351562,
0.04936874285340309,
-0.6775450706481934,
-0.058334965258836746,
0.02780725620687008,
0.2872869372367859,
-0.8043492436408997,
-0.1000589057803154,
0.3152576684951782,
-0.6432673335075378,
0.07316767424345016,
-0.3273787200450897,
-0.7215893268585205,
-0.041702475398778915,
-0.26891106367111206,
0.10852298885583878,
-0.29253411293029785,
-0.13514912128448486,
0.4258127510547638,
0.15122413635253906,
-0.3730798065662384,
-0.11525699496269226,
-0.8654882907867432,
0.4684845805168152,
0.48490452766418457,
0.8373302221298218,
-0.38839149475097656,
-0.023591334000229836,
-0.6834807991981506,
0.37673497200012207,
-0.28894200921058655,
0.4353848993778229,
-0.4723004400730133,
-0.6139367818832397,
0.08419651538133621,
0.2436506450176239,
-0.2677299976348877,
-0.7621026635169983,
0.8026207685470581,
-0.13655902445316315,
0.09069506078958511,
-0.1626223921775818,
-0.42716658115386963,
0.017281364649534225,
-0.06115461513400078,
-0.6478859782218933,
0.7914914488792419,
0.31272122263908386,
-0.8223381042480469,
0.3482355773448944,
-0.6914686560630798,
-0.8804125189781189,
0.3755037486553192,
0.11424420028924942,
-0.24420680105686188,
0.17347083985805511,
0.2754001021385193,
0.3850752115249634,
-0.4993158280849457,
0.03753193840384483,
-0.26796388626098633,
0.03381657972931862,
-0.10713732242584229,
-0.03515062481164932,
0.7576252818107605,
0.4055038392543793,
-0.08003198355436325,
-0.4277724325656891,
-0.4586825966835022,
0.12344272434711456,
-0.07748642563819885,
-0.21413825452327728,
-0.5697764754295349,
-0.059953879565000534,
0.22324417531490326,
0.14539529383182526,
0.16028043627738953,
-0.5597460865974426,
-0.1373831182718277,
-0.24200360476970673,
0.27390056848526,
-0.10257480293512344,
0.010193734429776669,
0.4729957580566406,
-0.4710923731327057,
0.6223610639572144,
0.01614154875278473,
0.22326625883579254,
0.19212205708026886,
-1.0207951068878174,
-0.0898478701710701,
-0.43404871225357056,
0.17301765084266663,
1.0185272693634033,
-0.5885654091835022,
0.09584221243858337,
-0.47275400161743164,
-0.2864905297756195,
-1.0843384265899658,
0.3076011538505554,
0.39385560154914856,
0.8662177920341492,
0.7357490062713623,
-0.20860648155212402,
-0.24703744053840637,
-0.9169423580169678,
-0.15239232778549194,
-0.16527368128299713,
0.009553682059049606,
0.54771888256073,
0.4132080376148224,
-0.7450255751609802,
0.2771483063697815,
-0.2298729568719864,
-0.35491254925727844,
-0.2456023097038269,
-0.13956566154956818,
0.10327061265707016,
0.578018069267273,
0.6626546382904053,
-0.8722661733627319,
-0.5678904056549072,
0.5580079555511475,
-0.9570996761322021,
-0.2552921772003174,
0.42032328248023987,
-0.5036082863807678,
-0.08495882898569107,
-0.09180807322263718,
-0.4165503680706024,
0.5118652582168579,
1.0442296266555786,
-0.2658083736896515,
0.30586522817611694,
-0.21509438753128052,
0.2955223321914673,
-1.1093807220458984,
0.3234381377696991,
0.08982899785041809,
-0.34359675645828247,
-0.795080304145813,
0.3217388689517975,
0.143922358751297,
-0.3524515628814697,
-0.38473179936408997,
0.7996504306793213,
-0.14466536045074463,
0.42844387888908386,
-0.05656694620847702,
-0.3911246657371521,
0.16416753828525543,
-0.269266813993454,
-0.1851961314678192,
0.820257842540741,
0.3641163110733032,
-0.3142624795436859,
0.25304946303367615,
0.5088530778884888,
-0.21755003929138184,
0.7254011034965515,
-0.6729394197463989,
0.12830308079719543,
0.16121596097946167,
0.023802386596798897,
-0.2739337086677551,
-0.6266886591911316,
0.266024649143219,
-0.4105648696422577,
0.09339529275894165,
0.05086881294846535,
-0.36322021484375,
-0.2667655348777771,
0.19699831306934357,
0.46853572130203247,
0.35014331340789795,
-0.3291902244091034,
-0.14256270229816437,
1.0550761222839355,
-0.4558906853199005,
-0.180791974067688,
-1.2746622562408447,
0.23968534171581268,
-0.42844346165657043,
-0.8130757808685303,
0.632148027420044,
0.03559105098247528,
-0.5142267942428589,
0.39212095737457275,
0.06632155925035477,
-0.37525561451911926,
-0.31055986881256104,
0.01704014278948307,
0.23549824953079224,
-0.23012661933898926,
0.3876766860485077,
-0.1197122111916542,
-0.11854156106710434,
-0.10617250204086304,
-0.6492417454719543,
-0.04460306465625763,
0.08470818400382996,
0.026112644001841545,
-0.2217428833246231,
1.157524824142456,
0.3237035870552063,
-0.21905802190303802,
0.6289097666740417,
0.15700310468673706,
-0.5773307681083679,
-0.08757223188877106,
-0.1535847932100296,
0.27337557077407837,
-0.3111760914325714,
0.16739553213119507,
-0.22010448575019836,
-0.8229804635047913,
0.3781784176826477,
0.2733466327190399,
-0.1321554332971573,
0.4866246283054352,
0.8695030808448792,
-0.1843046396970749,
0.8855990171432495,
0.775529682636261,
-0.23360586166381836,
-0.014426693320274353,
-0.06349590420722961,
0.41098883748054504,
-0.5174039602279663,
-0.14005853235721588,
-0.5310033559799194,
-0.23282170295715332,
-0.9320660829544067,
-0.38294583559036255,
0.6936954855918884,
-0.24886587262153625,
0.13093732297420502,
0.4636785686016083,
-0.4089985489845276,
-0.09358043223619461,
0.3021378815174103,
0.47383424639701843,
0.24244368076324463,
0.03551825135946274,
-0.2985129654407501,
-0.19601786136627197,
-0.6024336814880371,
-0.5431075692176819,
1.095996618270874,
0.13284695148468018,
0.6898936033248901,
0.12300034612417221,
0.6947354078292847,
0.3060915172100067,
0.14902865886688232,
-0.7191357612609863,
-0.09872868657112122,
-0.6686086654663086,
-0.6397524476051331,
-0.11460119485855103,
-0.6191490888595581,
-1.2331488132476807,
-0.0979844182729721,
-0.02091066725552082,
-0.4276367127895355,
0.24738098680973053,
0.19851265847682953,
-0.380716472864151,
0.18673990666866302,
-0.8336569666862488,
0.7485160827636719,
-0.38987550139427185,
-0.47881466150283813,
-0.20057690143585205,
-0.4902157485485077,
0.050507768988609314,
-0.19840475916862488,
0.38707834482192993,
-0.15982267260551453,
0.1057920977473259,
0.5229882597923279,
-0.4281860291957855,
0.369864821434021,
0.1642882376909256,
0.04167897254228592,
0.01393857505172491,
-0.12452319264411926,
0.22607365250587463,
0.29957717657089233,
-0.3331991136074066,
0.3028178811073303,
0.12513229250907898,
-0.7713295221328735,
-0.19794034957885742,
0.6724708676338196,
-0.3705289363861084,
-0.4728410840034485,
-0.25772109627723694,
-0.7816479802131653,
-0.4454888105392456,
0.10897284001111984,
0.29822206497192383,
0.46172642707824707,
-0.05793354660272598,
0.06182179972529411,
0.3215017318725586,
-0.27418187260627747,
-0.1298598051071167,
0.354663223028183,
-0.016719764098525047,
-0.4297528564929962,
0.9017835855484009,
0.2960036098957062,
0.2170330286026001,
0.38073116540908813,
0.2763039767742157,
-0.061310961842536926,
-0.42139187455177307,
-0.6364397406578064,
0.28062915802001953,
-0.2521192133426666,
-0.2642782926559448,
-0.4628354609012604,
-0.22162030637264252,
-0.5822288393974304,
-0.1948251724243164,
0.1393389254808426,
-0.19086889922618866,
-0.00021149114763829857,
-0.1966295838356018,
0.43612346053123474,
0.7486380934715271,
-0.13588277995586395,
-0.19596384465694427,
-0.9515901803970337,
0.3925741910934448,
0.14539681375026703,
0.06220346689224243,
-0.4571886956691742,
-0.28246137499809265,
-0.7917742729187012,
0.17268455028533936,
-0.11586017161607742,
-0.9777923822402954,
0.8431852459907532,
0.16669520735740662,
0.5126479864120483,
0.04294666275382042,
-0.16391678154468536,
0.7341139316558838,
-0.8490831851959229,
0.6528028845787048,
0.11293430626392365,
-0.5313995480537415,
0.40545323491096497,
-0.25795605778694153,
0.28178420662879944,
0.7181612253189087,
0.5997037887573242,
-0.8568522930145264,
-0.2583847641944885,
-0.6071347594261169,
-0.74054354429245,
-0.034968841820955276,
0.1088157519698143,
0.1759369969367981,
-0.3239338994026184,
-0.0008747988031245768,
0.3662017285823822,
0.1672608107328415,
0.08204550296068192,
-0.060501378029584885,
0.1043216735124588,
-0.2736239433288574,
-0.33467352390289307,
0.11673838645219803,
-0.27879154682159424,
-0.5411303043365479,
0.5016497373580933,
-0.17424745857715607,
0.340824693441391,
0.24797728657722473,
-0.28573480248451233,
-0.26878616213798523,
0.1732519119977951,
0.21557602286338806,
0.4657629728317261,
-0.18277645111083984,
0.11012955009937286,
0.06547276675701141,
-0.8895106911659241,
0.12076137959957123,
0.19761055707931519,
-0.20619215071201324,
0.32005470991134644,
0.5010230541229248,
0.6317116022109985,
0.16340850293636322,
-0.5317261815071106,
0.42896485328674316,
0.2946937382221222,
0.0115968631580472,
0.2330249845981598,
-0.28352949023246765,
0.06531893461942673,
-0.06699114292860031,
0.15444043278694153,
0.019367491826415062,
0.3554537296295166,
-0.5385665893554688,
0.4254891872406006,
0.12195756286382675,
-0.3532181978225708,
-0.6696706414222717,
0.7590277791023254,
0.31247958540916443,
-0.12036620825529099,
0.5056581497192383,
-0.042380474507808685,
0.006158689968287945,
0.3213195502758026,
0.6444715857505798,
0.716951847076416,
-0.09244891256093979,
0.3800937533378601,
0.249655619263649,
0.16566801071166992,
0.06353443115949631,
0.5039147734642029,
0.3679198622703552,
-0.4987674057483673,
-0.46986740827560425,
-0.6511099934577942,
-0.5070099830627441,
0.09801280498504639,
-0.8988810181617737,
0.16647469997406006,
0.3132464289665222,
-0.30570322275161743,
0.07402124255895615,
0.1637869030237198,
-1.2164307832717896,
0.4243078827857971,
0.16401585936546326,
0.9066557884216309,
-0.7644243240356445,
1.0799766778945923,
0.8773192763328552,
-0.486916720867157,
-0.47515958547592163,
0.202070415019989,
0.16030322015285492,
-0.8533348441123962,
0.6340892910957336,
-0.1973712146282196,
0.02718912623822689,
-0.1732197403907776,
-0.19959013164043427,
-0.734592080116272,
0.6909609436988831,
0.7763329744338989,
-0.41304636001586914,
-0.22796103358268738,
0.5699477195739746,
0.593136727809906,
-0.5061075687408447,
-0.06809025257825851,
0.47901061177253723,
0.6133536696434021,
-0.4899485409259796,
-1.3104037046432495,
-0.2919926345348358,
-0.45046478509902954,
-0.2289290726184845,
0.18493057787418365,
-0.6619412899017334,
0.8503398895263672,
-0.14815418422222137,
-0.21533899009227753,
-0.06338537484407425,
0.327067494392395,
-0.1844651848077774,
0.528213381767273,
0.08024715632200241,
0.7275731563568115,
1.0743612051010132,
0.09635229408740997,
1.3447365760803223,
-0.3858276903629303,
0.21379207074642181,
0.8633980751037598,
-0.4608275294303894,
0.7262963056564331,
0.4727048873901367,
-0.0880727544426918,
0.21695317327976227,
0.3591512143611908,
0.5050004720687866,
0.6790667772293091,
-0.04078631475567818,
-0.4919881820678711,
-0.0856490433216095,
-0.4264183044433594,
-0.462161660194397,
0.4100461006164551,
0.4444812536239624,
-0.48643800616264343,
-0.2745775580406189,
0.32412198185920715,
0.2967108488082886,
0.1406840980052948,
-0.2107539176940918,
0.43901363015174866,
0.3233644366264343,
-0.07091480493545532,
0.5193658471107483,
-0.1562180519104004,
0.3380665183067322,
-0.4790501296520233,
-0.015005295164883137,
-0.39056921005249023,
-0.005948083475232124,
-0.4590367078781128,
-0.7007648348808289,
0.6557074189186096,
0.23817791044712067,
-0.4897885024547577,
-0.4122462868690491,
0.5278944373130798,
-0.5915878415107727,
-0.7487158179283142,
0.6680111885070801,
0.9011853337287903,
0.4249497652053833,
0.39979371428489685,
-0.4146207869052887,
-0.23523983359336853,
-0.3452986478805542,
0.17004095017910004,
0.41259104013442993,
0.6601877808570862,
-0.47727859020233154,
0.22581195831298828,
0.6867881417274475,
0.8200739622116089,
0.035554926842451096,
-0.1813223510980606,
0.5152156352996826,
-0.43831413984298706,
-0.4281831681728363,
-0.46360722184181213,
0.23134347796440125,
0.08774711936712265,
-0.646839439868927,
0.7739776968955994,
0.7238180637359619,
0.9233454465866089,
0.08724600076675415,
1.1512962579727173,
-0.2103157639503479,
0.8233151435852051,
-0.2924698293209076,
0.867387592792511,
-0.7938593626022339,
-0.48535603284835815,
0.012979096733033657,
-0.2399066686630249,
-0.6030781269073486,
0.21042296290397644,
-0.2508365213871002,
-0.6062631011009216,
0.8768376111984253,
0.8179193735122681,
-0.2092752903699875,
-0.140851691365242,
0.6038208603858948,
-0.04850049316883087,
0.041572436690330505,
0.6347793340682983,
0.14444345235824585,
-0.39681708812713623,
0.08723804354667664,
-0.3303011357784271,
-0.15601851046085358,
-0.16652558743953705,
-0.695274293422699,
-0.35428833961486816,
-0.5541386604309082,
-0.09781075268983841,
-0.34039196372032166,
0.5580876469612122,
0.8651851415634155,
0.8168119788169861,
-1.2053965330123901,
-0.3221890330314636,
0.489757776260376,
-0.35505175590515137,
-0.658902108669281,
-0.08238578587770462,
0.30316320061683655,
-0.3430725038051605,
-0.7582375407218933,
0.7617896199226379,
0.43416720628738403,
-0.3488498330116272,
0.04746568575501442,
-0.27650341391563416,
-0.05529288202524185,
-0.0024235877208411694,
0.5548045635223389,
0.4764308035373688,
-0.2394830584526062,
-0.4180361330509186,
0.13562457263469696,
-0.6830001473426819,
0.15182429552078247,
0.6847745180130005,
-0.39100366830825806,
0.5363318920135498,
0.3971289098262787,
0.900530219078064,
0.23805737495422363,
-0.21778738498687744,
0.6664195656776428,
-0.31387823820114136,
0.3593325912952423,
0.38740962743759155,
0.48252907395362854,
0.4130195081233978,
-0.6226541996002197,
0.7783804535865784,
0.2984004318714142,
-0.687641978263855,
-0.6649892330169678,
-0.17487315833568573,
-0.7435368895530701,
0.28152933716773987,
1.1566925048828125,
-0.12466729432344437,
-0.36580270528793335,
-0.335249662399292,
0.03647705540060997,
0.2734716832637787,
-0.3584327697753906,
0.6141248941421509,
0.650761604309082,
-0.21382761001586914,
0.36640459299087524,
-1.3187499046325684,
0.420729398727417,
0.4211463928222656,
-0.9154175519943237,
-0.18551985919475555,
0.16693544387817383,
0.13363142311573029,
-0.07304047793149948,
0.6855661869049072,
-0.28041818737983704,
0.2954177260398865,
-0.17785422503948212,
0.03177120164036751,
0.3432905077934265,
-0.29867231845855713,
0.0016177041688933969,
0.0083547318354249,
-0.5547320246696472,
-0.2105029672384262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03558v1
|
Benchmarking Hallucination in Large Language Models based on Unanswerable Math Word Problem
| 2024-03-06T09:06:34 | 2024-03-06T09:06:34 |
Yuhong Sun, Zhangyue Yin, Qipeng Guo, Jiawen Wu, Xipeng Qiu, Hui Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are highly effective in various natural language
processing (NLP) tasks. However, they are susceptible to producing unreliable
conjectures in ambiguous contexts called hallucination. This paper presents a
new method for evaluating LLM hallucination in Question Answering (QA) based on
the unanswerable math word problem (MWP). To support this approach, we
innovatively develop a dataset called Unanswerable Math Word Problem (UMWP)
which comprises 5200 questions across five categories. We developed an
evaluation methodology combining text similarity and mathematical expression
detection to determine whether LLM considers the question unanswerable. The
results of extensive experiments conducted on 31 LLMs, including GPT-3,
InstructGPT, LLaMA, and Claude, demonstrate that in-context learning and
reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) training significantly
enhance the model's ability to avoid hallucination. We show that utilizing MWP
is a reliable and effective approach to assess hallucination. Our code and data
are available at https://github.com/Yuki-Asuuna/UMWP.
|
[
-0.43591445684432983,
-0.9939020276069641,
0.633955717086792,
0.4087124764919281,
-0.19295236468315125,
0.055597126483917236,
-0.3030684292316437,
-0.334264874458313,
0.11582822352647781,
0.46176624298095703,
-0.6223899126052856,
-0.47448939085006714,
-0.4722987413406372,
0.32312604784965515,
-0.3580192029476166,
0.503738522529602,
-0.15537816286087036,
0.2719813585281372,
-0.687913179397583,
-0.3419063985347748,
-0.8546135425567627,
-0.5902268886566162,
-0.4994436502456665,
-0.5460859537124634,
0.12029760330915451,
0.02645183354616165,
0.5464038252830505,
0.22343358397483826,
0.6444149017333984,
0.30202516913414,
0.029391320422291756,
0.3220570683479309,
-0.4152566194534302,
0.00989500805735588,
0.049510616809129715,
-0.23188605904579163,
-0.07840638607740402,
-0.18395386636257172,
0.4913861155509949,
0.9754440188407898,
-0.459541380405426,
0.2042575180530548,
0.14645405113697052,
0.741150975227356,
-0.5385046005249023,
0.24939794838428497,
-1.0020220279693604,
0.3526158630847931,
0.20239019393920898,
-0.3370644152164459,
-0.35855385661125183,
-0.4069540798664093,
0.04525983706116676,
-0.3668525218963623,
0.028960736468434334,
-0.006809096317738295,
0.5174371600151062,
0.3556879460811615,
-0.08473998308181763,
-0.42337554693222046,
-0.5339151620864868,
0.7165777683258057,
-0.7717605829238892,
0.44862794876098633,
0.4935443699359894,
0.20001432299613953,
-0.4471019208431244,
-0.40008577704429626,
-0.6142981052398682,
-0.3098832070827484,
0.1582968384027481,
-0.032043471932411194,
-0.19464987516403198,
-0.25375238060951233,
0.5156227946281433,
0.112635038793087,
-0.6988643407821655,
-0.0015622774371877313,
-0.0074937427416443825,
-0.22357606887817383,
0.37406444549560547,
0.20361605286598206,
0.2549288272857666,
-0.2056448757648468,
-0.2216920107603073,
-0.18957734107971191,
-0.4614420235157013,
-0.009417005814611912,
0.10414467006921768,
0.12053325027227402,
0.18900103867053986,
0.8158541321754456,
-0.16446246206760406,
0.5492420196533203,
-0.3226403295993805,
0.04745179042220116,
0.3422568142414093,
0.344117671251297,
-0.21457891166210175,
-0.047303617000579834,
0.5017935633659363,
0.23365797102451324,
0.4035690426826477,
-0.5256478786468506,
-0.49741145968437195,
0.29299452900886536,
0.274465411901474,
-0.7315751910209656,
0.024773182347416878,
0.15278171002864838,
-0.29061567783355713,
-0.14161819219589233,
0.18266622722148895,
-0.8613457679748535,
-0.4761873483657837,
-0.1578429639339447,
0.7465580701828003,
-0.3176615834236145,
-0.028245940804481506,
0.21727187931537628,
0.025171425193548203,
0.32732027769088745,
0.06577912718057632,
-0.8182741403579712,
0.4954527020454407,
0.738102376461029,
0.7799654603004456,
-0.4624994993209839,
-0.43422257900238037,
-0.8203602433204651,
-0.24497433006763458,
-0.45033055543899536,
0.815365731716156,
-0.3811122179031372,
-0.3491075038909912,
0.08643671870231628,
-0.09587633609771729,
-0.16790403425693512,
-1.1057541370391846,
0.4966031014919281,
-0.5360403656959534,
0.10262167453765869,
-0.2060205489397049,
-0.7965726852416992,
-0.27922534942626953,
0.5013642311096191,
-0.583470344543457,
1.095457911491394,
0.275113970041275,
-0.5865218639373779,
0.10641152411699295,
-0.5057793259620667,
-0.1591496765613556,
0.017712999135255814,
-0.32912760972976685,
-0.5566385388374329,
0.5557869076728821,
0.46618524193763733,
0.3259837329387665,
-0.316491037607193,
0.3868270814418793,
-0.4685695767402649,
-0.5547776818275452,
0.6032611131668091,
-0.5295491814613342,
0.37996533513069153,
-0.1328953355550766,
-0.48351842164993286,
0.0786827951669693,
-0.8711451292037964,
0.3121599555015564,
0.3227347731590271,
-0.0405997596681118,
-0.31604132056236267,
-0.04861071705818176,
-0.11817535012960434,
0.2322329878807068,
0.0037147465627640486,
-0.34541118144989014,
0.06037629023194313,
-0.4119354486465454,
0.14253541827201843,
0.7763606309890747,
0.06610491871833801,
-0.08704826235771179,
-0.42086562514305115,
0.5391063094139099,
-0.3223811686038971,
-0.15237566828727722,
0.26486241817474365,
-0.4979977011680603,
-0.6509454846382141,
0.1943531483411789,
0.2251756638288498,
0.5323671102523804,
-0.8429859280586243,
0.41525790095329285,
-0.07126733660697937,
-0.2225433886051178,
-0.3579398989677429,
0.06436324864625931,
0.3836284875869751,
0.64183109998703,
0.4627288579940796,
-0.20127466320991516,
-0.41740527749061584,
-0.6299896836280823,
-0.452715665102005,
-0.12060154229402542,
-0.3116724491119385,
0.32828593254089355,
0.5786145925521851,
-0.37577158212661743,
0.688970148563385,
-0.6813419461250305,
-0.38039353489875793,
-0.08344005793333054,
0.4667445421218872,
0.06684168428182602,
0.09415661543607712,
0.06807515025138855,
-0.4728395342826843,
-0.10672987252473831,
-0.288360595703125,
-0.9151738286018372,
-0.3834865689277649,
-0.031108319759368896,
0.1189289391040802,
0.3657923936843872,
0.5107128620147705,
-0.5163710117340088,
0.476723313331604,
0.5060922503471375,
-0.3316584825515747,
0.662376880645752,
-0.2668815851211548,
0.19958360493183136,
-0.8176507949829102,
0.10996487736701965,
-0.1914312094449997,
-0.05900130048394203,
-0.32916152477264404,
0.1905926764011383,
0.11331606656312943,
-0.28238576650619507,
-0.26153138279914856,
0.4850054383277893,
-0.3979685604572296,
-0.34736204147338867,
-0.4051775336265564,
0.25113925337791443,
-0.4237035810947418,
0.7976688146591187,
0.11387383937835693,
0.7046006321907043,
0.1814197152853012,
-0.4818943440914154,
0.2643624246120453,
0.17491692304611206,
-0.5023080110549927,
0.2325400412082672,
-0.662844717502594,
0.29314103722572327,
-0.03390828147530556,
-0.030929213389754295,
-0.9362401366233826,
0.08233197033405304,
-0.07945995777845383,
-0.5019097924232483,
-0.20193539559841156,
0.3855487108230591,
-0.6304311156272888,
-0.32092610001564026,
-0.2239590585231781,
0.48695722222328186,
0.4843751788139343,
-0.6190391182899475,
0.5712747573852539,
0.40647274255752563,
0.0460975244641304,
-0.4006366729736328,
-0.24458400905132294,
-0.08267506211996078,
-0.3066129684448242,
-0.44110819697380066,
0.17572470009326935,
-0.2416224479675293,
-0.24287842214107513,
-0.2505573630332947,
-0.29304540157318115,
0.03325480595231056,
0.18630924820899963,
0.3056528866291046,
0.295332133769989,
0.05925874039530754,
0.22726351022720337,
-0.2871255874633789,
-0.1591019630432129,
0.6172196865081787,
0.06877288222312927,
1.0223644971847534,
-0.16040921211242676,
-0.47611987590789795,
-0.305531769990921,
0.20408327877521515,
0.37371811270713806,
-0.013613401912152767,
0.423374205827713,
0.4844040274620056,
-0.7978895902633667,
-0.3357810974121094,
-0.5674802660942078,
-0.41492900252342224,
-0.4085645377635956,
0.47427859902381897,
-0.4256613850593567,
-0.8596723675727844,
0.6862389445304871,
-0.14739635586738586,
0.008682102896273136,
0.4437256157398224,
0.536841094493866,
0.2968413233757019,
1.1666449308395386,
0.4351363182067871,
-0.14456015825271606,
0.02257549948990345,
-0.046927936375141144,
0.13866379857063293,
-0.7380883693695068,
-0.40618035197257996,
-0.5454561114311218,
-0.2074274867773056,
-0.4402766525745392,
-0.5760514736175537,
0.3689992427825928,
0.13349798321723938,
0.09850334376096725,
0.2024485468864441,
-0.2031409740447998,
0.5677730441093445,
0.13549210131168365,
0.013717285357415676,
0.4401180148124695,
0.07580123841762543,
-0.3306785225868225,
-0.31033459305763245,
-0.4606315791606903,
-0.21803322434425354,
1.037032961845398,
0.28211677074432373,
0.6325185298919678,
0.050675831735134125,
0.5495651364326477,
0.21805977821350098,
0.32494664192199707,
-0.7714815139770508,
0.7385765910148621,
0.12303401529788971,
-0.18824677169322968,
-0.6460588574409485,
-0.8638421893119812,
-0.9074644446372986,
0.5448706746101379,
-0.4339326024055481,
-0.868431031703949,
-0.3525071442127228,
-0.3089037239551544,
-0.16659238934516907,
0.2892422080039978,
-0.3164089322090149,
0.7152335047721863,
-0.10188434273004532,
-0.08498448878526688,
-0.26087331771850586,
-0.20224028825759888,
0.4777360260486603,
-0.35874539613723755,
0.10022032260894775,
-0.2023182064294815,
0.09985598921775818,
0.8330278992652893,
-0.3494277894496918,
0.38335269689559937,
0.021620729938149452,
-0.3463989496231079,
0.027237383648753166,
0.23198489844799042,
0.6195291876792908,
0.24386665225028992,
-0.03681303933262825,
0.21156689524650574,
-0.07347263395786285,
-0.110909104347229,
-0.8839791417121887,
0.7009156346321106,
-0.6073033213615417,
-0.3246833384037018,
-0.5937325358390808,
-0.7968109250068665,
-0.6720758676528931,
0.06852711737155914,
0.17171527445316315,
0.36585676670074463,
-0.32576054334640503,
0.10994204878807068,
0.7772054076194763,
-0.4077092409133911,
0.4507271647453308,
0.44257852435112,
-0.7038792371749878,
-0.4479520618915558,
0.8986000418663025,
0.04076245799660683,
0.0622025765478611,
0.42195776104927063,
0.3258044421672821,
-0.5388027429580688,
-0.4223816692829132,
-0.33916419744491577,
0.2805429995059967,
-0.6279751658439636,
-0.21207650005817413,
-0.6571623682975769,
-0.3926053047180176,
-0.317252516746521,
0.07686690241098404,
-0.264043927192688,
-0.2139744758605957,
-0.12742304801940918,
0.16894245147705078,
0.04043399542570114,
0.5744473338127136,
0.3169715404510498,
-0.20863385498523712,
-0.5425741076469421,
0.6776561141014099,
0.5506145358085632,
0.4572872817516327,
0.24175295233726501,
-0.7590191960334778,
0.0639694333076477,
-0.04412517696619034,
-0.3263739049434662,
-0.7344510555267334,
0.46668899059295654,
-0.18988032639026642,
0.4990914463996887,
0.34720855951309204,
0.2068680077791214,
0.8392622470855713,
-0.45276787877082825,
0.3246951699256897,
0.21912547945976257,
-1.1005924940109253,
0.1812409609556198,
-0.0030543524771928787,
0.5379432439804077,
0.5334823131561279,
0.23733144998550415,
-0.6968245506286621,
-0.3877350687980652,
-0.5862144827842712,
-0.6729428768157959,
0.1776859611272812,
0.2298339456319809,
0.014579704031348228,
-0.09398546814918518,
0.2869044840335846,
0.1400914341211319,
0.3655940592288971,
-0.8207337856292725,
0.016237866133451462,
0.3446522355079651,
0.11387012898921967,
-0.1674281507730484,
-0.1559443324804306,
-0.015335915610194206,
-0.33987101912498474,
0.5807860493659973,
-0.18311552703380585,
0.23759156465530396,
-0.015474814921617508,
-0.3284282982349396,
-0.2241470217704773,
0.13282828032970428,
0.639565646648407,
0.992356538772583,
-0.3731936812400818,
0.18425163626670837,
0.5416635274887085,
-0.48347193002700806,
-0.018531398847699165,
0.03783543035387993,
-0.07046292722225189,
0.0731501504778862,
0.4250822067260742,
0.4664445221424103,
0.2686506509780884,
-1.117209792137146,
0.5377724170684814,
-0.24959324300289154,
-0.3784817159175873,
-0.4849357008934021,
-0.09895823895931244,
0.02823038585484028,
0.1459789127111435,
0.46360301971435547,
-0.3112347722053528,
0.06047363951802254,
-0.5851641893386841,
0.3385196626186371,
0.7366102337837219,
-0.511783242225647,
-0.01515336986631155,
0.6235054135322571,
-0.15708096325397491,
-0.5345172882080078,
0.8697636723518372,
-0.22553737461566925,
-0.6141694784164429,
0.6258613467216492,
0.7936910390853882,
0.9242234826087952,
0.011904388666152954,
0.3224193751811981,
0.2797985374927521,
0.3569280803203583,
-0.19193023443222046,
0.5172438621520996,
0.12657737731933594,
-0.6932981014251709,
-0.3494659960269928,
-0.666923463344574,
-0.4362991154193878,
0.48465991020202637,
-0.7870226502418518,
0.14978590607643127,
-0.39462754130363464,
0.1399042159318924,
-0.11820166558027267,
0.20899535715579987,
-0.4509821832180023,
0.08127138763666153,
-0.0768018439412117,
0.6424014568328857,
-0.8783664703369141,
0.6109086871147156,
0.4071584641933441,
0.0049220966175198555,
-0.6775050759315491,
0.3342075049877167,
-0.13790930807590485,
-0.9877252578735352,
0.28606462478637695,
0.4959794878959656,
-0.14287395775318146,
0.014453951269388199,
-0.28619202971458435,
-0.4448334574699402,
0.9224130511283875,
0.23430663347244263,
-0.5902128219604492,
0.27583587169647217,
0.37969785928726196,
0.5933238863945007,
-0.29604047536849976,
0.04696940630674362,
0.5412442684173584,
0.2932244837284088,
0.14705072343349457,
-0.5390426516532898,
0.219078928232193,
-0.1773989051580429,
0.1517287939786911,
0.42008599638938904,
-0.3340473473072052,
0.49429309368133545,
-0.37478169798851013,
-0.17083223164081573,
0.307829350233078,
0.8292669653892517,
0.6568841338157654,
0.48425787687301636,
0.7465211153030396,
0.8883875012397766,
0.8292927145957947,
-0.09272387623786926,
0.6557437181472778,
0.02006390504539013,
0.42216917872428894,
0.9911273717880249,
-0.3243934214115143,
1.1604139804840088,
0.7580762505531311,
-0.2965744435787201,
0.1489822119474411,
0.46830877661705017,
-0.11129499226808548,
0.40187785029411316,
0.8805264830589294,
-0.1401558369398117,
-0.26456978917121887,
-0.008466042578220367,
-0.48007461428642273,
0.5506550073623657,
0.028270285576581955,
0.019120676442980766,
-0.3463946580886841,
0.13994628190994263,
-0.058154404163360596,
0.24529637396335602,
-0.12001968920230865,
0.7133049368858337,
0.09236495196819305,
-0.6668384075164795,
0.7357461452484131,
0.03969153016805649,
0.5369077324867249,
-0.5166105628013611,
-0.33253708481788635,
-0.5058475732803345,
0.07462821900844574,
0.02751142531633377,
-0.325562447309494,
0.23377512395381927,
-0.04339870065450668,
-0.07135330885648727,
0.1919628530740738,
0.3213564157485962,
-0.44087475538253784,
-0.7061538100242615,
0.3771899342536926,
0.6021506786346436,
0.3714761435985565,
-0.38675573468208313,
-0.6373258233070374,
0.11719270050525665,
-0.129838228225708,
-0.0348379947245121,
0.5242913961410522,
0.5279926061630249,
-0.13244056701660156,
0.7981987595558167,
0.6224192380905151,
0.08471345156431198,
-0.17149390280246735,
0.3731788992881775,
0.7538546323776245,
-0.8003188967704773,
-0.29077693819999695,
-0.8716501593589783,
-0.08584321290254593,
0.029358793050050735,
-0.5018762350082397,
0.8466066718101501,
0.5796559453010559,
0.8560612201690674,
-0.05482923611998558,
0.29430580139160156,
0.27960261702537537,
0.4187964200973511,
-0.6642932295799255,
0.5632621049880981,
-0.6197300553321838,
0.5926840901374817,
-0.6397525668144226,
-1.3222379684448242,
-0.4191291630268097,
0.7030966281890869,
-0.03546272590756416,
0.051986027508974075,
0.9921686053276062,
0.6690212488174438,
0.11391844600439072,
0.1509314626455307,
0.5826199054718018,
-0.02701866813004017,
-0.001995790982618928,
0.8156281113624573,
0.9310259819030762,
-0.4449431598186493,
0.45187878608703613,
-0.3760391175746918,
-0.19666200876235962,
-0.12571489810943604,
-0.8246783018112183,
-1.065460205078125,
-0.5574655532836914,
-0.23194774985313416,
-0.4996923506259918,
-0.250089168548584,
0.8780675530433655,
0.12590186297893524,
-0.7862412333488464,
-0.4141828119754791,
-0.11863201856613159,
0.2505568265914917,
-0.5668959617614746,
-0.2212650626897812,
0.6168290972709656,
-0.3084341883659363,
-0.55475914478302,
0.1654079705476761,
0.3320970833301544,
0.01261153444647789,
-0.42334112524986267,
-0.012499404139816761,
-0.011091018095612526,
0.07110846787691116,
0.6991133093833923,
0.1569654792547226,
-0.5551275014877319,
-0.19590942561626434,
0.18587729334831238,
0.11071564257144928,
-0.11194868385791779,
0.9519187808036804,
-0.6457002758979797,
0.26831522583961487,
0.4502144157886505,
1.058333158493042,
0.2670593857765198,
0.016586096957325935,
0.26593008637428284,
-0.40878525376319885,
-0.05179068446159363,
0.2992125451564789,
0.2737385034561157,
0.16464291512966156,
-0.12811097502708435,
0.6063642501831055,
0.3842470645904541,
-0.5852656364440918,
-1.096677541732788,
-0.012281525880098343,
-0.7550939917564392,
-0.5281428694725037,
1.0495840311050415,
0.1544727236032486,
-0.09494675695896149,
0.001192263443954289,
-0.018448414281010628,
-0.023171454668045044,
-0.07388503104448318,
1.5416001081466675,
0.9526479840278625,
-0.13950251042842865,
-0.07491381466388702,
-0.7334040999412537,
0.3351741433143616,
0.7327454090118408,
-1.1718899011611938,
0.22219008207321167,
0.39879611134529114,
-0.009694679640233517,
-0.013137812726199627,
0.4815577566623688,
-0.17584969103336334,
0.13804668188095093,
-0.1354225128889084,
0.05949586257338524,
0.0950276330113411,
-0.38591015338897705,
-0.44244182109832764,
0.3452005088329315,
-0.07972987741231918,
-0.0893995389342308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03544v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03544v1
|
Prompt Mining for Language-based Human Mobility Forecasting
| 2024-03-06T08:43:30 | 2024-03-06T08:43:30 |
Hao Xue, Tianye Tang, Ali Payani, Flora D. Salim
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the advancement of large language models, language-based forecasting has
recently emerged as an innovative approach for predicting human mobility
patterns. The core idea is to use prompts to transform the raw mobility data
given as numerical values into natural language sentences so that the language
models can be leveraged to generate the description for future observations.
However, previous studies have only employed fixed and manually designed
templates to transform numerical values into sentences. Since the forecasting
performance of language models heavily relies on prompts, using fixed templates
for prompting may limit the forecasting capability of language models. In this
paper, we propose a novel framework for prompt mining in language-based
mobility forecasting, aiming to explore diverse prompt design strategies.
Specifically, the framework includes a prompt generation stage based on the
information entropy of prompts and a prompt refinement stage to integrate
mechanisms such as the chain of thought. Experimental results on real-world
large-scale data demonstrate the superiority of generated prompts from our
prompt mining pipeline. Additionally, the comparison of different prompt
variants shows that the proposed prompt refinement process is effective. Our
study presents a promising direction for further advancing language-based
mobility forecasting.
|
[
-0.38213929533958435,
-0.2923593521118164,
0.5944586396217346,
0.3178935647010803,
-0.4005703926086426,
-0.21337014436721802,
0.07464803010225296,
-0.1919119507074356,
0.4189004898071289,
0.32576677203178406,
-1.0947017669677734,
-0.42233920097351074,
0.08169261366128922,
0.18992853164672852,
-0.14242972433567047,
0.5936688184738159,
0.2660028040409088,
-0.004768797662109137,
0.0013867788948118687,
-0.11034141480922699,
-1.0538393259048462,
-0.3560616970062256,
-0.4381120800971985,
-0.021560240536928177,
0.5914434790611267,
0.5047675371170044,
0.7895343899726868,
0.6521908044815063,
-0.09373404830694199,
0.19823049008846283,
0.04610224440693855,
0.03860180452466011,
0.18944071233272552,
0.4666506350040436,
-0.11488164216279984,
-0.24529770016670227,
-0.1730179637670517,
-0.17976760864257812,
0.5704055428504944,
0.7982069849967957,
-0.3155229389667511,
0.008071317337453365,
-0.1785939484834671,
0.5847770571708679,
-0.3841671645641327,
0.019503232091665268,
-0.5721499919891357,
-0.0603615939617157,
-0.4621802270412445,
-0.24368539452552795,
-0.37544286251068115,
-0.31611913442611694,
-0.07000732421875,
-0.2502296566963196,
0.19873808324337006,
0.4430069029331207,
0.5858902335166931,
0.15864628553390503,
-0.3496781885623932,
-0.2734369933605194,
-0.3348650634288788,
0.6144174933433533,
-0.4657799005508423,
0.5361167788505554,
0.2734736204147339,
0.5046549439430237,
-0.1907212734222412,
-0.4696994125843048,
-0.39169806241989136,
-0.2964915335178375,
0.14512024819850922,
-0.11893998086452484,
0.0145261837169528,
-0.22179625928401947,
0.19038081169128418,
-0.05264448747038841,
-0.6999853253364563,
0.3002476096153259,
-0.3185616433620453,
-0.2598291039466858,
0.5167462825775146,
0.590783417224884,
0.4009304344654083,
-0.0689312070608139,
-0.40117472410202026,
0.11774183809757233,
-0.644103467464447,
0.2483479231595993,
0.22331595420837402,
0.8415781855583191,
-0.21163241565227509,
0.4027647078037262,
-0.5832984447479248,
0.7214961051940918,
0.06387965381145477,
-0.0032943401020020247,
0.4476487636566162,
-0.22822166979312897,
0.16168707609176636,
0.24208340048789978,
0.8469494581222534,
0.742518424987793,
0.19352079927921295,
-0.44863611459732056,
-0.24906878173351288,
-0.35975924134254456,
-0.10682301223278046,
-0.8992159962654114,
0.01921015791594982,
0.04878147318959236,
-0.6557645797729492,
-0.3545215129852295,
0.10269786417484283,
-1.2758368253707886,
-0.6214780807495117,
-0.08753254264593124,
-0.4791108965873718,
-0.45326995849609375,
-0.33585044741630554,
0.20465731620788574,
0.0012851132778450847,
0.20850956439971924,
0.2949584126472473,
-1.0980324745178223,
-0.17681479454040527,
0.314531147480011,
1.1114208698272705,
-0.00742823351174593,
-0.2766101062297821,
-0.7726786136627197,
-0.2806967496871948,
-0.16857510805130005,
0.9873145818710327,
-0.673158586025238,
-0.513970673084259,
0.2191086709499359,
-0.03285043686628342,
0.04036196321249008,
-0.19032713770866394,
0.8509059548377991,
-0.5671429634094238,
0.45430806279182434,
-0.43598851561546326,
-0.07332207262516022,
-0.13682930171489716,
0.14834916591644287,
-0.759828507900238,
0.9424235224723816,
0.1376589685678482,
-0.8301456570625305,
0.5461127161979675,
-0.6973500847816467,
-0.5042731761932373,
0.3814082145690918,
0.1749957650899887,
-0.06107570230960846,
0.05716143921017647,
0.31853243708610535,
0.4564424157142639,
-0.6740085482597351,
0.5983417630195618,
-0.4967062771320343,
-0.0639532208442688,
0.08611755818128586,
-0.36971649527549744,
0.9493539333343506,
0.5617937445640564,
-0.10467614978551865,
0.040453795343637466,
-0.751420259475708,
0.06028422713279724,
-0.3131070137023926,
-0.03794650360941887,
-0.31962963938713074,
0.08470476418733597,
-0.16578689217567444,
0.5330209732055664,
0.21196503937244415,
-0.41698867082595825,
0.14425894618034363,
-0.6351562738418579,
0.20149335265159607,
0.8735383152961731,
-0.04072696343064308,
0.8594963550567627,
-0.29242536425590515,
0.9183686971664429,
0.07168396562337875,
-0.12134408950805664,
-0.7731824517250061,
-0.6330444812774658,
-0.09056253731250763,
0.05847639590501785,
0.1650848686695099,
0.8602373600006104,
-0.6758143305778503,
0.5655034780502319,
-0.36452046036720276,
-0.5005980134010315,
-0.45015472173690796,
-0.20759537816047668,
-0.3260860741138458,
0.5849636793136597,
0.3070451319217682,
0.26348379254341125,
-0.5895957946777344,
-0.3642095923423767,
-0.5201405882835388,
-0.37304797768592834,
-0.08015213161706924,
-0.02023906819522381,
-0.020418355241417885,
-0.45707762241363525,
1.2740397453308105,
-0.3563961684703827,
0.25289690494537354,
-0.36463719606399536,
0.0827052891254425,
0.4034941792488098,
0.3933243751525879,
0.6096010208129883,
-0.6932281255722046,
-0.36552563309669495,
-0.20222711563110352,
-0.5182530879974365,
-0.3805491626262665,
-0.508358359336853,
-0.02424711175262928,
-0.1915110945701599,
0.5120440721511841,
-0.7008985280990601,
0.306898832321167,
0.1767221987247467,
-0.8452185988426208,
0.6587326526641846,
0.0383153036236763,
-0.02836143597960472,
-1.1798516511917114,
0.006346640642732382,
0.2540607154369354,
-0.153196319937706,
-0.6968400478363037,
-0.24733896553516388,
-0.16293911635875702,
-0.3873755931854248,
-0.2090907245874405,
0.9064852595329285,
-0.4471435546875,
0.29283595085144043,
-0.23277679085731506,
-0.21286852657794952,
-0.47812139987945557,
0.00186194758862257,
-0.19233302772045135,
0.68989098072052,
0.7325010299682617,
-0.6938542127609253,
0.43737679719924927,
-0.028703192248940468,
-0.464734822511673,
0.5324843525886536,
-0.44633176922798157,
-0.03634251281619072,
-0.45273342728614807,
0.2218979150056839,
-0.8749268651008606,
-0.002062057377770543,
0.258925199508667,
-0.30174702405929565,
-0.18165835738182068,
-0.33216333389282227,
-0.397892028093338,
-0.42849159240722656,
-0.21124312281608582,
0.32547467947006226,
0.6895440816879272,
-0.4410526156425476,
0.6588442325592041,
0.3888731300830841,
-0.4311716556549072,
-0.3491203188896179,
-0.3433426320552826,
0.3141480088233948,
-0.7476075887680054,
-0.84634929895401,
0.3547528386116028,
-0.09881452471017838,
-0.34299904108047485,
-0.28464171290397644,
0.10492219775915146,
0.16482606530189514,
0.2952425181865692,
0.49631035327911377,
0.45787665247917175,
0.2726345956325531,
0.19946713745594025,
-0.2114265114068985,
-0.4018120765686035,
0.2274336963891983,
-0.6249093413352966,
0.7250415682792664,
0.18939054012298584,
0.20738255977630615,
-0.318528950214386,
0.2235189527273178,
0.7007584571838379,
-0.21891282498836517,
0.6166184544563293,
0.6746094226837158,
-0.24001538753509521,
-0.05346749350428581,
-0.2330169677734375,
-0.11473629623651505,
-0.5305350422859192,
0.07088395208120346,
-0.45103174448013306,
-0.6716533303260803,
0.7627007961273193,
-0.46634814143180847,
0.2379983365535736,
0.4491642117500305,
0.5207974910736084,
0.012145346961915493,
1.2122060060501099,
0.6361919045448303,
-0.17036433517932892,
0.834867537021637,
0.40839293599128723,
0.06937224417924881,
-0.37077197432518005,
-0.4114244282245636,
-0.7196651101112366,
0.008687387220561504,
-0.7707152366638184,
-0.3249143660068512,
0.11729222536087036,
-0.09841670095920563,
-0.22786712646484375,
0.18973121047019958,
-0.10131510347127914,
0.2834411859512329,
0.44320374727249146,
-0.1613861322402954,
-0.2953643500804901,
0.3304115831851959,
-0.38776302337646484,
0.09171328693628311,
-0.6992626786231995,
-0.5393859148025513,
0.7405206561088562,
0.2275078147649765,
0.7711340188980103,
-0.3084942102432251,
0.4357094168663025,
0.5008913278579712,
0.19902998208999634,
-0.48376157879829407,
0.6807997226715088,
0.29291337728500366,
-0.23416553437709808,
-0.3451600670814514,
-0.7429242730140686,
-1.0621949434280396,
-0.04930491745471954,
-0.08049560338258743,
-0.8227707147598267,
0.3643209934234619,
-0.05882493406534195,
-0.3822379410266876,
0.2950364649295807,
-0.4330609440803528,
0.7067269682884216,
-0.12721915543079376,
-0.1900331676006317,
-0.1263640969991684,
-0.7370645999908447,
0.00727623188868165,
0.11204025894403458,
0.6630988717079163,
-0.3976795971393585,
0.06126388534903526,
0.7659938335418701,
-0.8367620706558228,
0.7826630473136902,
-0.7150211930274963,
-0.14974619448184967,
0.4062544107437134,
0.10258165001869202,
0.8590579628944397,
0.09531553834676743,
-0.6631454825401306,
-0.10535721480846405,
-0.45397940278053284,
-0.3183102011680603,
-0.3234877586364746,
0.6763903498649597,
-0.1550748199224472,
-0.2919250428676605,
-0.2744694948196411,
-0.2961846590042114,
-0.26967304944992065,
0.24722401797771454,
0.5383700132369995,
0.5216807126998901,
-0.07920005917549133,
-0.448507696390152,
0.17736472189426422,
-0.22069519758224487,
0.7428209185600281,
0.30954355001449585,
-0.041789986193180084,
-0.5105162262916565,
0.9596233367919922,
0.09826493263244629,
-0.39583125710487366,
0.35512951016426086,
0.3316460847854614,
-0.5520036816596985,
-0.4601552486419678,
-0.7052796483039856,
0.021124480292201042,
-0.4488812983036041,
-0.19920355081558228,
-0.5292050242424011,
0.3979005813598633,
-0.5414563417434692,
-0.21704928576946259,
-0.017762836068868637,
-0.48738256096839905,
-0.2304285764694214,
-0.3201126158237457,
0.3474467992782593,
0.3997872769832611,
-0.10381119698286057,
0.29943791031837463,
-0.7259001731872559,
-0.017296962440013885,
0.2787363827228546,
0.5072699189186096,
-0.07588496059179306,
-0.3073296546936035,
-0.5423136353492737,
0.16438277065753937,
-0.11216647177934647,
-0.978027880191803,
0.7384281158447266,
-0.12348490953445435,
0.41180938482284546,
0.35285434126853943,
0.5352782607078552,
0.6658216118812561,
-0.7631208896636963,
0.966457724571228,
0.5961490273475647,
-0.6324197053909302,
0.6691731810569763,
-0.36539509892463684,
0.3796187937259674,
0.6249889135360718,
0.10899733006954193,
-0.7734835147857666,
-0.011969747953116894,
-0.5734061598777771,
-1.0647460222244263,
0.46200770139694214,
-0.19311301410198212,
0.2374849021434784,
-0.3186456859111786,
0.20433539152145386,
0.21884649991989136,
0.15737994015216827,
-0.5745043754577637,
-0.10408836603164673,
-0.2727457284927368,
-0.3331940472126007,
0.14540688693523407,
-0.33355656266212463,
0.41471976041793823,
-0.08408711105585098,
0.35911476612091064,
-0.1011965274810791,
0.13109977543354034,
-0.04668186604976654,
0.13222144544124603,
-0.22015585005283356,
0.3254311978816986,
0.5948134064674377,
0.3525714576244354,
-0.22696536779403687,
0.008640862070024014,
0.4269792139530182,
-0.22818468511104584,
0.4309195876121521,
-0.11804915219545364,
-0.35469698905944824,
0.3502110540866852,
0.21655979752540588,
0.870398759841919,
-0.29055482149124146,
-0.8654760718345642,
0.3026736080646515,
-0.18626032769680023,
0.2033165693283081,
-0.4598070979118347,
0.03410843387246132,
-0.42392468452453613,
-0.013755880296230316,
0.5373903512954712,
0.44571423530578613,
0.26022404432296753,
-0.4869619905948639,
0.06906191259622574,
0.25719818472862244,
-0.6842384338378906,
-0.7782514691352844,
0.8198128342628479,
0.4818810820579529,
-0.6212127804756165,
0.7557687163352966,
-0.5691439509391785,
-0.3007155954837799,
0.13054043054580688,
0.4369013011455536,
1.136311650276184,
-0.6903320550918579,
0.05246952548623085,
0.5144278407096863,
0.12810811400413513,
-0.3552496135234833,
0.467426061630249,
0.06034950911998749,
-0.6596108078956604,
-0.45918041467666626,
-0.3841281533241272,
0.062213361263275146,
-0.3492841124534607,
-0.5333693623542786,
0.6009001731872559,
-0.16053013503551483,
-0.3168637752532959,
-0.46452754735946655,
-0.2682763338088989,
-0.6733750700950623,
0.20392222702503204,
0.25550055503845215,
1.1638076305389404,
-0.8689893484115601,
0.6303396224975586,
0.9510877728462219,
0.038449976593256,
-0.5972451567649841,
0.2625560462474823,
-0.12433920055627823,
-0.4997285008430481,
0.520803689956665,
0.6487739682197571,
-0.09367857128381729,
-0.04669439047574997,
-0.37848344445228577,
-0.5926827192306519,
0.9463049173355103,
0.49712294340133667,
-0.5149461030960083,
-0.44136205315589905,
-0.13466133177280426,
0.052516207098960876,
-0.551891565322876,
0.13678225874900818,
0.3635612428188324,
0.48525470495224,
0.1136891320347786,
-0.7447471618652344,
0.40036287903785706,
-0.40305426716804504,
-0.011206519789993763,
0.19697877764701843,
-0.26398423314094543,
0.8430063128471375,
-0.4579232335090637,
-0.657012939453125,
0.10044260323047638,
0.6726052165031433,
0.2551923990249634,
0.6223241686820984,
0.9268231987953186,
0.4558505415916443,
1.1490647792816162,
0.12888476252555847,
0.984806478023529,
-0.4394240975379944,
-0.03884198144078255,
0.8042528629302979,
-0.4889431893825531,
0.30437061190605164,
0.22961464524269104,
0.09100133180618286,
1.0511397123336792,
0.611691415309906,
0.29272180795669556,
0.8147350549697876,
0.15192916989326477,
-0.39534032344818115,
-0.5308744311332703,
-0.2087058126926422,
-0.26248833537101746,
0.0981319397687912,
0.25519174337387085,
-0.17905293405056,
-0.2980235815048218,
0.28558090329170227,
0.12650875747203827,
-0.21707653999328613,
-0.5228198170661926,
0.7360813617706299,
-0.22459053993225098,
-0.8581194877624512,
0.4592975676059723,
0.29690098762512207,
0.605173647403717,
-0.27409446239471436,
0.13151034712791443,
-0.16544748842716217,
-0.34391793608665466,
-0.040002137422561646,
-0.7280897498130798,
0.18090295791625977,
0.1510123461484909,
-0.19559063017368317,
-0.6687526106834412,
0.6131799817085266,
-0.21266281604766846,
-0.38491785526275635,
-0.09823199361562729,
0.41582319140434265,
-0.008422115817666054,
-0.18882770836353302,
-0.554776668548584,
-0.2275087982416153,
0.2890477180480957,
-0.010691991075873375,
0.2980850338935852,
0.9444201588630676,
-0.1572006493806839,
1.086904764175415,
0.7139989733695984,
0.20473229885101318,
-0.09117299318313599,
-0.07780865579843521,
0.8717638850212097,
-1.234495997428894,
-1.0919994115829468,
-1.2944010496139526,
0.8506501317024231,
-0.060248106718063354,
-0.23537400364875793,
0.6621114015579224,
0.6248087286949158,
-0.013389951549470425,
0.07167653739452362,
0.914240837097168,
-0.09530382603406906,
0.497042179107666,
-0.6680227518081665,
0.016910260543227196,
-0.06389716267585754,
0.7260462641716003,
-0.018685104325413704,
-0.41052502393722534,
-0.12231973558664322,
0.5276851654052734,
-0.24422962963581085,
-0.07460767775774002,
0.3590274751186371,
0.8297312259674072,
0.14269642531871796,
0.04838913679122925,
-0.0483786016702652,
-0.24166420102119446,
0.4910212755203247,
0.23380610346794128,
0.882766604423523,
0.026223760098218918,
0.35133811831474304,
0.11195584386587143,
-0.10753139853477478,
-0.4631917476654053,
-0.9899589419364929,
-0.7266132831573486,
-0.8378487229347229,
-0.20475400984287262,
-0.5098004341125488,
-0.08271893113851547,
1.1990797519683838,
0.9133405685424805,
-0.6067520976066589,
-0.30088987946510315,
-0.4749094545841217,
0.31639188528060913,
-0.1877465695142746,
-0.30002546310424805,
0.18390585482120514,
-0.6534264087677002,
-0.28950390219688416,
0.6854690313339233,
0.20661945641040802,
0.3613905608654022,
-0.033022474497556686,
-0.0923537090420723,
0.3315991163253784,
-0.12145537883043289,
0.4578185975551605,
0.19142776727676392,
-0.18062368035316467,
-0.051944419741630554,
0.06444820761680603,
0.1408158838748932,
-0.19782598316669464,
1.1011778116226196,
-1.184425711631775,
0.3246147632598877,
0.48669013381004333,
0.11199703812599182,
0.014074953272938728,
0.270325630903244,
1.1210960149765015,
-0.8838613629341125,
0.37638717889785767,
0.22627992928028107,
0.44345203042030334,
0.22314602136611938,
-0.3604632616043091,
0.31393715739250183,
0.19470642507076263,
-0.30706197023391724,
-1.0219495296478271,
0.37637239694595337,
-0.730068027973175,
-0.19618433713912964,
1.1668400764465332,
0.1333480328321457,
-0.043684959411621094,
-0.44989779591560364,
-0.31087952852249146,
-0.05084777623414993,
-0.758395791053772,
0.6972072124481201,
0.2566423714160919,
0.1776428371667862,
-0.3196471631526947,
-0.3265581429004669,
0.5445348620414734,
-0.033385053277015686,
-0.47963255643844604,
0.7157647609710693,
0.4752003252506256,
0.046848852187395096,
-0.03778785094618797,
0.6585806608200073,
0.21064700186252594,
0.2161547839641571,
-0.29914116859436035,
-0.15542399883270264,
-0.035348013043403625,
-0.2799551486968994,
-0.3189004063606262,
0.42874088883399963,
0.0819447711110115,
-0.05462438240647316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03538v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03538v1
|
RADIA -- Radio Advertisement Detection with Intelligent Analytics
| 2024-03-06T08:34:28 | 2024-03-06T08:34:28 |
Jorge Álvarez, Juan Carlos Armenteros, Camilo Torrón, Miguel Ortega-Martín, Alfonso Ardoiz, Óscar García, Ignacio Arranz, Íñigo Galdeano, Ignacio Garrido, Adrián Alonso, Fernando Bayón, Oleg Vorontsov
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Radio advertising remains an integral part of modern marketing strategies,
with its appeal and potential for targeted reach undeniably effective. However,
the dynamic nature of radio airtime and the rising trend of multiple radio
spots necessitates an efficient system for monitoring advertisement broadcasts.
This study investigates a novel automated radio advertisement detection
technique incorporating advanced speech recognition and text classification
algorithms. RadIA's approach surpasses traditional methods by eliminating the
need for prior knowledge of the broadcast content. This contribution allows for
detecting impromptu and newly introduced advertisements, providing a
comprehensive solution for advertisement detection in radio broadcasting.
Experimental results show that the resulting model, trained on carefully
segmented and tagged text data, achieves an F1-macro score of 87.76 against a
theoretical maximum of 89.33. This paper provides insights into the choice of
hyperparameters and their impact on the model's performance. This study
demonstrates its potential to ensure compliance with advertising broadcast
contracts and offer competitive surveillance. This groundbreaking research
could fundamentally change how radio advertising is monitored and open new
doors for marketing optimization.
|
[
-0.592243492603302,
-0.7590698003768921,
0.24498577415943146,
0.35089102387428284,
-0.034099459648132324,
0.021083038300275803,
-0.2837647795677185,
-0.6375213861465454,
0.4860524535179138,
0.15529410541057587,
-0.5552408695220947,
-0.5567399263381958,
-0.6074609756469727,
-0.07772194594144821,
-0.4415768086910248,
0.7779216766357422,
0.7221049070358276,
-0.2671273350715637,
-0.1815733164548874,
-0.20181751251220703,
-0.2681795358657837,
0.18318496644496918,
-0.5421023964881897,
-0.24919135868549347,
0.168312668800354,
0.6089777946472168,
0.8086124658584595,
0.663800060749054,
0.5390785932540894,
0.37619543075561523,
0.10974079370498657,
0.42788541316986084,
-0.10856824368238449,
0.3412134349346161,
0.10643444210290909,
0.07804770022630692,
-0.655174195766449,
0.1781391054391861,
0.547660231590271,
0.07725069671869278,
-0.2589159607887268,
0.19757390022277832,
-0.3471115827560425,
0.4338477849960327,
-0.7075538039207458,
0.20904231071472168,
-0.6232092976570129,
-0.2600986361503601,
-0.41585373878479004,
-0.6975715756416321,
-0.5715869665145874,
-0.40477168560028076,
0.04122914746403694,
-0.6711559295654297,
0.0669843852519989,
0.17788998782634735,
1.0466256141662598,
0.3031754493713379,
-0.32102593779563904,
-0.784496009349823,
-1.1114306449890137,
0.7579278945922852,
-0.3013577163219452,
0.2699221074581146,
0.4944300651550293,
0.537813127040863,
0.29544100165367126,
-0.6234204173088074,
-0.247634619474411,
-0.21148979663848877,
0.17535711824893951,
0.14773960411548615,
-0.9228640198707581,
-0.09657330811023712,
-0.02254805527627468,
0.13890062272548676,
-0.4640384614467621,
0.07792846858501434,
-0.2584942877292633,
-0.13054537773132324,
0.5167178511619568,
0.0071968939155340195,
0.28767693042755127,
-0.20485787093639374,
-0.2971545457839966,
0.1395968347787857,
-0.2233215719461441,
-0.38690611720085144,
0.36426883935928345,
-0.007992259226739407,
-0.001156332204118371,
-0.0035909570287913084,
-0.425012469291687,
0.6608049273490906,
-0.2230883687734604,
0.10723502933979034,
0.14199984073638916,
0.16980989277362823,
-0.15959301590919495,
0.33789190649986267,
0.9914092421531677,
-0.09267332404851913,
0.1460992842912674,
0.2685396671295166,
-0.25164687633514404,
0.42951974272727966,
-0.12903693318367004,
-0.45135679841041565,
-0.33845117688179016,
-0.1840360164642334,
-0.3141832947731018,
-0.6892004013061523,
0.10096953809261322,
-0.3947242498397827,
0.041100408881902695,
0.07065747678279877,
0.4265666902065277,
-0.4622124433517456,
-0.35790392756462097,
0.48066604137420654,
0.22679977118968964,
0.24523699283599854,
0.009528029710054398,
-0.7423665523529053,
0.25098443031311035,
0.6717289090156555,
0.6527536511421204,
0.39966246485710144,
0.4317348599433899,
-0.550197184085846,
0.18985243141651154,
-0.07778851687908173,
1.2523138523101807,
-0.8211812973022461,
-0.28633561730384827,
-0.3597249686717987,
-0.535364031791687,
-0.027687320485711098,
-0.4210734963417053,
0.5637395977973938,
-1.03038489818573,
0.37117549777030945,
0.1447434276342392,
-0.4734616279602051,
-0.33615684509277344,
0.03093552216887474,
-0.5835310220718384,
0.9371402859687805,
-0.008159049786627293,
-0.5270026326179504,
0.5465332865715027,
-0.6868398189544678,
-0.4518492519855499,
0.39945611357688904,
-0.08969084918498993,
-0.7938602566719055,
0.04990202933549881,
0.4175734221935272,
0.20768199861049652,
-0.28971540927886963,
-0.0900842621922493,
-0.3075760304927826,
-0.3059326410293579,
0.7207832336425781,
-0.7544826865196228,
0.5353944897651672,
0.6698338985443115,
-0.16155724227428436,
0.025657285004854202,
-0.6940593719482422,
0.2091008573770523,
0.001603465061634779,
-0.318338543176651,
-0.7422841787338257,
-0.0012690778821706772,
0.5459023714065552,
0.008694644086062908,
-0.06138276681303978,
-0.5551390051841736,
0.004448906984180212,
-0.42066490650177,
0.12783809006214142,
0.32614824175834656,
0.017779022455215454,
0.2317444533109665,
-0.12923017144203186,
0.7196225523948669,
-0.6209766864776611,
0.24612127244472504,
-0.31150516867637634,
-0.5284088253974915,
-0.332785427570343,
-0.4874206781387329,
0.5296654105186462,
0.4001295268535614,
-0.08595157414674759,
0.6630731225013733,
-0.11777828633785248,
-0.5772870779037476,
-0.5353859066963196,
-0.0626714825630188,
0.16246913373470306,
0.29111477732658386,
-0.011321566067636013,
0.10013327747583389,
-0.5409950613975525,
-0.5786294341087341,
-0.3204534947872162,
0.16714850068092346,
0.4057925343513489,
0.23934291303157806,
0.2629943788051605,
-0.3817628026008606,
1.1275148391723633,
-0.8992601633071899,
-0.7766664028167725,
-0.42696887254714966,
0.27324700355529785,
0.3854093849658966,
0.25395432114601135,
0.824878990650177,
-0.9578182697296143,
-0.6649813652038574,
0.11210089921951294,
-0.7183540463447571,
-0.5047236680984497,
-0.03180074691772461,
0.37106406688690186,
-0.3415983021259308,
0.6101753115653992,
-0.4217405915260315,
0.3452948033809662,
0.4453102648258209,
-0.30250638723373413,
0.28260019421577454,
-0.5041570067405701,
0.12335658818483353,
-0.692620575428009,
-0.1502525955438614,
0.2785211205482483,
-0.31220752000808716,
-0.4899333119392395,
-0.4046449363231659,
0.09044744074344635,
-0.1858031153678894,
-0.37671545147895813,
0.243614062666893,
-0.3223729133605957,
-0.3906921148300171,
-0.8346431255340576,
-0.19554319977760315,
0.09104051440954208,
-0.12346622347831726,
-0.07221664488315582,
0.797653317451477,
0.6042090654373169,
-0.7440738081932068,
0.5923140048980713,
0.1826406717300415,
-0.9788834452629089,
0.35509198904037476,
-0.5618184804916382,
0.09949425607919693,
-0.39540618658065796,
0.2172434777021408,
-1.490085482597351,
-0.33022642135620117,
0.04921673610806465,
-0.8554946780204773,
0.1551300287246704,
0.07287302613258362,
-0.1829603612422943,
-0.09810951352119446,
0.015250518918037415,
0.5396391153335571,
0.33038094639778137,
-0.3058997392654419,
0.5415116548538208,
0.6126514077186584,
0.03549320623278618,
-0.4361574053764343,
-0.18741898238658905,
0.1640922725200653,
-0.43239066004753113,
-0.49918702244758606,
0.2981714904308319,
0.42218801379203796,
-0.15203244984149933,
0.25085368752479553,
-0.18916329741477966,
-0.1809724122285843,
0.09094545990228653,
-0.04274237900972366,
0.09605128318071365,
-0.4149731695652008,
-0.03266172856092453,
0.10762690007686615,
-0.5997214317321777,
0.1566472202539444,
-0.37127363681793213,
0.5209813117980957,
-0.010742202401161194,
-0.07689984887838364,
-1.1236522197723389,
0.2772662341594696,
0.994746208190918,
-0.541841447353363,
0.42631301283836365,
0.8590957522392273,
-0.3912719190120697,
-0.28304344415664673,
-0.48993560671806335,
0.10545184463262558,
-0.6086892485618591,
0.3938450515270233,
-0.01468763966113329,
-0.15390798449516296,
0.17278733849525452,
0.13337044417858124,
-0.4071592092514038,
0.3734856843948364,
0.4109220504760742,
-0.24741680920124054,
1.5198285579681396,
0.6199049949645996,
-0.15728069841861725,
0.5543235540390015,
-0.3463466763496399,
0.1728672981262207,
-0.3260587155818939,
-0.384883850812912,
-0.7084639072418213,
-0.08139624446630478,
-0.4026804268360138,
-0.2131357043981552,
0.8180282115936279,
-0.5943599939346313,
0.1938343495130539,
0.1628352701663971,
-0.5060804486274719,
0.5808596611022949,
0.32746803760528564,
0.10880766063928604,
0.2830813527107239,
-0.020680516958236694,
0.5272646546363831,
-0.12136919051408768,
-0.45696502923965454,
-0.3045661747455597,
0.7866631150245667,
0.3380739390850067,
1.2122294902801514,
0.06033971160650253,
0.2674797773361206,
0.9114883542060852,
0.6037941575050354,
-0.9795782566070557,
0.3970438838005066,
-0.16590291261672974,
-0.764947235584259,
-0.13846413791179657,
-0.39893120527267456,
-0.7999714612960815,
0.23292239010334015,
-0.2422577440738678,
-0.10809548199176788,
0.174712672829628,
0.2149861454963684,
-0.5190967321395874,
-0.060430873185396194,
-0.4854826331138611,
0.44269829988479614,
-0.4631445109844208,
0.08978905528783798,
-0.6421286463737488,
-0.04292704164981842,
0.24991534650325775,
-0.0509459413588047,
0.7142276167869568,
-0.6487646698951721,
0.003714899532496929,
1.0010380744934082,
-0.09137134253978729,
0.3079816401004791,
-0.2532544434070587,
0.11095669120550156,
0.06134389713406563,
-0.12173641473054886,
0.26351872086524963,
0.09825058281421661,
0.1828557699918747,
-0.5343992710113525,
-0.3175356388092041,
-0.37874725461006165,
-0.3951287567615509,
0.7709080576896667,
-0.5425484776496887,
-0.13540178537368774,
-0.7101505398750305,
-0.6530599594116211,
-0.2609511911869049,
0.49736613035202026,
0.4136194586753845,
0.6415473222732544,
-0.45205220580101013,
0.24742603302001953,
0.956660270690918,
-0.5397242307662964,
0.20798827707767487,
0.7445417046546936,
-0.03490007296204567,
-0.5901288986206055,
1.006908893585205,
-0.302835077047348,
0.08920399099588394,
0.4956963062286377,
0.519637942314148,
-0.665122926235199,
-0.5158027410507202,
0.26179051399230957,
0.4742771089076996,
-0.5984427332878113,
-0.3277745246887207,
-0.7788563370704651,
0.16972285509109497,
-0.5619086623191833,
0.0691801905632019,
-0.39426442980766296,
-0.2178940325975418,
-0.1995553821325302,
0.09074754267930984,
0.3354796767234802,
0.8249630331993103,
-0.19241924583911896,
0.7228580713272095,
-0.6155876517295837,
0.30902206897735596,
0.22343039512634277,
0.13189361989498138,
-0.2476503998041153,
-0.3370420038700104,
-0.5437124371528625,
-0.2716841399669647,
-0.2126796990633011,
-0.7896836400032043,
0.5810003280639648,
0.4439232051372528,
0.4255845844745636,
0.9261852502822876,
-0.032865144312381744,
0.21068128943443298,
-0.053057633340358734,
-0.18720078468322754,
0.015839479863643646,
-0.8675540089607239,
0.695265531539917,
-0.7633952498435974,
0.260920912027359,
0.40799880027770996,
0.3149842917919159,
-0.40233859419822693,
-0.18892458081245422,
-0.4107673168182373,
-0.659857988357544,
0.7848392128944397,
0.050195999443531036,
0.0966474637389183,
-0.1045796126127243,
-0.06245773658156395,
-0.40650004148483276,
0.004295013844966888,
-0.2630203366279602,
-0.19485600292682648,
0.20865210890769958,
-0.2181975096464157,
0.1840161234140396,
-0.21129514276981354,
0.27646222710609436,
-0.44185054302215576,
0.7067294120788574,
0.32796788215637207,
0.21553540229797363,
-0.06287302821874619,
-0.2086072862148285,
-0.1023370772600174,
0.06898188591003418,
0.696028470993042,
0.45005619525909424,
-0.6210390329360962,
-0.1909211277961731,
-0.2575848400592804,
-0.4222638010978699,
0.2568347752094269,
-0.1674654334783554,
-0.06798071414232254,
0.3805505037307739,
0.10585044324398041,
0.44846388697624207,
0.3397887647151947,
-0.43678194284439087,
0.5118211507797241,
-0.06853539496660233,
-0.08739326149225235,
-0.6411362290382385,
0.07690940052270889,
-0.09876006841659546,
-0.07662872970104218,
0.500332772731781,
0.42737218737602234,
0.3019465506076813,
-0.37809139490127563,
0.5796276330947876,
0.6358579993247986,
-0.6245139837265015,
-0.15008434653282166,
1.1562198400497437,
0.2812313437461853,
-0.16673250496387482,
0.29562363028526306,
0.0021806994918733835,
-0.4829102158546448,
0.8656168580055237,
0.47540387511253357,
0.8921177983283997,
-0.8085632920265198,
0.3406420648097992,
-0.2074005901813507,
0.2520570158958435,
0.15164367854595184,
-0.003218695754185319,
-0.1439272165298462,
-0.8901781439781189,
-0.26976022124290466,
-0.3115989863872528,
-0.4003694951534271,
0.12421240657567978,
-1.0057611465454102,
0.4787589907646179,
-0.5230996012687683,
-0.4664515256881714,
0.8689553737640381,
-0.01606118492782116,
-0.5873786807060242,
0.5004165768623352,
0.4620475471019745,
1.0829720497131348,
-1.1384165287017822,
1.075696587562561,
0.6998807191848755,
0.01800122857093811,
-0.3123350143432617,
-0.0850614383816719,
0.09827658534049988,
-0.8168423175811768,
0.659771740436554,
0.2879476249217987,
-0.6781678199768066,
0.30405759811401367,
-0.22375239431858063,
-0.8500033020973206,
0.5820721983909607,
-0.15445931255817413,
-0.14471542835235596,
-0.062442976981401443,
-0.1679866909980774,
0.21570497751235962,
-0.5070518851280212,
0.27241623401641846,
0.8191015720367432,
0.5414366722106934,
-0.03628148138523102,
-0.578062891960144,
-0.3413786292076111,
0.02665313147008419,
-0.3886280357837677,
0.5027737617492676,
-0.4897214472293854,
0.31516003608703613,
-0.0075593376532197,
-0.106731116771698,
-0.005799489561468363,
0.881141722202301,
-0.15065595507621765,
0.8606438040733337,
0.5524393916130066,
0.329952597618103,
0.47278374433517456,
-0.14262259006500244,
0.6715054512023926,
-0.05213182419538498,
0.6716949939727783,
0.18182942271232605,
-0.3358215391635895,
0.25280457735061646,
-0.08407556265592575,
0.0649009570479393,
0.3864522874355316,
0.1764148324728012,
-0.004861482419073582,
0.9566361904144287,
-0.3672274351119995,
-0.6697132587432861,
-0.35288912057876587,
-0.06869185715913773,
-0.244963139295578,
1.0472558736801147,
1.077128529548645,
-0.31905311346054077,
-0.5097989439964294,
0.582119882106781,
0.1270459145307541,
0.4191713333129883,
-0.14795935153961182,
0.5870219469070435,
-0.22737006843090057,
-0.21660436689853668,
0.48997679352760315,
0.35510942339897156,
0.8649610877037048,
-0.9177048802375793,
0.40695783495903015,
0.20535069704055786,
0.6672323346138,
-0.315475195646286,
-0.28602534532546997,
0.5029544234275818,
-0.10525999963283539,
-0.03229174390435219,
-0.19801190495491028,
0.8136718273162842,
-0.19805149734020233,
-0.35276466608047485,
0.10082368552684784,
0.23423518240451813,
-0.02955150604248047,
-0.02955181896686554,
-0.7239297032356262,
0.5256816744804382,
0.04781501740217209,
-0.2007061243057251,
0.02579684555530548,
0.17604580521583557,
0.24262315034866333,
0.6153928637504578,
0.5781194567680359,
0.3677845597267151,
-0.2113083004951477,
-0.27349627017974854,
0.5945913791656494,
-0.8013659119606018,
-1.0400360822677612,
-0.5999948382377625,
-0.25366297364234924,
-0.07403231412172318,
-0.1859024316072464,
0.6836990714073181,
0.7739109396934509,
0.4353666603565216,
0.05152533948421478,
0.8839471340179443,
0.015956426039338112,
0.5996578931808472,
-0.25439542531967163,
0.8410993218421936,
-0.31810590624809265,
0.6905247569084167,
-0.4095398485660553,
-0.7774395942687988,
-0.4070896506309509,
0.7020450830459595,
-0.5886670351028442,
-0.08082421869039536,
0.28657811880111694,
0.8474265933036804,
-0.4298809766769409,
0.14617222547531128,
0.14488790929317474,
-0.27556708455085754,
0.6364439129829407,
0.3640601634979248,
0.8918073177337646,
-0.43099451065063477,
0.8435569405555725,
-0.030449632555246353,
-0.5325734615325928,
-0.3607650101184845,
-0.6102975606918335,
-0.5260050296783447,
-0.333117812871933,
-0.5844270586967468,
-0.3208587169647217,
-0.003027633996680379,
0.7814109921455383,
0.805596113204956,
-0.7465330958366394,
-0.3195514678955078,
0.3698335289955139,
-0.008924332447350025,
-0.6159575581550598,
-0.3390313982963562,
0.41507866978645325,
-0.15717917680740356,
-0.7156501412391663,
0.7341582775115967,
0.46808990836143494,
-0.21584950387477875,
0.0049054184928536415,
0.26545342803001404,
-0.21729695796966553,
0.4236014485359192,
0.23572804033756256,
0.5636259913444519,
-0.15482133626937866,
0.18234196305274963,
-0.07961812615394592,
-0.17427362501621246,
-0.1040181890130043,
1.0504570007324219,
-0.8521808385848999,
0.2527283728122711,
0.6748495697975159,
0.3538554906845093,
0.5486189723014832,
0.27534425258636475,
0.2272644191980362,
-0.6545641422271729,
0.4177444875240326,
0.4558061361312866,
-0.06398066878318787,
0.307560533285141,
-0.3337463140487671,
-0.25217804312705994,
0.3130691647529602,
-0.6110481023788452,
-0.9031987190246582,
0.2180880904197693,
-0.8890582919120789,
-0.3671703338623047,
0.8577160239219666,
0.5262411236763,
-0.13414287567138672,
-0.4219217598438263,
-0.005181760992854834,
0.10136928409337997,
-0.42741942405700684,
0.6626819372177124,
0.21227571368217468,
-0.3050362765789032,
0.05946671962738037,
-0.6582642793655396,
0.5458240509033203,
0.4170585572719574,
-0.4514547288417816,
-0.08226880431175232,
0.4792025089263916,
0.5853320360183716,
0.03078419528901577,
0.9354268312454224,
-0.04595820605754852,
0.6082902550697327,
-0.3125617802143097,
-0.4758777916431427,
-0.5053369998931885,
-0.4090741276741028,
-0.22270408272743225,
0.1642593890428543,
-0.10005004703998566,
-0.8128076791763306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03522v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03522v2
|
Non-verbal information in spontaneous speech -- towards a new framework of analysis
| 2024-03-06T08:03:05 | 2024-03-13T09:50:40 |
Tirza Biron, Moshe Barboy, Eran Ben-Artzy, Alona Golubchik, Yanir Marmor, Smadar Szekely, Yaron Winter, David Harel
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Non-verbal signals in speech are encoded by prosody and carry information
that ranges from conversation action to attitude and emotion. Despite its
importance, the principles that govern prosodic structure are not yet
adequately understood. This paper offers an analytical schema and a
technological proof-of-concept for the categorization of prosodic signals and
their association with meaning. The schema interprets surface-representations
of multi-layered prosodic events. As a first step towards implementation, we
present a classification process that disentangles prosodic phenomena of three
orders. It relies on fine-tuning a pre-trained speech recognition model,
enabling the simultaneous multi-class/multi-label detection. It generalizes
over a large variety of spontaneous data, performing on a par with, or superior
to, human annotation. In addition to a standardized formalization of prosody,
disentangling prosodic patterns can direct a theory of communication and speech
organization. A welcome by-product is an interpretation of prosody that will
enhance speech- and language-related technologies.
|
[
-0.26685670018196106,
-0.832588791847229,
0.4049457013607025,
0.4435238242149353,
-0.4416438341140747,
0.03810741379857063,
-0.17748798429965973,
-0.44609740376472473,
0.5898417234420776,
0.1650414913892746,
-0.514252245426178,
-0.44055604934692383,
-0.5642759799957275,
-0.1049848273396492,
-0.5073375701904297,
0.7196910381317139,
0.3561517596244812,
0.207514688372612,
0.1507948338985443,
-0.05397985503077507,
-0.050259944051504135,
-0.7323318123817444,
-0.20052556693553925,
-0.03307456895709038,
0.41341081261634827,
0.2884628474712372,
0.5559937357902527,
0.2678706645965576,
0.24935398995876312,
0.40146201848983765,
-0.11986387521028519,
0.08920412510633469,
-0.05605205148458481,
0.21479001641273499,
0.18110299110412598,
-0.4908792972564697,
-0.6772873401641846,
0.4497476816177368,
0.8918665647506714,
0.9057894945144653,
-0.2126447707414627,
0.1221357062458992,
0.1992209106683731,
0.33510562777519226,
-0.14644016325473785,
0.573289155960083,
-0.10487836599349976,
0.11883018165826797,
-0.6964060068130493,
-0.5901889801025391,
-0.5006280541419983,
-0.3345848023891449,
0.046973858028650284,
-0.3885062038898468,
0.3141940236091614,
-0.11267838627099991,
0.4423445463180542,
0.08538316935300827,
-0.5571524500846863,
-0.29644516110420227,
-0.9191660284996033,
0.38898545503616333,
-0.2179141491651535,
0.7878115773200989,
0.34343716502189636,
0.28003156185150146,
-0.34820878505706787,
-0.5870593190193176,
-0.774765133857727,
-0.22242796421051025,
-0.0260179303586483,
0.1519542932510376,
0.015319869853556156,
0.15299329161643982,
-0.22711333632469177,
0.3103034794330597,
-0.5382967591285706,
0.16091196238994598,
-0.2529294192790985,
-0.24658244848251343,
0.7723059058189392,
-0.05932900682091713,
0.2977586090564728,
-0.12353646755218506,
-0.12919139862060547,
0.11513229459524155,
-0.28335821628570557,
0.03713257983326912,
0.2321104109287262,
0.5859655141830444,
-0.30704131722450256,
0.4083697497844696,
-0.12931442260742188,
0.5963517427444458,
0.04628203064203262,
-0.3732834756374359,
0.5673292279243469,
-0.23312263190746307,
0.009148244746029377,
0.5001034736633301,
0.8502866625785828,
0.015650199726223946,
0.028494179248809814,
-0.2103446125984192,
0.03992607817053795,
0.09742471575737,
-0.08200232684612274,
-0.3820863962173462,
-0.12837760150432587,
0.16502174735069275,
-0.3416427671909332,
-0.41773009300231934,
0.2187521904706955,
-0.3356187641620636,
-0.4363599121570587,
-0.5720184445381165,
0.25786834955215454,
-0.1604597121477127,
-0.7003695368766785,
-0.015214679762721062,
-0.09983905404806137,
-0.03497296944260597,
0.04096066206693649,
-0.8084560632705688,
0.41495415568351746,
0.5412638783454895,
0.9143620133399963,
0.26893922686576843,
-0.2767055332660675,
-0.43457716703414917,
-0.05863871052861214,
-0.359354704618454,
0.8508425951004028,
-0.4898717403411865,
-0.37111541628837585,
-0.32635730504989624,
0.32480257749557495,
-0.02658214420080185,
-0.3876907229423523,
0.2786952555179596,
-0.45662540197372437,
-0.03592218458652496,
0.06266293674707413,
-0.5731882452964783,
-0.013752343133091927,
-0.3272974491119385,
-0.6544779539108276,
0.5049171447753906,
-0.0717107281088829,
-0.5854828357696533,
0.20222456753253937,
-0.5578359961509705,
-0.532158613204956,
0.36258676648139954,
-0.29310908913612366,
-0.14910165965557098,
0.4502990245819092,
-0.6421463489532471,
0.4056321084499359,
-0.04869275912642479,
0.5155249238014221,
-0.3361987769603729,
-0.19311565160751343,
0.7142384648323059,
-0.335015207529068,
0.7285664081573486,
0.3213520646095276,
-0.15435639023780823,
0.16597066819667816,
-0.9971773624420166,
-0.014161711558699608,
-0.20462919771671295,
-0.12767522037029266,
-0.25576794147491455,
0.19787214696407318,
-0.15718422830104828,
0.38278594613075256,
0.1291479915380478,
-0.4481581747531891,
0.08010386675596237,
-0.3927566409111023,
0.827892005443573,
0.5126630663871765,
0.23685628175735474,
0.7084539532661438,
0.18447637557983398,
0.26112645864486694,
0.16505563259124756,
0.34178462624549866,
0.17011964321136475,
-0.6887807846069336,
-0.5503340363502502,
-0.42924660444259644,
0.1698564887046814,
0.5641897320747375,
-0.441042423248291,
0.4219217002391815,
0.05081986263394356,
-0.5967673063278198,
-0.3671964108943939,
-0.3152506649494171,
0.19980506598949432,
0.5725006461143494,
0.2982999384403229,
-0.13751719892024994,
-0.5721673965454102,
-0.567634642124176,
-0.22023531794548035,
-0.10033851861953735,
-0.0519234873354435,
-0.16391167044639587,
0.006656848359853029,
0.1403113752603531,
0.7886690497398376,
-0.26919472217559814,
-0.4355664849281311,
-0.10001496225595474,
0.6794873476028442,
0.313824325799942,
0.41014376282691956,
0.0707254484295845,
-0.6726649403572083,
-0.07431266456842422,
0.041945021599531174,
-0.8683552145957947,
-0.15346238017082214,
0.012949075549840927,
0.0850391834974289,
-0.2588498890399933,
0.6816146373748779,
-0.5438080430030823,
0.3235129714012146,
0.0507231205701828,
-0.1268039494752884,
0.4182535707950592,
-0.14839088916778564,
-0.12732015550136566,
-0.6293693780899048,
-0.2806616425514221,
-0.0196676142513752,
0.10071023553609848,
-1.0928845405578613,
-0.5159044861793518,
-0.033246662467718124,
-0.26936936378479004,
-0.5779169797897339,
0.3291045129299164,
-0.4916422367095947,
-0.17652831971645355,
-0.469003826379776,
0.19083963334560394,
-0.18109168112277985,
0.3701866865158081,
0.3487222194671631,
0.2658812999725342,
0.7603201866149902,
-0.8594908118247986,
0.41561734676361084,
0.2280360460281372,
-0.2778644263744354,
0.5881498456001282,
-0.4230406582355499,
0.26776596903800964,
-0.4633253812789917,
0.1514306515455246,
-0.9589831233024597,
-0.3091997504234314,
0.2649117708206177,
-0.6412846446037292,
0.23758819699287415,
-0.0907723531126976,
-0.6550079584121704,
0.08854643255472183,
0.07859349995851517,
0.24868500232696533,
0.408007949590683,
-0.09574881941080093,
0.4502660930156708,
0.6800485849380493,
-0.2880965769290924,
-0.04897076264023781,
-0.47699305415153503,
-0.1805383563041687,
-0.2482016235589981,
-0.45552346110343933,
0.2984364330768585,
0.3373779356479645,
-0.34858793020248413,
-0.1534697413444519,
-0.23331789672374725,
-0.2935027480125427,
0.20131291449069977,
0.505643367767334,
0.0484980046749115,
0.05024198815226555,
0.39143383502960205,
0.1152484342455864,
-0.41263532638549805,
0.1607540100812912,
-0.4667319655418396,
0.3768743872642517,
-0.12788434326648712,
-0.05841334909200668,
-0.8724132180213928,
0.2952159643173218,
0.5906652808189392,
-0.17406320571899414,
0.6455302834510803,
0.6022909879684448,
-0.29708701372146606,
-0.06302008777856827,
0.08029540628194809,
-0.24978837370872498,
-0.4753718376159668,
0.15637725591659546,
-0.4242689311504364,
-0.5645467042922974,
0.2904990017414093,
-0.15407709777355194,
-0.2513296902179718,
0.06414714455604553,
0.38874155282974243,
-0.539371907711029,
1.070699691772461,
0.4568028748035431,
0.31266558170318604,
0.4647058844566345,
0.000344056956237182,
0.4636131823062897,
-0.4284038543701172,
-0.65461266040802,
-0.5871025919914246,
-0.30935025215148926,
-0.7704018950462341,
-0.25145313143730164,
0.5094031095504761,
0.374968558549881,
-0.029537543654441833,
0.15775296092033386,
-0.4736534059047699,
0.2298266887664795,
0.41710424423217773,
-0.021157892420887947,
0.05966490879654884,
-0.1428299844264984,
0.19658464193344116,
-0.13958650827407837,
-0.46479153633117676,
-0.582615077495575,
0.5391257405281067,
0.2835673391819,
0.34183117747306824,
0.2438715398311615,
0.8474364280700684,
0.15726546943187714,
0.20175771415233612,
-0.7728146314620972,
0.6636786460876465,
-0.15909238159656525,
-0.4863590896129608,
-0.3724021017551422,
-0.18939530849456787,
-0.9869238138198853,
0.3565126657485962,
-0.3065931499004364,
-0.9158335328102112,
0.5691937208175659,
0.2276477962732315,
-0.32629653811454773,
-0.27395865321159363,
-0.8424749374389648,
0.6605735421180725,
-0.3527372479438782,
-0.24582162499427795,
-0.10047999769449234,
-0.7486485838890076,
0.36055636405944824,
0.008721786551177502,
0.6410667300224304,
-0.25683847069740295,
0.153975248336792,
0.7911777496337891,
-0.4174126982688904,
1.059736728668213,
-0.6408709287643433,
-0.15676124393939972,
0.4961105287075043,
0.201532781124115,
0.18937206268310547,
-0.0049780202098190784,
0.22111885249614716,
0.35658836364746094,
0.04949904605746269,
-0.09043526649475098,
-0.726746678352356,
0.35573795437812805,
-0.5950598120689392,
-0.19582335650920868,
-0.45367372035980225,
-0.06590079516172409,
-0.35796022415161133,
0.1957121193408966,
0.280370831489563,
0.6550763845443726,
-0.09411398321390152,
0.061044659465551376,
0.6421047449111938,
0.10813082009553909,
0.43528640270233154,
0.6502063274383545,
-0.03288853168487549,
-0.24932627379894257,
1.2810204029083252,
0.47961100935935974,
0.005048668012022972,
0.40167680382728577,
0.2495124489068985,
-0.616584062576294,
-0.36585476994514465,
0.09532803297042847,
0.18133284151554108,
-0.70687335729599,
0.16690902411937714,
-0.5427229404449463,
-0.13308550417423248,
-0.6310132145881653,
0.2778260409832001,
-0.15144863724708557,
-0.49181562662124634,
-0.6079303026199341,
-0.2931515872478485,
0.1307777762413025,
0.5581838488578796,
-0.4470721185207367,
0.44182124733924866,
-0.8886678814888,
0.47970619797706604,
0.2387949675321579,
0.1856101006269455,
-0.1517670899629593,
-0.27374598383903503,
0.011465583927929401,
-0.11329692602157593,
-0.06664012372493744,
-1.5030856132507324,
0.36694079637527466,
0.4994231164455414,
0.6574240326881409,
0.6186131834983826,
0.1510952264070511,
0.550790011882782,
-0.5149670839309692,
0.6211686134338379,
0.22290150821208954,
-1.1820003986358643,
0.7020220756530762,
-0.1884244829416275,
-0.02709270268678665,
0.2617754638195038,
0.4120173752307892,
-0.6665288209915161,
-0.39032238721847534,
-0.8721848726272583,
-0.8727424144744873,
0.7165600657463074,
0.14693625271320343,
-0.21525982022285461,
-0.21377916634082794,
0.1081099733710289,
0.003967239987105131,
0.3790530264377594,
-0.503667414188385,
-0.16134925186634064,
-0.5595143437385559,
-0.2163085788488388,
-0.26461440324783325,
-0.18893727660179138,
-0.17837867140769958,
-0.21460841596126556,
0.24514439702033997,
0.1895633339881897,
0.6083825826644897,
0.06005515158176422,
-0.46433794498443604,
0.2978203296661377,
0.3817965090274811,
0.7763442397117615,
0.3031245768070221,
-0.05679508298635483,
0.6971197128295898,
-0.21447837352752686,
-0.6151432394981384,
0.5502986311912537,
0.026658006012439728,
0.32733428478240967,
0.11525392532348633,
0.6215419769287109,
0.683629035949707,
0.19273680448532104,
-0.1687764823436737,
0.3978135585784912,
0.0890486016869545,
-0.2045489251613617,
-0.4725690186023712,
0.0586206428706646,
-0.09866160154342651,
0.24745142459869385,
0.2947157621383667,
-0.0771193876862526,
0.30867132544517517,
-0.6082006692886353,
0.33013394474983215,
0.2063809484243393,
-0.3895527124404907,
-0.905579686164856,
0.37331530451774597,
0.42986536026000977,
-0.5882124900817871,
0.5145835280418396,
-0.6538796424865723,
-0.2539644241333008,
0.41249507665634155,
0.17327266931533813,
0.891281008720398,
-0.6113531589508057,
0.4640892744064331,
0.020401235669851303,
0.1721242070198059,
0.19256307184696198,
0.6757284998893738,
-0.5900601744651794,
-0.7576514482498169,
-0.22137127816677094,
-0.6712390184402466,
-0.10211331397294998,
0.1315365582704544,
-0.7791410088539124,
0.2511143684387207,
-0.730697512626648,
-0.2724131643772125,
0.5127233266830444,
-0.3746129870414734,
-0.3141125440597534,
0.022385206073522568,
0.2809033989906311,
0.37389883399009705,
-1.2302696704864502,
0.9345650672912598,
0.5182833075523376,
-0.2138156294822693,
-0.5598053336143494,
-0.15427546203136444,
0.3659898638725281,
-0.5160031914710999,
0.9814413785934448,
0.198163703083992,
-0.40639376640319824,
0.15502123534679413,
-0.4091223180294037,
-0.8578493595123291,
0.6833459138870239,
0.15820038318634033,
-0.731013834476471,
0.2523816227912903,
0.31522566080093384,
0.5792022943496704,
-0.11180877685546875,
0.1241041049361229,
0.6576067209243774,
0.44874829053878784,
-0.11725516617298126,
-0.9996510148048401,
-0.19367818534374237,
-0.23444288969039917,
-0.2976240813732147,
0.2599037289619446,
-0.3194549083709717,
0.7598047852516174,
0.13627083599567413,
-0.6559624671936035,
-0.3391953706741333,
0.5503710508346558,
0.17644010484218597,
0.5875880122184753,
0.3859023451805115,
0.02691764570772648,
1.0295207500457764,
-0.25462302565574646,
0.3890736699104309,
-0.20879200100898743,
0.07889560610055923,
1.0188175439834595,
-0.42533501982688904,
0.5125161409378052,
0.25829559564590454,
-0.26005011796951294,
0.3164166510105133,
0.7394038438796997,
0.45349374413490295,
0.7256655693054199,
0.32121741771698,
-0.44593676924705505,
-0.1966637521982193,
-0.03706572949886322,
-0.4500959515571594,
0.736838698387146,
0.7270876169204712,
-0.09025271236896515,
-0.04303153231739998,
0.4281850755214691,
-0.21504507958889008,
-0.2446957379579544,
-0.2180100828409195,
0.8787457346916199,
0.11249192804098129,
-0.14530028402805328,
0.6444787979125977,
-0.17458701133728027,
0.15223270654678345,
-0.4228026568889618,
-0.011325333267450333,
0.09075763821601868,
0.009199397638440132,
-0.427499383687973,
-0.44833803176879883,
0.4488796293735504,
-0.2871607840061188,
0.06203516572713852,
-0.4236947298049927,
0.5221874713897705,
-0.22754469513893127,
-0.15694120526313782,
-0.039595961570739746,
0.3650347590446472,
0.5349403023719788,
-0.004006191622465849,
-0.357465922832489,
0.0514061264693737,
-0.37983402609825134,
-0.003151366952806711,
0.1757039874792099,
0.6054397225379944,
-0.4631388783454895,
0.24743220210075378,
0.512483537197113,
0.04406337812542915,
0.29382702708244324,
0.47205817699432373,
0.559903621673584,
-0.8177325129508972,
-0.873722493648529,
-0.6319449543952942,
0.512671172618866,
-0.06176288425922394,
-0.0985613688826561,
0.7070373892784119,
0.20340296626091003,
0.5088871717453003,
0.2069796621799469,
0.5117037296295166,
0.07428008317947388,
0.2949924170970917,
-0.4227098226547241,
0.3946366608142853,
-0.13649460673332214,
0.03466886654496193,
-0.3709768056869507,
-0.7423116564750671,
-0.4044909179210663,
0.7287062406539917,
-0.28009161353111267,
-0.331024169921875,
0.6629015207290649,
0.5076053142547607,
0.24151423573493958,
0.632305920124054,
0.14804236590862274,
0.2310962975025177,
0.13188162446022034,
-0.014261774718761444,
1.2970155477523804,
0.12384491413831711,
0.0716763436794281,
-0.04398590326309204,
-0.7189112305641174,
-0.2527417242527008,
-0.5580518841743469,
-0.385888934135437,
-0.9866002202033997,
-0.3953670561313629,
-0.09703758358955383,
-0.28415149450302124,
0.6261629462242126,
0.8885214924812317,
-0.5615288019180298,
-0.3144252300262451,
-0.4210185408592224,
-0.02044178918004036,
-0.526420533657074,
-0.19775307178497314,
0.14742837846279144,
-0.42652758955955505,
-0.449872225522995,
0.9416268467903137,
0.3371177017688751,
0.4130823314189911,
-0.27317631244659424,
0.09922484308481216,
0.13923615217208862,
0.031338322907686234,
0.7529473304748535,
0.4895186722278595,
-0.4701049029827118,
0.14514264464378357,
0.06334801018238068,
0.4499417245388031,
-0.2151966243982315,
0.8513635396957397,
-0.586536169052124,
0.2637052834033966,
0.42222800850868225,
-0.14019875228405,
0.4007630944252014,
-0.24868720769882202,
0.14186495542526245,
-1.0548557043075562,
0.6841490864753723,
0.3751911520957947,
0.09510254859924316,
0.000046462693717330694,
-0.4370458424091339,
-0.049069587141275406,
0.4196077287197113,
-0.17232783138751984,
-1.0882760286331177,
0.5834592580795288,
-0.8628360629081726,
-0.37442341446876526,
0.7616421580314636,
0.15361922979354858,
-0.3249310553073883,
-0.4536079466342926,
0.12922772765159607,
0.5360245108604431,
-0.1459561288356781,
0.5078021287918091,
0.797977864742279,
-0.7840253710746765,
-0.28904178738594055,
-0.2999737560749054,
0.5385645627975464,
-0.029983822256326675,
-0.6227830052375793,
0.08799183368682861,
0.5548606514930725,
0.04595315083861351,
0.4861947298049927,
0.9175567030906677,
-0.22502166032791138,
0.02159019187092781,
0.03181396797299385,
0.021382734179496765,
-0.017473381012678146,
-0.7378730773925781,
-0.4835968017578125,
0.4125594198703766,
0.05828084051609039,
-0.727080762386322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03521v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03521v1
|
BiVert: Bidirectional Vocabulary Evaluation using Relations for Machine Translation
| 2024-03-06T08:02:21 | 2024-03-06T08:02:21 |
Carinne Cherf, Yuval Pinter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural machine translation (NMT) has progressed rapidly in the past few
years, promising improvements and quality translations for different languages.
Evaluation of this task is crucial to determine the quality of the translation.
Overall, insufficient emphasis is placed on the actual sense of the translation
in traditional methods. We propose a bidirectional semantic-based evaluation
method designed to assess the sense distance of the translation from the source
text. This approach employs the comprehensive multilingual encyclopedic
dictionary BabelNet. Through the calculation of the semantic distance between
the source and its back translation of the output, our method introduces a
quantifiable approach that empowers sentence comparison on the same linguistic
level. Factual analysis shows a strong correlation between the average
evaluation scores generated by our method and the human assessments across
various machine translation systems for English-German language pair. Finally,
our method proposes a new multilingual approach to rank MT systems without the
need for parallel corpora.
|
[
-0.10316292941570282,
-0.40688908100128174,
0.2041286677122116,
0.428608775138855,
-0.6372995376586914,
-0.04215236008167267,
-0.5199313759803772,
-0.21133334934711456,
0.2633562982082367,
0.04586005583405495,
-0.39661335945129395,
-0.5145177245140076,
-0.6873141527175903,
0.2820725440979004,
-0.18985311686992645,
0.8364946842193604,
-0.015419852919876575,
0.28171905875205994,
-0.5775591731071472,
-0.4659844934940338,
-0.6170492768287659,
-0.325221985578537,
-0.3544961214065552,
-0.338874489068985,
0.5546664595603943,
-0.024424828588962555,
0.7250008583068848,
0.2296164333820343,
0.9570568799972534,
0.439930260181427,
-0.1042894721031189,
0.1254790872335434,
-0.14969457685947418,
0.20331670343875885,
-0.5416597127914429,
-0.13306675851345062,
-0.34479057788848877,
0.024854345247149467,
0.7094418406486511,
0.8326963782310486,
0.041903186589479446,
0.1476072520017624,
0.006011351011693478,
0.8169621229171753,
-0.3572581112384796,
-0.006374260876327753,
-0.5601307153701782,
0.08826632052659988,
-0.17351007461547852,
-0.2653113603591919,
-0.27358293533325195,
-0.25976917147636414,
0.2862618565559387,
-0.30114465951919556,
-0.011832951568067074,
0.1400977522134781,
1.1817833185195923,
0.26915213465690613,
-0.5502667427062988,
-0.27490514516830444,
-0.4547407925128937,
0.6169643402099609,
-0.6914005875587463,
0.7685710191726685,
0.07286840677261353,
0.35438576340675354,
0.14908236265182495,
-0.5974516868591309,
-0.6690056920051575,
-0.5731772780418396,
-0.010140106081962585,
0.6254608035087585,
0.0017765476368367672,
-0.1876411736011505,
-0.19758795201778412,
0.3709944188594818,
-0.790360689163208,
-0.2292645275592804,
-0.2635989785194397,
-0.1726071685552597,
0.41111987829208374,
-0.2062598466873169,
0.37211787700653076,
-0.6829367280006409,
-0.8532395958900452,
-0.35503119230270386,
-0.4302496016025543,
-0.37637150287628174,
0.41473647952079773,
0.28901925683021545,
-0.10716268420219421,
0.8400136232376099,
-0.08822549879550934,
0.5381987690925598,
-0.32752522826194763,
0.1803485006093979,
0.4340430498123169,
-0.736762285232544,
-0.14504891633987427,
-0.0024410586338490248,
0.9550017714500427,
0.8490200042724609,
0.10794307291507721,
-0.5611876249313354,
-0.28393128514289856,
0.018932590261101723,
0.21038323640823364,
-0.7370385527610779,
0.09274695813655853,
-0.2220996916294098,
-0.3614014983177185,
-0.13317592442035675,
0.07163768261671066,
-0.6129222512245178,
-0.02044239267706871,
-0.3734862506389618,
0.5901666283607483,
-0.618541419506073,
-0.2508985698223114,
-0.0003905964840669185,
-0.1455400139093399,
0.09932081401348114,
-0.016001738607883453,
-0.16777992248535156,
0.14672741293907166,
0.6534683108329773,
1.0205327272415161,
-0.2428852915763855,
-0.6358495354652405,
-0.26897379755973816,
-0.006303578149527311,
-0.17007020115852356,
0.7058635354042053,
0.020122073590755463,
-0.235270693898201,
-0.29590046405792236,
-0.14925946295261383,
-0.24900616705417633,
-0.5671064257621765,
0.5649130940437317,
-0.8115739822387695,
0.4727798402309418,
0.026800571009516716,
-0.2847174406051636,
-0.34268635511398315,
0.5137624740600586,
-0.40161699056625366,
0.9267558455467224,
0.39197659492492676,
-0.7641872763633728,
0.3050057291984558,
-0.6262866258621216,
-0.7170936465263367,
0.21623869240283966,
0.2863047122955322,
-0.03147318959236145,
0.04606037959456444,
-0.07547641545534134,
0.10560134053230286,
-0.4881792664527893,
0.36555585265159607,
-0.043285489082336426,
0.046780187636613846,
0.33965638279914856,
-0.7332467436790466,
0.913553774356842,
0.17811299860477448,
-0.20833025872707367,
0.24045854806900024,
-0.6653319001197815,
0.037837572395801544,
-0.11758974939584732,
-0.33854755759239197,
-0.6896543502807617,
-0.1688501238822937,
0.15443721413612366,
0.5633906126022339,
0.5836608409881592,
-0.5722056031227112,
-0.18337330222129822,
-1.0440008640289307,
0.2561609148979187,
0.5805238485336304,
-0.08929350972175598,
0.4390421211719513,
0.27621057629585266,
0.4271678030490875,
0.13636280596256256,
0.13884375989437103,
0.32996562123298645,
-0.3822099566459656,
-0.7092534899711609,
-0.05704842135310173,
0.8305057883262634,
0.6860849857330322,
-1.0757532119750977,
0.6137669682502747,
-0.7026245594024658,
-0.307413250207901,
-0.6724398732185364,
0.11527017503976822,
0.748112678527832,
0.6552942991256714,
0.4741939604282379,
-0.4712088704109192,
-0.32009920477867126,
-1.0005663633346558,
-0.2597242593765259,
-0.12872406840324402,
-0.14675074815750122,
0.06711558997631073,
0.43624645471572876,
-0.2620849609375,
0.5514477491378784,
-0.1695536971092224,
0.06126437336206436,
0.040826283395290375,
0.11276796460151672,
0.23770393431186676,
0.28698301315307617,
0.24917152523994446,
-0.8324292898178101,
-0.4137716293334961,
0.3881814181804657,
-0.7478041648864746,
-0.05129653215408325,
0.16222792863845825,
-0.5795703530311584,
0.17971991002559662,
0.16290028393268585,
-0.6224228143692017,
0.21563737094402313,
0.6647192239761353,
-0.592462420463562,
0.43789148330688477,
-0.33742162585258484,
0.23814451694488525,
-1.3223532438278198,
0.370774507522583,
-0.21082669496536255,
-0.15085116028785706,
-0.21775969862937927,
0.2942310571670532,
0.20284663140773773,
0.08917438983917236,
-0.38947275280952454,
0.42790883779525757,
-0.2976440489292145,
-0.2833837568759918,
0.07919920235872269,
0.8145943284034729,
0.23552265763282776,
0.2472856491804123,
-0.1574288010597229,
0.7364372611045837,
0.041251324117183685,
-0.3940398097038269,
0.7425843477249146,
0.333391398191452,
-0.22972846031188965,
0.9928943514823914,
-0.6473120450973511,
0.09490284323692322,
0.10038881748914719,
-0.3292742073535919,
-1.146661400794983,
0.25994059443473816,
0.21520297229290009,
-0.8679128289222717,
0.4145672023296356,
-0.012441548518836498,
-0.5743131637573242,
-0.22958479821681976,
-0.09447161108255386,
0.28775399923324585,
0.10469137132167816,
-0.2798030972480774,
0.21909263730049133,
0.01177216973155737,
-0.11310440301895142,
-0.5005961656570435,
-0.6017726063728333,
0.44022253155708313,
-0.034800656139850616,
-0.8939421772956848,
0.2543012797832489,
0.08467830717563629,
-0.3139914870262146,
0.045091621577739716,
-0.2465372383594513,
-0.004284077323973179,
0.1913749873638153,
-0.02848353609442711,
0.520606517791748,
-0.2874400317668915,
0.3197876214981079,
0.25537165999412537,
-0.30002638697624207,
0.15211346745491028,
-0.3116745948791504,
0.42448174953460693,
-0.4146680235862732,
-0.3236284554004669,
-0.020636599510908127,
0.1274619847536087,
0.546924352645874,
-0.5296477675437927,
0.5243642330169678,
0.6702340841293335,
-0.20189809799194336,
0.1405128389596939,
-0.23610275983810425,
-0.13890209794044495,
-0.37579745054244995,
0.4898439347743988,
-0.5272122621536255,
-0.32560354471206665,
0.1543191522359848,
-0.05807405337691307,
-0.24991892278194427,
0.6207802891731262,
0.6244622468948364,
0.010792180895805359,
0.6014753580093384,
0.25872310996055603,
0.1424824744462967,
-0.15216223895549774,
-0.15465348958969116,
0.3975626528263092,
-0.8951169848442078,
-0.36526253819465637,
-0.5312761664390564,
-0.32404813170433044,
-0.5021689534187317,
-0.414749413728714,
0.39562320709228516,
0.2514207661151886,
0.0023699169978499413,
0.7619503140449524,
-0.4336555004119873,
0.0993037074804306,
0.5537503361701965,
-0.120147705078125,
0.3847919702529907,
-0.05925291031599045,
-0.6355625987052917,
-0.04548700526356697,
-0.5171690583229065,
-0.46041640639305115,
0.7357659339904785,
0.08578546345233917,
-0.07087847590446472,
0.5268592834472656,
0.5548882484436035,
0.14448656141757965,
0.4885680079460144,
-1.1424596309661865,
0.5933356881141663,
-0.06845264881849289,
-0.46517834067344666,
-0.4880934953689575,
-0.6621699929237366,
-1.019904375076294,
0.5396998524665833,
0.0305846706032753,
-0.22109298408031464,
-0.1174529567360878,
-0.4883011281490326,
-0.019757572561502457,
-0.23120713233947754,
-0.821258008480072,
1.039657711982727,
-0.3517521023750305,
-0.5503640174865723,
-0.2585374414920807,
-0.8989371657371521,
0.038443490862846375,
0.1621403694152832,
0.0015659480122849345,
-0.25284039974212646,
-0.21786247193813324,
0.871015727519989,
-0.5065475106239319,
0.21224413812160492,
-0.08967018127441406,
0.01835777796804905,
-0.12641091644763947,
0.39206773042678833,
0.0017892292235046625,
0.03054090403020382,
-0.39622312784194946,
0.5033552050590515,
0.4293014109134674,
-0.2263079732656479,
-0.6536301374435425,
0.7660719156265259,
-0.5890254378318787,
-0.12712056934833527,
-0.3957734704017639,
-0.671858012676239,
-0.45202839374542236,
0.6039413809776306,
0.2811807096004486,
0.2634285092353821,
-0.2597619593143463,
0.06564889848232269,
0.005115683656185865,
-0.22027477622032166,
0.40322139859199524,
0.5782787799835205,
-0.06033790111541748,
-0.5834937691688538,
0.8526484966278076,
0.10480129718780518,
0.11914654076099396,
0.6978992819786072,
0.4776613414287567,
-0.7969147562980652,
-0.37676382064819336,
-0.8282812237739563,
0.31144797801971436,
-0.5695086121559143,
-0.43965116143226624,
-0.20734553039073944,
0.06095239520072937,
-0.37538549304008484,
0.017928268760442734,
-0.41559529304504395,
-0.40802478790283203,
0.2829091548919678,
0.0650620087981224,
0.20292967557907104,
0.37054258584976196,
0.117970310151577,
0.02318590320646763,
-0.7451108694076538,
0.06745339184999466,
0.07208740711212158,
0.4475488066673279,
-0.1358899623155594,
-0.6614302396774292,
-0.2693275809288025,
0.1278086006641388,
-0.3307882845401764,
-0.9715157747268677,
0.6044418215751648,
-0.03354761749505997,
0.33586829900741577,
0.25660425424575806,
-0.05640258640050888,
0.6753962635993958,
-0.6289359927177429,
0.5661506652832031,
0.41143083572387695,
-1.0093156099319458,
0.3860572874546051,
-0.07476884126663208,
0.049473244696855545,
0.6666372418403625,
0.3801790475845337,
-0.753748893737793,
0.04748651385307312,
-0.5465745329856873,
-0.8051192760467529,
0.26668500900268555,
0.31000953912734985,
0.16321802139282227,
-0.22822999954223633,
0.04336954280734062,
-0.27972444891929626,
0.3755611181259155,
-0.3730093538761139,
-0.20819227397441864,
-0.28937238454818726,
-0.2958674430847168,
-0.2889697253704071,
0.05924072116613388,
-0.06989248096942902,
-0.3958975374698639,
0.48952504992485046,
0.038037460297346115,
0.39246633648872375,
0.17932826280593872,
-0.4468361735343933,
0.11948584020137787,
0.3469332158565521,
0.5066956877708435,
0.705467939376831,
-0.31965145468711853,
0.3875923454761505,
0.2624262273311615,
-0.43412619829177856,
0.02138575166463852,
0.26298850774765015,
-0.1630014032125473,
0.4207819402217865,
0.37102726101875305,
0.5094290375709534,
0.3673170804977417,
-0.4441191852092743,
0.9871742129325867,
0.21526359021663666,
-0.045874662697315216,
-0.06027217209339142,
-0.7287739515304565,
0.35661783814430237,
0.05066360905766487,
-0.26431068778038025,
0.27030041813850403,
0.3972479999065399,
-0.30882713198661804,
0.22417907416820526,
0.3026972711086273,
-0.6429900527000427,
-0.40261372923851013,
0.20498311519622803,
0.20036648213863373,
-0.4277653396129608,
0.8073469400405884,
-0.3394660949707031,
-0.716377854347229,
0.455959677696228,
0.4247605502605438,
0.9617823958396912,
-0.38112425804138184,
0.1009363904595375,
0.4558938145637512,
0.5212640166282654,
0.29211047291755676,
0.048896584659814835,
-0.05947459861636162,
-0.7203110456466675,
-0.5805785655975342,
-0.9544777274131775,
-0.08003024756908417,
-0.4373290538787842,
-0.7394939661026001,
0.22184795141220093,
-0.030115710571408272,
-0.024535706266760826,
-0.06289014965295792,
0.10645829886198044,
-0.5740938186645508,
-0.0424247644841671,
-0.15995566546916962,
0.8068931102752686,
-0.5316077470779419,
0.8277744054794312,
0.745268702507019,
-0.48530539870262146,
-0.560052752494812,
-0.040540263056755066,
-0.3780992329120636,
-0.7782506346702576,
1.0713719129562378,
-0.02963658981025219,
-0.39472144842147827,
-0.06586228311061859,
0.0873430147767067,
-0.5442506670951843,
0.905353307723999,
0.21296602487564087,
-0.34157925844192505,
0.16934968531131744,
0.10998876392841339,
0.7478852272033691,
0.20112504065036774,
0.3983471691608429,
0.3883380591869354,
0.5867114663124084,
0.0841047540307045,
-1.0495325326919556,
0.019223935902118683,
-0.5095817446708679,
0.30503809452056885,
0.39150604605674744,
-0.4587882161140442,
0.5367907285690308,
0.09536785632371902,
-0.32732921838760376,
-0.0725531131029129,
0.6789419054985046,
-0.2746124565601349,
0.4798969030380249,
0.4001089334487915,
0.6129552721977234,
0.4649341404438019,
0.03230349346995354,
0.9798817038536072,
-0.5300310254096985,
0.5647308826446533,
1.1320507526397705,
-0.4647374153137207,
1.227418303489685,
0.8239163160324097,
-0.4062310457229614,
0.4177965819835663,
0.2969381511211395,
0.08352166414260864,
0.4799481928348541,
0.42382708191871643,
-0.2196456491947174,
0.034428779035806656,
0.07604961097240448,
-0.1934967190027237,
0.5704528093338013,
0.24196121096611023,
-0.26413729786872864,
-0.525320827960968,
0.18218524754047394,
0.0637541115283966,
0.30339688062667847,
0.07439199835062027,
0.7408217191696167,
0.09440118074417114,
-0.7617079019546509,
0.8657437562942505,
0.41311517357826233,
0.5370056629180908,
-0.44046342372894287,
0.09508739411830902,
-0.27860331535339355,
0.17961134016513824,
0.07680164277553558,
-0.665172815322876,
0.7363596558570862,
-0.10571244359016418,
-0.10288853198289871,
-0.04761642590165138,
0.5797396302223206,
-0.48314395546913147,
-0.42675498127937317,
0.5211091041564941,
0.7773560285568237,
0.34218186140060425,
-0.20711708068847656,
-0.8609804511070251,
-0.43717753887176514,
-0.3402681350708008,
-0.1240980252623558,
0.15756165981292725,
0.6655954718589783,
-0.011347075924277306,
0.36670100688934326,
0.6103638410568237,
0.0815146192908287,
0.05854305624961853,
0.1728644073009491,
0.5959177613258362,
-0.38798826932907104,
-0.23325830698013306,
-0.8460301756858826,
0.15063881874084473,
-0.14981889724731445,
-0.5027883052825928,
1.1654473543167114,
0.7172686457633972,
0.9859949946403503,
-0.0456162765622139,
0.3641546070575714,
-0.18701355159282684,
0.46695375442504883,
-0.3415756821632385,
0.8181175589561462,
-0.551803469657898,
0.10953862220048904,
-0.25044578313827515,
-0.9670413732528687,
-0.40715858340263367,
0.6373103260993958,
-0.6311467289924622,
-0.09248989075422287,
1.1500931978225708,
0.9536892771720886,
-0.18495525419712067,
-0.18495303392410278,
0.631945788860321,
0.1468227207660675,
-0.2449953705072403,
0.4902176856994629,
0.8670949935913086,
-0.7361453175544739,
0.5186452269554138,
-0.4226416349411011,
-0.24668669700622559,
-0.14108999073505402,
-0.817707359790802,
-0.6499027609825134,
-0.6810035109519958,
-0.18812528252601624,
-0.6587351560592651,
0.1283923238515854,
0.8477246165275574,
0.43842625617980957,
-0.5659075975418091,
-0.41347306966781616,
0.06460404396057129,
0.17313149571418762,
-0.5398751497268677,
-0.20415076613426208,
0.7378178238868713,
-0.39016860723495483,
-0.6796937584877014,
0.368002712726593,
0.47688397765159607,
-0.36836758255958557,
-0.35516953468322754,
-0.2326032966375351,
-0.517811119556427,
-0.14077818393707275,
1.2304058074951172,
-0.3486956059932709,
-0.606691837310791,
-0.14568255841732025,
0.03838964179158211,
-0.27688950300216675,
0.03513258323073387,
0.3848356008529663,
-0.5018879175186157,
0.6659078001976013,
0.9124258160591125,
0.5769972205162048,
0.1850755661725998,
-0.13785651326179504,
0.3298044502735138,
-0.7291992902755737,
0.12339447438716888,
0.3399559259414673,
0.18812568485736847,
0.4629356861114502,
-0.16063331067562103,
0.5727559328079224,
0.5585755109786987,
-0.253390908241272,
-0.6498449444770813,
0.06136490777134895,
-1.1898754835128784,
-0.19155052304267883,
1.1162313222885132,
-0.3533582389354706,
-0.36641380190849304,
-0.01528945006430149,
-0.10387174785137177,
0.5421746969223022,
0.040772680193185806,
0.5049147605895996,
0.5831142067909241,
0.409950852394104,
0.03985154628753662,
-0.6470425128936768,
-0.049882445484399796,
0.5697999596595764,
-0.5734460949897766,
-0.2764870226383209,
0.298007607460022,
0.213063046336174,
0.3732667863368988,
0.02216968685388565,
-0.4765482246875763,
0.12120993435382843,
-0.007210536394268274,
0.4303871989250183,
-0.042697492986917496,
-0.29073262214660645,
-0.4266480505466461,
-0.03862897679209709,
0.05865642428398132,
-0.39838773012161255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03516v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03516v1
|
Unsupervised Multilingual Dense Retrieval via Generative Pseudo Labeling
| 2024-03-06T07:49:06 | 2024-03-06T07:49:06 |
Chao-Wei Huang, Chen-An Li, Tsu-Yuan Hsu, Chen-Yu Hsu, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Dense retrieval methods have demonstrated promising performance in
multilingual information retrieval, where queries and documents can be in
different languages. However, dense retrievers typically require a substantial
amount of paired data, which poses even greater challenges in multilingual
scenarios. This paper introduces UMR, an Unsupervised Multilingual dense
Retriever trained without any paired data. Our approach leverages the sequence
likelihood estimation capabilities of multilingual language models to acquire
pseudo labels for training dense retrievers. We propose a two-stage framework
which iteratively improves the performance of multilingual dense retrievers.
Experimental results on two benchmark datasets show that UMR outperforms
supervised baselines, showcasing the potential of training multilingual
retrievers without paired data, thereby enhancing their practicality. Our
source code, data, and models are publicly available at
https://github.com/MiuLab/UMR
|
[
-0.23631258308887482,
-0.5332236886024475,
0.37003839015960693,
-0.017496593296527863,
-0.3720647692680359,
0.06714849174022675,
-0.2666683495044708,
-0.24932806193828583,
0.20924605429172516,
0.4420778155326843,
0.04513471573591232,
-0.27432021498680115,
-0.3345226049423218,
0.10655369609594345,
-0.27841153740882874,
1.0148756504058838,
0.29987698793411255,
0.3484417796134949,
-0.09673912078142166,
-0.3869636356830597,
-0.2661329507827759,
-0.7371864318847656,
-0.3947983980178833,
-0.3698197603225708,
0.6988509297370911,
0.631621778011322,
0.5948848128318787,
0.2479766309261322,
0.16209764778614044,
0.32211437821388245,
-0.014600638300180435,
0.22430668771266937,
-0.5936064720153809,
0.03516654297709465,
0.09717563539743423,
-0.3825680911540985,
0.1315125972032547,
-0.4622466266155243,
1.0147336721420288,
1.0556671619415283,
-0.454135000705719,
-0.10580070316791534,
0.09502176940441132,
0.762580931186676,
-0.6401547789573669,
-0.11338455975055695,
-0.4603768289089203,
0.18571490049362183,
-0.6671269536018372,
-0.1714724451303482,
-0.5769646763801575,
-0.12038443982601166,
0.14742033183574677,
-0.598278284072876,
0.35364624857902527,
0.19302386045455933,
0.4464300274848938,
-0.10042443126440048,
-0.5578431487083435,
0.043161891400814056,
-0.7663904428482056,
0.8004907965660095,
-0.24305976927280426,
0.8425356149673462,
0.43659666180610657,
0.284370481967926,
-0.012417332269251347,
-0.8128155469894409,
-0.3915805220603943,
0.0200770553201437,
-0.2530670762062073,
0.09706992655992508,
-0.05219707265496254,
-0.205829456448555,
0.09318231046199799,
0.5468127727508545,
-1.0540049076080322,
0.004698588512837887,
-0.26400405168533325,
-0.2171175181865692,
0.40330401062965393,
-0.16214489936828613,
0.23156723380088806,
-0.12915752828121185,
-0.34802624583244324,
-0.24927733838558197,
-0.45990851521492004,
-0.12016728520393372,
0.2965832054615021,
0.3537413477897644,
-0.052641212940216064,
0.8977025747299194,
-0.08700258284807205,
0.8881852030754089,
-0.0672086626291275,
-0.057385459542274475,
0.3944074213504791,
-0.2744007110595703,
0.19908678531646729,
0.1774071753025055,
0.9805556535720825,
-0.05985308811068535,
0.05520648881793022,
-0.5875192880630493,
-0.358938992023468,
-0.15108463168144226,
-0.04864869266748428,
-0.7690832614898682,
-0.6086488366127014,
-0.019791502505540848,
-0.43567588925361633,
0.3517330288887024,
0.22193481028079987,
-0.9719126224517822,
-0.11772332340478897,
-0.203200563788414,
0.44296371936798096,
-0.38355281949043274,
-0.38687974214553833,
0.13835115730762482,
-0.1423250138759613,
0.1514819711446762,
-0.1404934525489807,
-0.6512651443481445,
-0.02749556675553322,
0.09052126109600067,
0.6435842514038086,
0.04995289072394371,
-0.21965859830379486,
-0.6904557347297668,
0.2574465870857239,
-0.2618406116962433,
0.771433413028717,
-0.6376206874847412,
-0.5878903865814209,
-0.03273055702447891,
-0.016754867509007454,
-0.13836173713207245,
-0.5931676626205444,
0.4152698516845703,
-0.9335664510726929,
0.22919467091560364,
-0.45446211099624634,
-0.4795394241809845,
0.03287896886467934,
-0.0005336804315447807,
-0.8123767375946045,
1.420224666595459,
-0.07495157420635223,
-1.0431487560272217,
0.19587525725364685,
-0.2602923810482025,
-0.7895354628562927,
0.304304301738739,
-0.22461974620819092,
-0.27667856216430664,
0.0601159930229187,
0.1507551521062851,
0.22166700661182404,
-0.3336385190486908,
0.4521624743938446,
-0.3216163218021393,
-0.5157793760299683,
0.1715870350599289,
-0.26790013909339905,
0.6513364315032959,
0.36344456672668457,
-0.10302764922380447,
-0.02806198224425316,
-0.9214065670967102,
0.16212080419063568,
0.23263490200042725,
-0.4781773090362549,
-0.6322479248046875,
0.026078086346387863,
0.47147807478904724,
0.15488868951797485,
0.20890988409519196,
-0.5526201725006104,
0.17963922023773193,
-0.21948327124118805,
0.1125413253903389,
0.22872081398963928,
-0.19352081418037415,
0.8320966362953186,
0.06878113001585007,
0.1903112232685089,
-0.022954043000936508,
-0.21574442088603973,
-0.08220131695270538,
-0.3768374025821686,
-0.8063061237335205,
-0.32613062858581543,
0.4978320002555847,
0.6474848389625549,
-1.32811439037323,
0.2938917577266693,
-0.26214078068733215,
-0.2239111214876175,
-0.7589895129203796,
0.5221167206764221,
0.7656503319740295,
0.5504419207572937,
0.6411005258560181,
-0.286817729473114,
-0.7684723734855652,
-0.719875156879425,
-0.048511311411857605,
-0.014039714820683002,
-0.21993698179721832,
0.20135846734046936,
0.2564376890659332,
-0.31446143984794617,
0.746908962726593,
-0.4591185748577118,
-0.49119657278060913,
-0.46982476115226746,
0.541468620300293,
-0.005267726723104715,
0.508712112903595,
0.2741287350654602,
-1.1799771785736084,
-0.5007697939872742,
0.07804341614246368,
-1.0793882608413696,
0.14521369338035583,
0.22206278145313263,
-0.13352185487747192,
0.2099602222442627,
0.5046002268791199,
-0.3939516246318817,
0.1272868663072586,
0.27256888151168823,
0.18722103536128998,
0.06113497540354729,
-0.5799789428710938,
0.11379215121269226,
-1.0480791330337524,
0.43660399317741394,
0.024328360334038734,
-0.004841162823140621,
-0.5277950763702393,
-0.08872825652360916,
0.2963443398475647,
-0.15862365067005157,
-0.3534618616104126,
0.7674980759620667,
-0.870136559009552,
-0.34827175736427307,
-0.09204462915658951,
-0.054207611829042435,
0.02599012479186058,
0.0041416906751692295,
0.5037547945976257,
0.8422365188598633,
0.4489433169364929,
-0.610561192035675,
0.08006752282381058,
0.30824992060661316,
-0.4618920087814331,
0.590904951095581,
-0.6754056811332703,
0.3388296365737915,
-0.48944419622421265,
0.20292866230010986,
-0.9031471014022827,
-0.24348464608192444,
-0.081410713493824,
-0.19404052197933197,
0.6262571811676025,
-0.5048127174377441,
-0.9103636741638184,
-0.6423977613449097,
0.038403138518333435,
0.7243714928627014,
0.3238828480243683,
-0.6556872129440308,
0.4559043347835541,
0.5085332989692688,
-0.0145627586171031,
-0.6399210095405579,
-0.8546560406684875,
0.028941532596945763,
-0.20549152791500092,
-0.3201834261417389,
0.3544224798679352,
-0.3271537721157074,
-0.07627324759960175,
-0.14236238598823547,
0.08635953813791275,
-0.41340604424476624,
-0.28036341071128845,
-0.24075941741466522,
0.12253987789154053,
-0.19095264375209808,
-0.08444101363420486,
-0.06603296101093292,
-0.3168298900127411,
-0.3810456395149231,
-0.4524564743041992,
0.38431933522224426,
-0.053371917456388474,
-0.22574545443058014,
-0.04325103387236595,
0.5144997239112854,
0.010747406631708145,
-0.5828577280044556,
0.7983125448226929,
0.9469469785690308,
-0.27365460991859436,
0.16120781004428864,
-0.8368566632270813,
-0.17110131680965424,
-0.4327384829521179,
0.13175082206726074,
-0.6858664751052856,
-1.013045310974121,
0.4010930359363556,
0.22235402464866638,
-0.3510512709617615,
0.13652440905570984,
0.39076918363571167,
-0.1753949522972107,
1.038277506828308,
0.7408844828605652,
-0.18413704633712769,
0.30146539211273193,
-0.2526390254497528,
0.27246519923210144,
-0.5941039323806763,
-0.6438775062561035,
-0.574116051197052,
0.015691019594669342,
-0.43384984135627747,
-0.46362024545669556,
0.4729483127593994,
0.4250885248184204,
0.09624824672937393,
0.22841781377792358,
-0.3210675120353699,
0.6299889087677002,
0.6774871945381165,
0.07330502569675446,
0.3977108895778656,
0.18356452882289886,
-0.5030893683433533,
-0.33001184463500977,
-0.995966374874115,
-0.16415604948997498,
0.9861992597579956,
-0.4284423887729645,
0.722480833530426,
0.26810207962989807,
0.5671725869178772,
0.18696165084838867,
0.15054090321063995,
-0.4265938401222229,
0.2252476066350937,
-0.12238213419914246,
-0.6331173181533813,
-0.05945586785674095,
-0.7377861142158508,
-1.225400686264038,
0.7670777440071106,
-0.047562308609485626,
-0.6124568581581116,
0.28696587681770325,
0.09372764825820923,
-0.17458567023277283,
0.19363988935947418,
-0.6322588324546814,
0.9504874348640442,
-0.4827856123447418,
-0.47805240750312805,
0.16469806432724,
-1.115705132484436,
0.24605390429496765,
-0.3533581793308258,
0.39744827151298523,
0.30130258202552795,
0.2146536111831665,
0.7987048029899597,
-0.21509552001953125,
0.6416714191436768,
-0.19308844208717346,
0.055615127086639404,
0.31123587489128113,
0.01184491254389286,
0.3806867003440857,
0.08661403506994247,
-0.25841641426086426,
0.16875775158405304,
-0.09868555516004562,
-0.6704792976379395,
-0.2314668744802475,
0.8572365045547485,
-0.658775269985199,
0.014650363475084305,
-0.536690890789032,
-0.5359779596328735,
-0.14971017837524414,
0.5300304293632507,
0.612762987613678,
0.3699500262737274,
-0.42300400137901306,
0.20679335296154022,
0.8841914534568787,
-0.07822846621274948,
0.6046209931373596,
0.7498283386230469,
-0.09821229428052902,
-0.3964180648326874,
1.0750339031219482,
0.13535761833190918,
-0.24048806726932526,
0.8776183128356934,
-0.03960347920656204,
-0.8385133147239685,
-0.3547496795654297,
-0.7242209315299988,
0.23568248748779297,
-0.5186071395874023,
-0.24199919402599335,
-1.0016963481903076,
0.17531925439834595,
-0.30077558755874634,
0.05001698434352875,
-0.4597731828689575,
-0.19543620944023132,
-0.36514878273010254,
0.07813180983066559,
0.05653531104326248,
0.4806996285915375,
-0.2736809253692627,
0.3065977096557617,
-0.8858925700187683,
0.5460887551307678,
0.11307933926582336,
0.1291077435016632,
-0.10391648858785629,
-0.6318830251693726,
-0.23291683197021484,
0.06716201454401016,
0.12081360816955566,
-0.5863338708877563,
0.40458402037620544,
0.30801087617874146,
0.5958805084228516,
0.5259965658187866,
0.2486850917339325,
0.9755867719650269,
-0.5696321129798889,
0.31573987007141113,
0.19038330018520355,
-0.5481720566749573,
0.4130900800228119,
-0.12828849256038666,
0.24533717334270477,
0.7299267053604126,
0.7215612530708313,
-0.2918481230735779,
0.27145278453826904,
-0.21733415126800537,
-0.9137645363807678,
0.62807297706604,
-0.019100623205304146,
-0.007728429976850748,
-0.30544376373291016,
0.2097894251346588,
0.08981560915708542,
0.26686644554138184,
-0.7876841425895691,
-0.44020718336105347,
-0.1526249349117279,
0.05502421781420708,
-0.5676940083503723,
-0.5689252614974976,
0.10740233212709427,
-0.1961323469877243,
0.44118183851242065,
-0.1177179291844368,
0.031004002317786217,
0.08040352910757065,
-0.7589015364646912,
-0.15404103696346283,
0.46286970376968384,
0.13634011149406433,
0.3825099766254425,
-0.35040342807769775,
0.3906172513961792,
-0.17637363076210022,
0.04831757768988609,
0.231904998421669,
0.6766677498817444,
-0.2821846306324005,
0.049988020211458206,
0.025800546631217003,
0.5149330496788025,
0.8233682513237,
-0.7034332156181335,
0.4830102324485779,
0.029454797506332397,
0.15362979471683502,
-0.2230299562215805,
-0.7114322781562805,
0.009096101857721806,
0.15114592015743256,
0.5809918642044067,
-0.2203381508588791,
0.5436365008354187,
-0.22957569360733032,
0.5216020941734314,
0.42135828733444214,
-0.34298408031463623,
-0.4412384629249573,
0.8775699734687805,
-0.09369932115077972,
0.24356836080551147,
0.9789971709251404,
-0.3733956813812256,
-0.3149225115776062,
-0.021727023646235466,
0.8451859354972839,
0.24530810117721558,
-0.428188681602478,
0.3257397711277008,
0.4257428050041199,
0.25892919301986694,
-0.40306422114372253,
0.3266696631908417,
-0.1587929129600525,
-0.7086823582649231,
-0.39749476313591003,
-0.7544434070587158,
0.05681993439793587,
0.0362064465880394,
-0.8634627461433411,
-0.0023951807525008917,
0.006760202813893557,
0.012442462146282196,
-0.10688060522079468,
-0.17132568359375,
-0.5358161926269531,
0.13602028787136078,
0.14374323189258575,
0.44623252749443054,
-0.7093371748924255,
1.0758569240570068,
0.8960021138191223,
-0.6552281975746155,
-0.44063204526901245,
-0.42491215467453003,
0.15480324625968933,
-0.6578645706176758,
0.546945333480835,
0.17360134422779083,
-0.037050239741802216,
0.2963438034057617,
0.016145864501595497,
-0.916165828704834,
0.7063210010528564,
0.46093833446502686,
-0.6567556858062744,
0.04263196885585785,
0.1735934615135193,
0.48591428995132446,
0.12181201577186584,
0.3975713849067688,
0.16784347593784332,
0.46108177304267883,
0.3805760443210602,
-0.5764731168746948,
-0.2967391908168793,
-0.3292730152606964,
0.36138173937797546,
0.4127403795719147,
-0.4187677800655365,
0.6395254731178284,
-0.460953950881958,
-0.3044142425060272,
0.4292048215866089,
0.911760687828064,
0.22255799174308777,
0.2825169265270233,
0.17930041253566742,
0.8856818079948425,
0.827951967716217,
-0.003473458345979452,
1.2872200012207031,
-0.0843302384018898,
0.23543916642665863,
1.1252577304840088,
-0.5560241341590881,
0.9696826338768005,
0.49636051058769226,
-0.03226444870233536,
0.11981680244207382,
0.6172609329223633,
0.15513187646865845,
0.6786920428276062,
-0.07416655123233795,
-0.33313238620758057,
-0.3655620813369751,
-0.4068123996257782,
-0.5952010750770569,
0.3107764422893524,
0.09169302135705948,
-0.07822218537330627,
-0.24088872969150543,
0.21362566947937012,
0.15864935517311096,
0.14381617307662964,
-0.058886248618364334,
0.7021613121032715,
0.1299237757921219,
-0.4679005444049835,
0.6984208822250366,
0.11779055744409561,
0.7992027997970581,
-0.5128306746482849,
-0.02543252892792225,
-0.48509681224823,
0.2784600853919983,
-0.12331783026456833,
-0.5661186575889587,
0.029869120568037033,
-0.10899271816015244,
-0.25153154134750366,
-0.15568435192108154,
0.6089702248573303,
-0.8504573106765747,
-0.6976019740104675,
0.7673202157020569,
0.8111671209335327,
0.20869030058383942,
-0.23445768654346466,
-0.8178356289863586,
0.04419582337141037,
-0.12720683217048645,
-0.08620987087488174,
0.6284139156341553,
0.49476394057273865,
-0.17698507010936737,
0.46436944603919983,
0.8424732685089111,
-0.30814751982688904,
0.2793341279029846,
0.537480354309082,
0.7043587565422058,
-0.5243194699287415,
-0.17513597011566162,
-0.4892268776893616,
0.4320569336414337,
0.2449633628129959,
0.11698698997497559,
0.8177908658981323,
1.1771867275238037,
1.2326655387878418,
-0.08545400202274323,
0.5988749861717224,
-0.13756118714809418,
0.39721596240997314,
-0.47344622015953064,
0.6233634948730469,
-0.748967170715332,
0.09378903359174728,
-0.20632943511009216,
-1.2729923725128174,
-0.5348668098449707,
0.6236200928688049,
-0.10564425587654114,
0.24720579385757446,
0.42376384139060974,
0.7802351117134094,
-0.4542890191078186,
-0.3017388582229614,
0.45198947191238403,
0.1246817409992218,
-0.18673284351825714,
0.39389967918395996,
0.8474118709564209,
-0.46703070402145386,
0.6989852786064148,
-0.5248876810073853,
-0.13839752972126007,
-0.17130419611930847,
-0.5118887424468994,
-0.8616980314254761,
-0.6040934324264526,
-0.11489573121070862,
-0.18946747481822968,
0.1446918100118637,
0.4593735933303833,
0.671346127986908,
-0.8716526031494141,
-0.35054370760917664,
0.20711010694503784,
-0.11993610113859177,
0.16586211323738098,
-0.23281048238277435,
0.2234622687101364,
-0.28890693187713623,
-0.6538077592849731,
0.8123806715011597,
0.13645383715629578,
0.06770782917737961,
0.2772938311100006,
-0.28588753938674927,
-0.62445068359375,
-0.6017708778381348,
0.6083840131759644,
0.7377368807792664,
-0.6595524549484253,
0.24237284064292908,
-0.056608352810144424,
-0.05943486839532852,
0.14594946801662445,
0.8247638940811157,
-0.7107649445533752,
0.700653076171875,
0.24679921567440033,
0.6786832809448242,
0.8646633625030518,
-0.10124877095222473,
0.38915419578552246,
-0.9885095357894897,
0.4428381025791168,
0.06374379992485046,
0.5014424920082092,
0.7541107535362244,
-0.21447061002254486,
0.47479772567749023,
0.2731640636920929,
-0.28412383794784546,
-0.7704823613166809,
-0.07363473623991013,
-0.7948610782623291,
-0.19436757266521454,
1.0081210136413574,
-0.09195196628570557,
0.2517124116420746,
-0.28562507033348083,
-0.04485565051436424,
0.32574912905693054,
-0.4256129860877991,
0.46289560198783875,
0.11298466473817825,
0.2119840383529663,
-0.3725086748600006,
-0.4338756203651428,
0.11028164625167847,
0.614368736743927,
-0.4695921540260315,
-0.32315483689308167,
0.6799094080924988,
0.21275953948497772,
0.08711962401866913,
0.9066001176834106,
-0.29249757528305054,
-0.0826709121465683,
-0.27916213870048523,
0.25579652190208435,
0.3065294027328491,
-0.6366855502128601,
-0.3095293641090393,
0.1046418696641922,
0.04164247587323189,
0.15177641808986664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03514v1
|
CLongEval: A Chinese Benchmark for Evaluating Long-Context Large Language Models
| 2024-03-06T07:43:43 | 2024-03-06T07:43:43 |
Zexuan Qiu, Jingjing Li, Shijue Huang, Wanjun Zhong, Irwin King
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Developing Large Language Models (LLMs) with robust long-context capabilities
has been the recent research focus, resulting in the emergence of long-context
LLMs proficient in Chinese. However, the evaluation of these models remains
underdeveloped due to a lack of benchmarks. To address this gap, we present
CLongEval, a comprehensive Chinese benchmark for evaluating long-context LLMs.
CLongEval is characterized by three key features: (1) Sufficient data volume,
comprising 7 distinct tasks and 7,267 examples; (2) Broad applicability,
accommodating to models with context windows size from 1K to 100K; (3) High
quality, with over 2,000 manually annotated question-answer pairs in addition
to the automatically constructed labels. With CLongEval, we undertake a
comprehensive assessment of 6 open-source long-context LLMs and 2 leading
commercial counterparts that feature both long-context abilities and
proficiency in Chinese. We also provide in-depth analysis based on the
empirical results, trying to shed light on the critical capabilities that
present challenges in long-context settings. The dataset, evaluation scripts,
and model outputs will be released.
|
[
-0.05960601568222046,
-0.6171959042549133,
0.3840569853782654,
0.7063380479812622,
-0.4862949550151825,
-0.29129675030708313,
-0.8984007239341736,
-0.5616642832756042,
-0.20640674233436584,
0.5492242574691772,
-0.07778920233249664,
-0.6679010987281799,
-0.41463708877563477,
0.03015092760324478,
-0.31670108437538147,
0.605050265789032,
-0.05009884014725685,
0.025771547108888626,
-0.14103476703166962,
-0.38444676995277405,
-0.5288756489753723,
-0.4642789363861084,
-0.44630488753318787,
-0.28130608797073364,
0.23462659120559692,
0.08340145647525787,
0.4883422255516052,
0.5823991894721985,
0.34072449803352356,
0.2069849669933319,
-0.10790480673313141,
0.1387893110513687,
-0.5676338076591492,
0.14350320398807526,
-0.02081933245062828,
-0.058435942977666855,
-0.5639987587928772,
-0.09721545875072479,
0.8533674478530884,
0.7799353003501892,
-0.19933462142944336,
0.4879569709300995,
0.5235182046890259,
0.6260740160942078,
-0.5583646297454834,
0.23903483152389526,
-0.6432393789291382,
-0.19605885446071625,
-0.5902720093727112,
0.08918599784374237,
-0.23155629634857178,
-0.5820685029029846,
0.4653550386428833,
-0.26633113622665405,
-0.2394282966852188,
-0.21686670184135437,
0.2663189470767975,
0.09624054282903671,
-0.6589390635490417,
-0.39359360933303833,
-0.25793731212615967,
0.9788529276847839,
-0.9817836880683899,
0.36695244908332825,
0.12806306779384613,
0.4948309361934662,
-0.25556689500808716,
-1.032631754875183,
-0.20778897404670715,
-0.6087958812713623,
-0.014058845117688179,
-0.020346319302916527,
0.3229207396507263,
0.08805125206708908,
0.1689358502626419,
0.39794492721557617,
-0.7716953158378601,
0.13332843780517578,
-0.4079429805278778,
-0.27199995517730713,
0.894149661064148,
0.0514594167470932,
0.1815612018108368,
-0.15518605709075928,
-0.6874794363975525,
0.31834542751312256,
-0.8047972917556763,
0.2514777183532715,
-0.2062184065580368,
0.603722095489502,
-0.035894036293029785,
0.23728743195533752,
-0.14655448496341705,
0.6664823293685913,
-0.3385664224624634,
-0.3546314239501953,
0.3554306626319885,
-0.1916554719209671,
-0.3261801302433014,
0.24685890972614288,
0.7769550085067749,
0.45842522382736206,
0.1639135181903839,
0.05267907679080963,
-0.3355916440486908,
-0.3512934148311615,
-0.2690291106700897,
-1.154673457145691,
-0.09278000146150589,
0.57416832447052,
-0.5336938500404358,
0.06730882823467255,
-0.11208169162273407,
-0.7207995057106018,
-0.6169029474258423,
-0.0329040065407753,
0.1631779968738556,
-0.20734484493732452,
-0.3506009578704834,
0.06559400260448456,
0.03649866580963135,
0.33245518803596497,
0.22546041011810303,
-0.583429217338562,
0.1393502652645111,
0.9826359748840332,
1.0506675243377686,
-0.4750635325908661,
-0.5446068048477173,
-0.5189921259880066,
-0.03706749528646469,
-0.31721240282058716,
0.3476288616657257,
-0.3091388940811157,
-0.4692573547363281,
0.5326424241065979,
0.20552979409694672,
0.039324551820755005,
-0.7936657071113586,
0.9102057814598083,
-0.3593735694885254,
-0.09448811411857605,
-0.22717252373695374,
-0.6023963093757629,
-0.02391614392399788,
0.4330550730228424,
-0.574495255947113,
1.1095271110534668,
0.13124214112758636,
-0.547754168510437,
0.24933312833309174,
-0.5456768870353699,
-0.6000250577926636,
0.4309658110141754,
-0.10749709606170654,
-0.1110447347164154,
-0.12590204179286957,
0.03201131522655487,
0.4527158737182617,
-0.47337982058525085,
0.4938175678253174,
-0.3792814612388611,
-0.4942515194416046,
0.10101831704378128,
-0.48156893253326416,
0.9353229403495789,
0.11414144188165665,
-0.42778459191322327,
0.24295184016227722,
-0.7362895607948303,
0.37419700622558594,
0.06481625139713287,
-0.3741013705730438,
-0.5041444897651672,
-0.03483640402555466,
0.20017530024051666,
0.1974758803844452,
0.8772555589675903,
-0.40867480635643005,
0.04858855903148651,
-0.32946813106536865,
0.8153252005577087,
0.5625531077384949,
-0.3175773024559021,
0.03827787935733795,
-0.019494520500302315,
0.2558458149433136,
-0.10319895297288895,
0.14141805469989777,
-0.24639254808425903,
-0.10685618966817856,
-0.4546405076980591,
-0.2813335657119751,
0.2428112030029297,
0.43232452869415283,
-0.2992601692676544,
0.4254624545574188,
-0.4398249685764313,
-0.7727811336517334,
-0.4695596992969513,
0.4613603353500366,
0.4269077777862549,
0.39518970251083374,
0.4003963768482208,
-0.19486387073993683,
-0.2875223457813263,
-0.8016775250434875,
-0.25525256991386414,
-0.06190541759133339,
-0.26073914766311646,
0.429743230342865,
0.5154539942741394,
-0.14826959371566772,
0.5657888650894165,
-0.30882102251052856,
-0.3900192975997925,
-0.2601057291030884,
-0.19505348801612854,
0.4019670784473419,
0.27192485332489014,
0.43616971373558044,
-0.6093195080757141,
-0.6392804980278015,
0.1549833118915558,
-0.7030564546585083,
-0.2019064873456955,
0.1033845990896225,
0.08794663101434708,
0.21908187866210938,
0.46194136142730713,
-0.6557384133338928,
0.0655834972858429,
0.7649018168449402,
0.1505119502544403,
0.7416616082191467,
-0.16438235342502594,
-0.021193774417042732,
-0.8845207691192627,
0.41419047117233276,
-0.11940324306488037,
-0.24165470898151398,
-0.6283972859382629,
0.26948511600494385,
0.396350622177124,
-0.16052855551242828,
-0.5597137212753296,
0.7012885808944702,
-0.520641028881073,
-0.1455661803483963,
-0.34304821491241455,
0.8211104273796082,
-0.16766513884067535,
0.24959231913089752,
0.12695395946502686,
0.8535779714584351,
0.41069984436035156,
-0.5044317841529846,
0.6319316625595093,
-0.02748100273311138,
-0.7169808149337769,
0.34955260157585144,
-1.0639995336532593,
0.07925430685281754,
0.34120312333106995,
0.47566890716552734,
-0.7867164611816406,
-0.3664260506629944,
-0.16932030022144318,
-0.07643590867519379,
-0.016410989686846733,
-0.1664409339427948,
-0.31145724654197693,
-0.4614783227443695,
-0.4792128801345825,
0.6548823714256287,
0.40892577171325684,
-0.7882317304611206,
0.25940582156181335,
0.32085201144218445,
-0.10725708305835724,
-0.6205368041992188,
-0.6031634211540222,
0.0978536382317543,
-0.3580070734024048,
-0.7902140617370605,
0.36479029059410095,
-0.13192203640937805,
-0.17883454263210297,
-0.4039207696914673,
0.11667447537183762,
-0.10507079213857651,
0.11715924739837646,
0.1331033855676651,
0.03764358535408974,
-0.5761944651603699,
0.23037859797477722,
-0.307537704706192,
0.17127151787281036,
0.16611449420452118,
-0.3208908438682556,
0.5283397436141968,
-0.34434735774993896,
-0.232392355799675,
-0.21606118977069855,
-0.04781273007392883,
0.594004213809967,
-0.4935508966445923,
0.3740808665752411,
0.37059682607650757,
-0.3179832994937897,
-0.6212145686149597,
-0.39740806818008423,
0.19720499217510223,
-0.4816724956035614,
0.6150554418563843,
-0.16481193900108337,
-0.8870677351951599,
0.5114977955818176,
-0.2849152982234955,
0.34152916073799133,
0.22440116107463837,
0.6094604134559631,
0.4745442569255829,
0.6157276034355164,
0.3162323832511902,
-0.48679232597351074,
0.1464414894580841,
0.19680391252040863,
-0.0028520540799945593,
-0.8423429727554321,
0.051813166588544846,
-0.19463808834552765,
0.010699501261115074,
-0.6319667100906372,
-0.41726088523864746,
0.3575989305973053,
0.22901061177253723,
-0.32368600368499756,
0.3594972491264343,
-0.3909735679626465,
0.3971980810165405,
0.2868788242340088,
-0.07980496436357498,
0.25996315479278564,
-0.6094593405723572,
0.13181114196777344,
0.13204547762870789,
-0.26601535081863403,
-0.6700150370597839,
1.0284790992736816,
0.5139638185501099,
0.40530630946159363,
0.18418282270431519,
0.503852903842926,
0.195313960313797,
0.3227609395980835,
-0.6669146418571472,
0.6854214668273926,
-0.3262525200843811,
-0.5931383371353149,
-0.5256547331809998,
-0.17288975417613983,
-0.9245864748954773,
0.42217105627059937,
0.26310259103775024,
-0.6684288382530212,
-0.28147146105766296,
0.08026084303855896,
-0.31151822209358215,
0.055590126663446426,
-0.42198479175567627,
1.0942877531051636,
-0.5646443367004395,
-0.4244888722896576,
-0.12705807387828827,
-0.607390820980072,
0.7131238579750061,
-0.15248006582260132,
0.04892926663160324,
-0.1832309514284134,
-0.10311529785394669,
0.44336333870887756,
-0.3300534784793854,
0.7491899728775024,
-0.27155542373657227,
-0.2834898829460144,
0.45938053727149963,
-0.11654508113861084,
0.43298375606536865,
0.14886850118637085,
-0.4316120743751526,
0.28998222947120667,
0.2871621549129486,
-0.5108675360679626,
-0.4365386366844177,
1.0467078685760498,
-0.5151698589324951,
-0.5955126881599426,
-0.2979317307472229,
-0.2642157971858978,
-0.1974438577890396,
0.534919798374176,
-0.06306248158216476,
0.5516238808631897,
-0.5823054313659668,
0.4218820333480835,
0.3374532461166382,
-0.3140038549900055,
0.5131593942642212,
0.34357747435569763,
-0.47861459851264954,
-0.4433079659938812,
0.720015823841095,
0.19909438490867615,
0.39457622170448303,
-0.049165960401296616,
0.2525455355644226,
-0.32600319385528564,
-0.7813720107078552,
-0.38188448548316956,
0.05744446441531181,
-0.6962815523147583,
0.039704810827970505,
-0.00066078343661502,
-0.5452307462692261,
-0.3615705072879791,
0.060440778732299805,
-0.36902907490730286,
-0.06263977289199829,
0.003936841152608395,
0.16009105741977692,
-0.1460425704717636,
0.44084328413009644,
0.3502534329891205,
0.1147695928812027,
-0.8327546119689941,
-0.037088364362716675,
0.26515763998031616,
0.43095412850379944,
0.2850745916366577,
-0.4986589848995209,
-0.38106217980384827,
0.0503852553665638,
-0.2467382252216339,
-0.3688557744026184,
0.3166109025478363,
0.37543103098869324,
0.49005475640296936,
0.534491240978241,
0.2911573350429535,
0.8336066007614136,
-0.5617395043373108,
1.1902602910995483,
-0.21535396575927734,
-0.9911461472511292,
0.4126223027706146,
-0.37613531947135925,
0.3449614942073822,
0.5954169631004333,
0.193156436085701,
-0.6440514922142029,
-0.05655267462134361,
-0.1453101485967636,
-0.8197977542877197,
0.17163926362991333,
-0.037657640874385834,
0.17974968254566193,
-0.09762372076511383,
0.31654128432273865,
0.1318339705467224,
0.3005307614803314,
-0.7853958606719971,
0.029662789776921272,
-0.23484404385089874,
-0.04141075909137726,
-0.15299049019813538,
-0.30250659584999084,
-0.04897167533636093,
-0.06942874938249588,
0.41216525435447693,
-0.20129959285259247,
-0.38033244013786316,
0.26847708225250244,
-0.32641878724098206,
0.26689597964286804,
0.3699316680431366,
0.8475660681724548,
0.9860197901725769,
-0.3230195641517639,
0.09638164937496185,
0.5396560430526733,
-0.3846215009689331,
-0.39892640709877014,
0.21385441720485687,
0.09515564143657684,
-0.07058674842119217,
0.7010083794593811,
0.4307885766029358,
0.13310952484607697,
-1.0697102546691895,
0.7116211652755737,
0.18094998598098755,
0.09644822031259537,
-0.7476249933242798,
-0.10122326761484146,
0.18616057932376862,
0.31488272547721863,
0.42182600498199463,
-0.5987566709518433,
0.124856136739254,
-0.5393018126487732,
0.20057475566864014,
0.5283766388893127,
-0.43747952580451965,
-0.3744256794452667,
0.46038177609443665,
0.46424633264541626,
-0.06822317838668823,
0.5497336983680725,
0.08430152386426926,
-0.5687409043312073,
0.4524262547492981,
0.5883623957633972,
0.8484529256820679,
-0.26184535026550293,
-0.19031094014644623,
0.5635252594947815,
0.25058138370513916,
-0.22208094596862793,
0.09312308579683304,
-0.07059451937675476,
-0.21397939324378967,
-0.09626014530658722,
-0.5178260803222656,
-0.2542402744293213,
0.38075733184814453,
-0.5291487574577332,
0.3333313763141632,
-0.48299917578697205,
-0.14456483721733093,
-0.32360467314720154,
0.39170458912849426,
-0.27905499935150146,
0.09243497997522354,
0.1549614816904068,
1.2209972143173218,
-0.34798330068588257,
1.0652657747268677,
0.21248935163021088,
-0.02840787172317505,
-0.4932471811771393,
0.17239180207252502,
-0.0982762798666954,
-0.9138938188552856,
0.665130615234375,
0.6533501148223877,
-0.17922838032245636,
-0.3422400951385498,
-0.5339385867118835,
-0.5569414496421814,
1.480541467666626,
0.16001147031784058,
-0.6448996663093567,
0.11106007546186447,
0.36865705251693726,
0.7499243021011353,
-0.5147900581359863,
0.27256035804748535,
0.7760156393051147,
0.45936059951782227,
-0.2449522167444229,
-1.241578459739685,
0.1420615315437317,
-0.12182405591011047,
0.08878376334905624,
0.09802243858575821,
-1.1451481580734253,
0.7834630608558655,
-0.044347528368234634,
-0.4316728413105011,
0.5323109030723572,
0.8491991758346558,
0.43594494462013245,
0.47275060415267944,
0.4915235638618469,
-0.024745700880885124,
0.9258902072906494,
0.06902100890874863,
0.77436363697052,
-0.8132463097572327,
0.28584131598472595,
1.1879069805145264,
-0.6187167167663574,
1.315242886543274,
0.17080913484096527,
-0.10178078711032867,
0.32399457693099976,
0.5828264355659485,
0.022661305963993073,
0.29572781920433044,
0.43531534075737,
-0.36671069264411926,
-0.26483801007270813,
-0.3641490340232849,
-0.5580558776855469,
0.2233794927597046,
0.40061458945274353,
-0.28108373284339905,
-0.14033649861812592,
-0.34110474586486816,
-0.081259585916996,
0.1649470180273056,
-0.36802470684051514,
0.2639143168926239,
0.4752882122993469,
-0.7542615532875061,
0.8038852214813232,
-0.08243709802627563,
0.6863559484481812,
-0.7344425320625305,
0.08070578426122665,
-0.24412542581558228,
0.3330138325691223,
-0.19087940454483032,
-0.9517659544944763,
-0.10565659403800964,
-0.1576586365699768,
0.23050394654273987,
0.2937982678413391,
0.751530647277832,
-0.7916430830955505,
-0.15667226910591125,
0.5128827691078186,
0.19343629479408264,
0.1140325516462326,
-0.004337577614933252,
-0.5906102657318115,
0.14684927463531494,
-0.2413448840379715,
-0.2138623148202896,
0.3086104989051819,
0.5117828249931335,
-0.24820083379745483,
0.8284619450569153,
0.4293539226055145,
0.20635193586349487,
-0.10138922184705734,
0.07489674538373947,
0.6211383938789368,
-0.8034943342208862,
-0.25829774141311646,
-0.9350035190582275,
0.37648287415504456,
-0.2381892055273056,
-0.6745449900627136,
0.8870488405227661,
0.7122285962104797,
0.6096086502075195,
0.17008747160434723,
0.8011494874954224,
0.19785232841968536,
0.4519578516483307,
-0.365151971578598,
0.7097019553184509,
-0.547239363193512,
0.33720487356185913,
-0.03613702952861786,
-0.8695639371871948,
-0.28801101446151733,
0.11554541438817978,
-0.4048879146575928,
0.04585481062531471,
0.4631389379501343,
0.626733124256134,
-0.03645017743110657,
-0.0239699874073267,
0.3821645677089691,
0.28631430864334106,
0.46995916962623596,
0.900662362575531,
0.8288632035255432,
-0.3347068727016449,
0.45910635590553284,
-0.18797752261161804,
-0.22201845049858093,
-0.24443960189819336,
-1.0387728214263916,
-1.2874082326889038,
-0.48279765248298645,
0.04839609935879707,
-0.17046518623828888,
0.10527990013360977,
1.160923957824707,
0.5127210021018982,
-0.8414410352706909,
-0.57842618227005,
0.37225738167762756,
-0.11048086732625961,
-0.18631486594676971,
-0.17640212178230286,
0.8466994762420654,
-0.3629395663738251,
-0.5848243832588196,
0.47909557819366455,
0.32112085819244385,
-0.24172422289848328,
-0.5882424116134644,
-0.11152803897857666,
0.30216318368911743,
0.0701073408126831,
0.9441688656806946,
0.3684873580932617,
-0.8945521712303162,
-0.40845808386802673,
-0.12375962734222412,
-0.3347209692001343,
-0.05754593759775162,
0.667500913143158,
-0.39826902747154236,
0.35380274057388306,
0.40205681324005127,
0.6255689859390259,
0.13768188655376434,
0.19810950756072998,
0.5510134100914001,
-0.5704020857810974,
0.208909273147583,
0.09837686270475388,
0.3777785003185272,
0.41831958293914795,
0.09519831091165543,
0.4394585192203522,
-0.19416221976280212,
-0.9525161981582642,
-1.0385801792144775,
0.01934386044740677,
-1.0105375051498413,
-0.2567977011203766,
1.1723432540893555,
-0.4844876527786255,
-0.30743226408958435,
-0.03653842583298683,
-0.14825664460659027,
-0.10802812874317169,
-0.2110927402973175,
0.7018657326698303,
0.7126805782318115,
0.2030317187309265,
0.02327524870634079,
-0.7684983611106873,
0.5838012099266052,
0.2226475328207016,
-0.6341997981071472,
0.6918242573738098,
0.38037046790122986,
0.3132292330265045,
-0.0009909248910844326,
0.5419428944587708,
-0.020937319844961166,
0.2779465913772583,
-0.31927400827407837,
-0.3048953115940094,
0.03589770197868347,
-0.10525602847337723,
-0.31279799342155457,
0.25747743248939514,
0.4253867566585541,
0.1539347767829895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03506v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03506v4
|
Detecting AI-Generated Sentences in Human-AI Collaborative Hybrid Texts: Challenges, Strategies, and Insights
| 2024-03-06T07:25:46 | 2024-05-23T13:18:33 |
Zijie Zeng, Shiqi Liu, Lele Sha, Zhuang Li, Kaixun Yang, Sannyuya Liu, Dragan Gašević, Guanliang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study explores the challenge of sentence-level AI-generated text
detection within human-AI collaborative hybrid texts. Existing studies of
AI-generated text detection for hybrid texts often rely on synthetic datasets.
These typically involve hybrid texts with a limited number of boundaries. We
contend that studies of detecting AI-generated content within hybrid texts
should cover different types of hybrid texts generated in realistic settings to
better inform real-world applications. Therefore, our study utilizes the
CoAuthor dataset, which includes diverse, realistic hybrid texts generated
through the collaboration between human writers and an intelligent writing
system in multi-turn interactions. We adopt a two-step, segmentation-based
pipeline: (i) detect segments within a given hybrid text where each segment
contains sentences of consistent authorship, and (ii) classify the authorship
of each identified segment. Our empirical findings highlight (1) detecting
AI-generated sentences in hybrid texts is overall a challenging task because
(1.1) human writers' selecting and even editing AI-generated sentences based on
personal preferences adds difficulty in identifying the authorship of segments;
(1.2) the frequent change of authorship between neighboring sentences within
the hybrid text creates difficulties for segment detectors in identifying
authorship-consistent segments; (1.3) the short length of text segments within
hybrid texts provides limited stylistic cues for reliable authorship
determination; (2) before embarking on the detection process, it is beneficial
to assess the average length of segments within the hybrid text. This
assessment aids in deciding whether (2.1) to employ a text segmentation-based
strategy for hybrid texts with longer segments, or (2.2) to adopt a direct
sentence-by-sentence classification strategy for those with shorter segments.
|
[
-0.31370455026626587,
-0.7114987373352051,
0.771168053150177,
0.057432763278484344,
-0.17591287195682526,
0.42716753482818604,
-0.19859303534030914,
-0.6310350298881531,
0.26640966534614563,
0.7430359125137329,
-0.5812028646469116,
-0.5227291584014893,
-0.4801118075847626,
0.6835567951202393,
-0.4659136235713959,
1.0123159885406494,
-0.16040366888046265,
-0.4806364178657532,
-0.6333858370780945,
-0.08370977640151978,
-0.5391755700111389,
-0.30753690004348755,
-0.2751712203025818,
-0.03334775194525719,
0.4771655201911926,
0.4937985837459564,
0.4586987793445587,
0.7473761439323425,
0.47734469175338745,
0.38848012685775757,
0.10993575304746628,
0.6860356330871582,
-0.13199694454669952,
0.2834199368953705,
0.3194969892501831,
-0.26465263962745667,
-0.08780356496572495,
0.15807834267616272,
0.5666667222976685,
0.3379090130329132,
0.21979843080043793,
-0.08082059770822525,
-0.1302984207868576,
0.43307411670684814,
-0.5874120593070984,
-0.1456061750650406,
-0.5538792610168457,
0.019502626731991768,
-0.6062511801719666,
-0.21659474074840546,
-0.586268961429596,
-0.10443750768899918,
0.1410759836435318,
-0.6100772619247437,
0.261110782623291,
0.48040705919265747,
0.6106943488121033,
0.24121330678462982,
-0.4430023431777954,
-0.5666543245315552,
-0.7114097476005554,
0.6893899440765381,
-0.38184207677841187,
-0.1401747167110443,
0.1180541068315506,
-0.18764694035053253,
-0.06284452974796295,
-0.47087639570236206,
-1.101364254951477,
-0.322732150554657,
-0.3583020865917206,
0.12810418009757996,
-0.1908332258462906,
0.04425450786948204,
0.07474265247583389,
0.4590621292591095,
-0.7104987502098083,
0.35335102677345276,
-0.24400709569454193,
-0.46368134021759033,
1.0025843381881714,
0.32328397035598755,
0.7560330629348755,
-0.3845255970954895,
-0.3563898205757141,
-0.02423398569226265,
-0.21633729338645935,
0.018471796065568924,
0.7644673585891724,
-0.04968931898474693,
-0.1770583540201187,
0.6821652054786682,
0.11574867367744446,
0.60386061668396,
-0.009581213817000389,
0.0505850575864315,
0.13370130956172943,
-0.6623826622962952,
0.25431323051452637,
0.06796848773956299,
1.3513033390045166,
0.22038577497005463,
0.5047223567962646,
-0.21295584738254547,
-0.0956060141324997,
0.02381177619099617,
0.18851079046726227,
-0.22846472263336182,
-0.31115782260894775,
0.19056487083435059,
-0.41762638092041016,
-0.39087939262390137,
0.5099029541015625,
-0.4557552635669708,
-0.5297839045524597,
-0.16934804618358612,
0.1624916046857834,
-0.4883446991443634,
-0.09462907165288925,
-0.039669767022132874,
-0.42151179909706116,
0.09760662913322449,
0.06902317702770233,
-0.7606256008148193,
0.21722903847694397,
0.7281002998352051,
0.8427402377128601,
-0.7173796892166138,
-0.6046628952026367,
-0.5905126333236694,
0.06249287724494934,
-0.20591166615486145,
1.0247621536254883,
-0.35165804624557495,
-0.4206686317920685,
-0.21672573685646057,
-0.38422152400016785,
-0.4143901765346527,
-0.5979970097541809,
0.5102550983428955,
-0.2373342514038086,
0.8064244389533997,
0.02136632800102234,
-0.8091561794281006,
0.31445518136024475,
0.08334068953990936,
-0.6164798140525818,
0.7748687267303467,
-0.026048999279737473,
-0.8691736459732056,
0.5145532488822937,
-0.7972080111503601,
-0.7624082565307617,
0.2992995083332062,
-0.30757617950439453,
-0.8327781558036804,
-0.23109440505504608,
0.27347201108932495,
0.3664306104183197,
0.02949860505759716,
0.14055977761745453,
0.08340325951576233,
-0.4015689790248871,
0.41542378067970276,
-0.15645532310009003,
0.765094518661499,
-0.16486264765262604,
-0.3023374676704407,
0.46833914518356323,
-0.6618127822875977,
-0.28660663962364197,
0.05239316448569298,
-0.2723158001899719,
-0.37805238366127014,
0.09244947135448456,
0.34844350814819336,
-0.21314166486263275,
0.2432355433702469,
-0.8583794236183167,
0.0706733912229538,
-0.06741535663604736,
0.13536794483661652,
0.7963746190071106,
0.23966874182224274,
0.4681575894355774,
-0.6026526689529419,
0.6052632331848145,
-0.1304357796907425,
-0.043851904571056366,
-0.3733038604259491,
-0.6090765595436096,
-0.5637751817703247,
-0.4923693537712097,
0.1629740595817566,
0.6388458013534546,
-0.8361112475395203,
1.1467597484588623,
0.009091184474527836,
-0.3914140462875366,
-0.5224005579948425,
0.18302947282791138,
0.4487650990486145,
0.32794588804244995,
0.4337465465068817,
-0.1261856108903885,
-0.42611628770828247,
-0.9666296243667603,
-0.6134330034255981,
-0.30661702156066895,
-0.025245478376746178,
0.08890308439731598,
0.7649897933006287,
-0.12564386427402496,
1.2443081140518188,
-0.7792907953262329,
-0.4483300745487213,
-0.6002007722854614,
0.509457528591156,
-0.4433329403400421,
0.5980378985404968,
0.4093812108039856,
-0.9846498370170593,
-0.8217735290527344,
-0.07853379100561142,
-0.710712194442749,
-0.21046467125415802,
-0.6417949795722961,
-0.028171207755804062,
0.06616033613681793,
0.5114259123802185,
-0.6558429598808289,
0.46477213501930237,
0.16699281334877014,
-0.3549889624118805,
0.7293991446495056,
-0.16540876030921936,
0.06784053146839142,
-1.1450589895248413,
0.024854488670825958,
0.24077454209327698,
-0.22471027076244354,
-0.48956310749053955,
0.06133342161774635,
-0.31783825159072876,
0.36677905917167664,
0.06735321134328842,
0.24244727194309235,
-0.5118710994720459,
0.14349713921546936,
-0.2997320294380188,
0.03785119950771332,
0.04290345683693886,
0.3062114715576172,
0.052121035754680634,
0.8353572487831116,
-0.012654650956392288,
-0.12146429717540741,
0.3380172848701477,
0.5038721561431885,
-0.5180310606956482,
0.5734312534332275,
-0.510923445224762,
0.4516562819480896,
-0.02260351926088333,
0.5805419087409973,
-0.91084223985672,
-0.3085537552833557,
0.3994166851043701,
-0.543864369392395,
-0.16108088195323944,
0.2635560929775238,
-0.82708340883255,
-0.27114593982696533,
-0.36368894577026367,
0.30029064416885376,
0.2840653657913208,
-0.18402424454689026,
0.564075767993927,
0.37053295969963074,
-0.19426830112934113,
-0.04434696212410927,
-0.47783955931663513,
0.266205757856369,
-0.271758496761322,
-0.9074259996414185,
0.567543625831604,
-0.008015223778784275,
-0.42873987555503845,
-0.056190136820077896,
0.3443252444267273,
-0.07704521715641022,
0.2106735110282898,
0.21975241601467133,
0.1778266727924347,
-0.016730904579162598,
-0.3187541961669922,
0.3673018515110016,
-0.20634357631206512,
0.08385997265577316,
-0.015165208838880062,
0.41084256768226624,
0.15590713918209076,
-0.15891306102275848,
-0.8722236752510071,
0.7134756445884705,
0.6398146748542786,
-0.49275991320610046,
0.6505037546157837,
0.9590099453926086,
-0.08721613883972168,
-0.3300696909427643,
-0.4002715051174164,
-0.061816949397325516,
-0.4187415838241577,
0.0817420706152916,
0.08608819544315338,
-0.9545360803604126,
0.4365319311618805,
0.4617826044559479,
-0.08267324417829514,
0.49427321553230286,
0.5193989276885986,
-0.3105573356151581,
0.7612289786338806,
0.535541832447052,
-0.1763477623462677,
0.41242727637290955,
-0.1727360635995865,
0.2370816171169281,
-0.860338568687439,
-0.34512457251548767,
-0.47060611844062805,
-0.4631095826625824,
-0.5927028059959412,
-0.19787193834781647,
0.6805850863456726,
-0.6155182719230652,
0.19693827629089355,
0.4825829267501831,
-0.631009042263031,
0.5810027718544006,
0.9622692465782166,
0.21613666415214539,
0.3621712625026703,
-0.29482927918434143,
0.025234652683138847,
0.04012930020689964,
-0.35187798738479614,
-0.3663596510887146,
0.8824596405029297,
0.00047179259127005935,
0.14965610206127167,
-0.1206895262002945,
0.9672172665596008,
0.791999876499176,
-0.2372305989265442,
-0.5679115653038025,
0.6598912477493286,
-0.13612474501132965,
-0.45377078652381897,
-0.29655787348747253,
-0.43079933524131775,
-0.9603062868118286,
0.09885996580123901,
-0.470615416765213,
-0.6953818202018738,
-0.22371193766593933,
-0.04773274436593056,
-0.5417869091033936,
0.29029443860054016,
-0.6763415932655334,
0.9181938171386719,
-0.2920730412006378,
-0.20956487953662872,
-0.13072913885116577,
-0.9355570673942566,
0.03153225779533386,
0.010098977945744991,
-0.018832970410585403,
0.15903422236442566,
0.14636874198913574,
0.9324861168861389,
-0.47333329916000366,
0.7141125202178955,
0.07295993715524673,
0.1371387243270874,
0.6320443749427795,
0.018145378679037094,
0.3549412488937378,
-0.15512260794639587,
0.1887449324131012,
-0.18401728570461273,
-0.34826359152793884,
-0.33428922295570374,
-0.18273800611495972,
0.33059555292129517,
-0.7065961956977844,
-0.34021610021591187,
-0.5568462014198303,
-0.7785736918449402,
-0.04640110209584236,
0.25972485542297363,
0.7557513117790222,
0.19367530941963196,
-0.1656407117843628,
0.13841387629508972,
0.15968681871891022,
-0.20032083988189697,
0.49532875418663025,
-0.05076286941766739,
0.2825621962547302,
-0.3573707640171051,
1.04843008518219,
-0.2806631326675415,
0.035350482910871506,
0.48550787568092346,
0.20921576023101807,
-0.1654183715581894,
-0.9385685324668884,
-0.6220402121543884,
0.15210650861263275,
-0.07998563349246979,
0.17856205999851227,
-0.6662636995315552,
-0.08423753827810287,
-0.30336886644363403,
-0.34180980920791626,
0.012950270436704159,
-0.05479121580719948,
-0.6191226243972778,
0.0930771455168724,
0.19142776727676392,
0.7954461574554443,
0.11070366203784943,
0.28264814615249634,
-0.7252897620201111,
0.29310211539268494,
-0.10830435901880264,
-0.2386537343263626,
-0.15074655413627625,
-0.09371806681156158,
-0.08310957998037338,
-0.18895888328552246,
-0.34856268763542175,
-0.5267918705940247,
0.18073445558547974,
-0.02288970537483692,
0.34802189469337463,
0.04800409823656082,
0.18246769905090332,
0.3500818908214569,
-0.27972662448883057,
1.0176336765289307,
0.11517590284347534,
-0.9127420783042908,
0.4531298875808716,
-0.6037234663963318,
0.3053646683692932,
0.7490529417991638,
0.18698334693908691,
-0.6181495785713196,
-0.6480218172073364,
-0.3480384051799774,
-0.718040943145752,
0.5981701612472534,
0.7565778493881226,
0.12090403586626053,
0.07284107059240341,
0.27176976203918457,
0.3198085129261017,
0.24966172873973846,
-0.7150875329971313,
-0.04749196022748947,
0.43608754873275757,
-0.5421342849731445,
0.13035765290260315,
0.07398911565542221,
0.1682584434747696,
0.06007959693670273,
0.3376762270927429,
-0.1943892538547516,
0.1112896203994751,
0.22583554685115814,
-0.15382805466651917,
-0.006877195555716753,
0.02440549060702324,
0.623491108417511,
0.2779608368873596,
0.12000828236341476,
-0.30862241983413696,
-0.33308297395706177,
-0.4326063394546509,
-0.13096515834331512,
0.2099681943655014,
-0.5314628481864929,
-0.03816719725728035,
1.1596847772598267,
0.6082620024681091,
-0.34032681584358215,
-0.7425528764724731,
0.7193784713745117,
0.08258667588233948,
-0.2087228149175644,
-0.46430718898773193,
0.2507597506046295,
-0.24304354190826416,
0.1426355391740799,
0.43746674060821533,
0.4275974631309509,
0.21683262288570404,
-0.4369807839393616,
0.21396486461162567,
0.5026350021362305,
-0.17986735701560974,
-0.44039031863212585,
0.5354903340339661,
0.498715877532959,
-0.4944474995136261,
0.7660298943519592,
-0.3269343674182892,
-0.8521283268928528,
0.8046044707298279,
0.1688026487827301,
0.9394301772117615,
0.28478556871414185,
0.4007667899131775,
-0.13432247936725616,
0.1276993453502655,
0.15285809338092804,
-0.040089428424835205,
-0.2821154296398163,
-0.9336913824081421,
-0.20097313821315765,
-0.19331447780132294,
-0.5198030471801758,
-0.011049812659621239,
-0.5379554033279419,
0.2851448357105255,
-0.33445391058921814,
0.07896194607019424,
0.2898779809474945,
-0.07311031967401505,
-0.09626496583223343,
-0.11249081790447235,
0.35699403285980225,
0.3849475681781769,
-0.8791708946228027,
0.25579705834388733,
0.5073013305664062,
-0.3449343144893646,
-0.5166944265365601,
0.4540965259075165,
0.31791144609451294,
-0.52427077293396,
-0.07185815274715424,
0.3713710904121399,
-0.2490052878856659,
-0.047913867980241776,
-0.5819755792617798,
-0.1351429671049118,
1.10686194896698,
-0.035028114914894104,
-0.18704842031002045,
-0.2088167369365692,
0.23495513200759888,
0.7279459834098816,
-0.5304149985313416,
-0.03811170160770416,
0.38221701979637146,
0.4082949161529541,
-0.13122108578681946,
-0.9354089498519897,
-0.1887696534395218,
-0.19111758470535278,
-0.33727648854255676,
0.301665335893631,
-0.8754583597183228,
0.8469665050506592,
-0.1332715004682541,
-0.04780761897563934,
0.5210874676704407,
0.6981294751167297,
0.2657492458820343,
0.7488166689872742,
0.7969241142272949,
0.34320351481437683,
0.6039838790893555,
0.12944835424423218,
0.9934449791908264,
0.03872822970151901,
0.044040001928806305,
0.8941606283187866,
-0.49944329261779785,
0.5631995797157288,
0.3430212438106537,
-0.0019180318340659142,
1.083092212677002,
0.3224825859069824,
-0.3398832380771637,
0.17924334108829498,
0.1736079752445221,
-0.3578895628452301,
-0.3825162947177887,
-0.26147347688674927,
-0.013890569098293781,
0.7875621318817139,
-0.07240759581327438,
-0.40710073709487915,
0.33630937337875366,
0.06677252054214478,
0.19389814138412476,
0.7064076662063599,
0.15209370851516724,
0.9301246404647827,
-0.19080163538455963,
-1.0558891296386719,
-0.22647283971309662,
0.12367076426744461,
0.7622316479682922,
-0.2535514533519745,
0.18294228613376617,
0.006224887445569038,
0.17787840962409973,
-0.26509132981300354,
-0.918255090713501,
0.30339983105659485,
0.24798619747161865,
-0.23760710656642914,
-0.33943068981170654,
0.6471120119094849,
-0.5826901197433472,
-0.4746416509151459,
0.06432630121707916,
0.487697035074234,
-0.12846744060516357,
-0.26109567284584045,
-0.4456081986427307,
0.12065652012825012,
0.1376238465309143,
0.14795835316181183,
0.05325745791196823,
0.23716005682945251,
-0.07654271274805069,
0.3097052574157715,
0.7302623987197876,
-0.19476521015167236,
-0.15265154838562012,
-0.16128399968147278,
0.6125808954238892,
-0.36744093894958496,
-0.7758700847625732,
-0.9807096123695374,
0.6077284216880798,
-0.37720000743865967,
-0.6188209652900696,
0.6842387914657593,
0.9251936078071594,
0.7645265460014343,
-0.07875906676054001,
1.1190038919448853,
-0.24427852034568787,
0.5097355246543884,
-0.5822737216949463,
0.7726507186889648,
-0.4022948145866394,
0.20446600019931793,
-0.35756221413612366,
-0.5254538655281067,
-0.3465650677680969,
0.35934823751449585,
-0.44189345836639404,
-0.04072149842977524,
0.661070704460144,
0.3504857122898102,
0.023529641330242157,
0.2419108897447586,
-0.22891385853290558,
-0.18135519325733185,
0.4277527630329132,
0.5323180556297302,
1.0414215326309204,
-0.2774317264556885,
0.5906012654304504,
-0.23223014175891876,
-0.00820030178874731,
-0.0867542028427124,
-0.6104519367218018,
-1.1100448369979858,
-0.8039607405662537,
-0.5651596188545227,
-0.10208304971456528,
-0.26275527477264404,
0.9449059367179871,
0.479390949010849,
-0.6814086437225342,
-0.3117716312408447,
-0.2686202824115753,
0.16042698919773102,
-0.10250434279441833,
-0.2558549642562866,
0.2529498338699341,
0.20709067583084106,
-0.7172968983650208,
0.5162609815597534,
0.3475545346736908,
-0.08965674787759781,
-0.24917994439601898,
-0.021349644288420677,
-0.41908419132232666,
-0.07970912754535675,
0.2570199966430664,
0.08114074915647507,
-0.6307411193847656,
-0.39520981907844543,
0.19898240268230438,
-0.03704749420285225,
0.030010348185896873,
1.08114755153656,
-0.5115095376968384,
0.3660717010498047,
0.5167958736419678,
0.6136296987533569,
0.3362104594707489,
0.3856829106807709,
0.6643301844596863,
-0.8335914015769958,
-0.17644375562667847,
0.517597496509552,
0.1444830447435379,
0.5133285522460938,
-0.570980966091156,
0.283863365650177,
0.6894163489341736,
-0.6011839509010315,
-0.6447265148162842,
0.2848217785358429,
-1.1209371089935303,
-0.1279555708169937,
1.0144344568252563,
-0.14654937386512756,
-0.052524399012327194,
-0.14559496939182281,
-0.4321669340133667,
0.052774615585803986,
-0.41889920830726624,
0.6451574563980103,
0.661994218826294,
-0.6097250580787659,
-0.0035815173760056496,
0.31325656175613403,
0.42327556014060974,
0.24276310205459595,
-0.9760589599609375,
-0.10440433770418167,
0.6913676261901855,
-0.026825277134776115,
0.5215747356414795,
0.6205861568450928,
0.3160364627838135,
0.33684709668159485,
0.009263191372156143,
-0.28352150321006775,
-0.25640493631362915,
-0.43020346760749817,
0.10537304729223251,
0.22498463094234467,
-0.4466041624546051,
-0.3453950583934784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03496v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03496v1
|
A Knowledge Plug-and-Play Test Bed for Open-domain Dialogue Generation
| 2024-03-06T06:54:02 | 2024-03-06T06:54:02 |
Xiangci Li, Linfeng Song, Lifeng Jin, Haitao Mi, Jessica Ouyang, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge-based, open-domain dialogue generation aims to build chit-chat
systems that talk to humans using mined support knowledge. Many types and
sources of knowledge have previously been shown to be useful as support
knowledge. Even in the era of large language models, response generation
grounded in knowledge retrieved from additional up-to-date sources remains a
practically important approach. While prior work using single-source knowledge
has shown a clear positive correlation between the performances of knowledge
selection and response generation, there are no existing multi-source datasets
for evaluating support knowledge retrieval. Further, prior work has assumed
that the knowledge sources available at test time are the same as during
training. This unrealistic assumption unnecessarily handicaps models, as new
knowledge sources can become available after a model is trained. In this paper,
we present a high-quality benchmark named multi-source Wizard of Wikipedia
(Ms.WoW) for evaluating multi-source dialogue knowledge selection and response
generation. Unlike existing datasets, it contains clean support knowledge,
grounded at the utterance level and partitioned into multiple knowledge
sources. We further propose a new challenge, dialogue knowledge plug-and-play,
which aims to test an already trained dialogue model on using new support
knowledge from previously unseen sources in a zero-shot fashion.
|
[
-0.7433702945709229,
-0.6749303340911865,
0.33807113766670227,
0.14277304708957672,
0.09240575134754181,
-0.03751023858785629,
-0.2350064069032669,
-0.16204795241355896,
-0.1381407380104065,
0.580017626285553,
-0.7532315254211426,
-0.09571275860071182,
-0.1748097985982895,
0.024412065744400024,
-0.1821955144405365,
0.933210551738739,
0.08240052312612534,
0.08765224367380142,
-0.5399938821792603,
-0.19459983706474304,
-0.6627320647239685,
-0.3529985249042511,
-0.3514940142631531,
-0.16268055140972137,
0.4100068211555481,
0.4026525318622589,
0.5980367660522461,
-0.18704716861248016,
0.1464143842458725,
0.2378561794757843,
0.12935025990009308,
0.38091903924942017,
-0.5444056987762451,
0.28208285570144653,
-0.10822519659996033,
-0.1052965596318245,
-0.23593570291996002,
0.08598291873931885,
0.27719545364379883,
0.44106951355934143,
-0.19893300533294678,
0.15099333226680756,
0.08902659267187119,
0.1929701268672943,
-0.6464993953704834,
0.30387261509895325,
-0.9185781478881836,
0.02553819678723812,
0.13357631862163544,
-0.2743318974971771,
-0.534254789352417,
-0.5411417484283447,
0.34734106063842773,
-0.8515008091926575,
0.3090640902519226,
0.18109861016273499,
0.6613649725914001,
0.140469029545784,
-0.5105146169662476,
-0.19328175485134125,
-0.7759576439857483,
0.6314622163772583,
-0.7731115818023682,
0.47111931443214417,
0.15670552849769592,
0.7933027148246765,
-0.524590790271759,
-0.4707358181476593,
-1.022674322128296,
-0.21286365389823914,
-0.012891347520053387,
0.2337391972541809,
-0.004713485948741436,
-0.21436433494091034,
0.26987120509147644,
0.3066238462924957,
-0.3955446183681488,
-0.5379008650779724,
-0.387756884098053,
-0.28071069717407227,
0.36881592869758606,
-0.18662656843662262,
0.12603424489498138,
-0.2417423576116562,
-0.35904496908187866,
-0.12338542938232422,
-0.7111985087394714,
-0.14510217308998108,
0.4003199338912964,
0.5190075039863586,
0.14108899235725403,
0.7474957704544067,
-0.23826661705970764,
0.7211084365844727,
-0.1576801985502243,
-0.3214859962463379,
0.177313894033432,
-0.4090013802051544,
-0.1908547431230545,
-0.07819481939077377,
0.9098967909812927,
0.16924406588077545,
0.27598366141319275,
-0.031207816675305367,
0.42398399114608765,
-0.11474689841270447,
0.4370487630367279,
-0.6958778500556946,
-0.13131912052631378,
-0.0757051408290863,
-0.22795523703098297,
-0.19316649436950684,
-0.23621831834316254,
-0.8428822159767151,
-0.5674868226051331,
-0.09038054943084717,
0.44362449645996094,
-0.7053827047348022,
-0.6466699242591858,
0.007941300049424171,
-0.2865349352359772,
0.24642489850521088,
0.4756375849246979,
-0.49475303292274475,
0.238106831908226,
0.2939271628856659,
0.5882806181907654,
-0.03951428458094597,
-0.18215960264205933,
-0.7327031493186951,
0.11522950977087021,
-0.29030314087867737,
0.9359840154647827,
-0.23962369561195374,
-0.48009806871414185,
0.20232020318508148,
-0.18728119134902954,
-0.03405509144067764,
-0.4378119707107544,
0.4143846333026886,
-0.6051125526428223,
0.7612164616584778,
-0.11895523220300674,
-0.4985877573490143,
0.0005115466192364693,
0.2641149163246155,
-0.5219646096229553,
0.8589574694633484,
0.4636930823326111,
-0.8953993916511536,
0.4003823399543762,
-0.6759657859802246,
-0.23521682620048523,
0.017984848469495773,
-0.4568921625614166,
-0.12226076424121857,
-0.10194031149148941,
0.07185767590999603,
0.09630173444747925,
-0.404702365398407,
0.11805486679077148,
-0.5639122724533081,
-0.06380196660757065,
0.27179595828056335,
-0.47242552042007446,
0.6314564347267151,
0.1214773878455162,
-0.3493100702762604,
-0.2221543788909912,
-0.9212753176689148,
0.29092442989349365,
0.1286800354719162,
-0.4018251597881317,
-0.31287264823913574,
0.12601453065872192,
-0.30723434686660767,
0.5194392204284668,
-0.3310832381248474,
-0.8198136687278748,
0.004782112780958414,
-0.3016705811023712,
-0.02826465107500553,
0.5700865983963013,
0.22381223738193512,
-0.022595398128032684,
-0.04824322462081909,
0.3338431119918823,
0.17807860672473907,
0.15849889814853668,
-0.31866928935050964,
-0.8458083868026733,
-0.705170214176178,
-0.03191417083144188,
0.19046752154827118,
0.40828806161880493,
-0.9698508977890015,
0.43892765045166016,
0.000930235197301954,
-0.32293957471847534,
-0.6752172708511353,
-0.01169645693153143,
0.32341358065605164,
0.7669068574905396,
0.5309180021286011,
-0.3906301259994507,
-0.2867407202720642,
-0.790037989616394,
-0.2042139619588852,
-0.38625192642211914,
-0.39936432242393494,
0.7763218879699707,
0.02839713729918003,
0.07402285188436508,
1.1809375286102295,
-0.8102567195892334,
-0.07314896583557129,
0.11213445663452148,
0.14895831048488617,
-0.24053393304347992,
0.1375419944524765,
0.2767309844493866,
-0.5096069574356079,
-0.5275329351425171,
0.0779879167675972,
-0.7184724807739258,
0.11602556705474854,
0.2538662254810333,
-0.4410085380077362,
0.056467462331056595,
0.23029902577400208,
-0.7409329414367676,
0.34935352206230164,
0.5247064828872681,
-0.368453711271286,
0.6808454394340515,
0.12625209987163544,
0.538189709186554,
-1.196954369544983,
0.1844651848077774,
-0.31724658608436584,
-0.06790344417095184,
-0.5213043093681335,
-0.15599782764911652,
0.013516639359295368,
-0.34557420015335083,
-0.52632075548172,
0.5408779978752136,
-0.12619276344776154,
0.03405371308326721,
-0.09097421169281006,
0.3710927367210388,
0.1212543249130249,
0.6728857755661011,
0.03640160337090492,
0.9002558588981628,
0.2951996326446533,
-0.5719252228736877,
0.5618951916694641,
0.6260738968849182,
-0.5030537247657776,
0.7552369832992554,
-0.4973333179950714,
0.3781135380268097,
0.13240031898021698,
0.17144107818603516,
-1.2049628496170044,
-0.3208242654800415,
0.10069867223501205,
-0.5508158802986145,
0.09618252515792847,
-0.06376813352108002,
-0.5172710418701172,
-0.45888927578926086,
-0.009637018665671349,
0.19160613417625427,
0.43569570779800415,
-0.5793225169181824,
0.44461968541145325,
0.3028690218925476,
-0.22145803272724152,
-0.6818547248840332,
-0.02347412519156933,
-0.304634690284729,
-0.03763590008020401,
-0.7415570616722107,
-0.04920561611652374,
-0.4468379318714142,
-0.09249120205640793,
-0.09461027383804321,
-0.18941251933574677,
-0.12426825612783432,
-0.12363823503255844,
0.09573867917060852,
0.21271753311157227,
-0.33682239055633545,
0.2301964908838272,
0.06461039930582047,
0.17959728837013245,
0.10726037621498108,
-0.3200128376483917,
0.4983014166355133,
0.3376530110836029,
-0.7041783332824707,
0.31325531005859375,
0.4794533848762512,
0.49246281385421753,
-0.25654760003089905,
0.6215240359306335,
0.43403804302215576,
-0.0620991587638855,
-0.29465505480766296,
-0.7597450017929077,
-0.12458858639001846,
-0.44756147265434265,
-0.011263884603977203,
-0.33156198263168335,
-0.9042295217514038,
0.2086300402879715,
-0.3535284996032715,
0.41487210988998413,
0.35615238547325134,
0.5623533725738525,
0.10988165438175201,
0.9702390432357788,
0.41928765177726746,
0.22510665655136108,
0.22524400055408478,
0.12448740005493164,
0.45741403102874756,
-0.5176987648010254,
-0.31064748764038086,
-0.6639793515205383,
0.21352511644363403,
-0.2123119980096817,
-0.5662782192230225,
0.4687654674053192,
0.140773206949234,
-0.23573260009288788,
0.42205560207366943,
-0.18970587849617004,
0.26864227652549744,
0.6610589027404785,
0.03612203150987625,
0.5833123326301575,
-0.002837991574779153,
-0.48435238003730774,
0.08129792660474777,
-0.5502833724021912,
-0.18107619881629944,
1.0815683603286743,
0.002217805478721857,
0.6167550683021545,
0.21646003425121307,
0.22267986834049225,
0.1255623996257782,
0.07948452234268188,
-0.5915639996528625,
0.4330258071422577,
0.44178324937820435,
-0.6870067715644836,
-0.43076223134994507,
-0.532566249370575,
-0.7171370387077332,
0.3009098172187805,
-0.162372425198555,
-0.4640904664993286,
-0.07042030990123749,
0.04042951390147209,
-0.491874098777771,
0.19087660312652588,
-0.9547224044799805,
0.786819577217102,
0.32790228724479675,
-0.14818787574768066,
-0.13137705624103546,
-0.5083304643630981,
0.7427377700805664,
-0.03676745668053627,
0.2152642160654068,
-0.10863812267780304,
0.6073660850524902,
0.2947353720664978,
-0.35635092854499817,
0.5331459045410156,
-0.29370447993278503,
-0.2122897505760193,
0.458878755569458,
0.14729240536689758,
0.14838027954101562,
0.22734738886356354,
0.13868139684200287,
-0.1327594667673111,
-0.03380468115210533,
-0.3448978066444397,
-0.742358922958374,
0.630388617515564,
-0.9697754979133606,
-0.5158330202102661,
-0.05934947729110718,
-0.4980372190475464,
-0.9313068985939026,
0.15266656875610352,
0.1153900995850563,
0.42034247517585754,
-0.48480257391929626,
0.10228004306554794,
0.9418298006057739,
-0.5993980765342712,
0.00398076931014657,
0.7284761071205139,
-0.28331172466278076,
-0.4799957275390625,
0.712658166885376,
-0.16915105283260345,
0.49272334575653076,
0.09531508386135101,
0.10930875688791275,
-0.22932428121566772,
0.1173117607831955,
-0.7769043445587158,
-0.0838131234049797,
-0.5379049777984619,
-0.44928547739982605,
-0.7373478412628174,
-0.5611708760261536,
-0.6869900226593018,
0.3132783770561218,
-0.3160354197025299,
-0.5097010731697083,
0.11570379883050919,
-0.12501172721385956,
0.4135701358318329,
0.6565601825714111,
0.16826386749744415,
-0.10326029360294342,
-0.7470132112503052,
0.4347301125526428,
0.8505379557609558,
0.6653083562850952,
0.04292598366737366,
-0.06734884530305862,
-0.4429589509963989,
-0.04337409511208534,
-0.7781209945678711,
-1.0652227401733398,
0.0004964436520822346,
0.11800828576087952,
0.808384358882904,
0.32027754187583923,
0.28344979882240295,
0.4977364242076874,
-0.8965506553649902,
1.0976225137710571,
0.33622267842292786,
-0.57867431640625,
0.65120929479599,
-0.3431358337402344,
0.28133583068847656,
0.445391982793808,
0.3239746689796448,
-0.5393281579017639,
-0.6305907964706421,
-0.7838252186775208,
-0.4479445219039917,
0.8260388374328613,
0.2904101610183716,
0.1888609230518341,
-0.2027873694896698,
-0.16822314262390137,
0.46985578536987305,
0.5853766798973083,
-0.29900145530700684,
-0.22729508578777313,
-0.5050389170646667,
0.2515869140625,
0.036785632371902466,
0.0990867093205452,
-0.5594403743743896,
-0.11220161616802216,
0.7048671245574951,
-0.3686017692089081,
0.578670859336853,
0.045381736010313034,
0.064887635409832,
-0.4355882704257965,
0.4628440737724304,
0.4053420424461365,
0.6138976216316223,
-0.159957617521286,
-0.14282412827014923,
0.059946611523628235,
-0.30010557174682617,
-0.035697683691978455,
0.13152427971363068,
0.009715812280774117,
0.21213853359222412,
0.014353032223880291,
0.8896382451057434,
0.2365858107805252,
-0.633881151676178,
0.639342725276947,
-0.2607984244823456,
-0.35218724608421326,
-0.22354008257389069,
0.38542938232421875,
0.09370087087154388,
0.19977232813835144,
0.2721259295940399,
0.27906301617622375,
0.02552603743970394,
-0.5456157326698303,
0.32930105924606323,
0.6124444007873535,
-0.3498650789260864,
-0.10141018778085709,
0.4072350859642029,
0.3184773623943329,
-0.29366087913513184,
0.5480061769485474,
-0.2502387464046478,
-0.1577758491039276,
0.07846777886152267,
0.34881311655044556,
0.7404366731643677,
-0.31934744119644165,
0.5210997462272644,
0.4774637520313263,
-0.18278849124908447,
0.242428719997406,
0.3567514419555664,
-0.1787974089384079,
-0.7984499931335449,
-0.5397717356681824,
-0.4722842574119568,
-0.7224236726760864,
0.41668829321861267,
-0.5568804144859314,
0.3505989611148834,
-0.0671585351228714,
0.019544916227459908,
-0.17285464704036713,
-0.07183758914470673,
-0.9087018966674805,
-0.10358560085296631,
-0.10170795768499374,
1.223516583442688,
-0.6073406934738159,
0.7859092950820923,
0.3532349467277527,
-0.4370080232620239,
-0.8611067533493042,
0.16659890115261078,
0.08098678290843964,
-0.697144091129303,
0.2836725413799286,
-0.13536661863327026,
0.077327199280262,
-0.07935170829296112,
-0.5972911715507507,
-0.7433797121047974,
1.0461591482162476,
0.38522565364837646,
0.05024728924036026,
-0.15029916167259216,
0.03296278417110443,
0.45296335220336914,
-0.337796688079834,
0.7173464298248291,
0.4396759867668152,
0.16920804977416992,
0.4206458330154419,
-1.212868332862854,
-0.15839821100234985,
-0.3052288889884949,
-0.06849191337823868,
0.013083736412227154,
-0.591900110244751,
0.8012590408325195,
0.04571880027651787,
-0.04480789229273796,
-0.04102224111557007,
0.5805795788764954,
0.5002032518386841,
0.0338641032576561,
0.6155429482460022,
0.40327388048171997,
0.5615549683570862,
0.07670954614877701,
0.6615925431251526,
-0.30494362115859985,
0.1989865005016327,
1.0596320629119873,
-0.4181567132472992,
0.9291974902153015,
0.3768356144428253,
-0.21372532844543457,
0.8414464592933655,
0.24847352504730225,
0.26938748359680176,
0.7337719798088074,
0.3190656006336212,
-0.5928454995155334,
-0.18181782960891724,
-0.2502536177635193,
-0.5824025273323059,
0.22840246558189392,
0.18779195845127106,
0.053470585495233536,
-0.5572372674942017,
-0.010924066416919231,
-0.09792281687259674,
-0.08064504712820053,
0.16835062205791473,
1.1152782440185547,
-0.07136279344558716,
-0.9938209652900696,
0.5759127736091614,
-0.3502097725868225,
0.36883336305618286,
-0.9337973594665527,
-0.41134098172187805,
-0.3112560212612152,
-0.003692600643262267,
-0.013085780665278435,
-0.5621114373207092,
0.009181557223200798,
0.09218305349349976,
-0.13827542960643768,
0.03249217942357063,
0.946747362613678,
-0.5896161198616028,
-0.08599406480789185,
0.3999897539615631,
0.9354385137557983,
0.08156828582286835,
-0.1986304223537445,
-0.30257508158683777,
-0.28242143988609314,
-0.027089888229966164,
-0.3314268887042999,
0.5914999842643738,
0.694904625415802,
0.14767774939537048,
0.3341699540615082,
0.6878775954246521,
0.06684215366840363,
0.2088768631219864,
0.1525423377752304,
1.239269733428955,
-0.25686269998550415,
-0.3659255802631378,
-0.16984961926937103,
0.7401911020278931,
-0.4210439920425415,
-0.2801998555660248,
0.9047179818153381,
0.5072911381721497,
0.9015236496925354,
-0.10395034402608871,
1.2369369268417358,
-0.20803417265415192,
0.9116580486297607,
-0.17086364328861237,
0.57904052734375,
-0.3502776622772217,
-0.15121592581272125,
-0.5299452543258667,
-0.8368731141090393,
0.23706817626953125,
0.3464086353778839,
0.1148308739066124,
-0.0957961454987526,
0.8510991334915161,
0.7966456413269043,
-0.21958264708518982,
0.43707895278930664,
0.5292372703552246,
0.07701819390058517,
0.3814762532711029,
0.3894764482975006,
0.9652994275093079,
-0.33356282114982605,
0.9720355272293091,
-0.08817119896411896,
-0.44276273250579834,
0.16243305802345276,
-0.6940705180168152,
-0.976565420627594,
-0.7320097088813782,
-0.0689970999956131,
-0.7334801554679871,
-0.1407536268234253,
0.7679647207260132,
0.7010644674301147,
-1.0189430713653564,
-0.19605864584445953,
0.08394141495227814,
0.066641665995121,
-0.30359917879104614,
-0.25787946581840515,
-0.04385624825954437,
-0.7187134623527527,
-0.4440690577030182,
0.6798691153526306,
0.08391492068767548,
-0.22211788594722748,
-0.6794649362564087,
-0.11647219210863113,
-0.11605438590049744,
0.24683824181556702,
0.7258890271186829,
0.37086057662963867,
-0.5080970525741577,
-0.4477623403072357,
0.363903284072876,
0.04300811514258385,
0.0005492657655850053,
1.0910532474517822,
-1.0280911922454834,
0.6062418818473816,
0.45344990491867065,
0.6678959727287292,
0.3851652443408966,
-0.2022748738527298,
1.0697345733642578,
-1.077148199081421,
-0.16306555271148682,
0.033593371510505676,
0.22386042773723602,
0.24022957682609558,
-0.12359706312417984,
0.4052261412143707,
0.30018913745880127,
-0.6017409563064575,
-0.7004838585853577,
0.3373223841190338,
-0.6379067897796631,
-0.1555480808019638,
1.1324652433395386,
-0.419694185256958,
0.17958295345306396,
-0.40420499444007874,
-0.4496907591819763,
0.35321661829948425,
-0.49051329493522644,
0.8709109425544739,
0.903954029083252,
-0.1203511506319046,
-0.10996672511100769,
-0.7705944776535034,
0.7698178887367249,
0.08225663751363754,
-0.8809146285057068,
0.24462084472179413,
0.7060558795928955,
0.15752531588077545,
0.556564450263977,
0.8981363773345947,
-0.05879654362797737,
0.11180991679430008,
0.16263562440872192,
0.13904695212841034,
0.02544047310948372,
-0.4051237106323242,
0.17415043711662292,
0.31244176626205444,
0.053839102387428284,
-0.12616649270057678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03481v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03481v1
|
Magic Markup: Maintaining Document-External Markup with an LLM
| 2024-03-06T05:40:31 | 2024-03-06T05:40:31 |
Edward Misback, Zachary Tatlock, Steven L. Tanimoto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text documents, including programs, typically have human-readable semantic
structure. Historically, programmatic access to these semantics has required
explicit in-document tagging. Especially in systems where the text has an
execution semantics, this means it is an opt-in feature that is hard to support
properly. Today, language models offer a new method: metadata can be bound to
entities in changing text using a model's human-like understanding of
semantics, with no requirements on the document structure. This method expands
the applications of document annotation, a fundamental operation in program
writing, debugging, maintenance, and presentation. We contribute a system that
employs an intelligent agent to re-tag modified programs, enabling rich
annotations to automatically follow code as it evolves. We also contribute a
formal problem definition, an empirical synthetic benchmark suite, and our
benchmark generator. Our system achieves an accuracy of 90% on our benchmarks
and can replace a document's tags in parallel at a rate of 5 seconds per tag.
While there remains significant room for improvement, we find performance
reliable enough to justify further exploration of applications.
|
[
-0.2845922112464905,
-0.4717807173728943,
0.5199406147003174,
0.13826212286949158,
-0.051338039338588715,
0.3734506070613861,
-0.29194891452789307,
-0.7175577878952026,
0.15936881303787231,
0.6940330862998962,
-0.4277768135070801,
-0.6517688632011414,
-0.5122014284133911,
0.17793332040309906,
-0.2632620334625244,
1.0200196504592896,
-0.3049832582473755,
-0.18039953708648682,
-0.2968454658985138,
-0.00012066009367117658,
-0.5463720560073853,
-0.3769732415676117,
-0.44134122133255005,
-0.5943416357040405,
0.4346770942211151,
0.38199254870414734,
0.9761224985122681,
1.2104089260101318,
0.9753216505050659,
0.3198999762535095,
0.5179793238639832,
0.5475654602050781,
0.014510070905089378,
0.15459127724170685,
-0.29351216554641724,
-0.6317058801651001,
-0.8115358948707581,
0.31955593824386597,
0.6425827145576477,
0.6037918329238892,
0.16790169477462769,
0.12635944783687592,
-0.19612246751785278,
0.4946884214878082,
-0.6083471179008484,
0.5502901077270508,
-0.762825071811676,
0.03340865299105644,
-0.224140465259552,
-0.6916568279266357,
-0.45942988991737366,
-0.3772526979446411,
-0.2975773215293884,
-1.0950334072113037,
0.018297182396054268,
0.20577651262283325,
1.0258395671844482,
0.5069931745529175,
-0.08020935952663422,
-0.42978471517562866,
-0.6668598651885986,
0.7002121806144714,
-0.496811181306839,
0.24793754518032074,
0.6978502869606018,
0.16453751921653748,
-0.5138565301895142,
-1.0152618885040283,
-0.5914070010185242,
-0.5966691374778748,
-0.1288236677646637,
0.04586281627416611,
-0.021319972351193428,
0.1440780758857727,
0.45540177822113037,
0.32438328862190247,
-0.20031112432479858,
0.029652314260601997,
-0.016399173066020012,
-0.14452770352363586,
0.6627941727638245,
0.35051652789115906,
0.7351371049880981,
0.2654429078102112,
-0.3201044797897339,
-0.03167154639959335,
-0.5683072805404663,
-0.5377984046936035,
0.44227051734924316,
0.08919274806976318,
0.5131086111068726,
0.7020983695983887,
-0.05675292760133743,
0.7199495434761047,
-0.32833191752433777,
-0.2593276798725128,
0.16172358393669128,
-0.26087620854377747,
-0.5001721382141113,
0.023404868319630623,
0.4567628800868988,
0.6569305658340454,
0.4745522141456604,
-0.33932164311408997,
-0.3185310661792755,
0.3153759837150574,
0.4136640429496765,
-0.43056023120880127,
-0.5383221507072449,
-0.08070390671491623,
-0.1141991913318634,
-0.14037081599235535,
0.15080933272838593,
-0.15234734117984772,
-0.7761156558990479,
-0.8331872224807739,
0.37288549542427063,
-0.7268350720405579,
-0.008428680710494518,
-0.11098889261484146,
-0.41163578629493713,
0.1785856932401657,
0.6328412294387817,
-0.9484937787055969,
0.34177935123443604,
0.986901044845581,
0.6693726181983948,
0.06272309273481369,
-0.4336825907230377,
-0.3075835704803467,
0.5548250675201416,
-0.5272698998451233,
1.0079922676086426,
-0.868371307849884,
-0.3661075532436371,
-0.284916490316391,
0.08722212165594101,
0.028282033279538155,
-0.5375776290893555,
0.608578085899353,
-0.6644662618637085,
0.05892962962388992,
-0.21651042997837067,
-0.7992128133773804,
-0.07653211802244186,
0.42603620886802673,
-0.4502677321434021,
1.2050740718841553,
0.10744120180606842,
-0.7104107141494751,
0.4672101140022278,
-0.9457489848136902,
-0.1701808124780655,
0.059639617800712585,
-0.15019164979457855,
-0.15833397209644318,
0.07060842961072922,
-0.16143186390399933,
0.17617060244083405,
-0.07477542757987976,
-0.049030665308237076,
-0.13662835955619812,
-0.5862098336219788,
0.27846646308898926,
-0.09157657623291016,
0.2734445035457611,
0.2436174899339676,
-0.14061927795410156,
0.13712787628173828,
-0.9780287146568298,
-0.037554532289505005,
0.30458366870880127,
-0.7216998338699341,
-0.7322060465812683,
0.1472650170326233,
0.062320806086063385,
0.08039408922195435,
0.4403570890426636,
-0.42248809337615967,
0.9670408368110657,
-0.46189507842063904,
0.075138621032238,
0.7143171429634094,
-0.19126997888088226,
0.5415303111076355,
-0.5382575392723083,
0.3416169583797455,
-0.3993607759475708,
0.018181363120675087,
-0.6082550883293152,
-0.4054200351238251,
-0.8384111523628235,
-0.43833982944488525,
0.2923545241355896,
0.6664191484451294,
-0.5788862109184265,
0.3697771430015564,
-0.26744797825813293,
-0.43829232454299927,
-0.5904381275177002,
0.2770748436450958,
0.3849453330039978,
0.44464585185050964,
0.3611873388290405,
-0.2526455223560333,
-0.43936294317245483,
-0.9411779642105103,
-0.3373037576675415,
-0.1255556344985962,
-0.1189369261264801,
0.07791582494974136,
0.435695081949234,
-0.4640962481498718,
1.2324546575546265,
-0.7126243114471436,
-0.3147072196006775,
0.01739225909113884,
0.38108381628990173,
-0.05711215361952782,
0.5565131306648254,
0.20818102359771729,
-0.7437409162521362,
-0.47816556692123413,
0.1506066769361496,
-0.6988747119903564,
-0.723924458026886,
-0.33204784989356995,
-0.2024182677268982,
0.4808781147003174,
0.5971515774726868,
-0.4029376208782196,
0.4149450957775116,
0.04555445909500122,
-0.24588172137737274,
0.4753626585006714,
-0.6197329163551331,
0.15144093334674835,
-0.8557869791984558,
0.17000485956668854,
-0.09490659832954407,
-0.14959418773651123,
-0.4745732247829437,
0.3088694214820862,
0.24821262061595917,
0.03151080384850502,
-0.20432843267917633,
0.6627205014228821,
-0.6908853054046631,
-0.10951831191778183,
-0.688238263130188,
0.26080620288848877,
0.32427284121513367,
0.24338997900485992,
-0.12366140633821487,
0.707168698310852,
0.10001172125339508,
-0.30958542227745056,
0.49427199363708496,
-0.0005095324013382196,
0.10599476099014282,
0.659916877746582,
-0.26940926909446716,
0.25839054584503174,
-0.15660949051380157,
0.13078871369361877,
-0.8569642901420593,
-0.2718966603279114,
0.5862926244735718,
-0.29987481236457825,
0.7742569446563721,
-0.14922139048576355,
-1.1699641942977905,
-0.01985110156238079,
-0.4427749514579773,
-0.325680673122406,
0.29523903131484985,
-0.33552461862564087,
0.753744900226593,
0.2668122947216034,
0.16014501452445984,
-0.414652943611145,
-0.6628591418266296,
0.646030604839325,
-0.038979146629571915,
-0.6619654893875122,
0.5750033855438232,
-0.14140555262565613,
-0.5672678351402283,
0.1500813066959381,
-0.07061848044395447,
0.016256418079137802,
0.42463967204093933,
0.5334362387657166,
0.24688148498535156,
0.025692109018564224,
0.46124494075775146,
-0.10847074538469315,
-0.6026775240898132,
-0.005150388460606337,
-0.37075528502464294,
0.2542286813259125,
-0.08042258024215698,
-0.5661545395851135,
-0.2657819092273712,
0.4075097143650055,
0.4120784103870392,
-0.4574766755104065,
0.5424473285675049,
0.6251516938209534,
-0.5636236071586609,
-0.3068394362926483,
-0.41947314143180847,
0.24088352918624878,
-0.49269890785217285,
0.01667138934135437,
-0.47041192650794983,
-0.26063376665115356,
0.37499919533729553,
-0.19334886968135834,
0.2080214023590088,
0.39409342408180237,
0.37113988399505615,
-0.23216311633586884,
0.7314050197601318,
0.9230186939239502,
0.14014190435409546,
0.6878437995910645,
-0.058219440281391144,
0.022186849266290665,
-0.7492393255233765,
-0.22764435410499573,
-0.4414418637752533,
-0.2763030230998993,
-0.44895464181900024,
-0.46865352988243103,
-0.051764655858278275,
0.25266221165657043,
0.07549893856048584,
0.3213632106781006,
-0.797150731086731,
0.6321359276771545,
0.7937670350074768,
-0.3629697263240814,
0.6198115348815918,
-0.19100607931613922,
-0.10407652705907822,
-0.19192691147327423,
-0.16366608440876007,
-0.9676841497421265,
0.8068554997444153,
0.4260982573032379,
1.0533479452133179,
-0.1493774801492691,
0.7238900065422058,
0.4765712320804596,
0.8274968266487122,
-0.7239115834236145,
0.6677000522613525,
0.1726127415895462,
-0.41307660937309265,
0.006320534739643335,
0.05855643004179001,
-0.7825863361358643,
0.1068948432803154,
-0.18152813613414764,
-0.892381489276886,
-0.3220396339893341,
0.2438201755285263,
0.08996905386447906,
0.30223190784454346,
-0.9992436170578003,
0.6494054794311523,
-0.16743344068527222,
-0.4236294627189636,
0.09369198977947235,
-0.5393819808959961,
0.0749930590391159,
-0.2703495919704437,
0.033435724675655365,
-0.3141658306121826,
-0.46314793825149536,
0.5203460454940796,
-0.6402664184570312,
0.6981492638587952,
0.062424153089523315,
-0.2625771462917328,
0.16114220023155212,
0.2567695379257202,
0.6131332516670227,
-0.31671616435050964,
-0.025583263486623764,
-0.14428894221782684,
0.17598901689052582,
-0.14664927124977112,
-0.8752711415290833,
0.737034261226654,
-0.48551520705223083,
-0.7032721042633057,
-0.6675763726234436,
-0.753474771976471,
-0.02042074128985405,
0.25846776366233826,
-0.230600968003273,
0.3014757037162781,
0.22251535952091217,
-0.2015327364206314,
0.5193797945976257,
-0.15843240916728973,
0.597609281539917,
0.690758228302002,
-0.328102707862854,
-0.09207204729318619,
0.9410916566848755,
0.3303171694278717,
0.046812787652015686,
0.5977500081062317,
0.0906611829996109,
-0.07218915969133377,
-0.5661942958831787,
-0.3480353355407715,
0.14525939524173737,
-0.951661229133606,
-0.14602982997894287,
-0.7348707914352417,
0.01823822781443596,
-0.11755099147558212,
-0.5467758178710938,
-0.19213537871837616,
-0.39159268140792847,
-0.4393673241138458,
0.01680169813334942,
0.39028745889663696,
0.7943482398986816,
0.09422432631254196,
0.1288205087184906,
-0.9446589946746826,
0.12669526040554047,
-0.15252278745174408,
0.4955417215824127,
-0.3611604869365692,
-0.18299990892410278,
-0.4244998097419739,
-0.25510939955711365,
-0.3520626723766327,
-0.903506338596344,
0.3033597767353058,
0.12320980429649353,
0.5959085822105408,
0.05152146890759468,
0.02595381811261177,
0.4440739154815674,
-0.6059238314628601,
0.6717631220817566,
-0.22724346816539764,
-0.8853365778923035,
0.7108508944511414,
-0.506627082824707,
0.2860970199108124,
0.39166268706321716,
0.228592187166214,
-0.6159809827804565,
-0.4957067668437958,
-0.4978969097137451,
-0.7487642168998718,
0.5142887830734253,
0.016140978783369064,
0.03059854730963707,
-0.06959378719329834,
0.3675491213798523,
-0.08188249170780182,
0.2007230520248413,
-0.44192659854888916,
-0.2903200089931488,
-0.04094495624303818,
-0.29185760021209717,
0.15421463549137115,
-0.07485219091176987,
-0.19120202958583832,
0.0071800751611590385,
0.7330618500709534,
-0.3575669527053833,
0.2033337950706482,
0.11981337517499924,
-0.30259454250335693,
0.00643302034586668,
0.3183151185512543,
0.6898987293243408,
0.8320837616920471,
-0.3450656831264496,
0.43232953548431396,
0.0720931887626648,
-0.576509416103363,
-0.09876775741577148,
0.2817724347114563,
-0.024238374084234238,
-0.080189548432827,
0.45263320207595825,
0.24487070739269257,
0.22213222086429596,
-0.6075073480606079,
0.1544654816389084,
0.06706105172634125,
0.17723938822746277,
-0.40101951360702515,
0.31090298295021057,
0.08129578828811646,
0.09835774451494217,
0.3395698666572571,
-0.02287682145833969,
0.06703756749629974,
-0.5949795842170715,
0.19380922615528107,
0.4074152708053589,
-0.24811165034770966,
-0.11338059604167938,
0.5606362819671631,
0.066372349858284,
-0.5929666757583618,
0.21657946705818176,
-0.39433008432388306,
-0.3760550320148468,
0.5908174514770508,
0.6724342703819275,
0.7293410301208496,
0.126738503575325,
-0.10524380207061768,
-0.26851269602775574,
0.5330998301506042,
0.16310063004493713,
0.2737375497817993,
0.015334292314946651,
-0.5731582045555115,
-0.22184742987155914,
-0.6109022498130798,
-0.5718541145324707,
-0.23763878643512726,
-0.1797465682029724,
0.37709420919418335,
-0.6247542500495911,
-0.24447034299373627,
0.17748552560806274,
0.40989944338798523,
-0.46046972274780273,
0.40160638093948364,
0.24400673806667328,
1.218373417854309,
-0.6203131079673767,
1.0463157892227173,
1.0149991512298584,
-0.7136365175247192,
-0.6084218621253967,
-0.10619478672742844,
0.07239743322134018,
-0.6400333642959595,
0.8155590891838074,
0.03429275378584862,
-0.09341873973608017,
0.017923662438988686,
-0.4913919270038605,
-0.8070757389068604,
1.1536028385162354,
0.26557815074920654,
-0.18589669466018677,
0.0819985568523407,
0.072708360850811,
0.6767756938934326,
-0.35666123032569885,
0.33833786845207214,
0.6418290734291077,
0.8747714161872864,
-0.06441736966371536,
-0.7979469299316406,
0.13844597339630127,
-0.4630119204521179,
0.12608136236667633,
0.40094104409217834,
-0.3614484965801239,
0.41019219160079956,
-0.020830685272812843,
-0.34140726923942566,
-0.14472538232803345,
0.42389601469039917,
0.018819084390997887,
0.5231235027313232,
0.04103802889585495,
0.668973445892334,
0.8664141297340393,
-0.34912845492362976,
1.3506536483764648,
-0.5428014993667603,
0.11587761342525482,
1.3053325414657593,
-0.24084848165512085,
0.5507274270057678,
0.41165295243263245,
-0.12814465165138245,
0.35409390926361084,
0.5908083915710449,
-0.4232613444328308,
0.1387440413236618,
0.42864149808883667,
-0.24324485659599304,
-0.024204328656196594,
-0.4961532950401306,
-0.41379064321517944,
0.3665587306022644,
0.46613505482673645,
-0.5827637910842896,
-0.18595468997955322,
-0.2912507653236389,
0.5175849795341492,
0.2994391620159149,
-0.2100277692079544,
0.6162168383598328,
-0.019909590482711792,
-0.4254450500011444,
0.015786228701472282,
0.5291184782981873,
0.6513906717300415,
-0.7070441246032715,
-0.3050919771194458,
-0.06935548037290573,
0.20354625582695007,
-0.4962373375892639,
-0.8059894442558289,
0.5687218904495239,
-0.28992587327957153,
-0.3349192440509796,
-0.36277392506599426,
1.1819795370101929,
-0.24690045416355133,
-0.35130617022514343,
0.11250664293766022,
0.2704874873161316,
0.010967434383928776,
0.05657511577010155,
-0.5864835381507874,
0.3603785037994385,
-0.4946593940258026,
-0.19287902116775513,
0.3528461158275604,
0.3604733943939209,
-0.22054728865623474,
0.7943709492683411,
0.8421914577484131,
0.07545312494039536,
0.1696358174085617,
0.027491804212331772,
0.985568106174469,
-0.6142064929008484,
-0.43820151686668396,
-0.9503911137580872,
0.5108990669250488,
-0.1742141842842102,
-0.01930413953959942,
1.0175316333770752,
0.5219928622245789,
0.6786890029907227,
0.018615100532770157,
0.7905306220054626,
0.21035951375961304,
0.04841853305697441,
-0.48092857003211975,
0.856201708316803,
-0.36617332696914673,
0.3005245625972748,
-0.5259759426116943,
-0.9902623295783997,
-0.748142659664154,
0.3921230435371399,
-0.46507498621940613,
-0.12442599982023239,
0.7129559516906738,
0.885399341583252,
0.13093794882297516,
-0.22723139822483063,
0.3098904490470886,
-0.2566984295845032,
0.5501566529273987,
0.27077382802963257,
0.8795051574707031,
-0.22777436673641205,
0.1961500495672226,
0.014599180780351162,
-0.3071309030056,
-0.2300688624382019,
-1.3043415546417236,
-0.6461431384086609,
-0.506929337978363,
-0.6054092049598694,
-0.3972536325454712,
-0.02568243443965912,
1.2618434429168701,
0.5854436755180359,
-0.38705524802207947,
0.24399609863758087,
0.24897950887680054,
0.26912733912467957,
-0.03968939185142517,
-0.25491616129875183,
0.27453044056892395,
-0.4904074966907501,
-0.7736689448356628,
0.2940504550933838,
0.8325895071029663,
0.10948404669761658,
-0.2551748752593994,
0.18841879069805145,
-0.21344013512134552,
0.3410091996192932,
0.3660617768764496,
0.43994763493537903,
-0.5999868512153625,
-0.47712641954421997,
-0.24527162313461304,
-0.3539877235889435,
0.17956669628620148,
0.8306990265846252,
-0.591586172580719,
0.6855626702308655,
0.43972137570381165,
0.83620285987854,
-0.000008404254913330078,
0.06779922544956207,
0.38857725262641907,
-0.7630898952484131,
-0.25428077578544617,
-0.09749138355255127,
0.3709372878074646,
0.49961796402931213,
-0.3920615315437317,
0.62799072265625,
0.5634477734565735,
-0.4903624653816223,
-0.6261849403381348,
0.11680343002080917,
-0.8855112195014954,
-0.25706496834754944,
1.0668816566467285,
-0.25889572501182556,
-0.28315240144729614,
-0.19550678133964539,
-0.5531585216522217,
0.28693535923957825,
-0.31508198380470276,
0.6051533818244934,
0.7663004994392395,
-0.2884082794189453,
-0.030669160187244415,
-0.5996541380882263,
0.5581620931625366,
-0.25429990887641907,
-1.0904303789138794,
-0.06590592116117477,
0.6405594348907471,
0.38814154267311096,
0.5837007761001587,
0.8670230507850647,
0.0007921427022665739,
-0.12806396186351776,
0.1880270391702652,
0.41966789960861206,
-0.7126502990722656,
-0.27316343784332275,
-0.12922337651252747,
0.21026819944381714,
0.19170261919498444,
-0.3253403604030609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03435v1
|
VLSP 2023 -- LTER: A Summary of the Challenge on Legal Textual Entailment Recognition
| 2024-03-06T03:42:06 | 2024-03-06T03:42:06 |
Vu Tran, Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Trung Vo, Son T. Luu, Hoang-Anh Dang, Ngoc-Cam Le, Thi-Thuy Le, Minh-Tien Nguyen, Truong-Son Nguyen, Le-Minh Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this new era of rapid AI development, especially in language processing,
the demand for AI in the legal domain is increasingly critical. In the context
where research in other languages such as English, Japanese, and Chinese has
been well-established, we introduce the first fundamental research for the
Vietnamese language in the legal domain: legal textual entailment recognition
through the Vietnamese Language and Speech Processing workshop. In analyzing
participants' results, we discuss certain linguistic aspects critical in the
legal domain that pose challenges that need to be addressed.
|
[
-0.09226704388856888,
-0.8320522308349609,
0.8013008832931519,
0.03833432123064995,
-0.2719569802284241,
-0.21738699078559875,
-0.054347164928913116,
-0.8262639045715332,
-0.09854663908481598,
1.1933729648590088,
-0.2590808868408203,
-0.34513941407203674,
-0.6827604174613953,
0.1940586119890213,
-0.42740491032600403,
0.619551420211792,
-0.32613998651504517,
-0.19613340497016907,
-0.2704162895679474,
-0.5295119881629944,
-0.6738290190696716,
-0.7305209636688232,
-0.8200374245643616,
-0.25104856491088867,
0.13340970873832703,
0.18714964389801025,
0.23969686031341553,
0.8164101839065552,
0.7339859008789062,
0.37599295377731323,
0.05793345347046852,
-0.052678339183330536,
-0.15623390674591064,
0.39667052030563354,
0.03344064950942993,
-0.562933623790741,
-0.363983154296875,
-0.05336078256368637,
0.5559288859367371,
0.2983611524105072,
-0.01545379962772131,
-0.08019942790269852,
-0.3680047392845154,
0.8336535692214966,
-0.5684350728988647,
0.12915614247322083,
-0.7239709496498108,
0.18060380220413208,
-0.37600648403167725,
-0.5177647471427917,
-0.46800073981285095,
-0.08553805947303772,
0.4926068186759949,
-0.7091402411460876,
0.1555052548646927,
-0.0848858579993248,
1.0744166374206543,
0.6862758994102478,
-0.6692126989364624,
-0.38522112369537354,
-0.7024645805358887,
0.3280687630176544,
-0.4908490777015686,
0.46889179944992065,
0.6226388216018677,
0.37886112928390503,
0.052742019295692444,
-1.0449776649475098,
-0.6815314292907715,
-0.3452374339103699,
0.034954264760017395,
0.19888298213481903,
-0.3483213782310486,
0.14779123663902283,
0.3109797537326813,
0.040275078266859055,
-0.6472067832946777,
0.249024897813797,
-0.4789624810218811,
-0.3088451325893402,
0.7189012169837952,
0.16840222477912903,
0.36198654770851135,
0.0381629578769207,
0.040732815861701965,
0.39184096455574036,
-0.6847307085990906,
-0.03441951051354408,
0.10273800790309906,
-0.03078412637114525,
-0.08626672625541687,
0.8325554728507996,
-0.14361883699893951,
0.5914996266365051,
-0.3129035234451294,
0.05656646192073822,
0.42254915833473206,
-0.5094068050384521,
-0.2987167537212372,
0.26235857605934143,
0.7447878122329712,
0.17458917200565338,
0.2864362597465515,
0.31148818135261536,
-0.22684571146965027,
-0.347332239151001,
0.1100955605506897,
-0.2952847182750702,
0.2262861728668213,
0.5691666603088379,
-0.5393015146255493,
0.11832822114229202,
0.229175865650177,
-0.3709821105003357,
-0.5122825503349304,
-0.7666825652122498,
0.06207681819796562,
-0.422630250453949,
-0.1708974540233612,
0.4484701454639435,
-0.34187963604927063,
0.8979936242103577,
0.6422443985939026,
-0.4139370918273926,
0.11932869255542755,
0.9509978890419006,
0.5099312663078308,
0.14016658067703247,
-0.23092864453792572,
-0.7608906030654907,
0.46453386545181274,
0.060175083577632904,
0.7715117335319519,
-0.7005453705787659,
-0.2621834874153137,
0.2761480510234833,
0.22635145485401154,
-0.013632933609187603,
-0.6633484959602356,
0.7733839154243469,
-0.33283141255378723,
0.2747795879840851,
0.019264627248048782,
-0.5923739671707153,
-0.18082204461097717,
0.38181596994400024,
-0.6694628000259399,
0.7306070923805237,
0.1188412755727768,
-0.6468597650527954,
0.6119019985198975,
-0.6578918099403381,
-0.46361467242240906,
0.6666817665100098,
-0.5572799444198608,
-0.678238570690155,
-0.05655696615576744,
-0.02539473958313465,
0.14715367555618286,
-0.27053341269493103,
0.3239958882331848,
0.27978795766830444,
-0.20927192270755768,
0.18362662196159363,
-0.41515201330184937,
0.9991627931594849,
0.21532824635505676,
-0.4896079897880554,
0.4401266872882843,
-0.9399939179420471,
-0.1816173493862152,
0.23399436473846436,
-0.5422434210777283,
-0.34786203503608704,
0.0970170721411705,
0.2337953746318817,
-0.06074824929237366,
0.5034462809562683,
-0.3033890128135681,
0.06825882941484451,
-0.41794806718826294,
0.6827993392944336,
0.5408913493156433,
-0.006490468978881836,
0.3691039979457855,
-0.005175834055989981,
0.4986180067062378,
-0.17760349810123444,
-0.0005275551229715347,
-0.33805763721466064,
-0.712296724319458,
-1.0257102251052856,
-0.2141863852739334,
0.2504587173461914,
0.8811551928520203,
-0.7241197824478149,
0.2748780846595764,
-0.1671198308467865,
-0.12018083781003952,
-0.9999423623085022,
-0.14565002918243408,
0.24924319982528687,
-0.10313311219215393,
0.24841338396072388,
0.2510477900505066,
-1.1476625204086304,
-0.8887394666671753,
-0.4318529963493347,
-0.5185704231262207,
-0.050787270069122314,
0.11079511046409607,
0.5811475515365601,
-0.5572614073753357,
0.7751904726028442,
-0.1744382083415985,
-0.6624083518981934,
-0.31539440155029297,
0.3979967534542084,
0.03592665493488312,
0.33430933952331543,
0.487205445766449,
-1.171558141708374,
-0.7173963189125061,
0.6327184438705444,
-0.9879127740859985,
-0.24896764755249023,
-0.0019950270652770996,
0.17355987429618835,
0.3836876451969147,
1.1749260425567627,
-0.4462595582008362,
0.6244082450866699,
-0.09962109476327896,
-0.6637881994247437,
0.2486446499824524,
-0.46863970160484314,
0.06872275471687317,
-0.6772516965866089,
-0.24770019948482513,
-0.15213847160339355,
-0.40654560923576355,
-0.7534910440444946,
0.4464041590690613,
-0.0869642049074173,
0.008326437324285507,
-0.5689201354980469,
0.4171043932437897,
-0.3513127267360687,
0.2904408574104309,
-0.46178463101387024,
-0.0008050687611103058,
-0.4124927818775177,
-0.1490064114332199,
0.1317370980978012,
0.5444000363349915,
0.5061274766921997,
-0.6308924555778503,
0.35392463207244873,
-0.015458371490240097,
0.043926727026700974,
0.7928925156593323,
-0.6626396179199219,
0.1222892701625824,
-0.39726224541664124,
-0.042995624244213104,
-0.30688604712486267,
-0.3342452049255371,
0.3208363354206085,
-0.5003549456596375,
0.216977059841156,
-0.10155493766069412,
-0.3744681179523468,
-0.3434688448905945,
-0.12196959555149078,
0.4022262990474701,
0.5698267817497253,
0.050374481827020645,
0.9325430989265442,
0.6711894273757935,
0.10064547508955002,
-0.5292564034461975,
-0.5332472324371338,
0.21601882576942444,
-0.505584716796875,
-0.1879594624042511,
0.23259615898132324,
0.3529956340789795,
-0.651858925819397,
-0.003689505159854889,
0.32404062151908875,
-0.3058282732963562,
0.033275216817855835,
0.1860635131597519,
-0.04069434851408005,
-0.3726879954338074,
-0.17505879700183868,
-0.2194727063179016,
-0.367529034614563,
0.4543842673301697,
-0.3883219361305237,
0.39043134450912476,
-0.13111332058906555,
-0.25457385182380676,
-0.6384138464927673,
0.364698588848114,
0.48336195945739746,
-0.3451273441314697,
0.28677067160606384,
0.649412214756012,
-0.6165571212768555,
0.08793994039297104,
-0.6980289220809937,
0.4633474051952362,
-0.47499966621398926,
0.5412498116493225,
-0.3495076298713684,
-1.3026061058044434,
0.046688955277204514,
0.14454373717308044,
0.030520770698785782,
0.804132878780365,
0.6640344262123108,
-0.08694532513618469,
0.47274208068847656,
1.1015535593032837,
-0.08774107694625854,
0.3164771497249603,
0.21161051094532013,
0.14688193798065186,
-0.3563425540924072,
-0.3497668206691742,
-0.9594542384147644,
0.3430978059768677,
-1.0577068328857422,
-0.5571963787078857,
0.3095676600933075,
-0.5136328935623169,
-0.1516232192516327,
0.7620096206665039,
-0.2619996964931488,
0.5735354423522949,
0.6911612153053284,
-0.1222359761595726,
0.44924888014793396,
-0.13601529598236084,
0.2415047585964203,
-0.2999138832092285,
-0.21010449528694153,
-0.7174211740493774,
0.855649471282959,
0.5390711426734924,
0.045708056539297104,
-0.04904405400156975,
0.7343905568122864,
0.37887611985206604,
-0.18197393417358398,
-0.8274598121643066,
0.7483850717544556,
-0.29031845927238464,
-0.3805118501186371,
-0.5126247406005859,
-0.29508090019226074,
-1.226812481880188,
0.12744227051734924,
-0.12577368319034576,
-0.6595618724822998,
0.06114031746983528,
-0.35763734579086304,
0.08396071940660477,
0.01258106715977192,
-0.1848781257867813,
0.6461565494537354,
-0.10184739530086517,
-0.17664672434329987,
-0.20853762328624725,
-0.6367462277412415,
0.10329098254442215,
-0.1737665832042694,
0.37263616919517517,
-0.15283682942390442,
-0.06725497543811798,
0.8817358613014221,
-0.4511764347553253,
0.4365958869457245,
-0.09659140557050705,
-0.3208642601966858,
0.7333235740661621,
-0.22814232110977173,
0.24191942811012268,
0.22988879680633545,
0.1576140820980072,
-0.25159114599227905,
0.07966647297143936,
-0.2012380063533783,
-0.26712384819984436,
0.05586806684732437,
-0.5068191289901733,
-0.8205743432044983,
-0.6769246459007263,
-0.3619857430458069,
0.25113585591316223,
0.44638311862945557,
0.29392746090888977,
-0.30643951892852783,
-0.3437866270542145,
0.17307397723197937,
0.6494368314743042,
-0.3837543725967407,
0.2636496126651764,
1.027209758758545,
-0.1631120890378952,
-0.290172278881073,
1.2560639381408691,
0.17365378141403198,
-0.36549317836761475,
0.7329918742179871,
0.01688363030552864,
-0.2159615159034729,
-0.6779334545135498,
-0.13116829097270966,
0.3161108195781708,
-0.8689245581626892,
0.14430317282676697,
-0.9116489887237549,
-0.6256491541862488,
-0.2658437192440033,
-0.19703660905361176,
-0.13798515498638153,
-0.2949540913105011,
-0.24635004997253418,
-0.039827875792980194,
0.23195809125900269,
1.117214560508728,
0.24781739711761475,
0.07945016771554947,
-0.8022065162658691,
0.5054317116737366,
0.27250269055366516,
-0.015590690076351166,
-0.6647629737854004,
-0.661879301071167,
-0.029444526880979538,
-0.15517935156822205,
-0.3197631537914276,
-0.3423570692539215,
0.1790582835674286,
0.23297786712646484,
0.716056227684021,
0.316358357667923,
-0.006551889702677727,
0.4625726342201233,
-0.8794984817504883,
0.7055330276489258,
-0.18703477084636688,
-1.0052663087844849,
0.9112752676010132,
-0.2502273917198181,
0.10273627191781998,
0.4886649549007416,
0.40027183294296265,
-0.40483057498931885,
-0.7159544825553894,
-0.5043191909790039,
-0.9918797612190247,
0.3683602213859558,
0.5032459497451782,
0.11555542051792145,
0.1911153793334961,
0.4082670211791992,
0.15753215551376343,
0.05504326894879341,
-0.8681313991546631,
0.08751066029071808,
0.21252527832984924,
-0.051932193338871,
0.3034284710884094,
-0.23875264823436737,
0.09616165608167648,
-0.49041399359703064,
0.18178188800811768,
0.05810727924108505,
0.369370698928833,
0.11774071305990219,
-0.06103722006082535,
0.10851001739501953,
0.313314288854599,
0.7196482419967651,
0.6181085109710693,
-0.06096425652503967,
0.06576137244701385,
0.1184549480676651,
-0.6876950263977051,
0.25578927993774414,
0.0035478491336107254,
-0.35293012857437134,
0.25883030891418457,
0.9104245901107788,
0.7908551096916199,
-0.26137933135032654,
-0.8975528478622437,
0.5488932728767395,
-0.1015387624502182,
-0.7101759910583496,
-0.7856918573379517,
-0.034485895186662674,
-0.33032265305519104,
0.24535919725894928,
0.38349050283432007,
-0.2109757959842682,
0.3740631937980652,
-0.7252210378646851,
0.32522696256637573,
0.17125670611858368,
-0.6733388304710388,
0.05362274870276451,
0.8652942776679993,
-0.09379303455352783,
-0.36542725563049316,
0.5030790567398071,
-0.0873035341501236,
-0.7088892459869385,
0.8510737419128418,
0.3433631658554077,
1.106606364250183,
-0.006563270464539528,
0.08763765543699265,
0.3757557272911072,
0.5076833963394165,
-0.19904035329818726,
0.6190065145492554,
0.09581565111875534,
-0.41256508231163025,
-0.24366256594657898,
-0.24886484444141388,
-0.5811665654182434,
-0.03752041608095169,
-0.491563081741333,
0.6273578405380249,
-0.2596838176250458,
-0.0791347399353981,
0.008080191910266876,
-0.35512569546699524,
-0.6993990540504456,
0.1733926236629486,
0.0850103497505188,
0.5493361949920654,
-0.23409296572208405,
0.8688857555389404,
0.7125160694122314,
-0.4764746427536011,
-0.04435168206691742,
0.10101746767759323,
0.2592005133628845,
-0.8353148102760315,
0.8297489881515503,
0.2550593316555023,
0.09170649200677872,
-0.09861323237419128,
-0.8039423227310181,
-0.2933138310909271,
1.0453407764434814,
0.19675467908382416,
-0.3016131520271301,
-0.10306316614151001,
0.7238664031028748,
0.7411023378372192,
-0.26872652769088745,
0.06073315441608429,
0.9546992182731628,
0.6598265767097473,
-0.14826799929141998,
-1.065002679824829,
0.016606677323579788,
-0.321076363325119,
-0.19403904676437378,
0.02972075343132019,
-0.3268904983997345,
0.7925738096237183,
0.015415131114423275,
-0.40064531564712524,
-0.07656890898942947,
0.9672614336013794,
0.4179447591304779,
0.7384375333786011,
0.21773061156272888,
0.3660130202770233,
0.646249532699585,
-0.36992835998535156,
0.7127810716629028,
-0.02924235910177231,
-0.008739552460610867,
1.0022259950637817,
-0.4392384886741638,
0.9085221290588379,
0.5779489278793335,
-0.49765652418136597,
-0.005203893408179283,
0.297421395778656,
0.010921752080321312,
0.19948242604732513,
0.2532646358013153,
-0.12151961773633957,
0.13420508801937103,
-0.571420431137085,
-0.563484787940979,
0.7147170305252075,
0.6351842880249023,
-0.14192098379135132,
0.2547565996646881,
0.15905295312404633,
-0.09425053000450134,
0.3884793519973755,
-0.1986866146326065,
1.164506196975708,
0.12050376832485199,
-0.5013604164123535,
0.3355552852153778,
0.24374985694885254,
0.6308565139770508,
-0.6318345069885254,
-0.2792132794857025,
0.026509445160627365,
-0.0017966888844966888,
-0.12802448868751526,
-1.044906735420227,
0.5738013982772827,
0.03345309570431709,
0.16509796679019928,
-0.15973255038261414,
0.5665410757064819,
-0.32972919940948486,
-0.2531791031360626,
0.5643067359924316,
0.45769309997558594,
0.265630304813385,
-0.07770191133022308,
-0.47191378474235535,
0.30050984025001526,
-0.17237235605716705,
0.10352451354265213,
0.11793641000986099,
1.212814211845398,
-0.12105977535247803,
0.6314570903778076,
0.33693480491638184,
-0.01067420095205307,
0.19297504425048828,
0.23559461534023285,
0.7692037224769592,
-0.8977212309837341,
-0.42853182554244995,
-0.8428077697753906,
0.4605675935745239,
0.0012896517291665077,
-0.3499765694141388,
0.5973265767097473,
0.49746766686439514,
0.9682358503341675,
-0.04963502660393715,
0.9640671014785767,
-0.26394346356391907,
0.07363896816968918,
-0.949863612651825,
0.6342321038246155,
-0.4916989505290985,
0.1516239196062088,
-0.2292664647102356,
-0.7136799693107605,
-0.3984386622905731,
0.5797572731971741,
0.03769141063094139,
-0.25104570388793945,
0.8436939716339111,
0.09728503227233887,
0.2862792909145355,
0.016974929720163345,
0.5269205570220947,
0.015329352580010891,
0.5603752732276917,
0.5297744870185852,
0.7251783013343811,
-0.7162740230560303,
0.34860163927078247,
-0.12755711376667023,
0.2107083946466446,
-0.1430448740720749,
-0.6162072420120239,
-0.9563944339752197,
-0.8935067057609558,
-0.3335806727409363,
-0.5001382827758789,
0.01978004351258278,
0.8813205361366272,
0.10284151881933212,
-1.0028337240219116,
-0.5871767997741699,
-0.3118729591369629,
-0.01078810729086399,
-0.04263162612915039,
-0.2488591969013214,
0.18936163187026978,
-0.32931211590766907,
-0.7721378803253174,
0.24602994322776794,
0.5751126408576965,
0.2868955433368683,
0.0838199332356453,
-0.2869088351726532,
-0.3840828537940979,
-0.09217985719442368,
0.8289042711257935,
0.41773146390914917,
-1.0080959796905518,
-0.25885307788848877,
-0.19999869167804718,
-0.19212374091148376,
0.0823848694562912,
1.2463018894195557,
-0.4087703227996826,
0.5645047426223755,
0.570203423500061,
1.104581356048584,
0.241617813706398,
-0.25678321719169617,
0.8588411808013916,
-0.18528880178928375,
0.4996441602706909,
0.2694760262966156,
0.5672405958175659,
-0.04192689061164856,
-0.4555247724056244,
1.0122984647750854,
0.420223206281662,
-0.5636535286903381,
-0.7236472368240356,
0.39628395438194275,
-0.8690004944801331,
-0.0937657430768013,
0.78754723072052,
-0.1299806833267212,
-0.20077595114707947,
-0.9315404891967773,
-0.6943747401237488,
0.3020470142364502,
-0.10395585000514984,
0.2723067104816437,
0.7887548208236694,
0.08669482916593552,
-0.5530680418014526,
-1.1602473258972168,
0.47110798954963684,
0.23647715151309967,
-0.8254492878913879,
-0.07905063033103943,
0.29455605149269104,
-0.2629912495613098,
-0.042056549340486526,
1.0598399639129639,
-0.21922987699508667,
0.3719192147254944,
0.07908639311790466,
-0.3103501498699188,
0.148686945438385,
-0.2942408621311188,
-0.3193584680557251,
0.1597490906715393,
0.17651718854904175,
0.2528733015060425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03432v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03432v1
|
Mixture-of-LoRAs: An Efficient Multitask Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-06T03:33:48 | 2024-03-06T03:33:48 |
Wenfeng Feng, Chuzhan Hao, Yuewei Zhang, Yu Han, Hao Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction Tuning has the potential to stimulate or enhance specific
capabilities of large language models (LLMs). However, achieving the right
balance of data is crucial to prevent catastrophic forgetting and interference
between tasks. To address these limitations and enhance training flexibility,
we propose the Mixture-of-LoRAs (MoA) architecture which is a novel and
parameter-efficient tuning method designed for multi-task learning with LLMs.
In this paper, we start by individually training multiple domain-specific LoRA
modules using corresponding supervised corpus data. These LoRA modules can be
aligned with the expert design principles observed in Mixture-of-Experts (MoE).
Subsequently, we combine the multiple LoRAs using an explicit routing strategy
and introduce domain labels to facilitate multi-task learning, which help
prevent interference between tasks and ultimately enhances the performance of
each individual task. Furthermore, each LoRA model can be iteratively adapted
to a new domain, allowing for quick domain-specific adaptation. Experiments on
diverse tasks demonstrate superior and robust performance, which can further
promote the wide application of domain-specific LLMs.
|
[
-0.48848581314086914,
-0.998069167137146,
0.3522777557373047,
0.08479264378547668,
-0.3516874611377716,
0.318930447101593,
-0.33934369683265686,
-0.1268516182899475,
0.42640548944473267,
0.6883536577224731,
-0.6145891547203064,
-0.42867162823677063,
-0.6611648201942444,
-0.29190680384635925,
-0.12913855910301208,
0.79264897108078,
0.05615413933992386,
-0.09680033475160599,
-0.12520036101341248,
-0.366224467754364,
-0.7124839425086975,
-0.3568311333656311,
-0.5285633206367493,
-0.3233258128166199,
0.8164075613021851,
0.45501357316970825,
0.2237006574869156,
0.8283243179321289,
0.25176629424095154,
0.4399673342704773,
0.06700385361909866,
0.9233312606811523,
-0.486100971698761,
0.2627376616001129,
-0.3305944800376892,
-0.5198568105697632,
-0.7328201532363892,
-0.35919177532196045,
0.5693569779396057,
0.6527562141418457,
-0.4363085925579071,
-0.02112877368927002,
0.17695680260658264,
0.5917935371398926,
-0.8133035898208618,
-0.043540552258491516,
-0.8608039617538452,
-0.20057417452335358,
-0.4863865077495575,
-0.480747789144516,
-0.3014379143714905,
0.19363993406295776,
-0.1198192611336708,
-0.6631978154182434,
-0.047130003571510315,
0.1308862715959549,
0.4621827006340027,
0.5302173495292664,
-0.4257480204105377,
-0.15766313672065735,
-0.44268426299095154,
1.0352221727371216,
-0.6605983972549438,
0.16464050114154816,
0.23025579750537872,
0.13914284110069275,
-0.2452998161315918,
-0.014559713192284107,
-0.4839957654476166,
0.24479828774929047,
0.33579522371292114,
-0.005779560189694166,
0.14016909897327423,
-0.1080062985420227,
-0.06159818917512894,
0.27845194935798645,
-0.36311182379722595,
0.4141804873943329,
-0.10793949663639069,
0.054611071944236755,
0.29904431104660034,
0.22515180706977844,
0.1750352531671524,
0.3304346203804016,
-0.2702336013317108,
-0.09620236605405807,
-0.6756976246833801,
-0.24239446222782135,
0.7077867984771729,
0.4797057509422302,
-0.15988686680793762,
0.4493834376335144,
-0.20288848876953125,
1.0346273183822632,
0.25449031591415405,
-0.7228764295578003,
0.41835466027259827,
-0.08376326411962509,
-0.12008105218410492,
-0.24338436126708984,
0.6395381093025208,
-0.17580683529376984,
-0.07972027361392975,
-0.2447006106376648,
-0.2668319642543793,
0.17376279830932617,
0.3955102860927582,
-0.5143023729324341,
-0.06916750967502594,
0.12534739077091217,
-0.09706849604845047,
-0.1375436633825302,
-0.22001168131828308,
-0.7717300057411194,
-0.2510644793510437,
-0.6562508344650269,
0.6387678980827332,
-0.6130582690238953,
-0.2267599105834961,
0.41534653306007385,
0.23483023047447205,
-0.14826877415180206,
0.19013287127017975,
-1.0805577039718628,
0.37790510058403015,
0.7569774389266968,
0.493365079164505,
-0.5174202919006348,
-0.627468466758728,
-0.8495789170265198,
0.32161805033683777,
-0.08928345888853073,
0.8866024017333984,
-0.6990184187889099,
-0.2590969204902649,
-0.04893815517425537,
-0.2613113522529602,
-0.5789693593978882,
-0.7584976553916931,
0.25616219639778137,
-0.6446008682250977,
0.08368741720914841,
-0.04207652062177658,
-0.4549623727798462,
-0.2154187560081482,
0.15498633682727814,
-0.5544155240058899,
1.1368982791900635,
0.2153867930173874,
-0.45777493715286255,
0.1494038701057434,
-0.6936230659484863,
-0.8675675988197327,
-0.11972690373659134,
-0.19445878267288208,
-0.3246016502380371,
0.10113237053155899,
0.30464470386505127,
0.503631055355072,
-0.25702932476997375,
0.21755170822143555,
-0.07659882307052612,
-0.1517588049173355,
0.25665968656539917,
-0.08395441621541977,
0.5098009705543518,
0.16205620765686035,
-0.15734544396400452,
0.2742732763290405,
-0.8106499910354614,
0.021255357190966606,
-0.15702974796295166,
-0.6287239789962769,
-0.5189940333366394,
0.14430613815784454,
-0.07245220243930817,
0.18126142024993896,
0.35561031103134155,
-0.23018284142017365,
0.1978508085012436,
-0.15271620452404022,
0.39328810572624207,
0.6991153955459595,
-0.20863601565361023,
0.33622393012046814,
-0.5745799541473389,
0.4838274419307709,
0.34353724122047424,
-0.19197970628738403,
-0.2813498079776764,
-0.4953556954860687,
-1.0752100944519043,
-0.5170193910598755,
0.20742130279541016,
0.5091909170150757,
-0.9088523387908936,
0.9604657888412476,
-0.11579117923974991,
-0.468936949968338,
-0.5502558350563049,
0.621151328086853,
0.4238665699958801,
0.47984635829925537,
0.2607942819595337,
-0.3171520233154297,
-0.5384572148323059,
-0.6028338670730591,
-0.0107549037784338,
0.45499804615974426,
0.3700137734413147,
0.24551114439964294,
0.5534229874610901,
-0.2619343400001526,
0.7565350532531738,
-0.47157296538352966,
-0.44029486179351807,
-0.1762058585882187,
0.057294633239507675,
0.19229212403297424,
0.5676299333572388,
0.4116112291812897,
-0.5483336448669434,
-0.4975782334804535,
0.2154356837272644,
-0.483874648809433,
0.1173853725194931,
0.17624486982822418,
-0.43817344307899475,
0.05794595554471016,
0.2136688083410263,
-0.42177414894104004,
-0.26478391885757446,
0.8408331871032715,
-0.07783689349889755,
0.23207174241542816,
-0.44393235445022583,
0.15234921872615814,
-1.3676096200942993,
-0.11089061200618744,
-0.0499085858464241,
-0.14224545657634735,
-0.5720474123954773,
0.24426087737083435,
0.13898982107639313,
0.14017044007778168,
-0.39618948101997375,
0.4152940809726715,
-0.26534897089004517,
0.2752332091331482,
-0.520092248916626,
0.15410710871219635,
-0.029999786987900734,
0.7831050753593445,
-0.13851816952228546,
0.8367255926132202,
0.9607876539230347,
-0.9113163948059082,
0.2339441031217575,
0.20914487540721893,
-0.6299822926521301,
0.7739586234092712,
-0.28665605187416077,
0.44503119587898254,
-0.09735927730798721,
0.06533267349004745,
-0.7807157635688782,
-0.28143081068992615,
0.010553430765867233,
0.08437568694353104,
0.1987055540084839,
0.055276088416576385,
-0.5213437676429749,
0.04042387381196022,
-0.08482290804386139,
0.4524453580379486,
0.3918364346027374,
-0.5128166675567627,
1.1408673524856567,
0.6269172430038452,
-0.09927046298980713,
-0.6767773032188416,
-0.48289602994918823,
-0.1051429808139801,
-0.4570237994194031,
-0.6402484774589539,
0.5663601756095886,
-0.17881083488464355,
-0.13731566071510315,
-0.10394230484962463,
-0.06416186690330505,
-0.2235507220029831,
0.12206587940454483,
0.15860119462013245,
0.1701090782880783,
-0.3791624903678894,
-0.0526929572224617,
0.37221166491508484,
-0.07894209027290344,
-0.4569869339466095,
-0.2620886564254761,
0.845732569694519,
0.18700312077999115,
-0.576621949672699,
-0.2694379389286041,
0.5252661108970642,
0.5062360167503357,
-0.5492783784866333,
0.900422990322113,
0.5834265947341919,
-0.13975335657596588,
-0.6181833744049072,
-0.742524266242981,
0.02280348539352417,
-0.5396309494972229,
0.5811638832092285,
-0.5393621325492859,
-0.9687149524688721,
0.4410918653011322,
-0.14750657975673676,
0.18593159317970276,
0.2250295728445053,
0.808280885219574,
-0.036820147186517715,
0.6446965336799622,
0.6775746941566467,
-0.37798017263412476,
0.6006179451942444,
-0.18344156444072723,
0.1561330109834671,
-0.865111231803894,
-0.14943689107894897,
-0.5239208936691284,
-0.44174647331237793,
-0.05465732887387276,
-0.7197890281677246,
0.5174928903579712,
-0.13100816309452057,
-0.06643742322921753,
0.27878183126449585,
-0.15015427768230438,
0.7633752226829529,
0.5504801869392395,
0.33836624026298523,
0.2699357867240906,
0.16621538996696472,
0.1229298934340477,
0.3236018717288971,
-0.854886531829834,
-0.17411500215530396,
1.0296211242675781,
0.031454045325517654,
0.8814603090286255,
0.15730807185173035,
0.6915071606636047,
0.10644419491291046,
-0.15917326509952545,
-0.6278545260429382,
0.5506389141082764,
-0.5920875668525696,
-0.3770905137062073,
-0.15960460901260376,
-0.2877234220504761,
-0.9304840564727783,
0.5574697852134705,
-0.1533033698797226,
-0.5881708860397339,
-0.018735846504569054,
0.23392541706562042,
-0.6294814944267273,
0.3717818856239319,
-0.7081636786460876,
0.6234540343284607,
-0.35121870040893555,
-0.2931573688983917,
-0.6346845030784607,
-0.3593701720237732,
0.3552030920982361,
-0.42753586173057556,
0.326691210269928,
-0.2084149718284607,
-0.21600426733493805,
0.8095521926879883,
-0.052742600440979004,
1.034292459487915,
0.04631037265062332,
-0.38377466797828674,
0.19540244340896606,
-0.04434885084629059,
0.4425387382507324,
-0.3501756489276886,
-0.040916312485933304,
-0.16085678339004517,
-0.3185328543186188,
-0.4840490221977234,
-0.4344378113746643,
0.9431340098381042,
-1.0265246629714966,
-0.4312223196029663,
0.031887222081422806,
-0.9895194172859192,
-0.6674939393997192,
-0.011109947226941586,
-0.04378817602992058,
0.5968987345695496,
0.05139881744980812,
0.2312231808900833,
1.0826679468154907,
-0.036602236330509186,
0.2500443458557129,
0.5462357997894287,
0.033257823437452316,
-0.34115874767303467,
1.2383567094802856,
-0.10624340921640396,
0.39933374524116516,
0.6108630895614624,
0.09274901449680328,
-0.03680946305394173,
-0.6123542785644531,
-0.42479097843170166,
0.1714092344045639,
-0.7176486253738403,
-0.14071232080459595,
-0.622224748134613,
0.033545736223459244,
-0.18705005943775177,
0.014521685428917408,
-0.4524250328540802,
0.029460899531841278,
-0.38020843267440796,
0.3298298418521881,
0.35318806767463684,
0.5843481421470642,
0.37183573842048645,
0.7313082814216614,
-0.6319373846054077,
0.4934956431388855,
0.39782488346099854,
0.37119585275650024,
-0.017469624057412148,
-0.6883651614189148,
-0.4533778727054596,
-0.1229834258556366,
-0.3317330479621887,
-0.43024006485939026,
0.2543104887008667,
0.4952993392944336,
0.658614993095398,
0.4501490890979767,
-0.3528748154640198,
0.8310075998306274,
-0.5653277039527893,
0.38866668939590454,
0.13218599557876587,
-0.8698776960372925,
0.2537049949169159,
-0.5679453015327454,
0.23283731937408447,
0.4270932078361511,
0.10529698431491852,
-0.2340175062417984,
-0.06991174817085266,
-0.21967293322086334,
-0.7548293471336365,
0.7473498582839966,
-0.1973688304424286,
0.22903521358966827,
0.26228421926498413,
0.027573304250836372,
0.5214906334877014,
0.2765118479728699,
-0.27213984727859497,
-0.3766006827354431,
0.10596241801977158,
-0.43933817744255066,
-0.10606440156698227,
-0.07915183901786804,
-0.4501648545265198,
-0.19629642367362976,
0.824043869972229,
-0.3913438022136688,
0.0217911209911108,
-0.6534705758094788,
-0.213874951004982,
-0.10325849056243896,
0.2794409394264221,
0.6225258111953735,
0.7747774124145508,
0.11460133641958237,
0.09631424397230148,
0.18274623155593872,
-0.22921808063983917,
0.1589372158050537,
-0.16332471370697021,
0.18898466229438782,
-0.2979820668697357,
0.12097770720720291,
1.0758883953094482,
0.4051373302936554,
-0.9084204435348511,
0.1101384237408638,
0.38171258568763733,
-0.29249757528305054,
0.19252242147922516,
0.6547814607620239,
0.3028891384601593,
0.22743751108646393,
0.27544552087783813,
0.3775237500667572,
-0.353069007396698,
-0.5636011958122253,
-0.03477136418223381,
0.36060911417007446,
0.20792309939861298,
-0.21945889294147491,
0.3505535125732422,
0.37553828954696655,
-0.3829077482223511,
0.0384259968996048,
0.00607050908729434,
-0.20488274097442627,
0.5197769403457642,
0.6616707444190979,
0.5285061597824097,
-0.3216608166694641,
0.0046242522075772285,
-0.09094294160604477,
-0.0002771329309325665,
-0.21594300866127014,
0.40624508261680603,
0.1376299262046814,
-0.9138680696487427,
-0.7114952802658081,
-0.5439204573631287,
-0.3881845474243164,
0.19828824698925018,
-0.4741276502609253,
0.12346653640270233,
-0.3250698745250702,
0.039659131318330765,
0.049381352961063385,
-0.29628366231918335,
-0.48875197768211365,
0.1425618827342987,
0.14114880561828613,
0.5721712112426758,
-0.7293943762779236,
1.353500247001648,
0.6941838264465332,
0.08242731541395187,
-0.530285656452179,
-0.23816056549549103,
-0.10198396444320679,
-0.9630747437477112,
0.36540427803993225,
-0.13610640168190002,
-0.4051714837551117,
-0.012844463810324669,
-0.1366596519947052,
-0.8914348483085632,
0.8485592007637024,
0.4341501295566559,
-0.7105112075805664,
0.061967507004737854,
0.12673760950565338,
0.29970845580101013,
-0.5386279225349426,
-0.20020920038223267,
0.6499550938606262,
0.21528765559196472,
-0.0040360684506595135,
-0.8144652247428894,
-0.3432981073856354,
-0.1286894977092743,
-0.2113935351371765,
0.35747089982032776,
-0.8260785937309265,
1.1101051568984985,
0.15978343784809113,
0.2842312157154083,
0.14946135878562927,
0.6170687675476074,
0.3544352650642395,
-0.14511261880397797,
0.8104535937309265,
0.6600757241249084,
0.9008065462112427,
-0.00214712368324399,
0.6609726548194885,
-0.48181861639022827,
0.009790639393031597,
1.1647658348083496,
-0.5139381885528564,
0.889995813369751,
0.5539931654930115,
-0.08941347897052765,
0.5216878652572632,
0.2654920220375061,
0.3128715455532074,
0.7450736165046692,
-0.03326622396707535,
-0.4141518175601959,
-0.4907822012901306,
-0.0024680709466338158,
-0.34729406237602234,
0.5113047361373901,
0.5965465307235718,
0.04360513016581535,
-0.148273304104805,
0.23869602382183075,
-0.12058638036251068,
0.13692086935043335,
-0.32133713364601135,
0.572081446647644,
-0.07919173687696457,
-0.8711259961128235,
0.5048273205757141,
0.2527139484882355,
1.0985071659088135,
-0.970220148563385,
0.23915313184261322,
-0.10989844799041748,
0.39186811447143555,
-0.17295308411121368,
-0.4239014983177185,
-0.0648832768201828,
-0.16778995096683502,
-0.18674182891845703,
-0.0921635702252388,
0.49408867955207825,
-0.7268211841583252,
-0.3408921957015991,
0.12014419585466385,
0.7318834662437439,
-0.1870838850736618,
-0.09116053581237793,
-0.5463052988052368,
0.18646521866321564,
-0.013532791286706924,
0.009033169597387314,
0.7736003398895264,
0.4988618791103363,
0.16572688519954681,
0.7423746585845947,
0.4996117055416107,
-0.05128656327724457,
0.3692421615123749,
0.05666819587349892,
1.0448857545852661,
-0.48083001375198364,
-0.6078313589096069,
-0.7676870822906494,
0.4036990702152252,
0.24497969448566437,
-0.5597767233848572,
0.5513516664505005,
0.4928971230983734,
0.6301472187042236,
-0.2710137963294983,
0.8487358093261719,
-0.03469053655862808,
0.5412001013755798,
-0.8663002848625183,
0.30329692363739014,
-0.6542239189147949,
0.11052215844392776,
0.041199952363967896,
-0.904796302318573,
0.06216668337583542,
0.4030652344226837,
0.04040205478668213,
0.11996597051620483,
0.7134689688682556,
0.8762393593788147,
-0.4377465546131134,
-0.16408489644527435,
0.38802751898765564,
-0.10888832062482834,
0.116177998483181,
0.6566492319107056,
0.6119499206542969,
-0.12543007731437683,
0.27394384145736694,
-0.3057591915130615,
-0.11051114648580551,
-0.2209036499261856,
-0.6997603178024292,
-1.0859915018081665,
-0.5925499200820923,
-0.3838588297367096,
-0.0015722950920462608,
0.07756970077753067,
1.0074290037155151,
1.0337591171264648,
-0.8234454989433289,
-0.51727694272995,
0.30310556292533875,
-0.09626051783561707,
-0.49583908915519714,
-0.06967849284410477,
0.2985350787639618,
-0.6251022219657898,
-0.9124555587768555,
0.9414369463920593,
0.2507975399494171,
-0.3689146935939789,
-0.41203463077545166,
-0.12041158229112625,
-0.25625959038734436,
0.08655888587236404,
0.5917293429374695,
-0.027736345306038857,
-0.6432498693466187,
0.0842684656381607,
-0.147765651345253,
-0.08348915725946426,
0.20806431770324707,
0.9189283847808838,
-0.6034068465232849,
0.25756603479385376,
0.2179204821586609,
0.9487311840057373,
0.2827692925930023,
-0.13649585843086243,
0.37718504667282104,
-0.9093058109283447,
0.27215856313705444,
0.016526995226740837,
0.5032083988189697,
0.19617301225662231,
-0.15521536767482758,
0.2574270963668823,
0.10045427083969116,
-0.4009992480278015,
-0.5107423067092896,
0.08062691241502762,
-1.4288300275802612,
-0.2515505850315094,
1.1425591707229614,
-0.01660817861557007,
-0.17434005439281464,
-0.2392919361591339,
-0.36003124713897705,
-0.02064576745033264,
-0.5418495535850525,
0.8524380326271057,
0.608430027961731,
-0.05498834699392319,
0.09968727082014084,
-0.5098528265953064,
0.00772235170006752,
0.6453123688697815,
-1.130112648010254,
-0.11801847815513611,
0.2645167112350464,
0.351287305355072,
0.06844646483659744,
0.3865329623222351,
0.4114600419998169,
0.03283574804663658,
-0.1754661649465561,
-0.11349344998598099,
-0.18999971449375153,
-0.41891929507255554,
0.010920981876552105,
0.3508460223674774,
0.023809606209397316,
-0.45751428604125977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03419v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03419v1
|
Negating Negatives: Alignment without Human Positive Samples via Distributional Dispreference Optimization
| 2024-03-06T03:02:38 | 2024-03-06T03:02:38 |
Shitong Duan, Xiaoyuan Yi, Peng Zhang, Tun Lu, Xing Xie, Ning Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized the role of AI, yet also
pose potential risks of propagating unethical content. Alignment technologies
have been introduced to steer LLMs towards human preference, gaining increasing
attention. Despite notable breakthroughs in this direction, existing methods
heavily rely on high-quality positive-negative training pairs, suffering from
noisy labels and the marginal distinction between preferred and dispreferred
response data. Given recent LLMs' proficiency in generating helpful responses,
this work pivots towards a new research focus: achieving alignment using solely
human-annotated negative samples, preserving helpfulness while reducing
harmfulness. For this purpose, we propose Distributional Dispreference
Optimization (D$^2$O), which maximizes the discrepancy between the generated
responses and the dispreferred ones to effectively eschew harmful information.
We theoretically demonstrate that D$^2$O is equivalent to learning a
distributional instead of instance-level preference model reflecting human
dispreference against the distribution of negative responses. Besides, D$^2$O
integrates an implicit Jeffrey Divergence regularization to balance the
exploitation and exploration of reference policies and converges to a
non-negative one during training. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our
method achieves comparable generation quality and surpasses the latest
baselines in producing less harmful and more informative responses with better
training stability and faster convergence.
|
[
-0.6150116324424744,
-0.5577952861785889,
0.3643229007720947,
-0.0668678879737854,
-0.35294589400291443,
-0.04955989494919777,
-0.2691660225391388,
-0.4066431522369385,
0.28237205743789673,
0.36295753717422485,
-0.5086408853530884,
-0.3529471755027771,
-0.6287974715232849,
0.17522305250167847,
-0.4809205234050751,
1.0500998497009277,
0.3842252194881439,
0.18970444798469543,
-0.37271496653556824,
-0.24258391559123993,
-0.31969889998435974,
-0.3287374675273895,
-0.4638281762599945,
-0.43384554982185364,
0.7154685258865356,
0.4386942684650421,
0.9654823541641235,
0.8225719928741455,
0.5780021548271179,
0.31789839267730713,
-0.0754050612449646,
0.10294869542121887,
-0.6969040036201477,
0.18802551925182343,
-0.25295260548591614,
-0.3674362599849701,
-0.27161192893981934,
0.10253772884607315,
0.15741227567195892,
0.6435917019844055,
-0.35744988918304443,
0.2933747172355652,
0.0969732478260994,
0.7182186841964722,
-0.8682042956352234,
-0.46171835064888,
-0.6048809885978699,
-0.08838438242673874,
-0.1528444141149521,
-0.17239320278167725,
-0.409837543964386,
-0.6529092788696289,
0.08809834718704224,
-0.841745138168335,
0.173669695854187,
-0.1005258560180664,
0.8941460251808167,
0.7053117752075195,
-0.316061794757843,
-0.4792995750904083,
-0.8423022031784058,
1.0024564266204834,
-0.7872825860977173,
0.35365062952041626,
0.6035205721855164,
0.09870191663503647,
-0.10055156797170639,
0.15065860748291016,
-0.8904081583023071,
-0.08706369251012802,
0.1017412543296814,
0.13960671424865723,
-0.19035550951957703,
0.09875243157148361,
0.1859343945980072,
0.010680030100047588,
-0.4310372471809387,
0.419303834438324,
-0.2078055441379547,
-0.1650848686695099,
0.8616949319839478,
-0.05790761485695839,
0.2068813145160675,
0.15046831965446472,
-0.1563296616077423,
-0.3873218297958374,
-0.8110554814338684,
-0.30583274364471436,
0.7137255072593689,
0.2206166684627533,
-0.03208440542221069,
0.5937732458114624,
0.1263514906167984,
0.6198186874389648,
0.3681439459323883,
-0.3349885642528534,
0.4323318898677826,
-0.16729822754859924,
-0.041082266718149185,
0.18873439729213715,
0.6583789587020874,
0.4143136441707611,
0.32494401931762695,
-0.16901235282421112,
-0.03008170612156391,
0.41362711787223816,
0.34522292017936707,
-0.681817352771759,
0.03045528009533882,
0.1295946091413498,
-0.09593243896961212,
-0.3670843541622162,
-0.0821649581193924,
-0.8654862642288208,
-0.9199962615966797,
-0.7709001302719116,
0.336688369512558,
-0.2991712987422943,
-0.12609200179576874,
0.04937630519270897,
-0.09059596806764603,
0.048438094556331635,
0.3963271677494049,
-0.9530318975448608,
0.09303189069032669,
0.5779903531074524,
0.44296994805336,
0.17709039151668549,
-0.07364983856678009,
-0.6897715926170349,
0.19149288535118103,
-0.4317294657230377,
0.47216933965682983,
-0.2993580996990204,
-0.2502325177192688,
-0.03579704090952873,
-0.447685569524765,
0.5403013825416565,
-0.6899409294128418,
0.5916609764099121,
-0.5316637754440308,
0.3263285458087921,
-0.37694263458251953,
-0.4795842170715332,
-0.021289896219968796,
0.3677451014518738,
-0.4815045893192291,
0.6568624377250671,
-0.03566809743642807,
-0.7762657403945923,
0.39319729804992676,
-0.2924571633338928,
-0.5493617653846741,
-0.14707808196544647,
-0.2731151580810547,
-0.6426413655281067,
-0.014766640961170197,
0.08946319669485092,
0.1743161529302597,
-0.2740418612957001,
0.29172036051750183,
-0.6960458755493164,
-0.42787885665893555,
0.24933919310569763,
-0.3043949007987976,
0.8370158076286316,
0.27098339796066284,
-0.4970615804195404,
0.06606362015008926,
-0.7876330018043518,
-0.3215347230434418,
0.008785250596702099,
-0.10017208009958267,
-0.7446417212486267,
0.10820088535547256,
-0.5131457448005676,
0.31495264172554016,
0.14261747896671295,
-0.5407336950302124,
-0.008350184187293053,
-0.4399029314517975,
0.2899323105812073,
1.0071468353271484,
-0.25317707657814026,
0.876248836517334,
-0.3201291859149933,
0.4383489489555359,
0.05786367133259773,
0.2389180213212967,
0.42750102281570435,
0.020150035619735718,
-0.5726503729820251,
-0.18342134356498718,
0.12282179296016693,
0.5262537598609924,
-0.7479148507118225,
0.7866947054862976,
-0.34890368580818176,
-0.3870522081851959,
-0.7783806324005127,
0.38430383801460266,
0.2079937607049942,
0.9626612067222595,
0.5655831694602966,
-0.1706906110048294,
-0.5651240944862366,
-0.8578739762306213,
0.10529516637325287,
-0.28745362162590027,
0.13465121388435364,
0.11040571331977844,
-0.08890160918235779,
-0.22477972507476807,
0.7774532437324524,
-0.4664277732372284,
-0.1516970545053482,
-0.051482297480106354,
-0.02285623364150524,
0.2317763715982437,
0.29259374737739563,
0.4650890827178955,
-0.9073800444602966,
-0.4798848330974579,
-0.38177406787872314,
-0.6343734860420227,
-0.3769448399543762,
-0.11744898557662964,
-0.36294305324554443,
0.1254999041557312,
0.22292032837867737,
-0.5753040909767151,
0.287678599357605,
0.4996771514415741,
-0.08606832474470139,
0.11064937710762024,
-0.06333868205547333,
-0.15257000923156738,
-1.1598715782165527,
0.12471596151590347,
0.3039400279521942,
-0.12041676044464111,
-0.5758095979690552,
-0.2648601830005646,
-0.05224938690662384,
0.1583743840456009,
-0.28267520666122437,
0.5020662546157837,
-0.43963858485221863,
0.14522144198417664,
-0.33961021900177,
0.4195069372653961,
0.01826643943786621,
0.17007218301296234,
-0.035415347665548325,
0.692165195941925,
0.21732617914676666,
-0.6603876352310181,
0.09693120419979095,
0.680281937122345,
0.1927206963300705,
0.919370174407959,
-0.4463096261024475,
0.044671736657619476,
-0.6565315127372742,
0.2478005439043045,
-0.8448395133018494,
0.0171883013099432,
0.42296111583709717,
-0.37292662262916565,
0.3246299922466278,
0.06912771612405777,
-0.20978112518787384,
-0.29247668385505676,
-0.6418280601501465,
0.4805373549461365,
0.8892216086387634,
-0.5206246972084045,
0.09029805660247803,
0.4305366575717926,
0.000715691945515573,
-1.0492769479751587,
-0.7743249535560608,
-0.07954332232475281,
-0.5871375799179077,
-0.3171257972717285,
0.3059225380420685,
-0.16934511065483093,
-0.32663118839263916,
-0.23346072435379028,
-0.14155949652194977,
0.20129765570163727,
0.1877431422472,
0.17594456672668457,
0.4734504520893097,
0.0199713297188282,
0.15334683656692505,
-0.08717120438814163,
-0.26042112708091736,
-0.23035040497779846,
-0.10246849805116653,
0.4316408634185791,
0.4037792980670929,
-0.4907127320766449,
-0.6367177367210388,
0.14504024386405945,
0.28680795431137085,
-0.05178915336728096,
0.7229596376419067,
0.5879427790641785,
-0.2616536617279053,
-0.06783339381217957,
-0.6096700429916382,
-0.39798203110694885,
-0.5002387166023254,
0.2917419373989105,
0.28948521614074707,
-0.6365025639533997,
0.056330133229494095,
0.15592049062252045,
0.03255161643028259,
0.15134042501449585,
0.34463784098625183,
-0.2793126106262207,
0.9397268295288086,
0.40292614698410034,
-0.35224032402038574,
0.7481092214584351,
-0.060162510722875595,
0.457032710313797,
-0.7173846364021301,
0.17100921273231506,
-0.552508533000946,
-0.48544150590896606,
-0.6056222319602966,
-0.18083752691745758,
0.3380250930786133,
0.4356226325035095,
-0.6791504621505737,
0.3832893371582031,
-0.8195952773094177,
0.5730849504470825,
0.6770613193511963,
0.07023120671510696,
0.1340118944644928,
-0.05613263323903084,
0.40502724051475525,
-0.16425392031669617,
-0.40852242708206177,
-0.5368089079856873,
1.1321738958358765,
0.2603180408477783,
1.0408273935317993,
0.32102251052856445,
1.1178698539733887,
0.22642210125923157,
0.66150963306427,
-0.5715857744216919,
0.5025180578231812,
-0.29987478256225586,
-0.36883869767189026,
-0.45671865344047546,
-0.5070565938949585,
-0.8791490197181702,
0.10594236105680466,
-0.13455022871494293,
-0.7447464466094971,
0.3114766478538513,
0.4309990704059601,
-0.32672691345214844,
0.027792679145932198,
-0.7116675972938538,
0.4031957685947418,
-0.36640965938568115,
-0.5005087852478027,
-0.051100391894578934,
-0.9116039276123047,
0.12315330654382706,
0.04046814143657684,
0.3598306477069855,
-0.2560795843601227,
0.035323891788721085,
0.3811134696006775,
-0.28713274002075195,
0.9393808841705322,
-0.506369411945343,
-0.37605053186416626,
0.2227196842432022,
-0.0002846230927389115,
0.596725583076477,
-0.052678756415843964,
-0.2766156494617462,
0.14152446389198303,
-0.16583681106567383,
-0.41451600193977356,
-0.4866619408130646,
0.5296760201454163,
-1.0462055206298828,
-0.5875809192657471,
-0.23118844628334045,
-0.3617528975009918,
-0.18580475449562073,
0.30731290578842163,
0.23780719935894012,
0.00426449254155159,
-0.042809825390577316,
-0.14527888596057892,
0.631255030632019,
-0.3306475579738617,
0.3390408456325531,
0.40085360407829285,
0.1701492816209793,
-0.5675089955329895,
1.1272680759429932,
0.05400065705180168,
0.4056017994880676,
0.5809717774391174,
0.3063070774078369,
-0.725364625453949,
-0.6847494840621948,
-0.41164430975914,
0.3251575231552124,
-0.6905272006988525,
-0.5381679534912109,
-0.25113511085510254,
0.027194246649742126,
-0.47581765055656433,
-0.18223817646503448,
-0.25929152965545654,
-0.3272586464881897,
-0.5927397608757019,
-0.10563494265079498,
-0.04960661008954048,
0.5506690740585327,
-0.392356276512146,
0.13558454811573029,
-0.6489307284355164,
0.35138705372810364,
0.034392695873975754,
0.02234848588705063,
0.02697172202169895,
-0.38185667991638184,
-0.07748445868492126,
0.5376302599906921,
-0.764165997505188,
-0.7865510582923889,
0.25982165336608887,
-0.04474257677793503,
0.42334622144699097,
0.5211899876594543,
0.4571622610092163,
0.9432815313339233,
-0.3506777286529541,
0.5860982537269592,
0.42917248606681824,
-0.8828203678131104,
0.25322285294532776,
-0.2226637601852417,
-0.019694708287715912,
0.906528890132904,
0.4491235315799713,
-0.56097811460495,
-0.3416648507118225,
-0.48019567131996155,
-1.0110617876052856,
0.47842103242874146,
0.09932376444339752,
0.3367356061935425,
-0.2110680639743805,
0.42156684398651123,
0.19495467841625214,
0.4849425256252289,
-0.6909628510475159,
-0.20810088515281677,
-0.22722981870174408,
-0.5028454661369324,
-0.1975567638874054,
-0.06999299675226212,
-0.48892802000045776,
-0.1305854320526123,
1.00590181350708,
-0.15401212871074677,
0.05721501260995865,
0.2462259978055954,
-0.12256620824337006,
-0.30401480197906494,
0.33079203963279724,
0.8111073970794678,
0.48744717240333557,
-0.009901638142764568,
0.39641493558883667,
-0.02302207425236702,
-0.2934264540672302,
0.5894762277603149,
0.23875758051872253,
-0.2729015648365021,
-0.3501746952533722,
0.2387307733297348,
0.3821922242641449,
-0.3931664824485779,
-0.47969791293144226,
0.6853496432304382,
0.18303556740283966,
-0.0466383658349514,
-0.3520817756652832,
0.0628444030880928,
0.1680402159690857,
0.15658985078334808,
0.18266892433166504,
0.07209312915802002,
-0.03281126171350479,
0.05072421953082085,
0.1385962814092636,
0.7117051482200623,
-0.28800198435783386,
-0.328997939825058,
0.6911141276359558,
0.3340265154838562,
-0.38855430483818054,
0.8286187052726746,
-0.35209497809410095,
-0.13019056618213654,
0.39255911111831665,
0.5161086320877075,
0.659913957118988,
-0.15343187749385834,
0.3955751359462738,
0.44254177808761597,
-0.0067229806445539,
-0.126703679561615,
0.022853562608361244,
-0.13769660890102386,
-1.0714013576507568,
-0.35088813304901123,
-0.5527031421661377,
-0.21170932054519653,
0.1378035992383957,
-0.7340760231018066,
0.31825724244117737,
-0.4127940237522125,
-0.2639942467212677,
0.06704185158014297,
-0.25393930077552795,
-0.4785786271095276,
0.11899767816066742,
0.38297250866889954,
0.4891190528869629,
-0.7917840480804443,
0.617354691028595,
0.46721211075782776,
-0.552405834197998,
-0.6876090168952942,
0.13594192266464233,
0.19320674240589142,
-0.9268491864204407,
0.4422723352909088,
0.11479920148849487,
-0.26648738980293274,
0.034412629902362823,
-0.5775346159934998,
-0.8081610798835754,
1.1191807985305786,
0.9605768918991089,
-0.8716310858726501,
0.08985763788223267,
0.30168384313583374,
0.6299299001693726,
0.10356405377388,
0.2315054088830948,
0.2591606676578522,
0.38591817021369934,
0.2753104567527771,
-0.6344602704048157,
0.17965076863765717,
-0.10148350149393082,
-0.04982062056660652,
0.5424502491950989,
-0.6353009343147278,
0.5253710746765137,
-0.26917344331741333,
-0.27310895919799805,
0.1147555485367775,
0.257345050573349,
0.2781963050365448,
0.2095552235841751,
0.543900191783905,
0.9200331568717957,
0.7979708909988403,
0.18635785579681396,
0.8271900415420532,
-0.2270948886871338,
0.33102282881736755,
1.2412265539169312,
-0.5938809514045715,
0.5630120038986206,
1.1398794651031494,
-0.22183993458747864,
0.31803566217422485,
0.6801049113273621,
0.055365223437547684,
0.6408695578575134,
0.5653700828552246,
-0.4015193283557892,
-0.16760359704494476,
-0.410111665725708,
-0.3982850909233093,
0.06824064999818802,
-0.030154284089803696,
-0.3341880440711975,
-0.3319421410560608,
-0.33463168144226074,
-0.077623650431633,
0.4375193417072296,
0.23872554302215576,
1.0539605617523193,
-0.03667433559894562,
-0.6891288161277771,
0.7398898601531982,
-0.16753339767456055,
0.8584615588188171,
-0.4019744098186493,
-0.07777395099401474,
-0.2619675099849701,
0.2847941517829895,
-0.3200259804725647,
-0.4888800084590912,
0.3163275122642517,
-0.2496563047170639,
-0.21226319670677185,
-0.2235523909330368,
0.3373546600341797,
-0.4981057047843933,
-0.2141997218132019,
0.3176907002925873,
0.27093708515167236,
-0.2120310366153717,
0.21396154165267944,
-0.5652059316635132,
-0.17393997311592102,
0.04137590155005455,
-0.04336315393447876,
0.4496169984340668,
0.23398150503635406,
-0.08224809169769287,
0.49351584911346436,
0.6739619970321655,
0.2043142169713974,
-0.2831078767776489,
0.21620619297027588,
0.7610491514205933,
-0.474163681268692,
-0.47806817293167114,
-1.1572684049606323,
0.42049655318260193,
-0.2031572014093399,
-0.16207584738731384,
0.5378820300102234,
0.36358293890953064,
0.9461120367050171,
0.17786987125873566,
0.8513561487197876,
-0.02814449928700924,
0.42206206917762756,
-0.1417774111032486,
0.4026019871234894,
-0.46069973707199097,
0.43926796317100525,
-0.44894319772720337,
-1.024215817451477,
-0.4507715702056885,
0.6941294074058533,
-0.5200753808021545,
-0.06669875234365463,
0.13580633699893951,
0.9312620759010315,
-0.059044189751148224,
-0.06843072921037674,
0.18030467629432678,
-0.04897773638367653,
0.5320658087730408,
0.4435192346572876,
1.034705638885498,
-0.2152828723192215,
0.42801526188850403,
-0.3719520568847656,
-0.19759877026081085,
0.010503221303224564,
-1.011273741722107,
-0.6248165369033813,
-0.40591251850128174,
-0.2568536102771759,
-0.5576170682907104,
0.048281047493219376,
1.122351884841919,
0.7733638286590576,
-0.6535207629203796,
-0.13355834782123566,
-0.46682047843933105,
0.2641129195690155,
0.005322099197655916,
-0.2148357480764389,
0.17228834331035614,
-0.16380943357944489,
-0.5952208042144775,
0.025784557685256004,
0.11483502388000488,
0.5089133977890015,
-0.4079006314277649,
-0.46746376156806946,
-0.15073645114898682,
-0.006584926508367062,
0.20823463797569275,
0.2532614469528198,
-0.5584691166877747,
-0.37009525299072266,
-0.08063279837369919,
-0.2704261839389801,
0.21107134222984314,
0.5056924819946289,
-0.356476753950119,
0.3304351568222046,
0.34581440687179565,
0.8421502113342285,
0.15901148319244385,
0.5017640590667725,
0.6348426342010498,
-0.7915789484977722,
0.31272804737091064,
0.5907704830169678,
-0.0030081418808549643,
0.6273446083068848,
-0.6830407381057739,
0.41619083285331726,
-0.01598810777068138,
-0.6399620771408081,
-0.8280305862426758,
0.3593134880065918,
-0.6946308016777039,
-0.13715621829032898,
1.188141107559204,
0.07952164858579636,
-0.07310023158788681,
0.08695753663778305,
-0.2467666119337082,
0.3665241003036499,
-0.599996030330658,
1.1870903968811035,
0.6472957730293274,
-0.425324946641922,
0.23560558259487152,
-0.08514135330915451,
0.5136295557022095,
0.6643397212028503,
-0.7689390778541565,
-0.0018631921848282218,
0.6876648664474487,
0.302746444940567,
0.41387948393821716,
0.6949858069419861,
0.05927131697535515,
0.059152811765670776,
-0.2811899781227112,
0.2080736607313156,
0.05549951642751694,
-0.12820172309875488,
-0.4114002287387848,
-0.0929747149348259,
0.2921394407749176,
-0.3692649006843567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03407v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03407v2
|
Human vs. Machine: Behavioral Differences Between Expert Humans and Language Models in Wargame Simulations
| 2024-03-06T02:23:32 | 2024-06-03T15:00:47 |
Max Lamparth, Anthony Corso, Jacob Ganz, Oriana Skylar Mastro, Jacquelyn Schneider, Harold Trinkunas
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
To some, the advent of artificial intelligence (AI) promises better
decision-making and increased military effectiveness while reducing the
influence of human error and emotions. However, there is still debate about how
AI systems, especially large language models (LLMs), behave compared to humans
in high-stakes military decision-making scenarios with the potential for
increased risks towards escalation and unnecessary conflicts. To test this
potential and scrutinize the use of LLMs for such purposes, we use a new
wargame experiment with 107 national security experts designed to look at
crisis escalation in a fictional US-China scenario and compare human players to
LLM-simulated responses in separate simulations. Wargames have a long history
in the development of military strategy and the response of nations to threats
or attacks. Here, we show a considerable high-level agreement in the LLM and
human responses and significant quantitative and qualitative differences in
individual actions and strategic tendencies. These differences depend on
intrinsic biases in LLMs regarding the appropriate level of violence following
strategic instructions, the choice of LLM, and whether the LLMs are tasked to
decide for a team of players directly or first to simulate dialog between
players. When simulating the dialog, the discussions lack quality and maintain
a farcical harmony. The LLM simulations cannot account for human player
characteristics, showing no significant difference even for extreme traits,
such as "pacifist" or "aggressive sociopath". Our results motivate policymakers
to be cautious before granting autonomy or following AI-based strategy
recommendations.
|
[
-0.5954877138137817,
-1.0281473398208618,
0.49309027194976807,
0.18314094841480255,
0.25679871439933777,
0.4291580617427826,
-0.2320629507303238,
-0.563810408115387,
0.057629454880952835,
0.49480223655700684,
-0.41877084970474243,
-0.10581320524215698,
-0.681408703327179,
0.23241785168647766,
-0.04478992149233818,
0.6888102889060974,
0.0719531774520874,
0.11191914975643158,
-0.11289645731449127,
0.015386747196316719,
-0.32299524545669556,
-0.9142634868621826,
-0.9201857447624207,
-0.6703985333442688,
0.24229590594768524,
0.1635594666004181,
0.999911904335022,
0.430812269449234,
0.7155662178993225,
0.48570379614830017,
-0.13700953125953674,
-0.02904626727104187,
-0.425381600856781,
0.20913568139076233,
-0.188887357711792,
-0.406548410654068,
-0.4177064597606659,
0.24892540276050568,
0.18807756900787354,
0.275665819644928,
-0.026217106729745865,
0.03562716394662857,
-0.06375663727521896,
0.36172032356262207,
-0.2378341555595398,
0.2647397816181183,
-0.38607335090637207,
0.16613566875457764,
0.1985209584236145,
0.010913931764662266,
-0.20686066150665283,
0.0011614096583798528,
0.5211431980133057,
-0.7020928859710693,
0.07173566520214081,
0.2424924671649933,
0.7191014289855957,
0.48043641448020935,
-0.4580638110637665,
-0.10944458097219467,
-1.087026834487915,
0.6163618564605713,
-0.7361413836479187,
-0.13341736793518066,
0.4743163585662842,
0.18089020252227783,
-0.4453187584877014,
-0.20727118849754333,
-0.49271392822265625,
-0.5776159167289734,
0.16716407239437103,
0.2573116421699524,
-0.2743544578552246,
0.3020017147064209,
0.663133978843689,
-0.13855047523975372,
-0.49098771810531616,
0.3110297918319702,
-0.3410934507846832,
-0.011012833565473557,
1.1401779651641846,
0.3738459646701813,
0.2563646137714386,
-0.11314618587493896,
-0.4861324429512024,
-0.30684196949005127,
-0.5137962102890015,
0.3944404423236847,
0.44635188579559326,
0.08767365664243698,
-0.3374797999858856,
0.27599966526031494,
-0.10814964026212692,
0.13933806121349335,
0.18867334723472595,
-0.252495139837265,
-0.22125659883022308,
0.09347635507583618,
-0.23928040266036987,
0.16191308200359344,
1.059113621711731,
0.7703455686569214,
0.5505461692810059,
-0.020416801795363426,
-0.1642177402973175,
0.264087438583374,
0.465133935213089,
-0.7854809761047363,
-0.17878323793411255,
0.05091610178351402,
-0.5576503276824951,
-0.46587252616882324,
0.14407750964164734,
-0.9662161469459534,
-0.74956876039505,
-0.04077008366584778,
0.32795536518096924,
-0.0700186938047409,
-0.22396884858608246,
0.053543198853731155,
-0.2613016366958618,
0.4307404160499573,
0.08835282921791077,
-0.6787567734718323,
0.4422204792499542,
0.5775153636932373,
0.48831260204315186,
-0.2656817138195038,
-0.4292221963405609,
-0.2012881636619568,
-0.10507305711507797,
-0.6167794466018677,
0.7186175584793091,
-0.4435792565345764,
-0.9050636291503906,
-0.06578649580478668,
-0.32476645708084106,
0.20925085246562958,
-0.706653892993927,
0.5561302304267883,
-0.32431524991989136,
-0.01791316643357277,
-0.4069790840148926,
-0.34350889921188354,
-0.17168593406677246,
0.2639729976654053,
-0.5839342474937439,
0.7266106605529785,
-0.09465024620294571,
-0.3736554682254791,
0.33691978454589844,
-0.8398094177246094,
-0.5275509357452393,
-0.016496608033776283,
-0.5600678324699402,
-0.27219220995903015,
-0.10703333467245102,
-0.06490916013717651,
0.3143481910228729,
-0.6704435348510742,
0.14349111914634705,
-0.645739734172821,
-0.5064447522163391,
0.761326014995575,
-0.4833303689956665,
0.6103565692901611,
0.12919004261493683,
-0.5362940430641174,
0.1688704490661621,
-0.1664474457502365,
-0.09044921398162842,
0.35448989272117615,
-0.4064045548439026,
-0.02188740111887455,
0.537484884262085,
-0.4813782572746277,
0.5249195694923401,
-0.13948184251785278,
-0.3337843120098114,
0.24832011759281158,
-0.2331838309764862,
0.4385698437690735,
0.8165888786315918,
0.21155624091625214,
0.44278573989868164,
-0.789203941822052,
0.494168221950531,
-0.07983461022377014,
0.4048821032047272,
0.31970876455307007,
-0.5886709690093994,
-0.6121107339859009,
-0.022963808849453926,
0.016932016238570213,
0.8719842433929443,
-0.6706053614616394,
0.11850281804800034,
0.05422137677669525,
-0.36639755964279175,
-0.3764141798019409,
-0.21876831352710724,
0.3493453860282898,
0.2821776270866394,
0.17610612511634827,
-0.21489210426807404,
-0.5988685488700867,
-0.6833853721618652,
-0.37786513566970825,
-0.807321310043335,
-0.10063444077968597,
0.618546724319458,
0.42642033100128174,
-0.19072572886943817,
0.7713751196861267,
-0.23151856660842896,
0.15026167035102844,
-0.35239335894584656,
0.4061962366104126,
-0.3855591416358948,
0.2660987377166748,
0.3973274827003479,
-0.7348973155021667,
-0.29650411009788513,
-0.2937382757663727,
-0.9408490657806396,
0.06228816881775856,
-0.2077331840991974,
-0.055233731865882874,
0.1704733818769455,
0.6147344708442688,
-0.5394916534423828,
0.5029153227806091,
0.17414483428001404,
-0.1863194853067398,
0.75331711769104,
-0.21081799268722534,
0.47262755036354065,
-0.7229403853416443,
0.05927199497818947,
-0.01254802942276001,
0.17563852667808533,
-1.029518961906433,
0.17590543627738953,
-0.2874758243560791,
-0.18369464576244354,
-0.3870095908641815,
0.48480096459388733,
-0.08770801872015,
-0.14355842769145966,
-0.2939802408218384,
0.05545549839735031,
-0.12856733798980713,
0.47132161259651184,
-0.025568608194589615,
0.84243243932724,
0.3048568069934845,
-0.6888371706008911,
0.4509844183921814,
0.11245577037334442,
-0.16004325449466705,
0.4878297448158264,
-0.8750808835029602,
0.211491197347641,
0.1027376800775528,
0.09763773530721664,
-0.6036697626113892,
-0.2709680497646332,
0.2986707091331482,
-0.3980562686920166,
0.005953697487711906,
0.12716838717460632,
-0.2812042832374573,
-0.4680907726287842,
-0.3809567987918854,
0.17399723827838898,
0.8076314330101013,
0.23404163122177124,
0.5423774719238281,
0.6087900400161743,
-0.30302610993385315,
-0.4046582579612732,
-0.6808431148529053,
0.36037880182266235,
-0.4408245086669922,
-0.35030195116996765,
0.2775593101978302,
-0.257709264755249,
-0.8345309495925903,
-0.3504646420478821,
0.14712755382061005,
-0.1877608299255371,
0.5386167168617249,
0.5485038757324219,
0.4005938768386841,
-0.13305555284023285,
-0.01612599939107895,
-0.5124658346176147,
-0.10945529490709305,
0.5988233089447021,
0.12903457880020142,
0.3821997046470642,
-0.1962287873029709,
-0.440471887588501,
-0.3362060487270355,
0.5493601560592651,
0.6254843473434448,
-0.147842675447464,
0.49645745754241943,
0.32710233330726624,
-0.078114815056324,
0.27589038014411926,
-0.45234811305999756,
-0.3010543882846832,
-0.44801065325737,
0.4625707268714905,
0.03695293888449669,
-0.6336519718170166,
0.4551059901714325,
-0.31580469012260437,
0.18602100014686584,
0.4095512330532074,
0.48546668887138367,
-0.3894479274749756,
1.3757903575897217,
0.6139968037605286,
-0.4271444082260132,
0.2384473830461502,
-0.08991003036499023,
0.07295572012662888,
-0.5120967626571655,
-0.1876373589038849,
-0.4676312208175659,
-0.5301842093467712,
-0.8852612376213074,
-0.2623959481716156,
0.37523216009140015,
-0.31958553194999695,
-0.772909939289093,
-0.2586052119731903,
-0.2437058389186859,
0.36345452070236206,
0.4706559181213379,
-0.07545735687017441,
-0.12018265575170517,
-0.05656680464744568,
0.13742780685424805,
0.02169272117316723,
-0.856120228767395,
-0.5557953715324402,
0.6538897752761841,
0.2707241177558899,
0.8636510372161865,
0.1063041239976883,
0.6019247770309448,
0.47018346190452576,
0.05715365707874298,
-0.8486857414245605,
0.7519181370735168,
0.0692158192396164,
-0.6301468014717102,
-0.39292991161346436,
-0.5029377937316895,
-0.9610758423805237,
0.0688202828168869,
-0.7450851798057556,
-0.45487180352211,
-0.06992819905281067,
-0.017492610961198807,
-0.7288563251495361,
0.27138838171958923,
-0.42638877034187317,
0.5108404755592346,
-0.4796484410762787,
-0.06769506633281708,
-0.1661524474620819,
-0.7191189527511597,
0.14994655549526215,
0.2575676739215851,
0.22095201909542084,
-0.044376760721206665,
-0.14946074783802032,
0.716084361076355,
0.02410118840634823,
0.9150311946868896,
-0.007440726738423109,
0.03164725378155708,
0.3266715407371521,
0.22172053158283234,
0.4002823829650879,
-0.17655326426029205,
-0.1313907951116562,
0.07717142254114151,
-0.2964456379413605,
-0.46766945719718933,
-0.41922813653945923,
0.34897953271865845,
-1.3558613061904907,
-1.1504379510879517,
-0.567138671875,
-0.5819503664970398,
0.025004055351018906,
0.14016364514827728,
0.22008642554283142,
0.30423545837402344,
-0.7703372240066528,
0.04182855412364006,
0.8851219415664673,
-0.37763211131095886,
0.41215062141418457,
0.5831826329231262,
-0.15107902884483337,
-0.22541145980358124,
0.6860772967338562,
0.20290470123291016,
0.39550113677978516,
0.09612224251031876,
0.3312441408634186,
-0.058056317269802094,
-0.32359567284584045,
-0.3711676597595215,
-0.02000548131763935,
-0.29116374254226685,
0.014569148421287537,
-0.14992432296276093,
-0.192190483212471,
-0.1100766658782959,
-0.20075452327728271,
-0.2001865804195404,
0.16684353351593018,
-0.019423652440309525,
0.015340400859713554,
0.3331817388534546,
1.1569700241088867,
0.005133303347975016,
0.14502522349357605,
-0.47008684277534485,
0.2800252139568329,
0.3622363209724426,
-0.04014879837632179,
-0.14787423610687256,
-0.46332189440727234,
-0.04179130494594574,
0.2544671595096588,
-0.3485550582408905,
-1.1153799295425415,
0.19846904277801514,
-0.055736370384693146,
0.6304749846458435,
0.5519118905067444,
0.31884634494781494,
0.6546168327331543,
-0.3723558187484741,
1.0180555582046509,
-0.13956455886363983,
-0.6507536172866821,
0.006680899765342474,
-0.4695160984992981,
0.2443065345287323,
0.1786598116159439,
0.29396504163742065,
-0.6465097665786743,
-0.20923756062984467,
-0.8752008080482483,
-0.5262048244476318,
0.5283828973770142,
-0.19797053933143616,
-0.04762430116534233,
0.0866030752658844,
0.36268332600593567,
-0.1980670839548111,
0.0828806608915329,
-0.23433329164981842,
-0.4151938557624817,
0.07090850919485092,
0.1758592575788498,
-0.30105480551719666,
-0.1642938107252121,
-0.477224200963974,
0.08292891085147858,
0.3564485013484955,
0.0788225457072258,
0.4106495678424835,
0.24972230195999146,
0.004414472728967667,
-0.31008079648017883,
0.3751877248287201,
0.6840924024581909,
0.372263640165329,
0.09659608453512192,
0.1357235461473465,
0.661654531955719,
-0.17765268683433533,
0.5053827166557312,
0.018524209037423134,
-0.22739844024181366,
-0.40387269854545593,
0.5421667695045471,
0.6730360388755798,
0.378121554851532,
-0.7563154697418213,
0.36368805170059204,
-0.21504199504852295,
-0.5919902324676514,
-0.16591885685920715,
0.22939805686473846,
-0.023626403883099556,
0.7023857831954956,
0.21568872034549713,
0.2909819185733795,
0.04383860528469086,
-0.8098911046981812,
0.09828227013349533,
0.49074050784111023,
-0.021534565836191177,
-0.25841858983039856,
0.410722941160202,
0.5012257099151611,
-0.9491665959358215,
0.4020659327507019,
-0.44356346130371094,
-0.6549139618873596,
0.6973731517791748,
0.2537766695022583,
0.7925366759300232,
-0.24109263718128204,
0.5310760736465454,
-0.09269271045923233,
0.36732789874076843,
-0.10083889216184616,
0.17328113317489624,
0.3338010013103485,
-0.5291788578033447,
-0.2582281529903412,
0.012208818458020687,
-0.6820192337036133,
0.3537757694721222,
-0.6048992276191711,
-0.21237687766551971,
-0.7631722688674927,
-0.36951902508735657,
-0.30071792006492615,
0.4558064043521881,
-0.6806393265724182,
-0.16886906325817108,
0.5351905822753906,
0.6926423907279968,
-0.5995204448699951,
0.27082711458206177,
0.7096118927001953,
-0.2977352440357208,
-0.8331787586212158,
0.257200688123703,
0.12902171909809113,
-0.45560815930366516,
0.5489931702613831,
0.04400090500712395,
-0.07519605755805969,
-0.431282103061676,
-0.499886691570282,
-0.7132906317710876,
0.9429017901420593,
0.42553648352622986,
-0.18835784494876862,
-0.07049372047185898,
0.43786776065826416,
0.6521548628807068,
-0.31972867250442505,
0.3972229063510895,
0.6883941292762756,
0.49876153469085693,
-0.20115189254283905,
-0.837772011756897,
-0.07710924744606018,
-0.07166039198637009,
-0.06536763906478882,
0.038581687957048416,
-1.050080418586731,
0.9510641694068909,
-0.3550170063972473,
-0.2894899249076843,
-0.05170981585979462,
0.6288034915924072,
0.2597883641719818,
0.2506874203681946,
0.46084004640579224,
0.1433415710926056,
0.6362531185150146,
0.06362061202526093,
1.0314888954162598,
-0.31455662846565247,
-0.07515299320220947,
0.5466725826263428,
-0.5421130657196045,
0.748175323009491,
0.10928374528884888,
-0.22094367444515228,
0.4992406666278839,
0.6770437955856323,
0.03441349044442177,
0.02312721125781536,
0.12030553817749023,
-0.10113253444433212,
-0.24780072271823883,
-0.011961320415139198,
-0.17302027344703674,
0.6351292729377747,
0.1620912104845047,
-0.03608042374253273,
-0.07134118676185608,
-0.31662097573280334,
0.3700907826423645,
0.04785148426890373,
-0.28976258635520935,
1.0030004978179932,
0.016615167260169983,
-0.7382615804672241,
0.4884718358516693,
0.1367628127336502,
0.6251192092895508,
-0.4153328239917755,
0.10151799023151398,
0.047406427562236786,
0.04524363577365875,
0.06788448244333267,
-0.7680134177207947,
-0.05468759313225746,
0.2017432153224945,
-0.2130889594554901,
-0.043091241270303726,
0.589846670627594,
-0.18179495632648468,
-0.23064422607421875,
0.2775629758834839,
0.7270886898040771,
0.2879208028316498,
-0.01754561997950077,
-1.140816330909729,
0.12041985988616943,
-0.25404882431030273,
-0.2952340841293335,
0.5362294316291809,
0.31123048067092896,
-0.10190644860267639,
0.7633450627326965,
0.5477715134620667,
0.27245649695396423,
-0.1821390837430954,
-0.13609158992767334,
0.789161205291748,
-0.6016293168067932,
-0.3325798809528351,
-1.1362155675888062,
0.05538932606577873,
-0.3313260078430176,
-0.3651806116104126,
0.5392382740974426,
0.05151718854904175,
0.5231466293334961,
0.06711014360189438,
1.0393563508987427,
0.010017125867307186,
0.0292164646089077,
-0.2304864525794983,
0.7260812520980835,
-0.044640276581048965,
0.029954027384519577,
-0.1385175734758377,
-0.35638976097106934,
0.0986877977848053,
0.5897138118743896,
-0.47346365451812744,
0.15058688819408417,
0.250881552696228,
0.780795156955719,
0.39349329471588135,
-0.17077267169952393,
0.4025821387767792,
0.34083884954452515,
0.44487687945365906,
0.4177192151546478,
1.0942553281784058,
-0.11735071241855621,
0.4869536757469177,
0.00204969453625381,
-0.3183548152446747,
-0.43715211749076843,
-0.6232526898384094,
-1.1295586824417114,
-0.3355831801891327,
0.1829090714454651,
-0.018208421766757965,
0.21585245430469513,
1.3930073976516724,
0.4978431761264801,
-0.4955827295780182,
-0.6091121435165405,
0.439193457365036,
0.11583202332258224,
-0.2490953505039215,
-0.16033567488193512,
-0.030847972258925438,
-0.027764463797211647,
-0.4665539562702179,
0.3396427035331726,
0.2334679514169693,
0.16775502264499664,
-0.4672398865222931,
-0.3999866843223572,
0.007563428021967411,
0.5538485646247864,
0.6560063362121582,
0.4957007169723511,
-0.911422848701477,
-0.3595142364501953,
0.15578071773052216,
-0.2109808325767517,
-0.06323752552270889,
0.7399781942367554,
-0.676273763179779,
0.21726904809474945,
0.36583030223846436,
0.6332676410675049,
-0.2872582674026489,
0.05739634111523628,
0.7730687260627747,
-0.22525765001773834,
0.19750140607357025,
0.23116745054721832,
0.11199080944061279,
0.14130784571170807,
-0.333157479763031,
0.2249865084886551,
0.12526673078536987,
-0.9064565896987915,
-0.7266699075698853,
0.2189198136329651,
-0.27439749240875244,
-0.3214908242225647,
1.1344696283340454,
-0.18368464708328247,
-0.03999149054288864,
-0.08833087980747223,
-0.467896044254303,
0.3485814034938812,
-0.7179884314537048,
1.1311676502227783,
0.79059898853302,
-0.38733020424842834,
0.06226462125778198,
-0.778950035572052,
0.8691877722740173,
0.30606338381767273,
-0.7946868538856506,
0.12868326902389526,
0.14393529295921326,
-0.23179516196250916,
0.04260595142841339,
0.1805776059627533,
0.4276706576347351,
0.38043105602264404,
0.13398995995521545,
-0.036044005304574966,
-0.14422354102134705,
-0.3372335731983185,
-0.21131175756454468,
-0.07049757242202759,
0.130611851811409,
0.22114220261573792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13826v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13826v1
|
Measuring Diversity in Co-creative Image Generation
| 2024-03-06T01:55:14 | 2024-03-06T01:55:14 |
Francisco Ibarrola, Kazjon Grace
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.0
|
Quality and diversity have been proposed as reasonable heuristics for
assessing content generated by co-creative systems, but to date there has been
little agreement around what constitutes the latter or how to measure it.
Proposed approaches for assessing generative models in terms of diversity have
limitations in that they compare the model's outputs to a ground truth that in
the era of large pre-trained generative models might not be available, or
entail an impractical number of computations. We propose an alternative based
on entropy of neural network encodings for comparing diversity between sets of
images that does not require ground-truth knowledge and is easy to compute. We
also compare two pre-trained networks and show how the choice relates to the
notion of diversity that we want to evaluate. We conclude with a discussion of
the potential applications of these measures for ideation in interactive
systems, model evaluation, and more broadly within computational creativity.
|
[
-0.7738130688667297,
-0.12227227538824081,
0.08731085062026978,
0.52849942445755,
-0.5424478054046631,
0.27256959676742554,
-0.3037727475166321,
-0.5625848770141602,
0.3725200593471527,
-0.21316474676132202,
-0.572849690914154,
-0.23114284873008728,
-0.7090595960617065,
0.11207780241966248,
-0.3953700363636017,
0.6112191677093506,
-0.010920671746134758,
0.09901659935712814,
-0.5045660138130188,
-0.2775256037712097,
-0.48842841386795044,
0.016067471355199814,
-0.5469798445701599,
-0.20183053612709045,
0.6899561285972595,
0.06715285032987595,
0.8669108748435974,
-0.05967026576399803,
0.7587271332740784,
0.4255596697330475,
-0.14248019456863403,
0.21728812158107758,
-0.6987969279289246,
0.2066735178232193,
-0.1992044299840927,
-0.2782727777957916,
0.09958649426698685,
0.16993115842342377,
0.36388087272644043,
0.8260541558265686,
0.2834136486053467,
0.2667083442211151,
-0.004347994923591614,
0.5966746807098389,
-0.8865954875946045,
-0.2994557023048401,
-0.47371694445610046,
0.7964886426925659,
0.021081430837512016,
-0.19321489334106445,
0.0381542406976223,
-0.4638105630874634,
0.19343118369579315,
-0.6422703266143799,
0.32797771692276,
-0.09855883568525314,
0.7619388103485107,
0.16163775324821472,
-0.1483745276927948,
-0.5931692123413086,
-0.9305118918418884,
0.8507189154624939,
-0.34824198484420776,
0.32084205746650696,
0.02730429358780384,
0.4057384431362152,
0.08710313588380814,
-0.6934009194374084,
-0.7888947129249573,
-0.18337398767471313,
0.466552197933197,
0.6819745898246765,
-0.4103933870792389,
-0.239741712808609,
0.05538235977292061,
1.0047919750213623,
-0.4550788998603821,
0.09283536672592163,
-0.30862924456596375,
-0.13729211688041687,
0.8153138160705566,
0.28585875034332275,
0.5767013430595398,
0.036940328776836395,
-0.22170421481132507,
-0.3253755271434784,
-0.2542140483856201,
0.06183796003460884,
0.8037768602371216,
-0.33842208981513977,
-0.24224857985973358,
0.7288973927497864,
-0.13573549687862396,
0.5073261857032776,
0.10979325324296951,
0.20095719397068024,
0.14188380539417267,
-0.602178692817688,
-0.25063833594322205,
-0.6244291067123413,
0.8865064382553101,
0.4719091057777405,
-0.16679756343364716,
-0.4317649006843567,
-0.2832605242729187,
0.04629655182361603,
0.17126378417015076,
-0.855808436870575,
-0.39182063937187195,
-0.09202031791210175,
-0.6060628890991211,
-0.24239695072174072,
0.3220495581626892,
-0.5911316871643066,
-0.2324196994304657,
-0.12700830399990082,
0.42578309774398804,
-0.24757859110832214,
-0.41219833493232727,
-0.016414014622569084,
-1.012786626815796,
-0.049986716359853745,
0.385677695274353,
-0.6628865599632263,
-0.006325853057205677,
0.41504591703414917,
0.8036614060401917,
-0.4373457729816437,
-0.2689630389213562,
0.1788371503353119,
-0.47014519572257996,
-0.7381463646888733,
0.6346502900123596,
-0.15895189344882965,
-0.2033211886882782,
-0.6265127658843994,
-0.46856552362442017,
0.1530272364616394,
-0.6585793495178223,
0.25487220287323,
-0.7705110907554626,
0.26494163274765015,
-0.4470179080963135,
-0.45473435521125793,
-0.22101739048957825,
0.10962299257516861,
-0.8444376587867737,
0.4205666482448578,
0.5046691298484802,
-0.8581446409225464,
0.8430557250976562,
-0.5656875371932983,
-0.19014307856559753,
0.3892723619937897,
-0.4123668074607849,
-0.5052441954612732,
0.4235687255859375,
-0.10767213255167007,
-0.03472679480910301,
-0.3866043984889984,
0.4431624710559845,
-0.6969189047813416,
-0.4370141923427582,
0.4882688522338867,
-0.6591733694076538,
1.1242969036102295,
0.7423449754714966,
-0.19975417852401733,
0.13445784151554108,
-0.6637629270553589,
0.25814610719680786,
0.15785041451454163,
-0.40121975541114807,
-0.04227130115032196,
-0.2700519859790802,
-0.11099859327077866,
0.09661146253347397,
0.025403935462236404,
-0.4357794225215912,
-0.4069446325302124,
-0.11971675604581833,
0.20831060409545898,
0.5965708494186401,
-0.21241070330142975,
0.5215795636177063,
-0.6099139451980591,
0.5696298480033875,
-0.004513368476182222,
0.05622189864516258,
0.05686427652835846,
-0.6680305600166321,
-0.8033515810966492,
-0.4993802607059479,
0.38092151284217834,
0.2861118018627167,
-0.8210527300834656,
0.8419358730316162,
-0.10419642180204391,
-0.7708986401557922,
-0.40709033608436584,
0.17810575664043427,
0.007974082604050636,
0.03836828097701073,
0.0026648344937711954,
-1.2048112154006958,
-0.6431325674057007,
-0.5735345482826233,
-0.30985504388809204,
0.036886200308799744,
-0.22709313035011292,
0.5591633319854736,
0.6724677085876465,
0.07369005680084229,
0.9504903554916382,
-0.035056114196777344,
0.49371421337127686,
-0.16011732816696167,
0.6869543194770813,
0.27522939443588257,
0.6292088031768799,
0.6678722500801086,
-0.7769917845726013,
-0.38777685165405273,
-0.24962112307548523,
-1.2060871124267578,
0.088567815721035,
-0.08557464182376862,
-0.018753662705421448,
-0.408940851688385,
-0.22713497281074524,
-0.6373966932296753,
0.7043349146842957,
0.6342755556106567,
-0.18887968361377716,
0.5179039239883423,
0.01612631045281887,
0.585901141166687,
-0.5651291012763977,
-0.10400600731372833,
-0.2715769410133362,
0.2060280442237854,
-0.4222133159637451,
0.3167746365070343,
-0.2854020893573761,
-0.3711269795894623,
-0.5080157518386841,
0.17388524115085602,
-0.5809496641159058,
-0.5747368931770325,
-0.2654809355735779,
-0.433563232421875,
0.3183637261390686,
0.18817384541034698,
0.005728381685912609,
0.6552004218101501,
0.6487175226211548,
-0.4559166133403778,
0.9024638533592224,
0.005672191269695759,
-0.9914114475250244,
0.6358240842819214,
-0.5747491717338562,
0.37370264530181885,
-0.2610958218574524,
0.08575030416250229,
-0.9608902931213379,
-0.28252625465393066,
0.21843959391117096,
-0.5132462382316589,
-0.034018516540527344,
0.12556688487529755,
-0.18539193272590637,
-0.6967942714691162,
-0.11792530864477158,
0.7896170020103455,
0.6476404070854187,
-0.6398928165435791,
0.18064111471176147,
-0.10181479156017303,
0.18322765827178955,
-0.5155022740364075,
-0.8260111808776855,
0.45386919379234314,
-0.44560056924819946,
-1.1550116539001465,
0.486892431974411,
-0.3470596671104431,
-0.42681068181991577,
0.23378315567970276,
0.07897043228149414,
-0.2056271731853485,
0.4210411012172699,
0.13892805576324463,
-0.05492869019508362,
-0.6112516522407532,
-0.08329514414072037,
0.02819310687482357,
0.43834713101387024,
-0.14250397682189941,
-0.5799424648284912,
0.39857277274131775,
-0.179205060005188,
-0.8022264242172241,
-0.2931464612483978,
0.4525757133960724,
0.32277652621269226,
-0.08890558779239655,
0.5887121558189392,
0.8258440494537354,
-0.08382581919431686,
-0.1356019526720047,
-0.2083641141653061,
0.11199354380369186,
-0.45802539587020874,
0.2653368413448334,
-0.16158396005630493,
-0.8813815712928772,
0.7735453248023987,
0.13351795077323914,
-0.287521094083786,
0.5712007284164429,
0.6793764233589172,
-0.4290353059768677,
0.5495501756668091,
0.4147076904773712,
0.7259421348571777,
0.5528897643089294,
-0.4534696340560913,
0.30335453152656555,
-0.38832056522369385,
-0.28119954466819763,
-0.2844071388244629,
-0.7642467617988586,
-0.5483953952789307,
-0.35437095165252686,
0.2508561909198761,
0.35132381319999695,
-0.31207776069641113,
0.012003282085061073,
-0.24439871311187744,
0.6418086290359497,
0.8649089336395264,
0.23133787512779236,
0.04203236103057861,
0.2169499397277832,
0.048394329845905304,
0.017670167610049248,
-0.8998925685882568,
-0.06480242311954498,
0.9423757195472717,
0.159428671002388,
0.892749011516571,
0.12096525728702545,
0.8587979078292847,
0.3137170076370239,
0.4570522606372833,
-0.7705671787261963,
0.41611653566360474,
-0.34968140721321106,
-0.5999119877815247,
-0.499295175075531,
-0.6830582022666931,
-0.8333367705345154,
0.13485321402549744,
-0.47459784150123596,
-0.3085605502128601,
0.6510466933250427,
0.01444198377430439,
-0.588062584400177,
0.5464308261871338,
-0.6202614903450012,
0.6148040294647217,
-0.5346528887748718,
-0.44709616899490356,
-0.10782928019762039,
-0.17619018256664276,
0.4529644548892975,
-0.06808801740407944,
-0.1352872997522354,
0.1516381800174713,
0.32827091217041016,
0.9212508797645569,
-0.37966054677963257,
0.7054924964904785,
0.09244033694267273,
0.07354459166526794,
0.8929249048233032,
-0.00610654940828681,
-0.265773206949234,
0.006468726322054863,
-0.04582515358924866,
0.4493991434574127,
-0.42389950156211853,
-0.3410172164440155,
-0.7156236171722412,
0.47559577226638794,
-1.0625028610229492,
-0.5071222186088562,
-0.06607931107282639,
-0.814085841178894,
0.2035893350839615,
0.1706121563911438,
0.8496148586273193,
0.07898222655057907,
-0.42514875531196594,
0.5770158767700195,
0.1629456728696823,
-0.5706580877304077,
0.5697793960571289,
-0.16895398497581482,
0.0825178399682045,
-0.6326063871383667,
0.8739540576934814,
0.3377034366130829,
0.3364757001399994,
-0.10104784369468689,
0.21059972047805786,
-0.03209535777568817,
-0.6216838955879211,
-0.32935065031051636,
-0.689215362071991,
-0.9462383389472961,
-0.0824606865644455,
-0.37223443388938904,
-0.28850093483924866,
-0.26402345299720764,
-0.06617250293493271,
-0.23597630858421326,
-0.6354720592498779,
-0.5078145861625671,
0.12046527862548828,
-0.06300465762615204,
0.6613390445709229,
-0.48265454173088074,
0.18747244775295258,
-0.338938444852829,
0.2988230586051941,
0.819966197013855,
0.5653174519538879,
0.1655208021402359,
-0.44265246391296387,
-0.26782873272895813,
0.044605135917663574,
-0.7077356576919556,
-0.967898428440094,
0.29271337389945984,
0.17645736038684845,
0.6375707387924194,
0.48627763986587524,
-0.3123026490211487,
0.4756743013858795,
0.15330368280410767,
0.9577344655990601,
0.8114441633224487,
-0.9402464032173157,
0.3052290678024292,
-0.09594782441854477,
0.14062418043613434,
0.414564311504364,
0.3625369071960449,
-0.18070897459983826,
-0.36965233087539673,
-0.7711466550827026,
-0.3685392439365387,
0.12403103709220886,
0.5421488285064697,
0.35430657863616943,
-0.10030563920736313,
-0.04003666341304779,
0.33541515469551086,
0.4188614785671234,
-0.7306869626045227,
0.052896495908498764,
-0.8786055445671082,
-0.12345711141824722,
0.024309102445840836,
0.10288733243942261,
-0.297294944524765,
-0.40943825244903564,
-0.017746172845363617,
0.1536637395620346,
0.4354557991027832,
0.029777657240629196,
0.0224703811109066,
-0.41248947381973267,
0.25581708550453186,
0.45636487007141113,
0.6679462790489197,
-0.018536966294050217,
0.5388844013214111,
0.05876040831208229,
-0.24221207201480865,
0.2667616307735443,
-0.35411351919174194,
-0.32129088044166565,
0.04486067593097687,
0.474188894033432,
1.141419768333435,
-0.41463446617126465,
-0.36742380261421204,
0.49790576100349426,
-0.08269402384757996,
-0.27701786160469055,
-0.16809876263141632,
0.5387094020843506,
0.1400042176246643,
0.3419438898563385,
0.017726903781294823,
0.8316446542739868,
0.14504101872444153,
-0.6717948317527771,
0.10677748918533325,
0.6151527166366577,
-0.2762608826160431,
-0.37363380193710327,
0.24241605401039124,
0.21008293330669403,
-0.5644598007202148,
0.9133205413818359,
-0.716779351234436,
-0.2507237493991852,
1.3516288995742798,
0.6188661456108093,
1.0328176021575928,
0.05636919289827347,
0.28693583607673645,
0.42352819442749023,
0.3503980338573456,
0.0306460652500391,
0.4835461974143982,
-0.1906241625547409,
-1.1681535243988037,
-0.19816230237483978,
-0.28427696228027344,
-0.2146597057580948,
0.27386900782585144,
-0.4993324279785156,
0.015536480583250523,
-0.5272356271743774,
-0.5643916726112366,
-0.07841475307941437,
-0.4689757227897644,
-1.0895464420318604,
0.5091197490692139,
0.35710471868515015,
0.6477037668228149,
-0.9191495180130005,
0.14805841445922852,
0.5531125664710999,
-0.5611693263053894,
-0.5228076577186584,
-0.22752070426940918,
-0.3770153522491455,
-0.5624336004257202,
0.9974207878112793,
0.057649124413728714,
-0.04502581059932709,
-0.2864142060279846,
-1.0326440334320068,
-0.8479894399642944,
1.1424980163574219,
0.44823354482650757,
-0.31383848190307617,
0.23317638039588928,
-0.023298757150769234,
0.5293007493019104,
-0.6835080981254578,
0.38961657881736755,
-0.016863545402884483,
0.27121713757514954,
0.49865245819091797,
-0.47689545154571533,
-0.41187620162963867,
-0.713057279586792,
0.08517280966043472,
-0.36213281750679016,
-0.36524173617362976,
1.2528643608093262,
-0.5227058529853821,
-0.6080291867256165,
0.25347965955734253,
0.8657568097114563,
0.25045421719551086,
0.6487866044044495,
0.729189932346344,
0.7976974248886108,
0.8071696758270264,
-0.1471414417028427,
0.8866700530052185,
0.08159054070711136,
0.4868331849575043,
0.8530495762825012,
0.060830388218164444,
0.18168100714683533,
0.34784242510795593,
-0.248067244887352,
0.3608889877796173,
0.8836118578910828,
-0.6023130416870117,
0.6792124509811401,
0.6466778516769409,
-0.30094072222709656,
-0.4806780219078064,
-0.12172526866197586,
-0.36587220430374146,
0.4631083905696869,
0.19999608397483826,
-0.47931724786758423,
-0.11738017946481705,
0.09535787254571915,
-0.8663698434829712,
-0.14219637215137482,
-0.23917469382286072,
0.700391948223114,
0.10086526721715927,
-0.8014547824859619,
0.5957828164100647,
-0.1359943300485611,
0.7541149258613586,
0.06487525254487991,
0.13532595336437225,
-0.42013442516326904,
-0.3998431861400604,
-0.34263670444488525,
-1.1339625120162964,
0.47902873158454895,
0.011035759001970291,
-0.12310602515935898,
0.05627023056149483,
0.778497040271759,
-0.07027002424001694,
-0.5094742774963379,
0.12068263441324234,
0.5994439125061035,
0.14072798192501068,
0.1592191457748413,
-0.5931833982467651,
0.027550989761948586,
-0.28795313835144043,
-0.027067076414823532,
-0.20328910648822784,
0.5520733594894409,
0.09030840545892715,
0.3664793074131012,
0.4948788583278656,
0.04607205092906952,
0.28160902857780457,
0.1393052190542221,
0.5438757538795471,
-0.4097057580947876,
-0.6853382587432861,
-0.7431867122650146,
0.36241060495376587,
-0.19011475145816803,
-0.4091421663761139,
0.5205737948417664,
0.34112927317619324,
0.9493272304534912,
-0.3085985779762268,
1.111621618270874,
-0.1913859248161316,
-0.36681699752807617,
-0.2804964482784271,
0.6889161467552185,
-0.6119301915168762,
0.10378313809633255,
-0.2569310665130615,
-0.9144671559333801,
-0.12888337671756744,
0.5754575729370117,
-0.3206746280193329,
0.3833535313606262,
0.44696128368377686,
0.6536321640014648,
-0.4374070167541504,
0.49508312344551086,
0.3439934253692627,
-0.30366525053977966,
-0.03429258242249489,
0.5303230881690979,
1.7924320697784424,
-0.11999236792325974,
0.15326635539531708,
-0.22256676852703094,
-0.4544369876384735,
0.09939827769994736,
-0.9282852411270142,
-0.8009240627288818,
-0.46765977144241333,
-0.2708772122859955,
-0.29982390999794006,
-0.1863718181848526,
0.6817849278450012,
0.8603864312171936,
-0.6381946206092834,
-0.22814980149269104,
-0.368447870016098,
0.1311587244272232,
-0.277189165353775,
-0.049473363906145096,
-0.034309983253479004,
-0.04836296662688255,
-0.27395910024642944,
0.17661401629447937,
0.4017837345600128,
0.3512050211429596,
-0.4642486572265625,
-0.24379390478134155,
0.5459787845611572,
0.24343453347682953,
0.466641902923584,
0.12513922154903412,
-0.5991372466087341,
-0.02379675582051277,
0.1137412041425705,
0.028351351618766785,
0.2411143183708191,
0.8360366821289062,
-0.20436078310012817,
0.6588983535766602,
1.1109167337417603,
0.7476016879081726,
0.34423184394836426,
-0.2935476303100586,
0.47511181235313416,
-0.5557575225830078,
0.011967497877776623,
0.32558804750442505,
0.2623867690563202,
0.5347064733505249,
-0.18655657768249512,
0.1646089404821396,
0.5974332690238953,
-0.1558661311864853,
-0.28658491373062134,
0.6429581642150879,
-0.795036792755127,
-0.1661730706691742,
0.6202796101570129,
-0.5608164072036743,
-0.06467374414205551,
0.11732377856969833,
0.24623847007751465,
0.29029372334480286,
0.12915652990341187,
0.9885427951812744,
0.67930006980896,
-0.03406798094511032,
-0.19057774543762207,
-0.021326856687664986,
0.14256952702999115,
0.39000198245048523,
-0.8126338720321655,
-0.8108842372894287,
0.3787268400192261,
0.1910741776227951,
0.6202779412269592,
0.5537328124046326,
-0.03326881304383278,
0.5736494064331055,
0.3484112322330475,
0.1817641705274582,
-0.026950949802994728,
-0.3464566767215729,
-0.12227436155080795,
0.4406270682811737,
0.11575233191251755,
0.00018228882981929928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03396v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03396v1
|
Japanese-English Sentence Translation Exercises Dataset for Automatic Grading
| 2024-03-06T01:37:03 | 2024-03-06T01:37:03 |
Naoki Miura, Hiroaki Funayama, Seiya Kikuchi, Yuichiroh Matsubayashi, Yuya Iwase, Kentaro Inui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper proposes the task of automatic assessment of Sentence Translation
Exercises (STEs), that have been used in the early stage of L2 language
learning. We formalize the task as grading student responses for each rubric
criterion pre-specified by the educators. We then create a dataset for STE
between Japanese and English including 21 questions, along with a total of 3,
498 student responses (167 on average). The answer responses were collected
from students and crowd workers. Using this dataset, we demonstrate the
performance of baselines including finetuned BERT and GPT models with few-shot
in-context learning. Experimental results show that the baseline model with
finetuned BERT was able to classify correct responses with approximately 90% in
F1, but only less than 80% for incorrect responses. Furthermore, the GPT models
with few-shot learning show poorer results than finetuned BERT, indicating that
our newly proposed task presents a challenging issue, even for the
stateof-the-art large language models.
|
[
-0.12268035113811493,
-1.0976910591125488,
0.3332299590110779,
0.13598458468914032,
-0.23925058543682098,
-0.05541376769542694,
-0.263062447309494,
-0.3225971758365631,
-0.15858957171440125,
0.3251645863056183,
-0.40557608008384705,
-0.3786664307117462,
-0.7144519090652466,
0.416387677192688,
-0.5054253935813904,
1.2395102977752686,
-0.5790627002716064,
0.5631071329116821,
0.03715391829609871,
-0.18245603144168854,
-0.542780339717865,
-0.13171306252479553,
-0.8401786088943481,
-0.048179011791944504,
0.10260779410600662,
0.6421984434127808,
0.4739407002925873,
0.3135297894477844,
0.7799258828163147,
0.29669687151908875,
0.29266542196273804,
0.025810804218053818,
-0.3985917568206787,
0.10838384181261063,
0.016210686415433884,
-0.581570029258728,
-0.3039449453353882,
0.15231095254421234,
0.8024559617042542,
0.8547768592834473,
0.2546170651912689,
0.3584980368614197,
0.1490452140569687,
0.5265159606933594,
0.05976580083370209,
0.18157760798931122,
-0.43934470415115356,
0.2180863469839096,
-0.0817117914557457,
0.1643385887145996,
-0.5442472696304321,
-0.3837835490703583,
0.026466425508260727,
-0.7382532358169556,
0.10805974900722504,
0.14189398288726807,
1.0272676944732666,
0.24814210832118988,
-0.4795478284358978,
-0.44215714931488037,
-0.20785017311573029,
0.7151978611946106,
-0.5050642490386963,
0.18006233870983124,
0.50562983751297,
0.2638740837574005,
-0.054160844534635544,
-0.6015576720237732,
-0.23370261490345,
-0.23716041445732117,
-0.2428598552942276,
0.30284130573272705,
0.08615422993898392,
0.13277478516101837,
0.301811546087265,
0.3351205289363861,
-0.963783860206604,
0.20906613767147064,
-0.48645591735839844,
-0.16566042602062225,
0.7837257385253906,
0.24230030179023743,
0.44962459802627563,
-0.6160435676574707,
-0.3608606159687042,
-0.2576802968978882,
-0.524626612663269,
0.2745841145515442,
0.32869890332221985,
0.346754252910614,
-0.23699979484081268,
0.7510771751403809,
-0.016346167773008347,
0.6566051840782166,
-0.05947254225611687,
0.05399472266435623,
0.1204228401184082,
-0.5376185774803162,
-0.2773600220680237,
-0.17695635557174683,
0.9798533916473389,
0.3728119730949402,
0.3645279109477997,
-0.0678723007440567,
-0.3949248492717743,
0.07559183984994888,
0.043287940323352814,
-0.7222990989685059,
-0.08422897011041641,
-0.03662090748548508,
-0.19856657087802887,
-0.25692659616470337,
-0.14869840443134308,
-0.5432181358337402,
0.19609805941581726,
-0.4404224157333374,
0.5949680805206299,
-0.3764149844646454,
0.24451586604118347,
-0.0064278594218194485,
-0.020025676116347313,
0.059703148901462555,
0.5143588185310364,
-0.45617103576660156,
0.49327319860458374,
0.4534590542316437,
0.7968644499778748,
-0.23219643533229828,
-0.27352067828178406,
-0.604311466217041,
-0.18314826488494873,
-0.48588618636131287,
0.6196841597557068,
-0.2631448209285736,
-0.3271801471710205,
-0.040980465710163116,
0.2784147560596466,
-0.16608618199825287,
-0.1245584562420845,
0.5159251093864441,
-0.4181854724884033,
0.8576077222824097,
-0.23138770461082458,
-0.9046683311462402,
-0.09675692766904831,
0.26384803652763367,
-0.3570028841495514,
1.1685081720352173,
0.36131390929222107,
-0.5705868601799011,
0.272290974855423,
-0.8944498896598816,
-0.610916018486023,
0.24659697711467743,
-0.1341397762298584,
-0.2903646230697632,
-0.04263560101389885,
0.2706773579120636,
0.5609378218650818,
0.09440607577562332,
0.2913636565208435,
-0.10278536379337311,
-0.6032817959785461,
0.1605069786310196,
-0.25920480489730835,
0.7181831002235413,
0.3854398727416992,
-0.35558316111564636,
-0.1630391925573349,
-0.43957844376564026,
0.16915808618068695,
0.10340345650911331,
-0.34045764803886414,
-0.5395841002464294,
-0.5204933285713196,
0.24272361397743225,
0.15452826023101807,
0.1319875866174698,
-0.4928792715072632,
0.5869244933128357,
-0.4921551048755646,
0.24216371774673462,
0.7807130813598633,
0.16800132393836975,
0.5321458578109741,
-0.11749383062124252,
0.6869192719459534,
-0.07673019170761108,
0.02875673398375511,
-0.016247574239969254,
-0.7021839022636414,
-0.5745898485183716,
0.06852884590625763,
0.479413777589798,
0.6818692684173584,
-0.953376293182373,
0.5074038505554199,
-0.5753280520439148,
-0.335735559463501,
-0.8149130344390869,
0.3990667760372162,
0.6720514297485352,
0.34194624423980713,
0.32912561297416687,
-0.45320451259613037,
-0.3754379451274872,
-0.7341213226318359,
-0.2782740890979767,
-0.3193979859352112,
-0.03188195824623108,
0.1011161208152771,
0.7242820858955383,
-0.013124982826411724,
0.7129530310630798,
-0.383720725774765,
-0.5463752150535583,
-0.2499638944864273,
0.6208292841911316,
-0.03957335650920868,
0.43454182147979736,
0.4078902006149292,
-0.5066251158714294,
-0.7769668102264404,
-0.08085165172815323,
-0.7329627871513367,
-0.2672383785247803,
-0.2291271984577179,
-0.23397494852542877,
0.1784897893667221,
0.3950556516647339,
-0.21204139292240143,
0.22500768303871155,
0.35333025455474854,
-0.2845759689807892,
0.15315908193588257,
-0.035179316997528076,
0.4098338186740875,
-1.2430682182312012,
0.11516567319631577,
0.20491951704025269,
-0.5688931941986084,
-0.4955451786518097,
0.16530844569206238,
0.10662291944026947,
-0.14939899742603302,
-0.4621071219444275,
0.7291750907897949,
-0.2880393862724304,
-0.2563531994819641,
-0.11521504074335098,
0.3351399004459381,
0.06441126763820648,
0.443332701921463,
0.08951961994171143,
0.9020675420761108,
0.16507747769355774,
-0.4707435369491577,
0.2828957438468933,
0.5159410238265991,
-0.5444781184196472,
0.46281591057777405,
-0.6007902026176453,
0.2579745054244995,
-0.20868001878261566,
0.36613407731056213,
-1.282220721244812,
-0.42270684242248535,
0.16445492208003998,
-0.6564306020736694,
0.2490244358778,
-0.14016778767108917,
-0.4821895658969879,
-0.4593837261199951,
-0.20460538566112518,
0.22923609614372253,
0.5629447102546692,
-0.17056354880332947,
-0.12732957303524017,
0.08936137706041336,
-0.4936387240886688,
-0.48558929562568665,
-0.8545392155647278,
-0.018413761630654335,
-0.04358891397714615,
-0.37274330854415894,
0.007640754338353872,
-0.10077887028455734,
-0.2472451627254486,
0.03050779178738594,
0.1194072812795639,
-0.2113136500120163,
0.18641480803489685,
-0.0355936661362648,
0.2100871354341507,
-0.2427075058221817,
0.1175142452120781,
0.32311105728149414,
0.09423141181468964,
-0.047370731830596924,
0.16403189301490784,
0.3442213833332062,
-0.280427485704422,
-0.23749379813671112,
-0.47079557180404663,
0.23383651673793793,
0.49912741780281067,
0.08215976506471634,
0.2621428370475769,
0.7226439714431763,
-0.4444410502910614,
0.12920008599758148,
-0.3736397325992584,
-0.21615757048130035,
-0.3868925869464874,
0.6766073107719421,
-0.49233198165893555,
-0.5419421195983887,
0.3624945282936096,
0.3005051016807556,
0.43175947666168213,
0.38436827063560486,
0.4746975898742676,
-0.4727705121040344,
1.176417350769043,
0.22239147126674652,
-0.2934521436691284,
0.4869906008243561,
-0.45041802525520325,
-0.021932855248451233,
-0.7298666834831238,
0.11885987222194672,
-0.5540395379066467,
-0.5118467211723328,
-0.4025765359401703,
-0.22225478291511536,
0.5564413070678711,
0.21071377396583557,
-0.11262194067239761,
0.5409678220748901,
-0.27921614050865173,
0.45727092027664185,
0.29069778323173523,
0.11854450404644012,
0.3069291114807129,
0.12062806636095047,
-0.10941360890865326,
-0.27998650074005127,
-0.45399343967437744,
-0.7056452631950378,
1.249653935432434,
0.50737065076828,
0.5998173356056213,
0.0074339318089187145,
0.7364745736122131,
0.33217665553092957,
0.654376208782196,
-1.0000743865966797,
0.5746444463729858,
-0.36373427510261536,
-0.7529325485229492,
-0.6678440570831299,
-0.5228255987167358,
-0.8695375919342041,
0.15410801768302917,
0.22212962806224823,
-0.1753004640340805,
-0.23516684770584106,
-0.23717278242111206,
-0.23177273571491241,
-0.1106262356042862,
-0.7940521836280823,
0.836415708065033,
-0.4718210697174072,
-0.331992506980896,
0.01978440023958683,
-0.8850588202476501,
0.3856359124183655,
-0.017262844368815422,
0.5234639048576355,
0.06375911086797714,
0.13391709327697754,
1.1223535537719727,
-0.2608760595321655,
0.671459972858429,
-0.4954403340816498,
-0.17106828093528748,
0.259863018989563,
0.19773012399673462,
0.564770519733429,
0.13250236213207245,
-0.03086148574948311,
-0.3640260398387909,
0.11441630870103836,
-0.4549321234226227,
-0.471811443567276,
0.4197952449321747,
-0.8890746831893921,
-0.13040132820606232,
-0.3541889488697052,
-0.6509488821029663,
-0.14859850704669952,
0.1709669828414917,
0.38351792097091675,
0.242288738489151,
-0.25369831919670105,
0.21104438602924347,
0.4184500575065613,
-0.03009493090212345,
0.1688743382692337,
0.7899161577224731,
-0.21570248901844025,
-0.40289855003356934,
0.5243936777114868,
0.1954570859670639,
0.44893014430999756,
0.24799858033657074,
-0.0016993812751024961,
-0.39945122599601746,
-0.40147435665130615,
-0.8089636564254761,
0.15432241559028625,
-0.9436546564102173,
-0.2762693166732788,
-0.385942280292511,
0.09611798822879791,
-0.6146621108055115,
-0.21254336833953857,
-0.19876132905483246,
-0.3889716565608978,
0.019871577620506287,
-0.2742614448070526,
0.09860917180776596,
0.8119701743125916,
0.22654472291469574,
0.22225940227508545,
-0.6334784030914307,
0.3929557502269745,
0.0511852391064167,
0.06840614974498749,
-0.5619363784790039,
-0.9812527298927307,
-0.3328743875026703,
0.3667159974575043,
-0.41143742203712463,
-0.7150647044181824,
0.22382836043834686,
0.26466062664985657,
0.32599371671676636,
0.14674347639083862,
-0.10753530263900757,
1.0153857469558716,
-0.4274095594882965,
1.0741413831710815,
0.0485735759139061,
-0.9201170206069946,
0.778778612613678,
-0.19330008327960968,
0.10189315676689148,
0.9989665746688843,
0.5218750238418579,
-0.7397467494010925,
-0.8118669986724854,
-0.5303024053573608,
-0.5774967670440674,
0.8007866144180298,
0.20169296860694885,
0.2806289494037628,
-0.032346077263355255,
0.4590819776058197,
0.18754112720489502,
-0.01208564918488264,
-1.0482240915298462,
-0.031045883893966675,
-0.03860795125365257,
-0.7089881300926208,
-0.24055594205856323,
0.1954677551984787,
-0.039546843618154526,
-0.6202185750007629,
0.8136312365531921,
-0.2977413833141327,
0.20664802193641663,
0.22467416524887085,
-0.6314042806625366,
-0.43612462282180786,
0.3741672933101654,
0.47269415855407715,
0.13884279131889343,
-0.2484864592552185,
-0.19577442109584808,
0.34917086362838745,
-0.49129343032836914,
0.4747392535209656,
-0.04874396324157715,
-0.4097965657711029,
0.22249317169189453,
0.4192727208137512,
0.8359462022781372,
0.3714929521083832,
-0.5377827882766724,
0.9227871894836426,
-0.03983873873949051,
-0.3301863968372345,
-0.21731765568256378,
-0.1196870505809784,
-0.5787460207939148,
-0.23954959213733673,
0.1575673669576645,
-0.09215237945318222,
0.2287266105413437,
-0.5742592215538025,
0.30600664019584656,
0.24778729677200317,
-0.4346909821033478,
-0.30390724539756775,
0.4909098148345947,
0.20835120975971222,
0.022668570280075073,
0.6493327021598816,
-0.3750985562801361,
-0.6580567955970764,
0.5474353432655334,
0.44921573996543884,
0.7057385444641113,
-0.2962268590927124,
0.22332313656806946,
0.6298536658287048,
0.47987133264541626,
-0.29763010144233704,
0.2865392565727234,
-0.00890983734279871,
-0.39998817443847656,
-0.23945669829845428,
-0.5671384930610657,
-0.42807823419570923,
0.22653719782829285,
-0.9569333791732788,
0.4952316880226135,
-0.12148374319076538,
-0.0387146882712841,
-0.30561351776123047,
0.31117749214172363,
-0.7756776809692383,
0.38243770599365234,
0.04069952294230461,
0.6689947843551636,
-1.3301794528961182,
0.9102080464363098,
1.1263304948806763,
-0.666027307510376,
-0.6838037371635437,
-0.08592306822538376,
-0.2467595785856247,
-0.9626016020774841,
1.060666561126709,
0.11070074886083603,
0.3070905804634094,
0.17256782948970795,
-0.4434684216976166,
-0.5339966416358948,
0.8794108629226685,
0.06599697470664978,
-0.44527947902679443,
-0.40543070435523987,
0.44322454929351807,
0.6866620182991028,
-0.09875272959470749,
0.5233340859413147,
0.3747110366821289,
0.6035531759262085,
-0.2896755635738373,
-1.0536047220230103,
-0.23341229557991028,
-0.3423994183540344,
-0.019785450771450996,
-0.06850811094045639,
-0.4282669723033905,
0.6044139862060547,
0.11614442616701126,
-0.1982603371143341,
0.2535112798213959,
0.4551922082901001,
-0.06445305794477463,
0.22135533392429352,
0.5828303098678589,
0.5254924893379211,
0.562420129776001,
-0.3321920931339264,
0.9382597804069519,
-0.20646287500858307,
0.5444440841674805,
0.9380310773849487,
-0.18769145011901855,
1.036498785018921,
0.5094385743141174,
-0.39241647720336914,
0.24228684604167938,
0.6817193031311035,
-0.030312512069940567,
0.5044807195663452,
0.4054360091686249,
0.2205381840467453,
-0.11811558902263641,
0.15578843653202057,
-0.374990314245224,
0.2934013307094574,
0.3810279667377472,
-0.39522773027420044,
-0.26256564259529114,
0.5826436877250671,
0.07462283223867416,
0.16396857798099518,
-0.19025659561157227,
0.9629976749420166,
0.1782289743423462,
-1.0680910348892212,
0.626560389995575,
0.26320040225982666,
0.7055262923240662,
-0.5723093748092651,
0.18239229917526245,
-0.5633322596549988,
0.1340324580669403,
-0.14739781618118286,
-1.0444658994674683,
0.2285517305135727,
0.4699634909629822,
0.10361818969249725,
-0.5508225560188293,
0.35126569867134094,
-0.6883273720741272,
-0.6612938046455383,
-0.10821055620908737,
0.34079575538635254,
0.503521203994751,
0.4025900065898895,
-0.8689598441123962,
-0.1532367318868637,
-0.03661271184682846,
-0.39043667912483215,
0.2124064713716507,
0.3438599109649658,
-0.10596311092376709,
0.4275844991207123,
0.22205783426761627,
-0.03393710032105446,
0.22767384350299835,
0.1222773939371109,
0.3118060529232025,
-0.2900543510913849,
-0.444914311170578,
-0.47423240542411804,
0.4419664442539215,
0.054019808769226074,
-0.3623184859752655,
0.7554491758346558,
0.7485053539276123,
0.9617223739624023,
-0.30651789903640747,
0.838512659072876,
-0.0838729590177536,
0.5796036720275879,
-0.6989181041717529,
0.47457176446914673,
-0.6861081719398499,
0.07041728496551514,
-0.42947694659233093,
-0.6124407052993774,
-0.234200119972229,
0.918350338935852,
-0.3934447467327118,
-0.15098409354686737,
1.0042991638183594,
0.4955475926399231,
0.033839866518974304,
-0.048708539456129074,
0.13052596151828766,
0.11592678725719452,
0.5195117592811584,
0.9518229365348816,
0.6159460544586182,
-1.2496488094329834,
0.33414363861083984,
-0.3549153208732605,
-0.08069667965173721,
-0.2612893879413605,
-0.40833717584609985,
-0.798190176486969,
-0.6867693662643433,
-0.5851889252662659,
-0.2860346734523773,
0.07331153005361557,
1.1658231019973755,
0.32947811484336853,
-0.9337290525436401,
-0.3109046518802643,
-0.20000845193862915,
-0.2909885048866272,
-0.11331138759851456,
-0.3286789357662201,
0.4277648627758026,
-0.837242841720581,
-1.0507497787475586,
0.3542023003101349,
-0.25643226504325867,
0.37713903188705444,
-0.10162508487701416,
-0.2328585684299469,
-0.09818021953105927,
-0.2457316666841507,
0.5716181397438049,
-0.08057114481925964,
-0.7513011693954468,
-0.3593601584434509,
0.083646260201931,
-0.581868052482605,
-0.05666756629943848,
0.4707200229167938,
-0.4457148015499115,
0.3918030560016632,
0.5952925086021423,
0.5636242032051086,
0.3226175904273987,
0.116728775203228,
0.5417882800102234,
-1.1451958417892456,
0.20051300525665283,
0.32417920231819153,
0.35100409388542175,
0.27559560537338257,
-0.17400415241718292,
0.6009503602981567,
0.3439549505710602,
-0.4641214907169342,
-1.1918458938598633,
0.015740778297185898,
-0.8024306893348694,
-0.0342407301068306,
1.2195316553115845,
-0.3826594650745392,
-0.03375089168548584,
0.03475227206945419,
-0.36695945262908936,
0.43136847019195557,
-0.07840516418218613,
0.7247442603111267,
1.2044544219970703,
0.21904513239860535,
0.11935222893953323,
-0.7201521396636963,
0.48694297671318054,
0.8161298632621765,
-1.0720300674438477,
-0.024781623855233192,
0.4126027524471283,
0.3696352243423462,
0.014675473794341087,
0.5968195796012878,
-0.26655691862106323,
0.3846481442451477,
-0.4334430396556854,
-0.039059828966856,
0.10630834102630615,
-0.25661802291870117,
-0.4293995797634125,
-0.1208096370100975,
0.08231052756309509,
-0.1867818683385849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03348v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03348v3
|
Learning to Maximize Mutual Information for Chain-of-Thought Distillation
| 2024-03-05T22:21:45 | 2024-06-09T14:24:54 |
Xin Chen, Hanxian Huang, Yanjun Gao, Yi Wang, Jishen Zhao, Ke Ding
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge distillation, the technique of transferring knowledge from large,
complex models to smaller ones, marks a pivotal step towards efficient AI
deployment. Distilling Step-by-Step~(DSS), a novel method utilizing
chain-of-thought~(CoT) distillation, has demonstrated promise by imbuing
smaller models with the superior reasoning capabilities of their larger
counterparts. In DSS, the distilled model acquires the ability to generate
rationales and predict labels concurrently through a multi-task learning
framework. However, DSS overlooks the intrinsic relationship between the two
training tasks, leading to ineffective integration of CoT knowledge with the
task of label prediction. To this end, we investigate the mutual relationship
of the two tasks from Information Bottleneck perspective and formulate it as
maximizing the mutual information of the representation features of the two
tasks. We propose a variational approach to solve this optimization problem
using a learning-based method. Our experimental results across four datasets
demonstrate that our method outperforms the state-of-the-art DSS. Our findings
offer insightful guidance for future research on language model distillation as
well as applications involving CoT. Codes are available at
\url{https://github.com/xinchen9/cot_distillation_ACL2024}.
|
[
-0.6157162189483643,
-0.7216723561286926,
0.6861708164215088,
-0.11849845945835114,
-0.43707045912742615,
0.3295382857322693,
-0.24522756040096283,
-0.3166015148162842,
-0.0492250882089138,
0.3028060495853424,
-0.7044665813446045,
-0.28309741616249084,
-1.0088779926300049,
0.040824390947818756,
-0.17336627840995789,
1.2983489036560059,
-0.2619907855987549,
-0.022324880585074425,
-0.3541727364063263,
-0.06139780208468437,
-0.3538649380207062,
-0.45429977774620056,
-0.5155453681945801,
-0.5488911271095276,
0.5437238812446594,
0.16602501273155212,
0.21843361854553223,
0.5029506683349609,
0.23473253846168518,
0.3183338940143585,
-0.3798491358757019,
0.3921941816806793,
-0.6840882897377014,
0.42155858874320984,
-0.19537492096424103,
-0.8800179958343506,
-0.0015228965785354376,
0.14609834551811218,
0.09585226327180862,
0.8024672269821167,
-0.24391813576221466,
0.21256019175052643,
0.41139525175094604,
1.097549557685852,
-0.8515734672546387,
0.3054402470588684,
-0.7276310920715332,
0.12522587180137634,
0.13850948214530945,
0.008880985900759697,
-0.18694725632667542,
-0.2865939140319824,
0.4757077395915985,
-0.4868897497653961,
0.30068841576576233,
0.11385808140039444,
0.552401602268219,
0.5414179563522339,
-0.4912743866443634,
-0.5036917328834534,
-0.836330771446228,
0.8032241463661194,
-0.3881221115589142,
0.1868574023246765,
0.5238067507743835,
0.47920337319374084,
-0.15776851773262024,
-0.6571981310844421,
-0.6554532647132874,
-0.3013199269771576,
-0.03850909322500229,
-0.20504681766033173,
-0.20969003438949585,
0.05889832228422165,
0.43793952465057373,
0.5926759243011475,
-0.18977414071559906,
-0.38252776861190796,
-0.499083936214447,
0.08729013800621033,
0.40646907687187195,
0.038521409034729004,
-0.022146129980683327,
0.3784453570842743,
-0.7046219110488892,
-0.17708507180213928,
-0.20321476459503174,
-0.22641384601593018,
0.08077909797430038,
0.2301143854856491,
-0.12241004407405853,
0.35284554958343506,
-0.22228699922561646,
0.7562171220779419,
0.43336009979248047,
-0.2636794149875641,
0.4066913425922394,
-0.4046388268470764,
-0.3389035165309906,
-0.10972191393375397,
0.7182307839393616,
0.07664430141448975,
-0.10381343215703964,
-0.11403996497392654,
-0.32923468947410583,
-0.10162439942359924,
0.1608843058347702,
-0.6552687883377075,
-0.12406755238771439,
-0.021674009039998055,
-0.18150262534618378,
-0.4556179642677307,
-0.061017956584692,
-0.7431872487068176,
-0.4268302321434021,
-0.6735342144966125,
0.34456005692481995,
-0.35709860920906067,
-0.29341408610343933,
-0.01681152917444706,
-0.37835970520973206,
-0.46181541681289673,
0.15188132226467133,
-0.8051935434341431,
0.2936994433403015,
0.45547521114349365,
1.0206242799758911,
-0.20092615485191345,
-0.10116225481033325,
-0.40166106820106506,
0.2535672187805176,
-0.3336828947067261,
0.262532502412796,
-0.25387850403785706,
-0.36891886591911316,
-0.4492071568965912,
-0.41589784622192383,
0.11756962537765503,
-0.6338024735450745,
0.1872791349887848,
-0.44732487201690674,
-0.17581769824028015,
-0.5227752923965454,
-0.5521486401557922,
-0.15833385288715363,
0.20689289271831512,
-0.8923056721687317,
0.8545105457305908,
0.039550796151161194,
-1.0508495569229126,
0.4384479522705078,
-0.4982260465621948,
-0.37347400188446045,
-0.22710449993610382,
-0.4501977860927582,
-0.26391544938087463,
0.30687952041625977,
0.1038384735584259,
0.41989943385124207,
-0.6651861071586609,
0.5158654451370239,
-0.274035781621933,
-0.03907109051942825,
0.08266947418451309,
-0.663489818572998,
0.66593998670578,
0.4687650501728058,
-0.47436031699180603,
-0.38333970308303833,
-0.6838547587394714,
-0.41984114050865173,
-0.06701365858316422,
-0.22937366366386414,
-0.6301700472831726,
-0.13781650364398956,
-0.569682776927948,
0.23139332234859467,
0.33961591124534607,
-0.28111791610717773,
0.23269936442375183,
0.017386535182595253,
0.27905985713005066,
0.7312528491020203,
0.15676893293857574,
0.39126309752464294,
-0.36373648047447205,
0.43735212087631226,
0.5007514357566833,
0.12276217341423035,
0.24448950588703156,
-0.226630300283432,
-0.7544578909873962,
-0.0435471348464489,
0.19071537256240845,
0.22226065397262573,
-1.1337482929229736,
0.41010981798171997,
0.04745537415146828,
-0.6734266877174377,
-0.19656652212142944,
0.1930040866136551,
0.524078369140625,
0.654387354850769,
0.39654356241226196,
-0.3264731466770172,
-0.42209774255752563,
-0.6243352293968201,
0.050407979637384415,
-0.13935811817646027,
0.09447970986366272,
0.13175401091575623,
0.3201914429664612,
-0.1709410846233368,
0.6785798668861389,
-0.9459192752838135,
-0.3109859228134155,
-0.2871882915496826,
0.7771430015563965,
0.41985318064689636,
0.392895370721817,
0.5859470963478088,
-0.9755200743675232,
-0.7898889780044556,
-0.0003652744635473937,
-0.6856211423873901,
0.12229909002780914,
-0.01772260293364525,
-0.21869012713432312,
0.018539903685450554,
0.5865494012832642,
-0.2951691746711731,
0.4137563407421112,
0.5063777565956116,
0.04248562827706337,
0.5921436548233032,
-0.4287151098251343,
0.24481439590454102,
-1.1807827949523926,
-0.01978517696261406,
0.21320568025112152,
-0.06521285325288773,
-0.5324950218200684,
-0.28174304962158203,
-0.3486599326133728,
0.22206057608127594,
-0.1541016846895218,
0.008667240850627422,
-0.667356014251709,
0.28318163752555847,
-0.4999561607837677,
0.020208854228258133,
0.1638113260269165,
0.714532196521759,
-0.17034406960010529,
0.6876580119132996,
0.7403078675270081,
-0.7562649250030518,
0.6259934902191162,
-0.054192621260881424,
-0.319838285446167,
0.6274424195289612,
-0.28917983174324036,
0.08311977237462997,
-0.30111443996429443,
0.27380144596099854,
-0.8097133040428162,
0.20997215807437897,
0.1533278077840805,
-0.28004971146583557,
0.5550413131713867,
-0.07943513244390488,
-0.18787910044193268,
-0.46303460001945496,
-0.053255949169397354,
0.528937578201294,
0.41809695959091187,
-0.49070560932159424,
0.6843919157981873,
0.5969869494438171,
0.08449356257915497,
-0.9020786285400391,
-0.7113674879074097,
-0.3684072196483612,
-0.32497161626815796,
-0.08238965272903442,
0.23253625631332397,
-0.02800413779914379,
-0.10438035428524017,
0.04866452515125275,
-0.7223435044288635,
-0.46702954173088074,
-0.18828457593917847,
0.1466505378484726,
0.3586015999317169,
0.05891278013586998,
0.1956731528043747,
0.24926349520683289,
-0.08933369815349579,
0.04816466197371483,
-0.5854960083961487,
0.4441293478012085,
-0.014223729260265827,
-0.06440620869398117,
-0.544029712677002,
0.23516611754894257,
0.7300622463226318,
0.2173231542110443,
0.8854506611824036,
0.51116943359375,
-0.19166386127471924,
-0.3633798062801361,
-0.5288819670677185,
-0.09480475634336472,
-0.5148635506629944,
0.3967975378036499,
-0.7985556125640869,
-0.5186835527420044,
0.1789637953042984,
-0.5264313817024231,
-0.18866866827011108,
0.35984236001968384,
0.25275692343711853,
-0.20983368158340454,
0.6119062900543213,
0.9749594330787659,
-0.535503089427948,
0.5764796733856201,
-0.6913536190986633,
0.28109458088874817,
-0.7845563888549805,
-0.37444257736206055,
-0.5251181721687317,
-0.40404438972473145,
-0.39803096652030945,
-0.7734532952308655,
0.5036605596542358,
0.400277704000473,
-0.06377796828746796,
0.5437703132629395,
-0.4431561827659607,
0.5689026117324829,
0.6502648591995239,
0.4479345381259918,
0.369539350271225,
0.007562506012618542,
-0.5516795516014099,
0.1957702934741974,
-0.7852276563644409,
-0.14219418168067932,
1.2052122354507446,
0.07086620479822159,
0.9737535119056702,
-0.40397197008132935,
1.0472363233566284,
0.364022821187973,
-0.1700395792722702,
-0.3976803421974182,
0.34330984950065613,
-0.2912566065788269,
-0.38120561838150024,
-0.3636784255504608,
-0.7005082368850708,
-0.4800693988800049,
0.17114290595054626,
-0.08732235431671143,
-0.7024022936820984,
0.34799185395240784,
0.37239086627960205,
-0.05215071141719818,
0.5633659958839417,
-0.46558326482772827,
0.412643164396286,
-0.2901558578014374,
-0.4462760090827942,
-0.5816377401351929,
-0.8527774810791016,
0.3545694649219513,
-0.21073365211486816,
0.34661051630973816,
-0.03171895071864128,
0.17353689670562744,
0.6796764731407166,
-0.5762045383453369,
0.8255721926689148,
-0.25517019629478455,
-0.1946088671684265,
0.5198537111282349,
0.06732504069805145,
0.5506550073623657,
-0.22459401190280914,
0.06260878592729568,
0.09287847578525543,
-0.0004391178663354367,
-0.17024005949497223,
-0.8376424312591553,
0.5672572255134583,
-0.6782616972923279,
-0.610883891582489,
-0.480775386095047,
-0.4127769470214844,
-0.29244571924209595,
-0.008905673399567604,
0.3551042079925537,
0.13225212693214417,
-0.10258371382951736,
-0.03580119088292122,
0.8159629106521606,
0.12949900329113007,
0.32793208956718445,
0.08624503761529922,
-0.022107457742094994,
-0.3002634048461914,
0.9403171539306641,
-0.05005866661667824,
0.6391681432723999,
0.6089924573898315,
0.16886159777641296,
-0.31992626190185547,
-0.3168260157108307,
-0.16704601049423218,
0.09246887266635895,
-0.7214617729187012,
-0.2880607843399048,
-0.5017738938331604,
-0.2517763674259186,
-0.008326808921992779,
0.06946886330842972,
-0.5765988826751709,
-0.29460087418556213,
-0.39949652552604675,
-0.1602693349123001,
0.26672109961509705,
0.8664412498474121,
-0.41157886385917664,
-0.01696651242673397,
-0.7153013944625854,
0.5721089243888855,
0.423146516084671,
0.18713703751564026,
0.31258952617645264,
-0.2079927623271942,
-0.37194979190826416,
0.5912424921989441,
-0.46950581669807434,
-0.7847138047218323,
0.03761644661426544,
0.13936907052993774,
0.6288393139839172,
0.45797741413116455,
0.3933827579021454,
0.7189028263092041,
-0.2552628517150879,
0.5191195011138916,
0.7030565142631531,
-1.117658019065857,
0.6024109125137329,
0.32957032322883606,
0.0509868860244751,
0.8943268656730652,
0.9275475144386292,
-0.3846239447593689,
-0.46523115038871765,
-0.4140640199184418,
-0.9026398062705994,
0.5985545516014099,
0.28999248147010803,
-0.19617712497711182,
0.25657758116722107,
0.216536745429039,
0.41058671474456787,
0.4303193986415863,
-0.5825960040092468,
-0.40199217200279236,
0.2869538962841034,
-0.18636196851730347,
-0.004387975204735994,
-0.040910668671131134,
-0.10917972773313522,
-0.4029900133609772,
0.8179999589920044,
0.02324986830353737,
-0.038291484117507935,
0.07865732908248901,
-0.11150366812944412,
0.012508586049079895,
-0.10334797948598862,
0.20220167934894562,
0.5880030989646912,
-0.015214361250400543,
0.3099726438522339,
0.15979686379432678,
-0.5254353284835815,
0.44255274534225464,
-0.24550610780715942,
0.15837937593460083,
0.01592392846941948,
0.11293958127498627,
1.2125731706619263,
-0.264726459980011,
-0.40283480286598206,
0.4770571291446686,
-0.1155271902680397,
-0.2580946087837219,
0.19817794859409332,
0.28852036595344543,
0.09562600404024124,
0.6438866853713989,
0.38350844383239746,
0.25015494227409363,
0.31133726239204407,
-0.5600523948669434,
0.3293219208717346,
0.217921182513237,
-0.46439987421035767,
0.015000936575233936,
0.5651069283485413,
0.17022393643856049,
0.13638678193092346,
0.41257861256599426,
-0.1823287308216095,
-0.508001983165741,
0.7074547410011292,
0.2773084044456482,
0.9996774196624756,
-0.1502527892589569,
0.2802354097366333,
0.4859949052333832,
-0.14678241312503815,
-0.2774317264556885,
-0.034609921276569366,
-0.7614861130714417,
-0.34923937916755676,
-0.05039449781179428,
-0.810994029045105,
-0.2860836088657379,
-0.04505537450313568,
-0.8706599473953247,
0.32326674461364746,
-0.21700653433799744,
-0.31593868136405945,
-0.011288515292108059,
-0.06049725040793419,
-0.6992914080619812,
0.2777339220046997,
0.08450667560100555,
0.5457781553268433,
-0.997694194316864,
1.0101531744003296,
0.18179042637348175,
-0.5722911953926086,
-0.8062006831169128,
0.327962726354599,
-0.11475802212953568,
-0.515431821346283,
0.7637205719947815,
0.045249756425619125,
-0.3805868923664093,
-0.29849472641944885,
-0.45805683732032776,
-0.8018252849578857,
1.2677276134490967,
0.3385925590991974,
-1.233289122581482,
-0.2099745273590088,
0.14737704396247864,
0.5090528130531311,
-0.5107463598251343,
0.0639871284365654,
0.651604950428009,
0.05665311962366104,
0.6368780732154846,
-0.9704461693763733,
0.11670684814453125,
-0.10992560535669327,
0.2009507566690445,
0.2240704745054245,
-0.43740373849868774,
0.8153746128082275,
-0.3774513304233551,
-0.0683971643447876,
-0.2657356262207031,
0.5208253264427185,
0.22829854488372803,
0.36346185207366943,
0.7323291897773743,
0.5462676882743835,
0.9175907969474792,
0.13612419366836548,
0.5420658588409424,
-0.2853235602378845,
0.51942378282547,
1.4771095514297485,
-0.09244522452354431,
0.5076537728309631,
0.7604279518127441,
-0.4684394896030426,
0.6009451746940613,
0.3824242949485779,
0.21948540210723877,
0.9996241331100464,
0.5189985632896423,
-0.5216262340545654,
0.20693299174308777,
0.11379968374967575,
-0.44874387979507446,
0.056588806211948395,
0.45372411608695984,
-0.5936490893363953,
-0.15038324892520905,
0.27005478739738464,
-0.2473617047071457,
-0.024547243490815163,
-0.0003807651228271425,
1.1297446489334106,
0.14178644120693207,
-0.7141603827476501,
0.9426963925361633,
-0.3571162819862366,
0.6502902507781982,
-0.5433913469314575,
0.054351408034563065,
-0.15388667583465576,
0.047631602734327316,
0.18855804204940796,
-0.39299264550209045,
0.29942595958709717,
-0.08939597010612488,
-0.34130653738975525,
-0.06739567965269089,
0.31226980686187744,
-0.7465419769287109,
-0.32360467314720154,
0.544934868812561,
0.4166300594806671,
0.08922386914491653,
-0.01315382868051529,
-0.5492835640907288,
0.10416500270366669,
0.23417232930660248,
0.010550959035754204,
0.20422795414924622,
0.7869439125061035,
0.2404128909111023,
0.6965215802192688,
0.27966979146003723,
0.23743341863155365,
0.08311266452074051,
-0.17397905886173248,
1.3167511224746704,
-0.39402323961257935,
-0.5407746434211731,
-0.9767011404037476,
0.29753318428993225,
-0.2634269893169403,
0.036633316427469254,
0.030718505382537842,
0.5537475347518921,
0.9690985679626465,
-0.14920534193515778,
1.133410930633545,
-0.2918088138103485,
0.21032963693141937,
-0.4103199243545532,
0.6178299188613892,
-0.6129763126373291,
0.4326621890068054,
-0.37592554092407227,
-1.0824546813964844,
0.2889869809150696,
0.44391685724258423,
-0.1652178168296814,
-0.12086623162031174,
1.07659113407135,
0.5591008067131042,
-0.09422176331281662,
0.10580158233642578,
0.25396841764450073,
0.09899618476629257,
0.05417083203792572,
0.9351345300674438,
0.6352434158325195,
-0.3140048086643219,
0.37932154536247253,
-0.6178695559501648,
-0.5905593633651733,
0.011470392346382141,
-0.8491007685661316,
-0.9613427519798279,
-1.1576519012451172,
-0.3644748330116272,
-0.19365768134593964,
0.24331529438495636,
0.8907958269119263,
0.6416283249855042,
-0.5879898071289062,
-0.38116490840911865,
-0.6855122447013855,
0.1621115356683731,
-0.30615296959877014,
-0.12794381380081177,
0.14122730493545532,
-0.6339468359947205,
-0.8155646324157715,
0.04284011200070381,
0.24490635097026825,
0.2759743332862854,
-0.17661048471927643,
-0.07769575715065002,
-0.3396110236644745,
0.08861146867275238,
0.25028717517852783,
0.0280259158462286,
-0.5456856489181519,
0.2502925992012024,
-0.5365877747535706,
-0.13877800107002258,
-0.011175952851772308,
1.0347148180007935,
-0.6644718050956726,
0.7583307027816772,
0.50738126039505,
0.47922706604003906,
1.0891258716583252,
-0.15370990335941315,
0.8525628447532654,
-0.7941111326217651,
0.39149144291877747,
0.19666659832000732,
0.2120065838098526,
-0.03105156123638153,
-0.4758775234222412,
0.4397095739841461,
0.3189975619316101,
-0.413488507270813,
-0.6178704500198364,
0.3234195411205292,
-0.7814406156539917,
-0.5469790101051331,
0.8177216649055481,
-0.5518592000007629,
-0.240776926279068,
-0.009572114795446396,
-0.2781462073326111,
0.7005549073219299,
-0.2900417447090149,
0.9679991006851196,
0.7313873171806335,
-0.15874072909355164,
0.21926045417785645,
-0.059986285865306854,
0.6412196159362793,
0.13087300956249237,
-0.6266255974769592,
0.16823923587799072,
0.4158560633659363,
0.2727872133255005,
0.2733658254146576,
0.4877108633518219,
0.23337216675281525,
-0.20916087925434113,
0.3439321219921112,
-0.23232045769691467,
-0.018168553709983826,
-0.69781094789505,
0.05504416674375534,
0.07512864470481873,
-0.006185328587889671,
-0.5790660977363586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04804v1
|
AttentionStitch: How Attention Solves the Speech Editing Problem
| 2024-03-05T22:09:58 | 2024-03-05T22:09:58 |
Antonios Alexos, Pierre Baldi
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
The generation of natural and high-quality speech from text is a challenging
problem in the field of natural language processing. In addition to speech
generation, speech editing is also a crucial task, which requires the seamless
and unnoticeable integration of edited speech into synthesized speech. We
propose a novel approach to speech editing by leveraging a pre-trained
text-to-speech (TTS) model, such as FastSpeech 2, and incorporating a double
attention block network on top of it to automatically merge the synthesized
mel-spectrogram with the mel-spectrogram of the edited text. We refer to this
model as AttentionStitch, as it harnesses attention to stitch audio samples
together. We evaluate the proposed AttentionStitch model against
state-of-the-art baselines on both single and multi-speaker datasets, namely
LJSpeech and VCTK. We demonstrate its superior performance through an objective
and a subjective evaluation test involving 15 human participants.
AttentionStitch is capable of producing high-quality speech, even for words not
seen during training, while operating automatically without the need for human
intervention. Moreover, AttentionStitch is fast during both training and
inference and is able to generate human-sounding edited speech.
|
[
-0.3839053511619568,
-0.832586407661438,
0.3454691171646118,
0.21045227348804474,
-0.2799316942691803,
0.12349558621644974,
-0.3456146717071533,
-0.5492340922355652,
0.44134747982025146,
0.6077033281326294,
-0.647506058216095,
-0.24106068909168243,
-0.5502028465270996,
0.19519993662834167,
-0.6753248572349548,
0.8914642930030823,
0.3092149794101715,
-0.20680519938468933,
0.049300678074359894,
-0.02383846417069435,
-0.536799430847168,
-0.28969669342041016,
-0.7778002023696899,
-0.05754735320806503,
0.3862276077270508,
0.4116593301296234,
0.5952564477920532,
0.6880349516868591,
0.3854481279850006,
0.3311980664730072,
-0.5266795754432678,
0.2914943993091583,
-0.38789719343185425,
0.23339037597179413,
-0.2531265616416931,
-0.19490931928157806,
-0.3885667324066162,
0.192914217710495,
0.45859581232070923,
0.33485716581344604,
0.15652771294116974,
0.45147719979286194,
0.34171900153160095,
0.6056407690048218,
-0.6370931267738342,
-0.4308718144893646,
-0.6826013922691345,
0.17362529039382935,
-0.34772247076034546,
-0.10030446201562881,
-0.29121410846710205,
-0.4013221263885498,
0.17616456747055054,
-0.4939354360103607,
0.44565582275390625,
-0.22510157525539398,
0.3303651213645935,
0.9472324848175049,
0.018990706652402878,
0.047788698226213455,
-0.7257549166679382,
0.2414591759443283,
-0.522193431854248,
0.49924132227897644,
0.42243173718452454,
0.040408313274383545,
0.05770636349916458,
-0.7809439897537231,
-0.48298633098602295,
-0.05253566429018974,
0.06838575005531311,
0.1560433804988861,
-0.02285088412463665,
0.15411517024040222,
0.34484347701072693,
0.14239370822906494,
-0.5672699213027954,
0.05570419505238533,
-0.03567562624812126,
-0.22722773253917694,
0.36681637167930603,
-0.11010108143091202,
0.2708793878555298,
-0.11968003213405609,
-0.23932625353336334,
0.17631486058235168,
-0.11084485054016113,
0.08646614849567413,
0.3818749785423279,
0.19877764582633972,
0.20885290205478668,
0.6953051090240479,
-0.2733619511127472,
0.8764320015907288,
0.32111993432044983,
0.17288708686828613,
-0.021796414628624916,
-0.38647374510765076,
-0.4074053168296814,
0.49741482734680176,
0.6359403729438782,
0.2772424817085266,
0.4271421730518341,
-0.11733186990022659,
0.19791802763938904,
0.03833702951669693,
0.22378863394260406,
-0.23923885822296143,
-0.36334168910980225,
0.4527095854282379,
-0.05460010841488838,
-0.45554739236831665,
-0.14719003438949585,
-0.8484832048416138,
-0.45888379216194153,
-0.43047773838043213,
0.526915431022644,
-0.07240907102823257,
-0.06317368149757385,
-0.023323582485318184,
-0.35723042488098145,
-0.5164828896522522,
0.11487601697444916,
-0.7825894355773926,
0.05160904675722122,
0.5330899953842163,
0.9824716448783875,
-0.12467554956674576,
-0.46898820996284485,
-0.807526707649231,
0.30116650462150574,
-0.3135905861854553,
0.8965231776237488,
-0.26683276891708374,
-0.269489586353302,
-0.48666438460350037,
-0.3294540345668793,
0.05948357656598091,
-0.3724772036075592,
0.5258404612541199,
-0.2321755439043045,
0.09775248169898987,
0.07203811407089233,
-0.3740297853946686,
0.471813440322876,
-0.038706839084625244,
-0.5868805050849915,
1.2615286111831665,
-0.13891443610191345,
-0.9822022318840027,
0.20770251750946045,
-0.8449824452400208,
-0.5332527756690979,
-0.00943774078041315,
0.5399845838546753,
-0.5292536020278931,
0.11058617383241653,
0.411612331867218,
0.3397960364818573,
0.024082615971565247,
0.14997920393943787,
-0.11660916358232498,
-0.40921008586883545,
0.4343324303627014,
-0.15931954979896545,
0.6027905941009521,
0.020280567929148674,
-0.46140626072883606,
0.174874946475029,
-0.8060356378555298,
0.23349983990192413,
0.014301137067377567,
-0.3783152401447296,
-0.416246622800827,
-0.21440814435482025,
0.37630346417427063,
0.2713785171508789,
0.20631501078605652,
-0.6827645897865295,
-0.09162311255931854,
-0.6666367650032043,
0.6948862671852112,
0.7065519690513611,
0.18257315456867218,
0.37167537212371826,
0.12654484808444977,
0.19925521314144135,
-0.45961204171180725,
0.37942224740982056,
-0.2236572951078415,
-0.4145558178424835,
-0.7140166759490967,
-0.18207912147045135,
0.6818760633468628,
0.5513641834259033,
-0.3310227394104004,
0.39077457785606384,
-0.08913740515708923,
-0.47983574867248535,
-0.8949790000915527,
0.08601325750350952,
0.5051544308662415,
0.6187394261360168,
0.4159015715122223,
-0.30761104822158813,
-0.6529271602630615,
-0.8082672953605652,
-0.8363580703735352,
0.20361992716789246,
-0.02758614532649517,
0.048425208777189255,
-0.05161835625767708,
-0.020021915435791016,
1.2145326137542725,
-0.41278761625289917,
-0.4346306324005127,
-0.04516950249671936,
0.30591481924057007,
-0.3234778940677643,
0.4157317578792572,
0.1191597506403923,
-0.5892992615699768,
-0.5450436472892761,
-0.14679400622844696,
-0.2569316327571869,
-0.463365763425827,
-0.0642581433057785,
-0.24243329465389252,
-0.1251249760389328,
0.5899020433425903,
-0.4859631061553955,
0.46035531163215637,
0.4158570468425751,
-0.2602805495262146,
0.5753553509712219,
-0.026086350902915,
0.30059540271759033,
-1.0979571342468262,
0.22043050825595856,
-0.08619284629821777,
-0.4325554072856903,
-0.8926224112510681,
-0.18456140160560608,
0.08410347998142242,
-0.6816272735595703,
-0.641930341720581,
0.5073151588439941,
-0.263418048620224,
-0.27911296486854553,
-0.3680652678012848,
0.2800576686859131,
0.03275027871131897,
0.5047795176506042,
-0.20604196190834045,
0.8412237167358398,
0.16438253223896027,
-0.3367440104484558,
0.5448614358901978,
0.5142546892166138,
-0.3560105562210083,
0.5036070346832275,
-0.5952577590942383,
0.7486140727996826,
-0.001910609775222838,
0.0456109419465065,
-0.9264918565750122,
-0.3208690881729126,
0.06790059804916382,
-0.5766295194625854,
0.2223641276359558,
-0.14227181673049927,
-0.4079630672931671,
-0.4363994598388672,
-0.26530295610427856,
0.2941837012767792,
0.1483232080936432,
-0.49459871649742126,
0.21853205561637878,
0.5625026226043701,
-0.7491766810417175,
-0.47621357440948486,
-0.7429594993591309,
0.5153299570083618,
-0.032755110412836075,
-0.48608148097991943,
0.442611962556839,
-0.13090136647224426,
-0.13079816102981567,
-0.01932680606842041,
-0.17201565206050873,
-0.3659838140010834,
-0.05366073548793793,
0.09452908486127853,
-0.06639517843723297,
0.2784908711910248,
0.1408282369375229,
0.07147897034883499,
-0.2724629044532776,
-0.28074824810028076,
-0.2670998275279999,
0.2991001605987549,
0.5737338066101074,
-0.0660715401172638,
-0.9319896101951599,
0.5473242998123169,
0.8071596026420593,
-0.7716690897941589,
0.0720357894897461,
0.3905567228794098,
-0.20668388903141022,
-0.05090942233800888,
-0.7658182382583618,
-0.26254940032958984,
-0.4036802053451538,
0.6041054725646973,
-0.06975960731506348,
-0.838351309299469,
0.10746102780103683,
-0.04387747868895531,
0.1279556155204773,
0.04052983969449997,
0.3553466796875,
-0.2563436031341553,
0.8895218372344971,
0.5868592858314514,
0.04256768897175789,
0.8779390454292297,
0.14662669599056244,
0.06899937987327576,
-0.8744451403617859,
0.01626567915081978,
-0.7902237176895142,
-0.40766996145248413,
-0.22000615298748016,
-0.3411586284637451,
0.4208480417728424,
-0.37018343806266785,
-0.046619392931461334,
0.26632291078567505,
-0.8199292421340942,
0.8291764855384827,
0.8351942896842957,
0.3577073812484741,
0.20490296185016632,
0.020196452736854553,
0.04189709201455116,
-0.22342483699321747,
-0.5884907841682434,
-0.09988541901111603,
0.8743957281112671,
0.14736932516098022,
0.45371320843696594,
-0.34963682293891907,
0.546051561832428,
0.38925912976264954,
-0.18493205308914185,
-0.7118765711784363,
0.4396708011627197,
-0.28824785351753235,
-0.47872400283813477,
-0.6130160093307495,
-0.180098295211792,
-0.5553550124168396,
0.02202007919549942,
-0.11741617321968079,
-0.5773460865020752,
0.19800949096679688,
0.5161330103874207,
-0.5636432766914368,
0.005599456373602152,
-1.0013667345046997,
0.8727260828018188,
-0.015057860873639584,
-0.49126628041267395,
-0.3377832770347595,
-0.8776467442512512,
0.33250513672828674,
-0.2775961756706238,
0.16290362179279327,
-0.1246640756726265,
0.2501545548439026,
1.0458285808563232,
-0.1466074138879776,
0.6421837210655212,
-0.17167194187641144,
0.2644038498401642,
0.252576619386673,
0.10135159641504288,
0.5645915269851685,
-0.06451645493507385,
0.10478819906711578,
0.06404446065425873,
-0.37142297625541687,
-0.012662725523114204,
-0.5369839668273926,
0.5804542899131775,
-0.4578552544116974,
-0.48746585845947266,
-0.07960265129804611,
-0.4041542112827301,
-0.5668431520462036,
0.09813383221626282,
0.3052898347377777,
0.5063936114311218,
-0.19482973217964172,
-0.10848259180784225,
0.5800005793571472,
0.052728477865457535,
0.46411892771720886,
0.22942161560058594,
0.17449919879436493,
-0.5395438075065613,
0.5965394973754883,
0.1880800724029541,
0.3297807276248932,
0.19331485033035278,
0.30571743845939636,
-0.20777909457683563,
-0.26791703701019287,
-0.16609521210193634,
0.11724314838647842,
-0.44222745299339294,
0.03503547981381416,
-0.9872481822967529,
-0.12690740823745728,
-0.5121884942054749,
-0.11975272744894028,
-0.6890823841094971,
-0.5655328035354614,
-0.17667578160762787,
0.06912685185670853,
0.29824942350387573,
0.39464014768600464,
-0.15259148180484772,
0.35431528091430664,
-0.8447352647781372,
0.7930903434753418,
0.9713953733444214,
0.3012439012527466,
-0.26441189646720886,
-0.5522071123123169,
-0.5276256799697876,
-0.13649016618728638,
-0.11335230618715286,
-1.0881273746490479,
0.17903754115104675,
0.3012878894805908,
0.20392639935016632,
-0.09073828160762787,
-0.08581001311540604,
0.8426421880722046,
-0.6927196979522705,
0.6769875288009644,
0.11153333634138107,
-1.2313435077667236,
1.0098880529403687,
-0.0018624040530994534,
0.6721842885017395,
0.5936908721923828,
-0.38416069746017456,
-0.8999199867248535,
-0.8818926811218262,
-0.46651583909988403,
-0.7778893113136292,
0.9019650816917419,
0.42767152190208435,
-0.14156176149845123,
0.19616757333278656,
0.23376987874507904,
-0.15019898116588593,
0.2870769500732422,
-0.23257331550121307,
-0.06343594193458557,
-0.3454626798629761,
-0.23422278463840485,
-0.16978545486927032,
-0.4539446234703064,
-0.0011567198671400547,
-0.1668383628129959,
0.6002643704414368,
0.22595231235027313,
0.2843904495239258,
0.33438506722450256,
-0.1889076679944992,
-0.24039380252361298,
0.5210395455360413,
0.6702743172645569,
0.27747631072998047,
-0.16033074259757996,
0.0416603609919548,
-0.02251095324754715,
-0.7104678153991699,
0.240762859582901,
0.22400641441345215,
-0.006043515168130398,
0.21607549488544464,
0.16717146337032318,
0.9404318332672119,
0.512971043586731,
-0.3874066174030304,
0.19794981181621552,
-0.14314502477645874,
-0.06856615096330643,
0.23589545488357544,
0.026516130194067955,
0.0587969571352005,
0.0951891764998436,
0.18186324834823608,
0.5372956395149231,
0.30397701263427734,
-0.048232417553663254,
0.27181366086006165,
0.130619078874588,
-0.2782873511314392,
-0.06911299377679825,
0.9300797581672668,
0.5777683258056641,
-0.80916428565979,
0.3271469175815582,
0.3233436048030853,
-0.4473225474357605,
0.5851136445999146,
0.14944994449615479,
1.1607047319412231,
-0.7651289701461792,
0.032668981701135635,
0.21292267739772797,
0.41923895478248596,
0.038949545472860336,
0.03811980038881302,
-0.29335784912109375,
-0.18554849922657013,
-0.6972935795783997,
-0.38652703166007996,
-0.5752108693122864,
0.14169789850711823,
-0.46799540519714355,
0.2302432656288147,
-0.28416305780410767,
-0.39429759979248047,
0.3131859004497528,
-0.41082075238227844,
-0.5222880244255066,
0.4582550525665283,
-0.019028551876544952,
0.6054225564002991,
-0.7112076878547668,
0.5706995129585266,
0.5816313028335571,
0.23301927745342255,
-0.6140214204788208,
0.33241724967956543,
-0.00092349509941414,
-0.5091721415519714,
0.2568436861038208,
0.24176591634750366,
-0.12551601231098175,
0.542758584022522,
-0.31544363498687744,
-0.8967801332473755,
0.3795959949493408,
0.540824294090271,
-0.887180507183075,
0.0692235603928566,
-0.019680535420775414,
0.29287561774253845,
0.29309189319610596,
-0.15019705891609192,
0.8650875091552734,
0.42321211099624634,
-0.17165617644786835,
-1.176218867301941,
-0.4731229245662689,
-0.1170945093035698,
-0.23736359179019928,
0.3168548047542572,
-0.5377795100212097,
0.47410377860069275,
-0.2148360162973404,
0.004650990944355726,
-0.31971433758735657,
0.29587018489837646,
-0.09619545936584473,
0.13580307364463806,
0.6407546997070312,
0.6307058930397034,
0.5937496423721313,
-0.005064820405095816,
0.5938220620155334,
-0.13280430436134338,
0.3764861226081848,
1.4976686239242554,
-0.07106821238994598,
0.7390830516815186,
0.5711371302604675,
-0.13338014483451843,
-0.18479925394058228,
0.5432254672050476,
0.34595248103141785,
0.6927180886268616,
-0.226658433675766,
-0.22597341239452362,
-0.18926461040973663,
-0.08535641431808472,
-0.23925092816352844,
0.7233418822288513,
-0.048969171941280365,
-0.24344369769096375,
-0.002498029265552759,
0.48221519589424133,
-0.18666677176952362,
0.05388977378606796,
-0.3786926865577698,
1.0747286081314087,
-0.2254774421453476,
-0.629878044128418,
0.2721877098083496,
-0.23135332763195038,
0.4356924593448639,
-0.39946693181991577,
0.13081152737140656,
0.011657225899398327,
-0.09371012449264526,
-0.04729438200592995,
-0.7781198024749756,
0.38246265053749084,
0.43187421560287476,
-0.28101980686187744,
-0.2991808354854584,
0.5686235427856445,
-0.6361072063446045,
-0.3044946789741516,
-0.021798448637127876,
0.1043369397521019,
-0.033801957964897156,
-0.40760791301727295,
-0.7732253074645996,
0.044655587524175644,
0.03652838245034218,
-0.47188472747802734,
0.09464558213949203,
0.30217185616493225,
0.31167080998420715,
0.3042769432067871,
0.7698908448219299,
0.279154896736145,
0.12706488370895386,
0.17884404957294464,
0.4596288502216339,
-0.493293434381485,
-1.1565704345703125,
-0.8969764709472656,
0.7706905007362366,
-0.23920390009880066,
-0.30049777030944824,
0.3397478461265564,
0.37707486748695374,
0.3940521776676178,
-0.12104982137680054,
0.9626064300537109,
0.3218594789505005,
0.9981174468994141,
-0.46545228362083435,
0.7522296905517578,
-0.326577752828598,
-0.3797919452190399,
-0.49211233854293823,
-0.8040438890457153,
-0.34717705845832825,
0.3233845829963684,
0.01238579023629427,
-0.29162532091140747,
0.7812742590904236,
0.6580106616020203,
-0.06968091428279877,
-0.0714799240231514,
0.3874814212322235,
0.3708708584308624,
0.06791892647743225,
0.3202553987503052,
0.5164093375205994,
-0.17159496247768402,
0.5842559933662415,
-0.401446133852005,
-0.33558323979377747,
-0.3023192286491394,
-0.4735841453075409,
-0.7742133140563965,
-0.5505692362785339,
-0.3787079453468323,
-0.05074377357959747,
0.35655513405799866,
0.7499454021453857,
0.5447437763214111,
-0.45423075556755066,
0.13590769469738007,
-0.078223317861557,
0.03001062199473381,
-0.3967133164405823,
-0.1876457929611206,
0.5504083633422852,
-0.21201741695404053,
-0.9225714206695557,
0.7363967895507812,
0.6890366077423096,
0.2203858345746994,
0.015335467644035816,
0.4296382665634155,
-0.12169443815946579,
0.12359879910945892,
0.47232499718666077,
0.2053518146276474,
-0.6031404137611389,
-0.193388432264328,
-0.2081526815891266,
-0.040690191090106964,
-0.003407649928703904,
0.8958443999290466,
-0.6791976690292358,
0.9584255218505859,
0.35102155804634094,
0.713100254535675,
0.4689461588859558,
0.06435198336839676,
0.32764020562171936,
-1.120482087135315,
0.4480911195278168,
0.16408425569534302,
0.08513238281011581,
0.4893057644367218,
-0.5890108346939087,
0.23825855553150177,
0.219635009765625,
-0.7055261135101318,
-0.8837375044822693,
0.06979312002658844,
-0.9230613112449646,
-0.03472466394305229,
0.7565301060676575,
0.07500877231359482,
-0.0912044495344162,
-0.30568453669548035,
-0.7015352249145508,
0.744438648223877,
-0.2646407186985016,
0.9190228581428528,
0.7216510772705078,
0.03491426631808281,
-0.3768237233161926,
-0.4826001524925232,
0.6652925610542297,
0.5541043281555176,
-0.9106078743934631,
0.5604991316795349,
0.3294426202774048,
0.22588616609573364,
-0.0008468221058137715,
0.44024795293807983,
0.2153221219778061,
0.7298768162727356,
-0.42182090878486633,
0.22085359692573547,
-0.39611729979515076,
-0.397157222032547,
-0.3530881702899933,
0.46083346009254456,
-0.22696416079998016,
-0.4848782420158386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03336v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03336v1
|
Scope of Large Language Models for Mining Emerging Opinions in Online Health Discourse
| 2024-03-05T21:38:19 | 2024-03-05T21:38:19 |
Joseph Gatto, Madhusudan Basak, Yash Srivastava, Philip Bohlman, Sarah M. Preum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
In this paper, we develop an LLM-powered framework for the curation and
evaluation of emerging opinion mining in online health communities. We
formulate emerging opinion mining as a pairwise stance detection problem
between (title, comment) pairs sourced from Reddit, where post titles contain
emerging health-related claims on a topic that is not predefined. The claims
are either explicitly or implicitly expressed by the user. We detail (i) a
method of claim identification -- the task of identifying if a post title
contains a claim and (ii) an opinion mining-driven evaluation framework for
stance detection using LLMs.
We facilitate our exploration by releasing a novel test dataset, Long
COVID-Stance, or LC-stance, which can be used to evaluate LLMs on the tasks of
claim identification and stance detection in online health communities. Long
Covid is an emerging post-COVID disorder with uncertain and complex treatment
guidelines, thus making it a suitable use case for our task. LC-Stance contains
long COVID treatment related discourse sourced from a Reddit community. Our
evaluation shows that GPT-4 significantly outperforms prior works on zero-shot
stance detection. We then perform thorough LLM model diagnostics, identifying
the role of claim type (i.e. implicit vs explicit claims) and comment length as
sources of model error.
|
[
-0.05568581074476242,
-0.7243375778198242,
0.8649311661720276,
0.07831350713968277,
-0.20008797943592072,
0.041781745851039886,
-0.23175859451293945,
-0.6295554041862488,
0.6358868479728699,
0.30413296818733215,
-0.3688148558139801,
-0.7802475690841675,
-0.8251779675483704,
-0.04595533013343811,
-0.19758160412311554,
1.363972544670105,
0.05124405771493912,
0.24386419355869293,
-0.41561439633369446,
-0.10889862477779388,
0.08726444840431213,
-0.4446885883808136,
-0.7416146993637085,
-0.5253345966339111,
0.4824469983577728,
0.28274062275886536,
0.5633915066719055,
0.008065992966294289,
0.3884641230106354,
0.09441786259412766,
-0.16251665353775024,
0.011616231873631477,
-0.32674652338027954,
0.03152972832322121,
-0.21159414947032928,
-0.38723447918891907,
-0.9135260581970215,
-0.056528665125370026,
0.41899171471595764,
0.37589508295059204,
-0.2822720408439636,
0.33063578605651855,
-0.009264960885047913,
0.36669179797172546,
-0.26288798451423645,
-0.06914959847927094,
-0.551863968372345,
0.14161497354507446,
-0.2083968073129654,
0.08765789121389389,
-0.37223950028419495,
-0.08152184635400772,
0.1196879893541336,
-0.2136048674583435,
-0.025264352560043335,
-0.21442808210849762,
0.8178662657737732,
-0.09572312980890274,
-0.5078927278518677,
-0.2876046299934387,
-0.6001562476158142,
0.7043816447257996,
-1.0279289484024048,
0.289124071598053,
0.27252480387687683,
0.09323778003454208,
-0.09263729304075241,
-0.6704432368278503,
-0.3891417682170868,
0.05806533619761467,
0.004275029990822077,
0.1299431174993515,
-0.5498490929603577,
0.16299866139888763,
0.026222532615065575,
0.43422967195510864,
-0.45782989263534546,
0.24045559763908386,
-0.11922915279865265,
-0.19513502717018127,
0.6629173159599304,
-0.16105519235134125,
0.21998414397239685,
-0.6533549427986145,
-0.5029692649841309,
0.6082260608673096,
-0.8328817486763,
0.13398019969463348,
0.21581508219242096,
0.15955416858196259,
-0.4958440065383911,
0.5743280053138733,
-0.04496217891573906,
0.552420973777771,
0.45735833048820496,
-0.2831389307975769,
0.32735395431518555,
-0.231347918510437,
-0.33881300687789917,
0.08921024203300476,
0.8775362372398376,
0.696297824382782,
-0.40749624371528625,
0.12775379419326782,
-0.08344653248786926,
-0.1605781763792038,
0.1719566136598587,
-0.7966125011444092,
-0.2700105905532837,
0.39121004939079285,
-0.8822950720787048,
-0.48031067848205566,
0.12377259135246277,
-0.9705488681793213,
-0.9173522591590881,
-0.05176645889878273,
0.22373175621032715,
0.0317925401031971,
-0.7808009386062622,
-0.00757260899990797,
-0.0332779660820961,
0.5151792764663696,
0.13285137712955475,
-0.5759493708610535,
0.2830202877521515,
1.017448902130127,
0.8738389611244202,
-0.41664865612983704,
0.4790489375591278,
-0.3580667972564697,
-0.08611547201871872,
-0.11469019204378128,
1.0042424201965332,
-0.6475114226341248,
-0.30992642045021057,
0.11850112676620483,
0.14403283596038818,
0.1243310421705246,
-0.4967610836029053,
0.7079077363014221,
-0.4806475341320038,
0.040827665477991104,
-0.1076815128326416,
-0.7272788286209106,
-0.04292718321084976,
0.7987038493156433,
-0.720647931098938,
0.7503669261932373,
-0.010411947034299374,
-1.07197904586792,
0.5406681299209595,
-0.650272786617279,
-0.4277469217777252,
0.16738511621952057,
-0.4083992838859558,
-0.7497017979621887,
0.10676039755344391,
0.31551170349121094,
0.6365437507629395,
-0.31750208139419556,
0.2981790006160736,
-0.6144347786903381,
0.18903109431266785,
0.16299813985824585,
-0.09259381890296936,
0.8301626443862915,
0.0994616150856018,
-0.4201735258102417,
0.3092818558216095,
-0.5918000340461731,
0.04799633100628853,
0.11558779329061508,
-0.24205508828163147,
-0.5391101241111755,
0.18864527344703674,
-0.20246580243110657,
0.2666119933128357,
0.5416232347488403,
-0.6461794376373291,
0.19879581034183502,
-0.6414684653282166,
0.5442160367965698,
0.58431476354599,
0.6672993302345276,
-0.005351534113287926,
-0.26033076643943787,
0.6836820244789124,
0.0269487127661705,
0.38768917322158813,
-0.04287005588412285,
-0.6414092183113098,
-0.6934248208999634,
-0.17770223319530487,
0.0864097848534584,
0.39757034182548523,
-0.4343029260635376,
0.4200576841831207,
-0.2478928565979004,
-0.3287973999977112,
-0.6045028567314148,
0.11499691009521484,
0.17202043533325195,
0.25685492157936096,
0.34216272830963135,
-0.2731134295463562,
-0.6082322001457214,
-1.0009398460388184,
-0.45967957377433777,
-0.39544862508773804,
0.1902492195367813,
0.2411312311887741,
0.27811041474342346,
-0.47044864296913147,
0.9104682803153992,
-0.32262131571769714,
0.03139335289597511,
-0.4277171492576599,
0.2576155960559845,
0.41497889161109924,
-0.12988169491291046,
0.3576948046684265,
-0.6889381408691406,
-0.4466613531112671,
0.03108109161257744,
-0.7780535817146301,
-0.02580985613167286,
0.0401676781475544,
0.2900935113430023,
0.10845160484313965,
0.4446944296360016,
-0.46364426612854004,
0.024791622534394264,
0.7946531176567078,
-0.17415431141853333,
0.2819868326187134,
-0.029553288593888283,
0.049883563071489334,
-1.4206103086471558,
-0.1853475719690323,
0.42810705304145813,
-0.3436037600040436,
-0.6582298874855042,
0.26866623759269714,
-0.2145494669675827,
0.21086710691452026,
-0.5967071652412415,
0.4520813822746277,
-0.30486130714416504,
0.2540217339992523,
-0.5034900903701782,
-0.19800466299057007,
-0.12967151403427124,
-0.018436376005411148,
0.08177004009485245,
0.08451354503631592,
0.5698035359382629,
-0.3454377353191376,
0.35050880908966064,
-0.17265039682388306,
-0.20194534957408905,
0.745779812335968,
-0.5688155293464661,
0.23232002556324005,
0.06528133153915405,
0.34473317861557007,
-0.8274098038673401,
-0.3109426200389862,
0.24292179942131042,
-0.6109791398048401,
0.08901900053024292,
-0.4169810712337494,
-0.30222198367118835,
-0.5279126167297363,
-0.4773755371570587,
0.2829003632068634,
0.19268949329853058,
-0.44510796666145325,
0.3728291392326355,
0.9306272268295288,
-0.35410478711128235,
-0.5354576110839844,
-0.4293918311595917,
0.09044355154037476,
-0.4242088198661804,
-0.39228084683418274,
0.248462975025177,
0.2065790444612503,
-0.7181856036186218,
0.022029582411050797,
0.031869154423475266,
-0.009244874119758606,
-0.0033952314406633377,
0.3654838800430298,
0.08528994768857956,
0.0915161743760109,
0.26725736260414124,
0.0006225761026144028,
0.03980773687362671,
0.4500669538974762,
-0.1440478265285492,
0.5067624449729919,
-0.2543048560619354,
-0.49308186769485474,
-0.19627158343791962,
0.5048980116844177,
0.5662497878074646,
0.08783373981714249,
0.383110910654068,
0.5474265217781067,
-0.638317883014679,
-0.2332749217748642,
-0.4046477675437927,
-0.11006352305412292,
-0.37341487407684326,
0.37489256262779236,
0.18440240621566772,
-0.8533473610877991,
0.17566680908203125,
-0.2369365692138672,
0.312444269657135,
0.6259319186210632,
0.9594486951828003,
-0.05057360604405403,
0.8648737072944641,
0.5964949727058411,
-0.3257964253425598,
0.05755919590592384,
-0.07122524082660675,
0.3840367794036865,
-0.6061787009239197,
-0.18289786577224731,
-0.07847191393375397,
-0.17759090662002563,
-0.7397090792655945,
-0.5502635836601257,
0.6666455268859863,
-0.2631852626800537,
-0.057958200573921204,
-0.0564584955573082,
-0.35122719407081604,
0.047655198723077774,
0.15454407036304474,
0.5419206023216248,
0.4184476137161255,
-0.12024091929197311,
-0.13190090656280518,
-0.18218836188316345,
-0.4591844379901886,
-0.344495564699173,
1.425806999206543,
0.5968102812767029,
0.4802803695201874,
0.24964720010757446,
0.7539063692092896,
0.6476426124572754,
0.613674521446228,
-1.2073147296905518,
0.48326513171195984,
-0.04754764586687088,
-0.5409497022628784,
0.0680372342467308,
-0.20455175638198853,
-1.0595402717590332,
-0.039190538227558136,
-0.5540428161621094,
-0.3740966022014618,
-0.2994876801967621,
0.15835507214069366,
-0.6312405467033386,
0.6312204599380493,
-0.22986742854118347,
0.5476251840591431,
-0.4752216339111328,
-0.5388922095298767,
-0.5182696580886841,
-0.6263309717178345,
0.4177151024341583,
0.07481162995100021,
0.43943536281585693,
-0.19529083371162415,
0.21990731358528137,
0.8143962025642395,
-0.45590847730636597,
1.074402928352356,
-0.36746886372566223,
-0.24651703238487244,
0.4401942789554596,
-0.3037072420120239,
0.2900350093841553,
0.30080318450927734,
-0.29430440068244934,
0.24823904037475586,
-0.1660134494304657,
-0.14940765500068665,
-0.24367240071296692,
0.8662490844726562,
-0.796347975730896,
-0.6838817000389099,
-0.6612027287483215,
-0.028282904997467995,
-0.46744492650032043,
0.20038382709026337,
0.11601635813713074,
0.20888984203338623,
-0.6719865202903748,
0.03770177438855171,
0.6589487195014954,
-0.28816184401512146,
0.23820745944976807,
0.4438280165195465,
-0.2769801616668701,
-0.4247547686100006,
0.5186324119567871,
-0.1648600548505783,
0.052584607154130936,
0.4589063823223114,
0.5915135741233826,
-0.2576957046985626,
-0.7114702463150024,
-0.18746675550937653,
0.21951177716255188,
-0.6213310360908508,
-0.2801070511341095,
-0.5491093993186951,
-0.30120813846588135,
-0.5310871005058289,
0.16628175973892212,
-0.21557267010211945,
-0.19789397716522217,
0.048686590045690536,
-0.5275067687034607,
0.6548708081245422,
0.9615846872329712,
-0.05322463810443878,
0.08811794966459274,
-0.7616385221481323,
0.24990448355674744,
0.3229186236858368,
0.3094939589500427,
-0.053787123411893845,
-0.2086741030216217,
-0.14775581657886505,
-0.020091891288757324,
-0.30526676774024963,
-0.8887386322021484,
0.43908390402793884,
-0.00523323705419898,
0.6356101632118225,
0.7816283106803894,
0.08157704025506973,
0.42436373233795166,
-0.24736088514328003,
0.9828818440437317,
0.4402146637439728,
-0.572698175907135,
0.6238583922386169,
-0.4305526316165924,
0.017138324677944183,
0.45943453907966614,
0.6123839616775513,
-0.6426680684089661,
-0.18825587630271912,
-0.7701079249382019,
-0.955247700214386,
0.1113879457116127,
-0.32001563906669617,
-0.040456049144268036,
-0.23450729250907898,
0.36901265382766724,
0.3363858163356781,
0.10082503408193588,
-1.0686696767807007,
-0.22062194347381592,
0.10210525989532471,
-0.13586081564426422,
0.2812303304672241,
-0.24996113777160645,
-0.43534043431282043,
-0.34142032265663147,
0.542515754699707,
-0.11557749658823013,
0.32543522119522095,
0.20572853088378906,
-0.10454541444778442,
-0.21503344178199768,
0.6912504434585571,
0.11689671128988266,
0.5104336738586426,
-0.005824004299938679,
0.42562201619148254,
0.05376441031694412,
-0.3061332404613495,
0.002370049012824893,
0.049098238348960876,
-0.3289509117603302,
0.09484916180372238,
0.293378084897995,
0.7048137187957764,
0.387405663728714,
-0.4927549660205841,
0.9465910792350769,
0.174448162317276,
-0.0881451740860939,
-0.6643010377883911,
-0.29217544198036194,
0.20483368635177612,
0.08166750520467758,
0.10766824334859848,
-0.03443111479282379,
0.27332165837287903,
-0.7234287858009338,
0.4657677710056305,
0.8431731462478638,
-0.6636701822280884,
-0.631065845489502,
0.49935901165008545,
0.35467347502708435,
-0.08211103081703186,
0.1851537823677063,
-0.15866488218307495,
-0.3122534453868866,
0.37299850583076477,
0.41658341884613037,
0.7414894104003906,
-0.15756893157958984,
0.3819868564605713,
0.41921722888946533,
-0.040437664836645126,
0.015528302639722824,
0.22191543877124786,
0.2790251672267914,
-0.7416578531265259,
-0.2627342641353607,
-0.48089319467544556,
-0.46119949221611023,
0.3982451558113098,
-0.7930845618247986,
0.5600521564483643,
-0.4414474368095398,
-0.46975454688072205,
-0.037819184362888336,
0.12698371708393097,
-0.37395399808883667,
0.060041580349206924,
0.5147454142570496,
0.4616566300392151,
-0.9606822729110718,
0.6906999349594116,
0.8376398682594299,
-0.04440583661198616,
-0.5194647312164307,
0.45029082894325256,
0.46850481629371643,
-0.9729626774787903,
0.0230509415268898,
0.20283393561840057,
-0.24543559551239014,
-0.34874752163887024,
-0.6192115545272827,
-0.519698441028595,
1.0988082885742188,
0.1418820321559906,
-0.5019004940986633,
0.05813572183251381,
0.08500445634126663,
0.6119488477706909,
-0.4404774606227875,
0.16435542702674866,
0.3171828091144562,
0.42902007699012756,
0.052611857652664185,
-0.9850781559944153,
0.08642594516277313,
-0.22297175228595734,
-0.6112394332885742,
0.046931687742471695,
-0.8001614212989807,
0.7192935943603516,
-0.42568472027778625,
-0.16410541534423828,
-0.10416504740715027,
0.5835926532745361,
0.4578706920146942,
0.5451420545578003,
0.6589863896369934,
0.7325522303581238,
0.9291473627090454,
0.32261428236961365,
0.9376357793807983,
-0.36806991696357727,
0.45216771960258484,
1.0260316133499146,
-0.47443708777427673,
1.0762083530426025,
0.4291009306907654,
-0.211390882730484,
0.8750770092010498,
0.842035174369812,
0.03165489435195923,
0.3055765926837921,
0.2577616274356842,
-0.5546351075172424,
-0.3950175940990448,
-0.19859153032302856,
-0.29700252413749695,
0.28673431277275085,
0.6542366743087769,
-0.7254038453102112,
-0.24059200286865234,
-0.12401320785284042,
0.45925021171569824,
0.06691493093967438,
-0.7760474681854248,
0.8929599523544312,
0.2749669551849365,
-0.7894412279129028,
0.16664372384548187,
0.2732947766780853,
0.7868648171424866,
-0.4270581901073456,
-0.12537319958209991,
0.19188055396080017,
0.19778266549110413,
-0.5695562362670898,
-0.7875160574913025,
0.22640188038349152,
0.11156855523586273,
-0.2671670615673065,
-0.17546968162059784,
1.0211180448532104,
-0.2943454682826996,
-0.6536868214607239,
0.4499739706516266,
0.8199841976165771,
0.12573903799057007,
0.09974996745586395,
-0.8903139233589172,
-0.13411776721477509,
-0.10511328279972076,
-0.16614064574241638,
0.4374304711818695,
0.10691279172897339,
-0.2993292212486267,
0.23373717069625854,
0.4293893575668335,
0.42320671677589417,
-0.1934504210948944,
0.08790205419063568,
0.7615223526954651,
-0.5317219495773315,
-0.5055534839630127,
-1.0043330192565918,
0.061179812997579575,
-0.2834617495536804,
0.03836912289261818,
0.8535983562469482,
0.6425992250442505,
0.42314448952674866,
0.32838529348373413,
1.1792082786560059,
-0.1376483142375946,
0.692509651184082,
-0.43342098593711853,
0.7357240319252014,
-0.4030335247516632,
0.12978962063789368,
-0.05598224699497223,
-0.24785397946834564,
-0.456686794757843,
0.36494743824005127,
-0.4504643678665161,
-0.24873125553131104,
0.5841097235679626,
0.5759841799736023,
0.17931976914405823,
-0.052525393664836884,
-0.05004303529858589,
0.4338235855102539,
0.4329303503036499,
0.5915088653564453,
0.5487012267112732,
-0.1810590624809265,
0.24272416532039642,
0.14613376557826996,
-0.3410479724407196,
-0.27512800693511963,
-1.152554988861084,
-0.773687481880188,
-0.18861360847949982,
-0.46904903650283813,
-0.7242427468299866,
-0.1185731291770935,
1.4568864107131958,
0.7990900874137878,
-0.958069384098053,
-0.019420474767684937,
-0.014818882569670677,
0.09568526595830917,
-0.38370785117149353,
-0.21681849658489227,
0.40911054611206055,
0.25525760650634766,
-0.3716060519218445,
0.42719677090644836,
0.24595080316066742,
-0.37273672223091125,
-0.47888779640197754,
-0.07585499435663223,
-0.2708429992198944,
-0.02082008309662342,
0.8380063772201538,
0.48719924688339233,
-0.791024923324585,
-0.27453234791755676,
0.03255860507488251,
0.06527695804834366,
0.4430348873138428,
0.9857804775238037,
-0.5053319931030273,
0.5644516944885254,
0.16036830842494965,
0.4551251232624054,
0.5508179068565369,
0.1223735585808754,
0.5144299864768982,
-0.7160473465919495,
-0.1445079892873764,
0.368056058883667,
0.52129727602005,
0.5674715638160706,
-0.3741539418697357,
0.10612127929925919,
0.3327578604221344,
-0.33581507205963135,
-0.5432152152061462,
0.2916175425052643,
-1.2040420770645142,
-0.21977849304676056,
1.648937702178955,
-0.2386765033006668,
-0.06256058812141418,
-0.3275509476661682,
0.08699847757816315,
0.03628254309296608,
-0.45778515934944153,
0.7773574590682983,
0.6457476615905762,
-0.5489892959594727,
-0.11406520009040833,
-0.5050168633460999,
0.4458688497543335,
-0.02429107390344143,
-0.8886752724647522,
0.049092259258031845,
0.34125643968582153,
0.5382216572761536,
0.049154508858919144,
0.9396871328353882,
-0.459123820066452,
0.027515171095728874,
-0.5388925671577454,
-0.010958222672343254,
0.34829843044281006,
0.06326267123222351,
-0.5717401504516602,
0.48339247703552246,
0.2823072373867035,
0.1312817633152008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03334v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03334v1
|
DIVERSE: Deciphering Internet Views on the U.S. Military Through Video Comment Stance Analysis, A Novel Benchmark Dataset for Stance Classification
| 2024-03-05T21:36:23 | 2024-03-05T21:36:23 |
Iain J. Cruickshank, Lynnette Hui Xian Ng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Stance detection of social media text is a key component of downstream tasks
involving the identification of groups of users with opposing opinions on
contested topics such as vaccination and within arguments. In particular,
stance provides an indication of an opinion towards an entity. This paper
introduces DIVERSE, a dataset of over 173,000 YouTube video comments annotated
for their stance towards videos of the U.S. military. The stance is annotated
through a human-guided, machine-assisted labeling methodology that makes use of
weak signals of tone within the sentence as supporting indicators, as opposed
to using manual annotations by humans. These weak signals consist of the
presence of hate speech and sarcasm, the presence of specific keywords, the
sentiment of the text, and the stance inference from two Large Language Models.
The weak signals are then consolidated using a data programming model before
each comment is annotated with a final stance label. On average, the videos
have 200 comments each, and the stance of the comments skews slightly towards
the "against" characterization for both the U.S. Army and the videos posted on
the channel.
|
[
-0.9412698745727539,
-0.7802221179008484,
0.17142851650714874,
0.06667114794254303,
-0.5571635961532593,
0.45833033323287964,
0.08080087602138519,
-0.06141217425465584,
0.30928096175193787,
0.33887848258018494,
-0.7861939668655396,
-0.8415623307228088,
-1.1273232698440552,
0.018389683216810226,
-0.4060189425945282,
1.252145767211914,
0.13860301673412323,
-0.02684973180294037,
0.3244563937187195,
-0.5366266369819641,
0.2573050856590271,
-0.5100535750389099,
-0.09610778838396072,
-0.15084616839885712,
0.35856953263282776,
0.4625953733921051,
0.7908957600593567,
0.5730686187744141,
0.4113847613334656,
0.39390212297439575,
-0.10752706974744797,
-0.429759681224823,
-0.5641468167304993,
0.1894337236881256,
-0.3082876205444336,
-0.3804975152015686,
-0.1132369413971901,
0.1787436306476593,
0.7458643317222595,
0.5951565504074097,
0.3185993731021881,
0.31158778071403503,
-0.20916979014873505,
0.4039174020290375,
-0.593510627746582,
-0.4302613437175751,
-0.6995465755462646,
0.289871484041214,
-0.3159998953342438,
0.2704930007457733,
-0.10440702736377716,
-0.2208189219236374,
0.3153274655342102,
-0.28717029094696045,
0.4892648160457611,
-0.3420830965042114,
0.7454164028167725,
0.20892022550106049,
-0.7288058996200562,
0.18693006038665771,
-0.6429622173309326,
1.050035834312439,
-0.5572560429573059,
0.6665893793106079,
0.35078373551368713,
0.49382147192955017,
0.18897642195224762,
-0.2717963755130768,
-0.6412873864173889,
0.3122018575668335,
0.5389419794082642,
0.11267437785863876,
-0.2851122319698334,
0.0038925325497984886,
0.21429389715194702,
0.4336344301700592,
-0.48876628279685974,
0.20890536904335022,
-0.25132372975349426,
-0.09385652840137482,
0.550183892250061,
0.01656193658709526,
0.4496776759624481,
-0.3696114122867584,
-0.46150335669517517,
-0.0779842957854271,
-0.2308686226606369,
0.43928977847099304,
0.6156300902366638,
0.12404534965753555,
-0.4194399416446686,
0.697665274143219,
-0.5476391315460205,
0.3406623303890228,
0.21966376900672913,
-0.27680453658103943,
0.4168008267879486,
0.09514814615249634,
-0.47880110144615173,
-0.113093800842762,
0.8425175547599792,
0.6815710067749023,
0.1758921593427658,
0.18545237183570862,
-0.13450951874256134,
0.4041801691055298,
0.5324989557266235,
-0.7933478951454163,
-0.08591505885124207,
-0.08598548173904419,
-1.1059690713882446,
-0.38705867528915405,
0.26153868436813354,
-1.046817660331726,
-0.971235990524292,
-0.18579240143299103,
-0.05750450864434242,
-0.09974291175603867,
-0.40226709842681885,
-0.36735039949417114,
-0.47587868571281433,
0.23010866343975067,
0.36591777205467224,
-0.7158177495002747,
0.44779109954833984,
0.7415951490402222,
0.7360374331474304,
-0.24578414857387543,
0.02107631415128708,
-0.4428423345088959,
-0.23703987896442413,
0.09567016363143921,
0.9587165117263794,
-0.8303807973861694,
-0.3580635190010071,
0.022408656775951385,
0.09670602530241013,
0.3649018406867981,
-0.48760083317756653,
0.6014364957809448,
-0.6075851917266846,
-0.2287193238735199,
-0.4333851635456085,
-0.4443711042404175,
-0.5077406764030457,
0.7663953304290771,
-0.8530523180961609,
0.7027478218078613,
0.10420645028352737,
-0.9165821671485901,
0.7604759931564331,
-0.1456153690814972,
-0.21676789224147797,
-0.14680776000022888,
-0.5551386475563049,
-0.4743192791938782,
-0.021380528807640076,
0.10557591170072556,
0.5267925262451172,
-0.17286285758018494,
-0.060024626553058624,
-0.9887770414352417,
-0.05587293207645416,
0.3963901698589325,
-0.3372989296913147,
0.8191764950752258,
0.35398194193840027,
-0.6584603786468506,
-0.0564875565469265,
-0.6904424428939819,
-0.2302686721086502,
-0.3271707594394684,
-0.37393686175346375,
-0.2617405951023102,
0.06846196204423904,
0.08684350550174713,
0.4097258746623993,
-0.25419437885284424,
-0.652804970741272,
0.057204972952604294,
-0.3447111248970032,
0.0678996816277504,
0.8795362710952759,
0.2794232666492462,
0.3473573625087738,
0.011681207455694675,
0.7461795806884766,
0.1906929612159729,
0.4240652620792389,
0.2554856240749359,
-0.6224933862686157,
-0.4700998067855835,
-0.3704146146774292,
-0.2675971984863281,
0.5329160094261169,
-0.2953663170337677,
0.10535086691379547,
-0.13189101219177246,
-0.4858516752719879,
-0.2301652431488037,
0.5474354028701782,
0.24168714880943298,
0.26316556334495544,
0.32447510957717896,
-0.4082544147968292,
-0.8768892288208008,
-1.0897506475448608,
-0.5263744592666626,
-0.43767207860946655,
0.13687682151794434,
0.08440437912940979,
0.3697759509086609,
-0.47046810388565063,
0.5691696405410767,
-0.2879962921142578,
-0.029183421283960342,
-0.10842099040746689,
0.5491090416908264,
-0.033030226826667786,
-0.14619696140289307,
0.5363368391990662,
-1.1698802709579468,
-0.7756713032722473,
0.03771452233195305,
-0.8035134673118591,
0.1592205911874771,
-0.03167284280061722,
-0.07119277119636536,
-0.5843870043754578,
0.31872862577438354,
-0.38006657361984253,
0.4180435836315155,
0.4295506775379181,
-0.1668161004781723,
0.2014124095439911,
0.7575757503509521,
0.41630810499191284,
-0.8919007778167725,
-0.29691508412361145,
0.4153363108634949,
0.1063065305352211,
-0.6434800028800964,
-0.17695389688014984,
-0.5032404065132141,
-0.020265407860279083,
-0.4971352517604828,
0.18384318053722382,
0.0036617193836718798,
-0.028639107942581177,
-0.2647087275981903,
-0.1403498351573944,
-0.2178080826997757,
0.1343802809715271,
0.07075828313827515,
0.22037898004055023,
0.6364941596984863,
-0.3625311851501465,
0.46554237604141235,
0.23177824914455414,
-0.03999080881476402,
0.7886505126953125,
-0.17418250441551208,
-0.17366941273212433,
-0.09043402224779129,
0.22522704303264618,
-1.1486557722091675,
-0.35430416464805603,
0.3980817198753357,
-0.5337082147598267,
-0.019979750737547874,
-0.4258246421813965,
0.07871107757091522,
-0.18438822031021118,
-0.788784921169281,
0.45430564880371094,
0.12012653797864914,
-0.2975209653377533,
0.5529808402061462,
1.0705194473266602,
-0.17675140500068665,
-0.9828540086746216,
-0.7087443470954895,
0.039339225739240646,
-0.3911864757537842,
-0.310623437166214,
0.24156755208969116,
0.23535260558128357,
-0.6384971141815186,
-0.03613219037652016,
-0.380301296710968,
-0.5105924606323242,
-0.03242862969636917,
0.6156434416770935,
-0.03130316361784935,
-0.20524832606315613,
0.04468216747045517,
-0.01384319644421339,
0.28028857707977295,
0.1629900187253952,
0.004162788391113281,
0.29759809374809265,
-0.2984422445297241,
-0.3558201789855957,
-0.37636661529541016,
0.6922088265419006,
0.6486263871192932,
0.15624156594276428,
0.3397384285926819,
0.8099326491355896,
-0.28549039363861084,
-0.4656911790370941,
-0.4987069070339203,
-0.041154809296131134,
-0.5130915641784668,
0.24757342040538788,
0.027012312784790993,
-0.5654572248458862,
0.4757224917411804,
-0.181123286485672,
0.2209693342447281,
0.3899352252483368,
0.448454886674881,
-0.2656574845314026,
1.2060116529464722,
0.6416488885879517,
-0.4912942051887512,
0.645893394947052,
-0.2418101280927658,
-0.031465623527765274,
-0.2978459894657135,
-0.1559264361858368,
-0.43571728467941284,
-0.7774360179901123,
-0.7600241899490356,
-0.24263978004455566,
-0.04876268655061722,
-0.11574301868677139,
-0.5419750213623047,
0.060465626418590546,
-0.5996853113174438,
0.2342553287744522,
0.20526623725891113,
0.12758326530456543,
-0.13509178161621094,
0.3680606484413147,
-0.11189330369234085,
-0.48378631472587585,
0.01784663461148739,
-0.52851802110672,
1.1522266864776611,
0.3817065954208374,
0.6218134760856628,
0.395481139421463,
0.7727378606796265,
0.8030891418457031,
0.47074776887893677,
-1.2114254236221313,
0.7966336011886597,
-0.6555975675582886,
-0.46331658959388733,
0.04823604226112366,
-0.3123396039009094,
-0.718490719795227,
0.07629051804542542,
-0.4007689356803894,
-0.7225407958030701,
-0.037956658750772476,
0.07611497491598129,
0.009301173500716686,
0.5117116570472717,
-0.4540821611881256,
0.7356361746788025,
-0.3002326488494873,
-0.1682974249124527,
-0.27953583002090454,
-0.7931114435195923,
0.4507521986961365,
0.41070058941841125,
0.14938877522945404,
0.0007920761709101498,
-0.09963413327932358,
0.7206013798713684,
-0.299197256565094,
1.1257679462432861,
-0.43726715445518494,
0.3126530051231384,
0.27632150053977966,
-0.3329519033432007,
0.002635970478877425,
0.10038012266159058,
-0.016143837943673134,
-0.08552351593971252,
-0.48183828592300415,
-0.3043012022972107,
-0.3290586769580841,
0.6962690353393555,
-1.2010769844055176,
-0.4537304937839508,
-0.3277354836463928,
-0.015285249799489975,
-0.3926747441291809,
0.400431364774704,
0.16810521483421326,
0.145313560962677,
-0.6754651665687561,
0.47451862692832947,
0.9285833835601807,
-0.15437659621238708,
0.1676226556301117,
0.16163422167301178,
0.032494012266397476,
-0.7140710353851318,
0.7945968508720398,
0.16078737378120422,
-0.049943577498197556,
0.4815312623977661,
-0.014750747941434383,
-0.2397150844335556,
-0.550463080406189,
-0.5133005976676941,
0.03730779141187668,
-1.1344375610351562,
-0.0027487645857036114,
-0.6301911473274231,
0.011446606367826462,
-0.2429094761610031,
-0.2269241064786911,
-0.26016291975975037,
-0.3728443682193756,
-0.00032434536842629313,
-0.4441668391227722,
0.23696863651275635,
0.8508704304695129,
0.3477979898452759,
0.49430161714553833,
-0.6719154119491577,
0.8210117220878601,
0.4462520182132721,
0.44061440229415894,
-0.4867755174636841,
-0.3399728834629059,
0.05527679622173309,
-0.15670102834701538,
-0.5738115310668945,
-1.3507193326950073,
-0.0033058898989111185,
0.08693499863147736,
0.9032706022262573,
0.9267666339874268,
-0.022597752511501312,
0.4229874908924103,
0.046512044966220856,
0.910708487033844,
0.20747879147529602,
-0.8110585808753967,
0.5954145789146423,
-0.41443654894828796,
0.3167831301689148,
0.7270357012748718,
0.7749775052070618,
-0.24788732826709747,
-0.5766076445579529,
-0.7070828080177307,
-0.5947431325912476,
0.3896857500076294,
-0.14325757324695587,
0.040677472949028015,
-0.049802038818597794,
-0.11335090547800064,
0.21714454889297485,
0.2583293318748474,
-0.6479896306991577,
-0.26207858324050903,
-0.8532453775405884,
-0.28041598200798035,
0.19831261038780212,
0.07313068956136703,
-0.36671724915504456,
-0.04995664581656456,
0.37920570373535156,
-0.13920201361179352,
0.0328102745115757,
-0.285505473613739,
-0.2500266134738922,
-0.06759730726480484,
0.4468710124492645,
0.3852401375770569,
0.2403758019208908,
-0.22412896156311035,
0.5272971987724304,
0.15698359906673431,
-0.9269334077835083,
0.30610203742980957,
-0.07546255737543106,
-0.35460972785949707,
0.36794784665107727,
0.08789319545030594,
0.4476962387561798,
0.17938031256198883,
-0.4711017608642578,
0.5610488653182983,
-0.08879111707210541,
-0.17070311307907104,
-0.07988763600587845,
-0.08990491181612015,
-0.1198502853512764,
0.1576801836490631,
0.21029439568519592,
0.5369070172309875,
0.4641009271144867,
-0.7766870260238647,
0.5984607934951782,
0.7614023685455322,
-0.5738663673400879,
-0.5932474732398987,
0.4328656494617462,
0.29137322306632996,
-0.1994621604681015,
0.18108265101909637,
0.07706554979085922,
-0.6529273390769958,
0.563703179359436,
0.12737534940242767,
1.0891921520233154,
-0.2181900590658188,
0.802166223526001,
0.4027670621871948,
0.12349551916122437,
0.0745873674750328,
0.22831201553344727,
-0.15949904918670654,
-0.7258121967315674,
0.1416541337966919,
-0.4637901484966278,
-0.4068601131439209,
0.31028473377227783,
-0.8370203971862793,
0.432773619890213,
-1.2371255159378052,
-0.5909998416900635,
0.4581068754196167,
0.06720497459173203,
-0.7572891116142273,
0.6813662052154541,
0.5243682265281677,
0.42928022146224976,
-1.2443991899490356,
0.7194095253944397,
1.0865105390548706,
-0.36827290058135986,
-0.5677937269210815,
0.3057107925415039,
0.854742169380188,
-0.6052693128585815,
0.6773994565010071,
0.41327905654907227,
-0.5351821184158325,
-0.6890623569488525,
-0.38536572456359863,
-0.20879194140434265,
0.4816321134567261,
0.21026255190372467,
-0.08515653759241104,
0.4910144507884979,
0.4550357162952423,
0.4721582531929016,
-0.37471023201942444,
0.23682691156864166,
0.25045040249824524,
0.2474551647901535,
-0.14654864370822906,
-0.41295409202575684,
0.11841312050819397,
-0.6381452679634094,
-0.37262746691703796,
0.17429988086223602,
-0.8473989367485046,
1.0260978937149048,
0.3675631880760193,
-0.203349769115448,
-0.5233632326126099,
0.38967716693878174,
0.1790647655725479,
0.4678487479686737,
0.9633126854896545,
0.5589613914489746,
0.6415412425994873,
0.2750146985054016,
0.576225757598877,
0.2001837193965912,
0.08496181666851044,
0.6533717513084412,
-0.10849473625421524,
0.9044787883758545,
0.6110764145851135,
-0.14687281847000122,
0.8135862350463867,
0.4871887266635895,
-0.30196303129196167,
0.5259217619895935,
-0.026384687051177025,
-0.6449304223060608,
-0.26439395546913147,
-0.09871670603752136,
-0.23262298107147217,
0.5901687741279602,
0.45136913657188416,
-0.6284843683242798,
-0.3726124167442322,
-0.08661671727895737,
-0.11446831375360489,
0.3228403329849243,
-0.5076547861099243,
0.9107154607772827,
0.04193970561027527,
-0.5486760139465332,
0.47470149397850037,
-0.07498854398727417,
0.6210290193557739,
-0.45441579818725586,
-0.07926978170871735,
0.12485571950674057,
0.352691113948822,
-0.5312264561653137,
-1.0467060804367065,
0.2670329511165619,
0.5882337093353271,
-0.4544065594673157,
-0.16410882771015167,
0.7034022808074951,
0.05503986030817032,
-0.2360028624534607,
0.21617689728736877,
0.24633623659610748,
0.009911696426570415,
0.05171654000878334,
-0.9975579977035522,
0.2412864863872528,
0.11481001228094101,
-0.3649584650993347,
0.48259079456329346,
0.439668744802475,
-0.24705222249031067,
0.5956158638000488,
0.4812031090259552,
-0.1383959800004959,
0.17581874132156372,
0.2954484820365906,
1.1805050373077393,
-0.710698127746582,
-0.6089960336685181,
-0.9091914892196655,
0.5632312893867493,
-0.5541201233863831,
-0.5823436379432678,
0.9668078422546387,
0.535879909992218,
0.774838924407959,
-0.04214539751410484,
1.2588649988174438,
-0.04736974090337753,
0.5284690260887146,
-0.17442305386066437,
0.41622617840766907,
-0.4570889472961426,
0.20423157513141632,
-0.39132851362228394,
-0.6270106434822083,
-0.3275868892669678,
0.5888287425041199,
-0.3013373613357544,
-0.2874850928783417,
0.27500322461128235,
0.6531246304512024,
-0.5577454566955566,
0.30694377422332764,
-0.055913664400577545,
0.07950785756111145,
0.29019811749458313,
-0.057840343564748764,
0.9540589451789856,
-0.20820140838623047,
0.9235550165176392,
-0.40513932704925537,
-0.1759893149137497,
-0.3012581169605255,
-0.5781274437904358,
-1.1595768928527832,
-0.006771842483431101,
-0.3035043776035309,
-0.3362121284008026,
-0.26767390966415405,
0.9733608961105347,
0.8853281140327454,
-1.1044635772705078,
-0.24050657451152802,
-0.16630209982395172,
0.12403785437345505,
-0.2527875602245331,
-0.21215207874774933,
-0.12562969326972961,
0.055395159870386124,
-0.5039555430412292,
0.295052170753479,
0.23069077730178833,
-0.29576683044433594,
-0.2128247767686844,
-0.05934746935963631,
-0.37360912561416626,
0.0016468333778902888,
0.38826262950897217,
0.7105951905250549,
-0.9796929955482483,
-0.4509662091732025,
0.28155940771102905,
-0.05795227736234665,
0.1298288106918335,
0.7711565494537354,
-0.4649338722229004,
0.7307930588722229,
0.7758695483207703,
0.9750947952270508,
0.6444146633148193,
0.4799043536186218,
0.4115850627422333,
-0.9676448702812195,
0.34820711612701416,
0.4026486575603485,
0.2425544708967209,
0.5105628967285156,
-0.20358076691627502,
0.027463199570775032,
0.46446648240089417,
-0.3371067941188812,
-0.8146966695785522,
0.45723798871040344,
-1.3096396923065186,
-0.2998473346233368,
0.9340057373046875,
-0.24483050405979156,
0.05135045945644379,
-0.3723878264427185,
-0.19614006578922272,
0.33150526881217957,
-0.6017993688583374,
0.8446128368377686,
0.7503451704978943,
-0.09812361001968384,
-0.41202303767204285,
-0.5400463342666626,
0.4479399025440216,
0.42442286014556885,
-0.7282581925392151,
-0.3204861283302307,
0.4723288416862488,
0.3739453852176666,
0.08061310648918152,
0.4605288803577423,
0.21511483192443848,
0.3882620930671692,
0.29008597135543823,
-0.3408959209918976,
0.4354206919670105,
-0.2024581879377365,
-0.2938607633113861,
0.5923692584037781,
-0.091680146753788,
-0.30880242586135864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03329v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03329v3
|
Guardrail Baselines for Unlearning in LLMs
| 2024-03-05T21:19:06 | 2024-06-11T15:47:39 |
Pratiksha Thaker, Yash Maurya, Shengyuan Hu, Zhiwei Steven Wu, Virginia Smith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work has demonstrated that finetuning is a promising approach to
'unlearn' concepts from large language models. However, finetuning can be
expensive, as it requires both generating a set of examples and running
iterations of finetuning to update the model. In this work, we show that simple
guardrail-based approaches such as prompting and filtering can achieve
unlearning results comparable to finetuning. We recommend that researchers
investigate these lightweight baselines when evaluating the performance of more
computationally intensive finetuning methods. While we do not claim that
methods such as prompting or filtering are universal solutions to the problem
of unlearning, our work suggests the need for evaluation metrics that can
better separate the power of guardrails vs. finetuning, and highlights
scenarios where guardrails expose possible unintended behavior in existing
metrics and benchmarks.
|
[
-0.4932136833667755,
-0.7561168074607849,
0.5544020533561707,
-0.04315836355090141,
-0.5385070443153381,
0.28480663895606995,
-0.2949103116989136,
-0.07117577642202377,
-0.3472227454185486,
0.5952320098876953,
-0.7201318144798279,
-0.4356749951839447,
-0.5206505656242371,
-0.4286029040813446,
-0.5291881561279297,
1.0740852355957031,
-0.175779327750206,
0.38923054933547974,
-0.15951380133628845,
-0.12906013429164886,
-0.6342455744743347,
-0.1562718003988266,
-0.8427954316139221,
-0.8139288425445557,
0.484127938747406,
0.7727686166763306,
0.3482254147529602,
0.7318241000175476,
0.38587284088134766,
0.23719185590744019,
-0.48752158880233765,
0.14257460832595825,
-0.6739439964294434,
0.12045703083276749,
-0.2958706021308899,
-0.4775047302246094,
-0.1483316570520401,
-0.033414844423532486,
0.4687567353248596,
1.1286890506744385,
-0.29684561491012573,
0.21280430257320404,
0.7477306127548218,
0.8017910718917847,
-0.7126513719558716,
-0.010926708579063416,
-0.6599165797233582,
0.11190992593765259,
-0.34294581413269043,
-0.3540281057357788,
-0.18424749374389648,
-0.10406945645809174,
0.057429585605859756,
-0.4353499412536621,
0.3218216896057129,
0.0773579552769661,
0.6437492966651917,
0.4488442838191986,
-0.3533007502555847,
-0.203053817152977,
-0.6443386077880859,
0.9190660715103149,
-0.43122923374176025,
0.3212650418281555,
0.4266927242279053,
0.3027796447277069,
-0.2199787050485611,
-0.74171382188797,
-0.11306972801685333,
-0.21356219053268433,
-0.05223358795046806,
0.3898598849773407,
-0.31174084544181824,
0.19833675026893616,
0.3633289635181427,
0.4243859350681305,
-0.39188793301582336,
0.7547570466995239,
-0.5223067402839661,
-0.1151496171951294,
0.28075969219207764,
0.42719194293022156,
0.14232087135314941,
-0.28251713514328003,
-0.3850889801979065,
0.02846209518611431,
-1.0139188766479492,
0.2542977035045624,
0.3682905435562134,
0.3565032482147217,
-0.1908423900604248,
0.39634615182876587,
-0.31064891815185547,
0.36141982674598694,
0.05966633930802345,
0.17810001969337463,
-0.21670961380004883,
-0.08583417534828186,
-0.0693008303642273,
-0.20354679226875305,
0.5746092796325684,
0.6525714993476868,
0.5065292119979858,
-0.4317689538002014,
-0.4539029896259308,
0.26950162649154663,
0.17866362631320953,
-0.752072811126709,
-0.404948353767395,
0.20473338663578033,
-0.4284282922744751,
-0.21493247151374817,
-0.22503156960010529,
-1.0180957317352295,
-0.689579427242279,
-0.584534764289856,
0.40113165974617004,
-0.5105611085891724,
0.025423603132367134,
0.03712540864944458,
-0.12085504829883575,
0.32694539427757263,
0.456415593624115,
-1.0132806301116943,
0.35998889803886414,
0.7930521368980408,
0.9210847616195679,
-0.3463895618915558,
-0.3199765384197235,
-0.6584339141845703,
-0.3658325672149658,
-0.3586535155773163,
0.9695190191268921,
-0.014971364289522171,
-0.616641104221344,
0.033040601760149,
-0.09513365477323532,
0.2983261048793793,
-0.6672158241271973,
0.6550281047821045,
-0.42059022188186646,
0.11742930859327316,
-0.14370694756507874,
-0.6042457818984985,
0.10121988505125046,
-0.11790875345468521,
-0.39327219128608704,
0.8774815201759338,
-0.02385266311466694,
-0.48004579544067383,
0.6657370924949646,
-0.33935487270355225,
-0.3261009752750397,
0.1763043999671936,
-0.05194978788495064,
-0.45855602622032166,
0.23562832176685333,
0.16228893399238586,
0.5750476121902466,
-0.269629567861557,
0.5011811256408691,
-0.1364009976387024,
-0.46506011486053467,
-0.08160093426704407,
-0.7311891913414001,
0.8793468475341797,
0.6125828623771667,
-0.27040669322013855,
0.1077757254242897,
-0.7323163151741028,
0.036027729511260986,
-0.3075883090496063,
-0.523567259311676,
-0.2960508465766907,
0.17713865637779236,
-0.001112322206608951,
-0.16384443640708923,
0.2199811041355133,
-0.5272990465164185,
-0.12460992485284805,
-0.40053606033325195,
0.3427219092845917,
1.1992000341415405,
0.29533126950263977,
0.5833767652511597,
-0.5330185890197754,
0.4005025029182434,
-0.07334011793136597,
0.0745730996131897,
0.12390316277742386,
-0.12397535890340805,
-1.0464271306991577,
-0.14917074143886566,
0.2551005184650421,
0.21203164756298065,
-0.7368381023406982,
0.10425284504890442,
-0.009540621191263199,
-0.6111960411071777,
-0.4544098377227783,
0.585823655128479,
0.9608182907104492,
0.4856531620025635,
0.4354473650455475,
-0.388722687959671,
-0.6766473650932312,
-0.492330402135849,
-0.3088953495025635,
0.020055441185832024,
-0.06344499439001083,
-0.24957261979579926,
0.4496671259403229,
0.0441330149769783,
0.8118045330047607,
-0.3906305134296417,
-0.28462493419647217,
-0.17712736129760742,
0.34655335545539856,
0.021366802975535393,
0.6383271217346191,
0.27056628465652466,
-0.31565821170806885,
-0.3875699043273926,
-0.057832300662994385,
-0.7964780926704407,
-0.17784292995929718,
-0.053687237203121185,
0.05686766654253006,
-0.18775035440921783,
0.9416104555130005,
-0.28607937693595886,
0.265490859746933,
0.21966652572155,
-0.12237311899662018,
0.5588045120239258,
-0.26884421706199646,
-0.24777492880821228,
-0.9135286808013916,
-0.06964460015296936,
-0.03128715977072716,
-0.11373557895421982,
-0.8501334190368652,
0.00923236459493637,
-0.0056519294157624245,
0.07742837816476822,
-0.7248502373695374,
0.7140694856643677,
-0.6581725478172302,
-0.051313966512680054,
-0.4261035621166229,
0.3350064754486084,
-0.04271301254630089,
0.4922182857990265,
-0.22185258567333221,
0.8817940950393677,
0.6625908017158508,
-0.9847553968429565,
0.14222559332847595,
0.21293748915195465,
-0.6963310837745667,
0.7065356373786926,
-0.37928861379623413,
-0.23660685122013092,
-0.3483782112598419,
-0.01008687075227499,
-0.8469183444976807,
-0.09888269752264023,
-0.19216373562812805,
-0.3041283190250397,
0.16704091429710388,
-0.5059654712677002,
-0.2587473392486572,
-0.15635806322097778,
-0.49776580929756165,
-0.2227402776479721,
0.732323944568634,
-0.9182589054107666,
0.05945334956049919,
0.4303717613220215,
0.14980442821979523,
-0.5338528752326965,
-0.5570242404937744,
-0.13843800127506256,
-0.604583203792572,
0.05964318662881851,
0.2297370582818985,
0.04037749767303467,
-0.37390705943107605,
-0.18986622989177704,
-0.31134775280952454,
-0.03321360424160957,
0.5857946276664734,
0.4750535190105438,
0.12746873497962952,
-0.13840043544769287,
0.09682640433311462,
-0.2277888059616089,
-0.3666132986545563,
0.20492924749851227,
-0.10766653716564178,
0.696747899055481,
-0.06055205687880516,
-0.5609366297721863,
-0.32010161876678467,
0.023700911551713943,
0.41803714632987976,
-0.18637096881866455,
0.5137630105018616,
0.4853992760181427,
-0.47413140535354614,
-0.45789819955825806,
-0.3093074560165405,
-0.21923042833805084,
-0.5871991515159607,
0.26713910698890686,
-0.3225163221359253,
-0.9794940948486328,
0.6805119514465332,
-0.40700680017471313,
0.39930012822151184,
0.24947312474250793,
0.3455755412578583,
-0.5754603743553162,
1.027717113494873,
0.7329666018486023,
0.02632368728518486,
0.8550752997398376,
-0.4077260494232178,
-0.15683776140213013,
-0.9817233681678772,
-0.20636281371116638,
-0.6684076189994812,
-0.2213916778564453,
-0.6714800000190735,
0.03294263035058975,
0.18114808201789856,
0.6529536843299866,
-0.5446996688842773,
0.2032383233308792,
-0.2860288918018341,
0.8156248331069946,
0.6286934018135071,
0.2487647533416748,
0.4461248815059662,
0.25791239738464355,
-0.43709155917167664,
0.04078413173556328,
-0.6684677004814148,
-0.7341439127922058,
1.2216475009918213,
0.05964362248778343,
1.1380195617675781,
0.20104539394378662,
0.6837102174758911,
0.11443473398685455,
0.41323843598365784,
-0.8625385165214539,
0.6887275576591492,
-0.4378587305545807,
-0.286197692155838,
-0.246427521109581,
-0.5135842561721802,
-1.2908440828323364,
0.18797531723976135,
-0.3141174614429474,
-1.0207439661026,
0.1038125604391098,
0.26187312602996826,
-0.6998039484024048,
0.5110082030296326,
-0.7269649505615234,
0.7100212574005127,
-0.42571383714675903,
-0.38556843996047974,
-0.29410743713378906,
-0.31849405169487,
0.34249839186668396,
-0.1926695704460144,
-0.0062646628357470036,
-0.16170965135097504,
0.1977812796831131,
0.9165533781051636,
-0.47964462637901306,
1.1256072521209717,
-0.29911553859710693,
-0.0029294113628566265,
0.2570289373397827,
0.11179874837398529,
0.3394005000591278,
-0.19243039190769196,
0.13712947070598602,
-0.23595063388347626,
0.05460266396403313,
-0.2784900963306427,
-0.6172769665718079,
0.7913148403167725,
-0.8367480039596558,
-0.5377715826034546,
-0.19440412521362305,
-0.2157149612903595,
-0.5094472169876099,
0.15723469853401184,
0.42492395639419556,
0.519191324710846,
-0.2773110866546631,
0.19540470838546753,
0.8404549956321716,
0.0611070953309536,
0.6301936507225037,
0.798654317855835,
-0.18373586237430573,
-0.2687441408634186,
0.852977454662323,
0.30582723021507263,
0.27071866393089294,
0.1939360797405243,
0.25386881828308105,
-0.34368523955345154,
-1.0632672309875488,
-0.39072102308273315,
-0.02715909667313099,
-0.8850233554840088,
-0.29128575325012207,
-0.1532575637102127,
-0.1602959930896759,
-0.03370390087366104,
-0.4194001257419586,
-0.22858816385269165,
-0.41982871294021606,
-0.355995774269104,
-0.33919450640678406,
0.6268523931503296,
0.8713535666465759,
-0.35050299763679504,
0.8815112709999084,
-0.44725853204727173,
0.18461668491363525,
0.3349418640136719,
0.6658093929290771,
0.1195913702249527,
-0.8382812142372131,
-0.36145704984664917,
-0.07564689964056015,
-0.4415474832057953,
-0.3029196560382843,
0.0912095308303833,
-0.08307655900716782,
0.7992039918899536,
0.6897674202919006,
0.20957067608833313,
1.0274547338485718,
-0.6929517388343811,
0.5789636373519897,
0.1996934413909912,
-0.8257627487182617,
0.4876909852027893,
-0.31099429726600647,
0.2526593804359436,
0.9282739162445068,
0.20219261944293976,
-0.7250950336456299,
-0.3433350622653961,
-0.6703044176101685,
-0.9138885140419006,
0.64812833070755,
-0.1421298235654831,
0.14409251511096954,
0.26446911692619324,
0.443390429019928,
-0.12175215035676956,
0.0029294746927917004,
-0.4800272285938263,
-0.15734313428401947,
0.12122780829668045,
-0.12756909430027008,
-0.44717028737068176,
-0.16797442734241486,
-0.19904407858848572,
-0.06516756117343903,
0.4867173731327057,
-0.010144778527319431,
-0.07151827961206436,
-0.35891443490982056,
-0.4054715931415558,
-0.22414997220039368,
0.48414745926856995,
0.3049759864807129,
0.5309190154075623,
-0.2856638729572296,
0.452038437128067,
0.66251540184021,
-0.3521786630153656,
0.21399646997451782,
-0.32071468234062195,
-0.4006609320640564,
-0.34687986969947815,
0.45578330755233765,
0.6750571727752686,
0.36656731367111206,
-0.5891994833946228,
0.303506463766098,
0.26677411794662476,
-0.20095837116241455,
-0.10126224160194397,
0.275858998298645,
-0.031905487179756165,
0.06557054817676544,
-0.01945304498076439,
0.11871186643838882,
-0.12242530286312103,
-0.5640259385108948,
0.5440071225166321,
0.5370281338691711,
-0.7626038193702698,
-0.09799875319004059,
0.6758553385734558,
0.19739365577697754,
-0.22754275798797607,
0.29572319984436035,
0.03323143720626831,
-0.3080085217952728,
0.4890737533569336,
0.25742393732070923,
0.7029871344566345,
-0.04705478623509407,
0.05081624910235405,
0.17659857869148254,
0.3299248218536377,
-0.4194466471672058,
0.1178973913192749,
-0.207421213388443,
-0.6470853686332703,
-0.41482824087142944,
-0.527805507183075,
-0.8184179067611694,
0.23056086897850037,
-0.8434487581253052,
0.25162273645401,
-0.7631117701530457,
0.0035618406254798174,
0.0055625359527766705,
0.20608937740325928,
-0.5573762059211731,
0.14124631881713867,
0.03243826702237129,
0.7814810872077942,
-0.9415923953056335,
0.5339844226837158,
0.5271692276000977,
-0.584242582321167,
-0.7635626792907715,
-0.06833105534315109,
0.3699986934661865,
-0.8406031727790833,
0.3751876950263977,
0.12694746255874634,
-0.39612603187561035,
0.07040207833051682,
-0.4740552604198456,
-0.5827805995941162,
1.0478191375732422,
0.23865389823913574,
-0.4662315249443054,
0.15016335248947144,
0.15307390689849854,
0.6311439275741577,
0.04067755863070488,
0.2499733418226242,
0.6588817238807678,
0.15933582186698914,
-0.287945419549942,
-0.6107275485992432,
-0.09446258097887039,
0.04798220098018646,
-0.21020835638046265,
0.05791659653186798,
-0.8110794425010681,
0.8654668927192688,
0.1989762783050537,
-0.5245131850242615,
0.23615942895412445,
0.4855126738548279,
0.11961443722248077,
0.24635200202465057,
0.4003065824508667,
0.5560568571090698,
0.9252040386199951,
-0.2435484230518341,
0.5877410769462585,
-0.09826071560382843,
0.319979190826416,
1.269951343536377,
-0.20991301536560059,
0.885812520980835,
0.5408638119697571,
-0.1749226301908493,
0.16446156799793243,
0.7524595260620117,
0.12481839954853058,
0.6944647431373596,
0.3787787854671478,
-0.3204512298107147,
-0.2816953659057617,
-0.1911025047302246,
0.11758767813444138,
0.34092357754707336,
0.29004621505737305,
0.17267265915870667,
-0.8299802541732788,
0.26150044798851013,
0.36622154712677,
0.2578554153442383,
-0.6183004975318909,
0.9611486792564392,
0.33789631724357605,
-0.8934137225151062,
0.7035837769508362,
-0.014557931572198868,
0.816802978515625,
-0.4735353887081146,
0.18672321736812592,
-0.6770846247673035,
0.48263436555862427,
-0.25506797432899475,
-1.0658620595932007,
0.2488420158624649,
0.6234267950057983,
0.09787748008966446,
-0.772789478302002,
0.46083390712738037,
-0.2649013102054596,
-0.002471656771376729,
0.3322848379611969,
0.8875219821929932,
0.3478078246116638,
0.3049774765968323,
-0.6044188737869263,
-0.45718836784362793,
0.06958311796188354,
-0.14676271378993988,
0.626439094543457,
0.4860904812812805,
-0.29112082719802856,
1.0545793771743774,
0.8096721172332764,
0.13968759775161743,
0.053781021386384964,
0.32866498827934265,
0.9689750075340271,
-0.45722323656082153,
-0.24701745808124542,
-0.9581830501556396,
0.5849816799163818,
0.14327014982700348,
-0.49729123711586,
0.8974964022636414,
0.5665177702903748,
0.8694057464599609,
0.19850675761699677,
0.6194635629653931,
0.33888813853263855,
0.67315274477005,
-1.0232845544815063,
0.9157429337501526,
-0.4817504584789276,
0.6041987538337708,
-0.09338317066431046,
-0.7269645929336548,
-0.3537781834602356,
0.3734806478023529,
-0.2516624331474304,
-0.20708966255187988,
0.5771740674972534,
1.034498691558838,
-0.2444426566362381,
-0.15734580159187317,
0.5458105206489563,
-0.09037687629461288,
0.18214452266693115,
0.34966275095939636,
1.250939130783081,
-0.04317208752036095,
0.6436641812324524,
-0.2549695372581482,
0.0026078158989548683,
-0.009296356700360775,
-0.68229079246521,
-1.021401286125183,
-0.3739067018032074,
-0.1373233050107956,
-0.2705380618572235,
0.2612271308898926,
0.6943848729133606,
0.5582187175750732,
-0.8977641463279724,
-0.38444215059280396,
-0.4296237826347351,
0.2583271861076355,
-0.045378390699625015,
-0.13443362712860107,
0.3712402284145355,
-0.5753147602081299,
-0.5638018250465393,
0.4714547097682953,
-0.13316898047924042,
0.3576478064060211,
-0.4646511673927307,
-0.08992785215377808,
0.12289786338806152,
-0.026075147092342377,
0.22322668135166168,
0.530706524848938,
-0.5288783311843872,
-0.35732293128967285,
-0.30919286608695984,
-0.0861344262957573,
0.05098509043455124,
0.7620172500610352,
-0.8508055210113525,
0.1278754621744156,
0.3583504259586334,
0.5671640634536743,
0.6176714301109314,
0.005800032056868076,
0.2833751440048218,
-1.0307151079177856,
0.04063418135046959,
-0.156266987323761,
0.6813844442367554,
0.2901853919029236,
0.055886924266815186,
0.5170920491218567,
-0.11134790629148483,
-0.47293394804000854,
-0.9879485964775085,
0.33554795384407043,
-0.6088895201683044,
-0.16116701066493988,
0.9257243871688843,
-0.1343296319246292,
-0.03524235635995865,
-0.36091339588165283,
-0.14681869745254517,
0.22997026145458221,
-0.19754032790660858,
0.4534798562526703,
0.6361156105995178,
-0.06818505376577377,
-0.3998697102069855,
-0.8441649675369263,
0.720641553401947,
0.7389019131660461,
-0.822041928768158,
0.3746199607849121,
0.5004457831382751,
0.4860755205154419,
-0.06519412249326706,
0.5236015915870667,
0.1450193077325821,
0.16328078508377075,
-0.07077951729297638,
-0.02497403882443905,
0.12754714488983154,
-0.34796661138534546,
-0.8865715861320496,
-0.15375114977359772,
0.3187275826931,
-0.060770515352487564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03307v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03307v1
|
Book2Dial: Generating Teacher-Student Interactions from Textbooks for Cost-Effective Development of Educational Chatbots
| 2024-03-05T20:12:05 | 2024-03-05T20:12:05 |
Junling Wang, Jakub Macina, Nico Daheim, Sankalan Pal Chowdhury, Mrinmaya Sachan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Educational chatbots are a promising tool for assisting student learning.
However, the development of effective chatbots in education has been
challenging, as high-quality data is seldom available in this domain. In this
paper, we propose a framework for generating synthetic teacher-student
interactions grounded in a set of textbooks. Our approaches capture one aspect
of learning interactions where curious students with partial knowledge
interactively ask a teacher questions about the material in the textbook. We
highlight various quality criteria that such dialogues should fulfill and
compare several approaches relying on either prompting or fine-tuning large
language models. We use synthetic dialogues to train educational chatbots and
show benefits of further fine-tuning in different educational domains. However,
human evaluation shows that our best data synthesis method still suffers from
hallucinations and tends to reiterate information from previous conversations.
Our findings offer insights for future efforts in synthesizing conversational
data that strikes a balance between size and quality. We will open-source our
data and code.
|
[
-0.34120315313339233,
-0.8620328903198242,
0.19969530403614044,
-0.2354707419872284,
-0.012063187547028065,
0.15439195930957794,
-0.05789348855614662,
-0.311963826417923,
-0.1260572075843811,
0.5572855472564697,
-0.5377132892608643,
-0.12396915256977081,
0.19634279608726501,
-0.22094295918941498,
-0.4033888280391693,
0.8053905963897705,
0.30468517541885376,
0.3266751766204834,
-0.7005357146263123,
0.3150249421596527,
-0.49186214804649353,
-0.6000841856002808,
-0.667344331741333,
-0.3576231300830841,
0.2405960112810135,
0.8072870969772339,
0.881984531879425,
0.031513988971710205,
0.162567138671875,
0.26319655776023865,
0.14436332881450653,
0.5582175254821777,
-0.6414588689804077,
0.49275535345077515,
-0.2611445486545563,
-0.4455733299255371,
-0.2804037928581238,
0.12493046373128891,
0.563947856426239,
0.6553879380226135,
-0.07160453498363495,
-0.13090495765209198,
0.4748128652572632,
0.5887085795402527,
-0.10178548842668533,
0.14348110556602478,
-0.4147113263607025,
0.174715057015419,
0.17922981083393097,
-0.2009996771812439,
-0.6116746068000793,
-0.3131428062915802,
0.2360968440771103,
-0.619681715965271,
0.4137003421783447,
-0.16713698208332062,
0.577846884727478,
-0.03235475718975067,
-0.45099255442619324,
-0.6068093180656433,
-0.9636328816413879,
0.694252610206604,
-0.5098819732666016,
0.4071866273880005,
0.721466064453125,
0.48185333609580994,
-0.6121376752853394,
-0.677475094795227,
-0.7943248152732849,
-0.09699045121669769,
-0.2253216952085495,
0.4535970091819763,
0.17020419239997864,
-0.0222728680819273,
-0.015887049958109856,
0.1802242547273636,
-0.2255346179008484,
-0.27748343348503113,
-0.6365513801574707,
-0.1730985939502716,
0.6382916569709778,
0.3677111864089966,
0.3372243642807007,
-0.46186524629592896,
-0.2887054681777954,
-0.433409184217453,
-0.41425758600234985,
0.30451369285583496,
1.1341909170150757,
0.4243065118789673,
0.0036099469289183617,
0.6479628086090088,
0.13537579774856567,
0.5018038749694824,
-0.3360198438167572,
-0.10422467440366745,
-0.22826746106147766,
-0.7674579620361328,
0.2749592959880829,
0.011592925526201725,
0.6179695725440979,
0.7387875318527222,
0.4123955965042114,
0.02226545475423336,
-0.1311468780040741,
0.10814252495765686,
0.3948476314544678,
-1.0995205640792847,
-0.5884117484092712,
0.3906693160533905,
-0.09545350074768066,
-0.5871449708938599,
-0.17782333493232727,
-1.2960598468780518,
-0.35953980684280396,
-0.7375364899635315,
0.4628714621067047,
-0.4201575219631195,
-0.4191797971725464,
-0.17144732177257538,
-0.22852273285388947,
-0.033446382731199265,
0.35838717222213745,
-0.9525550603866577,
0.5895083546638489,
0.3993433117866516,
0.5141271948814392,
0.05970274284482002,
0.09771479666233063,
-0.4202137291431427,
0.04753870517015457,
-0.47752293944358826,
0.6120716333389282,
-0.7108089327812195,
-0.8599685430526733,
0.3396022617816925,
-0.26716551184654236,
0.29282495379447937,
-0.500712513923645,
0.1233999952673912,
-0.052967850118875504,
0.7048813700675964,
-0.011220861226320267,
-0.6818252801895142,
0.15581753849983215,
0.18194979429244995,
-0.23052044212818146,
1.1758438348770142,
0.34248971939086914,
-0.18578749895095825,
-0.053358808159828186,
-0.3706764578819275,
-0.36561495065689087,
0.06196703016757965,
-0.17270156741142273,
-0.27155324816703796,
-0.364944189786911,
-0.06933513283729553,
0.17842650413513184,
-0.43620142340660095,
0.3471619486808777,
0.21338343620300293,
-0.12753719091415405,
0.5701231360435486,
-0.39845818281173706,
0.39118751883506775,
0.24340827763080597,
0.06243524327874184,
-0.10957283526659012,
-0.8082749843597412,
0.2640846073627472,
0.1204252690076828,
-0.13810764253139496,
-0.22985464334487915,
0.2712140381336212,
0.2185322493314743,
-0.22071155905723572,
0.06248662993311882,
-0.25147292017936707,
0.30861297249794006,
-0.6550348997116089,
0.399740070104599,
0.5436034798622131,
0.26774439215660095,
0.5404350757598877,
-0.4356022775173187,
0.38038721680641174,
-0.0275835320353508,
0.2834586501121521,
-0.3785313367843628,
-0.43829214572906494,
-0.8901597857475281,
0.16282036900520325,
0.27695342898368835,
0.27452242374420166,
-0.8386920094490051,
0.09106139093637466,
-0.004615779500454664,
-0.686816930770874,
-0.34651026129722595,
0.35970020294189453,
0.38150081038475037,
0.439965158700943,
0.29359564185142517,
-0.3714454472064972,
-0.4155048727989197,
-0.5806746482849121,
-0.037120427936315536,
-0.2979191541671753,
-0.18440331518650055,
0.7460381388664246,
0.13187527656555176,
-0.15473422408103943,
1.3136111497879028,
-0.47924819588661194,
-0.3638942837715149,
-0.11835568398237228,
-0.12060900777578354,
-0.178383469581604,
0.8582256436347961,
0.5269559621810913,
-0.8088740706443787,
-0.4710879325866699,
-0.061156220734119415,
-0.5208631753921509,
0.16645468771457672,
-0.3893062174320221,
-0.7193629145622253,
0.2575790584087372,
0.40787380933761597,
-0.5056749582290649,
0.26807141304016113,
0.23243263363838196,
-0.07790740579366684,
0.2824260890483856,
-0.08876360207796097,
0.05205702781677246,
-1.3140764236450195,
-0.27175652980804443,
-0.189390167593956,
-0.13454365730285645,
-0.7803966403007507,
-0.3747195899486542,
-0.1850907802581787,
-0.5272913575172424,
-0.27187755703926086,
0.8537856340408325,
-0.16768662631511688,
0.0240161269903183,
-0.02630293183028698,
0.530032753944397,
-0.1695229709148407,
0.6150277853012085,
-0.003596522379666567,
0.8994227647781372,
0.16962434351444244,
-0.521847665309906,
0.48236778378486633,
0.7378795146942139,
-0.24012766778469086,
0.5315150022506714,
-0.8058980107307434,
0.2628456652164459,
0.18011754751205444,
0.4427899122238159,
-1.0946738719940186,
-0.6141269207000732,
0.5311322808265686,
-0.6783638000488281,
0.24823814630508423,
-0.4378955066204071,
-0.6563663482666016,
-0.16757917404174805,
-0.25734421610832214,
0.29663708806037903,
0.8409022688865662,
-0.5415353178977966,
0.4904552102088928,
0.49285027384757996,
-0.4935111403465271,
-0.054449208080768585,
-0.1484411358833313,
0.2560427486896515,
0.3744312524795532,
-0.3862636983394623,
0.06225783750414848,
-0.22481213510036469,
-0.046642813831567764,
0.0009943023324012756,
-0.12031792849302292,
-0.23174676299095154,
-0.16195234656333923,
0.34501558542251587,
0.5773545503616333,
0.08179092407226562,
0.4993989169597626,
0.46848878264427185,
-0.025441011413931847,
0.12549547851085663,
-0.24624398350715637,
0.7302954196929932,
0.3720549941062927,
-0.15335239470005035,
-0.4787262976169586,
0.12750700116157532,
0.389566034078598,
0.06260254234075546,
0.373575896024704,
0.19072186946868896,
-0.5184638500213623,
-0.46364158391952515,
-0.16675932705402374,
-0.7805448174476624,
-0.5477006435394287,
0.2272595465183258,
-0.22616930305957794,
-0.4543810188770294,
0.08397729694843292,
-0.06171489134430885,
0.271089106798172,
-0.16669616103172302,
0.6352447271347046,
-0.12569858133792877,
0.8301068544387817,
0.11904933303594589,
0.6096380352973938,
0.5850630402565002,
-0.17645639181137085,
0.4551610052585602,
-0.44168105721473694,
-0.6951907277107239,
-0.4354711174964905,
-0.066900834441185,
-0.5040132999420166,
-0.5091801285743713,
0.3075074553489685,
0.08543151617050171,
-0.05173334851861,
0.3152671754360199,
-0.6483747363090515,
0.5194959044456482,
0.7630503177642822,
0.23299741744995117,
-0.0874486044049263,
0.3135281205177307,
0.04446090757846832,
-0.00021327767171896994,
-0.5641487240791321,
-0.880951464176178,
1.0524660348892212,
-0.03038794733583927,
0.5690134763717651,
0.40065494179725647,
0.5199218988418579,
0.2698509097099304,
-0.03270755335688591,
-0.8204257488250732,
0.7177756428718567,
0.42614760994911194,
-0.7904053330421448,
-0.5004727840423584,
-0.5027722120285034,
-1.085149884223938,
0.12335965037345886,
-0.5896169543266296,
-0.5435084104537964,
-0.23603622615337372,
0.14883798360824585,
-0.09982109069824219,
-0.07405322045087814,
-0.8336254358291626,
0.7268063426017761,
0.16435186564922333,
-0.717682421207428,
-0.3120182752609253,
-0.5628801584243774,
0.016337713226675987,
-0.17463703453540802,
0.11575949937105179,
0.02394857443869114,
0.36197972297668457,
0.6806437969207764,
-0.7047668099403381,
1.150960087776184,
-0.053231775760650635,
-0.37545305490493774,
0.9504579901695251,
0.4623921811580658,
0.19666782021522522,
0.374521404504776,
0.03866233676671982,
-0.23796597123146057,
0.3831554353237152,
-0.5737944841384888,
-0.5773946046829224,
0.5951709747314453,
-0.974219799041748,
-0.6830658912658691,
-0.22774846851825714,
-0.643130898475647,
-0.5573539137840271,
0.07584322243928909,
-0.2132401466369629,
0.9001941680908203,
-0.093778595328331,
0.04609148949384689,
0.18738779425621033,
-0.26798176765441895,
0.21772684156894684,
0.26483356952667236,
-0.21470974385738373,
-0.4276113212108612,
1.3242963552474976,
0.2548576593399048,
0.4834275543689728,
0.032029468566179276,
0.13782532513141632,
-0.2640376091003418,
0.12088239192962646,
-0.6685065627098083,
-0.007934578694403172,
-0.696541965007782,
-0.17421795427799225,
-0.5775550603866577,
-0.4853416085243225,
-0.6429019570350647,
-0.34562167525291443,
-0.23265837132930756,
-0.5406299233436584,
-0.35021987557411194,
0.0324370451271534,
0.43124356865882874,
0.7710067629814148,
-0.036334145814180374,
0.1663021743297577,
-1.0206819772720337,
0.009190434589982033,
0.7631585597991943,
-0.030730171129107475,
0.20648472011089325,
-0.3583028316497803,
0.05278617888689041,
0.4653427004814148,
-0.6400606632232666,
-0.6675481796264648,
0.3768780529499054,
0.3173283040523529,
0.13237245380878448,
0.20554059743881226,
0.4828730821609497,
0.2966422736644745,
-0.5413926839828491,
1.1293431520462036,
0.316465824842453,
-0.8331230282783508,
0.6966084241867065,
-0.2681664228439331,
-0.27856025099754333,
0.0740317776799202,
0.2515489459037781,
-0.4238225221633911,
-0.46862831711769104,
-0.6656572818756104,
-0.7836938500404358,
0.9114570021629333,
0.6446148753166199,
0.9529381990432739,
0.17936614155769348,
0.3021956980228424,
0.22832804918289185,
0.193280890583992,
-0.17962263524532318,
-0.19773848354816437,
-0.3272230923175812,
-0.5849753618240356,
-0.005608841776847839,
-0.39782780408859253,
-0.2666318118572235,
-0.15099048614501953,
0.5541792511940002,
-0.04105096310377121,
0.06746482104063034,
0.06164383888244629,
0.3604884147644043,
-0.1334998458623886,
0.02194346860051155,
0.3619080185890198,
0.4794732928276062,
0.11841529607772827,
0.056018050760030746,
0.03271971270442009,
-0.6630097031593323,
0.07270628958940506,
-0.17391639947891235,
0.035196032375097275,
0.011643130332231522,
0.05085007846355438,
0.41190579533576965,
0.3313550651073456,
-0.9147711396217346,
0.43075183033943176,
-0.06402485817670822,
-0.07883875072002411,
-0.5896965265274048,
0.6691166162490845,
0.10481613874435425,
0.2697921097278595,
0.1425555795431137,
-0.047445740550756454,
-0.015917671844363213,
-0.6788778901100159,
0.16291995346546173,
0.13088220357894897,
-0.420159250497818,
-0.4567040205001831,
0.5673936605453491,
0.8771560788154602,
-0.776059627532959,
0.8020308017730713,
0.05016014724969864,
-0.47921112179756165,
0.6244475245475769,
0.5355041027069092,
0.20532821118831635,
-0.07059130817651749,
0.565622866153717,
0.7683809995651245,
-0.19769585132598877,
0.1829601675271988,
0.0317830853164196,
-0.4458976686000824,
-0.8188658356666565,
0.2056151032447815,
-0.29481586813926697,
-1.2607663869857788,
-0.2548731863498688,
-0.48281359672546387,
0.5022889971733093,
-0.3400678336620331,
-0.03627002239227295,
0.21769970655441284,
0.026870667934417725,
-0.4211285412311554,
0.14054441452026367,
-0.06985108554363251,
0.19069992005825043,
-0.3492749035358429,
0.6408383250236511,
0.6024583578109741,
-0.41083967685699463,
-0.6665633916854858,
-0.2278347611427307,
-0.15421023964881897,
-0.4160005450248718,
0.3382296562194824,
0.028680989518761635,
0.08268960565328598,
0.3486328125,
-0.6637404561042786,
-0.2979985177516937,
0.5634145736694336,
0.08112947642803192,
-0.5867615342140198,
0.11693985015153885,
0.48986220359802246,
0.48234257102012634,
0.11252753436565399,
0.25684434175491333,
0.23147234320640564,
0.10831032693386078,
0.3509286344051361,
-0.45101460814476013,
-0.26627975702285767,
-0.38803181052207947,
-0.18274296820163727,
0.1637229323387146,
-0.639054000377655,
0.4237085282802582,
-0.1974337100982666,
-0.24549368023872375,
0.2980695366859436,
0.5419299006462097,
-0.1899990439414978,
0.5601387023925781,
0.27288737893104553,
-0.1256544142961502,
0.8257954716682434,
-0.09933101385831833,
0.7983213663101196,
-0.4582565724849701,
0.4372791647911072,
0.9794663190841675,
-0.25143882632255554,
0.6950927972793579,
0.4824005663394928,
-0.38545748591423035,
0.14230678975582123,
0.695971667766571,
-0.04985347390174866,
0.165813609957695,
0.2735538184642792,
-0.48735374212265015,
-0.49261724948883057,
-0.2550559639930725,
-0.33758971095085144,
0.185578852891922,
0.45468905568122864,
0.2938217520713806,
0.10250124335289001,
0.055913813412189484,
-0.0939583107829094,
0.17857445776462555,
0.20217379927635193,
0.8579251170158386,
0.08677349984645844,
-0.734302818775177,
0.402817040681839,
-0.38369056582450867,
0.0402379184961319,
-0.21602217853069305,
-0.4502122700214386,
-0.30439135432243347,
0.10461699962615967,
-0.06555192172527313,
-0.9032641053199768,
-0.2700205445289612,
0.021839378401637077,
-0.09867420792579651,
-0.13510635495185852,
0.5606987476348877,
-0.9137036204338074,
-0.49530351161956787,
-0.22452588379383087,
0.4514226019382477,
0.43994566798210144,
0.43388593196868896,
-0.15004722774028778,
-0.24454393982887268,
0.0537109375,
-0.15556585788726807,
0.3617030382156372,
0.4540863037109375,
0.10088977962732315,
0.5269392132759094,
1.0907689332962036,
-0.18673300743103027,
-0.3837103545665741,
0.0759219080209732,
0.8560606241226196,
-0.3356652855873108,
-0.15965969860553741,
-0.2967584431171417,
0.44381237030029297,
-0.1981075555086136,
-0.48979276418685913,
0.5203831195831299,
0.50361168384552,
0.872035801410675,
-0.0364508256316185,
0.7931562662124634,
0.15342411398887634,
0.5189498066902161,
-0.45687392354011536,
0.7412416934967041,
-0.5049984455108643,
0.05201122909784317,
-0.08102371543645859,
-1.09104323387146,
0.23985639214515686,
0.7734848856925964,
0.32255634665489197,
-0.12002603709697723,
0.2915031313896179,
0.940670371055603,
-0.01912795938551426,
0.4442373514175415,
0.4636348485946655,
0.003556534880772233,
0.6893624067306519,
0.13999247550964355,
0.9285974502563477,
-0.729053795337677,
0.731897234916687,
-0.2681000828742981,
-0.03228916600346565,
-0.4236311912536621,
-0.2307032346725464,
-1.2256464958190918,
-0.891676127910614,
-0.40342938899993896,
-0.6762284636497498,
0.10128287971019745,
1.2315222024917603,
0.46686261892318726,
-0.5307465195655823,
-0.19348454475402832,
-0.23059824109077454,
0.06685005128383636,
0.3695337176322937,
-0.23436173796653748,
0.09662896394729614,
-0.729569673538208,
-1.3724421262741089,
0.2216353863477707,
-0.31053826212882996,
0.525849461555481,
-0.19763916730880737,
-0.14345331490039825,
0.5347802639007568,
0.6338297724723816,
0.6430476903915405,
0.021496988832950592,
-0.32165101170539856,
-0.29866209626197815,
-0.08390562236309052,
-0.3656463623046875,
-0.2647780478000641,
0.7846592664718628,
-0.7279000282287598,
0.8841432929039001,
0.2731180191040039,
0.6963984370231628,
0.31901589035987854,
-0.0218981746584177,
0.5667498707771301,
-0.5223302841186523,
0.30990245938301086,
0.3191375732421875,
-0.2018118053674698,
0.26406431198120117,
-0.18242739140987396,
0.6511808633804321,
0.28024429082870483,
-0.4699000120162964,
-1.2452881336212158,
0.09291279315948486,
-0.8349085450172424,
-0.19003748893737793,
1.359337568283081,
0.1350417137145996,
0.05664124712347984,
0.008516812697052956,
-0.8494075536727905,
0.24090084433555603,
-0.44134071469306946,
0.6777177453041077,
0.6709591746330261,
0.11439651250839233,
0.21912065148353577,
-0.5861182808876038,
0.5475009679794312,
0.33625325560569763,
-0.7780108451843262,
-0.04643014445900917,
0.5905280709266663,
-0.08520442992448807,
0.09267038851976395,
0.24565301835536957,
0.015738585963845253,
0.2619536817073822,
0.4252387285232544,
0.1492009311914444,
0.052439406514167786,
-0.3929624855518341,
0.6043359637260437,
-0.09687890857458115,
-0.29658734798431396,
-0.12515215575695038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03305v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03305v1
|
Best of Both Worlds: A Pliable and Generalizable Neuro-Symbolic Approach for Relation Classification
| 2024-03-05T20:08:32 | 2024-03-05T20:08:32 |
Robert Vacareanu, Fahmida Alam, Md Asiful Islam, Haris Riaz, Mihai Surdeanu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper introduces a novel neuro-symbolic architecture for relation
classification (RC) that combines rule-based methods with contemporary deep
learning techniques. This approach capitalizes on the strengths of both
paradigms: the adaptability of rule-based systems and the generalization power
of neural networks. Our architecture consists of two components: a declarative
rule-based model for transparent classification and a neural component to
enhance rule generalizability through semantic text matching. Notably, our
semantic matcher is trained in an unsupervised domain-agnostic way, solely with
synthetic data. Further, these components are loosely coupled, allowing for
rule modifications without retraining the semantic matcher. In our evaluation,
we focused on two few-shot relation classification datasets: Few-Shot TACRED
and a Few-Shot version of NYT29. We show that our proposed method outperforms
previous state-of-the-art models in three out of four settings, despite not
seeing any human-annotated training data. Further, we show that our approach
remains modular and pliable, i.e., the corresponding rules can be locally
modified to improve the overall model. Human interventions to the rules for the
TACRED relation \texttt{org:parents} boost the performance on that relation by
as much as 26\% relative improvement, without negatively impacting the other
relations, and without retraining the semantic matching component.
|
[
-0.010178717784583569,
-0.5195649862289429,
0.44048577547073364,
0.09590418636798859,
-0.37614905834198,
-0.1530272513628006,
-0.3291480839252472,
-0.5573040246963501,
0.14925892651081085,
0.26889073848724365,
-0.5565899610519409,
-0.6167148351669312,
-0.5557133555412292,
-0.05927891656756401,
0.05527535080909729,
1.119769811630249,
0.12681369483470917,
0.18215033411979675,
-0.28805306553840637,
-0.28253665566444397,
-0.3722690939903259,
-0.6264980435371399,
-0.5785045027732849,
-0.6241991519927979,
0.6840243935585022,
0.07380981743335724,
0.87703937292099,
0.9173544049263,
0.5808711051940918,
0.2603294551372528,
-0.23250770568847656,
0.4283461272716522,
-0.1525702029466629,
0.2751131057739258,
-0.22592483460903168,
-0.3651188611984253,
-0.6681143641471863,
-0.12803199887275696,
0.14685022830963135,
0.7509080171585083,
-0.15335823595523834,
0.11635828018188477,
-0.11834356188774109,
0.5151117444038391,
-0.7181084156036377,
0.656093418598175,
-0.6243069171905518,
0.26272985339164734,
0.02748982608318329,
-0.2856728136539459,
-0.48641443252563477,
-0.20086874067783356,
0.20344829559326172,
-0.7428073287010193,
0.2047630250453949,
-0.05351449176669121,
1.1521447896957397,
0.13291209936141968,
-0.6560903191566467,
-0.12406111508607864,
-0.723296046257019,
0.5171300768852234,
-0.542567253112793,
0.5221678614616394,
0.37153878808021545,
0.4557200074195862,
-0.33218756318092346,
-0.7834823727607727,
-0.409667432308197,
-0.16132517158985138,
-0.38272562623023987,
-0.04670184850692749,
-0.24825923144817352,
0.34362632036209106,
0.23269721865653992,
0.23159649968147278,
-0.3890720307826996,
0.1353534758090973,
-0.023529428988695145,
-0.1922278255224228,
0.6145193576812744,
0.3705712556838989,
0.4728001654148102,
-0.15058785676956177,
-0.2684156596660614,
-0.06780511885881424,
-0.452760249376297,
-0.2467224895954132,
0.1481747329235077,
0.4495220482349396,
-0.17873606085777283,
0.22687511146068573,
-0.16496506333351135,
0.594741940498352,
0.0623503178358078,
-0.046322789043188095,
0.11347564309835434,
-0.31549686193466187,
-0.2633308172225952,
-0.14813636243343353,
1.0778697729110718,
0.4658823311328888,
0.626133143901825,
-0.4729274809360504,
0.015272530727088451,
0.6194074153900146,
0.021319538354873657,
-0.7522350549697876,
-0.26621243357658386,
-0.3236374258995056,
-0.5456880331039429,
-0.2281697392463684,
0.05220058932900429,
-0.443057119846344,
-0.4078187942504883,
-0.6868131160736084,
0.22613625228405,
-0.5298991799354553,
-0.3556133210659027,
-0.04219921678304672,
-0.07969308644533157,
0.37980619072914124,
0.4457782208919525,
-1.077605962753296,
0.7787624597549438,
1.093061923980713,
0.8553635478019714,
0.01227729395031929,
-0.17917785048484802,
-0.2932948172092438,
0.2240559458732605,
-0.4264746904373169,
0.712732195854187,
-0.42724084854125977,
0.3264011740684509,
0.01119284424930811,
-0.3790875971317291,
-0.03521006554365158,
-0.5206364989280701,
0.3615459203720093,
-0.8839645981788635,
0.23598577082157135,
0.19258800148963928,
-0.557029128074646,
-0.17836414277553558,
0.3297005295753479,
-0.6110022068023682,
0.5346137881278992,
0.13877803087234497,
-0.7442007660865784,
0.6076299548149109,
-0.5027194619178772,
-0.5683835744857788,
-0.024390699341893196,
-0.367708683013916,
-0.40704065561294556,
-0.07601964473724365,
-0.15552887320518494,
0.6659826040267944,
-0.3766315281391144,
0.5229295492172241,
-0.47102996706962585,
-0.26582375168800354,
-0.025575734674930573,
-0.05930592492222786,
0.6895873546600342,
0.11685778945684433,
-0.11937523633241653,
0.27941498160362244,
-0.809175431728363,
-0.08810146152973175,
0.02207920514047146,
-0.06016126275062561,
-0.7115091681480408,
-0.1055070087313652,
0.0816219374537468,
0.6096321940422058,
0.03667239099740982,
-0.49169307947158813,
0.2600301504135132,
-0.5745234489440918,
0.5969801545143127,
0.6145377159118652,
0.06474535912275314,
0.8974291682243347,
-0.1828167885541916,
0.18022826313972473,
0.2288743257522583,
0.3006938695907593,
0.06917746365070343,
-0.3669896721839905,
-0.7187426090240479,
-0.13409574329853058,
0.6375440955162048,
0.3826133608818054,
-0.5791241526603699,
0.5849775075912476,
-0.6316848993301392,
-0.34198322892189026,
-0.16897159814834595,
0.14154280722141266,
0.5681792497634888,
0.486764520406723,
0.38196319341659546,
-0.3363765776157379,
-0.5037397742271423,
-1.0838584899902344,
-0.11378021538257599,
-0.23135484755039215,
0.08838694542646408,
0.23233240842819214,
0.5365164875984192,
-0.040433697402477264,
0.7932574152946472,
-0.5116901397705078,
-0.6654196381568909,
-0.009629474021494389,
0.01455728430300951,
0.29148998856544495,
0.34860026836395264,
0.5735677480697632,
-0.8026602864265442,
-0.39296653866767883,
0.3157103657722473,
-1.0792237520217896,
0.2767994999885559,
0.0708659365773201,
-0.2669919729232788,
-0.05744022876024246,
0.3376544415950775,
-0.6116528511047363,
0.4564438462257385,
-0.12374382466077805,
-0.5707611441612244,
0.19754520058631897,
-0.14400121569633484,
-0.2847153842449188,
-1.0644638538360596,
-0.3675703704357147,
0.17116156220436096,
-0.2707206606864929,
-0.8298990726470947,
0.2273428589105606,
0.17223428189754486,
0.27073895931243896,
-0.4502406418323517,
0.4074264168739319,
-0.317751944065094,
0.0616091825067997,
-0.25606557726860046,
-0.22895267605781555,
-0.189294695854187,
0.8018357753753662,
0.18778498470783234,
0.19448815286159515,
0.49669262766838074,
-0.8665410280227661,
0.3986918330192566,
0.4937744736671448,
0.11598917841911316,
0.7194105982780457,
-0.34464791417121887,
0.2506238520145416,
-0.276224821805954,
0.33543381094932556,
-0.5719536542892456,
-0.1735682338476181,
0.49181321263313293,
-0.5343750715255737,
0.38928794860839844,
-0.22044163942337036,
-0.7109869122505188,
0.2354874312877655,
-0.39362168312072754,
0.3286798894405365,
0.40298396348953247,
-0.6237369775772095,
1.1427305936813354,
0.09318221360445023,
0.2264678180217743,
-0.48649537563323975,
-0.7988849878311157,
0.15932908654212952,
-0.04353506118059158,
-0.6099091172218323,
0.7161113619804382,
0.16485944390296936,
-0.2488204538822174,
0.21864308416843414,
-0.3394382894039154,
-0.6481220722198486,
-0.018488075584173203,
0.4124167859554291,
0.3175114095211029,
-0.21386754512786865,
0.35638028383255005,
0.04902457818388939,
-0.16606251895427704,
0.16513434052467346,
0.05557621642947197,
0.3378058671951294,
-0.011331216432154179,
0.3727993369102478,
-0.738739550113678,
0.2196795791387558,
0.5708078145980835,
-0.0441049225628376,
0.7283536791801453,
0.24436531960964203,
-0.5636889338493347,
-0.4720003604888916,
-0.3607640862464905,
-0.32683566212654114,
-0.4274955987930298,
0.3234584331512451,
-0.6145709753036499,
-0.7593357563018799,
0.4008447229862213,
-0.05295339226722717,
-0.038782499730587006,
0.3455217182636261,
0.20874740183353424,
0.02567070536315441,
0.7711776494979858,
0.9021814465522766,
-0.12614406645298004,
0.3388632535934448,
-0.3909759521484375,
-0.05492433160543442,
-0.7725986838340759,
-0.5515206456184387,
-0.2958178222179413,
-0.4675211012363434,
-0.6871292591094971,
0.1338287889957428,
-0.07435213774442673,
-0.06216822937130928,
-0.4989752471446991,
0.7639791369438171,
-0.6100887060165405,
0.3862742483615875,
0.3534586727619171,
0.3645664155483246,
0.5251500010490417,
-0.20676809549331665,
-0.11548052728176117,
-0.33629509806632996,
-0.7744984030723572,
-0.28325551748275757,
0.8584468960762024,
0.22585266828536987,
0.5271957516670227,
0.2269982248544693,
0.7721543312072754,
0.0023568288888782263,
0.5406449437141418,
-1.1128568649291992,
0.6705323457717896,
-0.33732035756111145,
-0.43628183007240295,
0.2217067927122116,
-0.7905504703521729,
-0.9397526979446411,
0.2956850230693817,
-0.41088131070137024,
-0.5315354466438293,
0.349619597196579,
0.08487415313720703,
-0.22699512541294098,
0.23622320592403412,
-0.7494896054267883,
0.7268028855323792,
-0.2827460765838623,
-0.3453559875488281,
-0.2652214467525482,
-0.7412242293357849,
0.5030312538146973,
0.07122408598661423,
-0.11886114627122879,
-0.1203787550330162,
-0.3683890104293823,
0.8011959195137024,
-0.3830508589744568,
0.6378597021102905,
-0.030358154326677322,
0.3293425440788269,
-0.31004998087882996,
0.25807932019233704,
0.1251649707555771,
-0.06413709372282028,
0.020588243380188942,
0.133668452501297,
-0.016602514311671257,
-0.08068163692951202,
-1.1708595752716064,
0.7421140670776367,
-0.7717611789703369,
-0.13913463056087494,
-0.7665556073188782,
-0.5786958336830139,
-0.22275178134441376,
0.24950043857097626,
-0.005015150643885136,
0.20586618781089783,
-0.03508701175451279,
0.15087459981441498,
0.35275131464004517,
0.1567138135433197,
0.43517282605171204,
0.5511027574539185,
0.03410043567419052,
-0.6251896023750305,
0.7003315091133118,
0.0843718871474266,
-0.014023572206497192,
0.6424737572669983,
0.24238860607147217,
-0.38238999247550964,
-0.428139865398407,
0.08662839978933334,
0.43312934041023254,
-0.6668819785118103,
-0.4984035789966583,
-0.4135594964027405,
-0.27911075949668884,
-0.24395132064819336,
0.24118594825267792,
-0.1616934835910797,
-0.19705259799957275,
-0.26666146516799927,
-0.0017563077853992581,
0.38077113032341003,
0.6784290075302124,
0.305391401052475,
0.1221233531832695,
-0.3496651351451874,
0.5389314889907837,
0.3500954806804657,
0.5829192399978638,
0.05465797707438469,
-0.40313050150871277,
0.23708416521549225,
-0.29399317502975464,
-0.32619890570640564,
-0.9831358790397644,
0.1905258595943451,
0.4752349257469177,
0.26180407404899597,
0.412222295999527,
0.22416159510612488,
0.7483993172645569,
-0.5637050867080688,
0.21449586749076843,
0.5318524241447449,
-0.7821243405342102,
0.47131407260894775,
-0.20498622953891754,
-0.17223939299583435,
0.7760246396064758,
0.4481346607208252,
-0.33283719420433044,
0.1485690027475357,
-0.8702631592750549,
-0.7292543649673462,
0.7558978199958801,
0.2328149974346161,
0.2322133630514145,
0.07027808576822281,
0.773922324180603,
-0.1770317107439041,
0.2962017059326172,
-0.5582844018936157,
-0.3627421259880066,
-0.002821574220433831,
-0.4521878659725189,
0.4277305603027344,
0.12401195615530014,
0.18672649562358856,
-0.6695846319198608,
0.3930060863494873,
-0.20862339437007904,
0.20839235186576843,
0.10875655710697174,
-0.09711778163909912,
0.14713571965694427,
0.19073231518268585,
0.36306139826774597,
0.7291454672813416,
-0.2629803717136383,
0.24460946023464203,
0.11190395057201385,
-0.21865485608577728,
0.22320999205112457,
0.0400361493229866,
-0.2895532250404358,
0.09664110839366913,
0.37398993968963623,
0.643386960029602,
0.3811993896961212,
-0.096277616918087,
0.7255715727806091,
-0.11011216044425964,
-0.5321896076202393,
-0.20431329309940338,
0.03380105644464493,
0.09024040400981903,
0.19473502039909363,
-0.03448659926652908,
0.22335068881511688,
0.12374643981456757,
-0.7441378235816956,
0.3402566909790039,
0.4446714222431183,
-0.43764299154281616,
-0.36620500683784485,
0.6143537163734436,
-0.05646224319934845,
-0.4625019431114197,
0.6003416180610657,
-0.25905051827430725,
-0.4099561870098114,
0.3320227265357971,
0.2751941382884979,
0.955344557762146,
0.05147703364491463,
0.22764912247657776,
0.14547546207904816,
0.02421974018216133,
-0.09666900336742401,
-0.0943334698677063,
-0.31273555755615234,
-0.9348760843276978,
-0.5431012511253357,
-0.4144773483276367,
-0.3420219421386719,
0.3591403663158417,
-0.7500162124633789,
0.3875952959060669,
-0.9933796525001526,
-0.19348672032356262,
0.47081589698791504,
-0.12634716928005219,
-0.7165336012840271,
0.031086528673768044,
-0.03811134397983551,
0.8750572800636292,
-0.8020633459091187,
0.8072134256362915,
0.9179789423942566,
-0.652385950088501,
-0.8086398243904114,
-0.16456137597560883,
-0.17461682856082916,
-0.43644875288009644,
0.9732892513275146,
0.12744535505771637,
-0.08766692876815796,
-0.29087966680526733,
-0.5204433798789978,
-0.171611949801445,
0.9557065963745117,
0.7094836235046387,
-0.38406091928482056,
-0.3413122892379761,
-0.027236130088567734,
0.9219721555709839,
-0.3267359137535095,
0.4095970094203949,
0.6026197075843811,
0.3122299909591675,
0.13802722096443176,
-0.846768319606781,
0.2050989717245102,
-0.4448845684528351,
0.19781026244163513,
0.4558027386665344,
-0.6303507089614868,
0.3317057192325592,
0.0680406391620636,
-0.24114026129245758,
0.049922484904527664,
0.8326790928840637,
-0.02683238685131073,
0.48740166425704956,
0.4849886894226074,
0.6195544600486755,
0.3999246656894684,
-0.3136545717716217,
0.8365929126739502,
-0.08651738613843918,
0.3239210844039917,
1.330320954322815,
-0.2808370590209961,
0.9468022584915161,
0.5092326998710632,
-0.1512698233127594,
0.7991612553596497,
0.42262351512908936,
-0.13974207639694214,
0.5194565653800964,
0.28430813550949097,
-0.09006404876708984,
-0.4696568548679352,
-0.3870391547679901,
0.025459522381424904,
0.46135613322257996,
0.06347638368606567,
-0.5195100903511047,
-0.5519524216651917,
-0.28929558396339417,
-0.023845845833420753,
0.6394069194793701,
-0.1651187241077423,
1.1251115798950195,
0.3554774522781372,
-0.4326041638851166,
0.3146401643753052,
-0.03257288038730621,
1.1007468700408936,
-0.6552637219429016,
-0.3620774447917938,
0.02933560684323311,
0.44496139883995056,
-0.5284497737884521,
-0.5719012022018433,
0.2789032757282257,
-0.19140902161598206,
-0.4223833382129669,
-0.09762610495090485,
0.8130232691764832,
-0.39485108852386475,
-0.09303463250398636,
0.5349562168121338,
0.2876671254634857,
-0.2523123621940613,
0.00004208731115795672,
-0.7209951281547546,
-0.3790014386177063,
-0.4642989933490753,
0.08157870918512344,
0.5235520601272583,
0.3467899262905121,
-0.2736799716949463,
0.6066264510154724,
0.6298916339874268,
0.2158670276403427,
-0.13832272589206696,
0.1860019862651825,
1.0154881477355957,
-0.8025823831558228,
-0.5855526328086853,
-0.967076301574707,
0.13638919591903687,
-0.17559945583343506,
-0.581659734249115,
0.46428754925727844,
0.4500333368778229,
0.7461797595024109,
-0.01754044182598591,
0.2385169416666031,
0.07218007743358612,
0.038675907999277115,
-0.2325056791305542,
0.49812284111976624,
-0.19786643981933594,
0.0512419156730175,
-0.1732831746339798,
-0.9919921159744263,
-0.9492842555046082,
0.6206380128860474,
-0.3359415531158447,
0.05092654004693031,
0.8923835754394531,
0.678751528263092,
-0.2877315580844879,
0.06224101781845093,
0.2171575129032135,
0.043058451265096664,
0.17191773653030396,
1.025024652481079,
0.9158492088317871,
-0.583584725856781,
0.5834088325500488,
-0.4897157847881317,
-0.138070747256279,
0.1448177844285965,
-0.7575235962867737,
-1.0722395181655884,
-0.4498385488986969,
-0.6521221995353699,
-0.2953093647956848,
0.27368777990341187,
1.1539195775985718,
1.004986047744751,
-0.6558206081390381,
-0.0876852348446846,
-0.4586220383644104,
0.0875864177942276,
-0.35674047470092773,
-0.33673223853111267,
0.41908371448516846,
-0.26414549350738525,
-0.3592769503593445,
0.19425375759601593,
0.251228392124176,
-0.1995028555393219,
0.1241343691945076,
-0.24784739315509796,
-0.26343098282814026,
-0.4166639447212219,
0.6471512317657471,
0.20833157002925873,
-0.5659546256065369,
0.04196127504110336,
0.019723055884242058,
-0.17744074761867523,
0.13286618888378143,
0.6947945952415466,
-0.777012825012207,
0.20969870686531067,
0.6800838112831116,
0.689744234085083,
0.4972519278526306,
-0.08345378935337067,
0.4788079261779785,
-0.8627445101737976,
0.029678871855139732,
0.5486161708831787,
0.2783442437648773,
0.22320929169654846,
-0.4407889246940613,
0.6300082802772522,
0.2851437032222748,
-0.32022708654403687,
-0.6694018840789795,
0.2456386238336563,
-1.203313946723938,
-0.14940550923347473,
1.076414704322815,
-0.04819021001458168,
-0.4807189404964447,
-0.21428297460079193,
0.05357205122709274,
0.41480427980422974,
-0.47784820199012756,
0.49826785922050476,
0.27963241934776306,
-0.36666229367256165,
-0.16652080416679382,
-0.32669398188591003,
0.47059932351112366,
0.1958550214767456,
-0.7591529488563538,
-0.1602124124765396,
0.39448282122612,
0.5284941792488098,
0.4441608190536499,
0.26705601811408997,
-0.20016345381736755,
0.5326683521270752,
-0.30475765466690063,
-0.005740202032029629,
-0.5002837181091309,
-0.4535277783870697,
-0.4634641706943512,
0.22431503236293793,
0.015265632420778275,
-0.24049587547779083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03304v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03304v2
|
Large Language Models for Document-Level Event-Argument Data Augmentation for Challenging Role Types
| 2024-03-05T20:07:42 | 2024-06-12T19:21:33 |
Joseph Gatto, Parker Seegmiller, Omar Sharif, Sarah M. Preum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Event Argument Extraction (EAE) is an extremely difficult information
extraction problem -- with significant limitations in few-shot cross-domain
(FSCD) settings. A common solution to FSCD modeling is data augmentation.
Unfortunately, existing augmentation methods are not well-suited to a variety
of real-world EAE contexts including (i) The need to model long documents (10+
sentences) (ii) The need to model zero and few-shot roles (i.e. event roles
with little to no training representation). In this work, we introduce two
novel LLM-powered data augmentation frameworks for synthesizing extractive
document-level EAE samples using zero in-domain training data. Our highest
performing methods provide a 16-pt increase in F1 score on extraction of zero
shot role types.
To better facilitate analysis of cross-domain EAE, we additionally introduce
a new metric, Role-Depth F1 (RDF1), which uses statistical depth to identify
roles in the target domain which are semantic outliers with respect to roles
observed in the source domain. Our experiments show that LLM-based augmentation
can boost RDF1 performance by up to 11 F1 points compared to baseline methods.
|
[
-0.43196970224380493,
-0.7949198484420776,
0.5032405257225037,
0.0008365648682229221,
-0.21390461921691895,
0.006541958078742027,
-0.19234906136989594,
-0.6951223015785217,
0.06941806524991989,
0.40237781405448914,
-0.823554515838623,
-0.7049534916877747,
-0.6311762928962708,
0.18937274813652039,
-0.3304719924926758,
0.9270933270454407,
-0.07592500746250153,
-0.1041993722319603,
-0.42940622568130493,
0.02005218155682087,
-0.21669436991214752,
-0.5277736783027649,
-0.7577003240585327,
-0.24336132407188416,
0.419684499502182,
0.7404358983039856,
0.4050878882408142,
0.5641628503799438,
0.2762449085712433,
0.18153813481330872,
0.22612081468105316,
0.31695693731307983,
-0.37124666571617126,
0.2625614404678345,
-0.25885045528411865,
-0.297596275806427,
-0.7100299000740051,
-0.014481383375823498,
0.5035865306854248,
0.6528698205947876,
0.28114256262779236,
-0.051668766885995865,
-0.06624266505241394,
0.23935896158218384,
-0.5658597350120544,
0.30327802896499634,
-0.6300902366638184,
0.10934456437826157,
-0.22491410374641418,
-0.4055079221725464,
-0.37850522994995117,
0.24412883818149567,
0.22922541201114655,
-0.6911371350288391,
0.38424238562583923,
-0.2128608077764511,
0.7856968641281128,
-0.12608417868614197,
-0.27260127663612366,
-0.13214965164661407,
-0.6631365418434143,
0.769141435623169,
-0.9388152360916138,
0.3333055078983307,
0.22923536598682404,
-0.013982159085571766,
-0.13547946512699127,
-0.5035639405250549,
-0.4420604109764099,
0.020531633868813515,
0.008648411370813847,
0.05318270996212959,
-0.13090544939041138,
0.2728472054004669,
0.36536940932273865,
0.19727927446365356,
-0.5264685750007629,
0.4812704622745514,
-0.0942332074046135,
0.11829542368650436,
0.9383924603462219,
0.19804269075393677,
0.20908789336681366,
-0.1796083152294159,
-0.27806317806243896,
-0.13549745082855225,
-0.7519256472587585,
-0.10874877125024796,
0.4589981436729431,
0.3269519805908203,
-0.04282901808619499,
0.6179963946342468,
-0.1479637771844864,
0.5758057236671448,
0.10393669456243515,
-0.01335881743580103,
-0.22958926856517792,
-0.28316572308540344,
-0.41047006845474243,
0.07698255032300949,
0.5501697659492493,
0.12205328047275543,
0.06856048852205276,
-0.30914872884750366,
-0.07416665554046631,
-0.23359377682209015,
0.009404988959431648,
-1.0727300643920898,
0.11592280864715576,
0.4380013346672058,
-0.19220492243766785,
-0.44881048798561096,
0.31781697273254395,
-0.9379431009292603,
-0.5077017545700073,
-0.19171924889087677,
0.37391605973243713,
-0.518528163433075,
-0.18344064056873322,
0.13829389214515686,
-0.15405093133449554,
0.5193609595298767,
0.4800967574119568,
-0.781304657459259,
0.31245744228363037,
0.8434391617774963,
0.6089116930961609,
-0.5275205373764038,
-0.08184003084897995,
-0.8285767436027527,
0.16603416204452515,
-0.3144681453704834,
0.8946781754493713,
-0.8139446973800659,
-0.45390480756759644,
0.2399880439043045,
0.06400138884782791,
-0.037965077906847,
-0.44608527421951294,
0.8886345028877258,
-0.5266618728637695,
0.38805216550827026,
-0.03438080847263336,
-0.9097737669944763,
0.019996466115117073,
0.12696531414985657,
-0.6387420296669006,
1.0105581283569336,
0.1794954389333725,
-0.35388508439064026,
0.8057427406311035,
-1.0141425132751465,
-0.64912348985672,
0.2664440870285034,
-0.3863244354724884,
-0.28460103273391724,
0.08817141503095627,
0.5575300455093384,
0.7138358354568481,
-0.3800899088382721,
0.014381470158696175,
-0.35240551829338074,
-0.14755851030349731,
0.022037485614418983,
-0.5011179447174072,
0.5961745381355286,
-0.12984131276607513,
-0.25004929304122925,
0.1029142513871193,
-0.973454475402832,
-0.1861589401960373,
0.11669936776161194,
-0.1876537799835205,
-0.33086445927619934,
0.1370430737733841,
0.09399352222681046,
0.36818283796310425,
0.1429382711648941,
-0.6941467523574829,
0.25795260071754456,
-0.6326481699943542,
0.1422223150730133,
0.5912255644798279,
0.2384476512670517,
0.5904648303985596,
-0.07957527786493301,
0.7497934103012085,
0.20100043714046478,
-0.0029974260833114386,
-0.4120233654975891,
-0.30537188053131104,
-0.4214118421077728,
-0.5074676871299744,
0.213883176445961,
0.5477451682090759,
-0.641717791557312,
0.6693744659423828,
-0.39586421847343445,
-0.21648652851581573,
-0.46752214431762695,
0.22438573837280273,
-0.1184120699763298,
0.4163858890533447,
0.4219108521938324,
-0.06433822214603424,
-0.6075944900512695,
-0.7442020177841187,
-0.22558197379112244,
-0.2962273359298706,
-0.09528200328350067,
0.21032001078128815,
0.23249076306819916,
-0.026718029752373695,
1.1198333501815796,
-0.35575586557388306,
-0.5499303936958313,
-0.45488014817237854,
0.15871433913707733,
0.17084884643554688,
0.3323933482170105,
0.3555794656276703,
-0.5389612913131714,
-0.2003111094236374,
0.2871052026748657,
-0.7474808096885681,
-0.3130684196949005,
-0.37132155895233154,
0.08908151835203171,
0.41296157240867615,
0.4415687620639801,
-0.7770927548408508,
0.4092805087566376,
0.16517792642116547,
-0.35406243801116943,
0.28497740626335144,
0.08475550264120102,
0.16787207126617432,
-1.0394774675369263,
-0.10465579479932785,
0.24126151204109192,
-0.29012686014175415,
-0.777725100517273,
0.08499246835708618,
-0.0922350287437439,
-0.22556714713573456,
-0.4161865711212158,
0.8022871613502502,
-0.49603766202926636,
-0.09706822782754898,
-0.38204073905944824,
0.37465450167655945,
0.33707696199417114,
0.29309582710266113,
0.29503530263900757,
0.42342397570610046,
0.601911187171936,
-0.30277660489082336,
0.25556978583335876,
0.2568814754486084,
-0.3397676944732666,
0.5961499810218811,
-0.43532073497772217,
0.07084006816148758,
-0.14997020363807678,
0.1959589719772339,
-0.9348305463790894,
-0.36350709199905396,
-0.09527722001075745,
-0.19926875829696655,
0.5810708999633789,
-0.42334887385368347,
-0.48063549399375916,
-0.01570124551653862,
-0.49014970660209656,
0.3481348156929016,
0.1580122709274292,
-0.6902031898498535,
0.6390789747238159,
0.2566947937011719,
-0.38502493500709534,
-0.5768982768058777,
-0.7126012444496155,
0.24630126357078552,
-0.36648762226104736,
-0.9813582897186279,
0.6828998327255249,
0.16627706587314606,
-0.15292705595493317,
0.0765879824757576,
-0.21280208230018616,
-0.11805012077093124,
-0.04429575428366661,
0.1714799702167511,
0.3121606409549713,
-0.5074790120124817,
-0.016030509024858475,
0.2945265769958496,
0.027286643162369728,
0.018236542120575905,
-0.08574125915765762,
0.24482868611812592,
0.24734702706336975,
-0.5661349892616272,
-0.15282794833183289,
0.8649652600288391,
0.5587503910064697,
-0.1259901076555252,
0.6169722676277161,
0.5052996277809143,
-0.6208803653717041,
-0.4479280412197113,
-0.5361743569374084,
-0.32486358284950256,
-0.417685329914093,
0.5056408047676086,
-0.3349405825138092,
-0.97811359167099,
0.5581475496292114,
0.04358373209834099,
0.38694825768470764,
0.5138283967971802,
0.2687283456325531,
0.10048138350248337,
0.9405240416526794,
0.26600226759910583,
-0.07096664607524872,
0.5855197906494141,
-0.3792344629764557,
0.17074789106845856,
-0.6053149104118347,
0.00876329094171524,
-0.28307950496673584,
-0.13786710798740387,
-0.23582467436790466,
-0.6402386426925659,
0.46415531635284424,
0.2895912230014801,
0.08962325006723404,
0.2622701823711395,
-0.02495448663830757,
0.4049188494682312,
-0.05765051394701004,
-0.25556010007858276,
0.3595746159553528,
0.20452040433883667,
0.2889268100261688,
-0.11954724043607712,
-0.8556609749794006,
-0.5123283267021179,
0.8835108280181885,
0.512112021446228,
0.6021660566329956,
0.027798602357506752,
0.8784392476081848,
0.36350420117378235,
0.27546894550323486,
-0.8933686017990112,
0.572361946105957,
-0.2730039656162262,
-0.6196783781051636,
-0.5706431865692139,
-0.161394402384758,
-0.7900803685188293,
0.3552798628807068,
-0.4512922167778015,
-0.7835197448730469,
0.5272509455680847,
-0.27461865544319153,
-0.2808566391468048,
0.2585839629173279,
-0.4783581495285034,
0.9506123661994934,
-0.006784607190638781,
-0.5786086320877075,
-0.08837847411632538,
-0.2239011824131012,
0.2256329357624054,
-0.14724010229110718,
0.1616763472557068,
0.010551647283136845,
-0.0638645812869072,
0.695286750793457,
-0.4017705023288727,
0.7052810192108154,
-0.31240254640579224,
-0.3519640564918518,
0.3447262942790985,
-0.008109789341688156,
0.9266015887260437,
0.27451908588409424,
-0.5102704763412476,
0.05987035483121872,
0.010268324054777622,
-0.3164425194263458,
-0.7226029634475708,
0.7366039752960205,
-0.49297863245010376,
-0.7675632834434509,
-0.2489272505044937,
-0.46931684017181396,
-0.485371470451355,
-0.02827122062444687,
0.14065542817115784,
0.5665242671966553,
-0.4761683940887451,
0.37118634581565857,
0.4223276376724243,
-0.21092310547828674,
0.579174816608429,
0.6947721242904663,
0.16786886751651764,
-0.1814572811126709,
0.7541363835334778,
0.10850790143013,
0.10721836239099503,
0.5444168448448181,
-0.0976971983909607,
-0.40984976291656494,
-0.5447463393211365,
-0.6252732276916504,
0.034092016518116,
-0.7132466435432434,
-0.36945104598999023,
-0.7595009803771973,
-0.28033116459846497,
-0.45411163568496704,
-0.36371469497680664,
-0.18881307542324066,
-0.6819919943809509,
-0.5257473587989807,
-0.5498993992805481,
0.4069734811782837,
0.23709797859191895,
-0.13844867050647736,
0.2941213846206665,
-0.8449598550796509,
0.24419474601745605,
-0.07984676957130432,
0.17911221086978912,
-0.18824709951877594,
-0.4813912808895111,
-0.30050215125083923,
-0.2555098235607147,
-0.258070707321167,
-0.8737894892692566,
0.41229864954948425,
0.3968926966190338,
0.5987316370010376,
0.40088337659835815,
0.015719832852482796,
0.8732873797416687,
-0.3602657616138458,
0.9618363976478577,
0.07837948203086853,
-0.881416916847229,
0.48204973340034485,
-0.2970024049282074,
-0.12514474987983704,
0.42076948285102844,
0.24469424784183502,
-0.2552879750728607,
-0.4006143808364868,
-0.7192836403846741,
-1.0726696252822876,
0.9910757541656494,
0.08719641715288162,
0.017329007387161255,
-0.17888116836547852,
0.46863576769828796,
0.3260900676250458,
-0.1583278775215149,
-0.5690715909004211,
-0.005517768673598766,
0.11266181617975235,
-0.22329407930374146,
0.14641985297203064,
-0.05773438140749931,
-0.04309097304940224,
-0.06236686557531357,
0.7061929702758789,
-0.2727581560611725,
0.018107369542121887,
0.5085642337799072,
-0.16090603172779083,
-0.4150342345237732,
0.4410860240459442,
0.483713835477829,
0.6391812562942505,
-0.21437083184719086,
-0.1048860177397728,
0.30661094188690186,
-0.14379581809043884,
0.05128990486264229,
0.4804867208003998,
0.014980281703174114,
0.06723924726247787,
0.8272167444229126,
0.8541976809501648,
0.19691206514835358,
-0.5679242014884949,
0.6042539477348328,
0.21336248517036438,
-0.33795973658561707,
-0.14855895936489105,
0.1448301076889038,
-0.20854592323303223,
0.3237195312976837,
0.5599967837333679,
-0.4510353207588196,
0.10207557678222656,
-0.5514684915542603,
0.47944176197052,
0.6721600294113159,
-0.36529189348220825,
-0.17400896549224854,
0.5669969916343689,
0.28837308287620544,
-0.07483653724193573,
0.012621988542377949,
-0.007385484408587217,
0.03516538441181183,
0.6003767251968384,
0.582706093788147,
1.0108939409255981,
-0.024509381502866745,
0.338712215423584,
0.1528724879026413,
0.26624423265457153,
0.21360115706920624,
0.15797743201255798,
0.04599049687385559,
-0.6999996304512024,
-0.8558556437492371,
-0.6024135947227478,
-0.31979164481163025,
0.6432064175605774,
-0.5376201868057251,
0.40431055426597595,
-0.25689277052879333,
0.08301646262407303,
0.14671297371387482,
0.34352603554725647,
-0.6510677933692932,
0.20808935165405273,
0.042607031762599945,
1.0539743900299072,
-0.7520610690116882,
0.8459618091583252,
0.5764325857162476,
-0.3700692057609558,
-0.38782110810279846,
0.04349595680832863,
-0.18738819658756256,
-0.3238426744937897,
0.43261444568634033,
-0.11462302505970001,
0.02881617099046707,
0.0033410796895623207,
-0.18485575914382935,
-0.46747449040412903,
1.1598923206329346,
0.44045621156692505,
-0.3756332993507385,
-0.1403028964996338,
0.4454639256000519,
0.5362906455993652,
-0.9341976642608643,
0.15653295814990997,
0.5000814199447632,
0.5811996459960938,
-0.10612623393535614,
-0.37710610032081604,
0.1268479824066162,
0.046662092208862305,
-0.20213426649570465,
-0.013172364793717861,
-0.17153215408325195,
0.37458083033561707,
0.060038693249225616,
-0.30099087953567505,
-0.1583992838859558,
0.7281714677810669,
0.18088293075561523,
0.4916068911552429,
0.47730395197868347,
0.347861647605896,
0.5175336599349976,
0.17316952347755432,
1.088767409324646,
-0.1472572386264801,
0.05286666750907898,
0.9640651345252991,
-0.7117403149604797,
0.5637241005897522,
0.3304632902145386,
0.06976427882909775,
0.45477914810180664,
0.431487500667572,
0.09716389328241348,
0.1786908060312271,
-0.07421869039535522,
-0.4650556147098541,
-0.46888282895088196,
-0.027218788862228394,
-0.06268864870071411,
0.35560762882232666,
0.5126717686653137,
-0.3570893108844757,
-0.4220178723335266,
-0.15054179728031158,
-0.13926224410533905,
-0.035348761826753616,
-0.2054893523454666,
0.8192552328109741,
0.18748728930950165,
-0.5432971715927124,
0.29947441816329956,
0.3794965147972107,
0.37655872106552124,
-0.5700991749763489,
-0.23725472390651703,
-0.35033851861953735,
-0.033690471202135086,
-0.37096014618873596,
-0.846773087978363,
0.29736748337745667,
0.2902369499206543,
-0.3110874891281128,
-0.052717868238687515,
1.0126897096633911,
-0.59213787317276,
-0.429348349571228,
0.48354998230934143,
0.6367448568344116,
-0.00954496581107378,
-0.014023678377270699,
-0.5220701098442078,
0.08109906315803528,
-0.2987072467803955,
-0.39063629508018494,
0.5360268950462341,
0.6428712606430054,
-0.33682718873023987,
0.21414171159267426,
0.6572644114494324,
0.1724461168050766,
-0.0042665437795221806,
0.22664129734039307,
0.7562796473503113,
-0.5394037961959839,
-0.28380087018013,
-0.9591476321220398,
0.5350196361541748,
-0.45097360014915466,
-0.11660550534725189,
0.4783385097980499,
0.6676139235496521,
0.5644189715385437,
-0.08862335979938507,
0.9068788290023804,
0.013965105637907982,
0.2760148048400879,
-0.5130905508995056,
0.3131561577320099,
-0.5751630067825317,
0.3527824580669403,
-0.39407140016555786,
-0.9221780896186829,
-0.43513497710227966,
0.4462706446647644,
-0.26791566610336304,
-0.13286933302879333,
0.41778308153152466,
0.9424905776977539,
-0.3476479649543762,
0.11941644549369812,
0.5720147490501404,
0.018758825957775116,
0.6535230278968811,
0.6166538596153259,
0.6166263222694397,
-0.5625808835029602,
0.44063809514045715,
0.15295499563217163,
-0.2758829593658447,
-0.3428145945072174,
-1.1747525930404663,
-0.79256671667099,
-0.5297646522521973,
-0.5956470370292664,
-0.07075569033622742,
-0.03805418312549591,
1.123431921005249,
0.8707055449485779,
-0.903630256652832,
-0.1108836755156517,
-0.055022671818733215,
0.14459647238254547,
-0.1864195615053177,
-0.32901501655578613,
0.36755022406578064,
-0.3412803113460541,
-0.7864612340927124,
1.002408504486084,
0.49982210993766785,
-0.22608110308647156,
-0.17629581689834595,
-0.01580427773296833,
-0.21257631480693817,
0.4720361828804016,
0.890188455581665,
0.37370142340660095,
-0.6103775501251221,
-0.4766022861003876,
-0.21243959665298462,
0.16165892779827118,
0.04994206503033638,
0.8796687722206116,
-0.5286291837692261,
0.185189351439476,
0.5179795622825623,
0.8626016974449158,
0.6517406702041626,
0.15940648317337036,
0.7326458096504211,
-1.2726625204086304,
0.09178536385297775,
0.0812300518155098,
0.335868239402771,
0.2866010069847107,
-0.6082133054733276,
0.5776565670967102,
0.210415780544281,
-0.262412428855896,
-0.9537023901939392,
0.2441624253988266,
-1.1819443702697754,
-0.23650868237018585,
1.3279293775558472,
-0.19491411745548248,
-0.030254783108830452,
-0.12775734066963196,
-0.15464350581169128,
0.15994854271411896,
-0.38257938623428345,
0.4712652564048767,
0.8713942170143127,
-0.3358534872531891,
-0.24320751428604126,
-0.4196584224700928,
0.6582510471343994,
0.2578500509262085,
-1.0729014873504639,
0.36451563239097595,
0.6877694129943848,
0.11593049019575119,
0.06365480273962021,
0.5178042054176331,
-0.39111801981925964,
0.16788595914840698,
-0.2651868164539337,
-0.16738279163837433,
-0.30683255195617676,
-0.40428730845451355,
-0.4212596118450165,
0.527052640914917,
-0.07746889442205429,
0.12420327961444855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04801v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04801v2
|
Alpaca against Vicuna: Using LLMs to Uncover Memorization of LLMs
| 2024-03-05T19:32:01 | 2024-03-31T04:33:56 |
Aly M. Kassem, Omar Mahmoud, Niloofar Mireshghallah, Hyunwoo Kim, Yulia Tsvetkov, Yejin Choi, Sherif Saad, Santu Rana
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce a black-box prompt optimization method that uses
an attacker LLM agent to uncover higher levels of memorization in a victim
agent, compared to what is revealed by prompting the target model with the
training data directly, which is the dominant approach of quantifying
memorization in LLMs. We use an iterative rejection-sampling optimization
process to find instruction-based prompts with two main characteristics: (1)
minimal overlap with the training data to avoid presenting the solution
directly to the model, and (2) maximal overlap between the victim model's
output and the training data, aiming to induce the victim to spit out training
data. We observe that our instruction-based prompts generate outputs with 23.7%
higher overlap with training data compared to the baseline prefix-suffix
measurements. Our findings show that (1) instruction-tuned models can expose
pre-training data as much as their base-models, if not more so, (2) contexts
other than the original training data can lead to leakage, and (3) using
instructions proposed by other LLMs can open a new avenue of automated attacks
that we should further study and explore. The code can be found at
https://github.com/Alymostafa/Instruction_based_attack .
|
[
-0.3011800944805145,
-1.1844325065612793,
0.834319531917572,
-0.08750733733177185,
-0.42203542590141296,
-0.015144175849854946,
0.1187981367111206,
-0.27705398201942444,
0.27301132678985596,
0.6235871315002441,
-0.8794798254966736,
-0.7551761269569397,
-0.6490780711174011,
-0.0465262196958065,
-0.42381927371025085,
0.8151209354400635,
-0.031912531703710556,
0.094739630818367,
-0.12503251433372498,
-0.14532768726348877,
-0.7233914732933044,
-0.8009651303291321,
-0.8512686491012573,
-0.3066376745700836,
0.6326267719268799,
0.3634072542190552,
0.3862389326095581,
1.1536158323287964,
0.28951582312583923,
0.2747935950756073,
0.08582399040460587,
0.1817627102136612,
-0.41240304708480835,
0.2037733793258667,
0.19384151697158813,
-0.991022527217865,
-0.21913392841815948,
-0.09213804453611374,
0.4054076075553894,
0.2713831961154938,
-0.05209391564130783,
0.1764921098947525,
-0.15808211266994476,
0.4938565790653229,
-0.8799645900726318,
-0.16898488998413086,
-0.8471400141716003,
0.1930391937494278,
-0.11732641607522964,
-0.9045010209083557,
-0.49124231934547424,
-0.3187117278575897,
-0.18660852313041687,
-0.5755467414855957,
0.4621928632259369,
-0.12263638526201248,
0.6098397374153137,
0.6348772644996643,
-0.19302116334438324,
-0.6966604590415955,
-0.5365244746208191,
0.6265924572944641,
-0.3094601631164551,
-0.021023843437433243,
0.4541388154029846,
0.36325258016586304,
-0.44012391567230225,
-0.3139511048793793,
-0.2524194121360779,
-0.29250845313072205,
0.2660905718803406,
0.15934209525585175,
-0.4136356711387634,
0.11287041008472443,
0.27440932393074036,
0.17494550347328186,
-0.26182183623313904,
0.3417890965938568,
-0.33260369300842285,
-0.2471475750207901,
0.391323983669281,
0.4752688407897949,
0.24783101677894592,
0.023464830592274666,
-0.6865665912628174,
-0.16418758034706116,
-0.7957229614257812,
0.21205644309520721,
0.5787865519523621,
0.3353743255138397,
-0.01416908297687769,
0.5728994011878967,
0.0078123449347913265,
0.5854788422584534,
-0.17079271376132965,
-0.3234689235687256,
-0.007794499862939119,
0.19672851264476776,
-0.21452055871486664,
0.25691887736320496,
0.7674526572227478,
0.310185968875885,
-0.10203694552183151,
-0.1495339423418045,
-0.3832293152809143,
0.048942118883132935,
0.5376216769218445,
-0.7993764281272888,
-0.005037567112594843,
0.33188435435295105,
-0.2894795536994934,
-0.3747349977493286,
-0.06147068366408348,
-0.7853243947029114,
-0.4739266037940979,
-0.206370010972023,
0.6784642338752747,
-0.5670485496520996,
0.4712981581687927,
0.1290988177061081,
-0.21623429656028748,
0.500945508480072,
0.31350284814834595,
-0.7495144009590149,
0.3094902038574219,
0.8083007335662842,
0.938571035861969,
-0.0003440304135438055,
-0.2193317711353302,
-0.8539326786994934,
0.21026889979839325,
-0.4469785690307617,
0.7896339893341064,
-0.28940990567207336,
-0.5841931700706482,
0.021121978759765625,
-0.11396239697933197,
-0.06453100591897964,
-0.5078660845756531,
0.4284098148345947,
-0.5634766817092896,
-0.109211266040802,
-0.4310472309589386,
-0.6394909620285034,
-0.23622265458106995,
0.264245867729187,
-0.7836222648620605,
0.994899570941925,
-0.056569501757621765,
-0.4356689155101776,
0.1291278600692749,
-0.5310044288635254,
0.004942980129271746,
-0.1280393898487091,
-0.20625045895576477,
-0.6239464282989502,
0.09692280739545822,
0.30371177196502686,
0.3790821433067322,
-0.4337962865829468,
-0.22387781739234924,
-0.14633338153362274,
-0.6359385848045349,
0.4091565012931824,
-0.65926593542099,
0.9170849323272705,
0.1906844526529312,
-0.5225666761398315,
0.1358979046344757,
-0.8031772971153259,
-0.11425967514514923,
0.4350423812866211,
-0.19741567969322205,
-0.2923865020275116,
-0.2694442868232727,
-0.8375803232192993,
-0.30199503898620605,
0.3177070915699005,
-0.2034378945827484,
0.40401363372802734,
-0.07038042694330215,
0.006679730489850044,
0.9071903228759766,
0.43911635875701904,
0.2911759912967682,
-0.5566455125808716,
0.9099757075309753,
-0.18238447606563568,
0.5164518356323242,
-0.5096080303192139,
-0.3019729554653168,
-0.8286287784576416,
-0.47786903381347656,
-0.09357569366693497,
0.6961646676063538,
-0.6839202642440796,
0.25646090507507324,
0.21661800146102905,
-0.46718013286590576,
-0.7567220330238342,
0.23716150224208832,
0.5146203637123108,
0.6682488322257996,
0.5514266490936279,
-0.38608303666114807,
-0.4333735406398773,
-0.9005809426307678,
0.009748008102178574,
-0.14121392369270325,
0.026242705062031746,
0.11559837311506271,
0.334419846534729,
-0.3234614133834839,
0.7283843755722046,
-0.5194275379180908,
-0.3779401481151581,
0.07077474892139435,
-0.07387537509202957,
-0.01554987020790577,
0.26519617438316345,
0.6507387757301331,
-0.2889167070388794,
0.01674751006066799,
-0.42541179060935974,
-0.8270866274833679,
-0.23496872186660767,
-0.2033248096704483,
-0.231553316116333,
0.01850050687789917,
0.7639039754867554,
-0.5251743197441101,
0.6019391417503357,
0.06557001173496246,
-0.1392551064491272,
0.525264322757721,
-0.2920544743537903,
0.07916727662086487,
-0.8607852458953857,
-0.14234231412410736,
-0.31517672538757324,
-0.05683783069252968,
-0.7148824334144592,
0.3874968886375427,
0.11733043938875198,
0.04989725723862648,
-0.661308765411377,
0.43033313751220703,
-0.6903998255729675,
-0.18240632116794586,
-0.534964382648468,
-0.2523496448993683,
0.01527834590524435,
0.7136951088905334,
-0.3207584023475647,
0.970763623714447,
0.4519227147102356,
-0.7263216972351074,
0.39456260204315186,
-0.015353798866271973,
-0.11037836968898773,
0.34064415097236633,
-0.5794788599014282,
0.5957579612731934,
-0.3109491169452667,
0.040337368845939636,
-0.6427287459373474,
0.05324184522032738,
0.6686419248580933,
-0.4195132851600647,
0.17934273183345795,
-0.24067051708698273,
-0.3901131749153137,
-0.14458096027374268,
-0.5684630870819092,
0.3537180721759796,
0.3860034942626953,
-0.5954390168190002,
0.6211267113685608,
0.12558743357658386,
0.3004606366157532,
-0.9187936782836914,
-0.3677304685115814,
0.000692542758770287,
-0.5934657454490662,
-0.010794824920594692,
0.0709087923169136,
-0.2572464346885681,
-0.23190221190452576,
-0.3148406744003296,
-0.06820106506347656,
0.15290167927742004,
0.5020043253898621,
0.41679149866104126,
0.37082740664482117,
-0.17351683974266052,
0.08670035749673843,
0.022777320817112923,
-0.02263159118592739,
0.34610113501548767,
-0.20287446677684784,
0.9686350226402283,
-0.017448704689741135,
-0.568742573261261,
-0.6234098672866821,
0.48655009269714355,
0.18207046389579773,
-0.05690189078450203,
0.8398311734199524,
0.3614058196544647,
-0.2699231803417206,
-0.32165655493736267,
-0.5540472865104675,
-0.22092975676059723,
-0.5381345152854919,
0.26362189650535583,
-0.5008596181869507,
-0.36813098192214966,
0.7166804075241089,
0.171644926071167,
-0.0614333339035511,
0.04709567129611969,
0.6283029913902283,
-0.004475639201700687,
0.6047786474227905,
0.6586928963661194,
-0.18547110259532928,
0.6724655032157898,
-0.5802246928215027,
-0.35295048356056213,
-0.7128227353096008,
-0.469312846660614,
-0.5020295977592468,
-0.14840352535247803,
-0.1252683401107788,
-0.47690579295158386,
0.3573755621910095,
0.1718548685312271,
-0.10821985453367233,
0.24523086845874786,
-0.5444186329841614,
0.7447621822357178,
0.6384720802307129,
0.4376705586910248,
0.17882183194160461,
-0.08454982936382294,
0.02366749756038189,
0.23941104114055634,
-0.6661675572395325,
-0.6130658388137817,
1.3495527505874634,
0.4958811402320862,
0.6262485384941101,
-0.08091548830270767,
1.1530790328979492,
0.31117233633995056,
0.23419779539108276,
-1.1314501762390137,
0.6609039902687073,
0.4061918556690216,
-0.22070376574993134,
-0.24874404072761536,
-0.36760246753692627,
-1.4605623483657837,
0.20032280683517456,
0.014277912676334381,
-0.6252702474594116,
0.19479916989803314,
0.10986705869436264,
-0.4215353727340698,
0.2255755364894867,
-0.6964117884635925,
0.5217698216438293,
-0.4089006185531616,
-0.12847140431404114,
0.10802282392978668,
-0.42422086000442505,
0.309651643037796,
-0.010965334251523018,
0.18262362480163574,
-0.10662674903869629,
-0.5529758334159851,
0.8535141348838806,
-0.526941180229187,
0.9549950957298279,
-0.246812641620636,
-0.47604215145111084,
0.5279456377029419,
0.01365653146058321,
0.5155907273292542,
-0.07271828502416611,
0.03786996752023697,
-0.12150023877620697,
-0.39839309453964233,
-0.6796772480010986,
-0.7373664379119873,
0.29201263189315796,
-0.895190954208374,
-0.9448400735855103,
-0.2942259907722473,
-0.6279799938201904,
-0.04172775521874428,
0.02679396979510784,
0.6079376935958862,
0.45116859674453735,
-0.14874714612960815,
-0.12878260016441345,
0.9036635756492615,
-0.08726147562265396,
0.4633464515209198,
0.5855448246002197,
0.1506669968366623,
-0.47004953026771545,
0.7826812267303467,
0.14850719273090363,
0.353508323431015,
0.4722076952457428,
-0.01481635496020317,
0.029957134276628494,
-0.8442316055297852,
-0.36450663208961487,
0.2871169447898865,
-1.0100057125091553,
-0.42191940546035767,
-0.6401692032814026,
-0.020556507632136345,
-0.07518858462572098,
-0.09637151658535004,
-0.20903970301151276,
-0.1830538809299469,
-0.5569121837615967,
-0.2335961014032364,
0.4832075536251068,
0.5523768067359924,
0.26305678486824036,
0.7947879433631897,
-0.6039757132530212,
0.46999043226242065,
0.3033534586429596,
-0.12041527032852173,
0.1335407942533493,
-0.5664262175559998,
-0.25688523054122925,
0.04819108918309212,
-0.49616917967796326,
-1.4351270198822021,
0.5520002245903015,
-0.18384093046188354,
0.6881064176559448,
0.4973157048225403,
0.1257292777299881,
0.6168035864830017,
-0.3049120008945465,
0.31474581360816956,
0.09033530950546265,
-0.782159686088562,
0.7541748881340027,
-0.2462334781885147,
0.22645442187786102,
0.6507756114006042,
0.44100457429885864,
-0.11014903336763382,
-0.5998398661613464,
-0.6622620224952698,
-0.8791067004203796,
0.6133288145065308,
-0.1080227866768837,
0.1185665875673294,
-0.08792458474636078,
0.718345046043396,
0.21030466258525848,
0.14143335819244385,
-0.6112655997276306,
-0.6541651487350464,
-0.0542333759367466,
-0.16604755818843842,
0.11988318711519241,
-0.3932955861091614,
-0.47677353024482727,
0.1247880607843399,
0.5623477101325989,
-0.16633060574531555,
0.4745436906814575,
0.26750245690345764,
-0.2367226481437683,
-0.08453211933374405,
0.12371744960546494,
0.5642858743667603,
0.43435174226760864,
-0.14495787024497986,
0.036267735064029694,
0.3716586232185364,
-0.6469724774360657,
0.562554657459259,
0.00656565697863698,
-0.5039706230163574,
0.0048963762819767,
0.643675684928894,
1.004847526550293,
-0.03282509744167328,
-0.6427914500236511,
0.48019349575042725,
-0.12220567464828491,
-0.18147723376750946,
-0.5213666558265686,
0.590022623538971,
-0.29601556062698364,
0.3421766757965088,
0.6718750596046448,
-0.16685344278812408,
0.20987746119499207,
-0.8317630290985107,
0.08925019949674606,
0.6702924966812134,
-0.2722266614437103,
-0.031077539548277855,
0.5715685486793518,
-0.3686594069004059,
-0.6785142421722412,
0.23809345066547394,
0.019805612042546272,
-0.6158528923988342,
1.0010371208190918,
0.4256836175918579,
0.809760570526123,
-0.472744345664978,
0.053239695727825165,
0.18960213661193848,
0.5548698306083679,
0.07425136864185333,
0.1087387204170227,
-0.2650168836116791,
-0.42656275629997253,
0.09669479727745056,
-0.2808692753314972,
-0.5292280912399292,
0.3069385886192322,
-1.029930591583252,
0.38905641436576843,
-0.792474627494812,
-0.14820805191993713,
-0.11557518690824509,
0.20359303057193756,
-0.6088668704032898,
0.08280432969331741,
-0.01337120495736599,
0.8027608394622803,
-0.6608838438987732,
0.7886221408843994,
0.09396196156740189,
-0.3879431188106537,
-0.752297043800354,
0.0417940616607666,
0.11158470809459686,
-1.1980634927749634,
0.15391775965690613,
0.43806150555610657,
-0.13813798129558563,
-0.29393112659454346,
-0.5724625587463379,
-0.6896973848342896,
1.3535308837890625,
0.7425242066383362,
-0.45900917053222656,
-0.0051537551917135715,
0.12810994684696198,
0.3621538579463959,
-0.3717186748981476,
0.2777783274650574,
0.86857008934021,
0.21973462402820587,
-0.011773652397096157,
-0.29649466276168823,
0.15450243651866913,
-0.22342632710933685,
-0.1945371925830841,
0.2323865294456482,
-0.7929258346557617,
0.8797389268875122,
-0.3933210074901581,
-0.25655752420425415,
0.19911624491214752,
0.7925183773040771,
0.4783868193626404,
0.5731566548347473,
0.393783301115036,
0.380054771900177,
1.0355923175811768,
0.23538458347320557,
1.2243531942367554,
0.11906249821186066,
-0.2436937540769577,
1.0982128381729126,
0.0694805309176445,
0.6002349853515625,
0.5477526187896729,
0.013825051486492157,
0.40621528029441833,
0.6004093289375305,
-0.20645123720169067,
0.48309487104415894,
0.29847079515457153,
-0.3515094220638275,
0.14848116040229797,
0.005559063982218504,
-0.2998757064342499,
0.33052903413772583,
0.30837830901145935,
-0.31864091753959656,
-0.018241098150610924,
0.24989904463291168,
0.15651166439056396,
0.05212463065981865,
-0.4596766233444214,
1.0779473781585693,
0.061829227954149246,
-0.7120186686515808,
0.9382591843605042,
0.009742272086441517,
0.576602041721344,
-0.7056480646133423,
0.10628457367420197,
-0.3408535122871399,
-0.09150222688913345,
0.04203912615776062,
-0.25109297037124634,
0.03456792235374451,
0.07827126234769821,
-0.11240019649267197,
0.179731085896492,
0.4026491940021515,
-0.35620206594467163,
-0.24995465576648712,
0.4514896273612976,
0.3824668228626251,
0.2634190320968628,
-0.038333307951688766,
-0.6275068521499634,
0.20730683207511902,
0.0066050030291080475,
-0.34371909499168396,
0.3930220603942871,
0.47719430923461914,
-0.21197757124900818,
0.9896783828735352,
0.6765932440757751,
0.2264653593301773,
0.3427695631980896,
0.12032954394817352,
0.8438140153884888,
-0.7911161184310913,
-0.47962966561317444,
-1.210086703300476,
-0.07871603220701218,
0.1120246946811676,
-0.08721645921468735,
0.633213222026825,
0.6477180123329163,
0.4878140091896057,
0.07911951094865799,
0.540720522403717,
0.7274727821350098,
0.29000380635261536,
-0.9889916777610779,
0.3088400065898895,
-0.2903516888618469,
0.6840164661407471,
-0.021696997806429863,
-0.8392972946166992,
0.030097773298621178,
0.2046014368534088,
-0.2279059737920761,
-0.1361919343471527,
0.5941252708435059,
0.977997899055481,
0.20314297080039978,
-0.1495772898197174,
0.18014755845069885,
-0.0993412435054779,
0.43964529037475586,
0.7684964537620544,
0.9353992342948914,
-0.5339853763580322,
0.7726993560791016,
-0.3585904538631439,
-0.3376465439796448,
-0.2786678373813629,
-0.6050736904144287,
-1.1375272274017334,
-0.3350342810153961,
-0.04884656146168709,
-0.20358891785144806,
0.29006320238113403,
0.9724376797676086,
0.2596903145313263,
-0.400704950094223,
-0.2541155219078064,
0.07209166884422302,
0.17445655167102814,
-0.16394396126270294,
-0.1475718468427658,
0.5112179517745972,
-0.4056066572666168,
-0.6574358344078064,
0.6702266335487366,
0.009914539754390717,
0.5791010856628418,
-0.17525097727775574,
-0.11274414509534836,
0.12603361904621124,
0.485201895236969,
0.1535172313451767,
0.3754607141017914,
-0.6559929251670837,
0.025279078632593155,
-0.0048333122394979,
-0.24975579977035522,
0.1435835212469101,
1.0064435005187988,
-0.7841468453407288,
0.23880194127559662,
-0.07334788143634796,
0.6829391121864319,
0.5503137707710266,
0.011911998502910137,
0.5282708406448364,
-0.8842810392379761,
0.4898500442504883,
0.22413776814937592,
0.4971288740634918,
0.27906370162963867,
-0.792033314704895,
0.45357391238212585,
-0.1526852250099182,
-0.20724117755889893,
-0.9882676601409912,
0.1474549025297165,
-0.8889598846435547,
-0.5064095854759216,
0.9930044412612915,
-0.02035480923950672,
-0.7695846557617188,
-0.0803644210100174,
-0.4009517431259155,
0.40865325927734375,
-0.5515207648277283,
1.0176551342010498,
0.3883618116378784,
-0.006735007278621197,
-0.19856847822666168,
-0.5529589056968689,
0.546621561050415,
0.4950924813747406,
-0.9497385025024414,
-0.0306757390499115,
0.3897165358066559,
0.04857945814728737,
0.05416252091526985,
0.9263370633125305,
0.005715226288884878,
0.5868206024169922,
0.02378893457353115,
-0.04351729154586792,
-0.5642521381378174,
-0.5073607563972473,
-0.6042317748069763,
0.36593419313430786,
-0.04085272178053856,
-0.5280128121376038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03218v7
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03218v7
|
The WMDP Benchmark: Measuring and Reducing Malicious Use With Unlearning
| 2024-03-05T18:59:35 | 2024-05-15T19:16:09 |
Nathaniel Li, Alexander Pan, Anjali Gopal, Summer Yue, Daniel Berrios, Alice Gatti, Justin D. Li, Ann-Kathrin Dombrowski, Shashwat Goel, Long Phan, Gabriel Mukobi, Nathan Helm-Burger, Rassin Lababidi, Lennart Justen, Andrew B. Liu, Michael Chen, Isabelle Barrass, Oliver Zhang, Xiaoyuan Zhu, Rishub Tamirisa, Bhrugu Bharathi, Adam Khoja, Zhenqi Zhao, Ariel Herbert-Voss, Cort B. Breuer, Samuel Marks, Oam Patel, Andy Zou, Mantas Mazeika, Zifan Wang, Palash Oswal, Weiran Lin, Adam A. Hunt, Justin Tienken-Harder, Kevin Y. Shih, Kemper Talley, John Guan, Russell Kaplan, Ian Steneker, David Campbell, Brad Jokubaitis, Alex Levinson, Jean Wang, William Qian, Kallol Krishna Karmakar, Steven Basart, Stephen Fitz, Mindy Levine, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru, Uday Tupakula, Vijay Varadharajan, Ruoyu Wang, Yan Shoshitaishvili, Jimmy Ba, Kevin M. Esvelt, Alexandr Wang, Dan Hendrycks
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The White House Executive Order on Artificial Intelligence highlights the
risks of large language models (LLMs) empowering malicious actors in developing
biological, cyber, and chemical weapons. To measure these risks of malicious
use, government institutions and major AI labs are developing evaluations for
hazardous capabilities in LLMs. However, current evaluations are private,
preventing further research into mitigating risk. Furthermore, they focus on
only a few, highly specific pathways for malicious use. To fill these gaps, we
publicly release the Weapons of Mass Destruction Proxy (WMDP) benchmark, a
dataset of 3,668 multiple-choice questions that serve as a proxy measurement of
hazardous knowledge in biosecurity, cybersecurity, and chemical security. WMDP
was developed by a consortium of academics and technical consultants, and was
stringently filtered to eliminate sensitive information prior to public
release. WMDP serves two roles: first, as an evaluation for hazardous knowledge
in LLMs, and second, as a benchmark for unlearning methods to remove such
hazardous knowledge. To guide progress on unlearning, we develop RMU, a
state-of-the-art unlearning method based on controlling model representations.
RMU reduces model performance on WMDP while maintaining general capabilities in
areas such as biology and computer science, suggesting that unlearning may be a
concrete path towards reducing malicious use from LLMs. We release our
benchmark and code publicly at https://wmdp.ai
|
[
-0.4141865670681,
-0.6021658778190613,
0.4153076112270355,
-0.32515382766723633,
-0.05448572337627411,
0.3108658194541931,
-0.09966637194156647,
-0.22046029567718506,
-0.48797640204429626,
0.6737830638885498,
-0.432483971118927,
-0.6736522316932678,
-0.73227858543396,
-0.18348923325538635,
-0.22239908576011658,
1.0053410530090332,
0.21548664569854736,
-0.058288272470235825,
-0.4150577187538147,
-0.30147498846054077,
-0.33031514286994934,
-0.4743153154850006,
-0.2736966907978058,
-0.5079737901687622,
0.6336719393730164,
0.24056591093540192,
0.8934172987937927,
0.8822243809700012,
0.7998275756835938,
0.3107506036758423,
0.029802929610013962,
0.028407560661435127,
-0.5776017308235168,
-0.05153222009539604,
-0.6155063509941101,
-0.21661202609539032,
-0.2315414398908615,
0.4037112891674042,
0.2678954005241394,
1.03337824344635,
-0.29409724473953247,
0.4158439636230469,
0.05509299039840698,
0.6461231708526611,
-0.9419644474983215,
0.0016932531725615263,
-0.680395781993866,
-0.019791141152381897,
-0.19407621026039124,
-0.22821073234081268,
-0.4935036301612854,
-0.12863871455192566,
0.10375281423330307,
-0.47186657786369324,
-0.04865661635994911,
-0.14685885608196259,
0.336485892534256,
0.3964632749557495,
-0.6987797617912292,
0.36867955327033997,
-0.7537820935249329,
0.8808225989341736,
-0.6434683799743652,
0.4188915193080902,
0.4187488555908203,
0.325041800737381,
-0.701070249080658,
-0.8830403089523315,
-0.22504861652851105,
-0.3113887906074524,
0.3600209653377533,
0.13622966408729553,
-0.4519491493701935,
0.27920740842819214,
0.5228861570358276,
0.04695276543498039,
-0.7156701683998108,
0.12303896248340607,
-0.5548619031906128,
-0.3895891308784485,
0.7472284436225891,
0.09826235473155975,
0.10916692018508911,
0.043618105351924896,
-0.686153769493103,
-0.3159579038619995,
-0.8645778298377991,
-0.09112660586833954,
0.36496880650520325,
0.023651303723454475,
0.07960876077413559,
0.730883002281189,
-0.14779891073703766,
0.2649371325969696,
-0.7056298851966858,
-0.16583363711833954,
0.21792906522750854,
0.19011950492858887,
-0.3742482364177704,
-0.22599710524082184,
0.868090808391571,
0.625225841999054,
0.14138415455818176,
-0.20781634747982025,
-0.1133934035897255,
0.42373815178871155,
0.7252082228660583,
-0.7072295546531677,
-0.252375990152359,
0.017810387536883354,
-0.6346635222434998,
-0.2534274756908417,
0.03498472273349762,
-0.7625285387039185,
-0.7636361122131348,
-0.10404694080352783,
0.48738187551498413,
-0.24002480506896973,
-0.02799801714718342,
-0.1414465606212616,
-0.5493044257164001,
-0.3841377794742584,
-0.0054861148819327354,
-0.4017414152622223,
0.5919381976127625,
0.7098814845085144,
0.6276342272758484,
-0.31182193756103516,
-0.4430491626262665,
-0.47519439458847046,
0.3352794051170349,
-0.2707054913043976,
0.45592790842056274,
-0.5776052474975586,
-0.682904839515686,
0.0703866109251976,
-0.18248818814754486,
0.28843754529953003,
-0.9505232572555542,
0.4058181941509247,
-0.3938651382923126,
0.028405670076608658,
-0.24384526908397675,
-0.3908168077468872,
-0.50074303150177,
0.10382845252752304,
-0.38208696246147156,
0.9001779556274414,
0.1716831922531128,
-0.49224236607551575,
0.35636863112449646,
-0.38115018606185913,
-0.20542684197425842,
0.16442538797855377,
0.006797320209443569,
-0.2954504191875458,
0.0875813439488411,
-0.14852206408977509,
0.355989933013916,
-0.48797646164894104,
0.33707714080810547,
-0.629220187664032,
-0.3697104752063751,
0.20826007425785065,
-0.691188633441925,
0.7255833148956299,
0.4144653379917145,
-0.3143138885498047,
0.29309380054473877,
-0.8798153400421143,
0.02794361114501953,
0.09065151959657669,
-0.4875887632369995,
-0.36131551861763,
0.2578606605529785,
-0.30485114455223083,
0.2562963366508484,
0.021352916955947876,
-0.5131048560142517,
0.06996196508407593,
-0.1796032041311264,
0.27170029282569885,
0.8965104222297668,
0.19406025111675262,
0.312651127576828,
-0.6595878005027771,
0.3265986442565918,
-0.05445513501763344,
0.35440513491630554,
0.21550345420837402,
-0.5674857497215271,
-0.28575143218040466,
-0.1800260692834854,
-0.13667045533657074,
0.633740246295929,
-0.6038591861724854,
0.19525781273841858,
0.13470648229122162,
-0.8503270745277405,
-0.23431867361068726,
0.3019443154335022,
0.6356897354125977,
0.540690004825592,
0.6577193140983582,
-0.37849733233451843,
-0.45957887172698975,
-0.6613608598709106,
-0.5755096077919006,
-0.3632698655128479,
-0.3040210008621216,
0.02776511386036873,
0.47947463393211365,
-0.4481442868709564,
0.3276851177215576,
-0.42469194531440735,
-0.2690562903881073,
0.026354366913437843,
0.42068877816200256,
-0.1637197881937027,
0.3946239650249481,
0.06771419197320938,
-0.4925897717475891,
-0.02034943178296089,
-0.16935817897319794,
-0.8808999061584473,
-0.08855437487363815,
0.15814189612865448,
-0.07838272303342819,
-0.15085293352603912,
0.686465859413147,
-0.5649756789207458,
0.44912710785865784,
0.3791333734989166,
-0.06302020698785782,
0.4346903860569,
-0.422140896320343,
0.16046443581581116,
-0.7619129419326782,
0.21912944316864014,
-0.09563015401363373,
0.054662954062223434,
-0.593587338924408,
0.35497555136680603,
0.036744676530361176,
-0.3521137833595276,
-0.7202475070953369,
0.34852325916290283,
-0.38536301255226135,
0.09458867460489273,
-0.19500799477100372,
0.28684002161026,
-0.07187527418136597,
0.35543179512023926,
-0.37655994296073914,
0.4317535161972046,
0.31944572925567627,
-0.6876277923583984,
0.381474107503891,
-0.02396329864859581,
-0.1845657229423523,
0.2531585693359375,
-0.485627144575119,
0.11961719393730164,
0.13943958282470703,
-0.09668833017349243,
-0.6281135082244873,
0.15954656898975372,
0.06964970380067825,
-0.12459447234869003,
0.24477262794971466,
-0.15220299363136292,
-0.3522346317768097,
-0.34725067019462585,
-0.5095297694206238,
0.3263329565525055,
0.9182726144790649,
-0.4260992109775543,
0.3568556308746338,
0.7516353726387024,
0.1903967261314392,
-0.9700264930725098,
-0.38258618116378784,
0.004283079877495766,
-0.22932285070419312,
-0.24260014295578003,
0.3949546813964844,
-0.05668867751955986,
-0.4466640055179596,
-0.013325592502951622,
-0.32464975118637085,
0.17327545583248138,
0.29913458228111267,
0.6380632519721985,
0.2090567946434021,
-0.060936737805604935,
-0.016360051929950714,
-0.11626110970973969,
-0.2557218670845032,
0.7466128468513489,
-0.009067829698324203,
0.35606250166893005,
0.42804980278015137,
-0.4509623646736145,
-0.30722740292549133,
0.23909805715084076,
0.7223840951919556,
-0.19866740703582764,
0.6052262187004089,
0.34584298729896545,
-0.38025712966918945,
-0.5029421448707581,
-0.4469347894191742,
-0.14556549489498138,
-0.5054128170013428,
0.436067670583725,
0.009470200166106224,
-0.3940519392490387,
0.34674400091171265,
-0.6933411955833435,
0.33400774002075195,
0.31720685958862305,
0.34703466296195984,
0.23073594272136688,
1.1460199356079102,
0.5862348079681396,
-0.36263012886047363,
0.1813616007566452,
-0.1384008377790451,
0.017305847257375717,
-0.6522559523582458,
-0.5817418694496155,
-0.4138779044151306,
-0.20240518450737,
-0.6894250512123108,
-0.41941624879837036,
0.27703866362571716,
-0.050707586109638214,
-0.5957698225975037,
0.23765958845615387,
-0.49157580733299255,
0.43523550033569336,
0.688737690448761,
0.13823771476745605,
0.22761304676532745,
-0.21313999593257904,
-0.16598469018936157,
0.08566344529390335,
-0.21089094877243042,
-0.6366922855377197,
1.4685331583023071,
0.3634275197982788,
0.8125889301300049,
0.09003116190433502,
0.5432528257369995,
0.5230884552001953,
0.14287064969539642,
-0.5696582794189453,
0.9236462116241455,
-0.23395013809204102,
-0.4117008447647095,
-0.1080048456788063,
-0.6779608130455017,
-0.8657902479171753,
0.3163297176361084,
-0.2909433841705322,
-0.5103448629379272,
-0.3120273947715759,
-0.031004076823592186,
-0.04795294255018234,
0.5403411388397217,
-0.5090413093566895,
0.8004950284957886,
0.09340708702802658,
-0.28383204340934753,
-0.5354441404342651,
-0.5848138928413391,
0.3090566396713257,
0.052753571420907974,
0.11869154870510101,
-0.49218475818634033,
-0.2603088617324829,
1.005741000175476,
-0.41815394163131714,
0.6601271033287048,
-0.323005735874176,
0.07878288626670837,
0.20115239918231964,
0.2910902500152588,
0.31421515345573425,
-0.036584366112947464,
-0.015610797330737114,
0.4375140964984894,
-0.011115279980003834,
-0.15844999253749847,
-0.24445657432079315,
0.6868883371353149,
-0.8778054714202881,
-0.8268865942955017,
-0.7017834186553955,
-0.685762345790863,
-0.25084826350212097,
0.4831215441226959,
0.162613645195961,
0.27875563502311707,
-0.5684002041816711,
0.07266588509082794,
0.6797300577163696,
-0.31138113141059875,
0.5315335392951965,
0.6789384484291077,
-0.0277357529848814,
-0.20646932721138,
0.8443211317062378,
0.16121798753738403,
0.2799314558506012,
0.3814012110233307,
0.39513179659843445,
-0.17471453547477722,
-0.8204517364501953,
-0.16953688859939575,
0.2698870599269867,
-0.8057461977005005,
-0.47991904616355896,
-0.5507891178131104,
-0.2521820664405823,
-0.4923056960105896,
-0.029157835990190506,
-0.27284255623817444,
-0.03005901537835598,
-0.1250152736902237,
-0.20140224695205688,
0.22962282598018646,
1.0552728176116943,
-0.23228025436401367,
-0.06291671097278595,
-0.6981990337371826,
0.583295464515686,
0.3410511612892151,
0.20447057485580444,
-0.2862478494644165,
-0.7247870564460754,
0.10386839509010315,
0.11581122130155563,
-0.7085197567939758,
-0.8217362761497498,
0.4202783405780792,
0.05523205175995827,
0.7270506024360657,
0.5658131837844849,
0.47112640738487244,
0.6261948347091675,
-0.5775890350341797,
0.6421627402305603,
-0.031338926404714584,
-0.8389145731925964,
0.48556458950042725,
-0.2923947274684906,
0.22876645624637604,
0.41076257824897766,
0.7511035203933716,
-0.47873133420944214,
-0.6407269835472107,
-0.646494448184967,
-0.6578177809715271,
0.4964248836040497,
-0.27525290846824646,
0.09306133538484573,
-0.17823028564453125,
0.09901729226112366,
0.029776383191347122,
0.25053995847702026,
-0.25379735231399536,
-0.5101809501647949,
-0.03798694908618927,
0.022104056552052498,
-0.17319053411483765,
-0.3384445607662201,
-0.5318570733070374,
-0.02824920415878296,
0.7597115635871887,
0.16050273180007935,
-0.13059988617897034,
-0.30298569798469543,
-0.11362740397453308,
-0.30093467235565186,
0.24453376233577728,
0.48919183015823364,
0.7182379961013794,
-0.26953139901161194,
0.48298853635787964,
0.23301148414611816,
-0.9599584937095642,
0.1344520002603531,
-0.07655705511569977,
0.02037987671792507,
-0.37090688943862915,
0.26775723695755005,
-0.06501805782318115,
0.09756597131490707,
-1.026522159576416,
0.5338309407234192,
0.21915282309055328,
-0.17406319081783295,
-0.11330556124448776,
0.2314654290676117,
-0.1404147893190384,
0.1718209683895111,
0.31515899300575256,
0.3618563115596771,
0.2981962263584137,
-0.8256375193595886,
0.4348699748516083,
0.54645174741745,
-0.3769868016242981,
-0.1099780723452568,
0.7747096419334412,
0.10774172842502594,
-0.13526779413223267,
0.7547838687896729,
-0.14138980209827423,
-0.18962670862674713,
0.4657626450061798,
0.537343442440033,
0.5631141066551208,
-0.5266320705413818,
0.3858919143676758,
0.29634571075439453,
0.5852765440940857,
-0.06225219741463661,
0.2094992995262146,
0.27990150451660156,
-0.4426775872707367,
0.10460283607244492,
-0.26211005449295044,
-0.3872635066509247,
0.4891064763069153,
-0.8946337103843689,
0.03514035418629646,
-1.0011787414550781,
-0.15125524997711182,
0.04175005853176117,
0.09883962571620941,
-0.4181686043739319,
0.20405039191246033,
-0.045385025441646576,
0.7606247663497925,
-0.968355119228363,
0.5604571104049683,
0.41071709990501404,
-0.3477649688720703,
-0.4752371311187744,
-0.2738591432571411,
0.6765012145042419,
-0.844726026058197,
0.31149208545684814,
0.17381002008914948,
-0.028748853132128716,
-0.2786675691604614,
-0.3312985599040985,
-0.6773352026939392,
0.8664883971214294,
0.506410539150238,
-0.3951859176158905,
0.40195780992507935,
0.22386591136455536,
0.4227295517921448,
0.09981411695480347,
0.11096931248903275,
0.5882449150085449,
0.3544178009033203,
-0.23188728094100952,
-0.6274709701538086,
0.3695889711380005,
-0.2538732588291168,
-0.10265360027551651,
0.5354223251342773,
-0.27885425090789795,
0.7934192419052124,
-0.44203484058380127,
-0.39376723766326904,
-0.1072627529501915,
0.4971601068973541,
0.03509284555912018,
0.5784858465194702,
0.14338354766368866,
0.8011267185211182,
0.7190718054771423,
-0.1050274595618248,
0.7605067491531372,
0.0937260165810585,
-0.12998786568641663,
0.9589353799819946,
-0.4462791681289673,
1.069253921508789,
0.44491735100746155,
-0.24683092534542084,
0.33383607864379883,
0.28003180027008057,
-0.34097886085510254,
0.7253415584564209,
0.5698665976524353,
-0.448078453540802,
0.07140748202800751,
-0.3788307011127472,
-0.38248544931411743,
0.38718774914741516,
0.16588683426380157,
-0.3069899380207062,
-0.19169700145721436,
0.22750045359134674,
0.3029938340187073,
0.2985953092575073,
-0.30762866139411926,
1.0556122064590454,
0.09738753736019135,
-0.5664387941360474,
0.4467146694660187,
0.15022629499435425,
0.2900122404098511,
-0.7152835726737976,
-0.2389584630727768,
0.023527825251221657,
0.49984532594680786,
-0.22309915721416473,
-0.6155831813812256,
0.23417696356773376,
-0.05048517882823944,
-0.08352252840995789,
-0.06389425694942474,
0.3087563216686249,
-0.2779074013233185,
-0.06701648235321045,
0.715134859085083,
0.4204626977443695,
0.2097962647676468,
-0.17103923857212067,
-0.7427385449409485,
-0.04775387421250343,
-0.23135380446910858,
-0.2226882129907608,
0.6969642639160156,
0.3199096918106079,
-0.10766510665416718,
0.9922030568122864,
0.8795639872550964,
0.3575946092605591,
0.06467954814434052,
0.42730119824409485,
0.9429957866668701,
-0.5216890573501587,
0.13521252572536469,
-0.8829540610313416,
0.33776339888572693,
-0.0007714240928180516,
-0.4729434549808502,
0.882459282875061,
0.6061769723892212,
1.168333888053894,
0.13062798976898193,
0.625893771648407,
0.162859246134758,
0.4004497826099396,
-0.3349815309047699,
0.9858865141868591,
-0.42225754261016846,
0.46985137462615967,
-0.21752458810806274,
-1.006407618522644,
-0.2574842572212219,
0.05475794896483421,
0.06686870008707047,
0.11189065873622894,
0.9026591777801514,
0.8941221237182617,
0.12759077548980713,
-0.27488741278648376,
0.7608810663223267,
0.0949556902050972,
0.3173612356185913,
0.2842295467853546,
0.7391091585159302,
-0.4438599646091461,
0.6614390015602112,
-0.7860996127128601,
-0.3362457752227783,
0.0685211643576622,
-0.8995991945266724,
-1.1627986431121826,
-0.4523964524269104,
-0.35358336567878723,
-0.26552584767341614,
0.20587870478630066,
0.7910853624343872,
0.3624457120895386,
-0.6878082752227783,
-0.42039382457733154,
0.14181119203567505,
0.08622277528047562,
-0.5525786876678467,
-0.13628043234348297,
0.18316900730133057,
-0.016613302752375603,
-0.26008087396621704,
0.7733041644096375,
0.3700997233390808,
-0.03757566958665848,
-0.27708977460861206,
0.03540132939815521,
-0.059651341289281845,
0.1129782646894455,
0.5074702501296997,
0.5177194476127625,
-0.6725331544876099,
-0.37175923585891724,
-0.27246174216270447,
-0.10490112751722336,
-0.4032732844352722,
0.7614833116531372,
-0.6238664388656616,
0.45911702513694763,
0.5474588871002197,
0.621458113193512,
-0.09351374208927155,
-0.1364406794309616,
0.5229647755622864,
-0.6675310730934143,
0.15532241761684418,
0.3026074171066284,
0.5026840567588806,
0.03557131066918373,
-0.34229227900505066,
0.5627825260162354,
0.29538244009017944,
-0.7047049403190613,
-1.0604227781295776,
0.13266485929489136,
-0.7897557020187378,
-0.491435706615448,
0.867621660232544,
-0.20512273907661438,
-0.090213842689991,
-0.49002620577812195,
0.08303576707839966,
0.3924504220485687,
-0.3683832585811615,
0.9001942873001099,
0.06161509454250336,
0.25300145149230957,
0.007259465288370848,
-0.6592837572097778,
0.6243821978569031,
0.18347600102424622,
-0.9538059234619141,
0.46877434849739075,
0.4316534101963043,
0.17380768060684204,
0.020636722445487976,
0.3009651303291321,
-0.19581814110279083,
0.34461238980293274,
0.19634512066841125,
0.14798325300216675,
-0.3798559010028839,
-0.6794165968894958,
-0.11172609031200409,
0.19896841049194336,
-0.08760227262973785,
-0.24552975594997406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03194v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03194v1
|
MAGID: An Automated Pipeline for Generating Synthetic Multi-modal Datasets
| 2024-03-05T18:31:28 | 2024-03-05T18:31:28 |
Hossein Aboutalebi, Hwanjun Song, Yusheng Xie, Arshit Gupta, Justin Sun, Hang Su, Igor Shalyminov, Nikolaos Pappas, Siffi Singh, Saab Mansour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Development of multimodal interactive systems is hindered by the lack of
rich, multimodal (text, images) conversational data, which is needed in large
quantities for LLMs. Previous approaches augment textual dialogues with
retrieved images, posing privacy, diversity, and quality constraints. In this
work, we introduce \textbf{M}ultimodal \textbf{A}ugmented \textbf{G}enerative
\textbf{I}mages \textbf{D}ialogues (MAGID), a framework to augment text-only
dialogues with diverse and high-quality images. Subsequently, a diffusion model
is applied to craft corresponding images, ensuring alignment with the
identified text. Finally, MAGID incorporates an innovative feedback loop
between an image description generation module (textual LLM) and image quality
modules (addressing aesthetics, image-text matching, and safety), that work in
tandem to generate high-quality and multi-modal dialogues. We compare MAGID to
other SOTA baselines on three dialogue datasets, using automated and human
evaluation. Our results show that MAGID is comparable to or better than
baselines, with significant improvements in human evaluation, especially
against retrieval baselines where the image database is small.
|
[
-0.549732506275177,
-0.4445756673812866,
0.35990437865257263,
0.1604926586151123,
-0.09121813625097275,
0.2708131968975067,
-0.22530913352966309,
-0.27213698625564575,
0.29953309893608093,
0.2670100927352905,
-0.810204803943634,
-0.6568233370780945,
-0.03691903129220009,
0.26121214032173157,
-0.3364652097225189,
0.9281065464019775,
0.36617377400398254,
0.32699835300445557,
-0.4735472500324249,
-0.14578288793563843,
-0.22443507611751556,
-0.14358912408351898,
-0.29577556252479553,
-0.05716250091791153,
0.6845837235450745,
0.4487687647342682,
1.0008305311203003,
0.42428717017173767,
0.43760380148887634,
0.32789573073387146,
0.2021956741809845,
0.9657979607582092,
-0.31297004222869873,
0.46829432249069214,
-0.12236321717500687,
-0.10808374732732773,
-0.4963294565677643,
-0.0007612816989421844,
0.5801494121551514,
0.3044646382331848,
0.05348796397447586,
0.03388837352395058,
-0.04123484715819359,
0.476253867149353,
-0.7143477201461792,
0.11967091262340546,
-0.37401190400123596,
0.1554708331823349,
-0.12130683660507202,
-0.386480450630188,
-0.47367775440216064,
-0.19327299296855927,
0.11174743622541428,
-0.7550286054611206,
-0.14665919542312622,
0.20510946214199066,
0.8898761868476868,
0.21076050400733948,
-0.4473550319671631,
-0.6545599102973938,
-0.7805731892585754,
0.6525025367736816,
-0.6185261011123657,
0.19541501998901367,
0.2645275294780731,
0.15283212065696716,
-0.1468988060951233,
-0.717237114906311,
-0.8203065395355225,
-0.13412143290042877,
-0.33826184272766113,
0.26368778944015503,
-0.05800517648458481,
0.16239731013774872,
-0.006134346593171358,
0.431152880191803,
-0.3070976138114929,
-0.07039658725261688,
-0.36752548813819885,
-0.2511012852191925,
0.7776494026184082,
0.5748379230499268,
0.34256455302238464,
-0.546848475933075,
-0.3786846399307251,
-0.1093144491314888,
-0.6240223050117493,
-0.05822888761758804,
0.5672973990440369,
-0.0006642066291533411,
0.09001177549362183,
0.6795182824134827,
-0.1923646628856659,
0.6343785524368286,
0.027722176164388657,
-0.40694624185562134,
0.4419836699962616,
-0.9024364948272705,
-0.19416199624538422,
-0.48912614583969116,
1.2032880783081055,
0.8397388458251953,
-0.11786073446273804,
-0.0900554358959198,
-0.2068934142589569,
-0.16832302510738373,
0.18464942276477814,
-0.9126157760620117,
-0.23544193804264069,
0.11859583854675293,
-0.42269080877304077,
-0.4214635193347931,
0.15125197172164917,
-0.9100096821784973,
-0.5000773072242737,
-0.4759954512119293,
0.42323628067970276,
-0.49686142802238464,
-0.15804481506347656,
-0.18421506881713867,
0.11863645166158676,
-0.06313365697860718,
0.32683491706848145,
-0.6755425930023193,
-0.05876743420958519,
0.1446801871061325,
0.7799221873283386,
-0.3589745759963989,
-0.043321333825588226,
-0.48925256729125977,
0.23919644951820374,
-0.39923498034477234,
0.8134106397628784,
-0.8239585757255554,
-0.6155475974082947,
-0.07591290026903152,
0.005252430215477943,
-0.035003114491701126,
-0.5065640807151794,
0.5788081884384155,
-0.2201540619134903,
0.5014005899429321,
-0.11848974227905273,
-0.10498973727226257,
-0.09726252406835556,
0.26607567071914673,
-0.5502021312713623,
0.8332242369651794,
-0.1646200716495514,
-0.7150525450706482,
0.2992887496948242,
-0.9823287725448608,
-0.277707040309906,
-0.11605098098516464,
-0.34989410638809204,
-0.3114418089389801,
-0.09481314569711685,
0.49299490451812744,
0.2833905518054962,
-0.5103583335876465,
0.299678236246109,
-0.11537633091211319,
-0.2649947702884674,
0.6144386529922485,
-0.5381509065628052,
0.2763586640357971,
0.6923097968101501,
-0.016949482262134552,
0.3362603485584259,
-0.741004467010498,
0.3394348621368408,
-0.30460479855537415,
-0.2663041949272156,
-0.03785180300474167,
0.03159326687455177,
0.17769786715507507,
0.25503331422805786,
-0.0741007998585701,
-0.44618454575538635,
0.26621073484420776,
-0.32876259088516235,
0.3260605037212372,
0.8163362145423889,
-0.12997543811798096,
0.564368724822998,
-0.4699624478816986,
0.5660918951034546,
0.13732998073101044,
0.30317366123199463,
-0.8869954943656921,
-0.27562442421913147,
-0.9857933521270752,
-0.902523934841156,
0.5733428597450256,
0.6202940940856934,
-1.0771968364715576,
0.33019524812698364,
-0.46594133973121643,
-0.34689387679100037,
-0.5874093174934387,
0.2386060655117035,
0.43105652928352356,
0.08572475612163544,
-0.020424295216798782,
-0.5196732878684998,
-0.5412712097167969,
-1.190299391746521,
0.325528085231781,
-0.2166537493467331,
-0.3315434455871582,
0.7320417165756226,
0.26788103580474854,
-0.43656331300735474,
1.0941886901855469,
-0.22148898243904114,
-0.4382554888725281,
0.03458366543054581,
0.3914211094379425,
-0.0116220498457551,
0.4342343509197235,
0.37003228068351746,
-0.6752554774284363,
-0.4386284649372101,
-0.03394707664847374,
-0.8708077669143677,
-0.23755763471126556,
-0.39096304774284363,
-0.30757662653923035,
0.06475349515676498,
0.3023105561733246,
-0.7956290245056152,
0.3448668122291565,
0.5454638004302979,
-0.08359618484973907,
0.45640331506729126,
-0.04352816194295883,
0.6362786889076233,
-1.3596082925796509,
0.06161605194211006,
-0.23586030304431915,
-0.12880899012088776,
-0.4673110544681549,
-0.15138094127178192,
-0.2867979109287262,
-0.28112655878067017,
-0.44464266300201416,
0.43788254261016846,
-0.6181674599647522,
-0.23077405989170074,
-0.04591035842895508,
0.09248830378055573,
0.2818438708782196,
0.5800701975822449,
-0.23448830842971802,
1.1325993537902832,
0.681486189365387,
-0.24130749702453613,
0.6611366868019104,
0.4644909203052521,
-0.38637664914131165,
1.0662561655044556,
-0.5024468302726746,
0.25771448016166687,
-0.2469351887702942,
0.24047598242759705,
-1.1846468448638916,
-0.5462620854377747,
0.30337080359458923,
-0.38572344183921814,
0.16813434660434723,
-0.0014856120105832815,
-0.7788856625556946,
-0.0702706053853035,
-0.33611220121383667,
0.3516499698162079,
0.2544160485267639,
-0.3294883966445923,
0.8345929980278015,
0.3046746253967285,
-0.3977400064468384,
-0.4594557583332062,
-0.4130772352218628,
0.5233956575393677,
-0.04378737881779671,
-1.0031169652938843,
0.1789463460445404,
-0.3490923047065735,
-0.16247397661209106,
-0.0984385535120964,
0.1927761733531952,
-0.12201821804046631,
-0.24715378880500793,
0.5391783714294434,
0.33821168541908264,
-0.09106825292110443,
0.5748407244682312,
0.2022753208875656,
0.001785671222023666,
-0.23096825182437897,
-0.0050110043957829475,
0.3893582820892334,
-0.1437074840068817,
-0.7304471135139465,
-0.7470399737358093,
0.6346793174743652,
0.8365675210952759,
-0.1670718491077423,
0.3806259036064148,
0.7659465670585632,
-0.01813315600156784,
0.259642630815506,
-0.5721146464347839,
-0.15289150178432465,
-0.49062806367874146,
-0.016590643674135208,
-0.4883349537849426,
-0.6685853004455566,
0.500659167766571,
-0.21233932673931122,
0.08483731001615524,
0.179141566157341,
0.6936275362968445,
-0.32948049902915955,
1.3096338510513306,
0.1375339925289154,
0.38906341791152954,
0.4668137729167938,
-0.2950003445148468,
0.04887865111231804,
-0.7518972754478455,
-0.47019749879837036,
-0.041377242654561996,
-0.585851788520813,
-0.24641570448875427,
-0.5733999609947205,
0.7931745052337646,
-0.12215182930231094,
0.1739039123058319,
-0.0902339443564415,
-0.5254336595535278,
0.6553255915641785,
0.5213755965232849,
0.2046409398317337,
0.5460333824157715,
0.2692573666572571,
-0.29018348455429077,
-0.23292528092861176,
-0.5229113101959229,
-0.6564545631408691,
1.1525914669036865,
0.09952259063720703,
1.2259169816970825,
0.18383800983428955,
0.3233991265296936,
0.5145533084869385,
0.44803446531295776,
-0.6321920156478882,
0.5923689007759094,
0.1314646303653717,
-0.7192441821098328,
0.01074401568621397,
-0.14482760429382324,
-0.8309475779533386,
0.3556707203388214,
-0.6548455953598022,
-0.5020800828933716,
0.35825321078300476,
0.04127916321158409,
-0.5878536701202393,
0.10126841068267822,
-0.8993304371833801,
0.6174083948135376,
-0.1373242735862732,
-0.49074649810791016,
-0.048367295414209366,
-0.7660495042800903,
0.3029007315635681,
0.013790213502943516,
0.17061103880405426,
-0.18585705757141113,
0.02810494229197502,
0.2308753877878189,
-0.3624774217605591,
0.9067146182060242,
0.16361604630947113,
-0.061604470014572144,
0.46494996547698975,
0.13558055460453033,
0.27659085392951965,
0.27113106846809387,
-0.04052357375621796,
-0.028401793912053108,
0.056810613721609116,
-0.1779368817806244,
-0.7334232330322266,
0.7419365048408508,
-0.5580534338951111,
-0.4812966287136078,
-0.17252260446548462,
-0.7589703798294067,
-0.11346004158258438,
-0.0026405106764286757,
0.2016294002532959,
0.8565508723258972,
-0.19022823870182037,
0.37934091687202454,
0.5395159721374512,
-0.24107234179973602,
0.43542614579200745,
0.25998654961586,
-0.30558133125305176,
-0.721037745475769,
0.8452494740486145,
-0.11526951193809509,
0.3049151599407196,
-0.053503651171922684,
-0.1838751882314682,
-0.293205589056015,
-0.15333819389343262,
-0.9293620586395264,
-0.001900550676509738,
-0.751500129699707,
-0.5109408497810364,
-0.8108368515968323,
-0.22279156744480133,
-0.12039843946695328,
0.023135721683502197,
-0.29666492342948914,
-0.3839733898639679,
-0.5490550994873047,
-0.00693549495190382,
0.31119680404663086,
0.4541274309158325,
-0.2965824604034424,
0.18150946497917175,
-0.8549050688743591,
0.22456856071949005,
0.5502530932426453,
0.13655351102352142,
-0.211410254240036,
-0.24486158788204193,
-0.23819677531719208,
0.2916209101676941,
-0.6176777482032776,
-0.6932586431503296,
0.5647035837173462,
0.6618834733963013,
0.43222737312316895,
0.4526824653148651,
0.1467682123184204,
0.7615665197372437,
-0.4363199770450592,
0.8613207936286926,
0.4039916694164276,
-0.7767250537872314,
0.5660214424133301,
-0.4174646735191345,
0.2429763823747635,
0.37622785568237305,
0.15168870985507965,
-0.3913498520851135,
-0.45383891463279724,
-0.3177197575569153,
-0.6314337849617004,
0.535500168800354,
0.4428654611110687,
0.5380902886390686,
-0.1295575201511383,
0.06635857373476028,
0.23199979960918427,
0.4112240970134735,
-0.5887309908866882,
-0.1268896758556366,
-0.3120919466018677,
-0.4229249358177185,
0.3494792878627777,
-0.26279088854789734,
-0.6904761791229248,
-0.2816832661628723,
0.314239501953125,
-0.4471677243709564,
0.49397701025009155,
0.334809273481369,
-0.21270854771137238,
0.04801812022924423,
0.47833406925201416,
0.6913279294967651,
0.7624308466911316,
0.1406586915254593,
0.11355508118867874,
0.010936878621578217,
-0.1506006121635437,
0.2557215988636017,
-0.16915300488471985,
-0.21677953004837036,
0.19633527100086212,
-0.07323341071605682,
0.9785488843917847,
-0.15488681197166443,
-0.9647015333175659,
0.6239216327667236,
-0.028862811625003815,
-0.09354494512081146,
-0.29928743839263916,
0.08806632459163666,
-0.051719605922698975,
0.5362400412559509,
0.4886745512485504,
0.3112773001194,
0.44427981972694397,
-0.6287776231765747,
0.2875448167324066,
0.5789365172386169,
-0.35113272070884705,
-0.3904965817928314,
0.4703485369682312,
0.5469545722007751,
-0.2859097123146057,
0.5233180522918701,
-0.4001929461956024,
-0.0355847105383873,
0.012751062400639057,
0.2460743635892868,
0.5897925496101379,
0.10025349259376526,
0.4955363869667053,
0.25600960850715637,
0.10876698791980743,
0.2632444500923157,
0.2953050136566162,
0.0033895482774823904,
-0.6783408522605896,
-0.6028739213943481,
-0.3841058015823364,
-0.3983533978462219,
-0.12392611801624298,
-0.38965359330177307,
0.2981930673122406,
-0.48167651891708374,
-0.5571528673171997,
-0.08053923398256302,
-0.5404233336448669,
-0.4357900321483612,
0.07088254392147064,
0.16867336630821228,
0.36675408482551575,
-0.5693523287773132,
0.5669863224029541,
0.44820278882980347,
-0.4780694246292114,
-0.3998529613018036,
-0.20819176733493805,
0.07869184762239456,
-0.5227420926094055,
0.6924889087677002,
0.12474076449871063,
-0.2641697824001312,
-0.02375735528767109,
-0.7782322764396667,
-0.6288464069366455,
1.125184416770935,
0.4206739068031311,
-0.14045552909374237,
-0.09282219409942627,
-0.07402931153774261,
0.6067427396774292,
-0.7853057384490967,
0.5065947771072388,
0.2560730576515198,
0.49580955505371094,
0.5623596906661987,
-0.9583951830863953,
-0.1847686469554901,
-0.6720215678215027,
0.06875716894865036,
-0.11299712210893631,
-0.5509577393531799,
0.6134052872657776,
-0.29623058438301086,
-0.6227205991744995,
0.5153528451919556,
0.5232704877853394,
-0.09510062634944916,
0.24214665591716766,
0.5770374536514282,
0.45016539096832275,
0.5207544565200806,
-0.325443834066391,
0.8963443040847778,
-0.17594969272613525,
0.11511823534965515,
0.8985034823417664,
-0.1585346907377243,
0.4064621329307556,
0.38763725757598877,
0.08862198144197464,
0.6645746827125549,
0.5935205817222595,
-0.1808762550354004,
0.5793115496635437,
0.02353142946958542,
-0.5223135352134705,
-0.5683528780937195,
-0.5999240875244141,
-0.1819784939289093,
0.5315728187561035,
0.4608764946460724,
-0.5200235247612,
-0.01719488576054573,
0.3203260600566864,
-0.18338169157505035,
0.06517284363508224,
0.08666735887527466,
0.9406141042709351,
-0.40241050720214844,
-0.4374571442604065,
0.6510769128799438,
-0.2252444475889206,
0.740593671798706,
-0.23326458036899567,
-0.06150168552994728,
-0.28493160009384155,
-0.30780571699142456,
-0.3333771228790283,
-0.7018425464630127,
0.1838236004114151,
-0.14972811937332153,
-0.26931580901145935,
-0.2411051243543625,
0.5650086998939514,
-0.7075207829475403,
-0.5274387001991272,
-0.3906641900539398,
0.4998079836368561,
0.2227601259946823,
0.2961830794811249,
-0.6109253764152527,
0.11142045259475708,
-0.07529658079147339,
-0.05965573713183403,
0.06832654029130936,
0.425772100687027,
0.008979570120573044,
0.8647546172142029,
0.8423272967338562,
-0.2783084809780121,
-0.009405513294041157,
0.010079503059387207,
1.1761023998260498,
-0.257492333650589,
-0.16314220428466797,
-0.6054715514183044,
0.8515662550926208,
-0.39899933338165283,
-0.1083044558763504,
0.45421019196510315,
0.5200786590576172,
0.47001615166664124,
-0.15620574355125427,
0.5878933668136597,
-0.14148637652397156,
0.40729790925979614,
-0.6880886554718018,
0.6559880971908569,
-0.6585495471954346,
0.24173425137996674,
-0.2371063232421875,
-0.9753850698471069,
-0.29890525341033936,
0.7121566534042358,
0.15381529927253723,
-0.20404237508773804,
0.5933661460876465,
1.2888323068618774,
-0.14269445836544037,
-0.0707554891705513,
0.42665866017341614,
-0.05742906779050827,
0.30754220485687256,
0.18606457114219666,
1.2560803890228271,
-0.4429294168949127,
0.8960829377174377,
0.20510753989219666,
0.05613837391138077,
-0.13360832631587982,
-0.7896308898925781,
-0.8238092660903931,
-0.7225192785263062,
-0.15251922607421875,
-0.29441362619400024,
-0.029143325984477997,
1.016965627670288,
0.9920351505279541,
-0.6131048798561096,
-0.12712228298187256,
0.4909344017505646,
0.0014977911487221718,
0.26655104756355286,
-0.23667040467262268,
0.022511282935738564,
-0.2813533544540405,
-1.1519975662231445,
0.49240922927856445,
0.6520398855209351,
0.18882609903812408,
-0.6131244897842407,
-0.193166583776474,
-0.12747377157211304,
0.3768153190612793,
0.5352292656898499,
-0.030721178278326988,
-0.8413975834846497,
-0.34776434302330017,
0.2284003347158432,
-0.2352849841117859,
0.2911698520183563,
0.8480224609375,
-0.5710734128952026,
0.9398598670959473,
0.4198751449584961,
0.44903895258903503,
0.326158732175827,
0.07405436038970947,
0.7914511561393738,
-0.8763049840927124,
0.3660892844200134,
0.09656353294849396,
0.12498504668474197,
0.5404108762741089,
-0.13322268426418304,
0.48071736097335815,
0.25175032019615173,
-0.4275608956813812,
-0.8079257607460022,
0.5272520780563354,
-0.8786191344261169,
0.06338027864694595,
1.1308058500289917,
-0.27197888493537903,
0.15115903317928314,
-0.03176545351743698,
-0.7498096227645874,
-0.21688663959503174,
-0.4627421200275421,
0.725514829158783,
0.7615578174591064,
-0.1278696060180664,
-0.36676543951034546,
-0.22540131211280823,
0.40678712725639343,
0.21325641870498657,
-0.9161004424095154,
-0.19454525411128998,
1.0918021202087402,
-0.03822791948914528,
0.5145274996757507,
0.6376028060913086,
-0.29467564821243286,
0.2018377184867859,
-0.28156915307044983,
0.17690396308898926,
-0.22716695070266724,
-0.4593963027000427,
0.18393269181251526,
0.036952342838048935,
-0.2102339118719101,
-0.2083517462015152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03187v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03187v1
|
Reliable, Adaptable, and Attributable Language Models with Retrieval
| 2024-03-05T18:22:33 | 2024-03-05T18:22:33 |
Akari Asai, Zexuan Zhong, Danqi Chen, Pang Wei Koh, Luke Zettlemoyer, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Wen-tau Yih
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Parametric language models (LMs), which are trained on vast amounts of web
data, exhibit remarkable flexibility and capability. However, they still face
practical challenges such as hallucinations, difficulty in adapting to new data
distributions, and a lack of verifiability. In this position paper, we advocate
for retrieval-augmented LMs to replace parametric LMs as the next generation of
LMs. By incorporating large-scale datastores during inference,
retrieval-augmented LMs can be more reliable, adaptable, and attributable.
Despite their potential, retrieval-augmented LMs have yet to be widely adopted
due to several obstacles: specifically, current retrieval-augmented LMs
struggle to leverage helpful text beyond knowledge-intensive tasks such as
question answering, have limited interaction between retrieval and LM
components, and lack the infrastructure for scaling. To address these, we
propose a roadmap for developing general-purpose retrieval-augmented LMs. This
involves a reconsideration of datastores and retrievers, the exploration of
pipelines with improved retriever-LM interaction, and significant investment in
infrastructure for efficient training and inference.
|
[
-0.3244610130786896,
-0.4834173321723938,
0.7461137175559998,
0.07726119458675385,
0.03260399401187897,
0.21052968502044678,
-0.27865853905677795,
-0.5049768090248108,
0.36888137459754944,
0.8472625017166138,
-0.06577416509389877,
-0.2600654065608978,
-0.426009863615036,
0.10245051234960556,
-0.7181134223937988,
0.5928748250007629,
-0.10234089195728302,
-0.16011369228363037,
-0.3074791729450226,
-0.32693949341773987,
-0.32533887028694153,
-0.720277726650238,
-0.5218332409858704,
-0.03659825772047043,
0.6691361665725708,
0.11313306540250778,
1.081203818321228,
0.5996617674827576,
0.33751380443573,
0.2894667685031891,
-0.03993150219321251,
0.17542989552021027,
-0.19332019984722137,
0.308589369058609,
-0.39865922927856445,
-0.42875978350639343,
-0.4495967924594879,
-0.22805155813694,
0.9531128406524658,
0.9908449649810791,
-0.4033365547657013,
0.004335317760705948,
0.1804436594247818,
0.6842927932739258,
-0.9192020297050476,
0.0002815940242726356,
-0.7948251962661743,
-0.2955394685268402,
-0.11427048593759537,
-0.11159709095954895,
-0.39209309220314026,
-0.4226636290550232,
0.2582574486732483,
-0.48483800888061523,
0.028820164501667023,
0.17686590552330017,
0.4947466254234314,
-0.009346057660877705,
-0.4029936194419861,
-0.432064950466156,
-0.7457032203674316,
0.8475977182388306,
-0.7157101631164551,
0.9048841595649719,
0.6927950978279114,
0.4415471851825714,
-0.2187357246875763,
-0.8737545609474182,
-0.1672116369009018,
-0.3633516728878021,
0.02115132473409176,
-0.4802909195423126,
0.1519797295331955,
-0.04754404351115227,
-0.15641584992408752,
0.21312284469604492,
-0.38063985109329224,
-0.03747986629605293,
-0.08461961895227432,
-0.039836201816797256,
0.34129342436790466,
0.3660663962364197,
0.3361453115940094,
-0.03216802701354027,
-0.025251420214772224,
0.43594714999198914,
-0.7949063777923584,
-0.35078129172325134,
0.12444356828927994,
0.6727210283279419,
0.39886826276779175,
0.31929585337638855,
-0.46595513820648193,
0.9171804189682007,
-0.24154341220855713,
0.08316192030906677,
0.24425755441188812,
-0.3982025980949402,
0.04474257677793503,
-0.11910268664360046,
0.6515302658081055,
0.0462128221988678,
0.12933366000652313,
-0.5757323503494263,
-0.4854215085506439,
-0.45594537258148193,
0.4315500259399414,
-0.629470944404602,
-0.17168645560741425,
0.364596426486969,
-0.3480033874511719,
-0.07929921895265579,
-0.23278532922267914,
-0.819165050983429,
-0.5554482340812683,
-0.33574607968330383,
0.5648842453956604,
-0.40682095289230347,
-0.3039083778858185,
0.17619118094444275,
0.09833430498838425,
0.024693040177226067,
0.35329386591911316,
-1.105393648147583,
0.42863184213638306,
0.5955838561058044,
1.0150859355926514,
-0.1873730719089508,
-0.3024847209453583,
-0.4668331444263458,
0.41702309250831604,
-0.41375023126602173,
0.8797075152397156,
-0.8117562532424927,
-0.3971773087978363,
0.358504056930542,
0.07721396535634995,
0.18178735673427582,
-0.8442587852478027,
0.4914565086364746,
-0.593224287033081,
0.13744883239269257,
-0.5417040586471558,
-0.49406901001930237,
0.14142274856567383,
0.3908413350582123,
-0.824752151966095,
0.7828852534294128,
0.2161150872707367,
-0.5527006983757019,
0.08442659676074982,
-0.2801673710346222,
-0.16652008891105652,
0.2051912099123001,
0.057244982570409775,
-0.12514473497867584,
0.04796643927693367,
0.2666643559932709,
0.1677098125219345,
-0.6291263699531555,
0.3662409484386444,
-0.5383299589157104,
-0.645845890045166,
0.13453608751296997,
-0.3782913386821747,
0.5279163718223572,
0.2522890567779541,
0.15490199625492096,
-0.16540540754795074,
-0.9622469544410706,
0.09231602400541306,
-0.07324846088886261,
-0.593407392501831,
-0.5056371688842773,
0.5521816611289978,
0.050838928669691086,
-0.16547253727912903,
0.5010064840316772,
-0.31980353593826294,
0.060147468000650406,
-0.19225037097930908,
0.4886228144168854,
0.5555937886238098,
-0.15990974009037018,
0.7688116431236267,
-0.14595215022563934,
0.5235517024993896,
-0.2021140456199646,
0.15754185616970062,
-0.026104256510734558,
-0.0569705106317997,
-0.5843315720558167,
-0.1336359828710556,
0.09174440801143646,
0.4524194300174713,
-0.9863770008087158,
0.1134161502122879,
-0.3101513683795929,
-0.48671433329582214,
-0.38416361808776855,
0.3054857850074768,
0.13038130104541779,
0.6263629198074341,
0.5305622220039368,
0.05530702322721481,
-0.7431337237358093,
-0.705544650554657,
-0.48725345730781555,
-0.27238595485687256,
-0.12889966368675232,
0.28616592288017273,
0.11366523057222366,
-0.3293439745903015,
0.8863691687583923,
-0.10264531522989273,
-0.03257942199707031,
-0.15698570013046265,
-0.17901477217674255,
0.18644748628139496,
0.33847302198410034,
0.2968596816062927,
-0.8580530285835266,
-0.4441145062446594,
-0.03956956788897514,
-0.9263604283332825,
-0.12435264885425568,
0.37380748987197876,
0.0834064781665802,
0.050969548523426056,
0.5220615863800049,
-0.5931839346885681,
-0.08895088732242584,
0.3078839182853699,
0.014331947080790997,
0.6885885000228882,
-0.14526060223579407,
0.17971733212471008,
-0.8791093826293945,
0.12033013999462128,
-0.14575830101966858,
-0.22450630366802216,
-0.7702160477638245,
0.17058944702148438,
0.2577175498008728,
-0.27002593874931335,
-0.41415947675704956,
0.7555239200592041,
-0.6001311540603638,
-0.19649244844913483,
-0.26398199796676636,
0.22357794642448425,
-0.015269243158400059,
0.02981887385249138,
0.04721095412969589,
0.9765850901603699,
0.5687119364738464,
-0.7946673035621643,
0.5536034107208252,
0.21711930632591248,
-0.409210741519928,
0.7310222387313843,
-0.6239981055259705,
0.17939932644367218,
-0.14314261078834534,
0.35535570979118347,
-0.5423169136047363,
-0.17569361627101898,
0.11204864084720612,
-0.27136048674583435,
0.10417824983596802,
-0.043437354266643524,
-0.5458240509033203,
-0.3038921058177948,
-0.38584181666374207,
0.2691032290458679,
0.30311694741249084,
-0.6954324245452881,
0.8218508362770081,
0.400276780128479,
-0.2645658254623413,
-0.5757843255996704,
-0.5610262155532837,
0.47626250982284546,
-0.29467517137527466,
-0.23793283104896545,
0.1708661913871765,
0.14689497649669647,
-0.15195690095424652,
0.0013215760700404644,
0.1339099407196045,
-0.23991987109184265,
-0.06127036735415459,
-0.2208513617515564,
0.22058941423892975,
-0.18497733771800995,
0.328654408454895,
-0.20580613613128662,
0.06037919968366623,
0.057302091270685196,
-0.35449057817459106,
0.4329952895641327,
-0.1326519399881363,
-0.38451215624809265,
-0.14897283911705017,
0.3581831753253937,
0.4855659604072571,
-0.2903929650783539,
0.8582490086555481,
0.2888154685497284,
-0.6246687769889832,
0.08104953914880753,
-0.8537968397140503,
-0.08290934562683105,
-0.5078386068344116,
0.5153760313987732,
-0.4763694107532501,
-0.8556699156761169,
0.6778407096862793,
-0.10427390038967133,
-0.0988362729549408,
-0.006361489184200764,
0.4048496186733246,
-0.04530299827456474,
1.1300219297409058,
0.30124208331108093,
-0.15821047127246857,
0.5663142800331116,
0.17209547758102417,
0.09992364794015884,
-1.0573641061782837,
-0.2599886655807495,
-0.6867985725402832,
-0.12609902024269104,
-0.5788624286651611,
-0.1971173882484436,
0.15989677608013153,
0.1927955597639084,
-0.3382589817047119,
0.4456431269645691,
-0.22866706550121307,
0.2977278232574463,
0.3857387900352478,
0.2746756374835968,
0.37029367685317993,
-0.03134993836283684,
0.3139875531196594,
-0.012670643627643585,
-0.5051096677780151,
-0.6471019983291626,
1.2414438724517822,
0.24730829894542694,
0.871161937713623,
0.21836921572685242,
0.6127693057060242,
0.17231200635433197,
0.19469955563545227,
-0.3971749544143677,
0.6256235241889954,
-0.16441136598587036,
-0.7463262677192688,
-0.22403167188167572,
-0.3742958903312683,
-0.796403706073761,
0.1951993852853775,
0.1015651598572731,
-1.0544053316116333,
0.3709089159965515,
0.31452468037605286,
-0.13666127622127533,
0.2846311926841736,
-0.6370775699615479,
0.6630086898803711,
-0.09261438250541687,
-0.5675948858261108,
-0.014800471253693104,
-0.4479805529117584,
0.14323574304580688,
-0.22041912376880646,
0.31718742847442627,
0.1582270860671997,
-0.3407766819000244,
0.4300558269023895,
-0.6192835569381714,
0.513660728931427,
-0.40578290820121765,
-0.188880056142807,
0.5086577534675598,
0.09508419781923294,
0.7199552059173584,
0.020450757816433907,
-0.3979509770870209,
-0.3850826621055603,
0.21601983904838562,
-0.6607121825218201,
-0.9402402639389038,
0.8608598113059998,
-0.4406191408634186,
-0.886897623538971,
-0.16242127120494843,
-0.6925532817840576,
-0.7651939988136292,
0.028403041884303093,
-0.2066037654876709,
0.431761234998703,
-0.13193847239017487,
0.4349279999732971,
0.6541286110877991,
-0.10703027993440628,
0.25535303354263306,
0.5397008061408997,
-0.47028517723083496,
-0.45921486616134644,
1.3299248218536377,
0.11890015751123428,
0.3562227487564087,
0.34061118960380554,
0.04424772784113884,
-0.5638014674186707,
-0.7167097926139832,
-0.27540701627731323,
0.0557364858686924,
-0.6002446413040161,
-0.028760338202118874,
-0.583219587802887,
-0.09396789222955704,
-0.3216463029384613,
-0.03601979836821556,
-0.4872221052646637,
-0.2511039972305298,
-0.5503973364830017,
0.11060824990272522,
0.39744728803634644,
0.38195130228996277,
-0.08291831612586975,
0.16685576736927032,
-0.8759108781814575,
0.23810480535030365,
0.23797261714935303,
0.4466955065727234,
0.1274840533733368,
-0.6693525910377502,
-0.3805501461029053,
0.2326759546995163,
0.000941654434427619,
-0.6339371204376221,
0.2999214828014374,
0.32404735684394836,
0.372999906539917,
0.054015129804611206,
-0.1700185239315033,
0.5739805698394775,
-0.7302415370941162,
0.6966521143913269,
-0.07969535142183304,
-0.7525632977485657,
0.5066376328468323,
-0.38840654492378235,
0.05474989488720894,
0.6325536370277405,
0.44230982661247253,
-0.5870054960250854,
-0.18764851987361908,
-0.13434340059757233,
-0.7757024168968201,
0.39753055572509766,
-0.2776986062526703,
0.45960015058517456,
-0.1437864899635315,
0.6219052672386169,
0.07025045901536942,
0.4294864237308502,
-0.45192596316337585,
0.17473946511745453,
-0.1368774026632309,
-0.22589784860610962,
-0.07815675437450409,
-0.2517752945423126,
0.37177029252052307,
-0.17706744372844696,
0.5967330932617188,
-0.08297225832939148,
0.13428597152233124,
-0.1654479056596756,
-0.2298009693622589,
0.11938083171844482,
0.2506448030471802,
-0.008937397040426731,
0.9252750277519226,
-0.4252191185951233,
0.27498072385787964,
0.17953692376613617,
-0.3685798645019531,
0.39848658442497253,
0.19624963402748108,
-0.1972130835056305,
0.023480016738176346,
0.15632550418376923,
0.8389638662338257,
0.2775444984436035,
-0.8164141774177551,
0.09792446345090866,
0.27715128660202026,
0.13239207863807678,
-0.21410320699214935,
-0.0356871522963047,
0.3591309189796448,
0.35389697551727295,
0.5356656908988953,
-0.43168866634368896,
0.34202346205711365,
-0.7499409914016724,
0.29154303669929504,
0.5917401909828186,
-0.46358492970466614,
-0.26162058115005493,
0.7738057374954224,
0.1384844183921814,
-0.6002994775772095,
0.5979378819465637,
-0.08260612189769745,
-0.37318235635757446,
0.014902443625032902,
0.5549395084381104,
0.6333709955215454,
-0.5001010894775391,
0.13357704877853394,
0.0810059979557991,
0.1681913435459137,
-0.4294362962245941,
0.31479543447494507,
0.14447054266929626,
-0.5469412207603455,
-0.3105378746986389,
-0.6029179692268372,
-0.46683794260025024,
0.09710805863142014,
-0.6257197260856628,
0.33411502838134766,
-0.37762704491615295,
-0.07027970999479294,
-0.4684126675128937,
-0.12560708820819855,
-0.36998629570007324,
0.3287161588668823,
-0.06187707185745239,
1.0326915979385376,
-0.49645939469337463,
0.9316787719726562,
0.6338576674461365,
-0.6613883376121521,
-0.47223228216171265,
-0.20150111615657806,
-0.3056223392486572,
-0.7743505239486694,
0.41425400972366333,
-0.31334397196769714,
0.0567767508327961,
0.17520453035831451,
-0.4595896899700165,
-0.841179609298706,
1.10370934009552,
0.5957388281822205,
-0.5501046776771545,
-0.5578054785728455,
0.3141827881336212,
0.5906877517700195,
-0.20677673816680908,
0.2639242112636566,
0.569568395614624,
0.1928698569536209,
-0.07573128491640091,
-0.764762818813324,
0.07118979096412659,
0.053101055324077606,
0.4954800307750702,
0.32846030592918396,
-0.48960569500923157,
0.7459542751312256,
0.023094279691576958,
0.09306622296571732,
0.3643476963043213,
0.8195545077323914,
0.3500176668167114,
0.07556504756212234,
0.29232943058013916,
0.5717757940292358,
0.5815078616142273,
0.09950178116559982,
0.9729096293449402,
-0.23361030220985413,
0.3266817033290863,
1.2576888799667358,
-0.4806899130344391,
1.2538096904754639,
0.6551523208618164,
-0.5268985629081726,
0.5101760029792786,
0.5490707159042358,
0.2524605095386505,
0.6419249773025513,
0.01761862449347973,
-0.5858895182609558,
-0.17308905720710754,
-0.3524034917354584,
-0.3469591438770294,
0.05043518543243408,
0.6085160970687866,
-0.3885391652584076,
-0.23849447071552277,
0.07727281749248505,
-0.20406293869018555,
0.1875852346420288,
-0.26132169365882874,
0.3803180456161499,
0.06971415132284164,
-0.356231689453125,
0.8265737295150757,
-0.1507253348827362,
0.4841560423374176,
-0.5413329005241394,
0.06933359801769257,
-0.3281044065952301,
0.04785016551613808,
-0.11708218604326248,
-0.6549068093299866,
0.30017155408859253,
-0.10618860274553299,
-0.09786555916070938,
-0.116330087184906,
0.9212930798530579,
-0.5313454866409302,
-0.4037594497203827,
0.42189085483551025,
0.5894268751144409,
0.06818846613168716,
-0.40904489159584045,
-0.5286566615104675,
0.3207058310508728,
-0.18552500009536743,
-0.4258604943752289,
0.6551565527915955,
0.4583452343940735,
0.007347879000008106,
0.9853781461715698,
0.44486624002456665,
0.20317387580871582,
0.14846667647361755,
0.1739853471517563,
0.7887989282608032,
-0.5634374618530273,
-0.07042213529348373,
-0.6580655574798584,
0.2897644639015198,
0.18718886375427246,
0.15375962853431702,
0.5337736010551453,
0.4501928389072418,
0.4111199975013733,
0.1390678435564041,
0.7969891428947449,
-0.01544132363051176,
0.8345077037811279,
-0.3555481731891632,
0.5428475141525269,
-0.7027841210365295,
0.35849928855895996,
-0.28789591789245605,
-1.2893555164337158,
-0.19283589720726013,
0.3546271026134491,
-0.22897396981716156,
0.2560570240020752,
0.5557325482368469,
0.8183140158653259,
-0.10645449906587601,
0.004171294160187244,
0.2291775941848755,
0.08862339705228806,
0.4299815595149994,
0.5339852571487427,
0.6771723031997681,
-0.5841032862663269,
0.6367729306221008,
-0.04912712052464485,
-0.08847626298666,
-0.17328299582004547,
-0.6890045404434204,
-0.4945088326931,
-0.7346733212471008,
-0.20457375049591064,
-0.353157639503479,
0.4936889708042145,
0.6807068586349487,
0.276388019323349,
-0.9482092261314392,
-0.31571441888809204,
-0.4282274544239044,
-0.019770536571741104,
0.17903991043567657,
-0.2094084769487381,
0.25471287965774536,
-0.5695179104804993,
-0.944410502910614,
0.3370564579963684,
0.25205400586128235,
-0.17170575261116028,
-0.5163818597793579,
-0.2403891384601593,
-0.5132675170898438,
-0.06655871123075485,
0.5660094618797302,
0.5456664562225342,
-0.7930909395217896,
-0.5978959798812866,
0.0979156494140625,
-0.13909873366355896,
-0.09043289721012115,
0.5414733290672302,
-0.9689880609512329,
0.45562490820884705,
0.3030787706375122,
1.0863300561904907,
0.06492085754871368,
-0.07417827099561691,
0.7533155679702759,
-0.3478212058544159,
0.06615142524242401,
0.25091278553009033,
0.42721042037010193,
0.543190062046051,
0.04570969566702843,
0.30844148993492126,
0.18098463118076324,
-0.6336032152175903,
-1.1233601570129395,
0.12976641952991486,
-0.3027462959289551,
-0.1496027559041977,
1.1289857625961304,
-0.13228675723075867,
-0.09511103481054306,
-0.17232565581798553,
-0.05229547992348671,
0.005418435204774141,
-0.13859246671199799,
0.562232255935669,
0.8716485500335693,
0.1366547793149948,
-0.45503076910972595,
-0.6207666397094727,
0.4017091691493988,
0.524302065372467,
-0.840143620967865,
0.28242090344429016,
0.482561856508255,
0.18820172548294067,
0.16375532746315002,
0.5802948474884033,
-0.2244720458984375,
-0.026845155283808708,
-0.12381922453641891,
-0.11847390979528427,
0.34621837735176086,
-0.28467071056365967,
-0.14008578658103943,
-0.005211031995713711,
0.5720675587654114,
-0.18328210711479187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03170v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03170v1
|
SNIFFER: Multimodal Large Language Model for Explainable Out-of-Context Misinformation Detection
| 2024-03-05T18:04:59 | 2024-03-05T18:04:59 |
Peng Qi, Zehong Yan, Wynne Hsu, Mong Li Lee
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY
|
Misinformation is a prevalent societal issue due to its potential high risks.
Out-of-context (OOC) misinformation, where authentic images are repurposed with
false text, is one of the easiest and most effective ways to mislead audiences.
Current methods focus on assessing image-text consistency but lack convincing
explanations for their judgments, which is essential for debunking
misinformation. While Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have rich
knowledge and innate capability for visual reasoning and explanation
generation, they still lack sophistication in understanding and discovering the
subtle crossmodal differences. In this paper, we introduce SNIFFER, a novel
multimodal large language model specifically engineered for OOC misinformation
detection and explanation. SNIFFER employs two-stage instruction tuning on
InstructBLIP. The first stage refines the model's concept alignment of generic
objects with news-domain entities and the second stage leverages language-only
GPT-4 generated OOC-specific instruction data to fine-tune the model's
discriminatory powers. Enhanced by external tools and retrieval, SNIFFER not
only detects inconsistencies between text and image but also utilizes external
knowledge for contextual verification. Our experiments show that SNIFFER
surpasses the original MLLM by over 40% and outperforms state-of-the-art
methods in detection accuracy. SNIFFER also provides accurate and persuasive
explanations as validated by quantitative and human evaluations.
|
[
-0.40682584047317505,
-0.8583065867424011,
0.5909784436225891,
0.04203643649816513,
-0.18285825848579407,
-0.09585700929164886,
-0.15362706780433655,
-0.6088303327560425,
-0.24488839507102966,
0.28310197591781616,
-0.3739108443260193,
-0.22214895486831665,
-0.7830283045768738,
-0.18008777499198914,
-0.3486242890357971,
0.7810770273208618,
-0.06894852221012115,
-0.07782728224992752,
-0.24813209474086761,
-0.07455506175756454,
-0.4699854552745819,
-0.03415757790207863,
-0.5363075137138367,
-0.2506154477596283,
0.3394559919834137,
0.6792221069335938,
0.6918807029724121,
0.2570475935935974,
0.12987978756427765,
0.3095257580280304,
0.0674835816025734,
0.2582593262195587,
-0.5843013525009155,
-0.06703262031078339,
-0.2803947329521179,
-0.37604033946990967,
0.17687858641147614,
-0.10931963473558426,
0.4857472777366638,
0.1237289234995842,
-0.09874700009822845,
0.03981811925768852,
-0.1197860836982727,
0.3262547254562378,
-0.8484629988670349,
0.07276683300733566,
-0.8250299692153931,
-0.33243441581726074,
-0.12150608003139496,
-0.48047685623168945,
-0.6593393683433533,
-0.037606801837682724,
0.05991721153259277,
-0.4707571566104889,
0.292236864566803,
0.039431966841220856,
0.9440639019012451,
0.19158926606178284,
-0.7478100657463074,
-0.3918032646179199,
-0.48731565475463867,
0.7367918491363525,
-0.6305428147315979,
0.6361936926841736,
0.2922403812408447,
0.5143161416053772,
-0.15751126408576965,
-0.6037485599517822,
-0.9612436890602112,
-0.13579875230789185,
-0.19800515472888947,
0.10091559588909149,
-0.22537900507450104,
-0.36581021547317505,
0.049088116735219955,
0.1716080904006958,
-0.6268185973167419,
0.0869058147072792,
-0.27913954854011536,
-0.3023309111595154,
0.2701552212238312,
-0.2395213544368744,
0.5950908064842224,
-0.1514492928981781,
-0.758072555065155,
-0.10785994678735733,
-0.3882456421852112,
0.05557841807603836,
0.22575633227825165,
-0.26619189977645874,
-0.17392633855342865,
0.42970138788223267,
0.013532654382288456,
0.5213971138000488,
0.24891193211078644,
-0.4410858750343323,
0.2321658730506897,
-0.24570146203041077,
-0.21897508203983307,
0.33687788248062134,
0.6383158564567566,
0.5458511710166931,
0.013865536078810692,
-0.0006481683230958879,
-0.11085954308509827,
0.16199256479740143,
0.13799983263015747,
-0.9791766405105591,
-0.18136411905288696,
0.12534594535827637,
-0.7213810682296753,
-0.24874870479106903,
0.06396427750587463,
-1.060520052909851,
-0.6948521733283997,
-0.14000168442726135,
0.4880247116088867,
-0.6133302450180054,
-0.2965998351573944,
0.15234996378421783,
-0.4158920645713806,
-0.017569459974765778,
0.48899194598197937,
-0.5604588985443115,
-0.22855135798454285,
0.3425194323062897,
0.6748711466789246,
-0.010538680478930473,
-0.3948594629764557,
-0.6596412062644958,
0.2760114371776581,
-0.0805654376745224,
0.868155837059021,
-0.8831143975257874,
-0.021263888105750084,
-0.10819125920534134,
0.08911807835102081,
-0.18762658536434174,
-0.48433661460876465,
0.4043952226638794,
-0.594775915145874,
0.42120152711868286,
-0.0027354639023542404,
-0.43641912937164307,
-0.48159098625183105,
0.5435824990272522,
-0.5953818559646606,
1.1529072523117065,
0.1110936626791954,
-1.0138555765151978,
0.5685917735099792,
-0.755868136882782,
-0.10521049052476883,
-0.007608553394675255,
-0.12758105993270874,
-0.38373154401779175,
0.12632960081100464,
0.5240948796272278,
0.24416936933994293,
-0.07441087067127228,
0.30618882179260254,
-0.20385316014289856,
-0.39796182513237,
0.38997524976730347,
-0.8504747152328491,
0.7006528377532959,
0.20899289846420288,
-0.5765514969825745,
0.23536142706871033,
-0.72093266248703,
-0.12062506377696991,
0.12723878026008606,
-0.354679673910141,
-0.5211895108222961,
-0.08112874627113342,
0.15649592876434326,
0.5384207367897034,
0.12463392317295074,
-0.6786657571792603,
-0.11294964700937271,
0.09553368389606476,
0.44321534037590027,
0.41037917137145996,
0.027707314118742943,
0.3543374538421631,
-0.1608390510082245,
0.4415604770183563,
0.48303714394569397,
0.34789541363716125,
-0.8081578612327576,
-0.551181435585022,
-0.4632226228713989,
-0.3843737244606018,
-0.09687848389148712,
0.5333698987960815,
-0.9284653663635254,
0.15097719430923462,
-0.250607430934906,
-0.43235909938812256,
-0.42973199486732483,
0.09120261669158936,
0.3693365156650543,
0.6250379085540771,
0.5141677856445312,
0.07724984735250473,
-0.3172105848789215,
-0.7984369397163391,
-0.5879130959510803,
0.06155237928032875,
0.13443459570407867,
0.055749550461769104,
0.6200697422027588,
-0.6392011046409607,
0.8031100630760193,
-0.1837674230337143,
-0.19792534410953522,
-0.29448240995407104,
0.346894234418869,
-0.27127671241760254,
0.33691170811653137,
0.4476145803928375,
-1.1289775371551514,
-0.39691680669784546,
0.22031669318675995,
-0.603206992149353,
0.06823984533548355,
-0.34846583008766174,
-0.08693856000900269,
0.33624786138534546,
0.6787486672401428,
-0.5452038645744324,
0.6547819972038269,
0.6725707054138184,
-0.5079624652862549,
0.5369937419891357,
-0.38056737184524536,
0.3298584520816803,
-0.8399254679679871,
-0.06270148605108261,
0.15627852082252502,
-0.3231079578399658,
-0.5947569012641907,
0.19059212505817413,
0.41129279136657715,
-0.002597134094685316,
-0.5657904148101807,
0.6182389259338379,
-0.6209933757781982,
0.3536594808101654,
-0.3208792209625244,
0.21826782822608948,
0.3422018587589264,
0.2905561327934265,
0.00018033839296549559,
0.4330907166004181,
0.5642000436782837,
-0.4066094160079956,
0.29747915267944336,
0.1389002501964569,
-0.5563176870346069,
0.7620088458061218,
-0.367728054523468,
-0.024194147437810898,
-0.4842231869697571,
0.5124701857566833,
-1.2109276056289673,
-0.41008055210113525,
0.41825971007347107,
-0.33921849727630615,
0.29383766651153564,
-0.3153509199619293,
-0.527938961982727,
-0.25544270873069763,
-0.1815105527639389,
0.5878976583480835,
0.11877933144569397,
-1.0210028886795044,
0.8336215615272522,
0.21509772539138794,
0.23232601583003998,
-0.6239094138145447,
-0.6250039935112,
0.12161886692047119,
-0.3135073184967041,
-0.7247664332389832,
0.05424647405743599,
-0.047044429928064346,
-0.18401776254177094,
-0.03120156191289425,
-0.32733678817749023,
-0.26224711537361145,
-0.23263350129127502,
0.23064327239990234,
0.2467740923166275,
-0.20601405203342438,
0.43026649951934814,
-0.05252429470419884,
-0.016452500596642494,
-0.05273238196969032,
-0.1898193061351776,
0.45569339394569397,
-0.11641917377710342,
-0.5548011660575867,
-0.44648757576942444,
0.28853079676628113,
0.7863685488700867,
-0.30510133504867554,
0.8467540144920349,
1.01150381565094,
-0.29258787631988525,
-0.10053534805774689,
-0.7767489552497864,
-0.10197795182466507,
-0.46223846077919006,
0.5166256427764893,
-0.30827823281288147,
-0.5646994709968567,
0.19106772541999817,
-0.1066974326968193,
-0.1466313898563385,
0.19261984527111053,
0.2164774388074875,
0.12233777344226837,
0.9969222545623779,
0.5329838395118713,
0.1344892978668213,
0.44747379422187805,
0.04056737571954727,
0.47680845856666565,
-0.37905406951904297,
-0.49804162979125977,
-0.27500176429748535,
-0.35012996196746826,
-0.24516715109348297,
-0.6481993198394775,
0.3771204948425293,
0.06818599253892899,
-0.008794722147285938,
-0.10275238752365112,
-0.3193283677101135,
0.8740513920783997,
0.42686283588409424,
0.2313583642244339,
0.43762636184692383,
0.016671638935804367,
0.08660119771957397,
0.11068602651357651,
-0.5588489770889282,
-0.41879627108573914,
0.6728190183639526,
0.49991148710250854,
0.9049963355064392,
0.12328651547431946,
0.32265886664390564,
0.08168157190084457,
0.30333733558654785,
-0.8010479807853699,
0.24218612909317017,
-0.009202252142131329,
-0.8329591751098633,
-0.27902379631996155,
-0.3789256513118744,
-0.6740390062332153,
0.5756219029426575,
-0.25429606437683105,
-0.7420383095741272,
0.31060469150543213,
0.37417691946029663,
0.12042170017957687,
0.49182412028312683,
-0.883539080619812,
1.1679956912994385,
-0.37699005007743835,
-0.14883773028850555,
-0.2741679251194,
-0.666113555431366,
0.6453736424446106,
-0.0939590334892273,
0.5035481452941895,
0.059549544006586075,
0.009811412543058395,
0.27702218294143677,
-0.15418919920921326,
0.9762323498725891,
-0.3946080505847931,
-0.37730342149734497,
0.11054880917072296,
0.1270628273487091,
0.5713940262794495,
0.06311087310314178,
0.24242600798606873,
0.20851358771324158,
0.0680142417550087,
-0.2966846227645874,
-0.6469932198524475,
0.6797544360160828,
-0.3445342481136322,
-0.2712327837944031,
-0.12782590091228485,
-0.7282559275627136,
-0.03978104516863823,
0.34685131907463074,
0.6166112422943115,
0.6209489703178406,
-0.09572874754667282,
0.27836766839027405,
0.7994803786277771,
-0.6018156409263611,
0.15167970955371857,
0.4732101261615753,
-0.32397860288619995,
0.04847799986600876,
1.014096975326538,
-0.36554884910583496,
0.25481292605400085,
0.6634380221366882,
0.3923613131046295,
-0.45747584104537964,
-0.24139121174812317,
-0.5245554447174072,
0.13422632217407227,
-0.999330997467041,
0.03751766309142113,
-0.5614152550697327,
0.11216102540493011,
-0.17477533221244812,
-0.002690500346943736,
-0.20927351713180542,
0.050237346440553665,
0.12482821196317673,
0.17547090351581573,
0.14021994173526764,
0.6165014505386353,
0.12320297211408615,
0.43724268674850464,
-0.75998455286026,
0.6967496871948242,
0.2521750032901764,
0.37480834126472473,
-0.010725977830588818,
-0.5427883267402649,
-0.2141556441783905,
0.3198763430118561,
-0.34545236825942993,
-1.038185954093933,
0.24552981555461884,
0.2120218276977539,
0.5705111026763916,
0.9275128245353699,
-0.0943119004368782,
0.7071845531463623,
-0.2017209380865097,
0.6550949811935425,
0.3475821018218994,
-0.9904200434684753,
0.42150741815567017,
-0.19961348176002502,
0.43647104501724243,
0.29321008920669556,
0.471775621175766,
-0.7208282351493835,
-0.4333193600177765,
-0.38434866070747375,
-0.7750366926193237,
0.7501002550125122,
-0.1732138842344284,
-0.07338066399097443,
-0.06278683990240097,
-0.211232990026474,
0.3858429789543152,
-0.0875384509563446,
-0.8624227643013,
0.01354992389678955,
-0.4984951317310333,
-0.24634520709514618,
-0.18551594018936157,
-0.4029938280582428,
-0.17682601511478424,
-0.028342563658952713,
0.7076101899147034,
-0.2529623806476593,
0.06841269135475159,
0.0802837461233139,
-0.6551288366317749,
-0.11864837259054184,
0.5245584845542908,
0.7403759956359863,
0.8991640210151672,
0.0213480107486248,
0.4923607110977173,
-0.06007527559995651,
-0.5559994578361511,
0.04507669061422348,
0.014131900854408741,
-0.029303599148988724,
0.20091363787651062,
0.3764130771160126,
0.7868490815162659,
0.33084550499916077,
-0.9983626008033752,
0.8141801953315735,
-0.17097191512584686,
-0.0865301862359047,
-0.18501074612140656,
-0.1746077537536621,
0.08215156942605972,
0.3024132549762726,
0.20924657583236694,
0.43417876958847046,
0.15874698758125305,
-0.6707397699356079,
-0.06884660571813583,
0.43490344285964966,
-0.28318607807159424,
-0.15348409116268158,
0.6306495070457458,
-0.0660790354013443,
0.2246188223361969,
0.3832751512527466,
-0.09589629620313644,
-0.4861944913864136,
0.4213082790374756,
0.5967534780502319,
0.4407452940940857,
-0.2124844193458557,
0.3580247461795807,
0.07216626405715942,
0.4334428608417511,
-0.20854179561138153,
0.06021437048912048,
-0.13144952058792114,
-0.8441450595855713,
-0.2423902302980423,
-0.26643607020378113,
0.04504337161779404,
0.5074605941772461,
-0.555334210395813,
0.10061901807785034,
0.014563851058483124,
0.1571892648935318,
0.13053075969219208,
-0.7038357257843018,
-0.6930865049362183,
0.21469621360301971,
0.21264570951461792,
1.0445376634597778,
-0.848910391330719,
0.7028177976608276,
0.6561940312385559,
-0.26744547486305237,
-0.565409243106842,
0.4387563169002533,
0.2961520254611969,
-0.8373429775238037,
0.7052426338195801,
0.5402145385742188,
-0.33205389976501465,
-0.381721556186676,
-0.514836311340332,
-0.6198475956916809,
0.772269070148468,
0.5186011791229248,
-0.6161308288574219,
0.072287417948246,
-0.042103223502635956,
0.2469988465309143,
-0.22113218903541565,
0.5040513873100281,
0.46120861172676086,
0.8179991841316223,
0.1772707849740982,
-0.8536553978919983,
0.09063208103179932,
-0.2704688310623169,
-0.02590133622288704,
0.1945546567440033,
-0.2622753381729126,
0.697180449962616,
-0.3635573387145996,
-0.2103378027677536,
-0.16006071865558624,
0.25107482075691223,
0.10439373552799225,
0.6946808099746704,
0.7860571146011353,
0.48255860805511475,
0.6960274577140808,
0.08460342884063721,
0.9651341438293457,
-0.15768226981163025,
0.031880974769592285,
1.34804368019104,
-0.06358612328767776,
0.7256998419761658,
0.5498874187469482,
0.41313618421554565,
0.7904074788093567,
0.3256203234195709,
0.15352170169353485,
0.3655147850513458,
-0.10638964176177979,
-0.27077749371528625,
-0.36148154735565186,
0.09236003458499908,
-0.352560430765152,
0.8056676983833313,
0.45624518394470215,
-0.5198670625686646,
-0.3561134338378906,
0.3067464232444763,
-0.08337263017892838,
0.05918600782752037,
-0.29825320839881897,
0.5397276282310486,
-0.3760872781276703,
-0.679745078086853,
0.7081565856933594,
0.06313294172286987,
0.7220926284790039,
-0.4662363529205322,
-0.05619889870285988,
0.038461390882730484,
0.5650564432144165,
-0.2996408939361572,
-0.7868507504463196,
0.13105225563049316,
-0.12541761994361877,
-0.2040024697780609,
-0.16377128660678864,
0.9309656023979187,
-0.7429119348526001,
-0.28171947598457336,
0.3557158410549164,
0.2964208126068115,
0.19302205741405487,
-0.40578532218933105,
-0.5222939252853394,
0.16415779292583466,
-0.043821774423122406,
-0.1307201236486435,
0.11860324442386627,
0.8588912487030029,
-0.27769097685813904,
0.7368731498718262,
0.5351817011833191,
-0.25767982006073,
0.2551144063472748,
0.14518262445926666,
0.783758282661438,
-0.34015634655952454,
-0.6127324104309082,
-0.8213831782341003,
0.6132707595825195,
-0.18195226788520813,
-0.22789989411830902,
0.8573222160339355,
0.563607394695282,
0.8889743089675903,
-0.3175796866416931,
0.8714734315872192,
0.10571189224720001,
0.39667999744415283,
-0.5199520587921143,
0.6708968281745911,
-0.7560429573059082,
0.03127342462539673,
-0.10968442261219025,
-0.6868531107902527,
-0.046109214425086975,
0.42963579297065735,
-0.1923927217721939,
-0.06198860704898834,
0.8013424277305603,
0.9523346424102783,
-0.6249576210975647,
0.14373323321342468,
0.30443060398101807,
0.4178484082221985,
0.30148428678512573,
0.3576025664806366,
1.1315793991088867,
-0.26463690400123596,
0.8332578539848328,
-0.027314400300383568,
-0.3600405752658844,
-0.44507119059562683,
-0.9501068592071533,
-1.0014137029647827,
-0.5038471221923828,
-0.25211241841316223,
-0.1568158119916916,
-0.15239505469799042,
0.5005588531494141,
0.9078172445297241,
-0.6946728825569153,
0.18346276879310608,
0.1049654632806778,
0.03459365665912628,
-0.33880800008773804,
-0.3387816846370697,
0.040140990167856216,
-0.21928556263446808,
-0.5341869592666626,
0.5734575390815735,
0.31473448872566223,
-0.12706996500492096,
-0.21419823169708252,
-0.182808518409729,
-0.23809827864170074,
0.2152000367641449,
0.6455553770065308,
0.17879298329353333,
-0.904242217540741,
-0.19715820252895355,
-0.33591148257255554,
0.06343188136816025,
0.11572790890932083,
0.8259639143943787,
-0.6488967537879944,
0.8027015924453735,
0.453157514333725,
0.35541969537734985,
0.4193727374076843,
0.05744701623916626,
0.1417170912027359,
-0.8623433113098145,
0.25884130597114563,
-0.19984786212444305,
0.49141785502433777,
0.36578133702278137,
-0.5067006349563599,
0.02915525808930397,
0.07598283886909485,
-0.39337873458862305,
-0.6946902275085449,
0.2985335886478424,
-0.9389991164207458,
-0.69931560754776,
1.0965778827667236,
-0.016527414321899414,
-0.15501944720745087,
-0.3385922312736511,
-0.689643144607544,
0.1861703246831894,
-0.5596354603767395,
0.9527662396430969,
0.4970499575138092,
0.07510171085596085,
-0.4199899733066559,
-0.4882586598396301,
0.217600017786026,
-0.027979711070656776,
-0.9331076741218567,
-0.049692586064338684,
0.679341197013855,
0.5371488928794861,
0.27138686180114746,
0.3808060884475708,
-0.09434569627046585,
0.45037841796875,
0.08738023787736893,
0.018185148015618324,
-0.34323006868362427,
-0.4499129056930542,
-0.13870012760162354,
0.13487592339515686,
-0.3807918131351471,
-0.3820480406284332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03167v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03167v3
|
PARADISE: Evaluating Implicit Planning Skills of Language Models with Procedural Warnings and Tips Dataset
| 2024-03-05T18:01:59 | 2024-06-06T08:22:16 |
Arda Uzunoglu, Abdalfatah Rashid Safa, Gözde Gül Şahin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, there has been growing interest within the community regarding
whether large language models are capable of planning or executing plans.
However, most prior studies use LLMs to generate high-level plans for
simplified scenarios lacking linguistic complexity and domain diversity,
limiting analysis of their planning abilities. These setups constrain
evaluation methods (e.g., predefined action space), architectural choices
(e.g., only generative models), and overlook the linguistic nuances essential
for realistic analysis. To tackle this, we present PARADISE, an abductive
reasoning task using Q\&A format on practical procedural text sourced from
wikiHow. It involves warning and tip inference tasks directly associated with
goals, excluding intermediary steps, with the aim of testing the ability of the
models to infer implicit knowledge of the plan solely from the given goal. Our
experiments, utilizing fine-tuned language models and zero-shot prompting,
reveal the effectiveness of task-specific small models over large language
models in most scenarios. Despite advancements, all models fall short of human
performance. Notably, our analysis uncovers intriguing insights, such as
variations in model behavior with dropped keywords, struggles of BERT-family
and GPT-4 with physical and abstract goals, and the proposed tasks offering
valuable prior knowledge for other unseen procedural tasks. The PARADISE
dataset and associated resources are publicly available for further research
exploration with https://github.com/GGLAB-KU/paradise.
|
[
-0.09860441833734512,
-0.936610996723175,
0.9136298894882202,
0.36667150259017944,
-0.09310294687747955,
-0.16237027943134308,
-0.31141456961631775,
-0.05440885201096535,
-0.08730296045541763,
0.6194621324539185,
-1.0160409212112427,
-0.8311325311660767,
-0.4760493338108063,
0.19558502733707428,
-0.449800580739975,
0.9305135607719421,
-0.045779865235090256,
-0.23422451317310333,
-0.31647205352783203,
0.2462984323501587,
-0.642566442489624,
-0.2827891707420349,
-0.5767525434494019,
-0.055864207446575165,
0.6053513884544373,
0.45357218384742737,
0.625849187374115,
0.5216770768165588,
0.33035358786582947,
0.23988045752048492,
-0.04980142414569855,
0.2241823673248291,
-0.7225404977798462,
0.16471950709819794,
-0.09623441845178604,
-0.30262935161590576,
-0.31880316138267517,
-0.29842430353164673,
0.587722659111023,
0.7824837565422058,
-0.00663402397185564,
0.16437110304832458,
-0.009826519526541233,
0.5931761264801025,
-0.8201292157173157,
0.5104954838752747,
-0.8373503684997559,
0.10609467327594757,
0.1798991858959198,
-0.2891882061958313,
-0.40389081835746765,
-0.432839035987854,
0.31021133065223694,
-0.4615839719772339,
0.03239483758807182,
0.03329434618353844,
0.5005357265472412,
0.4971133768558502,
-0.264496773481369,
-0.46099337935447693,
-0.9955830574035645,
0.7376210689544678,
-0.47459015250205994,
0.21341021358966827,
0.47879350185394287,
0.1911860555410385,
-0.32859790325164795,
-0.4991205036640167,
-0.5715025663375854,
-0.4477865695953369,
-0.044232554733753204,
0.05597729980945587,
-0.24054041504859924,
0.275270015001297,
0.5107566714286804,
0.013881378807127476,
-0.6091281771659851,
-0.12994204461574554,
-0.33311063051223755,
0.019837670028209686,
0.4816226363182068,
0.2924021780490875,
0.2925872504711151,
-0.4186937212944031,
-0.06437037885189056,
0.12148918956518173,
-1.0004652738571167,
0.28856638073921204,
0.4835883378982544,
0.4346823990345001,
-0.1387469321489334,
0.8483431339263916,
-0.37335678935050964,
0.5379469394683838,
-0.4379855692386627,
0.0349937379360199,
-0.32292640209198,
-0.29324695467948914,
-0.2653501033782959,
-0.24406512081623077,
0.5454052686691284,
0.3212055563926697,
0.32936781644821167,
-0.1998804807662964,
-0.1699475795030594,
0.0011634931433945894,
0.5782127380371094,
-0.6141646504402161,
-0.4667302966117859,
0.37073197960853577,
-0.18505653738975525,
0.07009278237819672,
-0.45116016268730164,
-0.25616562366485596,
-0.208587646484375,
-0.3356667160987854,
0.26516595482826233,
-0.6393145322799683,
-0.23549309372901917,
0.20519031584262848,
0.003901353105902672,
0.19965995848178864,
0.3975822925567627,
-0.5964053869247437,
0.2392488270998001,
0.8454617857933044,
0.6593503355979919,
-0.042006269097328186,
-0.2548048794269562,
-0.3899703919887543,
-0.03964104875922203,
-0.5254268646240234,
0.8380985260009766,
-0.5433380007743835,
-0.6710332036018372,
0.2706722319126129,
-0.048771291971206665,
-0.3030628561973572,
-0.12072525173425674,
0.7720624208450317,
-0.392984539270401,
0.0349297821521759,
-0.6379454135894775,
-0.3343842029571533,
-0.42667946219444275,
0.42914697527885437,
-0.4464277923107147,
0.646277904510498,
0.1486426144838333,
-0.4451577961444855,
0.34168168902397156,
-0.663025975227356,
-0.4526813328266144,
0.08767671138048172,
-0.4373887777328491,
-0.318619966506958,
0.03631730377674103,
0.16759493947029114,
0.4274357557296753,
-0.076470747590065,
0.3279147148132324,
-0.19180439412593842,
-0.4770374298095703,
0.2071748673915863,
-0.33289456367492676,
0.7452681660652161,
-0.023117342963814735,
-0.4425238370895386,
0.3031582236289978,
-0.42221376299858093,
0.02920719049870968,
0.23210225999355316,
-0.26997092366218567,
-0.3166436553001404,
0.22743912041187286,
-0.17320217192173004,
0.1459701657295227,
0.15398994088172913,
-0.25133591890335083,
0.3405224084854126,
-0.3595430850982666,
0.14999596774578094,
0.5825633406639099,
0.20419619977474213,
0.3306262791156769,
-0.2704881727695465,
0.7566477060317993,
-0.3976723849773407,
0.2838691473007202,
-0.07406312227249146,
-0.5846384167671204,
-0.9325082898139954,
-0.060725048184394836,
0.065203458070755,
0.4070066213607788,
-0.8600698113441467,
0.19382524490356445,
-0.5287752151489258,
-0.20240317285060883,
-0.18549098074436188,
-0.01329673733562231,
0.7924702167510986,
0.289916068315506,
0.22681304812431335,
-0.05611342564225197,
-0.4091538190841675,
-1.0066654682159424,
-0.20701919496059418,
-0.16186054050922394,
0.0951792523264885,
0.452880859375,
0.6442919373512268,
0.07936683297157288,
1.0207031965255737,
-0.6069457530975342,
-0.13261236250400543,
-0.5085694789886475,
0.10801813751459122,
0.0956045612692833,
0.406637966632843,
0.5123152136802673,
-0.9538737535476685,
-0.24989789724349976,
-0.19702963531017303,
-0.7069318294525146,
0.23093552887439728,
-0.08331691473722458,
-0.266157329082489,
-0.028377512469887733,
0.11564747244119644,
-0.753964900970459,
0.5162546038627625,
0.22921894490718842,
-0.41659456491470337,
0.8163707852363586,
-0.10542465001344681,
0.17892831563949585,
-0.6161704659461975,
-0.0153905488550663,
0.022263189777731895,
-0.0997311919927597,
-0.6401728987693787,
0.18154653906822205,
0.011319759301841259,
0.13947933912277222,
-0.5096616148948669,
0.39854902029037476,
-0.33977922797203064,
-0.2045034021139145,
-0.29893824458122253,
-0.2359289824962616,
-0.14424148201942444,
0.7832863330841064,
0.37840554118156433,
0.8636605739593506,
0.35089173913002014,
-0.7952678799629211,
-0.06594961881637573,
0.41602233052253723,
-0.21136756241321564,
0.3335627615451813,
-0.5002567172050476,
0.24726922810077667,
-0.127763032913208,
0.0052436902187764645,
-0.9700135588645935,
-0.2724880278110504,
0.5078368186950684,
-0.44381293654441833,
0.07357695698738098,
-0.6884849667549133,
-0.32422566413879395,
-0.41619575023651123,
-0.20669184625148773,
0.22299514710903168,
0.5840193033218384,
-0.01761799305677414,
0.5746476650238037,
0.3180103302001953,
-0.5248443484306335,
-0.5936943888664246,
-0.337227463722229,
0.0946282297372818,
-0.19823144376277924,
-0.12464096397161484,
0.09045391529798508,
-0.1936967670917511,
-0.40188828110694885,
0.1759244203567505,
-0.14750459790229797,
-0.09987346082925797,
0.06315270811319351,
0.6645492315292358,
0.25671491026878357,
-0.1299552619457245,
-0.27338147163391113,
0.4799923300743103,
0.1169419214129448,
0.4710385203361511,
-0.38865306973457336,
0.5306641459465027,
-0.17374226450920105,
-0.4813469648361206,
-0.1586163192987442,
0.09656345099210739,
0.32027286291122437,
0.01293496135622263,
0.639621913433075,
0.07551927864551544,
-0.5544689297676086,
-0.2197880744934082,
-0.40825721621513367,
0.10649415850639343,
-0.40836402773857117,
0.327574759721756,
-0.6412946581840515,
-0.6847981810569763,
0.2698736786842346,
0.008302758447825909,
0.3770768344402313,
0.3798806965351105,
0.4189159572124481,
-0.012652434408664703,
0.9545913934707642,
0.7417989373207092,
0.37929806113243103,
0.10841496288776398,
-0.6838215589523315,
0.029209889471530914,
-0.793790340423584,
-0.3714725375175476,
-0.5331398844718933,
0.0011588115012273192,
-0.30412641167640686,
-0.6068771481513977,
0.3969391882419586,
-0.23392944037914276,
0.023463033139705658,
0.47293075919151306,
-0.2253183126449585,
0.5936212539672852,
0.42580822110176086,
0.00869703572243452,
0.3995302617549896,
-0.006301903631538153,
-0.1422155797481537,
-0.041190072894096375,
-0.5547816753387451,
-0.7915116548538208,
1.2741142511367798,
0.28355854749679565,
0.28549158573150635,
-0.08111879229545593,
0.3911300301551819,
0.46763744950294495,
0.24012348055839539,
-0.8878982067108154,
0.7229679822921753,
-0.0010599895613268018,
-0.40808841586112976,
-0.414970338344574,
-0.41521766781806946,
-0.9075925946235657,
0.22122491896152496,
-0.14736519753932953,
-0.561069130897522,
0.2257308065891266,
-0.0170154832303524,
-0.7636786699295044,
0.06844450533390045,
-0.5252915620803833,
0.7966506481170654,
-0.2105312943458557,
-0.2957340478897095,
-0.3671734035015106,
-0.33474186062812805,
0.5684227347373962,
0.03976839408278465,
0.2779730558395386,
-0.375702440738678,
-0.012508728541433811,
0.5514208674430847,
0.028056470677256584,
0.7686916589736938,
-0.2779944837093353,
-0.17616862058639526,
0.338001012802124,
0.519672691822052,
0.36089810729026794,
0.028315860778093338,
0.054958414286375046,
0.11347337067127228,
0.0167867299169302,
-0.3513000011444092,
-0.5256191492080688,
0.7568593621253967,
-0.5968546867370605,
-0.5271573662757874,
-0.18510451912879944,
-0.7702121734619141,
-0.459201455116272,
0.22256062924861908,
0.04826229065656662,
0.4596949815750122,
-0.3535903990268707,
-0.17298267781734467,
0.5670218467712402,
-0.2735830545425415,
0.33743584156036377,
0.529069721698761,
-0.3014577329158783,
-0.1553380787372589,
0.7368910312652588,
0.026794107630848885,
0.18936939537525177,
0.29885444045066833,
-0.026770511642098427,
-0.5170773863792419,
-1.063504695892334,
-0.4076790511608124,
0.1694220006465912,
-0.7859338521957397,
0.04431361332535744,
-0.7717873454093933,
-0.27261877059936523,
-0.36537835001945496,
0.02952740155160427,
-0.30035534501075745,
-0.46321138739585876,
0.16215409338474274,
-0.1306878626346588,
0.047367289662361145,
1.1480984687805176,
0.20152971148490906,
0.35384631156921387,
-0.508983850479126,
0.3568408787250519,
0.20375984907150269,
0.038325484842061996,
-0.06367745250463486,
-0.28557273745536804,
-0.04678647220134735,
0.25108450651168823,
-0.12073356658220291,
-0.6949244737625122,
0.48046931624412537,
-0.02990540862083435,
0.5076805949211121,
0.4896118640899658,
0.2591001093387604,
0.5784967541694641,
-0.5860258936882019,
0.6268200278282166,
-0.2044995129108429,
-0.5742827653884888,
0.7188367247581482,
-0.6462140083312988,
0.09279527515172958,
0.5915013551712036,
0.7789629697799683,
-0.22898946702480316,
-0.4374350309371948,
-0.7004808187484741,
-0.7707019448280334,
0.5961853861808777,
0.624018669128418,
0.18678952753543854,
-0.005025307647883892,
0.5544543862342834,
0.32112109661102295,
0.489587664604187,
-0.8282791376113892,
-0.17023058235645294,
0.2720639109611511,
0.12962587177753448,
0.028761783614754677,
-0.44494083523750305,
-0.2760535776615143,
-0.24445359408855438,
0.5427569150924683,
-0.2032625377178192,
0.3594687879085541,
0.018875030800700188,
-0.27354881167411804,
-0.1556517779827118,
0.24106952548027039,
0.5927494168281555,
0.9077026844024658,
-0.253011018037796,
0.02483542449772358,
0.1207335814833641,
-0.2788405120372772,
-0.08305063843727112,
0.07672984153032303,
-0.4405782222747803,
-0.20088671147823334,
0.4298253059387207,
0.6876983046531677,
0.4489728510379791,
-0.8050257563591003,
0.4248330593109131,
-0.41365811228752136,
-0.2319728434085846,
-0.569254457950592,
0.3211591839790344,
-0.06523112952709198,
0.13637752830982208,
0.3404003381729126,
0.09452731162309647,
0.3771277666091919,
-0.4289177656173706,
-0.09875498712062836,
0.6001947522163391,
-0.45330652594566345,
-0.290754497051239,
0.35046669840812683,
0.10762500762939453,
-0.24960097670555115,
0.7296017408370972,
-0.5619285702705383,
-0.5781607031822205,
0.5325543284416199,
0.30925676226615906,
0.9394684433937073,
0.17344412207603455,
0.39903905987739563,
0.2604566812515259,
0.5422140955924988,
0.2337927222251892,
0.4092182517051697,
-0.3453501760959625,
-0.6282628774642944,
-0.7648149728775024,
-0.757552444934845,
-0.5256140828132629,
0.23290733993053436,
-0.3148139417171478,
0.07212555408477783,
-0.44636425375938416,
0.05392155423760414,
-0.4427075982093811,
-0.0184948593378067,
-0.7647316455841064,
0.09639815241098404,
0.1482779085636139,
0.8562557697296143,
-0.8743891716003418,
0.4919997453689575,
0.6758284568786621,
-0.3856355845928192,
-0.783412754535675,
0.33351820707321167,
-0.061751529574394226,
-0.8962100744247437,
0.5743547677993774,
0.2416527271270752,
-0.2515479028224945,
0.05759880319237709,
-0.4539391100406647,
-0.736396312713623,
0.7411441206932068,
0.502514123916626,
-0.4670667052268982,
-0.43971821665763855,
0.26725319027900696,
0.37608787417411804,
-0.20928271114826202,
0.3405810296535492,
0.893541693687439,
0.46466580033302307,
0.356864869594574,
-0.9385132789611816,
0.06876403093338013,
-0.16854247450828552,
-0.15445946156978607,
-0.07625222206115723,
-0.07689907401800156,
0.5973677635192871,
-0.40525785088539124,
-0.35102230310440063,
0.30765092372894287,
0.6127645373344421,
0.3130745589733124,
0.2003345638513565,
0.6618407368659973,
0.4463227391242981,
0.5297639966011047,
-0.19038046896457672,
1.2638946771621704,
-0.08559691905975342,
0.14886732399463654,
0.8770222067832947,
-0.14271143078804016,
0.8684414029121399,
0.19347257912158966,
-0.3116911053657532,
0.5989336967468262,
0.6757386326789856,
0.5394209623336792,
0.6706395745277405,
0.1349892020225525,
-0.1874808967113495,
-0.49035778641700745,
-0.1314016580581665,
-0.18500679731369019,
0.45024898648262024,
0.6980350613594055,
0.1473379284143448,
-0.2910824120044708,
-0.007614407688379288,
0.05716285482048988,
0.04954563453793526,
-0.4273145794868469,
0.661797046661377,
0.021755268797278404,
-0.9313569068908691,
0.49014338850975037,
-0.12512239813804626,
0.34325936436653137,
-0.6010715365409851,
-0.19837908446788788,
-0.12628984451293945,
0.06099753454327583,
-0.003263105871155858,
-0.8213443756103516,
0.3442772626876831,
0.023915603756904602,
0.17100921273231506,
-0.2579611837863922,
0.6263310313224792,
-0.29840078949928284,
-0.4695165753364563,
0.08573237806558609,
0.5951427221298218,
0.2401399314403534,
-0.4855222702026367,
-0.7944702506065369,
0.0010029723634943366,
-0.023760400712490082,
-0.08169087767601013,
0.11815112084150314,
0.3538146913051605,
-0.07221689820289612,
0.887425422668457,
0.8263890147209167,
0.34384986758232117,
0.05613941699266434,
0.04097789525985718,
0.8971859216690063,
-0.5899627208709717,
-0.5830225944519043,
-0.8358121514320374,
0.5972407460212708,
0.016151556745171547,
-0.10597290098667145,
0.7907687425613403,
0.7291035652160645,
0.6441343426704407,
-0.2613590359687805,
0.8118502497673035,
-0.04251781478524208,
0.32181626558303833,
-0.7613491415977478,
0.5024471282958984,
-0.31575649976730347,
0.26710739731788635,
-0.325088232755661,
-0.9213536977767944,
-0.1676570326089859,
0.6071256399154663,
-0.8921763300895691,
-0.02183057926595211,
0.657948911190033,
0.4714208245277405,
0.019177915528416634,
0.03873105347156525,
0.3894074261188507,
0.1687132716178894,
0.2726243734359741,
0.7379473447799683,
1.3004285097122192,
0.00901674572378397,
0.5554046034812927,
-0.46075186133384705,
-0.17171311378479004,
-0.19612769782543182,
-0.9659873247146606,
-1.0322058200836182,
-0.6233866214752197,
-0.3056013584136963,
-0.16576842963695526,
0.39673519134521484,
0.9559738636016846,
0.6612280011177063,
-0.7128711938858032,
-0.24307969212532043,
-0.3310146927833557,
0.39986076951026917,
-0.14460572600364685,
-0.19177258014678955,
0.41634508967399597,
-0.36345240473747253,
-0.819076418876648,
0.6417260766029358,
0.3520096242427826,
-0.027955513447523117,
-0.4259628355503082,
-0.14576968550682068,
-0.07441869378089905,
-0.16958406567573547,
0.5310795307159424,
0.38480210304260254,
-0.8697433471679688,
-0.15340131521224976,
0.053870461881160736,
0.08640981465578079,
-0.34948351979255676,
0.9453054070472717,
-0.8323337435722351,
0.07197873294353485,
0.0340157225728035,
0.4260759949684143,
0.21140363812446594,
-0.002719508484005928,
0.6870824694633484,
-0.7786535024642944,
0.004096291493624449,
0.44149842858314514,
0.4534097909927368,
0.20931148529052734,
-0.48049238324165344,
0.4111083149909973,
0.07818931341171265,
-0.4364193081855774,
-0.7198126912117004,
0.1287778615951538,
-0.7717498540878296,
-0.2729648947715759,
1.3923975229263306,
-0.16689537465572357,
-0.3359988331794739,
-0.2073623239994049,
-0.476288378238678,
0.09225522726774216,
-0.2935944199562073,
0.8317117094993591,
0.54598069190979,
-0.3110998868942261,
-0.0472618043422699,
-0.774682879447937,
0.7532504200935364,
0.3149660527706146,
-0.7470955848693848,
0.24618154764175415,
0.7850528359413147,
0.21307896077632904,
0.11113253235816956,
0.8589788675308228,
0.20536617934703827,
0.42504629492759705,
-0.21051815152168274,
-0.06996307522058487,
-0.2183607518672943,
-0.7852997779846191,
-0.18139956891536713,
0.1433977633714676,
0.3682895302772522,
-0.08514397591352463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03163v1
|
Design2Code: How Far Are We From Automating Front-End Engineering?
| 2024-03-05T17:56:27 | 2024-03-05T17:56:27 |
Chenglei Si, Yanzhe Zhang, Zhengyuan Yang, Ruibo Liu, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY
|
Generative AI has made rapid advancements in recent years, achieving
unprecedented capabilities in multimodal understanding and code generation.
This can enable a new paradigm of front-end development, in which multimodal
LLMs might directly convert visual designs into code implementations. In this
work, we formalize this as a Design2Code task and conduct comprehensive
benchmarking. Specifically, we manually curate a benchmark of 484 diverse
real-world webpages as test cases and develop a set of automatic evaluation
metrics to assess how well current multimodal LLMs can generate the code
implementations that directly render into the given reference webpages, given
the screenshots as input. We also complement automatic metrics with
comprehensive human evaluations. We develop a suite of multimodal prompting
methods and show their effectiveness on GPT-4V and Gemini Pro Vision. We
further finetune an open-source Design2Code-18B model that successfully matches
the performance of Gemini Pro Vision. Both human evaluation and automatic
metrics show that GPT-4V performs the best on this task compared to other
models. Moreover, annotators think GPT-4V generated webpages can replace the
original reference webpages in 49% of cases in terms of visual appearance and
content; and perhaps surprisingly, in 64% of cases GPT-4V generated webpages
are considered better than the original reference webpages. Our fine-grained
break-down metrics indicate that open-source models mostly lag in recalling
visual elements from the input webpages and in generating correct layout
designs, while aspects like text content and coloring can be drastically
improved with proper finetuning.
|
[
-0.6233751177787781,
-0.40511420369148254,
0.48001545667648315,
0.3245629668235779,
-0.2729944586753845,
-0.015053355135023594,
-0.108894482254982,
-0.5284639596939087,
-0.2963763475418091,
0.0010372115066275,
-0.6524335145950317,
-0.6035681962966919,
-0.2665935158729553,
0.22124016284942627,
-0.3318673074245453,
0.5488607287406921,
-0.2676451504230499,
-0.0616663359105587,
-0.5811651349067688,
0.08580440282821655,
-0.3163658380508423,
-0.11328203976154327,
-0.5354568958282471,
0.10509558022022247,
0.42289045453071594,
0.08034878224134445,
0.5083292722702026,
0.3691008985042572,
0.5370494723320007,
0.25742119550704956,
0.27954211831092834,
0.19068631529808044,
-0.2863628566265106,
-0.04151458293199539,
-0.14327286183834076,
-0.4912416338920593,
-0.3437079191207886,
0.24325914680957794,
0.19527597725391388,
0.17435121536254883,
0.13607311248779297,
0.2650599777698517,
0.16559608280658722,
0.71744304895401,
-0.6905282735824585,
0.4480113387107849,
-0.24431191384792328,
0.2941669225692749,
0.09005200117826462,
-0.14547376334667206,
-0.5527980923652649,
-0.3326924443244934,
-0.33764296770095825,
-0.8403766751289368,
0.33240440487861633,
0.1079956591129303,
0.7301090359687805,
0.5851937532424927,
-0.179857537150383,
-0.31840819120407104,
-0.4728192985057831,
0.6094852685928345,
-0.3779992163181305,
0.8170677423477173,
0.14674507081508636,
0.2915368974208832,
0.05516684800386429,
-0.8371225595474243,
-0.613582968711853,
-0.5191035270690918,
0.10248693823814392,
0.3819102644920349,
-0.5604486465454102,
0.004838010761886835,
0.3349864184856415,
0.310360312461853,
-0.7759979367256165,
0.2783525586128235,
-0.35889914631843567,
-0.2973489463329315,
0.6437410116195679,
0.09516799449920654,
0.392937034368515,
-0.22201676666736603,
-0.49090585112571716,
-0.29892000555992126,
-0.5999324917793274,
0.031403012573719025,
0.3882029354572296,
-0.2589389681816101,
-0.2668590843677521,
0.42697861790657043,
-0.291114866733551,
0.5294685959815979,
0.08473160117864609,
0.18777599930763245,
0.4064144790172577,
-0.6295139193534851,
-0.10194975137710571,
-0.6577481627464294,
0.8989417552947998,
0.919560968875885,
0.4444388747215271,
-0.29011082649230957,
-0.4076254069805145,
0.5021296143531799,
0.7454438209533691,
-0.6850730776786804,
-0.4965316653251648,
0.2874203026294708,
-0.631497323513031,
-0.20933912694454193,
-0.06830228865146637,
-0.8348268270492554,
-0.2308320254087448,
-0.48428067564964294,
0.4963873326778412,
-0.18279004096984863,
-0.15198323130607605,
-0.309739887714386,
-0.4117051959037781,
0.34262019395828247,
0.4445871114730835,
-0.6390150785446167,
-0.028469327837228775,
0.5495572686195374,
0.7979293465614319,
-0.38555213809013367,
-0.20090322196483612,
-0.18213653564453125,
-0.2460668534040451,
-0.7395569086074829,
0.7899916172027588,
-0.10307491570711136,
-0.4330889582633972,
-0.019067781046032906,
-0.3863224387168884,
0.3457764685153961,
-0.6496091485023499,
0.18818911910057068,
-0.4272698163986206,
0.070592001080513,
-0.02327532321214676,
-0.14078909158706665,
-0.0584263876080513,
0.36123818159103394,
-0.7117817997932434,
0.7209018468856812,
0.30400410294532776,
-0.5541054606437683,
0.5443848967552185,
-0.6090527176856995,
-0.36197978258132935,
-0.020323345437645912,
-0.5486907958984375,
-0.5623052716255188,
0.3507381081581116,
0.21166281402111053,
0.10904248058795929,
-0.38026440143585205,
-0.1665356457233429,
-0.23108713328838348,
-0.3340494930744171,
0.13632577657699585,
-0.5027194619178772,
0.45054882764816284,
0.48361778259277344,
-0.4843604266643524,
0.29271700978279114,
-0.8210412263870239,
0.26058855652809143,
0.13928455114364624,
-0.4424684941768646,
0.11502192169427872,
-0.15053437650203705,
0.214542418718338,
0.3951301574707031,
0.029344547539949417,
-0.47540590167045593,
0.18783773481845856,
-0.232019305229187,
0.45896488428115845,
0.8127473592758179,
-0.20878620445728302,
0.49172094464302063,
-0.2072814404964447,
0.7262095808982849,
-0.1211320012807846,
0.47027209401130676,
-0.25204795598983765,
-0.7455898523330688,
-0.8761732578277588,
-0.08891081809997559,
-0.005437532905489206,
0.46426936984062195,
-1.0651682615280151,
0.049527768045663834,
-0.05556938797235489,
-0.2096170037984848,
-0.2662190794944763,
0.29148104786872864,
0.6781794428825378,
0.22601671516895294,
0.3459997773170471,
-0.8326067924499512,
-0.36687546968460083,
-1.040541648864746,
-0.090519979596138,
-0.22375614941120148,
-0.2828496992588043,
0.3394286632537842,
0.4684973657131195,
-0.45015984773635864,
0.9674020409584045,
-0.34263283014297485,
-0.04393389821052551,
0.018832378089427948,
0.3754194974899292,
-0.116510771214962,
0.33755022287368774,
0.6547532677650452,
-0.7153269052505493,
-0.3224782347679138,
-0.07305295765399933,
-1.1226884126663208,
-0.17266301810741425,
-0.07693040370941162,
-0.04856209456920624,
0.2875043749809265,
0.2894826829433441,
-0.5926861763000488,
0.7370635867118835,
0.34855660796165466,
-0.10565867274999619,
0.6455596685409546,
-0.26136553287506104,
0.16629548370838165,
-0.706298828125,
0.1323019117116928,
0.22808854281902313,
0.08398435264825821,
-0.3478119373321533,
0.4323332905769348,
0.433002233505249,
-0.35485222935676575,
-0.5272886157035828,
0.5797041654586792,
-0.7321629524230957,
-0.5614171624183655,
-0.17852148413658142,
-0.11835242062807083,
0.28883349895477295,
0.5982152819633484,
-0.262386679649353,
1.1125258207321167,
0.17267514765262604,
-0.5672088861465454,
0.7099847197532654,
0.27795088291168213,
-0.34688031673431396,
0.5786389112472534,
-0.662421703338623,
0.28208574652671814,
-0.1929805725812912,
0.3386164605617523,
-1.1446073055267334,
-0.2283267229795456,
0.4241020381450653,
-0.45129281282424927,
0.10458888858556747,
-0.05201511085033417,
-0.6131801009178162,
-0.8177492022514343,
-0.4703674614429474,
0.34413042664527893,
0.7683589458465576,
-0.500373125076294,
0.4362921118736267,
-0.10181541740894318,
-0.07976983487606049,
-0.2172224372625351,
-0.6598308682441711,
0.31879621744155884,
0.05059415102005005,
-0.8702138066291809,
0.44912973046302795,
-0.2850881814956665,
-0.3759326636791229,
-0.15334740281105042,
-0.07607158273458481,
0.078242227435112,
0.031566303223371506,
0.37765613198280334,
0.24237070977687836,
-0.15227271616458893,
-0.07418149709701538,
-0.15029887855052948,
-0.34014102816581726,
0.15404246747493744,
-0.3401213586330414,
0.3501993417739868,
0.02041497454047203,
-0.6555867791175842,
-1.0542387962341309,
0.2693968117237091,
0.5614830851554871,
-0.412555456161499,
-0.16374263167381287,
0.7822510004043579,
-0.1817125529050827,
-0.1738649308681488,
-0.5263699889183044,
-0.06958648562431335,
-0.4593330919742584,
0.30826234817504883,
-0.6108731031417847,
-0.37413135170936584,
0.2027358114719391,
0.05065212398767471,
0.2810102701187134,
0.42171791195869446,
0.7057714462280273,
-0.23222662508487701,
0.9431229829788208,
0.676537811756134,
0.2938212752342224,
0.5610283017158508,
-0.361686110496521,
0.01663428358733654,
-0.6417272686958313,
-0.35476112365722656,
-0.15154586732387543,
-0.3529835045337677,
-0.573423445224762,
-0.6027957797050476,
0.6304445862770081,
-0.014876888133585453,
-0.04611814394593239,
0.2365979105234146,
-0.5719735622406006,
0.15564489364624023,
0.758538544178009,
0.2538289725780487,
0.14835792779922485,
0.14383594691753387,
-0.1663082093000412,
0.005743179004639387,
-0.5502824783325195,
-0.24508769810199738,
1.0929516553878784,
0.3791097104549408,
0.952434778213501,
0.19384193420410156,
0.6007747650146484,
0.6131506562232971,
0.4500129222869873,
-0.6949880123138428,
0.31320422887802124,
-0.17572177946567535,
-0.3168710172176361,
0.0996975526213646,
-0.20783454179763794,
-0.6727415323257446,
0.025964973494410515,
-0.09399980306625366,
-0.18506914377212524,
0.10538291186094284,
0.36106255650520325,
-0.6346181035041809,
-0.1961609423160553,
-0.8710167407989502,
0.9105079770088196,
-0.5668229460716248,
-0.887539267539978,
-0.3048880100250244,
-0.5203861594200134,
0.24288935959339142,
0.05654605105519295,
0.24651683866977692,
0.07177521288394928,
0.03824695199728012,
0.5593550801277161,
-0.2088364064693451,
0.7718729376792908,
-0.17511720955371857,
-0.342524915933609,
0.3749638795852661,
-0.041630420833826065,
0.30534330010414124,
0.039446186274290085,
0.13719886541366577,
0.03380785509943962,
-0.3458593189716339,
-0.25258690118789673,
-0.6233445405960083,
0.527870237827301,
-0.8857235908508301,
-0.4341752529144287,
-0.2507529854774475,
-0.16174209117889404,
-0.12221016734838486,
-0.06700064986944199,
0.4086276888847351,
0.6341487169265747,
-0.11390355974435806,
-0.09198399633169174,
0.4414336681365967,
-0.6064522862434387,
0.5700607299804688,
0.19516953825950623,
-0.15410418808460236,
-0.4617498815059662,
0.8195050954818726,
-0.3348535895347595,
0.16434705257415771,
0.3395799696445465,
-0.16206960380077362,
-0.4943421483039856,
-0.6090518236160278,
-1.2182867527008057,
-0.1665990799665451,
-0.8561603426933289,
-0.2017509490251541,
-0.4163373112678528,
-0.13515597581863403,
-0.4723456799983978,
-0.0949362963438034,
-0.4262773394584656,
-0.16670019924640656,
-0.2296973615884781,
0.10917683690786362,
0.062000349164009094,
1.0730979442596436,
-0.17607668042182922,
-0.035909753292798996,
-0.5970786809921265,
0.5675053596496582,
0.521401047706604,
0.38865530490875244,
-0.1250300407409668,
-0.16460071504116058,
-0.030522115528583527,
-0.18621087074279785,
-0.5860592722892761,
-0.5563499331474304,
0.12670378386974335,
-0.010597352869808674,
0.698325514793396,
0.3183801770210266,
-0.2817177474498749,
0.5321546792984009,
-0.5110464692115784,
0.9530177116394043,
0.5215792059898376,
-0.6040502786636353,
0.5790573358535767,
-0.1655573546886444,
0.4726268947124481,
0.37550050020217896,
0.25404295325279236,
-0.36521685123443604,
0.03933399170637131,
-0.3345955014228821,
-0.710407018661499,
0.36427345871925354,
0.28139951825141907,
0.0989479273557663,
0.02897266298532486,
0.32356390357017517,
0.13150271773338318,
0.15730997920036316,
-0.3438112139701843,
0.05660059303045273,
-0.6317498683929443,
-0.35097044706344604,
0.01400936022400856,
-0.15725000202655792,
-0.04934077709913254,
0.05024143308401108,
0.10273858159780502,
-0.26974526047706604,
0.7615956664085388,
-0.11885351687669754,
-0.28874748945236206,
0.1653011590242386,
-0.03510850667953491,
0.8005263209342957,
1.0133793354034424,
0.22201815247535706,
0.011835119687020779,
-0.14536087214946747,
-0.16489727795124054,
0.14291934669017792,
0.21808691322803497,
-0.17673389613628387,
-0.14984442293643951,
0.4049701988697052,
0.823796272277832,
0.21811644732952118,
-0.5491544604301453,
0.7317893505096436,
-0.165771484375,
-0.21105420589447021,
-0.4898674190044403,
0.1842748075723648,
-0.27146416902542114,
0.3121761977672577,
0.31678467988967896,
0.14879246056079865,
0.22324924170970917,
-0.5363282561302185,
0.4302542209625244,
0.38546106219291687,
-0.20891234278678894,
-0.5911593437194824,
1.22590172290802,
0.7988969087600708,
-0.3415403664112091,
0.8508241772651672,
-0.29268720746040344,
-0.35895785689353943,
0.6699640154838562,
0.28614509105682373,
0.8192806243896484,
0.22237472236156464,
0.04266809672117233,
0.5022065043449402,
-0.009733414277434349,
0.25397223234176636,
0.29350629448890686,
-0.35318538546562195,
-0.4215150475502014,
-0.3578110933303833,
-0.782503068447113,
-0.31298768520355225,
-0.1765209585428238,
-0.5414604544639587,
0.21655073761940002,
-0.658524215221405,
-0.17920975387096405,
0.022467447444796562,
-0.24160920083522797,
-0.9333797097206116,
0.4120025336742401,
0.5427631735801697,
0.8249730467796326,
-0.5435867309570312,
0.46622055768966675,
0.6838411092758179,
-0.7483170628547668,
-0.14447025954723358,
-0.07307934015989304,
0.4567185044288635,
-0.9269726872444153,
0.7097538709640503,
0.30423447489738464,
-0.039752308279275894,
0.12425962090492249,
-0.405480295419693,
-0.4402132034301758,
1.1311553716659546,
-0.20193390548229218,
-0.8026885390281677,
-0.31562894582748413,
-0.052170783281326294,
0.35003069043159485,
-0.03433768078684807,
0.4319590926170349,
0.12164881825447083,
0.47140443325042725,
-0.12181778252124786,
-1.0417962074279785,
-0.08665712922811508,
-0.5185110569000244,
0.3320119082927704,
0.04036915302276611,
-0.7433655858039856,
0.7810512781143188,
-0.3197575509548187,
-0.21898253262043,
0.4347805380821228,
0.5784197449684143,
0.10747591406106949,
0.416663259267807,
0.3740777373313904,
0.6893364787101746,
0.26090729236602783,
-0.1319705992937088,
1.101775050163269,
-0.4670950770378113,
0.16872189939022064,
0.6025810837745667,
-0.027416067197918892,
0.6608445644378662,
0.4402849078178406,
-0.40518563985824585,
0.23973943293094635,
0.5953429937362671,
-0.24851810932159424,
0.6149018406867981,
0.37421903014183044,
-0.16929806768894196,
-0.03752496466040611,
0.26138836145401,
-0.39915722608566284,
0.5721989274024963,
0.17593717575073242,
-0.4773915112018585,
-0.1649397313594818,
0.23826508224010468,
-0.16755661368370056,
-0.029198160395026207,
-0.09857699275016785,
0.8328755497932434,
0.09049555659294128,
-0.9110335111618042,
0.5889022350311279,
0.27301284670829773,
0.8422017693519592,
-0.3632529079914093,
-0.034161560237407684,
-0.5781587958335876,
0.49444228410720825,
-0.14651888608932495,
-0.8887726068496704,
0.2924005687236786,
0.05710906162858009,
-0.15649940073490143,
-0.609038233757019,
0.37119317054748535,
0.11137370020151138,
-0.31761834025382996,
0.13279497623443604,
0.5413088798522949,
0.13813069462776184,
-0.11992640793323517,
-0.6102077960968018,
0.4261314868927002,
0.16786102950572968,
0.06394927948713303,
0.25083085894584656,
0.14291661977767944,
-0.2264583855867386,
0.6557949781417847,
0.7076616883277893,
-0.44198891520500183,
0.17575067281723022,
0.3609335422515869,
0.9096291065216064,
-0.604939341545105,
-0.4347032308578491,
-0.7213391065597534,
0.49149349331855774,
0.021573442965745926,
-0.4427991807460785,
0.6050662398338318,
0.6315662264823914,
0.9251729846000671,
-0.22077368199825287,
0.9630140662193298,
-0.09253326803445816,
-0.18183757364749908,
-0.566109836101532,
0.6959330439567566,
-0.60122150182724,
-0.09919121861457825,
-0.09455100446939468,
-0.9331380724906921,
-0.30025342106819153,
0.6415749192237854,
-0.020440446212887764,
0.05342775583267212,
0.40009447932243347,
0.7831504344940186,
-0.14468064904212952,
-0.09435246139764786,
0.251211017370224,
-0.12610286474227905,
0.5234142541885376,
0.6754516363143921,
1.0372904539108276,
-0.32944604754447937,
0.695198655128479,
-0.2831170856952667,
-0.46041396260261536,
-0.2972011864185333,
-0.527647852897644,
-0.7321704030036926,
-0.45132976770401,
-0.34806105494499207,
-0.13799092173576355,
0.3148510456085205,
0.6457613706588745,
0.8691498637199402,
-0.49110281467437744,
0.05159394443035126,
-0.2129254937171936,
-0.4081195592880249,
-0.19044643640518188,
-0.17516809701919556,
-0.03378433734178543,
-0.2865939736366272,
-0.6368099451065063,
0.3245908319950104,
0.3552398681640625,
0.11482291668653488,
-0.6496415138244629,
-0.17324909567832947,
0.2936052978038788,
-0.3640214800834656,
0.9419154524803162,
0.12965504825115204,
-0.9716765880584717,
-0.3204515874385834,
0.05292095988988876,
-0.19234906136989594,
0.34954193234443665,
0.6164045333862305,
-0.8267563581466675,
0.6152570843696594,
0.5617039203643799,
0.4975438714027405,
0.41932955384254456,
0.25523680448532104,
0.5872411131858826,
-0.5519829392433167,
0.007676638197153807,
-0.05942452326416969,
0.11182049661874771,
0.4763305187225342,
0.06218741461634636,
0.5962854027748108,
0.43911340832710266,
-0.3100135624408722,
-0.2854989469051361,
0.415296733379364,
-0.7400584816932678,
-0.12408877909183502,
1.1502084732055664,
-0.16188384592533112,
-0.08623837679624557,
0.08321645110845566,
-0.17636071145534515,
0.14316394925117493,
-0.201751708984375,
0.6970430612564087,
0.3363637626171112,
-0.4984302818775177,
-0.4013907313346863,
-0.8597677946090698,
0.4096826910972595,
0.10214996337890625,
-0.8888713121414185,
-0.337113618850708,
0.7357932925224304,
0.4282527565956116,
0.260872483253479,
0.5451096296310425,
-0.0828176960349083,
0.6732155680656433,
0.3619794547557831,
0.41088157892227173,
-0.24315626919269562,
-0.40739816427230835,
-0.12530358135700226,
0.21502645313739777,
0.10587060451507568,
-0.4093961715698242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03141v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03141v1
|
Language Guided Exploration for RL Agents in Text Environments
| 2024-03-05T17:26:41 | 2024-03-05T17:26:41 |
Hitesh Golchha, Sahil Yerawar, Dhruvesh Patel, Soham Dan, Keerthiram Murugesan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Real-world sequential decision making is characterized by sparse rewards and
large decision spaces, posing significant difficulty for experiential learning
systems like $\textit{tabula rasa}$ reinforcement learning (RL) agents. Large
Language Models (LLMs), with a wealth of world knowledge, can help RL agents
learn quickly and adapt to distribution shifts. In this work, we introduce
Language Guided Exploration (LGE) framework, which uses a pre-trained language
model (called GUIDE ) to provide decision-level guidance to an RL agent (called
EXPLORER). We observe that on ScienceWorld (Wang et al.,2022), a challenging
text environment, LGE outperforms vanilla RL agents significantly and also
outperforms other sophisticated methods like Behaviour Cloning and Text
Decision Transformer.
|
[
-0.17025117576122284,
-0.8487768173217773,
0.8365787267684937,
0.3241848945617676,
0.07137136906385422,
0.3902563154697418,
-0.3499397337436676,
-0.5001354813575745,
0.06663186848163605,
0.46599698066711426,
-0.9806570410728455,
-0.6633449196815491,
-0.392165869474411,
0.1757400929927826,
-0.01635306514799595,
1.04547119140625,
-0.19778931140899658,
-0.21860554814338684,
-0.0952390655875206,
-0.062394410371780396,
-0.5406436920166016,
-0.20095497369766235,
-0.8484624028205872,
-0.6146378517150879,
0.84889817237854,
0.3869647681713104,
0.7868232131004333,
0.4254775643348694,
0.2994038462638855,
0.3003568947315216,
-0.32763609290122986,
0.44963181018829346,
-0.44781970977783203,
0.4946906566619873,
-0.45770490169525146,
-0.44794711470603943,
-0.2345338761806488,
-0.08443925529718399,
0.5627660155296326,
0.445259690284729,
-0.2701702117919922,
-0.07211947441101074,
-0.0811888799071312,
0.6449520587921143,
-0.2917276620864868,
0.5389618277549744,
-0.13147149980068207,
0.514516294002533,
0.16150349378585815,
-0.3631683886051178,
-0.6664201617240906,
-0.19572804868221283,
0.6998488903045654,
-1.170885443687439,
-0.009173000231385231,
0.39940041303634644,
0.566335916519165,
0.3726203143596649,
-0.3612845540046692,
-0.47099465131759644,
-0.786369800567627,
0.8445965647697449,
-0.1655002385377884,
0.39407041668891907,
0.12835054099559784,
0.48447781801223755,
-0.44392624497413635,
-0.9270465970039368,
-0.43086421489715576,
-0.31877368688583374,
-0.16420044004917145,
0.03803985193371773,
0.10389496386051178,
0.13345186412334442,
0.2509134113788605,
-0.27499324083328247,
-0.6399461030960083,
0.2352839857339859,
-0.13902334868907928,
-0.16986040771007538,
0.5192558169364929,
0.13642951846122742,
0.31397539377212524,
0.08497245609760284,
-0.3032122254371643,
-0.6043498516082764,
-0.7514848113059998,
0.2901698350906372,
0.05371274799108505,
0.3153451681137085,
0.12763386964797974,
0.16097015142440796,
-0.14093010127544403,
0.8616175055503845,
-0.22477498650550842,
-0.28254351019859314,
0.18249040842056274,
0.03698539361357689,
-0.10238932818174362,
0.0559266097843647,
0.49849364161491394,
0.1763918101787567,
0.4108928442001343,
-0.029039477929472923,
-0.4517132341861725,
-0.40005868673324585,
0.1966896951198578,
-0.7347537279129028,
-0.17286071181297302,
-0.12728062272071838,
-0.44959211349487305,
-0.26962172985076904,
-0.2607148587703705,
-0.8613837957382202,
-0.7067409157752991,
0.047688622027635574,
0.4291817545890808,
-0.24340038001537323,
-0.3320181965827942,
0.2156025916337967,
-0.11588291823863983,
0.3891022801399231,
0.6152468323707581,
-0.6920242309570312,
0.1071840226650238,
0.5308311581611633,
0.8265040516853333,
-0.2395029515028,
-0.5080714225769043,
-0.7417472004890442,
-0.03694768622517586,
-0.3149174153804779,
1.0362155437469482,
-0.7353628277778625,
-0.774164617061615,
0.19268415868282318,
0.08378135412931442,
-0.04102551192045212,
-0.3677583932876587,
0.4954807460308075,
-0.869787871837616,
0.2586402893066406,
-0.19138990342617035,
-0.3251751661300659,
-0.339384526014328,
0.4350548982620239,
-0.6249163150787354,
1.0909909009933472,
0.03896095231175423,
-0.391758531332016,
0.5442478656768799,
-0.901211678981781,
-0.21587802469730377,
0.15280362963676453,
-0.2858881950378418,
-0.20684714615345,
-0.31507638096809387,
0.35584402084350586,
0.23520389199256897,
0.08197861164808273,
0.20653687417507172,
0.14371417462825775,
-0.4162597954273224,
0.1744185835123062,
-0.24370886385440826,
0.23336558043956757,
0.28173965215682983,
-0.37887781858444214,
0.46703359484672546,
-0.5559172034263611,
0.09498237818479538,
0.2536315321922302,
-0.4453103244304657,
-0.5582742691040039,
0.38907042145729065,
-0.006068181712180376,
0.12462219595909119,
0.22115790843963623,
-0.26870298385620117,
0.7310222387313843,
-0.31422159075737,
0.012280703522264957,
1.004506230354309,
0.1972658783197403,
0.5850691795349121,
-0.10535039007663727,
0.9865769743919373,
-0.22482022643089294,
0.07370314002037048,
-0.3455287218093872,
-0.47630128264427185,
-0.6578441858291626,
-0.043469712138175964,
0.34548047184944153,
0.7339003682136536,
-0.9505738019943237,
0.22216321527957916,
-0.21757733821868896,
-0.2608322203159332,
-0.3672480285167694,
-0.0882517620921135,
0.31502702832221985,
0.106504887342453,
0.31090790033340454,
0.23554261028766632,
-0.33501899242401123,
-0.6222976446151733,
-0.36940842866897583,
-0.05850546807050705,
0.2562354803085327,
0.611089289188385,
0.4387695789337158,
-0.6190919280052185,
0.9083245396614075,
-0.6474679708480835,
-0.28555458784103394,
-0.7003649473190308,
0.10154392570257187,
0.24329058825969696,
0.25473782420158386,
0.21869643032550812,
-0.7768924832344055,
-0.6270241141319275,
0.172831192612648,
-0.8453238010406494,
-0.10469396412372589,
-0.34768906235694885,
-0.13829270005226135,
0.1902889460325241,
0.7426127195358276,
-0.39724940061569214,
0.3727157413959503,
0.40311989188194275,
-0.5953829288482666,
0.3218570947647095,
-0.6065137982368469,
-0.07329116761684418,
-0.5531187057495117,
-0.22975267469882965,
0.06607034057378769,
-0.5202402472496033,
-0.5886337757110596,
0.3882293403148651,
-0.02039049006998539,
-0.01521738525480032,
-0.26482710242271423,
0.9671359062194824,
-0.6123504042625427,
-0.07408645749092102,
-0.37527257204055786,
0.5065251588821411,
-0.24387918412685394,
0.5578464269638062,
0.536051869392395,
0.9239538311958313,
0.6637769937515259,
-0.6930077075958252,
0.15616920590400696,
0.2812498211860657,
-0.4632495045661926,
0.07811706513166428,
-0.5004838109016418,
0.18553155660629272,
-0.3377429246902466,
0.5900928378105164,
-0.5190250277519226,
0.24364446103572845,
0.1738331913948059,
-0.1467091143131256,
0.1933508962392807,
0.1897650808095932,
-0.3336527347564697,
-0.08295918256044388,
-0.2623279392719269,
0.44431057572364807,
0.5812864899635315,
-0.7948610186576843,
0.7166867256164551,
0.000027642236091196537,
-0.2138686180114746,
-0.9692779779434204,
-0.35481300950050354,
0.05679526925086975,
-0.09834723174571991,
-0.3416050374507904,
0.12429258972406387,
-0.3013693392276764,
-0.39889776706695557,
-0.015826985239982605,
-0.01317003183066845,
0.4548470377922058,
0.011950865387916565,
0.1296718716621399,
0.06824157387018204,
-0.029164232313632965,
0.21389320492744446,
-0.1857360303401947,
-0.1898292899131775,
0.12177615612745285,
-0.3353649377822876,
0.4929123818874359,
-0.09781408309936523,
-0.2705238461494446,
0.11486531049013138,
0.2265889048576355,
0.17758364975452423,
-0.10887269675731659,
0.6237784028053284,
0.4296833276748657,
-0.05791251361370087,
-0.7680829167366028,
-0.11219906061887741,
0.008181260898709297,
-0.5331403613090515,
0.7004759907722473,
-0.37552186846733093,
-0.8492596745491028,
0.5020482540130615,
-0.3195643424987793,
0.2198687493801117,
0.2657284140586853,
0.12167896330356598,
0.12233024835586548,
1.1299328804016113,
1.002493143081665,
-0.026556052267551422,
0.5883221626281738,
-0.35157307982444763,
0.192974254488945,
-0.48505035042762756,
-0.5039004683494568,
-0.3339785933494568,
-0.37101083993911743,
-0.6639664173126221,
-0.5726224780082703,
0.5990756154060364,
-0.22493113577365875,
-0.023843109607696533,
-0.14073531329631805,
-0.43344128131866455,
0.7106056213378906,
0.5508434772491455,
0.11367061734199524,
0.2951398491859436,
-0.014718716032803059,
-0.28586769104003906,
-0.06884648650884628,
-0.80368572473526,
-0.41801053285598755,
0.9310796856880188,
0.4218144416809082,
0.9575738906860352,
0.12954455614089966,
0.8297279477119446,
0.6128668189048767,
0.35991883277893066,
-0.7919241786003113,
0.8082675337791443,
0.39637845754623413,
-0.16793504357337952,
-0.5249560475349426,
-0.21785080432891846,
-1.039178729057312,
0.3997762203216553,
-0.2859368920326233,
-0.5089795589447021,
0.09405341744422913,
-0.05197053402662277,
-0.3514999747276306,
0.16396786272525787,
-0.5364808440208435,
0.7172158360481262,
-0.3569127023220062,
-0.36170125007629395,
-0.3900744915008545,
-0.48708033561706543,
0.06604956835508347,
-0.08221309632062912,
0.4604702293872833,
0.4727573096752167,
-0.23968933522701263,
0.8299046754837036,
-0.11836662143468857,
0.663087010383606,
-0.5607494711875916,
-0.3550456464290619,
0.22737720608711243,
0.2807784378528595,
1.0306223630905151,
-0.03003876470029354,
0.13927626609802246,
-0.4751353859901428,
-0.22560648620128632,
-0.1346621811389923,
-0.7162095308303833,
0.6585121154785156,
-0.7695938944816589,
-0.764320433139801,
-0.8587024807929993,
-0.5076991319656372,
-0.23592723906040192,
0.11436286568641663,
-0.0899481549859047,
0.21186190843582153,
-0.38131919503211975,
-0.1330873668193817,
1.1989586353302002,
-0.7895669937133789,
0.48257845640182495,
0.9499340653419495,
-0.8108968138694763,
0.07400867342948914,
0.934953510761261,
-0.18636633455753326,
0.081731416285038,
0.5259301066398621,
0.19803299009799957,
-0.4699971675872803,
-0.7376799583435059,
-0.4032786786556244,
0.03368375450372696,
-0.8850305080413818,
0.05655485391616821,
-0.636635959148407,
-0.172748401761055,
-0.018840009346604347,
-0.2790985107421875,
0.06281711906194687,
0.00796973891556263,
-0.06910542398691177,
-0.3233785629272461,
0.42040321230888367,
1.2183160781860352,
-0.0945693701505661,
0.4611143469810486,
-0.7041430473327637,
0.10238446295261383,
0.3547879159450531,
0.2849694788455963,
-0.12074991315603256,
-0.4105512797832489,
-0.38784390687942505,
-0.233109712600708,
0.0632006824016571,
-0.8212065696716309,
0.5184987783432007,
0.16124217212200165,
0.8469377160072327,
0.1747349500656128,
-0.14127814769744873,
0.4794270992279053,
-0.47088193893432617,
0.7753002047538757,
-0.35827022790908813,
-0.4912257790565491,
0.5831239819526672,
-0.37128281593322754,
0.4336145520210266,
0.32872042059898376,
0.15619328618049622,
-0.7804369330406189,
-0.22625088691711426,
-0.49733734130859375,
-0.8133570551872253,
0.8751786947250366,
-0.3030063807964325,
-0.2937329113483429,
0.2665810286998749,
0.39192548394203186,
0.1647711843252182,
-0.008335993625223637,
-1.2788017988204956,
-0.3082548677921295,
0.10370205342769623,
0.010136744007468224,
-0.3552895784378052,
-0.10743248462677002,
0.03365262225270271,
0.030405178666114807,
0.836102306842804,
-0.22451622784137726,
0.21408464014530182,
0.3916793465614319,
-0.4297294318675995,
-0.12977689504623413,
0.30179622769355774,
0.7378928661346436,
0.42495083808898926,
-0.3008672297000885,
-0.09651540219783783,
0.1363140493631363,
-0.3948219418525696,
0.21485969424247742,
0.1783258020877838,
-0.22685539722442627,
-0.21152539551258087,
0.5002003312110901,
0.8522103428840637,
0.022286539897322655,
-1.209733009338379,
0.3525068163871765,
-0.4119724631309509,
-0.1766195148229599,
-0.45566698908805847,
0.262754887342453,
-0.19720765948295593,
0.5233702063560486,
0.5942950248718262,
-0.09471204876899719,
0.052209582179784775,
-0.5087593793869019,
0.01829439587891102,
0.42962923645973206,
-0.3610440492630005,
0.06636574864387512,
0.2834891378879547,
0.2831386625766754,
-0.677344024181366,
0.3782285153865814,
-0.6055251955986023,
-0.7029986381530762,
0.49862366914749146,
0.45678406953811646,
0.890773594379425,
-0.0014510095352306962,
0.3407304584980011,
0.23341460525989532,
0.495930552482605,
-0.3371473252773285,
0.15493659675121307,
-0.23290802538394928,
-0.622998058795929,
-0.6120744943618774,
-0.4407427906990051,
-0.552281379699707,
0.04040072485804558,
-0.23761749267578125,
0.13298620283603668,
-0.36476820707321167,
0.34377387166023254,
-0.5417430400848389,
0.10285570472478867,
-0.7167232036590576,
0.0941040962934494,
0.14156752824783325,
1.294281005859375,
-0.7357380390167236,
0.8308978080749512,
0.8847277760505676,
-0.017944924533367157,
-0.8377552628517151,
0.11329352855682373,
-0.25933438539505005,
-0.9311605095863342,
0.9130082726478577,
0.12450256198644638,
-0.5229255557060242,
0.05624664947390556,
-0.600020706653595,
-0.788728654384613,
1.1830767393112183,
-0.22555077075958252,
-0.6167802214622498,
-0.17645706236362457,
-0.1344677060842514,
0.7097414135932922,
-0.3885135352611542,
0.38620907068252563,
0.4598124325275421,
0.6567192077636719,
-0.1910354197025299,
-0.7377753853797913,
-0.020892135798931122,
-0.17330004274845123,
-0.24576014280319214,
0.20418094098567963,
-0.6211991310119629,
0.47737857699394226,
-0.41459351778030396,
-0.20572905242443085,
-0.005372592713683844,
0.8530382513999939,
0.5082401633262634,
0.3598543703556061,
0.86688232421875,
0.19877667725086212,
0.7633205652236938,
0.03388351574540138,
0.9943259358406067,
-0.05950947478413582,
0.22872406244277954,
0.7449368238449097,
-0.3689901828765869,
0.654567539691925,
0.20812305808067322,
-0.06124604120850563,
0.9777889847755432,
0.8317825198173523,
0.4196114242076874,
0.7851856350898743,
0.2642396092414856,
-0.35872557759284973,
-0.28237253427505493,
0.008337529376149178,
-0.31880614161491394,
0.20895956456661224,
0.6121413111686707,
-0.2087208777666092,
-0.2741166651248932,
0.21157655119895935,
-0.1451861560344696,
0.35059303045272827,
-0.4166393280029297,
0.8261861801147461,
-0.2746833562850952,
-1.0861924886703491,
0.2995016574859619,
0.04129486531019211,
0.8383867740631104,
-0.9748616218566895,
-0.44373857975006104,
-0.30785080790519714,
0.2730870246887207,
0.06331774592399597,
-0.8494387865066528,
-0.2129964828491211,
-0.13992996513843536,
0.05737582966685295,
-0.7206379175186157,
0.8254832625389099,
-0.40947505831718445,
-0.21159759163856506,
0.5207896828651428,
0.767039954662323,
0.07158224284648895,
0.22207002341747284,
-0.69426029920578,
-0.0810837522149086,
0.29043692350387573,
-0.794771671295166,
0.46806541085243225,
0.5104101300239563,
-0.14093580842018127,
1.1754212379455566,
0.40724724531173706,
0.15203668177127838,
-0.08271949738264084,
-0.08057677745819092,
0.6430048942565918,
-1.0374566316604614,
-0.8703967928886414,
-0.5716122388839722,
0.14513157308101654,
-0.025876205414533615,
0.0016082118963822722,
0.6059145927429199,
0.3504977822303772,
0.5839885473251343,
-0.04436992481350899,
0.8902508616447449,
-0.018946120515465736,
0.5522958636283875,
-0.735492467880249,
0.30751800537109375,
-0.44749799370765686,
0.37754711508750916,
-0.13642652332782745,
-0.8075758218765259,
-0.12115094065666199,
0.9093497395515442,
-0.16257202625274658,
0.12705937027931213,
0.7951357364654541,
0.9042522311210632,
0.11675598472356796,
-0.08739442378282547,
0.14390026032924652,
0.15574505925178528,
0.6416598558425903,
0.633600652217865,
1.1564689874649048,
0.07349048554897308,
0.4903530478477478,
0.21080033481121063,
-0.3368562161922455,
-0.020686186850070953,
-1.132891297340393,
-0.929205596446991,
-0.45530909299850464,
-0.07617788761854172,
-0.2722768187522888,
0.23956328630447388,
1.261866807937622,
0.5436308979988098,
-0.3206693232059479,
-0.22341226041316986,
-0.15774287283420563,
0.36089828610420227,
-0.37213796377182007,
-0.2489151805639267,
0.3600139021873474,
-0.3597291111946106,
-0.8258603811264038,
0.9713075160980225,
0.15420067310333252,
0.023139793425798416,
-0.738738477230072,
-0.5287070274353027,
-0.24212349951267242,
-0.032783932983875275,
0.42273712158203125,
0.5200592875480652,
-0.4128111004829407,
-0.31959670782089233,
0.21215131878852844,
0.056341204792261124,
-0.2961568832397461,
0.962487518787384,
-1.2201182842254639,
0.40996307134628296,
0.27888429164886475,
0.643412172794342,
0.5729775428771973,
-0.2903367877006531,
0.6915862560272217,
-0.811870276927948,
0.3365771174430847,
0.15095312893390656,
0.2527952492237091,
0.09389781206846237,
-0.3141421973705292,
0.6131776571273804,
-0.014608851633965969,
-0.8128142356872559,
-0.7765470743179321,
0.19368784129619598,
-0.8853833675384521,
-0.4553520679473877,
1.44868004322052,
-0.06875056773424149,
-0.2591913640499115,
-0.04396253824234009,
-0.5450274348258972,
-0.10748772323131561,
-0.5652410984039307,
0.5556970238685608,
0.6952039003372192,
-0.2106226533651352,
-0.14272934198379517,
-0.7018033266067505,
0.8057670593261719,
0.4127373695373535,
-0.7184606790542603,
-0.020033027976751328,
0.5867246389389038,
0.09479299932718277,
0.1332295686006546,
0.716640293598175,
0.5046628713607788,
0.13402695953845978,
-0.3459741473197937,
0.05629337951540947,
-0.0902169719338417,
-0.5874664187431335,
-0.4322645664215088,
-0.04186192899942398,
0.5131374001502991,
0.010877788998186588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03129v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03129v2
|
CoGenesis: A Framework Collaborating Large and Small Language Models for Secure Context-Aware Instruction Following
| 2024-03-05T17:15:28 | 2024-06-06T09:30:24 |
Kaiyan Zhang, Jianyu Wang, Ermo Hua, Biqing Qi, Ning Ding, Bowen Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the advancement of language models (LMs), their exposure to private data
is increasingly inevitable, and their deployment (especially for smaller ones)
on personal devices, such as PCs and smartphones, has become a prevailing
trend. In contexts laden with user information, enabling models to both
safeguard user privacy and execute commands efficiently emerges as an essential
research imperative. In this paper, we propose CoGenesis, a collaborative
generation framework integrating large (hosted on cloud infrastructure) and
small models (deployed on local devices) to address privacy concerns logically.
Initially, we design a pipeline to create personalized writing instruction
datasets enriched with extensive context details as the testbed of this
research issue. Subsequently, we introduce two variants of CoGenesis based on
sketch and logits respectively. Our experimental findings, based on our
synthesized dataset and two additional open-source datasets, indicate that: 1)
Large-scale models perform well when provided with user context but struggle in
the absence of such context. 2) While specialized smaller models fine-tuned on
the synthetic dataset show promise, they still lag behind their larger
counterparts. 3) Our CoGenesis framework, utilizing mixed-scale models,
showcases competitive performance, providing a feasible solution to privacy
issues.
|
[
-0.15961074829101562,
-0.9290382862091064,
0.5074270367622375,
0.1931552290916443,
0.36304861307144165,
0.05296453833580017,
-0.35667088627815247,
-0.32793745398521423,
-0.08953024446964264,
0.7250331044197083,
-0.6751293540000916,
-0.8768144249916077,
-0.22568388283252716,
-0.28174108266830444,
-0.474678635597229,
0.7608723044395447,
0.10047147423028946,
-0.11329431086778641,
-0.7347655892372131,
0.14253324270248413,
-0.41994616389274597,
-0.6628967523574829,
-0.5229828953742981,
0.11437255889177322,
0.32196852564811707,
0.809195876121521,
0.5800859928131104,
1.049860954284668,
0.437919020652771,
0.2870524525642395,
0.15170300006866455,
-0.00985506922006607,
-0.5158595442771912,
0.357266902923584,
-0.3356591761112213,
-0.17802613973617554,
-0.5014883279800415,
-0.12138135731220245,
0.29831451177597046,
0.9084843993186951,
-0.23219986259937286,
0.0347990021109581,
0.1969897300004959,
0.28843390941619873,
-0.5836862921714783,
-0.01805463805794716,
-0.44127851724624634,
0.2555263340473175,
-0.04823122173547745,
0.031897470355033875,
-0.726837694644928,
-0.26917609572410583,
0.5192891955375671,
-0.5883932709693909,
0.6774261593818665,
0.24590864777565002,
0.264010488986969,
0.005817836150527,
-0.2496291697025299,
-0.6775153279304504,
-0.50229811668396,
1.0310636758804321,
-0.4244953691959381,
0.37395381927490234,
0.3301038444042206,
0.3396172523498535,
-0.3622797131538391,
-1.1910967826843262,
-0.284908652305603,
-0.11138216406106949,
-0.16614480316638947,
-0.14674131572246552,
0.2491246461868286,
0.13486574590206146,
0.04174180328845978,
0.4452064335346222,
-0.5016463994979858,
0.3914148509502411,
-0.3284102976322174,
-0.5179874897003174,
0.7138341069221497,
0.2954322099685669,
0.49030256271362305,
0.19561031460762024,
-0.3668699562549591,
-0.10813770443201065,
-1.1185033321380615,
0.1906619518995285,
0.31690293550491333,
0.5460642576217651,
-0.6464502215385437,
0.34940090775489807,
-0.15798236429691315,
0.6650884747505188,
0.16223986446857452,
0.0825045257806778,
-0.3219336271286011,
-0.34588736295700073,
-0.31889763474464417,
0.21265444159507751,
0.8646795153617859,
0.16415399312973022,
-0.318688303232193,
-0.3557548522949219,
0.3408270478248596,
-0.037523407489061356,
0.058220360428094864,
-1.1734564304351807,
-0.28284987807273865,
0.29725539684295654,
-0.12851789593696594,
-0.3973333537578583,
-0.10353589802980423,
-0.9847950339317322,
-0.6413892507553101,
-0.13997122645378113,
0.14360761642456055,
-0.09708479791879654,
0.23344159126281738,
0.10234211385250092,
0.2577767074108124,
-0.22787661850452423,
0.3107552230358124,
-1.4202802181243896,
0.5470145344734192,
0.9984147548675537,
0.6956695318222046,
-0.16871249675750732,
-0.1913815438747406,
-0.6217191219329834,
0.29397091269493103,
-0.22520963847637177,
-0.0279341209679842,
-0.5820164084434509,
-0.6497201323509216,
0.17200791835784912,
0.0955362468957901,
-0.17234881222248077,
-0.2618331015110016,
0.3865555226802826,
-0.44274553656578064,
0.6300598978996277,
-0.23674508929252625,
-0.8389269113540649,
-0.03343101963400841,
0.048202548176050186,
-0.6252602338790894,
0.5858771204948425,
0.14298327267169952,
-0.6983555555343628,
0.32996365427970886,
-0.7465359568595886,
-0.35633161664009094,
0.23008090257644653,
-0.4865459203720093,
-0.5754502415657043,
-0.004398900084197521,
-0.06847966462373734,
0.8237791657447815,
-0.3241548240184784,
0.5053033828735352,
-0.32261309027671814,
-0.32960712909698486,
-0.005286188796162605,
-0.04660137742757797,
0.7727707028388977,
0.1780296266078949,
-0.5725781321525574,
0.10780183970928192,
-0.8017005920410156,
0.16029928624629974,
-0.12628111243247986,
-0.11155758798122406,
-0.4456036686897278,
0.02866215631365776,
-0.4306683838367462,
0.11728610843420029,
0.4778118133544922,
-0.6699623465538025,
-0.02055986411869526,
-0.29762235283851624,
0.5785142779350281,
0.431905597448349,
0.1362452208995819,
0.969498872756958,
-0.12713797390460968,
0.4235076606273651,
0.09710273891687393,
0.16858422756195068,
-0.46508464217185974,
-0.5162396430969238,
-0.5267065763473511,
-0.3815428614616394,
0.034917838871479034,
0.2434454709291458,
-0.3342510759830475,
0.5285332202911377,
-0.21048583090305328,
-0.34853145480155945,
-0.26563915610313416,
0.3608962893486023,
0.5240128040313721,
0.7178805470466614,
0.2557915449142456,
-0.250448077917099,
-0.631324827671051,
-0.8331863284111023,
-0.21509413421154022,
0.37928301095962524,
0.22937534749507904,
0.5974786281585693,
0.2689568102359772,
-0.34928110241889954,
1.022689700126648,
-0.4171820282936096,
-0.18793101608753204,
-0.006287096068263054,
-0.023951493203639984,
-0.20066355168819427,
0.9019092917442322,
0.36125651001930237,
-0.631804883480072,
-0.7663850784301758,
0.043235115706920624,
-0.8365262150764465,
0.07555484771728516,
0.06532126665115356,
-0.23229117691516876,
-0.055513497442007065,
0.6861998438835144,
-0.09380345791578293,
0.3230772912502289,
1.0794316530227661,
-0.45428648591041565,
0.02085770107805729,
-0.29148125648498535,
-0.1941661685705185,
-1.397671103477478,
-0.1132681667804718,
-0.17878088355064392,
-0.3533267080783844,
-0.6951463222503662,
0.4255223274230957,
0.0018956705462187529,
-0.5016494393348694,
-0.43894463777542114,
0.5811638236045837,
-0.4145215153694153,
0.08951880037784576,
-0.024020912125706673,
0.01983243227005005,
0.15412195026874542,
0.23097380995750427,
0.17574693262577057,
0.9830546379089355,
0.6024301052093506,
-0.4990048110485077,
-0.01366263534873724,
0.11897645145654678,
-0.3488578796386719,
0.10028009861707687,
-0.4800872802734375,
0.5804075002670288,
0.4225391745567322,
0.14250724017620087,
-0.36161309480667114,
-0.8070325255393982,
0.08298344910144806,
0.0035079114604741335,
0.11607003957033157,
0.009890666231513023,
-0.5450730919837952,
-0.08564694225788116,
-0.22295239567756653,
0.13349737226963043,
0.397908091545105,
-0.7732878923416138,
0.3954128324985504,
0.538068950176239,
-0.22166259586811066,
-0.3839249610900879,
-0.6471695899963379,
0.05028320848941803,
-0.17334508895874023,
-1.0847450494766235,
0.5640404224395752,
-0.1761585921049118,
-0.23618687689304352,
-0.013493363745510578,
0.3816250264644623,
-0.22525300085544586,
0.2284063994884491,
0.6128446459770203,
0.022796278819441795,
-0.349852591753006,
-0.15064014494419098,
0.6434563398361206,
0.1714586615562439,
-0.10256635397672653,
-0.23703022301197052,
0.4721750020980835,
-0.17316827178001404,
-0.19337327778339386,
-0.4643438458442688,
0.45865336060523987,
0.390482097864151,
-0.09273943305015564,
1.1240153312683105,
0.4589346945285797,
-0.3982160985469818,
-0.6236886978149414,
-0.1696486920118332,
-0.3320508301258087,
-0.5732744336128235,
0.022219937294721603,
-0.06541383266448975,
-1.4842787981033325,
0.5105416178703308,
-0.1376110166311264,
0.013938646763563156,
-0.04357762262225151,
0.7600804567337036,
0.09812967479228973,
0.9423655271530151,
0.9520624279975891,
0.35846030712127686,
0.4727441966533661,
-0.31631824374198914,
0.2527226209640503,
-0.7507289052009583,
-0.3390958905220032,
-0.29754945635795593,
-0.1461419314146042,
-0.5927579402923584,
-0.5015336275100708,
0.24131904542446136,
0.08545459806919098,
-0.13486596941947937,
0.526078462600708,
-0.6699433922767639,
0.4638608992099762,
0.6197813749313354,
0.07960832864046097,
0.17903684079647064,
0.05138249322772026,
-0.440841943025589,
-0.2008059173822403,
-0.7032709121704102,
-0.6782735586166382,
1.1554876565933228,
0.30665600299835205,
0.6273408532142639,
0.1887635588645935,
1.1974281072616577,
0.1283995509147644,
0.3840641379356384,
-0.3537067472934723,
0.6635287404060364,
-0.31054413318634033,
-0.9856582283973694,
-0.2808280885219574,
-0.39442622661590576,
-0.8628523349761963,
0.05831907317042351,
-0.150838702917099,
-1.0873862504959106,
0.4172978103160858,
0.3408297896385193,
-0.7263253927230835,
-0.06843250244855881,
-1.2505394220352173,
1.2061610221862793,
-0.09344498068094254,
-1.4228501319885254,
-0.1104583814740181,
-0.586469292640686,
0.5045388340950012,
-0.16773664951324463,
0.44891345500946045,
0.31063947081565857,
-0.0304091926664114,
0.5990314483642578,
-0.7723791599273682,
1.1666005849838257,
-0.422701895236969,
-0.18600541353225708,
0.6795570850372314,
0.22816886007785797,
0.4870436489582062,
0.10060141980648041,
-0.10476808995008469,
-0.18941046297550201,
0.04830483719706535,
-0.09041327238082886,
-0.4071885645389557,
1.2358276844024658,
-0.5632498860359192,
-0.573838472366333,
-0.015535516664385796,
-0.6274480223655701,
-0.2671944200992584,
0.3740837275981903,
0.42536190152168274,
0.431671142578125,
-0.37833839654922485,
0.8573542237281799,
0.604954183101654,
-0.41236141324043274,
0.4870782792568207,
0.25729602575302124,
-0.26024749875068665,
-0.16623997688293457,
0.9361293911933899,
0.04037364199757576,
0.186324805021286,
0.1961149424314499,
0.47103559970855713,
-0.26765334606170654,
-0.5003583431243896,
-0.5354644656181335,
-0.2052099108695984,
-0.5474519729614258,
0.10284706950187683,
-0.6100651025772095,
-0.09202247112989426,
-0.4306038022041321,
-0.5456101298332214,
-0.33949723839759827,
-0.3096725642681122,
-0.3440457880496979,
0.009959204122424126,
0.0892462208867073,
0.42365562915802,
-0.009785253554582596,
0.7365849614143372,
-0.8219006657600403,
-0.1381271779537201,
0.2832832634449005,
0.3820757567882538,
0.04538096860051155,
-0.11921000480651855,
-0.5787439942359924,
0.1637798398733139,
-0.47041916847229004,
-0.4599410593509674,
0.4176535904407501,
0.24707822501659393,
0.17882423102855682,
0.17258131504058838,
-0.043147485703229904,
0.45766356587409973,
-0.4362298250198364,
0.7783613204956055,
0.016922833397984505,
-0.9458304047584534,
0.27934789657592773,
-0.5896143317222595,
-0.07440456748008728,
0.7835831642150879,
0.1526467353105545,
-0.3750339150428772,
-0.16953593492507935,
-0.7514225840568542,
-0.7254739999771118,
0.6712454557418823,
0.06042319908738136,
0.33228862285614014,
0.28323686122894287,
0.35175827145576477,
0.4191921651363373,
0.3652336299419403,
-0.5227180123329163,
0.15697874128818512,
0.03556228056550026,
-0.6169627904891968,
0.06384182721376419,
0.013598809950053692,
-0.29013684391975403,
-0.16299155354499817,
0.23100309073925018,
-0.03230489045381546,
0.04957759752869606,
0.0008318440522998571,
-0.031205184757709503,
-0.08970475196838379,
0.24525736272335052,
0.5648437738418579,
0.3437848389148712,
-0.055546779185533524,
-0.020144108682870865,
-0.14806170761585236,
-0.7147157788276672,
0.10012385994195938,
-0.049169279634952545,
-0.4582000970840454,
-0.3882327377796173,
0.3242436945438385,
0.5602999329566956,
0.4544807970523834,
-0.5787895917892456,
0.7062133550643921,
-0.2837914526462555,
-0.0459570586681366,
-0.35251060128211975,
0.5866939425468445,
0.39356303215026855,
-0.055754415690898895,
-0.17972655594348907,
0.06838683038949966,
0.2130078226327896,
-0.6838922500610352,
0.2587742805480957,
0.15744581818580627,
-0.33210697770118713,
-0.5895763039588928,
0.6762802004814148,
0.47143352031707764,
-0.40930455923080444,
0.1671687215566635,
-0.29671019315719604,
-0.25029388070106506,
0.6583243012428284,
0.6733775734901428,
0.8292441964149475,
-0.24731574952602386,
0.175742968916893,
0.28981077671051025,
-0.06582488864660263,
-0.1606781780719757,
0.09586658328771591,
-0.18959541618824005,
-0.5565963387489319,
-0.12402228266000748,
-0.5010445713996887,
-0.586452305316925,
0.1850357949733734,
-0.5093240737915039,
0.20714862644672394,
-1.0183979272842407,
0.003644628217443824,
-0.22614707052707672,
0.029413720592856407,
-0.6896204352378845,
0.4200500547885895,
-0.02630290947854519,
0.5919027924537659,
-0.6545592546463013,
0.9025546312332153,
0.42247286438941956,
-0.03834925964474678,
-0.8454556465148926,
-0.23689796030521393,
0.204072043299675,
-0.4092037081718445,
0.4098840653896332,
0.3332936763763428,
-0.1959783136844635,
0.22400450706481934,
-0.6406143307685852,
-0.6000435948371887,
1.202493667602539,
0.2824048399925232,
-1.0290435552597046,
-0.14936187863349915,
0.2049207240343094,
0.8032276034355164,
-0.8636460304260254,
-0.5650980472564697,
0.21081095933914185,
-0.04325597360730171,
-0.01050401572138071,
-0.31474795937538147,
0.1551717221736908,
0.15944251418113708,
-0.32551756501197815,
-0.21755823493003845,
-0.6464767456054688,
0.9951013326644897,
-0.13901405036449432,
-0.31302139163017273,
0.4027092754840851,
0.5517754554748535,
0.2713857591152191,
0.6716150641441345,
0.05131534859538078,
0.4016402065753937,
0.8712563514709473,
0.12223708629608154,
1.1532301902770996,
-0.7110952138900757,
0.25811073184013367,
1.4148972034454346,
-0.29279977083206177,
0.8334681987762451,
0.2833636403083801,
0.25843754410743713,
0.6806894540786743,
0.3842088282108307,
0.324756383895874,
0.5998401641845703,
0.11035765707492828,
-0.4798559248447418,
0.046103790402412415,
-0.1690416932106018,
-0.3281715214252472,
0.35687336325645447,
0.5584856271743774,
-0.730588436126709,
0.08646632730960846,
-0.1694941520690918,
0.23303252458572388,
0.4908861219882965,
-0.09728869795799255,
0.6464940905570984,
0.35185500979423523,
-0.7570203542709351,
0.1786295622587204,
0.27793088555336,
0.3991842269897461,
-0.3154596984386444,
0.2275092899799347,
-0.13669784367084503,
0.39350736141204834,
-0.33823511004447937,
-0.3786768317222595,
0.33967193961143494,
0.2029804289340973,
-0.06648007780313492,
-0.3210753798484802,
0.6954204440116882,
-0.6226598024368286,
-0.2898138165473938,
0.2378452718257904,
0.3664226233959198,
-0.3364441394805908,
0.4657846689224243,
-0.379013329744339,
0.26257333159446716,
-0.20578938722610474,
0.047660332173109055,
0.4416535794734955,
0.32531100511550903,
-0.24916855990886688,
0.36773115396499634,
0.6603209376335144,
-0.14331401884555817,
0.32028883695602417,
-0.008645602501928806,
0.6758025884628296,
-0.37702447175979614,
-0.6767274141311646,
-0.8623932600021362,
0.42432576417922974,
-0.2623825967311859,
-0.10816425830125809,
1.0345607995986938,
0.7320384383201599,
0.8027908205986023,
-0.07023610919713974,
0.8373794555664062,
-0.07534582912921906,
0.5840883851051331,
-0.4073559641838074,
0.9188761711120605,
-0.25087907910346985,
0.3073473870754242,
-0.1425136774778366,
-0.7014643549919128,
-0.30773311853408813,
0.438655287027359,
-0.5998736619949341,
0.05391353368759155,
0.5785412788391113,
0.9263514280319214,
-0.276746541261673,
0.39956122636795044,
0.23440086841583252,
-0.03338995948433876,
0.4551581144332886,
0.4531205892562866,
0.7041060924530029,
-0.3364150822162628,
-0.03745487332344055,
-0.6597840785980225,
-0.17520791292190552,
-0.31063178181648254,
-0.9654437303543091,
-1.054886817932129,
-0.5005121827125549,
-0.23629748821258545,
-0.1833282709121704,
-0.04554159939289093,
0.8974106907844543,
1.0924859046936035,
-0.8332256078720093,
-0.2996969223022461,
-0.6275955438613892,
-0.12691821157932281,
0.22582124173641205,
-0.16592100262641907,
0.3628113567829132,
-0.06868312507867813,
-0.74644535779953,
0.6151596307754517,
0.17573903501033783,
0.17234517633914948,
-0.46113795042037964,
-0.2100047767162323,
0.19926458597183228,
0.13058635592460632,
0.45238667726516724,
0.36419564485549927,
-0.227620467543602,
-0.39655303955078125,
0.18150348961353302,
-0.4352357089519501,
-0.2267008274793625,
1.0017616748809814,
-0.42656153440475464,
0.728178083896637,
0.4722015857696533,
0.8092872500419617,
0.4025770425796509,
0.03162754327058792,
0.7498652935028076,
-1.0400712490081787,
0.3943200409412384,
0.1546822041273117,
0.1761404275894165,
0.735531210899353,
-0.7141072154045105,
0.2655787169933319,
0.14664751291275024,
-0.5400980710983276,
-0.9047548174858093,
0.28717875480651855,
-0.6622278690338135,
0.000912244024220854,
0.6573339104652405,
-0.5012353658676147,
-0.5166177153587341,
0.05369914323091507,
0.00798899494111538,
0.09854181855916977,
-0.3481656312942505,
0.7765542268753052,
0.5911334156990051,
0.02232285402715206,
0.015728920698165894,
-0.324355810880661,
0.670371413230896,
0.32858404517173767,
-0.9114890694618225,
0.09728153049945831,
0.5024720430374146,
0.011716237291693687,
0.3287106156349182,
0.39920148253440857,
-0.0912792980670929,
0.2359488308429718,
0.24440816044807434,
-0.2579934000968933,
-0.3387247323989868,
-0.6504257917404175,
-0.19333413243293762,
0.36677515506744385,
-0.07664977014064789,
-0.0037469458766281605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03121v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03121v3
|
Angry Men, Sad Women: Large Language Models Reflect Gendered Stereotypes in Emotion Attribution
| 2024-03-05T17:04:05 | 2024-05-28T14:43:52 |
Flor Miriam Plaza-del-Arco, Amanda Cercas Curry, Alba Curry, Gavin Abercrombie, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) reflect societal norms and biases, especially
about gender. While societal biases and stereotypes have been extensively
researched in various NLP applications, there is a surprising gap for emotion
analysis. However, emotion and gender are closely linked in societal discourse.
E.g., women are often thought of as more empathetic, while men's anger is more
socially accepted. To fill this gap, we present the first comprehensive study
of gendered emotion attribution in five state-of-the-art LLMs (open- and
closed-source). We investigate whether emotions are gendered, and whether these
variations are based on societal stereotypes. We prompt the models to adopt a
gendered persona and attribute emotions to an event like 'When I had a serious
argument with a dear person'. We then analyze the emotions generated by the
models in relation to the gender-event pairs. We find that all models
consistently exhibit gendered emotions, influenced by gender stereotypes. These
findings are in line with established research in psychology and gender
studies. Our study sheds light on the complex societal interplay between
language, gender, and emotion. The reproduction of emotion stereotypes in LLMs
allows us to use those models to study the topic in detail, but raises
questions about the predictive use of those same LLMs for emotion applications.
|
[
-0.24801601469516754,
-0.3510178029537201,
0.32369524240493774,
0.5023672580718994,
0.12462829053401947,
0.17313909530639648,
-0.06643228232860565,
-0.4528520703315735,
0.1370372325181961,
0.26747244596481323,
-0.64731365442276,
-0.30853304266929626,
-0.6455544829368591,
0.38499289751052856,
-0.5023618340492249,
0.5994418263435364,
-0.09341411292552948,
0.2271575927734375,
-0.18014700710773468,
-0.23814551532268524,
-0.08875767886638641,
-1.0099704265594482,
-0.48005837202072144,
-0.5066195726394653,
0.8649990558624268,
0.027628179639577866,
0.49185505509376526,
0.05715561658143997,
0.527545690536499,
0.30993905663490295,
-0.2159656137228012,
-0.057089414447546005,
-0.6383669972419739,
0.2645391523838043,
-0.12092617899179459,
-0.4196030795574188,
-0.48946526646614075,
0.32728052139282227,
0.23862135410308838,
0.46848762035369873,
-0.20709708333015442,
0.16657806932926178,
-0.06661444157361984,
0.8709824085235596,
-0.6364650726318359,
0.2913338243961334,
-0.3988610804080963,
0.3037508726119995,
-0.08716529607772827,
-0.10913379490375519,
-0.32772713899612427,
-0.6447654366493225,
0.18436792492866516,
0.18593043088912964,
-0.015390574000775814,
0.2311428338289261,
0.5982288122177124,
0.1221119612455368,
-0.8029685616493225,
-0.5507707595825195,
-0.5142419338226318,
0.9114797115325928,
-0.6626957654953003,
0.26645365357398987,
-0.07525371015071869,
0.03390614315867424,
-0.14867442846298218,
-0.1447434425354004,
-0.41398733854293823,
-0.20074871182441711,
0.06028047204017639,
0.06256027519702911,
-0.753305196762085,
-0.10008957982063293,
0.11925090849399567,
0.22184795141220093,
-0.23862044513225555,
0.059123314917087555,
-0.3379623293876648,
0.26335442066192627,
0.6649061441421509,
0.1968362033367157,
0.5143169164657593,
-0.4272118806838989,
-0.16657191514968872,
0.2221813201904297,
-0.6683210134506226,
-0.369220495223999,
0.6501988172531128,
0.36694982647895813,
-0.308811753988266,
0.6514992117881775,
0.2979516088962555,
0.26603153347969055,
0.08349786698818207,
0.05287865921854973,
0.24126440286636353,
0.31412070989608765,
-0.10589172691106796,
0.23498663306236267,
1.00388765335083,
0.5300877094268799,
0.780529260635376,
0.03985310345888138,
-0.2655196487903595,
0.1944945901632309,
0.45138031244277954,
-0.5188751220703125,
0.08653585612773895,
0.1633215695619583,
-0.45290687680244446,
-0.5773681998252869,
-0.4877697229385376,
-0.948436975479126,
-0.8937969207763672,
-0.051088858395814896,
0.06369497627019882,
0.09524863213300705,
-0.3742045760154724,
0.0012397373793646693,
-0.2441987544298172,
0.14679540693759918,
0.15826813876628876,
-0.771439254283905,
0.23545926809310913,
0.7002266645431519,
0.8409344553947449,
0.12927283346652985,
0.08407460898160934,
0.08986995369195938,
0.03418496996164322,
-0.5170652270317078,
0.525492787361145,
-0.6790193915367126,
-0.25482872128486633,
0.33091259002685547,
-0.09905929118394852,
0.10163716971874237,
-0.48903316259384155,
0.5133771300315857,
-0.17652422189712524,
0.34078532457351685,
-0.41503390669822693,
-0.3378467559814453,
-0.21136264503002167,
0.32994890213012695,
-0.5471907258033752,
0.8715200424194336,
-0.07729119807481766,
-0.8079277873039246,
0.0060412148013710976,
-0.6521270275115967,
-0.03184288367629051,
-0.3071945607662201,
-0.4753500521183014,
-0.212508425116539,
0.5748157501220703,
-0.13631092011928558,
0.4632229804992676,
-0.82356196641922,
0.33649659156799316,
-0.6358869075775146,
0.1307784616947174,
0.19235362112522125,
0.0345822349190712,
0.6259716749191284,
0.1472456008195877,
-0.3386674225330353,
0.30210933089256287,
-0.29240682721138,
-0.6050719022750854,
0.4735904932022095,
-0.15628555417060852,
-0.4699697494506836,
0.3223687708377838,
-0.08557087182998657,
0.2612704038619995,
0.07358432561159134,
-0.6430671215057373,
-0.05826827138662338,
-0.23425954580307007,
0.4903005361557007,
0.9400877356529236,
-0.41229933500289917,
0.39861783385276794,
-0.056992825120687485,
0.6859164834022522,
0.06889178603887558,
0.065858393907547,
0.3288416266441345,
-0.38385406136512756,
-0.64418625831604,
-0.07840294390916824,
-0.20538797974586487,
0.5012051463127136,
-0.1969335824251175,
0.17879077792167664,
0.2215515822172165,
-0.630591869354248,
-0.43564873933792114,
-0.25133216381073,
0.43099939823150635,
0.2151426076889038,
-0.15161502361297607,
-0.08461497724056244,
-0.6672119498252869,
-0.9514691829681396,
-0.701262354850769,
-0.4617030620574951,
0.050250906497240067,
0.6115289330482483,
0.3196418583393097,
-0.1876923143863678,
0.8882631063461304,
-0.6075211763381958,
-0.1469012349843979,
-0.3852936327457428,
0.6498826146125793,
-0.09981802105903625,
0.24433676898479462,
0.833096444606781,
-0.3827403485774994,
-0.1344737410545349,
-0.23087507486343384,
-0.9169805645942688,
-0.4997729957103729,
0.3922502398490906,
-0.13422614336013794,
0.3655848801136017,
0.32410672307014465,
-0.3324443995952606,
0.007309316657483578,
0.8581823706626892,
-0.4123029112815857,
0.6194138526916504,
0.10261702537536621,
0.230392187833786,
-0.7893254160881042,
-0.22468477487564087,
0.29351329803466797,
-0.023246916010975838,
-0.43536409735679626,
-0.10895274579524994,
-0.0514591820538044,
-0.3616325259208679,
-0.6575690507888794,
0.5997776389122009,
-0.6145525574684143,
-0.2793751060962677,
0.06697388738393784,
-0.0256346445530653,
-0.14609727263450623,
0.02459094487130642,
-0.0024338781367987394,
0.31015852093696594,
0.37793228030204773,
-0.25534000992774963,
0.46075302362442017,
0.21235233545303345,
-0.12290984392166138,
0.5133020877838135,
-0.4193227291107178,
0.21439403295516968,
-0.4631079435348511,
0.23430873453617096,
-1.0108267068862915,
-0.3259594738483429,
0.21097436547279358,
-0.3317393958568573,
0.11711106449365616,
-0.01822310872375965,
-0.3311573565006256,
-0.43559008836746216,
-0.22167116403579712,
0.34185972809791565,
0.4971502721309662,
-0.29578012228012085,
1.0659245252609253,
0.39662182331085205,
-0.2779301106929779,
-0.44918352365493774,
-0.5749364495277405,
0.22561870515346527,
-0.33851194381713867,
-0.53726726770401,
-0.4571835696697235,
0.037057723850011826,
-0.7920147180557251,
-0.35803791880607605,
0.11510462313890457,
-0.14665010571479797,
-0.043806057423353195,
0.44436195492744446,
-0.02580047957599163,
-0.13683760166168213,
0.22706499695777893,
0.038633961230516434,
0.2001679688692093,
0.46184277534484863,
0.4396861791610718,
0.6686920523643494,
-0.4532414376735687,
-0.23569031059741974,
-0.20260652899742126,
0.5344353914260864,
0.722748875617981,
0.05674088001251221,
0.913549542427063,
0.5129019618034363,
-0.6453154683113098,
0.09113036841154099,
-0.39430171251296997,
-0.13572603464126587,
-0.40515053272247314,
0.4737876057624817,
-0.291061133146286,
-1.0169379711151123,
0.6086318492889404,
-0.18628692626953125,
0.08315686136484146,
0.45811933279037476,
0.6486591696739197,
-0.4056910276412964,
1.1780166625976562,
0.6085230112075806,
-0.43996894359588623,
0.4301917850971222,
0.2001650631427765,
0.23781593143939972,
-0.6749247312545776,
-0.1191486045718193,
-0.9638895392417908,
-0.6058290600776672,
-0.6715513467788696,
-0.21871760487556458,
0.06591302901506424,
-0.31616032123565674,
-0.449243426322937,
-0.3788699209690094,
-0.04045011103153229,
0.23209360241889954,
-0.031008707359433174,
-0.1660972237586975,
0.025226827710866928,
-0.26479753851890564,
0.41502729058265686,
-0.44378358125686646,
-0.5669383406639099,
-0.6107192635536194,
0.8306717872619629,
0.571160614490509,
1.0394138097763062,
0.41352325677871704,
0.537803053855896,
0.5036650896072388,
0.5860874056816101,
-0.777614414691925,
0.5475811958312988,
-0.6106709241867065,
-1.0372978448867798,
0.12934157252311707,
-0.48246508836746216,
-0.6921917796134949,
0.026510480791330338,
-0.04055991768836975,
-1.0331528186798096,
0.41558414697647095,
0.36159661412239075,
0.09787789732217789,
0.3999493718147278,
-0.4832914173603058,
0.7721805572509766,
-0.08159757405519485,
-0.08083796501159668,
-0.11619063466787338,
-0.4670761823654175,
0.9975742697715759,
-0.05488165095448494,
0.4784201979637146,
-0.4659528434276581,
0.1868765652179718,
0.6851658225059509,
-0.26748400926589966,
1.0489213466644287,
0.01977616176009178,
-0.6075605154037476,
-0.08555089682340622,
0.34961846470832825,
0.3982808589935303,
-0.47755709290504456,
-0.2558380961418152,
0.3264627158641815,
-0.43113529682159424,
-0.16702991724014282,
-0.22043447196483612,
0.7336300611495972,
-0.8499384522438049,
-0.5110805034637451,
-0.47933799028396606,
-0.5997318029403687,
0.1083049401640892,
-0.3163890242576599,
-0.08103663474321365,
0.4712667465209961,
-0.1606472283601761,
-0.027609845623373985,
0.722782552242279,
-0.7396501898765564,
0.007762556429952383,
0.34611353278160095,
-0.5629861950874329,
-0.08763623982667923,
0.6282961964607239,
-0.1788998395204544,
0.47757774591445923,
0.21326562762260437,
0.5147659778594971,
-0.05967886745929718,
0.13800331950187683,
-0.25318285822868347,
0.3795282244682312,
-0.8308067321777344,
0.018015563488006592,
-0.7389676570892334,
0.09711464494466782,
-0.5349375009536743,
-0.40374934673309326,
-0.9851211905479431,
0.027749620378017426,
-0.43623414635658264,
0.10954304039478302,
0.42154768109321594,
0.8482773303985596,
0.07747481018304825,
0.24377213418483734,
-0.8175796270370483,
0.29293859004974365,
0.2173888385295868,
0.22930720448493958,
-0.014494095928966999,
-0.42655977606773376,
0.4836195707321167,
-0.35598066449165344,
0.05875612795352936,
-1.323312520980835,
0.6769030094146729,
0.3227851092815399,
0.03289191424846649,
0.5426383018493652,
0.31216415762901306,
0.35986337065696716,
-0.3385859429836273,
0.9204384684562683,
0.3504222333431244,
-1.0389153957366943,
0.2214214950799942,
-0.5012542009353638,
0.025197524577379227,
-0.11109693348407745,
0.4760848879814148,
-0.9380102157592773,
-0.6323506832122803,
-0.4072163999080658,
-0.8702996373176575,
0.7906450033187866,
-0.17230278253555298,
0.4677262008190155,
-0.26146870851516724,
0.438218891620636,
0.07616880536079407,
0.26913347840309143,
-0.7208600640296936,
-0.48991623520851135,
0.16957299411296844,
-0.6516867280006409,
-0.1559077501296997,
-0.6649892926216125,
-0.1774420589208603,
0.09245413541793823,
0.3544912040233612,
0.05587712302803993,
0.60575932264328,
-0.1247628778219223,
-0.11296924203634262,
-0.35444772243499756,
0.3922201991081238,
0.45778751373291016,
0.25829461216926575,
-0.5257759094238281,
0.2882867455482483,
-0.021655386313796043,
-0.18823859095573425,
0.4056747257709503,
-0.3314400613307953,
0.11111801862716675,
0.1530894935131073,
0.20436085760593414,
0.9844794273376465,
0.4258076250553131,
-0.8235884308815002,
0.6265658140182495,
-0.12326931953430176,
-0.24425239861011505,
-0.36961761116981506,
-0.27331286668777466,
0.43937671184539795,
0.8621026873588562,
0.07973849773406982,
-0.16287057101726532,
0.290018230676651,
-1.0501798391342163,
-0.5231211185455322,
0.48915931582450867,
-0.6997478604316711,
-0.3151249885559082,
0.5960710048675537,
0.3760673701763153,
-0.28193357586860657,
0.45535120368003845,
-0.14596475660800934,
-0.9335538148880005,
0.5679988861083984,
0.5823625922203064,
1.0643893480300903,
-0.24617348611354828,
0.18646830320358276,
0.3767203092575073,
0.44872304797172546,
-0.0843927413225174,
0.655484676361084,
0.6621303558349609,
-0.7117277979850769,
-0.043909747153520584,
-0.6466785669326782,
-0.5659840106964111,
-0.036513280123472214,
-0.5458476543426514,
0.18176402151584625,
-0.40682753920555115,
-0.20398417115211487,
-0.31233030557632446,
-0.3158378005027771,
-0.55577552318573,
0.06522011756896973,
0.7311481833457947,
0.8228253126144409,
-1.1768022775650024,
0.14855192601680756,
0.8175832629203796,
-0.03014647215604782,
-0.6578540205955505,
-0.1944190412759781,
0.5150606632232666,
-0.5440574288368225,
0.9052071571350098,
0.12737709283828735,
-0.23921464383602142,
0.034805186092853546,
-0.6443860530853271,
-0.6259676814079285,
0.5242392420768738,
0.5241938829421997,
-0.6916396021842957,
0.07826529443264008,
0.10735572874546051,
0.36240652203559875,
-0.5323947668075562,
0.5646865367889404,
0.4961671829223633,
0.4582129120826721,
-0.11733861267566681,
-0.8081861138343811,
-0.05054266378283501,
-0.10272244364023209,
-0.12193295359611511,
0.38415539264678955,
-0.7213917970657349,
1.0511221885681152,
-0.031223591417074203,
-0.0820293053984642,
-0.26837587356567383,
0.7647162675857544,
0.35731157660484314,
0.21489256620407104,
0.6193751692771912,
0.21209973096847534,
0.6677184700965881,
-0.2812035083770752,
1.033808708190918,
0.1269754320383072,
0.1473371386528015,
0.8777577877044678,
-0.4731905162334442,
0.7081453800201416,
0.35967543721199036,
-0.41993066668510437,
0.4664483666419983,
0.5604984164237976,
0.325778990983963,
-0.03302222490310669,
0.6671323776245117,
-0.3023030757904053,
-0.15088948607444763,
-0.30297279357910156,
-0.18065227568149567,
0.6400862336158752,
0.3281266987323761,
-0.5772637724876404,
-0.1428316980600357,
-0.04733753204345703,
0.20022261142730713,
-0.15813972055912018,
-0.5097077488899231,
0.6490741968154907,
0.3419073820114136,
0.04496346414089203,
0.2338668555021286,
-0.009816178120672703,
0.7780977487564087,
-0.6165264844894409,
0.3769766688346863,
-0.3736453354358673,
0.09458153694868088,
-0.2789590060710907,
-0.502790629863739,
0.146569162607193,
0.5457180142402649,
-0.41066858172416687,
0.019763000309467316,
0.7801685333251953,
-0.5275939106941223,
-0.43403682112693787,
0.4330785572528839,
0.4803248345851898,
0.6129712462425232,
-0.3582291305065155,
-0.526797890663147,
0.1955508589744568,
0.07814900577068329,
-0.5835234522819519,
0.5920335650444031,
0.4911670982837677,
-0.15550772845745087,
0.8402925729751587,
0.1858726143836975,
-0.042618025094270706,
0.1839461326599121,
0.5118018984794617,
0.6143515110015869,
-0.9042394757270813,
0.033292271196842194,
-0.9702966809272766,
0.5029047727584839,
0.14264534413814545,
-0.18063390254974365,
0.23338459432125092,
0.1938931941986084,
0.12186957150697708,
-0.18406441807746887,
0.6713411808013916,
-0.0936674177646637,
0.4366588294506073,
-0.12874853610992432,
0.7437295913696289,
-0.7810488343238831,
-0.08720908313989639,
-0.7879542708396912,
-0.9345539212226868,
-0.15822745859622955,
0.45060786604881287,
-0.3519733250141144,
-0.04108245298266411,
0.429361492395401,
0.46006518602371216,
0.3423149883747101,
0.1843203902244568,
0.10114211589097977,
0.40138623118400574,
0.5035262107849121,
0.45972421765327454,
1.2158584594726562,
-0.12346053123474121,
0.28704166412353516,
0.029714297503232956,
-0.2536315619945526,
-0.38429397344589233,
-1.306134581565857,
-0.614128828048706,
-0.1531790792942047,
-0.5708574056625366,
-0.040172990411520004,
0.036334287375211716,
1.1693798303604126,
0.0033459272235631943,
-0.3962821662425995,
-0.4570525288581848,
0.3448319137096405,
0.12088312953710556,
0.22229069471359253,
-0.21585576236248016,
-0.004973937291651964,
-0.18431343138217926,
-0.8838856220245361,
0.02426806278526783,
0.21344423294067383,
-0.14267174899578094,
-0.35883548855781555,
-0.17107801139354706,
-0.1039416640996933,
0.46386197209358215,
0.7249482870101929,
-0.03702819347381592,
-0.7766306400299072,
-0.4067752957344055,
-0.2946755886077881,
-0.13549602031707764,
-0.07461147755384445,
0.7086102962493896,
-0.22317779064178467,
0.2780991196632385,
0.5165797472000122,
0.1991761475801468,
-0.24792663753032684,
-0.20251832902431488,
0.9741198420524597,
-0.8573076725006104,
0.016987688839435577,
0.08478421717882156,
0.5917206406593323,
0.49683067202568054,
-0.25748157501220703,
0.3017396032810211,
0.17947837710380554,
-0.5974404811859131,
-0.9478812217712402,
0.2600654065608978,
-0.8938547372817993,
-0.13989202678203583,
1.1554255485534668,
-0.2707751989364624,
-0.15183955430984497,
0.3633640706539154,
-0.29165640473365784,
0.5828350782394409,
-0.7615664005279541,
0.9296764135360718,
0.9404865503311157,
-0.08491022139787674,
-0.3981126844882965,
-0.7053013443946838,
0.2936260998249054,
0.4102741479873657,
-0.8474745154380798,
0.5114729404449463,
0.7952349781990051,
-0.14609193801879883,
0.0359337218105793,
0.2401653379201889,
-0.10080322623252869,
-0.2513120174407959,
-0.05576512590050697,
0.7450072169303894,
0.3481784164905548,
-0.07418058067560196,
-0.39389559626579285,
0.23620671033859253,
-0.012395349331200123,
0.33557161688804626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03102v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03102v3
|
"In Dialogues We Learn": Towards Personalized Dialogue Without Pre-defined Profiles through In-Dialogue Learning
| 2024-03-05T16:43:03 | 2024-03-12T05:33:16 |
Chuanqi Cheng, Quan Tu, Wei Wu, Shuo Shang, Cunli Mao, Zhengtao Yu, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Personalized dialogue systems have gained significant attention in recent
years for their ability to generate responses in alignment with different
personas. However, most existing approaches rely on pre-defined personal
profiles, which are not only time-consuming and labor-intensive to create but
also lack flexibility. We propose In-Dialogue Learning (IDL), a fine-tuning
framework that enhances the ability of pre-trained large language models to
leverage dialogue history to characterize persona for completing personalized
dialogue generation tasks without pre-defined profiles. Our experiments on
three datasets demonstrate that IDL brings substantial improvements, with BLEU
and ROUGE scores increasing by up to 200% and 247%, respectively. Additionally,
the results of human evaluations further validate the efficacy of our proposed
method.
|
[
-0.5005748271942139,
-0.5366908311843872,
0.6389442682266235,
-0.0964558944106102,
-0.05019678547978401,
0.764883279800415,
-0.12654763460159302,
-0.06249440088868141,
0.1212952584028244,
0.6273937821388245,
-0.876423716545105,
-0.4651309847831726,
-0.1891133040189743,
-0.011447127908468246,
0.17855440080165863,
1.1162598133087158,
0.6010370254516602,
0.2394261509180069,
-0.10430482029914856,
-0.0632203072309494,
-0.6170963048934937,
-0.4014202654361725,
-0.8974615335464478,
-0.4236477017402649,
0.6192599534988403,
0.7497431635856628,
0.22922271490097046,
0.164276123046875,
0.17806729674339294,
0.2765030264854431,
0.01996155083179474,
0.3865322470664978,
-0.6594278812408447,
0.27202194929122925,
-0.2826762795448303,
-0.35470813512802124,
-0.2524721622467041,
0.03332386910915375,
0.6596394777297974,
1.0570127964019775,
0.058535780757665634,
0.12892694771289825,
0.3447962999343872,
0.8403474688529968,
-0.4912276268005371,
0.2147374004125595,
-0.6283703446388245,
0.011662805452942848,
-0.058893702924251556,
-0.342387318611145,
-0.6835461258888245,
-0.697700560092926,
0.5741159319877625,
-0.40165722370147705,
0.02586996741592884,
0.05097503587603569,
0.6517804265022278,
0.0803426057100296,
-0.4340429902076721,
-0.19624605774879456,
-0.9174730181694031,
0.6150510311126709,
-0.7247081398963928,
0.16753792762756348,
0.5197964310646057,
0.6415687799453735,
-0.21082937717437744,
-0.6516609191894531,
-0.25779107213020325,
-0.3894555866718292,
-0.30182063579559326,
0.1751752644777298,
0.17676152288913727,
0.3257178068161011,
0.6096575260162354,
0.11949881166219711,
-0.48791825771331787,
0.1485980600118637,
-0.15182875096797943,
-0.11144651472568512,
0.6312711238861084,
0.5128750801086426,
0.008535824716091156,
0.27892646193504333,
-0.1685822308063507,
-0.11293578892946243,
-0.7911295294761658,
0.5692513585090637,
0.6299902200698853,
0.4716850817203522,
-0.14774538576602936,
0.06480895727872849,
-0.3347250521183014,
0.31773823499679565,
0.754887044429779,
-0.35951271653175354,
0.10674580186605453,
-0.13343633711338043,
-0.28773191571235657,
-0.08204610645771027,
0.7091343998908997,
0.1809549778699875,
0.41896912455558777,
-0.312102347612381,
-0.006661819759756327,
-0.3962613046169281,
0.07581277191638947,
-1.1353466510772705,
-0.4911116361618042,
-0.010671226307749748,
-0.34043189883232117,
-0.1872822493314743,
0.1054786816239357,
-0.843005895614624,
-0.5935400128364563,
-0.5627599358558655,
0.362712025642395,
-0.42278823256492615,
0.11362472176551819,
-0.11877024918794632,
-0.0025497903116047382,
0.01600857637822628,
0.6383720636367798,
-0.9487106204032898,
0.4874055087566376,
0.16983269155025482,
0.44424325227737427,
-0.07798853516578674,
-0.02224237099289894,
-0.90215665102005,
0.020765673369169235,
-0.226523295044899,
0.5825838446617126,
-0.8034672141075134,
-0.571886420249939,
0.02771088108420372,
-0.32465964555740356,
-0.023079000413417816,
-0.8393856287002563,
0.08927144855260849,
-0.02446082979440689,
0.39942437410354614,
-0.3375571072101593,
-0.699886679649353,
-0.10245189815759659,
0.11429164558649063,
-0.20142582058906555,
0.4245723783969879,
0.4794224500656128,
-0.26182907819747925,
0.43276286125183105,
-0.7959311604499817,
-0.37206441164016724,
0.4601626396179199,
-0.1684139221906662,
-0.18379563093185425,
-0.07328727096319199,
0.102736696600914,
0.4350684583187103,
-0.27175015211105347,
0.3536261320114136,
-0.28943756222724915,
-0.4549080431461334,
0.29669949412345886,
-0.249483123421669,
0.7787168025970459,
0.08586587011814117,
-0.367257297039032,
0.22024033963680267,
-0.803800642490387,
0.07657541334629059,
-0.23946590721607208,
-0.3139653205871582,
-0.06389686465263367,
-0.08603843301534653,
-0.1811937391757965,
0.16077269613742828,
0.12806850671768188,
-0.7368694543838501,
0.2119496911764145,
-0.8531547784805298,
0.22800545394420624,
0.9141137599945068,
0.08273837715387344,
0.6688746809959412,
-0.4484839141368866,
0.3924567699432373,
0.19772665202617645,
0.07409106194972992,
-0.7644936442375183,
-0.2052045613527298,
-0.8644900918006897,
-0.29989010095596313,
0.11818545311689377,
0.6095899343490601,
-0.5096051692962646,
0.642633855342865,
-0.1147695928812027,
-0.5239099264144897,
-0.22365814447402954,
0.3475269079208374,
0.7591269016265869,
0.7468793988227844,
0.19298449158668518,
-0.7206490635871887,
-0.4747222363948822,
-0.8540447950363159,
-0.4710930287837982,
-0.23230701684951782,
-0.18455925583839417,
0.6665288209915161,
0.1831616759300232,
-0.2853182852268219,
1.2081242799758911,
-0.5104156136512756,
-0.3056555986404419,
-0.4894915819168091,
0.06273069977760315,
-0.08077996224164963,
0.43023478984832764,
0.3763894736766815,
-0.6090153455734253,
-1.136892318725586,
0.1145886704325676,
-0.5335417985916138,
-0.013408685103058815,
-0.17820125818252563,
0.1025405153632164,
-0.09389404952526093,
0.6197433471679688,
-0.36078745126724243,
0.5654758214950562,
-0.038005854934453964,
-0.23756709694862366,
0.24887987971305847,
-0.19760537147521973,
-0.06771893799304962,
-1.116004228591919,
-0.11834053695201874,
0.19244475662708282,
-0.5159704685211182,
-0.7916107177734375,
-0.4936242699623108,
-0.12457983195781708,
-0.3623535633087158,
-0.415528267621994,
0.8948467969894409,
0.17691753804683685,
0.1816289871931076,
0.023992734029889107,
0.07230342924594879,
0.0447952076792717,
1.1257721185684204,
-0.16202634572982788,
0.44196680188179016,
0.2825547456741333,
-0.6036094427108765,
0.15641050040721893,
0.5150614380836487,
-0.4306267499923706,
0.8851579427719116,
-0.35553786158561707,
0.529633104801178,
-0.27263373136520386,
0.4476180672645569,
-1.0622658729553223,
-0.49667486548423767,
0.4645920693874359,
-0.18939544260501862,
0.41814303398132324,
-0.23463624715805054,
-0.13620315492153168,
0.16928456723690033,
-0.0846739187836647,
0.04447013884782791,
0.6233946084976196,
-0.6910314559936523,
0.6316862106323242,
0.3522716164588928,
-0.3387475907802582,
-0.05052824690937996,
0.035941943526268005,
-0.05956839397549629,
-0.4889514446258545,
-0.3718419671058655,
0.23498192429542542,
-0.7489649653434753,
-0.367975652217865,
-0.6706063747406006,
0.11393571645021439,
-0.2228090912103653,
0.029721172526478767,
0.4385335147380829,
-0.13460685312747955,
-0.014176657423377037,
0.2825080454349518,
0.04340025782585144,
-0.029061123728752136,
-0.34460726380348206,
-0.18127505481243134,
0.6050450801849365,
-0.008354073390364647,
-0.10304845869541168,
-0.997644305229187,
0.3761208951473236,
0.5890042781829834,
-0.4205946624279022,
0.4189222455024719,
0.3571634888648987,
0.028521964326500893,
-0.17006780207157135,
-0.516901969909668,
-0.37192413210868835,
-0.536532461643219,
0.14516982436180115,
-0.31538453698158264,
-1.0429304838180542,
0.4311331808567047,
-0.5537303686141968,
0.2995292544364929,
-0.18986696004867554,
0.38772985339164734,
-0.584670901298523,
1.2703838348388672,
0.6395946145057678,
-0.006214257795363665,
0.768065869808197,
0.01326652243733406,
0.48289087414741516,
-0.7032727599143982,
-0.3745403587818146,
-0.31667712330818176,
-0.5486944913864136,
-0.45543116331100464,
0.20806413888931274,
0.4034343361854553,
-0.19255882501602173,
-0.7211757302284241,
0.15082508325576782,
-0.19511984288692474,
0.5463664531707764,
0.5728260278701782,
0.2694779634475708,
0.08940853178501129,
-0.3000607490539551,
0.15017209947109222,
-0.32821768522262573,
-0.1586841195821762,
-0.3717200458049774,
1.0151234865188599,
0.18431934714317322,
0.7615198493003845,
0.15940915048122406,
0.807831883430481,
0.24895331263542175,
0.16106626391410828,
-0.6801825165748596,
0.6098357439041138,
-0.2046072781085968,
-0.2512023150920868,
-0.3428419828414917,
-0.3023010790348053,
-1.0073634386062622,
0.027975376695394516,
-0.02834259159862995,
-1.29313325881958,
0.037788886576890945,
0.44055575132369995,
-0.9084552526473999,
-0.06279462575912476,
-0.8726668357849121,
0.7443549036979675,
-0.3209244906902313,
-0.27707135677337646,
-0.18833611905574799,
-0.8554799556732178,
0.2136867344379425,
-0.10544631630182266,
-0.27479156851768494,
-0.20894914865493774,
0.49879956245422363,
0.19976361095905304,
-0.2724458575248718,
1.1865100860595703,
-0.35726800560951233,
0.4092155396938324,
0.04490390792489052,
0.21761004626750946,
0.5077012181282043,
0.40548744797706604,
0.18287961184978485,
-0.42094680666923523,
-0.06666820496320724,
-0.25376924872398376,
-1.0559494495391846,
0.42764419317245483,
-0.542130708694458,
-0.6406663656234741,
-0.08004047721624374,
-0.4285910725593567,
-0.6017424464225769,
0.09085462242364883,
0.33123335242271423,
0.7004966139793396,
-0.6178749799728394,
0.27193331718444824,
0.9506551027297974,
-0.3293500244617462,
0.4222719073295593,
0.6501899361610413,
-0.18775567412376404,
-0.18054524064064026,
0.922803521156311,
-0.13978321850299835,
0.31991153955459595,
0.5334529280662537,
0.30535686016082764,
-0.07685977220535278,
-0.3289967477321625,
-0.36453568935394287,
0.0831102728843689,
-0.5359153151512146,
-0.12220974266529083,
-0.5594128370285034,
-0.24482718110084534,
-0.28370964527130127,
-0.09528829902410507,
-0.17653024196624756,
0.04046707972884178,
-0.4945525825023651,
0.10080540925264359,
-0.12090720981359482,
0.7956177592277527,
0.57780921459198,
0.6447064876556396,
-0.780971348285675,
0.09248040616512299,
0.6157017350196838,
0.19413886964321136,
-0.21974749863147736,
-0.5774571895599365,
-0.41981855034828186,
0.30076804757118225,
-0.818992555141449,
-0.5072540044784546,
0.4694471061229706,
0.7612691521644592,
0.49335166811943054,
0.6872910261154175,
-0.028513362631201744,
0.8503917455673218,
-0.632285475730896,
0.6049632430076599,
0.00815882720053196,
-0.9830157160758972,
0.7675859332084656,
-0.3595074415206909,
0.6033653020858765,
0.9412644505500793,
0.3274954557418823,
-0.47089603543281555,
-0.2928377091884613,
-0.6949585676193237,
-0.3286809027194977,
0.5992590188980103,
-0.09521456807851791,
0.565398097038269,
0.211472749710083,
0.5162336230278015,
0.38300979137420654,
0.29150885343551636,
-0.4121656119823456,
0.011764274910092354,
0.05854453518986702,
-0.17978408932685852,
-0.2992011606693268,
0.009380532428622246,
-0.033509254455566406,
-0.5821630954742432,
0.47572237253189087,
-0.5217317342758179,
-0.20722167193889618,
-0.03648117184638977,
-0.1982356458902359,
-0.09682163596153259,
-0.005995600018650293,
0.5038639903068542,
0.6993945240974426,
-0.3342227041721344,
-0.5255283117294312,
0.09341409802436829,
-0.1837332546710968,
-0.041078440845012665,
-0.3025732934474945,
-0.04615221917629242,
-0.1966933161020279,
-0.07140571624040604,
1.057490348815918,
0.5796412229537964,
-0.9849110841751099,
0.5628219842910767,
-0.4093816876411438,
-0.03515039384365082,
-0.7145923972129822,
0.3662364184856415,
-0.22502608597278595,
0.4388887584209442,
0.07800594717264175,
0.28910812735557556,
0.07772227376699448,
-0.7137768268585205,
0.16086508333683014,
0.524156928062439,
-0.7385005354881287,
-0.5452758073806763,
0.25113093852996826,
0.5742456316947937,
-0.7002655863761902,
0.7237231135368347,
-0.22096748650074005,
-0.08428731560707092,
0.1734829843044281,
0.42267370223999023,
1.08016836643219,
-0.37484076619148254,
0.4542267620563507,
0.4172267019748688,
-0.3059259355068207,
0.18423859775066376,
-0.24134941399097443,
-0.3990384042263031,
-0.7728386521339417,
-0.11695033311843872,
-0.6183860898017883,
-0.660006582736969,
0.37600216269493103,
-0.5520470142364502,
0.42407363653182983,
-0.959963321685791,
0.018517998978495598,
0.04750851169228554,
0.059721771627664566,
-0.7876330614089966,
0.19567811489105225,
-0.017099397256970406,
0.6024337410926819,
-0.5987817645072937,
1.016197919845581,
0.3485757112503052,
-0.275534063577652,
-0.6663911938667297,
0.18296504020690918,
0.05985548719763756,
-0.17855818569660187,
0.8025084733963013,
0.3247838616371155,
-0.2995073199272156,
0.21501049399375916,
-0.5289238095283508,
-0.5557122826576233,
0.8759642839431763,
0.7758618593215942,
-0.6324676871299744,
-0.3381590247154236,
-0.03915173560380936,
0.6128775477409363,
-0.83283931016922,
0.3205163776874542,
0.7566184997558594,
0.04741005226969719,
0.1663748025894165,
-0.8993949890136719,
-0.6285689473152161,
-0.20973099768161774,
-0.08765099197626114,
0.11292098462581635,
-0.7597851157188416,
0.701151967048645,
-0.10534599423408508,
-0.25995394587516785,
0.3791101574897766,
0.39953652024269104,
-0.24401293694972992,
0.275444358587265,
0.39318445324897766,
0.35702624917030334,
0.9891071915626526,
-0.01418248564004898,
0.9191509485244751,
-0.05374639853835106,
-0.016286876052618027,
1.4457690715789795,
-0.5050199627876282,
0.4818264842033386,
0.1488182544708252,
0.033238090574741364,
0.7863430380821228,
0.6535071730613708,
0.2763974368572235,
0.6448912620544434,
0.11151330918073654,
-0.5262289643287659,
-0.5147964358329773,
0.03307212144136429,
0.32180342078208923,
0.7046213746070862,
0.6196972727775574,
-0.351101815700531,
-0.07677534222602844,
0.2154901921749115,
-0.08846352994441986,
0.4970041513442993,
-0.11318960040807724,
1.203985333442688,
0.0782928392291069,
-0.8050533533096313,
0.2877354025840759,
-0.5595349073410034,
0.5217961072921753,
-0.7065796852111816,
-0.24943146109580994,
-0.502433717250824,
0.31271326541900635,
0.0016375893028452992,
-0.39422810077667236,
-0.04519692435860634,
-0.16363456845283508,
-0.13044396042823792,
-0.5770237445831299,
0.40924063324928284,
-0.6130170822143555,
-0.22246088087558746,
0.15722790360450745,
0.48738226294517517,
0.15278275310993195,
0.022289646789431572,
-0.41830965876579285,
-0.5613874793052673,
0.26101672649383545,
0.07602609694004059,
0.7743432521820068,
0.0701669380068779,
-0.028338687494397163,
0.9262275099754333,
0.43826615810394287,
-0.34820038080215454,
-0.27484068274497986,
0.17670972645282745,
0.7583688497543335,
-0.4355500638484955,
-0.48349714279174805,
-0.8091945052146912,
0.8632286787033081,
-0.23982113599777222,
-0.6495190858840942,
0.6260891556739807,
0.703283965587616,
1.1710892915725708,
-0.022334877401590347,
0.949263334274292,
0.3344173729419708,
0.9693855047225952,
-0.3163679242134094,
0.5111937522888184,
-0.3752245604991913,
0.27064353227615356,
-0.33327198028564453,
-0.908543586730957,
-0.12950798869132996,
0.511201798915863,
-0.07071449607610703,
-0.020949114114046097,
0.4630102813243866,
0.881106972694397,
0.014547649770975113,
0.03631995618343353,
0.6513214707374573,
-0.004478636663407087,
0.5801421999931335,
0.6012963652610779,
0.8461900353431702,
0.00539257051423192,
0.18607696890830994,
-0.35085606575012207,
-0.19754450023174286,
-0.20279636979103088,
-0.44392773509025574,
-1.4285329580307007,
-0.9879215955734253,
-0.2605139911174774,
-0.1539386808872223,
0.14528147876262665,
1.2370967864990234,
0.6666576266288757,
-0.6568162441253662,
-0.4695856273174286,
0.05278611555695534,
-0.1424100697040558,
0.10953716933727264,
-0.12774725258350372,
-0.06428235024213791,
-0.6432870030403137,
-1.1178462505340576,
0.7293028831481934,
0.6406615376472473,
0.006042818073183298,
-0.28067874908447266,
-0.41118690371513367,
0.16995751857757568,
0.208870992064476,
0.5849014520645142,
0.583212673664093,
-0.7382404804229736,
-0.524329662322998,
-0.07310468703508377,
-0.03198498487472534,
0.44052237272262573,
1.0811766386032104,
-1.048109769821167,
0.8056678175926208,
0.34503304958343506,
0.5289459228515625,
0.608393669128418,
0.17146365344524384,
0.8461818099021912,
-0.8897088170051575,
0.22232922911643982,
0.5263949632644653,
0.16401338577270508,
0.45755577087402344,
-0.34600919485092163,
0.0753922387957573,
-0.08934971690177917,
-0.6158244609832764,
-0.6335635781288147,
0.7340807318687439,
-0.8021182417869568,
0.08201878517866135,
0.6155045628547668,
-0.47997844219207764,
0.30091002583503723,
-0.4307815134525299,
-0.5301133394241333,
0.013380022719502449,
-0.5523418188095093,
0.7246428728103638,
0.4520648121833801,
-0.6168399453163147,
-0.19520528614521027,
-0.21514973044395447,
0.9721032977104187,
0.2287115901708603,
-0.789905309677124,
-0.1774546355009079,
0.26711928844451904,
0.24362313747406006,
0.06308519840240479,
0.7306447625160217,
0.2776694893836975,
0.2815798819065094,
-0.5659656524658203,
-0.3579074740409851,
0.2875356376171112,
-0.5245852470397949,
-0.18141770362854004,
-0.035725098103284836,
0.19470813870429993,
0.2298869490623474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03101v1
|
KnowAgent: Knowledge-Augmented Planning for LLM-Based Agents
| 2024-03-05T16:39:12 | 2024-03-05T16:39:12 |
Yuqi Zhu, Shuofei Qiao, Yixin Ou, Shumin Deng, Ningyu Zhang, Shiwei Lyu, Yue Shen, Lei Liang, Jinjie Gu, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG, cs.MA
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated great potential in complex
reasoning tasks, yet they fall short when tackling more sophisticated
challenges, especially when interacting with environments through generating
executable actions. This inadequacy primarily stems from the lack of built-in
action knowledge in language agents, which fails to effectively guide the
planning trajectories during task solving and results in planning
hallucination. To address this issue, we introduce KnowAgent, a novel approach
designed to enhance the planning capabilities of LLMs by incorporating explicit
action knowledge. Specifically, KnowAgent employs an action knowledge base and
a knowledgeable self-learning strategy to constrain the action path during
planning, enabling more reasonable trajectory synthesis, and thereby enhancing
the planning performance of language agents. Experimental results on HotpotQA
and ALFWorld based on various backbone models demonstrate that KnowAgent can
achieve comparable or superior performance to existing baselines. Further
analysis indicates the effectiveness of KnowAgent in terms of planning
hallucinations mitigation. Code is available in
https://github.com/zjunlp/KnowAgent.
|
[
-0.28843820095062256,
-0.7326088547706604,
0.8190627098083496,
0.22912605106830597,
0.4216321110725403,
-0.009378872811794281,
-0.048751309514045715,
-0.483333945274353,
0.6833344101905823,
0.8291404843330383,
-0.5937098860740662,
-0.4706607758998871,
-0.19951386749744415,
-0.34594812989234924,
-0.1455596387386322,
0.6331444978713989,
-0.09626945853233337,
-0.19642308354377747,
0.018228529021143913,
-0.06264398247003555,
-0.5725200176239014,
-0.3703888952732086,
-0.6114597320556641,
-0.5591179728507996,
0.4811953902244568,
0.36673301458358765,
0.8934142589569092,
0.3711579442024231,
0.27548590302467346,
0.36883655190467834,
0.10412484407424927,
0.6250013709068298,
-0.31946802139282227,
0.464054137468338,
-0.36399680376052856,
-0.19782263040542603,
-0.8310251832008362,
-0.5764964818954468,
0.14348697662353516,
0.5414345860481262,
-0.19176514446735382,
-0.34710249304771423,
-0.4825949966907501,
0.5655291080474854,
-0.6507778763771057,
0.3369385898113251,
-0.4922466576099396,
0.2436349093914032,
0.44691863656044006,
-0.1926494836807251,
-0.2213529348373413,
-0.10469845682382584,
0.31377536058425903,
-0.7094495296478271,
0.0730440765619278,
-0.08497519046068192,
0.1821812093257904,
0.6914252638816833,
-0.20602932572364807,
-0.3196394443511963,
-1.262792944908142,
0.33285626769065857,
-0.3891594707965851,
0.34555500745773315,
0.43440261483192444,
0.6928324103355408,
-0.4736350476741791,
-0.7085479497909546,
-0.5872815251350403,
-0.07952012121677399,
-0.05793881043791771,
0.04197826609015465,
-0.15734677016735077,
0.18154864013195038,
0.29429975152015686,
0.019874338060617447,
-0.6216899752616882,
-0.05723961442708969,
-0.1606656163930893,
-0.31891101598739624,
0.5653350353240967,
0.1621888428926468,
0.19717390835285187,
0.06880945712327957,
-0.5427208542823792,
0.06763584166765213,
-0.593542754650116,
-0.054843753576278687,
-0.03671653941273689,
0.11457041651010513,
0.2502483129501343,
0.6557897329330444,
-0.44359081983566284,
0.7395331263542175,
-0.1383347362279892,
0.005856328643858433,
-0.17917154729366302,
0.1838785856962204,
-0.19574962556362152,
0.15783555805683136,
0.33152633905410767,
0.0903046578168869,
0.29084497690200806,
-0.38364601135253906,
-0.5269351601600647,
-0.2606082558631897,
0.32460370659828186,
-0.568397581577301,
-0.6210237145423889,
0.4040878415107727,
0.3229367434978485,
-0.004884619265794754,
-0.302102655172348,
-0.4947947859764099,
-0.7779581546783447,
-0.40315330028533936,
0.7999087572097778,
-0.7497690320014954,
-0.3247508704662323,
0.26003119349479675,
-0.01854678802192211,
0.40835875272750854,
0.5828773975372314,
-0.5695288777351379,
0.22527311742305756,
0.4593689739704132,
0.43461132049560547,
0.09898141771554947,
-0.7335605621337891,
-0.6123928427696228,
0.6555224657058716,
-0.43817928433418274,
1.2174242734909058,
-0.3872804045677185,
-0.21595466136932373,
0.01877552457153797,
-0.3300454020500183,
0.08387698978185654,
-0.4602063000202179,
0.20453059673309326,
-0.649941086769104,
-0.23747998476028442,
-0.36994585394859314,
-0.48595932126045227,
-0.41185057163238525,
0.7045337557792664,
-0.7818499803543091,
0.7447443604469299,
0.08135956525802612,
-0.3271596133708954,
0.2995871305465698,
-0.8447597622871399,
-0.5732578635215759,
0.2835647463798523,
-0.27876806259155273,
0.16032153367996216,
-0.33002689480781555,
0.4576278328895569,
0.5544857382774353,
0.27204054594039917,
0.2706145942211151,
0.16032762825489044,
-0.21390630304813385,
0.0812109038233757,
-0.06739947199821472,
0.14909136295318604,
0.037524428218603134,
-0.34282150864601135,
0.5519378185272217,
-0.6699184775352478,
0.12893933057785034,
0.06297104805707932,
-0.14074063301086426,
-0.05648551136255264,
0.09964003413915634,
-0.47035515308380127,
0.2587129473686218,
0.41471606492996216,
-0.0016477983444929123,
0.36399614810943604,
-0.5062711238861084,
-0.015483210794627666,
0.7004867792129517,
0.11587563157081604,
0.5511223673820496,
-0.6691991090774536,
0.6092849373817444,
-0.32583150267601013,
0.033123183995485306,
-0.04454535245895386,
-0.039856649935245514,
-1.0357351303100586,
-0.03635035827755928,
-0.2814297080039978,
0.5837944746017456,
-1.1260124444961548,
0.31763729453086853,
-0.23298420011997223,
-0.8040869832038879,
0.19321021437644958,
-0.1277959942817688,
0.23594218492507935,
0.24347053468227386,
0.4877588748931885,
0.29265904426574707,
-0.500106930732727,
-0.4273225963115692,
-0.39845287799835205,
-0.19635368883609772,
0.3416280746459961,
0.11914274841547012,
0.37579286098480225,
-0.2710018455982208,
1.0656970739364624,
-0.6027613282203674,
-0.5562800765037537,
-0.7454829216003418,
-0.04428618401288986,
-0.15613050758838654,
0.20326273143291473,
0.3191801607608795,
-0.6975209712982178,
-0.06351474672555923,
0.12161371856927872,
-0.8311288356781006,
0.09092774242162704,
-0.09662888199090958,
-0.15284447371959686,
0.08794524520635605,
0.5002076029777527,
-0.8952250480651855,
0.5761236548423767,
0.33005189895629883,
-0.5214649438858032,
0.7718367576599121,
-0.5940757989883423,
-0.1271151900291443,
-0.942740261554718,
-0.07498658448457718,
-0.4103836119174957,
-0.23453032970428467,
-0.8921845555305481,
0.10772659629583359,
-0.1608075201511383,
-0.13925474882125854,
-0.563815712928772,
0.8940639495849609,
-0.5383737683296204,
-0.33680739998817444,
-0.5339676141738892,
0.11859361082315445,
-0.13493070006370544,
0.7149693965911865,
0.40109002590179443,
0.7996345162391663,
0.5266613364219666,
-0.9522147178649902,
0.44768109917640686,
0.38428905606269836,
-0.05475917086005211,
0.23483064770698547,
-0.43489333987236023,
0.15668611228466034,
-0.01177315041422844,
0.10564438253641129,
-0.5510178208351135,
-0.5216140747070312,
0.19699735939502716,
-0.3169081509113312,
0.2584191858768463,
-0.06084499880671501,
-0.3375818431377411,
-0.22999335825443268,
0.037421178072690964,
0.1524536907672882,
0.17081694304943085,
-0.6210961937904358,
1.2018717527389526,
0.4685036540031433,
0.08836706727743149,
-0.6853334903717041,
-0.5801292657852173,
0.02176293358206749,
0.09381525963544846,
-0.5533866882324219,
0.09766778349876404,
-0.14375856518745422,
-0.4431602358818054,
-0.10567868500947952,
-0.20806573331356049,
-0.05579175055027008,
-0.2619949281215668,
0.2926393151283264,
-0.20953378081321716,
0.21722257137298584,
0.4709431231021881,
0.03778407350182533,
-0.16906359791755676,
0.2566865384578705,
-0.4635135531425476,
0.7759226560592651,
0.04611576721072197,
-0.4813739061355591,
0.12120872735977173,
0.14974865317344666,
0.5973519086837769,
-0.4604297876358032,
0.5280065536499023,
0.3007175326347351,
-0.4250554144382477,
-0.6072424054145813,
-0.6165292859077454,
-0.26602277159690857,
-0.492660790681839,
0.4022701680660248,
-0.5231592655181885,
-0.632675051689148,
0.5989938378334045,
-0.4033786356449127,
0.13722173869609833,
0.036422181874513626,
0.39780324697494507,
0.2821192443370819,
0.7384654879570007,
0.6376634240150452,
0.19083455204963684,
0.1947486251592636,
-0.49292710423469543,
0.2940482795238495,
-0.4927280843257904,
-0.4814624488353729,
-0.09541509300470352,
-0.28567928075790405,
-0.26257210969924927,
-0.9101219773292542,
0.4862596392631531,
-0.34061041474342346,
-0.33517003059387207,
0.23437756299972534,
-0.21147117018699646,
0.5702484846115112,
0.25222939252853394,
0.00160667160525918,
0.3686174750328064,
-0.029440447688102722,
-0.08591536432504654,
0.255458265542984,
-0.7262305617332458,
-0.4958900511264801,
0.7444936633110046,
-0.008369004353880882,
0.8009634613990784,
0.18588605523109436,
0.6741467118263245,
0.38879430294036865,
-0.08022402971982956,
-0.910658061504364,
0.9785686135292053,
0.4723508059978485,
-0.49194982647895813,
-0.6832940578460693,
-0.19797943532466888,
-0.9236369729042053,
0.07266992330551147,
-0.04415249451994896,
-0.6436634659767151,
0.12888658046722412,
0.2201000303030014,
-0.39632880687713623,
0.4863046109676361,
-0.5007471442222595,
0.5643348097801208,
-0.5164967179298401,
-0.3533145487308502,
-0.21550250053405762,
-0.3664447069168091,
0.037802472710609436,
0.03257410228252411,
0.08906197547912598,
-0.15566985309123993,
-0.1942979246377945,
0.5646131634712219,
-0.5765289068222046,
0.7044154405593872,
-0.3471142053604126,
-0.2260025590658188,
0.41760969161987305,
0.5471946001052856,
1.1774587631225586,
-0.20103225111961365,
-0.030399776995182037,
-0.2921087443828583,
-0.3525082767009735,
-0.387600839138031,
-0.7957512736320496,
0.8651765584945679,
-0.6825873255729675,
-0.8041800856590271,
-0.22083188593387604,
-1.0521653890609741,
-0.48284950852394104,
0.26725029945373535,
0.003369278274476528,
0.2595607042312622,
-0.39484280347824097,
-0.4966752231121063,
0.7262102365493774,
-0.20003633201122284,
0.49049341678619385,
0.8195738196372986,
-0.694062352180481,
-0.34195226430892944,
0.8705064654350281,
0.3194659948348999,
0.1449776142835617,
0.5389395952224731,
0.09020508080720901,
-0.028509274125099182,
-0.49764472246170044,
-0.1145554631948471,
0.2902102470397949,
-0.9502785205841064,
-0.02564394846558571,
-0.8094632625579834,
-0.48733943700790405,
-0.4411045014858246,
-0.30377376079559326,
-0.4819948375225067,
-0.5718508362770081,
0.28557896614074707,
-0.3179820775985718,
0.5400958061218262,
1.0727757215499878,
-0.12449967861175537,
0.36492472887039185,
-0.35585254430770874,
0.16751326620578766,
0.674468994140625,
0.0320897214114666,
-0.17355652153491974,
-0.030744098126888275,
-0.18497343361377716,
-0.18225185573101044,
-0.1991964429616928,
-0.8477608561515808,
0.7359315156936646,
-0.1372383087873459,
0.7541303634643555,
0.4387022852897644,
0.3762797713279724,
0.6366914510726929,
-0.17431674897670746,
0.5287960171699524,
-0.3205960690975189,
-0.502494215965271,
0.9009670615196228,
-0.43243443965911865,
0.4561980962753296,
0.3131431043148041,
0.2714666724205017,
-0.18138892948627472,
-0.4796806871891022,
-0.6564399600028992,
-0.7254317402839661,
0.508480966091156,
0.3874083161354065,
-0.16074760258197784,
0.23871807754039764,
0.13873513042926788,
0.0880965143442154,
0.11843126267194748,
-0.6121250987052917,
-0.1003924235701561,
0.0650908574461937,
0.22758010029792786,
0.07732849568128586,
-0.21207524836063385,
-0.1592593789100647,
-0.11314607411623001,
0.6147897243499756,
-0.2301625907421112,
0.3482482433319092,
0.45817506313323975,
-0.3575132191181183,
-0.1627531349658966,
0.13606105744838715,
0.7642151117324829,
0.9624412655830383,
-0.18808752298355103,
0.3735591173171997,
0.4246957302093506,
-0.5319636464118958,
0.03853244706988335,
0.2901958227157593,
-0.06536135822534561,
-0.2761154770851135,
0.393891304731369,
0.5482176542282104,
0.12084994465112686,
-0.8903840780258179,
0.20085643231868744,
-0.08568200469017029,
-0.18287192285060883,
-0.932860255241394,
0.41162246465682983,
-0.04465453326702118,
0.7376208305358887,
0.2542444169521332,
0.1632920354604721,
0.0307758878916502,
-0.25203898549079895,
0.02326847054064274,
0.18378636240959167,
-0.7786809206008911,
-0.2687233090400696,
0.25714734196662903,
0.15309548377990723,
-0.6111636757850647,
0.01980256475508213,
-0.28265494108200073,
-0.6746272444725037,
0.5321565866470337,
0.5150695443153381,
0.7609795928001404,
-0.5282948613166809,
0.2150103896856308,
0.06552187353372574,
0.4720519483089447,
0.04135055094957352,
0.6754754185676575,
-0.0980725809931755,
-0.9074705243110657,
-0.4473380744457245,
-0.2944452464580536,
-0.323810338973999,
0.16524283587932587,
0.016798043623566628,
0.32628360390663147,
-0.43077462911605835,
0.11137460917234421,
-0.5631061792373657,
0.021548550575971603,
-0.6372430920600891,
0.06359276920557022,
-0.3127693831920624,
0.9484016299247742,
-0.4677117168903351,
0.6962987184524536,
1.1480233669281006,
-0.2867479622364044,
-1.2335530519485474,
0.2113250344991684,
-0.21371930837631226,
-0.844323456287384,
0.3505335748195648,
0.11298439651727676,
-0.5016656517982483,
0.1391235888004303,
-0.33898767828941345,
-0.9240393042564392,
1.4345154762268066,
0.3129671514034271,
-0.3656434416770935,
-0.16923415660858154,
0.2457951158285141,
0.40965574979782104,
-0.2815124988555908,
0.08665935695171356,
0.4631199240684509,
0.6797728538513184,
0.512438178062439,
-0.7303421497344971,
0.041821543127298355,
-0.0359729565680027,
-0.5584880709648132,
0.45952531695365906,
-0.536249041557312,
0.36069151759147644,
-0.6238753199577332,
0.024397462606430054,
-0.16352614760398865,
0.8144457340240479,
0.48459428548812866,
0.5975344181060791,
0.35954058170318604,
0.5245903730392456,
0.9236057996749878,
0.2956054210662842,
0.7859431505203247,
-0.3923380970954895,
-0.06398457288742065,
1.2768856287002563,
-0.38570985198020935,
0.5962096452713013,
0.2810412347316742,
0.17317934334278107,
0.38074880838394165,
0.039513394236564636,
0.43054282665252686,
0.4376785159111023,
-0.07085976749658585,
-0.4345705807209015,
-0.5670920014381409,
-0.002557463012635708,
-0.04032395780086517,
0.6707068681716919,
0.5241828560829163,
-0.03869671747088432,
-0.37453556060791016,
0.09237980842590332,
0.2703077793121338,
0.14249984920024872,
-0.4182160794734955,
0.7729365229606628,
-0.16263872385025024,
-0.9270798563957214,
0.35084497928619385,
-0.4483559727668762,
0.07646866887807846,
-0.6620558500289917,
-0.21724668145179749,
-0.2969849109649658,
0.4459901750087738,
-0.06017063930630684,
-0.8713762760162354,
0.2552030086517334,
-0.3237578868865967,
0.06649373471736908,
-0.032862380146980286,
1.2398087978363037,
-0.39357995986938477,
-0.1490602344274521,
0.4144380986690521,
0.9617278575897217,
0.24664276838302612,
-0.42672744393348694,
-0.27041178941726685,
-0.35463717579841614,
-0.20737387239933014,
-0.3090137243270874,
0.09708357602357864,
0.8180918097496033,
-0.16126857697963715,
1.2478699684143066,
0.38358065485954285,
0.2337736338376999,
-0.14662250876426697,
-0.029493121430277824,
1.0390183925628662,
-0.8315942287445068,
-0.35594046115875244,
-0.5012426376342773,
0.38894909620285034,
-0.08978137373924255,
0.03213861212134361,
0.6552256345748901,
0.5768170952796936,
0.5207096338272095,
-0.05264861509203911,
0.6805099248886108,
0.016700172796845436,
0.3181666135787964,
-0.5185583233833313,
0.7822031378746033,
-0.21270489692687988,
0.639107882976532,
0.07743468135595322,
-0.9025444388389587,
-0.2919890582561493,
0.4661158621311188,
-0.7510207295417786,
0.20156064629554749,
0.5818002820014954,
0.9832122325897217,
0.12779180705547333,
-0.2803539037704468,
0.821357786655426,
0.18702451884746552,
0.5410640239715576,
0.6146382093429565,
1.1126389503479004,
-0.03393621742725372,
0.759835422039032,
-0.30300500988960266,
-0.07424674928188324,
-0.09248335659503937,
-0.6826590299606323,
-1.1293877363204956,
-0.5175437331199646,
-0.018067553639411926,
0.051707424223423004,
0.21789251267910004,
0.9286981821060181,
0.7691559195518494,
-0.3340056240558624,
-0.2694430947303772,
-0.3808012902736664,
0.36472195386886597,
-0.17823930084705353,
-0.1425597220659256,
0.34286922216415405,
-0.372577041387558,
-0.28214266896247864,
0.6455301642417908,
0.34087690711021423,
0.11742187291383743,
-0.47411486506462097,
-0.6082881689071655,
-0.3003239333629608,
0.21310901641845703,
0.6323310732841492,
0.41865766048431396,
-0.6898332238197327,
-0.11209488660097122,
0.1502281129360199,
0.1455974280834198,
-0.27904385328292847,
0.8999283909797668,
-1.1982455253601074,
0.493563175201416,
0.3187771439552307,
0.2384079396724701,
0.4315377473831177,
-0.23365169763565063,
0.7063215374946594,
-0.6993223428726196,
0.184227854013443,
0.3961726725101471,
0.2962372899055481,
0.14596529304981232,
-0.5790942907333374,
0.6866170763969421,
-0.135152205824852,
-0.8481513857841492,
-0.34083375334739685,
0.3855384588241577,
-0.8581066131591797,
-0.37317171692848206,
1.285811185836792,
0.08181695640087128,
-0.3057677149772644,
-0.19842742383480072,
-0.5798215270042419,
0.2656131386756897,
-0.3193374276161194,
0.7393824458122253,
0.27404868602752686,
-0.4006282687187195,
-0.24878674745559692,
-0.44248995184898376,
0.6659408807754517,
0.22875571250915527,
-1.005448341369629,
0.3048674762248993,
0.5755715370178223,
-0.04206647351384163,
0.29521316289901733,
0.5458329319953918,
0.3891581594944,
0.2851680815219879,
-0.10011529177427292,
0.492062509059906,
-0.36109301447868347,
-0.7173828482627869,
0.1482788622379303,
0.10697472840547562,
0.4034942090511322,
0.2678259015083313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03100v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03100v3
|
NaturalSpeech 3: Zero-Shot Speech Synthesis with Factorized Codec and Diffusion Models
| 2024-03-05T16:35:25 | 2024-04-23T08:38:03 |
Zeqian Ju, Yuancheng Wang, Kai Shen, Xu Tan, Detai Xin, Dongchao Yang, Yanqing Liu, Yichong Leng, Kaitao Song, Siliang Tang, Zhizheng Wu, Tao Qin, Xiang-Yang Li, Wei Ye, Shikun Zhang, Jiang Bian, Lei He, Jinyu Li, Sheng Zhao
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
While recent large-scale text-to-speech (TTS) models have achieved
significant progress, they still fall short in speech quality, similarity, and
prosody. Considering speech intricately encompasses various attributes (e.g.,
content, prosody, timbre, and acoustic details) that pose significant
challenges for generation, a natural idea is to factorize speech into
individual subspaces representing different attributes and generate them
individually. Motivated by it, we propose NaturalSpeech 3, a TTS system with
novel factorized diffusion models to generate natural speech in a zero-shot
way. Specifically, 1) we design a neural codec with factorized vector
quantization (FVQ) to disentangle speech waveform into subspaces of content,
prosody, timbre, and acoustic details; 2) we propose a factorized diffusion
model to generate attributes in each subspace following its corresponding
prompt. With this factorization design, NaturalSpeech 3 can effectively and
efficiently model intricate speech with disentangled subspaces in a
divide-and-conquer way. Experiments show that NaturalSpeech 3 outperforms the
state-of-the-art TTS systems on quality, similarity, prosody, and
intelligibility, and achieves on-par quality with human recordings.
Furthermore, we achieve better performance by scaling to 1B parameters and 200K
hours of training data.
|
[
-0.6518347859382629,
-1.096935749053955,
0.5123857855796814,
0.3131074607372284,
-0.44596555829048157,
0.18722327053546906,
-0.04995906725525856,
-0.44237637519836426,
0.41626864671707153,
0.31076157093048096,
-0.6879603862762451,
-0.496557354927063,
-0.24430954456329346,
0.2248581051826477,
-0.560667097568512,
0.9215015769004822,
0.19611060619354248,
0.23524042963981628,
0.27348989248275757,
-0.02331716939806938,
-0.4161298871040344,
-0.2362280935049057,
-0.7653912901878357,
-0.2626985013484955,
0.35797059535980225,
0.3520859181880951,
0.569292426109314,
0.31248676776885986,
0.029194341972470284,
0.2577396333217621,
-0.13753116130828857,
0.12560336291790009,
-0.19597797095775604,
0.14346498250961304,
0.14289088547229767,
-0.40106067061424255,
-0.5481662154197693,
0.13379433751106262,
0.6533290147781372,
0.6013186573982239,
-0.26188787817955017,
-0.027020307257771492,
0.002728383056819439,
0.5225121974945068,
-0.4436548054218292,
-0.15523451566696167,
-0.4123314321041107,
0.2572164535522461,
-0.14758893847465515,
-0.1774429976940155,
-0.2770860195159912,
-0.6978801488876343,
0.3012141287326813,
-0.48311740159988403,
0.7205626964569092,
-0.28010013699531555,
0.3861735761165619,
0.19899289309978485,
-0.24186301231384277,
0.03322397917509079,
-1.1042317152023315,
0.6801379919052124,
-0.985291600227356,
0.23606278002262115,
0.419035941362381,
0.33875033259391785,
-0.08944007009267807,
-0.5512781739234924,
-0.816592276096344,
-0.30168718099594116,
0.3807336986064911,
0.0548708550632,
-0.46911704540252686,
0.016721269115805626,
-0.10174697637557983,
0.47591865062713623,
-0.7520284652709961,
0.10903701186180115,
-0.2681235671043396,
-0.2625594437122345,
0.5110694169998169,
0.07393553107976913,
0.38614633679389954,
-0.287058025598526,
-0.08300506323575974,
0.11400429904460907,
-0.6067190766334534,
-0.1797102838754654,
0.4251156151294708,
0.471675306558609,
-0.10317542403936386,
0.4410592317581177,
-0.3325284421443939,
1.069307804107666,
0.073699451982975,
-0.21889151632785797,
0.25615987181663513,
-0.3345924913883209,
-0.13551673293113708,
0.35244008898735046,
0.8743423819541931,
0.08750763535499573,
-0.0877731516957283,
-0.24746377766132355,
-0.05239498242735863,
-0.05307509005069733,
0.44343113899230957,
-0.8290656805038452,
0.07285784184932709,
0.4144209027290344,
-0.1004134863615036,
-0.43149706721305847,
-0.13367599248886108,
-0.6378244757652283,
-0.09042910486459732,
-0.647851824760437,
0.8066450357437134,
-0.7699583768844604,
-0.44241371750831604,
0.12889394164085388,
-0.0814899206161499,
0.03343593701720238,
0.2514018714427948,
-0.7996413707733154,
0.5419467091560364,
0.5772580504417419,
1.237362265586853,
-0.19199542701244354,
-0.2809106707572937,
-0.7991959452629089,
-0.12058430165052414,
-0.6600944399833679,
0.5305777788162231,
-0.2224084585905075,
-0.5130234956741333,
-0.16772772371768951,
-0.303351491689682,
0.3637917637825012,
-0.4315570294857025,
0.1851578801870346,
-0.22664512693881989,
0.24807973206043243,
0.07017243653535843,
-0.4316224753856659,
-0.1402081400156021,
-0.16385549306869507,
-0.6073791980743408,
0.7986276149749756,
-0.05206615850329399,
-0.4069921672344208,
0.24046467244625092,
-0.7916927933692932,
-0.7016297578811646,
0.17930947244167328,
0.031997911632061005,
-0.2387719452381134,
0.4911104142665863,
0.11362648755311966,
0.45428621768951416,
-0.36638930439949036,
0.28555062413215637,
-0.09893622994422913,
-0.3595193922519684,
0.30253279209136963,
-0.6646462082862854,
0.4592449963092804,
0.32507002353668213,
-0.6415045261383057,
-0.05917635187506676,
-0.9473943114280701,
-0.020236745476722717,
0.0012666104594245553,
0.07413013279438019,
-0.029462996870279312,
-0.10446541011333466,
-0.17838069796562195,
0.0777892917394638,
-0.2354602962732315,
-0.9231587052345276,
-0.20598183572292328,
-0.6901633143424988,
0.7677789330482483,
0.34930452704429626,
0.4457586705684662,
0.8369832634925842,
-0.09917008876800537,
0.4240371584892273,
-0.07289667427539825,
0.08949515968561172,
0.16980431973934174,
-0.5237456560134888,
-0.8242627382278442,
-0.6446346044540405,
0.3567560613155365,
0.21332059800624847,
-0.9660362005233765,
0.4260410964488983,
-0.1829797625541687,
-0.6700344681739807,
-0.48835456371307373,
-0.3629184067249298,
0.07948911935091019,
0.6518136262893677,
0.43531784415245056,
-0.20358425378799438,
-0.341529905796051,
-0.9743162989616394,
0.19212527573108673,
0.13045525550842285,
-0.7664825320243835,
-0.1130552813410759,
0.2818135619163513,
0.1256338357925415,
1.0798425674438477,
-0.6217966079711914,
-0.4445978105068207,
-0.1642315685749054,
0.6240275502204895,
0.23348021507263184,
0.5229218006134033,
0.5565353035926819,
-0.36870715022087097,
-0.17224113643169403,
-0.18376651406288147,
-0.1422877460718155,
0.008525961078703403,
0.006179099436849356,
-0.32903653383255005,
0.14307647943496704,
0.3669641315937042,
-0.5711320638656616,
0.4427012503147125,
0.31924039125442505,
-0.16502101719379425,
0.2779645025730133,
-0.018811726942658424,
0.1799733191728592,
-1.017328143119812,
0.1958344429731369,
-0.036354172974824905,
-0.29941487312316895,
-1.1016974449157715,
-0.16545075178146362,
-0.29182523488998413,
-0.5849971771240234,
-0.6706473231315613,
0.1797569990158081,
0.00018801628903020173,
0.06334535032510757,
-0.4291357100009918,
0.2265326827764511,
0.13358666002750397,
0.6082837581634521,
0.3043055832386017,
0.766539990901947,
0.6925013065338135,
-0.7398749589920044,
0.14437614381313324,
0.13093647360801697,
-0.12489404529333115,
0.8033834099769592,
-0.7980366945266724,
0.29640093445777893,
-0.0375104583799839,
0.4120748043060303,
-0.6347848773002625,
-0.23556387424468994,
-0.09422770142555237,
-0.7800947427749634,
0.20398902893066406,
-0.04638490453362465,
-0.5529101490974426,
-0.17253230512142181,
-0.31528982520103455,
0.19352221488952637,
0.6083201169967651,
-0.3962107300758362,
0.6445493102073669,
0.2773624658584595,
-0.28947678208351135,
0.15269289910793304,
-0.9896922707557678,
0.1485038697719574,
0.030981959775090218,
-0.670825719833374,
0.6579281687736511,
0.06373268365859985,
0.3405112028121948,
0.07341516762971878,
-0.22065846621990204,
-0.3476349413394928,
-0.16895030438899994,
0.07986747473478317,
0.24333293735980988,
-0.15460067987442017,
-0.2451484650373459,
-0.11224193125963211,
-0.1593327820301056,
-0.08326709270477295,
-0.33201277256011963,
0.4278820753097534,
-0.09766696393489838,
-0.1924850046634674,
-0.5014617443084717,
0.4835754930973053,
0.5659729242324829,
-0.32621273398399353,
0.4850391745567322,
0.7665595412254333,
-0.588527500629425,
-0.3989376425743103,
-0.3224015235900879,
-0.18676479160785675,
-0.44884932041168213,
0.10042957216501236,
-0.013444885611534119,
-1.1649919748306274,
0.2205314040184021,
0.24367251992225647,
0.005968973506242037,
0.14871971309185028,
0.5467329621315002,
-0.061374396085739136,
1.2136852741241455,
0.26936331391334534,
0.23259440064430237,
0.4985736310482025,
-0.38101401925086975,
0.5160472989082336,
-0.5985028743743896,
-0.0805518701672554,
-0.43723800778388977,
-0.39227673411369324,
-0.5091912746429443,
-0.7852389812469482,
0.5564951300621033,
-0.06920799612998962,
-0.38347190618515015,
0.35478878021240234,
-0.6390548348426819,
0.39613214135169983,
0.882887065410614,
0.08646328002214432,
-0.045514896512031555,
0.3147708773612976,
-0.12622903287410736,
-0.17817634344100952,
-0.5097270607948303,
-0.2268248200416565,
0.7548834681510925,
0.3846668601036072,
0.21727272868156433,
0.4675079882144928,
0.9587734937667847,
0.09163061529397964,
-0.13331587612628937,
-0.7522993683815002,
0.5198137760162354,
-0.35970956087112427,
-0.613373875617981,
-0.30285629630088806,
-0.45777833461761475,
-0.5059076547622681,
0.12506364285945892,
-0.23981410264968872,
-0.6771979928016663,
0.2941048741340637,
0.06963660567998886,
-0.8068411946296692,
0.2224331945180893,
-0.7425377368927002,
0.23626340925693512,
0.19978784024715424,
-0.767113208770752,
-0.20569922029972076,
-0.49862203001976013,
0.41358113288879395,
-0.05822889134287834,
-0.017238803207874298,
-0.161289244890213,
0.21831636130809784,
0.7157871127128601,
-0.5326271653175354,
0.6750105619430542,
-0.3567962646484375,
-0.003628087928518653,
0.6293920874595642,
0.6637904047966003,
0.08127152174711227,
0.20857085287570953,
0.026604000478982925,
0.3635799288749695,
-0.14442738890647888,
-0.19540536403656006,
-0.6108608245849609,
0.8581868410110474,
-0.5832713842391968,
-0.2739447057247162,
-0.2747308015823364,
0.06749870628118515,
-0.6241894960403442,
0.19084613025188446,
0.4095987379550934,
0.9000908136367798,
-0.3304804861545563,
0.22116805613040924,
0.5549854636192322,
-0.2764226496219635,
0.6884864568710327,
0.9496709704399109,
0.006449142005294561,
-0.8321012258529663,
1.4024441242218018,
0.15598896145820618,
0.3382441997528076,
0.2688203752040863,
0.20747165381908417,
-0.20549333095550537,
-0.45324376225471497,
-0.30703648924827576,
0.060383591800928116,
-0.26075199246406555,
-0.6120529174804688,
-0.4006788432598114,
-0.43046140670776367,
-0.2136419415473938,
-0.23154473304748535,
-0.7652251720428467,
-0.4572920501232147,
-0.6194421648979187,
-0.3271370828151703,
0.37572526931762695,
0.8332780003547668,
-0.6214280724525452,
0.29474112391471863,
-0.7756769061088562,
0.8761187195777893,
0.5382637977600098,
0.57070392370224,
0.07003665715456009,
-0.47679972648620605,
0.023914337158203125,
0.1886776238679886,
-0.2639152705669403,
-0.9389674663543701,
0.5675660967826843,
0.15876458585262299,
0.1875472217798233,
0.13940300047397614,
-0.07861605286598206,
0.5735850930213928,
-0.868372917175293,
1.1562877893447876,
0.4870012700557709,
-1.1970877647399902,
0.7211028933525085,
-0.29404976963996887,
0.4803988039493561,
0.463652104139328,
0.08752527087926865,
-0.43864357471466064,
-0.46513640880584717,
-0.5569025874137878,
-0.8941494226455688,
0.921921968460083,
0.761734127998352,
0.0020481024403125048,
-0.1760687232017517,
-0.033258095383644104,
0.09763404726982117,
0.1864422708749771,
-0.41370272636413574,
-0.10900593549013138,
-0.5934756398200989,
-0.056207749992609024,
-0.01867707073688507,
-0.15742111206054688,
-0.17192013561725616,
-0.3115483522415161,
0.6555046439170837,
0.022145481780171394,
0.5908339619636536,
0.35327717661857605,
0.14350423216819763,
-0.006445500999689102,
0.3545284569263458,
0.8791344165802002,
0.1061653420329094,
-0.3926856815814972,
0.34846973419189453,
-0.07879848033189774,
-0.4956130385398865,
0.414033442735672,
0.10201842337846756,
-0.14472469687461853,
0.23649559915065765,
0.34884074330329895,
1.2109479904174805,
0.2618253231048584,
-0.07647715508937836,
0.5583364367485046,
-0.18041111528873444,
-0.6269005537033081,
-0.10426431894302368,
0.11933984607458115,
0.07438750565052032,
-0.18290816247463226,
0.46059882640838623,
0.3504192531108856,
0.2675411105155945,
-0.05344471335411072,
0.21697625517845154,
0.07073467969894409,
-0.30748629570007324,
-0.4787988066673279,
0.7565184831619263,
0.6719323992729187,
-0.5128821730613708,
0.33445990085601807,
-0.39294740557670593,
-0.12311939150094986,
0.24564585089683533,
0.4058596193790436,
1.242659568786621,
-0.2470220923423767,
0.7947274446487427,
0.5260187983512878,
0.1740778684616089,
-0.009832390584051609,
0.19384287297725677,
-0.25699442625045776,
-0.32426100969314575,
-0.7057114839553833,
-0.774105966091156,
-0.35686635971069336,
0.29507288336753845,
-0.5758638978004456,
0.1688481718301773,
-0.5480878949165344,
-0.192392036318779,
0.08694233000278473,
-0.2801688313484192,
-0.7438880801200867,
0.07834485173225403,
0.47145894169807434,
0.6599478721618652,
-0.8618903160095215,
0.5638241767883301,
0.15075801312923431,
-0.34371957182884216,
-0.7807543873786926,
0.01192118227481842,
0.15384431183338165,
-0.2964135408401489,
0.24794700741767883,
0.08504743129014969,
-0.3494897484779358,
0.3465562164783478,
-0.5445611476898193,
-0.8411121368408203,
0.9428683519363403,
0.38995566964149475,
-0.5636479258537292,
0.3045070171356201,
0.4361557066440582,
0.700395941734314,
-0.20194900035858154,
0.029946208000183105,
0.9257976412773132,
0.10065457969903946,
0.23511233925819397,
-0.7265267968177795,
-0.2973327040672302,
0.016779929399490356,
0.1619964987039566,
0.004508600570261478,
-0.24057404696941376,
0.5412327647209167,
0.04341795668005943,
-0.38786008954048157,
-0.18544624745845795,
0.5872201323509216,
0.26686155796051025,
-0.007719652261584997,
0.4124193787574768,
0.39718297123908997,
0.5262313485145569,
-0.07241203635931015,
0.7468218803405762,
-0.05813411995768547,
-0.014555854722857475,
1.1152437925338745,
-0.42172786593437195,
0.9822360277175903,
0.39019033312797546,
-0.312374085187912,
0.2714513838291168,
0.23222661018371582,
0.3885313868522644,
0.7572961449623108,
0.1837635040283203,
-0.6934577822685242,
-0.13315381109714508,
-0.017630470916628838,
-0.11179624497890472,
0.5555147528648376,
0.1926964968442917,
0.19409172236919403,
-0.3840295672416687,
0.2608643174171448,
-0.1771273910999298,
-0.02114485763013363,
0.043347880244255066,
0.8605794906616211,
-0.1158585473895073,
-0.6500629782676697,
0.6913614273071289,
0.09274259954690933,
0.6571860313415527,
-0.8360341191291809,
-0.3049222528934479,
-0.4798295497894287,
-0.38282206654548645,
-0.12313312292098999,
-0.702955424785614,
0.25821760296821594,
0.1652485728263855,
-0.17709539830684662,
-0.18400712311267853,
0.3476099967956543,
-0.3438832759857178,
-0.453884482383728,
-0.10623598098754883,
0.2162654995918274,
-0.21155528724193573,
-0.20231281220912933,
-0.3870510458946228,
0.14249837398529053,
0.2788058817386627,
-0.09959205985069275,
0.05591575801372528,
0.2691204845905304,
0.31244194507598877,
0.4211495518684387,
0.756000280380249,
0.25625765323638916,
0.04019659385085106,
0.3115778863430023,
0.5413183569908142,
-0.5030978918075562,
-0.6672645807266235,
-0.7162166833877563,
0.557603657245636,
-0.03692823275923729,
-0.1902422457933426,
0.42437538504600525,
0.2570782005786896,
0.23934020102024078,
-0.11607591062784195,
0.6300398707389832,
-0.10158710926771164,
0.7567291259765625,
-0.5379378795623779,
0.5140337944030762,
-0.34476974606513977,
0.002795468783006072,
-0.3511752188205719,
-1.0244309902191162,
-0.3961504399776459,
0.6654624342918396,
0.05626441538333893,
-0.21394945681095123,
0.63592129945755,
0.9451873898506165,
0.0765070840716362,
0.3004392981529236,
0.44515010714530945,
0.14208665490150452,
0.5808559060096741,
0.3543793261051178,
0.6999210119247437,
-0.2730512320995331,
0.3627142906188965,
-0.4488295912742615,
-0.3162710666656494,
-0.16226419806480408,
-0.8280206918716431,
-0.3636682331562042,
-0.7029843330383301,
-0.5652568936347961,
-0.0011603557504713535,
-0.29888686537742615,
0.6588582396507263,
0.8312158584594727,
-0.7892168164253235,
0.06350753456354141,
-0.7419495582580566,
-0.24363362789154053,
-0.007480392698198557,
-0.3138197660446167,
0.06507571041584015,
-0.09625901281833649,
-0.762673556804657,
0.9532670378684998,
0.4607214033603668,
0.3687308728694916,
-0.5352212190628052,
0.015001071617007256,
-0.07172558456659317,
0.24458001554012299,
0.6602742075920105,
0.27688074111938477,
-0.6453964114189148,
-0.2984205186367035,
0.0324186310172081,
0.17424333095550537,
-0.22228394448757172,
0.8806699514389038,
-0.8679318428039551,
0.6371836066246033,
0.5436354875564575,
0.29589810967445374,
0.5788549780845642,
-0.18722669780254364,
0.9050298929214478,
-1.2403985261917114,
0.33921122550964355,
0.5386005640029907,
0.015861522406339645,
0.4244137704372406,
-0.04405045509338379,
0.4182138741016388,
-0.10417324304580688,
-0.43399399518966675,
-0.8887744545936584,
0.13216334581375122,
-0.7714472413063049,
-0.3344242572784424,
1.1050630807876587,
0.3437405228614807,
-0.14281997084617615,
0.09929249435663223,
-0.36174091696739197,
0.31209826469421387,
-0.37725502252578735,
0.20278815925121307,
0.4314294755458832,
-0.3083474636077881,
0.15984000265598297,
-0.655747652053833,
0.6655104756355286,
0.2975638508796692,
-0.39717555046081543,
0.020381050184369087,
0.8224985599517822,
0.4260958731174469,
0.23410195112228394,
0.6829610466957092,
-0.11925467848777771,
0.34319406747817993,
0.17749857902526855,
0.2867929935455322,
-0.08013177663087845,
-0.1878165304660797,
-0.5290651917457581,
0.18218129873275757,
-0.009030790068209171,
-0.5225951671600342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03075v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03075v1
|
Detecting Concrete Visual Tokens for Multimodal Machine Translation
| 2024-03-05T16:01:09 | 2024-03-05T16:01:09 |
Braeden Bowen, Vipin Vijayan, Scott Grigsby, Timothy Anderson, Jeremy Gwinnup
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The challenge of visual grounding and masking in multimodal machine
translation (MMT) systems has encouraged varying approaches to the detection
and selection of visually-grounded text tokens for masking. We introduce new
methods for detection of visually and contextually relevant (concrete) tokens
from source sentences, including detection with natural language processing
(NLP), detection with object detection, and a joint detection-verification
technique. We also introduce new methods for selection of detected tokens,
including shortest $n$ tokens, longest $n$ tokens, and all detected concrete
tokens. We utilize the GRAM MMT architecture to train models against
synthetically collated multimodal datasets of source images with masked
sentences, showing performance improvements and improved usage of visual
context during translation tasks over the baseline model.
|
[
-0.4137583076953888,
-0.6113361716270447,
0.5127779841423035,
0.267583966255188,
-0.6899144053459167,
0.04863198846578598,
-0.09853726625442505,
-0.2750888764858246,
-0.044972702860832214,
0.5140746235847473,
-0.5332664847373962,
-0.6088254451751709,
-0.9232581257820129,
0.3477339446544647,
-0.4436461925506592,
0.7739588618278503,
-0.23200742900371552,
0.12641756236553192,
-0.3588949143886566,
-0.29548847675323486,
-0.8927158713340759,
-0.6678665280342102,
-0.48163050413131714,
0.013727434910833836,
0.3634442389011383,
0.25282829999923706,
0.5680537819862366,
0.6694665551185608,
0.8110259771347046,
0.3579944372177124,
0.07252269238233566,
0.5232194066047668,
0.14736458659172058,
0.16857600212097168,
0.14475403726100922,
-0.24492208659648895,
-0.2565886676311493,
0.021211840212345123,
0.6427309513092041,
0.3370751738548279,
0.5272154808044434,
0.21446657180786133,
-0.20279796421527863,
0.4612780511379242,
-0.7579453587532043,
0.43654173612594604,
-0.7185625433921814,
0.3524335026741028,
-0.3503246605396271,
-0.5106779336929321,
-0.7071638107299805,
0.38126665353775024,
-0.45610323548316956,
-0.3708217442035675,
0.2969438433647156,
0.3162534832954407,
0.6573694348335266,
0.37374651432037354,
-0.8616564273834229,
-0.21874511241912842,
-0.2902292013168335,
0.7124586701393127,
-0.32944145798683167,
0.7322403192520142,
0.40737974643707275,
0.5285293459892273,
-0.13851135969161987,
-0.923825204372406,
-0.67755526304245,
-0.4087313413619995,
-0.26283201575279236,
0.31469765305519104,
-0.1485345959663391,
0.20481984317302704,
0.2967545986175537,
0.2742144465446472,
-0.6210669875144958,
-0.2540147006511688,
-0.1850648671388626,
-0.5102732181549072,
-0.1319209784269333,
-0.1197015568614006,
0.67444908618927,
-0.5586962699890137,
-0.7119452357292175,
-0.2943701446056366,
-0.41730597615242004,
-0.26935091614723206,
-0.09898985177278519,
0.11243820935487747,
-0.1783202737569809,
0.8631834983825684,
-0.33554667234420776,
0.7789707779884338,
-0.24166370928287506,
-0.4305087625980377,
0.34527185559272766,
-0.6869254112243652,
-0.34476402401924133,
-0.16419678926467896,
0.6445580124855042,
0.5281122326850891,
0.2543056011199951,
-0.18520747125148773,
-0.4638495147228241,
0.32620829343795776,
-0.09303487092256546,
-0.6506727933883667,
-0.09187383204698563,
-0.10186654329299927,
-0.6475145816802979,
-0.41269829869270325,
0.06761220842599869,
-0.46884235739707947,
-0.10095564275979996,
-0.4331579804420471,
0.24077655375003815,
-0.33220282196998596,
-0.06976879388093948,
0.007528990041464567,
-0.6341254711151123,
0.11291920393705368,
0.15559512376785278,
-0.8624421954154968,
0.09935284405946732,
0.3731189966201782,
1.037005066871643,
-0.18997719883918762,
-0.23872530460357666,
-0.9102632403373718,
0.36055609583854675,
-0.399807870388031,
0.8297765254974365,
-0.45572665333747864,
-0.03986978158354759,
0.07003001123666763,
0.14891543984413147,
-0.16763904690742493,
-0.5377417802810669,
0.6611133813858032,
-0.3670036196708679,
0.09253716468811035,
-0.1591651737689972,
-0.0883493423461914,
0.018951117992401123,
0.7056102156639099,
-0.6345505118370056,
0.8414477109909058,
-0.019271619617938995,
-0.7407945990562439,
0.6497840285301208,
-0.7401483058929443,
-0.4483089745044708,
0.004324627108871937,
-0.36740902066230774,
-0.25056102871894836,
0.24060097336769104,
0.6975571513175964,
0.5885326266288757,
0.07404402643442154,
0.2201116532087326,
-0.19081689417362213,
-0.2033773511648178,
0.4607006907463074,
-0.7862844467163086,
0.4913639426231384,
0.40985867381095886,
-0.3555120527744293,
0.24621130526065826,
-0.9263622760772705,
-0.18571379780769348,
-0.03692987933754921,
-0.28344401717185974,
-0.12462977319955826,
0.0012194407172501087,
0.4924524426460266,
0.6150081157684326,
-0.0032382849603891373,
-0.49785229563713074,
0.091965451836586,
0.19677264988422394,
0.6140795350074768,
0.8049625158309937,
0.006344006396830082,
0.21849417686462402,
0.06604668498039246,
0.47444257140159607,
0.47084537148475647,
0.17297689616680145,
-0.7091949582099915,
-0.7332022190093994,
-0.8899065256118774,
-0.6631380915641785,
0.2251565307378769,
0.5530073642730713,
-1.293105959892273,
0.20098598301410675,
-0.2977309226989746,
0.22386109828948975,
-0.36929598450660706,
0.10128055512905121,
0.3743104338645935,
0.4143998324871063,
0.5904560685157776,
-0.23552146553993225,
-0.6455921530723572,
-0.9480557441711426,
-0.17576944828033447,
-0.11690827459096909,
-0.06375611573457718,
-0.008952264674007893,
0.8620998859405518,
-0.37285467982292175,
0.8047475814819336,
-0.375656396150589,
-0.5627158880233765,
0.14985544979572296,
0.3276345729827881,
-0.1313212513923645,
0.7384627461433411,
0.5774157047271729,
-1.1865209341049194,
-0.45520538091659546,
0.22083042562007904,
-0.809712290763855,
-0.18006673455238342,
-0.21497848629951477,
-0.01858198456466198,
-0.017596278339624405,
1.1484965085983276,
-0.7159872651100159,
0.42754849791526794,
0.621751070022583,
-0.38563305139541626,
0.3144780397415161,
-0.06306476145982742,
0.4297511577606201,
-1.0490601062774658,
0.07859963923692703,
-0.22054755687713623,
-0.8777452111244202,
-0.3063715994358063,
0.36950016021728516,
0.326953649520874,
-0.23489251732826233,
-0.6126312017440796,
0.42109623551368713,
-0.6262044310569763,
-0.1636120229959488,
-0.29851728677749634,
0.16661982238292694,
0.07567288726568222,
0.5287447571754456,
-0.07583092153072357,
0.9341559410095215,
0.33823251724243164,
-0.3109804689884186,
0.4156823456287384,
0.25026071071624756,
-0.21463163197040558,
0.8765612840652466,
-0.3305613696575165,
0.19418849050998688,
-0.2631801664829254,
0.35403090715408325,
-1.0814766883850098,
-0.13430792093276978,
0.5894060134887695,
-0.5597627758979797,
0.1751125156879425,
-0.5120553374290466,
-0.9047325253486633,
-0.16542768478393555,
-0.11706709116697311,
0.5861201286315918,
0.3218124210834503,
-0.5117039084434509,
0.504469096660614,
-0.02598269283771515,
0.19884420931339264,
-0.5318924784660339,
-0.8010404109954834,
0.7084088921546936,
-0.17465101182460785,
-0.5326884984970093,
0.40442773699760437,
-0.08278650045394897,
0.06749148666858673,
-0.0472729355096817,
-0.18626363575458527,
-0.14163346588611603,
0.16144254803657532,
0.20135223865509033,
0.09577173739671707,
-0.17208240926265717,
-0.07060499489307404,
-0.011821181513369083,
-0.471632719039917,
-0.11743848025798798,
-0.6013660430908203,
0.5306995511054993,
-0.04457835853099823,
-0.6607233881950378,
-0.3089311718940735,
0.4126517176628113,
0.8973200917243958,
-0.5441080927848816,
0.6439376473426819,
1.340744137763977,
-0.5262755751609802,
0.41041773557662964,
-0.6749178171157837,
-0.018530700355768204,
-0.41584575176239014,
0.42659711837768555,
-0.6333558559417725,
-0.7488540410995483,
0.4373217821121216,
0.07238505035638809,
-0.37926679849624634,
0.41184505820274353,
0.5974700450897217,
0.1504412144422531,
1.550316572189331,
0.6308635473251343,
0.08828054368495941,
0.6574118137359619,
-0.004009338561445475,
0.20197618007659912,
-0.9713627099990845,
-0.2128746211528778,
-0.31443607807159424,
-0.12997201085090637,
-0.5711798071861267,
-0.8284474015235901,
0.36487483978271484,
0.17131327092647552,
0.3051401376724243,
0.2188190519809723,
-0.37466520071029663,
0.7005746960639954,
0.6357517838478088,
0.09130383282899857,
0.436466246843338,
0.08886545896530151,
-0.5672407746315002,
0.029415318742394447,
-0.29830777645111084,
-0.5041967034339905,
0.8422608971595764,
0.23893551528453827,
0.08564877510070801,
0.09874483942985535,
0.3048592209815979,
0.4124878942966461,
0.29093137383461,
-0.5707732439041138,
0.48217418789863586,
-0.14938360452651978,
-0.5415267944335938,
0.15938740968704224,
-0.27727603912353516,
-0.581790030002594,
0.5226513147354126,
-0.3138614892959595,
-0.4380316436290741,
0.033898599445819855,
0.0574057400226593,
0.20068296790122986,
0.2570239007472992,
-0.6919721364974976,
1.1028386354446411,
-0.00939564872533083,
0.13118787109851837,
0.04730743169784546,
-0.6762112975120544,
0.36416950821876526,
0.09441950917243958,
0.1593320220708847,
-0.0009144768700934947,
-0.17831513285636902,
0.4356086254119873,
-0.02455182373523712,
0.746086061000824,
-0.10574431717395782,
0.10553477704524994,
0.001366833341307938,
-0.001977371284738183,
0.4214116930961609,
0.07992014288902283,
0.4293200969696045,
0.09248197823762894,
-0.09508994221687317,
-0.6303122639656067,
-0.48773014545440674,
0.38549286127090454,
-0.3770581781864166,
-0.25714752078056335,
-0.4161115884780884,
-0.5459113121032715,
0.11613652110099792,
0.4754769802093506,
0.31394872069358826,
0.31906071305274963,
-0.034561414271593094,
0.43831196427345276,
0.30392003059387207,
-0.1526685357093811,
0.45800867676734924,
0.12325260788202286,
-0.26307040452957153,
-0.7518306970596313,
0.8826955556869507,
-0.17707189917564392,
0.29374584555625916,
0.5725370049476624,
-0.01749727874994278,
-0.1768428534269333,
-0.9144232273101807,
-0.8284962773323059,
-0.08270871639251709,
-1.0272438526153564,
-0.43541669845581055,
-0.7555446624755859,
0.0852549821138382,
-0.6223604679107666,
-0.09218140691518784,
-0.01699644885957241,
-0.3181706666946411,
-0.16673772037029266,
-0.17997443675994873,
-0.012796059250831604,
0.35178714990615845,
0.004626332316547632,
0.3489841818809509,
-0.7662709951400757,
0.8001798391342163,
0.39366865158081055,
0.11377543210983276,
-0.5377848148345947,
-0.28298816084861755,
-0.1673106551170349,
0.014322993345558643,
-0.2895318567752838,
-0.7966738343238831,
0.3717014491558075,
0.03383028507232666,
0.3531777560710907,
0.5817244648933411,
-0.21313774585723877,
0.9009688496589661,
-0.729042649269104,
0.8082469701766968,
0.4330741763114929,
-0.9458301663398743,
0.5032258033752441,
-0.35398516058921814,
0.33027514815330505,
0.3956432044506073,
-0.07365287095308304,
-0.8581753969192505,
-0.5225301384925842,
-0.14553266763687134,
-0.7148180603981018,
0.3895762264728546,
0.5719137787818909,
0.20325103402137756,
-0.45682385563850403,
0.04564400017261505,
-0.3353084325790405,
0.46659061312675476,
-1.2194782495498657,
-0.02945556864142418,
-0.30732280015945435,
-0.3133973777294159,
-0.0771290734410286,
-0.27184781432151794,
-0.011841877363622189,
-0.018523424863815308,
0.22456102073192596,
-0.44957321882247925,
0.36938604712486267,
0.2826192080974579,
-0.6460555195808411,
0.051354002207517624,
0.07931088656187057,
0.9808392524719238,
0.37233075499534607,
-0.3071238398551941,
0.6289960741996765,
-0.0071739801205694675,
-0.3699432909488678,
0.05159734934568405,
-0.12348476052284241,
-0.20681482553482056,
0.32168862223625183,
0.6194280982017517,
0.7216460108757019,
0.2725679278373718,
-0.6730969548225403,
0.8083446621894836,
0.026645967736840248,
-0.05072848126292229,
-0.27701476216316223,
-0.4405207335948944,
-0.21142584085464478,
0.0823013111948967,
0.21338681876659393,
0.6471506357192993,
0.23218278586864471,
-0.602250337600708,
0.3524559438228607,
0.5409713387489319,
-0.663663923740387,
-0.2372749149799347,
0.7072657346725464,
0.07270935922861099,
-0.2561534643173218,
0.4691741168498993,
-0.23208440840244293,
-0.834713339805603,
0.4976378381252289,
0.7635377049446106,
0.8389406800270081,
0.0980471819639206,
0.18128949403762817,
-0.06701609492301941,
0.6524683833122253,
0.0833330899477005,
-0.10536766052246094,
-0.213599294424057,
-0.6060569286346436,
-0.5374671220779419,
-0.3307454288005829,
0.023310834541916847,
0.04226469621062279,
-0.3614734411239624,
0.5085064172744751,
-0.2290835827589035,
-0.103037029504776,
-0.22764383256435394,
-0.5995965003967285,
-0.7635697722434998,
0.20968197286128998,
0.44411852955818176,
0.7017066478729248,
-1.135206937789917,
0.6876013278961182,
0.6523119211196899,
-0.656093955039978,
-0.13578194379806519,
-0.2476806491613388,
0.004579116590321064,
-0.9129590392112732,
1.090988039970398,
0.40044155716896057,
-0.07945224642753601,
-0.03433110564947128,
-0.4768840968608856,
-0.5318554639816284,
0.9756270051002502,
0.4260348081588745,
0.049336519092321396,
0.08098603039979935,
0.3027515709400177,
0.21222367882728577,
-0.3222966492176056,
0.2344064563512802,
0.17291322350502014,
0.6333745718002319,
0.07101011276245117,
-0.7544378042221069,
0.021352162584662437,
-0.32016894221305847,
-0.020783735439181328,
0.18529152870178223,
-0.30209916830062866,
0.947604238986969,
0.41375407576560974,
-0.22034718096256256,
0.07401811331510544,
0.5664110779762268,
0.20070961117744446,
0.39970663189888,
0.5435861945152283,
0.5713414549827576,
0.3845898509025574,
-0.022974051535129547,
0.8474925756454468,
-0.20656552910804749,
0.1093926802277565,
0.7514104843139648,
0.059478066861629486,
0.7289499640464783,
0.9003583788871765,
0.1783386766910553,
0.4145857095718384,
0.5231865048408508,
-0.10652007162570953,
0.6042017936706543,
0.035577066242694855,
-0.33142945170402527,
-0.2650741934776306,
-0.29687604308128357,
-0.38265150785446167,
0.5017287731170654,
0.05910472571849823,
-0.46058782935142517,
-0.14746877551078796,
0.44843772053718567,
-0.04901944473385811,
0.0049468642100691795,
-0.0806950256228447,
0.7658554315567017,
0.08201844245195389,
-0.6233512163162231,
0.47679558396339417,
0.5376662611961365,
0.532086193561554,
-0.3300057351589203,
-0.33723756670951843,
-0.2614867389202118,
0.13609130680561066,
0.015058704651892185,
-0.17601805925369263,
0.11878836899995804,
0.0040580700151622295,
-0.1871645599603653,
-0.6666789650917053,
0.8251937031745911,
-0.454501748085022,
-0.5812723636627197,
0.12523390352725983,
0.45855358242988586,
0.04297998547554016,
-0.4860611855983734,
-0.5321986675262451,
-0.007792214397341013,
-0.15878956019878387,
0.08888920396566391,
0.35202527046203613,
0.7768207788467407,
-0.27381324768066406,
0.6382807493209839,
1.193203330039978,
-0.0858076959848404,
0.40831881761550903,
0.09640050679445267,
0.8350446224212646,
-0.6074864864349365,
-0.6218016743659973,
-1.0598634481430054,
0.5879884958267212,
-0.2803097069263458,
-0.13157914578914642,
0.8391317129135132,
0.6179079413414001,
0.9017926454544067,
-0.4196609854698181,
0.37173619866371155,
0.21171896159648895,
-0.33540889620780945,
-1.0587339401245117,
0.38218560814857483,
-0.39491006731987,
-0.016283856704831123,
-0.4000868499279022,
-1.0365887880325317,
-0.7183364033699036,
0.7202189564704895,
0.2579616606235504,
-0.24981336295604706,
1.2215712070465088,
0.6439427733421326,
-0.479044109582901,
-0.4929374158382416,
0.6142396926879883,
-0.2518698275089264,
0.5655753016471863,
0.25616905093193054,
0.8212121725082397,
-0.7240635752677917,
0.8136212825775146,
0.01209949143230915,
-0.1071876585483551,
-0.31588611006736755,
-1.1826921701431274,
-1.083853006362915,
-0.7026598453521729,
-0.40054523944854736,
-0.15419679880142212,
-0.18215183913707733,
0.8108818531036377,
1.031873345375061,
-0.8253960013389587,
0.02858840674161911,
-0.2360437959432602,
0.16848565638065338,
-0.46948006749153137,
-0.17186646163463593,
0.21243825554847717,
-0.6085501313209534,
-0.6388634443283081,
0.5176587700843811,
0.6066992282867432,
0.30013981461524963,
-0.11520211398601532,
0.016849316656589508,
-0.35059216618537903,
-0.2082446664571762,
0.9670036435127258,
-0.23443487286567688,
-0.8781073093414307,
-0.5348902940750122,
0.12482257187366486,
-0.06211981177330017,
0.07462175190448761,
1.0896084308624268,
-0.7110472321510315,
0.5632661581039429,
0.48285096883773804,
0.5586323738098145,
0.5863446593284607,
-0.1942274123430252,
0.4019524157047272,
-1.2916591167449951,
0.7283170819282532,
-0.008579835295677185,
0.5634650588035583,
0.3862347900867462,
0.034360893070697784,
0.5177178978919983,
0.6481331586837769,
-0.11314225941896439,
-1.0701133012771606,
0.38982224464416504,
-1.0737531185150146,
-0.1475195288658142,
0.8132091760635376,
-0.11775070428848267,
-0.1789122074842453,
-0.2536484897136688,
-0.5183036923408508,
0.2966199815273285,
-0.008109023794531822,
0.4414592683315277,
0.7825286388397217,
0.5081119537353516,
-0.38988250494003296,
-0.9150909185409546,
0.31477808952331543,
0.37905803322792053,
-0.6333996653556824,
-0.20007364451885223,
0.5124163627624512,
-0.07391970604658127,
0.3928378224372864,
0.6289593577384949,
-0.18859411776065826,
0.2758060395717621,
0.005388599820435047,
-0.0016124004032462835,
-0.2423637956380844,
-0.44598281383514404,
-0.12089122831821442,
0.1904839277267456,
-0.018045829609036446,
-0.7435441017150879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03045v1
|
Adding Multimodal Capabilities to a Text-only Translation Model
| 2024-03-05T15:28:24 | 2024-03-05T15:28:24 |
Vipin Vijayan, Braeden Bowen, Scott Grigsby, Timothy Anderson, Jeremy Gwinnup
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While most current work in multimodal machine translation (MMT) uses the
Multi30k dataset for training and evaluation, we find that the resulting models
overfit to the Multi30k dataset to an extreme degree. Consequently, these
models perform very badly when evaluated against typical text-only testing sets
such as the WMT newstest datasets. In order to perform well on both Multi30k
and typical text-only datasets, we use a performant text-only machine
translation (MT) model as the starting point of our MMT model. We add
vision-text adapter layers connected via gating mechanisms to the MT model, and
incrementally transform the MT model into an MMT model by 1) pre-training using
vision-based masking of the source text and 2) fine-tuning on Multi30k.
|
[
-0.43724995851516724,
-0.42755571007728577,
0.6621270179748535,
0.19007766246795654,
-0.4582207202911377,
-0.051601920276880264,
-0.07162369787693024,
-0.3731437027454376,
-0.09599456936120987,
0.6615380048751831,
-0.8138622045516968,
-0.2774917781352997,
-0.7300164103507996,
0.20001208782196045,
-0.3677331805229187,
1.3313806056976318,
-0.20499369502067566,
0.1117701306939125,
-0.20196129381656647,
-0.36263638734817505,
-0.44788068532943726,
-0.4802088737487793,
-0.2516436278820038,
-0.19590112566947937,
0.545580267906189,
0.35864582657814026,
0.6150239706039429,
0.6054757833480835,
0.7935628294944763,
0.2448548674583435,
0.15301775932312012,
0.3934994339942932,
-0.07728289067745209,
-0.20715603232383728,
0.02434716373682022,
-0.3406745195388794,
-0.735312819480896,
0.14522062242031097,
0.661738395690918,
0.318305104970932,
0.11067657917737961,
0.2703033685684204,
0.03408123925328255,
0.38777849078178406,
-0.34869185090065,
0.16630449891090393,
-0.6228172183036804,
0.01963992603123188,
-0.2133224606513977,
-0.336262047290802,
-0.624788224697113,
0.07166583091020584,
0.14907854795455933,
-0.6652935743331909,
0.09911993891000748,
0.06572144478559494,
0.8201645612716675,
0.14554181694984436,
-0.9269316792488098,
-0.06577074527740479,
-0.642055094242096,
0.7800669074058533,
-0.48400112986564636,
0.5909309387207031,
0.2787024974822998,
0.4902115762233734,
0.32213136553764343,
-0.5520809888839722,
-0.7414533495903015,
-0.35003167390823364,
-0.02636532485485077,
0.473049134016037,
-0.05553116649389267,
0.11681568622589111,
0.23769740760326385,
0.3309580981731415,
-0.7091421484947205,
-0.1571614295244217,
-0.41245654225349426,
-0.0868334248661995,
0.2425529658794403,
0.20223769545555115,
0.27862057089805603,
-0.3348166346549988,
-0.7471933364868164,
-0.4695071578025818,
-0.3535534143447876,
-0.05988708883523941,
0.09648926556110382,
0.29737818241119385,
-0.04402785375714302,
1.0301047563552856,
-0.06350238621234894,
0.656250536441803,
-0.2761800289154053,
-0.09591266512870789,
0.46485063433647156,
-0.6082831025123596,
-0.5501642823219299,
-0.3223865032196045,
0.7231560349464417,
0.5442128777503967,
0.18335728347301483,
-0.09787808358669281,
-0.4573386311531067,
0.10614985972642899,
0.4253675043582916,
-0.7906057834625244,
-0.19263553619384766,
0.0036164477933198214,
-0.4157540798187256,
-0.4430692493915558,
-0.17388339340686798,
-0.6386831998825073,
-0.37364616990089417,
-0.32436367869377136,
0.8412694334983826,
-0.5480539798736572,
-0.23068353533744812,
0.041701678186655045,
-0.22330579161643982,
-0.0337587334215641,
0.2847587764263153,
-0.6852078437805176,
0.06551039218902588,
0.0666920393705368,
0.9191749095916748,
-0.08801562339067459,
-0.6501554846763611,
-0.2741704285144806,
0.27164849638938904,
-0.3470558822154999,
0.810064435005188,
-0.33443892002105713,
-0.1381663829088211,
-0.14121714234352112,
0.3437638282775879,
-0.4655153453350067,
-0.3009048104286194,
0.6219572424888611,
-0.3969813287258148,
0.1309618353843689,
-0.17922405898571014,
-0.20585273206233978,
-0.37639808654785156,
0.35563531517982483,
-0.6238288879394531,
0.8728820085525513,
0.20872041583061218,
-0.5634552836418152,
0.5396080613136292,
-1.0768983364105225,
-0.4952172338962555,
-0.0962982177734375,
0.22881624102592468,
-0.48612186312675476,
0.33179542422294617,
0.541886568069458,
0.47459667921066284,
-0.08003546297550201,
0.027987133711576462,
-0.24386397004127502,
-0.05070384591817856,
0.38584449887275696,
-0.813647449016571,
0.3502678871154785,
0.2723888158798218,
-0.04551384598016739,
0.21422097086906433,
-0.9155155420303345,
-0.050266485661268234,
0.0617571659386158,
-0.464616060256958,
-0.1987753063440323,
-0.11825890839099884,
0.4884427785873413,
0.5943937301635742,
0.030071884393692017,
-0.5149312615394592,
0.23209908604621887,
-0.042417097836732864,
0.40956833958625793,
0.7288426756858826,
-0.3816107213497162,
0.45167815685272217,
-0.4927857518196106,
0.5464081168174744,
0.33697617053985596,
0.2002841830253601,
-0.5127217769622803,
-0.6046876907348633,
-0.9233081340789795,
-0.3207624554634094,
0.18959860503673553,
0.8045505881309509,
-1.2748943567276,
-0.19173172116279602,
-0.5511237978935242,
-0.4515225887298584,
-0.6654128432273865,
0.13363763689994812,
0.37542709708213806,
0.4013036787509918,
0.5809606313705444,
-0.26491183042526245,
-0.4272722601890564,
-1.0654447078704834,
-0.0656161680817604,
0.17145128548145294,
-0.1203693300485611,
0.18549491465091705,
0.6459177732467651,
-0.2628718912601471,
0.4924817979335785,
-0.3289314806461334,
-0.5604532361030579,
-0.19829073548316956,
0.12968358397483826,
0.05490898713469505,
0.41753774881362915,
0.5752851366996765,
-0.8899521231651306,
-0.4877181053161621,
0.3522566854953766,
-0.7054968476295471,
-0.012105702422559261,
-0.15842203795909882,
0.09733032435178757,
0.06593989580869675,
0.4129451811313629,
-0.5462552905082703,
0.3856261968612671,
1.0600824356079102,
-0.23491370677947998,
0.5192080736160278,
-0.31252631545066833,
0.5786627531051636,
-1.3412898778915405,
0.0009878118289634585,
0.0635022222995758,
-0.5230157375335693,
-0.6128360033035278,
0.19405217468738556,
0.49558043479919434,
-0.39469584822654724,
-0.5549659132957458,
0.3891248106956482,
-0.4046086072921753,
0.1744493544101715,
-0.2677155137062073,
0.030210746452212334,
0.28833162784576416,
0.5301461815834045,
-0.19839240610599518,
1.0474278926849365,
0.23860056698322296,
-0.6442968845367432,
0.37930071353912354,
0.31971481442451477,
-0.4288628101348877,
0.8173511624336243,
-0.38098546862602234,
-0.0328504703938961,
-0.06667143106460571,
0.11607800424098969,
-1.0058866739273071,
-0.31648334860801697,
0.0684061273932457,
-0.4699561297893524,
0.20739781856536865,
-0.18565280735492706,
-0.7435570955276489,
-0.40195727348327637,
-0.2644883096218109,
0.40824100375175476,
0.17664901912212372,
-0.40892159938812256,
0.6776673197746277,
0.06432673335075378,
-0.1007876992225647,
-0.18150997161865234,
-1.121424674987793,
0.37897175550460815,
-0.15995319187641144,
-0.7440405488014221,
0.3877739906311035,
-0.10335128009319305,
0.3285742402076721,
-0.17516009509563446,
0.11152219772338867,
-0.2560681998729706,
-0.09380583465099335,
0.08276192098855972,
0.28453072905540466,
-0.36111313104629517,
0.17288297414779663,
0.23142434656620026,
-0.27910786867141724,
-0.4367976486682892,
-0.33737725019454956,
0.4576384723186493,
0.03139492869377136,
-0.4214020073413849,
-0.4707731008529663,
0.45765766501426697,
1.0889075994491577,
-0.5846573114395142,
0.9280928373336792,
0.8792710304260254,
-0.1851349025964737,
0.21755965054035187,
-0.5406810641288757,
-0.04222937673330307,
-0.4133166968822479,
0.877167284488678,
-0.9353598356246948,
-0.6356492042541504,
0.49108871817588806,
0.11060690879821777,
0.075692318379879,
0.5366551280021667,
0.5519665479660034,
-0.29067203402519226,
1.3903748989105225,
0.8526747226715088,
0.39054569602012634,
0.6860117316246033,
0.13160978257656097,
-0.027169302105903625,
-1.0920153856277466,
-0.11665117740631104,
-0.11848854273557663,
-0.26705658435821533,
-0.5713006854057312,
-0.36813294887542725,
0.35940080881118774,
-0.20965205132961273,
0.015458548441529274,
0.640313446521759,
-0.41215094923973083,
0.23420408368110657,
0.5193161964416504,
0.35621216893196106,
0.4395310580730438,
0.15521574020385742,
-0.28182336688041687,
-0.19929476082324982,
-0.5811716914176941,
-0.493567556142807,
1.3931294679641724,
0.32824987173080444,
0.59935462474823,
0.2905038893222809,
-0.009974556975066662,
0.07867468893527985,
0.45622366666793823,
-0.5369277000427246,
0.3201749622821808,
-0.5811925530433655,
-0.7653647065162659,
0.010954047553241253,
-0.5066284537315369,
-0.5610380172729492,
0.4125244915485382,
-0.2471812516450882,
-0.3835035264492035,
0.112004354596138,
-0.004779874347150326,
-0.23321132361888885,
0.46484002470970154,
-1.1376984119415283,
1.0352178812026978,
-0.1700110286474228,
0.030132565647363663,
0.14460906386375427,
-0.42930176854133606,
0.3776295483112335,
-0.3121388256549835,
0.40693965554237366,
-0.058599237352609634,
-0.08257322013378143,
0.6031378507614136,
0.038347817957401276,
0.7050309777259827,
-0.13803178071975708,
-0.11254163086414337,
0.011252920143306255,
0.09865289181470871,
0.40599697828292847,
-0.1512073278427124,
0.12446056306362152,
-0.057966772466897964,
0.19709807634353638,
-0.4441966116428375,
-0.5632741451263428,
0.38857901096343994,
-0.7268880605697632,
-0.3219988942146301,
-0.26473793387413025,
-0.9493205547332764,
-0.13556666672229767,
0.24965503811836243,
0.20754292607307434,
0.39185208082199097,
0.0005552443908527493,
0.30975741147994995,
0.534760594367981,
-0.08854827284812927,
0.4241844713687897,
0.5375704169273376,
-0.4631125032901764,
-0.6357762813568115,
1.1393046379089355,
0.2910698354244232,
0.6725972890853882,
0.3575814664363861,
0.04306473582983017,
-0.26648980379104614,
-0.641758918762207,
-1.1027859449386597,
-0.1961110532283783,
-0.6990258097648621,
-0.0808524489402771,
-0.8278166055679321,
-0.16334742307662964,
-0.5247700214385986,
0.1390274614095688,
-0.4534653127193451,
-0.27781885862350464,
-0.06006051227450371,
-0.04613615199923515,
0.21807533502578735,
0.5564820766448975,
0.14776673913002014,
0.6931440830230713,
-1.011268138885498,
0.3946518003940582,
0.3416048586368561,
0.26720884442329407,
-0.36838439106941223,
-0.7351444363594055,
-0.5140826106071472,
0.19129398465156555,
-0.5663426518440247,
-0.7731602787971497,
0.3709549903869629,
0.2270292490720749,
0.2994459569454193,
0.30569973587989807,
-0.3160059452056885,
0.9234558343887329,
-0.7030090093612671,
0.5892015099525452,
0.20353363454341888,
-0.7966409921646118,
0.349012553691864,
-0.547513484954834,
0.5656654834747314,
0.5132603049278259,
0.10445450991392136,
-0.6298167109489441,
-0.26079338788986206,
-0.13399337232112885,
-0.5406691431999207,
0.672939121723175,
0.4559309482574463,
0.4460369348526001,
0.2410690188407898,
0.0808248296380043,
0.15095964074134827,
0.3279375731945038,
-1.1497130393981934,
0.07303555309772491,
-0.5018827319145203,
-0.3326139748096466,
-0.446219265460968,
-0.29129910469055176,
-0.06496787816286087,
-0.25797832012176514,
0.49401211738586426,
-0.3025374114513397,
0.3366222381591797,
0.14655879139900208,
-0.4541877508163452,
0.012152818962931633,
0.2902001440525055,
0.8794630765914917,
0.6116415858268738,
-0.32625317573547363,
0.22944635152816772,
0.15410131216049194,
-0.5853619575500488,
0.16350285708904266,
0.18474310636520386,
-0.10732808709144592,
-0.129325270652771,
0.23985981941223145,
0.906761109828949,
0.08139414340257645,
-0.3939177691936493,
0.5842134356498718,
-0.016742920503020287,
-0.20609909296035767,
0.22800159454345703,
-0.2422390729188919,
-0.035355761647224426,
0.22926458716392517,
0.42695221304893494,
0.6114386320114136,
-0.09575394541025162,
-0.35709309577941895,
0.4402526617050171,
0.1782795786857605,
-0.730287492275238,
-0.338456392288208,
0.8053008913993835,
0.08749555051326752,
0.02484706975519657,
0.41192859411239624,
0.032344043254852295,
-0.5948070883750916,
0.46876001358032227,
0.6271584630012512,
0.7106776237487793,
-0.45812198519706726,
0.18326061964035034,
0.12212119996547699,
0.903275191783905,
0.08886660635471344,
0.047633036971092224,
0.07378432899713516,
-0.5879472494125366,
-0.6404116749763489,
-0.5739683508872986,
-0.23083624243736267,
0.037612270563840866,
-0.6029871702194214,
0.4073379933834076,
-0.053601086139678955,
-0.1891968995332718,
-0.028658626601099968,
-0.2739996910095215,
-0.7360193729400635,
0.568243682384491,
-0.08661416172981262,
0.6750140190124512,
-0.9710118770599365,
1.0631911754608154,
0.8854795098304749,
-0.6068263649940491,
-0.24069491028785706,
-0.18877722322940826,
-0.061780210584402084,
-0.9561082720756531,
0.28204911947250366,
0.3492429554462433,
0.22928576171398163,
0.17778316140174866,
-0.28293323516845703,
-0.5543093681335449,
1.0815370082855225,
0.34006956219673157,
-0.3431411683559418,
-0.05096299573779106,
0.3955099284648895,
0.13559813797473907,
-0.3541405200958252,
0.23011897504329681,
0.0235452800989151,
0.5842675566673279,
0.11102934181690216,
-1.1468920707702637,
-0.08765364438295364,
-0.245879665017128,
0.01856086403131485,
0.10355772823095322,
-0.5812222361564636,
1.1044758558273315,
0.0567963570356369,
-0.16244956851005554,
0.0839444026350975,
0.4422912895679474,
-0.14229068160057068,
0.2591079771518707,
0.37442073225975037,
0.6862809062004089,
0.36247679591178894,
-0.03028874658048153,
1.2883212566375732,
0.03323207423090935,
0.380239874124527,
1.0798437595367432,
0.01672300137579441,
0.7403156161308289,
0.6010985970497131,
-0.15601569414138794,
-0.05003752559423447,
0.6423256993293762,
-0.2170291692018509,
0.7728412747383118,
-0.22501708567142487,
-0.21479402482509613,
-0.3410702049732208,
0.0027719305362552404,
-0.4351538121700287,
0.5329798460006714,
-0.05733708664774895,
-0.5453205704689026,
-0.2883414924144745,
0.6927471160888672,
-0.1484680324792862,
-0.22753842175006866,
-0.13072778284549713,
0.7027878761291504,
0.01921316795051098,
-0.3868120610713959,
0.25457248091697693,
0.44022053480148315,
0.6652165651321411,
-0.6396223306655884,
0.1252581775188446,
-0.06363214552402496,
0.21809814870357513,
-0.009590035304427147,
-0.7780601382255554,
0.5092154741287231,
-0.08114323765039444,
-0.4840870797634125,
-0.4070715010166168,
0.4558578431606293,
-0.4410858452320099,
-0.9322725534439087,
0.1728597730398178,
0.6828252077102661,
-0.05851057544350624,
-0.6224366426467896,
-0.46398741006851196,
-0.1472802311182022,
0.15220502018928528,
-0.32843634486198425,
0.49351945519447327,
0.7245587110519409,
-0.08203084766864777,
0.7433041930198669,
1.0224934816360474,
-0.15875838696956635,
0.3582049608230591,
-0.05421921983361244,
0.9640472531318665,
-0.6037906408309937,
-0.23283067345619202,
-1.0534669160842896,
0.7618411183357239,
0.08961022645235062,
-0.35996341705322266,
0.8056827783584595,
0.6089141964912415,
0.7308260202407837,
-0.16094262897968292,
0.6311444640159607,
0.03596644103527069,
0.035619914531707764,
-0.5366726517677307,
1.0924113988876343,
-0.8922547101974487,
-0.08349084109067917,
-0.3475496768951416,
-1.0141363143920898,
-0.45112329721450806,
0.4487060606479645,
-0.006608326453715563,
0.03199685737490654,
0.8986994028091431,
0.6105343699455261,
-0.4184139668941498,
0.00825376994907856,
0.8921117186546326,
0.22565901279449463,
0.46208110451698303,
0.5833491086959839,
0.5865914821624756,
-0.8337441682815552,
0.9756064414978027,
-0.12905189394950867,
-0.47925299406051636,
0.021783724427223206,
-0.8863321542739868,
-1.0766903162002563,
-0.7447183132171631,
-0.06887948513031006,
-0.258740097284317,
-0.1741693764925003,
0.41239169239997864,
0.7867746353149414,
-0.6592335104942322,
0.05499456450343132,
0.1845402717590332,
-0.2098546326160431,
-0.21939298510551453,
-0.17857788503170013,
0.24333195388317108,
-0.3036434054374695,
-0.7271925210952759,
0.41296958923339844,
0.3139800727367401,
0.2929023802280426,
-0.26741236448287964,
0.10683661699295044,
-0.26071712374687195,
0.055677060037851334,
0.9495769739151001,
-0.4782363772392273,
-0.37627825140953064,
-0.31172746419906616,
0.1892661452293396,
-0.12176083028316498,
0.33827200531959534,
0.6289547085762024,
-0.43966910243034363,
0.7045329809188843,
0.08138178288936615,
0.5858882665634155,
0.6562916040420532,
-0.3615480959415436,
0.5683495402336121,
-0.8106919527053833,
0.23469197750091553,
-0.0803612694144249,
0.18970593810081482,
0.23949594795703888,
-0.025210555642843246,
0.2682925760746002,
0.3419780731201172,
-0.3355758786201477,
-0.7908452153205872,
0.2059147208929062,
-1.0082231760025024,
-0.000575041922274977,
0.7599707245826721,
-0.15794964134693146,
-0.32584086060523987,
0.021385163068771362,
-0.377843976020813,
0.2943849265575409,
-0.1580803543329239,
0.5247533321380615,
1.0595861673355103,
0.23450873792171478,
-0.6120759844779968,
-1.1192504167556763,
0.10941186547279358,
0.2867125868797302,
-0.6721237897872925,
-0.1547815054655075,
0.06234614923596382,
0.2725493609905243,
0.17987746000289917,
0.31813499331474304,
-0.2911604344844818,
0.27608850598335266,
0.18001602590084076,
0.20704317092895508,
-0.45171818137168884,
-0.4276341199874878,
-0.028031252324581146,
0.24803641438484192,
-0.31236588954925537,
-0.5464438199996948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03031v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03031v4
|
Learning to Use Tools via Cooperative and Interactive Agents
| 2024-03-05T15:08:16 | 2024-06-22T14:00:56 |
Zhengliang Shi, Shen Gao, Xiuyi Chen, Yue Feng, Lingyong Yan, Haibo Shi, Dawei Yin, Pengjie Ren, Suzan Verberne, Zhaochun Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tool learning empowers large language models (LLMs) as agents to use external
tools and extend their utility. Existing methods employ one single LLM-based
agent to iteratively select and execute tools, thereafter incorporating
execution results into the next action prediction. Despite their progress,
these methods suffer from performance degradation when addressing practical
tasks due to: (1) the pre-defined pipeline with restricted flexibility to
calibrate incorrect actions, and (2) the struggle to adapt a general LLM-based
agent to perform a variety of specialized actions. To mitigate these problems,
we propose ConAgents, a Cooperative and interactive Agents framework, which
coordinates three specialized agents for tool selection, tool execution, and
action calibration separately. ConAgents introduces two communication protocols
to enable the flexible cooperation of agents. To effectively generalize the
ConAgents into open-source models, we also propose specialized action
distillation, enhancing their ability to perform specialized actions in our
framework. Our extensive experiments on three datasets show that the LLMs, when
equipped with the ConAgents, outperform baselines with substantial improvement
(i.e., up to 14% higher success rate).
|
[
-0.12394750863313675,
-0.7581630945205688,
0.5900864005088806,
0.08754246681928635,
-0.23105669021606445,
0.5660399794578552,
-0.40117284655570984,
-0.24772708117961884,
0.03025040403008461,
0.5117368698120117,
-0.5081097483634949,
-0.6169492602348328,
-0.6449085474014282,
0.05891949310898781,
-0.1659596562385559,
0.8456070423126221,
-0.004862587433308363,
0.21004527807235718,
-0.016447776928544044,
-0.36870327591896057,
-0.6216433048248291,
-0.22744131088256836,
-0.9915562868118286,
-0.6623765826225281,
0.669630765914917,
0.7076086401939392,
0.9813324809074402,
0.33304691314697266,
0.4202692210674286,
0.6128477454185486,
0.38560378551483154,
0.31849968433380127,
-0.5429844260215759,
0.23260311782360077,
-0.41068291664123535,
-0.7042272686958313,
-0.463512659072876,
0.21436721086502075,
0.25310468673706055,
0.6408904194831848,
-0.3719836473464966,
-0.006483609322458506,
0.19233430922031403,
0.3008541464805603,
-0.5217769742012024,
0.22648200392723083,
-0.5528227686882019,
-0.10052737593650818,
0.10663961619138718,
-0.06596609950065613,
-0.5627615451812744,
-0.3102935254573822,
0.23125708103179932,
-0.9054227471351624,
0.07509925216436386,
-0.19317539036273956,
0.06928667426109314,
0.42340192198753357,
-0.3405291438102722,
-0.4865412414073944,
-0.7431942820549011,
0.8389329314231873,
-0.497416228055954,
0.1741524040699005,
0.341182678937912,
0.5268303155899048,
-0.557876706123352,
-1.1625871658325195,
-0.4942634701728821,
-0.4195452034473419,
-0.2752777338027954,
0.1319945901632309,
-0.09139346331357956,
0.13816095888614655,
0.2905578017234802,
-0.012818953953683376,
-0.38797640800476074,
0.4584980905056,
-0.2728719711303711,
-0.22352339327335358,
0.6339606642723083,
0.3122763931751251,
0.08010359853506088,
0.5530175566673279,
-0.30899354815483093,
-0.2596472501754761,
-0.3486483693122864,
0.16051243245601654,
0.3060130178928375,
0.35372281074523926,
-0.31736454367637634,
0.42682507634162903,
0.11303944140672684,
0.5420974493026733,
0.11207948625087738,
-0.20718835294246674,
0.19372166693210602,
-0.10363452881574631,
-0.5132386684417725,
-0.36297017335891724,
0.7817654013633728,
-0.055555153638124466,
0.2472645342350006,
-0.34623855352401733,
-0.1728244423866272,
0.04201047867536545,
0.08532794564962387,
-0.5915883779525757,
-0.3736783266067505,
0.31871840357780457,
0.06835422664880753,
-0.11628063023090363,
-0.024790186434984207,
-0.3104005455970764,
-0.47609928250312805,
-0.5226561427116394,
0.5500049591064453,
-0.26812657713890076,
-0.2736523449420929,
0.2313764989376068,
-0.2913995385169983,
-0.017997752875089645,
0.6727167367935181,
-0.5074337720870972,
0.7029190063476562,
0.774734377861023,
0.8495147228240967,
-0.325870156288147,
-0.48210400342941284,
-1.3015704154968262,
0.13503219187259674,
-0.1931784301996231,
0.5511864423751831,
-0.8695780038833618,
-0.5978107452392578,
-0.10276970267295837,
0.22082839906215668,
0.045365408062934875,
-0.4369668662548065,
0.15026813745498657,
-0.5514509081840515,
-0.07782658189535141,
-0.24981029331684113,
-0.3737790882587433,
-0.37782150506973267,
0.19262267649173737,
-1.026963472366333,
0.7220816612243652,
0.2598637044429779,
-0.4228146970272064,
0.256097674369812,
-0.6584601998329163,
-0.2633059024810791,
0.31194180250167847,
-0.4058668315410614,
-0.3497692048549652,
-0.10306394845247269,
-0.25357142090797424,
0.5089607834815979,
-0.334903746843338,
0.20620174705982208,
-0.4534030854701996,
-0.5677083134651184,
0.23534853756427765,
-0.22988039255142212,
0.713189959526062,
-0.03404949605464935,
-0.18926599621772766,
0.5374728441238403,
-0.4579619765281677,
-0.20113660395145416,
-0.1439387947320938,
-0.3991338908672333,
-0.14859221875667572,
-0.02046354115009308,
-0.22929200530052185,
0.3522647023200989,
0.07649504393339157,
-0.6270769238471985,
0.2738449275493622,
-0.30320218205451965,
0.22945179045200348,
0.8788720369338989,
-0.20324519276618958,
0.7052133083343506,
-0.39203941822052,
0.6791544556617737,
-0.08103184401988983,
0.21785375475883484,
0.21001239120960236,
-0.11939653009176254,
-0.6446495652198792,
-0.3757738173007965,
0.10502801835536957,
0.4385676980018616,
-1.079796314239502,
0.2375664860010147,
-0.051997341215610504,
-0.8916136026382446,
-0.2639269232749939,
0.329071044921875,
0.44356226921081543,
0.2559148669242859,
0.13611458241939545,
-0.6046768426895142,
-0.2447512298822403,
-0.530223548412323,
-0.0893147885799408,
-0.10477974265813828,
-0.08404556661844254,
0.09099306911230087,
0.22563698887825012,
0.017716489732265472,
0.8544658422470093,
-0.1421053558588028,
-0.22709958255290985,
-0.4272175133228302,
0.058516960591077805,
0.09480290114879608,
0.3107556402683258,
0.4374617636203766,
-0.8656321167945862,
-0.8421787023544312,
0.22292731702327728,
-0.48971027135849,
0.02756904996931553,
0.11351311951875687,
0.03897957503795624,
0.015644092112779617,
0.5393175482749939,
-0.31302890181541443,
0.22281549870967865,
0.8693840503692627,
-0.13915078341960907,
0.49526312947273254,
-0.2485324591398239,
-0.28974664211273193,
-1.0168613195419312,
0.029178349301218987,
0.0631062388420105,
-0.5011073350906372,
-0.5038639903068542,
-0.14311888813972473,
-0.25003865361213684,
0.11466321349143982,
-0.7181177735328674,
0.6916497945785522,
-0.4196428656578064,
-0.056850191205739975,
-0.41674235463142395,
0.27458295226097107,
-0.05329356715083122,
0.652068555355072,
0.013696670532226562,
0.7604407668113708,
0.641724169254303,
-0.5599755048751831,
0.6736140251159668,
0.10853400081396103,
0.13688047230243683,
0.3363295793533325,
-0.792961061000824,
0.23855020105838776,
0.13680969178676605,
0.25906458497047424,
-0.7305125594139099,
-0.21717266738414764,
0.2985459864139557,
-0.12211053818464279,
0.3051206171512604,
-0.1125372126698494,
-0.6443219780921936,
0.04965068772435188,
-0.3797641396522522,
-0.050398752093315125,
0.2813861072063446,
-0.3500550091266632,
0.9221435189247131,
0.31215420365333557,
-0.0461578406393528,
-0.8355277180671692,
-0.562899112701416,
-0.22328194975852966,
-0.01602477766573429,
-0.349975049495697,
0.03480777144432068,
-0.25550246238708496,
-0.33889201283454895,
-0.06663071364164352,
0.01277893502265215,
0.15031149983406067,
0.281919926404953,
0.4914274513721466,
-0.04794628545641899,
0.23083887994289398,
0.47150281071662903,
-0.06079777330160141,
-0.26843583583831787,
-0.16238372027873993,
0.1154353991150856,
0.5818740725517273,
-0.15988485515117645,
-0.6196715235710144,
-0.10914278775453568,
0.5125775933265686,
0.5671834945678711,
-0.5092097520828247,
0.6775227785110474,
0.6781799793243408,
0.05174311250448227,
-0.4529181718826294,
-0.4613679051399231,
-0.4164859354496002,
-0.6355167031288147,
0.44301387667655945,
-0.2723647952079773,
-1.0014413595199585,
0.5326346158981323,
-0.6144517064094543,
0.48278579115867615,
-0.14679737389087677,
0.589927613735199,
0.1618407964706421,
0.9185358285903931,
0.9606380462646484,
0.0779046043753624,
0.7349499464035034,
-0.4009377658367157,
-0.06985801458358765,
-0.5852790474891663,
-0.18034768104553223,
-0.3426775634288788,
-0.5654503107070923,
-0.7777273058891296,
-0.3872910737991333,
0.5467146039009094,
-0.13115984201431274,
-0.19357670843601227,
0.27915823459625244,
-0.2940883934497833,
0.5145487785339355,
0.6076548099517822,
0.21157340705394745,
0.3955754339694977,
0.015650825574994087,
-0.26995712518692017,
0.3025346100330353,
-0.6363477110862732,
-0.7438321709632874,
1.003197193145752,
0.21015767753124237,
0.938498854637146,
0.2858879566192627,
0.7162451148033142,
0.23394674062728882,
0.524708092212677,
-0.942678689956665,
0.7422276735305786,
-0.25089913606643677,
-0.1396542489528656,
-0.369473397731781,
-0.041080985218286514,
-1.133039951324463,
0.25833964347839355,
-0.06840591877698898,
-0.6744328141212463,
0.16341157257556915,
0.03692273795604706,
-0.3125742971897125,
0.12526246905326843,
-0.8839099407196045,
0.7564122676849365,
-0.1277153193950653,
-0.7680525779724121,
-0.4577721357345581,
-0.7648152112960815,
-0.13530543446540833,
-0.17033083736896515,
0.18650931119918823,
-0.14612039923667908,
-0.3664598762989044,
0.25027117133140564,
-0.42589887976646423,
1.1945866346359253,
-0.2379673272371292,
0.02067919634282589,
0.3119738698005676,
0.4203716814517975,
0.8432956337928772,
0.05043414607644081,
-0.5120667815208435,
-0.17748767137527466,
-0.17873406410217285,
-0.2703514099121094,
-0.7949297428131104,
0.7020481824874878,
-0.8246552348136902,
-0.8020868301391602,
-0.22064760327339172,
-0.5901772975921631,
-0.10525558143854141,
0.1285938173532486,
-0.2549517750740051,
0.4924226403236389,
-0.18982137739658356,
0.23177160322666168,
0.1532960832118988,
0.09487567842006683,
0.7984290719032288,
1.0432465076446533,
-0.012289587408304214,
-0.21629372239112854,
0.6207085251808167,
0.1456843763589859,
0.5206528306007385,
0.0658000260591507,
0.12234995514154434,
-0.0008958530961535871,
-0.5787228941917419,
-0.048132602125406265,
0.18464189767837524,
-0.8628183007240295,
-0.24473837018013,
-0.5331646800041199,
0.09059733152389526,
0.019168293103575706,
-0.3684481978416443,
-0.18778355419635773,
-0.08454340696334839,
-0.24414287507534027,
-0.16424903273582458,
0.5091744661331177,
0.6639590859413147,
-0.14975927770137787,
0.5728436708450317,
-0.8270019292831421,
-0.14729532599449158,
0.4323548376560211,
0.2558797001838684,
-0.16082964837551117,
-0.04464271292090416,
-0.30750471353530884,
-0.021159479394555092,
-0.6304832100868225,
-0.7198355197906494,
0.22557389736175537,
0.30905643105506897,
0.7702355980873108,
0.02201157808303833,
0.2602103352546692,
0.2727288007736206,
-0.36137205362319946,
0.5403730273246765,
-0.05798343941569328,
-0.7737476229667664,
0.22582286596298218,
-0.14069591462612152,
0.2508529722690582,
0.4416133761405945,
0.45420411229133606,
-0.37289246916770935,
-0.6179248690605164,
-0.5809630751609802,
-0.5315790772438049,
0.8490746021270752,
0.1734062284231186,
0.18576371669769287,
0.1383751481771469,
0.12012466043233871,
0.48403245210647583,
0.25490087270736694,
-0.5845167636871338,
0.03203645721077919,
0.15206675231456757,
-0.1366337388753891,
-0.2834586501121521,
0.3463916480541229,
-0.3116214871406555,
0.10606071352958679,
0.5818644762039185,
-0.488138884305954,
-0.28444111347198486,
0.11268938332796097,
-0.17278945446014404,
-0.22985611855983734,
0.2647668719291687,
0.15246567130088806,
0.6854563355445862,
0.24451600015163422,
0.057724591344594955,
0.22317111492156982,
-0.40763989090919495,
0.3030785620212555,
0.08364775031805038,
0.35330119729042053,
-0.07863916456699371,
0.355618417263031,
0.6158878803253174,
0.1813337504863739,
-0.6965621709823608,
0.4752582013607025,
-0.1981934756040573,
0.15466362237930298,
-0.3400111496448517,
0.5096175074577332,
0.2763672173023224,
0.7555660605430603,
0.07432028651237488,
0.11034999042749405,
0.19896851480007172,
-0.6042740941047668,
0.21056294441223145,
0.4409342110157013,
-0.4557608366012573,
-0.509657084941864,
-0.02372298389673233,
0.5871828198432922,
-0.7028284072875977,
0.18617813289165497,
-0.3052515387535095,
-0.16990505158901215,
0.6804294586181641,
0.30718371272087097,
0.8988259434700012,
-0.4688188135623932,
0.3668067455291748,
0.02464519999921322,
0.18395738303661346,
-0.1552925705909729,
0.3095078468322754,
-0.08344735950231552,
-0.6998567581176758,
-0.47909823060035706,
-0.3773374855518341,
-0.6319560408592224,
0.026557255536317825,
-0.358621746301651,
0.5747641921043396,
-0.45274993777275085,
-0.2577172517776489,
0.002748786937445402,
0.2281678318977356,
-0.9729683995246887,
-0.03908250480890274,
-0.5260728597640991,
0.8873597979545593,
-0.7967905402183533,
1.081432580947876,
0.9509881138801575,
-0.4513648748397827,
-1.0653364658355713,
-0.1765863299369812,
0.06521381437778473,
-0.43566980957984924,
0.37624257802963257,
0.03704793378710747,
-0.4035422205924988,
0.22027507424354553,
-0.734318733215332,
-0.5259377956390381,
1.2736423015594482,
0.7397372126579285,
-0.8336163759231567,
0.08101462572813034,
0.11628879606723785,
0.6619208455085754,
-0.34596237540245056,
0.34930720925331116,
0.3987947702407837,
0.3207533359527588,
0.2596381902694702,
-1.299802303314209,
0.12639622390270233,
0.032043736428022385,
-0.3734245002269745,
0.11678079515695572,
-0.8626604080200195,
0.8572572469711304,
-0.17097792029380798,
-0.16235597431659698,
-0.1475100964307785,
0.19753344357013702,
0.34077584743499756,
0.2412153035402298,
0.5399357080459595,
0.050405651330947876,
0.5544975399971008,
0.19944210350513458,
0.8430944681167603,
0.06743308901786804,
0.14962179958820343,
1.3441905975341797,
-0.4789772927761078,
0.7820649147033691,
0.4721880257129669,
0.07561849802732468,
0.6126272082328796,
0.3470119833946228,
0.14555084705352783,
0.52663254737854,
0.09567011892795563,
-0.5151527523994446,
-0.45858636498451233,
-0.14405374228954315,
0.24010060727596283,
0.705563485622406,
0.6191115379333496,
-0.19668632745742798,
-0.4140530824661255,
0.0961669385433197,
-0.004937772639095783,
0.3261810541152954,
-0.15986917912960052,
1.0420607328414917,
0.2649918496608734,
-0.7277563214302063,
0.16216079890727997,
-0.06309417635202408,
0.4629921317100525,
-0.8185755610466003,
-0.35084268450737,
0.05039869621396065,
0.36191779375076294,
-0.20001220703125,
-0.7717277407646179,
0.19793452322483063,
-0.35492902994155884,
0.19474826753139496,
0.18126064538955688,
0.7838610410690308,
-0.5990762114524841,
-0.17299513518810272,
0.6253566145896912,
0.6066268086433411,
-0.03441501408815384,
0.19229331612586975,
-0.7094098925590515,
0.2436063438653946,
-0.37169209122657776,
-0.18867100775241852,
0.243500754237175,
0.6169673204421997,
-0.22722259163856506,
0.8262910842895508,
0.5876846313476562,
-0.05011967569589615,
-0.2597388029098511,
0.03581281378865242,
1.2247778177261353,
-0.06090428680181503,
-0.2812958061695099,
-0.9154126644134521,
0.8152400851249695,
-0.23495347797870636,
0.20180480182170868,
0.6589440703392029,
0.2628667652606964,
0.9925912022590637,
0.01746983267366886,
0.912187933921814,
0.1274128407239914,
0.3037692606449127,
-0.27285414934158325,
0.4285159111022949,
-0.2965555787086487,
0.37717652320861816,
-0.07624184340238571,
-0.7379913926124573,
-0.1938076913356781,
0.32828328013420105,
-0.282094806432724,
0.189285546541214,
0.5489131808280945,
0.768741250038147,
-0.31721216440200806,
-0.23057503998279572,
0.49054285883903503,
-0.043041475117206573,
0.7006458044052124,
0.46749135851860046,
0.42251718044281006,
-0.12945467233657837,
0.4298989176750183,
-0.20345093309879303,
-0.3279343247413635,
-0.1876789927482605,
-0.9025968909263611,
-1.0371114015579224,
-0.5015336871147156,
-0.29857805371284485,
0.05513377487659454,
0.024088097736239433,
1.2664470672607422,
0.7812390327453613,
-0.49935296177864075,
-0.445365309715271,
-0.17242830991744995,
0.17087408900260925,
-0.18874318897724152,
-0.07862575352191925,
0.0732119083404541,
-0.4063856303691864,
-0.9659342169761658,
0.34060364961624146,
0.3138450086116791,
-0.048521317541599274,
-0.40285441279411316,
-0.4088200330734253,
-0.07496386021375656,
0.038478489965200424,
0.4608606696128845,
0.2446971833705902,
-0.7233983278274536,
-0.375869482755661,
-0.0033847177401185036,
-0.03353163227438927,
-0.2079085111618042,
0.8863485455513,
-0.8877144455909729,
0.7538429498672485,
0.37538909912109375,
0.368284672498703,
0.23870420455932617,
-0.27515891194343567,
0.9129199385643005,
-1.0731709003448486,
0.5164926648139954,
0.4566599726676941,
0.18722806870937347,
0.3260727822780609,
-0.14693351089954376,
0.5336049199104309,
-0.1734972596168518,
-0.6391476392745972,
-0.598035991191864,
0.36383265256881714,
-0.8408345580101013,
-0.09165459871292114,
1.120773196220398,
-0.5347306728363037,
-0.07461321353912354,
-0.4667544662952423,
-0.5758424997329712,
0.5608364939689636,
-0.5993273854255676,
0.4942120313644409,
0.5605797171592712,
-0.04945559799671173,
-0.18762703239917755,
-0.3116120398044586,
0.5904238224029541,
0.08529936522245407,
-0.6660309433937073,
0.11682107299566269,
0.390002578496933,
0.4515819847583771,
0.1487925499677658,
0.47252804040908813,
0.11038047820329666,
0.3851439356803894,
-0.15243838727474213,
0.04727550223469734,
-0.41460344195365906,
-0.27084019780158997,
-0.25494733452796936,
0.04075535014271736,
0.34670835733413696,
-0.19464296102523804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03029v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03029v1
|
Socratic Reasoning Improves Positive Text Rewriting
| 2024-03-05T15:05:06 | 2024-03-05T15:05:06 |
Anmol Goel, Nico Daheim, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reframing a negative into a positive thought is at the crux of several
cognitive approaches to mental health and psychotherapy that could be made more
accessible by large language model-based solutions. Such reframing is typically
non-trivial and requires multiple rationalization steps to uncover the
underlying issue of a negative thought and transform it to be more positive.
However, this rationalization process is currently neglected by both datasets
and models which reframe thoughts in one step. In this work, we address this
gap by augmenting open-source datasets for positive text rewriting with
synthetically-generated Socratic rationales using a novel framework called
\textsc{SocraticReframe}. \textsc{SocraticReframe} uses a sequence of
question-answer pairs to rationalize the thought rewriting process. We show
that such Socratic rationales significantly improve positive text rewriting for
different open-source LLMs according to both automatic and human evaluations
guided by criteria from psychotherapy research.
|
[
-0.22934363782405853,
-0.6239553093910217,
0.8914657831192017,
0.1634286493062973,
-0.5262656807899475,
0.03797999024391174,
-0.2519606351852417,
-0.29819178581237793,
0.38965630531311035,
0.6149803400039673,
-0.4890722930431366,
-0.514747679233551,
-0.3221137821674347,
0.2263163924217224,
-0.2423449605703354,
1.098852276802063,
-0.13157355785369873,
0.4213554859161377,
-0.29906123876571655,
-0.06496575474739075,
-0.323172390460968,
-0.4882108271121979,
-0.6483222842216492,
-0.6359795928001404,
0.47523704171180725,
0.4344536364078522,
0.7637931108474731,
-0.0426834374666214,
0.26582828164100647,
0.12351647019386292,
0.11355169862508774,
0.18566511571407318,
-0.7706129550933838,
0.5988149046897888,
-0.3929128348827362,
-0.7616828083992004,
-0.42876914143562317,
0.09724307060241699,
0.40058740973472595,
0.46080538630485535,
-0.22962380945682526,
0.21895064413547516,
-0.16132260859012604,
0.7643833756446838,
-0.5065650343894958,
-0.056737545877695084,
-0.6529654264450073,
0.04355037212371826,
0.10765790939331055,
-0.2772977650165558,
-0.5180777311325073,
-0.8275010585784912,
-0.051180824637413025,
-0.7500565648078918,
0.4937383234500885,
-0.1537429541349411,
0.5663106441497803,
0.22135210037231445,
-0.4801570177078247,
0.008294342085719109,
-0.7349095940589905,
0.6486856937408447,
-0.8513492941856384,
0.5239986777305603,
0.36858391761779785,
0.22826021909713745,
-0.43592432141304016,
-0.42987385392189026,
-0.5783448815345764,
-0.039375390857458115,
-0.02909892611205578,
0.1252063810825348,
0.07195409387350082,
0.104388028383255,
0.34432318806648254,
0.32916104793548584,
-0.24053499102592468,
-0.47488829493522644,
-0.4864597022533417,
-0.468953013420105,
0.7191276550292969,
0.18404363095760345,
0.057661931961774826,
-0.11787830293178558,
-0.0890769436955452,
0.3012157678604126,
-0.7353729009628296,
0.09485353529453278,
-0.14266349375247955,
0.036614928394556046,
0.22122777998447418,
0.6801292300224304,
-0.24192065000534058,
0.44939306378364563,
0.12750758230686188,
-0.46725428104400635,
0.2732948362827301,
-0.5353156924247742,
-0.17661380767822266,
0.1823226362466812,
0.262375146150589,
0.7678082585334778,
0.3438243567943573,
-0.4783744513988495,
-0.07060717791318893,
0.5250478386878967,
0.4181898534297943,
-0.850446343421936,
0.07055087387561798,
0.41340312361717224,
-0.24954813718795776,
-0.14536823332309723,
-0.3264848291873932,
-0.5404840111732483,
-0.5895984172821045,
-0.7263522148132324,
0.17905710637569427,
-0.6401072144508362,
-0.06780091673135757,
0.6971473693847656,
-0.24246501922607422,
0.3287092447280884,
0.8237598538398743,
-0.45698872208595276,
-0.002933502197265625,
0.8834764957427979,
0.8096519708633423,
0.33654502034187317,
0.1321694701910019,
-0.5918964743614197,
0.1985483169555664,
-0.45381149649620056,
1.0547152757644653,
-0.6342517733573914,
-0.28151240944862366,
-0.19632689654827118,
-0.031861305236816406,
0.19338063895702362,
-0.37681370973587036,
0.7879205346107483,
-0.2572007477283478,
0.45933547616004944,
-0.4072277545928955,
-0.45905601978302,
-0.09670138359069824,
0.4218254089355469,
-0.21841596066951752,
0.7529211640357971,
-0.0923013985157013,
-0.7810288071632385,
0.31363412737846375,
-0.1882459819316864,
-0.5933254361152649,
-0.04227568581700325,
-0.34804508090019226,
-0.4044859707355499,
0.35759758949279785,
0.19307328760623932,
0.15705786645412445,
-0.6025818586349487,
0.43575748801231384,
-0.5850797891616821,
-0.3901320695877075,
0.5166130661964417,
-0.23767434060573578,
0.9182078838348389,
0.13828879594802856,
-0.40601325035095215,
0.32935237884521484,
-0.6477614045143127,
0.30752548575401306,
-0.10067922621965408,
-0.09257267415523529,
-0.3906913995742798,
-0.0855446308851242,
-0.30420777201652527,
0.30359169840812683,
-0.006736322771757841,
-0.9073010087013245,
0.178351491689682,
-0.5008496046066284,
0.5844056606292725,
0.6908916234970093,
0.42158249020576477,
0.37405088543891907,
-0.5908076167106628,
0.7615855932235718,
-0.21531060338020325,
0.11224889010190964,
-0.06499430537223816,
-0.6357780694961548,
-0.6856220960617065,
-0.4322994351387024,
-0.2879442274570465,
0.33036136627197266,
-0.932979166507721,
-0.10090147703886032,
0.026760706678032875,
-0.6466763019561768,
-0.9409403800964355,
-0.03601484000682831,
0.3434946537017822,
0.636146068572998,
0.43567654490470886,
-0.25843870639801025,
-0.44689804315567017,
-0.8641418218612671,
-0.20620545744895935,
-0.08097335696220398,
0.1595715433359146,
0.15002213418483734,
0.2432321161031723,
-0.23285339772701263,
0.8315911293029785,
-0.784124493598938,
0.07465630024671555,
-0.1424064189195633,
0.17594105005264282,
0.017021091654896736,
0.382914274930954,
0.32410889863967896,
-0.5205298066139221,
-0.41703808307647705,
-0.5483537316322327,
-0.7146706581115723,
-0.3110096752643585,
-0.5363535284996033,
-0.6824015974998474,
-0.04599650204181671,
0.4460468292236328,
-0.6463283896446228,
0.7558090090751648,
-0.24486806988716125,
-0.6306884288787842,
1.008681297302246,
-0.10521415621042252,
0.32683321833610535,
-0.9716523289680481,
-0.07312498241662979,
0.061333999037742615,
-0.27609288692474365,
-0.4808027148246765,
0.10828585177659988,
-0.08457574993371964,
-0.2970728278160095,
-0.19571392238140106,
0.27082911133766174,
-0.27407240867614746,
0.033084556460380554,
-0.20805209875106812,
0.5459530353546143,
0.2969362735748291,
0.4134298861026764,
-0.18053185939788818,
0.9013428688049316,
0.4282745122909546,
-0.1746937483549118,
0.2716042995452881,
0.291716605424881,
-0.36454710364341736,
0.5651664733886719,
-0.6314758658409119,
0.144663006067276,
-0.7063002586364746,
0.6234992146492004,
-0.9482224583625793,
0.007688529323786497,
0.500274658203125,
-0.36655083298683167,
-0.22609871625900269,
0.233146071434021,
-0.2600531280040741,
0.054336048662662506,
-0.6562361717224121,
0.4580143690109253,
0.13521334528923035,
-0.20699454843997955,
0.16391649842262268,
0.1977389007806778,
-0.0981292873620987,
-0.4573754668235779,
-0.5998631119728088,
0.1662992388010025,
-0.024233190342783928,
-0.6176437735557556,
0.5983598232269287,
-0.30160510540008545,
-0.4876596927642822,
-0.07784325629472733,
-0.19624771177768707,
0.11743219941854477,
0.07237004488706589,
0.15567801892757416,
0.3345748782157898,
-0.1957055926322937,
0.454886257648468,
0.2039458006620407,
-0.347591370344162,
0.2354876697063446,
-0.039212293922901154,
0.47340071201324463,
-0.21264921128749847,
-0.15674994885921478,
-0.44089600443840027,
0.40699154138565063,
0.8236851096153259,
-0.5333593487739563,
0.8528557419776917,
0.3653360605239868,
-0.49166014790534973,
-0.2152356058359146,
-0.38092830777168274,
-0.2857730984687805,
-0.36493822932243347,
0.04058977961540222,
-0.16607330739498138,
-1.0050112009048462,
0.22170577943325043,
0.22997687757015228,
0.03469987213611603,
-0.10019470751285553,
0.5954169631004333,
0.14569205045700073,
0.8559049963951111,
0.15832453966140747,
0.30200064182281494,
0.35147425532341003,
-0.1781332939863205,
0.6070550084114075,
-1.044753909111023,
-0.09479010850191116,
-0.34072384238243103,
-0.21270638704299927,
-0.37836670875549316,
-0.6145819425582886,
0.23313331604003906,
0.2839339077472687,
-0.3693152964115143,
0.07446248084306717,
-0.7437478303909302,
0.3978411853313446,
0.18602365255355835,
0.5715447068214417,
0.4815710484981537,
-0.07511568814516068,
-0.19028714299201965,
-0.29579663276672363,
-0.4149591624736786,
-0.6786288619041443,
1.044925570487976,
0.06834770739078522,
0.553054928779602,
0.19200706481933594,
0.8365821838378906,
0.17991918325424194,
1.0428434610366821,
-0.7131302356719971,
0.8092648983001709,
0.22141362726688385,
-0.8956342339515686,
-0.25989997386932373,
-0.21050430834293365,
-0.6302798390388489,
0.550683319568634,
-0.5376191735267639,
-0.6831375360488892,
0.37780481576919556,
0.1148340255022049,
-0.5541141033172607,
0.06366819888353348,
-0.8037283420562744,
0.6649389863014221,
-0.2562466263771057,
-0.649299681186676,
-0.6991735100746155,
-0.325496643781662,
0.37133482098579407,
-0.10330662876367569,
0.15366268157958984,
-0.32428115606307983,
0.005416637286543846,
0.44235435128211975,
-0.3639175295829773,
0.7771545648574829,
-0.21856476366519928,
-0.287955641746521,
0.4780569076538086,
0.17081493139266968,
0.21962565183639526,
0.5071007609367371,
-0.36267298460006714,
-0.2400846779346466,
0.08319269120693207,
-0.5287615060806274,
-0.9942008256912231,
0.595691442489624,
-0.5479177832603455,
-1.0287723541259766,
-0.45708343386650085,
-0.2199551910161972,
-0.26408350467681885,
0.2469109743833542,
0.05159537121653557,
0.5579970479011536,
-0.11262248456478119,
0.2929528057575226,
0.42060866951942444,
-0.3132823407649994,
-0.2978062033653259,
0.7060261964797974,
-0.6518286466598511,
-0.8406890034675598,
0.6137886047363281,
0.09470248967409134,
0.40041637420654297,
0.23315101861953735,
-0.023787036538124084,
-0.08233391493558884,
-0.536274790763855,
0.06611744314432144,
0.6286494135856628,
-0.8173980116844177,
-0.27729177474975586,
-0.3168710768222809,
0.02345169335603714,
-0.7808223962783813,
-0.4098083972930908,
-0.03307647258043289,
-0.702454686164856,
-0.11522457003593445,
-0.3208315074443817,
0.2629834711551666,
0.17502346634864807,
0.030735813081264496,
-0.16781467199325562,
-0.5754007697105408,
0.48612502217292786,
0.12686754763126373,
0.41323256492614746,
0.3822392225265503,
-0.31404125690460205,
-0.2020745575428009,
0.3234056830406189,
-0.41606515645980835,
-1.0642181634902954,
0.3535730838775635,
-0.12467055767774582,
0.3580456078052521,
0.24269942939281464,
0.3840007781982422,
0.7236972451210022,
-0.43366965651512146,
0.6033934354782104,
0.24717384576797485,
-0.7995442748069763,
0.45004427433013916,
-0.18869169056415558,
0.31454968452453613,
0.7769796848297119,
0.3405531346797943,
-0.8665242195129395,
-0.4260846972465515,
-0.4493781328201294,
-0.7252064347267151,
0.4790573716163635,
0.3836881220340729,
-0.3838285803794861,
-0.25283750891685486,
1.0496301651000977,
0.1600579023361206,
0.26972582936286926,
-0.709902822971344,
-0.05182158201932907,
-0.53654944896698,
-0.17416900396347046,
-0.41174226999282837,
-0.16518084704875946,
-0.12300173193216324,
-0.46948158740997314,
1.0781303644180298,
-0.07833611220121384,
0.40745943784713745,
0.6750400066375732,
-0.01263065543025732,
-0.2696216404438019,
0.6577880382537842,
0.5385074615478516,
0.269654244184494,
-0.34704628586769104,
0.31650811433792114,
-0.0800008624792099,
-0.28005099296569824,
0.40975624322891235,
-0.053512685000896454,
-0.4597214460372925,
-0.24264325201511383,
0.25359758734703064,
0.37458565831184387,
0.31018710136413574,
-0.7515362501144409,
0.2635907232761383,
-0.22375638782978058,
-0.0485958531498909,
-0.29271507263183594,
0.3206992447376251,
0.2674553096294403,
0.506334125995636,
-0.04524020850658417,
0.2460412234067917,
0.0644686371088028,
-0.6543273329734802,
0.21877047419548035,
0.38920721411705017,
-0.2744755148887634,
-0.42133867740631104,
0.4412896931171417,
0.24803663790225983,
-0.6391380429267883,
0.634786069393158,
-0.2100963294506073,
-0.6671998500823975,
0.35790717601776123,
0.9918320775032043,
0.9819881916046143,
0.20788341760635376,
0.7431656122207642,
0.6743891835212708,
0.2456168383359909,
0.04992688074707985,
0.38485953211784363,
-0.34332120418548584,
-1.0614066123962402,
-0.47672751545906067,
-0.3512376844882965,
-0.44422703981399536,
0.023433325812220573,
-0.5917907357215881,
0.19928601384162903,
-0.6868346929550171,
-0.3075776696205139,
0.13517816364765167,
-0.087786465883255,
-0.20170265436172485,
0.209429532289505,
0.1030067726969719,
0.8365100622177124,
-0.5500169396400452,
0.8809211850166321,
0.8365620374679565,
-0.5987553596496582,
-0.5485105514526367,
0.06844834983348846,
-0.10378661751747131,
-0.6033860445022583,
0.1787424236536026,
0.31968066096305847,
-0.6210988163948059,
-0.17725159227848053,
-0.5886392593383789,
-0.7325908541679382,
1.1286650896072388,
0.7596622705459595,
-0.29700928926467896,
0.03505637124180794,
0.12383556365966797,
0.9056304693222046,
-0.4694806933403015,
0.06320608407258987,
0.2686890661716461,
0.43757712841033936,
-0.0033094247337430716,
-0.2735298275947571,
0.42485353350639343,
-0.4049642086029053,
-0.2250353991985321,
0.3205060362815857,
-0.6717879176139832,
0.5126395225524902,
-0.44470879435539246,
-0.3781068027019501,
-0.14292655885219574,
0.41168344020843506,
0.2822989821434021,
0.489607036113739,
0.38501009345054626,
0.6532183289527893,
0.9100666046142578,
0.23371541500091553,
0.8078598380088806,
-0.31548863649368286,
0.20426438748836517,
1.3402700424194336,
-0.44108566641807556,
0.7334702610969543,
0.4930957555770874,
-0.09432118386030197,
0.7762343287467957,
0.380971759557724,
0.32981210947036743,
0.3387625515460968,
0.02090061455965042,
-0.5633482933044434,
-0.8075371980667114,
-0.15009357035160065,
-0.30851274728775024,
0.03316672518849373,
0.27615657448768616,
-0.2532070279121399,
-0.3228561580181122,
-0.08899218589067459,
0.15345871448516846,
0.47758960723876953,
-0.21054840087890625,
0.3695388436317444,
0.27589353919029236,
-1.0453273057937622,
0.6530588865280151,
0.12909303605556488,
0.3133383095264435,
-0.22773799300193787,
-0.08624967932701111,
-0.27777811884880066,
0.3325462341308594,
-0.4523340165615082,
-0.7790688276290894,
0.5353459119796753,
0.0920751616358757,
-0.2952333986759186,
-0.4476698637008667,
1.0150890350341797,
-0.3484967052936554,
-0.38133320212364197,
0.05099669098854065,
0.19136974215507507,
-0.1052158921957016,
-0.06232938915491104,
-0.6129098534584045,
-0.3051835596561432,
0.47999337315559387,
0.06937598437070847,
0.15528173744678497,
0.6075649857521057,
-0.025098172947764397,
0.7014797329902649,
0.7772925496101379,
0.024393616244196892,
-0.4076802730560303,
-0.015158694237470627,
0.9557244777679443,
-0.9994571805000305,
-0.43638357520103455,
-0.626340389251709,
0.3715669512748718,
-0.23951561748981476,
-0.31655657291412354,
0.7763272523880005,
0.5063114762306213,
0.6587893962860107,
0.20257961750030518,
0.5984352827072144,
0.29682883620262146,
0.5160250067710876,
-0.16199292242527008,
0.4717555344104767,
-0.36175790429115295,
0.4923868775367737,
-0.2502172291278839,
-0.8036679625511169,
-0.5811430215835571,
0.9738789796829224,
-0.9372761249542236,
-0.5240569114685059,
0.541448175907135,
0.9425321221351624,
0.35884037613868713,
0.4869370758533478,
0.022407902404665947,
0.3814651668071747,
0.6863164305686951,
0.426408588886261,
0.7192794680595398,
-0.1463846117258072,
0.1227211058139801,
-0.20197147130966187,
-0.35566189885139465,
0.06348824501037598,
-0.8357003331184387,
-0.7631558179855347,
-0.3399297595024109,
-0.3408122956752777,
-0.7453804612159729,
0.12629002332687378,
1.2823394536972046,
0.1384817659854889,
-0.5530593395233154,
0.00703472550958395,
-0.2949243187904358,
0.41933754086494446,
-0.1299455165863037,
-0.28706008195877075,
0.0388825461268425,
-0.28664126992225647,
0.1704728752374649,
0.1076979711651802,
0.46568673849105835,
-0.18838901817798615,
-0.3984023928642273,
-0.22764432430267334,
-0.23679082095623016,
0.581580400466919,
0.6733964085578918,
0.016843929886817932,
-0.49314987659454346,
-0.5463191270828247,
0.020965909585356712,
-0.12525275349617004,
0.3691507577896118,
1.1037935018539429,
-0.992775022983551,
0.652056872844696,
0.5360745191574097,
0.3280183672904968,
0.6280516982078552,
0.008996332064270973,
0.7565373182296753,
0.0022174064069986343,
0.0265885628759861,
0.47257450222969055,
0.33181947469711304,
0.42288339138031006,
-0.364335834980011,
0.4191049635410309,
0.4732278883457184,
-0.47865521907806396,
-0.7809576392173767,
0.440070778131485,
-0.7748939394950867,
-0.5219789743423462,
0.9500893950462341,
-0.06390503793954849,
-0.26962441205978394,
-0.22638797760009766,
-0.7852626442909241,
0.20293429493904114,
-0.44262444972991943,
1.2755721807479858,
0.774197518825531,
-0.4244418740272522,
-0.010018670931458473,
0.08637027442455292,
0.24027277529239655,
0.5505973100662231,
-0.7680817246437073,
0.3624744117259979,
0.7636280059814453,
0.20846526324748993,
0.14921672642230988,
0.9616256952285767,
-0.22714225947856903,
0.36044222116470337,
-0.05041686072945595,
-0.06094619631767273,
0.0489470399916172,
-0.027127649635076523,
-0.0632777139544487,
0.110667884349823,
-0.060210298746824265,
0.4767044186592102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03028v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03028v1
|
Word Importance Explains How Prompts Affect Language Model Outputs
| 2024-03-05T15:04:18 | 2024-03-05T15:04:18 |
Stefan Hackmann, Haniyeh Mahmoudian, Mark Steadman, Michael Schmidt
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7; I.5.2
|
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized numerous
applications across industries. However, their "black box" nature often hinders
the understanding of how they make specific decisions, raising concerns about
their transparency, reliability, and ethical use. This study presents a method
to improve the explainability of LLMs by varying individual words in prompts to
uncover their statistical impact on the model outputs. This approach, inspired
by permutation importance for tabular data, masks each word in the system
prompt and evaluates its effect on the outputs based on the available text
scores aggregated over multiple user inputs. Unlike classical attention, word
importance measures the impact of prompt words on arbitrarily-defined text
scores, which enables decomposing the importance of words into the specific
measures of interest--including bias, reading level, verbosity, etc. This
procedure also enables measuring impact when attention weights are not
available. To test the fidelity of this approach, we explore the effect of
adding different suffixes to multiple different system prompts and comparing
subsequent generations with different large language models. Results show that
word importance scores are closely related to the expected suffix importances
for multiple scoring functions.
|
[
-0.3114338517189026,
-0.6131514310836792,
0.9185776710510254,
0.48443469405174255,
-0.023332562297582626,
-0.29334306716918945,
-0.11565133929252625,
-0.12220223993062973,
0.06695961207151413,
0.25622639060020447,
-0.4511564075946808,
-0.3299631178379059,
-0.8238354921340942,
0.20457711815834045,
-0.36951375007629395,
0.959175705909729,
0.11917677521705627,
0.050560057163238525,
-0.2959670126438141,
0.09972025454044342,
-0.7317987084388733,
-0.5696611404418945,
-0.4711005687713623,
-0.31802207231521606,
0.8530451655387878,
0.29256540536880493,
0.8951947689056396,
0.7400292754173279,
0.6142715811729431,
0.3447458744049072,
-0.3219758868217468,
-0.31787076592445374,
-0.6521126627922058,
0.1822526603937149,
-0.31303671002388,
-0.4502637982368469,
-0.3916551172733307,
0.18605704605579376,
0.7741017937660217,
0.9076685309410095,
0.18950295448303223,
0.4375703036785126,
0.3492402732372284,
0.34326520562171936,
-0.5096870064735413,
0.3048053979873657,
-0.5407492518424988,
-0.3027001619338989,
-0.194959357380867,
-0.5729027390480042,
-0.39949315786361694,
-0.34717705845832825,
0.08947625011205673,
-0.32726967334747314,
0.05163395032286644,
0.11942311376333237,
0.9899482727050781,
0.21510732173919678,
-0.0660126805305481,
-0.14642424881458282,
-0.5671356320381165,
0.8897169232368469,
-0.6510917544364929,
0.3273313641548157,
0.13450145721435547,
0.09060323983430862,
-0.5426133871078491,
-0.20949731767177582,
-0.4146155118942261,
-0.025673536583781242,
-0.09178224205970764,
-0.03471701219677925,
-0.11264228820800781,
0.4840890169143677,
0.35511714220046997,
0.26091283559799194,
-0.20417369902133942,
0.16706903278827667,
-0.17564795911312103,
-0.29112690687179565,
0.349826842546463,
0.3376101851463318,
0.7031980752944946,
-0.1422376036643982,
-0.19926126301288605,
-0.08279823511838913,
-0.8498154878616333,
0.5269386172294617,
0.4843820333480835,
0.40341514348983765,
0.021740391850471497,
0.7508630156517029,
-0.19261905550956726,
0.6806499361991882,
-0.07560881972312927,
-0.430229514837265,
0.04529114440083504,
-0.4422703981399536,
-0.09230642765760422,
0.22567108273506165,
0.6468494534492493,
0.34679409861564636,
0.06974440068006516,
-0.11497364938259125,
-0.17868541181087494,
-0.06349530816078186,
0.09300928562879562,
-0.7384204864501953,
0.2788446247577667,
0.29465073347091675,
-0.4662575125694275,
-0.175283744931221,
0.1746261864900589,
-0.681115984916687,
-0.5699425339698792,
-0.3371557891368866,
0.6750006675720215,
-0.17054244875907898,
0.020596781745553017,
0.19311867654323578,
-0.3295190632343292,
0.11111409962177277,
0.6965605020523071,
-1.0232683420181274,
0.011035303585231304,
0.8449545502662659,
0.5374879240989685,
-0.23922498524188995,
-0.3995218575000763,
-0.8472930192947388,
-0.04000549763441086,
-0.36766237020492554,
0.8114568591117859,
-0.8389845490455627,
-0.2422778308391571,
-0.06515199691057205,
0.07002921402454376,
-0.02433134615421295,
-0.35818809270858765,
0.5749878883361816,
-0.3009064793586731,
0.15928800404071808,
-0.3947776257991791,
-0.5489211082458496,
-0.2551770508289337,
-0.177965447306633,
-0.4417644143104553,
0.7162303924560547,
-0.03485778346657753,
-0.6628578901290894,
0.37456148862838745,
-0.6552796363830566,
-0.46921423077583313,
0.3028898239135742,
-0.17868992686271667,
-0.013990674167871475,
0.6100825071334839,
0.07663100957870483,
0.6248457431793213,
-0.38026294112205505,
0.2903539538383484,
-0.2156973034143448,
-0.4593958854675293,
0.6567409634590149,
-0.531173825263977,
0.5483747720718384,
-0.22488394379615784,
-0.22980894148349762,
0.17315636575222015,
-0.6198990941047668,
-0.08240096271038055,
-0.1408693641424179,
-0.6826376914978027,
-0.605217456817627,
-0.04649510607123375,
-0.1886773407459259,
-0.05292665585875511,
0.19064201414585114,
-0.13905954360961914,
-0.1113288402557373,
-0.40100547671318054,
0.2971563935279846,
0.7135127782821655,
0.16499191522598267,
0.3322591185569763,
0.012622687965631485,
0.9730786681175232,
-0.16476066410541534,
0.12892751395702362,
-0.4710908830165863,
-0.7591419219970703,
-0.5605857372283936,
-0.3721596896648407,
0.40619587898254395,
0.43309709429740906,
-0.2522856295108795,
0.4155016243457794,
-0.2997561991214752,
-0.18544375896453857,
-0.5000055432319641,
-0.03330807387828827,
0.3685706555843353,
0.2596205472946167,
-0.09736677259206772,
-0.12544693052768707,
-0.3165319859981537,
-1.0045735836029053,
-0.504988431930542,
-0.31322038173675537,
-0.02532668597996235,
0.31417497992515564,
0.2779589891433716,
-0.1097286269068718,
1.052347183227539,
-0.5535520911216736,
0.2642703354358673,
-0.416299045085907,
-0.014635637402534485,
0.44041693210601807,
-0.09070896357297897,
0.32105252146720886,
-0.34007152915000916,
0.022673532366752625,
-0.24414031207561493,
-0.39985474944114685,
-0.6253104209899902,
-0.3529210686683655,
-0.28161630034446716,
-0.30697616934776306,
0.3988129198551178,
-0.638343334197998,
0.47446954250335693,
0.5282343626022339,
-0.5909539461135864,
0.7124221324920654,
-0.24671603739261627,
0.26680102944374084,
-0.6837250590324402,
-0.08479982614517212,
-0.005748899187892675,
0.0654706209897995,
-0.7360516786575317,
-0.04805038124322891,
0.044154416769742966,
-0.33626383543014526,
-0.36321860551834106,
0.7939332127571106,
-0.6139741539955139,
-0.30736058950424194,
-0.13135887682437897,
0.25249046087265015,
0.28473520278930664,
0.11564304679632187,
-0.5325760841369629,
0.9962303042411804,
0.31837335228919983,
-0.8775914907455444,
-0.010018274188041687,
0.02305018901824951,
-0.42755502462387085,
0.16994892060756683,
-0.6213508248329163,
-0.30376124382019043,
-0.1512724608182907,
-0.2776741683483124,
-1.5865390300750732,
-0.038304653018713,
-0.05279091000556946,
-0.5413137078285217,
0.3094441890716553,
0.116362065076828,
-0.3919285535812378,
-0.2368864119052887,
-0.38157492876052856,
0.15011493861675262,
0.21464061737060547,
-0.46003100275993347,
0.43418610095977783,
0.656182587146759,
-0.26798146963119507,
-0.43199947476387024,
-0.5324795246124268,
0.2293541580438614,
-0.4405355751514435,
-0.5127531290054321,
0.1288854032754898,
-0.02582608535885811,
-0.547619640827179,
-0.17873823642730713,
-0.16277353465557098,
0.34573203325271606,
0.637935221195221,
0.4170616865158081,
0.2850326895713806,
-0.07478385418653488,
0.6659879088401794,
0.1082015261054039,
-0.19821599125862122,
0.28500524163246155,
-0.039387233555316925,
0.5778531432151794,
0.1484682857990265,
-0.08241903781890869,
-0.33907607197761536,
0.28919923305511475,
0.6413783431053162,
-0.222757950425148,
0.9539994597434998,
0.2695702910423279,
-0.2267981469631195,
-0.18026839196681976,
-0.5720894932746887,
-0.3711315393447876,
-0.47231850028038025,
0.479379266500473,
-0.2941332459449768,
-0.7849153876304626,
0.5514355301856995,
0.1034836620092392,
-0.015875471755862236,
0.5738845467567444,
0.4697740077972412,
0.07788560539484024,
0.936320960521698,
0.6669321656227112,
0.028211776167154312,
0.7136155962944031,
0.32434067130088806,
0.4653286933898926,
-0.7933144569396973,
0.14735770225524902,
-0.6119124293327332,
-0.11324393004179001,
-0.49258267879486084,
-0.28581321239471436,
0.4202716052532196,
0.2622971832752228,
0.0988503247499466,
0.03604792058467865,
-0.3994702696800232,
0.5079644322395325,
0.33802613615989685,
-0.11539851874113083,
0.3971390426158905,
0.3270731270313263,
-0.021171417087316513,
-0.14171139895915985,
-0.6122769117355347,
-0.864537239074707,
0.9562253952026367,
0.6145371794700623,
0.8622131943702698,
0.15048807859420776,
0.5335054993629456,
0.2305307239294052,
0.12863244116306305,
-0.8895714282989502,
0.7065790891647339,
-0.1503048986196518,
-0.39986398816108704,
-0.6211732625961304,
-0.45352914929389954,
-1.1951369047164917,
0.3253049850463867,
-0.20677410066127777,
-0.882714569568634,
0.09137014299631119,
0.1349167823791504,
-0.6720088720321655,
-0.21696557104587555,
-0.9668972492218018,
0.6418018937110901,
-0.147474467754364,
-0.308644562959671,
-0.3116647005081177,
-0.23238787055015564,
0.35098084807395935,
0.0657428428530693,
0.38879483938217163,
-0.18478640913963318,
-0.28417661786079407,
0.9572364091873169,
-0.5025244355201721,
0.9300618767738342,
0.12410784512758255,
-0.23898281157016754,
0.137678861618042,
0.016202596947550774,
0.4101555645465851,
0.010812605731189251,
-0.07848364114761353,
0.3383544087409973,
-0.3284952640533447,
0.03664937987923622,
-0.6764413118362427,
0.9096733331680298,
-0.6716462969779968,
-1.2275739908218384,
-0.22168400883674622,
-0.7806219458580017,
-0.018022362142801285,
0.02683255448937416,
0.009329967200756073,
0.6910450458526611,
0.08976201713085175,
-0.06088591367006302,
0.6695072054862976,
-0.590837299823761,
0.4248698055744171,
0.38201120495796204,
-0.32959240674972534,
-0.1803431510925293,
0.7784131169319153,
0.46071839332580566,
0.33815091848373413,
0.40327218174934387,
0.6106787919998169,
-0.21021120250225067,
-0.455252468585968,
-0.38320842385292053,
0.4171615540981293,
-0.9154208898544312,
0.10163472592830658,
-0.8891028165817261,
0.03329860046505928,
-0.3804883658885956,
-0.08974801003932953,
0.23352840542793274,
-0.3948788046836853,
-0.506779134273529,
-0.09685448557138443,
0.7157774567604065,
0.7289239168167114,
0.3045555651187897,
0.49172523617744446,
-0.6835512518882751,
0.19128729403018951,
0.45505842566490173,
0.5346200466156006,
0.18812233209609985,
-0.7455755472183228,
-0.13132354617118835,
-0.4010564982891083,
-0.05946286767721176,
-1.2055305242538452,
0.2512078881263733,
-0.011255599558353424,
0.962377667427063,
0.4850742816925049,
-0.21292255818843842,
0.5397911667823792,
-0.49089303612709045,
0.7325300574302673,
0.2611239552497864,
-1.1428308486938477,
0.5050606727600098,
-0.4698870778083801,
0.703349769115448,
0.4530942142009735,
0.04704197123646736,
-0.6125741004943848,
-0.4666653573513031,
-0.48875731229782104,
-1.0289108753204346,
0.9402767419815063,
0.13718274235725403,
0.05844768509268761,
-0.16296212375164032,
0.44417983293533325,
0.14931584894657135,
0.21641844511032104,
-0.4965163767337799,
-0.2487368881702423,
0.35390445590019226,
-0.17638105154037476,
-0.14033308625221252,
-0.6924741268157959,
0.1586565226316452,
-0.15668684244155884,
0.6311514377593994,
0.2948773205280304,
0.11890950798988342,
0.11745663732290268,
-0.010824616998434067,
0.03364621475338936,
0.6616148352622986,
0.6111615300178528,
0.6798768639564514,
0.07307861745357513,
0.16287420690059662,
0.14200572669506073,
-0.625361979007721,
0.16012981534004211,
-0.14721761643886566,
-0.30510592460632324,
0.24238042533397675,
0.43705660104751587,
0.8696561455726624,
0.2910239100456238,
-0.6048844456672668,
0.3063860237598419,
0.1456095278263092,
0.3506912887096405,
0.1669742465019226,
0.20286698639392853,
0.24872300028800964,
0.01712319254875183,
0.3648476004600525,
-0.23381565511226654,
0.37692585587501526,
-0.8654032945632935,
-0.1420455127954483,
0.37529119849205017,
-0.31760719418525696,
-0.1947515904903412,
0.2694506347179413,
0.21248921751976013,
-0.5587000250816345,
-0.0644088163971901,
-0.12148735672235489,
-0.5589994788169861,
0.8212957978248596,
0.4412460923194885,
0.7349123954772949,
-0.6173689365386963,
0.15112528204917908,
0.3706583082675934,
0.5586613416671753,
-0.21842904388904572,
0.29143083095550537,
0.35901185870170593,
-0.4383346736431122,
-0.472518652677536,
-0.6126474142074585,
-0.26021328568458557,
0.22167186439037323,
-0.24913401901721954,
0.4219083786010742,
-0.38465404510498047,
-0.4848460555076599,
0.23594965040683746,
-0.389221727848053,
-0.6045625805854797,
0.009712700732052326,
0.034365542232990265,
0.48295119404792786,
-0.9757026433944702,
0.17306795716285706,
0.6455666422843933,
-0.23734621703624725,
-0.8918672800064087,
0.13202805817127228,
-0.0811203196644783,
-0.6413678526878357,
0.8225231170654297,
0.3735719919204712,
-0.2274124175310135,
-0.08713969588279724,
-0.29122260212898254,
-1.3545546531677246,
0.643638014793396,
0.5006442070007324,
-0.7007726430892944,
0.29877105355262756,
0.03030741587281227,
0.5334587693214417,
-0.4784161150455475,
0.7567610740661621,
0.5729988813400269,
0.6854975819587708,
-0.2742288410663605,
-0.7872904539108276,
0.1841748058795929,
0.07975871115922928,
0.21302032470703125,
0.3680853247642517,
-0.21283504366874695,
0.6544476747512817,
-0.5396238565444946,
-0.6734012961387634,
-0.3894098401069641,
0.29496562480926514,
0.24842160940170288,
0.1426359862089157,
0.5333779454231262,
0.1464896947145462,
0.7244061231613159,
-0.12946189939975739,
1.2059789896011353,
-0.09718142449855804,
0.05477626621723175,
0.9576233625411987,
-0.05230842903256416,
0.6538545489311218,
0.6896324753761292,
-0.3649533987045288,
0.17100930213928223,
0.6127669215202332,
0.11448102444410324,
0.17219381034374237,
0.579279899597168,
0.13378632068634033,
-0.3628818392753601,
-0.33979931473731995,
-0.21810299158096313,
0.232629656791687,
0.6493005156517029,
-0.69135582447052,
-0.35315901041030884,
0.15434402227401733,
0.16696017980575562,
-0.013060917146503925,
-0.41715294122695923,
0.6214501857757568,
0.06842726469039917,
-0.6936944127082825,
0.4835579991340637,
-0.19281424582004547,
0.4410957992076874,
-0.537346601486206,
-0.08431108295917511,
-0.11677709221839905,
0.07460691779851913,
-0.3192983865737915,
-0.885948657989502,
-0.17904731631278992,
0.06666592508554459,
-0.4945595860481262,
-0.13086867332458496,
0.45442822575569153,
-0.3717416822910309,
-0.7442101836204529,
0.41328057646751404,
0.4649563133716583,
0.45534831285476685,
-0.13159815967082977,
-0.29748162627220154,
0.3087127208709717,
-0.037371303886175156,
-0.4731522500514984,
0.29806673526763916,
0.5828389525413513,
-0.21950380504131317,
0.6700014472007751,
0.6141142845153809,
0.25222650170326233,
-0.019368445500731468,
0.3067522644996643,
0.7350674867630005,
-0.6296192407608032,
-0.5194950699806213,
-1.0863977670669556,
0.353004515171051,
0.06543786078691483,
-0.42469310760498047,
0.9512930512428284,
0.30966535210609436,
0.07016901671886444,
-0.0035592075437307358,
0.7116217613220215,
0.3616824448108673,
0.44871416687965393,
-0.44355854392051697,
0.7379192113876343,
-0.5250696539878845,
0.7299445867538452,
-0.42821574211120605,
-0.9102727174758911,
-0.3368765115737915,
0.08921889215707779,
-0.7540788054466248,
-0.061053644865751266,
0.7509272694587708,
0.7554876804351807,
0.256622850894928,
-0.1711958646774292,
0.5386174917221069,
0.47634661197662354,
0.15672224760055542,
0.22026503086090088,
0.656058669090271,
-0.28205832839012146,
0.6055944561958313,
0.24273507297039032,
-0.5658032298088074,
-0.3804944157600403,
-0.946648120880127,
-0.864759087562561,
-0.4766797125339508,
-0.5000730156898499,
-0.31565752625465393,
0.08982264995574951,
0.8434739112854004,
0.25171372294425964,
-0.6582403182983398,
-0.11322580277919769,
0.3720780313014984,
0.3734835088253021,
-0.17976558208465576,
-0.29587310552597046,
0.5882102251052856,
-0.5113004446029663,
-0.3547286093235016,
0.2539386451244354,
0.5775420069694519,
-0.01623672805726528,
-0.3136407434940338,
0.30998894572257996,
-0.0002847762661986053,
0.3305761218070984,
0.7066247463226318,
-0.19566412270069122,
-1.0756862163543701,
-0.487181156873703,
-0.0294850692152977,
-0.22436173260211945,
-0.14663806557655334,
0.7020977139472961,
-0.671474039554596,
0.48866209387779236,
0.9832062721252441,
0.4904136061668396,
-0.33065229654312134,
-0.017738061025738716,
0.8362401127815247,
-0.3465305268764496,
-0.18901361525058746,
-0.22848229110240936,
0.5958040356636047,
0.48339223861694336,
-0.9159979224205017,
0.2751743793487549,
0.027077605947852135,
-0.5246583819389343,
-0.7116518616676331,
0.13963812589645386,
-0.846149206161499,
-0.3396623432636261,
1.6258418560028076,
-0.13116885721683502,
-0.4154394865036011,
-0.3634648323059082,
-0.30026811361312866,
0.005171307362616062,
-0.7897370457649231,
0.8881806135177612,
1.0594983100891113,
0.21366874873638153,
-0.25544291734695435,
-0.5964013338088989,
0.35153505206108093,
0.5434538125991821,
-0.726747453212738,
0.48677128553390503,
0.39272546768188477,
0.14640839397907257,
0.27239564061164856,
0.21569249033927917,
-0.22308449447155,
0.05690383538603783,
-0.3331073224544525,
0.3221793472766876,
0.15268972516059875,
-0.17470267415046692,
-0.8382973670959473,
0.23507507145404816,
0.14417989552021027,
-0.040758922696113586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03014v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03014v1
|
The Case for Evaluating Multimodal Translation Models on Text Datasets
| 2024-03-05T14:49:52 | 2024-03-05T14:49:52 |
Vipin Vijayan, Braeden Bowen, Scott Grigsby, Timothy Anderson, Jeremy Gwinnup
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A good evaluation framework should evaluate multimodal machine translation
(MMT) models by measuring 1) their use of visual information to aid in the
translation task and 2) their ability to translate complex sentences such as
done for text-only machine translation. However, most current work in MMT is
evaluated against the Multi30k testing sets, which do not measure these
properties. Namely, the use of visual information by the MMT model cannot be
shown directly from the Multi30k test set results and the sentences in Multi30k
are are image captions, i.e., short, descriptive sentences, as opposed to
complex sentences that typical text-only machine translation models are
evaluated against.
Therefore, we propose that MMT models be evaluated using 1) the CoMMuTE
evaluation framework, which measures the use of visual information by MMT
models, 2) the text-only WMT news translation task test sets, which evaluates
translation performance against complex sentences, and 3) the Multi30k test
sets, for measuring MMT model performance against a real MMT dataset. Finally,
we evaluate recent MMT models trained solely against the Multi30k dataset
against our proposed evaluation framework and demonstrate the dramatic drop
performance against text-only testing sets compared to recent text-only MT
models.
|
[
-0.38326936960220337,
-0.382242888212204,
0.5302563309669495,
0.297504186630249,
-0.37481051683425903,
-0.13191178441047668,
-0.27111852169036865,
-0.2843364477157593,
-0.31674623489379883,
0.3489704430103302,
-0.7626393437385559,
-0.26861414313316345,
-0.696135938167572,
0.37955549359321594,
-0.7263088822364807,
1.0327750444412231,
-0.3740997016429901,
0.25696367025375366,
-0.5122377276420593,
-0.3564683496952057,
-0.5718988180160522,
-0.4060441851615906,
-0.09558897465467453,
-0.24859820306301117,
0.37443575263023376,
0.24939575791358948,
0.7832005620002747,
0.6802773475646973,
1.1272013187408447,
0.3559671640396118,
0.19500455260276794,
0.27791866660118103,
-0.2100847363471985,
-0.27652254700660706,
0.0511200986802578,
-0.4277040660381317,
-0.3148583769798279,
0.26429328322410583,
0.5439153909683228,
0.7604669332504272,
0.1608198881149292,
0.21621805429458618,
-0.08799504488706589,
0.47877898812294006,
-0.4094277322292328,
0.4173109233379364,
-0.39005619287490845,
0.2415364384651184,
-0.1864878237247467,
-0.34258487820625305,
-0.6953535676002502,
-0.0969148576259613,
0.1242586150765419,
-0.653319239616394,
0.20434671640396118,
0.33117732405662537,
0.8244352340698242,
0.1481962352991104,
-0.9467452764511108,
-0.17968562245368958,
-0.5831295251846313,
0.966193437576294,
-0.5308563709259033,
0.6552989482879639,
0.2425607591867447,
0.6199883222579956,
0.025386517867445946,
-0.40099626779556274,
-0.604627251625061,
-0.5362093448638916,
-0.04367201775312424,
0.6338152885437012,
-0.3278527855873108,
0.10266571491956711,
0.3351966440677643,
0.499637246131897,
-0.8402507901191711,
-0.17928504943847656,
-0.38823792338371277,
-0.07476191967725754,
0.2580261528491974,
0.39747416973114014,
0.3748350739479065,
-0.4604807198047638,
-0.7529987692832947,
-0.4626690149307251,
-0.4540809988975525,
0.0000913737021619454,
0.06897732615470886,
0.18871580064296722,
-0.3962419629096985,
1.0337185859680176,
-0.11649172753095627,
0.7726005911827087,
-0.357644647359848,
-0.20247076451778412,
0.47922468185424805,
-0.7683368921279907,
-0.38861754536628723,
-0.47397077083587646,
0.8265217542648315,
0.9036685824394226,
0.3071545362472534,
-0.3058015704154968,
-0.36916738748550415,
0.19574926793575287,
0.17624229192733765,
-0.9254419207572937,
-0.026002848520874977,
-0.10718102008104324,
-0.682072639465332,
-0.22620795667171478,
-0.07700985670089722,
-0.7483749985694885,
-0.1718853861093521,
-0.38531115651130676,
0.4200487434864044,
-0.3900093734264374,
-0.11431095004081726,
0.12650595605373383,
-0.3282953202724457,
-0.07876311242580414,
0.3566587269306183,
-0.6099171042442322,
0.2185322344303131,
0.20808684825897217,
0.758307695388794,
-0.33839818835258484,
-0.521665096282959,
-0.295926034450531,
0.016769984737038612,
-0.2784328758716583,
0.7138862609863281,
-0.3646608591079712,
-0.09931632876396179,
-0.012088732793927193,
0.30686134099960327,
-0.7050819396972656,
-0.45731881260871887,
0.5373992323875427,
-0.325125128030777,
0.03531664237380028,
-0.23963148891925812,
-0.4073881208896637,
-0.33832430839538574,
0.421721875667572,
-0.740250289440155,
0.4897219240665436,
0.046682316809892654,
-0.6170358657836914,
0.5240239500999451,
-0.8794047236442566,
-0.4998287856578827,
-0.2998654544353485,
0.14024688303470612,
-0.45849207043647766,
0.21033401787281036,
0.2977021634578705,
0.5462046265602112,
-0.4423668384552002,
0.19545933604240417,
-0.5427011847496033,
-0.37055981159210205,
0.45998603105545044,
-0.8573059439659119,
0.398712694644928,
0.49209627509117126,
-0.2089962661266327,
0.054044779390096664,
-0.616077721118927,
-0.13055133819580078,
-0.018112098798155785,
-0.5081250071525574,
-0.2919122278690338,
-0.053860701620578766,
0.5323376059532166,
0.535361111164093,
-0.11459631472826004,
-0.5753329396247864,
0.1661943644285202,
-0.03932530805468559,
0.3047836124897003,
0.6438527703285217,
-0.28731510043144226,
0.3190276324748993,
-0.4723418056964874,
0.7345510721206665,
0.31827083230018616,
0.11849938333034515,
-0.4975352883338928,
-0.5390751361846924,
-0.8884260654449463,
-0.3584385812282562,
0.2675246596336365,
0.5151359438896179,
-1.05634605884552,
-0.10992299765348434,
-0.7147957682609558,
-0.46864819526672363,
-0.49260246753692627,
-0.20119065046310425,
0.5022463202476501,
0.2857288718223572,
0.4663756191730499,
-0.1798924058675766,
-0.3676735460758209,
-1.12576425075531,
-0.38799095153808594,
0.13052977621555328,
0.11642342805862427,
0.22570516169071198,
0.7340536713600159,
-0.1903703361749649,
0.5561624765396118,
-0.18142485618591309,
-0.019368022680282593,
-0.16578011214733124,
0.3611743152141571,
0.02528453804552555,
0.4179256856441498,
0.5474612712860107,
-1.0167696475982666,
-0.28729623556137085,
0.19793549180030823,
-0.9480450749397278,
0.04470052570104599,
-0.32125478982925415,
0.23719270527362823,
-0.15130022168159485,
0.19589851796627045,
-0.6375616788864136,
0.5241857171058655,
0.8866395354270935,
-0.35827410221099854,
0.5454750657081604,
-0.16856689751148224,
0.8359515070915222,
-1.0065199136734009,
0.12496943026781082,
0.12412749230861664,
-0.5442308783531189,
-0.37108656764030457,
0.03512544557452202,
0.31411904096603394,
-0.2990027070045471,
-0.5302829146385193,
0.471242755651474,
-0.3424626290798187,
-0.13981503248214722,
0.12582720816135406,
0.024517789483070374,
0.12341167032718658,
0.38721922039985657,
-0.3576015830039978,
0.9064416289329529,
0.040837619453668594,
-0.5448593497276306,
0.33461448550224304,
0.36442095041275024,
-0.6788398623466492,
0.8613535165786743,
-0.1793309599161148,
-0.09903640300035477,
0.081153005361557,
0.08973174542188644,
-1.0324277877807617,
-0.22415979206562042,
0.14888617396354675,
-0.32668617367744446,
0.05005621537566185,
0.015215059742331505,
-0.8421294689178467,
-0.3998945355415344,
-0.15641723573207855,
0.3323262631893158,
0.09855161607265472,
-0.46594366431236267,
0.3985259532928467,
-0.047012586146593094,
0.05250048637390137,
-0.2939940392971039,
-0.916690468788147,
0.3073042631149292,
-0.31447502970695496,
-0.8333091139793396,
0.21359604597091675,
-0.2732541561126709,
0.01226546335965395,
-0.09524289518594742,
-0.001740271458402276,
-0.21035268902778625,
0.152670755982399,
0.2984687387943268,
0.1923035830259323,
-0.19073817133903503,
0.13972660899162292,
0.11956644058227539,
-0.21451592445373535,
-0.16533197462558746,
0.0946824923157692,
0.3375318646430969,
-0.1689210832118988,
-0.5653659105300903,
-0.42025622725486755,
0.38244667649269104,
0.980989396572113,
-0.44598400592803955,
0.6758599877357483,
0.813726544380188,
-0.15749463438987732,
0.4206849932670593,
-0.4613226056098938,
-0.014589987695217133,
-0.3309684693813324,
0.7576762437820435,
-0.7984585165977478,
-0.6399815678596497,
0.41766461730003357,
-0.14245466887950897,
0.015540274791419506,
0.5898089408874512,
0.688753068447113,
-0.2352394312620163,
1.3383550643920898,
0.5379159450531006,
0.4441349506378174,
0.44971132278442383,
-0.16862283647060394,
0.13598927855491638,
-0.8454143404960632,
-0.012441493570804596,
-0.3687920868396759,
-0.21493294835090637,
-0.6937990188598633,
-0.2001497596502304,
0.37653565406799316,
-0.25745052099227905,
0.0350499153137207,
0.45608046650886536,
-0.16945835947990417,
0.16914628446102142,
0.20908890664577484,
0.14899416267871857,
0.5495823621749878,
0.1458345204591751,
-0.2923620641231537,
-0.28614357113838196,
-0.6769984364509583,
-0.6640888452529907,
1.336223840713501,
0.2796247601509094,
0.6721756458282471,
0.0840035155415535,
-0.06058377027511597,
0.37989887595176697,
0.5993949770927429,
-0.5621991753578186,
0.40616893768310547,
-0.42449262738227844,
-0.7517087459564209,
0.009596049785614014,
-0.7974104285240173,
-0.9159736633300781,
0.5047938823699951,
-0.0977504551410675,
-0.06408127397298813,
0.11925602704286575,
-0.07127240300178528,
-0.07813067734241486,
0.16923272609710693,
-1.0200414657592773,
1.209121584892273,
-0.19435042142868042,
-0.022112257778644562,
-0.14184817671775818,
-0.47895339131355286,
0.44892799854278564,
-0.19643284380435944,
0.5416116714477539,
-0.20166660845279694,
0.0822252482175827,
0.790686845779419,
-0.08705256134271622,
0.6306336522102356,
-0.09099684655666351,
0.2080937922000885,
-0.06682612001895905,
0.054460205137729645,
0.228667214512825,
-0.3481071889400482,
-0.04161491617560387,
-0.026350995525717735,
0.3747924864292145,
-0.3259076774120331,
-0.5743514895439148,
0.38171297311782837,
-0.6002898812294006,
-0.05649692192673683,
-0.24103708565235138,
-0.9120003581047058,
-0.05969538539648056,
0.19129139184951782,
0.262026846408844,
0.39060306549072266,
-0.2166387438774109,
0.4921717047691345,
0.20494601130485535,
-0.048765022307634354,
0.4661502242088318,
0.4801982343196869,
-0.3082074522972107,
-0.45809417963027954,
0.9659025073051453,
0.26291605830192566,
0.5670385360717773,
0.21867279708385468,
0.12191655486822128,
-0.30091193318367004,
-0.43995147943496704,
-0.9604488015174866,
-0.2266804277896881,
-0.8887632489204407,
-0.24233683943748474,
-0.6352620720863342,
0.2576644718647003,
-0.18888023495674133,
0.18682074546813965,
-0.4236546456813812,
-0.3444499373435974,
0.21681950986385345,
0.08092380315065384,
0.005403394810855389,
0.5633278489112854,
0.1675136834383011,
0.44948631525039673,
-0.818575382232666,
0.4028458595275879,
0.18539565801620483,
0.10856525599956512,
-0.25791099667549133,
-0.45500507950782776,
-0.5218943357467651,
0.19226573407649994,
-0.5004687309265137,
-0.8655539155006409,
0.34032514691352844,
0.01684962771832943,
0.4260309338569641,
0.121951162815094,
-0.21802368760108948,
0.8616898655891418,
-0.5125320553779602,
0.564179539680481,
0.281110942363739,
-0.8610446453094482,
0.11497517675161362,
-0.4054316282272339,
0.4235267639160156,
0.5026334524154663,
0.05347893014550209,
-0.6958971619606018,
-0.28499624133110046,
-0.26280972361564636,
-0.526789665222168,
0.45312216877937317,
0.5623860359191895,
0.23076821863651276,
0.0615687258541584,
0.0047231148928403854,
0.12979048490524292,
0.6063120365142822,
-1.092803955078125,
-0.05322587117552757,
-0.21439620852470398,
-0.4834349453449249,
-0.2869628667831421,
-0.07166676968336105,
0.04755116254091263,
-0.16890209913253784,
0.2705696225166321,
-0.12518759071826935,
0.4345223605632782,
0.022459063678979874,
-0.5301294326782227,
-0.04726286605000496,
0.3052200675010681,
0.6400700807571411,
0.6392207741737366,
-0.2594778537750244,
0.16868644952774048,
-0.05429479852318764,
-0.2603982985019684,
0.34398195147514343,
0.18850752711296082,
-0.19262725114822388,
0.11138534545898438,
0.5584114789962769,
0.8665353059768677,
0.354329913854599,
-0.5403715968132019,
0.8562271595001221,
-0.11873709410429001,
-0.05783537030220032,
0.041375137865543365,
-0.31321701407432556,
0.008484935387969017,
0.17006386816501617,
0.02404152788221836,
0.6242843866348267,
0.2475338578224182,
-0.38505813479423523,
0.26450273394584656,
0.25384438037872314,
-0.743599534034729,
-0.2862202227115631,
0.580122709274292,
0.12940631806850433,
0.06186237931251526,
0.6106236577033997,
-0.10398135334253311,
-0.4455942213535309,
0.7666136622428894,
0.4694722890853882,
0.667984127998352,
-0.28804662823677063,
0.07118009030818939,
0.06750660389661789,
0.7803931832313538,
-0.11637742072343826,
0.039129361510276794,
0.023161757737398148,
-0.4808540642261505,
-0.5978846549987793,
-0.33211463689804077,
-0.3020818829536438,
-0.0952741727232933,
-0.6514551639556885,
0.34215015172958374,
0.1879376471042633,
-0.18268702924251556,
-0.047342751175165176,
-0.33945152163505554,
-0.9971342086791992,
0.475991815328598,
-0.17289689183235168,
0.6793679594993591,
-1.1583974361419678,
0.676730215549469,
0.6325469017028809,
-0.6410877108573914,
-0.20632609724998474,
-0.345947802066803,
-0.17904633283615112,
-0.504264771938324,
0.561108410358429,
0.4956277906894684,
0.215611532330513,
-0.08868158608675003,
-0.42876383662223816,
-0.43768027424812317,
1.0838470458984375,
0.631786048412323,
-0.39574486017227173,
0.29721778631210327,
0.41452908515930176,
0.3011014759540558,
-0.42228609323501587,
0.40443551540374756,
0.11658068746328354,
0.8775566816329956,
-0.06846712529659271,
-1.18692946434021,
-0.056367695331573486,
-0.3570127487182617,
0.01306040957570076,
-0.07163012772798538,
-0.6761935353279114,
1.0224107503890991,
-0.038602977991104126,
-0.22261932492256165,
0.13886132836341858,
0.33078494668006897,
0.028362786397337914,
0.386931836605072,
0.5625903010368347,
0.5217116475105286,
0.329314649105072,
-0.2027732878923416,
1.4537653923034668,
0.11481314897537231,
0.6121106743812561,
0.9642170667648315,
-0.13625457882881165,
0.7278660535812378,
0.6496514678001404,
-0.11044708639383316,
-0.18618981540203094,
0.7857730388641357,
-0.3788468539714813,
0.7376824021339417,
0.266219824552536,
0.08992723375558853,
-0.512084424495697,
-0.0685916393995285,
-0.36829572916030884,
0.509278416633606,
-0.27049559354782104,
-0.4996296465396881,
-0.40537071228027344,
0.5706789493560791,
0.10058864206075668,
-0.10059206932783127,
0.1461479216814041,
0.4612923264503479,
0.10591739416122437,
-0.5758063197135925,
0.49862968921661377,
0.4154583215713501,
0.38222765922546387,
-0.34596186876296997,
-0.15310432016849518,
-0.2328225076198578,
0.2991383671760559,
-0.0036192499101161957,
-0.51724773645401,
0.4283387362957001,
0.03865780681371689,
-0.275021493434906,
-0.37528714537620544,
0.26666051149368286,
-0.3253656029701233,
-0.7825978398323059,
0.26669934391975403,
0.6119754314422607,
0.1890391707420349,
-0.3521535396575928,
-0.6491552591323853,
0.08732420951128006,
0.055627644062042236,
-0.3668850362300873,
0.22395148873329163,
0.5182251930236816,
-0.12089844048023224,
0.8603044152259827,
0.8827887773513794,
-0.2764568626880646,
0.26798269152641296,
0.008319860324263573,
0.8042091727256775,
-0.5729764699935913,
-0.20968858897686005,
-1.023095726966858,
0.5479983687400818,
0.06744402647018433,
-0.387546181678772,
0.8936001062393188,
0.9555909633636475,
0.7249877452850342,
-0.348577082157135,
0.7214240431785583,
0.1548868715763092,
0.0993828997015953,
-0.7154595255851746,
0.8641660213470459,
-0.829547643661499,
0.034489311277866364,
-0.41063347458839417,
-0.967016339302063,
-0.3368466794490814,
0.519372284412384,
-0.24717648327350616,
0.14961187541484833,
1.060255527496338,
0.5347679853439331,
-0.39406001567840576,
0.04273053631186485,
0.7515556812286377,
0.16675254702568054,
0.4155321419239044,
0.5905194878578186,
0.9097269177436829,
-0.9360642433166504,
0.8260539770126343,
-0.053022220730781555,
-0.31782498955726624,
-0.04824693128466606,
-0.8463497757911682,
-1.0514596700668335,
-0.6148630976676941,
-0.20229294896125793,
-0.15349455177783966,
0.009971353225409985,
0.6335552930831909,
0.78199303150177,
-0.575261652469635,
-0.3799059987068176,
0.24077928066253662,
-0.12525996565818787,
-0.4822559654712677,
-0.1076146736741066,
0.3429933786392212,
-0.23137493431568146,
-0.6959779858589172,
0.3796006143093109,
0.3792293965816498,
0.10916801542043686,
-0.2662546634674072,
0.01892141066491604,
-0.2424808293581009,
-0.11426422744989395,
0.735490620136261,
-0.5437981486320496,
-0.5290656685829163,
-0.14314480125904083,
0.22420091927051544,
-0.2721674144268036,
0.2844211161136627,
0.5598229765892029,
-0.3264566957950592,
0.7520135045051575,
0.38152214884757996,
0.4573667645454407,
0.7174151539802551,
-0.3187178075313568,
0.6618765592575073,
-0.3170393407344818,
0.19956253468990326,
-0.13777151703834534,
0.4013575315475464,
0.4236425757408142,
0.13954220712184906,
0.6102153062820435,
0.4884018898010254,
-0.20406027138233185,
-0.8037483096122742,
-0.011496960185468197,
-0.9736680388450623,
0.1265062689781189,
0.8542081117630005,
-0.4358114004135132,
-0.35121363401412964,
-0.07233018428087234,
-0.0659928098320961,
0.3009682297706604,
-0.06384384632110596,
0.5955235362052917,
1.0553480386734009,
0.2613126039505005,
-0.3635765016078949,
-1.2270007133483887,
0.040754422545433044,
0.3609010577201843,
-0.8667585253715515,
-0.029924558475613594,
0.2660486400127411,
0.0643291249871254,
0.2058703750371933,
0.1964581459760666,
-0.2729722559452057,
0.2748662531375885,
-0.05891202762722969,
0.3112999498844147,
-0.25536781549453735,
-0.23146219551563263,
-0.08160777390003204,
0.06967301666736603,
-0.3498205840587616,
-0.5498194098472595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02990v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02990v4
|
Data Augmentation using Large Language Models: Data Perspectives, Learning Paradigms and Challenges
| 2024-03-05T14:11:54 | 2024-07-02T07:59:40 |
Bosheng Ding, Chengwei Qin, Ruochen Zhao, Tianze Luo, Xinze Li, Guizhen Chen, Wenhan Xia, Junjie Hu, Anh Tuan Luu, Shafiq Joty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the rapidly evolving field of large language models (LLMs), data
augmentation (DA) has emerged as a pivotal technique for enhancing model
performance by diversifying training examples without the need for additional
data collection. This survey explores the transformative impact of LLMs on DA,
particularly addressing the unique challenges and opportunities they present in
the context of natural language processing (NLP) and beyond. From both data and
learning perspectives, we examine various strategies that utilize LLMs for data
augmentation, including a novel exploration of learning paradigms where
LLM-generated data is used for diverse forms of further training. Additionally,
this paper highlights the primary open challenges faced in this domain, ranging
from controllable data augmentation to multi-modal data augmentation. This
survey highlights a paradigm shift introduced by LLMs in DA, and aims to serve
as a comprehensive guide for researchers and practitioners.
|
[
-0.3643002212047577,
-0.8678044080734253,
0.4709649384021759,
-0.06188337504863739,
-0.051089514046907425,
0.33497077226638794,
-0.39213648438453674,
-0.7196974158287048,
0.09472224861383438,
0.4989362359046936,
-0.6838903427124023,
-0.44261038303375244,
-0.6026544570922852,
0.28747937083244324,
-0.47589701414108276,
0.8154850602149963,
0.04830024018883705,
0.17857694625854492,
-0.39372238516807556,
0.06440874189138412,
-0.6380180716514587,
-0.898016095161438,
-0.5186993479728699,
-0.3112986385822296,
0.5624647736549377,
0.3217712938785553,
0.6469090580940247,
0.7558293342590332,
0.47908326983451843,
0.27085772156715393,
-0.09540323168039322,
0.4950920343399048,
-0.4984000325202942,
0.30624300241470337,
-0.024364588782191277,
-0.6752864122390747,
-0.5477396845817566,
-0.12731288373470306,
1.0234699249267578,
1.2926815748214722,
0.04568469524383545,
-0.023765133693814278,
0.018504412844777107,
0.8767375946044922,
-0.5739591121673584,
0.23971426486968994,
-0.5817508697509766,
0.030223388224840164,
-0.4421091377735138,
-0.10893809795379639,
-0.21535924077033997,
-0.19972456991672516,
0.2817106246948242,
-0.40106332302093506,
-0.060740724205970764,
-0.15517549216747284,
0.27513858675956726,
0.29036256670951843,
-0.7003096342086792,
-0.26184698939323425,
-1.087071418762207,
0.8775367140769958,
-0.7304273247718811,
0.6453070640563965,
0.15531043708324432,
0.10784570127725601,
-0.25762876868247986,
-0.6674101948738098,
-0.5705072283744812,
-0.03345651179552078,
0.16440525650978088,
-0.3225632905960083,
0.007597249001264572,
-0.06144722178578377,
0.444156289100647,
0.673533022403717,
-0.2652876079082489,
0.67442786693573,
-0.33188769221305847,
0.14669564366340637,
0.9318320751190186,
0.4425414502620697,
0.15762177109718323,
0.0012944485060870647,
-0.14630942046642303,
-0.312706857919693,
-0.913008987903595,
-0.18877728283405304,
0.4575612246990204,
0.4133060574531555,
-0.04596719145774841,
0.6089729070663452,
-0.2577253580093384,
1.010960578918457,
-0.2845965325832367,
-0.0331149697303772,
0.4688214361667633,
-0.34042346477508545,
-0.15244263410568237,
-0.22702667117118835,
0.490690141916275,
0.1400275081396103,
-0.002406658139079809,
-0.1386859267950058,
-0.32272103428840637,
-0.22385598719120026,
0.16480432450771332,
-0.5803660750389099,
0.07585650682449341,
0.10284150391817093,
-0.13026678562164307,
-0.3227778375148773,
0.09552796930074692,
-0.7931451201438904,
-0.6379581093788147,
-0.7010526657104492,
0.05648701265454292,
-0.20756402611732483,
-0.38158315420150757,
0.33561277389526367,
0.09920959919691086,
0.439022958278656,
0.5211517214775085,
-1.0189553499221802,
0.22244562208652496,
0.8369842767715454,
0.7378186583518982,
-0.45995911955833435,
-0.09833695739507675,
-0.22363747656345367,
0.1681448221206665,
-0.5681347250938416,
0.583337664604187,
-0.6818623542785645,
-0.5155942440032959,
0.20415014028549194,
-0.07933370769023895,
-0.019909802824258804,
-0.62921541929245,
0.436226487159729,
-0.6060102581977844,
0.21667997539043427,
-0.25673454999923706,
-0.7641928791999817,
-0.3539358377456665,
0.2867280840873718,
-0.8397617340087891,
1.1592463254928589,
0.07018858194351196,
-0.545325756072998,
0.49223023653030396,
-0.73834228515625,
-0.5140846371650696,
0.12134840339422226,
-0.3117673993110657,
-0.27199652791023254,
0.36021938920021057,
0.2822008430957794,
0.6093189120292664,
-0.521821141242981,
0.3020114302635193,
-0.3382780849933624,
-0.043456826359033585,
0.4339645504951477,
-0.5865650773048401,
0.5947227478027344,
0.005653986241668463,
0.06974617391824722,
0.07771343737840652,
-1.0008753538131714,
-0.20869122445583344,
0.28551986813545227,
-0.44492846727371216,
-0.35698193311691284,
0.11039093881845474,
0.15000203251838684,
0.3113000988960266,
0.2709790766239166,
-0.38867637515068054,
0.5556902289390564,
-0.49869805574417114,
0.26776188611984253,
0.7097077965736389,
-0.05817541480064392,
0.47330528497695923,
-0.3980695903301239,
0.5116499066352844,
0.013043809682130814,
-0.0035728539805859327,
-0.37202635407447815,
-0.3411657512187958,
-0.5790705680847168,
-0.16587261855602264,
0.45704200863838196,
0.38204339146614075,
-0.8868820667266846,
0.5661637187004089,
-0.5940428972244263,
-0.41403329372406006,
-0.5858903527259827,
0.3252476751804352,
-0.23534885048866272,
0.4141806364059448,
0.3797202706336975,
-0.19883625209331512,
-0.6639277338981628,
-0.8048127889633179,
0.04018339514732361,
0.0587533675134182,
-0.16668879985809326,
0.31748929619789124,
0.3196025788784027,
-0.4292558431625366,
0.9530158638954163,
-0.5192509293556213,
-0.2239716500043869,
-0.46801963448524475,
-0.12903402745723724,
0.09288205206394196,
0.5322257876396179,
0.2601063847541809,
-0.9097022414207458,
-0.3123544156551361,
0.02759113721549511,
-0.7466914057731628,
-0.019571267068386078,
-0.2933357357978821,
0.53029465675354,
0.2637433111667633,
0.6253923177719116,
-0.4264928996562958,
0.10034757852554321,
0.5068178176879883,
0.11488446593284607,
0.47446322441101074,
-0.15995700657367706,
0.05744120478630066,
-1.1103273630142212,
-0.0380285307765007,
0.04249045252799988,
-0.09881040453910828,
-0.9843748211860657,
0.1350722312927246,
-0.02832735888659954,
0.05038386210799217,
-0.26751646399497986,
0.5328909158706665,
-0.6231914758682251,
-0.2612258195877075,
-0.41654172539711,
-0.012894341722130775,
-0.08877541124820709,
0.03235592320561409,
0.18654122948646545,
0.6507588028907776,
0.8099886775016785,
-0.6781256794929504,
0.6401225924491882,
0.27373406291007996,
-0.4042486548423767,
0.3081490993499756,
-0.4675535261631012,
0.36820000410079956,
-0.3147529661655426,
0.43886029720306396,
-0.7854073643684387,
-0.40944409370422363,
0.10746179521083832,
-0.18271400034427643,
0.47186800837516785,
-0.027014384046196938,
-0.8246041536331177,
-0.2893918752670288,
-0.36902981996536255,
0.5920098423957825,
0.3690210282802582,
-0.6840481162071228,
0.4305533468723297,
0.4056180715560913,
-0.2590630352497101,
-0.575956404209137,
-0.7411951422691345,
0.5652673840522766,
-0.4001609683036804,
-0.6424133777618408,
0.4568456709384918,
0.0016046133823692799,
-0.28275978565216064,
-0.308188259601593,
0.07604892551898956,
0.09368201345205307,
0.16785070300102234,
0.006761851720511913,
0.4378654956817627,
0.004686551634222269,
0.3664471507072449,
-0.06243322044610977,
0.03249469771981239,
0.12675780057907104,
-0.24139565229415894,
0.7317677736282349,
0.18461644649505615,
-0.5343354940414429,
-0.2191682755947113,
0.4050859212875366,
0.2921820878982544,
-0.18468789756298065,
0.849554181098938,
0.4482647776603699,
-0.4339151680469513,
-0.29853031039237976,
-0.5449597835540771,
-0.23854310810565948,
-0.4416971206665039,
0.4606637954711914,
-0.22372809052467346,
-1.0032461881637573,
0.4021691679954529,
-0.29699549078941345,
0.16159071028232574,
0.28583285212516785,
0.6071373820304871,
0.11276644468307495,
1.072524070739746,
0.7768672704696655,
-0.340311199426651,
0.6263805627822876,
-0.34321239590644836,
0.18008454144001007,
-0.9658652544021606,
-0.4063156545162201,
-0.34807083010673523,
-0.40027573704719543,
-0.632361888885498,
-0.6459188461303711,
0.3823529779911041,
-0.14877347648143768,
0.15204374492168427,
-0.04463018849492073,
-0.24069423973560333,
0.1264546811580658,
0.1908489316701889,
0.004832651931792498,
0.6092564463615417,
-0.013709906488656998,
0.4364393949508667,
-0.1130078136920929,
-0.6895735263824463,
-0.41111788153648376,
1.460929274559021,
0.5937352776527405,
0.9739179015159607,
0.0540788508951664,
0.4565325677394867,
0.18132638931274414,
-0.008020853623747826,
-1.0058351755142212,
0.5262571573257446,
0.03155069798231125,
-0.4136885404586792,
-0.32257574796676636,
-0.4793527126312256,
-1.0181028842926025,
0.17171692848205566,
-0.4930124580860138,
-0.5162404179573059,
0.23089593648910522,
-0.11763504892587662,
-0.06902419775724411,
0.28733521699905396,
-0.37027111649513245,
0.41859522461891174,
-0.34289267659187317,
-0.3557632863521576,
-0.18343432247638702,
-0.5642892122268677,
0.45641401410102844,
-0.44630134105682373,
0.25520801544189453,
0.1847446858882904,
-0.37664222717285156,
0.6389204263687134,
-0.19914880394935608,
0.8553653359413147,
-0.008076740428805351,
-0.6254510283470154,
0.04898015409708023,
-0.27866697311401367,
0.7114962339401245,
-0.06362220644950867,
0.03672970458865166,
0.25914669036865234,
-0.3032285273075104,
-0.22157932817935944,
-0.6270561218261719,
0.7119150161743164,
-0.48864778876304626,
-0.6714813709259033,
-0.3008137345314026,
-1.052288293838501,
-0.6183658242225647,
-0.08186855167150497,
-0.2681411802768707,
0.31704482436180115,
-0.042719438672065735,
0.439927339553833,
0.6886461973190308,
-0.2281881421804428,
0.4045034646987915,
0.36267438530921936,
-0.416297048330307,
-0.22300408780574799,
0.9043660163879395,
0.22297675907611847,
0.41230159997940063,
0.3420373201370239,
-0.07389891147613525,
-0.5993121266365051,
-0.9211933016777039,
-0.43529221415519714,
0.13587002456188202,
-0.5960041880607605,
0.10066813975572586,
-0.5636364221572876,
-0.16023360192775726,
-0.5298206210136414,
0.09344393759965897,
-0.3188617527484894,
-0.5346899628639221,
-0.3552357256412506,
-0.2287968546152115,
0.41776421666145325,
0.8240837454795837,
-0.07703541964292526,
0.369037002325058,
-0.6879914402961731,
0.24731360375881195,
0.2611478567123413,
0.3764367997646332,
-0.00997508317232132,
-0.4572919011116028,
-0.4413295090198517,
0.22848893702030182,
-0.049171335995197296,
-0.6765913963317871,
0.468695729970932,
0.052569691091775894,
0.5122907161712646,
0.2375836819410324,
-0.16285043954849243,
0.5704196691513062,
-0.4496638774871826,
0.7908768057823181,
0.07505371421575546,
-0.5659443736076355,
0.3002700209617615,
-0.3708154559135437,
0.12310871481895447,
0.2749587595462799,
0.4817989766597748,
-0.6986745595932007,
-0.03831654042005539,
-0.4030267596244812,
-1.029768466949463,
0.55746990442276,
-0.1005525141954422,
0.41324901580810547,
0.2609393000602722,
0.45067620277404785,
0.2676268219947815,
0.31359973549842834,
-0.684778094291687,
-0.280927449464798,
0.28066977858543396,
-0.05190896615386009,
-0.19217044115066528,
0.059286706149578094,
-0.04911072552204132,
-0.35355761647224426,
0.5411942005157471,
-0.23593787848949432,
-0.16079069674015045,
-0.15393967926502228,
-0.2678877115249634,
0.02767650969326496,
0.3130188584327698,
0.31185299158096313,
0.7086120247840881,
0.07577629387378693,
-0.1561468243598938,
0.1861979067325592,
-0.22101132571697235,
0.0916876271367073,
0.1574438512325287,
-0.20550702512264252,
-0.1657799929380417,
0.37797778844833374,
1.0224754810333252,
0.0801469087600708,
-0.7774327993392944,
0.25674471259117126,
0.25048503279685974,
-0.18034835159778595,
-0.13781344890594482,
0.10890103876590729,
-0.06284573674201965,
0.24772851169109344,
0.6532253623008728,
-0.30021217465400696,
0.11435718834400177,
-0.6084057688713074,
0.05371992290019989,
0.6696081757545471,
-0.06969769299030304,
-0.2866048812866211,
0.489735871553421,
-0.07617262750864029,
-0.021781684830784798,
0.44843584299087524,
0.25611889362335205,
-0.09202542155981064,
0.36361047625541687,
0.5776049494743347,
0.7370538711547852,
-0.23242616653442383,
0.022502105683088303,
0.037826135754585266,
0.24273213744163513,
-0.05162625387310982,
0.14372554421424866,
-0.027458354830741882,
-0.8144001364707947,
-0.7394682765007019,
-0.4519907832145691,
-0.5707813501358032,
0.44092196226119995,
-0.7336264252662659,
0.38610273599624634,
-0.3060242235660553,
0.03122180700302124,
0.027989475056529045,
-0.011866757646203041,
-0.6397879719734192,
0.20956149697303772,
0.479727566242218,
0.862432599067688,
-0.8185455799102783,
0.9336674809455872,
0.8670565485954285,
-0.21431668102741241,
-0.3773535490036011,
-0.04341816529631615,
-0.05767514929175377,
-0.7204082608222961,
0.5781010985374451,
-0.0011216608108952641,
0.09916237741708755,
0.06711985170841217,
-0.47103771567344666,
-0.7783787846565247,
0.8601341247558594,
0.36943888664245605,
-0.4865396022796631,
-0.22472161054611206,
0.7000092267990112,
0.6326242089271545,
-0.5144685506820679,
-0.04805148020386696,
0.742078423500061,
0.4816511869430542,
0.031948138028383255,
-0.746778666973114,
-0.12969885766506195,
0.0412810742855072,
0.22997932136058807,
0.12177916616201401,
-0.3477329611778259,
0.713982343673706,
-0.024001093581318855,
-0.19888095557689667,
-0.2996062934398651,
0.6231086850166321,
0.03996575251221657,
0.08500530570745468,
0.4989185929298401,
0.5757342576980591,
0.6007170081138611,
0.058324385434389114,
1.0450505018234253,
-0.06964549422264099,
0.15643352270126343,
1.013175368309021,
-0.40944844484329224,
0.641974925994873,
0.5383837223052979,
-0.4004805386066437,
0.3438730537891388,
0.7363569736480713,
-0.11478395015001297,
0.17458350956439972,
0.18675805628299713,
-0.36395007371902466,
-0.1275753676891327,
-0.2072068154811859,
-0.5340514779090881,
0.6708694696426392,
0.7348116636276245,
-0.15722918510437012,
-0.3299020230770111,
0.2485153079032898,
-0.2271963655948639,
0.10520635545253754,
-0.41805511713027954,
0.9659689664840698,
-0.044789258390665054,
-0.260357528924942,
0.49225109815597534,
0.12576784193515778,
0.7721102833747864,
-0.5807567238807678,
-0.16512753069400787,
-0.04741339758038521,
-0.10375650227069855,
-0.3007162809371948,
-0.7929995059967041,
0.34737351536750793,
-0.012437470257282257,
-0.25747764110565186,
-0.39052000641822815,
0.6626236438751221,
-0.5933539867401123,
-0.49834713339805603,
0.21003630757331848,
0.8044703602790833,
-0.013617370277643204,
-0.02841142565011978,
-0.5468464493751526,
0.3447652757167816,
-0.14496426284313202,
-0.23422127962112427,
0.6068848371505737,
0.2510029971599579,
-0.11502905189990997,
0.8320769667625427,
0.7680591344833374,
0.2985544502735138,
0.20987610518932343,
0.16389255225658417,
1.0851658582687378,
-0.5660207867622375,
-0.32927224040031433,
-0.8548513054847717,
0.37494441866874695,
-0.10063139349222183,
-0.02139151655137539,
0.8604698777198792,
0.7101806998252869,
0.984108030796051,
-0.032442785799503326,
0.9978245496749878,
0.005763530731201172,
0.7392285466194153,
-0.6106643080711365,
0.39755234122276306,
-0.5226439833641052,
0.5465628504753113,
-0.23997239768505096,
-1.0568538904190063,
-0.3384805917739868,
0.1702253818511963,
-0.5274479985237122,
0.13180530071258545,
0.29430121183395386,
0.6136884093284607,
0.11028959602117538,
0.046664852648973465,
0.28211885690689087,
0.07474901527166367,
0.45890164375305176,
0.3586368262767792,
0.9203768372535706,
-0.37230563163757324,
0.09472187608480453,
-0.22878777980804443,
-0.09544868767261505,
-0.08873558789491653,
-0.7945461869239807,
-0.7073174118995667,
-0.8374587893486023,
-0.23809705674648285,
0.11194456368684769,
-0.320880264043808,
1.1081821918487549,
0.5358595252037048,
-0.7143009901046753,
-0.32166001200675964,
-0.05087042227387428,
0.22826559841632843,
0.004351403098553419,
-0.23785711824893951,
0.2846733629703522,
-0.5294699668884277,
-1.230962872505188,
0.8775960803031921,
0.17492231726646423,
0.15621764957904816,
-0.5545922517776489,
0.08670037984848022,
-0.1893274486064911,
-0.1195082738995552,
0.7838582992553711,
0.32326018810272217,
-0.41502830386161804,
-0.1491473764181137,
-0.06982217729091644,
0.07587669044733047,
0.13909414410591125,
0.9066866636276245,
-0.8673168420791626,
0.5645660758018494,
0.2837311923503876,
1.2561403512954712,
0.48110008239746094,
-0.07133776694536209,
0.7884587645530701,
-0.8445025682449341,
0.11331872642040253,
0.29302874207496643,
0.14701272547245026,
0.6369035840034485,
-0.31858763098716736,
0.4549838602542877,
0.32379794120788574,
-0.3294050097465515,
-1.1989169120788574,
0.3054061532020569,
-0.859738290309906,
-0.2333567589521408,
1.193159580230713,
0.31561586260795593,
0.16922320425510406,
-0.18419186770915985,
0.0002306329843122512,
0.03270510211586952,
-0.02673618122935295,
0.6881350874900818,
0.720021665096283,
-0.21792493760585785,
-0.20798331499099731,
-0.8094900250434875,
0.4899393320083618,
0.2926044762134552,
-1.1709800958633423,
0.3166291117668152,
0.8995386958122253,
0.04378221929073334,
-0.07987350225448608,
0.18641643226146698,
-0.16251803934574127,
-0.15355941653251648,
-0.26060575246810913,
-0.05212035030126572,
-0.16805556416511536,
-0.38705548644065857,
-0.819159209728241,
0.10968846082687378,
0.09035531431436539,
-0.006212862208485603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02975v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02975v2
|
A General and Flexible Multi-concept Parsing Framework for Multilingual Semantic Matching
| 2024-03-05T13:55:16 | 2024-04-04T01:07:24 |
Dong Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sentence semantic matching is a research hotspot in natural language
processing, which is considerably significant in various key scenarios, such as
community question answering, searching, chatbot, and recommendation. Since
most of the advanced models directly model the semantic relevance among words
between two sentences while neglecting the \textit{keywords} and
\textit{intents} concepts of them, DC-Match is proposed to disentangle keywords
from intents and utilizes them to optimize the matching performance. Although
DC-Match is a simple yet effective method for semantic matching, it highly
depends on the external NER techniques to identify the keywords of sentences,
which limits the performance of semantic matching for minor languages since
satisfactory NER tools are usually hard to obtain. In this paper, we propose to
generally and flexibly resolve the text into multi concepts for multilingual
semantic matching to liberate the model from the reliance on NER models. To
this end, we devise a \underline{M}ulti-\underline{C}oncept \underline{P}arsed
\underline{S}emantic \underline{M}atching framework based on the pre-trained
language models, abbreviated as \textbf{MCP-SM}, to extract various concepts
and infuse them into the classification tokens. We conduct comprehensive
experiments on English datasets QQP and MRPC, and Chinese dataset Medical-SM.
Besides, we experiment on Arabic datasets MQ2Q and XNLI, the outstanding
performance further prove MCP-SM's applicability in low-resource languages.
|
[
-0.36085739731788635,
-0.6706959009170532,
0.6579505205154419,
-0.0067672207951545715,
-0.5588170886039734,
0.066724494099617,
-0.17849867045879364,
-0.2536504566669464,
0.15316377580165863,
0.44044819474220276,
-0.6880203485488892,
-0.5067874789237976,
-0.27310311794281006,
0.261581689119339,
-0.1511121243238449,
0.593121349811554,
-0.09292631596326828,
0.16273967921733856,
-0.2318061888217926,
-0.309188574552536,
-0.3363422453403473,
-0.45072638988494873,
-0.5532991290092468,
-0.1744042932987213,
0.43531182408332825,
0.6230891942977905,
0.580695390701294,
0.7121279239654541,
0.636421263217926,
0.36422449350357056,
-0.11037662625312805,
0.3801118731498718,
0.06906083226203918,
0.07933621108531952,
-0.32624903321266174,
-0.15515008568763733,
-0.42210307717323303,
-0.05273567512631416,
0.6237543821334839,
0.6883927583694458,
-0.20714138448238373,
-0.1533183604478836,
-0.02546064741909504,
0.5786043405532837,
-0.5878924131393433,
0.04240031540393829,
-0.9254013299942017,
-0.06502503901720047,
-0.2339542806148529,
-0.2612549662590027,
-0.21111737191677094,
0.09937994182109833,
-0.0395524837076664,
-0.6668049097061157,
0.39205071330070496,
0.059958942234516144,
0.8613102436065674,
0.2425217479467392,
-0.6390122771263123,
-0.4672825038433075,
-0.18422767519950867,
0.5265195369720459,
-0.5868431329727173,
0.39567098021507263,
0.10006790608167648,
0.479020357131958,
-0.1367681324481964,
-0.46948567032814026,
-1.0063223838806152,
-0.049576111137866974,
-0.2996121644973755,
0.018522081896662712,
0.17961853742599487,
0.18929708003997803,
-0.04825834557414055,
0.412822961807251,
-0.5680972337722778,
-0.017184965312480927,
0.10855904966592789,
-0.1024894267320633,
0.32335367798805237,
0.14293979108333588,
0.4504639208316803,
-0.3249412477016449,
-0.41570696234703064,
-0.23610423505306244,
-0.5869749784469604,
-0.10673701018095016,
0.17559267580509186,
0.7288356423377991,
-0.2773960530757904,
0.9309486150741577,
-0.5282955765724182,
0.7735432982444763,
-0.16255047917366028,
-0.2860707640647888,
0.25701388716697693,
-0.9050649404525757,
-0.18601550161838531,
0.14392362534999847,
0.7192804217338562,
0.4237365424633026,
0.2925831973552704,
-0.11409225314855576,
0.2637912929058075,
0.7150959968566895,
-0.09524080902338028,
-0.876570999622345,
-0.07374060899019241,
0.0028769930358976126,
-0.35396790504455566,
0.03883781284093857,
-0.029997175559401512,
-0.8661801815032959,
-0.05891144648194313,
-0.37017959356307983,
-0.04738524928689003,
-0.39965832233428955,
-0.4726424813270569,
0.4672861695289612,
-0.05359591171145439,
0.325242280960083,
0.07322094589471817,
-0.7936815023422241,
0.2983815371990204,
0.6895173192024231,
0.9421366453170776,
-0.05534740537405014,
-0.19523140788078308,
-0.4991680085659027,
0.09030082076787949,
-0.055138975381851196,
0.8022487163543701,
-0.7196708917617798,
-0.20711122453212738,
-0.13447080552577972,
0.09232641756534576,
-0.5186498761177063,
-0.35050874948501587,
0.7113848924636841,
-0.4138880968093872,
0.10579132288694382,
-0.3287774920463562,
-0.5824944376945496,
0.023951247334480286,
0.5064451098442078,
-0.47899580001831055,
0.406711608171463,
-0.1873076856136322,
-0.932823657989502,
0.5400012135505676,
-0.7850343585014343,
-0.35614854097366333,
-0.10810457915067673,
-0.31253090500831604,
-0.18345868587493896,
-0.008511574938893318,
0.29149487614631653,
0.5612422227859497,
-0.47411754727363586,
0.22990398108959198,
-0.5252562165260315,
-0.015982795506715775,
-0.01058198045939207,
-0.37546730041503906,
0.5249745845794678,
0.3178597092628479,
-0.036310046911239624,
0.32397547364234924,
-1.0041184425354004,
0.1999894082546234,
0.02644975297152996,
-0.15044914186000824,
-0.5215064287185669,
0.04749691113829613,
0.16303624212741852,
0.8820173144340515,
-0.0503363199532032,
-0.6919173002243042,
-0.07160136848688126,
-0.5647082328796387,
0.6438720226287842,
0.3601197302341461,
-0.256013959646225,
0.389364629983902,
-0.06086172163486481,
0.47936132550239563,
0.4094459116458893,
-0.26911264657974243,
-0.28918564319610596,
-0.41303548216819763,
-0.7124888300895691,
-0.5366772413253784,
0.2689897418022156,
0.5303781032562256,
-0.829903781414032,
0.518534779548645,
-0.4222318232059479,
-0.2963533401489258,
-0.9368387460708618,
0.011170994490385056,
0.3672071397304535,
0.6207888126373291,
0.5928221344947815,
-0.09005360305309296,
-0.24080173671245575,
-0.843515932559967,
-0.211419478058815,
0.0326680988073349,
0.08533696085214615,
0.2194129228591919,
0.40532350540161133,
-0.34913429617881775,
0.9986422061920166,
-0.5343138575553894,
-0.5494123697280884,
-0.30380794405937195,
-0.17483066022396088,
0.09161417186260223,
0.43105852603912354,
0.4703236520290375,
-1.1123478412628174,
-0.6173149943351746,
0.2524762749671936,
-0.47989463806152344,
0.0731334462761879,
0.14665724337100983,
-0.24555543065071106,
-0.025293393060564995,
0.6131294965744019,
-0.8386131525039673,
0.2756078839302063,
0.5388760566711426,
-0.6654749512672424,
0.282272607088089,
-0.22479484975337982,
0.30121010541915894,
-1.4546147584915161,
0.16695868968963623,
-0.07195516675710678,
-0.14366371929645538,
-0.35683339834213257,
0.3941199481487274,
0.12601031363010406,
-0.07262062281370163,
-0.5340332388877869,
0.6832327246665955,
-0.24032294750213623,
0.28415894508361816,
-0.28049924969673157,
0.5981332659721375,
0.1412823498249054,
0.2264978587627411,
0.3114306628704071,
0.5632933378219604,
0.5608789920806885,
-0.7584870457649231,
0.40351325273513794,
0.23584136366844177,
-0.06311840564012527,
0.8130118250846863,
-0.7278555631637573,
-0.19718478620052338,
-0.18098294734954834,
0.10995770245790482,
-1.004835605621338,
-0.07097647339105606,
0.34285810589790344,
-0.24238236248493195,
0.0805719643831253,
-0.019734755158424377,
-0.74534010887146,
-0.18265613913536072,
-0.15066123008728027,
0.5474360585212708,
-0.18908116221427917,
-0.4661867916584015,
0.6610138416290283,
0.24104546010494232,
0.07347577065229416,
-0.713878333568573,
-0.5320559740066528,
-0.02195955440402031,
-0.38301539421081543,
-0.7041852474212646,
0.6231095790863037,
-0.3106359839439392,
-0.1865350753068924,
0.06296152621507645,
-0.13629037141799927,
-0.222153902053833,
0.2335563600063324,
-0.13951948285102844,
0.168348491191864,
-0.3077726662158966,
0.030825013294816017,
0.13452516496181488,
-0.3436725437641144,
-0.3795467019081116,
-0.02936198003590107,
0.7058107852935791,
-0.19078391790390015,
-0.47875508666038513,
-0.21841895580291748,
0.5120566487312317,
0.5741869211196899,
-0.29526007175445557,
0.9062106013298035,
0.5979618430137634,
-0.3766707181930542,
0.215479776263237,
-0.3739915192127228,
0.03289695829153061,
-0.46304452419281006,
0.3731738328933716,
-0.9311999678611755,
-0.9906727075576782,
0.3943428695201874,
-0.07521750777959824,
-0.12931522727012634,
0.6261287927627563,
0.5201762914657593,
0.29365596175193787,
0.94073086977005,
0.8131032586097717,
-0.016971779987215996,
-0.036558061838150024,
0.13757987320423126,
0.4167715013027191,
-0.6878873109817505,
-0.09768827259540558,
-0.7391999959945679,
0.07580263912677765,
-0.8814219832420349,
-0.2927844226360321,
-0.12042231857776642,
0.2726166844367981,
0.09622333198785782,
0.5499807000160217,
-0.4998466968536377,
0.5225774049758911,
0.1557195633649826,
-0.3711150586605072,
0.4509066641330719,
-0.34004342555999756,
-0.7100039124488831,
-0.18147733807563782,
-0.5662155151367188,
-0.39842653274536133,
0.728283703327179,
0.08285888284444809,
0.5187005996704102,
0.3291747272014618,
0.4847944974899292,
-0.18827466666698456,
-0.1636747270822525,
-0.8349476456642151,
0.5975716710090637,
-0.3995414972305298,
-0.4143795967102051,
-0.08741430193185806,
-0.6669445633888245,
-0.9609955549240112,
0.7468444108963013,
-0.2444220781326294,
-0.5094465017318726,
0.0037573915906250477,
-0.03813736140727997,
-0.243940070271492,
0.09392647445201874,
-0.7725287079811096,
1.2569531202316284,
-0.0068838344886898994,
0.15763650834560394,
-0.3914731740951538,
-0.841592013835907,
0.38628825545310974,
-0.17494802176952362,
0.31921207904815674,
-0.5347269773483276,
0.07911504060029984,
0.29600760340690613,
-0.19424711167812347,
0.4049663543701172,
0.04177234321832657,
-0.025085851550102234,
-0.191806361079216,
-0.1899830847978592,
-0.15359921753406525,
0.32332316040992737,
0.10737946629524231,
-0.048289164900779724,
0.3211829662322998,
-0.2592993974685669,
-0.32248514890670776,
0.7740443348884583,
-0.43916064500808716,
-0.1408962458372116,
-0.4862394630908966,
-0.4379004240036011,
-0.05861305817961693,
0.5107865333557129,
0.16363687813282013,
0.18958482146263123,
-0.28363096714019775,
0.17537598311901093,
0.4145589768886566,
-0.09265147149562836,
0.4802407920360565,
0.6713781356811523,
-0.04520764201879501,
-0.3140728175640106,
0.5986800193786621,
-0.3244228661060333,
0.21936734020709991,
0.8289752006530762,
0.16466887295246124,
-0.5561478137969971,
-0.12747566401958466,
-0.4311709403991699,
0.34422004222869873,
-0.6800909042358398,
-0.31018614768981934,
-0.990617573261261,
-0.01357998140156269,
-0.5482324361801147,
-0.07023925334215164,
-0.22360654175281525,
-0.3809707462787628,
-0.22615933418273926,
0.06502911448478699,
0.07188113778829575,
0.10917507112026215,
0.08975192159414291,
0.4700743556022644,
-0.6690307259559631,
0.9558695554733276,
0.1674250215291977,
0.25793397426605225,
-0.4389665126800537,
-0.15426665544509888,
0.08505918830633163,
0.2243058979511261,
-0.24514704942703247,
-0.62331622838974,
0.1474170833826065,
0.6055672764778137,
0.5319697856903076,
0.41308507323265076,
0.11676092445850372,
0.8608421683311462,
-0.8264340758323669,
0.4940325915813446,
0.41511017084121704,
-1.1171795129776,
0.5861734747886658,
-0.01420552097260952,
0.3032916486263275,
0.788445770740509,
0.25618860125541687,
-0.8192083835601807,
-0.3113915026187897,
-0.5106803178787231,
-0.9493290781974792,
0.6716356873512268,
0.0043096356093883514,
0.05120455473661423,
-0.3998813331127167,
0.3370963931083679,
-0.21913254261016846,
0.40183329582214355,
-0.7232378721237183,
-0.30251559615135193,
-0.1832662969827652,
-0.5522417426109314,
-0.22196905314922333,
-0.05563311278820038,
0.10633455961942673,
-0.2902941405773163,
0.5720458030700684,
-0.49618834257125854,
0.18593527376651764,
-0.012097331695258617,
-0.29641491174697876,
0.19985546171665192,
0.6230118274688721,
0.5837379693984985,
0.44996917247772217,
-0.023229427635669708,
0.20049560070037842,
-0.06630691140890121,
-0.313478022813797,
0.34069910645484924,
0.4330802261829376,
0.03863460570573807,
0.012756342068314552,
0.1568118929862976,
0.3254532217979431,
0.18154403567314148,
-0.7912493944168091,
0.5910642147064209,
-0.3467606008052826,
0.07925118505954742,
-0.05118641257286072,
0.0736207365989685,
0.2764233350753784,
0.13786213099956512,
-0.055105432868003845,
0.22428220510482788,
0.17309078574180603,
-0.62892085313797,
0.514746904373169,
0.5927431583404541,
-0.2882276177406311,
-0.2143258899450302,
0.6846131086349487,
0.004210319370031357,
0.009347682818770409,
0.5258156657218933,
-0.5059128403663635,
-0.6014790534973145,
0.2947773337364197,
0.5480072498321533,
0.6093958020210266,
-0.25755101442337036,
0.30922746658325195,
0.2894326150417328,
0.04018723592162132,
-0.09990707784891129,
0.2838624119758606,
-0.12841399013996124,
-1.1678154468536377,
-0.6598897576332092,
-0.7755743861198425,
-0.17299245297908783,
-0.1979546993970871,
-0.5579853653907776,
0.4380654990673065,
-0.2785029113292694,
-0.03407258540391922,
0.2645292580127716,
0.1246953159570694,
-0.7913172245025635,
0.2537573575973511,
0.052977412939071655,
0.822212278842926,
-0.7620582580566406,
1.069419264793396,
0.807523787021637,
-0.4222365617752075,
-0.5136576294898987,
0.0024666571989655495,
0.05339103192090988,
-0.638885498046875,
0.3419322371482849,
0.4165285527706146,
-0.39084842801094055,
0.01640559360384941,
0.028398742899298668,
-0.6209449172019958,
0.8119283318519592,
0.508198618888855,
-0.451427698135376,
-0.29557475447654724,
0.1843140423297882,
0.3861103653907776,
-0.5943454504013062,
0.1501763015985489,
0.7110394835472107,
0.33071109652519226,
0.19724838435649872,
-0.976230800151825,
0.07393232733011246,
-0.2155342698097229,
-0.12929996848106384,
0.2049611657857895,
-0.5226925015449524,
0.9087333679199219,
-0.08561746776103973,
-0.29530325531959534,
0.25034499168395996,
0.5493974089622498,
0.4061029553413391,
0.1322721242904663,
0.5335946679115295,
0.7924049496650696,
0.5892060995101929,
-0.0835380107164383,
0.5189395546913147,
-0.3441446125507355,
0.5193530321121216,
1.016546368598938,
-0.5093091130256653,
0.938508927822113,
0.5121753811836243,
-0.010753356851637363,
0.4854675829410553,
0.44659680128097534,
0.24602003395557404,
0.9026358127593994,
0.2221362143754959,
-0.003461926942691207,
-0.2303805649280548,
-0.2663986384868622,
-0.36097487807273865,
0.6417033672332764,
0.5161970853805542,
0.00856372993439436,
-0.5350779294967651,
-0.04823264479637146,
0.08774532377719879,
0.308615118265152,
-0.04140596091747284,
0.8505119681358337,
0.16454362869262695,
-0.336690217256546,
0.28992295265197754,
0.36137598752975464,
0.9341369271278381,
-0.7480857372283936,
0.020454969257116318,
0.1741337925195694,
0.39438074827194214,
0.006144840735942125,
-0.3606961667537689,
0.4074810743331909,
-0.31254351139068604,
-0.2113456130027771,
0.06699728220701218,
0.6467655897140503,
-0.7167707681655884,
-0.4934116005897522,
0.6294004321098328,
0.6312099695205688,
-0.17094606161117554,
-0.16026365756988525,
-1.0299084186553955,
-0.22187958657741547,
-0.24308502674102783,
0.3361511826515198,
0.19030725955963135,
0.7402461171150208,
0.35873672366142273,
0.5653718709945679,
0.4674166440963745,
0.10997499525547028,
-0.10879281163215637,
0.1772053986787796,
0.6881963610649109,
-0.7127752304077148,
-0.8072262406349182,
-1.022375226020813,
0.381723552942276,
-0.09634651988744736,
-0.4029543101787567,
0.6935715675354004,
0.4645187258720398,
1.0353147983551025,
0.30515000224113464,
0.4327263832092285,
-0.1349584311246872,
0.569160521030426,
-0.6892406940460205,
0.46417099237442017,
-0.767549455165863,
0.09752723574638367,
-0.5731050968170166,
-1.0181536674499512,
-0.35845696926116943,
0.7872965931892395,
0.21469439566135406,
-0.05269915238022804,
1.011731743812561,
0.4938538670539856,
-0.4351308047771454,
-0.13674332201480865,
0.34133344888687134,
-0.2073642611503601,
0.3536272644996643,
0.4984094500541687,
0.5424627661705017,
-0.29347309470176697,
0.41218844056129456,
-0.17641519010066986,
0.004835777450352907,
-0.08641060441732407,
-0.8735062479972839,
-0.8671399354934692,
-0.7045395970344543,
-0.4695347249507904,
-0.09973302483558655,
-0.2752416133880615,
1.0458872318267822,
0.6941849589347839,
-0.8569847345352173,
0.022327132523059845,
-0.1429969072341919,
0.18619343638420105,
-0.3436748683452606,
-0.24262650310993195,
0.510429322719574,
-0.42157360911369324,
-0.4355974793434143,
0.5150862336158752,
0.1435472071170807,
0.07891302555799484,
0.11124516278505325,
0.0018589550163596869,
-0.5442551970481873,
0.00829323474317789,
0.6865618228912354,
-0.17656536400318146,
-0.8917976021766663,
-0.308512806892395,
0.06793136894702911,
-0.018551990389823914,
0.0014167724875733256,
0.969817578792572,
-0.5671417117118835,
0.3651186227798462,
0.16654406487941742,
0.8587773442268372,
0.18430441617965698,
-0.11517712473869324,
0.37402236461639404,
-0.9454609155654907,
0.34993529319763184,
0.04846781864762306,
0.6118237376213074,
0.4763135015964508,
-0.19342337548732758,
0.45063507556915283,
0.3823844790458679,
-0.20720697939395905,
-0.6753374934196472,
0.4736901819705963,
-1.0284698009490967,
-0.41407322883605957,
0.9496338963508606,
-0.1424931138753891,
0.11128593981266022,
-0.3783186674118042,
-0.128532275557518,
0.35880082845687866,
-0.12816525995731354,
0.4118146002292633,
0.7616947889328003,
0.20250444114208221,
-0.20648519694805145,
-0.35467955470085144,
0.5767384171485901,
0.3460095226764679,
-0.8223510980606079,
0.11182272434234619,
0.4381733536720276,
0.18053078651428223,
0.3942185342311859,
0.7731436491012573,
-0.06642317026853561,
0.1203746572136879,
-0.19985432922840118,
-0.16221874952316284,
0.32489630579948425,
-0.5290940999984741,
-0.2228613942861557,
0.17403492331504822,
-0.08677873015403748,
-0.3712225556373596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02966v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02966v2
|
Evidence-Focused Fact Summarization for Knowledge-Augmented Zero-Shot Question Answering
| 2024-03-05T13:43:58 | 2024-06-19T06:47:32 |
Sungho Ko, Hyunjin Cho, Hyungjoo Chae, Jinyoung Yeo, Dongha Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent studies have investigated utilizing Knowledge Graphs (KGs) to enhance
Quesetion Answering (QA) performance of Large Language Models (LLMs), yet
structured KG verbalization remains challengin. Existing methods, such as
triple-form or free-form textual conversion of triple-form facts, encounter
several issues. These include reduced evidence density due to duplicated
entities or relationships, and reduced evidence clarity due to an inability to
emphasize crucial evidence. To address these issues, we propose EFSum, an
Evidence-focused Fact Summarization framework for enhanced QA with
knowledge-augmented LLMs. We optimize an open-source LLM as a fact summarizer
through distillation and preference alignment. Our extensive experiments show
that EFSum improves LLM's zero-shot QA performance, and it is possible to
ensure both the helpfulness and faithfulness of the summary.
|
[
-0.17280840873718262,
-0.8928935527801514,
0.9067180156707764,
-0.2635868787765503,
-0.36743733286857605,
0.03303097188472748,
0.1080750972032547,
-0.21983075141906738,
0.4080854058265686,
0.3072417080402374,
-0.1760135143995285,
-0.6859810948371887,
-0.6283804178237915,
0.10708820074796677,
-0.2750781774520874,
1.2469953298568726,
-0.20059965550899506,
-0.04478049650788307,
-0.4843405783176422,
-0.33381253480911255,
-0.04235094040632248,
-0.4412594139575958,
-0.2511788308620453,
-0.23565933108329773,
0.5969529747962952,
0.786068856716156,
0.6395408511161804,
0.6107091903686523,
0.38844746351242065,
0.2036544531583786,
-0.1417485922574997,
0.37135642766952515,
-0.7985879778862,
0.14530205726623535,
0.043848056346178055,
-0.5008462071418762,
-0.7657197713851929,
-0.19444401562213898,
0.4969538450241089,
0.8063021898269653,
-0.22799620032310486,
0.32684043049812317,
-0.27841004729270935,
0.5932215452194214,
-0.7873224020004272,
0.24948811531066895,
-0.32568496465682983,
-0.1351613849401474,
0.09784291684627533,
-0.2960522472858429,
-0.29404014348983765,
-0.588237464427948,
0.1379464566707611,
-0.9906989336013794,
0.20791809260845184,
0.08504191786050797,
0.8775354623794556,
0.2941729426383972,
-0.5622571110725403,
-0.2650436460971832,
-0.5790038704872131,
0.4860866963863373,
-0.876743495464325,
0.3282342553138733,
0.17713509500026703,
0.10191981494426727,
-0.1365857571363449,
-0.5704390406608582,
-0.5240446329116821,
0.13535813987255096,
-0.28520268201828003,
0.16564518213272095,
-0.07850923389196396,
0.2988292872905731,
0.28102079033851624,
0.43611809611320496,
-0.6278303861618042,
-0.31225210428237915,
-0.1648920327425003,
-0.3526327311992645,
0.5045357346534729,
0.022514989599585533,
0.2538246214389801,
0.053740642964839935,
-0.035235993564128876,
-0.062237173318862915,
-0.7839276790618896,
-0.013955331407487392,
-0.11800673604011536,
0.14069212973117828,
0.06022994965314865,
0.8993184566497803,
-0.7748684883117676,
0.9217737913131714,
0.007384995464235544,
-0.4801744222640991,
0.2863077223300934,
-0.370945543050766,
-0.2520274519920349,
0.30319178104400635,
0.5071247816085815,
0.6584175825119019,
0.013950821943581104,
-0.314931184053421,
0.1364748328924179,
-0.20621977746486664,
-0.421021968126297,
-1.3616390228271484,
-0.10313435643911362,
0.48877212405204773,
-0.010247751139104366,
-0.13627314567565918,
-0.005402098409831524,
-0.636618971824646,
-0.2559830844402313,
-0.1389944851398468,
0.4369700253009796,
-0.46457624435424805,
-0.2710387408733368,
0.2779093384742737,
-0.3888799548149109,
0.25502175092697144,
0.4428059458732605,
-0.6672379374504089,
0.23602865636348724,
0.5930364727973938,
0.8209066987037659,
0.2808733582496643,
-0.0640806034207344,
-0.8433405160903931,
0.6639995574951172,
-0.17940513789653778,
0.9829729795455933,
-0.3675347864627838,
-0.16364960372447968,
-0.1402328759431839,
-0.131999209523201,
0.03550208732485771,
-0.27256080508232117,
0.5364821553230286,
-0.7479621767997742,
0.44822394847869873,
-0.5425151586532593,
-0.8099074959754944,
-0.44503092765808105,
0.5648823380470276,
-0.4270937442779541,
0.8180945515632629,
-0.06981604546308517,
-0.763722836971283,
0.39878609776496887,
-0.6907619833946228,
-0.6296759843826294,
-0.15839426219463348,
-0.1938442885875702,
-0.2822268009185791,
0.1530091017484665,
0.5743477940559387,
0.37940743565559387,
0.015305952169001102,
0.36845988035202026,
-0.3997907340526581,
-0.2763056755065918,
0.05779821425676346,
0.08472051471471786,
0.42827221751213074,
0.2238614857196808,
-0.04937028884887695,
0.08823461830615997,
-0.748787522315979,
-0.06726933270692825,
0.2925240099430084,
-0.27642202377319336,
-0.4484689235687256,
0.1489151120185852,
-0.6225665807723999,
0.08477268368005753,
0.2221023142337799,
-0.7958441376686096,
-0.0823386162519455,
-0.3285869061946869,
0.10421669483184814,
0.26505574584007263,
0.2222854197025299,
0.37477079033851624,
-0.6179737448692322,
0.37489956617355347,
0.16921941936016083,
-0.06267476081848145,
-0.18672308325767517,
-0.4507078528404236,
-0.7416053414344788,
-0.47645503282546997,
0.1295057088136673,
0.3827981948852539,
-0.923199474811554,
0.13449087738990784,
-0.5448777675628662,
-0.20729275047779083,
-0.3818345069885254,
-0.01270030066370964,
0.2378818541765213,
0.8706210851669312,
0.3636056184768677,
0.04838046059012413,
-0.3389297425746918,
-0.7312967777252197,
-0.23244617879390717,
-0.4215674102306366,
-0.022259507328271866,
0.14771100878715515,
0.28636419773101807,
0.38580942153930664,
1.1664247512817383,
-1.031531572341919,
-0.15567313134670258,
-0.10829533636569977,
0.11896870285272598,
0.2425437718629837,
-0.1679002195596695,
0.6999902129173279,
-0.4966050982475281,
-0.3052598237991333,
-0.1991182118654251,
-0.8517705202102661,
-0.16643114387989044,
0.3226311504840851,
-0.2711755633354187,
0.02742212638258934,
0.2234758585691452,
-0.5181857943534851,
0.19665490090847015,
0.25696688890457153,
-0.4855407476425171,
0.05743607506155968,
0.16333447396755219,
0.5130450129508972,
-1.047687292098999,
0.2088017612695694,
-0.2246372103691101,
-0.39209872484207153,
-0.9041627049446106,
0.0693507269024849,
0.015571624971926212,
-0.051562923938035965,
-0.41945070028305054,
0.2614573538303375,
-0.36757203936576843,
-0.06216215714812279,
-0.20499072968959808,
0.5611399412155151,
0.44462257623672485,
0.46517547965049744,
0.14358964562416077,
0.746354877948761,
0.07844635844230652,
-0.6442343592643738,
0.07158510386943817,
0.4478077292442322,
-0.09869305789470673,
0.4616273045539856,
-0.6377745270729065,
0.054863616824150085,
-0.4484456181526184,
0.1082175150513649,
-1.0033752918243408,
-0.4143480062484741,
0.09328461438417435,
-0.5081549286842346,
0.4436328113079071,
-0.004138728138059378,
-0.26405319571495056,
0.14493942260742188,
-0.6105970740318298,
0.41015809774398804,
0.32881927490234375,
-0.3989024758338928,
0.587020218372345,
0.443911075592041,
-0.32819414138793945,
-0.7044247984886169,
-0.5753283500671387,
-0.03295627608895302,
0.03293672949075699,
-0.688854992389679,
0.3381044864654541,
-0.17408280074596405,
-0.2944287359714508,
0.18202535808086395,
-0.07040788233280182,
0.07564994692802429,
0.29507648944854736,
-0.10915522277355194,
0.12206518650054932,
-0.33821022510528564,
0.1808614581823349,
0.1089244857430458,
0.2525433897972107,
-0.01453380100429058,
-0.006494942121207714,
0.2866659462451935,
-0.1259656399488449,
-0.3467230498790741,
-0.14526613056659698,
0.2961607575416565,
0.6364534497261047,
-0.09026496112346649,
0.78989177942276,
0.17482899129390717,
-0.3462096154689789,
0.10534682869911194,
-0.5619832873344421,
-0.10421125590801239,
-0.32675105333328247,
0.43708372116088867,
-0.25613871216773987,
-1.2963309288024902,
0.47592321038246155,
0.05179189145565033,
0.34115850925445557,
0.49678608775138855,
0.4041084051132202,
-0.033019114285707474,
0.8181098103523254,
0.39604514837265015,
0.010055889375507832,
0.23817189037799835,
0.05331381410360336,
0.4169052541255951,
-0.5998162627220154,
-0.1892208755016327,
-0.3428433835506439,
0.10389363020658493,
-0.016148729249835014,
-0.1746731996536255,
0.6163153052330017,
0.3118189871311188,
-0.11485537886619568,
-0.06599141657352448,
-0.34117284417152405,
0.5111359357833862,
0.11133866012096405,
0.1418534815311432,
0.717308521270752,
0.040835730731487274,
0.019123779609799385,
0.34454965591430664,
-0.9995420575141907,
-0.30843591690063477,
1.2168407440185547,
0.2351735234260559,
0.32412058115005493,
0.610287070274353,
0.7730757594108582,
0.07494522631168365,
0.5909061431884766,
-0.8395029306411743,
0.4488358795642853,
0.20248764753341675,
-0.7365301251411438,
-0.45984575152397156,
-0.6146529316902161,
-0.37028613686561584,
0.409376323223114,
-0.1934853196144104,
-0.15420657396316528,
0.0202315766364336,
0.06471791863441467,
-0.6991453170776367,
0.2236337959766388,
-0.8343387246131897,
0.47233113646507263,
-0.19547638297080994,
-0.26019686460494995,
-0.04797310382127762,
-0.3271748721599579,
0.6848321557044983,
0.06472184509038925,
0.4049156606197357,
-0.2824174165725708,
-0.03964141011238098,
0.8297515511512756,
-0.7114155888557434,
0.5034916996955872,
-0.37298282980918884,
-0.23551325500011444,
0.45204445719718933,
-0.10598082840442657,
0.41363903880119324,
0.056442536413669586,
-0.07923948019742966,
-0.15144550800323486,
0.2534030079841614,
-0.5568345785140991,
-0.7962440848350525,
0.51512610912323,
-0.7289335131645203,
-0.8187705874443054,
-0.4574368894100189,
-0.7081162333488464,
-0.34139975905418396,
0.16374284029006958,
-0.1921290159225464,
0.4973730742931366,
-0.5281515717506409,
0.06373601406812668,
0.7787467241287231,
0.06328161060810089,
0.2410195916891098,
0.9413568377494812,
-0.47882208228111267,
-0.6583659052848816,
0.8204343914985657,
0.29641613364219666,
0.3080306053161621,
0.6258025169372559,
0.17064213752746582,
-0.3945010304450989,
-0.8612695932388306,
-0.6559959650039673,
0.34373965859413147,
-0.6629296541213989,
-0.3488069772720337,
-0.87541264295578,
-0.03880896791815758,
-0.7597237825393677,
0.026507781818509102,
0.1539587378501892,
-0.9044950604438782,
-0.20080436766147614,
-0.5068580508232117,
0.7986648678779602,
0.6348636746406555,
0.016050681471824646,
0.225347101688385,
-0.7679157853126526,
0.556923508644104,
0.49251416325569153,
0.3896545469760895,
-0.201640784740448,
-0.5984075665473938,
-0.2663474977016449,
0.13263489305973053,
-0.047676533460617065,
-0.9087811708450317,
0.0412997268140316,
0.40919265151023865,
0.47947895526885986,
0.6106770038604736,
0.43440598249435425,
0.673355758190155,
-0.22253985702991486,
0.7434672713279724,
0.21860799193382263,
-0.6507186889648438,
0.4583060145378113,
-0.47314023971557617,
0.21529333293437958,
0.8328977823257446,
0.329437792301178,
-0.42976078391075134,
-0.2040715515613556,
-0.27853652834892273,
-0.6047332882881165,
0.718881368637085,
0.13382789492607117,
-0.3348614275455475,
-0.21239982545375824,
0.4671090245246887,
-0.01318942941725254,
0.3789273500442505,
-0.2958415746688843,
-0.24379555881023407,
-0.34032952785491943,
-0.4237554669380188,
-0.0552494116127491,
-0.5977153778076172,
-0.513340950012207,
-0.2719149887561798,
0.948764979839325,
-0.3892430365085602,
-0.020043976604938507,
0.6145724058151245,
-0.426421582698822,
-0.07042644917964935,
0.5028150081634521,
0.7776820659637451,
0.7661761045455933,
-0.575384259223938,
0.2551282048225403,
0.38734182715415955,
-0.38198041915893555,
0.3479902744293213,
0.22532030940055847,
-0.5809835195541382,
0.009778367355465889,
0.26856377720832825,
0.5131019353866577,
0.13525612652301788,
-0.552014172077179,
0.7285646200180054,
-0.08751051127910614,
-0.5063745975494385,
-0.07642905414104462,
-0.06975844502449036,
0.11631029844284058,
-0.012690907344222069,
0.3670426309108734,
-0.4554382562637329,
0.2879304885864258,
-0.5548345446586609,
0.09935257583856583,
0.2353384792804718,
-0.2635594308376312,
-0.24854475259780884,
0.42392081022262573,
0.3738669157028198,
0.3262357711791992,
0.334705650806427,
-0.26615771651268005,
-0.48539701104164124,
0.43845051527023315,
0.3594207465648651,
0.6117972731590271,
-0.05307331308722496,
0.42531540989875793,
0.40240365266799927,
0.20880445837974548,
0.018656093627214432,
0.47624683380126953,
-0.13532446324825287,
-0.8239982724189758,
-0.7403683066368103,
-0.5302692651748657,
-0.47145938873291016,
-0.234292134642601,
-0.6454952955245972,
-0.016590243205428123,
-0.4374498128890991,
-0.0030067290645092726,
-0.07850757241249084,
-0.008418377488851547,
-0.27325108647346497,
0.1104251816868782,
0.018184665590524673,
0.7317866086959839,
-0.8974471688270569,
0.4961000680923462,
0.7390328049659729,
-0.5494639277458191,
-0.6877734661102295,
-0.2561458349227905,
0.022191893309354782,
-0.5777368545532227,
0.24705202877521515,
-0.12116881459951401,
-0.35646575689315796,
0.05191182717680931,
-0.5234225988388062,
-1.0013898611068726,
1.568627119064331,
0.5748540759086609,
-0.29787009954452515,
0.0435827374458313,
0.2494581639766693,
0.3206690847873688,
-0.3395318388938904,
0.6183352470397949,
0.5667277574539185,
0.47221487760543823,
0.4416005611419678,
-0.5542412996292114,
0.2632736265659332,
-0.2746063470840454,
-0.5038450360298157,
0.29385653138160706,
-0.9059451222419739,
0.3727115988731384,
-0.4793698191642761,
-0.5157551765441895,
-0.22703459858894348,
0.876880407333374,
0.40695542097091675,
0.650740921497345,
0.34191885590553284,
0.868232786655426,
0.8995262980461121,
-0.04226695001125336,
0.8245444893836975,
-0.4991459548473358,
0.17903973162174225,
1.2599751949310303,
-0.6110897064208984,
0.611510157585144,
0.5226653814315796,
-0.1439681351184845,
0.5931658744812012,
0.4441901743412018,
0.35134750604629517,
0.46189627051353455,
-0.12945982813835144,
-0.24324443936347961,
-0.35451096296310425,
-0.6159854531288147,
-0.46310561895370483,
0.30356520414352417,
0.2933291494846344,
-0.14462533593177795,
-0.5377798080444336,
-0.5550267696380615,
0.4479011297225952,
0.022644272074103355,
-0.3424105644226074,
0.9274442195892334,
-0.08361534774303436,
-0.6831534504890442,
0.5178937911987305,
-0.184512197971344,
0.3437424898147583,
-0.6858288049697876,
-0.1597081422805786,
-0.2748228907585144,
-0.21967270970344543,
-0.5142790675163269,
-0.7350949645042419,
0.23559394478797913,
0.1016436293721199,
-0.37267258763313293,
0.025772614404559135,
0.5376733541488647,
-0.5295698046684265,
-0.3662059009075165,
0.10806316882371902,
0.7310078740119934,
0.15717756748199463,
-0.09588146209716797,
-0.12328380346298218,
-0.37472084164619446,
-0.07870149612426758,
-0.26247289776802063,
0.3515821695327759,
0.45461952686309814,
0.141295924782753,
0.370551735162735,
0.6737610697746277,
-0.11325440555810928,
-0.06424839049577713,
0.17398510873317719,
1.1661982536315918,
-0.5242943167686462,
-0.32049375772476196,
-0.6843391060829163,
0.26957154273986816,
-0.3551487624645233,
-0.021203499287366867,
0.8282641172409058,
0.8529666662216187,
0.6145908236503601,
0.25629764795303345,
0.7235016226768494,
-0.12175889313220978,
0.5963840484619141,
-0.5078952312469482,
0.8248206377029419,
-0.47785764932632446,
-0.025237170979380608,
-0.05288657546043396,
-0.6913379430770874,
-0.3735053837299347,
0.022691132500767708,
-0.30730941891670227,
-0.1531095951795578,
0.7250704765319824,
0.8342949748039246,
0.17047162353992462,
0.15416668355464935,
0.5154961943626404,
0.22857964038848877,
0.29252830147743225,
0.6686365008354187,
0.7198221683502197,
-0.4598124027252197,
0.7389127016067505,
-0.24146370589733124,
-0.3169595003128052,
-0.17795921862125397,
-0.9252150058746338,
-0.7804441452026367,
-0.24695762991905212,
-0.5445420145988464,
-0.2079138457775116,
0.054264940321445465,
0.8096901178359985,
0.5152190327644348,
-0.9615893959999084,
0.09259345382452011,
0.180691197514534,
0.29788103699684143,
0.052454084157943726,
-0.175882488489151,
0.5825047492980957,
-0.12503287196159363,
-0.22704264521598816,
0.4218311905860901,
0.24597470462322235,
-0.10932982712984085,
0.09999436885118484,
-0.0701887235045433,
-0.4105908274650574,
0.16198739409446716,
0.804839015007019,
0.2976817786693573,
-0.42820611596107483,
-0.4926031231880188,
0.26363763213157654,
0.14753878116607666,
0.06273679435253143,
0.7959781885147095,
-0.6060144901275635,
0.4842866063117981,
0.7982375025749207,
0.5704107880592346,
0.576633095741272,
0.2939680814743042,
0.5366601347923279,
-0.6476364135742188,
-0.15047594904899597,
-0.01935635879635811,
0.428806334733963,
0.3299732804298401,
-0.45271390676498413,
0.5325959324836731,
0.1946929395198822,
-0.47712525725364685,
-0.6115458607673645,
0.13176223635673523,
-0.854435920715332,
-0.2702898383140564,
1.1945606470108032,
-0.24715308845043182,
-0.45896026492118835,
-0.3695143461227417,
0.017809322103857994,
0.46647825837135315,
-0.507246732711792,
0.6449915766716003,
0.7131744027137756,
-0.28608986735343933,
-0.1593780517578125,
-0.24327364563941956,
0.45184966921806335,
0.4335639774799347,
-0.8369458913803101,
0.07415211200714111,
1.012949824333191,
0.5066667795181274,
0.19657066464424133,
0.7950626015663147,
-0.2634345591068268,
0.2778298854827881,
-0.32146239280700684,
0.28034043312072754,
-0.6596914529800415,
-0.14280976355075836,
-0.36548885703086853,
0.5590439438819885,
0.35691380500793457,
-0.04402007535099983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02959v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02959v1
|
SimuCourt: Building Judicial Decision-Making Agents with Real-world Judgement Documents
| 2024-03-05T13:30:02 | 2024-03-05T13:30:02 |
Zhitao He, Pengfei Cao, Chenhao Wang, Zhuoran Jin, Yubo Chen, Jiexin Xu, Huaijun Li, Xiaojian Jiang, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the development of deep learning, natural language processing technology
has effectively improved the efficiency of various aspects of the traditional
judicial industry. However, most current efforts focus solely on individual
judicial stage, overlooking cross-stage collaboration. As the autonomous agents
powered by large language models are becoming increasingly smart and able to
make complex decisions in real-world settings, offering new insights for
judicial intelligence. In this paper, (1) we introduce SimuCourt, a judicial
benchmark that encompasses 420 judgment documents from real-world, spanning the
three most common types of judicial cases, and a novel task Judicial
Decision-Making to evaluate the judicial analysis and decision-making power of
agents. To support this task, we construct a large-scale judicial knowledge
base, JudicialKB, with multiple legal knowledge. (2) we propose a novel
multi-agent framework, AgentsCourt. Our framework follows the real-world
classic court trial process, consisting of court debate simulation, legal
information retrieval and judgement refinement to simulate the decision-making
of judge. (3) we perform extensive experiments, the results demonstrate that,
our framework outperforms the existing advanced methods in various aspects,
especially in generating legal grounds, where our model achieves significant
improvements of 8.6% and 9.1% F1 score in the first and second instance
settings, respectively.
|
[
-0.4792049527168274,
-0.5845656991004944,
0.8889566659927368,
-0.11126698553562164,
-0.21869181096553802,
0.09272196143865585,
-0.25666454434394836,
-0.5000434517860413,
0.12199157476425171,
0.6332100033760071,
-0.5854666233062744,
-0.3392568528652191,
-0.3254697322845459,
-0.24364542961120605,
-0.2846370041370392,
0.715796947479248,
0.15801504254341125,
0.27047979831695557,
-0.24139182269573212,
-0.3265790045261383,
-0.2602058947086334,
-0.40085795521736145,
-0.41849416494369507,
-0.21468810737133026,
0.29995158314704895,
0.5189704895019531,
0.9700604677200317,
0.4675845801830292,
0.5845497250556946,
0.4457233250141144,
0.23371095955371857,
0.14212755858898163,
-0.09824052453041077,
0.3251515030860901,
-0.5014369487762451,
-0.653373658657074,
-0.43199679255485535,
0.33237192034721375,
0.18844105303287506,
0.356783926486969,
-0.3736676275730133,
0.023385899141430855,
-0.5585233569145203,
0.6922333836555481,
-0.8415707945823669,
0.16127464175224304,
-0.47788330912590027,
0.38913699984550476,
0.08746868371963501,
-0.048815105110406876,
-0.4322313964366913,
-0.5595104694366455,
0.16075198352336884,
-0.9486639499664307,
0.2657148540019989,
0.3048335313796997,
0.5957459211349487,
0.46387648582458496,
-0.5439727902412415,
-0.18846817314624786,
-0.8095914125442505,
0.49700647592544556,
-0.6236077547073364,
0.48956382274627686,
0.26138386130332947,
1.0154391527175903,
-0.1452811062335968,
-1.2844253778457642,
-0.6142593026161194,
-0.5677312612533569,
0.006563741248100996,
0.4641627073287964,
0.1416802555322647,
0.328838586807251,
0.38662707805633545,
-0.1898544579744339,
-0.286543071269989,
-0.3127784729003906,
-0.10243765264749527,
-0.15762829780578613,
0.7197979688644409,
0.052153486758470535,
0.12066864222288132,
-0.1504729837179184,
-0.18518708646297455,
-0.49465182423591614,
-0.16565468907356262,
0.124493308365345,
0.47033506631851196,
0.5517964959144592,
0.24283018708229065,
0.24538762867450714,
-0.4640999734401703,
0.44538265466690063,
0.007857076823711395,
-0.22357437014579773,
0.09968537837266922,
-0.28683775663375854,
-0.30992749333381653,
0.3424011766910553,
0.7771401405334473,
0.4363528788089752,
0.42117777466773987,
-0.002249028068035841,
-0.08934340626001358,
-0.2356867790222168,
0.5545357465744019,
-0.9205342531204224,
0.0620851069688797,
0.21220505237579346,
-0.577593207359314,
-0.30204200744628906,
0.4608802795410156,
-0.5328296422958374,
-0.7730237245559692,
-0.7241578698158264,
0.19068683683872223,
-0.44607558846473694,
-0.18797935545444489,
0.006932632531970739,
-0.17527852952480316,
0.0510731115937233,
0.7400988340377808,
-0.19847175478935242,
0.5126266479492188,
0.6635032296180725,
0.4499834179878235,
0.38617345690727234,
-0.2872273623943329,
-0.877833366394043,
0.010650914162397385,
-0.37438827753067017,
0.8382945656776428,
-0.5849596261978149,
-0.08682356029748917,
0.13943302631378174,
-0.08196087181568146,
0.02074243128299713,
-0.5838748216629028,
1.0374568700790405,
-0.5327621102333069,
-0.2229413092136383,
-0.4433322846889496,
-0.4875216484069824,
-0.22773776948451996,
0.41784870624542236,
-0.936269998550415,
0.5407680869102478,
-0.15993638336658478,
-0.4098528325557709,
1.075034499168396,
-0.5523003935813904,
-0.46235191822052,
0.2958933711051941,
-0.5486416220664978,
-0.40034881234169006,
0.018976522609591484,
0.09739270806312561,
0.26195430755615234,
-0.47940075397491455,
0.5274737477302551,
-0.44281160831451416,
-0.3344230651855469,
0.08770450949668884,
-0.32636064291000366,
0.6453022956848145,
0.28415587544441223,
-0.33078205585479736,
-0.0037468462251126766,
-0.6749926805496216,
0.08381394296884537,
-0.07987003028392792,
-0.12266643345355988,
-0.2827935516834259,
0.20599576830863953,
-0.05288822576403618,
0.576839029788971,
-0.22366200387477875,
-0.5610179305076599,
0.2917153835296631,
-0.10660752654075623,
0.03320017084479332,
0.6587935090065002,
0.0492822602391243,
0.29253649711608887,
-0.39661529660224915,
0.535010039806366,
-0.16968227922916412,
0.4550028443336487,
0.2785387635231018,
-0.34762272238731384,
-0.6204583644866943,
-0.09270516037940979,
0.6221249103546143,
0.46780839562416077,
-0.7888939380645752,
0.12585824728012085,
-0.43424487113952637,
-0.39747539162635803,
-0.6559407114982605,
-0.21753954887390137,
0.12731561064720154,
0.1286715865135193,
0.2715931534767151,
-0.10332665592432022,
-0.39423760771751404,
-1.0474274158477783,
-0.6944725513458252,
-0.32457244396209717,
0.3676426112651825,
0.4849841296672821,
0.6042029857635498,
-0.06159969046711922,
1.1379095315933228,
-0.09775935858488083,
-0.32766592502593994,
-0.11729878932237625,
0.19922396540641785,
0.14038866758346558,
0.1863519698381424,
0.5488050580024719,
-1.099502682685852,
-0.3586205840110779,
0.24113649129867554,
-0.8954969644546509,
0.1031407043337822,
-0.4990476071834564,
-0.29927027225494385,
-0.2898019552230835,
0.6503169536590576,
-0.7009950280189514,
0.5114572644233704,
-0.30459409952163696,
-0.48192504048347473,
0.6135308742523193,
-0.2981005012989044,
0.42147424817085266,
-0.7066499590873718,
-0.16429337859153748,
-0.2743823528289795,
-0.5187345147132874,
-0.5736829042434692,
0.2597462832927704,
0.2801518440246582,
0.34796246886253357,
-0.6354409456253052,
0.5354681015014648,
-0.2809287905693054,
-0.2909349799156189,
-0.08960267156362534,
0.36366143822669983,
-0.11330829560756683,
0.3899746537208557,
-0.18412214517593384,
0.41953471302986145,
0.1072070375084877,
-0.4598236680030823,
0.6772847175598145,
0.10622908920049667,
-0.3396263122558594,
0.8024294376373291,
-0.10788675397634506,
-0.22613398730754852,
-0.017813855782151222,
0.4132744073867798,
-0.29230159521102905,
-0.3476678729057312,
0.1555003821849823,
-0.1577633172273636,
0.048387765884399414,
-0.3003689646720886,
-0.7484003901481628,
-0.4043617248535156,
-0.27677619457244873,
0.3638175129890442,
0.11845466494560242,
-0.39348304271698,
1.329508900642395,
0.22416895627975464,
-0.112967349588871,
-0.6788942813873291,
-0.7005861401557922,
0.25020843744277954,
0.25283291935920715,
-0.5110720992088318,
0.278608113527298,
-0.08708043396472931,
-0.687889039516449,
0.25216394662857056,
-0.07080391049385071,
0.03198011964559555,
-0.016582025215029716,
0.508770763874054,
-0.2666453421115875,
-0.06202135607600212,
0.3518123924732208,
0.37903493642807007,
0.07535960525274277,
0.2363940179347992,
-0.16190184652805328,
0.18504023551940918,
-0.018394121900200844,
-0.921482264995575,
-0.3643133342266083,
0.11739937961101532,
0.7255563139915466,
-0.2901135981082916,
0.3670678436756134,
0.1006387248635292,
-0.17829881608486176,
-0.7818806767463684,
-0.6404018998146057,
-0.0068454742431640625,
-0.42360004782676697,
0.10906311124563217,
-0.6407427787780762,
-0.5076414942741394,
0.45866072177886963,
-0.4988915026187897,
0.2785670757293701,
0.2440561205148697,
0.7055109143257141,
0.3614855706691742,
0.645199716091156,
0.2854592204093933,
0.08721933513879776,
0.5189282894134521,
-0.16902491450309753,
0.2628443241119385,
-0.2281380146741867,
-0.19803278148174286,
-0.2306089550256729,
-0.19521886110305786,
-0.6007497310638428,
-0.3988787531852722,
0.18218693137168884,
-0.342395544052124,
-0.2957947552204132,
0.05904063209891319,
-0.22196556627750397,
0.5425413846969604,
0.9779679775238037,
0.09474875032901764,
0.5053225159645081,
-0.3272908627986908,
-0.7498372793197632,
0.3753729462623596,
-0.604745090007782,
-0.34491896629333496,
1.1236203908920288,
-0.12731288373470306,
0.3681846857070923,
0.06876348704099655,
0.7959284782409668,
0.729842483997345,
0.20138777792453766,
-0.745175838470459,
0.703432559967041,
0.04807829111814499,
-0.6155811548233032,
-0.05703721567988396,
-0.3452482521533966,
-0.5426806807518005,
0.8054499626159668,
-0.39711326360702515,
-0.15011873841285706,
0.39877721667289734,
-0.42491158843040466,
-0.797881543636322,
0.2349836677312851,
-0.5306137204170227,
0.6625545024871826,
-0.31946203112602234,
-0.7346367239952087,
-0.26246899366378784,
-0.7660802006721497,
0.38613393902778625,
-0.01784987933933735,
0.4204707145690918,
-0.24430179595947266,
0.013102843426167965,
0.46044838428497314,
-0.819586992263794,
0.4222854971885681,
-0.3871290385723114,
0.13669157028198242,
0.53565913438797,
0.18411695957183838,
0.6222217082977295,
0.26516658067703247,
-0.30394917726516724,
-0.49666768312454224,
-0.06753621995449066,
-0.03421403840184212,
-0.8251382112503052,
0.4771614968776703,
-0.621477484703064,
-0.40988248586654663,
-0.7441588640213013,
-0.5890175104141235,
-0.18398833274841309,
0.19525553286075592,
-0.16610422730445862,
0.2788972556591034,
-0.5180118680000305,
0.0651726946234703,
0.12098640948534012,
-0.014673380181193352,
0.3847329020500183,
0.8308972120285034,
-0.05260329693555832,
-0.28973299264907837,
0.7824059128761292,
0.3329848051071167,
-0.08609959483146667,
0.09098038822412491,
-0.046832822263240814,
-0.09940788149833679,
-0.28122028708457947,
-0.37582287192344666,
-0.010178910568356514,
-0.8569010496139526,
-0.29147449135780334,
-0.5640957951545715,
-0.15353865921497345,
-0.40239009261131287,
-0.11651147902011871,
-0.4499327540397644,
-0.5139511227607727,
0.49724382162094116,
-0.3454664647579193,
0.11444909870624542,
0.6417543888092041,
-0.1219475045800209,
-0.003977315034717321,
-0.5183712840080261,
0.5901962518692017,
0.7748584747314453,
0.4322148561477661,
-0.15142996609210968,
-0.17341254651546478,
-0.15493060648441315,
-0.044234104454517365,
-0.13708527386188507,
-0.43190014362335205,
0.25084027647972107,
0.006626223213970661,
0.8451348543167114,
0.3931581676006317,
0.5231102705001831,
0.5933238863945007,
-0.6204646825790405,
0.44327685236930847,
-0.20306716859340668,
-0.6151102185249329,
0.5212692618370056,
-0.17511452734470367,
0.04108291119337082,
1.0266480445861816,
-0.12465253472328186,
-0.365167498588562,
-0.5525132417678833,
-0.7619572281837463,
-0.6907859444618225,
1.2321093082427979,
0.5147088766098022,
-0.12450803816318512,
0.39572596549987793,
0.3822060227394104,
-0.014745448715984821,
0.2847507894039154,
-0.4130917191505432,
-0.00010063078661914915,
-0.15792740881443024,
-0.14331811666488647,
0.4514065086841583,
0.17484623193740845,
-0.2357802838087082,
-0.35054895281791687,
0.7028186321258545,
-0.2958270311355591,
0.02284875512123108,
0.2304673194885254,
-0.32402655482292175,
-0.03365813195705414,
0.14042897522449493,
0.33684059977531433,
0.5516151785850525,
-0.347935289144516,
0.08890821039676666,
0.06546011567115784,
-0.38914525508880615,
0.217942476272583,
0.5236372947692871,
-0.10660538822412491,
-0.20652484893798828,
0.6709918975830078,
0.6967873573303223,
-0.06453470885753632,
-0.9222084879875183,
0.6812897324562073,
-0.6897717714309692,
-0.5463340878486633,
-0.5107784271240234,
0.21375252306461334,
-0.0760556310415268,
0.8226422667503357,
0.4187323749065399,
0.27299371361732483,
0.5549086928367615,
-0.6874048113822937,
0.5387639999389648,
0.27686765789985657,
-0.3306275010108948,
0.345747709274292,
0.5230686664581299,
0.2785664498806,
-0.10131237655878067,
0.3037131428718567,
-0.536373496055603,
-0.41764289140701294,
0.9426631927490234,
-0.09509817510843277,
0.9080855846405029,
0.038370728492736816,
0.2787334620952606,
0.13415876030921936,
0.28344303369522095,
-0.4110863506793976,
0.054387062788009644,
-0.41834649443626404,
-0.5662291049957275,
-0.23191121220588684,
-0.6213254332542419,
-0.7463676929473877,
-0.3898199200630188,
-0.47967782616615295,
0.16419434547424316,
-0.6501064896583557,
-0.37466001510620117,
0.005865597166121006,
0.3861289918422699,
-0.7144359946250916,
0.32904502749443054,
0.045612700283527374,
0.7211384177207947,
-0.6202560663223267,
0.7904930114746094,
0.600822925567627,
-0.5543665885925293,
-0.631992518901825,
0.1553889364004135,
0.2229379266500473,
-0.3821897506713867,
0.689374566078186,
0.18444736301898956,
-0.35027989745140076,
-0.44593197107315063,
-0.5647792816162109,
-0.47615447640419006,
1.2403560876846313,
0.5252800583839417,
-0.6756196618080139,
0.0695863887667656,
0.17930543422698975,
0.5803146362304688,
-0.4154486358165741,
0.5417937636375427,
0.7714303135871887,
0.7252103686332703,
0.08281178027391434,
-0.659193754196167,
0.2056742012500763,
-0.5488336086273193,
-0.15772472321987152,
0.1324131339788437,
-0.7545216083526611,
0.9395473003387451,
-0.10732127726078033,
-0.13231930136680603,
-0.0923997238278389,
0.5668337941169739,
0.34730178117752075,
0.35356661677360535,
0.5292330980300903,
0.7283706665039062,
0.7570213079452515,
-0.0917799100279808,
1.2788914442062378,
-0.4347217381000519,
0.2417771816253662,
1.2738348245620728,
-0.5270527005195618,
0.4147156774997711,
0.19288994371891022,
-0.04268024116754532,
0.554477334022522,
0.2957630455493927,
-0.08318054676055908,
0.31709620356559753,
0.0918419137597084,
-0.2719009518623352,
-0.8133986592292786,
-0.3282249867916107,
-0.07286763191223145,
0.392707884311676,
0.013500231318175793,
-0.3786700963973999,
-0.22801098227500916,
0.05554063245654106,
-0.10221987217664719,
0.23170211911201477,
-0.10544633865356445,
0.8049430251121521,
-0.007078840862959623,
-0.6562185883522034,
-0.10247236490249634,
-0.007077718619257212,
0.026624124497175217,
-0.4843960106372833,
-0.33095118403434753,
-0.16260024905204773,
0.4835948348045349,
-0.11631200462579727,
-0.6637862324714661,
-0.36116981506347656,
-0.10821588337421417,
-0.09537643194198608,
-0.19802218675613403,
0.5820470452308655,
-0.05234413966536522,
-0.750464916229248,
0.7651455998420715,
0.6824880242347717,
-0.11394216865301132,
-0.24403703212738037,
-0.9816444516181946,
-0.1787114143371582,
-0.3782539367675781,
-0.5568426847457886,
0.2554113268852234,
1.0209035873413086,
-0.39058026671409607,
0.68925541639328,
0.6738958358764648,
0.1694752424955368,
-0.04193418100476265,
0.7348405718803406,
1.0255160331726074,
-0.774810254573822,
-0.5769630074501038,
-0.5902224183082581,
0.2375251203775406,
-0.6671255826950073,
-0.003733270335942507,
0.413509339094162,
0.5867273211479187,
0.6799147725105286,
0.2868611514568329,
1.0446960926055908,
-0.21222476661205292,
0.4718393385410309,
-0.4725233018398285,
0.6596209406852722,
-0.5939399600028992,
0.04309336841106415,
-0.2486037164926529,
-0.7694389224052429,
-0.324253648519516,
0.5312070250511169,
-0.24224917590618134,
0.3341561257839203,
0.6384693384170532,
0.6807466149330139,
-0.2596822679042816,
0.09909781068563461,
0.4355219900608063,
0.09643488377332687,
0.40785714983940125,
0.43430837988853455,
0.8086366653442383,
-0.4992394745349884,
0.6714703440666199,
-0.3259808123111725,
-0.02323516644537449,
-0.5357009768486023,
-0.5554991960525513,
-0.8450575470924377,
-0.09907618910074234,
0.16062378883361816,
0.09715663641691208,
0.2034655511379242,
1.277204990386963,
0.7460699081420898,
-0.783684492111206,
-0.24263469874858856,
-0.21363483369350433,
0.08211296796798706,
-0.34748920798301697,
-0.15094749629497528,
0.2686625123023987,
-0.5205066204071045,
-0.4759000241756439,
0.36723482608795166,
0.10599011927843094,
-0.37124505639076233,
0.23180286586284637,
-0.33938276767730713,
-0.6448861956596375,
0.35828033089637756,
0.5612027645111084,
-0.03880828619003296,
-0.755528450012207,
-0.09668713063001633,
-0.4902137219905853,
-0.19199338555335999,
-0.08744733035564423,
1.021734356880188,
-1.0195270776748657,
0.7743204236030579,
0.4077644646167755,
0.5797871947288513,
0.6161752939224243,
0.33163461089134216,
0.5487025380134583,
-0.4324570894241333,
0.31742575764656067,
0.36850497126579285,
0.6209394335746765,
-0.05480460077524185,
-0.060637060552835464,
0.7433220148086548,
0.27390244603157043,
-0.4355577826499939,
-0.39560970664024353,
0.011936397291719913,
-0.8293192386627197,
-0.726006269454956,
0.7958235144615173,
0.034087516367435455,
-0.22892291843891144,
-0.20440898835659027,
-0.450773149728775,
0.35065239667892456,
-0.7656232118606567,
0.4820724427700043,
0.6313852071762085,
-0.14886519312858582,
0.016490204259753227,
-0.9500750303268433,
0.6403374671936035,
0.20656783878803253,
-0.8963784575462341,
0.09938276559114456,
0.7937771677970886,
-0.11750254780054092,
0.3439217805862427,
0.5476112365722656,
0.12724421918392181,
0.5926074981689453,
0.2819634974002838,
0.22575442492961884,
-0.3024485409259796,
-0.5514460802078247,
0.02814502827823162,
0.4953732490539551,
-0.11667114496231079,
0.29052305221557617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02951v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02951v2
|
Benchmarking the Text-to-SQL Capability of Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Evaluation
| 2024-03-05T13:23:48 | 2024-03-06T08:43:17 |
Bin Zhang, Yuxiao Ye, Guoqing Du, Xiaoru Hu, Zhishuai Li, Sun Yang, Chi Harold Liu, Rui Zhao, Ziyue Li, Hangyu Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as a powerful tool in advancing the
Text-to-SQL task, significantly outperforming traditional methods.
Nevertheless, as a nascent research field, there is still no consensus on the
optimal prompt templates and design frameworks. Additionally, existing
benchmarks inadequately explore the performance of LLMs across the various
sub-tasks of the Text-to-SQL process, which hinders the assessment of LLMs'
cognitive capabilities and the optimization of LLM-based solutions. To address
the aforementioned issues, we firstly construct a new dataset designed to
mitigate the risk of overfitting in LLMs. Then we formulate five evaluation
tasks to comprehensively assess the performance of diverse methods across
various LLMs throughout the Text-to-SQL process.Our study highlights the
performance disparities among LLMs and proposes optimal in-context learning
solutions tailored to each task. These findings offer valuable insights for
enhancing the development of LLM-based Text-to-SQL systems.
|
[
-0.2848452031612396,
-0.8440161943435669,
0.7934798002243042,
0.25225570797920227,
-0.40441980957984924,
0.1433294415473938,
-0.5669117569923401,
-0.31939733028411865,
-0.24641062319278717,
0.4571814239025116,
-0.6054134964942932,
-0.6590188145637512,
-0.4839107096195221,
0.45717909932136536,
-0.4500126540660858,
0.7355962991714478,
0.05964157357811928,
0.02535749413073063,
-0.726390540599823,
-0.10454390197992325,
-0.7040307521820068,
-0.5524646043777466,
-0.4615980088710785,
-0.32927876710891724,
0.21657536923885345,
0.3322863280773163,
0.21322481334209442,
0.43391382694244385,
0.37596365809440613,
0.20518139004707336,
-0.20232440531253815,
0.1931605339050293,
-0.6942840218544006,
0.29326876997947693,
-0.3393220007419586,
-0.4040025770664215,
-0.35118988156318665,
-0.32232168316841125,
0.8621805310249329,
0.7913804054260254,
-0.10550261288881302,
0.24776999652385712,
0.18398232758045197,
0.7950060963630676,
-0.6529742479324341,
-0.008107719011604786,
-0.7607789635658264,
-0.01748342253267765,
-0.3667437732219696,
-0.11739101260900497,
-0.6748458743095398,
-0.4444372355937958,
0.15767736732959747,
-0.24249707162380219,
-0.17084462940692902,
0.15895843505859375,
0.2438073307275772,
0.23787488043308258,
-0.6288429498672485,
-0.3389168679714203,
-0.5933486819267273,
0.9801067113876343,
-0.6017655730247498,
0.4447420835494995,
-0.05143118277192116,
0.3432227373123169,
-0.3001202344894409,
-0.5797047019004822,
-0.2105366736650467,
-0.3838304281234741,
0.05891143158078194,
-0.03481246158480644,
0.005595080554485321,
-0.20485055446624756,
0.2848465144634247,
0.3336447477340698,
-0.7209653258323669,
0.3499477207660675,
0.14419949054718018,
-0.018939228728413582,
0.6294788718223572,
0.5187348127365112,
0.006573725491762161,
-0.017184175550937653,
-0.3858143091201782,
0.075224369764328,
-0.7351398468017578,
-0.11769554018974304,
-0.06687349081039429,
0.5235707759857178,
0.07150859385728836,
0.6159509420394897,
-0.25992515683174133,
0.7155126929283142,
-0.196206197142601,
-0.1518137902021408,
0.2697114050388336,
-0.45158517360687256,
-0.2797492444515228,
-0.17106761038303375,
0.8504745960235596,
0.30383622646331787,
0.23389285802841187,
-0.520369827747345,
-0.4951469302177429,
-0.15461909770965576,
0.22359950840473175,
-0.841765284538269,
0.3359151780605316,
0.18492154777050018,
-0.3324297070503235,
-0.10634013265371323,
-0.3967275321483612,
-0.8244921565055847,
-0.5760184526443481,
-0.3322681784629822,
0.35347986221313477,
-0.26722002029418945,
-0.08272890001535416,
-0.1526954621076584,
0.029917053878307343,
0.11481212079524994,
0.2973472774028778,
-0.6894489526748657,
0.5739730000495911,
0.7190859913825989,
0.7562960982322693,
-0.7525730729103088,
-0.03853287175297737,
-0.2582058906555176,
0.06981241703033447,
-0.530616819858551,
0.8241556286811829,
-0.46104851365089417,
-0.6378649473190308,
0.25050532817840576,
-0.14912129938602448,
0.02279004268348217,
-0.8063397407531738,
0.6429315805435181,
-0.4331821799278259,
0.06870433688163757,
-0.6378076076507568,
-0.8992173075675964,
0.20910926163196564,
0.36086156964302063,
-0.5163757801055908,
1.152195692062378,
0.14004775881767273,
-0.4462276101112366,
0.43261411786079407,
-0.405622661113739,
-0.49869269132614136,
0.12603624165058136,
-0.39541977643966675,
-0.34185123443603516,
0.4119116961956024,
0.22856250405311584,
0.5244590640068054,
-0.9529493451118469,
0.2973138093948364,
-0.18928027153015137,
-0.52776038646698,
0.31367066502571106,
-0.30979567766189575,
0.5914941430091858,
0.14265108108520508,
-0.25126126408576965,
0.146408349275589,
-0.7914673686027527,
0.1568065881729126,
0.22279682755470276,
-0.5016880631446838,
-0.1751539260149002,
0.17695826292037964,
0.16198928654193878,
0.055751360952854156,
0.31456804275512695,
-0.33576279878616333,
0.10305339097976685,
-0.29918593168258667,
0.4201872646808624,
0.5592020153999329,
-0.19804616272449493,
0.3336119055747986,
-0.2592681348323822,
0.3958176076412201,
-0.10293326526880264,
0.008323955349624157,
-0.23083025217056274,
0.014666950330138206,
-0.6160982847213745,
-0.33590570092201233,
0.1421288251876831,
0.5037354230880737,
-0.5910308957099915,
0.525928795337677,
-0.2870931029319763,
-0.5523239374160767,
-0.01630113460123539,
0.22714155912399292,
0.407851904630661,
0.389081209897995,
0.4280693531036377,
-0.37192633748054504,
-0.3316847085952759,
-0.8300107717514038,
-0.48548266291618347,
0.09171270579099655,
-0.18550017476081848,
0.3510555326938629,
0.4711492955684662,
-0.02935073897242546,
0.9432975053787231,
-0.28777197003364563,
-0.366354763507843,
-0.32846689224243164,
-0.1642066389322281,
0.2514190375804901,
0.15114758908748627,
0.5490858554840088,
-0.34535300731658936,
-0.42829543352127075,
-0.0894085243344307,
-0.7353289127349854,
-0.14920218288898468,
-0.0642644464969635,
0.19809240102767944,
0.45194685459136963,
0.7506998181343079,
-0.38089892268180847,
-0.07013194262981415,
0.3646700084209442,
-0.17714248597621918,
0.674193799495697,
-0.07374989986419678,
0.027304094284772873,
-0.9734795689582825,
0.31011420488357544,
0.11375012993812561,
-0.16169872879981995,
-0.4364053010940552,
-0.11345651745796204,
0.3171793818473816,
-0.03546831011772156,
-0.2609490156173706,
0.5913532376289368,
-0.6192783117294312,
-0.3304062485694885,
-0.07896383106708527,
0.2825002372264862,
-0.14092811942100525,
0.25731492042541504,
-0.04286110773682594,
0.9116401076316833,
0.4527917802333832,
-0.5039219856262207,
0.2871277928352356,
0.20472636818885803,
-0.7250334024429321,
0.7727100253105164,
-0.7400686144828796,
0.018008718267083168,
-0.09322181344032288,
0.32696640491485596,
-1.060973048210144,
0.03813404217362404,
-0.2198876440525055,
-0.1952148973941803,
0.32732462882995605,
0.068938709795475,
-0.6711048483848572,
-0.1361730992794037,
-0.3610225319862366,
0.4498618245124817,
0.49886447191238403,
-0.470741331577301,
0.6409478783607483,
0.26721614599227905,
-0.15454280376434326,
-0.5115143656730652,
-0.6178239583969116,
0.3452722430229187,
-0.2957684397697449,
-0.3066498637199402,
0.4949336349964142,
0.10598137974739075,
-0.23727251589298248,
-0.3910362720489502,
-0.16042238473892212,
-0.010521277785301208,
0.09994107484817505,
0.02216198854148388,
0.18376511335372925,
-0.14911989867687225,
0.4552866518497467,
-0.008957027457654476,
-0.05173274129629135,
0.32946324348449707,
-0.19239281117916107,
0.46308815479278564,
0.046422913670539856,
-0.44253912568092346,
-0.0750165730714798,
0.2948058247566223,
0.40073227882385254,
-0.3280225098133087,
0.7298762202262878,
0.14990629255771637,
-0.286783367395401,
-0.5169063806533813,
-0.7483693361282349,
-0.12450110912322998,
-0.441925048828125,
0.6522794365882874,
-0.2898748219013214,
-0.8563985824584961,
0.3442666232585907,
-0.505113959312439,
0.27733904123306274,
0.4196946620941162,
0.5744608044624329,
0.08896937966346741,
0.6735498309135437,
0.6522166132926941,
-0.018232183530926704,
0.5060463547706604,
0.07283448427915573,
0.1227940246462822,
-0.744707465171814,
-0.46523141860961914,
-0.8412373661994934,
0.04549199342727661,
-0.3696942627429962,
-0.4932519793510437,
0.4078630208969116,
-0.021119577810168266,
-0.34453707933425903,
0.19341088831424713,
-0.2985782027244568,
0.49357765913009644,
0.017790185287594795,
-0.000001774222823769378,
0.4681452214717865,
0.09327071160078049,
-0.31519848108291626,
-0.20978188514709473,
-0.6547774076461792,
-0.6730673909187317,
1.1961129903793335,
0.3114931583404541,
0.715629518032074,
0.0942571833729744,
0.4658326506614685,
0.13718941807746887,
0.32021892070770264,
-0.6323614716529846,
0.7082774043083191,
-0.3834387958049774,
-0.5713037848472595,
-0.3893554210662842,
-0.47846347093582153,
-0.6738886833190918,
0.16179941594600677,
-0.32445400953292847,
-0.8324901461601257,
-0.16459669172763824,
-0.11370990425348282,
-0.033801283687353134,
0.04880031570792198,
-0.549281895160675,
0.9057060480117798,
-0.3111858367919922,
-0.5522816181182861,
-0.21006086468696594,
-0.38171395659446716,
0.22502487897872925,
-0.34281888604164124,
0.20098455250263214,
-0.08778353035449982,
-0.4589793384075165,
0.6454147100448608,
-0.0957479178905487,
0.7135033011436462,
0.06712047010660172,
-0.20769411325454712,
0.13173998892307281,
-0.0935114324092865,
0.4083356261253357,
-0.016650892794132233,
-0.4838147461414337,
0.08505386859178543,
-0.023149022832512856,
-0.29499000310897827,
-0.4185808300971985,
0.7806366086006165,
-0.42915114760398865,
-0.39523041248321533,
-0.30675435066223145,
-0.3546961843967438,
-0.5872229337692261,
0.1992644965648651,
0.1103094294667244,
0.5193095803260803,
-0.6172952651977539,
0.3777863681316376,
0.7894496321678162,
-0.43679994344711304,
0.5966859459877014,
0.5103840827941895,
-0.1746777445077896,
-0.3326009213924408,
0.6585091948509216,
0.10608489066362381,
0.31072235107421875,
0.5739029049873352,
-0.024703210219740868,
-0.7461354732513428,
-0.8919157385826111,
-0.46909329295158386,
0.126799076795578,
-0.8508418202400208,
-0.0016671366756781936,
-0.4470869302749634,
0.044753506779670715,
-0.1903156042098999,
0.007224487606436014,
-0.37087568640708923,
-0.06777043640613556,
-0.29826775193214417,
0.26416075229644775,
0.20104052126407623,
0.6735725998878479,
0.6135236024856567,
0.19188228249549866,
-0.6542837023735046,
-0.08474518358707428,
0.14473120868206024,
0.5811870694160461,
0.15985684096813202,
-0.5050787329673767,
-0.1547849029302597,
-0.3818572461605072,
-0.2726987600326538,
-0.6869366765022278,
-0.007660632021725178,
0.205485537648201,
0.7735602855682373,
0.0633736103773117,
0.17925943434238434,
0.5317967534065247,
-0.6158442497253418,
0.8268834352493286,
0.08585983514785767,
-1.090423345565796,
0.3923805356025696,
-0.27288830280303955,
0.4318411648273468,
0.6663556694984436,
0.38629359006881714,
-0.37031710147857666,
-0.07083728164434433,
-0.07562542706727982,
-1.005287766456604,
0.4482272267341614,
0.12405967712402344,
0.11756699532270432,
-0.11517243087291718,
0.38322779536247253,
0.12966059148311615,
0.3646731674671173,
-0.668239176273346,
-0.11635709553956985,
0.35709652304649353,
-0.12699130177497864,
-0.47706738114356995,
-0.3172999322414398,
0.05249187350273132,
-0.01745278760790825,
0.3860272169113159,
-0.31421852111816406,
0.13871292769908905,
-0.011996646411716938,
-0.2624894380569458,
0.08118664473295212,
0.35046660900115967,
0.49574804306030273,
1.0166728496551514,
-0.03153765946626663,
-0.13632456958293915,
0.736102819442749,
-0.18851184844970703,
-0.060096994042396545,
-0.06680572032928467,
0.06442651152610779,
-0.05415046960115433,
0.587689995765686,
0.5775690078735352,
0.1787211000919342,
-1.0231125354766846,
0.3918589651584625,
-0.18065226078033447,
-0.07288920879364014,
-0.1595371663570404,
0.059375982731580734,
0.3589283227920532,
0.20921804010868073,
0.4833005964756012,
-0.389079213142395,
0.07209497690200806,
-0.6413864493370056,
-0.007930798456072807,
0.7040848731994629,
-0.33893096446990967,
0.08742738515138626,
0.37854626774787903,
0.31957778334617615,
-0.38945481181144714,
0.4463336169719696,
0.2235565334558487,
-0.29557058215141296,
0.5512277483940125,
0.43939781188964844,
0.8144785761833191,
-0.10869656503200531,
-0.21253745257854462,
0.3704351782798767,
0.281342089176178,
-0.12126068025827408,
0.24676895141601562,
-0.050575029104948044,
-0.2796090841293335,
-0.4657256007194519,
-0.5822340250015259,
-0.39055466651916504,
0.0900072380900383,
-0.48644331097602844,
0.43537190556526184,
-0.29095572233200073,
-0.24680697917938232,
-0.009015521965920925,
0.2177799642086029,
-0.48703283071517944,
0.24787868559360504,
-0.1275109350681305,
1.1684908866882324,
-0.7039979100227356,
0.736287534236908,
0.6200564503669739,
-0.051475752145051956,
-0.26898738741874695,
-0.04238370805978775,
-0.09132308512926102,
-0.5652430057525635,
0.3179767429828644,
0.149953693151474,
0.09332847595214844,
-0.16864725947380066,
-0.19063173234462738,
-0.5657685399055481,
1.0135788917541504,
0.591350793838501,
-0.9702968001365662,
0.11508182436227798,
0.470832496881485,
0.7044888734817505,
-0.4673409163951874,
0.4706987142562866,
0.7747012972831726,
0.3315936326980591,
-0.032048746943473816,
-0.9596932530403137,
0.19183215498924255,
0.04831179976463318,
0.34036576747894287,
0.29935383796691895,
-0.5147466063499451,
0.6434494256973267,
-0.0653834342956543,
-0.13146162033081055,
0.12938882410526276,
0.3926110565662384,
0.3054211437702179,
0.2191319763660431,
0.4695828855037689,
0.2998983860015869,
0.5897233486175537,
-0.11704675853252411,
0.9937396049499512,
-0.19250713288784027,
0.2642555236816406,
1.1392625570297241,
-0.5780206322669983,
1.089632511138916,
0.6640797853469849,
-0.3375387191772461,
0.07264211028814316,
0.5879327058792114,
-0.03157709166407585,
0.37712207436561584,
0.6238112449645996,
-0.26241952180862427,
-0.29388970136642456,
-0.195787712931633,
-0.2977289855480194,
0.12943679094314575,
0.3980768620967865,
-0.37140730023384094,
-0.3916610777378082,
-0.26211288571357727,
-0.33022671937942505,
0.4396442174911499,
-0.11456051468849182,
0.9702457189559937,
0.14034131169319153,
-0.6707059741020203,
0.5855367183685303,
-0.04572691768407822,
0.6982061862945557,
-0.5550124049186707,
0.18455708026885986,
-0.23046579957008362,
0.2821316421031952,
-0.10354593396186829,
-0.7700248956680298,
0.252462774515152,
0.14388830959796906,
-0.10438286513090134,
-0.18507973849773407,
0.5237393379211426,
-0.3234543800354004,
-0.3730957806110382,
0.4257413446903229,
0.6023911237716675,
0.05062437430024147,
-0.023334739729762077,
-0.5910602807998657,
0.40400785207748413,
-0.24714280664920807,
-0.29295921325683594,
0.5941345691680908,
0.4916835427284241,
-0.14570175111293793,
0.7053608298301697,
0.35338616371154785,
-0.04566597193479538,
-0.2725372910499573,
0.21068914234638214,
0.8160310983657837,
-0.6421644687652588,
-0.24475149810314178,
-1.1955578327178955,
0.36193645000457764,
-0.19951578974723816,
-0.4421914517879486,
0.7647233009338379,
0.8051588535308838,
0.7368472218513489,
0.021280111744999886,
0.6723061203956604,
0.10890074819326401,
0.5270388722419739,
-0.5166566371917725,
0.5805904269218445,
-0.7355828881263733,
0.5690152049064636,
-0.4618004262447357,
-1.183450698852539,
-0.17897485196590424,
0.22311638295650482,
-0.2021780014038086,
0.32198888063430786,
0.8438777327537537,
0.7336172461509705,
0.2665407359600067,
-0.0400976687669754,
0.414489209651947,
0.04789569228887558,
0.33390259742736816,
0.6813013553619385,
0.8585414290428162,
-0.3553195595741272,
0.45234283804893494,
0.06761044263839722,
-0.1501355767250061,
-0.2631007730960846,
-1.318055510520935,
-1.2457118034362793,
-0.526077389717102,
-0.18839754164218903,
-0.14149394631385803,
0.34588831663131714,
0.9741204977035522,
0.5725480318069458,
-0.742038905620575,
-0.6066008806228638,
-0.06486237049102783,
0.0676119327545166,
-0.099190354347229,
-0.08757544308900833,
0.2964496314525604,
-0.5217131972312927,
-0.5759619474411011,
0.44517701864242554,
0.2953753173351288,
-0.011174019426107407,
-0.2759588956832886,
0.017733776941895485,
0.031211508437991142,
0.07716178148984909,
0.8375717401504517,
-0.1327035129070282,
-0.5778028964996338,
0.13701318204402924,
0.02012733556330204,
-0.32082709670066833,
-0.12027166783809662,
0.7638155817985535,
-0.6999724507331848,
0.1484581083059311,
0.49377936124801636,
0.9144411683082581,
0.3918861746788025,
-0.18810544908046722,
0.7135206460952759,
-0.7135077118873596,
-0.1543855369091034,
0.3286752700805664,
0.17831547558307648,
0.3284022808074951,
-0.11787343770265579,
0.41984355449676514,
-0.08123656362295151,
-0.5590362548828125,
-1.0654703378677368,
-0.07273553311824799,
-0.886841893196106,
-0.5119215250015259,
1.1207034587860107,
-0.08333428204059601,
-0.02739136293530464,
-0.1394851952791214,
-0.12293901294469833,
0.017650669440627098,
-0.3317776322364807,
0.668387234210968,
0.6791542768478394,
0.11510208994150162,
0.0023205068428069353,
-0.6319594979286194,
0.5744550228118896,
0.5970330834388733,
-1.043988823890686,
0.4044770896434784,
0.4518001079559326,
0.3965703248977661,
-0.26461490988731384,
0.48647934198379517,
-0.1459108293056488,
0.07439560443162918,
-0.2110840231180191,
-0.19082948565483093,
0.035153716802597046,
-0.31990647315979004,
-0.5880159735679626,
0.21867483854293823,
0.3611390292644501,
0.2341015338897705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02939v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02939v2
|
PaperWeaver: Enriching Topical Paper Alerts by Contextualizing Recommended Papers with User-collected Papers
| 2024-03-05T13:10:06 | 2024-05-09T07:59:01 |
Yoonjoo Lee, Hyeonsu B. Kang, Matt Latzke, Juho Kim, Jonathan Bragg, Joseph Chee Chang, Pao Siangliulue
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
With the rapid growth of scholarly archives, researchers subscribe to "paper
alert" systems that periodically provide them with recommendations of recently
published papers that are similar to previously collected papers. However,
researchers sometimes struggle to make sense of nuanced connections between
recommended papers and their own research context, as existing systems only
present paper titles and abstracts. To help researchers spot these connections,
we present PaperWeaver, an enriched paper alerts system that provides
contextualized text descriptions of recommended papers based on user-collected
papers. PaperWeaver employs a computational method based on Large Language
Models (LLMs) to infer users' research interests from their collected papers,
extract context-specific aspects of papers, and compare recommended and
collected papers on these aspects. Our user study (N=15) showed that
participants using PaperWeaver were able to better understand the relevance of
recommended papers and triage them more confidently when compared to a baseline
that presented the related work sections from recommended papers.
|
[
-0.32477566599845886,
-0.1519441157579422,
0.7828091979026794,
0.24576857686042786,
-0.31863608956336975,
0.08244851976633072,
-0.1396714746952057,
-0.6955939531326294,
0.39947906136512756,
0.2621760666370392,
-0.2691200375556946,
-0.4058474004268646,
-0.47977399826049805,
0.09607990086078644,
-0.7443318963050842,
1.1891889572143555,
0.1698378473520279,
-0.32182976603507996,
-0.47263845801353455,
0.1423136591911316,
-0.344383180141449,
0.012963195331394672,
-0.2955509424209595,
-0.5893673300743103,
0.7582186460494995,
0.5009412169456482,
0.34661999344825745,
0.14851033687591553,
1.0220141410827637,
0.20239542424678802,
-0.15961723029613495,
-0.01085171289741993,
-0.3468436598777771,
0.4256470501422882,
-0.5631611347198486,
-0.0876600369811058,
-0.4804256856441498,
-0.096712626516819,
0.0003932459803763777,
0.4541761875152588,
-0.044133592396974564,
0.4703487157821655,
0.25240588188171387,
0.5555148720741272,
-1.0311747789382935,
-0.2714604437351227,
-0.5193842053413391,
-0.06997103989124298,
-0.4431593120098114,
-0.7324056625366211,
-0.3636249601840973,
-0.3916127383708954,
0.3290875256061554,
-0.5443795919418335,
0.2631337344646454,
-0.23770862817764282,
0.575259804725647,
-0.24526967108249664,
-0.39336612820625305,
-0.350475937128067,
-0.9318717122077942,
0.4952443540096283,
-0.1974370926618576,
0.09299007058143616,
0.43304234743118286,
0.5568343997001648,
-0.0746319517493248,
-1.0649818181991577,
-0.07583113759756088,
0.2749885618686676,
-0.1470770686864853,
0.5131911635398865,
-0.276437908411026,
-0.3256738781929016,
0.15038755536079407,
0.24954146146774292,
-0.6232713460922241,
-0.4008657932281494,
-0.4171466529369354,
-0.05858452618122101,
0.4905889332294464,
0.034746717661619186,
0.1764463633298874,
-0.21696840226650238,
-0.33380258083343506,
-0.07005629688501358,
-0.44546061754226685,
0.06556832045316696,
-0.06756936758756638,
0.10863800346851349,
0.0786285400390625,
0.22616420686244965,
-0.18428482115268707,
0.7732304930686951,
0.18090195953845978,
-0.5943636298179626,
0.2016127109527588,
0.08367475867271423,
-0.08349519968032837,
-0.045424625277519226,
0.4383796453475952,
0.5300564169883728,
0.08968918025493622,
-0.2809229791164398,
-0.3338393270969391,
-0.298088014125824,
0.20967063307762146,
-0.6886954307556152,
-0.27769678831100464,
0.2909855544567108,
-0.6495413184165955,
-0.17037390172481537,
0.15925022959709167,
-0.9002044796943665,
-0.7245379090309143,
-0.4035717248916626,
0.19022789597511292,
-0.19748516380786896,
-0.3992175757884979,
-0.05820353701710701,
-0.4775104522705078,
-0.3768653869628906,
0.6362748742103577,
-0.572288453578949,
0.04388349875807762,
0.6502923965454102,
0.6759487986564636,
-0.13892243802547455,
-0.14223915338516235,
-0.3757021427154541,
0.6198064684867859,
0.07943196594715118,
1.1820846796035767,
-0.7376976609230042,
-0.8245574235916138,
0.2202068567276001,
-0.33590587973594666,
0.3022455871105194,
-0.26096320152282715,
0.7236549854278564,
-0.8237076997756958,
0.38396134972572327,
-0.4381696283817291,
-0.2820829451084137,
-0.1041710153222084,
0.24427618086338043,
-0.28583571314811707,
0.9859768748283386,
0.238374263048172,
-1.085842490196228,
0.4775761663913727,
-0.5066486597061157,
-0.5338100790977478,
0.4173375070095062,
-0.10893852263689041,
0.10418444871902466,
0.2760261595249176,
0.07156974822282791,
0.41808727383613586,
-0.5700013637542725,
0.5277584195137024,
-0.15964211523532867,
-0.2194955199956894,
-0.023390596732497215,
0.18031014502048492,
0.7562926411628723,
0.5330815315246582,
-0.06294281780719757,
0.1564044952392578,
-0.3600396513938904,
-0.11900219321250916,
-0.0505710132420063,
-0.08914077281951904,
-0.6716218590736389,
-0.2010776847600937,
0.40962013602256775,
-0.042999010533094406,
0.4559708535671234,
-0.12838293612003326,
0.005075725261121988,
0.18720725178718567,
0.13013124465942383,
0.4588491916656494,
0.15278063714504242,
0.26585763692855835,
-0.7047041654586792,
0.6290686726570129,
-0.32683897018432617,
-0.11510500311851501,
-0.27601104974746704,
-0.29123759269714355,
-0.4718163311481476,
-0.2547416090965271,
0.31068745255470276,
0.7694148421287537,
-0.3480396270751953,
0.5130908489227295,
-0.3432391285896301,
-0.6026577353477478,
0.2094457745552063,
0.11321131139993668,
0.13841065764427185,
0.6707131266593933,
0.3968864381313324,
0.007439290173351765,
-0.6929498314857483,
-0.8375914096832275,
-0.5612594485282898,
0.09557349234819412,
-0.39054909348487854,
0.3632950782775879,
0.2497788369655609,
-0.5403522849082947,
1.320691704750061,
-0.765865683555603,
-0.2611062526702881,
-0.11754405498504639,
0.49205759167671204,
0.17627055943012238,
0.11538298428058624,
0.7040045261383057,
-0.7890805602073669,
-0.788759171962738,
-0.09483833611011505,
-0.5950015783309937,
-0.5794212222099304,
-0.1768740713596344,
-0.12171084433794022,
-0.5954464077949524,
0.6197131872177124,
-0.18077392876148224,
0.46374019980430603,
0.21011163294315338,
-0.1744779348373413,
0.25357094407081604,
-0.11130734533071518,
-0.036523375660181046,
-1.12444269657135,
0.3918483257293701,
0.17980267107486725,
-0.2741364538669586,
-0.28364118933677673,
-0.17020297050476074,
0.08595595508813858,
-0.21001273393630981,
0.011097701266407967,
0.767037570476532,
-0.6137065291404724,
-0.19353093206882477,
-0.6115570664405823,
0.5415874123573303,
0.23467300832271576,
-0.029773183166980743,
-0.041004180908203125,
1.0107343196868896,
0.26460739970207214,
-0.5775547623634338,
-0.3360690474510193,
0.16528725624084473,
-0.14429348707199097,
0.6381255388259888,
-0.5492755770683289,
0.14178432524204254,
-0.001411850331351161,
0.13898442685604095,
-0.6261722445487976,
-0.38530322909355164,
-0.32346490025520325,
-0.283357173204422,
0.3582259714603424,
-0.1443200409412384,
-0.2121240496635437,
-0.31080344319343567,
-0.42269954085350037,
0.21307645738124847,
0.38758981227874756,
-0.4186043441295624,
0.8155339360237122,
0.7027457356452942,
-0.2912081778049469,
-0.34744784235954285,
-0.5149738192558289,
0.2827789783477783,
-0.26833972334861755,
-0.32546472549438477,
0.8474730849266052,
0.12465841323137283,
-0.5276948809623718,
0.09329096227884293,
-0.10047466307878494,
-0.02908763289451599,
0.2782154977321625,
0.4195869565010071,
-0.03359396010637283,
0.23961468040943146,
0.2578125596046448,
-0.043561432510614395,
-0.1264398992061615,
0.022393666207790375,
-0.16266877949237823,
0.3222365379333496,
-0.16297116875648499,
-0.11205446720123291,
0.06427208334207535,
0.41765984892845154,
0.4271824359893799,
-0.16223543882369995,
0.2687903046607971,
0.7802285552024841,
-0.4120008945465088,
0.1366024613380432,
-0.5706785917282104,
-0.1827818602323532,
-0.5054890513420105,
-0.25007155537605286,
-0.4570213556289673,
-0.9455539584159851,
0.4668700695037842,
-0.40089309215545654,
0.10855629295110703,
0.5281529426574707,
0.28273746371269226,
-0.3567945063114166,
0.723052442073822,
0.7371061444282532,
-0.15263988077640533,
0.9026704430580139,
0.0025442058686167,
0.10665693879127502,
-1.0621908903121948,
-0.06794696301221848,
-0.8666415810585022,
-0.17987558245658875,
-0.4475228786468506,
-0.059400979429483414,
0.4307251572608948,
0.23154233396053314,
-0.21338286995887756,
0.3015417158603668,
-0.8195890784263611,
0.539158821105957,
0.6495118737220764,
-0.07051420956850052,
0.10782058537006378,
0.24594220519065857,
-0.05609119310975075,
-0.03345687314867973,
-0.3654024004936218,
-0.7563360929489136,
0.9154008626937866,
-0.05855388566851616,
0.6936616897583008,
0.06747262924909592,
0.822998046875,
0.5852479934692383,
0.8572295904159546,
-0.47837451100349426,
0.4209020435810089,
-0.06791849434375763,
-0.6538717746734619,
0.20663946866989136,
-0.09193557500839233,
-0.9334455728530884,
0.041196372359991074,
-0.37234556674957275,
-1.1718435287475586,
0.45818421244621277,
0.058764245361089706,
-0.2527712285518646,
-0.038795195519924164,
-0.260187029838562,
0.28165632486343384,
-0.2814059257507324,
-0.741832435131073,
-0.219726100564003,
-0.2793661057949066,
0.3722080886363983,
-0.11252894997596741,
0.3576289713382721,
-0.10386244207620621,
-0.000955296098254621,
0.9045728445053101,
-0.08330633491277695,
0.6372759938240051,
-0.17269346117973328,
0.09017670899629593,
0.39699554443359375,
0.28054919838905334,
0.5450311303138733,
0.32905539870262146,
-0.23153631389141083,
-0.15363286435604095,
-0.1305171698331833,
-0.25663042068481445,
-0.24810466170310974,
0.737589418888092,
-0.5793318152427673,
-0.9836176037788391,
-0.6354381442070007,
-0.4790601134300232,
-0.27761393785476685,
0.6695712208747864,
0.40863674879074097,
0.49275311827659607,
-0.13833633065223694,
0.39427974820137024,
0.5553371906280518,
0.12353279441595078,
0.37940627336502075,
0.47241219878196716,
-0.5028597712516785,
-0.6877449154853821,
0.5165508389472961,
-0.14619454741477966,
-0.5056581497192383,
0.5348621606826782,
0.389979749917984,
-0.002142293844372034,
-0.7171879410743713,
0.034613773226737976,
-0.013128083199262619,
-0.873020589351654,
-0.5589761137962341,
-0.9891424179077148,
0.1943587213754654,
-0.37677884101867676,
-0.5839165449142456,
0.27338218688964844,
-0.4045816957950592,
-0.4482920467853546,
0.062133971601724625,
0.5822927355766296,
0.5538594722747803,
-0.15208736062049866,
0.5071375370025635,
-1.0015701055526733,
0.2432446926832199,
0.4988814890384674,
0.20969241857528687,
-0.01580875553190708,
-0.6149083971977234,
-0.3043500483036041,
-0.3433819115161896,
-0.35847973823547363,
-0.9574698805809021,
0.3437832295894623,
0.022086840122938156,
0.5080050230026245,
0.8090447783470154,
0.3597632646560669,
0.43935781717300415,
-0.33806928992271423,
0.49553000926971436,
0.20287854969501495,
-0.8122848272323608,
0.7295091152191162,
-1.101086974143982,
0.4528086185455322,
1.1894274950027466,
0.4252988398075104,
-0.43847715854644775,
-0.08271367102861404,
-0.4572813808917999,
-0.8914380669593811,
0.24656392633914948,
0.006919273640960455,
0.010026034899055958,
0.008991300128400326,
0.4296618103981018,
-0.02377353608608246,
0.1205408126115799,
-0.592735230922699,
0.12857572734355927,
-0.2850169837474823,
-0.14936912059783936,
0.21031737327575684,
-0.7469444870948792,
-0.6174737811088562,
-0.018484432250261307,
0.47300705313682556,
-0.12240378558635712,
0.3654780089855194,
0.30694109201431274,
-0.19653795659542084,
-0.20328722894191742,
0.28679919242858887,
0.8259969353675842,
1.233235478401184,
-0.7391067743301392,
0.2793126106262207,
-0.09855281561613083,
-0.6986337900161743,
-0.18823592364788055,
0.11976528912782669,
-0.3925628364086151,
-0.08890372514724731,
0.6194126009941101,
0.19957640767097473,
0.010532664135098457,
-0.3293524384498596,
0.33732476830482483,
-0.3634439706802368,
-0.049411874264478683,
-0.3987189829349518,
0.11973746865987778,
0.26870471239089966,
-0.02224913239479065,
0.7875664234161377,
0.2679896652698517,
0.6836332082748413,
-0.3731119930744171,
0.1141057088971138,
0.34626609086990356,
-0.379427045583725,
-0.2541917562484741,
0.41165387630462646,
0.5503726601600647,
-0.4877692759037018,
0.07621785998344421,
0.08764206618070602,
-0.6232000589370728,
0.47256413102149963,
0.7727156281471252,
1.2266719341278076,
0.13166528940200806,
-0.06952095031738281,
0.3164995014667511,
0.28905028104782104,
-0.05118051916360855,
0.22491328418254852,
-0.21746134757995605,
-0.4283650517463684,
-0.03937779366970062,
-0.4154247045516968,
-0.6587839722633362,
0.18292942643165588,
-0.8810164928436279,
0.27600640058517456,
-0.5095453262329102,
-0.6712914109230042,
0.17242451012134552,
-0.028530597686767578,
-0.45957091450691223,
0.16303350031375885,
-0.14947079122066498,
1.198136568069458,
-0.6634919047355652,
0.6546481847763062,
0.9388526678085327,
-0.19653816521167755,
-0.40359237790107727,
0.5057181119918823,
0.09114173799753189,
-0.17472265660762787,
0.5617024898529053,
0.13601510226726532,
-0.4591104984283447,
-0.45288631319999695,
-0.1836233288049698,
-1.0177276134490967,
1.1191823482513428,
-0.05743108317255974,
-0.4577616751194,
0.5411245226860046,
-0.37463808059692383,
0.6847721934318542,
-0.42498987913131714,
0.6932839751243591,
0.1246044710278511,
0.5865737199783325,
-0.016900919377803802,
-0.42735201120376587,
-0.04091861844062805,
-0.6367074847221375,
-0.17138993740081787,
0.28400808572769165,
-0.46284693479537964,
0.7674063444137573,
0.18868988752365112,
-0.13465477526187897,
-0.48517316579818726,
0.7203001379966736,
0.22984130680561066,
0.7243334650993347,
0.4998190701007843,
0.029106711968779564,
0.8062392473220825,
0.11328211426734924,
0.9978935122489929,
-0.6916680932044983,
-0.01728535257279873,
1.43610417842865,
-0.5879740715026855,
0.6479576826095581,
0.4393819272518158,
-0.023060264065861702,
0.7425304055213928,
0.717086911201477,
0.18414634466171265,
0.7229478359222412,
-0.3153938353061676,
-0.3942050039768219,
-0.21931880712509155,
-0.3117417097091675,
-0.780612587928772,
0.18160364031791687,
0.6420111060142517,
-0.24477379024028778,
-0.29820433259010315,
-0.04489053413271904,
-0.04167502000927925,
0.29094386100769043,
-0.02060115896165371,
0.8074369430541992,
0.07606489956378937,
-0.8163173198699951,
0.24332228302955627,
-0.009598021395504475,
0.6438853144645691,
-0.5060349702835083,
0.20266211032867432,
-0.43667173385620117,
0.22316381335258484,
-0.4703049957752228,
-0.7355461120605469,
0.403795063495636,
0.33440229296684265,
-0.5303890109062195,
-0.4079661965370178,
1.18217134475708,
-0.061965253204107285,
-0.30126702785491943,
0.3531849980354309,
0.49336472153663635,
-0.10151782631874084,
0.17358581721782684,
-0.5448980927467346,
-0.2373017519712448,
0.044532410800457,
-0.2039644569158554,
0.4145408868789673,
0.4108893573284149,
-0.3259366750717163,
0.5515080690383911,
0.6187894940376282,
-0.0937519297003746,
-0.7285496592521667,
-0.06609908491373062,
0.9219496846199036,
-0.4904336631298065,
-0.5097155570983887,
-0.49909520149230957,
0.3176994025707245,
-0.42458516359329224,
-0.5014188885688782,
0.861151397228241,
0.7749039530754089,
0.37322211265563965,
-0.07218153029680252,
0.8666292428970337,
-0.07807794213294983,
0.8539505004882812,
-0.11530306190252304,
0.5048424005508423,
-0.6208944320678711,
0.5887420177459717,
-0.3833402097225189,
-0.8816944360733032,
-0.36100196838378906,
0.5609018802642822,
-0.6768261790275574,
0.13539740443229675,
0.586733877658844,
0.4537726938724518,
-0.33987218141555786,
0.02387726865708828,
-0.1842537373304367,
-0.5302757024765015,
0.311238169670105,
-0.06284617632627487,
0.7190357446670532,
0.00545503618195653,
0.4236941635608673,
-0.28975144028663635,
-0.3421994149684906,
-0.7675986289978027,
-1.2568919658660889,
-0.9751980900764465,
-0.451938658952713,
-0.23076103627681732,
-0.20015253126621246,
0.09353361278772354,
0.7562460899353027,
0.5884624719619751,
-1.0503801107406616,
-0.41835737228393555,
0.012962997891008854,
0.09010425209999084,
-0.00985067617148161,
-0.2773146331310272,
0.5287876129150391,
-0.12643666565418243,
-0.1989695131778717,
0.42158910632133484,
0.5293853282928467,
0.16946589946746826,
-0.05130024999380112,
0.32950443029403687,
-0.3226945698261261,
0.17287635803222656,
0.3777652680873871,
0.26832300424575806,
-0.2317286878824234,
-0.051215339452028275,
0.08575340360403061,
-0.5247163772583008,
-0.1234956681728363,
1.2327678203582764,
-0.7011393308639526,
0.2938504219055176,
0.98907470703125,
0.32754650712013245,
0.8442323803901672,
0.04889149218797684,
0.6610890030860901,
-0.5909596085548401,
0.3570805490016937,
0.3168830871582031,
0.45835861563682556,
0.4338749647140503,
-0.7143687605857849,
0.897880494594574,
-0.10394246131181717,
-0.5450587272644043,
-0.9063713550567627,
-0.11531781405210495,
-0.830143928527832,
-0.47575902938842773,
0.866168200969696,
-0.19845855236053467,
0.014117835089564323,
-0.21185778081417084,
-0.13374680280685425,
0.06174489110708237,
-0.6123508810997009,
0.9829526543617249,
0.24485990405082703,
-0.01574762724339962,
-0.08274592459201813,
-0.4205288589000702,
0.6937363147735596,
0.20696456730365753,
-0.973270058631897,
-0.012021390721201897,
0.37275534868240356,
0.08651033788919449,
0.7220117449760437,
0.5959515571594238,
0.3107655644416809,
0.6042435169219971,
-0.1698734313249588,
0.059684138745069504,
-0.1334443837404251,
-0.40243998169898987,
0.015443943440914154,
0.29030734300613403,
0.17973355948925018,
0.41589105129241943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02938v1
|
AIx Speed: Playback Speed Optimization Using Listening Comprehension of Speech Recognition Models
| 2024-03-05T13:08:52 | 2024-03-05T13:08:52 |
Kazuki Kawamura, Jun Rekimoto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Since humans can listen to audio and watch videos at faster speeds than
actually observed, we often listen to or watch these pieces of content at
higher playback speeds to increase the time efficiency of content
comprehension. To further utilize this capability, systems that automatically
adjust the playback speed according to the user's condition and the type of
content to assist in more efficient comprehension of time-series content have
been developed. However, there is still room for these systems to further
extend human speed-listening ability by generating speech with playback speed
optimized for even finer time units and providing it to humans. In this study,
we determine whether humans can hear the optimized speech and propose a system
that automatically adjusts playback speed at units as small as phonemes while
ensuring speech intelligibility. The system uses the speech recognizer score as
a proxy for how well a human can hear a certain unit of speech and maximizes
the speech playback speed to the extent that a human can hear. This method can
be used to produce fast but intelligible speech. In the evaluation experiment,
we compared the speech played back at a constant fast speed and the flexibly
speed-up speech generated by the proposed method in a blind test and confirmed
that the proposed method produced speech that was easier to listen to.
|
[
-0.5702546238899231,
-0.5762538909912109,
0.7137240767478943,
0.300648033618927,
-0.5635039210319519,
-0.1477901190519333,
-0.176291361451149,
-0.5149728655815125,
0.2988160252571106,
0.4293668866157532,
-0.5383740067481995,
0.1160377636551857,
-0.1644638329744339,
0.1246117651462555,
-0.418780118227005,
0.3363052308559418,
0.44601166248321533,
0.07819029688835144,
0.15029281377792358,
-0.09172329306602478,
-0.42194315791130066,
-0.18395887315273285,
-0.8719821572303772,
-0.20309728384017944,
0.35677334666252136,
0.8525065183639526,
0.8574566841125488,
1.1033315658569336,
0.458871066570282,
0.2847755253314972,
-0.14551053941249847,
-0.11357549577951431,
-0.28470587730407715,
0.5237252116203308,
0.03298157826066017,
-0.2540097236633301,
-0.5181410312652588,
-0.2895519435405731,
1.0656108856201172,
0.47012704610824585,
-0.14793138206005096,
0.397285521030426,
-0.1329248547554016,
0.8361544013023376,
-0.4134141206741333,
-0.35452568531036377,
-0.5158633589744568,
0.08312266319990158,
-0.34866026043891907,
-0.7102736830711365,
-0.22778400778770447,
-0.4069589376449585,
0.2549370229244232,
-0.61042320728302,
0.4584428668022156,
0.4845340847969055,
0.3893107771873474,
0.6250656843185425,
-0.1657259315252304,
0.14314018189907074,
-1.0488111972808838,
0.5405098795890808,
-0.5727971792221069,
0.756698489189148,
0.2538806200027466,
0.6125044226646423,
0.15871478617191315,
-0.4923478662967682,
-0.7156976461410522,
-0.06936768442392349,
0.3142891526222229,
-0.09559380263090134,
0.09211216866970062,
0.17524927854537964,
0.623444676399231,
0.34805241227149963,
-0.9954569935798645,
-0.016500530764460564,
-0.36234939098358154,
-0.6169400811195374,
0.9452109932899475,
0.38040077686309814,
0.14863361418247223,
-0.10434278100728989,
0.15726755559444427,
-0.33296337723731995,
-0.16609756648540497,
0.21985799074172974,
0.442078173160553,
0.2247174084186554,
0.325014591217041,
0.5040701031684875,
-0.40181031823158264,
0.5583189725875854,
-0.1523299217224121,
-0.43954339623451233,
0.3677501678466797,
-0.20624451339244843,
-0.15132448077201843,
0.628494381904602,
0.41502827405929565,
0.3541828393936157,
0.27983805537223816,
-0.05610623210668564,
-0.13479623198509216,
0.12385115772485733,
0.15548613667488098,
-0.6700990200042725,
0.1991075575351715,
0.14747105538845062,
-0.36764129996299744,
-0.08639751374721527,
-0.04924526810646057,
-0.6339651346206665,
-0.24926701188087463,
-0.511236846446991,
0.6728442907333374,
-0.4967978298664093,
-0.2956303656101227,
0.056115131825208664,
-0.36887648701667786,
0.08090141415596008,
0.09662032872438431,
-1.0155251026153564,
0.6275832653045654,
0.33439385890960693,
0.9416761994361877,
-0.15809647738933563,
-0.17711801826953888,
-1.1639050245285034,
0.268796443939209,
-0.34351077675819397,
0.6453598141670227,
-0.340371698141098,
-0.6039635539054871,
-0.39632731676101685,
-0.12225989997386932,
0.013386005535721779,
-0.41982778906822205,
0.8240339159965515,
-0.4090566635131836,
-0.08388297259807587,
-0.32994353771209717,
-0.7596229910850525,
-0.10724414139986038,
-0.5418462753295898,
-0.5658062100410461,
0.676832914352417,
-0.1143936961889267,
-0.4570123553276062,
0.5707473754882812,
-0.8358941674232483,
-0.8394119143486023,
0.18451043963432312,
0.21684664487838745,
-0.26576539874076843,
0.09667665511369705,
0.13694795966148376,
0.40784308314323425,
-0.12528006732463837,
-0.020358413457870483,
0.003452505450695753,
-0.7837592363357544,
0.09043334424495697,
-0.5378785133361816,
0.48678845167160034,
0.5661266446113586,
-0.5077891945838928,
0.06492627412080765,
-0.8713672161102295,
0.23434758186340332,
-0.06373501569032669,
-0.5059877634048462,
-0.10342616587877274,
0.3209356963634491,
0.17908789217472076,
-0.17650561034679413,
-0.30380406975746155,
-0.6882103681564331,
-0.41965699195861816,
-0.5252642631530762,
0.5006958842277527,
0.7585028409957886,
0.1577133685350418,
0.2895771265029907,
-0.42171230912208557,
0.4273698627948761,
-0.23850741982460022,
0.17115484178066254,
-0.2476765513420105,
-0.392010360956192,
-0.7219844460487366,
-0.13234294950962067,
0.10057595372200012,
0.563545823097229,
-0.34955933690071106,
0.023064179345965385,
-0.17669141292572021,
-0.3737278878688812,
-0.8009711503982544,
0.027139024809002876,
0.18406957387924194,
0.7501556873321533,
0.33599719405174255,
-0.5149952173233032,
-0.6421683430671692,
-0.9355641007423401,
-0.564506471157074,
-0.2354688197374344,
-0.25705692172050476,
0.7042049765586853,
0.04146793857216835,
0.17079655826091766,
0.6180408596992493,
-0.4869375228881836,
0.15458859503269196,
-0.1141325831413269,
0.15510642528533936,
-0.04989246279001236,
0.4628165364265442,
0.1071082055568695,
-0.8487256765365601,
-0.25420719385147095,
-0.22239245474338531,
-0.1619824916124344,
-0.13418571650981903,
0.11553231626749039,
0.05817721411585808,
0.14728008210659027,
0.572225034236908,
-0.03370814025402069,
0.40879690647125244,
0.11713644117116928,
-0.3368769586086273,
0.5419531464576721,
-0.4045618772506714,
0.28236448764801025,
-0.6329590082168579,
0.05289389193058014,
-0.12152789533138275,
-0.4816448390483856,
-0.6188256144523621,
-0.5760533809661865,
-0.13193675875663757,
-0.5655657649040222,
-0.7803881764411926,
0.3219755291938782,
-0.09624572843313217,
-0.6471424102783203,
-0.29120513796806335,
0.32716479897499084,
-0.0613478347659111,
0.4055420458316803,
0.16678225994110107,
1.1489238739013672,
0.5708338618278503,
-1.2274816036224365,
0.3015909194946289,
-0.13762347400188446,
-0.4188445210456848,
0.46884092688560486,
-0.807935893535614,
0.17318445444107056,
-0.21003897488117218,
-0.10084870457649231,
-0.7204375267028809,
-0.39694851636886597,
-0.3512803912162781,
-0.44733351469039917,
0.1031474843621254,
0.3774345815181732,
-0.2936362326145172,
-0.1704198569059372,
0.06666523963212967,
0.43926894664764404,
0.745060384273529,
-0.37026703357696533,
0.3490230143070221,
0.5266586542129517,
-0.12689806520938873,
-0.16616833209991455,
-0.3400894105434418,
-0.3047066032886505,
-0.35358160734176636,
-0.9717310070991516,
0.5582690238952637,
-0.35901957750320435,
-0.3532862067222595,
-0.31444165110588074,
-0.07489926367998123,
0.12851980328559875,
0.08461874723434448,
0.16095958650112152,
-0.16616511344909668,
-0.3779635727405548,
0.4481067359447479,
0.2334521859884262,
-0.14788885414600372,
-0.1473056972026825,
-0.4145806133747101,
0.3139234185218811,
-0.33679571747779846,
-0.17214353382587433,
-0.8335009217262268,
0.48242348432540894,
0.6679528951644897,
0.02676435187458992,
0.39350759983062744,
0.7634064555168152,
-0.272871732711792,
0.22070790827274323,
-0.7907682657241821,
-0.37802812457084656,
-0.4419187009334564,
0.2380802035331726,
-0.18366187810897827,
-0.8255048990249634,
0.1733235865831375,
0.08229824155569077,
-0.22599191963672638,
0.35200080275535583,
0.334477961063385,
-0.12097936868667603,
1.3061271905899048,
0.6178106665611267,
-0.11177682131528854,
0.4013412296772003,
0.10034199804067612,
-0.20559266209602356,
-0.8616993427276611,
0.0012956573627889156,
-0.7378262281417847,
-0.2625332772731781,
-0.7152274250984192,
-0.16970735788345337,
0.4905376434326172,
-0.24618899822235107,
-0.49309250712394714,
0.365853875875473,
-0.46980705857276917,
0.44760018587112427,
0.7960624694824219,
0.2683725655078888,
0.3277338743209839,
-0.2162133753299713,
-0.12781445682048798,
-0.05192820355296135,
-0.4961235821247101,
-0.34131085872650146,
0.6710085272789001,
0.3494928181171417,
0.5022003054618835,
0.2937416732311249,
0.36210599541664124,
0.7590744495391846,
-0.374148428440094,
-0.6143290400505066,
0.6291501522064209,
-0.22103294730186462,
-0.7162620425224304,
-0.8124616742134094,
-0.34155887365341187,
-0.4967411160469055,
0.05630616471171379,
-0.07935106754302979,
-0.8152990937232971,
0.3049018979072571,
0.425760954618454,
-0.4921342432498932,
-0.015066560357809067,
-0.7693551182746887,
0.7278929352760315,
-0.21042415499687195,
-0.5212677717208862,
-0.5559135675430298,
-0.7984878420829773,
0.09875651448965073,
0.1468687206506729,
0.15705305337905884,
-0.27144762873649597,
0.07152309268712997,
0.8962661623954773,
-0.29727721214294434,
0.1321980357170105,
-0.36583924293518066,
0.5485385656356812,
0.2530028820037842,
0.17334489524364471,
0.16288280487060547,
-0.027744237333536148,
-0.26569369435310364,
-0.19170258939266205,
-0.10692103207111359,
-0.34092143177986145,
-0.5247496366500854,
0.3246673047542572,
-0.6380789279937744,
-0.829718291759491,
-0.13647542893886566,
-0.40547528862953186,
-0.197052463889122,
0.037332698702812195,
0.28345048427581787,
0.4422944188117981,
-0.3171767294406891,
0.10706470906734467,
0.7659817337989807,
-0.07186286896467209,
0.6454243063926697,
0.5536997318267822,
0.16651730239391327,
-0.00871205236762762,
1.178783893585205,
0.04902474582195282,
0.40421146154403687,
0.3627634644508362,
0.3496016561985016,
-0.5069425702095032,
-0.5459665060043335,
-0.3579176068305969,
0.14025287330150604,
-0.2771468460559845,
0.31242093443870544,
-0.23192843794822693,
-0.18450552225112915,
-0.5878874659538269,
0.08055181801319122,
-0.23197028040885925,
-0.775689959526062,
-0.268894225358963,
-0.005308955442160368,
0.2217303216457367,
0.21022175252437592,
-0.4062138497829437,
0.4416368305683136,
-0.6506025791168213,
0.4884204864501953,
0.6112222075462341,
0.34326791763305664,
-0.12502367794513702,
-0.9370027184486389,
-0.14672107994556427,
-0.0770096480846405,
-0.4243139922618866,
-0.6735717058181763,
0.4552599787712097,
0.46666422486305237,
0.5298555493354797,
0.42595893144607544,
-0.005179965868592262,
0.7412612438201904,
-0.6381277441978455,
0.5953173041343689,
-0.09081245958805084,
-1.1959701776504517,
0.919153094291687,
-0.08123191446065903,
0.36311277747154236,
0.385886013507843,
0.23136800527572632,
-0.6951899528503418,
-0.10735876858234406,
-0.47096961736679077,
-0.7286947965621948,
0.8578483462333679,
0.5008991956710815,
-0.21272216737270355,
0.19639605283737183,
0.4028628468513489,
-0.04605057090520859,
0.11164653301239014,
0.1151985302567482,
-0.19153541326522827,
-0.3833000659942627,
0.15258191525936127,
-0.5252804160118103,
-0.14333467185497284,
0.21457421779632568,
-0.17163388431072235,
1.0093953609466553,
-0.07892663776874542,
0.17138080298900604,
0.7061329483985901,
-0.2966124415397644,
-0.5656718611717224,
0.30171555280685425,
0.864698052406311,
0.5428085923194885,
-0.552426815032959,
-0.02872856892645359,
0.09906245023012161,
-0.7570289373397827,
0.40834519267082214,
0.05804269388318062,
-0.2354375571012497,
-0.0457494743168354,
0.1223931610584259,
1.1527314186096191,
-0.054726969450712204,
-0.867150068283081,
0.15159930288791656,
-0.5322571992874146,
-0.06407961994409561,
-0.3344307839870453,
0.5838407278060913,
-0.051321715116500854,
0.2315634936094284,
0.2518632113933563,
0.15980082750320435,
0.36718711256980896,
-0.5370378494262695,
0.3171960115432739,
0.1560339778661728,
-0.44037559628486633,
0.06046070158481598,
1.1101619005203247,
0.31536799669265747,
-0.9391685128211975,
0.7045403718948364,
0.07904665172100067,
-0.22823728621006012,
0.36238929629325867,
0.22547617554664612,
1.0473393201828003,
-0.6333910822868347,
0.06021800637245178,
0.3464577794075012,
0.10692849010229111,
-0.08098483830690384,
0.28956830501556396,
-0.3526321053504944,
-0.7004847526550293,
-0.5108256340026855,
-0.7591845989227295,
-0.5621757507324219,
-0.20596107840538025,
-0.8032199144363403,
0.03781362622976303,
-0.0236513614654541,
-0.3843834698200226,
0.41631701588630676,
0.1093282476067543,
-0.6857367157936096,
0.4733092486858368,
0.22771380841732025,
1.1086612939834595,
-0.5899258255958557,
0.7852858901023865,
0.23122826218605042,
-0.2228977084159851,
-0.83378666639328,
0.046609312295913696,
-0.05822864919900894,
-0.44683289527893066,
0.4322499632835388,
0.002397752832621336,
-0.41236409544944763,
0.06665933132171631,
-0.20297187566757202,
-0.7386471033096313,
1.2341669797897339,
0.3958057761192322,
-0.8758201599121094,
0.21450462937355042,
0.11559736728668213,
0.5260209441184998,
-0.46823427081108093,
0.22880405187606812,
0.8932576775550842,
0.5029206275939941,
0.023245180025696754,
-1.0821532011032104,
-0.07499967515468597,
-0.10249412804841995,
0.18947762250900269,
-0.15941384434700012,
-0.5782778263092041,
0.5616450309753418,
-0.39146730303764343,
0.029404930770397186,
0.0519380047917366,
0.6956799030303955,
0.18637701869010925,
0.6824220418930054,
0.9214174747467041,
0.29751038551330566,
0.839800238609314,
0.10214848071336746,
1.045609712600708,
-0.06430458277463913,
-0.14990897476673126,
0.7702730298042297,
-0.25918033719062805,
0.628932535648346,
0.47539809346199036,
-0.01692384108901024,
0.2732776403427124,
0.5955159068107605,
0.5723248720169067,
0.47178924083709717,
0.1382911652326584,
-0.5161709785461426,
-0.4032328128814697,
-0.27183109521865845,
-0.24869710206985474,
0.4611476957798004,
0.2503804564476013,
-0.3580001890659332,
0.6173183917999268,
0.20887227356433868,
-0.43934541940689087,
0.04746343567967415,
-0.46366703510284424,
0.8564578294754028,
-0.28679314255714417,
-0.8835222125053406,
0.6008846163749695,
-0.06326238065958023,
0.02978399582207203,
-0.5386231541633606,
0.16847409307956696,
-0.07243414223194122,
0.18794716894626617,
0.08480465412139893,
-0.5138709545135498,
0.29939505457878113,
0.025218416005373,
-0.2128329575061798,
0.12930133938789368,
0.5319538712501526,
-0.11126430332660675,
-0.3223445415496826,
0.1650734394788742,
0.25510191917419434,
0.6618309020996094,
-0.08244065195322037,
-0.33977174758911133,
0.2932271957397461,
0.12014738470315933,
-0.27942007780075073,
0.11493469774723053,
0.13048656284809113,
0.10772985219955444,
0.6969277262687683,
0.5434824228286743,
0.1818399578332901,
0.0028515858575701714,
0.4318746030330658,
0.5623527765274048,
-0.8741433620452881,
-0.4811481833457947,
-0.6866514086723328,
0.3806505501270294,
-0.19190627336502075,
-0.184133380651474,
0.4909343123435974,
0.6206485629081726,
0.6767111420631409,
0.05517673119902611,
0.6620699763298035,
0.10762836784124374,
1.0108633041381836,
-0.558897078037262,
0.3973715603351593,
-0.7459487318992615,
0.25455912947654724,
-0.5811616778373718,
-1.0237318277359009,
-0.0073148575611412525,
0.6542015671730042,
0.07057984173297882,
-0.11472707986831665,
0.7582753896713257,
0.8259335160255432,
0.0075359465554356575,
0.5726540684700012,
0.578616738319397,
0.18819114565849304,
0.30601295828819275,
0.40694698691368103,
0.28536683320999146,
-0.35220348834991455,
0.7308176159858704,
-0.6532861590385437,
-0.2252226024866104,
-0.3890210688114166,
-0.8712468147277832,
-0.424035906791687,
-0.8509286642074585,
-0.1225389912724495,
-0.2996537685394287,
0.5141982436180115,
0.5816302299499512,
0.8990887403488159,
-0.4928849935531616,
-0.45278114080429077,
-0.05030335858464241,
0.0659479945898056,
-0.6029078364372253,
-0.3280767798423767,
0.2943230867385864,
-0.07583063095808029,
-0.6981213688850403,
0.6998511552810669,
0.3758026957511902,
0.13156135380268097,
-0.2715252637863159,
-0.4994041323661804,
0.09560814499855042,
0.3369729816913605,
0.36400550603866577,
0.49678823351860046,
-0.44050922989845276,
-0.5160863399505615,
0.22724200785160065,
0.23279786109924316,
0.00014102327986620367,
1.2547701597213745,
-0.9018211960792542,
0.6929863095283508,
0.6485578417778015,
0.2105586677789688,
0.977047324180603,
0.15636305510997772,
0.5054640769958496,
-0.507135808467865,
0.26835954189300537,
0.6048253178596497,
0.3856689929962158,
0.29865139722824097,
-0.37416690587997437,
0.3014301359653473,
0.11041579395532608,
-0.8674877285957336,
-0.7445780634880066,
0.2837775945663452,
-1.0320565700531006,
0.025543145835399628,
0.6855471730232239,
0.22695845365524292,
-0.39597535133361816,
-0.20670081675052643,
-0.421956866979599,
0.5293378829956055,
-0.6438508629798889,
0.5644822716712952,
0.28583258390426636,
-0.5973800420761108,
-0.037309639155864716,
-0.44274383783340454,
0.5394983887672424,
0.42628392577171326,
-0.37059688568115234,
0.0032647373154759407,
0.3231053352355957,
0.22068892419338226,
0.07280629128217697,
0.6950112581253052,
0.15983302891254425,
0.8083766102790833,
0.034147121012210846,
-0.2313610166311264,
-0.10501537472009659,
-0.35947784781455994,
-0.08923160284757614,
0.01859317347407341,
0.03719590604305267,
-0.09064151346683502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02932v2
|
RulePrompt: Weakly Supervised Text Classification with Prompting PLMs and Self-Iterative Logical Rules
| 2024-03-05T12:50:36 | 2024-04-25T09:23:28 |
Miaomiao Li, Jiaqi Zhu, Yang Wang, Yi Yang, Yilin Li, Hongan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Weakly supervised text classification (WSTC), also called zero-shot or
dataless text classification, has attracted increasing attention due to its
applicability in classifying a mass of texts within the dynamic and open Web
environment, since it requires only a limited set of seed words (label names)
for each category instead of labeled data. With the help of recently popular
prompting Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs), many studies leveraged manually
crafted and/or automatically identified verbalizers to estimate the likelihood
of categories, but they failed to differentiate the effects of these
category-indicative words, let alone capture their correlations and realize
adaptive adjustments according to the unlabeled corpus. In this paper, in order
to let the PLM effectively understand each category, we at first propose a
novel form of rule-based knowledge using logical expressions to characterize
the meanings of categories. Then, we develop a prompting PLM-based approach
named RulePrompt for the WSTC task, consisting of a rule mining module and a
rule-enhanced pseudo label generation module, plus a self-supervised
fine-tuning module to make the PLM align with this task. Within this framework,
the inaccurate pseudo labels assigned to texts and the imprecise logical rules
associated with categories mutually enhance each other in an alternative
manner. That establishes a self-iterative closed loop of knowledge (rule)
acquisition and utilization, with seed words serving as the starting point.
Extensive experiments validate the effectiveness and robustness of our
approach, which markedly outperforms state-of-the-art weakly supervised
methods. What is more, our approach yields interpretable category rules,
proving its advantage in disambiguating easily-confused categories.
|
[
-0.2575591504573822,
-0.8590582609176636,
0.5745341181755066,
-0.043084681034088135,
-0.48251065611839294,
-0.19266559183597565,
-0.2991275191307068,
-0.2041075974702835,
-0.060099489986896515,
0.41914206743240356,
-0.7019585371017456,
-0.843868613243103,
-0.588348925113678,
0.3317835330963135,
-0.5983445048332214,
1.4186865091323853,
0.16164250671863556,
-0.3735601305961609,
-0.363970011472702,
-0.12074567377567291,
-0.5683413743972778,
-0.48156216740608215,
-0.22787517309188843,
-0.13353122770786285,
0.5256760120391846,
0.7119190096855164,
0.44703197479248047,
0.4826166033744812,
0.4100722372531891,
0.3793083131313324,
-0.1937141716480255,
0.16672629117965698,
-0.2793309986591339,
0.03861328959465027,
-0.39299771189689636,
-0.3639463484287262,
-0.23810449242591858,
0.05892876163125038,
0.12455962598323822,
0.6183887720108032,
-0.20959481596946716,
0.3229464292526245,
0.24979111552238464,
0.3365127742290497,
-0.6649840474128723,
0.3352679908275604,
-0.6699555516242981,
0.0046064588241279125,
-0.2894536554813385,
-0.4563809633255005,
-0.5995668768882751,
-0.24436749517917633,
0.1346721351146698,
-0.5309649705886841,
0.38679322600364685,
0.03156759589910507,
0.8659999370574951,
0.19228003919124603,
-0.3494258224964142,
-0.4844013452529907,
-0.5748933553695679,
0.8697014451026917,
-0.5828643441200256,
0.12087100744247437,
0.43741488456726074,
-0.047807976603507996,
-0.23512157797813416,
-0.9755743741989136,
-0.6619411706924438,
0.03045644983649254,
-0.17997559905052185,
0.3595629930496216,
-0.30126428604125977,
0.1408987194299698,
0.29231005907058716,
0.26829612255096436,
-0.594210147857666,
0.15608446300029755,
-0.39166060090065,
-0.23286330699920654,
0.3287416100502014,
0.1579105108976364,
0.16670875251293182,
-0.3827953040599823,
-0.5780661106109619,
0.08533647656440735,
-0.31487229466438293,
0.1635138988494873,
0.0949556902050972,
0.5025541186332703,
-0.01647125743329525,
0.6038033366203308,
-0.36602360010147095,
0.8628929853439331,
0.14635856449604034,
-0.3847678601741791,
0.1880194991827011,
-0.4456421136856079,
-0.21459369361400604,
0.37161940336227417,
1.0166127681732178,
0.15934357047080994,
0.26796332001686096,
-0.014797939918935299,
-0.032309822738170624,
0.28888171911239624,
0.24577941000461578,
-0.6426312923431396,
-0.2966262996196747,
0.09309888631105423,
-0.5788409113883972,
-0.5372837781906128,
-0.009177937172353268,
-0.698924720287323,
-0.3463912010192871,
-0.5300418138504028,
0.6744089722633362,
-0.2822728455066681,
-0.08545614778995514,
0.1119702011346817,
-0.13282537460327148,
0.15457318723201752,
0.37463247776031494,
-0.6945410966873169,
0.33681783080101013,
0.48400720953941345,
0.8371539115905762,
-0.10953949391841888,
-0.18319068849086761,
-0.45070236921310425,
-0.03220474347472191,
-0.3570597171783447,
1.0754679441452026,
-0.3046186864376068,
-0.19382648169994354,
0.007672441657632589,
-0.025007279589772224,
-0.025753209367394447,
-0.269818514585495,
0.7237396836280823,
-0.37333422899246216,
0.5032808184623718,
-0.05568360537290573,
-0.7815405130386353,
-0.10923348367214203,
0.2458958476781845,
-0.2701284885406494,
0.9718495011329651,
-0.1674920916557312,
-1.044808030128479,
0.5611873865127563,
-0.21380499005317688,
-0.5985598564147949,
0.3379417657852173,
0.0483991876244545,
-0.474290668964386,
0.13688145577907562,
-0.02034267969429493,
0.6097175478935242,
-0.16261254251003265,
0.4505893886089325,
-0.35096365213394165,
-0.2683374285697937,
0.047107212245464325,
-0.21780209243297577,
0.6764176487922668,
0.24836084246635437,
-0.2809281051158905,
0.47435104846954346,
-0.7418202757835388,
0.13589739799499512,
0.028862640261650085,
0.11288067698478699,
-0.5790067911148071,
0.29490694403648376,
-0.381766140460968,
0.45209914445877075,
0.24491016566753387,
-0.35715821385383606,
0.21303728222846985,
-0.30894437432289124,
0.22174130380153656,
0.7184702754020691,
0.17086076736450195,
0.43861475586891174,
-0.16152550280094147,
0.14240357279777527,
-0.027701066806912422,
0.39627477526664734,
-0.08464785665273666,
-0.6343872547149658,
-0.8918817639350891,
-0.3909972012042999,
0.35329100489616394,
0.6125332117080688,
-0.9035456776618958,
0.7435056567192078,
0.07808660715818405,
-0.4871181845664978,
-0.2979131042957306,
0.4124471843242645,
0.21059274673461914,
0.9028499722480774,
0.6513347625732422,
-0.1851608008146286,
-0.6682911515235901,
-0.5998599529266357,
-0.0643157884478569,
-0.373712420463562,
0.14837263524532318,
-0.12887060642242432,
0.29460808634757996,
-0.03370874747633934,
0.9888670444488525,
-0.488567978143692,
-0.8696890473365784,
-0.5514142513275146,
0.569336473941803,
0.3709498345851898,
0.2562364637851715,
0.03617722913622856,
-0.5943323969841003,
-0.30918043851852417,
-0.3331407904624939,
-0.8722701072692871,
-0.43446773290634155,
-0.13336175680160522,
-0.02884211391210556,
-0.036130521446466446,
0.6183501482009888,
-0.26835742592811584,
0.5233457088470459,
0.15829646587371826,
-0.33714190125465393,
0.5119770765304565,
-0.26306354999542236,
-0.21477684378623962,
-0.7394921779632568,
-0.14408136904239655,
0.2484157383441925,
-0.22738665342330933,
-0.6300510168075562,
-0.30067571997642517,
0.04352927207946777,
0.07065106183290482,
-0.5921090245246887,
0.4391094148159027,
-0.346183180809021,
0.40269118547439575,
-0.6329180002212524,
0.14293654263019562,
-0.2113654762506485,
0.514500617980957,
0.38075360655784607,
0.3781783878803253,
0.6762003302574158,
-1.0426863431930542,
0.22911950945854187,
0.17951764166355133,
-0.09119794517755508,
0.6483672261238098,
-0.2641844153404236,
-0.15824848413467407,
-0.2084902822971344,
0.004692047368735075,
-0.8169428110122681,
0.07274423539638519,
0.2333981692790985,
-0.2347513884305954,
0.2348964512348175,
-0.1720409393310547,
-0.7494221329689026,
-0.44401711225509644,
-0.36433932185173035,
0.11959879100322723,
0.7614194750785828,
-0.5269057750701904,
0.4085308313369751,
0.1915874183177948,
0.09915933012962341,
-0.2717428505420685,
-0.3507266044616699,
0.0030093153472989798,
-0.23821136355400085,
-0.08377674967050552,
0.142774298787117,
0.017848564311861992,
-0.05054838955402374,
0.15715409815311432,
-0.1512140929698944,
-0.09744124859571457,
0.1272285133600235,
0.25099512934684753,
0.2719097137451172,
0.007622193079441786,
0.3006446957588196,
0.0643104836344719,
-0.2182428389787674,
-0.10409527271986008,
-0.4973193407058716,
0.21389172971248627,
-0.19238869845867157,
-0.07092703133821487,
-0.67084801197052,
-0.034057460725307465,
0.04220368713140488,
-0.08685211837291718,
0.6869288682937622,
0.6329885125160217,
-0.26256024837493896,
-0.579754114151001,
-0.2990438938140869,
-0.2869964838027954,
-0.5048056244850159,
-0.1460505723953247,
-0.33431610465049744,
-0.7960287928581238,
0.1863553822040558,
-0.3547361493110657,
-0.1863437443971634,
0.5520463585853577,
0.5711572170257568,
-0.32756170630455017,
0.9434744119644165,
0.879153847694397,
0.1492939591407776,
0.349953293800354,
0.0838850662112236,
0.0587674155831337,
-0.2933294177055359,
-0.33490556478500366,
-0.5419609546661377,
-0.15210014581680298,
-0.8446165919303894,
-0.13419409096240997,
0.11281727999448776,
0.26972606778144836,
-0.01223529502749443,
0.4026171565055847,
-0.6482341289520264,
0.3995641767978668,
0.6163336634635925,
0.06911437213420868,
0.3674371838569641,
-0.1069108098745346,
-0.3345116078853607,
-0.1631677895784378,
-0.8274327516555786,
-0.3647182583808899,
0.74921715259552,
0.09594301879405975,
0.7723783254623413,
-0.05302216857671738,
0.873356819152832,
0.540714681148529,
0.3763846158981323,
-1.0623735189437866,
0.7217013835906982,
-0.4810178279876709,
-0.41285762190818787,
0.05767931416630745,
-0.42559289932250977,
-0.801657497882843,
0.07852020859718323,
-0.2607184648513794,
-0.8019098043441772,
0.24497580528259277,
0.34136372804641724,
-0.13556285202503204,
0.1732882410287857,
-0.8966057300567627,
0.971035361289978,
-0.25264304876327515,
-0.48727717995643616,
0.13868004083633423,
-0.5512040853500366,
0.4366123378276825,
-0.14445729553699493,
0.3251277804374695,
-0.15678705275058746,
-0.06202644482254982,
0.8136090636253357,
-0.6456645131111145,
1.1197657585144043,
-0.32127323746681213,
-0.04207463189959526,
0.7594640851020813,
0.19093967974185944,
0.4094982147216797,
-0.2824660837650299,
0.13932523131370544,
0.05956455320119858,
0.0724971666932106,
-0.2696821689605713,
-0.5244861245155334,
0.469980388879776,
-0.3941875398159027,
-0.4788512885570526,
-0.7071908712387085,
0.004383312072604895,
-0.32154107093811035,
0.4552849233150482,
0.31186673045158386,
0.3380935788154602,
0.026467056944966316,
0.14067889750003815,
0.7146915197372437,
-0.0643414556980133,
0.4297487139701843,
0.7103303074836731,
-0.092208631336689,
-0.16409535706043243,
1.2003145217895508,
-0.08697347342967987,
0.002412168076261878,
0.4146452248096466,
0.5471227765083313,
-0.5550768971443176,
-0.6484636068344116,
-0.0870860144495964,
-0.02658827230334282,
-0.6951757073402405,
-0.6366959810256958,
-0.49881792068481445,
-0.12385407835245132,
-0.2032005339860916,
-0.002656411612406373,
-0.0588926300406456,
-0.22876498103141785,
-0.5424323081970215,
-0.05168713256716728,
0.5548880100250244,
0.6709282994270325,
0.025692444294691086,
0.3784690797328949,
-0.5556132197380066,
0.4455815255641937,
0.11126428097486496,
0.36957430839538574,
-0.24410812556743622,
-0.6581165790557861,
0.07909131050109863,
-0.47497525811195374,
-0.14376597106456757,
-1.0017485618591309,
0.29582104086875916,
0.4141598045825958,
0.42264071106910706,
0.5472966432571411,
0.5763018131256104,
0.6541696786880493,
-0.4692777693271637,
0.5688435435295105,
0.3698258101940155,
-1.0730692148208618,
0.863724946975708,
-0.1168469786643982,
0.18470735847949982,
0.7812724113464355,
0.4262145757675171,
-0.424903929233551,
-0.6486929655075073,
-0.7335305213928223,
-0.8060896396636963,
0.8986131548881531,
0.18196019530296326,
-0.05440405383706093,
-0.16854523122310638,
0.13789024949073792,
0.19477586448192596,
0.2651657164096832,
-0.7128337025642395,
-0.16247712075710297,
-0.5439354777336121,
-0.8074271082878113,
0.10336338728666306,
-0.26318222284317017,
0.157755509018898,
-0.2964301109313965,
0.6967931985855103,
-0.4508315622806549,
0.0012832734500989318,
0.25834962725639343,
-0.3160419762134552,
0.19674228131771088,
0.5647454261779785,
0.3141035735607147,
0.33207306265830994,
-0.19605237245559692,
0.6472119092941284,
0.220467209815979,
-0.2699471116065979,
0.181270033121109,
0.03697710111737251,
-0.33192217350006104,
-0.08665890991687775,
0.512194037437439,
0.5821208953857422,
0.3009498715400696,
-0.6677749156951904,
0.6742310523986816,
-0.19768370687961578,
-0.38617125153541565,
0.15004995465278625,
0.22389093041419983,
-0.33685293793678284,
-0.14459790289402008,
0.22548289597034454,
0.05491376668214798,
0.24631671607494354,
-0.4480777382850647,
0.433358758687973,
0.24634726345539093,
-0.5684199333190918,
-0.28693026304244995,
0.3842189610004425,
0.010374742560088634,
0.11166014522314072,
0.24708910286426544,
-0.7015891671180725,
-0.5587115287780762,
0.27951911091804504,
0.607564389705658,
0.6652492880821228,
0.10549271106719971,
0.49300649762153625,
0.39407411217689514,
0.3477857708930969,
-0.260088711977005,
0.14133687317371368,
-0.40636083483695984,
-0.6216151714324951,
-0.3680444657802582,
-0.7884043455123901,
-0.14044472575187683,
0.20365853607654572,
-0.5316739082336426,
0.4487643241882324,
-0.6831908226013184,
-0.14923584461212158,
0.03454361483454704,
0.07169882953166962,
-0.5510886311531067,
0.3315725326538086,
0.12291914224624634,
0.800312876701355,
-1.0148409605026245,
0.7778640389442444,
0.7104049921035767,
-0.49522295594215393,
-0.8569016456604004,
-0.001591873704455793,
0.18689274787902832,
-0.4190353751182556,
0.5838219523429871,
0.09105978161096573,
-0.06983443349599838,
0.1442272663116455,
-0.649980902671814,
-0.4704926311969757,
0.7022572755813599,
-0.17110887169837952,
-0.4910668730735779,
0.3205983638763428,
0.01015909668058157,
0.8334339261054993,
0.10139094293117523,
0.3049775958061218,
0.26561978459358215,
0.44606292247772217,
0.29657262563705444,
-0.7678852677345276,
0.1773230880498886,
-0.19453346729278564,
-0.24323447048664093,
0.13933905959129333,
-0.40890684723854065,
0.36813995242118835,
-0.1372658908367157,
-0.3514324426651001,
-0.012775564566254616,
0.831893801689148,
0.01734047196805477,
0.5052253007888794,
0.5507226586341858,
0.46835678815841675,
0.7434678077697754,
-0.11736738681793213,
0.7188515663146973,
-0.057262491434812546,
0.39602598547935486,
1.2187817096710205,
-0.3754347860813141,
0.7650584578514099,
0.26832813024520874,
-0.09916975349187851,
0.6539627313613892,
0.6863470077514648,
-0.20906531810760498,
0.690589964389801,
0.06833190470933914,
-0.29155540466308594,
-0.4248920977115631,
-0.4487123191356659,
0.06827803701162338,
0.5696227550506592,
0.35349446535110474,
-0.08042845875024796,
-0.48971614241600037,
0.1503853052854538,
-0.12384665757417679,
0.26562410593032837,
-0.5163979530334473,
1.337494134902954,
0.17680123448371887,
-0.588050127029419,
0.40230414271354675,
0.13383537530899048,
0.7959348559379578,
-0.6679500341415405,
0.06710205227136612,
-0.047457098960876465,
0.2602452337741852,
-0.44647929072380066,
-0.9180256724357605,
0.1593981236219406,
0.35865867137908936,
-0.15137119591236115,
-0.33106231689453125,
1.2539595365524292,
-0.3004401922225952,
-0.5564488172531128,
0.347522109746933,
0.6370413899421692,
0.0740685984492302,
0.10371033847332001,
-0.76351398229599,
-0.19125370681285858,
-0.18934400379657745,
0.12419266998767853,
0.24184198677539825,
0.769959568977356,
-0.29092109203338623,
0.4492778480052948,
0.645231306552887,
0.061496078968048096,
0.018194830045104027,
0.22515496611595154,
0.6664076447486877,
-0.6650308966636658,
-0.5594063401222229,
-0.8990928530693054,
0.287618488073349,
0.10370521247386932,
-0.11284967511892319,
0.8560342788696289,
0.42305442690849304,
0.614302396774292,
0.03275299072265625,
0.54495769739151,
-0.1659018099308014,
0.39415717124938965,
-0.5401000380516052,
0.4550430476665497,
-0.5702616572380066,
0.08306610584259033,
-0.32064273953437805,
-0.4701201021671295,
-0.4590444564819336,
0.3751573860645294,
-0.3609054684638977,
-0.10992351174354553,
0.8483690619468689,
0.5016120672225952,
-0.0805203840136528,
0.11757569015026093,
0.1840900182723999,
0.1771640032529831,
0.021911654621362686,
0.2563779950141907,
0.9213627576828003,
-0.16850848495960236,
0.7519721388816833,
-0.4128305912017822,
-0.3316076099872589,
-0.06318023800849915,
-0.97327721118927,
-0.9329738020896912,
-0.5186982750892639,
-0.6308475732803345,
-0.27607083320617676,
0.07994356751441956,
0.8488762974739075,
0.6902981996536255,
-0.9687459468841553,
0.06295893341302872,
-0.5187282562255859,
0.4154598116874695,
-0.30824893712997437,
-0.29581716656684875,
0.4127430021762848,
-0.8041132688522339,
-0.3744361996650696,
0.33709415793418884,
0.0868963971734047,
0.05792821943759918,
0.12364733219146729,
0.12923288345336914,
-0.2786079943180084,
-0.14797161519527435,
0.645801305770874,
0.4461261034011841,
-0.3780292272567749,
0.08229205757379532,
-0.09627565741539001,
-0.05976634472608566,
-0.1328222155570984,
0.7849159240722656,
-1.0165785551071167,
0.5085974931716919,
0.4664444029331207,
0.31257930397987366,
0.287552148103714,
0.22019673883914948,
0.07896198332309723,
-1.0261365175247192,
0.20683389902114868,
0.2584044933319092,
0.11039336770772934,
0.12618368864059448,
-0.23307976126670837,
0.11246412992477417,
0.6457903981208801,
-0.16045723855495453,
-0.6908767223358154,
0.026819607242941856,
-1.0717045068740845,
-0.5837873220443726,
1.035692811012268,
0.07661120593547821,
-0.4734187722206116,
-0.3455640971660614,
-0.1294059306383133,
0.2681007981300354,
-0.4248596131801605,
0.6796330809593201,
0.35076481103897095,
-0.22156934440135956,
-0.2541941702365875,
-0.37555965781211853,
0.7150666117668152,
0.33311727643013,
-0.9924553632736206,
-0.10148487985134125,
0.3512989282608032,
0.17622070014476776,
0.09932700544595718,
0.6015516519546509,
0.03559333086013794,
0.10894764959812164,
-0.22538970410823822,
0.026642512530088425,
-0.03885027766227722,
-0.42534884810447693,
-0.2343752533197403,
0.3556751310825348,
0.09229700267314911,
-0.14020606875419617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02930v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02930v2
|
A Second Look on BASS -- Boosting Abstractive Summarization with Unified Semantic Graphs -- A Replication Study
| 2024-03-05T12:48:29 | 2024-03-25T12:07:13 |
Osman Alperen Koraş, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present a detailed replication study of the BASS framework, an abstractive
summarization system based on the notion of Unified Semantic Graphs. Our
investigation includes challenges in replicating key components and an ablation
study to systematically isolate error sources rooted in replicating novel
components. Our findings reveal discrepancies in performance compared to the
original work. We highlight the significance of paying careful attention even
to reasonably omitted details for replicating advanced frameworks like BASS,
and emphasize key practices for writing replicable papers.
|
[
-0.464067667722702,
-0.8149158358573914,
0.3865363299846649,
0.18390688300132751,
-0.26227957010269165,
0.09479252994060516,
0.1896660178899765,
-0.40543022751808167,
0.733643651008606,
0.40927818417549133,
-0.5790595412254333,
-0.2520654499530792,
-0.5688653588294983,
0.3659071922302246,
-0.7824500799179077,
1.094046950340271,
0.20085996389389038,
-0.015372753143310547,
-0.18531757593154907,
-0.4683598279953003,
-0.3510839343070984,
-0.2101273238658905,
-0.761223316192627,
-0.830017626285553,
0.43273797631263733,
0.5184988975524902,
0.8724546432495117,
0.9042686223983765,
0.3865269720554352,
0.27175965905189514,
-0.41190969944000244,
0.19626614451408386,
-0.6243776679039001,
0.1714172661304474,
-0.40508371591567993,
-0.1407860964536667,
-0.9203881025314331,
-0.18988262116909027,
0.7021316289901733,
1.1832298040390015,
0.20977090299129486,
0.07995753735303879,
-0.08815287053585052,
0.9411293268203735,
-0.4568679928779602,
0.00594496913254261,
-0.09404366463422775,
-0.05590605363249779,
-0.0007178910891525447,
-0.2411167472600937,
-0.5179581642150879,
-0.2585445046424866,
-0.014984077773988247,
-0.5868510603904724,
0.48601433634757996,
-0.01862102374434471,
0.427764892578125,
0.08359462767839432,
-0.8055848479270935,
-0.3018922209739685,
-0.8336593508720398,
0.3192705810070038,
-0.5452847480773926,
-0.08194403350353241,
-0.11607294529676437,
0.0011033888440579176,
-0.07208199799060822,
-1.145408034324646,
-0.6452983617782593,
0.1724921315908432,
-0.4833132028579712,
0.4588688015937805,
-0.28363677859306335,
0.02308281697332859,
-0.050756458193063736,
0.623939037322998,
-0.37756383419036865,
-0.16391173005104065,
-0.6585983037948608,
-0.2791925370693207,
0.658932626247406,
0.2582879960536957,
0.14410395920276642,
-0.13149133324623108,
-0.2918550670146942,
-0.43879348039627075,
-0.5390986204147339,
-0.19775760173797607,
0.3299725651741028,
0.34967687726020813,
0.02241373062133789,
0.8049426078796387,
-0.286144495010376,
0.5670152902603149,
0.0230404082685709,
0.07886266708374023,
0.6024574041366577,
-0.7478583455085754,
-0.13831117749214172,
0.3208828866481781,
0.2814660966396332,
0.7947141528129578,
0.08542419224977493,
-0.20905935764312744,
-0.22197742760181427,
0.16889703273773193,
0.42367666959762573,
-0.4405211806297302,
-0.5089641809463501,
0.25560998916625977,
-0.5603676438331604,
-0.18894153833389282,
0.3928653597831726,
-0.47981926798820496,
-0.26502981781959534,
-0.43629220128059387,
0.2758476138114929,
-0.3486141264438629,
-0.5554949045181274,
0.017988208681344986,
-0.6682494878768921,
0.04046503081917763,
0.1629083752632141,
-0.8754734396934509,
0.4785718023777008,
1.1803464889526367,
1.0424797534942627,
-0.47001421451568604,
-0.4211942255496979,
-0.05496148020029068,
0.3780055642127991,
-0.49906468391418457,
0.9228864312171936,
-0.062225379049777985,
-0.671577513217926,
-0.1980026811361313,
0.16495969891548157,
0.1829763501882553,
-0.37549638748168945,
0.5356835722923279,
-0.6279894709587097,
-0.21044334769248962,
-0.524086594581604,
-0.8862011432647705,
-0.3558962345123291,
-0.21564096212387085,
-0.7701295018196106,
0.7326362729072571,
0.4247055649757385,
-0.9594548344612122,
0.24620835483074188,
-0.6267256140708923,
-0.8629021048545837,
-0.1346588432788849,
0.13190194964408875,
-0.3495887219905853,
0.4587087035179138,
-0.18600896000862122,
0.09564564377069473,
0.4198674261569977,
-0.12283097952604294,
-0.16348180174827576,
-0.6793543100357056,
-0.2370450794696808,
0.248506098985672,
0.8126957416534424,
0.06663500517606735,
-0.3064117133617401,
0.3447919189929962,
-1.071785569190979,
0.12963871657848358,
-0.023107100278139114,
-0.021034371107816696,
-0.428681880235672,
-0.18326814472675323,
0.31885865330696106,
-0.16944222152233124,
-0.27383336424827576,
-0.41597980260849,
0.12015470117330551,
-0.3103460669517517,
0.22652071714401245,
0.673576831817627,
0.31579726934432983,
0.7177755832672119,
-0.5193937420845032,
0.3953555226325989,
-0.2069053053855896,
-0.4758431315422058,
-0.783983588218689,
-0.18792825937271118,
-0.5901697278022766,
-0.19196385145187378,
0.33512958884239197,
0.4373244643211365,
-0.23427274823188782,
0.3443583548069,
-0.2081519365310669,
-0.4830702245235443,
-0.25526273250579834,
-0.05507730692625046,
0.6761828064918518,
0.5828953385353088,
0.30905869603157043,
-0.49159228801727295,
-0.9051650762557983,
-1.2026573419570923,
0.14916515350341797,
0.1779835820198059,
0.1509234458208084,
0.08100524544715881,
0.7215228080749512,
-0.4231110215187073,
1.071191668510437,
-0.587611734867096,
-0.39982834458351135,
-0.5579314231872559,
0.46413174271583557,
0.06423622369766235,
0.8363426327705383,
0.8828568458557129,
-0.7571995258331299,
-0.3271337151527405,
-0.2196081280708313,
-0.8405805230140686,
-0.17259889841079712,
-0.07087364047765732,
-0.2693413197994232,
0.36893707513809204,
0.8184725046157837,
-0.3434081971645355,
0.2658935785293579,
0.29925695061683655,
-0.45014524459838867,
0.6154764890670776,
-0.2901404798030853,
-0.024990905076265335,
-1.128057599067688,
0.1488693505525589,
-0.4651677906513214,
-0.2472386658191681,
-0.44227978587150574,
0.05338745936751366,
-0.16578900814056396,
0.2615533173084259,
0.15846781432628632,
0.1650177240371704,
-0.48180636763572693,
-0.6156935095787048,
-0.7860772609710693,
0.25492048263549805,
0.046149324625730515,
0.13672730326652527,
-0.2903139591217041,
0.7461931109428406,
0.2984234392642975,
-0.38406893610954285,
0.5334429144859314,
0.3230028450489044,
-0.004305551759898663,
0.8177762627601624,
-1.0279887914657593,
-0.02920534834265709,
-0.44241559505462646,
0.5408206582069397,
-1.3094524145126343,
-0.5612148642539978,
0.002521724905818701,
-0.5992586612701416,
0.41113007068634033,
0.10314979404211044,
-0.4184076189994812,
-0.1612703651189804,
-0.4184466600418091,
0.2649979889392853,
0.3526027202606201,
-0.3640327751636505,
0.5347368717193604,
0.40808600187301636,
-0.4722955822944641,
-0.604721188545227,
-0.5932340621948242,
-0.1598079949617386,
0.19817188382148743,
-0.5234601497650146,
0.3750687837600708,
0.22851775586605072,
-0.5534226894378662,
0.5171986818313599,
-0.3153377175331116,
0.2757350206375122,
0.3222162127494812,
0.4017200767993927,
-0.00338677573017776,
-0.3532547056674957,
0.197261244058609,
0.28057578206062317,
-0.5313556790351868,
0.14098726212978363,
-0.4960510730743408,
0.4541066586971283,
-0.377493679523468,
-0.20915944874286652,
-0.818571925163269,
0.7106491923332214,
0.5160115957260132,
0.09077673405408859,
0.3360523283481598,
0.2529616355895996,
-0.11698180437088013,
-0.0714196264743805,
-0.1251305192708969,
-0.20222793519496918,
-0.4273511469364166,
0.5054017305374146,
-0.19926109910011292,
-0.4902760982513428,
0.6276925802230835,
-0.09165983647108078,
0.09204018115997314,
0.5708451271057129,
0.4108324348926544,
-0.5293919444084167,
0.6546480655670166,
1.086329698562622,
-0.014980755746364594,
0.3585284650325775,
-0.4569621682167053,
-0.26033297181129456,
-0.7769849300384521,
-0.04933597147464752,
-0.3534194231033325,
-0.4805279076099396,
-0.34219691157341003,
0.15034127235412598,
0.23722991347312927,
0.2760091722011566,
-0.07351045310497284,
0.24233148992061615,
-0.25500157475471497,
0.8808729648590088,
0.7250610589981079,
-0.17814064025878906,
0.6985794901847839,
-0.008684647269546986,
-0.12027483433485031,
0.24255651235580444,
-0.3379155993461609,
-0.5600752234458923,
1.223125696182251,
-0.3030128479003906,
0.43088653683662415,
0.06387414038181305,
0.7580271363258362,
0.5967003703117371,
0.43147188425064087,
-0.4435126781463623,
0.254495233297348,
0.18759028613567352,
-0.5646925568580627,
-0.4772624373435974,
-0.2880000174045563,
-0.7865806221961975,
0.7602552771568298,
-0.09477411955595016,
-0.5318344235420227,
-0.2601758539676666,
0.4852184057235718,
-0.35943374037742615,
0.2757151424884796,
-0.595234751701355,
0.6832367181777954,
0.4333914816379547,
-0.06589922308921814,
-0.25543099641799927,
-0.8446162939071655,
0.5166516304016113,
0.11877508461475372,
0.39917489886283875,
0.3308379054069519,
0.11106434464454651,
0.5461317896842957,
-0.40510299801826477,
0.5631502270698547,
0.1474047601222992,
-0.042941220104694366,
0.18567076325416565,
0.2067175656557083,
0.2652862071990967,
0.2781289219856262,
0.14421877264976501,
-0.5291507244110107,
-0.08420758694410324,
-0.5015661716461182,
-0.6386641263961792,
0.6205393075942993,
-0.5273683667182922,
-0.5607761144638062,
-0.43718743324279785,
-0.7105040550231934,
-0.07068722695112228,
0.5010658502578735,
0.35692256689071655,
0.6630136370658875,
-0.16018718481063843,
0.46939435601234436,
0.35106587409973145,
0.547442615032196,
0.4439358711242676,
0.04831508919596672,
-0.25308066606521606,
-0.5750535726547241,
0.4249345362186432,
0.04043421521782875,
0.4773612916469574,
0.004477049224078655,
-0.12247192114591599,
0.10573531687259674,
-0.6168466210365295,
-0.4749930202960968,
0.2807859778404236,
-0.6279416680335999,
0.030025508254766464,
-0.9571329951286316,
0.17995628714561462,
-0.6149606108665466,
-0.6782597899436951,
-0.7025603652000427,
-0.9986587166786194,
-0.12376251816749573,
-0.6199731826782227,
0.18798214197158813,
1.019762396812439,
-0.5667588710784912,
0.4266529381275177,
-0.5224292874336243,
0.2648015320301056,
-0.10070370882749557,
0.3465428650379181,
0.2155357003211975,
-0.3623904585838318,
-0.17910023033618927,
0.029174750670790672,
-0.29267919063568115,
-0.874579668045044,
-0.09181065112352371,
0.06474559754133224,
0.4856712222099304,
0.24596907198429108,
0.06958125531673431,
0.5288568735122681,
-0.19702404737472534,
0.6953481435775757,
0.024529725313186646,
-0.978978157043457,
0.4982168972492218,
-0.4107508063316345,
0.269738107919693,
0.786264955997467,
0.1966375857591629,
-0.40793922543525696,
-0.4713607430458069,
-0.7181051969528198,
-1.2706360816955566,
0.7289268970489502,
0.195652574300766,
0.2059314250946045,
0.18637731671333313,
0.5953855514526367,
0.09226876497268677,
0.18095776438713074,
-0.5158308148384094,
-0.900180995464325,
-0.2979230284690857,
0.08832015097141266,
-0.34339138865470886,
-0.6892008185386658,
-0.38241273164749146,
-0.28730103373527527,
0.8652315735816956,
-0.19584327936172485,
-0.17269828915596008,
0.4332936406135559,
-0.09420299530029297,
0.018905511125922203,
0.0877917930483818,
0.802530825138092,
0.8707799911499023,
-0.38164961338043213,
0.280232310295105,
-0.1644311398267746,
-0.4715665876865387,
0.1878010332584381,
-0.3165263831615448,
-0.7263369560241699,
0.25300276279449463,
0.8467099666595459,
0.3671882748603821,
0.555379331111908,
-0.42836329340934753,
0.5280388593673706,
0.3669770061969757,
-0.06925110518932343,
-0.42628124356269836,
-0.18546916544437408,
0.3834955096244812,
0.2739923298358917,
0.33177945017814636,
0.20042535662651062,
0.3738324046134949,
-0.8832485675811768,
0.5810772180557251,
0.16071102023124695,
-0.1579403430223465,
-0.49113112688064575,
0.5181221961975098,
0.14898116886615753,
-0.1197332888841629,
0.5006673336029053,
-0.45169639587402344,
-0.5738011598587036,
0.6758142113685608,
0.8675781488418579,
0.5547770857810974,
0.1365857869386673,
0.20676955580711365,
0.3908092677593231,
0.1209041029214859,
-0.22949004173278809,
0.3422667980194092,
-0.22612646222114563,
-0.5622526407241821,
-0.12805679440498352,
-0.010450446046888828,
-0.522951602935791,
-0.6461285352706909,
-1.4258921146392822,
-0.11395802348852158,
-0.18815313279628754,
-0.11730299144983292,
0.3835291266441345,
-0.25085803866386414,
0.23879285156726837,
-0.1535852551460266,
-0.3899616003036499,
0.8647550344467163,
-0.7887209057807922,
0.4146595001220703,
0.9197289347648621,
-0.47857943177223206,
-0.40157565474510193,
-0.30166780948638916,
0.40314555168151855,
-0.1525459736585617,
0.5989794135093689,
-0.09510280936956406,
-0.4771459698677063,
-0.005903355777263641,
-0.2101781964302063,
-0.8896989226341248,
1.4037079811096191,
0.006667787209153175,
0.23182259500026703,
-0.06515935063362122,
-0.3907732367515564,
0.6246252655982971,
-0.4874608814716339,
0.03983974829316139,
0.7252956628799438,
0.18617193400859833,
0.41026803851127625,
-0.8093448877334595,
-0.07801907509565353,
-0.2819194197654724,
0.020372984930872917,
-0.018147800117731094,
-0.7089998126029968,
1.072733998298645,
-0.6395276784896851,
-0.41441014409065247,
0.20651540160179138,
0.8520528078079224,
0.1326998472213745,
0.488364577293396,
0.31907370686531067,
0.6275725364685059,
0.9243525862693787,
-0.16267961263656616,
1.1798776388168335,
-0.13595670461654663,
0.5233376622200012,
1.7343508005142212,
-0.3013697862625122,
0.6258471608161926,
0.5229551196098328,
0.004796277731657028,
0.5010361671447754,
0.1926245391368866,
-0.24471335113048553,
0.6423371434211731,
0.15233944356441498,
0.11528851091861725,
0.08050193637609482,
0.101247139275074,
-0.7664803266525269,
0.47339773178100586,
-0.08610615134239197,
-0.4619143605232239,
-0.36470499634742737,
0.06792368739843369,
0.36266976594924927,
0.34979403018951416,
-0.3590259552001953,
0.8764276504516602,
-0.1402231603860855,
-0.6827259659767151,
0.10170412808656693,
-0.0009213837329298258,
0.4317239820957184,
-0.3888005316257477,
0.03895929455757141,
-0.5542625784873962,
0.5183739066123962,
-0.20322594046592712,
-0.5016422867774963,
0.7904312610626221,
-0.3276914358139038,
-0.6117386817932129,
-0.38872602581977844,
0.38661396503448486,
0.10943979769945145,
-0.4166908860206604,
0.43740183115005493,
0.41606083512306213,
-0.09940959513187408,
0.3337319791316986,
0.13196337223052979,
0.12023970484733582,
-0.05851209908723831,
-0.4147394299507141,
0.06251759827136993,
0.2377604842185974,
0.3748775124549866,
0.5171400308609009,
0.44427573680877686,
0.026258355006575584,
-0.005258419085294008,
-0.10147374868392944,
0.7539066076278687,
-0.7158193588256836,
-0.7461226582527161,
-0.8548957109451294,
0.3648037314414978,
-0.3309546113014221,
-0.4041236937046051,
0.9445991516113281,
0.9717318415641785,
1.2077142000198364,
-0.20476223528385162,
0.774660050868988,
0.07818656414747238,
0.5879770517349243,
-0.4570893943309784,
0.7558006644248962,
-0.436318039894104,
0.010412541218101978,
-0.5377798676490784,
-0.7622103095054626,
-0.39112040400505066,
0.5056368112564087,
0.5667775869369507,
-0.2625710070133209,
0.7142542600631714,
0.6233039498329163,
0.2156410664319992,
0.5605878233909607,
-0.11320725828409195,
0.41685670614242554,
0.023142168298363686,
0.19229161739349365,
0.5314323306083679,
-0.4139006435871124,
0.22367925941944122,
-0.3645879626274109,
-0.35135728120803833,
-0.3255647122859955,
-0.7074943780899048,
-0.39021870493888855,
-0.6810179948806763,
-0.27754679322242737,
-0.6540228724479675,
0.06120719015598297,
0.9824589490890503,
0.5618009567260742,
-0.9847226738929749,
-0.08068834990262985,
-0.0809272825717926,
0.2881418764591217,
-0.5552576780319214,
-0.21571995317935944,
0.711945652961731,
-0.28184622526168823,
-0.68936687707901,
0.2750450670719147,
0.20949673652648926,
0.33404630422592163,
0.0003694790357258171,
0.3402641713619232,
0.09364209324121475,
-0.07169130444526672,
0.6547783613204956,
0.34246599674224854,
-0.5621175765991211,
-0.34099870920181274,
-0.2652057111263275,
-0.011281791143119335,
-0.10100860893726349,
1.2347264289855957,
-0.5441517233848572,
0.37409111857414246,
0.3638756275177002,
0.5925679206848145,
0.45850250124931335,
0.3895593583583832,
0.6827427744865417,
-0.6437390446662903,
0.05819539353251457,
-0.06550972163677216,
0.6913752555847168,
0.20826764404773712,
-0.040980055928230286,
0.7851125001907349,
0.5628834366798401,
-0.2669035792350769,
-1.1103758811950684,
0.2602578103542328,
-1.3145655393600464,
-0.21959248185157776,
0.8739545345306396,
-0.14055146276950836,
0.2345058023929596,
-0.13773727416992188,
-0.3316602408885956,
0.22605431079864502,
-0.09121712297201157,
0.6339556574821472,
0.8234480619430542,
-0.46678027510643005,
0.2495591640472412,
-0.17958158254623413,
0.4031696021556854,
0.18119469285011292,
-0.4655758738517761,
0.1945231556892395,
0.8378852009773254,
0.40341562032699585,
0.5973991751670837,
0.8716279864311218,
-0.3110291063785553,
0.46585437655448914,
0.530439555644989,
-0.22268860042095184,
-0.6667695641517639,
-0.35089293122291565,
-0.45802322030067444,
0.5922499895095825,
-0.3572613596916199,
0.09483353793621063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04799v1
|
AI Literacy in Low-Resource Languages:Insights from creating AI in Yoruba videos
| 2024-03-05T12:27:28 | 2024-03-05T12:27:28 |
Wuraola Oyewusi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
To effectively navigate the AI revolution, AI literacy is crucial. However,
content predominantly exists in dominant languages, creating a gap for
low-resource languages like Yoruba (41 million native speakers). This case
study explores bridging this gap by creating and distributing AI videos in
Yoruba.The project developed 26 videos covering foundational, intermediate, and
advanced AI concepts, leveraging storytelling and accessible explanations.
These videos were created using a cost-effective methodology and distributed
across YouTube, LinkedIn, and Twitter, reaching an estimated global audience of
22 countries. Analysis of YouTube reveals insights into viewing patterns, with
the 25-44 age group contributing the most views. Notably, over half of the
traffic originated from external sources, highlighting the potential of
cross-platform promotion.This study demonstrates the feasibility and impact of
creating AI literacy content in low-resource languages. It emphasizes that
accurate interpretation requires both technical expertise in AI and fluency in
the target language. This work contributes a replicable methodology, a 22-word
Yoruba AI vocabulary, and data-driven insights into audience demographics and
acquisition channel
|
[
-0.4919240474700928,
-0.8299403190612793,
0.193370521068573,
0.010726970620453358,
0.05803796276450157,
0.3907698392868042,
-0.330278605222702,
-0.6158986687660217,
0.1674129068851471,
0.2735263705253601,
-0.5933868885040283,
-0.08687406033277512,
-0.6163954138755798,
0.10731469094753265,
-0.064907968044281,
0.7954607605934143,
0.23291444778442383,
-0.09175749868154526,
-0.07509639859199524,
-0.35335808992385864,
-0.5919512510299683,
0.032781392335891724,
-0.6046665906906128,
-0.1930459588766098,
0.4494866728782654,
0.8438623547554016,
0.7723276019096375,
0.767459511756897,
0.07484513521194458,
0.38998836278915405,
0.0391969233751297,
0.3881165385246277,
-0.5025997161865234,
-0.15699133276939392,
0.0036486899480223656,
-0.5273849368095398,
-0.11424140632152557,
0.03981345146894455,
0.41053956747055054,
0.7067735195159912,
0.1732679158449173,
0.4648304879665375,
0.023129023611545563,
0.7274405360221863,
-0.5361586213111877,
0.27096542716026306,
-0.37193745374679565,
0.03536630794405937,
-0.40230652689933777,
-0.04005909338593483,
-0.16632159054279327,
-0.348384290933609,
-0.030972769483923912,
-0.6097123622894287,
0.17751826345920563,
-0.23509368300437927,
0.31292736530303955,
0.5035239458084106,
-0.3299250900745392,
-0.23480932414531708,
-0.8256268501281738,
0.6896354556083679,
-0.4764236509799957,
0.27591806650161743,
1.0251662731170654,
0.304757684469223,
0.19835230708122253,
-0.3477661609649658,
-0.7551635503768921,
-0.10453851521015167,
0.2547408640384674,
-0.1449209600687027,
-0.12100731581449509,
-0.29956477880477905,
0.08064121007919312,
0.3194592595100403,
-0.3874207139015198,
0.31782716512680054,
-0.692546546459198,
-0.17979414761066437,
0.7678906321525574,
0.14531266689300537,
0.44083940982818604,
-0.22260046005249023,
0.20980504155158997,
-0.1794074922800064,
-0.4939274787902832,
0.27345865964889526,
0.8935331702232361,
0.2948508560657501,
-0.39012548327445984,
0.6822167634963989,
-0.21532131731510162,
0.5489022731781006,
-0.10261015594005585,
-0.3675163984298706,
0.1355847269296646,
-0.5299854874610901,
-0.09148091822862625,
0.1393466591835022,
0.823846697807312,
-0.08720485866069794,
0.42778632044792175,
0.18750602006912231,
0.0980663076043129,
-0.10950356721878052,
0.43862682580947876,
-0.6243794560432434,
-0.09249690920114517,
-0.11369980871677399,
-0.5559633374214172,
-0.08841663599014282,
-0.17399030923843384,
-0.7404642105102539,
-0.6818462610244751,
-0.047769732773303986,
0.20827382802963257,
-0.5957427024841309,
-0.1748141497373581,
-0.22551685571670532,
-0.0861888974905014,
0.09965614974498749,
0.39901256561279297,
-1.148630976676941,
-0.04932102560997009,
0.3785795569419861,
0.7675831317901611,
0.3564262092113495,
-0.2629048526287079,
-0.0964670479297638,
0.10803569853305817,
-0.3393600285053253,
0.45966362953186035,
-0.3350347876548767,
-0.30145907402038574,
0.2758963406085968,
-0.2942737340927124,
0.047196872532367706,
-0.20188525319099426,
0.18945544958114624,
-0.6324161887168884,
0.02150927484035492,
0.17825211584568024,
-0.16431476175785065,
-0.40750357508659363,
0.3964632451534271,
-0.8241423964500427,
0.6238870024681091,
0.13966763019561768,
-0.32172897458076477,
-0.026952659711241722,
-0.671089231967926,
-0.7770807147026062,
0.28462523221969604,
-0.29516202211380005,
0.06232471019029617,
0.00015981464821379632,
0.3127061128616333,
0.022006042301654816,
-0.13472215831279755,
-0.01437927782535553,
0.26396098732948303,
-0.12117736041545868,
0.215879887342453,
-1.2457923889160156,
0.9994034171104431,
0.26400062441825867,
-0.5114877223968506,
-0.20092611014842987,
-0.5456693768501282,
-0.10395418852567673,
0.13810864090919495,
-0.2074468433856964,
-0.17351597547531128,
0.01098906621336937,
-0.0644410029053688,
-0.27605485916137695,
0.42846447229385376,
-0.3191971778869629,
0.2499532252550125,
-0.2973055839538574,
0.6070570945739746,
0.5052269697189331,
-0.11051766574382782,
0.46486878395080566,
-0.12278616428375244,
0.8074544668197632,
-0.27520808577537537,
0.30354398488998413,
-0.2624826729297638,
-0.7760820984840393,
-0.5744810104370117,
0.1869371384382248,
-0.11739198118448257,
0.5066812634468079,
-0.9144552946090698,
0.021849796175956726,
-0.07376652956008911,
-0.6572743654251099,
-1.0106080770492554,
0.7326732277870178,
0.22709238529205322,
0.7638118863105774,
0.4013112783432007,
0.011914506554603577,
-0.21022512018680573,
-0.7831769585609436,
0.24351230263710022,
-0.6268286108970642,
0.17989228665828705,
0.35776668787002563,
0.2747983932495117,
-0.40694761276245117,
0.6083211898803711,
-0.40759721398353577,
-0.505466103553772,
-0.6715899109840393,
0.14578798413276672,
0.24046890437602997,
0.44434067606925964,
0.5937562584877014,
-1.0091923475265503,
-0.5830697417259216,
0.18514126539230347,
-0.5192732214927673,
0.39316850900650024,
-0.03242644667625427,
0.03553232550621033,
0.34718775749206543,
0.2856411635875702,
-0.24772553145885468,
0.516330361366272,
0.6807509064674377,
-0.15423685312271118,
0.285499632358551,
-0.3402270972728729,
0.3971778154373169,
-0.9692395925521851,
-0.05900491774082184,
0.053290851414203644,
-0.10717833042144775,
-0.4418517053127289,
-0.20579762756824493,
-0.4603976905345917,
-0.26105058193206787,
-0.5052140951156616,
0.3727246820926666,
-0.1921941339969635,
0.2403930425643921,
-0.16126450896263123,
0.1733616292476654,
-0.18698206543922424,
0.3170579969882965,
-0.02884334698319435,
0.9420019388198853,
0.06397223472595215,
-0.42319703102111816,
0.3400607407093048,
0.6492681503295898,
-0.5589972138404846,
0.3474390208721161,
-0.5089269280433655,
-0.17516955733299255,
-0.11390068382024765,
-0.21360884606838226,
-0.9084139466285706,
-0.5466965436935425,
0.3998638987541199,
-0.7273650169372559,
0.16213558614253998,
-0.33921897411346436,
-0.20993441343307495,
-0.2360546886920929,
0.07831040024757385,
0.5214206576347351,
0.5201284885406494,
-0.23512376844882965,
0.30155935883522034,
0.8213270306587219,
-0.356751948595047,
-0.7534019947052002,
-0.884728193283081,
0.09957555681467056,
-0.09786133468151093,
-0.5707240700721741,
0.05174749717116356,
-0.15818504989147186,
-0.3279477059841156,
0.29338330030441284,
0.17773278057575226,
-0.3074025809764862,
0.3657756447792053,
0.20688797533512115,
0.02345765009522438,
-0.3780978322029114,
-0.039942242205142975,
-0.16712859272956848,
0.12124814838171005,
-0.05879291146993637,
-0.22987522184848785,
0.6716101765632629,
-0.3104540705680847,
-0.450467050075531,
-0.7253343462944031,
0.4542781412601471,
0.38261911273002625,
-0.26617732644081116,
0.9431509971618652,
0.8256542682647705,
-0.41767001152038574,
-0.18115289509296417,
-0.41046544909477234,
0.11197447776794434,
-0.44710227847099304,
0.40178534388542175,
0.1096886619925499,
-0.5572072863578796,
0.3454248309135437,
0.46817266941070557,
-0.05596143752336502,
0.4119212031364441,
0.479596346616745,
-0.5367700457572937,
0.8435265421867371,
0.9905859231948853,
-0.5591487288475037,
0.8372002840042114,
-0.7492769956588745,
0.2126525342464447,
-0.4146021604537964,
-0.5549575090408325,
-0.7009268403053284,
-0.5268445611000061,
-0.7172278165817261,
-0.5415722131729126,
0.5086444616317749,
-0.13734355568885803,
-0.3271771967411041,
0.26719650626182556,
0.0063063884153962135,
0.5417347550392151,
1.06582510471344,
-0.008766403421759605,
0.3806971311569214,
0.12160972505807877,
0.4264468848705292,
-0.13096174597740173,
-0.9753602743148804,
-0.5136005878448486,
0.7579836249351501,
0.10500767827033997,
0.43943071365356445,
0.35816851258277893,
0.5888672471046448,
0.9106725454330444,
0.25380751490592957,
-1.0520765781402588,
0.29559072852134705,
-0.14708571135997772,
-0.4723411798477173,
-0.6388311982154846,
-0.3577744960784912,
-0.8417494297027588,
-0.4433946907520294,
-0.2554273307323456,
-0.4814102351665497,
-0.08072376996278763,
0.10157503932714462,
-0.2804611325263977,
0.40986067056655884,
-0.6093204617500305,
0.9637449383735657,
-0.34667548537254333,
-0.44157010316848755,
-0.6787353754043579,
-0.6547083854675293,
0.23020251095294952,
0.07572085410356522,
0.6280465722084045,
0.01887928880751133,
0.12344259768724442,
0.5380131602287292,
-0.6798853874206543,
1.013420581817627,
-0.02477201633155346,
0.08883872628211975,
0.8366093635559082,
-0.02421160414814949,
-0.12880995869636536,
0.2710915505886078,
-0.1324746310710907,
0.22369101643562317,
-0.4723617732524872,
-0.5537420511245728,
-0.2965981960296631,
0.44583144783973694,
-1.151671051979065,
-0.6452297568321228,
-0.21270515024662018,
-0.6187049150466919,
-0.27841755747795105,
0.45168203115463257,
0.0232891533523798,
0.369810551404953,
-0.25207334756851196,
0.26985976099967957,
0.5794444680213928,
-0.25257420539855957,
0.615757167339325,
0.08415187150239944,
0.6039870381355286,
-0.5409398078918457,
1.0576764345169067,
0.09864062815904617,
0.18994589149951935,
0.2741398811340332,
0.14502349495887756,
-0.20543137192726135,
-0.6616452932357788,
-0.9994129538536072,
0.17220231890678406,
-0.5528553128242493,
-0.10887055844068527,
-0.1644064486026764,
-0.33123311400413513,
-0.4692780375480652,
-0.36046889424324036,
-0.31494390964508057,
-0.20707370340824127,
-0.25573423504829407,
-0.17310026288032532,
0.3732703626155853,
0.9556470513343811,
-0.32706740498542786,
0.6193922758102417,
-0.8932492733001709,
0.27759024500846863,
0.33821403980255127,
0.17683418095111847,
0.1831255555152893,
-0.45330721139907837,
-0.8401010036468506,
0.3605450689792633,
-0.23202835023403168,
-0.8673977851867676,
0.4636959135532379,
0.3865434527397156,
0.741872251033783,
0.6341113448143005,
0.0319177471101284,
0.8125584125518799,
-0.3949950933456421,
0.9499976634979248,
0.12941263616085052,
-0.8392775654792786,
0.687290370464325,
-0.3625602424144745,
0.19453370571136475,
0.7662716507911682,
0.8008314371109009,
-0.6675014495849609,
-0.3130451738834381,
-0.4953897297382355,
-0.8294731974601746,
0.6407108306884766,
0.09547755122184753,
0.6190350651741028,
-0.08825941383838654,
-0.13657821714878082,
0.24185311794281006,
0.2667943239212036,
-0.49171262979507446,
-0.3890168368816376,
-0.4248526692390442,
-0.34409046173095703,
-0.2609662711620331,
0.09120716899633408,
-0.08645942807197571,
-0.026580294594168663,
0.7427724003791809,
-0.4033649265766144,
-0.15472419559955597,
0.010901154018938541,
-0.42657485604286194,
0.011671225540339947,
-0.0050674439407885075,
0.3428870737552643,
0.5894390344619751,
0.0705309733748436,
-0.13514523208141327,
-0.3533428907394409,
-0.8193703293800354,
0.07887713611125946,
0.04302898421883583,
-0.5276888608932495,
-0.23295807838439941,
0.6797035336494446,
0.7687095403671265,
-0.04732399061322212,
-1.0931352376937866,
0.217742457985878,
-0.043540820479393005,
0.21718978881835938,
-0.5102819800376892,
0.17823469638824463,
0.09363387525081635,
0.4453953802585602,
0.5607868432998657,
0.16604889929294586,
-0.14590498805046082,
-0.754008948802948,
-0.03281144052743912,
0.28178608417510986,
-0.26138195395469666,
-0.21052879095077515,
0.9363888502120972,
0.5682007670402527,
-0.5107647776603699,
1.1311957836151123,
-0.14003871381282806,
-0.33645424246788025,
0.8935883045196533,
0.43221524357795715,
0.6084423065185547,
0.14139048755168915,
0.6757178902626038,
0.36796024441719055,
0.4933769702911377,
0.10957364737987518,
0.06395211815834045,
-0.3969901502132416,
-0.8754492402076721,
-0.35178694128990173,
-0.34733062982559204,
-0.5705585479736328,
0.05223073065280914,
-0.6388216018676758,
0.055073510855436325,
-0.34151360392570496,
-0.2880430221557617,
-0.20764674246311188,
0.32120856642723083,
-0.8589229583740234,
0.19082589447498322,
0.4887254536151886,
0.7826402187347412,
-1.0823283195495605,
0.6458198428153992,
0.7015595436096191,
-0.8599244952201843,
-0.6878974437713623,
-0.09549530595541,
0.01874382607638836,
-0.9724220037460327,
0.4621061086654663,
0.07687713950872421,
-0.017486324533820152,
0.021159833297133446,
-0.3810385763645172,
-0.6299762725830078,
1.0116201639175415,
0.17686989903450012,
-0.1883481740951538,
0.018865318968892097,
0.4287887513637543,
0.6565960645675659,
-0.22087650001049042,
0.3095221221446991,
0.30885377526283264,
0.37487632036209106,
-0.03475251793861389,
-0.5745257139205933,
-0.7443745136260986,
-0.26020535826683044,
-0.2657906115055084,
-0.08650394529104233,
-0.6873918175697327,
0.29178494215011597,
-0.48938047885894775,
0.0006612552679143846,
0.21607594192028046,
1.0679792165756226,
0.03413452208042145,
0.49743878841400146,
0.3217957615852356,
0.17186321318149567,
0.8224771618843079,
0.17388860881328583,
0.8128913640975952,
-0.28419438004493713,
-0.3119455575942993,
0.9376310110092163,
0.2953081429004669,
0.7313407063484192,
0.36019599437713623,
-0.08948691189289093,
0.635495126247406,
0.4658941626548767,
0.09998615831136703,
0.24923014640808105,
-0.20603586733341217,
-0.23198427259922028,
-0.12990207970142365,
-0.7812411785125732,
-0.0801648199558258,
0.6599771976470947,
0.48411694169044495,
-0.008369497954845428,
0.26027581095695496,
0.1659180372953415,
-0.02634011209011078,
0.48164448142051697,
-0.7574845552444458,
0.6047047972679138,
-0.08281157910823822,
-0.509696364402771,
0.008603605441749096,
-0.16597558557987213,
0.49955129623413086,
-0.6316040754318237,
0.04070833697915077,
-0.4528777301311493,
0.054569635540246964,
-0.027141371741890907,
-0.9418425559997559,
0.4063476324081421,
0.4944498538970947,
-0.14950942993164062,
-0.41515249013900757,
0.3674167990684509,
-0.4556161165237427,
-0.42803892493247986,
0.058015357702970505,
0.8221627473831177,
0.1401849240064621,
0.30610164999961853,
-0.3315417170524597,
0.025326747447252274,
0.08344657719135284,
0.06134974956512451,
0.12500393390655518,
0.3863147497177124,
-0.34663525223731995,
0.7258704900741577,
0.3979107141494751,
0.3535657823085785,
0.002906362758949399,
0.03803926333785057,
0.35403692722320557,
-0.4780495762825012,
-0.43608570098876953,
-0.6231868267059326,
0.5436336398124695,
-0.0024496372789144516,
-0.41099515557289124,
0.7845552563667297,
0.41266998648643494,
1.2873033285140991,
-0.21783366799354553,
1.0237103700637817,
-0.5068039298057556,
-0.28587019443511963,
-0.17942039668560028,
0.9262312650680542,
-0.6229588389396667,
-0.15728114545345306,
0.027390586212277412,
-0.6994883418083191,
0.18173252046108246,
0.5291130542755127,
-0.042984724044799805,
-0.20491690933704376,
0.027938930317759514,
0.2548527717590332,
0.21051210165023804,
-0.17269141972064972,
0.22228415310382843,
0.19308660924434662,
0.23845098912715912,
0.3620554506778717,
0.7443345785140991,
-0.44450071454048157,
0.6848568320274353,
-0.4422000050544739,
-0.15197695791721344,
-0.25549814105033875,
-0.7220814824104309,
-0.6780072450637817,
-0.5135210752487183,
-0.33687928318977356,
-0.2588958144187927,
-0.16440610587596893,
0.9384716153144836,
0.5138121247291565,
-0.6143630146980286,
-0.34365206956863403,
0.2356056421995163,
0.4901443123817444,
-0.32092931866645813,
-0.19099603593349457,
0.10551963746547699,
-0.045018695294857025,
-1.3832091093063354,
0.7212405204772949,
-0.060956016182899475,
0.03012111783027649,
-0.628498375415802,
-0.141435906291008,
-0.19638675451278687,
-0.025558609515428543,
0.3812864124774933,
0.8473079204559326,
-0.2287132441997528,
-0.08962415158748627,
0.16060440242290497,
-0.01684468425810337,
0.013192686252295971,
0.6424505710601807,
-0.789726972579956,
0.40748709440231323,
0.798729658126831,
1.0678461790084839,
0.34750980138778687,
0.1667720377445221,
0.5469771027565002,
-0.6279718279838562,
0.47853636741638184,
0.4930056631565094,
0.25001221895217896,
0.4560245871543884,
-0.24593707919120789,
0.5152263045310974,
0.40436655282974243,
-0.3591703176498413,
-0.6323592662811279,
0.22876587510108948,
-0.7459469437599182,
0.03811131417751312,
0.8140138983726501,
-0.03697870299220085,
-0.2006361484527588,
-0.10523158311843872,
-0.0038727987557649612,
0.4571303427219391,
-0.40669119358062744,
0.8540952801704407,
0.45656365156173706,
-0.10563825815916061,
0.0023240339942276478,
-0.7540993690490723,
0.2470749467611313,
0.17720691859722137,
-0.7187246680259705,
-0.3562368154525757,
0.6885175108909607,
0.039364613592624664,
0.38475319743156433,
0.5354920625686646,
0.2379566878080368,
0.21526536345481873,
0.16734392940998077,
-0.20139794051647186,
-0.4529567062854767,
-0.49584299325942993,
-0.1895572990179062,
-0.016610030084848404,
0.0370006263256073,
-0.1924789398908615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02902v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02902v2
|
Demonstrating Mutual Reinforcement Effect through Information Flow
| 2024-03-05T12:11:32 | 2024-06-05T15:47:38 |
Chengguang Gan, Xuzheng He, Qinghao Zhang, Tatsunori Mori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Mutual Reinforcement Effect (MRE) investigates the synergistic
relationship between word-level and text-level classifications in text
classification tasks. It posits that the performance of both classification
levels can be mutually enhanced. However, this mechanism has not been
adequately demonstrated or explained in prior research. To address this gap, we
employ information flow analysis to observe and substantiate the MRE theory.
Our experiments on six MRE hybrid datasets revealed the presence of MRE in the
model and its impact. Additionally, we conducted fine-tuning experiments, whose
results were consistent with those of the information flow experiments. The
convergence of findings from both experiments corroborates the existence of
MRE. Furthermore, we extended the application of MRE to prompt learning,
utilizing word-level information as a verbalizer to bolster the model's
prediction of text-level classification labels. In our final experiment, the
F1-score significantly surpassed the baseline in five out of six datasets,
further validating the notion that word-level information enhances the language
model's comprehension of the text as a whole.
|
[
-0.5068635940551758,
-0.8078107833862305,
0.1957978457212448,
0.10831579566001892,
0.017891597002744675,
-0.06158125028014183,
0.06645436584949493,
-0.5294626355171204,
0.2629830837249756,
0.007435772567987442,
-0.5277155041694641,
-0.30196014046669006,
-0.9776281118392944,
0.18730057775974274,
-0.5014760494232178,
1.180894374847412,
-0.15065626800060272,
-0.010657192207872868,
-0.27609381079673767,
-0.10297852754592896,
-0.6848587393760681,
-0.47481483221054077,
-0.8074290752410889,
-0.5708473324775696,
0.9921205639839172,
0.3319762945175171,
0.6610471606254578,
0.43779680132865906,
0.5379806160926819,
0.36383214592933655,
-0.10645104944705963,
-0.2086963951587677,
-0.646735668182373,
0.2066533863544464,
-0.4182198643684387,
-0.7221954464912415,
0.015891069546341896,
0.3984900414943695,
0.8730038404464722,
0.4379580616950989,
-0.3281704783439636,
-0.17263855040073395,
0.31994155049324036,
0.7608557939529419,
-0.6263414621353149,
0.08811291307210922,
-0.1593243032693863,
0.1582631915807724,
-0.10207013785839081,
-0.5559994578361511,
-0.5162717700004578,
-0.15236052870750427,
0.22296860814094543,
-0.6853067874908447,
-0.13588856160640717,
0.26072394847869873,
1.222216010093689,
0.23075677454471588,
-0.40262117981910706,
-0.2097606062889099,
-0.7481660842895508,
0.5981033444404602,
-0.3514566421508789,
0.44232484698295593,
0.35649487376213074,
0.271233469247818,
-0.22919820249080658,
-0.6984993815422058,
-0.8413378596305847,
-0.2845364809036255,
-0.1917840540409088,
0.2353331446647644,
0.02572440169751644,
0.2828417122364044,
0.39379796385765076,
0.31760525703430176,
-0.5184450149536133,
-0.16675445437431335,
-0.41195499897003174,
-0.10183951258659363,
0.18485860526561737,
0.11082155257463455,
0.5003499388694763,
-0.05784625560045242,
-0.6194130778312683,
-0.5462638735771179,
-0.09408475458621979,
0.4886218309402466,
-0.06940589845180511,
0.0343790240585804,
-0.04478336125612259,
0.5873646140098572,
-0.07321822643280029,
0.5190209150314331,
-0.12257256358861923,
-0.1718607395887375,
0.1274365484714508,
-0.5981153845787048,
-0.19172118604183197,
-0.16748911142349243,
0.919850766658783,
0.2277093231678009,
0.24385800957679749,
-0.10815570503473282,
-0.3074590265750885,
0.043980684131383896,
0.12130483239889145,
-0.9515145421028137,
0.202161967754364,
-0.2630270719528198,
-0.6218280792236328,
-0.4868279993534088,
0.6599156856536865,
-0.6984677314758301,
-0.287234902381897,
-0.3166884183883667,
0.7317500114440918,
-0.5168006420135498,
-0.49695467948913574,
0.20599932968616486,
-0.74387127161026,
0.20430602133274078,
0.14696580171585083,
-0.7074033617973328,
0.5333475470542908,
0.5761640071868896,
0.9530963897705078,
-0.12180465459823608,
-0.6312561631202698,
-0.3805341124534607,
0.17444632947444916,
-0.21975301206111908,
0.8698586821556091,
-0.9859514832496643,
-0.3065745234489441,
-0.060491662472486496,
-0.12120817601680756,
-0.5890020728111267,
-0.4338677227497101,
0.30268988013267517,
-0.5613399744033813,
0.9224632978439331,
-0.31854918599128723,
-0.7362219095230103,
-0.354547917842865,
0.23850826919078827,
-0.5425840020179749,
0.9176742434501648,
0.07954691350460052,
-1.2606968879699707,
0.5164297819137573,
-0.7519959807395935,
-0.33113911747932434,
-0.34027940034866333,
-0.3171788454055786,
-0.11614298075437546,
0.0066309720277786255,
-0.24169297516345978,
0.3093056380748749,
-0.055814579129219055,
-0.006155545357614756,
-0.35857704281806946,
-0.5333667397499084,
0.46660342812538147,
-0.3621078431606293,
0.2321339249610901,
0.020204903557896614,
-0.23120160400867462,
0.1035897359251976,
-0.41444680094718933,
-0.26756057143211365,
0.12032224982976913,
-0.27877458930015564,
-0.7517935633659363,
-0.07508959621191025,
-0.4856826066970825,
0.48167189955711365,
0.02211749739944935,
-0.4071529805660248,
0.21267251670360565,
-0.07748435437679291,
-0.06711088120937347,
0.6160703301429749,
0.4223788380622864,
0.4765496850013733,
-0.7308057546615601,
0.6839296817779541,
0.1728723645210266,
0.03354961797595024,
-0.02926579862833023,
-0.3958611786365509,
-0.468812495470047,
-0.157615065574646,
0.4682364761829376,
0.8060207366943359,
-0.9418285489082336,
-0.0012558462331071496,
-0.08297928422689438,
0.0011125571327283978,
-0.3518398404121399,
-0.0478304959833622,
0.34721386432647705,
0.45555421710014343,
0.31422603130340576,
-0.35025471448898315,
0.001858533127233386,
-0.68641197681427,
-0.20604351162910461,
-0.3012397885322571,
0.1096290647983551,
0.2619929611682892,
0.21489985287189484,
-0.1168341338634491,
0.7489721775054932,
-0.5042641758918762,
-0.1361767202615738,
-0.24273282289505005,
0.6517903208732605,
0.07515046745538712,
0.4345644414424896,
0.3812866806983948,
-0.5268132090568542,
-0.07884375751018524,
-0.27927273511886597,
-0.9464829564094543,
-0.08960762619972229,
-0.19196869432926178,
-0.4358670711517334,
-0.1375402957201004,
0.5984710454940796,
-0.26401597261428833,
0.3097115159034729,
0.45104554295539856,
-0.7388107180595398,
0.4686504006385803,
-0.23729439079761505,
0.6814914345741272,
-0.9774479866027832,
-0.20104241371154785,
0.32833144068717957,
-0.07587531954050064,
-0.5645782947540283,
-0.22433876991271973,
-0.058007173240184784,
-0.0041863927617669106,
0.20853067934513092,
0.37192633748054504,
-0.03871834650635719,
0.011481143534183502,
-0.6938084959983826,
0.3531281054019928,
0.10966163128614426,
0.312144935131073,
0.1291666030883789,
0.9101577997207642,
0.5048441886901855,
-0.8110599517822266,
-0.18081772327423096,
-0.023096337914466858,
-0.11714191734790802,
0.6116165518760681,
-0.671022891998291,
-0.127700537443161,
-0.383806437253952,
0.1665581613779068,
-1.0349106788635254,
0.01054366771131754,
0.1364155113697052,
-0.6475382447242737,
0.6724267601966858,
0.30601274967193604,
-0.558996319770813,
-0.2707030177116394,
-0.43161872029304504,
0.31726694107055664,
0.19671474397182465,
-0.46265727281570435,
0.310494989156723,
0.32123273611068726,
-0.1493784636259079,
-0.6521204113960266,
-0.4435102939605713,
-0.16284684836864471,
-0.18732547760009766,
-0.9057451486587524,
0.04543079063296318,
-0.09121675044298172,
-0.21503810584545135,
0.030062129721045494,
-0.1180570125579834,
-0.34892889857292175,
0.154255673289299,
0.21768349409103394,
0.35860690474510193,
-0.19130630791187286,
0.4218299686908722,
0.24415607750415802,
-0.09118562191724777,
0.32192862033843994,
-0.04288622736930847,
0.3546185791492462,
0.019068168476223946,
0.016528381034731865,
-0.7838819622993469,
0.052526820451021194,
0.46432197093963623,
-0.12577766180038452,
1.2875264883041382,
0.6872921586036682,
-0.21201443672180176,
-0.2548496425151825,
-0.18989889323711395,
-0.6294224858283997,
-0.5119032859802246,
0.24489852786064148,
-0.5889765024185181,
-1.0192234516143799,
0.1651923656463623,
-0.09914058446884155,
-0.09504715353250504,
0.30319249629974365,
-0.27680957317352295,
-0.3182773292064667,
0.8292555212974548,
0.723139762878418,
-0.1861724853515625,
1.0486747026443481,
-0.16311639547348022,
-0.22065258026123047,
-0.559133768081665,
-0.3562067151069641,
-0.5938904285430908,
-0.4058104157447815,
-0.5029555559158325,
-0.24505548179149628,
0.34354525804519653,
0.5847355723381042,
0.09379688650369644,
0.2142346203327179,
-0.17480245232582092,
0.38615092635154724,
0.4988901913166046,
0.23092466592788696,
0.2561313211917877,
-0.053871992975473404,
-0.3948812782764435,
0.012629860080778599,
-0.8917856812477112,
-0.28494954109191895,
0.5398479700088501,
0.5319880247116089,
0.7181644439697266,
-0.10551754385232925,
0.6699135303497314,
0.5581825971603394,
0.2563539743423462,
-0.39935502409935,
0.6268725395202637,
0.16546525061130524,
-0.436384379863739,
-0.3829610347747803,
-0.7636905908584595,
-1.0018974542617798,
0.5031158924102783,
-0.661853015422821,
-0.25266191363334656,
0.08683240413665771,
0.00304710166528821,
0.21361567080020905,
0.02357563190162182,
-0.7082943916320801,
0.9043385982513428,
0.1755926012992859,
-0.6001440286636353,
-0.9488745331764221,
-0.3386370837688446,
0.5953758955001831,
0.09811709821224213,
0.459961861371994,
0.18097971379756927,
-0.17965084314346313,
0.9792200326919556,
-0.47162190079689026,
0.6241509914398193,
-0.4409273862838745,
-0.11992856860160828,
0.37914592027664185,
0.06982104480266571,
0.6673900485038757,
-0.09286563843488693,
0.05140995979309082,
-0.08298726379871368,
-0.12879198789596558,
-0.5745065212249756,
-1.0561007261276245,
0.5644786357879639,
-0.6395391225814819,
-0.4823525547981262,
-0.5593687295913696,
-0.5588218569755554,
-0.16060341894626617,
-0.003309884574264288,
-0.04619468376040459,
0.5413635969161987,
-0.024688823148608208,
-0.14267568290233612,
0.8489411473274231,
-0.29152587056159973,
0.319450318813324,
0.8061007261276245,
-0.314850777387619,
-0.4436560273170471,
0.9852175712585449,
-0.01599065214395523,
0.6100738048553467,
0.5788807272911072,
0.48443281650543213,
-0.3065795302391052,
-0.3909837305545807,
-0.08021090179681778,
0.6120337247848511,
-0.4726835787296295,
0.1201825961470604,
-0.3669993281364441,
-0.08206315338611603,
-0.10014139115810394,
0.09302473068237305,
0.1452728509902954,
-0.5397429466247559,
0.11898665130138397,
-0.36693277955055237,
0.299008846282959,
1.2182120084762573,
-0.1468021720647812,
0.31823301315307617,
-0.7880222201347351,
0.04742489755153656,
0.3393196761608124,
0.4492836594581604,
-0.051230307668447495,
-0.7899636626243591,
-0.3712364733219147,
-0.2089965045452118,
-0.22031643986701965,
-0.9065901637077332,
-0.2467171549797058,
-0.059794776141643524,
0.5996702313423157,
0.586101770401001,
-0.02510717324912548,
0.40082964301109314,
-0.2312057465314865,
0.5195444822311401,
0.2836579382419586,
-0.8603343963623047,
0.502930760383606,
-0.3016917407512665,
0.29825183749198914,
0.5351264476776123,
0.4518810510635376,
-0.6746805310249329,
-0.8511244654655457,
-0.6180967688560486,
-0.37463778257369995,
0.6699713468551636,
0.2733150124549866,
-0.22952145338058472,
-0.16259720921516418,
0.3276953101158142,
-0.009672819636762142,
0.3451639413833618,
-0.9992624521255493,
-0.24640902876853943,
-0.07989611476659775,
-0.13037143647670746,
0.186616912484169,
-0.282904714345932,
0.41612708568573,
0.033685605973005295,
0.7588629126548767,
0.35297486186027527,
0.2597249746322632,
0.33778542280197144,
-0.026783062145113945,
-0.21415013074874878,
0.4019947052001953,
0.8768571019172668,
0.25913292169570923,
-0.19287458062171936,
0.20348699390888214,
0.0015538724837824702,
-0.23369061946868896,
0.07546140253543854,
0.08970360457897186,
-0.1481437236070633,
0.04864051565527916,
0.627004086971283,
0.8069480061531067,
0.16464611887931824,
-0.28851693868637085,
0.7719224095344543,
-0.3292790651321411,
-0.46415504813194275,
0.3524740934371948,
0.36140871047973633,
-0.30219367146492004,
0.4284825026988983,
-0.028010746464133263,
0.24586710333824158,
0.20294088125228882,
-0.37144675850868225,
0.6259756684303284,
0.5475378632545471,
-0.5575435161590576,
-0.28060075640678406,
0.47992655634880066,
0.12081284075975418,
-0.06356578320264816,
0.23231753706932068,
-0.21297068893909454,
-0.3952314257621765,
0.3726564347743988,
0.5476688146591187,
0.45146092772483826,
-0.3830222487449646,
0.34398728609085083,
0.6407691240310669,
0.5152307748794556,
-0.2406294047832489,
0.19435395300388336,
-0.17236153781414032,
-0.5478611588478088,
-0.6610366106033325,
-0.38577380776405334,
-0.1536468118429184,
-0.08475196361541748,
-0.7305656671524048,
0.023031311109662056,
-0.41418978571891785,
-0.09425244480371475,
-0.2106621116399765,
-0.22158728539943695,
-0.26229599118232727,
0.15443100035190582,
0.10137861222028732,
1.1863468885421753,
-0.993718683719635,
0.8425089716911316,
0.7010675072669983,
-0.7221267223358154,
-0.8239244818687439,
0.24543948471546173,
-0.22651992738246918,
-0.6890706419944763,
0.7380536198616028,
0.3629666864871979,
-0.447020947933197,
-0.18058253824710846,
-0.3815949857234955,
-0.8233135938644409,
1.1095889806747437,
-0.22766491770744324,
-0.39191246032714844,
0.03420696035027504,
0.1779589205980301,
0.5002705454826355,
-0.2322567105293274,
0.7087574601173401,
0.032009925693273544,
0.5549899339675903,
0.142214834690094,
-0.8497425317764282,
0.08771337568759918,
-0.2012513130903244,
0.04440838843584061,
0.55843585729599,
-0.6352613568305969,
0.2739376425743103,
-0.22541069984436035,
-0.4414568543434143,
-0.38921451568603516,
1.0537537336349487,
0.02450568974018097,
0.5249235033988953,
0.9131364822387695,
0.6297146081924438,
0.9695395231246948,
0.12925472855567932,
1.1163992881774902,
-0.2513604164123535,
0.07505104690790176,
0.8215559124946594,
-0.0527641586959362,
0.8862562775611877,
0.21511739492416382,
-0.17988930642604828,
1.0863066911697388,
0.3355257511138916,
0.4232335686683655,
0.5573720932006836,
0.28931725025177,
-0.4072583317756653,
0.07394576817750931,
-0.4842935800552368,
-0.38303306698799133,
-0.07857590168714523,
0.304634153842926,
-0.44556349515914917,
-0.15140089392662048,
0.3134630024433136,
-0.15370386838912964,
0.2265569418668747,
-0.3954014778137207,
0.9381616711616516,
0.1401412934064865,
-0.6030162572860718,
0.5025752782821655,
-0.1634763926267624,
0.6959549784660339,
-0.7708207964897156,
-0.046699121594429016,
-0.271725594997406,
0.063827745616436,
-0.1679135113954544,
-0.7641876935958862,
0.1947072595357895,
-0.23929952085018158,
-0.4641944468021393,
-0.20495818555355072,
0.8448666334152222,
-0.6211504340171814,
0.08498154580593109,
0.5880932807922363,
0.4229998290538788,
0.023238299414515495,
0.12444791197776794,
-0.6928077340126038,
-0.27892857789993286,
-0.02874600514769554,
-0.25010475516319275,
0.5611854791641235,
0.8396283388137817,
0.3322925865650177,
0.6882915496826172,
0.39205554127693176,
-0.04148918762803078,
0.2412036806344986,
0.09588919579982758,
0.8516213893890381,
-0.9740374684333801,
-0.3360574543476105,
-0.7111006379127502,
0.3611166179180145,
-0.256727397441864,
-0.0048211608082056046,
0.7191277742385864,
0.5246725678443909,
0.7446371912956238,
0.13927099108695984,
0.7853097915649414,
0.1229345053434372,
0.6732616424560547,
-0.5459336638450623,
0.21615761518478394,
-0.5917742252349854,
0.19469907879829407,
-0.3824198842048645,
-0.5246573686599731,
0.1643151491880417,
0.5841884613037109,
-0.24377323687076569,
-0.049584630876779556,
1.2634023427963257,
0.7777854204177856,
0.14013724029064178,
0.2476995289325714,
0.1572578400373459,
0.04224430397152901,
0.06633295118808746,
0.41784489154815674,
1.1131973266601562,
-0.30724748969078064,
0.6749730110168457,
-0.1605144888162613,
-0.6746051907539368,
0.2723064720630646,
-0.524091362953186,
-1.332579493522644,
-0.4415074586868286,
-0.32794857025146484,
-0.7484210729598999,
0.21076063811779022,
0.7701377868652344,
0.4938555061817169,
-0.46405038237571716,
-0.3458356559276581,
-0.41075393557548523,
0.2484234869480133,
-0.3268797695636749,
-0.3664724826812744,
-0.23304863274097443,
-0.7934035658836365,
-0.39656227827072144,
0.4753761887550354,
0.17308400571346283,
0.2913113832473755,
0.1416224241256714,
-0.2788873314857483,
-0.21790453791618347,
0.2721085250377655,
0.5747065544128418,
0.16725361347198486,
0.027610989287495613,
-0.011129145510494709,
-0.15131795406341553,
-0.42959025502204895,
0.015806952491402626,
1.0025540590286255,
-0.6572890281677246,
0.16339075565338135,
0.7871987223625183,
0.6757811307907104,
0.2966935336589813,
0.23467418551445007,
0.8557372689247131,
-0.5109370946884155,
-0.019080255180597305,
-0.34341132640838623,
0.30377069115638733,
-0.2134782373905182,
-0.21394933760166168,
0.4003160297870636,
0.5805157423019409,
-0.7113259434700012,
-0.4175047278404236,
0.21016639471054077,
-0.6430500745773315,
-0.5694560408592224,
1.124205470085144,
0.09596475958824158,
-0.13452595472335815,
0.1327424943447113,
-0.13795606791973114,
0.3175792098045349,
-0.7744638919830322,
0.8912204504013062,
1.0481791496276855,
-0.1513473242521286,
-0.25863590836524963,
-0.4941854774951935,
0.40016570687294006,
0.7100709676742554,
-1.0415663719177246,
-0.2645595669746399,
0.4808103144168854,
0.1593881994485855,
0.12876547873020172,
0.5214423537254333,
0.21584254503250122,
0.04942593723535538,
0.037126731127500534,
-0.11035933345556259,
-0.13967926800251007,
-0.43848511576652527,
-0.36829954385757446,
0.267962247133255,
0.28934913873672485,
-0.34650492668151855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04798v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04798v2
|
JMI at SemEval 2024 Task 3: Two-step approach for multimodal ECAC using in-context learning with GPT and instruction-tuned Llama models
| 2024-03-05T12:07:18 | 2024-04-02T14:52:37 |
Arefa, Mohammed Abbas Ansari, Chandni Saxena, Tanvir Ahmad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper presents our system development for SemEval-2024 Task 3: "The
Competition of Multimodal Emotion Cause Analysis in Conversations". Effectively
capturing emotions in human conversations requires integrating multiple
modalities such as text, audio, and video. However, the complexities of these
diverse modalities pose challenges for developing an efficient multimodal
emotion cause analysis (ECA) system. Our proposed approach addresses these
challenges by a two-step framework. We adopt two different approaches in our
implementation. In Approach 1, we employ instruction-tuning with two separate
Llama 2 models for emotion and cause prediction. In Approach 2, we use GPT-4V
for conversation-level video description and employ in-context learning with
annotated conversation using GPT 3.5. Our system wins rank 4, and system
ablation experiments demonstrate that our proposed solutions achieve
significant performance gains. All the experimental codes are available on
Github.
|
[
-0.4873499870300293,
-1.034206509590149,
0.7438793778419495,
0.17212575674057007,
-0.19918705523014069,
-0.08003199845552444,
-0.044436998665332794,
-0.4781067371368408,
0.14689140021800995,
0.30947399139404297,
-0.7490416169166565,
-0.2658114433288574,
-0.6161224842071533,
0.03271971642971039,
-0.04532909393310547,
0.885588526725769,
-0.3612760603427887,
0.12081290781497955,
-0.2880339026451111,
-0.24461114406585693,
-0.5712352395057678,
-0.45108968019485474,
-0.7079810500144958,
0.08644940704107285,
0.5394476056098938,
0.7821663022041321,
-0.06528734415769577,
0.015670230612158775,
0.5378889441490173,
0.3382228910923004,
0.137774258852005,
0.25726163387298584,
-0.17848163843154907,
0.24430690705776215,
0.07618677616119385,
-0.22844545543193817,
-0.6652945876121521,
-0.20380054414272308,
0.25044459104537964,
0.10171210020780563,
-0.13626356422901154,
0.18819661438465118,
0.0008348784758709371,
0.5893971920013428,
-0.8067675828933716,
0.13380154967308044,
-0.4381161332130432,
-0.002925978973507881,
-0.16522572934627533,
-0.6718055605888367,
-0.17577388882637024,
0.0418192483484745,
0.09809085726737976,
-0.39917266368865967,
-0.16097085177898407,
-0.000521987909451127,
0.5205091834068298,
0.4278640151023865,
-0.9836720824241638,
-0.5604429841041565,
-0.46954378485679626,
0.6238250732421875,
-0.63597172498703,
0.1654311567544937,
0.23006413877010345,
0.09787847846746445,
0.03831324726343155,
-0.519717276096344,
-0.6350207328796387,
0.3087855875492096,
0.348041832447052,
0.3942005932331085,
-0.14099863171577454,
0.14594727754592896,
0.2365483194589615,
-0.07625508308410645,
-0.6327080726623535,
0.07501780986785889,
-0.37117376923561096,
-0.001463641761802137,
0.4110766649246216,
0.29932019114494324,
0.43931466341018677,
-0.1266927272081375,
-0.47860708832740784,
-0.1471300721168518,
-0.6644973158836365,
-0.03416329622268677,
0.45467838644981384,
-0.005272533278912306,
-0.3321114182472229,
0.22542399168014526,
-0.27524325251579285,
0.06071857362985611,
-0.19347713887691498,
-0.11236546188592911,
0.43674811720848083,
-0.39871808886528015,
-0.2294645458459854,
0.1640099287033081,
0.5480879545211792,
0.4363391399383545,
-0.29429781436920166,
0.3400414288043976,
-0.09517999738454819,
0.2921920418739319,
0.23908117413520813,
-0.9849379062652588,
-0.08628905564546585,
0.36862310767173767,
-0.31330665946006775,
-0.19685141742229462,
-0.3056046962738037,
-1.2901198863983154,
-0.263179212808609,
-0.36204439401626587,
0.9482752084732056,
-0.09812676161527634,
-0.3651449978351593,
-0.1904272884130478,
0.20012083649635315,
0.27117928862571716,
0.459913969039917,
-0.9168547987937927,
0.13922278583049774,
0.4423823356628418,
0.6240649223327637,
0.07575590163469315,
-0.10418824851512909,
-0.48389148712158203,
0.10622166097164154,
-0.07392792403697968,
0.7731999158859253,
-0.6267645955085754,
-0.2967897355556488,
0.024675417691469193,
0.09191328287124634,
-0.06405512243509293,
-0.10845314711332321,
0.6850488185882568,
-0.3750356137752533,
0.3381889760494232,
-0.30854532122612,
-0.18779884278774261,
-0.4630313515663147,
0.46275633573532104,
-0.2988854646682739,
0.6313469409942627,
-0.260149210691452,
-0.5616406798362732,
0.08619794249534607,
-1.0234243869781494,
-0.4522424638271332,
-0.15311363339424133,
-0.07883866876363754,
-0.44699999690055847,
0.08277060836553574,
0.33293774724006653,
0.49799495935440063,
-0.2147376388311386,
0.19420531392097473,
-0.28852972388267517,
-0.2381851077079773,
0.10938729345798492,
-0.7025632858276367,
0.30208930373191833,
0.35956239700317383,
-0.646708071231842,
0.016200007870793343,
-0.8007049560546875,
-0.17069683969020844,
0.011408166028559208,
-0.18273653090000153,
-0.22609727084636688,
0.14187170565128326,
-0.07646887749433517,
0.4383174777030945,
0.2181657999753952,
-0.4627944529056549,
-0.017023691907525063,
-0.09487929195165634,
0.23157013952732086,
0.829418420791626,
0.4529431164264679,
0.3057859241962433,
0.22586919367313385,
0.7037049531936646,
0.39049553871154785,
0.16307637095451355,
-0.5908846855163574,
-0.42476335167884827,
-1.0023150444030762,
-0.05025440454483032,
-0.15930113196372986,
0.4728783071041107,
-0.6944670081138611,
-0.28500375151634216,
0.2733858823776245,
-0.3619428277015686,
-0.09973109513521194,
-0.024580640718340874,
0.43769583106040955,
0.575056791305542,
0.3506896495819092,
-0.3993098735809326,
-0.782872200012207,
-0.8041732311248779,
-0.0011310416739434004,
-0.1323057860136032,
0.20743215084075928,
0.4654928743839264,
0.5524923205375671,
-0.47760656476020813,
0.2694539427757263,
-0.053793054074048996,
-0.19614416360855103,
0.008475172333419323,
0.6465335488319397,
-0.10579778254032135,
0.33565884828567505,
0.3262791037559509,
-0.6582630276679993,
-0.23178011178970337,
0.04098764434456825,
-0.7591012120246887,
-0.38642919063568115,
-0.15993209183216095,
-0.10624878108501434,
0.43619295954704285,
0.3812733590602875,
-0.246172696352005,
0.523240864276886,
0.8077885508537292,
-0.22611811757087708,
0.04915425181388855,
-0.0031537667382508516,
0.79644376039505,
-1.2666070461273193,
-0.13199648261070251,
0.17571423947811127,
0.08797967433929443,
-0.6972701549530029,
-0.3415088951587677,
0.12331530451774597,
-0.20009250938892365,
-0.5973054766654968,
0.0934746041893959,
-0.309176504611969,
-0.18423345685005188,
-0.3446008563041687,
0.1790926456451416,
-0.0911262109875679,
0.9304581880569458,
-0.07319121062755585,
0.7201378345489502,
0.29054078459739685,
-0.6738191246986389,
0.0544617623090744,
0.12590369582176208,
-0.061286523938179016,
0.8205447793006897,
-0.3981809914112091,
0.28619033098220825,
-0.051050394773483276,
0.17765769362449646,
-1.130002737045288,
-0.6011714935302734,
0.3352874517440796,
-0.40341827273368835,
0.2902185320854187,
0.22522646188735962,
-0.0625222697854042,
-0.11147638410329819,
-0.26395106315612793,
0.4130917489528656,
0.2492475062608719,
-0.554818868637085,
0.8682854771614075,
0.6134955286979675,
-0.5602315664291382,
-0.39934059977531433,
-0.409651517868042,
0.14172539114952087,
-0.5639537572860718,
-0.6197960376739502,
0.17990973591804504,
-0.16686908900737762,
-0.07355307042598724,
-0.33815526962280273,
-0.017608163878321648,
-0.01269260048866272,
0.34697064757347107,
0.5436877608299255,
0.1834593117237091,
0.04558215290307999,
0.07948366552591324,
0.3464844226837158,
-0.018342824652791023,
0.3775920271873474,
0.3838905692100525,
0.2545441687107086,
-0.22584238648414612,
-0.5157452821731567,
-0.6496958136558533,
0.5055109262466431,
0.578898549079895,
-0.1220741793513298,
0.244704008102417,
0.8165122866630554,
-0.29268017411231995,
0.09813020378351212,
-0.5772218108177185,
-0.09993655979633331,
-0.4493437707424164,
0.5458775758743286,
-0.3528653085231781,
-0.9492054581642151,
0.39403969049453735,
-0.4704864025115967,
-0.053216300904750824,
0.268704354763031,
0.9554181694984436,
-0.22974306344985962,
1.5264441967010498,
0.5711880922317505,
0.1203470304608345,
0.6422265768051147,
0.11895842105150223,
0.3178410828113556,
-0.909666895866394,
-0.36283552646636963,
-0.4885081946849823,
-0.36415502429008484,
-0.4864911139011383,
-0.22547020018100739,
0.8106510043144226,
-0.18941770493984222,
-0.27472805976867676,
0.08004278689622879,
-0.031203895807266235,
0.3751758337020874,
0.35871508717536926,
-0.03124125301837921,
0.04226412996649742,
0.010786221362650394,
0.18442432582378387,
0.08352240175008774,
-0.3804134428501129,
-0.540596604347229,
1.0581951141357422,
0.5502962470054626,
0.4096428155899048,
0.4789887070655823,
0.6494888067245483,
0.16361238062381744,
0.3612464368343353,
-0.45244812965393066,
0.5313596129417419,
0.3929356634616852,
-0.5268797874450684,
-0.055991463363170624,
-0.17871709167957306,
-0.6059499979019165,
0.27143460512161255,
0.015462135896086693,
-1.0286705493927002,
0.16730763018131256,
0.14100542664527893,
-0.08139242231845856,
0.0060515934601426125,
-0.7842174768447876,
0.9328427910804749,
-0.3174743950366974,
-0.6386061310768127,
-0.4424148499965668,
-0.7858673334121704,
0.649154782295227,
-0.13822153210639954,
0.38524630665779114,
-0.1822168081998825,
0.06490699201822281,
0.7363681793212891,
-0.26855430006980896,
0.8646643757820129,
-0.40673017501831055,
-0.16666632890701294,
0.42790576815605164,
-0.07937527447938919,
0.6437851190567017,
0.14064791798591614,
0.23102505505084991,
-0.11398405581712723,
0.1680140644311905,
-0.09546688199043274,
-0.5207327008247375,
0.6066012978553772,
-0.8222333192825317,
-0.40652796626091003,
-0.33414459228515625,
-0.12506893277168274,
-0.45836010575294495,
-0.28280532360076904,
-0.0025737809482961893,
0.5591441988945007,
-0.1825970709323883,
0.2895617187023163,
0.5319241285324097,
-0.21611282229423523,
0.7620848417282104,
0.5982393622398376,
0.20816045999526978,
-0.4694182872772217,
0.956795334815979,
-0.25512054562568665,
0.0028714286163449287,
0.24643605947494507,
-0.0809483453631401,
-0.1358063668012619,
-0.23034919798374176,
-0.4606873691082001,
-0.16706795990467072,
-0.721114456653595,
-0.384716272354126,
-0.6341698169708252,
0.217572420835495,
-0.293876588344574,
-0.03183047100901604,
-0.4060792326927185,
-0.0038400026969611645,
-0.5525620579719543,
-0.05420514941215515,
0.07830573618412018,
0.5260047316551208,
-0.12503428757190704,
0.2277935892343521,
-0.7805452346801758,
0.07590653002262115,
0.458442360162735,
0.0028644027188420296,
-0.17435918748378754,
-0.47448500990867615,
-0.39099860191345215,
-0.06096433848142624,
-0.8915286660194397,
-0.9713277816772461,
0.5854141712188721,
0.2385350465774536,
0.2528024911880493,
0.4760405719280243,
-0.15800417959690094,
0.9377123713493347,
-0.3182108402252197,
0.9185305833816528,
0.33772629499435425,
-1.0954039096832275,
0.8125838041305542,
-0.3751828372478485,
0.12649501860141754,
0.5061345100402832,
0.27898073196411133,
-0.5818140506744385,
-0.06834306567907333,
-0.49708694219589233,
-0.9246265292167664,
0.7498533725738525,
0.011951076798141003,
0.26972708106040955,
-0.141777902841568,
-0.08345502614974976,
-0.03911488130688667,
0.011362334713339806,
-0.4468861520290375,
0.13498935103416443,
-0.13094784319400787,
-0.4285501539707184,
0.12646158039569855,
-0.6501871347427368,
-0.1712426096200943,
0.2264614999294281,
0.9041138887405396,
-0.3704942464828491,
0.46199673414230347,
0.08891156315803528,
-0.20977692306041718,
-0.39623504877090454,
0.6607619524002075,
0.8579700589179993,
0.3462643623352051,
-0.1817103624343872,
-0.03576279431581497,
0.536121129989624,
-0.14185382425785065,
0.15114302933216095,
-0.2039399892091751,
0.3162698447704315,
-0.4291982650756836,
0.1497959941625595,
1.0212284326553345,
0.46524450182914734,
-0.7986392974853516,
0.7420766353607178,
-0.13114799559116364,
-0.4094600975513458,
-0.45670849084854126,
-0.07592891156673431,
-0.04605380445718765,
0.6808170080184937,
0.22782115638256073,
-0.14000743627548218,
0.6435514092445374,
-0.4826054871082306,
0.13536123931407928,
0.16700337827205658,
-0.2915996313095093,
-0.6163533926010132,
0.6649568676948547,
0.6248008608818054,
0.020873291417956352,
0.21810097992420197,
-0.24535878002643585,
-0.5848833322525024,
0.7074761986732483,
0.568117618560791,
0.9677616953849792,
-0.3317307233810425,
0.09723136574029922,
0.41026771068573,
-0.025615843012928963,
0.14067164063453674,
0.4657894968986511,
-0.2598254680633545,
-0.589868426322937,
-0.437559574842453,
-0.3675335943698883,
-0.845356822013855,
0.03798925504088402,
-0.6426692008972168,
0.32264161109924316,
-0.2282969057559967,
0.008593878708779812,
-0.4123755097389221,
-0.0038033619057387114,
-0.7641326189041138,
0.268584281206131,
0.5562745332717896,
0.27224382758140564,
-1.0703001022338867,
0.5197467803955078,
0.6637853980064392,
-0.2786027193069458,
-0.923354983329773,
-0.2672191858291626,
0.4749312400817871,
-0.4025248885154724,
0.7106335163116455,
0.3639150857925415,
-0.1717686653137207,
-0.1368979960680008,
-0.5226134061813354,
-0.7370114326477051,
1.4391945600509644,
-0.10648536682128906,
-0.6487876772880554,
0.35816892981529236,
-0.30006077885627747,
0.42049843072891235,
-0.5467298030853271,
0.6231087446212769,
0.6512890458106995,
0.31465253233909607,
0.18643593788146973,
-0.7359528541564941,
-0.3416558504104614,
-0.4140292704105377,
-0.1587378829717636,
0.1499621868133545,
-0.8645185828208923,
0.5688126683235168,
-0.02967435121536255,
-0.25263717770576477,
-0.0629023090004921,
0.7607932686805725,
0.32490748167037964,
0.8318370580673218,
0.3523171842098236,
0.5537027716636658,
0.5669692754745483,
0.007176029495894909,
0.6562290787696838,
-0.28400182723999023,
0.35657525062561035,
1.0293325185775757,
-0.4990953207015991,
0.8863894939422607,
0.7120251059532166,
-0.1552630215883255,
0.5956241488456726,
0.8015845417976379,
0.5118640661239624,
0.5699481964111328,
-0.2551076412200928,
-0.578045129776001,
-0.13546405732631683,
-0.2057555764913559,
-0.23424793779850006,
0.8468274474143982,
0.7072826623916626,
-0.23683671653270721,
0.08678094297647476,
0.2827821671962738,
0.08289387077093124,
-0.36743873357772827,
-0.3165821433067322,
0.8400269150733948,
-0.12244707345962524,
-0.5834252238273621,
-0.04785754904150963,
-0.005972496699541807,
0.5062198638916016,
-0.33145061135292053,
-0.10532550513744354,
-0.3153955936431885,
0.009022636339068413,
-0.1104874387383461,
-0.28407716751098633,
0.11237175017595291,
0.18806159496307373,
0.28582122921943665,
-0.12053232640028,
0.7407084703445435,
-0.44012147188186646,
-0.22875240445137024,
0.0770878717303276,
0.4011741280555725,
0.2594803273677826,
0.17071007192134857,
-0.4735630750656128,
0.3760773241519928,
-0.003235722193494439,
-0.843980610370636,
0.4717599153518677,
0.6234049797058105,
-0.11585146188735962,
0.403322696685791,
0.2760518193244934,
-0.42621830105781555,
-0.2522265315055847,
0.3255082070827484,
0.7943418025970459,
-0.5239845514297485,
-0.4015537202358246,
-0.7500502467155457,
0.7035590410232544,
0.05237757787108421,
-0.31342458724975586,
0.41366249322891235,
0.1489616334438324,
0.5559921264648438,
0.07191907614469528,
0.7382264137268066,
-0.16220131516456604,
0.3546801507472992,
-0.6985392570495605,
-0.0452752485871315,
-0.8598701357841492,
0.30641213059425354,
-0.635768711566925,
-0.8638814687728882,
-0.2123870700597763,
0.3836817145347595,
-0.19281016290187836,
-0.03541063144803047,
0.8757449388504028,
1.0249890089035034,
0.09589213132858276,
0.38170871138572693,
0.3666134476661682,
-0.024453848600387573,
0.5249338150024414,
0.9019178748130798,
0.9334287643432617,
-0.504664421081543,
0.5199218392372131,
-0.13305364549160004,
-0.33580461144447327,
-0.521619975566864,
-0.8975073099136353,
-0.6464064121246338,
-0.7178837656974792,
-0.4424639940261841,
0.006284900940954685,
-0.08158301562070847,
1.0149506330490112,
0.529117226600647,
-0.5868135690689087,
0.13190415501594543,
-0.03451552614569664,
-0.18835431337356567,
0.2116166651248932,
-0.17089255154132843,
0.06693411618471146,
-0.4670540988445282,
-0.9073900580406189,
0.5404704809188843,
0.7106385231018066,
-0.1670316606760025,
-0.16341648995876312,
-0.26003727316856384,
-0.09223994612693787,
0.1595180779695511,
0.7011810541152954,
0.31103307008743286,
-0.6701471209526062,
-0.7051990628242493,
-0.3449561297893524,
-0.009631761349737644,
-0.03813071921467781,
0.7833852767944336,
-0.47188425064086914,
0.5713155269622803,
0.48269471526145935,
0.7652627229690552,
0.5677709579467773,
0.03989292308688164,
0.40666133165359497,
-0.6015464663505554,
0.07364200055599213,
-0.07848220318555832,
0.4701288938522339,
0.18496698141098022,
-0.3585076928138733,
0.6818676590919495,
0.09922745078802109,
-1.0035924911499023,
-0.6243924498558044,
0.14836643636226654,
-1.1825066804885864,
0.02441764622926712,
1.0469603538513184,
-0.07811366021633148,
-0.28110823035240173,
0.21069346368312836,
-0.418138712644577,
0.42011475563049316,
-0.39354294538497925,
0.6817434430122375,
0.6473302841186523,
-0.44622400403022766,
-0.5291622281074524,
-0.7551770210266113,
0.048302747309207916,
0.6174145340919495,
-1.1565907001495361,
-0.3675788342952728,
0.7016062140464783,
0.04010958597064018,
-0.048519257456064224,
0.7074489593505859,
-0.10320993512868881,
0.4038217067718506,
-0.06852155923843384,
0.35064131021499634,
0.04959666728973389,
-0.5651096701622009,
-0.45576298236846924,
0.22882255911827087,
-0.14515505731105804,
-0.28325730562210083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02893v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02893v2
|
Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Document-Level Event Causality Identification with Heterogeneous Graph Contrastive Transfer Learning
| 2024-03-05T11:57:21 | 2024-03-22T07:44:32 |
Zhitao He, Pengfei Cao, Zhuoran Jin, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Zhiqiang Zhang, Mengshu Sun, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Event Causality Identification (ECI) refers to the detection of causal
relations between events in texts. However, most existing studies focus on
sentence-level ECI with high-resource languages, leaving more challenging
document-level ECI (DECI) with low-resource languages under-explored. In this
paper, we propose a Heterogeneous Graph Interaction Model with
Multi-granularity Contrastive Transfer Learning (GIMC) for zero-shot
cross-lingual document-level ECI. Specifically, we introduce a heterogeneous
graph interaction network to model the long-distance dependencies between
events that are scattered over a document. Then, to improve cross-lingual
transferability of causal knowledge learned from the source language, we
propose a multi-granularity contrastive transfer learning module to align the
causal representations across languages. Extensive experiments show our
framework outperforms the previous state-of-the-art model by 9.4% and 8.2% of
average F1 score on monolingual and multilingual scenarios respectively.
Notably, in the multilingual scenario, our zero-shot framework even exceeds
GPT-3.5 with few-shot learning by 24.3% in overall performance.
|
[
-0.2097686529159546,
-1.0700377225875854,
0.584061861038208,
0.019773708656430244,
-0.10496547818183899,
-0.05230863764882088,
-0.11293447017669678,
-0.8045246601104736,
0.25996074080467224,
0.05358777195215225,
-0.4166554808616638,
-0.5425372123718262,
-0.6466362476348877,
-0.08402581512928009,
-0.1057499349117279,
1.0974043607711792,
-0.3323759138584137,
-0.1599315106868744,
0.046677518635988235,
-0.17867088317871094,
-0.20189978182315826,
-0.47738808393478394,
-0.8148440718650818,
-0.45322751998901367,
0.9864469766616821,
0.5021732449531555,
0.2518838942050934,
0.32337486743927,
0.3141655921936035,
0.26734909415245056,
0.04121456295251846,
-0.12808646261692047,
-0.6124675869941711,
-0.3832447826862335,
-0.460423082113266,
-0.22447849810123444,
-0.3471994400024414,
-0.0490097776055336,
0.6572728753089905,
0.9176728129386902,
0.08501691371202469,
-0.18250690400600433,
-0.0146591542288661,
0.2458602786064148,
-0.8085567355155945,
0.4908275306224823,
-0.5488585829734802,
0.3102557063102722,
-0.09208919107913971,
-0.3706035315990448,
-0.43368420004844666,
0.11052330583333969,
-0.06150398403406143,
-0.870685875415802,
0.17245563864707947,
-0.2659691274166107,
1.1901941299438477,
-0.24469776451587677,
-0.6604171991348267,
-0.2704125642776489,
-0.6787447333335876,
0.6421222686767578,
-0.4510054290294647,
0.11689687520265579,
0.3199927508831024,
0.2946035861968994,
0.250796914100647,
-0.7124478220939636,
-0.577548086643219,
-0.007206480484455824,
-0.21063730120658875,
0.34582555294036865,
-0.2619907259941101,
-0.10617957264184952,
0.055767081677913666,
-0.0707385316491127,
-0.5348660349845886,
0.37524113059043884,
-0.3287854492664337,
-0.3644133508205414,
0.33017557859420776,
0.2861124575138092,
0.482389360666275,
-0.22368477284908295,
-0.44495144486427307,
0.19689492881298065,
-0.5458465814590454,
-0.016517652198672295,
0.6092615127563477,
0.5195538997650146,
-0.455549418926239,
0.10610458999872208,
-0.38567331433296204,
0.5879343152046204,
0.42437267303466797,
-0.13987646996974945,
0.3914252519607544,
-0.7037345767021179,
-0.07648196071386337,
0.11252531409263611,
0.7701173424720764,
-0.021121684461832047,
0.12337886542081833,
-0.3354202210903168,
0.11638541519641876,
-0.20507307350635529,
-0.06160816177725792,
-1.075408697128296,
0.024685511365532875,
0.019277654588222504,
-0.22620297968387604,
-0.38040056824684143,
0.17727412283420563,
-0.6489699482917786,
-0.10463748872280121,
-0.22406382858753204,
0.45512211322784424,
-0.6096749901771545,
-0.2470632642507553,
-0.041378289461135864,
0.10220007598400116,
0.36376190185546875,
0.42379501461982727,
-0.7466357350349426,
-0.08659615367650986,
0.4847121238708496,
0.8589867949485779,
-0.13355277478694916,
-0.9031612873077393,
-0.850506603717804,
0.7138614654541016,
-0.3030604422092438,
0.8787135481834412,
-0.47725367546081543,
-0.3476775288581848,
0.3464113175868988,
0.35293859243392944,
-0.4179103374481201,
-0.016935668885707855,
0.4768882989883423,
-0.4539448618888855,
0.5871822237968445,
-0.14096218347549438,
-0.44425907731056213,
-0.1467614769935608,
0.6089110970497131,
-0.502011239528656,
0.5719642639160156,
0.033613476902246475,
-1.086245059967041,
0.250020831823349,
-0.5146728754043579,
-0.8578658103942871,
0.07049456983804703,
-0.39514636993408203,
-0.4763796031475067,
-0.27654728293418884,
-0.024418527260422707,
0.5197595357894897,
0.04464366286993027,
0.47152212262153625,
-0.5639790892601013,
-0.3004589378833771,
-0.10844170302152634,
-0.5933635830879211,
0.6743204593658447,
0.09377244859933853,
-0.22512097656726837,
0.07268358021974564,
-0.9969905614852905,
-0.21922580897808075,
0.005752684082835913,
-0.33882999420166016,
-0.35884228348731995,
-0.46165239810943604,
0.26961854100227356,
0.5864761471748352,
0.12410039454698563,
-0.5477100610733032,
0.08604349941015244,
-0.07813864201307297,
0.0828552320599556,
0.49000146985054016,
0.2647721469402313,
0.631658136844635,
-0.10315623134374619,
0.4545629322528839,
0.4314926266670227,
0.07498093694448471,
-0.2778310775756836,
-0.3215755224227905,
-0.3324207067489624,
-0.2520514130592346,
0.28028663992881775,
0.7443283796310425,
-1.2364757061004639,
0.3078671991825104,
-0.42774754762649536,
-0.3027319014072418,
0.09957683831453323,
-0.10547256469726562,
0.5046294331550598,
0.9759300351142883,
0.20220236480236053,
-0.2547687888145447,
-0.09770301729440689,
-0.6943705677986145,
-0.07107421010732651,
-0.3471665680408478,
0.015765832737088203,
0.5493449568748474,
0.5214837193489075,
-0.32261767983436584,
0.4877934753894806,
-0.412519633769989,
-0.43828555941581726,
-0.2564099133014679,
0.7037383317947388,
0.08779072016477585,
0.3676060736179352,
0.7680450081825256,
-0.6906794309616089,
-0.7278286218643188,
0.687991738319397,
-0.8509958982467651,
-0.4530351758003235,
-0.3131018280982971,
-0.16813503205776215,
0.3485643267631531,
0.6898152232170105,
-0.11156657338142395,
0.4309767186641693,
0.47993481159210205,
-0.6597148776054382,
0.4529292583465576,
-0.3970925509929657,
0.3493642807006836,
-1.182961106300354,
0.4963582456111908,
0.09825654327869415,
-0.1200617328286171,
-0.834572970867157,
-0.15170231461524963,
0.20787450671195984,
-0.28648194670677185,
-0.7632899880409241,
0.744711697101593,
-0.4994395673274994,
0.07339529693126678,
-0.18658800423145294,
0.37036916613578796,
0.11800337582826614,
0.7840671539306641,
0.11775293201208115,
0.4734797775745392,
0.7142423391342163,
-0.48226481676101685,
-0.08210399001836777,
0.1397394835948944,
-0.05641995370388031,
1.1083488464355469,
-0.42052438855171204,
-0.1434173732995987,
-0.11942698806524277,
0.2849821150302887,
-0.781255304813385,
-0.13434797525405884,
0.36485999822616577,
-0.377364844083786,
0.6229372024536133,
-0.38219061493873596,
-0.08953932672739029,
0.16687458753585815,
-0.160761296749115,
0.641383707523346,
-0.09596887975931168,
-0.4411337673664093,
1.0647019147872925,
0.18600225448608398,
-0.21937532722949982,
-0.7690790891647339,
-0.7269814610481262,
0.11583662033081055,
-0.009222080931067467,
-0.6275152564048767,
0.39988231658935547,
0.05069611594080925,
0.22269639372825623,
0.1873263418674469,
0.04967508465051651,
-0.4589468240737915,
-0.0019498864421620965,
0.21203017234802246,
0.4576610326766968,
-0.1752476692199707,
-0.0039157141000032425,
-0.04683275520801544,
-0.4275484085083008,
-0.23569516837596893,
-0.1773136705160141,
0.44726014137268066,
0.025934457778930664,
-0.5052283406257629,
-0.4605588912963867,
0.5916763544082642,
0.4681425094604492,
-0.006441585253924131,
0.8383463025093079,
1.076114535331726,
-0.2448788583278656,
0.2187281996011734,
-0.23266524076461792,
0.3157225251197815,
-0.32881343364715576,
0.5427929759025574,
-0.7707405686378479,
-0.7650890350341797,
0.9202920794487,
-0.10643202066421509,
-0.4303138554096222,
0.5887666344642639,
0.45868486166000366,
0.21609751880168915,
0.594648540019989,
0.7337934374809265,
-0.6092931032180786,
0.9219461679458618,
-0.2721700668334961,
0.1799054592847824,
-0.6813631057739258,
-0.15786615014076233,
-0.6308572292327881,
-0.14913587272167206,
-0.49279364943504333,
-0.3294152021408081,
0.25501981377601624,
0.23112753033638,
-0.33497172594070435,
0.20463760197162628,
0.20672082901000977,
0.5743588805198669,
0.1239098384976387,
-0.01621200703084469,
0.41475120186805725,
0.04309892654418945,
-0.23993688821792603,
0.3968575894832611,
-0.8282355070114136,
-0.022463086992502213,
0.6535457372665405,
-0.0160080399364233,
0.631450891494751,
0.15040980279445648,
0.6730823516845703,
0.07643509656190872,
0.24928587675094604,
-0.5199244618415833,
0.2701585292816162,
-0.12130469083786011,
-0.3607123792171478,
-0.39571627974510193,
-0.8127699494361877,
-1.171315312385559,
0.2426183968782425,
-0.16805344820022583,
-0.9362086653709412,
0.5246797800064087,
-0.3463185727596283,
0.005435953848063946,
0.39294520020484924,
-0.6513068675994873,
1.023011326789856,
-0.0391329824924469,
-0.6471443176269531,
-0.14992262423038483,
-0.6704028844833374,
0.21116548776626587,
-0.08466419577598572,
0.3607212007045746,
0.06503061205148697,
-0.000912922783754766,
0.36816737055778503,
-0.12144169956445694,
1.1070266962051392,
-0.05761886015534401,
-0.34153422713279724,
0.10271255671977997,
0.07005572319030762,
0.7520209550857544,
0.07581034302711487,
-0.13653726875782013,
0.5652837157249451,
-0.18293991684913635,
-0.6583850979804993,
-0.4252797067165375,
0.941855251789093,
-0.7941998839378357,
-0.22792845964431763,
-0.17747752368450165,
-0.4959351420402527,
-0.0860070213675499,
0.4085785746574402,
0.35081732273101807,
0.5578250288963318,
-0.6122105717658997,
-0.2657346725463867,
0.42790621519088745,
-0.22797855734825134,
0.6672497987747192,
1.0474598407745361,
-0.09123769402503967,
-0.3492926359176636,
1.204066276550293,
0.1193067729473114,
0.40862056612968445,
0.5117250084877014,
0.04032337665557861,
0.14264780282974243,
-0.3617193102836609,
-0.596582293510437,
0.28806018829345703,
-0.7979462146759033,
-0.022204989567399025,
-0.7598598599433899,
-0.23047155141830444,
-0.27551206946372986,
-0.5326284766197205,
-0.14047600328922272,
-0.23617954552173615,
-0.41359278559684753,
-0.1091529056429863,
-0.1827378273010254,
0.2111068218946457,
-0.31258270144462585,
0.03727643936872482,
-0.7398378252983093,
0.31845057010650635,
0.15927056968212128,
0.4165847897529602,
-0.0256398543715477,
-0.6794617176055908,
-0.4450082778930664,
-0.3237016797065735,
-0.10305251181125641,
-0.6778967976570129,
0.19056254625320435,
0.26660847663879395,
0.6360489130020142,
0.6813059449195862,
-0.14770428836345673,
0.6564928293228149,
-0.5883157849311829,
0.5563579797744751,
0.5670648813247681,
-0.9246355295181274,
0.27502119541168213,
-0.41110628843307495,
0.3710729479789734,
0.5758756995201111,
0.5627261996269226,
-0.7536419034004211,
-0.35734227299690247,
-0.72822105884552,
-0.8395523428916931,
0.8836157917976379,
0.03872746229171753,
0.04109670966863632,
-0.08199605345726013,
0.20492513477802277,
0.04377421364188194,
-0.05504468455910683,
-0.8716735243797302,
-0.12493094801902771,
0.016033193096518517,
-0.0760229229927063,
-0.050080977380275726,
0.01978239417076111,
-0.14495858550071716,
-0.013472842052578926,
0.8141372203826904,
-0.6149343848228455,
0.11973930895328522,
0.2578851580619812,
-0.221637561917305,
-0.39432278275489807,
0.3292779326438904,
0.5271022915840149,
0.5590602159500122,
-0.026870889589190483,
0.2416526973247528,
0.20946359634399414,
-0.3731286823749542,
0.004196531604975462,
0.526122510433197,
-0.2942847013473511,
-0.03922417014837265,
0.8354487419128418,
0.964913547039032,
0.31048667430877686,
-0.20612266659736633,
0.7514309883117676,
-0.007974265143275261,
-0.3157908022403717,
0.2295229434967041,
-0.3133041560649872,
-0.07144202291965485,
0.1715191900730133,
0.09621632844209671,
-0.3393436074256897,
0.13827437162399292,
-0.8910858631134033,
0.17357413470745087,
0.4055073857307434,
-0.7512397170066833,
-0.4851016700267792,
0.43099409341812134,
0.4437296986579895,
-0.0964546725153923,
0.21231700479984283,
-0.2500385046005249,
-0.5035413503646851,
0.7552828192710876,
0.5046703219413757,
0.855561375617981,
-0.18615493178367615,
0.619481086730957,
0.5418907403945923,
0.16996945440769196,
0.3469032645225525,
0.1169925108551979,
-0.06090227887034416,
-0.9474287033081055,
-0.4986516535282135,
-0.29548320174217224,
-0.4015245735645294,
0.040312979370355606,
-0.48179084062576294,
0.2926314175128937,
0.013314333744347095,
0.304170697927475,
0.2674495279788971,
0.19531744718551636,
-0.6372711658477783,
-0.003098451066762209,
0.27510836720466614,
0.4373006820678711,
-1.2777764797210693,
1.0288381576538086,
0.5111026763916016,
-0.9055388569831848,
-0.7614213824272156,
0.061834707856178284,
-0.10884213447570801,
-0.6791319251060486,
0.5056108832359314,
-0.05570168048143387,
-0.04446960240602493,
-0.16814586520195007,
-0.19740141928195953,
-0.6183748841285706,
1.157986044883728,
0.40689021348953247,
-0.4947718679904938,
0.1853107362985611,
0.24275588989257812,
0.6187103986740112,
-0.5117673873901367,
0.4406258463859558,
0.20387254655361176,
0.5732192993164062,
0.3286077380180359,
-0.7564662098884583,
0.04578317329287529,
-0.17914502322673798,
-0.11111514270305634,
0.31379127502441406,
-0.6122127175331116,
0.8003737330436707,
-0.13396358489990234,
-0.36984720826148987,
-0.256434828042984,
0.5230171084403992,
-0.17135223746299744,
0.7666812539100647,
0.22984039783477783,
0.5207495093345642,
0.8087426424026489,
0.14386431872844696,
1.3019115924835205,
-0.6201755404472351,
0.5225253701210022,
1.1930161714553833,
-0.5709643959999084,
0.5588557124137878,
0.4922976791858673,
0.13243699073791504,
0.7185080051422119,
0.2579164206981659,
0.21009637415409088,
0.5692403316497803,
-0.10600502043962479,
-0.408577561378479,
-0.1274987906217575,
-0.24748924374580383,
-0.25456497073173523,
0.012082633562386036,
0.038428302854299545,
-0.1477160006761551,
-0.6135861277580261,
0.06573615223169327,
0.07710805535316467,
-0.21424230933189392,
-0.3271927833557129,
0.885394811630249,
-0.14556743204593658,
-0.2764787971973419,
0.453154057264328,
0.001679089618846774,
0.49978122115135193,
-0.7696429491043091,
0.07101999968290329,
-0.36123475432395935,
0.05092637240886688,
-0.19464826583862305,
-0.7533666491508484,
0.3110498785972595,
-0.2586365044116974,
-0.42996010184288025,
0.15937530994415283,
1.0408141613006592,
-0.8396126627922058,
-0.546543300151825,
0.6117706298828125,
0.7833641171455383,
0.03690597787499428,
0.14813759922981262,
-0.6062535047531128,
-0.22267897427082062,
-0.13237696886062622,
-0.18754076957702637,
0.787708044052124,
1.0786232948303223,
-0.22339051961898804,
0.33544406294822693,
0.5344128012657166,
-0.034553930163383484,
-0.24103374779224396,
0.4496802091598511,
0.7278140187263489,
-0.5987939834594727,
-0.6212403178215027,
-0.577842652797699,
0.3053288757801056,
-0.1977687031030655,
-0.36900201439857483,
0.48490214347839355,
0.4639757573604584,
0.8889939785003662,
0.012317019514739513,
0.7503622174263,
-0.06686291843652725,
-0.1252247840166092,
-0.4252651035785675,
0.6374379396438599,
-0.4229640066623688,
0.04887564480304718,
-0.4542045593261719,
-0.547532856464386,
-0.3897409439086914,
0.18063120543956757,
-0.4323332607746124,
-0.1246517151594162,
0.9696555733680725,
0.6798287034034729,
-0.39326968789100647,
-0.3276245594024658,
0.7845767736434937,
0.1580481082201004,
0.2772321403026581,
0.8404537439346313,
0.5546913146972656,
-0.45420706272125244,
0.7737154960632324,
-0.10504068434238434,
-0.27088862657546997,
-0.14686384797096252,
-1.1106051206588745,
-0.799211323261261,
-0.5429924726486206,
-0.7088757157325745,
-0.1336064487695694,
0.05864708125591278,
0.20437699556350708,
0.5277348160743713,
-0.7604562640190125,
0.025840656831860542,
-0.05860860273241997,
0.33670350909233093,
-0.21850979328155518,
-0.2928297221660614,
0.5530657172203064,
-0.535523533821106,
-0.6835439801216125,
0.17373524606227875,
0.5215495824813843,
-0.058638881891965866,
0.05647619813680649,
-0.130225270986557,
-0.501575767993927,
0.29321786761283875,
0.5932713150978088,
0.5325697660446167,
-0.2906646132469177,
-0.6239808797836304,
-0.4819643199443817,
-0.3881210386753082,
0.17518393695354462,
0.8729838132858276,
-0.510821521282196,
0.27067282795906067,
0.44734859466552734,
0.7375122904777527,
0.5505881905555725,
-0.2412707507610321,
0.2824987471103668,
-0.8760697245597839,
0.4085283577442169,
-0.2398856282234192,
0.6242392659187317,
0.1868695765733719,
-0.5011091232299805,
0.687462568283081,
0.5649862289428711,
-0.32000190019607544,
-0.35948023200035095,
0.32514047622680664,
-1.173161268234253,
-0.48643550276756287,
1.221972942352295,
-0.4287031590938568,
-0.3489895164966583,
-0.2070421725511551,
-0.16481846570968628,
0.4040769338607788,
-0.126834437251091,
0.808135449886322,
0.6627616286277771,
0.043598536401987076,
0.057263463735580444,
-0.09797075390815735,
-0.03844517469406128,
0.09341038763523102,
-1.139186143875122,
-0.1507626473903656,
0.6562656164169312,
0.3278481960296631,
0.4331354796886444,
0.7249734997749329,
-0.19229453802108765,
0.262267529964447,
0.09931155294179916,
0.2682785093784332,
-0.1795601099729538,
-0.47553911805152893,
-0.5206056833267212,
0.4372637867927551,
-0.5070377588272095,
-0.10678477585315704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02889v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02889v2
|
In Search of Truth: An Interrogation Approach to Hallucination Detection
| 2024-03-05T11:50:01 | 2024-03-20T09:53:17 |
Yakir Yehuda, Itzik Malkiel, Oren Barkan, Jonathan Weill, Royi Ronen, Noam Koenigstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite the many advances of Large Language Models (LLMs) and their
unprecedented rapid evolution, their impact and integration into every facet of
our daily lives is limited due to various reasons. One critical factor
hindering their widespread adoption is the occurrence of hallucinations, where
LLMs invent answers that sound realistic, yet drift away from factual truth. In
this paper, we present a novel method for detecting hallucinations in large
language models, which tackles a critical issue in the adoption of these models
in various real-world scenarios. Through extensive evaluations across multiple
datasets and LLMs, including Llama-2, we study the hallucination levels of
various recent LLMs and demonstrate the effectiveness of our method to
automatically detect them. Notably, we observe up to 62% hallucinations for
Llama-2 in a specific experiment, where our method achieves a Balanced Accuracy
(B-ACC) of 87%, all without relying on external knowledge.
|
[
-0.3061646521091461,
-0.9790606498718262,
1.1192526817321777,
0.13951753079891205,
-0.2885372042655945,
0.1602421998977661,
-0.24384647607803345,
-0.4928288459777832,
0.37545865774154663,
0.5196679830551147,
-0.620313286781311,
-0.7051137089729309,
-0.7755069732666016,
0.18927671015262604,
-0.46399345993995667,
0.3107750117778778,
-0.017686527222394943,
0.027706531807780266,
-0.07543043047189713,
0.06289152801036835,
-0.5359827280044556,
-0.5479063391685486,
-0.01939324289560318,
-0.3051181435585022,
0.34714844822883606,
0.3426716923713684,
0.6387841701507568,
0.5666635632514954,
0.47649428248405457,
0.19635197520256042,
-0.12885943055152893,
0.7398543357849121,
-0.650929868221283,
0.2631834149360657,
-0.03657591715455055,
-0.6037940979003906,
0.049797289073467255,
0.08064892888069153,
0.42631009221076965,
0.46389278769493103,
-0.41602271795272827,
-0.01636015623807907,
-0.28171229362487793,
0.4322798252105713,
-0.6047970652580261,
-0.10748419910669327,
-1.0055179595947266,
0.32856982946395874,
-0.023301709443330765,
-0.3058963119983673,
-0.6082198023796082,
-0.5827843546867371,
0.009234652854502201,
-0.44489574432373047,
0.1586763858795166,
0.16584369540214539,
0.7055327296257019,
0.6847700476646423,
-0.19474367797374725,
-0.8184738755226135,
-0.6227748394012451,
0.8474077582359314,
-0.6818458437919617,
0.5832374691963196,
0.3372880816459656,
0.4196009337902069,
-0.4216288924217224,
-0.5725897550582886,
-1.0448112487792969,
-0.538338840007782,
-0.19439415633678436,
-0.3343239724636078,
-0.2366640716791153,
-0.22460386157035828,
0.3270999789237976,
0.07698763906955719,
-0.6796183586120605,
0.026820408180356026,
-0.09024564921855927,
-0.36066505312919617,
0.3775518834590912,
0.14101317524909973,
0.16546916961669922,
-0.22773444652557373,
-0.09472928941249847,
0.15230315923690796,
-0.48690155148506165,
-0.46176058053970337,
0.3264317810535431,
0.1349261999130249,
0.10177988559007645,
0.5668598413467407,
-0.04450080171227455,
0.4590819180011749,
0.027274901047348976,
-0.4302459955215454,
0.37245336174964905,
0.06000058725476265,
-0.056768015027046204,
0.37895599007606506,
0.502790093421936,
0.3313555121421814,
0.07486025989055634,
-0.2673070728778839,
-0.3857785165309906,
0.3404310941696167,
0.4465286135673523,
-0.927942156791687,
-0.12884481251239777,
0.3318179249763489,
-0.4930858016014099,
-0.46324872970581055,
-0.2099906951189041,
-0.9506660103797913,
-1.0620734691619873,
-0.2055443972349167,
0.5795616507530212,
-0.2718122899532318,
-0.3294704258441925,
0.44807878136634827,
0.06622514128684998,
0.5524013042449951,
0.20616494119167328,
-0.7032785415649414,
0.287626713514328,
0.7412024736404419,
1.1158658266067505,
-0.3698362410068512,
0.010872245766222477,
-0.7685759663581848,
-0.1824076920747757,
-0.5898540019989014,
1.0233954191207886,
-0.6079358458518982,
-0.2799125015735626,
-0.025255713611841202,
0.029498817399144173,
0.29550352692604065,
-0.9559534192085266,
0.6926852464675903,
-0.45935195684432983,
-0.0829315036535263,
-0.28949564695358276,
-0.5053326487541199,
-0.5303823351860046,
0.4637134075164795,
-0.49713972210884094,
0.953529417514801,
-0.14999128878116608,
-0.45927196741104126,
0.1500837206840515,
-0.5091999173164368,
-0.21180301904678345,
-0.1194005161523819,
-0.43010735511779785,
-0.45488789677619934,
0.3553127944469452,
0.3449644446372986,
0.3606092631816864,
-0.17704077064990997,
0.49119073152542114,
-0.26355960965156555,
-0.8246735334396362,
0.4405454397201538,
-0.5340174436569214,
0.6288933157920837,
0.05552992597222328,
-0.714861273765564,
-0.14936350286006927,
-0.6725625395774841,
-0.2697254419326782,
0.4257974624633789,
0.2549425959587097,
-0.20162393152713776,
0.140645831823349,
-0.2684769928455353,
-0.017273588106036186,
0.26733851432800293,
-0.5541836619377136,
0.12857267260551453,
-0.4001281261444092,
-0.03654025122523308,
0.6700732111930847,
0.05286325514316559,
-0.20430947840213776,
-0.1402287483215332,
0.3231467306613922,
0.04356255754828453,
0.19858582317829132,
0.16070649027824402,
-0.4721258580684662,
-0.8183577656745911,
-0.21411561965942383,
-0.07873552292585373,
0.47444862127304077,
-0.36191433668136597,
0.8572858572006226,
-0.11643493175506592,
-0.49778100848197937,
-0.7058665156364441,
0.03187032788991928,
0.14590324461460114,
0.5823953747749329,
0.4477890133857727,
0.1652902364730835,
-0.6895127892494202,
-0.8964264392852783,
-0.1886368840932846,
-0.19380749762058258,
0.0384257473051548,
0.26995664834976196,
0.7041689157485962,
-0.6704307198524475,
0.7998283505439758,
-0.6132903695106506,
-0.3025747835636139,
-0.14397257566452026,
0.2111629843711853,
0.2545175850391388,
0.14177854359149933,
0.3680896759033203,
-0.8606221675872803,
-0.06767884641885757,
-0.1150587871670723,
-1.3221278190612793,
-0.29596781730651855,
-0.030758528038859367,
0.02568519301712513,
0.18482650816440582,
0.3577501177787781,
-0.37481385469436646,
0.5382636785507202,
0.6117022037506104,
-0.1593099683523178,
0.49115002155303955,
0.02995503507554531,
0.14942921698093414,
-0.5701850652694702,
0.0060120560228824615,
-0.23773856461048126,
-0.059314705431461334,
-0.6648255586624146,
0.11525387316942215,
0.05977935716509819,
0.39120447635650635,
-0.22082717716693878,
0.33297744393348694,
-0.24514462053775787,
-0.13270938396453857,
-0.4570293724536896,
0.446117639541626,
-0.07619333267211914,
0.3782289922237396,
0.2687492072582245,
0.7453249096870422,
0.42996543645858765,
-0.39003786444664,
0.563687264919281,
0.291558176279068,
-0.7212589383125305,
0.31022748351097107,
-0.387700617313385,
0.664161741733551,
-0.3220752775669098,
0.2657413184642792,
-1.0829358100891113,
-0.28690633177757263,
0.46559277176856995,
-0.38162627816200256,
-0.10087641328573227,
0.0288547333329916,
-0.6965251564979553,
-0.1748582422733307,
-0.3133338391780853,
0.26072922348976135,
0.5294923186302185,
-1.0017316341400146,
0.7377328276634216,
0.49369147419929504,
0.2006601244211197,
-0.7076216340065002,
-0.5578475594520569,
0.4268713891506195,
-0.23495382070541382,
-0.4645282030105591,
-0.015247571282088757,
-0.3252573311328888,
-0.6203365921974182,
-0.37846219539642334,
-0.3574763536453247,
0.0833769366145134,
0.13224774599075317,
0.35028210282325745,
0.22660334408283234,
-0.09029082208871841,
0.011564171873033047,
0.08821036666631699,
-0.01284021232277155,
0.22625002264976501,
-0.15532827377319336,
0.8464049100875854,
-0.16717778146266937,
-0.48169195652008057,
-0.7193640470504761,
0.17583346366882324,
0.6179888248443604,
0.002682334743440151,
0.706410825252533,
0.5078529119491577,
-0.7519660592079163,
-0.3177354633808136,
-1.170255422592163,
-0.39557793736457825,
-0.5191274285316467,
0.4532206058502197,
-0.3533819019794464,
-0.5300194025039673,
0.503760576248169,
-0.18975476920604706,
-0.20104894042015076,
0.015094065107405186,
0.6802054047584534,
0.2679123282432556,
1.3403841257095337,
0.42491012811660767,
0.07653165608644485,
-0.005290862172842026,
-0.15400688350200653,
0.6545030474662781,
-0.6993036270141602,
-0.7627435922622681,
-0.4302327036857605,
-0.26102936267852783,
-0.41412386298179626,
-0.5183014869689941,
0.5325469970703125,
-0.14344044029712677,
0.15124860405921936,
-0.006125271786004305,
-0.6931778788566589,
0.7599624991416931,
-0.03702492639422417,
0.29585009813308716,
0.5665579438209534,
0.0507962740957737,
0.017175374552607536,
-0.21042047441005707,
-0.11648520827293396,
-0.6502772569656372,
1.0011926889419556,
0.3736068308353424,
0.6453014016151428,
0.1935257613658905,
0.5984394550323486,
0.4823732376098633,
0.30074024200439453,
-1.0682142972946167,
0.6258381009101868,
0.18255804479122162,
-0.38735100626945496,
-0.3988479971885681,
-0.336832195520401,
-0.43516355752944946,
0.3587871491909027,
-0.02769714780151844,
-0.7650208473205566,
0.2859717309474945,
-0.3019367456436157,
-0.4564163386821747,
0.3095129430294037,
-0.26878923177719116,
0.5162122845649719,
-0.4869736135005951,
-0.1566752940416336,
-0.4654385447502136,
-0.40861982107162476,
0.5939185619354248,
-0.3875747323036194,
0.25174927711486816,
-0.30757153034210205,
-0.11706764996051788,
0.7757263779640198,
-0.061319537460803986,
0.6671643853187561,
-0.28428712487220764,
-0.5085214376449585,
0.1620020866394043,
0.4321950376033783,
0.8750247359275818,
0.140961691737175,
-0.26070892810821533,
0.32360273599624634,
-0.35104721784591675,
-0.0451451800763607,
-0.9263569116592407,
0.6688235402107239,
-0.47603753209114075,
-0.7780978083610535,
-0.47726473212242126,
-0.6184079647064209,
-0.16266177594661713,
-0.1104799434542656,
0.08475957810878754,
0.0357496552169323,
-0.14042484760284424,
0.0002556523832026869,
1.0345371961593628,
-0.3151746988296509,
0.09886065125465393,
0.6178309917449951,
-0.5164252519607544,
-0.18656402826309204,
0.7828946113586426,
-0.019622251391410828,
-0.14280158281326294,
0.03045002371072769,
0.3869610130786896,
-0.629206120967865,
-0.7396007180213928,
-0.22521723806858063,
0.598747968673706,
-0.8666139841079712,
-0.014223163947463036,
-0.9614155888557434,
-0.17382530868053436,
-0.3330184817314148,
0.00739854434505105,
-0.3254513740539551,
0.1113760769367218,
-0.24455125629901886,
-0.29551106691360474,
0.3565831184387207,
0.8272682428359985,
-0.0884333997964859,
0.212955504655838,
-0.34218069911003113,
0.8102317452430725,
0.4354608654975891,
0.19113454222679138,
-0.16796354949474335,
-1.0136295557022095,
0.11181727051734924,
0.0673334002494812,
-0.11078238487243652,
-1.0038323402404785,
0.5147477388381958,
-0.15362393856048584,
0.4883142411708832,
0.6273238062858582,
0.10894377529621124,
0.7227358818054199,
-0.14968325197696686,
0.6262176036834717,
-0.1586543768644333,
-1.1049374341964722,
0.460265576839447,
0.16459283232688904,
-0.26293155550956726,
0.44347184896469116,
0.5415814518928528,
-0.6366518139839172,
-0.32368573546409607,
-0.18999724090099335,
-0.24571332335472107,
0.4588632881641388,
0.19328506290912628,
0.07287263870239258,
0.13403987884521484,
0.5123006105422974,
0.3022174835205078,
0.343580424785614,
-0.768057644367218,
-0.18493488430976868,
0.027429981157183647,
-0.18026120960712433,
0.2134086787700653,
-0.3921038508415222,
-0.11736030876636505,
-0.3941894769668579,
0.5754587650299072,
-0.051281560212373734,
0.15250729024410248,
0.15306100249290466,
-0.2797931432723999,
-0.19687871634960175,
-0.2058250457048416,
0.6989433169364929,
0.7270104289054871,
-0.3651611804962158,
0.40291473269462585,
0.42932555079460144,
-0.5135496258735657,
0.25959235429763794,
-0.3415803909301758,
-0.12570396065711975,
0.36173778772354126,
0.30394378304481506,
0.7218190431594849,
-0.07510031759738922,
-1.1314764022827148,
0.6738222241401672,
0.004571067169308662,
-0.21035632491111755,
-0.5795024037361145,
-0.062154702842235565,
-0.1909145563840866,
0.4450978636741638,
0.4693087041378021,
-0.20111624896526337,
0.3926272690296173,
-0.6838402152061462,
0.29476121068000793,
0.47949984669685364,
-0.39855068922042847,
-0.19540318846702576,
0.4262023866176605,
-0.2564161717891693,
-0.4157938063144684,
0.7265238165855408,
-0.5297601222991943,
-0.9545276761054993,
0.4481252431869507,
0.5497589707374573,
0.961338996887207,
-0.37158769369125366,
0.30066293478012085,
0.20370405912399292,
0.44268330931663513,
-0.31825894117355347,
0.28561675548553467,
0.21669937670230865,
-0.9000737071037292,
-0.3088003993034363,
-0.7120957374572754,
-0.3949381113052368,
0.577736496925354,
-0.39293715357780457,
0.39510172605514526,
-0.2997668981552124,
0.15852662920951843,
-0.17177677154541016,
-0.04265320673584938,
-0.13249623775482178,
-0.05024132877588272,
0.573166012763977,
0.568123996257782,
-0.7208312749862671,
0.6515682339668274,
-0.10449184477329254,
0.019641004502773285,
-0.3943076729774475,
0.36077451705932617,
0.1982242465019226,
-1.0140317678451538,
0.5343109965324402,
0.6146854162216187,
-0.5395147204399109,
-0.11940603703260422,
-0.9122982025146484,
-0.6207494735717773,
0.8917348980903625,
0.5438709855079651,
-0.5910323262214661,
-0.05275863781571388,
0.12370483577251434,
0.4801776707172394,
-0.4275943338871002,
0.1367424726486206,
1.2557294368743896,
0.8608866930007935,
0.2526838779449463,
-0.5542197823524475,
0.17491064965724945,
-0.006654044613242149,
-0.3995738923549652,
-0.0036320649087429047,
-0.46356913447380066,
0.5762258768081665,
-0.4009445607662201,
-0.26219257712364197,
0.046563707292079926,
0.7010095715522766,
0.5813950300216675,
0.4123654365539551,
0.7916147708892822,
0.2370077222585678,
1.2387181520462036,
0.09260380268096924,
0.4253717362880707,
-0.20398634672164917,
0.22115692496299744,
0.8675588369369507,
-0.6635395288467407,
0.6145927309989929,
0.529171347618103,
0.18598929047584534,
0.5970278978347778,
0.4789484143257141,
-0.25198855996131897,
0.5829071998596191,
0.569426417350769,
-0.33484748005867004,
-0.5388354063034058,
-0.3948206901550293,
-0.20750375092029572,
0.5195924043655396,
0.6043443083763123,
0.018192119896411896,
0.046529460698366165,
0.19407303631305695,
0.12615296244621277,
0.25114706158638,
0.10091099143028259,
0.6275681853294373,
-0.07710689306259155,
-0.5991541147232056,
0.9923844337463379,
-0.23644255101680756,
0.7930961847305298,
-0.3363026976585388,
-0.4640820622444153,
-0.3867599368095398,
0.0052212816663086414,
-0.19550621509552002,
-0.5042253136634827,
0.20668166875839233,
0.2537088692188263,
0.20807819068431854,
0.2334616482257843,
0.35241684317588806,
-0.33667901158332825,
-0.5671511888504028,
0.6614100933074951,
0.39181891083717346,
0.5120306611061096,
-0.46885862946510315,
-0.16217397153377533,
0.5345610976219177,
0.0902564525604248,
-0.06476365029811859,
-0.14398998022079468,
0.49296149611473083,
0.09399435669183731,
0.803562343120575,
0.4631728529930115,
0.10905672609806061,
0.11994171887636185,
-0.07927147299051285,
0.705022931098938,
-0.5230199098587036,
-0.24569661915302277,
-0.9960114359855652,
0.01707860827445984,
-0.16384316980838776,
-0.044842448085546494,
0.565742015838623,
0.6927121877670288,
0.6152336597442627,
0.11584331840276718,
0.9084903001785278,
0.19118553400039673,
0.5747318267822266,
-0.561514675617218,
0.6683971285820007,
-0.6670932173728943,
0.5248122811317444,
-0.0635172575712204,
-0.8623376488685608,
-0.3868711590766907,
0.9968713521957397,
-0.2914849817752838,
-0.35752931237220764,
0.8438323140144348,
1.4302457571029663,
-0.007252593524754047,
0.24612978100776672,
0.5023871064186096,
0.5770941376686096,
0.3012916147708893,
0.3295265734195709,
1.2352550029754639,
-0.3396640419960022,
0.4540480971336365,
-0.15995781123638153,
-0.2668333053588867,
-0.42381393909454346,
-0.6984706521034241,
-0.994204044342041,
-0.520452618598938,
-0.10099299252033234,
-0.3696761429309845,
0.13056430220603943,
1.0458824634552002,
0.4363403022289276,
-0.9602062106132507,
-0.309260755777359,
0.16828343272209167,
0.2681959569454193,
-0.18948645889759064,
-0.13376449048519135,
0.3647743761539459,
-0.21120648086071014,
-0.676833987236023,
0.8693385720252991,
0.25403857231140137,
-0.014950682409107685,
-0.5751746892929077,
-0.28669777512550354,
-0.07928895950317383,
0.38222771883010864,
0.38032448291778564,
-0.23523560166358948,
-1.0516661405563354,
-0.4506654441356659,
0.1707361936569214,
-0.06784245371818542,
0.20741187036037445,
0.7627276182174683,
-0.931159496307373,
0.42747512459754944,
0.25690045952796936,
0.5084154009819031,
0.43126189708709717,
-0.1847047060728073,
0.15146100521087646,
-0.395674467086792,
0.2755598723888397,
0.3983697295188904,
0.10505448281764984,
0.3179754316806793,
-0.5237002968788147,
0.5885805487632751,
0.4747794568538666,
-0.36874324083328247,
-1.436638593673706,
0.011524195782840252,
-0.9410234093666077,
-0.26959070563316345,
1.0835756063461304,
0.3242063820362091,
-0.09320961683988571,
-0.3946903347969055,
-0.3891235291957855,
0.28319597244262695,
-0.2581036388874054,
1.473007082939148,
0.5609316229820251,
0.018942054361104965,
0.06084281578660011,
-0.631705105304718,
0.4719443619251251,
0.2095593512058258,
-0.8260651230812073,
0.3813226819038391,
0.44454920291900635,
-0.08998412638902664,
0.3900810480117798,
0.10580603778362274,
0.11866014450788498,
0.11187989264726639,
-0.07989729940891266,
0.12075713276863098,
0.06963568180799484,
-0.6905493140220642,
-0.36861762404441833,
0.1898168921470642,
-0.173023983836174,
-0.004365148488432169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02884v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02884v1
|
MathScale: Scaling Instruction Tuning for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-03-05T11:42:59 | 2024-03-05T11:42:59 |
Zhengyang Tang, Xingxing Zhang, Benyou Wang, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
problem-solving. However, their proficiency in solving mathematical problems
remains inadequate. We propose MathScale, a simple and scalable method to
create high-quality mathematical reasoning data using frontier LLMs (e.g., {\tt
GPT-3.5}). Inspired by the cognitive mechanism in human mathematical learning,
it first extracts topics and knowledge points from seed math questions and then
build a concept graph, which is subsequently used to generate new math
questions. MathScale exhibits effective scalability along the size axis of the
math dataset that we generate. As a result, we create a mathematical reasoning
dataset (MathScaleQA) containing two million math question-answer pairs. To
evaluate mathematical reasoning abilities of LLMs comprehensively, we construct
{\sc MwpBench}, a benchmark of Math Word Problems, which is a collection of ten
datasets (including GSM8K and MATH) covering K-12, college, and competition
level math problems. We apply MathScaleQA to fine-tune open-source LLMs (e.g.,
LLaMA-2 and Mistral), resulting in significantly improved capabilities in
mathematical reasoning. Evaluated on {\sc MwpBench}, MathScale-7B achieves
state-of-the-art performance across all datasets, surpassing its best peers of
equivalent size by 42.9\% in micro average accuracy and 43.7\% in macro average
accuracy, respectively.
|
[
-0.5361244678497314,
-0.9282016754150391,
0.6110602617263794,
0.3972003757953644,
-0.002321857726201415,
0.08119484037160873,
-0.3271532654762268,
0.17855434119701385,
-0.10088260471820831,
0.4442339837551117,
-0.8526132702827454,
-0.520698070526123,
-0.4217657744884491,
-0.17216797173023224,
0.005782910156995058,
0.8776580095291138,
0.09870966523885727,
0.1354629099369049,
-0.6381189227104187,
-0.22691766917705536,
-0.335856556892395,
-0.3259776532649994,
-0.9229994416236877,
-0.36987990140914917,
0.27249976992607117,
0.5854642987251282,
0.9675396680831909,
0.9194736480712891,
0.622765839099884,
0.36074426770210266,
-0.1439930647611618,
0.41341152787208557,
-0.5537281036376953,
-0.1323002576828003,
-0.3733002543449402,
-0.6526916027069092,
-0.8692920207977295,
0.004051665775477886,
0.5999507904052734,
0.8721985220909119,
-0.2860891819000244,
0.42392653226852417,
-0.043950192630290985,
0.684950053691864,
-0.2989957332611084,
0.19738416373729706,
-0.6882266402244568,
-0.10171041637659073,
-0.227484792470932,
-0.06708203256130219,
-0.2996505796909332,
-0.7419373989105225,
-0.2701582610607147,
-0.9299244284629822,
0.1660120040178299,
0.04493192955851555,
0.6236766576766968,
0.4168334901332855,
-0.3227458894252777,
-0.3343881666660309,
-0.355612188577652,
1.0167083740234375,
-0.7463234066963196,
0.23590174317359924,
0.4826773405075073,
0.6110921502113342,
-0.19935275614261627,
-0.776787281036377,
-0.28721529245376587,
0.03686414286494255,
0.2277156561613083,
-0.1563134789466858,
-0.30459895730018616,
-0.10261354595422745,
0.7362314462661743,
0.5853768587112427,
-0.5552111864089966,
0.06600756198167801,
-0.1508602648973465,
-0.3898693025112152,
0.5676352977752686,
0.48588526248931885,
0.16568322479724884,
0.1719246655702591,
0.2135755568742752,
-0.2563324570655823,
-0.7871047258377075,
-0.08385571092367172,
0.1384037286043167,
0.17727234959602356,
0.13275858759880066,
0.688016414642334,
-0.1753273755311966,
0.7856358289718628,
0.007701308466494083,
-0.5008167624473572,
0.09284672886133194,
-0.2476876676082611,
-0.1454971730709076,
-0.3277006149291992,
0.44776222109794617,
0.3078424036502838,
0.447439968585968,
0.2227606475353241,
-0.2716287672519684,
0.09009841084480286,
0.06537210941314697,
-0.9255974292755127,
-0.3979347348213196,
-0.01043700985610485,
-0.005291590932756662,
-0.07105936110019684,
-0.3810560703277588,
-0.8558061122894287,
-0.33486849069595337,
-0.6470741629600525,
0.6906570196151733,
-0.42946746945381165,
0.06881586462259293,
-0.021895144134759903,
0.013876440934836864,
-0.0785893052816391,
0.406729519367218,
-0.8030599355697632,
0.43358683586120605,
0.6739961504936218,
0.7442190051078796,
-0.028794938698410988,
-0.12780845165252686,
-0.5504122376441956,
-0.20716282725334167,
-0.5345731377601624,
0.7453761696815491,
-0.47085997462272644,
-0.33352211117744446,
-0.15315742790699005,
-0.2853046655654907,
0.13891781866550446,
-0.8247832655906677,
0.594860315322876,
-0.3215024769306183,
-0.033371709287166595,
-0.49584344029426575,
-0.6050163507461548,
0.07825659215450287,
0.2950497269630432,
-0.5568710565567017,
1.1480962038040161,
0.32260632514953613,
-0.35439398884773254,
0.17006316781044006,
-0.6537580490112305,
-0.2587207555770874,
0.08031877875328064,
-0.17787706851959229,
-0.4435441493988037,
0.11884259432554245,
0.7236635088920593,
0.13340510427951813,
-0.5852619409561157,
0.10137049108743668,
-0.21993684768676758,
-0.20493146777153015,
0.3058602511882782,
-0.4668722450733185,
0.6002992987632751,
0.20838119089603424,
-0.2097623348236084,
0.08231242746114731,
-0.6661829948425293,
0.5547530055046082,
0.20044690370559692,
-0.03229719400405884,
-0.05270370841026306,
-0.022170109674334526,
-0.4240383207798004,
0.00033815146889537573,
0.4334091544151306,
-0.5372397303581238,
0.20108212530612946,
-0.1513736993074417,
0.7069665789604187,
0.7801814079284668,
-0.1300298422574997,
0.49236637353897095,
-0.5350984334945679,
0.5456914305686951,
-0.3034101724624634,
0.12719666957855225,
-0.012584581971168518,
-0.4316868185997009,
-0.8515980243682861,
-0.3957277536392212,
0.22527268528938293,
0.5269308090209961,
-0.8017125725746155,
0.17942190170288086,
-0.34756994247436523,
-0.5692049860954285,
-0.17862848937511444,
0.2451765537261963,
0.3730835020542145,
0.5759634971618652,
0.43571457266807556,
0.48629435896873474,
-0.1960522085428238,
-0.9426103234291077,
-0.31663206219673157,
0.2927054166793823,
-0.4348963499069214,
0.5771871209144592,
0.3205747604370117,
0.030297894030809402,
1.0472854375839233,
-0.9896043539047241,
-0.2489757388830185,
-0.08311983942985535,
0.09004893898963928,
0.37096306681632996,
0.2624390721321106,
0.30302414298057556,
-0.4868181347846985,
-0.34659746289253235,
-0.021667122840881348,
-0.4934355616569519,
-0.5997108817100525,
0.03646232187747955,
-0.3681877553462982,
-0.11478961259126663,
0.5368674397468567,
-0.29175102710723877,
0.11438044160604477,
0.5073121190071106,
-0.3925356864929199,
0.4636685848236084,
-0.2917535901069641,
0.07185050845146179,
-1.0170060396194458,
-0.3610941767692566,
0.14091075956821442,
0.018838055431842804,
-0.19373778998851776,
0.04809398576617241,
0.25686073303222656,
-0.30229896306991577,
-0.04879432171583176,
0.48946818709373474,
-0.16087575256824493,
-0.0684373527765274,
-0.04316325485706329,
0.3120897114276886,
-0.07057424634695053,
0.4660617709159851,
-0.25733864307403564,
1.2070120573043823,
0.2944800555706024,
-0.47588303685188293,
0.3419376015663147,
-0.038202255964279175,
-0.1993253231048584,
0.8804008960723877,
-0.6996720433235168,
-0.005414227955043316,
0.21877706050872803,
0.17594949901103973,
-0.7837331295013428,
-0.20165495574474335,
-0.3597981333732605,
-0.5543636083602905,
-0.03576742485165596,
-0.09797397255897522,
-0.5561740398406982,
-0.31120967864990234,
-0.13878639042377472,
0.6023208498954773,
0.5990786552429199,
-0.6526884436607361,
0.68569016456604,
0.32799792289733887,
-0.4176208972930908,
-0.2179894894361496,
-0.5679930448532104,
-0.1483457386493683,
-0.1381039321422577,
-0.7460519075393677,
-0.07333903014659882,
-0.18204265832901,
-0.3497438430786133,
-0.0036171050742268562,
-0.35348406434059143,
-0.34708043932914734,
-0.18435293436050415,
0.11918823421001434,
0.4343697130680084,
-0.4454573094844818,
0.287349134683609,
0.5059622526168823,
-0.16953419148921967,
0.32917654514312744,
-0.46425947546958923,
0.3143406808376312,
-0.4943777024745941,
-0.31120315194129944,
0.18049265444278717,
0.0906733050942421,
0.70896977186203,
-0.3750966489315033,
0.2931276857852936,
0.3661573827266693,
-0.45617276430130005,
-0.6759558320045471,
-0.4240175783634186,
-0.16777604818344116,
-0.5293899774551392,
0.32517102360725403,
-0.516579806804657,
-1.1146774291992188,
0.3010959029197693,
-0.524265468120575,
0.2589857578277588,
0.5440805554389954,
0.6872051954269409,
0.13303135335445404,
1.0357568264007568,
0.2417757511138916,
0.13546845316886902,
0.16070303320884705,
-0.35261037945747375,
0.062152594327926636,
-0.7780081629753113,
-0.06495401263237,
-0.4281579554080963,
-0.3132646381855011,
-0.4024238884449005,
-0.8230220079421997,
0.6633221507072449,
0.1069454699754715,
-0.5517356991767883,
0.2688879370689392,
-0.6793168187141418,
0.9148015975952148,
0.45585697889328003,
0.16072756052017212,
0.23910288512706757,
0.2322980910539627,
-0.3557775318622589,
-0.5338344573974609,
-0.6936136484146118,
-0.28227123618125916,
1.2627909183502197,
0.07239823043346405,
0.7828302383422852,
0.1680343896150589,
0.39005765318870544,
0.07512406259775162,
0.28799694776535034,
-0.8207307457923889,
0.6351974606513977,
-0.19571071863174438,
-0.5209186673164368,
-0.5759584903717041,
-0.9234343767166138,
-0.7879632115364075,
0.3099733591079712,
-0.13413694500923157,
-0.6575493812561035,
-0.4432147145271301,
0.1861625760793686,
-0.18367548286914825,
0.33498308062553406,
-0.6559946537017822,
0.7283395528793335,
-0.1063590943813324,
-0.44491827487945557,
-0.35725194215774536,
-0.015012511983513832,
0.44394686818122864,
-0.18694187700748444,
0.5200056433677673,
-0.21687808632850647,
-0.12822461128234863,
0.5860316753387451,
-0.7922746539115906,
0.5366542339324951,
0.05727697163820267,
-0.17664243280887604,
0.30498698353767395,
0.5472778081893921,
0.23868168890476227,
0.34078511595726013,
0.08528699725866318,
0.20899684727191925,
0.11709065735340118,
-0.49667447805404663,
-0.9249135851860046,
0.9144425988197327,
-0.7747425436973572,
-0.5836640000343323,
-0.2050008624792099,
-1.1951204538345337,
-0.6370471715927124,
0.10252455621957779,
0.06646225601434708,
0.8230516910552979,
0.26794400811195374,
0.16805756092071533,
1.0209139585494995,
-0.0004752464883495122,
0.2153298705816269,
0.3005679249763489,
-0.1941441297531128,
-0.8577932715415955,
1.186118245124817,
0.24223968386650085,
0.3528665006160736,
0.33369937539100647,
0.4872109889984131,
-0.42568036913871765,
-0.23595719039440155,
-0.608330249786377,
0.3579678535461426,
-0.7069782614707947,
-0.4918631315231323,
-0.035746488720178604,
-0.34513217210769653,
-0.1393846571445465,
-0.46390554308891296,
-0.36143773794174194,
-0.6657270789146423,
0.08737993240356445,
0.2874024212360382,
0.5921134948730469,
0.4685414731502533,
-0.06138458475470543,
0.3345254361629486,
-0.5852728486061096,
0.29957252740859985,
0.5751410722732544,
0.38045433163642883,
-0.1773395538330078,
-0.807300329208374,
-0.07466360926628113,
0.15006154775619507,
-0.3150929808616638,
-0.1506500393152237,
0.18498320877552032,
0.1485980600118637,
0.3674287796020508,
0.23087206482887268,
-0.12367632240056992,
0.766786515712738,
-0.6048833131790161,
0.5135841369628906,
0.032632775604724884,
-1.1690739393234253,
0.6957213878631592,
-0.3654135763645172,
0.6235548257827759,
0.27462148666381836,
0.22822938859462738,
-0.19419510662555695,
-0.2518923282623291,
-0.5659878849983215,
-0.3842507600784302,
0.5356727242469788,
0.29039573669433594,
-0.1265239119529724,
0.14285323023796082,
0.47697973251342773,
-0.1152409166097641,
-0.03410768136382103,
-0.29073789715766907,
-0.021126938983798027,
-0.03944563865661621,
-0.5005576014518738,
-0.13594011962413788,
-0.10455186665058136,
-0.3694087564945221,
-0.47032901644706726,
0.39572209119796753,
-0.4603894352912903,
0.03410876914858818,
-0.14121635258197784,
0.08212542533874512,
-0.021468309685587883,
0.22981207072734833,
0.6981167793273926,
1.0877612829208374,
0.07785641402006149,
0.09195572137832642,
0.5013002157211304,
-0.8242202997207642,
0.05653653293848038,
-0.04018436744809151,
0.023781361058354378,
-0.32792067527770996,
0.4182432293891907,
0.3616798520088196,
0.238612100481987,
-0.7669874429702759,
0.40536266565322876,
-0.02002083696424961,
-0.607143223285675,
-0.10585404932498932,
0.11800715327262878,
0.2407047301530838,
0.24582138657569885,
0.20863254368305206,
-0.1415773332118988,
-0.09002047777175903,
-0.1632167547941208,
0.17016050219535828,
0.37476828694343567,
0.036409683525562286,
0.09774207323789597,
0.627312958240509,
-0.032290320843458176,
-0.35721561312675476,
0.858705997467041,
-0.1371847689151764,
-0.38474705815315247,
0.8054002523422241,
0.7456035017967224,
0.3197331428527832,
-0.0824783593416214,
0.13847698271274567,
0.730675220489502,
0.5218876004219055,
0.006392812356352806,
0.3128402531147003,
-0.1847304403781891,
-0.6358500719070435,
-0.7140041589736938,
-0.7235830426216125,
-0.6600866913795471,
-0.03297872841358185,
-0.7104413509368896,
0.014572158455848694,
-0.8286773562431335,
-0.09797946363687515,
-0.023215265944600105,
0.2867913544178009,
-0.33100783824920654,
0.28986144065856934,
-0.0976472869515419,
1.0343190431594849,
-0.7277923226356506,
0.6786683797836304,
0.6611906290054321,
-0.03675495833158493,
-1.0295259952545166,
-0.4124014675617218,
0.2874835729598999,
-1.0338622331619263,
0.38605043292045593,
-0.20742438733577728,
-0.027730446308851242,
0.2138669341802597,
-0.5262188911437988,
-1.002079963684082,
1.2743891477584839,
0.47875118255615234,
-0.6147144436836243,
0.2776861786842346,
0.3445160388946533,
0.41758230328559875,
-0.2591620087623596,
0.28829821944236755,
0.7354193925857544,
0.31200823187828064,
0.634218692779541,
-0.8742682933807373,
0.08077248185873032,
-0.07934819906949997,
0.14945515990257263,
0.6018121838569641,
-0.42511263489723206,
1.0729520320892334,
-0.256274938583374,
0.21056917309761047,
-0.061706919223070145,
0.5024715662002563,
0.6625894904136658,
0.3796694874763489,
0.4820420742034912,
1.1219362020492554,
0.8982138633728027,
-0.45394253730773926,
0.7016304731369019,
-0.03320222720503807,
0.3056027889251709,
1.0526580810546875,
0.20414038002490997,
0.7477589845657349,
0.13018415868282318,
-0.5190430879592896,
0.390850692987442,
0.5652062892913818,
0.02833021990954876,
-0.029444480314850807,
0.5282399654388428,
-0.2528621554374695,
-0.6293568015098572,
0.1418694108724594,
-0.2010667622089386,
0.10445889085531235,
0.7671979069709778,
0.14054197072982788,
-0.5201207399368286,
-0.22583653032779694,
0.2881792485713959,
0.3964467942714691,
-0.7863463163375854,
0.31092900037765503,
0.1305609494447708,
-0.44664037227630615,
0.5784663558006287,
-0.16152594983577728,
0.16031426191329956,
-0.6539027094841003,
-0.26115041971206665,
-0.5901998281478882,
0.45821791887283325,
-0.23824498057365417,
-0.8204065561294556,
0.24863196909427643,
-0.015344700776040554,
-0.10537348687648773,
0.06812465190887451,
0.2420332431793213,
-0.2691667675971985,
-0.8439763188362122,
-0.37446895241737366,
0.5682776570320129,
0.12444524466991425,
-0.18537373840808868,
-0.628503143787384,
0.2096119374036789,
-0.10718953609466553,
0.1975060999393463,
0.5254113078117371,
0.9497982263565063,
-0.35359272360801697,
0.9042255282402039,
0.8308125734329224,
0.1217341348528862,
0.06509827077388763,
0.0990278348326683,
1.0198558568954468,
-0.47319039702415466,
-0.20901155471801758,
-0.6540301442146301,
0.11282631754875183,
-0.22790947556495667,
-0.6677538156509399,
0.8836157917976379,
0.5446473360061646,
0.7011246085166931,
0.24628223478794098,
0.3234027624130249,
0.08784478902816772,
0.45758697390556335,
-0.526172399520874,
0.37383031845092773,
-0.4235626459121704,
0.20586420595645905,
-0.04225533828139305,
-1.0462249517440796,
-0.376787006855011,
0.601825475692749,
-0.4433761239051819,
-0.006778985261917114,
0.9326498508453369,
0.8217606544494629,
-0.031216736882925034,
0.008612102828919888,
0.3606557846069336,
0.0822373703122139,
0.21634875237941742,
0.7720063924789429,
0.5044784545898438,
-0.12048139423131943,
0.8414022922515869,
-0.28244608640670776,
-0.7161608338356018,
0.18464022874832153,
-0.6866591572761536,
-1.0955564975738525,
-0.2863450348377228,
-0.2583179473876953,
-0.37780120968818665,
-0.3466339707374573,
0.606212317943573,
0.5478149056434631,
-0.5905042886734009,
-0.4054037630558014,
-0.2486218810081482,
0.19390630722045898,
-0.2878740727901459,
-0.29542076587677,
0.3407878875732422,
-0.6445202231407166,
-0.6098175048828125,
0.1922595351934433,
0.3047615587711334,
-0.2944968342781067,
-0.2105729579925537,
0.1121630072593689,
0.38216423988342285,
0.3644493520259857,
0.7924776077270508,
0.1474725753068924,
-0.6161782145500183,
-0.06674832105636597,
0.24103033542633057,
-0.07287324219942093,
-0.15893195569515228,
0.9287351369857788,
-0.5173130035400391,
0.25478267669677734,
0.19114802777767181,
0.8855159282684326,
0.5181398987770081,
-0.1158953532576561,
0.27247682213783264,
-0.2824292778968811,
-0.12466242909431458,
0.26991406083106995,
0.1873633712530136,
0.06092720106244087,
-0.23989427089691162,
0.6394408345222473,
0.3227343261241913,
-0.7882993817329407,
-0.4990229308605194,
0.16695375740528107,
-0.9267301559448242,
-0.26396289467811584,
1.089379906654358,
-0.03808092325925827,
-0.2368016093969345,
0.41877269744873047,
-0.3584800660610199,
-0.2922276258468628,
-0.28738072514533997,
0.5221882462501526,
0.8000048398971558,
-0.3292788565158844,
-0.17460240423679352,
-0.5602878332138062,
0.25270628929138184,
0.42158523201942444,
-0.8971934914588928,
0.093279168009758,
0.6787375211715698,
0.3353850245475769,
0.006953727919608355,
0.27966225147247314,
-0.2659657597541809,
0.3826347291469574,
0.5212735533714294,
-0.09646207839250565,
-0.2594034969806671,
-0.12806066870689392,
-0.10330718755722046,
0.22686126828193665,
0.1365155577659607,
-0.008318791165947914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02875v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02875v1
|
Enhancing Conceptual Understanding in Multimodal Contrastive Learning through Hard Negative Samples
| 2024-03-05T11:38:48 | 2024-03-05T11:38:48 |
Philipp J. Rösch, Norbert Oswald, Michaela Geierhos, Jindřich Libovický
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Current multimodal models leveraging contrastive learning often face
limitations in developing fine-grained conceptual understanding. This is due to
random negative samples during pretraining, causing almost exclusively very
dissimilar concepts to be compared in the loss function. Consequently, the
models struggle with fine-grained semantic differences. To address this
problem, we introduce a novel pretraining method incorporating synthetic hard
negative text examples. The hard negatives permute terms corresponding to
visual concepts, leading to a more fine-grained visual and textual concept
alignment. Further, we introduce InpaintCOCO, a new challenging dataset for
assessing the fine-grained alignment of colors, objects, and sizes in
vision-language models. We created the dataset using generative inpainting from
COCO images by changing the visual concepts so that the images no longer match
their original captions. Our results show significant improvements in
fine-grained concept understanding across a wide range of vision-language
datasets, including our InpaintCOCO dataset.
|
[
-0.579058825969696,
-0.6397722363471985,
0.3676583766937256,
0.011255811899900436,
-0.5036080479621887,
0.3052853047847748,
-0.12477466464042664,
-0.461987167596817,
0.11229000240564346,
0.4738869071006775,
-0.7389308214187622,
-0.5550410151481628,
-0.4177480936050415,
0.06502142548561096,
-0.230436772108078,
1.1538403034210205,
-0.26243355870246887,
0.19876320660114288,
-0.4807947278022766,
-0.34870368242263794,
-0.5459724068641663,
-0.277118444442749,
-0.4449886083602905,
-0.5234994888305664,
0.4753999710083008,
0.6602210402488708,
0.49658203125,
0.23553621768951416,
0.6668494343757629,
0.22204969823360443,
0.0743911862373352,
0.2622356116771698,
-0.590901255607605,
-0.22365552186965942,
-0.3616728186607361,
-0.6075751185417175,
-0.08955821394920349,
0.1105612963438034,
0.1377648413181305,
0.6242470741271973,
-0.18911635875701904,
-0.17264105379581451,
0.20717309415340424,
0.5444339513778687,
-1.075492262840271,
0.29522940516471863,
-0.6840315461158752,
0.3006960153579712,
-0.2365674525499344,
-0.43709850311279297,
-0.22949589788913727,
-0.03719461336731911,
0.04401909187436104,
-1.2244964838027954,
0.6378147006034851,
-0.2951815724372864,
1.2130930423736572,
0.2765738070011139,
-0.36991986632347107,
-0.44215065240859985,
-0.33003130555152893,
0.7376546263694763,
-0.3834739625453949,
0.306991845369339,
0.40511277318000793,
0.2564471364021301,
0.09113743156194687,
-0.6374150514602661,
-1.132807970046997,
-0.1831679493188858,
-0.0025346006732434034,
0.4625577926635742,
0.34028467535972595,
0.22843150794506073,
-0.024021204560995102,
0.5179826021194458,
-0.286827951669693,
0.10926102846860886,
-0.36696621775627136,
-0.1922995001077652,
0.4502052962779999,
0.18598929047584534,
0.29809948801994324,
-0.16229362785816193,
-0.6363611221313477,
-0.4932404160499573,
-0.6676138043403625,
-0.20668064057826996,
0.12135347723960876,
0.3491634130477905,
-0.47065499424934387,
0.6901591420173645,
-0.20070068538188934,
0.6964454650878906,
-0.025171834975481033,
-0.20668810606002808,
0.5614744424819946,
-0.5423473119735718,
-0.4310648441314697,
0.14570210874080658,
0.4888126850128174,
0.6698250770568848,
0.3865417540073395,
-0.10231901705265045,
0.01790750026702881,
0.5372700691223145,
0.19326069951057434,
-1.0296220779418945,
-0.3667842745780945,
-0.025382164865732193,
-0.07718310505151749,
-0.4139443635940552,
0.0902475118637085,
-0.7236954569816589,
-0.6548219323158264,
-0.7019095420837402,
0.683552086353302,
-0.6006171107292175,
-0.04486105963587761,
0.34931954741477966,
-0.25478440523147583,
0.28631699085235596,
0.5772395730018616,
-0.9048818945884705,
0.246268630027771,
0.395363450050354,
0.6958443522453308,
-0.14513510465621948,
-0.28381890058517456,
-0.2586180567741394,
0.22831448912620544,
-0.6399191617965698,
0.7289918661117554,
-0.5613347291946411,
-0.184151291847229,
-0.20644457638263702,
0.0026052624452859163,
-0.06672666221857071,
-0.6488465666770935,
0.4290478825569153,
-0.3769896924495697,
0.1835251897573471,
-0.014187189750373363,
-0.385642945766449,
-0.2311359941959381,
0.648222029209137,
-0.3259466588497162,
0.5758395195007324,
0.15490315854549408,
-0.7204758524894714,
0.49599581956863403,
-0.48679137229919434,
-0.48406457901000977,
-0.16594648361206055,
-0.4183696508407593,
-0.38005778193473816,
0.32388225197792053,
0.12880371510982513,
0.5386796593666077,
-0.31420692801475525,
-0.01851242408156395,
-0.5732088685035706,
-0.39462611079216003,
0.25303521752357483,
-0.2585226595401764,
0.549360454082489,
0.30298295617103577,
-0.05209628865122795,
0.07256738096475601,
-0.9273083209991455,
-0.18176183104515076,
0.1679866909980774,
0.1730777472257614,
-0.6041598916053772,
-0.17098748683929443,
0.06661059707403183,
0.4608004689216614,
0.03667237237095833,
-0.5763141512870789,
-0.027096115052700043,
-0.4173703193664551,
0.491269588470459,
0.6701660752296448,
-0.059434548020362854,
0.48483237624168396,
-0.2617652118206024,
0.47610238194465637,
0.5040855407714844,
0.0532686710357666,
-0.4701724350452423,
-0.06580726057291031,
-0.9908857941627502,
-0.2896696627140045,
0.13147638738155365,
0.31997138261795044,
-1.1680772304534912,
-0.09356442838907242,
-0.14222505688667297,
-0.3485391139984131,
-0.4591480791568756,
0.3453339636325836,
0.5205048322677612,
0.8047423958778381,
0.6981935501098633,
-0.8286607265472412,
-0.30390042066574097,
-0.8028638958930969,
0.35106420516967773,
0.36833927035331726,
0.06796739995479584,
0.3704679012298584,
0.48670387268066406,
-0.38881930708885193,
0.7554094791412354,
-0.7782266139984131,
-0.5843615531921387,
0.07015015184879303,
0.373930424451828,
0.05930936709046364,
0.7775733470916748,
0.2900239825248718,
-0.9495668411254883,
-0.378497451543808,
0.10662657022476196,
-0.735753059387207,
0.19659432768821716,
-0.16902950406074524,
-0.19703926146030426,
-0.08477305620908737,
0.8462328314781189,
-0.5636281967163086,
0.20353810489177704,
0.4582855701446533,
-0.1798320859670639,
0.23249413073062897,
-0.2017046958208084,
0.17583659291267395,
-1.1522517204284668,
-0.2438288927078247,
0.1757413148880005,
0.109440878033638,
-0.4301791489124298,
0.38426005840301514,
0.25106561183929443,
-0.27561697363853455,
-0.7461695075035095,
0.5525079369544983,
-0.2797645628452301,
0.30261772871017456,
-0.14420463144779205,
0.23127813637256622,
0.4258439838886261,
0.5711851119995117,
0.24055622518062592,
0.6808110475540161,
0.43673422932624817,
-0.6931726932525635,
0.13037043809890747,
0.3259377181529999,
-0.6178183555603027,
0.909988522529602,
-0.4867098331451416,
0.17567531764507294,
-0.5145134329795837,
0.3326011300086975,
-1.153579592704773,
-0.2770955562591553,
0.335528165102005,
-0.16177697479724884,
0.5730597972869873,
0.03143083304166794,
-0.33858367800712585,
-0.014380116015672684,
-0.4285602271556854,
0.8567480444908142,
-0.08993757516145706,
-0.4641549587249756,
0.33869847655296326,
0.17025475203990936,
0.07840289175510406,
-0.6546116471290588,
-0.8612853288650513,
0.07069721817970276,
-0.3231589198112488,
-0.24736268818378448,
0.7317181825637817,
-0.10653175413608551,
-0.024396024644374847,
-0.17524686455726624,
-0.18882891535758972,
-0.16592243313789368,
0.1112307533621788,
0.12894925475120544,
0.31055986881256104,
-0.13143758475780487,
0.4254726469516754,
-0.03385362774133682,
-0.10840804874897003,
-0.22218382358551025,
-0.11178115010261536,
0.7267338633537292,
0.12819910049438477,
-0.2777833342552185,
-0.5677767395973206,
-0.0702609047293663,
0.5051068067550659,
-0.35305100679397583,
0.5773235559463501,
0.7070135474205017,
-0.3174630403518677,
0.11089266091585159,
-0.3571148216724396,
-0.16992077231407166,
-0.4296773076057434,
0.3759225904941559,
-0.578318178653717,
-0.5330801606178284,
0.277577668428421,
0.09511855989694595,
-0.4133152663707733,
0.37305986881256104,
0.27400246262550354,
-0.6020525097846985,
0.6140261888504028,
0.7523632049560547,
0.32748982310295105,
0.6058727502822876,
-0.6395660638809204,
-0.07507137954235077,
-0.8219882249832153,
-0.39307084679603577,
-0.24665269255638123,
-0.3118056356906891,
-0.678145706653595,
-0.7357770800590515,
0.025427063927054405,
0.23028235137462616,
-0.32290396094322205,
0.20511062443256378,
-0.38956233859062195,
0.6634991765022278,
0.2570878267288208,
0.6043090224266052,
0.2875620722770691,
-0.03143833950161934,
-0.06321488320827484,
-0.09661906957626343,
-0.3647996783256531,
-0.25905635952949524,
1.1072155237197876,
-0.06196146830916405,
0.9718957543373108,
-0.09417717158794403,
0.6456289887428284,
-0.00993343535810709,
0.5839831233024597,
-0.80732661485672,
0.26724204421043396,
-0.48349374532699585,
-0.6187751889228821,
-0.06837781518697739,
-0.27602407336235046,
-0.7216677069664001,
0.3295808434486389,
-0.5289643406867981,
-0.37120866775512695,
0.5308980345726013,
0.2779940664768219,
-0.38206350803375244,
-0.003405787283554673,
-1.094583511352539,
1.1080082654953003,
-0.10048800706863403,
-0.4669731557369232,
-0.4813368022441864,
-0.6665447950363159,
0.41565707325935364,
-0.07765062898397446,
0.13154157996177673,
-0.052556633949279785,
0.031410083174705505,
0.46391257643699646,
-0.24193927645683289,
0.9454188346862793,
-0.09796100109815598,
-0.3614075183868408,
0.3726545572280884,
0.07015896588563919,
0.19437381625175476,
0.022715309634804726,
0.19452472031116486,
0.11734433472156525,
-0.06318312883377075,
-0.5933273434638977,
-0.6950490474700928,
0.4588842988014221,
-0.6334857940673828,
-0.3084602952003479,
-0.3415246605873108,
-0.5708253979682922,
-0.2534264624118805,
-0.0041267904452979565,
0.28033873438835144,
0.4925622344017029,
-0.22221392393112183,
0.2859935462474823,
0.6243757009506226,
-0.3529614210128784,
0.1416364163160324,
0.31978532671928406,
0.1379658430814743,
-0.24052812159061432,
1.341794490814209,
-0.03832787647843361,
0.4628974199295044,
0.8988319635391235,
0.03592469170689583,
-0.2655162811279297,
-0.554987907409668,
-0.18912014365196228,
0.01592489890754223,
-0.7321597337722778,
-0.31321972608566284,
-0.4409061074256897,
0.07330448180437088,
0.1055159941315651,
-0.4399038851261139,
-0.25840550661087036,
-0.33630263805389404,
-0.5368242859840393,
-0.14682208001613617,
-0.1357116848230362,
0.3072596788406372,
0.14179185032844543,
0.3892780542373657,
-0.46853432059288025,
0.5590901374816895,
0.40625855326652527,
0.21079733967781067,
0.0036103278398513794,
-0.4603831171989441,
-0.2501465678215027,
0.2249400019645691,
-0.7072928547859192,
-0.5510780811309814,
0.22081667184829712,
0.2790468633174896,
0.062485482543706894,
0.6122678518295288,
-0.13833966851234436,
1.0751231908798218,
-0.31189000606536865,
0.5208241939544678,
0.7082460522651672,
-0.9355868101119995,
0.46046388149261475,
-0.17027239501476288,
0.41462278366088867,
0.8389714956283569,
0.41801559925079346,
-0.5079967975616455,
-0.14964565634727478,
-0.6258414387702942,
-0.7600530982017517,
0.548194944858551,
0.07940220087766647,
0.5102176070213318,
-0.010989136062562466,
0.15873821079730988,
0.32738015055656433,
0.3701489567756653,
-0.7288749814033508,
0.11418836563825607,
-0.7581344246864319,
-0.5079078078269958,
-0.7876799702644348,
-0.13706731796264648,
-0.26944997906684875,
-0.4312773644924164,
0.555372416973114,
-0.3501977324485779,
0.0012680798536166549,
0.08278438448905945,
-0.4706270098686218,
0.19548483192920685,
0.2622915804386139,
0.822442352771759,
0.5633273124694824,
-0.2442314475774765,
0.4013773798942566,
0.37499740719795227,
-0.4153583347797394,
0.2568743824958801,
0.18977604806423187,
0.1305736005306244,
-0.35606104135513306,
0.47622114419937134,
0.7725632190704346,
0.2282835841178894,
-0.7193392515182495,
0.5187093615531921,
-0.03505562245845795,
-0.03565647453069687,
-0.029267724603414536,
0.1357758790254593,
-0.06828446686267853,
-0.054124485701322556,
0.048384979367256165,
0.28744229674339294,
-0.03597135469317436,
-0.6688324809074402,
0.10754434019327164,
0.37349581718444824,
-0.7296839356422424,
-0.29327479004859924,
0.337546169757843,
0.2918376624584198,
0.18651850521564484,
0.730758547782898,
-0.22938670217990875,
-0.16284744441509247,
0.8454786539077759,
0.5723308324813843,
0.4899104833602905,
0.09928518533706665,
0.37376779317855835,
0.32505711913108826,
0.05913754180073738,
0.2558972239494324,
0.04718516021966934,
-0.5459002256393433,
-1.250710129737854,
-0.3758692741394043,
-0.5299139618873596,
-0.3639226257801056,
0.2618371546268463,
-0.6038578748703003,
0.4198879897594452,
-0.4681336581707001,
0.12213636189699173,
0.08402932435274124,
-0.05537835881114006,
-0.8972707986831665,
0.7222892642021179,
0.22396017611026764,
0.6190313696861267,
-0.9622686505317688,
0.7736918926239014,
0.6083345413208008,
-0.6317912340164185,
-0.49028295278549194,
-0.03744107112288475,
-0.09603816270828247,
-0.8838254809379578,
0.8161435127258301,
0.45435038208961487,
-0.20889414846897125,
0.012921626679599285,
-0.5851712226867676,
-0.521255612373352,
0.9888145923614502,
0.4734842777252197,
-0.6229367256164551,
0.15078769624233246,
-0.0009556504082866013,
0.5068047642707825,
-0.30036410689353943,
0.33297309279441833,
0.31051668524742126,
0.2919658124446869,
0.38425928354263306,
-0.4186220169067383,
-0.23403671383857727,
-0.15461547672748566,
-0.012427442707121372,
0.21916699409484863,
-0.5674504041671753,
0.8607041835784912,
-0.28938722610473633,
-0.375060111284256,
0.06364711374044418,
0.5925890803337097,
0.08927133679389954,
0.5796645879745483,
0.5153905153274536,
0.9523473978042603,
0.6422899961471558,
-0.11950980126857758,
1.026411771774292,
-0.05501123145222664,
0.48133227229118347,
1.4332728385925293,
-0.08115585893392563,
0.510152280330658,
0.7765254378318787,
0.10056942701339722,
0.5536015629768372,
0.800348162651062,
0.1159045398235321,
0.762393057346344,
0.36320582032203674,
-0.3481367826461792,
-0.3356916606426239,
-0.4808386266231537,
-0.4152054786682129,
0.5947990417480469,
0.42817699909210205,
-0.11678671836853027,
-0.4301093518733978,
0.22701212763786316,
-0.20308303833007812,
0.2425219565629959,
-0.3843182921409607,
0.7345997095108032,
0.2008509337902069,
-0.4194999635219574,
0.7704691886901855,
-0.19805306196212769,
0.890704333782196,
-0.5746138095855713,
-0.18216857314109802,
-0.28388479351997375,
0.3672320246696472,
-0.33795586228370667,
-0.7064984440803528,
0.14181746542453766,
-0.3129897117614746,
0.05245286598801613,
-0.05484427884221077,
0.25794512033462524,
-0.5351076126098633,
-0.37927719950675964,
0.18709228932857513,
0.15593478083610535,
-0.07067885994911194,
-0.035997174680233,
-0.6364413499832153,
0.031178956851363182,
-0.1718064844608307,
0.2762119174003601,
0.1681329607963562,
0.542635977268219,
-0.14461137354373932,
0.47770431637763977,
0.4833754599094391,
-0.26371482014656067,
-0.3016764223575592,
0.3379118740558624,
0.7857861518859863,
-0.5492908954620361,
-0.342680960893631,
-0.9230987429618835,
0.4102398157119751,
-0.025531359016895294,
-0.5301245450973511,
0.42860931158065796,
0.4572969377040863,
1.4752811193466187,
-0.2518869638442993,
0.29616594314575195,
0.05196453258395195,
-0.22484974563121796,
-0.7542542219161987,
0.516858696937561,
-0.8564493656158447,
-0.19757753610610962,
-0.6417140960693359,
-0.9056809544563293,
-0.34678003191947937,
0.7344479560852051,
-0.18611112236976624,
-0.2229134887456894,
0.7135758996009827,
0.9996171593666077,
-0.4487401843070984,
-0.034651849418878555,
0.20435689389705658,
0.2488269954919815,
0.2615009844303131,
0.5418728590011597,
1.0281928777694702,
-0.42630892992019653,
0.40634697675704956,
-0.5372431874275208,
-0.012656860053539276,
-0.05724727734923363,
-0.9047598838806152,
-0.8193268179893494,
-0.7618415355682373,
-0.32651203870773315,
-0.16803793609142303,
0.08230584859848022,
0.8183711767196655,
0.8033071756362915,
-0.8748270273208618,
-0.14849525690078735,
-0.5930450558662415,
0.08661728352308273,
-0.0891084372997284,
-0.24804499745368958,
0.3828166127204895,
-0.4949812591075897,
-0.7148448824882507,
0.1078229546546936,
0.20341801643371582,
0.4189077913761139,
0.06777109205722809,
-0.05903119221329689,
-0.2365054190158844,
-0.021140312775969505,
0.8132035136222839,
0.19868436455726624,
-0.3362103998661041,
-0.2521838843822479,
-0.5076074004173279,
-0.15477144718170166,
0.3330959379673004,
0.8363221883773804,
-0.7785288691520691,
0.8313899040222168,
0.2896246314048767,
0.6280174851417542,
1.0233882665634155,
0.07105424255132675,
0.3048867881298065,
-0.7007153630256653,
0.590666651725769,
0.16046012938022614,
0.23913469910621643,
0.6293686032295227,
-0.06638937443494797,
0.4878275394439697,
0.3342456817626953,
0.2558135390281677,
-0.6515310406684875,
0.3675612211227417,
-1.157251000404358,
-0.4855784475803375,
0.6835572123527527,
0.13980016112327576,
-0.06588556617498398,
0.11422540247440338,
-0.40240994095802307,
0.33777448534965515,
-0.12481799721717834,
0.9642913937568665,
0.7526793479919434,
0.008065314032137394,
-0.12828044593334198,
-0.10725998133420944,
0.3540753126144409,
0.5181015729904175,
-0.8671319484710693,
-0.35862788558006287,
0.24751247465610504,
0.168598011136055,
0.43904560804367065,
0.49231764674186707,
-0.18649043142795563,
0.17770875990390778,
-0.1514965444803238,
0.2555791735649109,
-0.15180832147598267,
-0.5088127255439758,
-0.1980157047510147,
0.1605559140443802,
-0.2601814568042755,
-0.5132700800895691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02839v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02839v2
|
On the Limitations of Fine-tuned Judge Models for LLM Evaluation
| 2024-03-05T10:20:52 | 2024-06-17T12:10:34 |
Hui Huang, Yingqi Qu, Hongli Zhou, Jing Liu, Muyun Yang, Bing Xu, Tiejun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, there has been a growing trend of utilizing Large Language Model
(LLM) to evaluate the quality of other LLMs. Many studies have employed
proprietary close-source models, especially GPT-4, as the evaluator.
Alternatively, other works have fine-tuned judge models based on open-source
LLMs as the evaluator. While the fine-tuned judge models are claimed to achieve
comparable evaluation capability with GPT-4, in this study, we conduct an
empirical study of judge models. Our findings indicate that although the
fine-tuned judge models achieve high performance on in-domain test sets, even
surpassing GPT-4, they underperform GPT-4 across several dimensions, including
generalizability, fairness, aspect-specific evaluation, and scalability. We
also reveal that the fine-tuned judge model inherently operates as a
task-specific classifier, consequently imposing the limitations. Finally, we
propose an effective indicator to measure the reliability of fine-tuned judges,
with the aim of maximizing their utility in LLM evaluation.
|
[
-0.43487727642059326,
-0.5467883348464966,
1.0868576765060425,
-0.07092350721359253,
-0.16751597821712494,
-0.28903284668922424,
-0.6891606450080872,
-0.6253497004508972,
-0.4015620946884155,
0.5129082202911377,
-0.2433212697505951,
-0.4238492548465729,
-0.7991909384727478,
0.23888570070266724,
-0.3572794795036316,
1.1661245822906494,
-0.09212800115346909,
0.23521098494529724,
-0.23839877545833588,
-0.16293588280677795,
-0.5329515933990479,
-0.43282783031463623,
-0.324150413274765,
-0.44884416460990906,
0.21723340451717377,
0.45620399713516235,
0.7227906584739685,
0.284287691116333,
0.8138586282730103,
0.3205380141735077,
-0.17881129682064056,
0.14427541196346283,
-0.5372522473335266,
-0.18053855001926422,
-0.49809399247169495,
-0.5420136451721191,
-0.6461736559867859,
0.432603120803833,
0.5749613046646118,
0.509181559085846,
-0.1073462963104248,
0.2755768299102783,
0.10748381167650223,
0.5028793811798096,
-0.5675860047340393,
0.42502886056900024,
-0.8826935291290283,
-0.051022544503211975,
-0.2974718511104584,
-0.1717568039894104,
-0.28863856196403503,
-0.6424036026000977,
0.04227615147829056,
-0.4068419635295868,
0.22208699584007263,
-0.06729550659656525,
0.9357187747955322,
0.4185158908367157,
-0.3910196125507355,
-0.14082258939743042,
-0.8083111047744751,
0.7830086350440979,
-1.0763529539108276,
0.3706614077091217,
0.5047858357429504,
0.5513115525245667,
-0.07259591668844223,
-0.6534475088119507,
-0.43095794320106506,
-0.782418429851532,
0.1377446949481964,
0.0389661006629467,
-0.1371627002954483,
0.11544733494520187,
0.32078564167022705,
0.6144072413444519,
-0.3395722806453705,
0.50016850233078,
-0.1742178499698639,
-0.0701049193739891,
0.5406140685081482,
0.3946426808834076,
-0.05889185145497322,
-0.14057165384292603,
-0.15698561072349548,
0.5239181518554688,
-0.5059465169906616,
0.03853314369916916,
0.46620088815689087,
0.44340190291404724,
0.21468912065029144,
0.5897024869918823,
-0.46451666951179504,
0.8616676926612854,
0.41244199872016907,
-0.13713900744915009,
0.0776473879814148,
-0.42189088463783264,
-0.23874083161354065,
-0.6085571646690369,
0.7754729986190796,
0.5257173180580139,
0.5785578489303589,
-0.33367684483528137,
-0.5175585150718689,
0.05856472998857498,
0.35469627380371094,
-0.8182708024978638,
-0.04856023192405701,
-0.06691408157348633,
-0.5336918234825134,
-0.3335404396057129,
-0.004993401002138853,
-0.4875953197479248,
-0.32098013162612915,
-0.3929981589317322,
0.4217754006385803,
-0.2812057137489319,
-0.07463020086288452,
0.17253999412059784,
0.047842420637607574,
-0.011411793529987335,
0.17079153656959534,
-0.9468900561332703,
0.5691467523574829,
0.8624215126037598,
0.6053406000137329,
-0.4105522930622101,
-0.2799278795719147,
-0.7964527606964111,
-0.39375439286231995,
-0.17787930369377136,
0.6267663240432739,
-0.8492668271064758,
-0.15544384717941284,
-0.09365277737379074,
0.10990770161151886,
-0.10029886662960052,
-0.7246840596199036,
0.9507637619972229,
-0.6520067453384399,
-0.23324823379516602,
-0.27561795711517334,
-0.8406379818916321,
-0.012806237675249577,
0.4623628556728363,
-0.5945348739624023,
0.5896883606910706,
0.47104138135910034,
-0.4300774931907654,
0.6197089552879333,
-0.4597691595554352,
-0.2646145820617676,
0.10805852711200714,
-0.17149145901203156,
-0.5002959966659546,
0.4027860462665558,
0.16102097928524017,
0.5710367560386658,
-0.5862658023834229,
0.35555794835090637,
-0.6562007069587708,
-0.7099013328552246,
0.1571839451789856,
-0.5186444520950317,
0.12487278878688812,
0.3543711006641388,
-0.31465473771095276,
0.20964635908603668,
-0.8122740983963013,
0.16086792945861816,
-0.03928183764219284,
-0.6319285035133362,
-0.06400763988494873,
0.057279739528894424,
0.021887561306357384,
0.059054482728242874,
0.38940030336380005,
-0.5890011191368103,
-0.12895368039608002,
-0.5212875008583069,
0.619113564491272,
0.7964869737625122,
-0.09235678613185883,
0.2859523892402649,
-0.3150183856487274,
0.7814133763313293,
-0.3008505702018738,
0.18190860748291016,
0.2526106834411621,
-0.2453271448612213,
-0.5271838903427124,
-0.08535585552453995,
0.5679392218589783,
0.23931558430194855,
-0.26775720715522766,
0.4722069501876831,
-0.30282801389694214,
-0.6931032538414001,
-0.30197277665138245,
0.2638762891292572,
0.47913533449172974,
0.24306762218475342,
0.17312435805797577,
-0.5012240409851074,
0.03323587030172348,
-1.0517165660858154,
-0.6037275195121765,
0.15360386669635773,
0.19064103066921234,
0.5048615336418152,
0.5645868182182312,
-0.060900215059518814,
0.7838810086250305,
-0.19063125550746918,
0.029225703328847885,
-0.25588905811309814,
-0.2956162095069885,
0.4835129380226135,
0.2965754270553589,
0.8215303421020508,
-0.4517880976200104,
-0.4774433672428131,
0.21502694487571716,
-0.4725991487503052,
-0.27224209904670715,
0.2830832004547119,
0.1960584670305252,
0.0053144400008022785,
0.24137060344219208,
-0.509471595287323,
0.34310242533683777,
0.6405878663063049,
-0.4120098948478699,
0.9717234373092651,
-0.24229151010513306,
0.21119199693202972,
-0.3975180387496948,
-0.08310151100158691,
0.22912481427192688,
-0.454710990190506,
-0.33268067240715027,
0.37770166993141174,
0.2645314037799835,
0.040977369993925095,
-0.20494167506694794,
0.549523115158081,
-0.22261030972003937,
-0.23738211393356323,
-0.4471222162246704,
0.23025883734226227,
-0.12478190660476685,
0.4612305462360382,
-0.2928805649280548,
0.5686951279640198,
0.20463459193706512,
-0.6560300588607788,
0.3474098742008209,
0.04408480226993561,
-0.7535589933395386,
0.8586127161979675,
-0.6303480863571167,
-0.014525683596730232,
0.4497171640396118,
0.03882969170808792,
-0.4806036353111267,
-0.26558876037597656,
-0.08189231157302856,
-0.029472462832927704,
0.4196655750274658,
-0.30274319648742676,
-0.5543084740638733,
-0.4755175709724426,
-0.15933741629123688,
0.25778692960739136,
0.3644985854625702,
-0.6234961152076721,
0.23448143899440765,
0.0392267219722271,
-0.11913935840129852,
-0.2547595798969269,
-0.4093273878097534,
-0.15356490015983582,
-0.3111356198787689,
-0.5387228727340698,
0.13700051605701447,
-0.19209659099578857,
-0.17324869334697723,
0.04595492035150528,
-0.47634008526802063,
0.010688775219023228,
0.335511177778244,
0.2144564837217331,
-0.02183864824473858,
-0.24336384236812592,
-0.08229325711727142,
-0.06860047578811646,
-0.026360798627138138,
0.0905175730586052,
-0.10722748190164566,
0.2577318847179413,
-0.4843153655529022,
-0.8253709673881531,
-0.5130209922790527,
-0.04519810155034065,
0.635148823261261,
-0.44014349579811096,
0.22723586857318878,
0.28214526176452637,
-0.10445348173379898,
-0.22913646697998047,
-0.6306594014167786,
0.036610476672649384,
-0.460578978061676,
0.5884952545166016,
-0.636842668056488,
-1.2427364587783813,
0.3926483988761902,
-0.21548263728618622,
-0.18367069959640503,
0.5870842337608337,
0.7656673192977905,
0.26045161485671997,
0.863732099533081,
0.508788526058197,
-0.12937282025814056,
0.40281981229782104,
0.11641447991132736,
0.19410185515880585,
-0.8979086875915527,
0.05835399404168129,
-0.6622932553291321,
-0.2689480185508728,
-0.8180733919143677,
-0.07798996567726135,
0.3389204740524292,
0.16471555829048157,
-0.540054976940155,
0.08065915107727051,
-0.42297881841659546,
0.5688130259513855,
0.6077263951301575,
0.28059905767440796,
0.5230093002319336,
-0.26342490315437317,
-0.42892390489578247,
0.1033562421798706,
-0.3884408175945282,
-0.7309727668762207,
1.2788606882095337,
0.610710084438324,
0.7715249061584473,
0.041124846786260605,
0.4728550910949707,
0.15660487115383148,
0.19230681657791138,
-0.838779091835022,
0.5103941559791565,
-0.321313738822937,
-0.6423814296722412,
-0.2848314344882965,
-0.4477529525756836,
-0.6016764640808105,
0.2752196490764618,
0.07099895924329758,
-0.8496882915496826,
0.05951026827096939,
0.05116366222500801,
-0.43747738003730774,
0.2733272314071655,
-0.6413044929504395,
0.9541822075843811,
-0.3756483197212219,
-0.35872262716293335,
-0.2213316708803177,
-0.26614728569984436,
0.441800057888031,
-0.5794187784194946,
0.07208974659442902,
-0.28294891119003296,
0.3388366997241974,
0.3999508321285248,
-0.7764787077903748,
0.673149049282074,
-0.25546035170555115,
-0.08852200210094452,
0.09115342050790787,
0.1651863306760788,
0.7528150677680969,
0.04448327049612999,
-0.3770443797111511,
0.18186452984809875,
-0.005184993613511324,
-0.23954381048679352,
-0.5850075483322144,
0.9526841044425964,
-0.6903755068778992,
-0.8337032198905945,
-0.27202099561691284,
-0.42838752269744873,
-0.6759603023529053,
0.19091302156448364,
0.0758046954870224,
0.22625187039375305,
-0.21398045122623444,
0.0040895650163292885,
0.036608461290597916,
-0.2640918791294098,
0.19810117781162262,
0.890953779220581,
-0.08050953596830368,
-0.051820795983076096,
0.7358043193817139,
0.017971819266676903,
0.391223281621933,
-0.15269383788108826,
0.29424214363098145,
0.01979030855000019,
-1.0490145683288574,
-0.31353020668029785,
0.14013947546482086,
-0.6415044069290161,
-0.1741674244403839,
-0.11623473465442657,
-0.1773376613855362,
0.07981017976999283,
0.0774843692779541,
-0.41874295473098755,
-0.417069673538208,
-0.06795434653759003,
-0.30138659477233887,
0.17904388904571533,
0.981567919254303,
0.12340554594993591,
0.23346084356307983,
-0.5489488244056702,
0.29954949021339417,
0.3489162027835846,
1.0748027563095093,
-0.1059737280011177,
-0.8480494022369385,
-0.4431765079498291,
-0.24634836614131927,
-0.45762789249420166,
-0.43235623836517334,
0.0011761601781472564,
0.015964200720191002,
0.6965829133987427,
0.45956021547317505,
-0.19492946565151215,
0.6841155886650085,
-0.8403597474098206,
0.7079026699066162,
-0.034904852509498596,
-0.9507209658622742,
0.41526973247528076,
-0.4915197491645813,
0.11987575143575668,
0.605679452419281,
-0.09265157580375671,
-0.020071491599082947,
-0.8092159032821655,
-0.41331470012664795,
-0.5161213874816895,
0.845360517501831,
0.08216452598571777,
0.1405935138463974,
-0.056998055428266525,
0.6711052656173706,
0.38840505480766296,
0.2615208625793457,
-0.617638111114502,
0.12152750790119171,
-0.039561476558446884,
-0.02929696999490261,
-0.2204829603433609,
-0.41236093640327454,
0.014190232381224632,
-0.43478187918663025,
0.48246896266937256,
-0.040398985147476196,
-0.009444544091820717,
-0.14227814972400665,
0.05330083146691322,
-0.23141172528266907,
0.5597370266914368,
0.44852253794670105,
0.8380177021026611,
-0.33931219577789307,
-0.1157911866903305,
0.23161648213863373,
-0.128304123878479,
-0.03635215759277344,
0.38107579946517944,
-0.18380343914031982,
-0.25965258479118347,
0.357714980840683,
0.9534030556678772,
0.3429313004016876,
-0.43501317501068115,
0.6673703789710999,
0.05789002403616905,
-0.23041169345378876,
-0.18536920845508575,
0.3725747764110565,
0.07188999652862549,
0.6843760013580322,
-0.14845940470695496,
0.29067566990852356,
0.20824341475963593,
-0.35848888754844666,
0.14021503925323486,
0.6429265737533569,
-0.47037968039512634,
-0.2770911455154419,
1.0478968620300293,
0.21658866107463837,
-0.08534831553697586,
0.3816881775856018,
-0.270969033241272,
-0.3589038550853729,
0.5883384346961975,
0.41194745898246765,
0.77084881067276,
0.0878056064248085,
-0.12900188565254211,
0.12370526045560837,
0.32366299629211426,
-0.3032151460647583,
0.1872790902853012,
0.0036106945481151342,
-0.6095162630081177,
-0.5664276480674744,
-0.9685479998588562,
-0.5907729268074036,
0.25582706928253174,
-0.6178032159805298,
0.10984262079000473,
-0.36996540427207947,
-0.5164738893508911,
-0.036587610840797424,
0.1580967903137207,
-1.0887186527252197,
0.18444111943244934,
0.134286567568779,
0.9244025945663452,
-0.4922228157520294,
0.8168198466300964,
0.4339718818664551,
-0.2830916941165924,
-0.9252588152885437,
0.012874539941549301,
-0.11773340404033661,
-0.7460685968399048,
0.7003867030143738,
0.17759211361408234,
-0.05775051936507225,
-0.30563321709632874,
-0.42173928022384644,
-0.6579524278640747,
0.856278657913208,
0.6636170148849487,
-1.0147985219955444,
0.12012438476085663,
0.08775937557220459,
0.718616783618927,
-0.18779584765434265,
0.40705105662345886,
1.0075247287750244,
0.8017420172691345,
-0.34676414728164673,
-1.6140098571777344,
0.10112405568361282,
-0.19250479340553284,
0.12844429910182953,
0.03391245752573013,
-0.7755782008171082,
0.7664554715156555,
-0.22040405869483948,
0.18384936451911926,
0.4615429937839508,
0.25905001163482666,
0.29671695828437805,
0.24739313125610352,
0.44081881642341614,
0.6194603443145752,
0.7930837273597717,
-0.23766127228736877,
1.4363924264907837,
-0.4411684572696686,
0.6747048497200012,
1.3720296621322632,
-0.42336326837539673,
0.6477444767951965,
0.029111862182617188,
-0.25036320090293884,
0.21513043344020844,
0.5499718189239502,
-0.4860263466835022,
0.40843498706817627,
0.4099352955818176,
0.027721906080842018,
-0.45915231108665466,
0.17156249284744263,
-0.06314064562320709,
0.6097498536109924,
-0.004543965216726065,
-0.49290260672569275,
-0.1760866791009903,
-0.14795367419719696,
-0.06014380231499672,
0.2150537073612213,
-0.6226439476013184,
0.3747539520263672,
0.2524380087852478,
-0.6999291777610779,
0.4544425308704376,
0.3632605969905853,
0.6273559927940369,
-0.43382054567337036,
0.21703538298606873,
-0.1766146868467331,
0.3792843222618103,
-0.3034552037715912,
-0.6360602378845215,
0.04537577927112579,
0.25047948956489563,
-0.024750323966145515,
0.08807915449142456,
0.651498019695282,
0.04745765030384064,
-0.4551663100719452,
0.4551756978034973,
0.533658504486084,
0.22493939101696014,
-0.33232635259628296,
-0.46845313906669617,
-0.06448448449373245,
-0.21544957160949707,
-0.5674116015434265,
0.41584891080856323,
0.6988257765769958,
-0.16109059751033783,
0.586515486240387,
0.3444577753543854,
0.37901315093040466,
-0.04543326050043106,
0.43766045570373535,
0.7875407934188843,
-0.8138583898544312,
-0.2080567330121994,
-0.9589515924453735,
0.19035635888576508,
0.25940924882888794,
-0.26695093512535095,
0.7621849775314331,
0.48997774720191956,
0.9018186330795288,
-0.07046154886484146,
0.9082961678504944,
0.21432901918888092,
0.5545252561569214,
-0.6149168014526367,
0.610227108001709,
-0.622679591178894,
0.42526742815971375,
-0.3954959511756897,
-0.8568602800369263,
-0.06464797258377075,
0.26628464460372925,
-0.6056276559829712,
0.5091825127601624,
0.6976478695869446,
0.45554181933403015,
-0.3282855451107025,
0.010147321037948132,
0.6876275539398193,
0.3295592963695526,
0.32278507947921753,
0.7213268876075745,
0.8637340068817139,
-0.010385282337665558,
0.5090404748916626,
-0.03477337956428528,
-0.13944031298160553,
-0.37447866797447205,
-0.5480475425720215,
-1.0999337434768677,
-0.13271817564964294,
-0.06248375028371811,
-0.07445228099822998,
-0.16286341845989227,
0.43885934352874756,
0.5997747778892517,
-0.8280008435249329,
0.01592366397380829,
0.0306161530315876,
-0.08657419681549072,
-0.22329989075660706,
-0.2168327122926712,
0.3109320402145386,
-0.6001429557800293,
-0.9148152470588684,
0.5398966670036316,
0.19446173310279846,
-0.4893345236778259,
-0.18923413753509521,
-0.2595379650592804,
0.4548507034778595,
0.07456979155540466,
0.5574359893798828,
-0.11373298615217209,
-0.9337125420570374,
-0.6650674939155579,
-0.4231979250907898,
-0.05552123859524727,
0.021758783608675003,
0.6048633456230164,
-0.5765216946601868,
0.5401990413665771,
0.05176197737455368,
0.535079836845398,
0.5395439863204956,
0.1385401487350464,
0.653416097164154,
-0.4033823311328888,
-0.2570362389087677,
0.18525952100753784,
0.6788815855979919,
-0.02928854152560234,
-0.1788000464439392,
0.7384761571884155,
-0.0022298165131360292,
-0.9772194027900696,
-0.5887623429298401,
0.2858838737010956,
-0.9879991412162781,
-0.10171051323413849,
1.2864229679107666,
-0.24604064226150513,
0.2975856363773346,
0.08021241426467896,
0.04619620740413666,
0.07068343460559845,
-0.3486101031303406,
0.5013352632522583,
1.0163683891296387,
-0.34331774711608887,
0.14545594155788422,
-1.0834693908691406,
0.3661789000034332,
0.4364500939846039,
-0.6237433552742004,
-0.07068407535552979,
0.512174665927887,
0.8328633904457092,
-0.10051531344652176,
0.5381516814231873,
-0.36339569091796875,
0.2811248302459717,
-0.29554283618927,
-0.18969255685806274,
-0.3445488214492798,
-0.02128586359322071,
-0.5119144320487976,
0.35424432158470154,
0.634695291519165,
0.05142662301659584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02799v1
|
DPPA: Pruning Method for Large Language Model to Model Merging
| 2024-03-05T09:12:49 | 2024-03-05T09:12:49 |
Yaochen Zhu, Rui Xia, Jiajun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Model merging is to combine fine-tuned models derived from multiple domains,
with the intent of enhancing the model's proficiency across various domains.
The principal concern is the resolution of parameter conflicts. A substantial
amount of existing research remedy this issue during the merging stage, with
the latest study focusing on resolving this issue throughout the pruning stage.
The DARE approach has exhibited promising outcomes when applied to a simplistic
fine-tuned model. However, the efficacy of this method tends to wane when
employed on complex fine-tuned models that show a significant parameter bias
relative to the baseline model. In this paper, we introduce a dual-stage method
termed Dynamic Pruning Partition Amplification (DPPA), devised to tackle the
challenge of merging complex fine-tuned models. Initially, we introduce
Dynamically Pruning (DP), an improved approach based on magnitude pruning,
which aim is to enhance performance at higher pruning rates. Subsequently, we
propose Dynamically Partition Amplification (DPA), a rescaling strategy, is
designed to dynamically amplify parameter partitions in relation to their
significance levels. The experimental results show that our method maintains a
mere 20% of domain-specific parameters and yet delivers a performance
comparable to other methodologies that preserve up to 90% of parameters.
Furthermore, our method displays outstanding performance post-pruning, leading
to a significant improvement of nearly 20% performance in model merging. We
make our code on Github.
|
[
-0.6803587079048157,
-1.045498013496399,
0.4149094223976135,
0.3135051429271698,
-0.47217828035354614,
0.47294938564300537,
-0.32287082076072693,
-0.4179420471191406,
-0.18596875667572021,
0.19605258107185364,
-0.6914873719215393,
-0.15848776698112488,
-0.4887315034866333,
-0.24533647298812866,
-0.22208699584007263,
0.5251379013061523,
0.00611515250056982,
-0.10203571617603302,
-0.16204626858234406,
0.08380820602178574,
-0.6630494594573975,
-0.3883230984210968,
-0.5520811080932617,
-0.17955508828163147,
0.49106594920158386,
0.3882882297039032,
0.7384133338928223,
0.8563869595527649,
0.5952814221382141,
0.3964899182319641,
-0.6064968109130859,
0.6605920791625977,
-0.41558247804641724,
0.6032390594482422,
0.07979390025138855,
-0.24876675009727478,
-0.5526993870735168,
-0.04459882155060768,
1.1309059858322144,
0.8113285303115845,
-0.20516236126422882,
0.1114189401268959,
0.03374607861042023,
0.4741678535938263,
-0.5096179246902466,
0.2497115582227707,
-0.5241926312446594,
-0.13508157432079315,
-0.23141886293888092,
-0.2056577503681183,
-0.3546445965766907,
-0.47096550464630127,
-0.28962478041648865,
-0.35018831491470337,
-0.008489489555358887,
-0.10348895937204361,
0.8213887214660645,
0.6140882968902588,
-0.8204607963562012,
0.21815307438373566,
-1.155777931213379,
1.0291697978973389,
-0.940587043762207,
0.3577916622161865,
-0.10149744898080826,
0.42153987288475037,
-0.39697444438934326,
-0.5755374431610107,
-0.8108242750167847,
-0.21450309455394745,
0.10237918794155121,
-0.49701184034347534,
0.17233900725841522,
0.1175854429602623,
0.3792956471443176,
0.7587487101554871,
-0.12986071407794952,
0.28815001249313354,
-0.2435009926557541,
-0.06279129534959793,
0.9400232434272766,
0.12045252323150635,
0.3642887473106384,
0.18105864524841309,
-0.2917759418487549,
-0.5593662858009338,
-0.6853426098823547,
-0.20361964404582977,
0.797609806060791,
0.4196532666683197,
0.09451386332511902,
0.3990013003349304,
-0.05923106521368027,
1.0516279935836792,
0.2068772166967392,
-0.41624435782432556,
0.26833173632621765,
-0.49305620789527893,
-0.04731852561235428,
-0.17895746231079102,
0.6298294067382812,
0.19749818742275238,
0.13267995417118073,
0.20926499366760254,
-0.1822437345981598,
0.007276454009115696,
0.2656089663505554,
-0.8149252533912659,
-0.36158570647239685,
0.3702481985092163,
-0.22948983311653137,
-0.5294932723045349,
-0.34783223271369934,
-1.0308748483657837,
-0.39538073539733887,
-0.511725664138794,
0.14173169434070587,
-0.5051223039627075,
-0.6808689832687378,
-0.05376003682613373,
0.17894385755062103,
-0.011712171137332916,
0.4451996386051178,
-0.8240247368812561,
0.18124280869960785,
1.0018669366836548,
0.6278460621833801,
-0.20753757655620575,
-0.3047870993614197,
-0.6124194860458374,
0.13241922855377197,
-0.2593346834182739,
0.4406408369541168,
-0.5249287486076355,
-0.3188219368457794,
-0.03456898778676987,
-0.24528206884860992,
-0.0029015010222792625,
-0.7281880378723145,
0.6153220534324646,
-0.7121667861938477,
-0.02458850108087063,
-0.2585848271846771,
-0.5129207968711853,
-0.3920915424823761,
0.36613985896110535,
-0.6813087463378906,
0.9640988707542419,
-0.0033225477673113346,
-0.5417843461036682,
0.46551966667175293,
-0.2864339351654053,
-0.5130590796470642,
0.1317823827266693,
-0.21176086366176605,
-0.591117262840271,
0.15937954187393188,
0.12475071102380753,
0.18263529241085052,
-0.2936367988586426,
0.8437730073928833,
-0.4451467990875244,
-0.1976683884859085,
0.09667699784040451,
-0.7439684271812439,
0.7053693532943726,
0.2509559094905853,
-0.1429256945848465,
0.39270463585853577,
-0.8956870436668396,
0.0632835105061531,
0.1793418526649475,
-0.5090387463569641,
-0.3031938970088959,
0.03567587211728096,
-0.11486823856830597,
0.22327175736427307,
0.41596338152885437,
-0.4538463354110718,
0.7128027081489563,
-0.519555389881134,
0.4637126922607422,
0.5303972363471985,
0.25077253580093384,
0.4333771765232086,
-0.21813265979290009,
0.3735564053058624,
-0.03886820003390312,
0.09934049099683762,
-0.024925682693719864,
-0.43412116169929504,
-0.6699410676956177,
-0.40503498911857605,
0.6018218994140625,
0.25383976101875305,
-0.3953554034233093,
0.6625159382820129,
-0.15382570028305054,
-0.5835596919059753,
-0.30815717577934265,
-0.038097769021987915,
0.3195025622844696,
0.37330570816993713,
0.2213398516178131,
-0.25514930486679077,
-0.3828444182872772,
-0.9959783554077148,
-0.08560203015804291,
-0.3395228385925293,
-0.028219960629940033,
0.23678269982337952,
0.0951341986656189,
0.10215859115123749,
0.8415592908859253,
-0.7355714440345764,
-0.1880379021167755,
-0.15661141276359558,
0.13893547654151917,
0.13410073518753052,
0.7663711905479431,
0.4550674855709076,
-1.240237832069397,
-0.6391612887382507,
-0.1397671103477478,
-0.2988990545272827,
0.011616379953920841,
-0.04079113155603409,
0.09395317733287811,
-0.14931036531925201,
0.17835180461406708,
-0.5290042757987976,
0.0955103188753128,
0.6557846069335938,
-0.21248750388622284,
0.5319167971611023,
-0.2248900979757309,
0.3634135127067566,
-0.89373779296875,
-0.12142161279916763,
-0.13776172697544098,
-0.18422819674015045,
-0.6942156553268433,
0.41815680265426636,
0.15947225689888,
-0.28423768281936646,
-0.5505785346031189,
0.42391934990882874,
-0.6855329871177673,
0.25651153922080994,
-0.5174812078475952,
-0.12308050692081451,
-0.09412729740142822,
0.4710882604122162,
-0.1854531615972519,
0.7064905166625977,
0.47155889868736267,
-0.7155095934867859,
0.6753250360488892,
0.24690912663936615,
-0.22209866344928741,
0.01318695954978466,
-0.4038563072681427,
-0.04202650859951973,
0.24512766301631927,
0.3213675320148468,
-1.12787663936615,
-0.22875908017158508,
0.10283207148313522,
-0.1506691575050354,
0.8341506719589233,
-0.40360864996910095,
-0.5823261737823486,
-0.43553426861763,
-0.1716102957725525,
0.7544004917144775,
0.5383796691894531,
-0.49375930428504944,
0.5281277298927307,
0.6997646689414978,
-0.36789408326148987,
-0.2395416498184204,
-0.5195531845092773,
0.02642131596803665,
-0.49793583154678345,
-0.8946616053581238,
0.7884940505027771,
-0.11830800026655197,
-0.28718575835227966,
-0.17704352736473083,
-0.22228631377220154,
-0.2527042627334595,
-0.06406930088996887,
0.11074496060609818,
0.26864248514175415,
0.09807887673377991,
-0.026517556980252266,
0.3224808871746063,
0.030069759115576744,
-0.2654672861099243,
0.09196442365646362,
0.8190564513206482,
0.17564231157302856,
-0.4732966423034668,
-0.5830880403518677,
0.2605706751346588,
0.8698152303695679,
-0.526753842830658,
0.9651540517807007,
0.4311481714248657,
-0.2845863401889801,
-0.28862547874450684,
-0.6957085728645325,
-0.3527960777282715,
-0.5175994038581848,
0.15832707285881042,
-0.5781539082527161,
-0.7780119776725769,
0.6625590920448303,
-0.5452966690063477,
0.28966671228408813,
0.21648390591144562,
0.65897136926651,
0.392008513212204,
1.1788733005523682,
0.8353023529052734,
0.047628358006477356,
0.5127769112586975,
-0.2217070609331131,
0.5642492771148682,
-0.8626328706741333,
-0.26207435131073,
-0.40575453639030457,
-0.6344202160835266,
-0.5593723058700562,
-0.7758268117904663,
0.05378340557217598,
0.10207682847976685,
0.05578731372952461,
0.20791015028953552,
-0.6993601322174072,
0.19993464648723602,
0.4606570303440094,
-0.21621324121952057,
0.4167023301124573,
-0.03352401405572891,
0.051299087703228,
-0.2113189995288849,
-0.6465187668800354,
-0.24521149694919586,
0.60002601146698,
0.5954171419143677,
0.3779849708080292,
0.2822337746620178,
0.6281536817550659,
-0.01951378583908081,
-0.15051503479480743,
-0.8469353318214417,
0.8401567339897156,
-0.11027888208627701,
-0.5935519933700562,
-0.5702501535415649,
-0.6310932040214539,
-0.7062032222747803,
0.550830602645874,
-0.1598772406578064,
-0.4896015524864197,
0.5644635558128357,
0.260036438703537,
-0.3802982568740845,
0.43754488229751587,
-0.5209612846374512,
0.5993573665618896,
-0.1743471622467041,
-0.49578604102134705,
-0.5051364898681641,
-0.32563984394073486,
0.6370837688446045,
-0.33848273754119873,
0.15435534715652466,
-0.36869901418685913,
-0.09035470336675644,
0.6268208026885986,
-0.6093709468841553,
0.6486223936080933,
-0.31836047768592834,
-0.3788023889064789,
0.1302838921546936,
0.28689485788345337,
0.7714034914970398,
0.04239532724022865,
-0.06842868030071259,
0.10514144599437714,
0.044975198805332184,
-0.15939125418663025,
-0.6360955834388733,
1.0050489902496338,
-0.4417487382888794,
-0.7356985807418823,
-0.25242844223976135,
-0.8798859715461731,
-0.47086697816848755,
0.23599304258823395,
-0.2960926294326782,
0.3879365921020508,
0.04378502443432808,
0.28916841745376587,
0.6141377091407776,
-0.286531537771225,
0.31643587350845337,
0.6976146101951599,
-0.14144189655780792,
-0.15874531865119934,
0.731206476688385,
0.15132495760917664,
0.15456758439540863,
0.2660859525203705,
0.1581411212682724,
-0.11180146783590317,
-0.9096320271492004,
-0.38365989923477173,
0.4021831154823303,
-0.2401609569787979,
-0.28455850481987,
-0.41262152791023254,
-0.19949468970298767,
-0.5310617685317993,
0.2584366500377655,
-0.6954163908958435,
-0.450667142868042,
0.19712349772453308,
0.19233988225460052,
0.2940447926521301,
0.29573893547058105,
0.07569613307714462,
0.27638673782348633,
-0.9790351986885071,
0.2658557891845703,
0.0946049764752388,
0.2862042784690857,
0.10481372475624084,
-0.4364953339099884,
0.046721816062927246,
0.1026039868593216,
-0.29969078302383423,
-1.0018038749694824,
0.6466384530067444,
0.1633089780807495,
0.538110077381134,
0.1967153400182724,
0.43791651725769043,
0.8752133250236511,
-0.4506072998046875,
0.6647459864616394,
0.03512946516275406,
-0.7115709781646729,
0.6207370758056641,
-0.5708073377609253,
0.14827032387256622,
0.6460068821907043,
0.3252584934234619,
-0.20649398863315582,
-0.42826682329177856,
-0.5902696847915649,
-1.2391799688339233,
0.6335046887397766,
-0.010678282007575035,
-0.03745737299323082,
0.2369159758090973,
0.37354663014411926,
-0.16290594637393951,
0.3174341320991516,
-0.30215737223625183,
-0.13443952798843384,
0.7191699147224426,
-0.08119766414165497,
0.012720217928290367,
-0.47484055161476135,
-0.5376797318458557,
-0.4692430794239044,
0.6099210977554321,
0.1522628664970398,
-0.2750436067581177,
-0.3530319631099701,
0.21371400356292725,
-0.19543567299842834,
0.08213485032320023,
0.29270079731941223,
0.8778160810470581,
-0.2118385285139084,
-0.1251482367515564,
0.028010182082653046,
-0.4082522690296173,
0.31823185086250305,
0.34279316663742065,
-0.2947186529636383,
-0.2245253026485443,
0.30010995268821716,
0.8085587620735168,
0.17800703644752502,
-0.6056559681892395,
0.38398104906082153,
-0.15146052837371826,
-0.238875150680542,
-0.06695224344730377,
0.19266776740550995,
-0.13173937797546387,
0.24077342450618744,
0.3162800073623657,
-0.017891045659780502,
-0.002657382283359766,
-0.6035805940628052,
0.3292635381221771,
0.3501688539981842,
-0.007803497835993767,
-0.106325663626194,
0.4437200129032135,
0.49512821435928345,
-0.20547473430633545,
0.8773555755615234,
-0.1604502946138382,
-0.5708761215209961,
0.5685411095619202,
0.3310980498790741,
0.5659013390541077,
-0.4133000373840332,
-0.06603860855102539,
0.43070414662361145,
0.04631292447447777,
-0.09339768439531326,
-0.060608308762311935,
-0.3367033004760742,
-0.5756412744522095,
-1.0348150730133057,
-0.9121354222297668,
-0.34996041655540466,
0.1813523769378662,
-0.5346340537071228,
0.3417738080024719,
-0.2447131872177124,
-0.1383456289768219,
0.009576627053320408,
0.5537192225456238,
-0.0781828835606575,
0.26458969712257385,
0.027154529467225075,
0.9191386699676514,
-1.009065866470337,
1.2188512086868286,
0.7051243185997009,
-0.24610772728919983,
-1.179240345954895,
0.2721843421459198,
0.11805551499128342,
-0.36887815594673157,
0.589372992515564,
-0.10996346175670624,
0.3118961751461029,
-0.0266302227973938,
0.1342640519142151,
-0.9456158876419067,
0.915554940700531,
0.4707697331905365,
-0.966106116771698,
-0.04675115644931793,
-0.024587322026491165,
0.3934304416179657,
-0.09846607595682144,
-0.3585790693759918,
0.6454432010650635,
0.8464711904525757,
0.6261742115020752,
-1.0640192031860352,
0.2670028507709503,
-0.12647207081317902,
-0.14575397968292236,
0.6812701225280762,
-0.7162861824035645,
0.9220647811889648,
0.012632242403924465,
-0.36351972818374634,
-0.0867583230137825,
0.6312717795372009,
0.3613151013851166,
0.26025429368019104,
0.8770820498466492,
0.5400718450546265,
0.9282974004745483,
-0.20832692086696625,
0.7214170694351196,
-0.528773844242096,
0.3972739279270172,
1.0705891847610474,
-0.3396613597869873,
0.8701968789100647,
0.613078773021698,
-0.4008517265319824,
0.2149461954832077,
0.6667174100875854,
-0.06421775370836258,
0.5083749294281006,
0.2336881458759308,
-0.33724918961524963,
-0.2941850423812866,
0.06140604987740517,
-0.5411535501480103,
0.3493221700191498,
0.18124370276927948,
-0.07783615589141846,
-0.01675858348608017,
0.06442084908485413,
-0.05744927376508713,
0.21409901976585388,
0.039333526045084,
0.8398829102516174,
-0.1435735821723938,
-0.9232914447784424,
0.71788090467453,
0.09365475177764893,
0.7028458714485168,
-0.6448598504066467,
-0.06872209161520004,
-0.13233508169651031,
0.5075767040252686,
-0.11487971246242523,
-0.713747501373291,
0.6715572476387024,
-0.29431286454200745,
-0.2114097625017166,
-0.3480222821235657,
0.8331071734428406,
-0.7054192423820496,
-0.38925305008888245,
0.3283785879611969,
0.18734806776046753,
-0.016110477969050407,
-0.14567634463310242,
-0.60564124584198,
0.7273197770118713,
0.3548048138618469,
-0.3023349344730377,
0.6772494912147522,
0.2010982483625412,
0.018451739102602005,
0.710529088973999,
0.689857542514801,
0.45931878685951233,
-0.13098862767219543,
0.03855098411440849,
1.1603745222091675,
-0.25502100586891174,
-0.39986884593963623,
-0.7972870469093323,
0.598033607006073,
-0.26857292652130127,
-0.012290006503462791,
0.8194963335990906,
0.5115837454795837,
0.6053377389907837,
0.13541877269744873,
0.3321400582790375,
-0.14026181399822235,
0.5586183071136475,
-0.2045806497335434,
0.5120986700057983,
-0.8029391765594482,
0.5890945196151733,
0.07356411218643188,
-1.2643866539001465,
-0.32284173369407654,
0.2821633219718933,
-0.447733998298645,
0.06974390149116516,
0.25919851660728455,
0.7069659233093262,
-0.21464450657367706,
-0.3510693907737732,
0.3479224741458893,
0.2305617779493332,
0.5972785949707031,
0.2318469136953354,
0.5788136124610901,
-0.14684799313545227,
0.5565223693847656,
-0.4797806739807129,
-0.5826142430305481,
-0.2333831787109375,
-0.854207456111908,
-0.3206128478050232,
-0.6359056830406189,
-0.6632054448127747,
-0.21056580543518066,
0.01787586696445942,
0.34843909740448,
0.9572624564170837,
-0.4499966502189636,
-0.03505067899823189,
-0.14670351147651672,
-0.036296673119068146,
-0.2787739038467407,
-0.24565063416957855,
0.2271573543548584,
-0.30202749371528625,
-1.280103325843811,
0.7021659016609192,
0.26968449354171753,
-0.22991934418678284,
-0.5869607925415039,
0.11720874905586243,
-0.3200643062591553,
0.18069258332252502,
0.307301789522171,
0.30460554361343384,
-0.4854092597961426,
0.06552401185035706,
-0.6383736729621887,
0.23671402037143707,
-0.2599484324455261,
0.8526492714881897,
-0.6577691435813904,
0.37921959161758423,
0.8968051671981812,
0.45874840021133423,
0.5735645890235901,
0.30359703302383423,
1.0068202018737793,
-0.9104160666465759,
0.534134030342102,
0.3779887855052948,
0.12442026287317276,
0.392425000667572,
-0.4019770622253418,
0.32232484221458435,
0.005352537147700787,
-0.7551036477088928,
-1.3970558643341064,
0.5502997636795044,
-1.0064209699630737,
-0.5471145510673523,
1.0832713842391968,
-0.08571963012218475,
-0.04362119734287262,
0.26143625378608704,
-0.21401934325695038,
0.5221624970436096,
-0.21605074405670166,
0.619502067565918,
0.5230318307876587,
-0.059164345264434814,
-0.13645949959754944,
-0.3514290452003479,
0.6250793933868408,
0.41806867718696594,
-0.4226127564907074,
0.3750964105129242,
0.5535056591033936,
0.08203358948230743,
0.3323659896850586,
0.21096457540988922,
-0.2135043740272522,
-0.12350787222385406,
0.19901783764362335,
-0.1849183440208435,
-0.3728320300579071,
-0.4472253620624542,
-0.3873995840549469,
0.5140581727027893,
0.3325512409210205,
-0.32286155223846436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02795v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02795v2
|
Evaluating and Optimizing Educational Content with Large Language Model Judgments
| 2024-03-05T09:09:15 | 2024-05-06T04:54:19 |
Joy He-Yueya, Noah D. Goodman, Emma Brunskill
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Creating effective educational materials generally requires expensive and
time-consuming studies of student learning outcomes. To overcome this barrier,
one idea is to build computational models of student learning and use them to
optimize instructional materials. However, it is difficult to model the
cognitive processes of learning dynamics. We propose an alternative approach
that uses Language Models (LMs) as educational experts to assess the impact of
various instructions on learning outcomes. Specifically, we use GPT-3.5 to
evaluate the overall effect of instructional materials on different student
groups and find that it can replicate well-established educational findings
such as the Expertise Reversal Effect and the Variability Effect. This
demonstrates the potential of LMs as reliable evaluators of educational
content. Building on this insight, we introduce an instruction optimization
approach in which one LM generates instructional materials using the judgments
of another LM as a reward function. We apply this approach to create math word
problem worksheets aimed at maximizing student learning gains. Human teachers'
evaluations of these LM-generated worksheets show a significant alignment
between the LM judgments and human teacher preferences. We conclude by
discussing potential divergences between human and LM opinions and the
resulting pitfalls of automating instructional design.
|
[
-0.1659417450428009,
-0.9497475028038025,
0.5821378827095032,
-0.022040221840143204,
-0.055447209626436234,
0.2620618939399719,
-0.49271243810653687,
-0.05791829898953438,
-0.10690924525260925,
0.26709964871406555,
-0.3499569594860077,
-0.3408052623271942,
-0.5673784017562866,
-0.20404092967510223,
-0.24731320142745972,
0.961020827293396,
-0.21426516771316528,
0.2694467604160309,
-0.28403282165527344,
0.24222059547901154,
-0.5873354077339172,
-0.3569950759410858,
-0.6431877017021179,
-0.5570566654205322,
0.4494389593601227,
0.5191214084625244,
0.8627018928527832,
0.703546941280365,
0.42256826162338257,
0.3113158047199249,
0.18818184733390808,
-0.015024389140307903,
-0.5390280485153198,
-0.2179684340953827,
-0.3193909227848053,
-0.3230103552341461,
-0.21575994789600372,
0.24218648672103882,
0.42243802547454834,
0.855722188949585,
-0.5083925724029541,
0.07648114860057831,
0.2270086407661438,
0.7425181865692139,
-0.6683444380760193,
0.23710402846336365,
-0.3287484347820282,
0.20459391176700592,
0.21847198903560638,
-0.31503260135650635,
-0.4434482455253601,
-0.6526498198509216,
0.40377476811408997,
-0.4140617549419403,
-0.0123093631118536,
-0.29238590598106384,
0.530207097530365,
0.13927051424980164,
-0.0686144009232521,
-0.665645956993103,
-0.7414459586143494,
1.056136965751648,
-0.5726553201675415,
0.5456341505050659,
0.5052257776260376,
0.1825326681137085,
-0.0708002895116806,
-0.3258599638938904,
-0.44558435678482056,
-0.32746198773384094,
0.15830323100090027,
0.4009529650211334,
0.062001559883356094,
-0.10707199573516846,
0.05751536041498184,
0.26733726263046265,
-0.4559233784675598,
0.2018432766199112,
-0.48683851957321167,
-0.12327519059181213,
0.5862679481506348,
0.3629404604434967,
0.545271635055542,
-0.14102056622505188,
-0.32355743646621704,
-0.3331112861633301,
-0.5857760310173035,
0.08894577622413635,
0.7239370346069336,
0.3192267417907715,
0.07583630830049515,
0.6093676686286926,
0.15825499594211578,
0.6961673498153687,
-0.25527673959732056,
-0.4315186142921448,
0.07803478837013245,
-0.05018756538629532,
0.08447680622339249,
-0.25309786200523376,
0.5314365029335022,
0.30577877163887024,
0.2634962499141693,
-0.2337869554758072,
-0.36064448952674866,
0.2855360805988312,
0.46930980682373047,
-0.8624283671379089,
-0.3418639004230499,
-0.15952515602111816,
-0.19342480599880219,
-0.32881855964660645,
0.07297353446483612,
-0.711380660533905,
-0.13188327848911285,
-0.8407301902770996,
0.6918724179267883,
-0.4700864851474762,
-0.0802958756685257,
0.3807985782623291,
0.07614196836948395,
-0.05869803577661514,
0.4756842255592346,
-0.9235759377479553,
0.3950594663619995,
0.5948659777641296,
0.5290571451187134,
-0.43232741951942444,
-0.24434766173362732,
-0.376324862241745,
-0.12065599113702774,
-0.5321738123893738,
0.5444552302360535,
-0.7685193419456482,
-0.6623960137367249,
-0.0020094478968530893,
-0.30947670340538025,
-0.011948035098612309,
-0.3700987696647644,
0.4540182948112488,
-0.48297348618507385,
0.5003448128700256,
-0.21525394916534424,
-0.8857386708259583,
-0.14288008213043213,
-0.053385861217975616,
-0.6863495111465454,
0.7424795627593994,
0.40639373660087585,
-0.37932318449020386,
0.1774446815252304,
-0.6193205118179321,
-0.3715782165527344,
0.09980744868516922,
-0.2715200185775757,
-0.22883854806423187,
0.10895833373069763,
-0.1393594741821289,
0.1185135692358017,
-0.379672646522522,
0.2164093554019928,
0.05854425206780434,
-0.3152106702327728,
0.3357243835926056,
-0.4219801723957062,
0.4923374056816101,
0.1941021978855133,
-0.4888703227043152,
-0.13374345004558563,
-0.3642784357070923,
0.09997747838497162,
0.1375119984149933,
-0.7726243734359741,
-0.5008818507194519,
0.2818619906902313,
-0.1436396837234497,
-0.03995918482542038,
0.20092125236988068,
-0.1499672830104828,
0.17157049477100372,
-0.22972586750984192,
0.07193813472986221,
1.0258657932281494,
-0.1219388023018837,
0.5714097023010254,
-0.30593356490135193,
0.7736487984657288,
-0.34575456380844116,
0.07878495752811432,
0.03047027811408043,
-0.3242882490158081,
-0.6886105537414551,
0.06403886526823044,
0.2546834349632263,
0.3849984109401703,
-0.8225098848342896,
-0.010047715157270432,
-0.023343229666352272,
-0.37329035997390747,
-0.37323197722435,
0.5627502799034119,
0.6309953927993774,
0.5008139610290527,
0.20155219733715057,
-0.4719850420951843,
-0.22886216640472412,
-0.8136953115463257,
-0.4931716024875641,
0.005949188023805618,
0.006090492010116577,
0.33388975262641907,
0.4352436065673828,
0.01229726430028677,
0.853157639503479,
-0.7966896295547485,
0.08521490544080734,
-0.13159120082855225,
0.24210752546787262,
0.17096224427223206,
0.48114505410194397,
0.4896852374076843,
-0.6831730604171753,
-0.7017769813537598,
-0.22136765718460083,
-0.4800110459327698,
-0.1411299854516983,
-0.1306096315383911,
-0.3081414997577667,
0.28395575284957886,
0.14604808390140533,
-0.36187687516212463,
0.3367675244808197,
0.10393493622541428,
-0.1620226949453354,
0.5884891152381897,
-0.17504167556762695,
0.047226786613464355,
-0.5836922526359558,
-0.22637681663036346,
0.23309208452701569,
0.15178388357162476,
-0.537295937538147,
0.16945204138755798,
0.07022863626480103,
0.01429081056267023,
-0.2652878165245056,
0.5175782442092896,
-0.4656456708908081,
0.07450736314058304,
-0.27815359830856323,
0.22380919754505157,
0.09817089140415192,
0.6250839233398438,
0.1421763300895691,
0.8471641540527344,
0.18706703186035156,
-0.40251871943473816,
0.19704221189022064,
-0.046374477446079254,
-0.6182236671447754,
0.6317145228385925,
-0.6221296787261963,
0.28520500659942627,
-0.2113790512084961,
-0.218455970287323,
-0.5823888778686523,
-0.1317819505929947,
0.16144970059394836,
-0.31356680393218994,
0.45055902004241943,
0.004727642983198166,
-0.34265395998954773,
-0.454216867685318,
-0.4529702067375183,
0.1282108724117279,
0.707515299320221,
-0.47761279344558716,
0.5138572454452515,
0.4758376479148865,
-0.32122117280960083,
-0.5245731472969055,
-0.37785476446151733,
-0.07650331407785416,
-0.15835799276828766,
-0.14574262499809265,
0.1721932739019394,
-0.4900006055831909,
-0.45134156942367554,
0.13830599188804626,
-0.28206586837768555,
-0.09635666757822037,
0.1105230301618576,
0.0005431827739812434,
0.6282982230186462,
-0.08379495143890381,
0.32966485619544983,
-0.022783659398555756,
-0.03457725793123245,
0.2199535071849823,
-0.4666483402252197,
0.39118507504463196,
-0.2018665224313736,
-0.46246302127838135,
0.03199172019958496,
0.28203096985816956,
0.1500975787639618,
-0.12980413436889648,
0.525230348110199,
0.3831511437892914,
-0.3439944386482239,
-0.3764442205429077,
-0.44439706206321716,
-0.234784796833992,
-0.4799692630767822,
0.6662673950195312,
-0.12859582901000977,
-0.4189813435077667,
0.07339929044246674,
0.22602532804012299,
0.10950513184070587,
0.22680936753749847,
0.6357542872428894,
-0.025034844875335693,
1.1720777750015259,
0.5620319843292236,
0.06037641689181328,
0.6329332590103149,
-0.5443801879882812,
0.2425730675458908,
-0.6378581523895264,
-0.22067615389823914,
-0.2955687940120697,
-0.08298470824956894,
-0.22770778834819794,
-0.411837637424469,
0.38778698444366455,
0.061340782791376114,
-0.18134157359600067,
0.2621501684188843,
-0.5069076418876648,
0.7924312353134155,
0.5209715366363525,
0.4136936068534851,
0.11879822611808777,
0.11795279383659363,
-0.22292670607566833,
-0.14502908289432526,
-0.7497252821922302,
-0.7212751507759094,
1.0452195405960083,
0.17015962302684784,
0.9717700481414795,
0.21317709982395172,
0.5226137638092041,
0.22230684757232666,
0.719143807888031,
-0.9022114872932434,
0.49410611391067505,
-0.15658096969127655,
-0.4626636505126953,
-0.39738690853118896,
-0.719412624835968,
-0.9774519205093384,
0.16240490972995758,
-0.2929213047027588,
-0.7056521773338318,
-0.31715884804725647,
-0.16275689005851746,
-0.1716395616531372,
0.3509286344051361,
-0.9299913048744202,
0.9087902903556824,
-0.48377615213394165,
-0.7593221068382263,
-0.4256240725517273,
-0.14996083080768585,
0.2024141550064087,
-0.4260244071483612,
0.5601206421852112,
0.05105037987232208,
0.07447585463523865,
0.8268072605133057,
-0.5131968855857849,
0.7587330341339111,
-0.11632677167654037,
-0.3464938998222351,
0.5634005665779114,
0.25728729367256165,
0.2195737361907959,
-0.21093803644180298,
-0.17082862555980682,
-0.36177298426628113,
-0.29621535539627075,
-0.33358561992645264,
-0.9030510783195496,
0.7263818979263306,
-0.9480462670326233,
-0.8887079954147339,
-0.06880126893520355,
-0.7812805771827698,
-0.06854233145713806,
0.21969062089920044,
-0.08223438262939453,
0.5507156252861023,
-0.09724111109972,
-0.17612776160240173,
0.4230872094631195,
-0.3058881163597107,
0.389925479888916,
0.729561448097229,
-0.028845278546214104,
-0.25364547967910767,
1.4520821571350098,
0.35019156336784363,
0.4500044286251068,
0.17806003987789154,
0.5677338242530823,
-0.31929269433021545,
-0.4212302565574646,
-0.3693312704563141,
0.08089271187782288,
-1.0560213327407837,
-0.0711144357919693,
-0.20360085368156433,
0.027276713401079178,
0.020821744576096535,
-0.31604573130607605,
-0.24675223231315613,
-0.3380996882915497,
-0.3096051812171936,
0.005607936065644026,
-0.10495831072330475,
1.0033634901046753,
-0.08338833600282669,
0.3081215023994446,
-0.6525232195854187,
0.05247657001018524,
0.6581144332885742,
0.35542041063308716,
0.24154320359230042,
-0.5302751064300537,
-0.5337436199188232,
0.3140365779399872,
-0.5694975852966309,
-0.7871032953262329,
0.4797994792461395,
0.062468454241752625,
0.7078224420547485,
0.2738010585308075,
-0.10613127797842026,
0.298164039850235,
-0.5364956855773926,
0.4640185236930847,
0.30233460664749146,
-1.081217646598816,
0.39041516184806824,
-0.1824798732995987,
0.19690857827663422,
0.2151731550693512,
0.4944855570793152,
-0.1788617968559265,
-0.28615066409111023,
-0.5786901116371155,
-0.7135772705078125,
0.6955432891845703,
0.12055715918540955,
0.3334444761276245,
-0.0879540666937828,
0.3216821849346161,
0.25874000787734985,
0.24804173409938812,
-0.4331269860267639,
-0.06823933124542236,
-0.18526488542556763,
-0.41079816222190857,
-0.07957623898983002,
-0.11843767017126083,
-0.11661140620708466,
-0.1326354593038559,
0.5740092992782593,
-0.07151121646165848,
-0.07080177962779999,
-0.12633202970027924,
-0.22340460121631622,
-0.2112012356519699,
0.2792936861515045,
0.6192293763160706,
0.9941734671592712,
-0.04589845612645149,
0.02460772544145584,
0.20841608941555023,
-0.6066117882728577,
0.038638047873973846,
-0.17214250564575195,
-0.1671474277973175,
-0.1512330025434494,
0.3453192710876465,
0.6290023922920227,
0.45640280842781067,
-0.6334264278411865,
0.5337610244750977,
-0.03534168004989624,
-0.04150046408176422,
-0.21563847362995148,
0.2919216752052307,
0.08880767226219177,
0.08224928379058838,
0.34162449836730957,
-0.04531506448984146,
0.06265326589345932,
-0.6248787641525269,
0.1338241845369339,
0.34840160608291626,
-0.20444603264331818,
-0.35041576623916626,
0.4969767928123474,
0.090891994535923,
-0.6818361878395081,
0.5167890191078186,
0.01856173761188984,
-0.6937260627746582,
0.8601630330085754,
0.5753692388534546,
0.7464326024055481,
-0.5305215716362,
0.38912612199783325,
0.413521409034729,
0.14053258299827576,
-0.16174225509166718,
0.16577307879924774,
-0.047565486282110214,
-0.6800981760025024,
-0.38079383969306946,
-0.4485044479370117,
-0.7881218791007996,
-0.29717177152633667,
-0.7591638565063477,
0.28274402022361755,
-0.3335752785205841,
-0.14045611023902893,
0.2593708038330078,
-0.07596567273139954,
-0.7563624382019043,
0.2859785258769989,
0.006249091122299433,
0.4237706661224365,
-0.6891703605651855,
0.588790237903595,
0.7311398386955261,
-0.5188730359077454,
-0.9855678677558899,
-0.2200252115726471,
-0.12064875662326813,
-0.8319189548492432,
0.7636559009552002,
-0.0586840845644474,
-0.14290575683116913,
-0.1413760483264923,
-0.5053137540817261,
-0.5620068311691284,
0.6968968510627747,
0.4456609785556793,
-0.36640116572380066,
-0.07839788496494293,
0.20786377787590027,
0.4986857771873474,
-0.39749521017074585,
0.4931797385215759,
0.35176873207092285,
0.39103060960769653,
0.044813692569732666,
-0.558349072933197,
-0.11548428982496262,
-0.2366739958524704,
-0.00475901598110795,
0.25137361884117126,
-0.3627057671546936,
0.9089238047599792,
-0.4698207974433899,
-0.27742108702659607,
-0.2066170871257782,
0.35478025674819946,
0.12173639982938766,
0.11139006912708282,
0.5392955541610718,
0.39688605070114136,
0.6223536133766174,
0.1257850080728531,
1.0976343154907227,
-0.38703101873397827,
0.5474087595939636,
0.9766535758972168,
0.1829729825258255,
0.644837498664856,
0.4733673632144928,
-0.5279631614685059,
0.5519468188285828,
0.6462748050689697,
-0.10634714365005493,
0.33772891759872437,
0.5730558037757874,
-0.1375795602798462,
-0.26646921038627625,
0.003232299815863371,
-0.3008486032485962,
0.34611034393310547,
0.4196361005306244,
-0.09713611751794815,
-0.22422808408737183,
-0.20264729857444763,
0.03932365030050278,
0.36651918292045593,
-0.27611610293388367,
0.4779258966445923,
0.03171493485569954,
-0.7721081376075745,
0.5297731757164001,
0.0646502897143364,
0.2667170464992523,
-0.2937052249908447,
-0.25193750858306885,
-0.17657038569450378,
0.14092789590358734,
-0.10434066504240036,
-0.725493311882019,
0.08683739602565765,
0.03033154085278511,
-0.054068807512521744,
-0.0548001192510128,
0.44387730956077576,
-0.738654375076294,
-0.7360290884971619,
0.06925074011087418,
0.5124614834785461,
0.11164439469575882,
0.3625902831554413,
-0.6298021674156189,
-0.03410305827856064,
-0.13409636914730072,
-0.3018624782562256,
0.28439101576805115,
0.16166463494300842,
0.11054285615682602,
0.601636528968811,
0.6710404753684998,
0.07774823158979416,
-0.2753541171550751,
0.18448327481746674,
0.7637015581130981,
-0.4680790603160858,
-0.33406364917755127,
-0.9292786717414856,
0.40371203422546387,
0.05305413156747818,
-0.15975414216518402,
0.7040700316429138,
0.5697136521339417,
0.9141005873680115,
-0.16209962964057922,
0.860659122467041,
0.3526521921157837,
0.29326170682907104,
-0.5908797383308411,
0.5197522640228271,
-0.542104184627533,
0.5347675681114197,
-0.6615966558456421,
-1.0042626857757568,
0.03210463747382164,
0.7808719873428345,
-0.5130082368850708,
0.28083252906799316,
0.7394137382507324,
0.4335610866546631,
0.07754868268966675,
0.2352084368467331,
0.1937202662229538,
-0.06727226823568344,
0.22431746125221252,
0.7748549580574036,
0.9514436721801758,
-0.2055823653936386,
0.35993731021881104,
-0.36028578877449036,
-0.37042614817619324,
-0.022868022322654724,
-0.7193824648857117,
-1.0435664653778076,
-0.3862771987915039,
-0.33583757281303406,
-0.1505989283323288,
0.0037632337771356106,
1.049056887626648,
0.3384383022785187,
-0.4791080355644226,
-0.4860779941082001,
-0.08493468165397644,
0.4516092836856842,
0.12552015483379364,
-0.2566260099411011,
0.5984780788421631,
-0.512033224105835,
-0.9176753759384155,
0.2538124918937683,
0.02931245230138302,
0.24051903188228607,
-0.45699194073677063,
-0.30682992935180664,
0.25569087266921997,
0.3850697875022888,
0.5837258100509644,
0.0371275432407856,
-0.645403265953064,
-0.2589423954486847,
0.2668321430683136,
-0.280173122882843,
-0.09377578645944595,
0.7955082058906555,
-0.48734205961227417,
0.6776066422462463,
0.3281061053276062,
0.7089024186134338,
0.4329107403755188,
-0.029871702194213867,
0.689561128616333,
-0.13880373537540436,
-0.2516753375530243,
0.14990393817424774,
0.2497929036617279,
0.3429837226867676,
-0.1756831258535385,
0.6519514322280884,
0.14583362638950348,
-0.49422329664230347,
-0.790479302406311,
0.16654805839061737,
-0.42959317564964294,
-0.3684532642364502,
1.0267953872680664,
-0.2775940001010895,
-0.1840982735157013,
0.2863560616970062,
-0.1964867264032364,
0.17402374744415283,
-0.3370305597782135,
1.1883084774017334,
0.9075418710708618,
-0.058999791741371155,
-0.009830423630774021,
-0.7583648562431335,
0.25157660245895386,
0.6982683539390564,
-0.7269810438156128,
-0.2617672383785248,
0.33821383118629456,
0.16430574655532837,
0.14186303317546844,
0.26471152901649475,
-0.08056402951478958,
0.20080649852752686,
-0.05989207327365875,
0.12602220475673676,
-0.02685685083270073,
-0.30309608578681946,
-0.020420335233211517,
-0.04674895480275154,
0.01271413080394268,
0.12650300562381744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15412v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15412v4
|
Towards Measuring and Modeling "Culture" in LLMs: A Survey
| 2024-03-05T08:29:36 | 2024-06-19T05:43:27 |
Muhammad Farid Adilazuarda, Sagnik Mukherjee, Pradhyumna Lavania, Siddhant Singh, Alham Fikri Aji, Jacki O'Neill, Ashutosh Modi, Monojit Choudhury
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We present a survey of more than 90 recent papers that aim to study cultural
representation and inclusion in large language models (LLMs). We observe that
none of the studies explicitly define "culture, which is a complex,
multifaceted concept; instead, they probe the models on some specially designed
datasets which represent certain aspects of "culture". We call these aspects
the proxies of culture, and organize them across two dimensions of demographic
and semantic proxies. We also categorize the probing methods employed. Our
analysis indicates that only certain aspects of ``culture,'' such as values and
objectives, have been studied, leaving several other interesting and important
facets, especially the multitude of semantic domains (Thompson et al., 2020)
and aboutness (Hershcovich et al., 2022), unexplored. Two other crucial gaps
are the lack of robustness of probing techniques and situated studies on the
impact of cultural mis- and under-representation in LLM-based applications.
|
[
-0.6601501107215881,
-0.6198633313179016,
0.4245947003364563,
0.1797761768102646,
-0.032210446894168854,
0.2521038353443146,
-0.3697829246520996,
-0.565525233745575,
0.6499213576316833,
0.3548772931098938,
-0.4662170112133026,
-0.3802141845226288,
-0.5386841893196106,
0.03319342061877251,
-0.22958967089653015,
0.5910661816596985,
-0.04006188362836838,
0.3974112868309021,
-0.512039840221405,
-0.3296770751476288,
-0.26782718300819397,
-0.78148353099823,
-0.0682731345295906,
-0.42506954073905945,
0.354532927274704,
0.2874204218387604,
0.5079415440559387,
0.4798772931098938,
0.31305229663848877,
0.278130441904068,
-0.3617331087589264,
0.15339398384094238,
-0.5126447677612305,
0.3946511447429657,
-0.1364612877368927,
-0.47231486439704895,
-0.5490127801895142,
0.6757593750953674,
0.6613535284996033,
1.1195929050445557,
0.17732901871204376,
0.47540250420570374,
0.21018818020820618,
0.3964770436286926,
-0.5856189131736755,
0.04974175617098808,
-0.24277353286743164,
0.13338841497898102,
-0.24310897290706635,
-0.17748723924160004,
-0.12317686527967453,
-0.2862189710140228,
-0.09837520867586136,
-0.007925272919237614,
0.04661719128489494,
0.031917210668325424,
0.3973132371902466,
-0.12647205591201782,
-1.1047793626785278,
-0.4517182409763336,
-0.9669256806373596,
1.1625328063964844,
-0.26561248302459717,
0.4428042471408844,
0.3877713084220886,
0.20801976323127747,
-0.3116931617259979,
-0.5257198810577393,
-0.4685131013393402,
-0.3780635893344879,
0.015652690082788467,
0.26805567741394043,
-0.1294652670621872,
-0.2518852949142456,
-0.008014705032110214,
0.448932945728302,
-0.38436567783355713,
0.1712873876094818,
-0.23784556984901428,
-0.3683837056159973,
0.6236568093299866,
0.47278958559036255,
0.330025315284729,
0.049400098621845245,
-0.2826525568962097,
0.07283314317464828,
-0.9223939776420593,
0.0894828587770462,
0.3744391202926636,
-0.027130361646413803,
-0.055056214332580566,
0.5053772926330566,
-0.0687677338719368,
0.36930546164512634,
-0.42584115266799927,
-0.16573791205883026,
0.12046583741903305,
-0.4466811716556549,
0.17428012192249298,
-0.2818795442581177,
0.5353721380233765,
0.4074660837650299,
0.4047105610370636,
-0.026153769344091415,
-0.0987955704331398,
0.06758923083543777,
-0.0769333764910698,
-0.6720945835113525,
0.00949854776263237,
0.25597986578941345,
-0.4490405023097992,
-0.19487833976745605,
0.12901020050048828,
-0.41381901502609253,
-0.5179533958435059,
-0.15303930640220642,
-0.20804904401302338,
0.16734939813613892,
-0.6072250008583069,
-0.28055474162101746,
-0.0655069425702095,
0.47175925970077515,
0.272423654794693,
-0.6169513463973999,
0.1241360530257225,
0.825552225112915,
0.7015748023986816,
-0.18737481534481049,
-0.3183910548686981,
-0.059031158685684204,
0.13078227639198303,
-0.7005080580711365,
0.6691948175430298,
-0.6508990526199341,
-0.8753926157951355,
0.36099326610565186,
0.1585223376750946,
0.23853394389152527,
-0.6906653642654419,
0.507250964641571,
-0.5628921389579773,
0.2698969542980194,
-0.5666670799255371,
-0.4846867322921753,
-0.1831359565258026,
0.6284618377685547,
-0.6400367617607117,
0.9524121880531311,
0.0030523212626576424,
-0.4445045590400696,
0.44313040375709534,
-0.38265460729599,
-0.2542164623737335,
-0.021979836747050285,
-0.3099076449871063,
0.103706955909729,
0.2742842137813568,
-0.14502811431884766,
0.5216507911682129,
-0.379962295293808,
0.42070072889328003,
-0.6002932190895081,
-0.5716055035591125,
0.6634947657585144,
-0.4766920506954193,
0.9267526268959045,
0.3943994343280792,
0.03390324488282204,
-0.08113332837820053,
-0.4680876135826111,
-0.03480228781700134,
0.05433008074760437,
-0.4131867289543152,
-0.4200911223888397,
0.1641712337732315,
0.20677155256271362,
0.24468043446540833,
0.4623216390609741,
-0.5278832912445068,
0.26229190826416016,
-0.13415753841400146,
0.48569217324256897,
0.3182385265827179,
-0.3213059902191162,
0.6694709062576294,
-0.19402094185352325,
0.7098481059074402,
0.14746274054050446,
0.21683648228645325,
-0.029710397124290466,
-0.3289042115211487,
-0.6412792205810547,
-0.05195508897304535,
0.23451028764247894,
0.5361016392707825,
-0.4587920904159546,
0.11106942594051361,
-0.21572336554527283,
-0.6959736943244934,
-0.23783943057060242,
0.07121188193559647,
0.1418294459581375,
0.0998770222067833,
-0.08483486622571945,
-0.5427271723747253,
-0.3541044294834137,
-0.890536367893219,
-0.10347239673137665,
-0.5445636510848999,
-0.3228002190589905,
0.1998451203107834,
0.6161192655563354,
-0.22096936404705048,
0.932506799697876,
-0.29772114753723145,
-0.370349258184433,
-0.22787629067897797,
0.0019301578868180513,
0.20698393881320953,
0.4259800910949707,
0.6833593249320984,
-0.7300645112991333,
-0.20271582901477814,
-0.19694514572620392,
-0.8181049823760986,
-0.2392168641090393,
0.562846839427948,
0.2513669729232788,
0.08864516019821167,
0.6061176657676697,
-0.3942314684391022,
0.12820251286029816,
0.8784407377243042,
-0.2717900276184082,
0.5230597257614136,
-0.042281899601221085,
0.174612358212471,
-0.9656469821929932,
-0.11425143480300903,
0.10241088271141052,
0.07262519001960754,
-0.8756536841392517,
0.11450057476758957,
0.15209010243415833,
-0.1644984930753708,
-0.5608492493629456,
0.7772543430328369,
-0.6862061619758606,
-0.07859644293785095,
-0.3250231146812439,
0.24417221546173096,
0.1572018712759018,
0.11971050500869751,
0.2052871733903885,
0.7221506834030151,
0.4892575740814209,
-0.4217660129070282,
0.37277138233184814,
-0.06153722107410431,
-0.5401054620742798,
0.7794967889785767,
-0.4263882339000702,
0.15505823493003845,
-0.19083847105503082,
0.7941040992736816,
-0.987902045249939,
-0.25755175948143005,
0.33762407302856445,
-0.4341738224029541,
0.00960046611726284,
-0.3973294794559479,
-0.5543516874313354,
-0.20323136448860168,
-0.3706049621105194,
0.5530725717544556,
0.5378345251083374,
-0.033552929759025574,
0.6702649593353271,
0.7115535140037537,
0.020121397450566292,
-0.4567949175834656,
-0.6952752470970154,
0.18864507973194122,
-0.6412653923034668,
-0.7558393478393555,
0.26153481006622314,
-0.011075709015130997,
-0.8645959496498108,
-0.22905318439006805,
-0.09176500886678696,
-0.08046883344650269,
0.37631794810295105,
0.20282448828220367,
0.08545361459255219,
-0.5252799391746521,
-0.037751857191324234,
-0.4093281030654907,
0.01371223945170641,
0.25881731510162354,
-0.25013303756713867,
0.49332985281944275,
-0.28244900703430176,
-0.5283678770065308,
-0.055089112371206284,
0.6657024621963501,
0.6454737782478333,
-0.34004923701286316,
0.7513219118118286,
0.671333372592926,
-0.22701656818389893,
-0.1440902054309845,
-0.6924645304679871,
-0.20996615290641785,
-0.44232216477394104,
0.22781823575496674,
-0.22938819229602814,
-1.306785225868225,
0.9237404465675354,
-0.1511898934841156,
-0.09212850779294968,
0.3001249134540558,
0.49593234062194824,
-0.5134049654006958,
0.9062463641166687,
0.7431406378746033,
0.04125510901212692,
0.29662325978279114,
-0.05966710299253464,
0.30020543932914734,
-0.7498262524604797,
-0.18585969507694244,
-0.7784022688865662,
-0.35886773467063904,
-1.0723658800125122,
-0.4486134946346283,
0.6236081123352051,
0.02577386610209942,
-0.1328577846288681,
-0.2473851889371872,
0.12538489699363708,
0.30276602506637573,
0.5632787942886353,
-0.48923811316490173,
0.2725529670715332,
-0.3095892369747162,
0.15060299634933472,
-0.31380581855773926,
-0.6022763252258301,
-0.819717288017273,
0.6902685761451721,
0.6468465328216553,
0.9680531620979309,
0.39265623688697815,
0.3673843443393707,
0.02665160782635212,
0.575698971748352,
-0.9973076581954956,
0.6916555166244507,
-0.33865025639533997,
-0.9596831202507019,
-0.2347385734319687,
-0.0877930149435997,
-0.7520756125450134,
0.5049614906311035,
0.0687178522348404,
-0.8381407260894775,
0.4285101890563965,
0.12295730412006378,
-0.011689427308738232,
0.2502160668373108,
-0.41577064990997314,
0.560903787612915,
-0.20252466201782227,
-0.3140430748462677,
0.018815821036696434,
-0.4761013090610504,
0.5756462216377258,
-0.04830056056380272,
0.5088051557540894,
-0.4630059003829956,
0.038429372012615204,
0.7987285852432251,
-0.13640709221363068,
1.2000428438186646,
-0.07136712223291397,
-0.5063220858573914,
0.4682442247867584,
0.45300957560539246,
0.22116343677043915,
-0.09865112602710724,
-0.0002905221190303564,
0.3338932394981384,
0.4716871380805969,
-0.44322457909584045,
-0.47879916429519653,
0.8050345778465271,
-0.5722766518592834,
-0.7765612602233887,
-0.5334283709526062,
-0.6407573223114014,
-0.5722802877426147,
-0.19914822280406952,
-0.1679653823375702,
0.424951434135437,
-0.27350708842277527,
0.5766468644142151,
0.7890392541885376,
-0.3082946240901947,
0.36024728417396545,
0.5992683172225952,
-0.21640940010547638,
0.04444639012217522,
0.6740846037864685,
0.5151028633117676,
0.2454449087381363,
0.11159799247980118,
0.2661778926849365,
-0.40959301590919495,
-0.3952794075012207,
-0.3448181450366974,
0.22624707221984863,
-0.8559557795524597,
0.33554911613464355,
-0.4267430305480957,
-0.05654332786798477,
-0.5309093594551086,
0.04534650966525078,
-0.28691422939300537,
-0.08736761659383774,
-0.2475092113018036,
0.10624372959136963,
0.07416319847106934,
0.6594073176383972,
0.11809927225112915,
0.35571199655532837,
-0.7436910271644592,
-0.2194814532995224,
0.22204020619392395,
0.2506727874279022,
-0.127663254737854,
-0.4211318790912628,
-0.21398453414440155,
-0.053134504705667496,
-0.10861404240131378,
-0.901361346244812,
0.25331640243530273,
0.007837919518351555,
0.8063265681266785,
0.5617159008979797,
0.06977640837430954,
0.6007398962974548,
-0.2630610764026642,
1.2557659149169922,
-0.23183752596378326,
-0.6878454685211182,
0.34503471851348877,
-0.46464312076568604,
0.19349263608455658,
0.3558099865913391,
0.7050669193267822,
-0.9274957180023193,
-0.5159627199172974,
-0.3647194504737854,
-0.7269014716148376,
0.3550160825252533,
-0.3353850841522217,
0.7584675550460815,
-0.12848499417304993,
0.013732665218412876,
-0.16349704563617706,
0.15605607628822327,
-0.6578068137168884,
-0.26601240038871765,
0.13549581170082092,
0.0037154858000576496,
-0.07288490235805511,
-0.7830796241760254,
-0.28066685795783997,
-0.07048425078392029,
0.401957243680954,
-0.0728660374879837,
-0.04782431200146675,
-0.1065211072564125,
-0.3109327554702759,
0.08182388544082642,
0.32263386249542236,
0.5635969042778015,
0.9981683492660522,
-0.149149090051651,
0.42646220326423645,
0.21359482407569885,
-0.6080526113510132,
0.21396870911121368,
-0.34101182222366333,
-0.03338212892413139,
-0.05019950121641159,
0.5122208595275879,
0.20078180730342865,
-0.020308062434196472,
-0.43500611186027527,
0.30117616057395935,
0.004114574287086725,
-0.10398620367050171,
-0.6550564765930176,
0.0035945894196629524,
0.16686800122261047,
0.3508608043193817,
0.4273625910282135,
-0.635093092918396,
-0.1337655484676361,
-1.0332610607147217,
-0.1418551653623581,
0.6424423456192017,
-0.8161296248435974,
-0.3607669174671173,
0.5397598147392273,
0.2965359389781952,
-0.056513819843530655,
0.6486241817474365,
-0.01466122455894947,
-0.3023715317249298,
0.5350093245506287,
0.3377240002155304,
0.5739459991455078,
-0.29898911714553833,
0.16281728446483612,
-0.011974422261118889,
0.48769596219062805,
0.028718067333102226,
0.24561333656311035,
0.2446388304233551,
-1.1258763074874878,
-0.5511605143547058,
-0.6972604393959045,
-0.4425298869609833,
0.21281205117702484,
-0.49523618817329407,
0.009186308830976486,
0.02422216348350048,
-0.254121333360672,
-0.2703157365322113,
0.1263875961303711,
-0.5129894614219666,
0.1509212851524353,
0.23010343313217163,
1.1973645687103271,
-1.353276252746582,
0.9455697536468506,
1.053367018699646,
-0.25933054089546204,
-0.2900615632534027,
0.17962078750133514,
0.38350027799606323,
-0.6137689352035522,
0.6470832824707031,
-0.046201784163713455,
-0.35826265811920166,
-0.28192880749702454,
-0.4888119101524353,
-0.816282331943512,
0.8716177344322205,
-0.004655478987842798,
-0.06849920004606247,
0.3973458409309387,
0.20145881175994873,
0.7177020907402039,
-0.45221567153930664,
0.2325965166091919,
0.5959566831588745,
0.477437824010849,
-0.03162791579961777,
-0.8856643438339233,
-0.2987726330757141,
-0.32481324672698975,
0.13132722675800323,
0.040173452347517014,
-0.6851380467414856,
0.7900112867355347,
0.2814607620239258,
-0.10551333427429199,
-0.01200350932776928,
0.8971996903419495,
0.2679423987865448,
0.5238588452339172,
0.5158244967460632,
-0.04760385677218437,
0.479998916387558,
-0.4393655061721802,
0.9635828733444214,
-0.19747743010520935,
0.1961870789527893,
0.7064862251281738,
-0.49209997057914734,
0.5508466362953186,
0.7937109470367432,
-0.3949441909790039,
0.105577751994133,
0.9625619053840637,
0.15511970221996307,
0.09267916530370712,
0.5668831467628479,
-0.3574768602848053,
-0.30691131949424744,
-0.695451557636261,
-0.23888954520225525,
0.7285324335098267,
0.6294015645980835,
-0.17896534502506256,
-0.09588771313428879,
-0.2191438525915146,
0.42576414346694946,
0.09892220795154572,
-0.15942880511283875,
0.6203579306602478,
0.20930258929729462,
-0.6122691631317139,
0.17032776772975922,
0.18998688459396362,
0.7599104642868042,
-0.6848604083061218,
0.15465541183948517,
-0.9218438267707825,
-0.4143694341182709,
0.05792553722858429,
-1.0761961936950684,
0.3025515675544739,
-0.11738124489784241,
-0.12405464798212051,
-0.5313581824302673,
0.6764594912528992,
-0.375355988740921,
-0.4062705934047699,
0.15236245095729828,
1.037217617034912,
0.4244726002216339,
0.13303200900554657,
0.006069577764719725,
0.3914370834827423,
-0.3557395040988922,
-0.3705659508705139,
0.4927355945110321,
0.47266286611557007,
-0.6707403659820557,
0.6431233286857605,
0.29130393266677856,
0.07361503690481186,
-0.13320903480052948,
0.2713675796985626,
0.42608827352523804,
-0.745798647403717,
-0.216708704829216,
-0.8635942339897156,
0.49277034401893616,
0.08538614958524704,
-0.39637771248817444,
0.7799873948097229,
0.36800751090049744,
1.0558669567108154,
0.10087243467569351,
0.5931711196899414,
-0.10775879770517349,
0.16426607966423035,
-0.39061835408210754,
0.7614493370056152,
-0.6121904850006104,
0.24540431797504425,
-0.10780853778123856,
-0.9651175141334534,
-0.2691085934638977,
0.2927800416946411,
-0.3107176423072815,
0.1763225942850113,
0.288741797208786,
0.9252966642379761,
-0.11308258771896362,
0.03296017274260521,
0.44842836260795593,
0.1758190095424652,
0.2636857330799103,
-0.030183419585227966,
1.543649673461914,
0.24887412786483765,
0.15585416555404663,
-0.24520930647850037,
-0.24622780084609985,
-0.2840086817741394,
-1.1139984130859375,
-0.5534681081771851,
-0.8764085173606873,
-0.3093453645706177,
-0.1966674029827118,
-0.39915627241134644,
0.8089630603790283,
0.6018584966659546,
-0.7142651081085205,
-0.5683996677398682,
0.8948631286621094,
0.0748603567481041,
-0.14298902451992035,
-0.14829154312610626,
-0.007975262589752674,
0.015287871472537518,
-0.9818435311317444,
0.47487449645996094,
0.08795757591724396,
0.034627389162778854,
-1.0117771625518799,
0.13487771153450012,
0.22641821205615997,
0.06121409684419632,
0.8817382454872131,
0.043538764119148254,
-0.8180647492408752,
-0.28249460458755493,
0.11845006793737411,
0.0639413595199585,
-0.1448165774345398,
0.9146478176116943,
-0.3462487757205963,
0.22635827958583832,
0.5401517152786255,
0.29027771949768066,
0.13416551053524017,
-0.3252461850643158,
0.46531370282173157,
-0.875501811504364,
0.13433212041854858,
0.1657925546169281,
0.43595463037490845,
0.40067508816719055,
0.02869580313563347,
0.5278221368789673,
0.22865541279315948,
-0.358182817697525,
-0.983596682548523,
0.5132877230644226,
-0.7917324900627136,
-0.3231337070465088,
1.2751083374023438,
-0.020492414012551308,
-0.16824474930763245,
-0.1358030140399933,
0.20201656222343445,
0.037610601633787155,
0.18757469952106476,
0.6633428335189819,
0.9372373819351196,
-0.015538264997303486,
0.06335363537073135,
-1.2120864391326904,
0.11594482511281967,
0.2463349848985672,
-0.3856180012226105,
-0.132327139377594,
0.7533921003341675,
0.456061452627182,
0.3260384202003479,
0.5032495260238647,
-0.40825173258781433,
-0.07965600490570068,
-0.3534177839756012,
-0.12790437042713165,
0.2018580287694931,
-0.27778181433677673,
-0.33084169030189514,
0.25886428356170654,
0.30482742190361023,
0.0041690063662827015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02757v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02757v1
|
In-Memory Learning: A Declarative Learning Framework for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-05T08:25:11 | 2024-03-05T08:25:11 |
Bo Wang, Tianxiang Sun, Hang Yan, Siyin Wang, Qingyuan Cheng, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The exploration of whether agents can align with their environment without
relying on human-labeled data presents an intriguing research topic. Drawing
inspiration from the alignment process observed in intelligent organisms, where
declarative memory plays a pivotal role in summarizing past experiences, we
propose a novel learning framework. The agents adeptly distill insights from
past experiences, refining and updating existing notes to enhance their
performance in the environment. This entire process transpires within the
memory components and is implemented through natural language, so we character
this framework as In-memory Learning. We also delve into the key features of
benchmarks designed to evaluate the self-improvement process. Through
systematic experiments, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework and
provide insights into this problem.
|
[
-0.08525315672159195,
-0.581310510635376,
0.7913190722465515,
-0.34374967217445374,
0.06004834920167923,
0.41391462087631226,
-0.43598875403404236,
-0.5381466150283813,
0.007740604691207409,
0.3692373037338257,
-0.5591069459915161,
-0.45181602239608765,
-0.17970462143421173,
0.02282823622226715,
-0.22404702007770538,
0.9198212027549744,
-0.05618204548954964,
-0.04221559688448906,
-0.7143771648406982,
-0.402731329202652,
-0.6899407505989075,
-0.4658239185810089,
-0.7836347818374634,
-0.6599528789520264,
0.2829136848449707,
0.5168541669845581,
0.7004740238189697,
0.9826591610908508,
0.564699113368988,
0.375476598739624,
0.1946486234664917,
0.2978662848472595,
-0.4784111976623535,
0.38486918807029724,
-0.5750871300697327,
-0.518867552280426,
-0.30510714650154114,
-0.07605510205030441,
0.8882859945297241,
0.6860909461975098,
-0.22796978056430817,
-0.040268223732709885,
0.12696297466754913,
0.8983685970306396,
-0.4661157429218292,
0.3866099715232849,
-0.6800341010093689,
0.11390096694231033,
0.01318940706551075,
-0.1630851775407791,
-0.497268944978714,
-0.4569239914417267,
0.07449857890605927,
-0.5616880059242249,
0.0686621367931366,
-0.036060817539691925,
0.8153780698776245,
0.4764179587364197,
-0.09625755995512009,
-0.5711820721626282,
-0.6148601770401001,
0.7844136953353882,
-0.7634239196777344,
0.460150808095932,
0.3232859969139099,
0.3029248118400574,
-0.3464275896549225,
-0.5269967317581177,
-0.422269344329834,
-0.17121100425720215,
0.09376134723424911,
0.06538446247577667,
0.247404545545578,
0.07640742510557175,
0.07767084240913391,
0.2688888907432556,
-0.5000701546669006,
0.1436714380979538,
-0.20112352073192596,
-0.0741686075925827,
0.4059445559978485,
0.20782847702503204,
0.2750006914138794,
0.580093502998352,
-0.49725502729415894,
-0.275995671749115,
-0.39378419518470764,
-0.15350326895713806,
0.27142706513404846,
0.552163302898407,
0.11724827438592911,
0.16259419918060303,
0.06542941927909851,
0.7378130555152893,
0.2854606509208679,
-0.36971718072891235,
0.4298730790615082,
0.04400721564888954,
-0.10952957719564438,
0.5458364486694336,
0.3009125590324402,
0.21438130736351013,
0.10667315870523453,
-0.5470260977745056,
-0.481302410364151,
0.08541061729192734,
0.5536853671073914,
-0.9020445942878723,
-0.2514876127243042,
0.053223222494125366,
-0.39685240387916565,
-0.07405908405780792,
-0.03197131305932999,
-0.8066068291664124,
-0.47394800186157227,
-0.47081810235977173,
0.48718199133872986,
-0.7900477647781372,
-0.2815345823764801,
0.03780197352170944,
-0.21690839529037476,
0.38326606154441833,
0.32782498002052307,
-1.1353377103805542,
0.621688961982727,
0.875420868396759,
0.7623133659362793,
-0.1071881428360939,
-0.5827727913856506,
-0.4057222008705139,
0.43508291244506836,
-0.465069442987442,
0.8598501086235046,
-0.9792020916938782,
-0.2069517821073532,
-0.05290690436959267,
-0.16567105054855347,
-0.2541176676750183,
-0.8918777108192444,
0.11716621369123459,
-0.548380434513092,
0.1262235939502716,
-0.5227368474006653,
-0.9667291641235352,
-0.47147345542907715,
0.3658682405948639,
-0.5034627914428711,
0.7631361484527588,
0.28401151299476624,
-0.31459158658981323,
0.5494896173477173,
-0.8123992085456848,
-0.14714229106903076,
0.06265870481729507,
-0.3083801865577698,
-0.3161148428916931,
-0.049651652574539185,
-0.20250286161899567,
0.08168978989124298,
-0.18750089406967163,
0.16227436065673828,
-0.2959640920162201,
-0.3671513497829437,
0.41208958625793457,
-0.24930110573768616,
0.48545101284980774,
0.17829984426498413,
-0.12424688041210175,
-0.04756808280944824,
-0.7087127566337585,
-0.07123108208179474,
-0.0052533941343426704,
-0.4646684229373932,
-0.3441290855407715,
0.04717488959431648,
-0.6396927237510681,
0.1965641975402832,
0.47595521807670593,
-0.5953764915466309,
0.2899332046508789,
-0.6548410058021545,
0.552713930606842,
0.7633652091026306,
0.15022554993629456,
0.9343611598014832,
-0.634527325630188,
0.2614891231060028,
0.30311813950538635,
0.07662022858858109,
-0.451635479927063,
-0.04195564612746239,
-0.5390781760215759,
-0.2961467206478119,
-0.04113563895225525,
0.15333808958530426,
-0.3911411166191101,
0.22615401446819305,
-0.247503399848938,
-0.326567143201828,
-0.3247218430042267,
0.4887370467185974,
0.570237398147583,
0.8169879913330078,
0.40010499954223633,
-0.4575175344944,
-0.3584991991519928,
-0.6847206354141235,
-0.09696696698665619,
-0.39294084906578064,
0.20307520031929016,
0.19896376132965088,
0.585033655166626,
-0.39728471636772156,
1.1122865676879883,
-0.25711727142333984,
-0.18142277002334595,
-0.13393712043762207,
0.05283426120877266,
-0.06076936051249504,
0.7132436037063599,
0.45978716015815735,
-0.6962136030197144,
-0.2888818383216858,
0.20629853010177612,
-0.942680299282074,
0.3707676827907562,
-0.22450248897075653,
-0.11162269115447998,
0.25106415152549744,
0.6308119893074036,
-0.5331009030342102,
-0.01585262268781662,
0.18320368230342865,
-0.19673949480056763,
0.10046843439340591,
-0.5778719782829285,
-0.14875368773937225,
-0.9002923369407654,
-0.16231852769851685,
-0.15462926030158997,
-0.16261601448059082,
-0.5368388891220093,
-0.1273844689130783,
0.39622950553894043,
0.12709374725818634,
-0.2882627248764038,
0.6231884360313416,
-0.6975831389427185,
-0.0787036344408989,
-0.3909054696559906,
0.21365852653980255,
-0.03406406193971634,
0.6539322733879089,
-0.008768743835389614,
0.493394672870636,
0.4611804485321045,
-0.6397829055786133,
0.15826918184757233,
0.28326839208602905,
-0.07830322533845901,
0.7235674262046814,
-0.09932256489992142,
0.2863101661205292,
-0.643400251865387,
0.1256190687417984,
-0.9334854483604431,
-0.2168123424053192,
0.25174835324287415,
-0.3366837203502655,
0.6538578867912292,
0.10152529925107956,
-0.42988860607147217,
-0.04655992612242699,
-0.003990835044533014,
0.3356510102748871,
0.4937804937362671,
-0.7256438136100769,
0.7894827127456665,
0.3092557191848755,
0.2371179461479187,
-0.33966392278671265,
-0.37767601013183594,
0.015996553003787994,
-0.5778058171272278,
-0.17541341483592987,
0.3493530750274658,
-0.15164737403392792,
-0.5088924169540405,
0.09413622319698334,
-0.21379801630973816,
-0.13524313271045685,
0.051279112696647644,
0.3071151375770569,
0.12255603820085526,
-0.399037629365921,
0.751612663269043,
-0.3759113848209381,
-0.02346023917198181,
0.057231515645980835,
-0.5298852920532227,
0.5208908319473267,
-0.32050010561943054,
-0.32281067967414856,
-0.23582394421100616,
0.009058644063770771,
0.596755862236023,
-0.4255368709564209,
0.5849623084068298,
0.038918014615774155,
-0.5627937912940979,
-0.5089529752731323,
-0.46819210052490234,
-0.27925223112106323,
-0.5492579936981201,
0.224192276597023,
-0.20608189702033997,
-0.5091337561607361,
0.5431910157203674,
-0.28879037499427795,
0.018865028396248817,
0.16912570595741272,
0.1768677979707718,
-0.3073485493659973,
0.6844435334205627,
0.9607222080230713,
-0.1686341017484665,
0.53462153673172,
-0.23917517066001892,
0.008533221669495106,
-0.7295202612876892,
-0.32744133472442627,
-0.3141580820083618,
-0.4998558759689331,
-0.14852364361286163,
-0.29624512791633606,
-0.002414107322692871,
-0.16719800233840942,
-0.6134464740753174,
0.37363865971565247,
-0.5048571228981018,
0.6773709654808044,
0.24449951946735382,
0.13936364650726318,
0.026787269860506058,
-0.3819446563720703,
-0.08583864569664001,
0.07986383885145187,
-0.45328840613365173,
-0.6163905262947083,
0.8787983655929565,
0.3618260324001312,
0.6671212911605835,
0.06937647610902786,
0.7942571640014648,
0.18238449096679688,
0.4123580753803253,
-0.6285346746444702,
0.530275821685791,
0.2674995958805084,
-0.4570700228214264,
-0.4584091007709503,
-0.1522715538740158,
-0.9817973375320435,
0.2586336135864258,
0.11713077127933502,
-0.9072737097740173,
0.2557193636894226,
0.05420636385679245,
-0.4973822832107544,
0.40639016032218933,
-0.5926008224487305,
1.0564054250717163,
-0.6880505084991455,
-0.539987325668335,
-0.30416595935821533,
-0.7486758232116699,
0.023533130064606667,
-0.2081795185804367,
-0.058423545211553574,
-0.054547019302845,
-0.4169449806213379,
0.5823172330856323,
-0.29745736718177795,
1.1447710990905762,
-0.29236143827438354,
-0.051109518855810165,
0.3025488257408142,
0.09777458757162094,
0.49470844864845276,
-0.2774136960506439,
-0.2556527554988861,
-0.2924750745296478,
-0.11331495642662048,
-0.37690797448158264,
-0.8246400356292725,
0.5418233275413513,
-0.6024782061576843,
-0.36330777406692505,
-0.41077670454978943,
-0.7005865573883057,
-0.45450490713119507,
0.13762760162353516,
-0.22278964519500732,
0.5068608522415161,
-0.4217079281806946,
0.11836721003055573,
1.0465909242630005,
-0.05492008849978447,
0.8688254952430725,
0.7771874070167542,
-0.2048470675945282,
-0.40644681453704834,
1.1077841520309448,
0.17643818259239197,
0.33675384521484375,
0.6072819828987122,
0.16984553635120392,
-0.4563896059989929,
-0.5172613263130188,
-0.345612108707428,
0.5080991387367249,
-0.8062193989753723,
-0.2859370708465576,
-0.584017813205719,
-0.13938575983047485,
-0.026076873764395714,
-0.43918976187705994,
-0.43609321117401123,
0.04719984158873558,
-0.4273214638233185,
-0.29415926337242126,
0.2283870428800583,
0.8703794479370117,
0.0717366635799408,
0.16343854367733002,
-0.8289507031440735,
-0.048442766070365906,
0.3235463798046112,
0.1484939157962799,
0.18378451466560364,
-0.5373955965042114,
-0.647891104221344,
0.27090969681739807,
-0.5529375076293945,
-0.8385712504386902,
0.6138362288475037,
0.5499765276908875,
0.8987841606140137,
0.7353515625,
-0.05006720498204231,
0.9420104026794434,
-0.26028144359588623,
0.5198104977607727,
-0.09071644395589828,
-0.7598584890365601,
0.559181272983551,
-0.27619731426239014,
0.42565953731536865,
0.8822165131568909,
0.3198217451572418,
-0.37241142988204956,
-0.43175360560417175,
-0.8181785345077515,
-0.6171746253967285,
0.40148088335990906,
-0.2760370969772339,
0.042478784918785095,
-0.12142687290906906,
0.5596242547035217,
0.22474563121795654,
0.5108188986778259,
-0.3363577127456665,
0.18732093274593353,
-0.0780772939324379,
-0.3226799964904785,
-0.2741128206253052,
-0.053474072366952896,
-0.06421326100826263,
-0.3113252520561218,
0.5838987827301025,
-0.4229496121406555,
0.03402499854564667,
0.1235196590423584,
-0.42239394783973694,
-0.28128790855407715,
-0.1070026382803917,
0.5566903352737427,
0.8610870838165283,
-0.23581820726394653,
0.21786122024059296,
0.3272205889225006,
-0.3006616532802582,
0.3131507933139801,
-0.32108065485954285,
0.010866992175579071,
-0.35476189851760864,
0.21879111230373383,
0.387277215719223,
0.5296592712402344,
-0.9152064323425293,
0.4369865953922272,
0.016577884554862976,
0.043048709630966187,
-0.5540696978569031,
0.17778998613357544,
0.06306557357311249,
0.4644160866737366,
0.27432480454444885,
0.1997869610786438,
0.04350532218813896,
-0.9154247641563416,
0.4852341413497925,
0.5385512709617615,
-0.7630046606063843,
-0.41531142592430115,
0.6208787560462952,
-0.09418735653162003,
-0.39187902212142944,
0.8787468075752258,
-0.36471816897392273,
-0.38809752464294434,
0.8193536400794983,
0.9378015398979187,
1.0167388916015625,
-0.23790955543518066,
0.2010095864534378,
0.4910382628440857,
0.13207636773586273,
-0.39213716983795166,
0.028836259618401527,
-0.39825499057769775,
-1.0055229663848877,
-0.006069540046155453,
-0.6984491348266602,
-0.46848973631858826,
-0.2423635721206665,
-0.5102183818817139,
-0.10050148516893387,
-0.6140294075012207,
0.04790633171796799,
-0.164258673787117,
0.12005231529474258,
-0.43326765298843384,
0.2692972719669342,
0.2781836986541748,
0.7612835764884949,
-0.8215348720550537,
1.133898377418518,
0.7670327425003052,
-0.6755041480064392,
-0.5667402148246765,
0.132913276553154,
-0.01616283878684044,
-0.6440678238868713,
0.6229005455970764,
0.5362861156463623,
-0.27072611451148987,
-0.007193753030151129,
-0.45401281118392944,
-1.1859694719314575,
1.232162594795227,
0.5770797729492188,
-0.20259425044059753,
0.05063296854496002,
0.0067899711430072784,
0.8426927328109741,
-0.7017351984977722,
0.18342696130275726,
0.6543789505958557,
0.45736756920814514,
0.03739003837108612,
-0.5732011795043945,
0.010447553358972073,
-0.23164118826389313,
0.006456845439970493,
0.31993404030799866,
-1.0267094373703003,
0.9169906377792358,
-0.2002197951078415,
-0.45821914076805115,
-0.10325881838798523,
0.9824804663658142,
-0.11739256978034973,
0.2899816036224365,
0.25457456707954407,
0.7723187804222107,
1.2094231843948364,
0.2261805683374405,
0.5263832807540894,
-0.24850502610206604,
-0.001944621209986508,
1.436766266822815,
-0.5645178556442261,
0.760597825050354,
0.5424076318740845,
0.13234497606754303,
0.8158555626869202,
0.5499299764633179,
0.05452483892440796,
0.6877173185348511,
0.11708428710699081,
-0.34945356845855713,
-0.26224568486213684,
-0.0750674158334732,
-0.0871129259467125,
0.5421037077903748,
0.5910384654998779,
-0.363899290561676,
-0.37604695558547974,
0.07483618706464767,
-0.10323657095432281,
0.561026930809021,
-0.31957119703292847,
1.121384620666504,
-0.03495959937572479,
-0.6964644193649292,
0.4305424988269806,
-0.6245891451835632,
0.3188849687576294,
-0.551529049873352,
-0.4521588683128357,
-0.24343764781951904,
0.5539153814315796,
-0.1600044071674347,
-0.5404613018035889,
0.3294152617454529,
-0.5061929821968079,
-0.2762022316455841,
-0.5048139691352844,
0.5229821801185608,
-0.5314507484436035,
-0.13353054225444794,
0.3562203049659729,
0.35876068472862244,
0.21364910900592804,
0.08097874373197556,
-0.5655575394630432,
-0.066994808614254,
-0.11788730323314667,
0.01632937788963318,
0.62074214220047,
0.6685739755630493,
-0.04927374795079231,
1.0378562211990356,
0.2507167160511017,
-0.0551178976893425,
-0.2305222749710083,
-0.25775718688964844,
0.7963628768920898,
-0.8034083843231201,
-0.32990318536758423,
-1.0569796562194824,
0.41960227489471436,
-0.19415831565856934,
-0.1526104360818863,
0.8196431994438171,
0.9876285791397095,
1.1298402547836304,
0.061332084238529205,
0.7263104319572449,
0.32359373569488525,
0.44962385296821594,
-0.41396281123161316,
0.5447523593902588,
-0.30209770798683167,
0.2298288643360138,
0.0367964431643486,
-0.763533353805542,
0.007959087379276752,
0.5310450792312622,
-0.28462839126586914,
-0.1032707542181015,
0.902679443359375,
1.0757354497909546,
0.11927066743373871,
0.009376423433423042,
0.4717986583709717,
0.1465623527765274,
0.20112426578998566,
0.7058286666870117,
1.02192223072052,
-0.19120168685913086,
0.2318166345357895,
-0.22615200281143188,
0.0037678030785173178,
0.08380643278360367,
-0.7479057908058167,
-0.8796693682670593,
-0.8572410345077515,
-0.3607926368713379,
-0.06007695943117142,
0.22068816423416138,
1.2966886758804321,
0.3628652095794678,
-0.5818265676498413,
-0.41700369119644165,
-0.3143824636936188,
0.06140919029712677,
-0.627787709236145,
-0.12145168334245682,
0.08688141405582428,
-0.8801466822624207,
-0.6474873423576355,
0.6812472939491272,
0.5639575123786926,
0.2598840296268463,
-0.2107188105583191,
-0.270833820104599,
-0.035329725593328476,
0.12058553844690323,
0.19121138751506805,
0.7362305521965027,
-0.4326898157596588,
-0.2842716872692108,
-0.2527841031551361,
-0.22919784486293793,
0.5686979293823242,
0.6484593152999878,
-1.0280524492263794,
0.5685009956359863,
0.18678638339042664,
0.7362677454948425,
0.35512983798980713,
0.21692413091659546,
0.6718007326126099,
-0.3393733501434326,
0.08930031210184097,
0.45511215925216675,
0.32838401198387146,
0.4801338016986847,
-0.4506494700908661,
0.38092049956321716,
-0.040685635060071945,
-0.7645766735076904,
-0.617163896560669,
0.025973856449127197,
-0.7458045482635498,
-0.399004191160202,
0.9252781867980957,
-0.004302928689867258,
-0.5846161246299744,
-0.17023035883903503,
-0.13221825659275055,
0.1599835753440857,
-0.5133711099624634,
0.8543887734413147,
0.5285810828208923,
-0.20518089830875397,
0.026952262967824936,
-0.4337720572948456,
0.6999638676643372,
0.04711516201496124,
-0.706055223941803,
0.01863323152065277,
0.7732952237129211,
0.22127623856067657,
0.11943483352661133,
0.6198169589042664,
-0.12424080818891525,
0.11111140996217728,
0.10481566935777664,
0.13995999097824097,
0.11631204187870026,
-0.5267530083656311,
-0.5001289248466492,
0.19967404007911682,
0.30120551586151123,
-0.3073914051055908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02756v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02756v1
|
Role Prompting Guided Domain Adaptation with General Capability Preserve for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-05T08:22:41 | 2024-03-05T08:22:41 |
Rui Wang, Fei Mi, Yi Chen, Boyang Xue, Hongru Wang, Qi Zhu, Kam-Fai Wong, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The growing interest in Large Language Models (LLMs) for specialized
applications has revealed a significant challenge: when tailored to specific
domains, LLMs tend to experience catastrophic forgetting, compromising their
general capabilities and leading to a suboptimal user experience. Additionally,
crafting a versatile model for multiple domains simultaneously often results in
a decline in overall performance due to confusion between domains. In response
to these issues, we present the RolE Prompting Guided Multi-Domain Adaptation
(REGA) strategy. This novel approach effectively manages multi-domain LLM
adaptation through three key components: 1) Self-Distillation constructs and
replays general-domain exemplars to alleviate catastrophic forgetting. 2) Role
Prompting assigns a central prompt to the general domain and a unique role
prompt to each specific domain to minimize inter-domain confusion during
training. 3) Role Integration reuses and integrates a small portion of
domain-specific data to the general-domain data, which are trained under the
guidance of the central prompt. The central prompt is used for a streamlined
inference process, removing the necessity to switch prompts for different
domains. Empirical results demonstrate that REGA effectively alleviates
catastrophic forgetting and inter-domain confusion. This leads to improved
domain-specific performance compared to standard fine-tuned models, while still
preserving robust general capabilities.
|
[
-0.3166644275188446,
-0.7168815732002258,
0.5460545420646667,
0.39456281065940857,
-0.25525400042533875,
0.10283465683460236,
-0.3289882242679596,
-0.06316632777452469,
-0.0030840414110571146,
0.4783918559551239,
-0.7212381958961487,
-0.3982684910297394,
-0.48888930678367615,
0.2693538963794708,
0.15592986345291138,
0.890692412853241,
-0.09831024706363678,
0.11297920346260071,
-0.3908434212207794,
-0.1810840517282486,
-1.2573792934417725,
-0.6279854774475098,
-0.8438647389411926,
-0.17138822376728058,
0.41987818479537964,
0.5078665614128113,
0.1589292585849762,
0.23033948242664337,
0.0017490556929260492,
0.22048576176166534,
0.328380286693573,
0.5975955724716187,
-0.4611636996269226,
0.3557095527648926,
-0.42747023701667786,
-0.4794464707374573,
-0.6643734574317932,
-0.13007551431655884,
0.7294881939888,
0.5663487315177917,
-0.3097614347934723,
0.032643917948007584,
0.4799483120441437,
0.5698229074478149,
-0.619625985622406,
0.325379878282547,
-0.8187834620475769,
-0.2894343435764313,
0.05806972086429596,
-0.4349118769168854,
-0.6882896423339844,
0.1268274188041687,
0.2600345015525818,
-0.8232743740081787,
0.2260858565568924,
-0.021018516272306442,
0.2830810844898224,
0.22171218693256378,
-0.3828129172325134,
-0.23041574656963348,
-0.8865800499916077,
0.8165291547775269,
-0.4799838960170746,
0.24735118448734283,
0.34395942091941833,
0.3800664246082306,
-0.3923248052597046,
-0.3411906063556671,
-0.4497990906238556,
0.03346771374344826,
0.3034777045249939,
0.2368536740541458,
-0.2267673760652542,
-0.09347374737262726,
-0.03620688244700432,
-0.19330786168575287,
-0.598268449306488,
0.28141993284225464,
-0.20755764842033386,
-0.15628518164157867,
0.3876100182533264,
0.03421850502490997,
0.3378804326057434,
0.22425015270709991,
-0.42704451084136963,
-0.017786545678973198,
-0.8834072351455688,
0.03097744658589363,
0.033821914345026016,
0.6091448068618774,
0.08623955398797989,
0.1389409601688385,
0.1303439438343048,
0.6911061406135559,
0.23858267068862915,
-0.12861259281635284,
-0.037899792194366455,
-0.027285583317279816,
-0.32256388664245605,
-0.1057540699839592,
0.4964737892150879,
0.2061571329832077,
0.5146200656890869,
-0.09264824539422989,
-0.024027612060308456,
-0.128105029463768,
0.4142387807369232,
-0.5716222524642944,
-0.1543562412261963,
0.13442163169384003,
-0.2788548469543457,
0.3562883734703064,
-0.23124954104423523,
-0.7728657126426697,
-0.3130590319633484,
-0.40098679065704346,
0.6412347555160522,
-0.5042903423309326,
-0.12078447639942169,
0.36667031049728394,
0.02283405140042305,
0.184787780046463,
0.6094991564750671,
-1.1823503971099854,
0.35978785157203674,
0.5376977920532227,
0.7162118554115295,
-0.4030768573284149,
-0.4665103256702423,
-0.8304128050804138,
0.31433263421058655,
-0.13445304334163666,
0.6784619092941284,
-0.6333225965499878,
-0.46316036581993103,
0.05943305045366287,
0.1585071086883545,
-0.589087724685669,
-0.6223512291908264,
0.25337228178977966,
-0.8591641187667847,
0.21370594203472137,
-0.12017396837472916,
-0.32647910714149475,
-0.37019744515419006,
0.08591954410076141,
-0.7437594532966614,
0.5502462387084961,
0.06495654582977295,
-0.2427872270345688,
0.5027127861976624,
-0.48677128553390503,
-0.39507806301116943,
-0.14181597530841827,
-0.1474384367465973,
-0.39746183156967163,
0.1276838332414627,
0.49519336223602295,
0.571971595287323,
-0.38635510206222534,
0.24936047196388245,
-0.3573296070098877,
-0.0988907665014267,
0.04677398130297661,
-0.3683573007583618,
0.5269492864608765,
-0.03410465642809868,
0.05742017924785614,
0.19028349220752716,
-0.5658369064331055,
-0.20565278828144073,
0.09378544241189957,
-0.1978531777858734,
-0.7237496376037598,
-0.10805709660053253,
-0.254937082529068,
0.2617185115814209,
0.08026108145713806,
0.07994712889194489,
0.5437800884246826,
0.17998814582824707,
0.3219511806964874,
0.9488654136657715,
0.2804882228374481,
0.6243413090705872,
-0.23531687259674072,
0.8032630681991577,
0.23010341823101044,
0.26098212599754333,
-0.17696617543697357,
-0.5759906768798828,
-0.4338502585887909,
-0.4820534288883209,
0.2506099343299866,
0.5976510047912598,
-0.6739126443862915,
0.5008112192153931,
-0.009358653798699379,
-0.08373367041349411,
-0.36051467061042786,
0.29167982935905457,
0.17226038873195648,
0.47196829319000244,
0.6058111786842346,
-0.5698011517524719,
-0.38158947229385376,
-0.7291326522827148,
-0.2068605273962021,
-0.16145651042461395,
0.11662224680185318,
0.197828471660614,
0.38287973403930664,
-0.3560726046562195,
0.9216309785842896,
-0.37879815697669983,
-0.7695707082748413,
-0.29744595289230347,
-0.050204820930957794,
0.17994964122772217,
0.397655189037323,
0.5842752456665039,
-0.7193920016288757,
-0.4924826920032501,
-0.21293406188488007,
-0.4100537896156311,
-0.23815178871154785,
-0.5628268122673035,
-0.048583585768938065,
0.22362051904201508,
0.2939220368862152,
-0.676130473613739,
0.08564268052577972,
0.7098556756973267,
-0.20752815902233124,
0.6580374836921692,
-0.4460091292858124,
0.21408706903457642,
-1.2075085639953613,
0.1412743330001831,
-0.054182883352041245,
-0.04200643301010132,
-0.761199414730072,
-0.4029681980609894,
0.17302139103412628,
0.1440189927816391,
-0.05901731923222542,
0.6366281509399414,
-0.7566313147544861,
0.0363190695643425,
-0.3305661082267761,
0.14815840125083923,
0.2852784991264343,
0.5323455929756165,
-0.12326975166797638,
1.0940921306610107,
0.7975509762763977,
-0.947691023349762,
-0.09470359236001968,
0.5993010997772217,
-0.037864167243242264,
0.384797602891922,
-0.22877338528633118,
0.1120280772447586,
-0.23073627054691315,
0.40199702978134155,
-1.009387493133545,
-0.13677532970905304,
0.1825913041830063,
-0.1317681223154068,
0.46202993392944336,
-0.3187037706375122,
-0.12538568675518036,
-0.14000551402568817,
-0.06193876266479492,
0.3964095115661621,
0.3771759271621704,
-0.5850510001182556,
0.9314836859703064,
0.3675185739994049,
-0.3843071460723877,
-0.7193838953971863,
-0.4831954538822174,
0.13268335163593292,
-0.40360918641090393,
-0.46371158957481384,
0.4814445376396179,
-0.2726449966430664,
0.09806671738624573,
-0.16530363261699677,
-0.26841798424720764,
-0.2639935612678528,
0.25847750902175903,
0.17358605563640594,
0.3506486713886261,
-0.20940762758255005,
0.2143210768699646,
0.2518922686576843,
-0.07674458622932434,
-0.11146613210439682,
-0.3995720148086548,
0.5143563151359558,
0.1269124448299408,
-0.4162297248840332,
-0.45761582255363464,
0.49162930250167847,
0.6584628224372864,
-0.40116026997566223,
0.7127304077148438,
0.42014795541763306,
-0.25991660356521606,
-0.7474417686462402,
-0.42667242884635925,
-0.30594322085380554,
-0.41810205578804016,
0.34809839725494385,
-0.5236785411834717,
-1.1055597066879272,
0.7836976647377014,
-0.4421655535697937,
-0.0435093455016613,
0.33890971541404724,
0.5070570707321167,
0.3481447994709015,
0.7852365970611572,
0.7796355485916138,
-0.2859556972980499,
0.45516854524612427,
-0.0778462290763855,
0.3611312210559845,
-0.9132691025733948,
-0.24933430552482605,
-0.32406729459762573,
0.011369573883712292,
-0.0566701740026474,
-0.6770918369293213,
0.3920932412147522,
0.5248910188674927,
-0.007932576350867748,
0.21270599961280823,
-0.14203205704689026,
0.36892271041870117,
0.3963066041469574,
-0.04938405379652977,
0.39270511269569397,
0.10190736502408981,
0.00831844937056303,
0.026949893683195114,
-0.881037712097168,
-0.4207266867160797,
0.8937744498252869,
0.33208808302879333,
0.9356619715690613,
0.2719358801841736,
0.6889412999153137,
0.4553493857383728,
0.20445148646831512,
-0.7890562415122986,
0.467600017786026,
-0.261483758687973,
-0.3573321998119354,
-0.3843708038330078,
-0.19665105640888214,
-0.8884573578834534,
0.2952422797679901,
-0.08971421420574188,
-0.5185732245445251,
0.295190691947937,
0.35383665561676025,
-0.8078700304031372,
0.012554577551782131,
-0.8472495079040527,
0.9198488593101501,
-0.03225705772638321,
-0.2552719712257385,
-0.34965595602989197,
-0.3947128355503082,
0.3550311326980591,
-0.5538756251335144,
0.09902278333902359,
-0.02428271993994713,
0.030571212992072105,
0.47858554124832153,
0.22182422876358032,
1.2487252950668335,
-0.4598046541213989,
-0.26816821098327637,
0.4004663825035095,
0.0675259530544281,
0.5692393183708191,
0.09680761396884918,
-0.05563782528042793,
0.0002422503021080047,
-0.25512364506721497,
-0.20936936140060425,
-0.6925710439682007,
0.6882779002189636,
-0.7100496292114258,
-0.9445912837982178,
-0.17862722277641296,
-0.4769984185695648,
-0.7010653614997864,
0.22923706471920013,
-0.25149333477020264,
0.4296111762523651,
-0.48457401990890503,
-0.061723899096250534,
0.7912099361419678,
-0.39558145403862,
0.38195380568504333,
0.6133501529693604,
-0.027738196775317192,
-0.3631637394428253,
0.6343523859977722,
-0.04573720693588257,
0.5409946441650391,
0.29839327931404114,
0.03570648282766342,
-0.46006348729133606,
-0.6541116237640381,
-0.6291659474372864,
0.21972934901714325,
-0.6937727928161621,
-0.3684970438480377,
-0.6286087036132812,
0.00352821359410882,
-0.6685099005699158,
-0.045084692537784576,
-0.047250375151634216,
-0.24560655653476715,
-0.6202365159988403,
0.13367114961147308,
0.37197184562683105,
0.5391464829444885,
-0.0712653174996376,
0.2921597361564636,
-0.96321040391922,
0.3808310031890869,
0.5496609807014465,
0.2557368576526642,
0.0740162655711174,
-0.7698068618774414,
-0.2778456509113312,
-0.24085859954357147,
-0.16641268134117126,
-0.6126021146774292,
0.40631303191185,
0.6471784114837646,
0.8614761829376221,
0.20881123840808868,
0.014304076321423054,
0.8616489768028259,
-0.921235978603363,
0.7120839357376099,
0.19322940707206726,
-0.8354762196540833,
0.3212803602218628,
-0.321227103471756,
0.2509859502315521,
0.3615034520626068,
0.4448118805885315,
-0.5108932852745056,
-0.10118192434310913,
-0.17355220019817352,
-0.6302925944328308,
0.6908078193664551,
-0.369855135679245,
0.15198034048080444,
-0.10224656015634537,
0.40877291560173035,
0.34078189730644226,
-0.11196090281009674,
-0.32895541191101074,
-0.049187202006578445,
-0.14664685726165771,
-0.035475339740514755,
0.000035665929317474365,
-0.2998199462890625,
-0.34017762541770935,
0.09803640097379684,
0.745356559753418,
-0.612436056137085,
0.15366502106189728,
0.3421049416065216,
-0.28179025650024414,
-0.08723548799753189,
0.44865673780441284,
0.7764808535575867,
0.8202072978019714,
0.09202506393194199,
0.01691843383014202,
0.3480032980442047,
-0.4118453562259674,
0.24346430599689484,
-0.05640999227762222,
0.2549188435077667,
-0.35935086011886597,
0.38423433899879456,
0.7337929606437683,
0.013490976765751839,
-0.42111337184906006,
0.38794028759002686,
-0.05759340524673462,
-0.14891250431537628,
-0.0616377629339695,
0.23374386131763458,
0.003278592601418495,
0.40895748138427734,
0.6806129217147827,
0.24202123284339905,
-0.07569976896047592,
-0.47546321153640747,
0.4406887888908386,
0.2937130928039551,
-0.04327913746237755,
-0.41967883706092834,
0.6332718729972839,
0.1686548888683319,
0.03611725941300392,
0.17444844543933868,
0.17858946323394775,
-0.39214086532592773,
0.43431976437568665,
0.9811263084411621,
1.1826647520065308,
-0.7209011912345886,
0.38048055768013,
0.21261096000671387,
0.11788482964038849,
-0.3608534336090088,
0.16446344554424286,
0.2964227795600891,
-0.8365263938903809,
-0.7051299214363098,
-0.42902636528015137,
-0.2685713469982147,
0.22810816764831543,
-0.6773919463157654,
-0.027388643473386765,
-0.56121426820755,
-0.15247182548046112,
-0.21739071607589722,
-0.2423606663942337,
-0.45311111211776733,
0.23228546977043152,
-0.036418817937374115,
1.010641098022461,
-0.932035505771637,
1.0574431419372559,
0.4358740448951721,
-0.24576957523822784,
-0.6479147672653198,
0.1239997148513794,
0.027288323268294334,
-0.8627986907958984,
0.5542992353439331,
0.09214077144861221,
-0.33112573623657227,
0.06574784964323044,
-0.19481396675109863,
-0.6565579175949097,
1.2175920009613037,
0.4079339802265167,
-0.5642006397247314,
0.11147267371416092,
-0.06113986298441887,
0.49453529715538025,
-0.7661545872688293,
-0.4073846638202667,
0.488555908203125,
0.3126068115234375,
-0.11779788136482239,
-0.9434010982513428,
0.2921871244907379,
0.1603081375360489,
0.00642267195507884,
-0.12967467308044434,
-0.7020492553710938,
0.7232816815376282,
-0.27374619245529175,
-0.2222609519958496,
-0.04090193286538124,
0.6294031739234924,
0.3529651463031769,
-0.004699962679296732,
0.7478119730949402,
0.11560926586389542,
0.8838912844657898,
0.3355255126953125,
0.6484466791152954,
-0.27070727944374084,
0.07807811349630356,
1.132145881652832,
-0.6258885860443115,
0.6579414010047913,
0.47708070278167725,
0.2027101218700409,
0.46603283286094666,
0.3642314672470093,
0.19511070847511292,
0.7124001383781433,
-0.011441539041697979,
-0.5553603768348694,
-0.5927783250808716,
0.03311559930443764,
-0.17854167520999908,
0.49754583835601807,
0.47504404187202454,
-0.18256214261054993,
-0.25413015484809875,
0.10858490318059921,
-0.20935438573360443,
0.05016414821147919,
-0.2505139112472534,
0.6781448125839233,
0.2995573878288269,
-0.9141273498535156,
0.5906863212585449,
-0.04327980428934097,
0.23978115618228912,
-0.8639997839927673,
-0.32447895407676697,
-0.21140055358409882,
0.29059267044067383,
0.09895665943622589,
-0.4736934006214142,
0.14059674739837646,
-0.24375760555267334,
-0.5611982345581055,
-0.44862571358680725,
0.841602623462677,
-0.6103205680847168,
0.15041963756084442,
0.560042679309845,
0.6544444561004639,
-0.2753085494041443,
-0.16162268817424774,
-0.7141262292861938,
0.12325230985879898,
-0.059935249388217926,
-0.07115557789802551,
0.4670247733592987,
0.7181742787361145,
-0.47736528515815735,
0.7505549788475037,
0.5846914052963257,
-0.06070858985185623,
-0.003277538577094674,
0.5314254760742188,
0.9684633612632751,
-0.6132670640945435,
-0.41766634583473206,
-0.6874570846557617,
0.49886593222618103,
0.14026044309139252,
-0.26174670457839966,
0.8021535277366638,
0.2634294331073761,
0.4988541603088379,
-0.48394590616226196,
1.0208373069763184,
0.17368587851524353,
0.2467096596956253,
-0.781792163848877,
0.5708811283111572,
-0.4148951768875122,
0.29892417788505554,
-0.02137274481356144,
-0.8743254542350769,
-0.6279293298721313,
0.44494253396987915,
-0.2495032399892807,
0.1988193541765213,
0.5740124583244324,
0.8140654563903809,
-0.1720767468214035,
-0.3072797954082489,
0.4336533546447754,
0.15050382912158966,
0.5673301815986633,
0.7162217497825623,
0.633919894695282,
-0.22420594096183777,
0.2617650032043457,
0.5212117433547974,
-0.5955559611320496,
-0.30344754457473755,
-0.901627242565155,
-1.031801462173462,
-0.6419058442115784,
-0.22700737416744232,
-0.2702659070491791,
0.025655394420027733,
0.9049985408782959,
0.7217300534248352,
-0.9788127541542053,
-0.058299336582422256,
0.21595068275928497,
-0.0680009201169014,
-0.48640453815460205,
-0.1552261859178543,
0.38629376888275146,
-0.6092255115509033,
-0.60117506980896,
0.8243991732597351,
0.47421759366989136,
-0.007019083946943283,
-0.34306636452674866,
-0.08038067072629929,
-0.22536785900592804,
0.19468966126441956,
0.6850348711013794,
0.41350409388542175,
-0.6297765374183655,
-0.45903733372688293,
-0.006462069693952799,
-0.05529695749282837,
-0.09994851052761078,
0.9976269602775574,
-0.6192346215248108,
0.443937748670578,
0.26168617606163025,
0.9049232006072998,
0.1187480092048645,
0.09310327470302582,
0.9096117615699768,
-0.7187694907188416,
-0.16322743892669678,
0.02374129556119442,
0.2701202929019928,
0.26193588972091675,
-0.37973111867904663,
0.25568848848342896,
0.21744444966316223,
-0.6456453800201416,
-0.47961437702178955,
0.28677695989608765,
-1.2182127237319946,
-0.4303863048553467,
1.1782774925231934,
-0.2954440116882324,
-0.2052399218082428,
-0.3951990306377411,
-0.3410891890525818,
0.12168128043413162,
-0.37244999408721924,
0.9977937936782837,
0.6307811141014099,
-0.10849935561418533,
-0.04060377553105354,
-0.4457603991031647,
0.6922292709350586,
0.4233260452747345,
-0.7437418103218079,
0.5871573686599731,
0.639529287815094,
0.47590941190719604,
-0.01088149007409811,
0.7966692447662354,
0.07165063172578812,
0.11422061920166016,
-0.2939823567867279,
-0.020826365798711777,
-0.049395542591810226,
-0.9639369249343872,
-0.7530217170715332,
0.01294850092381239,
0.11835989356040955,
-0.25294721126556396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02745v1
|
CURATRON: Complete Robust Preference Data for Robust Alignment of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-05T07:58:12 | 2024-03-05T07:58:12 |
Son The Nguyen, Niranjan Uma Naresh, Theja Tulabandhula
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper addresses the challenges of aligning large language models (LLMs)
with human values via preference learning (PL), with a focus on the issues of
incomplete and corrupted data in preference datasets. We propose a novel method
for robustly and completely recalibrating values within these datasets to
enhance LLMs resilience against the issues. In particular, we devise a
guaranteed polynomial time ranking algorithm that robustifies several existing
models, such as the classic Bradley--Terry--Luce (BTL) (Bradley and Terry,
1952) model and certain generalizations of it. To the best of our knowledge,
our present work is the first to propose an algorithm that provably recovers an
{\epsilon}-optimal ranking with high probability while allowing as large as
O(n) perturbed pairwise comparison results per model response. Furthermore, we
show robust recovery results in the partially observed setting. Our experiments
confirm that our algorithms handle adversarial noise and unobserved comparisons
well in both general and LLM preference dataset settings. This work contributes
to the development and scaling of more reliable and ethically aligned AI models
by equipping the dataset curation pipeline with the ability to handle missing
and maliciously manipulated inputs.
|
[
0.0029288798104971647,
-0.621528148651123,
0.4388226866722107,
-0.27205953001976013,
0.03836478665471077,
0.35075539350509644,
-0.5873998403549194,
-0.03115292638540268,
0.007976795546710491,
0.6376189589500427,
-0.18478910624980927,
-0.3199940323829651,
-0.5108112096786499,
-0.08200699836015701,
-0.11544954031705856,
1.1866449117660522,
0.34275171160697937,
0.05051596835255623,
-0.11176560819149017,
-0.2727750539779663,
-0.13078664243221283,
-0.761338472366333,
-0.6887791156768799,
-0.2901739478111267,
0.32995715737342834,
0.4332391917705536,
1.1352547407150269,
0.7769048810005188,
0.4743313789367676,
0.31051281094551086,
-0.14379467070102692,
0.3884963393211365,
-0.7172698378562927,
0.3888069987297058,
-0.14082816243171692,
-0.16524185240268707,
-0.6759403347969055,
0.030310211703181267,
0.6414088606834412,
0.7957162261009216,
-0.2904694080352783,
0.07565652579069138,
0.24326092004776,
0.6334473490715027,
-0.6473609209060669,
-0.07051882892847061,
-0.8511139750480652,
0.078165203332901,
-0.28192490339279175,
-0.13233615458011627,
-0.5960145592689514,
-0.6130631566047668,
0.03950629383325577,
-0.37979647517204285,
-0.0023587755858898163,
0.2632714509963989,
0.8493826389312744,
0.3894370198249817,
-0.32675299048423767,
0.09841721504926682,
-0.6920669674873352,
1.0930449962615967,
-0.6967244148254395,
0.2876795828342438,
0.4928434193134308,
0.21105873584747314,
-0.35738539695739746,
-0.30045488476753235,
-0.3311863839626312,
-0.3806101381778717,
0.12788738310337067,
0.083195760846138,
-0.16600096225738525,
0.017483923584222794,
0.1547243595123291,
0.4553225636482239,
-0.6144570112228394,
0.2910495400428772,
0.02420351468026638,
-0.5188708305358887,
0.44900646805763245,
0.28275057673454285,
0.15888597071170807,
0.04584117606282234,
-0.1009814664721489,
-0.2596355676651001,
-0.6147414445877075,
0.2696077525615692,
0.7282381653785706,
0.5783013701438904,
-0.10402518510818481,
0.5653150677680969,
-0.13453231751918793,
0.8055191040039062,
0.45871004462242126,
-0.17153479158878326,
0.43305596709251404,
-0.35508593916893005,
-0.2843877971172333,
0.09076288342475891,
0.879848062992096,
0.09603051841259003,
0.25045809149742126,
-0.37375760078430176,
-0.043389663100242615,
0.0896245539188385,
0.39452970027923584,
-0.3890761435031891,
-0.4424203336238861,
0.322765976190567,
-0.20778895914554596,
-0.7420501112937927,
0.033589527010917664,
-0.6770393252372742,
-0.4949166476726532,
-0.3582867980003357,
0.18389849364757538,
-0.10089487582445145,
-0.2538893520832062,
0.1571701616048813,
0.44980093836784363,
0.18438491225242615,
0.22976990044116974,
-1.245940923690796,
0.1815691739320755,
0.8136664628982544,
0.5422751307487488,
-0.410939484834671,
0.017249228432774544,
-0.9010328054428101,
-0.05340736731886864,
-0.2659304738044739,
0.44981279969215393,
-0.5168097615242004,
-0.15557625889778137,
-0.08635871112346649,
0.0886409655213356,
0.2636289894580841,
-0.5688510537147522,
0.965985119342804,
-0.5848637223243713,
0.12851332128047943,
-0.2106170356273651,
-0.33890339732170105,
0.10881468653678894,
0.5544466376304626,
-0.6018990278244019,
0.9848394393920898,
0.13168619573116302,
-0.9378060698509216,
0.09872245043516159,
-0.09198521077632904,
-0.21667392551898956,
-0.29882752895355225,
-0.08956309407949448,
-0.8725093603134155,
-0.16527175903320312,
0.2445344179868698,
0.23401953279972076,
-0.1781540960073471,
0.4590184688568115,
-0.877552330493927,
-0.042825572192668915,
0.2707799971103668,
-0.640723466873169,
1.1110543012619019,
0.09451264888048172,
-0.25243452191352844,
0.4429738521575928,
-0.5328434705734253,
0.14458604156970978,
0.06950044631958008,
-0.2644883990287781,
-0.2935514748096466,
-0.026712968945503235,
-0.13789524137973785,
0.03856709599494934,
0.6565070152282715,
-0.6492477059364319,
0.25716692209243774,
-0.45198407769203186,
0.5635728240013123,
1.155788540840149,
-0.3935455083847046,
0.7094418406486511,
-0.4384966790676117,
0.4658935070037842,
-0.07547516375780106,
0.353647381067276,
0.29952266812324524,
-0.10359573364257812,
-0.7072621583938599,
-0.2026037871837616,
0.3139786720275879,
0.6281846165657043,
-0.2981228232383728,
0.6564474105834961,
-0.44461190700531006,
-0.37446022033691406,
-0.5961418747901917,
0.2453175187110901,
0.3296334147453308,
0.8944915533065796,
0.19699664413928986,
-0.17817915976047516,
-0.5060378313064575,
-1.0715844631195068,
0.2212011218070984,
-0.31760987639427185,
-0.04802858084440231,
0.4472492039203644,
-0.04202166944742203,
-0.16292324662208557,
0.7464959025382996,
-0.352823406457901,
-0.07520661503076553,
-0.12365441024303436,
-0.42187702655792236,
0.41797491908073425,
0.4401867985725403,
0.38266438245773315,
-0.7779747247695923,
-0.24016468226909637,
0.15110546350479126,
-0.5840071439743042,
-0.02620711550116539,
0.3128408193588257,
-0.5143821239471436,
0.2687017321586609,
0.10156380385160446,
-0.1360938400030136,
0.08915387094020844,
0.6817494630813599,
0.022685077041387558,
0.4598716199398041,
-0.2619141638278961,
0.2840712070465088,
-1.2811894416809082,
0.2625860273838043,
-0.11172042787075043,
-0.5551648139953613,
-0.6344877481460571,
-0.20118160545825958,
0.027315037325024605,
0.11247958987951279,
-0.32780057191848755,
0.41560831665992737,
0.054797083139419556,
-0.04268623888492584,
-0.22333809733390808,
0.2287846803665161,
-0.0693247839808464,
0.47060373425483704,
0.06799812614917755,
0.6942049860954285,
0.37792715430259705,
-0.3176327645778656,
0.36743757128715515,
0.4973418712615967,
0.07258827239274979,
0.6220827698707581,
-0.5898427963256836,
0.3713759183883667,
-0.05170881003141403,
-0.1079777330160141,
-0.942893385887146,
-0.2725588381290436,
0.26957952976226807,
-0.5109957456588745,
0.26912426948547363,
-0.26384449005126953,
-0.19430509209632874,
0.10044675320386887,
-0.4317359924316406,
0.5690920948982239,
0.3102172613143921,
-0.54143226146698,
0.38052013516426086,
0.8594403266906738,
-0.23174621164798737,
-0.990509033203125,
-0.16880984604358673,
-0.09941595792770386,
-0.28767335414886475,
-0.5167858600616455,
0.31339123845100403,
-0.22057421505451202,
-0.37064293026924133,
-0.057678818702697754,
0.03469425439834595,
0.10404093563556671,
0.3012741506099701,
0.4279446005821228,
0.782478392124176,
0.0793037936091423,
-0.290792316198349,
-0.16195528209209442,
-0.2586568593978882,
-0.25690779089927673,
-0.17907869815826416,
0.5088139176368713,
-0.228326216340065,
-0.13808155059814453,
-0.12637431919574738,
0.08335645496845245,
0.6819441318511963,
-0.1461092084646225,
0.31848275661468506,
0.44370904564857483,
-0.4468785524368286,
0.08969490975141525,
-0.4347127377986908,
-0.06411118060350418,
-0.4399110972881317,
0.21920029819011688,
0.09381726384162903,
-1.1794642210006714,
0.42795059084892273,
0.374074250459671,
0.2820247709751129,
0.23616796731948853,
0.7328006625175476,
0.16456884145736694,
1.152104377746582,
0.7104985117912292,
-0.8863691091537476,
0.43633970618247986,
0.1804809868335724,
0.28105300664901733,
-0.8323196172714233,
-0.08210953325033188,
-0.6513498425483704,
-0.21483077108860016,
-0.6123674511909485,
0.14281585812568665,
0.4445943236351013,
-0.2239760309457779,
-0.7213773131370544,
0.2339126318693161,
-0.6229324340820312,
0.28333327174186707,
0.5703125,
0.16869805753231049,
0.2682594954967499,
0.21193404495716095,
-0.057189006358385086,
-0.1659134179353714,
-0.4089903235435486,
-0.5463326573371887,
1.226855754852295,
0.0713878870010376,
0.8464343547821045,
0.3616146445274353,
0.49567288160324097,
0.40597352385520935,
0.22617995738983154,
-0.7343122363090515,
0.2058650255203247,
-0.1964282989501953,
-0.4266963601112366,
-0.3907856345176697,
-0.5785632729530334,
-0.9345119595527649,
-0.0016295554814860225,
-0.42117437720298767,
-0.7504475712776184,
-0.08585112541913986,
0.20061595737934113,
-0.7271663546562195,
0.2971433997154236,
-0.2254210114479065,
0.7386071085929871,
-0.4341946542263031,
-0.6770581603050232,
0.0411977656185627,
-0.689502477645874,
0.4027652144432068,
-0.13242200016975403,
-0.09414085745811462,
-0.14454364776611328,
0.2598763704299927,
0.6576674580574036,
-0.29582059383392334,
0.5281453728675842,
0.142890065908432,
0.10975872725248337,
-0.3233547508716583,
0.18701063096523285,
0.4480891525745392,
0.2292965054512024,
-0.3877965211868286,
0.06493115425109863,
-0.03831585496664047,
-0.47014737129211426,
-0.4549615979194641,
0.9296348690986633,
-1.0684043169021606,
-0.7172408103942871,
-0.5498019456863403,
-0.6676905751228333,
-0.38225170969963074,
0.24363228678703308,
0.021580908447504044,
0.4529258608818054,
-0.051210589706897736,
0.10346713662147522,
0.7898527979850769,
-0.20158028602600098,
0.27735307812690735,
0.3792427182197571,
-0.052868179976940155,
-0.9033164978027344,
0.7879815101623535,
-0.10804059356451035,
0.2642451822757721,
0.24010992050170898,
0.061352554708719254,
-0.33045250177383423,
-0.5768173933029175,
-0.29668208956718445,
0.1774652749300003,
-0.2767944931983948,
-0.401277631521225,
-0.3026528060436249,
-0.32499757409095764,
-0.35417166352272034,
-0.3524375855922699,
-0.4178745746612549,
-0.4172244966030121,
-0.2689335346221924,
-0.1399984508752823,
0.22446918487548828,
0.45352068543434143,
0.013898669742047787,
-0.0691557377576828,
-0.532886266708374,
0.07363852858543396,
0.16659407317638397,
0.1749134659767151,
-0.14226916432380676,
-0.8386161923408508,
-0.08354480564594269,
0.13303427398204803,
-0.40810444951057434,
-0.35540711879730225,
0.6002623438835144,
-0.05314398184418678,
0.5194737911224365,
0.4864809215068817,
0.34930485486984253,
0.5809651613235474,
-0.3368540406227112,
0.6427499651908875,
-0.18377047777175903,
-0.7393028140068054,
0.42905598878860474,
-0.3675181269645691,
0.05464230850338936,
0.8415864706039429,
0.20329423248767853,
-0.39245158433914185,
-0.36644357442855835,
-0.6703845262527466,
-0.8036208152770996,
0.5535600781440735,
0.08753065019845963,
0.03559403866529465,
0.13394206762313843,
0.48101556301116943,
0.12010910362005234,
0.18106751143932343,
-0.47212618589401245,
-0.2963387966156006,
-0.04035656899213791,
-0.5503918528556824,
-0.12492252886295319,
-0.2259042114019394,
-0.32530471682548523,
-0.04288845509290695,
0.8582108020782471,
-0.17659474909305573,
-0.06250150501728058,
-0.0653928741812706,
0.04327404871582985,
-0.04326511546969414,
0.3038022518157959,
0.5763582587242126,
0.4958678185939789,
-0.5205554366111755,
0.35332855582237244,
0.02948983944952488,
-0.4345947206020355,
0.30081430077552795,
0.07467551529407501,
-0.2890000641345978,
-0.4915575087070465,
-0.0094749229028821,
0.47458651661872864,
0.20673732459545135,
-0.5964329838752747,
0.5146167278289795,
-0.19427907466888428,
0.18535450100898743,
-0.6396770477294922,
-0.10983610153198242,
-0.2979988753795624,
0.10164368897676468,
0.16680195927619934,
0.30599692463874817,
-0.03622430935502052,
-0.29491662979125977,
0.3874308466911316,
0.7708151936531067,
-0.5687135457992554,
-0.39116132259368896,
0.9478166103363037,
-0.01310627069324255,
-0.17404769361019135,
0.8112720251083374,
-0.0630294531583786,
-0.5128284096717834,
0.3460979759693146,
0.3715571463108063,
0.619468629360199,
-0.09366639703512192,
0.1669560968875885,
0.3581717014312744,
0.11279353499412537,
-0.34169360995292664,
0.07657136768102646,
0.042606424540281296,
-1.107332468032837,
-0.13027551770210266,
-0.5498093366622925,
-0.6816163063049316,
0.07148874551057816,
-0.775586724281311,
0.15095803141593933,
-0.7576466798782349,
-0.4523735046386719,
-0.08625978231430054,
0.23447859287261963,
-0.2947408854961395,
-0.20881842076778412,
0.12711569666862488,
0.41003990173339844,
-0.7728126049041748,
1.023193120956421,
0.39234107732772827,
-0.22187788784503937,
-0.7979145646095276,
-0.24080882966518402,
0.3645710349082947,
-0.6808053255081177,
0.2619974613189697,
-0.2076515406370163,
-0.25812211632728577,
0.07542401552200317,
-0.4825485050678253,
-0.939191460609436,
0.9673358798027039,
0.8954116702079773,
-0.4324732720851898,
0.14205341041088104,
-0.042351264506578445,
0.3907031714916229,
-0.32609570026397705,
0.21076208353042603,
0.5223073363304138,
0.3582562208175659,
-0.15042997896671295,
-0.9659502506256104,
0.01058070920407772,
-0.19546303153038025,
-0.2751358449459076,
0.3791557848453522,
-0.7800722718238831,
0.5714446306228638,
-0.13528050482273102,
0.09638320654630661,
0.2965541183948517,
0.4725331664085388,
0.32392531633377075,
0.01392634678632021,
0.48596009612083435,
0.6927636861801147,
1.0656365156173706,
-0.1328859180212021,
0.7902606129646301,
-0.4434719979763031,
0.5184234976768494,
1.0525858402252197,
-0.46312499046325684,
0.8474078178405762,
0.3002513349056244,
-0.1644597053527832,
0.029539139941334724,
0.7367132306098938,
0.05479947105050087,
0.40790995955467224,
-0.20805764198303223,
-0.22672481834888458,
-0.7832645177841187,
-0.43812501430511475,
-0.14970433712005615,
0.2984044849872589,
0.03771263360977173,
-0.259299099445343,
0.06343324482440948,
-0.35057690739631653,
0.2520386874675751,
0.26154825091362,
-0.24943207204341888,
0.5134715437889099,
-0.10709992051124573,
-0.5869387984275818,
0.5269511342048645,
-0.22147813439369202,
0.6505982279777527,
-0.4007808566093445,
0.15504857897758484,
-0.3217727243900299,
0.2311905026435852,
-0.35581913590431213,
-0.7075156569480896,
0.09000445157289505,
-0.2998993396759033,
-0.4429800808429718,
-0.023948634043335915,
0.3809625804424286,
-0.5848450064659119,
-0.5404443740844727,
0.02909966930747032,
0.21191895008087158,
-0.22221486270427704,
0.41537636518478394,
-0.5491760969161987,
0.3037741780281067,
0.2058212012052536,
0.03749937564134598,
0.542863130569458,
-0.15752217173576355,
-0.2036142498254776,
0.7041216492652893,
0.5915579795837402,
0.13561107218265533,
-0.2825208306312561,
-0.1370224952697754,
0.6600036025047302,
-0.3576916456222534,
-0.17752686142921448,
-0.9825085401535034,
0.33383193612098694,
-0.2576727569103241,
-0.12794680893421173,
0.7600268721580505,
0.6633540391921997,
0.8230674862861633,
0.2632703185081482,
0.7784193158149719,
0.15260043740272522,
0.4258883595466614,
-0.32373523712158203,
0.6981708407402039,
-0.19578564167022705,
0.19943760335445404,
-0.2104647159576416,
-0.7472814321517944,
-0.5533445477485657,
0.5176287293434143,
-0.38043326139450073,
-0.15346334874629974,
0.21656011044979095,
1.0643564462661743,
-0.12865497171878815,
-0.27997514605522156,
0.43322229385375977,
0.11130998283624649,
0.4088141620159149,
0.7954528331756592,
0.44670170545578003,
-0.19036589562892914,
0.3771200180053711,
-0.22220511734485626,
-0.3473539650440216,
-0.10593871772289276,
-0.7659918665885925,
-0.5773792862892151,
-0.6444339752197266,
-0.276734858751297,
-0.7134815454483032,
0.07451026141643524,
1.270634651184082,
0.576434850692749,
-0.970991849899292,
-0.10000748187303543,
0.4408787488937378,
0.33416813611984253,
-0.17961542308330536,
-0.16999344527721405,
0.5797740817070007,
-0.15917253494262695,
-0.851525068283081,
0.3212487995624542,
0.48512905836105347,
-0.10342670977115631,
-0.27777302265167236,
-0.2651346027851105,
0.1255347728729248,
-0.05449633672833443,
0.33521372079849243,
0.5551626682281494,
-0.6420366764068604,
-0.6485563516616821,
0.2093469649553299,
-0.2546871304512024,
0.2608262002468109,
0.6059170961380005,
-0.6680848002433777,
0.5031375885009766,
0.35997238755226135,
0.9434344172477722,
-0.06830178946256638,
0.3227551579475403,
0.6078760027885437,
-0.3696119487285614,
0.10927700996398926,
0.21846461296081543,
0.6257195472717285,
0.6017769575119019,
-0.43895524740219116,
0.4215206205844879,
0.018694058060646057,
-1.033735990524292,
-0.9557388424873352,
0.3775010108947754,
-1.4872430562973022,
0.29307109117507935,
1.0998514890670776,
-0.18671663105487823,
-0.2825164198875427,
-0.22578595578670502,
-0.30587533116340637,
0.19046038389205933,
-0.5924054980278015,
1.123892068862915,
0.5718962550163269,
-0.10132703930139542,
0.05944473296403885,
-0.28994351625442505,
0.4625752568244934,
0.45212244987487793,
-0.47155240178108215,
0.24785563349723816,
0.6220192909240723,
0.5748206973075867,
-0.012471077963709831,
0.45786482095718384,
-0.37730708718299866,
0.08524888753890991,
-0.5842353701591492,
-0.18090976774692535,
-0.20416098833084106,
0.01978396065533161,
-0.5880200862884521,
0.40438514947891235,
0.46820390224456787,
0.10439470410346985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02742v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02742v1
|
Towards Training A Chinese Large Language Model for Anesthesiology
| 2024-03-05T07:53:49 | 2024-03-05T07:53:49 |
Zhonghai Wang, Jie Jiang, Yibing Zhan, Bohao Zhou, Yanhong Li, Chong Zhang, Liang Ding, Hua Jin, Jun Peng, Xu Lin, Weifeng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Medical large language models (LLMs) have gained popularity recently due to
their significant practical utility. However, most existing research focuses on
general medicine, and there is a need for in-depth study of LLMs in specific
fields like anesthesiology. To fill the gap, we introduce Hypnos, a Chinese
Anesthesia model built upon existing LLMs, e.g., Llama. Hypnos' contributions
have three aspects: 1) The data, such as utilizing Self-Instruct, acquired from
current LLMs likely includes inaccuracies. Hypnos implements a cross-filtering
strategy to improve the data quality. This strategy involves using one LLM to
assess the quality of the generated data from another LLM and filtering out the
data with low quality. 2) Hypnos employs a general-to-specific training
strategy that starts by fine-tuning LLMs using the general medicine data and
subsequently improving the fine-tuned LLMs using data specifically from
Anesthesiology. The general medical data supplement the medical expertise in
Anesthesiology and enhance the effectiveness of Hypnos' generation. 3) We
introduce a standardized benchmark for evaluating medical LLM in
Anesthesiology. Our benchmark includes both publicly available instances from
the Internet and privately obtained cases from the Hospital. Hypnos outperforms
other medical LLMs in anesthesiology in metrics, GPT-4, and human evaluation on
the benchmark dataset.
|
[
0.17444568872451782,
-0.14608895778656006,
0.7365217804908752,
-0.06820062547922134,
-0.5283296704292297,
0.0364995077252388,
-0.4837590157985687,
-0.4535517990589142,
0.5491762161254883,
0.6470848917961121,
-0.3189897835254669,
-0.5729618668556213,
-0.24555553495883942,
0.12465977668762207,
-0.34337830543518066,
0.7327704429626465,
-0.05939901992678642,
0.647112250328064,
0.16112585365772247,
0.08373688906431198,
0.014373153448104858,
-0.7049670815467834,
-0.7310894727706909,
-0.48241114616394043,
0.5102751851081848,
0.13073450326919556,
0.8500737547874451,
1.0640276670455933,
0.3598538041114807,
0.20224645733833313,
0.10048895329236984,
-0.06780628859996796,
-0.24082300066947937,
-0.15730087459087372,
0.00452675623819232,
-0.43216219544410706,
-0.2235841155052185,
-0.16947494447231293,
0.6628832221031189,
0.8410132527351379,
-0.6198597550392151,
-0.10297029465436935,
-0.1316588819026947,
0.2711500823497772,
-0.36646655201911926,
-0.301053524017334,
-0.6154125928878784,
0.4712039828300476,
-0.22120054066181183,
-0.2502758800983429,
-0.11122023314237595,
-0.48961392045021057,
0.3358437716960907,
-0.8028047680854797,
0.27450674772262573,
0.20746839046478271,
0.878284215927124,
0.29697465896606445,
-0.28002068400382996,
-0.4171624183654785,
-0.41876259446144104,
0.5046163201332092,
-1.0001670122146606,
0.6063263416290283,
0.1767846643924713,
0.32678693532943726,
-0.03708949312567711,
-0.7353159189224243,
-0.41945356130599976,
-0.6652477979660034,
0.06821108609437943,
0.008065284229815006,
0.5110854506492615,
0.2962130308151245,
0.12208767235279083,
0.6132268309593201,
-0.481605589389801,
0.5761337876319885,
-0.48522263765335083,
-0.2959156036376953,
0.5672061443328857,
0.35534051060676575,
0.38021132349967957,
-0.282842755317688,
-0.6111201047897339,
0.182650625705719,
-1.0221933126449585,
-0.2795325219631195,
0.4113899767398834,
0.021630292758345604,
-0.24320270121097565,
0.3796727955341339,
-0.1641448587179184,
0.6661335229873657,
-0.20618081092834473,
-0.38080519437789917,
0.3404962718486786,
-0.25873059034347534,
-0.3724415600299835,
0.13430584967136383,
0.7548655271530151,
0.08698104321956635,
0.32823872566223145,
-0.2646525204181671,
-0.23450669646263123,
-0.006449889857321978,
0.5302889943122864,
-0.8726412057876587,
-0.380121648311615,
0.20296895503997803,
-0.4364204704761505,
-0.2855912446975708,
-0.08690181374549866,
-0.6098271608352661,
-0.9166848659515381,
-0.6683948636054993,
0.2631576955318451,
-0.14390629529953003,
-0.2999137341976166,
0.3845313489437103,
0.12323115020990372,
0.1615903526544571,
0.5422555804252625,
-0.9639109969139099,
0.5155319571495056,
0.6336857676506042,
0.8748407959938049,
-0.43313583731651306,
-0.406607061624527,
-0.12057028710842133,
0.029703866690397263,
-0.658333957195282,
0.49467483162879944,
-0.2294677495956421,
-0.2079060971736908,
0.26712024211883545,
0.04795874282717705,
0.013145757839083672,
-0.720888078212738,
0.335213840007782,
-0.004488476552069187,
0.12478945404291153,
-0.14403556287288666,
-0.5901760458946228,
-0.012266666628420353,
0.29456546902656555,
-0.5781055092811584,
0.4584988057613373,
0.006521979812532663,
-0.4799256920814514,
0.3344554901123047,
-0.4120151102542877,
-0.40950527787208557,
-0.008323267102241516,
-0.5104573369026184,
-0.5167069435119629,
0.058510951697826385,
0.21029752492904663,
0.297173410654068,
-0.7392414212226868,
0.29733791947364807,
-0.32023653388023376,
-0.5409562587738037,
0.1176915392279625,
-0.07567544281482697,
0.8243601322174072,
0.1616688072681427,
0.21700690686702728,
0.23058095574378967,
-0.6571217179298401,
-0.3053920269012451,
0.16174349188804626,
-0.4343090057373047,
-0.25049489736557007,
-0.1360863298177719,
-0.24601255357265472,
0.01966872252523899,
0.15565815567970276,
-0.7549030184745789,
0.321109801530838,
-0.5651131272315979,
0.7349658012390137,
0.31152433156967163,
0.38222724199295044,
0.29982078075408936,
-0.42974528670310974,
0.2385588437318802,
-0.29068076610565186,
0.560570240020752,
0.0199288297444582,
-0.20006677508354187,
-0.7562035322189331,
-0.17175184190273285,
0.32019662857055664,
0.3684985637664795,
-0.7146181464195251,
0.32007235288619995,
0.07541865110397339,
-0.6296820044517517,
-0.7979061603546143,
0.20587705075740814,
0.04628137871623039,
0.8335085511207581,
0.20784910023212433,
-0.3482394814491272,
-0.5398908257484436,
-0.5219539999961853,
-0.003470001742243767,
-0.19439005851745605,
-0.256150484085083,
-0.03335646167397499,
0.359089195728302,
-0.318718284368515,
0.3199411630630493,
-0.36993488669395447,
-0.42731112241744995,
0.0350814014673233,
-0.2586927115917206,
0.3250979781150818,
0.39619332551956177,
0.32251685857772827,
-0.30936199426651,
-0.30525845289230347,
0.22720371186733246,
-0.9271289706230164,
0.04012315720319748,
-0.14180898666381836,
-0.12460167706012726,
0.030654508620500565,
0.4567302465438843,
-0.36989840865135193,
0.25908854603767395,
0.5580607652664185,
0.11203502118587494,
0.5931389927864075,
-0.371590793132782,
0.05666306987404823,
-0.9606180191040039,
0.08152933418750763,
-0.09480303525924683,
0.23183681070804596,
-0.9494672417640686,
-0.020224066451191902,
0.2914177477359772,
-0.3591514229774475,
-0.5456135272979736,
0.5361209511756897,
-0.5059134364128113,
-0.13583600521087646,
-0.3138898015022278,
-0.0919950008392334,
0.0037434299010783434,
0.44364890456199646,
0.3784908354282379,
0.24566484987735748,
0.8361673355102539,
-0.691941499710083,
0.647125780582428,
0.07715986669063568,
-0.31566736102104187,
0.40751123428344727,
-0.8523716926574707,
0.14722777903079987,
0.1857232004404068,
0.06254340708255768,
-0.6977335214614868,
-0.392417848110199,
0.12865321338176727,
-0.24074986577033997,
0.2969886064529419,
-0.2551538050174713,
-0.4592122733592987,
-0.6052268147468567,
-0.23786833882331848,
0.13470454514026642,
0.4035148322582245,
-0.8621847629547119,
0.2077830582857132,
0.26767611503601074,
0.08558359742164612,
-0.4899112582206726,
-0.5172740817070007,
0.17308826744556427,
-0.16033506393432617,
-0.2521836459636688,
0.2686557173728943,
0.15898652374744415,
-0.07244819402694702,
0.0024433021899312735,
-0.19293801486492157,
-0.2384253889322281,
0.1518165022134781,
0.0260826013982296,
0.29606303572654724,
-0.25922563672065735,
0.6061959266662598,
-0.0033590716775506735,
0.10760480910539627,
0.10201948881149292,
-0.5202714800834656,
0.5282863974571228,
0.34680262207984924,
-0.4783917963504791,
-0.7895292043685913,
-0.20318034291267395,
0.33994796872138977,
-0.08215682953596115,
0.150509774684906,
0.3769305348396301,
-0.7197350859642029,
-0.18840473890304565,
-0.718449592590332,
-0.3651795983314514,
-0.4124114513397217,
0.3413439095020294,
0.027391713112592697,
-0.5977321267127991,
0.41613683104515076,
-0.10907436907291412,
0.11634722352027893,
0.21561883389949799,
0.6577275395393372,
-0.07378549128770828,
0.5847776532173157,
0.3246845602989197,
-0.2870621681213379,
0.445337176322937,
-0.14066894352436066,
-0.2375902235507965,
-0.7281965613365173,
-0.05627189204096794,
-0.5903679132461548,
0.18539802730083466,
-0.3986707031726837,
-0.24450936913490295,
0.5431106686592102,
-0.1546703279018402,
-0.4436303973197937,
0.16101416945457458,
-0.3924112021923065,
0.23685193061828613,
0.1285095363855362,
0.35622531175613403,
0.31650081276893616,
0.055355995893478394,
-0.02763412520289421,
0.20938318967819214,
-0.663844883441925,
-0.21522283554077148,
1.254590392112732,
0.6419997811317444,
1.1750438213348389,
-0.24578998982906342,
0.8797396421432495,
0.06270471215248108,
0.27396160364151,
-0.8172963261604309,
0.07534759491682053,
-0.18207913637161255,
-0.5172426700592041,
-0.5132799744606018,
-0.46874114871025085,
-1.0210514068603516,
0.4003221094608307,
-0.24014516174793243,
-0.3954891860485077,
0.037225592881441116,
0.16882449388504028,
-0.5420478582382202,
0.3295200765132904,
-0.420103520154953,
0.6609290242195129,
-0.4470140039920807,
-0.2982012629508972,
-0.26518914103507996,
-0.5371843576431274,
0.40536633133888245,
-0.2045181393623352,
-0.02901918813586235,
-0.14757376909255981,
-0.336835652589798,
0.7776528000831604,
-0.5255886912345886,
0.9285919666290283,
-0.2593138813972473,
-0.2743028402328491,
0.10211203247308731,
-0.15089228749275208,
0.23981568217277527,
0.2101026177406311,
-0.4458340108394623,
0.3466716706752777,
-0.12354365736246109,
-0.39092400670051575,
-0.5689921975135803,
0.7043324112892151,
-0.8491749167442322,
-0.5180783867835999,
-0.29500558972358704,
-0.18028676509857178,
-0.34336134791374207,
0.04358988627791405,
0.31263625621795654,
0.4643489122390747,
-0.19288325309753418,
-0.020277058705687523,
0.5482281446456909,
-0.37955138087272644,
0.17179754376411438,
0.588671863079071,
0.12560538947582245,
-0.6196749210357666,
0.4527118504047394,
0.22970904409885406,
0.10100889950990677,
0.2556224763393402,
0.633956789970398,
-0.49877581000328064,
-0.6745870113372803,
-0.8487542271614075,
0.5827972888946533,
-0.636547863483429,
-0.01941695809364319,
-0.3374387323856354,
-0.5829941034317017,
-0.39015090465545654,
0.033528830856084824,
-0.3849765956401825,
0.10288180410861969,
-0.273603618144989,
-0.021603785455226898,
0.17275333404541016,
1.0151585340499878,
0.21783971786499023,
0.5790520310401917,
-0.4229530692100525,
0.4415406584739685,
0.31502920389175415,
0.546323299407959,
0.20790836215019226,
-0.6493021845817566,
-0.5334078669548035,
-0.23576600849628448,
0.01030460000038147,
-0.9749268889427185,
0.5344492197036743,
-0.0537433996796608,
0.8625518679618835,
0.4868810474872589,
-0.09472642838954926,
0.5628409385681152,
-0.46383634209632874,
0.6703930497169495,
0.5293871164321899,
-0.8279762864112854,
0.6549028158187866,
-0.08001630008220673,
0.12951980531215668,
0.5835025310516357,
0.4458926320075989,
-0.604995846748352,
-0.21909286081790924,
-0.23323549330234528,
-0.5099861025810242,
0.4803869128227234,
-0.27687641978263855,
0.09053001552820206,
0.3559947907924652,
0.5938196778297424,
0.20152147114276886,
0.44777432084083557,
-0.6884921193122864,
0.12995921075344086,
-0.08429720997810364,
-0.15746089816093445,
-0.04498617351055145,
0.026602301746606827,
-0.2292163372039795,
-0.27439773082733154,
0.48405009508132935,
-0.2208942472934723,
0.036200787872076035,
0.30900290608406067,
-0.04792168363928795,
-0.13137146830558777,
0.046241242438554764,
0.4933989346027374,
0.8007605075836182,
0.031185077503323555,
0.13289527595043182,
0.38116654753685,
-0.6275144219398499,
0.11267971992492676,
-0.20966589450836182,
-0.12318335473537445,
0.03874870389699936,
0.3638354241847992,
0.8228495121002197,
-0.019503915682435036,
-0.2976081073284149,
0.383550763130188,
0.06627163290977478,
-0.22356516122817993,
-0.3825579881668091,
0.050909679383039474,
-0.04789665713906288,
-0.13651786744594574,
0.1940317004919052,
-0.2967170774936676,
0.19204017519950867,
-0.4927934408187866,
0.1999129205942154,
0.010116695426404476,
-0.33611658215522766,
-0.28529971837997437,
0.4598548114299774,
0.3770020008087158,
-0.17096832394599915,
0.356876939535141,
0.03241667151451111,
-0.5079637765884399,
0.6506862640380859,
0.44064733386039734,
0.6012511253356934,
-0.5515960454940796,
-0.1672850400209427,
0.7111575603485107,
0.3945944607257843,
-0.5129667520523071,
0.28236573934555054,
0.04226363077759743,
-0.4041026830673218,
-0.481318861246109,
-0.4137667119503021,
-0.8907589316368103,
0.2397618591785431,
-0.5853174328804016,
0.5968745946884155,
-0.7969064116477966,
0.022360093891620636,
-0.23865914344787598,
0.30632132291793823,
-0.5286835432052612,
0.3224603235721588,
0.1951150745153427,
0.7058337330818176,
-0.6846224069595337,
1.2156682014465332,
0.5094340443611145,
-0.296539843082428,
-0.6453848481178284,
0.25685298442840576,
-0.11126169562339783,
-1.1557561159133911,
0.04215085133910179,
-0.09268565475940704,
0.35267871618270874,
-0.336706280708313,
-0.3836682140827179,
-0.8406586647033691,
1.0151805877685547,
0.3666420578956604,
-0.8842127919197083,
-0.1871662437915802,
0.10456957668066025,
0.8535485863685608,
-0.4737118184566498,
-0.03318117931485176,
0.5132529735565186,
0.12786555290222168,
-0.025083942338824272,
-1.138649821281433,
0.2568836212158203,
0.03461635112762451,
-0.06305676698684692,
-0.11318056285381317,
-0.586093544960022,
1.0095263719558716,
-0.4797871708869934,
-0.040711190551519394,
0.22364217042922974,
0.3157985210418701,
0.2186276912689209,
0.30877646803855896,
0.5408795475959778,
0.42908284068107605,
1.1131526231765747,
-0.04870643839240074,
1.0648150444030762,
-0.4365440309047699,
0.14599205553531647,
0.9393275380134583,
-0.6095984578132629,
0.7750016450881958,
0.36537599563598633,
0.09739528596401215,
0.42687663435935974,
0.7237259745597839,
-0.2778150737285614,
0.3394031822681427,
0.8499898910522461,
-0.07976289093494415,
-0.21147355437278748,
-0.09218738228082657,
-0.6130873560905457,
0.46473392844200134,
0.4633096158504486,
-0.34265434741973877,
0.06192978098988533,
0.16828976571559906,
0.10871279984712601,
0.05463205277919769,
-0.5261678695678711,
0.8121718168258667,
0.19952256977558136,
-0.6577316522598267,
0.8400593996047974,
-0.11305660754442215,
0.6032397150993347,
-0.779833197593689,
0.1353415697813034,
-0.16989313066005707,
-0.005253658164292574,
-0.43090036511421204,
-0.4218713939189911,
0.04632332921028137,
-0.1907740831375122,
0.2890448570251465,
0.2720092535018921,
0.598895251750946,
-0.5089887380599976,
-0.16699005663394928,
0.3297257423400879,
0.3360503911972046,
0.24821321666240692,
0.10980556160211563,
-0.35922086238861084,
0.07459257543087006,
-0.18275296688079834,
0.04841972887516022,
0.26348885893821716,
0.4628300368785858,
-0.04346383363008499,
0.6092756986618042,
0.6412378549575806,
0.7268767356872559,
-0.13129618763923645,
0.5151568651199341,
0.7304980754852295,
-0.6603026986122131,
-0.8035896420478821,
-0.6867715120315552,
-0.20518143475055695,
-0.12167487293481827,
-0.5588012337684631,
0.5258327722549438,
0.4160061478614807,
0.6912199854850769,
-0.07804783433675766,
0.8649196028709412,
0.5635908246040344,
0.5831791162490845,
-0.6854515075683594,
0.8404385447502136,
-0.6775622963905334,
0.24725677073001862,
0.24389363825321198,
-0.6074346303939819,
-0.38281282782554626,
0.47735658288002014,
-0.17385698854923248,
-0.142147958278656,
0.558590292930603,
0.5708370804786682,
0.18673571944236755,
-0.025812659412622452,
0.5734772682189941,
0.06496924161911011,
0.08115320652723312,
0.5646942257881165,
1.184260606765747,
-0.3178595006465912,
0.3103608191013336,
-0.35193273425102234,
0.03593999519944191,
-0.23537428677082062,
-0.5785284638404846,
-0.981478750705719,
-0.03696565330028534,
-0.34460127353668213,
-0.2914794981479645,
0.18479369580745697,
1.0671985149383545,
0.9972506761550903,
-0.7350522875785828,
-0.7307937741279602,
0.0698070153594017,
0.13651211559772491,
-0.12241854518651962,
-0.04661770910024643,
0.5368528962135315,
-0.4331297278404236,
-0.543805718421936,
0.35246801376342773,
0.13053230941295624,
0.23962625861167908,
-0.5387918949127197,
-0.4389243721961975,
0.24357832968235016,
-0.061706919223070145,
0.20895543694496155,
0.26696324348449707,
-0.7680345177650452,
-0.06546834111213684,
0.15473626554012299,
-0.4014934301376343,
0.159709632396698,
0.9509488344192505,
-0.35804417729377747,
0.3713628053665161,
0.3573491871356964,
0.763627290725708,
0.4795912206172943,
-0.30488601326942444,
0.34289124608039856,
-0.6794716715812683,
0.026562660932540894,
0.24957996606826782,
0.6594508290290833,
0.5397318005561829,
-0.43489745259284973,
0.7222983241081238,
0.2665781080722809,
-0.48177871108055115,
-0.9462870359420776,
-0.19505560398101807,
-0.8053955435752869,
-0.2580728232860565,
1.431460976600647,
-0.13249196112155914,
-0.24998866021633148,
-0.3008469045162201,
-0.2783164381980896,
0.311592161655426,
-0.22873546183109283,
0.7769772410392761,
0.3438931703567505,
-0.06828974187374115,
0.11460069566965103,
-0.5737035274505615,
0.606734037399292,
0.2548306882381439,
-0.9985565543174744,
-0.0871981680393219,
0.16931220889091492,
0.4960584342479706,
0.11763929575681686,
0.8055998086929321,
-0.10356186330318451,
0.43432557582855225,
0.08092791587114334,
0.5542636513710022,
-0.05698540434241295,
-0.4643019139766693,
-0.6143710613250732,
0.17721916735172272,
0.21268247067928314,
-0.30896151065826416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02738v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02738v2
|
Causal Prompting: Debiasing Large Language Model Prompting based on Front-Door Adjustment
| 2024-03-05T07:47:34 | 2024-05-22T16:21:38 |
Congzhi Zhang, Linhai Zhang, Jialong Wu, Deyu Zhou, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the notable advancements of existing prompting methods, such as
In-Context Learning and Chain-of-Thought for Large Language Models (LLMs), they
still face challenges related to various biases. Traditional debiasing methods
primarily focus on the model training stage, including approaches based on data
augmentation and reweighting, yet they struggle with the complex biases
inherent in LLMs. To address such limitations, the causal relationship behind
the prompting methods is uncovered using a structural causal model, and a novel
causal prompting method based on front-door adjustment is proposed to
effectively mitigate LLMs biases. In specific, causal intervention is achieved
by designing the prompts without accessing the parameters and logits of LLMs.
The chain-of-thought generated by LLM is employed as the mediator variable and
the causal effect between input prompts and output answers is calculated
through front-door adjustment to mitigate model biases. Moreover, to accurately
represent the chain-of-thoughts and estimate the causal effects, contrastive
learning is used to fine-tune the encoder of chain-of-thought by aligning its
space with that of the LLM. Experimental results show that the proposed causal
prompting approach achieves excellent performance across seven natural language
processing datasets on both open-source and closed-source LLMs.
|
[
-0.37849462032318115,
-1.3429454565048218,
0.6767899990081787,
0.46095651388168335,
-0.2510688006877899,
-0.35147926211357117,
-0.3599167466163635,
-0.05439603701233864,
-0.04117117449641228,
0.3178726136684418,
-0.8023326396942139,
-0.45320212841033936,
-0.4648025631904602,
0.32783403992652893,
-0.08738306164741516,
0.7021263837814331,
0.1574229747056961,
0.33339551091194153,
-0.19183625280857086,
0.20773610472679138,
-0.9751949310302734,
-0.13166166841983795,
-1.0129177570343018,
-0.52777099609375,
0.8553664088249207,
0.2444913387298584,
0.5863165259361267,
0.2750372588634491,
0.04156966507434845,
0.25730741024017334,
-0.17945346236228943,
0.04414669796824455,
-0.4701913595199585,
0.22414958477020264,
-0.48823219537734985,
-0.41579100489616394,
-0.18592354655265808,
-0.08103565871715546,
0.7196058034896851,
0.6689056158065796,
-0.04324820637702942,
0.26168400049209595,
0.3476870357990265,
0.761631965637207,
-0.671870768070221,
0.23834984004497528,
-0.670843780040741,
-0.1617816537618637,
0.08680892735719681,
-0.41872870922088623,
-0.7174484133720398,
-0.6072855591773987,
0.05343339219689369,
-0.40047067403793335,
0.11830370128154755,
0.10875322669744492,
0.5080493092536926,
0.5369800925254822,
-0.4272494316101074,
-0.19718065857887268,
-0.5915321707725525,
0.6512713432312012,
-0.7181437015533447,
0.5273285508155823,
0.44916489720344543,
0.06446228176355362,
-0.44775575399398804,
-0.015458746813237667,
-0.488693505525589,
-0.4724172353744507,
-0.017083358019590378,
-0.02599218860268593,
-0.4288143217563629,
-0.02499031275510788,
0.423444926738739,
0.01015439722687006,
-0.408724844455719,
0.4964126944541931,
-0.14272452890872955,
-0.025736071169376373,
0.26009657979011536,
0.1589745730161667,
0.21466772258281708,
0.08908175677061081,
-0.3402738571166992,
-0.05907691642642021,
-1.128899335861206,
0.01039926614612341,
0.46113675832748413,
0.4489331543445587,
-0.11591118574142456,
0.2925228774547577,
-0.331035315990448,
0.9529885649681091,
0.4787709712982178,
0.1810641884803772,
0.05249553918838501,
0.05650796368718147,
-0.3960607349872589,
0.21829229593276978,
0.6514198780059814,
0.5543592572212219,
0.3548097610473633,
0.024816283956170082,
-0.0828443393111229,
0.17472153902053833,
0.10420393943786621,
-0.6768816709518433,
0.1044638380408287,
0.21979765594005585,
-0.24009345471858978,
-0.39046549797058105,
-0.18879792094230652,
-0.9137778282165527,
-0.6884527206420898,
-0.530948281288147,
0.4624345898628235,
-0.022297879680991173,
0.029299963265657425,
0.08830507099628448,
0.034157928079366684,
0.16558685898780823,
0.40949705243110657,
-0.8162682056427002,
0.13515926897525787,
0.4619426727294922,
0.7515812516212463,
0.1035885289311409,
-0.24735254049301147,
-0.8125028610229492,
0.2648453116416931,
-0.42892521619796753,
0.6725592017173767,
-0.49877792596817017,
-0.23280440270900726,
0.12064513564109802,
-0.1711621731519699,
0.054451826959848404,
-0.41404280066490173,
0.42734119296073914,
-0.6976920366287231,
0.32028836011886597,
-0.5491164922714233,
-0.16606055200099945,
-0.16918377578258514,
0.4767923951148987,
-0.6511527299880981,
0.8475918173789978,
-0.24978046119213104,
-0.9324679970741272,
0.3898147940635681,
-0.2969425320625305,
-0.3911013603210449,
-0.2902876138687134,
-0.29715755581855774,
-0.20792151987552643,
0.23126733303070068,
0.7387396097183228,
0.3555138111114502,
-0.799884021282196,
0.9086290001869202,
-0.3989812433719635,
-0.21848464012145996,
0.21742641925811768,
-0.6993379592895508,
0.9324625134468079,
0.05295474827289581,
-0.463697224855423,
0.4107609689235687,
-0.7386342883110046,
-0.46655863523483276,
0.0648946762084961,
-0.13783036172389984,
-0.551173210144043,
0.01808466948568821,
-0.678538978099823,
0.39488348364830017,
0.08747148513793945,
-0.39623087644577026,
0.027281710878014565,
-0.5243126749992371,
-0.049341004341840744,
1.100553035736084,
0.30504873394966125,
0.3356796205043793,
-0.2022031992673874,
0.42002972960472107,
0.1747734099626541,
0.21290960907936096,
-0.20991984009742737,
-0.32633697986602783,
-0.7535918354988098,
-0.07703988999128342,
-0.05722617357969284,
0.5420386791229248,
-0.7301297783851624,
0.5597444176673889,
0.01458385493606329,
-0.24953381717205048,
-0.34726929664611816,
0.16333051025867462,
0.41727951169013977,
0.7847861647605896,
0.3047843873500824,
0.016527948901057243,
-0.3969303369522095,
-0.7504022121429443,
-0.3361992835998535,
-0.24912604689598083,
-0.06198183447122574,
0.09706577658653259,
0.25267770886421204,
-0.16576068103313446,
0.8634707927703857,
-0.7702973484992981,
-0.1463150978088379,
-0.0012753133196383715,
0.1236228421330452,
0.4960905909538269,
0.3984268009662628,
0.27585870027542114,
-0.39291873574256897,
-0.28967204689979553,
-0.28713303804397583,
-0.6245929598808289,
-0.5598032474517822,
-0.2359321564435959,
-0.17633937299251556,
0.015652043744921684,
0.7267151474952698,
-0.40749916434288025,
0.28558191657066345,
0.4602523744106293,
-0.23828333616256714,
0.6205402612686157,
-0.18543966114521027,
0.05137554928660393,
-0.9128957390785217,
0.11442121118307114,
0.12555496394634247,
0.3289291262626648,
-0.54451584815979,
-0.12802480161190033,
-0.08696726709604263,
-0.034211743623018265,
-0.30987340211868286,
0.7819339036941528,
-0.5197316408157349,
0.30274248123168945,
-0.27159053087234497,
0.3638249337673187,
-0.07805806398391724,
0.561110258102417,
-0.03533818945288658,
0.5719982385635376,
0.6678913831710815,
-0.8662127256393433,
0.25710445642471313,
0.3261510133743286,
-0.23094578087329865,
0.5443401336669922,
-0.579266369342804,
0.08017436414957047,
-0.3687726557254791,
0.5234789848327637,
-1.0481570959091187,
0.04779529571533203,
0.5139034390449524,
-0.14804916083812714,
0.15050436556339264,
-0.018033409491181374,
-0.39781999588012695,
-0.4589304029941559,
-0.3720910847187042,
0.22810332477092743,
0.2907485067844391,
-0.7680153250694275,
0.25952598452568054,
-0.08292657881975174,
-0.24202390015125275,
-0.5627439022064209,
-0.5087607502937317,
-0.007251191884279251,
-0.21703995764255524,
-0.3675585985183716,
-0.0016987695125862956,
-0.15007330477237701,
-0.3051206171512604,
-0.22793883085250854,
-0.03730233758687973,
0.26050475239753723,
0.07263169437646866,
0.1605079025030136,
0.3847211003303528,
-0.02672041952610016,
0.23417645692825317,
0.308097779750824,
-0.30574697256088257,
0.4626944363117218,
-0.3767237067222595,
0.5038809180259705,
0.3486586809158325,
-0.4274669885635376,
-0.39833658933639526,
0.06633923947811127,
0.38419729471206665,
-0.06459185481071472,
0.750351071357727,
0.3125284016132355,
-0.28494513034820557,
-0.2192162573337555,
-0.7871233820915222,
-0.589093804359436,
-0.47240012884140015,
0.05958093702793121,
-0.21045583486557007,
-0.8927894234657288,
0.37536492943763733,
-0.12530213594436646,
-0.08584124594926834,
0.07826918363571167,
0.8975781798362732,
0.47307467460632324,
1.0704487562179565,
0.32837018370628357,
-0.4266052842140198,
0.7252255082130432,
0.3179101347923279,
0.3936351537704468,
-0.8347636461257935,
-0.2458585798740387,
-0.7346804141998291,
-0.23457148671150208,
-0.3939795196056366,
-0.3920624852180481,
0.2027532309293747,
0.1079574003815651,
-0.47634127736091614,
-0.1355760246515274,
-0.2720503807067871,
0.3747071921825409,
0.5947489142417908,
0.2522101104259491,
0.3059305250644684,
-0.08425097167491913,
-0.504295825958252,
0.08710587024688721,
-0.6116446852684021,
-0.27014896273612976,
0.6349979043006897,
0.29049110412597656,
1.128229022026062,
-0.02146533690392971,
0.5507950186729431,
0.10556471347808838,
0.3166760802268982,
-0.6764426827430725,
0.5219663977622986,
0.3119896948337555,
-0.5813887715339661,
-0.280965656042099,
-0.4535040855407715,
-0.8737444281578064,
0.2661488950252533,
-0.08048532158136368,
-0.8715689778327942,
0.5309354662895203,
0.32432836294174194,
-0.3895222544670105,
0.07136833667755127,
-0.470907986164093,
0.5633805990219116,
-0.007521584630012512,
-0.6336125135421753,
-0.31937113404273987,
-0.5737216472625732,
0.45844751596450806,
-0.030961651355028152,
0.22026044130325317,
-0.025296526029706,
0.28720712661743164,
0.5356020331382751,
-0.19291599094867706,
1.4415147304534912,
-0.38247546553611755,
-0.6383774280548096,
0.25864920020103455,
0.290795236825943,
0.8921637535095215,
0.0802592784166336,
-0.1898512989282608,
0.031267497688531876,
-0.6247842907905579,
-0.0014487146399915218,
-0.7319051623344421,
0.7624050378799438,
-0.38739603757858276,
-1.0930975675582886,
-0.1825544238090515,
-0.40214017033576965,
-0.4910031259059906,
0.15515488386154175,
0.1494860202074051,
0.5343226194381714,
-0.30999964475631714,
-0.03264009952545166,
0.6262804269790649,
-0.5576761364936829,
0.27059152722358704,
0.6389287114143372,
-0.24183522164821625,
-0.5396948456764221,
0.48215940594673157,
-0.2808550000190735,
0.32803627848625183,
0.6695700883865356,
0.743226170539856,
-0.3493179976940155,
-0.389763206243515,
-0.31554001569747925,
0.21052607893943787,
-0.6559155583381653,
-0.3177594542503357,
-0.5426937937736511,
0.17986994981765747,
-0.4709487855434418,
-0.19565126299858093,
0.0017914969939738512,
-0.03132644668221474,
-0.22097812592983246,
-0.2669181823730469,
0.32541215419769287,
0.6183829307556152,
-0.00559981307014823,
0.3533060848712921,
-0.7489396333694458,
0.1888718158006668,
0.3946494162082672,
0.24432216584682465,
0.5277212858200073,
-0.49367833137512207,
-0.25581541657447815,
0.044815339148044586,
-0.2862667739391327,
-0.9225918054580688,
0.21236711740493774,
-0.2763504683971405,
0.5176177024841309,
0.7568894624710083,
0.22492368519306183,
0.7115986347198486,
-0.6884111762046814,
0.8063842058181763,
0.3305829167366028,
-1.0194523334503174,
0.7339518070220947,
-0.45245519280433655,
0.5309317708015442,
0.4308956265449524,
0.3174380958080292,
-0.5855260491371155,
-0.6729571223258972,
-0.27808046340942383,
-0.6653715968132019,
0.5785819888114929,
-0.21981701254844666,
0.014755437150597572,
-0.3352947533130646,
0.13840778172016144,
0.048110492527484894,
0.28020042181015015,
-0.6999284625053406,
-0.14029671251773834,
0.08907964080572128,
-0.13363152742385864,
-0.03755590692162514,
-0.2872880697250366,
-0.15035228431224823,
-0.29501473903656006,
0.8672020435333252,
-0.20321747660636902,
0.11541852355003357,
0.24954456090927124,
-0.25663071870803833,
-0.3428346812725067,
0.5194199085235596,
0.779667854309082,
0.6644576191902161,
-0.11022795736789703,
0.20725314319133759,
0.45291849970817566,
-0.1392086297273636,
0.1957411915063858,
-0.18598631024360657,
-0.42194899916648865,
-0.19360420107841492,
0.2519041895866394,
0.9978088736534119,
0.5033285021781921,
-0.3167376220226288,
0.35995981097221375,
0.1866866648197174,
0.1073063388466835,
0.1736108958721161,
-0.02571863867342472,
-0.07406934350728989,
0.3094818890094757,
0.20568861067295074,
-0.28502005338668823,
0.0007656668312847614,
-0.34578418731689453,
-0.0185609832406044,
0.43776777386665344,
-0.5590059757232666,
-0.45028090476989746,
0.7254233360290527,
0.31401336193084717,
-0.1323765218257904,
0.5768185257911682,
0.054327256977558136,
-0.6074580550193787,
0.23116856813430786,
1.0107771158218384,
1.2204277515411377,
-0.5485677719116211,
0.187719464302063,
0.6692670583724976,
0.3977225720882416,
-0.11900144815444946,
0.03781212493777275,
-0.06252627074718475,
-0.905928373336792,
-0.6682677865028381,
-0.4458267092704773,
-0.3300451636314392,
0.21933278441429138,
-0.6943486928939819,
0.34553518891334534,
-0.4601196050643921,
-0.07241359353065491,
-0.49440228939056396,
-0.1460273265838623,
-0.4706123173236847,
0.2676757872104645,
0.19014157354831696,
1.0435566902160645,
-1.0388857126235962,
0.7606673240661621,
0.38515421748161316,
-0.4404658377170563,
-0.7780552506446838,
0.17078816890716553,
0.3370574712753296,
-0.7324644327163696,
0.9317900538444519,
0.0367823950946331,
-0.3691544532775879,
0.08790723979473114,
-0.5035098195075989,
-0.5653808116912842,
0.7592586874961853,
0.44341835379600525,
-0.7787306904792786,
-0.11494287103414536,
-0.1769062578678131,
0.33506473898887634,
-0.2290794551372528,
0.11221069097518921,
0.46047741174697876,
0.6832506656646729,
-0.0035901565570384264,
-0.4582439363002777,
0.6482739448547363,
0.01003720611333847,
-0.14873848855495453,
0.2322636842727661,
-0.5554062724113464,
0.6289554834365845,
-0.2522810399532318,
-0.11807220429182053,
-0.2553832232952118,
0.47525209188461304,
0.47852322459220886,
0.17379724979400635,
0.6704221963882446,
0.38473135232925415,
0.7926570177078247,
0.10853911191225052,
0.8804929256439209,
-0.2674559950828552,
0.0454394593834877,
1.342909812927246,
-0.5297126770019531,
0.6242206692695618,
0.7625829577445984,
0.03719194233417511,
0.6830581426620483,
0.4456619620323181,
0.06499849259853363,
0.5214896202087402,
0.2964950501918793,
-0.34091705083847046,
-0.05958383530378342,
-0.14858758449554443,
-0.27334466576576233,
0.08878090232610703,
0.35559579730033875,
-0.28730309009552,
-0.466697096824646,
-0.054694171994924545,
0.02068651281297207,
-0.013793016783893108,
-0.2522719204425812,
0.8509519100189209,
0.287229984998703,
-0.943000316619873,
0.46318110823631287,
-0.12685149908065796,
0.5190860033035278,
-0.6241576671600342,
0.04408590868115425,
-0.19130094349384308,
0.06954046338796616,
-0.023843353614211082,
-0.33538416028022766,
0.03834931552410126,
0.004291097167879343,
-0.26118746399879456,
-0.3932285010814667,
0.6263089179992676,
-0.49225059151649475,
-0.18007859587669373,
0.49475783109664917,
0.4903928339481354,
-0.3749106526374817,
-0.13675644993782043,
-0.5838354229927063,
0.1815522462129593,
-0.014405595138669014,
-0.27251648902893066,
0.13006280362606049,
0.4532618522644043,
-0.3685983717441559,
0.501359760761261,
0.85781329870224,
0.19938069581985474,
-0.22853191196918488,
0.5789341330528259,
0.9087786078453064,
-0.8799334168434143,
-0.7066843509674072,
-1.2812716960906982,
0.31641945242881775,
0.031548138707876205,
-0.15103423595428467,
0.9271050095558167,
0.18192629516124725,
0.5874654054641724,
-0.23994427919387817,
0.45847535133361816,
0.2601446807384491,
0.21746474504470825,
-0.7544160485267639,
0.5527337789535522,
-0.20404623448848724,
0.41790229082107544,
-0.5882799029350281,
-0.9300816655158997,
-0.4300002157688141,
0.47200778126716614,
-0.6968662738800049,
-0.1396336406469345,
0.9102810621261597,
1.0833423137664795,
0.33699074387550354,
0.19933511316776276,
0.3016096353530884,
0.4820737838745117,
0.37996232509613037,
0.354104220867157,
1.0472686290740967,
-0.016303395852446556,
0.0026178054977208376,
0.1994280219078064,
-0.3828166127204895,
-0.2769200801849365,
-1.0634742975234985,
-1.1067047119140625,
-0.42229965329170227,
-0.2676489055156708,
-0.3733510971069336,
0.08114869147539139,
1.1275765895843506,
0.19699999690055847,
-0.8352156281471252,
-0.20766755938529968,
-0.2869419455528259,
0.5018737316131592,
-0.28703054785728455,
-0.21599209308624268,
0.34832775592803955,
-0.5655219554901123,
-0.6277305483818054,
0.5295957922935486,
0.23241065442562103,
-0.10625883936882019,
-0.36627519130706787,
-0.017747696489095688,
-0.37766778469085693,
0.2710912525653839,
0.691628634929657,
-0.04911474883556366,
-0.726573646068573,
-0.3405664265155792,
-0.32763949036598206,
0.0939071848988533,
-0.02043086104094982,
1.034964919090271,
-0.9045754671096802,
0.4484221339225769,
0.6202024221420288,
0.5854281783103943,
0.12951654195785522,
0.007938721217215061,
0.9439753293991089,
-0.8222376704216003,
0.2719272971153259,
-0.10798732936382294,
0.2232137769460678,
0.25238674879074097,
-0.6196343898773193,
0.20117045938968658,
0.0032841507345438004,
-0.35773202776908875,
-0.7524548172950745,
0.41717371344566345,
-0.5807093977928162,
-0.25750666856765747,
1.1129485368728638,
0.19635632634162903,
-0.28496649861335754,
-0.11490412056446075,
-0.4448573887348175,
0.4000566005706787,
-0.5034311413764954,
0.8566083312034607,
0.7667980790138245,
0.15859460830688477,
0.05948272719979286,
-0.3253468871116638,
0.39163675904273987,
0.3820648193359375,
-0.758368968963623,
0.44846218824386597,
0.7553355693817139,
0.13622520864009857,
-0.08318030834197998,
0.5749292373657227,
-0.03289215639233589,
0.09427983313798904,
-0.048864178359508514,
-0.05101512745022774,
-0.10339494794607162,
-0.45117130875587463,
-0.7664223909378052,
-0.12343797832727432,
0.14103908836841583,
-0.007471307180821896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02727v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02727v1
|
HARGPT: Are LLMs Zero-Shot Human Activity Recognizers?
| 2024-03-05T07:34:51 | 2024-03-05T07:34:51 |
Sijie Ji, Xinzhe Zheng, Chenshu Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
There is an ongoing debate regarding the potential of Large Language Models
(LLMs) as foundational models seamlessly integrated with Cyber-Physical Systems
(CPS) for interpreting the physical world. In this paper, we carry out a case
study to answer the following question: Are LLMs capable of zero-shot human
activity recognition (HAR). Our study, HARGPT, presents an affirmative answer
by demonstrating that LLMs can comprehend raw IMU data and perform HAR tasks in
a zero-shot manner, with only appropriate prompts. HARGPT inputs raw IMU data
into LLMs and utilizes the role-play and think step-by-step strategies for
prompting. We benchmark HARGPT on GPT4 using two public datasets of different
inter-class similarities and compare various baselines both based on
traditional machine learning and state-of-the-art deep classification models.
Remarkably, LLMs successfully recognize human activities from raw IMU data and
consistently outperform all the baselines on both datasets. Our findings
indicate that by effective prompting, LLMs can interpret raw IMU data based on
their knowledge base, possessing a promising potential to analyze raw sensor
data of the physical world effectively.
|
[
-0.06081758812069893,
-0.8044846653938293,
0.849212646484375,
-0.14357949793338776,
-0.26585808396339417,
0.1722821742296219,
-0.09149541705846786,
-0.8264070153236389,
-0.03673630580306053,
0.329242467880249,
-0.4680977165699005,
-0.281937837600708,
-0.24334800243377686,
0.03381113335490227,
-0.2921030819416046,
0.5696784853935242,
-0.14841926097869873,
-0.015343124978244305,
-0.08967515826225281,
-0.038504958152770996,
-0.567430853843689,
-0.7262293100357056,
-0.5300553441047668,
-0.9155701398849487,
0.4198457896709442,
0.29390469193458557,
0.3466120660305023,
0.36098968982696533,
0.3043571710586548,
0.24243493378162384,
-0.006507088430225849,
0.011485596187412739,
-0.3780268728733063,
0.2135181427001953,
-0.003121354151517153,
-0.17691850662231445,
-0.5068897604942322,
-0.11622092872858047,
0.5465859770774841,
0.5065163373947144,
0.04100339859724045,
0.23178519308567047,
0.33129966259002686,
0.24574822187423706,
-0.509974479675293,
0.3082236647605896,
-0.39293351769447327,
0.22549574077129364,
-0.07500337809324265,
-0.37638095021247864,
-0.28215906023979187,
0.5308254361152649,
0.13756318390369415,
-0.28646600246429443,
0.2802404463291168,
0.076033815741539,
0.6232189536094666,
0.10376977920532227,
-0.41159889101982117,
0.1517287641763687,
-1.0025328397750854,
0.6650596857070923,
-0.45943641662597656,
0.4169464111328125,
0.30179813504219055,
0.20706680417060852,
-0.17632156610488892,
-0.19972984492778778,
-0.5763242244720459,
-0.17156973481178284,
-0.06515371054410934,
0.14260724186897278,
-0.1957872360944748,
0.09103667736053467,
0.44384875893592834,
0.33651962876319885,
-0.6260014176368713,
0.3275201618671417,
-0.24405670166015625,
-0.19635893404483795,
0.5667057633399963,
0.3605991303920746,
0.001464474480599165,
-0.38224369287490845,
-0.43705856800079346,
0.08029207587242126,
-0.806196928024292,
0.24464508891105652,
0.06794272363185883,
0.21774893999099731,
-0.41415250301361084,
0.8414394855499268,
-0.3681502342224121,
0.7572076916694641,
-0.19594770669937134,
-0.12485671788454056,
-0.014028308913111687,
-0.17414548993110657,
-0.530474066734314,
0.09491802006959915,
0.6716195344924927,
0.12103413790464401,
0.36970606446266174,
-0.33449941873550415,
-0.32351136207580566,
-0.09763011336326599,
0.40533095598220825,
-0.6473054885864258,
-0.07437776774168015,
0.21593470871448517,
-0.256670743227005,
-0.24312995374202728,
0.008690204471349716,
-0.5590649247169495,
-0.5770918726921082,
-0.45804983377456665,
0.6136247515678406,
-0.11566966027021408,
-0.23921138048171997,
0.5685110688209534,
0.1153615415096283,
0.6386801600456238,
0.5956773161888123,
-0.6587178707122803,
0.37854692339897156,
0.7846928238868713,
0.8929956555366516,
-0.1525288075208664,
-0.31547844409942627,
-0.3862978219985962,
0.18773366510868073,
-0.09078702330589294,
0.8529679179191589,
-0.12688668072223663,
-0.44822847843170166,
-0.11374234408140182,
-0.05704865604639053,
-0.14787444472312927,
-0.3931455612182617,
0.3625015616416931,
-0.575137734413147,
0.10111227631568909,
-0.2326989769935608,
-0.40124788880348206,
-0.08655961602926254,
0.8098999261856079,
-0.32499879598617554,
1.0227456092834473,
0.13456493616104126,
-0.5179436802864075,
0.396679550409317,
-0.9596341252326965,
-0.4987952411174774,
0.3556276559829712,
-0.37359103560447693,
-0.3880518972873688,
0.17325954139232635,
0.16113674640655518,
0.6999821662902832,
-0.07535649091005325,
0.06751637160778046,
-0.3242047429084778,
-0.43561694025993347,
0.5488622188568115,
-0.664237916469574,
0.48241522908210754,
0.1364385038614273,
-0.3800162971019745,
0.08322801440954208,
-0.3688940405845642,
-0.12617787718772888,
0.21365509927272797,
-0.43879616260528564,
0.0700957328081131,
0.15374822914600372,
-0.2672346532344818,
0.3421770930290222,
0.08838752657175064,
-0.850223958492279,
0.2564852237701416,
-0.023148737847805023,
0.24468351900577545,
0.7744636535644531,
-0.14458726346492767,
0.24804572761058807,
-0.34002941846847534,
0.646024227142334,
-0.1664048284292221,
-0.060051608830690384,
-0.39216822385787964,
-0.6645361185073853,
-0.4087589383125305,
-0.5937663912773132,
-0.056459661573171616,
0.6871238946914673,
-0.5017121434211731,
0.5496423840522766,
-0.4314914345741272,
-0.25625211000442505,
-0.11993352323770523,
-0.17235040664672852,
0.24999460577964783,
0.9081011414527893,
0.3248797357082367,
-0.2392864227294922,
-0.49522364139556885,
-0.2691975235939026,
-0.21508149802684784,
-0.4935632646083832,
-0.3192150592803955,
0.638947606086731,
0.4648681581020355,
-0.07709024846553802,
0.8771195411682129,
-0.3181490898132324,
-0.18678396940231323,
-0.3854493498802185,
0.38954654335975647,
0.24257557094097137,
0.0830271989107132,
0.3501429259777069,
-0.4598889648914337,
-0.29301002621650696,
-0.02905857563018799,
-1.1326525211334229,
-0.12275099009275436,
-0.13597188889980316,
0.07801684737205505,
-0.04873332008719444,
0.4147595763206482,
-0.7215190529823303,
0.7449600100517273,
0.23045822978019714,
-0.5035507678985596,
0.6172179579734802,
-0.2516299784183502,
0.23537716269493103,
-0.6673445701599121,
0.2619903087615967,
-0.0723852813243866,
-0.4635099470615387,
-0.8826902508735657,
-0.1868477463722229,
-0.06472163647413254,
-0.3377265930175781,
-0.7822043299674988,
0.8302804827690125,
-0.5673638582229614,
-0.5209646821022034,
-0.49341318011283875,
-0.47608286142349243,
-0.0907239243388176,
0.3654232323169708,
0.36452415585517883,
0.5957869291305542,
0.7110959887504578,
-0.8032825589179993,
0.3358311653137207,
0.1409662812948227,
-0.43917614221572876,
0.5109580755233765,
-0.6364541053771973,
0.052262239158153534,
-0.044067539274692535,
0.2963314950466156,
-0.8763464689254761,
-0.6784030199050903,
0.3017290532588959,
-0.3723672926425934,
0.2951159179210663,
-0.3946358263492584,
-0.7672609686851501,
-0.5369685888290405,
-0.22136053442955017,
0.4404408633708954,
0.6403743624687195,
-0.5160942673683167,
0.42225751280784607,
0.3387501835823059,
0.1513187736272812,
-0.4707465171813965,
-0.5773478150367737,
0.21526937186717987,
-0.30325445532798767,
-0.25993072986602783,
0.1294214129447937,
-0.04325554519891739,
-0.05450601875782013,
-0.27004680037498474,
-0.17406415939331055,
-0.15542714297771454,
0.2830188274383545,
0.4898495674133301,
0.6194086670875549,
-0.12188095599412918,
-0.1661699265241623,
-0.6486819982528687,
-0.1736348420381546,
0.06762191653251648,
-0.056507259607315063,
0.7789580821990967,
-0.11872901767492294,
-0.7874878644943237,
-0.6140496730804443,
-0.06387678533792496,
0.6102829575538635,
0.08074518293142319,
0.3212348520755768,
0.540596604347229,
-0.5663378834724426,
0.4641040861606598,
-0.2632710039615631,
-0.16179561614990234,
-0.47285109758377075,
-0.03256138041615486,
-0.11946500092744827,
-1.0655914545059204,
0.2686379849910736,
0.00394510617479682,
0.12109296023845673,
0.067798912525177,
0.6573650240898132,
-0.4456653594970703,
0.9596036672592163,
0.4481537938117981,
-0.19629472494125366,
0.5382941961288452,
-0.22889390587806702,
0.15555131435394287,
-0.9184413552284241,
-0.15896709263324738,
-0.18167637288570404,
-0.6744593381881714,
-0.36485016345977783,
-0.39386045932769775,
0.6341072916984558,
-0.12292454391717911,
-0.39290687441825867,
0.21836324036121368,
-0.3585284352302551,
0.5194477438926697,
0.2115715891122818,
0.18764728307724,
0.13276463747024536,
0.23769637942314148,
0.17048856616020203,
-0.02485886588692665,
-0.5501423478126526,
-0.6059487462043762,
0.9185245037078857,
0.39770936965942383,
0.9785690903663635,
0.030367886647582054,
0.7913423776626587,
0.2593550384044647,
0.4136362373828888,
-1.217679500579834,
0.7141655087471008,
0.2922229766845703,
-0.7103371024131775,
-0.36492252349853516,
-0.061147719621658325,
-1.3279058933258057,
0.3341098725795746,
-0.2697986960411072,
-1.0562379360198975,
0.1469583362340927,
0.28407737612724304,
-0.4820665717124939,
0.7088676691055298,
-0.4485786557197571,
0.6973659992218018,
-0.4687735140323639,
-0.4636029303073883,
-0.09760046750307083,
-0.3838755488395691,
0.34282785654067993,
0.08698515594005585,
0.3251578211784363,
-0.3665931820869446,
0.03930133208632469,
0.549709141254425,
0.062027234584093094,
1.1410349607467651,
-0.2928643226623535,
-0.00042396021308377385,
0.42974504828453064,
0.2273384928703308,
0.3497648239135742,
-0.05562644079327583,
-0.06254715472459793,
0.3804425895214081,
-0.3226943910121918,
-0.38224151730537415,
-0.2589879333972931,
0.48974844813346863,
-0.6162784099578857,
-0.5133979320526123,
-0.7750966548919678,
-0.5233586430549622,
-0.07497511059045792,
0.26375406980514526,
0.020750638097524643,
0.36255720257759094,
-0.39269161224365234,
0.1835714876651764,
0.5164397954940796,
0.14414988458156586,
0.5538653135299683,
0.77089923620224,
-0.10974496603012085,
0.05786643549799919,
0.8380451798439026,
-0.010238743387162685,
-0.05897345393896103,
0.5445886254310608,
0.26718685030937195,
-0.24851958453655243,
-0.455931156873703,
-0.473489373922348,
0.3407204747200012,
-0.20810812711715698,
-0.2578282058238983,
-0.6903243660926819,
-0.23831932246685028,
-0.3661387860774994,
-0.36828136444091797,
0.01938021555542946,
-0.15719470381736755,
-0.48284974694252014,
-0.05555014684796333,
0.1275162249803543,
0.87947016954422,
-0.23412726819515228,
0.4118483364582062,
-0.9228010773658752,
0.6474161744117737,
0.34675663709640503,
0.2773702144622803,
-0.11651410907506943,
-0.5158921480178833,
-0.2518376410007477,
0.016262365505099297,
-0.42303580045700073,
-0.7461205720901489,
0.3255421221256256,
-0.021045226603746414,
0.535391092300415,
0.5087372064590454,
-0.02129196934401989,
0.6742481589317322,
-0.5307182669639587,
1.0094189643859863,
0.2394031584262848,
-0.6976999640464783,
0.3696780204772949,
-0.3967837989330292,
0.5322327017784119,
0.2491481453180313,
0.45125770568847656,
-0.559684693813324,
0.19766147434711456,
-0.6903826594352722,
-0.4907497465610504,
0.805429220199585,
-0.08882696181535721,
0.07005156576633453,
0.16641850769519806,
0.3379390835762024,
-0.14159199595451355,
0.11177489161491394,
-0.8080406188964844,
0.27202439308166504,
-0.078401118516922,
0.11139284819364548,
-0.03271223232150078,
-0.06820178776979446,
-0.11716220527887344,
-0.26430609822273254,
0.2072417140007019,
-0.2964131534099579,
0.5966811776161194,
0.2598952651023865,
-0.1843361258506775,
-0.36350056529045105,
0.5226995944976807,
0.2605665922164917,
0.46416640281677246,
-0.2502475678920746,
0.3026107847690582,
0.3980672359466553,
-0.4626481533050537,
0.3657810091972351,
-0.2604200839996338,
-0.08926674723625183,
-0.1717999130487442,
0.5814729928970337,
0.5776479244232178,
0.2923121154308319,
-0.7825567126274109,
0.6077525019645691,
-0.0658969134092331,
-0.3012787699699402,
-0.2616596519947052,
0.2608266770839691,
-0.2548541724681854,
0.10610580444335938,
0.16337169706821442,
-0.13178445398807526,
-0.004171387758105993,
-0.6923272609710693,
0.01451846957206726,
0.5900245904922485,
-0.574598491191864,
-0.7303584218025208,
0.49170398712158203,
-0.008715261705219746,
-0.39593902230262756,
0.5449318885803223,
-0.16977448761463165,
-0.5098589658737183,
0.39585456252098083,
0.42317861318588257,
0.8399116396903992,
-0.3064836263656616,
0.1046999916434288,
0.3553139269351959,
0.18109411001205444,
-0.009979159571230412,
0.7253842949867249,
-0.4702387750148773,
-0.879185140132904,
-0.6210275292396545,
-0.48110464215278625,
-0.7357732653617859,
0.45645806193351746,
-0.5948901176452637,
0.31931862235069275,
-0.40411823987960815,
0.023624638095498085,
-0.09778434038162231,
-0.15859760344028473,
-0.9573338031768799,
0.16434122622013092,
0.4661608636379242,
0.6019530296325684,
-0.8566347360610962,
0.8342785835266113,
0.8522464036941528,
0.08179259300231934,
-0.3445311188697815,
0.022387195378541946,
0.2650223970413208,
-1.0441285371780396,
0.6260458827018738,
0.319754421710968,
-0.08627836406230927,
-0.0691511258482933,
-0.5887061357498169,
-0.5095481276512146,
1.314132571220398,
0.22623926401138306,
-0.3318037688732147,
-0.0313897542655468,
0.4224245250225067,
0.6157410740852356,
-0.1515958160161972,
0.10423464328050613,
0.2993892729282379,
0.5175002217292786,
0.11545152217149734,
-0.9222970008850098,
-0.07442593574523926,
0.16140368580818176,
-0.6183679103851318,
0.15629950165748596,
-0.3865687847137451,
0.6567556858062744,
-0.3480973243713379,
-0.3383278250694275,
-0.19813604652881622,
0.4741375744342804,
0.48530814051628113,
0.625508725643158,
0.69451504945755,
0.45446428656578064,
0.5487292408943176,
0.016426222398877144,
1.146976351737976,
-0.12350710481405258,
0.09814604371786118,
0.8911499977111816,
-0.8096332550048828,
0.9151812791824341,
0.27336809039115906,
-0.2362416684627533,
0.26153668761253357,
0.5260069370269775,
0.12554596364498138,
0.2770671248435974,
0.07898753136396408,
-0.7287558913230896,
-0.45457273721694946,
-0.1640091836452484,
0.04557959362864494,
0.6629114151000977,
0.5201446413993835,
0.12435165792703629,
-0.44200599193573,
-0.08144381642341614,
-0.05351811647415161,
-0.4939013719558716,
-0.2132880687713623,
0.8403105139732361,
-0.0013249969342723489,
-0.6560119390487671,
0.503166913986206,
-0.11682402342557907,
0.649297833442688,
-0.6551219820976257,
-0.05597400665283203,
0.3433810770511627,
-0.0341990701854229,
-0.27868664264678955,
-1.1731408834457397,
0.29239270091056824,
0.2955526113510132,
0.0412156842648983,
-0.60475754737854,
1.1685575246810913,
-0.0000015918473081910633,
-0.11593706905841827,
0.16095469892024994,
0.800432026386261,
0.5193464159965515,
-0.22728170454502106,
-0.6017588376998901,
-0.21451003849506378,
-0.26241734623908997,
-0.13317133486270905,
0.6319985389709473,
0.2654517889022827,
-0.19231991469860077,
0.5297672748565674,
0.8359993696212769,
0.010328005068004131,
-0.19496174156665802,
-0.12802015244960785,
0.6958127617835999,
-0.8257575035095215,
-0.40545880794525146,
-0.8704650402069092,
0.4746784567832947,
0.04410863667726517,
-0.056199852377176285,
0.6218606233596802,
0.6141229271888733,
0.6585455536842346,
0.08717872202396393,
0.8588234186172485,
0.01826898194849491,
0.5653429627418518,
-0.3549659848213196,
0.46529075503349304,
-0.25884488224983215,
0.18652339279651642,
0.19092755019664764,
-0.5890108942985535,
-0.2947077751159668,
0.6106840968132019,
-0.31401994824409485,
-0.13901200890541077,
0.35193270444869995,
0.6571587324142456,
-0.5752193331718445,
-0.04430845379829407,
0.6864762902259827,
0.02972349151968956,
0.5437790751457214,
0.2107439786195755,
1.0707718133926392,
-0.16240601241588593,
0.2146661877632141,
-0.0492267943918705,
-0.3640189468860626,
-0.4362930953502655,
-1.0817807912826538,
-0.8379676938056946,
-0.16334620118141174,
-0.25264453887939453,
-0.08443856239318848,
-0.19155281782150269,
0.8399183750152588,
0.7995194792747498,
-0.652085542678833,
-0.5643141865730286,
-0.0583915114402771,
-0.0607118234038353,
-0.11682617664337158,
-0.2271808385848999,
0.011757184751331806,
-0.03579237312078476,
-0.3823556900024414,
0.8705103397369385,
0.43567922711372375,
0.433933287858963,
-0.3579578101634979,
-0.2597981095314026,
-0.1222371831536293,
0.0022944328375160694,
0.9299876689910889,
0.8017294406890869,
-0.6748504638671875,
-0.5230788588523865,
0.30313536524772644,
0.11548148840665817,
0.18385958671569824,
1.2113933563232422,
-0.9661688804626465,
0.3284078538417816,
0.6831475496292114,
0.5408118963241577,
0.642676830291748,
-0.05887623876333237,
0.22149373590946198,
-0.8581299781799316,
0.08854474872350693,
0.29360270500183105,
0.6308757066726685,
0.4032417833805084,
-0.42137411236763,
0.6876238584518433,
0.25897517800331116,
-0.8311218619346619,
-0.7664634585380554,
0.28490519523620605,
-1.0777350664138794,
-0.1265401691198349,
1.221315860748291,
-0.21312367916107178,
-0.27101922035217285,
-0.4811536371707916,
-0.2509215772151947,
0.10048383474349976,
-0.22280709445476532,
0.745049238204956,
0.5912511944770813,
-0.8559216260910034,
-0.21071241796016693,
-0.747070848941803,
0.02673509158194065,
0.14882299304008484,
-0.8873677253723145,
0.2906167209148407,
0.5568627119064331,
0.0855007916688919,
0.03807112202048302,
0.8897920250892639,
0.01611245609819889,
0.22273294627666473,
-0.526175320148468,
0.011091808788478374,
-0.16982659697532654,
-0.3057376742362976,
-0.5570711493492126,
-0.12990140914916992,
0.028586795553565025,
-0.09745419770479202
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.