id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00417v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00417v1
|
Rethinking Tokenization: Crafting Better Tokenizers for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-01T10:03:07 | 2024-03-01T10:03:07 |
Jinbiao Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tokenization significantly influences language models(LMs)' performance. This
paper traces the evolution of tokenizers from word-level to subword-level,
analyzing how they balance tokens and types to enhance model adaptability while
controlling complexity. Despite subword tokenizers like Byte Pair Encoding
(BPE) overcoming many word tokenizer limitations, they encounter difficulties
in handling non-Latin languages and depend heavily on extensive training data
and computational resources to grasp the nuances of multiword expressions
(MWEs). This article argues that tokenizers, more than mere technical tools,
should drawing inspiration from the cognitive science about human language
processing. This study then introduces the "Principle of Least Effort" from
cognitive science, that humans naturally seek to reduce cognitive effort, and
discusses the benefits of this principle for tokenizer development. Based on
this principle, the paper proposes that the Less-is-Better (LiB) model could be
a new approach for LLM tokenizer. The LiB model can autonomously learn an
integrated vocabulary consisting of subwords, words, and MWEs, which
effectively reduces both the numbers of tokens and types. Comparative
evaluations show that the LiB tokenizer outperforms existing word and BPE
tokenizers, presenting an innovative method for tokenizer development, and
hinting at the possibility of future cognitive science-based tokenizers being
more efficient.
|
[
-0.18024468421936035,
-0.6205151081085205,
0.4048268496990204,
-0.09776484966278076,
-0.43732529878616333,
0.2718856930732727,
-0.3391273617744446,
-0.3086879849433899,
0.29232537746429443,
0.13172955811023712,
-0.24170587956905365,
-0.290645956993103,
-0.7390932440757751,
0.014229925349354744,
-0.16744013130664825,
1.033905029296875,
0.21630966663360596,
0.2638980448246002,
-0.3200652003288269,
-0.03873058781027794,
-0.5162920951843262,
-0.6377050280570984,
-0.8817955255508423,
-0.6376062035560608,
0.6542201042175293,
-0.023661594837903976,
0.7100499868392944,
0.7342097759246826,
0.5288934111595154,
0.268777072429657,
-0.5639944076538086,
-0.04196912795305252,
-0.6157460808753967,
-0.23650479316711426,
-0.1213371530175209,
-0.8143854141235352,
-0.3825979232788086,
-0.03480859100818634,
0.2810828387737274,
0.9132639765739441,
-0.07382204383611679,
0.3006901443004608,
-0.03397894278168678,
0.6606035828590393,
-0.6753221154212952,
0.003277795622125268,
-0.8912004828453064,
-0.12716640532016754,
-0.3121109902858734,
0.014999354258179665,
-0.4636678993701935,
0.005263248924165964,
-0.30850470066070557,
-0.6131502389907837,
0.31546035408973694,
0.23090507090091705,
0.5359653234481812,
0.22483490407466888,
-0.2684580683708191,
-0.05217915400862694,
-0.5463823080062866,
0.8220746517181396,
-0.876753568649292,
0.6787481904029846,
0.08527977764606476,
-0.14272825419902802,
-0.3386903405189514,
-0.6436767578125,
-0.46024632453918457,
-0.2547881305217743,
-0.03547349572181702,
-0.20141154527664185,
-0.19548025727272034,
0.26154065132141113,
0.19563515484333038,
0.22415445744991302,
-0.30599769949913025,
0.26329395174980164,
-0.5363205671310425,
-0.2521195411682129,
0.3585967719554901,
0.2231951653957367,
0.2921999990940094,
-0.31686723232269287,
-0.14553198218345642,
0.18084201216697693,
-0.7477631568908691,
0.34108608961105347,
0.02562502585351467,
0.4070071578025818,
0.1553955227136612,
0.6880376935005188,
0.005930684506893158,
0.4626353085041046,
0.0641568973660469,
-0.2555980086326599,
-0.05927694961428642,
-0.6043161749839783,
-0.24213747680187225,
-0.013872349634766579,
0.3786124885082245,
0.32852980494499207,
-0.011478982865810394,
-0.35042592883110046,
-0.5221284031867981,
0.2360858917236328,
0.2649539113044739,
-0.8411946892738342,
-0.14469218254089355,
0.1910921186208725,
-0.9072547554969788,
-0.2993611693382263,
-0.08481141924858093,
-0.25966063141822815,
-0.4839242100715637,
-0.39341306686401367,
0.10764679312705994,
-0.5097557306289673,
-0.15872997045516968,
0.12258791923522949,
-0.2579710781574249,
0.23083826899528503,
0.054166220128536224,
-1.0565112829208374,
0.553956925868988,
1.2555227279663086,
1.0010396242141724,
-0.37180060148239136,
-0.138947531580925,
-0.4209858775138855,
0.06746525317430496,
-0.6009775996208191,
0.5482324361801147,
-0.4536440670490265,
-0.5741283297538757,
-0.22346223890781403,
-0.23140452802181244,
0.06978067755699158,
-0.3932357132434845,
0.3837401568889618,
-0.573004961013794,
-0.015024563297629356,
-0.4001173973083496,
-0.7987766265869141,
-0.015477252192795277,
-0.0018845971208065748,
-0.5683282613754272,
0.9483482837677002,
-0.09258807450532913,
-0.6885068416595459,
0.7733679413795471,
-0.9466220140457153,
-0.4255326986312866,
0.2531157433986664,
0.008239539340138435,
-0.02845928817987442,
0.9999808669090271,
0.12007804960012436,
0.11364738643169403,
-0.3304353356361389,
0.3872108459472656,
-0.2093440294265747,
-0.4566861093044281,
0.26245835423469543,
-0.3333316445350647,
0.6420761346817017,
0.1688707172870636,
-0.22327443957328796,
0.20280605554580688,
-0.6232476234436035,
-0.045680876821279526,
0.12090995907783508,
-0.6939575672149658,
-0.42749327421188354,
0.09427817910909653,
0.26128819584846497,
-0.03048679605126381,
0.4421115219593048,
-0.8164713382720947,
0.14625973999500275,
-0.8434855937957764,
0.7352895736694336,
0.9214580059051514,
-0.27740785479545593,
0.662920355796814,
-0.3665902316570282,
0.394662469625473,
-0.21694239974021912,
0.4214009642601013,
0.11721721291542053,
-0.28506651520729065,
-0.9651566743850708,
-0.3732699751853943,
0.4454604983329773,
0.3745022416114807,
-0.46980345249176025,
0.18224868178367615,
-0.6044899225234985,
-0.4778826832771301,
-0.6184660196304321,
0.4335726797580719,
0.3375692069530487,
0.031435202807188034,
0.30799630284309387,
-0.5492880940437317,
-0.5441357493400574,
-0.895244836807251,
-0.5286714434623718,
-0.33148428797721863,
0.1919289529323578,
-0.09550482779741287,
0.48333731293678284,
-0.10150564461946487,
1.0173923969268799,
-0.2544077932834625,
0.03066825494170189,
-0.5790050029754639,
0.06961681693792343,
0.2523050904273987,
0.5181947946548462,
0.5123457908630371,
-0.5757719874382019,
-0.22957763075828552,
-0.06972713023424149,
-0.14921920001506805,
-0.011075636371970177,
0.1231096163392067,
-0.05268588289618492,
0.3463083803653717,
0.6945931315422058,
-0.5702647566795349,
0.40729618072509766,
0.3171980381011963,
-0.18536944687366486,
0.15106606483459473,
-0.1318492293357849,
-0.44363221526145935,
-0.9275027513504028,
0.15393725037574768,
-0.33645009994506836,
-0.01192181184887886,
-0.7760564684867859,
0.1632576435804367,
-0.16452984511852264,
-0.00026063242694363,
-0.4963044226169586,
0.7189382314682007,
-0.31554242968559265,
0.007857285439968109,
-0.5564522743225098,
0.14112348854541779,
-0.08831235021352768,
0.3323199450969696,
-0.21068738400936127,
0.5673930644989014,
0.29797443747520447,
-0.5178345441818237,
0.32769039273262024,
-0.1403036117553711,
-0.2448778748512268,
0.3680509328842163,
-0.881577730178833,
0.3356236219406128,
-0.37129509449005127,
0.2065736949443817,
-1.0011767148971558,
0.13825732469558716,
-0.09296915680170059,
-0.3874053359031677,
0.24228279292583466,
-0.1666402667760849,
-0.5220291018486023,
-0.2532317638397217,
-0.45984742045402527,
0.4578299820423126,
0.3981589674949646,
-0.3060392141342163,
0.6960591673851013,
0.290668249130249,
-0.023370100185275078,
-0.4801715612411499,
-0.780314028263092,
0.4063263237476349,
-0.08324357122182846,
-0.5940273404121399,
0.5586156249046326,
-0.23739533126354218,
-0.24690181016921997,
0.017354946583509445,
-0.3196783661842346,
0.136918306350708,
0.3718630075454712,
0.08120103925466537,
0.3871791958808899,
-0.13542291522026062,
0.40180718898773193,
-0.11194261163473129,
-0.2883550524711609,
-0.1444542109966278,
-0.4931406080722809,
0.8136963844299316,
0.05670448765158653,
-0.3341157138347626,
-0.4056949317455292,
0.15299783647060394,
0.4499483108520508,
-0.2864420711994171,
0.9076388478279114,
0.6904304027557373,
-0.3493884801864624,
0.21321550011634827,
-0.6446840763092041,
-0.26998645067214966,
-0.4589116871356964,
0.5364286303520203,
-0.5757876038551331,
-0.9214601516723633,
0.2690593898296356,
-0.14923468232154846,
0.5175144672393799,
0.11498769372701645,
0.5144143104553223,
0.1532193273305893,
0.9183111786842346,
0.9696512818336487,
-0.31151989102363586,
0.8667740821838379,
-0.04229787737131119,
0.43974629044532776,
-0.9523698687553406,
0.007048276253044605,
-0.29738470911979675,
-0.4928574562072754,
-0.6066976189613342,
-0.5159237384796143,
0.08343720436096191,
0.11654969304800034,
-0.02619093842804432,
0.1707935333251953,
-0.4411482810974121,
0.477839857339859,
0.5701518654823303,
-0.0822577103972435,
0.10327065736055374,
-0.11886278539896011,
-0.20240654051303864,
-0.07149950414896011,
-0.9089816212654114,
-0.6357533931732178,
1.071022391319275,
0.2768097221851349,
0.5811325311660767,
0.18772420287132263,
0.9842746257781982,
0.11556661874055862,
0.39238983392715454,
-0.9661957621574402,
0.5672737956047058,
-0.26860377192497253,
-0.7390332818031311,
-0.26444458961486816,
-0.23053711652755737,
-0.9914479851722717,
0.36513054370880127,
-0.37385421991348267,
-0.523412823677063,
0.14652292430400848,
0.1312970668077469,
-0.2972393333911896,
0.4220969080924988,
-0.632625162601471,
0.7786867618560791,
-0.39041590690612793,
-0.24811871349811554,
-0.38615235686302185,
-0.3153667747974396,
0.10587737709283829,
-0.0017925210995599627,
0.7066962122917175,
0.24802131950855255,
-0.5208644866943359,
0.7503488063812256,
-0.3743741810321808,
0.9638129472732544,
-0.2498270869255066,
-0.019975585862994194,
0.16405057907104492,
0.19688081741333008,
0.6500630974769592,
-0.29026931524276733,
0.008994566276669502,
-0.06515517830848694,
0.07983475178480148,
-0.7713578939437866,
-0.6295273303985596,
0.4053855240345001,
-0.585452139377594,
-0.6825371384620667,
0.11818302422761917,
-0.27094098925590515,
0.12979815900325775,
0.3326035737991333,
0.15655003488063812,
0.3363124430179596,
-0.4529104232788086,
0.347677618265152,
0.3238464891910553,
-0.12056060880422592,
0.5399638414382935,
0.3596627116203308,
-0.27653059363365173,
-0.5528091192245483,
1.0779647827148438,
0.23578646779060364,
0.2849007248878479,
0.5562503337860107,
0.4634873569011688,
-0.10570940375328064,
-0.9000811576843262,
-0.03491418808698654,
0.2959286570549011,
-0.8350257277488708,
0.040281280875205994,
-0.5118375420570374,
0.10961354523897171,
-0.6074602007865906,
-0.24533192813396454,
-0.518215537071228,
-0.47419387102127075,
-0.10882972925901413,
-0.3151681125164032,
0.22869250178337097,
0.7024443745613098,
-0.14443250000476837,
0.48685362935066223,
-0.5617212653160095,
0.08121893554925919,
0.1671123057603836,
0.1964053064584732,
0.029049472883343697,
-0.576483964920044,
-0.3504607379436493,
-0.2706151306629181,
0.003554706461727619,
-0.3300012946128845,
-0.046462226659059525,
0.05941954255104065,
0.4471491575241089,
0.19118565320968628,
-0.21663543581962585,
0.6884260773658752,
-0.467314213514328,
0.8992936015129089,
0.3402954638004303,
-1.3761612176895142,
0.20156258344650269,
0.05394628643989563,
0.11660964787006378,
0.5037949085235596,
-0.20858339965343475,
-0.9863499999046326,
-0.17210650444030762,
-0.5012785196304321,
-1.1236971616744995,
0.5055875778198242,
0.11620403081178665,
0.4561217725276947,
0.03883577883243561,
0.6990808844566345,
0.13962645828723907,
0.30743208527565,
-1.0872429609298706,
-0.1551312506198883,
-0.24013976752758026,
-0.4176454544067383,
-0.2346818596124649,
-0.2544592022895813,
0.11507565528154373,
-0.2213979810476303,
0.6780851483345032,
-0.12548600137233734,
0.046130988746881485,
-0.08244989067316055,
-0.35833051800727844,
0.0030028135515749454,
0.4663779139518738,
0.6072649955749512,
0.6016309261322021,
0.14035628736019135,
0.2989509105682373,
0.3626767098903656,
-0.2770814597606659,
0.05754745006561279,
-0.3684341311454773,
-0.27412891387939453,
-0.12861368060112,
0.6233600974082947,
0.877575695514679,
0.2101028710603714,
-0.5297935009002686,
0.42338791489601135,
0.05074820667505264,
0.07596869766712189,
-0.013809760101139545,
0.14463429152965546,
0.3057098090648651,
0.16248932480812073,
0.12537096440792084,
0.03594560548663139,
-0.04497702792286873,
-0.44026753306388855,
-0.0620448924601078,
0.6942887306213379,
-0.33951041102409363,
-0.4043527841567993,
0.5914757251739502,
0.21348701417446136,
-0.6187020540237427,
0.20821183919906616,
-0.1747559905052185,
-0.5186882615089417,
0.365488737821579,
0.4259069859981537,
0.6885901093482971,
0.12803351879119873,
-0.07716909050941467,
0.1450597643852234,
0.6980639696121216,
0.006436917930841446,
0.024351727217435837,
-0.08391828089952469,
-0.6702501177787781,
-0.46682292222976685,
-0.6563790440559387,
-0.16973279416561127,
-0.03554549440741539,
-0.369799941778183,
0.2923024296760559,
-0.7166416049003601,
-0.47614800930023193,
-0.00009853521623881534,
0.08671708405017853,
-0.6253644824028015,
0.08550472557544708,
0.15173199772834778,
0.8543040156364441,
-0.6574814319610596,
0.6544210910797119,
0.8219695091247559,
-0.41142404079437256,
-0.572395920753479,
-0.3054167926311493,
-0.11990629881620407,
-0.8885237574577332,
0.8153433203697205,
-0.025989331305027008,
-0.09612402319908142,
-0.04285166412591934,
-0.6208396553993225,
-0.9816619753837585,
0.9707365036010742,
0.29244527220726013,
-0.5563876032829285,
-0.13151505589485168,
0.07211530953645706,
0.6376122832298279,
-0.35693982243537903,
0.03902255743741989,
0.5204275250434875,
0.5112462639808655,
-0.1293061524629593,
-0.6944689750671387,
0.18766705691814423,
-0.20522178709506989,
0.42501091957092285,
0.3313952088356018,
-0.8125147819519043,
0.960491955280304,
-0.08269288390874863,
-0.27458715438842773,
0.18338805437088013,
0.7226144671440125,
-0.03599599376320839,
0.22360287606716156,
0.5835527181625366,
0.4515131115913391,
0.7141789793968201,
0.16930150985717773,
0.9598773121833801,
-0.5379323363304138,
0.17357012629508972,
0.9960088133811951,
-0.07057999074459076,
0.7109359502792358,
0.915651261806488,
-0.2392692267894745,
0.3974367380142212,
0.4976791441440582,
0.03632969781756401,
0.2151540070772171,
0.6426934599876404,
-0.05277204513549805,
-0.3743359446525574,
-0.27752548456192017,
0.24045245349407196,
0.5370332598686218,
0.10954737663269043,
-0.26390957832336426,
0.038553714752197266,
0.013051585294306278,
0.1671997308731079,
0.020427385345101357,
-0.17551206052303314,
0.891801655292511,
0.08671689033508301,
-0.4356667697429657,
0.5585120916366577,
0.4349478781223297,
1.024261236190796,
-0.3779864013195038,
0.3749137222766876,
-0.2878817617893219,
0.028942471370100975,
-0.15786044299602509,
-0.0699005126953125,
0.1949053257703781,
0.0947883352637291,
-0.2571987509727478,
-0.11215268820524216,
0.6201369166374207,
-0.02333618700504303,
-0.6296722292900085,
0.3359246253967285,
0.649101197719574,
0.17917202413082123,
0.17965291440486908,
-0.7315078973770142,
0.10247325152158737,
-0.10959868133068085,
-0.19051076471805573,
0.2687755823135376,
0.40331366658210754,
-0.048119451850652695,
0.6567690968513489,
0.8959547877311707,
0.435080349445343,
0.2655823528766632,
0.13108761608600616,
0.7540557980537415,
-0.8401219844818115,
-0.22383402287960052,
-1.0717036724090576,
0.29936373233795166,
0.03833260387182236,
-0.2063547521829605,
0.3725881576538086,
0.6514905691146851,
0.7729723453521729,
0.2379196733236313,
0.711731493473053,
-0.1446206122636795,
0.23555216193199158,
-0.3919415771961212,
0.3479785919189453,
-0.6661430597305298,
0.24894778430461884,
-0.2081199586391449,
-0.7907150387763977,
-0.2494717389345169,
0.4784357249736786,
-0.170311838388443,
0.08804985135793686,
0.6506367325782776,
0.7911971807479858,
0.12877388298511505,
-0.27127426862716675,
0.26708176732063293,
0.061059895902872086,
0.6744670867919922,
0.3490039110183716,
0.7087941765785217,
-0.2788969576358795,
0.617520809173584,
-0.1601993441581726,
-0.15193967521190643,
-0.22935542464256287,
-0.7535989284515381,
-1.0409880876541138,
-0.29847007989883423,
-0.10535114258527756,
-0.0519784539937973,
-0.11721906065940857,
1.3482836484909058,
0.5782659649848938,
-0.6473224759101868,
-0.31775256991386414,
-0.3672414720058441,
0.32294654846191406,
-0.11761489510536194,
-0.20384745299816132,
0.21878685057163239,
-0.590790331363678,
-0.7516498565673828,
0.3220994472503662,
0.39088866114616394,
0.05977568402886391,
-0.2988515794277191,
-0.004865356255322695,
0.10493332892656326,
0.5491893291473389,
0.6779860258102417,
-0.13633278012275696,
-0.9771631956100464,
-0.358097642660141,
0.12901942431926727,
-0.16044306755065918,
0.07405342906713486,
1.1943731307983398,
-0.561226487159729,
0.3573175072669983,
0.46192386746406555,
0.6415945291519165,
0.21769095957279205,
-0.25880298018455505,
0.4268456995487213,
-0.43388891220092773,
0.1596674919128418,
-0.022930217906832695,
0.4101807177066803,
0.42255523800849915,
-0.17654448747634888,
0.45935145020484924,
0.517117977142334,
-0.1060674637556076,
-0.9388604760169983,
0.38700658082962036,
-0.5188156366348267,
-0.5106101036071777,
0.8924332857131958,
0.03610860928893089,
-0.5358887910842896,
-0.13805097341537476,
-0.35043013095855713,
0.33632373809814453,
-0.5654926300048828,
0.8518995642662048,
0.8386980295181274,
-0.18816880881786346,
-0.030761785805225372,
-0.2452787309885025,
0.3784165382385254,
0.8750197291374207,
-0.48175904154777527,
0.2820345163345337,
0.1895255744457245,
0.4072873890399933,
0.3336333632469177,
0.7355924248695374,
0.051307667046785355,
-0.036383986473083496,
-0.007506558205932379,
0.1946878731250763,
-0.08043324947357178,
-0.026774466037750244,
-0.3134404420852661,
0.01859377510845661,
0.5497347712516785,
0.010604646988213062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00411v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00411v2
|
Cross-Lingual Learning vs. Low-Resource Fine-Tuning: A Case Study with Fact-Checking in Turkish
| 2024-03-01T09:57:46 | 2024-03-22T15:54:03 |
Recep Firat Cekinel, Pinar Karagoz, Cagri Coltekin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid spread of misinformation through social media platforms has raised
concerns regarding its impact on public opinion. While misinformation is
prevalent in other languages, the majority of research in this field has
concentrated on the English language. Hence, there is a scarcity of datasets
for other languages, including Turkish. To address this concern, we have
introduced the FCTR dataset, consisting of 3238 real-world claims. This dataset
spans multiple domains and incorporates evidence collected from three Turkish
fact-checking organizations. Additionally, we aim to assess the effectiveness
of cross-lingual transfer learning for low-resource languages, with a
particular focus on Turkish. We demonstrate in-context learning (zero-shot and
few-shot) performance of large language models in this context. The
experimental results indicate that the dataset has the potential to advance
research in the Turkish language.
|
[
-0.5905866026878357,
-0.8489675521850586,
0.1292017251253128,
0.004987712949514389,
-0.2820262312889099,
0.045155636966228485,
-0.5466260313987732,
-0.6706344485282898,
-0.25828817486763,
0.21964357793331146,
-0.30740419030189514,
-0.35454511642456055,
-0.7530630826950073,
0.30111053586006165,
-0.1473657339811325,
1.2145286798477173,
-0.13685525953769684,
0.1660056859254837,
0.11986618489027023,
-0.5899183750152588,
-0.3771717846393585,
-0.36087530851364136,
-0.7536039352416992,
-0.1869739294052124,
0.7158149480819702,
0.8689709901809692,
0.4523017108440399,
0.4791715741157532,
0.32420021295547485,
0.1483308970928192,
0.02184457704424858,
0.26205432415008545,
-0.5209922790527344,
-0.33027738332748413,
-0.5723487734794617,
-0.3629705011844635,
0.15157921612262726,
0.009743135422468185,
0.5995447039604187,
0.6247233748435974,
0.07117088884115219,
0.41393858194351196,
0.1470261961221695,
0.7324092984199524,
-0.8363714814186096,
0.15757301449775696,
-0.52156662940979,
0.21303308010101318,
-0.2714526653289795,
-0.03988536074757576,
-0.15704427659511566,
-0.23908500373363495,
0.3102802634239197,
-0.6165724396705627,
0.3166273534297943,
0.15038135647773743,
0.7957033514976501,
0.032755281776189804,
-0.6253762245178223,
-0.4112272560596466,
-0.854173481464386,
0.9714419841766357,
-0.3765864968299866,
0.7927682995796204,
0.5122355818748474,
0.3436758518218994,
0.15502123534679413,
-0.45566949248313904,
-0.401986300945282,
-0.028159409761428833,
-0.3399992287158966,
-0.11816819757223129,
-0.23764748871326447,
-0.310609370470047,
0.20225143432617188,
0.1874389797449112,
-0.5160349011421204,
-0.07313515990972519,
-0.640665590763092,
-0.2534390091896057,
0.4826602637767792,
-0.17516165971755981,
0.0922200083732605,
-0.025045188143849373,
-0.09061461687088013,
-0.11300046741962433,
-0.8530632853507996,
0.12168850749731064,
0.06210698187351227,
0.7588682174682617,
-0.3136207163333893,
0.5071717500686646,
-0.6151404976844788,
0.7506471872329712,
0.36720678210258484,
-0.269729882478714,
-0.002511628670617938,
-0.490217924118042,
-0.35970738530158997,
0.47205033898353577,
0.5548346042633057,
0.19817061722278595,
0.080108642578125,
-0.15967315435409546,
-0.09884218126535416,
-0.04094035550951958,
-0.21674218773841858,
-0.7310822606086731,
0.10781274735927582,
-0.10923752188682556,
-0.3468714654445648,
-0.14226657152175903,
0.14655278623104095,
-0.7617572546005249,
-0.38948941230773926,
-0.20079590380191803,
0.40646323561668396,
-0.4071899950504303,
-0.20850062370300293,
0.049520883709192276,
0.2980128824710846,
0.2679653763771057,
0.46596959233283997,
-0.742442786693573,
0.1574403941631317,
0.7216439843177795,
0.8410739898681641,
0.047881126403808594,
-0.28194287419319153,
-0.79491126537323,
-0.034400828182697296,
-0.5506190657615662,
0.9448594450950623,
-0.45449987053871155,
-0.10090476274490356,
0.1929675191640854,
0.22898302972316742,
-0.030489228665828705,
-0.5145925879478455,
0.5992060899734497,
-0.30424949526786804,
0.4762909710407257,
-0.7747272253036499,
-0.2557438910007477,
-0.3850584626197815,
0.35766375064849854,
-0.6954703330993652,
0.9615228176116943,
0.1733020544052124,
-1.0024389028549194,
0.8235467672348022,
-0.5646504163742065,
-0.8153913617134094,
-0.15969298779964447,
-0.203666552901268,
-0.29430463910102844,
0.1135757640004158,
0.1987362504005432,
0.4502577781677246,
-0.3442644476890564,
-0.027853449806571007,
-0.07538852095603943,
-0.3766842484474182,
0.023235436528921127,
-0.25528639554977417,
0.6244460940361023,
0.5901694893836975,
-0.512497067451477,
-0.3947090804576874,
-0.5649762749671936,
-0.3636704981327057,
-0.19203853607177734,
-0.7109435200691223,
-0.5136164426803589,
-0.2732584476470947,
0.24884527921676636,
0.514994740486145,
0.04646378010511398,
-0.6654283404350281,
-0.0716172307729721,
-0.16586273908615112,
0.028674259781837463,
0.24780087172985077,
-0.07138734310865402,
0.4634999632835388,
-0.6637609601020813,
0.28926900029182434,
0.3751469552516937,
-0.07866676896810532,
0.18284578621387482,
-0.0524282343685627,
-0.9367488026618958,
0.012172483839094639,
0.5033007264137268,
0.43883663415908813,
-0.9145967364311218,
-0.01343502663075924,
-0.09257496148347855,
-0.4533969759941101,
-0.5519123077392578,
0.35306334495544434,
0.29203692078590393,
0.6634219288825989,
0.31688785552978516,
0.006067207083106041,
-0.5795099139213562,
-0.687716007232666,
-0.514352023601532,
-0.1521673947572708,
0.29205018281936646,
0.42629775404930115,
0.29765862226486206,
-0.012323332950472832,
0.6505975723266602,
0.12451460212469101,
-0.5911984443664551,
-0.6078488230705261,
0.288077175617218,
-0.023517724126577377,
0.41462159156799316,
0.6628299355506897,
-0.6268764734268188,
-0.8514289855957031,
0.5671003460884094,
-0.5086771249771118,
0.07001987099647522,
-0.150278702378273,
-0.0012624578084796667,
0.9537293314933777,
0.413245290517807,
-0.4847760498523712,
0.16671264171600342,
0.6321654915809631,
-0.49860939383506775,
0.28254857659339905,
-0.041822247207164764,
0.587500274181366,
-1.02618408203125,
0.2867894768714905,
0.2581034302711487,
-0.1610366255044937,
-0.6276477575302124,
-0.2727329730987549,
-0.08276776224374771,
0.21464194357395172,
-0.8212084770202637,
0.7638872265815735,
-0.33074912428855896,
0.05784540995955467,
-0.1498452126979828,
-0.14163115620613098,
-0.2600475549697876,
0.35328155755996704,
0.22662784159183502,
0.786979615688324,
0.3284521996974945,
-0.48717185854911804,
0.10042754560709,
0.07712443917989731,
-0.8649466633796692,
0.6657613515853882,
-0.207566037774086,
-0.16569355130195618,
-0.05877070128917694,
0.13783377408981323,
-0.5786909461021423,
-0.2928311824798584,
0.3069345951080322,
-0.24282167851924896,
0.2117009311914444,
-0.4923417270183563,
-0.45187482237815857,
0.18722254037857056,
0.040976110845804214,
0.2947438657283783,
0.16565178334712982,
-0.567336916923523,
0.3175968527793884,
0.3782362937927246,
-0.2242266833782196,
-0.8600999712944031,
-0.869592010974884,
-0.11052923649549484,
-0.37538379430770874,
-0.35480043292045593,
-0.1341942697763443,
0.38822075724601746,
-0.5208378434181213,
0.09927696734666824,
-0.18958719074726105,
-0.19366370141506195,
-0.06788644939661026,
-0.21119210124015808,
-0.0940919890999794,
-0.605434238910675,
0.24092678725719452,
0.025122713297605515,
0.18574926257133484,
-0.2529917359352112,
-0.1798601895570755,
0.22152650356292725,
-0.4360713064670563,
-0.23668251931667328,
-0.20609374344348907,
0.28217872977256775,
0.5670273303985596,
-0.06348015367984772,
0.8610773682594299,
0.804366409778595,
-0.5192769765853882,
-0.1359613686800003,
-0.7084100246429443,
-0.10209514200687408,
-0.3866783082485199,
0.37166956067085266,
-0.26321831345558167,
-1.0956400632858276,
0.3479274809360504,
-0.05368621647357941,
0.1535869687795639,
0.49932342767715454,
0.5938868522644043,
-0.11324702203273773,
0.7005804181098938,
0.9354504346847534,
-0.2773209810256958,
0.5516113042831421,
-0.18345403671264648,
0.19860047101974487,
-0.08042073249816895,
-0.002686902182176709,
-0.592339038848877,
-0.22034604847431183,
-0.7383750677108765,
-0.23707808554172516,
0.18013812601566315,
0.031274355947971344,
-0.1983247697353363,
0.2494654357433319,
0.19540093839168549,
0.6293051838874817,
0.3659258186817169,
-0.07558231055736542,
0.48805132508277893,
0.3501321077346802,
-0.24706292152404785,
-0.0376158133149147,
-1.1527483463287354,
-0.3005118668079376,
0.8118025064468384,
0.11113807559013367,
0.7784217000007629,
0.1311011016368866,
0.38883018493652344,
0.40851840376853943,
0.30683544278144836,
-0.794926106929779,
0.0799684226512909,
-0.3339310884475708,
-0.7107635736465454,
-0.482160359621048,
-0.5709100961685181,
-0.8601148128509521,
0.3697558641433716,
-0.6285461783409119,
-0.39849790930747986,
0.42323145270347595,
0.2574044167995453,
-0.4166727066040039,
0.5116645097732544,
-0.5102245211601257,
0.9331523180007935,
-0.33015382289886475,
-0.6472452282905579,
-0.5149506330490112,
-0.4580695331096649,
0.3692854046821594,
-0.24676203727722168,
0.41804835200309753,
-0.013776694424450397,
0.29092779755592346,
0.7501733899116516,
-0.25576305389404297,
0.7592915296554565,
-0.16517271101474762,
0.031023046001791954,
0.3072117865085602,
0.09634285420179367,
0.3900899291038513,
0.016869643703103065,
0.06910774856805801,
0.25712263584136963,
0.21921350061893463,
-0.5098583698272705,
-0.41677913069725037,
0.6733237504959106,
-0.8896750211715698,
-0.3521548807621002,
-0.5711857080459595,
-0.3587322533130646,
-0.3898302912712097,
0.2518254816532135,
0.2836243808269501,
0.34427210688591003,
-0.5606088042259216,
0.3857493996620178,
0.6470171809196472,
-0.2431216537952423,
0.2555714249610901,
0.8024873733520508,
0.06851751357316971,
-0.1762728989124298,
0.8696296811103821,
0.3566735088825226,
0.08109965920448303,
0.47281113266944885,
0.2913611829280853,
-0.1313614845275879,
-0.16333873569965363,
-0.5379692316055298,
0.36460375785827637,
-0.670450747013092,
-0.0460062138736248,
-0.4921439290046692,
0.014489869587123394,
-0.35270848870277405,
-0.2619386315345764,
-0.6005536317825317,
-0.5064132809638977,
0.00822522398084402,
-0.04569384828209877,
0.42815136909484863,
0.7665955424308777,
-0.5456935167312622,
0.14836634695529938,
-0.7965932488441467,
0.05847114324569702,
0.30058297514915466,
0.4092631936073303,
-0.1618691235780716,
-0.5099340081214905,
-0.9332525730133057,
0.202519029378891,
-0.03087013214826584,
-0.3621752858161926,
0.2450115978717804,
0.2801405191421509,
0.582909345626831,
0.46900931000709534,
0.10539447516202927,
0.589609682559967,
-0.1856289952993393,
0.45417320728302,
-0.04317156970500946,
-0.6756378412246704,
0.3172428011894226,
-0.25481855869293213,
0.3325818181037903,
0.8004470467567444,
0.6542697548866272,
-1.1778236627578735,
-0.08744418621063232,
-0.5017609000205994,
-0.4315532147884369,
0.9690327048301697,
-0.1973710060119629,
-0.18944746255874634,
0.26608818769454956,
-0.039301399141550064,
0.47459396719932556,
-0.01700424961745739,
-0.39006003737449646,
-0.05982102081179619,
-0.29047781229019165,
-0.06378979235887527,
-0.21290740370750427,
-0.16381171345710754,
-0.18931740522384644,
-0.3801155388355255,
0.8082687258720398,
-0.2442111372947693,
-0.08295562863349915,
0.1707400232553482,
-0.5846771597862244,
-0.6305021047592163,
0.4679957926273346,
0.8053719401359558,
0.6822123527526855,
-0.20696498453617096,
0.31343162059783936,
0.5075947642326355,
-0.5220019817352295,
0.12169550359249115,
0.05955470725893974,
-0.0165199376642704,
0.07833852618932724,
0.3713659644126892,
0.7319177389144897,
0.2088509351015091,
-0.5019010305404663,
0.4592096507549286,
-0.07462944835424423,
-0.31207597255706787,
0.032006729394197464,
-0.31397005915641785,
-0.22375155985355377,
0.2589821219444275,
0.39215996861457825,
-0.000020811710783164017,
-0.1416510045528412,
-0.6722602844238281,
0.3070656955242157,
0.17948272824287415,
-0.4790187478065491,
-0.3747013211250305,
0.15781879425048828,
0.2683953046798706,
0.24560317397117615,
0.48144209384918213,
0.21558533608913422,
-0.3514825999736786,
0.356003999710083,
0.24165436625480652,
0.6867902278900146,
-0.05057871341705322,
0.3625207543373108,
0.4572032392024994,
0.5047584772109985,
-0.19493666291236877,
0.09739255905151367,
-0.31130820512771606,
-0.800421953201294,
-0.5792104601860046,
-0.5289930701255798,
-0.5121424794197083,
0.5049165487289429,
-0.38849076628685,
0.47452619671821594,
-0.5260202884674072,
0.025013592094182968,
-0.09820982068777084,
0.4820147454738617,
-0.8695968985557556,
0.24687300622463226,
0.16467711329460144,
1.0122889280319214,
-1.2491047382354736,
0.9527380466461182,
0.9584516882896423,
-0.36535531282424927,
-0.447897732257843,
0.033726222813129425,
0.09211345762014389,
-0.5450279116630554,
0.8419784307479858,
-0.016271108761429787,
-0.13233162462711334,
-0.33566442131996155,
-0.4313467741012573,
-0.9286613464355469,
0.7948738932609558,
0.3981851041316986,
-0.44391751289367676,
0.2955915033817291,
0.48085370659828186,
0.5081889033317566,
-0.375465989112854,
-0.14557534456253052,
0.6569774746894836,
0.5876255035400391,
0.03369547054171562,
-1.055732011795044,
-0.05457833781838417,
0.14345034956932068,
-0.4812377095222473,
-0.08963623642921448,
-0.9270174503326416,
0.7500778436660767,
-0.1471775472164154,
-0.4217420220375061,
-0.4138772785663605,
0.5961965322494507,
0.03243707865476608,
0.28136950731277466,
0.5635539889335632,
0.3382773995399475,
0.4860355854034424,
-0.04342642426490784,
0.7296217083930969,
-0.44748568534851074,
0.3153543770313263,
0.9566299915313721,
-0.08011534065008163,
0.6983378529548645,
0.5916057229042053,
0.2103412002325058,
0.19457170367240906,
0.806982696056366,
0.16439610719680786,
0.6838517189025879,
-0.28965461254119873,
-0.23354320228099823,
-0.3982000946998596,
-0.3380843698978424,
-0.20902669429779053,
0.5791411399841309,
0.47399410605430603,
-0.15695855021476746,
-0.5864929556846619,
-0.06373825669288635,
0.29523658752441406,
-0.25606685876846313,
-0.3397403061389923,
0.8067129850387573,
0.007622046861797571,
-0.5679959654808044,
0.670195460319519,
0.11195499449968338,
0.700406014919281,
-0.32565951347351074,
-0.07872769236564636,
-0.5469754338264465,
0.22614841163158417,
-0.24064570665359497,
-0.48937973380088806,
0.5371954441070557,
0.17567402124404907,
-0.016091763973236084,
-0.020371032878756523,
0.8229219913482666,
-0.7062340974807739,
-0.5262457728385925,
0.07663348317146301,
0.9403459429740906,
0.06723206490278244,
0.21794748306274414,
-0.6609067916870117,
-0.0425257571041584,
-0.1416165679693222,
-0.05966921150684357,
0.42335909605026245,
0.7591314315795898,
-0.3571576774120331,
0.3983423411846161,
0.5004181265830994,
0.1908716857433319,
-0.06653096526861191,
-0.17753639817237854,
0.6319917440414429,
-0.5091255903244019,
-0.3808145821094513,
-0.5939604043960571,
0.12636740505695343,
0.19425716996192932,
-0.33095359802246094,
0.7608442902565002,
0.5939080119132996,
1.5178089141845703,
-0.06660092622041702,
1.172815203666687,
-0.14124679565429688,
0.6216548681259155,
-0.4046975374221802,
1.0152997970581055,
-0.6917833089828491,
-0.2302929311990738,
-0.17650511860847473,
-0.6436136960983276,
-0.3564262092113495,
0.7860168814659119,
-0.33777663111686707,
-0.1464739292860031,
0.6654378771781921,
0.748996913433075,
-0.4461010992527008,
-0.0474858321249485,
0.5347712635993958,
0.2016400545835495,
-0.17523568868637085,
0.45616522431373596,
0.8311922550201416,
-0.3821115791797638,
0.5948529243469238,
-0.49514544010162354,
-0.1163005530834198,
-0.5184478163719177,
-0.7955378890037537,
-1.0692555904388428,
-0.61982661485672,
-0.23976543545722961,
-0.3643943667411804,
0.32799604535102844,
1.2150694131851196,
0.6032377481460571,
-1.2454402446746826,
-0.39613208174705505,
0.19461706280708313,
0.2433195412158966,
-0.27354851365089417,
-0.17511850595474243,
0.31866076588630676,
-0.3319576680660248,
-0.4944291114807129,
0.16048821806907654,
-0.05141126364469528,
0.09053505212068558,
-0.15824110805988312,
-0.15434853732585907,
-0.47121745347976685,
0.07494811713695526,
0.6551882028579712,
0.7724121809005737,
-0.546245276927948,
-0.45014604926109314,
-0.10878221690654755,
-0.3154621124267578,
0.08678731322288513,
1.0421874523162842,
-0.6758046746253967,
0.21078093349933624,
0.5803636312484741,
0.7761486768722534,
0.4990379214286804,
-0.24538582563400269,
0.5764065980911255,
-0.633249044418335,
0.20559576153755188,
-0.24915863573551178,
0.4345730245113373,
0.6662284731864929,
-0.29805800318717957,
0.4814116060733795,
0.31487396359443665,
-0.3273049592971802,
-0.6259503960609436,
-0.059620555490255356,
-0.5993103384971619,
-0.3117802143096924,
1.2433507442474365,
0.047419242560863495,
-0.16777943074703217,
-0.4399503767490387,
-0.14300662279129028,
0.48418930172920227,
-0.461410254240036,
1.1260349750518799,
0.8731709718704224,
-0.07481617480516434,
-0.24075740575790405,
-0.4463734030723572,
0.9092878699302673,
0.33853375911712646,
-0.6141610741615295,
0.25371065735816956,
0.5043214559555054,
0.6219192147254944,
0.009009936824440956,
0.3794192671775818,
0.07011575251817703,
0.49203214049339294,
-0.09904299676418304,
-0.20661278069019318,
0.04851844534277916,
-0.37691256403923035,
-0.46171772480010986,
-0.09899329394102097,
-0.007149433251470327,
0.02163068577647209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00409v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00409v2
|
Provably Robust DPO: Aligning Language Models with Noisy Feedback
| 2024-03-01T09:55:18 | 2024-04-12T01:09:37 |
Sayak Ray Chowdhury, Anush Kini, Nagarajan Natarajan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Learning from preference-based feedback has recently gained traction as a
promising approach to align language models with human interests. While these
aligned generative models have demonstrated impressive capabilities across
various tasks, their dependence on high-quality human preference data poses a
bottleneck in practical applications. Specifically, noisy (incorrect and
ambiguous) preference pairs in the dataset might restrict the language models
from capturing human intent accurately. While practitioners have recently
proposed heuristics to mitigate the effect of noisy preferences, a complete
theoretical understanding of their workings remain elusive.
In this work, we aim to bridge this gap by by introducing a general framework
for policy optimization in the presence of random preference flips. We focus on
the direct preference optimization (DPO) algorithm in particular since it
assumes that preferences adhere to the Bradley-Terry-Luce (BTL) model, raising
concerns about the impact of noisy data on the learned policy. We design a
novel loss function, which de-bias the effect of noise on average, making a
policy trained by minimizing that loss robust to the noise. Under log-linear
parameterization of the policy class and assuming good feature coverage of the
SFT policy, we prove that the sub-optimality gap of the proposed robust DPO
(rDPO) policy compared to the optimal policy is of the order
$O(\frac{1}{1-2\epsilon}\sqrt{\frac{d}{n}})$, where $\epsilon < 1/2$ is flip
rate of labels, $d$ is policy parameter dimension and $n$ is size of dataset.
Our experiments on IMDb sentiment generation and Anthropic's helpful-harmless
dataset show that rDPO is robust to noise in preference labels compared to
vanilla DPO and other heuristics proposed by practitioners.
|
[
-0.3325027823448181,
-0.5318315625190735,
0.582455575466156,
0.08659616112709045,
-0.16204853355884552,
-0.08355219662189484,
-0.4246392548084259,
0.049883779138326645,
0.01864432729780674,
0.4213961958885193,
-0.7868462800979614,
-0.23895670473575592,
-0.3786524832248688,
-0.09074760973453522,
0.008014224469661713,
0.9438756704330444,
0.20407184958457947,
-0.06966344267129898,
-0.026067091152071953,
0.21023577451705933,
-0.18518929183483124,
-0.28085342049598694,
-0.38154444098472595,
-0.4095169007778168,
0.3143562376499176,
0.4272649884223938,
1.1687705516815186,
0.5489739179611206,
0.2791503965854645,
0.2161417305469513,
-0.16821545362472534,
0.23371213674545288,
-0.7493294477462769,
0.16226594150066376,
-0.10009880363941193,
-0.32954421639442444,
-0.23524408042430878,
-0.04996541514992714,
0.6409479975700378,
0.6381508708000183,
-0.23915161192417145,
-0.22894029319286346,
0.2552449405193329,
0.8037481904029846,
-0.6739124059677124,
0.04358169436454773,
-0.7629936933517456,
0.1167527511715889,
-0.07683610916137695,
-0.19101257622241974,
-0.5433954000473022,
-0.4863257110118866,
0.25729134678840637,
-0.5609261989593506,
0.023451203480362892,
-0.10251310467720032,
1.0416399240493774,
0.657401978969574,
-0.160919189453125,
0.0020096900407224894,
-0.9905368089675903,
1.0601587295532227,
-0.5910101532936096,
0.4196683466434479,
0.6915853023529053,
0.018070155754685402,
-0.37559399008750916,
0.08987044543027878,
-0.5470619201660156,
-0.28190648555755615,
0.20095109939575195,
0.2578042149543762,
-0.29543936252593994,
0.12246537953615189,
-0.11972730606794357,
0.43023282289505005,
-0.25926682353019714,
0.36649662256240845,
0.15541376173496246,
-0.267419695854187,
0.5845322608947754,
-0.1029106006026268,
-0.27461013197898865,
-0.03184986487030983,
-0.3965131640434265,
-0.2677716016769409,
-0.45749011635780334,
0.15383826196193695,
1.0142643451690674,
0.3743864893913269,
0.035122647881507874,
0.21590736508369446,
-0.2764677107334137,
0.8157323598861694,
0.3705765902996063,
-0.3420126140117645,
0.26989755034446716,
-0.2285534143447876,
0.10260383039712906,
-0.11656873673200607,
0.894579291343689,
0.46441054344177246,
0.37117746472358704,
-0.2023286074399948,
-0.25733381509780884,
-0.09128430485725403,
0.24878574907779694,
-0.6152509450912476,
-0.23433001339435577,
0.2748412787914276,
-0.29673588275909424,
-0.8987936973571777,
-0.051202304661273956,
-0.9669253826141357,
-0.3608221709728241,
-0.28141316771507263,
0.3356417119503021,
-0.2603406012058258,
-0.553578794002533,
0.26081863045692444,
0.15114133059978485,
0.021116310730576515,
0.24587224423885345,
-1.1180546283721924,
0.22902505099773407,
0.5881137847900391,
0.5610076785087585,
-0.21553239226341248,
-0.10122649371623993,
-0.4386981725692749,
-0.021839851513504982,
-0.3114508092403412,
0.49466681480407715,
-0.5193431973457336,
-0.3841661810874939,
0.09120684862136841,
-0.472726047039032,
-0.02679404243826866,
-0.46536293625831604,
0.6699440479278564,
-0.49263492226600647,
0.2864304780960083,
-0.31114232540130615,
-0.2125299721956253,
0.0999792069196701,
0.3058018088340759,
-0.4791763722896576,
0.8115907907485962,
0.07424082607030869,
-0.8800358772277832,
0.6198910474777222,
-0.24005326628684998,
-0.22990190982818604,
-0.5301520228385925,
-0.17326891422271729,
-0.652481734752655,
-0.10192183405160904,
0.1726406067609787,
0.142414852976799,
-0.16299687325954437,
0.47598716616630554,
-0.6626056432723999,
-0.4145859181880951,
0.5429463982582092,
-0.6738051772117615,
0.7675318121910095,
0.32222384214401245,
-0.4243285357952118,
0.08391183614730835,
-0.809610903263092,
0.03159508481621742,
0.0043492745608091354,
-0.3770136535167694,
-0.31100648641586304,
0.23334158957004547,
-0.3358449339866638,
-0.006356116849929094,
0.05363418534398079,
-0.42291322350502014,
0.4273022413253784,
-0.26772889494895935,
0.3433670699596405,
1.1226069927215576,
-0.09648338705301285,
0.5891553163528442,
-0.16493749618530273,
0.4394262731075287,
0.09301891922950745,
0.4215613007545471,
0.17476628720760345,
-0.17105983197689056,
-0.2888168394565582,
-0.5407950282096863,
0.2682013213634491,
0.48399531841278076,
-0.34069257974624634,
0.5038169622421265,
-0.15875601768493652,
0.030903184786438942,
-0.6861242651939392,
0.20241545140743256,
0.14357522130012512,
0.7936073541641235,
0.10548022389411926,
-0.2742423713207245,
-0.33951306343078613,
-0.9449487924575806,
0.011379793286323547,
-0.4146440029144287,
0.16137853264808655,
0.40967807173728943,
-0.24350038170814514,
-0.26653623580932617,
1.085808277130127,
-0.5591577887535095,
-0.1625104397535324,
-0.009655308909714222,
-0.12817734479904175,
0.2746129333972931,
0.2046923190355301,
0.5182974934577942,
-0.6854540705680847,
-0.4150811731815338,
-0.1817922592163086,
-0.09601011872291565,
-0.3343329131603241,
-0.028147991746664047,
-0.15084894001483917,
0.18731151521205902,
-0.04387522116303444,
-0.2760610580444336,
0.09924960136413574,
0.5510233640670776,
-0.019098971039056778,
0.47966518998146057,
-0.13309624791145325,
-0.04514584317803383,
-0.7863774299621582,
-0.15143023431301117,
-0.2015962302684784,
-0.20474691689014435,
-0.3488878309726715,
-0.4806833565235138,
-0.36680030822753906,
-0.07686672359704971,
-0.06648208945989609,
0.1926184892654419,
-0.1569492369890213,
-0.010946034453809261,
-0.24851275980472565,
-0.034105729311704636,
0.0946006178855896,
0.6000068187713623,
0.2939399182796478,
0.7007932066917419,
0.670998752117157,
-0.6497904062271118,
-0.0787324383854866,
0.20442816615104675,
-0.035950008779764175,
0.48863860964775085,
-0.3793756067752838,
0.1336439996957779,
-0.22531327605247498,
0.060425762087106705,
-0.9903917908668518,
-0.09933603554964066,
0.3852013647556305,
-0.19910144805908203,
0.5268481373786926,
-0.31219640374183655,
-0.18264265358448029,
-0.24542060494422913,
-0.508966863155365,
0.11012377589941025,
0.5536975860595703,
-0.5794513821601868,
-0.04638265073299408,
0.46642938256263733,
0.1456204205751419,
-0.9749647974967957,
-0.4444933831691742,
-0.24278248846530914,
-0.24275624752044678,
-0.4215291440486908,
0.31928518414497375,
0.02812119945883751,
-0.2794307470321655,
0.07072091102600098,
-0.25249773263931274,
-0.2101287841796875,
0.038805365562438965,
0.11379037797451019,
0.2949230372905731,
0.0845986008644104,
0.032876018434762955,
-0.09494967013597488,
-0.26484206318855286,
-0.21728065609931946,
-0.4119400382041931,
0.5657538771629333,
-0.24068686366081238,
-0.21521522104740143,
-0.41873541474342346,
0.29788243770599365,
0.55118328332901,
0.12365774810314178,
0.25562477111816406,
0.4929208755493164,
0.22964416444301605,
-0.31396719813346863,
-0.3848729133605957,
-0.1845165342092514,
-0.45516008138656616,
0.40178054571151733,
-0.337534636259079,
-0.595964789390564,
0.37848183512687683,
0.07125125080347061,
0.03340797498822212,
0.13843435049057007,
0.6228681802749634,
0.004242144990712404,
0.995514452457428,
0.6747815012931824,
-0.27372610569000244,
0.750783383846283,
-0.20614425837993622,
0.26653170585632324,
-0.4488966464996338,
0.05469658225774765,
-0.37132641673088074,
-0.29067879915237427,
-0.7616782188415527,
-0.21652929484844208,
0.09611332416534424,
0.14313451945781708,
-0.19735155999660492,
0.14227299392223358,
-0.672329306602478,
0.3107030987739563,
0.7547560334205627,
0.15027876198291779,
0.34549903869628906,
0.16953523457050323,
-0.07132089883089066,
-0.27101826667785645,
-0.8640254139900208,
-0.38213545083999634,
0.9896277785301208,
0.4635604918003082,
1.2912086248397827,
-0.03554413840174675,
0.9979631304740906,
0.229078471660614,
-0.04525739699602127,
-0.9003872871398926,
0.3417576849460602,
-0.19185183942317963,
-0.29176145792007446,
-0.3978343605995178,
-0.5088963508605957,
-0.867314875125885,
0.1737491488456726,
-0.17144349217414856,
-0.5945979356765747,
0.6882275938987732,
0.6269581913948059,
-0.353889137506485,
0.2725304961204529,
-0.6212536096572876,
0.5998860001564026,
-0.3585435152053833,
-0.7660266757011414,
-0.3289802074432373,
-0.6559239029884338,
0.32949140667915344,
0.17563514411449432,
0.06035054847598076,
-0.2535032629966736,
0.05274360999464989,
0.3482673168182373,
-0.4251384139060974,
0.8122799396514893,
-0.374249666929245,
-0.09354457259178162,
0.2482316642999649,
0.03325841203331947,
0.48748263716697693,
0.07665311545133591,
-0.24885064363479614,
0.050949566066265106,
-0.13381396234035492,
-0.20651909708976746,
-0.35703203082084656,
0.5888573527336121,
-1.056603193283081,
-0.5309509038925171,
-0.35436388850212097,
-0.519659161567688,
-0.4472130835056305,
0.15546788275241852,
0.26820147037506104,
0.2003953605890274,
-0.12022455781698227,
-0.022992780432105064,
0.8579218983650208,
-0.16555722057819366,
0.2458307147026062,
0.5338202118873596,
-0.17941492795944214,
-0.49563536047935486,
1.13042151927948,
0.04756379872560501,
0.4224380552768707,
0.3958142101764679,
0.6674363613128662,
-0.41931453347206116,
-0.48850685358047485,
-0.40303075313568115,
0.02271021343767643,
-0.30023816227912903,
-0.12839743494987488,
-0.33835941553115845,
0.06961794197559357,
-0.28688207268714905,
-0.014537088572978973,
-0.6174384951591492,
-0.5409544706344604,
-0.11514095216989517,
-0.05621778592467308,
0.3433108329772949,
0.3231376111507416,
-0.3510020673274994,
0.17035561800003052,
-0.24025152623653412,
0.22034743428230286,
0.4169631600379944,
0.6888795495033264,
-0.19506871700286865,
-0.407920241355896,
0.08348099142313004,
0.20064345002174377,
-0.4588899314403534,
-0.8374659419059753,
0.2540116608142853,
0.20166923105716705,
0.5165503621101379,
0.7965932488441467,
0.4723687171936035,
0.5468457937240601,
-0.25519365072250366,
0.506840705871582,
0.00035993134952150285,
-0.593147337436676,
0.6128859519958496,
-0.5043660998344421,
0.05932847037911415,
1.013725757598877,
0.3358226716518402,
-0.07971753925085068,
-0.3440432548522949,
-0.6898316144943237,
-0.8336934447288513,
0.7087278962135315,
0.0052552297711372375,
0.13567110896110535,
-0.007603953592479229,
0.19719819724559784,
0.22382532060146332,
0.47910961508750916,
-0.6904934048652649,
-0.12327412515878677,
-0.38814952969551086,
-0.05945611000061035,
0.34250399470329285,
-0.3881041705608368,
-0.3097963333129883,
0.028638670220971107,
0.729701817035675,
-0.05873648822307587,
0.13264904916286469,
0.2570594251155853,
0.2131125032901764,
-0.16482241451740265,
0.5258196592330933,
0.6182398200035095,
0.2941833436489105,
-0.6980714201927185,
0.07206118851900101,
-0.564373254776001,
-0.48479795455932617,
0.21144142746925354,
0.07470981031656265,
-0.7886639833450317,
0.03474320471286774,
-0.14187771081924438,
0.905730664730072,
0.16635145246982574,
-0.5450505018234253,
0.5880842208862305,
0.02118736505508423,
-0.24493113160133362,
-0.07112699747085571,
0.002597943414002657,
-0.4301767349243164,
-0.12319251894950867,
0.14511843025684357,
0.3763922154903412,
0.1826200634241104,
-0.4614228904247284,
0.30162346363067627,
0.6566634178161621,
-0.6192289590835571,
-0.3867141008377075,
0.6026116013526917,
0.4269934594631195,
-0.15590421855449677,
0.41744330525398254,
-0.3283052146434784,
-0.5432143807411194,
0.13889925181865692,
0.46567773818969727,
1.013342261314392,
-0.020035000517964363,
0.4534508287906647,
0.25672945380210876,
0.25155186653137207,
-0.19526423513889313,
0.06971155852079391,
-0.46121615171432495,
-1.0450724363327026,
-0.3367820680141449,
-0.5781489610671997,
-0.7324657440185547,
0.035100407898426056,
-0.7430199980735779,
0.21871960163116455,
-0.4844505488872528,
-0.3869674801826477,
-0.38796213269233704,
0.028385089710354805,
-0.4853202998638153,
-0.06819560378789902,
-0.05768292769789696,
0.34785059094429016,
-0.8197123408317566,
0.811313271522522,
0.35525989532470703,
-0.24786095321178436,
-0.7020319104194641,
0.3561880588531494,
0.18699902296066284,
-1.0780525207519531,
0.3552054762840271,
-0.15658970177173615,
-0.27228426933288574,
-0.10064668208360672,
-0.3542647063732147,
-0.7678319811820984,
0.5867605805397034,
0.6465902328491211,
-0.6899767518043518,
0.11992182582616806,
0.08404150605201721,
0.3396645188331604,
-0.16466936469078064,
-0.08307447284460068,
0.5220714807510376,
0.5190884470939636,
0.22773759067058563,
-0.7278661727905273,
-0.14601349830627441,
0.18314412236213684,
-0.199905127286911,
0.2786366641521454,
-0.9481943249702454,
0.29167836904525757,
-0.5312405824661255,
0.04345409572124481,
-0.29813843965530396,
0.27898797392845154,
0.16826468706130981,
0.12005575746297836,
0.8971821069717407,
0.6412290930747986,
0.7981830835342407,
-0.06649114936590195,
1.1198943853378296,
-0.2620944678783417,
0.2884036600589752,
1.0597518682479858,
-0.38993361592292786,
0.7231881022453308,
0.7668783068656921,
-0.42979681491851807,
0.28562992811203003,
0.6741945147514343,
0.11961470544338226,
0.9871088266372681,
0.2060660719871521,
-0.20905929803848267,
-0.28684866428375244,
-0.2069074511528015,
-0.18319664895534515,
0.3200874626636505,
-0.1056593805551529,
-0.18641938269138336,
-0.041091203689575195,
-0.24872738122940063,
0.09702351689338684,
0.2521800398826599,
-0.0380927175283432,
0.8370394706726074,
-0.1557939052581787,
-0.8346977829933167,
0.544102668762207,
-0.42894333600997925,
0.7917618155479431,
-0.7272996306419373,
0.22028037905693054,
-0.16949746012687683,
0.43777838349342346,
-0.21170258522033691,
-0.7122461795806885,
0.38810014724731445,
-0.3375762104988098,
-0.45386478304862976,
-0.4292519688606262,
0.5314041376113892,
-0.6986492276191711,
-0.13801375031471252,
0.09152371436357498,
0.04138460382819176,
-0.19727404415607452,
0.24565261602401733,
-0.6852489113807678,
0.28173330426216125,
0.3211708962917328,
-0.346905916929245,
0.4206101596355438,
0.25263503193855286,
0.09844130277633667,
0.6651706099510193,
0.48567989468574524,
0.2643163800239563,
-0.14551028609275818,
0.20436635613441467,
0.6474366784095764,
-0.16657906770706177,
-0.6108686923980713,
-0.6621268391609192,
0.3897792398929596,
-0.08984397351741791,
-0.3206510543823242,
0.578940749168396,
0.28998300433158875,
0.7132318019866943,
-0.049118444323539734,
0.757986307144165,
0.029475940391421318,
0.44510871171951294,
-0.3669876754283905,
0.3899383544921875,
-0.35308846831321716,
0.43917787075042725,
-0.39182689785957336,
-0.8403612971305847,
-0.07169391214847565,
0.7859001159667969,
-0.3764384984970093,
-0.07696300745010376,
0.2367497980594635,
1.0345860719680786,
0.10411231219768524,
-0.36488115787506104,
0.25175172090530396,
0.11624552309513092,
0.21766845881938934,
0.25163671374320984,
0.6837533712387085,
-0.10297688841819763,
0.7316469550132751,
-0.5985186696052551,
-0.36169683933258057,
-0.2288765013217926,
-0.9460103511810303,
-0.3910999298095703,
-0.34757310152053833,
-0.560337245464325,
-0.4467274844646454,
0.11440007388591766,
0.6851911544799805,
0.8408671021461487,
-0.6870002150535583,
-0.14740265905857086,
-0.21602435410022736,
0.45761343836784363,
-0.5189856886863708,
-0.3552647531032562,
0.3307861387729645,
-0.36400842666625977,
-0.828516960144043,
0.3093149960041046,
0.34526610374450684,
0.12477140128612518,
-0.3358040153980255,
-0.31598642468452454,
0.07604476809501648,
0.07581537961959839,
0.3003024756908417,
0.5140979290008545,
-0.6596492528915405,
-0.3100322484970093,
0.054628483951091766,
0.03197605535387993,
0.005335946101695299,
0.8493295311927795,
-0.6397049427032471,
0.7462348341941833,
0.5008970499038696,
0.6442001461982727,
0.45243558287620544,
0.15915293991565704,
0.8472557663917542,
-0.7913700938224792,
0.38024067878723145,
0.3870089054107666,
0.085392527282238,
0.3429332971572876,
-0.4917096197605133,
0.4316234588623047,
0.20622828602790833,
-0.7813160419464111,
-1.0758488178253174,
0.4397166669368744,
-1.2583434581756592,
0.013351905159652233,
1.1323696374893188,
0.16680403053760529,
0.09430551528930664,
0.020287321880459785,
-0.30656176805496216,
-0.1973194032907486,
-0.7550181746482849,
1.038693904876709,
0.6008851528167725,
-0.33820629119873047,
-0.12908421456813812,
-0.22160731256008148,
0.779818594455719,
0.6521931886672974,
-0.13025803864002228,
0.3362498879432678,
0.48224955797195435,
0.1727534830570221,
0.030526308342814445,
0.9369708895683289,
-0.1816047728061676,
0.10533259809017181,
-0.04200874641537666,
-0.15589535236358643,
-0.13784052431583405,
-0.10721512138843536,
-0.4216909408569336,
0.001251655980013311,
0.44368746876716614,
-0.49435627460479736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00393v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00393v2
|
TRUCE: Private Benchmarking to Prevent Contamination and Improve Comparative Evaluation of LLMs
| 2024-03-01T09:28:38 | 2024-06-24T08:28:18 |
Tanmay Rajore, Nishanth Chandran, Sunayana Sitaram, Divya Gupta, Rahul Sharma, Kashish Mittal, Manohar Swaminathan
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Benchmarking is the de-facto standard for evaluating LLMs, due to its speed,
replicability and low cost. However, recent work has pointed out that the
majority of the open source benchmarks available today have been contaminated
or leaked into LLMs, meaning that LLMs have access to test data during
pretraining and/or fine-tuning. This raises serious concerns about the validity
of benchmarking studies conducted so far and the future of evaluation using
benchmarks. To solve this problem, we propose Private Benchmarking, a solution
where test datasets are kept private and models are evaluated without revealing
the test data to the model. We describe various scenarios (depending on the
trust placed on model owners or dataset owners), and present solutions to avoid
data contamination using private benchmarking. For scenarios where the model
weights need to be kept private, we describe solutions from confidential
computing and cryptography that can aid in private benchmarking. We build an
end-to-end system, TRUCE, that enables such private benchmarking showing that
the overheads introduced to protect models and benchmark are negligible (in the
case of confidential computing) and tractable (when cryptographic security is
required). Finally, we also discuss solutions to the problem of benchmark
dataset auditing, to ensure that private benchmarks are of sufficiently high
quality.
|
[
-0.3749758303165436,
0.07174297422170639,
0.6410142183303833,
0.293997585773468,
-0.46323344111442566,
0.13966669142246246,
0.07390228658914566,
-0.803780198097229,
-0.32575711607933044,
0.41503918170928955,
-0.15495604276657104,
-0.5749327540397644,
-0.8445408344268799,
-0.09257619827985764,
-0.4437887370586395,
0.9602217674255371,
-0.3397792875766754,
0.4247608482837677,
-0.6118078827857971,
-0.6008920669555664,
-0.07681985944509506,
-0.5901026129722595,
-0.34445831179618835,
-0.37821659445762634,
0.15357744693756104,
0.14906249940395355,
0.6921178698539734,
1.101286768913269,
0.843171238899231,
0.38432157039642334,
-0.2384852021932602,
0.11776535212993622,
-0.760307788848877,
0.4580124020576477,
-0.34326010942459106,
-0.6681879758834839,
-0.4232739806175232,
0.3142567574977875,
0.6069759726524353,
0.4811110198497772,
-0.10685434937477112,
0.5578761696815491,
0.11042195558547974,
0.8951535820960999,
-1.123734712600708,
0.17067930102348328,
-0.6102409362792969,
0.2748388946056366,
-0.5257923603057861,
-0.061185322701931,
-0.06791709363460541,
-0.6333588361740112,
-0.2721640169620514,
-0.5145015120506287,
0.051509588956832886,
0.21727682650089264,
0.7385783791542053,
0.40957164764404297,
-0.1441878080368042,
0.49835023283958435,
-0.6740338802337646,
0.8634244799613953,
-0.5879457592964172,
0.4734766185283661,
0.4668845236301422,
0.4975266456604004,
-0.13566090166568756,
-0.744301438331604,
0.16010616719722748,
-0.08464553952217102,
0.207132488489151,
0.38611575961112976,
-0.3299778401851654,
-0.2694251239299774,
0.17806410789489746,
0.715499997138977,
-0.22082678973674774,
0.2866186499595642,
-0.27468016743659973,
-0.22440920770168304,
1.0170217752456665,
0.4703543484210968,
-0.1365676373243332,
0.4358813762664795,
-0.8029795289039612,
-0.13130587339401245,
-1.1556241512298584,
-0.0726168230175972,
0.6372585892677307,
-0.14179345965385437,
-0.20371085405349731,
0.43454402685165405,
-0.3916422426700592,
0.2084135115146637,
-0.10974466800689697,
-0.06426665931940079,
0.12969131767749786,
-0.2891201674938202,
-0.35580572485923767,
-0.027724729850888252,
0.7672700881958008,
0.6717580556869507,
0.15742406249046326,
-0.500240683555603,
-0.3765530586242676,
0.34387272596359253,
0.15436625480651855,
-0.8281376957893372,
-0.1757873296737671,
0.3004899024963379,
-0.6065165400505066,
-0.6761361360549927,
-0.008362418971955776,
-0.8134118914604187,
-0.7576717138290405,
-0.32056915760040283,
0.6370608806610107,
0.10849808156490326,
-0.10049872100353241,
0.104840949177742,
-0.18778717517852783,
-0.249895378947258,
0.2983987033367157,
-0.4313899278640747,
0.9578405618667603,
1.1141153573989868,
0.7436162233352661,
-0.3581693470478058,
-0.10718582570552826,
-0.7691056132316589,
0.40402334928512573,
-0.322436660528183,
0.5283122062683105,
-0.31747695803642273,
-0.793074369430542,
-0.20491936802864075,
-0.02243475429713726,
0.5028454065322876,
-0.9517385959625244,
0.42354243993759155,
-0.37522658705711365,
0.13010026514530182,
-0.3470204472541809,
-0.8456108570098877,
0.2312564104795456,
0.03857268765568733,
-0.5511766672134399,
0.8477036952972412,
-0.3466792106628418,
-0.8912073969841003,
0.1233893483877182,
-0.42275431752204895,
0.05272122472524643,
0.16665787994861603,
-0.6150099635124207,
-0.6952703595161438,
0.32639941573143005,
0.05474339425563812,
0.17360597848892212,
-0.40662622451782227,
0.22207115590572357,
-0.7252101302146912,
-0.6030410528182983,
0.2826472818851471,
-0.3694246709346771,
0.6151638031005859,
0.38783395290374756,
-0.5369371175765991,
0.12178271263837814,
-0.5830892324447632,
0.3701373338699341,
0.12798380851745605,
0.05106997862458229,
-0.22711887955665588,
0.01064127404242754,
-0.44935768842697144,
-0.1493120938539505,
0.6531786918640137,
-0.5008779168128967,
-0.30957141518592834,
-0.11631527543067932,
0.1408909410238266,
1.2159829139709473,
0.056636933237314224,
0.29679155349731445,
-0.9562302827835083,
0.4009816348552704,
0.14680513739585876,
0.5891907215118408,
0.2180233746767044,
-0.5433294773101807,
-0.47564706206321716,
-0.3470211625099182,
0.6309477090835571,
0.321444034576416,
0.15000298619270325,
0.23353607952594757,
0.02879195287823677,
-0.6959471702575684,
-0.6511178612709045,
0.16140298545360565,
0.8200546503067017,
0.2523321807384491,
0.3133004307746887,
-0.6981137990951538,
-0.251018226146698,
-1.1210254430770874,
-0.6653690934181213,
0.08604028075933456,
-0.15535689890384674,
0.3821733295917511,
0.28742459416389465,
0.21586652100086212,
0.5787402987480164,
-0.39666280150413513,
-0.3084981441497803,
0.4541665017604828,
0.12737171351909637,
-0.03482631593942642,
0.7420570254325867,
0.06972859054803848,
-0.6277221441268921,
-0.21715053915977478,
-0.07289549708366394,
-1.0208148956298828,
-0.1686835139989853,
0.5083181262016296,
-0.2515109181404114,
-0.286793053150177,
0.6201444268226624,
-0.07614169269800186,
0.3918120265007019,
0.655910313129425,
0.006115338299423456,
0.638185441493988,
-0.3695073127746582,
0.0863608568906784,
-0.5971880555152893,
0.14590595662593842,
-0.24140429496765137,
-0.5295411944389343,
-0.07740314304828644,
0.5138809084892273,
0.08452210575342178,
-0.41920116543769836,
-0.5057985186576843,
0.7188894748687744,
-0.4246736168861389,
-0.44393229484558105,
-0.18349745869636536,
0.22434495389461517,
0.18602916598320007,
0.02423270232975483,
-0.17901384830474854,
0.879425048828125,
0.5037346482276917,
-0.3169161379337311,
0.03000897355377674,
0.2883675992488861,
-0.4116121530532837,
0.47253918647766113,
-0.7285167574882507,
0.3348492980003357,
0.3915053606033325,
-0.12451069056987762,
-0.39842283725738525,
0.15259824693202972,
0.2341671735048294,
-0.1372867226600647,
0.24728424847126007,
-0.2095358520746231,
-0.5738345980644226,
0.27548664808273315,
-0.7002682685852051,
0.29926592111587524,
0.6731313467025757,
-0.703713595867157,
-0.01567976176738739,
0.5538350343704224,
0.07675278186798096,
-0.6681001782417297,
-0.5293695330619812,
-0.13261198997497559,
-0.3714327812194824,
-0.5075979232788086,
0.6583827137947083,
-0.4966426491737366,
-0.5569717884063721,
0.21498575806617737,
-0.7589662671089172,
-0.23407314717769623,
0.4429888427257538,
0.6587466597557068,
0.09357321262359619,
-0.13999713957309723,
-0.19700118899345398,
0.022796092554926872,
-0.5842934846878052,
0.24976052343845367,
-0.01603308878839016,
0.0532102957367897,
-0.2830377221107483,
-0.558156430721283,
-0.6590135097503662,
0.3253968358039856,
0.3335969150066376,
-0.4385305941104889,
0.4744471609592438,
0.18571120500564575,
-0.497554212808609,
-0.02776123397052288,
-0.6216779947280884,
-0.041653092950582504,
-0.5622870326042175,
-0.24737633764743805,
-0.2943176031112671,
-0.6290258169174194,
0.4917907118797302,
-0.635633647441864,
-0.08386612683534622,
0.0020198056008666754,
0.5353639721870422,
-0.03992696851491928,
0.8162602782249451,
0.7337232232093811,
-0.37665465474128723,
0.31629666686058044,
0.00703803263604641,
-0.03578822687268257,
-0.6670337319374084,
-0.15945321321487427,
-0.6421376466751099,
-0.5534802079200745,
-0.7473065853118896,
-0.19160565733909607,
0.44990015029907227,
0.45627105236053467,
-0.4898706376552582,
0.04465698078274727,
-0.4958132207393646,
0.8659766912460327,
0.5427969098091125,
0.3607175648212433,
0.6826834678649902,
-0.25341731309890747,
-0.2573803961277008,
-0.26509103178977966,
-0.28518953919410706,
-0.45269861817359924,
1.1593189239501953,
0.2553498148918152,
0.7924482226371765,
-0.07518088817596436,
1.5137706995010376,
0.050027258694171906,
0.39060258865356445,
-0.07473072409629822,
0.5709800720214844,
-0.1054592877626419,
-0.6243172287940979,
-0.033296965062618256,
-0.7006847262382507,
-0.8746677041053772,
0.19999925792217255,
0.006291959900408983,
-0.9913690090179443,
0.5413912534713745,
-0.2376893013715744,
-0.09336696565151215,
0.34365567564964294,
-0.38109317421913147,
0.8821579217910767,
-0.13306818902492523,
-0.819399356842041,
-0.13272929191589355,
-0.49646878242492676,
0.45023149251937866,
-0.2140202820301056,
0.24585893750190735,
-0.4970944821834564,
-0.3557112514972687,
0.8482422828674316,
-0.7248746752738953,
0.5708777904510498,
-0.10999457538127899,
0.0022397972643375397,
-0.16790930926799774,
0.3647364675998688,
0.6583146452903748,
0.27802687883377075,
-0.23084022104740143,
0.42733263969421387,
0.2731032371520996,
-0.3370474874973297,
-0.36347347497940063,
1.005875825881958,
-0.9195970296859741,
-0.6771669387817383,
-0.5555898547172546,
-0.35700246691703796,
-0.34098729491233826,
0.1764659285545349,
0.3928285539150238,
0.10365708917379379,
-0.06225055456161499,
0.29043421149253845,
0.7710428237915039,
0.18246884644031525,
0.22626852989196777,
0.8150723576545715,
-0.14841648936271667,
-0.3309271037578583,
0.7964452505111694,
0.10014748573303223,
0.18715547025203705,
0.02354532480239868,
0.38592711091041565,
-0.26391398906707764,
-0.9641685485839844,
0.03904034197330475,
0.10480347275733948,
-0.5709633231163025,
-0.7960366606712341,
-0.11168114840984344,
-0.24514269828796387,
-0.023793146014213562,
-0.06785353273153305,
-0.8047335743904114,
-0.26968395709991455,
0.09938657283782959,
-0.027804594486951828,
0.4499780237674713,
0.6591997742652893,
-0.6455796360969543,
0.10804523527622223,
-0.7443196177482605,
0.4590885639190674,
-0.005262524820864201,
0.8612530827522278,
-0.35819774866104126,
-0.28070342540740967,
-0.06576546281576157,
-0.17286145687103271,
-0.3995555639266968,
-0.5715203285217285,
0.1270878165960312,
-0.17540611326694489,
0.6440544128417969,
0.4497694969177246,
0.5138201117515564,
0.594563364982605,
-0.4845696985721588,
0.4393400251865387,
0.1293375939130783,
-1.360795021057129,
0.26498058438301086,
-0.23000328242778778,
-0.04696072265505791,
0.8860948085784912,
0.5347963571548462,
-0.29238349199295044,
-0.8613092303276062,
-0.7987234592437744,
-0.7888939380645752,
0.36424046754837036,
0.431934118270874,
-0.32343554496765137,
0.5258077383041382,
0.1733408123254776,
0.23611979186534882,
0.42005273699760437,
-0.5569153428077698,
-0.3112359941005707,
0.12650945782661438,
0.04133263975381851,
0.03532441705465317,
-0.044428788125514984,
-0.8868497610092163,
0.009205020032823086,
0.5882475972175598,
0.3574409484863281,
0.009611773304641247,
-0.0646684467792511,
0.24229992926120758,
-0.31805503368377686,
0.09167704731225967,
-0.01502515934407711,
0.7473726272583008,
-0.30473166704177856,
0.031851328909397125,
0.21755321323871613,
-0.14884164929389954,
0.3677971065044403,
0.2602744698524475,
-0.026162629947066307,
-0.15018920600414276,
-0.003891913453117013,
-0.023656100034713745,
0.4928804934024811,
-0.44287341833114624,
0.7867913246154785,
-0.2943403422832489,
-0.14614562690258026,
-0.18651536107063293,
0.237487331032753,
0.2568988800048828,
0.5419641733169556,
-0.23949241638183594,
0.16070656478405,
0.1845257729291916,
-0.22695036232471466,
0.3727145493030548,
0.24856160581111908,
-0.13982796669006348,
0.08041083067655563,
1.0473806858062744,
0.0015885975444689393,
-0.2717856168746948,
0.23727940022945404,
-0.12727393209934235,
-0.05914256349205971,
0.48409682512283325,
0.21774019300937653,
0.7501784563064575,
-0.3883904218673706,
-0.1398259997367859,
-0.19779936969280243,
0.2712325155735016,
-0.24316900968551636,
0.348004013299942,
-0.23781457543373108,
-0.3298083245754242,
-0.019352354109287262,
-0.4362560510635376,
-0.9962168335914612,
0.29397058486938477,
-1.0729012489318848,
0.19100145995616913,
-0.9487224221229553,
0.06619252264499664,
-0.0964302122592926,
0.3081013858318329,
-0.6204161047935486,
0.1917189508676529,
0.20799976587295532,
1.0732150077819824,
-0.46030300855636597,
0.6587215662002563,
-0.07208777219057083,
-0.10507114976644516,
-0.3780820965766907,
-0.32110950350761414,
0.07763440161943436,
-0.8391101956367493,
0.2874545454978943,
0.0716688260436058,
-0.19735562801361084,
-0.45760226249694824,
-0.5702901482582092,
-0.7245591878890991,
1.123396635055542,
0.783568263053894,
-0.8432559967041016,
0.4229651689529419,
0.09689569473266602,
0.44608795642852783,
0.06898088753223419,
-0.1875242292881012,
0.35945355892181396,
0.7040461897850037,
-0.6007503271102905,
-0.7926775813102722,
0.30039724707603455,
-0.3059731423854828,
-0.23910218477249146,
0.31685250997543335,
-0.7866842150688171,
0.7133150100708008,
0.19103649258613586,
-0.34237223863601685,
0.5272206664085388,
0.33703720569610596,
0.3210861086845398,
0.8286323547363281,
0.13677847385406494,
0.7237119078636169,
0.9147543907165527,
-0.1380246877670288,
1.0328645706176758,
-0.6337257623672485,
0.35024139285087585,
1.647610068321228,
-0.8819701671600342,
0.9823722839355469,
0.1365349292755127,
-0.28294873237609863,
0.013818785548210144,
0.5329119563102722,
-0.31219589710235596,
0.6729309558868408,
0.6204559206962585,
-0.7222644686698914,
-0.13509619235992432,
-0.12592485547065735,
-0.9809063076972961,
0.2544552683830261,
-0.2048507183790207,
-0.2649085819721222,
-0.457882285118103,
-0.5923631191253662,
0.07985752075910568,
0.30265799164772034,
-0.1993321180343628,
0.818030595779419,
0.27701258659362793,
-0.08840751647949219,
0.2774465084075928,
0.10196419805288315,
0.3417721688747406,
-0.8308845162391663,
0.41563358902931213,
-0.43897372484207153,
0.5122462511062622,
-0.38298267126083374,
-0.39841485023498535,
0.3269416093826294,
0.01735401526093483,
0.16411073505878448,
-0.4052026569843292,
0.630171000957489,
-0.15822112560272217,
-0.13412639498710632,
0.7484212517738342,
0.7643356323242188,
0.4080014228820801,
-0.14829230308532715,
-0.7860102653503418,
0.36749067902565,
-0.5396081805229187,
0.0010354359401389956,
0.9599901437759399,
0.3411618769168854,
0.1060812696814537,
0.6189972162246704,
0.5819075107574463,
0.20162010192871094,
-0.06946469098329544,
-0.07062599807977676,
1.071001648902893,
-0.5170130133628845,
-0.5530632734298706,
-0.7614311575889587,
0.0944669172167778,
-0.13136804103851318,
-0.19391585886478424,
0.8615037202835083,
0.8777000904083252,
0.94173264503479,
0.27815255522727966,
0.5457602143287659,
0.7754665017127991,
0.35473400354385376,
-0.34451037645339966,
1.0826407670974731,
-0.5308027267456055,
0.20332255959510803,
-0.15091313421726227,
-0.6396471261978149,
-0.10205948352813721,
0.07283814996480942,
-0.34999531507492065,
-0.16898803412914276,
0.6841630935668945,
0.7198824882507324,
-0.13795475661754608,
0.25979962944984436,
0.5520359873771667,
0.0754646435379982,
0.24647168815135956,
0.46131351590156555,
0.8856253623962402,
-0.44594311714172363,
0.39921462535858154,
-0.6682040095329285,
-0.28866299986839294,
0.1473231464624405,
-1.1721515655517578,
-0.44023218750953674,
-0.1853753626346588,
-0.5306804180145264,
-0.2822539210319519,
0.5496285557746887,
0.29191914200782776,
0.7344721555709839,
-0.7121554613113403,
-0.46527326107025146,
-0.06203221157193184,
0.21080976724624634,
-0.39791569113731384,
-0.08859766274690628,
0.18409760296344757,
-0.32379573583602905,
-0.4971112310886383,
0.8621639609336853,
0.25415101647377014,
0.11706490069627762,
-0.22903501987457275,
0.012738010846078396,
0.424398809671402,
0.002553424332290888,
-0.033086489886045456,
0.20399922132492065,
-0.19249850511550903,
-0.18240304291248322,
-0.48528486490249634,
0.06510353088378906,
0.25921574234962463,
0.8317227959632874,
-0.607276976108551,
0.376722127199173,
0.19792668521404266,
0.8015092015266418,
0.7672039270401001,
-0.18186715245246887,
0.6923070549964905,
-0.6591272354125977,
0.18178512156009674,
0.2793269157409668,
0.5657814741134644,
0.08740485459566116,
-0.48790615797042847,
0.6901556253433228,
0.12222757935523987,
-0.7541211843490601,
-1.2026913166046143,
0.1301812380552292,
-0.7507153749465942,
-0.16931402683258057,
0.4519064128398895,
-0.7339355945587158,
-0.368287593126297,
0.0035143992863595486,
0.40731409192085266,
0.18805751204490662,
-0.2410253882408142,
0.9081827998161316,
0.5434753894805908,
-0.031977687031030655,
0.4011155068874359,
-0.39932096004486084,
0.5016161203384399,
0.4683322012424469,
-1.0893325805664062,
0.26263052225112915,
0.04500608891248703,
0.4383571147918701,
-0.05878019332885742,
0.4965376853942871,
-0.7461106777191162,
0.23938104510307312,
0.18426166474819183,
-0.36308959126472473,
-0.383744478225708,
-0.30323752760887146,
-0.6736570000648499,
0.1862219274044037,
-0.03188904747366905,
-0.58236163854599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00370v1
|
Post-decoder Biasing for End-to-End Speech Recognition of Multi-turn Medical Interview
| 2024-03-01T08:53:52 | 2024-03-01T08:53:52 |
Heyang Liu, Yu Wang, Yanfeng Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
End-to-end (E2E) approach is gradually replacing hybrid models for automatic
speech recognition (ASR) tasks. However, the optimization of E2E models lacks
an intuitive method for handling decoding shifts, especially in scenarios with
a large number of domain-specific rare words that hold specific important
meanings. Furthermore, the absence of knowledge-intensive speech datasets in
academia has been a significant limiting factor, and the commonly used speech
corpora exhibit significant disparities with realistic conversation. To address
these challenges, we present Medical Interview (MED-IT), a multi-turn
consultation speech dataset that contains a substantial number of
knowledge-intensive named entities. We also explore methods to enhance the
recognition performance of rare words for E2E models. We propose a novel
approach, post-decoder biasing, which constructs a transform probability matrix
based on the distribution of training transcriptions. This guides the model to
prioritize recognizing words in the biasing list. In our experiments, for
subsets of rare words appearing in the training speech between 10 and 20 times,
and between 1 and 5 times, the proposed method achieves a relative improvement
of 9.3% and 5.1%, respectively.
|
[
-0.4257029592990875,
-0.14514322578907013,
0.49427464604377747,
-0.13200059533119202,
-0.5496962070465088,
0.09340709447860718,
-0.11379383504390717,
-0.3075319826602936,
0.47881218791007996,
0.42672157287597656,
-0.6712486147880554,
-0.3838358521461487,
-0.9110438227653503,
0.05293022841215134,
-0.27863800525665283,
1.184179425239563,
0.0027479236014187336,
0.7540662884712219,
-0.11636931449174881,
-0.3758729100227356,
-0.21511948108673096,
-0.6950727105140686,
-0.607641875743866,
-0.17250816524028778,
0.07126438617706299,
0.15105170011520386,
0.3496696650981903,
0.4766031503677368,
0.23435619473457336,
0.16080772876739502,
-0.2767287492752075,
0.2486867904663086,
-0.46231865882873535,
-0.06370279937982559,
-0.19582360982894897,
-0.505908191204071,
-0.3166634440422058,
-0.02347404882311821,
0.4496401846408844,
0.9063301682472229,
-0.3053736388683319,
0.10985399782657623,
-0.04820381850004196,
0.3984111547470093,
-0.5888975858688354,
-0.061279550194740295,
-0.8076932430267334,
0.1480465978384018,
-0.3031848073005676,
-0.4184545576572418,
-0.3768434226512909,
-0.17835858464241028,
0.30359673500061035,
-0.5026957988739014,
0.3617095351219177,
-0.2100374698638916,
0.7165154814720154,
0.405718594789505,
-0.14836904406547546,
-0.0738959014415741,
-0.83818119764328,
0.6565481424331665,
-0.4807300567626953,
0.6778324842453003,
0.5464627146720886,
0.31628286838531494,
0.04409538954496384,
-0.43242722749710083,
-0.5198535323143005,
0.2829590141773224,
0.1872873455286026,
0.21281839907169342,
-0.16363444924354553,
0.15798090398311615,
0.19902671873569489,
0.22989895939826965,
-0.4001109004020691,
0.17155417799949646,
-0.29421746730804443,
-0.4199526607990265,
0.2549876272678375,
-0.02407016232609749,
0.11624108999967575,
0.34080275893211365,
0.005014019086956978,
-0.24222834408283234,
-0.6724231839179993,
-0.05539293214678764,
0.25425320863723755,
-0.1660909801721573,
0.08754871040582657,
0.5560146570205688,
-0.0823565274477005,
0.5846455693244934,
0.31046533584594727,
-0.0418064221739769,
0.6801976561546326,
-0.30493393540382385,
-0.04647824913263321,
0.13315366208553314,
0.5353863835334778,
0.5619117617607117,
0.20316897332668304,
-0.19634336233139038,
0.006191664841026068,
0.37059783935546875,
0.32554855942726135,
-0.5940845012664795,
-0.020472005009651184,
0.2786124050617218,
-0.5467125177383423,
-0.05401991680264473,
-0.19317053258419037,
-0.8416334986686707,
-0.3792881369590759,
-0.3557165563106537,
0.1942572444677353,
-0.3652448058128357,
-0.23505902290344238,
0.39432576298713684,
-0.15355370938777924,
0.33121898770332336,
0.17238138616085052,
-0.600707471370697,
0.2552263140678406,
0.293694406747818,
0.6726416349411011,
-0.1485646814107895,
0.2024606466293335,
-0.8219335079193115,
0.11555203050374985,
-0.18413716554641724,
0.928005039691925,
-0.6476695537567139,
-0.5942239761352539,
-0.013124293647706509,
0.11820290982723236,
-0.08994650095701218,
-0.7314324975013733,
0.7515197992324829,
-0.36033210158348083,
0.3431316912174225,
-0.08305606245994568,
-0.43824395537376404,
0.1277514547109604,
0.10970053821802139,
-0.38969942927360535,
0.4817698001861572,
-0.15287645161151886,
-0.8095042109489441,
0.6884869933128357,
-0.6013534069061279,
-0.5726472735404968,
-0.1682233363389969,
-0.7333562970161438,
-0.7081722021102905,
0.14644311368465424,
0.6149830222129822,
0.18760237097740173,
-0.2755684554576874,
0.09085365384817123,
-0.02950170822441578,
-0.18479196727275848,
0.39195170998573303,
-0.5158631205558777,
0.5623682737350464,
0.1029374897480011,
-0.3590475618839264,
-0.006416631862521172,
-0.944810152053833,
0.08125845342874527,
-0.036892447620630264,
-0.304806649684906,
-0.41996532678604126,
0.13992932438850403,
0.17455917596817017,
0.35617804527282715,
-0.12760981917381287,
-0.6864293217658997,
-0.024359967559576035,
-0.7896319627761841,
0.360461562871933,
0.4268491566181183,
-0.11335299909114838,
0.5158290266990662,
-0.27795878052711487,
0.43848681449890137,
0.4528343081474304,
0.17376215755939484,
0.016299791634082794,
-0.5486819744110107,
-0.6478872299194336,
-0.3011923134326935,
0.19115090370178223,
0.7408152222633362,
-0.845364511013031,
0.34444424510002136,
-0.4133327305316925,
-0.09295975416898727,
-1.2470370531082153,
-0.27197328209877014,
0.5601032376289368,
0.39921796321868896,
0.7062291502952576,
-0.368635892868042,
-0.9177987575531006,
-1.0682933330535889,
-0.4037001430988312,
0.21961617469787598,
-0.5097028017044067,
0.5764219760894775,
-0.09871288388967514,
-0.6204714179039001,
0.7998468279838562,
-0.4366866946220398,
-0.5027921795845032,
-0.16009874641895294,
-0.0013402352342382073,
0.39937683939933777,
0.30642566084861755,
0.17573529481887817,
-0.7403531074523926,
-0.2865760028362274,
-0.09093914180994034,
-0.42255762219429016,
-0.07332793623209,
-0.1940617859363556,
-0.22252564132213593,
0.18185579776763916,
0.4530985653400421,
-0.45227453112602234,
0.22440139949321747,
0.4054127037525177,
-0.21000614762306213,
0.2155432254076004,
-0.07641863822937012,
0.12099382281303406,
-1.1820024251937866,
-0.12657347321510315,
-0.012604499235749245,
-0.0853019654750824,
-0.8660199046134949,
-0.538352370262146,
-0.17854435741901398,
0.17051422595977783,
-0.18957765400409698,
0.20713140070438385,
-0.8780472278594971,
-0.13276782631874084,
-0.29898008704185486,
-0.14334945380687714,
-0.1070595309138298,
0.2812606692314148,
0.5143166780471802,
0.6583278179168701,
0.6244003176689148,
-0.5680941939353943,
-0.2338414192199707,
0.4329734742641449,
-0.22636447846889496,
0.5792219638824463,
-0.409551739692688,
0.5759756565093994,
-0.32141757011413574,
0.3354174792766571,
-0.6796496510505676,
0.16477978229522705,
-0.09342993050813675,
-0.6464207768440247,
0.625949501991272,
-0.2854873538017273,
-0.1576172113418579,
-0.3917878568172455,
-0.23365537822246552,
0.7428587675094604,
0.6727312803268433,
-0.39456531405448914,
0.5504862666130066,
0.8544652462005615,
-0.22031469643115997,
-0.6084081530570984,
-0.6218027472496033,
0.16417670249938965,
-0.018713975325226784,
-0.38492563366889954,
0.634128212928772,
-0.07586663216352463,
0.03950348496437073,
-0.45634761452674866,
-0.27883070707321167,
-0.17241273820400238,
-0.5735922455787659,
0.11202947795391083,
0.32102489471435547,
0.022718191146850586,
-0.3075043857097626,
0.3643994629383087,
-0.3522162139415741,
0.06496348232030869,
-0.6085395812988281,
0.6651930809020996,
0.36863914132118225,
-0.2457732856273651,
-0.2096855193376541,
0.570443332195282,
0.7187594771385193,
-0.19387030601501465,
0.5678392052650452,
0.8277963399887085,
-0.6033581495285034,
0.13359412550926208,
-0.8077076077461243,
-0.35294780135154724,
-0.38842809200286865,
0.6754829287528992,
-0.3610818386077881,
-0.7386119961738586,
0.34503301978111267,
-0.06904502213001251,
0.04612576216459274,
0.20017626881599426,
0.7558742761611938,
-0.06126956269145012,
1.1314315795898438,
0.3786196708679199,
-0.2308516651391983,
0.3534996807575226,
-0.0893663614988327,
0.2677566409111023,
-1.044162631034851,
-0.4214734435081482,
-0.2721823453903198,
-0.04888954758644104,
-0.4473603367805481,
-0.6458534002304077,
0.8497284054756165,
-0.24620191752910614,
0.3456451892852783,
0.08072721213102341,
-0.8213170170783997,
0.32736414670944214,
0.5387855172157288,
0.37016561627388,
0.07021763175725937,
0.3791482448577881,
-0.04793088510632515,
-0.34026309847831726,
-0.541816234588623,
-0.062462154775857925,
1.3093888759613037,
0.3148214817047119,
0.603042721748352,
-0.0953507348895073,
0.5692465901374817,
-0.1589421182870865,
0.05395619198679924,
-0.6291911005973816,
0.286138653755188,
-0.3865815997123718,
-0.3197425901889801,
-0.25703588128089905,
-0.3304108679294586,
-0.7570798993110657,
0.25209149718284607,
-0.27074891328811646,
-0.42733636498451233,
0.33549579977989197,
0.23523057997226715,
-0.49611401557922363,
0.16115503013134003,
-0.39066416025161743,
0.4026663899421692,
0.046831853687763214,
-0.1473255753517151,
-0.21623243391513824,
-0.8930695056915283,
0.034381549805402756,
0.01701986789703369,
0.3707256317138672,
0.44072943925857544,
0.13199877738952637,
1.0634158849716187,
-0.40262964367866516,
0.5662664771080017,
-0.36188289523124695,
0.18063154816627502,
-0.024600299075245857,
-0.2958621680736542,
0.6322576999664307,
-0.09890974313020706,
0.09826592355966568,
0.44181692600250244,
0.196344256401062,
-0.15128086507320404,
-0.29078882932662964,
0.1516394168138504,
-0.8999283909797668,
-0.2766163945198059,
-0.3444426953792572,
-0.41028159856796265,
-0.6928427219390869,
0.0323631651699543,
0.9390428066253662,
0.4125140905380249,
-0.23690229654312134,
-0.07875270396471024,
1.0179688930511475,
-0.5882366895675659,
-0.09285816550254822,
0.6242882013320923,
0.2731695771217346,
-0.558074414730072,
0.7663781046867371,
0.2824523150920868,
0.2042059302330017,
0.4062708914279938,
0.11502551287412643,
-0.5076807737350464,
-0.8224382996559143,
-0.6360070705413818,
0.22936224937438965,
-0.46208667755126953,
-0.10167749226093292,
-1.2394459247589111,
-0.4269411861896515,
-0.538028359413147,
-0.096555694937706,
-0.40777868032455444,
-0.18683864176273346,
-0.320768266916275,
-0.2678855359554291,
0.3733937740325928,
0.2707486152648926,
-0.02541092224419117,
0.22266098856925964,
-0.6710913181304932,
0.5013478398323059,
-0.043906815350055695,
0.3637336492538452,
-0.4772369861602783,
-0.9008132219314575,
-0.2487114518880844,
0.04317954555153847,
0.12053338438272476,
-0.9247394800186157,
0.4191427230834961,
0.25828951597213745,
0.6573283672332764,
0.6382459402084351,
-0.07880209386348724,
0.45455604791641235,
-0.8238560557365417,
0.45268112421035767,
0.448776513338089,
-0.6541232466697693,
0.4592832922935486,
-0.2146398425102234,
0.2520468831062317,
0.7149619460105896,
0.3349633514881134,
-0.5166507959365845,
-0.31093552708625793,
-0.5173840522766113,
-1.146483063697815,
0.63737952709198,
0.12057395279407501,
-0.024020906537771225,
-0.10486429929733276,
0.11414637416601181,
0.2620207965373993,
0.40521496534347534,
-0.5228554010391235,
-0.37258362770080566,
-0.23722444474697113,
-0.3117921054363251,
0.05969841405749321,
-0.6304794549942017,
-0.3464352786540985,
-0.28593844175338745,
0.44635701179504395,
0.057806819677352905,
0.5859851837158203,
0.10284915566444397,
-0.18347486853599548,
0.100521519780159,
0.6059775948524475,
0.6704396605491638,
0.11975322663784027,
-0.13368572294712067,
0.16465705633163452,
0.3078162670135498,
-0.8450782895088196,
0.04363192245364189,
0.32759401202201843,
-0.008574111387133598,
0.36406856775283813,
-0.04765959084033966,
0.8841841220855713,
-0.08279292285442352,
-0.6284621357917786,
0.7132737040519714,
0.08466169983148575,
-0.10564600676298141,
-0.360350102186203,
-0.3800927996635437,
-0.1822834461927414,
-0.0203294325619936,
0.3121391534805298,
0.2568720877170563,
0.6448352336883545,
-0.2985397279262543,
0.40010330080986023,
0.4360356032848358,
-0.22725944221019745,
-0.18934231996536255,
0.6685471534729004,
0.034404683858156204,
-0.12195967137813568,
0.543041467666626,
-0.2530592381954193,
-0.637984037399292,
0.29600435495376587,
0.6177815198898315,
0.8681142330169678,
-0.6758123636245728,
-0.05188439413905144,
0.3201694190502167,
0.1462498903274536,
-0.2658827006816864,
0.48649439215660095,
0.06260859966278076,
-0.8441303968429565,
-0.3460458517074585,
-0.5951253175735474,
-0.2407485842704773,
0.19757525622844696,
-0.8675259947776794,
0.41996029019355774,
-0.32655858993530273,
-0.31630972027778625,
-0.12235337495803833,
-0.7178027629852295,
-0.7774478793144226,
0.2896934151649475,
0.20278336107730865,
0.39556390047073364,
-0.7992180585861206,
0.7179994583129883,
0.681060254573822,
-0.17714065313339233,
-0.5140496492385864,
-0.1078309491276741,
0.1684277057647705,
-0.9301965832710266,
0.21334442496299744,
0.14415988326072693,
-0.21557024121284485,
-0.07943087071180344,
-0.08790750056505203,
-0.8364934325218201,
0.8183242082595825,
0.23927487432956696,
-1.0267292261123657,
-0.2854515016078949,
0.35235142707824707,
0.5418477654457092,
-0.34226417541503906,
0.6138602495193481,
0.6061137914657593,
-0.009511836804449558,
0.11911781877279282,
-1.270735502243042,
-0.16881486773490906,
-0.43229925632476807,
-0.04556165263056755,
0.17321719229221344,
-0.09759103506803513,
0.584473192691803,
-0.23078282177448273,
-0.24752019345760345,
-0.5293350219726562,
0.26016220450401306,
0.3021479547023773,
0.532016396522522,
0.6722570657730103,
0.367709755897522,
0.631851077079773,
0.13775242865085602,
0.773804783821106,
-0.31517794728279114,
-0.02564799040555954,
1.1688004732131958,
-0.24791476130485535,
0.734192967414856,
0.5370193123817444,
-0.32561540603637695,
0.05136436969041824,
0.5450443625450134,
0.17385849356651306,
0.8451562523841858,
0.23071451485157013,
-0.39910560846328735,
-0.19152583181858063,
-0.22816385328769684,
-0.5535193681716919,
0.30061638355255127,
0.6281623840332031,
-0.611606776714325,
0.0023912370670586824,
0.43970903754234314,
-0.02142765372991562,
-0.04760337993502617,
-0.2979423999786377,
1.091385841369629,
0.3517279624938965,
-0.4247240722179413,
0.48262354731559753,
-0.17400066554546356,
0.9444178342819214,
-0.415444016456604,
-0.012054679915308952,
-0.013211855664849281,
0.235066756606102,
-0.3437180519104004,
-0.46841761469841003,
0.4222574234008789,
-0.0207715705037117,
-0.5932142734527588,
-0.11554352939128876,
0.39380159974098206,
-0.6719595789909363,
-0.5994393229484558,
0.4034954309463501,
0.5018528699874878,
0.4170973300933838,
-0.2089611291885376,
-0.4774401783943176,
0.024941110983490944,
0.08269135653972626,
0.01201673410832882,
0.4880290627479553,
0.1635352224111557,
-0.009400992654263973,
0.3325425088405609,
0.6147814989089966,
0.36639904975891113,
0.16340091824531555,
0.6361474394798279,
0.8538896441459656,
-0.2861151099205017,
-0.9798619747161865,
-0.696957528591156,
0.41163375973701477,
-0.06120176240801811,
-0.06100284308195114,
0.22579464316368103,
0.6506618857383728,
0.7861221432685852,
-0.06443953514099121,
0.9573904871940613,
0.35480737686157227,
0.9399076104164124,
-0.6322285532951355,
0.6133404970169067,
-0.2850508689880371,
0.28541696071624756,
-0.40320277214050293,
-0.5787109136581421,
-0.1637340635061264,
0.8230612874031067,
-0.36721351742744446,
0.05388987809419632,
0.5402219891548157,
0.8518866896629333,
-0.07339083403348923,
-0.11951325833797455,
0.480987548828125,
0.22004570066928864,
0.20642797648906708,
0.7725784778594971,
0.43132394552230835,
-0.30617862939834595,
0.5199389457702637,
0.3531389534473419,
-0.5144583582878113,
-0.10971827805042267,
-0.2634677588939667,
-0.7483652830123901,
-0.6204369068145752,
-0.318203330039978,
-0.6858550310134888,
0.20918934047222137,
1.1454846858978271,
0.739823043346405,
-0.8977500796318054,
0.16642682254314423,
0.061997123062610626,
-0.5164871215820312,
-0.2651710510253906,
-0.1259680986404419,
0.3625433146953583,
0.10703107714653015,
-0.6266980767250061,
0.48881271481513977,
0.35895538330078125,
-0.08940218389034271,
0.1368577480316162,
0.012353787198662758,
0.06623108685016632,
-0.05820858106017113,
0.6101429462432861,
0.21130076050758362,
-0.5118849873542786,
0.023547004908323288,
0.12379441410303116,
0.20510084927082062,
0.2617672383785248,
1.010210633277893,
-0.7279247045516968,
0.5811415314674377,
0.0666816383600235,
0.9642003774642944,
0.6454076170921326,
-0.13520477712154388,
0.7485005855560303,
-0.4508833885192871,
0.1085922122001648,
0.4070872962474823,
0.43898850679397583,
0.34664079546928406,
-0.5219963192939758,
0.2763451337814331,
0.3381021320819855,
-0.40539151430130005,
-0.813641369342804,
0.2746031880378723,
-0.9121525883674622,
0.014611010439693928,
1.2506580352783203,
0.11844298243522644,
0.23817452788352966,
-0.4909272789955139,
-0.26482510566711426,
0.5236794948577881,
-0.3660230040550232,
0.7683672904968262,
0.475722998380661,
-0.3334728479385376,
-0.3286541998386383,
-0.41206425428390503,
0.6097036004066467,
0.7193737030029297,
-0.7089700698852539,
-0.16921661794185638,
0.5700910687446594,
0.5780812501907349,
0.00754369655624032,
1.1104313135147095,
-0.40125739574432373,
0.1826888769865036,
-0.1464294195175171,
0.14929330348968506,
0.057828497141599655,
-0.2877410650253296,
-0.5915954113006592,
-0.13445012271404266,
-0.00039559448487125337,
-0.604663610458374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00354v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00354v2
|
Self-Consistent Reasoning-based Aspect-Sentiment Quad Prediction with Extract-Then-Assign Strategy
| 2024-03-01T08:34:02 | 2024-06-08T08:41:53 |
Jieyong Kim, Ryang Heo, Yongsik Seo, SeongKu Kang, Jinyoung Yeo, Dongha Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the task of aspect sentiment quad prediction (ASQP), generative methods
for predicting sentiment quads have shown promising results. However, they
still suffer from imprecise predictions and limited interpretability, caused by
data scarcity and inadequate modeling of the quadruplet composition process. In
this paper, we propose Self-Consistent Reasoning-based Aspect-sentiment
quadruple Prediction (SCRAP), optimizing its model to generate reasonings and
the corresponding sentiment quadruplets in sequence. SCRAP adopts the
Extract-Then-Assign reasoning strategy, which closely mimics human cognition.
In the end, SCRAP significantly improves the model's ability to handle complex
reasoning tasks and correctly predict quadruplets through consistency voting,
resulting in enhanced interpretability and accuracy in ASQP.
|
[
-0.47044917941093445,
-0.18017680943012238,
0.7100324034690857,
0.5397758483886719,
-0.13604888319969177,
0.41981974244117737,
0.0798499584197998,
-0.31994834542274475,
0.34247466921806335,
0.6890270113945007,
-0.7349219918251038,
-0.21024465560913086,
-0.24896472692489624,
0.1894731968641281,
-0.10970015823841095,
0.9828569889068604,
-0.05898120999336243,
-0.03235480561852455,
-0.5215602517127991,
-0.08838759362697601,
-0.48852381110191345,
-0.839718759059906,
-0.4092588722705841,
-0.26416346430778503,
0.31640443205833435,
0.7348557114601135,
0.49120229482650757,
0.7733982801437378,
0.32891497015953064,
0.2973526120185852,
0.015812033787369728,
0.23182062804698944,
0.0656164288520813,
0.28187355399131775,
-0.7728433609008789,
-0.2760477662086487,
-0.4110914170742035,
-0.09986381232738495,
0.3532286584377289,
0.40620648860931396,
-0.12276753783226013,
0.06829220056533813,
0.39376452565193176,
0.5742243528366089,
-0.7165107727050781,
0.08741962164640427,
-0.5406415462493896,
-0.30264273285865784,
-0.036437027156353,
-0.06720271706581116,
-0.32603809237480164,
-0.31412652134895325,
-0.3237253427505493,
-0.4629378020763397,
0.1165834441781044,
0.30198928713798523,
0.9096224308013916,
0.09383926540613174,
-0.1141798123717308,
-0.008630252443253994,
-0.5350408554077148,
0.8768556714057922,
-0.7418549656867981,
0.06879439204931259,
0.5288069248199463,
0.08060070872306824,
-0.10323665291070938,
-0.7278123497962952,
-0.7071873545646667,
0.2152947336435318,
0.09565985202789307,
0.25807249546051025,
0.28128930926322937,
0.03345564752817154,
-0.004947640933096409,
0.40845537185668945,
-0.20254047214984894,
-0.11892452836036682,
-0.11988966166973114,
-0.3801572024822235,
0.8268113136291504,
0.38937830924987793,
0.2045486718416214,
-0.8606036901473999,
-0.7489049434661865,
0.24593091011047363,
-0.44375383853912354,
0.17467395961284637,
0.2984711229801178,
0.2351294755935669,
0.20532011985778809,
0.5735743641853333,
-0.7359781861305237,
0.29062214493751526,
0.6014338731765747,
0.16465695202350616,
0.4263862371444702,
-0.5518012642860413,
-0.0961494967341423,
-0.309407502412796,
0.9626142382621765,
0.5021435618400574,
-0.2139972448348999,
-0.007318293675780296,
-0.17703941464424133,
-0.03057507611811161,
0.6756830811500549,
-0.38241806626319885,
-0.711602509021759,
0.6072165966033936,
-0.3466232419013977,
-0.6095651984214783,
-0.3049699068069458,
-0.9721056818962097,
-0.2629086971282959,
-0.2784954011440277,
0.5026552677154541,
-0.866661012172699,
-0.22685973346233368,
-0.15602070093154907,
-0.07104279845952988,
0.08567601442337036,
0.5638825297355652,
-1.0093178749084473,
0.13697591423988342,
0.8673182725906372,
0.7008340358734131,
-0.44200730323791504,
-0.49523675441741943,
-0.49975448846817017,
0.09131596982479095,
-0.21274839341640472,
1.3138105869293213,
-0.4993772804737091,
-0.12246792763471603,
-0.20249536633491516,
-0.053793735802173615,
0.22253087162971497,
-0.4574146270751953,
0.9255351424217224,
-0.23233696818351746,
0.11121351271867752,
-0.6718490123748779,
-0.44533392786979675,
-0.42715466022491455,
0.6794853806495667,
-0.6943135857582092,
1.151767373085022,
0.3051183819770813,
-0.938834011554718,
0.40269556641578674,
-0.3270581364631653,
-0.18002092838287354,
0.21231278777122498,
-0.0675477683544159,
-0.7015182375907898,
-0.031325072050094604,
0.3920864760875702,
0.3019670844078064,
-0.06760423630475998,
-0.08470338582992554,
-0.8182713389396667,
0.13504628837108612,
0.2170943170785904,
-0.185182586312294,
0.6296911835670471,
0.2235136777162552,
-0.3780732750892639,
0.23697958886623383,
-0.6015236973762512,
0.710807204246521,
-0.10883710533380508,
-0.16839845478534698,
-0.15790624916553497,
0.09252436459064484,
-0.1525028944015503,
0.425382524728775,
0.44510748982429504,
-0.7260578274726868,
0.44388294219970703,
-0.45839694142341614,
0.2337997704744339,
0.9373961091041565,
0.16651798784732819,
0.6039627194404602,
-0.46005386114120483,
0.542991042137146,
0.24192194640636444,
0.22020591795444489,
-0.014655315317213535,
-0.042289793491363525,
-0.7790970802307129,
-0.32358890771865845,
0.6569440364837646,
0.3255499005317688,
-0.8849168419837952,
0.4402807950973511,
-0.24887681007385254,
-0.4352058470249176,
-0.4816012978553772,
-0.12662331759929657,
0.39269188046455383,
0.2668801248073578,
0.4802797734737396,
-0.36489421129226685,
-0.646878182888031,
-0.7384260892868042,
-0.47173526883125305,
-0.13917462527751923,
0.277516633272171,
-0.03312040492892265,
0.33331385254859924,
0.12199713289737701,
0.957826554775238,
-0.3944140374660492,
-0.190857395529747,
-0.48230746388435364,
0.4158203601837158,
-0.2011125683784485,
0.4895205497741699,
0.1784474402666092,
-0.6425356268882751,
-0.5620549321174622,
-0.2896486222743988,
-0.5865646600723267,
-0.1626824140548706,
-0.11226242035627365,
-0.38282039761543274,
0.4851424992084503,
0.18219272792339325,
-0.4944617748260498,
0.38745421171188354,
0.27870693802833557,
-0.4041687846183777,
0.9351209998130798,
-0.014181435108184814,
0.13965551555156708,
-0.9761788845062256,
-0.23376765847206116,
-0.11760783940553665,
-0.5405518412590027,
-0.15297822654247284,
-0.015160083770751953,
0.20459359884262085,
0.2707737386226654,
-0.20177201926708221,
0.4243199825286865,
-0.525844156742096,
-0.16919881105422974,
-0.4791012108325958,
-0.3652424216270447,
0.6076827049255371,
0.5909271240234375,
0.17388533055782318,
0.6197470426559448,
0.28716760873794556,
-0.2874492108821869,
0.12608124315738678,
0.3919457495212555,
-0.05074409395456314,
0.6060932278633118,
-0.32496991753578186,
0.17668135464191437,
0.1703135371208191,
0.15187492966651917,
-0.9137994647026062,
-0.060120999813079834,
0.2797124981880188,
-0.5339677929878235,
0.2687799632549286,
-0.1362156718969345,
-0.4364434778690338,
-0.43494853377342224,
-0.45835986733436584,
0.4137011766433716,
0.2773715853691101,
-0.6480052471160889,
1.03888738155365,
0.2918776869773865,
-0.5446133613586426,
-0.7016271352767944,
0.027718879282474518,
-0.19465935230255127,
-0.21329937875270844,
-0.27851545810699463,
0.31003865599632263,
-0.08552045375108719,
0.10574798285961151,
-0.0014765342930331826,
-0.19862718880176544,
0.027652479708194733,
0.05779261514544487,
0.3959704041481018,
0.2354084849357605,
0.09746401011943817,
-0.00819798931479454,
0.055245544761419296,
-0.155888631939888,
0.28379392623901367,
-0.14301367104053497,
0.6124962568283081,
-0.32280078530311584,
-0.30546844005584717,
-0.22636070847511292,
0.5550746917724609,
0.5063757300376892,
-0.2728255093097687,
0.20828716456890106,
0.2930741012096405,
-0.021792538464069366,
-0.4271310865879059,
-0.6758202314376831,
-0.055051904171705246,
-0.4427924156188965,
0.19207510352134705,
-0.6718382835388184,
-0.32649388909339905,
0.476926326751709,
-0.4487819969654083,
-0.04894556477665901,
0.6471430659294128,
0.5223115682601929,
-0.6684966087341309,
1.0764254331588745,
0.4595670998096466,
-0.21041929721832275,
0.19069868326187134,
-0.3708440661430359,
-0.01458085048943758,
-1.209732174873352,
-0.3519980013370514,
-0.329683393239975,
-0.08867193758487701,
-0.3773476481437683,
-0.30005359649658203,
0.18435753881931305,
0.3192366063594818,
-0.5139161944389343,
-0.04008805379271507,
-0.7527856826782227,
0.24518707394599915,
0.8040847182273865,
0.004200339782983065,
0.2787698805332184,
0.006869702134281397,
-0.07108739018440247,
-0.07676336169242859,
-0.42509856820106506,
-0.3741413652896881,
0.9606509208679199,
0.1415848284959793,
0.4817511737346649,
-0.21204064786434174,
1.0308281183242798,
0.5473271608352661,
0.07345000654459,
-0.5673553943634033,
0.32121849060058594,
0.07445257157087326,
-0.3666101396083832,
-0.23959973454475403,
-0.24129803478717804,
-0.6577845215797424,
0.30110588669776917,
-0.2995241582393646,
-0.6512048840522766,
0.03217950090765953,
0.10293329507112503,
-0.44032764434814453,
0.19042859971523285,
-0.22029827535152435,
0.7781429290771484,
-0.2862926423549652,
-0.4174381494522095,
-0.24928724765777588,
-0.657229483127594,
0.018234414979815483,
0.02754494920372963,
0.3703216016292572,
-0.3997587561607361,
0.27404123544692993,
0.5221742987632751,
-0.7243778705596924,
0.8105807304382324,
-0.1517896205186844,
0.4322933852672577,
0.6496371626853943,
0.4117501974105835,
0.4893074333667755,
-0.10710005462169647,
-0.07500141113996506,
0.3838026523590088,
0.29705721139907837,
-0.45750415325164795,
-0.7844204306602478,
0.47622647881507874,
-0.9502270221710205,
-0.6267334222793579,
-0.6877703070640564,
-0.44121024012565613,
-0.1571822613477707,
0.2767646610736847,
0.5612926483154297,
0.40247273445129395,
0.10517117381095886,
-0.2901316285133362,
0.22261027991771698,
0.3325289785861969,
0.5940130949020386,
0.32526057958602905,
-0.2827591001987457,
-0.7881479263305664,
1.084304690361023,
-0.05323975160717964,
0.21557199954986572,
0.06656840443611145,
0.4221624433994293,
-0.4164866805076599,
-0.5101401209831238,
-0.7125265598297119,
0.08846044540405273,
-0.6469380259513855,
-0.7975093126296997,
-0.77944016456604,
-0.39133551716804504,
-0.3219741880893707,
-0.294149249792099,
-0.7870628237724304,
-0.5583739280700684,
-0.12566295266151428,
-0.011767538264393806,
0.23318347334861755,
0.566119909286499,
-0.424971342086792,
0.01722579263150692,
-0.8236932158470154,
0.3206276595592499,
0.19043929874897003,
0.31088486313819885,
-0.13078519701957703,
-0.5661149621009827,
-0.17528623342514038,
0.18617306649684906,
-0.764793872833252,
-0.7817636132240295,
0.5833560228347778,
-0.05109987407922745,
0.308104008436203,
0.05069099739193916,
0.2585076689720154,
0.5157971978187561,
-0.28330856561660767,
0.8824863433837891,
0.29013529419898987,
-1.2086820602416992,
0.4721546769142151,
-0.34513166546821594,
0.09489301592111588,
0.6312859654426575,
0.41165924072265625,
-0.07647831737995148,
-0.5285438299179077,
-1.057991623878479,
-0.9476760625839233,
0.7578679323196411,
0.0403466559946537,
-0.24255578219890594,
0.08956019580364227,
0.2996441423892975,
0.37741386890411377,
0.15016379952430725,
-0.6830547451972961,
-0.007405078038573265,
-0.6740655899047852,
-0.46880224347114563,
0.42708784341812134,
-0.5025113224983215,
0.16379563510417938,
-0.30025580525398254,
0.8636143207550049,
-0.3774585425853729,
0.2117544263601303,
0.06512200832366943,
0.4516894519329071,
-0.15166886150836945,
0.2749459445476532,
-0.03080139122903347,
0.42102816700935364,
-0.0039298152551054955,
0.11707702279090881,
0.0882963091135025,
-0.2600402534008026,
0.2999305725097656,
-0.11174583435058594,
-0.20675347745418549,
-0.2919708490371704,
0.1471562385559082,
0.26818597316741943,
0.03084523230791092,
-0.3658526837825775,
0.7087032794952393,
0.23030847311019897,
-0.17580439150333405,
-0.854987621307373,
0.027971316128969193,
0.037429921329021454,
0.5356326103210449,
0.07592327147722244,
0.2763460874557495,
0.37122416496276855,
-0.5540117621421814,
0.2788994610309601,
0.3233940601348877,
-0.3265123963356018,
-0.40888944268226624,
0.5781487822532654,
0.10422501713037491,
-0.12147931009531021,
0.8070600032806396,
-0.5817914605140686,
-1.0342729091644287,
0.4438038468360901,
0.45021700859069824,
0.8718060255050659,
-0.31881728768348694,
0.4120040237903595,
0.4323831796646118,
-0.23341670632362366,
-0.2607842683792114,
0.8414716720581055,
0.009398755617439747,
-1.0485281944274902,
-0.6477234959602356,
-0.8040032982826233,
-0.47208431363105774,
-0.11493296176195145,
-0.918836772441864,
0.3109923005104065,
-0.5395309329032898,
0.052392181009054184,
0.06187266483902931,
0.2486390471458435,
-0.3665159046649933,
0.5478481650352478,
0.25301802158355713,
0.3746849298477173,
-0.9415651559829712,
0.8014419674873352,
0.7207929491996765,
-0.7911303639411926,
-1.2642970085144043,
0.09162025898694992,
-0.23869310319423676,
-0.6189478039741516,
0.5673537850379944,
0.1015382930636406,
-0.0688374936580658,
-0.12480850517749786,
-0.69074547290802,
-1.306203007698059,
0.6979901790618896,
-0.03390956670045853,
-0.19576257467269897,
0.04495292156934738,
-0.18662108480930328,
0.2842195928096771,
-0.28578099608421326,
0.2804836630821228,
0.5284119248390198,
0.383747935295105,
0.52522873878479,
-0.875336229801178,
0.22226257622241974,
-0.11294002830982208,
-0.20481492578983307,
0.36135539412498474,
-0.7984880805015564,
0.9424132704734802,
-0.24280418455600739,
-0.13500241935253143,
-0.01812913827598095,
1.3464491367340088,
0.36935457587242126,
0.30420219898223877,
0.5581556558609009,
0.735637366771698,
0.5882298350334167,
0.11292504519224167,
0.913144052028656,
-0.14346614480018616,
0.45950374007225037,
1.437971591949463,
-0.27023518085479736,
1.1728607416152954,
0.08735036849975586,
-0.1334991604089737,
1.1800397634506226,
0.5869666337966919,
0.004683033563196659,
0.8203276991844177,
-0.275803804397583,
-0.2445724457502365,
-0.7103622555732727,
0.11125005036592484,
0.06223411113023758,
0.8866921663284302,
0.32667937874794006,
-0.14716894924640656,
-0.01937944069504738,
-0.1678778976202011,
0.1724798083305359,
0.05239415168762207,
-0.56647127866745,
1.016801118850708,
-0.07418227940797806,
-1.0394649505615234,
0.5229272246360779,
-0.06468590348958969,
0.30591651797294617,
0.10509897768497467,
-0.2123986929655075,
0.026097705587744713,
0.19050925970077515,
-0.40068432688713074,
-1.1223334074020386,
0.5818367004394531,
-0.5358324646949768,
-0.5669523477554321,
-0.18354976177215576,
0.845820426940918,
-0.40077537298202515,
-0.5504716634750366,
-0.10285540670156479,
0.42355671525001526,
-0.008259055204689503,
-0.5011953115463257,
-0.7080951929092407,
-0.10956230014562607,
0.41516566276550293,
-0.14918431639671326,
0.5532729029655457,
0.7351666688919067,
-0.17659778892993927,
0.6744313836097717,
0.3719428777694702,
0.176461860537529,
-0.2554302513599396,
-0.439323753118515,
1.1343636512756348,
-0.937492847442627,
-0.7035478353500366,
-0.8245319128036499,
0.6813738346099854,
-0.22342880070209503,
0.055471163243055344,
0.6468113660812378,
0.6231331825256348,
0.3550645709037781,
0.2434028536081314,
1.2768816947937012,
-0.06897285580635071,
1.046725869178772,
-0.3618305027484894,
0.26865726709365845,
-0.37558531761169434,
-0.11900602281093597,
-0.095543771982193,
-0.5496487021446228,
0.37292101979255676,
0.5431060791015625,
-0.2813616991043091,
0.0011105707380920649,
0.975972592830658,
0.2172187715768814,
0.0010855520376935601,
0.36707770824432373,
-0.0009146329248324037,
0.17835472524166107,
0.09827941656112671,
0.30253028869628906,
0.8283947110176086,
-0.04447526857256889,
0.35822808742523193,
-0.6569180488586426,
-0.13401158154010773,
-0.3475341200828552,
-1.00645112991333,
-0.5927011966705322,
-0.7230096459388733,
-0.48232513666152954,
-0.7125230431556702,
-0.3788439929485321,
0.7519822716712952,
0.3785717487335205,
-0.5588780641555786,
0.37075677514076233,
-0.11961902678012848,
0.22715270519256592,
-0.48274797201156616,
-0.29922112822532654,
0.5426446199417114,
-0.662204384803772,
-0.39348840713500977,
0.032893482595682144,
0.33862781524658203,
-0.37593987584114075,
-0.2933041751384735,
0.4583706557750702,
0.0509604774415493,
0.05972135066986084,
0.503965437412262,
0.39914625883102417,
-0.7812114953994751,
-0.8090257048606873,
-0.24188533425331116,
-0.00023411829897668213,
0.4216119647026062,
0.5240569114685059,
-0.8962398767471313,
0.5076723694801331,
0.531493604183197,
0.26357588171958923,
0.4916423559188843,
0.7684004902839661,
0.7262488603591919,
-0.4856748878955841,
-0.34452375769615173,
0.5962585210800171,
0.3476008474826813,
0.45284244418144226,
-0.6340308785438538,
0.2928510010242462,
0.1700749546289444,
-0.9405151605606079,
-0.39182519912719727,
0.3236458897590637,
-1.0691194534301758,
-0.3860221803188324,
1.3983417749404907,
-0.41971954703330994,
-0.58277827501297,
-0.398857980966568,
-0.2015361487865448,
0.10971136391162872,
-0.32337790727615356,
0.9568042159080505,
0.3711443543434143,
-0.4864967465400696,
-0.10582856833934784,
-0.023930033668875694,
0.6275312304496765,
0.6762288212776184,
-0.7856265306472778,
0.2660609483718872,
0.6242313981056213,
0.6475644707679749,
0.23005814850330353,
0.9009395837783813,
0.03403428941965103,
0.05851740762591362,
0.12953375279903412,
0.6346747279167175,
-0.04643657058477402,
-0.4750957787036896,
0.04702746123075485,
0.4161373972892761,
0.2521798610687256,
-0.3686509430408478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00876v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00876v1
|
Word Order and World Knowledge
| 2024-03-01T08:13:48 | 2024-03-01T08:13:48 |
Qinghua Zhao, Vinit Ravishankar, Nicolas Garneau, Anders Søgaard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Word order is an important concept in natural language, and in this work, we
study how word order affects the induction of world knowledge from raw text
using language models. We use word analogies to probe for such knowledge.
Specifically, in addition to the natural word order, we first respectively
extract texts of six fixed word orders from five languages and then pretrain
the language models on these texts. Finally, we analyze the experimental
results of the fixed word orders on word analogies and show that i) certain
fixed word orders consistently outperform or underperform others, though the
specifics vary across languages, and ii) the Wov2Lex hypothesis is not hold in
pre-trained language models, and the natural word order typically yields
mediocre results. The source code will be made publicly available at
https://github.com/lshowway/probing_by_analogy.
|
[
-0.10897298157215118,
-0.7166840434074402,
0.48819857835769653,
-0.04354846850037575,
-0.2142123430967331,
-0.24039340019226074,
0.125285804271698,
-0.9438915848731995,
-0.11464100331068039,
0.3915505111217499,
-0.1807984709739685,
-0.2478284388780594,
-0.8465464115142822,
0.14181622862815857,
-0.31066274642944336,
0.7581983804702759,
0.05086522176861763,
0.05053495615720749,
-0.2406989485025406,
-0.6164764761924744,
-0.1425771862268448,
-0.420198529958725,
-0.1646246314048767,
-0.8194472193717957,
0.5753467082977295,
0.09241452813148499,
1.1860458850860596,
0.8504091501235962,
0.39331257343292236,
0.46340280771255493,
-0.1413823962211609,
0.13619835674762726,
-0.4659319221973419,
0.02028549090027809,
-0.37740641832351685,
-0.5744016766548157,
-0.2650313973426819,
0.47839751839637756,
0.2645386755466461,
0.8351671099662781,
-0.14720509946346283,
0.16689342260360718,
-0.10944818705320358,
0.5321692228317261,
-0.7359130382537842,
0.2560086250305176,
-0.8154038786888123,
-0.07691377401351929,
0.09331051260232925,
-0.14738892018795013,
-0.24243363738059998,
-0.4741950035095215,
0.7358916401863098,
-0.8224002122879028,
0.1665172427892685,
0.4410853683948517,
1.032710313796997,
-0.15308044850826263,
-0.21529674530029297,
-0.4455907642841339,
-0.6502212882041931,
0.7140640616416931,
-0.5538872480392456,
0.5681852698326111,
0.22759678959846497,
-0.0014713178388774395,
-0.4436284303665161,
-1.0647903680801392,
-1.063818097114563,
-0.0207629706710577,
-0.10250496119260788,
0.5283885598182678,
-0.06214338168501854,
0.26767832040786743,
0.28789955377578735,
0.4856148660182953,
-0.6294751167297363,
0.25663134455680847,
-0.1978921741247177,
-0.09042772650718689,
0.5568343997001648,
0.006593005266040564,
0.6877052187919617,
-0.10955676436424255,
-0.39637166261672974,
-0.35197609663009644,
-0.7540068030357361,
0.16416984796524048,
0.2975725829601288,
0.0668821707367897,
0.09176046401262283,
0.7951385974884033,
-0.25099071860313416,
0.915937066078186,
-0.3440050780773163,
-0.3828614056110382,
0.3018595576286316,
-0.22662688791751862,
-0.24477891623973846,
0.14612208306789398,
0.7847407460212708,
0.6251020431518555,
0.3104831874370575,
-0.3478846251964569,
-0.24411797523498535,
0.32455119490623474,
0.02974986471235752,
-0.6989821195602417,
0.08649113029241562,
-0.02562892436981201,
-0.2683204710483551,
-0.2523044943809509,
0.4816320240497589,
-0.40685224533081055,
-0.3916434943675995,
-0.38723868131637573,
0.9018319249153137,
-0.40572041273117065,
-0.24749228358268738,
0.13650093972682953,
-0.6826719045639038,
0.38872748613357544,
0.10935474932193756,
-0.9622907638549805,
0.3792995810508728,
0.8421906232833862,
0.4708947241306305,
-0.15639623999595642,
-0.7765584588050842,
-0.24021276831626892,
0.02540588565170765,
-0.6408224701881409,
0.8549600839614868,
-0.5643835663795471,
-0.44624918699264526,
0.24423757195472717,
0.03652447834610939,
0.10459454357624054,
-0.6686243414878845,
0.5353558659553528,
-0.6609700918197632,
0.5823166370391846,
-0.18190082907676697,
-0.9111170172691345,
-0.19764041900634766,
0.07978959381580353,
-0.29316967725753784,
1.1478550434112549,
-0.09484422206878662,
-1.0438932180404663,
0.4819329082965851,
-0.4676128923892975,
-0.4789568781852722,
0.006236986257135868,
0.007604388054460287,
0.30491235852241516,
0.3615364730358124,
-0.048105448484420776,
0.458484947681427,
-0.25140371918678284,
-0.1408851146697998,
-0.23499983549118042,
-0.6077445149421692,
0.2962976396083832,
-0.004183056298643351,
0.5753270387649536,
0.11003340780735016,
-0.21564747393131256,
-0.15413080155849457,
-0.7449422478675842,
0.2997390329837799,
0.3662404417991638,
-0.19832034409046173,
-1.0730512142181396,
0.1498059183359146,
-0.2978041172027588,
0.22094468772411346,
-0.019465668126940727,
-0.7902982234954834,
0.31246235966682434,
-1.0566761493682861,
0.33012643456459045,
0.4847438335418701,
0.12329866737127304,
0.7330510020256042,
-0.13366295397281647,
0.18085084855556488,
-0.09678825736045837,
0.14691554009914398,
0.33282896876335144,
-0.7853993773460388,
-0.65620356798172,
0.29785898327827454,
0.46150079369544983,
0.7201448082923889,
-0.8959724307060242,
0.12168526649475098,
-0.532788097858429,
-0.5484920144081116,
-0.4327389895915985,
-0.2543536424636841,
0.5343326330184937,
0.2707040309906006,
0.19286905229091644,
-0.18552574515342712,
-0.2745230197906494,
-0.8371152877807617,
-0.676998496055603,
-0.29435524344444275,
-0.21814480423927307,
-0.09248407185077667,
0.3122311234474182,
-0.2845965027809143,
0.7008582353591919,
-0.8223972916603088,
0.23256927728652954,
-0.2030649185180664,
0.5533257126808167,
0.21026651561260223,
-0.10879562795162201,
0.33222323656082153,
-0.8716485500335693,
-0.1977297067642212,
0.07892860472202301,
-0.6049497723579407,
-0.06609545648097992,
0.3365095853805542,
-0.486206978559494,
0.008165564388036728,
0.6657660007476807,
-0.3609010875225067,
0.48232707381248474,
0.6303426027297974,
-0.19568362832069397,
0.3669862449169159,
-0.5538504719734192,
-0.1813042163848877,
-1.4233072996139526,
-0.29430335760116577,
-0.19555087387561798,
0.0932564064860344,
-0.8223710060119629,
0.26693195104599,
0.09219588339328766,
0.13434797525405884,
-0.49834710359573364,
0.6978905200958252,
-0.6498866081237793,
-0.11074309796094894,
-0.5294564366340637,
0.451577365398407,
0.17069917917251587,
0.1635947823524475,
0.18865008652210236,
0.6717358231544495,
0.08521702140569687,
-0.9305995106697083,
0.22228752076625824,
0.3594759404659271,
-0.7995700240135193,
0.12995867431163788,
-0.49487268924713135,
-0.008101698942482471,
-0.07757095992565155,
-0.21187768876552582,
-0.850489616394043,
0.12420470267534256,
-0.24006372690200806,
-0.49028295278549194,
0.20992650091648102,
0.02386556938290596,
-0.6231912970542908,
-0.45333850383758545,
-0.11469656229019165,
0.028966646641492844,
0.7337908744812012,
-0.5853008031845093,
0.13637813925743103,
0.534913182258606,
0.0704532042145729,
-0.5382862687110901,
-0.5284853577613831,
-0.35226964950561523,
0.043247416615486145,
-0.14910157024860382,
0.6407514810562134,
-0.18950369954109192,
-0.8530085682868958,
-0.17754970490932465,
-0.22193877398967743,
-0.17780251801013947,
0.01709272526204586,
0.25473812222480774,
0.17798098921775818,
-0.127311110496521,
0.16908708214759827,
-0.12026499956846237,
0.035206519067287445,
0.22439852356910706,
-0.5076572299003601,
0.21469244360923767,
0.16545870900154114,
-0.048336926847696304,
0.1637309342622757,
0.14344492554664612,
0.7668978571891785,
-0.06790876388549805,
0.8814124464988708,
0.2808758616447449,
-0.5235424637794495,
-0.16685238480567932,
-0.4467058777809143,
0.06869123131036758,
-0.5500279664993286,
0.27992257475852966,
-0.42420193552970886,
-0.3344074785709381,
0.2644036114215851,
0.009584329091012478,
0.42320653796195984,
0.46172282099723816,
0.4490099251270294,
-0.17126020789146423,
0.9969987273216248,
0.7855484485626221,
-0.005064242985099554,
0.47912898659706116,
-0.13244250416755676,
0.34378406405448914,
-0.5631718635559082,
0.024163292720913887,
-0.37247130274772644,
-0.0017516049556434155,
-0.9047388434410095,
-0.25749093294143677,
0.14050282537937164,
0.2283901423215866,
0.08252686262130737,
0.3826877176761627,
-0.22278183698654175,
0.7209867835044861,
0.43194812536239624,
-0.07533260434865952,
0.38563424348831177,
0.058692481368780136,
-0.5473716855049133,
-0.04979587346315384,
-0.7254282236099243,
-0.3968687355518341,
0.8192979693412781,
-0.14723414182662964,
0.5325692892074585,
0.06047419086098671,
0.656310498714447,
-0.016335047781467438,
0.32994040846824646,
-1.0856668949127197,
0.46181073784828186,
-0.12611167132854462,
-0.47582733631134033,
-0.32322564721107483,
0.006312007084488869,
-1.2735328674316406,
0.6307224035263062,
-0.30556461215019226,
-0.5929020643234253,
-0.05982131510972977,
-0.14673618972301483,
-0.10484208166599274,
0.01802693121135235,
-0.8825284838676453,
0.511233925819397,
-0.07832668721675873,
-0.24562019109725952,
-0.0595138855278492,
-0.6543329954147339,
0.21634069085121155,
0.26489588618278503,
0.44100290536880493,
-0.15402695536613464,
0.16262920200824738,
0.9743380546569824,
-0.6853123903274536,
0.43021029233932495,
0.07037964463233948,
-0.35634517669677734,
0.5201887488365173,
0.1441296637058258,
0.48111268877983093,
-0.31164032220840454,
-0.2072564959526062,
0.005976132582873106,
0.28401196002960205,
-0.45685720443725586,
-0.672939658164978,
0.5860186219215393,
-0.8282459378242493,
-0.6019981503486633,
-0.6105904579162598,
-0.7030534744262695,
-0.39037901163101196,
0.35486751794815063,
0.8123452663421631,
0.7661599516868591,
-0.2744288742542267,
-0.3064446449279785,
0.5366792678833008,
-0.04570909962058067,
0.6403039693832397,
0.5868039131164551,
-0.3310399353504181,
-0.10525186359882355,
0.9628538489341736,
0.5654054284095764,
0.5582913160324097,
0.8023931980133057,
0.6222397089004517,
-0.43129968643188477,
-0.5073397755622864,
-0.29159119725227356,
0.0755777582526207,
-0.7936373353004456,
0.15066426992416382,
-0.5740622282028198,
-0.22704996168613434,
-0.4491073787212372,
-0.022521838545799255,
-0.24868999421596527,
-0.4383641481399536,
0.1438388079404831,
-0.2228853702545166,
0.4412022531032562,
1.1643598079681396,
0.25218310952186584,
0.1012868657708168,
-0.8205547332763672,
0.6068013906478882,
0.6204913854598999,
0.24041658639907837,
-0.12160208076238632,
-0.6451566815376282,
0.0337410494685173,
0.17549532651901245,
-0.16230899095535278,
-0.9304929971694946,
0.3377113938331604,
0.2075507938861847,
0.7934361100196838,
0.6838787198066711,
0.1994543969631195,
0.864227294921875,
-0.8864330649375916,
0.7280281186103821,
0.24071896076202393,
-0.8498361110687256,
0.30486324429512024,
-0.4015819728374481,
0.4840693473815918,
0.3853405714035034,
0.41124585270881653,
-0.8379800915718079,
-0.5112274885177612,
-0.7883706092834473,
-0.8068888187408447,
0.45643770694732666,
0.15870438516139984,
0.1899665892124176,
-0.10063665360212326,
0.4231817424297333,
0.36818844079971313,
0.023177849128842354,
-0.7392397522926331,
-0.3601164221763611,
-0.18085725605487823,
-0.10623113065958023,
-0.07424265891313553,
-0.23285062611103058,
0.10258770734071732,
-0.4063597321510315,
0.5916517376899719,
-0.08362171798944473,
0.3832404613494873,
0.14711353182792664,
-0.46858710050582886,
0.10114218294620514,
0.3396192193031311,
0.5625526905059814,
1.1239045858383179,
0.06797824054956436,
0.38983458280563354,
0.33023303747177124,
-0.7601592540740967,
0.1084931343793869,
-0.11163634806871414,
-0.11419577151536942,
0.058828264474868774,
0.6123592257499695,
0.5301384329795837,
0.36477261781692505,
-0.5131739974021912,
0.46250829100608826,
-0.22287432849407196,
-0.2756301760673523,
-0.014452914707362652,
0.1556229293346405,
0.23525775969028473,
0.032118819653987885,
0.09925483912229538,
-0.4089808762073517,
0.08658783882856369,
-0.8521009683609009,
0.010512311942875385,
0.32215937972068787,
-0.26300475001335144,
-0.562253475189209,
0.24431779980659485,
-0.13953065872192383,
-0.4512738585472107,
0.5336017608642578,
-0.31454434990882874,
-0.813035249710083,
0.46859562397003174,
0.8137983679771423,
0.3932785093784332,
-0.23175376653671265,
0.017588211223483086,
0.260310560464859,
0.2981169819831848,
-0.20361384749412537,
0.6218871474266052,
0.26692384481430054,
-1.0614243745803833,
-0.16136901080608368,
-0.8594037890434265,
-0.4245333969593048,
0.20140916109085083,
-0.7950173616409302,
0.17228691279888153,
-0.33615684509277344,
0.11264084279537201,
0.05779494717717171,
-0.1150306910276413,
-0.6961061954498291,
0.2251807600259781,
0.14701953530311584,
0.8532207608222961,
-0.9664826989173889,
1.0222660303115845,
0.9031646847724915,
-0.1600986123085022,
-0.8938038349151611,
0.40856343507766724,
-0.14911264181137085,
-1.0935883522033691,
0.5675698518753052,
0.37550339102745056,
-0.13735446333885193,
0.1976071149110794,
-0.4241606891155243,
-1.0107446908950806,
0.9311244487762451,
-0.18913806974887848,
-0.18327896296977997,
0.21367602050304413,
0.08257735520601273,
0.7698084115982056,
-0.07516893744468689,
0.18814057111740112,
0.41142916679382324,
0.3128945529460907,
-0.05477491766214371,
-0.6810195446014404,
-0.16102786362171173,
-0.25745898485183716,
0.17866151034832,
0.46946683526039124,
-0.25917673110961914,
0.37881118059158325,
-0.31896981596946716,
-0.3687874674797058,
0.08730251342058182,
0.8333330154418945,
-0.06579730659723282,
0.11337573826313019,
0.5984794497489929,
0.6597405672073364,
0.5905938744544983,
-0.10482051968574524,
1.1046897172927856,
-0.14875496923923492,
0.128793403506279,
0.9667614102363586,
-0.4175167381763458,
0.967449963092804,
0.6284054517745972,
-0.4539790153503418,
0.543854832649231,
0.8988717198371887,
0.331402063369751,
0.742296576499939,
0.34463632106781006,
0.03914747014641762,
0.05664212629199028,
-0.07624704390764236,
-0.421206533908844,
0.523633599281311,
0.39747536182403564,
-0.05340281128883362,
-0.055523913353681564,
-0.08208025991916656,
0.07220671325922012,
0.07012635469436646,
-0.21833190321922302,
1.0680456161499023,
0.1393103152513504,
-1.061000943183899,
0.7799607515335083,
0.04589694365859032,
0.524968147277832,
-0.6418082118034363,
-0.10277600586414337,
-0.2874155044555664,
0.24329739809036255,
0.1793936938047409,
-0.5240113139152527,
0.09365224838256836,
-0.2499350756406784,
-0.21089749038219452,
-0.07683710008859634,
0.5185475945472717,
-0.32270097732543945,
-0.5083814859390259,
0.5422889590263367,
0.6660721302032471,
0.14598481357097626,
0.20532254874706268,
-0.5142480731010437,
-0.5005361437797546,
-0.45033568143844604,
-0.5275932550430298,
0.38552209734916687,
0.5348032116889954,
-0.18470583856105804,
0.2025749832391739,
0.683724045753479,
0.04314757511019707,
0.308704674243927,
-0.00597181124612689,
0.3754155933856964,
-0.4712710976600647,
-0.5620783567428589,
-0.8513332009315491,
0.07714708894491196,
-0.04780539125204086,
-0.33813750743865967,
0.7648090124130249,
0.3330414891242981,
0.9141907095909119,
-0.030439205467700958,
0.6208087205886841,
-0.15233244001865387,
0.3201774060726166,
-0.5815780162811279,
0.6796299815177917,
-0.5964158177375793,
-0.2540166676044464,
-0.3819282352924347,
-1.0511418581008911,
-0.15126103162765503,
0.3486505150794983,
-0.31083962321281433,
-0.48857229948043823,
1.1396468877792358,
0.6569329500198364,
-0.1617743968963623,
0.3242112100124359,
0.5481768250465393,
0.4293614327907562,
-0.04851025715470314,
-0.02683344855904579,
0.8746681213378906,
-0.634319543838501,
0.3324578106403351,
-0.4773172438144684,
-0.17692266404628754,
0.2055063545703888,
-0.8805360794067383,
-0.8177997469902039,
-0.5815380811691284,
-0.030529843643307686,
-0.4794876277446747,
0.07657230645418167,
0.9738949537277222,
0.3785495162010193,
-0.6343067288398743,
-0.17986220121383667,
-0.3365464508533478,
0.22039934992790222,
-0.41015225648880005,
-0.14219921827316284,
0.3743317425251007,
-0.08709690719842911,
-0.8155789971351624,
0.4534466862678528,
-0.04790736362338066,
0.26257017254829407,
0.19855423271656036,
0.053774360567331314,
-0.41932186484336853,
0.32703784108161926,
0.9846982955932617,
0.1083013117313385,
-0.9507128596305847,
-0.48439329862594604,
0.03387889638543129,
-0.2611229717731476,
0.02574518881738186,
0.6652860641479492,
-0.5930353999137878,
0.47756627202033997,
0.9161125421524048,
0.28659024834632874,
0.07784091681241989,
-0.1123168095946312,
0.6941467523574829,
-0.6482082009315491,
0.4984873831272125,
-0.2850560247898102,
0.5045443773269653,
0.025125935673713684,
-0.2754753828048706,
0.4390404224395752,
0.5259697437286377,
-0.27973493933677673,
-0.5508317947387695,
0.443692684173584,
-0.5463933944702148,
-0.5685992240905762,
1.365487813949585,
-0.08104175329208374,
-0.3676967918872833,
-0.137112095952034,
-0.062246281653642654,
0.4963582158088684,
0.16051951050758362,
0.6997798085212708,
0.8966607451438904,
-0.07007300108671188,
0.36606577038764954,
-0.7127540111541748,
0.4733506739139557,
0.4037182927131653,
-0.6453496217727661,
-0.00634363666176796,
0.1741645336151123,
0.37034910917282104,
0.20128048956394196,
0.2988460659980774,
-0.05267411470413208,
-0.06015530973672867,
-0.08562099933624268,
0.21564939618110657,
0.30791622400283813,
-0.09351994842290878,
-0.06058230623602867,
0.029681235551834106,
0.21813037991523743,
-0.24757620692253113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00338v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00338v1
|
Semi-Instruct: Bridging Natural-Instruct and Self-Instruct for Code Large Language Models
| 2024-03-01T08:05:44 | 2024-03-01T08:05:44 |
Xianzhen Luo, Qingfu Zhu, Zhiming Zhang, Xu Wang, Qing Yang, Dongliang Xu, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning plays a pivotal role in Code Large Language Models (Code
LLMs) for the task of program synthesis. Presently, two dominant paradigms for
collecting tuning data are natural-instruct (human-written) and self-instruct
(automatically generated). Natural-instruct includes diverse and correct codes
but lacks instruction-code pairs, and exists improper code formats like nested
single-line codes. In contrast, self-instruct automatically generates proper
paired data. However, it suffers from low diversity due to generating
duplicates and cannot ensure the correctness of codes. To bridge the both
paradigms, we propose \textbf{Semi-Instruct}. It first converts diverse but
improper codes from natural-instruct into proper instruction-code pairs through
a method similar to self-instruct. To verify the correctness of generated
codes, we design a novel way to construct test cases by generating cases'
inputs and executing correct codes from natural-instruct to get outputs.
Finally, diverse and correct instruction-code pairs are retained for
instruction tuning. Experiments show that semi-instruct is significantly better
than natural-instruct and self-instruct. Furthermore, the performance steadily
improves as data scale increases.
|
[
-0.34297388792037964,
-0.9453607201576233,
0.20901954174041748,
0.16150076687335968,
-0.11195926368236542,
0.3384549915790558,
-0.44738683104515076,
-0.4172458350658417,
-0.07306970655918121,
0.5366367697715759,
-0.5348233580589294,
-0.5086237788200378,
0.12363816797733307,
0.1917782872915268,
-0.4474140703678131,
1.061358094215393,
0.09585323929786682,
0.11775626987218857,
-0.35280776023864746,
0.15920819342136383,
-0.554819643497467,
-0.3991391956806183,
-0.39695510268211365,
-0.07651853561401367,
-0.18994882702827454,
0.6355374455451965,
0.49531763792037964,
0.8355484008789062,
0.05615038052201271,
0.3867114186286926,
0.3416164517402649,
0.3980986773967743,
-0.5036575198173523,
0.050021231174468994,
0.01294388435781002,
-0.6241269111633301,
-0.2696089446544647,
0.11546950042247772,
0.7643922567367554,
0.4267616868019104,
-0.3271271884441376,
0.37157145142555237,
0.11827981472015381,
0.6846248507499695,
-0.41003382205963135,
-0.06129802018404007,
-0.5392063856124878,
0.0500151626765728,
-0.21387827396392822,
-0.5856735110282898,
-0.6050618290901184,
-0.5940485596656799,
-0.23724877834320068,
-0.29326456785202026,
0.5580771565437317,
0.32539162039756775,
0.6308783888816833,
0.3972245454788208,
-0.4970700442790985,
-0.18337160348892212,
-0.957943856716156,
0.6265664100646973,
-0.9672061204910278,
0.2441299557685852,
0.179000586271286,
0.25099316239356995,
-0.4267278015613556,
-0.5833816528320312,
-0.37507250905036926,
-0.2794407308101654,
0.03138319402933121,
0.07236569374799728,
0.14885999262332916,
0.18688641488552094,
0.2826724946498871,
0.8992180228233337,
-0.5550106167793274,
0.3926120400428772,
-0.44404658675193787,
-0.5398162603378296,
0.9281426072120667,
0.2152605950832367,
0.5994106531143188,
-0.013754493556916714,
-0.24702444672584534,
0.1422259360551834,
-1.1727138757705688,
-0.06606495380401611,
0.6763694882392883,
0.3807966411113739,
-0.3135935962200165,
0.5388311147689819,
-0.058720897883176804,
1.084722876548767,
0.39100080728530884,
-0.12206144630908966,
0.1369553953409195,
-0.615990400314331,
-0.29783985018730164,
0.4161607027053833,
0.7026727795600891,
0.30456316471099854,
0.3121420741081238,
-0.2504813075065613,
-0.24792736768722534,
0.17113995552062988,
0.26605021953582764,
-0.7091427445411682,
-0.35635408759117126,
-0.09653341770172119,
-0.36639830470085144,
-0.3397967517375946,
0.02997458167374134,
-0.8922098875045776,
-0.05565711110830307,
-0.662413477897644,
0.49488553404808044,
-0.1255750209093094,
-0.04139265418052673,
0.27628278732299805,
0.14090164005756378,
0.4283504784107208,
-0.11619319766759872,
-1.0552136898040771,
0.27201133966445923,
0.3713371157646179,
0.5827194452285767,
-0.01333653461188078,
-0.21746057271957397,
-0.7335731387138367,
0.19371621310710907,
-0.49819478392601013,
0.6599831581115723,
-0.607124924659729,
-0.5100440382957458,
0.03894834965467453,
-0.019733579829335213,
0.010638970881700516,
-0.8021584749221802,
0.37302011251449585,
-0.44103315472602844,
0.38518741726875305,
0.10386614501476288,
-0.9189322590827942,
0.30654796957969666,
-0.037364766001701355,
-0.31868669390678406,
1.3362057209014893,
0.2624431252479553,
-0.488536536693573,
0.2239750772714615,
-0.5764039158821106,
-1.0582013130187988,
0.10443376004695892,
-0.2190113663673401,
-0.5875385999679565,
0.1691635400056839,
0.23718629777431488,
0.41683530807495117,
-0.20228229463100433,
0.014612684026360512,
-0.32207855582237244,
-0.4775872528553009,
-0.05485476925969124,
-0.27667251229286194,
0.7145693302154541,
0.005685117561370134,
-0.5577041506767273,
-0.05839853733778,
-0.8508698344230652,
0.19728870689868927,
0.08105462044477463,
-0.5636749863624573,
-0.35476675629615784,
0.01703941822052002,
-0.3514241576194763,
-0.006946458946913481,
0.22517983615398407,
-0.5417335629463196,
0.45983052253723145,
-0.7569913864135742,
0.6215600967407227,
0.7679072618484497,
0.19867441058158875,
0.8508148789405823,
-0.10637465119361877,
0.5472540855407715,
-0.280157208442688,
0.3077712953090668,
-0.054776959121227264,
-0.2091161459684372,
-0.8365758061408997,
-0.11900164932012558,
0.42863959074020386,
0.4929952621459961,
-0.8266748785972595,
0.4272269010543823,
0.21305719017982483,
-0.3383534550666809,
-0.6031016707420349,
0.4346863627433777,
0.5506551861763,
0.47574320435523987,
0.29451799392700195,
-0.06436546891927719,
-0.7027238011360168,
-0.9152235984802246,
-0.07151979207992554,
0.06992010027170181,
0.12935273349285126,
0.0395825020968914,
0.3186931014060974,
-0.1454434096813202,
0.640623152256012,
-0.444149374961853,
0.014108551666140556,
-0.14031565189361572,
0.22386080026626587,
0.09127314388751984,
0.6479998230934143,
0.4106792211532593,
-0.41854628920555115,
-0.5736004710197449,
-0.048526398837566376,
-0.5538217425346375,
-0.0834372416138649,
-0.2860216796398163,
-0.43671295046806335,
0.49114280939102173,
0.67054682970047,
0.0362599715590477,
0.36314284801483154,
0.597054123878479,
-0.11520235985517502,
0.6013101935386658,
-0.5780450701713562,
0.15049117803573608,
-0.9689568877220154,
-0.3750697076320648,
-0.10909532010555267,
-0.249203622341156,
-0.5223627090454102,
0.010862533003091812,
0.30939561128616333,
0.08828182518482208,
-0.08755428344011307,
0.08043290674686432,
-0.9046685695648193,
-0.19761602580547333,
-0.09040068089962006,
-0.3904150128364563,
-0.21385733783245087,
0.41921958327293396,
-0.2380090355873108,
1.273607611656189,
0.7111945152282715,
-0.9692510962486267,
0.30317607522010803,
0.012526901438832283,
-0.5568446516990662,
0.3751140534877777,
-0.6969447135925293,
0.39963313937187195,
0.13282226026058197,
-0.048344213515520096,
-0.721977949142456,
-0.19840562343597412,
-0.011677342467010021,
-0.16669557988643646,
0.7051172852516174,
-0.5063042640686035,
-0.7794731855392456,
-0.3810749351978302,
-0.0976790264248848,
0.40722665190696716,
0.6868842840194702,
-0.7276214957237244,
0.28310737013816833,
0.44553881883621216,
0.13956540822982788,
-0.1323949247598648,
-0.5886024832725525,
-0.014520173892378807,
-0.1511491984128952,
-0.46913594007492065,
0.372996985912323,
-0.33145105838775635,
0.2194031924009323,
-0.1036437600851059,
-0.2502821385860443,
-0.027582233771681786,
0.004903668537735939,
0.18772311508655548,
0.5735816955566406,
-0.36264199018478394,
0.20229193568229675,
0.4387592673301697,
-0.10904834419488907,
0.16500301659107208,
-0.4988625645637512,
0.4734712243080139,
-0.18155860900878906,
-0.5331767201423645,
-0.19453996419906616,
0.2856086194515228,
0.44787776470184326,
-0.7121301889419556,
0.39702075719833374,
0.28301405906677246,
-0.10766709595918655,
-0.9963966608047485,
-0.4960820972919464,
-0.32018589973449707,
-0.5552473664283752,
0.03424372151494026,
-0.15005989372730255,
-1.0272319316864014,
0.17587170004844666,
-0.2617260813713074,
0.31544652581214905,
0.15604017674922943,
0.7557718753814697,
-0.31932079792022705,
1.041756510734558,
0.6318393349647522,
-0.021999316290020943,
0.47957703471183777,
-0.31588199734687805,
0.46091988682746887,
-0.5787144899368286,
-0.10335391759872437,
-0.4504856467247009,
-0.17065691947937012,
-0.6944518685340881,
-0.3212658166885376,
0.6338766813278198,
-0.32865384221076965,
-0.15379036962985992,
0.2069532573223114,
-0.7797038555145264,
0.7391776442527771,
0.7671836018562317,
0.16481445729732513,
0.15698207914829254,
0.04329751059412956,
-0.08041662722826004,
0.03252900764346123,
-0.8685756325721741,
-0.42453140020370483,
1.117957592010498,
-0.033486396074295044,
1.0513365268707275,
-0.08949790149927139,
1.1585114002227783,
0.3705705404281616,
-0.09098974615335464,
-0.5935394763946533,
0.4458794593811035,
-0.14865443110466003,
-0.7594294548034668,
-0.15283699333667755,
-0.5468740463256836,
-0.8423910737037659,
-0.2898854613304138,
-0.16679950058460236,
-0.34858888387680054,
-0.07416951656341553,
0.6446730494499207,
-0.5345494747161865,
0.19754061102867126,
-1.0304155349731445,
1.0431376695632935,
-0.5045222043991089,
-0.5397005081176758,
-0.2677728235721588,
-0.68324875831604,
0.4995855987071991,
0.18660765886306763,
0.06556610018014908,
0.2759791612625122,
0.3240759074687958,
0.6483288407325745,
-0.1890418529510498,
1.1327310800552368,
0.03165009245276451,
-0.20763805508613586,
0.5096662640571594,
0.4675356149673462,
0.4645857512950897,
0.26242682337760925,
0.043811388313770294,
-0.33621159195899963,
0.23406122624874115,
-0.3456859588623047,
-0.6992042660713196,
0.6817042231559753,
-0.7793263792991638,
-0.5416662096977234,
-0.16805694997310638,
-0.44446152448654175,
-0.2924697995185852,
0.21591481566429138,
0.30549609661102295,
0.9837994575500488,
-0.07787586003541946,
-0.04841112717986107,
1.0460872650146484,
-0.22516386210918427,
0.3419989347457886,
0.531805694103241,
-0.015301255509257317,
-0.17891938984394073,
1.134333848953247,
-0.024882497265934944,
0.5932585597038269,
0.4408073425292969,
0.22079360485076904,
-0.16940854489803314,
-0.5951336026191711,
-0.6468793749809265,
0.15728002786636353,
-0.4435727596282959,
-0.34704914689064026,
0.03823568671941757,
-0.42763659358024597,
-0.17758242785930634,
-0.1166827455163002,
-0.6390609741210938,
-0.07720678299665451,
-0.1151353269815445,
-0.051053475588560104,
0.1663118451833725,
0.7405442595481873,
-0.12752975523471832,
-0.08852125704288483,
-0.9240567684173584,
0.40608179569244385,
0.4520503878593445,
0.4422604441642761,
-0.23923400044441223,
-0.5036147832870483,
-0.508674144744873,
0.2052365392446518,
-0.09170158952474594,
-0.8983179330825806,
0.15558843314647675,
0.26020151376724243,
0.5891340970993042,
0.3596609830856323,
0.4379841685295105,
0.6083939671516418,
-0.6748403906822205,
0.5161958336830139,
-0.07278219610452652,
-1.0002660751342773,
0.7884414792060852,
-0.07903507351875305,
0.350021630525589,
0.6656824350357056,
-0.0015833195066079497,
-0.3268992006778717,
-0.5888252854347229,
-0.5221512317657471,
-0.6037294268608093,
0.6816340088844299,
0.10446548461914062,
0.183897465467453,
0.0682867094874382,
0.26675429940223694,
0.36544397473335266,
0.05127715319395065,
-0.40679389238357544,
-0.3144001066684723,
-0.09692610055208206,
-0.2674751877784729,
-0.014126955531537533,
-0.2225860208272934,
-0.19210727512836456,
-0.523659348487854,
0.626986563205719,
-0.16356904804706573,
0.41119876503944397,
0.05107194557785988,
-0.12693803012371063,
-0.22156964242458344,
0.165498748421669,
0.5050040483474731,
0.4994012415409088,
-0.12425979226827621,
0.2884865403175354,
0.11192654073238373,
-0.13392886519432068,
0.12020359933376312,
-0.26623308658599854,
-0.42090904712677,
-0.25553077459335327,
0.39128828048706055,
0.706928014755249,
0.5417546033859253,
-0.42592647671699524,
0.16902926564216614,
0.019266434013843536,
-0.09457089006900787,
-0.26212960481643677,
0.48798954486846924,
0.08481816202402115,
0.03838631883263588,
-0.12742415070533752,
0.040707625448703766,
0.2133447527885437,
-0.6419625282287598,
0.19490313529968262,
0.4303396940231323,
0.05211197957396507,
-0.3883999288082123,
0.35268503427505493,
0.5948185324668884,
-0.361764520406723,
0.9857490658760071,
-0.5286323428153992,
-0.5136879086494446,
0.7163599729537964,
0.8490921258926392,
0.7079078555107117,
-0.11854349076747894,
0.32101869583129883,
0.6104157567024231,
0.43154892325401306,
0.011740043759346008,
0.3612791895866394,
-0.3331005275249481,
-0.633506178855896,
-0.5653614401817322,
-0.5714945197105408,
-0.21787309646606445,
-0.07840191572904587,
-0.7597036361694336,
0.15962499380111694,
-0.5433390140533447,
0.2745540142059326,
-0.16469812393188477,
-0.03654933348298073,
-0.4805207848548889,
0.06064445897936821,
0.21573984622955322,
0.7953216433525085,
-0.9499367475509644,
0.9311721920967102,
0.8555985689163208,
-0.19232724606990814,
-1.0602285861968994,
0.0015288341091945767,
-0.02657587081193924,
-0.696474015712738,
0.10025317221879959,
0.04419434443116188,
-0.1627110242843628,
0.26244014501571655,
-0.7741723656654358,
-0.5644188523292542,
0.8094940781593323,
0.4380073547363281,
-0.6870478391647339,
0.17229537665843964,
0.033202607184648514,
0.5066315531730652,
-0.24623294174671173,
-0.01651296392083168,
0.6071303486824036,
0.364132821559906,
0.09737180918455124,
-0.8637651205062866,
-0.030223941430449486,
-0.21438810229301453,
-0.09047218412160873,
0.616527795791626,
-0.634541928768158,
0.41241955757141113,
-0.35837340354919434,
-0.5474264025688171,
-0.03702438995242119,
0.6939990520477295,
-0.008652770891785622,
0.30664342641830444,
0.47810274362564087,
0.37547504901885986,
0.6995105743408203,
0.04807310178875923,
0.9540984034538269,
-0.5281199216842651,
0.3260705769062042,
1.2109884023666382,
-0.10866641998291016,
0.533955454826355,
0.4019618034362793,
-0.4127066731452942,
0.4026339054107666,
0.7790107131004333,
-0.2410990595817566,
0.45335355401039124,
0.1937737911939621,
-0.08630900830030441,
-0.5921412110328674,
0.31374865770339966,
-0.4123387634754181,
0.5134231448173523,
0.05801524221897125,
-0.08089473843574524,
-0.1993330866098404,
-0.29442527890205383,
-0.12284759432077408,
0.3483821451663971,
-0.16639935970306396,
0.783917248249054,
-0.059557925909757614,
-0.9093790054321289,
0.7252103686332703,
0.026562968268990517,
0.5335359573364258,
-0.6886241436004639,
-0.20909151434898376,
-0.369044691324234,
0.11241544038057327,
-0.337373286485672,
-0.6713215112686157,
0.30642327666282654,
-0.12802237272262573,
-0.22857455909252167,
-0.21188586950302124,
0.5439940690994263,
-0.6194642782211304,
-0.6696535348892212,
-0.04732907563447952,
0.2623659670352936,
-0.053442105650901794,
0.4108474552631378,
-0.5563814640045166,
-0.17895743250846863,
0.2370501607656479,
0.08024080842733383,
0.3389086127281189,
0.4140574336051941,
-0.045034170150756836,
0.5496407747268677,
0.6376198530197144,
0.047753654420375824,
0.4737361967563629,
0.18037964403629303,
0.7382603883743286,
-0.5015972852706909,
-0.47237709164619446,
-0.8436504006385803,
0.4142017960548401,
-0.13143646717071533,
-0.34664419293403625,
0.7653339505195618,
0.8358539938926697,
0.9809162616729736,
-0.35332706570625305,
0.6395116448402405,
-0.2784459590911865,
0.13874128460884094,
-0.8803271651268005,
0.3927949368953705,
-0.45843908190727234,
0.24400228261947632,
0.007639170624315739,
-0.7260745763778687,
-0.08209773153066635,
0.43855106830596924,
-0.23964333534240723,
0.06578806042671204,
0.5994399785995483,
1.31715989112854,
-0.3493324816226959,
0.02290371246635914,
0.11926521360874176,
0.17977459728717804,
0.13668550550937653,
0.6977288722991943,
0.9276828169822693,
-0.17236292362213135,
0.3588331937789917,
-0.5495244860649109,
-0.38155826926231384,
-0.05043848976492882,
-0.8027786016464233,
-1.1756268739700317,
-0.524878740310669,
-0.5955151319503784,
-0.14398691058158875,
-0.10203813016414642,
1.0412665605545044,
0.8691630959510803,
-0.8765369057655334,
-0.4024066925048828,
-0.29209014773368835,
0.2504962980747223,
-0.34458646178245544,
-0.19614781439304352,
0.18630659580230713,
-0.5954931378364563,
-0.7592038512229919,
0.6205112338066101,
0.5535420775413513,
0.06600549817085266,
-0.416847825050354,
-0.24862006306648254,
-0.10673952102661133,
0.04832569137215614,
0.3938545286655426,
0.47900763154029846,
-0.3665158748626709,
-0.07024609297513962,
-0.025310562923550606,
-0.14002792537212372,
0.06143911927938461,
0.9441846013069153,
-0.666391909122467,
0.6712283492088318,
0.2988051176071167,
0.8134990930557251,
0.451202929019928,
-0.17478488385677338,
0.8782139420509338,
-0.7970075011253357,
-0.13450025022029877,
0.16864189505577087,
0.1845700889825821,
0.23729351162910461,
-0.5516526103019714,
0.43970173597335815,
0.04599922522902489,
-0.6348706483840942,
-0.9804307818412781,
0.4846281409263611,
-0.805728018283844,
-0.018233569338917732,
1.0130290985107422,
0.17343538999557495,
-0.34635016322135925,
0.14939457178115845,
-0.3124730587005615,
0.45302921533584595,
-0.17191006243228912,
0.9544138312339783,
0.28063255548477173,
-0.1320543885231018,
-0.027012422680854797,
-0.5679247975349426,
0.4301021695137024,
0.3743877708911896,
-0.8873997926712036,
-0.013660015538334846,
0.5068790316581726,
0.36315518617630005,
-0.3152347505092621,
0.10158887505531311,
0.048453811556100845,
0.40983906388282776,
-0.028856953606009483,
0.20952969789505005,
-0.3524783253669739,
-0.31093302369117737,
-0.07367584854364395,
-0.06860999017953873,
0.1777508705854416,
-0.41418272256851196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00871v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00871v1
|
Teach LLMs to Phish: Stealing Private Information from Language Models
| 2024-03-01T06:15:07 | 2024-03-01T06:15:07 |
Ashwinee Panda, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Zhengming Zhang, Yaoqing Yang, Prateek Mittal
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
When large language models are trained on private data, it can be a
significant privacy risk for them to memorize and regurgitate sensitive
information. In this work, we propose a new practical data extraction attack
that we call "neural phishing". This attack enables an adversary to target and
extract sensitive or personally identifiable information (PII), e.g., credit
card numbers, from a model trained on user data with upwards of 10% attack
success rates, at times, as high as 50%. Our attack assumes only that an
adversary can insert as few as 10s of benign-appearing sentences into the
training dataset using only vague priors on the structure of the user data.
|
[
0.07353228330612183,
-0.8445745706558228,
0.3057805895805359,
-0.18774332106113434,
-0.0008566107135266066,
-0.0831340029835701,
0.0819927304983139,
-0.4126429557800293,
0.041270092129707336,
0.7259606719017029,
-0.4336633086204529,
-0.35587388277053833,
-0.5232895016670227,
-0.30100399255752563,
-0.7596216797828674,
1.1326993703842163,
0.7639304399490356,
0.2768374979496002,
0.24490754306316376,
0.5316057205200195,
0.08704816550016403,
-0.8175417184829712,
-0.6571858525276184,
-0.0473250187933445,
0.867253839969635,
0.5530647039413452,
0.5966622829437256,
0.6793185472488403,
0.7390733361244202,
0.2674972712993622,
0.15401695668697357,
-0.6533055305480957,
-0.5701829195022583,
0.16170254349708557,
-0.3185812532901764,
-0.8449017405509949,
-0.4111432731151581,
0.08974617719650269,
0.35201725363731384,
0.5245963335037231,
-0.06447392702102661,
0.1498332917690277,
-0.3266957700252533,
0.7788098454475403,
-0.7012009024620056,
-0.007374809123575687,
-0.9550325274467468,
0.15065224468708038,
-0.528901219367981,
-0.3304216265678406,
-0.6095584630966187,
-0.31661921739578247,
0.38269171118736267,
-0.2598227858543396,
0.18505971133708954,
0.04300496354699135,
0.5880013704299927,
-0.23833496868610382,
-0.20798549056053162,
-0.2248157113790512,
-0.5689460635185242,
0.5182305574417114,
-0.7588557004928589,
-0.014225461520254612,
0.8131510615348816,
0.3994676470756531,
-0.007157177664339542,
-0.7107462882995605,
-0.5147843360900879,
-0.19341805577278137,
0.05045362189412117,
-0.09411237388849258,
-0.3885331153869629,
0.050045523792505264,
0.5486587882041931,
0.6864516735076904,
-0.4446345567703247,
0.2727448642253876,
-0.815731406211853,
0.07218463718891144,
0.9294337630271912,
0.07602052390575409,
0.6834012269973755,
-0.27571994066238403,
-0.3986245393753052,
0.04847615584731102,
-0.8469399809837341,
0.1102742999792099,
0.8719790577888489,
0.3985520005226135,
-0.17844483256340027,
0.6968191862106323,
0.12072677165269852,
0.5191425681114197,
0.08414400368928909,
-0.19426394999027252,
-0.031463414430618286,
0.13272307813167572,
-0.520991861820221,
0.13639603555202484,
0.7037990689277649,
0.06337977945804596,
0.6817082166671753,
-0.4528961777687073,
-0.27712324261665344,
0.06649691611528397,
0.5524376630783081,
-0.6292491555213928,
-0.5823062062263489,
0.13591374456882477,
-0.43249213695526123,
-0.8347926139831543,
0.008423099294304848,
-1.3849217891693115,
-0.8370444178581238,
0.1770922988653183,
0.010376711376011372,
-0.4662702977657318,
-0.2762231230735779,
0.11035825312137604,
-0.17097152769565582,
0.4746621549129486,
-0.07747635990381241,
-1.323769450187683,
0.625482439994812,
0.854371190071106,
0.5850925445556641,
-0.2666415274143219,
-0.19595448672771454,
-0.6526216268539429,
0.17554302513599396,
-0.17012235522270203,
0.41355010867118835,
-0.5213634967803955,
-0.5090311765670776,
0.09872547537088394,
-0.07888022810220718,
-0.0835639238357544,
-0.4571613371372223,
0.1564473658800125,
-0.8135213851928711,
0.2869417369365692,
-0.05387289822101593,
-0.5544533133506775,
-0.05142923444509506,
0.17119278013706207,
-0.6424731016159058,
0.5054992437362671,
0.02025359682738781,
-0.9382358193397522,
-0.28258633613586426,
-0.37391623854637146,
-0.5558322072029114,
0.04083459824323654,
-0.2178497016429901,
-0.32333725690841675,
0.30038225650787354,
-0.15458300709724426,
0.6524600386619568,
-0.2054339200258255,
0.1651870608329773,
-0.5910214185714722,
-0.1899646371603012,
0.6873238682746887,
-0.599868893623352,
1.129010558128357,
0.22732453048229218,
-0.5864327549934387,
-0.10849446803331375,
-1.0724154710769653,
-0.28659355640411377,
0.46551385521888733,
-0.3091195523738861,
-0.5003840923309326,
-0.2973528206348419,
-0.17104487121105194,
0.08527950942516327,
-0.00728364335373044,
-0.4638718366622925,
0.15669342875480652,
-0.822192370891571,
0.39695581793785095,
1.080700397491455,
0.23685157299041748,
0.8377218246459961,
-0.5211228728294373,
0.5694295763969421,
-0.12666766345500946,
0.10684049129486084,
-0.31653204560279846,
-0.5519195199012756,
-0.541969358921051,
-0.22677607834339142,
0.14436759054660797,
0.769987940788269,
-0.29404038190841675,
0.22763650119304657,
-0.25802651047706604,
-0.5737107396125793,
-0.30741754174232483,
0.20088742673397064,
0.28674033284187317,
0.6336629390716553,
-0.019074879586696625,
-0.17946365475654602,
-0.10566848516464233,
-1.0106301307678223,
-0.5278558135032654,
0.03294924646615982,
-0.14659804105758667,
0.2151329517364502,
0.30012601613998413,
0.18543685972690582,
0.5607113242149353,
-0.40721315145492554,
-0.15307876467704773,
-0.07458840310573578,
-0.14824724197387695,
-0.0576891228556633,
0.7833563089370728,
0.3150410056114197,
-0.7292730808258057,
-0.3748827576637268,
-0.14129631221294403,
-0.7627837657928467,
0.3433743715286255,
-0.37437209486961365,
-0.025587409734725952,
-0.2748490571975708,
0.24586369097232819,
-0.7449942827224731,
0.830713152885437,
0.1748453676700592,
-0.3682911694049835,
0.33540377020835876,
-0.10981537401676178,
-0.18086354434490204,
-1.095671534538269,
-0.07315699756145477,
0.048845212906599045,
0.17410336434841156,
-1.002178430557251,
0.07557924836874008,
0.14195775985717773,
-0.521734356880188,
-0.6953918933868408,
0.42728689312934875,
-0.5714234113693237,
-0.13293179869651794,
-0.14571373164653778,
-0.03229600191116333,
-0.3263982832431793,
0.6481122970581055,
-0.31974709033966064,
0.6593054533004761,
0.8259222507476807,
-0.592900812625885,
0.4691408574581146,
0.01915964111685753,
-0.43341711163520813,
0.49808600544929504,
-0.39222750067710876,
0.7028031945228577,
0.08395189791917801,
-0.2989364266395569,
-0.9123844504356384,
-0.5267153382301331,
0.565824568271637,
-0.7540572285652161,
0.5566514134407043,
-0.06479661166667938,
-0.4695596992969513,
0.08169897645711899,
-0.3842124342918396,
0.14871332049369812,
0.5061337947845459,
-0.5480783581733704,
0.7189077138900757,
0.672408401966095,
-0.32912248373031616,
-0.6823018193244934,
-1.0824183225631714,
0.08407409489154816,
-0.4499882459640503,
-0.539147675037384,
0.3563717305660248,
0.18893787264823914,
-0.49965226650238037,
-0.1566341668367386,
-0.013098633848130703,
-0.32169756293296814,
0.46596014499664307,
0.37455978989601135,
0.19722579419612885,
-0.1697738766670227,
-0.0023320454638451338,
-0.18178337812423706,
-0.1751306802034378,
0.4663650393486023,
-0.23615460097789764,
0.674127459526062,
0.1410069614648819,
-0.526311457157135,
-1.072758436203003,
0.5648096203804016,
0.48240000009536743,
-0.15591229498386383,
0.7160038948059082,
0.05577053129673004,
-0.7161078453063965,
-0.05264579504728317,
-0.5271981358528137,
-0.6008560657501221,
-0.4893631041049957,
0.3701919615268707,
-0.14099015295505524,
-0.45692312717437744,
0.38136306405067444,
0.07049661129713058,
0.25940412282943726,
0.04782808944582939,
0.22651447355747223,
-0.11032184958457947,
0.9394922256469727,
0.8914570212364197,
-0.46425947546958923,
0.6015496850013733,
-0.1954583376646042,
0.21688072383403778,
-0.28545212745666504,
-0.5723055601119995,
-0.4842265248298645,
-0.282432496547699,
-0.5517725348472595,
0.0137315159663558,
-0.42108964920043945,
-0.03527012839913368,
-0.16422627866268158,
0.10869885981082916,
-0.1579047292470932,
0.4711449444293976,
0.7148911356925964,
0.236108660697937,
0.09778327494859695,
0.6325023174285889,
0.18049657344818115,
-0.317557692527771,
-0.26465144753456116,
-0.4483483135700226,
1.5293619632720947,
0.4419563114643097,
0.789768397808075,
0.23067565262317657,
0.6656479239463806,
0.3410693407058716,
0.32183709740638733,
-0.6704026460647583,
0.5129866003990173,
-0.04808320477604866,
-0.7279699444770813,
-0.21928779780864716,
-0.3283138871192932,
-0.9709341526031494,
-0.02159636840224266,
-0.24225342273712158,
-1.1973204612731934,
0.21566897630691528,
-0.17616692185401917,
-0.6442133784294128,
0.6758941411972046,
-0.7005669474601746,
0.5304283499717712,
-0.49355271458625793,
-0.4512293338775635,
-0.22764819860458374,
-0.665065348148346,
0.5676378011703491,
-0.30327966809272766,
0.3824932277202606,
-0.14721514284610748,
-0.048976048827171326,
0.8358832001686096,
-0.2078961282968521,
1.132442831993103,
-0.19987578690052032,
0.05726001039147377,
-0.05972063168883324,
0.17901895940303802,
0.5811407566070557,
0.17916424572467804,
-0.1794314980506897,
0.0414373017847538,
-0.401711642742157,
-0.601200520992279,
-0.99847012758255,
0.6216315627098083,
-0.6806783080101013,
-0.7774738669395447,
-0.5036616921424866,
-0.2492007166147232,
-0.2045006901025772,
0.06290493160486221,
0.2668535113334656,
0.102068692445755,
0.10225141048431396,
0.08600117266178131,
0.7258604764938354,
-0.22830483317375183,
0.41703858971595764,
0.34099844098091125,
-0.045972444117069244,
-0.6758157014846802,
1.097989559173584,
-0.04406660795211792,
0.28628894686698914,
0.19267705082893372,
0.2501518428325653,
0.05059945210814476,
-0.6083357930183411,
-0.008987554349005222,
0.5049552917480469,
-0.6811589002609253,
-0.12153377383947372,
-0.6624419093132019,
-0.42859190702438354,
-0.5743058323860168,
-0.16603419184684753,
-0.1521560251712799,
-0.447771817445755,
-0.48869192600250244,
-0.4163462817668915,
0.2429291158914566,
0.8790202736854553,
0.05410533770918846,
0.9307414293289185,
-0.746566891670227,
0.09474650770425797,
0.4314943850040436,
0.10408042371273041,
0.0467374324798584,
-0.6492394208908081,
0.1105392649769783,
-0.23540636897087097,
-0.22202861309051514,
-1.4789388179779053,
0.576072633266449,
-0.04271151125431061,
0.6946478486061096,
0.6885234117507935,
-0.10287892818450928,
0.4942053258419037,
-0.2436673641204834,
0.7316184043884277,
0.42762449383735657,
-0.7294345498085022,
0.6867493391036987,
-0.24614502489566803,
-0.06800761818885803,
0.669144868850708,
0.6226415634155273,
-0.4698142111301422,
-0.18770895898342133,
-1.098174810409546,
-0.664382815361023,
0.7748995423316956,
0.05441891774535179,
0.5027176737785339,
0.17642436921596527,
0.7271652221679688,
0.06567615270614624,
0.18719378113746643,
-1.0324914455413818,
-0.4795997738838196,
0.37767493724823,
-0.3259628713130951,
0.08928722888231277,
-0.683879017829895,
0.012650416232645512,
-0.17923392355442047,
0.4011009931564331,
0.37876102328300476,
0.2469460368156433,
-0.23616822063922882,
-0.080543652176857,
0.14341884851455688,
-0.029756421223282814,
0.30586397647857666,
0.4254726469516754,
0.24843600392341614,
0.1620701253414154,
0.0038216374814510345,
-0.722422182559967,
0.026672717183828354,
0.06297557055950165,
-0.3942483961582184,
-0.3035260736942291,
0.37044477462768555,
0.299156129360199,
0.5165786147117615,
-0.5534480214118958,
0.82484370470047,
-0.2063256949186325,
-0.2262694090604782,
-0.5716314911842346,
0.17191892862319946,
0.06342364102602005,
0.2839837968349457,
0.29467085003852844,
0.15159328281879425,
0.10226225107908249,
-0.31615111231803894,
0.6335505843162537,
0.3413362205028534,
-0.39141130447387695,
-0.6505103707313538,
0.37117570638656616,
0.03064059652388096,
-0.8896263241767883,
1.0840059518814087,
0.32280978560447693,
-0.3575427234172821,
0.43974289298057556,
0.5499263405799866,
0.7963099479675293,
-0.7423664927482605,
-0.005372251383960247,
0.16102531552314758,
0.3800835609436035,
0.07025771588087082,
0.22518107295036316,
-0.17908379435539246,
-0.3485226631164551,
0.12754656374454498,
-0.14177154004573822,
-0.1402866393327713,
0.6561347842216492,
-0.8638970851898193,
0.3497501313686371,
-1.1304868459701538,
-0.09349851310253143,
0.18225623667240143,
-0.18134482204914093,
-0.5217545032501221,
0.047591861337423325,
0.35022956132888794,
0.7372609376907349,
-0.4957539439201355,
1.0741841793060303,
0.013591310940682888,
-0.35011932253837585,
-0.6001501083374023,
-0.009053845889866352,
0.3206515908241272,
-0.8475877642631531,
0.7264264822006226,
0.2501131296157837,
0.2745839059352875,
-0.05850527063012123,
-0.6907426118850708,
-0.7890949845314026,
0.7526441216468811,
0.7515220046043396,
-0.6777342557907104,
-0.38923758268356323,
0.37653520703315735,
0.14818188548088074,
-0.3989059627056122,
-0.16861054301261902,
0.5832640528678894,
0.0747532770037651,
-0.21936829388141632,
-0.21197377145290375,
-0.2024434506893158,
-0.42457038164138794,
-0.40409180521965027,
-0.33710235357284546,
-0.18085484206676483,
1.138001561164856,
-0.21380996704101562,
-0.47066912055015564,
-0.22970524430274963,
0.7420824766159058,
0.02276003360748291,
0.28226330876350403,
0.319440633058548,
0.2921900749206543,
1.2215431928634644,
0.2653105854988098,
1.06864333152771,
-0.380535751581192,
-0.02972777746617794,
1.1835496425628662,
-0.09827110171318054,
1.0254769325256348,
0.473745197057724,
0.06493978202342987,
0.21324783563613892,
0.7663680911064148,
-0.17710646986961365,
0.7348004579544067,
0.639013409614563,
-0.3108826279640198,
0.130702942609787,
0.5281537175178528,
-0.3065568506717682,
0.539379894733429,
0.5494102835655212,
-0.7721502184867859,
-0.0880686566233635,
0.17564526200294495,
0.39497873187065125,
0.1521729677915573,
-0.09404607117176056,
0.8384513854980469,
0.3368450701236725,
-0.23356063663959503,
0.23426978290081024,
0.09443677961826324,
0.6654925346374512,
-0.651645302772522,
0.13739296793937683,
-0.30598580837249756,
0.24434131383895874,
-0.26545822620391846,
-0.08761774003505707,
0.23872463405132294,
0.313062459230423,
-0.10402368754148483,
-0.12440483272075653,
0.7728056311607361,
-0.11866874247789383,
-0.4681525230407715,
0.2951453626155853,
0.355334609746933,
0.22574855387210846,
-0.22073589265346527,
-0.9900912642478943,
-0.2768051326274872,
0.1152467206120491,
-0.4764612019062042,
0.7910894751548767,
0.16858160495758057,
0.5133129358291626,
0.829344630241394,
0.9414581060409546,
0.4657038152217865,
0.38531115651130676,
-0.10412507504224777,
0.7265524864196777,
-0.9586941599845886,
-0.6319760084152222,
-1.5119788646697998,
0.3167608976364136,
-0.6014195680618286,
-0.23886588215827942,
1.0427196025848389,
0.6885589361190796,
0.9468407034873962,
0.035821545869112015,
0.8296849131584167,
0.5383169054985046,
0.3783082365989685,
-0.3933309018611908,
0.9962600469589233,
-0.21526192128658295,
0.6637822985649109,
-0.03475584462285042,
-0.5586628913879395,
-0.28722724318504333,
0.5322798490524292,
-0.6342276334762573,
-0.14236654341220856,
0.6823382377624512,
0.8523402214050293,
0.08310007303953171,
0.4503710865974426,
0.42975303530693054,
-0.01633867435157299,
0.4759352207183838,
0.48465171456336975,
0.9869099855422974,
-0.2804213762283325,
0.4144935607910156,
-0.7254613041877747,
-0.22443291544914246,
0.028699761256575584,
-0.4394208490848541,
-1.099976897239685,
-0.33092939853668213,
-0.30150067806243896,
-0.464347243309021,
0.028267908841371536,
0.5190367698669434,
0.7230586409568787,
-0.7836176753044128,
-0.408647358417511,
-0.03677213564515114,
0.05148836225271225,
0.15509331226348877,
-0.22529108822345734,
0.34915027022361755,
-0.2569098472595215,
-0.5962448716163635,
0.44806885719299316,
0.3300219774246216,
0.37707942724227905,
-0.5851356983184814,
0.4035051167011261,
-0.23176144063472748,
0.12353647500276566,
0.009549682959914207,
0.3322787284851074,
-0.6134262084960938,
0.12832282483577728,
0.1842963546514511,
-0.39399003982543945,
0.07486086338758469,
1.1695778369903564,
-0.3231762647628784,
0.21166947484016418,
0.15340591967105865,
1.2233829498291016,
0.30715295672416687,
-0.1643996387720108,
0.5819738507270813,
-0.45983046293258667,
0.14520137012004852,
0.37604808807373047,
0.11844155937433243,
0.325735479593277,
-0.833128035068512,
0.12650719285011292,
0.5559726357460022,
-0.1295802742242813,
-1.0187592506408691,
0.1174122616648674,
-0.7644833326339722,
-0.4030403792858124,
1.117061734199524,
-0.4748525023460388,
-0.8891633152961731,
-0.2575017809867859,
0.08602588623762131,
-0.07633192837238312,
-0.32288679480552673,
0.9637380838394165,
0.5294179916381836,
0.3057107627391815,
-0.023321548476815224,
-0.7524576187133789,
0.7167472839355469,
0.17187121510505676,
-0.8686330914497375,
0.1741221696138382,
0.13253681361675262,
0.47275009751319885,
-0.011101529002189636,
0.7991600632667542,
-0.37414202094078064,
0.22041413187980652,
0.33739086985588074,
-0.34675684571266174,
-0.06403379142284393,
-0.323239266872406,
-0.7860392332077026,
0.7406671047210693,
-0.2746713161468506,
-0.2549755275249481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00292v1
|
DPP-Based Adversarial Prompt Searching for Lanugage Models
| 2024-03-01T05:28:06 | 2024-03-01T05:28:06 |
Xu Zhang, Xiaojun Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models risk generating mindless and offensive content, which hinders
their safe deployment. Therefore, it is crucial to discover and modify
potential toxic outputs of pre-trained language models before deployment. In
this work, we elicit toxic content by automatically searching for a prompt that
directs pre-trained language models towards the generation of a specific target
output. The problem is challenging due to the discrete nature of textual data
and the considerable computational resources required for a single forward pass
of the language model. To combat these challenges, we introduce Auto-regressive
Selective Replacement Ascent (ASRA), a discrete optimization algorithm that
selects prompts based on both quality and similarity with determinantal point
process (DPP). Experimental results on six different pre-trained language
models demonstrate the efficacy of ASRA for eliciting toxic content.
Furthermore, our analysis reveals a strong correlation between the success rate
of ASRA attacks and the perplexity of target outputs, while indicating limited
association with the quantity of model parameters.
|
[
-0.2787856161594391,
-0.7569367289543152,
0.5476634502410889,
0.2653583586215973,
-0.09863831847906113,
0.11910223960876465,
0.08573488891124725,
-0.11339178681373596,
-0.1825437694787979,
0.35341116786003113,
-0.8834543228149414,
-0.38447603583335876,
-0.6623679399490356,
0.1981794387102127,
-0.42673346400260925,
0.7620345950126648,
0.14207805693149567,
-0.3218643367290497,
0.38704028725624084,
0.24612195789813995,
-0.5931529402732849,
-0.5235817432403564,
-1.1334846019744873,
-0.2802353799343109,
0.8391198515892029,
0.23739293217658997,
0.7543748617172241,
0.5963878631591797,
0.16027319431304932,
0.33827897906303406,
-0.26359787583351135,
0.13431169092655182,
-0.4418514370918274,
0.3059317171573639,
-0.2668251395225525,
-0.37544500827789307,
-0.17146193981170654,
0.16870491206645966,
0.5699583888053894,
0.36370712518692017,
-0.4175277054309845,
-0.05570109561085701,
0.25066280364990234,
0.5725193619728088,
-0.6583771109580994,
-0.14279018342494965,
-0.9671921133995056,
0.039850588887929916,
-0.22398518025875092,
-0.2521574795246124,
-0.6407499313354492,
-0.4400267004966736,
0.016660936176776886,
-0.6517252326011658,
-0.027428703382611275,
-0.1892727017402649,
0.8411855697631836,
0.358967125415802,
-0.253872811794281,
-0.5277239084243774,
-0.4822898805141449,
0.802612841129303,
-0.7126570343971252,
0.024932699277997017,
0.3697538375854492,
0.29926303029060364,
-0.4515308439731598,
-0.4605620503425598,
-0.4666159749031067,
-0.40076446533203125,
0.04485974833369255,
0.023008067160844803,
-0.5852758884429932,
0.05480826273560524,
0.06789863109588623,
0.03454790636897087,
-0.7399346232414246,
0.505189061164856,
-0.026454618200659752,
-0.14103637635707855,
0.805249035358429,
0.31408631801605225,
0.5225719809532166,
-0.2972122132778168,
-0.29567721486091614,
-0.32110917568206787,
-0.764847457408905,
-0.059804342687129974,
0.7899825572967529,
0.6312836408615112,
0.2340322732925415,
0.1495000571012497,
-0.16495513916015625,
0.8056155443191528,
0.24866147339344025,
0.35773831605911255,
0.06307369470596313,
-0.06688625365495682,
-0.07276149839162827,
-0.049681276082992554,
1.1666319370269775,
-0.011645234189927578,
0.024913808330893517,
0.27943989634513855,
-0.2969095706939697,
0.14406469464302063,
0.5350425243377686,
-0.5757701992988586,
-0.4286021292209625,
0.13953790068626404,
-0.20517677068710327,
-0.7545450925827026,
-0.4342585504055023,
-0.8351696729660034,
-0.5467970371246338,
0.08775714039802551,
0.3730235993862152,
-0.5706201791763306,
-0.16656583547592163,
0.14039625227451324,
-0.03168174996972084,
-0.31922274827957153,
0.5030858516693115,
-0.7060303688049316,
-0.03231063112616539,
0.29096922278404236,
0.5632134079933167,
-0.14938269555568695,
-0.4428916871547699,
-0.7196900248527527,
-0.1705981343984604,
-0.4633970856666565,
0.8967608213424683,
-0.6577666401863098,
-0.5296670794487,
0.06597980856895447,
-0.24771645665168762,
-0.13741035759449005,
-0.5544431209564209,
0.72186279296875,
-0.8731316924095154,
0.43216121196746826,
-0.4516298174858093,
-0.01708064414560795,
-0.285854697227478,
0.326534628868103,
-0.5417200326919556,
1.0906563997268677,
-0.17913870513439178,
-0.7172632813453674,
0.11654338240623474,
-0.7368252277374268,
-0.32332324981689453,
-0.049807108938694,
-0.11309172213077545,
-0.38999101519584656,
-0.09101404994726181,
0.31147781014442444,
0.2922288179397583,
-0.3762136697769165,
0.2554761469364166,
-0.15289151668548584,
-0.245113343000412,
0.32266005873680115,
-0.6363620758056641,
0.9508218765258789,
0.5383386015892029,
-0.45409318804740906,
0.2705995440483093,
-0.6966995000839233,
-0.2145511656999588,
0.5161020755767822,
-0.307576447725296,
-0.4624241888523102,
0.18812930583953857,
-0.2293350249528885,
0.267959862947464,
0.2873697578907013,
-0.41206982731819153,
0.07872536778450012,
-0.3154853582382202,
0.04426418989896774,
1.049207329750061,
0.131827712059021,
0.24723634123802185,
-0.4330117106437683,
0.7077346444129944,
0.007439554203301668,
0.42838555574417114,
-0.05772632360458374,
-0.5231663584709167,
-0.3653081953525543,
-0.12409338355064392,
-0.14115487039089203,
0.6010177135467529,
-0.8800522685050964,
0.4054766297340393,
0.1711910516023636,
-0.737050473690033,
-0.4722259044647217,
-0.11506239324808121,
0.45653966069221497,
0.7205745577812195,
0.3691413700580597,
0.019898373633623123,
-0.5060969591140747,
-0.6090410947799683,
-0.2863801121711731,
-0.4675408899784088,
-0.09211890399456024,
0.34161612391471863,
0.055677615106105804,
-0.382229208946228,
0.6465925574302673,
-0.6829997897148132,
-0.32383063435554504,
-0.11220137774944305,
0.2866571247577667,
0.3822827637195587,
0.14773282408714294,
0.6429550647735596,
-0.5858355164527893,
-0.8441033959388733,
-0.28188762068748474,
-0.6024578809738159,
-0.6840959787368774,
-0.20556586980819702,
0.1048852875828743,
-0.03140880540013313,
0.46471431851387024,
-0.307736337184906,
0.0884632095694542,
0.5640977621078491,
-0.142168328166008,
0.6540457010269165,
-0.28813794255256653,
0.3148164451122284,
-0.6516748070716858,
0.3677842319011688,
-0.0577695369720459,
0.1101381927728653,
-0.7613969445228577,
0.29226744174957275,
-0.12275596708059311,
-0.3964519202709198,
-0.5171597003936768,
0.5565264225006104,
-0.29136598110198975,
0.3714878559112549,
-0.29196828603744507,
0.23479679226875305,
0.14814290404319763,
0.29819267988204956,
-0.11535732448101044,
0.9272536635398865,
0.44912809133529663,
-0.7343187928199768,
0.3307783901691437,
0.3840829133987427,
0.09598655998706818,
0.4431353807449341,
-0.5521814227104187,
0.13648483157157898,
-0.30453190207481384,
0.21149060130119324,
-0.9837107062339783,
0.20083624124526978,
0.40351107716560364,
-0.533599317073822,
0.18753014504909515,
-0.10086841136217117,
-0.4617874324321747,
-0.40348997712135315,
-0.2817980647087097,
0.2028721123933792,
0.5071195363998413,
-0.5624706149101257,
0.4247184097766876,
0.39354804158210754,
-0.4349503517150879,
-0.7759268283843994,
-0.3912303149700165,
0.1177324429154396,
-0.4503490924835205,
-0.2612992525100708,
0.3120526075363159,
-0.19860510528087616,
0.010136457160115242,
-0.2946966290473938,
0.298088401556015,
0.13801701366901398,
0.3813949525356293,
0.012908149510622025,
0.1871916502714157,
0.0632171556353569,
-0.14230570197105408,
-0.06702053546905518,
-0.19909115135669708,
0.2562800645828247,
0.09010377526283264,
0.7750764489173889,
0.15114127099514008,
-0.3083703815937042,
-0.4472515285015106,
0.496198832988739,
0.36455073952674866,
-0.24534308910369873,
0.4031691253185272,
0.42324647307395935,
-0.18468619883060455,
-0.49082884192466736,
-0.40165168046951294,
-0.02936108410358429,
-0.6368365287780762,
0.40036532282829285,
-0.31377848982810974,
-0.2897856831550598,
0.8142322301864624,
0.09420447051525116,
0.09403850883245468,
0.6590976715087891,
0.44767165184020996,
0.001299282186664641,
1.2642791271209717,
0.319338858127594,
-0.14589333534240723,
0.6812154650688171,
-0.14676225185394287,
-0.13301871716976166,
-0.4576469659805298,
-0.166728213429451,
-0.5523869395256042,
-0.02889001928269863,
-0.23341090977191925,
-0.24685324728488922,
0.5184585452079773,
-0.21964384615421295,
-0.4841032326221466,
0.33572155237197876,
-0.7747616171836853,
0.270082026720047,
0.6134423613548279,
0.10614058375358582,
0.24796772003173828,
-0.014800461009144783,
-0.3899391293525696,
-0.0941726490855217,
-0.8642852902412415,
-0.22507035732269287,
0.7770230174064636,
0.48780468106269836,
0.9254724383354187,
0.1747436225414276,
0.6787909865379333,
0.4031031131744385,
0.38512685894966125,
-0.4411490559577942,
0.7190560698509216,
-0.5594275593757629,
-0.40152913331985474,
-0.3017594814300537,
-0.5079120993614197,
-1.186537504196167,
0.03380860388278961,
0.09304589778184891,
-0.5121852159500122,
0.18049663305282593,
0.08007857203483582,
-0.7648233771324158,
0.29055801033973694,
-0.3606656789779663,
0.7267728447914124,
-0.24428774416446686,
0.022484859451651573,
-0.3561096787452698,
-0.40678510069847107,
0.1904934197664261,
-0.3878144919872284,
0.16903388500213623,
-0.16735923290252686,
0.05008789896965027,
0.5118264555931091,
-0.23366935551166534,
0.9160353541374207,
-0.4245409071445465,
-0.40778404474258423,
0.3021426200866699,
0.40212738513946533,
0.7303301095962524,
-0.15787091851234436,
-0.41418272256851196,
0.025455264374613762,
-0.4839726984500885,
-0.07550419867038727,
-0.4861738681793213,
0.7448440790176392,
-0.8915498852729797,
-0.740969717502594,
-0.5897405743598938,
-0.44466665387153625,
-0.002049686387181282,
0.20027655363082886,
0.44754505157470703,
0.19097469747066498,
-0.21220296621322632,
-0.42774835228919983,
0.7010440826416016,
-0.8287941813468933,
0.5194317102432251,
0.8821720480918884,
-0.1371268481016159,
-0.23630255460739136,
1.0506281852722168,
-0.0302882082760334,
0.31393229961395264,
0.22340062260627747,
0.23951947689056396,
-0.42774611711502075,
-0.7572315335273743,
-0.41939833760261536,
0.1264725923538208,
-0.694236695766449,
-0.4434734582901001,
-0.7179469466209412,
-0.40489086508750916,
-0.03323652595281601,
-0.17337949573993683,
-0.5779958963394165,
0.22608733177185059,
-0.7816492915153503,
0.17345471680164337,
0.3913893401622772,
0.8102582097053528,
-0.2665833532810211,
0.4606356918811798,
-0.8161500692367554,
0.13594092428684235,
0.3987608850002289,
0.30118152499198914,
0.028385022655129433,
-0.7930896282196045,
0.20738321542739868,
0.32575908303260803,
-0.4277828335762024,
-1.1996009349822998,
0.8051405549049377,
0.15585462749004364,
0.7088977694511414,
0.3104206919670105,
0.3829805552959442,
0.5573310256004333,
-0.5607846975326538,
0.6558882594108582,
0.041952647268772125,
-0.6768235564231873,
0.9597269892692566,
-0.7927267551422119,
0.23208965361118317,
0.49965667724609375,
0.7219057083129883,
-0.404541015625,
-0.44805386662483215,
-0.6148050427436829,
-0.6884427666664124,
0.6116025447845459,
-0.039304688572883606,
0.10586167871952057,
-0.2527256906032562,
0.19390961527824402,
-0.07743915915489197,
-0.018978752195835114,
-0.470213383436203,
-0.3798949420452118,
-0.06651922315359116,
-0.16847774386405945,
0.05259115248918533,
-0.28402137756347656,
-0.0920979380607605,
0.3073461651802063,
0.7774542570114136,
0.017941007390618324,
0.050106678158044815,
0.12623710930347443,
0.09379252046346664,
-0.3390630781650543,
0.14319372177124023,
0.14357353746891022,
0.008858778513967991,
-0.17695507407188416,
-0.054213594645261765,
0.10951907187700272,
-0.36115890741348267,
0.48896050453186035,
0.5076924562454224,
-0.35165897011756897,
0.017198555171489716,
-0.181709885597229,
0.4971272051334381,
0.01771659590303898,
-0.776328444480896,
0.49456411600112915,
-0.24494317173957825,
0.13290032744407654,
-0.49036291241645813,
0.08610082417726517,
-0.46340009570121765,
0.11911486834287643,
0.7455736994743347,
0.02184901386499405,
0.36673879623413086,
-0.49883410334587097,
0.481863409280777,
0.4657609164714813,
-0.3356684744358063,
-0.24245668947696686,
0.8478513360023499,
0.14781847596168518,
-0.23564064502716064,
0.6921043992042542,
-0.5234901905059814,
-0.6267386674880981,
0.408304363489151,
0.40779367089271545,
0.7489177584648132,
-0.929590106010437,
0.6199208498001099,
0.2714349329471588,
0.17902898788452148,
0.00007072540029184893,
0.2975436747074127,
0.5938348770141602,
-0.7770519256591797,
-0.4534062147140503,
-0.48867371678352356,
-0.22718070447444916,
0.33615434169769287,
-0.5111392736434937,
0.32663536071777344,
-0.5095290541648865,
-0.1868707835674286,
0.0026139297988265753,
0.008767673745751381,
-0.3644336760044098,
0.2833150327205658,
0.1644764393568039,
0.5998859405517578,
-1.1792536973953247,
0.5988795757293701,
0.49117511510849,
-0.48831644654273987,
-0.7208389043807983,
-0.08806966990232468,
0.1828484833240509,
-0.8683314323425293,
0.7979472875595093,
-0.14967241883277893,
0.12193912267684937,
0.17344219982624054,
-0.05905139446258545,
-0.9256211519241333,
0.6355947852134705,
0.4862240254878998,
-0.28359609842300415,
-0.3573249280452728,
0.014394530095160007,
0.450203537940979,
-0.12399745732545853,
0.24656738340854645,
0.3727722465991974,
0.1896418333053589,
0.23131000995635986,
-0.8575356602668762,
0.36905160546302795,
-0.3458116352558136,
-0.06220647320151329,
0.017382819205522537,
-0.500505268573761,
0.9764427542686462,
-0.14320515096187592,
-0.4605025053024292,
-0.11331567168235779,
0.39808785915374756,
0.6150788068771362,
-0.0861625149846077,
0.7331473231315613,
0.4368535578250885,
0.6686187982559204,
0.2817721664905548,
0.8961414098739624,
-0.11099380999803543,
0.11355476081371307,
1.0406360626220703,
-0.2461957186460495,
0.8766655921936035,
0.08712444454431534,
-0.21540866792201996,
0.7123059630393982,
0.8204920291900635,
-0.09248274564743042,
0.6735489964485168,
0.26070308685302734,
-0.32927751541137695,
0.06725405156612396,
-0.2889738976955414,
-0.30598658323287964,
0.340595006942749,
0.5779991745948792,
-0.3875379264354706,
-0.4856758713722229,
0.04407871514558792,
0.10348579287528992,
0.3949718773365021,
-0.20969462394714355,
0.7366859912872314,
-0.08342023193836212,
-0.8003556132316589,
0.9361248016357422,
0.03624998405575752,
0.7304309606552124,
-0.7705458998680115,
0.06490650773048401,
-0.2183123677968979,
0.09308753162622452,
0.0660773292183876,
-0.6358519792556763,
0.5833384394645691,
0.025878772139549255,
0.10247942060232162,
-0.5114476680755615,
0.6600990295410156,
-0.31876522302627563,
-0.19063732028007507,
0.4402874708175659,
0.3756132125854492,
-0.11481399834156036,
-0.5740851163864136,
-1.0685112476348877,
0.07008790224790573,
0.18182390928268433,
-0.3299017548561096,
0.45427393913269043,
0.3275722563266754,
0.19288590550422668,
0.957808256149292,
0.8004781007766724,
0.2857431471347809,
-0.10050620883703232,
0.09564719349145889,
1.136669397354126,
-0.24988840520381927,
-0.8340542316436768,
-0.8477546572685242,
0.5080420970916748,
0.02944607473909855,
0.034752100706100464,
0.708254873752594,
0.26640069484710693,
0.34193459153175354,
0.06906043738126755,
0.8139921426773071,
0.1213996559381485,
0.6758509278297424,
-0.26789528131484985,
0.9783453345298767,
-0.46730470657348633,
0.5719370245933533,
-0.3807159960269928,
-0.5656879544258118,
-0.14495836198329926,
0.578204333782196,
-0.30345582962036133,
-0.14134655892848969,
0.48388153314590454,
0.9192294478416443,
0.14105099439620972,
-0.3100607991218567,
0.22653932869434357,
0.3383338153362274,
0.5023171901702881,
0.6787481307983398,
0.9963318109512329,
-0.45304644107818604,
0.7343860268592834,
0.017019011080265045,
-0.3972809612751007,
-0.1624516248703003,
-0.997283399105072,
-0.7130424380302429,
-0.7145534157752991,
-0.3576463460922241,
-0.3597886264324188,
0.28453725576400757,
0.6359784603118896,
0.3326869606971741,
-0.6434022188186646,
-0.05043575540184975,
-0.29108911752700806,
-0.05684707313776016,
-0.18984906375408173,
-0.2411201447248459,
0.26321348547935486,
-0.4968748092651367,
-0.6045902967453003,
0.7805636525154114,
-0.022703371942043304,
0.238175168633461,
-0.46375417709350586,
0.13001692295074463,
-0.383038729429245,
0.22394582629203796,
0.18736553192138672,
0.3769456744194031,
-0.5555262565612793,
-0.28850528597831726,
0.14350929856300354,
-0.19877099990844727,
-0.17910952866077423,
0.3673408329486847,
-0.6813945174217224,
0.40843629837036133,
0.5146884322166443,
0.5104315280914307,
0.07997065037488937,
-0.05359071493148804,
1.1072869300842285,
-1.0596522092819214,
0.12295442819595337,
0.4310331642627716,
0.1899271011352539,
0.3175913989543915,
-0.6258901953697205,
0.2865709066390991,
-0.0029857459012418985,
-0.4822688698768616,
-0.8761405348777771,
0.36855176091194153,
-0.49566787481307983,
-0.43923044204711914,
1.2323986291885376,
-0.3804483413696289,
0.05394909903407097,
-0.10639972984790802,
-0.3216026723384857,
0.19333654642105103,
-0.4954703450202942,
1.116949439048767,
0.2065580040216446,
0.08099019527435303,
-0.1832159161567688,
-0.36200881004333496,
0.8590006828308105,
0.35761430859565735,
-0.6273450255393982,
0.1894357055425644,
0.3840695321559906,
0.18060512840747833,
0.20603230595588684,
0.6517865657806396,
-0.047905512154102325,
0.17845484614372253,
0.041672155261039734,
-0.20149444043636322,
-0.03771369904279709,
-0.29074203968048096,
-0.5186358094215393,
0.23557473719120026,
0.13637663424015045,
-0.12555623054504395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00277v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00277v1
|
Gender Bias in Large Language Models across Multiple Languages
| 2024-03-01T04:47:16 | 2024-03-01T04:47:16 |
Jinman Zhao, Yitian Ding, Chen Jia, Yining Wang, Zifan Qian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the growing deployment of large language models (LLMs) across various
applications, assessing the influence of gender biases embedded in LLMs becomes
crucial. The topic of gender bias within the realm of natural language
processing (NLP) has gained considerable focus, particularly in the context of
English. Nonetheless, the investigation of gender bias in languages other than
English is still relatively under-explored and insufficiently analyzed. In this
work, We examine gender bias in LLMs-generated outputs for different languages.
We use three measurements: 1) gender bias in selecting descriptive words given
the gender-related context. 2) gender bias in selecting gender-related pronouns
(she/he) given the descriptive words. 3) gender bias in the topics of
LLM-generated dialogues. We investigate the outputs of the GPT series of LLMs
in various languages using our three measurement methods. Our findings revealed
significant gender biases across all the languages we examined.
|
[
-0.2563384175300598,
-0.6758348941802979,
0.5463507175445557,
0.3063618242740631,
0.08423236757516861,
0.02699200063943863,
-0.310970664024353,
-0.5012043118476868,
-0.026293272152543068,
0.44148504734039307,
-0.8225841522216797,
-0.38242244720458984,
-0.6396138668060303,
0.35351598262786865,
-0.30744487047195435,
0.8586380481719971,
-0.037208251655101776,
0.6213076710700989,
-0.33177703619003296,
-0.09051517397165298,
-0.6928332448005676,
-0.7145116925239563,
-0.4932616949081421,
-0.6027872562408447,
0.3355909287929535,
-0.01167389191687107,
0.4226437509059906,
0.03971608728170395,
0.3630867004394531,
0.267183393239975,
-0.36486366391181946,
0.11987311393022537,
-0.3689400553703308,
0.3357284665107727,
-0.3168441653251648,
-0.5080482959747314,
-0.4107050597667694,
0.12452834844589233,
0.844829797744751,
0.6891583800315857,
0.10454785078763962,
0.34206849336624146,
0.25207066535949707,
0.7739739418029785,
-0.7064078450202942,
0.26619574427604675,
-0.5255734324455261,
0.09199530631303787,
-0.20539690554141998,
-0.004372811410576105,
-0.24922186136245728,
-0.06839975714683533,
0.33421456813812256,
0.04663711413741112,
0.3343679904937744,
-0.04613417759537697,
0.5306974053382874,
-0.14691729843616486,
-0.6308611035346985,
-0.4326346218585968,
-0.8111755847930908,
1.0450383424758911,
-0.8113563060760498,
0.5820179581642151,
0.39029303193092346,
0.12874816358089447,
-0.11099638044834137,
-0.20088356733322144,
-0.3221077620983124,
-0.40607723593711853,
-0.10590096563100815,
-0.09920628368854523,
-0.24835550785064697,
-0.10640811175107956,
0.31706365942955017,
0.22715382277965546,
-0.15802650153636932,
0.24809952080249786,
-0.14194132387638092,
-0.08929930627346039,
0.6356396675109863,
0.07779146730899811,
0.3111458122730255,
-0.3547668755054474,
-0.07450799643993378,
0.08095284551382065,
-1.0139566659927368,
-0.1908583641052246,
0.9203987121582031,
0.41883358359336853,
-0.11309715360403061,
0.7469640970230103,
0.04521122947335243,
0.44837769865989685,
-0.05759512260556221,
-0.1968105286359787,
0.13494573533535004,
-0.4866677224636078,
-0.04036763310432434,
-0.010585205629467964,
0.942353367805481,
0.247492715716362,
0.3791562616825104,
0.10513997077941895,
-0.12732724845409393,
-0.17133399844169617,
0.13812999427318573,
-0.5950011014938354,
0.2743093967437744,
0.022186703979969025,
-0.3768126666545868,
-0.034910649061203,
-0.12814714014530182,
-0.6905041337013245,
-0.587928831577301,
-0.0003941029426641762,
0.017216678708791733,
0.09788735210895538,
-0.5340182185173035,
-0.08659608662128448,
-0.07925369590520859,
0.20486629009246826,
0.2397475391626358,
-1.221708059310913,
0.20816469192504883,
0.6745973229408264,
0.4731428921222687,
-0.1955171823501587,
-0.29995667934417725,
-0.29782935976982117,
0.0976482555270195,
-0.3663952648639679,
0.5658862590789795,
-0.592257559299469,
-0.4840937554836273,
0.2403143048286438,
-0.07438195496797562,
-0.1486094444990158,
-0.46978959441185,
0.3792477548122406,
-0.1035882756114006,
0.5389899611473083,
-0.4966065287590027,
-0.47449082136154175,
-0.09659534692764282,
0.3594788610935211,
-0.5145109295845032,
1.0148025751113892,
-0.1974872350692749,
-1.1374139785766602,
0.5094802379608154,
-0.5889765620231628,
-0.3467504382133484,
-0.35993075370788574,
-0.6732118725776672,
-0.48919904232025146,
0.1547476351261139,
0.3681926727294922,
0.5971390008926392,
-0.6857315301895142,
0.6404874920845032,
-0.0997931957244873,
-0.15666070580482483,
0.3849920332431793,
-0.6330804228782654,
0.6641559600830078,
-0.2559669315814972,
-0.320217490196228,
0.23383669555187225,
-0.4545913636684418,
-0.4025800824165344,
0.15952980518341064,
-0.0682334303855896,
-0.41040652990341187,
0.19973912835121155,
-0.03919447585940361,
0.14873643219470978,
0.06840109825134277,
-0.5668597221374512,
-0.010495806112885475,
-0.2956806421279907,
0.5971484184265137,
0.6184523701667786,
-0.17297016084194183,
0.6002504229545593,
-0.025694506242871284,
0.6614883542060852,
-0.10828015953302383,
-0.09637867659330368,
-0.007888076826930046,
-0.6630285382270813,
-0.5496221780776978,
-0.19152523577213287,
0.29078173637390137,
0.3949560821056366,
-0.3469681143760681,
0.06809551268815994,
-0.14592482149600983,
-0.21605470776557922,
-0.4537402093410492,
0.14376866817474365,
0.4786842465400696,
0.15769965946674347,
-0.008888568729162216,
-0.02337077632546425,
-0.4765006899833679,
-1.3462847471237183,
-0.5690947771072388,
-0.41479256749153137,
-0.1394515335559845,
0.3630545437335968,
0.6974002718925476,
-0.37037357687950134,
0.8986720442771912,
-0.4330070912837982,
-0.3964248597621918,
-0.5521243810653687,
0.13668495416641235,
0.13459111750125885,
0.24899543821811676,
0.7101551294326782,
-0.45677199959754944,
-0.19140297174453735,
-0.17548248171806335,
-0.5001956820487976,
-0.41286128759384155,
0.009083595126867294,
-0.16014952957630157,
0.3393663465976715,
0.4091356694698334,
-0.6344008445739746,
0.21636267006397247,
0.8228936791419983,
-0.29827967286109924,
0.6050286293029785,
0.12976232171058655,
0.10513711720705032,
-1.0535786151885986,
-0.05172865465283394,
0.24368761479854584,
-0.264575719833374,
-0.5085569620132446,
0.037645529955625534,
-0.1101522371172905,
0.3585495352745056,
-0.5299598574638367,
0.7785387635231018,
-0.7732856273651123,
-0.504636824131012,
-0.02362198196351528,
0.0014055222272872925,
-0.07703473418951035,
0.19743755459785461,
0.22730092704296112,
0.8226625323295593,
0.3882582187652588,
-0.3560923635959625,
0.12010475993156433,
0.259827196598053,
-0.1511884182691574,
0.39157840609550476,
-0.45548588037490845,
0.19638362526893616,
-0.12394871562719345,
0.28617167472839355,
-1.091946005821228,
0.06927354633808136,
0.24831923842430115,
-0.30619820952415466,
0.35350608825683594,
-0.4048902988433838,
-0.5792678594589233,
-0.3031260371208191,
-0.41539570689201355,
0.18630236387252808,
0.15968485176563263,
-0.23127548396587372,
0.5858116745948792,
0.4228988289833069,
-0.16479752957820892,
-0.730509340763092,
-0.7211102843284607,
-0.0966932401061058,
-0.22439594566822052,
-0.48687630891799927,
-0.17979280650615692,
0.002001926302909851,
-0.6022905111312866,
-0.41584137082099915,
-0.07146503776311874,
-0.06572811305522919,
0.08249343186616898,
0.25541502237319946,
0.20195911824703217,
-0.19784104824066162,
0.0042074574157595634,
0.13248564302921295,
0.2735711932182312,
0.2346356213092804,
-0.046737756580114365,
0.8358221650123596,
-0.05735771730542183,
-0.5573713779449463,
-0.14431506395339966,
0.5276048183441162,
0.45683959126472473,
-0.036601901054382324,
0.8527896404266357,
0.64873206615448,
-0.28432393074035645,
-0.10542642325162888,
-0.6959479451179504,
-0.2675751745700836,
-0.39195752143859863,
0.5341391563415527,
-0.3089830279350281,
-1.166978359222412,
0.7490683794021606,
0.2578543424606323,
0.19985845685005188,
0.5289351940155029,
0.7631580233573914,
0.0451246052980423,
1.228763222694397,
0.6303775906562805,
-0.24454867839813232,
0.3954824209213257,
-0.030087227001786232,
0.2475435435771942,
-1.0887458324432373,
0.019116895273327827,
-0.7260597348213196,
-0.07680550217628479,
-1.186012625694275,
-0.2485453486442566,
0.16503414511680603,
-0.21319347620010376,
-0.26810362935066223,
-0.08519284427165985,
-0.0733814612030983,
0.30446359515190125,
0.5390461087226868,
-0.24149471521377563,
0.3066163957118988,
0.033276401460170746,
-0.009778895415365696,
-0.3800641894340515,
-0.6552908420562744,
-0.7199975848197937,
1.1532719135284424,
0.532595157623291,
0.5056815147399902,
0.20580486953258514,
0.4078713655471802,
0.19458796083927155,
0.27881136536598206,
-0.5466959476470947,
0.5613143444061279,
-0.33363837003707886,
-0.9797484874725342,
-0.2019919604063034,
-0.4290348291397095,
-0.911858320236206,
0.46766960620880127,
-0.15632174909114838,
-0.8102149963378906,
-0.05917136371135712,
-0.06601802259683609,
0.10790154337882996,
0.2834010422229767,
-0.4533753991127014,
0.5520693063735962,
-0.041453417390584946,
-0.4553927183151245,
-0.06361300498247147,
-0.34964367747306824,
0.7131776213645935,
-0.07391797751188278,
0.2235279530286789,
-0.3847372531890869,
0.1562003642320633,
0.6490562558174133,
-0.11282409727573395,
1.0280990600585938,
0.004399409517645836,
-0.7046579122543335,
-0.031534865498542786,
0.1107143983244896,
0.23128223419189453,
0.3538038730621338,
-0.04445676505565643,
0.6373410820960999,
-0.21400214731693268,
-0.16286495327949524,
-0.008831647224724293,
0.6902433633804321,
-0.7778019905090332,
-0.8514127135276794,
-0.6217070817947388,
-0.5581667423248291,
-0.35088059306144714,
0.08262398093938828,
0.2600533962249756,
0.25563231110572815,
-0.43697983026504517,
-0.17572754621505737,
0.4709795415401459,
-0.7381287217140198,
0.35747867822647095,
0.6024038791656494,
-0.517643392086029,
0.05260230973362923,
0.32518112659454346,
0.13406439125537872,
0.48411694169044495,
0.4121914207935333,
0.3427276611328125,
-0.35516560077667236,
-0.3533620536327362,
-0.6174623966217041,
0.44379177689552307,
-0.5298712253570557,
0.0584094412624836,
-0.6019278764724731,
-0.28916415572166443,
-0.5452617406845093,
0.20338734984397888,
-0.45578673481941223,
-0.2125381976366043,
-0.13892874121665955,
-0.09978532046079636,
0.24471227824687958,
0.8056153059005737,
0.3296745717525482,
0.2463805377483368,
-0.6301991939544678,
0.5267332196235657,
0.4349721670150757,
0.11747080832719803,
-0.057714901864528656,
-0.4654524624347687,
0.12581919133663177,
0.1631331443786621,
-0.12317293882369995,
-1.024560809135437,
0.5320116877555847,
0.18523891270160675,
0.5557174682617188,
0.10361376404762268,
-0.4228324890136719,
0.19810724258422852,
-0.6433374881744385,
1.232405662536621,
0.08231598883867264,
-0.9081016778945923,
0.45848405361175537,
-0.7204976081848145,
0.4138680696487427,
0.1906929463148117,
0.17286711931228638,
-0.6836602091789246,
-0.7361131906509399,
-0.40090516209602356,
-0.9339392185211182,
0.7570796012878418,
0.36754387617111206,
0.4991055727005005,
-0.25506603717803955,
0.21609526872634888,
0.3649545907974243,
0.6755002737045288,
-0.8540565371513367,
-0.5037074685096741,
0.42219340801239014,
0.2570003569126129,
-0.10394566506147385,
-0.5508490204811096,
-0.00719476118683815,
-0.08259449154138565,
0.6557996869087219,
-0.13271164894104004,
0.5398344993591309,
-0.024314608424901962,
-0.2691478729248047,
-0.08391222357749939,
0.5744221210479736,
0.7003769874572754,
0.7246178388595581,
-0.19523464143276215,
-0.0027932070661336184,
0.18170513212680817,
-0.5950250029563904,
0.07505858689546585,
-0.09133291244506836,
-0.44489914178848267,
0.2668137848377228,
0.5952280163764954,
0.9462226629257202,
-0.03152965381741524,
-0.5511844754219055,
0.4135168790817261,
-0.21497772634029388,
-0.057888370007276535,
-0.3291628360748291,
-0.14115117490291595,
0.3329586088657379,
0.25691211223602295,
0.30929863452911377,
-0.13496482372283936,
0.16720540821552277,
-0.7520092129707336,
-0.2772623896598816,
0.7695231437683105,
-0.15040786564350128,
-0.29597482085227966,
0.6894842386245728,
0.13521437346935272,
0.0003879469586536288,
0.4856157600879669,
-0.12696805596351624,
-0.6878710389137268,
0.559825599193573,
0.5042349100112915,
1.2162672281265259,
-0.26220208406448364,
0.29351186752319336,
0.43012118339538574,
0.5331920385360718,
-0.19094198942184448,
0.463530570268631,
0.2346002161502838,
-0.973002552986145,
-0.6245008111000061,
-0.5677286386489868,
-0.3573950231075287,
0.2110622525215149,
-0.5702714920043945,
0.24860502779483795,
-0.18630926311016083,
-0.3215223252773285,
-0.088840052485466,
0.006214303895831108,
-0.7268997430801392,
-0.17294420301914215,
0.6205766797065735,
0.44626110792160034,
-1.1429333686828613,
0.4682551920413971,
0.7805481553077698,
-0.1593257188796997,
-0.5207846164703369,
0.05969114601612091,
0.1965644210577011,
-0.8103550672531128,
0.8596127033233643,
0.1452336460351944,
-0.21261118352413177,
-0.3122928738594055,
-0.30644142627716064,
-0.7131193280220032,
0.7573734521865845,
0.507416307926178,
-0.7228935360908508,
0.1354067474603653,
0.6839156150817871,
0.5722858905792236,
-0.3943813741207123,
0.5988286137580872,
0.7084859609603882,
0.5138257741928101,
-0.3631172478199005,
-1.2911791801452637,
-0.2348708212375641,
-0.025327876210212708,
0.14564713835716248,
0.2632432281970978,
-0.539065957069397,
0.8991464376449585,
0.085051991045475,
0.0861763283610344,
-0.19640402495861053,
0.516132652759552,
0.4386323094367981,
0.13706164062023163,
0.32652905583381653,
0.06669263541698456,
0.5687761902809143,
-0.12495927512645721,
1.0411872863769531,
0.001272439956665039,
0.0912785530090332,
1.2039347887039185,
-0.5672063231468201,
0.6209660172462463,
0.4931105077266693,
-0.4331655502319336,
0.20428800582885742,
0.385680228471756,
0.15435415506362915,
-0.017981160432100296,
0.4349486231803894,
-0.1524198204278946,
-0.0331357941031456,
-0.3211962580680847,
-0.2899654507637024,
0.5752624273300171,
0.3624342978000641,
-0.5565929412841797,
-0.01762021705508232,
-0.028574202209711075,
0.39717110991477966,
0.015267266891896725,
-0.34074318408966064,
0.702029824256897,
0.27866998314857483,
-0.621757447719574,
0.259280800819397,
0.1565839797258377,
0.9596551656723022,
-0.7443389296531677,
0.0017299902392551303,
-0.3401029706001282,
-0.02105104923248291,
-0.15175987780094147,
-0.8394142389297485,
0.04589518904685974,
0.3184588551521301,
-0.36127230525016785,
-0.3375006914138794,
0.7714443206787109,
-0.6850802898406982,
-0.658454418182373,
0.4160153269767761,
1.059489369392395,
0.09210023283958435,
-0.19824321568012238,
-0.5184417963027954,
0.01685390993952751,
0.21306991577148438,
-0.35390767455101013,
0.5462566018104553,
0.1829482614994049,
-0.4277994930744171,
0.725175142288208,
0.40787947177886963,
0.3090760111808777,
0.3310691714286804,
0.516356348991394,
0.418282151222229,
-0.5106810331344604,
-0.22630366683006287,
-1.049787998199463,
0.20325294137001038,
0.12753069400787354,
-0.30403855443000793,
1.081125020980835,
0.45630791783332825,
0.6714513301849365,
-0.07515569031238556,
0.8481958508491516,
0.18689580261707306,
0.5400765538215637,
-0.5406832695007324,
0.5608395934104919,
-0.251975417137146,
0.5160117149353027,
-0.6105032563209534,
-1.3441214561462402,
-0.11363890767097473,
0.5793349742889404,
-0.41228607296943665,
0.19290414452552795,
0.5712877511978149,
0.4443439841270447,
0.17592041194438934,
0.1333489716053009,
0.13346421718597412,
0.3049764633178711,
0.26480281352996826,
0.1421656310558319,
1.069696307182312,
-0.3546135723590851,
-0.044506482779979706,
-0.092613585293293,
0.25873297452926636,
0.048259228467941284,
-1.1182644367218018,
-1.1212135553359985,
-0.3442615568637848,
-0.4165400564670563,
0.0024331456515938044,
0.010687445290386677,
0.8856198787689209,
0.47437363862991333,
-0.6957076787948608,
-0.5341620445251465,
0.18066991865634918,
0.28916579484939575,
-0.10411467403173447,
-0.16651959717273712,
0.3511511981487274,
-0.00557413324713707,
-0.971699595451355,
0.2303350865840912,
0.04328693449497223,
-0.2481977641582489,
-0.6710543632507324,
0.05764232203364372,
-0.3667340576648712,
0.04870188236236572,
0.6710964441299438,
-0.1964719593524933,
-0.773728609085083,
-0.2946946620941162,
0.010368998162448406,
-0.0693994015455246,
0.01463412493467331,
0.7653834819793701,
-0.48072901368141174,
0.21940134465694427,
0.6989290714263916,
0.19432345032691956,
0.25855979323387146,
-0.3690420091152191,
1.0709228515625,
-1.138765811920166,
0.11117929220199585,
0.07709357887506485,
0.48536521196365356,
0.6691011786460876,
-0.2612587809562683,
0.510198175907135,
0.07521083205938339,
-0.44859275221824646,
-0.8657943606376648,
0.35081738233566284,
-0.5892698764801025,
-0.3503296673297882,
1.6815377473831177,
0.12815827131271362,
0.0983026996254921,
0.07479364424943924,
-0.3069629371166229,
0.17100790143013,
-0.4079005718231201,
0.378160297870636,
1.0027426481246948,
0.09376741200685501,
-0.1092507392168045,
-1.23841392993927,
0.36792126297950745,
0.38973671197891235,
-0.5566810369491577,
0.17481476068496704,
0.6143819689750671,
0.3251881003379822,
0.00797274336218834,
0.5944229364395142,
-0.09844920784235,
-0.12955597043037415,
-0.3717423379421234,
0.19674132764339447,
0.414831280708313,
-0.05499844253063202,
-0.39809441566467285,
-0.19832271337509155,
0.17740768194198608,
0.1109180897474289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00868v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00868v2
|
SoftTiger: A Clinical Foundation Model for Healthcare Workflows
| 2024-03-01T04:39:16 | 2024-03-27T03:03:00 |
Ye Chen, Igor Couto, Wei Cai, Cong Fu, Bruno Dorneles
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce SoftTiger, a clinical large language model (CLaM) designed as a
foundation model for healthcare workflows. The narrative and unstructured
nature of clinical notes is a major obstacle for healthcare intelligentization.
We address a critical problem of structuring clinical notes into clinical data,
according to international interoperability standards. We collect and annotate
data for three subtasks, namely, international patient summary, clinical
impression and medical encounter. We then supervised fine-tuned a
state-of-the-art LLM using public and credentialed clinical data. The training
is orchestrated in a way that the target model can first support basic clinical
tasks such as abbreviation expansion and temporal information extraction, and
then learn to perform more complex downstream clinical tasks. Moreover, we
address several modeling challenges in the healthcare context, e.g., extra long
context window. Our blind pairwise evaluation shows that SoftTiger outperforms
other popular open-source models and GPT-3.5, comparable to Gemini-pro, with a
mild gap from GPT-4. We believe that LLMs may become a step-stone towards
healthcare digitalization and democratization. Therefore, we publicly release
SoftTiger models at scales of 13 billion and 70 billion parameters, as well as
datasets and code for our innovative scalable evaluation, hopefully, making a
significant contribution to the healthcare industry.
|
[
0.17265170812606812,
-0.6126852035522461,
0.725101113319397,
-0.20806923508644104,
-0.37496939301490784,
-0.2208273708820343,
-0.24329398572444916,
-0.4166189134120941,
0.0926414430141449,
0.9533191323280334,
-0.42046621441841125,
-0.9062576293945312,
-0.7057013511657715,
-0.03297539800405502,
-0.3330721855163574,
1.6603038311004639,
-0.0803452879190445,
0.1907796710729599,
-0.14754930138587952,
-0.33774587512016296,
-0.12977325916290283,
-0.4660656750202179,
-0.27570876479148865,
-0.5575546026229858,
0.6245828866958618,
0.5053598880767822,
0.7934087514877319,
0.7378650307655334,
0.879134476184845,
0.354328989982605,
-0.14223513007164001,
-0.27799278497695923,
-0.39956599473953247,
0.22435078024864197,
-0.0359782837331295,
-0.4373894929885864,
-0.9507310390472412,
-0.18468281626701355,
0.3263787031173706,
0.9222428202629089,
-0.4029955565929413,
0.3558407723903656,
-0.2271692305803299,
0.7418138384819031,
-0.30496945977211,
0.24802860617637634,
-0.22430767118930817,
0.14420610666275024,
-0.3464847803115845,
0.15459223091602325,
-0.036744676530361176,
-0.2879108786582947,
0.45251357555389404,
-0.3703121244907379,
0.5621519088745117,
-0.3185069262981415,
0.2236889749765396,
0.18132935464382172,
-0.4952701926231384,
-0.4077937602996826,
-0.7540620565414429,
0.36070194840431213,
-0.7982626557350159,
0.1833280771970749,
-0.08714303374290466,
0.437126487493515,
-0.13277986645698547,
-1.343630313873291,
-0.1530289351940155,
-0.37487149238586426,
-0.17361712455749512,
0.06612519174814224,
0.1473844349384308,
0.4908730685710907,
0.21458333730697632,
0.5203326940536499,
-0.7356443405151367,
0.05507124960422516,
-0.7106463313102722,
-0.12221626192331314,
0.8246375322341919,
0.4645240902900696,
0.04749103635549545,
-0.008147940039634705,
-0.2958088219165802,
0.17880845069885254,
-0.4813533127307892,
-0.1454426795244217,
-0.20669519901275635,
0.2202553153038025,
-0.4294133484363556,
0.4249957501888275,
-0.194240003824234,
0.406925767660141,
-0.3010571002960205,
-0.5740854740142822,
0.294076532125473,
-0.008725308813154697,
-0.3619403839111328,
0.3686995804309845,
0.7110394835472107,
0.13640283048152924,
0.08704470843076706,
-0.2966160178184509,
-0.31798627972602844,
0.2003035992383957,
0.3871356248855591,
-0.9610344171524048,
-0.2826651930809021,
0.5483382940292358,
-0.5496025085449219,
-0.34470316767692566,
0.02263026311993599,
-0.6683056950569153,
-0.6705920696258545,
-0.3724791705608368,
0.08671343326568604,
-0.18537196516990662,
-0.31122055649757385,
0.29396599531173706,
0.25199422240257263,
-0.17621980607509613,
0.4132038950920105,
-0.6569836735725403,
0.49476730823516846,
1.1688041687011719,
0.9058655500411987,
-0.302070289850235,
-0.023777315393090248,
-0.4971393644809723,
0.35023194551467896,
-0.08074170351028442,
0.6392188668251038,
-0.21237996220588684,
-0.4628942608833313,
0.280964732170105,
0.2691492736339569,
0.05057317763566971,
-0.6615753769874573,
0.4853765070438385,
-0.17876780033111572,
-0.039876170456409454,
0.21809810400009155,
-0.4896049201488495,
-0.10894256830215454,
0.2918659746646881,
-0.7551953792572021,
0.28785428404808044,
0.38983437418937683,
-0.5821580290794373,
0.35314813256263733,
-0.8551985621452332,
-0.6218979954719543,
0.5692986249923706,
-0.16414852440357208,
-0.6768641471862793,
0.30954593420028687,
-0.28329411149024963,
0.6887363195419312,
-0.591373860836029,
0.7568713426589966,
-0.620640218257904,
-0.4774642884731293,
0.2415183186531067,
-0.025564147159457207,
0.72291499376297,
0.12175291031599045,
-0.32661792635917664,
0.3337520658969879,
-0.7623284459114075,
-0.20361939072608948,
0.09782736748456955,
-0.2025647908449173,
-0.07963545620441437,
-0.3947312831878662,
0.3592686057090759,
0.02615797147154808,
0.10254189372062683,
-0.41132307052612305,
0.30529123544692993,
-0.429991751909256,
0.8672921061515808,
0.516089677810669,
0.057622455060482025,
0.313912034034729,
-0.6695263981819153,
0.6063504815101624,
0.0694754347205162,
0.575989842414856,
-0.21443045139312744,
-0.3407380282878876,
-0.47573569416999817,
-0.5243423581123352,
0.36839523911476135,
0.5801595449447632,
-0.034435536712408066,
0.07951133698225021,
-0.37233859300613403,
-0.5722634792327881,
-0.557350218296051,
0.38478827476501465,
0.34958791732788086,
0.7557079792022705,
0.09410859644412994,
-0.4201546013355255,
-0.25420454144477844,
-0.9592193961143494,
0.058843132108449936,
-0.123199462890625,
0.01405908539891243,
0.055663954466581345,
0.6813914179801941,
-0.7171656489372253,
0.47292792797088623,
-0.43049174547195435,
-0.6831247806549072,
-0.5793845653533936,
0.17345036566257477,
0.5334348678588867,
0.5846084356307983,
0.08856137841939926,
-0.906075119972229,
-0.19519378244876862,
-0.14428460597991943,
-0.7563749551773071,
-0.052875619381666183,
0.10465080291032791,
0.06920874118804932,
0.07217387109994888,
0.3387438952922821,
-0.71285080909729,
0.4900733232498169,
0.4534965753555298,
-0.04913316294550896,
0.31692057847976685,
-0.23252235352993011,
-0.07265542447566986,
-1.0640755891799927,
0.32908979058265686,
0.047893453389406204,
-0.24119998514652252,
-0.82094806432724,
-0.04300414398312569,
0.00039745407411828637,
-0.30994999408721924,
-0.6345663070678711,
0.5858913660049438,
-0.1780700385570526,
0.13798730075359344,
-0.010725224390625954,
-0.06162118911743164,
0.07607678323984146,
0.40651386976242065,
0.18267129361629486,
0.3294278681278229,
0.4763891398906708,
-0.44923654198646545,
0.4786861538887024,
0.24222412705421448,
-0.21187953650951385,
0.7727233171463013,
-0.9340220093727112,
0.14712026715278625,
-0.17841309309005737,
0.31077662110328674,
-0.8034713268280029,
-0.4613267779350281,
0.09547380357980728,
-0.1471012681722641,
0.40127354860305786,
-0.5110132694244385,
-0.6216657161712646,
-0.31703221797943115,
-0.11498750001192093,
0.31638163328170776,
0.5386433005332947,
-0.00783555954694748,
0.6451032161712646,
0.5932507514953613,
-0.3166778087615967,
-0.11123443394899368,
-0.7377963066101074,
0.01922890916466713,
-0.20701752603054047,
-0.7144045233726501,
0.3496285378932953,
-0.04370684176683426,
-0.40084776282310486,
-0.06186215952038765,
-0.16039685904979706,
-0.27399998903274536,
-0.0017595639219507575,
0.664097785949707,
0.40764084458351135,
-0.382475882768631,
0.056446488946676254,
-0.1713031828403473,
-0.4777655601501465,
0.0925801694393158,
-0.40681254863739014,
-0.03960512951016426,
-0.4221031665802002,
-0.4726543128490448,
-0.461635947227478,
0.3139617145061493,
0.9183806777000427,
0.062235359102487564,
0.6056477427482605,
0.6566543579101562,
-0.6893232464790344,
-0.0422394834458828,
-0.5471234321594238,
-0.20280084013938904,
-0.46259570121765137,
0.24694162607192993,
0.11099684238433838,
-0.9824520945549011,
0.5288112163543701,
-0.17132918536663055,
0.44235917925834656,
0.15575821697711945,
0.7282693982124329,
-0.11353546380996704,
1.063675880432129,
0.6714328527450562,
0.1962711662054062,
-0.06477557867765427,
-0.35068950057029724,
0.102340467274189,
-0.5692562460899353,
-0.4916030168533325,
-0.2104290872812271,
-0.23926503956317902,
-0.6285891532897949,
-0.15824344754219055,
0.9738338589668274,
-0.17365911602973938,
-0.24630317091941833,
0.010279788635671139,
-0.5958980321884155,
-0.14643622934818268,
0.27818864583969116,
0.2237975150346756,
0.3983868956565857,
-0.4101995825767517,
0.051547273993492126,
-0.002094774041324854,
-0.6702461838722229,
-0.6242293119430542,
1.0872637033462524,
0.49975067377090454,
0.8658220171928406,
0.037590134888887405,
0.5961765050888062,
0.4878327548503876,
1.0394383668899536,
-0.6702033877372742,
0.4564904570579529,
-0.349666029214859,
-0.7050455808639526,
-0.005876997485756874,
-0.24599730968475342,
-0.8510435223579407,
0.024038465693593025,
-0.08623708039522171,
-0.5009962916374207,
-0.3415721356868744,
0.470429927110672,
-0.552983283996582,
0.13735456764698029,
-0.6507288813591003,
1.2088301181793213,
-0.3919510841369629,
-0.5017082691192627,
0.014977985993027687,
-0.7784361839294434,
0.6015137434005737,
0.055175065994262695,
0.23418918251991272,
-0.25976788997650146,
-0.1876012086868286,
0.7291139364242554,
-0.8083105683326721,
0.9718838930130005,
-0.06206522136926651,
0.028612777590751648,
0.315034419298172,
0.19850461184978485,
0.35377296805381775,
0.4713997542858124,
0.19647341966629028,
0.30386316776275635,
0.29397252202033997,
-0.3459020256996155,
-0.5637404322624207,
0.5419555902481079,
-0.40246063470840454,
-0.5552108287811279,
-0.5992331504821777,
-0.41656652092933655,
-0.36890169978141785,
0.2027314305305481,
-0.005823862738907337,
0.8308588266372681,
-0.20806755125522614,
0.19741423428058624,
0.7107851505279541,
0.05076169595122337,
0.046764906495809555,
0.8557115793228149,
0.24877440929412842,
-0.5712913870811462,
0.4656360447406769,
-0.056184496730566025,
0.013547049835324287,
0.2835642993450165,
0.3694581985473633,
-0.3062203824520111,
-0.7811623811721802,
-0.35945969820022583,
0.5995637774467468,
-0.6368308067321777,
-0.22523176670074463,
-0.787051260471344,
-0.26175355911254883,
-0.6399683356285095,
-0.44141310453414917,
-0.3442312777042389,
-0.09015432745218277,
-0.2959991693496704,
-0.060633573681116104,
0.5266445279121399,
0.914318323135376,
0.1281060129404068,
0.5601261854171753,
-1.0971126556396484,
0.21701309084892273,
0.08781971782445908,
0.6327634453773499,
-0.3750770688056946,
-0.427493691444397,
-0.20107072591781616,
-0.35811978578567505,
-0.09461236745119095,
-0.8013142943382263,
0.16356946527957916,
-0.15820935368537903,
0.44641873240470886,
0.5880280137062073,
-0.10975034534931183,
0.5129997730255127,
-0.5210490226745605,
0.47955605387687683,
0.31098294258117676,
-0.711663007736206,
0.4716958701610565,
-0.40754345059394836,
0.336577445268631,
0.9178785085678101,
0.2082175612449646,
-0.7431250214576721,
-0.23090732097625732,
-0.8086837530136108,
-0.8345329761505127,
0.5750590562820435,
-0.22935853898525238,
-0.09956641495227814,
0.29751330614089966,
0.5074454545974731,
0.28743842244148254,
0.5057555437088013,
-0.4779328405857086,
0.09457547217607498,
0.016234196722507477,
-0.6718627214431763,
-0.11669734120368958,
-0.25179997086524963,
-0.4067758321762085,
0.05121810734272003,
0.40049976110458374,
-0.2173423320055008,
-0.06761688739061356,
0.24599717557430267,
-0.3387509286403656,
-0.09559743851423264,
0.2785234749317169,
0.5478324294090271,
0.7765003442764282,
-0.16221198439598083,
0.13808980584144592,
0.07448303699493408,
-0.7018170356750488,
-0.05966420844197273,
0.29104623198509216,
-0.08290986716747284,
0.018063658848404884,
0.6704812049865723,
0.6018249988555908,
0.5377618670463562,
-1.0749434232711792,
0.7625434994697571,
0.013409551233053207,
-0.3162323832511902,
-0.6545320153236389,
0.3083494305610657,
0.0054892669431865215,
0.348326176404953,
-0.10946474969387054,
-0.273714154958725,
0.322091281414032,
-0.4285673201084137,
0.4072037637233734,
0.15689781308174133,
-0.6775103807449341,
-0.44529181718826294,
0.8405899405479431,
0.18376977741718292,
-0.34591981768608093,
0.48220449686050415,
0.1956477016210556,
-0.3472743630409241,
0.6711949706077576,
0.378795325756073,
0.822803258895874,
-0.027872206643223763,
0.22484035789966583,
0.07255537807941437,
0.2501990497112274,
-0.31554192304611206,
0.18615421652793884,
-0.029733721166849136,
0.015476600266993046,
-0.29864734411239624,
-0.5052077770233154,
-0.6517159342765808,
0.4704238474369049,
-0.5558672547340393,
0.490535706281662,
-0.7472596168518066,
-0.23183506727218628,
-0.027165526524186134,
0.13991528749465942,
-0.8003907799720764,
0.158480703830719,
0.2206297218799591,
1.0768791437149048,
-0.7564522624015808,
0.5690886974334717,
0.7765829563140869,
-0.2503829598426819,
-0.45769357681274414,
-0.41295158863067627,
0.4258059859275818,
-0.7488391399383545,
0.24966874718666077,
0.3244061768054962,
0.2547816038131714,
-0.32330870628356934,
-0.3085978925228119,
-0.4401993453502655,
1.223012924194336,
0.13808904588222504,
-0.684272289276123,
-0.026529435068368912,
0.35194993019104004,
0.7823169231414795,
-0.441607803106308,
0.24152252078056335,
0.6366599202156067,
0.35572350025177,
0.08820736408233643,
-0.8095912933349609,
0.16788841784000397,
-0.19545410573482513,
-0.13981188833713531,
0.18455950915813446,
-0.6944795250892639,
0.6910222768783569,
-0.5775758624076843,
-0.013153714127838612,
0.15648408234119415,
0.41897445917129517,
0.31193822622299194,
0.7627338767051697,
0.5017322301864624,
0.4525595009326935,
0.6257680058479309,
0.014894596301019192,
0.7978993058204651,
-0.34413662552833557,
-0.0002260651672258973,
0.9859445691108704,
-0.8024321794509888,
0.23333750665187836,
0.18209242820739746,
0.04509057104587555,
0.4900577664375305,
0.43668508529663086,
0.03439812362194061,
0.24836021661758423,
0.24573877453804016,
-0.42843446135520935,
-0.016351383179426193,
-0.13530734181404114,
-0.26280227303504944,
0.2323225885629654,
0.5914864540100098,
-0.49413055181503296,
-0.15069934725761414,
0.10698574781417847,
0.3372611105442047,
-0.10637161880731583,
-0.353119820356369,
0.9466572999954224,
0.30071109533309937,
-0.7649195194244385,
0.20939108729362488,
0.027804940938949585,
0.25290435552597046,
-0.884746253490448,
-0.05344042927026749,
-0.17312388122081757,
0.4632173478603363,
-0.28116676211357117,
-0.5925233364105225,
0.23631206154823303,
0.07352019846439362,
-0.013180868700146675,
-0.40443435311317444,
0.7656496167182922,
-0.3590746521949768,
-0.4625983238220215,
0.016600295901298523,
0.32245030999183655,
0.19383278489112854,
0.21229799091815948,
-1.0175284147262573,
0.1221240758895874,
-0.4374966025352478,
-0.27930566668510437,
0.24621011316776276,
0.5455861687660217,
-0.2271958887577057,
0.5397164225578308,
0.6596762537956238,
0.32133617997169495,
-0.3699546158313751,
0.2931624948978424,
0.6760205030441284,
-0.6540619134902954,
-0.6815465092658997,
-0.7441818118095398,
0.6261366605758667,
0.04088080674409866,
-0.49348464608192444,
0.08604960888624191,
0.5528474450111389,
0.40354451537132263,
0.11699718236923218,
0.854271650314331,
0.09339270740747452,
0.6659752726554871,
-0.2730586528778076,
0.6211957931518555,
-0.5053495764732361,
0.008580358698964119,
-0.04423295333981514,
-0.48120826482772827,
-0.42521125078201294,
0.13795216381549835,
-0.24237266182899475,
-0.02811918593943119,
0.5324423909187317,
0.7537286877632141,
-0.1581151783466339,
0.20805174112319946,
0.13880616426467896,
0.24345412850379944,
0.38402506709098816,
0.8127114772796631,
0.42124396562576294,
-0.02708711288869381,
0.601717472076416,
-0.4301166236400604,
-0.46142497658729553,
-0.49279820919036865,
-0.9003614187240601,
-1.0960099697113037,
-0.49503642320632935,
-0.49810105562210083,
-0.678009033203125,
0.1149691715836525,
0.9482187628746033,
0.9112557768821716,
-0.8153595924377441,
-0.08250695466995239,
-0.037805601954460144,
0.06371966004371643,
-0.14621123671531677,
-0.14918674528598785,
0.2253478765487671,
0.03968586400151253,
-0.2792244851589203,
-0.036230091005563736,
0.5817261934280396,
0.19383785128593445,
-0.5797243714332581,
0.04356881231069565,
0.5133464932441711,
-0.3168703615665436,
0.28473222255706787,
0.37981054186820984,
-0.3926360607147217,
0.28204572200775146,
-0.02711641974747181,
-0.3913947641849518,
0.06469924747943878,
1.3972291946411133,
-0.4734390079975128,
0.250152051448822,
0.29778367280960083,
0.5187765955924988,
0.5486040711402893,
-0.1819809377193451,
0.34776467084884644,
-0.13290749490261078,
0.2998333275318146,
0.7296175956726074,
0.45042499899864197,
0.44165676832199097,
-0.4822554886341095,
0.5830979347229004,
0.43496543169021606,
-0.47135454416275024,
-1.1104570627212524,
0.05852994695305824,
-0.9462940096855164,
-0.06380052864551544,
1.0435022115707397,
-0.062182631343603134,
-0.531644344329834,
-0.27654382586479187,
0.14504024386405945,
0.2158198058605194,
-0.1128990426659584,
0.8507021069526672,
0.19927960634231567,
-0.15254512429237366,
0.04989894479513168,
-0.9484500288963318,
0.5024904608726501,
0.19785074889659882,
-0.9666097164154053,
0.03798244148492813,
0.4944460690021515,
0.5807393789291382,
-0.0029613536316901445,
1.0878499746322632,
-0.43056759238243103,
0.4986344277858734,
-0.3354024589061737,
-0.07589150965213776,
-0.28083324432373047,
-0.4819996953010559,
-0.37555813789367676,
0.3213193714618683,
-0.25872382521629333,
0.19748203456401825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00260v1
|
Extracting Polymer Nanocomposite Samples from Full-Length Documents
| 2024-03-01T03:51:56 | 2024-03-01T03:51:56 |
Ghazal Khalighinejad, Defne Circi, L. C. Brinson, Bhuwan Dhingra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper investigates the use of large language models (LLMs) for
extracting sample lists of polymer nanocomposites (PNCs) from full-length
materials science research papers. The challenge lies in the complex nature of
PNC samples, which have numerous attributes scattered throughout the text. The
complexity of annotating detailed information on PNCs limits the availability
of data, making conventional document-level relation extraction techniques
impractical due to the challenge in creating comprehensive named entity span
annotations. To address this, we introduce a new benchmark and an evaluation
technique for this task and explore different prompting strategies in a
zero-shot manner. We also incorporate self-consistency to improve the
performance. Our findings show that even advanced LLMs struggle to extract all
of the samples from an article. Finally, we analyze the errors encountered in
this process, categorizing them into three main challenges, and discuss
potential strategies for future research to overcome them.
|
[
-0.33404114842414856,
-0.9423305988311768,
0.7029849290847778,
0.16575689613819122,
-0.20681408047676086,
0.1302674263715744,
-0.38991618156433105,
-0.46893203258514404,
0.07504657655954361,
0.44458773732185364,
-0.30887627601623535,
-0.11953846365213394,
-0.6510037183761597,
0.6997705698013306,
-0.49223533272743225,
0.9407432079315186,
-0.12817926704883575,
-0.42298445105552673,
-0.2565576136112213,
0.36685875058174133,
0.09717664867639542,
-0.004403864499181509,
-0.465366929769516,
-0.16208995878696442,
0.6659802794456482,
0.4646541476249695,
0.05041762813925743,
0.6521266102790833,
0.3183095455169678,
0.28615981340408325,
-0.46327000856399536,
0.5445865392684937,
-0.1948772519826889,
0.039486415684223175,
-0.49789246916770935,
0.011350354179739952,
-0.24771645665168762,
0.3245576024055481,
0.6000414490699768,
0.6280394196510315,
0.19859637320041656,
0.39566582441329956,
0.37962955236434937,
0.20153959095478058,
-0.7745084166526794,
-0.09535522013902664,
-0.5641376972198486,
-0.03900441899895668,
-0.18117740750312805,
-0.2826343774795532,
-0.5119529962539673,
0.03852034732699394,
0.3995720148086548,
-0.5453301668167114,
0.44846871495246887,
-0.020318858325481415,
1.044076681137085,
-0.48651084303855896,
-0.32919108867645264,
-0.34141433238983154,
-0.8568024039268494,
0.8933706879615784,
-0.6255667209625244,
0.18977372348308563,
0.18384332954883575,
-0.01845892146229744,
-0.3921109139919281,
-0.8367521166801453,
-0.857280433177948,
-0.3897306025028229,
0.08290412276983261,
-0.00590342516079545,
-0.04279955476522446,
0.054709818214178085,
0.34219786524772644,
0.6630866527557373,
-0.2036794126033783,
0.2480548620223999,
-0.4462107717990875,
0.07513394206762314,
0.5821153521537781,
-0.05668335407972336,
0.144511878490448,
-0.6470522880554199,
-0.33214884996414185,
-0.26596614718437195,
-0.4588265120983124,
-0.21313577890396118,
0.38829225301742554,
0.47097674012184143,
0.013491081073880196,
0.9849140048027039,
-0.26349830627441406,
0.5456534028053284,
-0.06662193685770035,
-0.4120461642742157,
0.04901815578341484,
-0.39173588156700134,
-0.22797119617462158,
-0.3163772225379944,
1.0797691345214844,
-0.07313879579305649,
0.37481218576431274,
-0.20812995731830597,
-0.024554749950766563,
-0.876947283744812,
0.07696563750505447,
-0.7343228459358215,
-0.20007668435573578,
0.25206461548805237,
-0.6159065365791321,
-0.21522855758666992,
0.4655369818210602,
-1.176954984664917,
-0.4855286180973053,
-0.42800992727279663,
0.3460070788860321,
-0.02863050438463688,
-0.3793565332889557,
-0.056976620107889175,
-0.34282392263412476,
-0.06820540130138397,
0.4285920262336731,
-0.7606780529022217,
0.4264243245124817,
0.7182814478874207,
1.0265154838562012,
-0.5658547878265381,
-0.21073225140571594,
-0.22869035601615906,
0.14128471910953522,
-0.06914912164211273,
0.9964880347251892,
-0.34748777747154236,
-0.4277329742908478,
-0.3320368826389313,
0.25356176495552063,
-0.01772363670170307,
-0.6746307015419006,
0.3742888271808624,
0.10462197661399841,
0.15624754130840302,
-0.07126177102327347,
-0.574374794960022,
0.2660028040409088,
0.15467992424964905,
-0.8877149820327759,
0.9422788023948669,
0.2296239286661148,
-0.9290221333503723,
-0.08020951598882675,
-0.17631061375141144,
-0.21561133861541748,
-0.1986628919839859,
-0.12810173630714417,
-0.46845924854278564,
0.3352905809879303,
0.2904492914676666,
0.624993085861206,
-0.6455562114715576,
-0.048001471906900406,
-0.36297130584716797,
-0.20880882441997528,
0.2991768419742584,
-0.3947691321372986,
0.5228301882743835,
0.03493601456284523,
-0.2791348099708557,
-0.1258595883846283,
-0.8956761360168457,
-0.48047974705696106,
0.21654435992240906,
-0.5082539319992065,
-0.19867315888404846,
-0.11717730015516281,
0.1777932345867157,
0.30316558480262756,
0.40322253108024597,
-1.0426868200302124,
0.30093809962272644,
-0.1368730217218399,
0.13569071888923645,
1.0355769395828247,
0.24587520956993103,
0.3009032905101776,
-0.2486698478460312,
0.7215794324874878,
-0.1751835197210312,
-0.1475648432970047,
-0.15836045145988464,
-0.16149331629276276,
-0.7252628803253174,
-0.4047234058380127,
0.6023590564727783,
0.4327564835548401,
-0.8090875744819641,
0.38495925068855286,
-0.20956087112426758,
-0.70048987865448,
-0.21133722364902496,
0.328136682510376,
0.15990552306175232,
0.5890941619873047,
0.3351540267467499,
-0.07592731714248657,
-0.6258659362792969,
-0.7572512626647949,
-0.018998561426997185,
0.10307321697473526,
-0.09930399060249329,
0.30519193410873413,
0.7439972162246704,
0.2434367835521698,
1.0160034894943237,
-0.6313485503196716,
-0.08711203932762146,
-0.4619251489639282,
0.4826214015483856,
0.29497385025024414,
0.40458130836486816,
-0.04154575616121292,
-0.6287858486175537,
-0.34029239416122437,
0.11823093146085739,
-0.5151132941246033,
-0.17801621556282043,
-0.3985850512981415,
0.20880697667598724,
0.033029962331056595,
0.7081084847450256,
-0.8326688408851624,
0.39710381627082825,
0.25826749205589294,
-0.01722501777112484,
1.0562206506729126,
-0.16774560511112213,
-0.2520245611667633,
-1.0481222867965698,
0.5116551518440247,
0.6346001625061035,
0.008762857876718044,
-0.28496086597442627,
-0.1225997656583786,
-0.1999874860048294,
-0.0508100651204586,
-0.4331459701061249,
0.7894793152809143,
-0.8072571754455566,
-0.102445587515831,
-0.5094515681266785,
0.16540071368217468,
0.2025536149740219,
0.10965660959482193,
0.34044912457466125,
0.5997323393821716,
-0.036831099539995193,
-0.48585233092308044,
0.4125158190727234,
0.16411320865154266,
-0.3089514970779419,
0.35492730140686035,
-0.6322863101959229,
-0.16046200692653656,
-0.19849734008312225,
0.4017132520675659,
-0.7986799478530884,
0.15978080034255981,
0.10737218707799911,
-0.2253313660621643,
0.5130252838134766,
-0.05633199214935303,
-0.8702081441879272,
-0.5122398734092712,
-0.37848708033561707,
-0.09935831278562546,
-0.03168375417590141,
-0.25063183903694153,
0.6789168119430542,
0.20225533843040466,
-0.5542617440223694,
-0.5566942691802979,
-0.11045672744512558,
0.1816554069519043,
-0.10915209352970123,
0.06945587694644928,
0.24129128456115723,
-0.15681014955043793,
-0.0002524697338230908,
-0.22015763819217682,
-0.48191291093826294,
-0.028776276856660843,
0.22161740064620972,
0.08152797818183899,
0.12297739088535309,
0.005018981173634529,
-0.04366256296634674,
-0.25378721952438354,
-0.1006275936961174,
-0.14937251806259155,
-0.025999058037996292,
0.4863874614238739,
0.4250107407569885,
0.11985328048467636,
-0.4661121964454651,
0.49889716506004333,
0.414227157831192,
-0.07203306257724762,
0.5175638198852539,
0.3719085156917572,
-0.24307017028331757,
-0.48281794786453247,
-0.7335038781166077,
-0.15048494935035706,
-0.4566888213157654,
0.2747020423412323,
-0.4544018507003784,
-0.8411884903907776,
0.28090742230415344,
-0.32518988847732544,
-0.008910533972084522,
0.5248116254806519,
0.2059449851512909,
-0.2564677298069,
0.5399113893508911,
0.9086318612098694,
0.05059661716222763,
0.3983808755874634,
-0.23551934957504272,
0.12880820035934448,
-0.9850844144821167,
-0.40263980627059937,
-0.8878262639045715,
-0.08849181979894638,
-0.5175023078918457,
-0.3841891586780548,
0.1817808449268341,
0.18775106966495514,
-0.012755499221384525,
0.5245767831802368,
-0.6417141556739807,
0.5504694581031799,
0.4325278103351593,
0.1466786414384842,
0.4251459836959839,
0.320130854845047,
0.03322764113545418,
0.026444362476468086,
-0.32998907566070557,
-0.3348483145236969,
0.8917317390441895,
0.38971033692359924,
0.5984450578689575,
-0.2955959141254425,
0.6420572996139526,
-0.09512261301279068,
0.04572325944900513,
-0.6755210757255554,
0.6769054532051086,
-0.31726008653640747,
-0.4907684028148651,
-0.20203055441379547,
-0.729638397693634,
-1.112852931022644,
0.18755927681922913,
-0.2653231620788574,
-1.078799843788147,
0.44821253418922424,
-0.4098498821258545,
-0.3266911208629608,
0.4634518623352051,
-0.13862696290016174,
0.7589849233627319,
-0.12016774713993073,
-0.2406783103942871,
0.16828827559947968,
-0.3576546013355255,
0.07738260179758072,
-0.30093786120414734,
0.21502000093460083,
-0.2751414477825165,
-0.10328010469675064,
0.7406497001647949,
-0.1967720240354538,
0.7283654808998108,
0.22954048216342926,
-0.2920442819595337,
0.363365113735199,
0.27310711145401,
0.364023357629776,
-0.3036825656890869,
-0.08416299521923065,
-0.08230667561292648,
-0.024783087894320488,
-0.1834913194179535,
-0.29936254024505615,
0.46675774455070496,
-0.5596149563789368,
-0.5600060224533081,
-0.630275547504425,
-0.5638401508331299,
-0.12215898931026459,
0.37810343503952026,
0.11647176742553711,
0.09652484953403473,
0.06665868312120438,
0.5270880460739136,
0.7561914324760437,
-0.47623971104621887,
0.7175817489624023,
0.4746569097042084,
0.12136544287204742,
-0.3644392788410187,
1.020576000213623,
0.4099871516227722,
0.09570856392383575,
0.597510576248169,
0.37164968252182007,
-0.1498112827539444,
-0.7822966575622559,
0.01093829981982708,
0.563977837562561,
-0.41759055852890015,
-0.23428863286972046,
-0.9109624624252319,
-0.33704087138175964,
-0.5686426758766174,
0.003891020081937313,
-0.20560763776302338,
-0.6587480902671814,
-0.6754274964332581,
-0.3160443902015686,
0.14031991362571716,
0.8372480869293213,
-0.21381708979606628,
0.21232421696186066,
-0.8436396718025208,
0.5623636841773987,
0.19080191850662231,
0.13512609899044037,
0.3300018012523651,
-0.28864815831184387,
-0.22361239790916443,
-0.40854939818382263,
-0.38873186707496643,
-0.9655904769897461,
0.2999238967895508,
0.10383147746324539,
0.6852226853370667,
0.04842182248830795,
-0.0021814117208123207,
0.6460117697715759,
-0.3067418932914734,
0.832114040851593,
0.0005015525966882706,
-0.7942339777946472,
0.672077476978302,
-0.5327653884887695,
0.17180250585079193,
0.5861033797264099,
0.8080013990402222,
-0.3624531924724579,
-0.1868339627981186,
-0.7635250091552734,
-1.255955696105957,
0.6145286560058594,
0.08604642748832703,
-0.18267644941806793,
-0.3860800564289093,
0.43864014744758606,
-0.020790383219718933,
0.15598925948143005,
-0.9264640808105469,
0.14676626026630402,
0.3314187526702881,
-0.26982581615448,
0.12788787484169006,
-0.5605181455612183,
0.03554029017686844,
-0.05377373471856117,
0.5768388509750366,
-0.2766752243041992,
-0.04311256483197212,
0.44157347083091736,
-0.11736869812011719,
-0.0693451538681984,
0.16161946952342987,
0.37533536553382874,
0.8323346972465515,
-0.30505844950675964,
0.2290191352367401,
0.037238746881484985,
-0.3616437613964081,
0.08482737839221954,
0.2891468107700348,
-0.039756543934345245,
0.10638875514268875,
0.40412768721580505,
0.05236101523041725,
-0.04086939990520477,
-0.8922616243362427,
0.6365014314651489,
0.08559056371450424,
0.07322726398706436,
-0.22095316648483276,
-0.5149009823799133,
-0.0856122225522995,
0.017521876841783524,
0.6008337140083313,
-0.6255740523338318,
0.2057713270187378,
-0.5186383128166199,
0.4904928207397461,
0.29154834151268005,
-0.051617544144392014,
-0.11508224904537201,
0.2010008692741394,
0.04318821430206299,
0.18784867227077484,
0.43940144777297974,
-0.012274923734366894,
-0.05257251113653183,
0.7266777753829956,
0.6413913369178772,
0.6984137296676636,
0.042933858931064606,
0.38659191131591797,
0.45859912037849426,
0.22295984625816345,
-0.38363274931907654,
0.016434352844953537,
-0.18759965896606445,
-0.37686464190483093,
-0.7282652854919434,
-0.9437246322631836,
-0.4181355834007263,
0.2453051060438156,
-0.5326825976371765,
0.19616875052452087,
-0.7423052787780762,
0.14943435788154602,
0.1763359159231186,
0.36271703243255615,
-0.21076330542564392,
0.18174776434898376,
0.33237573504447937,
1.1740719079971313,
-0.8398732542991638,
0.619504451751709,
0.32434919476509094,
-0.5494804978370667,
-0.7138605117797852,
-0.3286512792110443,
0.1325826644897461,
-0.18973378837108612,
0.6895575523376465,
0.13878194987773895,
0.16443662345409393,
-0.34919607639312744,
-0.5410081148147583,
-0.8094608187675476,
0.975644588470459,
0.018949739634990692,
-0.5518364310264587,
-0.37354934215545654,
0.2926388680934906,
0.2627975046634674,
-0.23556195199489594,
0.427486389875412,
0.613620936870575,
0.425954669713974,
-0.015068955719470978,
-1.1526157855987549,
0.23400837182998657,
-0.32796868681907654,
0.0943741723895073,
0.06656963378190994,
-0.5470889210700989,
0.9331638813018799,
0.3875502049922943,
-0.13929951190948486,
0.5233206152915955,
0.7587118744850159,
0.5152350664138794,
0.044131115078926086,
0.4152106046676636,
0.6399211287498474,
0.4485875964164734,
-0.026971565559506416,
0.9331504702568054,
0.1946234554052353,
0.39160043001174927,
1.3505547046661377,
-0.21809464693069458,
0.861757755279541,
0.5889964699745178,
0.007792808581143618,
0.45125678181648254,
0.5473769307136536,
-0.4999534785747528,
0.1110144630074501,
0.31991249322891235,
-0.23961196839809418,
-0.0712570995092392,
-0.46205776929855347,
0.035446587949991226,
0.3816192150115967,
0.46889176964759827,
-0.3341251015663147,
-0.44903361797332764,
-0.21408525109291077,
0.27189356088638306,
-0.0009504698100499809,
-0.21049493551254272,
0.9266330599784851,
0.43029865622520447,
-0.47540876269340515,
-0.010016434825956821,
0.02082069218158722,
0.8024665117263794,
-0.46826818585395813,
-0.19695205986499786,
-0.09714291989803314,
0.05860048159956932,
-0.1669255495071411,
-0.7787414789199829,
0.12844066321849823,
0.06608723104000092,
-0.27221596240997314,
-0.2921428084373474,
0.6744743585586548,
-0.29227185249328613,
-0.484135240316391,
0.2659367322921753,
0.511822521686554,
-0.06124844774603844,
0.0011539245024323463,
-0.6340305209159851,
-0.019874772056937218,
-0.04307476058602333,
-0.5402523875236511,
0.40551120042800903,
0.5399965643882751,
0.05339404568076134,
0.3678945004940033,
0.8745059370994568,
0.5838635563850403,
-0.23601758480072021,
-0.3806241750717163,
0.6287839412689209,
-0.6825960278511047,
0.0037969572003930807,
-0.8576979637145996,
0.6580086946487427,
-0.5066578984260559,
-0.4262082874774933,
0.8999291062355042,
0.5304364562034607,
0.6552572846412659,
0.1277332603931427,
0.6359677910804749,
-0.09892163425683975,
0.7452623248100281,
-0.3124554455280304,
0.3611348867416382,
-0.4037036597728729,
0.1536281406879425,
-0.528083860874176,
-1.167578935623169,
-0.2657925486564636,
0.46731793880462646,
-0.01985948160290718,
-0.0833563357591629,
0.7087504863739014,
0.4870333969593048,
-0.17643027007579803,
-0.1914627104997635,
-0.18267859518527985,
0.27403923869132996,
0.580696165561676,
0.2058231085538864,
0.6344990134239197,
-0.1156509518623352,
0.6239711046218872,
-0.5230929255485535,
0.004629139788448811,
-0.10638712346553802,
-1.2753024101257324,
-0.8029076457023621,
-0.33741867542266846,
-0.4589419662952423,
-0.5404348373413086,
-0.14800365269184113,
0.9592474699020386,
0.5721566677093506,
-0.7113944888114929,
-0.44586747884750366,
-0.015926044434309006,
0.08424963057041168,
-0.040947504341602325,
-0.26906338334083557,
0.6195732951164246,
-0.00810763705521822,
-0.8395139575004578,
0.557330846786499,
0.24781696498394012,
0.3443886339664459,
-0.13645143806934357,
0.6050119400024414,
-0.4761512577533722,
0.030298201367259026,
0.49348184466362,
0.6982387900352478,
-0.3988496661186218,
-0.2780623435974121,
-0.2086714506149292,
0.0806909054517746,
-0.09360212087631226,
0.8610643148422241,
-0.5221155285835266,
0.4405539333820343,
0.88078373670578,
0.6065108180046082,
0.6769613027572632,
-0.019683053717017174,
0.6382215619087219,
-0.992681086063385,
0.11390668898820877,
0.1599055975675583,
0.455363005399704,
0.416635662317276,
-0.1429874151945114,
0.5663025975227356,
0.3608444631099701,
-0.50059574842453,
-0.9138041138648987,
-0.05231102183461189,
-1.3017653226852417,
-0.8934844732284546,
1.2692445516586304,
-0.27841660380363464,
-0.4944611191749573,
-0.03183845430612564,
-0.09192972630262375,
0.2193721979856491,
-0.06947015970945358,
0.61632239818573,
0.6908560395240784,
0.054406169801950455,
-0.7086710333824158,
-0.5416821837425232,
0.24143405258655548,
0.04201735183596611,
-0.6852670907974243,
0.18352153897285461,
0.3426796793937683,
0.4149499237537384,
0.35608842968940735,
0.4579736292362213,
-0.22734659910202026,
0.1910587102174759,
-0.24077868461608887,
0.09232320636510849,
-0.16799816489219666,
-0.5809903144836426,
-0.3340148329734802,
0.5289450287818909,
-0.07583104074001312,
0.41956570744514465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00252v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00252v2
|
EUROPA: A Legal Multilingual Keyphrase Generation Dataset
| 2024-03-01T03:30:38 | 2024-06-14T13:51:01 |
Olivier Salaün, Frédéric Piedboeuf, Guillaume Le Berre, David Alfonso Hermelo, Philippe Langlais
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Keyphrase generation has primarily been explored within the context of
academic research articles, with a particular focus on scientific domains and
the English language. In this work, we present EUROPA, a dataset for
multilingual keyphrase generation in the legal domain. It is derived from legal
judgments from the Court of Justice of the European Union (EU), and contains
instances in all 24 EU official languages. We run multilingual models on our
corpus and analyze the results, showing room for improvement on a
domain-specific multilingual corpus such as the one we present.
|
[
-0.07431580126285553,
-0.2779379189014435,
0.7508075833320618,
-0.11947179585695267,
-0.5950220227241516,
0.13092868030071259,
-0.20383970439434052,
-0.16743049025535583,
0.3925643861293793,
0.7381517887115479,
-0.5234032273292542,
-0.9642711877822876,
-0.6816429495811462,
0.497490793466568,
-0.32185378670692444,
0.9676153063774109,
0.17145361006259918,
0.6348395943641663,
0.25112268328666687,
-0.5046201348304749,
-0.24713250994682312,
-0.6952532529830933,
-0.06229927018284798,
0.4268113374710083,
0.6693195104598999,
0.7489656209945679,
0.41402459144592285,
0.4376475214958191,
0.9579185247421265,
0.24742743372917175,
-0.03693947568535805,
0.0864429622888565,
-0.303475022315979,
0.44727757573127747,
-0.41805586218833923,
-0.6045523881912231,
-0.35814017057418823,
-0.3873049020767212,
0.5121561288833618,
0.24680502712726593,
-0.2278522402048111,
0.21539944410324097,
-0.3548664450645447,
0.6011878252029419,
-0.5605224967002869,
0.017998525872826576,
-0.9972292184829712,
0.31613996624946594,
-0.6141485571861267,
-0.28238052129745483,
-0.1912241280078888,
-0.3732547163963318,
-0.07157360762357712,
-0.6147505640983582,
0.4043199419975281,
0.1586313247680664,
0.5818722248077393,
0.02829219587147236,
-0.6744614243507385,
-0.7697198987007141,
-0.3008955717086792,
0.46170732378959656,
-0.5443621873855591,
0.6927701234817505,
0.05982077866792679,
0.4096299707889557,
-0.0997558981180191,
-1.0329011678695679,
-0.49770909547805786,
-0.2071252465248108,
0.35337457060813904,
0.34968242049217224,
0.03914392739534378,
-0.19955524802207947,
-0.24661575257778168,
-0.08615119010210037,
-0.8299914002418518,
-0.02908811718225479,
-0.9064806699752808,
0.029189206659793854,
0.33180487155914307,
-0.0749891921877861,
0.40762871503829956,
-0.37698057293891907,
0.33955010771751404,
-0.38097989559173584,
-1.2355868816375732,
-0.2593768239021301,
0.8239180445671082,
0.7634900808334351,
0.19016394019126892,
0.656551718711853,
0.024561524391174316,
0.2806828022003174,
-0.1277860552072525,
-0.1601586490869522,
0.3830665647983551,
-0.4464419186115265,
0.3251447379589081,
0.3587680757045746,
0.6192470192909241,
0.6053963899612427,
0.050689008086919785,
-0.47751128673553467,
0.15701279044151306,
0.1634710282087326,
0.36272719502449036,
-0.8273319005966187,
-0.1451822966337204,
0.5375180244445801,
-0.35337626934051514,
-0.43900182843208313,
0.38770735263824463,
-1.0002802610397339,
-0.013448427431285381,
-0.08674776554107666,
-0.014759000390768051,
-0.31064867973327637,
-0.09084796160459518,
0.352696031332016,
-0.4770117998123169,
-0.21904446184635162,
-0.2050594985485077,
-0.3943423926830292,
-0.046008236706256866,
0.5730553269386292,
0.49480706453323364,
0.02442655712366104,
-0.2896958887577057,
-0.5731323957443237,
0.22869350016117096,
-0.4025472402572632,
0.6666079163551331,
-0.8595947027206421,
-0.5370321869850159,
0.555106520652771,
0.25207966566085815,
0.0916745513677597,
-0.4575851559638977,
1.1616344451904297,
-0.7858973741531372,
0.250736266374588,
-0.27984243631362915,
-0.5023511052131653,
-0.12324430793523788,
-0.04605545476078987,
-0.749396800994873,
0.6829819083213806,
-0.42898839712142944,
-0.7558467984199524,
1.0570077896118164,
-1.0490542650222778,
-0.5651792287826538,
0.3436233401298523,
-0.45480507612228394,
-0.4934854805469513,
0.1396234780550003,
-0.11038567125797272,
0.3596777617931366,
-0.03384998440742493,
0.4823305606842041,
-0.27890416979789734,
0.3983350098133087,
0.22598020732402802,
0.0009091230458579957,
0.5237182974815369,
0.6252861022949219,
-0.5212612152099609,
-0.13477011024951935,
-0.8340765833854675,
0.013112368062138557,
0.011270972900092602,
-0.372626394033432,
-0.3751995861530304,
0.2579934298992157,
0.45524725317955017,
0.49074816703796387,
0.3597226142883301,
-1.1017487049102783,
0.030782409012317657,
-0.016500646248459816,
0.6829634308815002,
0.3877016305923462,
0.23016025125980377,
0.05473396182060242,
0.003115288680419326,
0.7956021428108215,
0.12694880366325378,
-0.26129353046417236,
0.1407259851694107,
-0.5599672198295593,
-0.18416929244995117,
-0.24415811896324158,
0.8370012640953064,
0.6367033123970032,
-0.5033362507820129,
0.4394841194152832,
-0.5834309458732605,
-0.40389543771743774,
-0.8547558784484863,
0.1328076720237732,
0.4339037239551544,
-0.04910719022154808,
0.14834117889404297,
0.10575675219297409,
-0.5872554779052734,
-0.9013328552246094,
-0.3175777196884155,
0.021964674815535545,
0.18073368072509766,
0.458584189414978,
0.9794500470161438,
-0.061654288321733475,
0.7082936763763428,
-0.19464077055454254,
-0.4212000072002411,
-0.33271220326423645,
0.11871451884508133,
0.34544575214385986,
0.3310118317604065,
0.6366512775421143,
-1.2718154191970825,
-0.8117889761924744,
0.15307551622390747,
-0.7575830221176147,
0.01972927525639534,
0.0896473154425621,
-0.2761097848415375,
-0.20932480692863464,
0.548474907875061,
-0.5174087882041931,
-0.03711140528321266,
0.49751991033554077,
-0.833605945110321,
0.26473742723464966,
-0.47151750326156616,
0.5139808654785156,
-1.5997192859649658,
0.4016600251197815,
-0.25287461280822754,
-0.2617882788181305,
-0.5338452458381653,
0.5990422964096069,
0.2943337559700012,
-0.2662225663661957,
-0.7915850281715393,
0.3534829616546631,
-0.2997538149356842,
0.16180481016635895,
0.019560877233743668,
0.2753409445285797,
-0.04372624680399895,
-0.009935482405126095,
0.06180993467569351,
0.9733101725578308,
0.6143441200256348,
-0.5888015627861023,
0.15504932403564453,
0.6426753997802734,
-0.35858193039894104,
0.7044560313224792,
-0.4980883300304413,
-0.18495668470859528,
-0.18794949352741241,
0.02478797547519207,
-0.5929247736930847,
-0.463238924741745,
-0.15195970237255096,
-0.31509071588516235,
-0.0395813062787056,
-0.1901915818452835,
-0.8157936334609985,
-0.5566304922103882,
-0.07976817339658737,
0.16596701741218567,
0.30027055740356445,
-0.4687473177909851,
0.17497001588344574,
0.6483173370361328,
-0.6557331085205078,
-0.44620150327682495,
-0.5065680742263794,
0.4964858889579773,
-0.7821342945098877,
-0.6598795056343079,
0.38043877482414246,
-0.02247767709195614,
-0.2309858202934265,
0.08786150813102722,
0.402543306350708,
-0.16576190292835236,
0.058846186846494675,
0.13792218267917633,
-0.20757713913917542,
-0.04141435772180557,
0.10146017372608185,
0.30566421151161194,
0.2729201912879944,
0.10220478475093842,
-0.22907692193984985,
0.47456619143486023,
0.293515682220459,
-0.3866751790046692,
-0.37014827132225037,
0.794201672077179,
0.9106003046035767,
-0.33684220910072327,
0.22084060311317444,
-0.08112549781799316,
-0.047589149326086044,
-0.010593992657959461,
-0.038821741938591,
-0.3500485122203827,
-0.40374699234962463,
0.4514603912830353,
-0.8513052463531494,
-0.6446956992149353,
0.5966651439666748,
0.052847567945718765,
0.6353775858879089,
0.7218595743179321,
0.8282862305641174,
0.12322232127189636,
0.9978196024894714,
0.5723569393157959,
-0.22915039956569672,
0.16708683967590332,
-0.047967586666345596,
0.3445136845111847,
-0.42730581760406494,
0.10170648247003555,
-0.9715343713760376,
-0.1391947716474533,
-1.0074018239974976,
-0.15464287996292114,
0.6628955006599426,
-0.23090584576129913,
0.2037925124168396,
0.5804948210716248,
-0.2682325541973114,
0.3884747624397278,
0.9480561017990112,
0.1601557582616806,
0.18161281943321228,
0.1253589242696762,
-0.8099458813667297,
-0.2302970439195633,
-0.7664307951927185,
-0.7744904160499573,
1.7571717500686646,
0.019505102187395096,
0.26486217975616455,
0.5095975399017334,
0.9630144238471985,
0.5385218858718872,
-0.26234710216522217,
-0.21675357222557068,
0.19878673553466797,
-0.5448811650276184,
-1.1981700658798218,
-0.22223526239395142,
-0.40878403186798096,
-1.407799243927002,
0.4603192210197449,
-0.06519650667905807,
-0.40136075019836426,
0.08133140206336975,
-0.17780698835849762,
-0.5519353747367859,
0.08974707871675491,
-0.07818866521120071,
0.9716472625732422,
-0.2328166514635086,
-0.2203764170408249,
-0.5219368934631348,
-0.7030932307243347,
0.04780178889632225,
-0.31082648038864136,
0.4621600806713104,
-0.04306642338633537,
0.3748512268066406,
1.0204054117202759,
-0.3520108163356781,
0.39376014471054077,
-0.315540075302124,
-0.14941304922103882,
0.24148117005825043,
0.013380322605371475,
0.44688981771469116,
0.16137728095054626,
-0.02064693346619606,
-0.210520401597023,
0.14817287027835846,
-0.08643200993537903,
0.10639410465955734,
0.3986615538597107,
-0.5084556937217712,
-0.07181286811828613,
-0.21736067533493042,
-0.4203881025314331,
-0.02251788042485714,
0.3611634075641632,
0.5549507141113281,
0.335408478975296,
-0.36476707458496094,
0.5097514986991882,
0.5299106240272522,
-0.22043085098266602,
0.19591741263866425,
0.8496096134185791,
-0.13438796997070312,
-0.520267903804779,
0.9663776755332947,
0.21489998698234558,
-0.25677335262298584,
0.28229978680610657,
-0.1466989368200302,
-0.6891182065010071,
-0.33001551032066345,
-0.5344619750976562,
0.18186330795288086,
-0.7054448127746582,
-0.0739268958568573,
-0.656446099281311,
0.23876911401748657,
-0.7886757850646973,
-0.07852907478809357,
-0.1374519318342209,
-0.7613151669502258,
0.128149151802063,
-0.4201638996601105,
0.4603245258331299,
0.6158917546272278,
-0.33922621607780457,
0.36169886589050293,
-0.9777970910072327,
0.6757348775863647,
0.011661789380013943,
-0.11045557260513306,
-0.8187143802642822,
-0.5657487511634827,
-0.10664808005094528,
-0.028797976672649384,
-0.5125489830970764,
-0.9090760350227356,
0.5065606832504272,
0.5078678727149963,
0.5499982833862305,
0.42021018266677856,
-0.01917121559381485,
0.4115254580974579,
-1.349851131439209,
0.874226987361908,
0.05469641834497452,
-0.4183271527290344,
0.6250307559967041,
-0.42812514305114746,
0.03598186746239662,
0.822031557559967,
0.4199255406856537,
-0.6715835928916931,
-1.1606465578079224,
-1.071272611618042,
-1.0527602434158325,
0.23169279098510742,
0.3378262221813202,
0.34029677510261536,
0.07753664255142212,
0.10848399251699448,
0.39777320623397827,
0.4813603162765503,
-0.5715593695640564,
-0.03586699068546295,
0.18692928552627563,
-0.4977010488510132,
-0.02811664342880249,
-0.03137196600437164,
-0.5303760170936584,
0.15439236164093018,
0.7716830372810364,
-0.050873611122369766,
0.2769443392753601,
0.018263457342982292,
-0.35827919840812683,
-0.08351673930883408,
0.48489707708358765,
0.764371395111084,
0.787588357925415,
-0.08233902603387833,
-0.11123869568109512,
-0.2748236060142517,
-0.45148009061813354,
0.05562837794423103,
0.18289005756378174,
-0.271628201007843,
0.7088306546211243,
0.10994534194469452,
0.44140028953552246,
0.1419418901205063,
-0.9338061213493347,
0.484423965215683,
-0.2100655734539032,
-0.8146460652351379,
-0.2355048805475235,
-0.31330105662345886,
-0.029559532180428505,
0.26206326484680176,
0.4975323975086212,
-0.40919700264930725,
0.47848841547966003,
-0.44669660925865173,
0.8096450567245483,
0.34449830651283264,
0.2880735695362091,
-0.3981795608997345,
1.0479414463043213,
0.2622091770172119,
-0.026033278554677963,
0.3216061592102051,
-0.08593308925628662,
-0.7652028203010559,
0.5354122519493103,
0.1342482566833496,
0.8267408609390259,
0.06894438713788986,
0.3804522454738617,
0.37447473406791687,
0.11614116281270981,
0.17462757229804993,
1.0761427879333496,
0.024360138922929764,
-0.5885586738586426,
-0.00017078619566746056,
-0.6197644472122192,
-0.5225552916526794,
0.04753047972917557,
-0.5696077942848206,
-0.05892195925116539,
0.01592971570789814,
-0.5560114979743958,
0.11929868906736374,
-0.21485553681850433,
-0.8099467158317566,
0.18262314796447754,
0.032693639397621155,
0.8332221508026123,
-0.9569925665855408,
0.6307632327079773,
0.6762317419052124,
-0.23277094960212708,
-0.19731761515140533,
-0.4101257622241974,
-0.21756267547607422,
-0.6364257335662842,
1.09596848487854,
0.049851179122924805,
0.1950945407152176,
-0.2513810098171234,
-0.41733109951019287,
-0.7003561854362488,
0.796345591545105,
0.1774892807006836,
-0.7441880106925964,
-0.053965989500284195,
0.6504986882209778,
0.5081884264945984,
-0.35682064294815063,
-0.4775524139404297,
0.4050174355506897,
0.6017591953277588,
-0.3389076888561249,
-0.8217169642448425,
-0.3485007882118225,
-0.4826253056526184,
-0.37876757979393005,
0.12436416745185852,
-0.37525635957717896,
0.7446640729904175,
0.29452893137931824,
-0.03273428604006767,
0.07253348082304001,
0.5658119916915894,
0.4991157352924347,
-0.2247631698846817,
0.2455965280532837,
0.8089790940284729,
0.9595557451248169,
-0.08998306095600128,
0.7895711064338684,
-1.4551239013671875,
0.14772869646549225,
1.0304754972457886,
-0.4781779646873474,
1.0082370042800903,
0.7086988687515259,
0.09488130360841751,
0.29807451367378235,
0.6215180158615112,
-0.13285699486732483,
0.9547030925750732,
0.04612429812550545,
-0.16703175008296967,
-0.006033825688064098,
-0.009953277185559273,
-0.3614880442619324,
0.4254240095615387,
0.31259143352508545,
-0.658717691898346,
-0.5019719004631042,
0.13739922642707825,
0.12459506094455719,
-0.03845282644033432,
-0.010641560889780521,
0.8852006793022156,
-0.11456342786550522,
-0.6715832352638245,
-0.008077959530055523,
0.30874013900756836,
0.24831052124500275,
-0.3350008726119995,
0.019764848053455353,
-0.08539384603500366,
0.25130075216293335,
0.17719605565071106,
-0.7881267666816711,
-0.12167535722255707,
0.6451436281204224,
-0.004936503246426582,
-0.4317716062068939,
0.05884433910250664,
-0.4659369885921478,
-0.8700434565544128,
0.10178688913583755,
0.5773434042930603,
0.6397185921669006,
0.09573380649089813,
-0.8172402381896973,
-0.42361781001091003,
-0.163127139210701,
-0.19777275621891022,
0.020758086815476418,
0.9993956089019775,
0.20016194880008698,
0.36370816826820374,
0.6193375587463379,
0.44786569476127625,
0.8172778487205505,
0.1601322740316391,
0.5852019190788269,
-0.5625410676002502,
-0.8069456219673157,
-0.5033649206161499,
0.7140326499938965,
-0.11473236232995987,
-0.751912534236908,
0.8064053654670715,
0.884253203868866,
0.6132146120071411,
-0.36482420563697815,
1.2522517442703247,
-0.3786303699016571,
0.7517093420028687,
-0.7426452040672302,
0.6892932653427124,
-0.6219848990440369,
-0.48876044154167175,
-0.13546288013458252,
-0.8349922895431519,
-0.3325343728065491,
0.482352614402771,
0.15091140568256378,
-0.40211009979248047,
0.7281556725502014,
0.6782777309417725,
-0.1373845487833023,
-0.3637439012527466,
0.43607404828071594,
-0.13179729878902435,
0.38744789361953735,
0.13955539464950562,
0.4285171926021576,
-0.48560672998428345,
0.4346776306629181,
-0.15311963856220245,
0.2377350777387619,
-0.3303053379058838,
-0.48199546337127686,
-0.5846896767616272,
-0.6312897205352783,
0.025731688365340233,
-0.32269224524497986,
0.21100790798664093,
0.7608799338340759,
0.40939977765083313,
-1.1531453132629395,
-0.4390844702720642,
-0.38759946823120117,
-0.3415967524051666,
0.30601996183395386,
-0.16001535952091217,
0.3668305575847626,
-0.7371952533721924,
-0.826240599155426,
0.5811597108840942,
-0.07554572075605392,
-0.14848800003528595,
-0.11628895998001099,
-0.17395463585853577,
-0.2051030695438385,
0.10613977164030075,
0.34115204215049744,
0.11001555621623993,
-0.5526316165924072,
-0.12916943430900574,
0.036759208887815475,
-0.22864611446857452,
0.2565499544143677,
1.0096251964569092,
0.07820980995893478,
0.32638344168663025,
0.3042735457420349,
0.4808799922466278,
0.09415168315172195,
-0.2090141773223877,
0.7396116852760315,
-0.5646732449531555,
0.17728421092033386,
0.22071149945259094,
0.8336313366889954,
0.08454539626836777,
-0.18943993747234344,
0.5435814261436462,
0.09717727452516556,
-0.7209614515304565,
-0.7680578231811523,
0.16575530171394348,
-0.5063938498497009,
-0.3934365510940552,
1.1358994245529175,
-0.2923468351364136,
-0.3360392451286316,
0.040168456733226776,
-0.13343220949172974,
0.07758036255836487,
-0.6147875785827637,
1.0288758277893066,
0.8231863975524902,
0.5158403515815735,
0.3366001844406128,
-0.7204342484474182,
0.5358085632324219,
0.4517955780029297,
-0.7820262312889099,
0.08340944349765778,
0.6423120498657227,
0.29788362979888916,
0.5368765592575073,
0.13363657891750336,
-0.3263658881187439,
0.5116012692451477,
-0.015836497768759727,
0.26832759380340576,
0.6474794745445251,
-0.841288149356842,
-0.13287630677223206,
0.48848801851272583,
-0.005800308659672737,
-0.18523947894573212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00867v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00867v2
|
Gradient Cuff: Detecting Jailbreak Attacks on Large Language Models by Exploring Refusal Loss Landscapes
| 2024-03-01T03:29:54 | 2024-03-05T13:46:50 |
Xiaomeng Hu, Pin-Yu Chen, Tsung-Yi Ho
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are becoming a prominent generative AI tool,
where the user enters a query and the LLM generates an answer. To reduce harm
and misuse, efforts have been made to align these LLMs to human values using
advanced training techniques such as Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback
(RLHF). However, recent studies have highlighted the vulnerability of LLMs to
adversarial jailbreak attempts aiming at subverting the embedded safety
guardrails. To address this challenge, this paper defines and investigates the
Refusal Loss of LLMs and then proposes a method called Gradient Cuff to detect
jailbreak attempts. Gradient Cuff exploits the unique properties observed in
the refusal loss landscape, including functional values and its smoothness, to
design an effective two-step detection strategy. Experimental results on two
aligned LLMs (LLaMA-2-7B-Chat and Vicuna-7B-V1.5) and six types of jailbreak
attacks (GCG, AutoDAN, PAIR, TAP, Base64, and LRL) show that Gradient Cuff can
significantly improve the LLM's rejection capability for malicious jailbreak
queries, while maintaining the model's performance for benign user queries by
adjusting the detection threshold.
|
[
-0.4215802550315857,
-1.0183027982711792,
0.3608110547065735,
0.13605353236198425,
-0.21364645659923553,
0.36553841829299927,
-0.1194448471069336,
-0.15861545503139496,
0.17541849613189697,
0.7680790424346924,
-0.6334459781646729,
-0.5456365942955017,
-0.6886819005012512,
-0.299548476934433,
-0.7405463457107544,
1.219982385635376,
-0.10704988241195679,
-0.013219336979091167,
0.27806276082992554,
-0.21746787428855896,
-0.54945969581604,
-0.41427943110466003,
-0.7466509342193604,
-0.24389687180519104,
0.47223299741744995,
0.09686139971017838,
0.5870799422264099,
0.43537813425064087,
0.40342551469802856,
0.2292836308479309,
-0.21869264543056488,
-0.05448228865861893,
-0.4219634234905243,
0.18953390419483185,
0.15308932960033417,
-0.6439308524131775,
-0.2751428484916687,
-0.0008260984905064106,
0.3654889762401581,
0.28058546781539917,
-0.23227743804454803,
0.015501393936574459,
0.0017379075288772583,
0.896631121635437,
-0.6751521825790405,
-0.43651333451271057,
-0.7404025197029114,
0.06831768900156021,
-0.4967264235019684,
-0.00382071640342474,
-0.4037701189517975,
-0.0923948884010315,
-0.19476433098316193,
0.022373365238308907,
0.26879048347473145,
0.1376618593931198,
0.5259019732475281,
0.21844428777694702,
-0.16611789166927338,
-0.18333542346954346,
-0.476855993270874,
0.371245801448822,
-0.5296537280082703,
0.31023210287094116,
0.4629659652709961,
0.21936437487602234,
-0.6579630970954895,
-0.3001822829246521,
-0.620908796787262,
-0.6605515480041504,
0.1538347601890564,
-0.2071455866098404,
-0.09718238562345505,
0.0342845693230629,
0.05226685106754303,
0.054378360509872437,
-0.7523704171180725,
0.48480090498924255,
-0.35256630182266235,
-0.31005537509918213,
0.4230780601501465,
0.22054652869701385,
0.3773305118083954,
-0.13268409669399261,
-0.5733861327171326,
-0.1552402824163437,
-0.9078781008720398,
0.24848492443561554,
0.7459896206855774,
0.1366564780473709,
-0.2760484218597412,
0.3500756025314331,
0.10627298802137375,
0.78969407081604,
-0.09325115382671356,
0.034066446125507355,
0.13104452192783356,
0.14895954728126526,
-0.1056283488869667,
-0.14034365117549896,
0.8738524913787842,
0.37881651520729065,
0.21297527849674225,
-0.1819281131029129,
-0.4362463355064392,
-0.18640467524528503,
0.22973421216011047,
-0.5863457918167114,
-0.14483463764190674,
0.5113580822944641,
-0.5335994958877563,
-0.5660789012908936,
-0.07542218267917633,
-0.7278920412063599,
-1.2009974718093872,
0.21788690984249115,
0.12112390249967575,
-0.600139856338501,
-0.26920631527900696,
0.02713569812476635,
-0.3426688611507416,
0.44815754890441895,
0.23993289470672607,
-0.8933733105659485,
0.38415905833244324,
0.7747021317481995,
1.1353120803833008,
-0.05444779247045517,
-0.3022032380104065,
-0.9038511514663696,
-0.16637766361236572,
-0.15200892090797424,
0.47787362337112427,
-0.1179196834564209,
-0.584059476852417,
0.041084177792072296,
-0.3421221673488617,
-0.1156778559088707,
-0.7322354912757874,
0.7122136950492859,
-0.7516261339187622,
-0.4228014349937439,
0.27186909317970276,
-0.25663378834724426,
-0.02216780185699463,
0.611752450466156,
-0.6985460519790649,
0.728111743927002,
-0.014099852181971073,
-0.8422415852546692,
0.07519221305847168,
-0.43219345808029175,
-0.5577842593193054,
-0.21468953788280487,
-0.02220151573419571,
-0.5890087485313416,
0.08824097365140915,
0.2164967954158783,
0.3810129761695862,
-0.27179157733917236,
0.0839158222079277,
-0.5471768379211426,
-0.24547189474105835,
0.5368533730506897,
-0.40578675270080566,
0.8560628294944763,
0.2345902919769287,
-0.3792729377746582,
0.1456919014453888,
-0.6567555665969849,
-0.23521557450294495,
0.21639645099639893,
-0.46530506014823914,
-0.4220597743988037,
0.34065890312194824,
0.32017725706100464,
0.0658392533659935,
-0.10704058408737183,
-0.6606184840202332,
0.12076466530561447,
-0.4021100401878357,
0.6374411582946777,
1.005794644355774,
-0.3692517578601837,
0.27896934747695923,
-0.17455008625984192,
0.6233344674110413,
-0.05868338793516159,
0.2271949052810669,
0.3038623631000519,
-0.19130346179008484,
-0.6310542821884155,
-0.34935662150382996,
0.32388341426849365,
0.8029537200927734,
-0.4069897532463074,
0.4208946228027344,
0.09999515116214752,
-0.47482141852378845,
-0.584895133972168,
0.3164415657520294,
0.3699352741241455,
0.6364945769309998,
0.23794829845428467,
-0.4968183636665344,
-0.3760659098625183,
-0.7513384819030762,
-0.5164949297904968,
-0.4079778492450714,
-0.1822938472032547,
0.17261849343776703,
0.5011383891105652,
-0.2982710003852844,
0.5699599981307983,
-0.23965346813201904,
-0.47318390011787415,
-0.4085157513618469,
0.05461074411869049,
0.22221580147743225,
0.4984240233898163,
0.6813340783119202,
-0.5960326790809631,
-0.0865074023604393,
-0.32303810119628906,
-0.399151086807251,
-0.0024297544732689857,
-0.1825154572725296,
0.042994424700737,
0.17012491822242737,
0.6369131803512573,
-0.4467634856700897,
0.616401195526123,
0.5488300323486328,
-0.2032046616077423,
0.5898578763008118,
-0.011041395366191864,
-0.12495795637369156,
-0.6809632182121277,
-0.09431755542755127,
0.16018451750278473,
-0.2112397998571396,
-0.7015707492828369,
0.10217422246932983,
0.17163583636283875,
-0.007867760956287384,
-0.46773961186408997,
0.5792174339294434,
-0.06446277350187302,
0.12028191983699799,
-0.2589704990386963,
0.13972516357898712,
-0.34863582253456116,
0.30708494782447815,
-0.1797335296869278,
0.5677472949028015,
0.47213345766067505,
-0.4645044803619385,
0.3837467432022095,
0.1429070681333542,
-0.3483318090438843,
0.36182770133018494,
-0.6668010354042053,
0.26037833094596863,
-0.3501991629600525,
0.650700569152832,
-1.2216026782989502,
-0.13944119215011597,
0.4817720949649811,
-0.5697854161262512,
0.20950859785079956,
-0.49145424365997314,
-0.17081314325332642,
-0.42136266827583313,
-0.882699728012085,
0.14554913341999054,
0.48417383432388306,
-0.6424074769020081,
0.3801236152648926,
0.38574767112731934,
-0.004202680662274361,
-0.8138432502746582,
-0.7924747467041016,
0.14780838787555695,
-0.4169115722179413,
-0.6010491847991943,
0.27410009503364563,
-0.008988586254417896,
-0.21424564719200134,
-0.34178081154823303,
-0.03865319490432739,
0.02770620957016945,
0.6547126770019531,
0.3583087623119354,
0.4150022864341736,
0.2130471169948578,
-0.15464332699775696,
-0.2488366812467575,
0.030520064756274223,
0.3237437605857849,
-0.23378972709178925,
0.8781841397285461,
-0.12134803086519241,
-0.3451710343360901,
-0.5077146887779236,
0.13938790559768677,
0.6119117140769958,
-0.2960595190525055,
0.8966521620750427,
0.6496959328651428,
-0.11464761942625046,
-0.3945167660713196,
-0.36871060729026794,
-0.2306828647851944,
-0.4782278537750244,
0.37040141224861145,
-0.3052029609680176,
-1.0159556865692139,
0.7402140498161316,
-0.03346060961484909,
-0.029730789363384247,
0.1412472277879715,
0.6072080731391907,
-0.19359561800956726,
0.7837631106376648,
0.34702539443969727,
-0.76902836561203,
0.6353268623352051,
-0.23373854160308838,
0.3501133620738983,
-1.1120165586471558,
-0.17895391583442688,
-0.7027279138565063,
-0.4818187654018402,
-0.7140487432479858,
-0.06583225727081299,
0.5396742820739746,
0.21763156354427338,
-0.4098374545574188,
0.17179006338119507,
-0.28929403424263,
0.32827651500701904,
0.5017342567443848,
0.45422279834747314,
0.022444188594818115,
-0.006394263356924057,
-0.19242066144943237,
0.28051191568374634,
-0.26980987191200256,
-0.26858919858932495,
1.2511159181594849,
0.5603067874908447,
1.1601868867874146,
0.49363741278648376,
0.7424805164337158,
0.5680930614471436,
0.46883928775787354,
-0.8763322234153748,
0.5826770663261414,
0.06929248571395874,
-0.5647779703140259,
-0.16892676055431366,
-0.3183865547180176,
-0.9266114830970764,
0.2834322452545166,
-0.20357029139995575,
-0.9523757696151733,
-0.3512659966945648,
0.39698755741119385,
-0.3462124764919281,
0.46430760622024536,
-0.3994184732437134,
0.6652031540870667,
-0.4887565076351166,
-0.265275239944458,
-0.30510467290878296,
-0.8412185907363892,
0.5885239243507385,
0.11966908723115921,
0.37766337394714355,
-0.13610531389713287,
0.1948760747909546,
0.7462922930717468,
-0.705361545085907,
0.9081535935401917,
-0.3694561719894409,
0.08217379450798035,
0.22436638176441193,
0.5053719878196716,
0.7322061061859131,
0.21338681876659393,
-0.05772370472550392,
-0.0510793961584568,
-0.5131530165672302,
-0.2737739384174347,
-0.5158169269561768,
0.6584641337394714,
-0.7410163283348083,
-0.9052157402038574,
-0.31323227286338806,
-0.343628853559494,
-0.14961053431034088,
0.11633430421352386,
0.13397695124149323,
0.24364839494228363,
-0.16078606247901917,
-0.27377578616142273,
0.589533269405365,
-0.3381211757659912,
0.3527320325374603,
0.34210237860679626,
-0.2607163190841675,
-0.2657870054244995,
0.6296190619468689,
-0.22180084884166718,
0.11847738921642303,
0.046784672886133194,
0.192358136177063,
-0.2934888005256653,
-1.1417088508605957,
-0.7985565066337585,
0.16089673340320587,
-0.5043464303016663,
-0.19113005697727203,
-0.21148185431957245,
-0.3351423442363739,
-0.2937418222427368,
-0.009850412607192993,
-0.07720340043306351,
-0.25575655698776245,
-0.03354200720787048,
-0.1990838646888733,
0.5591966509819031,
0.34247469902038574,
-0.04807940497994423,
0.26969194412231445,
-0.8137157559394836,
0.19441616535186768,
0.06360108405351639,
0.4147481322288513,
0.07695671916007996,
-0.8572444319725037,
0.1367819607257843,
-0.3128102421760559,
-0.3090576231479645,
-0.9576788544654846,
0.41310927271842957,
-0.08077163249254227,
0.28868740797042847,
0.26037779450416565,
0.18572871387004852,
0.29898321628570557,
-0.6411604881286621,
0.4909624755382538,
0.20822183787822723,
-0.8484869003295898,
0.6812751293182373,
-0.47259020805358887,
-0.32491329312324524,
0.5378086566925049,
0.21211306750774384,
-0.7315338253974915,
-0.3050055503845215,
-0.4170804023742676,
-0.8916276693344116,
0.5701719522476196,
-0.08821123838424683,
0.3510776460170746,
0.17309585213661194,
0.45701083540916443,
-0.13125503063201904,
0.09610575437545776,
-0.7523267269134521,
-0.28620147705078125,
0.04425961896777153,
-0.13759556412696838,
0.2593497037887573,
-0.012586246244609356,
-0.3200068175792694,
0.03709830343723297,
0.47452685236930847,
0.09450934082269669,
0.09374098479747772,
0.037789229303598404,
-0.18802499771118164,
0.1420453041791916,
0.4522600769996643,
0.5443299412727356,
0.13951240479946136,
-0.3009791076183319,
0.16541141271591187,
0.0818302184343338,
-0.5249009728431702,
0.34285005927085876,
0.14063742756843567,
-0.26921260356903076,
-0.38102638721466064,
0.3817291855812073,
0.7141545414924622,
-0.4946976900100708,
-0.966158926486969,
0.6206132173538208,
-0.1268538236618042,
0.0388253852725029,
-0.4230386018753052,
0.348978728055954,
-0.20215311646461487,
0.17129959166049957,
0.06041574478149414,
0.1726839691400528,
0.12131957709789276,
-0.47113552689552307,
0.1431388556957245,
0.7184765338897705,
-0.48991858959198,
-0.09201188385486603,
0.7096220850944519,
0.25578179955482483,
-0.5716986656188965,
0.9058205485343933,
-0.08077945560216904,
-0.759075403213501,
0.5951148867607117,
0.48994383215904236,
0.8821957111358643,
-0.16373391449451447,
0.2255481630563736,
0.00671995896846056,
0.4989376664161682,
0.13417279720306396,
-0.05808170139789581,
0.0436781570315361,
-0.9617812037467957,
-0.09951680898666382,
-0.44475623965263367,
-0.42760011553764343,
0.40233397483825684,
-0.5431569814682007,
0.1449521780014038,
-0.9951815009117126,
-0.1590423285961151,
-0.08561357110738754,
-0.4573327302932739,
-0.4079449772834778,
-0.17684225738048553,
0.3059924840927124,
0.9574580192565918,
-0.7767390608787537,
0.7325740456581116,
0.4688391089439392,
-0.19077466428279877,
-0.6101491451263428,
0.23895610868930817,
0.4942804276943207,
-1.0380464792251587,
0.6454501152038574,
0.22255729138851166,
-0.25310227274894714,
-0.30555465817451477,
-0.5770710110664368,
-0.34197062253952026,
0.6653744578361511,
0.2947162091732025,
-0.5208924412727356,
0.3739994764328003,
-0.007131605874747038,
0.3300810158252716,
0.06262332201004028,
0.11569739878177643,
1.006892204284668,
0.26527953147888184,
-0.17591124773025513,
-0.7741613984107971,
0.1481476128101349,
-0.04268921911716461,
-0.06639754772186279,
0.5444111824035645,
-0.8920044302940369,
0.8338233828544617,
-0.3546995222568512,
0.1774752140045166,
0.2901533246040344,
0.4239826202392578,
0.5372863411903381,
0.2182140201330185,
0.6642916202545166,
0.6639792919158936,
0.704738199710846,
-0.027874883264303207,
1.2718827724456787,
-0.014844350516796112,
0.30955684185028076,
0.723552405834198,
-0.3299429416656494,
0.9668213129043579,
0.5143395662307739,
-0.18576422333717346,
0.5792354941368103,
0.7188544869422913,
0.17631463706493378,
0.650666356086731,
0.8504661321640015,
-0.4238571226596832,
0.018564295023679733,
0.13892781734466553,
-0.08693559467792511,
0.38811755180358887,
0.7024602890014648,
-0.2249945104122162,
-0.12261432409286499,
0.13238118588924408,
0.5631832480430603,
0.03276918828487396,
-0.49707821011543274,
0.3266814053058624,
-0.06018287315964699,
-0.5748505592346191,
0.8955477476119995,
0.5221514701843262,
0.7342219352722168,
-0.4513082206249237,
0.270127534866333,
-0.35493049025535583,
0.3003121018409729,
-0.21090473234653473,
-0.7024973034858704,
0.03100869618356228,
0.2131114900112152,
0.0958077535033226,
0.10801761597394943,
0.7169232964515686,
0.006235077977180481,
-0.15456852316856384,
0.5198827981948853,
0.22591054439544678,
-0.10072128474712372,
0.0336812287569046,
-0.8832249641418457,
0.30321189761161804,
-0.05411464348435402,
-0.4704248905181885,
0.5679801106452942,
-0.1872648298740387,
-0.1704663187265396,
0.9111424684524536,
0.5071504712104797,
0.06696303188800812,
0.018473446369171143,
0.10389789193868637,
0.9833115935325623,
-0.6195685863494873,
-0.33248603343963623,
-1.13755202293396,
0.3147626221179962,
-0.01898900605738163,
-0.23075130581855774,
0.5143716931343079,
0.19443373382091522,
0.7888016700744629,
0.09429553896188736,
1.09049654006958,
-0.15055468678474426,
0.41614168882369995,
-0.8529888987541199,
0.7084649205207825,
-0.22553758323192596,
0.7537600994110107,
-0.13264194130897522,
-0.3699316084384918,
-0.5209577083587646,
0.6565706729888916,
-0.36266711354255676,
0.016405729576945305,
0.47056835889816284,
0.970818042755127,
0.20652303099632263,
-0.23480384051799774,
-0.1309298574924469,
0.20282649993896484,
0.5782933235168457,
0.6462971568107605,
1.000501275062561,
-0.2603856921195984,
0.46031537652015686,
0.2551528513431549,
-0.36286547780036926,
-0.3538757264614105,
-0.5759854316711426,
-1.2520679235458374,
-0.1530531793832779,
0.05047142133116722,
-0.8919122219085693,
0.24886739253997803,
0.8867618441581726,
0.4633070230484009,
-0.7187319397926331,
-0.24544598162174225,
-0.14246207475662231,
0.29938438534736633,
0.09118148684501648,
-0.17279081046581268,
0.46868836879730225,
-0.16831591725349426,
-0.3934341073036194,
0.6044262647628784,
0.22182761132717133,
-0.01959739439189434,
-0.40354904532432556,
-0.1305791437625885,
-0.060000188648700714,
-0.08359566330909729,
0.224888876080513,
0.5570043325424194,
-0.726141631603241,
-0.4310873746871948,
-0.2787174880504608,
-0.050283096730709076,
-0.03373688831925392,
0.9496877193450928,
-0.9392507672309875,
0.12358075380325317,
0.3471178114414215,
1.0194371938705444,
0.4472667872905731,
-0.1609746515750885,
0.2764990031719208,
-0.8390899896621704,
0.4149427115917206,
0.12340418249368668,
0.41529330611228943,
0.22855637967586517,
-0.2430998533964157,
0.33216920495033264,
0.2491450309753418,
-0.4313139021396637,
-0.7081886529922485,
0.5263155102729797,
-0.6647272706031799,
-0.31608450412750244,
0.8918512463569641,
-0.0629468634724617,
-0.35210856795310974,
-0.17183034121990204,
-0.25837644934654236,
-0.23405250906944275,
-0.42957720160484314,
0.9844442009925842,
0.5221500396728516,
-0.25861865282058716,
-0.089472196996212,
-0.603834867477417,
0.5420013666152954,
0.5041416883468628,
-0.49598273634910583,
0.19989147782325745,
0.39677003026008606,
0.4783472716808319,
-0.13557656109333038,
0.6865179538726807,
-0.07078903168439865,
0.3736017346382141,
-0.42883989214897156,
-0.1564083695411682,
0.025874106213450432,
-0.16955432295799255,
-0.6065130829811096,
0.280021607875824,
0.49009475111961365,
-0.27054306864738464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00241v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00241v2
|
CASIMIR: A Corpus of Scientific Articles enhanced with Multiple Author-Integrated Revisions
| 2024-03-01T03:07:32 | 2024-03-19T08:34:05 |
Leane Jourdan, Florian Boudin, Nicolas Hernandez, Richard Dufour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Writing a scientific article is a challenging task as it is a highly codified
and specific genre, consequently proficiency in written communication is
essential for effectively conveying research findings and ideas. In this
article, we propose an original textual resource on the revision step of the
writing process of scientific articles. This new dataset, called CASIMIR,
contains the multiple revised versions of 15,646 scientific articles from
OpenReview, along with their peer reviews. Pairs of consecutive versions of an
article are aligned at sentence-level while keeping paragraph location
information as metadata for supporting future revision studies at the discourse
level. Each pair of revised sentences is enriched with automatically extracted
edits and associated revision intention. To assess the initial quality on the
dataset, we conducted a qualitative study of several state-of-the-art text
revision approaches and compared various evaluation metrics. Our experiments
led us to question the relevance of the current evaluation methods for the text
revision task.
|
[
-0.2821348011493683,
-0.5476725697517395,
0.6690389513969421,
0.6724575161933899,
-0.22923162579536438,
0.08446243405342102,
-0.32968372106552124,
-0.6257765889167786,
0.4573374092578888,
0.5716840028762817,
-0.3124255836009979,
-0.27221664786338806,
-0.4523606300354004,
0.8069226741790771,
-0.32345110177993774,
0.9951030611991882,
-0.5390520095825195,
0.34603455662727356,
-0.3513215184211731,
0.06609006971120834,
-0.08466655761003494,
0.06194642186164856,
-0.0422983393073082,
-0.15419761836528778,
0.8336377143859863,
0.1770942062139511,
0.4663844406604767,
0.6069616675376892,
0.6834486722946167,
0.25869110226631165,
-0.16736182570457458,
0.28682729601860046,
-0.6233108639717102,
0.3233787715435028,
-0.4214702248573303,
-0.02244793437421322,
-0.4903043210506439,
-0.033447977155447006,
0.8886432647705078,
0.8561685681343079,
0.42243313789367676,
0.18686777353286743,
0.24268023669719696,
0.6872792840003967,
-0.6581449508666992,
-0.04335016757249832,
-0.34719422459602356,
-0.10470160841941833,
-0.3967670798301697,
-0.4594714641571045,
-0.7182959318161011,
-0.5023670792579651,
-0.022608190774917603,
-1.0907115936279297,
0.3118933439254761,
-0.30368366837501526,
0.5084755420684814,
0.17435741424560547,
-0.3575352430343628,
-0.34208694100379944,
-0.6042208671569824,
0.7168363928794861,
-0.41139304637908936,
0.36309659481048584,
0.03994342312216759,
-0.21890482306480408,
-0.2679496705532074,
-0.9398090243339539,
-0.5154322981834412,
-0.037751100957393646,
0.08426382392644882,
0.3983127772808075,
0.10416572540998459,
-0.23565858602523804,
-0.03589288145303726,
0.21724601089954376,
-0.4700395166873932,
-0.23499472439289093,
-0.9384868741035461,
0.036883994936943054,
0.68677818775177,
0.05818193778395653,
-0.05187330022454262,
-0.22885359823703766,
-0.32014015316963196,
-0.4685088098049164,
-0.6371798515319824,
-0.1807423233985901,
0.5794609785079956,
0.18069125711917877,
0.5155625939369202,
0.6711235046386719,
-0.13618984818458557,
0.697168231010437,
0.20941728353500366,
-0.13230225443840027,
0.4676892161369324,
-0.8519567251205444,
0.1557900756597519,
0.193024143576622,
0.863461434841156,
0.5015498995780945,
-0.3917510211467743,
-0.06592439860105515,
0.16686329245567322,
-0.3436095714569092,
0.8935772180557251,
-0.6299899816513062,
-0.30864280462265015,
0.2450689673423767,
-0.35755857825279236,
-0.2629145681858063,
0.46053147315979004,
-0.6452572345733643,
-0.5025643110275269,
-0.3930891752243042,
0.08689285069704056,
-0.5462592840194702,
-0.011417754925787449,
0.25350433588027954,
-0.21090637147426605,
-0.6287400722503662,
0.9195519685745239,
-0.7244174480438232,
0.14797735214233398,
0.7256945967674255,
0.6584818363189697,
-0.053560808300971985,
-0.6120256185531616,
-0.008762151934206486,
0.270076185464859,
-0.5053583979606628,
0.8878312706947327,
-0.3846588730812073,
-0.4627103805541992,
-0.3965991139411926,
-0.08184784650802612,
0.05882607400417328,
-0.10680148750543594,
0.7592822313308716,
-0.6088433861732483,
0.212042436003685,
-0.3671965003013611,
-0.4288540184497833,
-0.2408786118030548,
-0.13660958409309387,
-0.7519591450691223,
0.9941701292991638,
0.21352440118789673,
-1.030383825302124,
0.6666399240493774,
-0.4432576596736908,
-0.20539607107639313,
0.01514153741300106,
0.3480651080608368,
-0.26117515563964844,
0.2081558257341385,
0.4840482175350189,
0.12397660315036774,
-0.012735258787870407,
0.14173021912574768,
-0.48691585659980774,
0.05900110304355621,
0.1867581456899643,
0.08736314624547958,
0.8189800381660461,
0.19335904717445374,
0.37988874316215515,
0.3470245599746704,
-0.8243945837020874,
0.011759405955672264,
-0.5180897116661072,
-0.19351059198379517,
-0.7224240303039551,
-0.02681540511548519,
0.17896665632724762,
-0.016667276620864868,
0.48038139939308167,
-1.0856153964996338,
0.5937619209289551,
-0.18838143348693848,
0.14185771346092224,
0.5046336054801941,
0.5018817186355591,
0.3907352387905121,
-0.39649730920791626,
0.22036953270435333,
-0.15687011182308197,
0.5965675115585327,
-0.24241451919078827,
-0.7323595881462097,
-0.364101767539978,
-0.27677592635154724,
0.5940162539482117,
0.18348002433776855,
-0.6322169899940491,
0.3207816481590271,
-0.1287832111120224,
-0.9492924809455872,
-1.1231942176818848,
0.2773756980895996,
0.3490968346595764,
0.4603799283504486,
0.6834133267402649,
-0.3741800785064697,
-0.6824492812156677,
-0.7506937384605408,
-0.35528314113616943,
-0.34545308351516724,
0.06153782829642296,
-0.043742019683122635,
0.6280723810195923,
-0.12162957340478897,
1.0338236093521118,
-0.4594173729419708,
-0.15394258499145508,
0.2999478876590729,
0.6005796194076538,
0.08080613613128662,
0.3989385962486267,
0.3831891715526581,
-0.7350447773933411,
-0.40909311175346375,
-0.0024676541797816753,
-0.9922828674316406,
-0.4490237832069397,
-0.3861936032772064,
-0.11861562728881836,
-0.10186784714460373,
0.5756440758705139,
-0.1287013292312622,
0.037278786301612854,
0.3255811035633087,
-0.21349841356277466,
0.7034405469894409,
-0.2692841589450836,
0.6050646305084229,
-0.9400379657745361,
0.1739819496870041,
0.05002392828464508,
0.20725902915000916,
-0.39188218116760254,
0.24742771685123444,
0.45000654458999634,
0.3224828243255615,
-0.48451346158981323,
0.4230141043663025,
-0.6233065724372864,
0.299147367477417,
0.018990730866789818,
0.12563739717006683,
0.19099688529968262,
-0.22150717675685883,
-0.06988078355789185,
0.623237133026123,
0.17513883113861084,
-0.2897639274597168,
0.21268485486507416,
0.6219077110290527,
-0.43883341550827026,
0.6082537174224854,
-0.561072826385498,
0.06994197517633438,
-0.4391803443431854,
0.38735827803611755,
-0.607698917388916,
-0.1579468995332718,
-0.006158170290291309,
-0.33452484011650085,
0.08683636784553528,
0.26488372683525085,
-0.6611987948417664,
-0.34563949704170227,
-0.7886542677879333,
0.26678135991096497,
-0.2178068310022354,
-0.2932983934879303,
-0.013638162054121494,
0.14539869129657745,
-0.606924831867218,
-0.565281331539154,
-0.28047409653663635,
0.5409467220306396,
0.23684833943843842,
-0.7867989540100098,
0.6801196336746216,
-0.32087522745132446,
-0.37594670057296753,
0.2159421741962433,
0.23011477291584015,
0.014311454258859158,
-0.21563468873500824,
0.11040819436311722,
0.14144368469715118,
0.15614186227321625,
0.014247057028114796,
0.42726290225982666,
0.16686184704303741,
-0.14453013241291046,
0.06568290293216705,
0.04229574277997017,
0.2745012640953064,
-0.10433096438646317,
-0.2081732302904129,
0.42117127776145935,
0.40183818340301514,
0.06322953850030899,
0.3949625790119171,
0.3924499750137329,
-0.13318473100662231,
0.11212211847305298,
-0.3826359510421753,
-0.24302971363067627,
-0.3668232560157776,
0.03885509818792343,
-0.3382691740989685,
-0.6334314942359924,
0.3696165978908539,
0.14489345252513885,
0.28058144450187683,
0.6964902281761169,
0.5127939581871033,
-0.06569395214319229,
0.6216887831687927,
0.4996826946735382,
0.5925136804580688,
0.27891990542411804,
0.15758554637432098,
0.15587513148784637,
-1.2329504489898682,
-0.4074312746524811,
-0.7311121225357056,
-0.13061964511871338,
-0.10379008203744888,
-0.40478432178497314,
0.596785306930542,
0.49892663955688477,
0.03231287747621536,
0.605624794960022,
-0.8186358213424683,
0.13285978138446808,
0.5717742443084717,
0.3024349808692932,
0.6886957883834839,
-0.08797220140695572,
0.018973970785737038,
-0.515738844871521,
-0.44959068298339844,
-0.8483263254165649,
1.2038910388946533,
0.19760309159755707,
0.8917472958564758,
-0.0690208300948143,
0.9582582116127014,
0.15111540257930756,
0.6358543038368225,
-0.2820272445678711,
0.3118301331996918,
0.17348447442054749,
-0.45860934257507324,
-0.21758493781089783,
-0.30847373604774475,
-1.0089685916900635,
0.32337766885757446,
-0.27217864990234375,
-0.6081300973892212,
0.4818674325942993,
-0.14815621078014374,
-0.2415793240070343,
-0.0069055743515491486,
-0.577345073223114,
0.6230770349502563,
0.09696921706199646,
-0.5740665793418884,
-0.0807759165763855,
-0.6796336770057678,
0.5229312181472778,
-0.6635271906852722,
0.026294194161891937,
0.2723545730113983,
-0.0449875108897686,
0.9604872465133667,
-0.45176932215690613,
0.6305473446846008,
0.19106271862983704,
-0.22430451214313507,
0.27709105610847473,
0.07619510591030121,
0.046831950545310974,
0.5569161176681519,
-0.2961621582508087,
-0.053917307406663895,
0.3227909803390503,
-0.14690664410591125,
-0.39316606521606445,
0.9209949970245361,
-0.5996685028076172,
-0.2817940413951874,
-0.6163697242736816,
-0.5238223075866699,
-0.0954912081360817,
0.32675305008888245,
0.2954409718513489,
0.21633280813694,
-0.44769909977912903,
0.1503032147884369,
0.2982307970523834,
-0.09531660377979279,
0.05089122802019119,
0.42014649510383606,
-0.35658517479896545,
-0.8360059261322021,
0.4512631297111511,
0.301693856716156,
-0.05603696405887604,
0.21501076221466064,
-0.06472685933113098,
-0.075409434735775,
-0.6223433613777161,
-0.5847104787826538,
0.3736896514892578,
-0.4285658299922943,
-0.26378652453422546,
-0.897674560546875,
0.17549926042556763,
-0.6927440762519836,
-0.5812749862670898,
-0.29762503504753113,
-0.7453392148017883,
-0.659619927406311,
0.10792628675699234,
0.37163257598876953,
1.0959417819976807,
-0.33476391434669495,
-0.011695589870214462,
-0.8357535600662231,
0.3731144070625305,
-0.07855401188135147,
0.18247918784618378,
-0.03907328099012375,
-0.06417138129472733,
-0.2568734288215637,
0.07913440465927124,
-0.7022755742073059,
-1.01436185836792,
0.305635005235672,
0.03905597701668739,
0.2798596918582916,
0.08685346692800522,
0.19640246033668518,
0.6151782870292664,
-0.6105215549468994,
1.0175024271011353,
0.38649988174438477,
-0.7123709917068481,
0.610538125038147,
-0.4135398268699646,
0.41005346179008484,
0.9493948817253113,
0.43124356865882874,
-0.38047313690185547,
-0.6258893609046936,
-0.599651575088501,
-0.9547640085220337,
0.2437015175819397,
-0.025153042748570442,
-0.23039846122264862,
-0.14850196242332458,
0.23909328877925873,
0.5853633284568787,
0.2688005566596985,
-0.35106655955314636,
0.27365657687187195,
-0.34120580554008484,
-0.11662670224905014,
-0.009332769550383091,
-0.21729488670825958,
-0.4881213903427124,
-0.3799622654914856,
0.8831210732460022,
0.00957582052797079,
0.07924110442399979,
0.6156048774719238,
-0.28487923741340637,
-0.1962747871875763,
0.32430359721183777,
0.7759267687797546,
1.0923328399658203,
-0.408058762550354,
-0.026670904830098152,
-0.271902471780777,
-0.7459274530410767,
-0.06526588648557663,
0.13680920004844666,
-0.408243864774704,
0.23458655178546906,
0.6171532273292542,
0.33090510964393616,
0.26520028710365295,
-0.2214740663766861,
0.2843371331691742,
0.11201804876327515,
-0.3713217079639435,
-0.07301770895719528,
-0.23479223251342773,
-0.23210102319717407,
0.1346658319234848,
0.558810293674469,
0.22977383434772491,
0.427508145570755,
-0.2326829582452774,
0.16280962526798248,
-0.006872974336147308,
-0.5908541679382324,
-0.5602888464927673,
0.6506285071372986,
0.0393933430314064,
0.09761106222867966,
0.3141903579235077,
-0.20081447064876556,
-0.13402119278907776,
0.03750574216246605,
0.4298425316810608,
0.6363465189933777,
-0.23118194937705994,
0.4011920094490051,
0.48525524139404297,
0.4850548505783081,
-0.2403966188430786,
0.65119469165802,
0.23978884518146515,
-0.21083873510360718,
-0.7151564955711365,
-0.7451419830322266,
-0.5129880309104919,
-0.3790748715400696,
-0.5802857279777527,
0.2726641893386841,
-0.2230978161096573,
-0.44965842366218567,
0.45540857315063477,
-0.18617616593837738,
-0.14660795032978058,
-0.32734042406082153,
-0.5136362314224243,
1.1218820810317993,
-0.6870537400245667,
0.4656643569469452,
0.8800714612007141,
-0.48279616236686707,
-0.09049014002084732,
-0.3916516900062561,
-0.034639205783605576,
-0.01945529319345951,
0.7013315558433533,
-0.37727558612823486,
-0.004210314713418484,
-0.18799979984760284,
-0.5992477536201477,
-0.6936700940132141,
0.693028450012207,
0.28345954418182373,
-0.12847638130187988,
0.1701069325208664,
-0.27341607213020325,
0.8733755946159363,
0.03556666523218155,
0.11993923038244247,
-0.06044939160346985,
0.9906310439109802,
-0.33341625332832336,
-1.1554157733917236,
-0.1437889188528061,
-0.6215195059776306,
-0.05378945171833038,
0.36612531542778015,
-0.49809741973876953,
1.0484322309494019,
-0.14590366184711456,
0.07221172004938126,
0.2703011929988861,
0.8689836263656616,
0.14555376768112183,
0.20882782340049744,
0.04203573986887932,
0.6611305475234985,
0.6376690864562988,
-0.0736757144331932,
0.8858608603477478,
-0.22189636528491974,
0.3026159107685089,
0.930371880531311,
-0.5554054975509644,
0.8371619582176208,
0.9602090120315552,
-0.011044608429074287,
0.48172903060913086,
0.4284702241420746,
-0.16152504086494446,
0.596592903137207,
0.26485487818717957,
-0.3712005913257599,
0.21179768443107605,
-0.3044060170650482,
-0.4812162518501282,
-0.010304669849574566,
0.17080146074295044,
-0.37974095344543457,
-0.21264159679412842,
0.4060860276222229,
0.2846065163612366,
0.3699917197227478,
-0.20993167161941528,
0.7840856909751892,
-0.12054843455553055,
-0.7990785837173462,
0.29213523864746094,
0.057808928191661835,
0.32762622833251953,
-0.3261417746543884,
-0.11699122935533524,
0.20911861956119537,
0.1308968961238861,
-0.5398526787757874,
-1.124099850654602,
0.3769243061542511,
0.05861099809408188,
-0.3513377010822296,
-0.7056894898414612,
0.3426639437675476,
-0.26359274983406067,
-0.6090394258499146,
-0.07341568917036057,
0.23702484369277954,
0.0893731415271759,
0.21030956506729126,
-0.26664116978645325,
0.35303717851638794,
-0.23892533779144287,
-0.45123234391212463,
0.11328122019767761,
0.4076129198074341,
-0.02427956648170948,
0.21349039673805237,
0.6881425380706787,
0.37915894389152527,
0.08688332140445709,
0.000015177012755884789,
0.8175792694091797,
-0.4124685823917389,
-0.3765377104282379,
-0.23831342160701752,
0.41276976466178894,
-0.44437938928604126,
-0.8505324721336365,
1.0863699913024902,
0.824026882648468,
0.8431025147438049,
-0.29059645533561707,
0.7763314843177795,
0.026360023766756058,
0.5685620307922363,
-0.441401869058609,
0.5745624899864197,
-0.28699809312820435,
-0.15333348512649536,
-0.7182815670967102,
-0.881900429725647,
-0.6836971640586853,
0.6090433597564697,
-0.07889007031917572,
-0.2536482810974121,
1.044783115386963,
0.4823133647441864,
-0.07596251368522644,
0.28396186232566833,
-0.36212557554244995,
0.23772172629833221,
0.3149636685848236,
0.08670315146446228,
0.6087839007377625,
-0.6040189862251282,
-0.1254098117351532,
-0.47792327404022217,
-0.2769733667373657,
-0.2860800623893738,
-0.9972137808799744,
-0.4043124318122864,
-1.0198447704315186,
-0.5241461396217346,
-0.4792085289955139,
0.26659661531448364,
0.759505569934845,
0.21499422192573547,
-0.5726965069770813,
-0.050008371472358704,
0.20478564500808716,
-0.2935034930706024,
-0.5988882780075073,
-0.18005938827991486,
0.5156470537185669,
-0.3045920133590698,
-0.6253383755683899,
0.7061994671821594,
0.47809043526649475,
-0.3645097613334656,
-0.2830771207809448,
0.14778520166873932,
-0.3866782784461975,
0.044316213577985764,
0.575127899646759,
0.20662088692188263,
-0.34469398856163025,
-0.2642485201358795,
0.07373329997062683,
-0.20032989978790283,
-0.12352310121059418,
1.0004761219024658,
-0.6071636080741882,
0.963076651096344,
0.8431373834609985,
0.3449702560901642,
0.6247047781944275,
0.024059420451521873,
0.47573694586753845,
-0.5252580642700195,
-0.13299836218357086,
0.4542679488658905,
0.31643757224082947,
0.416121244430542,
-0.06713708490133286,
0.525833010673523,
0.10666680335998535,
-0.6651636362075806,
-1.0380500555038452,
-0.1968826949596405,
-1.4194117784500122,
-0.4422130882740021,
0.9696841835975647,
0.06425932049751282,
-0.26254355907440186,
-0.3060489892959595,
-0.5234615802764893,
0.25368407368659973,
-0.4120492935180664,
0.9074806571006775,
0.9427384734153748,
-0.16119548678398132,
0.08573231846094131,
-0.45255017280578613,
0.250684529542923,
0.05147620290517807,
-0.7289262413978577,
0.11162548512220383,
0.5748118162155151,
-0.3208819627761841,
0.5485512018203735,
0.5318002104759216,
-0.5162482261657715,
0.3254729211330414,
-0.015886064618825912,
0.3595743477344513,
-0.2842484712600708,
-0.5172799825668335,
-0.21195082366466522,
0.2886369824409485,
0.08295188099145889,
0.5764986276626587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00236v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00236v1
|
Benchmarking zero-shot stance detection with FlanT5-XXL: Insights from training data, prompting, and decoding strategies into its near-SoTA performance
| 2024-03-01T02:33:26 | 2024-03-01T02:33:26 |
Rachith Aiyappa, Shruthi Senthilmani, Jisun An, Haewoon Kwak, Yong-Yeol Ahn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We investigate the performance of LLM-based zero-shot stance detection on
tweets. Using FlanT5-XXL, an instruction-tuned open-source LLM, with the
SemEval 2016 Tasks 6A, 6B, and P-Stance datasets, we study the performance and
its variations under different prompts and decoding strategies, as well as the
potential biases of the model. We show that the zero-shot approach can match or
outperform state-of-the-art benchmarks, including fine-tuned models. We provide
various insights into its performance including the sensitivity to instructions
and prompts, the decoding strategies, the perplexity of the prompts, and to
negations and oppositions present in prompts. Finally, we ensure that the LLM
has not been trained on test datasets, and identify a positivity bias which may
partially explain the performance differences across decoding strategie
|
[
-0.13863638043403625,
-0.803158164024353,
0.46384409070014954,
0.1747935712337494,
-0.4616859257221222,
-0.002029256196692586,
-0.041646361351013184,
-0.3828728497028351,
0.41043224930763245,
0.17364501953125,
-0.8515005707740784,
-0.9002736806869507,
-0.7762980461120605,
0.17363804578781128,
-0.3265689015388489,
0.8572573065757751,
-0.09622128307819366,
0.15766310691833496,
0.4020247459411621,
-0.635179877281189,
-0.38252004981040955,
-0.08594867587089539,
-0.5819069147109985,
0.030724283307790756,
0.44428253173828125,
0.7345959544181824,
0.29951727390289307,
0.4505253732204437,
0.2917742133140564,
0.05278124660253525,
0.1219322606921196,
-0.3029813766479492,
-0.863604724407196,
0.20557592809200287,
-0.08217952400445938,
-0.43260112404823303,
-0.5049256086349487,
-0.0275274608284235,
0.7126695513725281,
0.05589393898844719,
0.2858961522579193,
0.2308095544576645,
-0.3485427796840668,
0.2642742395401001,
-0.7919025421142578,
-0.06272812932729721,
-0.5379737615585327,
0.21757468581199646,
-0.3868952989578247,
-0.3471302390098572,
-0.2077023684978485,
-0.19702111184597015,
-0.18749050796031952,
-0.21095827221870422,
0.3294624090194702,
-0.16516390442848206,
0.892295777797699,
0.12913878262043,
-0.18840038776397705,
-0.07907579094171524,
-0.4538629949092865,
0.8062080144882202,
-0.7598053216934204,
0.24523787200450897,
0.07428387552499771,
0.40179380774497986,
0.10506606101989746,
-0.09848444908857346,
-0.5536606907844543,
0.07369975745677948,
0.466505765914917,
0.30030515789985657,
-0.2927778959274292,
0.018383918330073357,
0.3447662889957428,
0.08347472548484802,
-0.5057033896446228,
0.1253640502691269,
0.13113418221473694,
-0.1554913967847824,
0.6480398178100586,
-0.011030473746359348,
0.1958511471748352,
-0.0010496781906113029,
-0.5565954446792603,
-0.12865504622459412,
-0.6635767817497253,
0.2758040428161621,
0.26131752133369446,
0.28667590022087097,
-0.12097681313753128,
0.6652035117149353,
-0.4216490685939789,
0.31974026560783386,
0.18870909512043,
0.023373788222670555,
0.22850315272808075,
-0.06070426478981972,
-0.24731452763080597,
0.2080068439245224,
1.010001540184021,
0.587489664554596,
0.11235778033733368,
-0.07078568637371063,
-0.3891758918762207,
-0.005509336479008198,
0.04616894572973251,
-0.9693821668624878,
0.013578318990767002,
0.3781767785549164,
-0.3008708953857422,
-0.464356929063797,
0.04707431048154831,
-0.643330991268158,
-0.6993460655212402,
-0.04575720429420471,
0.6465184092521667,
-0.7788408994674683,
-0.4263373911380768,
0.27709871530532837,
-0.20576249063014984,
0.9374100565910339,
0.46853065490722656,
-0.7344587445259094,
-0.10806235671043396,
0.9001578688621521,
0.9584512710571289,
-0.15867799520492554,
-0.24852149188518524,
-0.8186616897583008,
-0.33228468894958496,
-0.5138970613479614,
0.9690719842910767,
-0.5249475240707397,
-0.24762874841690063,
0.2027072310447693,
-0.14305591583251953,
-0.06293557584285736,
-0.2955397069454193,
0.7340205907821655,
-0.3147980868816376,
-0.2711396813392639,
-0.6533734202384949,
-0.795361340045929,
0.1479007452726364,
0.5162070989608765,
-0.6184362769126892,
0.8020444512367249,
-0.03007873147726059,
-0.8211258053779602,
0.7658382058143616,
-0.7761178016662598,
-0.3801392614841461,
-0.04036742448806763,
-0.5388210415840149,
-0.4230403006076813,
0.2586513161659241,
0.16701027750968933,
0.7568583488464355,
0.08056103438138962,
-0.2785186171531677,
-0.5130546689033508,
-0.6130728125572205,
0.11742152273654938,
-0.2102382928133011,
0.9695814847946167,
0.02670411765575409,
-0.7297323942184448,
0.39197057485580444,
-0.6557806730270386,
-0.21878138184547424,
0.30979615449905396,
-0.0045972238294780254,
0.10161284357309341,
-0.08021292090415955,
-0.24248972535133362,
0.01045868918299675,
0.03355487436056137,
-0.8865874409675598,
0.19418497383594513,
-0.33059027791023254,
0.24269647896289825,
0.4533247947692871,
0.11327508836984634,
0.3693282902240753,
-0.011795219033956528,
0.6920874714851379,
0.15177230536937714,
0.06522458046674728,
-0.37322360277175903,
-0.2819788455963135,
-0.587336003780365,
-0.15951956808567047,
0.015727132558822632,
0.4827229678630829,
-0.675635039806366,
0.12474841624498367,
-0.2202170044183731,
-0.2268306165933609,
-0.5897554159164429,
0.009425186552107334,
0.33680853247642517,
0.4728800356388092,
0.3131190836429596,
-0.10999403893947601,
-0.4677976369857788,
-0.4883996844291687,
-0.5664393901824951,
0.052086472511291504,
0.29061034321784973,
-0.003245704108849168,
0.5482903122901917,
0.33620724081993103,
0.8196989893913269,
-0.12709330022335052,
-0.1829133927822113,
-0.4196667969226837,
0.2957676351070404,
0.0736226812005043,
-0.008952868171036243,
1.0325089693069458,
-0.4419562816619873,
-0.627518892288208,
-0.3455387353897095,
-0.825499951839447,
-0.29266566038131714,
-0.05337245389819145,
-0.12862226366996765,
0.6655778288841248,
0.557604193687439,
-0.5914322137832642,
0.6193838715553284,
0.3306131362915039,
-0.5329588651657104,
0.6912739872932434,
0.47451144456863403,
0.2787690758705139,
-1.0271774530410767,
0.0434558279812336,
0.3236285448074341,
-0.49509286880493164,
-0.8227508664131165,
0.047859422862529755,
0.13577169179916382,
0.08179862052202225,
-0.8300396800041199,
0.3682466745376587,
-0.34453389048576355,
-0.13313265144824982,
-0.33993029594421387,
0.0014638033462688327,
-0.200932115316391,
0.21013441681861877,
0.391361266374588,
0.6758421063423157,
0.6793496012687683,
-0.11496598273515701,
0.02459060400724411,
-0.08693311363458633,
-0.08462852984666824,
0.9784969687461853,
-0.546593427658081,
0.15371744334697723,
-0.010328621603548527,
0.247939333319664,
-1.250052809715271,
-0.1540783792734146,
0.47707027196884155,
-0.7380306124687195,
0.4707840085029602,
-0.40968629717826843,
-0.43698984384536743,
-0.05893019586801529,
-0.97511225938797,
0.20387443900108337,
0.30819517374038696,
-0.390887051820755,
0.15608209371566772,
0.033491890877485275,
0.3417399525642395,
-0.8865994811058044,
-0.47949519753456116,
0.11789112538099289,
-0.32685476541519165,
-0.4369475841522217,
0.15609148144721985,
0.15079879760742188,
-0.09952188283205032,
-0.39775243401527405,
-0.41954708099365234,
0.2628515064716339,
-0.08633353561162949,
0.14824393391609192,
-0.018552979454398155,
-0.4424559772014618,
-0.2863144874572754,
-0.23429690301418304,
-0.06863999366760254,
0.06886116415262222,
-0.4321180284023285,
0.5254186987876892,
-0.17358876764774323,
-0.40017586946487427,
-0.7933897972106934,
0.12891066074371338,
0.49158844351768494,
0.08955075591802597,
0.8442493081092834,
1.0501867532730103,
-0.20750021934509277,
-0.26857513189315796,
-0.30731746554374695,
-0.23896852135658264,
-0.4056571424007416,
-0.1573435366153717,
-0.2934023439884186,
-0.9085608124732971,
0.40549296140670776,
0.07924550026655197,
0.2112545669078827,
0.1981283724308014,
0.5982002019882202,
-0.3894554674625397,
0.8072731494903564,
0.39578917622566223,
-0.3219272792339325,
0.6027829051017761,
-0.5388716459274292,
0.13544781506061554,
-0.15909306704998016,
0.018333889544010162,
-0.2896260917186737,
-0.5833525061607361,
-0.44972100853919983,
-0.41168251633644104,
0.12003622949123383,
0.08662890642881393,
-0.23476363718509674,
0.45621204376220703,
-0.2202479988336563,
0.6064175963401794,
0.34255844354629517,
0.013698135502636433,
0.03200714662671089,
-0.004606600850820541,
-0.05197297781705856,
-0.17307795584201813,
-0.47220340371131897,
-0.426037073135376,
1.055381417274475,
0.41147786378860474,
0.6657319664955139,
0.24787159264087677,
0.9948179721832275,
0.3572578728199005,
-0.0876869261264801,
-1.1650416851043701,
0.7798590064048767,
-0.002869060728698969,
-0.1800188571214676,
-0.11189678311347961,
-0.20632003247737885,
-0.8792908191680908,
-0.02816048637032509,
-0.2294190376996994,
-0.7314245104789734,
0.06952697783708572,
0.2114911824464798,
-0.4158460795879364,
0.3838600218296051,
-0.5377015471458435,
0.9659407734870911,
-0.22873932123184204,
-0.628027081489563,
0.03993159532546997,
-0.657288134098053,
0.24463629722595215,
0.4096355140209198,
-0.3030385673046112,
-0.4771174490451813,
-0.24511678516864777,
0.5280232429504395,
-0.3760857880115509,
1.1434130668640137,
-0.7729021310806274,
-0.303343266248703,
0.15984557569026947,
0.19235418736934662,
0.12676742672920227,
0.04057806730270386,
-0.08462216705083847,
0.38932669162750244,
0.15732091665267944,
-0.585810661315918,
-0.2835675776004791,
0.7257895469665527,
-0.8200555443763733,
-0.40198883414268494,
-0.46637678146362305,
-0.25960230827331543,
-0.3230282962322235,
0.37352368235588074,
0.5465254187583923,
0.41592085361480713,
-0.518730878829956,
0.26051202416419983,
0.7958192229270935,
0.03190210461616516,
0.744676411151886,
0.6494753956794739,
0.036543890833854675,
-0.17016717791557312,
0.7136627435684204,
0.22218234837055206,
-0.10763704031705856,
0.7132159471511841,
0.2406432181596756,
-0.6243060827255249,
-0.8272756934165955,
-0.4766908884048462,
0.00949584599584341,
-0.5141781568527222,
-0.3394886255264282,
-0.36515265703201294,
-0.022553352639079094,
-0.5648435950279236,
-0.10415317118167877,
-0.34357112646102905,
-0.4477173089981079,
-0.358599990606308,
-0.17802314460277557,
0.4011892080307007,
0.676049530506134,
0.05767976865172386,
0.23333856463432312,
-0.3977016806602478,
0.39562681317329407,
-0.20840182900428772,
0.34771573543548584,
-0.37761780619621277,
-0.6235767602920532,
0.02160835638642311,
-0.02280341647565365,
-0.32903915643692017,
-1.2028002738952637,
0.08072436600923538,
0.13121317327022552,
0.4785195291042328,
0.8073908090591431,
0.40438735485076904,
0.45925483107566833,
-0.3134714663028717,
0.7791377902030945,
0.11140432953834534,
-0.8621326088905334,
0.7768430709838867,
-0.8542315363883972,
0.4162265360355377,
0.6545621156692505,
0.5014256238937378,
-0.08505448698997498,
-0.16559241712093353,
-0.5090882182121277,
-0.5671889185905457,
1.1138335466384888,
0.2889648973941803,
0.16491934657096863,
0.006822710856795311,
0.3627978265285492,
0.08617372810840607,
0.2140166014432907,
-0.4857564866542816,
-0.045591555535793304,
-0.6244969367980957,
-0.16090449690818787,
0.10966892540454865,
-0.2566210925579071,
-0.10196848213672638,
-0.219317227602005,
0.35638517141342163,
-0.26081612706184387,
0.43710318207740784,
0.05176490172743797,
-0.4059199392795563,
-0.13435375690460205,
0.29380741715431213,
0.9522022008895874,
0.4045494496822357,
-0.3509296178817749,
-0.07802709192037582,
0.20326535403728485,
-0.3680129051208496,
0.08382642269134521,
-0.2002726048231125,
-0.28581342101097107,
0.12148746103048325,
0.43123406171798706,
0.973145067691803,
0.17156274616718292,
-0.4542057514190674,
0.8053596615791321,
-0.03158479183912277,
-0.6148256659507751,
-0.22406698763370514,
0.18225274980068207,
-0.08864668011665344,
0.3810086250305176,
0.2790936231613159,
-0.04967585951089859,
-0.06011965870857239,
-0.6107436418533325,
0.13729050755500793,
0.4573555290699005,
-0.4967760741710663,
-0.7947520017623901,
0.5717499256134033,
0.04670891910791397,
-0.4660589098930359,
-0.10303731262683868,
-0.29198285937309265,
-0.3730258643627167,
0.4263004958629608,
0.2645788788795471,
1.0046875476837158,
-0.13356053829193115,
0.45837998390197754,
0.25998178124427795,
0.05666736140847206,
0.0778263509273529,
0.746231734752655,
-0.3267814815044403,
-0.8307323455810547,
-0.1448989361524582,
-0.29774343967437744,
-0.5292573571205139,
0.4214816391468048,
-0.7368062734603882,
0.6287057399749756,
-0.8780269622802734,
-0.1592698097229004,
0.09452485293149948,
0.23069457709789276,
-0.5878332853317261,
-0.04429593309760094,
0.1736731082201004,
1.2754384279251099,
-0.831153154373169,
0.7400487661361694,
0.93353271484375,
-0.46889427304267883,
-0.7453944683074951,
0.6454376578330994,
0.5702112317085266,
-1.018661618232727,
0.1741301268339157,
0.5195062160491943,
-0.6187596321105957,
0.08797431737184525,
-0.6837842464447021,
-0.11377567052841187,
1.2996066808700562,
0.7743867635726929,
-0.409053236246109,
0.4159182012081146,
0.4177117943763733,
0.6323709487915039,
-0.3152696192264557,
0.3842792510986328,
0.7246810793876648,
0.12363284081220627,
0.39488616585731506,
-0.592750608921051,
-0.018220091238617897,
-0.07017219066619873,
-0.28810757398605347,
0.07750386744737625,
-0.9107912182807922,
0.4821837246417999,
-0.012235576286911964,
-0.3345324993133545,
-0.12680447101593018,
0.4612721800804138,
0.31256774067878723,
0.6593557596206665,
0.3106110095977783,
0.5629759430885315,
0.3225710988044739,
0.005011304747313261,
0.8100672960281372,
-0.4505687654018402,
0.3462415933609009,
0.9219180345535278,
-0.6467788219451904,
1.3366035223007202,
0.49790674448013306,
0.06848035007715225,
0.3434706926345825,
0.5651232004165649,
0.2164030820131302,
0.4104716181755066,
-0.2642727792263031,
-0.441022664308548,
-0.22512367367744446,
-0.12930798530578613,
-0.00496391486376524,
0.5903763771057129,
0.3603780269622803,
-0.23483510315418243,
-0.5599942803382874,
-0.1453508734703064,
0.3274345099925995,
-0.036814454942941666,
-0.3350951671600342,
0.8707841634750366,
-0.00627156300470233,
-0.5742852091789246,
0.7148622870445251,
-0.0214450191706419,
0.8681051731109619,
-0.4320007264614105,
0.11102497577667236,
-0.37802788615226746,
0.21908414363861084,
-0.36388614773750305,
-1.0515973567962646,
0.2792719602584839,
0.24591758847236633,
0.1719452142715454,
-0.4601025879383087,
1.1099213361740112,
-0.07056021690368652,
-0.21016301214694977,
0.365527868270874,
0.4207902252674103,
0.18831680715084076,
-0.14842088520526886,
-0.91583651304245,
0.24551063776016235,
-0.09033159166574478,
-0.20164303481578827,
0.3226104974746704,
0.5455330014228821,
-0.08788258582353592,
0.27338123321533203,
0.30196914076805115,
-0.053465381264686584,
0.0735456719994545,
0.44841498136520386,
0.6710230112075806,
-0.6722181439399719,
-0.1917470544576645,
-1.166677713394165,
0.3079765737056732,
-0.19951394200325012,
-0.14715316891670227,
0.8814737796783447,
0.4395577013492584,
0.8127036690711975,
0.008403091691434383,
0.7585304975509644,
-0.10998570173978806,
0.5405092835426331,
-0.512367308139801,
0.7477741837501526,
-0.5210322141647339,
0.34312814474105835,
-0.08201946318149567,
-0.5182644128799438,
-0.35190439224243164,
0.6521521210670471,
-0.3865683376789093,
-0.07643652707338333,
0.4269801676273346,
1.0189565420150757,
-0.3042074739933014,
0.12359701097011566,
0.5400696992874146,
0.10771667212247849,
0.20912210643291473,
0.38652706146240234,
0.749741792678833,
-0.35398662090301514,
0.6407994031906128,
-0.05121241882443428,
-0.06581509113311768,
-0.6409681439399719,
-1.0914946794509888,
-1.3034275770187378,
-0.35897964239120483,
-0.42007043957710266,
-0.37539538741111755,
0.13630570471286774,
0.8989666700363159,
0.7049781680107117,
-1.0900241136550903,
-0.05299443006515503,
-0.3841152787208557,
-0.17143549025058746,
-0.11619848757982254,
-0.23438739776611328,
0.18286335468292236,
-0.3648642897605896,
-0.489604115486145,
0.5127821564674377,
0.3391311764717102,
-0.18744081258773804,
-0.21471630036830902,
-0.18176433444023132,
-0.3050820231437683,
0.2270289957523346,
0.634645938873291,
0.5976329445838928,
-0.667796790599823,
-0.3528555929660797,
0.4125257134437561,
0.07780645042657852,
0.3390941023826599,
0.8904106616973877,
-0.4784241020679474,
0.4042655825614929,
0.7629760503768921,
0.45631158351898193,
0.463460773229599,
0.2692870497703552,
0.5104843974113464,
-1.257576823234558,
-0.01578863337635994,
0.25238674879074097,
0.3220413625240326,
0.3145480453968048,
-0.02822069637477398,
0.3921565115451813,
0.3764583468437195,
-0.3064707815647125,
-0.7611715793609619,
0.033181484788656235,
-1.01082181930542,
-0.030778013169765472,
1.2968512773513794,
-0.34330686926841736,
-0.24190838634967804,
-0.06936536729335785,
-0.22809164226055145,
0.20517686009407043,
-0.8266615271568298,
0.4880368411540985,
0.571757972240448,
-0.4516020715236664,
-0.7608342170715332,
-0.6615591645240784,
0.4959942102432251,
0.5666230320930481,
-0.4544857144355774,
-0.16448649764060974,
0.46991705894470215,
0.5688557028770447,
-0.25433653593063354,
0.9762957096099854,
0.07414351403713226,
0.5317556858062744,
-0.07006701827049255,
-0.2629348635673523,
0.0027229017578065395,
-0.15505647659301758,
-0.7570263743400574,
0.08575505018234253,
0.102859728038311,
-0.6297029256820679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00231v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00231v3
|
Multimodal ArXiv: A Dataset for Improving Scientific Comprehension of Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-03-01T02:21:30 | 2024-06-02T15:47:16 |
Lei Li, Yuqi Wang, Runxin Xu, Peiyi Wang, Xiachong Feng, Lingpeng Kong, Qi Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Large vision-language models (LVLMs) excel across diverse tasks involving
concrete images from natural scenes. However, their ability to interpret
abstract figures, such as geometry shapes and scientific plots, remains limited
due to a scarcity of training datasets in scientific domains. To fill this gap,
we introduce Multimodal ArXiv, consisting of ArXivCap and ArXivQA, for
enhancing LVLMs scientific comprehension. ArXivCap is a figure-caption dataset
comprising 6.4M images and 3.9M captions, sourced from 572K ArXiv papers
spanning various scientific domains. Drawing from ArXivCap, we introduce
ArXivQA, a question-answering dataset generated by prompting GPT-4V based on
scientific figures. ArXivQA greatly enhances open-sourced LVLMs' mathematical
reasoning capabilities, achieving a 10.4\% absolute accuracy gain on a
multimodal mathematical reasoning benchmark. Furthermore, employing ArXivCap,
we devise four vision-to-text tasks for benchmarking LVLMs. Evaluation results
with state-of-the-art LVLMs underscore their struggle with the nuanced
semantics of academic figures, while domain-specific training yields
substantial performance gains. Our error analysis uncovers misinterpretations
of visual context, recognition errors, and the production of overly simplified
captions by current LVLMs, shedding light on future improvements.
|
[
-0.365293025970459,
-0.46852776408195496,
0.7147441506385803,
0.21036967635154724,
-0.3506670296192169,
0.16845357418060303,
0.09103158116340637,
-0.42671632766723633,
-0.2886076271533966,
0.4407847821712494,
-0.36626145243644714,
-0.322910338640213,
-0.4108130633831024,
0.22361119091510773,
-0.15029044449329376,
0.7276955246925354,
-0.18021787703037262,
0.32388952374458313,
-1.0152474641799927,
-0.5534038543701172,
-0.10446152091026306,
-0.27730321884155273,
-0.5385037660598755,
-0.13065026700496674,
0.8124799132347107,
0.020977871492505074,
0.5566350221633911,
0.5461908578872681,
0.6647965908050537,
0.29093465209007263,
0.2330092489719391,
0.6258413791656494,
-0.019497772678732872,
0.09129494428634644,
-0.2924502193927765,
-0.4699021875858307,
-0.2548366189002991,
-0.14663463830947876,
0.8351109623908997,
0.44260942935943604,
0.05480626970529556,
-0.011274063028395176,
-0.35584986209869385,
0.7706839442253113,
-0.637965202331543,
0.5249277949333191,
-0.3908696472644806,
0.049082305282354355,
0.13067927956581116,
-0.42709946632385254,
-0.5476683378219604,
-0.021110082045197487,
0.23607449233531952,
-1.0302776098251343,
0.15178266167640686,
0.4190950095653534,
0.6391363143920898,
0.45709362626075745,
-0.5605201721191406,
-0.050459425896406174,
-0.1972959190607071,
0.9343881011009216,
-0.4758569896221161,
0.7116353511810303,
0.1704212874174118,
0.30427828431129456,
0.1218339130282402,
-0.7045062184333801,
-0.8749423623085022,
-0.2290506213903427,
-0.11097542196512222,
0.25761884450912476,
-0.3684462308883667,
-0.06536532193422318,
0.4260692894458771,
-0.09541968256235123,
-0.7896937131881714,
-0.4017123878002167,
-0.5651786923408508,
-0.17799578607082367,
0.3405347168445587,
-0.12122780829668045,
0.33355215191841125,
-0.15721780061721802,
-0.33106938004493713,
-0.5186403393745422,
-0.46884769201278687,
0.0846281498670578,
0.05840742215514183,
-0.04384571686387062,
0.06048712879419327,
0.7227871417999268,
-0.03772049397230148,
0.8865794539451599,
-0.40261703729629517,
-0.30423596501350403,
0.3825943171977997,
-0.5306076407432556,
-0.3396104574203491,
-0.32558855414390564,
0.587965190410614,
0.4804029166698456,
0.32404249906539917,
-0.11920304596424103,
0.008275585249066353,
0.016475440934300423,
0.1476217359304428,
-0.7541800737380981,
-0.3570882976055145,
0.21803684532642365,
-0.2883646488189697,
-0.07022833824157715,
-0.1502586007118225,
-0.863304853439331,
-0.47624585032463074,
-0.5380039811134338,
0.3936731517314911,
-0.5361913442611694,
-0.0805184543132782,
-0.04978783801198006,
-0.20866255462169647,
0.05108697712421417,
0.6935047507286072,
-0.47525903582572937,
-0.027702799066901207,
0.3173981308937073,
1.0551786422729492,
-0.2536012828350067,
-0.38871142268180847,
-0.7692437171936035,
0.14626488089561462,
-0.20909321308135986,
1.0457521677017212,
-0.7426235675811768,
-0.06235310062766075,
-0.11822857707738876,
0.11411213874816895,
-0.3309400975704193,
-0.2814781367778778,
0.4583286941051483,
-0.6524747610092163,
0.26039084792137146,
-0.1274534910917282,
-0.07730979472398758,
-0.5583909749984741,
0.4889313280582428,
-0.7765278816223145,
0.6765789985656738,
-0.11602812260389328,
-0.6269023418426514,
0.25080379843711853,
-0.9387298226356506,
-0.2581574618816376,
0.0342300683259964,
-0.2455841302871704,
-0.4006524682044983,
-0.23063300549983978,
0.6579741835594177,
0.5271897912025452,
-0.11895608901977539,
-0.05002434924244881,
-0.2723604738712311,
0.06856265664100647,
0.40976426005363464,
-0.5860732793807983,
0.37408915162086487,
0.3026704788208008,
0.04446420446038246,
0.24805770814418793,
-0.7800782322883606,
0.23444682359695435,
0.10716508328914642,
-0.10335922241210938,
-0.478463351726532,
0.04274130240082741,
0.13479050993919373,
0.12384798377752304,
0.04456382989883423,
-0.4624515175819397,
0.22801190614700317,
-0.1330547332763672,
0.8560196161270142,
0.5297480821609497,
-0.09062951803207397,
0.556128978729248,
-0.21794022619724274,
0.5272858738899231,
0.12437201291322708,
0.13621246814727783,
-0.4682613015174866,
-0.5658581256866455,
-0.48479533195495605,
-0.40382158756256104,
0.0886349305510521,
0.49255773425102234,
-1.5086655616760254,
-0.431663453578949,
-0.3499491810798645,
-0.44879430532455444,
-0.46681153774261475,
0.13344691693782806,
0.40244531631469727,
0.628286600112915,
0.5851089954376221,
-0.1262897402048111,
-0.15200640261173248,
-0.8701839447021484,
-0.030126554891467094,
-0.08334819972515106,
0.14925885200500488,
0.5300814509391785,
0.84794020652771,
-0.2125866711139679,
0.6393846869468689,
-0.25256550312042236,
-0.08116389811038971,
0.28730830550193787,
0.2294481098651886,
-0.11211930215358734,
0.2629678547382355,
0.6259763836860657,
-1.1846131086349487,
-0.30126121640205383,
0.1966143548488617,
-0.7503972053527832,
0.2880544066429138,
-0.23533140122890472,
-0.08901114016771317,
0.3901223838329315,
0.29831162095069885,
-0.6385700702667236,
0.22663326561450958,
0.6292043924331665,
-0.41055864095687866,
0.6698449850082397,
-0.2981334626674652,
0.6131428480148315,
-0.7761943340301514,
0.1468292474746704,
0.27480605244636536,
-0.21938833594322205,
-0.37054815888404846,
0.12372471392154694,
0.3154585361480713,
-0.06192581355571747,
-0.7788466811180115,
0.6319745779037476,
-0.3999723196029663,
-0.030181284993886948,
-0.008305256254971027,
0.2246534526348114,
0.4232611060142517,
0.48856475949287415,
0.2624240815639496,
1.1472824811935425,
0.7052814960479736,
-0.3003462255001068,
0.6266617178916931,
0.4575085937976837,
-0.49616381525993347,
0.7080665230751038,
-0.8594980835914612,
0.052184637635946274,
-0.43742093443870544,
0.3701700270175934,
-0.9904778003692627,
-0.4453336000442505,
0.34564849734306335,
-0.44746339321136475,
-0.04112088680267334,
-0.10911385715007782,
-0.4338286817073822,
-0.1940978765487671,
-0.11812464892864227,
0.6090603470802307,
0.10607676208019257,
-0.6400591135025024,
0.7937232255935669,
-0.10825036466121674,
-0.21243096888065338,
-0.9840591549873352,
-0.5730159878730774,
0.10642014443874359,
-0.0704934149980545,
-0.7607799768447876,
0.051554203033447266,
-0.24429923295974731,
-0.41476282477378845,
0.11975443363189697,
0.004314339254051447,
-0.15065798163414001,
-0.41894102096557617,
0.16677549481391907,
0.44005563855171204,
-0.12006017565727234,
0.39091986417770386,
-0.010239332914352417,
0.174814373254776,
0.13288946449756622,
-0.22118403017520905,
0.2570207715034485,
-0.5387994647026062,
-0.4482482671737671,
-0.33655795454978943,
0.389754056930542,
1.0325173139572144,
-0.5931267142295837,
0.4817216694355011,
0.6742087602615356,
-0.1686280369758606,
0.013116519898176193,
-0.3245179355144501,
-0.04539575055241585,
-0.40575674176216125,
0.4598378539085388,
-0.45778417587280273,
-0.5948271155357361,
0.23263199627399445,
0.12777209281921387,
0.19020502269268036,
0.40529173612594604,
0.3766734004020691,
-0.2420857846736908,
1.116637945175171,
0.2902362644672394,
0.5006643533706665,
0.2542615532875061,
-0.24002693593502045,
-0.010528321377933025,
-0.7746967673301697,
-0.5713752508163452,
-0.29273518919944763,
0.0002636952558532357,
-0.0403410829603672,
-0.808752715587616,
0.46537572145462036,
-0.3456535339355469,
-0.07808317244052887,
-0.015801016241312027,
-0.7850785255432129,
0.5878415703773499,
0.6492090225219727,
0.12613998353481293,
0.3972315490245819,
0.3827720582485199,
0.07887257635593414,
-0.06846150755882263,
-0.6967974305152893,
-0.5263180732727051,
0.9432932734489441,
0.24789032340049744,
0.7164325714111328,
0.04745405167341232,
-0.0241953507065773,
0.3372421860694885,
0.03671811521053314,
-0.7258836030960083,
0.3816853165626526,
0.057337354868650436,
-0.42926183342933655,
-0.17925214767456055,
-0.4161764681339264,
-0.731188178062439,
0.541745126247406,
-0.4812239408493042,
-0.26463809609413147,
0.29899486899375916,
0.23626863956451416,
-0.3878251314163208,
0.2766662836074829,
-0.9411041140556335,
1.004601001739502,
-0.4688333570957184,
-0.535476565361023,
-0.13645601272583008,
-0.6691973209381104,
0.35114699602127075,
-0.10634124279022217,
0.4012974500656128,
0.08231338858604431,
-0.11565553396940231,
0.6843775510787964,
0.07716742157936096,
0.6371635794639587,
-0.08972656726837158,
0.027387799695134163,
0.23998913168907166,
-0.06370489299297333,
0.37356919050216675,
0.2503218948841095,
0.20951013267040253,
0.1653399020433426,
0.7299991846084595,
-0.5273637175559998,
-0.8866599202156067,
0.6460531949996948,
-0.9068998098373413,
-0.3566471338272095,
-0.7534115314483643,
-0.9769125580787659,
-0.19785122573375702,
0.15440407395362854,
-0.17687572538852692,
0.6560489535331726,
0.35473182797431946,
0.5554759502410889,
0.9270160794258118,
-0.30477625131607056,
0.32726389169692993,
0.28272178769111633,
-0.018122471868991852,
-0.5974198579788208,
0.8994084596633911,
-0.19818702340126038,
0.3989820182323456,
0.47580984234809875,
-0.04542119801044464,
-0.665129542350769,
-0.5648656487464905,
-0.6028949618339539,
0.273080050945282,
-0.9955422878265381,
-0.18255341053009033,
-0.7527531385421753,
0.022841647267341614,
-0.4824811518192291,
-0.05814302712678909,
0.005821084138005972,
-0.4958432614803314,
-0.2173686921596527,
0.34876182675361633,
0.5334576964378357,
0.49849164485931396,
0.0057336860336363316,
0.055400360375642776,
-0.69969642162323,
0.36363887786865234,
0.5068910121917725,
0.025544866919517517,
-0.12773427367210388,
-0.531679630279541,
-0.031542569398880005,
0.22381803393363953,
-0.13091236352920532,
-0.45752009749412537,
0.4769437313079834,
0.3557044565677643,
0.5182883739471436,
0.33833035826683044,
-0.18367144465446472,
0.7557145357131958,
-0.7203419208526611,
0.718787431716919,
0.43962937593460083,
-0.6884903907775879,
0.4623664915561676,
-0.2389615774154663,
0.2486797273159027,
0.21763481199741364,
0.4186055660247803,
-0.43731409311294556,
0.04019807279109955,
-0.33648228645324707,
-0.5058168768882751,
0.35458752512931824,
0.16970640420913696,
0.036411967128515244,
0.32610753178596497,
0.29036423563957214,
0.11963756382465363,
0.33139896392822266,
-0.9340833425521851,
-0.00862949900329113,
-0.7287275791168213,
-0.3111295998096466,
-0.2243187427520752,
0.06447753310203552,
-0.46346262097358704,
-0.4806424379348755,
0.5897949934005737,
-0.41708624362945557,
0.3469708561897278,
0.397589772939682,
-0.11731498688459396,
0.04540900141000748,
0.26825302839279175,
1.0667436122894287,
1.0839786529541016,
-0.013104128651320934,
0.5738328099250793,
-0.03576106205582619,
-0.5631966590881348,
-0.11645574867725372,
0.18566077947616577,
0.15159110724925995,
-0.04836618900299072,
0.5517643690109253,
0.8672767281532288,
-0.24186035990715027,
-1.1835426092147827,
0.35166263580322266,
-0.025115931406617165,
-0.5479022264480591,
-0.2994186282157898,
0.007887774147093296,
-0.05929262191057205,
0.5836632251739502,
0.4659977853298187,
0.49696409702301025,
0.020468275994062424,
-0.5476020574569702,
0.15952278673648834,
0.41761156916618347,
-0.1883542388677597,
-0.12120692431926727,
0.8798369765281677,
0.06215974688529968,
0.02354585751891136,
0.4026903808116913,
-0.03913005068898201,
-0.3825926184654236,
0.6135640740394592,
0.2870657444000244,
0.1676236093044281,
0.24276608228683472,
0.4265039563179016,
0.2542681396007538,
0.35977891087532043,
-0.009777165949344635,
0.12082602828741074,
-0.09626682847738266,
-0.6254039406776428,
-0.7729493975639343,
-0.5181498527526855,
-0.6374630928039551,
0.03512211889028549,
-0.34553879499435425,
-0.09141020476818085,
-0.3141633868217468,
0.2329854816198349,
0.3765433430671692,
-0.17785203456878662,
-0.5843256115913391,
0.3292711079120636,
0.08300182223320007,
0.7320762276649475,
-0.7097187638282776,
0.8004263639450073,
1.131137490272522,
-0.5480332374572754,
-0.32413291931152344,
-0.5947209596633911,
-0.28694942593574524,
-1.0103480815887451,
0.8160151243209839,
0.019784120842814445,
-0.12593510746955872,
0.011780074797570705,
-0.9111714363098145,
-0.6926618218421936,
1.1107970476150513,
0.21451902389526367,
-0.6274195313453674,
0.03597511351108551,
0.0934760570526123,
0.5006847381591797,
-0.3575136661529541,
0.19938570261001587,
0.13951322436332703,
0.6825380921363831,
0.5167365670204163,
-0.5716512799263,
-0.15369530022144318,
-0.5012643337249756,
-0.2575031518936157,
-0.017628679051995277,
-0.5425562262535095,
0.730011522769928,
-0.36974257230758667,
0.07192689180374146,
0.04470478743314743,
0.592731237411499,
0.4975709915161133,
0.6861052513122559,
0.6203562617301941,
0.4619588255882263,
0.6915900111198425,
-0.2967751920223236,
0.9329082369804382,
0.023967109620571136,
0.09683522582054138,
0.7827568650245667,
-0.0006020385771989822,
0.8911414742469788,
0.8668014407157898,
-0.0740140900015831,
0.495320588350296,
0.648306131362915,
-0.3722889721393585,
0.6406040191650391,
-0.20136046409606934,
-0.45695066452026367,
-0.49934861063957214,
-0.09938865154981613,
-0.3492259085178375,
0.16206593811511993,
0.4128582179546356,
-0.23417474329471588,
-0.08535744249820709,
0.5960938334465027,
-0.28570568561553955,
0.14781878888607025,
-0.3722319006919861,
0.25295504927635193,
0.03467260301113129,
-0.6445404887199402,
0.4218593239784241,
-0.31772172451019287,
0.3577742874622345,
-0.43129438161849976,
-0.4030996263027191,
0.13585011661052704,
0.1947137415409088,
-0.23311994969844818,
-1.0516387224197388,
0.016954928636550903,
-0.16538608074188232,
-0.37960970401763916,
-0.3022414743900299,
0.5165349841117859,
-0.564521074295044,
-0.5633173584938049,
-0.2480204850435257,
0.39687463641166687,
0.2939099669456482,
-0.3002912998199463,
-0.9027804732322693,
0.11401134729385376,
-0.008476531133055687,
-0.08271604031324387,
0.08713260293006897,
0.3558436632156372,
-0.19531507790088654,
0.972015917301178,
0.8597266674041748,
-0.17339764535427094,
0.10186547785997391,
-0.04246058687567711,
0.7830257415771484,
-0.28341954946517944,
-0.03379553183913231,
-0.5444033741950989,
0.5697805881500244,
-0.18236258625984192,
-0.17052628099918365,
0.6815691590309143,
0.4276912212371826,
0.690441370010376,
-0.32643643021583557,
0.903706431388855,
-0.04172441363334656,
0.3062281906604767,
-0.5891854763031006,
0.6662936806678772,
-0.9761241674423218,
-0.1906999945640564,
-0.023038620129227638,
-0.856952965259552,
-0.6164635419845581,
0.7860920429229736,
-0.31488990783691406,
-0.19601407647132874,
0.8408868908882141,
0.665043830871582,
-0.14618070423603058,
-0.1651962399482727,
0.4158315062522888,
0.08704423159360886,
0.3652837574481964,
0.43721842765808105,
0.9511917233467102,
-0.4845365881919861,
0.8647995591163635,
-0.14675377309322357,
-0.1876157522201538,
0.04762204736471176,
-0.8881477117538452,
-1.1627706289291382,
-0.7544217109680176,
-0.4805469810962677,
-0.1634570211172104,
0.11017253994941711,
0.5923028588294983,
0.5844964385032654,
-0.6851196885108948,
0.40233728289604187,
0.05918686464428902,
-0.0043451073579490185,
-0.19814659655094147,
-0.20774933695793152,
0.5434568524360657,
-0.27200424671173096,
-0.9633632302284241,
0.36434799432754517,
0.40321069955825806,
0.1624642312526703,
-0.36413928866386414,
-0.13423103094100952,
-0.24423690140247345,
0.12161683291196823,
1.0593442916870117,
0.42024365067481995,
-0.8468073010444641,
-0.3462783396244049,
0.2960295081138611,
0.09674464166164398,
0.06155078485608101,
0.4482952058315277,
-0.6295345425605774,
0.8300474286079407,
0.4359322488307953,
0.5598068237304688,
0.4181576073169708,
0.07283031195402145,
0.13614051043987274,
-0.5143550634384155,
0.21420714259147644,
0.32926133275032043,
0.45074039697647095,
0.42116308212280273,
-0.020202748477458954,
0.451553612947464,
0.44309768080711365,
-0.6432912945747375,
-0.9490589499473572,
0.019930429756641388,
-1.4074513912200928,
-0.39509886503219604,
1.223793625831604,
-0.052895572036504745,
-0.5234401822090149,
-0.0844554603099823,
-0.4603322148323059,
-0.17658810317516327,
-0.33969852328300476,
0.5442265868186951,
0.8119385242462158,
-0.10361095517873764,
-0.7520681023597717,
-0.8500934839248657,
0.3142516613006592,
0.34237581491470337,
-0.9597082138061523,
-0.12560167908668518,
0.6980949640274048,
0.13983654975891113,
0.4516114890575409,
0.0630044937133789,
-0.05089585855603218,
0.5925928354263306,
-0.06786194443702698,
0.1885875016450882,
-0.4634712040424347,
-0.5186145901679993,
0.08997971564531326,
0.19659191370010376,
-0.3036912977695465,
-0.1935470849275589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00226v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00226v3
|
A Semantic Distance Metric Learning approach for Lexical Semantic Change Detection
| 2024-03-01T02:09:25 | 2024-06-01T09:23:22 |
Taichi Aida, Danushka Bollegala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Detecting temporal semantic changes of words is an important task for various
NLP applications that must make time-sensitive predictions. Lexical Semantic
Change Detection (SCD) task involves predicting whether a given target word,
$w$, changes its meaning between two different text corpora, $C_1$ and $C_2$.
For this purpose, we propose a supervised two-staged SCD method that uses
existing Word-in-Context (WiC) datasets. In the first stage, for a target word
$w$, we learn two sense-aware encoders that represent the meaning of $w$ in a
given sentence selected from a corpus. Next, in the second stage, we learn a
sense-aware distance metric that compares the semantic representations of a
target word across all of its occurrences in $C_1$ and $C_2$. Experimental
results on multiple benchmark datasets for SCD show that our proposed method
achieves strong performance in multiple languages. Additionally, our method
achieves significant improvements on WiC benchmarks compared to a sense-aware
encoder with conventional distance functions. Source code is available at
https://github.com/LivNLP/svp-sdml .
|
[
-0.045156970620155334,
-0.4509572684764862,
0.49162501096725464,
0.15455181896686554,
-0.34092989563941956,
-0.217971071600914,
-0.333454430103302,
-0.679614782333374,
0.19748952984809875,
0.15943633019924164,
-0.7442533373832703,
-0.8612074255943298,
-0.773335874080658,
0.026348475366830826,
-0.2713145315647125,
0.48946404457092285,
-0.30785396695137024,
0.39741382002830505,
-0.10725782066583633,
-0.41935810446739197,
-0.5162689089775085,
-0.1117754802107811,
-0.47076135873794556,
-0.1439109593629837,
0.5828729867935181,
0.2789272665977478,
0.3677627146244049,
0.5851774215698242,
0.44505906105041504,
0.16670261323451996,
-0.24559688568115234,
0.48363974690437317,
0.1286805272102356,
0.3085132837295532,
-0.4663549065589905,
-0.38620761036872864,
0.06562630087137222,
-0.2314462512731552,
0.6904258131980896,
0.6863797903060913,
-0.10032571852207184,
0.11458343267440796,
0.05880473926663399,
0.7185697555541992,
-0.9107214212417603,
0.41338133811950684,
-1.074325680732727,
0.36697155237197876,
-0.48539331555366516,
-0.13688510656356812,
-0.16763845086097717,
0.03695144131779671,
-0.10893971472978592,
-0.7041290402412415,
0.21148307621479034,
-0.1490345001220703,
0.9838568568229675,
0.5057345628738403,
-0.2891598641872406,
-0.32579517364501953,
-0.5238540768623352,
0.6739126443862915,
-0.6823272705078125,
0.9171016216278076,
0.3079410195350647,
0.23762042820453644,
-0.22680158913135529,
-0.5649270415306091,
-0.7990889549255371,
-0.13999991118907928,
0.18872404098510742,
0.2975377142429352,
-0.08115051686763763,
-0.23493464291095734,
0.3297911286354065,
-0.09282677620649338,
-0.4754326641559601,
0.33117133378982544,
-0.3216441571712494,
-0.27099916338920593,
0.22500082850456238,
0.215302973985672,
-0.017524369060993195,
-0.03416149690747261,
-0.5164020657539368,
-0.21528363227844238,
-0.5081080794334412,
-0.1871057152748108,
0.10757128149271011,
0.413004070520401,
-0.22448471188545227,
0.5137497782707214,
-0.41860824823379517,
0.5313383340835571,
-0.0840655192732811,
-0.11398934572935104,
0.351540744304657,
-0.36000508069992065,
0.12032584846019745,
0.2680753171443939,
0.18321610987186432,
0.5394291877746582,
0.10205914825201035,
-0.13649523258209229,
-0.16729570925235748,
0.7874699234962463,
-0.11771110445261002,
-0.5328429937362671,
-0.027248412370681763,
-0.15463683009147644,
-0.452555775642395,
-0.16233310103416443,
-0.045226600021123886,
-0.46732282638549805,
-0.317806214094162,
-0.6195741891860962,
0.2981349527835846,
-0.6271934509277344,
-0.3398487865924835,
0.3287399411201477,
-0.2554287612438202,
0.30728062987327576,
0.11134719103574753,
-0.7265506386756897,
0.2985168993473053,
0.7080375552177429,
1.0824522972106934,
-0.5999550819396973,
-0.39456573128700256,
-0.6001285910606384,
0.19161444902420044,
-0.7266123294830322,
0.8333047032356262,
-0.4324313700199127,
-0.346419095993042,
0.02558722533285618,
0.007489343173801899,
-0.09694412350654602,
-0.49527740478515625,
0.15432170033454895,
-0.5159858465194702,
-0.007821977138519287,
-0.3567144572734833,
-0.678068220615387,
0.2764597237110138,
0.4465715289115906,
-0.4404228925704956,
1.5415980815887451,
0.5052337050437927,
-1.3241310119628906,
0.8789975047111511,
-0.5408709049224854,
-0.24647663533687592,
0.10370439291000366,
0.08319909870624542,
-0.2032778412103653,
0.10256365686655045,
0.07866058498620987,
0.2996060252189636,
0.3820776343345642,
-0.1307123601436615,
-0.338363379240036,
-0.2682029604911804,
0.049805060029029846,
-0.10465399920940399,
0.29355472326278687,
0.31643146276474,
-0.15028175711631775,
-0.007047674153000116,
-0.8622088432312012,
0.0752083957195282,
-0.08337578922510147,
-0.27247700095176697,
-0.6591289639472961,
0.3930152654647827,
0.22030164301395416,
0.5649327039718628,
0.3249482810497284,
-0.991416871547699,
-0.1218380406498909,
-0.525608479976654,
0.017857417464256287,
0.7180121541023254,
0.024599505588412285,
0.22081220149993896,
-0.005016663111746311,
0.22996629774570465,
0.6185813546180725,
0.08949001133441925,
0.17903077602386475,
-0.18659032881259918,
-0.6913841962814331,
-0.031015856191515923,
0.17717859148979187,
0.5037007927894592,
-0.9842173457145691,
0.48533472418785095,
-0.21249181032180786,
-0.4160093665122986,
-0.3348391354084015,
-0.06003915145993233,
0.24854089319705963,
0.5444714426994324,
0.7157964706420898,
-0.2643307149410248,
-0.33550214767456055,
-0.5700214505195618,
-0.6268883347511292,
-0.3398895561695099,
-0.2948329746723175,
-0.04670478031039238,
0.5501381158828735,
-0.3741888999938965,
1.2429617643356323,
-0.8047956228256226,
-0.5894181728363037,
0.07541771978139877,
-0.13508263230323792,
-0.424434632062912,
0.2789708971977234,
0.29272890090942383,
-0.7185273766517639,
-0.14724791049957275,
0.01745384931564331,
-0.32140591740608215,
-0.3851800858974457,
0.009818656370043755,
0.0350930355489254,
0.42858538031578064,
1.0607441663742065,
-0.2976144850254059,
0.7841075658798218,
0.5839406847953796,
-0.6490620374679565,
0.8980413675308228,
-0.2958379089832306,
0.05713332071900368,
-1.2820367813110352,
-0.38249263167381287,
-0.07039234787225723,
-0.12295574694871902,
-0.3190423548221588,
-0.24714134633541107,
0.15344136953353882,
0.22005532681941986,
-0.7892501950263977,
0.7449295520782471,
-0.10701604932546616,
-0.37734106183052063,
-0.1395639032125473,
0.4176810383796692,
-0.258164644241333,
0.2889927625656128,
0.39478328824043274,
0.2537611126899719,
0.3467811048030853,
-0.870046854019165,
0.2104649841785431,
0.07084987312555313,
-0.49640989303588867,
0.7702481150627136,
-0.2543591558933258,
-0.1910853236913681,
-0.11640743166208267,
0.30934077501296997,
-0.7117179036140442,
0.12292688339948654,
0.21640627086162567,
-0.7885504961013794,
-0.11480548977851868,
0.04737591743469238,
-0.7596984505653381,
-0.24851863086223602,
0.005459529347717762,
0.22855447232723236,
-0.12342759221792221,
-0.8279199004173279,
0.3319726884365082,
0.1135639175772667,
0.1821293830871582,
-0.1609923541545868,
-0.8770566582679749,
-0.03197184577584267,
-0.17854394018650055,
-0.5342840552330017,
0.5608418583869934,
0.055293649435043335,
-0.31913867592811584,
0.18950094282627106,
-0.391964316368103,
-0.08595968037843704,
0.10912727564573288,
0.16197499632835388,
0.17289923131465912,
0.09940706938505173,
0.651197075843811,
0.2719363570213318,
-0.3137015700340271,
0.028271052986383438,
-0.6236326098442078,
0.4668404459953308,
-0.018803080543875694,
-0.49246612191200256,
-0.5400515198707581,
0.3327993154525757,
0.15336798131465912,
-0.3393773138523102,
0.7694714665412903,
1.3405858278274536,
-0.830558717250824,
-0.26299288868904114,
-0.3133900463581085,
-0.1454675942659378,
-0.40495073795318604,
0.6243093609809875,
-0.44587722420692444,
-0.9738803505897522,
0.36711350083351135,
-0.31243380904197693,
0.030071979388594627,
0.5413565635681152,
0.4817529618740082,
-0.023111442103981972,
0.8592414259910583,
0.6302229166030884,
0.12065282464027405,
0.7534772753715515,
-0.03553668037056923,
0.11720094084739685,
-0.8768030405044556,
-0.3977220952510834,
-0.7066492438316345,
-0.2224917709827423,
-0.76908940076828,
-0.7842450141906738,
0.38948196172714233,
0.10478436946868896,
-0.20794230699539185,
0.4595281481742859,
-0.4219261109828949,
0.32342591881752014,
0.04015691578388214,
0.13196589052677155,
0.18294170498847961,
0.0582154281437397,
-0.5185214281082153,
-0.5024266839027405,
-0.4191363751888275,
-0.1036769449710846,
0.5885329246520996,
0.0848596915602684,
0.4765004515647888,
0.060836564749479294,
0.5289895534515381,
0.4011518359184265,
-0.1319790929555893,
-0.7550881505012512,
0.5590206980705261,
-0.26067039370536804,
0.18935994803905487,
-0.2231602817773819,
-0.29544177651405334,
-0.6867217421531677,
0.5234598517417908,
-0.3182402551174164,
-0.8212279677391052,
-0.007803095504641533,
-0.14277179539203644,
0.3662894368171692,
0.6140539050102234,
-0.3554155230522156,
0.6449828743934631,
0.1050778478384018,
-0.06858647614717484,
-0.7013769149780273,
-0.6772150993347168,
-0.1858728975057602,
0.07661621272563934,
0.13820689916610718,
-0.3838290274143219,
-0.35354992747306824,
0.7514768838882446,
-0.5355467796325684,
0.40476423501968384,
-0.4278593957424164,
-0.011204679496586323,
0.07432685792446136,
0.4618988335132599,
0.5007696747779846,
0.03879133611917496,
-0.054618772119283676,
0.3006402850151062,
0.3337033689022064,
-0.4380112290382385,
-0.3418491780757904,
0.8067032098770142,
-0.2590012848377228,
0.08376548439264297,
-0.5412444472312927,
-0.49764755368232727,
-0.37727659940719604,
0.03796694055199623,
0.23810037970542908,
0.4182751178741455,
-0.2709142863750458,
-0.24491249024868011,
0.49817386269569397,
-0.1429673135280609,
0.618183970451355,
0.7665887475013733,
0.14546087384223938,
-0.02126648649573326,
0.574809193611145,
-0.15033508837223053,
0.46734818816185,
0.5266863107681274,
0.400688111782074,
-0.4510315954685211,
-0.27003392577171326,
-0.3293026387691498,
0.17136134207248688,
-0.6257144808769226,
-0.05512858182191849,
-0.4828254282474518,
0.15572410821914673,
-0.41749539971351624,
-0.4323336184024811,
-0.5414957404136658,
-0.2503480017185211,
-0.3311063051223755,
0.014806743711233139,
0.5400825142860413,
0.4722343385219574,
-0.29100826382637024,
-0.03746270760893822,
-0.5822903513908386,
0.07032324373722076,
-0.14502549171447754,
0.227974534034729,
-0.27666541934013367,
-0.44357815384864807,
-0.2770169973373413,
0.026689933612942696,
-0.023410674184560776,
-0.6479381918907166,
0.4051215350627899,
0.25896263122558594,
-0.02152404561638832,
0.5030046701431274,
0.15479356050491333,
0.6886386871337891,
-0.5042593479156494,
1.0078567266464233,
0.48364824056625366,
-0.9366944432258606,
0.7236449122428894,
-0.010679084807634354,
0.8422703742980957,
0.3935067355632782,
0.14890433847904205,
-1.2797490358352661,
-0.47010764479637146,
-0.38272225856781006,
-0.5034090876579285,
0.5507261157035828,
-0.14524953067302704,
-0.08819886296987534,
-0.32114794850349426,
0.25481951236724854,
-0.018500521779060364,
-0.17052312195301056,
-0.2315017133951187,
-0.04360928758978844,
0.15568996965885162,
-0.18196216225624084,
0.3096911311149597,
0.06026393920183182,
0.3577600121498108,
-0.18431739509105682,
0.4943590462207794,
-0.39268675446510315,
0.15095970034599304,
0.41729313135147095,
-0.26993101835250854,
0.1864279806613922,
0.2729363739490509,
0.39872053265571594,
0.7686843872070312,
0.11098722368478775,
0.05399356782436371,
0.8603716492652893,
-0.6306123733520508,
-0.3279890716075897,
-0.14748609066009521,
0.030515829101204872,
0.47703564167022705,
0.4985528886318207,
0.553358793258667,
0.46171560883522034,
-0.516092836856842,
0.7174096703529358,
0.060195859521627426,
-0.2619352340698242,
-0.44550949335098267,
-0.24759487807750702,
0.09190208464860916,
0.16218562424182892,
0.011293848976492882,
0.18274334073066711,
-0.06160636618733406,
-0.10369294881820679,
0.4538097679615021,
0.09582481533288956,
-1.0298552513122559,
-0.29120123386383057,
0.6431753039360046,
-0.19817650318145752,
-0.1303664892911911,
0.6301820278167725,
-0.43917733430862427,
-0.761203944683075,
0.5560847520828247,
0.6202016472816467,
0.7023190855979919,
-0.3049415647983551,
0.21807552874088287,
0.5158609747886658,
-0.10533428192138672,
0.040275782346725464,
0.04451905936002731,
-0.4088023006916046,
-0.9741436839103699,
-0.1250983327627182,
-0.7982427477836609,
-0.03174824267625809,
-0.18307174742221832,
-0.8310251832008362,
0.6180456876754761,
-0.3710683286190033,
-0.02095342054963112,
0.003412451595067978,
0.16905252635478973,
-0.6695300936698914,
0.1843111217021942,
0.22030580043792725,
1.026320219039917,
-0.8953104615211487,
0.9079594016075134,
0.43195605278015137,
0.23808443546295166,
-0.5135032534599304,
0.1397583782672882,
0.35006195306777954,
-0.4266156256198883,
0.7496293187141418,
0.13425269722938538,
-0.5620482563972473,
-0.3944019377231598,
-0.1796288639307022,
-0.5571528673171997,
1.2254621982574463,
-0.0256208386272192,
-0.6495806574821472,
0.2228277623653412,
-0.032626595348119736,
0.6960562467575073,
-0.31546080112457275,
-0.09964453428983688,
0.7004054188728333,
0.2620730698108673,
0.05011313036084175,
-0.785789966583252,
-0.2970331609249115,
0.29339203238487244,
0.5082561373710632,
0.5852248668670654,
-0.38011419773101807,
0.45516878366470337,
-0.4171253740787506,
-0.4771050810813904,
0.031994178891181946,
0.929970920085907,
0.2307569980621338,
0.5215741991996765,
0.9029988050460815,
0.7355818748474121,
0.7355197668075562,
-0.21468447148799896,
0.6035844683647156,
-0.3018682897090912,
0.47378143668174744,
1.2724087238311768,
-0.39951589703559875,
1.080682396888733,
0.4843001663684845,
-0.25777605175971985,
0.48201221227645874,
0.8320637941360474,
0.12894827127456665,
0.6216551661491394,
0.4980103671550751,
-0.5999956727027893,
-0.3003329634666443,
-0.3246649205684662,
-0.33714592456817627,
0.6036610007286072,
0.6987621784210205,
0.03136804327368736,
-0.527614951133728,
0.15932992100715637,
0.3847481608390808,
0.4126581847667694,
-0.37206315994262695,
0.6826152801513672,
-0.0018281049560755491,
-0.1890551745891571,
0.04251604899764061,
0.3823195993900299,
0.8479099869728088,
-0.8134542107582092,
-0.04769468680024147,
0.02210119552910328,
0.6314374208450317,
-0.17992864549160004,
-0.4813378155231476,
0.5785255432128906,
-0.1461445540189743,
-0.21927663683891296,
0.08300965279340744,
0.7340825200080872,
-0.8067852854728699,
-0.5108095407485962,
0.7789192199707031,
0.09444880485534668,
0.1636040061712265,
0.06507391482591629,
-0.8628572821617126,
0.15815648436546326,
-0.34820353984832764,
0.30515462160110474,
0.35573914647102356,
0.3644268214702606,
-0.537530779838562,
0.5131297707557678,
0.5842521786689758,
0.4475748538970947,
0.04909277334809303,
0.32158777117729187,
0.6977164149284363,
-0.43119189143180847,
-0.8730435967445374,
-0.4894721806049347,
-0.14037036895751953,
-0.025738989934325218,
-0.5876885652542114,
0.49210017919540405,
0.6600543856620789,
1.3223507404327393,
0.0018588061211630702,
0.33031100034713745,
-0.23021766543388367,
0.7282242774963379,
-0.7962548732757568,
0.4203401505947113,
-0.5610944628715515,
0.14251957833766937,
-0.1909356266260147,
-0.8350644111633301,
-0.49411627650260925,
0.38991519808769226,
-0.09538178145885468,
-0.37254568934440613,
1.1648977994918823,
1.2305407524108887,
0.1347707062959671,
0.008062131702899933,
0.19315283000469208,
0.015362733975052834,
0.2254415601491928,
0.5932382941246033,
0.5657609701156616,
-0.3684069812297821,
0.3095150589942932,
-0.16967400908470154,
-0.07386606931686401,
0.1390083134174347,
-0.8104785084724426,
-0.5050879120826721,
-1.2361400127410889,
-0.5915098190307617,
-0.6264852285385132,
0.24196334183216095,
1.0067230463027954,
0.49910396337509155,
-0.7571880221366882,
0.2715872824192047,
0.013273117132484913,
-0.020476996898651123,
-0.6226397752761841,
-0.27359145879745483,
0.7391216158866882,
-0.49914121627807617,
-0.5402858257293701,
0.38637182116508484,
0.28529787063598633,
-0.3392520546913147,
-0.05767587572336197,
-0.18264593183994293,
-0.33643585443496704,
-0.0666968896985054,
0.7910652756690979,
-0.05038714408874512,
-0.7513971328735352,
-0.7214859127998352,
-0.3462994694709778,
-0.10554442554712296,
-0.2657865285873413,
0.9044705033302307,
-0.8332608938217163,
0.5671741962432861,
0.4894926846027374,
0.44737735390663147,
0.7064194083213806,
-0.25502967834472656,
-0.09972106665372849,
-0.9677990674972534,
0.3473804295063019,
0.04418113827705383,
0.1549525260925293,
0.41202545166015625,
-0.1600790172815323,
0.5765960216522217,
0.6625063419342041,
-0.20993736386299133,
-0.4830567538738251,
0.33695393800735474,
-0.9484081268310547,
-0.360563188791275,
1.3097174167633057,
-0.1378137320280075,
-0.21110646426677704,
-0.15611015260219574,
0.08059336990118027,
0.2989620268344879,
-0.10464630275964737,
0.44884660840034485,
0.6567350029945374,
0.07103458046913147,
0.43438708782196045,
-0.3516417145729065,
0.5576726794242859,
0.0539829321205616,
-0.7152143716812134,
-0.026188479736447334,
0.4665476977825165,
0.6625910401344299,
-0.18342174589633942,
0.33052298426628113,
-0.6139929890632629,
0.21875198185443878,
0.23552864789962769,
0.0706210732460022,
0.09964808076620102,
-0.26804280281066895,
-0.3545565903186798,
-0.5258764624595642,
-0.39277327060699463,
-0.5537093281745911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00212v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00212v1
|
Transcription and translation of videos using fine-tuned XLSR Wav2Vec2 on custom dataset and mBART
| 2024-03-01T01:15:45 | 2024-03-01T01:15:45 |
Aniket Tathe, Anand Kamble, Suyash Kumbharkar, Atharva Bhandare, Anirban C. Mitra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This research addresses the challenge of training an ASR model for
personalized voices with minimal data. Utilizing just 14 minutes of custom
audio from a YouTube video, we employ Retrieval-Based Voice Conversion (RVC) to
create a custom Common Voice 16.0 corpus. Subsequently, a Cross-lingual
Self-supervised Representations (XLSR) Wav2Vec2 model is fine-tuned on this
dataset. The developed web-based GUI efficiently transcribes and translates
input Hindi videos. By integrating XLSR Wav2Vec2 and mBART, the system aligns
the translated text with the video timeline, delivering an accessible solution
for multilingual video content transcription and translation for personalized
voice.
|
[
-0.3506620526313782,
-0.49103593826293945,
0.10150427371263504,
0.21035243570804596,
-0.21677471697330475,
0.26869577169418335,
-0.2647997736930847,
-0.11978819221258163,
0.07964403927326202,
0.41527777910232544,
-0.7624812722206116,
-0.4206882417201996,
-0.6038429737091064,
0.06788066774606705,
-0.6339890956878662,
1.0696747303009033,
0.1374131292104721,
0.4184899926185608,
0.1715216487646103,
-0.1992439180612564,
-0.429410845041275,
-0.22881962358951569,
-0.6128487586975098,
-0.028854958713054657,
0.07929304987192154,
0.6505911350250244,
0.530388593673706,
0.48749297857284546,
0.39771950244903564,
0.25442638993263245,
0.03671922907233238,
0.18622498214244843,
-0.43106988072395325,
-0.11258222907781601,
-0.14650116860866547,
-0.19128435850143433,
-0.21291452646255493,
-0.2782350480556488,
0.5748056769371033,
0.24759146571159363,
-0.33397871255874634,
0.6279769539833069,
0.032274503260850906,
0.33652612566947937,
-0.38022902607917786,
0.029973335564136505,
-0.5722774863243103,
0.15841534733772278,
-0.18840037286281586,
-0.3321990966796875,
-0.2622711956501007,
-0.5141002535820007,
-0.07830269634723663,
-0.48504310846328735,
0.35876867175102234,
-0.20957496762275696,
0.5152902007102966,
0.4917774498462677,
-0.540152907371521,
-0.17058013379573822,
-1.2756774425506592,
0.9344179630279541,
-0.5539230108261108,
0.7243781089782715,
0.39323705434799194,
0.8801071047782898,
0.38438671827316284,
-0.723797082901001,
-0.6942357420921326,
0.3105916976928711,
0.34462541341781616,
0.25204023718833923,
-0.20369718968868256,
-0.1582939177751541,
0.05323851481080055,
0.29845574498176575,
-0.6127312779426575,
0.015854187309741974,
-0.7325832843780518,
-0.17354156076908112,
0.5752847194671631,
0.2652118504047394,
0.5539915561676025,
-0.3733437955379486,
-0.0883350521326065,
-0.26748645305633545,
-0.3856900632381439,
0.33274024724960327,
0.40711620450019836,
0.3679264187812805,
-0.2763237953186035,
0.8256276845932007,
-0.050748441368341446,
0.5053316354751587,
0.1863405555486679,
-0.3190793991088867,
0.33939751982688904,
-0.3873218297958374,
-0.3616187572479248,
0.6626332402229309,
0.7495147585868835,
0.32696011662483215,
0.2835961580276489,
0.15920494496822357,
-0.04768984764814377,
-0.05390539765357971,
0.35277777910232544,
-0.6234368085861206,
0.009178354404866695,
0.004176042042672634,
-0.32117795944213867,
0.03620241582393646,
0.08628105372190475,
-0.43676891922950745,
0.16602879762649536,
-0.5501455068588257,
0.43817976117134094,
-0.35599789023399353,
-0.07095742970705032,
-0.08677893131971359,
-0.06689288467168808,
0.4218762516975403,
0.48680931329727173,
-1.0565731525421143,
0.694981038570404,
0.375247985124588,
0.7703896164894104,
-0.29887184500694275,
0.11245511472225189,
-0.6860870718955994,
0.6211512684822083,
-0.32387349009513855,
0.6268448829650879,
-0.3735744059085846,
-0.526578426361084,
0.15125320851802826,
-0.0393923781812191,
0.17584747076034546,
-0.5986886024475098,
0.5335977077484131,
-0.47066840529441833,
-0.0007057092734612525,
-0.09242226183414459,
-0.39602673053741455,
-0.028255509212613106,
-0.0859169065952301,
-0.4414672553539276,
0.9341483116149902,
0.20681893825531006,
-0.3758911192417145,
0.13671188056468964,
-0.5539066195487976,
-0.634040355682373,
-0.1026151105761528,
-0.3059671223163605,
-0.2107129693031311,
-0.2175370156764984,
0.3151819407939911,
0.3437904417514801,
-0.19706903398036957,
-0.07684212177991867,
0.09505877643823624,
-0.10297977179288864,
0.3564946949481964,
-0.18677374720573425,
0.46759942173957825,
0.548514187335968,
-0.20566144585609436,
0.02222340553998947,
-0.9305650591850281,
0.43560537695884705,
-0.3305768370628357,
-0.314667671918869,
0.10761138796806335,
-0.18892434239387512,
0.5928077101707458,
0.3210083842277527,
0.09764637798070908,
-0.6262658834457397,
-0.03388267755508423,
-0.3474642038345337,
0.5544555187225342,
0.48124387860298157,
-0.12331943958997726,
0.47905412316322327,
0.24006766080856323,
0.5330231189727783,
-0.1297885626554489,
0.16494843363761902,
0.2921830415725708,
-0.4071098566055298,
-0.39305776357650757,
0.043642621487379074,
0.104278564453125,
0.75716233253479,
-0.3042563199996948,
0.18527163565158844,
-0.44470393657684326,
-0.26488196849823,
-0.8531933426856995,
0.6630025506019592,
0.5288216471672058,
0.5368363261222839,
0.8738383054733276,
-0.4028759002685547,
-0.7888681292533875,
-1.0254343748092651,
0.1372179538011551,
0.15108788013458252,
-0.3775809109210968,
0.44904643297195435,
0.022476207464933395,
-0.48049962520599365,
0.9235714077949524,
-0.49774470925331116,
-0.8936631083488464,
-0.6615281105041504,
0.09709090739488602,
-0.05207526311278343,
0.49089720845222473,
0.37698128819465637,
-1.0970724821090698,
-1.0312896966934204,
0.312703013420105,
-0.3976629972457886,
-0.17562779784202576,
-0.08710014820098877,
0.11230486631393433,
-0.033416617661714554,
0.5835378766059875,
-0.3101547360420227,
0.5231443047523499,
0.6399393081665039,
0.13522404432296753,
0.2473304718732834,
-0.28579193353652954,
0.53153395652771,
-1.2470937967300415,
-0.08960746973752975,
-0.039059240370988846,
-0.48840710520744324,
-0.5556277632713318,
-0.39963477849960327,
-0.08487927168607712,
-0.15498457849025726,
-0.6340863704681396,
0.29656580090522766,
-0.14168329536914825,
-0.432145893573761,
-0.2299722135066986,
0.1972484588623047,
-0.2950543165206909,
0.2626208961009979,
0.148368239402771,
0.957057535648346,
0.24694734811782837,
-0.6423200964927673,
0.34135937690734863,
1.0604428052902222,
-0.3673674464225769,
0.5789455771446228,
-0.6739072799682617,
0.17016053199768066,
0.2498375028371811,
0.03756158798933029,
-0.8473303318023682,
-0.3246273100376129,
0.16741789877414703,
-0.9998053908348083,
0.4308665990829468,
-0.28128358721733093,
-0.3644365668296814,
-0.13583804666996002,
0.03405015543103218,
0.23111657798290253,
0.9034823775291443,
-0.3989010751247406,
0.41730597615242004,
0.3975568413734436,
-0.40886691212654114,
-0.08501478284597397,
-1.079248070716858,
0.14523975551128387,
0.0685521811246872,
-0.5439615249633789,
0.6628901362419128,
-0.253814697265625,
0.1311117708683014,
-0.02835104614496231,
-0.23098105192184448,
-0.4458322823047638,
-0.7180067300796509,
0.3067925274372101,
-0.10396759957075119,
-0.34067705273628235,
-0.4873741865158081,
0.48556455969810486,
0.04855455830693245,
-0.16298307478427887,
-0.1309477984905243,
0.2819356322288513,
0.2838573753833771,
-0.1534562110900879,
-0.7972858548164368,
0.6906293630599976,
0.31269413232803345,
-0.23492060601711273,
0.3102583885192871,
1.011810064315796,
-0.23882003128528595,
0.05359523743391037,
-0.7737422585487366,
0.14373892545700073,
-0.4997004270553589,
0.46674907207489014,
-0.4284588694572449,
-0.7629649043083191,
0.3621920943260193,
0.16916656494140625,
-0.43518903851509094,
0.30977314710617065,
0.7017509937286377,
-0.10794485360383987,
1.3402796983718872,
0.37602272629737854,
-0.02550007589161396,
0.5368421077728271,
-0.4342525005340576,
-0.07185014337301254,
-1.054742455482483,
-0.5657457709312439,
-0.3920471668243408,
-0.09080066531896591,
-0.4785550534725189,
-0.3624321222305298,
0.3431941270828247,
-0.353461891412735,
-0.3865223228931427,
0.5946635603904724,
-0.552460789680481,
0.26552507281303406,
0.5652598142623901,
0.08770085126161575,
0.13368874788284302,
0.2914220690727234,
0.05936695635318756,
-0.5933210849761963,
-0.3550957143306732,
-0.34315797686576843,
0.7028840780258179,
0.09991462528705597,
0.8446155786514282,
0.6805574893951416,
0.3945927321910858,
0.48262113332748413,
-0.37952861189842224,
-0.5429884791374207,
0.4467758238315582,
-0.5440349578857422,
-0.6177536249160767,
-0.450344055891037,
-0.27962973713874817,
-0.6631048917770386,
-0.33903512358665466,
-0.07274975627660751,
-0.8477736115455627,
-0.0033756911288946867,
0.21503961086273193,
-0.48185259103775024,
0.22363166511058807,
-0.5883021950721741,
0.636893630027771,
-0.3969970643520355,
-0.49822598695755005,
-0.4704486131668091,
-0.9741376638412476,
0.0754481852054596,
0.10627507418394089,
0.1776379942893982,
0.27569350600242615,
0.05347440391778946,
0.6605631113052368,
-0.44896799325942993,
0.48689714074134827,
-0.07303759455680847,
0.23776875436306,
0.5346198678016663,
0.11673423647880554,
0.12122372537851334,
0.19928722083568573,
0.31809335947036743,
-0.019028102979063988,
0.06121775880455971,
-0.09900283813476562,
-0.693714439868927,
0.7266170382499695,
-1.1666080951690674,
-0.3577188551425934,
-0.09276744723320007,
-0.03813998028635979,
-0.24320879578590393,
0.15877188742160797,
0.32137587666511536,
0.28552547097206116,
-0.31550776958465576,
0.3961479663848877,
0.8510774970054626,
-0.32936856150627136,
0.1352546215057373,
0.5043357610702515,
-0.05295832082629204,
-0.8499207496643066,
0.8619150519371033,
0.0457419715821743,
0.2845715284347534,
0.7107961177825928,
0.037303343415260315,
-0.5570700168609619,
-0.40055954456329346,
-0.8142889142036438,
-0.050362393260002136,
-0.8072595000267029,
-0.2356688231229782,
-0.7686828970909119,
-0.5085030794143677,
-1.0677275657653809,
-0.16324225068092346,
-0.8055826425552368,
-0.26697567105293274,
-0.6117849946022034,
-0.14420954883098602,
0.36171597242355347,
0.8554543852806091,
-0.25411999225616455,
0.4567883610725403,
-1.0532917976379395,
0.7081767916679382,
0.5430557131767273,
0.19118861854076385,
-0.3419815003871918,
-1.1938000917434692,
-0.4720277190208435,
0.029429595917463303,
-0.2783619165420532,
-0.8149799704551697,
0.804679811000824,
0.4964665174484253,
0.4233075976371765,
0.43852341175079346,
-0.464904248714447,
1.1736186742782593,
-0.9170199632644653,
0.8474399447441101,
0.432797908782959,
-1.0087543725967407,
0.7745595574378967,
-0.26154810190200806,
0.28727394342422485,
0.5487037301063538,
0.41860637068748474,
-0.571790874004364,
0.12130585312843323,
-0.18391233682632446,
-0.6986026167869568,
0.6977484226226807,
0.4282737076282501,
0.28515204787254333,
0.39739617705345154,
0.27911508083343506,
0.19375118613243103,
0.0028200787492096424,
-0.35904133319854736,
-0.18450216948986053,
-0.7347279191017151,
-0.2955780625343323,
-0.36788687109947205,
-0.2210405021905899,
0.24040327966213226,
-0.6465969085693359,
0.644632875919342,
-0.00932447798550129,
0.23767560720443726,
0.3084762990474701,
-0.2815498411655426,
-0.12556016445159912,
0.3526500463485718,
0.6555854678153992,
-0.03384530916810036,
-0.36566513776779175,
-0.15643902122974396,
0.2506915032863617,
-0.5846753120422363,
0.36770060658454895,
-0.03312985226511955,
-0.1051877811551094,
0.13875235617160797,
-0.11297920346260071,
0.707204282283783,
0.5652875900268555,
-0.5585715770721436,
0.3570913076400757,
-0.12360361218452454,
-0.0537324994802475,
-0.955014705657959,
0.15780450403690338,
-0.00019494946172926575,
0.1530952751636505,
0.4437633454799652,
0.15899109840393066,
0.5049026608467102,
-0.30664533376693726,
0.22975648939609528,
0.13957594335079193,
-0.6682270765304565,
-0.4773404002189636,
1.174201488494873,
0.0064318254590034485,
-0.5148422122001648,
0.46665266156196594,
0.0033941047731786966,
-0.27453240752220154,
0.23970180749893188,
0.6021318435668945,
0.9133213758468628,
-0.6786674857139587,
0.20648489892482758,
0.6093894243240356,
0.003592252731323242,
-0.32063809037208557,
0.0665411502122879,
-0.21631045639514923,
-0.34650763869285583,
-0.43386006355285645,
-0.592843770980835,
-0.47811445593833923,
0.11193970590829849,
-1.1101714372634888,
0.694607675075531,
-0.16416794061660767,
-0.07912483811378479,
-0.037621501833200455,
-0.26637378334999084,
-0.6839980483055115,
0.6114904880523682,
0.27623599767684937,
0.7081237435340881,
-0.828522264957428,
1.064124584197998,
0.5614832043647766,
-0.6481794714927673,
-1.033453345298767,
-0.5518648624420166,
0.01738811656832695,
-0.4235770106315613,
1.1145009994506836,
-0.25220757722854614,
-0.40684592723846436,
0.16344930231571198,
-0.42242851853370667,
-1.0489420890808105,
1.0445845127105713,
0.23728907108306885,
-0.6074598431587219,
-0.05471908301115036,
0.5196436047554016,
0.6395779848098755,
-0.38181185722351074,
0.05910087004303932,
0.38637906312942505,
0.18568076193332672,
0.33674854040145874,
-1.1013851165771484,
-0.49556276202201843,
-0.3633120656013489,
0.09756451100111008,
-0.22831235826015472,
-0.629800021648407,
0.612492024898529,
-0.1885719895362854,
-0.006549243349581957,
0.060721468180418015,
0.7708456516265869,
-0.22993414103984833,
0.2429398000240326,
0.15323592722415924,
0.37138140201568604,
0.1928725391626358,
0.4353480637073517,
0.894988477230072,
0.05398888885974884,
0.04258091375231743,
1.4498553276062012,
-0.24428114295005798,
1.0209392309188843,
0.47173982858657837,
-0.29875871539115906,
0.5117175579071045,
0.4972060024738312,
-0.1549452245235443,
0.7915142178535461,
-0.0055314768105745316,
-0.19145610928535461,
-0.3533611297607422,
0.04809526354074478,
-0.3045247197151184,
0.7275441288948059,
0.42780178785324097,
-0.28351932764053345,
0.14547474682331085,
0.2635488212108612,
-0.4684140086174011,
0.36580610275268555,
-0.3543573319911957,
1.0321990251541138,
0.09407143294811249,
-0.3861368000507355,
0.20376397669315338,
0.08263453841209412,
0.5011219382286072,
-0.8558156490325928,
-0.06588110327720642,
-0.023707184940576553,
0.33979833126068115,
-0.37924885749816895,
-0.588965654373169,
0.4389595091342926,
0.45947930216789246,
-0.17629210650920868,
-0.3825589418411255,
0.41682231426239014,
-0.5732848644256592,
-0.6610718369483948,
0.21978133916854858,
0.2852349281311035,
0.2424851506948471,
0.11488456279039383,
-0.5194738507270813,
0.07260148227214813,
0.2677568197250366,
-0.09766186028718948,
0.4201241731643677,
0.2822436988353729,
0.04243768751621246,
0.7130911946296692,
0.5438133478164673,
0.21911275386810303,
0.12547360360622406,
0.24643860757350922,
0.5741583108901978,
-0.7348650693893433,
-0.4767534136772156,
-0.6399135589599609,
0.2193383276462555,
0.036567315459251404,
-0.08945059031248093,
0.9291658401489258,
1.011857509613037,
1.1134475469589233,
-0.4796379506587982,
1.1133089065551758,
-0.034813255071640015,
0.7659328579902649,
-0.47282710671424866,
0.6974593997001648,
-0.610103189945221,
-0.024905456230044365,
-0.5188333988189697,
-0.5133899450302124,
-0.27260705828666687,
0.7366586923599243,
0.034223396331071854,
-0.1730041354894638,
0.3557182252407074,
0.7630822062492371,
-0.3354884386062622,
-0.29331785440444946,
0.4968191087245941,
0.007083007134497166,
0.36577004194259644,
0.31340354681015015,
0.42293214797973633,
-0.6822463870048523,
1.1258230209350586,
-0.16203899681568146,
0.1808621734380722,
-0.42151689529418945,
-0.479537695646286,
-0.8632290959358215,
-0.7623420357704163,
-0.5614973306655884,
-0.3382319509983063,
-0.06452324241399765,
1.0808994770050049,
0.8108612895011902,
-1.0209709405899048,
-0.46031060814857483,
0.2927277684211731,
-0.39061009883880615,
-0.07500706613063812,
-0.19789205491542816,
0.3049453794956207,
0.1721111685037613,
-0.8995551466941833,
0.40867260098457336,
0.33442267775535583,
0.3430640697479248,
-0.31232941150665283,
-0.464923232793808,
-0.0704466700553894,
0.1701326221227646,
0.5932349562644958,
0.521416187286377,
-0.7097587585449219,
-0.3315190374851227,
0.2659127414226532,
-0.11302777379751205,
0.4709261655807495,
0.8935679197311401,
-0.4548366963863373,
0.49560368061065674,
0.30783337354660034,
0.4722607731819153,
0.9394660592079163,
0.18705439567565918,
0.48023486137390137,
-0.8767586350440979,
0.1095552146434784,
0.05808253213763237,
0.035809338092803955,
0.6810759902000427,
-0.379119336605072,
0.3102582097053528,
-0.09927002340555191,
-0.41534116864204407,
-0.8301504254341125,
0.14202140271663666,
-1.4724105596542358,
0.15300314128398895,
1.291529893875122,
0.13164985179901123,
-0.15072494745254517,
-0.08521271497011185,
-0.5313257575035095,
0.7273125052452087,
-0.5730220675468445,
0.5571945309638977,
0.20254388451576233,
-0.3125995695590973,
-0.2950963079929352,
-0.8660067915916443,
0.49184760451316833,
0.11299355328083038,
-0.38363412022590637,
-0.27460160851478577,
0.2290499061346054,
0.5390748381614685,
-0.004911961033940315,
0.6395412087440491,
-0.18987509608268738,
0.5073489546775818,
-0.09613998234272003,
0.20701725780963898,
-0.10398852825164795,
-0.011908329091966152,
-0.3231509327888489,
-0.011740743182599545,
-0.06820999085903168,
-0.24057556688785553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00199v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00199v3
|
Improving Socratic Question Generation using Data Augmentation and Preference Optimization
| 2024-03-01T00:08:20 | 2024-04-19T02:36:26 |
Nischal Ashok Kumar, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
The Socratic method is a way of guiding students toward solving a problem
independently without directly revealing the solution to the problem. Although
this method has been shown to significantly improve student learning outcomes,
it remains a complex labor-intensive task for instructors. Large language
models (LLMs) can be used to augment human effort by automatically generating
Socratic questions for students. However, existing methods that involve
prompting these LLMs sometimes produce invalid outputs, e.g., those that
directly reveal the solution to the problem or provide irrelevant or premature
questions. To alleviate this problem, inspired by reinforcement learning with
AI feedback (RLAIF), we first propose a data augmentation method to enrich
existing Socratic questioning datasets with questions that are invalid in
specific ways. Next, we propose a method to optimize open-source LLMs such as
LLama 2 to prefer ground-truth questions over generated invalid ones, using
direct preference optimization (DPO). Our experiments on a Socratic questions
dataset for student code debugging show that a DPO-optimized 7B LLama 2 model
can effectively avoid generating invalid questions, and as a result,
outperforms existing state-of-the-art prompting methods.
|
[
-0.31716153025627136,
-0.8819130659103394,
0.6933633685112,
0.1606808453798294,
-0.41119667887687683,
0.28061848878860474,
-0.21832813322544098,
-0.2042335867881775,
0.015103843994438648,
0.5904139280319214,
-0.5212547779083252,
-0.3934202790260315,
-0.13505904376506805,
0.11813543736934662,
-0.035663899034261703,
0.9522431492805481,
-0.06683244556188583,
0.21482521295547485,
-0.659899890422821,
0.11056742817163467,
-0.3874841630458832,
-0.38764381408691406,
-0.8140127658843994,
-0.4585561454296112,
0.24262656271457672,
0.9863773584365845,
0.6369487047195435,
0.21910332143306732,
0.1498761922121048,
0.2009422779083252,
0.0631164088845253,
0.555648922920227,
-0.5965510606765747,
0.4024246037006378,
0.11952288448810577,
-0.7240850925445557,
-0.09032392501831055,
-0.10429638624191284,
0.49963322281837463,
0.6665861010551453,
-0.06911645829677582,
0.29197952151298523,
-0.09737568348646164,
0.7896270155906677,
-0.41378921270370483,
0.12986157834529877,
-0.5896562337875366,
0.06240895763039589,
0.196005180478096,
-0.3237289488315582,
-0.39355945587158203,
-0.965165913105011,
-0.15679295361042023,
-0.3582541048526764,
0.17368409037590027,
-0.12764529883861542,
0.37237003445625305,
0.4513690173625946,
-0.28766509890556335,
-0.11142311990261078,
-0.699735701084137,
0.5906025171279907,
-0.6358609795570374,
0.14382454752922058,
0.46541905403137207,
0.0906703844666481,
-0.5450292229652405,
-0.20852459967136383,
-0.6485369205474854,
-0.4510711133480072,
0.11807601898908615,
0.2382775992155075,
0.12838692963123322,
0.050521042197942734,
0.2744883894920349,
0.18983210623264313,
-0.55927973985672,
-0.007196994964033365,
-0.6938884854316711,
-0.07557594776153564,
0.8339362740516663,
0.27288618683815,
0.00458904542028904,
-0.3244685232639313,
-0.16394822299480438,
-0.12653090059757233,
-0.9221141338348389,
0.4436998963356018,
0.6874114274978638,
-0.019528381526470184,
0.24281838536262512,
0.4846423864364624,
-0.19739742577075958,
0.8182623982429504,
0.36089807748794556,
-0.14797575771808624,
0.15853053331375122,
-0.03802795708179474,
0.299043208360672,
0.16620559990406036,
0.477351576089859,
0.4395332932472229,
0.2386186271905899,
-0.15576308965682983,
-0.10026343911886215,
0.21409057080745697,
0.14766272902488708,
-0.7506428956985474,
-0.2352541834115982,
0.6572133898735046,
0.07349473237991333,
-0.637753427028656,
-0.11761483550071716,
-0.751883864402771,
-0.3589721918106079,
-0.5355378985404968,
0.2624172866344452,
-0.25509142875671387,
-0.19702784717082977,
0.2313390076160431,
0.1504155844449997,
0.23206186294555664,
0.5846643447875977,
-0.6699232459068298,
0.06426587700843811,
0.5916513204574585,
0.5405328869819641,
-0.1325007677078247,
-0.029850950464606285,
-0.7393959164619446,
-0.010563069023191929,
-0.515669584274292,
0.7998842597007751,
-0.7123714685440063,
-0.6064334511756897,
-0.2132231891155243,
-0.11582604050636292,
0.2672307789325714,
-0.6682548522949219,
0.25290465354919434,
-0.46080341935157776,
0.28691408038139343,
-0.3814835548400879,
-0.37170785665512085,
-0.031158899888396263,
0.2591499090194702,
-0.2720457911491394,
1.3320578336715698,
0.010135095566511154,
-0.4593268930912018,
0.046629905700683594,
-0.3568665385246277,
-0.23849700391292572,
0.14919179677963257,
-0.6140380501747131,
-0.43909087777137756,
0.013726525940001011,
0.37007901072502136,
0.17856121063232422,
-0.3734759986400604,
0.6514596343040466,
-0.045704685151576996,
-0.5218517184257507,
0.2845858037471771,
-0.08129158616065979,
0.8068794012069702,
0.03259122744202614,
-0.4939609467983246,
0.09119399636983871,
-0.6240249276161194,
0.133407324552536,
0.34268611669540405,
-0.3668695092201233,
-0.2497997134923935,
-0.015215342864394188,
-0.4909190237522125,
0.034359488636255264,
0.23165133595466614,
-0.6184316277503967,
0.18968842923641205,
-0.3371172249317169,
0.17907901108264923,
1.1380311250686646,
0.19866660237312317,
0.14898724853992462,
-0.44900768995285034,
0.9271875023841858,
0.036541350185871124,
0.18866461515426636,
0.19999639689922333,
-0.5131610035896301,
-0.8157206177711487,
0.23693275451660156,
-0.03394799306988716,
0.4543048143386841,
-0.9454381465911865,
0.11465539783239365,
0.13989996910095215,
-0.7273083925247192,
-0.6660153269767761,
0.30470651388168335,
0.1822260469198227,
0.7555673122406006,
0.25295984745025635,
-0.13666081428527832,
-0.4272383153438568,
-0.6325432062149048,
0.2295127809047699,
-0.6461700797080994,
0.3698582351207733,
0.7010952830314636,
0.2748657166957855,
0.12060675770044327,
1.0757155418395996,
-0.8136995434761047,
0.43498584628105164,
-0.3263660669326782,
0.0662306547164917,
0.11840204149484634,
0.4765627384185791,
0.4418124258518219,
-0.6728605628013611,
-0.32613497972488403,
-0.46814194321632385,
-0.47064241766929626,
-0.3859637975692749,
-0.13937169313430786,
-0.1905338317155838,
-0.014412125572562218,
0.2728520631790161,
-0.37309297919273376,
0.1983296126127243,
0.34599414467811584,
0.003967777360230684,
0.8867508769035339,
-0.09606920927762985,
0.16615132987499237,
-0.967544674873352,
-0.10310537368059158,
-0.19932177662849426,
-0.11294176429510117,
-0.3679932653903961,
-0.04661133140325546,
0.0719735324382782,
-0.47506752610206604,
-0.44239750504493713,
0.5326546430587769,
-0.21494312584400177,
-0.07304880023002625,
-0.3089101314544678,
0.2914358973503113,
0.20435047149658203,
0.4550798535346985,
0.021084580570459366,
1.1473455429077148,
0.459735244512558,
-0.7004905939102173,
0.7618111371994019,
0.3619861602783203,
-0.2007603645324707,
0.26834312081336975,
-0.9881547093391418,
0.6117403507232666,
-0.6694294214248657,
0.4186815917491913,
-1.2308741807937622,
-0.09478549659252167,
0.40636804699897766,
-0.5549112558364868,
-0.020434794947504997,
-0.15175886452198029,
-0.2714729905128479,
-0.3690631687641144,
-0.6285691857337952,
0.4866877496242523,
0.41823557019233704,
-0.8211629390716553,
0.0893256664276123,
0.1385485827922821,
-0.3489235043525696,
-0.7698764801025391,
-0.14992503821849823,
-0.14781005680561066,
-0.10380394011735916,
-0.6164332628250122,
0.18215204775333405,
-0.37217414379119873,
-0.34968313574790955,
-0.1552821844816208,
-0.13260427117347717,
0.23504804074764252,
0.2071847915649414,
0.23704907298088074,
0.5472046732902527,
-0.03698127716779709,
0.5414066910743713,
0.3115535378456116,
-0.035437535494565964,
0.274869829416275,
0.016776323318481445,
0.6492151618003845,
-0.06408395618200302,
-0.24095439910888672,
-0.08823785185813904,
0.33694738149642944,
0.3191785514354706,
-0.4633674621582031,
0.38398048281669617,
0.33068427443504333,
0.03803250938653946,
-0.3472535014152527,
-0.5738698244094849,
-0.5351659059524536,
-0.48149916529655457,
0.19599400460720062,
-0.22475118935108185,
-0.9395431876182556,
0.3529116213321686,
-0.15420790016651154,
0.1294662356376648,
-0.08220574259757996,
0.45433610677719116,
0.22832205891609192,
1.2056246995925903,
0.30712389945983887,
-0.10864408314228058,
0.3928089141845703,
-0.2599659562110901,
0.17325010895729065,
-0.7482555508613586,
-0.39080891013145447,
-0.6702786684036255,
-0.1185137927532196,
-0.2965822219848633,
-0.42991745471954346,
0.4780576527118683,
0.05811937525868416,
-0.14892277121543884,
0.015617316588759422,
-0.5787739157676697,
0.6171201467514038,
0.6087135076522827,
0.40103864669799805,
0.30914998054504395,
0.08449020981788635,
-0.09328969568014145,
0.05158505588769913,
-0.6432720422744751,
-0.5325024724006653,
1.266137719154358,
0.08536065369844437,
0.9780778288841248,
0.2099829614162445,
0.9771687388420105,
0.13898710906505585,
0.1665254384279251,
-0.8475886583328247,
0.7337851524353027,
0.3160758912563324,
-0.5539155006408691,
-0.23762750625610352,
-0.5874924063682556,
-0.8794530630111694,
0.19412106275558472,
-0.21281607449054718,
-0.5174681544303894,
0.29253241419792175,
0.2670971155166626,
-0.6287317276000977,
-0.04286636784672737,
-0.5116360783576965,
0.4575444161891937,
-0.5114707946777344,
-0.7648937106132507,
-0.10597199201583862,
-0.4929808974266052,
0.33601298928260803,
-0.016511788591742516,
-0.059458017349243164,
-0.1644812971353531,
0.04830078035593033,
0.68216872215271,
-0.37516653537750244,
0.8311452269554138,
-0.26365184783935547,
-0.2626053988933563,
0.6016462445259094,
0.024145174771547318,
0.6147222518920898,
0.5655584931373596,
-0.2567519247531891,
-0.4515407383441925,
-0.17135342955589294,
-0.49799099564552307,
-0.7558713555335999,
0.6672645211219788,
-1.0582927465438843,
-0.9642254710197449,
-0.335688978433609,
-0.4807043671607971,
-0.37540942430496216,
-0.2814885973930359,
0.07098037004470825,
0.5219761729240417,
0.15129487216472626,
-0.02623979188501835,
0.7295893430709839,
-0.3481772840023041,
0.019038917496800423,
0.7303386926651001,
-0.37091270089149475,
-0.3959721326828003,
0.77472323179245,
-0.17748291790485382,
0.34081515669822693,
-0.17691166698932648,
0.29446083307266235,
-0.35286927223205566,
-0.5585684776306152,
-0.6758270859718323,
0.4004397392272949,
-0.7087748050689697,
-0.3231028914451599,
-0.47270920872688293,
0.029199903830885887,
-0.7390525937080383,
-0.022068407386541367,
-0.1470588892698288,
-0.5779118537902832,
-0.37081465125083923,
-0.3279082477092743,
0.421231746673584,
0.46967893838882446,
-0.05854864418506622,
0.09115013480186462,
-0.6138596534729004,
0.23073384165763855,
0.6634767651557922,
-0.02745084837079048,
-0.029921477660536766,
-0.4623219668865204,
0.05372750759124756,
0.1472194343805313,
-0.521979808807373,
-1.0650917291641235,
0.09790877997875214,
-0.003350215731188655,
0.4706082046031952,
0.27003923058509827,
0.5110220313072205,
0.514438271522522,
-0.12833449244499207,
0.8191919326782227,
-0.010739986784756184,
-0.6584324836730957,
0.9231192469596863,
-0.1040533110499382,
0.10243599116802216,
0.6545483469963074,
0.40997982025146484,
-0.3622213900089264,
-0.3911459743976593,
-0.5335419178009033,
-0.8135119676589966,
0.679018497467041,
-0.028287937864661217,
0.31058385968208313,
-0.232660174369812,
0.7986918091773987,
0.3006366193294525,
0.3377644717693329,
-0.6566136479377747,
-0.31021490693092346,
-0.13765019178390503,
-0.13887090981006622,
-0.06145564839243889,
-0.17852775752544403,
-0.10155440121889114,
-0.3706974387168884,
0.9384182691574097,
-0.35759350657463074,
0.04618172347545624,
0.3678477108478546,
0.0937037318944931,
-0.4830501675605774,
0.4281693696975708,
0.6283965110778809,
0.7436012029647827,
-0.3298701345920563,
0.058377448469400406,
0.01948510855436325,
-0.46725788712501526,
0.444141685962677,
0.03754835203289986,
-0.5776928067207336,
-0.13138779997825623,
-0.2521822154521942,
0.7547795176506042,
-0.44643643498420715,
-0.9283875226974487,
0.3120631277561188,
-0.09881889820098877,
-0.240138441324234,
-0.3866106867790222,
0.44721755385398865,
-0.21816574037075043,
0.2896305322647095,
0.4235561788082123,
-0.2660444974899292,
0.06752068549394608,
-0.5550973415374756,
-0.035364579409360886,
0.4977850019931793,
-0.27113765478134155,
-0.13227634131908417,
0.45653364062309265,
0.2994604706764221,
-0.2345615029335022,
0.47508126497268677,
-0.09633474051952362,
-0.7477110624313354,
0.7516494989395142,
0.7871929407119751,
0.44715800881385803,
-0.28030532598495483,
0.8662066459655762,
0.5627561807632446,
0.26092103123664856,
-0.011605499312281609,
0.6264205574989319,
-0.2982305586338043,
-0.7559971213340759,
-0.3556537926197052,
-0.23231106996536255,
-0.8955255746841431,
0.3358672559261322,
-0.603144645690918,
0.2141091674566269,
-0.6018244624137878,
-0.13489389419555664,
-0.2888792157173157,
0.265368789434433,
-0.24064192175865173,
0.27453282475471497,
-0.13408227264881134,
0.34794968366622925,
-0.8357810974121094,
0.48299017548561096,
1.1129064559936523,
-0.42440086603164673,
-0.894069254398346,
-0.06904136389493942,
-0.2714836299419403,
-0.8577098846435547,
0.5755242109298706,
0.011524626053869724,
-0.17855845391750336,
0.12324795126914978,
-0.9542137384414673,
-0.6553765535354614,
0.967742919921875,
0.5231274962425232,
-0.30714908242225647,
0.1597250998020172,
0.3356996178627014,
0.34150415658950806,
-0.2780204117298126,
0.281762957572937,
0.30791759490966797,
0.3245455324649811,
0.24683256447315216,
-0.3393675982952118,
0.15915483236312866,
-0.27080902457237244,
-0.13825100660324097,
0.22576317191123962,
-0.8322265148162842,
0.6738839149475098,
-0.5733473300933838,
0.15910452604293823,
-0.11304124444723129,
0.576987087726593,
0.5102241635322571,
0.4775340259075165,
0.6063373684883118,
0.3790035843849182,
0.8843587040901184,
0.07557079195976257,
0.6415224671363831,
-0.2906937003135681,
0.2347179502248764,
1.1007282733917236,
-0.33764034509658813,
0.5376218557357788,
0.6602368950843811,
-0.18555596470832825,
0.48061561584472656,
0.8267804980278015,
0.06031511723995209,
0.34752342104911804,
0.4729144275188446,
-0.4296778440475464,
-0.5815641283988953,
-0.32941392064094543,
-0.6419010162353516,
0.45725539326667786,
0.19131246209144592,
-0.07685619592666626,
-0.0718817412853241,
-0.1343165785074234,
0.018296552821993828,
0.17667733132839203,
-0.16344165802001953,
0.6761224269866943,
-0.13642558455467224,
-0.992434024810791,
0.7026546001434326,
-0.17883053421974182,
0.21544018387794495,
-0.24265068769454956,
-0.1877027302980423,
-0.7052985429763794,
-0.06512446701526642,
-0.24422764778137207,
-0.5453188419342041,
-0.14963383972644806,
0.07175027579069138,
0.02678048610687256,
0.22913898527622223,
0.7747999429702759,
-0.5555281639099121,
-0.5010208487510681,
-0.08307822793722153,
0.5890936851501465,
0.22846627235412598,
0.21464024484157562,
-0.7051448822021484,
-0.11107832193374634,
0.24781933426856995,
-0.020242776721715927,
0.07101109623908997,
0.17375974357128143,
0.14554156363010406,
0.6746768951416016,
0.7108767032623291,
0.11782129108905792,
-0.1008961871266365,
-0.0033467202447354794,
1.0719695091247559,
-0.41519638895988464,
-0.36173778772354126,
-0.4811707139015198,
0.45031407475471497,
-0.11610912531614304,
-0.1594311147928238,
0.7110556364059448,
0.5404614806175232,
0.6563764214515686,
0.031340859830379486,
0.9250689744949341,
0.26146048307418823,
0.49339404702186584,
-0.4713078439235687,
0.08900512009859085,
-0.5599601864814758,
0.559300422668457,
-0.35660320520401,
-1.116407871246338,
0.1210305467247963,
0.7190055847167969,
-0.5874068140983582,
-0.02005188539624214,
0.415066123008728,
0.9819632172584534,
0.3042941987514496,
0.2254284769296646,
0.08696136623620987,
-0.1302167922258377,
0.33192873001098633,
0.6213293671607971,
1.1386154890060425,
-0.3068769574165344,
0.5447518825531006,
-0.469033807516098,
-0.31230801343917847,
-0.25030890107154846,
-0.4956582486629486,
-1.0015954971313477,
-0.32134637236595154,
-0.5049030780792236,
-0.5401610732078552,
0.23472030460834503,
1.218190312385559,
0.281575471162796,
-0.5638145208358765,
-0.21486829221248627,
-0.12082772701978683,
0.2990148067474365,
0.16363246738910675,
-0.24381932616233826,
0.2447541058063507,
-0.42231738567352295,
-0.6022042036056519,
0.44881755113601685,
-0.023574911057949066,
0.19944186508655548,
-0.4294452667236328,
-0.21975240111351013,
0.0972243919968605,
0.20583197474479675,
0.3634149432182312,
0.13857097923755646,
-0.4495464265346527,
-0.4247535467147827,
0.28648751974105835,
0.1324048936367035,
0.08040106296539307,
0.8132346272468567,
-0.867093563079834,
0.4207931160926819,
0.5212732553482056,
0.6560173034667969,
0.43865692615509033,
0.4257204234600067,
0.514209508895874,
-0.6247127056121826,
0.057245127856731415,
0.5062249898910522,
-0.0050957961939275265,
0.39898011088371277,
-0.61658775806427,
0.5129362940788269,
0.10798250138759613,
-0.6537858247756958,
-0.7812855839729309,
0.3422975242137909,
-0.748658299446106,
-0.27417904138565063,
1.2324035167694092,
-0.08371332287788391,
-0.12769059836864471,
-0.15182693302631378,
-0.6346784234046936,
0.06309787929058075,
-0.6372777223587036,
1.1210919618606567,
0.5155856609344482,
-0.31127244234085083,
-0.28065603971481323,
-0.34259146451950073,
0.457840234041214,
0.8285536766052246,
-0.8994842171669006,
0.05398973822593689,
0.8157473206520081,
0.15509556233882904,
-0.032692309468984604,
0.6905046105384827,
0.0003301824035588652,
0.5265030264854431,
-0.28290367126464844,
-0.14454485476016998,
-0.2755099833011627,
-0.3180793523788452,
-0.07204730063676834,
0.07912444323301315,
0.3359343707561493,
-0.12049522995948792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00198v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00198v1
|
AXOLOTL: Fairness through Assisted Self-Debiasing of Large Language Model Outputs
| 2024-03-01T00:02:37 | 2024-03-01T00:02:37 |
Sana Ebrahimi, Kaiwen Chen, Abolfazl Asudeh, Gautam Das, Nick Koudas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly advanced natural
language processing capabilities but are susceptible to biases present in their
training data, leading to unfair outcomes in various applications. While
numerous strategies have been proposed to mitigate bias, they often require
extensive computational resources and may compromise model performance. In this
work, we introduce AXOLOTL, a novel post-processing framework, which operates
agnostically across tasks and models, leveraging public APIs to interact with
LLMs without direct access to internal parameters. Through a three-step process
resembling zero-shot learning, AXOLOTL identifies biases, proposes resolutions,
and guides the model to self-debias its outputs. This approach minimizes
computational costs and preserves model performance, making AXOLOTL a promising
tool for debiasing LLM outputs with broad applicability and ease of use.
|
[
-0.25354182720184326,
-0.5798176527023315,
0.8344839215278625,
0.20209816098213196,
-0.264585942029953,
-0.003711300203576684,
-0.06547816842794418,
-0.404361754655838,
0.01264933217316866,
0.6553582549095154,
-0.5025956034660339,
-0.6241554021835327,
-0.7468828558921814,
-0.004543886985629797,
-0.27333152294158936,
1.0856348276138306,
0.12022467702627182,
0.21600951254367828,
-0.33690980076789856,
-0.3320472538471222,
-0.14235448837280273,
-0.7011342644691467,
-0.6876159906387329,
-0.4684393107891083,
0.5531179308891296,
0.17575523257255554,
0.776073157787323,
0.6821675300598145,
0.21502123773097992,
0.22012758255004883,
0.16871275007724762,
-0.2267710119485855,
-0.39764612913131714,
0.29161280393600464,
-0.41190746426582336,
-0.38400912284851074,
-0.7097293138504028,
0.1780678629875183,
0.5077934861183167,
0.5222841501235962,
-0.11971171945333481,
0.37293529510498047,
0.18057872354984283,
0.3217791020870209,
-0.8002617955207825,
0.25988855957984924,
-0.7552862167358398,
0.11925546824932098,
-0.31883057951927185,
-0.0447477251291275,
-0.37180304527282715,
-0.6530714631080627,
-0.18770764768123627,
-0.45856571197509766,
0.09178753197193146,
-0.11265713721513748,
0.3587987422943115,
0.4048723578453064,
-0.36499735713005066,
-0.18482369184494019,
-0.555682897567749,
1.0441592931747437,
-1.1047805547714233,
0.16236081719398499,
0.6241441965103149,
0.35799843072891235,
0.1303219348192215,
-0.636141836643219,
-0.6867963671684265,
0.1734103113412857,
-0.08805912733078003,
-0.3654552400112152,
-0.4160831868648529,
0.3342649042606354,
0.19327479600906372,
0.21184439957141876,
-0.5757744908332825,
0.2135968953371048,
-0.002897163387387991,
-0.3850412964820862,
0.45055946707725525,
0.02520301751792431,
0.15934008359909058,
-0.0034525070805102587,
0.04660840705037117,
0.12026675790548325,
-0.7631955742835999,
-0.17741748690605164,
0.6878352761268616,
0.38719215989112854,
0.1692175567150116,
0.40667885541915894,
-0.48854124546051025,
0.6117330193519592,
-0.08160960674285889,
0.07012967765331268,
0.44828730821609497,
0.17100438475608826,
-0.4253712594509125,
0.09491591900587082,
0.9373666644096375,
0.18940530717372894,
0.12654642760753632,
-0.3227529525756836,
-0.4277893602848053,
0.3216648995876312,
0.06035895645618439,
-0.9561115503311157,
0.0014955061487853527,
0.39359763264656067,
-0.3148829936981201,
-0.3900938034057617,
-0.7536723613739014,
-0.7511208057403564,
-0.5831379294395447,
-0.30753085017204285,
0.5321856141090393,
-0.09197703748941422,
-0.22765867412090302,
-0.08258407562971115,
0.297943651676178,
-0.03307308629155159,
0.3967333137989044,
-0.910885751247406,
0.4589497745037079,
0.5432893633842468,
0.8221578001976013,
0.2360452264547348,
-0.2722827196121216,
-0.9061611890792847,
0.08740470558404922,
-0.21068288385868073,
0.7374038696289062,
-0.6810687184333801,
-0.16336220502853394,
-0.10536623746156693,
-0.3399572968482971,
0.26039981842041016,
-0.4636165201663971,
0.6242353320121765,
-0.6490983963012695,
-0.02928825467824936,
-0.20885081589221954,
-0.29443028569221497,
-0.06212259456515312,
0.2912948727607727,
-0.5391924381256104,
0.7384033203125,
-0.0809762179851532,
-0.9348755478858948,
0.3660944402217865,
-0.4706180691719055,
-0.46263211965560913,
-0.16565944254398346,
-0.44149962067604065,
-0.3776916563510895,
0.067571721971035,
0.5097798109054565,
0.1985834836959839,
-0.37177637219429016,
0.36310574412345886,
-0.7580564618110657,
-0.24840576946735382,
-0.10172581672668457,
-0.5155119895935059,
0.8454408049583435,
0.41258156299591064,
-0.6588096022605896,
0.2829533517360687,
-0.681134045124054,
0.16091929376125336,
-0.03432554379105568,
-0.06584692746400833,
-0.4701385796070099,
-0.06163380667567253,
-0.18857704102993011,
0.4415842890739441,
0.15224243700504303,
-0.6785224676132202,
0.1592523455619812,
-0.4206315577030182,
0.40991222858428955,
1.1454089879989624,
-0.5778640508651733,
0.6651939153671265,
-0.07992934435606003,
0.5224171876907349,
-0.16685035824775696,
0.3621867597103119,
-0.07272838056087494,
-0.3016171455383301,
-0.7235724925994873,
-0.39733341336250305,
0.372561514377594,
0.11682119220495224,
-0.5445688962936401,
-0.018850058317184448,
-0.03981264680624008,
-0.3760438561439514,
-0.9332770705223083,
0.33879372477531433,
0.45915958285331726,
0.47227662801742554,
0.12686653435230255,
-0.26890406012535095,
-0.5298620462417603,
-0.9422547817230225,
-0.25183624029159546,
-0.014988800510764122,
-0.05371304228901863,
0.3212275803089142,
0.12343765795230865,
-0.2230449914932251,
1.1176633834838867,
-0.39510488510131836,
-0.4587027430534363,
-0.13324448466300964,
0.3965541124343872,
0.41791412234306335,
0.3187163770198822,
0.704449474811554,
-0.3331124484539032,
-0.24307501316070557,
-0.08069709688425064,
-0.8839124441146851,
-0.5805347561836243,
0.2817130386829376,
-0.23923425376415253,
0.3460520803928375,
0.30927157402038574,
-0.6609015464782715,
0.5135217905044556,
0.7429273128509521,
-0.33720263838768005,
0.4433498978614807,
-0.23990827798843384,
0.07151561230421066,
-0.5035997629165649,
0.13548047840595245,
-0.3791548013687134,
-0.45802974700927734,
-0.3445191979408264,
-0.07237043976783752,
-0.010578089393675327,
-0.08493281155824661,
-0.3687743842601776,
0.8988346457481384,
-0.43904951214790344,
-0.42944565415382385,
-0.5032476186752319,
0.08290275186300278,
0.164714515209198,
0.42720094323158264,
0.06438851356506348,
0.6299499869346619,
0.7444766163825989,
-0.45071619749069214,
0.23094627261161804,
-0.03137296810746193,
0.03686525300145149,
0.40126538276672363,
-0.6708646416664124,
0.4050643742084503,
-0.2880091965198517,
0.14233139157295227,
-0.8290407061576843,
0.1295737773180008,
0.38857677578926086,
-0.449584424495697,
-0.18752068281173706,
-0.4517923593521118,
-0.4752298593521118,
-0.2373449206352234,
-0.3111326992511749,
0.833283007144928,
0.46084290742874146,
-0.47923704981803894,
0.6627403497695923,
0.496488481760025,
-0.3587598502635956,
-0.9625274538993835,
-0.6637673377990723,
0.0002626607601996511,
0.00922254379838705,
-0.3299080431461334,
0.11267648637294769,
-0.19471105933189392,
-0.39945438504219055,
0.02746756747364998,
-0.06547185033559799,
-0.26539066433906555,
-0.03240412101149559,
0.3079086244106293,
-0.03287043794989586,
0.07809586077928543,
0.016456952318549156,
0.26678723096847534,
0.023835252970457077,
0.0352729856967926,
-0.5835008025169373,
0.7215971946716309,
0.09268375486135483,
-0.6465941071510315,
-0.23638896644115448,
0.19273091852664948,
0.6636906266212463,
-0.41048985719680786,
0.5087841749191284,
0.38252073526382446,
-0.3644907474517822,
-0.4111275374889374,
-0.5356056690216064,
-0.17546440660953522,
-0.4346057176589966,
0.07218046486377716,
0.02314060926437378,
-0.697239100933075,
0.5877965092658997,
0.40626785159111023,
0.22200244665145874,
0.03517061844468117,
0.57234787940979,
0.4134461283683777,
1.2018595933914185,
0.5092236399650574,
-0.22210648655891418,
0.24030733108520508,
0.014869382604956627,
0.4082476496696472,
-0.5692518353462219,
-0.04137144237756729,
-0.47611263394355774,
-0.2636200189590454,
-0.12292034924030304,
-0.594161331653595,
-0.009118198417127132,
-0.06571755558252335,
-0.2774204909801483,
-0.046199556440114975,
-0.3207087218761444,
0.532072901725769,
0.9812737703323364,
-0.1398782581090927,
0.5291664004325867,
-0.09852051734924316,
-0.2660602927207947,
-0.011542877182364464,
-0.3905397653579712,
-0.5176486968994141,
1.4123258590698242,
0.3244926929473877,
1.0951712131500244,
0.13558976352214813,
0.6809492111206055,
0.5387952923774719,
0.43490809202194214,
-0.6372936964035034,
0.5098035335540771,
0.09163717180490494,
-0.7423219084739685,
-0.313853919506073,
-0.5741690993309021,
-0.715701699256897,
0.40245068073272705,
-0.13394536077976227,
-0.5996949672698975,
0.1584436297416687,
0.40854573249816895,
-0.5214049816131592,
0.34690582752227783,
-0.46758753061294556,
0.8699283599853516,
-0.3830964267253876,
-0.8287750482559204,
-0.2982213497161865,
-0.2546962797641754,
0.1993044763803482,
-0.103989377617836,
0.5464445352554321,
-0.4620721936225891,
0.26392126083374023,
0.4658763110637665,
-0.39854758977890015,
1.0021730661392212,
-0.4169338345527649,
-0.1576937437057495,
0.21221548318862915,
0.5663996934890747,
0.4350917339324951,
0.43136143684387207,
-0.3992401957511902,
0.5209893584251404,
-0.2605331540107727,
-0.39720484614372253,
-0.5220668315887451,
0.890783965587616,
-0.724005401134491,
-0.7005155086517334,
-0.7427533864974976,
-0.7051711082458496,
-0.1297159194946289,
0.6509847640991211,
-0.1278294324874878,
0.5264480710029602,
-0.029124151915311813,
-0.20349673926830292,
0.3625945746898651,
-0.36486586928367615,
0.5549649596214294,
0.7269302010536194,
-0.6216081976890564,
-0.35077428817749023,
0.5250998139381409,
0.02036624774336815,
0.06503959000110626,
0.07456034421920776,
0.026618175208568573,
-0.6661093235015869,
-0.9633687734603882,
-0.427817165851593,
0.06582289189100266,
-0.7005482912063599,
-0.446761816740036,
-0.7754444479942322,
-0.1258373111486435,
-0.8564805388450623,
0.09248031675815582,
-0.4532701075077057,
-0.35966557264328003,
-0.07425892353057861,
-0.2125301957130432,
0.13958273828029633,
0.6369506120681763,
-0.28241434693336487,
0.3526645600795746,
-0.5386964678764343,
0.18512874841690063,
0.6591437458992004,
0.6639564037322998,
-0.006988967768847942,
-0.45855551958084106,
-0.010192482732236385,
0.16180048882961273,
-0.32986220717430115,
-0.39306703209877014,
0.623263418674469,
0.14321981370449066,
0.641452968120575,
0.4415947496891022,
0.35264018177986145,
0.40965890884399414,
-0.6094732880592346,
0.4012896716594696,
0.08381634205579758,
-1.2154059410095215,
0.51763516664505,
-0.5056014060974121,
0.23525011539459229,
0.3763316571712494,
0.06563648581504822,
-0.32741400599479675,
-0.6176814436912537,
-0.32444754242897034,
-0.8957352042198181,
1.0772254467010498,
0.3185786008834839,
0.2841428518295288,
-0.11186376214027405,
0.1976132094860077,
0.16020290553569794,
0.6104544997215271,
-1.156590223312378,
-0.06980453431606293,
-0.38344380259513855,
-0.18846148252487183,
-0.048004209995269775,
-0.24591544270515442,
-0.20256160199642181,
-0.10277768969535828,
0.48268020153045654,
-0.23026855289936066,
-0.13217154145240784,
0.18350140750408173,
-0.5251709222793579,
-0.02720755897462368,
0.3613120913505554,
0.15913952887058258,
0.8466516137123108,
-0.3269372880458832,
0.4943227767944336,
0.023859098553657532,
-0.17488664388656616,
0.17413651943206787,
0.26535025238990784,
-0.36652326583862305,
-0.09111032634973526,
0.2620600461959839,
0.7375300526618958,
0.1051650196313858,
-0.8461561799049377,
0.6914891600608826,
-0.30275046825408936,
0.0003495790879242122,
-0.10271167755126953,
-0.15708598494529724,
-0.18455085158348083,
0.4087199866771698,
0.3107757866382599,
0.11999169737100601,
0.4267517626285553,
-0.44031718373298645,
0.3379025161266327,
0.5812139511108398,
-0.39207422733306885,
-0.41212475299835205,
1.0088672637939453,
0.33275851607322693,
0.013466453179717064,
0.40094488859176636,
-0.3856809437274933,
-0.20858703553676605,
0.3024146258831024,
0.5410120487213135,
0.8883081078529358,
-0.4373166561126709,
0.4168814420700073,
0.16721859574317932,
0.15488611161708832,
0.005152587313205004,
-0.1283939778804779,
-0.08998576551675797,
-0.7288712859153748,
-0.5499793291091919,
-1.019598364830017,
-0.19457387924194336,
0.07746002078056335,
-0.4351629316806793,
0.1899081915616989,
-0.8452311754226685,
-0.3440624475479126,
-0.14960531890392303,
-0.35809561610221863,
-0.5835724472999573,
0.15446342527866364,
0.4266456067562103,
0.6412731409072876,
-0.7317601442337036,
1.034175992012024,
0.5162742733955383,
-0.39583441615104675,
-0.4950101673603058,
-0.15811556577682495,
0.1573653221130371,
-0.8741689324378967,
0.8130355477333069,
0.18232716619968414,
-0.41615384817123413,
0.032062072306871414,
-0.05685846135020256,
-0.6894752979278564,
0.7991160154342651,
1.1411656141281128,
-0.531458854675293,
-0.16043677926063538,
0.3027171492576599,
0.4763249158859253,
-0.24410197138786316,
0.7830420136451721,
0.4580613374710083,
0.17747458815574646,
0.04855763912200928,
-0.9212226271629333,
0.07208806276321411,
-0.14049430191516876,
-0.14089718461036682,
-0.05668652430176735,
-0.44408974051475525,
1.1315209865570068,
-0.09613021463155746,
-0.09809955954551697,
-0.3293640911579132,
0.3064188063144684,
0.09701581299304962,
0.3331734538078308,
0.47073104977607727,
0.7315959930419922,
0.7744930386543274,
0.16150063276290894,
0.8967500925064087,
-0.23652859032154083,
0.46370378136634827,
1.3048537969589233,
-0.6769997477531433,
0.5820283889770508,
0.3237144649028778,
-0.08728653937578201,
0.25773122906684875,
0.4600110352039337,
0.48536190390586853,
0.7148154377937317,
0.20092348754405975,
-0.5003121495246887,
-0.2974693179130554,
-0.21851301193237305,
-0.31354930996894836,
0.3970223665237427,
-0.09863349795341492,
-0.42273974418640137,
-0.5492309331893921,
-0.05581565573811531,
0.21568180620670319,
0.25667235255241394,
-0.5471562147140503,
0.6656277179718018,
0.06606757640838623,
-0.5406126976013184,
0.5297624468803406,
-0.23558227717876434,
0.8062469363212585,
-0.5707716941833496,
-0.09349731355905533,
-0.48544350266456604,
0.40219274163246155,
-0.17166022956371307,
-0.6751837730407715,
0.5018137097358704,
0.1295563280582428,
-0.24472111463546753,
-0.35738325119018555,
0.5615015029907227,
-0.30441927909851074,
-0.5349156260490417,
0.8484461903572083,
0.43620604276657104,
-0.18912510573863983,
-0.3829478919506073,
-0.6637487411499023,
0.24044103920459747,
-0.05574849247932434,
-0.1015813872218132,
0.34740278124809265,
0.34748780727386475,
0.08583953976631165,
0.7874637842178345,
0.48270758986473083,
0.2954291105270386,
0.008619776926934719,
0.30342450737953186,
0.959178626537323,
-0.4453374445438385,
-0.4409942328929901,
-1.138663411140442,
0.08270964026451111,
-0.13832618296146393,
0.028684085234999657,
0.890421986579895,
0.5151950120925903,
0.8969377875328064,
0.1269885152578354,
1.1510446071624756,
-0.00031594777829013765,
0.5811837315559387,
-0.4001932144165039,
0.9514467716217041,
-0.38110336661338806,
0.5627979040145874,
-0.4945976436138153,
-0.9746207594871521,
-0.49659863114356995,
0.6135548949241638,
-0.7821953296661377,
-0.08752783387899399,
0.2757791578769684,
0.8007696866989136,
-0.22948765754699707,
-0.30980348587036133,
0.43759796023368835,
0.29582592844963074,
0.45683756470680237,
0.41837751865386963,
0.6581341624259949,
-0.08932845294475555,
0.7947695255279541,
-0.10358425229787827,
-0.3577297627925873,
-0.09689534455537796,
-0.9132047891616821,
-0.9972296357154846,
-0.0781109631061554,
0.0714229866862297,
-0.1995958536863327,
0.39525139331817627,
0.870800793170929,
0.9779807925224304,
-0.8326649069786072,
-0.22521179914474487,
-0.09498676657676697,
0.3463292419910431,
0.10726922005414963,
-0.1446841061115265,
0.1800280660390854,
-0.5296112895011902,
-0.9946375489234924,
0.02496805600821972,
0.34377291798591614,
-0.2704460322856903,
-0.1759931594133377,
-0.19089125096797943,
0.11567384004592896,
0.11723757535219193,
0.5304475426673889,
0.2579570710659027,
-0.4830460250377655,
-0.24702680110931396,
-0.35389772057533264,
-0.03456456959247589,
0.16502271592617035,
0.7955324053764343,
-1.0309901237487793,
0.6436547636985779,
0.2858855724334717,
0.5613505840301514,
0.354554682970047,
-0.15957660973072052,
0.8461141586303711,
-0.6780630946159363,
0.6306583285331726,
0.4851647615432739,
0.3977244198322296,
0.42182254791259766,
-0.2983974516391754,
0.26148712635040283,
0.07433514297008514,
-0.6542598605155945,
-0.9652146100997925,
0.3489985466003418,
-0.4469045400619507,
-0.3326590359210968,
1.0390452146530151,
-0.2555222511291504,
-0.21453918516635895,
-0.17374305427074432,
-0.3518768846988678,
0.2528235912322998,
-0.5753585696220398,
0.8924561142921448,
0.428456574678421,
-0.03384486958384514,
-0.2250928431749344,
-0.5488553643226624,
0.561190128326416,
0.3918064534664154,
-0.7533861398696899,
0.4177057445049286,
0.7367333769798279,
0.4846514165401459,
-0.2438473254442215,
1.1724369525909424,
-0.28650349378585815,
-0.024808524176478386,
-0.15030378103256226,
0.42397353053092957,
-0.07312066107988358,
-0.17514868080615997,
-0.4352411925792694,
0.006948158144950867,
0.5867501497268677,
-0.005390658974647522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00180v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00180v2
|
"Flex Tape Can't Fix That": Bias and Misinformation in Edited Language Models
| 2024-02-29T23:11:55 | 2024-06-16T18:08:11 |
Karina Halevy, Anna Sotnikova, Badr AlKhamissi, Syrielle Montariol, Antoine Bosselut
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Model editing has emerged as a cost-effective strategy to update knowledge
stored in language models. However, model editing can have unintended
consequences after edits are applied: information unrelated to the edits can
also be changed, and other general behaviors of the model can be wrongly
altered. In this work, we investigate how model editing methods unexpectedly
amplify model biases post-edit. We introduce a novel benchmark dataset,
Seesaw-CF, for measuring bias-related harms of model editing and conduct the
first in-depth investigation of how different weight-editing methods impact
model bias. Specifically, we focus on biases with respect to demographic
attributes such as race, geographic origin, and gender, as well as qualitative
flaws in long-form texts generated by edited language models. We find that
edited models exhibit, to various degrees, more biased behavior as they become
less confident in attributes for Asian, African, and South American subjects.
Furthermore, edited models amplify sexism and xenophobia in text generations
while remaining seemingly coherent and logical. Finally, editing facts about
place of birth, country of citizenship, or gender have particularly negative
effects on the model's knowledge about unrelated features like field of work.
|
[
-0.24747584760189056,
-0.7137861251831055,
0.4558996856212616,
-0.03761335089802742,
0.12516632676124573,
0.2623295187950134,
-0.22437645494937897,
-0.6020246148109436,
0.0498613566160202,
0.49696165323257446,
-0.7368305325508118,
-0.13783514499664307,
-0.6392588019371033,
-0.0932014212012291,
-0.4060785174369812,
1.0410161018371582,
0.02883736416697502,
0.1937146782875061,
-0.05865335837006569,
-0.4340529441833496,
-0.5174891352653503,
-0.538894534111023,
-0.016007419675588608,
-0.11013200879096985,
0.36353230476379395,
0.47670912742614746,
1.332209825515747,
0.8400564193725586,
0.265125036239624,
0.23296497762203217,
-0.6411716341972351,
0.08653642982244492,
-0.6225555539131165,
-0.2854602336883545,
-0.4282838702201843,
-0.6895080804824829,
-0.7172713279724121,
0.38009366393089294,
0.4633793532848358,
0.7927094101905823,
0.13754895329475403,
0.31697073578834534,
-0.020652128383517265,
0.5510326623916626,
-0.625270426273346,
-0.30683234333992004,
-0.8209680318832397,
-0.24532684683799744,
-0.5069515109062195,
0.1987791657447815,
-0.21322964131832123,
-0.26813533902168274,
0.053905583918094635,
-0.3272659182548523,
0.49271783232688904,
-0.02564394660294056,
0.9155176281929016,
0.3083595037460327,
-0.45865413546562195,
-0.12162508815526962,
-0.7427444458007812,
0.516811728477478,
-0.9594772458076477,
0.46586811542510986,
0.43410107493400574,
0.04144375026226044,
-0.2185753732919693,
-0.37272462248802185,
-0.5627216696739197,
0.2596164643764496,
-0.049443233758211136,
-0.3096766471862793,
-0.0068190149031579494,
0.1166413277387619,
0.7470903992652893,
0.17449085414409637,
-0.29483845829963684,
0.19188706576824188,
-0.632001519203186,
0.07150629162788391,
0.8319286704063416,
0.12019335478544235,
0.5352789163589478,
-0.2247202843427658,
0.006678395438939333,
-0.3004792332649231,
-0.9153871536254883,
0.06020263582468033,
0.8425660133361816,
0.24303540587425232,
0.11989200860261917,
0.8604167699813843,
-0.04977554827928543,
0.5847264528274536,
0.17723798751831055,
-0.048182934522628784,
0.10746811330318451,
0.06499773263931274,
-0.341199666261673,
0.04061416536569595,
0.4294915795326233,
0.5808612704277039,
0.05591318756341934,
0.0802052766084671,
-0.10153591632843018,
0.009260662831366062,
0.08729785680770874,
-0.39872583746910095,
-0.008338087238371372,
0.16373798251152039,
-0.42952650785446167,
-0.4528706967830658,
-0.03586791455745697,
-0.6412700414657593,
-0.6830898523330688,
-0.21875420212745667,
0.2009858787059784,
-0.27306848764419556,
-0.2600824534893036,
0.3388349413871765,
-0.3088705241680145,
-0.059506434947252274,
0.25375476479530334,
-0.6518847346305847,
0.08862060308456421,
0.6565581560134888,
0.45241081714630127,
0.23585839569568634,
-0.3175303041934967,
-0.07347419857978821,
-0.10803357511758804,
-0.3061523735523224,
0.727419912815094,
-0.7063685059547424,
-0.4341420531272888,
-0.2019018828868866,
0.011512319557368755,
-0.01809697598218918,
-0.5117024183273315,
0.5400844812393188,
-0.2753644585609436,
0.4704344570636749,
-0.5106157064437866,
-0.38453271985054016,
0.07159305363893509,
-0.14786139130592346,
-0.5717167258262634,
1.038417935371399,
0.1260090172290802,
-0.9872885942459106,
0.4313833713531494,
-0.2429790496826172,
-0.26286399364471436,
-0.49779412150382996,
0.15397168695926666,
-0.5953779816627502,
0.3203173279762268,
0.19292621314525604,
0.011780809611082077,
-0.14890339970588684,
0.6953842639923096,
-0.6159698963165283,
-0.18769721686840057,
0.6979407668113708,
-0.435696005821228,
1.056814432144165,
-0.16484291851520538,
-0.2616298794746399,
0.14158540964126587,
-0.9947189092636108,
-0.31486180424690247,
-0.0109183918684721,
-0.32500889897346497,
-0.5886693596839905,
-0.06339660286903381,
0.10708833485841751,
0.4651666581630707,
-0.1693723350763321,
-0.7435959577560425,
0.2589818835258484,
-0.06902829557657242,
0.2830687463283539,
0.8045215606689453,
-0.18845950067043304,
0.4000586271286011,
-0.4749363958835602,
0.4459756314754486,
-0.16914254426956177,
0.12209524214267731,
-0.03967908024787903,
-0.3972192704677582,
-0.7340470552444458,
0.24281981587409973,
0.521353006362915,
0.41154003143310547,
-0.5787948369979858,
-0.18388500809669495,
-0.18862447142601013,
-0.7981259226799011,
-0.7834407091140747,
0.10883446782827377,
0.4678012430667877,
0.6641939878463745,
0.19232389330863953,
-0.09654776006937027,
-0.5874452590942383,
-0.8658550977706909,
-1.1237692832946777,
-0.3240894675254822,
-0.07688792794942856,
0.12769514322280884,
0.44440382719039917,
-0.21941561996936798,
0.8654650449752808,
-0.7285218238830566,
-0.11153609305620193,
0.04224593564867973,
0.26957377791404724,
-0.11589731276035309,
0.5884490609169006,
0.6359548568725586,
-0.25553563237190247,
-0.07330289483070374,
-0.2878384292125702,
-0.2612561583518982,
-0.5101161003112793,
-0.2751040756702423,
-0.04976111650466919,
0.17295368015766144,
0.4660271406173706,
-0.6314582824707031,
0.6629214882850647,
0.4402790069580078,
-0.6493721008300781,
0.8806726336479187,
-0.25883689522743225,
0.13137808442115784,
-0.4698643982410431,
-0.13985015451908112,
0.04237930849194527,
-0.08390229195356369,
-0.5947255492210388,
-0.06253348290920258,
0.34608519077301025,
-0.10923327505588531,
-0.4613589644432068,
0.3153327703475952,
-0.3097049295902252,
0.03590381145477295,
-0.19952118396759033,
-0.07274365425109863,
0.18179140985012054,
0.40991446375846863,
-0.02416793629527092,
0.520159900188446,
0.04312514886260033,
-0.1724095642566681,
-0.19578056037425995,
0.3106309771537781,
-0.44505712389945984,
0.503670334815979,
-0.4414307177066803,
0.34280306100845337,
-0.5219715237617493,
0.12028966844081879,
-0.9379908442497253,
-0.23640106618404388,
0.0006929429364390671,
-0.32588866353034973,
0.19409030675888062,
-0.009385927580296993,
-0.28623104095458984,
-0.22294345498085022,
-0.3888240158557892,
0.25471726059913635,
0.11168307811021805,
-0.5660242438316345,
0.3959490656852722,
0.5613678693771362,
-0.20899124443531036,
-0.6806528568267822,
-0.9266357421875,
0.12707999348640442,
-0.2461041361093521,
-0.6745994091033936,
0.26727691292762756,
-0.14761021733283997,
-0.5931241512298584,
0.0670168548822403,
-0.30446434020996094,
-0.189214289188385,
0.2127864509820938,
0.04083573445677757,
0.25574055314064026,
-0.11541995406150818,
0.19365255534648895,
0.5020279884338379,
0.15416617691516876,
0.099250927567482,
0.3296003043651581,
0.044829245656728745,
0.1744794249534607,
-0.2311372011899948,
-0.0879770889878273,
0.12823182344436646,
0.546462893486023,
-0.2675519585609436,
0.6838775873184204,
0.08234598487615585,
-0.3525719940662384,
-0.1859920769929886,
-0.6527196168899536,
-0.16395919024944305,
-0.44127899408340454,
0.5962117910385132,
-0.10104406625032425,
-0.7892895340919495,
0.4439486265182495,
0.10180561244487762,
0.14368188381195068,
0.37222665548324585,
0.18993712961673737,
-0.21798112988471985,
1.129641056060791,
0.5928130149841309,
0.24844780564308167,
0.4858591556549072,
0.032298874109983444,
0.05954194813966751,
-0.7671186923980713,
-0.03288176283240318,
-0.7319502234458923,
-0.4830611050128937,
-0.6451680660247803,
-0.4536493718624115,
-0.01719033159315586,
-0.05575352534651756,
-0.21616050601005554,
0.39521902799606323,
-0.08947215229272842,
0.6673515439033508,
0.2769937515258789,
0.15117235481739044,
0.2781035006046295,
-0.5014124512672424,
0.24904142320156097,
-0.35948610305786133,
-0.9227115511894226,
-0.48883721232414246,
1.1624743938446045,
0.530095100402832,
0.7070019245147705,
0.148208349943161,
0.05740805342793465,
0.3867394030094147,
0.47427546977996826,
-0.36527493596076965,
0.30539077520370483,
-0.08586467057466507,
-0.8147580027580261,
-0.22487320005893707,
-0.11392752826213837,
-0.41760867834091187,
0.3709210753440857,
-0.45664623379707336,
-0.7222423553466797,
0.7932959794998169,
0.46204644441604614,
-0.07199500501155853,
0.6303414106369019,
-0.6498066186904907,
0.8827293515205383,
-0.46269670128822327,
-0.47161850333213806,
-0.1304798722267151,
-0.4244285821914673,
0.7853079438209534,
-0.19503088295459747,
0.6956194639205933,
-0.32143762707710266,
0.20031453669071198,
0.6240657567977905,
-0.8400445580482483,
0.8043548464775085,
-0.08875203877687454,
-0.11153583228588104,
-0.15068723261356354,
0.4191936254501343,
0.4846617579460144,
-0.01645272597670555,
-0.2651814818382263,
0.191952183842659,
0.05553773045539856,
-0.26183605194091797,
-0.6076398491859436,
0.3119645416736603,
-0.788360595703125,
-0.8994693160057068,
-0.35531240701675415,
-0.7494232058525085,
-0.3345060348510742,
0.08589055389165878,
0.12035555392503738,
0.4184817969799042,
-0.24532726407051086,
-0.15886735916137695,
0.427362322807312,
-0.48163899779319763,
0.17558279633522034,
0.4221574068069458,
-0.4777621030807495,
-0.09366153925657272,
0.690674901008606,
0.4613938629627228,
0.5570906400680542,
-0.291971355676651,
0.2234024703502655,
0.1985408067703247,
-0.22119630873203278,
-0.34988313913345337,
0.42119544744491577,
-0.6760228276252747,
-0.039747267961502075,
-0.5429469347000122,
0.012625227682292461,
-0.3854951858520508,
-0.25982666015625,
-0.5903945565223694,
-0.7461981773376465,
-0.2200397551059723,
-0.26346322894096375,
0.19742369651794434,
0.7545549273490906,
-0.05064794048666954,
0.6595356464385986,
-0.5324342250823975,
0.2117433398962021,
0.23230373859405518,
0.45615118741989136,
-0.07177475094795227,
-0.6640291810035706,
-0.37923821806907654,
0.23006388545036316,
-0.23134702444076538,
-1.0499039888381958,
0.30444127321243286,
-0.04085031896829605,
0.19363276660442352,
0.2925785779953003,
0.07441507279872894,
0.8248814940452576,
-0.2626614272594452,
0.6293274164199829,
-0.27941879630088806,
-1.3058528900146484,
0.31719839572906494,
-0.3911072313785553,
0.6147100925445557,
0.3859303891658783,
-0.07673308253288269,
-0.8543596267700195,
-0.759192943572998,
-0.7630309462547302,
-0.5626276731491089,
1.030745267868042,
-0.11150766909122467,
0.07070919871330261,
0.10176955908536911,
0.30118268728256226,
0.18640980124473572,
0.19466590881347656,
-0.6065765023231506,
-0.40956911444664,
-0.25809481739997864,
0.231454536318779,
0.26935476064682007,
-0.7010736465454102,
0.01982644945383072,
-0.3965257704257965,
0.9665541052818298,
0.08023525774478912,
-0.2835861146450043,
0.07904542237520218,
-0.44435203075408936,
-0.5550858974456787,
0.4510304033756256,
0.8528690338134766,
0.9212781190872192,
-0.4056420624256134,
-0.002713229041546583,
0.3823505640029907,
-0.2357589453458786,
0.03920797258615494,
-0.013814332894980907,
-0.37289369106292725,
0.187507763504982,
0.4402942657470703,
1.1080992221832275,
0.44033098220825195,
-0.7094569206237793,
0.31465834379196167,
-0.11795329302549362,
-0.17582017183303833,
0.056181468069553375,
0.071729876101017,
0.11943369358778,
0.06453913450241089,
0.045180246233940125,
0.5918492078781128,
-0.06706855446100235,
-0.5570160746574402,
-0.14609448611736298,
0.34116441011428833,
-0.4205882251262665,
-0.41837331652641296,
1.0321441888809204,
0.08127973228693008,
-0.47026780247688293,
0.4682859480381012,
0.28621095418930054,
-0.49156758189201355,
0.45277467370033264,
0.34244540333747864,
0.5556725859642029,
-0.5227954983711243,
0.2916562855243683,
0.2538662254810333,
0.6574673652648926,
-0.0376620776951313,
0.00280218617990613,
0.40632474422454834,
-0.9153469204902649,
-0.3115297555923462,
-0.005076475441455841,
-0.31923016905784607,
0.22938556969165802,
-0.6100109219551086,
0.47788968682289124,
-0.45788106322288513,
-0.3518049418926239,
-0.017320821061730385,
-0.5170179605484009,
-0.6979002952575684,
0.2569167912006378,
0.08099956065416336,
1.005517601966858,
-1.1666717529296875,
0.7183026075363159,
0.5550810694694519,
-0.06129246577620506,
-0.6084485054016113,
-0.12289305031299591,
0.5235689282417297,
-0.4088464081287384,
0.30651023983955383,
-0.017262903973460197,
0.1491893231868744,
-0.4429152309894562,
-0.44832783937454224,
-1.037441611289978,
0.6211914420127869,
0.6836301684379578,
-0.6697151064872742,
-0.07892447710037231,
0.48630791902542114,
0.5397282242774963,
-0.04965139552950859,
0.26677122712135315,
1.0822899341583252,
0.48346182703971863,
-0.2948409914970398,
-1.0574970245361328,
-0.10287748277187347,
-0.004803344141691923,
0.037462279200553894,
0.021702006459236145,
-0.6247044801712036,
1.0208226442337036,
-0.2713082730770111,
-0.1399080902338028,
-0.28277868032455444,
0.4618854224681854,
-0.004562025424093008,
0.03970295563340187,
0.4433393180370331,
0.492402583360672,
0.9878156185150146,
0.0037863748148083687,
0.9945149421691895,
-0.043343160301446915,
0.1565674990415573,
1.4593474864959717,
-0.2854677736759186,
0.42121678590774536,
0.3800753653049469,
-0.11392096430063248,
0.41947922110557556,
0.3319738209247589,
0.1333916038274765,
0.16346858441829681,
0.009832696989178658,
-0.06523341685533524,
0.07973233610391617,
-0.05188342556357384,
-0.15635955333709717,
0.5846816897392273,
0.43811655044555664,
-0.42480960488319397,
-0.04462137073278427,
0.242188960313797,
0.7110924124717712,
0.20734593272209167,
-0.2760010361671448,
0.5166988372802734,
-0.10536554455757141,
-0.5007397532463074,
0.28906580805778503,
0.2636778652667999,
0.5449299812316895,
-0.29400303959846497,
0.12955057621002197,
-0.21217943727970123,
0.2310655415058136,
-0.39761805534362793,
-0.8312211632728577,
0.5785632133483887,
0.15360499918460846,
-0.2727120518684387,
-0.2410132735967636,
0.7679895758628845,
-0.5930033326148987,
-0.6389052271842957,
0.14854739606380463,
0.5899105072021484,
-0.2319774627685547,
-0.0600256472826004,
-0.7241837978363037,
0.3888727128505707,
0.14615720510482788,
-0.37697169184684753,
0.313839316368103,
0.18618036806583405,
-0.28600895404815674,
0.5975179672241211,
0.5413591861724854,
0.3582715690135956,
0.010197218507528305,
-0.1815100908279419,
0.6991119384765625,
-0.5444485545158386,
-0.24187010526657104,
-0.7674780488014221,
0.7921602725982666,
-0.12128972262144089,
-0.47977375984191895,
0.6751284599304199,
0.48172295093536377,
1.114473581314087,
-0.033790700137615204,
0.8764138221740723,
0.060710154473781586,
0.5280523896217346,
-0.31769198179244995,
1.0001376867294312,
-0.33483952283859253,
0.46298912167549133,
-0.5937715768814087,
-0.8153690695762634,
-0.40517759323120117,
0.17221809923648834,
-0.5792966485023499,
-0.087799072265625,
0.6487492918968201,
0.9478228092193604,
-0.03512623533606529,
0.1356533020734787,
0.25470173358917236,
0.6287983655929565,
0.21513690054416656,
-0.10497880727052689,
0.557158350944519,
-0.5152532458305359,
0.250681072473526,
-0.6431064605712891,
0.02061024121940136,
-0.018532780930399895,
-0.7794786095619202,
-0.820536196231842,
-0.4798640310764313,
-0.5423471927642822,
-0.530669629573822,
0.11901165544986725,
0.7794256210327148,
0.34027668833732605,
-0.6114160418510437,
-0.3200436234474182,
0.48074719309806824,
0.5990180373191833,
-0.1520172506570816,
-0.2512584328651428,
0.5174164175987244,
0.1822211593389511,
-0.6469050049781799,
0.17968228459358215,
-0.0037591210566461086,
-0.08390868455171585,
-0.08492418378591537,
0.11820516735315323,
-0.2205270528793335,
0.3035898506641388,
0.310385137796402,
0.41492295265197754,
-0.6323486566543579,
-0.5229573845863342,
-0.3136676251888275,
0.048872724175453186,
0.12261184304952621,
0.8954387903213501,
-0.683788537979126,
0.641410231590271,
0.40983325242996216,
0.338327556848526,
0.2214483618736267,
-0.039120014756917953,
0.9620087742805481,
-0.6569810509681702,
0.2659207582473755,
-0.2014492005109787,
0.5508050918579102,
0.5602394938468933,
-0.49181193113327026,
0.33373984694480896,
0.3317839205265045,
-0.47339051961898804,
-1.1889922618865967,
-0.04122608155012131,
-0.4803371727466583,
-0.5316330194473267,
0.8152644038200378,
0.05485488101840019,
-0.3443157970905304,
-0.0817008912563324,
-0.6145277619361877,
0.36040839552879333,
0.04282674938440323,
0.9355965256690979,
0.8924363255500793,
0.03351396694779396,
-0.41305437684059143,
-0.5170710682868958,
0.753106415271759,
0.4401746988296509,
-0.6462580561637878,
0.5172517895698547,
0.705730676651001,
0.41582801938056946,
-0.33890455961227417,
0.2608306407928467,
-0.03720628470182419,
0.5136072039604187,
-0.05292314663529396,
0.23625448346138,
-0.21481598913669586,
0.029490860179066658,
-0.4891413748264313,
-0.1432347148656845,
0.23112177848815918,
0.424984335899353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00863v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00863v2
|
LLM-Ensemble: Optimal Large Language Model Ensemble Method for E-commerce Product Attribute Value Extraction
| 2024-02-29T23:03:19 | 2024-06-20T07:10:28 |
Chenhao Fang, Xiaohan Li, Zezhong Fan, Jianpeng Xu, Kaushiki Nag, Evren Korpeoglu, Sushant Kumar, Kannan Achan
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Product attribute value extraction is a pivotal component in Natural Language
Processing (NLP) and the contemporary e-commerce industry. The provision of
precise product attribute values is fundamental in ensuring high-quality
recommendations and enhancing customer satisfaction. The recently emerging
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated state-of-the-art performance in
numerous attribute extraction tasks, without the need for domain-specific
training data. Nevertheless, varying strengths and weaknesses are exhibited by
different LLMs due to the diversity in data, architectures, and
hyperparameters. This variation makes them complementary to each other, with no
single LLM dominating all others. Considering the diverse strengths and
weaknesses of LLMs, it becomes necessary to develop an ensemble method that
leverages their complementary potentials. In this paper, we propose a novel
algorithm called LLM-ensemble to ensemble different LLMs' outputs for attribute
value extraction. We iteratively learn the weights for different LLMs to
aggregate the labels with weights to predict the final attribute value. Not
only can our proposed method be proven theoretically optimal, but it also
ensures efficient computation, fast convergence, and safe deployment. We have
also conducted extensive experiments with various state-of-the-art LLMs,
including Llama2-13B, Llama2-70B, PaLM-2, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4, on Walmart's
internal data. Our offline metrics demonstrate that the LLM-ensemble method
outperforms all the state-of-the-art single LLMs on Walmart's internal dataset.
This method has been launched in several production models, leading to improved
Gross Merchandise Volume (GMV), Click-Through Rate (CTR), Conversion Rate
(CVR), and Add-to-Cart Rate (ATC).
|
[
-0.4537349343299866,
-0.5463084578514099,
0.41542848944664,
0.12839071452617645,
-0.26594221591949463,
0.508995532989502,
-0.4033213257789612,
-0.8915805816650391,
0.24500660598278046,
0.24947185814380646,
-0.7274497747421265,
-0.6128091812133789,
-0.43251708149909973,
0.12525822222232819,
-0.1778932362794876,
0.9134811758995056,
0.18046818673610687,
-0.06088678538799286,
-0.3316287696361542,
-0.008563699200749397,
-0.028719615191221237,
-0.3966328501701355,
-0.39799797534942627,
-0.12774163484573364,
0.36983025074005127,
0.3582564890384674,
0.18020400404930115,
0.5059157609939575,
0.5450209379196167,
0.3618110418319702,
0.01959574595093727,
0.33935290575027466,
-0.4535718858242035,
0.19387318193912506,
-0.046818025410175323,
-0.25600841641426086,
-0.6849296689033508,
-0.04926431179046631,
0.4129691421985626,
0.28168773651123047,
-0.18727687001228333,
0.5134454369544983,
0.09064812958240509,
0.44241786003112793,
-0.7931602597236633,
0.05577494576573372,
-0.8418004512786865,
0.05068697780370712,
-0.04233107343316078,
-0.14409953355789185,
-0.3489539325237274,
-0.35786163806915283,
-0.0015379830729216337,
-0.4700034260749817,
0.03860839456319809,
0.30053308606147766,
0.958527147769928,
-0.04140833392739296,
-0.07020942866802216,
-0.10544025152921677,
-0.7087526321411133,
1.390122413635254,
-0.7109866738319397,
0.29600268602371216,
0.2606789767742157,
0.0695687085390091,
-0.03874079883098602,
-0.552105724811554,
-0.5870245695114136,
-0.09200667589902878,
0.20255067944526672,
0.3021344542503357,
-0.3412649631500244,
-0.16220930218696594,
-0.20176568627357483,
0.5792995691299438,
-0.3258667290210724,
0.733637273311615,
-0.1852009892463684,
0.13656124472618103,
0.9422074556350708,
0.11757579445838928,
0.00831033755093813,
0.11814890056848526,
-0.6821929216384888,
-0.2032768428325653,
-0.6516761183738708,
0.11355212330818176,
0.33693262934684753,
0.16913555562496185,
0.20284521579742432,
0.32060444355010986,
-0.31643062829971313,
0.42902857065200806,
0.10767285525798798,
-0.7644761800765991,
0.40465307235717773,
-0.071256622672081,
-0.278873473405838,
0.2373858541250229,
0.9021807312965393,
0.25540879368782043,
-0.168033167719841,
-0.22975695133209229,
-0.4927925765514374,
-0.32173097133636475,
-0.038540106266736984,
-0.5115446448326111,
0.09304560720920563,
0.3842160999774933,
-0.5126805305480957,
-0.6364367008209229,
0.024478906765580177,
-1.0847609043121338,
-0.14815054833889008,
-0.23032400012016296,
0.5283973217010498,
-0.03645935654640198,
-0.15401749312877655,
-0.321807861328125,
0.11011841148138046,
0.4038320481777191,
0.2315734177827835,
-0.8949597477912903,
0.47923678159713745,
0.7731592059135437,
0.7544043660163879,
-0.829359233379364,
-0.10216547548770905,
-0.41748034954071045,
0.24768991768360138,
0.00828972551971674,
1.056628704071045,
-0.47547823190689087,
-0.2553463578224182,
-0.11684475094079971,
-0.04773051664233208,
0.27461549639701843,
-0.7577950358390808,
0.6904599666595459,
-0.7683371305465698,
-0.1464126855134964,
0.06983977556228638,
-0.7544345855712891,
-0.25418195128440857,
0.44332799315452576,
-0.8178502917289734,
0.9183865189552307,
-0.028815973550081253,
-0.19764049351215363,
0.3425261378288269,
-0.3814535439014435,
-0.38977524638175964,
0.32982131838798523,
-0.06959917396306992,
-0.8413690328598022,
0.2342987060546875,
0.422244131565094,
0.6103858351707458,
-0.7869410514831543,
-0.1338738054037094,
-0.5587068200111389,
-0.12763692438602448,
0.4288597106933594,
-0.5080826878547668,
0.6123971939086914,
0.3193570077419281,
-0.17854489386081696,
-0.13024179637432098,
-0.8283427357673645,
0.33218419551849365,
0.36242005228996277,
-0.25786876678466797,
-0.1315048485994339,
0.006665955297648907,
0.12583647668361664,
0.06823556870222092,
0.44320857524871826,
-0.46693098545074463,
0.2558327317237854,
-0.13650642335414886,
0.10040318220853806,
1.0857068300247192,
-0.04811902716755867,
0.41734427213668823,
-0.3385619819164276,
0.5298327803611755,
-0.28957220911979675,
0.06673411279916763,
0.03312964737415314,
-0.4517420530319214,
-0.3704199492931366,
-0.6977083086967468,
0.2614894509315491,
0.6945584416389465,
-0.28368690609931946,
0.7992938756942749,
-0.28462716937065125,
-0.4665645360946655,
-0.2711530029773712,
0.4021860659122467,
0.030331801623106003,
0.3352281153202057,
0.2535986602306366,
-0.26483845710754395,
-0.35505661368370056,
-0.8618808388710022,
-0.020534448325634003,
-0.17926743626594543,
-0.29429659247398376,
0.2626035809516907,
0.1338772028684616,
-0.12652398645877838,
0.9301041960716248,
-0.7996087074279785,
-0.3707083463668823,
-0.3552965223789215,
0.1992574781179428,
0.5482290983200073,
0.23296569287776947,
0.14989754557609558,
-0.5747855305671692,
-0.3234904706478119,
0.18816229701042175,
-0.38892728090286255,
-0.4281778037548065,
-0.009540537372231483,
-0.09563827514648438,
0.2933999300003052,
-0.15228527784347534,
-0.46855589747428894,
0.14964120090007782,
0.6813910007476807,
0.2852078080177307,
0.6556876301765442,
-0.14627555012702942,
0.13869833946228027,
-1.1171208620071411,
-0.2583453953266144,
0.2850436866283417,
-0.08449407666921616,
-0.4989631772041321,
-0.062468357384204865,
-0.037497978657484055,
0.18085677921772003,
-0.5283679366111755,
0.28016144037246704,
-0.4518077075481415,
-0.3337305188179016,
-0.1647568792104721,
-0.03560659661889076,
0.029901929199695587,
0.6165755391120911,
0.10740389674901962,
0.5576736927032471,
0.376125305891037,
-0.7824302315711975,
0.7021912932395935,
0.012801898643374443,
-0.556225597858429,
0.9125430583953857,
-0.333135187625885,
0.16790060698986053,
0.008373376913368702,
-0.006460660602897406,
-0.9014267325401306,
-0.048796337097883224,
-0.0013834587298333645,
-0.10449162125587463,
0.4410459101200104,
0.02822071872651577,
-0.4778532385826111,
-0.30933964252471924,
-0.4359400272369385,
0.41160476207733154,
0.6747540831565857,
-0.7741968035697937,
0.786020040512085,
0.5958887934684753,
-0.4064575731754303,
-0.3903721868991852,
-0.5955677628517151,
0.03325548768043518,
-0.6000283360481262,
-0.679878830909729,
0.634077787399292,
-0.12238196283578873,
-0.19265645742416382,
-0.22313185036182404,
-0.08474714308977127,
-0.08116460591554642,
0.15225711464881897,
-0.20459821820259094,
0.5648158192634583,
-0.05735137313604355,
0.3426789343357086,
-0.08301091939210892,
-0.20640423893928528,
-0.09969577193260193,
-0.45771557092666626,
0.49026554822921753,
-0.22751900553703308,
-0.41454631090164185,
-0.35148996114730835,
0.19388926029205322,
0.1818884164094925,
-0.2249760776758194,
0.592809796333313,
0.633591890335083,
-0.27601730823516846,
-0.4020542502403259,
-0.7531268000602722,
-0.10355114936828613,
-0.4974680542945862,
0.5093405246734619,
0.0011277865851297975,
-0.5885570049285889,
0.4509849548339844,
-0.3746813237667084,
0.0916612520813942,
0.43809640407562256,
0.6675403118133545,
-0.23093591630458832,
1.0445239543914795,
0.32727861404418945,
-0.30728256702423096,
0.33862313628196716,
-0.2765425145626068,
0.3764464855194092,
-0.7161476016044617,
-0.3650994598865509,
-0.4674389958381653,
-0.576205849647522,
-0.7394117116928101,
-0.23553253710269928,
0.5736159682273865,
0.007958264090120792,
-0.12150391936302185,
0.10872623324394226,
-0.41229552030563354,
0.47632357478141785,
0.5650323629379272,
0.2723654508590698,
0.46767058968544006,
0.5055919885635376,
0.29422494769096375,
0.13549505174160004,
-0.34602561593055725,
-0.3713170289993286,
1.1213568449020386,
0.2989051342010498,
0.9667466878890991,
0.3758108615875244,
0.7120741605758667,
0.24074847996234894,
0.2697505056858063,
-1.029901385307312,
0.47905150055885315,
-0.16646599769592285,
-0.17414702475070953,
-0.21255435049533844,
-0.40051060914993286,
-0.7577640414237976,
0.2523922622203827,
-0.352363258600235,
-1.2245469093322754,
0.2503418028354645,
0.08008866757154465,
-0.36344754695892334,
0.4703432023525238,
-0.48251011967658997,
0.4009315073490143,
-0.8882312774658203,
-0.6945960521697998,
-0.010041921399533749,
-0.3695714771747589,
0.3951970338821411,
-0.41744697093963623,
0.25498872995376587,
-0.19195394217967987,
-0.3535597324371338,
0.6696184873580933,
-0.29788506031036377,
0.42552849650382996,
0.29832974076271057,
-0.34993380308151245,
0.2760345935821533,
-0.057521454989910126,
0.916601836681366,
-0.18678435683250427,
-0.044491980224847794,
0.366599440574646,
-0.25072962045669556,
-0.21623815596103668,
-0.520326554775238,
0.6881331205368042,
-0.7089410424232483,
-0.47094276547431946,
-0.2771530747413635,
-0.32498180866241455,
-0.39795079827308655,
0.0026095733046531677,
0.21665546298027039,
0.04797927290201187,
-0.17569436132907867,
0.2902243435382843,
0.6890023350715637,
-0.30514419078826904,
0.7626011967658997,
0.267539381980896,
-0.1271338164806366,
-0.6008300185203552,
1.169179081916809,
0.02431097999215126,
0.449101060628891,
0.60660719871521,
0.401022344827652,
-0.3706378638744354,
-0.4243149161338806,
-0.20943757891654968,
-0.1358405351638794,
-0.6278573870658875,
-0.5862821936607361,
-0.528523862361908,
-0.0853792056441307,
-0.2475603222846985,
-0.06736086308956146,
-0.22219985723495483,
-0.45565155148506165,
-0.28125983476638794,
-0.1955375373363495,
0.42993664741516113,
0.5204365849494934,
-0.11801236867904663,
0.3377218544483185,
-0.9527553915977478,
0.023875199258327484,
0.6592952609062195,
0.12076765298843384,
0.12088043987751007,
-0.2002229243516922,
-0.1700253039598465,
-0.09293544292449951,
-0.5416791439056396,
-0.8787807822227478,
0.7036881446838379,
0.28867581486701965,
0.7277032136917114,
0.7122682332992554,
-0.007022078614681959,
0.5405925512313843,
-0.14354053139686584,
0.7440448999404907,
0.26478907465934753,
-0.7490757703781128,
0.08511003106832504,
-0.04351010546088219,
0.024731801822781563,
0.3877074122428894,
0.3263581693172455,
-0.24006283283233643,
0.03221461921930313,
-0.5347232222557068,
-1.1897146701812744,
0.6885285973548889,
0.23254740238189697,
-0.1794625073671341,
0.21573664247989655,
-0.20345447957515717,
0.11730232834815979,
0.4103504717350006,
-0.8021196126937866,
-0.17842411994934082,
0.2432113140821457,
-0.45510876178741455,
-0.05984446778893471,
-0.12190471589565277,
0.08054458349943161,
-0.3108924627304077,
0.8413285613059998,
-0.1227104663848877,
0.43579816818237305,
-0.14395900070667267,
-0.23092646896839142,
-0.11156655102968216,
0.3080579340457916,
0.3487718403339386,
0.4480029344558716,
-0.255087286233902,
0.08719976991415024,
0.6002427339553833,
-0.355374276638031,
0.23879127204418182,
0.02972971647977829,
0.02542831376194954,
-0.4348808526992798,
0.2237846553325653,
0.617552638053894,
-0.03577978163957596,
-0.7619417905807495,
0.4882696866989136,
0.2462809830904007,
-0.016828183084726334,
-0.4193580448627472,
-0.23489713668823242,
-0.07211782038211823,
0.3242814242839813,
0.6979308128356934,
-0.22715598344802856,
0.24980925023555756,
-0.42104512453079224,
0.21467919647693634,
0.599663496017456,
0.04418545216321945,
-0.10818997025489807,
0.17221961915493011,
-0.1117926836013794,
-0.21193715929985046,
0.5414183139801025,
-0.19427630305290222,
-0.6015833616256714,
0.8055815696716309,
0.7830507159233093,
1.2499229907989502,
-0.31091323494911194,
0.13487598299980164,
0.17013409733772278,
0.2928733825683594,
-0.044717613607645035,
-0.10166572034358978,
-0.16269591450691223,
-0.8618844151496887,
-0.3057198226451874,
-0.8962456583976746,
-0.2882929742336273,
0.1858544945716858,
-0.46106281876564026,
0.29346761107444763,
-0.23726283013820648,
-0.04488730803132057,
-0.26958489418029785,
0.12280991673469543,
-0.7453767657279968,
0.16365982592105865,
0.328315794467926,
0.3716418147087097,
-0.6826741695404053,
0.5183299779891968,
0.30369865894317627,
-0.21537429094314575,
-0.6964373588562012,
-0.1341436356306076,
0.16755633056163788,
-0.9797650575637817,
0.6606913805007935,
0.0954294502735138,
-0.10714460909366608,
-0.05144735798239708,
-0.6506335139274597,
-1.021782636642456,
1.323793649673462,
0.04542466253042221,
-0.7507548928260803,
0.2427680790424347,
0.2509848177433014,
0.2615356147289276,
-0.6663420796394348,
0.4619021713733673,
0.6097579598426819,
0.47628429532051086,
0.4650067389011383,
-0.4922848343849182,
-0.08108358085155487,
-0.02349487505853176,
0.045394763350486755,
0.13281488418579102,
-0.5404219031333923,
0.7050688862800598,
0.039562076330184937,
-0.05289500951766968,
0.13889533281326294,
0.5749481320381165,
0.5056108832359314,
0.22453589737415314,
0.6128321886062622,
0.7931110262870789,
0.9623029232025146,
0.054924093186855316,
0.8854982256889343,
-0.17228084802627563,
0.5369358062744141,
0.9289368987083435,
-0.4757700562477112,
1.0289926528930664,
0.4005434811115265,
-0.4475710391998291,
0.39417538046836853,
0.598943829536438,
-0.2941359579563141,
0.6411350965499878,
0.1710771769285202,
-0.586452841758728,
-0.34368810057640076,
-0.007326965685933828,
-0.09283271431922913,
0.4435041546821594,
0.3764585554599762,
-0.42963412404060364,
-0.0272526778280735,
-0.1856519728899002,
-0.1913827359676361,
-0.4968332350254059,
-0.5099020600318909,
1.051265835762024,
0.020729871466755867,
-0.30906274914741516,
0.5153411030769348,
-0.05064646527171135,
0.693764865398407,
-0.513454794883728,
0.03943257033824921,
-0.011132126674056053,
0.2086973488330841,
-0.352304071187973,
-0.576238751411438,
-0.29355931282043457,
-0.002649773145094514,
0.050016164779663086,
-0.16208516061306,
0.7785952091217041,
-0.3640286922454834,
-0.942446231842041,
0.053861409425735474,
0.34046533703804016,
-0.0031089140102267265,
0.09181910008192062,
-0.5394313335418701,
0.018147282302379608,
-0.2062913179397583,
-0.3312219977378845,
0.467497855424881,
0.07504580914974213,
0.05666050314903259,
0.5476011037826538,
0.7192153930664062,
0.10564842075109482,
-0.07561013847589493,
-0.2824822664260864,
0.6452398896217346,
-0.4760945737361908,
-0.48404374718666077,
-0.9406771063804626,
0.4870777130126953,
-0.4627440273761749,
0.04790504649281502,
0.6323702931404114,
0.5078873634338379,
0.7438551783561707,
0.14637230336666107,
0.6925472617149353,
0.18562942743301392,
0.1999194175004959,
-0.6442142128944397,
0.45851027965545654,
-0.6524748206138611,
0.524713397026062,
-0.5304812788963318,
-1.321068525314331,
-0.17891021072864532,
0.551592230796814,
-0.113568976521492,
0.17601531744003296,
0.5594516396522522,
0.7717170715332031,
-0.004459143150597811,
0.1298515498638153,
0.31847071647644043,
0.10730947554111481,
0.22959491610527039,
0.6880806088447571,
0.7536277174949646,
-0.2523259222507477,
0.49648815393447876,
-0.3635044991970062,
-0.4384964406490326,
-0.18024174869060516,
-1.2578595876693726,
-0.34442710876464844,
-0.307770699262619,
-0.24698695540428162,
-0.15340854227542877,
-0.22673526406288147,
1.4529423713684082,
0.6206446886062622,
-0.8404499888420105,
-0.4885329306125641,
0.1270291805267334,
0.12726417183876038,
-0.589887261390686,
-0.20830433070659637,
0.4010835886001587,
-0.1977984756231308,
-0.7391005158424377,
0.338797003030777,
0.3535929322242737,
0.05277091637253761,
-0.2520044147968292,
-0.13560988008975983,
-0.16968651115894318,
0.051415205001831055,
0.7587911486625671,
0.1284204125404358,
-0.5658801794052124,
-0.06469728797674179,
-0.0510316900908947,
0.29592880606651306,
0.23897422850131989,
0.3836805820465088,
-0.5746047496795654,
0.19955366849899292,
0.5204219222068787,
0.8323513865470886,
0.5276925563812256,
0.06396596133708954,
0.507506251335144,
-0.638175368309021,
-0.0715220719575882,
0.2325073480606079,
0.3528088331222534,
0.17319057881832123,
-0.39818164706230164,
0.2487758845090866,
0.30493953824043274,
-0.6600828766822815,
-0.7000793814659119,
0.2964603006839752,
-1.0108590126037598,
-0.2682614028453827,
1.1570146083831787,
0.014216702431440353,
-0.5421838164329529,
0.30577552318573,
-0.0028324564918875694,
0.010282402858138084,
-0.507268488407135,
0.8658744692802429,
0.3960743546485901,
-0.05760171636939049,
-0.3693375587463379,
-0.11347080767154694,
0.10565080493688583,
0.123491071164608,
-1.0653603076934814,
-0.308914452791214,
0.3667728304862976,
0.04066028073430061,
0.10090000182390213,
0.09099120646715164,
0.12468526512384415,
-0.05890486016869545,
-0.4787715673446655,
0.19201157987117767,
0.07616808265447617,
-0.04976503551006317,
-0.39138758182525635,
0.31427767872810364,
0.044465795159339905,
-0.15709765255451202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00165v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00165v2
|
TELEClass: Taxonomy Enrichment and LLM-Enhanced Hierarchical Text Classification with Minimal Supervision
| 2024-02-29T22:26:07 | 2024-06-16T19:10:39 |
Yunyi Zhang, Ruozhen Yang, Xueqiang Xu, Rui Li, Jinfeng Xiao, Jiaming Shen, Jiawei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Hierarchical text classification aims to categorize each document into a set
of classes in a label taxonomy. Most earlier works focus on fully or
semi-supervised methods that require a large amount of human annotated data
which is costly and time-consuming to acquire. To alleviate human efforts, in
this paper, we work on hierarchical text classification with the minimal amount
of supervision: using the sole class name of each node as the only supervision.
Recently, large language models (LLM) show competitive performance on various
tasks through zero-shot prompting, but this method performs poorly in the
hierarchical setting, because it is ineffective to include the large and
structured label space in a prompt. On the other hand, previous
weakly-supervised hierarchical text classification methods only utilize the raw
taxonomy skeleton and ignore the rich information hidden in the text corpus
that can serve as additional class-indicative features. To tackle the above
challenges, we propose TELEClass, Taxonomy Enrichment and LLM-Enhanced
weakly-supervised hierarchical text Classification, which (1) automatically
enriches the label taxonomy with class-indicative terms to facilitate
classifier training and (2) utilizes LLMs for both data annotation and creation
tailored for the hierarchical label space. Experiments show that TELEClass can
outperform previous weakly-supervised methods and LLM-based zero-shot prompting
methods on two public datasets.
|
[
-0.1576118916273117,
-0.8423470258712769,
0.30296072363853455,
-0.3465746343135834,
-0.11941199004650116,
0.4099838137626648,
-0.25467413663864136,
-0.8625347018241882,
0.11843789368867874,
0.35500437021255493,
-0.5615740418434143,
-0.8702470660209656,
-0.5628156661987305,
0.38876208662986755,
-0.2763986587524414,
1.2105507850646973,
0.15888643264770508,
-0.3845583200454712,
-0.28586769104003906,
0.21315328776836395,
0.08242975175380707,
-0.6179940104484558,
-0.3676067590713501,
-0.3920459747314453,
0.5962312817573547,
0.7974488139152527,
0.789137065410614,
0.9283260703086853,
0.4575866460800171,
0.29523155093193054,
-0.3667824864387512,
0.3931131660938263,
-0.1754464954137802,
-0.0390462763607502,
0.13452023267745972,
-0.574543297290802,
-0.7041451930999756,
-0.15483218431472778,
0.643226683139801,
0.815208375453949,
0.16180209815502167,
0.42230138182640076,
0.2529875636100769,
0.11244449764490128,
-0.7443568706512451,
0.3854061961174011,
-0.6683452725410461,
0.2673180401325226,
-0.5695878267288208,
-0.5050222873687744,
-0.3516189157962799,
-0.24508309364318848,
0.11578121036291122,
-0.6303563714027405,
0.3775809109210968,
0.19526700675487518,
0.9708663821220398,
0.32526639103889465,
-0.5591175556182861,
0.20946632325649261,
-0.6623722314834595,
0.7909952402114868,
-0.5356312394142151,
0.14638996124267578,
0.8747109174728394,
0.046850014477968216,
0.29641780257225037,
-0.6766647696495056,
-0.2859492003917694,
-0.015949571505188942,
-0.11112894117832184,
0.21307069063186646,
-0.19954097270965576,
0.5517193078994751,
0.2818027436733246,
0.46626344323158264,
-0.2747437357902527,
0.7966759204864502,
-0.433647483587265,
-0.30298537015914917,
0.23337817192077637,
0.3628726899623871,
0.12802278995513916,
-0.46580952405929565,
-0.3741980195045471,
0.17408809065818787,
-0.6173280477523804,
-0.01049361564218998,
0.16514359414577484,
0.6376911401748657,
-0.030930863693356514,
0.643459677696228,
-0.4046943485736847,
0.5836233496665955,
-0.05957351624965668,
-0.30875229835510254,
0.2741066813468933,
-0.36210858821868896,
-0.3630014657974243,
0.3193494975566864,
0.9300061464309692,
0.23619674146175385,
0.005441560409963131,
-0.2087453454732895,
-0.12870796024799347,
0.1841559261083603,
0.027606360614299774,
-0.7010014653205872,
0.14271992444992065,
0.28459474444389343,
-0.3517027497291565,
-0.8319851756095886,
-0.2828488349914551,
-0.9666165709495544,
-0.3294176757335663,
-0.39809301495552063,
0.3253728151321411,
-0.007983321323990822,
0.06564696878194809,
0.05302286520600319,
-0.04639790952205658,
0.08901111781597137,
0.43176257610321045,
-1.1189302206039429,
0.5909255743026733,
0.7515973448753357,
1.0041595697402954,
-0.22067919373512268,
-0.3233208656311035,
-0.6413138508796692,
0.2918091118335724,
-0.024516550824046135,
0.8471477627754211,
-0.7498953938484192,
-0.17974646389484406,
0.48301172256469727,
-0.09017408639192581,
0.18841715157032013,
-0.4925532937049866,
0.6673256158828735,
-0.3975459039211273,
0.5741803646087646,
0.36880946159362793,
-0.59444659948349,
0.024735890328884125,
0.33292368054389954,
-0.2426905483007431,
1.4128406047821045,
0.1098145842552185,
-0.9492114782333374,
0.45528656244277954,
-0.42900413274765015,
-0.25754907727241516,
0.5409526824951172,
-0.10189112275838852,
-0.534990668296814,
-0.2856767475605011,
0.3112640380859375,
0.6132453680038452,
-0.3286573588848114,
0.3648044168949127,
-0.21765540540218353,
-0.45629987120628357,
-0.22178915143013,
-0.1653251349925995,
0.5725706219673157,
-0.11777228116989136,
-0.41899633407592773,
0.11262800544500351,
-0.682959258556366,
0.06258201599121094,
-0.28271210193634033,
-0.34891313314437866,
-0.3887290954589844,
-0.0810699462890625,
0.2852504849433899,
-0.08556321263313293,
0.29960891604423523,
-0.48250889778137207,
0.3753869831562042,
-0.42442622780799866,
0.08250876516103745,
0.650099515914917,
0.038269732147455215,
0.7274127006530762,
-0.509588360786438,
0.574713408946991,
-0.08389448374509811,
0.19787226617336273,
0.01776769571006298,
-0.4561258852481842,
-0.8099440932273865,
-0.4310038685798645,
0.5289019346237183,
0.8049971461296082,
-0.6892393231391907,
0.767661452293396,
-0.46932169795036316,
-0.5158264636993408,
-0.39141035079956055,
0.3651216924190521,
0.2560662627220154,
0.43016067147254944,
0.45268234610557556,
-0.18910610675811768,
-0.5546635389328003,
-0.7961078882217407,
0.16925856471061707,
-0.24796819686889648,
-0.10692466050386429,
0.21789810061454773,
0.3263043165206909,
-0.5032563805580139,
0.86838299036026,
-0.451078861951828,
-0.7528253793716431,
-0.3356834948062897,
0.20760540664196014,
0.10203669965267181,
0.08014632016420364,
0.26568976044654846,
-0.3527402877807617,
-0.27215856313705444,
0.03686688840389252,
-0.7552734017372131,
-0.5709682703018188,
-0.15931618213653564,
0.05391230434179306,
-0.009867110289633274,
0.5129753947257996,
-0.42001470923423767,
0.3840588331222534,
0.18327143788337708,
0.09039802849292755,
0.544623613357544,
0.07860226184129715,
-0.25331586599349976,
-0.9128355979919434,
-0.2312975972890854,
0.12257686257362366,
-0.3271692991256714,
-0.7302168011665344,
-0.2051490992307663,
-0.05669279769062996,
-0.11674650013446808,
-0.21573491394519806,
0.45150601863861084,
-0.4049626886844635,
0.061566002666950226,
-0.3044874370098114,
0.33140793442726135,
-0.17273537814617157,
0.5220168232917786,
0.5141961574554443,
0.4032629728317261,
1.002877116203308,
-0.6555429100990295,
0.2794981300830841,
0.28390786051750183,
-0.11823059618473053,
0.22280800342559814,
-0.3745856285095215,
-0.04545752331614494,
-0.053967710584402084,
0.22447852790355682,
-0.6781212687492371,
-0.3450603187084198,
0.2841278910636902,
-0.22238659858703613,
0.3573927879333496,
-0.21511173248291016,
-0.8580968379974365,
-0.16160154342651367,
-0.6349106431007385,
0.24179837107658386,
0.5024319291114807,
-0.6546518206596375,
0.4076506197452545,
0.19130055606365204,
-0.1311836689710617,
-0.5506987571716309,
-0.6919211149215698,
0.22765804827213287,
-0.32342249155044556,
-0.24862037599086761,
0.537120521068573,
0.4269987642765045,
-0.1020163893699646,
-0.010687609203159809,
-0.17260044813156128,
-0.2870698869228363,
0.006294586230069399,
0.46760791540145874,
0.6067874431610107,
-0.28868797421455383,
0.3524235785007477,
0.2688324749469757,
-0.09254632890224457,
-0.21588240563869476,
-0.21195074915885925,
0.10827186703681946,
-0.019242897629737854,
-0.08478598296642303,
-1.0080899000167847,
0.20032215118408203,
0.3830496668815613,
0.003997213207185268,
0.49773141741752625,
0.4114179313182831,
-0.37645912170410156,
-0.3901890218257904,
-0.43459129333496094,
-0.23668929934501648,
-0.5157445669174194,
0.17366264760494232,
-0.0016886198427528143,
-1.085341453552246,
0.10276450216770172,
-0.24267354607582092,
0.09842567890882492,
0.2378004640340805,
0.3942257761955261,
0.001627290272153914,
0.5026528239250183,
0.6593583822250366,
-0.3600112199783325,
0.7087230086326599,
-0.13186323642730713,
-0.25430208444595337,
-0.6253219246864319,
-0.2728942930698395,
-0.658118724822998,
-0.17448565363883972,
-0.7757445573806763,
-0.29855504631996155,
0.30444014072418213,
-0.16771720349788666,
-0.27864041924476624,
0.382956326007843,
-0.6641124486923218,
0.5190308094024658,
0.5610212087631226,
0.20323772728443146,
0.6015684008598328,
0.26443883776664734,
0.2004273384809494,
-0.01708458736538887,
-0.8187057375907898,
-0.677157998085022,
0.8567997217178345,
0.530712366104126,
0.6163283586502075,
-0.10299999266862869,
1.0946834087371826,
0.3235895335674286,
0.2024298757314682,
-1.2855297327041626,
0.7060487270355225,
-0.07476142048835754,
-0.5028574466705322,
-0.12015519291162491,
-0.5821272134780884,
-1.0276225805282593,
0.14183147251605988,
-0.38862505555152893,
-0.9473996162414551,
0.19516992568969727,
-0.05431019142270088,
-0.35742852091789246,
0.34757000207901,
-0.6492013931274414,
0.52000892162323,
-0.106684111058712,
-0.32372814416885376,
0.09716881066560745,
-0.6728698015213013,
0.2743828594684601,
-0.31226637959480286,
0.38913068175315857,
0.11955627053976059,
-0.5552922487258911,
0.7600984573364258,
-0.522128701210022,
1.4421333074569702,
0.06296458840370178,
-0.02906794473528862,
0.30582937598228455,
0.07599551975727081,
0.3794551491737366,
-0.16104097664356232,
0.16779962182044983,
0.06316017359495163,
-0.1095535159111023,
-0.2750251889228821,
-0.3656313121318817,
0.21405087411403656,
-0.7630725502967834,
-0.43622106313705444,
-0.5856689214706421,
-0.17695939540863037,
-0.5299841165542603,
0.24933354556560516,
0.3163837492465973,
0.6291298866271973,
0.2584080100059509,
0.14613020420074463,
0.5503413677215576,
-0.10855929553508759,
0.4266532361507416,
0.2560482323169708,
-0.2363518625497818,
-0.34852463006973267,
0.6787850260734558,
0.01847025752067566,
0.38491806387901306,
0.6974385380744934,
0.3228110074996948,
-0.23928293585777283,
-0.6418557167053223,
-0.09127114713191986,
0.07466690242290497,
-0.4889536201953888,
-0.6558531522750854,
-0.6407691240310669,
-0.25290340185165405,
-0.28504833579063416,
-0.17378279566764832,
0.02735922299325466,
-0.6383520364761353,
-0.5573683977127075,
-0.25399670004844666,
0.4820995330810547,
0.717791736125946,
-0.020171020179986954,
0.7192279696464539,
-0.9604273438453674,
0.333825021982193,
0.2307438999414444,
0.16044174134731293,
0.02388472482562065,
-0.6952741146087646,
-0.07385488599538803,
-0.2574111819267273,
-0.35477063059806824,
-0.6857919692993164,
0.07706885784864426,
0.5758078098297119,
0.2195964753627777,
0.49719104170799255,
0.2415211945772171,
0.5409038066864014,
-0.48061230778694153,
0.7809970378875732,
0.21178682148456573,
-0.9730446934700012,
0.675574779510498,
-0.5310589075088501,
0.28593909740448,
0.5382777452468872,
0.48088401556015015,
-0.47651174664497375,
-0.7438277006149292,
-0.6711828112602234,
-0.9418399333953857,
0.9815959334373474,
0.16087260842323303,
0.1488915979862213,
0.08568191528320312,
0.07894928008317947,
0.11693630367517471,
-0.03881623223423958,
-0.7672641277313232,
-0.2830270230770111,
0.0028981384821236134,
-0.21877361834049225,
0.21696075797080994,
-0.2993530333042145,
0.0893513411283493,
-0.2678593099117279,
0.5257670879364014,
-0.07209528237581253,
0.10376196354627609,
0.05075094476342201,
0.08914464712142944,
-0.0654933825135231,
0.5422249436378479,
0.06151456758379936,
0.06787827610969543,
-0.33583730459213257,
0.40008869767189026,
0.35638847947120667,
-0.4805000424385071,
0.06355348974466324,
-0.008684594184160233,
-0.2875268757343292,
0.1252741664648056,
0.7865590453147888,
0.4725366234779358,
0.36758172512054443,
-0.3356344699859619,
0.4736379086971283,
0.2096855789422989,
-0.3574332296848297,
0.016125066205859184,
0.11656638234853745,
-0.23493731021881104,
0.12962190806865692,
0.5049207806587219,
-0.2149408608675003,
0.13493603467941284,
-0.5271698832511902,
0.21624192595481873,
0.021070243790745735,
-0.20287516713142395,
-0.10193774104118347,
0.43029719591140747,
0.15080814063549042,
-0.2095121592283249,
0.31259986758232117,
-0.22808218002319336,
-0.6667295694351196,
0.44507870078086853,
0.5028823614120483,
0.7112865447998047,
0.098056361079216,
0.49424827098846436,
0.284077525138855,
0.23888926208019257,
-0.07245870679616928,
-0.1202482357621193,
-0.4877561330795288,
-0.5710556507110596,
-0.4849094748497009,
-0.6434271931648254,
-0.765977680683136,
-0.0023621637374162674,
-0.5867003202438354,
0.4338422417640686,
-0.5475915670394897,
-0.3319500684738159,
0.29413723945617676,
0.1023508608341217,
-0.19378811120986938,
0.127041757106781,
0.3976868689060211,
0.8271852731704712,
-0.789857029914856,
0.7599151730537415,
0.6411640048027039,
-0.16146725416183472,
-0.601738452911377,
0.07098692655563354,
0.32982754707336426,
-0.4744625985622406,
0.8733639121055603,
0.22069689631462097,
-0.2729419469833374,
0.009548746980726719,
-0.6035923361778259,
-0.4557948708534241,
0.9437867999076843,
-0.057377640157938004,
-0.36577796936035156,
-0.16198541224002838,
0.43548548221588135,
0.7399529218673706,
-0.07675573229789734,
0.27489158511161804,
0.1227244958281517,
0.34655267000198364,
0.2837107181549072,
-1.1347805261611938,
-0.08358582109212875,
-0.09706253558397293,
-0.1880614161491394,
0.18997251987457275,
-0.5267283916473389,
0.13977691531181335,
-0.06665287166833878,
-0.37290820479393005,
0.0877968892455101,
0.6410422325134277,
-0.13620784878730774,
0.525275468826294,
0.3402261435985565,
0.36576464772224426,
0.9841331243515015,
-0.09033159166574478,
0.8379222750663757,
0.08395931124687195,
0.4410574734210968,
1.1864441633224487,
-0.23541301488876343,
0.8541814088821411,
0.027605652809143066,
-0.1987917423248291,
0.3890628516674042,
1.013851284980774,
-0.19983340799808502,
0.3279751241207123,
0.06560347974300385,
-0.5499750375747681,
-0.44430452585220337,
-0.6881611347198486,
-0.3718229830265045,
0.5933390259742737,
0.30494606494903564,
-0.05697530135512352,
-0.5510473251342773,
-0.11774710565805435,
0.17300944030284882,
-0.09594286978244781,
-0.5887802243232727,
0.9269008636474609,
0.10098664462566376,
-0.17571428418159485,
0.6331228613853455,
-0.006777922157198191,
1.082417607307434,
-0.46195656061172485,
0.3073037564754486,
-0.05089637637138367,
0.06018870323896408,
-0.7346863150596619,
-0.7291767597198486,
0.20462806522846222,
0.24122707545757294,
0.05644281208515167,
-0.38734471797943115,
0.8096441030502319,
-0.39586812257766724,
-0.35352274775505066,
0.26494908332824707,
0.5769408345222473,
0.08461305499076843,
0.1977556049823761,
-0.3801071345806122,
-0.2926107943058014,
-0.29577746987342834,
-0.0166191216558218,
0.3829503059387207,
0.7055404186248779,
0.07579512894153595,
0.5675001740455627,
0.5310980081558228,
0.19392971694469452,
-0.005048317834734917,
0.08896542340517044,
0.7898513078689575,
-0.6261537671089172,
-0.1694979965686798,
-0.9161847233772278,
0.07405681163072586,
-0.07802870124578476,
-0.34394747018814087,
0.6709417104721069,
0.7319283485412598,
0.6711015701293945,
0.045134786516427994,
0.636509358882904,
0.016220223158597946,
0.2665097415447235,
-0.38419580459594727,
0.2547118663787842,
-0.6125497817993164,
0.192741259932518,
-0.34475716948509216,
-0.9102829098701477,
-0.71073979139328,
0.13605156540870667,
-0.32977697253227234,
-0.15687651932239532,
0.8049209713935852,
0.7389290928840637,
-0.11457618325948715,
0.07550173997879028,
0.2225508689880371,
-0.09268976002931595,
-0.08201535791158676,
0.5385271906852722,
1.058377742767334,
-0.17149093747138977,
0.6255925893783569,
-0.4067871570587158,
-0.39282509684562683,
-0.0899885818362236,
-0.8015891313552856,
-1.2073169946670532,
-0.30551543831825256,
-0.655523419380188,
-0.10067214071750641,
-0.1262599378824234,
1.0899440050125122,
0.6901955604553223,
-0.5986711978912354,
-0.18249955773353577,
0.09798654913902283,
0.23010078072547913,
0.008958152495324612,
-0.27183428406715393,
0.41141602396965027,
-0.6212344765663147,
-0.8156512975692749,
0.18490765988826752,
0.16408686339855194,
0.2065267562866211,
0.18912717700004578,
0.45839375257492065,
-0.0256970152258873,
-0.3499883711338043,
0.508564829826355,
0.2125902771949768,
-0.3447718322277069,
-0.08184612542390823,
-0.054954852908849716,
-0.22300094366073608,
0.2623460590839386,
0.5591372847557068,
-0.7533288598060608,
0.056565672159194946,
0.37308621406555176,
0.7660488486289978,
0.4356590807437897,
0.1710273027420044,
-0.02262464538216591,
-1.1407455205917358,
0.0889735221862793,
0.43906646966934204,
0.15886272490024567,
0.10946787893772125,
-0.592395007610321,
0.5093526244163513,
0.4025585651397705,
-0.5132287740707397,
-0.8127270340919495,
0.09255141019821167,
-1.2949471473693848,
-0.11068878322839737,
1.4413491487503052,
0.2315485179424286,
-0.2077479511499405,
-0.2951386868953705,
-0.2481633871793747,
0.10096212476491928,
-0.46779969334602356,
0.7379376888275146,
0.4868605136871338,
-0.07748425751924515,
-0.26496171951293945,
-0.621278703212738,
0.4749915599822998,
0.2825051248073578,
-1.195754051208496,
0.24196095764636993,
0.5565186738967896,
-0.14356833696365356,
0.2766346335411072,
0.4305274784564972,
-0.04849743843078613,
0.13819332420825958,
-0.07122217863798141,
-0.16233107447624207,
-0.13901808857917786,
-0.3072715401649475,
-0.24534288048744202,
0.3076000511646271,
0.06762759387493134,
-0.21623221039772034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00143v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00143v1
|
Ensemble-Based Unsupervised Discontinuous Constituency Parsing by Tree Averaging
| 2024-02-29T21:49:31 | 2024-02-29T21:49:31 |
Behzad Shayegh, Yuqiao Wen, Lili Mou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We address unsupervised discontinuous constituency parsing, where we observe
a high variance in the performance of the only previous model. We propose to
build an ensemble of different runs of the existing discontinuous parser by
averaging the predicted trees, to stabilize and boost performance. To begin
with, we provide comprehensive computational complexity analysis (in terms of P
and NP-complete) for tree averaging under different setups of binarity and
continuity. We then develop an efficient exact algorithm to tackle the task,
which runs in a reasonable time for all samples in our experiments. Results on
three datasets show our method outperforms all baselines in all metrics; we
also provide in-depth analyses of our approach.
|
[
-0.40330299735069275,
-0.5192536115646362,
0.507062554359436,
0.34270721673965454,
-0.5164827704429626,
0.5758927464485168,
-0.10444306582212448,
-0.3929612934589386,
0.25793159008026123,
0.45458102226257324,
-0.39185988903045654,
-0.4656158685684204,
-0.5732492208480835,
0.043910056352615356,
-0.44952574372291565,
0.33126166462898254,
0.6870534420013428,
0.26973506808280945,
-0.2629440128803253,
-0.3958568871021271,
-0.36946526169776917,
-0.20792052149772644,
-0.5981535315513611,
-0.2808014452457428,
0.10724605619907379,
0.5065015554428101,
0.37987884879112244,
0.6427339911460876,
0.26304754614830017,
0.44635844230651855,
-0.48969072103500366,
0.09115472435951233,
-0.23898915946483612,
0.18277214467525482,
-0.06440722197294235,
-0.36376744508743286,
-0.07200176268815994,
-0.09681352227926254,
0.9745912551879883,
1.3472108840942383,
-0.4506196677684784,
-0.24584682285785675,
0.18836188316345215,
0.7837693095207214,
-0.6071814298629761,
-0.052520137280225754,
-0.9410425424575806,
0.020536502823233604,
-0.21299241483211517,
-0.3885752260684967,
-0.46202003955841064,
-0.4905698001384735,
0.030130822211503983,
-0.36537614464759827,
0.19970861077308655,
-0.05635783076286316,
0.10293392837047577,
0.19624672830104828,
-0.24421006441116333,
0.12696440517902374,
-0.5082806348800659,
0.7962490320205688,
-0.807976245880127,
0.32431647181510925,
0.04182947799563408,
0.11797785758972168,
-0.33754491806030273,
-0.6673084497451782,
-0.008564761839807034,
0.11915263533592224,
0.08157478272914886,
0.30819377303123474,
-0.506342887878418,
0.3458199203014374,
0.007749853190034628,
0.3236251175403595,
-0.3549274504184723,
0.42868033051490784,
-0.03903486952185631,
0.3124769628047943,
0.4339359998703003,
-0.14655162394046783,
-0.12249898910522461,
-0.2799009680747986,
-0.18230977654457092,
0.015255442820489407,
-0.2655542492866516,
0.210411936044693,
0.3479132652282715,
0.1705697774887085,
-0.00045461926492862403,
0.37798741459846497,
-0.4387289881706238,
0.6657905578613281,
-0.029208339750766754,
0.48329252004623413,
-0.06387125700712204,
-0.08347611129283905,
-0.5770647525787354,
0.34622257947921753,
0.729911208152771,
0.39082029461860657,
0.14058905839920044,
-0.23469533026218414,
-0.11651835590600967,
0.2086031287908554,
-0.09445781260728836,
-0.472095787525177,
-0.7156692147254944,
0.537063717842102,
-0.5678211450576782,
-0.48108765482902527,
-0.18728883564472198,
-1.3618959188461304,
-0.48611918091773987,
-0.531191885471344,
-0.07878126204013824,
-0.5542778968811035,
-0.46892720460891724,
-0.10762212425470352,
-0.18850231170654297,
-0.3904755711555481,
0.38429564237594604,
-0.6776115298271179,
0.7220659255981445,
0.703706681728363,
0.9820064306259155,
0.08624057471752167,
-0.34575173258781433,
-0.7567502856254578,
-0.36281201243400574,
-0.4947341978549957,
1.003824234008789,
-0.8152928948402405,
-0.38465872406959534,
-0.16071929037570953,
-0.20319832861423492,
-0.28689101338386536,
-0.5454105138778687,
0.37597164511680603,
-0.20912957191467285,
0.20909909904003143,
-0.1836341768503189,
-0.6846172213554382,
-0.30467522144317627,
-0.03297726437449455,
-0.5763257741928101,
0.9342703819274902,
0.19611094892024994,
-0.7862192988395691,
0.46267828345298767,
-0.6340703368186951,
0.18594127893447876,
0.0875236988067627,
-0.15393537282943726,
-0.2948412001132965,
0.4471479654312134,
0.507956862449646,
0.3972405791282654,
-0.0507986843585968,
0.3449782133102417,
-0.5681982636451721,
-0.19394944608211517,
0.1614949256181717,
-0.5762837529182434,
1.187490463256836,
-0.08195466548204422,
-0.22183357179164886,
0.18063092231750488,
-1.0456920862197876,
0.4046193063259125,
-0.312227338552475,
-0.047897931188344955,
-0.380275696516037,
0.5563789010047913,
0.052249178290367126,
-0.2161245346069336,
-0.022374937310814857,
-0.6316837668418884,
0.21915777027606964,
-0.669999361038208,
0.4188123643398285,
0.801118791103363,
0.15901623666286469,
0.24867036938667297,
-0.24506598711013794,
0.09122870862483978,
0.255186527967453,
-0.11707417666912079,
-0.22523611783981323,
-0.40911513566970825,
-0.5650712847709656,
-0.3720643222332001,
0.8795756697654724,
0.4674227833747864,
-0.18080578744411469,
0.7784967422485352,
-0.16794508695602417,
-0.4201839566230774,
-0.24350446462631226,
0.027076978236436844,
0.2568710148334503,
0.20736749470233917,
0.24826611578464508,
-0.7145165205001831,
-0.8998829126358032,
-0.6838918924331665,
0.1477556675672531,
-0.45042598247528076,
-0.1003502607345581,
-0.1762302815914154,
0.1671563684940338,
0.02332606166601181,
1.0590052604675293,
-0.19557981193065643,
0.25267308950424194,
0.05384187400341034,
0.5565224885940552,
0.34662607312202454,
0.47219714522361755,
0.33826392889022827,
-0.36072245240211487,
-0.07967445999383926,
0.32688820362091064,
-0.573927640914917,
-0.39676323533058167,
-0.09482837468385696,
0.10757360607385635,
0.23611141741275787,
0.3322974741458893,
-0.6305088400840759,
0.21900391578674316,
0.5808004140853882,
-0.29500001668930054,
0.46366262435913086,
-0.13992983102798462,
0.19255304336547852,
-1.1078449487686157,
0.0224558524787426,
0.05032815411686897,
-0.49667903780937195,
-0.3514213562011719,
-0.3157241642475128,
-0.18132522702217102,
-0.007433322258293629,
-0.293785035610199,
-0.2071256786584854,
-0.5867338180541992,
-0.5174792408943176,
-0.1371227204799652,
-0.19531194865703583,
-0.2670244574546814,
0.4918442666530609,
0.16716153919696808,
0.2606087028980255,
0.7425645589828491,
-0.26704445481300354,
0.24817505478858948,
-0.2162644863128662,
-0.2898324131965637,
0.6969336271286011,
-0.5412325263023376,
-0.22842374444007874,
-0.2432655692100525,
0.18323670327663422,
-1.2651276588439941,
-0.2731596529483795,
-0.04375994950532913,
-0.42615562677383423,
0.31947728991508484,
-0.5469658970832825,
-0.23560605943202972,
0.004111289046704769,
-0.4218844473361969,
0.4146222472190857,
0.3128247559070587,
-0.692506730556488,
0.4078136384487152,
0.2618403732776642,
-0.2036348581314087,
-0.2848612666130066,
-0.22874665260314941,
0.1697123497724533,
-0.3828914761543274,
-0.6187459230422974,
0.26461467146873474,
0.322397381067276,
-0.42698022723197937,
0.1496933549642563,
0.06517180055379868,
-0.10964629054069519,
0.15098212659358978,
0.28476807475090027,
-0.16998735070228577,
-0.45618608593940735,
-0.061941470950841904,
0.097492516040802,
-0.06425916403532028,
0.0762738436460495,
-0.3033343553543091,
0.5995160937309265,
-0.1874740719795227,
-0.5090358257293701,
-0.4732467532157898,
0.738966703414917,
1.0000320672988892,
-0.17583420872688293,
0.03920686990022659,
-0.16966493427753448,
-0.5283389687538147,
-0.05445926636457443,
-0.45026013255119324,
0.2744320333003998,
-0.41212230920791626,
0.21347655355930328,
0.13143502175807953,
-0.6885415315628052,
0.6980923414230347,
-0.566805362701416,
0.313141405582428,
0.42030516266822815,
0.4446956217288971,
-0.23032993078231812,
0.9057340621948242,
0.3328060805797577,
-0.2755360007286072,
0.29112985730171204,
-0.06771855056285858,
-0.16480527818202972,
-0.609926700592041,
-0.10927076637744904,
-0.7095717191696167,
-0.3728378713130951,
-0.8918291926383972,
-0.3159557282924652,
0.1308472454547882,
0.5286007523536682,
-0.25127875804901123,
-0.02381453663110733,
-0.8444319367408752,
0.6617125868797302,
0.6833568811416626,
-0.11863890290260315,
0.26908400654792786,
0.08486299216747284,
0.029525374993681908,
0.2950786352157593,
-0.7631891369819641,
-0.1907956302165985,
0.8639793992042542,
0.39403146505355835,
0.46022677421569824,
0.09748987853527069,
0.7740798592567444,
0.257484495639801,
-0.12547022104263306,
-0.7136809825897217,
0.38387444615364075,
-0.13335679471492767,
0.07196423411369324,
-0.526343584060669,
-0.49551311135292053,
-1.225929617881775,
0.5874881148338318,
0.07832979410886765,
-1.3314595222473145,
0.7066203951835632,
0.031396638602018356,
-0.35922232270240784,
0.4469974935054779,
-0.6864644289016724,
0.6720245480537415,
-0.05964702367782593,
-0.0645064264535904,
0.20316395163536072,
-0.8486095070838928,
0.5993966460227966,
0.019750826060771942,
0.04633728787302971,
0.038008831441402435,
0.06021447107195854,
0.9755797982215881,
-0.3460976183414459,
0.936225950717926,
-0.31203943490982056,
0.5828462839126587,
0.34802502393722534,
0.06772034615278244,
0.4039860665798187,
0.20865829288959503,
-0.0017478218069300056,
0.3763977885246277,
0.23849919438362122,
-0.4075128734111786,
-0.5822870135307312,
0.6402599215507507,
-0.6664685010910034,
-0.22966735064983368,
-0.6794939041137695,
-0.24751973152160645,
-0.3570525050163269,
0.13874852657318115,
0.07429839670658112,
0.4470100700855255,
-0.3943081796169281,
0.6004318594932556,
0.563363254070282,
0.5618597269058228,
1.1455304622650146,
0.1570928692817688,
-0.019480442628264427,
-0.7630909085273743,
0.48379451036453247,
0.18814055621623993,
-0.1196858361363411,
0.3931964635848999,
0.39101967215538025,
-0.6613077521324158,
-0.7448787093162537,
-0.5969875454902649,
-0.26670175790786743,
-0.3733932673931122,
-0.4274826943874359,
-0.8215048313140869,
-0.16023294627666473,
-0.14402805268764496,
-0.06512273102998734,
-0.45856502652168274,
-0.6502971053123474,
-0.25182268023490906,
0.2035342901945114,
0.36352187395095825,
0.42756086587905884,
-0.24629318714141846,
0.6637334823608398,
-0.7834212183952332,
-0.22291886806488037,
0.2748979330062866,
0.3891806900501251,
-0.2720341682434082,
-0.019694792106747627,
0.23800376057624817,
0.12054263800382614,
-0.4532430171966553,
-1.166495442390442,
0.19566848874092102,
0.29138249158859253,
0.5405938029289246,
0.5134127140045166,
-0.1402789205312729,
0.8363156914710999,
-0.29489293694496155,
0.757499098777771,
0.4153610169887543,
-0.9863435626029968,
0.4492014944553375,
-0.4613316059112549,
0.27442625164985657,
0.8708696961402893,
-0.0933706983923912,
-0.37311092019081116,
-0.29669904708862305,
-0.9064264297485352,
-0.7639784812927246,
0.6580040454864502,
0.5378541350364685,
-0.3696517050266266,
0.19865432381629944,
-0.05014726147055626,
-0.2465386837720871,
0.014804345555603504,
-0.5072503089904785,
0.05088016018271446,
-0.21337810158729553,
-0.11486656963825226,
-0.019916221499443054,
-0.16404065489768982,
-0.23168233036994934,
-0.33967825770378113,
0.5226876735687256,
-0.1270221769809723,
0.061720624566078186,
0.019100386649370193,
0.39655473828315735,
-0.5006120800971985,
0.44702085852622986,
0.3730658292770386,
0.9399552345275879,
-0.5043942928314209,
0.3564310371875763,
0.21869400143623352,
-0.158682182431221,
0.30524688959121704,
0.37166211009025574,
0.2976755201816559,
0.21744850277900696,
0.6055248975753784,
0.507622480392456,
0.38806843757629395,
-0.5683884620666504,
0.28675007820129395,
-0.1325145959854126,
-0.29726311564445496,
-0.23405064642429352,
-0.1284869760274887,
0.2974410653114319,
0.28067636489868164,
0.30264589190483093,
0.31093087792396545,
0.1313331425189972,
-0.3548080623149872,
0.5325151681900024,
0.4911937713623047,
-0.2147306501865387,
-0.00042326198308728635,
0.19271954894065857,
0.07953321188688278,
-0.3268234431743622,
0.5034849047660828,
-0.014484904706478119,
-0.4240931570529938,
0.7776774764060974,
0.4048340916633606,
0.8483242392539978,
-0.6646772027015686,
0.18272936344146729,
0.09117906540632248,
0.37533435225486755,
-0.13387596607208252,
0.13012248277664185,
-0.2642936706542969,
-0.29284220933914185,
-0.4382462203502655,
-0.8656954169273376,
-0.5010833740234375,
0.1843569576740265,
-0.5936137437820435,
0.1302584558725357,
-0.4430859088897705,
0.3669050633907318,
0.32968902587890625,
0.1208772361278534,
-0.014743917621672153,
0.49127042293548584,
-0.5062595009803772,
0.6741172075271606,
-0.985161304473877,
0.423054039478302,
0.5606194734573364,
0.27019059658050537,
-0.5650272369384766,
-0.054211750626564026,
0.00031929684337228537,
-0.42898064851760864,
-0.16946616768836975,
0.08853823691606522,
0.13892300426959991,
-0.02670242264866829,
-0.17303381860256195,
-0.8108960390090942,
0.8711994886398315,
0.2978545129299164,
-1.0617611408233643,
0.23939451575279236,
0.02431446500122547,
0.46157434582710266,
-0.3592718541622162,
0.4956805109977722,
0.8311874866485596,
0.13019990921020508,
0.5398159623146057,
-0.5719031095504761,
-0.2955555021762848,
-0.2203277051448822,
0.08513718843460083,
0.6692468523979187,
-0.3161439299583435,
0.8312494158744812,
0.466791033744812,
-0.18751072883605957,
-0.03331529721617699,
0.6208198666572571,
0.25448471307754517,
0.7133257985115051,
0.8004341125488281,
0.9805355072021484,
1.004287600517273,
0.09260173887014389,
0.6102542877197266,
-0.3439220190048218,
0.5251350998878479,
1.316779375076294,
-0.09653908759355545,
0.8423426151275635,
0.4613238275051117,
-0.46778473258018494,
0.22606107592582703,
1.1118875741958618,
0.22254343330860138,
0.4515363872051239,
0.17485199868679047,
-0.6020188927650452,
-0.4752098619937897,
0.0767965242266655,
-0.46570301055908203,
0.8241273760795593,
0.2664213478565216,
-0.4735512137413025,
-0.8278616070747375,
-0.5410653948783875,
-0.32059112191200256,
0.038010258227586746,
-0.32167237997055054,
0.7346413135528564,
-0.059986013919115067,
-0.7906885147094727,
0.6302779316902161,
-0.01899607479572296,
0.183799147605896,
-0.35029101371765137,
-0.3398404121398926,
-0.06359922140836716,
-0.1909300982952118,
-0.38432395458221436,
-0.734102189540863,
0.3500572443008423,
-0.16902586817741394,
-0.057027943432331085,
0.07806761562824249,
0.5172804594039917,
-0.17702071368694305,
-0.9950236678123474,
-0.028944533318281174,
0.6020233631134033,
0.22845101356506348,
-0.09935466200113297,
-0.5107151865959167,
-0.062424398958683014,
0.008777356706559658,
-0.13297607004642487,
0.2118537425994873,
0.7453051805496216,
-0.13560941815376282,
0.2655560374259949,
0.6689121723175049,
0.09964123368263245,
0.07225264608860016,
-0.14432600140571594,
1.1414040327072144,
-0.3708549439907074,
-0.46131572127342224,
-1.037237286567688,
0.6730153560638428,
-0.39515936374664307,
-0.3739747703075409,
0.4865662455558777,
0.9695262312889099,
0.564307689666748,
0.3577096164226532,
0.6294165253639221,
-0.05269971489906311,
0.3516806960105896,
-0.6238288283348083,
0.5174362659454346,
-0.4474361836910248,
0.4085348844528198,
-0.30643174052238464,
-1.0718939304351807,
-0.3761485517024994,
0.37556377053260803,
0.11264554411172867,
-0.014909093268215656,
0.645591139793396,
0.8219351768493652,
-0.5658117532730103,
0.5060575604438782,
0.5295026302337646,
0.017134999856352806,
0.1708049774169922,
0.6145733594894409,
0.8359532952308655,
0.08558563143014908,
0.008686638437211514,
-0.48195314407348633,
-0.7176564931869507,
0.011988053098320961,
-0.9818269610404968,
-0.6949911117553711,
-0.41811856627464294,
-0.3204841911792755,
-0.2175479680299759,
0.13445177674293518,
0.9117816090583801,
0.6915692687034607,
-0.7549018263816833,
-0.3172445595264435,
-0.889782726764679,
0.18874609470367432,
-0.2228098213672638,
-0.17383933067321777,
0.5997722148895264,
-0.39270251989364624,
-0.5578263401985168,
0.47089484333992004,
0.4198402762413025,
-0.30875182151794434,
-0.3233327865600586,
0.3367089033126831,
-0.36563989520072937,
0.022645721212029457,
0.5357779860496521,
0.27068954706192017,
-0.5590754151344299,
-0.4102206826210022,
-0.5461156368255615,
0.5278801321983337,
0.49403515458106995,
0.7791765928268433,
-0.6806411743164062,
0.6330344080924988,
0.5306054949760437,
0.5848450064659119,
0.3421610891819,
0.5500524044036865,
0.11517930775880814,
-0.9811599254608154,
-0.04458227381110191,
0.6385456323623657,
0.42874664068222046,
0.21435703337192535,
-0.33709073066711426,
0.40127071738243103,
0.631575882434845,
-0.612602174282074,
-0.8924323916435242,
0.02462908625602722,
-1.3703469038009644,
-0.3692464530467987,
0.8301476240158081,
-0.07252304255962372,
-0.41514480113983154,
-0.2156413346529007,
-0.20194010436534882,
0.18745462596416473,
-0.41207942366600037,
0.7124327421188354,
0.6138089895248413,
-0.4814385175704956,
-0.5646183490753174,
0.025444529950618744,
0.12267287820577621,
0.4127245843410492,
-0.9849898219108582,
0.4593791365623474,
0.7207019329071045,
0.3346695899963379,
0.18209360539913177,
0.8051872849464417,
-0.0571158342063427,
0.46921423077583313,
0.2781108319759369,
-0.35840746760368347,
0.2837052643299103,
-0.42714065313339233,
-0.5946587324142456,
0.6847391128540039,
-0.06490577757358551,
-0.6013683080673218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00144v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00144v1
|
EBBS: An Ensemble with Bi-Level Beam Search for Zero-Shot Machine Translation
| 2024-02-29T21:49:31 | 2024-02-29T21:49:31 |
Yuqiao Wen, Behzad Shayegh, Chenyang Huang, Yanshuai Cao, Lili Mou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.6; I.2.m; I.5.1; I.7.m
|
The ability of zero-shot translation emerges when we train a multilingual
model with certain translation directions; the model can then directly
translate in unseen directions. Alternatively, zero-shot translation can be
accomplished by pivoting through a third language (e.g., English). In our work,
we observe that both direct and pivot translations are noisy and achieve less
satisfactory performance. We propose EBBS, an ensemble method with a novel
bi-level beam search algorithm, where each ensemble component explores its own
prediction step by step at the lower level but they are synchronized by a "soft
voting" mechanism at the upper level. Results on two popular multilingual
translation datasets show that EBBS consistently outperforms direct and pivot
translations as well as existing ensemble techniques. Further, we can distill
the ensemble's knowledge back to the multilingual model to improve inference
efficiency; profoundly, our EBBS-based distillation does not sacrifice, or even
improves, the translation quality.
|
[
-0.14976167678833008,
-0.7282053232192993,
0.6397039294242859,
0.03407058119773865,
-0.4659053385257721,
0.47497865557670593,
0.0020378592889755964,
-0.5756033658981323,
0.3712860643863678,
0.06491915881633759,
-0.5931790471076965,
-0.5802861452102661,
-0.778612494468689,
0.22883360087871552,
-0.6491535902023315,
1.1514755487442017,
-0.15908513963222504,
0.2875802516937256,
0.5244112610816956,
0.19194938242435455,
-0.2123168259859085,
0.05337769538164139,
-0.3746533691883087,
-0.24163173139095306,
0.6625714302062988,
0.2920249402523041,
0.5579054951667786,
0.416677325963974,
0.4203933775424957,
0.3411630094051361,
-0.16273748874664307,
0.16319359838962555,
-0.5723769068717957,
0.6664716601371765,
-0.14290829002857208,
-0.6752158403396606,
-0.37073588371276855,
-0.20494748651981354,
0.7255414128303528,
0.8321925401687622,
-0.23651115596294403,
0.058720409870147705,
-0.0947687178850174,
0.6962732076644897,
-0.6644337773323059,
0.18042805790901184,
-0.689145028591156,
0.4296857714653015,
-0.508119523525238,
-0.2907249331474304,
-0.6391641497612,
-0.021120021119713783,
-0.20810472965240479,
-0.3677651882171631,
0.46252503991127014,
0.5323725342750549,
0.6185272932052612,
0.030845453962683678,
-0.4849626421928406,
0.03491456061601639,
-0.7710747122764587,
0.8783268928527832,
-0.564626157283783,
0.46913787722587585,
0.010357355698943138,
0.305459201335907,
-0.2770169675350189,
-0.4327859580516815,
-0.5202203392982483,
0.08951400965452194,
0.014816530980169773,
0.39829951524734497,
-0.1840629279613495,
0.27394986152648926,
-0.1766190379858017,
0.2997014820575714,
-0.9003075361251831,
0.029667330905795097,
-0.5938909649848938,
-0.11594321578741074,
0.5585242509841919,
0.15457512438297272,
0.31925860047340393,
0.21757949888706207,
-0.22802314162254333,
-0.23570945858955383,
-0.4560622274875641,
-0.07123187929391861,
0.15798543393611908,
0.6353035569190979,
0.07458408176898956,
0.447965532541275,
-0.5040434002876282,
0.9355311989784241,
0.42751067876815796,
0.20358344912528992,
0.495104044675827,
-0.24747082591056824,
-0.18295787274837494,
0.43686529994010925,
0.640595018863678,
0.024975115433335304,
-0.2084551900625229,
-0.4017777144908905,
-0.470130980014801,
-0.23968136310577393,
0.002000667154788971,
-0.7951990365982056,
-0.011102557182312012,
0.3966476023197174,
-0.3189755976200104,
-0.18880626559257507,
0.10821105539798737,
-0.7976415753364563,
-0.05515217036008835,
-0.08459416776895523,
0.5440031290054321,
-0.2359534502029419,
-0.26056793332099915,
0.07884801179170609,
-0.30994585156440735,
0.2085074633359909,
0.23882882297039032,
-0.9425579905509949,
-0.06094178929924965,
0.5370506048202515,
1.0735704898834229,
0.14871586859226227,
-0.7802609801292419,
-0.8519344329833984,
0.3415963649749756,
-0.8513091206550598,
0.8967768549919128,
-0.4815860688686371,
-0.19519124925136566,
0.051434244960546494,
0.0575343556702137,
0.002515062689781189,
-0.1601417064666748,
0.08744240552186966,
-0.5489104390144348,
0.19308140873908997,
0.1147148460149765,
-0.36319106817245483,
-0.219078928232193,
0.057216085493564606,
-0.41744348406791687,
0.7709662318229675,
-0.16785869002342224,
-0.09469368308782578,
0.501513659954071,
-0.39040330052375793,
-0.7020324468612671,
0.18124648928642273,
-0.12344256788492203,
-0.30217474699020386,
0.6130571365356445,
0.18280045688152313,
0.6188921928405762,
-0.20701882243156433,
0.20985722541809082,
-0.4894729256629944,
-0.5494208335876465,
-0.1356680989265442,
-0.3337317407131195,
0.7801145911216736,
0.3581153452396393,
-0.3702148497104645,
-0.09419244527816772,
-0.26691189408302307,
-0.020732790231704712,
0.057477373629808426,
-0.04726340249180794,
-0.19313810765743256,
0.004511469043791294,
-0.1506955921649933,
0.030489038676023483,
0.16045479476451874,
-0.7370038628578186,
0.1294214427471161,
-0.5758575201034546,
0.26481956243515015,
0.6383962631225586,
-0.2638818919658661,
0.864272952079773,
-0.19927187263965607,
0.3408346176147461,
0.2696308493614197,
0.11115437746047974,
-0.3197186589241028,
-0.7723594903945923,
-0.3751450479030609,
-0.254893958568573,
0.20553697645664215,
0.4518628716468811,
-0.8843051791191101,
0.2405233532190323,
-0.3202228844165802,
-0.6214781403541565,
-0.8160989880561829,
0.2801534831523895,
0.5047609210014343,
0.249842569231987,
0.6155886054039001,
-0.25434380769729614,
-0.08745615184307098,
-0.8014635443687439,
-0.2838536202907562,
-0.3052527606487274,
0.05466390773653984,
-0.47874465584754944,
0.2724689841270447,
0.11219783127307892,
0.3700401484966278,
-0.313189297914505,
-0.2862805426120758,
-0.3984021842479706,
0.5649358034133911,
0.5972782969474792,
0.4074919521808624,
0.5482742190361023,
-0.7441962957382202,
-0.8517648577690125,
0.39789795875549316,
-0.624954342842102,
-0.169411763548851,
-0.13674865663051605,
-0.490212619304657,
0.2538526654243469,
0.2417031079530716,
-0.5603242516517639,
0.31958505511283875,
0.6068207025527954,
-0.1482456475496292,
0.03564908355474472,
-0.2687057852745056,
0.39071911573410034,
-1.0291990041732788,
-0.11808674037456512,
-0.17931023240089417,
-0.20416854321956635,
-0.8485581278800964,
0.4033780097961426,
0.3434896469116211,
-0.2026601880788803,
-0.5333465337753296,
0.3820838928222656,
-0.916916012763977,
-0.2143300324678421,
-0.03434254601597786,
0.37320035696029663,
0.17717896401882172,
0.5633788108825684,
-0.03067800961434841,
0.3277912735939026,
0.6323140263557434,
-0.412254273891449,
0.5249266028404236,
0.31418031454086304,
-0.40891656279563904,
0.6710371375083923,
-0.22583413124084473,
0.19419646263122559,
-0.34674516320228577,
0.3102002739906311,
-1.1366016864776611,
-0.2134639471769333,
0.10412406921386719,
-0.6413004994392395,
1.1095679998397827,
-0.17183180153369904,
-0.32963523268699646,
-0.28586432337760925,
-0.33847576379776,
0.2484281361103058,
0.3517720103263855,
-0.3283790647983551,
0.41576579213142395,
0.32450053095817566,
-0.33103233575820923,
-0.733793318271637,
-1.143811821937561,
0.19828997552394867,
0.2694817781448364,
-0.6253734827041626,
0.5983821153640747,
0.11205586045980453,
0.013409951701760292,
0.029141152277588844,
-0.1688382923603058,
-0.27607497572898865,
0.004148443695157766,
-0.43128082156181335,
0.40598347783088684,
-0.14471983909606934,
0.060952939093112946,
0.5303312540054321,
-0.13548217713832855,
-0.6658579707145691,
-0.4297797381877899,
0.5065674185752869,
-0.24901829659938812,
-0.5815763473510742,
-0.16123440861701965,
0.6365117430686951,
0.6861165165901184,
-0.21188296377658844,
0.8260459303855896,
0.7388829588890076,
-0.2336108684539795,
-0.35849693417549133,
-0.5256050229072571,
-0.15477825701236725,
-0.4122547507286072,
0.7115610241889954,
-0.4063931107521057,
-0.4827088713645935,
0.3584737181663513,
0.19032855331897736,
0.44134122133255005,
0.2856438457965851,
0.6998387575149536,
-0.39386942982673645,
1.3676077127456665,
0.24115097522735596,
-0.04438678175210953,
0.38254112005233765,
-0.13966473937034607,
0.637926459312439,
-0.5432094931602478,
-0.32050633430480957,
-0.6479688882827759,
-0.9990526437759399,
-0.5967816114425659,
-0.3024806082248688,
0.7072454690933228,
0.24914239346981049,
-0.2235405147075653,
0.6494616866111755,
-0.588076651096344,
0.418340265750885,
0.5963389277458191,
0.12000586092472076,
0.24270984530448914,
0.17611733078956604,
-0.08769486844539642,
0.23734767735004425,
-0.7509903311729431,
-0.085244320333004,
0.8528032898902893,
-0.08761398494243622,
0.5794682502746582,
0.5247176885604858,
1.1924537420272827,
0.05193231254816055,
0.08975774049758911,
-0.8511313796043396,
0.41720137000083923,
-0.1624811738729477,
-1.0978376865386963,
-0.6309433579444885,
-0.5964466333389282,
-1.0550086498260498,
0.54587322473526,
-0.1997711956501007,
-0.42068806290626526,
0.2680444121360779,
-0.03782748803496361,
-0.4416528642177582,
0.5110885500907898,
-0.7014948129653931,
0.6856701970100403,
-0.5240350365638733,
-0.5981569290161133,
-0.3427896201610565,
-0.8079895973205566,
0.01832420937716961,
-0.20583222806453705,
0.5036502480506897,
-0.1276901662349701,
0.01758440025150776,
0.21119944751262665,
-0.14104412496089935,
0.5129784941673279,
-0.3666912019252777,
0.12339036911725998,
0.11968954652547836,
0.6386606097221375,
0.5261508226394653,
-0.48380592465400696,
-0.27451378107070923,
0.48138242959976196,
0.23033510148525238,
-0.7914320826530457,
-0.5535687804222107,
0.46600207686424255,
-0.5724548101425171,
-0.6613191366195679,
-0.3070715367794037,
-0.4191068112850189,
-0.13452664017677307,
0.25615233182907104,
0.2963927090167999,
0.3262077867984772,
0.014102078042924404,
0.44318056106567383,
0.20875631272792816,
-0.043682537972927094,
0.6549393534660339,
0.8167677521705627,
-0.4652450382709503,
-0.17593006789684296,
0.9574770331382751,
0.3710551857948303,
0.21619680523872375,
0.8012039065361023,
0.08655375987291336,
-0.3237917721271515,
-0.7343562841415405,
-1.2431237697601318,
-0.06056968495249748,
-0.33927080035209656,
-0.4916245937347412,
-0.263500452041626,
0.12523525953292847,
-0.5938636064529419,
-0.4254983067512512,
-0.3036850392818451,
-0.3791048526763916,
0.15656521916389465,
-0.22650720179080963,
-0.0551065094769001,
0.7785892486572266,
-0.3257957398891449,
-0.039313044399023056,
-1.255537748336792,
0.0883200615644455,
0.014027555473148823,
0.25108733773231506,
-0.3285341262817383,
-0.8111931681632996,
-0.53474360704422,
0.14695940911769867,
-0.5322846174240112,
-1.3825922012329102,
0.6928257346153259,
0.43067121505737305,
0.8672550320625305,
0.2800697386264801,
0.07780966907739639,
0.806330680847168,
-0.6543564200401306,
0.7644316554069519,
0.61235111951828,
-1.050087571144104,
0.37274476885795593,
-0.23211845755577087,
0.10506762564182281,
0.5953029990196228,
0.26991361379623413,
-0.4704906642436981,
-0.4775596261024475,
-0.15704192221164703,
-0.842321515083313,
0.9051980972290039,
0.07651383429765701,
0.14862075448036194,
-0.10343074053525925,
-0.033938921988010406,
0.027760321274399757,
0.4453567564487457,
-0.5778260827064514,
-0.013182951137423515,
-0.04192695394158363,
-0.3202578127384186,
-0.22758400440216064,
0.19030936062335968,
0.16320936381816864,
-0.07347407191991806,
0.8322381973266602,
0.021196825429797173,
0.23278316855430603,
0.16651926934719086,
-0.3398248255252838,
-0.652824878692627,
0.23750774562358856,
0.2825694680213928,
0.048374611884355545,
-0.13319315016269684,
0.16150589287281036,
0.2882096767425537,
-0.06855592876672745,
0.3759550154209137,
-0.08466490358114243,
-0.40372347831726074,
0.2572457194328308,
0.36511585116386414,
0.7859770059585571,
0.4959442615509033,
-0.34932759404182434,
0.5408567190170288,
0.5880265831947327,
-0.2707532048225403,
0.12333295494318008,
-0.3621765673160553,
-0.1135675311088562,
0.3727447986602783,
0.4437892735004425,
0.17572322487831116,
0.39186757802963257,
-0.8954712748527527,
0.06371281296014786,
0.3131101131439209,
-0.38174352049827576,
-0.47730356454849243,
0.4925670623779297,
0.4068523049354553,
-0.4001935124397278,
0.42969396710395813,
-0.5129426717758179,
-0.44035959243774414,
0.34734073281288147,
0.35542231798171997,
1.0189985036849976,
-0.6854705214500427,
0.38502082228660583,
0.3999774158000946,
0.4830962121486664,
-0.30511465668678284,
0.054322272539138794,
-0.1529792696237564,
-0.765771210193634,
-0.5697758197784424,
-0.7163721919059753,
-0.4548521339893341,
-0.48713114857673645,
-0.6945464015007019,
0.4813764691352844,
0.028031399473547935,
0.042614199221134186,
-0.23007714748382568,
-0.11923597007989883,
-0.5792113542556763,
-0.3166472613811493,
0.5898705124855042,
0.5817368626594543,
-0.7171006798744202,
0.7544106245040894,
0.6937797665596008,
-0.5079219937324524,
-0.4945628345012665,
-0.08525400608778,
0.21216540038585663,
-0.805594265460968,
0.5977585911750793,
0.09430985152721405,
-0.31790176033973694,
0.08818904310464859,
-0.43545860052108765,
-0.7574265599250793,
1.1259911060333252,
0.4594544470310211,
-0.9717999696731567,
-0.2029077559709549,
-0.004569338168948889,
0.4915652275085449,
0.08608297258615494,
0.410459041595459,
0.23183901607990265,
0.6169289350509644,
0.2582997977733612,
-1.1333180665969849,
-0.39167165756225586,
-0.31042951345443726,
-0.1777796447277069,
0.4848359525203705,
-0.7753877639770508,
1.029494047164917,
-0.07799974828958511,
-0.40822768211364746,
-0.16092531383037567,
0.49374479055404663,
-0.029662223532795906,
0.5673601627349854,
0.2343970388174057,
0.37018364667892456,
0.7570174932479858,
-0.006228042300790548,
0.8844205737113953,
-0.695393979549408,
0.49089759588241577,
0.9201584458351135,
-0.7764223217964172,
1.0097157955169678,
0.6175360083580017,
-0.19915364682674408,
0.5023488402366638,
0.49634361267089844,
0.11479419469833374,
0.7710758447647095,
0.012734636664390564,
-0.3168725371360779,
-0.48132064938545227,
0.3130881190299988,
-0.21667563915252686,
0.4414999186992645,
0.2299310714006424,
-0.20226922631263733,
-0.43682295083999634,
-0.20943482220172882,
-0.16831687092781067,
0.029960837215185165,
-0.3450499475002289,
0.6529245376586914,
0.12156917154788971,
-0.7246127128601074,
0.4356496334075928,
0.15341567993164062,
0.5156911611557007,
-0.5338841676712036,
-0.05698496103286743,
-0.25705549120903015,
0.12421279400587082,
-0.11178798228502274,
-0.8578459620475769,
0.49623769521713257,
-0.04907860606908798,
0.07545492798089981,
-0.5218068361282349,
0.397705614566803,
-0.6472516655921936,
-0.7044440507888794,
0.6748847961425781,
1.0436699390411377,
0.44324854016304016,
0.029644344002008438,
-0.6526250243186951,
-0.2735740840435028,
0.07473436743021011,
-0.45000067353248596,
0.461335152387619,
0.7278534173965454,
0.34540456533432007,
0.2634905278682709,
0.5439860224723816,
0.3468055725097656,
0.3157665729522705,
-0.18420195579528809,
0.391163170337677,
-0.39393725991249084,
-0.2697151303291321,
-0.8336982727050781,
0.44294029474258423,
-0.035055436193943024,
-0.011152477003633976,
0.430656760931015,
0.4615193009376526,
1.1830300092697144,
-0.06829437613487244,
0.7618817090988159,
-0.09122336655855179,
0.5150357484817505,
-0.44751185178756714,
0.7046201825141907,
-0.7348763346672058,
-0.14928030967712402,
-0.15620262920856476,
-1.0622941255569458,
-0.4992651343345642,
0.8583537936210632,
-0.322797954082489,
-0.12073830515146255,
0.7073420882225037,
0.9986559152603149,
-0.033184923231601715,
0.09931167215108871,
1.0485042333602905,
0.4530009329319,
0.13456538319587708,
0.6847370862960815,
0.6160656213760376,
-0.550003707408905,
0.8210700154304504,
-0.1770181655883789,
-0.37711888551712036,
-0.2675491273403168,
-0.6987777352333069,
-0.5955838561058044,
-0.5264338850975037,
0.04960789158940315,
0.07031034678220749,
0.0336519218981266,
1.1252343654632568,
0.6571382284164429,
-0.9908298254013062,
-0.36664867401123047,
-0.05933525785803795,
-0.1385338306427002,
-0.28750357031822205,
-0.08007023483514786,
-0.13121524453163147,
-0.775583803653717,
-1.2272266149520874,
0.842350423336029,
0.5174731612205505,
-0.2630639672279358,
-0.2594744563102722,
-0.14155437052249908,
-0.27871695160865784,
0.02884450927376747,
0.5467444062232971,
-0.004116234835237265,
-0.5923123955726624,
-0.1473502814769745,
0.26652947068214417,
-0.037348221987485886,
-0.16807042062282562,
0.534212589263916,
-0.2428785264492035,
0.8705695867538452,
0.8259596824645996,
0.4692537486553192,
0.7707958817481995,
-0.4766709506511688,
0.5915482640266418,
-0.5564906001091003,
0.191136434674263,
0.16706563532352448,
0.6591156721115112,
0.0942334309220314,
-0.1528780162334442,
0.47571679949760437,
0.35976964235305786,
-0.3896804451942444,
-0.7994900941848755,
0.13612598180770874,
-0.6737011075019836,
-0.4467093348503113,
0.8906329274177551,
-0.2932141125202179,
-0.22375094890594482,
-0.27798837423324585,
-0.09407876431941986,
0.5839976072311401,
-0.48863765597343445,
0.9064069986343384,
0.6334841847419739,
0.0649867057800293,
0.03137216717004776,
-0.5828836560249329,
-0.2058759182691574,
0.6513660550117493,
-0.08785749971866608,
-0.20123131573200226,
0.44775888323783875,
-0.2487175166606903,
0.41249990463256836,
0.37709060311317444,
-0.22520236670970917,
0.11519887298345566,
0.08992387354373932,
0.33080315589904785,
-0.09980619698762894,
-0.5677394270896912,
-0.3007435202598572,
0.254055917263031,
-0.15650537610054016,
-0.17472243309020996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00141v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00141v1
|
EROS: Entity-Driven Controlled Policy Document Summarization
| 2024-02-29T21:44:50 | 2024-02-29T21:44:50 |
Joykirat Singh, Sehban Fazili, Rohan Jain, Md Shad Akhtar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Privacy policy documents have a crucial role in educating individuals about
the collection, usage, and protection of users' personal data by organizations.
However, they are notorious for their lengthy, complex, and convoluted language
especially involving privacy-related entities. Hence, they pose a significant
challenge to users who attempt to comprehend organization's data usage policy.
In this paper, we propose to enhance the interpretability and readability of
policy documents by using controlled abstractive summarization -- we enforce
the generated summaries to include critical privacy-related entities (e.g.,
data and medium) and organization's rationale (e.g.,target and reason) in
collecting those entities. To achieve this, we develop PD-Sum, a
policy-document summarization dataset with marked privacy-related entity
labels. Our proposed model, EROS, identifies critical entities through a
span-based entity extraction model and employs them to control the information
content of the summaries using proximal policy optimization (PPO). Comparison
shows encouraging improvement over various baselines. Furthermore, we furnish
qualitative and human evaluations to establish the efficacy of EROS.
|
[
-0.48206669092178345,
-0.5368337631225586,
0.2835347652435303,
0.16728349030017853,
-0.27566638588905334,
0.0491657517850399,
-0.11227288097143173,
-0.48795169591903687,
0.5564776062965393,
0.8145173192024231,
-0.4058208465576172,
-0.6771535873413086,
-0.2285478264093399,
0.22756849229335785,
-0.30353111028671265,
1.637306571006775,
-0.22388453781604767,
-0.5014665126800537,
0.24440260231494904,
0.22232824563980103,
0.17330710589885712,
0.011575008742511272,
-0.45356500148773193,
-0.12076166272163391,
0.20112957060337067,
0.4313788115978241,
0.8364461660385132,
0.794957160949707,
0.47932788729667664,
0.25246962904930115,
-0.3953905403614044,
0.29010194540023804,
-0.48804521560668945,
0.1095251515507698,
-0.2589159607887268,
-0.3465083837509155,
-0.9983707070350647,
-0.28503984212875366,
0.8234943747520447,
0.5067324638366699,
-0.5192216038703918,
-0.05907948687672615,
0.27510425448417664,
0.5130935311317444,
-0.6299773454666138,
0.06266187876462936,
-0.3704194724559784,
0.17171593010425568,
0.06475034356117249,
-0.19869931042194366,
-0.3290861248970032,
-0.36044222116470337,
0.36929890513420105,
-1.0217468738555908,
0.035341694951057434,
0.2477637529373169,
0.977081298828125,
-0.04168180376291275,
-0.22417418658733368,
-0.32085269689559937,
-0.6775349378585815,
0.6843323707580566,
-0.46232911944389343,
0.3126778304576874,
0.4875357151031494,
-0.14651571214199066,
-0.12013387680053711,
-0.6869269013404846,
-0.5328158736228943,
0.07557639479637146,
-0.17765845358371735,
0.20388981699943542,
-0.19295848906040192,
0.39715826511383057,
0.044086284935474396,
0.2865856885910034,
-0.4440407454967499,
0.21630993485450745,
-0.3521597683429718,
-0.26187267899513245,
0.60667884349823,
0.2608288824558258,
0.22468353807926178,
-0.047579411417245865,
-0.185151144862175,
0.23391787707805634,
-0.5805590748786926,
-0.16031071543693542,
0.6516249179840088,
-0.07635612785816193,
-0.18415379524230957,
0.7121140956878662,
-0.3897346556186676,
0.48558059334754944,
-0.11814238131046295,
-0.32082363963127136,
0.18175165355205536,
-0.09532386809587479,
-0.45064640045166016,
-0.006652155891060829,
0.486707866191864,
0.6420619487762451,
0.36683163046836853,
-0.41325643658638,
-0.24973711371421814,
-0.5274094343185425,
0.22736263275146484,
-0.7794209122657776,
-0.14169400930404663,
0.4109402000904083,
-0.46812906861305237,
-0.5527355670928955,
0.14289894700050354,
-1.110403299331665,
-0.16350550949573517,
-0.38953131437301636,
-0.2404106855392456,
-0.2661542296409607,
-0.19115066528320312,
-0.11099322140216827,
-0.19580981135368347,
-0.14048351347446442,
0.5675807595252991,
-1.0275707244873047,
0.6753216981887817,
0.7414291501045227,
0.8866720795631409,
-0.22532698512077332,
-0.2836053967475891,
0.019910497590899467,
0.7432040572166443,
-0.24173066020011902,
0.3560488522052765,
-0.6827678084373474,
-0.7035713195800781,
0.07745330035686493,
-0.109970323741436,
0.008907701820135117,
-0.33691662549972534,
0.36432477831840515,
-0.618320107460022,
0.26814571022987366,
-0.12048783153295517,
-0.3797997832298279,
-0.1699308305978775,
0.3046582043170929,
-0.5740359425544739,
0.4651196300983429,
0.13107016682624817,
-0.6270043253898621,
0.5761898159980774,
-0.9108353853225708,
-0.5030258297920227,
0.04044192656874657,
-0.3195982873439789,
-0.5744762420654297,
0.08538622409105301,
0.1469113677740097,
0.40344342589378357,
-0.1633266657590866,
0.31472745537757874,
-0.17676608264446259,
-0.00545845041051507,
0.25206607580184937,
0.08273176103830338,
0.631935715675354,
0.5018420219421387,
-0.19087207317352295,
0.1951514333486557,
-0.8840630650520325,
-0.0667966827750206,
-0.0008388313581235707,
-0.45896151661872864,
-0.46086499094963074,
0.05895209312438965,
-0.1584070473909378,
-0.3068484663963318,
0.35869890451431274,
-0.13645507395267487,
-0.2883108854293823,
-0.22471702098846436,
0.3277808725833893,
0.9063597917556763,
0.30514630675315857,
0.9141516089439392,
-0.18905070424079895,
0.5698361992835999,
-0.09729306399822235,
0.31026601791381836,
-0.40185436606407166,
-0.23817139863967896,
-0.1864822655916214,
-0.6128320097923279,
0.07847080379724503,
0.6388645172119141,
-0.3805989623069763,
0.6529565453529358,
-0.3743162453174591,
-0.16027235984802246,
0.03279688581824303,
0.039353255182504654,
0.3488183617591858,
0.8413530588150024,
0.11282028257846832,
-0.29715409874916077,
-0.1503056287765503,
-0.883021354675293,
-0.2583561837673187,
-0.22666232287883759,
-0.28427278995513916,
0.47539547085762024,
0.6820029020309448,
0.01149018295109272,
0.8362793922424316,
-0.7171512842178345,
-0.32784876227378845,
-0.24858611822128296,
0.05196944251656532,
-0.10178611427545547,
0.38996946811676025,
0.1438877433538437,
-1.0619568824768066,
-0.14542602002620697,
-0.03447413817048073,
-0.8293072581291199,
-0.06730842590332031,
-0.21249061822891235,
-0.09621383249759674,
-0.002583664609119296,
0.05124412477016449,
-0.365910142660141,
0.2482394576072693,
-0.06545968353748322,
-0.40497684478759766,
0.447184294462204,
-0.5436137914657593,
0.09462133795022964,
-0.8114244937896729,
0.07661981135606766,
0.045502930879592896,
-0.36058494448661804,
-0.6101164817810059,
0.1845841407775879,
0.04936440289020538,
-0.4954870939254761,
-0.3427903354167938,
-0.054918818175792694,
-0.4872446358203888,
-0.10153283178806305,
-0.04469508305191994,
0.26288750767707825,
0.04979431629180908,
0.4599010646343231,
0.2113334834575653,
0.6778798699378967,
0.4135030210018158,
-0.9426652193069458,
-0.04130368307232857,
0.32873281836509705,
0.03594352677464485,
0.8148221969604492,
-0.7771235704421997,
0.05248453840613365,
-0.3466385304927826,
0.2880714535713196,
-0.306039959192276,
-0.5941046476364136,
0.3475261628627777,
-0.011356680653989315,
0.5430458188056946,
0.18576441705226898,
-0.4138573706150055,
0.07036656141281128,
-0.6589679718017578,
-0.30481746792793274,
0.1036444827914238,
-0.24888640642166138,
0.8667421340942383,
1.1129083633422852,
-0.3390878736972809,
-0.7000331282615662,
-0.686011552810669,
0.11227831244468689,
-0.5271627306938171,
-0.4407966434955597,
0.534125566482544,
0.5034696459770203,
-0.41468822956085205,
0.30777907371520996,
-0.20529510080814362,
-0.05716684088110924,
0.2096443474292755,
0.2516228258609772,
0.2730099558830261,
0.29216283559799194,
0.0561378076672554,
0.5064781904220581,
-0.12375364452600479,
0.11241503804922104,
-0.17713981866836548,
0.2411738485097885,
-0.3343730866909027,
0.1610872894525528,
-0.43190696835517883,
0.6001379489898682,
0.5111149549484253,
-0.25282788276672363,
0.7584035992622375,
-0.06870173662900925,
-0.6430107355117798,
-0.12846918404102325,
-0.0909983292222023,
-0.11152750998735428,
-0.3995993733406067,
0.32516393065452576,
-0.49269577860832214,
-0.6533435583114624,
0.8340798020362854,
-0.3274501860141754,
0.46350571513175964,
0.1971883475780487,
0.2813061773777008,
-0.14009413123130798,
0.7176206111907959,
0.7028098106384277,
-0.13688482344150543,
0.567375659942627,
-0.3085384666919708,
0.04452739655971527,
-0.8922800421714783,
-0.5265750288963318,
-0.3876585364341736,
-0.08581554889678955,
-0.7413133978843689,
0.28046345710754395,
0.3690330386161804,
0.12150271981954575,
-0.13288229703903198,
0.5352053046226501,
-0.5662141442298889,
0.5992458462715149,
0.01650412753224373,
0.39237216114997864,
0.3986898362636566,
0.06567880511283875,
0.2938576936721802,
0.09021525830030441,
-0.21367256343364716,
-0.9582267999649048,
1.2155684232711792,
0.7401350140571594,
1.0060673952102661,
0.38003385066986084,
1.061758279800415,
0.4525373578071594,
0.1782330572605133,
-0.2658037543296814,
0.7248706221580505,
0.03868979588150978,
-0.6139177083969116,
-0.5958253741264343,
-0.5275031328201294,
-0.7280300259590149,
0.44289833307266235,
-0.12985196709632874,
-1.1998116970062256,
0.6063756942749023,
0.3541712462902069,
-0.36398932337760925,
-0.029494306072592735,
-0.7183699607849121,
0.5466068983078003,
-0.07539427280426025,
-0.41319701075553894,
-0.31728172302246094,
-0.6421266794204712,
0.23067869246006012,
-0.1015707328915596,
0.17784501612186432,
0.08350332081317902,
-0.6436052918434143,
0.9843623042106628,
-0.6294114589691162,
0.5978400707244873,
-0.05941900983452797,
-0.001855942071415484,
0.35146716237068176,
-0.08893556892871857,
0.8501771092414856,
0.24396111071109772,
0.23546580970287323,
0.025303322821855545,
-0.2575373351573944,
-0.2033219337463379,
-0.30741798877716064,
0.7372344136238098,
-0.4165268838405609,
-0.27431976795196533,
-0.2687176465988159,
-0.4743807315826416,
-0.056976567953825,
0.55644291639328,
0.233115091919899,
0.1391517072916031,
-0.33382508158683777,
-0.03912106156349182,
1.101887822151184,
-0.0954953134059906,
0.19825522601604462,
0.6753682494163513,
-0.26912564039230347,
-0.3758811056613922,
0.8887161016464233,
0.45639052987098694,
0.07114476710557938,
0.48705920577049255,
0.06653404980897903,
-0.3939061164855957,
-0.6052539944648743,
-0.23209290206432343,
0.17714723944664001,
-0.6530252695083618,
0.05814921110868454,
-0.8297911882400513,
0.4693179428577423,
-0.5591598153114319,
-0.2453749179840088,
0.015964969992637634,
-0.5234552025794983,
-0.5452685356140137,
-0.37693244218826294,
-0.000240060398937203,
0.3998839259147644,
-0.1368032544851303,
0.43539664149284363,
-0.26863813400268555,
0.6320210695266724,
0.0853092223405838,
0.3026207685470581,
-0.3843477666378021,
-0.2512862980365753,
0.10043219476938248,
-0.3282197415828705,
-0.1416255086660385,
-1.3789088726043701,
0.31607216596603394,
0.17945821583271027,
0.3701382875442505,
0.6939405798912048,
0.03721208497881889,
0.3705849051475525,
-0.34674420952796936,
0.35609009861946106,
0.1993466168642044,
-0.840756356716156,
0.6735540628433228,
-0.24063004553318024,
-0.3347349166870117,
0.7116233110427856,
0.38193845748901367,
-0.0667419582605362,
-0.4114735722541809,
-0.7112162113189697,
-1.2060989141464233,
0.7139006853103638,
0.2978905141353607,
0.12989124655723572,
0.07322054356336594,
0.25262826681137085,
-0.1701015830039978,
0.4622909128665924,
-0.3787827789783478,
-0.21002531051635742,
0.06530271470546722,
-0.11450597643852234,
0.4692077934741974,
-0.34846463799476624,
-0.4243031442165375,
0.49234122037887573,
0.8667580485343933,
0.20776396989822388,
0.04113795608282089,
0.29202550649642944,
-0.12288564443588257,
-0.08175303041934967,
0.6196079254150391,
0.5469564199447632,
0.9383970499038696,
-0.3878794312477112,
0.022557521238923073,
0.062097638845443726,
-0.7543330192565918,
-0.26157456636428833,
0.36345118284225464,
-0.9048037528991699,
0.09191212058067322,
-0.18245595693588257,
0.5506327152252197,
0.03355882316827774,
-0.6144838929176331,
0.241136372089386,
0.010035068728029728,
0.05475040525197983,
-0.5550693869590759,
0.05401802062988281,
-0.31776270270347595,
0.05155517905950546,
0.2013133466243744,
-0.3621804118156433,
0.5972414016723633,
-0.4701392948627472,
0.08047321438789368,
0.06581206619739532,
-0.13314414024353027,
-0.06278260797262192,
0.8264766335487366,
0.37030038237571716,
-0.21152691543102264,
0.3454582393169403,
-0.11174654960632324,
-0.27976900339126587,
0.5444715023040771,
0.5083619356155396,
0.7113009691238403,
-0.15346936881542206,
0.3622652292251587,
-0.029938403517007828,
0.5865236520767212,
-0.00683238822966814,
0.4878624379634857,
-0.42812076210975647,
-0.5164670348167419,
-0.1216128021478653,
-0.147385373711586,
-0.5874561667442322,
0.13633818924427032,
-0.9105737209320068,
0.1375473141670227,
-0.7200368642807007,
-0.1334955394268036,
0.16796253621578217,
-0.1978575438261032,
-0.3939453661441803,
0.2596544921398163,
-0.2590717673301697,
0.8396334648132324,
-0.8567836880683899,
0.21120961010456085,
0.5209124088287354,
-0.5344861149787903,
-0.6029871106147766,
-0.15411025285720825,
0.1157744899392128,
-0.5864956974983215,
0.09667830914258957,
-0.11300134658813477,
0.10092385113239288,
-0.14236576855182648,
-0.27392712235450745,
-0.255090594291687,
1.1096203327178955,
0.3159836232662201,
-0.8616970181465149,
-0.2727121412754059,
-0.0595548041164875,
0.48834094405174255,
-0.2956966459751129,
-0.0005553039954975247,
0.7835312485694885,
0.3734506070613861,
-0.4022153913974762,
-0.7562494277954102,
0.11233175545930862,
-0.010160653851926327,
-0.12717582285404205,
0.4650096595287323,
-0.28232428431510925,
0.46361613273620605,
-0.46090370416641235,
-0.25848591327667236,
-0.4456785321235657,
1.0078445672988892,
0.05899694189429283,
0.748171329498291,
0.37324607372283936,
0.6422573924064636,
1.041558027267456,
0.012669648975133896,
1.3134702444076538,
-0.12437450140714645,
0.29004526138305664,
1.3705651760101318,
-0.3023327887058258,
0.4159437119960785,
0.4599684178829193,
-0.2360268235206604,
0.14834745228290558,
0.46203041076660156,
0.24104730784893036,
0.6303759813308716,
0.12220562994480133,
-0.6351467370986938,
0.31688791513442993,
-0.37547433376312256,
-0.19037120044231415,
0.039375968277454376,
0.4917598068714142,
-0.9763918519020081,
-0.2012196183204651,
-0.10796824097633362,
0.3789282739162445,
0.22094056010246277,
-0.44219228625297546,
1.0327064990997314,
0.05790148302912712,
-0.5771397948265076,
-0.22136835753917694,
0.23190201818943024,
0.19020085036754608,
-0.5457518696784973,
0.04403822124004364,
0.13360749185085297,
-0.011418613605201244,
-0.524974524974823,
-1.0268487930297852,
0.49879229068756104,
0.4638730585575104,
-0.15326309204101562,
-0.30529505014419556,
0.803514838218689,
-0.2515822649002075,
0.09415880590677261,
-0.14922581613063812,
0.09679974615573883,
0.5623688697814941,
0.11140475422143936,
-0.7154767513275146,
-0.3195274770259857,
0.023182542994618416,
-0.5529631972312927,
0.15151222050189972,
0.28664398193359375,
-0.2556957006454468,
0.4511811137199402,
0.5176416635513306,
0.5278134346008301,
-0.2431720793247223,
0.11344095319509506,
0.93119877576828,
-0.09710199385881424,
-1.1287996768951416,
-0.8119635581970215,
0.33740565180778503,
-0.5324477553367615,
-0.46073591709136963,
0.33167389035224915,
0.7463936805725098,
0.8108289837837219,
0.1479749083518982,
0.8005224466323853,
-0.2849411070346832,
0.6788205504417419,
-0.5008655190467834,
0.6377074122428894,
-0.0038675074465572834,
0.3873527944087982,
-0.08954541385173798,
-0.8985113501548767,
-0.21570318937301636,
0.6107320189476013,
-0.476222425699234,
-0.18785296380519867,
0.23551933467388153,
0.8182306885719299,
0.20168602466583252,
0.0672178789973259,
0.028928251937031746,
-0.12221688777208328,
0.4695182740688324,
0.17656953632831573,
0.2186446636915207,
-0.10675794631242752,
0.5697809457778931,
-0.4616684317588806,
-0.5030850768089294,
0.011193718761205673,
-0.8324946761131287,
-0.6473610997200012,
-0.35540249943733215,
-0.46535781025886536,
-0.35446998476982117,
0.1984417885541916,
0.5407636165618896,
0.48416125774383545,
-0.7238219976425171,
0.1365991085767746,
-0.5110716819763184,
0.45913854241371155,
-0.054429974406957626,
-0.28618231415748596,
0.385860800743103,
0.049896277487277985,
-0.7056407928466797,
-0.08898404985666275,
0.6398888230323792,
0.24478453397750854,
-0.05386793613433838,
-0.23294122517108917,
0.30827486515045166,
-0.07722217589616776,
0.20908278226852417,
0.7348775863647461,
-0.43818092346191406,
0.14071474969387054,
-0.13474725186824799,
0.023809555917978287,
-0.3958044946193695,
0.9412283301353455,
-0.17425543069839478,
0.6093975901603699,
0.6196280717849731,
0.42857903242111206,
0.4544372856616974,
0.22329416871070862,
0.43676015734672546,
-0.4152536988258362,
-0.19592252373695374,
0.34108513593673706,
0.49532681703567505,
0.05018819868564606,
-0.806814432144165,
0.578729510307312,
-0.2164422571659088,
-0.4379870295524597,
-0.9261322617530823,
0.23081684112548828,
-0.9082174301147461,
-0.12394919991493225,
0.9012821912765503,
-0.6156275868415833,
-0.3794713020324707,
-0.26880714297294617,
-0.10865385085344315,
0.2761012613773346,
-0.8766798377037048,
0.8436567187309265,
0.2541566491127014,
-0.16126687824726105,
-0.1920616775751114,
-0.1935444176197052,
0.2710933983325958,
0.07371982932090759,
-1.1275913715362549,
0.11676908284425735,
0.6480152606964111,
0.179058238863945,
0.3949848711490631,
0.8510408997535706,
-0.5426728129386902,
0.1722833514213562,
-0.22799250483512878,
-0.20105168223381042,
-0.343505859375,
-0.7193735241889954,
-0.3532184362411499,
0.2554566264152527,
-0.3653102219104767,
-0.4504074156284332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00127v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00127v2
|
Prompting ChatGPT for Translation: A Comparative Analysis of Translation Brief and Persona Prompts
| 2024-02-29T21:05:38 | 2024-04-28T09:45:58 |
Sui He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC
|
Prompt engineering has shown potential for improving translation quality in
LLMs. However, the possibility of using translation concepts in prompt design
remains largely underexplored. Against this backdrop, the current paper
discusses the effectiveness of incorporating the conceptual tool of translation
brief and the personas of translator and author into prompt design for
translation tasks in ChatGPT. Findings suggest that, although certain elements
are constructive in facilitating human-to-human communication for translation
tasks, their effectiveness is limited for improving translation quality in
ChatGPT. This accentuates the need for explorative research on how translation
theorists and practitioners can develop the current set of conceptual tools
rooted in the human-to-human communication paradigm for translation purposes in
this emerging workflow involving human-machine interaction, and how translation
concepts developed in translation studies can inform the training of GPT models
for translation tasks.
|
[
-0.3516367971897125,
-0.611314594745636,
0.9002028107643127,
0.501639187335968,
-0.4149545729160309,
0.3487897217273712,
0.007883868180215359,
-0.2910734713077545,
0.11104848235845566,
0.023467063903808594,
-0.764268159866333,
-0.1857766956090927,
-0.5092243552207947,
0.4983251988887787,
-0.33415094017982483,
0.7769762873649597,
-0.25791433453559875,
0.24501095712184906,
-0.1315956562757492,
0.1098916307091713,
-1.087698221206665,
-0.3928140699863434,
-0.9794180989265442,
-0.2841275632381439,
0.7387054562568665,
0.3359367549419403,
0.6478801369667053,
-0.013182966969907284,
0.5728484392166138,
0.21071146428585052,
-0.2594689130783081,
0.02119888924062252,
-0.18172980844974518,
0.4438192546367645,
-0.11563243716955185,
-0.5539388656616211,
-0.23819537460803986,
0.23072266578674316,
0.5939532518386841,
0.7086963653564453,
0.13413038849830627,
-0.03681137040257454,
0.4815755784511566,
0.5245184302330017,
-0.0022361651062965393,
0.2062854766845703,
-0.08412057161331177,
0.1293952316045761,
-0.1789560765028,
-0.4968372583389282,
-0.4797384738922119,
-0.4468976557254791,
0.15121042728424072,
-0.5973411202430725,
0.18731927871704102,
0.5833966135978699,
0.7500876784324646,
0.3447520434856415,
-0.5312334299087524,
-0.48496484756469727,
-0.4237050712108612,
0.4519611895084381,
-0.5614360570907593,
0.2907995283603668,
0.11847669631242752,
0.34584566950798035,
-0.3924190104007721,
-0.4555031359195709,
-0.4737727642059326,
-0.3303663432598114,
-0.3897075355052948,
0.31376031041145325,
-0.014014825224876404,
0.15311625599861145,
0.341249942779541,
0.34649357199668884,
-0.8534162044525146,
0.16458137333393097,
-0.22250314056873322,
-0.26132699847221375,
0.2652911841869354,
0.30437353253364563,
0.7522897124290466,
-0.39011916518211365,
-0.40046051144599915,
0.09526491910219193,
-0.9272926449775696,
0.25018349289894104,
0.15760032832622528,
0.3028143644332886,
-0.2177547961473465,
0.5180874466896057,
-0.08956637978553772,
0.4930708110332489,
0.12733596563339233,
-0.08077970892190933,
0.017693515866994858,
-0.5582991242408752,
0.11695712059736252,
-0.18856006860733032,
0.8542025089263916,
0.5164264440536499,
0.07468274980783463,
-0.33566346764564514,
-0.2825591266155243,
-0.09144333750009537,
0.20306867361068726,
-0.7237255573272705,
-0.16342858970165253,
0.1355827897787094,
-0.4154954254627228,
-0.2244265079498291,
-0.13401629030704498,
-0.5720082521438599,
-0.42582499980926514,
-0.5931035280227661,
0.1523093730211258,
-0.2537864148616791,
-0.06489893049001694,
-0.09150040149688721,
-0.30340227484703064,
0.6179758906364441,
0.5460997223854065,
-0.8539209365844727,
-0.16787035763263702,
0.596034824848175,
1.0529574155807495,
-0.5309217572212219,
-0.2624386250972748,
-0.476009339094162,
-0.19366507232189178,
-0.40583038330078125,
1.090025782585144,
-0.41223838925361633,
-1.1256388425827026,
0.039807628840208054,
-0.023255787789821625,
-0.23048537969589233,
-0.2693706452846527,
0.6395075917243958,
-0.37301456928253174,
0.47487950325012207,
-0.7706229090690613,
-0.317788302898407,
0.12200388312339783,
0.06709256768226624,
-0.3606133759021759,
0.8451314568519592,
0.2711639106273651,
-0.5820791125297546,
0.2614424228668213,
-0.7857632040977478,
-0.4013298749923706,
0.41970300674438477,
-0.41939809918403625,
0.1211063489317894,
0.2808884084224701,
0.44935548305511475,
0.32350587844848633,
-0.5849862694740295,
0.2738369405269623,
0.2787357568740845,
-0.35166120529174805,
0.6368082165718079,
-0.15917713940143585,
0.8174625039100647,
0.49758288264274597,
0.08200038224458694,
0.15150880813598633,
-0.0025889966636896133,
-0.29712721705436707,
0.08021374046802521,
-0.3414938449859619,
0.13745349645614624,
-0.2107831835746765,
-0.1861690878868103,
0.3032287657260895,
0.08824377506971359,
-0.2586264908313751,
0.3923153579235077,
-0.2867531478404999,
0.5508542656898499,
0.5415923595428467,
0.25877806544303894,
0.7738521695137024,
-0.382222443819046,
0.969504177570343,
-0.17816592752933502,
0.0597330667078495,
-0.5194867849349976,
-0.9214322566986084,
-0.577377200126648,
-0.06633683294057846,
0.2708932161331177,
0.7884004712104797,
-1.1862393617630005,
0.10668620467185974,
-0.2980377674102783,
-0.25666525959968567,
-0.658442497253418,
-0.04358850419521332,
0.378002405166626,
0.6889562606811523,
0.2457389086484909,
-0.44876375794410706,
-0.19996905326843262,
-0.6690607070922852,
-0.33759090304374695,
-0.3509927988052368,
-0.36701539158821106,
0.007768705487251282,
0.3095523416996002,
0.044717252254486084,
0.9741887450218201,
-0.28830763697624207,
-0.09790855646133423,
-0.3794917166233063,
0.28283730149269104,
0.3304504454135895,
0.48066475987434387,
0.7492955327033997,
-0.5338268876075745,
-0.8162783980369568,
-0.14488279819488525,
-0.6984050869941711,
-0.4836874008178711,
-0.29626592993736267,
-0.22998486459255219,
-0.45580199360847473,
0.5281186699867249,
-1.005457878112793,
0.2589418292045593,
0.09874844551086426,
-0.41800427436828613,
0.6946781277656555,
0.028762059286236763,
0.6478255391120911,
-1.1960915327072144,
0.07352760434150696,
-0.12368419021368027,
-0.23748521506786346,
-0.8356248736381531,
0.24229054152965546,
0.14222384989261627,
-0.427482932806015,
-0.6658892035484314,
0.7552277445793152,
-0.49128055572509766,
0.19561630487442017,
-0.329529345035553,
0.4503580629825592,
0.18265078961849213,
0.33474770188331604,
-0.15720294415950775,
1.500132441520691,
0.35017094016075134,
-0.7217932343482971,
0.4264257848262787,
0.7732071876525879,
-0.25182849168777466,
1.2613334655761719,
-0.8849768042564392,
0.2537190318107605,
-0.21428947150707245,
0.25138822197914124,
-1.2529792785644531,
-0.16988272964954376,
0.9488244652748108,
-0.7015007138252258,
0.38185563683509827,
-0.1738296002149582,
-0.5421693325042725,
-0.32170382142066956,
-0.08458906412124634,
0.22774863243103027,
0.9151101112365723,
-0.26163533329963684,
0.2527351677417755,
-0.05495919659733772,
-0.7786283493041992,
-0.03563937172293663,
-0.7010510563850403,
0.4221382141113281,
-0.35733017325401306,
-0.7667962908744812,
0.5697687268257141,
-0.3249678611755371,
-0.18858839571475983,
-0.39197883009910583,
-0.031221680343151093,
0.012804844416677952,
0.22807736694812775,
-0.11858230084180832,
0.23927749693393707,
-0.1558535248041153,
0.11448978632688522,
0.15696226060390472,
-0.4233987629413605,
0.24800153076648712,
-0.20178310573101044,
0.28695788979530334,
0.20009280741214752,
-0.32200416922569275,
-0.7162265777587891,
0.590304970741272,
0.22937895357608795,
-0.07536590844392776,
0.48977863788604736,
0.4622857868671417,
0.2486943155527115,
0.2888358533382416,
-0.5457897782325745,
-0.31594809889793396,
-0.48564156889915466,
-0.00760129326954484,
-0.5221230387687683,
-0.7402127385139465,
0.610630214214325,
-0.35593941807746887,
0.06339520961046219,
0.1830683797597885,
0.37914809584617615,
-0.39922747015953064,
0.8413950800895691,
0.47844061255455017,
-0.06588251143693924,
0.6703376770019531,
0.17032940685749054,
0.4157229959964752,
-1.144292950630188,
-0.1251962035894394,
-0.7195239663124084,
-0.391217976808548,
-0.18641836941242218,
-0.4815899133682251,
0.388470321893692,
-0.004483524244278669,
0.22999262809753418,
0.44760939478874207,
-0.39070555567741394,
0.30211350321769714,
0.46270909905433655,
-0.015586373396217823,
0.2623535692691803,
-0.14138862490653992,
-0.28854110836982727,
-0.2496315836906433,
-0.491923451423645,
-0.6898847222328186,
0.39870384335517883,
0.22497887909412384,
0.4925362765789032,
0.1069871187210083,
0.47117623686790466,
0.34459444880485535,
0.2617843747138977,
-0.8687117695808411,
0.6034074425697327,
0.5358858108520508,
-0.30287715792655945,
-0.05475381389260292,
-0.22360394895076752,
-1.046791434288025,
0.33930107951164246,
0.28245148062705994,
-0.7276772856712341,
0.22017072141170502,
0.11880200356245041,
-0.5148366093635559,
-0.2807145416736603,
-0.7549712061882019,
0.9247328639030457,
-0.21278047561645508,
-0.025003626942634583,
0.10552439093589783,
-0.7798700928688049,
-0.03187286853790283,
0.023923911154270172,
0.1131008192896843,
-0.12977959215641022,
-0.2571221590042114,
0.5310265421867371,
-0.14186345040798187,
0.8266856074333191,
-0.02656666748225689,
-0.5485204458236694,
0.322106271982193,
0.23381036520004272,
0.7113475799560547,
0.13587893545627594,
0.09087418764829636,
-0.3314986526966095,
-0.13532112538814545,
-0.4529099762439728,
-0.854053258895874,
0.2749165892601013,
-0.4244030714035034,
-0.9626464247703552,
-0.19731062650680542,
-0.5450173020362854,
-0.32834988832473755,
-0.03072783164680004,
0.5570665001869202,
0.1255529671907425,
-0.15882444381713867,
-0.14257891476154327,
0.7799546718597412,
-0.24968020617961884,
0.38514891266822815,
0.4836520850658417,
-0.1078961119055748,
-0.08632852882146835,
0.8025692105293274,
-0.305362343788147,
0.3484690189361572,
0.46248969435691833,
0.049147140234708786,
-0.3429780900478363,
-0.46660199761390686,
-0.6190185546875,
0.2733924984931946,
-0.8442986011505127,
-0.04115484282374382,
-0.35223472118377686,
-0.03526182100176811,
-0.4913826286792755,
-0.3438739478588104,
0.05236061289906502,
-0.34256887435913086,
-0.37548044323921204,
0.019468480721116066,
0.19524991512298584,
0.4274542033672333,
0.43209609389305115,
0.7421536445617676,
-0.797100841999054,
0.14138826727867126,
0.1827019602060318,
-0.28677013516426086,
-0.28368836641311646,
-0.8852539658546448,
0.050039131194353104,
0.056573331356048584,
-0.48106396198272705,
-1.1702011823654175,
0.24383163452148438,
-0.27137067914009094,
0.66126948595047,
0.14591892063617706,
-0.059351127594709396,
0.47550299763679504,
-0.5987124443054199,
1.229490041732788,
0.1990501880645752,
-0.8271045088768005,
0.6929888725280762,
-0.4106437861919403,
0.5068951845169067,
0.32839637994766235,
0.5051068067550659,
-1.181971788406372,
-0.3516212999820709,
-0.31955307722091675,
-0.5387089252471924,
0.4921877384185791,
0.44680455327033997,
0.27131569385528564,
0.10158383101224899,
0.45027613639831543,
0.13504114747047424,
0.431796669960022,
-0.4155103862285614,
-0.0733501985669136,
0.03412018343806267,
-0.09251022338867188,
-0.0004972433671355247,
-0.2636708617210388,
0.08879954367876053,
-0.028291387483477592,
0.5513538718223572,
-0.045331474393606186,
0.6383755207061768,
0.17426617443561554,
-0.16370810568332672,
0.3258220851421356,
0.5227115154266357,
0.6293087601661682,
0.5845393538475037,
0.3653229773044586,
-0.1633060723543167,
0.18052391707897186,
-0.26238173246383667,
0.4134052097797394,
-0.17929749190807343,
-0.5104174017906189,
0.20540077984333038,
0.034223586320877075,
0.7531426548957825,
0.3292662799358368,
-0.13550637662410736,
0.5185925960540771,
-0.1119789108633995,
-0.048025649040937424,
0.035247400403022766,
0.055438775569200516,
0.13620106875896454,
0.18986238539218903,
0.0874718502163887,
-0.0029683029279112816,
0.17088495194911957,
-0.2616371810436249,
-0.26863256096839905,
0.3255123794078827,
-0.36118531227111816,
-0.5974467396736145,
0.7732095718383789,
0.7581964135169983,
-0.6388956904411316,
0.6594920754432678,
-0.3264342248439789,
-0.3755631446838379,
0.18050868809223175,
0.27986758947372437,
0.9930296540260315,
-0.4292282164096832,
0.42368683218955994,
0.16754049062728882,
0.2503284513950348,
-0.14947205781936646,
0.16451017558574677,
-0.2690333425998688,
-0.27125564217567444,
-0.561340868473053,
-0.11628439277410507,
-0.5576645731925964,
-0.35165873169898987,
-0.2601982355117798,
0.3442162275314331,
0.22421503067016602,
-0.21414397656917572,
-0.3538794219493866,
-0.37262311577796936,
-0.7931084036827087,
-0.4144268333911896,
-0.20557712018489838,
0.7938148379325867,
-0.587087094783783,
0.5655813813209534,
0.7426336407661438,
-0.6879574656486511,
-0.647497832775116,
0.01821151003241539,
0.19577805697917938,
-0.652057945728302,
0.5784037113189697,
-0.0858626440167427,
0.17153584957122803,
0.31056085228919983,
-0.366485595703125,
-0.5620220899581909,
0.9259395599365234,
0.41162624955177307,
-0.2618975341320038,
-0.5630791783332825,
0.3963806629180908,
0.23489798605442047,
-0.024011677131056786,
0.2048535943031311,
0.44856521487236023,
0.5733388066291809,
0.16234035789966583,
-1.11054265499115,
0.15966783463954926,
-0.2916467487812042,
0.1911085695028305,
0.09205374866724014,
-0.5272876620292664,
0.5441385507583618,
-0.00179981195833534,
-0.5405113697052002,
0.4541224539279938,
0.6794387698173523,
-0.016598736867308617,
0.060407042503356934,
-0.04750518500804901,
-0.08351772278547287,
0.7083789706230164,
-0.30371183156967163,
1.2056297063827515,
-0.2720630466938019,
-0.0077726393938064575,
0.7657115459442139,
-0.15046773850917816,
0.285444051027298,
0.7941792011260986,
-0.3623836934566498,
0.1677486151456833,
0.859055757522583,
0.17121602594852448,
0.5142784714698792,
-0.029044784605503082,
-0.4357464611530304,
-0.1397005170583725,
-0.37177419662475586,
-0.546024739742279,
-0.20016463100910187,
0.4116847515106201,
-0.282223105430603,
-0.19733840227127075,
0.30350106954574585,
-0.025046108290553093,
-0.06335915625095367,
0.017714733257889748,
0.6939878463745117,
0.6176789402961731,
-1.0816402435302734,
0.3127586543560028,
-0.03054220974445343,
0.5103393197059631,
-0.42922043800354004,
0.11351671069860458,
-0.565671980381012,
-0.4940342903137207,
0.11502119153738022,
-0.8608520030975342,
0.12312296777963638,
-0.17588411271572113,
0.08745955675840378,
-0.8628142476081848,
0.6193495392799377,
-0.13954032957553864,
0.010283122770488262,
-0.38141074776649475,
0.9779300093650818,
0.35341453552246094,
-0.2589651644229889,
-0.7101520895957947,
-0.08174862712621689,
-0.16281290352344513,
-0.13896413147449493,
0.22807340323925018,
0.7497690320014954,
0.13885778188705444,
0.7701125144958496,
0.44382885098457336,
-0.053034473210573196,
-0.05710645020008087,
0.13990211486816406,
0.8545608520507812,
-0.6517861485481262,
-0.6148217916488647,
-0.8956136107444763,
0.7761375308036804,
-0.0019392756512388587,
-0.39428675174713135,
0.8763098120689392,
0.12965427339076996,
0.5433096289634705,
-0.39219310879707336,
0.741733968257904,
-0.08112163096666336,
0.3618311882019043,
-0.6801738739013672,
0.4216183125972748,
-0.11750930547714233,
0.28450649976730347,
-0.3084043562412262,
-0.8748185634613037,
-0.06884176284074783,
0.4728715121746063,
-0.2250164896249771,
-0.0013107582926750183,
1.0734715461730957,
0.7499699592590332,
0.15819969773292542,
0.10687721520662308,
0.3078906834125519,
-0.3485599458217621,
0.718137800693512,
0.4975797235965729,
1.2228580713272095,
-0.2551431357860565,
0.49036499857902527,
0.14150144159793854,
-0.02988501638174057,
-0.24310819804668427,
-0.8713467121124268,
-1.1531468629837036,
-0.6816134452819824,
-0.3833881616592407,
-0.06029415503144264,
0.07522902637720108,
0.9508795738220215,
0.37395480275154114,
-0.4668978154659271,
-0.05036791041493416,
-0.1293264627456665,
0.08084765076637268,
-0.2289549559354782,
-0.1494063138961792,
0.020361866801977158,
-0.8140449523925781,
-0.7571902275085449,
0.5765827298164368,
0.18996869027614594,
0.5548509359359741,
-0.3015391528606415,
-0.17488163709640503,
0.31061848998069763,
-0.11227447539567947,
0.6165243983268738,
0.24027703702449799,
-0.8716726899147034,
-0.23136800527572632,
0.24807025492191315,
-0.22569040954113007,
0.18809331953525543,
1.2982866764068604,
-0.6141192317008972,
0.1452903002500534,
0.7507016658782959,
0.685218334197998,
-0.04762016609311104,
0.14521221816539764,
0.957248866558075,
-0.8893056511878967,
0.2636352479457855,
0.1402597427368164,
0.34576475620269775,
0.4704969823360443,
-0.37723755836486816,
0.5602664947509766,
0.3675070106983185,
-0.6667799353599548,
-0.5307958126068115,
0.4771133363246918,
-0.8258591294288635,
0.03106309473514557,
1.1596887111663818,
-0.17505858838558197,
0.01837129145860672,
-0.3188439607620239,
-0.9580683708190918,
0.11784853786230087,
-0.7083424925804138,
0.6725029945373535,
1.000157117843628,
-0.14120246469974518,
-0.41256043314933777,
-0.9738613963127136,
0.6169341206550598,
0.5384191870689392,
-0.880274772644043,
-0.22422929108142853,
0.25155743956565857,
-0.0644431784749031,
-0.03996710479259491,
0.7992725968360901,
0.07288410514593124,
0.4025998115539551,
-0.1936873197555542,
-0.35302671790122986,
0.1813896894454956,
0.024197913706302643,
0.014725244604051113,
-0.26928654313087463,
0.4652152955532074,
-0.022602876648306847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00126v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00126v1
|
FAC$^2$E: Better Understanding Large Language Model Capabilities by Dissociating Language and Cognition
| 2024-02-29T21:05:37 | 2024-02-29T21:05:37 |
Xiaoqiang Wang, Bang Liu, Lingfei Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are primarily evaluated by overall performance
on various text understanding and generation tasks. However, such a paradigm
fails to comprehensively differentiate the fine-grained language and cognitive
skills, rendering the lack of sufficient interpretation to LLMs' capabilities.
In this paper, we present FAC$^2$E, a framework for Fine-grAined and
Cognition-grounded LLMs' Capability Evaluation. Specifically, we formulate
LLMs' evaluation in a multi-dimensional and explainable manner by dissociating
the language-related capabilities and the cognition-related ones. Besides,
through extracting the intermediate reasoning from LLMs, we further break down
the process of applying a specific capability into three sub-steps: recalling
relevant knowledge, utilizing knowledge, and solving problems. Finally,
FAC$^2$E evaluates each sub-step of each fine-grained capability, providing a
two-faceted diagnosis for LLMs. Utilizing FAC$^2$E, we identify a common
shortfall in knowledge utilization among models and propose a straightforward,
knowledge-enhanced method to mitigate this issue. Our results not only showcase
promising performance enhancements but also highlight a direction for future
LLM advancements.
|
[
-0.5200072526931763,
-1.1067588329315186,
0.9350641369819641,
0.004859980661422014,
-0.07749000936746597,
0.1337311565876007,
-0.48781725764274597,
-0.29145681858062744,
-0.25980618596076965,
0.46179038286209106,
-0.3983936905860901,
-0.330348938703537,
-0.9393743872642517,
-0.14150375127792358,
-0.20450584590435028,
0.755609929561615,
-0.04057804122567177,
0.03825895115733147,
-0.6257780194282532,
-0.0184592567384243,
-0.40420836210250854,
-0.2872903347015381,
-0.9095904231071472,
-0.633895218372345,
0.21284791827201843,
0.5196426510810852,
0.712363600730896,
0.40012863278388977,
0.3544957935810089,
0.2507702708244324,
-0.254393607378006,
0.40446150302886963,
-0.6114372611045837,
-0.2671723961830139,
-0.2160426825284958,
-0.4266156554222107,
-0.7074989676475525,
0.05065986141562462,
0.5902066826820374,
0.8123449087142944,
-0.04152664542198181,
-0.09269551187753677,
0.29807937145233154,
0.7951634526252747,
-0.49664539098739624,
0.42593592405319214,
-0.6392121315002441,
-0.1770358681678772,
-0.09341641515493393,
0.027829982340335846,
-0.4972888231277466,
0.12991192936897278,
0.1299467384815216,
-0.665641188621521,
-0.02053135819733143,
-0.08663729578256607,
0.49993306398391724,
0.25245028734207153,
-0.5024515390396118,
-0.40605297684669495,
-0.6765600442886353,
0.8053174614906311,
-0.4571418762207031,
0.5145229697227478,
0.5717566013336182,
0.27731776237487793,
-0.15943755209445953,
-0.3485344648361206,
-0.6256460547447205,
-0.26270824670791626,
-0.025026077404618263,
-0.1371726095676422,
-0.23927989602088928,
-0.0030867147725075483,
0.21700875461101532,
0.4975910186767578,
-0.4100038707256317,
0.3439723551273346,
-0.1540953665971756,
-0.38509637117385864,
0.4547809064388275,
0.28140318393707275,
0.25440722703933716,
0.07683010399341583,
-0.30692118406295776,
0.06829921156167984,
-0.5944474339485168,
-0.0710684210062027,
0.043685510754585266,
-0.0416109636425972,
-0.16006144881248474,
0.4971039593219757,
0.0036358938086777925,
0.31810495257377625,
0.09421254694461823,
-0.355143666267395,
0.09474416822195053,
-0.07440012693405151,
-0.2936260402202606,
-0.4697076380252838,
0.5968706607818604,
0.1895967721939087,
0.29452595114707947,
-0.1746998280286789,
-0.2824556231498718,
-0.12702712416648865,
0.052870381623506546,
-0.6406487226486206,
-0.020015647634863853,
0.1477518528699875,
-0.6008508205413818,
-0.09219589829444885,
-0.2604856491088867,
-0.7545441389083862,
-0.4583549201488495,
-0.32211029529571533,
0.38637682795524597,
-0.6574406623840332,
-0.36513879895210266,
0.06853421032428741,
0.01255915965884924,
0.12420303374528885,
0.42676058411598206,
-1.0116593837738037,
0.4539046883583069,
0.9005953669548035,
0.8159025311470032,
-0.12951217591762543,
-0.14692020416259766,
-0.44588688015937805,
0.03902149200439453,
-0.16253136098384857,
0.6264660954475403,
-0.5237431526184082,
-0.3950766921043396,
-0.1655380129814148,
-0.2184009850025177,
0.06969161331653595,
-0.5758797526359558,
0.32402217388153076,
-0.5402764678001404,
-0.09591644257307053,
-0.23135536909103394,
-0.6320301294326782,
-0.2476680725812912,
0.14818362891674042,
-0.8228681087493896,
0.8605866432189941,
0.2400614619255066,
-0.5714413523674011,
0.13282950222492218,
-0.5924374461174011,
-0.3659646213054657,
-0.011674870736896992,
-0.3003122806549072,
-0.080299973487854,
0.3169146776199341,
0.12680736184120178,
0.6774086952209473,
-0.7031540870666504,
0.35289713740348816,
-0.4193531572818756,
-0.06781072914600372,
0.14262720942497253,
-0.4967762231826782,
0.6238132119178772,
0.29952964186668396,
-0.31526443362236023,
-0.19706733524799347,
-0.7121822237968445,
-0.007700605317950249,
0.18827269971370697,
-0.2808507978916168,
-0.4263802468776703,
0.15864506363868713,
-0.12608441710472107,
0.2912507951259613,
0.5440324544906616,
-0.1194632351398468,
-0.047515761107206345,
-0.5886868238449097,
0.4809574782848358,
0.5464637875556946,
-0.17655685544013977,
0.6797718405723572,
-0.1868721842765808,
0.18152707815170288,
0.014168862253427505,
0.10849671810865402,
0.03997981175780296,
-0.33509594202041626,
-0.9126453399658203,
-0.30814340710639954,
-0.11847914010286331,
0.48089873790740967,
-0.7642139196395874,
0.45857447385787964,
-0.09770727157592773,
-0.42740973830223083,
-0.12603281438350677,
0.38011834025382996,
0.5428855419158936,
0.282259076833725,
0.5310860872268677,
-0.20555324852466583,
-0.19478072226047516,
-1.0767360925674438,
-0.21712066233158112,
-0.1594715565443039,
-0.16795147955417633,
0.27294856309890747,
0.4883027970790863,
-0.3010425567626953,
0.634301483631134,
-0.4007270336151123,
-0.24287854135036469,
-0.32732805609703064,
0.22163036465644836,
-0.11129181832075119,
0.3950762152671814,
0.3208494782447815,
-0.5297053456306458,
-0.09335903078317642,
0.10213492810726166,
-0.6430332660675049,
-0.1103750616312027,
-0.16666311025619507,
-0.013546421192586422,
0.3547399938106537,
0.6334183812141418,
-0.4974399209022522,
0.302475243806839,
0.516106903553009,
-0.3996681869029999,
0.5420354604721069,
-0.24133601784706116,
0.07270222157239914,
-0.6953117251396179,
-0.009334753267467022,
0.06499489396810532,
-0.08640293031930923,
-0.5560614466667175,
0.12366107106208801,
-0.022436147555708885,
0.17943589389324188,
-0.12629424035549164,
0.6371724605560303,
-0.5567246675491333,
-0.17261230945587158,
-0.38795971870422363,
0.5378451943397522,
0.14774373173713684,
0.2769886553287506,
-0.05531831085681915,
0.5524459481239319,
0.35608622431755066,
-0.5838053226470947,
0.03130369633436203,
-0.008908778429031372,
-0.4187183082103729,
0.3800273537635803,
-0.4164750874042511,
0.21102431416511536,
0.03580952063202858,
0.026909392327070236,
-1.0501588582992554,
-0.11901471018791199,
-0.10082469135522842,
-0.24392633140087128,
0.5044906139373779,
0.16757594048976898,
-0.5825929045677185,
-0.21809348464012146,
-0.05216900631785393,
0.5044510960578918,
0.33076903223991394,
-0.34426674246788025,
0.7755962014198303,
0.5186291337013245,
-0.10958017408847809,
-0.3070407509803772,
-0.7247363924980164,
-0.16054727137088776,
0.003131122561171651,
-0.8549392819404602,
0.2953353226184845,
-0.0701746717095375,
-0.5449132323265076,
-0.21306714415550232,
-0.1751052737236023,
-0.17471392452716827,
0.5573047399520874,
0.19498324394226074,
0.18364980816841125,
-0.21408623456954956,
0.2135133296251297,
0.29838788509368896,
-0.2039254754781723,
0.26007702946662903,
-0.12744832038879395,
0.6246963739395142,
-0.36060741543769836,
-0.28743186593055725,
-0.3150789737701416,
0.32742375135421753,
0.8456069827079773,
-0.2261958122253418,
0.802005410194397,
0.42034539580345154,
-0.5938138961791992,
-0.2141653448343277,
-0.6540009379386902,
-0.19518530368804932,
-0.40050208568573,
0.5192577242851257,
-0.4712534546852112,
-1.154663324356079,
0.5173794031143188,
-0.42102155089378357,
-0.05234646052122116,
0.6016027331352234,
0.7995094656944275,
0.15744414925575256,
0.9036665558815002,
0.7125346660614014,
0.1478748917579651,
0.24518322944641113,
-0.23865628242492676,
0.343555748462677,
-0.8963651061058044,
-0.5858148336410522,
-0.3886381685733795,
0.03498922288417816,
-0.21111838519573212,
-0.8558133244514465,
0.23042157292366028,
0.4979080855846405,
-0.25255417823791504,
-0.043196965008974075,
-0.006873265840113163,
0.45259368419647217,
-0.13955549895763397,
0.059272509068250656,
0.438394695520401,
-0.0059503549709916115,
-0.4206356108188629,
0.01591373048722744,
-0.5563361048698425,
-0.9285289645195007,
0.9628499746322632,
0.8110266923904419,
0.36341673135757446,
0.09626881033182144,
0.4369063675403595,
0.22478698194026947,
0.31225693225860596,
-1.0716581344604492,
0.5976138114929199,
-0.5615595579147339,
-0.5638449192047119,
-0.31190618872642517,
-0.4564211666584015,
-0.44946590065956116,
0.2175925374031067,
-0.27317407727241516,
-0.9309609532356262,
-0.11172319203615189,
0.03218876197934151,
-0.35007157921791077,
0.28164103627204895,
-0.6896873116493225,
0.7175602316856384,
-0.336106538772583,
-0.3856189250946045,
-0.6712888479232788,
-0.2649613320827484,
0.5754034519195557,
-0.33484867215156555,
0.6102497577667236,
-0.21419085562229156,
-0.14262893795967102,
0.8036371469497681,
-0.3079230785369873,
0.6801455616950989,
-0.10416354238986969,
-0.3793860375881195,
0.3067578077316284,
0.40507635474205017,
0.39974701404571533,
0.13292934000492096,
-0.16223664581775665,
0.38215842843055725,
-0.09719660133123398,
-0.2253599464893341,
-0.6607852578163147,
0.8573237061500549,
-0.7135705351829529,
-0.6658177971839905,
0.14764036238193512,
-0.5604738593101501,
-0.5129861831665039,
0.09012221544981003,
0.018717410042881966,
0.27235981822013855,
-0.5667580962181091,
0.13134828209877014,
0.6932015419006348,
-0.20727719366550446,
0.3733712136745453,
0.49481508135795593,
-0.3088485598564148,
-0.3300582468509674,
0.6579493284225464,
0.15324963629245758,
0.3264508545398712,
0.29150548577308655,
0.19664235413074493,
-0.31539538502693176,
-0.5983564257621765,
-0.14688609540462494,
0.21204227209091187,
-0.7603698968887329,
0.0024851500056684017,
-0.6371586918830872,
0.04377860575914383,
-0.19820362329483032,
-0.17774522304534912,
-0.4673585593700409,
-0.35576069355010986,
-0.5021799206733704,
-0.032142847776412964,
0.13490520417690277,
0.7892459034919739,
-0.06265042722225189,
0.3518155515193939,
-0.7146825194358826,
0.31974369287490845,
0.1681259125471115,
0.29377028346061707,
0.4210423529148102,
-0.6503399610519409,
-0.43732649087905884,
0.14672796428203583,
-0.35051771998405457,
-0.7016346454620361,
0.08398705720901489,
0.11726979166269302,
0.6436922550201416,
0.534684419631958,
-0.2730906009674072,
0.5771316289901733,
-0.4318122863769531,
0.7672438621520996,
0.35600408911705017,
-1.453035593032837,
0.3840935230255127,
-0.09925112873315811,
0.05057607591152191,
0.42180970311164856,
0.4093869626522064,
-0.28507521748542786,
-0.3488287329673767,
-0.5418285727500916,
-0.9198994636535645,
0.6545475721359253,
0.11916942894458771,
-0.11321273446083069,
-0.24893662333488464,
0.5806993842124939,
0.16257672011852264,
-0.11841809004545212,
-0.49138885736465454,
-0.289315789937973,
0.11046279966831207,
-0.08686784654855728,
-0.1953967958688736,
-0.5512682199478149,
-0.1152564212679863,
-0.2578544616699219,
0.6573232412338257,
-0.1761506348848343,
0.23391732573509216,
0.03147321194410324,
-0.22423426806926727,
-0.023200584575533867,
0.3295982778072357,
0.4498143792152405,
0.6187835335731506,
0.15797238051891327,
0.39670801162719727,
0.3750544786453247,
-0.36395764350891113,
-0.04381868615746498,
-0.21300260722637177,
0.31648799777030945,
-0.5547243356704712,
0.5715237259864807,
0.5521268844604492,
0.3206174671649933,
-0.5609870553016663,
0.4364718794822693,
0.1344059705734253,
-0.28192320466041565,
-0.13173674046993256,
0.17339907586574554,
0.31037789583206177,
0.5289760828018188,
0.40227022767066956,
-0.019030367955565453,
0.045765724033117294,
-0.6027275919914246,
0.4043670892715454,
0.4482227563858032,
-0.11573843657970428,
-0.17704659700393677,
0.3655532896518707,
0.34381869435310364,
-0.06058168038725853,
0.5007302761077881,
-0.25528547167778015,
-0.4623435437679291,
0.6725010275840759,
0.5315699577331543,
0.7739357948303223,
-0.09929904341697693,
0.08727585524320602,
0.23689702153205872,
0.504452645778656,
-0.18894155323505402,
0.035148631781339645,
0.1508035659790039,
-0.8965117335319519,
-0.5883301496505737,
-0.5330544710159302,
0.030345436185598373,
0.6116218566894531,
-0.7036951184272766,
0.12832650542259216,
-0.760304868221283,
-0.16600140929222107,
0.22165508568286896,
0.2639012038707733,
-0.7311353087425232,
0.08036766946315765,
0.30927368998527527,
0.9596216678619385,
-0.8299674391746521,
0.9269595146179199,
0.5348184704780579,
-0.24780014157295227,
-0.8611285090446472,
0.18534328043460846,
0.2286929041147232,
-0.7844136953353882,
0.7966400980949402,
0.2065224051475525,
-0.42104488611221313,
-0.004068444017320871,
-0.3944317698478699,
-0.6304097771644592,
1.1827880144119263,
0.4352496862411499,
-0.7834119200706482,
0.27238038182258606,
0.026402834802865982,
0.5313334465026855,
-0.700852632522583,
0.4146708548069,
1.052358865737915,
0.7067431211471558,
-0.11353994905948639,
-0.9917110204696655,
0.2139323502779007,
0.05483424663543701,
-0.051890842616558075,
0.16603721678256989,
-0.7092908024787903,
0.8414860367774963,
-0.35464563965797424,
-0.35595110058784485,
0.08096710592508316,
0.5215489268302917,
0.09502200782299042,
0.5675846934318542,
0.4898904263973236,
0.5677235126495361,
0.9957342147827148,
-0.0918506309390068,
0.7991644740104675,
-0.16046184301376343,
0.6067573428153992,
1.016224980354309,
-0.29488226771354675,
0.9018809795379639,
0.4690147340297699,
-0.06421227008104324,
0.3689936399459839,
0.2443035989999771,
0.20144611597061157,
0.3175940215587616,
0.13065116107463837,
-0.27547845244407654,
-0.7156832218170166,
0.04767729714512825,
-0.031172258779406548,
0.7012119889259338,
0.7939120531082153,
-0.485185444355011,
-0.32526135444641113,
-0.03354503586888313,
0.3311997950077057,
0.24906274676322937,
-0.32567086815834045,
0.7095087766647339,
0.22570791840553284,
-0.47722047567367554,
0.6829822063446045,
0.2947190999984741,
0.4469761252403259,
-0.2913111746311188,
-0.13681183755397797,
-0.16982145607471466,
0.1519598364830017,
-0.283753901720047,
-0.9348112344741821,
0.508360743522644,
0.1805592030286789,
-0.5092098712921143,
0.0008185954065993428,
0.7276161313056946,
-0.3038094639778137,
-0.23255062103271484,
0.6718587279319763,
0.7483550310134888,
0.253954142332077,
-0.07315854728221893,
-0.7456015348434448,
0.2871720790863037,
0.09535454958677292,
-0.17317862808704376,
0.34553104639053345,
0.6668856739997864,
-0.11269459128379822,
0.6553221344947815,
0.45102712512016296,
-0.20964761078357697,
-0.4264087677001953,
0.010940417647361755,
0.8748193979263306,
-0.44048789143562317,
-0.007191623095422983,
-1.0088564157485962,
0.39319369196891785,
0.07763244211673737,
-0.12057886272668839,
0.42352595925331116,
0.4832962453365326,
0.6487047076225281,
0.07261037826538086,
0.7869051098823547,
-0.13922840356826782,
0.029917271807789803,
-0.7646695375442505,
0.8549169898033142,
-0.6981024742126465,
0.7235902547836304,
-0.042865119874477386,
-0.7126666307449341,
-0.1356734186410904,
0.7519230842590332,
-0.572608470916748,
0.12602093815803528,
0.9394581317901611,
0.6992927193641663,
0.038423918187618256,
0.018326779827475548,
0.6559931039810181,
0.5048612356185913,
0.326436311006546,
0.8034300208091736,
0.7131403088569641,
-0.2557578682899475,
0.3380674719810486,
-0.10467181354761124,
-0.5854522585868835,
-0.28992143273353577,
-0.9287393093109131,
-1.0376017093658447,
-0.6965245604515076,
-0.20728625357151031,
-0.18717578053474426,
-0.20682069659233093,
0.7983638048171997,
0.5529516339302063,
-0.5164385437965393,
-0.006468840874731541,
-0.2088596075773239,
0.34865108132362366,
-0.03865355625748634,
-0.25018152594566345,
0.1899578869342804,
-0.31223180890083313,
-0.5954381823539734,
0.5553586483001709,
0.42215919494628906,
-0.07199113816022873,
-0.4801027476787567,
-0.2189626544713974,
-0.07135818153619766,
0.2627457082271576,
0.9750654697418213,
-0.09988100081682205,
-0.8901910185813904,
-0.427133709192276,
-0.12693513929843903,
-0.06482889503240585,
-0.27304548025131226,
0.9743622541427612,
-0.5839439034461975,
0.2823692560195923,
0.3361365497112274,
0.5070849657058716,
0.18991245329380035,
-0.3686904311180115,
0.4199047088623047,
-0.46544158458709717,
0.036751314997673035,
0.09422902017831802,
0.4379914700984955,
0.16177387535572052,
-0.5174202919006348,
0.3184647858142853,
0.1830357313156128,
-0.48628291487693787,
-0.43169453740119934,
0.3158019483089447,
-1.1108145713806152,
-0.5845624208450317,
1.407076358795166,
-0.3556893765926361,
-0.14129342138767242,
-0.3314008414745331,
-0.05149420350790024,
0.3593120574951172,
-0.3586597144603729,
0.6272588968276978,
1.019317388534546,
-0.11331808567047119,
0.05724261328577995,
-0.689751923084259,
0.2677627205848694,
0.44414016604423523,
-0.8510595560073853,
0.4364399313926697,
0.7044693827629089,
0.45736008882522583,
0.25545188784599304,
0.5055750608444214,
-0.45873749256134033,
0.062283702194690704,
-0.009583824314177036,
0.015353411436080933,
-0.185574010014534,
-0.5095379948616028,
-0.3724137246608734,
0.16656151413917542,
0.3252483010292053,
0.3340910077095032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00862v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00862v4
|
NewsBench: A Systematic Evaluation Framework for Assessing Editorial Capabilities of Large Language Models in Chinese Journalism
| 2024-02-29T21:05:14 | 2024-06-04T14:50:58 |
Miao Li, Ming-Bin Chen, Bo Tang, Shengbin Hou, Pengyu Wang, Haiying Deng, Zhiyu Li, Feiyu Xiong, Keming Mao, Peng Cheng, Yi Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present NewsBench, a novel evaluation framework to systematically assess
the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) for editorial capabilities in
Chinese journalism. Our constructed benchmark dataset is focused on four facets
of writing proficiency and six facets of safety adherence, and it comprises
manually and carefully designed 1,267 test samples in the types of multiple
choice questions and short answer questions for five editorial tasks in 24 news
domains. To measure performances, we propose different GPT-4 based automatic
evaluation protocols to assess LLM generations for short answer questions in
terms of writing proficiency and safety adherence, and both are validated by
the high correlations with human evaluations. Based on the systematic
evaluation framework, we conduct a comprehensive analysis of ten popular LLMs
which can handle Chinese. The experimental results highlight GPT-4 and ERNIE
Bot as top performers, yet reveal a relative deficiency in journalistic safety
adherence in creative writing tasks. Our findings also underscore the need for
enhanced ethical guidance in machine-generated journalistic content, marking a
step forward in aligning LLMs with journalistic standards and safety
considerations.
|
[
-0.031007708981633186,
-0.6850466132164001,
0.5805517435073853,
0.47907304763793945,
-0.20056885480880737,
0.19993452727794647,
-0.5153583884239197,
-0.33695968985557556,
-0.10899937897920609,
0.31873130798339844,
-0.4337367117404938,
-0.8713151216506958,
-0.3368591070175171,
0.17564137279987335,
-0.46562981605529785,
1.202462911605835,
-0.2942054271697998,
0.12892937660217285,
-0.11895811557769775,
-0.16730961203575134,
-0.2555016577243805,
-0.3873226046562195,
-0.6576712727546692,
0.1833188235759735,
0.6959966421127319,
0.06769037246704102,
0.649049699306488,
0.6337306499481201,
0.7875614762306213,
0.28366008400917053,
-0.06659013032913208,
-0.18077416718006134,
-0.4487047493457794,
-0.43438684940338135,
-0.3713768720626831,
-0.33803504705429077,
-0.5696259140968323,
0.21375246345996857,
0.7148929238319397,
0.5868004560470581,
-0.15721410512924194,
0.3607913851737976,
0.09422483295202255,
0.6387598514556885,
-0.4121406078338623,
-0.14962273836135864,
-0.45988765358924866,
0.07631317526102066,
-0.24372468888759613,
-0.08777046203613281,
-0.34456244111061096,
-0.698307991027832,
-0.16310298442840576,
-0.6370427012443542,
0.14618104696273804,
0.026928456500172615,
0.8694239258766174,
-0.01713479682803154,
-0.5510226488113403,
-0.34932079911231995,
-0.40762555599212646,
0.5848272442817688,
-0.7800195813179016,
0.23581278324127197,
0.15367843210697174,
0.34038883447647095,
-0.05045279115438461,
-0.7472113370895386,
-0.5294608473777771,
-0.38451284170150757,
0.21949712932109833,
0.49361562728881836,
0.2701844573020935,
0.09956171363592148,
0.10309379547834396,
0.4099026918411255,
-0.8066621422767639,
0.1764264851808548,
-0.3665629029273987,
-0.3639504909515381,
0.828263521194458,
0.18183283507823944,
0.38313809037208557,
-0.24638251960277557,
-0.3976823389530182,
0.10960102081298828,
-0.4687330722808838,
0.15250614285469055,
0.731212854385376,
-0.07632838189601898,
-0.10631579160690308,
0.39056533575057983,
-0.350667268037796,
0.5190611481666565,
-0.1656525582075119,
-0.19768746197223663,
0.3001214861869812,
-0.5847622752189636,
0.1661144345998764,
0.09099113196134567,
0.9067842960357666,
0.7133080363273621,
-0.008336282335221767,
-0.08722217381000519,
-0.20977652072906494,
-0.16187050938606262,
0.4122389853000641,
-0.5460177659988403,
0.0013393154367804527,
0.14230413734912872,
-0.5782116055488586,
-0.6255754232406616,
0.21976180374622345,
-0.6761611104011536,
-0.6144216656684875,
-0.08140179514884949,
0.4388960599899292,
-0.09147538244724274,
-0.3009606897830963,
0.17472964525222778,
-0.21119579672813416,
0.44868725538253784,
0.20076406002044678,
-0.7232472896575928,
0.0372343547642231,
0.8113402724266052,
0.8381842970848083,
-0.4668525457382202,
-0.48794442415237427,
-0.3588872253894806,
0.2117459625005722,
-0.610725998878479,
0.586982011795044,
-0.12910500168800354,
0.05241912603378296,
0.11570252478122711,
0.08347838371992111,
-0.008860817179083824,
-0.21188627183437347,
1.0412986278533936,
-0.5159223675727844,
0.18182754516601562,
-0.4343663156032562,
-0.41982007026672363,
-0.3055868446826935,
0.474385142326355,
-0.7736909985542297,
0.7626417875289917,
0.37469902634620667,
-0.8220013380050659,
0.40665873885154724,
-0.32075411081314087,
-0.5971416234970093,
-0.30244308710098267,
0.08213585615158081,
-0.3887557089328766,
0.0427960529923439,
0.2842087745666504,
0.17919346690177917,
-0.12322178483009338,
0.5151751041412354,
-0.3704354166984558,
-0.48187071084976196,
0.1268683820962906,
-0.6568973660469055,
0.9509479403495789,
0.03393932804465294,
-0.1859675794839859,
0.4348722994327545,
-0.8215408325195312,
0.0743350088596344,
-0.15141667425632477,
-0.729526162147522,
-0.032621338963508606,
-0.18102622032165527,
0.2182312309741974,
0.4744790196418762,
0.22757183015346527,
-0.571282148361206,
0.19632193446159363,
-0.1836034059524536,
0.5029937028884888,
0.7311368584632874,
0.10909532755613327,
0.13652901351451874,
-0.40576171875,
0.5963835120201111,
-0.2742445468902588,
0.2543371021747589,
-0.17043393850326538,
-0.038429196923971176,
-0.6887975931167603,
0.085281603038311,
0.48100343346595764,
0.6897307634353638,
-0.6762832999229431,
0.581105649471283,
-0.29070717096328735,
-0.724534273147583,
-0.38058406114578247,
0.39931386709213257,
0.2947663366794586,
0.5516666769981384,
-0.027602797374129295,
-0.4898817837238312,
-0.35427841544151306,
-0.8809877038002014,
-0.544095516204834,
-0.12286140769720078,
-0.025058869272470474,
-0.2410285323858261,
0.3150152862071991,
0.2165311872959137,
0.6381986141204834,
0.10565857589244843,
-0.22183789312839508,
-0.6691863536834717,
0.17421378195285797,
0.3644201159477234,
0.25379258394241333,
0.5453740954399109,
-0.6510943174362183,
-0.38508132100105286,
-0.09535248577594757,
-0.9347167611122131,
-0.28123000264167786,
-0.4963326156139374,
-0.21153458952903748,
0.37350401282310486,
0.5349722504615784,
-0.6214044690132141,
0.2899795174598694,
0.7104038596153259,
-0.06759572774171829,
0.819936215877533,
0.14225272834300995,
0.24045491218566895,
-0.7157284617424011,
0.2466384321451187,
-0.03791480511426926,
-0.09824386984109879,
-0.4850762188434601,
-0.05173708498477936,
0.3055402338504791,
-0.08496078103780746,
-0.79583340883255,
0.4249264895915985,
-0.3721471428871155,
-0.16843390464782715,
-0.19694797694683075,
0.47692641615867615,
0.19027957320213318,
0.4341682493686676,
0.06892145425081253,
0.5740223526954651,
0.2727490961551666,
-0.3425174355506897,
0.621985673904419,
0.06589171290397644,
-0.5512689352035522,
0.47769299149513245,
-0.6308502554893494,
0.03681601956486702,
-0.01373964548110962,
0.4554203748703003,
-0.9737264513969421,
-0.24388442933559418,
0.02460186555981636,
-0.2027330845594406,
-0.031169649213552475,
0.1966702789068222,
-0.7099382281303406,
-0.5853331685066223,
-0.5833331346511841,
0.0016648051096126437,
0.25758716464042664,
-0.05516763776540756,
0.3437249958515167,
0.11447055637836456,
-0.5127773284912109,
-0.47242632508277893,
-0.6799061894416809,
0.2817399203777313,
-0.21485202014446259,
-0.8549174666404724,
0.09372164309024811,
-0.051899202167987823,
0.07723911106586456,
0.09046605974435806,
-0.22606399655342102,
-0.1580582857131958,
0.1750485599040985,
-0.28875046968460083,
0.2539595067501068,
-0.4057011902332306,
-0.05665116012096405,
-0.02173754945397377,
0.025015149265527725,
0.11234527081251144,
0.14419607818126678,
0.2574549615383148,
-0.2657932937145233,
-0.5423694849014282,
-0.5370572209358215,
0.10313698649406433,
0.3029640316963196,
-0.3759881854057312,
0.4482652544975281,
0.7815788984298706,
-0.10015428066253662,
-0.038277335464954376,
-0.4893937408924103,
-0.0004405180225148797,
-0.46229231357574463,
0.6660733819007874,
0.08644793182611465,
-0.643370509147644,
0.4841161370277405,
0.1421755701303482,
0.3213881552219391,
0.5089707374572754,
0.6795588731765747,
0.08545523881912231,
0.9232879877090454,
0.6861250996589661,
-0.48235031962394714,
0.2547608017921448,
0.15793576836585999,
0.16925622522830963,
-0.41565003991127014,
0.2680870294570923,
-0.14129117131233215,
-0.4572877585887909,
-0.31847867369651794,
-0.09423918277025223,
0.5234829187393188,
0.07475518435239792,
-0.14115411043167114,
0.09962392598390579,
-0.2650943994522095,
0.5690627098083496,
0.3855944871902466,
-0.30999481678009033,
0.6784455180168152,
-0.4752556085586548,
0.06346356123685837,
0.11619669944047928,
-0.6158062815666199,
-0.6424307823181152,
0.9580421447753906,
0.49634507298469543,
0.8060048222541809,
-0.03092186525464058,
0.4212625324726105,
0.10661423951387405,
0.5493566393852234,
-0.6405264139175415,
0.5594805479049683,
-0.05470768362283707,
-0.8481859564781189,
-0.30889222025871277,
-0.18727464973926544,
-0.4839593470096588,
0.30121076107025146,
0.07286173850297928,
-0.5355449318885803,
-0.2591651678085327,
-0.13971897959709167,
-0.5640648603439331,
0.1806863397359848,
-0.5502502918243408,
0.8951787352561951,
-0.8015167117118835,
-0.40613558888435364,
-0.07125087827444077,
-0.7475588917732239,
0.7057837247848511,
-0.1618734896183014,
0.3090468645095825,
-0.26430803537368774,
-0.16317489743232727,
0.7451246976852417,
0.1615990847349167,
0.9331651926040649,
0.031388115137815475,
-0.25676289200782776,
0.37656834721565247,
-0.092435821890831,
0.278007447719574,
0.14775194227695465,
-0.43102404475212097,
0.3671634793281555,
0.13918094336986542,
-0.0032589451875537634,
-0.4521104097366333,
0.44045668840408325,
-0.5240496397018433,
-0.7848755121231079,
-0.5343598127365112,
-0.6799389719963074,
-0.30221158266067505,
0.7263819575309753,
0.3191109001636505,
0.15490859746932983,
-0.4917339086532593,
0.3539544343948364,
0.10937964171171188,
-0.33154842257499695,
0.5036147832870483,
0.6332792639732361,
-0.32370617985725403,
-0.3948005437850952,
0.7771159410476685,
0.16020750999450684,
0.19081000983715057,
0.18004955351352692,
0.06800880283117294,
-0.18432393670082092,
-0.8287143111228943,
-0.7362061738967896,
0.10460485517978668,
-0.703299343585968,
0.023065542802214622,
-0.33551445603370667,
-0.5962817668914795,
-0.2711757719516754,
-0.33492523431777954,
-0.45992934703826904,
-0.30180981755256653,
0.09257519245147705,
-0.23815126717090607,
-0.13770456612110138,
0.5451378226280212,
0.0023022708483040333,
0.18077236413955688,
-0.9331179261207581,
0.3528139293193817,
-0.16707192361354828,
0.5140050053596497,
-0.26088443398475647,
-0.2863002121448517,
-0.4642777740955353,
-0.19452671706676483,
-0.8785181045532227,
-0.760006844997406,
0.051560334861278534,
0.006736373994499445,
0.7774476408958435,
0.4685903489589691,
0.2084292769432068,
0.31593409180641174,
-0.49804258346557617,
0.9899506568908691,
-0.1059333011507988,
-1.0503517389297485,
0.38472139835357666,
-0.9290072321891785,
0.07376045733690262,
0.795266330242157,
0.24048036336898804,
-0.9280977249145508,
-0.6831799745559692,
-0.381152480840683,
-0.8153401017189026,
0.5300047397613525,
0.05493204668164253,
0.2276744842529297,
0.2073255032300949,
0.16038289666175842,
0.09128783643245697,
0.5218690633773804,
-0.8407642245292664,
0.2416357845067978,
-0.1668877750635147,
-0.35483479499816895,
0.06963342428207397,
-0.18903113901615143,
-0.31949159502983093,
-0.17742523550987244,
0.6340864896774292,
-0.0633988007903099,
-0.0037958987522870302,
0.16457054018974304,
-0.10993154346942902,
-0.17128023505210876,
0.3232898712158203,
0.5518790483474731,
1.1139801740646362,
0.07329276204109192,
-0.14569485187530518,
0.25026118755340576,
-0.3630499541759491,
0.0971810519695282,
0.19863981008529663,
-0.14601682126522064,
0.024982627481222153,
0.6535942554473877,
0.367156982421875,
0.20325148105621338,
-0.6551356315612793,
0.7632390856742859,
0.014656972140073776,
-0.45921966433525085,
-0.489117294549942,
0.17810112237930298,
0.25882968306541443,
-0.0337107852101326,
0.1825522631406784,
-0.3521670699119568,
0.23443372547626495,
-0.5214788317680359,
0.29274988174438477,
0.22802016139030457,
-0.3622110188007355,
-0.3218255639076233,
0.7022964358329773,
0.40147992968559265,
0.171099454164505,
0.446600079536438,
-0.1603146493434906,
-0.5605548620223999,
0.7662945985794067,
0.2674010992050171,
0.6724734306335449,
-0.15076501667499542,
0.25686874985694885,
0.24501310288906097,
0.6536827683448792,
-0.3395867347717285,
0.25057920813560486,
0.48242321610450745,
-0.5188868045806885,
-0.4328327775001526,
-0.34352564811706543,
-0.43652886152267456,
0.24054016172885895,
-0.5751901268959045,
0.5042777061462402,
-0.6914623975753784,
0.0507962629199028,
-0.12913823127746582,
0.18007174134254456,
-0.3155783712863922,
-0.08088670670986176,
0.23006173968315125,
1.2437211275100708,
-0.7678003311157227,
0.5837708115577698,
0.5723482966423035,
-0.4281015992164612,
-0.7709692716598511,
0.24301232397556305,
0.4817618429660797,
-0.4877726435661316,
0.08025806397199631,
0.5536249876022339,
0.22181326150894165,
-0.0442667156457901,
-0.41339245438575745,
-0.7406193614006042,
1.1168559789657593,
0.3486902713775635,
-0.6559447646141052,
-0.0018777616787701845,
0.15500293672084808,
0.6842730641365051,
-0.11572542041540146,
0.04378713667392731,
0.6576780676841736,
0.7566903829574585,
-0.2885628640651703,
-1.1142679452896118,
-0.0690281018614769,
-0.3065001368522644,
-0.13149915635585785,
-0.1738380789756775,
-1.2576426267623901,
0.6362650394439697,
-0.17974363267421722,
-0.2344180941581726,
0.2876802980899811,
0.6556265354156494,
0.17374305427074432,
0.606833815574646,
0.3654845356941223,
0.35542842745780945,
0.7143782377243042,
-0.01772357150912285,
1.133717656135559,
-0.3579899072647095,
0.17763271927833557,
0.8417977690696716,
-0.4264335334300995,
0.6414018869400024,
0.12521600723266602,
0.026882924139499664,
0.5889338850975037,
0.6660885214805603,
-0.36703169345855713,
0.4527329206466675,
0.25908219814300537,
-0.09416638314723969,
-0.052288126200437546,
-0.1289147585630417,
-0.36243781447410583,
0.4815289378166199,
0.06760167330503464,
-0.3010551333427429,
-0.3085075616836548,
-0.07452414929866791,
0.23873713612556458,
0.1641937494277954,
-0.21682463586330414,
0.7194021940231323,
0.08803743869066238,
-0.7841953635215759,
0.3296484351158142,
0.25881078839302063,
0.4399992525577545,
-0.6938736438751221,
0.179948627948761,
-0.04497181996703148,
0.1713704615831375,
-0.16982686519622803,
-1.1150814294815063,
0.27796831727027893,
0.04535529389977455,
0.018891537562012672,
0.041007790714502335,
0.6711068153381348,
-0.42024949193000793,
-0.7764171361923218,
-0.02346113696694374,
0.47835347056388855,
0.010603764094412327,
0.11174424737691879,
-0.7112913727760315,
0.2850271463394165,
-0.24093766510486603,
-0.7044545412063599,
0.16389545798301697,
0.5135396718978882,
-0.2912984788417816,
0.4912623465061188,
0.7027124166488647,
0.2514926791191101,
-0.06427470594644547,
0.1710909754037857,
0.7821032404899597,
-0.7705850005149841,
-0.668217122554779,
-0.7477161884307861,
0.4295702278614044,
-0.09023838490247726,
-0.42385342717170715,
0.9837775230407715,
0.6133638620376587,
0.7662844657897949,
-0.05041661486029625,
1.2880263328552246,
-0.1813923716545105,
0.48285263776779175,
-0.6493684649467468,
1.0451536178588867,
-0.28884994983673096,
0.09473829716444016,
-0.22813986241817474,
-0.9666236639022827,
-0.2887357175350189,
0.3692508637905121,
-0.4927787184715271,
0.21221871674060822,
0.8284770846366882,
0.7026873826980591,
0.20814238488674164,
0.18067386746406555,
0.13511969149112701,
0.06053372845053673,
0.4164929986000061,
0.7478765249252319,
0.9662039875984192,
-0.13506139814853668,
0.7016898393630981,
-0.34384170174598694,
-0.17981214821338654,
-0.003223598236218095,
-1.264844536781311,
-1.0623630285263062,
-0.230134516954422,
0.04177580401301384,
0.0370124988257885,
0.2666929066181183,
0.5590232610702515,
0.4150068461894989,
-0.5803865790367126,
-0.0078777140006423,
0.17654463648796082,
0.1835489422082901,
-0.4874189496040344,
-0.23061953485012054,
0.5071209073066711,
-0.3965570032596588,
-0.6594581604003906,
0.05654653534293175,
0.1633438915014267,
-0.41289547085762024,
-0.43614813685417175,
0.18102815747261047,
0.039694592356681824,
-0.14773423969745636,
0.37493613362312317,
0.08564631640911102,
-0.5720665454864502,
-0.3286391794681549,
-0.03939194604754448,
-0.35198652744293213,
-0.01826927252113819,
0.8989598155021667,
-0.23034845292568207,
0.23326970636844635,
0.5161260962486267,
0.7704838514328003,
-0.12514162063598633,
0.26629748940467834,
0.46928736567497253,
-0.6202065944671631,
0.16644130647182465,
0.2257051169872284,
0.10420544445514679,
0.41771677136421204,
-0.5606836676597595,
0.5600734353065491,
0.14432966709136963,
-0.7166443467140198,
-0.5794028639793396,
-0.1066654846072197,
-0.9016414284706116,
-0.05449846759438515,
1.350569248199463,
-0.14490751922130585,
-0.13919991254806519,
-0.22109220921993256,
-0.32239630818367004,
0.2304385006427765,
-0.22007504105567932,
0.8128383755683899,
1.1359518766403198,
-0.01909838616847992,
-0.2586684226989746,
-1.170035719871521,
0.3780292868614197,
0.2237376719713211,
-0.8258832693099976,
0.212388277053833,
0.5225305557250977,
0.4618960916996002,
-0.13036470115184784,
0.8045300245285034,
-0.2758389115333557,
0.5997776985168457,
-0.22142517566680908,
0.05165934935212135,
-0.18402841687202454,
-0.3340074121952057,
-0.17754098773002625,
0.04118094593286514,
-0.007332933600991964,
0.24021752178668976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00108v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00108v1
|
LoRA-as-an-Attack! Piercing LLM Safety Under The Share-and-Play Scenario
| 2024-02-29T20:25:16 | 2024-02-29T20:25:16 |
Hongyi Liu, Zirui Liu, Ruixiang Tang, Jiayi Yuan, Shaochen Zhong, Yu-Neng Chuang, Li Li, Rui Chen, Xia Hu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Fine-tuning LLMs is crucial to enhancing their task-specific performance and
ensuring model behaviors are aligned with human preferences. Among various
fine-tuning methods, LoRA is popular for its efficiency and ease to use,
allowing end-users to easily post and adopt lightweight LoRA modules on
open-source platforms to tailor their model for different customization.
However, such a handy share-and-play setting opens up new attack surfaces, that
the attacker can render LoRA as an attacker, such as backdoor injection, and
widely distribute the adversarial LoRA to the community easily. This can result
in detrimental outcomes. Despite the huge potential risks of sharing LoRA
modules, this aspect however has not been fully explored. To fill the gap, in
this study we thoroughly investigate the attack opportunities enabled in the
growing share-and-play scenario. Specifically, we study how to inject backdoor
into the LoRA module and dive deeper into LoRA's infection mechanisms. We found
that training-free mechanism is possible in LoRA backdoor injection. We also
discover the impact of backdoor attacks with the presence of multiple LoRA
adaptions concurrently as well as LoRA based backdoor transferability. Our aim
is to raise awareness of the potential risks under the emerging share-and-play
scenario, so as to proactively prevent potential consequences caused by
LoRA-as-an-Attack. Warning: the paper contains potential offensive content
generated by models.
|
[
-0.16588108241558075,
-0.9569113850593567,
0.22108282148838043,
0.026145247742533684,
-0.11908285319805145,
0.06757041811943054,
0.4182586073875427,
-0.9531200528144836,
0.2980329394340515,
0.722619891166687,
-0.6527013778686523,
-0.5155318975448608,
-0.5461240410804749,
-0.29857584834098816,
-0.544887900352478,
0.8533796072006226,
0.09731008112430573,
-0.276908814907074,
0.29092487692832947,
-0.2334618717432022,
-0.7215968370437622,
-0.5159903764724731,
-0.6208221912384033,
-0.08011389523744583,
1.1024786233901978,
0.1532139778137207,
0.47536003589630127,
0.6114628911018372,
0.6123926639556885,
0.2676636576652527,
-0.1622745543718338,
-0.16852553188800812,
-0.5774322152137756,
0.08516139537096024,
-0.3467924892902374,
-0.5820085406303406,
-0.7233428359031677,
0.1316133290529251,
0.19739368557929993,
0.2520389258861542,
-0.2783268094062805,
0.20735250413417816,
0.01386537216603756,
0.6187971830368042,
-0.8131775856018066,
-0.6274783611297607,
-1.030014991760254,
0.06261880695819855,
-0.48294752836227417,
-0.12669634819030762,
-0.3509061932563782,
-0.16426312923431396,
0.03227776661515236,
-0.5972697138786316,
-0.4479386806488037,
0.048860102891922,
0.6194719672203064,
0.19100232422351837,
-0.35398268699645996,
-0.1700739711523056,
-0.2504104673862457,
0.3449033796787262,
-0.4719412922859192,
-0.15239626169204712,
0.03470635041594505,
0.40036460757255554,
-0.3978613018989563,
-0.3564959466457367,
-0.05447329580783844,
0.21750110387802124,
0.02547505870461464,
0.11878625303506851,
-0.6030721068382263,
-0.036634329706430435,
0.25096485018730164,
0.3639568090438843,
-0.3386000990867615,
0.45344969630241394,
-0.48588475584983826,
-0.09011752158403397,
0.6323572993278503,
0.2697736322879791,
0.5460975766181946,
0.07222969084978104,
-0.8350734114646912,
0.14668792486190796,
-1.0785794258117676,
0.12670980393886566,
0.736091673374176,
0.39751100540161133,
-0.4035729765892029,
0.6572356224060059,
-0.01557209063321352,
0.4118804931640625,
0.17162519693374634,
0.36342838406562805,
0.02430722676217556,
-0.09330443292856216,
-0.3125248849391937,
0.08919710665941238,
0.735261857509613,
0.35327601432800293,
-0.13028484582901,
-0.061478182673454285,
-0.19401641190052032,
0.11605557799339294,
0.5409035086631775,
-0.6673294305801392,
0.26367297768592834,
0.3113876283168793,
-0.22433282434940338,
-0.9344316720962524,
0.14213362336158752,
-0.6741341948509216,
-0.6479737758636475,
0.4793044328689575,
1.0717071294784546,
-0.38164815306663513,
-0.28332948684692383,
0.3858650326728821,
-0.08127135038375854,
0.28496870398521423,
0.4193520247936249,
-0.6554556488990784,
0.32056906819343567,
1.0283604860305786,
0.8186283111572266,
-0.3338621258735657,
-0.39494389295578003,
-0.7603070735931396,
0.6442222595214844,
-0.17186637222766876,
0.6567988395690918,
0.08576235920190811,
-0.515404462814331,
0.12853403389453888,
-0.28197625279426575,
0.004299037624150515,
-0.6203700304031372,
0.030403247103095055,
-0.7948379516601562,
0.0018070065416395664,
-0.12650048732757568,
-0.2738421559333801,
-0.206925630569458,
0.5877672433853149,
-0.860889196395874,
0.3783687651157379,
-0.14316326379776,
-1.0914764404296875,
0.16613468527793884,
-1.0871355533599854,
-0.541652500629425,
-0.13768965005874634,
0.053974252194166183,
-0.29563888907432556,
0.32948005199432373,
-0.05873558670282364,
0.2839542031288147,
0.12645040452480316,
-0.3871074616909027,
-0.5432085990905762,
-0.5468586087226868,
0.7081941366195679,
-0.20508219301700592,
0.6527565121650696,
0.17133280634880066,
-0.1503829061985016,
0.20258097350597382,
-0.3603062629699707,
-0.1689140349626541,
-0.05150606483221054,
-0.27535516023635864,
-0.36809012293815613,
-0.3004401922225952,
-0.31532517075538635,
-0.06146979704499245,
0.4378165006637573,
-0.5726903080940247,
0.18558956682682037,
-0.809424877166748,
0.29255619645118713,
0.7397662997245789,
0.41213271021842957,
0.3252403140068054,
-0.46341559290885925,
0.30864638090133667,
0.12352944165468216,
0.7845616936683655,
0.03634500503540039,
-0.4682869613170624,
-0.36588841676712036,
-0.5152832269668579,
0.1717132031917572,
0.5222219824790955,
-0.469698429107666,
0.04479203000664711,
0.4379678964614868,
-0.4730603098869324,
-0.5714371800422668,
-0.013977907598018646,
0.6028813123703003,
0.0831974595785141,
0.024460524320602417,
-0.3218599855899811,
-0.4082470238208771,
-0.549811840057373,
-0.42978227138519287,
-0.028950460255146027,
0.30535775423049927,
0.2809774577617645,
0.35145559906959534,
-0.45738813281059265,
0.7818711400032043,
-0.38901323080062866,
-0.4714801609516144,
0.043911177664995193,
-0.12425410002470016,
0.5174748301506042,
0.6250781416893005,
0.47139474749565125,
-0.4702654480934143,
-0.4350457191467285,
0.2250305414199829,
-0.8727946877479553,
0.06523250788450241,
0.3146710693836212,
-0.295443594455719,
0.1680169701576233,
0.3740042448043823,
-0.6339336037635803,
0.8985819816589355,
0.7003162503242493,
-0.27906423807144165,
0.4005671739578247,
-0.18150776624679565,
0.051058366894721985,
-1.2878073453903198,
0.1571439802646637,
-0.46493980288505554,
0.0011878443183377385,
-0.7402274012565613,
0.7885026335716248,
-0.19743743538856506,
-0.2339732050895691,
-0.8714356422424316,
0.5311477184295654,
0.029443340376019478,
-0.33237016201019287,
-0.3386791944503784,
-0.06528670340776443,
0.05119432136416435,
0.12986643612384796,
-0.3873347043991089,
0.7594040036201477,
0.6685993075370789,
-0.4578564763069153,
0.25492605566978455,
-0.08579318970441818,
-0.2021176517009735,
0.5023017525672913,
-0.7340894341468811,
0.20782975852489471,
0.7114589214324951,
-0.012049932032823563,
-0.5687070488929749,
-0.34955519437789917,
0.6577666401863098,
-0.41509494185447693,
0.2784607410430908,
-0.5179035067558289,
-0.3559515178203583,
0.11808902770280838,
-0.6073959469795227,
0.3385109007358551,
0.3758925795555115,
-0.8262216448783875,
0.7998417019844055,
0.29357200860977173,
0.3480389714241028,
-1.084944248199463,
-0.6655896902084351,
0.062093980610370636,
-0.9350749254226685,
-1.0239461660385132,
0.2064048796892166,
-0.26157572865486145,
-0.43495121598243713,
-0.16554462909698486,
-0.0650668740272522,
-0.02540936879813671,
0.8455440998077393,
0.6980063915252686,
0.2846081852912903,
-0.13081562519073486,
-0.3097357153892517,
-0.06300808489322662,
-0.26879799365997314,
0.08444540202617645,
-0.06543127447366714,
0.5444141030311584,
-0.1666973978281021,
-0.8451207280158997,
-0.6728971600532532,
0.6125347018241882,
0.4001691937446594,
-0.10391943156719208,
0.6257423162460327,
0.43030330538749695,
-0.21790772676467896,
-0.08347022533416748,
-0.5154269933700562,
-0.16663454473018646,
-0.5998464226722717,
0.17599175870418549,
-0.3381580710411072,
-0.8135148286819458,
0.7245578765869141,
0.1074921190738678,
0.2816995084285736,
0.23017868399620056,
0.3072347044944763,
-0.6164840459823608,
0.5081537961959839,
0.6471856832504272,
-0.02178703434765339,
0.3982868194580078,
-0.18819785118103027,
-0.02205289900302887,
-0.819878339767456,
-0.19317291676998138,
-0.05126159265637398,
-0.5312390923500061,
-0.48325756192207336,
-0.08885478973388672,
0.33141422271728516,
0.0977458655834198,
-0.17427878081798553,
0.3978225588798523,
-0.06166230887174606,
0.5109162330627441,
0.42706727981567383,
0.4126903712749481,
0.5047562718391418,
0.0002877211372833699,
0.0001456909376429394,
0.22042550146579742,
-0.33814820647239685,
-0.055853791534900665,
0.9945764541625977,
0.6324011087417603,
1.1187677383422852,
0.5715047121047974,
1.2264643907546997,
0.42021021246910095,
0.10657995939254761,
-0.7777531147003174,
0.5557950139045715,
-0.1600494682788849,
-0.6311294436454773,
-0.16028186678886414,
-0.2735130786895752,
-1.1663846969604492,
0.0032130021136254072,
-0.2008904665708542,
-0.9282204508781433,
0.033587440848350525,
0.269056499004364,
-0.7833800315856934,
0.46887484192848206,
-0.7835801243782043,
0.6832504272460938,
-0.1879766285419464,
-0.48265913128852844,
-0.3717345595359802,
-0.39837735891342163,
0.42458608746528625,
-0.3307194709777832,
0.27821996808052063,
0.08541593700647354,
-0.07101867347955704,
0.4942648112773895,
-0.32678458094596863,
1.1090433597564697,
-0.11156003177165985,
-0.4592868685722351,
0.05992284417152405,
0.38985109329223633,
0.39667755365371704,
0.39733436703681946,
0.18439576029777527,
0.22223129868507385,
-0.08568811416625977,
-0.2340492308139801,
-0.5016013383865356,
0.6113505959510803,
-0.8951932787895203,
-1.0216144323349,
-0.6225892305374146,
-0.5292467474937439,
-0.009188353084027767,
-0.031564392149448395,
0.3140096068382263,
0.284820556640625,
-0.3022308945655823,
-0.11440660059452057,
0.9093050956726074,
-0.342265784740448,
0.4689123034477234,
0.47496530413627625,
-0.4770812392234802,
-0.36845970153808594,
0.8238563537597656,
-0.07442615181207657,
0.5814582705497742,
0.11920709162950516,
0.2716381549835205,
0.201130211353302,
-0.8443505764007568,
-0.2681067883968353,
0.27777910232543945,
-0.34587034583091736,
-0.3166104555130005,
-0.31395167112350464,
-0.40918901562690735,
-0.07165010273456573,
-0.23124541342258453,
-0.41138961911201477,
-0.06529267877340317,
-0.22253860533237457,
-0.037784237414598465,
0.7349587082862854,
0.9834912419319153,
-0.34983140230178833,
0.696108341217041,
-0.537761390209198,
-0.006642748136073351,
0.5835651755332947,
0.4009557366371155,
-0.1917995810508728,
-0.526181697845459,
-0.316497802734375,
-0.06457450240850449,
-0.006588136311620474,
-0.7511821985244751,
0.17488421499729156,
-0.3719950020313263,
0.19469009339809418,
0.513992428779602,
-0.10222455859184265,
0.5016241073608398,
-0.3944093585014343,
0.36675962805747986,
0.34054768085479736,
-0.6028140187263489,
0.46288222074508667,
-0.6059569120407104,
-0.010224868543446064,
0.46011587977409363,
-0.03328965976834297,
-0.3558711111545563,
0.0667283684015274,
-0.5428555607795715,
-0.7161540985107422,
0.6183979511260986,
-0.020453987643122673,
0.10274849086999893,
0.35730797052383423,
0.18214952945709229,
0.17946277558803558,
0.13241691887378693,
-0.7892154455184937,
-0.0733601450920105,
0.030409006401896477,
0.28717219829559326,
0.4834200441837311,
-0.2793659567832947,
-0.6430062055587769,
0.5478668212890625,
0.604926347732544,
0.24086910486221313,
0.08583086729049683,
-0.32029709219932556,
-0.07681497931480408,
-0.10030996054410934,
0.3711102604866028,
0.35865840315818787,
0.0983627587556839,
-0.4486711621284485,
0.03228548541665077,
0.3412063419818878,
-0.46424272656440735,
-0.10143473744392395,
-0.12193004041910172,
-0.07626429945230484,
-0.5620676875114441,
0.18140020966529846,
0.35684362053871155,
0.28783249855041504,
-0.5355659127235413,
0.6468505263328552,
-0.11261128634214401,
-0.159364253282547,
-0.2967194616794586,
0.3434871435165405,
0.14969182014465332,
0.7186862826347351,
0.07170751690864563,
0.24133078753948212,
0.06984958052635193,
-0.8319070935249329,
0.053406935185194016,
0.6594306230545044,
-0.47577062249183655,
-0.43086859583854675,
-0.003643695032224059,
0.09662369638681412,
-0.4320734143257141,
-0.023358099162578583,
0.13149364292621613,
-0.4497925639152527,
0.3671048879623413,
0.4302216172218323,
0.7310339212417603,
-0.304815411567688,
-0.18251876533031464,
-0.255261093378067,
0.3459904193878174,
0.3050554096698761,
0.3593093156814575,
0.3496943414211273,
-0.7145039439201355,
-0.06583932787179947,
-0.16500189900398254,
-0.3684568703174591,
0.15048666298389435,
-0.8612387776374817,
0.13233938813209534,
-0.7516797780990601,
-0.1574302315711975,
-0.4183861017227173,
-0.06052923575043678,
-0.19122715294361115,
-0.15120773017406464,
0.1049741804599762,
1.0191234350204468,
-0.6997258067131042,
0.7199458479881287,
0.3462115526199341,
-0.23077166080474854,
-0.5576295852661133,
0.13412953913211823,
0.11202828586101532,
-1.0501649379730225,
0.5622302889823914,
0.2020118683576584,
-0.442602276802063,
-0.4029523432254791,
-0.3575005531311035,
-0.8180482387542725,
1.1334885358810425,
0.24860118329524994,
-0.3440565764904022,
-0.2623341381549835,
0.07991991937160492,
0.1530686318874359,
-0.236373633146286,
-0.3278202414512634,
0.4755585193634033,
0.22495803236961365,
0.18941588699817657,
-0.5806421041488647,
0.03939220681786537,
-0.031532950699329376,
-0.37954607605934143,
0.09519408643245697,
-0.5271691083908081,
0.8200584053993225,
-0.12828201055526733,
-0.20898421108722687,
0.3585703372955322,
0.4130925238132477,
0.5726970434188843,
0.5377053022384644,
0.5786116123199463,
0.7335717678070068,
0.34391504526138306,
0.16609561443328857,
0.7828307747840881,
-0.04157281294465065,
-0.2971586585044861,
1.2095834016799927,
-0.5034306645393372,
1.107795000076294,
0.7504559755325317,
0.13497239351272583,
0.21724630892276764,
0.43797776103019714,
0.1026177629828453,
0.5804746747016907,
0.2817160487174988,
-0.3594426214694977,
0.07733716815710068,
-0.16915467381477356,
-0.8559935092926025,
0.542026937007904,
0.5278186798095703,
0.06384534388780594,
0.01926412247121334,
-0.06038079038262367,
0.1642051488161087,
0.05781004950404167,
-0.5566203594207764,
0.8889416456222534,
0.2048569619655609,
-0.03777886554598808,
-0.07385408878326416,
-0.15302212536334991,
1.0668128728866577,
-0.8590992093086243,
0.27616429328918457,
-0.33023127913475037,
0.1872168928384781,
-0.5026577115058899,
-0.658955454826355,
0.215689554810524,
0.17169803380966187,
0.027667999267578125,
0.2371058464050293,
0.7802465558052063,
0.05741843953728676,
0.014573524706065655,
0.8247439861297607,
0.5873610973358154,
-0.05695408955216408,
-0.13193368911743164,
-0.5700290203094482,
0.35046127438545227,
-0.13176409900188446,
-0.1311459243297577,
0.8897418975830078,
0.45615068078041077,
0.22499464452266693,
0.617545485496521,
0.6103784441947937,
0.2304680347442627,
0.1774366796016693,
-0.025606021285057068,
1.078906536102295,
-0.48601654171943665,
-0.4592423737049103,
-0.9713211059570312,
0.4917307496070862,
-0.12518717348575592,
0.00008615206752438098,
0.8804024457931519,
0.4659295678138733,
0.5875846147537231,
0.19493572413921356,
0.6095229983329773,
0.20682983100414276,
0.5255236029624939,
-0.6659666299819946,
1.129483699798584,
-0.6974001526832581,
0.5439109802246094,
-0.43638738989830017,
-0.23781989514827728,
-0.1137368381023407,
0.21066977083683014,
-0.07345453649759293,
-0.3411118686199188,
0.48357728123664856,
0.8764612078666687,
-0.154747873544693,
-0.09614858031272888,
0.5183573961257935,
0.2656235098838806,
0.2057214081287384,
0.5287105441093445,
1.3737585544586182,
-0.4643594026565552,
0.6990808248519897,
-0.04136183112859726,
-0.14861789345741272,
-0.3715773820877075,
-1.0484510660171509,
-1.1734800338745117,
0.08037517964839935,
-0.2302013635635376,
-0.6408595442771912,
0.38059157133102417,
0.6342392563819885,
0.5810846090316772,
-0.5612128376960754,
-0.44942304491996765,
0.3816930055618286,
0.045783620327711105,
-0.060360874980688095,
-0.06092187017202377,
0.039856359362602234,
0.010328495875000954,
-0.07047247141599655,
0.7055676579475403,
0.3159908950328827,
0.13654324412345886,
-0.19780489802360535,
0.0002897271479014307,
-0.35498008131980896,
0.14426952600479126,
0.19664475321769714,
0.42911139130592346,
-0.6626665592193604,
-0.3717883825302124,
-0.05014561116695404,
-0.1274794340133667,
0.01757890172302723,
0.5453362464904785,
-0.4510912299156189,
0.09064333885908127,
0.09815477579832077,
0.7837864756584167,
0.3148050010204315,
-0.28095588088035583,
0.6756259799003601,
-0.8328782916069031,
0.05575374886393547,
-0.15130944550037384,
0.4444381594657898,
-0.014172934927046299,
-0.5280226469039917,
0.573611855506897,
0.1080181673169136,
-0.15541045367717743,
-0.9339035153388977,
0.6156752109527588,
-1.1768728494644165,
-0.28399601578712463,
0.8906373381614685,
-0.38832104206085205,
-0.44965681433677673,
-0.030381444841623306,
-0.17749838531017303,
0.16607627272605896,
-0.4767996668815613,
0.8261663317680359,
0.09550055116415024,
0.2845747768878937,
0.31722548604011536,
-0.33935999870300293,
0.3094140589237213,
0.04429688677191734,
-0.8637047410011292,
0.029914850369095802,
-0.03918800503015518,
0.3326982259750366,
0.19779707491397858,
0.07696610689163208,
-0.1465085744857788,
0.5463036298751831,
-0.19599460065364838,
-0.2660351097583771,
-0.3616009056568146,
-0.3089444935321808,
-0.5236348509788513,
0.38260579109191895,
0.19293731451034546,
-0.30013716220855713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00858v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00858v4
|
Direct Alignment of Draft Model for Speculative Decoding with Chat-Fine-Tuned LLMs
| 2024-02-29T19:55:06 | 2024-05-13T18:34:30 |
Raghavv Goel, Mukul Gagrani, Wonseok Jeon, Junyoung Park, Mingu Lee, Christopher Lott
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Text generation with Large Language Models (LLMs) is known to be memory bound
due to the combination of their auto-regressive nature, huge parameter counts,
and limited memory bandwidths, often resulting in low token rates. Speculative
decoding has been proposed as a solution for LLM inference acceleration.
However, since draft models are often unavailable in the modern open-source LLM
families, e.g., for Llama 2 7B, training a high-quality draft model is required
to enable inference acceleration via speculative decoding. In this paper, we
propose a simple draft model training framework for direct alignment to
chat-capable target models. With the proposed framework, we train Llama 2 Chat
Drafter 115M, a draft model for Llama 2 Chat 7B or larger, with only 1.64\% of
the original size. Our training framework only consists of pretraining,
distillation dataset generation, and finetuning with knowledge distillation,
with no additional alignment procedure. For the finetuning step, we use
instruction-response pairs generated by target model for distillation in
plausible data distribution, and propose a new Total Variation Distance++
(TVD++) loss that incorporates variance reduction techniques inspired from the
policy gradient method in reinforcement learning. Our empirical results show
that Llama 2 Chat Drafter 115M with speculative decoding achieves up to 2.3
block efficiency and 2.4$\times$ speed-up relative to autoregressive decoding
on various tasks with no further task-specific fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.04258161038160324,
-0.6900372505187988,
0.4373002350330353,
0.27839216589927673,
-0.544926106929779,
0.3025906980037689,
-0.18041853606700897,
-0.45460039377212524,
0.22348731756210327,
0.640393078327179,
-0.8147373795509338,
-0.366416335105896,
-0.6691433191299438,
-0.11802767217159271,
-0.3937961757183075,
0.7866665720939636,
-0.3098732829093933,
-0.04120054095983505,
0.01898873597383499,
0.34325817227363586,
-0.5185601115226746,
-0.39550548791885376,
-0.5287129282951355,
-0.18890009820461273,
0.3437115252017975,
0.4911497235298157,
0.40617823600769043,
0.9915960431098938,
0.5936545133590698,
0.2823260426521301,
-0.1760096549987793,
0.4320731461048126,
-1.0061492919921875,
0.16815029084682465,
0.13454946875572205,
-0.6696900129318237,
-0.5483759045600891,
-0.07704757899045944,
0.5670862197875977,
0.29110291600227356,
-0.24626587331295013,
0.09400346130132675,
0.04598322510719299,
0.5638147592544556,
-0.6110937595367432,
0.036997027695178986,
-1.0242584943771362,
-0.03556109964847565,
-0.35172510147094727,
-0.4407280683517456,
-0.5580397844314575,
-0.2337377518415451,
0.02552116848528385,
-0.7596818804740906,
0.34320157766342163,
0.3122580349445343,
0.9059451818466187,
0.521763026714325,
-0.44221004843711853,
-0.1767805814743042,
-0.9121677875518799,
0.6377318501472473,
-0.7806496620178223,
0.20408183336257935,
0.34823471307754517,
0.31530579924583435,
-0.4955025017261505,
-0.5024079084396362,
-0.7160986065864563,
0.024654800072312355,
0.19844144582748413,
0.07598639279603958,
-0.11717456579208374,
0.2656533718109131,
0.16230417788028717,
0.37913355231285095,
-0.52010178565979,
0.4934524595737457,
-0.32567861676216125,
-0.41003668308258057,
0.683872640132904,
0.41226258873939514,
-0.3469873368740082,
0.19169701635837555,
-0.5555680990219116,
-0.1999857872724533,
-0.6709979176521301,
-0.06739343702793121,
0.6549835801124573,
0.1888384073972702,
-0.23051440715789795,
0.5338646769523621,
-0.3467283248901367,
0.662651777267456,
0.5346242189407349,
-0.15516163408756256,
0.1375592052936554,
-0.23169760406017303,
-0.14257760345935822,
0.19713890552520752,
0.8012163639068604,
0.35746145248413086,
-0.02858605422079563,
-0.06872344017028809,
-0.11830110102891922,
0.20521245896816254,
0.2524814307689667,
-0.803449273109436,
-0.16446898877620697,
0.12849651277065277,
-0.29579493403434753,
-0.6225610375404358,
-0.1989092081785202,
-0.46917715668678284,
-0.45436346530914307,
-0.2407415807247162,
0.08117234706878662,
-0.34625041484832764,
-0.2966012954711914,
0.49624714255332947,
-0.01590980403125286,
0.4529525935649872,
0.4450693428516388,
-1.1291494369506836,
0.23822468519210815,
0.6468837261199951,
0.5645765662193298,
-0.2888581454753876,
-0.21749497950077057,
-0.4657147228717804,
0.3006224036216736,
-0.481533944606781,
0.9977536201477051,
-0.4380679428577423,
-0.3239764869213104,
-0.04877401515841484,
-0.27802103757858276,
0.028845947235822678,
-0.25234466791152954,
0.7923159599304199,
-0.6765334606170654,
-0.012145226821303368,
-0.08875858038663864,
-0.8620576858520508,
0.01752137392759323,
0.322934091091156,
-0.4853263199329376,
0.8580987453460693,
-0.18676809966564178,
-0.8462574481964111,
0.3559691905975342,
-0.16614727675914764,
-0.233793705701828,
-0.190140962600708,
-0.06484350562095642,
-0.2844946086406708,
0.10852586477994919,
0.2878449857234955,
0.4173201024532318,
-0.43604862689971924,
0.3690965175628662,
-0.4856264889240265,
-0.652062714099884,
0.2462390661239624,
-0.8397748470306396,
0.19172601401805878,
0.2879791259765625,
-0.09715864062309265,
0.06217191740870476,
-0.6616505980491638,
-0.07005762308835983,
0.1393510103225708,
-0.49325087666511536,
-0.04728313162922859,
0.14948983490467072,
-0.07305378466844559,
-0.006239134352654219,
0.32312968373298645,
-0.4396746754646301,
0.4393165707588196,
-0.4543205201625824,
0.20695869624614716,
0.7691848874092102,
-0.0502287782728672,
0.5044612288475037,
-0.4322369694709778,
0.3968270421028137,
0.2470894157886505,
-0.007946588099002838,
-0.020832553505897522,
-0.01497641857713461,
-0.839920163154602,
-0.3296217918395996,
0.3823668658733368,
0.46297702193260193,
-0.7085901498794556,
0.5049261450767517,
-0.3738137483596802,
-0.5022701621055603,
-0.5756210088729858,
0.205910786986351,
0.3520508110523224,
0.6091386675834656,
0.1536969095468521,
-0.011355453170835972,
-0.735289990901947,
-0.7889900207519531,
-0.045454781502485275,
-0.21124547719955444,
0.11584243178367615,
0.07579941302537918,
-0.03443904221057892,
-0.21707595884799957,
0.6332338452339172,
-0.565697431564331,
-0.21623145043849945,
-0.3791424632072449,
-0.009130389429628849,
0.12318053841590881,
0.5718414783477783,
0.2499002069234848,
-0.469922810792923,
-0.292334645986557,
-0.1072588637471199,
-0.5235424041748047,
-0.17214885354042053,
-0.13098350167274475,
-0.6067693829536438,
0.0729944258928299,
0.5765204429626465,
-0.7007836103439331,
0.2143591344356537,
0.6351940035820007,
-0.2255013883113861,
0.3481805622577667,
-0.11885473877191544,
-0.10499121993780136,
-1.401457667350769,
-0.18154162168502808,
-0.02061927504837513,
-0.1824212223291397,
-0.7170490622520447,
-0.1749008148908615,
0.049849025905132294,
0.1435161530971527,
-0.39199480414390564,
0.5039591193199158,
-0.5429948568344116,
0.2513657808303833,
-0.5574899315834045,
0.0721641406416893,
0.1424885243177414,
0.45490750670433044,
0.3157244026660919,
0.59055095911026,
0.38832107186317444,
-0.45278242230415344,
0.18323566019535065,
0.31850743293762207,
-0.23935867846012115,
0.11491188406944275,
-0.47728392481803894,
0.2944440543651581,
-0.13449867069721222,
0.5948911309242249,
-0.9726576209068298,
-0.2703627049922943,
0.4040682315826416,
-0.19669120013713837,
0.5800194144248962,
-0.0419352762401104,
-0.19158318638801575,
-0.35824307799339294,
-0.3094957172870636,
0.43332016468048096,
0.5815726518630981,
-0.46721750497817993,
0.38102149963378906,
0.234441876411438,
0.20720253884792328,
-0.9646169543266296,
-0.6065981388092041,
-0.14200685918331146,
-0.2748827338218689,
-0.5480853319168091,
0.47876566648483276,
0.032624900341033936,
0.04131545498967171,
-0.1537596583366394,
-0.3233463168144226,
-0.09455284476280212,
-0.03286976367235184,
0.22433529794216156,
0.41199809312820435,
-0.2997778356075287,
-0.08246079832315445,
0.32991114258766174,
-0.10046636313199997,
-0.14557398855686188,
-0.2854275405406952,
0.6780145168304443,
0.14202037453651428,
-0.3149639070034027,
-0.5073887705802917,
0.19914518296718597,
0.3019406497478485,
0.00807711761444807,
0.5777496695518494,
0.5174278616905212,
-0.13086757063865662,
-0.19629976153373718,
-0.9351494908332825,
-0.0991540178656578,
-0.5109479427337646,
0.4293960630893707,
-0.358475923538208,
-0.9630123376846313,
0.5569769740104675,
-0.20043744146823883,
0.07556229829788208,
0.4171374440193176,
0.495193213224411,
-0.16520586609840393,
0.72505122423172,
0.6890205144882202,
-0.19197113811969757,
0.5248615145683289,
-0.2446841299533844,
-0.16269266605377197,
-0.7678354978561401,
-0.1824525147676468,
-0.31803151965141296,
-0.612879753112793,
-0.28594595193862915,
-0.6413640975952148,
-0.27951323986053467,
0.40249142050743103,
-0.20103897154331207,
0.225343719124794,
-0.3431081771850586,
0.6367282271385193,
0.3062075078487396,
0.2388305962085724,
0.3535881042480469,
0.041809000074863434,
0.05254322662949562,
0.04347682371735573,
-0.742182731628418,
-0.5139237642288208,
1.1931211948394775,
0.49302440881729126,
1.1195182800292969,
-0.11707303673028946,
0.8156224489212036,
0.0815371572971344,
0.12701962888240814,
-0.7232447862625122,
0.4231979548931122,
-0.06688948720693588,
-0.40368983149528503,
-0.16785922646522522,
-0.47113895416259766,
-0.7228572368621826,
0.056800477206707,
-0.3593527674674988,
-0.5131561756134033,
0.23022443056106567,
0.4300040900707245,
-0.3037608861923218,
0.29412841796875,
-0.6290388107299805,
0.5672949552536011,
-0.12789735198020935,
-0.13726061582565308,
-0.2852078378200531,
-0.4847046434879303,
0.7907411456108093,
-0.09211137890815735,
-0.32434919476509094,
-0.3462600111961365,
-0.033972177654504776,
0.6053929328918457,
-0.4006383419036865,
0.89046311378479,
-0.18487685918807983,
-0.31941187381744385,
0.31992459297180176,
0.1804060935974121,
0.8454431295394897,
-0.005305455066263676,
-0.05663685128092766,
0.1560932695865631,
-0.0825464278459549,
-0.34062647819519043,
-0.4801104962825775,
0.5323021411895752,
-0.9843360781669617,
-0.6871852874755859,
-0.2726482152938843,
-0.6601221561431885,
-0.38344496488571167,
-0.0029974179342389107,
0.4887371361255646,
0.20794977247714996,
-0.3017236590385437,
-0.06235858052968979,
0.7668817043304443,
0.07834476232528687,
0.20559661090373993,
0.6869842410087585,
0.01040458120405674,
-0.16862185299396515,
0.7931568026542664,
-0.34116271138191223,
0.3199232518672943,
0.6598576307296753,
-0.1119597777724266,
-0.4363132119178772,
-0.9611570239067078,
-0.44636455178260803,
0.13814601302146912,
-0.40734434127807617,
-0.532124400138855,
-0.4502279460430145,
-0.3901880085468292,
-0.15973570942878723,
-0.09456387162208557,
-0.5275745391845703,
-0.2859806418418884,
-0.5626809597015381,
-0.10710567235946655,
0.48684176802635193,
0.4732561409473419,
0.1284344345331192,
0.6686179041862488,
-0.7569195032119751,
0.2649538815021515,
-0.07449910789728165,
0.25699055194854736,
-0.016799647361040115,
-0.895088255405426,
-0.11286409199237823,
0.33068034052848816,
-0.43419402837753296,
-0.5656083822250366,
0.3041161298751831,
0.17675599455833435,
0.38887378573417664,
0.5779705047607422,
0.2744396924972534,
0.9854124188423157,
-0.5647251009941101,
0.43970978260040283,
0.19654175639152527,
-0.7066826820373535,
0.351335734128952,
-0.4681069850921631,
0.19538258016109467,
0.6818305253982544,
0.23520249128341675,
-0.32930445671081543,
-0.4140125513076782,
-0.3075174391269684,
-0.44439172744750977,
0.847396731376648,
0.09024930745363235,
0.26318374276161194,
0.010042061097919941,
0.5374774932861328,
0.2508860230445862,
0.03309674933552742,
-0.25708672404289246,
0.030011476948857307,
-0.009059618227183819,
-0.39033257961273193,
-0.035355206578969955,
-0.5094324946403503,
-0.035482700914144516,
-0.025423530489206314,
0.6353446245193481,
-0.22212187945842743,
0.3729109466075897,
0.02357017621397972,
0.011705591343343258,
-0.26633742451667786,
0.03821944445371628,
0.5992415547370911,
0.12518087029457092,
-0.263939768075943,
-0.06323931366205215,
0.15822334587574005,
-0.6748510599136353,
0.4605254530906677,
0.2233334481716156,
0.06929198652505875,
-0.27591779828071594,
0.2655492126941681,
1.1355277299880981,
0.2388709932565689,
-0.5352936387062073,
0.4100980758666992,
-0.4287246763706207,
-0.464874804019928,
-0.027770021930336952,
0.23069892823696136,
0.16878753900527954,
0.5444595217704773,
0.37324774265289307,
0.20526418089866638,
-0.061261504888534546,
-0.07607155293226242,
-0.03848309814929962,
0.47791028022766113,
-0.1291002333164215,
-0.2641405165195465,
0.7421516180038452,
0.3829273581504822,
0.01719496212899685,
0.6751461625099182,
-0.19137068092823029,
-0.17842857539653778,
0.44132623076438904,
0.7211517691612244,
0.850237250328064,
0.06135119870305061,
0.07545982301235199,
0.15365663170814514,
0.020708909258246422,
-0.4229426681995392,
0.2998335361480713,
-0.005882973317056894,
-0.9480885863304138,
-0.6892996430397034,
-0.7895252108573914,
-0.42954912781715393,
0.2022896558046341,
-0.6240707635879517,
0.3673804700374603,
-0.34858232736587524,
-0.08430750668048859,
-0.34061557054519653,
0.09488695859909058,
-0.6938260793685913,
-0.14760391414165497,
0.36255067586898804,
0.995072066783905,
-0.5096678733825684,
1.0910762548446655,
0.2744956910610199,
0.0912843719124794,
-1.074942946434021,
0.20383703708648682,
-0.03248688578605652,
-0.8964613080024719,
0.468196302652359,
0.06727611273527145,
-0.025754883885383606,
0.12838415801525116,
-0.4362858235836029,
-1.1207964420318604,
1.2388391494750977,
0.801336944103241,
-1.0797444581985474,
-0.31916260719299316,
0.059102870523929596,
0.3898940980434418,
-0.38917896151542664,
0.16821883618831635,
0.4075865149497986,
-0.02586854249238968,
0.5446058511734009,
-0.8461978435516357,
0.04983455687761307,
-0.27781981229782104,
0.1333945095539093,
0.15716984868049622,
-0.8076093196868896,
0.5089698433876038,
-0.06349638104438782,
-0.2305358499288559,
0.2732216417789459,
0.9312303066253662,
0.35993924736976624,
-0.014046710915863514,
0.2688431739807129,
0.5268620252609253,
0.7902962565422058,
-0.02443377673625946,
0.7856300473213196,
-0.4314664602279663,
0.0826692134141922,
1.1229299306869507,
-0.4386521577835083,
0.9603938460350037,
0.4321315884590149,
0.032806072384119034,
0.31765222549438477,
0.8143932819366455,
0.31329861283302307,
0.6351724863052368,
0.15965773165225983,
-0.19931218028068542,
-0.2872646152973175,
0.038418009877204895,
-0.3772364556789398,
0.5659859776496887,
0.41385430097579956,
-0.22522859275341034,
-0.10019983351230621,
-0.20852942764759064,
-0.18129536509513855,
-0.06537722796201706,
-0.19378787279129028,
0.8699175119400024,
0.05283576622605324,
-0.5905671715736389,
0.9540790915489197,
-0.016434824094176292,
0.9523334503173828,
-0.7528659701347351,
0.18579696118831635,
-0.3941097855567932,
0.3961883783340454,
0.02585332840681076,
-0.53519207239151,
0.2574717104434967,
0.055663950741291046,
-0.26350677013397217,
-0.06888994574546814,
0.6940780878067017,
-0.5221977233886719,
-0.5200618505477905,
0.08765579015016556,
0.36973926424980164,
0.03532644733786583,
0.08651891350746155,
-0.5088609457015991,
0.4458863437175751,
0.09820496290922165,
-0.36064431071281433,
0.4780898690223694,
0.6044062972068787,
0.02704618126153946,
0.5279402136802673,
0.7256944179534912,
0.15758377313613892,
0.1686185598373413,
-0.10479126870632172,
1.0673264265060425,
-0.4423880875110626,
-0.4280364513397217,
-0.8926733732223511,
0.2726963460445404,
0.051000408828258514,
-0.34715554118156433,
0.4976203441619873,
0.3387763500213623,
0.7323704361915588,
0.0007535145850852132,
0.5603851079940796,
0.23607373237609863,
0.2656994163990021,
-0.6805334687232971,
0.45256128907203674,
-0.14240331947803497,
0.370510071516037,
-0.13447514176368713,
-0.9985643029212952,
0.09738948941230774,
0.3991042673587799,
-0.24750202894210815,
-0.372234970331192,
0.3035600185394287,
0.900985062122345,
-0.08737605810165405,
-0.008805741555988789,
0.16775619983673096,
0.08335449546575546,
0.26314297318458557,
0.7429013252258301,
0.967315673828125,
-0.46255165338516235,
0.7070255875587463,
-0.1992834359407425,
-0.07025577127933502,
-0.2277260571718216,
-0.8936598300933838,
-0.979089617729187,
-0.3485391139984131,
-0.16774970293045044,
-0.21157324314117432,
0.14786513149738312,
0.9290992617607117,
0.6177409887313843,
-0.4517350494861603,
-0.24036531150341034,
-0.2597912549972534,
-0.21122945845127106,
-0.08075490593910217,
-0.17785707116127014,
0.20108798146247864,
-0.2944355309009552,
-0.5940343141555786,
0.4884912073612213,
-0.026085590943694115,
0.41805577278137207,
-0.0921521931886673,
-0.3392477035522461,
-0.1323515623807907,
0.14566482603549957,
0.29441583156585693,
0.2687629163265228,
-0.7657034993171692,
-0.07828134298324585,
0.08026348054409027,
-0.22876495122909546,
-0.00789936725050211,
0.6323927640914917,
-0.7423295378684998,
0.19052410125732422,
0.3885668218135834,
0.7982827425003052,
0.7571996450424194,
0.26108378171920776,
0.7772488594055176,
-0.8052627444267273,
0.6055873036384583,
0.2614079713821411,
0.1689886450767517,
0.05728405714035034,
-0.5608646869659424,
0.13582083582878113,
0.008276429958641529,
-0.4640631675720215,
-0.8842583894729614,
0.05045167729258537,
-1.0551377534866333,
0.016107412055134773,
1.2470241785049438,
0.06852428615093231,
-0.24384045600891113,
0.29128703474998474,
-0.575587809085846,
0.396857351064682,
-0.579711377620697,
0.7218553423881531,
0.533890962600708,
-0.012445516884326935,
-0.10421052575111389,
-0.1494370400905609,
0.6309576630592346,
0.29120248556137085,
-0.6281887888908386,
0.32815542817115784,
0.5289903283119202,
0.05418061465024948,
-0.19156989455223083,
0.7727489471435547,
0.19833293557167053,
0.08316401392221451,
0.309008926153183,
-0.011081424541771412,
-0.21944013237953186,
-0.1453910619020462,
-0.2055439054965973,
-0.2094424068927765,
0.21909920871257782,
-0.18680340051651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00092v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00092v2
|
PROC2PDDL: Open-Domain Planning Representations from Texts
| 2024-02-29T19:40:25 | 2024-07-02T04:50:36 |
Tianyi Zhang, Li Zhang, Zhaoyi Hou, Ziyu Wang, Yuling Gu, Peter Clark, Chris Callison-Burch, Niket Tandon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Planning in a text-based environment continues to be a major challenge for AI
systems. Recent approaches have used language models to predict a planning
domain definition (e.g., PDDL) but have only been evaluated in closed-domain
simulated environments. To address this, we present Proc2PDDL , the first
dataset containing open-domain procedural texts paired with expert-annotated
PDDL representations. Using this dataset, we evaluate state-of-the-art models
on defining the preconditions and effects of actions. We show that Proc2PDDL is
highly challenging, with GPT-3.5's success rate close to 0% and GPT-4's around
35%. Our analysis shows both syntactic and semantic errors, indicating LMs'
deficiency in both generating domain-specific prgorams and reasoning about
events. We hope this analysis and dataset helps future progress towards
integrating the best of LMs and formal planning.
|
[
-0.22826407849788666,
-0.7569804787635803,
0.7443925738334656,
0.2660783529281616,
0.06691142171621323,
-0.13606923818588257,
-0.28740614652633667,
-0.08283897489309311,
-0.18720580637454987,
0.5928083658218384,
-0.7696018218994141,
-0.5500162243843079,
-0.38254010677337646,
-0.021357540041208267,
0.01917584426701069,
1.0191535949707031,
-0.7370192408561707,
0.1586296558380127,
-0.41113707423210144,
0.14211405813694,
-0.4140660762786865,
-0.7213979363441467,
-0.43724560737609863,
-0.4123881757259369,
0.10173958539962769,
0.3056785464286804,
0.8082149624824524,
0.028396906331181526,
0.4483833611011505,
0.040093835443258286,
0.1797131448984146,
0.5295987725257874,
-0.41333287954330444,
-0.04757742956280708,
-0.30113330483436584,
0.008414927870035172,
-0.48520413041114807,
0.08494196087121964,
0.3859879970550537,
0.5600194931030273,
-0.25466305017471313,
-0.3214515447616577,
-0.018013939261436462,
0.4424130916595459,
-0.5328907370567322,
0.8397009372711182,
-0.25476327538490295,
0.1521397829055786,
-0.11501923203468323,
-0.13390934467315674,
-0.44336235523223877,
-0.23810279369354248,
0.34002628922462463,
-0.8821000456809998,
0.12677668035030365,
-0.1300647109746933,
0.38581860065460205,
0.3034299612045288,
-0.13084836304187775,
-0.61240154504776,
-1.1648098230361938,
0.41571497917175293,
-0.40782612562179565,
0.08629146963357925,
0.7370206117630005,
0.2631155252456665,
-0.5494371652603149,
-0.8598418235778809,
-0.8553537130355835,
0.06576436758041382,
-0.18415091931819916,
0.1834222376346588,
0.10663080215454102,
0.25589340925216675,
0.20893271267414093,
-0.23226548731327057,
-0.6965218186378479,
0.1874476820230484,
-0.3964843153953552,
-0.131539449095726,
0.6718159317970276,
0.23359018564224243,
-0.05428691953420639,
0.34023329615592957,
-0.36823880672454834,
-0.008534505032002926,
-0.9612785577774048,
-0.12032344192266464,
0.29152926802635193,
0.1965090036392212,
-0.10846477001905441,
0.8447372317314148,
0.07250512391328812,
0.4813258647918701,
-0.3175339698791504,
0.061273250728845596,
-0.08855683356523514,
-0.5307225584983826,
-0.33878132700920105,
-0.16312693059444427,
0.621057391166687,
0.48650577664375305,
0.8229936957359314,
-0.08265715092420578,
-0.3426581025123596,
-0.17631413042545319,
0.24594146013259888,
-0.6697328686714172,
-0.603064239025116,
0.48226800560951233,
-0.19028739631175995,
-0.021214602515101433,
-0.038754697889089584,
-0.6190212368965149,
-0.5833373069763184,
-0.3250023424625397,
0.26610830426216125,
-0.42164281010627747,
-0.4103422164916992,
0.21789512038230896,
0.1542268991470337,
0.08628497272729874,
0.4905562698841095,
-0.7506815791130066,
0.5519891381263733,
0.6389190554618835,
0.5860670804977417,
-0.12661653757095337,
-0.31053054332733154,
-0.20602373778820038,
0.23820970952510834,
-0.6300608515739441,
1.0713144540786743,
-0.45035260915756226,
-0.7019098997116089,
0.34396615624427795,
-0.24923112988471985,
-0.07620719820261002,
-0.7065228819847107,
0.6884843707084656,
-0.3790530860424042,
0.23910056054592133,
-0.24894581735134125,
-0.5170485377311707,
-0.03006347455084324,
0.1310870200395584,
-0.7015511393547058,
1.0283170938491821,
0.2505967319011688,
-0.5565558671951294,
0.36101603507995605,
-0.8026506304740906,
-0.4036335349082947,
0.07820861041545868,
-0.5468815565109253,
-0.2127254605293274,
-0.24406123161315918,
-0.0044867717660963535,
0.3696692883968353,
-0.42515477538108826,
0.4257533550262451,
0.12505406141281128,
-0.042900849133729935,
0.03969999775290489,
-0.04583681374788284,
0.5077683925628662,
-0.07708540558815002,
-0.26597046852111816,
0.3520633578300476,
-0.47202223539352417,
0.07982994616031647,
0.17971386015415192,
-0.1703939437866211,
-0.1375860571861267,
0.5884326100349426,
-0.013126976788043976,
0.24476397037506104,
0.09751562029123306,
-0.21258188784122467,
0.49271124601364136,
-0.3373911380767822,
0.19492536783218384,
0.8866886496543884,
0.01566186361014843,
0.635364830493927,
-0.17042744159698486,
0.5201990008354187,
0.07622043043375015,
-0.07699001580476761,
-0.109369657933712,
-0.8110017776489258,
-0.27809324860572815,
0.09682063013315201,
0.2263096421957016,
0.5768105983734131,
-1.009833574295044,
0.30183693766593933,
0.01961534656584263,
-0.36960285902023315,
-0.14693354070186615,
-0.3940546214580536,
0.47773224115371704,
0.3122234642505646,
0.46587711572647095,
-0.25423741340637207,
-0.3576284348964691,
-0.6202106475830078,
0.09420282393693924,
-0.3634805977344513,
0.0231793075799942,
0.2603744864463806,
0.60526442527771,
-0.03979445621371269,
1.1732773780822754,
-0.5133809447288513,
-0.6356751918792725,
-0.3695549964904785,
0.232610285282135,
-0.05027821287512779,
0.4663056433200836,
0.4545900523662567,
-0.8695147633552551,
-0.2673064172267914,
-0.2303258627653122,
-0.6807635426521301,
-0.018838226795196533,
-0.45466798543930054,
-0.12367244064807892,
0.24545922875404358,
0.1615515649318695,
-0.8640787601470947,
0.7174426317214966,
0.2518047094345093,
-0.6277472972869873,
1.0761560201644897,
-0.5294727683067322,
-0.3110959529876709,
-0.6144706606864929,
-0.08973752707242966,
0.10449136793613434,
0.1198887899518013,
-0.8420986533164978,
0.0706750825047493,
0.04090317711234093,
-0.1153627410531044,
-0.44151443243026733,
0.8064945936203003,
-0.3454684913158417,
-0.3106107711791992,
0.012945306487381458,
0.12913841009140015,
-0.27758926153182983,
0.6082355380058289,
0.632785439491272,
0.913591742515564,
0.447869211435318,
-0.67110276222229,
0.25709399580955505,
0.4899589419364929,
-0.4122403860092163,
0.1837875247001648,
-0.4966752231121063,
0.15493786334991455,
-0.1503496766090393,
0.5284121036529541,
-0.438882440328598,
-0.42861419916152954,
0.48566722869873047,
-0.23237238824367523,
0.1073806956410408,
0.08389407396316528,
-0.7704751491546631,
-0.230706125497818,
-0.12452592700719833,
0.3607863783836365,
0.4424160122871399,
-0.24284334480762482,
0.5315772294998169,
0.32634031772613525,
-0.24308240413665771,
-0.31828758120536804,
-0.4882583022117615,
-0.061933863908052444,
0.3560529053211212,
-0.34055179357528687,
0.5555723905563354,
-0.12679795920848846,
-0.49028781056404114,
0.17001117765903473,
-0.03124077245593071,
-0.20296870172023773,
-0.08441358804702759,
0.28335055708885193,
0.04251052439212799,
-0.007754263002425432,
-0.1288243532180786,
-0.07915499806404114,
-0.17615269124507904,
0.21431304514408112,
-0.4968940317630768,
0.671668529510498,
0.44425660371780396,
-0.37397751212120056,
-0.5088554620742798,
0.34658634662628174,
0.29311859607696533,
-0.34602826833724976,
0.8454879522323608,
0.12284265458583832,
-0.8202601075172424,
-0.43553081154823303,
0.1375432014465332,
0.09619385749101639,
-0.36876076459884644,
0.357471764087677,
-0.46690985560417175,
-0.2578943073749542,
0.2591291069984436,
-0.22496959567070007,
0.1831987053155899,
0.4088517427444458,
0.7435188293457031,
-0.13900843262672424,
0.8039539456367493,
0.5348234176635742,
0.6349111795425415,
-0.07889809459447861,
-0.4731077253818512,
0.26766273379325867,
-0.6386334896087646,
-0.8472045660018921,
-0.3367865979671478,
-0.14146438241004944,
-0.27690890431404114,
-0.9709324240684509,
0.1661120057106018,
0.2661120295524597,
-0.30336615443229675,
0.23401294648647308,
-0.10042152553796768,
0.4096762239933014,
0.5052213668823242,
-0.19360589981079102,
-0.01575261540710926,
-0.06929805874824524,
-0.31447842717170715,
-0.14299270510673523,
-0.4689734876155853,
-0.8737974166870117,
0.9895917773246765,
0.26086845993995667,
0.6273496150970459,
0.1893015056848526,
0.38019660115242004,
0.4047858715057373,
0.08169234544038773,
-0.669949471950531,
0.7596501111984253,
-0.08098351210355759,
-0.401824414730072,
-0.2593303322792053,
-0.1065807044506073,
-0.6559337973594666,
-0.18173164129257202,
-0.11134762316942215,
-0.5384025573730469,
0.4243531823158264,
-0.08093874901533127,
-0.461178719997406,
0.1933639943599701,
-0.6466234922409058,
0.8736934661865234,
-0.26509231328964233,
-0.24210980534553528,
-0.1800740510225296,
-0.3488587439060211,
0.08519814908504486,
-0.3325623869895935,
0.18371105194091797,
-0.10888522118330002,
-0.15179738402366638,
0.710170328617096,
-0.523840606212616,
0.708296000957489,
-0.501327395439148,
-0.24288693070411682,
0.5604950189590454,
0.2782265543937683,
0.8064799308776855,
-0.030294032767415047,
-0.32201918959617615,
-0.11691749840974808,
-0.149963840842247,
-0.35894161462783813,
-0.5245802998542786,
0.4500071704387665,
-0.8292258977890015,
-0.2302725464105606,
-0.5461413860321045,
-0.3152470886707306,
-0.2865019142627716,
0.08785188943147659,
-0.009182006120681763,
0.7134474515914917,
-0.5400819778442383,
-0.42086678743362427,
0.5407730340957642,
-0.3620723783969879,
0.3866077959537506,
0.4433023929595947,
-0.33704355359077454,
0.013931545428931713,
0.7482650876045227,
0.2889735996723175,
0.12202650308609009,
0.0742330476641655,
-0.21629677712917328,
-0.4456671178340912,
-0.9100797176361084,
-0.4161708354949951,
-0.007805114611983299,
-0.6921684145927429,
-0.03995034843683243,
-0.447969913482666,
-0.30384179949760437,
-0.3881068527698517,
-0.1947731226682663,
-0.12243760377168655,
-0.5394291877746582,
-0.4932721257209778,
-0.19954557716846466,
-0.10388030856847763,
1.0972065925598145,
0.01939341612160206,
0.2223351001739502,
-0.29225221276283264,
0.4100475311279297,
-0.22009585797786713,
0.43732208013534546,
-0.3963544964790344,
0.1391049474477768,
-0.10396474599838257,
0.06786195188760757,
-0.3243260085582733,
-0.9076030850410461,
0.47679340839385986,
0.2865852415561676,
0.6891124844551086,
0.17977601289749146,
0.4211350679397583,
0.3696679472923279,
-0.6785159111022949,
1.0480382442474365,
-0.1251724362373352,
-0.2871277630329132,
0.7019838690757751,
-0.22545795142650604,
0.043859247118234634,
0.2965233623981476,
0.8016437888145447,
-0.14659054577350616,
0.04317793995141983,
-0.6435036063194275,
-0.7135135531425476,
0.9672155976295471,
0.5145921111106873,
-0.3335025906562805,
-0.19041208922863007,
0.5508648157119751,
0.164779394865036,
0.04574035480618477,
-0.39951902627944946,
-0.10521950572729111,
0.012426205910742283,
-0.20521998405456543,
-0.1034211739897728,
-0.4334743320941925,
-0.14770148694515228,
0.050633545964956284,
0.5237587690353394,
-0.12244637310504913,
0.6916372179985046,
0.29642194509506226,
-0.14052040874958038,
-0.013734135776758194,
-0.15861891210079193,
0.8597026467323303,
0.8488975763320923,
-0.18353745341300964,
0.09416548907756805,
-0.07365153729915619,
-0.4988887906074524,
-0.058546025305986404,
0.28458109498023987,
-0.13669182360172272,
-0.10878686606884003,
0.6021968126296997,
0.6410586833953857,
-0.04780543968081474,
-0.9698367118835449,
0.41217753291130066,
-0.0795559361577034,
-0.32709816098213196,
-0.6363756656646729,
-0.10330154746770859,
-0.2280614972114563,
0.21064552664756775,
0.2736048698425293,
0.23552414774894714,
-0.21801601350307465,
-0.6673216223716736,
0.19297678768634796,
-0.008612697944045067,
-0.39618268609046936,
-0.5807072520256042,
0.6638857126235962,
0.396859735250473,
-0.4582166075706482,
0.6094761490821838,
-0.6535505652427673,
-0.5850417017936707,
0.7341791987419128,
0.5090014934539795,
0.7235759496688843,
-0.03497280925512314,
0.38332459330558777,
0.3409891426563263,
0.2695959508419037,
-0.2119363695383072,
0.7263410687446594,
0.09729590266942978,
-0.710689127445221,
-0.39000433683395386,
-0.6048391461372375,
-0.5814232230186462,
-0.13364683091640472,
-0.15279795229434967,
0.4074602723121643,
-0.6911717057228088,
0.011539905332028866,
-0.33533740043640137,
0.11495914310216904,
-0.6879599690437317,
0.1587829887866974,
-0.08318514376878738,
1.221939206123352,
-0.5097326040267944,
1.0528080463409424,
0.9448958039283752,
-0.43238717317581177,
-0.5611051321029663,
0.3111499845981598,
0.12552079558372498,
-0.6352065801620483,
0.724463939666748,
-0.052765700966119766,
0.04244472086429596,
0.013936602510511875,
-0.1483304351568222,
-0.31388866901397705,
1.1263158321380615,
0.0020818798802793026,
-0.5484841465950012,
-0.3928000032901764,
0.41729268431663513,
0.5380791425704956,
-0.5444768667221069,
0.27701449394226074,
0.7824565768241882,
0.5307732224464417,
-0.044980160892009735,
-1.037270188331604,
-0.0887097716331482,
0.008377754129469395,
-0.37847331166267395,
0.10289347171783447,
-0.2883513271808624,
0.822798490524292,
-0.5060345530509949,
-0.3441036343574524,
0.13740122318267822,
0.5828437209129333,
0.08832791447639465,
0.47218361496925354,
0.11723936349153519,
0.37004169821739197,
0.7601205706596375,
-0.3323521018028259,
1.1061571836471558,
-0.10651730746030807,
0.2520870268344879,
1.2095487117767334,
-0.7254496216773987,
1.0105677843093872,
-0.06197236850857735,
-0.29986998438835144,
0.4066435694694519,
0.7623557448387146,
0.3320521116256714,
0.9853377342224121,
0.26823729276657104,
-0.397589772939682,
0.043042950332164764,
-0.09849532693624496,
-0.2341679483652115,
0.19172853231430054,
0.590419352054596,
-0.015651721507310867,
-0.25705835223197937,
-0.02332969568669796,
-0.04704141244292259,
0.3189436197280884,
-0.21657367050647736,
0.8091483116149902,
-0.16656559705734253,
-0.747499406337738,
0.1851741373538971,
0.26385733485221863,
0.26272574067115784,
-0.4149898886680603,
-0.1249794289469719,
-0.24625833332538605,
0.3054324984550476,
-0.03412661328911781,
-1.3848518133163452,
0.5410701036453247,
0.07210257649421692,
-0.05270325019955635,
-0.5795190930366516,
0.7247123122215271,
-0.3676055073738098,
-0.18814760446548462,
0.243875652551651,
0.4699314832687378,
0.24623176455497742,
-0.17193935811519623,
-0.4976169764995575,
-0.09452974796295166,
-0.11812106519937515,
-0.18764908611774445,
0.2614458203315735,
0.5894091129302979,
-0.3829105496406555,
0.4060527980327606,
0.32323604822158813,
0.11695721745491028,
-0.17714805901050568,
-0.07817347347736359,
0.9566306471824646,
-0.5055771470069885,
-0.29760682582855225,
-0.5523191690444946,
0.4960513412952423,
0.06646716594696045,
-0.2998298704624176,
0.05184523016214371,
0.565353274345398,
0.9586813449859619,
0.016593366861343384,
0.8548961281776428,
-0.20372343063354492,
0.21177931129932404,
-0.7228921055793762,
0.4830431342124939,
0.009435078129172325,
0.27248916029930115,
0.2272241860628128,
-0.9121826887130737,
-0.25125738978385925,
0.6423032283782959,
-0.4833407402038574,
-0.14732575416564941,
0.7808539271354675,
0.7034217119216919,
0.17360331118106842,
0.003928004298359156,
0.12137060612440109,
0.2027163803577423,
0.6302446126937866,
0.6596099734306335,
0.7303585410118103,
-0.06801152229309082,
0.38714084029197693,
-0.10849663615226746,
-0.44494614005088806,
-0.1056506335735321,
-0.7902452945709229,
-0.9795053601264954,
-0.8906667828559875,
-0.24874581396579742,
-0.3042355477809906,
0.40583711862564087,
1.045814037322998,
0.47669893503189087,
-0.634387195110321,
-0.07181074470281601,
-0.3055074214935303,
-0.09149045497179031,
-0.10770504921674728,
-0.13764634728431702,
0.5246999263763428,
-0.1315326988697052,
-0.5086344480514526,
0.5055607557296753,
0.13444747030735016,
0.1740848571062088,
-0.5185834765434265,
-0.5855094790458679,
-0.2055206447839737,
0.1462680548429489,
0.6434639692306519,
0.29868292808532715,
-0.6346890330314636,
-0.1592431366443634,
-0.1864665001630783,
-0.0276643019169569,
-0.2370944321155548,
1.1145211458206177,
-1.0132980346679688,
0.40973109006881714,
0.3011751174926758,
0.34597522020339966,
0.33339181542396545,
-0.048101913183927536,
0.8781185150146484,
-0.8912864327430725,
0.16898193955421448,
0.5525854825973511,
0.15337857604026794,
0.0026434941682964563,
-0.10059874504804611,
0.8028635382652283,
0.25392594933509827,
-0.4804564118385315,
-0.6839784383773804,
0.2902183532714844,
-0.7790825963020325,
-0.3812291920185089,
1.3192880153656006,
-0.2959423065185547,
0.15206778049468994,
-0.3128168284893036,
-0.5612767338752747,
0.0690767765045166,
-0.16187843680381775,
0.38216790556907654,
0.7889109253883362,
-0.4223617911338806,
0.023587817326188087,
-0.8407714366912842,
0.9159281253814697,
-0.0057986644096672535,
-0.88642817735672,
0.45322832465171814,
0.6887110471725464,
-0.32159802317619324,
0.04372898489236832,
1.1440626382827759,
0.017252469435334206,
0.23357385396957397,
0.005534767173230648,
0.02066126838326454,
-0.23072771728038788,
-0.7578061819076538,
0.11177561432123184,
0.2059418112039566,
0.16952800750732422,
0.2599087953567505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00071v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00071v2
|
Resonance RoPE: Improving Context Length Generalization of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-29T19:02:03 | 2024-06-10T13:30:34 |
Suyuchen Wang, Ivan Kobyzev, Peng Lu, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Bang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper addresses the challenge of train-short-test-long (TSTL) scenarios
in Large Language Models (LLMs) equipped with Rotary Position Embedding (RoPE),
where models pre-trained on shorter sequences face difficulty with
out-of-distribution (OOD) token positions in longer sequences. We introduce
Resonance RoPE, a novel approach designed to narrow the generalization gap in
TSTL scenarios by refining the interpolation of RoPE features for OOD
positions, significantly improving the model performance without additional
online computational costs. Furthermore, we present PosGen, a new synthetic
benchmark specifically designed for fine-grained behavior analysis in TSTL
scenarios, aiming to isolate the constantly increasing difficulty of token
generation on long contexts from the challenges of recognizing new token
positions. Our experiments on synthetic tasks show that after applying
Resonance RoPE, Transformers recognize OOD position better and more robustly.
Our extensive LLM experiments also show superior performance after applying
Resonance RoPE to the current state-of-the-art RoPE scaling method, YaRN, on
both upstream language modeling tasks and a variety of downstream long-text
applications.
|
[
-0.5893679261207581,
-0.8404045701026917,
0.18496066331863403,
0.0396156869828701,
-0.4701469838619232,
-0.09782855212688446,
-0.5807569622993469,
-0.5569903254508972,
0.01649435982108116,
0.27586087584495544,
-0.17820917069911957,
-0.5516104102134705,
-0.511375367641449,
-0.023042913526296616,
-0.5307464003562927,
0.9799667596817017,
-0.04761170968413353,
-0.20852228999137878,
0.19375404715538025,
-0.4799184501171112,
-0.12374312430620193,
-0.5181007981300354,
-0.44843581318855286,
-0.2815391421318054,
0.6019852757453918,
0.155115008354187,
0.5294339656829834,
0.45448023080825806,
0.3642809987068176,
0.27371785044670105,
-0.35203638672828674,
0.052207157015800476,
-0.4515618085861206,
0.1647329479455948,
-0.1875690221786499,
-0.15404824912548065,
-0.46300023794174194,
-0.13110487163066864,
0.866439700126648,
0.5389700531959534,
-0.25583285093307495,
0.18023556470870972,
0.0008565267198719084,
0.4821118712425232,
-0.503967821598053,
0.03811851516366005,
-0.5977799892425537,
-0.013573646545410156,
-0.4727992117404938,
-0.12209272384643555,
-0.31582316756248474,
-0.10595071315765381,
0.33176010847091675,
-0.29901206493377686,
0.36119288206100464,
0.33174362778663635,
0.7493546009063721,
-0.03538293391466141,
-0.5084009170532227,
-0.24698251485824585,
-0.7797890305519104,
1.0147370100021362,
-0.8764973878860474,
0.4509720504283905,
0.2780037820339203,
0.541450560092926,
-0.3566195070743561,
-0.7454946637153625,
-0.5986865162849426,
-0.26967909932136536,
-0.016939502209424973,
-0.32969415187835693,
0.34026944637298584,
0.19636240601539612,
0.3405322730541229,
0.3832770884037018,
-0.43241965770721436,
0.008026923052966595,
-0.2615785300731659,
0.18762549757957458,
0.6797376275062561,
0.06393097341060638,
0.2220727801322937,
0.17387397587299347,
-0.17005012929439545,
-0.3687542676925659,
-0.5899912714958191,
0.24039018154144287,
0.3641825318336487,
0.5376326441764832,
-0.20972226560115814,
0.5656906962394714,
0.12269311398267746,
0.8370119333267212,
0.07563897222280502,
-0.016246473416686058,
0.22964006662368774,
-0.175213024020195,
-0.014581006020307541,
0.16613568365573883,
0.6114336252212524,
0.18073280155658722,
0.14145605266094208,
-0.025284478440880775,
-0.3711283504962921,
-0.3128865957260132,
0.14004173874855042,
-0.7032505869865417,
0.06241970881819725,
0.1328396201133728,
-0.3671940863132477,
-0.023061493411660194,
0.2576111853122711,
-0.9335592985153198,
-0.5129489898681641,
-0.24490350484848022,
0.1529054194688797,
-0.3001115322113037,
-0.3585464060306549,
0.43528154492378235,
-0.17251740396022797,
0.6917705535888672,
-0.021567588672041893,
-0.9820061326026917,
0.401198148727417,
0.9456722140312195,
0.9608786702156067,
-0.21968279778957367,
-0.2699601650238037,
-0.888187050819397,
0.26341497898101807,
-0.2297496646642685,
0.37868669629096985,
-0.7236164808273315,
-0.352282851934433,
0.22732411324977875,
-0.048991478979587555,
-0.07924159616231918,
-0.588129997253418,
0.5410656929016113,
-0.5731086134910583,
0.07585591822862625,
0.19335883855819702,
-0.5067402720451355,
0.14929743111133575,
0.11339190602302551,
-0.5764738321304321,
1.0918420553207397,
0.38737550377845764,
-0.7340593338012695,
0.0305264163762331,
-0.6507476568222046,
-0.6554406881332397,
-0.3886377513408661,
-0.1962711066007614,
-0.4633396863937378,
0.4538842737674713,
0.02431563474237919,
0.06507261842489243,
-0.4878632724285126,
0.15671642124652863,
-0.31491994857788086,
-0.5809550285339355,
0.33167633414268494,
-0.16610117256641388,
0.28404584527015686,
0.1576376110315323,
-0.303266316652298,
0.17735783755779266,
-0.4589139223098755,
0.04093538597226143,
-0.12370873987674713,
-0.3239578902721405,
-0.5115566253662109,
0.14616751670837402,
0.20870445668697357,
0.09935931116342545,
-0.06562140583992004,
-0.47823864221572876,
0.4045323133468628,
-0.7697122693061829,
0.8086719512939453,
0.5935853719711304,
-0.21554161608219147,
0.6351860165596008,
-0.3188875913619995,
0.585235595703125,
-0.12365960329771042,
-0.009086824022233486,
-0.18095292150974274,
-0.3784754276275635,
-0.5282256603240967,
-0.14473678171634674,
0.5130125284194946,
0.04868081212043762,
-0.5291124582290649,
0.42128875851631165,
-0.4925967752933502,
-0.23443099856376648,
-0.3531961739063263,
-0.1896561235189438,
0.36415061354637146,
0.25601381063461304,
0.48743969202041626,
-0.3547220528125763,
-0.5213794708251953,
-0.5827215909957886,
-0.6213765740394592,
-0.022801527753472328,
-0.36984699964523315,
0.05045437440276146,
0.3975238502025604,
-0.2213636040687561,
1.1189278364181519,
-0.3601810038089752,
-0.4140024781227112,
-0.35765987634658813,
0.25753283500671387,
0.5177783966064453,
0.5685844421386719,
0.37967202067375183,
-0.7767642736434937,
-0.5499409437179565,
0.226313516497612,
-0.2839418053627014,
0.12516623735427856,
0.09006324410438538,
0.14484873414039612,
0.3609541058540344,
0.4675463140010834,
-0.6704363226890564,
0.3898240327835083,
0.7047184109687805,
-0.10970920324325562,
0.42491617798805237,
-0.23915305733680725,
-0.06356893479824066,
-0.8733336925506592,
0.14260908961296082,
0.03255404531955719,
-0.05323624610900879,
-0.5874242782592773,
0.14905235171318054,
0.12182772159576416,
-0.24437549710273743,
-0.3925614058971405,
0.8000291585922241,
-0.4325788617134094,
-0.2319362461566925,
-0.029755735769867897,
0.42598336935043335,
-0.20719586312770844,
0.4889817535877228,
-0.10671748220920563,
0.7594879865646362,
0.31130340695381165,
-0.722287118434906,
0.11955218017101288,
0.21338611841201782,
-0.6331281661987305,
0.282335489988327,
-0.702521800994873,
0.1669607162475586,
-0.14196322858333588,
0.4323924779891968,
-1.1108349561691284,
-0.4070766270160675,
0.031696394085884094,
-0.41813352704048157,
0.5990926623344421,
-0.26150617003440857,
-0.21061529219150543,
-0.41849207878112793,
-0.5202826857566833,
0.92878258228302,
0.7008046507835388,
-0.49164286255836487,
0.5777350664138794,
0.46434739232063293,
0.024707164615392685,
-0.4357466399669647,
-0.7840642333030701,
-0.07108195126056671,
-0.592472493648529,
-0.5264579653739929,
0.7134632468223572,
0.24290131032466888,
-0.18333452939987183,
-0.38350313901901245,
-0.42212945222854614,
-0.2100396454334259,
-0.09463907778263092,
-0.12117238342761993,
-0.3571418225765228,
-0.34375664591789246,
0.46336767077445984,
-0.07358039915561676,
-0.11112489551305771,
-0.23520682752132416,
-0.4756335914134979,
0.8108989596366882,
-0.23614399135112762,
-0.34359461069107056,
-0.2949873208999634,
0.22918501496315002,
0.6268963813781738,
-0.383933424949646,
0.6647592186927795,
0.46426185965538025,
-0.18806980550289154,
-0.46571484208106995,
-0.3233877718448639,
-0.19260622560977936,
-0.5537513494491577,
0.40444040298461914,
-0.24237175285816193,
-1.0621390342712402,
0.4056960642337799,
-0.16108611226081848,
0.018066653981804848,
0.12575089931488037,
0.0003560297773219645,
-0.17482592165470123,
1.0131831169128418,
0.5483825206756592,
-0.281697154045105,
0.7061200737953186,
-0.22457586228847504,
0.6061094999313354,
-1.0980544090270996,
0.21743030846118927,
-0.6760754585266113,
-0.5459134578704834,
-0.6927317380905151,
-0.7012972235679626,
0.5517189502716064,
0.44645601511001587,
-0.4314926564693451,
0.44453391432762146,
-0.268126517534256,
0.5322042107582092,
0.2443893998861313,
-0.25675275921821594,
0.13810479640960693,
0.1349995881319046,
-0.3509947657585144,
0.05384862795472145,
-0.609043538570404,
-0.30767548084259033,
0.773125171661377,
0.26720908284187317,
0.7574002742767334,
0.12030202150344849,
0.49989232420921326,
0.16708646714687347,
0.3246577978134155,
-0.9110608100891113,
0.4386759400367737,
-0.21711085736751556,
-0.4680265486240387,
-0.6849848031997681,
-0.2272268384695053,
-1.070711612701416,
0.18474289774894714,
0.2538074254989624,
-0.8007299304008484,
-0.3363601267337799,
0.2153296172618866,
-0.14922629296779633,
0.4388369619846344,
-0.21987952291965485,
0.7177780866622925,
-0.06614885479211807,
-0.2787521779537201,
-0.14822910726070404,
-0.5577202439308167,
0.23750658333301544,
0.0161411352455616,
0.38618379831314087,
-0.024744369089603424,
-0.11616437137126923,
0.3374866545200348,
-0.5868223905563354,
0.6397318243980408,
-0.16399826109409332,
-0.4418554902076721,
0.5425493121147156,
-0.029534459114074707,
0.9316109418869019,
-0.17226071655750275,
-0.3299024999141693,
0.04966162145137787,
-0.19658468663692474,
-0.20603090524673462,
-0.6664287447929382,
0.7950900793075562,
-0.4080950915813446,
-0.5777860879898071,
-0.2835189998149872,
-0.32001280784606934,
-0.394440233707428,
-0.06197648495435715,
0.20785778760910034,
0.6950244307518005,
0.072959303855896,
0.5573111176490784,
0.4400080740451813,
-0.4832528233528137,
0.6546826362609863,
0.3018963038921356,
-0.3245750963687897,
-0.5570586323738098,
0.7870920896530151,
0.062339358031749725,
0.05515359714627266,
0.3902852535247803,
0.34151726961135864,
-0.6905467510223389,
-0.5993250608444214,
-0.3354935944080353,
0.3019835650920868,
-0.363904744386673,
0.0167485810816288,
-0.2954331636428833,
-0.04790712147951126,
-0.2935637831687927,
-0.12231779098510742,
-0.4108392596244812,
-0.4175916612148285,
0.16265201568603516,
0.038870878517627716,
0.3851575553417206,
0.5877740383148193,
0.3403433561325073,
0.46957075595855713,
-0.9332759380340576,
0.267039030790329,
0.09302090853452682,
0.7484135031700134,
0.2243863195180893,
-0.7191466689109802,
-0.3766384720802307,
0.07074569910764694,
-0.29231080412864685,
-0.4034337103366852,
0.2817685008049011,
0.42675238847732544,
0.5290817022323608,
0.17919227480888367,
0.4153200387954712,
0.8661169409751892,
-0.6425689458847046,
0.8499508500099182,
0.31453341245651245,
-1.0089939832687378,
0.3157631754875183,
-0.752501368522644,
0.3599802255630493,
0.1875971108675003,
0.2496347278356552,
-0.8761698007583618,
-0.3030083179473877,
-0.3213370740413666,
-1.0557688474655151,
0.6101903915405273,
0.2402736395597458,
0.24992331862449646,
-0.359977126121521,
0.3843398690223694,
-0.09344714134931564,
0.15386459231376648,
-0.5072664022445679,
0.05274898558855057,
0.09047878533601761,
-0.39768633246421814,
-0.23510794341564178,
-0.13146495819091797,
0.0002102572616422549,
-0.2549619674682617,
0.4266589283943176,
-0.343291699886322,
0.2825257182121277,
0.16641300916671753,
-0.20535053312778473,
-0.2197420448064804,
0.20004519820213318,
0.7871561646461487,
0.6476636528968811,
0.08151334524154663,
0.08889738470315933,
0.4920409917831421,
-0.132816344499588,
0.27494099736213684,
-0.22259511053562164,
0.061988573521375656,
0.12266293913125992,
0.4637986421585083,
0.491764634847641,
0.43520814180374146,
-0.7334732413291931,
0.5233500599861145,
0.10823247581720352,
0.07722654938697815,
-0.306648313999176,
0.1455802470445633,
0.08816838264465332,
0.2250712513923645,
0.32710617780685425,
-0.31714823842048645,
-0.0650811418890953,
-0.4038183391094208,
0.3027990758419037,
0.3763522207736969,
-0.6109873652458191,
-0.5659127235412598,
0.48928701877593994,
0.2729296386241913,
-0.6796969771385193,
0.4586021900177002,
0.04820867255330086,
-0.250196248292923,
0.6239086985588074,
0.5473341941833496,
0.881805956363678,
-0.3848814070224762,
-0.08179571479558945,
0.6251100897789001,
-0.20133721828460693,
-0.40585070848464966,
0.0019074383890256286,
-0.10680420696735382,
-0.4107389450073242,
-0.4502439498901367,
-0.8642235994338989,
-0.0496036671102047,
0.2074212282896042,
-0.6956116557121277,
0.5241133570671082,
-0.4032902121543884,
-0.30980852246284485,
-0.4535846412181854,
-0.27142441272735596,
-0.16966231167316437,
-0.13457798957824707,
-0.15172502398490906,
0.8584874272346497,
-0.21896083652973175,
1.225657343864441,
0.502662181854248,
-0.032605886459350586,
-0.49129897356033325,
0.280619353055954,
-0.22402489185333252,
-0.153804749250412,
0.5889267921447754,
0.5168964266777039,
-0.3985896408557892,
0.007604088168591261,
-0.32441046833992004,
-0.7948232889175415,
1.0052919387817383,
0.16238722205162048,
-0.7576144337654114,
-0.05971183255314827,
0.4418359100818634,
0.7206305861473083,
-0.2667650282382965,
0.08086502552032471,
0.6109090447425842,
0.3377794921398163,
-0.03428424894809723,
-1.0514612197875977,
-0.2726365029811859,
0.04075704514980316,
0.5297253131866455,
0.6556605696678162,
-0.639250636100769,
0.8575254082679749,
0.12207696586847305,
-0.3521140515804291,
0.5930856466293335,
0.5853357315063477,
0.2547456622123718,
0.22698579728603363,
0.48478075861930847,
0.35209155082702637,
0.6512784361839294,
0.06920260190963745,
1.0867995023727417,
-0.4096490740776062,
0.6749863624572754,
1.3798327445983887,
-0.4645649492740631,
0.992289662361145,
0.5797294974327087,
-0.1937951147556305,
0.4509286880493164,
0.36905309557914734,
0.40155982971191406,
0.4987362325191498,
0.8344584703445435,
-0.4209049642086029,
-0.13345570862293243,
-0.08475133776664734,
-0.6126516461372375,
0.2515697777271271,
0.39704492688179016,
-0.2828828692436218,
-0.2799895107746124,
0.11059296131134033,
-0.3714625835418701,
0.24368004500865936,
-0.17146584391593933,
0.4734453558921814,
0.23138748109340668,
-0.6992607116699219,
0.962513267993927,
0.2023475617170334,
0.7244945168495178,
-0.6937052607536316,
0.020334679633378983,
-0.33739739656448364,
0.44266581535339355,
0.2276831865310669,
-0.4792048931121826,
0.4351949691772461,
0.004003596492111683,
0.13849668204784393,
-0.25315457582473755,
0.45923471450805664,
-0.5768594145774841,
0.025636427104473114,
0.466129869222641,
-0.10114165395498276,
-0.07606101781129837,
-0.012863176874816418,
-0.3074115812778473,
0.25756600499153137,
-0.41744059324264526,
-0.4418260157108307,
0.47778981924057007,
0.614612340927124,
-0.2975226640701294,
0.7140191793441772,
0.4001050889492035,
-0.3399502635002136,
0.03817060962319374,
0.021906254813075066,
0.8032766580581665,
-0.9933366775512695,
-0.368920236825943,
-0.7912145853042603,
0.42635613679885864,
-0.02711048536002636,
-0.36084991693496704,
0.5958059430122375,
0.4833882749080658,
1.0735112428665161,
-0.4012407958507538,
0.5181600451469421,
-0.03472865745425224,
0.46916496753692627,
-0.5574849843978882,
0.5799238085746765,
-0.49023985862731934,
0.2608938217163086,
-0.21920274198055267,
-1.012405276298523,
-0.43491798639297485,
0.7765039205551147,
-0.3815450370311737,
0.08774757385253906,
0.7566966414451599,
0.8750104904174805,
-0.2969023287296295,
-0.14255113899707794,
0.33215585350990295,
0.1859872043132782,
0.4673614203929901,
0.5815542340278625,
1.1196262836456299,
-0.5899410247802734,
0.4964178204536438,
0.1209777370095253,
0.25448861718177795,
-0.4054848253726959,
-0.9887748956680298,
-0.8964400291442871,
-0.590599000453949,
-0.1507047414779663,
-0.17745812237262726,
-0.039921391755342484,
1.055777668952942,
0.7552475333213806,
-0.9455979466438293,
-0.6806777119636536,
-0.40060773491859436,
0.03797520697116852,
-0.19183845818042755,
-0.23323893547058105,
0.14063486456871033,
-0.6083480715751648,
-0.8332063555717468,
0.45934659242630005,
0.2887602746486664,
0.03947988525032997,
-0.04249178618192673,
-0.36770519614219666,
-0.14708955585956573,
-0.03008594922721386,
0.6568294167518616,
0.3315635025501251,
-0.8384491801261902,
-0.6903054118156433,
-0.25976189970970154,
-0.09847266972064972,
0.1393093317747116,
1.0639163255691528,
-0.5702183842658997,
0.24306659400463104,
0.6511068344116211,
0.5952080488204956,
0.7234963178634644,
0.08510155230760574,
0.8023110032081604,
-1.0425323247909546,
0.2925662696361542,
0.310842365026474,
0.13422316312789917,
0.05380377918481827,
0.22072210907936096,
0.6558176279067993,
-0.04896017163991928,
-0.25907018780708313,
-0.8696910738945007,
0.5068451762199402,
-0.7775311470031738,
-0.26515093445777893,
1.2305516004562378,
-0.2842235267162323,
-0.3506656885147095,
-0.15011096000671387,
-0.31009408831596375,
0.3394733965396881,
-0.15721704065799713,
0.8478725552558899,
0.6533504724502563,
0.2245585024356842,
-0.009974797256290913,
-0.42136701941490173,
0.7848226428031921,
0.3867160677909851,
-0.40766164660453796,
0.2300412952899933,
0.19384628534317017,
0.18281172215938568,
-0.01017814315855503,
0.1747823804616928,
-0.1804451197385788,
-0.014802712947130203,
-0.43067625164985657,
-0.2596118152141571,
-0.018259216099977493,
-0.4366559386253357,
-0.5249990224838257,
0.2662709653377533,
0.2311243712902069,
-0.002705517690628767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00067v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00067v1
|
Query-OPT: Optimizing Inference of Large Language Models via Multi-Query Instructions in Meeting Summarization
| 2024-02-29T19:00:47 | 2024-02-29T19:00:47 |
Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Elena Khasanova, Xue-Yong Fu, Cheng Chen, Shashi Bhushan TN
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work focuses on the task of query-based meeting summarization in which
the summary of a context (meeting transcript) is generated in response to a
specific query. When using Large Language Models (LLMs) for this task, a new
call to the LLM inference endpoint/API is required for each new query even if
the context stays the same. However, repeated calls to the LLM inference
endpoints would significantly increase the costs of using them in production,
making LLMs impractical for many real-world use cases. To address this problem,
in this paper, we investigate whether combining the queries for the same input
context in a single prompt to minimize repeated calls can be successfully used
in meeting summarization. In this regard, we conduct extensive experiments by
comparing the performance of various popular LLMs: GPT-4, PaLM-2, LLaMA-2,
Mistral, and FLAN-T5 in single-query and multi-query settings. We observe that
while most LLMs tend to respond to the multi-query instructions, almost all of
them (except GPT-4), even after fine-tuning, could not properly generate the
response in the required output format. We conclude that while multi-query
prompting could be useful to optimize the inference costs by reducing calls to
the inference endpoints/APIs for the task of meeting summarization, this
capability to reliably generate the response in the expected format is only
limited to certain LLMs.
|
[
-0.5363186001777649,
-0.8656004071235657,
0.7091376185417175,
0.30662110447883606,
-0.4095090925693512,
-0.14860296249389648,
-0.3739297688007355,
-0.40351584553718567,
0.2780840992927551,
0.5178767442703247,
-0.9162473082542419,
-0.5400647521018982,
-0.2573449909687042,
0.2984846234321594,
-0.3116602897644043,
0.7495540380477905,
0.06808619946241379,
0.17439015209674835,
-0.40633946657180786,
-0.25956329703330994,
-0.3057788610458374,
-0.7706049680709839,
-0.8192332983016968,
-0.127676859498024,
0.4710373282432556,
0.4228469729423523,
0.2739815413951874,
0.21619708836078644,
0.2518836259841919,
0.23047830164432526,
-0.19369164109230042,
0.705722987651825,
-0.6080156564712524,
0.39498698711395264,
0.19018247723579407,
-0.5234710574150085,
-0.3990093767642975,
-0.0721767395734787,
0.6274334788322449,
0.9334660172462463,
-0.09689109772443771,
0.15219314396381378,
0.2768546938896179,
0.5827454328536987,
-0.5918222069740295,
0.12987643480300903,
-0.5979394316673279,
-0.031398966908454895,
0.06767792999744415,
-0.3229428827762604,
-0.3656366169452667,
-0.2980385422706604,
0.11483317613601685,
-0.5013583302497864,
0.21954484283924103,
0.2899930775165558,
0.6190088391304016,
0.27882564067840576,
-0.37464165687561035,
-0.226490780711174,
-0.37981849908828735,
0.8103423118591309,
-0.8210768103599548,
0.21479466557502747,
0.24676522612571716,
0.3442745506763458,
-0.27438294887542725,
-0.6233929991722107,
-0.39329615235328674,
-0.16368544101715088,
-0.0924743115901947,
0.3631494641304016,
0.02867322973906994,
0.241963192820549,
0.28232651948928833,
0.13378897309303284,
-0.5653364062309265,
0.16417597234249115,
-0.18513406813144684,
-0.0473514162003994,
0.4327951669692993,
0.40010347962379456,
-0.03853466734290123,
0.041533760726451874,
-0.26278042793273926,
0.24441368877887726,
-0.8833951354026794,
-0.1821862757205963,
0.01899035833775997,
0.49165889620780945,
0.01798516884446144,
0.5530918836593628,
-0.43936702609062195,
0.8180999755859375,
-0.10029352456331253,
-0.07481937110424042,
-0.1762278825044632,
-0.8964089155197144,
-0.10339286178350449,
-0.1378525048494339,
0.9281366467475891,
0.8607510924339294,
0.14707526564598083,
-0.10147614777088165,
-0.12859754264354706,
-0.2356964647769928,
-0.1375100165605545,
-0.9714517593383789,
0.031882207840681076,
0.40300455689430237,
-0.3012259304523468,
-0.03202987462282181,
-0.23942230641841888,
-0.8278235197067261,
-0.064222052693367,
-0.3223147392272949,
0.2655542492866516,
-0.13790759444236755,
0.060614846646785736,
-0.06914724409580231,
-0.1260204017162323,
0.22449176013469696,
0.6575816869735718,
-0.8172303438186646,
0.3508833348751068,
0.399681031703949,
1.0601978302001953,
-0.2566602826118469,
-0.45542263984680176,
-0.805460512638092,
0.19517210125923157,
-0.2921563386917114,
0.8287502527236938,
-0.2581964135169983,
-0.7868585586547852,
-0.1017218604683876,
-0.18925489485263824,
-0.24321629106998444,
-0.5366450548171997,
0.3331153690814972,
-0.37601369619369507,
0.5179675221443176,
-0.5959215760231018,
-0.6003190279006958,
0.04991127923130989,
0.3152463138103485,
-0.5583271980285645,
0.8461994528770447,
-0.10269473493099213,
-0.4844880998134613,
0.49406519532203674,
-0.7601958513259888,
-0.5004458427429199,
0.02755696512758732,
-0.35827988386154175,
-0.15333136916160583,
0.09951882809400558,
0.6447018980979919,
0.25462010502815247,
-0.41171374917030334,
-0.07816558331251144,
-0.2275451123714447,
-0.32023558020591736,
0.08511491119861603,
-0.28475555777549744,
0.43759089708328247,
0.16936828196048737,
-0.11954590678215027,
0.4454820454120636,
-0.464458167552948,
0.08711621910333633,
0.18047429621219635,
-0.6195942163467407,
-0.06866276264190674,
0.18767720460891724,
-0.19025057554244995,
-0.023456642404198647,
0.27157509326934814,
-0.20190535485744476,
0.281203955411911,
-0.3925797939300537,
0.30895617604255676,
0.4751967787742615,
0.3051435351371765,
0.2654680907726288,
-0.38355323672294617,
0.5962263345718384,
-0.2308846265077591,
0.05229445546865463,
-0.45708903670310974,
-0.40150099992752075,
-0.46301355957984924,
-0.40078651905059814,
-0.017138442024588585,
0.5093135237693787,
-0.5692628622055054,
-0.06668335199356079,
-0.17380495369434357,
-0.2174111157655716,
-0.19943735003471375,
-0.031223615631461143,
0.390729695558548,
0.5062849521636963,
0.2052212357521057,
0.2178054302930832,
-0.4811241030693054,
-0.726041853427887,
-0.6368207335472107,
0.0026300083845853806,
-0.08080132305622101,
0.6457559466362,
0.28044524788856506,
0.3861161172389984,
0.747138261795044,
-0.6783959865570068,
-0.013177644461393356,
-0.3985149562358856,
-0.04156411066651344,
0.4668560028076172,
0.12651383876800537,
0.8057289719581604,
-0.6617518663406372,
-0.5082259774208069,
-0.24039028584957123,
-0.5586580038070679,
-0.28650325536727905,
-0.24018000066280365,
-0.15191225707530975,
0.3356388807296753,
0.44899851083755493,
-0.7157070636749268,
0.27593886852264404,
0.3503221571445465,
0.0249487217515707,
0.8484730124473572,
-0.20734615623950958,
0.4786418080329895,
-1.090761423110962,
-0.11761371791362762,
-0.2170771211385727,
-0.3125354051589966,
-0.46246784925460815,
0.14019007980823517,
0.01986442692577839,
-0.21281324326992035,
-0.31422901153564453,
0.5960803627967834,
-0.7161818742752075,
-0.1513979136943817,
-0.3387443721294403,
0.3871801197528839,
0.2023279368877411,
0.7456800937652588,
-0.0989246517419815,
1.2326397895812988,
0.5764799118041992,
-0.8897519111633301,
0.21569815278053284,
0.48242899775505066,
-0.2035653293132782,
0.3831275999546051,
-0.8181940317153931,
0.19896598160266876,
-0.04584355652332306,
0.2844650149345398,
-1.1995967626571655,
-0.4691796600818634,
0.09468960762023926,
-0.43649643659591675,
0.2052455097436905,
-0.2097303718328476,
-0.5153453350067139,
-0.28908464312553406,
-0.6582016944885254,
0.264174222946167,
0.17771770060062408,
-0.7520585656166077,
0.6065740585327148,
0.247144415974617,
-0.3383907079696655,
-0.4685186743736267,
-0.7196730971336365,
0.1941155642271042,
-0.3981325626373291,
-0.5690993666648865,
0.22861246764659882,
-0.1043517142534256,
-0.08931387960910797,
-0.3188764750957489,
-0.3579101860523224,
0.09610423445701599,
-0.06575999408960342,
0.19377541542053223,
0.25342652201652527,
-0.18857550621032715,
-0.07123401761054993,
0.253741979598999,
0.15488019585609436,
0.04735931009054184,
-0.3340979814529419,
0.687979519367218,
-0.11013651639223099,
-0.6253854632377625,
-0.536555290222168,
0.8602110147476196,
0.7763994336128235,
-0.3112925589084625,
0.9311392307281494,
0.1169714629650116,
-0.2989899218082428,
0.005011505912989378,
-0.6235023140907288,
-0.27235159277915955,
-0.43169018626213074,
0.3924451470375061,
-0.5858092308044434,
-0.8294476270675659,
0.7900932431221008,
-0.3245752453804016,
0.4153442978858948,
0.2361660599708557,
0.6515246033668518,
-0.043095339089632034,
1.1002227067947388,
0.037173379212617874,
-0.004044165834784508,
0.5723413228988647,
-0.09416195005178452,
-0.018424903973937035,
-0.8991333842277527,
-0.10551425069570541,
-0.7744554281234741,
-0.024902667850255966,
-0.34540683031082153,
-0.20132263004779816,
0.7363470196723938,
0.09209778904914856,
-0.09479246288537979,
0.1062278300523758,
-0.19533325731754303,
0.6045171022415161,
0.7825180292129517,
0.06207023561000824,
0.3496531546115875,
0.10534850507974625,
-0.11438605934381485,
0.11988973617553711,
-0.867142915725708,
-0.44939547777175903,
0.9646961688995361,
-0.3135164976119995,
0.6605581641197205,
0.35900139808654785,
0.8458360433578491,
-0.240143284201622,
0.16672934591770172,
-0.7685280442237854,
0.6854422688484192,
0.10721896588802338,
-0.4047105312347412,
-0.3144228458404541,
-0.7205044627189636,
-0.9894118905067444,
0.8778678178787231,
-0.011850145645439625,
-0.9988396167755127,
-0.06400179117918015,
0.2663474678993225,
-0.36797255277633667,
0.11307866871356964,
-0.9485749006271362,
0.8741480708122253,
-0.18910863995552063,
-0.3369681239128113,
-0.1943904012441635,
-0.5325376987457275,
0.35865601897239685,
-0.14453443884849548,
0.33038294315338135,
-0.13826654851436615,
-0.15265658497810364,
0.5176554322242737,
-0.551979660987854,
0.6312245726585388,
-0.11769285798072815,
0.1001502051949501,
0.203450009226799,
-0.05884827673435211,
0.6140653491020203,
0.17123281955718994,
-0.23774929344654083,
-0.19652874767780304,
0.24658803641796112,
-0.18901799619197845,
-0.6294639706611633,
0.7079668641090393,
-0.42706483602523804,
-0.8403030633926392,
-0.05347469076514244,
-0.4872582256793976,
-0.4089008569717407,
0.2771800756454468,
0.5175923705101013,
0.8484463095664978,
-0.1057695597410202,
-0.009936987422406673,
0.20900435745716095,
-0.27403688430786133,
0.5387818217277527,
0.41932982206344604,
-0.37494656443595886,
-0.5203835964202881,
0.5468955636024475,
-0.018218951299786568,
0.555708110332489,
0.2816615700721741,
0.21850909292697906,
-0.5046785473823547,
-0.9151829481124878,
-0.41030633449554443,
0.3062390089035034,
-0.7429671883583069,
-0.22378697991371155,
-0.6333940625190735,
0.33532705903053284,
-0.4862181544303894,
0.06793376803398132,
-0.16665974259376526,
-0.5696189403533936,
-0.28221943974494934,
-0.0283657256513834,
0.16130830347537994,
0.1706809252500534,
0.12744927406311035,
0.4697082042694092,
-0.9750154614448547,
0.33286094665527344,
-0.019425993785262108,
0.10333333164453506,
-0.08488014340400696,
-0.36375921964645386,
-0.05707741901278496,
0.011187328025698662,
-0.20297975838184357,
-1.1585732698440552,
0.3638533055782318,
0.5570780634880066,
0.7143537402153015,
0.350082129240036,
0.24799636006355286,
0.7697926163673401,
-0.48293566703796387,
0.8102083802223206,
0.20699235796928406,
-0.664944589138031,
0.8029065728187561,
-0.49541881680488586,
0.692592442035675,
0.6564653515815735,
0.2044452726840973,
-0.49889397621154785,
-0.5425136089324951,
-0.1915949434041977,
-1.2217987775802612,
0.9436256885528564,
0.16167059540748596,
0.16567197442054749,
-0.24165143072605133,
0.42834001779556274,
0.02394665591418743,
0.37738773226737976,
-0.37650173902511597,
-0.3841545283794403,
0.13789258897304535,
0.12093900889158249,
0.31825128197669983,
-0.3863304853439331,
-0.37082555890083313,
-0.028800450265407562,
0.5367475152015686,
-0.27737289667129517,
0.1435401737689972,
0.17231567203998566,
-0.004060820210725069,
0.09428513050079346,
0.20288550853729248,
0.7008058428764343,
0.9961950778961182,
-0.18272185325622559,
-0.17973537743091583,
0.5414394736289978,
-0.10049717128276825,
-0.4135974645614624,
0.08750889450311661,
0.10154428333044052,
0.14767058193683624,
0.4310077130794525,
0.7372070550918579,
0.26796624064445496,
-0.7073700428009033,
0.3292791545391083,
-0.3251883089542389,
-0.3832414150238037,
-0.05292760208249092,
0.09543132036924362,
0.19534938037395477,
0.21690456569194794,
0.42974358797073364,
-0.26139935851097107,
0.30289125442504883,
-0.42963528633117676,
-0.01348177995532751,
0.5868763327598572,
0.19821171462535858,
0.14435754716396332,
0.8600410223007202,
0.2650119364261627,
-0.2762911021709442,
0.5758437514305115,
-0.15497130155563354,
-0.5647823214530945,
0.3405514359474182,
0.4295421242713928,
0.5982388854026794,
-0.12116289883852005,
-0.2511034607887268,
0.506019651889801,
0.04232709854841232,
0.043481115251779556,
0.4388997256755829,
-0.28759947419166565,
-0.4548502564430237,
-0.7789194583892822,
-0.505526065826416,
-0.6855767369270325,
-0.07513253390789032,
-0.7484575510025024,
0.045246440917253494,
-0.13412140309810638,
-0.24731658399105072,
0.03772323206067085,
-0.10782504081726074,
-0.345709890127182,
-0.23172986507415771,
-0.14513014256954193,
0.8393237590789795,
-0.2522059679031372,
0.3228400945663452,
0.6422311067581177,
-0.3912763297557831,
-0.8218531608581543,
-0.1969291716814041,
0.2637995183467865,
-0.6215773820877075,
0.1555127501487732,
0.22999431192874908,
-0.29121220111846924,
-0.06143919751048088,
-0.4886923134326935,
-0.6001437306404114,
0.9497910141944885,
0.44135236740112305,
-0.5755268931388855,
-0.06619910895824432,
-0.09901592135429382,
0.1213981956243515,
-0.26673218607902527,
0.18632428348064423,
0.616662859916687,
0.346513956785202,
0.4061300456523895,
-1.1997793912887573,
0.14603739976882935,
0.08108960092067719,
-0.2390459030866623,
0.40969276428222656,
-0.5387578010559082,
0.6014783382415771,
-0.38642266392707825,
-0.41097286343574524,
0.1664157658815384,
0.5383250117301941,
0.5300644636154175,
0.3130822777748108,
0.3318074643611908,
0.16941116750240326,
0.8851577043533325,
-0.18761631846427917,
1.2791248559951782,
-0.35514509677886963,
0.3270682990550995,
1.3979085683822632,
-0.25686609745025635,
0.6092351078987122,
0.47591283917427063,
-0.36193057894706726,
-0.2530263364315033,
0.7628215551376343,
0.18265794217586517,
0.5134105682373047,
0.1169237568974495,
-0.4605914056301117,
-0.152889683842659,
-0.017525559291243553,
-0.4097103178501129,
0.3355790674686432,
0.41372087597846985,
-0.03670410066843033,
-0.495539128780365,
-0.12775711715221405,
0.10730578005313873,
-0.17835642397403717,
-0.14794984459877014,
1.010787844657898,
0.14281673729419708,
-0.8600956797599792,
0.5557740330696106,
-0.15586236119270325,
0.43777790665626526,
-0.6382748484611511,
0.15088686347007751,
-0.6416272521018982,
-0.07167099416255951,
-0.08496969193220139,
-0.3483585715293884,
0.22510671615600586,
-0.095280721783638,
-0.040222179144620895,
-0.09238599240779877,
0.34349992871284485,
-0.5482814908027649,
-0.18178312480449677,
0.028937356546521187,
0.7255358099937439,
0.4786999225616455,
-0.5642136931419373,
-0.44396746158599854,
0.06205035001039505,
0.019677774980664253,
-0.5502431392669678,
0.34422510862350464,
0.3931230902671814,
0.008528848178684711,
0.7309422492980957,
0.7178570628166199,
0.11294569820165634,
0.06297844648361206,
0.6317988038063049,
0.9453136324882507,
-0.5178446173667908,
-0.6044402122497559,
-0.9935827255249023,
0.13552585244178772,
-0.2422913759946823,
-0.1890324503183365,
0.6581019759178162,
0.7400192022323608,
0.31222859025001526,
0.05621526762843132,
0.6788724064826965,
0.3138301372528076,
0.4512452483177185,
-0.780038058757782,
0.47671929001808167,
-0.6977136135101318,
0.46313410997390747,
-0.14352060854434967,
-0.963608980178833,
-0.22922520339488983,
0.26422756910324097,
-0.1588965654373169,
0.24896249175071716,
0.7981644868850708,
0.8237962126731873,
0.23724637925624847,
0.1638278216123581,
0.2146271914243698,
-0.21957138180732727,
0.5336323380470276,
0.4995042383670807,
0.809508740901947,
0.024072008207440376,
0.7161118984222412,
0.17459455132484436,
-0.2684101462364197,
-0.39155954122543335,
-0.7433907985687256,
-0.8130585551261902,
-0.4750159978866577,
-0.26511523127555847,
-0.13676892220973969,
-0.022018706426024437,
0.9852518439292908,
0.614489734172821,
-0.5595252513885498,
-0.23237600922584534,
0.14042676985263824,
0.07420758903026581,
-0.18286657333374023,
-0.20629841089248657,
0.5107113122940063,
-0.6223836541175842,
-0.9685405492782593,
0.6297821402549744,
0.3303796350955963,
0.05473534017801285,
0.2318985015153885,
0.12690186500549316,
-0.12528663873672485,
0.04602671414613724,
0.6974366903305054,
0.15648093819618225,
-0.7916001081466675,
-0.055157534778118134,
0.027408527210354805,
0.04707169532775879,
-0.03848304599523544,
0.7492780089378357,
-0.4788855016231537,
0.34948015213012695,
0.36620020866394043,
0.5993518233299255,
0.8476325869560242,
0.21321304142475128,
0.7627657651901245,
-0.9835715293884277,
-0.08197080343961716,
0.11340070515871048,
0.5504114627838135,
0.11007164418697357,
-0.3215940296649933,
0.5933197140693665,
-0.07048489898443222,
-0.5560402870178223,
-0.72730952501297,
0.3486254811286926,
-1.115921974182129,
-0.40040892362594604,
1.129374623298645,
0.02325545810163021,
-0.057770632207393646,
0.04223237186670303,
-0.43479493260383606,
0.18988502025604248,
-0.4382808208465576,
0.32127252221107483,
0.7516849040985107,
-0.7503792643547058,
-0.2960028052330017,
-0.7011626362800598,
0.4182840585708618,
0.44361358880996704,
-0.8574246764183044,
0.3244156241416931,
0.9081150889396667,
0.11415856331586838,
-0.04715270176529884,
0.7792348265647888,
0.03454757481813431,
0.24462245404720306,
-0.029369380325078964,
-0.40983909368515015,
-0.3280884623527527,
-0.01788320392370224,
-0.03083028458058834,
0.2870401442050934,
0.08415622264146805,
-0.5341076850891113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19471v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19471v2
|
Loose LIPS Sink Ships: Asking Questions in Battleship with Language-Informed Program Sampling
| 2024-02-29T18:58:15 | 2024-05-01T19:00:06 |
Gabriel Grand, Valerio Pepe, Jacob Andreas, Joshua B. Tenenbaum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Questions combine our mastery of language with our remarkable facility for
reasoning about uncertainty. How do people navigate vast hypothesis spaces to
pose informative questions given limited cognitive resources? We study these
tradeoffs in a classic grounded question-asking task based on the board game
Battleship. Our language-informed program sampling (LIPS) model uses large
language models (LLMs) to generate natural language questions, translate them
into symbolic programs, and evaluate their expected information gain. We find
that with a surprisingly modest resource budget, this simple Monte Carlo
optimization strategy yields informative questions that mirror human
performance across varied Battleship board scenarios. In contrast, LLM-only
baselines struggle to ground questions in the board state; notably, GPT-4V
provides no improvement over non-visual baselines. Our results illustrate how
Bayesian models of question-asking can leverage the statistics of language to
capture human priors, while highlighting some shortcomings of pure LLMs as
grounded reasoners.
|
[
-0.7602372765541077,
-1.0216726064682007,
1.2488040924072266,
-0.29389867186546326,
-0.2529245913028717,
-0.1836153119802475,
-0.16326208412647247,
-0.09720706194639206,
-0.034470487385988235,
1.1860625743865967,
-0.7751218676567078,
-0.3458315432071686,
-0.35354700684547424,
-0.5054054260253906,
-0.08772315084934235,
0.8979902863502502,
0.08179771900177002,
-0.08366671949625015,
-0.1577041745185852,
0.06683678179979324,
-0.7123047113418579,
-0.2839335501194,
-0.7240763902664185,
-0.2592412531375885,
0.20936138927936554,
0.7473884224891663,
0.7915238738059998,
0.4291117787361145,
0.43018078804016113,
0.16245435178279877,
0.025659874081611633,
-0.20679250359535217,
-0.6823645234107971,
0.11491113156080246,
-0.4466669261455536,
-0.9227069616317749,
0.30893659591674805,
0.10493995249271393,
0.38290470838546753,
0.9792025089263916,
-0.2730785012245178,
0.2547420561313629,
-0.2679064869880676,
0.6192173361778259,
-0.6299518346786499,
0.10326246172189713,
-0.8420798182487488,
-0.07956153154373169,
-0.29207560420036316,
-0.09987947344779968,
-0.35744911432266235,
-0.20970146358013153,
0.4234119951725006,
-0.5917150974273682,
0.15170162916183472,
0.11748103052377701,
0.9412686228752136,
0.4127623438835144,
-0.49114057421684265,
-0.24049772322177887,
-0.646818995475769,
0.7872390747070312,
-0.490325391292572,
0.38272395730018616,
0.5956875085830688,
0.2191605269908905,
-0.5255684852600098,
-0.4921831786632538,
-0.3546110987663269,
-0.40457072854042053,
0.23506911098957062,
0.4365907609462738,
-0.34337207674980164,
0.1709626466035843,
0.23888613283634186,
0.03569686412811279,
-0.7382748126983643,
-0.0444994792342186,
-0.35560014843940735,
-0.17200039327144623,
0.4244930148124695,
-0.021679405122995377,
0.4294494390487671,
-0.15765947103500366,
-0.2445289045572281,
-0.5325052738189697,
-0.689362108707428,
0.29346349835395813,
0.4425276219844818,
0.11860926449298859,
-0.13762550055980682,
0.6691357493400574,
-0.04141535982489586,
0.8533113598823547,
0.03285151720046997,
0.3367455303668976,
-0.7740678787231445,
0.3671082854270935,
0.0704057514667511,
-0.1899661272764206,
0.43002697825431824,
0.6933417320251465,
0.44048547744750977,
0.07592473924160004,
-0.044163864105939865,
0.1086341068148613,
0.4604823589324951,
-0.3919748067855835,
-0.3960029184818268,
0.34992918372154236,
-0.3185916841030121,
-0.14466561377048492,
0.0009082462056539953,
-0.8438319563865662,
-0.37103867530822754,
-0.12445838749408722,
0.3405121862888336,
-0.29291513562202454,
-0.04765702784061432,
0.08495625853538513,
-0.772739589214325,
0.2789885699748993,
0.2946443557739258,
-0.756364643573761,
0.4355775713920593,
0.5321207046508789,
0.30922555923461914,
-0.0028086502570658922,
0.32142794132232666,
-0.5504871010780334,
0.26872700452804565,
-0.556653618812561,
0.8510234951972961,
-0.2746867537498474,
-0.5704701542854309,
-0.14411288499832153,
-0.35360538959503174,
0.40671706199645996,
-0.30225634574890137,
0.5474706888198853,
-0.6054542660713196,
0.27601274847984314,
-0.7869035005569458,
-0.5284588932991028,
-0.13043345510959625,
0.38482141494750977,
-0.5219051837921143,
0.6363014578819275,
-0.18029965460300446,
-0.7049810290336609,
0.6707653999328613,
-0.0668330118060112,
-0.10930804908275604,
0.2383396178483963,
-0.43219679594039917,
-0.11796918511390686,
0.22324247658252716,
0.5048218965530396,
0.3516930043697357,
-0.6110583543777466,
0.5020813941955566,
-0.4030105173587799,
-0.34593266248703003,
0.4835381507873535,
-0.40975284576416016,
0.5419706106185913,
0.34835514426231384,
-0.36589285731315613,
-0.2647564709186554,
-0.4558814764022827,
0.24184928834438324,
0.02912597358226776,
-0.21939511597156525,
-0.4379124641418457,
0.5263336300849915,
-0.31540894508361816,
-0.1708732396364212,
0.10944366455078125,
-0.2534830570220947,
0.08104552328586578,
-0.35069456696510315,
0.2701806426048279,
0.6537277698516846,
0.4559187889099121,
0.6565708518028259,
-0.5233445763587952,
0.4728013873100281,
-0.32302457094192505,
-0.04382923245429993,
0.26692259311676025,
-0.8136931657791138,
-0.697352409362793,
-0.06944222748279572,
-0.16566428542137146,
0.5987961292266846,
-0.811200737953186,
-0.008129981346428394,
-0.13661547005176544,
-0.6488915085792542,
-0.21085454523563385,
-0.41515231132507324,
0.005356955341994762,
0.5365958213806152,
0.39546337723731995,
0.08734437823295593,
-0.4276321530342102,
-0.9254999160766602,
-0.44400885701179504,
-0.5867149233818054,
-0.12635332345962524,
0.5572524070739746,
0.4290145933628082,
0.32669708132743835,
0.9890033602714539,
-0.8291028141975403,
0.18780183792114258,
-0.505219578742981,
0.37616613507270813,
0.4580651819705963,
0.4322821795940399,
0.22350051999092102,
-0.8542765974998474,
-0.058979906141757965,
-0.3576262295246124,
-0.44767630100250244,
-0.09827135503292084,
-0.5333783626556396,
-0.287830114364624,
-0.23544292151927948,
0.5835118889808655,
-0.9923668503761292,
0.30226966738700867,
0.26993998885154724,
-0.12561796605587006,
0.27648645639419556,
-0.3095504641532898,
0.050182148814201355,
-0.7109822630882263,
0.19245107471942902,
-0.3217415511608124,
0.13558505475521088,
-0.421794593334198,
0.27741166949272156,
-0.05856325477361679,
-0.5003241896629333,
0.07729944586753845,
0.6110418438911438,
-0.651782214641571,
-0.09649626165628433,
-0.15989965200424194,
0.36828088760375977,
-0.06729066371917725,
0.16661959886550903,
0.31996652483940125,
0.46745678782463074,
0.339548259973526,
-0.927091121673584,
-0.012972574681043625,
0.04147743433713913,
-0.2968125641345978,
0.5658293962478638,
-0.6334879994392395,
0.0846233069896698,
-0.7752550840377808,
0.27925610542297363,
-1.5161564350128174,
-0.3548053205013275,
-0.06567560136318207,
-0.30954626202583313,
0.17980153858661652,
-0.45041409134864807,
0.1699589639902115,
-0.5120806694030762,
-0.19299155473709106,
0.026331081986427307,
0.8882890343666077,
-0.22792404890060425,
0.28247910737991333,
0.778841495513916,
-0.17914807796478271,
-0.6672303676605225,
-0.954190194606781,
-0.11080850660800934,
-0.22559970617294312,
-0.5719850063323975,
0.23225420713424683,
-0.05363105610013008,
-0.5581563115119934,
-0.06862952560186386,
-0.5215125679969788,
-0.1774802803993225,
0.3187812864780426,
0.273921936750412,
0.3028040826320648,
-0.31520116329193115,
0.0847235918045044,
0.16416345536708832,
0.1317310482263565,
0.2800145745277405,
-0.567078173160553,
0.45472452044487,
-0.014292966574430466,
-0.46971189975738525,
0.013063319958746433,
0.19813452661037445,
0.2999669313430786,
-0.07852144539356232,
0.3939111530780792,
0.046188876032829285,
-0.10626209527254105,
-0.343544602394104,
-0.9964671730995178,
-0.4019041657447815,
-0.3897128999233246,
0.14978045225143433,
-0.49305710196495056,
-0.9805842041969299,
0.6014313697814941,
0.060718417167663574,
-0.01589503325521946,
0.27820059657096863,
0.23354636132717133,
-0.4195365607738495,
0.6891612410545349,
0.44803398847579956,
-0.0010700238635763526,
-0.001148263574577868,
-0.04755057394504547,
-0.05604584887623787,
-0.17828750610351562,
0.14315512776374817,
-0.551916778087616,
-0.26757267117500305,
-0.35387706756591797,
-0.7023651599884033,
0.2896605134010315,
0.21722917258739471,
-0.21079587936401367,
0.15736156702041626,
-0.2742195725440979,
0.4751356542110443,
0.6448442935943604,
0.017661595717072487,
0.007724551949650049,
-0.24836087226867676,
-0.338567316532135,
-0.3846155107021332,
-0.7802483439445496,
-0.6039479374885559,
0.9876539707183838,
0.23528355360031128,
0.9021177291870117,
-0.0008122827275656164,
0.6999852657318115,
-0.07447275519371033,
0.25754228234291077,
-0.5081869959831238,
0.6627333760261536,
0.2617458403110504,
-1.102808952331543,
-0.533666729927063,
-0.6899693608283997,
-0.9397019147872925,
0.17241306602954865,
-0.12687306106090546,
-0.7607846856117249,
0.09046099334955215,
0.09762866050004959,
-0.3820312023162842,
0.3004361391067505,
-0.5348560810089111,
0.9362272620201111,
-0.18889130651950836,
-0.1862887442111969,
-0.13930396735668182,
-0.931771993637085,
0.43109357357025146,
0.1469523161649704,
0.3970720171928406,
-0.2322712540626526,
-0.1735631674528122,
0.4243111312389374,
-0.2865684926509857,
0.5615265369415283,
-0.22282466292381287,
-0.06256359815597534,
0.7200967073440552,
0.48940980434417725,
0.3132646083831787,
0.3927552402019501,
0.1693767011165619,
-0.17288699746131897,
-0.18370138108730316,
-0.2338694930076599,
-0.5442371368408203,
0.5108391046524048,
-0.6499133706092834,
-0.6882565021514893,
-0.3291449546813965,
-0.5058249831199646,
-0.3058128356933594,
0.20729835331439972,
0.6037691831588745,
0.16888786852359772,
-0.40288034081459045,
0.0008667297079227865,
0.8435081839561462,
-0.4060545563697815,
0.19407054781913757,
0.6397678256034851,
-0.1290227770805359,
-0.21152372658252716,
0.4907797574996948,
0.22371648252010345,
0.33307185769081116,
0.8584965467453003,
0.26755642890930176,
-0.4366796314716339,
-0.41129639744758606,
-0.41624587774276733,
0.32972997426986694,
-0.5505620241165161,
0.01017233170568943,
-0.3091611862182617,
0.3356701135635376,
-0.06670248508453369,
-0.29946184158325195,
-0.350739985704422,
-0.29617613554000854,
-0.06012527644634247,
-0.266557902097702,
0.1296849250793457,
0.5039891600608826,
-0.06691521406173706,
0.37554267048835754,
-0.6765574812889099,
0.38203760981559753,
0.4139235019683838,
0.20288698375225067,
-0.3050876557826996,
-0.5012516975402832,
0.39159244298934937,
0.22616522014141083,
-0.1232881098985672,
-1.3021267652511597,
0.08454139530658722,
-0.237075537443161,
0.7970206141471863,
0.20932801067829132,
0.14397262036800385,
0.7817041277885437,
-0.39191222190856934,
0.8136818408966064,
-0.14649218320846558,
-0.8263988494873047,
0.6958983540534973,
-0.6508821249008179,
0.4505259692668915,
0.5948273539543152,
0.6899930834770203,
-0.48492351174354553,
-0.6070212721824646,
-0.8246075510978699,
-0.5781922936439514,
0.6270496249198914,
0.12731541693210602,
0.04777425900101662,
-0.2848548889160156,
0.3916967511177063,
-0.2718520760536194,
0.2178422063589096,
-0.578315019607544,
-0.053596172481775284,
0.029073143377900124,
0.03167431056499481,
-0.10346278548240662,
-0.16899637877941132,
-0.014409222640097141,
0.16094648838043213,
0.5506960153579712,
-0.043854258954524994,
0.022026434540748596,
0.27789637446403503,
-0.17491920292377472,
-0.09293821454048157,
0.34690624475479126,
0.4557710886001587,
0.3826788067817688,
-0.33316242694854736,
0.3477812707424164,
0.3176354169845581,
-0.3157082200050354,
0.1723507046699524,
-0.12480214983224869,
-0.37271180748939514,
-0.09720473736524582,
0.1599947214126587,
0.6309462189674377,
0.41103094816207886,
-1.0445313453674316,
0.4080736041069031,
-0.18132248520851135,
-0.245955228805542,
-0.28024300932884216,
-0.04457138106226921,
0.3305821418762207,
0.05776199698448181,
0.24765363335609436,
-0.015223179943859577,
0.07744951546192169,
-0.7093363404273987,
0.30986106395721436,
0.5674121379852295,
-0.4125612676143646,
0.183498352766037,
0.874650239944458,
-0.21228531002998352,
0.2211640179157257,
0.8291218876838684,
-0.07296105474233627,
-0.1307486742734909,
0.4105173349380493,
0.2369883805513382,
0.2971576750278473,
-0.1085713803768158,
0.4209357500076294,
0.33632344007492065,
0.6707308888435364,
-0.3098280727863312,
0.6181814074516296,
-0.14846274256706238,
-0.9073854684829712,
-0.6179912090301514,
-0.15868569910526276,
-0.5662632584571838,
0.34499189257621765,
-0.6218618750572205,
0.29370859265327454,
-0.8343916535377502,
-0.4699743986129761,
-0.3877628743648529,
-0.23954108357429504,
-0.37284785509109497,
0.21056543290615082,
0.4289878010749817,
0.6943753957748413,
-0.6577497720718384,
0.11129932105541229,
0.7582970261573792,
-0.7810256481170654,
-0.9681472182273865,
0.05257127061486244,
-0.144424170255661,
-0.5166983008384705,
0.6231713891029358,
0.008578717708587646,
0.18765588104724884,
0.0860769972205162,
-0.7832411527633667,
-1.2181302309036255,
0.5961304306983948,
0.4515090584754944,
-0.21736747026443481,
-0.05901597812771797,
0.1821250170469284,
0.2678009271621704,
0.26236072182655334,
0.4125402867794037,
0.7306362986564636,
0.6030829548835754,
-0.050703175365924835,
-0.45681634545326233,
0.12228327989578247,
-0.005653334315866232,
0.008947501890361309,
0.3697015047073364,
-0.43240949511528015,
0.8579595685005188,
-0.37717169523239136,
-0.17126038670539856,
0.0332786962389946,
0.8810139894485474,
0.6243568658828735,
-0.04775466397404671,
0.49013862013816833,
0.5907065868377686,
0.9043224453926086,
-0.31497055292129517,
1.164457082748413,
0.02684229239821434,
0.0671706348657608,
0.8148854374885559,
-0.20561324059963226,
0.8372102975845337,
0.693096935749054,
-0.08016154915094376,
0.4117521345615387,
0.3210286498069763,
0.05322546884417534,
0.5362809896469116,
0.7622767686843872,
0.15529489517211914,
-0.36196669936180115,
0.21488721668720245,
-0.06079717352986336,
0.533710777759552,
0.5715631246566772,
0.30751848220825195,
-0.4969216585159302,
-0.0629427582025528,
0.1828807294368744,
0.2405351847410202,
-0.055372484028339386,
0.6857210397720337,
0.19838164746761322,
-1.1802281141281128,
0.2850033938884735,
0.11484022438526154,
0.2726128399372101,
-0.6946457028388977,
-0.06924881786108017,
-0.30244383215904236,
0.07192142307758331,
0.3120347261428833,
-0.9401915669441223,
-0.04663920775055885,
-0.09293986856937408,
0.05092039704322815,
-0.30731281638145447,
0.7282224893569946,
-0.4212287664413452,
-0.025225285440683365,
-0.22094452381134033,
0.6596925854682922,
0.5293087363243103,
-0.4065445363521576,
-0.6324774026870728,
0.024786517024040222,
0.012223295867443085,
-0.263680636882782,
0.03712202608585358,
0.5688529014587402,
-0.057356879115104675,
0.9022424817085266,
0.767521321773529,
0.16113117337226868,
0.028753601014614105,
-0.0472407303750515,
0.40790584683418274,
-0.5561180710792542,
-0.765640377998352,
-0.6478126049041748,
0.7973790764808655,
-0.1635131537914276,
-0.3917228579521179,
0.6536713242530823,
0.38021141290664673,
0.5553826689720154,
-0.41931140422821045,
0.7657034993171692,
0.04400739073753357,
0.5002825856208801,
-0.8223549127578735,
0.7082615494728088,
-0.38779205083847046,
0.16883404552936554,
-0.47350630164146423,
-0.9848139882087708,
0.0405799001455307,
0.8351811170578003,
-0.5304074883460999,
-0.04857218265533447,
0.5925275087356567,
0.6077648997306824,
0.01586182415485382,
0.2527782618999481,
0.26635491847991943,
0.04043347015976906,
0.506417453289032,
0.6232979893684387,
1.1811476945877075,
-0.2771179676055908,
0.4968634247779846,
-0.12309471517801285,
-0.1829623281955719,
-0.17659491300582886,
-0.8533703684806824,
-0.9065114259719849,
-0.4698103666305542,
-0.07529720664024353,
-0.014115069061517715,
-0.0979708805680275,
0.6013063192367554,
0.5033448934555054,
-0.4129585325717926,
-0.6084596514701843,
-0.5557669997215271,
0.08238434791564941,
0.11061760783195496,
-0.22836565971374512,
0.11845483630895615,
-0.42910036444664,
-0.31301942467689514,
0.6159764528274536,
0.0541326105594635,
0.24751508235931396,
0.004704286810010672,
0.3124769926071167,
-0.27995479106903076,
0.08233626186847687,
0.02279515005648136,
0.2719360589981079,
-0.6380348801612854,
-0.40406396985054016,
0.17203281819820404,
-0.06345263123512268,
-0.48881614208221436,
0.7945818901062012,
-0.6941739320755005,
0.32216915488243103,
0.5448970794677734,
0.7932945489883423,
0.8147408366203308,
0.16872023046016693,
0.955702006816864,
-0.7866144180297852,
0.29282498359680176,
0.5201413631439209,
0.3315610885620117,
0.10429459810256958,
-0.24609969556331635,
0.3018784821033478,
0.13494227826595306,
-0.5453659892082214,
-0.506547212600708,
0.21969501674175262,
-0.9365442395210266,
-0.5727629661560059,
0.8168846368789673,
0.2520606219768524,
-0.02483147382736206,
-0.13591068983078003,
-0.4393836259841919,
-0.08452394604682922,
-0.35131558775901794,
0.3524988889694214,
1.2455480098724365,
0.11277268826961517,
-0.14805006980895996,
-0.9804710745811462,
0.643301248550415,
0.730993926525116,
-0.6407083868980408,
-0.06523876637220383,
0.7605085968971252,
0.24790474772453308,
0.028834491968154907,
0.9284961223602295,
0.12488844990730286,
0.19443152844905853,
0.23877467215061188,
0.0914565771818161,
0.487701952457428,
-0.2033633142709732,
0.15020038187503815,
0.2419598549604416,
0.09458694607019424,
0.2262183278799057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19467v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19467v3
|
TV-TREES: Multimodal Entailment Trees for Neuro-Symbolic Video Reasoning
| 2024-02-29T18:57:01 | 2024-03-11T01:31:58 |
Kate Sanders, Nathaniel Weir, Benjamin Van Durme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, I.2.7; I.2.10
|
It is challenging to perform question-answering over complex, multimodal
content such as television clips. This is in part because current
video-language models rely on single-modality reasoning, have lowered
performance on long inputs, and lack interpetability. We propose TV-TREES, the
first multimodal entailment tree generator. TV-TREES serves as an approach to
video understanding that promotes interpretable joint-modality reasoning by
producing trees of entailment relationships between simple premises directly
entailed by the videos and higher-level conclusions. We then introduce the task
of multimodal entailment tree generation to evaluate the reasoning quality of
such methods. Our method's experimental results on the challenging TVQA dataset
demonstrate intepretable, state-of-the-art zero-shot performance on full video
clips, illustrating a best-of-both-worlds contrast to black-box methods.
|
[
-0.5051949620246887,
-1.177095890045166,
0.42250674962997437,
0.008275304920971394,
-0.45231491327285767,
0.13083790242671967,
-0.06780721992254257,
-0.01792723312973976,
0.1438063234090805,
0.15245814621448517,
-0.8377197980880737,
-0.14068716764450073,
-0.6537910103797913,
0.14896127581596375,
-0.44708436727523804,
0.684593141078949,
-0.043546173721551895,
-0.1019241064786911,
-0.2527017295360565,
-0.2517372965812683,
-0.4106639325618744,
-0.19373300671577454,
-0.29396453499794006,
0.02316362038254738,
0.31676632165908813,
0.38000476360321045,
0.8790395259857178,
0.5375563502311707,
0.38300126791000366,
0.29938140511512756,
0.25707587599754333,
0.41352376341819763,
-0.14697979390621185,
0.38130152225494385,
0.12166310846805573,
-0.2821740508079529,
-0.15659065544605255,
-0.24754013121128082,
0.4348641037940979,
0.3055025041103363,
0.13518285751342773,
0.41232210397720337,
-0.08735289424657822,
0.3068411648273468,
-0.7466601133346558,
-0.07648307085037231,
-0.6453490853309631,
0.17985789477825165,
0.012528005056083202,
-0.8957290649414062,
-0.4924596846103668,
-0.27723169326782227,
0.08152861148118973,
-0.8255335688591003,
0.32031071186065674,
-0.26928073167800903,
1.0401839017868042,
0.6588149070739746,
-0.8133257627487183,
-0.009396231733262539,
-0.5981125831604004,
0.4095233082771301,
-0.46197524666786194,
0.49134448170661926,
0.5788663625717163,
0.7723634839057922,
0.06003694608807564,
-0.49398574233055115,
-0.5198470950126648,
-0.2945733368396759,
0.20930372178554535,
0.16475847363471985,
-0.18842115998268127,
0.3243793845176697,
0.416774719953537,
0.17134003341197968,
-0.6771209239959717,
-0.42851704359054565,
-0.08524473756551743,
-0.049852292984724045,
0.47832271456718445,
0.143611878156662,
0.35052454471588135,
-0.5454367995262146,
0.15108397603034973,
-0.04132808744907379,
-0.5409195423126221,
0.11862246692180634,
0.34978076815605164,
-0.18383438885211945,
0.1845622956752777,
0.955977201461792,
-0.26429978013038635,
0.5685544013977051,
0.028902770951390266,
-0.3432871699333191,
-0.12727804481983185,
-0.6277514696121216,
-0.6285108327865601,
0.06271754950284958,
0.4279894530773163,
0.4301973879337311,
0.44245776534080505,
0.09146212041378021,
0.15872327983379364,
0.5536941289901733,
0.009817336685955524,
-0.948577344417572,
-0.36192187666893005,
0.1736110895872116,
-0.6178596019744873,
-0.032988134771585464,
-0.20776915550231934,
-0.6767753958702087,
-0.14317165315151215,
-0.399442583322525,
0.8747375011444092,
-0.7478823065757751,
-0.5997519493103027,
0.11457391083240509,
-0.4127708971500397,
0.09353470802307129,
0.6167519092559814,
-0.5645076632499695,
0.26562801003456116,
0.41071414947509766,
0.46013203263282776,
0.455026239156723,
-0.24493972957134247,
-0.687699556350708,
0.45319610834121704,
-0.2541026473045349,
0.603786826133728,
-0.7430958151817322,
0.17132353782653809,
-0.04326093569397926,
-0.008951147086918354,
0.11107806861400604,
-0.18377920985221863,
0.23265311121940613,
-0.2727814018726349,
0.32711267471313477,
-0.07172302901744843,
-0.2580052316188812,
-0.5831433534622192,
0.6499869227409363,
-0.4120965301990509,
0.7102872133255005,
-0.10886649042367935,
-0.5808842778205872,
0.7245618104934692,
-0.6005152463912964,
-0.5133659839630127,
-0.1320887953042984,
-0.38689759373664856,
-0.13846875727176666,
-0.04555334523320198,
0.43050363659858704,
0.24789011478424072,
-0.30278661847114563,
0.5459417104721069,
-0.225007101893425,
0.06943292915821075,
0.16768091917037964,
-1.1530985832214355,
0.5607279539108276,
0.258659303188324,
-0.2943786084651947,
0.2194952666759491,
-0.5005197525024414,
0.10995715111494064,
-0.0522298589348793,
0.10313180088996887,
-0.13769885897636414,
0.2885212302207947,
-0.16453400254249573,
0.3895038068294525,
-0.20407633483409882,
-0.7422571778297424,
-0.19847898185253143,
-0.04933867231011391,
0.6456026434898376,
0.578249990940094,
-0.049302902072668076,
0.05254590883851051,
-0.26391857862472534,
0.6754456162452698,
0.17788423597812653,
0.29003214836120605,
-0.6534026861190796,
-0.40956664085388184,
-0.568631649017334,
-0.24744096398353577,
0.045025698840618134,
0.2542155385017395,
-1.0597894191741943,
-0.1691027283668518,
-0.19593432545661926,
-0.18498283624649048,
-0.3289586901664734,
-0.11745193600654602,
0.3784998953342438,
0.03404202312231064,
0.26260265707969666,
-0.3098401129245758,
-0.524580717086792,
-0.9557466506958008,
0.05678891763091087,
0.02641928754746914,
0.18415120244026184,
0.28434908390045166,
0.5665625929832458,
0.37114396691322327,
0.8377172350883484,
-0.4969848096370697,
-0.0115879587829113,
0.04683423414826393,
0.26294201612472534,
0.030870676040649414,
0.31202319264411926,
0.4007139503955841,
-0.8652592897415161,
-0.5195937752723694,
0.14262789487838745,
-0.9684704542160034,
0.4059268534183502,
-0.3145442008972168,
0.02023773267865181,
0.07728539407253265,
0.39002910256385803,
-0.9821040034294128,
0.5712841153144836,
0.38705843687057495,
-0.6826854944229126,
0.5418589115142822,
-0.10378768295049667,
0.5600728988647461,
-0.8400226831436157,
-0.15978555381298065,
0.06179265305399895,
-0.36518236994743347,
-0.2777825891971588,
-0.12759940326213837,
-0.44890961050987244,
-0.26074573397636414,
-0.44786524772644043,
0.07147032022476196,
-0.3225402235984802,
-0.26441308856010437,
0.1038610190153122,
0.005943982861936092,
0.24568107724189758,
0.7007541656494141,
-0.14998053014278412,
0.532741904258728,
0.7902318239212036,
-0.43274733424186707,
0.43943649530410767,
0.17708098888397217,
-0.2469007670879364,
0.7511892914772034,
-0.40621721744537354,
-0.2627769410610199,
-0.6523059010505676,
0.14686058461666107,
-1.0946712493896484,
-0.538629412651062,
0.11826545745134354,
-0.6854839324951172,
0.10293066501617432,
-0.29017171263694763,
-0.37648922204971313,
-0.0690867155790329,
-0.12851084768772125,
0.6680383086204529,
0.1619689166545868,
-0.4345465302467346,
0.6378057599067688,
0.2625313997268677,
0.11398005485534668,
-0.5929404497146606,
-0.403276264667511,
0.20139364898204803,
-0.2879604697227478,
-0.9143370985984802,
0.2263011783361435,
0.011684971861541271,
-0.11788306385278702,
0.49657514691352844,
-0.4795002341270447,
-0.4655582904815674,
-0.12063737213611603,
0.22429879009723663,
-0.08694931864738464,
-0.49952372908592224,
0.3031662404537201,
0.2016368806362152,
0.20668601989746094,
0.084834523499012,
0.24659276008605957,
0.14418424665927887,
-0.1041351929306984,
-0.6185467839241028,
-0.39845943450927734,
0.6843218207359314,
0.67437344789505,
-0.4134795665740967,
-0.0415705107152462,
0.4594764709472656,
-0.6195706725120544,
-0.15132200717926025,
-0.35310155153274536,
-0.36707279086112976,
-0.44261202216148376,
0.5755400657653809,
-0.6134220361709595,
-0.7911995649337769,
-0.17277580499649048,
0.012162074446678162,
0.05347323790192604,
0.016404539346694946,
0.3448752760887146,
-0.24980956315994263,
1.4772404432296753,
0.1953127384185791,
0.780965268611908,
0.4309401214122772,
-0.4070880711078644,
0.08223742246627808,
-0.292934775352478,
-0.336997926235199,
-0.10773726552724838,
-0.4127284288406372,
-0.3309163451194763,
-0.4771093428134918,
0.5216549038887024,
0.06391887366771698,
-0.6569042801856995,
0.4141930639743805,
-0.6255460381507874,
0.6241072416305542,
0.3592897355556488,
0.20586004853248596,
0.5809658765792847,
0.028905505314469337,
0.3139118552207947,
-0.08410454541444778,
-0.8363562226295471,
-0.3795730173587799,
0.7825836539268494,
0.3866117298603058,
0.7046290040016174,
0.46873417496681213,
0.17388120293617249,
0.15238437056541443,
0.18392342329025269,
-0.9168506264686584,
0.6753200888633728,
-0.32458680868148804,
-0.6610317230224609,
-0.3856303095817566,
-0.1562490314245224,
-0.9776961207389832,
0.4344238340854645,
-0.2283206284046173,
-0.5855059027671814,
-0.053065910935401917,
0.19543486833572388,
-0.3242785930633545,
0.20689821243286133,
-0.7513149976730347,
1.1432734727859497,
-0.44946619868278503,
-0.3982558250427246,
-0.5740472078323364,
-0.6008359789848328,
0.7311203479766846,
0.46236035227775574,
0.05100357159972191,
-0.22700463235378265,
0.22551172971725464,
0.5206555128097534,
-0.30762431025505066,
0.5690277814865112,
-0.21756337583065033,
0.3421976864337921,
0.7306393384933472,
0.6928502917289734,
-0.07894507795572281,
0.25696423649787903,
0.5447555184364319,
-0.3249235153198242,
0.5603548884391785,
0.004839262925088406,
-0.8412129878997803,
0.43966567516326904,
-0.6658040881156921,
-0.6308959126472473,
-0.43449702858924866,
-0.767600953578949,
-0.17166148126125336,
0.09948191791772842,
-0.07046493887901306,
0.9260424375534058,
0.13342897593975067,
0.6064407825469971,
0.5490192174911499,
-0.08765724301338196,
0.6733012795448303,
-0.03202333673834801,
-0.2742365002632141,
-0.589779794216156,
1.0555280447006226,
0.16648681461811066,
0.3537442088127136,
0.35525891184806824,
0.026945408433675766,
-0.21459686756134033,
-0.29872986674308777,
-0.633010983467102,
-0.12159980088472366,
-0.7765143513679504,
-0.3634556829929352,
-0.4933636486530304,
-0.31519633531570435,
0.04009952396154404,
0.015726817771792412,
-0.23265570402145386,
-0.5919690728187561,
0.18888626992702484,
-0.15734633803367615,
0.3505685329437256,
0.4337795674800873,
0.012692896649241447,
0.15744994580745697,
-0.7424628138542175,
0.771246612071991,
0.7802941203117371,
0.35238009691238403,
-0.1856057494878769,
-0.15689904987812042,
0.05318833142518997,
0.12185010313987732,
-0.8127988576889038,
-1.1395487785339355,
0.27684035897254944,
0.399845689535141,
0.5212793350219727,
0.3096538186073303,
-0.252682089805603,
0.9394072890281677,
-0.2355147749185562,
0.7101953625679016,
0.4557303190231323,
-0.800381064414978,
0.5484491586685181,
-0.3979783058166504,
0.255254864692688,
0.30758747458457947,
0.3742254674434662,
-0.33165034651756287,
0.01773972064256668,
-0.5839825868606567,
-0.34967392683029175,
0.6688026785850525,
0.38325363397598267,
-0.06877205520868301,
-0.05949008837342262,
-0.34234797954559326,
0.23987440764904022,
0.3399527966976166,
-0.5747151970863342,
0.04256923496723175,
-0.8838739991188049,
-0.11478683352470398,
0.1434827446937561,
0.17516052722930908,
-0.3123636841773987,
-0.5955776572227478,
0.3032729923725128,
-0.4869750738143921,
0.2793391942977905,
0.4003875255584717,
-0.16018758714199066,
-0.4178915023803711,
0.3816053569316864,
0.4227459728717804,
0.8049684762954712,
-0.43334391713142395,
0.4988928735256195,
-0.08402926474809647,
-0.1212068423628807,
0.2971322238445282,
-0.22780947387218475,
-0.12506268918514252,
0.31623899936676025,
0.14916066825389862,
0.9018737077713013,
0.02391304261982441,
-0.8058727383613586,
0.6500876545906067,
0.12310848385095596,
-0.5615954995155334,
-0.2845172584056854,
-0.2622058689594269,
-0.09349837154150009,
0.08664654940366745,
0.12250446528196335,
0.26002880930900574,
0.2229892611503601,
-0.8542476296424866,
0.42625874280929565,
0.7303977012634277,
-0.22988395392894745,
-0.30262264609336853,
0.6604480743408203,
0.15448613464832306,
-0.394420325756073,
0.5542105436325073,
-0.07423770427703857,
-0.19069668650627136,
0.8954015374183655,
0.44734814763069153,
0.9921462535858154,
0.1852034628391266,
0.8378545641899109,
0.5411165952682495,
0.3863201439380646,
0.20203529298305511,
0.506249725818634,
-0.3858797252178192,
-0.5526468753814697,
-1.0591371059417725,
-0.1729019284248352,
-0.39054062962532043,
0.07456930726766586,
-0.4354235827922821,
0.2823377847671509,
-0.3013152778148651,
-0.1692405790090561,
0.13833914697170258,
-0.6168050169944763,
-0.6668002605438232,
0.30619096755981445,
0.21280047297477722,
0.8666285276412964,
-0.7273621559143066,
0.7778201699256897,
0.5683576464653015,
-0.5775772929191589,
-0.6847619414329529,
-0.09026079624891281,
-0.255979984998703,
-0.37574994564056396,
0.7230166792869568,
0.23499387502670288,
-0.1615631878376007,
0.0034889960661530495,
-0.6058523058891296,
-0.8192052245140076,
1.005286455154419,
0.6132933497428894,
-0.011621976271271706,
-0.12742285430431366,
0.22282180190086365,
0.24973848462104797,
-0.11823821067810059,
0.7424139976501465,
0.3933093547821045,
0.5300033092498779,
0.4285328984260559,
-0.8951761722564697,
-0.04493376240134239,
-0.3068176507949829,
-0.4177601635456085,
0.466072142124176,
-0.3158508241176605,
0.8456711769104004,
-0.11600761115550995,
-0.44245800375938416,
-0.36666521430015564,
0.4312868118286133,
0.24149474501609802,
0.5405358076095581,
0.5473909378051758,
0.6965234279632568,
0.06464283168315887,
-0.021125275641679764,
0.7203841209411621,
-0.03121669963002205,
0.12645792961120605,
1.1282458305358887,
0.13308745622634888,
0.6084940433502197,
0.8349063396453857,
-0.2451748549938202,
0.46961721777915955,
0.4619074761867523,
0.2262682467699051,
0.5139676332473755,
0.06018776446580887,
-0.18371984362602234,
-0.9885720014572144,
-0.3950597941875458,
-0.23919422924518585,
0.675929844379425,
0.4109540283679962,
0.047650180757045746,
-0.7393621206283569,
0.026938794180750847,
-0.26783740520477295,
0.20756588876247406,
-0.2846347689628601,
0.5021859407424927,
-0.02402709238231182,
-1.0573323965072632,
0.5468882322311401,
-0.28301775455474854,
0.4299558699131012,
-0.7740857005119324,
-0.5498642921447754,
0.174460768699646,
-0.10445427149534225,
-0.38297590613365173,
-1.1772639751434326,
0.48001542687416077,
-0.06170467659831047,
0.16890975832939148,
-0.35082271695137024,
0.39231568574905396,
-0.5522683262825012,
-0.2160644829273224,
-0.10293243080377579,
0.6036269068717957,
0.04514092206954956,
-0.12552054226398468,
-0.4429408311843872,
-0.20734229683876038,
-0.25998562574386597,
-0.1000235304236412,
0.24609878659248352,
0.6882430911064148,
-0.13315752148628235,
0.6624921560287476,
0.4968140125274658,
-0.4957362413406372,
0.309990257024765,
-0.1928769052028656,
0.7578908801078796,
-0.4239717125892639,
-0.23682653903961182,
-0.8800747394561768,
0.6834868788719177,
-0.009181790985167027,
-0.3901076912879944,
0.8192237019538879,
0.5739760398864746,
0.8825748562812805,
-0.17106202244758606,
0.6816580295562744,
-0.5711118578910828,
-0.22037360072135925,
-0.46365252137184143,
0.10981272906064987,
-0.7603559494018555,
-0.40030673146247864,
-0.17745688557624817,
-0.7031688690185547,
-0.24407874047756195,
0.536790132522583,
0.07307779788970947,
-0.29475244879722595,
1.11699640750885,
0.9341459274291992,
-0.2368856519460678,
0.30828797817230225,
0.41373249888420105,
-0.04238414019346237,
0.3149552643299103,
0.927405059337616,
1.126502275466919,
-0.4369477331638336,
1.0044792890548706,
-0.4770507216453552,
0.048248592764139175,
0.2377120852470398,
-0.834928572177887,
-0.8110573887825012,
-0.6974796652793884,
-0.416853129863739,
-0.35364657640457153,
0.10726256668567657,
0.9470833539962769,
0.8352005481719971,
-0.5972098112106323,
-0.29633238911628723,
-0.254825234413147,
0.23771172761917114,
-0.5399851202964783,
-0.22559911012649536,
0.3191007077693939,
0.06604404002428055,
-0.5881971120834351,
0.4449455440044403,
0.4077717065811157,
-0.34946757555007935,
-0.5027248859405518,
-0.24920441210269928,
-0.5524576306343079,
0.07474158704280853,
0.8292422890663147,
0.1990581601858139,
-0.8653402328491211,
-0.5568605661392212,
0.11272880434989929,
0.24698027968406677,
0.22782674431800842,
1.0535252094268799,
-0.8414743542671204,
0.7578890919685364,
0.892471432685852,
0.5228834748268127,
0.6867265701293945,
0.050855718553066254,
0.28516191244125366,
-0.6504061222076416,
-0.0067476243712008,
0.39092403650283813,
0.35573965311050415,
0.10280025005340576,
0.0077603720128536224,
0.4190961718559265,
0.3097151517868042,
-0.40432149171829224,
-0.895929753780365,
0.5269666910171509,
-1.3090540170669556,
-0.3992891311645508,
1.1153043508529663,
0.17509125173091888,
-0.15012682974338531,
-0.21879133582115173,
-0.6339471936225891,
0.42753154039382935,
-0.22131653130054474,
0.367954820394516,
0.5195885896682739,
-0.20004931092262268,
-0.6847824454307556,
-0.7382622361183167,
0.48811325430870056,
0.5479859709739685,
-0.8673909306526184,
-0.07003187388181686,
0.6683670282363892,
0.13964994251728058,
-0.0019904160872101784,
0.5134691596031189,
0.03277583420276642,
0.712333619594574,
0.3567492663860321,
-0.22362732887268066,
-0.5580596327781677,
-0.733524739742279,
0.11467921733856201,
0.6378652453422546,
-0.12966227531433105,
-0.5405022501945496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19465v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19465v1
|
Towards Tracing Trustworthiness Dynamics: Revisiting Pre-training Period of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-29T18:55:06 | 2024-02-29T18:55:06 |
Chen Qian, Jie Zhang, Wei Yao, Dongrui Liu, Zhenfei Yin, Yu Qiao, Yong Liu, Jing Shao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Ensuring the trustworthiness of large language models (LLMs) is crucial. Most
studies concentrate on fully pre-trained LLMs to better understand and improve
LLMs' trustworthiness. In this paper, to reveal the untapped potential of
pre-training, we pioneer the exploration of LLMs' trustworthiness during this
period, focusing on five key dimensions: reliability, privacy, toxicity,
fairness, and robustness. To begin with, we apply linear probing to LLMs. The
high probing accuracy suggests that \textit{LLMs in early pre-training can
already distinguish concepts in each trustworthiness dimension}. Therefore, to
further uncover the hidden possibilities of pre-training, we extract steering
vectors from a LLM's pre-training checkpoints to enhance the LLM's
trustworthiness. Finally, inspired by~\citet{choi2023understanding} that mutual
information estimation is bounded by linear probing accuracy, we also probe
LLMs with mutual information to investigate the dynamics of trustworthiness
during pre-training. We are the first to observe a similar two-phase
phenomenon: fitting and compression~\citep{shwartz2017opening}. This research
provides an initial exploration of trustworthiness modeling during LLM
pre-training, seeking to unveil new insights and spur further developments in
the field. We will make our code publicly accessible at
\url{https://github.com/ChnQ/TracingLLM}.
|
[
-0.4345409870147705,
-0.58199542760849,
0.8458258509635925,
-0.1133095845580101,
-0.22738206386566162,
0.1645798683166504,
-0.03467896208167076,
-0.5227217674255371,
0.019283683970570564,
0.23935791850090027,
-0.8514184355735779,
-0.2894952595233917,
-0.8814494013786316,
-0.2732895612716675,
-0.6186160445213318,
0.9035316109657288,
-0.01734626293182373,
0.11447487771511078,
-0.3220385015010834,
-0.10432341694831848,
-0.10800337046384811,
-0.7905842065811157,
-0.5630099177360535,
-0.6192852258682251,
0.5555902123451233,
0.08509726822376251,
0.5299245715141296,
0.5079946517944336,
0.2343963086605072,
0.33296793699264526,
-0.14094555377960205,
-0.15426993370056152,
-0.9067862629890442,
0.32201558351516724,
-0.09034772217273712,
-0.6288811564445496,
-0.6939390897750854,
0.5152727365493774,
0.7030872702598572,
0.3681361973285675,
0.028393186628818512,
0.25613757967948914,
0.5470641255378723,
0.5287444591522217,
-0.4831610321998596,
0.23406106233596802,
-0.597896158695221,
-0.11382865160703659,
-0.39019492268562317,
-0.4858795404434204,
-0.33643877506256104,
-0.4138168692588806,
0.4236062467098236,
-0.7022616267204285,
0.06068544462323189,
0.1341705024242401,
1.267231822013855,
0.12048149853944778,
-0.3637904226779938,
-0.1755327433347702,
-0.6180295348167419,
0.7945821285247803,
-0.4270825982093811,
0.5675142407417297,
0.4086604118347168,
0.12681016325950623,
-0.24760757386684418,
-0.9615442156791687,
-0.514936625957489,
-0.42418593168258667,
-0.02858811244368553,
-0.20065702497959137,
-0.08045322448015213,
-0.09867747873067856,
0.15196482837200165,
0.23971131443977356,
-0.1791892945766449,
0.18591898679733276,
0.028802070766687393,
-0.7218883037567139,
0.3798462152481079,
0.018774982541799545,
0.1305847465991974,
0.32979950308799744,
-0.39467984437942505,
-0.3251020610332489,
-0.7714092135429382,
0.11933240294456482,
0.488129585981369,
-0.14704929292201996,
-0.33230942487716675,
0.26526305079460144,
0.13668569922447205,
0.21027617156505585,
0.1783147007226944,
-0.24743209779262543,
0.22095417976379395,
-0.6750797033309937,
0.0056986939162015915,
-0.21678811311721802,
0.8559691905975342,
-0.010267066769301891,
0.555998682975769,
-0.03288790583610535,
-0.14410410821437836,
-0.16335101425647736,
0.2541429102420807,
-0.735838770866394,
-0.23323312401771545,
0.09112700074911118,
-0.5177310109138489,
-0.6777182221412659,
0.040316417813301086,
-0.6508083343505859,
-0.4094061553478241,
-0.2864437401294708,
0.6280157566070557,
-0.4451901614665985,
-0.5337424278259277,
-0.0874181017279625,
0.3305622637271881,
0.4153698980808258,
0.2610418498516083,
-0.430166631937027,
-0.02555629424750805,
0.8428722023963928,
0.808017909526825,
-0.06645914167165756,
-0.6376542448997498,
-0.6081956624984741,
0.013402855023741722,
-0.21739795804023743,
0.3049575090408325,
-0.4415581524372101,
-0.21331648528575897,
0.13152800500392914,
-0.022563718259334564,
0.14627644419670105,
-0.1817745417356491,
0.4144861400127411,
-0.7279785871505737,
-0.01008773222565651,
-0.3806135058403015,
-0.5627395510673523,
-0.06999421119689941,
0.5762028694152832,
-0.5626192092895508,
0.9777988791465759,
-0.12282981723546982,
-0.9382747411727905,
0.4483904242515564,
-0.3305510878562927,
-0.059717241674661636,
-0.22824862599372864,
-0.284988135099411,
-0.46670031547546387,
0.042882297188043594,
-0.1805277019739151,
0.6702952980995178,
-0.15416336059570312,
0.1894136220216751,
-0.664250910282135,
-0.3071901798248291,
0.4834236800670624,
-0.3694052994251251,
0.7147762179374695,
0.01930268481373787,
-0.2555120289325714,
0.11354890465736389,
-0.8181390762329102,
0.08378161489963531,
0.0020206605549901724,
-0.11204700171947479,
-0.23932336270809174,
-0.09904447197914124,
-0.46914416551589966,
0.22973424196243286,
0.5387402772903442,
-0.37102675437927246,
-0.3271125555038452,
-0.2396204024553299,
0.28494128584861755,
0.9302234649658203,
-0.18171513080596924,
0.47999095916748047,
-0.31935301423072815,
0.6755067706108093,
0.1958145797252655,
0.31479039788246155,
-0.10016936808824539,
-0.16386468708515167,
-0.7699394822120667,
-0.003976938780397177,
0.19214682281017303,
0.2651427984237671,
-0.48851796984672546,
0.2645796239376068,
-0.3366340100765228,
-0.3872523903846741,
-0.31277403235435486,
0.11306627839803696,
0.5524889826774597,
0.32151681184768677,
0.09194977581501007,
-0.4233514070510864,
-0.39466241002082825,
-0.6647195816040039,
-0.18486616015434265,
-0.37860432267189026,
0.0690600648522377,
0.1378578543663025,
0.5237551331520081,
-0.23841971158981323,
0.7285773754119873,
-0.1430513858795166,
-0.1199532002210617,
-0.08613979071378708,
0.24606172740459442,
-0.14529085159301758,
0.5347071886062622,
0.532346785068512,
-0.355784147977829,
-0.24417494237422943,
-0.1916331797838211,
-0.4322066009044647,
-0.10093893110752106,
0.1955115646123886,
-0.2547309994697571,
0.04795535281300545,
0.8115659356117249,
-0.4020141661167145,
0.2565505802631378,
0.9668624401092529,
-0.35360610485076904,
0.6879551410675049,
-0.28505176305770874,
-0.05152720957994461,
-1.057138204574585,
0.09048395603895187,
-0.17477670311927795,
-0.4055843651294708,
-0.4965105652809143,
0.055565472692251205,
-0.00908154807984829,
0.1813732385635376,
-0.2961731553077698,
0.2961272597312927,
-0.7364702820777893,
-0.2101021409034729,
-0.20985980331897736,
0.2391841560602188,
-0.17311720550060272,
0.19542576372623444,
-0.4448772668838501,
0.6642510890960693,
0.8282420635223389,
-0.601274311542511,
0.04727071523666382,
-0.14380182325839996,
-0.28768038749694824,
0.6131383776664734,
-0.517211377620697,
0.43429237604141235,
-0.16474665701389313,
0.189208984375,
-0.7962409853935242,
0.08462793380022049,
0.16714274883270264,
-0.6248056292533875,
0.5649441480636597,
-0.2398689091205597,
-0.43191421031951904,
0.11606362462043762,
-0.34034600853919983,
0.28745052218437195,
0.49447065591812134,
-0.35642918944358826,
0.8371198177337646,
0.42861661314964294,
0.0073456610552966595,
-0.660053551197052,
-0.3443109095096588,
-0.2803702652454376,
-0.19467228651046753,
-0.6920012831687927,
-0.09037408232688904,
-0.1486673355102539,
-0.22256749868392944,
-0.16614773869514465,
-0.3366797864437103,
-0.3340452015399933,
0.3644218146800995,
0.5733272433280945,
0.2991231381893158,
-0.16824284195899963,
-0.19642750918865204,
-0.20872363448143005,
-0.36478713154792786,
0.5744253396987915,
-0.33387333154678345,
0.8678617477416992,
-0.38195109367370605,
-0.22096915543079376,
-0.6262084245681763,
-0.1725974977016449,
0.5797558426856995,
-0.246578186750412,
0.9510824680328369,
0.8536655902862549,
-0.09471887350082397,
-0.21420817077159882,
-0.6286889314651489,
-0.48837095499038696,
-0.5699087977409363,
0.27218857407569885,
-0.3391200602054596,
-1.2638890743255615,
0.6058369278907776,
-0.19642746448516846,
-0.21879856288433075,
0.2999497652053833,
0.3725108802318573,
-0.17550981044769287,
0.5578575134277344,
0.8992425799369812,
-0.28189244866371155,
0.35220497846603394,
0.08302139490842819,
0.14085954427719116,
-0.3756188154220581,
-0.5475791096687317,
-0.677927553653717,
-0.13457360863685608,
-0.6936748623847961,
-0.5095459818840027,
0.3813360035419464,
0.2135889083147049,
-0.1647876352071762,
-0.09823693335056305,
0.21783985197544098,
0.5070655345916748,
0.3737705647945404,
0.047525737434625626,
0.327377051115036,
-0.281020849943161,
-0.29672905802726746,
-0.08414098620414734,
-0.4081595242023468,
-0.41600072383880615,
1.0613669157028198,
0.8822261095046997,
0.7975465655326843,
-0.17175482213497162,
0.7122727036476135,
-0.2722640931606293,
0.19982722401618958,
-0.4732356667518616,
0.7083473205566406,
0.17967423796653748,
-0.5855830907821655,
-0.4651663303375244,
-0.46332862973213196,
-0.7379375696182251,
-0.10094723105430603,
-0.4667756259441376,
-0.624517023563385,
-0.0986638143658638,
0.5735846757888794,
-0.24420508742332458,
0.16688013076782227,
-0.2955071032047272,
0.5546591281890869,
-0.24743089079856873,
-0.4807874262332916,
-0.4208192825317383,
-0.8709348440170288,
0.4854162037372589,
-0.3147595524787903,
0.11702075600624084,
-0.18369963765144348,
0.1752210557460785,
0.6711515188217163,
-0.30822402238845825,
0.8699126839637756,
-0.1705925464630127,
-0.2986646890640259,
-0.008109304122626781,
0.3975166976451874,
0.6892490386962891,
0.07289562374353409,
0.33692434430122375,
0.36594271659851074,
0.3670022487640381,
-0.32297155261039734,
-0.5158728361129761,
0.7655854225158691,
-0.6988778114318848,
-0.36960962414741516,
-0.633396327495575,
-0.44161278009414673,
-0.444680780172348,
0.3878743350505829,
0.22417865693569183,
0.2602575123310089,
-0.27737733721733093,
0.33757638931274414,
1.1232699155807495,
-0.18052473664283752,
0.4287818372249603,
0.670164167881012,
-0.2839532792568207,
0.18917809426784515,
0.6600940227508545,
-0.1227237731218338,
0.3556610941886902,
0.35350722074508667,
0.18457812070846558,
-0.32766732573509216,
-0.9381346702575684,
0.20235097408294678,
0.42919114232063293,
-0.29242250323295593,
0.012416480109095573,
-0.2842337191104889,
-0.39120393991470337,
-0.2544141113758087,
0.1644202619791031,
-0.8111083507537842,
-0.09801958501338959,
-0.34319832921028137,
-0.22253547608852386,
0.1620442122220993,
0.7782387137413025,
-0.21622534096240997,
0.27763745188713074,
-0.8087109923362732,
-0.1800099015235901,
0.27167677879333496,
0.5899212956428528,
0.055010613054037094,
-0.5472835302352905,
-0.33936935663223267,
0.0006578732863999903,
-0.1510181427001953,
-0.6724995970726013,
0.20549802482128143,
-0.0006287699216045439,
0.6295799612998962,
0.6781759858131409,
-0.13680726289749146,
0.5525426864624023,
-0.4070914685726166,
0.7618751525878906,
0.09854511171579361,
-1.1454486846923828,
0.3188793957233429,
-0.3193204700946808,
-0.08884285390377045,
0.7029802203178406,
0.6736659407615662,
-0.01797908917069435,
-0.44798094034194946,
-0.5176041722297668,
-0.5866038799285889,
0.4620225429534912,
0.1890278309583664,
-0.015760572627186775,
0.5401644110679626,
0.6823589205741882,
0.007525179535150528,
0.1838439702987671,
-0.7300925850868225,
-0.417217880487442,
-0.29812246561050415,
0.05694681033492088,
-0.4207707941532135,
-0.7547979950904846,
-0.2846596837043762,
-0.0970466136932373,
0.5517208576202393,
0.04753545671701431,
0.1839904487133026,
0.05747101828455925,
-0.19638311862945557,
0.11195756494998932,
0.24018289148807526,
0.565197765827179,
0.8556421995162964,
-0.23562468588352203,
0.40870141983032227,
0.03672848641872406,
-0.7957680225372314,
0.23974134027957916,
0.06658410280942917,
0.06520937383174896,
-0.2592504918575287,
0.5485544800758362,
0.6316640973091125,
0.24814525246620178,
-0.31421807408332825,
0.7899125218391418,
-0.048472125083208084,
-0.2843623459339142,
-0.521572470664978,
0.023090915754437447,
0.0822036862373352,
0.4776228368282318,
0.027720555663108826,
-0.27563801407814026,
-0.31947535276412964,
-0.533924400806427,
0.3643732964992523,
0.5803407430648804,
-0.5979322791099548,
-0.7379180192947388,
0.650829553604126,
0.19301064312458038,
0.011533060111105442,
0.411109060049057,
-0.08997910469770432,
-0.5525383353233337,
-0.02021852694451809,
0.10013893246650696,
0.7371772527694702,
-0.42104893922805786,
0.22540283203125,
0.10178491473197937,
0.4905228614807129,
-0.14589561522006989,
0.15647979080677032,
0.02297014743089676,
-1.0136868953704834,
-0.4550665616989136,
-0.590878427028656,
-0.23795609176158905,
0.366359680891037,
-0.9840314984321594,
0.011468350887298584,
-0.47984737157821655,
-0.1650254875421524,
-0.4864698052406311,
0.23343399167060852,
-0.7195521593093872,
0.10110773146152496,
0.05081918090581894,
0.8398060202598572,
-0.7500836253166199,
1.2204145193099976,
0.2671818137168884,
-0.08763014525175095,
-1.0751750469207764,
0.22764898836612701,
0.2518232762813568,
-1.182543396949768,
0.6368701457977295,
-0.05454869940876961,
-0.5491287708282471,
-0.03588232770562172,
-0.7476659417152405,
-0.8357273936271667,
1.456572413444519,
0.46077314019203186,
-0.8162633180618286,
-0.18157757818698883,
0.1866236925125122,
0.4969623386859894,
-0.2084464281797409,
0.1531337946653366,
0.7015312314033508,
0.3569025993347168,
-0.07306144386529922,
-1.0766197443008423,
0.2413766086101532,
-0.019002031534910202,
-0.20495310425758362,
0.07673732191324234,
-0.6156015396118164,
0.9164412021636963,
-0.06409487873315811,
-0.15505628287792206,
0.013308431953191757,
0.7787939310073853,
0.33067452907562256,
0.40319138765335083,
0.7388821244239807,
0.4886165261268616,
0.8214004635810852,
-0.03235917165875435,
0.9414974451065063,
-0.5971145629882812,
0.280941903591156,
1.1505317687988281,
-0.020595017820596695,
0.7389093637466431,
0.6126947999000549,
0.08106085658073425,
0.4096646308898926,
0.23918956518173218,
0.36602431535720825,
0.3704082667827606,
0.179664745926857,
-0.07921335846185684,
-0.2622074782848358,
0.056657031178474426,
-0.4741424322128296,
0.37439948320388794,
0.04906467720866203,
-0.427884042263031,
0.033059678971767426,
-0.31942781805992126,
0.4810742437839508,
-0.2215176671743393,
-0.1715741902589798,
0.37522903084754944,
0.27042561769485474,
-0.20181167125701904,
0.2703476548194885,
-0.3392782509326935,
0.6854373812675476,
-0.9343999028205872,
0.21996286511421204,
-0.28571027517318726,
0.05261662229895592,
0.08831488341093063,
-0.7260894179344177,
-0.03763635456562042,
-0.2538735270500183,
0.06847233325242996,
-0.5727934241294861,
0.6791335344314575,
-0.3541371822357178,
0.04455435276031494,
0.6106172800064087,
0.6531771421432495,
0.10431907325983047,
-0.062070876359939575,
-0.3416312634944916,
0.47864872217178345,
0.009377763606607914,
-0.3559633493423462,
0.7690266966819763,
0.6667987704277039,
0.4677262306213379,
0.7833937406539917,
0.5216734409332275,
0.2445494532585144,
0.2944423258304596,
-0.09633741527795792,
0.8928932547569275,
-0.44377318024635315,
-0.42038506269454956,
-0.8234686851501465,
0.4262242615222931,
0.049720898270606995,
-0.3017343580722809,
1.0577645301818848,
0.2968844473361969,
0.9903903007507324,
0.3133445084095001,
0.5331670641899109,
0.43749991059303284,
0.5754445791244507,
-0.8005245923995972,
1.0638259649276733,
-0.37635594606399536,
0.40112170577049255,
-0.24996918439865112,
-0.751956582069397,
0.20694619417190552,
0.5587928295135498,
0.11630161106586456,
0.018234513700008392,
0.9327265620231628,
0.917978048324585,
0.008687092922627926,
0.010522324591875076,
0.2846226990222931,
0.7917379140853882,
0.39835792779922485,
0.3946705758571625,
1.0703177452087402,
-0.09213142842054367,
0.7155133485794067,
-0.32710373401641846,
-0.3000771105289459,
0.06201443076133728,
-1.14385986328125,
-0.9939948320388794,
-0.6256464719772339,
-0.14093631505966187,
-0.8183115124702454,
-0.061659712344408035,
0.47898516058921814,
0.874397337436676,
-0.569266676902771,
-0.1680617332458496,
-0.05845055356621742,
-0.19326581060886383,
0.18946295976638794,
-0.16169589757919312,
0.032212622463703156,
-0.15013526380062103,
-0.44019705057144165,
0.4946359097957611,
-0.04376940429210663,
0.41895806789398193,
-0.6426783800125122,
-0.3425968289375305,
0.19132256507873535,
0.08060283958911896,
0.4143938422203064,
0.2515687942504883,
-0.3427312672138214,
-0.5853520035743713,
-0.10193224996328354,
0.06159842014312744,
-0.23756487667560577,
1.0766161680221558,
-0.44000953435897827,
0.1959078311920166,
0.2779146730899811,
0.5028990507125854,
0.6683326363563538,
-0.14656740427017212,
0.8451426029205322,
-0.5970674753189087,
0.2062147706747055,
0.13393273949623108,
0.24824799597263336,
-0.02927696891129017,
-0.11963644623756409,
0.16649547219276428,
0.2044484168291092,
-0.7234005331993103,
-0.9512290358543396,
0.3666325807571411,
-1.0129413604736328,
0.05919170752167702,
1.0738087892532349,
-0.5006563067436218,
-0.007731858175247908,
-0.11112932860851288,
0.24587345123291016,
0.19972555339336395,
-0.16177329421043396,
0.6539987325668335,
1.094574213027954,
-0.02185880020260811,
-0.29078951478004456,
-0.5130033493041992,
0.7953855991363525,
0.38931530714035034,
-0.7488845586776733,
-0.2763427495956421,
0.486393004655838,
0.6515387892723083,
0.1467260867357254,
0.7242845892906189,
-0.2164425551891327,
-0.1573653221130371,
0.03733443468809128,
-0.49010440707206726,
-0.25771382451057434,
-0.6371089816093445,
-0.333784282207489,
0.3382112383842468,
0.3589588701725006,
-0.2549612522125244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19464v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19464v1
|
Curiosity-driven Red-teaming for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-29T18:55:03 | 2024-02-29T18:55:03 |
Zhang-Wei Hong, Idan Shenfeld, Tsun-Hsuan Wang, Yung-Sung Chuang, Aldo Pareja, James Glass, Akash Srivastava, Pulkit Agrawal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) hold great potential for many natural language
applications but risk generating incorrect or toxic content. To probe when an
LLM generates unwanted content, the current paradigm is to recruit a
\textit{red team} of human testers to design input prompts (i.e., test cases)
that elicit undesirable responses from LLMs. However, relying solely on human
testers is expensive and time-consuming. Recent works automate red teaming by
training a separate red team LLM with reinforcement learning (RL) to generate
test cases that maximize the chance of eliciting undesirable responses from the
target LLM. However, current RL methods are only able to generate a small
number of effective test cases resulting in a low coverage of the span of
prompts that elicit undesirable responses from the target LLM. To overcome this
limitation, we draw a connection between the problem of increasing the coverage
of generated test cases and the well-studied approach of curiosity-driven
exploration that optimizes for novelty. Our method of curiosity-driven red
teaming (CRT) achieves greater coverage of test cases while mantaining or
increasing their effectiveness compared to existing methods. Our method, CRT
successfully provokes toxic responses from LLaMA2 model that has been heavily
fine-tuned using human preferences to avoid toxic outputs. Code is available at
\url{https://github.com/Improbable-AI/curiosity_redteam}
|
[
-0.253654807806015,
-0.9138733744621277,
0.6040850877761841,
0.39993804693222046,
-0.07637836784124374,
0.46324247121810913,
-0.308941513299942,
-0.527792751789093,
0.29879072308540344,
0.387174516916275,
-0.8158094882965088,
-0.4175472557544708,
-0.3699815273284912,
0.028288109228014946,
-0.42537790536880493,
1.17336106300354,
-0.016031809151172638,
-0.3734806478023529,
-0.07839429378509521,
-0.11655252426862717,
-0.3628544211387634,
-0.42058438062667847,
-0.7462300062179565,
-0.3510151505470276,
0.8364884257316589,
0.6833986639976501,
0.42395004630088806,
0.1788693219423294,
0.3913118243217468,
0.2315649688243866,
-0.2101571261882782,
0.29261863231658936,
-0.8559663891792297,
0.5200982093811035,
-0.03105539083480835,
-0.654191792011261,
-0.09555186331272125,
-0.06940758973360062,
0.26430007815361023,
0.1870933324098587,
-0.30434995889663696,
0.10135913640260696,
-0.21800099313259125,
0.4582309424877167,
-0.5652701258659363,
0.06625816226005554,
-0.8851302266120911,
0.14886248111724854,
-0.029845932498574257,
-0.49258655309677124,
-0.5232916474342346,
-0.2485363781452179,
0.12251059710979462,
-0.5811135768890381,
0.22719810903072357,
0.14951768517494202,
0.5853158831596375,
0.4353600740432739,
-0.2583587169647217,
-0.16108106076717377,
-0.8866814970970154,
0.8242019414901733,
-0.5012091994285583,
-0.055838778614997864,
0.21929343044757843,
0.361211359500885,
-0.29348886013031006,
-0.30148378014564514,
-0.5812199115753174,
-0.4180002212524414,
-0.07576371729373932,
0.20452824234962463,
-0.15715163946151733,
-0.06807291507720947,
0.11749275028705597,
0.0835149809718132,
-0.7992962002754211,
0.36548638343811035,
-0.24499867856502533,
-0.2183549702167511,
0.9309552311897278,
0.39051195979118347,
0.42926326394081116,
0.28559738397598267,
-0.5061419606208801,
-0.16993989050388336,
-0.7304991483688354,
-0.09396551549434662,
0.30410999059677124,
0.2765547037124634,
-0.052054762840270996,
0.7668079137802124,
-0.3627642095088959,
0.23820167779922485,
-0.003804275766015053,
0.28357741236686707,
0.21174299716949463,
-0.3659327030181885,
-0.021803203970193863,
0.026901952922344208,
0.7962729334831238,
0.1770695298910141,
0.3198556900024414,
-0.15437251329421997,
-0.5071668028831482,
0.23088400065898895,
0.37078794836997986,
-0.6298885345458984,
-0.4549126923084259,
0.5004599094390869,
0.14133372902870178,
-0.6216177344322205,
-0.2791045904159546,
-0.8846928477287292,
-0.5411612391471863,
0.15184436738491058,
0.350439190864563,
-0.39491593837738037,
-0.4183236360549927,
0.06859233230352402,
-0.10067761689424515,
0.09599103778600693,
0.26491910219192505,
-0.8579182624816895,
0.12132806330919266,
0.3571920394897461,
0.5280758142471313,
-0.6644923090934753,
-0.35976409912109375,
-0.8940852880477905,
0.10498321056365967,
-0.2364969700574875,
0.7325584292411804,
-0.3613082766532898,
-0.41565993428230286,
0.0656886026263237,
-0.33536845445632935,
0.20771671831607819,
-0.6334543228149414,
0.22481881082057953,
-0.7929157614707947,
0.27138710021972656,
-0.0719655454158783,
-0.184372216463089,
-0.057736027985811234,
0.6552723050117493,
-0.409153550863266,
1.0886884927749634,
0.10843266546726227,
-0.6763384938240051,
0.37608763575553894,
-0.9645054340362549,
-0.5372400283813477,
0.3785648047924042,
-0.11407230794429779,
-0.5914261937141418,
-0.11204393208026886,
0.0768313780426979,
0.3802424371242523,
-0.13852454721927643,
0.1419842541217804,
-0.20717176795005798,
-0.4017990529537201,
0.36829450726509094,
-0.19533535838127136,
0.6064325571060181,
0.04635099321603775,
-0.5922176837921143,
0.746218740940094,
-0.42053109407424927,
0.1499350517988205,
0.5557141900062561,
-0.5251159071922302,
-0.4477040767669678,
-0.06361857801675797,
0.12869445979595184,
0.15664885938167572,
0.08577939122915268,
-0.40169280767440796,
-0.0829777643084526,
-0.3278895318508148,
0.2606094479560852,
0.8689773678779602,
0.20810037851333618,
0.40227052569389343,
-0.5671519041061401,
0.8500121235847473,
0.02230905182659626,
0.201254740357399,
0.0319368839263916,
-0.3102430999279022,
-0.9673064351081848,
-0.18454788625240326,
-0.023024551570415497,
0.5426480770111084,
-0.925288736820221,
0.1288043111562729,
0.0389074832201004,
-0.6302844285964966,
-0.2548224627971649,
0.1057242602109909,
0.41682758927345276,
0.1845039576292038,
0.47707194089889526,
-0.11507619917392731,
-0.494187593460083,
-0.9271408319473267,
-0.10868922621011734,
-0.351256787776947,
0.03463375195860863,
0.6426664590835571,
0.5902882814407349,
-0.6076049208641052,
0.8870946168899536,
-0.5210726261138916,
-0.1858842968940735,
-0.5796698927879333,
0.23440317809581757,
0.07931750267744064,
0.2772798240184784,
0.48939037322998047,
-1.0166040658950806,
-0.7827866673469543,
0.07416552305221558,
-0.4783379137516022,
-0.16002923250198364,
-0.1995493620634079,
-0.07960285246372223,
0.5033714175224304,
0.31721827387809753,
-0.6653526425361633,
0.12037941813468933,
0.6688864231109619,
-0.20253010094165802,
0.7675796151161194,
-0.0019894118886440992,
-0.00663219066336751,
-0.7592838406562805,
0.03716351091861725,
0.13387253880500793,
-0.2828058898448944,
-0.611179530620575,
0.3265351951122284,
0.015815574675798416,
0.060843903571367264,
-0.724611759185791,
0.6526232957839966,
-0.35594743490219116,
0.23793788254261017,
-0.2006908655166626,
0.12755878269672394,
-0.2453271448612213,
0.5871101021766663,
-0.06012578681111336,
1.1750059127807617,
0.280101478099823,
-0.8211377263069153,
0.43312814831733704,
0.14487086236476898,
-0.06915343552827835,
0.08120211213827133,
-0.5804986357688904,
0.09354615211486816,
0.03327403962612152,
0.19719332456588745,
-0.784412145614624,
-0.4069691002368927,
0.3643200099468231,
-0.3458782434463501,
0.1959257274866104,
0.2292143702507019,
-0.6321452856063843,
-0.546303927898407,
-0.2733754515647888,
0.5083792805671692,
0.6453683376312256,
-0.5620275735855103,
0.47576022148132324,
0.5257975459098816,
-0.375393271446228,
-0.4356824457645416,
-0.7234721183776855,
0.01856018416583538,
-0.5150855779647827,
-0.33901411294937134,
0.2691947817802429,
-0.3171045780181885,
-0.35654276609420776,
-0.056225940585136414,
-0.032166216522455215,
-0.3390865921974182,
0.41995131969451904,
0.28420785069465637,
0.3448488414287567,
-0.07087811082601547,
0.15747739374637604,
-0.17971502244472504,
-0.00037312728818506,
0.2866213619709015,
-0.05779363960027695,
0.8375211954116821,
-0.1295730024576187,
-0.3507923185825348,
-0.2710883617401123,
0.4086454510688782,
0.6035780906677246,
-0.2898634672164917,
0.4911566972732544,
0.4703333377838135,
-0.06888291984796524,
-0.706098735332489,
-0.5042483806610107,
-0.5429807305335999,
-0.5042105317115784,
0.6182798147201538,
-0.028231292963027954,
-1.2460200786590576,
0.453858882188797,
0.1369880586862564,
0.06195341795682907,
0.2729758322238922,
0.8024923801422119,
-0.19013334810733795,
0.8476784825325012,
0.7874655723571777,
-0.198776975274086,
0.3574416935443878,
0.013690647669136524,
0.07393015921115875,
-0.5163511037826538,
-0.2188798189163208,
-0.21310864388942719,
-0.19982106983661652,
-0.44389045238494873,
-0.4049067497253418,
0.5516439080238342,
-0.6089327335357666,
-0.20618075132369995,
0.15688763558864594,
-0.5076211094856262,
0.7155072689056396,
0.6623608469963074,
0.1464414894580841,
0.28868281841278076,
-0.18982306122779846,
-0.14760033786296844,
0.013166197575628757,
-0.9277226328849792,
-0.11942640691995621,
0.9675253033638,
0.3811970353126526,
0.7890129685401917,
0.3333372175693512,
0.8487274646759033,
0.3010036051273346,
0.5891554355621338,
-0.8659577369689941,
0.6312282085418701,
0.4392496943473816,
-0.7938513159751892,
-0.5089648962020874,
-0.6125585436820984,
-0.8822140693664551,
-0.010007073171436787,
-0.2272166907787323,
-0.3986225426197052,
-0.3617967665195465,
0.17348803579807281,
-0.6304333806037903,
0.22479300200939178,
-0.7810803651809692,
0.41735026240348816,
-0.40812602639198303,
-0.5413630604743958,
-0.336757630109787,
-0.5048336982727051,
0.7418503761291504,
-0.3458494544029236,
-0.14538618922233582,
0.2683776617050171,
0.144139364361763,
0.4918205440044403,
0.173615962266922,
1.1038202047348022,
0.07565710693597794,
-0.2498999983072281,
0.2927212119102478,
0.4952971339225769,
0.7879564762115479,
0.32945600152015686,
0.1244099885225296,
-0.29652687907218933,
-0.4713485836982727,
-0.33201509714126587,
-0.3639693856239319,
0.5130670070648193,
-0.5766708254814148,
-0.9097651839256287,
-0.6243024468421936,
-1.0055570602416992,
-0.3057658076286316,
0.25488442182540894,
0.013716399669647217,
-0.2721770405769348,
-0.1685977280139923,
-0.014519593678414822,
1.0719503164291382,
-0.696293830871582,
0.3774459958076477,
0.7446808815002441,
-0.20074869692325592,
0.10013563930988312,
0.9560450315475464,
-0.5248459577560425,
0.5269957780838013,
0.38187175989151,
0.1277054101228714,
-0.25081703066825867,
-0.8204780220985413,
-0.02268156036734581,
0.24064593017101288,
-0.2694946229457855,
-0.19595731794834137,
-0.7235969305038452,
-0.3077905476093292,
-0.12119898200035095,
0.06250132620334625,
-0.4393303096294403,
-0.004711883142590523,
-0.3688141107559204,
-0.053197186440229416,
0.48158565163612366,
0.7336569428443909,
0.08508267998695374,
0.08633814007043839,
-0.6969488263130188,
0.09145153313875198,
0.6824547052383423,
0.16738128662109375,
-0.18073450028896332,
-0.3813926875591278,
0.023773500695824623,
0.036924734711647034,
-0.3354833126068115,
-0.5633689165115356,
0.6129830479621887,
-0.3375159204006195,
0.5994441509246826,
0.03991341218352318,
0.36518192291259766,
0.17407943308353424,
-0.3074950575828552,
0.5542697310447693,
0.1073860228061676,
-0.49620556831359863,
0.6091929078102112,
-0.8066656589508057,
0.04797033220529556,
0.6457294821739197,
0.3622055649757385,
-0.5086026787757874,
-0.6257065534591675,
-0.6221089363098145,
-0.8988502025604248,
0.5848626494407654,
0.18373209238052368,
0.11655797809362411,
-0.008799870498478413,
0.1704159677028656,
0.019344668835401535,
0.1567181497812271,
-0.958268404006958,
-0.20443680882453918,
0.27361589670181274,
-0.017427626997232437,
-0.08151419460773468,
-0.4489816427230835,
-0.44413653016090393,
0.17596939206123352,
0.7589181065559387,
-0.13941644132137299,
0.14761444926261902,
0.15066953003406525,
-0.07375199347734451,
-0.1718728095293045,
0.3323196768760681,
0.878974199295044,
0.24768666923046112,
-0.3301069438457489,
0.10633616149425507,
0.3280135989189148,
-0.27216002345085144,
0.20042745769023895,
-0.12182051688432693,
-0.1724172979593277,
-0.3571816086769104,
0.08089832216501236,
0.5090347528457642,
0.02601482905447483,
-1.135262370109558,
0.5082029700279236,
-0.20700053870677948,
-0.3171234726905823,
-0.3946143388748169,
0.5430650115013123,
0.04048304259777069,
0.4320957362651825,
0.3280388414859772,
0.01642143912613392,
-0.14630624651908875,
-0.5052428245544434,
0.39877310395240784,
0.5485630035400391,
-0.5085698366165161,
-0.1254451870918274,
0.5555523633956909,
0.42558637261390686,
-0.43465128540992737,
0.4848056435585022,
-0.6039227843284607,
-0.9981124401092529,
0.8103547096252441,
0.5300476551055908,
0.6823778748512268,
-0.03746617212891579,
0.5055784583091736,
0.16640497744083405,
0.4096401035785675,
-0.018600089475512505,
0.11174727231264114,
0.2659204304218292,
-0.7239694595336914,
-0.5541582107543945,
-0.1875763237476349,
-0.7734020948410034,
0.3645220398902893,
-0.35282811522483826,
0.15449506044387817,
-0.3677194118499756,
0.2838127315044403,
-0.5804471969604492,
0.023701688274741173,
-0.4142628014087677,
-0.05658924952149391,
-0.014213275164365768,
0.8010663986206055,
-0.7947816848754883,
0.7362993359565735,
0.6007809638977051,
-0.36476919054985046,
-0.7043277621269226,
0.2748670279979706,
0.04610440880060196,
-0.8754826188087463,
0.8787870407104492,
0.04396674036979675,
0.06407987326383591,
0.12639980018138885,
-0.4893893301486969,
-0.5875374674797058,
1.0708611011505127,
0.07329939305782318,
-0.6457105875015259,
0.19320973753929138,
0.019119875505566597,
0.5319961905479431,
-0.18274840712547302,
0.10735636204481125,
0.3972621560096741,
0.5260249972343445,
0.013494294136762619,
-0.6476803421974182,
0.22811266779899597,
-0.21649949252605438,
-0.3524894714355469,
0.12082768976688385,
-0.7993345260620117,
0.7744873762130737,
-0.7218210697174072,
-0.3894025385379791,
0.05512222647666931,
0.48654454946517944,
0.8077781796455383,
0.21242757141590118,
0.691323459148407,
0.34275874495506287,
0.7831471562385559,
0.16982728242874146,
1.2182252407073975,
0.1445797234773636,
0.21951331198215485,
1.2412339448928833,
-0.5183350443840027,
0.5951822400093079,
0.6224363446235657,
-0.051574114710092545,
0.11084745824337006,
0.5387289524078369,
-0.14817865192890167,
0.5131160616874695,
0.5279043316841125,
-0.42220360040664673,
-0.363319456577301,
-0.32206204533576965,
-0.15278653800487518,
0.254315584897995,
0.20599031448364258,
-0.073100745677948,
-0.10259754955768585,
-0.34694135189056396,
-0.17112119495868683,
0.2718685269355774,
0.14970935881137848,
0.6207228899002075,
-0.18711766600608826,
-0.688788115978241,
0.40497568249702454,
-0.2930459976196289,
1.0068511962890625,
-0.509421169757843,
0.07313930988311768,
-0.4342903196811676,
0.015180020593106747,
0.08508729934692383,
-0.8585757613182068,
0.19083920121192932,
-0.0408761166036129,
-0.18430054187774658,
-0.23894190788269043,
0.4958808720111847,
-0.45528456568717957,
-0.13296197354793549,
0.4867636263370514,
0.6553651094436646,
-0.22028769552707672,
-0.14216746389865875,
-0.5343501567840576,
-0.0806845873594284,
0.19941945374011993,
-0.3663792312145233,
0.5154345035552979,
0.47880297899246216,
0.022180184721946716,
1.0743348598480225,
0.7902631163597107,
0.2897581160068512,
-0.004559532273560762,
-0.010485697537660599,
1.1413484811782837,
-0.5799652934074402,
-0.3912643492221832,
-0.8344094753265381,
0.45959341526031494,
-0.04364112392067909,
-0.27514275908470154,
0.5899181365966797,
0.5202393531799316,
0.6010110974311829,
-0.04352225735783577,
0.8920376896858215,
0.19160224497318268,
0.4949533939361572,
-0.39849892258644104,
0.9574941396713257,
-0.5134379267692566,
0.3851839303970337,
-0.05336460843682289,
-0.724729061126709,
-0.5272181034088135,
0.38295814394950867,
-0.12692385911941528,
-0.1058654636144638,
0.7987878918647766,
0.9615218639373779,
0.02476172335445881,
-0.08286512643098831,
0.2143951803445816,
0.4235413372516632,
0.6384758949279785,
0.9663761258125305,
1.1789402961730957,
0.04828992486000061,
0.7376596331596375,
-0.14447185397148132,
-0.2878783345222473,
-0.37334170937538147,
-0.8203862905502319,
-1.1130595207214355,
-0.33689597249031067,
-0.26562169194221497,
-0.2941781282424927,
0.1046767309308052,
0.89226895570755,
0.503322422504425,
-0.6982636451721191,
0.0724995955824852,
-0.41421377658843994,
0.2165898233652115,
0.006034802179783583,
-0.2865171730518341,
-0.09745629131793976,
-0.46888136863708496,
-0.6672956347465515,
0.5129360556602478,
0.15668949484825134,
0.3032066524028778,
-0.394962877035141,
-0.20688234269618988,
-0.21132712066173553,
-0.17090870440006256,
0.5337215662002563,
0.4856387972831726,
-0.5025629997253418,
-0.28914445638656616,
0.23328863084316254,
-0.31090283393859863,
-0.19041019678115845,
0.49731138348579407,
-0.8399683833122253,
0.05407192185521126,
0.28665801882743835,
1.0914306640625,
0.44721734523773193,
-0.20169079303741455,
0.6645349264144897,
-0.7358381152153015,
0.08716051280498505,
0.7745816707611084,
-0.039911601692438126,
0.1035107970237732,
-0.5606108903884888,
0.7118538022041321,
0.11129187047481537,
-0.5636281371116638,
-1.1747775077819824,
0.34611889719963074,
-0.996932864189148,
-0.2870657742023468,
1.6878665685653687,
0.13225923478603363,
-0.14069035649299622,
-0.13848574459552765,
-0.20996840298175812,
0.11990727484226227,
-0.651454746723175,
1.2688345909118652,
0.4333530068397522,
-0.2022739052772522,
-0.08861519396305084,
-0.6125365495681763,
0.3717435300350189,
0.8289945125579834,
-1.008795976638794,
0.25196573138237,
0.2183637171983719,
0.24027155339717865,
0.19327495992183685,
0.46816179156303406,
0.17005951702594757,
0.34066808223724365,
-0.3480437397956848,
0.1855098456144333,
-0.08653521537780762,
-0.4525657296180725,
-0.0772053673863411,
0.13511472940444946,
0.06004021689295769,
-0.03753449395298958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19462v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19462v2
|
Accelerating materials discovery for polymer solar cells: Data-driven insights enabled by natural language processing
| 2024-02-29T18:54:46 | 2024-06-22T03:56:31 |
Pranav Shetty, Aishat Adeboye, Sonakshi Gupta, Chao Zhang, Rampi Ramprasad
|
cond-mat.mtrl-sci
|
cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.CL, physics.app-ph
|
We present a simulation of various active learning strategies for the
discovery of polymer solar cell donor/acceptor pairs using data extracted from
the literature spanning $\sim$20 years by a natural language processing
pipeline. While data-driven methods have been well established to discover
novel materials faster than Edisonian trial-and-error approaches, their
benefits have not been quantified for material discovery problems that can take
decades. Our approach demonstrates a potential reduction in discovery time by
approximately 75 %, equivalent to a 15 year acceleration in material
innovation. Our pipeline enables us to extract data from greater than 3300
papers which is $\sim$5 times larger and therefore more diverse than similar
data sets reported by others. We also trained machine learning models to
predict the power conversion efficiency and used our model to identify
promising donor-acceptor combinations that are as yet unreported. We thus
demonstrate a pipeline that goes from published literature to extracted
material property data which in turn is used to obtain data-driven insights.
Our insights include active learning strategies that can be used to train
strong predictive models of material properties or be robust to the initial
material system used. This work provides a valuable framework for data-driven
research in materials science.
|
[
-0.03675249218940735,
-0.9471679329872131,
0.620722770690918,
-0.217288538813591,
-0.027605028823018074,
0.3336491584777832,
-0.16772203147411346,
-0.24011072516441345,
-0.365255743265152,
0.33495503664016724,
-0.36733224987983704,
-0.2125806212425232,
-0.27094316482543945,
0.12303615361452103,
-0.06969623267650604,
0.5486158132553101,
-0.5034691095352173,
0.1907121241092682,
-0.3188261091709137,
0.3594990074634552,
0.23092998564243317,
0.19939599931240082,
-0.4484335482120514,
-0.3935374915599823,
0.274983286857605,
0.5119279026985168,
0.23480628430843353,
0.7360997200012207,
0.5387522578239441,
0.2868301570415497,
-0.44282084703445435,
0.48573899269104004,
0.006802711635828018,
-0.08640138804912567,
-0.3300507068634033,
-0.24371199309825897,
-0.4359987676143646,
0.3956044614315033,
0.6507232189178467,
0.8637677431106567,
-0.20957063138484955,
0.2524760067462921,
0.04720436409115791,
0.7744187116622925,
-0.5949693918228149,
0.29608532786369324,
-0.7535350322723389,
0.2901804447174072,
-0.2841832637786865,
-0.4158147871494293,
-0.5561685562133789,
-0.44573184847831726,
0.2876489460468292,
-0.5368415713310242,
0.9704787731170654,
0.06877613812685013,
0.7967556715011597,
-0.42456313967704773,
-0.4139988422393799,
-0.31074216961860657,
-0.9336214661598206,
0.8195756077766418,
-0.34352707862854004,
0.051777780055999756,
0.1807105541229248,
0.4909362196922302,
-0.3391246199607849,
-0.6334698796272278,
-0.6785987615585327,
-0.02045186422765255,
0.025371110066771507,
0.1637936234474182,
0.3612256348133087,
0.3794236183166504,
-0.08098568022251129,
0.6168373227119446,
-0.566425621509552,
-0.23081530630588531,
-0.6360511779785156,
-0.32579734921455383,
0.7168487310409546,
-0.03983425721526146,
-0.022554896771907806,
-0.4587870240211487,
-0.360623836517334,
-0.11362183094024658,
-0.3055401146411896,
0.013168971054255962,
0.5940084457397461,
0.7247881293296814,
-0.09690546244382858,
0.937026858329773,
0.006458922754973173,
0.758461594581604,
-0.21516405045986176,
0.2562834322452545,
0.173452690243721,
-0.9427476525306702,
-0.10467454046010971,
0.15956445038318634,
0.6401911377906799,
-0.08120066672563553,
0.05034848302602768,
-0.03207915648818016,
-0.11833452433347702,
-0.32194408774375916,
0.17665891349315643,
-0.8633086085319519,
-0.49816033244132996,
0.1573188304901123,
-0.8179746866226196,
-0.3992139995098114,
0.29560229182243347,
-0.5763152241706848,
-0.7689288854598999,
-0.4462085962295532,
0.5246176719665527,
-0.20487836003303528,
-0.4965283274650574,
0.40639787912368774,
-0.4976268410682678,
0.12512724101543427,
0.5627622008323669,
-0.8039209246635437,
0.5125715136528015,
0.5021393299102783,
0.9596738219261169,
-0.23646633327007294,
0.12184590846300125,
-0.5777965188026428,
-0.0293726846575737,
-0.18027810752391815,
0.8761905431747437,
-0.516542375087738,
-0.1505459100008011,
-0.3489852845668793,
0.11419007182121277,
-0.08255946636199951,
-0.5593262910842896,
0.5767602920532227,
-0.184244766831398,
0.4336493909358978,
0.0047081769444048405,
-0.35211122035980225,
-0.18784503638744354,
-0.24777686595916748,
-0.6852996349334717,
0.7200812697410583,
0.3875806927680969,
-0.6639624834060669,
0.48075565695762634,
-0.7304635643959045,
-0.28285646438598633,
-0.2523868680000305,
0.30191925168037415,
-0.925821840763092,
0.25435927510261536,
-0.11929382383823395,
0.5412155389785767,
-0.5373499393463135,
0.23511332273483276,
-0.14956483244895935,
-0.03179577365517616,
0.23121587932109833,
-0.35983744263648987,
0.4808025062084198,
0.3036789000034332,
-0.1684843748807907,
-0.00733663747087121,
-1.090166687965393,
-0.41894665360450745,
0.021184775978326797,
-0.2870527505874634,
-0.006098093464970589,
0.18574181199073792,
0.38859322667121887,
0.024386733770370483,
0.15305376052856445,
-1.2345330715179443,
0.12257584929466248,
-0.37085363268852234,
0.18443387746810913,
1.0698809623718262,
-0.06801028549671173,
0.6132300496101379,
-0.05089560151100159,
0.47738397121429443,
0.06297235935926437,
0.21109530329704285,
-0.28634563088417053,
-0.36437758803367615,
-0.5880945324897766,
0.32570526003837585,
0.29339101910591125,
0.24341949820518494,
-0.6931079626083374,
0.11861374229192734,
0.3722638189792633,
-0.7123469114303589,
-0.17030023038387299,
0.2632642090320587,
0.09819725900888443,
0.7960816025733948,
0.26494738459587097,
-0.4734206795692444,
-0.444314181804657,
-0.906254768371582,
-0.22773617506027222,
-0.21141444146633148,
0.16667912900447845,
0.6607881188392639,
0.2341553270816803,
0.07015518844127655,
1.066878080368042,
-0.8069518804550171,
-0.3067489564418793,
-0.3815171420574188,
0.37876319885253906,
0.6492338180541992,
0.4888112545013428,
0.1527733951807022,
-1.120408296585083,
-0.5357014536857605,
0.7105996012687683,
-0.5761141180992126,
0.28725889325141907,
-0.27041658759117126,
0.1247924342751503,
0.2078971415758133,
0.2620496153831482,
-0.33910977840423584,
0.15647771954536438,
0.36881116032600403,
-0.5169345140457153,
0.4650717079639435,
-0.5592373013496399,
0.00606024032458663,
-1.0930070877075195,
0.48790353536605835,
0.2680048942565918,
0.10736067593097687,
-0.7538517713546753,
-0.7296806573867798,
0.22641314566135406,
-0.40498122572898865,
-0.5208051800727844,
0.3008320927619934,
-0.6412169337272644,
-0.1268385946750641,
-0.43757522106170654,
-0.2451593279838562,
0.09326519072055817,
0.12744082510471344,
0.11538910120725632,
0.7972310185432434,
0.6845763921737671,
-0.8346905708312988,
0.4733823537826538,
0.05288968235254288,
-0.29803621768951416,
0.0804593488574028,
-0.3616529703140259,
0.030916903167963028,
-0.3711007237434387,
-0.005289370194077492,
-0.9936747550964355,
0.007957454770803452,
0.17745596170425415,
-0.47891730070114136,
0.36562442779541016,
-0.21499322354793549,
-0.5784921646118164,
-0.4436788558959961,
-0.10444612801074982,
0.29633834958076477,
-0.02784413844347,
-0.4755348563194275,
1.0296202898025513,
0.2654927968978882,
-0.34000498056411743,
-0.17478306591510773,
-0.025668811053037643,
-0.07309664040803909,
-0.07163278758525848,
-0.6279667019844055,
0.7639882564544678,
-0.3448791205883026,
0.028539512306451797,
-0.18370550870895386,
-0.3136458098888397,
-0.13848547637462616,
0.46365293860435486,
-0.007697108201682568,
0.3673592507839203,
0.032296545803546906,
0.2801661193370819,
-0.03399716317653656,
-0.39106500148773193,
0.06629391014575958,
-0.4739322066307068,
0.48482948541641235,
0.18512362241744995,
0.07284221053123474,
-0.6108858585357666,
-0.1412835717201233,
0.3678450286388397,
-0.1324670910835266,
0.6375436186790466,
0.4999467134475708,
-0.4753124415874481,
-0.3137933015823364,
-0.1782550811767578,
-0.23924054205417633,
-0.559762179851532,
0.03556090220808983,
-0.2559574544429779,
-0.24727416038513184,
0.4800741970539093,
-0.12196099758148193,
0.3306562900543213,
0.26876768469810486,
0.10126753151416779,
0.15665750205516815,
1.039062261581421,
0.7217517495155334,
0.465369313955307,
0.7930659651756287,
-0.38654765486717224,
0.26631927490234375,
-0.3653159439563751,
-0.7316600680351257,
-0.5411489009857178,
-0.2624029219150543,
-0.6335190534591675,
-0.638325572013855,
0.26559311151504517,
-0.4643743634223938,
0.20401795208454132,
0.5002642273902893,
-0.6949649453163147,
0.409746378660202,
-0.03304998576641083,
0.08184031397104263,
0.2755795121192932,
0.08606743067502975,
0.018190456554293633,
0.15277226269245148,
-0.7264928221702576,
-0.24258115887641907,
1.2091845273971558,
0.12230074405670166,
0.8026827573776245,
-0.21032917499542236,
0.3460012972354889,
0.2883983850479126,
-0.1313951313495636,
-0.7107168436050415,
0.4991699457168579,
0.0500061959028244,
-0.5611213445663452,
0.13441777229309082,
-0.7855203151702881,
-1.1674046516418457,
-0.14252792298793793,
-0.17570137977600098,
-0.059582654386758804,
0.46273279190063477,
0.10793111473321915,
-0.15459375083446503,
0.6445731520652771,
-0.7968435287475586,
0.6834781169891357,
-0.26006340980529785,
-0.7898280024528503,
-0.4624689817428589,
-0.43836453557014465,
-0.04039692133665085,
-0.07229816168546677,
0.14305679500102997,
-0.06473347544670105,
0.06972205638885498,
0.7272613048553467,
-0.21191716194152832,
0.29937517642974854,
-0.3825363516807556,
-0.400347501039505,
0.4203754961490631,
-0.06853632628917694,
0.4355924129486084,
0.04199377819895744,
-0.6499269008636475,
-0.6258661150932312,
-0.6399143934249878,
-0.5709104537963867,
-0.3182198703289032,
0.5020013451576233,
-0.3803280293941498,
-0.28635790944099426,
-0.5312452912330627,
-0.43896281719207764,
0.13089676201343536,
0.09849771112203598,
-0.09570533037185669,
0.44237491488456726,
-0.244937464594841,
0.08045259118080139,
0.7973127961158752,
-0.28551575541496277,
0.7402209639549255,
0.6458149552345276,
0.2797802686691284,
-0.17038626968860626,
1.3639013767242432,
0.20230679214000702,
0.3306749165058136,
0.40781259536743164,
0.3902013599872589,
-0.24203945696353912,
-1.0014984607696533,
-0.36768120527267456,
0.2588767111301422,
-0.06490827351808548,
-0.18577437102794647,
-0.6692827939987183,
-0.23083050549030304,
-0.28310346603393555,
-0.13324964046478271,
-0.7810773253440857,
-0.5563094615936279,
-0.4502655863761902,
-0.47841984033584595,
0.5093564391136169,
0.7957640290260315,
-0.1970546692609787,
-0.13471750915050507,
-0.6344837546348572,
0.5690274238586426,
0.25474444031715393,
0.8195521831512451,
-0.017859678715467453,
-0.15104825794696808,
-0.5953342318534851,
-0.048649825155735016,
-0.46284955739974976,
-0.6301782131195068,
0.39007365703582764,
0.2039634883403778,
0.5893588662147522,
0.40406155586242676,
0.034733809530735016,
0.21070784330368042,
-0.0840313509106636,
0.37418150901794434,
0.10993558168411255,
-0.7032483220100403,
1.196278691291809,
-0.6007662415504456,
0.052661195397377014,
0.3547896444797516,
0.22510796785354614,
-0.033865656703710556,
0.12770992517471313,
-0.9995009899139404,
-1.007705807685852,
1.1535738706588745,
0.43026936054229736,
-0.2526572346687317,
0.33547914028167725,
0.34540003538131714,
0.5972474813461304,
0.1475188136100769,
-0.5300896167755127,
-0.36094337701797485,
-0.02866920828819275,
0.14492642879486084,
-0.07701122015714645,
0.21605895459651947,
0.12669368088245392,
-0.22171753644943237,
0.7164742946624756,
-0.4302452504634857,
0.15197905898094177,
0.2539849877357483,
-0.010623646900057793,
-0.2933662533760071,
0.0375252291560173,
0.1980690360069275,
0.7097153067588806,
-0.7947584986686707,
-0.10297515243291855,
-0.12170460820198059,
-0.5137963891029358,
0.02880803868174553,
0.5840501189231873,
0.022956565022468567,
0.23490406572818756,
-0.47848376631736755,
0.6802652478218079,
-0.42151713371276855,
-0.6885671615600586,
0.22903698682785034,
-0.3934478759765625,
-0.18990373611450195,
-0.4113871455192566,
0.08000309765338898,
-0.3141539692878723,
-0.06091677024960518,
0.7575663924217224,
0.5406672358512878,
0.40264901518821716,
-0.9258089065551758,
0.37728050351142883,
0.39881032705307007,
-0.6026599407196045,
-0.4299391210079193,
0.5411058664321899,
0.48417291045188904,
-0.06032203510403633,
0.21346424520015717,
-0.13303127884864807,
-0.12067393958568573,
0.9903314709663391,
0.4335176348686218,
0.7048192620277405,
-0.07716439664363861,
0.5912833213806152,
0.5692394971847534,
-0.1894761323928833,
-0.09211563318967819,
0.23333720862865448,
-0.5934804677963257,
-0.5798068046569824,
-0.13433204591274261,
-0.5250980854034424,
-0.6766549348831177,
-0.24208009243011475,
-0.5802768468856812,
0.4313586354255676,
-0.5722203254699707,
0.18005625903606415,
0.22358667850494385,
0.688184916973114,
-0.4075700044631958,
0.11936703324317932,
0.23432080447673798,
0.829609751701355,
-0.9871966242790222,
0.5625801682472229,
0.5747187733650208,
0.09237431734800339,
-0.3996235132217407,
-0.4137054681777954,
0.04265299439430237,
-0.2699180245399475,
0.4838227927684784,
0.4523749053478241,
-0.030360843986272812,
0.03130873292684555,
-0.43216168880462646,
-0.7233880758285522,
1.339559555053711,
0.0774785652756691,
-0.027526527643203735,
0.30660825967788696,
0.0016490279231220484,
0.21933190524578094,
-0.4417731761932373,
0.39629387855529785,
0.5954819321632385,
0.5840167999267578,
0.048891399055719376,
-0.6350553035736084,
-0.14092397689819336,
-0.6183505654335022,
-0.3695221543312073,
0.5770998597145081,
-0.6215336322784424,
0.5986747741699219,
-0.34183192253112793,
-0.40071040391921997,
0.20540602505207062,
0.767556369304657,
0.35155266523361206,
0.7690770030021667,
0.3401009440422058,
0.17395834624767303,
0.8422693014144897,
-0.009859729558229446,
0.9175196886062622,
0.24646343290805817,
0.2555711567401886,
0.16815683245658875,
-0.3768291473388672,
0.3958621025085449,
0.6086093783378601,
-0.19078953564167023,
0.6588019728660583,
0.5676190257072449,
-0.30605727434158325,
0.3944990038871765,
0.3248976171016693,
-0.5668860673904419,
-0.2660188376903534,
-0.7156967520713806,
-0.15566514432430267,
0.3005746006965637,
0.41303908824920654,
-0.6301088333129883,
-0.12609902024269104,
0.11168352514505386,
-0.23177672922611237,
0.31046536564826965,
-0.35217782855033875,
0.6426163911819458,
-0.0989040657877922,
-0.5671929121017456,
0.18340203166007996,
0.03635243698954582,
0.7044804096221924,
-0.5952129364013672,
-0.12509262561798096,
0.01039397157728672,
0.32709893584251404,
-0.31382542848587036,
-0.9357776641845703,
-0.02672027423977852,
0.004758605733513832,
-0.4916464388370514,
-0.9716991186141968,
0.8157930374145508,
-0.07090289145708084,
-0.60880047082901,
0.2222287803888321,
0.45214563608169556,
-0.24082690477371216,
0.24779276549816132,
-0.4843468964099884,
-0.5252056121826172,
0.3216816186904907,
-0.24257084727287292,
0.35528650879859924,
0.42670711874961853,
0.2858620584011078,
0.750948965549469,
0.9770411849021912,
0.23366796970367432,
-0.3359620273113251,
-0.2090781033039093,
1.0280447006225586,
-0.8392818570137024,
-0.06857164949178696,
-0.5309925675392151,
0.602023184299469,
-0.40384000539779663,
-0.24344412982463837,
0.5957310199737549,
1.1431611776351929,
0.5741934776306152,
0.024796606972813606,
0.7627229690551758,
-0.04926231876015663,
0.5750748515129089,
-0.5704103112220764,
0.6964737772941589,
-0.3937108516693115,
0.43188753724098206,
-0.18014605343341827,
-0.8687627911567688,
-0.1379903256893158,
0.6146450042724609,
-0.022468851879239082,
-0.26537778973579407,
0.5739827156066895,
0.7274684309959412,
-0.23397625982761383,
0.26048335433006287,
-0.46098265051841736,
0.19768688082695007,
0.6731954216957092,
0.11419431865215302,
0.45714354515075684,
-0.6433089375495911,
0.8698514103889465,
-0.4595392644405365,
-0.07834747433662415,
0.07175791263580322,
-0.7408261895179749,
-0.6161222457885742,
-0.6393970847129822,
-0.4493614137172699,
-0.26515859365463257,
0.018589448183774948,
0.6502484679222107,
0.49476680159568787,
-0.6979680061340332,
-0.524936318397522,
-0.9621718525886536,
0.5066521763801575,
-0.11139953136444092,
-0.2969246506690979,
0.48146501183509827,
-0.2080383002758026,
-0.8434982299804688,
0.660304069519043,
0.26237747073173523,
0.35803452134132385,
-0.04226691648364067,
0.024207862094044685,
-0.2535770535469055,
0.049381889402866364,
0.34801924228668213,
0.25455018877983093,
0.03499558940529823,
0.18847233057022095,
0.38315290212631226,
0.1966240406036377,
0.23010294139385223,
0.8469637036323547,
-1.2803869247436523,
0.770586371421814,
1.1411960124969482,
0.3350566625595093,
0.6730045080184937,
0.011957135982811451,
1.160083293914795,
-0.45188266038894653,
-0.05035141110420227,
0.43597114086151123,
0.3377258777618408,
0.45733776688575745,
-0.23567530512809753,
0.5256291627883911,
0.401998907327652,
-0.5801562666893005,
-0.8435595631599426,
0.23745620250701904,
-1.3779360055923462,
-0.4108995199203491,
0.8563186526298523,
0.25796863436698914,
-0.4128898084163666,
-0.2586868107318878,
-0.4543018043041229,
0.40286722779273987,
-0.5764302611351013,
0.903652012348175,
0.1634611189365387,
-0.3212718367576599,
-0.19163647294044495,
-0.30593985319137573,
0.5601739883422852,
0.6733118295669556,
-0.7933627963066101,
0.4926351010799408,
0.32559096813201904,
-0.19316428899765015,
0.15250061452388763,
0.05290370061993599,
-0.25871530175209045,
0.6059298515319824,
-0.16326099634170532,
-0.17807765305042267,
-0.2026963084936142,
-0.32895711064338684,
-0.1527349352836609,
0.3024342656135559,
-0.13495558500289917,
0.07953555136919022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19457v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19457v2
|
$\texttt{COSMIC}$: Mutual Information for Task-Agnostic Summarization Evaluation
| 2024-02-29T18:51:23 | 2024-03-01T15:29:52 |
Maxime Darrin, Philippe Formont, Jackie Chi Kit Cheung, Pablo Piantanida
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Assessing the quality of summarizers poses significant challenges. In
response, we propose a novel task-oriented evaluation approach that assesses
summarizers based on their capacity to produce summaries that are useful for
downstream tasks, while preserving task outcomes. We theoretically establish a
direct relationship between the resulting error probability of these tasks and
the mutual information between source texts and generated summaries. We
introduce $\texttt{COSMIC}$ as a practical implementation of this metric,
demonstrating its strong correlation with human judgment-based metrics and its
effectiveness in predicting downstream task performance. Comparative analyses
against established metrics like $\texttt{BERTScore}$ and $\texttt{ROUGE}$
highlight the competitive performance of $\texttt{COSMIC}$.
|
[
-0.1896965056657791,
-0.45519062876701355,
0.5194292068481445,
0.20091550052165985,
-0.4056377410888672,
0.24357058107852936,
-0.3287016451358795,
-0.3950417935848236,
0.6525858640670776,
0.12058810144662857,
-0.48491236567497253,
-0.10901579260826111,
-0.9767305254936218,
0.10239455103874207,
-0.21124248206615448,
1.219566822052002,
0.13248467445373535,
-0.1419648677110672,
-0.5390527248382568,
-0.1488572359085083,
-0.7958089113235474,
-0.34553399682044983,
-0.5724005103111267,
-0.12525226175785065,
0.9440046548843384,
0.020264655351638794,
0.6870395541191101,
0.3706248104572296,
0.9485584497451782,
0.34937214851379395,
0.04003056511282921,
0.3787843585014343,
-0.6107031106948853,
0.1488441526889801,
-0.535576581954956,
-0.2682916224002838,
-0.5444842576980591,
0.09721656143665314,
0.6506021022796631,
0.9473283290863037,
0.062217406928539276,
0.5387662053108215,
0.2785068154335022,
0.934297502040863,
-1.0053160190582275,
0.2839229702949524,
-0.21995535492897034,
0.1881142258644104,
-0.2910310626029968,
-0.6659079790115356,
-0.07792352885007858,
-0.5029576420783997,
-0.011010689660906792,
-0.7551310062408447,
0.03635243698954582,
0.0760200098156929,
0.8156284093856812,
0.5439264178276062,
-0.40117236971855164,
-0.40184274315834045,
-0.7511370182037354,
0.6552636623382568,
-0.37915608286857605,
0.32291650772094727,
0.41647249460220337,
0.6391188502311707,
0.10418005287647247,
-0.6350734829902649,
-0.34846240282058716,
-0.11137805879116058,
-0.27196189761161804,
0.912979781627655,
-0.28019067645072937,
-0.23555834591388702,
-0.3761079013347626,
0.4689374566078186,
-0.23885710537433624,
-0.35292530059814453,
-0.4393003582954407,
-0.13530340790748596,
0.6171371936798096,
0.5887988805770874,
0.1733980029821396,
-0.33150821924209595,
0.05881491303443909,
0.06634274870157242,
-0.33714139461517334,
-0.0804641917347908,
0.4452521502971649,
0.09756115078926086,
-0.03774411231279373,
0.6813703179359436,
-0.19799745082855225,
0.4776109457015991,
0.39837968349456787,
0.13828961551189423,
-0.049989234656095505,
-0.8974536657333374,
-0.15876896679401398,
-0.515356719493866,
0.8445883989334106,
0.6840060353279114,
-0.22701290249824524,
-0.5238986611366272,
0.020701460540294647,
0.058798763900995255,
0.7399934530258179,
-0.7740416526794434,
-0.07414750754833221,
-0.01525967102497816,
-0.5644054412841797,
-0.11759699881076813,
0.3741725981235504,
-0.46587130427360535,
-0.2206488698720932,
-0.41350895166397095,
0.626180112361908,
-0.39541444182395935,
-0.2228080928325653,
-0.2990948259830475,
-0.7234414219856262,
-0.39024195075035095,
0.4480569064617157,
-0.8222419619560242,
0.35600167512893677,
0.8903411030769348,
0.9393581748008728,
-0.044710587710142136,
-0.3286425769329071,
-0.5661885142326355,
0.15532882511615753,
-0.2405889332294464,
0.864129364490509,
-0.22400400042533875,
-0.7240865230560303,
-0.5710187554359436,
-0.3129376471042633,
-0.21061958372592926,
-0.3238752782344818,
0.6962629556655884,
-0.4611609876155853,
0.2550586462020874,
-0.71979820728302,
-0.7562718987464905,
-0.23457401990890503,
0.10692443698644638,
-0.561308741569519,
0.5069586038589478,
0.19398283958435059,
-1.1202218532562256,
0.7762439250946045,
-0.5958133935928345,
-0.31005725264549255,
0.23035269975662231,
-0.002970925299450755,
-0.11919569224119186,
0.43149545788764954,
-0.18383562564849854,
0.5580555200576782,
-0.20677532255649567,
0.30122244358062744,
-0.24734623730182648,
-0.6134673357009888,
0.06970103830099106,
-0.39285069704055786,
0.49953439831733704,
0.29901641607284546,
0.0070568351075053215,
0.10083379596471786,
-0.2888126075267792,
-0.2860223650932312,
-0.08622784167528152,
-0.23203758895397186,
-0.7216678857803345,
0.31851059198379517,
-0.12046248465776443,
-0.25918135046958923,
0.53203946352005,
-0.413843035697937,
-0.11760881543159485,
-0.1541478931903839,
-0.04944990947842598,
0.6321511268615723,
0.1231173649430275,
0.38061174750328064,
-0.5462819337844849,
0.3486412763595581,
-0.277214378118515,
0.21262948215007782,
-0.05564965680241585,
-0.34156495332717896,
-0.47062408924102783,
-0.20124821364879608,
0.18492397665977478,
0.5484211444854736,
-0.39078086614608765,
1.0410146713256836,
-0.5502505898475647,
-1.098002552986145,
0.032295823097229004,
-0.06143641471862793,
0.7219292521476746,
0.48118820786476135,
0.18106356263160706,
-0.762579619884491,
-0.31664222478866577,
-0.6680301427841187,
-0.6264210939407349,
-0.2422172576189041,
-0.08912491053342819,
0.31062251329421997,
0.36986181139945984,
-0.16657783091068268,
0.8920683264732361,
-0.5983251333236694,
-0.17583486437797546,
-0.21715614199638367,
0.3299838900566101,
0.39071518182754517,
0.37088456749916077,
0.5512060523033142,
-0.4981728494167328,
-0.2967737913131714,
0.05890737473964691,
-0.9832347631454468,
-0.17985689640045166,
-0.04802648350596428,
-0.30455687642097473,
-0.23841427266597748,
0.060800518840551376,
-0.3723783791065216,
0.23953066766262054,
0.5657005906105042,
-0.9407550096511841,
0.9242726564407349,
-0.35831892490386963,
0.7986342310905457,
-1.1180821657180786,
0.4363136291503906,
-0.0070394244976341724,
-0.2772653102874756,
-0.23178568482398987,
0.2968732714653015,
0.03173612058162689,
0.28957244753837585,
-0.0716559886932373,
0.6089087724685669,
-0.378709077835083,
-0.26383647322654724,
-0.3787337839603424,
0.18205131590366364,
0.04954352229833603,
0.2919858992099762,
-0.2608790397644043,
0.5427189469337463,
0.17968282103538513,
-0.6065597534179688,
0.24210429191589355,
0.3127078711986542,
-0.22408682107925415,
1.2100906372070312,
-0.6403036117553711,
-0.1628180742263794,
-0.19094440340995789,
0.464525043964386,
-0.8344846367835999,
-0.2898528277873993,
-0.0011245050700381398,
-0.8504795432090759,
0.1840774118900299,
0.1269555687904358,
-0.5614713430404663,
-0.2679561674594879,
-0.21818864345550537,
0.5021932125091553,
0.4378536343574524,
-0.23885127902030945,
0.4379419982433319,
0.4726443290710449,
-0.35213878750801086,
-0.8943713903427124,
-0.5057170391082764,
0.21132132411003113,
-0.20072565972805023,
-0.5145257115364075,
0.16440895199775696,
-0.1440938115119934,
-0.2526143193244934,
0.27939122915267944,
-0.516320526599884,
-0.06689346581697464,
0.25986212491989136,
0.6947000026702881,
0.3613792061805725,
0.24327977001667023,
-0.24462415277957916,
0.44424450397491455,
-0.29502010345458984,
0.2781096398830414,
-0.2718054950237274,
-0.11669851094484329,
0.03725910559296608,
-0.4639136493206024,
-0.36586764454841614,
0.15646196901798248,
0.20218251645565033,
0.049153752624988556,
0.3843274414539337,
0.5939954519271851,
-0.23421145975589752,
0.21587075293064117,
-0.5698018670082092,
0.007464471273124218,
-0.4042332172393799,
0.4010448753833771,
-0.16326142847537994,
-0.8595408797264099,
0.641913890838623,
0.1756971776485443,
0.13166166841983795,
0.8608462810516357,
0.5406473278999329,
-0.15210340917110443,
0.4633192718029022,
0.44036585092544556,
-0.03543717414140701,
0.27264121174812317,
-0.16851308941841125,
-0.04437540844082832,
-0.8459565043449402,
-0.1458490788936615,
-0.5793786644935608,
-0.1972481906414032,
-0.07179027050733566,
-0.44121482968330383,
0.6471408009529114,
0.2915063500404358,
-0.007442118600010872,
0.6754958033561707,
-0.35473304986953735,
0.6443891525268555,
0.6155418157577515,
-0.05162648484110832,
0.36939382553100586,
-0.4974256753921509,
0.19164100289344788,
-0.15041489899158478,
-0.3875219225883484,
-0.3032301664352417,
1.0817945003509521,
-0.02699495479464531,
0.3288619816303253,
0.24401865899562836,
0.7266197800636292,
0.5427648425102234,
0.5626596808433533,
-0.5067971348762512,
0.4474675953388214,
-0.38229650259017944,
-0.5275393724441528,
-0.11165132373571396,
-0.8510422706604004,
-0.8497788310050964,
0.2726944088935852,
-0.2515801787376404,
-0.6499486565589905,
-0.12196693569421768,
0.059117820113897324,
-0.3591402769088745,
0.06439168006181717,
-0.734407365322113,
0.738603949546814,
0.18676334619522095,
-0.32190054655075073,
-0.8105547428131104,
-0.5342409610748291,
0.39107590913772583,
-0.29323601722717285,
0.20835287868976593,
-0.16664578020572662,
-0.1831163763999939,
0.949764609336853,
-0.4633764922618866,
0.7341874837875366,
-0.35962218046188354,
0.20848456025123596,
0.33346986770629883,
0.20863479375839233,
0.058235906064510345,
0.35925400257110596,
0.025756962597370148,
0.535649299621582,
0.02936791628599167,
-0.30471593141555786,
-0.8341706991195679,
0.6464588642120361,
-0.6599562168121338,
-0.420697957277298,
-0.21975430846214294,
-0.5509039759635925,
-0.12118006497621536,
0.3080803453922272,
0.39264148473739624,
0.521844208240509,
-0.49737685918807983,
-0.04237556830048561,
-0.14992737770080566,
-0.18126080930233002,
0.47600066661834717,
0.39426130056381226,
0.11653759330511093,
-0.7664459943771362,
0.8007053136825562,
0.10995407402515411,
0.1501457244157791,
0.8519365787506104,
0.21330511569976807,
-0.3606569170951843,
-0.5081268548965454,
-0.4577901065349579,
0.04678158089518547,
-0.6072810888290405,
-0.3634548485279083,
-0.7645846605300903,
-0.07969189435243607,
0.15501028299331665,
-0.5131155848503113,
-0.4236399829387665,
-0.7230204939842224,
0.09386936575174332,
-0.042562682181596756,
-0.1424180567264557,
0.7061390280723572,
-0.2704821527004242,
0.07246419787406921,
-1.0745493173599243,
0.13890986144542694,
0.301102876663208,
0.32849639654159546,
-0.06924133002758026,
-0.36601024866104126,
-0.8791497945785522,
-0.13094361126422882,
-0.40096285939216614,
-0.7182944416999817,
0.24457357823848724,
-0.05013783648610115,
0.43275880813598633,
0.23148807883262634,
-0.15259025990962982,
0.7402651309967041,
-0.4552975594997406,
1.0341073274612427,
0.5642955303192139,
-1.2682535648345947,
0.4461250305175781,
-0.638873815536499,
0.4707944989204407,
0.8937361836433411,
0.0420646034181118,
-0.37111082673072815,
-1.0619031190872192,
-0.7398802042007446,
-0.6862629652023315,
0.4478816092014313,
0.6655018925666809,
0.05606549233198166,
-0.09022632986307144,
0.28775498270988464,
0.3556749224662781,
0.4228056073188782,
-0.21427461504936218,
-0.2939111292362213,
-0.349416583776474,
-0.00627003563567996,
-0.35938432812690735,
0.14638015627861023,
-0.07333338260650635,
-0.04251205548644066,
0.28249403834342957,
-0.008852438069880009,
0.4668292999267578,
0.30502647161483765,
-0.001700547174550593,
-0.11553235352039337,
0.1716502159833908,
0.40446871519088745,
0.8798065781593323,
-0.5126811861991882,
0.09038513898849487,
0.0837249904870987,
-0.6531113386154175,
0.035936515778303146,
0.12553556263446808,
0.12299463152885437,
0.10895458608865738,
0.6473097205162048,
0.3032444715499878,
0.21245232224464417,
-0.444191575050354,
0.7689378261566162,
-0.23837171494960785,
0.02690289355814457,
-0.23017115890979767,
0.23612412810325623,
-0.1396999955177307,
0.24162934720516205,
0.5263556838035583,
0.768047571182251,
0.6652474999427795,
-0.3064030408859253,
0.2713770270347595,
0.48200133442878723,
-0.45980483293533325,
-0.8477672934532166,
1.0268539190292358,
0.3922572135925293,
0.11529447883367538,
-0.04715194180607796,
-0.5852484107017517,
-0.1567905843257904,
0.6766482591629028,
0.025932900607585907,
1.1728911399841309,
-0.08236701786518097,
-0.07597891241312027,
0.6762204766273499,
0.07767878472805023,
0.1485775262117386,
0.00894651934504509,
-0.45411598682403564,
-0.5276868343353271,
-0.8738456964492798,
-0.5667082071304321,
-0.6206325888633728,
-0.7486801743507385,
-0.6361465454101562,
0.046131525188684464,
-0.3262473940849304,
-0.37721380591392517,
0.2261609584093094,
-0.014818327501416206,
-0.6843071579933167,
0.2407795786857605,
-0.2609747648239136,
0.6893927454948425,
-0.45732367038726807,
0.24532058835029602,
0.6827113032341003,
-0.4237430989742279,
-0.5773104429244995,
-0.004808059893548489,
0.21204935014247894,
-0.5058779120445251,
0.8299863934516907,
0.07560468465089798,
-0.1475134938955307,
-0.44366517663002014,
0.2536177635192871,
-0.7925848960876465,
1.3316631317138672,
0.2288767546415329,
-0.43639862537384033,
0.015139698050916195,
-0.35942479968070984,
0.5956500172615051,
-0.07914310693740845,
0.9004765748977661,
0.23869122564792633,
0.5950444340705872,
-0.1355588734149933,
-1.177212119102478,
0.20069299638271332,
-0.5566821098327637,
-0.22286048531532288,
0.48190397024154663,
-0.7986990809440613,
0.24431395530700684,
-0.3141692578792572,
-0.43524277210235596,
-0.08020045608282089,
0.7954049110412598,
0.1924862265586853,
0.68632572889328,
0.6262650489807129,
0.5125802755355835,
0.5771821737289429,
-0.19670070707798004,
1.14359712600708,
-0.3038753271102905,
0.43862903118133545,
1.0734426975250244,
0.17311479151248932,
0.6087243556976318,
0.22593674063682556,
-0.38803213834762573,
0.2757013738155365,
0.300013929605484,
-0.0036422729026526213,
0.6390555500984192,
0.05811301991343498,
0.0533331036567688,
0.25712692737579346,
-0.11695779114961624,
-0.09826195985078812,
0.3407074213027954,
0.2576373815536499,
-0.17518964409828186,
-0.20049144327640533,
-0.5939207673072815,
0.07899657636880875,
0.14931175112724304,
-0.21751226484775543,
0.8423019647598267,
0.06281840801239014,
-1.0078788995742798,
0.1664593368768692,
-0.1435207724571228,
0.8231439590454102,
-0.4765906035900116,
0.30388638377189636,
-0.23261667788028717,
-0.09077562391757965,
-0.38682809472084045,
-0.6587846279144287,
1.1468199491500854,
0.00918576493859291,
-0.21789158880710602,
-0.05563316494226456,
0.5563657283782959,
0.05252533033490181,
-0.3013903796672821,
0.2824260890483856,
0.6944090723991394,
-0.03914180397987366,
-0.026624415069818497,
-0.30475643277168274,
-0.35636401176452637,
-0.2967413663864136,
-0.11687437444925308,
0.19939382374286652,
0.2666096091270447,
0.45415106415748596,
0.34102240204811096,
0.511358380317688,
0.1729341745376587,
-0.3742210268974304,
0.04945115000009537,
0.5430690050125122,
-0.828124463558197,
-0.8731083273887634,
-0.8470715284347534,
0.7515115737915039,
-0.17406077682971954,
-0.505215585231781,
1.0441335439682007,
0.6530953645706177,
0.3971869647502899,
-0.13246309757232666,
0.7844473123550415,
-0.33360573649406433,
0.45963677763938904,
-0.155150905251503,
0.8169997930526733,
-0.5810306668281555,
0.10916631668806076,
-0.6747308373451233,
-1.3028167486190796,
-0.118365079164505,
-0.07223373651504517,
-0.06724285334348679,
-0.04086010903120041,
0.9400811791419983,
0.14273950457572937,
-0.27640122175216675,
0.20410330593585968,
0.2771994173526764,
-0.18158994615077972,
0.08670367300510406,
0.6934499740600586,
0.8970903754234314,
-0.3018617630004883,
0.30302736163139343,
-0.11995955556631088,
-0.6510854363441467,
-0.09336703270673752,
-0.8121741414070129,
-0.9139457941055298,
-0.779569685459137,
-0.2882212698459625,
-0.1509798914194107,
0.18783622980117798,
0.4195910096168518,
0.8765787482261658,
-0.16143719851970673,
-0.1553923785686493,
-0.2354738712310791,
-0.17940978705883026,
-0.6245542764663696,
-0.24008814990520477,
0.4086655080318451,
-0.2793812155723572,
-0.7442300319671631,
0.2704933285713196,
0.5958448648452759,
-0.39093056321144104,
-0.1729818433523178,
-0.14565014839172363,
0.6523953676223755,
0.38316285610198975,
0.5696229934692383,
-0.07199561595916748,
-0.39934730529785156,
-0.21101175248622894,
-0.22017884254455566,
0.07159551233053207,
-0.4597368836402893,
0.7922449111938477,
-0.4332672655582428,
0.4390900135040283,
0.5801173448562622,
0.865186333656311,
0.3004068434238434,
0.1288275271654129,
0.7694485187530518,
-0.800081729888916,
-0.13564303517341614,
0.08669442683458328,
0.5282770991325378,
0.15221357345581055,
-0.5611530542373657,
0.8695092797279358,
0.37294888496398926,
-0.9667922854423523,
-0.3762947618961334,
0.05258899927139282,
-1.375867486000061,
-0.0008571114740334451,
0.8348750472068787,
-0.3829859495162964,
0.08872772008180618,
0.16019730269908905,
0.09069457650184631,
0.381522536277771,
-0.5668954849243164,
0.8601120114326477,
0.565984845161438,
-0.11055898666381836,
0.3930359184741974,
-0.3238065838813782,
0.23610562086105347,
0.4960680603981018,
-1.0742478370666504,
0.008833142928779125,
0.7661110758781433,
0.1346709430217743,
0.7052700519561768,
0.7869961261749268,
-0.16459427773952484,
0.3983463644981384,
0.16014456748962402,
-0.13721230626106262,
-0.1821790486574173,
0.06400824338197708,
0.04368022456765175,
0.15137754380702972,
-0.23279692232608795,
-0.07533812522888184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19450v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19450v1
|
Functional Benchmarks for Robust Evaluation of Reasoning Performance, and the Reasoning Gap
| 2024-02-29T18:48:18 | 2024-02-29T18:48:18 |
Saurabh Srivastava, Annarose M B, Anto P V, Shashank Menon, Ajay Sukumar, Adwaith Samod T, Alan Philipose, Stevin Prince, Sooraj Thomas
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We propose a framework for robust evaluation of reasoning capabilities of
language models, using functional variants of benchmarks. Models that solve a
reasoning test should exhibit no difference in performance over the static
version of a problem compared to a snapshot of the functional variant. We have
rewritten the relevant fragment of the MATH benchmark into its functional
variant MATH(), with functionalization of other benchmarks to follow. When
evaluating current state-of-the-art models over snapshots of MATH(), we find a
reasoning gap -- the percentage difference between the static and functional
accuracies. We find reasoning gaps from 58.35% to 80.31% among the
state-of-the-art closed and open weights models that perform well on static
benchmarks, with the caveat that the gaps are likely to be smaller with more
sophisticated prompting strategies. Here we show that models which anecdotally
have good reasoning performance over real-world tasks, have quantifiable lower
gaps, motivating the open problem of building "gap 0" models. Code for
evaluation and new evaluation datasets, three MATH() snapshots, are publicly
available at https://github.com/consequentai/fneval/.
|
[
-0.3583172857761383,
-0.7605252265930176,
0.5777844786643982,
0.08788908272981644,
0.05723064765334129,
-0.15001200139522552,
-0.20632773637771606,
-0.4838413894176483,
-0.22297318279743195,
0.20284411311149597,
-0.5643680691719055,
-0.20750068128108978,
-0.3536733090877533,
-0.14794015884399414,
-0.24471697211265564,
0.42858874797821045,
-0.10242712497711182,
0.11141260713338852,
-0.7639609575271606,
-0.5115516185760498,
-0.5413883328437805,
-0.439439982175827,
0.06124462932348251,
-0.3958386778831482,
0.2077133059501648,
0.42895272374153137,
0.9555524587631226,
0.4293912351131439,
0.6487411260604858,
0.2448762208223343,
-0.14276482164859772,
-0.1103641614317894,
-0.32403120398521423,
0.2718808650970459,
-0.210414320230484,
-0.41048258543014526,
-0.3939976394176483,
-0.12292568385601044,
0.5355556607246399,
1.0554003715515137,
-0.21011418104171753,
0.3368656635284424,
-0.39080795645713806,
0.4578855335712433,
-0.9777042269706726,
0.1391797959804535,
-0.6553515791893005,
-0.10507455468177795,
-0.20811861753463745,
0.36369845271110535,
-0.29989492893218994,
-0.6472399830818176,
0.1195090189576149,
-0.5065575242042542,
0.09428400546312332,
-0.2596479058265686,
0.9079412817955017,
0.40080374479293823,
-0.10700199007987976,
0.04353460296988487,
-0.43711766600608826,
0.8544201850891113,
-0.8811595439910889,
0.6344693899154663,
0.32485559582710266,
0.605678379535675,
-0.013169615529477596,
-0.6630235910415649,
-0.21513201296329498,
-0.45445358753204346,
0.08855798840522766,
-0.20315086841583252,
-0.2837453782558441,
-0.3469780385494232,
0.7516289949417114,
0.7949785590171814,
-0.35453394055366516,
-0.13206619024276733,
-0.23874421417713165,
-0.1282707005739212,
0.5986034274101257,
0.2238161563873291,
0.2571980357170105,
0.1846107393503189,
-0.1879686862230301,
-0.107744500041008,
-0.7482905983924866,
0.21160785853862762,
0.24536161124706268,
0.192390576004982,
0.01010674424469471,
0.6264593005180359,
-0.45107921957969666,
0.982609212398529,
-0.47215673327445984,
0.054728880524635315,
0.34752801060676575,
-0.47846874594688416,
-0.29088887572288513,
-0.5298792123794556,
0.30969932675361633,
0.25424137711524963,
0.5088667273521423,
-0.05144165828824043,
-0.42161449790000916,
0.4046023190021515,
0.2668851912021637,
-0.8519339561462402,
-0.2519148290157318,
0.012216453440487385,
-0.33465978503227234,
-0.06012338772416115,
0.08916300535202026,
-0.67206209897995,
-0.20329786837100983,
-0.3779049813747406,
0.3790647089481354,
-0.5775246620178223,
-0.32719579339027405,
0.438331663608551,
-0.010645791888237,
-0.06738676875829697,
0.3996054530143738,
-0.8036463260650635,
0.6380355358123779,
0.8043215274810791,
0.6982301473617554,
-0.009913153946399689,
-0.0616801455616951,
-0.6442906856536865,
-0.505365788936615,
-0.2405817061662674,
0.830938458442688,
-0.6624768376350403,
-0.36453020572662354,
0.10636946558952332,
-0.3020952641963959,
-0.24065575003623962,
-0.7317866086959839,
0.8089904189109802,
-0.2631944715976715,
0.047701504081487656,
-0.3398362100124359,
-0.6225384473800659,
-0.1930023431777954,
0.2766904830932617,
-0.8214725255966187,
1.2341800928115845,
0.4281652271747589,
-0.5590856671333313,
0.43192601203918457,
-0.7058741450309753,
-0.34692150354385376,
0.054185960441827774,
-0.1844034492969513,
-0.3781909942626953,
0.3524986207485199,
0.22388434410095215,
-0.06173449754714966,
-0.5372300744056702,
0.12759500741958618,
-0.7489950060844421,
-0.6052513122558594,
0.7347722053527832,
-0.3356006443500519,
0.8168850541114807,
0.3399634063243866,
-0.33937960863113403,
0.06563104689121246,
-0.772748589515686,
0.29349732398986816,
0.025047171860933304,
0.12105106562376022,
-0.4154207110404968,
0.17726722359657288,
-0.3299270272254944,
0.17344175279140472,
0.10687518119812012,
-0.34530267119407654,
0.08614937216043472,
-0.507841944694519,
0.38952866196632385,
0.5911092758178711,
-0.13375811278820038,
0.14425857365131378,
-0.6765143871307373,
0.5758076906204224,
-0.16312751173973083,
0.3018759489059448,
-0.289371520280838,
-0.5411533117294312,
-0.6623185276985168,
-0.5031391978263855,
0.68768709897995,
0.47377917170524597,
-0.476879358291626,
0.2076553851366043,
-0.11387112736701965,
-0.5131228566169739,
-0.28530290722846985,
-0.14669707417488098,
0.39553600549697876,
0.7082036733627319,
0.2595510184764862,
-0.3264796733856201,
-0.10603579133749008,
-0.6907550096511841,
-0.648493230342865,
-0.07791853696107864,
-0.1920749843120575,
0.33530300855636597,
0.6530260443687439,
0.06501957029104233,
0.8207990527153015,
-0.5459430813789368,
0.3327193260192871,
0.12319166958332062,
0.14649462699890137,
0.3564198315143585,
0.4842965304851532,
0.6840416193008423,
-0.6825091242790222,
-0.12880735099315643,
-0.23797982931137085,
-0.544915497303009,
-0.34398895502090454,
0.20538072288036346,
-0.14536692202091217,
-0.03233562409877777,
0.2892490029335022,
-0.5266501903533936,
0.49962854385375977,
0.1535058468580246,
-0.5087920427322388,
0.6917901635169983,
0.2868252992630005,
0.07861878722906113,
-0.5590934753417969,
0.23219004273414612,
0.010763349011540413,
-0.208139568567276,
-0.5171819925308228,
0.2535839378833771,
-0.07918920367956161,
-0.2796511650085449,
-0.3469502925872803,
0.7453460097312927,
-0.3521280884742737,
-0.09961893409490585,
0.28541576862335205,
0.13266555964946747,
-0.025757381692528725,
0.1652064025402069,
-0.20074087381362915,
0.6715229153633118,
0.6751105189323425,
-0.4466368854045868,
-0.1501212865114212,
0.15758787095546722,
-0.6123404502868652,
0.5117266774177551,
-0.8026748299598694,
-0.11513224989175797,
0.4640176296234131,
-0.10389602184295654,
-0.7833361029624939,
-0.28969496488571167,
0.027693184092640877,
-0.45796963572502136,
-0.009945116005837917,
-0.020278971642255783,
-0.49720776081085205,
-0.3694721460342407,
-0.3257661461830139,
0.6750242710113525,
0.49769482016563416,
-0.40357330441474915,
0.3796054422855377,
0.23178620636463165,
-0.11867272853851318,
-0.535586416721344,
-0.7970659732818604,
-0.5177072882652283,
-0.03932780772447586,
-0.9330783486366272,
0.17196235060691833,
-0.11253810673952103,
-0.3995577394962311,
0.1914067417383194,
-0.5827731490135193,
-0.37431544065475464,
0.4422908425331116,
0.0717497393488884,
0.3234313428401947,
-0.42989176511764526,
0.019429873675107956,
-0.26381006836891174,
-0.24001239240169525,
0.14425355195999146,
-0.2638542056083679,
0.12091394513845444,
-0.46697932481765747,
-0.7646922469139099,
-0.12029912322759628,
0.22880300879478455,
0.7462921738624573,
-0.44002386927604675,
0.37801045179367065,
0.2515164911746979,
-0.8644781708717346,
-0.26609912514686584,
-0.5467575788497925,
-0.28173568844795227,
-0.4022254943847656,
-0.16434086859226227,
-0.5682304501533508,
-1.1636996269226074,
0.5935845971107483,
-0.10047439485788345,
0.009484506212174892,
0.3307918608188629,
0.5316447019577026,
0.35517075657844543,
1.023569107055664,
0.28048190474510193,
0.43520981073379517,
0.4836353361606598,
-0.17211824655532837,
0.39079195261001587,
-0.3987610936164856,
-0.07835365831851959,
-0.719817578792572,
0.02390475943684578,
-0.3417704701423645,
-0.7046436667442322,
0.1301078200340271,
0.45580440759658813,
-0.300685852766037,
0.15011313557624817,
-0.4221596419811249,
0.46813124418258667,
0.47820839285850525,
-0.2083768993616104,
0.15318141877651215,
-0.05804675817489624,
-0.5641806125640869,
-0.27537769079208374,
-0.7032000422477722,
-0.4270486831665039,
0.8874977827072144,
0.2929839491844177,
0.6967524290084839,
0.1871587038040161,
0.4000924229621887,
0.1970226913690567,
0.4338270425796509,
-0.6280292272567749,
0.4522600769996643,
-0.03716997802257538,
-0.6306061148643494,
-0.07839827239513397,
-0.6810262799263,
-0.6373897790908813,
0.3219640851020813,
-0.09674882888793945,
-1.2005993127822876,
0.2985818386077881,
0.133714497089386,
-0.34287959337234497,
0.11355011910200119,
-0.7687658667564392,
1.2897274494171143,
-0.17930831015110016,
-0.553039014339447,
-0.08172158896923065,
-0.30309316515922546,
0.6642849445343018,
0.19188107550144196,
0.09332859516143799,
-0.3942599892616272,
0.19230598211288452,
0.22738318145275116,
-0.9164649248123169,
0.4792117476463318,
-0.21366575360298157,
0.20209652185440063,
0.4105866849422455,
0.3128792941570282,
0.1350816786289215,
0.2605447769165039,
-0.38858258724212646,
0.23573963344097137,
0.21381941437721252,
-0.49814555048942566,
-0.8477191925048828,
0.4472056031227112,
-0.21579985320568085,
-0.3902810215950012,
-0.5789899230003357,
-0.4465334713459015,
-0.5643507838249207,
0.29102954268455505,
-0.0681927353143692,
0.765956699848175,
-0.28914177417755127,
0.3451627194881439,
0.6551774740219116,
0.03130350261926651,
0.2335187792778015,
0.39395514130592346,
-0.11510591953992844,
-0.4971320629119873,
0.7385995984077454,
-0.0029481900855898857,
0.3142204284667969,
0.2279641032218933,
0.1863473355770111,
-0.6584116220474243,
-0.3096681833267212,
-0.39392295479774475,
0.1219363659620285,
-0.8237758874893188,
-0.4028502404689789,
-0.18419897556304932,
-0.12504388391971588,
-0.18507197499275208,
-0.33375096321105957,
-0.42321914434432983,
-0.8362874984741211,
0.09575490653514862,
0.16076523065567017,
0.1263437718153,
0.37807175517082214,
-0.06500428169965744,
-0.21553468704223633,
-0.5495920181274414,
0.1706768274307251,
0.1294056475162506,
0.7659944295883179,
0.02074914239346981,
-0.13300122320652008,
-0.15603673458099365,
0.0005221627652645111,
-0.3548159599304199,
-0.6857061386108398,
-0.1843770444393158,
-0.12508894503116608,
0.8950881958007812,
0.2772713601589203,
0.0764499306678772,
0.4973590672016144,
-0.10694567859172821,
0.8780224323272705,
0.31942957639694214,
-1.2771323919296265,
0.3927111327648163,
-0.3680330812931061,
0.47541263699531555,
0.7606484889984131,
0.04871918261051178,
-0.06861942261457443,
-0.2929536700248718,
-0.7568920254707336,
-0.4733719527721405,
0.5508081316947937,
0.49380725622177124,
-0.3189128041267395,
0.004374208394438028,
0.0836915448307991,
0.01303044706583023,
0.2561400234699249,
-0.5726889371871948,
0.05655816197395325,
-0.3314346373081207,
-0.09249278157949448,
0.25884801149368286,
-0.03321420028805733,
-0.2814634144306183,
-0.4250923991203308,
0.32673388719558716,
-0.24364885687828064,
0.28825271129608154,
0.10323642939329147,
-0.138406440615654,
0.0841541662812233,
0.37388551235198975,
0.8477645516395569,
1.097597599029541,
-0.2250385880470276,
0.0029806550592184067,
0.2382757067680359,
-0.1694498360157013,
0.09269759804010391,
0.5483164191246033,
-0.266552209854126,
0.022133927792310715,
0.3446316123008728,
0.7710515856742859,
0.6615016460418701,
-0.8524653911590576,
0.5996026396751404,
-0.24551530182361603,
-0.3302670121192932,
-0.0031775315292179585,
0.2706229090690613,
0.003974705934524536,
0.1509038656949997,
-0.0268133245408535,
0.2752450108528137,
0.13680499792099,
-0.41321417689323425,
0.41622257232666016,
0.2755190134048462,
-0.3202034533023834,
-0.28502511978149414,
0.7489444613456726,
0.010659252293407917,
-0.339207261800766,
0.5268512964248657,
-0.21059179306030273,
-0.41022512316703796,
0.6096752285957336,
0.4787762463092804,
0.8452866077423096,
-0.12826743721961975,
0.26068562269210815,
0.4777907133102417,
0.22729605436325073,
-0.1761111170053482,
0.7130491137504578,
-0.34462970495224,
-0.46711117029190063,
-0.37783676385879517,
-0.6151122450828552,
-0.6767858862876892,
-0.023501457646489143,
-0.7269185781478882,
0.2995574176311493,
-0.3342345356941223,
-0.1471269726753235,
0.08321438729763031,
-0.03629964590072632,
-0.51375412940979,
0.37881332635879517,
-0.04668344929814339,
1.3585981130599976,
-0.5651867985725403,
0.5446009039878845,
0.7722181677818298,
-0.5184050798416138,
-0.7657021880149841,
-0.030780576169490814,
-0.03232439607381821,
-0.311872661113739,
0.03095880150794983,
0.33533260226249695,
-0.1373811513185501,
-0.48694494366645813,
-0.28375035524368286,
-0.8239039778709412,
0.7898851633071899,
0.739387035369873,
-0.3393038511276245,
0.40714600682258606,
0.16017334163188934,
0.6409352421760559,
-0.584180474281311,
0.38703206181526184,
0.46981081366539,
0.551363468170166,
0.2210148125886917,
-0.7014731764793396,
0.22953863441944122,
-0.5239533185958862,
0.1207454726099968,
0.3540566861629486,
-0.5153511762619019,
1.030779480934143,
-0.13693051040172577,
-0.22333401441574097,
0.2721532881259918,
0.37613925337791443,
0.525200366973877,
0.6217019557952881,
0.6261323690414429,
0.818413257598877,
0.9126412868499756,
-0.5717732310295105,
1.0744661092758179,
-0.29795223474502563,
0.3662593364715576,
1.0032650232315063,
-0.403899610042572,
0.7681783437728882,
0.07205675542354584,
-0.06750103831291199,
0.6566238403320312,
0.5163228511810303,
-0.12582866847515106,
0.29880091547966003,
0.5294853448867798,
-0.22963516414165497,
-0.45300841331481934,
0.036069244146347046,
-0.5292111039161682,
0.3290829360485077,
0.38554704189300537,
-0.0029823658987879753,
-0.42027902603149414,
-0.5289686918258667,
0.04358847811818123,
0.33990222215652466,
-0.0657784640789032,
0.16193188726902008,
0.10708314925432205,
-1.0922352075576782,
0.8885626196861267,
-0.08552655577659607,
0.03212760388851166,
-0.5699033737182617,
-0.11197996139526367,
-0.16164612770080566,
0.36441275477409363,
-0.16599084436893463,
-0.554587185382843,
0.5496731996536255,
0.009241176769137383,
-0.05878753215074539,
-0.15169650316238403,
0.9169713258743286,
-0.04344598203897476,
-0.5175538659095764,
0.15843650698661804,
0.5889638662338257,
-0.07016254961490631,
0.1600504070520401,
-0.8560064435005188,
0.24514798820018768,
-0.22372832894325256,
0.043695103377103806,
0.086125448346138,
0.35571447014808655,
-0.3567561209201813,
0.5778732299804688,
0.6604288816452026,
-0.3001597821712494,
0.06232178956270218,
0.43212929368019104,
0.9498981833457947,
-0.6153895854949951,
-0.5113133788108826,
-0.6336236596107483,
0.7802876830101013,
-0.3269897997379303,
-0.5831400752067566,
0.6083849668502808,
0.5567240118980408,
0.7961600422859192,
-0.04782300069928169,
0.4973506033420563,
-0.09090032428503036,
0.4853818118572235,
-0.5178143978118896,
0.42448288202285767,
-0.7789316773414612,
0.13222278654575348,
-0.4042937755584717,
-0.7480384111404419,
-0.4800877273082733,
0.7365618348121643,
-0.3264462947845459,
0.16126275062561035,
0.8261588215827942,
0.7479170560836792,
-0.42142653465270996,
0.39937540888786316,
0.348176509141922,
-0.06454648077487946,
0.164421945810318,
0.5572686195373535,
1.0462141036987305,
-0.3604387938976288,
0.22309476137161255,
-0.17112943530082703,
-0.4435828924179077,
-0.25348201394081116,
-1.0856294631958008,
-0.8548851609230042,
-0.39233943819999695,
-0.4996877610683441,
-0.4247703552246094,
0.0408661887049675,
0.30189183354377747,
0.8450329899787903,
-0.8536365032196045,
-0.17880350351333618,
-0.4051121175289154,
0.46050190925598145,
-0.5940026640892029,
-0.25759100914001465,
-0.11957024037837982,
-0.47695392370224,
-0.38795238733291626,
0.4097377061843872,
0.33992740511894226,
-0.18724553287029266,
-0.29652971029281616,
-0.035742294043302536,
-0.17208988964557648,
0.5075913667678833,
0.28746792674064636,
0.558700680732727,
-0.7378991842269897,
-0.33584117889404297,
0.2612696886062622,
0.15610632300376892,
0.03304661065340042,
1.0897802114486694,
-0.547855019569397,
0.5250731706619263,
0.7402779459953308,
0.8053074479103088,
0.6495979428291321,
0.14970862865447998,
0.6048291325569153,
-0.5537088513374329,
0.15737637877464294,
0.45288753509521484,
0.49133238196372986,
0.40227025747299194,
0.09684816747903824,
0.8838214874267578,
0.3782130181789398,
-0.5577490925788879,
-1.3173216581344604,
0.3979913294315338,
-0.9502336382865906,
-0.11201063543558121,
0.8100167512893677,
-0.4020158648490906,
-0.17838869988918304,
0.16180793941020966,
0.3826947808265686,
-0.16593515872955322,
-0.166017085313797,
0.6518838405609131,
1.0393978357315063,
-0.24944937229156494,
0.08113411068916321,
-0.565929651260376,
0.35427236557006836,
0.7403663396835327,
-0.8329175114631653,
0.025689072906970978,
0.7778642773628235,
0.2855314016342163,
0.21820136904716492,
0.6653735041618347,
-0.35179245471954346,
0.7267137765884399,
0.4518267512321472,
-0.3246474266052246,
-0.007092507090419531,
-0.3458702266216278,
-0.2460092455148697,
0.27402856945991516,
0.050024792551994324,
-0.12115826457738876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19449v1
|
Heavy-Tailed Class Imbalance and Why Adam Outperforms Gradient Descent on Language Models
| 2024-02-29T18:47:52 | 2024-02-29T18:47:52 |
Frederik Kunstner, Robin Yadav, Alan Milligan, Mark Schmidt, Alberto Bietti
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, math.OC, stat.ML
|
Adam has been shown to outperform gradient descent in optimizing large
language transformers empirically, and by a larger margin than on other tasks,
but it is unclear why this happens. We show that the heavy-tailed class
imbalance found in language modeling tasks leads to difficulties in the
optimization dynamics. When training with gradient descent, the loss associated
with infrequent words decreases slower than the loss associated with frequent
ones. As most samples come from relatively infrequent words, the average loss
decreases slowly with gradient descent. On the other hand, Adam and sign-based
methods do not suffer from this problem and improve predictions on all classes.
To establish that this behavior is indeed caused by class imbalance, we show
empirically that it persist through different architectures and data types, on
language transformers, vision CNNs, and linear models. We further study this
phenomenon on a linear classification with cross-entropy loss, showing that
heavy-tailed class imbalance leads to ill-conditioning, and that the
normalization used by Adam can counteract it.
|
[
-0.28248846530914307,
-0.695930004119873,
0.38213515281677246,
0.041611749678850174,
-0.09542346745729446,
0.4706278145313263,
-0.4319950044155121,
-0.5615307688713074,
0.19291800260543823,
0.14895857870578766,
-0.28848955035209656,
-0.17906764149665833,
-0.8105196952819824,
-0.0705910250544548,
-0.7203735113143921,
1.1421908140182495,
0.10318206995725632,
0.4684835374355316,
-0.40080520510673523,
-0.46912848949432373,
-0.21660447120666504,
-0.6037124395370483,
-0.9622812271118164,
-0.8096871376037598,
0.4658588767051697,
0.19736327230930328,
1.0751979351043701,
0.6403814554214478,
0.423168808221817,
0.2666643559932709,
-0.12898507714271545,
-0.3304981291294098,
-0.40651366114616394,
0.04875347390770912,
0.03406323865056038,
-0.9258856177330017,
0.06180419772863388,
-0.1540025770664215,
0.8661259412765503,
1.0803875923156738,
-0.3282290995121002,
0.17248402535915375,
0.33406683802604675,
0.9875355958938599,
-0.8231943845748901,
-0.1338554471731186,
-0.6528379917144775,
0.12512826919555664,
-0.5793448090553284,
-0.1973901242017746,
-0.2530246376991272,
0.19851896166801453,
0.12687119841575623,
-0.4646014869213104,
0.2522311210632324,
0.38785865902900696,
0.8112877607345581,
0.31542539596557617,
-0.21556180715560913,
-0.07556011527776718,
-1.0252487659454346,
1.2956161499023438,
-0.7309449911117554,
0.5239806175231934,
0.11569623649120331,
-0.053432367742061615,
-0.03499256819486618,
-0.19942882657051086,
-0.6348127722740173,
-0.31406715512275696,
0.28147587180137634,
0.003572512185201049,
-0.49385127425193787,
0.1440356969833374,
0.36473143100738525,
0.42364174127578735,
-0.5122257471084595,
0.5184075832366943,
-0.32819026708602905,
-0.1165895089507103,
0.4941912889480591,
0.30884483456611633,
0.4418798089027405,
0.3173448145389557,
-0.36437711119651794,
-0.4401729106903076,
-0.7838472127914429,
0.35007208585739136,
0.9386621117591858,
0.268062949180603,
0.13575658202171326,
0.6718757152557373,
0.12703736126422882,
0.7797581553459167,
-0.04309451952576637,
0.04916505888104439,
0.27199938893318176,
0.0031765939202159643,
-0.08229294419288635,
0.34805336594581604,
0.4989526867866516,
0.5772066712379456,
0.4847758412361145,
-0.1755782514810562,
-0.12704843282699585,
0.07543225586414337,
-0.010619055479764938,
-0.8369277119636536,
-0.16518661379814148,
0.07752835005521774,
-0.7193378806114197,
-0.046492625027894974,
-0.23077555000782013,
-0.529971718788147,
-0.4767407178878784,
-0.4138217866420746,
0.4225129783153534,
-0.2684347331523895,
-0.35089966654777527,
0.16499269008636475,
-0.3826948404312134,
0.24170911312103271,
0.24472080171108246,
-0.9329783916473389,
0.47814249992370605,
0.63205885887146,
0.74895840883255,
-0.47388455271720886,
-0.4040982723236084,
-0.467154860496521,
-0.3128518760204315,
-0.5553739666938782,
0.5539101362228394,
-0.6727534532546997,
0.20750370621681213,
0.05029691755771637,
-0.23086118698120117,
-0.18736949563026428,
-0.6996979713439941,
0.19388268887996674,
-0.2781842052936554,
0.11058306694030762,
-0.10219720751047134,
-0.5047469735145569,
-0.31874921917915344,
0.014217399060726166,
-0.2724231481552124,
0.9832817912101746,
0.11060652136802673,
-0.8781731724739075,
0.7253466844558716,
-0.2633172273635864,
-0.6160685420036316,
0.04114483296871185,
-0.12162996828556061,
-0.655967652797699,
0.2846282124519348,
-0.22076253592967987,
0.6185358762741089,
-0.5840571522712708,
-0.19603610038757324,
-0.4229850471019745,
-0.7328550219535828,
0.11002523452043533,
-0.1449391096830368,
0.9366713166236877,
0.14423774182796478,
-0.4765794575214386,
0.07639327645301819,
-0.8498578667640686,
-0.11066486686468124,
0.4556807279586792,
-0.33746761083602905,
-1.0787854194641113,
0.5928710103034973,
-0.05837514251470566,
0.031850844621658325,
-0.22400960326194763,
-0.6923483610153198,
0.11848212778568268,
-0.606330156326294,
0.33043769001960754,
0.495168000459671,
-0.19354651868343353,
0.6214141249656677,
-0.35281503200531006,
0.5266144871711731,
0.21265628933906555,
-0.005375334993004799,
0.26112470030784607,
-0.6735349297523499,
-0.9275003671646118,
0.045650433748960495,
0.2859079837799072,
0.8457234501838684,
-0.4831528663635254,
0.1734001785516739,
-0.045350417494773865,
-0.4757751226425171,
-0.6058031916618347,
0.42042621970176697,
0.31702524423599243,
0.5259975790977478,
0.4672830402851105,
-0.4210232198238373,
-0.24718110263347626,
-0.9623706340789795,
-0.4639298617839813,
-0.13347654044628143,
0.15521405637264252,
0.02096881903707981,
0.31562870740890503,
-0.24173499643802643,
0.3738841414451599,
-0.061624787747859955,
-0.08866145461797714,
-0.5646939873695374,
0.17957060039043427,
0.15337254106998444,
0.692278265953064,
0.7965041399002075,
-0.36670345067977905,
-0.13281884789466858,
-0.13531391322612762,
-0.43924304842948914,
0.11951937526464462,
-0.42627787590026855,
0.0820070132613182,
0.49184471368789673,
0.5141831040382385,
-0.2642536759376526,
0.5466874241828918,
0.5462541580200195,
-0.22086837887763977,
0.23132368922233582,
0.15275505185127258,
-0.25548070669174194,
-0.8492808938026428,
-0.3295685946941376,
0.24918417632579803,
0.02358579821884632,
-0.3951837718486786,
-0.07578600943088531,
-0.22998709976673126,
0.06368175894021988,
-0.426302433013916,
0.27044159173965454,
-0.20690636336803436,
-0.19650493562221527,
-0.16756628453731537,
-0.1949266642332077,
-0.22394806146621704,
0.5549477338790894,
-0.1605789065361023,
0.6154788136482239,
0.9610946774482727,
-0.7688590884208679,
0.2193177342414856,
0.05240369215607643,
-0.36401310563087463,
0.6671907901763916,
-0.6799653172492981,
-0.19684317708015442,
-0.48737311363220215,
0.016630269587039948,
-0.8874306082725525,
0.353851854801178,
0.1397353708744049,
-0.20783989131450653,
0.6087166666984558,
-0.2350539118051529,
-0.5082190632820129,
-0.32239270210266113,
-0.5147895216941833,
0.3862130343914032,
0.6040589809417725,
-0.5744538307189941,
0.5815038084983826,
0.04993583261966705,
0.07750751823186874,
-0.9947755932807922,
-0.9615294933319092,
0.14637547731399536,
-0.2674999237060547,
-0.43938711285591125,
0.16108901798725128,
-0.08639264106750488,
-0.5272447466850281,
0.18225140869617462,
-0.1426907479763031,
0.17973846197128296,
0.39051011204719543,
0.08339916169643402,
-0.08901180326938629,
-0.23514041304588318,
0.24460697174072266,
0.11817620694637299,
0.035788167268037796,
0.3805941045284271,
-0.342792272567749,
0.9036659598350525,
-0.2237679809331894,
-0.4337025582790375,
-0.509614884853363,
0.4435596168041229,
0.5431857109069824,
-0.10310176014900208,
1.0074011087417603,
0.6822904944419861,
-0.18504497408866882,
-0.4214429259300232,
-0.2629430592060089,
-0.2310747504234314,
-0.40540361404418945,
0.6114101409912109,
0.007158464752137661,
-0.5372976064682007,
0.8106932044029236,
0.19937682151794434,
0.2112453430891037,
0.8481305837631226,
0.5671510100364685,
-0.18797141313552856,
1.474438190460205,
0.5374583005905151,
-0.009853806346654892,
0.7333401441574097,
-0.5830755829811096,
0.11518674343824387,
-0.8071590065956116,
-0.13871915638446808,
-0.5671265125274658,
-0.6727819442749023,
-0.7572534680366516,
0.38762375712394714,
0.03215859457850456,
0.02225852943956852,
-0.43375256657600403,
0.2941019833087921,
-0.5932302474975586,
0.41071540117263794,
1.036311149597168,
-0.0689990371465683,
0.11073857545852661,
0.04802952706813812,
0.10223972052335739,
-0.09107338637113571,
-0.9560944437980652,
-0.20703516900539398,
1.2254438400268555,
0.4021724760532379,
1.192336916923523,
-0.09946568310260773,
0.7711930871009827,
0.08828838169574738,
0.2605727016925812,
-0.9626579880714417,
0.4313485324382782,
-0.20670941472053528,
-0.6490024924278259,
-0.22355997562408447,
-0.4485524594783783,
-0.9710618257522583,
-0.011583134531974792,
-0.49967485666275024,
-0.4509016275405884,
0.4410548210144043,
0.38418930768966675,
-0.18952810764312744,
0.5936105847358704,
-0.6638935208320618,
0.7473766803741455,
-0.39654675126075745,
-0.4176805019378662,
-0.40702101588249207,
-0.8368907570838928,
0.29987001419067383,
-0.08351388573646545,
0.04353157430887222,
-0.18331941962242126,
0.17337219417095184,
1.1165046691894531,
-0.5958952307701111,
0.580887496471405,
-0.37790316343307495,
-0.1288643330335617,
0.19975997507572174,
0.09488796442747116,
0.3706595003604889,
-0.12177179008722305,
0.06266237795352936,
0.25825732946395874,
0.015791846439242363,
-0.4926169216632843,
-0.6541656851768494,
0.5392055511474609,
-0.8127397894859314,
-0.203670471906662,
-0.6548145413398743,
-0.3752651512622833,
-0.2564535140991211,
0.054782770574092865,
0.47010737657546997,
0.5029047131538391,
0.29088059067726135,
0.4615092873573303,
0.5915409326553345,
-0.2958725690841675,
0.8460162878036499,
0.15093369781970978,
-0.053433045744895935,
-0.08067687600851059,
0.9737614393234253,
0.35894373059272766,
0.5831848382949829,
0.1093011349439621,
0.379352331161499,
-0.029418662190437317,
-0.8708815574645996,
-0.6115615963935852,
-0.1773681491613388,
-0.6545723080635071,
-0.2808934152126312,
-0.4697626233100891,
-0.011854814365506172,
0.06699614971876144,
-0.26144781708717346,
-0.4363637864589691,
-0.5657440423965454,
-0.07929559051990509,
0.21085774898529053,
0.22819267213344574,
0.5289078950881958,
0.06966574490070343,
0.5920213460922241,
-0.3522801995277405,
-0.08548083901405334,
0.31184765696525574,
0.34119853377342224,
0.3728408217430115,
-0.38784059882164,
-0.39136800169944763,
-0.008445369079709053,
-0.23389865458011627,
-0.38093647360801697,
0.04894912987947464,
0.5196362733840942,
0.5223828554153442,
0.5257249474525452,
-0.06624878197908401,
0.4932101368904114,
-0.3853325843811035,
0.6833380460739136,
0.38358214497566223,
-0.7423442006111145,
0.08720836043357849,
-0.151640847325325,
0.0960046723484993,
0.6507559418678284,
0.17526699602603912,
-0.2736246883869171,
-0.7538716197013855,
-0.6170402765274048,
-1.1598682403564453,
0.6412366032600403,
0.10347606241703033,
0.5055429339408875,
0.14443250000476837,
0.27810370922088623,
0.0921802669763565,
0.28076526522636414,
-0.838487446308136,
-0.6596567034721375,
-0.3601630926132202,
-0.22150787711143494,
-0.07573404908180237,
-0.08669759333133698,
-0.086018405854702,
-0.5191465616226196,
0.7996461987495422,
0.03835611045360565,
0.32589900493621826,
-0.030380504205822945,
-0.2530440092086792,
-0.48891618847846985,
0.19388413429260254,
0.6438171863555908,
0.5431792140007019,
-0.22609500586986542,
0.1277138739824295,
0.2470412254333496,
-0.5487744212150574,
0.03478800132870674,
0.20113369822502136,
-0.29940274357795715,
-0.11519114673137665,
0.5792088508605957,
0.9344910979270935,
0.02079714462161064,
-0.5119901299476624,
0.734137237071991,
-0.02895265258848667,
-0.15373264253139496,
-0.2798089385032654,
0.2776595652103424,
-0.27839139103889465,
0.18718232214450836,
0.7507933378219604,
0.5426289439201355,
0.15729843080043793,
-0.6454834342002869,
-0.06381090730428696,
0.7518410086631775,
-0.10877594351768494,
-0.11768777668476105,
0.8492105007171631,
-0.08469868451356888,
-0.10760872811079025,
0.6739316582679749,
-0.19160407781600952,
-0.47373974323272705,
0.5034394264221191,
0.814297616481781,
0.9064439535140991,
-0.043738409876823425,
-0.20087295770645142,
0.12952053546905518,
0.5134272575378418,
-0.1868664175271988,
0.4394257962703705,
-0.16457994282245636,
-0.7445975542068481,
-0.7532575726509094,
-0.6959222555160522,
-0.5708469748497009,
0.026948055252432823,
-0.6722400784492493,
0.0235445536673069,
-0.7985124588012695,
-0.10113547742366791,
0.1623038649559021,
-0.05393371358513832,
-0.6960670351982117,
0.2193160355091095,
0.18702557682991028,
0.486522912979126,
-0.9471756219863892,
0.3836807906627655,
0.7620577812194824,
-0.38672420382499695,
-0.7361919283866882,
0.1058264747262001,
-0.23477382957935333,
-1.0508880615234375,
0.8100318312644958,
0.24232217669487,
-0.29647862911224365,
0.166598379611969,
-0.6828813552856445,
-0.8050781488418579,
0.5000432729721069,
0.5306715369224548,
-0.6963917016983032,
0.06639504432678223,
0.06758402287960052,
0.5137239098548889,
-0.1564909815788269,
-0.03753547742962837,
0.13557493686676025,
0.3651406168937683,
-0.011019134894013405,
-0.6456875205039978,
-0.20466342568397522,
-0.06921196728944778,
-0.07472061365842819,
0.49083784222602844,
-0.5082936882972717,
0.9133334159851074,
-0.1532411277294159,
-0.03040928952395916,
-0.2563127279281616,
0.5854736566543579,
-0.20012998580932617,
0.42329537868499756,
0.7094581723213196,
0.9779232144355774,
0.3546193838119507,
-0.15745870769023895,
1.0722713470458984,
-0.4929942190647125,
0.21989235281944275,
0.529752790927887,
-0.09287384152412415,
0.7455853223800659,
0.4051172137260437,
-0.2561246156692505,
0.7876117825508118,
0.4968471825122833,
-0.10660048574209213,
0.37835589051246643,
0.49290168285369873,
-0.09879942983388901,
-0.4159756302833557,
-0.04701727628707886,
-0.3650330603122711,
0.6650291085243225,
0.17728838324546814,
-0.23941637575626373,
-0.16407828032970428,
0.25400683283805847,
0.13544031977653503,
-0.03686656057834625,
-0.7267706394195557,
0.6496303677558899,
-0.026236865669488907,
-0.44306889176368713,
0.7051528692245483,
-0.1605561375617981,
0.8819626569747925,
-0.37285172939300537,
0.09152237325906754,
-0.08495081961154938,
0.42846500873565674,
-0.2866591513156891,
-0.6767185926437378,
0.4668048322200775,
-0.5664121508598328,
-0.08678395301103592,
-0.22048647701740265,
0.6010131239891052,
-0.4055543839931488,
-0.5450970530509949,
0.3141847848892212,
0.41143155097961426,
0.022123856469988823,
-0.06097372993826866,
-0.7574449777603149,
-0.0317852646112442,
-0.48689520359039307,
-0.2504246234893799,
0.28522101044654846,
0.13500428199768066,
-0.1843044012784958,
0.6937353610992432,
0.6384285688400269,
0.25164052844047546,
0.12404646724462509,
0.05877523869276047,
0.5848950743675232,
-0.4148797392845154,
-0.2471488118171692,
-1.0727057456970215,
0.2772972285747528,
0.03690962865948677,
-0.4125874638557434,
0.7303361296653748,
0.8049870729446411,
1.0770004987716675,
0.11877622455358505,
0.5249907374382019,
0.013331227004528046,
0.5402354001998901,
-0.5666077136993408,
0.774413526058197,
-0.9445735812187195,
-0.047434236854314804,
-0.4086650013923645,
-1.3120886087417603,
-0.5771281719207764,
0.5229602456092834,
-0.03862215578556061,
0.1133025735616684,
0.6809273958206177,
0.37963083386421204,
0.033402301371097565,
-0.5139201283454895,
-0.0135604627430439,
-0.06970969587564468,
0.12459840625524521,
0.3559592366218567,
0.9253332614898682,
-0.36884796619415283,
0.41408053040504456,
-0.2861497104167938,
-0.03519682586193085,
-0.1927899867296219,
-0.7312122583389282,
-1.148764729499817,
-0.6475194096565247,
-0.41660216450691223,
-0.5952579975128174,
0.06021498143672943,
1.0979511737823486,
0.7308470010757446,
-0.9887328743934631,
-0.13894610106945038,
-0.270135760307312,
0.22579675912857056,
-0.5124912261962891,
-0.21794448792934418,
0.2886667847633362,
-0.41373610496520996,
-0.7854855060577393,
0.21309693157672882,
0.19759318232536316,
0.32403475046157837,
-0.357258141040802,
-0.0002656560973264277,
-0.04300340265035629,
-0.021121351048350334,
0.3603041172027588,
0.5168605446815491,
-0.5266975164413452,
-0.07079792767763138,
-0.11774440854787827,
0.03265119716525078,
0.19177018105983734,
0.7093100547790527,
-0.6992909908294678,
0.1402769684791565,
0.4374343752861023,
0.9595099091529846,
0.2745000422000885,
-0.1419176310300827,
0.4575112760066986,
-0.7702047228813171,
0.28999271988868713,
0.3819541335105896,
0.45902901887893677,
0.40227383375167847,
-0.23747289180755615,
0.19740232825279236,
0.4483932554721832,
-0.5047669410705566,
-0.959399938583374,
0.09120996296405792,
-0.9459235668182373,
-0.13584955036640167,
1.0576248168945312,
0.4989052712917328,
-0.21531075239181519,
-0.0630277469754219,
-0.022337427362799644,
0.11294258385896683,
-0.3835676908493042,
0.6728596687316895,
0.6186703443527222,
-0.3379672169685364,
-0.1288415789604187,
-0.594382643699646,
0.7076414823532104,
0.8575441837310791,
-0.39322441816329956,
0.11159930378198624,
0.1752370297908783,
0.23357152938842773,
0.2718590199947357,
-0.032872673124074936,
0.315712571144104,
0.14671315252780914,
-0.41041144728660583,
0.14038914442062378,
-0.05359154939651489,
-0.23958125710487366,
-0.39857906103134155,
-0.10182017832994461,
0.25207459926605225,
-0.30377283692359924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19446v1
|
ArCHer: Training Language Model Agents via Hierarchical Multi-Turn RL
| 2024-02-29T18:45:56 | 2024-02-29T18:45:56 |
Yifei Zhou, Andrea Zanette, Jiayi Pan, Sergey Levine, Aviral Kumar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
A broad use case of large language models (LLMs) is in goal-directed
decision-making tasks (or "agent" tasks), where an LLM needs to not just
generate completions for a given prompt, but rather make intelligent decisions
over a multi-turn interaction to accomplish a task (e.g., when interacting with
the web, using tools, or providing customer support). Reinforcement learning
(RL) provides a general paradigm to address such agent tasks, but current RL
methods for LLMs largely focus on optimizing single-turn rewards. By
construction, most single-turn RL methods cannot endow LLMs with the ability to
intelligently seek information over multiple turns, perform credit assignment,
or reason about their past actions -- all of which are critical in agent tasks.
This raises the question: how can we design effective and efficient multi-turn
RL algorithms for LLMs? In this paper, we develop a framework for building
multi-turn RL algorithms for fine-tuning LLMs, that preserves the flexibility
of existing single-turn RL methods for LLMs (e.g., proximal policy
optimization), while accommodating multiple turns, long horizons, and delayed
rewards effectively. To do this, our framework adopts a hierarchical RL
approach and runs two RL algorithms in parallel: a high-level off-policy
value-based RL algorithm to aggregate reward over utterances, and a low-level
RL algorithm that utilizes this high-level value function to train a token
policy within each utterance or turn. Our hierarchical framework, Actor-Critic
Framework with a Hierarchical Structure (ArCHer), can also give rise to other
RL methods. Empirically, we find that ArCHer significantly improves efficiency
and performance on agent tasks, attaining a sample efficiency of about 100x
over existing methods, while also improving with larger model capacity (upto
the 7 billion scale that we tested on).
|
[
-0.28494325280189514,
-0.6911016702651978,
0.4103509187698364,
0.20762601494789124,
0.08851537853479385,
0.5314794182777405,
-0.12072233110666275,
-0.2852414548397064,
0.07581673562526703,
0.3672967255115509,
-0.8283098936080933,
-0.384111225605011,
-0.4374442994594574,
-0.10766405612230301,
0.10379861295223236,
1.215285301208496,
0.11513915657997131,
0.10995780676603317,
0.06679172068834305,
-0.27584308385849,
-0.3358933925628662,
-0.2717758119106293,
-1.1871542930603027,
-0.728670597076416,
0.8937744498252869,
0.6292358636856079,
0.7550641894340515,
0.6038578152656555,
0.3635621964931488,
0.36502504348754883,
-0.02819008193910122,
0.5717806220054626,
-0.5157707929611206,
0.2526822090148926,
-0.30983760952949524,
-0.3252342641353607,
-0.5923542380332947,
-0.034450795501470566,
0.5730578899383545,
0.3157728910446167,
-0.39136001467704773,
0.17284731566905975,
-0.1285255402326584,
0.8025420308113098,
-0.5680640339851379,
0.5426705479621887,
-0.5440337061882019,
0.2750280797481537,
0.04595205560326576,
-0.5980658531188965,
-0.7985255122184753,
-0.29276323318481445,
-0.06610191613435745,
-0.5650346875190735,
-0.14527514576911926,
0.5426676273345947,
0.6705061197280884,
0.1677922010421753,
-0.32469090819358826,
-0.24542775750160217,
-0.773807942867279,
1.0618292093276978,
-0.593021810054779,
0.3003079295158386,
0.2319333553314209,
0.3989063799381256,
-0.22458426654338837,
-0.55942702293396,
-0.3407936096191406,
-0.45855167508125305,
-0.1513984203338623,
-0.052038103342056274,
-0.04273419827222824,
0.33294329047203064,
0.17481887340545654,
0.009532337076961994,
-0.4349232316017151,
0.26859062910079956,
0.023252543061971664,
0.0934818908572197,
0.6553995013237,
0.33503076434135437,
-0.050836723297834396,
0.25162461400032043,
-0.17234687507152557,
-0.341802716255188,
-0.7741973996162415,
0.38885989785194397,
0.36968135833740234,
0.675180971622467,
0.13211962580680847,
0.34197553992271423,
-0.1537570059299469,
0.48963668942451477,
0.2559249997138977,
-0.5815912485122681,
0.08230697363615036,
-0.0486675389111042,
-0.017612585797905922,
-0.15054510533809662,
0.5541110038757324,
0.005189327523112297,
0.40623119473457336,
-0.18694628775119781,
-0.42964279651641846,
-0.1494879126548767,
0.4409359097480774,
-0.7308191657066345,
0.1207108274102211,
0.37456241250038147,
-0.445746511220932,
-0.4387333393096924,
-0.2793676257133484,
-0.6678725481033325,
-0.38434088230133057,
-0.4784533977508545,
0.3650575876235962,
-0.26463502645492554,
-0.2933855354785919,
-0.073137566447258,
0.21242569386959076,
0.5120537877082825,
0.13903699815273285,
-0.9926199913024902,
0.4947579503059387,
0.8460760712623596,
0.6356445550918579,
-0.18314923346042633,
-0.7853614687919617,
-1.1241635084152222,
0.006661318242549896,
-0.5521199107170105,
0.8122878074645996,
-0.6142283082008362,
-0.05635826289653778,
0.2795020043849945,
-0.22437624633312225,
-0.20942942798137665,
-0.5833688974380493,
0.12362785637378693,
-0.6613757610321045,
-0.23400169610977173,
0.20670640468597412,
-0.19332903623580933,
-0.11454309523105621,
0.47081461548805237,
-0.4424838721752167,
0.7390092611312866,
-0.2066226452589035,
-0.46598803997039795,
0.3070988357067108,
-0.5992456078529358,
-0.7515403628349304,
-0.13707754015922546,
-0.2875872254371643,
-0.9064894914627075,
-0.024263864383101463,
0.39303964376449585,
0.469858318567276,
-0.32691237330436707,
0.23107470571994781,
-0.13513796031475067,
-0.3018482029438019,
0.1675119251012802,
-0.245464488863945,
0.38946273922920227,
0.1530468612909317,
-0.30098721385002136,
0.7232034802436829,
-0.4003790318965912,
0.18328967690467834,
0.12334516644477844,
-0.5357798337936401,
0.12405417859554291,
0.3110058605670929,
-0.010220721364021301,
0.07317493855953217,
-0.027772273868322372,
-0.22664378583431244,
0.4334275722503662,
-0.23310138285160065,
0.19616203010082245,
0.7650175094604492,
-0.04698881879448891,
0.2274959832429886,
-0.7442382574081421,
0.7061964273452759,
-0.0538337379693985,
0.2787747383117676,
-0.16020862758159637,
-0.13558068871498108,
-0.8918964862823486,
-0.3326205313205719,
-0.038235120475292206,
0.49493515491485596,
-0.8652489185333252,
0.17653939127922058,
0.048338375985622406,
-0.44266989827156067,
-0.6573372483253479,
-0.16394606232643127,
0.6335362195968628,
0.06116316467523575,
0.39468351006507874,
0.03270387649536133,
-0.293599396944046,
-0.661731481552124,
-0.4858122169971466,
-0.19498798251152039,
0.4683300256729126,
0.36927682161331177,
0.4675997793674469,
-0.1833048313856125,
0.8004803657531738,
-0.39800286293029785,
-0.41830602288246155,
-0.6178264021873474,
0.48265373706817627,
0.09050464630126953,
0.37045562267303467,
0.13658744096755981,
-0.7115586400032043,
-0.5099502801895142,
0.24164137244224548,
-0.5413870811462402,
0.21621178090572357,
-0.35997506976127625,
0.1675979346036911,
0.44026800990104675,
0.47651275992393494,
-0.6342779397964478,
0.28858715295791626,
0.32801124453544617,
-0.2928890287876129,
0.6837981343269348,
-0.39705049991607666,
0.11213076114654541,
-0.6619688272476196,
-0.17438089847564697,
-0.12068828195333481,
-0.44727030396461487,
-0.7455683946609497,
0.24858726561069489,
-0.10881521552801132,
-0.06668078899383545,
-0.5034128427505493,
0.4603194296360016,
-0.5395503640174866,
-0.32366153597831726,
-0.3456539809703827,
0.003034162102267146,
-0.31043192744255066,
1.1924479007720947,
0.16014575958251953,
0.7365803718566895,
0.6763219833374023,
-0.6136654615402222,
0.363491952419281,
-0.05136795714497566,
-0.0934549868106842,
0.693985104560852,
-0.49356722831726074,
0.2456202656030655,
-0.45299193263053894,
0.10110412538051605,
-0.6907486915588379,
0.07709475606679916,
0.15012173354625702,
-0.3763818144798279,
0.45238932967185974,
-0.10066325962543488,
-0.2276380956172943,
-0.03126915544271469,
-0.3312770426273346,
0.41433173418045044,
0.3730774223804474,
-0.5855386257171631,
1.0291889905929565,
0.37375783920288086,
-0.1449403315782547,
-0.7639097571372986,
-0.4483916759490967,
-0.11896779388189316,
-0.22642916440963745,
-0.253440260887146,
0.2568904757499695,
0.1698177307844162,
-0.12976595759391785,
0.054552361369132996,
0.0014813055749982595,
0.0715387836098671,
-0.07232079654932022,
0.07741238921880722,
-0.004210110753774643,
-0.01761109009385109,
0.18047700822353363,
-0.07319816946983337,
-0.34801167249679565,
-0.16987961530685425,
-0.5009176135063171,
0.6058747172355652,
-0.5125793218612671,
-0.5581183433532715,
-0.43092113733291626,
0.3760084807872772,
0.7660849094390869,
-0.49886423349380493,
0.7571642994880676,
0.36604276299476624,
-0.040450919419527054,
-0.5601390600204468,
-0.409349650144577,
-0.21313592791557312,
-0.4007699489593506,
0.6744027137756348,
-0.5674163699150085,
-0.8170844316482544,
0.3423313498497009,
-0.2414475530385971,
0.5238425135612488,
0.13842949271202087,
0.6289559006690979,
0.2180904895067215,
1.3062782287597656,
0.5704910755157471,
-0.29872366786003113,
0.5585780143737793,
-0.45453569293022156,
0.32874631881713867,
-0.6379073858261108,
-0.351906955242157,
-0.6015899777412415,
-0.21049770712852478,
-0.5595095157623291,
-0.3556734621524811,
0.33911412954330444,
-0.22880470752716064,
-0.49089744687080383,
0.05602036416530609,
-0.16644231975078583,
0.48203712701797485,
0.5081924796104431,
-0.0884493738412857,
0.42338886857032776,
-0.0749315470457077,
-0.05964275076985359,
0.2696201503276825,
-0.9077107310295105,
-0.3052855134010315,
0.743895947933197,
0.6268276572227478,
1.0866730213165283,
0.1518385112285614,
0.7749357223510742,
0.2950233817100525,
0.24114340543746948,
-1.0894489288330078,
0.4686395227909088,
0.05858200415968895,
-0.23200690746307373,
-0.7795443534851074,
-0.3602418005466461,
-0.9993454813957214,
0.601425290107727,
-0.19241440296173096,
-0.3739589750766754,
-0.030562574043869972,
0.33171069622039795,
-0.2549450993537903,
0.3038308620452881,
-0.37623628973960876,
0.8342490792274475,
-0.43821749091148376,
-0.4144914448261261,
-0.5992842316627502,
-0.4415483772754669,
0.012945863418281078,
0.23065587878227234,
0.34699925780296326,
-0.004790979437530041,
0.16977529227733612,
0.5388421416282654,
-0.3157857358455658,
0.7473872303962708,
-0.31606850028038025,
0.23636282980442047,
0.21808601915836334,
0.07759194076061249,
1.0210353136062622,
-0.03363412246108055,
0.1092723086476326,
-0.34741106629371643,
-0.08657806366682053,
-0.3711051642894745,
-0.6529580950737,
0.34299105405807495,
-0.9270673990249634,
-0.41432005167007446,
-0.6680417060852051,
-0.6656816601753235,
-0.4090302884578705,
0.13346348702907562,
-0.23920217156410217,
0.5841814279556274,
-0.0068517872132360935,
0.12632110714912415,
0.6118046045303345,
-0.07232054322957993,
0.2951745390892029,
0.6206554770469666,
-0.5318570137023926,
-0.2467980533838272,
1.0009052753448486,
-0.17235274612903595,
0.319208025932312,
0.5300225615501404,
0.28147420287132263,
-0.2884768545627594,
-0.6957035660743713,
-0.3005146384239197,
0.23392924666404724,
-0.542844831943512,
-0.26078468561172485,
-0.2754209339618683,
-0.3415197730064392,
-0.33313655853271484,
-0.045085277408361435,
-0.5486820936203003,
-0.040940698236227036,
-0.027045879513025284,
-0.0056847077794373035,
0.2699395418167114,
0.8020395636558533,
0.061136238276958466,
0.32289063930511475,
-0.3278631865978241,
0.35386714339256287,
0.37822282314300537,
0.3001667559146881,
0.37568214535713196,
-0.3672564923763275,
-0.39289793372154236,
-0.17003293335437775,
-0.3270687460899353,
-0.4384396970272064,
0.39514636993408203,
0.2757053077220917,
0.6528880596160889,
0.30862224102020264,
-0.04645621404051781,
0.6355915665626526,
-0.7189640402793884,
0.26589420437812805,
0.0013411755207926035,
-0.6559340953826904,
0.23695571720600128,
-0.19675374031066895,
0.33636710047721863,
0.4110569357872009,
0.30743494629859924,
-0.6801468133926392,
-0.5279227495193481,
-0.28426051139831543,
-0.7698236703872681,
0.959197998046875,
-0.12961512804031372,
-0.2115693986415863,
0.15143738687038422,
0.1686558574438095,
-0.12488124519586563,
0.32090696692466736,
-0.8650542497634888,
-0.350149929523468,
0.008743676356971264,
-0.1442439705133438,
-0.1433447152376175,
-0.1555316299200058,
0.01687401346862316,
-0.08645596355199814,
0.9460112452507019,
-0.4402112662792206,
0.13169342279434204,
-0.04027754068374634,
-0.03982429578900337,
-0.0739646926522255,
0.393295556306839,
0.5689238905906677,
0.6099675297737122,
-0.055618010461330414,
0.19254620373249054,
0.11496087163686752,
-0.07167903333902359,
0.2902679443359375,
-0.09324946999549866,
-0.07627372443675995,
-0.5152819752693176,
0.5952951908111572,
1.14448881149292,
0.1682918667793274,
-0.7034550309181213,
0.22283297777175903,
-0.024862142279744148,
-0.21017946302890778,
-0.3216632902622223,
-0.031165342777967453,
0.03865128010511398,
0.6236125826835632,
0.3084280490875244,
-0.05803503096103668,
-0.08265821635723114,
-0.8381862044334412,
0.2255871742963791,
0.6171830892562866,
-0.38742974400520325,
0.06088784337043762,
0.09372946619987488,
0.0932854562997818,
-0.7767431735992432,
0.5912150740623474,
-0.41785943508148193,
-0.5912104845046997,
0.43915194272994995,
0.5695584416389465,
1.1670141220092773,
-0.1342172771692276,
0.48469769954681396,
0.03445896506309509,
0.18809524178504944,
-0.11016077548265457,
0.15273040533065796,
0.0039642141200602055,
-0.7049171924591064,
-0.596774697303772,
-0.6246716380119324,
-0.6206539869308472,
-0.035643234848976135,
-0.45059046149253845,
-0.005786951165646315,
-0.5383375287055969,
0.0296288151293993,
-0.1976185292005539,
0.09688328206539154,
-0.4834580719470978,
-0.1018950343132019,
-0.19037564098834991,
0.6795740723609924,
-0.6792848706245422,
0.7594225406646729,
0.6512886881828308,
-0.29699626564979553,
-1.0058420896530151,
0.009515062905848026,
0.003554117865860462,
-0.8320642709732056,
0.6225045323371887,
0.006221238058060408,
-0.7122371196746826,
0.07741017639636993,
-0.2662511169910431,
-0.7312951683998108,
1.0226985216140747,
-0.03822305053472519,
-0.5414043068885803,
-0.14156267046928406,
0.15958960354328156,
0.6256396174430847,
-0.7583463788032532,
0.28432145714759827,
0.7275220155715942,
0.3869416117668152,
0.41823774576187134,
-0.8468825817108154,
-0.18497441709041595,
0.050537437200546265,
0.08133255690336227,
0.28226083517074585,
-0.7887158989906311,
0.9361178278923035,
-0.3955748975276947,
0.0642482340335846,
-0.04089656472206116,
0.6531002521514893,
0.5885664224624634,
0.24647532403469086,
0.5623566508293152,
0.3562028110027313,
0.7768881320953369,
0.145417720079422,
0.9304152131080627,
-0.17481453716754913,
0.5491642355918884,
0.9818158149719238,
-0.38094738125801086,
0.825649082660675,
0.5253601670265198,
-0.07529100030660629,
0.442222535610199,
0.49002304673194885,
0.25342726707458496,
0.7255973219871521,
0.4500994384288788,
-0.16109028458595276,
-0.3047175705432892,
-0.1537589430809021,
0.17906874418258667,
0.30944061279296875,
0.19311703741550446,
0.16251173615455627,
-0.21074211597442627,
0.14148259162902832,
0.12100810557603836,
0.14924131333827972,
-0.5512540936470032,
0.9560540914535522,
0.052836257964372635,
-1.0411869287490845,
0.44752106070518494,
0.2643751800060272,
0.5269371271133423,
-0.6239628195762634,
-0.14370806515216827,
-0.3071597218513489,
0.6305657029151917,
-0.10537049174308777,
-0.4981584846973419,
0.27972304821014404,
-0.10335922986268997,
-0.05856795608997345,
-0.33216428756713867,
0.5349818468093872,
-0.5600417256355286,
-0.37709537148475647,
0.3451656401157379,
0.35550206899642944,
0.06549733877182007,
0.13644438982009888,
-0.7768427729606628,
0.07253127545118332,
-0.1370408684015274,
-0.40112414956092834,
0.3394060730934143,
0.2671070098876953,
-0.15466222167015076,
1.0440785884857178,
0.3441547453403473,
0.40660977363586426,
-0.07243404537439346,
0.14184270799160004,
0.6291549801826477,
-0.6586753129959106,
-0.6097765564918518,
-0.7379894256591797,
0.4455685019493103,
0.10941316187381744,
-0.15042467415332794,
0.3568620979785919,
0.38234636187553406,
0.7863717079162598,
-0.0024292925372719765,
0.6523572206497192,
0.1287306845188141,
0.5573240518569946,
-0.7678947448730469,
0.4587690532207489,
-0.633689820766449,
0.1869811713695526,
-0.04027406498789787,
-0.7608340978622437,
-0.2405858039855957,
0.7494180202484131,
-0.19097857177257538,
0.34259530901908875,
0.8379712700843811,
0.8799824118614197,
0.14114682376384735,
-0.19946499168872833,
0.301813006401062,
0.028017282485961914,
0.6896417737007141,
0.6055854558944702,
0.8057509064674377,
-0.03241138905286789,
0.4949030876159668,
0.012717599980533123,
-0.25854477286338806,
-0.3055184483528137,
-0.7763671875,
-1.11042058467865,
-0.4402626156806946,
-0.3009611666202545,
-0.11167094111442566,
0.36023762822151184,
1.2504791021347046,
0.9318761825561523,
-0.8284369707107544,
-0.7561602592468262,
-0.12988042831420898,
0.48589375615119934,
-0.681978702545166,
-0.16072137653827667,
0.3469754159450531,
-0.8848663568496704,
-0.6247791647911072,
0.43245455622673035,
0.3809795677661896,
-0.2859327495098114,
-0.5124263167381287,
-0.5844004154205322,
-0.3556167185306549,
0.1390601396560669,
0.7201828956604004,
0.47267594933509827,
-0.7864564657211304,
-0.46480289101600647,
-0.202210932970047,
-0.017948145046830177,
0.059320975095033646,
0.9633171558380127,
-0.6397455334663391,
0.10719291865825653,
0.2543693780899048,
0.8230865597724915,
0.7543782591819763,
0.0391036756336689,
0.35376858711242676,
-0.6663411855697632,
0.18410615622997284,
0.3887939751148224,
-0.005149263888597488,
0.0646757110953331,
-0.04423093795776367,
0.22318561375141144,
-0.10436957329511642,
-0.8314676880836487,
-0.6487497687339783,
0.5236559510231018,
-0.6740347146987915,
-0.3664625287055969,
1.0481338500976562,
-0.09732268005609512,
-0.1506464183330536,
-0.1521214097738266,
-0.4123256504535675,
0.06491155177354813,
-0.5302518010139465,
0.5919610857963562,
0.4584105312824249,
-0.5627862811088562,
-0.5059258937835693,
-0.22636328637599945,
0.8373880982398987,
0.44378337264060974,
-0.8840732574462891,
0.24298711121082306,
0.3632994592189789,
-0.08995869755744934,
0.11259903758764267,
0.7524118423461914,
0.15179391205310822,
0.2266576737165451,
-0.07100827246904373,
0.05246320366859436,
-0.3033347427845001,
-1.0637214183807373,
-0.43632835149765015,
0.220313161611557,
0.7082131505012512,
-0.1535167247056961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00854v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00854v1
|
Speaker-Independent Dysarthria Severity Classification using Self-Supervised Transformers and Multi-Task Learning
| 2024-02-29T18:30:52 | 2024-02-29T18:30:52 |
Lauren Stumpf, Balasundaram Kadirvelu, Sigourney Waibel, A. Aldo Faisal
|
q-bio.NC
|
q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS, I.2.7; I.2.1; J.3
|
Dysarthria, a condition resulting from impaired control of the speech muscles
due to neurological disorders, significantly impacts the communication and
quality of life of patients. The condition's complexity, human scoring and
varied presentations make its assessment and management challenging. This study
presents a transformer-based framework for automatically assessing dysarthria
severity from raw speech data. It can offer an objective, repeatable,
accessible, standardised and cost-effective and compared to traditional methods
requiring human expert assessors. We develop a transformer framework, called
Speaker-Agnostic Latent Regularisation (SALR), incorporating a multi-task
learning objective and contrastive learning for speaker-independent multi-class
dysarthria severity classification. The multi-task framework is designed to
reduce reliance on speaker-specific characteristics and address the intrinsic
intra-class variability of dysarthric speech. We evaluated on the Universal
Access Speech dataset using leave-one-speaker-out cross-validation, our model
demonstrated superior performance over traditional machine learning approaches,
with an accuracy of $70.48\%$ and an F1 score of $59.23\%$. Our SALR model also
exceeded the previous benchmark for AI-based classification, which used support
vector machines, by $16.58\%$. We open the black box of our model by
visualising the latent space where we can observe how the model substantially
reduces speaker-specific cues and amplifies task-specific ones, thereby showing
its robustness. In conclusion, SALR establishes a new benchmark in
speaker-independent multi-class dysarthria severity classification using
generative AI. The potential implications of our findings for broader clinical
applications in automated dysarthria severity assessments.
|
[
-0.2966420352458954,
-0.537616491317749,
0.07621422410011292,
0.2834867537021637,
0.08053487539291382,
0.11249703168869019,
-0.11607686430215836,
-0.32461312413215637,
0.3505568206310272,
0.13711751997470856,
-0.38085728883743286,
-0.19686739146709442,
-0.9091378450393677,
0.22482143342494965,
-0.2524805963039398,
0.7106029391288757,
0.21430276334285736,
0.1422790139913559,
-0.040380626916885376,
-0.31662774085998535,
-0.5738247632980347,
-0.3764425814151764,
-0.2967993915081024,
-0.36644014716148376,
0.35383591055870056,
0.43869253993034363,
0.655957818031311,
0.46035832166671753,
0.5966582298278809,
0.39158400893211365,
-0.12836118042469025,
-0.2964017391204834,
-0.16403473913669586,
0.3275829553604126,
-0.04934246838092804,
-0.023626940324902534,
-0.6733483076095581,
0.16382764279842377,
0.5116461515426636,
0.9489354491233826,
-0.36179471015930176,
0.06167587265372276,
0.13312004506587982,
0.39474308490753174,
-0.2810046374797821,
0.32703396677970886,
-0.3390659987926483,
0.3197456896305084,
-0.24933640658855438,
-0.19507139921188354,
-0.3581995368003845,
0.12234247475862503,
0.013216993771493435,
-0.3696679472923279,
0.4066113233566284,
-0.025634346529841423,
0.4443923234939575,
0.7158991098403931,
-0.21256092190742493,
-0.07197593152523041,
-0.6637156009674072,
0.5503315329551697,
-0.3663112223148346,
0.6739586591720581,
0.4564562737941742,
0.6205624938011169,
-0.07076726108789444,
-0.6243390440940857,
-0.5568394660949707,
-0.4254003167152405,
-0.27604225277900696,
0.1685170829296112,
-0.6219577789306641,
0.22056181728839874,
0.18548738956451416,
0.7725304365158081,
-0.7708275318145752,
0.3535221517086029,
-0.5827602744102478,
-0.4017964005470276,
0.5573828220367432,
0.0883011668920517,
0.36182379722595215,
-0.5319528579711914,
-0.11474565416574478,
-0.029748521745204926,
-0.20803046226501465,
0.13417524099349976,
0.31921979784965515,
0.5590393543243408,
-0.30980992317199707,
0.39877238869667053,
-0.32590293884277344,
0.5644131898880005,
0.5569136738777161,
-0.5068618655204773,
0.4854130148887634,
0.18251556158065796,
0.03853677958250046,
0.3192436695098877,
0.6929644346237183,
0.1022898256778717,
-0.2851244807243347,
-0.5773373246192932,
0.11081709712743759,
0.29763537645339966,
0.276707261800766,
-0.7207499742507935,
-0.5798459053039551,
0.28581660985946655,
-0.34885480999946594,
-0.1971532106399536,
-0.1850622445344925,
-0.7858946919441223,
-0.5101178288459778,
-0.4426017701625824,
0.19462503492832184,
-0.2646860182285309,
-0.507357120513916,
-0.041545115411281586,
0.0794774666428566,
-0.14813315868377686,
0.129006490111351,
-0.8945776224136353,
0.5302072763442993,
0.04155939444899559,
0.6252802610397339,
-0.6334565877914429,
-0.4224029779434204,
-0.8396447896957397,
0.0018006933387368917,
-0.12194059044122696,
0.7715831995010376,
-0.41802528500556946,
-0.35323435068130493,
-0.702781617641449,
0.01434546709060669,
-0.2817068099975586,
-0.5022120475769043,
0.6090987920761108,
-0.14101512730121613,
0.28200486302375793,
0.32021042704582214,
-0.302713006734848,
-0.19140151143074036,
-0.08496012538671494,
-0.8515943884849548,
0.8053081035614014,
0.37320733070373535,
-0.9228084683418274,
0.40126723051071167,
-0.5679925680160522,
-0.40035510063171387,
0.4720599353313446,
-0.3921951353549957,
-0.27881577610969543,
0.1580112725496292,
0.22552800178527832,
0.4155932068824768,
-0.3301897644996643,
0.699806272983551,
-0.0690305307507515,
-0.284292608499527,
-0.07469876855611801,
-0.6893447637557983,
0.2865084409713745,
0.06209861487150192,
-0.607471227645874,
0.3350478708744049,
-0.9443559050559998,
-0.118580661714077,
-0.14828434586524963,
-0.12297525256872177,
-0.08598847687244415,
-0.03491118922829628,
0.048572439700365067,
0.42643991112709045,
-0.12278426438570023,
-0.5739632248878479,
-0.003456625621765852,
-0.518490731716156,
0.19356803596019745,
0.5900403261184692,
-0.09938672184944153,
0.1455070674419403,
-0.44285252690315247,
0.5499978065490723,
0.18627113103866577,
0.1825246959924698,
0.08098245412111282,
-0.6000360250473022,
-0.3829004168510437,
-0.6052689552307129,
0.36325162649154663,
0.5345285534858704,
-0.36656805872917175,
0.9693040251731873,
-0.5941113829612732,
-0.5658833980560303,
-0.8417697548866272,
-0.19134782254695892,
0.15978944301605225,
0.7589252591133118,
0.700527012348175,
-0.20252884924411774,
-0.19068674743175507,
-0.6931911110877991,
0.16056233644485474,
-0.1353135108947754,
0.10446189343929291,
0.2805078327655792,
0.17671382427215576,
-0.5210462212562561,
0.9574755430221558,
-0.10646350681781769,
-0.6648898720741272,
-0.2659023106098175,
0.27143266797065735,
0.13874341547489166,
0.4440803825855255,
0.1693008989095688,
-0.8087927103042603,
-0.4725673794746399,
0.16153885424137115,
-0.671084463596344,
-0.138040691614151,
0.015175930224359035,
0.7196341156959534,
0.09877517819404602,
0.30886873602867126,
-0.4419543445110321,
0.758892834186554,
0.7205974459648132,
-0.17313502728939056,
0.3639064431190491,
-0.31194064021110535,
0.29571908712387085,
-0.7924076914787292,
0.24514901638031006,
-0.18805478513240814,
0.0039757066406309605,
-0.5941099524497986,
-0.23059546947479248,
-0.18280857801437378,
-0.2771642804145813,
-0.11439616233110428,
0.39907440543174744,
-0.036992352455854416,
-0.09073387831449509,
-0.2670043706893921,
0.09133919328451157,
0.05753283202648163,
0.5337011814117432,
-0.2326008528470993,
0.8108541965484619,
0.9028119444847107,
-0.3588898479938507,
0.5778273940086365,
0.29379913210868835,
-0.23493121564388275,
0.4106329083442688,
-0.7479295134544373,
0.0011293390998616815,
-0.08086386322975159,
0.19137464463710785,
-1.1114252805709839,
-0.22996366024017334,
0.3402450382709503,
-0.35690560936927795,
0.7424643039703369,
-0.07622803747653961,
-0.1462809145450592,
-0.5275800228118896,
-0.015082568861544132,
0.24389530718326569,
0.11495816707611084,
-0.5528090596199036,
0.8212454319000244,
0.48001018166542053,
-0.7021945118904114,
-0.5326130390167236,
-0.5812410712242126,
0.17444957792758942,
-0.228817418217659,
-0.5798662900924683,
0.8809146881103516,
-0.35731199383735657,
-0.2659755349159241,
-0.07324273139238358,
-0.4370284378528595,
-0.022245682775974274,
-0.008012368343770504,
0.5743346810340881,
-0.07958374172449112,
0.08491974323987961,
0.44119226932525635,
0.2777584195137024,
-0.4239298105239868,
-0.3824312388896942,
0.21501845121383667,
0.42475616931915283,
-0.17351968586444855,
-0.8232879638671875,
-1.007595419883728,
0.5615043044090271,
0.8344486951828003,
-0.15753601491451263,
-0.07585886865854263,
0.527127206325531,
-0.1835116446018219,
0.10907988250255585,
-0.7110182642936707,
-0.25563931465148926,
-0.4495595693588257,
0.4636450409889221,
-0.7398614883422852,
-0.7053170204162598,
0.5049924254417419,
-0.10286010801792145,
-0.45942410826683044,
0.6979432106018066,
0.4923701584339142,
0.19388963282108307,
0.9800248742103577,
0.5706087946891785,
-0.44744211435317993,
0.02711704559624195,
0.07483281195163727,
0.24008366465568542,
-0.5780360698699951,
-0.18744945526123047,
-0.5644045472145081,
-0.16143545508384705,
-0.5761354565620422,
-0.14793182909488678,
0.3367132842540741,
0.037629906088113785,
0.028774207457900047,
-0.0636192262172699,
-0.7864279747009277,
0.20031684637069702,
0.08756045997142792,
0.262937068939209,
0.2443452775478363,
-0.03325225040316582,
-0.035748232156038284,
-0.11206656694412231,
-0.7459654808044434,
-0.2950684726238251,
0.7832632064819336,
0.46742498874664307,
0.8620241284370422,
0.04769247770309448,
0.6125596761703491,
0.8834289908409119,
0.32867565751075745,
-0.901874303817749,
0.08817778527736664,
-0.2923039197921753,
-0.03953845053911209,
-0.5478635430335999,
-0.5966823697090149,
-0.9597319960594177,
0.2208753377199173,
0.17813993990421295,
-0.5984990000724792,
0.38810643553733826,
-0.14166904985904694,
-0.482730895280838,
0.28050559759140015,
-0.5302898287773132,
0.9226363301277161,
-0.36463674902915955,
-0.15809424221515656,
-0.28199294209480286,
-0.8005281090736389,
-0.041816018521785736,
-0.14198127388954163,
0.29554060101509094,
-0.3858904242515564,
0.3721461594104767,
0.8415269255638123,
0.0023866132833063602,
0.971705973148346,
-0.3291456699371338,
-0.02678043767809868,
-0.06269966065883636,
0.03621084988117218,
0.12351129204034805,
0.008565252646803856,
-0.23586465418338776,
0.3270120918750763,
-0.00965168233960867,
-0.11524201184511185,
-0.45161116123199463,
0.7627243399620056,
-0.9669323563575745,
-0.6186934113502502,
-0.5916773080825806,
-0.724227249622345,
-0.4500512182712555,
-0.03872234746813774,
0.07717560231685638,
0.6296687126159668,
-0.2536545693874359,
0.06831160187721252,
0.4588756859302521,
0.017584621906280518,
0.43184250593185425,
0.569355309009552,
0.163499653339386,
-0.46072137355804443,
0.9773311614990234,
0.12156473100185394,
-0.10668475180864334,
0.25154441595077515,
0.46397408843040466,
-0.463947057723999,
-0.6444617509841919,
-0.568873405456543,
-0.04977021738886833,
-0.7755246162414551,
-0.2683400809764862,
-0.5154352784156799,
-0.19993425905704498,
-0.6956661343574524,
0.4074801206588745,
-0.0964232087135315,
-0.3698500394821167,
-0.3244030177593231,
-0.187972754240036,
0.2563702464103699,
0.739555835723877,
-0.20665858685970306,
0.26491445302963257,
-0.544999897480011,
0.6495062112808228,
0.6554543375968933,
0.6093911528587341,
-0.17958202958106995,
-0.8741552829742432,
0.12045706063508987,
-0.019506843760609627,
-0.40055546164512634,
-0.7862957715988159,
0.39262521266937256,
0.507142186164856,
1.000509262084961,
0.2082514613866806,
0.26796963810920715,
0.6809372305870056,
-0.4166431128978729,
0.6455785036087036,
0.3455926477909088,
-0.9349932074546814,
0.48107099533081055,
0.06572802364826202,
0.16437850892543793,
0.561434268951416,
0.5499255061149597,
-0.44602957367897034,
-0.2101963460445404,
-0.6147001385688782,
-0.6313706636428833,
0.9357975721359253,
-0.09919854998588562,
-0.13250860571861267,
-0.0007049948326312006,
0.1553446650505066,
0.3827560245990753,
-0.18529893457889557,
-0.5665873885154724,
-0.3451397716999054,
-0.5293192267417908,
-0.22991949319839478,
-0.3166084885597229,
-0.08610640466213226,
-0.26388442516326904,
-0.5828643441200256,
0.45677369832992554,
-0.35769379138946533,
0.04494654759764671,
0.2568281292915344,
-0.33221742510795593,
-0.29795315861701965,
0.4234764873981476,
0.3601292371749878,
0.647312581539154,
-0.15306687355041504,
0.007749851327389479,
0.2997187077999115,
-0.5253579616546631,
0.20121429860591888,
0.637927234172821,
0.3328567445278168,
0.15720678865909576,
0.1061365082859993,
0.8349462747573853,
0.13175296783447266,
-0.46110934019088745,
0.9092698693275452,
-0.18571676313877106,
-0.15775375068187714,
-0.012900562025606632,
-0.3238781988620758,
-0.2769269347190857,
0.23543184995651245,
0.4723253846168518,
0.36532747745513916,
0.19129826128482819,
0.0046708364970982075,
0.5933325290679932,
-0.057966746389865875,
-0.6536551117897034,
-0.4239497184753418,
0.45747971534729004,
0.11125291883945465,
-0.18277974426746368,
0.44269153475761414,
-0.28536441922187805,
-0.1645253300666809,
0.13514961302280426,
0.42751067876815796,
0.8393215537071228,
-0.9381455779075623,
0.05115903913974762,
-0.13199765980243683,
0.1299632340669632,
0.2383527159690857,
0.1734994500875473,
-0.2860657870769501,
-0.36147964000701904,
-0.45723211765289307,
-0.7790535688400269,
-0.47020071744918823,
-0.004336581565439701,
-0.8467176556587219,
0.13762818276882172,
-0.08620815724134445,
-0.26725831627845764,
0.34708285331726074,
-0.1525925099849701,
-0.33210498094558716,
0.2427166998386383,
0.13516198098659515,
0.5696521997451782,
-0.8530983328819275,
0.8932448029518127,
0.41073209047317505,
-0.5513087511062622,
-0.4790728688240051,
0.2747735381126404,
-0.1743771731853485,
-0.4973997175693512,
0.8592844009399414,
0.2703508138656616,
-0.28534430265426636,
-0.047147974371910095,
0.12641797959804535,
-0.7252097725868225,
0.9521605968475342,
0.3845973014831543,
-0.48379266262054443,
0.05315161496400833,
0.22123464941978455,
0.41127732396125793,
-0.06410210579633713,
0.2305978387594223,
0.4587233364582062,
0.336185097694397,
0.12018472701311111,
-1.4165937900543213,
-0.014545807614922523,
-0.3405905067920685,
-0.31728625297546387,
0.01752161793410778,
-0.32811713218688965,
0.6925384998321533,
-0.11854783445596695,
-0.16377362608909607,
-0.12344368547201157,
0.5364088416099548,
-0.04322760924696922,
0.2629450261592865,
0.4993342459201813,
0.589394748210907,
1.0305200815200806,
-0.047488000243902206,
0.6953091025352478,
-0.6647170186042786,
0.20364679396152496,
0.8970000147819519,
-0.37237611413002014,
0.5874638557434082,
0.3362696170806885,
-0.2960212528705597,
0.4270905554294586,
0.16949836909770966,
0.018291272222995758,
0.4089805483818054,
0.5281274318695068,
-0.2808194160461426,
-0.10705743730068207,
-0.11697108298540115,
-0.6255161762237549,
0.8380911350250244,
0.3748767375946045,
0.0882420688867569,
-0.3077467381954193,
0.3971730172634125,
-0.2951977849006653,
0.033649809658527374,
-0.17126764357089996,
0.898144543170929,
-0.27885809540748596,
-0.33657076954841614,
0.7136486768722534,
-0.05381610617041588,
0.8083363771438599,
-0.751457154750824,
0.11003049463033676,
-0.035962533205747604,
0.2973693907260895,
-0.32863685488700867,
-0.41085824370384216,
0.6220098733901978,
-0.14501777291297913,
-0.5677993297576904,
-0.2883667051792145,
0.5532885193824768,
-0.15121108293533325,
-0.5009392499923706,
0.3997299373149872,
0.5465227365493774,
0.22927457094192505,
-0.20777268707752228,
-0.559894323348999,
0.1449417918920517,
-0.3014954626560211,
0.04722782224416733,
0.42806991934776306,
0.2812868356704712,
-0.03427426517009735,
0.5952891111373901,
0.3065890371799469,
0.057651013135910034,
-0.08546293526887894,
0.34502607583999634,
1.0049545764923096,
-0.34885916113853455,
-0.43910959362983704,
-0.4323519170284271,
0.23741422593593597,
-0.004225027281790972,
-0.28178420662879944,
0.5786707401275635,
0.3796406388282776,
0.41052260994911194,
0.22768059372901917,
0.6829619407653809,
-0.17025671899318695,
0.8306919932365417,
0.07213667780160904,
0.9585059881210327,
-0.42429453134536743,
0.1065736636519432,
-0.24024710059165955,
-0.0579695999622345,
-0.49591362476348877,
0.5488279461860657,
-0.4381207227706909,
0.0721900686621666,
0.48440316319465637,
0.7173711061477661,
-0.08893109112977982,
0.17527063190937042,
0.5527698993682861,
0.1476248949766159,
0.26844078302383423,
0.13807722926139832,
0.6956746578216553,
-0.27461498975753784,
0.6112160682678223,
-0.4904272258281708,
-0.5707962512969971,
0.03209302946925163,
-0.604438841342926,
-0.5748549103736877,
-0.5990995168685913,
-0.5662493109703064,
-0.0510268397629261,
0.11862361431121826,
0.8570985198020935,
0.8755909204483032,
-0.9192315340042114,
-0.20979315042495728,
0.05717368423938751,
-0.0964631587266922,
-0.5039510726928711,
-0.1924510896205902,
0.7893924713134766,
-0.4629542827606201,
-0.33080512285232544,
0.9418020844459534,
0.3463156819343567,
0.08031806349754333,
-0.24663516879081726,
-0.14469310641288757,
0.1487589329481125,
-0.6312355995178223,
0.44554734230041504,
0.15146571397781372,
-0.9997490644454956,
-0.15602028369903564,
-0.058937571942806244,
-0.030711296945810318,
0.1870572715997696,
0.564581036567688,
-0.9351954460144043,
0.5531681776046753,
0.13524538278579712,
0.5594366192817688,
0.2968410849571228,
-0.07944232225418091,
0.07214914262294769,
-0.7516384720802307,
0.223848357796669,
0.5546528100967407,
0.37575218081474304,
0.47816288471221924,
-0.31046685576438904,
-0.017867716029286385,
0.5509809851646423,
-0.44140660762786865,
-0.6793361902236938,
-0.059735007584095,
-1.1654328107833862,
-0.2923140823841095,
0.7625157237052917,
-0.16305944323539734,
0.20416496694087982,
-0.4819743037223816,
-0.2676570415496826,
0.1713152825832367,
-0.2558615505695343,
1.0511081218719482,
0.13448524475097656,
-0.44742220640182495,
-0.020194819197058678,
-0.2757759988307953,
0.4280625581741333,
0.1745179146528244,
-0.6171552538871765,
0.26366034150123596,
0.4019007682800293,
0.17099647223949432,
0.38533875346183777,
0.49584487080574036,
-0.16989782452583313,
0.2804614007472992,
0.07577628642320633,
0.2461882382631302,
-0.20833732187747955,
-0.5300040245056152,
-0.5606468319892883,
0.4539729654788971,
-0.11116264760494232,
-0.15650655329227448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19431v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19431v1
|
Compositional API Recommendation for Library-Oriented Code Generation
| 2024-02-29T18:27:27 | 2024-02-29T18:27:27 |
Zexiong Ma, Shengnan An, Bing Xie, Zeqi Lin
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved exceptional performance in code
generation. However, the performance remains unsatisfactory in generating
library-oriented code, especially for the libraries not present in the training
data of LLMs. Previous work utilizes API recommendation technology to help LLMs
use libraries: it retrieves APIs related to the user requirements, then
leverages them as context to prompt LLMs. However, developmental requirements
can be coarse-grained, requiring a combination of multiple fine-grained APIs.
This granularity inconsistency makes API recommendation a challenging task. To
address this, we propose CAPIR (Compositional API Recommendation), which adopts
a "divide-and-conquer" strategy to recommend APIs for coarse-grained
requirements. Specifically, CAPIR employs an LLM-based Decomposer to break down
a coarse-grained task description into several detailed subtasks. Then, CAPIR
applies an embedding-based Retriever to identify relevant APIs corresponding to
each subtask. Moreover, CAPIR leverages an LLM-based Reranker to filter out
redundant APIs and provides the final recommendation. To facilitate the
evaluation of API recommendation methods on coarse-grained requirements, we
present two challenging benchmarks, RAPID (Recommend APIs based on
Documentation) and LOCG (Library-Oriented Code Generation). Experimental
results on these benchmarks, demonstrate the effectiveness of CAPIR in
comparison to existing baselines. Specifically, on RAPID's Torchdata-AR
dataset, compared to the state-of-the-art API recommendation approach, CAPIR
improves recall@5 from 18.7% to 43.2% and precision@5 from 15.5% to 37.1%. On
LOCG's Torchdata-Code dataset, compared to code generation without API
recommendation, CAPIR improves pass@100 from 16.0% to 28.0%.
|
[
-0.5499197840690613,
-0.35235658288002014,
0.39510953426361084,
0.3136160671710968,
-0.1357559859752655,
0.253981351852417,
-0.36896055936813354,
-0.35801777243614197,
0.08245760947465897,
0.5788908004760742,
-0.4850521683692932,
-0.8794767260551453,
-0.2745536267757416,
-0.11924148350954056,
-0.12212531268596649,
0.9988367557525635,
-0.10670739412307739,
-0.14224649965763092,
-0.3451046943664551,
-0.005627412348985672,
-0.9778768420219421,
-0.19843070209026337,
-0.4111231863498688,
-0.6318240761756897,
0.7218080759048462,
0.432041734457016,
0.3251306712627411,
0.846688449382782,
0.47938162088394165,
0.1953873485326767,
-0.05157865211367607,
0.3929901719093323,
-0.30133312940597534,
0.1605496108531952,
0.03630409017205238,
-0.4636313319206238,
-0.42256733775138855,
-0.3618004024028778,
-0.010501565411686897,
0.6465163230895996,
-0.04060548171401024,
0.30625787377357483,
0.12628114223480225,
0.9188791513442993,
-0.5963186025619507,
0.3437856137752533,
-0.5870770812034607,
0.2690543532371521,
-0.07121845334768295,
-0.44041019678115845,
-0.293712317943573,
-0.3758467137813568,
0.33638155460357666,
-0.538676381111145,
0.062449611723423004,
0.5122517943382263,
0.2605057656764984,
0.22674430906772614,
-0.04319044575095177,
-0.684998095035553,
-0.6789374947547913,
1.0428016185760498,
-0.5295414328575134,
0.23011164367198944,
0.5418301820755005,
-0.05459901690483093,
-0.16939987242221832,
-0.6473531126976013,
-0.026718728244304657,
-0.2624663710594177,
0.03564462810754776,
-0.19332368671894073,
-0.036759935319423676,
-0.030016057193279266,
0.14512288570404053,
0.6322100162506104,
-0.6651135683059692,
-0.04157984256744385,
-0.4887084364891052,
-0.3353305160999298,
0.21932190656661987,
0.195626363158226,
0.2106243073940277,
0.005638534668833017,
-0.34777429699897766,
0.224397674202919,
-0.7622318267822266,
0.12054800987243652,
0.5104907751083374,
0.6062908172607422,
0.032558418810367584,
0.4751952886581421,
-0.18656817078590393,
0.5412353873252869,
0.26369091868400574,
-0.23841184377670288,
0.4567948877811432,
-0.1647419035434723,
0.030341459438204765,
-0.07659614086151123,
0.6555895209312439,
0.49891284108161926,
0.1906745284795761,
-0.47674450278282166,
-0.4085933268070221,
-0.059385817497968674,
0.35522937774658203,
-0.725021481513977,
-0.13300146162509918,
0.3601338267326355,
-0.4983935058116913,
-0.04613342881202698,
-0.1615297645330429,
-0.40408390760421753,
-0.3122290372848511,
-0.5830797553062439,
0.07949265837669373,
-0.5083625912666321,
0.1324397474527359,
-0.1367509514093399,
-0.07511577010154724,
0.3210110664367676,
-0.06961585581302643,
-0.8725429773330688,
0.20870645344257355,
0.8916024565696716,
0.9253541231155396,
-0.3034433424472809,
-0.4057577848434448,
-0.5048224329948425,
0.039069484919309616,
-0.14877454936504364,
1.1531517505645752,
-0.5121618509292603,
-0.38752105832099915,
0.30011430382728577,
-0.14468920230865479,
0.4385421872138977,
-0.9440701007843018,
0.6738017797470093,
-0.42091554403305054,
-0.3998467028141022,
-0.5331976413726807,
-0.5721584558486938,
0.25040438771247864,
0.3121168911457062,
-0.621523380279541,
1.0359458923339844,
0.24834124743938446,
-0.6668375134468079,
0.681359589099884,
-0.5426486134529114,
-0.6141895651817322,
0.25975608825683594,
-0.274799644947052,
-0.24950750172138214,
-0.04680484160780907,
0.2830688953399658,
0.18631981313228607,
-0.43707919120788574,
0.31472131609916687,
-0.30097663402557373,
-0.5609331130981445,
0.05851879343390465,
0.1195434108376503,
0.08978462219238281,
0.5189673900604248,
-0.2182023823261261,
0.14549414813518524,
-0.6935046315193176,
0.1607665717601776,
-0.36682191491127014,
-0.6418221592903137,
-0.2822366952896118,
0.1286105066537857,
0.09236495196819305,
-0.15867449343204498,
0.3143742084503174,
-0.3515456020832062,
0.13806700706481934,
-0.4974499046802521,
0.5011370778083801,
0.7676738500595093,
-0.05237094685435295,
0.7013115882873535,
-0.8098064661026001,
0.3603964149951935,
-0.36070963740348816,
0.17082715034484863,
-0.2922530174255371,
-0.17450392246246338,
-0.7438961863517761,
-0.34173792600631714,
0.003630464430898428,
0.4842144250869751,
-0.5942454934120178,
0.6665146350860596,
0.03968073055148125,
-0.3775547444820404,
-0.1902713179588318,
0.626224160194397,
0.650287389755249,
0.2908109128475189,
0.3188895881175995,
-0.28908559679985046,
-0.8705469965934753,
-0.6301348805427551,
-0.14423567056655884,
-0.20837798714637756,
-0.07545074820518494,
0.6369665861129761,
0.08007414638996124,
-0.43680936098098755,
1.010022759437561,
-0.5693926811218262,
-0.34952130913734436,
-0.15059790015220642,
0.10012439638376236,
0.3926539719104767,
0.3946478068828583,
0.3558236360549927,
-0.3540298640727997,
-0.3180692493915558,
-0.13498306274414062,
-0.5498828291893005,
-0.3656269311904907,
0.27148717641830444,
-0.2942463159561157,
0.00039345084223896265,
0.4689381420612335,
-0.23363687098026276,
-0.002490052953362465,
0.3307783603668213,
-0.07318141311407089,
0.4751553535461426,
-0.30100300908088684,
-0.0694413036108017,
-1.0085340738296509,
0.14204715192317963,
-0.1523880660533905,
-0.14043334126472473,
-0.3415084481239319,
0.23413915932178497,
-0.15121199190616608,
-0.04286148399114609,
-0.4308628737926483,
0.6536392569541931,
-0.2310795783996582,
0.029469147324562073,
-0.488480806350708,
-0.17861387133598328,
-0.04611004516482353,
0.5252701044082642,
-0.21219998598098755,
0.7389611005783081,
0.5675340890884399,
-0.6473281383514404,
0.39579832553863525,
0.21060995757579803,
-0.34531405568122864,
0.4795410633087158,
-0.7459269165992737,
0.1948024183511734,
0.24697087705135345,
0.25873973965644836,
-0.8855818510055542,
0.0819779559969902,
-0.0388907790184021,
-0.02779361978173256,
-0.014592732302844524,
-0.3525775074958801,
-0.6091435551643372,
-0.33302220702171326,
-0.5914615392684937,
0.6239573359489441,
0.4819931387901306,
-0.5823444128036499,
0.6789031028747559,
0.2117345631122589,
-0.10358364135026932,
-0.7849774360656738,
-0.9109364748001099,
-0.09961921721696854,
-0.11218515783548355,
-0.4445066750049591,
0.39802348613739014,
-0.5363978147506714,
-0.09985115379095078,
-0.05479181185364723,
-0.3222014307975769,
0.09499199688434601,
-0.29473641514778137,
0.7849476933479309,
0.3104211986064911,
-0.15131333470344543,
0.13351304829120636,
-0.13179729878902435,
-0.0846957266330719,
0.07902779430150986,
-0.463897705078125,
0.8059408068656921,
-0.31670406460762024,
-0.37189334630966187,
0.04436443746089935,
0.2057565599679947,
0.5687418580055237,
-0.14279799163341522,
0.17775015532970428,
0.7285925149917603,
0.040610168129205704,
-0.4761561453342438,
-0.8517088890075684,
0.11614911258220673,
-0.44997456669807434,
-0.08353114128112793,
-0.34608232975006104,
-1.0032378435134888,
0.8110440969467163,
-0.21325401961803436,
0.15496264398097992,
0.05339248478412628,
0.7797689437866211,
0.11719631403684616,
0.29884374141693115,
0.43099597096443176,
-0.3730107247829437,
0.6920984983444214,
-0.5393506288528442,
0.15851958096027374,
-0.9233103394508362,
-0.24553079903125763,
-0.2590946853160858,
-0.36259275674819946,
-0.5567768812179565,
-0.2666635513305664,
0.07460427284240723,
-0.11477179825305939,
-0.24100786447525024,
0.30933526158332825,
-0.6343469619750977,
0.7775198817253113,
0.8170105218887329,
0.25438547134399414,
0.25050660967826843,
0.18889088928699493,
-0.1529334932565689,
0.4162681996822357,
-0.45042166113853455,
-0.27920034527778625,
1.397252082824707,
0.11769477277994156,
1.0363410711288452,
-0.05187813192605972,
0.9257754683494568,
0.7290711402893066,
0.08611687272787094,
-0.9123407006263733,
0.4096836447715759,
-0.3547382056713104,
-0.3983190357685089,
0.058342210948467255,
-0.27352818846702576,
-1.0181328058242798,
-0.23380246758460999,
-0.08946650475263596,
-0.36145055294036865,
0.22945381700992584,
0.020955592393875122,
-0.5183913111686707,
0.02339037135243416,
-0.6924588680267334,
0.5447507500648499,
-0.07336249202489853,
-0.2740025520324707,
0.07346650213003159,
-0.34240296483039856,
0.23915335536003113,
-0.17731893062591553,
0.2682775855064392,
-0.18853148818016052,
-0.0955871120095253,
0.4672095775604248,
-0.6022495627403259,
0.7650811672210693,
-0.18354929983615875,
-0.07869789004325867,
0.6785680055618286,
0.12130104750394821,
0.35407745838165283,
0.12539972364902496,
-0.12727780640125275,
0.06300104409456253,
-0.017125915735960007,
-0.25716808438301086,
-0.33754974603652954,
1.1003865003585815,
-0.9000276923179626,
-0.29021817445755005,
-0.10764308273792267,
-0.8332726359367371,
-0.11831851303577423,
0.2211589217185974,
0.2588163912296295,
0.6203559637069702,
0.07298613339662552,
0.12612533569335938,
0.7282123565673828,
-0.2349502593278885,
0.4913696050643921,
0.35826075077056885,
-0.3116697371006012,
-0.7534326314926147,
1.0028103590011597,
-0.13069771230220795,
-0.08855830878019333,
0.23784881830215454,
0.26433882117271423,
-0.21900244057178497,
-0.6430985331535339,
-0.178953155875206,
0.114833764731884,
-0.6587597727775574,
-0.5569049119949341,
-0.41071179509162903,
-0.08642985671758652,
-0.200614333152771,
-0.4271327555179596,
-0.3134920001029968,
0.06427933275699615,
-0.27525681257247925,
0.24159471690654755,
0.37679821252822876,
0.4641048014163971,
0.12233834713697433,
0.15792584419250488,
-0.49851441383361816,
0.38637498021125793,
0.23604117333889008,
0.6744260787963867,
-0.028906673192977905,
-0.4244450032711029,
-0.3082349896430969,
-0.5126553177833557,
-0.21858413517475128,
-0.10706263035535812,
0.12841370701789856,
0.043292753398418427,
0.5733550786972046,
0.2680603265762329,
0.2792012393474579,
0.6464143991470337,
-0.568400502204895,
0.607815682888031,
0.02409157156944275,
-0.730675995349884,
0.4790160655975342,
-0.3157048523426056,
0.4727466106414795,
0.7326365113258362,
-0.012655862607061863,
-0.01568670943379402,
-0.5619244575500488,
-0.06588196754455566,
-1.2217681407928467,
0.5912058353424072,
-0.01085425354540348,
0.23850293457508087,
-0.04829452186822891,
0.6019384860992432,
0.29683592915534973,
0.20425452291965485,
-0.608061671257019,
-0.2704453468322754,
0.12507377564907074,
-0.12176147103309631,
0.3056928515434265,
-0.25568997859954834,
-0.16828826069831848,
0.14632411301136017,
0.31574949622154236,
-0.11642364412546158,
0.17921055853366852,
0.09353004395961761,
0.036013856530189514,
-0.200557678937912,
0.3899151682853699,
0.3794993460178375,
0.8925540447235107,
-0.4714357554912567,
0.16090551018714905,
-0.014657215215265751,
-0.3660550117492676,
0.043144095689058304,
0.02839026413857937,
-0.06961088627576828,
-0.2416904717683792,
0.4112268090248108,
0.4951939582824707,
0.1564367711544037,
-1.1013118028640747,
0.46954914927482605,
-0.02787492796778679,
-0.16464224457740784,
-0.3543408215045929,
0.0755651518702507,
-0.052631109952926636,
0.5292466282844543,
0.4865167438983917,
0.14136599004268646,
0.1590835601091385,
-0.5868484973907471,
0.14313238859176636,
0.3310701549053192,
-0.12031753361225128,
0.002446468686684966,
0.20058020949363708,
0.3064626455307007,
-0.26587313413619995,
0.18985772132873535,
-0.3323676884174347,
-0.10225993394851685,
0.2882746458053589,
0.4903479218482971,
0.9350215792655945,
0.152457594871521,
-0.05221998319029808,
0.14276036620140076,
0.12778498232364655,
-0.23298907279968262,
0.27632126212120056,
-0.37602511048316956,
-0.4186619222164154,
-0.5371779799461365,
-0.8555384278297424,
-0.3941744565963745,
0.12030279636383057,
-0.49659621715545654,
0.29605740308761597,
-0.7687304019927979,
-0.21406440436840057,
-0.21755163371562958,
0.05081913247704506,
-0.6376743316650391,
-0.11458175629377365,
0.11813866347074509,
0.6681752800941467,
-0.5833648443222046,
0.4524949789047241,
0.6143276691436768,
-0.6091111302375793,
-0.7623808979988098,
0.046674784272909164,
-0.1392936110496521,
-0.6904833316802979,
0.7108193039894104,
-0.05318630114197731,
-0.1866254210472107,
-0.47150471806526184,
-0.2095460295677185,
-0.6829352378845215,
1.1532353162765503,
0.38344940543174744,
-0.4421769976615906,
-0.07680366933345795,
0.15102238953113556,
0.5499892830848694,
-0.6299716830253601,
0.3626178503036499,
0.4267205595970154,
0.24386008083820343,
0.4268488585948944,
-0.8264554142951965,
0.10064814984798431,
-0.120934396982193,
0.31047287583351135,
0.10858485847711563,
-0.6616918444633484,
0.9336112141609192,
-0.018129421398043633,
0.12232013791799545,
0.3698523938655853,
0.29905256628990173,
0.558286726474762,
0.6452777981758118,
0.38750752806663513,
0.4803953766822815,
0.4567064940929413,
0.15744371712207794,
0.8637598752975464,
-0.6946173906326294,
0.0917375236749649,
1.2008280754089355,
-0.3608529567718506,
0.8840565085411072,
0.4769594371318817,
-0.19386813044548035,
0.6100612282752991,
0.6046826839447021,
-0.3127564489841461,
0.5626765489578247,
0.3617686331272125,
-0.07808884233236313,
0.11736708879470825,
-0.29286861419677734,
-0.3660719096660614,
0.23899026215076447,
-0.13555017113685608,
-0.438037246465683,
-0.15500524640083313,
0.0635419711470604,
-0.09053108841180801,
0.001906661200337112,
-0.3780437111854553,
0.8894507884979248,
-0.15762311220169067,
-0.6954529285430908,
0.7137722373008728,
-0.15175214409828186,
0.7861664295196533,
-0.42818862199783325,
0.0039054397493600845,
-0.5507788062095642,
0.3464793264865875,
-0.46525388956069946,
-0.5815573334693909,
0.11986424773931503,
0.1695098578929901,
-0.6161900758743286,
-0.15453870594501495,
0.6918463110923767,
-0.23561300337314606,
-0.38838839530944824,
0.30101343989372253,
0.6161801815032959,
0.014298253692686558,
-0.10385418683290482,
-0.4382636845111847,
0.3780607283115387,
-0.03647416830062866,
0.0982075110077858,
0.36506015062332153,
0.5057955980300903,
0.29592713713645935,
0.6905419230461121,
0.704042375087738,
0.16927218437194824,
-0.01711033470928669,
0.20419630408287048,
1.2189445495605469,
-0.5147114992141724,
-0.3053773045539856,
-0.7132796049118042,
0.17297455668449402,
0.42104417085647583,
-0.1296454519033432,
0.573875367641449,
0.9903813600540161,
0.8171137571334839,
-0.1842038482427597,
0.7702551484107971,
-0.15012647211551666,
0.339310884475708,
-0.41880306601524353,
0.26805293560028076,
-0.2333812415599823,
0.8563724160194397,
-0.2681715190410614,
-1.4377819299697876,
-0.45253369212150574,
0.09561328589916229,
-0.34632375836372375,
0.11060073226690292,
0.6020034551620483,
0.9068685173988342,
-0.011326702311635017,
-0.3456905782222748,
0.09470944106578827,
-0.25013697147369385,
0.35510164499282837,
0.729344367980957,
0.8750341534614563,
-0.1863774061203003,
1.0251330137252808,
-0.0049085733480751514,
-0.2173912227153778,
-0.31369665265083313,
-0.7061285376548767,
-1.0513101816177368,
-0.3493511974811554,
-0.25313860177993774,
-0.3288676142692566,
0.013921316713094711,
1.1722307205200195,
0.8494781255722046,
-0.7452822327613831,
-0.4504241943359375,
-0.3932187259197235,
-0.03454101085662842,
-0.12889741361141205,
-0.21167942881584167,
0.24511633813381195,
-0.8401039838790894,
-0.6048803925514221,
0.4054091274738312,
0.3178170323371887,
-0.3615679442882538,
-0.3856259286403656,
-0.27089357376098633,
0.09350921213626862,
0.086951345205307,
0.6509102582931519,
0.3499945402145386,
-1.0382413864135742,
-0.04495542123913765,
-0.04953011870384216,
-0.004189607221633196,
0.029572945088148117,
1.1789731979370117,
-0.7619937062263489,
0.41086533665657043,
0.3738400638103485,
0.7232000231742859,
0.36277952790260315,
-0.08849366009235382,
0.1063029021024704,
-0.8773788213729858,
0.023076316341757774,
0.07176590710878372,
0.286788672208786,
0.11488725244998932,
-0.19008880853652954,
0.4927558898925781,
0.06945034861564636,
-0.9073961973190308,
-0.6936843395233154,
0.1156943142414093,
-1.2025599479675293,
-0.15898774564266205,
1.3151133060455322,
-0.30820924043655396,
-0.2969166040420532,
-0.07144862413406372,
-0.5126749277114868,
-0.062486253678798676,
-0.855999231338501,
0.7645047307014465,
0.6034036874771118,
-0.323195219039917,
-0.014163403771817684,
-0.23354242742061615,
0.1210973709821701,
0.03627561032772064,
-0.5621029734611511,
0.2583276629447937,
0.5758418440818787,
0.36086055636405945,
0.2771705389022827,
0.3728262782096863,
-0.007153660524636507,
-0.02778463065624237,
0.002779476810246706,
0.16589140892028809,
-0.34703394770622253,
-0.09345142543315887,
0.11147116124629974,
0.23476174473762512,
0.5013351440429688,
-0.000983239384368062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19427v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19427v1
|
Griffin: Mixing Gated Linear Recurrences with Local Attention for Efficient Language Models
| 2024-02-29T18:24:46 | 2024-02-29T18:24:46 |
Soham De, Samuel L. Smith, Anushan Fernando, Aleksandar Botev, George Cristian-Muraru, Albert Gu, Ruba Haroun, Leonard Berrada, Yutian Chen, Srivatsan Srinivasan, Guillaume Desjardins, Arnaud Doucet, David Budden, Yee Whye Teh, Razvan Pascanu, Nando De Freitas, Caglar Gulcehre
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Recurrent neural networks (RNNs) have fast inference and scale efficiently on
long sequences, but they are difficult to train and hard to scale. We propose
Hawk, an RNN with gated linear recurrences, and Griffin, a hybrid model that
mixes gated linear recurrences with local attention. Hawk exceeds the reported
performance of Mamba on downstream tasks, while Griffin matches the performance
of Llama-2 despite being trained on over 6 times fewer tokens. We also show
that Griffin can extrapolate on sequences significantly longer than those seen
during training. Our models match the hardware efficiency of Transformers
during training, and during inference they have lower latency and significantly
higher throughput. We scale Griffin up to 14B parameters, and explain how to
shard our models for efficient distributed training.
|
[
-0.35846567153930664,
-0.6161988973617554,
0.22706009447574615,
0.4769148826599121,
-0.04640805348753929,
0.2891922891139984,
-0.010619412176311016,
-0.4994017779827118,
0.2565264105796814,
0.41114386916160583,
-0.44754382967948914,
0.09297057241201401,
-0.7831130623817444,
0.061411622911691666,
-0.4143112599849701,
0.9991262555122375,
0.08170332759618759,
0.0026932447217404842,
0.22089819610118866,
-0.4411793649196625,
-0.1569606214761734,
-0.6418805122375488,
-0.991460919380188,
-0.6772655844688416,
0.9558039307594299,
-0.007897766306996346,
0.7978050112724304,
0.9261549711227417,
0.588401734828949,
0.3250199258327484,
-0.39268773794174194,
0.2525143623352051,
-0.693428099155426,
0.2502959966659546,
-0.08154170215129852,
-0.2897157073020935,
-0.28778064250946045,
-0.13946162164211273,
0.6321010589599609,
0.89946448802948,
-0.17730681598186493,
0.12409204244613647,
-0.031075360253453255,
0.5958408117294312,
-0.4536283612251282,
0.06057268753647804,
-0.6731498837471008,
0.5314667224884033,
-0.11788331717252731,
0.030193820595741272,
-0.15166252851486206,
-0.3704593777656555,
0.1503492146730423,
-0.5918242931365967,
0.29631057381629944,
0.024304363876581192,
0.6077976822853088,
0.1983427256345749,
-0.19285808503627777,
0.2333422154188156,
-0.8291252255439758,
1.2523552179336548,
-0.7771944403648376,
0.3477088510990143,
-0.037183381617069244,
0.11945194751024246,
-0.527420163154602,
-1.2576404809951782,
-0.6078794598579407,
-0.09467407315969467,
0.12736867368221283,
0.0374913215637207,
-0.41151437163352966,
0.1552092283964157,
0.537006676197052,
0.6528187990188599,
-0.2899104952812195,
-0.05569474771618843,
-0.3410489559173584,
-0.09889301657676697,
0.5409901738166809,
0.2933281660079956,
0.02426193654537201,
0.07881371676921844,
-0.3485550284385681,
-0.0008684989297762513,
-0.3606342673301697,
0.4708058536052704,
0.12980563938617706,
0.4711947441101074,
0.055246494710445404,
0.5408373475074768,
-0.13585032522678375,
0.9416155219078064,
0.5046800971031189,
-0.3378821909427643,
0.16055350005626678,
-0.23024706542491913,
-0.15680432319641113,
-0.1992223560810089,
0.892684280872345,
-0.013408634811639786,
0.12921154499053955,
-0.41941532492637634,
-0.24976111948490143,
-0.016852160915732384,
0.37205934524536133,
-0.5050758719444275,
-0.13219375908374786,
0.18400277197360992,
-0.5865905284881592,
-0.2701399326324463,
-0.13935256004333496,
-0.7479134798049927,
-0.41763758659362793,
-0.46139413118362427,
0.3488655686378479,
0.028371457010507584,
-0.2458205670118332,
0.31777477264404297,
-0.176137775182724,
0.2699528932571411,
0.08516530692577362,
-0.9998369812965393,
0.38510996103286743,
0.9674201607704163,
1.1111708879470825,
-0.05746091529726982,
-0.36603251099586487,
-1.0532939434051514,
-0.1798122525215149,
-0.18066677451133728,
0.5057258605957031,
-0.8061490654945374,
-0.29070645570755005,
-0.23011335730552673,
-0.12600722908973694,
-0.21308930218219757,
-0.49003785848617554,
0.29853489995002747,
-0.36966535449028015,
-0.19238433241844177,
-0.11408593505620956,
-0.2754928469657898,
-0.3945598006248474,
-0.21472148597240448,
-0.6534889340400696,
1.3066871166229248,
0.36460381746292114,
-0.8741326928138733,
0.08442956209182739,
-0.3434491753578186,
-0.8030366897583008,
-0.06466857343912125,
-0.08215220272541046,
-0.31198862195014954,
0.09249123185873032,
0.30018341541290283,
0.5481275320053101,
-0.17205195128917694,
0.2149457037448883,
-0.5797463655471802,
-0.4374779164791107,
0.08236974477767944,
-0.17773830890655518,
0.5065062642097473,
0.5619333982467651,
-0.5489324331283569,
0.20582176744937897,
-0.7574111819267273,
0.029511667788028717,
-0.035167671740055084,
-0.36883416771888733,
0.007659477181732655,
-0.08020006120204926,
-0.21867045760154724,
0.029379907995462418,
0.02322561666369438,
-0.5333606004714966,
0.34488916397094727,
-0.42530789971351624,
0.8394196033477783,
0.4991401433944702,
-0.2089352160692215,
0.5587080121040344,
-0.5301341414451599,
0.8285037875175476,
0.008478053845465183,
0.19198118150234222,
-0.15542499721050262,
-0.7442848086357117,
-0.9175963401794434,
-0.36107948422431946,
0.17214897274971008,
0.4836551547050476,
-0.5412626266479492,
0.22426098585128784,
-0.15676698088645935,
-0.46882903575897217,
-0.6946218609809875,
0.26179251074790955,
0.3090243637561798,
0.3320581614971161,
0.11172357946634293,
-0.5546196103096008,
-0.5811250805854797,
-0.8253958225250244,
-0.41826504468917847,
0.14431960880756378,
-0.034559350460767746,
0.5850164890289307,
0.1440156251192093,
-0.36176663637161255,
0.9001337885856628,
-0.0229605995118618,
-0.028119536116719246,
-0.7326655387878418,
0.47946232557296753,
0.42025622725486755,
0.19381187856197357,
0.18135316669940948,
-0.41649606823921204,
-0.16769343614578247,
0.4101291000843048,
-0.5696136355400085,
-0.009019127115607262,
-0.43651267886161804,
0.1118667796254158,
-0.2264833152294159,
0.3323262929916382,
-0.46942654252052307,
0.23661929368972778,
0.6475932002067566,
0.1601952165365219,
0.021199772134423256,
-0.055745501071214676,
-0.10628527402877808,
-0.8498731851577759,
-0.10530396550893784,
0.19618675112724304,
-0.49119454622268677,
-0.7345482707023621,
0.20365415513515472,
-0.19542363286018372,
-0.34804803133010864,
-0.33010566234588623,
0.28286319971084595,
-0.4043201804161072,
-0.5695704221725464,
-0.33158236742019653,
0.24968954920768738,
0.026574064046144485,
0.7557709813117981,
0.10353929549455643,
0.8316321969032288,
0.4775526225566864,
-0.6880496740341187,
0.6167510747909546,
0.007476813159883022,
-0.27323979139328003,
-0.2327543944120407,
-0.8806899189949036,
0.33110731840133667,
-0.12329299747943878,
0.4295685589313507,
-0.6257996559143066,
0.0196301881223917,
0.16477686166763306,
-0.30142343044281006,
0.26238787174224854,
-0.20168611407279968,
-0.14884573221206665,
-0.5415575504302979,
-0.22956445813179016,
0.7668783664703369,
0.46842148900032043,
-0.7508659958839417,
0.8181660771369934,
0.4024268388748169,
-0.18279050290584564,
-0.6933737993240356,
-0.6615293025970459,
0.10816505551338196,
-0.12957154214382172,
-0.6674584746360779,
0.16857856512069702,
0.5250799655914307,
-0.24403157830238342,
-0.14243517816066742,
0.0596010759472847,
-0.015590391121804714,
-0.032163284718990326,
0.23474115133285522,
-0.29384303092956543,
-0.49005699157714844,
-0.15998174250125885,
-0.2903274893760681,
-0.18095462024211884,
-0.26867225766181946,
-0.47444647550582886,
0.5213754773139954,
-0.38426268100738525,
-0.2559811472892761,
-0.6340996026992798,
0.6120410561561584,
0.755204975605011,
-0.5277425050735474,
0.659749448299408,
0.4690207839012146,
-0.24773922562599182,
-0.359989196062088,
-0.3948562741279602,
-0.2501618564128876,
-0.4377673268318176,
0.24294143915176392,
-0.2988685369491577,
-1.001143217086792,
0.7108793258666992,
-0.1593993604183197,
0.24911515414714813,
0.15892843902111053,
0.24992115795612335,
0.10424375534057617,
1.001922607421875,
0.4474446475505829,
-0.4240086078643799,
0.6063149571418762,
-0.3465997576713562,
0.5875699520111084,
-1.0324153900146484,
-0.15133507549762726,
-0.3673990070819855,
-0.6087379455566406,
-0.532899022102356,
-0.5815862417221069,
-0.018778594210743904,
0.19060547649860382,
-0.4777900278568268,
0.28169772028923035,
-0.5490124225616455,
0.39903292059898376,
0.8145257234573364,
0.009978332556784153,
0.12687049806118011,
0.10058220475912094,
-0.1438465565443039,
-0.01643414795398712,
-1.1187249422073364,
-0.09887232631444931,
0.955374538898468,
0.6865954995155334,
1.1039870977401733,
-0.11153767257928848,
0.4658835530281067,
0.2739581763744354,
0.09738200902938843,
-0.8912560939788818,
0.3495023548603058,
-0.22229066491127014,
-0.19270038604736328,
-0.2583281695842743,
-0.4911976456642151,
-1.0257951021194458,
0.3611365556716919,
-0.06972407549619675,
-0.559848427772522,
0.09672943502664566,
-0.020648762583732605,
-0.6817807555198669,
0.6417821049690247,
-0.36581212282180786,
0.44005468487739563,
-0.026586592197418213,
-0.4264870285987854,
-0.2153892070055008,
-0.41270434856414795,
0.5294930338859558,
0.007561374921351671,
-0.09878943115472794,
0.260477215051651,
0.24842040240764618,
0.5692318677902222,
-0.5621654987335205,
0.828022301197052,
0.10082774609327316,
0.20254839956760406,
0.48597007989883423,
-0.0396721176803112,
0.9233464598655701,
-0.0399172306060791,
0.10890059918165207,
0.30618906021118164,
-0.3685588240623474,
-0.48245304822921753,
-0.7906504273414612,
0.7757112383842468,
-0.8759817481040955,
-0.6855679154396057,
-0.6721570491790771,
-0.666199266910553,
-0.03938402980566025,
-0.23724551498889923,
0.05706081911921501,
0.8126736879348755,
0.5605757832527161,
0.3840237259864807,
0.6293115019798279,
-0.1275710016489029,
0.4186491370201111,
0.0418245829641819,
-0.2983461618423462,
-0.5273749232292175,
0.6148531436920166,
0.09259608387947083,
0.3087030351161957,
0.15623901784420013,
0.13910773396492004,
-0.3240930438041687,
-0.5680338740348816,
-0.37592723965644836,
0.3480824828147888,
-0.4920644164085388,
0.0486893467605114,
-0.8902063965797424,
-0.5940921902656555,
-0.18663865327835083,
-0.1175604984164238,
-0.5304631590843201,
-0.5209188461303711,
-0.22946512699127197,
-0.06482988595962524,
0.6365433931350708,
1.1018692255020142,
-0.12740695476531982,
0.3102094233036041,
-0.7732971906661987,
0.4674229025840759,
0.3712199330329895,
0.3622213900089264,
0.5535216331481934,
-0.9329181909561157,
-0.1126173585653305,
0.02780107408761978,
-0.31073102355003357,
-0.44346773624420166,
0.27463817596435547,
0.22567404806613922,
0.7112062573432922,
0.4915441572666168,
0.05725497379899025,
0.9406121373176575,
-0.5499468445777893,
0.7440881729125977,
0.3124872148036957,
-0.7538454532623291,
0.2115476429462433,
-0.528575599193573,
0.32391563057899475,
0.1742067188024521,
0.1803933084011078,
-0.6936197876930237,
-0.6983597278594971,
-0.32130131125450134,
-0.7163806557655334,
0.6472564339637756,
0.1192733645439148,
0.2710812985897064,
-0.20415127277374268,
0.685255765914917,
0.15687444806098938,
-0.1781366467475891,
-0.7892163395881653,
-0.2828366756439209,
-0.2931463420391083,
-0.18876667320728302,
0.007331819273531437,
-0.17569968104362488,
-0.004360464867204428,
-0.4741744101047516,
0.6233884692192078,
0.0809185728430748,
0.3300793468952179,
0.35557565093040466,
0.12508265674114227,
-0.002120734192430973,
-0.041244588792324066,
0.7796723246574402,
0.5348984599113464,
0.0927545428276062,
-0.100809745490551,
0.13686777651309967,
-0.5922220945358276,
0.23399028182029724,
-0.12681250274181366,
-0.1291762739419937,
0.05962810665369034,
0.29415377974510193,
0.9950960874557495,
0.6189138889312744,
-0.244098961353302,
0.2522249221801758,
-0.10282610356807709,
-0.16742673516273499,
-0.2096448838710785,
0.17803917825222015,
0.17233781516551971,
0.6341773271560669,
0.26734861731529236,
0.2770005762577057,
-0.09182041883468628,
-0.30627238750457764,
0.36799412965774536,
0.3564819097518921,
-0.4705806076526642,
-0.03398492559790611,
0.7620550394058228,
0.562974750995636,
-0.6417000889778137,
0.6520796418190002,
-0.05314706638455391,
-0.5817230939865112,
0.6467140316963196,
0.5704994797706604,
0.8975263833999634,
0.14297416806221008,
0.14680957794189453,
0.5445350408554077,
0.02922617271542549,
-0.3391534090042114,
0.1462516039609909,
-0.24221214652061462,
-0.6129176020622253,
-0.775230348110199,
-0.6698030829429626,
-0.30551594495773315,
0.5504759550094604,
-0.9147508144378662,
-0.09981861710548401,
-0.9320682883262634,
-0.5220119953155518,
-0.03510009124875069,
-0.06041620671749115,
-0.3631787598133087,
-0.14037896692752838,
-0.07420258969068527,
0.9114556908607483,
-0.4795788526535034,
0.7948805093765259,
0.3342265188694,
-0.001674541039392352,
-0.9351474642753601,
-0.24473609030246735,
-0.23824253678321838,
-0.656090259552002,
0.9235959649085999,
0.3020709156990051,
-0.5119050741195679,
0.12661203742027283,
-0.1243942528963089,
-0.9633241295814514,
0.8534964323043823,
0.009039515629410744,
-1.063607931137085,
0.3897874057292938,
-0.047415632754564285,
0.4288806617259979,
-0.4564870595932007,
0.03782281652092934,
0.5550706386566162,
0.07631353288888931,
0.12167883664369583,
-0.8083698749542236,
-0.4292137324810028,
-0.17929218709468842,
0.12785735726356506,
0.44248437881469727,
-0.8102388381958008,
1.0517911911010742,
-0.6077592968940735,
-0.2758125960826874,
0.24873168766498566,
0.986702561378479,
0.31164711713790894,
0.3751193881034851,
0.3767116069793701,
0.7405298948287964,
0.9245656132698059,
-0.14638659358024597,
1.3119676113128662,
-0.20621250569820404,
0.2642883360385895,
1.1276999711990356,
-0.3337406814098358,
0.8810490965843201,
0.4534316062927246,
-0.41765156388282776,
0.4889836609363556,
0.7171379327774048,
0.05152418464422226,
0.5280986428260803,
0.4164884686470032,
-0.6340734362602234,
-0.37873727083206177,
0.022524619475007057,
-0.447726845741272,
0.19697003066539764,
-0.1030270904302597,
-0.33764806389808655,
-0.056170813739299774,
0.12689445912837982,
-0.23160141706466675,
0.24369864165782928,
-0.5410886406898499,
0.7080312967300415,
0.3325636386871338,
-0.687250554561615,
0.6038469672203064,
-0.06935517489910126,
0.7648900747299194,
-0.5732463002204895,
0.06135556101799011,
-0.7172243595123291,
0.4134455621242523,
-0.1693178415298462,
-0.5097261071205139,
0.0014562724390998483,
0.13069696724414825,
-0.43833956122398376,
-0.001338647329248488,
0.381801038980484,
-0.43353450298309326,
-0.7094061970710754,
0.38287848234176636,
-0.09290055185556412,
0.23141098022460938,
0.19093269109725952,
-0.583121657371521,
-0.051634542644023895,
0.007538084872066975,
-0.30393821001052856,
0.3311053216457367,
0.3176162838935852,
-0.10599107295274734,
1.2493325471878052,
0.7769543528556824,
0.282693088054657,
0.5999278426170349,
0.44162219762802124,
0.6392882466316223,
-0.7850644588470459,
-0.40252023935317993,
-0.6328752636909485,
0.16629116237163544,
0.018343793228268623,
-0.21471288800239563,
0.6423090100288391,
0.3297816514968872,
0.6649259328842163,
0.052059005945920944,
0.7552223205566406,
0.38579896092414856,
0.5471171736717224,
-0.3087044358253479,
0.5016362071037292,
-0.42843174934387207,
0.11627350747585297,
0.25901785492897034,
-0.8514657020568848,
-0.18459497392177582,
0.8561661243438721,
-0.0508398674428463,
0.17890317738056183,
0.40514448285102844,
0.7045646905899048,
-0.08037085831165314,
0.2239290475845337,
0.22264830768108368,
0.07926712185144424,
0.24787703156471252,
0.835488498210907,
0.9600034356117249,
-0.49581262469291687,
0.536885142326355,
-0.2225099503993988,
-0.06563412398099899,
-0.14140890538692474,
-0.7946678996086121,
-0.8931944966316223,
-0.30127033591270447,
-0.19313491880893707,
-0.25148072838783264,
0.004503475967794657,
0.7966787815093994,
0.6831715703010559,
-0.9457815289497375,
0.00915928091853857,
-0.2866584360599518,
0.08006991446018219,
-0.37731075286865234,
-0.20417198538780212,
0.03134552389383316,
-0.5845234990119934,
-0.6854829788208008,
0.4354522228240967,
0.42170947790145874,
0.026004817336797714,
-0.3936375379562378,
-0.2724930942058563,
0.08113592863082886,
0.0822451040148735,
0.6170045733451843,
0.6017816662788391,
-1.1910301446914673,
-0.40897199511528015,
0.05168470740318298,
-0.20447275042533875,
0.03379916772246361,
1.1400508880615234,
-0.9535395503044128,
0.5104212760925293,
0.4708811342716217,
1.0925588607788086,
0.621680736541748,
0.22018805146217346,
1.0193020105361938,
-0.4667997658252716,
0.4149346351623535,
0.25244712829589844,
0.3742488920688629,
0.36602771282196045,
-0.2151963710784912,
0.3313951790332794,
0.2014022320508957,
-0.7172759175300598,
-0.750190794467926,
0.2771625518798828,
-0.9828697443008423,
-0.007038183975964785,
1.2761563062667847,
-0.3211529552936554,
-0.1063946932554245,
-0.3436494767665863,
-0.1047641783952713,
0.07468952983617783,
-0.2504274845123291,
0.770166277885437,
0.652411937713623,
-0.16677148640155792,
-0.3831882178783417,
-0.6119608879089355,
0.5138870477676392,
0.4630748927593231,
-0.21353788673877716,
0.14113840460777283,
0.00825791247189045,
0.16835421323776245,
-0.027370451018214226,
0.3540305495262146,
0.09257734566926956,
0.39464640617370605,
0.17780444025993347,
-0.2788102924823761,
-0.26501888036727905,
-0.3612084686756134,
-0.5882643461227417,
-0.01727597415447235,
-0.016854489222168922,
-0.3235922157764435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19411v1
|
PaECTER: Patent-level Representation Learning using Citation-informed Transformers
| 2024-02-29T18:09:03 | 2024-02-29T18:09:03 |
Mainak Ghosh, Sebastian Erhardt, Michael E. Rose, Erik Buunk, Dietmar Harhoff
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
PaECTER is a publicly available, open-source document-level encoder specific
for patents. We fine-tune BERT for Patents with examiner-added citation
information to generate numerical representations for patent documents. PaECTER
performs better in similarity tasks than current state-of-the-art models used
in the patent domain. More specifically, our model outperforms the next-best
patent specific pre-trained language model (BERT for Patents) on our patent
citation prediction test dataset on two different rank evaluation metrics.
PaECTER predicts at least one most similar patent at a rank of 1.32 on average
when compared against 25 irrelevant patents. Numerical representations
generated by PaECTER from patent text can be used for downstream tasks such as
classification, tracing knowledge flows, or semantic similarity search.
Semantic similarity search is especially relevant in the context of prior art
search for both inventors and patent examiners. PaECTER is available on Hugging
Face.
|
[
-0.3867082893848419,
-0.06973638385534286,
0.5237089395523071,
0.485056072473526,
-0.21949993073940277,
0.09307513386011124,
0.2994465231895447,
-0.42429155111312866,
0.2711420953273773,
0.40409305691719055,
-0.08916701376438141,
-0.26895901560783386,
-0.7077390551567078,
-0.01764627732336521,
-0.3914356529712677,
0.7136431932449341,
0.06474043428897858,
0.25013405084609985,
-0.34781840443611145,
0.2946479916572571,
-0.10460896044969559,
-0.5972596406936646,
-0.36739951372146606,
-0.4894481599330902,
0.7627415060997009,
0.07506760954856873,
0.1920160949230194,
0.15446892380714417,
0.7088381052017212,
0.3177829682826996,
-0.16156044602394104,
-0.23683607578277588,
-0.44666576385498047,
0.18820960819721222,
-0.4667741656303406,
-0.43134328722953796,
-0.03460194915533066,
0.1274043619632721,
0.36967381834983826,
0.6997465491294861,
0.2811744213104248,
0.05739356577396393,
0.10354883223772049,
0.571323573589325,
-0.6800076365470886,
0.3802196979522705,
-0.904377818107605,
0.237855464220047,
-0.14442986249923706,
-0.28430646657943726,
-0.7122121453285217,
-0.8170569539070129,
0.5814326405525208,
-0.7333705425262451,
0.3702082931995392,
0.21627458930015564,
1.1006033420562744,
0.1376437544822693,
-0.3581503629684448,
-0.15092730522155762,
-0.4548880457878113,
0.6092954874038696,
-0.17308089137077332,
0.17541053891181946,
-0.03864312916994095,
0.5158137083053589,
-0.13045215606689453,
-1.4155198335647583,
-0.6468491554260254,
-0.057189200073480606,
-0.020512567833065987,
0.018706440925598145,
-0.26762259006500244,
0.13852526247501373,
0.18000535666942596,
0.37953123450279236,
-0.48958465456962585,
-0.003494223579764366,
-0.7309619188308716,
-0.36959129571914673,
0.2171304076910019,
-0.5130348205566406,
0.18623390793800354,
-0.24741485714912415,
-0.6107455492019653,
-0.5263713002204895,
-0.6994771957397461,
-0.1670437753200531,
0.24257907271385193,
0.20886023342609406,
0.5212209224700928,
0.35021743178367615,
0.12732887268066406,
0.47297558188438416,
0.5444109439849854,
0.16645264625549316,
0.6288237571716309,
0.29535529017448425,
-0.27214351296424866,
0.37920665740966797,
0.5969985127449036,
0.013380910269916058,
0.18984809517860413,
-0.24982815980911255,
-0.17108312249183655,
-0.503048837184906,
0.41147685050964355,
-1.04256272315979,
-0.6265016198158264,
-0.06798351556062698,
-0.8469645977020264,
-0.19062629342079163,
0.6177663207054138,
-0.5997337698936462,
-0.7921035885810852,
-0.32792046666145325,
0.6393622159957886,
-0.5267578959465027,
-0.17417407035827637,
-0.10880424827337265,
-0.6117625832557678,
0.5016701221466064,
0.2983275353908539,
-0.7645519971847534,
0.11956389248371124,
0.8013066649436951,
0.7977904677391052,
-0.079474538564682,
-0.3653774559497833,
-0.5732598304748535,
0.014155155047774315,
-0.3870006799697876,
0.9992321133613586,
-0.7184355854988098,
-0.6003273129463196,
-0.04196757450699806,
0.16161507368087769,
-0.3914925456047058,
-0.9125118255615234,
0.6760625243186951,
-0.8156147599220276,
0.31099680066108704,
-0.3998412489891052,
-0.6273718476295471,
-0.1376151442527771,
0.03753094747662544,
-0.8009205460548401,
0.769547164440155,
0.08152613043785095,
-0.8152909874916077,
0.917560338973999,
-0.8692818880081177,
-0.2909209728240967,
0.20852063596248627,
-0.17140579223632812,
-0.5526478290557861,
0.27081814408302307,
0.32946157455444336,
0.32872915267944336,
-0.08708584308624268,
0.16949380934238434,
-0.17625391483306885,
-0.30829405784606934,
0.08724118024110794,
-0.07564996182918549,
0.8968785405158997,
0.44021669030189514,
-0.07099313288927078,
0.38658493757247925,
-0.858849823474884,
-0.29875296354293823,
0.11991849541664124,
-0.16836902499198914,
-0.4126821756362915,
-0.2070169597864151,
0.04887920990586281,
0.29859718680381775,
0.5288673639297485,
-1.074869155883789,
-0.04979661852121353,
-0.535122275352478,
0.29761236906051636,
0.7312034964561462,
0.3239128887653351,
0.5621417164802551,
-0.3624142110347748,
0.4912823736667633,
0.03377842530608177,
0.14400698244571686,
-0.22951987385749817,
-0.649685800075531,
-0.8041806817054749,
-0.2002275437116623,
0.6667091846466064,
0.3638186454772949,
-0.5389364361763,
0.49452105164527893,
-0.43763598799705505,
-0.630782425403595,
-0.6337738633155823,
-0.2744355797767639,
0.21110229194164276,
0.639969527721405,
0.314442902803421,
-0.509535551071167,
-0.5348609685897827,
-1.000725507736206,
-0.21897955238819122,
-0.2716236114501953,
-0.2896827757358551,
0.23799113929271698,
0.46151047945022583,
0.13782981038093567,
0.8773981928825378,
-0.24979524314403534,
-0.42063555121421814,
0.037421777844429016,
0.7596296668052673,
0.507984459400177,
0.5328330397605896,
0.7617297172546387,
-0.9793727993965149,
-0.7243800759315491,
0.1374269425868988,
-0.47473615407943726,
-0.03552364557981491,
-0.1487572193145752,
-0.014902404509484768,
0.06831972301006317,
0.6131935715675354,
-0.40658852458000183,
0.3963155150413513,
0.18087655305862427,
-0.12999773025512695,
0.3062228560447693,
-0.3482036292552948,
0.2048526257276535,
-0.9737131595611572,
0.5151194334030151,
-0.1657969206571579,
0.13022619485855103,
-0.29662665724754333,
0.011055980809032917,
0.3063664138317108,
-0.5356303453445435,
-0.7173861265182495,
0.33291327953338623,
-0.4998316168785095,
-0.1322362869977951,
-0.03505776822566986,
-0.2068837434053421,
0.17334464192390442,
0.17261187732219696,
0.012655469588935375,
1.1083961725234985,
0.6537095308303833,
-0.268598347902298,
0.10495515912771225,
0.23548220098018646,
-0.6521767973899841,
0.5735489726066589,
-0.908679187297821,
0.28859004378318787,
-0.1417207270860672,
0.23005151748657227,
-0.8672599196434021,
-0.10607730597257614,
-0.048103898763656616,
-0.3793907165527344,
0.37923020124435425,
-0.37151119112968445,
-0.741473376750946,
-0.6880568265914917,
-0.33284637331962585,
0.07370799034833908,
0.4271673262119293,
-1.076689600944519,
0.8731245398521423,
0.3038581311702728,
-0.45841851830482483,
-0.6421157121658325,
-0.7461881637573242,
-0.044470854103565216,
-0.14642876386642456,
-0.5399429798126221,
0.8331669569015503,
0.24239780008792877,
0.1415528953075409,
0.013871408998966217,
-0.12136762589216232,
-0.3101500868797302,
-0.3259977698326111,
0.4195232689380646,
0.11041504144668579,
-0.17874571681022644,
0.19927383959293365,
0.19379767775535583,
-0.22573767602443695,
0.26303768157958984,
-0.5608704090118408,
0.6371350288391113,
0.11481450498104095,
-0.5736464262008667,
-0.25604546070098877,
0.10588295012712479,
0.6430275440216064,
-0.24680055677890778,
0.5930215716362,
0.39885854721069336,
-0.28084471821784973,
-0.08686082065105438,
-0.5690358877182007,
0.07995621860027313,
-0.563813328742981,
0.11321598291397095,
-0.6977097988128662,
-0.7787812948226929,
0.5750732421875,
-0.24232730269432068,
-0.14549872279167175,
0.6545127034187317,
0.3104711174964905,
0.12200843542814255,
0.6897705793380737,
0.6872740983963013,
-0.1991928666830063,
0.6401254534721375,
-0.2587023973464966,
0.5675100684165955,
-0.5510427355766296,
-0.693874180316925,
-0.6380090713500977,
-0.42658117413520813,
-0.32868680357933044,
-0.4322299361228943,
0.2862628400325775,
-0.09293617308139801,
-0.5204299092292786,
0.48110079765319824,
-1.0641733407974243,
0.6874076724052429,
1.1061992645263672,
-0.04518771544098854,
0.0010326907504349947,
0.32204753160476685,
-0.3605130910873413,
-0.21507272124290466,
-0.37239333987236023,
-0.3152754008769989,
1.1398528814315796,
0.39969801902770996,
0.7508158087730408,
-0.28841397166252136,
1.0401344299316406,
0.21839962899684906,
-0.029595034196972847,
-0.7075821161270142,
0.3722582161426544,
-0.21198615431785583,
-0.6272275447845459,
0.041408225893974304,
0.0367574617266655,
-0.9893122315406799,
0.16161991655826569,
-0.01881241425871849,
-0.810257077217102,
1.0519520044326782,
-0.017890125513076782,
-0.18720334768295288,
0.3135322332382202,
-0.8281819224357605,
0.8504774570465088,
-0.21845583617687225,
-0.12745976448059082,
-0.2842811644077301,
-0.645447313785553,
-0.12250588089227676,
-0.20317797362804413,
-0.4991271495819092,
0.28767022490501404,
0.15637877583503723,
0.9192373156547546,
-0.559942364692688,
0.7355440855026245,
-0.6295987963676453,
0.040833260864019394,
0.294435977935791,
0.00036441031261347234,
0.39529919624328613,
-0.31296584010124207,
-0.3995009958744049,
-0.09995463490486145,
-0.036777570843696594,
-0.3283239006996155,
-0.5320194959640503,
0.899181604385376,
-0.6631209850311279,
-0.5760415196418762,
-0.7432944774627686,
-0.2575121223926544,
0.06505487114191055,
0.5566527843475342,
0.36012235283851624,
0.004822049755603075,
-0.20875605940818787,
0.27326369285583496,
0.7192766666412354,
-0.49968641996383667,
0.2900981307029724,
0.2982732355594635,
-0.0526239387691021,
-0.4067355692386627,
1.2376638650894165,
0.03776276484131813,
-0.34467068314552307,
0.8390280604362488,
-0.07392468303442001,
-0.39744582772254944,
-0.6387890577316284,
0.05743023008108139,
0.18835203349590302,
-0.9200806617736816,
-0.20313148200511932,
-0.74808669090271,
-0.5574634075164795,
-0.3234884440898895,
-0.21193993091583252,
-0.15758030116558075,
-0.6640229821205139,
-0.2889115810394287,
-0.2593868374824524,
0.24361741542816162,
0.8136284351348877,
-0.09187358617782593,
0.12797364592552185,
-0.35506340861320496,
0.0891580656170845,
0.6783325672149658,
0.4980129897594452,
-0.009066492319107056,
-0.413498193025589,
0.11453098058700562,
-0.4449029862880707,
-0.5334228277206421,
-0.4243699312210083,
0.3697679042816162,
0.30006420612335205,
0.7268593311309814,
0.503494381904602,
0.012123611755669117,
0.5363430380821228,
-0.5058764219284058,
0.9399517178535461,
0.2836371958255768,
-0.8466277122497559,
0.8150591850280762,
-0.06399679183959961,
0.09109426289796829,
0.6014546155929565,
0.5348904132843018,
0.14108872413635254,
-0.07584274560213089,
-0.471064031124115,
-0.9977970123291016,
0.5486071705818176,
-0.031420815736055374,
0.1340406984090805,
-0.07813743501901627,
0.013127458281815052,
0.3295273780822754,
-0.07677451521158218,
-0.6247707605361938,
0.04249686375260353,
-0.5262976884841919,
0.005972384475171566,
0.4631047546863556,
-0.2708956003189087,
0.10855840891599655,
-0.3608943819999695,
0.48708978295326233,
0.20823542773723602,
0.7047541737556458,
0.38453933596611023,
-0.18513920903205872,
0.04962867125868797,
0.12361952662467957,
0.19667989015579224,
0.7972607016563416,
-0.5506603717803955,
0.14359577000141144,
-0.1987060308456421,
-0.49868959188461304,
-0.25754597783088684,
0.8095216155052185,
0.06020144373178482,
0.31302711367607117,
0.1012040451169014,
0.5467395186424255,
0.06027565523982048,
-0.6308218240737915,
0.743261992931366,
-0.07301771640777588,
-0.5617015957832336,
-0.3559839427471161,
-0.1797069013118744,
-0.021828506141901016,
0.24017773568630219,
0.865447461605072,
0.3394891023635864,
0.4721696376800537,
-0.24470509588718414,
0.4377579092979431,
0.0729345977306366,
-0.6141394376754761,
-0.1301090121269226,
0.8671349883079529,
0.40577709674835205,
-0.04044073820114136,
0.3934096097946167,
-0.10980221629142761,
-0.4822981059551239,
0.6713744401931763,
0.5300598740577698,
0.9168655276298523,
-0.027559546753764153,
0.16943036019802094,
0.3646028935909271,
0.021942701190710068,
0.09139947593212128,
0.1208495944738388,
-0.2996222674846649,
-0.37480559945106506,
-0.2959953546524048,
-0.5088807940483093,
-0.5543060898780823,
0.08146997541189194,
-0.5362554788589478,
0.26543277502059937,
-0.6116823554039001,
-0.1427619457244873,
0.3109988570213318,
-0.11702808737754822,
-0.7539317011833191,
-0.07589951902627945,
0.12029264867305756,
1.27324378490448,
-0.5131399631500244,
0.966948926448822,
0.7200496196746826,
-0.8493223190307617,
-0.5537428259849548,
0.1616462767124176,
-0.19212472438812256,
-0.7242016792297363,
1.2417150735855103,
0.14612217247486115,
-0.09485381841659546,
-0.17194850742816925,
-0.42914634943008423,
-0.84452223777771,
1.140449047088623,
0.5282770991325378,
-0.46211642026901245,
-0.10675392299890518,
0.018057888373732567,
0.5271335244178772,
-0.48920953273773193,
0.14167006313800812,
0.28610795736312866,
0.3329959809780121,
0.2428661584854126,
-0.9963738322257996,
-0.10916627943515778,
-0.6743817925453186,
0.2019745111465454,
0.015403011813759804,
-0.15604601800441742,
0.78520268201828,
0.0487961620092392,
-0.15157094597816467,
0.2998349368572235,
0.5737135410308838,
0.3321823477745056,
0.3386380076408386,
0.3289407193660736,
0.4519732892513275,
0.856339693069458,
-0.18912528455257416,
1.088256597518921,
-0.5246525406837463,
0.09401316195726395,
1.1022709608078003,
-0.2795135974884033,
0.9084833264350891,
0.5748857855796814,
-0.13176611065864563,
0.8020032048225403,
0.4624675214290619,
-0.4088125228881836,
0.8484144806861877,
0.24251240491867065,
-0.20418593287467957,
0.18898485600948334,
-0.20437653362751007,
-0.5931469202041626,
0.02941814996302128,
0.21743276715278625,
-1.1096727848052979,
-0.017660165205597878,
0.009914943017065525,
-0.2995763123035431,
0.225297212600708,
-0.01535902451723814,
0.8183020949363708,
-0.02686762623488903,
-0.509718120098114,
0.5049482583999634,
-0.3530425429344177,
0.6743316650390625,
-0.3885139524936676,
-0.1284550577402115,
0.07023098319768906,
0.3508899211883545,
0.00614523608237505,
-0.8283721208572388,
0.0949954017996788,
-0.1730256825685501,
-0.19994477927684784,
-0.39454370737075806,
1.0303094387054443,
-0.07681472599506378,
-0.4380456805229187,
0.42785176634788513,
0.22125299274921417,
0.21914057433605194,
-0.19391568005084991,
-0.5404495000839233,
-0.11827336251735687,
-0.15738452970981598,
-0.030255258083343506,
0.2392711043357849,
0.689752459526062,
0.18843711912631989,
0.6765250563621521,
0.37143856287002563,
0.08828780055046082,
0.2510733902454376,
0.5395753979682922,
1.1223866939544678,
-0.4467380940914154,
-0.43217962980270386,
-0.04581638053059578,
0.3444914221763611,
-0.684406578540802,
-0.3559759855270386,
0.4297850728034973,
0.9179661870002747,
0.9046036005020142,
-0.5493656992912292,
0.9516924023628235,
-0.2083248496055603,
0.7390787601470947,
-0.016530433669686317,
0.8329750895500183,
-0.0832824632525444,
0.15208888053894043,
-0.35108837485313416,
-1.082200288772583,
-0.6738554239273071,
0.8493204712867737,
-0.655323326587677,
-0.11153606325387955,
0.5951763987541199,
0.806867778301239,
-0.4649769961833954,
-0.10223716497421265,
0.04761888086795807,
-0.0026167312171310186,
0.4825349748134613,
0.3674538731575012,
0.7606948018074036,
-0.5186459422111511,
0.7667917013168335,
-0.3266013264656067,
-0.08350217342376709,
-0.1494019776582718,
-0.6823501586914062,
-0.9875882267951965,
-0.745449960231781,
-0.15833841264247894,
-0.02903178334236145,
0.15101827681064606,
0.7965691089630127,
0.9745490550994873,
-1.1334154605865479,
0.0481458343565464,
-0.36243852972984314,
-0.07799765467643738,
-0.009725742042064667,
-0.3110094964504242,
0.617519199848175,
-0.5340126156806946,
-0.7144414782524109,
0.20801866054534912,
0.30758604407310486,
-0.18405643105506897,
-0.06417008489370346,
-0.06823325902223587,
-0.07145926356315613,
-0.07965464144945145,
0.6591114401817322,
0.4358519911766052,
-0.7394741177558899,
-0.2906440496444702,
-0.07314309477806091,
0.09317857027053833,
0.1547965407371521,
0.9569920301437378,
-1.0764141082763672,
0.9174275994300842,
0.9107088446617126,
0.7022575736045837,
0.741516649723053,
0.015664152801036835,
0.7678327560424805,
-0.6166515350341797,
0.3112693130970001,
0.4323504865169525,
0.6143746376037598,
0.32632923126220703,
-0.11258721351623535,
0.36557820439338684,
-0.05044151842594147,
-0.6841562390327454,
-0.485296368598938,
-0.031908564269542694,
-1.1346749067306519,
-0.32211756706237793,
0.4934629201889038,
-0.3591640293598175,
-0.2476395219564438,
-0.07256245613098145,
-0.3713408410549164,
0.026904772967100143,
-0.8196761608123779,
0.8719590902328491,
0.25422579050064087,
-0.11886351555585861,
-0.358974426984787,
0.1941944807767868,
0.16852879524230957,
0.0788436308503151,
-0.3014225661754608,
-0.3791942000389099,
0.10712254792451859,
0.10666237026453018,
0.7328367829322815,
0.31271377205848694,
-0.6817575097084045,
0.27401477098464966,
0.18815720081329346,
0.22378483414649963,
-0.13283774256706238,
-0.31176331639289856,
-0.06923910230398178,
0.581779420375824,
0.4230425953865051,
-0.45491233468055725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19406v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19406v2
|
On the Scaling Laws of Geographical Representation in Language Models
| 2024-02-29T18:04:11 | 2024-03-04T11:35:02 |
Nathan Godey, Éric de la Clergerie, Benoît Sagot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language models have long been shown to embed geographical information in
their hidden representations. This line of work has recently been revisited by
extending this result to Large Language Models (LLMs). In this paper, we
propose to fill the gap between well-established and recent literature by
observing how geographical knowledge evolves when scaling language models. We
show that geographical knowledge is observable even for tiny models, and that
it scales consistently as we increase the model size. Notably, we observe that
larger language models cannot mitigate the geographical bias that is inherent
to the training data.
|
[
-0.40432146191596985,
-0.3142324388027191,
1.0849981307983398,
0.0945359319448471,
-0.028783243149518967,
-0.44072702527046204,
-0.8420765399932861,
-0.6572091579437256,
0.25169801712036133,
0.8887587189674377,
-0.25685450434684753,
-0.3365550637245178,
-0.8761311769485474,
-0.26414209604263306,
-0.13248290121555328,
0.7028124332427979,
-0.03962279111146927,
0.14968685805797577,
-0.139694944024086,
-0.6675159335136414,
0.032233063131570816,
-0.8151434063911438,
-0.23668773472309113,
-0.6768103241920471,
0.3213299810886383,
0.4052950441837311,
0.9948710203170776,
1.05903160572052,
0.35880982875823975,
0.1912207305431366,
-0.4726260006427765,
-0.021711690351366997,
-0.4594084620475769,
0.2734779417514801,
-0.09392419457435608,
-0.9159025549888611,
-0.08588366210460663,
-0.06995834410190582,
1.1279970407485962,
0.9961957931518555,
-0.3105058968067169,
0.03363196924328804,
-0.06752454489469528,
0.4906517565250397,
-0.3272338807582855,
0.4325973093509674,
-0.6749534010887146,
-0.05731484293937683,
-0.16498754918575287,
0.1895081251859665,
-0.4452420473098755,
-0.2944335341453552,
0.28554338216781616,
-0.3658556044101715,
0.2132825255393982,
0.21788717806339264,
0.6739016771316528,
0.14978303015232086,
-0.8037773966789246,
-0.30619269609451294,
-0.8625445365905762,
0.7776662111282349,
-0.6146636605262756,
0.36620762944221497,
0.5352611541748047,
0.5464944839477539,
0.026399852707982063,
-0.3264034688472748,
-0.2301449030637741,
-0.50548255443573,
-0.186593160033226,
-0.48403269052505493,
-0.2489718794822693,
-0.27583661675453186,
0.43004024028778076,
0.34941864013671875,
-0.16661375761032104,
0.5542764663696289,
-0.21499726176261902,
0.1212872862815857,
0.5569772720336914,
0.02907400019466877,
0.5543782711029053,
0.030913719907402992,
0.021530764177441597,
0.07136887311935425,
-1.3079370260238647,
-0.06787022203207016,
0.16971498727798462,
0.5687212944030762,
-0.3701310455799103,
0.6698769330978394,
0.07382939010858536,
0.5733466148376465,
-0.029311442747712135,
0.08434827625751495,
0.026892200112342834,
0.2782651484012604,
-0.08860927075147629,
-0.026314683258533478,
0.6877213716506958,
0.2147108018398285,
0.5791264176368713,
-0.028582697734236717,
0.010237010195851326,
-0.5918524861335754,
0.00990153755992651,
-0.7315313816070557,
-0.2935875356197357,
-0.41927140951156616,
-0.18212369084358215,
0.05097799003124237,
0.06972631812095642,
-0.4649249017238617,
-0.7164560556411743,
-0.0002955968084279448,
-0.09719981998205185,
-0.017427196726202965,
-0.6117700338363647,
-0.04742369055747986,
0.07015181332826614,
0.3386295437812805,
0.11162028461694717,
-1.3614901304244995,
0.20136658847332,
0.8729346394538879,
0.6553279161453247,
0.5644243955612183,
-0.21633097529411316,
-0.06483463197946548,
0.08663532882928848,
-0.6524790525436401,
0.49745529890060425,
-0.5349776148796082,
-0.16075466573238373,
0.27770721912384033,
0.2488223910331726,
0.22494305670261383,
-0.7322242259979248,
0.12340644747018814,
-0.9603196382522583,
-0.16362743079662323,
-0.4830343723297119,
-0.29863160848617554,
-0.1827094405889511,
0.2071053385734558,
-0.8155213594436646,
1.0170135498046875,
0.043570972979068756,
-0.5511174201965332,
0.5537712574005127,
-0.4121624529361725,
-0.11484082788228989,
-0.03585391491651535,
-0.14388006925582886,
-0.41864463686943054,
0.5917446613311768,
0.5076389908790588,
0.29490891098976135,
-0.28488636016845703,
0.16959401965141296,
-0.6277379989624023,
0.02505880407989025,
0.14683382213115692,
-0.2739802598953247,
0.8550401329994202,
0.04388220235705376,
-0.2674778997898102,
-0.27560955286026,
-0.4799215495586395,
-0.16535627841949463,
0.27398839592933655,
-0.49536779522895813,
-0.6352711915969849,
0.1445724368095398,
-0.4167112112045288,
-0.12124621123075485,
0.29450392723083496,
-0.5003281235694885,
0.46518027782440186,
-0.4695359766483307,
0.4562901258468628,
0.4489966630935669,
-0.07482567429542542,
1.124570369720459,
0.07305984199047089,
0.5584430694580078,
-0.08325284719467163,
-0.22089532017707825,
-0.0011387885315343738,
-0.5390985608100891,
-0.6822000741958618,
-0.055086005479097366,
0.26742005348205566,
0.09647305309772491,
-0.3680599629878998,
0.1137683093547821,
-0.8549683690071106,
-0.5867971181869507,
-0.2280855029821396,
0.172398179769516,
-0.24115264415740967,
-0.12584589421749115,
0.0005809284630231559,
0.08345040678977966,
-0.5474796295166016,
-0.6279804110527039,
-0.46468281745910645,
-0.19911491870880127,
-0.3519614040851593,
0.6220290660858154,
0.35265496373176575,
-0.24982047080993652,
0.9188084602355957,
-0.43680551648139954,
0.02352006547152996,
-0.3673843443393707,
-0.0024825981818139553,
0.13464757800102234,
0.29312023520469666,
1.0514752864837646,
-0.6379406452178955,
-0.525820255279541,
0.3098856806755066,
-0.7442994713783264,
-0.3320201635360718,
0.3260573744773865,
0.13444799184799194,
-0.058331504464149475,
0.5219421982765198,
-0.5400916934013367,
0.21430836617946625,
0.7989377975463867,
-0.4655040502548218,
0.20982182025909424,
-0.7058623433113098,
-0.15819670259952545,
-0.7988375425338745,
-0.5570690035820007,
0.1603524535894394,
-0.5613187551498413,
-0.5277106761932373,
0.43793684244155884,
0.38747939467430115,
-0.10185037553310394,
-0.08879227936267853,
0.6743646860122681,
-0.7041623592376709,
-0.29878535866737366,
-0.3250212073326111,
0.22768959403038025,
-0.17095501720905304,
-0.019968781620264053,
0.24574534595012665,
0.45015254616737366,
0.796249270439148,
-0.462711900472641,
0.13765017688274384,
-0.17137107253074646,
-0.5860347151756287,
0.3545083999633789,
-0.3860313296318054,
-0.23162277042865753,
-0.2770589292049408,
0.2168889045715332,
-0.7706835269927979,
-0.3516188859939575,
-0.2956525981426239,
-0.09388145804405212,
0.33968302607536316,
-0.7072417140007019,
-0.6971278786659241,
-0.40135517716407776,
-0.047739531844854355,
0.42993873357772827,
0.7440539002418518,
-0.888414204120636,
0.5358698964118958,
0.694582998752594,
-0.09988423436880112,
-0.12219914048910141,
-0.9421992897987366,
-0.00589798204600811,
-0.5667667984962463,
-0.439223974943161,
-0.28450697660446167,
0.2578895390033722,
-0.6205649375915527,
-0.02979743853211403,
0.08578761667013168,
-0.22253312170505524,
-0.07049939036369324,
0.3285837173461914,
-0.2413940578699112,
-0.5318126678466797,
0.28805872797966003,
-0.21437278389930725,
0.38918212056159973,
0.5229665637016296,
-0.7393649816513062,
0.43417081236839294,
0.01359065156430006,
-0.23255346715450287,
0.03547534719109535,
-0.06850935518741608,
0.844554603099823,
-0.07694223523139954,
0.9914122223854065,
0.1408047080039978,
-0.41404345631599426,
-0.2279558777809143,
-0.4148690700531006,
0.12233757972717285,
-0.4734293520450592,
0.40173736214637756,
-0.3749411702156067,
-1.0226376056671143,
0.8970796465873718,
-0.3739601671695709,
-0.12767437100410461,
0.7780088782310486,
0.6363529562950134,
-0.14496006071567535,
0.8711874485015869,
1.142527461051941,
-0.35208413004875183,
0.5734800100326538,
-0.20501945912837982,
0.1708284616470337,
-0.8725124001502991,
-0.04571235552430153,
-0.6412661075592041,
-0.243277445435524,
-1.140980839729309,
-0.797870934009552,
0.38999125361442566,
0.26491913199424744,
-0.8392043709754944,
0.15247328579425812,
0.059122536331415176,
0.8004348278045654,
0.42209985852241516,
0.07681389153003693,
0.021463101729750633,
0.29332825541496277,
-0.19139724969863892,
-0.35015103220939636,
-0.9660797715187073,
-0.3102988600730896,
1.3253127336502075,
0.6125679612159729,
0.9021910429000854,
0.44591617584228516,
0.5769839882850647,
0.14508004486560822,
0.6421385407447815,
-0.6365249156951904,
0.3452168405056,
-0.17757420241832733,
-0.5081070065498352,
-0.46554431319236755,
-0.6032868027687073,
-0.9700158834457397,
0.27424976229667664,
0.1180325448513031,
-0.7652298212051392,
0.23246820271015167,
-0.10438457131385803,
-0.1388086974620819,
0.8247511386871338,
-0.40373560786247253,
0.32845938205718994,
-0.1397278606891632,
-0.010024558752775192,
-0.16042466461658478,
-0.3519558310508728,
0.12617704272270203,
-0.07684202492237091,
0.5535088777542114,
-0.08144199103116989,
-0.03269771486520767,
0.8035848140716553,
-0.7382848262786865,
0.9537122249603271,
-0.32381460070610046,
-0.3943701982498169,
0.45877909660339355,
0.3166787922382355,
0.5215093493461609,
0.014344057999551296,
0.012059052474796772,
0.21826252341270447,
-0.3374023139476776,
-0.6229385733604431,
-0.7138679623603821,
0.9516175389289856,
-0.9861228466033936,
-0.6911677718162537,
-0.12911434471607208,
-0.6617171168327332,
0.005373361520469189,
0.18768492341041565,
0.09551577270030975,
0.10136907547712326,
0.023100147023797035,
0.1530802696943283,
0.857435941696167,
-0.07067716866731644,
0.2432832419872284,
0.5788319110870361,
-0.6579380035400391,
-0.16535645723342896,
0.4068320095539093,
0.5293034315109253,
0.4077129065990448,
0.231807678937912,
0.5159831047058105,
-0.24594323337078094,
-0.43640464544296265,
-0.28931155800819397,
0.6674996614456177,
-0.9126796722412109,
0.06056438758969307,
-0.2516879737377167,
-0.21700450778007507,
-0.22175051271915436,
-0.20549553632736206,
-0.3114086389541626,
-0.5526663661003113,
-0.03775322437286377,
-0.29791030287742615,
0.6310566663742065,
1.420093297958374,
-0.3976127505302429,
0.6498091816902161,
-0.3583205044269562,
-0.1601221114397049,
0.24269087612628937,
0.3510156273841858,
0.03931472823023796,
-0.8838487863540649,
-0.5389694571495056,
0.19986997544765472,
0.11174753308296204,
-0.6870326995849609,
0.5000033378601074,
-0.06849879026412964,
0.43994441628456116,
0.5913952589035034,
-0.2087990641593933,
0.57079017162323,
-0.827415943145752,
0.9048030376434326,
-0.06948759406805038,
-0.5753117799758911,
0.39343056082725525,
-0.3738342821598053,
0.6251969337463379,
-0.1422077864408493,
0.5784205198287964,
-0.32656940817832947,
-0.710983395576477,
-0.5524807572364807,
-0.6607705950737,
0.3143244981765747,
-0.48546329140663147,
0.6213489770889282,
0.1695692539215088,
0.6633872389793396,
-0.05409493297338486,
-0.08714735507965088,
-1.0917521715164185,
0.005192913115024567,
0.19895489513874054,
-0.07458831369876862,
-0.4293534457683563,
-0.7144617438316345,
-0.168643519282341,
-0.28782185912132263,
0.25832828879356384,
0.05951601266860962,
0.18948134779930115,
-0.17855608463287354,
-0.2548516094684601,
-0.12984934449195862,
0.1853276640176773,
0.5410094857215881,
0.7672877907752991,
0.06060267612338066,
0.5344639420509338,
0.20833007991313934,
-0.5801841616630554,
0.1230773776769638,
-0.1872899979352951,
-0.1570388376712799,
-0.016825005412101746,
0.6172551512718201,
0.628702700138092,
0.33861008286476135,
-0.42586758732795715,
0.2629026770591736,
0.21295033395290375,
-0.1459423005580902,
-0.3447551131248474,
-0.07732367515563965,
0.31486278772354126,
0.565039873123169,
0.3796965479850769,
-0.13550132513046265,
-0.5026307702064514,
-0.6431182622909546,
-0.10972974449396133,
0.3062073886394501,
-0.4400627017021179,
-0.44651705026626587,
0.7860036492347717,
-0.19845375418663025,
-0.1560773402452469,
0.7331961393356323,
-0.18447935581207275,
-0.8059336543083191,
0.6229366660118103,
0.5114745497703552,
0.3126599192619324,
-0.23147520422935486,
-0.004731548950076103,
0.43918347358703613,
0.7527263760566711,
-0.32146188616752625,
0.059917666018009186,
-0.09560229629278183,
-0.7487579584121704,
-0.16880863904953003,
-0.4536741375923157,
-0.15603815019130707,
-0.09407086670398712,
-0.5504589080810547,
0.04778197035193443,
-0.4985893964767456,
-0.16995207965373993,
-0.24076591432094574,
0.02987404353916645,
-0.7692866325378418,
0.010878590866923332,
0.3820749819278717,
0.9440083503723145,
-1.0948750972747803,
0.9860091209411621,
0.5190091729164124,
-0.05114402249455452,
-0.7168950438499451,
0.10830239206552505,
-0.05615818127989769,
-1.1379636526107788,
0.9779609441757202,
-0.00460582971572876,
0.09558147192001343,
-0.2632272243499756,
-0.6913251280784607,
-1.0703033208847046,
0.9800792336463928,
0.45767056941986084,
-0.5508888959884644,
0.048613905906677246,
0.4211355447769165,
0.8158568143844604,
-0.6985952854156494,
0.020840398967266083,
0.3786941170692444,
0.2101898044347763,
0.006166201084852219,
-0.9923336505889893,
-0.01889912039041519,
0.41309118270874023,
0.27135545015335083,
0.149261012673378,
-0.4793355166912079,
1.0106385946273804,
-0.5418175458908081,
-0.07389945536851883,
-0.1250503659248352,
0.5746461153030396,
-0.01713285595178604,
-0.15095853805541992,
0.2640441954135895,
0.8312738537788391,
1.0108848810195923,
-0.2693576216697693,
1.161254644393921,
-0.31670069694519043,
0.6771488785743713,
1.202152967453003,
-0.3063334822654724,
0.9863426685333252,
0.262597918510437,
-0.27114588022232056,
0.7852551341056824,
0.721712589263916,
0.009544317610561848,
0.6329744458198547,
0.40359318256378174,
-0.30744749307632446,
-0.2542738914489746,
0.10666593164205551,
-0.19494761526584625,
0.4860054552555084,
0.33247971534729004,
-0.7471463680267334,
-0.5270597338676453,
0.13238117098808289,
0.40041571855545044,
0.12125333398580551,
-0.8689361214637756,
0.6782155632972717,
0.00977934431284666,
-0.2771075963973999,
0.5739739537239075,
-0.012487206608057022,
0.25265899300575256,
-0.5108081102371216,
0.25208255648612976,
-0.29987668991088867,
0.00745359668508172,
0.06336374580860138,
-1.014534592628479,
0.29854264855384827,
0.08387909829616547,
-0.29637181758880615,
-0.26493969559669495,
0.5157889723777771,
-0.5037585496902466,
-0.5856166481971741,
0.34585195779800415,
0.3768160939216614,
0.3058728277683258,
-0.1191611960530281,
-0.062296658754348755,
0.11494634300470352,
-0.08436176925897598,
-0.3916991353034973,
0.4008207619190216,
1.0315121412277222,
-0.29153525829315186,
0.8862130045890808,
0.12481795251369476,
0.574908435344696,
0.5426795482635498,
-0.045200444757938385,
0.622179388999939,
-0.5563323497772217,
-0.5257512331008911,
-1.0628236532211304,
0.0121315224096179,
-0.1634003221988678,
0.40317919850349426,
0.9481054544448853,
0.4660135805606842,
0.6876106858253479,
0.08455254882574081,
0.6252389550209045,
0.12128757685422897,
0.15150414407253265,
-0.2783133089542389,
0.9572811722755432,
-0.29247844219207764,
0.3971931040287018,
0.5232890844345093,
-0.8652486205101013,
-0.4542994499206543,
0.5396711826324463,
-0.9373290538787842,
0.11869856715202332,
0.4383888244628906,
0.5260249376296997,
-0.12652067840099335,
-0.24928539991378784,
0.368577778339386,
0.527065634727478,
0.23868365585803986,
0.37656906247138977,
0.6785269379615784,
-0.045266542583703995,
0.09778504073619843,
0.06451740115880966,
-0.29178497195243835,
-0.14895448088645935,
-0.814540684223175,
-0.8254602551460266,
-0.5138388276100159,
-0.2042331099510193,
-0.303814172744751,
-0.35813653469085693,
0.4045089781284332,
0.8835857510566711,
-0.5059904456138611,
-0.43998751044273376,
0.08017818629741669,
0.35915136337280273,
-0.034999363124370575,
-0.1898747831583023,
0.20575633645057678,
-0.08017009496688843,
-0.5894041657447815,
0.10359995812177658,
0.2125520408153534,
0.381145179271698,
-0.7112048268318176,
0.013627994805574417,
0.11640505492687225,
0.24907122552394867,
0.5942409634590149,
0.3969220817089081,
-0.6468295454978943,
-0.5565516352653503,
-0.42468446493148804,
-0.19357845187187195,
0.18388596177101135,
0.9586813449859619,
-0.5941283106803894,
0.5285705924034119,
0.23047517240047455,
0.4488242566585541,
0.75841224193573,
-0.5157865285873413,
0.5942708253860474,
-0.8951708674430847,
0.3270167112350464,
-0.12826727330684662,
0.617918074131012,
0.425081342458725,
-0.27599000930786133,
0.3230750560760498,
-0.050072282552719116,
-0.7139192223548889,
-0.7075001001358032,
0.32590779662132263,
-0.4320513904094696,
-0.08461447060108185,
1.2856292724609375,
-0.4418526589870453,
-0.3084954619407654,
0.326212614774704,
0.24926607310771942,
-0.20578080415725708,
0.1656663864850998,
0.6616170406341553,
1.0635212659835815,
-0.04636351764202118,
-0.37304216623306274,
-0.8160765171051025,
0.3073241412639618,
0.020112132653594017,
-0.36148354411125183,
0.5134413242340088,
0.3887229263782501,
0.7060881853103638,
0.1932096928358078,
0.5154873132705688,
-0.04556868225336075,
-0.3389747738838196,
0.07204291969537735,
-0.3424992561340332,
0.38586848974227905,
-0.2597867548465729,
-0.6634333729743958,
0.2943840026855469,
0.6152088046073914,
0.3624873161315918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19404v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19404v4
|
EAMA : Entity-Aware Multimodal Alignment Based Approach for News Image Captioning
| 2024-02-29T18:03:00 | 2024-05-06T14:41:56 |
Junzhe Zhang, Huixuan Zhang, Xunjian Yin, Xiaojun Wan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
News image captioning requires model to generate an informative caption rich
in entities, with the news image and the associated news article. Though
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capabilities in addressing various vision-language tasks, our research finds
that current MLLMs still bear limitations in handling entity information on
news image captioning task. Besides, while MLLMs have the ability to process
long inputs, generating high-quality news image captions still requires a
trade-off between sufficiency and conciseness of textual input information. To
explore the potential of MLLMs and address problems we discovered, we propose :
an Entity-Aware Multimodal Alignment based approach for news image captioning.
Our approach first aligns the MLLM through Balance Training Strategy with two
extra alignment tasks: Entity-Aware Sentence Selection task and Entity
Selection task, together with News Image Captioning task, to enhance its
capability in handling multimodal entity information. The aligned MLLM will
utilizes the additional entity-related information it explicitly extracts to
supplement its textual input while generating news image captions. Our approach
achieves better results than all previous models in CIDEr score on GoodNews
dataset (72.33 -> 88.39) and NYTimes800k dataset (70.83 -> 85.61).
|
[
-0.49268975853919983,
-0.5689403414726257,
0.5075268745422363,
0.1744319498538971,
-0.44128623604774475,
0.024378124624490738,
-0.04747619852423668,
-0.672183632850647,
0.392437219619751,
0.33677205443382263,
-0.4602791666984558,
-0.2528337836265564,
-0.624457836151123,
0.08920777589082718,
-0.4222813546657562,
0.9669625759124756,
-0.3367154002189636,
0.3934328854084015,
-0.49291014671325684,
-0.568652331829071,
-0.5135956406593323,
0.008516690693795681,
-0.5317769646644592,
0.28251421451568604,
0.5806396007537842,
0.2897421419620514,
0.7257619500160217,
0.7949340343475342,
0.834328830242157,
0.24113096296787262,
0.4256136119365692,
0.5475128293037415,
0.028018563985824585,
0.007460544351488352,
-0.10754555463790894,
-0.2508157193660736,
-0.45411327481269836,
-0.04575362056493759,
0.6109582185745239,
0.36629441380500793,
-0.1478198915719986,
0.2069692611694336,
-0.20498116314411163,
0.6657602190971375,
-0.583716094493866,
0.11113537847995758,
-0.6798404455184937,
-0.06108248233795166,
-0.09819097816944122,
-0.2917015850543976,
-0.4157535433769226,
0.2605837285518646,
-0.18263652920722961,
-0.8349698185920715,
-0.08616460859775543,
0.5910297632217407,
1.1681386232376099,
0.3830527365207672,
-0.8260176777839661,
-0.18579412996768951,
-0.4076290726661682,
0.7380825877189636,
-0.5673299431800842,
0.6266635656356812,
-0.08572621643543243,
0.24194838106632233,
0.23942643404006958,
-0.3560958504676819,
-0.9011613726615906,
-0.05727216973900795,
-0.11968687176704407,
0.12894093990325928,
0.0026028971187770367,
-0.05913309380412102,
0.11186932772397995,
0.16267743706703186,
-0.5408643484115601,
0.10822506248950958,
-0.2549930810928345,
-0.15938226878643036,
0.5821037292480469,
0.0737379789352417,
0.5238431096076965,
-0.12216006964445114,
-0.8848983645439148,
0.15283851325511932,
-0.5983158946037292,
0.02292237989604473,
0.20146161317825317,
0.050761375576257706,
-0.07525314390659332,
0.9231851100921631,
-0.08796506375074387,
0.737267017364502,
0.06012711673974991,
-0.3289739787578583,
0.3948564827442169,
-0.3484559655189514,
-0.2256174236536026,
0.05435756593942642,
0.6898858547210693,
1.0036534070968628,
-0.062120065093040466,
-0.11084455251693726,
-0.36746132373809814,
0.02706536278128624,
0.2957303524017334,
-0.6422844529151917,
0.12269850820302963,
0.19561336934566498,
-0.5142994523048401,
-0.1557486355304718,
0.29429149627685547,
-0.9750753045082092,
-0.33719170093536377,
-0.6063533425331116,
0.5761624574661255,
-0.15931423008441925,
-0.04565824195742607,
-0.17973142862319946,
0.024509241804480553,
0.21417714655399323,
0.4748668372631073,
-0.7224518060684204,
-0.012561597861349583,
0.27636998891830444,
0.7379225492477417,
-0.38024038076400757,
-0.3369702100753784,
-0.692846417427063,
0.6317421197891235,
-0.05364782363176346,
0.6337020397186279,
-0.4676755964756012,
0.38409557938575745,
-0.14815153181552887,
0.05352284386754036,
-0.029074976220726967,
-0.09969455748796463,
0.505615234375,
-0.7227827906608582,
0.1765877604484558,
-0.06918054074048996,
-0.5900257229804993,
-0.1609383523464203,
0.3435029983520508,
-1.1022013425827026,
0.4448384940624237,
-0.19836923480033875,
-0.9046962857246399,
0.5442918539047241,
-0.6263279318809509,
-0.5815433859825134,
-0.2985802888870239,
-0.15990352630615234,
-0.6449386477470398,
-0.008631587959825993,
0.7997302412986755,
0.43882906436920166,
-0.04618123546242714,
0.40103229880332947,
-0.34019193053245544,
-0.0531088188290596,
0.2145562469959259,
-0.545883297920227,
0.582783043384552,
0.32990762591362,
-0.3570210635662079,
0.11100716888904572,
-0.5707904100418091,
-0.12138493359088898,
0.15075580775737762,
-0.23863942921161652,
-0.3377765715122223,
-0.03541058674454689,
0.2913588583469391,
0.3909590542316437,
0.23977793753147125,
-0.5079275369644165,
0.2234416902065277,
0.0754215270280838,
0.2666880786418915,
0.5592876672744751,
-0.13321435451507568,
0.7240864634513855,
-0.31947484612464905,
0.2869652807712555,
0.31966471672058105,
0.15627634525299072,
-0.645928680896759,
-0.2757551074028015,
-0.7843308448791504,
-0.41390544176101685,
0.39068153500556946,
0.5723963379859924,
-1.073195457458496,
0.23295091092586517,
-0.3578195571899414,
-0.25925201177597046,
-0.7548476457595825,
0.31351354718208313,
0.2897109091281891,
0.46992138028144836,
0.43379703164100647,
-0.43730077147483826,
-0.5523520112037659,
-1.154340386390686,
-0.09166841208934784,
0.1382676661014557,
0.40724748373031616,
0.22091370820999146,
0.19107341766357422,
-0.005442459136247635,
0.6454675793647766,
-0.1702195405960083,
-0.5910840630531311,
0.08615434914827347,
0.1083931103348732,
-0.2146589308977127,
0.5439667105674744,
0.5802221894264221,
-1.2738659381866455,
-0.1551961898803711,
-0.061346106231212616,
-0.7330945730209351,
0.036291323602199554,
-0.39064234495162964,
-0.11461922526359558,
0.4885586202144623,
0.5287348031997681,
-1.0985634326934814,
-0.007373339496552944,
0.7714887857437134,
-0.15224958956241608,
0.27895328402519226,
0.032294485718011856,
0.40632086992263794,
-1.225213885307312,
-0.030403098091483116,
0.27673569321632385,
-0.4509764313697815,
-0.2612899839878082,
0.2596932351589203,
0.28002411127090454,
-0.184933140873909,
-0.3913364112377167,
0.46033215522766113,
-0.9965198636054993,
-0.1880350112915039,
-0.08789139240980148,
0.18933053314685822,
0.2782149910926819,
0.38041695952415466,
0.05764388293027878,
0.4469272196292877,
0.6684566736221313,
-0.16577017307281494,
0.5139927864074707,
0.09638045728206635,
-0.43498915433883667,
0.6827964186668396,
-0.18416264653205872,
-0.15774257481098175,
-0.507686197757721,
0.3095259666442871,
-0.9586077332496643,
-0.1902741640806198,
0.19548466801643372,
-0.28108635544776917,
0.6927973628044128,
0.21280983090400696,
-0.4269886016845703,
-0.13867832720279694,
-0.28040629625320435,
0.43182373046875,
-0.11381635814905167,
-0.33038556575775146,
0.8655290007591248,
0.47619855403900146,
-0.3070284426212311,
-0.9078570008277893,
-0.5507954955101013,
0.363116979598999,
-0.23153384029865265,
-0.6469797492027283,
0.4558195173740387,
-0.027577796950936317,
-0.0403708890080452,
0.35133033990859985,
-0.17443954944610596,
0.007059914991259575,
-0.13528478145599365,
0.09817779809236526,
0.6180042028427124,
-0.33567026257514954,
0.34429076313972473,
0.1808425784111023,
0.08227481693029404,
-0.13336580991744995,
-0.1514064222574234,
0.2796674370765686,
-0.11148278415203094,
-0.5326613783836365,
-0.5916563272476196,
0.5868713855743408,
0.9368788003921509,
-0.9145324230194092,
0.8233096599578857,
0.8967708945274353,
-0.5994663238525391,
0.322313517332077,
-0.7874292731285095,
-0.002667689695954323,
-0.29359230399131775,
0.5871849060058594,
-0.1073581650853157,
-0.6709708571434021,
0.14399701356887817,
0.20033587515354156,
0.3145972788333893,
0.4156751036643982,
0.4832128882408142,
-0.4036486744880676,
1.2824325561523438,
0.4213026762008667,
-0.18731838464736938,
0.6007874011993408,
0.11746816337108612,
0.26177310943603516,
-0.5733731985092163,
-0.1971343606710434,
-0.024680495262145996,
-0.6554628610610962,
-0.23594588041305542,
-0.3208348751068115,
0.10448181629180908,
0.012952563352882862,
0.11976085603237152,
0.17243753373622894,
-0.20111314952373505,
0.3508681356906891,
0.31998780369758606,
0.12364136427640915,
0.43092432618141174,
0.14681099355220795,
0.33537057042121887,
-0.09634226560592651,
-0.5030437707901001,
-0.41632983088493347,
0.9802572727203369,
0.3513529598712921,
0.9615341424942017,
0.11021970212459564,
0.4248046278953552,
0.14727962017059326,
0.45616355538368225,
-0.5333889126777649,
0.3277466893196106,
-0.02021588571369648,
-0.6349993944168091,
-0.29761940240859985,
-0.36222314834594727,
-0.669715940952301,
0.20870913565158844,
-0.5441246032714844,
-0.3283034861087799,
0.004149526357650757,
0.12200318276882172,
-0.2612914443016052,
0.30787965655326843,
-0.823976993560791,
0.896913468837738,
-0.5620295405387878,
-0.21859651803970337,
0.01697024330496788,
-0.8963945508003235,
0.39070338010787964,
0.012909436598420143,
0.5000054836273193,
-0.10416106134653091,
-0.44943758845329285,
0.4275788962841034,
0.03175373375415802,
0.557360827922821,
-0.2786911427974701,
-0.13171552121639252,
0.21652746200561523,
-0.1734917312860489,
0.5354263186454773,
0.1250387579202652,
0.4259521961212158,
-0.033177223056554794,
-0.1706247329711914,
-0.3641749322414398,
-0.5713404417037964,
0.7652251720428467,
-0.45716777443885803,
-0.7018070220947266,
-0.31438004970550537,
-0.9416797757148743,
-0.23264837265014648,
0.23350556194782257,
0.19244293868541718,
0.458819180727005,
0.16416609287261963,
0.37860825657844543,
0.5251302719116211,
0.1241898387670517,
0.7107610106468201,
0.46240678429603577,
-0.279376745223999,
-0.49120545387268066,
0.8645555377006531,
0.04967420920729637,
0.10847175866365433,
0.7203922271728516,
-0.45221173763275146,
-0.3473217487335205,
-0.485090434551239,
-1.02329683303833,
0.07878869026899338,
-0.5572019815444946,
-0.6611175537109375,
-0.8228365778923035,
0.036878105252981186,
-0.358834445476532,
-0.11872710287570953,
-0.2711252272129059,
-0.4478638470172882,
-0.15974251925945282,
-0.05722322314977646,
-0.09899258613586426,
0.23637479543685913,
0.4893520772457123,
-0.025944631546735764,
-1.0000065565109253,
0.4464156925678253,
0.3176428973674774,
0.29354315996170044,
-0.13741207122802734,
-0.15467901527881622,
-0.22048376500606537,
0.11972671747207642,
-0.5312981605529785,
-1.0222240686416626,
0.20596784353256226,
0.207139253616333,
0.6852272748947144,
0.5526224374771118,
-0.12144272774457932,
0.6203179955482483,
-0.5954778790473938,
0.7060841917991638,
0.519822895526886,
-0.8799296021461487,
0.30667176842689514,
-0.13911612331867218,
0.051394496113061905,
0.32406190037727356,
0.22073495388031006,
-0.17468060553073883,
-0.6209060549736023,
-0.2923775911331177,
-0.7952989935874939,
0.28417348861694336,
0.1440499722957611,
0.3309178948402405,
0.016647938638925552,
-0.005471822340041399,
0.06398791074752808,
0.4256085753440857,
-1.1666898727416992,
-0.08940868824720383,
-0.23418454825878143,
-0.6308785080909729,
-0.01319293212145567,
-0.09101854264736176,
-0.17249681055545807,
-0.17192843556404114,
0.6825199127197266,
-0.27426284551620483,
0.16525979340076447,
0.2569538950920105,
-0.6283372044563293,
-0.42721402645111084,
0.3749546706676483,
0.8883503079414368,
0.7808231115341187,
0.14373524487018585,
0.2263099104166031,
-0.022026319056749344,
-0.05089934542775154,
0.21116158366203308,
0.47861921787261963,
-0.06981851160526276,
0.1139029935002327,
0.31894612312316895,
0.8766529560089111,
0.1798693835735321,
-0.8732627630233765,
0.8679514527320862,
0.1554068624973297,
-0.03704454377293587,
-0.02757430262863636,
-0.3124645948410034,
0.2638247609138489,
0.46498480439186096,
0.5273485779762268,
0.5075317025184631,
0.2002871185541153,
-0.4685925543308258,
0.2718791961669922,
0.670748233795166,
-0.3642812967300415,
-0.007400959264487028,
0.9171523451805115,
0.3306480646133423,
0.1784096211194992,
0.34483903646469116,
-0.14806188642978668,
-0.3313385546207428,
0.6391719579696655,
0.6970351934432983,
0.36320140957832336,
-0.18727052211761475,
0.06525293737649918,
0.07263103872537613,
0.6047106385231018,
-0.01265513151884079,
0.20122623443603516,
0.3391737937927246,
-0.7851731777191162,
-0.5665819048881531,
-0.411242812871933,
0.0402410514652729,
-0.04616917297244072,
-0.5231770873069763,
0.3862912058830261,
-0.0929713249206543,
-0.02169857732951641,
0.19142329692840576,
-0.38590461015701294,
-0.6014124751091003,
0.3984026610851288,
0.44623810052871704,
0.8812317252159119,
-0.8803213238716125,
0.6231934428215027,
1.1329501867294312,
-0.5232747793197632,
-0.7208142280578613,
-0.13638505339622498,
0.028783271089196205,
-0.7159776091575623,
0.34263601899147034,
0.5411993265151978,
0.25938934087753296,
-0.006487049628049135,
-0.4956720769405365,
-0.72752445936203,
1.465453863143921,
0.5690186023712158,
-0.8028573393821716,
-0.21375171840190887,
-0.20755764842033386,
0.15528742969036102,
-0.8536952137947083,
-0.2422483265399933,
-0.10892051458358765,
0.5623120069503784,
-0.0977216586470604,
-0.8282166719436646,
0.0346943698823452,
-0.3912460505962372,
0.007102299947291613,
0.5236448049545288,
-0.7168802618980408,
0.7499724626541138,
-0.5385428071022034,
-0.2276235967874527,
0.08361881971359253,
0.9246418476104736,
-0.05473700165748596,
0.6490433216094971,
0.7990121245384216,
0.9078847169876099,
0.5450078845024109,
0.01210795808583498,
1.0693318843841553,
-0.26691222190856934,
0.32048818469047546,
1.0189677476882935,
-0.3997134268283844,
0.791135311126709,
0.9443343877792358,
0.2227490097284317,
0.27913063764572144,
0.45226168632507324,
-0.30774059891700745,
0.5785408020019531,
-0.2771894335746765,
-0.1399814337491989,
-0.21129339933395386,
-0.2663426101207733,
-0.12998896837234497,
0.5386646389961243,
-0.034857288002967834,
-0.7122577428817749,
-0.06424306333065033,
0.4102409780025482,
-0.14019818603992462,
-0.027987172827124596,
-0.5356097221374512,
0.6642889976501465,
-0.07778144627809525,
-0.6867728233337402,
-0.09140942990779877,
0.06979099661111832,
0.5107337236404419,
-0.300431489944458,
-0.12857985496520996,
0.11899237334728241,
-0.16591569781303406,
-0.2072937786579132,
-0.8583617806434631,
0.16190677881240845,
-0.13481570780277252,
-0.37146317958831787,
-0.1351483315229416,
0.7372515797615051,
-1.0100666284561157,
-0.5727598667144775,
-0.12145654112100601,
0.5595195889472961,
-0.28250259160995483,
-0.09646662324666977,
-0.5362465977668762,
-0.09062524139881134,
-0.030479498207569122,
-0.20703352987766266,
0.22665907442569733,
0.39116883277893066,
-0.27239471673965454,
0.4811181128025055,
0.5734931826591492,
-0.1456107646226883,
0.05968070030212402,
0.063443124294281,
0.7435129880905151,
-0.2078048437833786,
-0.4541575312614441,
-0.8476897478103638,
0.6033279299736023,
-0.21643561124801636,
-0.1121402308344841,
0.4354235827922821,
0.7289261817932129,
0.7524588108062744,
-0.24293233454227448,
0.4427368938922882,
-0.18097873032093048,
-0.023917783051729202,
-0.9450169801712036,
0.5824103355407715,
-0.8677797317504883,
0.013774177059531212,
-0.2390282154083252,
-1.2754135131835938,
-0.4141020178794861,
0.12638069689273834,
0.1398165076971054,
-0.02715115249156952,
0.6783371567726135,
0.7477434277534485,
-0.13452476263046265,
-0.033614903688430786,
0.2429157793521881,
-0.18516048789024353,
0.015374903567135334,
0.47854435443878174,
0.7454005479812622,
-0.37656062841415405,
0.7750467658042908,
-0.20343832671642303,
-0.021774908527731895,
-0.19089442491531372,
-1.0846270322799683,
-0.6001864075660706,
-0.7071723341941833,
-0.31468600034713745,
0.04792638123035431,
-0.10978789627552032,
0.9703678488731384,
0.6141607165336609,
-0.6885975003242493,
0.3815321922302246,
0.2898719310760498,
0.024504417553544044,
-0.36267274618148804,
-0.24817045032978058,
0.2555135488510132,
-0.22842957079410553,
-0.8289693593978882,
-0.16492648422718048,
0.4805873930454254,
0.2333904504776001,
-0.17363829910755157,
-0.1594732403755188,
-0.37475213408470154,
-0.0752648413181305,
0.5684835314750671,
-0.14776089787483215,
-0.8961771726608276,
-0.40177518129348755,
0.040928591042757034,
-0.4584580957889557,
0.1791275292634964,
0.8072453737258911,
-0.13405616581439972,
0.6053794026374817,
0.17238818109035492,
1.021139144897461,
0.08448704332113266,
0.15055151283740997,
0.39726316928863525,
-0.9056649208068848,
0.09968926012516022,
-0.0008098006946966052,
0.8239420652389526,
0.5343270897865295,
-0.39286795258522034,
0.1288384646177292,
0.11144791543483734,
-0.3222159147262573,
-0.5654689073562622,
0.005678804125636816,
-1.4378503561019897,
-0.03531529754400253,
0.9064409136772156,
-0.11328057199716568,
-0.13912971317768097,
0.32526156306266785,
-0.6054518818855286,
0.2844136357307434,
-0.42559999227523804,
0.6091713905334473,
0.8784948587417603,
0.22024664282798767,
-0.9097716808319092,
-0.5724861025810242,
0.0944773256778717,
0.40062540769577026,
-1.0149132013320923,
-0.27949076890945435,
0.6546898484230042,
0.09202354401350021,
0.4356922507286072,
0.23785540461540222,
-0.211153045296669,
0.5574691295623779,
-0.28170379996299744,
0.28110751509666443,
-0.5204887390136719,
-0.4518035650253296,
-0.1333199292421341,
0.16804426908493042,
-0.16845925152301788,
-0.4278262257575989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19379v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19379v5
|
Wisdom of the Silicon Crowd: LLM Ensemble Prediction Capabilities Rival Human Crowd Accuracy
| 2024-02-29T17:27:59 | 2024-06-17T11:38:00 |
Philipp Schoenegger, Indre Tuminauskaite, Peter S. Park, Rafael Valdece Sousa Bastos, Philip E. Tetlock
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Human forecasting accuracy in practice relies on the 'wisdom of the crowd'
effect, in which predictions about future events are significantly improved by
aggregating across a crowd of individual forecasters. Past work on the
forecasting ability of large language models (LLMs) suggests that frontier
LLMs, as individual forecasters, underperform compared to the gold standard of
a human-crowd forecasting-tournament aggregate. In Study 1, we expand this
research by using an LLM ensemble approach consisting of a crowd of 12 LLMs. We
compare the aggregated LLM predictions on 31 binary questions to those of a
crowd of 925 human forecasters from a three-month forecasting tournament. Our
preregistered main analysis shows that the LLM crowd outperforms a simple
no-information benchmark, and is not statistically different from the human
crowd. We also observe a set of human-like biases in machine responses, such as
an acquiescence effect and a tendency to favour round numbers. In Study 2, we
test whether LLM predictions (of GPT-4 and Claude 2) can be improved by drawing
on human cognitive output. We find that both models' forecasting accuracy
benefits from exposure to the median human prediction as information, improving
accuracy by between 17% and 28%, though this leads to less accurate predictions
than simply averaging human and machine forecasts. Our results suggest that
LLMs can achieve forecasting accuracy rivaling that of the human crowd: via the
simple, practically applicable method of forecast aggregation.
|
[
-0.48885196447372437,
-0.22810599207878113,
0.7240691781044006,
-0.0033298367634415627,
-0.12947386503219604,
0.32488003373146057,
-0.20027393102645874,
-0.8338792324066162,
0.3444787263870239,
0.43913042545318604,
-0.5709530115127563,
-0.1833641231060028,
-0.5467047095298767,
-0.07783234864473343,
-0.4823507070541382,
0.5384225845336914,
0.5497814416885376,
0.3488234579563141,
-0.4892979562282562,
0.17888198792934418,
-0.2545304596424103,
-0.466522216796875,
-0.5916852951049805,
-0.6246757507324219,
0.4025282859802246,
0.3631117641925812,
0.7676233053207397,
0.5382121205329895,
0.4055151641368866,
0.35599762201309204,
0.1402064859867096,
0.3063427209854126,
-0.5401774048805237,
-0.3436417877674103,
0.004034257493913174,
-0.5697521567344666,
-0.35530200600624084,
0.2628823220729828,
0.7758023738861084,
0.7633048295974731,
-0.24248106777668,
0.0922292172908783,
0.3024466335773468,
0.7982695698738098,
-0.38395801186561584,
-0.004627672489732504,
-1.1187033653259277,
-0.018485484644770622,
-0.3990073800086975,
-0.19483822584152222,
-0.34318268299102783,
-0.2038910835981369,
0.17205217480659485,
-0.619456946849823,
0.23025758564472198,
0.3221881091594696,
0.4954715967178345,
0.5228825807571411,
-0.10939919203519821,
0.1285586804151535,
-0.8084811568260193,
0.918457567691803,
-0.4915525019168854,
0.23553769290447235,
0.3676552474498749,
0.32927942276000977,
-0.3815471827983856,
-0.40629786252975464,
-0.515361487865448,
0.1423582285642624,
0.47895193099975586,
0.5021805167198181,
-0.3859454393386841,
-0.08966144919395447,
0.017181208357214928,
0.00018256466137245297,
-0.49057164788246155,
0.4037904441356659,
-0.7458192706108093,
-0.2524228096008301,
0.8742443919181824,
0.2059638798236847,
-0.19938518106937408,
-0.04030146077275276,
-0.732467532157898,
0.0006367753376252949,
-0.714252769947052,
-0.026590965688228607,
0.1972181797027588,
-0.014176853932440281,
0.14087854325771332,
0.25612103939056396,
-0.31558942794799805,
0.6292513012886047,
0.11564844101667404,
-0.3334648907184601,
-0.012688686139881611,
0.026725230738520622,
-0.13657042384147644,
0.18684665858745575,
0.8878230452537537,
0.6704936623573303,
0.5076968669891357,
-0.48799189925193787,
-0.0012343140551820397,
0.09715544432401657,
-0.01088206097483635,
-0.6257082223892212,
-0.447794646024704,
-0.045569878071546555,
-0.2894286811351776,
-0.1570100486278534,
0.3764379024505615,
-0.8716860413551331,
-0.6857136487960815,
-0.26848000288009644,
0.36071568727493286,
-0.29735684394836426,
0.010210763663053513,
0.010616718791425228,
-0.3692225217819214,
0.19087082147598267,
0.6311527490615845,
-0.6196573972702026,
0.5914514660835266,
0.7930813431739807,
0.7737533450126648,
-0.40029847621917725,
-0.46751493215560913,
-0.536981463432312,
-0.05481266230344772,
-0.296478807926178,
1.3088386058807373,
-0.43291565775871277,
-0.5693180561065674,
-0.47241508960723877,
-0.48067447543144226,
-0.014572716318070889,
-0.6557790040969849,
0.3253522217273712,
-0.5944810509681702,
0.15983974933624268,
-0.3643132746219635,
-0.7477625608444214,
-0.131134495139122,
-0.10331792384386063,
-0.4338853061199188,
0.6545562744140625,
-0.24756157398223877,
-0.4248082637786865,
0.5016455054283142,
-0.41883111000061035,
-0.03726169094443321,
0.30684539675712585,
-0.4057779610157013,
0.10861369222402573,
0.05652732402086258,
0.30475959181785583,
0.5118383169174194,
-0.2913750112056732,
0.020214613527059555,
-0.6991276144981384,
-0.6150170564651489,
0.6438894271850586,
-0.8609615564346313,
0.3083063066005707,
0.19236992299556732,
-0.14884698390960693,
-0.13663829863071442,
-0.3806093633174896,
0.005315460730344057,
-0.04673765227198601,
-0.22565287351608276,
-0.23028604686260223,
0.47435909509658813,
-0.41758760809898376,
0.040457583963871,
-0.000854470010381192,
-0.45867910981178284,
-0.021945256739854813,
-0.44836705923080444,
0.43747678399086,
1.2585607767105103,
-0.2353878915309906,
0.7077147364616394,
-0.6660415530204773,
0.3792266845703125,
-0.047697603702545166,
-0.02205168642103672,
-0.10711425542831421,
-0.915614128112793,
-0.16816407442092896,
-0.08343014866113663,
0.22903528809547424,
0.6606974005699158,
-0.694157600402832,
0.12555699050426483,
-0.5761073231697083,
-0.7539601922035217,
-0.3358360528945923,
0.30540862679481506,
0.014097671955823898,
0.668822705745697,
-0.04042014107108116,
-0.309359073638916,
-0.43241724371910095,
-0.563210666179657,
-0.3380849063396454,
-0.5891906023025513,
-0.11671973764896393,
0.5019060969352722,
0.05291931703686714,
-0.10107436776161194,
0.9406200647354126,
-0.5058364868164062,
0.12386966496706009,
-0.005597197450697422,
0.027112871408462524,
0.17885960638523102,
0.1289260983467102,
0.2047347128391266,
-0.6863288283348083,
-0.02471497841179371,
-0.2268543243408203,
-0.6075453758239746,
0.016753777861595154,
0.25887516140937805,
-0.08603300899267197,
0.3747332692146301,
0.04157696291804314,
-0.3679392337799072,
0.25203970074653625,
0.6514288783073425,
-0.33094921708106995,
0.6390958428382874,
0.05931231379508972,
0.1650189608335495,
-0.9507330656051636,
-0.5729292631149292,
0.34807315468788147,
-0.17106205224990845,
-0.42249158024787903,
-0.4599667489528656,
-0.08149722963571548,
0.15783900022506714,
-0.4255484640598297,
0.7504245042800903,
-0.16392752528190613,
-0.4947175681591034,
-0.45146387815475464,
0.4562591314315796,
-0.13876882195472717,
0.1185106411576271,
0.020027507096529007,
1.0282466411590576,
0.2785722017288208,
-0.8814367055892944,
0.47629043459892273,
-0.05241038277745247,
-0.7080744504928589,
0.3807566463947296,
-0.5163753032684326,
0.18612775206565857,
-0.09751544147729874,
0.34047916531562805,
-1.0116711854934692,
-0.4861987829208374,
-0.056753240525722504,
-0.7548555135726929,
0.002728282241150737,
0.19910919666290283,
-0.2893061637878418,
-0.7070246338844299,
-0.32020318508148193,
0.3313726484775543,
1.0171213150024414,
-0.516319990158081,
0.3759302496910095,
0.53440922498703,
-0.27498364448547363,
-0.4975525438785553,
-0.8303626179695129,
0.2063799649477005,
-0.37777408957481384,
-1.0602338314056396,
0.3687434792518616,
-0.07677304744720459,
-0.7161107659339905,
-0.2512376308441162,
-0.04597079008817673,
0.008189688436686993,
0.224041149020195,
0.22174392640590668,
0.6175887584686279,
-0.23364759981632233,
0.4706760048866272,
-0.4641353189945221,
-0.13291716575622559,
0.10149425268173218,
-0.6245219707489014,
0.5787646174430847,
-0.2704443037509918,
-0.6933246850967407,
-0.2626854181289673,
-0.22019071877002716,
0.261443167924881,
0.21519479155540466,
0.36102500557899475,
0.49347007274627686,
-0.3531785011291504,
0.23231518268585205,
-1.0778950452804565,
-0.4429466426372528,
-0.5073792934417725,
0.41580837965011597,
-0.04706958308815956,
-0.7767826914787292,
0.5638428330421448,
-0.08498093485832214,
-0.1245240718126297,
0.768983006477356,
0.31915998458862305,
-0.4655984938144684,
1.0753990411758423,
0.39246442914009094,
-0.5605481863021851,
0.4023282527923584,
-0.020740380510687828,
-0.4046876132488251,
-0.6708587408065796,
-0.17485053837299347,
-0.4258708953857422,
-0.5419585108757019,
-0.6611422896385193,
-0.5412612557411194,
0.5115675926208496,
0.020457401871681213,
-0.1980387568473816,
0.0585169792175293,
-0.40003153681755066,
0.6810458898544312,
0.7087422609329224,
0.2100798487663269,
0.38000378012657166,
0.2759571075439453,
0.460692435503006,
-0.1684083193540573,
-1.0349458456039429,
-0.755721926689148,
1.0978912115097046,
0.3304571509361267,
0.8182218670845032,
-0.14873243868350983,
0.700556218624115,
0.38074377179145813,
0.40606218576431274,
-0.5712556838989258,
0.6000412106513977,
-0.29783275723457336,
-0.39550191164016724,
-0.5661351680755615,
-0.6358715891838074,
-0.7878538966178894,
0.14794540405273438,
-0.16096176207065582,
-1.0668116807937622,
0.1855747103691101,
0.047754917293787,
-0.6231322884559631,
0.6701312065124512,
-0.6538152694702148,
0.3676987588405609,
-0.3113117218017578,
-0.29178011417388916,
-0.3605254888534546,
-0.41453683376312256,
0.4829198718070984,
-0.28488194942474365,
0.5275716781616211,
-0.4781467616558075,
-0.3675541281700134,
1.0694960355758667,
-0.17147262394428253,
0.9389621615409851,
-0.020088672637939453,
0.19072730839252472,
0.5437818169593811,
-0.20997865498065948,
0.5327171087265015,
-0.08664077520370483,
-0.5620958209037781,
0.24285118281841278,
-0.24136577546596527,
-0.5902219414710999,
-0.408232718706131,
0.7112305760383606,
-1.1884310245513916,
-0.8188562989234924,
-0.1711285561323166,
-0.3978281319141388,
-0.17560893297195435,
-0.2515658736228943,
0.4513588845729828,
0.5296299457550049,
-0.3048078417778015,
-0.04124406725168228,
0.6025934219360352,
-0.03731028735637665,
0.5634005069732666,
0.3633195459842682,
-0.20709888637065887,
-0.6668899059295654,
0.8913730382919312,
0.3253342807292938,
0.37756025791168213,
0.2016773223876953,
0.35860881209373474,
-0.2849738895893097,
-0.40257999300956726,
-0.7584326267242432,
0.038029927760362625,
-0.561394453048706,
-0.167029470205307,
-0.4873499572277069,
-0.015844086185097694,
-0.48372501134872437,
-0.04051893576979637,
-0.14224115014076233,
-0.4693959057331085,
-0.3037761449813843,
0.07430806010961533,
0.3709050416946411,
0.9887949228286743,
0.011110587976872921,
0.42707154154777527,
-0.9292685985565186,
-0.27658405900001526,
0.48597997426986694,
0.1820479929447174,
0.00576908141374588,
-0.665191113948822,
-0.09927245229482651,
0.2781478464603424,
-0.5337920784950256,
-0.8610936403274536,
0.274269700050354,
0.10353192687034607,
0.6474056839942932,
0.7317371964454651,
0.07524241507053375,
0.932152509689331,
-0.24240094423294067,
0.8916800022125244,
0.4199463129043579,
-0.6030611395835876,
0.33301103115081787,
-0.3528285026550293,
0.28690803050994873,
0.4927845895290375,
0.032852429896593094,
-0.4169924557209015,
-0.29166194796562195,
-0.8543707728385925,
-0.47129446268081665,
0.8207036256790161,
-0.09539082646369934,
0.0553751103579998,
-0.02240694686770439,
0.263028085231781,
0.23708932101726532,
0.27824991941452026,
-0.47479623556137085,
0.09813797473907471,
0.010301792062819004,
0.14510412514209747,
-0.5517565011978149,
-0.0719878301024437,
0.3008142113685608,
-0.14425571262836456,
0.6222246885299683,
-0.037275757640600204,
0.3843229115009308,
0.19293707609176636,
0.4294856786727905,
-0.4223250448703766,
0.03067738562822342,
0.5355197787284851,
0.7255606055259705,
-0.05440324544906616,
0.1386563777923584,
0.8867414593696594,
-0.27226701378822327,
-0.07158737629652023,
0.05844424292445183,
-0.10329080373048782,
-0.18270935118198395,
0.4323643445968628,
0.6405797600746155,
0.245317742228508,
-0.704349160194397,
0.2199554145336151,
0.06253144890069962,
-0.34954166412353516,
-0.6159926652908325,
0.2516775131225586,
0.21629706025123596,
0.3829840123653412,
0.8101754784584045,
0.49727126955986023,
0.13209868967533112,
-0.5858384966850281,
0.052544694393873215,
0.5080575942993164,
-0.5202544927597046,
-0.2944914996623993,
0.8129479289054871,
0.33695629239082336,
-0.45681264996528625,
0.5857882499694824,
-0.26619523763656616,
-0.5861338376998901,
0.8481405973434448,
0.2926346957683563,
0.7610384225845337,
-0.14175252616405487,
-0.03594236075878143,
0.05506788194179535,
0.264034241437912,
-0.4058362543582916,
-0.09718764573335648,
0.13399691879749298,
-0.9294763803482056,
-0.7343674898147583,
-0.4409721791744232,
-0.5939510464668274,
-0.21283182501792908,
-0.34869584441185,
0.1777438521385193,
-0.26109984517097473,
-0.27775144577026367,
-0.03804263100028038,
0.2631431221961975,
-0.675197422504425,
-0.0782453790307045,
0.4277053475379944,
1.0478501319885254,
-0.5517376065254211,
0.6278277635574341,
0.8457923531532288,
0.08782167732715607,
-0.8343482613563538,
0.2280290722846985,
0.14643900096416473,
-1.0255672931671143,
0.33370694518089294,
0.3294820785522461,
-0.09234156459569931,
-0.020637350156903267,
-0.6702555418014526,
-1.0336140394210815,
1.517494797706604,
0.3139185905456543,
-0.8520557284355164,
0.21529555320739746,
-0.09578084200620651,
0.15410113334655762,
-0.42369815707206726,
0.34694427251815796,
0.3933176100254059,
0.48049163818359375,
0.585921585559845,
-0.950234591960907,
-0.3639949560165405,
0.023876385763287544,
-0.18554864823818207,
0.19199138879776,
-0.9899818897247314,
0.6471731662750244,
-0.43275731801986694,
-0.15878929197788239,
0.17473135888576508,
1.0832144021987915,
0.4282020926475525,
0.9578978419303894,
0.682862401008606,
0.2702232003211975,
1.3065866231918335,
-0.24780626595020294,
1.1717737913131714,
-0.4088967442512512,
-0.28357720375061035,
0.7968630790710449,
-0.47867515683174133,
0.9292743802070618,
0.2109534591436386,
-0.6692788004875183,
0.4226658046245575,
0.8666728734970093,
0.12369324266910553,
0.33754029870033264,
0.059579260647296906,
-0.4107193946838379,
-0.6825043559074402,
0.16078411042690277,
-0.3372708857059479,
0.5406932234764099,
0.23114420473575592,
-0.008752112276852131,
0.04416460543870926,
-0.15982727706432343,
-0.1197536513209343,
0.22554618120193481,
-0.7748563885688782,
0.9463716745376587,
0.1930408775806427,
-0.9521368145942688,
0.10854217410087585,
-0.11789955943822861,
0.9191980361938477,
-0.07973627001047134,
0.37213075160980225,
0.09864210337400436,
0.38242653012275696,
-0.09186612814664841,
-0.7177611589431763,
0.20315967500209808,
-0.09972914308309555,
-0.22351288795471191,
0.09794999659061432,
1.1459568738937378,
-0.01251139771193266,
-0.7703250050544739,
0.22820058465003967,
0.8407250642776489,
0.6296114325523376,
-0.26935023069381714,
-0.37958285212516785,
-0.26140472292900085,
0.003674137871712446,
-0.06637535244226456,
0.5564586520195007,
0.36100831627845764,
-0.056755974888801575,
0.9502367973327637,
0.5266556739807129,
0.06890995055437088,
0.0779062807559967,
-0.15390139818191528,
0.8035144209861755,
-0.7438147068023682,
-0.19979821145534515,
-1.285949945449829,
0.05227086693048477,
-0.17843253910541534,
-0.04159729555249214,
0.5816053748130798,
0.5171905159950256,
0.5843637585639954,
0.17252425849437714,
0.9913854598999023,
0.5708972215652466,
0.46725064516067505,
-0.31621840596199036,
0.38319385051727295,
-0.2286265790462494,
0.4813440442085266,
-0.168110191822052,
-0.8697100281715393,
0.2335868924856186,
0.20527751743793488,
-0.7009314298629761,
0.2685782313346863,
0.17163878679275513,
0.6713961362838745,
0.21066296100616455,
0.5503019690513611,
0.5028181076049805,
0.1090647280216217,
-0.10697837918996811,
0.5308656692504883,
1.1143856048583984,
0.03727345168590546,
0.7802306413650513,
-0.1815497875213623,
-0.4928590655326843,
-0.22924688458442688,
-0.7896540760993958,
-0.8105090260505676,
-0.24129779636859894,
-0.12813226878643036,
-0.22347964346408844,
0.17145061492919922,
1.1567944288253784,
0.7228739857673645,
-0.5546547770500183,
-0.38687872886657715,
0.07282105088233948,
0.22021351754665375,
-0.172223299741745,
-0.19758982956409454,
-0.06467436999082565,
-0.17066030204296112,
-0.6421130299568176,
0.400448203086853,
0.26296088099479675,
0.11913412064313889,
-0.4227551221847534,
-0.42386725544929504,
0.3499147891998291,
0.2710036635398865,
0.54024738073349,
0.035811349749565125,
-0.843826413154602,
-0.2284766435623169,
0.3172697126865387,
0.02219037525355816,
-0.1634119600057602,
0.14522510766983032,
-1.2837268114089966,
0.009093080647289753,
0.2928340435028076,
0.38995683193206787,
0.4113074839115143,
0.35243669152259827,
0.6585475206375122,
-0.2790991961956024,
-0.20552755892276764,
0.12000879645347595,
0.34092167019844055,
0.24284827709197998,
-0.250533789396286,
0.5835663676261902,
0.5167635679244995,
-0.8925167322158813,
-0.4134715795516968,
-0.012857124209403992,
-0.7949804067611694,
-0.2155844271183014,
1.2357834577560425,
0.20761646330356598,
-0.46438783407211304,
-0.03929419070482254,
-0.08379807323217392,
-0.039432723075151443,
-0.7986263036727905,
1.011549949645996,
0.7548288702964783,
-0.2800354063510895,
0.0836867019534111,
-0.6601786017417908,
0.07676796615123749,
0.20246924459934235,
-0.4349513053894043,
-0.1336703598499298,
0.36329755187034607,
0.0976385846734047,
0.22947198152542114,
0.779611349105835,
0.10956119745969772,
0.39398351311683655,
-0.014418796636164188,
-0.027845045551657677,
0.013346744701266289,
-0.014858728274703026,
-0.12718228995800018,
0.13063590228557587,
0.16375915706157684,
-0.02664804831147194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19371v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19371v1
|
OpenMedLM: Prompt engineering can out-perform fine-tuning in medical question-answering with open-source large language models
| 2024-02-29T17:19:39 | 2024-02-29T17:19:39 |
Jenish Maharjan, Anurag Garikipati, Navan Preet Singh, Leo Cyrus, Mayank Sharma, Madalina Ciobanu, Gina Barnes, Rahul Thapa, Qingqing Mao, Ritankar Das
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
LLMs have become increasingly capable at accomplishing a range of
specialized-tasks and can be utilized to expand equitable access to medical
knowledge. Most medical LLMs have involved extensive fine-tuning, leveraging
specialized medical data and significant, thus costly, amounts of computational
power. Many of the top performing LLMs are proprietary and their access is
limited to very few research groups. However, open-source (OS) models represent
a key area of growth for medical LLMs due to significant improvements in
performance and an inherent ability to provide the transparency and compliance
required in healthcare. We present OpenMedLM, a prompting platform which
delivers state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance for OS LLMs on medical benchmarks.
We evaluated a range of OS foundation LLMs (7B-70B) on four medical benchmarks
(MedQA, MedMCQA, PubMedQA, MMLU medical-subset). We employed a series of
prompting strategies, including zero-shot, few-shot, chain-of-thought (random
selection and kNN selection), and ensemble/self-consistency voting. We found
that OpenMedLM delivers OS SOTA results on three common medical LLM benchmarks,
surpassing the previous best performing OS models that leveraged
computationally costly extensive fine-tuning. The model delivers a 72.6%
accuracy on the MedQA benchmark, outperforming the previous SOTA by 2.4%, and
achieves 81.7% accuracy on the MMLU medical-subset, establishing itself as the
first OS LLM to surpass 80% accuracy on this benchmark. Our results highlight
medical-specific emergent properties in OS LLMs which have not yet been
documented to date elsewhere, and showcase the benefits of further leveraging
prompt engineering to improve the performance of accessible LLMs for medical
applications.
|
[
-0.2068038135766983,
-0.8542751669883728,
1.0605390071868896,
0.1790112406015396,
-0.18146182596683502,
-0.09519529342651367,
-0.271160364151001,
-0.5194498300552368,
-0.17107681930065155,
0.4516584873199463,
-0.8216066956520081,
-0.6224063634872437,
-0.3880363702774048,
0.3093882203102112,
0.19848541915416718,
0.898385226726532,
-0.26313483715057373,
0.5760183930397034,
-0.3382999897003174,
-0.37822648882865906,
-0.43989044427871704,
-0.2699422538280487,
-0.5284229516983032,
-0.12077129632234573,
0.6061899662017822,
0.31899720430374146,
0.6496154069900513,
0.5326870083808899,
0.5387763381004333,
0.15429623425006866,
-0.272519588470459,
0.2796876132488251,
-0.43083423376083374,
0.5413827300071716,
-0.15795455873012543,
-0.4454479515552521,
-0.4601767659187317,
-0.07625221461057663,
0.4059279263019562,
0.5748060345649719,
-0.018195567652583122,
0.3523739278316498,
0.07379654794931412,
0.7412830591201782,
-0.41423436999320984,
-0.12043754756450653,
-0.49388614296913147,
-0.06878458708524704,
-0.18312060832977295,
-0.3907521665096283,
-0.42749640345573425,
-0.825762152671814,
-0.059375178068876266,
-0.6054855585098267,
-0.016314895823597908,
0.3767782747745514,
0.630945086479187,
0.5962212681770325,
0.19698581099510193,
-0.4378789961338043,
-0.45821142196655273,
0.5454491972923279,
-0.7561371326446533,
0.4428209364414215,
0.11409815400838852,
0.5009257793426514,
-0.19782619178295135,
-0.799439549446106,
-0.05201519653201103,
-0.38726234436035156,
0.25351545214653015,
0.15696197748184204,
-0.18171806633472443,
0.2613932490348816,
0.31763553619384766,
0.4502602219581604,
-0.6513657569885254,
0.4381467401981354,
-0.42857715487480164,
-0.04527062550187111,
0.23169218003749847,
0.398644357919693,
0.37765777111053467,
0.2159581184387207,
-0.46221017837524414,
0.4499224126338959,
-1.2252079248428345,
0.21956373751163483,
-0.2574799358844757,
0.3695532977581024,
0.049684539437294006,
0.8061416745185852,
-0.4708316922187805,
0.6811326146125793,
-0.16828033328056335,
0.038163915276527405,
0.23551657795906067,
-0.3251030445098877,
-0.32895559072494507,
-0.012120161205530167,
0.7305426001548767,
0.4193578064441681,
0.06503253430128098,
0.031302325427532196,
-0.21360482275485992,
-0.1976419985294342,
-0.014135591685771942,
-0.8281838893890381,
-0.1029723584651947,
0.6463298201560974,
-0.7408725619316101,
-0.07693225890398026,
-0.20418459177017212,
-0.4541587829589844,
-0.750135600566864,
-0.27114540338516235,
0.507845938205719,
-0.3785305917263031,
-0.007576757110655308,
0.28557083010673523,
0.0999424010515213,
-0.06290260702371597,
0.5453581213951111,
-0.30786699056625366,
-0.05556492134928703,
0.5856146216392517,
1.0334949493408203,
-0.0514594204723835,
0.016259485855698586,
-0.7818495631217957,
-0.431855708360672,
-0.40969201922416687,
0.6849358677864075,
-0.41831669211387634,
-0.2936212122440338,
-0.07187297940254211,
-0.04791828617453575,
0.08982989937067032,
-0.8505054116249084,
0.4793698787689209,
-0.5559879541397095,
0.19859643280506134,
-0.43667468428611755,
-0.5593818426132202,
0.202919602394104,
0.20021627843379974,
-0.39429235458374023,
0.8155179619789124,
0.06438741087913513,
-0.5448144674301147,
0.20772333443164825,
-1.0467145442962646,
0.010168490931391716,
0.29598021507263184,
-0.2759431004524231,
-0.17737078666687012,
0.36427679657936096,
0.4359029233455658,
0.29730522632598877,
-0.6994439959526062,
0.22856532037258148,
-0.29059141874313354,
-0.1658424437046051,
0.34598270058631897,
-0.20260894298553467,
0.8840903639793396,
0.4752418100833893,
0.10444757342338562,
0.5637080669403076,
-0.5935396552085876,
0.10555122792720795,
0.1598690003156662,
-0.2515380084514618,
-0.32249894738197327,
-0.23996052145957947,
-0.3573504388332367,
0.36216047406196594,
0.31197237968444824,
-0.8470242619514465,
0.2482500970363617,
-0.6605016589164734,
0.4304044246673584,
0.6665321588516235,
0.27439913153648376,
0.11098884791135788,
-0.5883523225784302,
0.7551942467689514,
-0.2020946890115738,
0.5070988535881042,
-0.3776840567588806,
-0.9004900455474854,
-0.1049383282661438,
-0.5728908777236938,
0.20397557318210602,
0.5402498841285706,
-0.7336400747299194,
0.010365583933889866,
0.14886777102947235,
-0.38705676794052124,
-1.2625473737716675,
-0.05734715238213539,
0.24222970008850098,
1.0358093976974487,
0.47646617889404297,
0.15194422006607056,
-0.41933318972587585,
-0.5934690833091736,
-0.3448423147201538,
-0.1257125288248062,
-0.46799376606941223,
0.5958930253982544,
-0.017379026859998703,
-0.0272042378783226,
0.9907028079032898,
-0.6082869172096252,
-0.15304186940193176,
0.04908374324440956,
-0.0169661995023489,
0.549074113368988,
0.2813486158847809,
0.29979923367500305,
-0.45874032378196716,
-0.3768704831600189,
-0.013291088864207268,
-0.8858529925346375,
-0.5804167985916138,
0.2360568344593048,
-0.025430506095290184,
0.08578818291425705,
0.5098788142204285,
-0.48877525329589844,
0.27716323733329773,
0.3880060017108917,
-0.3296321928501129,
0.5952343344688416,
-0.49760180711746216,
0.23156705498695374,
-0.9100337028503418,
0.28283214569091797,
-0.3798863887786865,
-0.0952228233218193,
-0.5710026621818542,
0.39824068546295166,
0.2741679847240448,
-0.2905324101448059,
-0.8039872646331787,
0.8097308874130249,
-0.4403781592845917,
0.17627254128456116,
-0.22991682589054108,
-0.06101338937878609,
-0.13711155951023102,
-0.05671408027410507,
-0.2508297562599182,
0.9339776039123535,
0.6436069011688232,
-0.632196843624115,
0.22100438177585602,
0.3551383316516876,
-0.3654896914958954,
0.5898684859275818,
-0.9194297790527344,
0.02864859066903591,
-0.11175470799207687,
-0.11609575152397156,
-0.8942795991897583,
-0.29733291268348694,
0.21992941200733185,
-0.4989985227584839,
0.020170459523797035,
0.09967827796936035,
-0.42687493562698364,
-0.4840555489063263,
-0.2773677706718445,
0.2081385850906372,
0.896734893321991,
-0.4992568790912628,
0.2841898202896118,
0.036061327904462814,
-0.6868937611579895,
-0.2672964930534363,
-0.391311377286911,
-0.11228447407484055,
0.20481032133102417,
-0.6313284039497375,
-0.028359686955809593,
-0.4010457396507263,
-0.16091684997081757,
-0.03386033698916435,
-0.15089647471904755,
0.10274199396371841,
0.10284588485956192,
0.3263610601425171,
0.601517915725708,
-0.5726330280303955,
0.404753714799881,
0.2735738158226013,
-0.04108324274420738,
0.1076013594865799,
-0.3218185305595398,
0.3752581477165222,
0.03891937807202339,
-0.7113246321678162,
-0.21714822947978973,
0.3056677281856537,
0.7632049918174744,
-0.3468035161495209,
0.5747809410095215,
0.17028701305389404,
-0.4611905515193939,
0.09254806488752365,
-0.4774208068847656,
-0.3642132878303528,
-0.451918363571167,
0.14149649441242218,
-0.2266978919506073,
-1.1337617635726929,
0.5322238206863403,
-0.3162558972835541,
0.5496975183486938,
0.33289170265197754,
0.8237116932868958,
-0.1906631737947464,
1.2371456623077393,
0.21147985756397247,
0.368937224149704,
0.1568010151386261,
0.3595650792121887,
-0.17171809077262878,
-0.7623081803321838,
-0.38992080092430115,
-0.7490524053573608,
-0.33999553322792053,
-0.2306031435728073,
-0.5413891673088074,
0.954703688621521,
0.10305333137512207,
-0.2315998673439026,
-0.3474500775337219,
-0.6224250197410583,
0.31485286355018616,
0.6323291659355164,
0.4803675711154938,
0.41804423928260803,
-0.21114301681518555,
-0.5437330007553101,
0.07756958901882172,
-0.6853280663490295,
-0.37676092982292175,
1.1343194246292114,
0.5904421806335449,
1.0941208600997925,
-0.15793326497077942,
0.6036363840103149,
-0.015733081847429276,
0.4702090322971344,
-0.6100271940231323,
0.4380314350128174,
-0.01665598526597023,
-0.6329489350318909,
-0.3375036120414734,
-0.3610522449016571,
-1.0486539602279663,
-0.1106305792927742,
-0.19584594666957855,
-0.46433040499687195,
0.05933677777647972,
0.3110395669937134,
-0.795141339302063,
0.22563205659389496,
-0.36260202527046204,
0.5540222525596619,
-0.13974156975746155,
-0.24223442375659943,
0.1730131357908249,
-0.8610095381736755,
0.21803420782089233,
-0.1144196093082428,
0.14660106599330902,
-0.29041218757629395,
-0.4915981590747833,
0.24907223880290985,
-0.5500635504722595,
0.562055230140686,
-0.3901727497577667,
-0.1015276238322258,
0.10203494131565094,
-0.03542039543390274,
0.4730527102947235,
0.03755706921219826,
-0.27178826928138733,
0.17379756271839142,
-0.13643158972263336,
-0.3068591356277466,
-0.5701994299888611,
0.6910446286201477,
-0.48070260882377625,
-0.6188288927078247,
-0.036874689161777496,
-0.5975779294967651,
-0.46467986702919006,
0.2742854058742523,
0.48282551765441895,
0.4762278199195862,
-0.03773405775427818,
0.1914842575788498,
1.0383074283599854,
-0.5741202235221863,
0.11949831247329712,
0.834868848323822,
-0.4863392412662506,
-0.4066299796104431,
0.6187299489974976,
0.1610250473022461,
0.3549407422542572,
0.20068645477294922,
0.5480654239654541,
-0.5682321190834045,
-0.776063084602356,
-0.9167959094047546,
0.2376147210597992,
-0.5562354922294617,
-0.3274158537387848,
-0.71875,
-0.39571595191955566,
-0.3544937074184418,
-0.1667848378419876,
-0.06745924800634384,
-0.16108763217926025,
-0.43828752636909485,
0.06741531938314438,
0.499899685382843,
0.8136911988258362,
0.1820129007101059,
-0.14587312936782837,
-1.0488650798797607,
0.39805731177330017,
0.043419912457466125,
0.6875587701797485,
-0.30296605825424194,
-0.4667488634586334,
0.058849580585956573,
-0.07004600763320923,
-0.07078967988491058,
-1.063759446144104,
-0.04346950352191925,
-0.025456659495830536,
0.7230303883552551,
0.3647734224796295,
0.4655555486679077,
0.340188205242157,
-0.612938642501831,
0.9036734104156494,
0.26339882612228394,
-0.4963470995426178,
0.794144868850708,
-0.28787922859191895,
0.6017992496490479,
0.5985859036445618,
0.5549638271331787,
-0.3038269579410553,
-0.6744024157524109,
-0.3100059926509857,
-0.5517047643661499,
0.6210271120071411,
-0.01942351832985878,
-0.20463505387306213,
-0.017550401389598846,
0.3559507131576538,
0.3755131661891937,
0.39054667949676514,
-0.18018917739391327,
-0.1264578402042389,
0.2108430564403534,
-0.436805784702301,
0.21242301166057587,
-0.1529306024312973,
-0.18648789823055267,
-0.007516966201364994,
0.5353238582611084,
-0.21232345700263977,
0.16228821873664856,
0.5684812068939209,
0.03508911654353142,
-0.264178067445755,
0.4219534397125244,
0.855122983455658,
0.6853604912757874,
-0.11429117619991302,
-0.11606168001890182,
0.20861268043518066,
-0.49024587869644165,
0.1295129507780075,
0.15850073099136353,
-0.39710238575935364,
0.14423711597919464,
-0.010445421561598778,
0.7493732571601868,
0.0442468598484993,
-0.958702802658081,
0.3206060826778412,
0.13565756380558014,
-0.17786791920661926,
0.47336336970329285,
0.019619427621364594,
0.08396371454000473,
0.31611981987953186,
0.3205742835998535,
0.14528888463974,
0.20675240457057953,
-0.27852901816368103,
0.056250084191560745,
0.3781920075416565,
-0.6582043170928955,
-0.1510910838842392,
0.981942892074585,
0.18827468156814575,
-0.3176821768283844,
0.3449201285839081,
0.193537175655365,
0.002428140491247177,
0.4159907400608063,
0.4726582169532776,
0.7947055697441101,
-0.47976893186569214,
-0.1579921543598175,
0.3128489851951599,
0.35619068145751953,
-0.11810769885778427,
0.9075062274932861,
0.19075137376785278,
-0.08211064338684082,
-0.5382153987884521,
-0.5392772555351257,
-0.703118085861206,
0.09104614704847336,
-0.5996283292770386,
0.31457942724227905,
-0.533554196357727,
-0.19860978424549103,
-0.19978941977024078,
-0.4022305905818939,
-0.5221211910247803,
0.14740322530269623,
-0.06573076546192169,
1.5627782344818115,
-0.489246666431427,
0.4669214189052582,
1.0289701223373413,
-0.24318048357963562,
-0.7217448353767395,
-0.22255252301692963,
0.050654955208301544,
-1.0981111526489258,
0.2898048162460327,
0.15033668279647827,
0.15184643864631653,
0.06834601610898972,
-0.673200249671936,
-0.5720930695533752,
1.0317487716674805,
0.57620769739151,
-0.790492057800293,
-0.22120602428913116,
-0.12707626819610596,
0.4131850600242615,
-0.2940223813056946,
0.3265507221221924,
0.12279567867517471,
0.33436283469200134,
0.13310277462005615,
-1.0734769105911255,
0.39888614416122437,
-0.05179072916507721,
-0.21943582594394684,
0.22668211162090302,
-0.3381897211074829,
0.8793254494667053,
-0.6288999915122986,
-0.16894172132015228,
0.49322646856307983,
0.2056511491537094,
0.7029281854629517,
0.7875415086746216,
0.292511522769928,
0.1756075620651245,
1.0513992309570312,
-0.1310235559940338,
0.9322080612182617,
-0.47920337319374084,
0.02597232349216938,
0.9192168712615967,
-0.5066508650779724,
0.8299477696418762,
0.3683283030986786,
-0.150504931807518,
0.15525786578655243,
0.6651299595832825,
0.37448766827583313,
0.32332897186279297,
0.13871082663536072,
-0.41405096650123596,
-0.13108308613300323,
-0.29387491941452026,
-0.7756099700927734,
-0.23345457017421722,
0.33756768703460693,
-0.6476619243621826,
-0.3023720979690552,
0.5510549545288086,
-0.16453202068805695,
-0.02856002002954483,
-0.6355351805686951,
0.9474727511405945,
0.17438383400440216,
-0.7113780379295349,
0.499187707901001,
-0.34784650802612305,
0.39478254318237305,
-0.836923360824585,
0.00937766581773758,
-0.10317830741405487,
-0.16148069500923157,
-0.20576651394367218,
-0.8388280868530273,
0.05778905749320984,
0.10655517876148224,
-0.27782174944877625,
-0.25109219551086426,
0.9069364666938782,
-0.24010047316551208,
-0.13322077691555023,
-0.011055444367229939,
0.7003397345542908,
0.22415344417095184,
-0.2245282679796219,
-0.5881111025810242,
0.1458795964717865,
-0.14483214914798737,
-0.1622713953256607,
0.2933349311351776,
0.47078752517700195,
-0.135320782661438,
0.7669447660446167,
0.9420893788337708,
0.44680550694465637,
0.10832926630973816,
0.05417667329311371,
1.036535382270813,
-0.5402310490608215,
-0.491731196641922,
-0.9341864585876465,
0.4990260899066925,
0.04325120523571968,
-0.38929057121276855,
0.5450169444084167,
0.49809810519218445,
0.30891138315200806,
-0.2126467078924179,
0.6789649128913879,
0.2451958954334259,
1.0049182176589966,
-0.7448498606681824,
0.858190655708313,
-0.608085572719574,
0.14459159970283508,
0.11816171556711197,
-0.5296033620834351,
-0.35049009323120117,
0.030186744406819344,
-0.19848453998565674,
-0.18882355093955994,
0.5167392492294312,
0.7907488346099854,
0.26648667454719543,
0.22444476187229156,
0.6031718850135803,
0.47930023074150085,
0.12017818540334702,
0.4646250903606415,
1.038418173789978,
0.11513675004243851,
0.3563401699066162,
0.32447871565818787,
-0.653936505317688,
-0.4653443694114685,
-0.7449212670326233,
-0.6984178423881531,
-0.1343342363834381,
-0.14292097091674805,
-0.4886954724788666,
0.1598169356584549,
1.2623900175094604,
0.5834037661552429,
-0.8533006906509399,
0.32794561982154846,
-0.006832081358879805,
-0.01026223972439766,
-0.24203798174858093,
-0.12560221552848816,
0.06321744620800018,
-0.503993034362793,
-0.45502769947052,
0.7243677973747253,
0.596442699432373,
0.051110703498125076,
-0.32789671421051025,
-0.22120438516139984,
0.20314307510852814,
0.26112300157546997,
0.36248329281806946,
0.47412535548210144,
-0.9521263837814331,
0.1357211023569107,
0.6558409929275513,
-0.33634668588638306,
0.20827314257621765,
0.8561787009239197,
-0.835326075553894,
0.6984347105026245,
0.6486415863037109,
0.9420644044876099,
-0.1613793671131134,
0.11456580460071564,
0.4330082833766937,
-0.4898639917373657,
-0.3453518748283386,
0.5142173767089844,
0.30653300881385803,
0.050441473722457886,
-0.44027939438819885,
0.29824984073638916,
-0.04972551017999649,
-0.7824190258979797,
-0.9619330763816833,
0.17951615154743195,
-0.6826561689376831,
-0.397468239068985,
0.9804931282997131,
-0.202785462141037,
-0.1304446905851364,
-0.39306366443634033,
-0.7331677675247192,
0.07009194791316986,
-0.3761560022830963,
0.36430248618125916,
0.41741567850112915,
-0.3597055971622467,
-0.08830193430185318,
-0.8044460415840149,
0.44744640588760376,
0.43428918719291687,
-0.8685199022293091,
-0.08501076698303223,
0.43940430879592896,
0.3919575810432434,
-0.07339829951524734,
0.9428771734237671,
-0.4172450006008148,
0.5931230783462524,
-0.4919548034667969,
0.02197931706905365,
-0.5229230523109436,
-0.29627540707588196,
-0.6421173810958862,
0.49906978011131287,
0.3668188154697418,
-0.4433193504810333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19350v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19350v5
|
Prompting Explicit and Implicit Knowledge for Multi-hop Question Answering Based on Human Reading Process
| 2024-02-29T16:56:36 | 2024-06-28T00:26:41 |
Guangming Huang, Yunfei Long, Cunjin Luo, Jiaxing Shen, Xia Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) leverage chains-of-thought (CoT) to
simulate human reasoning and inference processes, achieving proficient
performance in multi-hop QA. However, a gap persists between PLMs' reasoning
abilities and those of humans when tackling complex problems. Psychological
studies suggest a vital connection between explicit information in passages and
human prior knowledge during reading. Nevertheless, current research has given
insufficient attention to linking input passages and PLMs' pre-training-based
knowledge from the perspective of human cognition studies. In this study, we
introduce a Prompting Explicit and Implicit knowledge (PEI) framework, which
uses prompts to connect explicit and implicit knowledge, aligning with human
reading process for multi-hop QA. We consider the input passages as explicit
knowledge, employing them to elicit implicit knowledge through unified prompt
reasoning. Furthermore, our model incorporates type-specific reasoning via
prompts, a form of implicit knowledge. Experimental results show that PEI
performs comparably to the state-of-the-art on HotpotQA. Ablation studies
confirm the efficacy of our model in bridging and integrating explicit and
implicit knowledge.
|
[
-0.4124581813812256,
-0.9548844695091248,
1.105888843536377,
0.10624969750642776,
-0.23596741259098053,
0.11696748435497284,
0.06728648394346237,
-0.4525807201862335,
-0.4009269177913666,
0.45738425850868225,
-0.6867175698280334,
-0.34574946761131287,
-0.19704265892505646,
0.2858577370643616,
-0.032332874834537506,
0.404835969209671,
-0.07923013716936111,
-0.11586136370897293,
-0.2568419575691223,
0.15681126713752747,
-0.7306161522865295,
-0.5685243606567383,
-0.7337772846221924,
-0.24790151417255402,
0.8003284335136414,
0.29098400473594666,
0.37466877698898315,
0.3401798903942108,
0.14136409759521484,
0.2339339256286621,
-0.1356639713048935,
0.37170347571372986,
0.06970112770795822,
0.25936681032180786,
-0.13419471681118011,
-0.6439305543899536,
-0.17557397484779358,
0.13058894872665405,
0.7130003571510315,
0.7308309674263,
0.20942728221416473,
-0.08485788851976395,
0.14311251044273376,
0.5275707840919495,
-0.6330075263977051,
-0.06649777293205261,
-0.39375045895576477,
-0.05475080385804176,
0.011343196034431458,
-0.40942543745040894,
-0.6354579329490662,
-0.4991486966609955,
0.5092271566390991,
-0.739446222782135,
0.11701666563749313,
0.20065759122371674,
0.532906174659729,
0.3294391334056854,
-0.7568880319595337,
-0.4095718562602997,
-0.5550031661987305,
0.3800908923149109,
-0.31185808777809143,
0.5593273043632507,
0.4885571599006653,
-0.04052765667438507,
0.10008557140827179,
-0.553175151348114,
-0.7667129039764404,
-0.0832388773560524,
-0.2594487965106964,
0.11403433978557587,
0.022208765149116516,
0.21563781797885895,
0.28914040327072144,
-0.14716081321239471,
-0.5597414970397949,
-0.3136221766471863,
-0.5008925199508667,
0.02498585544526577,
0.3111017048358917,
-0.11814621090888977,
0.39856767654418945,
-0.004058752208948135,
-0.8403924107551575,
-0.08842775970697403,
-0.6121204495429993,
0.62321537733078,
0.11459735780954361,
0.2014320343732834,
0.18340079486370087,
0.3259086012840271,
-0.14240649342536926,
0.8054969310760498,
0.1603805422782898,
0.24643699824810028,
0.2930384576320648,
-0.24406784772872925,
-0.012313160113990307,
-0.04908638447523117,
0.6221858859062195,
0.014831333421170712,
0.5476585030555725,
-0.22295400500297546,
0.2836073935031891,
-0.16775524616241455,
0.2413041889667511,
-0.32723718881607056,
0.04346736893057823,
0.43299493193626404,
-0.03641544282436371,
0.24035032093524933,
0.15014532208442688,
-0.7049371600151062,
-0.42352184653282166,
-0.39885327219963074,
0.5754434466362,
-0.6280342936515808,
-0.3315961956977844,
0.31663966178894043,
-0.22984300553798676,
0.514308512210846,
0.4188985228538513,
-0.5989172458648682,
0.05898743495345116,
0.40950602293014526,
0.6213683485984802,
0.17623697221279144,
-0.6126713752746582,
-0.5493441820144653,
0.4564778208732605,
-0.08246365934610367,
1.1413403749465942,
-0.4986917972564697,
-0.25393423438072205,
-0.08820790797472,
-0.25538524985313416,
-0.6088743805885315,
0.0442352332174778,
0.4709111154079437,
-0.8486478328704834,
0.2947238087654114,
-0.5235183835029602,
-0.4654165506362915,
-0.36155399680137634,
0.4795570969581604,
-0.44397348165512085,
0.908841609954834,
-0.21732482314109802,
-0.9229240417480469,
0.1963665783405304,
-0.8762115836143494,
-0.3932589292526245,
-0.016187265515327454,
-0.018142281100153923,
0.12217159569263458,
-0.19511957466602325,
0.6890530586242676,
0.3162592351436615,
-0.06043986603617668,
0.31373196840286255,
-0.14709025621414185,
-0.4695795178413391,
0.4020841717720032,
-0.4075756072998047,
0.8089907169342041,
0.12154457718133926,
-0.26218634843826294,
0.22470667958259583,
-0.23602195084095,
0.1262003630399704,
-0.17072448134422302,
-0.2732718586921692,
-0.43476852774620056,
-0.1235729455947876,
-0.6776121258735657,
0.45440202951431274,
0.009846172295510769,
-0.5005390048027039,
0.36022019386291504,
-0.2895336449146271,
0.3715868592262268,
0.7660099864006042,
0.29536956548690796,
0.5108868479728699,
-0.23500747978687286,
0.507379949092865,
0.20041340589523315,
0.3509621322154999,
-0.5076937079429626,
-0.7501576542854309,
-0.49787554144859314,
-0.08981878310441971,
0.2427850067615509,
0.8022720813751221,
-0.8187915682792664,
0.17845085263252258,
0.2229090929031372,
-0.11371761560440063,
-0.599938690662384,
-0.010508745908737183,
0.3943215012550354,
0.7768619060516357,
0.5500063896179199,
0.14390309154987335,
-0.17061080038547516,
-0.3296807110309601,
-0.36458685994148254,
-0.45767584443092346,
-0.09232565760612488,
0.23064658045768738,
0.212899312376976,
-0.0137150464579463,
1.0429853200912476,
-0.5891352295875549,
-0.06592421978712082,
-0.15143872797489166,
0.45553669333457947,
-0.04329043626785278,
0.47247371077537537,
0.17450767755508423,
-0.763017475605011,
-0.23435507714748383,
-0.46157994866371155,
-0.7517976760864258,
-0.10067790746688843,
-0.1084800735116005,
-0.6175508499145508,
-0.2191447615623474,
0.7042374610900879,
-0.5170098543167114,
0.23090751469135284,
0.219682976603508,
-0.6702794432640076,
0.6984805464744568,
-0.19155403971672058,
0.3709394335746765,
-0.841399610042572,
0.21284985542297363,
-0.08249898999929428,
0.014998198486864567,
-0.5610811114311218,
0.044236909598112106,
0.09920889884233475,
-0.019698763266205788,
-0.5618652701377869,
0.8503655195236206,
-0.5853807330131531,
0.1562066376209259,
0.11667938530445099,
0.16695451736450195,
0.38626828789711,
0.7451477646827698,
0.5286340117454529,
0.7394606471061707,
0.4712259769439697,
-0.7883384227752686,
0.08234637975692749,
0.4687190055847168,
0.11015037447214127,
0.4584745764732361,
-0.7454468607902527,
0.4386575222015381,
-0.2701590657234192,
0.2646470069885254,
-1.0858945846557617,
0.2352546751499176,
0.31418168544769287,
-0.4787845313549042,
-0.043691929429769516,
-0.2889483869075775,
-0.42349445819854736,
-0.49182355403900146,
-0.10402655601501465,
0.5129157304763794,
0.4465453326702118,
-0.42787471413612366,
0.7684957981109619,
-0.12121158093214035,
-0.4004119336605072,
-0.6778039336204529,
-0.3476157486438751,
-0.40238678455352783,
-0.04698542505502701,
-0.708768367767334,
-0.0782032161951065,
-0.3160577416419983,
0.07386528700590134,
-0.1002378985285759,
0.04639887809753418,
-0.3479662537574768,
-0.05521783605217934,
0.11550342291593552,
0.39618170261383057,
-0.2525178790092468,
0.3326212167739868,
0.22799460589885712,
-0.14072559773921967,
0.3103705942630768,
-0.5008455514907837,
0.3463810682296753,
-0.3612388074398041,
-0.44988182187080383,
-0.5447018146514893,
0.45657113194465637,
0.4108976721763611,
-0.5257169008255005,
0.6202041506767273,
0.6075565814971924,
-0.0603836327791214,
0.15747655928134918,
-0.6426758170127869,
-0.3765479326248169,
-0.42802414298057556,
-0.23506216704845428,
-0.5464298725128174,
-0.8658391833305359,
0.2996487319469452,
-0.31236761808395386,
0.05513709783554077,
0.1251658946275711,
0.22528813779354095,
-0.6619786024093628,
1.1586217880249023,
0.4823901653289795,
0.3621165156364441,
0.4469924867153168,
-0.07992876321077347,
-0.037590693682432175,
-1.0795025825500488,
-0.4314546287059784,
-0.5965597033500671,
-0.10612963885068893,
0.2429821491241455,
-0.44841185212135315,
0.497518926858902,
0.4433480203151703,
-0.4203842580318451,
-0.30364665389060974,
-0.2997265160083771,
0.5381700396537781,
0.9834612607955933,
0.2858981490135193,
0.5901501774787903,
-0.2191184163093567,
-0.7487087845802307,
0.31263095140457153,
-0.7627128958702087,
-0.3743134140968323,
0.9937831163406372,
0.10582534968852997,
0.42213883996009827,
-0.14043065905570984,
0.37579792737960815,
0.22440503537654877,
0.056147251278162,
-0.38787806034088135,
0.2947145402431488,
0.489851176738739,
-0.7999069094657898,
-0.44769516587257385,
-0.3302946090698242,
-1.0555713176727295,
0.27801087498664856,
-0.20723956823349,
-0.5699209570884705,
0.37844449281692505,
0.34622862935066223,
-0.8145650029182434,
0.37671276926994324,
-0.8613240718841553,
0.6838995814323425,
-0.32507094740867615,
-0.3853236734867096,
0.14243091642856598,
-1.0187039375305176,
0.39045462012290955,
0.34635868668556213,
0.21710939705371857,
0.024968117475509644,
0.07132015377283096,
0.6358714699745178,
-0.10371643304824829,
0.8626851439476013,
-0.30106815695762634,
-0.08134573698043823,
0.5900295376777649,
0.005916541907936335,
0.24517518281936646,
0.17127159237861633,
-0.019567565992474556,
-0.23031993210315704,
0.04478198289871216,
-0.5455378293991089,
-0.571395754814148,
0.033010758459568024,
-0.8402560353279114,
-0.520704984664917,
-0.6725969314575195,
-0.6478966474533081,
-0.7496131658554077,
0.26035022735595703,
0.2671191692352295,
0.3657081127166748,
0.05139712616801262,
-0.3487332761287689,
1.2052257061004639,
-0.0861923098564148,
0.12734296917915344,
0.7031981945037842,
-0.04968960955739021,
-0.09047339856624603,
0.4347454309463501,
-0.2839266061782837,
0.16111356019973755,
0.527268648147583,
0.20276804268360138,
-0.9550451636314392,
-0.4220612645149231,
-0.590141773223877,
0.4480205774307251,
-0.5646700859069824,
-0.04500211775302887,
-0.8318187594413757,
-0.1480150818824768,
-0.4094579815864563,
-0.3200789988040924,
0.06190958246588707,
0.08598901331424713,
-0.08963354676961899,
-0.06688418984413147,
0.32332751154899597,
0.6747899651527405,
0.053886909037828445,
0.3500683903694153,
-1.0297425985336304,
0.550125777721405,
0.8285472393035889,
0.3750934898853302,
0.08450990915298462,
-0.24826481938362122,
0.06263067573308945,
0.1158604547381401,
-0.1475963443517685,
-1.1631124019622803,
-0.020729832351207733,
-0.17718079686164856,
0.553267240524292,
0.5029445290565491,
0.31539642810821533,
0.4529047906398773,
-0.37883925437927246,
0.5460976362228394,
0.09460820257663727,
-0.9614800810813904,
0.7013692259788513,
-0.3812839984893799,
0.5141794085502625,
0.7318342328071594,
0.6103813648223877,
-0.704415500164032,
-0.29168012738227844,
-0.5163186192512512,
-0.6571487784385681,
0.7295342087745667,
0.02831847593188286,
-0.25171560049057007,
0.09054405242204666,
0.3633913993835449,
0.11467341333627701,
0.2742699682712555,
-0.5262230038642883,
0.03067420795559883,
-0.009958022274076939,
-0.11760406941175461,
0.1373019814491272,
-0.11367223411798477,
0.06430183351039886,
-0.2548069357872009,
0.5480942130088806,
-0.22284677624702454,
0.28063368797302246,
0.4979570508003235,
-0.5080462098121643,
0.03257482498884201,
0.48522669076919556,
0.345478892326355,
0.7118021845817566,
-0.31377077102661133,
0.3231205940246582,
-0.08403744548559189,
-0.45211631059646606,
0.34087443351745605,
-0.036475829780101776,
-0.36596301198005676,
-0.41703200340270996,
0.22833481431007385,
0.5203530192375183,
0.0782349556684494,
-0.6509584188461304,
0.36040735244750977,
-0.32708317041397095,
-0.2047538161277771,
-0.020661622285842896,
0.04723316803574562,
0.29504746198654175,
0.3112882971763611,
0.4200534522533417,
0.17980284988880157,
0.011193003505468369,
-0.36158087849617004,
0.05858458951115608,
0.029336806386709213,
-0.3747198283672333,
-0.3251226842403412,
0.6182544827461243,
0.6255927681922913,
0.11516804248094559,
1.0866330862045288,
-0.1982550472021103,
-0.5680139064788818,
0.2927543520927429,
0.3321802318096161,
0.49409928917884827,
-0.3187390863895416,
0.382191002368927,
0.28732866048812866,
0.43115463852882385,
0.05178084224462509,
0.607571005821228,
-0.2924284338951111,
-0.7551184296607971,
-0.6444714069366455,
-0.3666040599346161,
-0.4729121923446655,
-0.05493520200252533,
-0.629976749420166,
0.017581405118107796,
-0.36205172538757324,
0.03943514823913574,
-0.2832949757575989,
-0.02644241414964199,
-0.820681631565094,
0.1349601000547409,
0.4131673574447632,
1.0112930536270142,
-1.0547621250152588,
0.6800337433815002,
0.7476450800895691,
-0.7489847540855408,
-1.024294137954712,
0.1543872356414795,
-0.16393987834453583,
-0.6452659964561462,
0.3466515839099884,
0.041603632271289825,
-0.2240348905324936,
0.395082026720047,
-0.36892205476760864,
-0.6893244385719299,
1.0190449953079224,
0.360027551651001,
-0.204265296459198,
-0.5473591089248657,
-0.010613912716507912,
0.23018349707126617,
-0.08306510746479034,
0.556640625,
0.5325255393981934,
0.6512545347213745,
0.3338114321231842,
-0.5470460653305054,
0.021400900557637215,
-0.3659610152244568,
-0.32182106375694275,
0.03109223209321499,
-0.37685129046440125,
0.8122097253799438,
-0.42516806721687317,
-0.05855582281947136,
-0.15263330936431885,
0.6884954571723938,
0.7403550148010254,
0.44146981835365295,
0.6305516958236694,
0.2848639190196991,
1.0668079853057861,
0.023161254823207855,
0.9371601939201355,
-0.047914426773786545,
-0.18597084283828735,
0.9850832223892212,
-0.2805800139904022,
0.8345543146133423,
0.3954225182533264,
-0.188433438539505,
0.8995772004127502,
0.757307231426239,
0.54512619972229,
0.22272051870822906,
-0.20732097327709198,
-0.2364598512649536,
-0.5034696459770203,
0.03767915442585945,
-0.5134937763214111,
0.10687528550624847,
0.35675182938575745,
0.03869585320353508,
-0.03806576877832413,
0.007128444500267506,
-0.09927219152450562,
-0.10873568058013916,
-0.4547770619392395,
0.8650854825973511,
-0.05582220479846001,
-0.978532612323761,
0.41727229952812195,
-0.18697726726531982,
0.553170919418335,
-0.7934586405754089,
-0.024087155237793922,
-0.13532674312591553,
-0.2981410622596741,
0.0899031013250351,
-1.020099401473999,
-0.01305771991610527,
0.06378257274627686,
-0.41012683510780334,
-0.2975504994392395,
0.6502663493156433,
-0.5172011256217957,
-0.2877008020877838,
0.1457674205303192,
1.0278037786483765,
0.2519210875034332,
-0.5689507126808167,
-0.7689465880393982,
-0.4233410358428955,
-0.1909675896167755,
-0.19555987417697906,
-0.000796761829406023,
0.5809159874916077,
-0.13557878136634827,
0.5718296766281128,
0.910475492477417,
-0.026102924719452858,
0.3681511878967285,
0.24263949692249298,
0.5963736176490784,
-0.7125235795974731,
-0.958555281162262,
-0.4975767731666565,
0.671389102935791,
0.1311858743429184,
-0.3034569323062897,
0.45997995138168335,
0.12510183453559875,
0.4829913079738617,
-0.02693810500204563,
0.9236311912536621,
0.24774955213069916,
0.5045421123504639,
-0.655505895614624,
0.49444010853767395,
-0.23940697312355042,
0.06727416813373566,
-0.31011128425598145,
-0.668092668056488,
-0.06925685703754425,
0.36405646800994873,
-0.494417667388916,
0.13550959527492523,
0.9783614873886108,
0.3063119053840637,
-0.02252608723938465,
0.22335852682590485,
0.15141335129737854,
0.05063260719180107,
-0.08888386934995651,
0.7833991050720215,
1.2276049852371216,
-0.04986565187573433,
0.7058618068695068,
0.0440903939306736,
-0.20902366936206818,
-0.07406176626682281,
-0.7324170470237732,
-0.9198660850524902,
-0.753677248954773,
-0.0981525257229805,
-0.07527166604995728,
0.2263164222240448,
0.7427897453308105,
0.696722686290741,
-0.4800652861595154,
0.0464920736849308,
-0.1261005997657776,
0.4827490448951721,
-0.5338983535766602,
-0.19517038762569427,
0.4886847138404846,
-0.5148676633834839,
-0.5707327127456665,
0.31287652254104614,
0.07525547593832016,
0.051246799528598785,
-0.1664636731147766,
-0.10837294161319733,
-0.6799769401550293,
0.24852842092514038,
0.5637819170951843,
0.4690530002117157,
-0.5397844910621643,
-0.03263940289616585,
0.3774460554122925,
0.07725045830011368,
0.0772601068019867,
1.1288666725158691,
-1.221463680267334,
0.367156982421875,
0.6028232574462891,
0.5818161964416504,
0.21042725443840027,
0.4009236693382263,
0.6884570717811584,
-0.9289461970329285,
0.013434324413537979,
0.3369360566139221,
0.22455789148807526,
0.06574124842882156,
-0.5386586785316467,
0.2901282012462616,
0.18093164265155792,
-0.45339855551719666,
-0.47376957535743713,
0.311251699924469,
-0.8535704612731934,
-0.4713594615459442,
0.986455500125885,
-0.23328813910484314,
-0.3415524959564209,
-0.6800718307495117,
-0.41497305035591125,
0.354907751083374,
-0.5055954456329346,
0.5174788236618042,
0.6129007935523987,
-0.45428356528282166,
-0.3820764124393463,
-0.1961231380701065,
0.47526147961616516,
0.3712558150291443,
-0.9988234043121338,
0.03641023114323616,
0.3715122640132904,
0.2115125060081482,
-0.02062557265162468,
0.9955247044563293,
0.05015047639608383,
0.571186363697052,
-0.11238674819469452,
0.1577111929655075,
-0.4206809401512146,
-0.6565883159637451,
-0.2767280340194702,
0.3102784752845764,
0.10654682666063309,
0.00025503270444460213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19334v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19334v2
|
Here's a Free Lunch: Sanitizing Backdoored Models with Model Merge
| 2024-02-29T16:37:08 | 2024-06-03T16:19:03 |
Ansh Arora, Xuanli He, Maximilian Mozes, Srinibas Swain, Mark Dras, Qiongkai Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The democratization of pre-trained language models through open-source
initiatives has rapidly advanced innovation and expanded access to cutting-edge
technologies. However, this openness also brings significant security risks,
including backdoor attacks, where hidden malicious behaviors are triggered by
specific inputs, compromising natural language processing (NLP) system
integrity and reliability. This paper suggests that merging a backdoored model
with other homogeneous models can significantly remediate backdoor
vulnerabilities even if such models are not entirely secure. In our
experiments, we verify our hypothesis on various models (BERT-Base,
RoBERTa-Large, Llama2-7B, and Mistral-7B) and datasets (SST-2, OLID, AG News,
and QNLI). Compared to multiple advanced defensive approaches, our method
offers an effective and efficient inference-stage defense against backdoor
attacks on classification and instruction-tuned tasks without additional
resources or specific knowledge. Our approach consistently outperforms recent
advanced baselines, leading to an average of about 75% reduction in the attack
success rate. Since model merging has been an established approach for
improving model performance, the extra advantage it provides regarding defense
can be seen as a cost-free bonus.
|
[
-0.06754600256681442,
-0.6805678606033325,
0.35764944553375244,
-0.24053263664245605,
0.005371458362787962,
-0.08250611275434494,
-0.08838322758674622,
-0.5151633620262146,
-0.339193195104599,
0.819184422492981,
-0.2647359073162079,
-0.538155198097229,
-0.527586042881012,
-0.43829068541526794,
-0.833482027053833,
1.1585094928741455,
0.28990429639816284,
-0.011247273534536362,
-0.15135306119918823,
0.17244376242160797,
-0.3501037061214447,
-0.658050000667572,
-0.2963865399360657,
-0.21543756127357483,
0.44860705733299255,
0.04001796990633011,
0.9370265603065491,
0.3999920189380646,
0.5484538078308105,
0.22682267427444458,
0.055330973118543625,
-0.27442610263824463,
-0.44404008984565735,
0.4570196866989136,
-0.5542094707489014,
-0.3897355794906616,
-0.6545655727386475,
0.3036952018737793,
0.3465796411037445,
0.5505563616752625,
-0.3274649381637573,
0.09036997705698013,
0.042115211486816406,
0.5157132744789124,
-0.9492122530937195,
-0.3754085302352905,
-0.8002529144287109,
0.1414232850074768,
0.015453510917723179,
0.0915992483496666,
-0.8025118112564087,
-0.561322808265686,
-0.1269170045852661,
-0.26168614625930786,
0.1503138393163681,
-0.14771191775798798,
0.8302278518676758,
0.25945815443992615,
-0.11298061907291412,
0.40668919682502747,
-0.6976118683815002,
0.6692183613777161,
-1.032821536064148,
0.8495643734931946,
0.2771872580051422,
0.3524935841560364,
-0.39607951045036316,
-0.4636865258216858,
-0.4585016965866089,
-0.2053317129611969,
0.12475574761629105,
-0.05071321129798889,
-0.7923874855041504,
0.05540665239095688,
0.12809251248836517,
0.3383403718471527,
-0.6361355781555176,
0.4814058244228363,
-0.538832426071167,
-0.1563170999288559,
0.744152307510376,
-0.05406918749213219,
0.5151203870773315,
0.1420777440071106,
-0.4830542802810669,
-0.4690462350845337,
-0.8284662365913391,
0.09733360260725021,
0.6434179544448853,
0.5716474652290344,
-0.20005786418914795,
0.5290855765342712,
0.06363993883132935,
0.46796557307243347,
-0.21254897117614746,
0.19900299608707428,
-0.0043676309287548065,
-0.4348396360874176,
-0.5497292876243591,
-0.2012965828180313,
0.5685865879058838,
0.40120115876197815,
0.13935458660125732,
-0.620633065700531,
-0.38678064942359924,
0.03278028964996338,
0.6820672750473022,
-0.7746725678443909,
-0.25419431924819946,
0.5188252329826355,
-0.5643448829650879,
-0.6001522541046143,
0.12239611893892288,
-0.8018065094947815,
-0.2881680428981781,
0.22103145718574524,
0.467405766248703,
-0.3642600476741791,
-0.39493313431739807,
-0.059148259460926056,
-0.49421805143356323,
0.44068288803100586,
0.41121914982795715,
-0.694943368434906,
0.2908499836921692,
1.1380796432495117,
0.728435218334198,
0.0612516850233078,
-0.10639198124408722,
-0.5506578087806702,
0.2809147536754608,
-0.5483466386795044,
0.3182564675807953,
-0.45566457509994507,
-0.5838527083396912,
-0.19224417209625244,
-0.15751685202121735,
-0.03631230816245079,
-0.3872934877872467,
-0.020100072026252747,
-0.7980180382728577,
0.4043814539909363,
0.10291309654712677,
-0.2193891704082489,
-0.342026948928833,
0.5434895157814026,
-0.8163820505142212,
0.781912624835968,
-0.025545261800289154,
-0.8439449071884155,
-0.057147376239299774,
-0.2983720898628235,
-0.284885048866272,
-0.03569720685482025,
0.011481287889182568,
-0.3794504404067993,
0.18121138215065002,
0.1073036715388298,
0.2640669345855713,
-0.2066989243030548,
0.2723950743675232,
-0.6997328996658325,
-0.07296983897686005,
0.1421172320842743,
-0.3589794337749481,
1.1448373794555664,
0.21257168054580688,
-0.1762869656085968,
0.37141549587249756,
-0.5290631651878357,
0.13798615336418152,
0.00235424074344337,
-0.09418191015720367,
-0.615531325340271,
-0.37876489758491516,
-0.3911602795124054,
0.21451258659362793,
0.04621826857328415,
-0.5833397507667542,
0.17710015177726746,
-0.8284616470336914,
-0.03352155163884163,
0.8838376402854919,
-0.042445000261068344,
0.7319782972335815,
-0.36282092332839966,
0.5589986443519592,
0.010635708458721638,
0.47693347930908203,
-0.2107035517692566,
-0.8298256993293762,
-0.44069066643714905,
-0.4128122925758362,
0.3724958598613739,
0.9149441123008728,
-0.5092677474021912,
0.47788962721824646,
0.04859362170100212,
-0.8851186037063599,
-0.5562597513198853,
-0.07325655221939087,
0.6789032816886902,
0.49137917160987854,
0.4687754511833191,
-0.38888970017433167,
-0.28927505016326904,
-0.8855039477348328,
-0.489259272813797,
-0.10782762616872787,
-0.2266080230474472,
-0.006469534710049629,
0.6494858264923096,
-0.38395991921424866,
0.8132324814796448,
-0.27057427167892456,
0.055933985859155655,
0.18717341125011444,
-0.1606680452823639,
0.07743874192237854,
0.8958152532577515,
0.5569934844970703,
-0.5383063554763794,
0.02649320289492607,
0.032311368733644485,
-0.7723957300186157,
0.21504279971122742,
0.4691287577152252,
-0.050640273839235306,
0.0896873027086258,
0.5269021391868591,
-0.5775648951530457,
0.6862571239471436,
0.7949120402336121,
-0.07785781472921371,
0.38394835591316223,
-0.0706472396850586,
0.09007907658815384,
-1.189109206199646,
-0.02267554961144924,
-0.21548476815223694,
0.08327419310808182,
-0.9534872174263,
0.8044845461845398,
0.13591304421424866,
-0.7638509273529053,
-0.4833039343357086,
0.7840942740440369,
-0.27095916867256165,
-0.09050635993480682,
0.02403716742992401,
-0.01916421577334404,
-0.20295469462871552,
0.31470543146133423,
-0.5525206923484802,
0.5143262147903442,
0.48954275250434875,
-0.3755686283111572,
0.36284568905830383,
-0.05205518752336502,
-0.0027158281300216913,
0.06635857373476028,
-0.701616644859314,
0.4083077013492584,
0.13691085577011108,
0.5241349935531616,
-1.0128220319747925,
-0.15159618854522705,
0.7025203704833984,
-0.5098018646240234,
0.3280712962150574,
-0.2654881775379181,
-0.2940939962863922,
-0.10791283845901489,
-0.648513674736023,
0.3838382661342621,
0.5834309458732605,
-0.6697999835014343,
0.9098629355430603,
0.07483870536088943,
-0.11850743740797043,
-0.8830761909484863,
-0.7715369462966919,
-0.05661381408572197,
0.09436824172735214,
-1.0573841333389282,
0.25773391127586365,
0.06244286522269249,
-0.3567001521587372,
0.2195443958044052,
-0.15279044210910797,
-0.2735564708709717,
0.5691959261894226,
0.5167000889778137,
0.46497535705566406,
-0.37747475504875183,
-0.13660387694835663,
0.16534988582134247,
-0.04207479953765869,
-0.15994611382484436,
-0.33075809478759766,
0.3803936839103699,
-0.009735957719385624,
-0.5592231750488281,
-0.6166204810142517,
0.692739725112915,
0.6657009720802307,
-0.5760865211486816,
1.0005849599838257,
0.31272652745246887,
-0.5767346024513245,
-0.13542944192886353,
-0.4623906910419464,
-0.6511879563331604,
-0.42415282130241394,
0.11188150942325592,
-0.09631900489330292,
-0.856011688709259,
0.4391193389892578,
0.4398805499076843,
0.6729772686958313,
0.10972616821527481,
0.30983009934425354,
0.266571581363678,
0.7919713854789734,
0.7399826049804688,
-0.0025741159915924072,
0.3288739025592804,
0.027330758050084114,
0.6741411089897156,
-0.49448448419570923,
-0.42208656668663025,
-0.6276246905326843,
-0.023188700899481773,
-0.6227343082427979,
-0.3337293267250061,
-0.14573855698108673,
-0.11190661042928696,
-0.07281412929296494,
0.2905397415161133,
-0.38603121042251587,
0.3198286294937134,
0.6305983066558838,
0.29756632447242737,
0.267701655626297,
-0.26990240812301636,
-0.02378331869840622,
0.2980748116970062,
-0.592914879322052,
-0.4935134947299957,
1.2231507301330566,
0.631112277507782,
1.0669186115264893,
0.35623136162757874,
1.228637933731079,
0.11415532976388931,
0.4360558092594147,
-0.5032970309257507,
0.6173979640007019,
-0.26659759879112244,
-0.6791867613792419,
-0.24038027226924896,
-0.3316553831100464,
-0.9004248380661011,
0.46322721242904663,
-0.33893147110939026,
-0.8579061627388,
0.23012353479862213,
0.45851394534111023,
-0.7097214460372925,
0.508211076259613,
-0.9969440698623657,
0.8430236577987671,
-0.14251373708248138,
-0.29784318804740906,
-0.2782963216304779,
-0.6122332811355591,
0.9989886283874512,
-0.13326187431812286,
0.3304985761642456,
0.027585074305534363,
0.16918180882930756,
0.6655027866363525,
-0.3762018084526062,
0.9445052146911621,
-0.09183666855096817,
-0.4287281036376953,
-0.42199042439460754,
0.2867387533187866,
0.3481672406196594,
-0.12618234753608704,
0.23272521793842316,
0.47536253929138184,
-0.0787162035703659,
-0.32433581352233887,
-0.7394862771034241,
0.6324365139007568,
-0.5500703454017639,
-1.2039438486099243,
-0.40574315190315247,
-0.42596542835235596,
-0.021533068269491196,
0.250895231962204,
0.14189332723617554,
0.18623487651348114,
-0.0630917176604271,
0.39168301224708557,
0.7857954502105713,
-0.3353422284126282,
0.4321359694004059,
0.5565209984779358,
-0.2542593479156494,
-0.3954351246356964,
0.3994462490081787,
-0.1258905827999115,
0.45018163323402405,
0.32352593541145325,
0.25539880990982056,
0.10451309382915497,
-0.46617570519447327,
-0.0046136025339365005,
0.13978871703147888,
-0.4708365201950073,
-0.5576571226119995,
-0.8638983964920044,
-0.5081542730331421,
-1.0359960794448853,
-0.11404874175786972,
-0.5548661947250366,
-0.3954800069332123,
-0.04701998084783554,
-0.09425874054431915,
0.15481457114219666,
0.4562593400478363,
-0.16461189091205597,
0.2979351580142975,
-1.0757745504379272,
0.18943239748477936,
0.38419920206069946,
0.19565866887569427,
0.3941139876842499,
-0.4125099778175354,
-0.08377578854560852,
0.16284693777561188,
-0.24342626333236694,
-1.1917446851730347,
0.4162597358226776,
-0.15964552760124207,
0.7309296131134033,
0.24325533211231232,
0.11437872052192688,
0.2115916758775711,
-0.44342994689941406,
0.8217002153396606,
0.23766325414180756,
-0.7888585329055786,
0.5364020466804504,
-0.19461406767368317,
-0.13906124234199524,
0.2271253764629364,
0.27295443415641785,
-0.3264697194099426,
-0.7317022085189819,
-0.7512326240539551,
-0.9969914555549622,
0.45836013555526733,
0.12577931582927704,
0.035834379494190216,
0.3550683856010437,
-0.09140776842832565,
-0.00791154894977808,
0.3061823844909668,
-0.6024622917175293,
0.15660160779953003,
-0.43208229541778564,
0.02415040135383606,
0.2663614749908447,
-0.09438717365264893,
-0.6289172172546387,
-0.04421873018145561,
0.8470884561538696,
0.4779040217399597,
-0.031725846230983734,
-0.3038037121295929,
-0.1442294418811798,
0.17571531236171722,
0.5039787292480469,
0.46776360273361206,
0.11176067590713501,
-0.2670097351074219,
0.1876867115497589,
-0.08325065672397614,
-0.26389920711517334,
0.1333215981721878,
0.24230407178401947,
-0.15575744211673737,
-0.31694141030311584,
0.41389158368110657,
0.3049298822879791,
0.37153899669647217,
-0.440256804227829,
0.6976102590560913,
-0.2298426330089569,
0.014987513422966003,
0.07490576058626175,
0.38455891609191895,
-0.18869182467460632,
0.5146877765655518,
0.2116101086139679,
0.17753802239894867,
-0.08701324462890625,
-0.6956605315208435,
0.47052469849586487,
0.6955254673957825,
-0.14814521372318268,
-0.3074086606502533,
0.4690597951412201,
0.45066311955451965,
-0.5303918719291687,
0.888080358505249,
0.153498575091362,
-0.6503060460090637,
0.2840600311756134,
0.6356186270713806,
1.1347315311431885,
-0.7599122524261475,
-0.20012041926383972,
0.10468123853206635,
0.7792048454284668,
-0.09156660735607147,
-0.15445426106452942,
-0.10796203464269638,
-0.9722620248794556,
0.03297273814678192,
-0.35109344124794006,
-0.4456820785999298,
0.1027144119143486,
-0.672968327999115,
0.029553614556789398,
-0.6926526427268982,
-0.07769883424043655,
-0.1730404794216156,
-0.37120330333709717,
-0.29864171147346497,
0.10319096595048904,
0.032699983566999435,
1.1421266794204712,
-1.256298542022705,
0.7257535457611084,
0.30771154165267944,
-0.494063138961792,
-0.7900928258895874,
0.11211239546537399,
0.11029085516929626,
-0.5824823379516602,
0.5722617506980896,
0.12183224409818649,
-0.1911410093307495,
-0.29323866963386536,
-0.5942287445068359,
-0.7029951214790344,
0.7061015963554382,
0.4648352265357971,
-0.5315935611724854,
-0.5575345158576965,
-0.5911924839019775,
0.19399532675743103,
-0.07840178161859512,
-0.25640013813972473,
0.41805824637413025,
0.44139328598976135,
-0.2422848343849182,
-0.7751504182815552,
0.20385101437568665,
-0.4681417644023895,
-0.06662754714488983,
0.2530972361564636,
-0.12886887788772583,
1.0988349914550781,
-0.29079458117485046,
-0.3526269495487213,
0.13585181534290314,
0.688352108001709,
0.44943928718566895,
0.4257839322090149,
0.3282928168773651,
0.9087411165237427,
0.6934835314750671,
-0.10052508115768433,
0.9726362824440002,
-0.21903157234191895,
0.025219829753041267,
1.2271504402160645,
-0.3624584674835205,
0.933052659034729,
0.38779544830322266,
0.31485307216644287,
0.4603978991508484,
0.273062527179718,
-0.2811732590198517,
0.5305764675140381,
-0.12564630806446075,
-0.005033592227846384,
-0.07714812457561493,
0.22398394346237183,
-0.826869785785675,
0.48532694578170776,
-0.003093306440860033,
-0.4075348973274231,
-0.562822699546814,
0.02840961329638958,
0.29749739170074463,
0.09389223158359528,
-0.04158121347427368,
0.6166162490844727,
0.018495310097932816,
-0.5949777364730835,
0.2574820816516876,
0.09231811761856079,
0.6795722246170044,
-0.6936792135238647,
-0.040809158235788345,
-0.2203812450170517,
0.25521376729011536,
-0.3743019104003906,
-0.6751591563224792,
0.36688947677612305,
0.053650159388780594,
-0.19708314538002014,
-0.2291194051504135,
0.6858237385749817,
-0.5116303563117981,
0.0009617867763154209,
0.465787798166275,
0.33708593249320984,
-0.06912033259868622,
-0.14793601632118225,
-0.46098655462265015,
-0.04204302653670311,
-0.09411781281232834,
0.06285012513399124,
0.3676707148551941,
-0.0637703463435173,
-0.11784424632787704,
0.513028085231781,
0.9730520844459534,
0.012126022018492222,
0.19778868556022644,
-0.014914989471435547,
1.0693007707595825,
-0.610946774482727,
-0.7572805285453796,
-0.9323002696037292,
0.4466911256313324,
-0.17261695861816406,
0.17032907903194427,
1.0542984008789062,
0.5969676375389099,
1.02446448802948,
-0.01663512922823429,
0.6659126281738281,
0.5208002328872681,
0.3073559105396271,
-0.5260080099105835,
1.1519672870635986,
-0.43816402554512024,
0.2740357518196106,
-0.2844594717025757,
-0.5958312153816223,
-0.2797091603279114,
0.1748741716146469,
-0.179936483502388,
-0.004218462388962507,
0.37179774045944214,
1.11017644405365,
-0.0925164669752121,
0.00272789946757257,
0.4330722391605377,
0.08832710236310959,
0.7246453166007996,
0.3824547529220581,
0.8352410793304443,
-0.3828299045562744,
0.43521207571029663,
-0.2583164572715759,
-0.481954425573349,
-0.31804803013801575,
-0.8264874815940857,
-0.9272529482841492,
-0.2606610655784607,
-0.09664785861968994,
-0.7544753551483154,
0.5187008380889893,
0.5734552145004272,
0.671485185623169,
-0.7263482809066772,
0.014740831218659878,
0.4072396159172058,
0.3835243880748749,
-0.20732292532920837,
-0.18247178196907043,
-0.13579390943050385,
-0.16792282462120056,
-0.25808587670326233,
0.5407364964485168,
0.34551802277565,
0.2175377458333969,
-0.15755638480186462,
0.2653592526912689,
-0.16773062944412231,
0.43732950091362,
0.31947287917137146,
0.5103262066841125,
-0.8683441877365112,
-0.3402460217475891,
-0.11231786012649536,
-0.20803718268871307,
-0.3610384166240692,
0.7592421770095825,
-0.6117594838142395,
0.4008829593658447,
0.5706697702407837,
0.9598346948623657,
-0.0569840669631958,
0.08192585408687592,
0.9047957062721252,
-0.8461447954177856,
0.37651583552360535,
0.3456823527812958,
0.23850117623806,
0.3508981764316559,
-0.4219084680080414,
0.32705122232437134,
0.18152135610580444,
-0.15731693804264069,
-1.3768116235733032,
0.6067310571670532,
-0.6920074224472046,
-0.519256055355072,
0.8766229748725891,
-0.2166423797607422,
-0.5207697749137878,
0.19011332094669342,
0.4441213309764862,
0.48503220081329346,
-0.44495683908462524,
0.7218700647354126,
0.381483793258667,
0.30626025795936584,
-0.008681953884661198,
-0.06641468405723572,
0.3531402349472046,
0.02744803950190544,
-0.9072358012199402,
0.22521689534187317,
0.2893451750278473,
0.34011155366897583,
0.27161774039268494,
0.21164122223854065,
-0.38745638728141785,
0.5475156903266907,
0.15005365014076233,
0.10340341180562973,
-0.28853970766067505,
-0.6046342849731445,
-0.5553411841392517,
0.2751425504684448,
-0.2932642996311188,
-0.4877924621105194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19333v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19333v2
|
Compact Speech Translation Models via Discrete Speech Units Pretraining
| 2024-02-29T16:36:51 | 2024-06-26T09:50:28 |
Tsz Kin Lam, Alexandra Birch, Barry Haddow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We propose a pretraining method to use Self-Supervised Speech (SSS) model to
creating more compact Speech-to-text Translation. In contrast to using the SSS
model for initialization, our method is more suitable to memory constrained
scenario such as on-device deployment. Our method is based on Discrete Speech
Units (DSU) extracted from the SSS model. In the first step, our method
pretrains two smaller encoder-decoder models on 1) Filterbank-to-DSU
(Fbk-to-DSU) and 2) DSU-to-Translation (DSU-to-Trl) data respectively. The DSU
thus become the distillation inputs of the smaller models. Subsequently, the
encoder from the Fbk-to-DSU model and the decoder from the DSU-to-Trl model are
taken to initialise the compact model. Finally, the compact model is finetuned
on the paired Fbk-Trl data. In addition to being compact, our method requires
no transcripts, making it applicable to low-resource settings. It also avoids
speech discretization in inference and is more robust to the DSU tokenization.
Evaluation on CoVoST-2 (X-En) shows that our method has consistent improvement
over the baseline in three metrics while being compact i.e., only half the SSS
model size.
|
[
-0.24699729681015015,
-0.4740584194660187,
0.5453271865844727,
0.057585157454013824,
-0.8500264286994934,
0.04955824092030525,
-0.3649308681488037,
-0.004599608480930328,
0.21875864267349243,
0.33653008937835693,
-0.7756487131118774,
-0.3630664348602295,
-0.5367662310600281,
0.12493575364351273,
-0.5250982642173767,
0.940974235534668,
0.12732329964637756,
0.24465806782245636,
-0.12372885644435883,
0.19995230436325073,
-0.35736963152885437,
-0.4930513799190521,
-0.4495251178741455,
-0.14030377566814423,
0.22461245954036713,
0.3060336112976074,
0.4721156358718872,
0.6861381530761719,
0.36825335025787354,
0.349371075630188,
-0.20593085885047913,
-0.1062965914607048,
-0.48386093974113464,
-0.08948308974504471,
-0.12283241003751755,
-0.3732583522796631,
-0.44846710562705994,
0.03660443052649498,
0.8051964044570923,
0.6470409035682678,
-0.588784396648407,
0.28235748410224915,
-0.016981229186058044,
0.3329907953739166,
-0.5104256272315979,
-0.03458733111619949,
-0.5541914701461792,
-0.04910577833652496,
-0.43967360258102417,
0.10617948323488235,
-0.5872769951820374,
-0.3146144151687622,
0.19162055850028992,
-0.6357009410858154,
0.31721416115760803,
-0.028336627408862114,
0.3476257920265198,
0.6383895874023438,
-0.4360411763191223,
-0.19967536628246307,
-1.1157785654067993,
0.878307580947876,
-0.9185580611228943,
0.6352657079696655,
0.3066592514514923,
0.4219050705432892,
0.012359419837594032,
-1.1069203615188599,
-0.73163241147995,
-0.13506312668323517,
-0.15873509645462036,
0.14774292707443237,
-0.09043724089860916,
0.24983493983745575,
0.09892846643924713,
0.3263998329639435,
-0.5756060481071472,
0.08910813182592392,
-0.4856331944465637,
-0.05274611711502075,
0.8250566124916077,
0.0124821150675416,
-0.0009295458439737558,
-0.13022881746292114,
-0.28807851672172546,
-0.07516638934612274,
-0.47844579815864563,
-0.17510481178760529,
0.11625601351261139,
0.42384976148605347,
-0.4530741274356842,
0.3581070005893707,
-0.23400762677192688,
0.6216676235198975,
0.4535486400127411,
-0.435779869556427,
0.2615928649902344,
-0.6226143836975098,
-0.29405057430267334,
0.49868521094322205,
0.8556970953941345,
-0.17332066595554352,
0.020343217998743057,
-0.23992465436458588,
-0.3596511781215668,
0.17560943961143494,
0.39796584844589233,
-0.8701252937316895,
-0.17405542731285095,
0.0005119178676977754,
-0.4360772669315338,
-0.17380058765411377,
-0.22247453033924103,
-0.433576762676239,
0.14843346178531647,
-0.4934096932411194,
0.4774938225746155,
-0.2940152585506439,
-0.18378520011901855,
0.11224938184022903,
0.23237493634223938,
0.18612386286258698,
0.07586625218391418,
-1.1978727579116821,
0.7495802640914917,
0.26656708121299744,
0.7296161651611328,
-0.27011412382125854,
-0.03378652036190033,
-0.42962509393692017,
0.19139546155929565,
-0.44223058223724365,
0.48823556303977966,
-0.08260241895914078,
-0.6755359172821045,
-0.33246269822120667,
-0.2304675430059433,
-0.24488124251365662,
-0.3543557822704315,
0.715293288230896,
-0.15105938911437988,
-0.0004696552932728082,
-0.045065201818943024,
-0.5900363326072693,
0.15822575986385345,
-0.2616860270500183,
-0.37202486395835876,
0.9279671311378479,
0.06688487529754639,
-0.4511082172393799,
-0.02437407523393631,
-0.5411837697029114,
-0.49713531136512756,
0.15948642790317535,
-0.5050061345100403,
-0.44957369565963745,
0.3719033896923065,
0.20020045340061188,
0.5563188195228577,
-0.2567783296108246,
0.4781307578086853,
-0.024580787867307663,
-0.3275260925292969,
0.18481726944446564,
-0.2867189049720764,
0.5758731365203857,
0.5692163109779358,
-0.2544606029987335,
0.295764297246933,
-0.6527006030082703,
0.03635665401816368,
0.17923596501350403,
-0.08720193803310394,
-0.23540888726711273,
0.10035713016986847,
-0.07179605960845947,
0.23475751280784607,
0.18574294447898865,
-0.7519837617874146,
-0.13512705266475677,
-0.3084804117679596,
0.6872230172157288,
0.5442641377449036,
-0.19327165186405182,
0.6928401589393616,
0.004458248615264893,
0.4111867845058441,
0.08149018883705139,
0.31531473994255066,
0.033488620072603226,
-0.19993683695793152,
-0.6042128801345825,
-0.32714948058128357,
0.5661797523498535,
0.4340085983276367,
-0.736875057220459,
0.5771241188049316,
-0.5694141983985901,
-0.6355684399604797,
-0.697623610496521,
-0.23780135810375214,
0.4794712960720062,
0.5356345176696777,
0.5042062997817993,
-0.38328543305397034,
-0.4478941559791565,
-0.6352784037590027,
0.22605964541435242,
0.001392401522025466,
-0.049961503595113754,
0.09522929787635803,
0.42336857318878174,
-0.2649209201335907,
0.8672019243240356,
-0.39890220761299133,
-0.3282347321510315,
-0.259125679731369,
0.0036752019077539444,
-0.06795433908700943,
0.7384682297706604,
0.571178674697876,
-0.8056627511978149,
-0.5278803110122681,
-0.09603092819452286,
-0.48595795035362244,
0.010551904328167439,
-0.06184034049510956,
0.2686271071434021,
-0.046860385686159134,
0.7625054121017456,
-0.5476598739624023,
0.5345233082771301,
0.8554573655128479,
-0.2095351666212082,
0.47077882289886475,
-0.34290811419487,
-0.054779164493083954,
-1.2831979990005493,
-0.0837862491607666,
-0.2949782907962799,
-0.5028083920478821,
-0.862159013748169,
-0.2829269468784332,
0.09410180151462555,
-0.37216153740882874,
-0.7495660185813904,
0.33943501114845276,
-0.2715268135070801,
-0.2873876988887787,
-0.05776425078511238,
0.4974120855331421,
-0.009474359452724457,
0.2949342727661133,
0.1892714947462082,
0.9732863306999207,
0.3330253064632416,
-0.5957459807395935,
0.3549887537956238,
0.6883602738380432,
-0.27478811144828796,
0.48073023557662964,
-0.82405686378479,
0.3955594301223755,
0.08307919651269913,
0.5189718008041382,
-0.8884278535842896,
0.0717475563287735,
0.09345728158950806,
-0.3459474444389343,
0.40194809436798096,
-0.0058115278370678425,
-0.32534199953079224,
-0.31823351979255676,
0.1993219256401062,
0.6917829513549805,
0.6055388450622559,
-0.4851495325565338,
0.418273389339447,
0.399274080991745,
-0.4973837733268738,
-0.17910899221897125,
-0.8423963785171509,
-0.15337149798870087,
-0.18049879372119904,
-0.5469702482223511,
0.8864848613739014,
-0.2092159241437912,
0.1685612052679062,
0.04239535704255104,
-0.2633049786090851,
-0.20893524587154388,
-0.08659686148166656,
0.033933594822883606,
0.07865385711193085,
-0.30598515272140503,
0.05423365533351898,
0.3359568119049072,
-0.20253309607505798,
-0.17686478793621063,
-0.45553091168403625,
0.4446919858455658,
-0.21479184925556183,
-0.15489208698272705,
-0.8677686452865601,
0.5304462909698486,
0.28821486234664917,
-0.49501585960388184,
0.6871902346611023,
0.6801026463508606,
-0.3554352819919586,
0.03310473635792732,
-0.3195113241672516,
-0.2776166796684265,
-0.4943661391735077,
0.37076136469841003,
-0.7042494416236877,
-0.7977299094200134,
0.25256747007369995,
-0.34177514910697937,
-0.2516596019268036,
0.37983691692352295,
0.4148993492126465,
-0.1399257928133011,
1.0088735818862915,
0.6322335004806519,
0.15552666783332825,
0.5675047636032104,
-0.37388965487480164,
0.2714921832084656,
-1.0582313537597656,
-0.20132873952388763,
-0.6069411039352417,
-0.20383791625499725,
-0.41018930077552795,
-0.357094407081604,
0.05992111563682556,
0.27488234639167786,
-0.05950584635138512,
0.4777815341949463,
-0.5260170698165894,
0.362507164478302,
0.5400663018226624,
-0.025242485105991364,
-0.017408745363354683,
-0.17224672436714172,
-0.24033689498901367,
-0.2045430690050125,
-0.9589037895202637,
-0.3518854081630707,
0.9896175265312195,
0.19841906428337097,
0.8665663003921509,
0.1822051703929901,
1.1134414672851562,
0.1390867531299591,
-0.02593737095594406,
-0.6674265265464783,
0.46649762988090515,
-0.6876437664031982,
-0.3681259751319885,
-0.5800124406814575,
-0.565828800201416,
-0.9289490580558777,
0.1375301331281662,
-0.1607000082731247,
-0.6549601554870605,
0.26268553733825684,
0.14218030869960785,
-0.8784388303756714,
0.01973085291683674,
-0.8155796527862549,
0.8464651703834534,
-0.41580817103385925,
0.10257749259471893,
-0.3733106553554535,
-0.7995386123657227,
0.14617961645126343,
-0.3328242003917694,
0.19535738229751587,
-0.00724048214033246,
0.2813469469547272,
0.9905616641044617,
-0.34854549169540405,
0.8311878442764282,
-0.1859586536884308,
0.05466421693563461,
0.3634781837463379,
-0.2281397581100464,
0.45045262575149536,
-0.27958351373672485,
0.02377081662416458,
0.25618064403533936,
0.3672390580177307,
-0.36633384227752686,
-0.5424078106880188,
0.40362799167633057,
-0.9617018103599548,
-0.3728543221950531,
-0.3461698293685913,
-0.40116775035858154,
0.03029198944568634,
0.3635770082473755,
0.4655073881149292,
0.6102292537689209,
-0.3629246652126312,
0.34459030628204346,
0.7752404808998108,
-0.05053454637527466,
0.32390135526657104,
0.49575746059417725,
-0.116913802921772,
-0.38103029131889343,
0.7492362260818481,
0.3674280643463135,
0.5155167579650879,
0.184636652469635,
0.408448725938797,
-0.7326831221580505,
-0.967867374420166,
-0.507311999797821,
0.3812783360481262,
-0.40295594930648804,
-0.23997993767261505,
-0.34360137581825256,
-0.41807886958122253,
-0.9754562377929688,
-0.009844599291682243,
-0.9184826016426086,
-0.4739171862602234,
-0.3915156424045563,
0.01756419986486435,
-0.0725543349981308,
0.8147786259651184,
-0.2134137898683548,
1.0963553190231323,
-0.7557706832885742,
0.7073405981063843,
0.3144633173942566,
0.12028750032186508,
-0.6396187543869019,
-1.0128711462020874,
-0.5768789649009705,
0.13794979453086853,
-0.18499641120433807,
-0.861982524394989,
0.5587376356124878,
0.422457754611969,
0.6608588695526123,
0.41601359844207764,
0.37307387590408325,
0.9068322777748108,
-0.7900987863540649,
0.7267768383026123,
0.3363235890865326,
-1.2300019264221191,
0.8128930330276489,
-0.25363993644714355,
0.3150557279586792,
0.5503878593444824,
0.15538141131401062,
-0.4616526961326599,
0.009047071449458599,
-0.7018675804138184,
-0.5025665760040283,
0.8788203001022339,
0.289299875497818,
0.06738865375518799,
-0.05019452050328255,
0.647194504737854,
-0.18960624933242798,
0.2606147527694702,
-0.3678211271762848,
-0.4120257794857025,
-0.34270787239074707,
-0.4506888687610626,
-0.5098519325256348,
-0.42508190870285034,
-0.09153211116790771,
-0.3475310802459717,
0.814992368221283,
-0.044547222554683685,
0.3669164478778839,
0.27728527784347534,
-0.12399953603744507,
-0.017918827012181282,
0.26075848937034607,
0.8506280183792114,
0.24334050714969635,
-0.13244222104549408,
0.05669602006673813,
0.2710813283920288,
-0.6292847394943237,
0.37149858474731445,
0.3169533312320709,
-0.3272594213485718,
0.1193380355834961,
-0.07967385649681091,
1.1672977209091187,
0.4368233382701874,
-0.1517394781112671,
0.6107455492019653,
-0.462951123714447,
-0.15049149096012115,
-0.44641968607902527,
-0.19525057077407837,
0.12957170605659485,
0.2232295721769333,
-0.0660160556435585,
0.12665070593357086,
0.06160584092140198,
-0.2411409616470337,
0.24836207926273346,
0.13281404972076416,
-0.3503175377845764,
-0.44934678077697754,
0.8114319443702698,
0.4921649396419525,
-0.4601961374282837,
0.6747815012931824,
-0.32942822575569153,
-0.18420082330703735,
0.18273819983005524,
0.9617001414299011,
0.9786876440048218,
-0.9923100471496582,
0.29195764660835266,
0.29162418842315674,
0.283265084028244,
-0.3379247486591339,
0.06828482449054718,
-0.26242801547050476,
-0.6305493116378784,
-0.6046987771987915,
-0.7351214289665222,
-0.3138197958469391,
0.15494920313358307,
-0.9783517718315125,
0.1321863979101181,
-0.16496288776397705,
-0.3554370701313019,
-0.1827087104320526,
0.06410209834575653,
-0.6002939343452454,
0.5711933374404907,
0.42882904410362244,
0.6787369847297668,
-0.8642551302909851,
1.5447996854782104,
0.3955947458744049,
-0.037701770663261414,
-0.9349671602249146,
-0.19838383793830872,
-0.08647762984037399,
-0.36675798892974854,
0.3585154414176941,
-0.020467789843678474,
-0.26802557706832886,
0.5838921070098877,
-0.29059410095214844,
-1.1696557998657227,
1.4028483629226685,
0.6681475043296814,
-1.0219719409942627,
-0.0916222482919693,
0.2593699097633362,
0.32618415355682373,
-0.4580255448818207,
-0.279346227645874,
0.735022783279419,
0.03567476570606232,
0.11537259072065353,
-1.1570662260055542,
-0.13792084157466888,
0.07561800628900528,
0.21070459485054016,
0.005935530178248882,
-0.5360460877418518,
0.9321697950363159,
-0.22041964530944824,
-0.4245280921459198,
0.26537394523620605,
0.8022945523262024,
0.051406871527433395,
0.13303525745868683,
0.494922935962677,
0.5642314553260803,
0.9622562527656555,
-0.08228662610054016,
0.8708398342132568,
-0.19660115242004395,
0.41538679599761963,
1.6180222034454346,
-0.21434803307056427,
0.9903187155723572,
0.5965521335601807,
-0.20096977055072784,
0.3749885857105255,
0.4992457628250122,
0.3690354824066162,
0.9210928082466125,
0.19044548273086548,
-0.46270278096199036,
-0.20339983701705933,
-0.09013469517230988,
-0.45762568712234497,
0.6503202319145203,
0.5317519307136536,
-0.1422504186630249,
-0.02871822565793991,
0.12680920958518982,
-0.3640397787094116,
0.16633717715740204,
-0.28867900371551514,
0.8054378628730774,
0.43557965755462646,
-0.395670622587204,
0.5726690292358398,
0.1457275003194809,
0.3979076147079468,
-0.9550641179084778,
0.44320717453956604,
-0.10029888153076172,
0.1926584094762802,
0.011926956474781036,
-0.2410770207643509,
0.606662929058075,
0.024622296914458275,
0.03405800461769104,
-0.4317374527454376,
0.5807023644447327,
-0.525847852230072,
-0.44364726543426514,
0.1937543749809265,
0.39857620000839233,
0.36138153076171875,
-0.0863732099533081,
-0.6080905199050903,
0.11151427030563354,
0.020839426666498184,
-0.06287410110235214,
0.2147788107395172,
0.427407830953598,
0.07399164885282516,
0.4237862527370453,
0.5912978053092957,
0.12641499936580658,
0.4741035997867584,
0.10936165601015091,
0.6257469058036804,
-0.5067844986915588,
-0.8083270192146301,
-0.6431955099105835,
0.3267645537853241,
0.1454218178987503,
0.032386839389801025,
0.6607006192207336,
0.42796874046325684,
0.9259235858917236,
-0.11694054305553436,
0.7305648326873779,
-0.04943016916513443,
0.40997883677482605,
-0.5513445138931274,
0.7361930012702942,
-0.17485079169273376,
-0.0017323181964457035,
-0.10843716561794281,
-0.7498565912246704,
-0.03021249733865261,
0.89924556016922,
-0.43843087553977966,
-0.21017812192440033,
0.7301427125930786,
0.5214177370071411,
-0.025360727682709694,
0.01197647862136364,
0.7029019594192505,
0.19759343564510345,
0.13627545535564423,
0.24109642207622528,
0.5522322058677673,
-0.652309238910675,
0.5771651864051819,
-0.4706527590751648,
-0.22428642213344574,
-0.02263573370873928,
-0.625604510307312,
-0.6827633380889893,
-0.7037754058837891,
-0.5589549541473389,
-0.1262897551059723,
-0.0034726739395409822,
0.749570906162262,
1.1335843801498413,
-0.7776120901107788,
-0.2651617228984833,
-0.1608627736568451,
-0.25901833176612854,
-0.2675594091415405,
-0.013921098783612251,
0.27400335669517517,
-0.3312224745750427,
-0.6734437346458435,
0.8029468655586243,
-0.070859394967556,
0.5945353507995605,
-0.22850875556468964,
-0.486240416765213,
-0.1676337569952011,
0.29658326506614685,
0.5686213970184326,
0.06215893104672432,
-0.650236189365387,
-0.213485449552536,
-0.21542835235595703,
-0.037146683782339096,
0.11796769499778748,
0.7298726439476013,
-0.867431640625,
0.4797675311565399,
0.20001213252544403,
0.5608336329460144,
0.9883355498313904,
0.009069211781024933,
0.4112508296966553,
-1.3261456489562988,
0.479145348072052,
0.17404614388942719,
0.2087285816669464,
0.4188805818557739,
-0.16997602581977844,
0.28634804487228394,
0.1777985394001007,
-0.5793933272361755,
-0.7009039521217346,
0.44556063413619995,
-1.1431100368499756,
0.042422059923410416,
0.9454255104064941,
-0.371045857667923,
-0.16762787103652954,
0.08023939281702042,
-0.0946737602353096,
0.7207202911376953,
-0.26580455899238586,
0.5607437491416931,
0.17095708847045898,
-0.04362551495432854,
-0.06646399199962616,
-0.28043094277381897,
0.5209370255470276,
0.30692586302757263,
-0.733322262763977,
-0.08964536339044571,
0.16018575429916382,
0.2487213909626007,
0.2548603415489197,
1.0089735984802246,
-0.17560794949531555,
-0.03912447392940521,
0.3456476628780365,
-0.011716142296791077,
0.13659952580928802,
-0.35401618480682373,
-0.5064790844917297,
-0.3432086706161499,
-0.12335282564163208,
-0.6125345826148987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00046v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00046v2
|
SEED: Customize Large Language Models with Sample-Efficient Adaptation for Code Generation
| 2024-02-29T16:09:02 | 2024-03-23T16:51:11 |
Xue Jiang, Yihong Dong, Zhi Jin, Ge Li
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Although Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant progress in code
generation, they still struggle with code generation tasks in specific
scenarios. These scenarios usually necessitate the adaptation of LLMs to
fulfill specific needs, but the limited training samples available in practice
lead to poor code generation performance. Therefore, how to effectively adapt
LLMs to new scenarios with few training samples is a major challenge for
current code generation. In this paper, we propose a novel adaptation approach
named SEED, which stands for Sample-Efficient adaptation with Error-Driven
learning for code generation. SEED leverages the errors made by LLMs as
learning opportunities, using error revision to overcome its own shortcomings,
thus achieving efficient learning. Specifically, SEED involves identifying
error code generated by LLMs, employing Self-revise for code revision,
optimizing the model with revised code, and iteratively adapting the process
for continuous improvement. Experimental results show that, compared to other
mainstream fine-tuning approaches, SEED achieves superior performance with few
training samples, showing an average relative improvement of 54.7% in Pass@1 on
multiple code generation benchmarks. We also validate the effectiveness of
Self-revise, which generates revised code that optimizes the model more
efficiently compared to the code samples from datasets. Moreover, SEED
consistently demonstrates strong performance across various LLMs, underscoring
its generalizability.
|
[
0.06102314963936806,
-0.2573321759700775,
0.25982409715652466,
0.6267077326774597,
-0.1303633451461792,
0.2562296688556671,
-0.3849765658378601,
-0.033343542367219925,
-0.012886129319667816,
0.4600098431110382,
-0.5838527679443359,
-0.5143489241600037,
-0.4006045162677765,
0.1927686631679535,
-0.29973655939102173,
0.7618944644927979,
-0.028114711865782738,
0.029781024903059006,
-0.09509998559951782,
-0.03797982260584831,
-0.7130539417266846,
-0.4249262511730194,
-0.6129661202430725,
-0.034328047186136246,
0.1593119353055954,
0.7296882271766663,
0.09369231760501862,
0.8301002979278564,
0.3045586049556732,
0.28168854117393494,
0.2543250620365143,
0.2629237473011017,
-0.8614919781684875,
0.1322525590658188,
-0.19539499282836914,
-0.303842693567276,
-0.37969473004341125,
-0.351056843996048,
0.594235897064209,
0.5506525039672852,
-0.15146072208881378,
0.2614559829235077,
0.1864631474018097,
0.7577865123748779,
-0.7122480273246765,
0.0496838204562664,
-1.0520695447921753,
0.00573133397847414,
0.05543773993849754,
-0.6010071635246277,
-0.5989567637443542,
-0.5484340190887451,
-0.5752003788948059,
-0.6724994778633118,
0.4371163845062256,
0.031241390854120255,
0.25785356760025024,
0.29994598031044006,
0.07360486686229706,
-0.3469785153865814,
-0.8982040286064148,
0.8814648389816284,
-1.028756856918335,
0.06022706627845764,
-0.08537808805704117,
0.3423684239387512,
-0.6162527203559875,
-0.671913206577301,
-0.5520254969596863,
0.012653393670916557,
0.31083017587661743,
-0.0007241172133944929,
-0.043924570083618164,
-0.26077044010162354,
0.20456524193286896,
0.3205944299697876,
-0.46275144815444946,
0.19055062532424927,
-0.3482731282711029,
-0.17084653675556183,
0.5810309052467346,
-0.035191480070352554,
0.21325793862342834,
-0.022587165236473083,
-0.13245049118995667,
-0.4301833212375641,
-0.9513162970542908,
-0.11349685490131378,
0.3141321837902069,
0.5053627490997314,
0.011404890567064285,
0.0930926576256752,
-0.20678874850273132,
0.7823680639266968,
0.22050291299819946,
-0.1461491882801056,
0.33251625299453735,
-0.23689191043376923,
-0.1967812180519104,
0.030968207865953445,
0.5656804442405701,
0.32424941658973694,
0.2650047242641449,
0.08443211019039154,
-0.34090253710746765,
-0.18014122545719147,
0.2526227533817291,
-1.0248613357543945,
-0.41821953654289246,
0.2504662275314331,
-0.38500481843948364,
-0.5940649509429932,
-0.1275087147951126,
-0.7085020542144775,
-0.5531328916549683,
0.21625825762748718,
0.21507534384727478,
-0.48644086718559265,
-0.11988963931798935,
0.1916685253381729,
0.018278388306498528,
0.19428125023841858,
0.4708419442176819,
-0.9337322115898132,
0.02628904953598976,
0.6403694748878479,
0.8324019312858582,
-0.08341921865940094,
-0.35490915179252625,
-0.7811758518218994,
0.06232839077711105,
-0.7361950874328613,
0.7181028723716736,
-0.34977206587791443,
-0.5246638059616089,
-0.10078705102205276,
-0.11319691687822342,
-0.06472588330507278,
-0.6375612020492554,
0.3138333261013031,
-0.6022939682006836,
-0.1836167275905609,
-0.004011719021946192,
-0.5570117235183716,
0.02683757245540619,
0.16950339078903198,
-0.34308555722236633,
0.711738646030426,
0.28664857149124146,
-0.5319772362709045,
0.4763769507408142,
-0.5274108648300171,
-0.44210609793663025,
0.013925382867455482,
-0.24678827822208405,
-0.46126171946525574,
0.40123310685157776,
0.27333149313926697,
0.5096902251243591,
-0.16626769304275513,
0.01709882915019989,
-0.3621525168418884,
-0.2913588583469391,
0.07854051142930984,
-0.20302344858646393,
0.5311821103096008,
0.36992010474205017,
-0.19650419056415558,
0.20633141696453094,
-1.2934930324554443,
0.36567750573158264,
0.32671400904655457,
-0.4260351061820984,
-0.2947245240211487,
0.2535076141357422,
-0.04127517342567444,
0.13212281465530396,
0.015993261709809303,
-0.3346235156059265,
0.6617806553840637,
-0.351477712392807,
0.28695356845855713,
0.9478853940963745,
0.22540636360645294,
0.4461054503917694,
-0.23164966702461243,
0.589219331741333,
0.135848730802536,
0.06312215328216553,
-0.6518508791923523,
-0.03725940361618996,
-0.915494441986084,
0.05528102442622185,
0.5586504340171814,
0.3293497562408447,
-0.7924410104751587,
0.4865744113922119,
-0.2661382555961609,
-0.4425610601902008,
-0.5283195376396179,
0.7357362508773804,
0.30289047956466675,
0.28541770577430725,
0.17222478985786438,
-0.5111583471298218,
-0.9042516350746155,
-0.5351729393005371,
-0.18699684739112854,
-0.07440223544836044,
0.012494062073528767,
0.17780518531799316,
0.4582028388977051,
-0.18978801369667053,
0.9723914265632629,
-0.5645841956138611,
-0.14173312485218048,
-0.3554355502128601,
-0.015859637409448624,
0.4193178117275238,
0.8837421536445618,
0.5604247450828552,
-0.5600852370262146,
-0.479788601398468,
-0.024220142513513565,
-0.37705758213996887,
-0.3686591386795044,
-0.45521846413612366,
0.004161635413765907,
-0.0032618860714137554,
0.6475613117218018,
0.27482783794403076,
-0.0890296921133995,
1.0567545890808105,
-0.28095734119415283,
0.5447302460670471,
-0.6333960294723511,
-0.06517993658781052,
-1.394422173500061,
-0.07584238052368164,
-0.19591273367404938,
-0.3092031478881836,
-0.5091902613639832,
0.18162676692008972,
0.3256562054157257,
0.050739388912916183,
-0.38813960552215576,
0.30136844515800476,
-0.6343713402748108,
-0.1004791110754013,
-0.6437134742736816,
-0.3879115581512451,
-0.07431474328041077,
0.2819405496120453,
-0.23817838728427887,
1.1292685270309448,
0.5563768148422241,
-0.6554241180419922,
0.17842543125152588,
-0.059025488793849945,
-0.3867221772670746,
0.09528711438179016,
-0.46379709243774414,
0.5368124842643738,
-0.04806128144264221,
0.3636021018028259,
-0.619658887386322,
-0.3474496304988861,
0.17277583479881287,
-0.3374805450439453,
0.3355460464954376,
-0.3485327661037445,
-0.45287659764289856,
-0.2770117223262787,
-0.13204661011695862,
0.20005512237548828,
0.7330940365791321,
-0.7895839214324951,
0.36149299144744873,
-0.09772483259439468,
-0.08456262201070786,
-0.3006238043308258,
-0.3651440739631653,
0.016312001273036003,
0.09500188380479813,
-0.35219210386276245,
0.09737080335617065,
-0.2846321165561676,
0.00889291986823082,
-0.23493033647537231,
-0.04838436469435692,
0.10253434628248215,
0.22078876197338104,
0.1687787026166916,
-0.08817530423402786,
-0.3962244987487793,
0.25379759073257446,
0.05561389401555061,
-0.14129559695720673,
-0.26751500368118286,
-0.7592580914497375,
0.6104379892349243,
0.12097882479429245,
-0.41858628392219543,
0.07666388154029846,
0.09666121006011963,
0.47746413946151733,
-0.18705764412879944,
0.663330078125,
0.09880615770816803,
-0.1848846971988678,
-0.929179847240448,
-0.46775391697883606,
-0.06040644645690918,
-0.49340999126434326,
0.6218723654747009,
-0.5312855243682861,
-0.5552305579185486,
0.2808328866958618,
-0.47952133417129517,
0.24132025241851807,
0.3343234062194824,
0.5931465029716492,
-0.1035107895731926,
0.7317336201667786,
1.0218453407287598,
-0.24438536167144775,
0.43140190839767456,
-0.21619635820388794,
-0.07363083958625793,
-0.7378196716308594,
0.16519629955291748,
-0.5654783844947815,
-0.1840958148241043,
-0.5379545092582703,
-0.9639303684234619,
0.04567493125796318,
0.31836140155792236,
-0.0870978981256485,
0.40276938676834106,
-0.4619753062725067,
0.6185492277145386,
0.5978175401687622,
-0.10157092660665512,
0.3250345289707184,
-0.07126829028129578,
0.05356211215257645,
0.15034188330173492,
-0.9720126986503601,
-0.4000847339630127,
1.1698392629623413,
0.2543036937713623,
0.880781352519989,
0.053631436079740524,
0.8789867162704468,
0.2783900499343872,
0.5072266459465027,
-0.3178199529647827,
0.28593504428863525,
-0.1814115196466446,
-0.2886171340942383,
-0.033735908567905426,
-0.6754040718078613,
-0.6145949363708496,
0.15410389006137848,
-0.21955649554729462,
-0.3916345238685608,
0.2840193808078766,
0.5844113826751709,
-0.43107903003692627,
0.388782262802124,
-0.8318040370941162,
0.8545334339141846,
-0.3247101902961731,
-0.22030583024024963,
-0.16008873283863068,
-0.0912238284945488,
0.31749647855758667,
-0.6881545186042786,
0.3519078493118286,
0.06117825210094452,
0.18267741799354553,
0.6083862781524658,
-0.4362691044807434,
0.9679454565048218,
-0.27924543619155884,
-0.15165410935878754,
0.22496360540390015,
0.20995165407657623,
0.828213095664978,
-0.14652378857135773,
-0.19722117483615875,
-0.1267067790031433,
-0.23700004816055298,
-0.49448686838150024,
-0.7237033843994141,
0.8138054609298706,
-0.7561916708946228,
-0.5549976229667664,
-0.21860118210315704,
-0.6759967803955078,
-0.31300926208496094,
0.3178713917732239,
0.24183258414268494,
0.19691140949726105,
-0.10749004036188126,
0.2527800500392914,
0.5305960178375244,
-0.7234864830970764,
0.4290347397327423,
0.574188768863678,
-0.40766528248786926,
-0.39350172877311707,
1.044600486755371,
-0.2078285962343216,
0.4434870779514313,
0.13398468494415283,
0.356852650642395,
0.1257265955209732,
-1.036103367805481,
-0.6580309867858887,
-0.03166276216506958,
-0.6004828810691833,
-0.3653201460838318,
-0.5048454403877258,
-0.08624449372291565,
-0.7007302045822144,
-0.23711399734020233,
-0.5131296515464783,
-0.17363643646240234,
-0.19652479887008667,
0.1381896287202835,
0.3249339163303375,
0.668624997138977,
-0.013361386023461819,
0.5287449359893799,
-0.8210563063621521,
0.14564670622348785,
0.11960692703723907,
0.5145567059516907,
-0.011098802089691162,
-0.7551500201225281,
-0.3055228292942047,
-0.19492213428020477,
-0.3297730088233948,
-0.7954115867614746,
0.40932101011276245,
0.43475568294525146,
0.13906148076057434,
0.2020362913608551,
0.05526353791356087,
0.7862005233764648,
-0.8320492506027222,
0.43554502725601196,
0.2811335325241089,
-0.8338156938552856,
0.6962847113609314,
-0.1630104035139084,
0.5139972567558289,
0.6152694225311279,
-0.09462405741214752,
-0.5837956666946411,
-0.24003836512565613,
-0.5291526317596436,
-0.8025174736976624,
0.4604060649871826,
0.08318927139043808,
0.1955299824476242,
0.27111294865608215,
0.5677375197410583,
0.23386436700820923,
0.12992434203624725,
-0.686856746673584,
-0.07082602381706238,
-0.1807841658592224,
-0.32146167755126953,
-0.32949668169021606,
-0.28461846709251404,
0.1236390620470047,
0.04595346748828888,
0.8494035601615906,
-0.5913087725639343,
-0.08394777029752731,
-0.0674227774143219,
-0.26272714138031006,
-0.3775671124458313,
0.34266558289527893,
0.5416867733001709,
0.6185953617095947,
-0.16055482625961304,
0.037851642817258835,
0.33631041646003723,
-0.329177588224411,
0.3772326409816742,
-0.15460722148418427,
-0.4236236810684204,
-0.16797584295272827,
0.40137845277786255,
0.6965247988700867,
0.27543047070503235,
-0.6029501557350159,
0.49711403250694275,
0.10553578287363052,
-0.011254778131842613,
-0.3161484897136688,
0.5203647613525391,
0.09403402358293533,
0.3119421899318695,
0.521733283996582,
0.17522113025188446,
-0.09952423721551895,
-0.5421409010887146,
0.3630315959453583,
0.13871243596076965,
-0.09628469496965408,
-0.24654537439346313,
0.5480682849884033,
0.2873714864253998,
-0.2718104422092438,
0.37745314836502075,
-0.33960744738578796,
-0.4303237199783325,
0.6648783683776855,
0.9503202438354492,
1.0459620952606201,
-0.19871652126312256,
-0.03259816765785217,
0.48719125986099243,
0.21195174753665924,
-0.05725279450416565,
0.1095694974064827,
0.1693316400051117,
-0.856473982334137,
-0.767025351524353,
-0.8401696681976318,
-0.3586556911468506,
0.1143331304192543,
-0.22505684196949005,
0.18867582082748413,
-0.772493839263916,
0.3008340299129486,
-0.4058058559894562,
-0.17408597469329834,
-0.5333159565925598,
0.29812857508659363,
0.03029671683907509,
1.3105509281158447,
-0.8067018389701843,
1.1523092985153198,
0.6780246496200562,
-0.1397249549627304,
-0.9017080068588257,
0.15825629234313965,
-0.1611134260892868,
-0.7798514366149902,
0.6246292591094971,
-0.07286194711923599,
0.17939217388629913,
0.203340545296669,
-0.5634236931800842,
-0.911088764667511,
0.939285397529602,
0.2981913387775421,
-0.9714740514755249,
0.057959191501140594,
-0.1075197234749794,
0.4095781147480011,
-0.4852057993412018,
0.06047067046165466,
0.4170280992984772,
0.15791282057762146,
0.28335145115852356,
-0.46170714497566223,
0.027944911271333694,
-0.16907931864261627,
0.42843493819236755,
0.058682024478912354,
-0.652245819568634,
0.5476054549217224,
-0.4350806772708893,
-0.116788350045681,
0.08447980880737305,
1.0474348068237305,
0.5051928758621216,
0.004830917343497276,
0.718682587146759,
0.19856449961662292,
0.6323535442352295,
0.0011234943522140384,
0.9692519307136536,
-0.6479049324989319,
0.401637464761734,
1.5034645795822144,
-0.24425339698791504,
0.819115936756134,
0.535636842250824,
-0.08424936980009079,
0.364852637052536,
0.4454226791858673,
-0.17567436397075653,
0.4743267297744751,
0.6322182416915894,
-0.015582172200083733,
-0.14951756596565247,
0.4438464343547821,
-0.4193839430809021,
0.34279245138168335,
0.0631893128156662,
-0.4769144356250763,
-0.22685088217258453,
-0.07852146774530411,
-0.17727597057819366,
0.08279206603765488,
-0.2878195345401764,
0.6835804581642151,
0.023906145244836807,
-0.6125301718711853,
0.46930253505706787,
0.17354626953601837,
0.6550465822219849,
-0.6648837327957153,
-0.297649621963501,
-0.40826737880706787,
0.574768602848053,
-0.19825749099254608,
-0.1705942302942276,
0.12683790922164917,
0.27243340015411377,
-0.33684369921684265,
-0.34774449467658997,
0.7773151397705078,
-0.1846911907196045,
-0.7936259508132935,
0.12004821747541428,
0.19930368661880493,
-0.03343857452273369,
0.010009159334003925,
-0.608806312084198,
0.4161318242549896,
0.22715185582637787,
-0.14550071954727173,
0.30860456824302673,
0.376437783241272,
0.14177604019641876,
0.6619972586631775,
0.8762346506118774,
0.6933348178863525,
0.3359423875808716,
0.04623299464583397,
0.7544024586677551,
-0.7542309761047363,
-0.5118480920791626,
-0.6251916289329529,
0.2737085521221161,
-0.08853544294834137,
-0.3175675868988037,
0.7682598829269409,
0.5768241286277771,
1.121472716331482,
-0.38536205887794495,
1.1775355339050293,
-0.12438587099313736,
0.5059813261032104,
-0.6870600581169128,
0.6247905492782593,
-0.37434136867523193,
0.5375085473060608,
-0.37142863869667053,
-0.9671271443367004,
-0.24495865404605865,
0.6054389476776123,
-0.2316853106021881,
0.17879648506641388,
0.3969178795814514,
0.8710911870002747,
-0.030559249222278595,
-0.33004435896873474,
0.5316562056541443,
0.5588420629501343,
0.6015559434890747,
0.7604818344116211,
0.6156443953514099,
-0.5055249929428101,
0.4360404312610626,
-0.38268816471099854,
-0.4587256908416748,
-0.3332144021987915,
-1.1904218196868896,
-0.49153122305870056,
-0.36249130964279175,
-0.383282333612442,
-0.4815313220024109,
0.2482209950685501,
1.3475077152252197,
0.7348803877830505,
-1.192626714706421,
-0.25601333379745483,
-0.3750302195549011,
-0.231623575091362,
-0.35432153940200806,
-0.10886527597904205,
0.30093416571617126,
-0.7451658248901367,
-0.8073354363441467,
0.6212605834007263,
0.20765641331672668,
0.033400069922208786,
-0.364865779876709,
-0.27708932757377625,
0.3144669234752655,
0.0333828367292881,
0.34863337874412537,
0.48041462898254395,
-0.24017159640789032,
-0.3410036265850067,
-0.12102562189102173,
-0.06204197555780411,
0.14350198209285736,
1.0925947427749634,
-0.7500669956207275,
0.6959612965583801,
0.276780366897583,
0.9368571043014526,
0.2326584905385971,
-0.011750400066375732,
0.7669434547424316,
-0.7921963334083557,
0.15404516458511353,
0.12887266278266907,
0.3299730122089386,
0.42877548933029175,
-0.2417210340499878,
0.32185354828834534,
0.2628266215324402,
-0.3002745509147644,
-0.7925927042961121,
0.2821745276451111,
-0.6679856181144714,
-0.3739476501941681,
1.3240514993667603,
-0.14188407361507416,
-0.47244468331336975,
0.24583204090595245,
-0.13436920940876007,
0.19540518522262573,
-0.2007640302181244,
0.9218617081642151,
0.36818721890449524,
0.3597624599933624,
-0.09859517216682434,
-0.49596861004829407,
0.4515823721885681,
0.3153788149356842,
-0.8013845086097717,
0.17154806852340698,
0.4263440668582916,
0.5641971826553345,
-0.03575313091278076,
0.7337952256202698,
0.04282698780298233,
0.2650252878665924,
0.0502629317343235,
0.5269675254821777,
-0.0761275365948677,
-0.29507774114608765,
-0.5553873181343079,
0.2448088675737381,
0.6153883934020996,
-0.37234601378440857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19282v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19282v6
|
WanJuan-CC: A Safe and High-Quality Open-sourced English Webtext Dataset
| 2024-02-29T15:49:15 | 2024-03-18T03:18:58 |
Jiantao Qiu, Haijun Lv, Zhenjiang Jin, Rui Wang, Wenchang Ning, Jia Yu, ChaoBin Zhang, Zhenxiang Li, Pei Chu, Yuan Qu, Jin Shi, Lindong Lu, Runyu Peng, Zhiyuan Zeng, Huanze Tang, Zhikai Lei, Jiawei Hong, Keyu Chen, Zhaoye Fei, Ruiliang Xu, Wei Li, Zhongying Tu, Lin Dahua, Yu Qiao, Hang Yan, Conghui He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents WanJuan-CC, a safe and high-quality open-sourced English
webtext dataset derived from Common Crawl data. The study addresses the
challenges of constructing large-scale pre-training datasets for language
models, which require vast amounts of high-quality data. A comprehensive
process was designed to handle Common Crawl data, including extraction,
heuristic rule filtering, fuzzy deduplication, content safety filtering, and
data quality filtering. From approximately 68 billion original English
documents, we obtained 2.22T Tokens of safe data and selected 1.0T Tokens of
high-quality data as part of WanJuan-CC. We have open-sourced 100B Tokens from
this dataset. The paper also provides statistical information related to data
quality, enabling users to select appropriate data according to their needs. To
evaluate the quality and utility of the dataset, we trained 1B-parameter and
3B-parameter models using WanJuan-CC and another dataset, RefinedWeb. Results
show that WanJuan-CC performs better on validation datasets and downstream
tasks.
|
[
-0.21141868829727173,
-0.4516456425189972,
0.08957317471504211,
0.1442577987909317,
-0.26500388979911804,
-0.3538089990615845,
-0.31011638045310974,
-0.23629550635814667,
-0.036559056490659714,
0.7674632668495178,
-0.3285793662071228,
-0.8741781115531921,
-0.48131033778190613,
0.028174929320812225,
-0.7715160250663757,
0.8660662770271301,
0.12519092857837677,
-0.030219119042158127,
-0.03989926353096962,
-0.1483539640903473,
-0.26372000575065613,
-0.36855247616767883,
-0.9020302295684814,
0.4492393732070923,
0.4739132821559906,
0.567045271396637,
0.9819011688232422,
0.6993685960769653,
0.7757419943809509,
0.11662458628416061,
0.048416849225759506,
0.35200101137161255,
-0.6902182698249817,
0.2145812213420868,
-0.5272034406661987,
-0.2298526018857956,
-0.5437244772911072,
0.19780106842517853,
0.19661180675029755,
0.5934283137321472,
-0.48721712827682495,
0.0669960156083107,
0.0003301700053270906,
0.851710855960846,
-0.7542589902877808,
0.051475051790475845,
-0.814429521560669,
-0.30273109674453735,
-0.6280525922775269,
0.37707340717315674,
-0.36207035183906555,
-0.6612702012062073,
-0.19879473745822906,
-0.9282707571983337,
0.2768579423427582,
0.31603747606277466,
1.2303240299224854,
0.022525493055582047,
-0.5420175790786743,
-0.4751178026199341,
-0.2833893895149231,
0.7622151374816895,
-0.6798433065414429,
0.49646297097206116,
0.9231154322624207,
0.5329944491386414,
-0.023328624665737152,
-0.7817748188972473,
-0.692803680896759,
0.14483781158924103,
-0.04630780220031738,
0.24324724078178406,
0.022429604083299637,
-0.12906578183174133,
-0.14628306031227112,
0.36076587438583374,
-0.882478654384613,
0.08661861717700958,
-0.4477667808532715,
-0.19874627888202667,
0.7059137225151062,
0.13575251400470734,
0.3133890628814697,
-0.28208693861961365,
-0.24839486181735992,
-0.37894660234451294,
-0.8839597702026367,
-0.18133972585201263,
0.7013195753097534,
0.5709847807884216,
0.08486466854810715,
0.6011723279953003,
-0.5299785733222961,
0.6215896010398865,
-0.2915126383304596,
-0.3006272614002228,
0.16580595076084137,
-0.4995146691799164,
0.08540794998407364,
-0.23736511170864105,
0.932066023349762,
0.518704891204834,
0.6494125723838806,
-0.15550920367240906,
-0.3048225939273834,
-0.0976896733045578,
0.48681482672691345,
-0.7268256545066833,
-0.17539536952972412,
0.2468162477016449,
-0.6491279602050781,
-0.39977961778640747,
0.6254047155380249,
-0.8673869967460632,
-0.07726779580116272,
-0.3272116482257843,
0.2746143341064453,
-0.45222434401512146,
-0.3689611554145813,
0.2748475670814514,
-0.03908925503492355,
0.06949261575937271,
0.2425660341978073,
-0.48158374428749084,
0.41869786381721497,
0.6860819458961487,
0.8034309148788452,
-0.6221904754638672,
-0.24197468161582947,
-0.3387787342071533,
0.2693435251712799,
-0.35991254448890686,
0.6239537596702576,
-0.32347536087036133,
-0.30033984780311584,
0.3238719701766968,
0.43101951479911804,
0.050014887005090714,
-0.7162136435508728,
0.9287517666816711,
-0.6598846316337585,
0.18574124574661255,
-0.08566560596227646,
-0.43577051162719727,
-0.22681079804897308,
0.2082933932542801,
-1.1589308977127075,
0.8178530335426331,
-0.01685337722301483,
-0.9711406826972961,
0.2223496288061142,
-0.4172620177268982,
-0.7276995778083801,
0.05405594781041145,
0.22815105319023132,
-0.2547290623188019,
-0.051773689687252045,
0.5158572196960449,
0.5817297101020813,
-0.48949411511421204,
0.4202258288860321,
-0.039851654320955276,
-0.2222871631383896,
0.10601142048835754,
-0.5139706134796143,
1.0267400741577148,
0.6612849235534668,
0.07441467046737671,
-0.30416038632392883,
-1.2122597694396973,
-0.04494013264775276,
0.22772513329982758,
-0.08658303320407867,
-0.6009276509284973,
0.11329320818185806,
0.14423608779907227,
0.12343687564134598,
0.18355686962604523,
-0.6227498054504395,
-0.13033169507980347,
-0.2142093926668167,
0.1377670019865036,
0.6167598366737366,
0.011558135971426964,
-0.05117326229810715,
-0.48764967918395996,
0.33821290731430054,
0.22363954782485962,
0.40049219131469727,
-0.23087041079998016,
-0.5991857647895813,
-0.5479413270950317,
-0.10135821253061295,
0.44517838954925537,
0.4891117215156555,
-0.5207073092460632,
0.3279346525669098,
-0.4733583927154541,
-0.666946530342102,
-0.46895793080329895,
-0.10490710288286209,
0.17581547796726227,
0.21109239757061005,
0.40570732951164246,
-0.2166098654270172,
-0.4343251585960388,
-0.6667531728744507,
-0.13965493440628052,
-0.03729593753814697,
-0.1202966719865799,
0.2304210364818573,
0.33368006348609924,
-0.3707124590873718,
1.0472272634506226,
-0.7355145812034607,
-0.44553491473197937,
-0.09951166063547134,
0.008587074466049671,
0.4606660008430481,
0.5974398255348206,
0.2520918548107147,
-0.8902625441551208,
-0.5803393125534058,
-0.024072162806987762,
-0.4802563786506653,
-0.11623845249414444,
-0.08127047121524811,
-0.420615553855896,
0.024263102561235428,
0.4018844962120056,
-0.5237879753112793,
0.3174753189086914,
0.8616459369659424,
-0.11542412638664246,
0.6014894247055054,
0.19473902881145477,
0.3797040581703186,
-1.414115309715271,
0.3797215521335602,
-0.14825233817100525,
-0.3809391260147095,
-0.4657723903656006,
0.36063843965530396,
0.15523776412010193,
-0.1401432454586029,
-0.6849478483200073,
0.6124178171157837,
-0.03220300376415253,
0.3646245002746582,
-0.028897786512970924,
0.3814751207828522,
0.12563058733940125,
0.25810202956199646,
-0.17140842974185944,
1.1110390424728394,
0.4688097834587097,
-0.7284875512123108,
0.43666961789131165,
0.6569933295249939,
-0.316266268491745,
0.6275665163993835,
-0.6138173937797546,
0.16157443821430206,
-0.027767904102802277,
-0.20163892209529877,
-0.817525327205658,
-0.35835978388786316,
-0.09709647297859192,
-0.6446857452392578,
0.10922995954751968,
-0.15151329338550568,
-0.5240340232849121,
-0.1805591881275177,
-0.2498965561389923,
0.11675529181957245,
0.3568536937236786,
-0.7207277417182922,
0.1124749481678009,
0.652874767780304,
-0.14785781502723694,
-0.6054191589355469,
-0.5495606660842896,
0.054457131773233414,
0.112831711769104,
-0.6102900505065918,
0.23665699362754822,
-0.00644909031689167,
-0.25435030460357666,
0.13641658425331116,
-0.09453010559082031,
-0.6362026929855347,
0.13410373032093048,
0.5712954998016357,
0.1056305468082428,
0.08359913527965546,
-0.1998938024044037,
0.13482815027236938,
-0.15341328084468842,
-0.00789265614002943,
-0.4006737172603607,
0.4557569622993469,
0.39190423488616943,
-0.3192140758037567,
-0.22835512459278107,
0.30031681060791016,
0.2911767363548279,
-0.09148965030908585,
0.9701637625694275,
0.4072662591934204,
-0.5826180577278137,
-0.14308133721351624,
-0.2716352641582489,
0.2943847179412842,
-0.4971189796924591,
0.07028880715370178,
-0.17217229306697845,
-0.730090856552124,
0.22437183558940887,
-0.02475542202591896,
0.1839619278907776,
0.7724632620811462,
0.2794322073459625,
-0.2992745041847229,
0.9014360904693604,
0.27760300040245056,
-0.11777641624212265,
0.0539824403822422,
-0.1783922016620636,
-0.062312327325344086,
-0.3193572461605072,
-0.19761468470096588,
-0.9145528674125671,
0.12948402762413025,
-0.6487573385238647,
-0.23377366364002228,
0.09094586968421936,
0.07904371619224548,
-0.2960622012615204,
0.5592033267021179,
-0.12475050985813141,
0.6332693696022034,
0.6162705421447754,
0.09513703733682632,
0.3754676282405853,
-0.041763078421354294,
-0.3094615638256073,
0.0625213086605072,
-0.04130404815077782,
-0.45809727907180786,
1.2830939292907715,
-0.04535726457834244,
1.174364447593689,
0.3498993217945099,
0.41436484456062317,
0.3899502158164978,
-0.2024049609899521,
-0.4243873655796051,
0.5394375324249268,
-0.59465092420578,
-1.015807867050171,
-0.2940148413181305,
-0.5680035948753357,
-1.3193248510360718,
-0.17077530920505524,
0.0014807278057560325,
-0.3329818546772003,
-0.22833289206027985,
-0.16112320125102997,
0.04082498699426651,
0.22279797494411469,
-0.39717936515808105,
0.5726273655891418,
-0.016900502145290375,
-0.2404041737318039,
-0.29197031259536743,
-0.5629978179931641,
0.32380473613739014,
-0.2336694598197937,
0.36163753271102905,
-0.16903828084468842,
0.08697469532489777,
0.8177575469017029,
-0.5723528265953064,
0.513125479221344,
-0.2176312804222107,
-0.020671531558036804,
0.5778771042823792,
0.2381725162267685,
0.6894417405128479,
0.21243222057819366,
-0.11704269796609879,
0.5983891487121582,
0.03170663118362427,
-0.48918524384498596,
-0.2577293813228607,
0.6536252498626709,
-0.8379848599433899,
-0.4300059974193573,
-0.301752507686615,
-0.03054194338619709,
-0.40362823009490967,
0.45451751351356506,
0.24901120364665985,
0.5738295316696167,
-0.22532685101032257,
0.5372527241706848,
0.5859229564666748,
-0.31000086665153503,
0.430484801530838,
0.3208071291446686,
-0.261082261800766,
-0.8359978199005127,
0.9890329241752625,
0.007125630974769592,
0.17984332144260406,
0.3809579610824585,
0.12286848574876785,
-0.1272665560245514,
-0.7833485007286072,
-0.3386204242706299,
0.18394377827644348,
-0.7219284772872925,
-0.6151040196418762,
-0.6405071020126343,
-0.5467150807380676,
-0.4433196187019348,
-0.02760954573750496,
-0.5727642178535461,
-0.6476973295211792,
-0.2250272035598755,
-0.16567860543727875,
0.332782119512558,
0.7688304781913757,
-0.11169326305389404,
0.48781082034111023,
-1.2321308851242065,
0.4993573725223541,
0.2648506462574005,
0.6143296360969543,
-0.13725046813488007,
-0.30781689286231995,
-0.6616489291191101,
0.2040131539106369,
0.0012502119643613696,
-0.7910645604133606,
0.4959616959095001,
0.32729974389076233,
0.5860669016838074,
0.4577633738517761,
0.1170729324221611,
0.47477030754089355,
-0.393608033657074,
1.2127989530563354,
-0.08839257806539536,
-0.828985333442688,
0.703835666179657,
-0.7173832058906555,
0.11430847644805908,
1.044614315032959,
0.9189227819442749,
-0.611318051815033,
-0.2464604526758194,
-0.3035924434661865,
-0.8827276229858398,
0.48994967341423035,
0.30905914306640625,
0.13728846609592438,
-0.15194560587406158,
0.5359109044075012,
0.6315135955810547,
0.17444859445095062,
-0.44112861156463623,
-0.16399557888507843,
-0.4275665879249573,
-0.6485987305641174,
0.24246208369731903,
-0.0996815413236618,
0.1397504210472107,
-0.03332749754190445,
0.8529700636863708,
-0.21405118703842163,
-0.025767017155885696,
-0.08636049926280975,
-0.5692867636680603,
0.1558624505996704,
-0.10136035829782486,
0.13183560967445374,
0.5959820747375488,
-0.18696855008602142,
0.06416396051645279,
-0.06678006798028946,
-1.264527440071106,
0.2318768948316574,
-0.24138741195201874,
-0.18341030180454254,
-0.032079800963401794,
0.2618758976459503,
0.3790661692619324,
-0.24034903943538666,
-0.9411808848381042,
0.9472792744636536,
-0.5207530856132507,
-0.04171102121472359,
-0.2879355251789093,
0.2591599225997925,
-0.08654674887657166,
-0.3676842451095581,
0.36893507838249207,
-0.034876540303230286,
0.16738615930080414,
-0.03793475031852722,
0.5428842902183533,
0.05957874655723572,
-0.28866609930992126,
-0.42430806159973145,
0.6596697568893433,
0.2684588134288788,
-0.013184763491153717,
0.9300448298454285,
-0.28511106967926025,
-0.13071776926517487,
0.2177160382270813,
0.4548805058002472,
0.7345024347305298,
-0.15797358751296997,
0.24265606701374054,
0.8691099882125854,
0.2878800630569458,
-0.2595730423927307,
0.4125273823738098,
0.369832843542099,
-0.7163639664649963,
-0.32556456327438354,
-0.8223539590835571,
-0.6665430068969727,
0.13074219226837158,
-0.7143271565437317,
0.4704277515411377,
-0.37826937437057495,
-0.007191586308181286,
-0.6148542165756226,
0.057067837566137314,
-0.7781399488449097,
0.5739098787307739,
-0.1704557240009308,
1.057999849319458,
-0.5663142800331116,
0.9722129702568054,
0.3993016183376312,
-0.36864539980888367,
-0.7389126420021057,
0.28192025423049927,
0.07906366884708405,
-0.6839218735694885,
0.4824126660823822,
0.3194092810153961,
0.11963082104921341,
0.028645580634474754,
-0.5834306478500366,
-1.156731367111206,
0.9707807898521423,
0.05081615597009659,
-0.8002137541770935,
-0.10779710114002228,
0.35670480132102966,
0.19700290262699127,
0.12936419248580933,
0.12535475194454193,
0.27226075530052185,
0.49775430560112,
-0.05046062916517258,
-0.6930537819862366,
-0.007813414558768272,
-0.2331826090812683,
-0.17609770596027374,
0.0345846451818943,
-0.7245628833770752,
0.8848787546157837,
0.19624032080173492,
-0.46099841594696045,
0.027866488322615623,
0.5969361662864685,
-0.054395172744989395,
-0.051842592656612396,
0.5717290639877319,
0.6906211972236633,
0.6932907700538635,
-0.11205901205539703,
0.6932770609855652,
-0.3186403810977936,
0.3298541009426117,
0.8715800046920776,
-0.3161657452583313,
0.9839639067649841,
-0.03699903562664986,
-0.3302789330482483,
0.45688632130622864,
0.451270192861557,
0.21520212292671204,
0.8170737028121948,
0.004868457093834877,
0.20412558317184448,
0.01658003032207489,
-0.0053458018228411674,
0.010651770979166031,
0.6747058629989624,
0.2261778861284256,
0.0647650957107544,
-0.04698866605758667,
-0.005520963575690985,
0.2542549669742584,
0.09740390628576279,
-0.17869216203689575,
0.8285440802574158,
-0.2087753564119339,
-0.5815533995628357,
0.33840614557266235,
-0.0998038649559021,
0.8257099986076355,
-0.5442737936973572,
0.17255564033985138,
-0.5232329964637756,
-0.03756461292505264,
-0.18527837097644806,
-0.7635701298713684,
0.6239801049232483,
0.11998772621154785,
0.017025385051965714,
0.039507847279310226,
0.7473835349082947,
-0.29299092292785645,
-0.4055347740650177,
0.08900187909603119,
0.45089542865753174,
0.12143445014953613,
-0.32458779215812683,
-0.39623787999153137,
0.01813945546746254,
-0.17382459342479706,
-0.3861664831638336,
0.2328629046678543,
0.46486005187034607,
-0.033806174993515015,
0.3960057497024536,
0.8985201120376587,
0.23495909571647644,
-0.00992757547646761,
0.0900372862815857,
0.6460245847702026,
-1.0199987888336182,
-0.38201600313186646,
-0.39072003960609436,
0.48443734645843506,
-0.3181275725364685,
-0.3458276689052582,
0.6322880387306213,
0.680277943611145,
1.0537757873535156,
0.18741628527641296,
0.7133854031562805,
0.05340007320046425,
0.8764565587043762,
-0.7202041745185852,
1.1596870422363281,
-0.5119269490242004,
-0.17690575122833252,
-0.09691011905670166,
-0.8543018698692322,
-0.4278349280357361,
0.45269575715065,
0.5913821458816528,
-0.18411682546138763,
0.8446634411811829,
0.9661714434623718,
-0.06758780777454376,
0.24279092252254486,
0.36765432357788086,
0.114881232380867,
0.6270251870155334,
0.17472143471240997,
0.6538321375846863,
-0.6556081771850586,
0.6456140279769897,
-0.15656287968158722,
0.05538839474320412,
-0.09053225070238113,
-0.8760097622871399,
-0.817725419998169,
-0.9666120409965515,
-0.11830507963895798,
-0.3467487692832947,
0.2592361271381378,
0.8986285924911499,
0.7595275640487671,
-1.2491705417633057,
-0.03242428973317146,
-0.16221760213375092,
-0.06305484473705292,
-0.24445632100105286,
-0.22237776219844818,
0.33086735010147095,
-0.43342283368110657,
-0.7244420051574707,
0.41334936022758484,
-0.03902396932244301,
-0.07350562512874603,
-0.09320153295993805,
-0.027588972821831703,
-0.232408806681633,
0.2772376537322998,
0.32471710443496704,
-0.22009898722171783,
-0.25551286339759827,
-0.3624138832092285,
0.10911936312913895,
-0.5115233659744263,
0.007840272970497608,
0.6569535136222839,
-0.5961207747459412,
0.14698629081249237,
0.48458757996559143,
0.7811024188995361,
0.30792325735092163,
-0.026208005845546722,
0.3981999158859253,
-0.8988522887229919,
0.07216743379831314,
0.05813130736351013,
0.37593740224838257,
0.36801213026046753,
-0.2901557981967926,
0.8293455243110657,
0.19809962809085846,
-0.5262665152549744,
-0.7062896490097046,
-0.12160607427358627,
-0.9572486877441406,
-0.3646511435508728,
1.4658379554748535,
-0.34964126348495483,
-0.296368271112442,
-0.1880217045545578,
-0.3184797167778015,
0.2412627786397934,
-0.21472573280334473,
0.5188256502151489,
0.7177242040634155,
0.6071305871009827,
0.13353700935840607,
-0.5186648368835449,
0.44740718603134155,
-0.08901501446962357,
-1.0573548078536987,
0.15686430037021637,
0.4637550115585327,
0.22775577008724213,
-0.10515207052230835,
0.21085669100284576,
-0.32882609963417053,
0.10175767540931702,
0.1212606281042099,
0.028215473517775536,
-0.24868705868721008,
-0.5661137700080872,
0.00003231912342016585,
0.3826209008693695,
-0.0570131279528141,
-0.12739501893520355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19273v1
|
PlanGPT: Enhancing Urban Planning with Tailored Language Model and Efficient Retrieval
| 2024-02-29T15:41:20 | 2024-02-29T15:41:20 |
He Zhu, Wenjia Zhang, Nuoxian Huang, Boyang Li, Luyao Niu, Zipei Fan, Tianle Lun, Yicheng Tao, Junyou Su, Zhaoya Gong, Chenyu Fang, Xing Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the field of urban planning, general-purpose large language models often
struggle to meet the specific needs of planners. Tasks like generating urban
planning texts, retrieving related information, and evaluating planning
documents pose unique challenges. To enhance the efficiency of urban
professionals and overcome these obstacles, we introduce PlanGPT, the first
specialized Large Language Model tailored for urban and spatial planning.
Developed through collaborative efforts with institutions like the Chinese
Academy of Urban Planning, PlanGPT leverages a customized local database
retrieval framework, domain-specific fine-tuning of base models, and advanced
tooling capabilities. Empirical tests demonstrate that PlanGPT has achieved
advanced performance, delivering responses of superior quality precisely
tailored to the intricacies of urban planning.
|
[
-0.3262596130371094,
-0.9126909971237183,
0.7091553807258606,
0.36205610632896423,
-0.055846597999334335,
-0.0056320540606975555,
-0.30967602133750916,
-0.3207351863384247,
0.2556709349155426,
0.5146632790565491,
-0.17636992037296295,
-0.3687687814235687,
-0.18226481974124908,
-0.3828427493572235,
-0.3867054283618927,
0.5785539150238037,
-0.2192583978176117,
0.16201846301555634,
0.45046380162239075,
0.11799362301826477,
-0.5344560146331787,
-0.44305679202079773,
-1.0279426574707031,
-0.4834783971309662,
0.20034538209438324,
0.37078389525413513,
1.0495187044143677,
0.6710574626922607,
0.7792032361030579,
0.102122001349926,
0.18301062285900116,
-0.02622280828654766,
-0.42628103494644165,
-0.48984503746032715,
-0.09044644981622696,
0.11587731540203094,
-0.9104089736938477,
-0.3308490812778473,
0.5635735988616943,
0.8937952518463135,
-0.5010939240455627,
-0.03514803573489189,
-0.18361268937587738,
0.7195649147033691,
-0.47883620858192444,
0.19064480066299438,
-0.5822373628616333,
-0.014103366993367672,
-0.3185465633869171,
-0.32665616273880005,
-0.11230289936065674,
-0.4729006290435791,
0.25916609168052673,
-0.5335240364074707,
0.20639030635356903,
-0.0535510778427124,
0.3594839870929718,
0.1343972235918045,
-0.35436901450157166,
-0.15354321897029877,
-0.9488602876663208,
0.275835782289505,
-0.5736702680587769,
0.4844472408294678,
0.31069493293762207,
0.6530013084411621,
-0.2358001470565796,
-1.0771783590316772,
-0.45620134472846985,
-0.3583938777446747,
-0.1705210953950882,
0.11321311444044113,
0.14391618967056274,
0.2601388096809387,
0.18089482188224792,
0.2537780702114105,
-1.0251131057739258,
-0.2540055513381958,
-0.47334933280944824,
0.08055558800697327,
0.6691985130310059,
0.23395700752735138,
0.3744610548019409,
-0.224659726023674,
-0.40133243799209595,
0.13247209787368774,
-0.9980326294898987,
0.0024158568121492863,
0.17486724257469177,
0.4018118679523468,
0.44647467136383057,
0.5666976571083069,
-0.6118015646934509,
0.43517398834228516,
-0.5290541648864746,
0.3494243025779724,
-0.33047911524772644,
-0.544771671295166,
-0.483128160238266,
-0.11185350269079208,
0.5152627229690552,
0.15070965886116028,
0.3602325916290283,
-0.35522395372390747,
-0.48967474699020386,
-0.23954495787620544,
0.29396095871925354,
-0.7633675932884216,
-0.9429453015327454,
0.031801436096429825,
-0.25142574310302734,
0.03413445129990578,
0.008577818050980568,
-0.5967978239059448,
-0.09712496399879456,
-0.3208121657371521,
0.1964500993490219,
-0.2584197521209717,
-0.4251175820827484,
0.4953952431678772,
0.10720041394233704,
0.3604844808578491,
0.4534757733345032,
-1.0478192567825317,
0.2629949152469635,
0.6451258063316345,
0.6546428799629211,
-0.3121029734611511,
-0.309893935918808,
-0.03396248444914818,
0.4314206838607788,
-0.5383470058441162,
1.120714545249939,
-0.6723474264144897,
-0.4019862413406372,
0.023202763870358467,
-0.34739404916763306,
0.15279531478881836,
-0.4830534756183624,
0.8628377318382263,
-0.3585234582424164,
-0.1660396158695221,
-0.40404370427131653,
-0.2246285229921341,
-0.2055252641439438,
0.3044915199279785,
-0.515851616859436,
1.1837563514709473,
0.30859628319740295,
-0.38597777485847473,
0.6990683078765869,
-0.9772894382476807,
-0.4022831916809082,
0.6517242193222046,
-0.17643308639526367,
0.04979473724961281,
-0.013196653686463833,
0.35681796073913574,
0.2937653660774231,
-0.1806584596633911,
0.6049466729164124,
-0.04344428703188896,
-0.366367369890213,
-0.5833314061164856,
-0.16944529116153717,
0.5770947337150574,
0.29873090982437134,
-0.06885795295238495,
0.49881717562675476,
-0.6811506748199463,
0.2736327350139618,
0.32779839634895325,
-0.8622447848320007,
-0.25771746039390564,
0.27319881319999695,
0.43747320771217346,
0.036925505846738815,
0.494913786649704,
-0.4015250504016876,
0.7449337840080261,
-0.11620055139064789,
0.37603676319122314,
0.4714680016040802,
-0.348380982875824,
0.6477493047714233,
-0.4636649191379547,
0.4528850018978119,
-0.7207662463188171,
0.008095337077975273,
-0.09320632368326187,
-0.37916436791419983,
-0.5145628452301025,
0.017396900802850723,
-0.005764771718531847,
0.5430722832679749,
-0.544299840927124,
0.03993189334869385,
-0.5867322683334351,
-0.8977984189987183,
-0.12230546772480011,
-0.28192898631095886,
-0.15287038683891296,
0.2355131208896637,
0.25940799713134766,
-0.0499182865023613,
-0.4901394248008728,
-0.696821928024292,
-0.2675510048866272,
0.126564159989357,
-0.1340833306312561,
0.4336603283882141,
0.3281087279319763,
-0.0721774473786354,
0.8814641833305359,
-0.7408153414726257,
-0.16263829171657562,
-0.4678419232368469,
-0.09547428786754608,
0.23777511715888977,
0.2650141417980194,
0.7647960782051086,
-0.9111917614936829,
-0.7349958419799805,
0.19129440188407898,
-0.2236846387386322,
-0.28861871361732483,
-0.016867097467184067,
-0.4383792281150818,
-0.5056923627853394,
0.21710892021656036,
-0.8248564004898071,
0.28276190161705017,
0.10563746839761734,
-0.5197345018386841,
0.8262285590171814,
-0.4462169110774994,
0.09930740296840668,
-0.8841098546981812,
0.27513250708580017,
-0.2999243140220642,
-0.3843892216682434,
-0.7418497204780579,
0.5081232190132141,
0.21919570863246918,
-0.38749104738235474,
-0.18631771206855774,
0.763207733631134,
-0.26205968856811523,
-0.1808462142944336,
-0.1731829047203064,
0.373144268989563,
-0.21536953747272491,
0.42964106798171997,
0.40152958035469055,
1.091257929801941,
0.27338382601737976,
-0.6643586158752441,
0.3226149082183838,
0.43651556968688965,
-0.4747440814971924,
0.36715519428253174,
-0.712273359298706,
0.39096421003341675,
-0.12568072974681854,
0.13292664289474487,
-0.6084739565849304,
-0.6028125882148743,
-0.1007673367857933,
0.02886849269270897,
0.015195554122328758,
-0.1288900077342987,
-0.6174308061599731,
-0.4472300708293915,
-0.05917513370513916,
0.1638956367969513,
0.27923449873924255,
-0.6126337647438049,
0.4692409634590149,
0.5534818768501282,
-0.3779132664203644,
-0.26910293102264404,
-0.4115957021713257,
0.13780272006988525,
-0.04872845858335495,
-0.681155800819397,
0.19138891994953156,
-0.24635200202465057,
-0.1801001876592636,
-0.20338769257068634,
-0.050969719886779785,
-0.5325660705566406,
-0.004556709434837103,
-0.42153242230415344,
-0.10529719293117523,
-0.1490192413330078,
0.1725997030735016,
-0.16362904012203217,
0.06649922579526901,
0.004772005137056112,
-0.36234715580940247,
0.78693026304245,
0.2573690712451935,
-0.23514707386493683,
0.2138986885547638,
0.6808017492294312,
0.5211959481239319,
-0.7243900895118713,
0.23703928291797638,
0.4781811237335205,
-0.5375409126281738,
-0.26561564207077026,
-0.35756778717041016,
0.10932406783103943,
-0.4791010022163391,
0.7503944635391235,
-0.7375969290733337,
-0.5842840671539307,
0.3906219005584717,
-0.25437131524086,
0.28260475397109985,
0.12259071320295334,
0.4403684735298157,
0.3374937176704407,
0.9831690788269043,
0.7888612151145935,
0.14423327147960663,
0.6227348446846008,
0.05570153892040253,
0.4273296892642975,
-0.6357080340385437,
-0.25145894289016724,
-0.5894766449928284,
-0.15201494097709656,
-0.25340577960014343,
-0.3829965591430664,
0.19878338277339935,
0.22576002776622772,
-0.4770163893699646,
0.6356521844863892,
-0.7829314470291138,
0.5524734854698181,
0.49185091257095337,
0.06524290889501572,
0.4616578221321106,
-0.19813181459903717,
0.03751175105571747,
0.06613486260175705,
-0.6748191714286804,
-0.7758718132972717,
0.9256539940834045,
0.03168948367238045,
0.8539445400238037,
0.4196271598339081,
0.4956749379634857,
-0.022017180919647217,
0.15747855603694916,
-0.5867395997047424,
0.6806377172470093,
-0.40066081285476685,
-0.6607442498207092,
-0.33780956268310547,
-0.3225477337837219,
-0.8904980421066284,
0.19555778801441193,
-0.08662073314189911,
-0.9592194557189941,
0.07787634432315826,
0.019579723477363586,
-0.40891072154045105,
0.4629104435443878,
-0.6950004696846008,
0.9151237607002258,
-0.2817244231700897,
0.049588363617658615,
-0.36425864696502686,
0.0420951321721077,
0.16003921627998352,
-0.3967481553554535,
-0.11232873797416687,
-0.2949846088886261,
0.22024771571159363,
0.3886624872684479,
-0.053697556257247925,
0.05910802632570267,
-0.22124949097633362,
0.15717999637126923,
-0.005323832388967276,
0.3263516128063202,
0.8198158144950867,
0.014083786867558956,
-0.42535024881362915,
-0.17975209653377533,
0.10044775903224945,
-0.4924335181713104,
-0.46015337109565735,
0.7683760523796082,
-0.4784247875213623,
-0.4010050296783447,
0.25249961018562317,
-0.8165791034698486,
0.0572274774312973,
0.5787372589111328,
0.18947739899158478,
0.3619349002838135,
-0.6028730273246765,
0.04214033484458923,
0.4006216824054718,
-0.17993341386318207,
0.45171698927879333,
0.5220622420310974,
-0.5270847678184509,
-0.04168447479605675,
0.6591722369194031,
0.18370388448238373,
0.03150170296430588,
0.646194338798523,
0.27050289511680603,
-0.36214619874954224,
-0.8531571626663208,
-0.278639554977417,
-0.2804587185382843,
-0.656257688999176,
-0.09921897947788239,
-0.6516849994659424,
-0.20139668881893158,
-0.5302701592445374,
-0.5057623386383057,
-0.5574194192886353,
-0.5300096273422241,
0.3907456696033478,
-0.14986826479434967,
-0.17545028030872345,
1.1568758487701416,
0.12738056480884552,
0.217850461602211,
-0.5768333673477173,
0.24257563054561615,
0.23751141130924225,
0.47797638177871704,
-0.19318386912345886,
0.1436755210161209,
-0.17084361612796783,
-0.0373564288020134,
-0.16538923978805542,
-0.8064659833908081,
0.5398291945457458,
0.061818964779376984,
0.5422752499580383,
0.2533358335494995,
0.235321044921875,
0.61820387840271,
-0.5180500745773315,
0.7124684453010559,
-0.44113802909851074,
-0.5390989780426025,
0.9211102724075317,
-0.879235565662384,
0.5415529608726501,
0.49188628792762756,
0.1027941182255745,
-0.43272385001182556,
0.05029549449682236,
-0.1927553415298462,
-1.1939467191696167,
0.5222669243812561,
0.11302018165588379,
0.10864381492137909,
0.007490328047424555,
0.6744009852409363,
-0.013846146874129772,
0.14713694155216217,
-1.0487605333328247,
0.03761531785130501,
-0.10589586943387985,
0.05135830491781235,
0.01487395167350769,
-0.420078843832016,
-0.05735243111848831,
-0.3670863211154938,
0.5342198610305786,
-0.0823012962937355,
0.37093234062194824,
0.3585176467895508,
0.031460147351026535,
-0.14234322309494019,
0.38968348503112793,
0.7089037299156189,
1.1090022325515747,
-0.2738816440105438,
-0.03580423444509506,
0.3023488521575928,
-0.5324606895446777,
-0.15448583662509918,
0.30815473198890686,
-0.5015069246292114,
-0.156177818775177,
0.24427303671836853,
0.5553238391876221,
0.1928510218858719,
-0.44133415818214417,
0.3041888177394867,
-0.133578822016716,
0.013082168996334076,
-0.550784170627594,
0.008344631642103195,
-0.17998869717121124,
0.31166383624076843,
0.6507522463798523,
-0.15925553441047668,
0.35627931356430054,
-0.37710651755332947,
0.30679982900619507,
0.3933028280735016,
-0.4219932556152344,
-0.12637539207935333,
0.9812623262405396,
0.18826431035995483,
-0.5162749886512756,
0.5914413928985596,
-0.2328001856803894,
-0.5041651129722595,
0.3453638553619385,
0.5560480356216431,
0.9739376902580261,
-0.25309616327285767,
0.039160508662462234,
0.6254440546035767,
0.5569878220558167,
-0.16363131999969482,
0.5709245204925537,
-0.020781219005584717,
-0.6080836057662964,
-0.49276435375213623,
-0.707030713558197,
-0.21418584883213043,
0.04225467890501022,
-0.3392808139324188,
0.3415364921092987,
-0.46064773201942444,
-0.007837919518351555,
-0.5308011174201965,
0.40803372859954834,
-0.5958293676376343,
-0.06279326230287552,
-0.14550304412841797,
1.5383626222610474,
-0.36880820989608765,
1.0332350730895996,
1.2789424657821655,
-0.1480492353439331,
-1.291895866394043,
0.23358027637004852,
-0.510047972202301,
-0.6871273517608643,
0.462539941072464,
-0.016616595908999443,
-0.11550154536962509,
0.18049713969230652,
-0.19929301738739014,
-0.8269715309143066,
1.294429063796997,
0.35875236988067627,
-0.6207265257835388,
-0.2893468737602234,
0.34381961822509766,
0.4888072609901428,
-0.25954556465148926,
0.31087836623191833,
0.7351163029670715,
0.7819367051124573,
-0.06425900757312775,
-1.2612056732177734,
0.07726118713617325,
0.06544515490531921,
0.006731294561177492,
0.5337816476821899,
-0.4719247817993164,
0.7841323018074036,
-0.29099559783935547,
-0.26761311292648315,
0.14667728543281555,
0.3092412054538727,
-0.06024433672428131,
0.12890498340129852,
0.15346519649028778,
0.4840458631515503,
0.9028975963592529,
-0.5150037407875061,
1.1192426681518555,
-0.48285242915153503,
0.3094821572303772,
1.1709282398223877,
-0.07403673231601715,
0.940923810005188,
-0.19164997339248657,
-0.2293560802936554,
-0.07306620478630066,
0.6592628359794617,
0.2036067098379135,
0.8089443445205688,
-0.0853867307305336,
-0.39354267716407776,
-0.21079358458518982,
0.004272394347935915,
-0.17087678611278534,
0.7326673269271851,
0.22312679886817932,
0.21148677170276642,
-0.39158037304878235,
-0.3043697774410248,
-0.04060423746705055,
0.1193886250257492,
-0.4176595211029053,
0.5743529796600342,
-0.16365347802639008,
-0.6324312686920166,
-0.1405903548002243,
-0.01565113477408886,
0.3445552885532379,
-0.8167531490325928,
-0.0549619235098362,
-0.4399637281894684,
0.21319150924682617,
-0.15174159407615662,
-1.0306034088134766,
0.6483802795410156,
-0.5173572897911072,
-0.046367097645998,
-0.20029643177986145,
0.7865104675292969,
-0.6129689812660217,
-0.22452688217163086,
0.4525367021560669,
0.3416499197483063,
0.021734928712248802,
-0.5135531425476074,
-0.52337646484375,
-0.27235302329063416,
-0.07759418338537216,
-0.2858138978481293,
0.05183553695678711,
0.6336458921432495,
-0.14322522282600403,
0.8466416597366333,
0.7945353984832764,
0.3233560025691986,
0.022258462384343147,
0.04792118817567825,
0.7551984786987305,
-0.739561915397644,
-0.505505383014679,
-0.6088486909866333,
0.2442442774772644,
-0.1381281614303589,
-0.23686592280864716,
0.31746265292167664,
0.7418708801269531,
0.8625653386116028,
-0.006217630580067635,
0.6273528337478638,
-0.20144949853420258,
0.31545016169548035,
-0.3684322237968445,
0.8604639172554016,
-0.3479102849960327,
0.4010072350502014,
-0.09265672415494919,
-1.2890225648880005,
-0.49994921684265137,
0.8651439547538757,
-0.41787344217300415,
0.09292658418416977,
0.35941341519355774,
0.6103087067604065,
-0.1726977676153183,
-0.3134438395500183,
0.5969896912574768,
-0.11567844450473785,
0.7601680159568787,
0.7482272386550903,
0.5630935430526733,
-0.15529976785182953,
0.731110692024231,
-0.2208719104528427,
-0.3289909362792969,
-0.026063842698931694,
-0.6214120984077454,
-0.7943205833435059,
-0.4189937710762024,
0.12037940323352814,
0.3751797080039978,
0.22037172317504883,
0.9069125056266785,
1.1132863759994507,
-0.6760891675949097,
-0.10404539853334427,
-0.23976008594036102,
-0.09407581388950348,
0.04260324314236641,
-0.33064597845077515,
0.5534837245941162,
-0.026803048327565193,
-0.7514606714248657,
0.6187629699707031,
0.5402919054031372,
0.039733074605464935,
-0.23375612497329712,
-0.09269880503416061,
0.031232330948114395,
0.03525121882557869,
0.5826111435890198,
0.250137597322464,
-0.3243776559829712,
-0.22158826887607574,
-0.021338418126106262,
-0.2871294319629669,
0.11779872328042984,
1.173589825630188,
-0.5399865508079529,
0.4272083342075348,
0.5268613696098328,
0.47784462571144104,
0.44620540738105774,
-0.11513237655162811,
0.9456084370613098,
-0.7437782287597656,
0.18104152381420135,
0.14793594181537628,
0.5395739078521729,
0.35048922896385193,
-0.6359943151473999,
0.9613038897514343,
-0.3324224352836609,
-1.014324426651001,
-0.31479325890541077,
0.4638001620769501,
-0.8665677309036255,
-0.1016589030623436,
0.9291347861289978,
0.004850239958614111,
0.38070279359817505,
-0.2878378629684448,
-0.5738579034805298,
0.08382142335176468,
-0.4685908257961273,
0.908873975276947,
0.48263150453567505,
-0.29646727442741394,
-0.3589840531349182,
-1.0184465646743774,
0.6126881837844849,
-0.014135482721030712,
-0.9087389707565308,
0.38797396421432495,
0.33097726106643677,
0.07348074018955231,
0.054272815585136414,
1.3161985874176025,
0.07266473025083542,
0.28216826915740967,
0.009920555166900158,
0.07745081931352615,
-0.023766539990901947,
-0.29865550994873047,
0.18417736887931824,
0.2269573211669922,
0.39227136969566345,
0.33192455768585205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19267v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19267v2
|
Robust Guidance for Unsupervised Data Selection: Capturing Perplexing Named Entities for Domain-Specific Machine Translation
| 2024-02-29T15:38:28 | 2024-05-21T17:19:37 |
Seunghyun Ji, Hagai Raja Sinulingga, Darongsae Kwon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Low-resourced data presents a significant challenge for neural machine
translation. In most cases, the low-resourced environment is caused by high
costs due to the need for domain experts or the lack of language experts.
Therefore, identifying the most training-efficient data within an unsupervised
setting emerges as a practical strategy. Recent research suggests that such
effective data can be identified by selecting 'appropriately complex data'
based on its volume, providing strong intuition for unsupervised data
selection. However, we have discovered that establishing criteria for
unsupervised data selection remains a challenge, as the 'appropriate level of
difficulty' may vary depending on the data domain. We introduce a novel
unsupervised data selection method named 'Capturing Perplexing Named Entities,'
which leverages the maximum inference entropy in translated named entities as a
metric for selection. When tested with the 'Korean-English Parallel Corpus of
Specialized Domains,' our method served as robust guidance for identifying
training-efficient data across different domains, in contrast to existing
methods.
|
[
-0.4228155314922333,
-0.3259343206882477,
0.5866459608078003,
0.2249748557806015,
-0.5667111873626709,
0.2169463038444519,
-0.46826890110969543,
-0.04911847040057182,
0.054099515080451965,
0.5668179988861084,
-0.6029289960861206,
-0.7293155789375305,
-0.7530393004417419,
0.3075725734233856,
-0.3866378962993622,
0.9671602249145508,
-0.2081102579832077,
0.08441042900085449,
-0.44385990500450134,
-0.17111985385417938,
-0.22904156148433685,
-0.6539632081985474,
-0.5066202282905579,
-0.4749055802822113,
0.4838492274284363,
0.470839262008667,
0.5849095582962036,
0.7701178193092346,
0.5850667357444763,
0.22462709248065948,
-0.20135299861431122,
0.582454264163971,
-0.36648061871528625,
0.35300374031066895,
-0.13664036989212036,
-0.5210422873497009,
-0.254160076379776,
-0.14824119210243225,
0.3683128356933594,
1.0898194313049316,
0.05631987005472183,
0.17482908070087433,
0.0829366147518158,
0.5857062339782715,
-0.6152750253677368,
0.13728190958499908,
-0.8855584859848022,
0.45040732622146606,
-0.511518120765686,
-0.336686372756958,
-0.3535817861557007,
0.24210608005523682,
0.13278985023498535,
-0.8080733418464661,
0.23837919533252716,
0.15101754665374756,
0.6744919419288635,
0.7024012804031372,
-0.41526633501052856,
0.03560703992843628,
-0.6357711553573608,
0.8817339539527893,
-0.2869669497013092,
0.41793933510780334,
0.4814704358577728,
0.2493007332086563,
-0.24385033547878265,
-0.5955842733383179,
-0.2577774226665497,
0.21122623980045319,
0.15171034634113312,
0.08179263770580292,
-0.35809454321861267,
-0.1985940784215927,
0.32378169894218445,
0.06808318942785263,
-0.4360654056072235,
0.250433087348938,
-0.13534776866436005,
-0.3817896842956543,
0.5952807664871216,
0.09469529986381531,
0.2307068258523941,
-0.08204840123653412,
-0.3772009313106537,
-0.09094054996967316,
-0.5630872845649719,
-0.2283058613538742,
0.42249900102615356,
0.4488341510295868,
0.21187196671962738,
0.6774910688400269,
-0.43314430117607117,
0.3898455798625946,
0.10312558710575104,
-0.05499536171555519,
0.4078115224838257,
0.009140080772340298,
-0.2381838858127594,
0.20645223557949066,
0.7229203581809998,
0.2143140584230423,
0.2562560439109802,
-0.7131761908531189,
-0.4869624078273773,
-0.16275888681411743,
0.32358455657958984,
-0.7278932332992554,
-0.5352169275283813,
0.16874538362026215,
-0.33647391200065613,
-0.2555237412452698,
-0.12160704284906387,
-0.9031268358230591,
-0.34794187545776367,
-0.1915723979473114,
-0.11596254259347916,
-0.18090015649795532,
-0.22900088131427765,
-0.10222404450178146,
-0.16698041558265686,
-0.2694515287876129,
0.30109715461730957,
-0.7610411047935486,
0.0312986858189106,
0.31935760378837585,
0.6965486407279968,
-0.6723285913467407,
-0.2581542432308197,
-0.4242599308490753,
0.1488463431596756,
-0.4655463695526123,
0.829351007938385,
-0.7554311156272888,
-0.16345186531543732,
-0.23036369681358337,
-0.08612427115440369,
-0.09010728448629379,
-0.7301144599914551,
0.5960793495178223,
-0.6290672421455383,
-0.1552584022283554,
-0.1653408706188202,
-0.5275301933288574,
-0.20161794126033783,
0.024560315534472466,
-0.6118746399879456,
0.7546443343162537,
0.2860562801361084,
-0.9564439654350281,
0.6472560167312622,
-0.3780759274959564,
-0.334339439868927,
0.18928076326847076,
-0.21125276386737823,
-0.5630148649215698,
0.1617153435945511,
0.48182496428489685,
0.6889262199401855,
-0.43864259123802185,
0.2539094388484955,
-0.28770262002944946,
0.14690572023391724,
0.2695114314556122,
-0.5608218312263489,
0.7023066878318787,
0.5667539834976196,
-0.1693883240222931,
-0.09074835479259491,
-0.7920566201210022,
0.19277071952819824,
0.34943056106567383,
-0.37037041783332825,
-0.6668362021446228,
-0.16223371028900146,
-0.040870435535907745,
-0.1954585164785385,
0.12550514936447144,
-0.24686169624328613,
0.19826626777648926,
0.11818113923072815,
0.3585548400878906,
0.4137941002845764,
0.019855454564094543,
0.6627324819564819,
0.17748916149139404,
0.7287049293518066,
0.29518523812294006,
-0.19747640192508698,
0.17115017771720886,
-0.44249647855758667,
-0.4763302505016327,
-0.38963451981544495,
0.7600837349891663,
0.7436818480491638,
-1.0161166191101074,
0.38113144040107727,
-0.18343570828437805,
-0.38823142647743225,
-0.7429794669151306,
0.383487343788147,
0.4528801441192627,
0.5394721031188965,
0.6028717160224915,
-0.21572762727737427,
-0.5321514010429382,
-0.8558338284492493,
-0.19279636442661285,
0.2920711934566498,
-0.17971333861351013,
0.42597833275794983,
0.336317241191864,
-0.41121241450309753,
0.40272441506385803,
-0.6331045031547546,
-0.07520847767591476,
-0.21651369333267212,
0.1855054348707199,
0.12321469932794571,
0.5299825072288513,
0.33323654532432556,
-1.0526211261749268,
-0.48707717657089233,
0.13314411044120789,
-0.8138164281845093,
-0.23431238532066345,
-0.39328062534332275,
-0.5162531137466431,
-0.16618694365024567,
0.5163810849189758,
-0.862060010433197,
0.3028496503829956,
0.2360062450170517,
-0.06876370310783386,
0.23628684878349304,
-0.1882224977016449,
-0.059984125196933746,
-0.9766053557395935,
0.14408650994300842,
0.02590981498360634,
-0.3534510135650635,
-0.4899842441082001,
-0.052037499845027924,
0.27240538597106934,
0.12464604526758194,
-0.29491546750068665,
0.19441033899784088,
-0.7780737280845642,
0.12103008478879929,
0.08615800738334656,
0.03788040205836296,
-0.3093341886997223,
0.4766593873500824,
0.1473499834537506,
0.5973045229911804,
0.7792356014251709,
-0.6632271409034729,
0.570405900478363,
0.4485376179218292,
-0.4583643078804016,
0.5799571871757507,
-0.18265984952449799,
0.25836116075515747,
-0.07484667748212814,
-0.1573289930820465,
-0.5141725540161133,
-0.4280347228050232,
0.0776473805308342,
-0.48566702008247375,
0.5586510896682739,
-0.4513791501522064,
-0.4360060393810272,
-0.1510811448097229,
0.20917287468910217,
0.6430372595787048,
0.3103991150856018,
-0.5516233444213867,
0.20640714466571808,
0.7202490568161011,
-0.04891585186123848,
-0.6304090619087219,
-0.9463589191436768,
0.22974735498428345,
-0.5867179036140442,
-0.15303905308246613,
0.46194663643836975,
0.05055812746286392,
0.007943945936858654,
-0.018678002059459686,
-0.5143473744392395,
-0.32899925112724304,
0.2896643579006195,
0.02978322096168995,
0.20183289051055908,
-0.25202110409736633,
-0.1618906706571579,
0.37373363971710205,
-0.31113937497138977,
0.1594357043504715,
-0.3704189360141754,
0.2519167363643646,
0.2081521600484848,
-0.17576879262924194,
-0.3699329197406769,
0.3839009404182434,
0.5881880521774292,
-0.2864547073841095,
0.4580719769001007,
0.5725274682044983,
-0.5496225357055664,
-0.5471700429916382,
-0.17114783823490143,
-0.021028032526373863,
-0.37710627913475037,
0.4845398962497711,
-0.5127727389335632,
-0.43406224250793457,
0.5669035911560059,
-0.46505776047706604,
-0.40602990984916687,
0.32210513949394226,
0.36503535509109497,
0.09095021337270737,
1.295856237411499,
0.576895534992218,
-0.15975870192050934,
0.12771126627922058,
-0.29135769605636597,
0.337654173374176,
-0.9246105551719666,
-0.5397554636001587,
-0.5270195007324219,
-0.3316183090209961,
-0.4538929760456085,
-0.3108021318912506,
0.2476477324962616,
0.22714734077453613,
-0.010951744392514229,
0.4476521611213684,
-0.6791602373123169,
0.5584874153137207,
0.5752778649330139,
-0.1074889525771141,
0.2529206871986389,
0.25182658433914185,
-0.32595789432525635,
-0.13900741934776306,
-0.744288444519043,
-0.4381290376186371,
1.141251802444458,
0.0972067266702652,
0.6618901491165161,
-0.03621593117713928,
0.565628170967102,
0.0914284810423851,
-0.1292942762374878,
-0.7920281291007996,
0.4579627811908722,
-0.2816406786441803,
-0.3154197037220001,
-0.31597596406936646,
-0.7349017262458801,
-1.3008449077606201,
0.21920855343341827,
-0.3181726038455963,
-0.6690219044685364,
0.18308722972869873,
-0.012779389508068562,
-0.39646098017692566,
0.4207848608493805,
-0.526820182800293,
0.9026424884796143,
-0.2628090977668762,
0.25406619906425476,
0.12440691143274307,
-0.6115654706954956,
0.05799095705151558,
-0.4642788767814636,
-0.26319265365600586,
-0.06861893832683563,
-0.24786406755447388,
0.6698974370956421,
-0.19882303476333618,
0.5229290723800659,
-0.20406046509742737,
0.1519450843334198,
0.12314945459365845,
0.21487969160079956,
0.423278272151947,
0.14420846104621887,
0.01335197128355503,
0.3323758542537689,
-0.2101553976535797,
-0.4042167067527771,
-0.6149882078170776,
0.703145444393158,
-0.6502726078033447,
-0.31893908977508545,
-0.14816419780254364,
-0.7128981947898865,
-0.44713398814201355,
0.41372615098953247,
0.6368723511695862,
-0.026875799521803856,
0.11916786432266235,
0.538607656955719,
0.9877513647079468,
-0.0448739118874073,
0.15182022750377655,
0.38534480333328247,
0.17863813042640686,
-0.3692582845687866,
1.0343828201293945,
0.22920900583267212,
-0.18197713792324066,
0.6271822452545166,
-0.07307172566652298,
-0.2637030780315399,
-1.001421332359314,
-0.7857356071472168,
-0.08473058044910431,
-0.5462765693664551,
-0.6320013999938965,
-0.7470397353172302,
-0.12304937839508057,
-0.16796809434890747,
0.04525381326675415,
-0.5900548696517944,
-0.4625250995159149,
-0.500156581401825,
-0.22603701055049896,
0.055266108363866806,
0.2837682068347931,
0.23255716264247894,
0.03923141956329346,
-0.6726706624031067,
0.27915361523628235,
0.12198010832071304,
0.070462666451931,
-0.2709869146347046,
-0.47761258482933044,
-0.13706792891025543,
-0.008658291772007942,
-0.05140037462115288,
-0.9132431149482727,
0.5592398643493652,
0.07892173528671265,
0.9114751815795898,
0.39169323444366455,
0.3985912501811981,
0.6885573863983154,
-0.4082362949848175,
0.51786208152771,
0.11622032523155212,
-0.652205765247345,
0.6375012397766113,
-0.09698540717363358,
0.18614055216312408,
0.5126383900642395,
0.7072153091430664,
-0.3060850203037262,
-0.45241430401802063,
-0.6099632382392883,
-1.2234901189804077,
0.6088054776191711,
0.3349247872829437,
0.1285562813282013,
0.12219306081533432,
0.41799306869506836,
0.3093208372592926,
0.4629547894001007,
-0.29035791754722595,
-0.39496126770973206,
-0.2069849967956543,
-0.19020304083824158,
0.08140184730291367,
0.15830174088478088,
-0.08445937186479568,
-0.21601344645023346,
0.5418340563774109,
-0.11142606288194656,
0.22768811881542206,
0.2728259861469269,
-0.27792614698410034,
-0.15233443677425385,
-0.0005594354006461799,
0.24525916576385498,
0.29550957679748535,
0.0808992013335228,
0.24162372946739197,
0.20235946774482727,
-0.5211728811264038,
-0.18886162340641022,
0.1405877023935318,
-0.424802303314209,
0.12607578933238983,
0.28586986660957336,
0.9700341820716858,
-0.0023289071395993233,
-0.6333619952201843,
0.47096937894821167,
0.08117210865020752,
-0.13733012974262238,
-0.16082856059074402,
0.06845614314079285,
-0.15084794163703918,
0.4542575180530548,
0.308959424495697,
0.42259639501571655,
0.16235937178134918,
-0.14204443991184235,
0.1758250594139099,
0.42596933245658875,
-0.266850084066391,
-0.29538482427597046,
0.7899375557899475,
0.023137293756008148,
-0.1538897603750229,
0.9935159087181091,
-0.5124343037605286,
-0.45878151059150696,
0.5192670226097107,
0.486379474401474,
0.9594058990478516,
-0.18327875435352325,
0.1588517725467682,
0.11663826555013657,
0.21636727452278137,
-0.3618510067462921,
0.12481047958135605,
-0.19652554392814636,
-0.7629378437995911,
-0.16779565811157227,
-0.42661765217781067,
-0.24970930814743042,
0.38755303621292114,
-0.9748877882957458,
0.03860948979854584,
-0.19231514632701874,
-0.2967495024204254,
0.24202923476696014,
-0.049646392464637756,
-0.9045938849449158,
0.21615153551101685,
0.3655836582183838,
0.9116522073745728,
-0.7242820858955383,
0.9519457817077637,
0.9394863843917847,
-0.3600926101207733,
-0.7298018932342529,
0.1245390996336937,
0.1365591287612915,
-0.7578720450401306,
0.48343896865844727,
-0.21379384398460388,
-0.017860041931271553,
-0.029715778306126595,
-0.6656893491744995,
-0.8457370400428772,
1.0676754713058472,
0.7154173851013184,
-0.3148474097251892,
-0.015876561403274536,
0.04702834039926529,
0.5434190630912781,
-0.5899572968482971,
-0.1572033315896988,
0.61307293176651,
0.43469059467315674,
0.10346230864524841,
-0.7876413464546204,
0.11603482812643051,
-0.47903183102607727,
0.02064460888504982,
0.20968188345432281,
-0.48346805572509766,
0.4973912239074707,
-0.36291253566741943,
-0.27568402886390686,
-0.030276117846369743,
0.7187199592590332,
-0.10619737207889557,
0.47219550609588623,
0.597301185131073,
0.4885067343711853,
1.3004629611968994,
0.02157154493033886,
0.8037576079368591,
-0.23778700828552246,
0.2487446665763855,
0.9470562934875488,
0.005976541433483362,
0.8085428476333618,
0.602618932723999,
-0.04852988198399544,
0.044679906219244,
0.8570176959037781,
-0.27756965160369873,
0.9990456104278564,
0.22733670473098755,
-0.10767129063606262,
-0.5980828404426575,
-0.2599118947982788,
-0.10009977221488953,
0.6439142227172852,
0.4457966685295105,
-0.28219738602638245,
-0.1125769093632698,
0.02111007645726204,
0.12904945015907288,
-0.08458294719457626,
-0.25056958198547363,
0.6581411957740784,
0.18109937012195587,
-0.7668938636779785,
0.8183481693267822,
-0.06283053755760193,
0.41723671555519104,
-0.3245701789855957,
0.10793381929397583,
-0.3229537010192871,
-0.015528630465269089,
-0.3818618059158325,
-0.762546956539154,
0.24917294085025787,
0.3762246072292328,
-0.17993175983428955,
-0.39290812611579895,
0.5036638975143433,
-0.6646589040756226,
-0.21755503118038177,
0.3077097237110138,
0.6191834807395935,
0.5920513868331909,
-0.5016168355941772,
-0.6859806776046753,
-0.24033349752426147,
0.35366660356521606,
-0.46004509925842285,
0.4182591140270233,
1.052563190460205,
-0.16488195955753326,
0.723900318145752,
0.5011400580406189,
0.23835784196853638,
-0.10042417049407959,
0.008868522942066193,
0.8695290684700012,
-0.6371975541114807,
-0.28246966004371643,
-0.5157115459442139,
0.4253920614719391,
-0.1937739998102188,
-0.4572398066520691,
0.6108518242835999,
0.6376335024833679,
1.2332336902618408,
-0.09060267359018326,
0.8213261961936951,
0.2733461260795593,
0.3156461715698242,
-0.5912349224090576,
0.7248112559318542,
-0.6407755017280579,
0.5006645321846008,
-0.05084039270877838,
-1.0647661685943604,
-0.4867238998413086,
0.5970680713653564,
-0.11147011816501617,
-0.22015395760536194,
0.8617265224456787,
0.7708463668823242,
-0.453678160905838,
-0.16587303578853607,
0.39471814036369324,
0.18294209241867065,
-0.12177971750497818,
0.5993527770042419,
0.531700074672699,
-0.1624039113521576,
0.8282158970832825,
-0.41392967104911804,
-0.13980528712272644,
-0.11738978326320648,
-0.8157087564468384,
-1.041911005973816,
-0.6669070720672607,
-0.5820413827896118,
-0.10694419592618942,
-0.19418634474277496,
0.99127596616745,
0.7937085628509521,
-1.0241985321044922,
0.2687602937221527,
0.0236377976834774,
0.18559439480304718,
-0.3851429224014282,
-0.10684403032064438,
0.39222148060798645,
-0.4405564069747925,
-0.9145192503929138,
0.7168776988983154,
0.17872832715511322,
0.1255827695131302,
0.007167200557887554,
-0.01430340576916933,
0.3479319214820862,
-0.04590190574526787,
0.3474701941013336,
0.23383569717407227,
-0.5467702150344849,
0.17150789499282837,
-0.058450810611248016,
-0.2455338090658188,
-0.009562492370605469,
0.8225674033164978,
-0.43263670802116394,
0.4257920980453491,
0.3961477279663086,
1.1590900421142578,
0.47850745916366577,
-0.1355813592672348,
0.43051838874816895,
-0.845075786113739,
0.08161941170692444,
0.38458794355392456,
0.3458353877067566,
0.49391427636146545,
-0.6895884275436401,
0.5615350008010864,
0.3775333762168884,
-0.4920955300331116,
-1.0759751796722412,
0.007675871253013611,
-0.9540182948112488,
-0.3066049814224243,
1.2140476703643799,
-0.4165571630001068,
-0.24692006409168243,
-0.32629749178886414,
-0.027244988828897476,
0.3617384433746338,
-0.451154500246048,
0.8436922430992126,
0.5735388994216919,
-0.11050624400377274,
0.05994722247123718,
-0.8315885663032532,
0.7130210399627686,
0.6155295372009277,
-0.5965530276298523,
0.05360065773129463,
0.1908443123102188,
0.10898305475711823,
0.13727588951587677,
0.1466929167509079,
0.035407133400440216,
-0.09416519105434418,
0.0917256698012352,
-0.244005024433136,
-0.01417478360235691,
-0.6193609833717346,
-0.10720301419496536,
0.06929588317871094,
-0.12722797691822052,
-0.33079633116722107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19255v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19255v2
|
GSM-Plus: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating the Robustness of LLMs as Mathematical Problem Solvers
| 2024-02-29T15:26:14 | 2024-07-02T03:46:03 |
Qintong Li, Leyang Cui, Xueliang Zhao, Lingpeng Kong, Wei Bi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance across
various mathematical reasoning benchmarks. However, there are increasing
debates regarding whether these models truly understand and apply mathematical
knowledge or merely rely on shortcuts for mathematical reasoning. One essential
and frequently occurring evidence is that when the math questions are slightly
changed, LLMs can behave incorrectly. This motivates us to evaluate the
robustness of LLMs' math reasoning capability by testing a wide range of
question variations. We introduce the adversarial grade school math (GSM-Plus)
dataset, an extension of GSM8K augmented with various mathematical
perturbations. Our experiments on 25 LLMs and 4 prompting techniques show that
while LLMs exhibit different levels of math reasoning abilities, their
performances are far from robust. In particular, even for problems that have
been solved in GSM8K, LLMs can make mistakes when new statements are added or
the question targets are altered. We also explore whether more robust
performance can be achieved by composing existing prompting methods, in which
we try an iterative method that generates and verifies each intermediate
thought based on its reasoning goal and calculation result.
|
[
-0.49427130818367004,
-0.9565897583961487,
0.6864532232284546,
0.25562986731529236,
0.00891659315675497,
0.14195874333381653,
-0.202154278755188,
-0.05591735243797302,
-0.4127488136291504,
0.21040117740631104,
-0.6336033344268799,
-0.48430246114730835,
-0.7996364831924438,
0.20940139889717102,
-0.1615930199623108,
0.7381482720375061,
-0.15754161775112152,
0.34891343116760254,
-0.45192861557006836,
-0.10095035284757614,
-0.4301329553127289,
-0.7469050884246826,
-0.7464327216148376,
-0.5145789980888367,
0.41750749945640564,
0.1755836009979248,
0.8758253455162048,
0.4274923503398895,
0.5806501507759094,
0.26964235305786133,
-0.3636782765388489,
0.3160489499568939,
-0.26301804184913635,
0.3149954676628113,
-0.03299851343035698,
-0.8933995962142944,
-0.5219902396202087,
-0.034499552100896835,
0.48407596349716187,
0.6977620124816895,
-0.23135808110237122,
0.2574363648891449,
0.0467524416744709,
0.5201839208602905,
-0.6017448902130127,
0.07082467526197433,
-1.0390945672988892,
-0.14056779444217682,
-0.2193942666053772,
-0.09060579538345337,
-0.348441481590271,
-0.6393328905105591,
-0.18663978576660156,
-0.49034327268600464,
0.03953337296843529,
-0.3778710663318634,
0.6672936081886292,
0.39558354020118713,
-0.26720738410949707,
-0.6556513905525208,
-0.46063557267189026,
0.8642557859420776,
-0.5504728555679321,
0.22140491008758545,
0.5300246477127075,
0.5140622854232788,
-0.3221542537212372,
-0.30398881435394287,
-0.24312804639339447,
-0.31773021817207336,
0.30991441011428833,
0.15346209704875946,
-0.07303661108016968,
-0.3056778609752655,
0.789496123790741,
0.18018776178359985,
-0.5819568037986755,
-0.2554050385951996,
-0.15262971818447113,
-0.23594781756401062,
0.4147127568721771,
0.5239548683166504,
0.28480398654937744,
0.06346213072538376,
-0.16228316724300385,
-0.19727753102779388,
-1.1167843341827393,
0.430045485496521,
0.5627850294113159,
0.13674131035804749,
0.19485852122306824,
0.5165311694145203,
0.10639156401157379,
0.695741593837738,
-0.28010305762290955,
-0.24161124229431152,
-0.08781696110963821,
-0.21648745238780975,
-0.03638768568634987,
-0.23987019062042236,
0.4581730365753174,
0.12500186264514923,
0.4807952642440796,
0.14788125455379486,
-0.29855746030807495,
0.5333864092826843,
0.10392394661903381,
-0.7009034156799316,
-0.23414652049541473,
0.03691030293703079,
-0.0316564217209816,
-0.16564086079597473,
-0.16098421812057495,
-0.5671656727790833,
-0.35709571838378906,
-0.304837703704834,
0.43836626410484314,
-0.4272618293762207,
0.06856098026037216,
0.4353804290294647,
0.12026241421699524,
0.02850520797073841,
0.468903511762619,
-0.686826765537262,
0.29312822222709656,
0.879921019077301,
0.568953275680542,
-0.03263005614280701,
-0.3647596836090088,
-0.6233457922935486,
-0.18316107988357544,
-0.5165995955467224,
0.8415353298187256,
-0.589223325252533,
-0.5610568523406982,
-0.07215524464845657,
-0.2355503886938095,
-0.2756052017211914,
-0.8064817190170288,
0.9766932129859924,
-0.6143836975097656,
0.126429945230484,
-0.5513296127319336,
-0.4624936282634735,
-0.06670064479112625,
0.7863627076148987,
-0.3012069761753082,
1.0017317533493042,
-0.035328175872564316,
-0.4524219334125519,
0.13947804272174835,
-0.42084044218063354,
-0.3349209427833557,
-0.18065330386161804,
-0.22585347294807434,
-0.6569492816925049,
0.03778683394193649,
0.5327377319335938,
0.17185978591442108,
-0.42841848731040955,
0.3429279029369354,
-0.6286159753799438,
-0.38871002197265625,
0.7045974731445312,
-0.7626417875289917,
1.0165088176727295,
0.18126195669174194,
0.01017707958817482,
-0.037833813577890396,
-0.8265911936759949,
0.2668783664703369,
0.3196866810321808,
-0.28264060616493225,
-0.16850636899471283,
-0.06602529436349869,
-0.6599646806716919,
0.1376662701368332,
0.2483036071062088,
-0.15170301496982574,
0.2773451507091522,
-0.06801412254571915,
0.4217655658721924,
0.7980829477310181,
-0.18297187983989716,
0.11850393563508987,
-0.7165822386741638,
0.6681247353553772,
-0.21188126504421234,
0.17499859631061554,
-0.4901562035083771,
-0.6652357578277588,
-0.5617790222167969,
-0.1570308804512024,
0.15083199739456177,
0.7157615423202515,
-0.6569478511810303,
0.04506579041481018,
-0.04348718747496605,
-0.35932692885398865,
-0.16566433012485504,
0.2632445693016052,
0.3735567033290863,
0.5257728099822998,
0.2523583471775055,
0.21091127395629883,
-0.41407573223114014,
-0.4594305753707886,
-0.5538173317909241,
0.006121817044913769,
-0.1504436582326889,
0.38005703687667847,
0.3701001703739166,
0.01229875348508358,
0.39696845412254333,
-0.5004600882530212,
0.19544976949691772,
-0.04205629974603653,
-0.013750649988651276,
0.2827429175376892,
0.07874861359596252,
0.29154181480407715,
-0.47280701994895935,
-0.3307613730430603,
-0.42931488156318665,
-0.8611564636230469,
-0.34201884269714355,
-0.006199374329298735,
0.030423371121287346,
-0.26559704542160034,
0.2909335196018219,
-0.6923438310623169,
0.2053949385881424,
0.4910065233707428,
-0.24978084862232208,
0.7677968144416809,
-0.1125999465584755,
0.03190752863883972,
-0.8685402870178223,
-0.30832600593566895,
0.06493458896875381,
0.06630195677280426,
-0.4507981836795807,
0.09699700772762299,
0.2562737464904785,
-0.3229258954524994,
-0.14273780584335327,
0.28131163120269775,
-0.40627387166023254,
-0.07587961852550507,
-0.2253182977437973,
0.0418546199798584,
0.1034717932343483,
0.2030264288187027,
-0.40423861145973206,
1.0790314674377441,
0.7631896734237671,
-0.6839425563812256,
0.5241917371749878,
0.049159303307533264,
-0.4043799042701721,
0.5474310517311096,
-0.7272564768791199,
0.2213159054517746,
-0.016025027260184288,
0.12171801924705505,
-1.0596423149108887,
-0.23124779760837555,
0.03648800402879715,
-0.5461074113845825,
0.10128028690814972,
-0.22920231521129608,
-0.5047801733016968,
-0.3776550889015198,
-0.45726191997528076,
0.34771689772605896,
0.44290798902511597,
-0.5984740853309631,
0.5076103210449219,
0.0619773231446743,
-0.29972442984580994,
-0.45645344257354736,
-0.3554680347442627,
0.24361050128936768,
-0.4289845824241638,
-0.9048019647598267,
-0.06221235916018486,
-0.2823130488395691,
-0.4837137758731842,
-0.1544199287891388,
-0.12496108561754227,
0.01588696427643299,
0.46861112117767334,
0.1345241367816925,
0.6191801428794861,
-0.3134804964065552,
-0.14620882272720337,
-0.04351990297436714,
-0.37731364369392395,
0.46459004282951355,
-0.05892972648143768,
0.45580124855041504,
-0.2775409519672394,
-0.7827582955360413,
-0.05184309184551239,
0.19762973487377167,
0.5991414785385132,
-0.22293907403945923,
0.3356858491897583,
0.2414269894361496,
-0.44049015641212463,
-0.21477100253105164,
-0.3779342472553253,
-0.15734004974365234,
-0.4901525676250458,
0.034104831516742706,
-0.7793252468109131,
-0.8403431177139282,
0.8525753021240234,
-0.2958255410194397,
-0.007639326620846987,
0.14317676424980164,
0.6166572570800781,
0.1824888288974762,
1.4481922388076782,
-0.01427095104008913,
0.11649877578020096,
0.21022310853004456,
-0.024413879960775375,
-0.07792877405881882,
-0.7103481888771057,
-0.16651806235313416,
-0.6186531782150269,
-0.002498013200238347,
-0.3057183623313904,
-0.26952946186065674,
0.48422661423683167,
0.3155006468296051,
-0.31571003794670105,
0.2446061670780182,
-0.37971940636634827,
0.6433057188987732,
0.284393846988678,
-0.1276264488697052,
0.2694789171218872,
0.020714374259114265,
-0.28211233019828796,
-0.261544406414032,
-0.601651668548584,
-0.6804304122924805,
1.219166874885559,
0.17284557223320007,
1.0652202367782593,
0.3678165674209595,
0.31901004910469055,
-0.24842819571495056,
0.6212356090545654,
-0.7229927778244019,
0.5546756386756897,
0.034630533307790756,
-0.6277679800987244,
-0.03284021466970444,
-0.6630939245223999,
-0.8547400832176208,
0.3129085600376129,
-0.04724712669849396,
-0.7365766167640686,
-0.14647670090198517,
0.04417485371232033,
-0.4725634455680847,
0.18426093459129333,
-0.6634371876716614,
0.5275894403457642,
-0.3701123297214508,
-0.33166784048080444,
0.25545069575309753,
-0.18724225461483002,
0.45208531618118286,
-0.018244929611682892,
0.30714151263237,
-0.2868792712688446,
-0.12302824854850769,
0.23420700430870056,
-0.242543563246727,
0.598962128162384,
0.045589350163936615,
-0.44674205780029297,
0.4419555962085724,
0.39711520075798035,
0.7548708915710449,
0.3894208073616028,
-0.2626441717147827,
-0.0159350223839283,
-0.19525335729122162,
-0.4118240773677826,
-0.9211933612823486,
0.8375884294509888,
-0.6958691477775574,
-0.8770177960395813,
-0.331091046333313,
-0.6517620086669922,
-0.5995976328849792,
-0.019101014360785484,
0.2831920385360718,
0.7134695053100586,
0.2948305606842041,
0.19750474393367767,
0.8484255075454712,
-0.030767953023314476,
0.2646070122718811,
0.38785138726234436,
-0.2561383843421936,
-0.6896494030952454,
0.8933612108230591,
0.3186464011669159,
0.25162020325660706,
0.028853364288806915,
0.4487810730934143,
-0.5583914518356323,
-0.6896705627441406,
-0.7206864953041077,
-0.09914161264896393,
-0.8497158885002136,
-0.27712297439575195,
-0.27642112970352173,
-0.25325265526771545,
-0.10631758719682693,
-0.16768424212932587,
-0.3074166178703308,
-0.30077746510505676,
-0.1773419976234436,
0.08760996162891388,
0.056260183453559875,
0.5158160924911499,
0.21228311955928802,
-0.11188843101263046,
-0.8108406066894531,
0.1339423954486847,
0.49135059118270874,
0.25632020831108093,
-0.12497220188379288,
-0.6744955778121948,
0.15199019014835358,
-0.017093205824494362,
-0.47339361906051636,
-0.7503486275672913,
-0.026022203266620636,
-0.07914932817220688,
0.5869748592376709,
0.43607479333877563,
-0.0429389551281929,
0.6841681599617004,
-0.39254438877105713,
0.7983496189117432,
0.06143391877412796,
-0.8838427662849426,
0.38633209466934204,
-0.5420570373535156,
0.4171060621738434,
0.21455566585063934,
0.27384841442108154,
-0.055239398032426834,
-0.28623566031455994,
-0.562963604927063,
-0.36307471990585327,
0.3047625422477722,
0.36440715193748474,
0.20477397739887238,
0.10231255739927292,
0.5201595425605774,
0.024833451956510544,
-0.016114098951220512,
-0.44422635436058044,
-0.34828895330429077,
-0.2285897433757782,
-0.19203433394432068,
-0.007176741026341915,
-0.31823819875717163,
-0.42525359988212585,
-0.15868620574474335,
0.42594030499458313,
-0.09673498570919037,
-0.014661280438303947,
-0.0398971252143383,
0.06831083446741104,
-0.06516684591770172,
0.4789067208766937,
1.0887489318847656,
1.0636569261550903,
0.031276389956474304,
0.5223767161369324,
0.5445126295089722,
-0.4330843389034271,
0.41784238815307617,
0.30493637919425964,
-0.2663273215293884,
-0.09405079483985901,
0.3103598356246948,
0.5171177983283997,
-0.044838711619377136,
-0.6091783046722412,
0.30147385597229004,
-0.3165419101715088,
-0.48330363631248474,
-0.07105900347232819,
0.2694808840751648,
0.21708019077777863,
0.08284394443035126,
0.44001173973083496,
0.28326156735420227,
-0.07795943319797516,
-0.41792935132980347,
0.09497692435979843,
0.6287040114402771,
-0.1054314449429512,
-0.41270092129707336,
0.6165879964828491,
-0.17309965193271637,
-0.5043574571609497,
0.03577771037817001,
-0.3972204029560089,
-0.8394636511802673,
0.8046693205833435,
0.7860326170921326,
0.4864741265773773,
-0.2494109719991684,
-0.04292811453342438,
0.30329272150993347,
0.40424954891204834,
-0.28939640522003174,
0.5366183519363403,
0.005437177140265703,
-0.8275746703147888,
-0.581025242805481,
0.0174789447337389,
-0.6375612020492554,
0.43764567375183105,
-0.6761970520019531,
0.14732931554317474,
-0.6928955316543579,
-0.38022205233573914,
0.013940560631453991,
0.10196349024772644,
-0.3595123291015625,
0.21282213926315308,
0.050691697746515274,
0.7769961953163147,
-0.4623721241950989,
0.5141748785972595,
1.064298152923584,
0.1923081874847412,
-0.8985947966575623,
-0.05416573956608772,
0.2175222486257553,
-1.0263453722000122,
0.34082409739494324,
0.0767734944820404,
-0.37437671422958374,
-0.29301103949546814,
-0.6202431321144104,
-0.741677463054657,
0.8136408925056458,
0.6673622727394104,
-0.4863097667694092,
0.39440450072288513,
0.159117192029953,
0.43960145115852356,
-0.03306898474693298,
0.344842791557312,
0.2639654874801636,
0.2875840961933136,
0.4156571328639984,
-0.6266351938247681,
0.08433657884597778,
-0.29433852434158325,
-0.12049349397420883,
0.4099048972129822,
-0.5875856280326843,
1.1768832206726074,
-0.3889082968235016,
-0.08244971930980682,
0.09133464097976685,
0.2697068452835083,
0.6571372151374817,
0.682628870010376,
0.3732422888278961,
0.6422926187515259,
0.9431071877479553,
-0.3585869371891022,
0.9306212067604065,
-0.3435690104961395,
0.43474456667900085,
1.037512183189392,
-0.3787755072116852,
0.5335968136787415,
0.1487848311662674,
-0.4405384957790375,
0.04552450403571129,
0.6203432679176331,
-0.009156223386526108,
0.20299053192138672,
0.47907358407974243,
-0.5053413510322571,
-0.6429883241653442,
0.17027531564235687,
-0.6700281500816345,
0.11585013568401337,
0.6157235503196716,
0.04061617702245712,
-0.439430296421051,
-0.16601184010505676,
0.16475147008895874,
0.24225784838199615,
-0.3423369228839874,
0.4769354462623596,
0.3260047733783722,
-0.7684146165847778,
0.7890560030937195,
-0.028591454029083252,
0.4354211688041687,
-0.542111337184906,
0.12409702688455582,
-0.31290286779403687,
0.3941349387168884,
-0.09343242645263672,
-0.9263529777526855,
0.35345369577407837,
0.18486598134040833,
-0.023737024515867233,
-0.04973520338535309,
0.8829047679901123,
-0.21390458941459656,
-0.6081461906433105,
-0.06519176065921783,
0.6331700086593628,
-0.020301321521401405,
-0.13108733296394348,
-0.9544521570205688,
0.26172152161598206,
-0.11071478575468063,
-0.11322025209665298,
0.4473813772201538,
0.6883382797241211,
-0.06623650342226028,
1.0593438148498535,
0.908683180809021,
0.11731306463479996,
0.15788061916828156,
0.29273509979248047,
1.028541088104248,
-0.5037441849708557,
-0.17926433682441711,
-1.2249784469604492,
0.149200901389122,
0.038118328899145126,
-0.45131707191467285,
1.203850269317627,
0.44948136806488037,
0.7771188616752625,
0.22514961659908295,
0.7639558911323547,
0.6438474059104919,
0.4073314964771271,
-0.6397892832756042,
0.3123900592327118,
-0.3662905693054199,
0.6189138889312744,
-0.04773415997624397,
-0.8083773255348206,
-0.5031172633171082,
0.6174654960632324,
-0.6087563037872314,
-0.00332463625818491,
0.515130877494812,
0.8013641834259033,
0.03811421990394592,
0.31254085898399353,
0.5246853232383728,
-0.2713506817817688,
0.3889321982860565,
0.7180824279785156,
1.4350554943084717,
-0.3502824306488037,
0.9720842242240906,
0.01749282516539097,
-0.05446775257587433,
-0.0052933646366000175,
-0.8346042633056641,
-1.137520432472229,
0.049760252237319946,
-0.22323249280452728,
-0.6577693223953247,
0.0502445213496685,
0.7511000037193298,
0.29862889647483826,
-0.7578673958778381,
-0.07967071980237961,
-0.2035338431596756,
0.48895835876464844,
-0.07381879538297653,
-0.16681963205337524,
0.20446529984474182,
-0.3955586552619934,
-0.5207775831222534,
0.44956424832344055,
0.24096831679344177,
0.19628183543682098,
-0.28355860710144043,
0.007922198623418808,
0.47105416655540466,
0.3542031943798065,
0.4994649291038513,
0.09036513417959213,
-0.5211697220802307,
-0.044203199446201324,
0.36519113183021545,
-0.17760324478149414,
0.12351558357477188,
1.0812301635742188,
-0.30149364471435547,
0.36227908730506897,
0.3433879017829895,
0.8312280774116516,
0.1417822241783142,
0.09883949905633926,
0.3501937687397003,
-0.27516090869903564,
-0.11754106730222702,
0.17301660776138306,
0.4240576922893524,
0.3878108859062195,
-0.16448256373405457,
0.1676153689622879,
0.3462986946105957,
-0.6071142554283142,
-0.8939111828804016,
0.38344770669937134,
-0.4700259268283844,
-0.18737728893756866,
1.1687322854995728,
-0.3903665542602539,
-0.08951212465763092,
-0.13007821142673492,
-0.2405700534582138,
-0.25892195105552673,
-0.43144354224205017,
0.9095990061759949,
1.1255168914794922,
-0.13883459568023682,
-0.2175808697938919,
-0.5550311207771301,
0.4072553813457489,
0.6001721024513245,
-0.8415374755859375,
-0.09971211105585098,
0.2431824803352356,
0.37875550985336304,
0.14941653609275818,
0.3360934257507324,
-0.204621821641922,
0.29411089420318604,
0.21943388879299164,
-0.6668854355812073,
-0.3151056170463562,
-0.2736431360244751,
-0.3820841312408447,
0.46383485198020935,
0.13101322948932648,
-0.009707613848149776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19248v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19248v2
|
Let LLMs Take on the Latest Challenges! A Chinese Dynamic Question Answering Benchmark
| 2024-02-29T15:22:13 | 2024-03-02T04:37:37 |
Zhikun Xu, Yinghui Li, Ruixue Ding, Xinyu Wang, Boli Chen, Yong Jiang, Hai-Tao Zheng, Wenlian Lu, Pengjun Xie, Fei Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
How to better evaluate the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) is
the focal point and hot topic in current LLMs research. Previous work has noted
that due to the extremely high cost of iterative updates of LLMs, they are
often unable to answer the latest dynamic questions well. To promote the
improvement of Chinese LLMs' ability to answer dynamic questions, in this
paper, we introduce CDQA, a Chinese Dynamic QA benchmark containing
question-answer pairs related to the latest news on the Chinese Internet. We
obtain high-quality data through a pipeline that combines humans and models,
and carefully classify the samples according to the frequency of answer changes
to facilitate a more fine-grained observation of LLMs' capabilities. We have
also evaluated and analyzed mainstream and advanced Chinese LLMs on CDQA.
Extensive experiments and valuable insights suggest that our proposed CDQA is
challenging and worthy of more further study. We believe that the benchmark we
provide will become one of the key data resources for improving LLMs' Chinese
question-answering ability in the future.
|
[
-0.3413223624229431,
-0.976830244064331,
0.5837312936782837,
0.08279572427272797,
-0.2541528642177582,
0.6066796779632568,
-0.24374938011169434,
-0.49085482954978943,
-0.216636523604393,
0.2915915548801422,
-0.664108157157898,
-0.34217461943626404,
-0.38100555539131165,
0.17746464908123016,
-0.5367746353149414,
0.4354868233203888,
-0.26227620244026184,
0.04489870369434357,
-0.2749214768409729,
-0.25423160195350647,
-0.3288135826587677,
-0.39033305644989014,
-0.7718787789344788,
-0.007542530540376902,
0.7216888666152954,
0.30035272240638733,
0.8591026663780212,
0.5004936456680298,
0.6163820028305054,
0.3817913234233856,
-0.428055077791214,
0.40288689732551575,
-0.2826213240623474,
0.18952058255672455,
0.298649400472641,
-0.5726914405822754,
-0.5447170734405518,
0.02925203926861286,
0.8208589553833008,
0.6791408658027649,
-0.3068847060203552,
0.2812441289424896,
-0.053894974291324615,
0.5625982284545898,
-0.3001290559768677,
-0.19578179717063904,
-0.8765037655830383,
0.056204959750175476,
-0.2712087035179138,
-0.17167875170707703,
0.04909157007932663,
-0.7007396817207336,
0.16382379829883575,
-0.602494478225708,
0.04811384901404381,
-0.31957438588142395,
1.0198863744735718,
0.3198075592517853,
-0.7356996536254883,
-0.13505546748638153,
-0.3590991795063019,
0.5551241040229797,
-0.6477308869361877,
0.26607581973075867,
-0.15738005936145782,
0.6671991348266602,
-0.28345489501953125,
-0.7673784494400024,
-0.6054227948188782,
-0.26827293634414673,
0.3404565751552582,
-0.023859398439526558,
0.11212778836488724,
-0.34446877241134644,
0.07845782488584518,
0.5803496241569519,
-0.643487274646759,
0.19124256074428558,
0.03369054198265076,
-0.04730956256389618,
0.7897856831550598,
0.5327476263046265,
0.38816267251968384,
0.13968832790851593,
-0.4651482403278351,
-0.12773920595645905,
-0.6847410798072815,
0.33466246724128723,
0.09201809763908386,
0.01727643609046936,
-0.18064028024673462,
0.13987676799297333,
-0.47683337330818176,
0.4216533899307251,
0.07355803996324539,
0.03007691539824009,
0.30410346388816833,
-0.3564436733722687,
-0.12441843003034592,
-0.20579271018505096,
0.4768226444721222,
0.23158174753189087,
0.0436771996319294,
-0.05323020741343498,
-0.30537712574005127,
-0.35551658272743225,
-0.11569055914878845,
-0.7243925929069519,
-0.23616011440753937,
0.6171214580535889,
-0.39573606848716736,
-0.2289699763059616,
-0.04582836478948593,
-0.5914891958236694,
-0.7281610369682312,
-0.10811507701873779,
0.3090830147266388,
0.034731507301330566,
-0.4665759801864624,
0.1092531830072403,
-0.06078101694583893,
0.5494691133499146,
0.8043104410171509,
-0.34278008341789246,
0.17693987488746643,
0.6463875770568848,
0.56405109167099,
-0.4615655541419983,
-0.053208380937576294,
-0.7615461349487305,
-0.07688185572624207,
-0.40943673253059387,
0.9434651136398315,
-0.28837740421295166,
-0.06435776501893997,
0.21842382848262787,
0.12400868535041809,
0.23630110919475555,
-0.9459460973739624,
0.6112062335014343,
-0.9175810813903809,
-0.05045893043279648,
-0.8730241656303406,
-0.2983417809009552,
0.029975125566124916,
0.6061918139457703,
-0.6815948486328125,
1.1478080749511719,
-0.000489951460622251,
-0.691390872001648,
0.09456346929073334,
-0.4229268729686737,
-0.08776422590017319,
0.34959930181503296,
-0.11686645448207855,
-0.21745483577251434,
-0.13474474847316742,
0.23566408455371857,
0.1686314344406128,
-0.6922788619995117,
0.3683115839958191,
-0.2515242099761963,
-0.48410844802856445,
0.7554807662963867,
-0.6217572093009949,
0.8968778848648071,
0.27650728821754456,
-0.13912062346935272,
0.02241123840212822,
-0.8827452063560486,
0.23022721707820892,
0.3802974820137024,
-0.6222980618476868,
0.03572334349155426,
0.1784602850675583,
-0.2003578245639801,
0.3922490179538727,
0.5419753789901733,
-0.449965238571167,
0.12418989092111588,
-0.06742841750383377,
0.34333789348602295,
0.9001220464706421,
-0.08696893602609634,
0.025604939088225365,
-0.611785888671875,
0.6265547275543213,
0.01508679986000061,
0.18569599092006683,
-0.11686450242996216,
-0.36889734864234924,
-0.758858859539032,
0.06941547989845276,
0.5123173594474792,
0.6684056520462036,
-0.9122816324234009,
0.04040687531232834,
-0.24163924157619476,
-0.7827203273773193,
-0.5949425101280212,
0.3645326495170593,
0.14665688574314117,
0.12726420164108276,
0.2945367097854614,
-0.44897595047950745,
-0.16253742575645447,
-0.46929454803466797,
-0.3672102093696594,
-0.3424239754676819,
-0.2271619290113449,
0.29706871509552,
0.12733489274978638,
0.14085595309734344,
0.331159383058548,
-0.3978731632232666,
0.11653338372707367,
-0.12994900345802307,
0.14454275369644165,
0.2474786788225174,
0.10756600648164749,
0.3511294722557068,
-1.0756791830062866,
-0.570344865322113,
-0.1965719610452652,
-0.670867919921875,
-0.373002290725708,
-0.12976834177970886,
-0.1314368098974228,
0.0003270893939770758,
0.41287359595298767,
-0.486075222492218,
-0.1523977369070053,
0.6759703159332275,
-0.1704142540693283,
0.5704994201660156,
-0.07551991194486618,
0.15670093894004822,
-0.6527769565582275,
-0.18728524446487427,
-0.21128490567207336,
0.056710075587034225,
-0.5169951319694519,
0.3424137532711029,
0.20614461600780487,
0.07284317165613174,
-0.6765816807746887,
0.6293613314628601,
-0.5493126511573792,
-0.1705239862203598,
-0.2884328067302704,
0.6394501328468323,
-0.23765303194522858,
0.31553950905799866,
-0.21955154836177826,
0.7542579770088196,
0.46439579129219055,
-0.6450002193450928,
0.9673686027526855,
0.197430819272995,
-0.5650525689125061,
0.24803541600704193,
-0.7516348958015442,
0.28149503469467163,
0.06524308025836945,
0.2976093292236328,
-1.2078841924667358,
0.06113132834434509,
-0.10520047694444656,
-0.4561837315559387,
0.0011373815359547734,
0.3494777977466583,
-0.7582710385322571,
-0.45575782656669617,
-0.45765241980552673,
0.4480460286140442,
0.5237270593643188,
-0.6486091017723083,
0.3990042209625244,
0.34455785155296326,
-0.12127092480659485,
-0.5161744356155396,
-0.5562533140182495,
0.29428791999816895,
-0.1333821713924408,
-0.7372834086418152,
0.43632209300994873,
-0.5168374180793762,
-0.22836080193519592,
-0.076531782746315,
-0.16968214511871338,
-0.3089632987976074,
0.49828070402145386,
-0.45879215002059937,
0.09210439771413803,
-0.44150370359420776,
0.07701045274734497,
-0.16129794716835022,
0.06976742297410965,
0.29650723934173584,
0.052942290902137756,
0.47694161534309387,
0.13804227113723755,
-0.16901731491088867,
-0.5671723484992981,
-0.01596860960125923,
0.41892310976982117,
-0.48860064148902893,
0.4072320759296417,
0.547783374786377,
-0.26835930347442627,
-0.24211156368255615,
-0.6258909106254578,
0.01469445414841175,
-0.636367678642273,
0.5394431352615356,
-0.4232184588909149,
-0.8019582033157349,
0.5932733416557312,
-0.22245419025421143,
0.3131994903087616,
0.12027531117200851,
0.7919774055480957,
-0.08267562091350555,
0.973745584487915,
0.2958969175815582,
-0.03739636763930321,
0.23397953808307648,
0.15868552029132843,
-0.1322871595621109,
-0.6455431580543518,
-0.25081995129585266,
-0.5281358361244202,
-0.34170275926589966,
-0.777341902256012,
-0.7138822078704834,
0.4637201428413391,
-0.11936216056346893,
-0.3434400260448456,
0.09270619601011276,
-0.37568947672843933,
0.09176933020353317,
0.47121861577033997,
0.06113312765955925,
0.4285999536514282,
-0.5022281408309937,
-0.19185826182365417,
0.19820913672447205,
-0.5102493166923523,
-0.4270007014274597,
0.8803123235702515,
0.37695732712745667,
0.6495200991630554,
0.33922678232192993,
0.12288503348827362,
0.21525877714157104,
0.08406361937522888,
-0.3195907473564148,
0.9568890929222107,
-0.16953647136688232,
-0.4479614198207855,
-0.27398237586021423,
-0.4017004072666168,
-0.8145649433135986,
0.3527126610279083,
-0.22869597375392914,
-0.3690067529678345,
-0.11556071788072586,
-0.0007836880395188928,
-0.2754553258419037,
0.436431884765625,
-0.07156781852245331,
0.6684843897819519,
-0.6512706875801086,
-0.3929944634437561,
-0.04221617802977562,
-0.4509621262550354,
0.4091583490371704,
-0.2333642989397049,
0.057151805609464645,
-0.44424232840538025,
-0.431621789932251,
0.5208143591880798,
-0.2091309130191803,
0.4868878126144409,
-0.16658708453178406,
-0.6338900327682495,
0.33762916922569275,
-0.08347992599010468,
0.516342282295227,
0.19195370376110077,
-0.2718347907066345,
-0.09121780097484589,
0.20910480618476868,
-0.6783122420310974,
-0.5856723785400391,
0.7312953472137451,
-0.7424802184104919,
-1.0754626989364624,
-0.5348473787307739,
-0.5977863669395447,
-0.43629422783851624,
-0.04286143556237221,
-0.2823520302772522,
0.20284178853034973,
-0.1608915776014328,
0.19360683858394623,
0.7128551006317139,
-0.7036482691764832,
0.41218289732933044,
0.7761147618293762,
-0.01363710593432188,
-0.18245723843574524,
0.45560646057128906,
0.20321807265281677,
0.383061945438385,
0.6058828234672546,
-0.03713662549853325,
-0.21111010015010834,
-0.8740401864051819,
-0.523814857006073,
0.13745689392089844,
-0.7022449970245361,
-0.06872515380382538,
-0.5940064787864685,
-0.4467891454696655,
-0.2150275856256485,
0.17710773646831512,
-0.30230507254600525,
-0.26353833079338074,
0.0972549095749855,
0.13764844834804535,
0.13667605817317963,
0.3127145767211914,
0.1960580050945282,
-0.11692141741514206,
-0.9710882306098938,
0.5086721181869507,
0.6221595406532288,
0.15372240543365479,
0.06657494604587555,
-0.6181764602661133,
-0.24943825602531433,
0.059056516736745834,
-0.6215507984161377,
-0.711763858795166,
0.12787780165672302,
-0.10105002671480179,
0.7688446044921875,
0.20759320259094238,
0.5455790162086487,
0.6352359652519226,
-0.3646394610404968,
1.1475151777267456,
-0.35544353723526,
-0.8168689608573914,
0.3423050343990326,
-0.23790858685970306,
0.637222409248352,
0.31321340799331665,
0.23450398445129395,
-0.8029441833496094,
-0.6034210920333862,
-0.20829768478870392,
-0.6004548072814941,
0.4325476884841919,
0.12718136608600616,
0.46060168743133545,
0.22252659499645233,
0.5203502774238586,
-0.09187749773263931,
0.28564563393592834,
-0.6012297868728638,
-0.39204204082489014,
0.28819894790649414,
-0.0007675240049138665,
0.23846468329429626,
-0.29739275574684143,
0.13861775398254395,
-0.2791846990585327,
0.5100547075271606,
-0.15797537565231323,
0.2737523913383484,
-0.004101488273590803,
0.1766686588525772,
-0.37525373697280884,
0.17053882777690887,
0.22293545305728912,
0.6524133086204529,
-0.22372882068157196,
0.02951621636748314,
0.8319969177246094,
-0.2575918436050415,
0.16811248660087585,
0.21330034732818604,
-0.16416703164577484,
-0.05089913308620453,
0.2865912914276123,
0.4598342180252075,
-0.06272599846124649,
-1.241985559463501,
0.5188313722610474,
-0.3395928740501404,
-0.2823755443096161,
-0.5877735018730164,
0.21943315863609314,
0.25247469544410706,
0.38626405596733093,
0.6857550740242004,
-0.44587787985801697,
-0.10462259501218796,
-0.766762912273407,
0.13167715072631836,
0.4985051155090332,
-0.23995235562324524,
-0.3319651484489441,
0.9470201730728149,
0.3766006529331207,
-0.10559319704771042,
0.4636969566345215,
-0.11712537705898285,
-0.7668911218643188,
0.9377496242523193,
0.1576644629240036,
0.6797341108322144,
-0.347416490316391,
0.22329223155975342,
0.31526464223861694,
0.15473587810993195,
0.14991654455661774,
0.5809266567230225,
-0.0017546722665429115,
-0.7925743460655212,
-0.25989091396331787,
-0.2297462671995163,
-0.7909271717071533,
0.15471142530441284,
-0.42900538444519043,
0.5898650884628296,
-0.341734915971756,
0.16086320579051971,
-0.1945503205060959,
0.6697841882705688,
-0.45782598853111267,
0.4622877836227417,
0.37839677929878235,
1.1418513059616089,
-0.261608749628067,
1.1708108186721802,
0.8254969120025635,
-0.10972990840673447,
-0.4941897690296173,
0.3038906753063202,
0.15167668461799622,
-0.7207775115966797,
0.6614044904708862,
0.07072889804840088,
0.11983338743448257,
-0.2817046344280243,
-0.6258779168128967,
-0.9806464314460754,
1.549816370010376,
0.3168199956417084,
-0.3511274456977844,
-0.15502500534057617,
0.3462556004524231,
0.5330379605293274,
-0.10706821829080582,
0.3061373829841614,
0.39442911744117737,
0.6020253896713257,
0.12596215307712555,
-0.855158269405365,
0.24903401732444763,
-0.39615926146507263,
-0.1610826700925827,
-0.00842258706688881,
-1.264237880706787,
1.18206787109375,
-0.13170769810676575,
-0.3843531012535095,
0.49810463190078735,
0.8318979740142822,
0.26729318499565125,
0.4521789848804474,
0.7313362956047058,
0.1416385918855667,
0.9199115633964539,
-0.1954844743013382,
0.7688431739807129,
-0.3593108654022217,
0.08149159699678421,
0.9214052557945251,
-0.5149311423301697,
0.9218151569366455,
0.0010796556016430259,
-0.33340543508529663,
0.5077513456344604,
0.8537836670875549,
-0.1840135157108307,
0.382733553647995,
0.6163280606269836,
-0.4137095808982849,
-0.5348834991455078,
-0.17186594009399414,
-0.3301446735858917,
0.3634891211986542,
0.03665537387132645,
0.16786132752895355,
-0.07720490545034409,
-0.17897142469882965,
0.021178223192691803,
0.3833365738391876,
-0.14182156324386597,
0.5806385278701782,
-0.034569140523672104,
-0.6581494808197021,
0.9334924817085266,
0.17511306703090668,
0.7204205393791199,
-0.5031260251998901,
0.08317462354898453,
-0.5304275155067444,
0.10910604894161224,
0.1236671581864357,
-0.7211243510246277,
-0.10676819086074829,
0.16140179336071014,
0.2572418451309204,
0.08092169463634491,
0.38945287466049194,
-0.4999471604824066,
-0.2227487862110138,
0.45438072085380554,
0.6109338402748108,
-0.08839459717273712,
0.037838224321603775,
-1.0625392198562622,
0.22189749777317047,
-0.15747255086898804,
-0.20749126374721527,
0.3927583694458008,
0.859288215637207,
0.05893653631210327,
1.0293136835098267,
0.43260708451271057,
0.16471420228481293,
0.22661924362182617,
-0.22714288532733917,
1.1023997068405151,
-0.799523651599884,
-0.22864438593387604,
-0.4284762144088745,
0.34193849563598633,
-0.14687299728393555,
-0.3505201041698456,
0.6342951655387878,
0.28983113169670105,
0.8416392207145691,
0.4224475622177124,
0.7287223935127258,
0.15759490430355072,
0.7070727348327637,
-0.498979777097702,
0.6523224711418152,
-1.034715175628662,
0.7010229229927063,
-0.10938529670238495,
-0.7491301894187927,
-0.18898159265518188,
-0.12631988525390625,
0.052481167018413544,
0.012754851020872593,
0.7083961963653564,
0.783894419670105,
0.3281395137310028,
-0.021164601668715477,
0.3749324679374695,
0.3777637481689453,
0.5292635560035706,
1.107245683670044,
1.1398484706878662,
-0.6588085293769836,
0.8974732756614685,
-0.3704981505870819,
-0.07637003064155579,
0.04245211184024811,
-0.8516474962234497,
-0.8118086457252502,
-0.5176227688789368,
-0.5883133411407471,
-0.18320435285568237,
0.24512822926044464,
0.9403635859489441,
0.26293694972991943,
-0.8378556966781616,
-0.26169735193252563,
0.28348782658576965,
0.13421373069286346,
-0.4437039792537689,
-0.13851448893547058,
0.6076667308807373,
-0.37995511293411255,
-1.1364893913269043,
0.2028285264968872,
-0.10075768083333969,
-0.0863734632730484,
-0.288634330034256,
0.020310919731855392,
-0.3380926847457886,
0.3582521677017212,
0.3880557417869568,
0.10416460782289505,
-0.709771990776062,
-0.32395070791244507,
0.3652026951313019,
-0.33734840154647827,
0.11703097820281982,
0.6376222372055054,
-0.6807316541671753,
0.1529960334300995,
0.4786880314350128,
1.1681956052780151,
0.09245970100164413,
0.1198352798819542,
0.558475136756897,
-0.31294336915016174,
-0.16576801240444183,
0.07064925134181976,
0.10823795944452286,
0.41839778423309326,
-0.15495005249977112,
0.40092870593070984,
0.15885907411575317,
-0.6039639711380005,
-0.8969159126281738,
-0.03196908161044121,
-1.0284446477890015,
-0.45028024911880493,
1.21065092086792,
-0.3215973973274231,
0.00034608173882588744,
-0.2545420825481415,
-0.15472500026226044,
0.3086092472076416,
-0.12382109463214874,
0.8934382200241089,
0.7734123468399048,
0.1976703256368637,
-0.5257471203804016,
-0.6332369446754456,
0.4368281066417694,
0.6203259229660034,
-0.9546329975128174,
0.24312572181224823,
0.20429296791553497,
0.08331070840358734,
-0.3154963254928589,
0.5992652773857117,
-0.21807287633419037,
0.5735817551612854,
-0.192702054977417,
-0.3342183530330658,
0.20048141479492188,
0.015276765450835228,
-0.09693409502506256,
0.33196505904197693,
0.3716486394405365,
-0.19926367700099945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19218v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19218v1
|
Memory-Augmented Generative Adversarial Transformers
| 2024-02-29T14:47:24 | 2024-02-29T14:47:24 |
Stephan Raaijmakers, Roos Bakker, Anita Cremers, Roy de Kleijn, Tom Kouwenhoven, Tessa Verhoef
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conversational AI systems that rely on Large Language Models, like
Transformers, have difficulty interweaving external data (like facts) with the
language they generate. Vanilla Transformer architectures are not designed for
answering factual questions with high accuracy. This paper investigates a
possible route for addressing this problem. We propose to extend the standard
Transformer architecture with an additional memory bank holding extra
information (such as facts drawn from a knowledge base), and an extra attention
layer for addressing this memory. We add this augmented memory to a Generative
Adversarial Network-inspired Transformer architecture. This setup allows for
implementing arbitrary felicity conditions on the generated language of the
Transformer. We first demonstrate how this machinery can be deployed for
handling factual questions in goal-oriented dialogues. Secondly, we demonstrate
that our approach can be useful for applications like {\it style adaptation} as
well: the adaptation of utterances according to certain stylistic (external)
constraints, like social properties of human interlocutors in dialogues.
|
[
-0.470861554145813,
-0.9325783848762512,
0.43620893359184265,
0.008415462449193,
0.1641252487897873,
0.20210792124271393,
-0.3668275773525238,
-0.25853386521339417,
0.3085712194442749,
0.38997799158096313,
-0.35236355662345886,
-0.06522314250469208,
-0.5835476517677307,
-0.2020144760608673,
-0.47066912055015564,
1.1515183448791504,
0.12821926176548004,
-0.07286065816879272,
-0.26899996399879456,
-0.3743336498737335,
-0.5380591750144958,
-0.6153997182846069,
-0.8560398817062378,
-0.14046849310398102,
0.2988995313644409,
0.25981405377388,
1.0617365837097168,
0.42523980140686035,
0.36511945724487305,
0.4502030611038208,
0.12044958025217056,
0.5077113509178162,
-0.4313846230506897,
0.07522464543581009,
-0.198289692401886,
-0.6404136419296265,
-0.30731549859046936,
-0.1484990119934082,
0.40730199217796326,
0.4759824275970459,
0.09312427043914795,
0.09535542875528336,
-0.09071847796440125,
0.5069164037704468,
-0.5235388875007629,
0.5058827996253967,
-0.6701860427856445,
0.17856308817863464,
0.30719754099845886,
-0.38920915126800537,
-0.4596216678619385,
-0.2859172821044922,
0.2924460768699646,
-0.674762487411499,
0.5113575458526611,
0.09217189252376556,
0.9702362418174744,
0.4695102870464325,
-0.10149130970239639,
-0.4588984251022339,
-1.076736330986023,
0.40637505054473877,
-0.13922537863254547,
0.23179006576538086,
0.1547779142856598,
0.4029281437397003,
0.1270657330751419,
-0.6690579652786255,
-0.7649736404418945,
-0.22393962740898132,
-0.4467056393623352,
0.319651335477829,
-0.3564814329147339,
-0.0006515511777251959,
0.24584951996803284,
0.37887078523635864,
-0.34283241629600525,
-0.4885716438293457,
-0.4912051558494568,
-0.03904034197330475,
0.4248028099536896,
0.12696009874343872,
0.32758828997612,
0.11277075856924057,
-0.2717326879501343,
-0.12213785946369171,
-0.509882926940918,
-0.17914418876171112,
0.4827670753002167,
0.17193110287189484,
0.05200585722923279,
0.5191063284873962,
-0.06900279968976974,
0.5550022721290588,
0.5190786123275757,
0.3711697459220886,
-0.028851652517914772,
-0.20320174098014832,
0.06130295619368553,
0.16924534738063812,
0.5749358534812927,
0.24437277019023895,
0.26149025559425354,
-0.4152499735355377,
0.05063096061348915,
0.06607190519571304,
0.8618454337120056,
-0.7328433394432068,
-0.6382274627685547,
0.07764111459255219,
-0.003265336388722062,
-0.1315457969903946,
-0.07705865055322647,
-0.6340707540512085,
-0.34227514266967773,
-0.34097397327423096,
0.7515620589256287,
-0.6457508206367493,
0.026315491646528244,
-0.17609356343746185,
-0.2496436983346939,
0.3073732554912567,
0.2272343635559082,
-0.9463524222373962,
0.35209932923316956,
0.5584424734115601,
0.5888303518295288,
0.026882385835051537,
0.002570114331319928,
-0.4925568699836731,
0.15628370642662048,
-0.3830416202545166,
0.6730576157569885,
-0.48507159948349,
-0.20417703688144684,
-0.014272434636950493,
-0.04789001867175102,
-0.1952575296163559,
-0.41967856884002686,
0.4985540211200714,
-0.9023924469947815,
0.46336326003074646,
-0.2943226099014282,
-0.28088435530662537,
-0.3700953722000122,
0.5111474990844727,
-0.5850191712379456,
0.592625617980957,
0.12956778705120087,
-0.5483371615409851,
0.028086649253964424,
-0.7554934620857239,
-0.6506179571151733,
0.12315114587545395,
-0.30809107422828674,
-0.41231685876846313,
-0.0258370041847229,
0.264803022146225,
0.23974739015102386,
-0.43008893728256226,
0.5758285522460938,
0.022980663925409317,
-0.394932359457016,
0.5498352646827698,
-0.854231595993042,
0.5015941858291626,
0.18398328125476837,
-0.21117030084133148,
0.09998299926519394,
-0.85782790184021,
-0.20209652185440063,
0.11089425534009933,
-0.4207351803779602,
-0.030039936304092407,
-0.020463867112994194,
-0.208774596452713,
-0.15759877860546112,
0.2700790464878082,
-0.4864906370639801,
0.05982274189591408,
-0.25644153356552124,
0.26348021626472473,
0.7557384371757507,
-0.17253732681274414,
0.49226483702659607,
-0.505936861038208,
0.30463212728500366,
0.08164505660533905,
0.10596015304327011,
-0.05211253464221954,
-0.36917343735694885,
-1.5035465955734253,
-0.08461301028728485,
-0.043154872953891754,
0.6637445688247681,
-1.0829010009765625,
0.45150259137153625,
-0.4848332405090332,
-0.17301450669765472,
-0.7002832889556885,
-0.029117552563548088,
0.4400627017021179,
0.7826583981513977,
0.5036158561706543,
0.09527209401130676,
-0.6460644602775574,
-0.9003374576568604,
-0.006764295510947704,
-0.37661033868789673,
-0.04200339689850807,
0.6513745188713074,
0.15565353631973267,
0.04558352008461952,
0.8304422497749329,
-0.673419177532196,
0.03438083454966545,
-0.11784731596708298,
0.16911739110946655,
0.07745929807424545,
0.2834055721759796,
0.4430830478668213,
-1.1075431108474731,
-0.4238932132720947,
-0.011419771239161491,
-0.782605767250061,
0.3859056234359741,
-0.3597120940685272,
-0.08085191994905472,
0.003877402516081929,
0.3047609031200409,
-1.0034246444702148,
0.20672765374183655,
0.4229017496109009,
-0.08851712942123413,
0.34276115894317627,
-0.26033908128738403,
0.3286867141723633,
-1.1207325458526611,
-0.02743690460920334,
-0.13357089459896088,
-0.008694196119904518,
-0.8998166918754578,
0.008319766260683537,
-0.2023405283689499,
-0.3332902789115906,
-0.24896103143692017,
0.3925521671772003,
-0.19605708122253418,
0.03763673081994057,
-0.3082835376262665,
0.007675168104469776,
0.27834922075271606,
0.8460242748260498,
0.20425266027450562,
1.0569661855697632,
0.5674023628234863,
-0.8364625573158264,
0.8544384837150574,
0.6085498332977295,
-0.2255154401063919,
0.8666283488273621,
-0.6304082870483398,
0.37421831488609314,
-0.3736593425273895,
0.11242251843214035,
-0.9802306890487671,
-0.12606632709503174,
0.3185482323169708,
-0.5949933528900146,
0.48907309770584106,
-0.3059000074863434,
-0.13937702775001526,
-0.15822665393352509,
0.009892592206597328,
0.2876471281051636,
0.5824519395828247,
-0.8879480361938477,
0.9927238821983337,
0.1434854120016098,
-0.1713505983352661,
-0.4841729998588562,
-0.612235963344574,
0.45227938890457153,
-0.23768478631973267,
-0.7521457076072693,
0.3475005328655243,
-0.10978495329618454,
-0.3374570906162262,
0.3179611265659332,
0.3018673360347748,
-0.048777878284454346,
-0.022388000041246414,
0.030640898272395134,
0.5022625923156738,
-0.6130486130714417,
0.17180004715919495,
-0.26838770508766174,
-0.0025930304545909166,
0.07163973897695541,
-0.4196905195713043,
0.49318987131118774,
-0.31171920895576477,
-0.3898507356643677,
-0.23613649606704712,
0.3461008071899414,
0.5864187479019165,
-0.03136514127254486,
0.9329009652137756,
0.6752200722694397,
-0.10784199088811874,
-0.04130566492676735,
-0.5402694344520569,
-0.06034183129668236,
-0.5226219892501831,
0.39704224467277527,
-0.6152294278144836,
-0.69118332862854,
0.4681183695793152,
0.19264456629753113,
-0.10217434167861938,
0.41047945618629456,
0.5972714424133301,
-0.1946481615304947,
0.8473173379898071,
0.18258091807365417,
0.007283766288310289,
0.43859994411468506,
-0.2961199879646301,
0.41634601354599,
-0.9883605241775513,
-0.05745553970336914,
-0.1185402050614357,
-0.41742122173309326,
-0.4503622353076935,
-0.5323588848114014,
0.4934680163860321,
-0.3581670820713043,
-0.169974222779274,
0.6512395739555359,
-0.2647411525249481,
0.11854640394449234,
0.5222131013870239,
0.19203300774097443,
0.06856679171323776,
-0.3019287884235382,
0.4075549840927124,
0.3465484082698822,
-0.9125340580940247,
-0.1801590919494629,
0.925155520439148,
0.10771546512842178,
0.7645044922828674,
0.11783281713724136,
-0.037152841687202454,
0.18315352499485016,
0.40964755415916443,
-0.8182820677757263,
0.4737371504306793,
-0.2197256237268448,
-0.6314704418182373,
-0.1529093235731125,
-0.37142491340637207,
-0.5843973755836487,
0.07365395873785019,
-0.09549477696418762,
-0.5521087646484375,
0.24415922164916992,
0.32818660140037537,
-0.6190293431282043,
0.28206977248191833,
-0.9136762022972107,
0.5686032772064209,
-0.20701654255390167,
-0.25907522439956665,
-0.08976694196462631,
-0.627456784248352,
0.3077391982078552,
0.27463656663894653,
-0.1620355099439621,
0.2942570447921753,
0.41849640011787415,
0.4606279134750366,
-0.2875022888183594,
0.7855834364891052,
-0.0846843346953392,
-0.007367262151092291,
0.6136191487312317,
-0.12465667724609375,
0.8050435781478882,
0.08555539697408676,
0.057172972708940506,
-0.1641208827495575,
-0.3599453866481781,
-0.20729954540729523,
-1.1235326528549194,
0.6381554007530212,
-0.8688461184501648,
-1.0761171579360962,
-0.17507606744766235,
-0.9802065491676331,
-0.5509833693504333,
-0.30249521136283875,
0.04230337217450142,
0.6701949834823608,
-0.42896828055381775,
0.3757157325744629,
0.9316521286964417,
-0.23795828223228455,
0.22808456420898438,
0.4946215748786926,
0.3674619197845459,
-0.3327758014202118,
1.226554036140442,
-0.1193288043141365,
0.49320563673973083,
0.7356488704681396,
0.20930778980255127,
-0.3424212634563446,
-0.35633614659309387,
-0.8435531854629517,
-0.12629035115242004,
-0.81287682056427,
-0.1032193973660469,
-0.9255088567733765,
-0.5869886875152588,
-0.500334620475769,
-0.05246492102742195,
-0.42640310525894165,
-0.5437113046646118,
-0.5476353168487549,
-0.1736719310283661,
0.7434578537940979,
0.3264312744140625,
0.20876263082027435,
0.302114874124527,
-0.7638230323791504,
0.6480284929275513,
0.656672477722168,
0.14210644364356995,
-0.2377156913280487,
-0.8068089485168457,
-0.22822360694408417,
0.11765940487384796,
-0.13940711319446564,
-0.41485634446144104,
0.14287309348583221,
0.2942636013031006,
0.28188544511795044,
0.4565189480781555,
0.05528716370463371,
0.7689745426177979,
-0.7414451837539673,
0.5162612795829773,
-0.09421263635158539,
-0.5378826260566711,
0.24902625381946564,
-0.1914253532886505,
0.0786648541688919,
0.42387717962265015,
0.2693517208099365,
-0.504548966884613,
-0.2417677789926529,
-0.5925021767616272,
-0.3357541859149933,
0.6422479748725891,
0.2534499764442444,
0.6460083723068237,
-0.16157740354537964,
0.3613424003124237,
-0.2389301359653473,
0.16716429591178894,
-0.26186156272888184,
-0.42362770438194275,
-0.4919199049472809,
-0.3398773670196533,
-0.09945634752511978,
-0.12544852495193481,
-0.5225535035133362,
-0.0647909939289093,
0.6547004580497742,
-0.3913646340370178,
0.526787281036377,
0.006605532020330429,
-0.16436630487442017,
0.13806067407131195,
0.3410814106464386,
0.4453775882720947,
0.3074413537979126,
0.09349140524864197,
0.30251437425613403,
0.29792481660842896,
-0.31240952014923096,
0.14679379761219025,
0.2915302515029907,
-0.4192112684249878,
-0.18091025948524475,
0.01815466769039631,
1.149306058883667,
-0.04982593655586243,
-0.43021026253700256,
0.39524000883102417,
-0.19431443512439728,
0.0634477362036705,
-0.46036478877067566,
0.3206619620323181,
0.12596388161182404,
0.393728643655777,
0.2109837532043457,
0.5456334948539734,
0.14125408232212067,
-0.885509729385376,
0.36736756563186646,
0.7165119647979736,
-0.7615323662757874,
-0.4391341209411621,
0.4948752522468567,
0.2824113368988037,
-0.48472726345062256,
0.43047598004341125,
-0.20883134007453918,
-0.7530927658081055,
0.47603076696395874,
0.7094272375106812,
0.855189323425293,
-0.06736931949853897,
0.22112229466438293,
0.1026502326130867,
0.24810940027236938,
0.31293126940727234,
0.0733942836523056,
-0.18162061274051666,
-1.0869258642196655,
-0.3573308289051056,
-0.4363998770713806,
-0.39086058735847473,
0.029671326279640198,
-0.5581813454627991,
0.19246049225330353,
-0.5510712265968323,
0.15821245312690735,
-0.16192680597305298,
-0.36315247416496277,
-0.7063461542129517,
0.5151248574256897,
0.09002777934074402,
0.48500531911849976,
-0.5590649247169495,
0.6918176412582397,
0.44248437881469727,
-0.318980872631073,
-0.3720732033252716,
-0.05071474611759186,
-0.34685301780700684,
-1.1288670301437378,
0.5883480906486511,
-0.17478808760643005,
-0.3406357169151306,
-0.09856626391410828,
-0.22737711668014526,
-0.90141361951828,
0.8359586000442505,
0.3955276608467102,
-0.16640721261501312,
-0.0333591066300869,
0.10814666002988815,
0.5803773999214172,
-0.18249768018722534,
0.2642359435558319,
0.5848801732063293,
0.3938275873661041,
0.5630610585212708,
-0.3508242964744568,
0.045871470123529434,
-0.5323402285575867,
-0.11713799089193344,
0.08406100422143936,
-0.942571222782135,
0.6964895725250244,
-0.24403756856918335,
-0.28394433856010437,
0.10112899541854858,
1.089465618133545,
-0.18469436466693878,
-0.046390388160943985,
0.5069315433502197,
0.5522770881652832,
0.5863245725631714,
-0.12318161129951477,
1.1197543144226074,
-0.4301857650279999,
-0.004152074921876192,
1.2532377243041992,
-0.2297569215297699,
0.25965774059295654,
0.19562159478664398,
-0.13300693035125732,
0.43598660826683044,
-0.03999759256839752,
-0.03454716503620148,
0.3287065327167511,
0.01170495804399252,
-0.5378465056419373,
-0.022346144542098045,
-0.3446595370769501,
-0.13561569154262543,
0.5839021801948547,
0.5161346197128296,
-0.29342126846313477,
0.17316065728664398,
-0.0354367159307003,
0.0041852230206131935,
0.0324728898704052,
0.04317202791571617,
1.0008045434951782,
-0.2868170738220215,
-0.9460542798042297,
0.32028505206108093,
-0.15794435143470764,
0.3781648576259613,
-0.45383378863334656,
-0.2961234152317047,
-0.03616136685013771,
0.33072778582572937,
0.08708751201629639,
-0.7086127996444702,
0.533350944519043,
0.011234012432396412,
-0.18384940922260284,
-0.22439658641815186,
0.6980270147323608,
-0.6332095265388489,
-0.6195393204689026,
-0.14320051670074463,
0.14211414754390717,
-0.10110754519701004,
0.05979663506150246,
-0.3889853358268738,
-0.14963126182556152,
-0.24235433340072632,
-0.19393563270568848,
0.17214486002922058,
0.4136919677257538,
0.2976253032684326,
0.6953960061073303,
0.5113245248794556,
-0.17134104669094086,
0.06912782043218613,
0.11715740710496902,
1.0376906394958496,
-0.32820194959640503,
-0.3798058032989502,
-0.6872800588607788,
0.3665403425693512,
-0.10155826061964035,
-0.16233915090560913,
0.8331003785133362,
0.5639156699180603,
0.5259515047073364,
-0.03193499147891998,
0.9966029524803162,
-0.21255560219287872,
0.1644783318042755,
-0.5801536440849304,
0.5516694784164429,
-0.14593900740146637,
0.05142752081155777,
0.11141973733901978,
-0.6366565823554993,
0.10927577316761017,
0.4685874879360199,
-0.26324403285980225,
-0.04230504110455513,
0.509343683719635,
0.815362811088562,
-0.1340634822845459,
0.3358328938484192,
0.3737090528011322,
0.2392028272151947,
0.45605942606925964,
0.6575729250907898,
1.0524511337280273,
-0.5703249573707581,
0.8211996555328369,
-0.15649640560150146,
0.010318269021809101,
-0.04625597223639488,
-0.425301730632782,
-0.9116083979606628,
-0.594093918800354,
-0.44029510021209717,
-0.41131994128227234,
0.2030232548713684,
0.663847029209137,
0.6200946569442749,
-0.8949175477027893,
0.12159044295549393,
-0.16955474019050598,
0.014513623900711536,
-0.07725445926189423,
-0.2656116783618927,
0.4300755262374878,
-0.42895278334617615,
-0.8603839874267578,
0.6059191823005676,
0.3570646345615387,
0.015675535425543785,
-0.4957396984100342,
0.030124975368380547,
-0.1310674250125885,
0.31782984733581543,
0.5713552236557007,
0.3375404477119446,
-0.3790487051010132,
-0.7884687781333923,
0.07500632107257843,
0.16264361143112183,
0.34793394804000854,
0.909924328327179,
-0.6661312580108643,
0.61762535572052,
0.32480910420417786,
1.1253246068954468,
0.5691014528274536,
0.2340065985918045,
0.7626407742500305,
-0.8472477793693542,
0.09969504177570343,
0.28865835070610046,
0.3169897794723511,
0.5176806449890137,
-0.7163465023040771,
-0.046608008444309235,
0.19592228531837463,
-0.20002038776874542,
-0.2023562490940094,
0.39671918749809265,
-0.650947093963623,
-0.02266795188188553,
1.036926031112671,
-0.3091402053833008,
-0.22306615114212036,
-0.25933390855789185,
-0.2979390025138855,
0.3344779312610626,
-0.10424955934286118,
0.8604256510734558,
0.640052318572998,
-0.20181965827941895,
-0.22664327919483185,
-0.23422913253307343,
0.4799913763999939,
0.3119906485080719,
-0.8248104453086853,
0.09476888179779053,
0.4207582473754883,
-0.03145619109272957,
0.6080906987190247,
0.45331689715385437,
0.09398020803928375,
0.2795175313949585,
0.15990497171878815,
-0.2952447831630707,
-0.06121407449245453,
-0.7083262801170349,
0.00537493359297514,
0.25630295276641846,
-0.2565802037715912,
-0.43654701113700867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19204v1
|
PeLLE: Encoder-based language models for Brazilian Portuguese based on open data
| 2024-02-29T14:34:03 | 2024-02-29T14:34:03 |
Guilherme Lamartine de Mello, Marcelo Finger, and Felipe Serras, Miguel de Mello Carpi, Marcos Menon Jose, Pedro Henrique Domingues, Paulo Cavalim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
In this paper we present PeLLE, a family of large language models based on
the RoBERTa architecture, for Brazilian Portuguese, trained on curated, open
data from the Carolina corpus. Aiming at reproducible results, we describe
details of the pretraining of the models. We also evaluate PeLLE models against
a set of existing multilingual and PT-BR refined pretrained Transformer-based
LLM encoders, contrasting performance of large versus smaller-but-curated
pretrained models in several downstream tasks. We conclude that several tasks
perform better with larger models, but some tasks benefit from
smaller-but-curated data in its pretraining.
|
[
-0.04611343890428543,
-0.6347147822380066,
0.4033873379230499,
0.19242127239704132,
0.005827735643833876,
-0.1073589101433754,
-0.6318327784538269,
-0.1425885260105133,
-0.022518930956721306,
0.8901740312576294,
-0.1104583740234375,
-0.5142561197280884,
-0.765460193157196,
0.21935875713825226,
-0.5530273914337158,
0.9723355174064636,
-0.2171325981616974,
0.3455030024051666,
-0.03614185005426407,
0.015164420939981937,
0.03699630871415138,
-0.9006776213645935,
-0.5803366303443909,
0.0016288453480228782,
0.4635566771030426,
0.1562279611825943,
0.46337246894836426,
0.48276934027671814,
0.15615488588809967,
0.27576112747192383,
-0.21432183682918549,
0.1805119663476944,
-0.8876055479049683,
-0.012906312942504883,
-0.22618451714515686,
-0.45348411798477173,
-0.6837630271911621,
-0.08157593011856079,
0.7802109718322754,
0.766471803188324,
-0.2117290049791336,
0.021096136420965195,
0.5855472683906555,
0.4625212848186493,
-0.6118372678756714,
0.34524184465408325,
-0.42421817779541016,
-0.11767745018005371,
-0.45879510045051575,
0.0995572879910469,
-0.6619865894317627,
-0.4565579295158386,
0.27313652634620667,
-0.4891470670700073,
0.18514004349708557,
-0.0628989189863205,
0.7558295726776123,
0.2114112228155136,
-0.4731951951980591,
-0.24319881200790405,
-0.8545200824737549,
0.9629762172698975,
-0.2983958125114441,
0.7683059573173523,
0.5279091596603394,
0.27891382575035095,
0.18866607546806335,
-0.5882382392883301,
-0.24672462046146393,
-0.30269521474838257,
-0.09603571146726608,
0.05722363293170929,
-0.21931028366088867,
-0.16870452463626862,
0.03602047264575958,
0.5157904028892517,
-0.8018835783004761,
0.10919976234436035,
-0.4689059257507324,
-0.07158609479665756,
0.5075098276138306,
-0.1421862691640854,
-0.20026464760303497,
0.4622836112976074,
-0.0375625342130661,
-0.01619703695178032,
-1.101790428161621,
-0.20151954889297485,
0.6203470230102539,
0.45884770154953003,
-0.40081390738487244,
0.576416015625,
-0.05472936853766441,
1.1593577861785889,
-0.1532040387392044,
0.004167851526290178,
0.39629992842674255,
-0.15261760354042053,
-0.3177160918712616,
-0.06379243731498718,
0.8186087012290955,
-0.4028441607952118,
0.7347310781478882,
-0.37008872628211975,
-0.35409677028656006,
-0.060985688120126724,
0.1869346648454666,
-0.6443468928337097,
-0.4864831566810608,
0.055862557142972946,
-0.5286943912506104,
-0.17792180180549622,
0.1455257385969162,
-0.6989986300468445,
-0.10072345286607742,
-0.32483774423599243,
0.08955194056034088,
-0.3875716030597687,
-0.17566893994808197,
0.29094651341438293,
0.3383587896823883,
0.11959897726774216,
0.327920138835907,
-0.6379213333129883,
0.5417947173118591,
0.525532066822052,
0.6115022301673889,
-0.27405500411987305,
-0.2863190770149231,
-0.7046563625335693,
0.1531582623720169,
-0.14883115887641907,
0.709697961807251,
-0.6532441973686218,
-0.6421165466308594,
0.19241811335086823,
0.3996127247810364,
-0.1315966695547104,
-0.4936402142047882,
0.9106268882751465,
-0.45470330119132996,
0.2980649471282959,
-0.0733511820435524,
-0.47214847803115845,
-0.06917046755552292,
0.36026787757873535,
-0.719482421875,
0.910647451877594,
0.4147271513938904,
-0.518982470035553,
0.19873294234275818,
-0.6221410632133484,
-0.3421877324581146,
0.058047860860824585,
-0.1257496178150177,
-0.42349404096603394,
0.059266477823257446,
0.29548704624176025,
0.4144149124622345,
-0.6310652494430542,
0.343720942735672,
-0.14233386516571045,
-0.233993262052536,
0.2620975971221924,
-0.47599533200263977,
0.8484474420547485,
0.31006166338920593,
0.11730914562940598,
0.1756909340620041,
-0.7249110341072083,
-0.21662554144859314,
0.20281516015529633,
-0.7210929989814758,
-0.2160436362028122,
0.039660271257162094,
0.2899274528026581,
-0.1337537169456482,
0.36316168308258057,
-0.8992469310760498,
0.30378836393356323,
-0.38954055309295654,
0.6470018029212952,
0.5134754180908203,
-0.44126883149147034,
0.737856388092041,
-0.3165540397167206,
0.7212525010108948,
0.2043411135673523,
0.2402549684047699,
-0.33198082447052,
-0.41086718440055847,
-0.8092901706695557,
-0.2699165642261505,
0.6482279896736145,
0.5050023794174194,
-0.6644991040229797,
0.4644230008125305,
-0.4401955306529999,
-0.4908783733844757,
-0.5040993690490723,
-0.0409870445728302,
0.5718161463737488,
0.2945197522640228,
0.5255172848701477,
-0.2997745871543884,
-0.28882238268852234,
-1.032029151916504,
-0.0965675339102745,
0.275305837392807,
-0.04195334389805794,
0.44551151990890503,
0.3360276222229004,
-0.22884294390678406,
0.7621687054634094,
-0.40042147040367126,
-0.20029152929782867,
-0.2572592794895172,
-0.13143271207809448,
0.32982102036476135,
0.562278151512146,
0.8808402419090271,
-0.6787633895874023,
-0.4329783618450165,
0.058983273804187775,
-0.3769722878932953,
-0.22261010110378265,
0.400058388710022,
0.05691520869731903,
0.28702282905578613,
0.2532215118408203,
-0.15455348789691925,
0.23250797390937805,
0.9846788048744202,
0.041377197951078415,
0.3397209942340851,
-0.31301265954971313,
0.008968532085418701,
-0.9772906303405762,
-0.19383609294891357,
0.06888424605131149,
-0.28137627243995667,
-0.5011406540870667,
-0.27422139048576355,
0.22604472935199738,
-0.39102667570114136,
-0.6410781145095825,
0.40048256516456604,
-0.7624821066856384,
-0.24340695142745972,
0.007779897656291723,
-0.07166804373264313,
0.11604268848896027,
0.30947574973106384,
0.5488539338111877,
0.7484858632087708,
0.8175292611122131,
-0.5528059601783752,
0.25734826922416687,
0.40792521834373474,
-0.4696086347103119,
0.4251489043235779,
-0.9573525786399841,
0.4491448998451233,
-0.2345648854970932,
0.23099955916404724,
-0.5615757703781128,
-0.021362964063882828,
0.083114854991436,
-0.11555402725934982,
0.42768394947052,
-0.8403447866439819,
-0.2658570408821106,
-0.5705748200416565,
0.29569876194000244,
0.4783259332180023,
0.49605870246887207,
-0.5758000612258911,
0.5625495910644531,
0.5461733341217041,
-0.2399846315383911,
-0.2548615336418152,
-0.8776782751083374,
-0.22676213085651398,
-0.21864300966262817,
-0.5157542824745178,
0.4629720151424408,
-0.0006508009391836822,
-0.103858083486557,
-0.02207483910024166,
0.45548802614212036,
-0.5262393355369568,
-0.22833748161792755,
0.28322210907936096,
0.03655001148581505,
-0.38018959760665894,
0.26075583696365356,
-0.04768659919500351,
-0.042830947786569595,
-0.35636281967163086,
-0.6260798573493958,
0.8741804361343384,
-0.32520201802253723,
-0.38352450728416443,
0.0037122396752238274,
0.2411952018737793,
0.2836674153804779,
-0.8599031567573547,
0.9545994400978088,
0.18721498548984528,
-0.20521654188632965,
-0.348479688167572,
-0.383927583694458,
0.11988820880651474,
-0.4385051429271698,
0.08664345741271973,
-0.56639164686203,
-1.1169604063034058,
0.310234934091568,
-0.12275777012109756,
-0.26771026849746704,
0.12179989367723465,
0.7499478459358215,
0.07153439521789551,
0.5331110954284668,
0.5921666026115417,
0.0449160598218441,
0.4690868854522705,
-0.4948959946632385,
0.05644167587161064,
-0.6163552403450012,
-0.2070707529783249,
-0.8686372637748718,
-0.03152192011475563,
-0.5096266269683838,
-0.5716317892074585,
0.34019455313682556,
-0.017414230853319168,
-0.4835874140262604,
0.6638033986091614,
-0.6746819615364075,
0.4196929335594177,
0.6302683353424072,
0.01671227067708969,
0.27321189641952515,
-0.10835673660039902,
0.1263173520565033,
0.14825938642024994,
-0.8762987852096558,
-0.806767463684082,
1.4843544960021973,
-0.02690216153860092,
1.1045172214508057,
0.011752059683203697,
0.6851882934570312,
-0.02898135781288147,
0.2288108468055725,
-0.5184296369552612,
0.2706698179244995,
-0.40482982993125916,
-0.2623199224472046,
-0.08221437782049179,
-0.3866160213947296,
-1.2574917078018188,
-0.06876785308122635,
-0.4435137212276459,
-0.39136213064193726,
0.30048444867134094,
0.2684662640094757,
-0.24223360419273376,
0.1274598240852356,
-0.5852421522140503,
1.004223108291626,
-0.6643196940422058,
-0.380644291639328,
-0.03312506526708603,
-0.25372248888015747,
0.05577225610613823,
-0.44809967279434204,
0.15152643620967865,
0.185827374458313,
0.04534846171736717,
0.6751681566238403,
-0.45797738432884216,
0.5778233408927917,
-0.10615619271993637,
-0.15734386444091797,
0.38193535804748535,
0.21541328728199005,
0.5998222231864929,
-0.14915704727172852,
-0.3431931138038635,
0.5934293866157532,
-0.0071876756846904755,
-0.4099501073360443,
-0.30556175112724304,
0.7291286587715149,
-1.0017648935317993,
-0.2579202353954315,
-0.2814299166202545,
-0.3476683795452118,
-0.23178112506866455,
0.0971326231956482,
0.4371970593929291,
0.6245692372322083,
-0.548380434513092,
0.48820656538009644,
0.4549475312232971,
-0.4749241769313812,
0.23831042647361755,
0.7937051653862,
-0.12026993930339813,
-0.17895877361297607,
0.5269501209259033,
0.27904707193374634,
-0.08923929184675217,
0.7145705223083496,
0.01261077355593443,
-0.18079924583435059,
-0.8579495549201965,
-0.4913722574710846,
0.21384210884571075,
-0.044637445360422134,
0.012566782534122467,
-0.6409977078437805,
0.02030746452510357,
-0.5392160415649414,
-0.1304132044315338,
-0.7199409604072571,
-0.33266353607177734,
-0.3079296946525574,
-0.003475150326266885,
0.3058726489543915,
0.9580430388450623,
0.2908467948436737,
0.5643229484558105,
-1.0971016883850098,
-0.2432849407196045,
0.052265141159296036,
0.31481266021728516,
-0.3682694435119629,
-0.39403024315834045,
-0.43829140067100525,
0.3457190990447998,
-0.19529575109481812,
-0.8608129024505615,
0.65982985496521,
0.1600954234600067,
0.7398500442504883,
0.23963893949985504,
-0.09152375161647797,
0.26547467708587646,
-0.5849511623382568,
0.7484697699546814,
-0.11535198241472244,
-0.9259356260299683,
0.72657310962677,
-0.6170763373374939,
-0.04317015781998634,
0.27717405557632446,
0.6057782769203186,
-0.01330769807100296,
0.20365320146083832,
-0.4605937898159027,
-0.4650046229362488,
0.5884740352630615,
0.20211181044578552,
-0.06580080091953278,
-0.14210101962089539,
0.20814372599124908,
0.19873471558094025,
0.2899247109889984,
-0.6240452527999878,
0.28674301505088806,
-0.3263695538043976,
-0.2680175006389618,
-0.39490291476249695,
-0.2743624150753021,
-0.019879136234521866,
-0.045130543410778046,
0.552172064781189,
-0.08563199639320374,
0.27540096640586853,
0.009445511735975742,
-0.44886860251426697,
0.14738231897354126,
0.2796574532985687,
0.30092257261276245,
0.5851097702980042,
0.14425688982009888,
-0.2666953504085541,
0.09126268327236176,
-0.17650829255580902,
0.006474353838711977,
0.10882848501205444,
-0.12952746450901031,
-0.2879432141780853,
0.34310826659202576,
0.898808479309082,
0.3326491415500641,
-0.8076582551002502,
0.6141716241836548,
0.03791733831167221,
0.06869786232709885,
-0.5684651732444763,
-0.03266049921512604,
-0.020808741450309753,
0.17011621594429016,
-0.1112765297293663,
-0.2262858897447586,
-0.12216716259717941,
-0.4969184696674347,
0.015351640991866589,
0.17582671344280243,
-0.41673216223716736,
-0.4622887969017029,
0.7158553600311279,
0.3779919743537903,
-0.494800329208374,
0.7939610481262207,
0.1400349885225296,
-0.4119792580604553,
0.3913175165653229,
0.5157959461212158,
0.771865963935852,
-0.44445061683654785,
0.050676509737968445,
0.27538809180259705,
0.2811964154243469,
-0.18811948597431183,
0.41926902532577515,
-0.11996036022901535,
-1.1076759099960327,
-0.49466225504875183,
-0.9955058097839355,
-0.31668171286582947,
-0.10002121329307556,
-0.8233984708786011,
0.3320975601673126,
0.0613238587975502,
-0.10167644917964935,
-0.4396853446960449,
-0.4665842056274414,
-0.9549705982208252,
0.10127302259206772,
-0.04917529225349426,
0.9854000210762024,
-0.7900381684303284,
1.4341044425964355,
0.716909646987915,
-0.3231509029865265,
-0.6972724795341492,
-0.3121243715286255,
-0.22246317565441132,
-0.7501550316810608,
0.8238276243209839,
-0.32552826404571533,
0.03749065846204758,
0.0979948565363884,
-0.29024335741996765,
-0.8612086772918701,
0.848031222820282,
0.6685898900032043,
-0.9874009490013123,
-0.05414704605937004,
0.23484697937965393,
0.5706430673599243,
-0.5818827748298645,
0.14747723937034607,
0.5812236070632935,
0.4433624744415283,
-0.24981734156608582,
-1.2653772830963135,
-0.6684406399726868,
-0.28712746500968933,
-0.07457670569419861,
0.36673805117607117,
-0.6084542870521545,
1.240530252456665,
0.23547236621379852,
0.139304980635643,
0.17787986993789673,
0.4027402400970459,
0.03598389774560928,
-0.2921576201915741,
0.34535953402519226,
0.7691305875778198,
0.7485207915306091,
-0.5005983114242554,
1.4152467250823975,
-0.6105847954750061,
0.3848955035209656,
1.2845962047576904,
-0.51192307472229,
0.740109384059906,
-0.02265878953039646,
-0.3679564595222473,
0.5313836932182312,
0.5426762104034424,
0.04271165281534195,
0.4246750473976135,
0.09341440349817276,
-0.12219130992889404,
-0.20860345661640167,
0.020610107108950615,
-0.358018159866333,
0.8403851985931396,
0.41867196559906006,
-0.6383259892463684,
-0.06724484264850616,
0.2688997685909271,
0.0047863544896245,
0.3180301785469055,
-0.5020764470100403,
0.5926522016525269,
0.006882894318550825,
-0.5528469085693359,
0.44167113304138184,
-0.08972478657960892,
0.5900930166244507,
-0.5312503576278687,
0.1365717202425003,
0.01668480969965458,
0.3721809387207031,
0.060079049319028854,
-0.8513045907020569,
0.40052902698516846,
0.1969923973083496,
-0.01415832806378603,
-0.7554146647453308,
0.7857657670974731,
-0.7561360597610474,
-0.4277161657810211,
0.44628456234931946,
0.7679266333580017,
0.30313363671302795,
-0.21379296481609344,
-0.5959102511405945,
0.36073267459869385,
-0.2721695005893707,
-0.42509016394615173,
0.18806958198547363,
0.3735411763191223,
-0.13864070177078247,
0.4282744526863098,
0.6395590901374817,
0.30403175950050354,
0.10458401590585709,
0.23882879316806793,
0.7757695913314819,
-0.3787616789340973,
-0.6950554847717285,
-0.6264379024505615,
0.18925537168979645,
0.011027735657989979,
-0.2661854028701782,
0.8837063908576965,
0.9747804403305054,
1.0793232917785645,
-0.35444098711013794,
0.8437193632125854,
0.30211102962493896,
0.816998302936554,
-0.48573029041290283,
0.6777898073196411,
-0.21772152185440063,
-0.020224478095769882,
0.04786882549524307,
-1.2169328927993774,
-0.07045385241508484,
0.7761998772621155,
-0.7492824196815491,
0.12634190917015076,
0.4275585412979126,
0.8584504723548889,
-0.20050844550132751,
0.22376881539821625,
0.298896849155426,
0.6023710370063782,
0.13437023758888245,
0.8858953714370728,
0.7686978578567505,
-0.07330923527479172,
0.41312649846076965,
-0.09496137499809265,
-0.2742484211921692,
-0.02087293192744255,
-0.7914614081382751,
-0.8531154990196228,
-0.6927840709686279,
-0.19053472578525543,
-0.26747962832450867,
0.31150874495506287,
0.680949330329895,
0.9309841990470886,
-0.9307664632797241,
-0.3358946740627289,
-0.1760621964931488,
-0.2587693929672241,
0.1340009868144989,
-0.12315048277378082,
0.22926115989685059,
0.1941504180431366,
-1.1267690658569336,
0.777951717376709,
0.31348559260368347,
0.20865434408187866,
-0.3175802528858185,
-0.2941652834415436,
0.15089592337608337,
-0.003174557350575924,
0.6582903265953064,
0.2375551164150238,
-0.32883700728416443,
-0.2690984904766083,
-0.15509739518165588,
0.07475268840789795,
0.04154295101761818,
0.9259689450263977,
-1.1657297611236572,
0.2502560615539551,
0.5472230911254883,
0.4213542938232422,
1.0870238542556763,
-0.0975794568657875,
0.8362658619880676,
-0.5270714163780212,
0.5848777890205383,
0.48874354362487793,
0.9095746278762817,
0.42952319979667664,
0.05611332878470421,
0.741631031036377,
0.050041913986206055,
-0.6003044247627258,
-0.6554716229438782,
0.33336299657821655,
-1.0661547183990479,
-0.16475190222263336,
1.1700701713562012,
-0.4219915270805359,
-0.3409729301929474,
-0.2110019028186798,
-0.2564118802547455,
0.14778728783130646,
-0.19572925567626953,
0.08603956550359726,
0.4324170649051666,
0.15385234355926514,
-0.22754432260990143,
-0.28332018852233887,
0.16125459969043732,
-0.12102406471967697,
-0.671466588973999,
-0.10624426603317261,
0.5700720548629761,
0.21181491017341614,
-0.11233879625797272,
0.6443339586257935,
-0.3741263449192047,
-0.07369892299175262,
-0.07597512006759644,
0.048299286514520645,
-0.3352760970592499,
-0.5871790647506714,
-0.30588048696517944,
0.3845895230770111,
-0.19794729351997375,
0.057610560208559036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19200v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19200v2
|
PRSA: PRompt Stealing Attacks against Large Language Models
| 2024-02-29T14:30:28 | 2024-06-08T03:43:12 |
Yong Yang, Changjiang Li, Yi Jiang, Xi Chen, Haoyu Wang, Xuhong Zhang, Zonghui Wang, Shouling Ji
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
In recent years, "prompt as a service" has greatly enhanced the utility of
large language models (LLMs) by enabling them to perform various downstream
tasks efficiently without fine-tuning. This has also increased the commercial
value of prompts. However, the potential risk of leakage in these
commercialized prompts remains largely underexplored. In this paper, we
introduce a novel attack framework, PRSA, designed for prompt stealing attacks
against LLMs. The main idea of PRSA is to infer the intent behind a prompt by
analyzing its input-output content, enabling the generation of a surrogate
prompt that replicates the original's functionality. Specifically, PRSA mainly
consists of two key phases: prompt mutation and prompt pruning. In the mutation
phase, we propose a prompt attention algorithm based on output difference. The
algorithm facilitates the generation of effective surrogate prompts by learning
key factors that influence the accurate inference of prompt intent. During the
pruning phase, we employ a two-step related word identification strategy to
detect and mask words that are highly related to the input, thus improving the
generalizability of the surrogate prompts. We verify the actual threat of PRSA
through evaluation in both real-world settings, non-interactive and interactive
prompt services. The results strongly confirm the PRSA's effectiveness and
generalizability. We have reported these findings to prompt service providers
and actively collaborate with them to implement defensive measures.
|
[
-0.2795507311820984,
-1.0308588743209839,
0.5614546537399292,
0.36636191606521606,
-0.3454540967941284,
-0.020739005878567696,
0.12222281098365784,
-0.3180510699748993,
0.3138165771961212,
0.8048346042633057,
-0.8789006471633911,
0.011595046147704124,
-0.5614473819732666,
0.41019588708877563,
-0.25631630420684814,
0.577447235584259,
0.1733754277229309,
-0.06333417445421219,
0.014090521261096,
0.10468503832817078,
-0.8510875105857849,
-0.5347793698310852,
-0.9681237936019897,
0.4042288362979889,
0.653342604637146,
0.29277563095092773,
0.4743058979511261,
0.26362448930740356,
0.39838942885398865,
0.3197389543056488,
-0.29063332080841064,
0.13814851641654968,
-0.24157214164733887,
0.477700412273407,
-0.2561449408531189,
-0.42664068937301636,
-0.15656918287277222,
-0.30743151903152466,
0.6411454677581787,
0.2150886207818985,
0.023915842175483704,
0.12276887893676758,
0.01981036737561226,
0.5562753677368164,
-0.7620431184768677,
-0.03637987747788429,
-0.6307362914085388,
-0.23358558118343353,
-0.5128604769706726,
-0.13653479516506195,
-0.7578107118606567,
-0.43699318170547485,
-0.17385250329971313,
-0.47669729590415955,
0.236515074968338,
0.07619661092758179,
0.7490940690040588,
0.15307770669460297,
-0.05194908380508423,
-0.2752056121826172,
-0.3622969686985016,
0.637769877910614,
-0.4998287558555603,
-0.00839894451200962,
0.3901415467262268,
0.5258190631866455,
-0.459847629070282,
-0.7088711857795715,
-0.7031255960464478,
-0.3903992474079132,
0.031552013009786606,
-0.17092201113700867,
-0.3803403675556183,
0.07456149905920029,
0.44674259424209595,
0.11243527382612228,
-0.4974231719970703,
0.10859089344739914,
-0.22088341414928436,
-0.27430495619773865,
0.5015696287155151,
0.04826640710234642,
0.6842957735061646,
-0.07184293866157532,
-0.6128647923469543,
-0.03341081365942955,
-1.098639965057373,
0.18473394215106964,
0.3515852391719818,
0.3450634777545929,
-0.05164719745516777,
0.40878409147262573,
-0.059752751141786575,
0.774431586265564,
-0.021829679608345032,
-0.04227412864565849,
0.006381014361977577,
-0.3301660418510437,
-0.1639934629201889,
-0.027247382327914238,
0.8012308478355408,
0.0004785761993844062,
0.4052983820438385,
-0.10437452048063278,
-0.250399112701416,
0.00588139658793807,
0.21443316340446472,
-0.5952248573303223,
0.031207995489239693,
0.07427315413951874,
-0.1537330150604248,
-0.3460133671760559,
0.15865367650985718,
-1.0857828855514526,
-0.8009438514709473,
0.08294469863176346,
0.25970548391342163,
-0.24574650824069977,
-0.186726376414299,
-0.046409402042627335,
0.0051232390105724335,
0.1331816017627716,
0.09495646506547928,
-0.6959599256515503,
0.08155989646911621,
0.8090944886207581,
0.8660476803779602,
-0.2097262740135193,
-0.25084173679351807,
-1.0840065479278564,
0.16694790124893188,
-0.20270571112632751,
0.8514405488967896,
-0.6153579354286194,
-0.6480969786643982,
0.004979909863322973,
0.1991702765226364,
-0.08322438597679138,
-0.5708494186401367,
0.5371164679527283,
-0.9013007879257202,
-0.02307739481329918,
-0.49911078810691833,
-0.3371928632259369,
0.16930778324604034,
0.11532662808895111,
-0.9584432244300842,
0.6133437752723694,
-0.08313935250043869,
-0.7967613339424133,
0.09358026087284088,
-0.5097128748893738,
-0.4995523989200592,
0.26779258251190186,
-0.06261655688285828,
-0.30468469858169556,
0.1464509516954422,
0.3676234781742096,
0.23751163482666016,
-0.32002443075180054,
0.249221533536911,
-0.3669174313545227,
-0.24601420760154724,
0.6680410504341125,
-0.5421622395515442,
0.9029991626739502,
0.23557455837726593,
-0.040632735937833786,
0.41161224246025085,
-0.5193275809288025,
-0.45326897501945496,
0.44070175290107727,
0.14271049201488495,
-0.3904062509536743,
-0.3011130392551422,
-0.42675521969795227,
0.08005735278129578,
0.29173049330711365,
-0.6601791977882385,
0.15913601219654083,
-0.4357808530330658,
0.39752814173698425,
0.8262138366699219,
0.6638897061347961,
0.3541758060455322,
-0.2862541079521179,
0.9650093913078308,
-0.06568603217601776,
0.48621851205825806,
-0.6148977279663086,
-0.5686704516410828,
-0.13603438436985016,
-0.8404761552810669,
0.22760097682476044,
0.5514276027679443,
-0.8992695808410645,
0.21489658951759338,
0.0922439694404602,
-0.4406868517398834,
-0.5348190665245056,
-0.029880717396736145,
0.38859474658966064,
0.6696211099624634,
0.2716769576072693,
-0.02882363460958004,
-0.30561333894729614,
-0.816330075263977,
-0.6242049932479858,
-0.024557359516620636,
-0.0448845773935318,
0.009594544768333435,
-0.03517751023173332,
-0.12750835716724396,
1.1028342247009277,
-0.5861024260520935,
-0.4080662429332733,
-0.4621945023536682,
-0.11743834614753723,
0.16877487301826477,
0.41956818103790283,
0.5905952453613281,
-0.699994683265686,
-0.35463547706604004,
-0.5955977439880371,
-0.3986670672893524,
-0.5448458194732666,
-0.5333117246627808,
0.10302332043647766,
-0.006413204129785299,
0.5401750206947327,
-0.8513201475143433,
0.3957749307155609,
0.28690892457962036,
-0.6524754166603088,
0.9186244606971741,
0.0045276484452188015,
-0.23011714220046997,
-0.9354317784309387,
0.13970811665058136,
0.05506834015250206,
-0.1454613357782364,
-0.6748063564300537,
0.2889304459095001,
0.03502902388572693,
-0.4171573519706726,
-0.6816726922988892,
0.716729462146759,
-0.45749136805534363,
-0.008688071742653847,
-0.23111094534397125,
-0.1351926028728485,
0.06632645428180695,
0.28798532485961914,
-0.2271237075328827,
1.1209580898284912,
0.5219270586967468,
-0.6885582804679871,
0.3603052794933319,
0.32470420002937317,
-0.30008381605148315,
0.4041721522808075,
-0.7734947204589844,
0.25779488682746887,
-0.05526510253548622,
0.3864310383796692,
-1.0365225076675415,
-0.00016272302309516817,
0.5245510935783386,
-0.5025993585586548,
0.3445630371570587,
-0.11141321808099747,
-0.43934571743011475,
-0.023031795397400856,
-0.30274298787117004,
0.07566044479608536,
0.38733214139938354,
-0.5822905898094177,
0.5303736329078674,
0.3669579327106476,
-0.6571995615959167,
-0.6049453020095825,
-0.510159432888031,
0.33377671241760254,
-0.2944285571575165,
-0.4622960388660431,
0.12411147356033325,
0.009012419730424881,
-0.3175601363182068,
-0.205745130777359,
-0.055680498480796814,
-0.018494494259357452,
0.495307981967926,
0.19806011021137238,
0.3953246772289276,
0.15729165077209473,
-0.19976963102817535,
0.0797598659992218,
-0.32566988468170166,
0.27727243304252625,
0.08294462412595749,
0.6558796167373657,
0.4795025587081909,
-0.47179391980171204,
-0.879582941532135,
0.5752004981040955,
0.8631916642189026,
-0.44342610239982605,
0.7797239422798157,
0.13075755536556244,
-0.1891520917415619,
-0.38036274909973145,
-0.4422362148761749,
-0.41766273975372314,
-0.572049081325531,
0.3185558617115021,
-0.4905717670917511,
-0.5687611699104309,
0.3928244113922119,
-0.08715107291936874,
0.2865179181098938,
0.03184640780091286,
0.23359239101409912,
0.14714232087135315,
0.9441392421722412,
0.45039182901382446,
-0.04038644954562187,
0.6489914059638977,
0.20014815032482147,
0.14932917058467865,
-0.6690811514854431,
-0.3058090806007385,
-0.6891651153564453,
-0.007848710753023624,
0.013665888458490372,
-0.3124682903289795,
0.06692580878734589,
0.09967239201068878,
-0.21551166474819183,
0.25683078169822693,
-0.23612965643405914,
0.5711752772331238,
0.43710577487945557,
-0.18090833723545074,
0.1374388039112091,
0.14579719305038452,
-0.13776111602783203,
-0.16387324035167694,
-0.28039130568504333,
-0.5592092871665955,
0.6355867981910706,
0.5284435749053955,
0.6520420908927917,
0.14906959235668182,
0.5295085906982422,
0.581200122833252,
0.11362676322460175,
-0.5656277537345886,
0.8470543622970581,
0.09670945256948471,
-0.2216513603925705,
-0.22148922085762024,
-0.5302253365516663,
-0.8857567310333252,
0.2802673876285553,
0.1863093376159668,
-0.6915388703346252,
0.3442330062389374,
0.06267056614160538,
-0.4732261002063751,
0.20952220261096954,
-0.8897996544837952,
0.6810735464096069,
-0.0650256797671318,
-0.2577272951602936,
-0.1761053204536438,
-0.5074292421340942,
0.3387751877307892,
-0.21655425429344177,
0.2649610638618469,
0.08021282404661179,
-0.025274790823459625,
0.7102717757225037,
-0.3431527018547058,
1.1524478197097778,
-0.5294687151908875,
-0.18533284962177277,
0.35324257612228394,
0.535198450088501,
0.952842652797699,
0.38309818506240845,
0.051443617790937424,
-0.05642686411738396,
-0.0625203475356102,
-0.3725883960723877,
-0.5539765954017639,
0.5521312355995178,
-0.4423365294933319,
-0.7678427696228027,
-0.3860945999622345,
-0.14773491024971008,
-0.3421141803264618,
0.2019496113061905,
0.2723909020423889,
0.41729652881622314,
-0.1286393404006958,
-0.16724301874637604,
0.7299891114234924,
-0.37369856238365173,
0.5237791538238525,
0.7105489373207092,
-0.08148553222417831,
-0.40122926235198975,
0.9622424840927124,
-0.15289898216724396,
0.3757314383983612,
0.36012598872184753,
0.2022857517004013,
-0.38628914952278137,
-0.4252386689186096,
-0.34637442231178284,
0.39522722363471985,
-0.4689106047153473,
-0.36019080877304077,
-0.585970938205719,
0.013617584481835365,
-0.45887118577957153,
-0.13017654418945312,
-0.055259425193071365,
-0.25860777497291565,
-0.42824530601501465,
-0.10322625935077667,
0.16798503696918488,
0.4550592303276062,
0.2381897270679474,
0.42189478874206543,
-0.9557618498802185,
0.4059305489063263,
0.44952502846717834,
-0.125947505235672,
0.04182073101401329,
-0.5127332210540771,
0.4083777666091919,
-0.12344330549240112,
-0.06666222214698792,
-1.4306832551956177,
0.5267388820648193,
-0.09527334570884705,
0.5670527219772339,
0.5437713265419006,
0.4605412781238556,
0.27059710025787354,
-0.43460991978645325,
0.8668721318244934,
0.379922479391098,
-0.9568051695823669,
0.3469536006450653,
0.00293954205699265,
0.3647037148475647,
0.5389131903648376,
0.0022772543597966433,
-0.6032880544662476,
-0.3905656337738037,
-0.6876404881477356,
-0.8368464708328247,
0.7560900449752808,
-0.132762148976326,
0.1472032368183136,
-0.12000672519207001,
0.1400776505470276,
0.04078514501452446,
0.1610613614320755,
-0.3883751928806305,
-0.11224810034036636,
0.09846296161413193,
-0.19279934465885162,
0.22485829889774323,
-0.6675493717193604,
-0.1884911209344864,
0.3010542690753937,
0.6045481562614441,
0.03164824843406677,
0.11529044806957245,
0.2206142395734787,
-0.2372645139694214,
0.16009250283241272,
0.34950196743011475,
0.5231715440750122,
0.4622305929660797,
0.40918290615081787,
0.21006371080875397,
0.2586340308189392,
-0.8021111488342285,
0.12498141080141068,
-0.09949517250061035,
-0.4203545153141022,
0.05513406917452812,
0.4770958721637726,
0.837033748626709,
0.06409859657287598,
-0.939882755279541,
0.6313018202781677,
-0.22479656338691711,
0.34466421604156494,
-0.22052401304244995,
-0.029059085994958878,
-0.107016421854496,
0.024350637570023537,
0.4677879512310028,
0.002059933030977845,
-0.13279113173484802,
-0.262984037399292,
0.28615790605545044,
0.4127669632434845,
-0.5105741620063782,
-0.5639448761940002,
0.19855986535549164,
0.26772987842559814,
-0.5093719959259033,
0.3101302981376648,
-0.31600937247276306,
-0.5625635981559753,
0.7789230942726135,
0.8980205059051514,
0.9909080266952515,
-0.6696094870567322,
0.3505549430847168,
0.041194118559360504,
0.4695366322994232,
0.053478676825761795,
0.34530916810035706,
-0.0848478376865387,
-0.3961125910282135,
-0.3612055480480194,
-0.5406670570373535,
-0.3421849310398102,
0.30275920033454895,
-0.5078850388526917,
0.3121736943721771,
-0.7933186888694763,
-0.02693122625350952,
-0.20556433498859406,
-0.31159737706184387,
-0.15693116188049316,
-0.1032884269952774,
0.09570285677909851,
1.0216656923294067,
-0.7256247401237488,
0.6477672457695007,
0.6883277893066406,
-0.2658965587615967,
-0.6736055612564087,
0.16040465235710144,
-0.027999451383948326,
-0.703595757484436,
0.612092137336731,
0.2599201202392578,
-0.03129133582115173,
-0.07065309584140778,
-0.44756487011909485,
-0.7677165269851685,
0.6625973582267761,
0.539277970790863,
-0.829761803150177,
-0.15281949937343597,
-0.06555969268083572,
-0.02936513163149357,
-0.12317823618650436,
-0.13273204863071442,
0.6167589426040649,
0.4451082646846771,
0.18103018403053284,
-0.44843053817749023,
0.417019784450531,
0.09896037727594376,
-0.16948387026786804,
0.22097256779670715,
-0.46506285667419434,
0.7689201235771179,
-0.23229525983333588,
-0.6869685649871826,
0.05388982221484184,
0.6147605776786804,
0.6742151379585266,
0.21253418922424316,
0.6333569288253784,
0.40493953227996826,
0.7221351861953735,
0.1388821005821228,
0.8231383562088013,
-0.0011793741723522544,
-0.01363260019570589,
1.0279415845870972,
-0.683534562587738,
0.6048020124435425,
0.5403743982315063,
-0.06483816355466843,
0.2480858415365219,
0.2921423017978668,
0.026808656752109528,
0.7151849865913391,
0.19994381070137024,
-0.3712993860244751,
-0.012517009861767292,
-0.22454115748405457,
-0.3985610008239746,
-0.03687864542007446,
0.5893315076828003,
-0.2546926438808441,
-0.2670263648033142,
0.2573392987251282,
0.4058673083782196,
0.06102808192372322,
-0.2257024049758911,
0.973717212677002,
0.2325415462255478,
-0.7671684622764587,
0.3487490117549896,
0.06579676270484924,
0.44487592577934265,
-0.8970102667808533,
0.10494185984134674,
-0.21028870344161987,
0.214688241481781,
0.043486762791872025,
-0.41149967908859253,
0.3230312764644623,
0.2850719690322876,
-0.04361908510327339,
-0.1339789181947708,
0.8390367031097412,
-0.013939118944108486,
-0.17531737685203552,
0.22827918827533722,
0.11865290254354477,
-0.2824575901031494,
-0.35565853118896484,
-0.7034332752227783,
0.29718366265296936,
0.09017988294363022,
-0.405668169260025,
0.4822761118412018,
0.144733265042305,
-0.21292328834533691,
0.675857663154602,
0.8187463283538818,
0.4448168873786926,
0.0975632518529892,
0.035718053579330444,
0.7511591911315918,
-0.49707311391830444,
-1.1059499979019165,
-1.0868029594421387,
0.05646997317671776,
-0.30387723445892334,
-0.25366291403770447,
0.7992703318595886,
0.12237528711557388,
0.25661784410476685,
-0.06965883821249008,
0.7774410843849182,
0.2281384915113449,
0.5797310471534729,
-0.5281198620796204,
0.6753901243209839,
0.12936130166053772,
0.5337510704994202,
-0.17649005353450775,
-0.786670982837677,
-0.15962761640548706,
0.10093555599451065,
-0.44266045093536377,
-0.3110809922218323,
0.7184582352638245,
0.8750013113021851,
0.256744384765625,
0.22052530944347382,
0.06975612044334412,
0.14459827542304993,
0.6883174777030945,
0.358247309923172,
1.047263264656067,
0.1485784947872162,
0.5190309286117554,
0.07546211034059525,
-0.5635356903076172,
-0.1432296484708786,
-0.6077609062194824,
-0.8166636824607849,
-0.38788706064224243,
-0.30877116322517395,
-0.32076793909072876,
0.1242445558309555,
0.6614497303962708,
0.33938658237457275,
-0.8111801147460938,
0.1764603704214096,
-0.2761577069759369,
0.12187254428863525,
-0.3858376443386078,
-0.25766628980636597,
0.37934085726737976,
-0.473622590303421,
-0.41255128383636475,
0.7751017808914185,
0.1813635230064392,
0.013510308228433132,
-0.427990585565567,
0.3160063624382019,
-0.12966765463352203,
0.4233112335205078,
0.14841865003108978,
0.6549383401870728,
-0.5805709958076477,
0.009816677309572697,
0.011448743753135204,
-0.040267154574394226,
-0.49271073937416077,
0.9993210434913635,
-0.8777242302894592,
0.250486820936203,
0.6571135520935059,
0.9678836464881897,
-0.09539388865232468,
0.12595175206661224,
0.48154959082603455,
-1.0113906860351562,
0.2826632559299469,
0.3742451071739197,
0.42537105083465576,
0.48299726843833923,
-0.6247856616973877,
0.017690949141979218,
0.41957980394363403,
-0.2121185064315796,
-1.2232388257980347,
0.749693751335144,
-0.7242076992988586,
-0.6097880601882935,
1.2983577251434326,
-0.365908145904541,
-0.512432336807251,
-0.28427788615226746,
-0.5280104875564575,
0.10596727579832077,
-0.6119700074195862,
0.6647607088088989,
0.40313011407852173,
0.531324565410614,
-0.07280949503183365,
-0.38225698471069336,
0.5747712850570679,
0.4241775870323181,
-0.728585422039032,
0.4867546260356903,
0.4056238532066345,
0.2859332859516144,
0.2556038498878479,
0.36002957820892334,
-0.3999193608760834,
0.33622801303863525,
-0.2870939075946808,
-0.293759286403656,
-0.5177523493766785,
-0.5183317065238953,
-0.7250508069992065,
0.7043483853340149,
-0.013161659240722656,
-0.4745562672615051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14661v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14661v1
|
Towards Modeling Learner Performance with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-29T14:06:34 | 2024-02-29T14:06:34 |
Seyed Parsa Neshaei, Richard Lee Davis, Adam Hazimeh, Bojan Lazarevski, Pierre Dillenbourg, Tanja Käser
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent work exploring the capabilities of pre-trained large language models
(LLMs) has demonstrated their ability to act as general pattern machines by
completing complex token sequences representing a wide array of tasks,
including time-series prediction and robot control. This paper investigates
whether the pattern recognition and sequence modeling capabilities of LLMs can
be extended to the domain of knowledge tracing, a critical component in the
development of intelligent tutoring systems (ITSs) that tailor educational
experiences by predicting learner performance over time. In an empirical
evaluation across multiple real-world datasets, we compare two approaches to
using LLMs for this task, zero-shot prompting and model fine-tuning, with
existing, non-LLM approaches to knowledge tracing. While LLM-based approaches
do not achieve state-of-the-art performance, fine-tuned LLMs surpass the
performance of naive baseline models and perform on par with standard Bayesian
Knowledge Tracing approaches across multiple metrics. These findings suggest
that the pattern recognition capabilities of LLMs can be used to model complex
learning trajectories, opening a novel avenue for applying LLMs to educational
contexts. The paper concludes with a discussion of the implications of these
findings for future research, suggesting that further refinements and a deeper
understanding of LLMs' predictive mechanisms could lead to enhanced performance
in knowledge tracing tasks.
|
[
-0.010867715813219547,
-0.7959206700325012,
0.6877245306968689,
-0.45721733570098877,
-0.09612926840782166,
0.3458581864833832,
-0.23112626373767853,
-0.43751415610313416,
-0.19506318867206573,
0.568411648273468,
-0.5177443027496338,
-0.56251060962677,
-0.49227187037467957,
-0.22174367308616638,
-0.5472528338432312,
0.7357193231582642,
0.10426458716392517,
0.12730003893375397,
-0.1989576518535614,
0.3043312430381775,
-0.6541581749916077,
-0.5185966491699219,
-0.5970453023910522,
-0.4434816837310791,
0.7448043823242188,
0.4928860366344452,
0.13579285144805908,
0.9000973701477051,
0.11886336654424667,
0.20936907827854156,
0.08866637945175171,
0.13819777965545654,
-0.40915924310684204,
0.24935366213321686,
-0.19108034670352936,
-0.8512508273124695,
-0.3327990472316742,
-0.09610055387020111,
0.7555856704711914,
0.7766628265380859,
0.06947183609008789,
0.23351125419139862,
0.32552677392959595,
0.5817631483078003,
-0.5430192351341248,
0.32030659914016724,
-0.3732094168663025,
0.03194684535264969,
-0.15766027569770813,
-0.2721134424209595,
-0.5281582474708557,
-0.3274022340774536,
0.36391907930374146,
-0.5026963949203491,
0.39812061190605164,
0.13692836463451385,
0.4077061712741852,
0.06033105403184891,
-0.24259749054908752,
-0.3322247862815857,
-1.040830135345459,
0.8153346180915833,
-0.9318665862083435,
0.22199177742004395,
0.12273864448070526,
0.6478806138038635,
-0.112083300948143,
-0.5503629446029663,
-0.30844396352767944,
-0.2293664962053299,
-0.006243362557142973,
0.00710394699126482,
0.16776743531227112,
-0.1452644169330597,
0.5455040335655212,
0.14171577990055084,
-0.35741522908210754,
0.5839715003967285,
-0.4167088568210602,
-0.12723186612129211,
0.4804452657699585,
0.5225621461868286,
-0.005561886355280876,
0.1808115541934967,
-0.32076114416122437,
-0.0017692568944767118,
-0.8783518075942993,
0.4611431062221527,
0.24613696336746216,
0.7653828859329224,
-0.08854750543832779,
0.6328540444374084,
-0.24849000573158264,
1.0708727836608887,
-0.20373541116714478,
-0.4469098448753357,
-0.3463471531867981,
0.07988027483224869,
0.0911969542503357,
-0.06529773026704788,
0.5075136423110962,
0.2870815694332123,
0.7145826816558838,
-0.27439919114112854,
-0.213023841381073,
0.0701170563697815,
0.10095750540494919,
-0.883228063583374,
-0.4490266442298889,
-0.20984138548374176,
-0.12780025601387024,
-0.01914164051413536,
-0.11767412722110748,
-0.8477384448051453,
-0.552142322063446,
-0.6322970390319824,
0.5158911347389221,
-0.57736736536026,
-0.08875451236963272,
0.3524274230003357,
0.07600861042737961,
0.4706971049308777,
0.49725914001464844,
-0.7260492444038391,
0.1423860341310501,
0.760068953037262,
0.874070942401886,
-0.2368202805519104,
-0.16643302142620087,
-0.4332510828971863,
0.45564767718315125,
-0.3199438154697418,
0.6057233810424805,
-0.8777152895927429,
-0.3595713675022125,
0.24617478251457214,
-0.1002524197101593,
-0.35731565952301025,
-0.3951609134674072,
0.021493451669812202,
-0.6109977960586548,
0.1622212827205658,
-0.17173929512500763,
-1.1774653196334839,
-0.48054975271224976,
0.16099603474140167,
-0.5159565806388855,
0.6337413191795349,
-0.019850648939609528,
-0.3627886474132538,
0.23493801057338715,
-0.5652332305908203,
-0.5024304389953613,
0.13507719337940216,
-0.044226620346307755,
-0.22198668122291565,
-0.044844452291727066,
-0.09960009902715683,
0.9133822321891785,
-0.22940441966056824,
0.2773759365081787,
-0.242752805352211,
-0.6707332730293274,
0.009557344950735569,
-0.43527525663375854,
0.46646279096603394,
-0.08045852929353714,
-0.3992663025856018,
0.026296619325876236,
-1.0660954713821411,
-0.08895847201347351,
0.025782378390431404,
-0.33482080698013306,
-0.3068431615829468,
0.3213083744049072,
-0.5130066275596619,
0.24164670705795288,
0.17779041826725006,
-0.4283747673034668,
0.40145546197891235,
-0.2285822331905365,
0.3042617738246918,
0.8379784822463989,
-0.23957429826259613,
0.3606497645378113,
-0.42329856753349304,
0.7661773562431335,
-0.04903363808989525,
-0.201430544257164,
-0.7211273908615112,
-0.37655889987945557,
-0.9039976596832275,
-0.30346301198005676,
0.25485992431640625,
0.6100571751594543,
-0.4321015775203705,
0.15516714751720428,
-0.198313370347023,
-0.47758591175079346,
-0.36867383122444153,
0.12528160214424133,
0.35002824664115906,
0.6729099750518799,
0.29657667875289917,
-0.23594114184379578,
-0.39622682332992554,
-0.2419152557849884,
-0.3384190499782562,
-0.21222297847270966,
-0.1896129697561264,
0.4921296536922455,
0.2141401171684265,
0.1103740930557251,
0.7318062782287598,
-0.37580424547195435,
-0.3111259937286377,
-0.3031153976917267,
0.004694477654993534,
0.049862489104270935,
0.42553985118865967,
0.43105247616767883,
-0.22885380685329437,
-0.28335055708885193,
-0.089798703789711,
-0.6546052694320679,
0.09458053857088089,
-0.042199574410915375,
0.007805496454238892,
0.2637075185775757,
0.7434055805206299,
-0.23399634659290314,
0.4019629657268524,
0.2623324692249298,
-0.478996604681015,
0.576448380947113,
-0.028163500130176544,
-0.01759699359536171,
-0.8744274973869324,
0.11130087077617645,
-0.03483520820736885,
-0.025604119524359703,
-0.6560031175613403,
-0.165694460272789,
0.04857489839196205,
0.13271573185920715,
-0.3968343734741211,
0.703519344329834,
-0.3304358422756195,
-0.23979634046554565,
-0.26103225350379944,
0.1145772710442543,
-0.08930584788322449,
0.4798191785812378,
0.018784109503030777,
0.6539504528045654,
0.7599126100540161,
-0.8094270825386047,
0.24368909001350403,
-0.2326626032590866,
-0.5991948246955872,
0.45844724774360657,
-0.539074182510376,
-0.05537211894989014,
-0.013732951134443283,
-0.06567184627056122,
-1.1295992136001587,
-0.11083321273326874,
0.005835541523993015,
-0.2746483087539673,
0.5350759029388428,
-0.2938893139362335,
-0.43503278493881226,
-0.38392654061317444,
-0.021600404754281044,
0.15255524218082428,
0.6543066501617432,
-0.41870996356010437,
0.6947900056838989,
-0.16235163807868958,
-0.15814600884914398,
-0.5197880864143372,
-0.04072268679738045,
-0.08783607929944992,
-0.3929140865802765,
-0.27292728424072266,
0.023020585998892784,
-0.10158023983240128,
0.08088614046573639,
-0.360711008310318,
-0.040481071919202805,
0.09096940606832504,
0.45559561252593994,
0.4408453404903412,
0.605451762676239,
-0.47094693779945374,
0.10026422888040543,
-0.35227346420288086,
-0.027663899585604668,
0.16825664043426514,
-0.43971624970436096,
0.5771156549453735,
0.15649725496768951,
-0.544265866279602,
-0.3273727595806122,
-0.17047198116779327,
0.612137496471405,
-0.2617017328739166,
0.6147351861000061,
0.45970842242240906,
-0.18256884813308716,
-0.4156171381473541,
-0.6029267311096191,
-0.3990466594696045,
-0.4594346582889557,
0.28143617510795593,
-0.11046672612428665,
-1.156326174736023,
0.6220822334289551,
-0.3964446187019348,
0.11601580679416656,
0.168196901679039,
0.2380896508693695,
-0.35497915744781494,
1.0393424034118652,
1.0011025667190552,
-0.26538124680519104,
0.6319566965103149,
-0.3782843053340912,
0.2093038111925125,
-0.7030634880065918,
-0.5393233895301819,
-0.41616809368133545,
-0.38915765285491943,
-0.4428161680698395,
-0.25909295678138733,
0.11218111217021942,
0.2559615969657898,
-0.3522886335849762,
0.042349282652139664,
0.016207579523324966,
0.5827391743659973,
0.6506518721580505,
-0.06282678991556168,
0.36819538474082947,
0.017688045278191566,
-0.29908907413482666,
0.15300993621349335,
-0.8361073732376099,
-0.7620124816894531,
1.1958259344100952,
0.09911686182022095,
0.8441416621208191,
-0.25638389587402344,
0.36588138341903687,
-0.027195341885089874,
0.1809128224849701,
-0.8358978033065796,
0.7274998426437378,
-0.29171133041381836,
-0.46933653950691223,
-0.41731587052345276,
-0.1571141481399536,
-0.9039319753646851,
-0.1160895824432373,
-0.04811781272292137,
-0.6756092309951782,
-0.33237433433532715,
0.2974887192249298,
-0.5759487152099609,
0.7089931964874268,
-0.46387290954589844,
0.6868168711662292,
-0.18658877909183502,
-0.443582147359848,
-0.010711711831390858,
-0.590876042842865,
0.2927907109260559,
-0.11669463664293289,
0.03601262718439102,
-0.21594907343387604,
0.08073797076940536,
0.801514208316803,
-0.003167348448187113,
1.2738991975784302,
-0.3745906949043274,
-0.248330220580101,
0.30500367283821106,
0.24691209197044373,
0.4495018720626831,
-0.45667386054992676,
-0.11087726801633835,
-0.0968439057469368,
0.020652182400226593,
-0.3941756784915924,
-0.5305609107017517,
0.7072306275367737,
-0.6332528591156006,
-0.7216915488243103,
-0.05100756511092186,
-0.6132382154464722,
-0.37626487016677856,
0.27409815788269043,
-0.08043854683637619,
0.48712608218193054,
0.06611911952495575,
-0.021607860922813416,
0.7829251885414124,
-0.1139708012342453,
0.6960827112197876,
1.1806004047393799,
-0.11459675431251526,
0.2821792960166931,
1.1030397415161133,
0.48238974809646606,
0.21931399405002594,
0.40564435720443726,
0.17779985070228577,
-0.21972711384296417,
-0.8285093307495117,
-0.39392194151878357,
0.2105463296175003,
-0.5079214572906494,
-0.3045896291732788,
-0.44345423579216003,
-0.26100581884384155,
-0.23438531160354614,
-0.28760284185409546,
-0.15622498095035553,
-0.4359571635723114,
-0.5484659671783447,
-0.21314087510108948,
0.44405215978622437,
1.029576063156128,
0.13449682295322418,
0.5107266306877136,
-0.6259666085243225,
0.08647529780864716,
0.508894681930542,
0.6045750975608826,
0.3836246728897095,
-0.8390389084815979,
-0.40841853618621826,
-0.023114468902349472,
-0.30011382699012756,
-0.38186269998550415,
0.39361250400543213,
0.34365808963775635,
0.4544099271297455,
0.47512006759643555,
-0.009993704035878181,
0.8731687664985657,
-0.6933442950248718,
0.8703243732452393,
-0.18740251660346985,
-0.6742604970932007,
0.6824538111686707,
-0.44384896755218506,
0.1570759266614914,
0.02505839802324772,
0.5118651986122131,
-0.33260130882263184,
-0.46171849966049194,
-0.299349844455719,
-0.7885972261428833,
0.7155327796936035,
-0.6269685626029968,
0.07468333840370178,
0.22647373378276825,
0.6376825571060181,
0.2668386399745941,
0.09558552503585815,
-0.23879504203796387,
-0.17475526034832,
-0.005003550089895725,
-0.14421704411506653,
-0.48757219314575195,
-0.2228219360113144,
0.1696959137916565,
-0.06373558938503265,
0.5145800709724426,
-0.2702988088130951,
0.04342046007514,
-0.3076540529727936,
-0.17703282833099365,
-0.19955509901046753,
0.10064354538917542,
0.5022751688957214,
0.8066354393959045,
-0.08259564638137817,
0.015953954309225082,
-0.022248512133955956,
-0.19989323616027832,
0.0822015106678009,
0.09212414920330048,
-0.23924967646598816,
-0.17630402743816376,
0.6379908919334412,
0.7112599611282349,
0.3319058120250702,
-0.7325160503387451,
0.3862258195877075,
0.2712576687335968,
-0.009923605248332024,
-0.33350616693496704,
0.6867458820343018,
0.11228165030479431,
0.622807502746582,
0.26790159940719604,
-0.17824819684028625,
-0.02634807489812374,
-0.3723333179950714,
0.12310346215963364,
0.4247617721557617,
-0.48381009697914124,
-0.6036117672920227,
0.628655731678009,
-0.03232664242386818,
-0.370633602142334,
0.5656362771987915,
0.3817216753959656,
-0.28765755891799927,
0.8196465373039246,
0.6461202502250671,
0.5593072175979614,
-0.503362238407135,
0.1493145078420639,
0.44388651847839355,
-0.0714886412024498,
-0.2666286826133728,
0.23198537528514862,
-0.15192796289920807,
-0.5048434138298035,
-0.6823901534080505,
-0.5945174098014832,
-0.38313162326812744,
0.09305661916732788,
-0.8416610360145569,
0.27066436409950256,
-0.5869085788726807,
0.1338249146938324,
0.006854305975139141,
-0.024154003709554672,
-0.8064979314804077,
0.24217256903648376,
0.46186816692352295,
0.8749895691871643,
-0.830083429813385,
0.9207472801208496,
0.6389720439910889,
-0.0015596983721479774,
-0.7960687875747681,
-0.2601882517337799,
-0.015893826261162758,
-1.0033191442489624,
0.6267157196998596,
0.3457525074481964,
-0.33568647503852844,
0.1760193407535553,
-0.4646105468273163,
-0.7625970244407654,
1.3879618644714355,
0.38412225246429443,
-0.8690295815467834,
-0.3682115077972412,
0.26272276043891907,
0.5285855531692505,
-0.49427464604377747,
0.18410728871822357,
0.6130695343017578,
0.036559365689754486,
0.21819670498371124,
-0.6518533229827881,
-0.08709485828876495,
0.16377222537994385,
-0.00679774908348918,
-0.01676810532808304,
-0.5462943315505981,
0.7004557251930237,
-0.5318512320518494,
-0.234800785779953,
0.22695697844028473,
0.4270138144493103,
0.18658146262168884,
0.43972107768058777,
0.03245506435632706,
0.3562977612018585,
0.6860391497612,
-0.015732131898403168,
0.8757537007331848,
-0.48775768280029297,
-0.013580619357526302,
1.1918447017669678,
-0.3137437403202057,
1.0183619260787964,
0.15282632410526276,
-0.3035939335823059,
0.7427723407745361,
0.40280789136886597,
-0.02302742935717106,
0.4855978190898895,
0.38485684990882874,
-0.15946365892887115,
-0.3364463448524475,
-0.07987383753061295,
-0.11990421265363693,
0.34227198362350464,
0.5002474188804626,
-0.37515756487846375,
-0.057672061026096344,
0.04426418989896774,
-0.11735259741544724,
0.028032807633280754,
-0.657966136932373,
0.8264585733413696,
-0.04995220527052879,
-0.6051817536354065,
0.5274420380592346,
-0.274580717086792,
0.7815321087837219,
-0.6176149845123291,
-0.2147516906261444,
-0.23803727328777313,
0.17165201902389526,
0.045619744807481766,
-0.6725115776062012,
-0.12832419574260712,
-0.019518911838531494,
-0.2033967673778534,
-0.23860234022140503,
0.6718183755874634,
-0.4972628355026245,
-0.48192813992500305,
0.4722197949886322,
0.7300863862037659,
-0.02170587331056595,
0.29869791865348816,
-0.2439582198858261,
-0.23804128170013428,
-0.08813615888357162,
-0.19389434158802032,
0.4486786723136902,
0.5117617249488831,
-0.002735678106546402,
1.0819265842437744,
0.565649151802063,
0.0784352570772171,
0.4431381821632385,
0.17252299189567566,
0.583511471748352,
-0.8426956534385681,
-0.18117663264274597,
-1.0691723823547363,
0.39923056960105896,
0.3655990958213806,
-0.07492095232009888,
0.8542672991752625,
0.38313689827919006,
1.1751182079315186,
-0.18100662529468536,
0.8302560448646545,
0.4066333770751953,
0.9199867248535156,
-0.576566755771637,
0.427924245595932,
-0.2735186219215393,
0.4410090744495392,
-0.1363198608160019,
-0.5999671220779419,
-0.3099362552165985,
0.41577810049057007,
-0.3812803328037262,
0.1696731150150299,
0.06220617517828941,
0.7195937633514404,
0.07300137728452682,
0.09843047708272934,
0.5476531982421875,
0.23222370445728302,
0.34093692898750305,
0.6002722382545471,
1.1003875732421875,
-0.11821962147951126,
0.28238964080810547,
-0.215400829911232,
0.015655266121029854,
-0.37105610966682434,
-0.7462767362594604,
-1.1418392658233643,
-0.4232138693332672,
-0.211247518658638,
0.06362952291965485,
0.19830216467380524,
0.5260559320449829,
0.5941988229751587,
-0.8363249897956848,
-0.5115386843681335,
0.0033852546475827694,
0.04983138293027878,
-0.11049006134271622,
-0.2117922306060791,
0.20009693503379822,
-0.426167368888855,
-0.5969715714454651,
0.3465888798236847,
0.11229617893695831,
0.40232956409454346,
-0.35373204946517944,
-0.035819459706544876,
0.13155753910541534,
0.05573442578315735,
0.7981851100921631,
0.44865158200263977,
-0.7792801260948181,
-0.3372449576854706,
0.30176782608032227,
0.23825328052043915,
-0.15880638360977173,
0.8803794980049133,
-1.1506378650665283,
0.4710468351840973,
0.1545592099428177,
0.5512126088142395,
0.41649365425109863,
-0.21186161041259766,
0.5712682008743286,
-0.48507896065711975,
-0.3096209168434143,
0.25929495692253113,
0.1973799616098404,
0.30328723788261414,
-0.10342594236135483,
0.3575681447982788,
0.03409915044903755,
-0.4343041181564331,
-0.7326768636703491,
0.14103804528713226,
-0.5052685737609863,
-0.25412046909332275,
0.990632176399231,
-0.5165631175041199,
-0.0555434487760067,
-0.13096903264522552,
-0.04585062712430954,
0.31571295857429504,
-0.12579528987407684,
0.847057580947876,
0.6393704414367676,
-0.22985777258872986,
-0.16584660112857819,
-0.8681225776672363,
0.3445136845111847,
0.36028334498405457,
-0.41592684388160706,
0.17834274470806122,
0.536105215549469,
0.5908213257789612,
-0.03946644812822342,
0.21946416795253754,
0.07633279263973236,
0.06985565274953842,
-0.42882040143013,
-0.24718451499938965,
-0.29278135299682617,
-0.6959360241889954,
-0.41490721702575684,
0.16901566088199615,
0.17572464048862457,
-0.09308589994907379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19170v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19170v2
|
Improving Legal Judgement Prediction in Romanian with Long Text Encoders
| 2024-02-29T13:52:33 | 2024-03-04T20:54:34 |
Mihai Masala, Traian Rebedea, Horia Velicu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years,the entire field of Natural Language Processing (NLP) has
enjoyed amazing novel results achieving almost human-like performance on a
variety of tasks. Legal NLP domain has also been part of this process, as it
has seen an impressive growth. However, general-purpose models are not readily
applicable for legal domain. Due to the nature of the domain (e.g. specialized
vocabulary, long documents) specific models and methods are often needed for
Legal NLP. In this work we investigate both specialized and general models for
predicting the final ruling of a legal case, task known as Legal Judgment
Prediction (LJP). We particularly focus on methods to extend to sequence length
of Transformer-based models to better understand the long documents present in
legal corpora. Extensive experiments on 4 LJP datasets in Romanian, originating
from 2 sources with significantly different sizes and document lengths, show
that specialized models and handling long texts are critical for a good
performance.
|
[
-0.18221484124660492,
-0.6190759539604187,
0.7274711728096008,
0.1444607377052307,
-0.5976694226264954,
-0.07451033592224121,
-0.3934613764286041,
-0.9034721851348877,
0.28232571482658386,
0.9468971490859985,
-0.0377570204436779,
-0.6617041230201721,
-0.9029443860054016,
0.08037983626127243,
-0.4762738347053528,
1.2130441665649414,
0.13958154618740082,
0.46749570965766907,
-0.2826397716999054,
-0.3351423442363739,
-0.6337725520133972,
-0.761864960193634,
-0.42131707072257996,
-0.4583107531070709,
0.31131917238235474,
0.007847671397030354,
0.6392934322357178,
0.29853975772857666,
0.7293857336044312,
0.2730701267719269,
-0.22978734970092773,
-0.20028847455978394,
-0.05100993439555168,
0.24661050736904144,
-0.36350300908088684,
-0.7750133275985718,
-0.4289679527282715,
-0.3994620144367218,
0.4886643588542938,
0.367587149143219,
-0.317037433385849,
-0.02892734482884407,
-0.11603488028049469,
0.8387841582298279,
-0.46578577160835266,
0.17508265376091003,
-0.42777976393699646,
0.5227828621864319,
-0.14272259175777435,
-0.4012887477874756,
-0.7090616822242737,
-0.30035242438316345,
0.2640741169452667,
-0.29948344826698303,
0.46305418014526367,
0.21323172748088837,
0.8231499791145325,
0.3919171392917633,
-0.6210706830024719,
-0.36997368931770325,
-0.9954769015312195,
0.5021249055862427,
-0.756871223449707,
0.5294564962387085,
0.3367438018321991,
0.5272713899612427,
-0.38950708508491516,
-0.9593765735626221,
-0.2769530415534973,
-0.5126057863235474,
-0.19316387176513672,
0.33260154724121094,
-0.4871855080127716,
0.3536011278629303,
0.4205709397792816,
0.008370651863515377,
-0.5247585773468018,
0.40858346223831177,
-0.5755671262741089,
0.02608289010822773,
0.5870545506477356,
0.012024838477373123,
-0.17040576040744781,
-0.273087739944458,
-0.05256368964910507,
0.29747962951660156,
-0.5529457926750183,
0.2202540934085846,
0.580581784248352,
0.08953806012868881,
0.210306316614151,
0.7616187930107117,
-0.11148767173290253,
0.8189297914505005,
0.3553827404975891,
0.0013777825515717268,
0.2937154471874237,
0.14268147945404053,
-0.4954484701156616,
0.19053968787193298,
0.7689652442932129,
0.49269339442253113,
0.34893283247947693,
-0.13920503854751587,
-0.3470347225666046,
0.02833016775548458,
0.4874613285064697,
-0.8516192436218262,
0.20248369872570038,
0.39443475008010864,
-0.5804567337036133,
-0.07988306134939194,
0.11312579363584518,
-0.9705155491828918,
-0.5970040559768677,
-0.5769233703613281,
-0.07013269513845444,
-0.476138174533844,
0.18512675166130066,
0.6715595126152039,
-0.08592025935649872,
0.3628809452056885,
0.39866337180137634,
-0.6924988627433777,
0.5020696520805359,
0.7816368341445923,
0.5252891778945923,
-0.11673600226640701,
0.2772546112537384,
-0.8143224716186523,
-0.07621948421001434,
-0.1503411829471588,
0.6712356209754944,
-0.7586708068847656,
-0.42665988206863403,
0.2694915235042572,
0.08422990888357162,
0.15904554724693298,
-0.5621529817581177,
1.4127205610275269,
-0.779126763343811,
0.3776250183582306,
0.26260215044021606,
-0.860571026802063,
-0.21313700079917908,
0.23594850301742554,
-0.8888427019119263,
0.5476166009902954,
-0.09029220044612885,
-1.0351306200027466,
0.7400407195091248,
-0.7640781402587891,
-0.7080820202827454,
0.3505780100822449,
-0.37489789724349976,
-0.670881450176239,
0.28805333375930786,
0.08861828595399857,
0.6501193642616272,
-0.31004220247268677,
0.7079258561134338,
-0.08177188038825989,
-0.2556556463241577,
-0.05297867953777313,
-0.26890602707862854,
0.6847695708274841,
0.18784382939338684,
-0.29910966753959656,
0.39937150478363037,
-0.7561339139938354,
-0.23987030982971191,
-0.06236478313803673,
-0.5951239466667175,
-0.35079583525657654,
0.2766527831554413,
0.12223178893327713,
0.20268873870372772,
0.09515752643346786,
-0.6442321538925171,
0.11198853701353073,
-0.394447386264801,
0.2015545815229416,
0.45882049202919006,
-0.10873039811849594,
0.5235994458198547,
-0.06145944818854332,
0.9620009064674377,
0.009856455959379673,
0.02882121317088604,
0.08690838515758514,
-0.7812695503234863,
-0.8732831478118896,
0.08403000980615616,
0.807071328163147,
0.7617278099060059,
-0.444151371717453,
0.7882964015007019,
-0.734339714050293,
-0.3921950161457062,
-0.5185225605964661,
-0.2601209282875061,
0.05754473805427551,
0.21090833842754364,
0.44397178292274475,
-0.4244723916053772,
-0.8435660004615784,
-1.0252381563186646,
-0.5244003534317017,
-0.057772886008024216,
-0.24727530777454376,
0.1731719970703125,
0.8315857648849487,
-0.26792722940444946,
1.146282434463501,
-0.25427350401878357,
-0.5056551098823547,
-0.45055800676345825,
0.028937634080648422,
0.7273260354995728,
0.25710734724998474,
0.6067145466804504,
-1.04316246509552,
-0.35731998085975647,
0.18159715831279755,
-0.5878346562385559,
0.30179160833358765,
-0.38042977452278137,
0.1017545834183693,
0.3812115490436554,
0.45512819290161133,
-0.6270189881324768,
0.5405278205871582,
0.2865866720676422,
-0.7916439175605774,
0.6617255806922913,
-0.5233088135719299,
0.0595930740237236,
-0.8986613750457764,
-0.1571090966463089,
0.4058939814567566,
-0.8168774843215942,
-0.7221633195877075,
0.2799168527126312,
0.2614271938800812,
0.24972820281982422,
-0.45035648345947266,
0.1531439870595932,
-0.29149386286735535,
-0.2145206332206726,
-0.16350272297859192,
-0.21300667524337769,
-0.034301310777664185,
0.36651355028152466,
0.411557674407959,
0.36940890550613403,
0.2973247766494751,
-0.37781739234924316,
0.5024104118347168,
0.07644981145858765,
-0.7244821190834045,
0.6283114552497864,
-0.7285662293434143,
-0.06345714628696442,
-0.4432242810726166,
0.5062787532806396,
-0.11244666576385498,
-0.010311185382306576,
0.22349482774734497,
-0.22748371958732605,
0.6359392404556274,
-0.6939565539360046,
-0.5393377542495728,
-0.6223915219306946,
0.11296433210372925,
0.1130828857421875,
0.48543059825897217,
-0.3040716052055359,
1.1255593299865723,
0.23777620494365692,
-0.018126817420125008,
-0.7947750091552734,
-0.6944872736930847,
0.3506065607070923,
-0.5700708031654358,
-0.5624369978904724,
0.596103847026825,
0.05737289413809776,
-0.2261994481086731,
-0.1110323965549469,
0.3621334433555603,
-0.018416324630379677,
-0.21062886714935303,
0.5494600534439087,
0.0876656025648117,
-0.2243286818265915,
0.20330896973609924,
0.08032523095607758,
-0.026280833408236504,
0.45915544033050537,
-0.30409660935401917,
0.5198476314544678,
-0.3275497257709503,
-0.2869463562965393,
-0.2267724722623825,
0.3964148461818695,
0.5361005067825317,
-0.46124809980392456,
0.5253263115882874,
0.28063294291496277,
-0.4187792241573334,
-0.0334031917154789,
-0.6461101174354553,
0.35717344284057617,
-0.3825790286064148,
0.4875126779079437,
-0.46771812438964844,
-0.840576171875,
0.5339611768722534,
0.03206895291805267,
-0.0027875215746462345,
0.6669749617576599,
0.7465204000473022,
0.2142687290906906,
0.7017594575881958,
0.894826352596283,
-0.274851530790329,
0.548933207988739,
-0.2213555872440338,
0.3247595727443695,
-0.3729776442050934,
-0.31297385692596436,
-0.5982427597045898,
-0.1093125268816948,
-0.8349798917770386,
-0.5632925629615784,
0.15364868938922882,
-0.15683774650096893,
0.024916693568229675,
0.4874233305454254,
-0.23907476663589478,
0.6705990433692932,
0.6584886908531189,
0.16004115343093872,
0.4449155926704407,
0.05223848298192024,
-0.18028898537158966,
-0.010717438533902168,
-0.457133024930954,
-0.47340086102485657,
1.183677315711975,
0.5144874453544617,
0.3766190707683563,
-0.04837116226553917,
0.9357622861862183,
0.4219284653663635,
-0.06768248230218887,
-1.0535175800323486,
0.38045549392700195,
-0.3149261772632599,
-0.425471693277359,
-0.20648778975009918,
-0.3285094201564789,
-1.1418670415878296,
0.18659743666648865,
-0.3335878252983093,
-0.3131170868873596,
0.33790966868400574,
-0.3306812345981598,
-0.6002297401428223,
0.1961609423160553,
-0.12116851657629013,
0.5762299299240112,
-0.12415585666894913,
-0.2884751260280609,
-0.5368465781211853,
-0.7342637777328491,
0.16590064764022827,
-0.24700693786144257,
0.17811240255832672,
0.017403731122612953,
0.26535189151763916,
0.9481139183044434,
-0.34357398748397827,
0.4790725111961365,
-0.18957892060279846,
-0.06595000624656677,
0.3164144456386566,
-0.05009447783231735,
0.6431831121444702,
-0.027165252715349197,
-0.3131464719772339,
-0.020595313981175423,
0.01696966029703617,
-0.15579360723495483,
-0.5942267775535583,
0.3729061186313629,
-0.45336300134658813,
-0.6229161024093628,
-0.5931560397148132,
-0.17068074643611908,
0.05384116619825363,
0.11135916411876678,
0.4124399721622467,
0.11144262552261353,
-0.32975834608078003,
0.26030266284942627,
0.4295768141746521,
-0.10945352911949158,
0.3221164047718048,
0.6888995170593262,
-0.10713732987642288,
-0.20565733313560486,
0.33154621720314026,
0.10766537487506866,
-0.3564779758453369,
0.33442452549934387,
0.10636956989765167,
-0.3744044005870819,
-0.8321011662483215,
-0.3820266127586365,
0.02216876484453678,
-0.9456992745399475,
-0.3838903307914734,
-0.6265376210212708,
-0.22467313706874847,
-0.2263747900724411,
-0.031744033098220825,
-0.23383353650569916,
-0.5112504363059998,
-0.28354597091674805,
-0.4082496464252472,
0.3145844042301178,
0.666504979133606,
0.2329818606376648,
0.0033652184065431356,
-0.7284902334213257,
0.3889363408088684,
-0.057886119931936264,
0.5542363524436951,
-0.5044819712638855,
-0.984158992767334,
-0.3609359860420227,
-0.13541805744171143,
-0.14368347823619843,
-0.6243954300880432,
0.7022426724433899,
0.045745737850666046,
0.48356327414512634,
0.4364829361438751,
0.04925595596432686,
0.4852537512779236,
-0.9327940940856934,
0.5205810070037842,
0.3037619888782501,
-0.6104304790496826,
0.6547313332557678,
-0.26477813720703125,
-0.08427412062883377,
0.43192151188850403,
0.34714579582214355,
-0.528352677822113,
-0.40622636675834656,
-0.6167846322059631,
-0.8461126089096069,
0.2623322010040283,
0.19200119376182556,
0.3242504894733429,
0.13019317388534546,
0.4643952548503876,
0.23782320320606232,
-0.0335177406668663,
-0.72878497838974,
0.16454511880874634,
-0.04044276475906372,
-0.10135866701602936,
0.0003648033016361296,
-0.30348101258277893,
0.01279799547046423,
-0.41101959347724915,
0.551807701587677,
-0.06437591463327408,
0.18024815618991852,
0.15184922516345978,
-0.25899264216423035,
-0.0363411046564579,
0.5959985256195068,
0.7063358426094055,
0.8043084740638733,
-0.3512676954269409,
-0.30810871720314026,
0.25230321288108826,
-0.458498477935791,
0.10141441226005554,
0.08409998565912247,
-0.08541826903820038,
0.3910301625728607,
0.3688221871852875,
0.9482031464576721,
-0.06851758807897568,
-0.6051357984542847,
0.6455457210540771,
-0.339659184217453,
-0.30391940474510193,
-0.9814746975898743,
-0.15959489345550537,
-0.08505608141422272,
0.4786420464515686,
0.25203362107276917,
0.20677118003368378,
0.49355417490005493,
-0.3782872259616852,
0.26954153180122375,
0.06158018857240677,
-0.2836697995662689,
-0.051302872598171234,
0.6634535789489746,
0.2804071605205536,
-0.3671090006828308,
0.6260561347007751,
-0.011794201098382473,
-0.4855908155441284,
0.7711232900619507,
0.3621510863304138,
0.9344001412391663,
0.03910049423575401,
-0.050084423273801804,
0.32601165771484375,
-0.018053296953439713,
-0.5080693364143372,
-0.029556527733802795,
0.11347881704568863,
-0.6324878931045532,
-0.62800532579422,
-0.8001779913902283,
-0.25748908519744873,
0.043783023953437805,
-0.9295653700828552,
0.569310188293457,
-0.45849841833114624,
-0.5595666766166687,
-0.12406110763549805,
0.13020282983779907,
-0.9637216329574585,
0.31993040442466736,
0.25851428508758545,
1.0411070585250854,
-0.5645877122879028,
0.9984094500541687,
0.1700713187456131,
-0.16754481196403503,
-0.021313883364200592,
-0.22185327112674713,
-0.47959235310554504,
-0.3242915868759155,
0.8589534163475037,
0.40798419713974,
-0.043599482625722885,
-0.4672890305519104,
-0.2950722575187683,
-0.4092244505882263,
0.840976357460022,
0.35767024755477905,
-1.3346314430236816,
-0.404857873916626,
0.39876118302345276,
0.9745317101478577,
-0.3971361517906189,
0.12268815189599991,
0.916664183139801,
0.5035120844841003,
-0.07147830724716187,
-0.7685995697975159,
-0.12461934983730316,
-0.25964710116386414,
-0.10790989547967911,
0.29211926460266113,
-0.06657012552022934,
0.24594786763191223,
-0.152119979262352,
0.06417147070169449,
-0.03325009346008301,
1.0551996231079102,
0.04929424077272415,
0.21506528556346893,
0.5057734847068787,
0.6737619042396545,
0.9347338676452637,
-0.03203589841723442,
1.2391844987869263,
-0.5152241587638855,
0.24636393785476685,
1.375184416770935,
-0.23361428081989288,
1.0721794366836548,
0.46669667959213257,
-0.09691737592220306,
0.7331697940826416,
0.5528436303138733,
-0.6043891906738281,
0.2749921381473541,
0.4066343605518341,
-0.12478990107774734,
-0.4049132168292999,
0.09822352230548859,
-0.17301924526691437,
0.6225073933601379,
0.335565984249115,
-0.9150242805480957,
0.21322230994701385,
-0.04277878627181053,
-0.062170542776584625,
0.14439715445041656,
-0.3606552183628082,
0.7224435210227966,
-0.007173503749072552,
-0.7803657054901123,
0.18707095086574554,
0.5096986889839172,
0.960926353931427,
-0.3193179666996002,
0.021447043865919113,
-0.05129565671086311,
0.2729836404323578,
-0.24082887172698975,
-1.0159026384353638,
0.36406540870666504,
0.11901512742042542,
-0.36391353607177734,
-0.26465678215026855,
0.731991171836853,
-0.22119759023189545,
-0.8199073672294617,
0.7636165022850037,
0.1694970726966858,
0.1977986842393875,
-0.22876174747943878,
-0.6337123513221741,
-0.5326098203659058,
-0.2127179354429245,
-0.44773510098457336,
0.34021082520484924,
0.4600406587123871,
-0.25263479351997375,
0.6177160739898682,
0.3855321705341339,
0.1549503654241562,
0.13989859819412231,
0.44493579864501953,
0.7907183170318604,
-0.7633007168769836,
-0.6275277733802795,
-0.9219542741775513,
0.5119795799255371,
-0.07111043483018875,
-0.1718727946281433,
0.26394253969192505,
0.7825425267219543,
0.7643271088600159,
-0.18804669380187988,
0.7055718898773193,
0.08851969987154007,
0.3080716133117676,
-0.7597655653953552,
0.6562304496765137,
-0.14096352458000183,
0.08124056458473206,
0.11845343559980392,
-0.8879289031028748,
-0.5495182275772095,
0.42712533473968506,
-0.3645358085632324,
-0.13398155570030212,
0.4846562445163727,
0.3730680048465729,
-0.14010567963123322,
-0.06326071918010712,
0.561860203742981,
0.0453428253531456,
0.4541586637496948,
0.5149227976799011,
0.4635111689567566,
-0.3206481337547302,
0.5061872005462646,
-0.11747842282056808,
0.19558507204055786,
-0.38768118619918823,
-0.8631328344345093,
-0.8792579174041748,
-0.4232271611690521,
-0.04358602315187454,
-0.43170127272605896,
0.12301097065210342,
0.8904707431793213,
0.428811639547348,
-0.9202905297279358,
-0.23546625673770905,
-0.21916693449020386,
-0.147875115275383,
0.15685468912124634,
-0.1676952838897705,
0.3432181775569916,
-0.23595567047595978,
-0.7118990421295166,
0.29546838998794556,
-0.010203712619841099,
0.025122782215476036,
0.045529577881097794,
-0.3331749439239502,
0.0051204729825258255,
0.01897243969142437,
0.750481903553009,
0.0463828444480896,
-0.8460489511489868,
-0.27308720350265503,
-0.42580848932266235,
0.09522352367639542,
0.4564818739891052,
1.0872801542282104,
-0.961544394493103,
0.34305229783058167,
0.6029201745986938,
0.31370219588279724,
0.7346981167793274,
-0.017877105623483658,
0.972542941570282,
-0.5410287976264954,
0.19616229832172394,
0.6582512855529785,
1.0786006450653076,
0.23155193030834198,
-0.3908163607120514,
0.7458159327507019,
-0.07692817598581314,
-0.6081496477127075,
-0.43481332063674927,
0.17647476494312286,
-0.8600917458534241,
-0.35732656717300415,
1.0968821048736572,
-0.41269704699516296,
-0.20837435126304626,
-0.10579074919223785,
-0.15152429044246674,
0.3247523009777069,
-0.5014963150024414,
0.7294818758964539,
0.5807861685752869,
0.1727510243654251,
-0.03390428423881531,
-0.7982441782951355,
0.43573445081710815,
0.30531972646713257,
-0.656289279460907,
0.027337007224559784,
0.5780024528503418,
0.3263702690601349,
0.3552456796169281,
0.2925466001033783,
-0.08790244162082672,
0.3095003366470337,
-0.3498665988445282,
0.08494914323091507,
0.04428575932979584,
-0.5108367204666138,
-0.7795722484588623,
0.26047247648239136,
-0.13647033274173737,
0.17125385999679565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19167v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19167v2
|
Teaching Large Language Models an Unseen Language on the Fly
| 2024-02-29T13:50:47 | 2024-06-13T04:58:21 |
Chen Zhang, Xiao Liu, Jiuheng Lin, Yansong Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing large language models struggle to support numerous low-resource
languages, particularly the extremely low-resource ones, for which there is
minimal training data available for effective parameter updating. We thus
investigate whether LLMs can learn a new language on the fly solely through
prompting. To study this question, we collect a research suite for Zhuang, a
language supported by no LLMs currently. We introduce DiPMT++, a framework for
adapting LLMs to unseen languages by in-context learning. Using a dictionary
and 5K parallel sentences only, DiPMT++ significantly enhances the performance
of GPT-4 from 0 to 16 BLEU for Chinese-to-Zhuang translation and achieves 32
BLEU for Zhuang-to-Chinese translation. We also validate the effectiveness of
our framework on Kalamang, another unseen language. Furthermore, we demonstrate
the practical utility of DiPMT++ in aiding humans in translating completely
unseen languages, which could contribute to the preservation of linguistic
diversity.
|
[
-0.0608363002538681,
-0.66094571352005,
0.45687368512153625,
0.3546799421310425,
-0.3301956057548523,
0.4544442594051361,
-0.6090539693832397,
-0.43594324588775635,
-0.12164624780416489,
0.2964654266834259,
-0.56491619348526,
-0.22167633473873138,
-0.43270981311798096,
0.23400257527828217,
-0.24209003150463104,
0.7649316191673279,
0.08973459899425507,
0.16226698458194733,
0.21428827941417694,
0.0765252411365509,
-0.3132767379283905,
-0.3015730082988739,
-0.42972224950790405,
-0.2918626666069031,
0.6155489683151245,
0.7647961974143982,
0.6297500133514404,
0.600963830947876,
0.15152037143707275,
0.21469569206237793,
-0.13832731544971466,
0.429866760969162,
-0.5614199042320251,
-0.34111320972442627,
-0.017580686137080193,
-0.6780226826667786,
-0.32506388425827026,
-0.06526347249746323,
0.9389052391052246,
1.0153777599334717,
0.03930916637182236,
-0.21690921485424042,
0.22901888191699982,
0.6921408176422119,
-0.43590056896209717,
-0.06803306192159653,
-0.7873479723930359,
0.14691820740699768,
-0.1482839733362198,
-0.349829763174057,
-0.4354000985622406,
-0.36568257212638855,
0.1960056871175766,
-0.6153658628463745,
-0.15078087151050568,
-0.2998870015144348,
0.7726051211357117,
0.01497083529829979,
-0.7148258090019226,
-0.1439885050058365,
-0.6068486571311951,
0.714156985282898,
-0.5292428135871887,
0.3328649401664734,
0.20210030674934387,
0.1524999588727951,
-0.3775881826877594,
-0.4408092796802521,
-0.432738333940506,
-0.7758364677429199,
0.011741788126528263,
0.2178945541381836,
0.15558132529258728,
0.1342260092496872,
0.13275137543678284,
0.3271847367286682,
-0.3079223930835724,
0.25609928369522095,
-0.1847037374973297,
0.15412059426307678,
0.28075096011161804,
-0.06315281987190247,
0.345862478017807,
-0.11449312418699265,
-0.5861120820045471,
-0.07985758781433105,
-0.9149062633514404,
0.014967179857194424,
0.08565539866685867,
0.5828654170036316,
-0.4404065012931824,
0.36644113063812256,
-0.03996973857283592,
0.829799234867096,
0.07450339943170547,
0.07140737026929855,
0.2221234291791916,
-0.02156628482043743,
-0.32651665806770325,
-0.23666037619113922,
0.5230517387390137,
-0.14072293043136597,
0.20434440672397614,
-0.2599608600139618,
-0.18612366914749146,
-0.4956658184528351,
-0.1277892142534256,
-0.7380619645118713,
-0.11265110969543457,
-0.049518607556819916,
-0.07287966459989548,
-0.2464776188135147,
-0.07726414501667023,
-0.2716251313686371,
-0.6406262516975403,
-0.08313669264316559,
0.5091738700866699,
-0.6468828916549683,
-0.5001509785652161,
0.1146184504032135,
0.03136684000492096,
0.5982275605201721,
0.6020002961158752,
-0.8075572848320007,
0.014438917860388756,
0.5446330308914185,
1.0246132612228394,
-0.17207658290863037,
-0.8670502305030823,
-0.7793645858764648,
0.31384971737861633,
-0.778042197227478,
0.6809872388839722,
-0.5451831817626953,
-0.6117103099822998,
0.0036004758439958096,
-0.030497392639517784,
-0.1286161243915558,
-0.6095533967018127,
0.3813159763813019,
-0.29858049750328064,
0.10213220864534378,
-0.4733492136001587,
-0.5434145331382751,
-0.2786867618560791,
0.277349591255188,
-0.32764559984207153,
0.6773635745048523,
0.40630045533180237,
-0.6108036041259766,
0.3038899004459381,
-0.8532276749610901,
-0.48950061202049255,
0.4853840172290802,
-0.321550577878952,
-0.09542736411094666,
0.3797141909599304,
0.08325670659542084,
0.4208514988422394,
-0.06476138532161713,
0.25532087683677673,
-0.13578222692012787,
-0.5128765106201172,
0.35625872015953064,
-0.7733603119850159,
0.9871410727500916,
-0.017349369823932648,
-0.2821218967437744,
0.028978556394577026,
-0.6304274201393127,
-0.002573576522991061,
0.0980401262640953,
-0.9602435231208801,
-0.05126069486141205,
-0.18435661494731903,
0.052524831146001816,
0.09848663210868835,
0.26637208461761475,
-0.3974476754665375,
0.594219982624054,
-0.5435189008712769,
0.24712148308753967,
0.8370879888534546,
-0.33232149481773376,
0.46752142906188965,
-0.2617619037628174,
0.6144617199897766,
0.18286846578121185,
-0.21587002277374268,
-0.26607847213745117,
-0.36152487993240356,
-0.9614517688751221,
-0.30595216155052185,
0.1599808633327484,
0.40841037034988403,
-0.8941236734390259,
-0.002395860617980361,
-0.30765390396118164,
-0.2316369116306305,
-0.4498218595981598,
0.3006645739078522,
0.23630391061306,
0.3965451717376709,
0.14493930339813232,
0.061427246779203415,
-0.435690313577652,
-0.5600705742835999,
-0.2718631625175476,
-0.15709714591503143,
-0.2640272378921509,
0.3050914406776428,
-0.009726111777126789,
-0.3929961025714874,
0.588096559047699,
-0.10523451119661331,
0.07727021723985672,
-0.5371615886688232,
-0.02188877947628498,
0.3120874762535095,
0.3517935574054718,
0.43886563181877136,
-0.6007951498031616,
-0.6012086868286133,
0.594237208366394,
-0.6334102749824524,
-0.042185455560684204,
-0.22870667278766632,
-0.07491280138492584,
0.2577819526195526,
0.5057029724121094,
-0.6255040168762207,
-0.165461465716362,
0.7571030855178833,
-0.27451062202453613,
0.45628201961517334,
-0.5526824593544006,
-0.18635670840740204,
-1.1139755249023438,
0.008786953054368496,
-0.3707635998725891,
-0.37099263072013855,
-0.735244870185852,
0.18327948451042175,
0.3765428066253662,
-0.1376151740550995,
-0.7658349275588989,
0.7942203283309937,
-0.7706307172775269,
0.10400582104921341,
-0.6622583866119385,
0.17197073996067047,
-0.24439166486263275,
0.47480785846710205,
0.261866956949234,
0.7971545457839966,
0.8887635469436646,
-0.7952539324760437,
0.14621587097644806,
0.1361970603466034,
-0.30559229850769043,
0.2647901475429535,
-0.19446076452732086,
0.05657077580690384,
-0.04855402186512947,
0.10105529427528381,
-0.5351412296295166,
-0.5376040935516357,
0.3068317174911499,
-0.47948649525642395,
0.5282769203186035,
-0.2696273624897003,
-0.22944414615631104,
-0.0934797152876854,
-0.26582634449005127,
0.12873290479183197,
0.45957309007644653,
-0.7621989846229553,
0.3816696107387543,
0.10645953565835953,
0.2243628352880478,
-0.5548617839813232,
-0.7207058072090149,
0.2756073474884033,
-0.17133228480815887,
-0.05867438390851021,
-0.16800400614738464,
-0.24370726943016052,
-0.024039417505264282,
-0.27694764733314514,
-0.05332639813423157,
-0.17703795433044434,
0.42440640926361084,
0.1303284913301468,
0.10685505717992783,
-0.2325722873210907,
0.20285506546497345,
-0.029637396335601807,
-0.08489084988832474,
-0.13021793961524963,
-0.5040832161903381,
0.4777684509754181,
-0.4214574098587036,
-0.2992989420890808,
-0.1917673647403717,
0.03313204646110535,
0.5531358122825623,
-0.04505699500441551,
0.5441983342170715,
0.6793730854988098,
-0.2620825171470642,
-0.45710283517837524,
-0.008913591504096985,
0.04514184221625328,
-0.6202092170715332,
0.5088992714881897,
-0.4052795171737671,
-1.0476477146148682,
0.2841710150241852,
-0.38291671872138977,
0.06336213648319244,
0.01322861947119236,
0.7613672018051147,
0.06683526188135147,
0.551815927028656,
1.0065096616744995,
-0.24122627079486847,
0.6535220742225647,
-0.12228080630302429,
-0.10632142424583435,
-0.631544828414917,
-0.08973950892686844,
-0.0857345312833786,
-0.10376553237438202,
-0.8123593926429749,
-0.6066781878471375,
0.4507339596748352,
0.36666977405548096,
-0.0699564591050148,
0.40199825167655945,
-0.2449391633272171,
0.7525702714920044,
0.567308783531189,
0.14190654456615448,
0.3615072965621948,
-0.028806816786527634,
-0.22750791907310486,
0.4038083851337433,
-0.858674168586731,
-0.2502000629901886,
0.9774798154830933,
0.13381901383399963,
0.6039499044418335,
0.029688723385334015,
0.6967145800590515,
0.002758881077170372,
0.43416330218315125,
-0.9258357286453247,
0.6709244847297668,
-0.02003897726535797,
-0.5269408226013184,
-0.461357057094574,
-0.5070431232452393,
-1.0246661901474,
0.5032987594604492,
0.10018523782491684,
-0.5364798903465271,
-0.01831469126045704,
0.054914433509111404,
-0.24641045928001404,
0.4433816373348236,
-0.8317455649375916,
0.5528383255004883,
-0.6692093014717102,
-0.2874738574028015,
-0.06441144645214081,
-0.5019960999488831,
0.442900687456131,
-0.3900870978832245,
0.15288248658180237,
-0.2499460130929947,
-0.4672570824623108,
0.31458601355552673,
-0.070425845682621,
0.884856104850769,
-0.15725195407867432,
-0.5134146213531494,
0.13419021666049957,
0.40652593970298767,
0.5060401558876038,
0.18740767240524292,
-0.062001604586839676,
0.11789041012525558,
-0.259103000164032,
-0.6251229047775269,
-0.38673537969589233,
0.8002296090126038,
-0.8161211609840393,
-0.8075188994407654,
-0.3249236047267914,
-0.843237042427063,
-0.3220365643501282,
0.4894189238548279,
0.08257561922073364,
-0.03572537750005722,
-0.01128689106553793,
0.14311759173870087,
0.47691866755485535,
-0.5269064903259277,
0.6401873826980591,
0.9591735601425171,
-0.36375662684440613,
-0.20539630949497223,
0.937836766242981,
0.04454153776168823,
0.3493022620677948,
0.7755830883979797,
0.6413506865501404,
-0.023928308859467506,
-0.4924141466617584,
-0.6895954012870789,
0.271507203578949,
-0.610909104347229,
-0.060694970190525055,
-0.5009149312973022,
-0.13730427622795105,
0.16143369674682617,
-0.3101360499858856,
-0.3940551280975342,
-0.29399311542510986,
-0.3177277743816376,
-0.15198315680027008,
0.44347190856933594,
0.5611233711242676,
-0.4110558032989502,
0.3362809419631958,
-0.8580775260925293,
0.18946483731269836,
0.33534377813339233,
0.33842405676841736,
0.007739195600152016,
-0.7130223512649536,
-0.4634634554386139,
0.28527241945266724,
-0.18008765578269958,
-0.5284278988838196,
0.24691058695316315,
0.4090597927570343,
0.4094558656215668,
0.6024225354194641,
0.07635608315467834,
0.743554413318634,
-0.6035537123680115,
0.7241899967193604,
-0.0042282347567379475,
-1.0395615100860596,
0.3865963816642761,
-0.8867365717887878,
0.5892652869224548,
0.27385756373405457,
0.40765270590782166,
-0.7778070569038391,
-0.44248485565185547,
-0.25562331080436707,
-0.41407597064971924,
0.9057543873786926,
-0.09929275512695312,
0.610460638999939,
-0.052918463945388794,
0.21891768276691437,
0.20952045917510986,
0.2479202151298523,
-1.1082134246826172,
0.0011539880651980639,
-0.04536280408501625,
0.32419684529304504,
-0.1366003304719925,
-0.0534123033285141,
0.049710895866155624,
-0.3412184715270996,
0.3093564808368683,
-0.29066431522369385,
0.2592102587223053,
-0.11515660583972931,
-0.13255970180034637,
-0.3905581533908844,
0.19603107869625092,
0.5181676149368286,
0.7619217038154602,
-0.18753667175769806,
0.22679798305034637,
0.4214271306991577,
-0.37467160820961,
0.20482952892780304,
-0.17579147219657898,
-0.18556451797485352,
0.06708753108978271,
0.46939507126808167,
0.6191189885139465,
0.32713639736175537,
-0.8368393778800964,
0.5659106373786926,
0.26429566740989685,
-0.14685003459453583,
-0.06833408772945404,
0.19622808694839478,
0.38030973076820374,
0.22503197193145752,
0.3989172577857971,
-0.21012145280838013,
-0.21952106058597565,
-0.48083382844924927,
0.10454145818948746,
0.5449345707893372,
-0.27254748344421387,
-0.45256489515304565,
0.6356223821640015,
0.18716850876808167,
-0.23539568483829498,
0.3881862163543701,
-0.15927442908287048,
-0.4016473591327667,
0.2639453411102295,
0.6398921608924866,
0.8920331597328186,
-0.3390063941478729,
0.4698357880115509,
0.01928616687655449,
0.38751041889190674,
-0.03379445895552635,
0.1644873321056366,
-0.33951982855796814,
-0.7077844738960266,
-0.4327770471572876,
-0.5039659142494202,
-0.8166808485984802,
0.4972262382507324,
-0.18949970602989197,
0.4648832082748413,
-0.37854573130607605,
0.4099971055984497,
-0.3237224519252777,
0.017656873911619186,
-0.38618752360343933,
-0.0897301584482193,
0.32905951142311096,
0.8577589392662048,
-0.6147733330726624,
1.211874008178711,
0.7569847702980042,
-0.26588594913482666,
-0.8437265753746033,
0.28011149168014526,
-0.24597302079200745,
-0.9737762212753296,
0.4386257827281952,
0.16716468334197998,
-0.3076271712779999,
0.23759356141090393,
-0.7061589360237122,
-0.8033071160316467,
0.7633534073829651,
0.8699004650115967,
-0.359996497631073,
0.015674997121095657,
0.2754404842853546,
0.5073436498641968,
0.14328116178512573,
0.17263075709342957,
0.23914243280887604,
0.3329063951969147,
0.1692507416009903,
-0.9992488622665405,
-0.08370191603899002,
0.01077563501894474,
-0.10648062080144882,
0.03664558008313179,
-0.9063060879707336,
0.986977219581604,
-0.3681809604167938,
-0.45050325989723206,
0.016820132732391357,
0.45855826139450073,
0.17817746102809906,
-0.05743464082479477,
0.08560191094875336,
0.007272727321833372,
0.792299747467041,
0.23265381157398224,
0.8976655602455139,
-0.17815347015857697,
0.2660827934741974,
1.019794225692749,
-0.3071873188018799,
0.8716333508491516,
0.486724853515625,
-0.17533262073993683,
0.25319594144821167,
0.6014033555984497,
0.17084099352359772,
0.40242135524749756,
0.18590611219406128,
-0.5282882452011108,
-0.3479752242565155,
-0.04154409468173981,
-0.37630948424339294,
0.44571051001548767,
0.2721913754940033,
0.07876288145780563,
-0.6224961876869202,
0.309237539768219,
0.13912101089954376,
-0.05112864449620247,
-0.410268634557724,
0.5326600670814514,
0.29729536175727844,
-0.36620938777923584,
1.2337703704833984,
0.06290382891893387,
0.799508810043335,
-0.6559447050094604,
0.07091411203145981,
-0.6530303955078125,
0.30206745862960815,
-0.09981738775968552,
-0.5305567979812622,
-0.03458911553025246,
0.05429382249712944,
0.22983963787555695,
-0.22165484726428986,
0.5238198637962341,
-0.5389693379402161,
-0.6232978701591492,
0.36291244626045227,
0.9350517392158508,
0.17535491287708282,
0.09781096130609512,
-0.4159393012523651,
-0.2753661274909973,
0.0190615002065897,
-0.31144624948501587,
0.5488993525505066,
0.8630918264389038,
0.10515673458576202,
1.1529791355133057,
0.5303781628608704,
0.2341184765100479,
0.1924804151058197,
-0.15184348821640015,
1.0844284296035767,
-0.6941156387329102,
-0.5125094652175903,
-0.8954848051071167,
0.18209998309612274,
0.4336475133895874,
0.05973554775118828,
1.1188069581985474,
0.49474409222602844,
1.230096697807312,
-0.4261227548122406,
0.9851263165473938,
0.10648681223392487,
0.4499152898788452,
-0.4612904489040375,
0.8418141007423401,
-0.6945475935935974,
0.2427382916212082,
-0.18218457698822021,
-0.7165676951408386,
-0.3661888539791107,
0.4360330402851105,
-0.1630217581987381,
-0.07762788236141205,
0.5447700023651123,
0.6667785048484802,
-0.16272825002670288,
-0.37878283858299255,
0.7805007696151733,
0.2448878288269043,
0.2930935025215149,
0.8209021091461182,
1.1530972719192505,
-0.06975232809782028,
0.5494681000709534,
0.19131450355052948,
-0.1714346706867218,
-0.2742098867893219,
-0.901281476020813,
-1.042380690574646,
-0.3520718812942505,
-0.11287888139486313,
-0.11995229870080948,
-0.04535258188843727,
1.1035329103469849,
0.5111857056617737,
-0.619352400302887,
-0.6964777708053589,
-0.48709940910339355,
0.27060288190841675,
-0.2384488731622696,
-0.12249084562063217,
0.30855593085289,
-0.4927714467048645,
-0.868821382522583,
0.859090268611908,
0.35125187039375305,
0.292033851146698,
-0.20659004151821136,
-0.367899626493454,
-0.12517742812633514,
0.031475797295570374,
0.6184486150741577,
0.5153079628944397,
-0.6163039207458496,
-0.2162812352180481,
-0.005799575243145227,
-0.047413330525159836,
0.2951861321926117,
0.7760271430015564,
-0.7618919610977173,
0.40082889795303345,
0.1860312521457672,
0.909654974937439,
0.24671855568885803,
-0.1871330589056015,
0.5881274342536926,
-0.8727246522903442,
0.4540735185146332,
0.06888139992952347,
0.046351511031389236,
0.32919514179229736,
-0.23922401666641235,
0.2686527967453003,
0.23196949064731598,
-0.22637365758419037,
-0.8963455557823181,
0.2882872521877289,
-0.8105345368385315,
-0.38197943568229675,
1.4869585037231445,
-0.08476104587316513,
-0.2024569809436798,
0.12886294722557068,
-0.3453400135040283,
0.28310585021972656,
-0.15555988252162933,
0.7369471788406372,
0.4956277906894684,
0.0007950172876007855,
-0.4193325340747833,
-0.4844001829624176,
0.6168712973594666,
0.22673125565052032,
-0.7833609580993652,
0.39549019932746887,
0.310113787651062,
0.36252060532569885,
-0.3732025921344757,
0.6760909557342529,
0.14441530406475067,
0.3146299719810486,
-0.06554792076349258,
-0.2228129357099533,
-0.26943808794021606,
-0.18333657085895538,
-0.6204357743263245,
-0.1928955316543579,
0.5053284168243408,
-0.39067503809928894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00843v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00843v2
|
Large Language Models are Learnable Planners for Long-Term Recommendation
| 2024-02-29T13:49:56 | 2024-04-26T07:41:07 |
Wentao Shi, Xiangnan He, Yang Zhang, Chongming Gao, Xinyue Li, Jizhi Zhang, Qifan Wang, Fuli Feng
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Planning for both immediate and long-term benefits becomes increasingly
important in recommendation. Existing methods apply Reinforcement Learning (RL)
to learn planning capacity by maximizing cumulative reward for long-term
recommendation. However, the scarcity of recommendation data presents
challenges such as instability and susceptibility to overfitting when training
RL models from scratch, resulting in sub-optimal performance. In this light, we
propose to leverage the remarkable planning capabilities over sparse data of
Large Language Models (LLMs) for long-term recommendation. The key to achieving
the target lies in formulating a guidance plan following principles of
enhancing long-term engagement and grounding the plan to effective and
executable actions in a personalized manner. To this end, we propose a Bi-level
Learnable LLM Planner framework, which consists of a set of LLM instances and
breaks down the learning process into macro-learning and micro-learning to
learn macro-level guidance and micro-level personalized recommendation
policies, respectively. Extensive experiments validate that the framework
facilitates the planning ability of LLMs for long-term recommendation. Our code
and data can be found at https://github.com/jizhi-zhang/BiLLP.
|
[
-0.2288912683725357,
-0.738859236240387,
0.5683725476264954,
0.4933704137802124,
0.036729224026203156,
-0.1234024316072464,
-0.46613451838493347,
-0.18800343573093414,
0.37547534704208374,
0.6477042436599731,
-0.9946243762969971,
-0.5054683685302734,
-0.07085482776165009,
-0.26061493158340454,
0.0871119499206543,
1.1159048080444336,
0.09756676107645035,
-0.07224485278129578,
0.13752837479114532,
0.0598037987947464,
-0.9228339791297913,
-0.24430325627326965,
-1.145843267440796,
-0.4937640428543091,
1.1435658931732178,
0.6774286031723022,
0.48631808161735535,
0.5073122382164001,
-0.11665257811546326,
0.22749385237693787,
-0.24451102316379547,
0.41587725281715393,
-0.7189185619354248,
0.19756031036376953,
-0.5344313383102417,
-0.05430776998400688,
-0.6779749393463135,
-0.4657541513442993,
0.562501072883606,
0.7811561822891235,
-0.5110352635383606,
-0.05198235809803009,
0.1359427273273468,
0.8457884192466736,
-0.324571818113327,
0.6493963599205017,
-0.6305729746818542,
0.0410677045583725,
0.22360654175281525,
-0.12526743113994598,
-0.5350878238677979,
-0.16494347155094147,
0.30053791403770447,
-0.5006877779960632,
-0.2659924030303955,
0.2156648337841034,
0.2233421802520752,
0.01186333131045103,
-0.2620028257369995,
-0.47471389174461365,
-1.1653878688812256,
0.7195254564285278,
-0.46453455090522766,
0.28870412707328796,
0.6278783679008484,
0.5933212041854858,
-0.4336183965206146,
-0.2961581349372864,
0.07674232870340347,
-0.4075036346912384,
0.1945577710866928,
-0.19926835596561432,
0.06958429515361786,
0.1289650946855545,
0.34763795137405396,
0.0690811276435852,
-0.5359307527542114,
0.3669712543487549,
-0.19184786081314087,
0.020580926910042763,
0.4907437860965729,
0.2206704467535019,
-0.06823822110891342,
0.1598106026649475,
-0.3349629044532776,
0.12695766985416412,
-0.7658310532569885,
0.12960579991340637,
0.2620753049850464,
0.5635388493537903,
-0.12887732684612274,
0.5354437232017517,
-0.3272547721862793,
0.36215949058532715,
0.053720273077487946,
-0.22864945232868195,
-0.14208126068115234,
-0.20757919549942017,
-0.13652156293392181,
-0.05685313791036606,
0.5190684199333191,
0.09344778954982758,
0.6459563970565796,
-0.3542424440383911,
-0.3103736340999603,
-0.5647100806236267,
0.14133064448833466,
-0.8067063689231873,
-0.17396800220012665,
0.04496557265520096,
-0.1521330624818802,
0.02885211445391178,
-0.3538638651371002,
-0.8231484293937683,
-0.506815493106842,
-0.32027700543403625,
0.2986776530742645,
-0.6201295852661133,
-0.08788203448057175,
0.4601094424724579,
0.3270449638366699,
-0.1503860354423523,
0.2708437740802765,
-1.187865138053894,
0.07431500405073166,
0.5285022854804993,
0.5833598971366882,
0.20639708638191223,
-0.48122814297676086,
-0.6909980773925781,
0.5684986114501953,
-0.27524253726005554,
0.7102770209312439,
-0.5095705986022949,
-0.7465879917144775,
0.4708264172077179,
-0.01527052279561758,
0.16584797203540802,
-0.5113191604614258,
0.5424123406410217,
-0.3574196398258209,
-0.03507294878363609,
-0.21900703012943268,
-0.28110504150390625,
-0.15204448997974396,
0.3407641053199768,
-0.5094518065452576,
0.7239396572113037,
0.23644627630710602,
-0.12706106901168823,
0.7181795835494995,
-0.6533738970756531,
-0.5199107527732849,
0.14322103559970856,
-0.07680574804544449,
-0.44718968868255615,
-0.3913547992706299,
0.4233659505844116,
0.8098673820495605,
-0.17197199165821075,
0.7173720598220825,
-0.5477941036224365,
-0.158560648560524,
-0.13745112717151642,
-0.2609204053878784,
0.10712986439466476,
-0.07936856895685196,
-0.1821547895669937,
0.5960000157356262,
-0.9353511333465576,
-0.15874598920345306,
0.0485137440264225,
-0.7643870711326599,
-0.25950145721435547,
0.39486730098724365,
-0.044503334909677505,
0.15714234113693237,
0.2808220684528351,
-0.1766832172870636,
0.6408433318138123,
-0.6824052929878235,
0.547888457775116,
0.8976095914840698,
0.0183670986443758,
0.6481027007102966,
-0.3034432828426361,
0.4362638592720032,
-0.2418433427810669,
-0.0033604453783482313,
-0.17278613150119781,
-0.09229404479265213,
-0.7402682304382324,
-0.11131588369607925,
-0.0644136294722557,
0.2913134694099426,
-0.8307933211326599,
0.7348026633262634,
-0.2765483260154724,
-0.2818952202796936,
0.10476727038621902,
0.3899473249912262,
0.36980167031288147,
0.02126331441104412,
0.532198965549469,
0.3005877137184143,
-0.5961152911186218,
-0.7066084742546082,
-0.12890630960464478,
-0.04556776583194733,
0.19415470957756042,
0.43469616770744324,
0.43363499641418457,
-0.5757400393486023,
0.729025661945343,
-0.548798143863678,
-0.5157754421234131,
-0.7634174227714539,
-0.0034666103310883045,
0.34044161438941956,
0.16696222126483917,
0.35549280047416687,
-0.32515597343444824,
-0.4258130192756653,
-0.04102921485900879,
-0.3047158122062683,
0.1591712087392807,
-0.3380226492881775,
-0.24377793073654175,
-0.05892040953040123,
0.43886598944664,
-0.4083278477191925,
0.11620289087295532,
0.2944639325141907,
-0.6117774844169617,
0.4194837510585785,
-0.5922719240188599,
-0.5469724535942078,
-1.059675693511963,
-0.2617323398590088,
0.3311939239501953,
-0.4416678845882416,
-0.25487086176872253,
-0.2485179752111435,
0.04705696925520897,
-0.19341924786567688,
0.026496712118387222,
0.7154881954193115,
-0.19058449566364288,
-0.016721734777092934,
-0.32937437295913696,
-0.2264566719532013,
-0.4122677743434906,
0.9860621094703674,
0.08110728114843369,
0.5966558456420898,
0.24280071258544922,
-0.6053816080093384,
0.28132501244544983,
0.2035568356513977,
-0.4966318905353546,
0.4185962677001953,
-0.6046121120452881,
-0.16030754148960114,
0.04940708354115486,
0.5108690857887268,
-0.6161985397338867,
-0.09970293939113617,
0.16405582427978516,
0.14985297620296478,
0.3657665252685547,
-0.3777080476284027,
-0.2758809030056,
-0.1621917188167572,
-0.1645296961069107,
0.127666637301445,
0.1577768623828888,
-0.7695916295051575,
0.7180078029632568,
0.3593693971633911,
-0.46696481108665466,
-0.5177879333496094,
-0.13031987845897675,
-0.04648689180612564,
-0.06957750767469406,
-0.2567654550075531,
0.17049017548561096,
-0.24859420955181122,
0.14184258878231049,
-0.12503400444984436,
0.21658410131931305,
0.30381542444229126,
-0.30722808837890625,
0.811354398727417,
0.2714417576789856,
0.12749548256397247,
0.14659015834331512,
-0.1350405514240265,
-0.44108715653419495,
0.16131694614887238,
-0.4154197573661804,
0.8814951777458191,
-0.03429868817329407,
-0.12143774330615997,
-0.09152905642986298,
0.15409408509731293,
0.452880859375,
-0.17581364512443542,
0.6354913711547852,
0.7370901703834534,
-0.10400281846523285,
-0.6965644359588623,
-0.5046539306640625,
0.14140723645687103,
-0.47360673546791077,
0.6541988253593445,
-0.35295483469963074,
-0.9966475963592529,
0.09676864743232727,
-0.24315974116325378,
0.3699977993965149,
0.14096513390541077,
0.6156054735183716,
0.1639571487903595,
1.057856798171997,
0.9275217056274414,
-0.48359763622283936,
0.6120539903640747,
-0.5809658765792847,
0.047454558312892914,
-0.712206244468689,
-0.48844024538993835,
-0.2339543104171753,
-0.25590962171554565,
-0.20467984676361084,
-0.44743263721466064,
0.2590787410736084,
-0.02616824395954609,
-0.5091155171394348,
0.145483136177063,
-0.17531757056713104,
0.39061471819877625,
0.42773672938346863,
0.021703090518712997,
-0.08838973939418793,
-0.006745248567312956,
-0.19541002810001373,
0.133241206407547,
-0.6346157789230347,
-0.16422933340072632,
0.8020212054252625,
0.5883647799491882,
0.9597353935241699,
-0.046172477304935455,
0.5236789584159851,
0.21953263878822327,
-0.12893551588058472,
-0.9161451458930969,
0.6601529717445374,
-0.10156850516796112,
-0.14188432693481445,
-0.6178173422813416,
-0.4757000803947449,
-0.97183758020401,
-0.15038268268108368,
-0.5991954207420349,
-0.6703945398330688,
0.24677948653697968,
0.1313508301973343,
-0.36620357632637024,
0.35076868534088135,
-0.3907468914985657,
0.6119682192802429,
-0.4174000918865204,
-0.6180815696716309,
-0.6298015117645264,
-0.20230525732040405,
0.047704290598630905,
-0.21044224500656128,
0.28444159030914307,
-0.16572734713554382,
-0.008650355972349644,
0.7248210310935974,
-0.07859283685684204,
0.8338369727134705,
-0.20430950820446014,
-0.11794793605804443,
-0.13261140882968903,
0.329652339220047,
1.0143961906433105,
0.2700372040271759,
-0.21649761497974396,
-0.23319357633590698,
-0.11967956274747849,
-0.3503910005092621,
-0.40928781032562256,
0.8660395741462708,
-0.6089663505554199,
-0.40213191509246826,
-0.13056202232837677,
-0.7490071058273315,
-0.5444437861442566,
0.2540617287158966,
-0.29418817162513733,
0.4693405032157898,
-0.416077584028244,
0.2991315424442291,
0.4662739336490631,
-0.6245608925819397,
0.40121641755104065,
0.6686392426490784,
-0.8111218810081482,
-0.650043785572052,
1.0308629274368286,
0.0964386835694313,
-0.03321535885334015,
0.4254336655139923,
0.39940428733825684,
-0.21801874041557312,
-0.6332708597183228,
-0.3015328347682953,
0.29829534888267517,
-0.3975282311439514,
0.08394209295511246,
-0.3871708810329437,
-0.15861308574676514,
-0.3307962119579315,
-0.4006344676017761,
-0.12457618862390518,
-0.004210006445646286,
0.05059671774506569,
-0.22940438985824585,
0.15094342827796936,
0.8474202156066895,
-0.054338693618774414,
0.08208458870649338,
-0.4353533983230591,
0.23421362042427063,
0.3082497715950012,
0.4136323928833008,
-0.01195361278951168,
-0.17070084810256958,
-0.6678777933120728,
0.019606592133641243,
0.02036917395889759,
-0.22228798270225525,
0.6980149745941162,
0.09745580703020096,
0.4999498426914215,
0.6958881616592407,
-0.07370849698781967,
0.7563329935073853,
-0.6111758351325989,
0.36807772517204285,
0.16706855595111847,
-0.23700293898582458,
0.4964272379875183,
-0.6714335083961487,
0.4756953716278076,
0.5113959312438965,
0.5364267230033875,
-0.3332231342792511,
-0.0067239063791930676,
-0.2379341870546341,
-0.9664682149887085,
0.6240448355674744,
-0.43611031770706177,
0.13285186886787415,
0.20826798677444458,
0.5065485835075378,
0.19198869168758392,
0.13199816644191742,
-0.8213356137275696,
0.12583434581756592,
0.35445213317871094,
0.154701367020607,
-0.5388530492782593,
-0.8873507976531982,
-0.02939084731042385,
-0.25744640827178955,
0.7447073459625244,
-0.1445913314819336,
-0.13076840341091156,
-0.25498950481414795,
0.2525346279144287,
-0.3362594544887543,
0.3969883918762207,
0.3942978084087372,
0.8115555047988892,
-0.5665757060050964,
-0.21136556565761566,
0.3657993674278259,
-0.15354444086551666,
-0.14239710569381714,
-0.05036827176809311,
-0.030263707041740417,
-0.5072753429412842,
0.3742021322250366,
0.7963090538978577,
0.7493561506271362,
-0.7334089875221252,
0.27850666642189026,
0.04349937289953232,
-0.34301885962486267,
-0.7454055547714233,
0.12770330905914307,
0.2740611732006073,
0.4514438211917877,
-0.019174160435795784,
-0.2687491774559021,
-0.2337821125984192,
-0.8619151711463928,
-0.07275716960430145,
0.44187429547309875,
-0.6548470258712769,
0.004102606792002916,
0.271679550409317,
0.4215606153011322,
-0.3271854817867279,
0.42441684007644653,
-0.10179726034402847,
-0.2786622643470764,
0.06147514283657074,
0.6583501696586609,
0.5893420577049255,
-0.01556292176246643,
0.3672232925891876,
0.33860862255096436,
0.05611681938171387,
-0.17273472249507904,
0.09375816583633423,
-0.20243041217327118,
-0.36709532141685486,
-0.3966347575187683,
-0.8314688205718994,
-0.15010617673397064,
0.23039866983890533,
-0.3988865315914154,
0.5110580325126648,
-0.8355204463005066,
0.04344742372632027,
-0.15665678679943085,
0.25231805443763733,
-0.4352826476097107,
0.0006996975862421095,
0.015406999737024307,
0.8656671643257141,
-0.3691059947013855,
0.9430335164070129,
0.5039152503013611,
-0.41487574577331543,
-0.9665703773498535,
-0.23273636400699615,
-0.13322322070598602,
-0.9132362008094788,
0.7496910691261292,
-0.06574109196662903,
-0.28422805666923523,
-0.21807537972927094,
-0.23629285395145416,
-0.5729912519454956,
1.1422401666641235,
0.2022302895784378,
-0.9028569459915161,
-0.6866110563278198,
0.056257110089063644,
0.4600270986557007,
-0.46072918176651,
0.07381930202245712,
0.23986689746379852,
0.4052775800228119,
0.3930377960205078,
-0.7704196572303772,
-0.15378864109516144,
0.1913645714521408,
-0.09281758219003677,
0.5599673986434937,
-0.5672934055328369,
0.5246124267578125,
-0.410324364900589,
0.026598360389471054,
0.12380139529705048,
0.6176959872245789,
0.14141996204853058,
0.4234583079814911,
0.6346736550331116,
0.4686020016670227,
0.3479592502117157,
0.31048113107681274,
0.7087509632110596,
-0.3213638663291931,
0.020190274342894554,
1.2757776975631714,
-0.317594438791275,
1.0962395668029785,
0.09173323214054108,
-0.016146892681717873,
0.7297660112380981,
0.5168397426605225,
-0.15845157206058502,
0.5765303373336792,
0.07490053027868271,
-0.018305178731679916,
-0.46717971563339233,
-0.028488414362072945,
-0.10215160250663757,
0.06054231524467468,
0.5874109864234924,
-0.3109378218650818,
-0.38967132568359375,
0.0917571559548378,
0.06436286121606827,
0.08464302867650986,
-0.6048181653022766,
0.8415787816047668,
0.1455991417169571,
-0.6285930871963501,
0.3255716562271118,
0.05809906870126724,
0.7438940405845642,
-0.9498002529144287,
-0.15609462559223175,
0.05992887541651726,
0.3433922529220581,
-0.24412521719932556,
-0.795220673084259,
-0.12626869976520538,
-0.15487369894981384,
-0.23983053863048553,
-0.4157654047012329,
0.7872796654701233,
-0.5293241739273071,
-0.383637934923172,
0.6692203879356384,
0.3732542097568512,
-0.17540544271469116,
0.089973583817482,
-0.6130754947662354,
-0.48821747303009033,
0.04424112290143967,
-0.15673387050628662,
0.6306430101394653,
0.3469257056713104,
0.05478089302778244,
1.2266515493392944,
0.7342196702957153,
0.5672866702079773,
-0.25447627902030945,
0.021307455375790596,
0.8431365489959717,
-0.7694208025932312,
-0.6423144936561584,
-0.6513129472732544,
0.22786849737167358,
0.10557065904140472,
-0.2504631578922272,
0.5154369473457336,
0.587081253528595,
0.8439597487449646,
0.09272821992635727,
0.4629376530647278,
0.3767930269241333,
0.557678759098053,
-0.704521656036377,
0.3228035569190979,
-0.41283711791038513,
0.8204798102378845,
0.13380199670791626,
-1.1751229763031006,
-0.04129929840564728,
0.34577327966690063,
-0.8195313811302185,
0.22548049688339233,
0.26832693815231323,
0.8389275670051575,
-0.059342797845602036,
-0.3365817964076996,
0.6648544669151306,
0.07219109684228897,
0.4956282377243042,
1.0237767696380615,
0.7166290283203125,
0.563572883605957,
0.6166752576828003,
-0.23056234419345856,
-0.05196196213364601,
-0.42819178104400635,
-0.6126059293746948,
-1.1657692193984985,
-0.715054988861084,
0.08221403509378433,
-0.3206501007080078,
0.5030866265296936,
1.4975016117095947,
0.7701635956764221,
-0.3430223762989044,
-0.49116072058677673,
-0.06636141985654831,
0.1153096929192543,
0.030036594718694687,
-0.14796362817287445,
0.46434539556503296,
-0.2806321680545807,
-0.5195850133895874,
0.7052207589149475,
0.5728482007980347,
-0.15923985838890076,
-0.5915974378585815,
-0.42613866925239563,
-0.28493621945381165,
-0.03591660410165787,
0.8153838515281677,
0.5711409449577332,
-0.46197429299354553,
-0.12000024318695068,
-0.45175614953041077,
-0.08365475386381149,
-0.36564555764198303,
1.002357006072998,
-0.7280591726303101,
0.3473415672779083,
0.2263234555721283,
0.5121594071388245,
0.5759401321411133,
-0.28412002325057983,
0.8002774119377136,
-0.5542406439781189,
0.13941390812397003,
0.18036794662475586,
0.47790491580963135,
-0.10367734730243683,
-0.25750821828842163,
0.5681672692298889,
-0.42722874879837036,
-0.9226283431053162,
-0.5941014885902405,
0.4045829772949219,
-1.1076545715332031,
-0.3670342266559601,
1.681858777999878,
-0.12139824032783508,
-0.02019129879772663,
-0.11014676839113235,
-0.6242859959602356,
0.0734124556183815,
-0.6666709780693054,
0.7466890811920166,
0.4597172439098358,
-0.06680963188409805,
0.002618839032948017,
-0.5581254363059998,
0.6064783930778503,
0.12741923332214355,
-0.5252805948257446,
0.35238248109817505,
0.6679831743240356,
0.17273010313510895,
-0.1508733034133911,
0.5298988223075867,
0.2764233946800232,
-0.08327864110469818,
-0.3837495744228363,
-0.1197538897395134,
-0.3890864849090576,
-0.7716357111930847,
-0.2155272215604782,
0.13700059056282043,
0.5824792385101318,
0.3237162232398987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19133v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19133v1
|
Evaluating Webcam-based Gaze Data as an Alternative for Human Rationale Annotations
| 2024-02-29T13:09:26 | 2024-02-29T13:09:26 |
Stephanie Brandl, Oliver Eberle, Tiago Ribeiro, Anders Søgaard, Nora Hollenstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rationales in the form of manually annotated input spans usually serve as
ground truth when evaluating explainability methods in NLP. They are, however,
time-consuming and often biased by the annotation process. In this paper, we
debate whether human gaze, in the form of webcam-based eye-tracking recordings,
poses a valid alternative when evaluating importance scores. We evaluate the
additional information provided by gaze data, such as total reading times, gaze
entropy, and decoding accuracy with respect to human rationale annotations. We
compare WebQAmGaze, a multilingual dataset for information-seeking QA, with
attention and explainability-based importance scores for 4 different
multilingual Transformer-based language models (mBERT, distil-mBERT, XLMR, and
XLMR-L) and 3 languages (English, Spanish, and German). Our pipeline can easily
be applied to other tasks and languages. Our findings suggest that gaze data
offers valuable linguistic insights that could be leveraged to infer task
difficulty and further show a comparable ranking of explainability methods to
that of human rationales.
|
[
-0.5263200402259827,
-0.3190769851207733,
0.6566358208656311,
0.33898866176605225,
-0.3332458734512329,
-0.4577232301235199,
-0.16122575104236603,
-0.5777597427368164,
0.16125714778900146,
0.050974734127521515,
-0.6399362087249756,
-0.4919813275337219,
-0.4126853048801422,
0.03895527496933937,
-0.13525988161563873,
0.5257424116134644,
-0.03144271299242973,
0.400741308927536,
-0.3729802668094635,
-0.12239636480808258,
-0.1750071495771408,
-0.5109235644340515,
-0.4744488596916199,
-0.06483009457588196,
0.6925250291824341,
0.12737806141376495,
0.6501166820526123,
0.40646472573280334,
0.7253862619400024,
0.25471702218055725,
0.2336026281118393,
-0.08099943399429321,
-0.20722903311252594,
-0.3066744804382324,
-0.12824445962905884,
-0.6721788644790649,
-0.3682682514190674,
0.48754608631134033,
0.17669729888439178,
0.9405787587165833,
0.02608313038945198,
0.714097797870636,
0.087534099817276,
0.8218827247619629,
-0.7512175440788269,
0.3820095658302307,
-0.24944336712360382,
0.12053240090608597,
-0.165337473154068,
-0.35438668727874756,
-0.4122585654258728,
-0.3186147212982178,
0.5527398586273193,
-0.7316807508468628,
0.40390539169311523,
0.03862721100449562,
1.0123718976974487,
0.4710928797721863,
-0.09707994759082794,
-0.06449083983898163,
-0.4820162057876587,
0.7824875116348267,
-0.6267477869987488,
0.4708775579929352,
0.6625815629959106,
0.3727470338344574,
0.12204975634813309,
-0.10935509949922562,
-0.43222498893737793,
-0.14032138884067535,
-0.028348486870527267,
0.127137690782547,
-0.10783308744430542,
0.15508787333965302,
0.6251400113105774,
0.1507362276315689,
-0.5850317478179932,
-0.18835729360580444,
-0.19731013476848602,
-0.24460025131702423,
0.35135313868522644,
-0.2000489979982376,
0.574783980846405,
-0.28208667039871216,
-0.3324398696422577,
-0.10426774621009827,
-0.27167680859565735,
0.6019749641418457,
0.35312631726264954,
0.0018214198062196374,
0.18000027537345886,
0.6387561559677124,
-0.5737963914871216,
0.6466455459594727,
0.1288212537765503,
-0.1965125948190689,
0.2538588047027588,
-0.033253904432058334,
0.03627119958400726,
-0.2171286791563034,
0.48452603816986084,
0.7983068227767944,
0.21865631639957428,
-0.5460033416748047,
0.31931695342063904,
0.36171597242355347,
0.5160361528396606,
-0.42756325006484985,
-0.18342682719230652,
0.4551860988140106,
-0.4599453806877136,
0.06708747148513794,
0.07708100229501724,
-0.818616509437561,
-0.18263953924179077,
-0.467963844537735,
0.4705994725227356,
-0.3679002821445465,
-0.11006109416484833,
0.0841495469212532,
-0.3540187478065491,
0.6282384991645813,
0.6350456476211548,
-0.729305624961853,
-0.09190439432859421,
0.35995206236839294,
0.8529977798461914,
-0.49808430671691895,
-0.37228983640670776,
-0.2037452757358551,
-0.20251497626304626,
-0.2843741178512573,
0.886695921421051,
-0.3382771611213684,
0.26332545280456543,
-0.1002875491976738,
0.005276476498693228,
-0.3132060766220093,
-0.4031566083431244,
0.6158427000045776,
-0.5920793414115906,
0.2163798063993454,
-0.44145098328590393,
-0.32042285799980164,
-0.7105540633201599,
0.2760857939720154,
-0.7849798798561096,
0.8305112719535828,
0.1264384388923645,
-0.7480484247207642,
0.6593909859657288,
-0.7863208651542664,
-0.19271832704544067,
0.2050953358411789,
0.12842482328414917,
-0.18490813672542572,
0.02456812933087349,
0.2705523371696472,
0.5091995596885681,
-0.3686957061290741,
0.26386669278144836,
-0.29264411330223083,
-0.23554350435733795,
0.5377177000045776,
-0.5113782286643982,
0.9525192975997925,
-0.11324475705623627,
-0.8635299801826477,
-0.29270464181900024,
-0.805916965007782,
0.3743305802345276,
-0.12052344530820847,
-0.33781763911247253,
-0.35570400953292847,
0.16719907522201538,
0.008943007327616215,
0.3276556730270386,
-0.03614713251590729,
-0.552394449710846,
-0.3425350487232208,
-0.1092575192451477,
0.17233906686306,
0.2776445150375366,
-0.22109392285346985,
0.16262935101985931,
-0.044723283499479294,
0.787276029586792,
-0.10178171098232269,
0.3711981475353241,
-0.015394654124975204,
-0.5124260187149048,
-0.8191220760345459,
-0.09451772272586823,
0.261457622051239,
0.7387521266937256,
-0.6152498126029968,
-0.012647248804569244,
-0.21518902480602264,
-0.2944348156452179,
-0.6568836569786072,
0.1124536320567131,
0.6155133247375488,
0.5281397104263306,
0.3958888053894043,
-0.5339477062225342,
-0.3550027310848236,
-1.2229032516479492,
-0.4158272445201874,
-0.2738991379737854,
-0.3363112509250641,
0.42707815766334534,
0.03048982098698616,
-0.10247697681188583,
0.9489618539810181,
-0.29413023591041565,
-0.2038024514913559,
-0.27374836802482605,
0.10644534230232239,
-0.22773365676403046,
0.18729494512081146,
0.6602172255516052,
-1.0903254747390747,
-0.33543288707733154,
-0.31768861413002014,
-0.9610694050788879,
-0.3559916019439697,
-0.3027464747428894,
-0.27644461393356323,
0.01708078756928444,
0.142098531126976,
-0.8523966670036316,
0.586510419845581,
0.38777610659599304,
-0.1916903704404831,
0.5661566257476807,
0.3527524471282959,
0.7407447099685669,
-0.4566609263420105,
0.20215792953968048,
0.5662108659744263,
-0.13788911700248718,
-0.7101574540138245,
0.0552922748029232,
0.10450071096420288,
0.005501149222254753,
-0.5862688422203064,
0.1605791300535202,
-0.6126740574836731,
-0.12789484858512878,
-0.14035649597644806,
0.6455296874046326,
0.10744661837816238,
0.7862443923950195,
0.021452922374010086,
0.6006993651390076,
0.4581761956214905,
-0.6775485277175903,
0.3551686406135559,
0.10673316568136215,
-0.5133461356163025,
0.4739575684070587,
-0.4582946002483368,
-0.07388047128915787,
-0.19922034442424774,
-0.153294175863266,
-0.9241669178009033,
-0.4369646906852722,
0.1734822541475296,
-0.708734393119812,
0.09846705198287964,
-0.12808506190776825,
0.14314180612564087,
-0.3804948329925537,
-0.5575900673866272,
0.2858738899230957,
0.2546253800392151,
-0.5897032618522644,
0.42795616388320923,
0.7488908767700195,
-0.21632207930088043,
-0.5979257225990295,
-0.6348488330841064,
0.3746102452278137,
-0.48936477303504944,
-0.5629522204399109,
0.12829069793224335,
0.13014519214630127,
-0.5509524941444397,
-0.10561645776033401,
-0.012937823310494423,
-0.47907087206840515,
0.17254547774791718,
0.2521706819534302,
0.4366055727005005,
-0.31554538011550903,
0.030547460541129112,
-0.4731433093547821,
-0.1754053384065628,
0.3694096803665161,
-0.04996093362569809,
0.08813592046499252,
-0.07539688795804977,
-0.3201694190502167,
-0.766167938709259,
0.34736430644989014,
0.5013642311096191,
0.11738943308591843,
0.46807506680488586,
0.6168062090873718,
-0.3965412676334381,
0.05664835870265961,
-0.8199363946914673,
-0.041190411895513535,
-0.33096998929977417,
0.22679336369037628,
-0.13947699964046478,
-0.6482090353965759,
0.3629782497882843,
-0.025701336562633514,
0.10225170105695724,
0.5639386177062988,
0.36045417189598083,
-0.34864339232444763,
1.0274688005447388,
0.6090049147605896,
0.15585707128047943,
0.4738684594631195,
-0.10911601036787033,
0.16763949394226074,
-0.9457070827484131,
-0.1679520308971405,
-0.2620372474193573,
-0.23863853514194489,
-0.22589057683944702,
-0.4302220046520233,
0.2683832347393036,
0.13223405182361603,
0.5940443277359009,
0.3469204902648926,
-0.3629121780395508,
0.5225653648376465,
0.4612426459789276,
0.1945788413286209,
0.12516608834266663,
-0.12671741843223572,
0.2264193296432495,
-0.32172948122024536,
-0.7538588047027588,
-0.7135329246520996,
0.9712626934051514,
0.1340305060148239,
0.5174410939216614,
0.14388595521450043,
0.0160023495554924,
0.31178227066993713,
0.2225903570652008,
-0.8783178329467773,
0.47680896520614624,
0.24004340171813965,
-0.6519479155540466,
-0.7100157737731934,
-0.22021602094173431,
-0.8922803997993469,
0.7065167427062988,
-0.12761859595775604,
-1.0300909280776978,
0.2636803090572357,
0.5686097741127014,
-0.4934788644313812,
0.004840329755097628,
-1.2446023225784302,
1.1128404140472412,
-0.30494779348373413,
-0.5787135362625122,
-0.2588728666305542,
-0.7457184195518494,
0.4084959626197815,
0.08624857664108276,
0.30015942454338074,
-0.3400194048881531,
0.05041253939270973,
0.7931657433509827,
-0.25564977526664734,
1.003040075302124,
-0.2175733596086502,
0.3135915696620941,
0.436376690864563,
-0.26273441314697266,
0.042193759232759476,
0.08746879547834396,
0.2049875557422638,
0.40493065118789673,
-0.128401517868042,
-0.43436887860298157,
-0.5941367745399475,
0.4648860991001129,
-0.41731730103492737,
-0.984488308429718,
-0.4026281535625458,
-0.40011128783226013,
-0.5628790855407715,
-0.06711970269680023,
0.18382704257965088,
0.4808636009693146,
0.02372898906469345,
0.24755410850048065,
0.4450722634792328,
-0.042932022362947464,
0.45517146587371826,
0.3788321018218994,
0.19725625216960907,
-0.0001778275182005018,
0.8182029128074646,
0.20764890313148499,
0.27556848526000977,
0.3448319435119629,
0.08536987006664276,
-0.28424596786499023,
-0.3728635609149933,
-0.7783299088478088,
0.08037374168634415,
-0.7139862775802612,
0.07962705194950104,
-0.7447287440299988,
0.15520447492599487,
-0.24168306589126587,
-0.14807747304439545,
-0.10774493962526321,
-0.592747151851654,
-0.23946736752986908,
-0.058253657072782516,
0.27760443091392517,
0.19598160684108734,
0.13802480697631836,
-0.03832061216235161,
-0.7171685099601746,
0.5597739219665527,
0.43116435408592224,
0.3434514105319977,
0.038118474185466766,
-0.19436413049697876,
-0.4227343201637268,
0.17749567329883575,
-0.23164263367652893,
-1.1047852039337158,
0.28189367055892944,
0.24044407904148102,
0.8499581813812256,
0.2561253607273102,
0.11397199332714081,
0.773329496383667,
-0.31989410519599915,
0.910717248916626,
0.19405364990234375,
-0.908168375492096,
0.49489620327949524,
-0.2257184237241745,
0.4289906620979309,
0.6673174500465393,
0.8013938665390015,
-0.3207535147666931,
-0.3210911452770233,
-0.3183589577674866,
-0.9299458861351013,
0.8780064582824707,
0.2157880663871765,
-0.3481023609638214,
0.17310063540935516,
0.575951099395752,
0.09929046034812927,
0.1324082911014557,
-0.9414001107215881,
-0.030456464737653732,
-0.20398272573947906,
-0.00826524943113327,
-0.0724630057811737,
-0.2959035336971283,
0.19316142797470093,
-0.12603214383125305,
0.5898059010505676,
-0.24561087787151337,
0.018428051844239235,
0.5429304242134094,
-0.5340564846992493,
-0.19650587439537048,
0.37715551257133484,
0.21653588116168976,
0.87331223487854,
-0.14349906146526337,
0.0845707431435585,
0.301405668258667,
-0.7197270393371582,
-0.05711164325475693,
-0.1655455082654953,
-0.40212035179138184,
0.16021780669689178,
0.2485537827014923,
0.8476667404174805,
0.2981492578983307,
-0.9103529453277588,
0.6080915331840515,
0.0839974656701088,
-0.05081111937761307,
-0.24473541975021362,
-0.04599933698773384,
0.017782049253582954,
0.2987962067127228,
0.3876556158065796,
0.06461764872074127,
0.7400986552238464,
-0.49549567699432373,
-0.049252044409513474,
0.5116981267929077,
-0.6296257972717285,
-0.4736749529838562,
0.66426020860672,
0.1951930969953537,
-0.1593511998653412,
0.09126915782690048,
-0.14266622066497803,
-0.5208640694618225,
0.572029709815979,
0.1143033355474472,
1.000611662864685,
-0.2624956965446472,
0.45372235774993896,
0.5206901431083679,
0.5363824367523193,
-0.2349046915769577,
0.13587605953216553,
-0.24909372627735138,
-0.39761772751808167,
-0.6470940113067627,
-0.6079421043395996,
-0.7091403603553772,
-0.051070231944322586,
-0.8195013999938965,
0.17366793751716614,
0.055446963757276535,
-0.5405544638633728,
0.3904024064540863,
-0.5610215663909912,
-0.49400854110717773,
0.31929174065589905,
0.07397284358739853,
0.4076296091079712,
-0.6429793238639832,
0.45217227935791016,
0.6207988262176514,
-0.40297505259513855,
-0.5499784350395203,
0.17279422283172607,
0.1563645899295807,
-0.4698401689529419,
0.5498926639556885,
0.3881306052207947,
-0.40622881054878235,
-0.3903177082538605,
-0.31949904561042786,
-1.058138132095337,
0.9284626841545105,
0.5105862617492676,
-0.28780239820480347,
-0.06471545994281769,
0.010332096368074417,
0.6936442852020264,
-0.1533300280570984,
0.1810055822134018,
0.3884177505970001,
0.4444217383861542,
-0.13255825638771057,
-0.835103452205658,
-0.2179996222257614,
-0.3483874499797821,
-0.0739399865269661,
0.046936579048633575,
-0.6136264801025391,
0.45480939745903015,
-0.5190750360488892,
-0.5652316212654114,
-0.548449695110321,
0.1463506519794464,
-0.37139245867729187,
0.3967936635017395,
0.6629124283790588,
0.3131521940231323,
0.3194611966609955,
-0.03732231631875038,
0.9954999685287476,
-0.04210459440946579,
0.24771907925605774,
0.8294945955276489,
-0.047910142689943314,
0.9327109456062317,
0.5735877752304077,
-0.48427051305770874,
0.2641978859901428,
0.52813720703125,
0.015028866939246655,
0.1603279709815979,
-0.13030005991458893,
0.21692343056201935,
-0.616265594959259,
-0.004880065098404884,
0.09950374066829681,
0.4317745566368103,
0.23695814609527588,
-0.1027313694357872,
-0.15144295990467072,
0.14568571746349335,
-0.21892598271369934,
-0.07880799472332001,
-0.23933318257331848,
0.6726378798484802,
0.02800793945789337,
-0.8341981768608093,
0.576477587223053,
-0.2821926176548004,
0.39475390315055847,
-0.4434300661087036,
0.0014129250776022673,
0.35997459292411804,
0.08028895407915115,
-0.33875879645347595,
-0.6020227670669556,
0.18742254376411438,
0.31900492310523987,
-0.40219494700431824,
-0.015918266028165817,
0.43517011404037476,
-0.3154776692390442,
-0.32451263070106506,
0.22285765409469604,
0.3068641722202301,
0.4176417589187622,
-0.2747330069541931,
-0.5918189883232117,
-0.3889312446117401,
0.17081525921821594,
-0.6484497785568237,
0.4160093069076538,
0.3109002709388733,
-0.222050741314888,
0.9420377016067505,
0.707689642906189,
-0.06817677617073059,
0.3467037081718445,
0.1371684968471527,
0.5738651752471924,
-0.728516161441803,
-0.23856613039970398,
-0.7224926948547363,
0.4008031487464905,
-0.16504444181919098,
-0.4320662021636963,
1.114037275314331,
0.5615107417106628,
0.5640660524368286,
-0.2107381522655487,
0.7641709446907043,
0.04283997789025307,
0.7078607678413391,
-0.6711497902870178,
0.4391838014125824,
-0.5393021106719971,
0.06226262450218201,
-0.39319926500320435,
-0.9210197925567627,
-0.48556652665138245,
0.7531803846359253,
-0.2372485250234604,
-0.16635677218437195,
0.9095737934112549,
0.4087807238101959,
0.13544577360153198,
0.08134094625711441,
0.43704715371131897,
-0.023488853126764297,
-0.127189502120018,
0.5813309550285339,
0.6698771119117737,
-0.30923736095428467,
0.6562547087669373,
-0.2923697829246521,
-0.6485784649848938,
-0.4619905352592468,
-0.6241095662117004,
-1.016315221786499,
-0.6137837171554565,
-0.5740957260131836,
0.048683371394872665,
-0.2219073474407196,
0.898382306098938,
0.528025209903717,
-0.7644028663635254,
-0.023165762424468994,
0.31905397772789,
-0.08229425549507141,
-0.4156983494758606,
-0.19842451810836792,
0.25881242752075195,
-0.5729607343673706,
-0.6799678802490234,
0.016656313091516495,
0.5460426807403564,
-0.020638344809412956,
-0.4245041310787201,
0.23919925093650818,
-0.21998284757137299,
0.16105057299137115,
0.78298020362854,
0.423895925283432,
-1.1127089262008667,
-0.38947272300720215,
0.27555742859840393,
-0.08235931396484375,
0.1751253604888916,
0.7985917925834656,
-0.5009776949882507,
0.5928061008453369,
0.34593117237091064,
0.48716339468955994,
0.35580548644065857,
0.22428588569164276,
0.3958829641342163,
-0.1624930500984192,
0.17845770716667175,
0.16157306730747223,
0.5760627388954163,
0.5305653214454651,
-0.3684294819831848,
0.5588657855987549,
0.23881857097148895,
-0.392791211605072,
-0.5301679968833923,
-0.030364936217665672,
-1.3638463020324707,
-0.043871741741895676,
1.2386549711227417,
-0.5661382675170898,
-0.5106292366981506,
-0.6112593412399292,
-0.47483891248703003,
-0.11536112427711487,
-0.18773694336414337,
1.2859500646591187,
1.0133774280548096,
-0.32504940032958984,
-0.2183379828929901,
-0.7840104103088379,
0.611023485660553,
0.3090203106403351,
-0.9245200753211975,
0.2891435921192169,
0.7757980227470398,
0.009546649642288685,
0.5112643241882324,
0.3892357349395752,
-0.24009652435779572,
0.6325758099555969,
0.053428757935762405,
0.34083592891693115,
0.4042032063007355,
-0.16440892219543457,
-0.05211174115538597,
0.3432876169681549,
0.04896041005849838,
-0.1830751597881317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19119v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19119v2
|
VIXEN: Visual Text Comparison Network for Image Difference Captioning
| 2024-02-29T12:56:18 | 2024-03-14T19:18:43 |
Alexander Black, Jing Shi, Yifei Fan, Tu Bui, John Collomosse
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
We present VIXEN - a technique that succinctly summarizes in text the visual
differences between a pair of images in order to highlight any content
manipulation present. Our proposed network linearly maps image features in a
pairwise manner, constructing a soft prompt for a pretrained large language
model. We address the challenge of low volume of training data and lack of
manipulation variety in existing image difference captioning (IDC) datasets by
training on synthetically manipulated images from the recent InstructPix2Pix
dataset generated via prompt-to-prompt editing framework. We augment this
dataset with change summaries produced via GPT-3. We show that VIXEN produces
state-of-the-art, comprehensible difference captions for diverse image contents
and edit types, offering a potential mitigation against misinformation
disseminated via manipulated image content. Code and data are available at
http://github.com/alexblck/vixen
|
[
-0.36755138635635376,
-0.31320297718048096,
0.41887566447257996,
0.39567428827285767,
-0.5112693309783936,
-0.043714381754398346,
-0.22621233761310577,
-0.3631002604961395,
0.3204648494720459,
0.41540688276290894,
-0.44095849990844727,
-0.6530933380126953,
-0.6354987621307373,
0.3508647382259369,
-0.5902073383331299,
0.7167476415634155,
-0.21851006150245667,
0.12691539525985718,
-0.2571909427642822,
-0.4926135838031769,
-0.6679252982139587,
-0.05874790996313095,
-0.6994367241859436,
-0.09206116944551468,
0.8293223977088928,
0.4066968858242035,
0.8771457672119141,
0.6389398574829102,
0.7777990698814392,
0.45863625407218933,
-0.21938477456569672,
0.3002443015575409,
-0.3178705871105194,
0.1810867190361023,
-0.19047677516937256,
-0.45113804936408997,
-0.1350875198841095,
-0.14994195103645325,
0.6051895618438721,
0.30749353766441345,
0.42564857006073,
-0.23963433504104614,
0.06568752229213715,
0.7710336446762085,
-0.42825016379356384,
0.29213646054267883,
-0.7259598970413208,
0.10229560732841492,
-0.11619545519351959,
-0.10078956931829453,
-0.01395495980978012,
-0.2436949610710144,
0.021092507988214493,
-0.7014325261116028,
0.4155209958553314,
0.14496318995952606,
0.8927832841873169,
0.23125059902668,
-0.25902625918388367,
0.010789379477500916,
-0.3515704870223999,
0.3708309233188629,
-0.5454616546630859,
-0.03412915766239166,
-0.03687470778822899,
0.38302168250083923,
0.3667115271091461,
-1.0274471044540405,
-0.9537509083747864,
0.018697142601013184,
-0.20867642760276794,
0.30692824721336365,
-0.12718136608600616,
-0.018558163195848465,
0.3202170729637146,
0.589483916759491,
-0.6836822628974915,
0.22301021218299866,
-0.39376550912857056,
-0.04354871064424515,
0.5469821095466614,
0.20117534697055817,
0.6388391256332397,
-0.1355305165052414,
-0.44403553009033203,
-0.6470282673835754,
-0.6954354047775269,
-0.13705813884735107,
0.18165326118469238,
0.10782897472381592,
-0.22353686392307281,
0.5824163556098938,
-0.05700790137052536,
0.373637855052948,
-0.2494492530822754,
0.2752082049846649,
0.3838992416858673,
-0.19432023167610168,
-0.38093090057373047,
0.02665511704981327,
1.008896827697754,
1.0913314819335938,
0.3457173705101013,
0.02716268226504326,
-0.5021141767501831,
0.09957610070705414,
-0.12812760472297668,
-0.8691249489784241,
-0.5015119910240173,
-0.05770917609333992,
-0.6540193557739258,
-0.39886248111724854,
0.2658950090408325,
-0.7592596411705017,
-0.8127235770225525,
-0.5977713465690613,
0.5104133486747742,
-0.14164578914642334,
-0.31118929386138916,
-0.05796322971582413,
-0.44865116477012634,
0.22534868121147156,
0.49213069677352905,
-0.4736022353172302,
0.28945374488830566,
0.5055932402610779,
1.280792474746704,
-0.4452417194843292,
-0.31087377667427063,
-0.5499978065490723,
-0.3156221807003021,
-0.33713796734809875,
0.8396731615066528,
-0.33014634251594543,
-0.5583842992782593,
0.12321359664201736,
0.14574673771858215,
0.07923264056444168,
-0.7204063534736633,
0.07085496932268143,
-0.45932209491729736,
0.17573964595794678,
-0.3487103581428528,
-0.3798750042915344,
-0.16879892349243164,
0.29169151186943054,
-0.9355193972587585,
0.7860433459281921,
0.1059357151389122,
-0.9252609610557556,
0.18840038776397705,
-0.7663098573684692,
-0.5423016548156738,
0.05023308843374252,
-0.26000112295150757,
-0.7228637337684631,
-0.2061840146780014,
0.5086809992790222,
0.37271055579185486,
0.007433289662003517,
-0.1319962739944458,
-0.14943835139274597,
-0.5412715077400208,
0.48261237144470215,
-0.3887946903705597,
0.46495309472084045,
0.0369473472237587,
-0.5145366191864014,
0.6004360318183899,
-0.6244717836380005,
-0.248321533203125,
0.31130462884902954,
0.155496284365654,
-0.5285918712615967,
-0.2671430706977844,
0.3293027877807617,
0.22146190702915192,
0.022059939801692963,
-0.12831728160381317,
0.39820951223373413,
-0.2594752907752991,
0.37399736046791077,
0.7657124400138855,
0.07727798819541931,
0.4197259545326233,
-0.21756958961486816,
0.3873656988143921,
0.17091509699821472,
0.4780970513820648,
-0.7186270356178284,
-0.4411350190639496,
-0.7305936813354492,
0.004987680818885565,
0.27502477169036865,
0.829364538192749,
-1.439389944076538,
-0.2608449459075928,
-0.3870299160480499,
-0.07553999125957489,
-0.3231772184371948,
0.2891283631324768,
0.6421398520469666,
0.5342147350311279,
0.4577053189277649,
-0.21884329617023468,
-0.2858424484729767,
-1.052857756614685,
-0.14679847657680511,
-0.01931941881775856,
0.10134915262460709,
0.1536727249622345,
0.4965597689151764,
-0.15815791487693787,
0.4178113639354706,
-0.42704373598098755,
-0.26108264923095703,
-0.2698667049407959,
0.3362264335155487,
0.10450972616672516,
0.41312333941459656,
0.708815336227417,
-1.2277252674102783,
-0.7809002995491028,
0.022991390898823738,
-0.7310335040092468,
-0.06055007502436638,
-0.3771078288555145,
-0.24955737590789795,
-0.19132572412490845,
0.8859111070632935,
-0.2887386679649353,
0.5631654858589172,
0.3986828625202179,
-0.16327078640460968,
0.6127077341079712,
-0.1668345183134079,
0.6819239258766174,
-1.2284374237060547,
-0.07488325983285904,
0.15425311028957367,
-0.4349578022956848,
-0.2211756557226181,
-0.0710311233997345,
0.21322131156921387,
-0.06173089146614075,
-0.5956655740737915,
0.602056086063385,
-0.5904953479766846,
-0.05249244347214699,
-0.2693566083908081,
0.24980428814888,
0.11669240146875381,
0.48757779598236084,
-0.014187331311404705,
1.0533969402313232,
0.7733157277107239,
-0.3139630854129791,
0.5789629817008972,
0.6574787497520447,
-0.31217727065086365,
0.6759480834007263,
-0.8285866379737854,
0.20798863470554352,
-0.2957300841808319,
-0.20539972186088562,
-1.1371502876281738,
-0.22499418258666992,
0.5595484972000122,
-0.3390130400657654,
0.21704913675785065,
-0.30184322595596313,
-0.6043013334274292,
-0.2522519826889038,
-0.453352153301239,
0.4372744858264923,
0.4547130763530731,
-0.8374754786491394,
0.09308141469955444,
-0.22188885509967804,
-0.5367426872253418,
-0.4634956121444702,
-0.9053783416748047,
0.6539806723594666,
-0.17623655498027802,
-0.6181221008300781,
0.3457275927066803,
-0.1918913722038269,
-0.6089004278182983,
0.025282571092247963,
0.16237911581993103,
-0.14564307034015656,
-0.20222844183444977,
0.48434892296791077,
0.3171943724155426,
-0.2716792821884155,
0.3990243971347809,
0.23401881754398346,
-0.09533736854791641,
-0.09926196187734604,
-0.27131345868110657,
-0.06976747512817383,
-0.2209324836730957,
-0.20965760946273804,
-0.45291903614997864,
0.5852205157279968,
0.3478606939315796,
-0.34888356924057007,
0.42412906885147095,
0.48672106862068176,
-0.1791234016418457,
0.0676165521144867,
-0.1477729082107544,
-0.14402282238006592,
-0.4471723139286041,
0.21108323335647583,
-0.08786957710981369,
-0.703406810760498,
0.3302220404148102,
0.015895068645477295,
0.1117861345410347,
0.20594117045402527,
0.1147325411438942,
-0.2464437633752823,
0.8840817213058472,
0.43383902311325073,
0.2636093497276306,
0.7419393062591553,
-0.2983626425266266,
-0.3218834698200226,
-0.24602338671684265,
0.1447414606809616,
-0.16885273158550262,
-0.5307835936546326,
-0.38233575224876404,
-0.4788781702518463,
0.4995076060295105,
-0.15449555218219757,
0.05566476285457611,
0.13807666301727295,
-0.4286069869995117,
0.9942048192024231,
0.5991913676261902,
0.1936461478471756,
0.28747743368148804,
0.2216183841228485,
0.04610179737210274,
-0.29055988788604736,
-0.3983958661556244,
-0.18217779695987701,
0.8052504062652588,
-0.13737598061561584,
0.5063081383705139,
0.09595341980457306,
0.37185534834861755,
0.8103486895561218,
0.42967626452445984,
-0.4478895962238312,
0.6274975538253784,
-0.3074682056903839,
0.03479452431201935,
-0.17977367341518402,
-0.46592703461647034,
-0.948341965675354,
0.2470974624156952,
-0.4096599817276001,
-0.28872019052505493,
0.12125253677368164,
0.28793004155158997,
-0.15297795832157135,
0.5269829630851746,
-0.7728492617607117,
0.7675421237945557,
-0.20933179557323456,
-0.3879268765449524,
-0.05846279859542847,
-0.9286065697669983,
0.13135461509227753,
0.5202910304069519,
-0.2155200093984604,
0.28241345286369324,
0.07033484429121017,
0.2980658710002899,
-0.7173874378204346,
0.7746956944465637,
-0.10708721727132797,
0.04158678278326988,
0.2423604428768158,
0.29567357897758484,
0.5162441730499268,
0.22440063953399658,
0.2635033428668976,
0.11817628890275955,
-0.3483222723007202,
-0.38887304067611694,
-0.9171391725540161,
0.6610554456710815,
-0.5525268912315369,
-0.29019394516944885,
-0.25200730562210083,
-0.27156615257263184,
0.07282725721597672,
0.19175425171852112,
0.5639941096305847,
1.0545860528945923,
0.026838280260562897,
0.020258190110325813,
0.8344857692718506,
-0.3128141760826111,
0.7451599836349487,
0.13922475278377533,
-0.4412265121936798,
-0.7579712867736816,
0.9470027089118958,
-0.23024015128612518,
0.18135549128055573,
0.8498947620391846,
-0.06065603345632553,
-0.4640793204307556,
-0.5485802888870239,
-0.4965980052947998,
0.10047391802072525,
-1.0178102254867554,
-0.21447984874248505,
-0.40813568234443665,
0.0057084821164608,
-0.2852756083011627,
-0.3479653298854828,
-0.1819409728050232,
-0.30965477228164673,
-0.20120464265346527,
-0.02202446013689041,
0.42651283740997314,
0.8876395225524902,
-0.09530181437730789,
0.6890944838523865,
-0.6779823303222656,
0.43928062915802,
0.6246231198310852,
0.3585020899772644,
-0.4763076603412628,
-0.1929994821548462,
-0.17047685384750366,
-0.1159791573882103,
-0.02648775465786457,
-0.9630891680717468,
0.3845355212688446,
0.17626337707042694,
0.14298920333385468,
0.4062884449958801,
-0.17867520451545715,
0.3567931652069092,
-0.10500630736351013,
0.8725256323814392,
0.6196087598800659,
-0.89982670545578,
0.599941611289978,
-0.340288907289505,
0.4669990837574005,
0.36004796624183655,
0.02966609038412571,
-0.7150061130523682,
-0.11801007390022278,
-0.3542991578578949,
-0.828142523765564,
0.21616654098033905,
0.46565794944763184,
-0.0012789079919457436,
0.15565742552280426,
0.41586780548095703,
0.3445698618888855,
0.24561893939971924,
-0.747357189655304,
-0.4324226677417755,
-0.45939508080482483,
-0.21396823227405548,
-0.02780713513493538,
-0.10987658053636551,
-0.06448012590408325,
-0.16817505657672882,
0.44008851051330566,
-0.42001795768737793,
0.21000812947750092,
0.5525100231170654,
-0.5584428906440735,
0.3727816939353943,
0.17308580875396729,
0.564865231513977,
0.6248216032981873,
0.3157874345779419,
0.29236340522766113,
0.026191409677267075,
-0.4196054935455322,
-0.09607964754104614,
0.23353992402553558,
-0.17577557265758514,
0.3345286548137665,
0.49956637620925903,
1.2228564023971558,
0.08722952753305435,
-0.4798264503479004,
0.8547524809837341,
-0.5640802979469299,
-0.4584046006202698,
-0.027465060353279114,
-0.02465842291712761,
-0.3149434030056,
0.44439491629600525,
-0.0008961697458289564,
0.48511219024658203,
0.32399874925613403,
0.1100974753499031,
0.07639818638563156,
-0.1611245572566986,
-0.7539142370223999,
-0.17208749055862427,
0.7260740399360657,
0.42107734084129333,
-0.19959788024425507,
0.7214819192886353,
-0.3906792998313904,
-0.22539834678173065,
0.6742111444473267,
0.049523722380399704,
0.899201512336731,
0.07234486937522888,
0.5668233633041382,
0.29868432879447937,
0.3251247704029083,
0.034322455525398254,
0.28167206048965454,
-0.2479294389486313,
-0.5130466222763062,
-0.39343246817588806,
0.23321859538555145,
-0.298611581325531,
0.1408529132604599,
-0.518103301525116,
0.3841184079647064,
-0.4311995506286621,
0.02168680541217327,
-0.15571537613868713,
-0.5394178628921509,
-0.6643474698066711,
0.186872199177742,
0.2761571705341339,
0.8338250517845154,
-0.7567564845085144,
0.3329399824142456,
0.9129116535186768,
-0.6999727487564087,
-0.40444672107696533,
-0.04738524183630943,
0.024914242327213287,
-0.476955384016037,
0.35808923840522766,
0.44424745440483093,
0.058944523334503174,
-0.20143675804138184,
-1.089311122894287,
0.022220715880393982,
0.991525411605835,
0.3265639543533325,
-0.8315488696098328,
0.28723615407943726,
0.1386006474494934,
0.3145945966243744,
-0.08540014177560806,
0.3556748330593109,
0.08844379335641861,
0.5264289379119873,
-0.05066453292965889,
-0.5039699673652649,
-0.11217234283685684,
-0.7255823612213135,
0.35391953587532043,
-0.05159085616469383,
-0.4717558026313782,
0.8819805979728699,
-0.3457087576389313,
-0.3161798119544983,
0.2346147894859314,
0.7299827933311462,
-0.2948729693889618,
0.49742788076400757,
0.8287827372550964,
0.17632189393043518,
0.4849777817726135,
-0.2373919039964676,
0.9214581847190857,
0.05881766229867935,
0.0625709816813469,
1.3279941082000732,
-0.08173903822898865,
0.39006343483924866,
0.4838271737098694,
0.06647680699825287,
0.4641342759132385,
0.6648317575454712,
-0.02073066495358944,
0.30334097146987915,
0.061207011342048645,
-0.37571221590042114,
-0.3599088191986084,
0.18225547671318054,
-0.4605364501476288,
-0.04176534339785576,
0.1924620419740677,
-0.5660563111305237,
-0.1530379205942154,
0.2177278995513916,
0.0043597533367574215,
0.5347484946250916,
-0.39757534861564636,
0.8593246936798096,
0.14137311279773712,
-0.5097374320030212,
0.4032689034938812,
-0.2545488476753235,
0.5197939872741699,
-0.416278600692749,
-0.4034513533115387,
-0.3980153501033783,
0.04783517122268677,
-0.01469101570546627,
-1.399803638458252,
-0.0737614557147026,
-0.13710381090641022,
-0.285112202167511,
-0.3594489097595215,
0.8545872569084167,
-0.5659331679344177,
-0.2565879821777344,
0.1684480607509613,
0.3838781714439392,
0.06649298220872879,
-0.4345686733722687,
-0.9139779806137085,
0.05150001868605614,
0.04109695926308632,
0.11119520664215088,
-0.1641116887331009,
0.3789535164833069,
-0.22566524147987366,
0.449413001537323,
0.49826955795288086,
-0.022332677617669106,
-0.05639105662703514,
0.7308877110481262,
0.7587859034538269,
-0.6306787729263306,
-0.8242495656013489,
-0.7118249535560608,
0.6856345534324646,
-0.6477226614952087,
-0.4658728837966919,
0.4787715971469879,
0.42470136284828186,
0.5487024188041687,
-0.3388875126838684,
1.1119410991668701,
0.20119649171829224,
0.07506180554628372,
-0.7273612022399902,
0.5672319531440735,
-0.6884743571281433,
0.10091222077608109,
-0.29897943139076233,
-0.9447668790817261,
-0.49877482652664185,
0.16880105435848236,
-0.15020693838596344,
-0.22948351502418518,
0.615336000919342,
1.2248753309249878,
-0.18358927965164185,
0.06556335091590881,
0.2136664092540741,
0.27732640504837036,
0.33079153299331665,
0.17772257328033447,
0.9261183142662048,
-0.4758892059326172,
0.6973315477371216,
-0.22966419160366058,
-0.12469352781772614,
-0.20210129022598267,
-0.8310918211936951,
-1.0515681505203247,
-0.9197497963905334,
-0.7519727349281311,
-0.41909900307655334,
0.4297362267971039,
0.7701367139816284,
0.5644261837005615,
-0.7112066745758057,
0.1975463479757309,
-0.31078335642814636,
0.29793545603752136,
-0.5345181822776794,
-0.1961565762758255,
0.2363283783197403,
-0.11042217910289764,
-0.6585323810577393,
0.10638659447431564,
0.5838133096694946,
0.4309433698654175,
-0.20472177863121033,
-0.07050824165344238,
0.2458917796611786,
-0.21764706075191498,
0.5067370533943176,
0.3253086805343628,
-0.2517131567001343,
0.0006843894370831549,
-0.09047944098711014,
-0.16667482256889343,
0.4569152593612671,
1.0150288343429565,
-0.5017457008361816,
0.7610240578651428,
0.7098393440246582,
0.47001513838768005,
0.3830138146877289,
-0.16166310012340546,
0.35027074813842773,
-0.97724848985672,
0.14183299243450165,
-0.258731484413147,
0.46541857719421387,
0.8812230825424194,
-0.23079334199428558,
0.29062825441360474,
0.48573511838912964,
-0.29211366176605225,
-0.32745739817619324,
0.09263775497674942,
-1.0411789417266846,
-0.2860369384288788,
1.2934635877609253,
-0.045403510332107544,
-0.25593137741088867,
0.16879941523075104,
-0.869839072227478,
0.024454107508063316,
-0.3412659764289856,
0.638177216053009,
0.2006158083677292,
0.4272485375404358,
-0.44485151767730713,
-0.10489300638437271,
0.22353486716747284,
0.19633087515830994,
-0.9206220507621765,
-0.3871925473213196,
0.5356959700584412,
0.24135418236255646,
-0.16038252413272858,
0.30687281489372253,
-0.16306836903095245,
0.44426998496055603,
0.09964349120855331,
0.3784032166004181,
-0.2967663109302521,
-0.3145514130592346,
-0.33866798877716064,
-0.14530721306800842,
-0.356111615896225,
-0.48601293563842773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19116v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19116v2
|
How to Understand "Support"? An Implicit-enhanced Causal Inference Approach for Weakly-supervised Phrase Grounding
| 2024-02-29T12:49:48 | 2024-03-04T08:42:56 |
Jiamin Luo, Jianing Zhao, Jingjing Wang, Guodong Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Weakly-supervised Phrase Grounding (WPG) is an emerging task of inferring the
fine-grained phrase-region matching, while merely leveraging the coarse-grained
sentence-image pairs for training. However, existing studies on WPG largely
ignore the implicit phrase-region matching relations, which are crucial for
evaluating the capability of models in understanding the deep multimodal
semantics. To this end, this paper proposes an Implicit-Enhanced Causal
Inference (IECI) approach to address the challenges of modeling the implicit
relations and highlighting them beyond the explicit. Specifically, this
approach leverages both the intervention and counterfactual techniques to
tackle the above two challenges respectively. Furthermore, a high-quality
implicit-enhanced dataset is annotated to evaluate IECI and detailed
evaluations show the great advantages of IECI over the state-of-the-art
baselines. Particularly, we observe an interesting finding that IECI
outperforms the advanced multimodal LLMs by a large margin on this
implicit-enhanced dataset, which may facilitate more research to evaluate the
multimodal LLMs in this direction.
|
[
-0.5374904274940491,
-0.7066548466682434,
0.9325961470603943,
0.4677751660346985,
-0.18343263864517212,
-0.5159348845481873,
-0.052420422434806824,
-0.33378836512565613,
-0.24911750853061676,
0.2449849545955658,
-0.884955883026123,
-0.6337521076202393,
-0.6502351760864258,
0.11149826645851135,
-0.07423866540193558,
0.8773967027664185,
0.018047910183668137,
0.31669843196868896,
-0.5604750514030457,
-0.24441193044185638,
-0.5941524505615234,
-0.16409221291542053,
-0.541305422782898,
-0.5127266049385071,
0.4993140399456024,
0.3943417966365814,
0.47442615032196045,
0.09737449139356613,
0.1872657686471939,
0.24780577421188354,
-0.09098019450902939,
0.2874818444252014,
-0.38720592856407166,
0.08647512644529343,
-0.005543916020542383,
-0.35182812809944153,
-0.45424526929855347,
0.13193801045417786,
0.20725896954536438,
0.7891846299171448,
0.3787384331226349,
-0.15695255994796753,
0.180061936378479,
0.43799328804016113,
-0.954328179359436,
0.17786885797977448,
-0.5863075852394104,
0.16214707493782043,
0.2897547483444214,
0.01541981752961874,
-0.5536561608314514,
-0.05440501123666763,
0.11585493385791779,
-0.7140616774559021,
0.16118337213993073,
-0.07073099911212921,
0.8559696674346924,
0.5194091796875,
-0.8933520317077637,
0.07294264435768127,
-0.5017911791801453,
0.6875283718109131,
-0.5077036619186401,
0.22419697046279907,
0.36315804719924927,
-0.027413155883550644,
-0.2764875590801239,
-0.5820318460464478,
-0.56820148229599,
-0.2548188865184784,
-0.49838337302207947,
0.6210483908653259,
-0.2742190957069397,
0.4270607531070709,
0.5088250041007996,
-0.0524267815053463,
-0.3223974108695984,
0.13212189078330994,
-0.08510398864746094,
-0.05663425102829933,
0.3683660626411438,
-0.19296403229236603,
0.2788117229938507,
-0.35255810618400574,
-0.6712831258773804,
0.22459813952445984,
-0.8369527459144592,
-0.026783909648656845,
0.05489202216267586,
0.20037929713726044,
-0.19978229701519012,
0.7029956579208374,
-0.3328665792942047,
0.30331405997276306,
0.25840049982070923,
0.125824436545372,
0.15889272093772888,
-0.2697621285915375,
-0.4063538610935211,
0.3755130171775818,
0.44690263271331787,
0.5296990871429443,
0.294260710477829,
-0.392617404460907,
0.14852125942707062,
0.42941421270370483,
0.05556236207485199,
-0.7463743686676025,
0.09071282297372818,
0.31847164034843445,
-0.5306568741798401,
-0.11491518467664719,
0.06827088445425034,
-0.6750019192695618,
-0.6414795517921448,
-0.6006197333335876,
0.47720998525619507,
-0.1947871744632721,
-0.21162940561771393,
-0.11551376432180405,
-0.4418941140174866,
0.35821500420570374,
0.32724934816360474,
-0.5330234169960022,
0.15982957184314728,
0.6999598741531372,
0.8885841369628906,
0.24984411895275116,
-0.17236711084842682,
-0.6780771017074585,
0.4635448753833771,
-0.30522069334983826,
0.9785392880439758,
-0.631491482257843,
-0.3811672031879425,
0.08375287055969238,
0.27083736658096313,
-0.09688957780599594,
-0.08469881117343903,
0.9232955574989319,
-0.2542479932308197,
0.17416499555110931,
-0.547356903553009,
-0.3845915198326111,
-0.08541369438171387,
0.18237891793251038,
-0.5305507183074951,
0.9723584651947021,
-0.36834824085235596,
-0.9374775886535645,
0.7117733359336853,
-0.18140706419944763,
-0.29643678665161133,
-0.3445829153060913,
-0.30210936069488525,
-0.40408551692962646,
0.46477264165878296,
0.6000226140022278,
0.4947957694530487,
-0.26153564453125,
0.6469571590423584,
-0.9249742031097412,
-0.5053238272666931,
-0.21998177468776703,
-0.5773597359657288,
0.36212313175201416,
-0.10882134735584259,
-0.687632143497467,
0.2511915862560272,
-0.9767706990242004,
-0.18216513097286224,
-0.31654441356658936,
0.3332008719444275,
-0.7134286761283875,
0.324695885181427,
0.08510202169418335,
0.5627865791320801,
-0.04817259684205055,
-0.5380852222442627,
0.06913630664348602,
-0.1755819022655487,
-0.009076932445168495,
0.9811317324638367,
-0.06627796590328217,
0.5273169875144958,
0.15333588421344757,
0.19161725044250488,
0.01838192157447338,
0.10499325394630432,
-0.1640097051858902,
-0.5170944929122925,
-0.6812628507614136,
-0.4212588369846344,
-0.03435419499874115,
0.5347188711166382,
-0.7522556781768799,
0.10058122128248215,
-0.24939048290252686,
-0.20763501524925232,
-0.4045529365539551,
0.10500969737768173,
0.5116541981697083,
0.7508871555328369,
0.6229109764099121,
0.3307613134384155,
-0.622409999370575,
-1.2169370651245117,
-0.039277780801057816,
-0.1441970020532608,
-0.06325079500675201,
0.6042280793190002,
0.4001680612564087,
-0.39153438806533813,
1.0185908079147339,
-0.5368825197219849,
-0.4635404944419861,
-0.15471164882183075,
0.5948755145072937,
0.04010314494371414,
0.5776671171188354,
0.546957790851593,
-1.046505093574524,
-0.11824002116918564,
-0.204535573720932,
-1.0777970552444458,
-0.6560366749763489,
-0.1888149082660675,
-0.34561532735824585,
-0.12080569565296173,
0.8370304107666016,
-0.5925198793411255,
0.39872318506240845,
0.6127030849456787,
-0.6297469735145569,
0.20831958949565887,
-0.2178381085395813,
0.3835580050945282,
-0.8499998450279236,
-0.03523262217640877,
0.4161415696144104,
-0.022476978600025177,
-0.45834964513778687,
-0.18363118171691895,
0.11243081092834473,
-0.08253739029169083,
-0.4190114736557007,
0.35810887813568115,
-0.5017419457435608,
0.007051865104585886,
-0.41361305117607117,
0.2969231903553009,
0.05751350522041321,
0.3758985996246338,
0.31234705448150635,
0.7554991841316223,
0.7839789390563965,
-0.4983327388763428,
0.052940573543310165,
0.13470862805843353,
0.24104592204093933,
0.8372834324836731,
-1.0540356636047363,
-0.20965678989887238,
-0.5635368824005127,
0.347367525100708,
-1.2940071821212769,
-0.056624636054039,
-0.026276661083102226,
-0.08981586992740631,
0.28657659888267517,
-0.7437781691551208,
-0.36870303750038147,
0.12352325767278671,
-0.46315962076187134,
0.39192116260528564,
0.31549179553985596,
-0.7376226186752319,
0.8294862508773804,
0.21976076066493988,
0.04740714281797409,
-0.6774874925613403,
-0.4217372536659241,
0.24548538029193878,
-0.4751465320587158,
-0.6705183982849121,
0.6755132079124451,
0.2702179253101349,
-0.4268462359905243,
0.13447073101997375,
-0.11339866369962692,
0.11001627147197723,
0.25863954424858093,
0.6431226134300232,
0.17908348143100739,
-0.39131924510002136,
0.22998733818531036,
0.3072667419910431,
-0.5335219502449036,
0.20322808623313904,
-0.2560780644416809,
0.005671951454132795,
-0.07841333001852036,
-0.4199473261833191,
-0.2408449947834015,
0.5483948588371277,
0.3535591959953308,
0.07654129713773727,
0.8232776522636414,
0.7886585593223572,
-0.4848739206790924,
0.0323617085814476,
-0.5753836631774902,
-0.05772954598069191,
-0.4578627645969391,
0.24285677075386047,
-0.38552531599998474,
-0.540637731552124,
0.21901769936084747,
-0.4171091914176941,
-0.3094477951526642,
0.33385366201400757,
-0.027309827506542206,
-0.01472788117825985,
1.5046017169952393,
0.7134882211685181,
-0.1642381250858307,
0.17250193655490875,
0.039881810545921326,
-0.09186770766973495,
-0.946229100227356,
-0.3549499213695526,
-0.5200374722480774,
-0.19513750076293945,
-0.8226639628410339,
-0.12571312487125397,
0.43602514266967773,
0.2908727824687958,
-0.21843257546424866,
0.0004521138034760952,
0.011799601837992668,
0.12493886798620224,
0.3629544973373413,
0.319537878036499,
0.12363243103027344,
-0.09128296375274658,
-0.15071368217468262,
-0.21516822278499603,
-0.41442057490348816,
-0.5083650946617126,
0.6280439496040344,
0.22938013076782227,
1.0112273693084717,
0.2202555388212204,
0.1998242288827896,
0.36480265855789185,
0.29856666922569275,
-0.477573424577713,
0.48877862095832825,
-0.22428853809833527,
-0.21022042632102966,
0.13130125403404236,
-0.16180124878883362,
-0.6371352672576904,
0.6255345344543457,
-0.5568082332611084,
-0.6942709684371948,
0.5305896401405334,
0.23012056946754456,
0.05796833336353302,
-0.1610785722732544,
-1.0297884941101074,
0.9243029952049255,
-0.11272244900465012,
-0.9813605546951294,
-0.11333095282316208,
-0.3717823624610901,
0.38250604271888733,
0.5103808045387268,
0.22037112712860107,
-0.04219745099544525,
-0.0925891175866127,
0.41345569491386414,
-0.1605633944272995,
1.0160990953445435,
-0.557782769203186,
-0.21773962676525116,
-0.06499974429607391,
-0.44403114914894104,
0.532234787940979,
0.49232417345046997,
0.09473234415054321,
0.008592715486884117,
-0.6200365424156189,
-0.538589358329773,
-0.6891661882400513,
1.164819598197937,
-0.5613554120063782,
-0.7596076726913452,
-0.3827410638332367,
-0.14044322073459625,
-0.49898597598075867,
0.08182056248188019,
0.03999446704983711,
0.5723828673362732,
-0.15075084567070007,
0.14908838272094727,
0.9689136147499084,
-0.23127084970474243,
0.42312678694725037,
0.2633190155029297,
0.2621743381023407,
-0.2790554165840149,
0.45938050746917725,
-0.2398139089345932,
0.03177565708756447,
0.36596038937568665,
0.13805754482746124,
-0.4562400281429291,
-0.40672609210014343,
-0.43627792596817017,
0.22458799183368683,
-0.8453279137611389,
-0.06819115579128265,
-1.0644652843475342,
0.38610681891441345,
-0.4914444386959076,
-0.21073924005031586,
-0.023506758734583855,
-0.1381845921278,
-0.203078955411911,
-0.5557076334953308,
0.3722900450229645,
0.5644575357437134,
0.010786192491650581,
0.24394755065441132,
-0.4806455671787262,
0.6006871461868286,
0.3373973071575165,
0.15595600008964539,
-0.2893921434879303,
-0.16966503858566284,
0.07127098739147186,
-0.19597236812114716,
0.016078229993581772,
-1.0685396194458008,
-0.004956535995006561,
0.3119180500507355,
0.6620174050331116,
0.4062935411930084,
0.06497447192668915,
1.232311487197876,
-0.6884254217147827,
0.765110194683075,
-0.06314121186733246,
-0.9198267459869385,
0.8340160846710205,
-0.16101785004138947,
0.10789388418197632,
0.5985020399093628,
0.41977375745773315,
-0.14902988076210022,
-0.47293946146965027,
-0.49907317757606506,
-1.358648657798767,
0.5064916610717773,
0.16737070679664612,
0.13762110471725464,
-0.13202905654907227,
0.34128785133361816,
-0.211015984416008,
0.11682554334402084,
-1.0329411029815674,
-0.4531162977218628,
-0.21738846600055695,
-0.4041955769062042,
-0.061503563076257706,
-0.4466155767440796,
-0.07515599578619003,
0.13381366431713104,
0.8027470707893372,
-0.5196897983551025,
0.25883498787879944,
0.4557276666164398,
-0.42979422211647034,
0.1261092573404312,
0.4046385586261749,
0.4944727122783661,
0.3765639364719391,
-0.22534975409507751,
0.45612695813179016,
0.2947995662689209,
-0.16035206615924835,
0.1033141240477562,
0.48859113454818726,
-0.23603549599647522,
-0.010770275257527828,
0.6482672691345215,
0.8560718297958374,
0.5225511193275452,
-0.5723477005958557,
0.6779552698135376,
-0.21932344138622284,
0.14957323670387268,
-0.2882300615310669,
-0.020060217007994652,
-0.17072173953056335,
0.3645959496498108,
0.5053793787956238,
-0.036736659705638885,
0.4234621524810791,
-0.3315199911594391,
0.4045014977455139,
0.6585526466369629,
-0.9245268702507019,
-0.21653634309768677,
0.7823557257652283,
0.19808329641819,
0.6538681983947754,
0.26176053285598755,
-0.035425689071416855,
-0.4250572621822357,
0.6827710270881653,
0.6480446457862854,
0.8572797179222107,
0.48699629306793213,
0.1874866932630539,
0.4150446057319641,
0.3679421842098236,
-0.13061116635799408,
0.14524014294147491,
-0.045556630939245224,
-0.44398364424705505,
-0.5952427983283997,
-0.15676453709602356,
0.07302650064229965,
0.2195039540529251,
-0.7276950478553772,
0.36074885725975037,
-0.15495629608631134,
-0.021014049649238586,
-0.24779658019542694,
-0.27988988161087036,
-0.5463695526123047,
0.5367358326911926,
0.41063550114631653,
0.7856734395027161,
-1.3417335748672485,
0.4204200208187103,
0.7845003008842468,
-0.4472546875476837,
-0.4077272415161133,
0.26544901728630066,
0.07383210957050323,
-0.5206597447395325,
0.9583028554916382,
0.42746400833129883,
-0.4717264175415039,
-0.19915392994880676,
-0.5259491205215454,
-0.6452358961105347,
1.1219532489776611,
0.38836470246315,
-0.3288671374320984,
0.18439990282058716,
-0.2060299962759018,
0.5188313126564026,
-0.36517801880836487,
0.742050290107727,
0.23498670756816864,
0.5022197961807251,
-0.15838615596294403,
-0.3098872900009155,
0.3739032447338104,
-0.3570999205112457,
0.024884574115276337,
-0.12190358340740204,
-0.4519985020160675,
0.4403746426105499,
-0.13339288532733917,
-0.11756676435470581,
-0.12660536170005798,
0.9793130159378052,
0.28355374932289124,
0.6427736282348633,
0.6122962832450867,
0.5190393328666687,
0.4372979402542114,
-0.29344573616981506,
1.1351408958435059,
-0.06265579164028168,
0.2665507197380066,
1.0599039793014526,
-0.3422536551952362,
0.4434525966644287,
0.603872537612915,
0.29198911786079407,
0.5126398801803589,
0.4939659535884857,
0.11963662505149841,
0.7737867832183838,
-0.19215285778045654,
-0.3731480538845062,
-0.4908257722854614,
-0.5671161413192749,
-0.32974687218666077,
0.2268349677324295,
0.29537463188171387,
-0.27453747391700745,
-0.3841162323951721,
0.11570288985967636,
0.05901872366666794,
0.14809538424015045,
-0.4704917073249817,
0.890123188495636,
0.06229279935359955,
-0.6122792959213257,
0.10180171579122543,
-0.02101544477045536,
0.6876945495605469,
-0.5078007578849792,
-0.35523921251296997,
-0.2864600718021393,
0.03690725192427635,
-0.3764517903327942,
-0.3883781135082245,
0.04560729116201401,
0.2092221975326538,
-0.3296316862106323,
-0.2207452952861786,
0.9317781329154968,
-0.3967611491680145,
-0.533260703086853,
0.7075197100639343,
0.469454824924469,
-0.5732520818710327,
0.01808427833020687,
-0.5667039752006531,
-0.21567314863204956,
-0.4376075565814972,
-0.15585967898368835,
0.29865211248397827,
0.7478540539741516,
-0.18425960838794708,
0.3552629053592682,
0.422998309135437,
-0.06485269218683243,
-0.23376917839050293,
0.5919073820114136,
0.8125628232955933,
-0.5542760491371155,
-0.3525201678276062,
-0.990117073059082,
0.7117231488227844,
-0.34209105372428894,
-0.2811071574687958,
0.864493727684021,
0.24747134745121002,
0.5177505016326904,
0.04071616381406784,
0.8394135236740112,
0.014498391188681126,
-0.23217220604419708,
-1.0481561422348022,
0.23158065974712372,
-0.670532763004303,
0.27706488966941833,
-0.6788631677627563,
-0.5754038095474243,
-0.18734727799892426,
0.519141435623169,
-0.31374719738960266,
0.006013860926032066,
0.6540380716323853,
0.7392963767051697,
-0.3153870105743408,
-0.14371919631958008,
0.21105869114398956,
0.3270331621170044,
0.4053322672843933,
0.3612711727619171,
0.9996919631958008,
-0.4506680369377136,
0.43265146017074585,
-0.09349726885557175,
-0.3489651381969452,
0.17757952213287354,
-1.2414371967315674,
-0.9566372632980347,
-0.22299717366695404,
-0.4515937566757202,
-0.3808787167072296,
0.1951722800731659,
0.9441965222358704,
0.7360283732414246,
-0.8032486438751221,
0.41093242168426514,
-0.36397916078567505,
0.24974887073040009,
-0.35863015055656433,
-0.2202823907136917,
0.46244359016418457,
-0.45488545298576355,
-0.8541290163993835,
0.5618553161621094,
0.20148345828056335,
-0.0643041655421257,
0.08981852233409882,
0.1760890781879425,
-0.16437505185604095,
0.001582713914103806,
0.6895663738250732,
-0.1857203245162964,
-0.5222208499908447,
-0.3829624652862549,
-0.08483804762363434,
-0.012009690515697002,
-0.2528935372829437,
0.9817548394203186,
-0.9576820731163025,
0.16345961391925812,
0.2659171223640442,
0.6793032288551331,
0.32913997769355774,
0.227569580078125,
0.6973183155059814,
-1.0883275270462036,
0.5284020900726318,
-0.27442747354507446,
0.7354766130447388,
0.31280311942100525,
-0.546488344669342,
0.46681615710258484,
0.4175620675086975,
-0.06622851639986038,
-0.6068648099899292,
0.2126186043024063,
-0.8545413613319397,
-0.41610634326934814,
1.397733211517334,
-0.3016487658023834,
-0.10582996904850006,
-0.3131931722164154,
-0.34904566407203674,
0.19118566811084747,
-0.33160150051116943,
0.6749132871627808,
0.5134069919586182,
-0.07390103489160538,
-0.28453490138053894,
-0.47046959400177,
0.5221718549728394,
0.5080238580703735,
-0.8359271883964539,
-0.18878063559532166,
0.8746667504310608,
-0.08759429305791855,
0.06251499801874161,
0.3737529218196869,
0.12477050721645355,
0.22174811363220215,
-0.042821064591407776,
-0.32512667775154114,
-0.07801518589258194,
-0.3816385567188263,
-0.44819971919059753,
0.3433992266654968,
-0.08550942689180374,
-0.07742565870285034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19103v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19103v1
|
Whispers that Shake Foundations: Analyzing and Mitigating False Premise Hallucinations in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-29T12:35:45 | 2024-02-29T12:35:45 |
Hongbang Yuan, Pengfei Cao, Zhuoran Jin, Yubo Chen, Daojian Zeng, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities but still
suffer from the issue of hallucinations. A significant type of this issue is
the false premise hallucination, which we define as the phenomenon when LLMs
generate hallucinated text when confronted with false premise questions. In
this paper, we perform a comprehensive analysis of the false premise
hallucination and elucidate its internal working mechanism: a small subset of
attention heads (which we designate as false premise heads) disturb the
knowledge extraction process, leading to the occurrence of false premise
hallucination. Based on our analysis, we propose \textbf{FAITH} (\textbf{F}alse
premise \textbf{A}ttention head constra\textbf{I}ining for mi\textbf{T}igating
\textbf{H}allucinations), a novel and effective method to mitigate false
premise hallucinations. It constrains the false premise attention heads during
the model inference process. Impressively, extensive experiments demonstrate
that constraining only approximately $1\%$ of the attention heads in the model
yields a notable increase of nearly $20\%$ of model performance.
|
[
-0.2825392782688141,
-0.9292520880699158,
0.6857908368110657,
0.3400841951370239,
-0.1429009586572647,
-0.002280622720718384,
0.01878652349114418,
-0.6358294486999512,
0.5276007652282715,
0.9070366024971008,
-0.582461416721344,
-0.25947365164756775,
-0.8390252590179443,
-0.013256684876978397,
-0.7048283815383911,
0.7829670906066895,
0.10237493366003036,
0.020786285400390625,
0.0014857262140139937,
0.09451624006032944,
-0.15776941180229187,
-0.15180400013923645,
-0.377562552690506,
-0.42416033148765564,
-0.013571619987487793,
0.08757779002189636,
0.9345345497131348,
0.5147849321365356,
0.4026205837726593,
0.20803363621234894,
-0.2870093882083893,
0.02593045122921467,
-0.875653862953186,
0.19310182332992554,
0.0391375832259655,
-0.7254559397697449,
-0.18158577382564545,
-0.0691477358341217,
0.63277667760849,
0.7901103496551514,
-0.22699446976184845,
0.035109635442495346,
0.042497579008340836,
0.5320764183998108,
-0.5946316719055176,
0.04983597621321678,
-1.1238645315170288,
0.19416971504688263,
-0.028230607509613037,
-0.45243239402770996,
-0.49486005306243896,
-0.3753082752227783,
0.5347247123718262,
-0.37413060665130615,
0.38144242763519287,
0.3333074152469635,
1.0741621255874634,
0.43247079849243164,
-0.22845107316970825,
-0.5217869877815247,
-0.5142889022827148,
0.7832699418067932,
-0.7243820428848267,
0.4288286566734314,
0.6219237446784973,
0.1348426789045334,
-0.48101234436035156,
-0.7255106568336487,
-0.5841490626335144,
-0.26105332374572754,
0.05953346937894821,
-0.2279432713985443,
0.08791196346282959,
0.26068323850631714,
0.5147479772567749,
0.6175630688667297,
-0.17411936819553375,
-0.3864383101463318,
-0.2683785557746887,
-0.347666472196579,
0.10759826749563217,
-0.17404206097126007,
0.2213708907365799,
-0.003292194101959467,
-0.30088773369789124,
-0.0549183264374733,
-0.946578860282898,
-0.01323613990098238,
0.07745193690061569,
0.32066887617111206,
0.021665308624505997,
0.6987032294273376,
-0.24493807554244995,
0.47724178433418274,
0.43780356645584106,
-0.651679515838623,
0.020686974748969078,
0.09702735394239426,
-0.5969387888908386,
0.34751570224761963,
0.5690745711326599,
0.20982421934604645,
0.16708621382713318,
-0.5538763403892517,
-0.3288046717643738,
0.31408604979515076,
0.3166010081768036,
-0.9759005308151245,
-0.10566868633031845,
0.2641356587409973,
-0.5876965522766113,
-0.6306049227714539,
-0.10056023299694061,
-0.6426960825920105,
-0.7473659515380859,
-0.12907131016254425,
0.8595293760299683,
-0.34278225898742676,
-0.5384132266044617,
0.4154723584651947,
-0.19989532232284546,
0.2370961308479309,
-0.17295309901237488,
-0.8168615698814392,
0.5679010152816772,
0.5228726863861084,
0.9362128973007202,
-0.05556201562285423,
-0.03415076062083244,
-0.5378912091255188,
0.17150655388832092,
-0.3783314824104309,
0.49887794256210327,
-0.4375940263271332,
-0.6209021210670471,
0.06741780787706375,
0.005317989271134138,
-0.09195263683795929,
-0.46938905119895935,
0.547472357749939,
-0.3551267087459564,
0.034226566553115845,
-0.8021134734153748,
-0.6014856696128845,
-0.3124362528324127,
0.11818502098321915,
-0.5415297150611877,
0.7795913815498352,
-0.31023380160331726,
-0.7991586923599243,
0.2725069522857666,
-0.1839393526315689,
-0.5574992299079895,
-0.3175722360610962,
-0.438451886177063,
-0.44789403676986694,
0.5247055888175964,
0.004209929145872593,
0.19664084911346436,
-0.3043936789035797,
0.3652838170528412,
-0.34450671076774597,
-0.4236830770969391,
0.362225741147995,
-0.3082893192768097,
0.8920806050300598,
-0.10430827736854553,
-0.980644941329956,
0.0063705830834805965,
-0.7544278502464294,
0.06329312175512314,
0.047169581055641174,
0.3626255393028259,
-0.17687273025512695,
0.1708822101354599,
-0.2706602215766907,
0.17979565262794495,
-0.08907648175954819,
-0.25173333287239075,
0.06996877491474152,
-0.813999593257904,
0.11618684232234955,
0.5271347761154175,
0.3974716067314148,
0.282643586397171,
-0.4405410587787628,
0.2779260277748108,
-0.07460557669401169,
-0.09237027913331985,
-0.02760268934071064,
-0.5064181685447693,
-0.994257390499115,
-0.14117830991744995,
-0.1399463266134262,
0.11927126348018646,
-0.4599667489528656,
0.36961495876312256,
-0.05522425100207329,
-0.15805664658546448,
-0.6201221942901611,
-0.23073476552963257,
0.47922971844673157,
0.7448480725288391,
0.4100612699985504,
0.03417796641588211,
-0.5581079721450806,
-1.0564789772033691,
-0.28970587253570557,
-0.22325551509857178,
0.2548504173755646,
-0.2990097105503082,
0.5925140380859375,
-0.10344938188791275,
1.140880823135376,
-0.4338117837905884,
-0.516122043132782,
0.050355155020952225,
0.4367773234844208,
0.08134916424751282,
0.19809943437576294,
0.5247373580932617,
-0.9040002226829529,
-0.2180626392364502,
-0.19893884658813477,
-0.7315574884414673,
-0.21440489590168,
-0.24942240118980408,
0.0717553049325943,
0.3204203248023987,
0.3138415515422821,
-1.005124568939209,
0.6368447542190552,
0.41339126229286194,
-0.3459591567516327,
0.9778612852096558,
0.4371708631515503,
0.14030621945858002,
-0.8314265608787537,
-0.005798387806862593,
-0.3795083463191986,
-0.0948973298072815,
-0.41221097111701965,
0.19703350961208344,
-0.10375256836414337,
0.06252139061689377,
0.02626163884997368,
0.21773603558540344,
-0.6561543941497803,
-0.09698405861854553,
-0.6352874636650085,
0.26822444796562195,
0.07854566723108292,
0.2447274923324585,
0.33091434836387634,
0.592803418636322,
0.9027528166770935,
-0.7297022938728333,
0.019377144053578377,
0.6052865982055664,
-0.36585959792137146,
0.31083646416664124,
-0.5360432863235474,
0.14818061888217926,
-0.04836778715252876,
0.14908654987812042,
-0.9505347609519958,
-0.1694415807723999,
0.34289979934692383,
-0.5318085551261902,
0.19456550478935242,
-0.08680121600627899,
-0.2761896848678589,
-0.18371690809726715,
-0.2563304901123047,
-0.2837027907371521,
0.45289918780326843,
-0.46456781029701233,
0.7965362071990967,
0.40690290927886963,
0.23400776088237762,
-0.8609828948974609,
-0.8353651165962219,
0.3871121108531952,
-0.21330609917640686,
-0.6654914617538452,
0.3633209466934204,
-0.06933111697435379,
-0.7675864100456238,
0.21164874732494354,
-0.7184489369392395,
0.14996293187141418,
0.12387164682149887,
0.4678625166416168,
-0.16446657478809357,
-0.47225621342658997,
0.029638344421982765,
0.30992379784584045,
0.01705627329647541,
0.5064399242401123,
-0.4959404766559601,
0.3929235339164734,
-0.08692669868469238,
-0.3219189941883087,
-0.4360779821872711,
0.041325632482767105,
0.8967196941375732,
0.0024453778751194477,
1.0840198993682861,
0.29161664843559265,
-0.6886076927185059,
-0.5081793069839478,
-0.925071656703949,
-0.5661185383796692,
-0.48655661940574646,
0.3167187571525574,
-0.7115355134010315,
-0.6049226522445679,
0.6811269521713257,
0.05171170458197594,
-0.004208228085190058,
0.23259322345256805,
0.6351709961891174,
0.18882395327091217,
0.7236835360527039,
0.6227105259895325,
-0.08284278213977814,
-0.1439606249332428,
-0.19417883455753326,
0.5257388353347778,
-0.47411224246025085,
-0.17875179648399353,
-0.5034160017967224,
-0.12463339418172836,
-0.17898990213871002,
-0.47512245178222656,
0.2929825484752655,
0.22572851181030273,
0.38051673769950867,
0.1649978756904602,
-0.3080121576786041,
0.525715708732605,
0.10684634000062943,
-0.062427859753370285,
0.416945219039917,
0.07817747443914413,
-0.32761162519454956,
-0.2623675465583801,
-0.2767687141895294,
-0.47396203875541687,
0.8985670804977417,
0.5373675227165222,
0.6060241460800171,
0.057914528995752335,
0.6402257084846497,
0.15974630415439606,
0.1001901775598526,
-0.9093617796897888,
0.49915072321891785,
0.4965499937534332,
-0.791972815990448,
-0.35336288809776306,
-0.33664941787719727,
-0.2568662464618683,
0.6091316342353821,
-0.5207713842391968,
-0.8602016568183899,
0.35498252511024475,
0.0926022157073021,
-0.39815208315849304,
0.4689417779445648,
-0.3539486825466156,
0.5704811215400696,
-0.1431206464767456,
-0.3810794949531555,
-0.4615825116634369,
-0.5857752561569214,
0.5812395215034485,
-0.08831754326820374,
0.1363275796175003,
0.057924218475818634,
0.30758902430534363,
0.6648383140563965,
-0.17451560497283936,
1.0744808912277222,
-0.20085778832435608,
-0.579289436340332,
0.4605485200881958,
0.44995132088661194,
0.9507671594619751,
-0.022322099655866623,
-0.02218153141438961,
-0.05641661956906319,
-0.05711504444479942,
-0.08897809684276581,
-0.461849182844162,
0.5749997496604919,
-0.5211905241012573,
-0.7739942073822021,
-0.4507274031639099,
-0.5295618176460266,
-0.6331906914710999,
0.33038613200187683,
0.5215626955032349,
0.40663614869117737,
-0.28167954087257385,
0.4304046332836151,
1.180854320526123,
0.08456037938594818,
0.23401720821857452,
0.4427906572818756,
-0.462959349155426,
-0.28670161962509155,
0.6663601398468018,
0.09026669710874557,
0.5531885027885437,
0.26416516304016113,
0.29459309577941895,
-0.42662012577056885,
-0.7871565818786621,
0.09736110270023346,
0.34963592886924744,
-0.8322248458862305,
-0.08617319911718369,
-0.9781988859176636,
-0.1699291318655014,
-0.6719924807548523,
0.060048799961805344,
-0.4151136875152588,
-0.4255072772502899,
-0.0752805545926094,
-0.36380913853645325,
0.08719930052757263,
0.5694858431816101,
0.21128018200397491,
0.5405186414718628,
-0.5370243191719055,
0.8414000868797302,
0.08192861825227737,
0.19072113931179047,
0.17122244834899902,
-0.5903164148330688,
-0.2075115293264389,
0.22296011447906494,
-0.32180920243263245,
-0.986289918422699,
0.30460602045059204,
0.0007197848171927035,
0.4582434296607971,
0.9765331149101257,
0.3389245271682739,
0.9970238208770752,
-0.3878779709339142,
0.4694490432739258,
0.2117580771446228,
-1.2081588506698608,
0.08022571355104446,
-0.22543705999851227,
-0.15977536141872406,
0.5233120918273926,
0.2914292514324188,
-0.4966326355934143,
-0.831621527671814,
-0.5494247674942017,
-0.5388776659965515,
0.36144718527793884,
0.4386921525001526,
-0.17638054490089417,
-0.02018599770963192,
0.3252348303794861,
0.1765575408935547,
0.5528770089149475,
-0.9470784068107605,
-0.19214101135730743,
-0.05533648654818535,
-0.08881707489490509,
0.5689194798469543,
-0.7273055911064148,
-0.45990005135536194,
0.04098673164844513,
0.8474267721176147,
-0.232736274600029,
0.0887375921010971,
0.4352615475654602,
-0.3702152967453003,
-0.7006243467330933,
-0.17192566394805908,
0.6142756342887878,
0.9957419633865356,
-0.21852600574493408,
0.23425604403018951,
-0.03721126541495323,
-0.49755945801734924,
-0.15552997589111328,
-0.2897021472454071,
-0.5017880201339722,
0.05041342228651047,
0.5550270080566406,
1.0251094102859497,
0.37270599603652954,
-0.4596271216869354,
0.31735751032829285,
0.18341021239757538,
-0.2887404263019562,
-0.5142713785171509,
-0.012476848438382149,
0.1317017823457718,
0.23627300560474396,
0.6698116660118103,
0.18337829411029816,
0.30336299538612366,
-0.6241961717605591,
0.39199772477149963,
0.6559716463088989,
-0.3909023106098175,
-0.4383598864078522,
0.6838080286979675,
0.004744954407215118,
0.007863537408411503,
0.3094368875026703,
-0.028009045869112015,
-0.7835000157356262,
0.36776313185691833,
0.9449155926704407,
1.1903674602508545,
-0.12622492015361786,
0.2729327082633972,
0.2234242558479309,
0.6463481783866882,
-0.6101497411727905,
0.0853571742773056,
0.052029311656951904,
-0.8933073878288269,
-0.5035934448242188,
-0.8559948801994324,
-0.35462015867233276,
0.3405289649963379,
-0.6104787588119507,
0.3399335443973541,
-0.416748583316803,
-0.1829681247472763,
-0.4213155508041382,
-0.03621813282370567,
0.10558554530143738,
0.3268436789512634,
0.34111902117729187,
0.7940215468406677,
-0.8820799589157104,
0.6691260933876038,
0.0964997187256813,
-0.23891820013523102,
-0.4046798050403595,
0.6658253073692322,
0.25031164288520813,
-0.7672044634819031,
0.43666893243789673,
0.2920851409435272,
-0.8140893578529358,
-0.0019845280330628157,
-0.6313507556915283,
-0.9627351760864258,
0.5967070460319519,
0.2816956341266632,
-0.6001566648483276,
-0.2834509611129761,
0.23772750794887543,
0.3170667886734009,
-0.35671162605285645,
-0.23716603219509125,
0.6637362241744995,
0.6529049873352051,
0.28120115399360657,
-0.9326056241989136,
0.357908695936203,
0.15810412168502808,
-0.5368945002555847,
0.037047553807497025,
-0.4295433759689331,
0.49434927105903625,
-0.4894827902317047,
-0.40598633885383606,
0.2503504157066345,
0.7951568961143494,
0.28973284363746643,
0.24122656881809235,
0.5676312446594238,
0.6157883405685425,
0.988959789276123,
-0.029540199786424637,
0.829430103302002,
-0.35535240173339844,
0.3564606010913849,
0.9477789402008057,
-0.5085245370864868,
0.5362436771392822,
0.7178170084953308,
0.02185269445180893,
0.211832195520401,
0.21937569975852966,
0.16816012561321259,
0.6020824909210205,
0.18317373096942902,
0.010146178305149078,
-0.3016420304775238,
-0.025519294664263725,
-0.4436774253845215,
0.29436177015304565,
0.5910825133323669,
-0.10878186672925949,
0.13425971567630768,
-0.0785256028175354,
0.19206860661506653,
0.10203485935926437,
-0.0525951161980629,
0.44264912605285645,
0.4592617154121399,
-0.5035386681556702,
0.8154839873313904,
-0.19863347709178925,
0.3832593560218811,
-0.7658396363258362,
-0.030055329203605652,
0.11460299789905548,
0.21230070292949677,
-0.23968729376792908,
-0.20043285191059113,
0.5032517910003662,
-0.45128104090690613,
-0.22672049701213837,
-0.1382654458284378,
0.6407908797264099,
-0.5314846634864807,
-0.3509623408317566,
0.4730408787727356,
0.10864156484603882,
-0.1273329257965088,
-0.5151433944702148,
-0.4649659991264343,
0.3886314928531647,
0.09813099354505539,
-0.39617177844047546,
0.10885162651538849,
0.6925172209739685,
0.004510477185249329,
0.8166767358779907,
0.5278575420379639,
0.3950308859348297,
0.032438043504953384,
-0.009001068770885468,
0.6388875246047974,
-0.6378926634788513,
-0.7414180636405945,
-0.7968395352363586,
0.23624403774738312,
-0.09730163961648941,
-0.1311945617198944,
0.8524172902107239,
0.43681424856185913,
0.27870795130729675,
-0.10119442641735077,
0.7008792757987976,
-0.06733217090368271,
0.48032212257385254,
-0.7073837518692017,
1.1423965692520142,
-0.5201133489608765,
0.14786601066589355,
-0.31378501653671265,
-1.0541722774505615,
-0.1815183311700821,
0.932121992111206,
-0.18798524141311646,
-0.30797386169433594,
1.2060198783874512,
0.7003389596939087,
0.1624508947134018,
0.3982493281364441,
0.40763235092163086,
0.99649578332901,
0.17855536937713623,
0.08783745020627975,
0.6633081436157227,
-0.4171239733695984,
0.4766930937767029,
-0.18883179128170013,
-0.08807789534330368,
-0.22451594471931458,
-0.8027870059013367,
-1.238467812538147,
-0.6098843812942505,
-0.43726828694343567,
-0.7552539706230164,
0.05059906095266342,
0.9240948557853699,
0.5336766242980957,
-1.1421197652816772,
-0.3932616710662842,
-0.11007198691368103,
0.1120610162615776,
-0.28518354892730713,
-0.23977912962436676,
0.41739127039909363,
-0.4000200033187866,
-0.48945939540863037,
0.6318262219429016,
0.18342402577400208,
0.14577430486679077,
-0.388082355260849,
-0.09265695512294769,
-0.02150605246424675,
0.1471281200647354,
0.42384177446365356,
0.09389422833919525,
-1.059484601020813,
-0.290113627910614,
0.15693122148513794,
0.03227710351347923,
-0.18306687474250793,
0.9237214922904968,
-0.7186473608016968,
0.21625341475009918,
0.17176614701747894,
0.6884357333183289,
0.46456265449523926,
-0.07504022866487503,
0.6227719783782959,
-0.5684203505516052,
0.39716121554374695,
0.271634578704834,
0.37110695242881775,
0.143024742603302,
-0.497662752866745,
0.28960278630256653,
0.5199833512306213,
-0.07628130167722702,
-1.3064106702804565,
0.2877713441848755,
-0.8091636896133423,
-0.2900516092777252,
1.0312665700912476,
0.2872426509857178,
-0.2892117500305176,
-0.17134784162044525,
-0.1944846510887146,
0.12137118726968765,
-0.11577288061380386,
1.3276242017745972,
0.9604418277740479,
0.2509241998195648,
0.018877938389778137,
-0.4842545688152313,
0.8877403736114502,
0.44561767578125,
-0.2226809859275818,
0.34974154829978943,
0.4161355197429657,
0.17799729108810425,
0.4973101317882538,
0.5721253156661987,
-0.20166799426078796,
-0.028608419001102448,
0.20170049369335175,
0.042491614818573,
0.10194503515958786,
-0.5770474672317505,
-0.02690858207643032,
0.5114316940307617,
-0.05950509384274483,
0.031330738216638565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19097v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19097v1
|
TEncDM: Understanding the Properties of Diffusion Model in the Space of Language Model Encodings
| 2024-02-29T12:25:45 | 2024-02-29T12:25:45 |
Alexander Shabalin, Viacheslav Meshchaninov, Tingir Badmaev, Dmitry Molchanov, Grigory Bartosh, Sergey Markov, Dmitry Vetrov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2; I.7
|
Drawing inspiration from the success of diffusion models in various domains,
numerous research papers proposed methods for adapting them to text data.
Despite these efforts, none of them has managed to achieve the quality of the
large language models. In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive analysis of
key components of the text diffusion models and introduce a novel approach
named Text Encoding Diffusion Model (TEncDM). Instead of the commonly used
token embedding space, we train our model in the space of the language model
encodings. Additionally, we propose to use a Transformer-based decoder that
utilizes contextual information for text reconstruction. We also analyse
self-conditioning and find that it increases the magnitude of the model
outputs, allowing the reduction of the number of denoising steps at the
inference stage. Evaluation of TEncDM on two downstream text generation tasks,
QQP and XSum, demonstrates its superiority over existing non-autoregressive
models.
|
[
-0.28001371026039124,
-0.8771520853042603,
0.6094282865524292,
0.29523855447769165,
-0.12195837497711182,
-0.08643108606338501,
-0.11822041124105453,
0.22306935489177704,
-0.025190528482198715,
0.6892558336257935,
-0.2787894010543823,
-0.5070885419845581,
-0.9044502377510071,
-0.013291354291141033,
-0.8212825655937195,
0.7287878394126892,
-0.06399326771497726,
0.1060580462217331,
-0.3516412675380707,
-0.06575576961040497,
-0.3246147930622101,
-0.8114919662475586,
-0.6950039863586426,
-0.2744947373867035,
-0.12336201220750809,
-0.13949382305145264,
0.5055518746376038,
0.502288818359375,
0.27530989050865173,
0.2392493188381195,
-0.47123152017593384,
-0.20022094249725342,
-0.573203980922699,
0.15784624218940735,
-0.09130429476499557,
-0.14577125012874603,
-0.22833579778671265,
0.07174516469240189,
0.9338132739067078,
0.9162288308143616,
-0.2616877853870392,
-0.28312593698501587,
0.08919022977352142,
0.6872663497924805,
-0.4894798994064331,
-0.22784408926963806,
-0.1797468364238739,
-0.03377941995859146,
0.09810727834701538,
0.06321097165346146,
-0.7417563796043396,
-0.1673021912574768,
-0.17165331542491913,
-0.32097575068473816,
0.40334081649780273,
-0.10183451324701309,
0.368383526802063,
0.18786124885082245,
-0.9343342781066895,
-0.44452527165412903,
-0.9579300284385681,
0.7485656142234802,
-0.7609026432037354,
0.3874064087867737,
0.577592134475708,
0.0897931158542633,
0.032796405255794525,
-0.8258771300315857,
-0.7178986072540283,
0.21002034842967987,
-0.11580546945333481,
0.07274454832077026,
-0.22034725546836853,
-0.17635509371757507,
-0.25967082381248474,
0.5320560932159424,
-0.47136086225509644,
-0.11843042820692062,
-0.08665350824594498,
0.084809310734272,
0.45702043175697327,
0.2400810867547989,
0.5074188113212585,
-0.13212552666664124,
-0.4195437431335449,
-0.22594888508319855,
-0.33811673521995544,
-0.43135371804237366,
0.22730040550231934,
0.06233219802379608,
-0.4244562089443207,
0.09038782864809036,
-0.04321680963039398,
0.5192062258720398,
0.2146175652742386,
-0.016643090173602104,
0.11418624967336655,
-0.538090169429779,
-0.3515050411224365,
-0.11523106694221497,
0.6748799681663513,
0.017047889530658722,
0.019321072846651077,
-0.21547579765319824,
-0.18100981414318085,
-0.0684501975774765,
0.5270854234695435,
-0.9335642457008362,
-0.41655656695365906,
0.1484069675207138,
-0.741582989692688,
-0.3791133165359497,
-0.3450690507888794,
-0.44242072105407715,
-0.2945815324783325,
0.06690508127212524,
0.36119362711906433,
-0.4804222881793976,
-0.5193634033203125,
0.37381210923194885,
-0.22877785563468933,
0.13427188992500305,
0.299755334854126,
-1.0341970920562744,
0.6184361577033997,
0.31683510541915894,
0.8769732117652893,
-0.7175496220588684,
-0.0893096998333931,
-0.08831745386123657,
0.23153528571128845,
-0.4684497117996216,
0.9733671545982361,
-0.6001508235931396,
-0.4790612757205963,
-0.051584597676992416,
0.030600104480981827,
-0.32025113701820374,
-0.44724953174591064,
0.45881691575050354,
-0.809249758720398,
0.4617723524570465,
-0.003559047356247902,
-0.9563785791397095,
-0.39789703488349915,
0.265449196100235,
-0.7864830493927002,
0.8928757905960083,
0.3239233195781708,
-0.6405264139175415,
0.11301789432764053,
-0.5035117268562317,
-0.307140052318573,
-0.08153186738491058,
0.2907159626483917,
-0.464672327041626,
0.35590964555740356,
0.10214526951313019,
0.513043999671936,
-0.18102994561195374,
0.44501596689224243,
-0.3162815570831299,
0.044189564883708954,
0.15119804441928864,
-0.7029094099998474,
0.7507839798927307,
0.39182910323143005,
0.12248082458972931,
-0.02089686132967472,
-0.5684989094734192,
-0.33764421939849854,
0.07796262949705124,
-0.3362463116645813,
-0.6750632524490356,
-0.1388237178325653,
0.23401357233524323,
0.25246548652648926,
-0.11736410111188889,
-0.3596094846725464,
0.21272440254688263,
-0.14309823513031006,
0.4847131669521332,
0.44215670228004456,
0.4769943952560425,
1.1511282920837402,
0.09677018225193024,
0.603480875492096,
0.37394243478775024,
-0.10607265681028366,
-0.4724246561527252,
-0.31737279891967773,
-0.5018952488899231,
0.030968407168984413,
0.44328874349594116,
0.08276280760765076,
-0.6515992283821106,
0.14874234795570374,
-0.18376246094703674,
-0.24776753783226013,
-0.05953289940953255,
0.036110322922468185,
0.06550364941358566,
0.2614441514015198,
0.25651586055755615,
-0.28864943981170654,
-0.033106788992881775,
-0.29363781213760376,
0.0032235714606940746,
0.04937877878546715,
0.16708649694919586,
0.17636853456497192,
0.4343907833099365,
-0.34323883056640625,
0.8139384388923645,
-0.5252375602722168,
-0.28366154432296753,
-0.5640708208084106,
0.14287054538726807,
0.031480103731155396,
0.6335164308547974,
0.6537672281265259,
-0.7683675289154053,
-0.5091859102249146,
-0.257193922996521,
-0.741666316986084,
-0.1889568418264389,
-0.3391733765602112,
-0.06796076893806458,
0.1277056336402893,
0.723963737487793,
-0.29710817337036133,
0.4745657444000244,
0.9018635153770447,
-0.8214651346206665,
0.4113602638244629,
-0.6750648021697998,
0.07409463077783585,
-1.1110421419143677,
-0.027091342955827713,
-0.05983763933181763,
-0.35636064410209656,
-1.1195251941680908,
0.14071649312973022,
0.32749414443969727,
-0.22831110656261444,
-0.4568156599998474,
1.0679868459701538,
-0.6814488768577576,
0.1497795283794403,
-0.5832353830337524,
0.23723098635673523,
0.23220428824424744,
0.3550529479980469,
0.25438982248306274,
0.7186287045478821,
0.3163308799266815,
-1.0022696256637573,
-0.09110012650489807,
0.33818209171295166,
-0.2050650417804718,
0.45857807993888855,
-0.4906138777732849,
-0.014934441074728966,
-0.19940871000289917,
0.21955983340740204,
-1.3050470352172852,
0.18912312388420105,
0.09332288056612015,
-0.29917365312576294,
0.4419807493686676,
-0.004357771947979927,
-0.35117214918136597,
-0.14981697499752045,
0.02638208121061325,
0.7527028322219849,
0.5629013180732727,
-0.4558667838573456,
0.7155015468597412,
0.47015151381492615,
0.06584528088569641,
-0.028871044516563416,
-0.45963576436042786,
0.21711529791355133,
-0.4471742510795593,
-0.5046011209487915,
0.46533435583114624,
-0.26168563961982727,
-0.06946174055337906,
-0.011655409820377827,
0.014576558023691177,
-0.3110406994819641,
0.5118483304977417,
0.007309670560061932,
-0.3454364240169525,
0.025397395715117455,
0.13903005421161652,
0.3896261751651764,
-0.23026321828365326,
0.2109520137310028,
-0.547480583190918,
0.6523429751396179,
0.6352531313896179,
-0.2033972591161728,
-0.42641711235046387,
0.20615030825138092,
0.25303950905799866,
0.07720905542373657,
1.0105361938476562,
0.6406379342079163,
-0.2661152482032776,
-0.4430460035800934,
-0.2169043868780136,
-0.08395636826753616,
-0.4423028826713562,
0.16339805722236633,
-0.40194663405418396,
-0.711381733417511,
0.5797153115272522,
-0.4533030688762665,
-0.461584210395813,
0.5454959273338318,
0.7461187839508057,
-0.013373492285609245,
0.888545036315918,
0.9908627271652222,
0.028613531962037086,
0.5202679634094238,
-0.5809782147407532,
0.1358100324869156,
-0.8605532646179199,
-0.1428135186433792,
-0.5459673404693604,
-0.026225045323371887,
-0.18569444119930267,
-0.6340075731277466,
-0.005980462301522493,
0.19808995723724365,
-0.09723830968141556,
0.25447943806648254,
-0.2602591812610626,
0.22290273010730743,
0.3945007622241974,
-0.10769001394510269,
0.29862073063850403,
0.09960594028234482,
-0.2882346510887146,
0.030314579606056213,
-0.8517364859580994,
-0.5391298532485962,
0.7877650856971741,
0.34980690479278564,
0.9306515455245972,
0.17974451184272766,
0.6040593981742859,
0.7803686857223511,
0.03943366929888725,
-0.3483734130859375,
0.24460439383983612,
-0.4219896197319031,
-0.4627940058708191,
-0.343561053276062,
-0.31578654050827026,
-0.9735845327377319,
0.17314200103282928,
0.018679294735193253,
-0.34353572130203247,
0.5130168199539185,
-0.17193597555160522,
-0.08558060228824615,
0.31505972146987915,
-0.6051367521286011,
0.87900310754776,
0.3025001585483551,
-0.09412427246570587,
-0.36923152208328247,
-0.1982453316450119,
0.41403132677078247,
-0.2934982478618622,
0.3296636641025543,
-0.056687239557504654,
-0.02265962027013302,
0.8052038550376892,
-0.3015572726726532,
0.9518882632255554,
-0.2035733163356781,
-0.4503690004348755,
0.2517188787460327,
0.4703288674354553,
0.25202232599258423,
-0.09078291803598404,
-0.15150359272956848,
0.24308502674102783,
0.08406385034322739,
-0.4838464856147766,
-0.6108768582344055,
0.6069072484970093,
-0.7925654053688049,
-0.49007123708724976,
-0.22544845938682556,
-0.43057799339294434,
0.1814345419406891,
0.28016677498817444,
0.217271625995636,
0.5662611126899719,
-0.5060319304466248,
0.13011524081230164,
0.710898756980896,
-0.48062434792518616,
0.8039250373840332,
0.4139329791069031,
-0.2658436596393585,
-0.3836406171321869,
0.629589319229126,
-0.10876118391752243,
0.5531256794929504,
0.47094959020614624,
0.26424700021743774,
-0.36271220445632935,
-0.7247694730758667,
-0.44556328654289246,
0.3384458124637604,
-0.7784421443939209,
-0.13940370082855225,
-1.0674866437911987,
-0.2670528292655945,
-0.5162190794944763,
-0.037443857640028,
-0.23457078635692596,
-0.62147057056427,
-0.6158278584480286,
0.07017375528812408,
0.04269472882151604,
0.9820868968963623,
0.05867631360888481,
0.8165551424026489,
-0.7482151985168457,
0.3877812623977661,
0.0780249536037445,
0.23403632640838623,
0.3152330219745636,
-1.0421276092529297,
-0.556216299533844,
-0.11599068343639374,
-0.3093198239803314,
-0.8506801724433899,
0.8563922047615051,
0.20150192081928253,
0.555204451084137,
0.5043572187423706,
0.20902054011821747,
0.29832741618156433,
-0.3889421820640564,
1.0554683208465576,
-0.0996832475066185,
-1.18672776222229,
0.38259032368659973,
0.07642722874879837,
0.4626242220401764,
0.012036644853651524,
0.35757675766944885,
-0.7975561022758484,
-0.4398135542869568,
-0.6302983164787292,
-0.49274682998657227,
0.6943992972373962,
0.41775450110435486,
0.6512277722358704,
-0.41268226504325867,
0.4651137590408325,
0.10574761033058167,
-0.09285523742437363,
-0.6003398299217224,
-0.34402695298194885,
-0.27490755915641785,
-0.21115374565124512,
-0.156931072473526,
-0.7560073137283325,
0.25248801708221436,
0.21808236837387085,
0.6141685843467712,
-0.008925226517021656,
0.42996856570243835,
0.055018264800310135,
-0.5286107063293457,
0.3413366973400116,
-0.05470369756221771,
0.6291545033454895,
0.19317349791526794,
0.1483924388885498,
0.322339802980423,
0.031917672604322433,
-0.639457643032074,
0.5631074905395508,
-0.4335297644138336,
-0.3338419795036316,
0.18449603021144867,
0.463422954082489,
0.7417721748352051,
0.032705776393413544,
-0.07252611964941025,
0.6170289516448975,
-0.4035302698612213,
-0.1640905886888504,
-0.028551870957016945,
0.10930515825748444,
0.23896382749080658,
-0.023716211318969727,
0.46061450242996216,
-0.2522726356983185,
0.265065997838974,
-0.16801045835018158,
0.17204399406909943,
0.37766149640083313,
-0.44185498356819153,
-0.5975899696350098,
1.0073347091674805,
0.2682921290397644,
-0.29464516043663025,
0.5754860043525696,
-0.3365311920642853,
-0.334760457277298,
0.6649423837661743,
0.8975529074668884,
0.9854029417037964,
-0.3347760736942291,
0.3932279646396637,
0.4149670898914337,
0.08856938034296036,
-0.23111820220947266,
-0.06920775026082993,
-0.3056970536708832,
-1.0846376419067383,
-0.46843594312667847,
-0.6302538514137268,
-0.14143602550029755,
-0.1946132630109787,
-0.5470165610313416,
0.015032447874546051,
-0.25321677327156067,
-0.21532824635505676,
-0.2465217411518097,
-0.16498354077339172,
-0.40269240736961365,
0.3297555446624756,
0.06786071509122849,
1.0089504718780518,
-1.1074998378753662,
1.1922483444213867,
0.33893492817878723,
-0.04585905000567436,
-0.3680912256240845,
0.0240172166377306,
-0.40766334533691406,
-0.8216040730476379,
0.6860427856445312,
-0.21795663237571716,
0.14881376922130585,
0.3094724714756012,
-0.29849639534950256,
-0.9254005551338196,
0.9241847395896912,
0.07468119263648987,
-0.003040618496015668,
-0.008900701999664307,
0.013618554919958115,
0.5735043287277222,
-0.5548346042633057,
0.31430116295814514,
0.5406532883644104,
0.2884603440761566,
-0.08529555052518845,
-0.2178165316581726,
0.11797834187746048,
-0.1316850632429123,
0.491258829832077,
0.1799335777759552,
-0.4853151738643646,
0.5976807475090027,
-0.20049741864204407,
-0.5994006395339966,
0.116562619805336,
0.7015969753265381,
-0.19981054961681366,
0.07935597002506256,
0.14185677468776703,
0.5233070254325867,
0.5245246291160583,
0.09905420243740082,
1.190285325050354,
-0.5579898953437805,
0.6529402136802673,
0.9491976499557495,
-0.14774133265018463,
0.5298993587493896,
0.33195340633392334,
-0.14520739018917084,
0.7280672788619995,
0.36583399772644043,
0.2169683426618576,
0.7182027697563171,
-0.07241062074899673,
-0.15260308980941772,
-0.12201898545026779,
0.11746679991483688,
-0.17541354894638062,
0.24765156209468842,
0.2856486141681671,
-0.5813227891921997,
-0.24843640625476837,
0.3590812683105469,
-0.06081072613596916,
0.3667030930519104,
-0.01823815330862999,
1.1392977237701416,
0.09804114699363708,
-0.10363677889108658,
0.6034812331199646,
0.2878642976284027,
0.43651390075683594,
-0.2714588940143585,
0.2640376091003418,
-0.872795045375824,
0.09312686324119568,
0.13130493462085724,
-0.6737548112869263,
0.5483191013336182,
-0.39911752939224243,
-0.40222877264022827,
-0.6781609058380127,
0.6349748373031616,
-0.4586102068424225,
-0.4965534806251526,
0.35476070642471313,
0.6452178955078125,
0.1970735639333725,
-0.16651207208633423,
-0.44187161326408386,
0.12966059148311615,
-0.008456708863377571,
-0.3107750713825226,
0.3283943235874176,
0.8928770422935486,
0.0017919440288096666,
0.8738645315170288,
0.39421510696411133,
0.15819598734378815,
-0.05845845490694046,
0.27796751260757446,
0.5356490015983582,
-0.9772039651870728,
-0.6992633938789368,
-0.9891287088394165,
0.18976429104804993,
0.11271467059850693,
-0.04319203644990921,
0.9083329439163208,
0.3647826313972473,
0.49646618962287903,
-0.1639813631772995,
0.4968877136707306,
0.2713868021965027,
0.2802141010761261,
-0.5340914130210876,
0.9021023511886597,
-0.22276394069194794,
0.3664468824863434,
-0.2358918935060501,
-0.8704987168312073,
-0.3366810083389282,
0.3981671631336212,
-0.10767746716737747,
0.15621481835842133,
0.8306471109390259,
0.4715571999549866,
-0.09322234243154526,
-0.24161770939826965,
0.6622573137283325,
0.22849111258983612,
0.42191505432128906,
0.22723759710788727,
0.7010955810546875,
-0.6693866848945618,
0.3474103510379791,
-0.19536113739013672,
0.11924757808446884,
-0.01244424283504486,
-0.9411269426345825,
-0.8700829744338989,
-0.7423077821731567,
-0.4925197660923004,
-0.33085551857948303,
-0.23121432960033417,
0.1480545550584793,
0.8004850149154663,
-0.7295538187026978,
-0.2660628855228424,
-0.22690917551517487,
0.31350478529930115,
-0.302707314491272,
-0.21450649201869965,
0.5145546793937683,
-0.5172519683837891,
-0.8319388628005981,
0.07208981364965439,
0.3753345310688019,
0.38908836245536804,
-0.43999555706977844,
-0.23303906619548798,
-0.0668262243270874,
0.2094830572605133,
0.7254753112792969,
-0.3838924467563629,
-0.3931508958339691,
0.09854564815759659,
-0.01024022325873375,
-0.21778550744056702,
0.07992754876613617,
0.9082366228103638,
-1.0444564819335938,
0.4136534035205841,
0.5218693017959595,
0.6911965608596802,
0.7377694845199585,
0.12598669528961182,
0.7724862694740295,
-0.4720742106437683,
-0.049965985119342804,
-0.16611769795417786,
0.24212870001792908,
0.40117231011390686,
-0.29937446117401123,
0.39256858825683594,
0.3591221570968628,
-0.4986780285835266,
-0.7174044847488403,
-0.07251548767089844,
-0.6182173490524292,
-0.68422931432724,
1.304911732673645,
-0.09313134104013443,
-0.33548885583877563,
-0.18116754293441772,
-0.05115238577127457,
0.1433529555797577,
-0.27553078532218933,
0.811329185962677,
0.6863662004470825,
0.20935611426830292,
-0.33491945266723633,
-0.07572539150714874,
0.35983115434646606,
0.1502072662115097,
-0.7166751623153687,
0.29516446590423584,
0.16947413980960846,
0.3656769394874573,
-0.10342159867286682,
0.7973476648330688,
-0.07823530584573746,
-0.007775834761559963,
0.1604985147714615,
0.14097000658512115,
0.2516930103302002,
-0.16775044798851013,
-0.9778313040733337,
0.3045614957809448,
-0.09540977329015732,
0.048305243253707886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19088v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19088v2
|
Survey in Characterization of Semantic Change
| 2024-02-29T12:13:50 | 2024-03-11T15:21:57 |
Jader Martins Camboim de Sá, Marcos Da Silveira, Cédric Pruski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Live languages continuously evolve to integrate the cultural change of human
societies. This evolution manifests through neologisms (new words) or
\textbf{semantic changes} of words (new meaning to existing words).
Understanding the meaning of words is vital for interpreting texts coming from
different cultures (regionalism or slang), domains (e.g., technical terms), or
periods. In computer science, these words are relevant to computational
linguistics algorithms such as translation, information retrieval, question
answering, etc. Semantic changes can potentially impact the quality of the
outcomes of these algorithms. Therefore, it is important to understand and
characterize these changes formally. The study of this impact is a recent
problem that has attracted the attention of the computational linguistics
community. Several approaches propose methods to detect semantic changes with
good precision, but more effort is needed to characterize how the meaning of
words changes and to reason about how to reduce the impact of semantic change.
This survey provides an understandable overview of existing approaches to the
\textit{characterization of semantic changes} and also formally defines three
classes of characterizations: if the meaning of a word becomes more general or
narrow (change in dimension) if the word is used in a more pejorative or
positive/ameliorated sense (change in orientation), and if there is a trend to
use the word in a, for instance, metaphoric or metonymic context (change in
relation). We summarized the main aspects of the selected publications in a
table and discussed the needs and trends in the research activities on semantic
change characterization.
|
[
-0.6721459031105042,
-1.0379514694213867,
0.22772802412509918,
0.054003406316041946,
-0.2569030225276947,
-0.10526132583618164,
-0.3788571357727051,
-0.946308434009552,
0.6106024384498596,
0.4605436623096466,
-0.5427838563919067,
-0.29650643467903137,
-0.6162167191505432,
0.4846494793891907,
-0.5005590319633484,
0.8787877559661865,
-0.24414844810962677,
0.057462919503450394,
-0.04374263435602188,
-0.26102975010871887,
-0.4765779376029968,
-0.30809128284454346,
-0.30245131254196167,
-0.1678219884634018,
0.5868428945541382,
-0.12153653800487518,
0.8204677104949951,
0.6384558081626892,
0.6356815099716187,
0.325186163187027,
-0.5893688201904297,
-0.2558290362358093,
-0.11899279057979584,
0.3546655476093292,
-0.12069392949342728,
-0.5117700695991516,
-0.17810072004795074,
0.28203046321868896,
0.8683133721351624,
1.0339105129241943,
0.17040292918682098,
0.2721991539001465,
-0.1969531774520874,
0.5732396841049194,
-0.7793449759483337,
0.32073384523391724,
-0.8865129947662354,
0.12566529214382172,
-0.5693013668060303,
-0.2654111087322235,
0.03822735697031021,
-0.11728928238153458,
0.16811759769916534,
-0.6517195701599121,
0.4955933392047882,
-0.3278546929359436,
1.0109163522720337,
0.14017026126384735,
-0.319977730512619,
-0.37118130922317505,
-0.7944993376731873,
0.8090153932571411,
-0.5832975506782532,
0.7020816802978516,
0.27330493927001953,
0.42273053526878357,
-0.2618972361087799,
-0.7713742852210999,
-0.5966765284538269,
-0.3910594582557678,
0.06535596400499344,
-0.028469014912843704,
-0.09482160210609436,
-0.13732972741127014,
0.08458594977855682,
0.41999563574790955,
-0.1009342223405838,
0.008874011225998402,
-0.2860970199108124,
-0.5082234740257263,
0.6338298916816711,
0.2753317356109619,
0.4643508791923523,
-0.22920279204845428,
-0.1624145209789276,
-0.35632792115211487,
-0.6986994743347168,
-0.006504280958324671,
0.34326717257499695,
0.17221365869045258,
0.2156974971294403,
0.23633098602294922,
-0.5346454977989197,
0.792931318283081,
-0.2956460118293762,
-0.1595308780670166,
0.27862676978111267,
-0.9146015048027039,
-0.025243554264307022,
-0.1550547033548355,
0.32898253202438354,
0.2960880398750305,
0.060492999851703644,
-0.16683092713356018,
-0.0008368258131667972,
0.31795379519462585,
0.040394414216279984,
-0.4814930558204651,
-0.027788443490862846,
-0.18573841452598572,
-0.6574908494949341,
-0.3770252466201782,
-0.03914286196231842,
-0.6717308759689331,
-0.44914567470550537,
-0.5638782978057861,
-0.04317841678857803,
-0.3621087968349457,
-0.4830695688724518,
0.3408287465572357,
-0.25515544414520264,
0.6263974905014038,
0.6710457801818848,
-0.7362125515937805,
0.3078962564468384,
0.7359910011291504,
0.6592395305633545,
-0.3297553062438965,
-0.23412568867206573,
0.10861745476722717,
-0.16914652287960052,
-0.4625909626483917,
0.9098376631736755,
-0.582015872001648,
-0.4041832685470581,
0.03737221285700798,
0.018321789801120758,
-0.083769291639328,
-0.4830588102340698,
0.34023916721343994,
-0.6488904356956482,
0.276720255613327,
-0.1406140774488449,
-0.41350284218788147,
-0.23487350344657898,
0.6428453326225281,
-0.5364354848861694,
0.9339149594306946,
0.1273939162492752,
-0.9725778102874756,
0.590867280960083,
-0.5593878626823425,
-0.23822320997714996,
0.32483935356140137,
0.007594063878059387,
-0.17346298694610596,
0.16123764216899872,
-0.4279272258281708,
0.15105491876602173,
-0.24084779620170593,
0.07824264466762543,
-0.2694048583507538,
-0.13143624365329742,
0.7275515198707581,
-0.0760335773229599,
0.8196972608566284,
0.3372057378292084,
-0.19216066598892212,
0.06379792094230652,
-0.8619555830955505,
0.19310681521892548,
-0.1736958622932434,
-0.2530440390110016,
-0.49417251348495483,
0.4784541130065918,
0.08848495781421661,
0.04852360486984253,
0.34210047125816345,
-0.7664568424224854,
0.10945212841033936,
-0.4917266368865967,
0.46722790598869324,
0.4344368278980255,
0.11394533514976501,
0.28859105706214905,
0.012159142643213272,
0.4465239346027374,
-0.09619469940662384,
0.5144996643066406,
0.21621358394622803,
-0.6651963591575623,
-0.6306454539299011,
0.0015760118840262294,
0.5770652890205383,
0.3380894660949707,
-0.4977061152458191,
0.20897355675697327,
-0.2775592803955078,
-0.4507099390029907,
-0.2825982868671417,
-0.12838108837604523,
-0.08305580168962479,
0.2343880534172058,
0.47792086005210876,
-0.36013081669807434,
-0.5521663427352905,
-0.7967228889465332,
-0.4964268207550049,
-0.4149864912033081,
0.10980037599802017,
0.12130874395370483,
0.5763648152351379,
-0.5328359007835388,
1.0272009372711182,
-0.5699803829193115,
0.002661181380972266,
-0.06766343861818314,
0.21114908158779144,
-0.10438212007284164,
0.08543630689382553,
0.3643418252468109,
-1.0145784616470337,
-0.13983222842216492,
0.1335015892982483,
-0.24654114246368408,
-0.22889575362205505,
0.05668316036462784,
0.009278841316699982,
0.0454883873462677,
0.8016995787620544,
-0.3244921863079071,
0.5166671872138977,
0.2994813024997711,
-0.5670246481895447,
0.7224847674369812,
0.11569361388683319,
0.0018259799107909203,
-0.8082189559936523,
-0.13611209392547607,
-0.2459583878517151,
0.22946326434612274,
-0.624641478061676,
0.33543989062309265,
-0.16374212503433228,
0.28306087851524353,
-0.5901933908462524,
0.6230001449584961,
-0.4638809859752655,
-0.04413772001862526,
-0.22195205092430115,
0.32700809836387634,
-0.23618878424167633,
-0.21388639509677887,
0.03233283758163452,
0.13054707646369934,
0.4737137258052826,
-0.8933077454566956,
0.6029106974601746,
0.27174893021583557,
-0.27692046761512756,
0.38172972202301025,
-0.3448048532009125,
-0.09619063138961792,
-0.23203417658805847,
0.26654788851737976,
-0.8191460967063904,
0.03925106301903725,
0.3647196888923645,
-0.7391082048416138,
0.03423945978283882,
0.024798834696412086,
-0.6436989307403564,
-0.0026485114358365536,
-0.3740692138671875,
0.3718336522579193,
0.10174259543418884,
0.10925000160932541,
0.2929300367832184,
0.3607006072998047,
0.12285884469747543,
-0.3105452060699463,
-0.7233105301856995,
0.3747347891330719,
-0.30605706572532654,
-0.7967609763145447,
0.4855171740055084,
-0.038929957896471024,
-0.7950342893600464,
0.131259948015213,
-0.031358662992715836,
-0.2387680858373642,
0.49052494764328003,
-0.2520813047885895,
0.18565665185451508,
-0.16272489726543427,
0.37936460971832275,
0.014278988353908062,
-0.23395074903964996,
0.2093704789876938,
-0.1395205408334732,
0.3796083927154541,
-0.1782471388578415,
0.30918988585472107,
-0.15451885759830475,
0.25396037101745605,
0.2611612379550934,
-0.3764116168022156,
0.8378830552101135,
0.8391234278678894,
-0.17723169922828674,
0.20538339018821716,
-0.4672200381755829,
-0.18631628155708313,
-0.342619925737381,
0.29042449593544006,
-0.2827347218990326,
-1.0640000104904175,
0.7075756788253784,
-0.1756017804145813,
-0.13484232127666473,
0.8406798243522644,
0.6598362326622009,
0.1675437092781067,
0.7551868557929993,
0.5639053583145142,
0.4362998306751251,
0.6763182282447815,
-0.015541641041636467,
0.21464988589286804,
-0.9030932784080505,
-0.19063128530979156,
-1.0212018489837646,
-0.2221100628376007,
-1.3601505756378174,
-0.43447303771972656,
0.3162815272808075,
-0.07055040448904037,
0.2007657140493393,
0.36655616760253906,
-0.39652442932128906,
0.11189208924770355,
-0.028614137321710587,
-0.39830195903778076,
0.26784172654151917,
-0.2300780564546585,
0.14667817950248718,
-0.12179567664861679,
-0.10929547995328903,
-0.4189274311065674,
0.7512145042419434,
0.27886587381362915,
0.7050229907035828,
0.32652872800827026,
0.5579341053962708,
0.39814645051956177,
0.20259246230125427,
-0.8801388144493103,
0.8261275291442871,
0.12569141387939453,
-0.5738730430603027,
-0.3339689373970032,
-0.47288069128990173,
-1.2510755062103271,
0.4121701717376709,
-0.32999831438064575,
-0.8688047528266907,
0.2840481698513031,
0.013562122359871864,
0.4984530210494995,
0.1511065661907196,
-0.21900561451911926,
0.8640676736831665,
-0.03740619495511055,
-0.02421504259109497,
-0.42102405428886414,
-0.7351172566413879,
0.039179764688014984,
0.053247157484292984,
0.19611965119838715,
-0.4157017469406128,
-0.3988528251647949,
0.7743490934371948,
-0.24859221279621124,
0.7525410652160645,
-0.15396349132061005,
-0.20535945892333984,
0.3771277666091919,
0.2902098000049591,
0.20115846395492554,
-0.19380693137645721,
-0.056720517575740814,
0.27128151059150696,
0.8108513951301575,
-0.38918668031692505,
-0.6095964908599854,
0.373185932636261,
-0.6432005763053894,
-0.21955925226211548,
-0.48218461871147156,
-0.4588748514652252,
-0.3139828145503998,
0.1819363385438919,
0.32392627000808716,
0.2404945194721222,
-0.5279504656791687,
0.024357233196496964,
0.5020943880081177,
-0.2814160883426666,
0.20635583996772766,
0.5665103197097778,
-0.36787939071655273,
-0.0468437634408474,
0.7575281262397766,
0.18756842613220215,
0.35168588161468506,
0.412553608417511,
0.5627350807189941,
-0.26284658908843994,
-0.6410838961601257,
-0.19257685542106628,
0.2819269299507141,
-0.5925756096839905,
0.12877853214740753,
-0.4690692722797394,
0.12233541160821915,
-0.5884274840354919,
0.0712641254067421,
-0.02285405993461609,
-0.6411184072494507,
-0.21526788175106049,
0.2172253578901291,
0.4353845417499542,
0.6567219495773315,
0.05563197284936905,
0.027244752272963524,
-0.5236819982528687,
0.05499408021569252,
0.08334281295537949,
0.1834278404712677,
-0.3733004033565521,
-0.47693100571632385,
-0.204881489276886,
-0.03286515548825264,
-0.15786467492580414,
-1.0951097011566162,
0.22529014945030212,
0.2661151885986328,
0.5615417957305908,
0.3151969611644745,
-0.06708770990371704,
0.4061034917831421,
-0.13068096339702606,
0.9627745747566223,
-0.07101255655288696,
-0.9203667044639587,
0.5234518647193909,
-0.3432559072971344,
0.2986975908279419,
0.50489741563797,
0.0957510843873024,
-1.1906945705413818,
-0.2593705952167511,
-0.6592110395431519,
-0.6382485032081604,
0.286016047000885,
0.0433754064142704,
0.40369343757629395,
-0.1342058777809143,
0.5157661437988281,
0.020685991272330284,
0.22813259065151215,
-0.33634480834007263,
-0.1754738837480545,
-0.07198835909366608,
0.15847447514533997,
0.05631234869360924,
-0.14907103776931763,
0.09393095225095749,
-0.39126190543174744,
0.448128342628479,
-0.11558376997709274,
0.36139655113220215,
0.005529625806957483,
-0.18263225257396698,
0.3096283972263336,
0.6373348832130432,
0.6589717864990234,
0.7786089181900024,
-0.042570896446704865,
0.4085140526294708,
0.17441916465759277,
-0.690933346748352,
-0.10074801743030548,
0.04033495485782623,
-0.5152654051780701,
0.20835039019584656,
0.4475712776184082,
0.6081976890563965,
0.13833561539649963,
-0.4325248897075653,
0.27484649419784546,
0.04567953199148178,
-0.07581716030836105,
-0.34969857335090637,
-0.04010424017906189,
-0.3000338077545166,
-0.3758555054664612,
-0.12540672719478607,
0.014255287125706673,
0.4939033091068268,
-0.844750702381134,
-0.08796261250972748,
0.3450480103492737,
-0.704451322555542,
-0.6113137006759644,
0.03602433577179909,
-0.004651566967368126,
-0.07610070705413818,
0.45107507705688477,
-0.41967180371284485,
-0.47790032625198364,
0.4867567718029022,
0.42342066764831543,
0.9279955625534058,
-0.2375011295080185,
0.42577287554740906,
0.12574978172779083,
0.20969842374324799,
0.2252042591571808,
0.08359513431787491,
-0.31236645579338074,
-1.2171896696090698,
-0.3460821211338043,
-0.7095182538032532,
-0.41275063157081604,
-0.1092802882194519,
-0.7295947074890137,
0.23058494925498962,
-0.24767404794692993,
-0.21389985084533691,
0.26973482966423035,
0.00105845567304641,
-0.3714723587036133,
0.1380605697631836,
0.13185584545135498,
0.8601659536361694,
-0.7984044551849365,
0.5896403193473816,
1.1546062231063843,
-0.21836817264556885,
-0.24110649526119232,
0.013754662126302719,
0.3115714490413666,
-0.34807494282722473,
0.739000678062439,
-0.0507429875433445,
-0.35902681946754456,
-0.3054431080818176,
-0.6038177013397217,
-0.8946903944015503,
0.6709909439086914,
-0.01200603973120451,
0.14024315774440765,
0.1081826463341713,
0.2617063820362091,
1.0868605375289917,
-0.09928707033395767,
0.146267369389534,
0.7120751738548279,
0.6766524314880371,
-0.0782509297132492,
-0.8188679814338684,
-0.24683204293251038,
-0.303768128156662,
0.3729507029056549,
0.7841393351554871,
-0.267588347196579,
0.9676725268363953,
0.2427154779434204,
-0.5212951302528381,
0.023591112345457077,
0.599299967288971,
-0.2977796196937561,
0.2751615047454834,
0.5555882453918457,
0.34240520000457764,
0.5157879590988159,
-0.2125273197889328,
0.9703728556632996,
-0.2961272597312927,
0.5110498666763306,
0.6898837089538574,
-0.054725050926208496,
0.7322574257850647,
0.4177323877811432,
-0.3834601938724518,
0.67345130443573,
0.7067776322364807,
0.0933542475104332,
0.13002321124076843,
0.6142082214355469,
-0.38858136534690857,
-0.17106600105762482,
-0.31729304790496826,
-0.4315306842327118,
0.8491517305374146,
0.6899670362472534,
-0.22424161434173584,
-0.4747912287712097,
0.09923303127288818,
0.41664761304855347,
-0.012790941633284092,
-0.2681862413883209,
0.8155507445335388,
-0.33226826786994934,
-0.5013302564620972,
0.4688482880592346,
0.3592289984226227,
0.5438153147697449,
-0.6844468116760254,
-0.07192683964967728,
0.010791189968585968,
0.08863359689712524,
-0.25861895084381104,
-0.6761934757232666,
0.6203265190124512,
-0.2611321210861206,
-0.11522482335567474,
-0.2735038101673126,
0.7045365571975708,
-0.13473711907863617,
-0.4271807074546814,
0.4386001229286194,
0.5270103216171265,
0.42015188932418823,
0.1220058873295784,
-0.7885308861732483,
0.3881841003894806,
-0.21554163098335266,
0.12159468978643417,
0.2503338158130646,
0.31203484535217285,
-0.41990339756011963,
0.34642571210861206,
0.3495922088623047,
0.42658403515815735,
0.42434996366500854,
-0.0385570153594017,
0.6362312436103821,
-0.6767011880874634,
-0.4420490264892578,
-0.3812941312789917,
-0.044513244181871414,
0.006107930094003677,
-0.6318992376327515,
0.7087001800537109,
0.19996629655361176,
1.0563956499099731,
0.17398597300052643,
0.5234029293060303,
-0.4479387104511261,
0.46916574239730835,
-0.5518133044242859,
0.23674795031547546,
-0.4314216673374176,
0.11540134251117706,
-0.3429766595363617,
-0.9999023675918579,
-0.4741230607032776,
0.4885897636413574,
-0.40131285786628723,
-0.12208825349807739,
0.7831720113754272,
0.6757778525352478,
0.23537428677082062,
0.1269836127758026,
0.12198080867528915,
0.3369806706905365,
0.245485320687294,
-0.20893462002277374,
0.9843441247940063,
-0.2620440423488617,
0.17384472489356995,
-0.08138233423233032,
-0.3321356773376465,
-0.15391100943088531,
-0.7644190192222595,
-0.10870101302862167,
-0.9354175925254822,
-0.7546614408493042,
-0.5022422671318054,
-0.06941796839237213,
0.5147978067398071,
0.287168949842453,
-0.7217055559158325,
-0.2761712670326233,
-0.11905306577682495,
0.04973744601011276,
-0.5418557524681091,
-0.28970614075660706,
0.30916857719421387,
-0.418632835149765,
-0.39178645610809326,
0.22119230031967163,
0.2738768458366394,
-0.18240925669670105,
-0.5186500549316406,
0.2432054877281189,
-0.2700672745704651,
0.22154109179973602,
0.8500666618347168,
0.483368843793869,
-0.9100981950759888,
-0.6069984436035156,
-0.0069086067378520966,
0.10717266798019409,
-0.005562441423535347,
1.089261531829834,
-0.661311149597168,
0.6808748841285706,
0.9391443133354187,
0.4635108411312103,
0.42280158400535583,
-0.3514035642147064,
0.13592009246349335,
-0.2766371965408325,
0.01068512536585331,
0.12884289026260376,
0.18661774694919586,
0.38191279768943787,
-0.03978365659713745,
0.6170666813850403,
0.6731762290000916,
-0.324896901845932,
-0.6398894786834717,
0.7884774208068848,
-0.9605805277824402,
-0.2903469502925873,
1.0701006650924683,
0.21404774487018585,
-0.2654449939727783,
-0.43481919169425964,
-0.004574059508740902,
0.16122695803642273,
0.09977740049362183,
0.7633431553840637,
0.8123536109924316,
-0.5408297181129456,
-0.0855853483080864,
-0.4672737419605255,
0.5671014785766602,
0.15747901797294617,
-0.9279924631118774,
-0.09341456741094589,
0.6218178272247314,
0.327591210603714,
0.5935571789741516,
0.3567142188549042,
-0.5595760345458984,
0.1437111347913742,
-0.20014818012714386,
0.10730093717575073,
0.3195304572582245,
-0.012785876169800758,
-0.26333707571029663,
-0.13407780230045319,
0.06256860494613647,
-0.14405959844589233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19085v1
|
Controllable Preference Optimization: Toward Controllable Multi-Objective Alignment
| 2024-02-29T12:12:30 | 2024-02-29T12:12:30 |
Yiju Guo, Ganqu Cui, Lifan Yuan, Ning Ding, Jiexin Wang, Huimin Chen, Bowen Sun, Ruobing Xie, Jie Zhou, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SY, eess.SY
|
Alignment in artificial intelligence pursues the consistency between model
responses and human preferences as well as values. In practice, the
multifaceted nature of human preferences inadvertently introduces what is known
as the "alignment tax" -a compromise where enhancements in alignment within one
objective (e.g.,harmlessness) can diminish performance in others
(e.g.,helpfulness). However, existing alignment techniques are mostly
unidirectional, leading to suboptimal trade-offs and poor flexibility over
various objectives. To navigate this challenge, we argue the prominence of
grounding LLMs with evident preferences. We introduce controllable preference
optimization (CPO), which explicitly specifies preference scores for different
objectives, thereby guiding the model to generate responses that meet the
requirements. Our experimental analysis reveals that the aligned models can
provide responses that match various preferences among the "3H" (helpfulness,
honesty, harmlessness) desiderata. Furthermore, by introducing diverse data and
alignment goals, we surpass baseline methods in aligning with single
objectives, hence mitigating the impact of the alignment tax and achieving
Pareto improvements in multi-objective alignment.
|
[
-0.42035844922065735,
-0.34811338782310486,
0.47228923439979553,
0.09242533147335052,
-0.09838178008794785,
0.1928451657295227,
-0.3449099659919739,
-0.3105868995189667,
0.2956780195236206,
0.6455381512641907,
-0.6099020838737488,
-0.23154230415821075,
-0.4985988736152649,
-0.21689368784427643,
0.21890641748905182,
1.0084086656570435,
-0.07916099578142166,
0.0013501147041097283,
-0.34213051199913025,
-0.45049402117729187,
-0.6253852248191833,
-0.5982301235198975,
-0.35407304763793945,
-0.4785902798175812,
0.46776142716407776,
0.5905970335006714,
1.0643341541290283,
1.1073237657546997,
0.6996815204620361,
0.15717969834804535,
0.20920170843601227,
0.2830042243003845,
-0.41476067900657654,
-0.05710897967219353,
-0.080723337829113,
-0.3207469582557678,
-0.45348483324050903,
0.17732621729373932,
0.2927837073802948,
0.5588438510894775,
-0.29560837149620056,
-0.08677112311124802,
0.330323725938797,
0.8138585090637207,
-1.0598387718200684,
-0.3086296617984772,
-0.7523982524871826,
-0.0029557975940406322,
-0.04262927547097206,
-0.08552487939596176,
-0.2396826148033142,
-0.6134920120239258,
-0.019931819289922714,
-0.6397733092308044,
-0.5160540342330933,
0.1158561035990715,
0.9529270529747009,
1.0284191370010376,
-0.29288268089294434,
-0.29895466566085815,
-0.4740656614303589,
1.2082043886184692,
-0.5140124559402466,
0.282754123210907,
0.1742333024740219,
0.0929897353053093,
-0.046893030405044556,
0.06494197249412537,
-0.2830600142478943,
-0.24852128326892853,
-0.09345865249633789,
0.2865417003631592,
-0.10223454982042313,
0.15750230848789215,
-0.028351163491606712,
-0.08423300832509995,
-0.14368072152137756,
0.23340094089508057,
0.14177900552749634,
-0.20677293837070465,
0.5785956978797913,
0.03321242332458496,
0.17904354631900787,
0.00043519705650396645,
-0.6838499307632446,
0.07010266184806824,
-0.5214211344718933,
0.5296002626419067,
0.6142221689224243,
0.4626041650772095,
0.037612706422805786,
0.8275313973426819,
-0.016146106645464897,
0.8067445755004883,
0.41679927706718445,
-0.307259738445282,
-0.029477067291736603,
-0.32013940811157227,
0.0064569199457764626,
0.22939686477184296,
0.5602664351463318,
0.7407271265983582,
0.2878066897392273,
-0.17589066922664642,
-0.17312349379062653,
0.34603676199913025,
0.5385600924491882,
-0.3897245228290558,
-0.034806057810783386,
0.3770488202571869,
-0.400989830493927,
-0.32752305269241333,
-0.008287866599857807,
-0.529020369052887,
-0.24266529083251953,
-1.0721226930618286,
0.2468825876712799,
-0.20431986451148987,
0.0860978215932846,
0.10615451633930206,
-0.07489863783121109,
0.3375857472419739,
0.36643239855766296,
-1.024641513824463,
0.32380759716033936,
0.7612281441688538,
0.42874738574028015,
-0.5276951193809509,
-0.21863363683223724,
-0.42151644825935364,
0.49075210094451904,
-0.3400265574455261,
0.6368816494941711,
-0.7188702821731567,
-0.2709451913833618,
-0.5129727125167847,
-0.46244314312934875,
0.010361957363784313,
-0.4598449468612671,
0.5249010920524597,
-0.28458070755004883,
0.08829689025878906,
-0.4364337623119354,
-0.5142263174057007,
-0.004580996930599213,
0.5655491948127747,
-0.34672480821609497,
0.6900438070297241,
-0.028446590527892113,
-0.5684013366699219,
0.5067191123962402,
-0.7059924602508545,
-0.1877482831478119,
-0.3069536089897156,
-0.32324206829071045,
-0.4518592357635498,
0.022767378017306328,
0.06795624643564224,
0.26542574167251587,
-0.1314357966184616,
0.5919433236122131,
-0.4836135506629944,
-0.04963758960366249,
0.020509520545601845,
-0.13978715240955353,
0.7859072685241699,
0.17309610545635223,
-0.4316757917404175,
0.4331802427768707,
-0.6124463081359863,
0.14131492376327515,
-0.28764650225639343,
-0.44634830951690674,
-0.4711325764656067,
0.2755996882915497,
-0.27325376868247986,
0.05275699123740196,
0.756324052810669,
-0.27465441823005676,
0.49733874201774597,
-0.09979034215211868,
0.21877028048038483,
1.254176139831543,
-0.3520582616329193,
0.8119024634361267,
-0.661155641078949,
0.3530274033546448,
-0.10830915719270706,
0.6302078366279602,
0.6265704035758972,
-0.30332496762275696,
-0.5216721296310425,
-0.4023735225200653,
0.04007530212402344,
0.6647093892097473,
-0.038762323558330536,
0.7901144623756409,
-0.11521176993846893,
-0.44911834597587585,
-0.5099567770957947,
0.24533966183662415,
0.34166690707206726,
0.899999737739563,
0.33958637714385986,
-0.02442818321287632,
-0.2255731076002121,
-1.462761402130127,
-0.39413461089134216,
0.017365556210279465,
0.13883529603481293,
0.6252488493919373,
0.16002890467643738,
-0.12529738247394562,
1.1259633302688599,
-0.5866153836250305,
-0.1337263584136963,
0.1846865564584732,
-0.06608337163925171,
0.2715533971786499,
0.9159745573997498,
0.5539912581443787,
-1.0824882984161377,
-0.36501237750053406,
0.1684894859790802,
-0.36940503120422363,
-0.27294257283210754,
-0.04457247629761696,
-0.5598376393318176,
-0.07020901888608932,
-0.06364946067333221,
-0.3322066366672516,
0.1475355625152588,
0.3869583308696747,
0.04884801432490349,
0.30626457929611206,
-0.06397773325443268,
0.28923627734184265,
-1.016963005065918,
0.14742907881736755,
-0.2212008684873581,
-0.07264005392789841,
-0.40013179183006287,
0.0012474684044718742,
0.2990114688873291,
0.15426790714263916,
-0.4887266755104065,
0.5104830265045166,
-0.24452286958694458,
-0.061532411724328995,
-0.1830066442489624,
-0.19184088706970215,
0.02060132659971714,
0.6379015445709229,
0.02035396359860897,
0.8578461408615112,
0.4725649058818817,
-0.8099800944328308,
0.07667141407728195,
0.36671072244644165,
0.3841729760169983,
0.9935353398323059,
-0.4707787036895752,
0.21890482306480408,
-0.23875337839126587,
-0.21387359499931335,
-0.7275930643081665,
-0.3353281617164612,
0.4186961054801941,
-0.3328658938407898,
0.34680160880088806,
-0.16246168315410614,
0.03395590931177139,
0.15003377199172974,
-0.689067006111145,
0.5306230783462524,
0.32768508791923523,
-0.506584882736206,
0.7275744080543518,
0.5116734504699707,
0.2923162281513214,
-1.0847821235656738,
-0.2795005142688751,
-0.1775842159986496,
-0.6933900713920593,
-0.49658650159835815,
0.6084498763084412,
-0.4795016944408417,
-0.41191285848617554,
-0.050854720175266266,
-0.2162209153175354,
0.3518989086151123,
0.39515721797943115,
0.09271282702684402,
0.5762856006622314,
0.18129806220531464,
-0.2381870299577713,
0.1402648538351059,
-0.24060314893722534,
-0.2654262185096741,
-0.44714590907096863,
0.43984314799308777,
0.006881071254611015,
-0.41062799096107483,
-0.367240846157074,
0.44927477836608887,
0.5312860608100891,
-0.3510955274105072,
0.30074137449264526,
0.037822723388671875,
-0.49842846393585205,
0.2571572959423065,
-0.5375613570213318,
0.007576050702482462,
-0.43928349018096924,
-0.23103787004947662,
-0.40533289313316345,
-0.8140228986740112,
0.4045582711696625,
0.04542848467826843,
0.35643115639686584,
0.1793842315673828,
0.4196351170539856,
-0.0005667994846589863,
1.4652131795883179,
0.5178741216659546,
-0.35405242443084717,
0.3972829282283783,
0.18618665635585785,
0.17650426924228668,
-1.0454530715942383,
-0.23946575820446014,
-0.7583421468734741,
-0.6077582836151123,
-0.6973272562026978,
0.10599725693464279,
0.42234882712364197,
0.455386757850647,
-0.6593304872512817,
0.34605109691619873,
-1.055330514907837,
0.5414605140686035,
0.8042687177658081,
0.16419978439807892,
0.02679768204689026,
-0.2596431076526642,
0.12881773710250854,
-0.20744377374649048,
-0.39896130561828613,
-0.6563809514045715,
1.1365383863449097,
0.03659813106060028,
0.9412540793418884,
0.19572314620018005,
0.9474574327468872,
0.18458732962608337,
0.38155174255371094,
-0.990301251411438,
0.17923709750175476,
-0.27499306201934814,
-0.3966979384422302,
-0.1629054695367813,
-0.3187383711338043,
-0.6788141131401062,
0.0587986521422863,
-0.055975284427404404,
-0.9556211233139038,
0.3274397552013397,
0.544039785861969,
-0.46449705958366394,
0.09449616074562073,
-0.5751146078109741,
0.7785778641700745,
-0.7901550531387329,
-0.6270604133605957,
0.0406491681933403,
-0.8990547060966492,
0.28239938616752625,
-0.09969142079353333,
0.17038829624652863,
-0.4719918370246887,
-0.36466628313064575,
0.6362506151199341,
-0.09725134819746017,
0.489596426486969,
-0.16605663299560547,
0.055268894881010056,
-0.2347586452960968,
0.0329253189265728,
0.48245230317115784,
-0.017366813495755196,
-0.03804507851600647,
0.026650626212358475,
-0.17005480825901031,
-0.505812406539917,
-0.5195149183273315,
0.7572189569473267,
-0.9639524817466736,
-0.805364191532135,
-0.20258960127830505,
-0.7085932493209839,
-0.3112849295139313,
0.43439629673957825,
0.08096355944871902,
-0.006864279042929411,
0.0011317611206322908,
-0.17849569022655487,
0.5042866468429565,
0.2048312872648239,
0.24019436538219452,
0.12012743204832077,
0.17530448734760284,
-0.6636162400245667,
0.748894989490509,
-0.18926924467086792,
0.4569816589355469,
0.5817298293113708,
0.5341688394546509,
-0.5208539366722107,
-0.5351294279098511,
-0.20900921523571014,
0.03379632905125618,
-0.5091966986656189,
-0.41914084553718567,
-0.41246989369392395,
0.2948169708251953,
-0.5386015772819519,
-0.8011994957923889,
-0.5789425373077393,
-0.32661688327789307,
-0.5322272777557373,
0.11102256923913956,
-0.10043159127235413,
0.465587317943573,
-0.2861834168434143,
0.32675570249557495,
-0.5640115737915039,
0.4439294636249542,
0.2173023521900177,
0.18928484618663788,
-0.4071362018585205,
-0.09396637976169586,
0.20962628722190857,
0.2894706428050995,
-0.566523015499115,
-0.5785195827484131,
0.12691976130008698,
-0.1430325210094452,
0.7259370684623718,
0.8460615277290344,
0.28546449542045593,
0.9312462210655212,
-0.32927876710891724,
0.46920403838157654,
0.3201506435871124,
-1.0480960607528687,
0.6986996531486511,
-0.23221416771411896,
-0.11057648807764053,
0.8628782629966736,
0.4291667938232422,
-0.016866620630025864,
-0.22911201417446136,
-0.4219028353691101,
-0.7378741502761841,
0.6603297591209412,
0.17314258217811584,
0.009184440597891808,
0.25199076533317566,
0.5141787528991699,
0.20548847317695618,
0.5969412326812744,
-0.7400586009025574,
-0.19415394961833954,
-0.23963166773319244,
-0.37769997119903564,
0.06940938532352448,
0.05340119078755379,
-0.833946704864502,
0.0411432646214962,
0.6037009358406067,
-0.35893452167510986,
0.03691581264138222,
0.006752409972250462,
0.16355222463607788,
-0.08700938522815704,
0.294901043176651,
0.8972828984260559,
0.7232063412666321,
-0.46141430735588074,
0.08773446828126907,
-0.3895034193992615,
-0.011506197974085808,
0.3401249349117279,
0.07997188717126846,
-0.30876338481903076,
-0.7828152775764465,
-0.07001999020576477,
0.4671511948108673,
0.06894668936729431,
-0.3575439453125,
0.26861369609832764,
0.19082124531269073,
-0.0460217110812664,
-0.0720347985625267,
0.2846640944480896,
-0.10938216000795364,
0.17757566273212433,
0.0743238776922226,
0.519160270690918,
0.14788074791431427,
-0.2803308963775635,
0.07672525197267532,
1.1397812366485596,
-0.3534037172794342,
0.1345718652009964,
0.9854066967964172,
-0.02811267413198948,
-0.31856825947761536,
0.4176841676235199,
0.21230794489383698,
-0.6460854411125183,
0.6386281847953796,
0.3600803315639496,
0.6160489320755005,
-0.16806909441947937,
-0.12646515667438507,
0.20571370422840118,
0.3767094910144806,
-0.16729436814785004,
0.25338438153266907,
-0.17457972466945648,
-1.2225288152694702,
0.07846512645483017,
-0.5017715096473694,
-0.678225576877594,
-0.34943437576293945,
-0.9557941555976868,
0.32600870728492737,
-0.5999505519866943,
-0.13482016324996948,
0.0825149416923523,
-0.0542663112282753,
-0.38460779190063477,
0.12839631736278534,
-0.007622030097991228,
0.5089905858039856,
-0.5611233115196228,
0.42240840196609497,
0.6122966408729553,
-0.2489982545375824,
-0.9559705257415771,
-0.0844867005944252,
0.18924488127231598,
-1.2763856649398804,
0.2462186962366104,
0.20931145548820496,
-0.2923942804336548,
0.1320277899503708,
-0.7676025629043579,
-0.9753740429878235,
0.9689064025878906,
0.5359020829200745,
-0.39545756578445435,
0.04048164188861847,
0.02323771081864834,
-0.02004082500934601,
-0.5832521915435791,
-0.039115164428949356,
0.610414445400238,
1.017758846282959,
-0.06691079586744308,
-0.8108367323875427,
-0.0867670550942421,
0.12846212089061737,
-0.13981042802333832,
0.6446230411529541,
-0.8952284455299377,
0.6271271109580994,
-0.09556511044502258,
0.12974372506141663,
-0.0014779377961531281,
0.1493896245956421,
0.5105524063110352,
0.2315075695514679,
0.6252492070198059,
0.8540706038475037,
0.8200967311859131,
-0.11981938034296036,
0.8320717811584473,
-0.5894490480422974,
0.19633318483829498,
0.9892232418060303,
-0.558073103427887,
0.4408450722694397,
0.9315589666366577,
-0.07702308148145676,
-0.12732075154781342,
0.7885098457336426,
0.043273650109767914,
0.7564128041267395,
0.1358238309621811,
0.008317920379340649,
-0.4367244839668274,
-0.5340824723243713,
-0.07200151681900024,
0.52667635679245,
0.07558334618806839,
0.13818995654582977,
-0.07145845144987106,
-0.16903898119926453,
-0.02340092696249485,
0.2010391801595688,
-0.27957749366760254,
0.7764543890953064,
-0.35573944449424744,
-1.0938448905944824,
0.510039210319519,
-0.24867211282253265,
0.838327169418335,
-0.7299476861953735,
0.049930140376091,
-0.20516502857208252,
0.16506405174732208,
-0.37354016304016113,
-0.6256685853004456,
0.21388322114944458,
-0.3524843156337738,
-0.35565388202667236,
-0.35273873805999756,
0.3997701406478882,
-0.2997988760471344,
-0.2487712800502777,
0.32357388734817505,
0.27795174717903137,
-0.14897467195987701,
0.1624402105808258,
-0.8936586380004883,
0.05951094999909401,
0.24631153047084808,
-0.01041889563202858,
0.3023940622806549,
-0.09871406853199005,
-0.1316288709640503,
0.5602890849113464,
0.7586585283279419,
0.08526702225208282,
-0.17997951805591583,
-0.23909012973308563,
0.842642605304718,
-0.4637393057346344,
-0.5281415581703186,
-0.9815064668655396,
0.6323853135108948,
-0.02663389779627323,
-0.3241420388221741,
0.527369499206543,
0.6894078254699707,
0.7637110948562622,
0.21416983008384705,
0.6893414855003357,
0.014974357560276985,
0.2512236535549164,
-0.6993005275726318,
0.40587130188941956,
-0.8132418990135193,
0.20664319396018982,
-0.2611464560031891,
-1.0673832893371582,
-0.4483855068683624,
0.5934584736824036,
-0.04778851568698883,
-0.0736689418554306,
0.3550892174243927,
0.8244688510894775,
-0.18755275011062622,
-0.33342626690864563,
0.1914491504430771,
-0.3607397973537445,
0.40315160155296326,
0.6435251235961914,
0.871635913848877,
0.18442825973033905,
0.19187723100185394,
-0.5352579951286316,
-0.5153682231903076,
0.01769406348466873,
-1.0775655508041382,
-0.47662603855133057,
-0.19045980274677277,
-0.3055483400821686,
-0.21717090904712677,
-0.10216496884822845,
1.0927720069885254,
0.8028871417045593,
-0.8405262231826782,
-0.37669092416763306,
-0.18368135392665863,
0.4341788589954376,
-0.20019951462745667,
-0.218866229057312,
0.4293942153453827,
-0.2945096492767334,
-0.8858604431152344,
0.18057772517204285,
0.45735785365104675,
0.244398295879364,
0.05072147399187088,
-0.3202623128890991,
-0.0781140923500061,
0.07711023092269897,
0.049877867102622986,
0.2718774676322937,
-0.8996366262435913,
-0.5329302549362183,
0.23590977489948273,
-0.02339467592537403,
0.4952915906906128,
0.929334282875061,
-0.27416592836380005,
0.291226327419281,
0.1307285726070404,
0.864833414554596,
-0.19913934171199799,
0.5500743389129639,
0.5832454562187195,
-0.4847172796726227,
0.03359396010637283,
0.5088480710983276,
0.3411453664302826,
0.24179808795452118,
-0.8600004315376282,
0.40950047969818115,
-0.13146166503429413,
-0.8418243527412415,
-0.5747092962265015,
0.4850179851055145,
-1.346022605895996,
-0.2090151160955429,
0.8182339072227478,
-0.019984176382422447,
-0.024379361420869827,
0.16050837934017181,
-0.32414335012435913,
0.07223625481128693,
-0.6758081912994385,
0.7877472639083862,
0.7049046754837036,
-0.9569169878959656,
0.09706305712461472,
0.04514805227518082,
0.5465400815010071,
0.730964720249176,
-0.8565359115600586,
-0.07390759140253067,
0.8022252917289734,
0.11208772659301758,
0.408668577671051,
0.5368720889091492,
0.045334432274103165,
0.05595371127128601,
-0.6091683506965637,
0.05634674057364464,
0.0862569585442543,
-0.4171368479728699,
-0.28803199529647827,
0.16090185940265656,
0.2316731959581375,
-0.4782032072544098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19076v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19076v1
|
Pointing out the Shortcomings of Relation Extraction Models with Semantically Motivated Adversarials
| 2024-02-29T12:01:46 | 2024-02-29T12:01:46 |
Gennaro Nolano, Moritz Blum, Basil Ell, Philipp Cimiano
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, large language models have achieved state-of-the-art
performance across various NLP tasks. However, investigations have shown that
these models tend to rely on shortcut features, leading to inaccurate
predictions and causing the models to be unreliable at generalization to
out-of-distribution (OOD) samples. For instance, in the context of relation
extraction (RE), we would expect a model to identify the same relation
independently of the entities involved in it. For example, consider the
sentence "Leonardo da Vinci painted the Mona Lisa" expressing the
created(Leonardo_da_Vinci, Mona_Lisa) relation. If we substiute "Leonardo da
Vinci" with "Barack Obama", then the sentence still expresses the created
relation. A robust model is supposed to detect the same relation in both cases.
In this work, we describe several semantically-motivated strategies to generate
adversarial examples by replacing entity mentions and investigate how
state-of-the-art RE models perform under pressure. Our analyses show that the
performance of these models significantly deteriorates on the modified datasets
(avg. of -48.5% in F1), which indicates that these models rely to a great
extent on shortcuts, such as surface forms (or patterns therein) of entities,
without making full use of the information present in the sentences.
|
[
-0.3843340277671814,
-0.8017760515213013,
0.6663199663162231,
-0.09423624724149704,
-0.3701508045196533,
-0.30750203132629395,
-0.07807283848524094,
-0.6264753341674805,
0.09099830687046051,
0.6239871978759766,
-0.6378582119941711,
-0.3253488838672638,
-0.8398812413215637,
0.1481262594461441,
-0.42809242010116577,
1.0646065473556519,
-0.11250894516706467,
-0.35999995470046997,
-0.1717972308397293,
-0.23689983785152435,
-0.11535032093524933,
-0.6417005062103271,
-0.31603139638900757,
-0.06638094037771225,
0.6165481209754944,
-0.18428562581539154,
1.2329938411712646,
0.8625163435935974,
0.604796826839447,
0.25517895817756653,
-0.4886913597583771,
0.20093142986297607,
-0.42949679493904114,
0.40207380056381226,
-0.27061429619789124,
-0.2641552686691284,
-0.05080696567893028,
0.3189919888973236,
0.39126187562942505,
0.7087507247924805,
0.024703137576580048,
-0.1187874898314476,
0.10342591255903244,
0.39304593205451965,
-0.8748719096183777,
0.30587038397789,
-1.041803240776062,
-0.27429601550102234,
-0.27710506319999695,
-0.04314722493290901,
-0.3761778175830841,
-0.16342797875404358,
0.3370838463306427,
-0.7191738486289978,
0.259245365858078,
-0.03293628245592117,
1.3573857545852661,
0.33077868819236755,
-0.2537938356399536,
-0.66531902551651,
-0.8328490853309631,
0.7508867383003235,
-0.43892142176628113,
0.08395364880561829,
0.24391072988510132,
0.34445449709892273,
-0.40621304512023926,
-0.6343273520469666,
-0.14337654411792755,
-0.39043107628822327,
-0.163513645529747,
-0.12866289913654327,
-0.30711275339126587,
-0.06536107510328293,
0.4349590837955475,
0.25690513849258423,
-0.09557310491800308,
0.12276720255613327,
-0.17460410296916962,
0.11838601529598236,
0.499758780002594,
0.040626686066389084,
0.27817437052726746,
-0.25228744745254517,
-0.5801798701286316,
-0.18851105868816376,
-1.0987417697906494,
0.002132760128006339,
0.298237681388855,
0.4215693771839142,
0.39665788412094116,
0.5627521276473999,
-0.004810328595340252,
0.7115044593811035,
-0.12834765017032623,
0.04848436638712883,
-0.06718190014362335,
-0.16030389070510864,
-0.2370564341545105,
-0.3221880793571472,
1.075506329536438,
-0.12524497509002686,
0.3637066185474396,
-0.4486314058303833,
-0.23815996944904327,
0.26663410663604736,
0.22869105637073517,
-0.9361155033111572,
-0.4087904095649719,
-0.10772975534200668,
-0.3192038834095001,
-0.632655680179596,
0.13282807171344757,
-0.7833813428878784,
-0.2886561453342438,
0.20784541964530945,
0.33741214871406555,
-0.4270961582660675,
-0.1858123391866684,
-0.024231111630797386,
-0.36148712038993835,
-0.32787641882896423,
0.2725958824157715,
-0.6772728562355042,
0.16264382004737854,
0.6257807016372681,
0.6220868229866028,
-0.0995967835187912,
-0.14438341557979584,
-0.5375363230705261,
0.05959164351224899,
-0.251264750957489,
0.5139557719230652,
-0.5549986362457275,
-0.38587895035743713,
-0.03508349508047104,
-0.0023249953519552946,
-0.15886400640010834,
-0.8421471118927002,
0.6359307169914246,
-0.7549516558647156,
0.2372117042541504,
-0.25734424591064453,
-0.47063469886779785,
-0.11523187160491943,
0.14605243504047394,
-0.9271241426467896,
0.5510228276252747,
0.06560955196619034,
-0.7108220458030701,
0.19048580527305603,
-0.2777744233608246,
-0.2973475456237793,
-0.2434392124414444,
-0.2210625261068344,
-0.6777457594871521,
0.10622205585241318,
0.40706560015678406,
0.44029700756073,
-0.5984082818031311,
0.20157642662525177,
-0.8536169528961182,
-0.12268843501806259,
0.3373388648033142,
-0.34250786900520325,
1.0230625867843628,
0.16640636324882507,
-0.315965473651886,
-0.2274758368730545,
-0.7935892343521118,
-0.2457258105278015,
0.4408898949623108,
-0.14163705706596375,
-0.8114222288131714,
0.09435105323791504,
-0.15553498268127441,
0.5954824686050415,
-0.09769603610038757,
-0.48614874482154846,
0.3137717843055725,
-0.6364576816558838,
0.37890759110450745,
0.6312475204467773,
0.48122188448905945,
0.35151371359825134,
-0.1935756802558899,
0.7203817367553711,
0.2181406468153,
-0.0837772861123085,
0.00915634073317051,
-0.4364108741283417,
-0.3931210935115814,
-0.3151925504207611,
0.2883993685245514,
0.41822391748428345,
-1.0607973337173462,
0.3651254177093506,
-0.4715019464492798,
-0.5822558403015137,
-0.3483950197696686,
0.5168362259864807,
0.48425301909446716,
0.5435693860054016,
0.36327430605888367,
0.01909445784986019,
-0.1868700236082077,
-0.8429633975028992,
-0.5071130990982056,
-0.29417911171913147,
0.055299822241067886,
0.2331155687570572,
0.4681471884250641,
0.02203911356627941,
0.9403354525566101,
-0.6555084586143494,
-0.3781071603298187,
-0.20565108954906464,
0.16823653876781464,
-0.0203940961509943,
0.2905420660972595,
0.7892822623252869,
-1.1554526090621948,
-0.1785050481557846,
-0.40611380338668823,
-0.7314630150794983,
0.22115744650363922,
-0.05159790813922882,
-0.09115014970302582,
-0.10687988996505737,
0.298307329416275,
-1.0684800148010254,
0.5931646823883057,
0.20674794912338257,
-0.09849804639816284,
0.36312079429626465,
0.13315947353839874,
-0.2783687114715576,
-0.9213266968727112,
-0.1375061720609665,
0.09638439863920212,
0.01828906126320362,
-0.4749537408351898,
0.3351796269416809,
-0.05179707705974579,
-0.2950156629085541,
-0.7115289568901062,
0.30497056245803833,
-0.5776024460792542,
0.21162299811840057,
-0.17142464220523834,
0.19821886718273163,
0.2456667572259903,
0.4707815647125244,
0.18203404545783997,
0.4169020652770996,
0.49958357214927673,
-0.7286261320114136,
0.5203749537467957,
0.3081364631652832,
-0.2637806236743927,
0.01685336045920849,
-0.729803204536438,
0.010541175492107868,
-0.08921266347169876,
0.08916377276182175,
-0.6378633379936218,
-0.05354386195540428,
0.387561172246933,
-0.2173704355955124,
0.4184699058532715,
-0.19078831374645233,
-0.5894048810005188,
-0.09270505607128143,
-0.2745487689971924,
0.23369194567203522,
0.5058053135871887,
-0.6713361144065857,
0.48880183696746826,
0.2660149037837982,
0.05963503569364548,
-0.5651014447212219,
-0.6700558066368103,
-0.04978230223059654,
-0.6657792925834656,
-0.6505910754203796,
0.3712664842605591,
0.4794188439846039,
-0.340898722410202,
0.5496835112571716,
0.028699055314064026,
-0.06478817760944366,
0.4186772406101227,
0.30777448415756226,
0.427536278963089,
-0.11219905316829681,
0.2899804413318634,
-0.33916014432907104,
0.10091943293809891,
0.3494362533092499,
0.2668982446193695,
0.12757252156734467,
0.09372473508119583,
-0.20799584686756134,
-0.33291149139404297,
0.4543490707874298,
0.6806483864784241,
-0.21081127226352692,
0.9915990829467773,
0.32892876863479614,
-0.47701045870780945,
-0.12631015479564667,
-0.09018086642026901,
-0.19578225910663605,
-0.40643903613090515,
0.47960400581359863,
-0.5594584345817566,
-0.4426689147949219,
0.5190095901489258,
-0.13686291873455048,
-0.027687570080161095,
0.6643717885017395,
0.044773168861866,
0.06140182539820671,
1.0336109399795532,
0.4914689064025879,
-0.18281099200248718,
0.5148654580116272,
-0.3864370584487915,
0.14095893502235413,
-0.8004019260406494,
0.0025504855439066887,
-0.5238076448440552,
0.02637569047510624,
-0.7418965101242065,
0.01462610624730587,
0.20296846330165863,
0.3575766682624817,
0.2688179016113281,
0.6515709161758423,
-0.27770209312438965,
0.014807101339101791,
0.4338904023170471,
0.12970010936260223,
-0.06419923901557922,
-0.07951737940311432,
0.22214819490909576,
-0.13622251152992249,
-0.6436293721199036,
-0.37678655982017517,
1.0151830911636353,
0.1608494222164154,
0.9192381501197815,
0.2695196866989136,
0.8667148351669312,
-0.039570897817611694,
0.41094842553138733,
-0.8183858394622803,
0.42862871289253235,
-0.15693138539791107,
-0.6473926305770874,
-0.24310971796512604,
-0.7343697547912598,
-1.1804224252700806,
0.3042246997356415,
-0.20725388824939728,
-0.7079499363899231,
0.543047308921814,
0.11323271691799164,
-0.4334524869918823,
0.3054826557636261,
-0.6071462035179138,
1.0342835187911987,
0.01573457568883896,
-0.35300448536872864,
0.10105175524950027,
-0.486383855342865,
0.5304049849510193,
-0.07552923262119293,
0.12260166555643082,
-0.12777070701122284,
0.06897401064634323,
0.6948228478431702,
-0.6728115677833557,
0.46662014722824097,
-0.2970883250236511,
0.08308393508195877,
0.45786696672439575,
0.18457700312137604,
0.9016916751861572,
-0.16989140212535858,
-0.09885965287685394,
-0.2342904955148697,
-0.20511826872825623,
-0.16677981615066528,
-1.0921118259429932,
0.642943799495697,
-0.6200680136680603,
-0.8333789110183716,
-0.24149157106876373,
-0.41175761818885803,
-0.27318260073661804,
-0.012647767551243305,
0.4808456301689148,
0.538750410079956,
-0.3118976056575775,
0.30104997754096985,
0.29803183674812317,
-0.0427260547876358,
0.36687731742858887,
-0.14374954998493195,
-0.1069115698337555,
-0.2826748490333557,
0.9161299467086792,
0.22077110409736633,
0.6392275094985962,
0.18675224483013153,
-0.00023702315229456872,
-0.41623857617378235,
-0.3011942207813263,
-0.4024982750415802,
0.24921955168247223,
-0.7464587092399597,
-0.1673250049352646,
-0.5812947154045105,
-0.07619571685791016,
-0.49906691908836365,
0.25223231315612793,
-0.5126634836196899,
-0.536382794380188,
-0.6422792673110962,
0.1338093876838684,
0.10458795726299286,
0.6387730836868286,
0.2337789386510849,
-0.055981408804655075,
-0.759780764579773,
0.5283706784248352,
0.27885299921035767,
-0.4384683072566986,
-0.1380707323551178,
-0.4863334894180298,
-0.04566670209169388,
0.012237081304192543,
-0.5063701868057251,
-1.2076292037963867,
0.45193567872047424,
0.306759774684906,
0.28587278723716736,
0.5620531439781189,
0.36585891246795654,
0.662163257598877,
-0.3413228690624237,
0.5336037874221802,
0.03892165422439575,
-0.5917851328849792,
0.7546715140342712,
-0.048896994441747665,
-0.056821681559085846,
0.3815607726573944,
0.5892574787139893,
-0.00037951135891489685,
-0.6030215620994568,
-1.078851580619812,
-0.88295578956604,
0.5574812293052673,
0.26968899369239807,
-0.08942031860351562,
-0.10609859228134155,
0.4422816038131714,
-0.20111609995365143,
0.21935711801052094,
-0.6975376009941101,
-0.2623439133167267,
-0.05887727439403534,
-0.13331645727157593,
-0.08551240712404251,
-0.4330443739891052,
-0.05869575962424278,
0.2637938857078552,
0.8110007047653198,
0.25294649600982666,
-0.057067953050136566,
0.1494242250919342,
-0.08664536476135254,
-0.003277443815022707,
0.3263772428035736,
0.26111721992492676,
0.534267783164978,
-0.38633105158805847,
0.1092514619231224,
-0.5032162070274353,
-0.09215554594993591,
0.22601109743118286,
0.640984058380127,
-0.4904548227787018,
0.2873857319355011,
0.3975830078125,
0.6695351600646973,
0.11720406264066696,
-0.4792761206626892,
0.6218512058258057,
0.08788105845451355,
0.12426862120628357,
-0.15772221982479095,
0.004455528222024441,
0.04219619929790497,
-0.015201873145997524,
0.18959787487983704,
0.37754037976264954,
0.21206867694854736,
-0.8167678713798523,
0.15516088902950287,
0.6956106424331665,
-0.48761260509490967,
-0.28806185722351074,
0.7403621673583984,
-0.06272011250257492,
-0.0886080339550972,
0.6128371357917786,
-0.33062639832496643,
-0.6473851203918457,
0.5115837454795837,
0.29015907645225525,
0.8283503651618958,
0.02380179986357689,
0.0537579320371151,
0.09239639341831207,
0.34219804406166077,
-0.045254673808813095,
-0.42719483375549316,
0.025832204148173332,
-0.7966277003288269,
-0.17951488494873047,
-0.33035269379615784,
-0.20118194818496704,
0.40141382813453674,
-1.0133088827133179,
0.31230616569519043,
-0.3762618899345398,
-0.2538801431655884,
0.2932898700237274,
-0.11839878559112549,
-0.6547045111656189,
0.2893844544887543,
-0.18354105949401855,
0.6071100831031799,
-0.9303289651870728,
0.9778250455856323,
0.616936445236206,
-0.6002019047737122,
-0.9039402604103088,
0.052896466106176376,
-0.054688308387994766,
-0.4341829717159271,
0.9897257685661316,
0.1139906793832779,
-0.05458411946892738,
-0.31929701566696167,
-0.19088687002658844,
-0.8625504374504089,
0.715043306350708,
0.6209596991539001,
-0.21762937307357788,
-0.46190935373306274,
-0.018065663054585457,
0.3985825479030609,
-0.3986864984035492,
-0.16283221542835236,
0.256743460893631,
-0.012622763402760029,
0.23473100364208221,
-0.4898127317428589,
0.37101998925209045,
-0.172737717628479,
0.06886378675699234,
0.30663982033729553,
-0.35312771797180176,
0.9288660883903503,
-0.19573049247264862,
-0.6135745644569397,
0.26021745800971985,
0.7050825357437134,
0.18533535301685333,
-0.02271563559770584,
0.7793974280357361,
0.6044889092445374,
0.35120531916618347,
-0.1315077841281891,
1.2136749029159546,
-0.03605515509843826,
0.37527045607566833,
1.2209721803665161,
-0.17434360086917877,
0.8584817051887512,
0.5761361122131348,
0.10619448870420456,
0.38993948698043823,
0.5146723985671997,
-0.05724555253982544,
0.8422809839248657,
-0.028678223490715027,
-0.037046726793050766,
-0.2608974277973175,
-0.09162143617868423,
-0.3513934016227722,
0.44158950448036194,
0.43590089678764343,
-0.7965534329414368,
-0.3864802122116089,
-0.11820922791957855,
0.06436583399772644,
0.20335198938846588,
0.020707037299871445,
0.6139166355133057,
0.22137318551540375,
-0.8311774134635925,
0.6527606844902039,
-0.08227963745594025,
0.3395867943763733,
-0.49807173013687134,
-0.01185180526226759,
0.2291630208492279,
0.27633196115493774,
0.14220209419727325,
-0.3959410786628723,
0.5366950631141663,
-0.0565204955637455,
-0.14762091636657715,
-0.2073124647140503,
0.7518871426582336,
-0.4251527488231659,
-0.38163477182388306,
0.43686506152153015,
0.43573901057243347,
0.046935342252254486,
-0.408826619386673,
-0.782846212387085,
-0.017865952104330063,
0.052798300981521606,
-0.5593084692955017,
0.33580756187438965,
0.687698483467102,
0.1195860356092453,
0.636883020401001,
0.5595702528953552,
0.43982571363449097,
-0.08849195390939713,
-0.24330489337444305,
1.0420613288879395,
-0.4162960350513458,
-0.26941996812820435,
-1.0278064012527466,
0.18250104784965515,
-0.18748173117637634,
-0.37717577815055847,
0.7459794878959656,
0.23895736038684845,
0.5751726627349854,
-0.058145370334386826,
0.5306469202041626,
0.1430724859237671,
0.5757327675819397,
-0.5685080885887146,
0.41951078176498413,
-0.640882670879364,
0.354425847530365,
-0.3649911880493164,
-0.897057294845581,
-0.19625769555568695,
0.21025405824184418,
-0.43694594502449036,
-0.03966255486011505,
0.670563817024231,
0.7175709009170532,
-0.05262864753603935,
-0.18215787410736084,
0.3468123972415924,
0.1254405975341797,
0.6138811707496643,
0.7667259573936462,
1.0364432334899902,
-0.606042742729187,
1.0490168333053589,
-0.6158011555671692,
0.018067898228764534,
-0.09464765340089798,
-0.6436583995819092,
-0.8661825656890869,
-0.49884870648384094,
-0.521765947341919,
-0.3941097557544708,
0.03884977847337723,
0.5963929295539856,
0.5517855882644653,
-0.5194492340087891,
0.3702484965324402,
-0.17248521745204926,
0.2651078701019287,
-0.18124720454216003,
-0.26878365874290466,
0.6130446195602417,
-0.2768416106700897,
-0.7423747181892395,
0.40144455432891846,
0.20611828565597534,
0.2507530450820923,
-0.2333529144525528,
0.21721777319908142,
-0.20081032812595367,
-0.20813417434692383,
0.10675201565027237,
0.38414648175239563,
-0.9677553772926331,
-0.2877327799797058,
-0.3199852406978607,
-0.2501934766769409,
-0.19457611441612244,
0.6383545398712158,
-0.6842463612556458,
0.1704331934452057,
0.2831946909427643,
0.7282626032829285,
0.17623968422412872,
0.3100253641605377,
0.5418339967727661,
-0.5991859436035156,
0.31243863701820374,
0.32907119393348694,
0.5167834758758545,
0.4413793087005615,
-0.5478289127349854,
0.4173349440097809,
0.5670804977416992,
-0.33212828636169434,
-0.8227767944335938,
0.5153756141662598,
-0.6730795502662659,
-0.3802781105041504,
1.0878782272338867,
-0.7765588760375977,
-0.4127672016620636,
0.0438569076359272,
0.2152382880449295,
0.13867099583148956,
-0.19797036051750183,
0.7515801787376404,
0.7366811633110046,
-0.17043769359588623,
0.13088668882846832,
-0.21906541287899017,
0.7744678258895874,
0.49828648567199707,
-0.5713931918144226,
0.16282498836517334,
0.40124571323394775,
0.08290474861860275,
0.5535731315612793,
0.2330222725868225,
-0.1549328863620758,
0.21096020936965942,
0.0790145993232727,
-0.324590265750885,
-0.2006845921278,
-0.3147346079349518,
-0.13675570487976074,
0.6066573262214661,
0.14870288968086243,
-0.5323082208633423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.19052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19052v1
|
Exploring the Efficacy of Large Language Models in Summarizing Mental Health Counseling Sessions: A Benchmark Study
| 2024-02-29T11:29:47 | 2024-02-29T11:29:47 |
Prottay Kumar Adhikary, Aseem Srivastava, Shivani Kumar, Salam Michael Singh, Puneet Manuja, Jini K Gopinath, Vijay Krishnan, Swati Kedia, Koushik Sinha Deb, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Comprehensive summaries of sessions enable an effective continuity in mental
health counseling, facilitating informed therapy planning. Yet, manual
summarization presents a significant challenge, diverting experts' attention
from the core counseling process. This study evaluates the effectiveness of
state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs) in selectively summarizing
various components of therapy sessions through aspect-based summarization,
aiming to benchmark their performance. We introduce MentalCLOUDS, a
counseling-component guided summarization dataset consisting of 191 counseling
sessions with summaries focused on three distinct counseling components (aka
counseling aspects). Additionally, we assess the capabilities of 11
state-of-the-art LLMs in addressing the task of component-guided summarization
in counseling. The generated summaries are evaluated quantitatively using
standard summarization metrics and verified qualitatively by mental health
professionals. Our findings demonstrate the superior performance of
task-specific LLMs such as MentalLlama, Mistral, and MentalBART in terms of
standard quantitative metrics such as Rouge-1, Rouge-2, Rouge-L, and BERTScore
across all aspects of counseling components. Further, expert evaluation reveals
that Mistral supersedes both MentalLlama and MentalBART based on six parameters
-- affective attitude, burden, ethicality, coherence, opportunity costs, and
perceived effectiveness. However, these models share the same weakness by
demonstrating a potential for improvement in the opportunity costs and
perceived effectiveness metrics.
|
[
-0.4100419580936432,
-0.7169408202171326,
0.8378632068634033,
0.3329324722290039,
-0.38474327325820923,
-0.08697449415922165,
-0.5399589538574219,
-0.26528581976890564,
0.17642788589000702,
0.44082099199295044,
-0.37920501828193665,
-0.7526269555091858,
-0.6548117399215698,
0.27036210894584656,
-0.5274444222450256,
1.0230681896209717,
-0.10579545795917511,
0.2804395854473114,
-0.13226886093616486,
-0.05830089747905731,
-0.8303967118263245,
-0.47323906421661377,
-0.5363216996192932,
-0.6573098301887512,
0.393494188785553,
0.10824813693761826,
0.7020769715309143,
0.31416288018226624,
0.6739508509635925,
0.26340731978416443,
-0.3955615758895874,
0.03526884317398071,
-0.6105688214302063,
0.17953698337078094,
-0.20245343446731567,
-0.4917528033256531,
-0.9946991801261902,
-0.1530744731426239,
0.5110412240028381,
0.8650725483894348,
-0.5859534740447998,
0.327178031206131,
0.2228294461965561,
0.572992742061615,
-0.6514842510223389,
0.17937567830085754,
-0.6387327313423157,
0.05874136835336685,
0.021462364122271538,
0.009068652056157589,
-0.2644079625606537,
-0.1646643877029419,
0.15504969656467438,
-0.40680816769599915,
0.2665127217769623,
-0.07390453666448593,
0.32652631402015686,
0.1420108824968338,
-0.574669599533081,
-0.07723632454872131,
-0.8097190856933594,
0.675845742225647,
-0.9650747179985046,
0.38545456528663635,
0.5982569456100464,
0.36995577812194824,
-0.31011930108070374,
-0.6148731708526611,
-0.03245202451944351,
-0.018002811819314957,
-0.09807400405406952,
0.3481208086013794,
-0.5268087983131409,
0.28007352352142334,
0.36346933245658875,
0.6579037308692932,
-0.45266517996788025,
0.16095948219299316,
-0.3202163279056549,
-0.13968080282211304,
0.6991809010505676,
0.599804162979126,
0.06629879027605057,
0.07551536709070206,
0.10364136099815369,
0.13562247157096863,
-0.4747818410396576,
0.12537333369255066,
-0.3603154420852661,
0.29029402136802673,
-0.23359911143779755,
0.6713888645172119,
-0.20775704085826874,
0.38089504837989807,
0.2159729301929474,
-0.9013403058052063,
-0.39127686619758606,
-0.1009172648191452,
-0.33496931195259094,
0.10008123517036438,
0.697793185710907,
0.903039813041687,
-0.08537767827510834,
-0.4048152267932892,
-0.14608518779277802,
-0.28735658526420593,
0.44128385186195374,
-0.7553723454475403,
-0.10377052426338196,
0.5157446265220642,
-0.6313164830207825,
0.14246247708797455,
-0.35776564478874207,
-0.5676414966583252,
-0.4973316192626953,
-0.5993093252182007,
0.04838972166180611,
-0.5680480599403381,
-0.3950592875480652,
0.13599799573421478,
-0.03993251547217369,
-0.04254884272813797,
0.42818158864974976,
-0.5184661746025085,
0.5230864882469177,
0.963342010974884,
1.1123268604278564,
-0.2529911398887634,
-0.2523115575313568,
-0.1956714242696762,
0.16000311076641083,
-0.4429459273815155,
0.775361180305481,
-0.34818723797798157,
-0.7860684990882874,
0.17309652268886566,
-0.039852261543273926,
-0.006148090120404959,
-0.5637161135673523,
0.3150472342967987,
-0.14556588232517242,
-0.002480271039530635,
-0.7229710817337036,
-0.7152865529060364,
-0.11835409700870514,
0.31021666526794434,
-0.39632898569107056,
0.6996846199035645,
0.29285669326782227,
-0.8286506533622742,
0.3453623056411743,
-0.2805330157279968,
-0.3054921627044678,
-0.0015478647546842694,
-0.1517285853624344,
-0.11277826130390167,
0.4758666157722473,
0.13753290474414825,
0.6046086549758911,
-0.4413919150829315,
0.5227599143981934,
-0.3070871829986572,
-0.37775444984436035,
0.4792279601097107,
-0.2645338773727417,
0.36224234104156494,
-0.14851592481136322,
-0.19462937116622925,
0.26174482703208923,
-0.43008485436439514,
-0.1757282167673111,
-0.0012001562863588333,
-0.08747057616710663,
-0.47241562604904175,
-0.15850766003131866,
0.0868012011051178,
0.24718335270881653,
0.0804046094417572,
-0.23354944586753845,
0.010149578563869,
-0.16226227581501007,
0.25443077087402344,
0.4067498445510864,
0.20206722617149353,
-0.03069462440907955,
-0.41884949803352356,
0.838107168674469,
-0.2644807696342468,
0.03613181784749031,
-0.356241911649704,
-0.2316698133945465,
-0.2754862904548645,
-0.7567213773727417,
-0.10381010919809341,
0.24304020404815674,
-0.6728881597518921,
0.5347212553024292,
-0.3147040009498596,
-0.824062705039978,
-0.22324740886688232,
-0.033420380204916,
0.6345651745796204,
0.5246864557266235,
0.35140854120254517,
-0.4828000068664551,
0.018632203340530396,
-1.0476906299591064,
-0.45962560176849365,
0.0487954244017601,
0.03689923137426376,
0.02012547478079796,
0.5690286159515381,
0.20505888760089874,
0.8951753973960876,
-0.5561618804931641,
-0.17539618909358978,
-0.48753124475479126,
0.23654645681381226,
0.07106558978557587,
-0.010115163400769234,
0.7082045078277588,
-0.19482722878456116,
-0.44071438908576965,
-0.13910672068595886,
-0.7201921939849854,
-0.16802696883678436,
0.09709223359823227,
-0.12933452427387238,
-0.1940740942955017,
0.15968891978263855,
-0.5326163172721863,
0.44694650173187256,
0.34684351086616516,
-0.41553401947021484,
0.7930256724357605,
-0.48548248410224915,
0.18557904660701752,
-0.8676788806915283,
0.22694195806980133,
0.1166909709572792,
-0.45939457416534424,
-0.5328425765037537,
-0.0530998557806015,
-0.0425739586353302,
-0.14666791260242462,
-0.25786224007606506,
0.2244073748588562,
-0.3892615735530853,
-0.09761760383844376,
-0.5524102449417114,
0.07514020800590515,
-0.327406644821167,
0.5998210906982422,
-0.1521366387605667,
0.7397423982620239,
0.4043755531311035,
-0.3768411874771118,
0.30270782113075256,
0.1082061231136322,
-0.17416036128997803,
0.9486185312271118,
-0.8000851273536682,
-0.08506087213754654,
-0.18809553980827332,
0.68216872215271,
-0.6812277436256409,
-0.3134368062019348,
-0.1350378394126892,
0.3388420045375824,
0.2197549045085907,
0.07942131906747818,
-0.35729682445526123,
-0.15304739773273468,
-0.3638094365596771,
0.46935874223709106,
0.3226633667945862,
0.03209277242422104,
0.29627537727355957,
0.329435259103775,
-0.598965048789978,
-0.321626216173172,
-0.39318761229515076,
0.32567375898361206,
-0.45889052748680115,
-0.05841356888413429,
0.6122055053710938,
0.20516465604305267,
-0.420840322971344,
-0.01727261207997799,
-0.18924939632415771,
0.18540601432323456,
0.008493817411363125,
0.38679376244544983,
0.10309092700481415,
-0.0036951382644474506,
0.09020436555147171,
0.2656269073486328,
-0.27329427003860474,
0.3376849591732025,
0.02210298739373684,
0.5427088737487793,
-0.289120614528656,
-0.65572190284729,
-0.4527204632759094,
0.656095564365387,
0.7011578679084778,
-0.38906198740005493,
0.7347077131271362,
0.37491872906684875,
-0.47996366024017334,
0.006877546664327383,
-0.641097903251648,
-0.11549893766641617,
-0.3025456964969635,
0.5873435735702515,
-0.05761472508311272,
-0.9328796863555908,
0.538186252117157,
-0.005463845562189817,
0.4043486416339874,
0.2636863589286804,
0.5476025938987732,
0.09240454435348511,
1.0133510828018188,
0.4349139630794525,
-0.15614718198776245,
0.38737356662750244,
-0.38762739300727844,
0.27184683084487915,
-0.870838463306427,
0.07721813768148422,
-0.18743135035037994,
-0.2827339470386505,
-0.3755878806114197,
-0.35457155108451843,
0.7400813102722168,
0.35298052430152893,
-0.1875915229320526,
0.07981086522340775,
-0.5277836322784424,
0.0534309446811676,
0.10851214826107025,
0.19741104543209076,
0.6220831274986267,
-0.1628689169883728,
0.09112442284822464,
-0.42727231979370117,
-0.42285481095314026,
-0.6713243126869202,
1.149717926979065,
0.44278809428215027,
0.3795171082019806,
0.19237643480300903,
0.46207720041275024,
0.1346634328365326,
0.7624186873435974,
-0.7948856949806213,
0.5693215727806091,
0.016060898080468178,
-0.41783028841018677,
-0.3008187711238861,
-0.15245193243026733,
-0.7941169142723083,
0.7468382120132446,
-0.22043778002262115,
-1.0172135829925537,
-0.01989155076444149,
0.11897623538970947,
-0.2955605089664459,
0.1880604326725006,
-0.180934876203537,
0.5155578255653381,
-0.2746664583683014,
-0.07129835337400436,
-0.730958878993988,
-0.3236508369445801,
0.6495710015296936,
-0.30447059869766235,
0.27370384335517883,
-0.38283464312553406,
-0.029934557154774666,
0.7516594529151917,
-0.4377230405807495,
0.5845767855644226,
-0.07161892205476761,
-0.2591208219528198,
-0.06300325691699982,
0.08171473443508148,
0.17083974182605743,
0.05609363690018654,
0.09692515432834625,
-0.016412796452641487,
0.4816107451915741,
-0.3301108479499817,
-0.89190673828125,
0.4135194420814514,
-0.44719773530960083,
-0.6773004531860352,
-0.16651791334152222,
-0.6881536245346069,
-0.5391719341278076,
0.3111056387424469,
0.22207482159137726,
0.795780599117279,
-0.38032469153404236,
0.11513141542673111,
0.3686467111110687,
-0.26674574613571167,
0.2813480794429779,
0.790560245513916,
-0.6598308086395264,
-0.6675539016723633,
0.6721325516700745,
0.36853134632110596,
0.1299663931131363,
-0.1275661736726761,
0.17749211192131042,
-0.022677233442664146,
-0.6617526412010193,
0.14224380254745483,
0.5373712182044983,
-0.6704038381576538,
-0.1276347041130066,
-0.5971688628196716,
-0.030519170686602592,
-0.2893999218940735,
-0.27117919921875,
-0.4489430785179138,
-0.21163597702980042,
0.33582693338394165,
-0.1730968952178955,
0.322454571723938,
0.6239915490150452,
0.34237608313560486,
0.45028823614120483,
-0.7426187992095947,
0.1839687079191208,
0.11069338768720627,
0.25206419825553894,
0.5340136289596558,
-0.31143853068351746,
-0.31477388739585876,
-0.031292952597141266,
-0.5476887226104736,
-1.0403777360916138,
0.379375696182251,
-0.19468359649181366,
0.4848475158214569,
0.6503856182098389,
0.07064502686262131,
1.015411138534546,
-0.3439316749572754,
0.8171142935752869,
0.3989485204219818,
-0.8378604650497437,
0.536505401134491,
-0.6825039386749268,
0.5468984246253967,
0.7026573419570923,
0.20126333832740784,
-0.6744241714477539,
-0.8698680400848389,
-0.5687643885612488,
-0.8858584761619568,
0.628529965877533,
0.34962978959083557,
-0.11452724784612656,
0.20831680297851562,
0.5078179240226746,
0.11319050937891006,
0.4070700407028198,
-0.2810812294483185,
-0.38929447531700134,
0.12901340425014496,
-0.1657513529062271,
-0.12717226147651672,
-0.27840712666511536,
-0.5814863443374634,
-0.2940433621406555,
0.6575766801834106,
0.08776749670505524,
0.30270257592201233,
0.2764832675457001,
0.07776127755641937,
-0.03477342799305916,
0.5854571461677551,
0.7152323722839355,
1.1114927530288696,
-0.15006214380264282,
0.18135719001293182,
0.3717272877693176,
-0.5601635575294495,
0.08107482641935349,
0.15099093317985535,
0.14794625341892242,
0.21428091824054718,
0.9532743692398071,
0.5923777222633362,
0.5096713900566101,
-0.6113408207893372,
0.5332123041152954,
-0.23678867518901825,
-0.11075256019830704,
-0.20416228473186493,
0.10159679502248764,
0.10971064865589142,
0.3876917362213135,
0.1422809213399887,
-0.492477685213089,
0.31108322739601135,
-0.4108886122703552,
-0.32043296098709106,
0.37403640151023865,
-0.5667707324028015,
-0.4522577226161957,
0.37140288949012756,
-0.11685549467802048,
-0.2967493534088135,
0.28729164600372314,
0.1438358575105667,
-0.08630833774805069,
0.4523146450519562,
0.6653026342391968,
0.8265770077705383,
-0.06126276031136513,
0.15278342366218567,
0.09847855567932129,
0.09830527752637863,
-0.3397994041442871,
0.15741001069545746,
-0.17689569294452667,
-0.22098970413208008,
-0.35385724902153015,
-0.31114986538887024,
-0.528846263885498,
0.2660100758075714,
-1.3354871273040771,
-0.0885506272315979,
-0.26317131519317627,
-0.7372382283210754,
-0.16652721166610718,
-0.11485160142183304,
-0.7757522463798523,
-0.0264878049492836,
-0.11847243458032608,
0.909009575843811,
-0.7137228846549988,
0.360532283782959,
1.114160180091858,
-0.20435598492622375,
-0.7494635581970215,
-0.009013388305902481,
0.32844820618629456,
-0.3457885682582855,
-0.20235411822795868,
0.04356325417757034,
-0.07323149591684341,
-0.3896089792251587,
-0.2369268536567688,
-0.8377119302749634,
1.585796594619751,
0.5751875042915344,
-0.4749702513217926,
-0.12124133855104446,
0.07327714562416077,
0.8635028004646301,
-0.29288721084594727,
0.5203752517700195,
0.8696057796478271,
0.3813524842262268,
-0.19634251296520233,
-1.231902837753296,
0.201734259724617,
-0.10786090791225433,
0.2837103605270386,
0.033097222447395325,
-0.6947574019432068,
0.4723794758319855,
0.27533286809921265,
-0.1702597439289093,
-0.1313210129737854,
0.6327326893806458,
0.5050721764564514,
0.33904770016670227,
0.4536226987838745,
0.2417639046907425,
0.7420201301574707,
0.08405466377735138,
0.9754636883735657,
-0.6624345183372498,
0.37273091077804565,
1.3149577379226685,
-0.32180872559547424,
0.7585114240646362,
0.299037903547287,
-0.5488315224647522,
0.14747633039951324,
0.41750368475914,
0.19724011421203613,
0.34445565938949585,
-0.0413854755461216,
-0.1781628131866455,
-0.21701595187187195,
-0.5242517590522766,
-0.4231119751930237,
0.30160942673683167,
0.3867954611778259,
-0.43006226420402527,
-0.4448269009590149,
0.15142101049423218,
0.3587946593761444,
0.03165441006422043,
-0.2590503692626953,
0.7619217038154602,
0.5267027616500854,
-0.7977787256240845,
0.30063483119010925,
0.24844282865524292,
0.2212052047252655,
-0.576969563961029,
0.12538723647594452,
-0.31560763716697693,
0.09173286706209183,
-0.2928231954574585,
-0.5580865740776062,
0.2559320628643036,
0.2925967276096344,
-0.10032426565885544,
-0.335833877325058,
0.6051947474479675,
-0.4018472135066986,
-0.5328726172447205,
0.1304740458726883,
0.5298904776573181,
0.06932639330625534,
-0.20571255683898926,
-0.3914836347103119,
-0.17281736433506012,
-0.4366534650325775,
-0.2747161388397217,
0.5563026070594788,
0.42666634917259216,
-0.17440034449100494,
0.6326925158500671,
0.20781922340393066,
0.43407875299453735,
-0.5236719250679016,
0.15922802686691284,
0.7760226130485535,
-0.7306111454963684,
-0.617169976234436,
-0.8048767447471619,
0.5193606019020081,
-0.15935280919075012,
-0.5154329538345337,
0.8628283143043518,
0.4330402910709381,
0.340728223323822,
0.2992093563079834,
0.6307558417320251,
0.32519179582595825,
0.37867483496665955,
-0.39786505699157715,
0.4997848570346832,
-0.41754502058029175,
0.19137977063655853,
-0.39107146859169006,
-0.9727694392204285,
0.03935058414936066,
0.258540540933609,
-0.6438173055648804,
0.02382054552435875,
0.8291841745376587,
0.48831212520599365,
0.05718535557389259,
0.28598612546920776,
0.27805930376052856,
0.19034817814826965,
0.6431625485420227,
0.3423359990119934,
0.7211865782737732,
0.09028179198503494,
-0.12382657080888748,
-0.4059346914291382,
-0.38554924726486206,
-0.03845828399062157,
-0.5979002714157104,
-1.0391725301742554,
-0.421665221452713,
-0.2724454402923584,
-0.012143840081989765,
-0.029034020379185677,
1.1327416896820068,
0.5266653895378113,
-0.5463847517967224,
-0.32908913493156433,
0.23848222196102142,
-0.20141544938087463,
-0.5506559014320374,
-0.19441089034080505,
0.41463950276374817,
-0.011056143790483475,
-0.17915137112140656,
0.13774605095386505,
0.5805076360702515,
-0.11578081548213959,
-0.6098873019218445,
0.28155946731567383,
0.4252750277519226,
-0.07410246133804321,
0.7614535689353943,
-0.15060803294181824,
-1.1786506175994873,
0.14428287744522095,
-0.32202407717704773,
-0.2984512150287628,
-0.15622147917747498,
1.141101598739624,
-0.25147494673728943,
0.314241498708725,
0.1165439784526825,
0.280030757188797,
0.4275228977203369,
0.23371440172195435,
0.852803647518158,
-0.2815965712070465,
-0.09534185379743576,
0.1142144575715065,
0.5164823532104492,
0.14234906435012817,
-0.3497299253940582,
0.3046717941761017,
-0.25423693656921387,
-0.41356712579727173,
-0.8176254630088806,
-0.15114092826843262,
-0.7710269093513489,
-0.35839876532554626,
1.0253504514694214,
-0.4706408977508545,
0.04603784158825874,
-0.2638200521469116,
-0.39565542340278625,
0.2970280051231384,
-0.314768522977829,
0.9826977252960205,
0.947902262210846,
-0.4886121153831482,
-0.025658901780843735,
-0.6903089880943298,
0.3562946021556854,
0.46800583600997925,
-0.8276253938674927,
0.333395391702652,
0.6027125120162964,
0.23949791491031647,
-0.09286278486251831,
0.9197749495506287,
-0.13259002566337585,
0.11536882817745209,
-0.30792665481567383,
-0.15372391045093536,
-0.13939444720745087,
0.028934353962540627,
-0.5468689799308777,
0.1756693422794342,
0.04374687373638153,
0.5182104706764221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00840v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00840v1
|
EyeGPT: Ophthalmic Assistant with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-29T09:35:41 | 2024-02-29T09:35:41 |
Xiaolan Chen, Ziwei Zhao, Weiyi Zhang, Pusheng Xu, Le Gao, Mingpu Xu, Yue Wu, Yinwen Li, Danli Shi, Mingguang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Artificial intelligence (AI) has gained significant attention in healthcare
consultation due to its potential to improve clinical workflow and enhance
medical communication. However, owing to the complex nature of medical
information, large language models (LLM) trained with general world knowledge
might not possess the capability to tackle medical-related tasks at an expert
level. Here, we introduce EyeGPT, a specialized LLM designed specifically for
ophthalmology, using three optimization strategies including role-playing,
finetuning, and retrieval-augmented generation. In particular, we proposed a
comprehensive evaluation framework that encompasses a diverse dataset, covering
various subspecialties of ophthalmology, different users, and diverse inquiry
intents. Moreover, we considered multiple evaluation metrics, including
accuracy, understandability, trustworthiness, empathy, and the proportion of
hallucinations. By assessing the performance of different EyeGPT variants, we
identify the most effective one, which exhibits comparable levels of
understandability, trustworthiness, and empathy to human ophthalmologists (all
Ps>0.05). Overall, ur study provides valuable insights for future research,
facilitating comprehensive comparisons and evaluations of different strategies
for developing specialized LLMs in ophthalmology. The potential benefits
include enhancing the patient experience in eye care and optimizing
ophthalmologists' services.
|
[
-0.40582096576690674,
-1.066408634185791,
0.8085903525352478,
0.031780946999788284,
-0.34096914529800415,
-0.07334711402654648,
-0.4815397262573242,
-0.6402687430381775,
0.2797950804233551,
0.31725430488586426,
-0.25176769495010376,
-0.33202826976776123,
-0.39774638414382935,
0.1544729769229889,
-0.0854497179389,
0.6518685221672058,
-0.23112423717975616,
0.5309399366378784,
0.050301264971494675,
-0.027022697031497955,
-0.29272621870040894,
-0.2149684727191925,
-0.9433035254478455,
-0.26814067363739014,
0.5627720952033997,
0.3053254187107086,
0.6978957653045654,
0.48443228006362915,
0.9796189069747925,
0.32036328315734863,
0.15089908242225647,
0.2474806308746338,
-0.26988425850868225,
-0.22015245258808136,
-0.1459071934223175,
-0.13015247881412506,
-0.7304070591926575,
-0.16568098962306976,
0.14834126830101013,
0.7626175284385681,
-0.46823495626449585,
0.05037254840135574,
-0.13756373524665833,
0.47966378927230835,
-0.41696423292160034,
0.23531049489974976,
-0.3094542622566223,
0.44416630268096924,
0.17237477004528046,
-0.2342812716960907,
-0.16920121014118195,
-0.0999121367931366,
0.6494088768959045,
-0.6939836144447327,
-0.2152060717344284,
0.3035518527030945,
0.4287971258163452,
0.4009312391281128,
-0.04637332260608673,
-0.00726972334086895,
-0.4506498873233795,
0.3991627097129822,
-0.7178748250007629,
0.1819782555103302,
0.14592236280441284,
0.4725240170955658,
0.3286747336387634,
-0.5580346584320068,
-0.5103158354759216,
-0.6589953303337097,
0.028300561010837555,
0.3851573169231415,
-0.027876220643520355,
0.18920989334583282,
0.114417165517807,
0.251817524433136,
-0.931888997554779,
0.3246099054813385,
-0.21809646487236023,
0.2049740105867386,
0.682555615901947,
0.2558678388595581,
0.4532891511917114,
0.11549828946590424,
-0.23569434881210327,
-0.13921567797660828,
-0.2698928713798523,
-0.26826563477516174,
0.19671161472797394,
-0.20063132047653198,
0.020406903699040413,
0.6658647656440735,
-0.382942795753479,
0.7667748928070068,
0.2539006769657135,
-0.1579127311706543,
0.2107318490743637,
-0.030386457219719887,
-0.2409772276878357,
-0.05099146068096161,
0.8748929500579834,
0.392840176820755,
0.6101551055908203,
-0.3730408847332001,
-0.1967538744211197,
0.08088144659996033,
0.583753228187561,
-0.5511073470115662,
-0.2772068977355957,
0.10476576536893845,
-0.5013598203659058,
-0.5059968829154968,
-0.03514482080936432,
-0.864630937576294,
-0.2856971025466919,
-0.4237768352031708,
0.5789198279380798,
-0.4997006058692932,
-0.257622629404068,
0.62992262840271,
0.3094087541103363,
0.1263430267572403,
0.4544641673564911,
-0.8767471313476562,
0.14589843153953552,
0.5342725515365601,
0.5984130501747131,
-0.5389924645423889,
-0.5835258960723877,
-0.4586157202720642,
-0.05388005077838898,
-0.4600292444229126,
0.5259739756584167,
-0.7422546744346619,
-0.11904630064964294,
-0.08776790648698807,
-0.2716122269630432,
-0.1464652717113495,
-0.5050250887870789,
0.17141582071781158,
-0.38482901453971863,
-0.08690124750137329,
0.3087468147277832,
-0.20257353782653809,
-0.1694020926952362,
0.27748045325279236,
-0.40502870082855225,
0.43338295817375183,
0.29578059911727905,
-0.34265363216400146,
0.3736635446548462,
-0.9730953574180603,
-0.4118095636367798,
0.6104093194007874,
-0.25309351086616516,
-0.34487593173980713,
0.15860766172409058,
0.5893475413322449,
0.5104875564575195,
-0.2616943120956421,
0.30710506439208984,
-0.15108926594257355,
-0.24397879838943481,
0.18871420621871948,
-0.18193916976451874,
0.3280166983604431,
-0.23467431962490082,
-0.6358331441879272,
0.3755623996257782,
-0.5819613933563232,
0.14743368327617645,
0.14700275659561157,
-0.2971304953098297,
-0.023042308166623116,
-0.0007953047752380371,
0.3540670573711395,
-0.2757650315761566,
0.31252747774124146,
-0.4806004762649536,
0.43548890948295593,
-0.531975507736206,
0.6684269309043884,
0.6822493076324463,
0.10088112950325012,
0.20257920026779175,
0.029112156480550766,
0.600114107131958,
-0.14818525314331055,
0.7632713913917542,
0.044762060046195984,
-0.42024314403533936,
-0.8430047035217285,
-0.055642444640398026,
0.005507737398147583,
0.9129688739776611,
-1.0557339191436768,
0.28850358724594116,
-0.19965142011642456,
-0.4941813051700592,
-0.5573351383209229,
-0.01569119095802307,
0.52884441614151,
0.5381008982658386,
0.33946582674980164,
-0.44329965114593506,
-0.080341637134552,
-1.1585880517959595,
-0.20452886819839478,
-0.10664354264736176,
0.1745891273021698,
0.5442944169044495,
0.3527250587940216,
-0.6495669484138489,
0.6403868794441223,
-0.711515486240387,
-0.5278984308242798,
-0.39054539799690247,
0.02542095072567463,
0.1443270891904831,
0.27021175622940063,
0.47298792004585266,
-0.9713265895843506,
-0.5963101983070374,
0.48826858401298523,
-0.9654667973518372,
-0.18104733526706696,
0.006695291958749294,
0.060468629002571106,
0.27280616760253906,
0.43785038590431213,
-0.6080683469772339,
0.57242751121521,
0.45916876196861267,
-0.1505749225616455,
0.46561214327812195,
-0.29922807216644287,
0.3003019094467163,
-0.7395694851875305,
0.2984717786312103,
0.004902973771095276,
-0.2673356831073761,
-0.4291064739227295,
0.3340494632720947,
-0.17330385744571686,
-0.2652710974216461,
-0.19483397901058197,
0.5011513233184814,
-0.2992169260978699,
-0.034017547965049744,
0.08249214291572571,
0.15546968579292297,
-0.5090696215629578,
0.5923383235931396,
0.20737360417842865,
0.838686466217041,
0.7491071224212646,
-0.15248849987983704,
0.808793306350708,
0.29321789741516113,
-0.4006847143173218,
0.605973482131958,
-0.8347659111022949,
0.21793994307518005,
0.24463973939418793,
-0.2520172595977783,
-0.4035404622554779,
-0.5174685120582581,
0.40390530228614807,
-0.32078805565834045,
0.32140037417411804,
0.21948125958442688,
-0.46546342968940735,
-0.4273792803287506,
0.05043487623333931,
0.5509494543075562,
0.6335201859474182,
-0.3530351221561432,
0.6632773280143738,
0.3584689199924469,
-0.5586382746696472,
-0.3658355474472046,
-0.4483689069747925,
0.3606914281845093,
-0.1445440798997879,
-0.6054021120071411,
-0.06458523124456406,
-0.18963903188705444,
-0.3211382031440735,
-0.02556123398244381,
0.1930139660835266,
-0.1221371740102768,
-0.32224270701408386,
-0.061996832489967346,
0.16855503618717194,
-0.436170756816864,
0.06790140271186829,
-0.47933605313301086,
-0.25533878803253174,
-0.11828573793172836,
-0.16391107439994812,
0.45077309012413025,
-0.4432356655597687,
-0.7669601440429688,
-0.3907408118247986,
0.4827939569950104,
0.47116681933403015,
-0.46726739406585693,
0.13488031923770905,
0.8800297975540161,
-0.006573623511940241,
-0.21628576517105103,
-0.7469265460968018,
-0.41274940967559814,
-0.4732295274734497,
0.8033514022827148,
-0.10162655264139175,
-0.7886924743652344,
0.1813027262687683,
0.18079903721809387,
-0.07448044419288635,
-0.015066881664097309,
0.5472071766853333,
0.3798614740371704,
0.988703191280365,
0.49897581338882446,
0.03525935485959053,
0.34156858921051025,
0.022760681807994843,
0.6102030277252197,
-0.8478845357894897,
-0.2899322211742401,
0.29938486218452454,
-0.09849642962217331,
-0.19920888543128967,
-0.36737826466560364,
0.9059877395629883,
-0.22208434343338013,
-0.038621366024017334,
0.11851043254137039,
-0.6885953545570374,
0.24623054265975952,
0.5499022603034973,
0.5385575890541077,
0.22428186237812042,
0.010429952293634415,
0.20612722635269165,
0.1985667645931244,
-0.8116326928138733,
-0.26869165897369385,
1.143180012702942,
0.2186630517244339,
0.8903403878211975,
-0.03984389081597328,
0.45267024636268616,
0.04203545302152634,
0.21926599740982056,
-0.9947993159294128,
0.726131021976471,
-0.24079754948616028,
0.05665115639567375,
-0.5784369111061096,
-0.32912084460258484,
-0.6415069103240967,
0.0836849957704544,
-0.19961708784103394,
-0.7804229855537415,
-0.12116429209709167,
0.3159797191619873,
-0.431618332862854,
0.11043509095907211,
-0.8803192973136902,
0.9683918356895447,
-0.4545978903770447,
-0.507299542427063,
-0.2371242344379425,
-0.5811071991920471,
-0.030287226662039757,
-0.3197632431983948,
-0.15185633301734924,
0.4857316017150879,
-0.3012743592262268,
0.3658040463924408,
0.01626029796898365,
0.751878023147583,
0.18513895571231842,
0.13212817907333374,
-0.10734600573778152,
-0.03798791766166687,
0.27812060713768005,
0.16276106238365173,
0.258503794670105,
0.20540408790111542,
-0.27757927775382996,
-0.12035992741584778,
-0.44386613368988037,
0.4934913218021393,
-0.5053431391716003,
-0.8363092541694641,
-0.2645511031150818,
-0.5686816573143005,
-0.509479284286499,
0.29966530203819275,
0.06342457979917526,
0.4300282895565033,
-0.2522957921028137,
0.22037577629089355,
0.6241437792778015,
-0.40063750743865967,
0.22356265783309937,
0.6689406633377075,
-0.26205477118492126,
-0.33153340220451355,
0.8065826892852783,
-0.1295512467622757,
0.1141432523727417,
0.39870399236679077,
0.2962142825126648,
0.1924344152212143,
-0.8234111666679382,
-0.7894933223724365,
0.1182572990655899,
-0.6962080597877502,
-0.029159311205148697,
-0.6287475228309631,
-0.1960541307926178,
-0.40883880853652954,
-0.2576668858528137,
-0.10313448309898376,
0.2870420217514038,
-0.14187659323215485,
0.012236388400197029,
0.41179096698760986,
0.6858184933662415,
0.08476481586694717,
0.2327808290719986,
-0.6365198493003845,
0.4768062233924866,
0.5713438391685486,
0.5236272811889648,
-0.08868569880723953,
0.12199337035417557,
-0.1706174612045288,
-0.306394100189209,
-0.023619338870048523,
-0.7765558958053589,
0.46466535329818726,
0.24234384298324585,
0.6803891658782959,
0.5947673320770264,
-0.253597229719162,
0.5849602818489075,
-0.8977752327919006,
0.782999575138092,
0.3511147201061249,
-0.9050869345664978,
0.3632357716560364,
-0.39382174611091614,
0.1614752858877182,
0.418239951133728,
-0.015484594739973545,
-0.22849106788635254,
-0.19228416681289673,
-0.35474658012390137,
-1.0312132835388184,
0.595156192779541,
-0.0685729905962944,
-0.072842538356781,
0.12091848254203796,
0.2838088572025299,
-0.026265205815434456,
0.3028324544429779,
-0.6362613439559937,
0.13988743722438812,
-0.054437655955553055,
-0.32742658257484436,
-0.3229929804801941,
-0.08122685551643372,
-0.22140958905220032,
-0.007113694213330746,
0.28747475147247314,
-0.4601040482521057,
0.09359143674373627,
0.5527167320251465,
0.04499001428484917,
-0.08636920899152756,
0.09978687018156052,
0.5946531891822815,
0.9357407689094543,
0.028328077867627144,
-0.22788739204406738,
0.2678755521774292,
-0.8244081735610962,
-0.46488386392593384,
0.06799963116645813,
0.10275779664516449,
-0.18791517615318298,
0.5773957967758179,
0.7907432913780212,
0.17810800671577454,
-1.0562301874160767,
0.6064532995223999,
0.2160148024559021,
-0.09580208361148834,
-0.4372340440750122,
0.3013592064380646,
-0.16509999334812164,
0.4111914038658142,
0.36909711360931396,
0.13656610250473022,
0.520570695400238,
-0.41137415170669556,
0.18117259442806244,
0.32562968134880066,
-0.41836923360824585,
0.007323185447603464,
0.4726228713989258,
0.23636086285114288,
-0.42003333568573,
0.2715965211391449,
0.24326521158218384,
-0.646321713924408,
0.6442807912826538,
0.09265843033790588,
0.8312053680419922,
-0.43968796730041504,
0.2221609503030777,
0.03895902633666992,
0.41137129068374634,
-0.14621029794216156,
0.16557517647743225,
0.24791200459003448,
-0.39201289415359497,
-0.3144558370113373,
-0.5587913990020752,
-0.5326657891273499,
0.1789812445640564,
-0.6663010120391846,
0.07466507703065872,
-0.2839604616165161,
-0.0633888766169548,
0.11520327627658844,
-0.2550794780254364,
-0.6438971757888794,
0.29748886823654175,
-0.27551186084747314,
0.920238733291626,
-0.32642385363578796,
0.4796583950519562,
0.9058184027671814,
-0.48886817693710327,
-0.7292967438697815,
0.08890555799007416,
-0.2508257031440735,
-1.3893768787384033,
0.6863588690757751,
-0.0011539128609001637,
-0.1781819462776184,
-0.019461702555418015,
-0.3717629611492157,
-0.27359288930892944,
0.9297001957893372,
0.20631301403045654,
-0.8015895485877991,
-0.1510516256093979,
0.13163217902183533,
0.8025246262550354,
-0.5644565224647522,
0.2155299037694931,
0.38143888115882874,
0.5553405284881592,
-0.2540498971939087,
-1.3744184970855713,
0.0040976968593895435,
-0.29211318492889404,
0.022249922156333923,
0.03302455693483353,
-0.5617998838424683,
0.8791880011558533,
-0.2408042550086975,
0.16159924864768982,
0.22961746156215668,
-0.18503360450267792,
-0.24995310604572296,
0.25572672486305237,
0.49868011474609375,
0.5353161692619324,
0.035262346267700195,
0.13291221857070923,
1.1538933515548706,
-0.3583749234676361,
0.16827598214149475,
0.5919118523597717,
-0.3599955141544342,
0.8637274503707886,
0.6760879755020142,
0.07929614186286926,
-0.10086027532815933,
0.5037345290184021,
-0.1892319917678833,
0.365997314453125,
0.11691566556692123,
-0.20088018476963043,
-0.4137910306453705,
0.19761613011360168,
-0.46830829977989197,
0.5261796712875366,
0.05417736619710922,
-0.403462678194046,
0.1636037975549698,
0.19197794795036316,
-0.36375653743743896,
-0.023025931790471077,
-0.5212059020996094,
1.2273733615875244,
0.15934598445892334,
-0.8918726444244385,
0.38947534561157227,
-0.33222028613090515,
0.41782405972480774,
-0.7137301564216614,
-0.1712159365415573,
-0.047769442200660706,
0.4575031101703644,
-0.18226593732833862,
-0.755720853805542,
-0.019522812217473984,
-0.19678384065628052,
0.010057872161269188,
0.009461089968681335,
0.3021901845932007,
-0.40213891863822937,
-0.5301814079284668,
0.36279839277267456,
0.424618661403656,
0.20897063612937927,
-0.12137472629547119,
-0.5661805272102356,
0.013457145541906357,
-0.05986011028289795,
-0.4314972162246704,
0.15370915830135345,
0.40893232822418213,
0.04600665345788002,
0.8626185059547424,
0.6925522089004517,
0.5283935070037842,
-0.3067288100719452,
0.11328516900539398,
0.8475931882858276,
-0.2657722234725952,
-0.4560006558895111,
-0.7954146862030029,
0.24061955511569977,
-0.23079252243041992,
-0.4168156385421753,
0.4496832489967346,
0.3109781742095947,
0.5968421101570129,
-0.4719506502151489,
0.7540096044540405,
0.2825925350189209,
0.41174042224884033,
-0.7527573108673096,
0.6883836388587952,
-0.7802625298500061,
0.02493203990161419,
-0.4768645465373993,
-0.9100670218467712,
-0.48819923400878906,
1.17854642868042,
-0.4426818788051605,
0.24653032422065735,
0.6345831155776978,
0.5205466151237488,
-0.212734192609787,
-0.17554427683353424,
0.7675936222076416,
0.2699657082557678,
0.07429799437522888,
0.893640398979187,
0.655327558517456,
0.0162248183041811,
0.3480064868927002,
0.027054378762841225,
-0.5639016628265381,
-0.7099148631095886,
-0.5339877009391785,
-1.0134246349334717,
-0.3260015845298767,
-0.21809951961040497,
0.24300724267959595,
0.22354963421821594,
0.7754395604133606,
1.0472848415374756,
-0.32721078395843506,
0.04430276155471802,
-0.08173975348472595,
-0.6013856530189514,
-0.10888823866844177,
-0.16680701076984406,
0.4977613687515259,
-0.2122538685798645,
-0.7352824211120605,
0.19623315334320068,
0.6985775828361511,
-0.0919504165649414,
-0.6849195957183838,
0.003973578568547964,
0.3721189498901367,
-0.07197695225477219,
0.7119266986846924,
0.043698716908693314,
-0.9799458980560303,
-0.3469376266002655,
0.3650742769241333,
0.028110338374972343,
0.03595958650112152,
0.5685200095176697,
-0.569725513458252,
0.6264006495475769,
0.10468852519989014,
0.7069709300994873,
0.11809936910867691,
-0.05668972432613373,
0.6784763336181641,
0.021266775205731392,
0.21407513320446014,
0.5605148077011108,
0.4083572328090668,
0.3044675588607788,
-0.6755693554878235,
0.7610634565353394,
-0.056256003677845,
-0.6389092206954956,
-0.6525697708129883,
0.4156619906425476,
-1.2757039070129395,
-0.21614469587802887,
1.2660937309265137,
-0.3650170564651489,
-0.1179300844669342,
-0.02217046730220318,
-0.7173716425895691,
-0.12608762085437775,
-0.39247703552246094,
0.9698832631111145,
0.41918227076530457,
-0.4118669629096985,
-0.49346256256103516,
-0.8139219284057617,
0.4092855453491211,
0.507968544960022,
-1.0433717966079712,
-0.2954655885696411,
0.4155661463737488,
0.20966380834579468,
0.26385247707366943,
0.4444487392902374,
-0.11297968029975891,
0.4310778081417084,
-0.1393168866634369,
-0.040778689086437225,
-0.37458255887031555,
-0.2121829390525818,
-0.02359194867312908,
0.1503157615661621,
-0.094482421875,
-0.02763880416750908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18950v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18950v1
|
PopALM: Popularity-Aligned Language Models for Social Media Trendy Response Prediction
| 2024-02-29T08:28:04 | 2024-02-29T08:28:04 |
Erxin Yu, Jing Li, Chunpu Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media platforms are daily exhibiting millions of events. To
preliminarily predict the mainstream public reaction to these events, we study
trendy response prediction to automatically generate top-liked user replies to
social media events. While previous works focus on generating responses without
factoring in popularity, we propose Popularity-Aligned Language Models (PopALM)
to distinguish responses liked by a larger audience through reinforcement
learning. Recognizing the noisy labels from user "likes", we tailor-make
curriculum learning in proximal policy optimization (PPO) to help models
capture the essential samples for easy-to-hard training. In experiments, we
build a large-scale Weibo dataset for trendy response prediction, and its
results show that PopALM can help boost the performance of advanced language
models.
|
[
-0.41969916224479675,
-0.7992478013038635,
0.2611156702041626,
0.562251627445221,
-0.11802265048027039,
0.07483762502670288,
-0.4109882712364197,
-0.15911909937858582,
0.5797988176345825,
0.5564389824867249,
-0.6266684532165527,
-0.3251167833805084,
-0.5612490177154541,
-0.3552752137184143,
-0.45426544547080994,
1.0923691987991333,
0.289040207862854,
0.008777113631367683,
0.0017998919356614351,
0.3106159269809723,
-0.2505943179130554,
-0.5090557932853699,
-0.7482870221138,
-0.14234019815921783,
0.5799102783203125,
0.5333123803138733,
0.763533353805542,
0.36011603474617004,
0.412555456161499,
0.23055465519428253,
0.1511690765619278,
0.19557185471057892,
-0.765279233455658,
0.14260093867778778,
0.08623103052377701,
-0.18266421556472778,
-0.4785284996032715,
0.0965077355504036,
0.6041646599769592,
0.24485044181346893,
-0.11972217261791229,
-0.04921894147992134,
0.07457482069730759,
0.4687665104866028,
-0.3539661765098572,
0.14246560633182526,
-0.8301457762718201,
-0.1873779147863388,
0.22343648970127106,
-0.1381596326828003,
-0.3052281439304352,
-0.9048000574111938,
0.13309939205646515,
-0.577549397945404,
-0.06192640960216522,
0.16558942198753357,
0.6928596496582031,
-0.1186799481511116,
-0.24093097448349,
-0.3955340087413788,
-0.8076499700546265,
1.0315780639648438,
-0.3835391104221344,
0.20017197728157043,
0.3496072292327881,
0.32729947566986084,
-0.5086169242858887,
-0.2734973132610321,
-0.5492884516716003,
-0.22799788415431976,
0.2080262154340744,
0.26364079117774963,
0.0645134225487709,
-0.19752159714698792,
-0.15090426802635193,
0.11060895025730133,
-0.7373249530792236,
-0.04059886559844017,
-0.0979907438158989,
0.15511004626750946,
0.8968409299850464,
0.014661317691206932,
0.2589583396911621,
-0.161624014377594,
-0.4733732044696808,
0.05693887546658516,
-0.49831458926200867,
0.0008104438311420381,
0.5103749632835388,
0.32139527797698975,
0.2299383580684662,
0.18912872672080994,
-0.016658281907439232,
0.3776679039001465,
0.2860705852508545,
0.013641269877552986,
0.29778364300727844,
-0.07427018135786057,
0.08851657062768936,
0.03467494994401932,
0.8022433519363403,
0.4219546914100647,
0.6465964317321777,
-0.11782342195510864,
-0.14878083765506744,
-0.19687499105930328,
0.1346600353717804,
-0.8444138765335083,
-0.17338937520980835,
0.37960466742515564,
-0.2927386164665222,
-0.5718318819999695,
0.2407463788986206,
-0.5525393486022949,
-0.4191584587097168,
-0.1735682338476181,
0.24884048104286194,
-0.27584800124168396,
-0.628754198551178,
0.06286309659481049,
0.00870297010987997,
-0.01148178894072771,
0.37796422839164734,
-0.7967372536659241,
0.14055870473384857,
0.7188220620155334,
0.8321102261543274,
-0.31983691453933716,
-0.16738715767860413,
-0.7294706106185913,
0.06071079894900322,
-0.636853814125061,
0.7524028420448303,
-0.6331112384796143,
-0.33656564354896545,
0.22567994892597198,
0.05799916759133339,
-0.16357117891311646,
-0.5094089508056641,
0.044021088629961014,
-0.9275130033493042,
0.05175596475601196,
-0.17908678948879242,
-0.41214272379875183,
0.16211505234241486,
0.30602291226387024,
-0.5500434637069702,
0.765801191329956,
0.10046299546957016,
-0.5614321827888489,
0.3465592861175537,
-0.6655675768852234,
-0.3263680934906006,
0.18512007594108582,
0.22779802978038788,
-0.4537639617919922,
-0.18438662588596344,
0.11055594682693481,
0.5434417128562927,
-0.04038206860423088,
0.6167142391204834,
-0.6862793564796448,
-0.24488134682178497,
0.6503539681434631,
0.023686867207288742,
0.5004076361656189,
0.5440396070480347,
-0.008611622266471386,
0.6278330087661743,
-0.63043212890625,
-0.23155860602855682,
0.37700554728507996,
-0.4679443836212158,
-0.3621085286140442,
0.24498966336250305,
0.4466618299484253,
0.3567226529121399,
0.27551788091659546,
-0.5541616678237915,
0.33735162019729614,
-0.465890496969223,
0.42093947529792786,
0.9345361590385437,
0.16549336910247803,
0.3050847053527832,
-0.3836560547351837,
0.3359711468219757,
0.14525462687015533,
0.028320802375674248,
0.08335849642753601,
-0.4035279154777527,
-0.13639084994792938,
0.04328301548957825,
0.04554282873868942,
0.35358887910842896,
-0.503808856010437,
0.22555509209632874,
-0.062310535460710526,
-0.5579180717468262,
-0.2618114948272705,
0.43438827991485596,
0.08893957734107971,
0.24380573630332947,
0.1546190083026886,
-0.18101269006729126,
-0.8360636234283447,
-0.5139018893241882,
-0.48651888966560364,
-0.47380396723747253,
0.004221237264573574,
0.5033954977989197,
0.012557201087474823,
-0.23827984929084778,
0.811176598072052,
-0.6042687892913818,
-0.09377209842205048,
-0.5655605792999268,
0.3284682333469391,
0.10197987407445908,
0.10971219837665558,
0.45290836691856384,
-1.0879443883895874,
-0.6802598237991333,
-0.1834915578365326,
-0.21378366649150848,
-0.2637827694416046,
0.06941257417201996,
0.004671974573284388,
0.19067662954330444,
0.3986322581768036,
-0.14197997748851776,
-0.06315457075834274,
0.5251215100288391,
0.01779034174978733,
0.4226817190647125,
0.3406431972980499,
0.200010746717453,
-1.4645185470581055,
-0.32018157839775085,
0.3753194510936737,
-0.2547839879989624,
-0.5692673325538635,
-0.3751808702945709,
-0.21914787590503693,
-0.250184565782547,
-0.56912761926651,
0.8008852005004883,
-0.05343122035264969,
-0.004126001615077257,
-0.5617429614067078,
0.08302508294582367,
-0.5599325299263,
0.20295603573322296,
0.48546138405799866,
0.6367030143737793,
0.547321617603302,
-0.7264776825904846,
0.3004278838634491,
0.06932100653648376,
-0.12952199578285217,
0.1411573588848114,
-0.6550263166427612,
0.0382072739303112,
-0.1441025584936142,
0.327858567237854,
-1.5268299579620361,
-0.7013810873031616,
0.024756943807005882,
-0.5032735466957092,
-0.04657956212759018,
-0.1754736453294754,
-0.33567944169044495,
-0.5899569988250732,
-0.4322769343852997,
0.09474088251590729,
0.6215310096740723,
-0.5942701101303101,
0.414237380027771,
0.5908628702163696,
-0.0783442035317421,
-0.4819795489311218,
-0.10666405409574509,
-0.2827894687652588,
-0.39513254165649414,
-0.2868770956993103,
-0.059709642082452774,
-0.30376148223876953,
-0.21020641922950745,
-0.26157113909721375,
0.24904568493366241,
0.06316591054201126,
0.22613726556301117,
0.4802165627479553,
0.1850333958864212,
-0.10125458985567093,
0.20053482055664062,
-0.4168400764465332,
-0.10865699499845505,
-0.03624018654227257,
-0.3740217685699463,
0.9641969203948975,
-0.4045149087905884,
-0.04059644788503647,
-0.3222842514514923,
-0.049652207642793655,
0.3585696816444397,
0.10488633066415787,
0.48858991265296936,
0.792365312576294,
-0.1889893114566803,
-0.07974658906459808,
-0.3532769978046417,
-0.3777218759059906,
-0.4695156514644623,
0.42704668641090393,
-0.03863275796175003,
-0.8531809449195862,
0.24300190806388855,
-0.10958794504404068,
0.16156256198883057,
0.16097265481948853,
0.6878366470336914,
-0.16383521258831024,
1.5605071783065796,
0.3565978705883026,
-0.14342208206653595,
0.9728520512580872,
0.0826902762055397,
0.2420092076063156,
-0.0662134513258934,
0.12065495550632477,
-0.22262704372406006,
-0.43881505727767944,
-0.7711660265922546,
-0.011478123255074024,
0.08740387111902237,
-0.09214425086975098,
-0.20487691462039948,
0.5573455691337585,
-0.17594961822032928,
0.26854443550109863,
0.6215617656707764,
-0.28784438967704773,
0.008200354874134064,
0.1541379690170288,
0.4213840365409851,
-0.08121711760759354,
-0.6286371350288391,
-0.40453457832336426,
1.0321097373962402,
0.30687662959098816,
1.0521503686904907,
-0.004189435858279467,
0.9340460896492004,
0.23548081517219543,
0.8139492273330688,
-0.8975426554679871,
0.6583654284477234,
-0.18240487575531006,
-0.3985711336135864,
-0.0928950309753418,
-0.38898059725761414,
-0.9813835620880127,
-0.2549484670162201,
-0.22453998029232025,
-0.7516937851905823,
-0.16555680334568024,
0.35950151085853577,
-0.2740711271762848,
0.13284821808338165,
-0.5360446572303772,
0.47556641697883606,
-0.1883593052625656,
-0.20249822735786438,
-0.09998040646314621,
-0.42142224311828613,
0.33094844222068787,
-0.000981164281256497,
0.25040796399116516,
-0.2868611216545105,
0.13339102268218994,
0.950958251953125,
-0.13163992762565613,
0.8501811027526855,
0.011277454905211926,
0.23776908218860626,
0.5125567317008972,
0.060519423335790634,
0.1256132870912552,
0.1336406022310257,
0.08546015620231628,
0.0032646360341459513,
0.010074370540678501,
-0.42499735951423645,
-0.2929975092411041,
1.1195802688598633,
-1.0465444326400757,
-0.5207265615463257,
-0.20047447085380554,
-0.803991436958313,
-0.3071112632751465,
0.01539356168359518,
0.0727008730173111,
0.022725341841578484,
-0.49375471472740173,
0.31558820605278015,
0.674758791923523,
0.11305669695138931,
0.578719973564148,
0.6412137746810913,
-0.7691192030906677,
-0.4249045252799988,
1.1635310649871826,
0.31557464599609375,
-0.01821085438132286,
0.2593512535095215,
0.4882064163684845,
-0.3050699532032013,
-0.34439900517463684,
-0.34853288531303406,
0.031205477192997932,
-0.18062402307987213,
0.056191638112068176,
-0.6951948404312134,
-0.2643013000488281,
-0.6494811177253723,
-0.2869685888290405,
-0.3499281406402588,
-0.18068228662014008,
-0.15145692229270935,
-0.003180619329214096,
0.2009681910276413,
0.838681697845459,
-0.13244137167930603,
0.5408018827438354,
-0.5926005244255066,
0.14395010471343994,
0.3010142147541046,
0.2054848074913025,
-0.013889973983168602,
-0.5034317374229431,
-0.17070668935775757,
-0.13800767064094543,
-0.5716487765312195,
-0.926166832447052,
0.5007981657981873,
0.20984774827957153,
0.28609246015548706,
0.8998168110847473,
0.09599113464355469,
0.34951043128967285,
-0.3537791073322296,
0.6052811741828918,
0.3779793381690979,
-0.4475492537021637,
0.9941663146018982,
-0.46930328011512756,
-0.03205627575516701,
0.18428125977516174,
0.9859970211982727,
-0.662153959274292,
-0.43786460161209106,
-0.7943490147590637,
-0.9400204420089722,
0.5111400485038757,
-0.2092846781015396,
0.6266008615493774,
-0.6310217380523682,
0.06057141348719597,
0.15658967196941376,
0.40040165185928345,
-0.7022559642791748,
0.004086187109351158,
-0.15230616927146912,
-0.23527149856090546,
-0.07501601427793503,
-0.22061693668365479,
-0.04159175232052803,
0.11844219267368317,
0.9638586640357971,
-0.2057042270898819,
-0.08068247139453888,
-0.4360269606113434,
0.15673264861106873,
-0.5303063988685608,
0.2646530866622925,
0.20942740142345428,
0.682260274887085,
-0.6298839449882507,
-0.040739767253398895,
-0.37637418508529663,
-0.4628392457962036,
0.12585331499576569,
0.12246919423341751,
-0.25604066252708435,
-0.1312253475189209,
-0.21655558049678802,
0.46935245394706726,
0.24613630771636963,
-0.7663004994392395,
0.5734103918075562,
-0.08166849613189697,
-0.16852574050426483,
-0.4034692049026489,
0.4128626585006714,
0.3235273063182831,
0.062470510601997375,
0.7116473913192749,
-0.2079508751630783,
-0.1488112062215805,
-0.7055875658988953,
0.5014116168022156,
0.5975581407546997,
-0.7242180109024048,
-0.49831151962280273,
0.7418571710586548,
0.0933779627084732,
-0.565920352935791,
0.0342089906334877,
-0.08444280922412872,
-0.4072490334510803,
0.5681168437004089,
0.8641070127487183,
0.6486895084381104,
-0.540000855922699,
0.5475435256958008,
0.567340075969696,
-0.15122507512569427,
-0.24256008863449097,
0.41567665338516235,
0.30749017000198364,
-0.9562016129493713,
-0.08414818346500397,
-0.6981550455093384,
-0.33130884170532227,
0.6771753430366516,
-0.5645420551300049,
0.3718916177749634,
-0.7965151071548462,
-0.3387758433818817,
0.12801741063594818,
0.10336454212665558,
-0.4128101170063019,
0.24533362686634064,
0.10815449804067612,
0.5079846382141113,
-1.192221999168396,
0.6438016295433044,
1.0009548664093018,
-0.5834291577339172,
-0.7693470120429993,
0.37860772013664246,
0.14983591437339783,
-0.9134794473648071,
0.6505374908447266,
0.22376328706741333,
0.05038517341017723,
0.1960793435573578,
-1.0586817264556885,
-0.7829903364181519,
0.533841609954834,
0.10366029292345047,
-0.5065879821777344,
0.3410448133945465,
-0.19445253908634186,
0.4133169651031494,
-0.7236304879188538,
0.25626564025878906,
0.2766213119029999,
0.13460767269134521,
0.38172629475593567,
-0.4831138551235199,
-0.22004225850105286,
-0.0542835034430027,
0.1917063593864441,
0.12710808217525482,
-0.7132809162139893,
0.5084250569343567,
-0.25609898567199707,
-0.005203604232519865,
-0.1369318813085556,
0.9522040486335754,
0.5579738616943359,
0.7349253296852112,
0.5323851704597473,
0.13465020060539246,
0.41716641187667847,
-0.1413581371307373,
0.8369374871253967,
-0.49125468730926514,
0.19806087017059326,
0.9105949401855469,
-0.23283255100250244,
1.0538901090621948,
0.4250692129135132,
-0.05955678969621658,
0.5436410307884216,
0.9372514486312866,
0.24109332263469696,
0.5266175270080566,
0.17127716541290283,
-0.034173887223005295,
-0.47183603048324585,
-0.30382660031318665,
-0.3701331317424774,
0.17782041430473328,
0.3275913596153259,
-0.31971973180770874,
-0.14081592857837677,
0.028733396902680397,
0.14855797588825226,
0.2472938746213913,
-0.6043661236763,
0.8655862808227539,
0.036618996411561966,
-0.8142610788345337,
0.4125998020172119,
-0.03605278953909874,
0.6674107313156128,
-0.5709444284439087,
0.13530607521533966,
-0.2440304011106491,
0.1282750815153122,
-0.18316569924354553,
-0.8902056217193604,
0.1535661518573761,
-0.2680951654911041,
-0.3221298158168793,
-0.031245049089193344,
0.9374498128890991,
-0.6491383910179138,
-0.30938583612442017,
0.3361985683441162,
0.3751985728740692,
0.21158677339553833,
-0.021363914012908936,
-0.9327906370162964,
-0.2649025321006775,
-0.0043755583465099335,
-0.5784787535667419,
0.6778780817985535,
-0.048096608370542526,
-0.37376657128334045,
0.7469439506530762,
0.7196105122566223,
0.11942286044359207,
-0.14618661999702454,
0.15681646764278412,
0.7199622392654419,
-0.07670924812555313,
-0.6826866865158081,
-0.5368273258209229,
0.03948577120900154,
-0.18363060057163239,
-0.12501002848148346,
0.6484746336936951,
0.41924238204956055,
0.7657879590988159,
-0.21604695916175842,
0.9895898699760437,
0.011013024486601353,
0.5344512462615967,
-0.06266681849956512,
0.48342740535736084,
-0.552385687828064,
0.18260669708251953,
-0.21885095536708832,
-1.0386297702789307,
-0.008737265132367611,
0.3555203974246979,
-1.0838487148284912,
0.18348228931427002,
0.10212693363428116,
0.8852007389068604,
-0.1786750704050064,
-0.0278262197971344,
0.2488744556903839,
0.14371336996555328,
0.18143583834171295,
0.5441523790359497,
0.8730489611625671,
0.00934452936053276,
0.7995584607124329,
0.08921703696250916,
-0.23760825395584106,
-0.7708641886711121,
-0.8396823406219482,
-0.8524665832519531,
-0.7403562068939209,
-0.4035303294658661,
-0.7837713360786438,
0.16609853506088257,
1.3028045892715454,
0.7736799120903015,
-1.201115369796753,
-0.3323378562927246,
-0.0739910826086998,
0.2587794065475464,
-0.34220123291015625,
-0.36406826972961426,
0.27844321727752686,
-0.3788444399833679,
-0.780951976776123,
0.16911837458610535,
0.0766817033290863,
0.001707427203655243,
-0.15664052963256836,
-0.36361271142959595,
-0.2339814454317093,
0.5413744449615479,
0.3117239475250244,
0.4376259446144104,
-0.5861662030220032,
-0.1444907933473587,
0.19188444316387177,
-0.2534971237182617,
0.10357194393873215,
0.805010974407196,
-0.31505152583122253,
0.26788368821144104,
0.6122539043426514,
0.5631606578826904,
0.30653685331344604,
0.5516148209571838,
0.4210382103919983,
-0.7495278120040894,
-0.14139889180660248,
0.22882795333862305,
0.08108788728713989,
0.3800375461578369,
-0.3181564509868622,
0.190439835190773,
0.3828490078449249,
-0.5463036298751831,
-0.6536585688591003,
0.39812302589416504,
-0.7585812211036682,
-0.34112000465393066,
1.497310996055603,
0.0071946666575968266,
-0.3394418954849243,
-0.15225514769554138,
-0.16102968156337738,
0.03804389387369156,
-0.6891660690307617,
0.9448338747024536,
0.7127661108970642,
-0.09421846270561218,
-0.19999171793460846,
-0.5463722944259644,
0.6535158157348633,
0.1595097929239273,
-0.43973857164382935,
-0.005595492664724588,
0.3275471329689026,
0.6376767158508301,
0.22881366312503815,
0.9009301066398621,
0.19299474358558655,
0.3982684016227722,
-0.44817349314689636,
0.04688842594623566,
-0.01193668507039547,
-0.443164587020874,
0.14720894396305084,
0.41173169016838074,
0.18637214601039886,
-0.08466749638319016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18945v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18945v2
|
SynGhost: Imperceptible and Universal Task-agnostic Backdoor Attack in Pre-trained Language Models
| 2024-02-29T08:20:49 | 2024-05-24T15:21:55 |
Pengzhou Cheng, Wei Du, Zongru Wu, Fengwei Zhang, Libo Chen, Gongshen Liu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Pre-training has been a necessary phase for deploying pre-trained language
models (PLMs) to achieve remarkable performance in downstream tasks. However,
we empirically show that backdoor attacks exploit such a phase as a vulnerable
entry point for task-agnostic. In this paper, we first propose
$\mathtt{maxEntropy}$, an entropy-based poisoning filtering defense, to prove
that existing task-agnostic backdoors are easily exposed, due to explicit
triggers used. Then, we present $\mathtt{SynGhost}$, an imperceptible and
universal task-agnostic backdoor attack in PLMs. Specifically,
$\mathtt{SynGhost}$ hostilely manipulates clean samples through different
syntactic and then maps the backdoor to representation space without disturbing
the primitive representation. $\mathtt{SynGhost}$ further leverages contrastive
learning to achieve universal, which performs a uniform distribution of
backdoors in the representation space. In light of the syntactic properties, we
also introduce an awareness module to alleviate the interference between
different syntactic. Experiments show that $\mathtt{SynGhost}$ holds more
serious threats. Not only do severe harmfulness to various downstream tasks on
two tuning paradigms but also to any PLMs. Meanwhile, $\mathtt{SynGhost}$ is
imperceptible against three countermeasures based on perplexity, fine-pruning,
and the proposed $\mathtt{maxEntropy}$.
|
[
0.052879758179187775,
-0.6933338046073914,
0.5179181694984436,
0.052711449563503265,
-0.0582919679582119,
-0.09193448722362518,
-0.12798725068569183,
-0.5070174932479858,
0.04296611621975899,
0.6657795310020447,
-0.6161394715309143,
-0.5263826251029968,
-0.5346675515174866,
-0.05071535333991051,
-0.5093685388565063,
1.011197566986084,
0.08955366909503937,
-0.26067042350769043,
0.030639449134469032,
-0.09206730127334595,
-0.5756137371063232,
-0.8967136740684509,
-0.2572551965713501,
-0.19272038340568542,
0.41478562355041504,
0.14690014719963074,
0.6786146759986877,
0.34153881669044495,
0.40561696887016296,
0.37238386273384094,
0.3788423240184784,
-0.46241918206214905,
-0.3218419849872589,
0.6407461166381836,
-0.3102060854434967,
-0.7033658623695374,
-0.24985149502754211,
0.09662564843893051,
0.5183199048042297,
0.21277880668640137,
-0.36579006910324097,
0.33170080184936523,
0.06430572271347046,
0.26363155245780945,
-0.7629740834236145,
-0.12023668736219406,
-1.3303855657577515,
0.1724848598241806,
-0.5032352805137634,
-0.2237568199634552,
-0.3737028241157532,
0.08221963047981262,
-0.17967870831489563,
-0.5756105780601501,
-0.014642754569649696,
0.07037689536809921,
0.6673071384429932,
0.41370731592178345,
0.07998792082071304,
-0.08016431331634521,
-0.44990453124046326,
0.5944008231163025,
-0.6085200905799866,
0.39752963185310364,
0.10133107751607895,
0.3705090284347534,
-0.2755657434463501,
-0.675431489944458,
-0.8386728167533875,
-0.37319326400756836,
-0.02181342989206314,
0.15579737722873688,
-0.42545148730278015,
0.30115875601768494,
0.29480820894241333,
0.4652561843395233,
-0.861774206161499,
0.19294606149196625,
0.10495664179325104,
-0.5270845890045166,
0.17385448515415192,
0.15356619656085968,
0.6341409683227539,
0.09994479268789291,
-0.6639577746391296,
-0.2591191232204437,
-0.7182371020317078,
-0.09653785824775696,
0.6033661961555481,
0.2380773276090622,
0.033434536308050156,
0.1784926950931549,
-0.017304101958870888,
0.7464603185653687,
-0.02528638206422329,
0.2016391009092331,
0.04051421955227852,
-0.30981123447418213,
-0.3932509422302246,
-0.17090965807437897,
0.5377637147903442,
-0.02996065467596054,
0.21577349305152893,
-0.2981070280075073,
-0.25297054648399353,
0.4006015956401825,
0.4576658010482788,
-0.6152327656745911,
-0.20094731450080872,
0.13181445002555847,
-0.16442283987998962,
-0.46524056792259216,
-0.03033255971968174,
-0.6005603671073914,
-0.3206841051578522,
0.28252026438713074,
0.7294371724128723,
-0.2599255442619324,
-0.29626893997192383,
0.005654648877680302,
0.04794377088546753,
0.33711615204811096,
0.1811438947916031,
-0.6425392627716064,
0.537861704826355,
0.7874128222465515,
0.7214676737785339,
-0.06796307116746902,
-0.765519380569458,
-0.6424845457077026,
0.20695990324020386,
-0.03566544130444527,
0.5761739611625671,
-0.5762621164321899,
-0.13493874669075012,
-0.16104166209697723,
-0.042158517986536026,
-0.2635546326637268,
-0.6552562713623047,
0.24404454231262207,
-0.7129971981048584,
0.37282195687294006,
0.099472276866436,
-0.21806077659130096,
-0.2176934778690338,
0.3621324896812439,
-0.4669909179210663,
0.6360662579536438,
0.07439663261175156,
-0.6568686962127686,
0.2046893686056137,
-0.43388745188713074,
-0.5913060903549194,
0.11869478225708008,
-0.02459157630801201,
-0.1675020307302475,
0.14809435606002808,
-0.2210477739572525,
0.2188292145729065,
0.018351735547184944,
0.16377176344394684,
-0.33276811242103577,
-0.2547152638435364,
0.03618447482585907,
-0.4306645393371582,
0.9925983548164368,
0.22199758887290955,
-0.47347021102905273,
0.36404576897621155,
-0.5766430497169495,
0.12048923224210739,
0.2079927772283554,
0.08888976275920868,
-0.5903488397598267,
-0.32397136092185974,
-0.3330436050891876,
0.6227543354034424,
0.2876392602920532,
-0.6729232668876648,
-0.1899636834859848,
-0.5262982845306396,
0.35631418228149414,
0.9373364448547363,
-0.066595159471035,
0.24742348492145538,
-0.2740875780582428,
0.6736921072006226,
0.030514582991600037,
0.2595353126525879,
-0.3670644164085388,
-0.4000738561153412,
-0.26062506437301636,
-0.13250599801540375,
0.014702938497066498,
0.9316012859344482,
-0.6675482392311096,
0.4606373906135559,
0.14215277135372162,
-0.39463186264038086,
-0.37356555461883545,
0.18441267311573029,
0.7269012928009033,
0.6204293966293335,
0.3183691203594208,
-0.42912358045578003,
-0.5124915242195129,
-0.6394386291503906,
-0.8311104774475098,
-0.28690916299819946,
0.06833962351083755,
-0.06939605623483658,
0.506600022315979,
-0.09633945673704147,
0.28105270862579346,
-0.37310725450515747,
-0.30362895131111145,
-0.022183900699019432,
-0.15433672070503235,
0.2525472939014435,
0.6678125858306885,
0.4254775047302246,
-0.5571511387825012,
-0.37300243973731995,
-0.2767922878265381,
-0.6482530236244202,
-0.30748701095581055,
-0.21014970541000366,
-0.17587138712406158,
0.11955263465642929,
0.4473351538181305,
-0.9732851982116699,
0.41086217761039734,
0.8212372660636902,
-0.32873252034187317,
0.9324900507926941,
-0.041233908385038376,
-0.3127793073654175,
-1.0637469291687012,
0.14116951823234558,
-0.39324283599853516,
-0.17614629864692688,
-0.8148372173309326,
0.7050867080688477,
-0.10961594432592392,
-0.3892688453197479,
-0.3118739128112793,
0.7203992605209351,
-0.38579443097114563,
0.021960675716400146,
-0.1317068636417389,
-0.22461190819740295,
-0.15428800880908966,
0.6207384467124939,
-0.21276788413524628,
0.6645609736442566,
0.7869899868965149,
-0.260070264339447,
0.4395175576210022,
0.16285814344882965,
-0.05149519816040993,
0.5033113360404968,
-0.5412279367446899,
0.19157415628433228,
0.26529139280319214,
0.3787792921066284,
-0.9818024635314941,
-0.1145482063293457,
0.6128903031349182,
-0.6315317153930664,
0.431730180978775,
0.019408803433179855,
-0.6519373655319214,
-0.2938077747821808,
-0.37474992871284485,
0.34467726945877075,
0.4470381438732147,
-0.4895177483558655,
0.18652787804603577,
0.2489393800497055,
-0.22262956202030182,
-0.7544628977775574,
-0.6360969543457031,
0.18210892379283905,
-0.1308857798576355,
-0.45844918489456177,
0.10425568372011185,
-0.15083955228328705,
-0.20786413550376892,
-0.22625035047531128,
-0.5406259894371033,
0.017913881689310074,
0.2829829752445221,
0.34321027994155884,
0.238160640001297,
-0.08530180901288986,
-0.13210517168045044,
-0.2561783790588379,
-0.12236973643302917,
0.3314506709575653,
-0.7692627906799316,
0.6035981178283691,
-0.07277439534664154,
-0.5641996264457703,
-0.3810940980911255,
0.43216073513031006,
0.6804873943328857,
-0.1224803701043129,
0.5209251046180725,
0.4255531430244446,
-0.38438424468040466,
-0.277344673871994,
-0.6140832304954529,
-0.3777792751789093,
-0.5375604629516602,
0.4311162829399109,
-0.4569259285926819,
-0.720594584941864,
0.7254059910774231,
0.2583714425563812,
-0.0036185523495078087,
0.27170196175575256,
0.3206801116466522,
0.006686312612146139,
0.8030531406402588,
0.6165347099304199,
-0.07152722030878067,
0.4868534207344055,
0.09947068244218826,
-0.04464263468980789,
-0.5224049091339111,
-0.016881950199604034,
-0.4615602195262909,
-0.1009211391210556,
-0.5235215425491333,
-0.08157721906900406,
0.3387462794780731,
-0.07341959327459335,
-0.24500420689582825,
0.46288612484931946,
-0.3602774143218994,
0.4063996374607086,
0.573725700378418,
0.09405995160341263,
0.24096553027629852,
0.1278526782989502,
-0.29424849152565,
0.03656638041138649,
-0.7518439888954163,
-0.17248480021953583,
0.9079756140708923,
0.21404442191123962,
0.8524883389472961,
-0.09952743351459503,
0.8406302332878113,
0.0999782457947731,
0.25503697991371155,
-0.38647642731666565,
0.7515882849693298,
-0.1814550757408142,
-0.8138146996498108,
-0.272973895072937,
-0.4087635278701782,
-0.7552552223205566,
0.4293472170829773,
0.008490036241710186,
-0.7422205209732056,
0.033706266433000565,
0.44314196705818176,
-0.290347695350647,
0.6801565289497375,
-0.8488054275512695,
1.1147397756576538,
-0.2347918301820755,
-0.26702171564102173,
-0.2821272909641266,
-1.0902612209320068,
0.4322737753391266,
-0.21979758143424988,
0.07412867993116379,
0.056344326585531235,
0.17664839327335358,
0.5195404887199402,
-0.48802298307418823,
0.8679089546203613,
-0.3998727798461914,
-0.2458919882774353,
0.03613318130373955,
0.501062273979187,
0.6983484029769897,
-0.1569143384695053,
0.16051973402500153,
0.3796411156654358,
-0.13018827140331268,
-0.44758927822113037,
-0.5380439758300781,
0.6251721978187561,
-0.44592538475990295,
-1.2041449546813965,
-0.5918222665786743,
-0.6885229349136353,
-0.2089087963104248,
0.4211593270301819,
0.40208858251571655,
0.2905208170413971,
0.12912020087242126,
-0.21482835710048676,
0.5166200399398804,
-0.25922876596450806,
0.34153667092323303,
0.44199419021606445,
0.15251338481903076,
-0.12655256688594818,
1.0731616020202637,
-0.1766648143529892,
0.5759924054145813,
0.5044088363647461,
0.23515036702156067,
-0.16511812806129456,
-0.7262907028198242,
-0.10247956216335297,
0.061886247247457504,
-0.41465088725090027,
-0.3380851447582245,
-0.5604816675186157,
-0.31837841868400574,
-0.43184566497802734,
0.01594243198633194,
-0.04541881009936333,
-0.33136966824531555,
0.03315106779336929,
0.14504706859588623,
-0.0475713275372982,
0.28336694836616516,
-0.33516669273376465,
0.28822600841522217,
-0.7658898234367371,
0.37522730231285095,
0.6248394846916199,
0.3598977327346802,
0.08056797832250595,
-0.5817557573318481,
-0.06589677929878235,
-0.143692284822464,
-0.27715393900871277,
-0.968646228313446,
0.2513195872306824,
0.14255759119987488,
0.7615412473678589,
0.3590923547744751,
0.05561386048793793,
0.48915335536003113,
-0.6532291173934937,
0.5319422483444214,
0.3600625991821289,
-0.9700121879577637,
0.4560061991214752,
-0.3165673017501831,
0.4195164740085602,
0.5241290330886841,
0.14198273420333862,
-0.49675223231315613,
-0.8416186571121216,
-0.874925434589386,
-0.8193076848983765,
0.5153914093971252,
0.12896056473255157,
0.3060576617717743,
0.31621769070625305,
-0.0014485577121376991,
0.5205230712890625,
0.5942897200584412,
-0.8123506307601929,
-0.0571693517267704,
-0.4682876467704773,
-0.002948229666799307,
0.04057302325963974,
-0.07264891266822815,
-0.16794344782829285,
-0.145482137799263,
0.402648389339447,
0.19951581954956055,
0.20400185883045197,
0.035743843764066696,
-0.516739547252655,
-0.10857369750738144,
0.5292519927024841,
0.5249031186103821,
0.4393566846847534,
-0.08267746865749359,
0.4699588418006897,
0.1479966938495636,
-0.7710232138633728,
0.21291851997375488,
0.24000945687294006,
-0.12877823412418365,
-0.09371145814657211,
0.5928515791893005,
0.5765529274940491,
0.15031959116458893,
-0.5413161516189575,
0.5421091914176941,
0.3132905662059784,
0.08106984943151474,
-0.14440451562404633,
0.1927034705877304,
-0.48474636673927307,
0.20874203741550446,
0.3950249254703522,
0.35308021306991577,
-0.05978323146700859,
-0.9242668747901917,
0.4077424705028534,
0.6908973455429077,
-0.11732376366853714,
-0.7821206450462341,
0.7154850959777832,
0.0815838873386383,
-0.29832276701927185,
0.07130172103643417,
-0.12741221487522125,
-1.0072107315063477,
0.34791600704193115,
0.824570894241333,
1.021445870399475,
-0.7068174481391907,
0.04806690663099289,
-0.07795216888189316,
0.5706284046173096,
0.15013930201530457,
0.3314312994480133,
-0.4152263402938843,
-0.8275022506713867,
-0.22517023980617523,
-0.6554275751113892,
-0.35374534130096436,
0.2269892692565918,
-0.44025203585624695,
-0.28383907675743103,
-0.5915495157241821,
0.11413154751062393,
-0.20571433007717133,
-0.2475651353597641,
-0.3792913258075714,
0.1159491315484047,
0.17734591662883759,
0.8818186521530151,
-0.7595958709716797,
0.739256739616394,
0.7527266144752502,
-0.05034239590167999,
-0.5249254703521729,
0.542358934879303,
-0.03913618624210358,
-1.2383593320846558,
0.6771287322044373,
0.11913289874792099,
-0.29036372900009155,
0.128483846783638,
-0.6031284928321838,
-0.5654221177101135,
0.6144207715988159,
0.5365124344825745,
-0.35490965843200684,
-0.29892510175704956,
-0.11716707795858383,
0.44550618529319763,
-0.15209297835826874,
-0.2189769148826599,
0.2735603451728821,
0.5310993194580078,
-0.18275396525859833,
-0.8627985715866089,
0.5282794833183289,
-0.24020560085773468,
-0.31071051955223083,
0.16639277338981628,
-0.5353644490242004,
0.8836920261383057,
-0.24798139929771423,
-0.44570642709732056,
0.04268587753176689,
0.2365671843290329,
0.42386510968208313,
0.251535564661026,
0.7994716763496399,
0.7655665874481201,
0.4780265986919403,
0.024370312690734863,
0.8900266885757446,
-0.3862043619155884,
-0.092605359852314,
1.2746869325637817,
-0.5549361705780029,
0.6527525782585144,
0.5122817754745483,
-0.10883133113384247,
0.5543109178543091,
0.18812698125839233,
-0.018769579008221626,
0.6800631880760193,
0.34919360280036926,
-0.15459869801998138,
-0.22839972376823425,
0.08739661425352097,
-0.489557147026062,
0.39571359753608704,
0.39079293608665466,
0.07713460922241211,
-0.43761828541755676,
0.12242879718542099,
0.21954768896102905,
0.13260197639465332,
-0.38196951150894165,
0.6208444833755493,
0.24011890590190887,
-0.4862806797027588,
0.7095692157745361,
-0.34835055470466614,
0.8125187754631042,
-0.9164020419120789,
0.05941496789455414,
0.023100024089217186,
0.04025604575872421,
-0.2056044638156891,
-0.7292258739471436,
0.335076242685318,
-0.1427309662103653,
0.04513917118310928,
-0.38163700699806213,
1.1975469589233398,
-0.4388059377670288,
0.08821660280227661,
0.5343467593193054,
0.3518804609775543,
-0.058344099670648575,
-0.46836352348327637,
-0.6312638521194458,
-0.12990613281726837,
-0.3290235102176666,
-0.15640124678611755,
0.3843208849430084,
0.22500388324260712,
-0.03732062876224518,
0.5697104930877686,
0.7749334573745728,
0.5141419172286987,
0.23455873131752014,
-0.22261042892932892,
0.872711718082428,
-0.6896676421165466,
-0.9126611351966858,
-0.9588364958763123,
0.05987364798784256,
0.050149813294410706,
-0.08783237636089325,
1.0000982284545898,
0.20385095477104187,
1.0393552780151367,
-0.020547447726130486,
0.7641576528549194,
0.1356915980577469,
0.2730211913585663,
-0.47474971413612366,
0.8374497890472412,
-0.4765014946460724,
0.11477230489253998,
-0.48139622807502747,
-0.7096261382102966,
-0.2886545658111572,
0.08438239991664886,
-0.2789454460144043,
-0.06509970873594284,
0.8299691081047058,
0.7707259654998779,
-0.014999439008533955,
0.00008093289216049016,
0.5498636960983276,
0.6719682216644287,
-0.12063301354646683,
0.8081020712852478,
0.9013199210166931,
-0.11886893957853317,
0.7190092206001282,
-0.030556313693523407,
-0.2964320182800293,
-0.10067645460367203,
-0.596070408821106,
-0.8511152267456055,
-0.5239123702049255,
0.08685573935508728,
-0.45942556858062744,
0.42788252234458923,
0.44404396414756775,
0.665080726146698,
-0.9189552664756775,
-0.1166125237941742,
-0.23080439865589142,
0.30608808994293213,
-0.3465511202812195,
-0.20381630957126617,
0.03322363644838333,
-0.39215943217277527,
-0.11479180306196213,
0.4114181399345398,
0.3110232353210449,
0.06791466474533081,
-0.2697812616825104,
0.2802496552467346,
-0.13481813669204712,
-0.10153647512197495,
0.3562820851802826,
0.6562578678131104,
-0.6215355396270752,
-0.3829474449157715,
-0.15420715510845184,
-0.07970016449689865,
-0.11233769357204437,
0.9166831970214844,
-0.699510395526886,
0.24530133605003357,
0.5541366934776306,
0.6315305233001709,
0.05099887400865555,
-0.2676272988319397,
0.6972747445106506,
-1.040737271308899,
0.47271132469177246,
0.25823459029197693,
0.13679838180541992,
0.08648461103439331,
-0.5739107728004456,
0.11851270496845245,
0.6096142530441284,
-0.25963807106018066,
-1.1286766529083252,
0.6604979634284973,
-0.7405869960784912,
-0.39624467492103577,
0.7979583740234375,
-0.32311031222343445,
-0.19776751101016998,
-0.1392127126455307,
0.3234512507915497,
0.2905674874782562,
-0.28704577684402466,
0.8142715692520142,
0.6616898775100708,
0.2104949951171875,
0.06907283514738083,
-0.6595815420150757,
0.5221104025840759,
0.6682667136192322,
-0.8405528664588928,
0.23659151792526245,
0.12864865362644196,
0.41203969717025757,
0.2397548407316208,
0.4224711060523987,
-0.18651923537254333,
0.43775683641433716,
0.14686118066310883,
-0.0081696892157197,
-0.3551919460296631,
-0.3905462324619293,
-0.6000946164131165,
0.321598082780838,
-0.2910808026790619,
-0.42991384863853455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18944v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18944v1
|
SemEval 2024 -- Task 10: Emotion Discovery and Reasoning its Flip in Conversation (EDiReF)
| 2024-02-29T08:20:06 | 2024-02-29T08:20:06 |
Shivani Kumar, Md Shad Akhtar, Erik Cambria, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present SemEval-2024 Task 10, a shared task centred on identifying
emotions and finding the rationale behind their flips within monolingual
English and Hindi-English code-mixed dialogues. This task comprises three
distinct subtasks - emotion recognition in conversation for code-mixed
dialogues, emotion flip reasoning for code-mixed dialogues, and emotion flip
reasoning for English dialogues. Participating systems were tasked to
automatically execute one or more of these subtasks. The datasets for these
tasks comprise manually annotated conversations focusing on emotions and
triggers for emotion shifts (The task data is available at
https://github.com/LCS2-IIITD/EDiReF-SemEval2024.git). A total of 84
participants engaged in this task, with the most adept systems attaining
F1-scores of 0.70, 0.79, and 0.76 for the respective subtasks. This paper
summarises the results and findings from 24 teams alongside their system
descriptions.
|
[
-0.6276534199714661,
-0.4250374138355255,
0.48239943385124207,
0.5389624238014221,
-0.20543745160102844,
0.09398014843463898,
0.0019264154834672809,
-0.4388951361179352,
0.48839274048805237,
0.42647334933280945,
-0.9641950130462646,
-0.5671701431274414,
-0.34203359484672546,
0.4126613438129425,
-0.31745490431785583,
0.9214385151863098,
-0.2726427912712097,
-0.05166405066847801,
-0.24536848068237305,
-0.49589723348617554,
-0.21521857380867004,
-0.5462487936019897,
-0.5012564063072205,
-0.45912253856658936,
0.42259642481803894,
0.8380413055419922,
0.13852815330028534,
-0.09664185345172882,
0.39779776334762573,
0.21702739596366882,
0.07660041004419327,
0.08478043228387833,
-0.5465312004089355,
0.41502049565315247,
-0.246886745095253,
-0.1702151745557785,
-0.5853370428085327,
-0.02086622826755047,
-0.020171720534563065,
0.3029048442840576,
-0.04323727637529373,
0.14272348582744598,
-0.004472473636269569,
0.7683132290840149,
-0.5655618906021118,
0.21184460818767548,
-0.12530824542045593,
0.12412599474191666,
-0.06198262795805931,
-0.3561996519565582,
-0.2519991397857666,
-0.12161098420619965,
0.12994202971458435,
-0.18715205788612366,
-0.21445360779762268,
-0.054040681570768356,
0.7434477210044861,
0.3264520466327667,
-0.7877366542816162,
-0.5429907441139221,
-0.4969761073589325,
0.6076356768608093,
-0.5214054584503174,
0.384956032037735,
0.10719815641641617,
-0.019936148077249527,
0.2534559965133667,
-0.4641757905483246,
-0.5067600011825562,
0.43205925822257996,
0.09029092639684677,
0.5308124423027039,
-0.07377690076828003,
0.1292797178030014,
0.32609614729881287,
0.33653080463409424,
-0.3470385670661926,
-0.15517207980155945,
-0.1516115367412567,
-0.16490861773490906,
0.9108404517173767,
0.3686199188232422,
0.383625864982605,
0.018397359177470207,
-0.31937023997306824,
0.005666638724505901,
-0.7076334357261658,
0.2553842067718506,
0.6117867827415466,
-0.047254178673028946,
-0.18599948287010193,
0.41735151410102844,
-0.4296380877494812,
0.007000652141869068,
0.15509626269340515,
0.20800097286701202,
0.5973866581916809,
-0.6320917010307312,
-0.20869939029216766,
0.25086668133735657,
0.6953062415122986,
0.4833231270313263,
0.15470652282238007,
0.4108334481716156,
-0.29232797026634216,
0.026413600891828537,
0.06784708052873611,
-0.7199775576591492,
-0.12533918023109436,
0.3905066251754761,
-0.29673540592193604,
-0.46550437808036804,
-0.2437431663274765,
-1.079551100730896,
-0.4949316382408142,
-0.22544823586940765,
0.505415678024292,
-0.34363290667533875,
-0.5183520317077637,
-0.0038474388420581818,
-0.016743984073400497,
0.4906966984272003,
0.6288727521896362,
-0.6073687672615051,
0.1766195297241211,
0.5104348063468933,
0.2722591459751129,
-0.30523183941841125,
-0.28193119168281555,
-0.3978963792324066,
-0.43853867053985596,
-0.12153183668851852,
0.8011953234672546,
-0.805005669593811,
-0.34377992153167725,
0.03990056365728378,
0.3373871445655823,
-0.24136969447135925,
-0.2866290807723999,
0.9727370738983154,
-0.1914450079202652,
0.31762775778770447,
-0.49599313735961914,
-0.2559420168399811,
-0.3718048632144928,
0.37838128209114075,
-0.5625109672546387,
1.1844552755355835,
-0.19012735784053802,
-0.8458781838417053,
-0.0032228215131908655,
-0.6447818875312805,
-0.6019192337989807,
0.00602660421282053,
-0.14435285329818726,
-0.20847328007221222,
0.034525930881500244,
0.1591077744960785,
0.3157877027988434,
-0.23790906369686127,
0.050936780869960785,
-0.10076168179512024,
-0.48159730434417725,
-0.14418156445026398,
-0.17125241458415985,
0.5907168388366699,
0.3761385977268219,
-0.8961467742919922,
0.167324960231781,
-0.6539980173110962,
0.008121702820062637,
0.03439467027783394,
-0.10870862752199173,
-0.25462037324905396,
-0.12202432751655579,
-0.1592189371585846,
0.3140723407268524,
0.2009381204843521,
-0.676510751247406,
0.044710248708724976,
-0.11653737723827362,
0.21162554621696472,
0.545428454875946,
0.19337230920791626,
0.4644549489021301,
0.2060452401638031,
0.787626326084137,
0.420177161693573,
0.15986433625221252,
-0.549978494644165,
-0.4901514947414398,
-1.0590397119522095,
0.12165307998657227,
-0.04142473265528679,
0.6696018576622009,
-0.7896074056625366,
-0.13095390796661377,
-0.06423468142747879,
-0.4001178741455078,
-0.5774493217468262,
-0.24160432815551758,
0.2608318328857422,
0.31889569759368896,
0.18235811591148376,
0.07721645385026932,
-0.5408831238746643,
-1.0545852184295654,
-0.27812013030052185,
-0.08985194563865662,
0.48104456067085266,
0.5844297409057617,
0.5913553237915039,
-0.5011923313140869,
0.31391674280166626,
-0.1016763374209404,
0.1999487727880478,
-0.33778685331344604,
0.6218419075012207,
-0.047687631100416183,
0.3316695988178253,
0.2978329062461853,
-0.8806988000869751,
-0.4976007640361786,
-0.0027400620747357607,
-0.6367084383964539,
-0.614849328994751,
-0.15289434790611267,
-0.23585334420204163,
0.595304012298584,
0.5829259157180786,
0.05223492905497551,
0.7089276313781738,
0.6422773003578186,
-0.45808184146881104,
0.44186460971832275,
0.23035193979740143,
0.8712742328643799,
-0.8755108118057251,
-0.10474229604005814,
-0.20603841543197632,
-0.25486117601394653,
-0.6721875667572021,
-0.197872593998909,
0.14298798143863678,
-0.10444774478673935,
-0.4397115111351013,
0.31868717074394226,
-0.45904111862182617,
-0.0659535676240921,
-0.10262119770050049,
-0.04043897986412048,
-0.08487194776535034,
0.7148298621177673,
0.17341139912605286,
0.6938384175300598,
0.3851509392261505,
-0.4048871397972107,
0.4943441152572632,
0.14801886677742004,
-0.11406572163105011,
0.8419197797775269,
-0.607905387878418,
0.408663272857666,
0.12588128447532654,
-0.0785500556230545,
-0.8657698631286621,
-0.17013296484947205,
0.14541733264923096,
-0.45402416586875916,
0.08887157589197159,
0.03878667578101158,
-0.08708418160676956,
-0.2708997428417206,
-0.21211859583854675,
0.4193824231624603,
0.4007077217102051,
-0.4274839460849762,
0.8348413705825806,
0.6254492998123169,
-0.4298368990421295,
-0.45550110936164856,
-0.5218790769577026,
0.14090369641780853,
-0.17118124663829803,
-0.7876357436180115,
-0.008045019581913948,
0.020680759102106094,
-0.2228020876646042,
-0.17721959948539734,
-0.18221791088581085,
0.18143506348133087,
-0.03560848906636238,
0.7226591110229492,
-0.11878911405801773,
0.0905211865901947,
0.059572722762823105,
0.20617137849330902,
-0.1357554793357849,
0.18521730601787567,
0.14028100669384003,
0.4584675133228302,
-0.680314838886261,
-0.5499323010444641,
0.012736646458506584,
0.6650015115737915,
0.7301969528198242,
-0.2990213632583618,
0.45402878522872925,
0.6631292700767517,
-0.40235474705696106,
-0.24868209660053253,
-0.4496050179004669,
-0.019367465749382973,
-0.3910839855670929,
0.3605334758758545,
-0.6036304831504822,
-0.9851123690605164,
0.8494274020195007,
-0.3448527157306671,
-0.128887340426445,
0.49196818470954895,
0.8260605931282043,
-0.23169414699077606,
1.3499112129211426,
0.5731289386749268,
0.19615225493907928,
0.2520698308944702,
-0.01270027831196785,
0.558971107006073,
-0.6754375100135803,
-0.5642581582069397,
-0.4500400424003601,
-0.6261807680130005,
-0.6234950423240662,
-0.3734889030456543,
0.5712044835090637,
-0.21213310956954956,
-0.1549719274044037,
0.3705359995365143,
-0.3291301429271698,
0.34298384189605713,
0.4889416992664337,
-0.14131520688533783,
0.039205729961395264,
-0.3760128319263458,
-0.32824432849884033,
-0.07912304997444153,
-0.5037260055541992,
-0.3786783814430237,
0.47850099205970764,
0.33074039220809937,
0.8090202212333679,
-0.04824642837047577,
1.1851149797439575,
0.20707115530967712,
-0.005040944088250399,
-0.7454255223274231,
0.8824333548545837,
0.2644626498222351,
-0.4736296832561493,
-0.30618107318878174,
-0.2065696120262146,
-0.6518722772598267,
-0.1802891492843628,
0.16572663187980652,
-0.5969364643096924,
0.43947893381118774,
-0.17224709689617157,
-0.12643228471279144,
-0.12545661628246307,
-0.6900002360343933,
1.0306662321090698,
-0.3210459053516388,
-0.42807167768478394,
-0.49848672747612,
-0.6932861804962158,
0.2744332551956177,
0.051606010645627975,
0.3614218831062317,
-0.18485590815544128,
0.28026747703552246,
0.8744803667068481,
-0.31673502922058105,
0.6164564490318298,
-0.2118462473154068,
-0.1398847997188568,
0.4547998011112213,
0.2477625608444214,
0.6506926417350769,
0.02420334331691265,
-0.12393978238105774,
-0.14658822119235992,
0.3813422918319702,
-0.238472580909729,
-0.46586501598358154,
0.7642521262168884,
-0.3888634443283081,
-0.5637685656547546,
-0.6786679625511169,
-0.25116121768951416,
-0.21235643327236176,
-0.004264445975422859,
0.12190976738929749,
0.29521071910858154,
-0.21954414248466492,
0.23387710750102997,
0.6974631547927856,
-0.5222175717353821,
0.4019552767276764,
0.544193685054779,
-0.13010674715042114,
-0.31405866146087646,
0.7870649695396423,
-0.12594683468341827,
0.12090632319450378,
0.13223159313201904,
0.02778155542910099,
-0.14360159635543823,
-0.07606056332588196,
-0.40209394693374634,
-0.05689384043216705,
-0.8442373275756836,
-0.210203617811203,
-0.7593353986740112,
-0.07236093282699585,
-0.48335447907447815,
-0.014713400043547153,
-0.5973182320594788,
-0.4914874732494354,
-0.06539947539567947,
-0.32787588238716125,
0.2236427515745163,
0.83940190076828,
-0.14930808544158936,
-0.4415031671524048,
-0.9069042801856995,
-0.22128507494926453,
0.3429253101348877,
0.17378392815589905,
-0.3959457278251648,
-0.6471723318099976,
-0.2906740605831146,
0.2339024692773819,
-0.14972785115242004,
-1.1822530031204224,
0.6176191568374634,
0.17775316536426544,
0.4324183464050293,
0.27026331424713135,
0.32507389783859253,
0.5496132969856262,
-0.19846968352794647,
0.863947331905365,
-0.05482364445924759,
-1.1642059087753296,
0.8728049397468567,
-0.34652891755104065,
0.32167375087738037,
0.7142840623855591,
0.53041011095047,
-0.8075125813484192,
-0.1245993971824646,
-0.6853407621383667,
-0.8255324959754944,
0.768329381942749,
0.311198890209198,
0.08928012102842331,
0.05074629932641983,
0.00500778341665864,
0.09243424236774445,
0.21176500618457794,
-0.33648502826690674,
-0.2338719666004181,
-0.10816367715597153,
-0.5709445476531982,
0.2026732861995697,
-0.41273900866508484,
-0.22899486124515533,
-0.23318049311637878,
0.6146189570426941,
-0.2334190309047699,
0.5492527484893799,
0.3467174768447876,
-0.16114865243434906,
-0.20606696605682373,
0.44213634729385376,
0.7423609495162964,
-0.032451506704092026,
-0.04758106917142868,
0.3663909137248993,
0.3109840154647827,
-0.39082321524620056,
0.09486988931894302,
-0.04478425532579422,
0.07909510284662247,
-0.14192377030849457,
0.2679206430912018,
1.0901821851730347,
0.3680223226547241,
-0.8039929270744324,
0.5733569860458374,
-0.08928752690553665,
-0.2707335352897644,
-0.24032482504844666,
-0.1902189552783966,
0.2414928674697876,
0.5517345070838928,
0.09690043330192566,
0.03552083298563957,
0.39682307839393616,
-0.8490118384361267,
0.2866824269294739,
0.06720238924026489,
-0.5428613424301147,
-0.7706729769706726,
0.29986584186553955,
0.8414083123207092,
-0.2547050416469574,
0.37935319542884827,
-0.5949700474739075,
-1.310936450958252,
0.6879671216011047,
0.09566070884466171,
1.1188386678695679,
-0.3061193525791168,
0.399201899766922,
0.4895677864551544,
0.10378454625606537,
0.11516912281513214,
0.8364546298980713,
-0.11778586357831955,
-0.8328745365142822,
-0.20518499612808228,
-0.368124783039093,
-0.6756970286369324,
-0.2721550464630127,
-0.6977552175521851,
0.5005662441253662,
0.13967175781726837,
0.12128018587827682,
-0.2508618235588074,
-0.03673170134425163,
-0.88603675365448,
0.17702031135559082,
0.4667782783508301,
0.7196491360664368,
-0.9847053289413452,
0.47628647089004517,
1.063211441040039,
-0.3033168613910675,
-0.889604926109314,
-0.32733649015426636,
0.3568938672542572,
-0.8127833604812622,
0.806931734085083,
0.05997217819094658,
-0.18730191886425018,
0.03992448002099991,
-0.627795934677124,
-0.5850327014923096,
1.0741283893585205,
-0.027419734746217728,
-0.397304505109787,
0.4007168114185333,
0.14661313593387604,
0.6595258712768555,
-0.5902888774871826,
0.7586998343467712,
0.6921482682228088,
0.4404873847961426,
0.3485633134841919,
-1.0838637351989746,
-0.16453300416469574,
-0.7157692909240723,
-0.792119026184082,
0.339695006608963,
-0.8470367789268494,
0.4408041834831238,
-0.33117398619651794,
-0.32380029559135437,
-0.5141209959983826,
0.36083999276161194,
0.1081729531288147,
0.7846784591674805,
0.5312527418136597,
0.7679248452186584,
0.5019851922988892,
-0.33967792987823486,
0.7922605276107788,
-0.36362341046333313,
0.24408438801765442,
0.8936380743980408,
-0.664962112903595,
0.7941083312034607,
0.5378125309944153,
-0.20751003921031952,
0.5370920896530151,
0.7785512804985046,
0.5320022702217102,
0.3988890051841736,
-0.08142632246017456,
-0.19805431365966797,
-0.5026232004165649,
-0.2273152619600296,
-0.09172140806913376,
0.47438302636146545,
0.45486557483673096,
-0.11353965103626251,
-0.03818375617265701,
0.3484973907470703,
0.009187949821352959,
-0.35090622305870056,
-0.15800036489963531,
0.8464345335960388,
0.08534170687198639,
-0.8932314515113831,
0.24894528090953827,
-0.3018305003643036,
0.5499263405799866,
-0.15668821334838867,
-0.14749504625797272,
-0.5769637823104858,
0.08089003711938858,
-0.3725471794605255,
-0.9934952855110168,
0.255717933177948,
0.20159094035625458,
0.1572975218296051,
-0.6814302206039429,
0.9030525088310242,
-0.6837975978851318,
-0.2435016930103302,
0.3247832655906677,
0.467430979013443,
0.3379731774330139,
-0.2369532287120819,
-0.5113822817802429,
0.33662402629852295,
0.48987606167793274,
-0.5608216524124146,
0.20591437816619873,
0.8209074139595032,
-0.12220100313425064,
0.5891357660293579,
-0.04231306537985802,
-0.33762043714523315,
-0.01582363247871399,
0.39098700881004333,
0.7463130950927734,
-0.733814001083374,
-0.3350256681442261,
-0.482521653175354,
0.6100418567657471,
-0.10139589011669159,
-0.34649258852005005,
0.7602189779281616,
0.39473408460617065,
0.5960685014724731,
-0.06640945374965668,
0.7305641770362854,
-0.12051983922719955,
0.5596780180931091,
-0.21967396140098572,
0.18823744356632233,
-0.6607476472854614,
0.23547986149787903,
-0.45423033833503723,
-0.6452401876449585,
0.34548166394233704,
0.5370352268218994,
-0.3962859809398651,
-0.16426344215869904,
0.9712721705436707,
0.6952735185623169,
0.37047693133354187,
0.6363371014595032,
0.30197733640670776,
0.06515634804964066,
0.29074952006340027,
0.906491219997406,
0.971859872341156,
-0.5479556322097778,
0.45642393827438354,
-0.4074980318546295,
-0.10061943531036377,
-0.3257567584514618,
-0.9348433613777161,
-0.6140044927597046,
-0.8336001038551331,
-0.7789924144744873,
-0.16333769261837006,
-0.0691731721162796,
1.0783665180206299,
0.2598491609096527,
-1.1210870742797852,
-0.020537087693810463,
-0.07275283336639404,
0.04272736236453056,
-0.04220390319824219,
-0.23916642367839813,
-0.16552352905273438,
-0.12598241865634918,
-0.990541934967041,
0.2873859107494354,
0.7996682524681091,
-0.12655235826969147,
0.08172950893640518,
-0.34692612290382385,
-0.32066524028778076,
0.24845969676971436,
0.44455522298812866,
0.26406270265579224,
-0.35952088236808777,
-0.46161946654319763,
0.36070430278778076,
-0.1500874161720276,
-0.30028051137924194,
0.997774600982666,
-0.5889246463775635,
0.50543612241745,
1.0033013820648193,
0.6562022566795349,
0.6261253952980042,
0.041752368211746216,
0.7364057898521423,
-0.37125375866889954,
-0.07918142527341843,
0.5415470004081726,
0.42582497000694275,
0.21840974688529968,
-0.23868504166603088,
0.9967539310455322,
0.46087703108787537,
-0.8856425285339355,
-0.9796746373176575,
0.13090673089027405,
-0.9026620984077454,
0.2443830966949463,
1.2872689962387085,
-0.22077523171901703,
-0.1084790825843811,
-0.016211675480008125,
-0.31990182399749756,
0.11210861057043076,
-0.4324326515197754,
0.31550347805023193,
1.0775563716888428,
-0.6667741537094116,
-0.592065691947937,
-0.36308029294013977,
0.6113747954368591,
0.8676721453666687,
-1.007912039756775,
-0.1639597862958908,
0.40438112616539,
-0.1537695825099945,
0.147665873169899,
0.5484926700592041,
-0.06702478229999542,
0.23220963776111603,
-0.08946691453456879,
0.2882641851902008,
0.15156258642673492,
-0.2940692603588104,
-0.4151705205440521,
-0.20828206837177277,
-0.5278257131576538,
-0.027299853041768074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18923v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18923v1
|
Inappropriate Pause Detection In Dysarthric Speech Using Large-Scale Speech Recognition
| 2024-02-29T07:29:42 | 2024-02-29T07:29:42 |
Jeehyun Lee, Yerin Choi, Tae-Jin Song, Myoung-Wan Koo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Dysarthria, a common issue among stroke patients, severely impacts speech
intelligibility. Inappropriate pauses are crucial indicators in severity
assessment and speech-language therapy. We propose to extend a large-scale
speech recognition model for inappropriate pause detection in dysarthric
speech. To this end, we propose task design, labeling strategy, and a speech
recognition model with an inappropriate pause prediction layer. First, we treat
pause detection as speech recognition, using an automatic speech recognition
(ASR) model to convert speech into text with pause tags. According to the newly
designed task, we label pause locations at the text level and their
appropriateness. We collaborate with speech-language pathologists to establish
labeling criteria, ensuring high-quality annotated data. Finally, we extend the
ASR model with an inappropriate pause prediction layer for end-to-end
inappropriate pause detection. Moreover, we propose a task-tailored metric for
evaluating inappropriate pause detection independent of ASR performance. Our
experiments show that the proposed method better detects inappropriate pauses
in dysarthric speech than baselines. (Inappropriate Pause Error Rate: 14.47%)
|
[
-0.5174948573112488,
-0.9182922840118408,
0.41967707872390747,
0.06938916444778442,
-0.1771048903465271,
0.2344643771648407,
-0.19464439153671265,
-0.6976770758628845,
0.36311545968055725,
0.23979899287223816,
-0.3633367717266083,
-0.03750288113951683,
-0.9035419225692749,
-0.06770189851522446,
-0.27658286690711975,
0.4997750222682953,
-0.2633344531059265,
0.16431283950805664,
0.19004777073860168,
-0.15802548825740814,
-1.0398969650268555,
-0.049438755959272385,
-0.7689175009727478,
-0.4738318622112274,
0.33855801820755005,
0.48940885066986084,
0.6346498131752014,
0.8085318207740784,
0.09706500917673111,
0.3040834963321686,
-0.7340669631958008,
-0.007490579970180988,
-0.04872085899114609,
0.5733364820480347,
0.3672058880329132,
0.40490055084228516,
-0.7949708700180054,
0.013943926431238651,
0.8991178274154663,
0.7202803492546082,
-0.14262419939041138,
0.05164823308587074,
0.08421670645475388,
0.41086485981941223,
-0.23745426535606384,
0.10381416976451874,
-0.10871485620737076,
0.22615599632263184,
-0.4858545660972595,
-0.3624269664287567,
-0.30433058738708496,
-0.12812571227550507,
0.12526628375053406,
-0.35421839356422424,
-0.19163009524345398,
0.08181773126125336,
0.35529565811157227,
0.503925085067749,
0.1692313253879547,
-0.3220972716808319,
-0.7184070348739624,
0.2378879338502884,
-0.5671164393424988,
0.587675154209137,
0.9358458518981934,
0.48514223098754883,
-0.14722098410129547,
-0.4585590660572052,
-0.6379594802856445,
-0.5127619504928589,
0.34225785732269287,
-0.0872613936662674,
-0.4063093364238739,
0.13950926065444946,
0.4208328425884247,
0.1278851330280304,
-0.5986555814743042,
0.8768174052238464,
-0.5738770365715027,
-0.3544105589389801,
0.6579278707504272,
0.3042412996292114,
0.5624557733535767,
0.02488395944237709,
0.027613122016191483,
0.42441534996032715,
-0.3644351065158844,
0.25062230229377747,
0.31246116757392883,
0.6240595579147339,
0.22088514268398285,
0.5840913653373718,
-0.2411162257194519,
0.8204206824302673,
0.3276841640472412,
-0.41190105676651,
0.26635637879371643,
0.517389178276062,
0.12487614154815674,
0.6760086417198181,
0.270381897687912,
0.22395166754722595,
0.1990763396024704,
-0.33470433950424194,
0.07023375481367111,
-0.013495054095983505,
0.18621915578842163,
-0.5110059380531311,
-0.42096859216690063,
0.701346218585968,
-0.322435200214386,
-0.04164597764611244,
-0.5443693399429321,
-0.4761808216571808,
-0.4413842260837555,
-0.6233373284339905,
0.31398236751556396,
-0.4856095016002655,
-0.39385220408439636,
0.11965440958738327,
-0.17297151684761047,
-0.2839943468570709,
0.0624268464744091,
-0.7183291912078857,
0.4593321681022644,
0.21930544078350067,
0.9116982817649841,
-0.41504594683647156,
-0.6308020949363708,
-1.0428346395492554,
0.1974555402994156,
-0.11815019696950912,
0.5825237035751343,
-0.5861660242080688,
-0.6665006279945374,
-0.1886158585548401,
0.10571594536304474,
0.014186911284923553,
-0.2868104577064514,
0.5405008792877197,
-0.35395288467407227,
-0.26665276288986206,
-0.14569814503192902,
-0.6489869952201843,
-0.09500999748706818,
0.05467744544148445,
-0.8814146518707275,
0.6641210913658142,
-0.2151869386434555,
-1.045886754989624,
0.5980178713798523,
-0.6969983577728271,
-0.615665853023529,
0.4231118857860565,
0.06850673258304596,
-0.5322276949882507,
-0.22770105302333832,
0.19879315793514252,
0.2498844563961029,
0.05405113101005554,
0.32469964027404785,
-0.13704301416873932,
-0.7107502222061157,
0.41032490134239197,
-0.5498815178871155,
0.6089106202125549,
0.16777460277080536,
-0.33529961109161377,
0.10681894421577454,
-0.7256426811218262,
0.18439309298992157,
-0.29773208498954773,
-0.4152291417121887,
-0.35155490040779114,
0.10826172679662704,
0.3609848916530609,
0.2660349905490875,
-0.1867104023694992,
-0.8253884315490723,
-0.09169889986515045,
-0.11108428239822388,
0.5441017746925354,
0.6100966930389404,
-0.15562111139297485,
-0.012412788346409798,
-0.5269344449043274,
0.5789198875427246,
-0.17353151738643646,
0.0061867316253483295,
0.15192782878875732,
-0.40647387504577637,
-0.15677271783351898,
-0.7099800705909729,
0.2854568660259247,
0.4878869652748108,
-0.4491818845272064,
0.7774209976196289,
-0.2677805721759796,
-0.2621285915374756,
-0.3187318742275238,
-0.5751953721046448,
0.2389824390411377,
0.9719036221504211,
0.709902286529541,
0.013043180108070374,
-0.42330291867256165,
-0.26799097657203674,
-0.22124752402305603,
0.017398657277226448,
0.2671235501766205,
0.1987869143486023,
0.323926717042923,
-0.20518885552883148,
0.9695572853088379,
-0.2584702670574188,
-0.6230986714363098,
-0.22751350700855255,
0.21863214671611786,
-0.006447791587561369,
0.5534150004386902,
-0.09939957410097122,
-0.639371931552887,
-0.35680967569351196,
0.059868667274713516,
-0.4001370072364807,
-0.15330255031585693,
0.2133718580007553,
0.5752051472663879,
0.22202563285827637,
0.6624400615692139,
-0.2806617319583893,
0.5956941843032837,
0.19995084404945374,
-0.3227004408836365,
0.6197046041488647,
-0.3329688608646393,
0.20551736652851105,
-0.6549537181854248,
0.3120608329772949,
-0.3824533224105835,
-0.07122568041086197,
-0.6777891516685486,
-0.6065734624862671,
-0.1686469465494156,
-0.3352990448474884,
-0.264286607503891,
0.46771320700645447,
-0.41600874066352844,
0.12376352399587631,
-0.4853111207485199,
0.2420847862958908,
-0.03414822369813919,
-0.14197002351284027,
0.26131367683410645,
0.4696495532989502,
0.6846669912338257,
-0.424562007188797,
0.1866251528263092,
0.5968438386917114,
-0.18219932913780212,
0.6988498568534851,
-0.7237843871116638,
0.012908424250781536,
-0.16803131997585297,
0.41997188329696655,
-1.1880054473876953,
-0.49664756655693054,
0.07092217355966568,
-0.6057690978050232,
0.9009369611740112,
-0.2191258668899536,
-0.07288680225610733,
-0.9446942210197449,
-0.25243231654167175,
0.5156508684158325,
0.24531523883342743,
-0.5118575692176819,
0.10907313227653503,
0.9114375710487366,
-0.44591429829597473,
-0.5608212351799011,
-1.0789775848388672,
0.14058806002140045,
-0.4745294749736786,
-0.6223924160003662,
0.5539336204528809,
-0.0790034607052803,
0.23583467304706573,
-0.04951769486069679,
-0.25895705819129944,
-0.3741263151168823,
-0.2140352874994278,
0.41162750124931335,
0.03673817962408066,
0.12154076993465424,
0.25339818000793457,
0.3252905607223511,
-0.23701263964176178,
-0.17189782857894897,
0.07912923395633698,
0.5241537690162659,
0.27343684434890747,
-0.35310429334640503,
-1.1048816442489624,
0.3506285548210144,
0.7864589691162109,
-0.16511861979961395,
-0.026975927874445915,
0.6324847936630249,
-0.8149769902229309,
0.144524484872818,
-0.492051362991333,
-0.25325465202331543,
-0.3781646192073822,
0.3132196366786957,
-0.24359630048274994,
-0.8922318816184998,
0.7643495202064514,
0.09396050870418549,
-0.4517838954925537,
-0.010134889744222164,
0.42694559693336487,
-0.0025358491111546755,
1.0396441221237183,
0.22652499377727509,
-0.29513347148895264,
0.18222635984420776,
0.02477050945162773,
0.22541958093643188,
-1.2079004049301147,
-0.04396558925509453,
-0.49778321385383606,
-0.28859856724739075,
-0.4474281966686249,
-0.24863484501838684,
0.3665512204170227,
0.03092869557440281,
-0.3005615472793579,
0.04112473502755165,
-0.8615459203720093,
0.45222556591033936,
-0.18909646570682526,
0.30163291096687317,
0.16950277984142303,
-0.032207392156124115,
0.11208640784025192,
-0.39607083797454834,
-0.5423836708068848,
-0.10501638054847717,
0.4721137285232544,
0.6009888648986816,
0.8707658648490906,
-0.11535178124904633,
0.5618345141410828,
0.5914188027381897,
-0.1274024397134781,
-1.0158131122589111,
-0.05413007363677025,
-0.16314736008644104,
-0.32003095746040344,
-0.9116629958152771,
-0.1313801258802414,
-1.0995200872421265,
-0.18555186688899994,
0.43980586528778076,
-1.2319766283035278,
0.37180906534194946,
0.11206132918596268,
-0.7034471035003662,
0.15574663877487183,
-0.19539080560207367,
0.667884886264801,
-0.26195964217185974,
-0.160172238945961,
0.16471247375011444,
-0.689520001411438,
0.317996084690094,
0.1785746067762375,
0.33517178893089294,
-0.3497125804424286,
0.03690255433320999,
0.8901543617248535,
-0.37524184584617615,
0.727284848690033,
-0.46719008684158325,
0.1492188572883606,
0.21874822676181793,
0.21103928983211517,
0.40598657727241516,
-0.1458759307861328,
-0.1009589359164238,
0.037215713411569595,
-0.10443806648254395,
0.03288676217198372,
0.20153534412384033,
0.8074930310249329,
-0.28085625171661377,
-0.09656915068626404,
-0.7477307319641113,
-0.8554250001907349,
-0.48822611570358276,
-0.030050303786993027,
0.292770653963089,
0.6763665080070496,
-0.2107359617948532,
-0.14846253395080566,
0.5986028909683228,
-0.07996298372745514,
0.5657248497009277,
0.5995339751243591,
0.09303182363510132,
-0.27129238843917847,
1.0378540754318237,
0.8099245429039001,
-0.11728312820196152,
-0.211069256067276,
0.5564030408859253,
-0.6518938541412354,
-0.8209074139595032,
-0.4918839931488037,
-0.02982647716999054,
-0.5445910692214966,
-0.20533759891986847,
-0.6628254055976868,
-0.38882771134376526,
-0.39166414737701416,
-0.11580398678779602,
-0.0253671295940876,
-0.2886704206466675,
-0.366355836391449,
-0.1147928237915039,
0.7586919665336609,
0.5530194044113159,
-0.39431148767471313,
0.1347973495721817,
-0.7387868165969849,
0.2834087610244751,
0.17460019886493683,
0.5063539147377014,
0.19240570068359375,
-1.036208987236023,
0.20487827062606812,
-0.15037252008914948,
-0.09930220246315002,
-0.8141947984695435,
0.4378601908683777,
0.24778787791728973,
0.6746346354484558,
0.1488751322031021,
0.3473793566226959,
0.8635657429695129,
-0.7814921736717224,
0.5515892505645752,
0.33211344480514526,
-1.0983580350875854,
0.5936451554298401,
-0.4766788184642792,
0.397296279668808,
0.43031713366508484,
0.46990668773651123,
-0.6822954416275024,
-0.3591783940792084,
-0.47539210319519043,
-1.1481224298477173,
0.8899999856948853,
-0.1307768076658249,
-0.332527756690979,
-0.19689078629016876,
0.03442268818616867,
0.10620814561843872,
-0.21067175269126892,
-0.2905299961566925,
0.15331149101257324,
0.09619862586259842,
0.16175134479999542,
0.30188795924186707,
-0.27246901392936707,
-0.25282517075538635,
-0.3650631308555603,
0.19182465970516205,
-0.09122724086046219,
0.0868540108203888,
0.2557474970817566,
-0.07055261731147766,
-0.38426724076271057,
0.0683356374502182,
0.5607677698135376,
0.9699399471282959,
-0.08128253370523453,
-0.09772231429815292,
0.37626776099205017,
-0.6549555659294128,
0.28389883041381836,
0.6881211996078491,
0.1541760265827179,
0.14968407154083252,
0.16451981663703918,
0.6433084607124329,
-0.053273674100637436,
-0.6930201649665833,
0.5154467821121216,
0.12542182207107544,
0.03572152927517891,
-0.44096168875694275,
-0.43971556425094604,
0.268353670835495,
0.2809445858001709,
0.042571377009153366,
-0.2556302547454834,
0.5204278230667114,
0.03411685302853584,
0.7043675184249878,
0.13351783156394958,
-0.6473817825317383,
-0.053855665028095245,
0.8644723296165466,
0.052872464060783386,
-0.3547825217247009,
0.29476502537727356,
-0.08187859505414963,
-0.5557539463043213,
0.490473210811615,
0.5633322596549988,
0.758292019367218,
-0.7328537106513977,
0.180026575922966,
0.09370552003383636,
0.03208288922905922,
-0.09108740836381912,
0.6382021903991699,
-0.1527019888162613,
-0.15015056729316711,
-0.523330569267273,
-0.3247373104095459,
-0.369180291891098,
0.09993623942136765,
-0.8883233070373535,
0.33082062005996704,
-0.34498918056488037,
-0.33180177211761475,
0.3671417832374573,
-0.24378806352615356,
-0.11983776092529297,
0.26835185289382935,
0.16853471100330353,
0.7169073820114136,
-0.6110089421272278,
0.9424335360527039,
0.22784508764743805,
-0.34364593029022217,
-0.5573869347572327,
0.26813364028930664,
0.09254616498947144,
-0.7215350270271301,
0.5887619853019714,
0.5264613032341003,
-0.3554646670818329,
-0.3243683874607086,
-0.03141647204756737,
-0.7723401784896851,
0.9837777018547058,
0.047263968735933304,
-0.6789959669113159,
0.35189294815063477,
-0.04038555547595024,
0.37855440378189087,
0.07385405153036118,
-0.22387707233428955,
0.8499687910079956,
0.5467193126678467,
0.3157224655151367,
-1.251909852027893,
0.15389324724674225,
0.16346777975559235,
-0.05568651854991913,
0.15406161546707153,
-0.3508521318435669,
0.6645026803016663,
-0.1565890908241272,
-0.06189124286174774,
0.2191591113805771,
0.03443382307887077,
0.4285088777542114,
0.5971531271934509,
0.5416305065155029,
0.38314178586006165,
1.0757074356079102,
-0.03389276936650276,
0.7820315957069397,
-0.099851094186306,
0.07703148573637009,
1.0495827198028564,
-0.4373936355113983,
0.9478882551193237,
0.2514042854309082,
0.0289811659604311,
-0.2898961305618286,
0.7951173782348633,
0.43624308705329895,
0.21472959220409393,
0.5673768520355225,
-0.2699258029460907,
-0.04535829648375511,
-0.31605443358421326,
-0.6824337244033813,
0.7491438388824463,
0.6258703470230103,
-0.1577167958021164,
-0.008429265581071377,
0.32321491837501526,
0.42439261078834534,
0.008853224106132984,
-0.2434503734111786,
0.4185655415058136,
-0.30395179986953735,
-0.49634063243865967,
0.9247890114784241,
-0.40719202160835266,
0.45910540223121643,
-0.30140256881713867,
0.056569118052721024,
0.2468685358762741,
0.0586058646440506,
-0.2504952549934387,
-0.8859124779701233,
0.558134913444519,
0.026700973510742188,
-0.20049625635147095,
-0.09819404035806656,
0.6277304291725159,
-0.5627794861793518,
-0.30526673793792725,
0.3890686333179474,
0.1741032749414444,
0.32884687185287476,
-0.012832819484174252,
-0.36464929580688477,
0.4222772419452667,
-0.35530945658683777,
-0.029995404183864594,
0.4041594862937927,
0.27762237191200256,
-0.09064541757106781,
0.4188658893108368,
0.5046658515930176,
0.1545887589454651,
-0.13470908999443054,
0.060797978192567825,
1.0116474628448486,
-0.38637736439704895,
-0.7630721926689148,
-0.6137246489524841,
0.5350595116615295,
-0.33426302671432495,
-0.6122666001319885,
0.32179516553878784,
0.10147693008184433,
0.0869714692234993,
0.3506612777709961,
0.4796193838119507,
-0.19879379868507385,
0.8391024470329285,
-0.38423335552215576,
0.9878877401351929,
-0.47669583559036255,
-0.06745632737874985,
-0.2678191363811493,
-0.441679984331131,
-0.5546237230300903,
0.6744388937950134,
-0.28963157534599304,
0.09648668766021729,
0.5388138890266418,
0.44391167163848877,
-0.008974271826446056,
0.11136143654584885,
0.45848339796066284,
0.3933950364589691,
0.2650546133518219,
0.20001168549060822,
0.7825565934181213,
0.040561825037002563,
0.3720413148403168,
-0.042296890169382095,
-0.5831767320632935,
-0.28700947761535645,
-0.8928502202033997,
-0.5641278624534607,
-0.44180846214294434,
-0.5035516619682312,
-0.43494340777397156,
0.22091172635555267,
0.6584992408752441,
0.8632363080978394,
-0.6652577519416809,
-0.13488447666168213,
0.03834858909249306,
-0.009915309958159924,
-0.4234057366847992,
-0.15948143601417542,
0.6556558012962341,
-0.3127225339412689,
-0.4895833730697632,
0.7885763645172119,
0.40133804082870483,
0.10346683859825134,
-0.10949448496103287,
-0.1867479532957077,
-0.2209460437297821,
-0.3917534649372101,
0.5471042990684509,
0.6757819652557373,
-0.7851759791374207,
-0.4219500720500946,
-0.16323360800743103,
0.2848399579524994,
-0.11149526387453079,
0.8423539996147156,
-0.49611416459083557,
0.7894873023033142,
0.4232619106769562,
0.7370837330818176,
0.46654170751571655,
-0.17045600712299347,
0.0945800319314003,
-0.46641236543655396,
0.25104403495788574,
0.8037680387496948,
0.3034047484397888,
0.42002102732658386,
-0.3641969859600067,
0.008467316627502441,
0.017206933349370956,
-0.8393547534942627,
-1.05955970287323,
0.08534161001443863,
-0.9962849020957947,
-0.11778996139764786,
0.9136340022087097,
-0.25550320744514465,
0.12811194360256195,
-0.7200664281845093,
-0.5483918190002441,
0.04072928801178932,
-0.4373199939727783,
0.9221961498260498,
0.6501901149749756,
-0.7545203566551208,
0.12245585769414902,
-0.6400813460350037,
0.6307570934295654,
0.020496102049946785,
-0.36529314517974854,
0.4422144591808319,
0.5022767782211304,
0.270449697971344,
0.19354844093322754,
0.6473564505577087,
-0.11754544079303741,
0.5983617305755615,
0.14015547931194305,
-0.36978811025619507,
-0.32772544026374817,
-0.4073587954044342,
-0.6088116765022278,
-0.0363318957388401,
0.31723374128341675,
-0.7476194500923157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18913v1
|
AdaMergeX: Cross-Lingual Transfer with Large Language Models via Adaptive Adapter Merging
| 2024-02-29T07:11:24 | 2024-02-29T07:11:24 |
Yiran Zhao, Wenxuan Zhang, Huiming Wang, Kenji Kawaguchi, Lidong Bing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As an effective alternative to the direct fine-tuning on target tasks in
specific languages, cross-lingual transfer addresses the challenges of limited
training data by decoupling ''task ability'' and ''language ability'' by
fine-tuning on the target task in the source language and another selected task
in the target language, respectively. However, they fail to fully separate the
task ability from the source language or the language ability from the chosen
task. In this paper, we acknowledge the mutual reliance between task ability
and language ability and direct our attention toward the gap between the target
language and the source language on tasks. As the gap removes the impact of
tasks, we assume that it remains consistent across tasks. Based on this
assumption, we propose a new cross-lingual transfer method called
$\texttt{AdaMergeX}$ that utilizes adaptive adapter merging. By introducing a
reference task, we can determine that the divergence of adapters fine-tuned on
the reference task in both languages follows the same distribution as the
divergence of adapters fine-tuned on the target task in both languages. Hence,
we can obtain target adapters by combining the other three adapters.
Furthermore, we propose a structure-adaptive adapter merging method. Our
empirical results demonstrate that our approach yields new and effective
cross-lingual transfer, outperforming existing methods across all settings.
|
[
-0.38552770018577576,
-0.5113458037376404,
0.3598513603210449,
0.16761787235736847,
-0.036709170788526535,
0.14670448005199432,
-0.48849058151245117,
-0.7915832996368408,
0.1694297343492508,
0.17929810285568237,
-0.37091004848480225,
-0.03919050469994545,
-0.7955910563468933,
0.18115617334842682,
-0.26610279083251953,
0.6598788499832153,
-0.4858657717704773,
-0.20053699612617493,
-0.06377441436052322,
-0.25159311294555664,
-0.707527220249176,
0.15736092627048492,
-0.8787862062454224,
-0.3066997826099396,
0.4405219554901123,
0.5146260261535645,
0.4871530532836914,
0.5184051394462585,
0.38887521624565125,
0.3215896487236023,
-0.10931454598903656,
0.0723365917801857,
-0.33582010865211487,
-0.19284994900226593,
-0.8927203416824341,
-0.5552348494529724,
-0.37418586015701294,
-0.33690711855888367,
0.8906028270721436,
0.9226649403572083,
0.02372349239885807,
0.1816883087158203,
0.3617252707481384,
0.6402589678764343,
-0.7400112748146057,
0.1386093944311142,
-0.5578400492668152,
0.2858349680900574,
-0.08118981122970581,
-0.022199230268597603,
-0.24506652355194092,
-0.015313333831727505,
0.08251029998064041,
-0.6968219876289368,
-0.08124072104692459,
0.16800695657730103,
0.6044290065765381,
0.14571401476860046,
-0.30154016613960266,
0.14777354896068573,
-0.9636998772621155,
0.7585024833679199,
-0.6558837294578552,
0.6730237603187561,
0.09517824649810791,
0.2987314462661743,
0.3084777295589447,
-0.4312828779220581,
-0.5520777702331543,
-0.020944710820913315,
0.07559780776500702,
-0.016374461352825165,
-0.620093822479248,
-0.2912222445011139,
-0.030329832807183266,
0.20146533846855164,
-0.4958651661872864,
-0.0044213514775037766,
-0.5833415389060974,
-0.05958274379372597,
0.5674670934677124,
-0.2558740973472595,
0.717367947101593,
0.4008632302284241,
-0.47180038690567017,
-0.27419334650039673,
-0.49016398191452026,
0.09263304620981216,
0.13399013876914978,
0.4368947446346283,
-0.0972345843911171,
0.30908337235450745,
-0.2097722440958023,
0.7501873970031738,
0.41311895847320557,
-0.06843457370996475,
0.2195480912923813,
-0.5495259761810303,
-0.033075202256441116,
0.4085414409637451,
0.6274698376655579,
0.35512301325798035,
0.39323607087135315,
-0.6159577369689941,
0.06932050734758377,
-0.1942177265882492,
0.22835072875022888,
-0.5148469805717468,
-0.09467338770627975,
-0.34795472025871277,
-0.3947713077068329,
0.12008928507566452,
-0.2605774998664856,
-0.5753275156021118,
0.19904844462871552,
-0.3252910077571869,
0.5337058305740356,
-0.32656869292259216,
-0.5538172721862793,
0.0979214683175087,
0.03624144196510315,
0.09636000543832779,
0.2759505808353424,
-0.9860209226608276,
0.42403554916381836,
0.39319920539855957,
0.6776496767997742,
-0.6099066138267517,
-0.6522147059440613,
-0.6800496578216553,
0.32596561312675476,
-0.4888269901275635,
0.8779311180114746,
-0.5380948781967163,
0.008270631544291973,
0.12544360756874084,
0.3707071542739868,
-0.5789422988891602,
-0.5445407629013062,
0.3292316496372223,
-0.42065665125846863,
0.1952306479215622,
-0.24993227422237396,
-0.35522449016571045,
-0.575028121471405,
0.3543376922607422,
-0.5214964151382446,
0.77885901927948,
0.465779572725296,
-0.5094138383865356,
0.30426740646362305,
-0.5456797480583191,
-0.7344088554382324,
0.175024151802063,
0.2063218653202057,
0.040516447275877,
0.035282719880342484,
0.23905159533023834,
0.34192341566085815,
-0.2600295841693878,
-0.07813383638858795,
-0.21096067130565643,
-0.31304770708084106,
-0.13936077058315277,
-0.05555260553956032,
0.6603839993476868,
0.12320578098297119,
-0.43344876170158386,
0.0856337621808052,
-0.6118618249893188,
-0.03292001411318779,
0.05522114038467407,
-0.48069027066230774,
-0.7191413640975952,
-0.09913589060306549,
0.2737713158130646,
0.3856443464756012,
0.3668462336063385,
-0.5118464231491089,
0.13268616795539856,
-0.4591432511806488,
0.2341986894607544,
0.4708828032016754,
-0.47376424074172974,
0.960956335067749,
-0.3718242943286896,
0.6341073513031006,
-0.006932033691555262,
-0.1319112777709961,
0.14851927757263184,
-0.18916349112987518,
-0.7386821508407593,
0.2752975523471832,
0.5715470910072327,
0.8162432312965393,
-1.072421908378601,
0.3875504434108734,
-0.5801023840904236,
-0.3765231966972351,
-0.4958723187446594,
0.4769695997238159,
0.48865434527397156,
0.4142417907714844,
0.4040742516517639,
-0.6443957090377808,
-0.31193098425865173,
-0.8043513894081116,
-0.4491972327232361,
-0.09703394770622253,
0.14131785929203033,
0.2519437074661255,
-0.06852541863918304,
-0.05155492201447487,
0.5486981272697449,
-0.22235648334026337,
-0.367449551820755,
-0.4971153438091278,
-0.048088036477565765,
-0.042224589735269547,
0.7529488205909729,
0.8093379139900208,
-0.48308756947517395,
-0.8217995166778564,
0.7533038258552551,
-0.4839426279067993,
-0.14156869053840637,
-0.1401330679655075,
-0.299268513917923,
0.2927186191082001,
0.7924319505691528,
-0.13259460031986237,
-0.131658136844635,
0.8977680206298828,
-0.5894545912742615,
0.12646256387233734,
-0.16330288350582123,
0.3393084704875946,
-1.403161883354187,
0.19834311306476593,
-0.04288067668676376,
-0.4345152676105499,
-0.6349245309829712,
0.06416942179203033,
0.07734505087137222,
0.1682755947113037,
-0.7949426770210266,
0.8956590890884399,
-0.4763042628765106,
0.052847910672426224,
-0.45699891448020935,
0.06586511433124542,
-0.2736378610134125,
0.50847989320755,
-0.15010379254817963,
0.6573526859283447,
0.7208757400512695,
-0.3675083816051483,
0.2839541733264923,
0.47502386569976807,
-0.16028818488121033,
0.9237350821495056,
-0.34983474016189575,
0.09561138600111008,
0.08579594641923904,
-0.07674255967140198,
-0.945290744304657,
0.23155577480793,
0.48634836077690125,
-0.15142464637756348,
0.510012686252594,
-0.43337640166282654,
0.04893959313631058,
-0.09367897361516953,
0.12105713784694672,
0.722698450088501,
0.39993423223495483,
-0.455623060464859,
0.94926518201828,
0.0613500215113163,
-0.6999073624610901,
-0.44701746106147766,
-0.8487200140953064,
0.23303429782390594,
-0.2016095370054245,
-0.7618405222892761,
0.5315501093864441,
-0.14792977273464203,
-0.00820603035390377,
0.3833249509334564,
-0.2753290832042694,
-0.021687353029847145,
-0.2724866271018982,
-0.13797831535339355,
0.3150600492954254,
-0.40562519431114197,
-0.33925026655197144,
0.4603131115436554,
-0.11127287894487381,
-0.029131099581718445,
-0.4318564236164093,
0.25449061393737793,
0.25602132081985474,
-0.283403217792511,
-0.1200357973575592,
0.5227659344673157,
0.6512991786003113,
-0.19136942923069,
0.6568787097930908,
0.8307103514671326,
-0.28598371148109436,
-0.15756076574325562,
-0.6194406747817993,
0.07054445892572403,
-0.3910830020904541,
0.4966963529586792,
-0.5666956901550293,
-1.0528451204299927,
0.6049620509147644,
-0.22521144151687622,
0.2658381462097168,
0.5191939473152161,
0.26219111680984497,
0.47171932458877563,
1.0574015378952026,
0.987755298614502,
-0.18533937633037567,
0.8341786861419678,
0.1152472048997879,
0.2763076722621918,
-1.0220364332199097,
0.059629183262586594,
-0.41180410981178284,
-0.5522005558013916,
-0.36671677231788635,
-0.39772653579711914,
0.028928395360708237,
-0.007245661225169897,
0.016954325139522552,
0.6642324328422546,
-0.33365511894226074,
0.4737623929977417,
0.5352799892425537,
-0.15456776320934296,
0.2955021560192108,
0.1901862472295761,
-0.1669427752494812,
0.0646999403834343,
-0.9606425166130066,
0.1745186299085617,
0.8458799719810486,
0.11466656625270844,
0.730606734752655,
0.15495063364505768,
0.4088861644268036,
0.08118147403001785,
0.023961113765835762,
-0.6215391159057617,
0.5109137892723083,
-0.511322021484375,
-0.2939290702342987,
-0.20362108945846558,
-0.48372042179107666,
-1.0485589504241943,
0.3018189072608948,
-0.35028430819511414,
-0.8396506905555725,
0.5524629354476929,
0.05649878829717636,
-0.19696664810180664,
0.5014953017234802,
-0.667796790599823,
0.9501986503601074,
-0.03838523477315903,
-0.5794715285301208,
-0.30673947930336,
-0.6416075825691223,
0.16606053709983826,
-0.17072159051895142,
0.2601017653942108,
-0.1855211853981018,
0.15345196425914764,
0.8575284481048584,
0.2109253704547882,
0.5898051857948303,
0.003316409420222044,
-0.33420222997665405,
-0.1264074593782425,
0.45708146691322327,
0.6360278129577637,
-0.3218182921409607,
0.26621368527412415,
0.2391546070575714,
0.12542898952960968,
-0.33900347352027893,
-0.45952507853507996,
0.7771348357200623,
-0.7045031189918518,
-0.45213040709495544,
-0.14552666246891022,
-0.9377539157867432,
-0.28441837430000305,
0.5286263823509216,
-0.11569522321224213,
0.12739834189414978,
-0.17773209512233734,
-0.07060183584690094,
0.2756788432598114,
0.08524026721715927,
0.508377730846405,
0.785383403301239,
-0.14499416947364807,
-0.371905654668808,
1.0300837755203247,
0.04753781110048294,
0.44149789214134216,
0.4812469482421875,
0.0818653553724289,
-0.21448001265525818,
-0.7072010636329651,
-0.6848524212837219,
0.27703845500946045,
-0.6478523015975952,
-0.03533264994621277,
-0.4250379502773285,
-0.18573245406150818,
-0.4076123535633087,
-0.4972849488258362,
-0.45353901386260986,
-0.3047068417072296,
-0.021141165867447853,
0.37680816650390625,
0.11402243375778198,
0.4628947675228119,
-0.19694742560386658,
0.09608674794435501,
-1.1447619199752808,
0.17710579931735992,
0.5347963571548462,
0.386352002620697,
-0.07057173550128937,
-0.7224275469779968,
-0.3767712414264679,
-0.05080653727054596,
-0.0261271633207798,
-0.5496357679367065,
0.3171319365501404,
0.24105195701122284,
0.6322391033172607,
0.23772288858890533,
-0.08641660958528519,
0.611297070980072,
-0.7619350552558899,
0.47142910957336426,
0.3504874110221863,
-0.9643917083740234,
0.330072283744812,
-0.14947587251663208,
0.4897279739379883,
0.6274864077568054,
0.1458507627248764,
-0.6989867687225342,
-0.3183296322822571,
-0.4728664457798004,
-1.0307673215866089,
1.0717840194702148,
0.06968146562576294,
0.08470018953084946,
0.29805275797843933,
0.10800479352474213,
0.004778100177645683,
-0.1657167375087738,
-0.5917788743972778,
0.027873927727341652,
0.163935124874115,
-0.28509286046028137,
-0.2546876072883606,
0.16341759264469147,
-0.3115439713001251,
-0.3933945894241333,
0.7119278311729431,
-0.41405433416366577,
-0.05898159742355347,
0.11934664100408554,
-0.30538052320480347,
-0.6606278419494629,
0.42594772577285767,
0.38100242614746094,
0.7744579315185547,
0.06827546656131744,
0.26856473088264465,
0.6823431849479675,
-0.47307100892066956,
0.20489968359470367,
0.6395547389984131,
-0.031119192019104958,
-0.15291497111320496,
0.4031432867050171,
0.8943514823913574,
0.3982563018798828,
-0.6776977777481079,
0.3571547269821167,
-0.07135772705078125,
-0.5262802243232727,
0.057476893067359924,
0.23192282021045685,
0.2010226845741272,
0.6611484885215759,
0.13565486669540405,
0.49138009548187256,
0.1377796083688736,
-0.4490724503993988,
0.06849916279315948,
0.3749263882637024,
-0.5650048851966858,
-0.3678898513317108,
0.7485772967338562,
0.23935900628566742,
-0.20112919807434082,
0.2703434228897095,
-0.05195214971899986,
-0.3739495277404785,
0.32644644379615784,
0.9525713324546814,
0.9851700663566589,
-0.6597504615783691,
-0.17189225554466248,
0.3422184884548187,
0.3488142490386963,
-0.2457270324230194,
0.07301197201013565,
-0.15786349773406982,
-0.8311842083930969,
-0.9976765513420105,
-0.585366427898407,
-0.2500961422920227,
-0.2636027932167053,
-0.6101077198982239,
0.03571190685033798,
0.09002747386693954,
0.3132295310497284,
-0.051975224167108536,
-0.33491814136505127,
-0.5578914880752563,
-0.056817952543497086,
0.3107355535030365,
0.9477418065071106,
-1.1275690793991089,
0.6285166144371033,
1.1175469160079956,
0.06440944224596024,
-0.9077975153923035,
0.03894620016217232,
-0.38687044382095337,
-0.7934588193893433,
0.3926634192466736,
-0.25810733437538147,
-0.09964588284492493,
0.17785410583019257,
0.1542765498161316,
-1.1541088819503784,
0.9363807439804077,
0.5679416060447693,
-0.8792836666107178,
-0.07432694733142853,
0.06538759917020798,
0.1940745860338211,
-0.3259953558444977,
-0.15372923016548157,
0.7161654829978943,
0.6765128374099731,
0.37700125575065613,
-1.3157718181610107,
0.45906564593315125,
-0.5136827230453491,
0.2132531851530075,
0.44797036051750183,
-0.3644130229949951,
0.5392032861709595,
0.030071960762143135,
-0.11507381498813629,
-0.25327521562576294,
0.5628633499145508,
-0.2107982039451599,
-0.03836914896965027,
0.9481605887413025,
0.6107143759727478,
0.1362033635377884,
0.06502501666545868,
0.7747551202774048,
-0.5702545642852783,
0.2466762810945511,
0.8333311676979065,
-0.3075506091117859,
0.9070111513137817,
0.49136725068092346,
-0.22791075706481934,
0.35333603620529175,
0.14596927165985107,
0.12830576300621033,
0.47821366786956787,
-0.23144195973873138,
-0.20793205499649048,
-0.36570706963539124,
-0.03123277798295021,
-0.24812079966068268,
0.47580641508102417,
-0.020615948364138603,
-0.2731684148311615,
-0.42217567563056946,
0.356381356716156,
0.0331258587539196,
-0.052727170288562775,
-0.3989686965942383,
0.9170339703559875,
-0.11538062989711761,
-1.0474218130111694,
0.7646544575691223,
-0.08575958013534546,
0.7352913022041321,
-0.6509982347488403,
-0.05554956942796707,
-0.010038742795586586,
0.4054188132286072,
-0.09581068158149719,
-0.8041568994522095,
0.6371524930000305,
-0.33292415738105774,
-0.03544262796640396,
-0.2566455006599426,
0.952591598033905,
-1.0143048763275146,
-0.6725307703018188,
0.5536566376686096,
0.7161847352981567,
-0.13342198729515076,
-0.018296340480446815,
-0.6289328336715698,
0.032368164509534836,
0.18366505205631256,
0.04618818312883377,
0.46241533756256104,
0.2855977714061737,
-0.060103677213191986,
0.2385328710079193,
0.6479343771934509,
0.2862448990345001,
0.009832441806793213,
-0.05120396241545677,
0.7306838631629944,
-0.39644595980644226,
-0.5897722244262695,
-0.5447797179222107,
0.3606817126274109,
0.1741759181022644,
-0.19592426717281342,
0.6090835332870483,
0.4366171658039093,
1.1423630714416504,
-0.054292548447847366,
0.9038639068603516,
-0.33269211649894714,
0.4098382890224457,
-0.4726131558418274,
0.6400753855705261,
-0.9408150315284729,
-0.11879982054233551,
-0.22160473465919495,
-1.1982921361923218,
-0.27075865864753723,
0.5500842928886414,
-0.20812343060970306,
0.03033914975821972,
0.7522964477539062,
0.46945708990097046,
-0.6585201621055603,
-0.4324570894241333,
0.3562237620353699,
0.16646696627140045,
0.05195401608943939,
0.9562548995018005,
0.45734357833862305,
-0.3993224501609802,
0.7830607295036316,
-0.2641527056694031,
-0.3284667730331421,
-0.21994905173778534,
-0.6979238390922546,
-0.8855254650115967,
-0.539146900177002,
-0.5296437740325928,
-0.2980116307735443,
0.27990350127220154,
0.7862309217453003,
0.7249144315719604,
-0.9030708074569702,
-0.22843945026397705,
-0.2030217945575714,
-0.038990121334791183,
-0.8388037085533142,
-0.19845739006996155,
0.3987126052379608,
-0.38974571228027344,
-1.1866092681884766,
0.5301182866096497,
0.3331667482852936,
0.0493256077170372,
-0.0451345331966877,
0.015155657194554806,
-0.28843703866004944,
0.05210474506020546,
0.5385250449180603,
0.5174313187599182,
-0.5556793808937073,
-0.41004976630210876,
-0.016066690906882286,
0.2485770583152771,
0.10101689398288727,
0.6819676756858826,
-0.6000152230262756,
0.5435140132904053,
0.6545571088790894,
0.9378212094306946,
0.43033063411712646,
-0.32626399397850037,
0.6902097463607788,
-0.629392683506012,
0.11488855630159378,
-0.1174352765083313,
0.536637008190155,
0.3342723846435547,
-0.162648007273674,
0.41741815209388733,
0.11461183428764343,
-0.3316790759563446,
-0.4658266007900238,
-0.00005586784754996188,
-1.2917609214782715,
-0.43326398730278015,
1.2462221384048462,
-0.10633192956447601,
-0.28529706597328186,
-0.17888829112052917,
-0.36992645263671875,
0.49407121539115906,
-0.0672401413321495,
0.7058220505714417,
0.651253342628479,
0.08190380036830902,
-0.44967278838157654,
-0.42016470432281494,
0.15835456550121307,
0.5807907581329346,
-0.8311580419540405,
0.024817440658807755,
0.043835680931806564,
0.6233685612678528,
0.45596808195114136,
0.2874552309513092,
0.08972229808568954,
0.5350713133811951,
-0.051447998732328415,
0.26463788747787476,
-0.029240349307656288,
-0.2474195957183838,
-0.30169612169265747,
0.06160479411482811,
0.08299156278371811,
-0.29512298107147217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18909v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18909v1
|
Updating Language Models with Unstructured Facts: Towards Practical Knowledge Editing
| 2024-02-29T07:08:34 | 2024-02-29T07:08:34 |
Xiaobao Wu, Liangming Pan, William Yang Wang, Anh Tuan Luu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge editing aims to inject knowledge updates into language models to
keep them correct and up-to-date. However, its current evaluation strategies
are notably impractical: they solely update with well-curated structured facts
(triplets with subjects, relations, and objects), whereas real-world knowledge
updates commonly emerge in unstructured texts like news articles. In this
paper, we propose a new benchmark, Unstructured Knowledge Editing (UKE). It
evaluates editing performance directly using unstructured texts as knowledge
updates, termed unstructured facts. Hence UKE avoids the laborious construction
of structured facts and enables efficient and responsive knowledge editing,
becoming a more practical benchmark. We conduct extensive experiments on newly
built datasets and demonstrate that UKE poses a significant challenge to
state-of-the-art knowledge editing methods, resulting in their critical
performance declines. We further show that this challenge persists even if we
extract triplets as structured facts. Our analysis discloses key insights to
motivate future research in UKE for more practical knowledge editing.
|
[
0.2156154215335846,
-0.6527620553970337,
0.7016602754592896,
-0.14331555366516113,
-0.26506635546684265,
0.3426327705383301,
-0.5636274814605713,
-0.33573850989341736,
-0.35235098004341125,
0.46806520223617554,
-0.24161840975284576,
-0.6683851480484009,
-0.3070675730705261,
0.049899376928806305,
-0.3086020052433014,
0.6899265646934509,
-0.18472667038440704,
-0.33230820298194885,
-0.48991209268569946,
-0.3473663330078125,
-0.5630707740783691,
-0.5321840047836304,
-0.21065647900104523,
-0.1350921392440796,
0.1363113969564438,
0.5353063344955444,
0.7474155426025391,
0.6802186965942383,
0.28367993235588074,
0.406021386384964,
-0.513102650642395,
0.4589376747608185,
-0.4264369606971741,
0.04919926077127457,
-0.20963582396507263,
-0.2398727983236313,
-0.3362468183040619,
0.1276903748512268,
0.6184256076812744,
1.1498560905456543,
-0.22755800187587738,
0.09702727943658829,
0.1871037483215332,
0.849334716796875,
-0.601716160774231,
0.2846694588661194,
-0.5633628964424133,
-0.10233514755964279,
-0.28075072169303894,
0.06426379829645157,
-0.37231147289276123,
-0.36383527517318726,
0.04949174448847771,
-0.6890090107917786,
-0.05871756002306938,
-0.13227373361587524,
0.4656268358230591,
0.236934632062912,
-0.3039981722831726,
-0.09154729545116425,
-0.6461118459701538,
0.4375632703304291,
-0.6545546054840088,
0.6821832656860352,
-0.16608840227127075,
0.10482992976903915,
-0.497994601726532,
-0.8685128092765808,
-0.520586371421814,
-0.1638115793466568,
-0.06264089047908783,
-0.055497024208307266,
-0.2749462425708771,
-0.06733989715576172,
0.2634405195713043,
0.20274288952350616,
0.00890504289418459,
0.0054337866604328156,
-0.4827839136123657,
-0.054161716252565384,
0.5692917108535767,
-0.17490211129188538,
0.2007945328950882,
-0.3006258010864258,
-0.13025712966918945,
-0.04193931818008423,
-0.6096081733703613,
0.28250861167907715,
0.27737942337989807,
0.06867604702711105,
0.23621869087219238,
0.6700202822685242,
-0.4589981436729431,
0.5861558318138123,
-0.16090306639671326,
-0.3072454333305359,
0.28915753960609436,
-0.19531556963920593,
-0.24911558628082275,
-0.12376019358634949,
0.7878603339195251,
0.6193402409553528,
0.3588448762893677,
-0.5659105181694031,
-0.12207023054361343,
-0.07126997411251068,
0.19196078181266785,
-0.5119218230247498,
-0.22406478226184845,
0.022858913987874985,
-0.13983581960201263,
-0.46858352422714233,
0.03836003690958023,
-0.691620945930481,
-0.4582732617855072,
0.0018640728667378426,
0.24715718626976013,
-0.47346290946006775,
0.15411251783370972,
0.4292850196361542,
-0.20074722170829773,
-0.4479336440563202,
0.60579514503479,
-0.5064209699630737,
0.12512806057929993,
0.48098739981651306,
0.6060853600502014,
0.0634770616889,
-0.31031328439712524,
-0.04363439604640007,
0.1602817177772522,
-0.36102211475372314,
1.2227647304534912,
-0.5396915078163147,
-0.3768466114997864,
-0.23059487342834473,
-0.2000986933708191,
0.04912145435810089,
-0.36660799384117126,
0.7641213536262512,
-0.5338461995124817,
0.3011111915111542,
-0.33649030327796936,
-0.7948371767997742,
-0.3077520728111267,
0.06608845293521881,
-0.54554283618927,
1.3381975889205933,
0.24440205097198486,
-0.7013967633247375,
0.5976735949516296,
-1.0113775730133057,
-0.28631269931793213,
-0.045945893973112106,
0.08647019416093826,
-0.16241449117660522,
0.18457280099391937,
0.16927476227283478,
0.2764907479286194,
-0.2394130975008011,
0.5395523905754089,
-0.2990545928478241,
-0.2719089090824127,
0.38813138008117676,
-0.4339509606361389,
0.5012035369873047,
-0.0498608835041523,
-0.023512404412031174,
0.1344469040632248,
-1.0188320875167847,
-0.10371722280979156,
-0.16492320597171783,
-0.5991344451904297,
-0.3798771798610687,
0.3109667897224426,
-0.24551089107990265,
0.14860564470291138,
0.0340144969522953,
-0.975272536277771,
0.5794911980628967,
-0.13304351270198822,
0.4252403974533081,
0.781424880027771,
0.07922395318746567,
0.2861536145210266,
-0.3910082280635834,
0.08229205012321472,
-0.06782881915569305,
0.1999371498823166,
0.23467062413692474,
-0.5437635183334351,
-0.37317004799842834,
-0.2667543888092041,
0.8307286500930786,
0.4898325800895691,
-0.6574313044548035,
0.15327797830104828,
-0.5213043093681335,
-0.49413710832595825,
-0.6954255700111389,
0.3444039225578308,
0.19202035665512085,
0.8345420360565186,
0.42501556873321533,
-0.13146336376667023,
-0.6086456179618835,
-0.7349720001220703,
-0.8079423904418945,
-0.10509466379880905,
-0.20264555513858795,
0.08477818965911865,
0.2811400592327118,
-0.07850611209869385,
1.0693440437316895,
-0.5057541728019714,
0.028458911925554276,
-0.08054459095001221,
0.3913179337978363,
0.11121934652328491,
0.29910972714424133,
0.14951790869235992,
-0.5067640542984009,
-0.32561972737312317,
0.09970510751008987,
-0.849776566028595,
-0.3196270167827606,
0.01927967183291912,
0.2817562520503998,
0.2795827388763428,
0.621909499168396,
-0.5720614194869995,
0.42248183488845825,
0.2287396639585495,
-0.3678137958049774,
0.42021822929382324,
-0.2836754620075226,
0.501214325428009,
-0.7387661933898926,
0.13503752648830414,
-0.24830199778079987,
-0.27999186515808105,
-0.5781977772712708,
0.01014733500778675,
0.2789057493209839,
0.028037486597895622,
-0.6782010793685913,
0.4754999577999115,
-0.4678175747394562,
0.1421619951725006,
0.1663096696138382,
0.22719767689704895,
0.01989162154495716,
0.5200273394584656,
-0.07765807956457138,
0.76227867603302,
0.22767415642738342,
-0.3815448582172394,
0.31273216009140015,
0.23347774147987366,
-0.8375238180160522,
0.2467011660337448,
-0.43151265382766724,
0.31615352630615234,
-0.12699218094348907,
0.035004276782274246,
-0.5069546699523926,
-0.025605935603380203,
-0.19178064167499542,
-0.10624008625745773,
0.23337218165397644,
-0.21787221729755402,
-0.6601701378822327,
-0.2111908346414566,
-0.7166669964790344,
0.13439911603927612,
0.4536742866039276,
-0.4358128607273102,
0.34515148401260376,
0.55900639295578,
-0.07619764655828476,
-0.5372351408004761,
-0.4142434000968933,
0.22360800206661224,
0.018437638878822327,
-0.791655957698822,
0.366106778383255,
-0.1124386414885521,
-0.5616967082023621,
0.35715624690055847,
-0.41433459520339966,
-0.05450858920812607,
0.25694209337234497,
-0.17915627360343933,
0.04105338454246521,
-0.09929051995277405,
-0.05277582257986069,
-0.001032232423312962,
-0.03799563646316528,
-0.18026654422283173,
-0.18592749536037445,
-0.15597309172153473,
-0.002752777887508273,
-0.1003253161907196,
-0.3246414363384247,
0.05532911792397499,
0.6924968361854553,
-0.005937650799751282,
0.5630385279655457,
0.150448739528656,
-0.38220885396003723,
-0.1116054430603981,
-0.6838716268539429,
0.18061544001102448,
-0.4778105914592743,
0.3387798070907593,
-0.4561340808868408,
-0.9022523164749146,
0.2792561948299408,
-0.5491053462028503,
0.2611216902732849,
0.46238774061203003,
0.06999717652797699,
-0.3786959648132324,
0.739066481590271,
0.5836084485054016,
0.37958040833473206,
0.07802349328994751,
0.005356177221983671,
0.24748729169368744,
-0.9664245843887329,
-0.37876853346824646,
-0.5355374813079834,
-0.12932923436164856,
-0.7436415553092957,
-0.6109266877174377,
0.6080589890480042,
0.4216817617416382,
0.21600352227687836,
0.26521387696266174,
-0.31096670031547546,
0.6887415647506714,
0.28552189469337463,
0.0050648716278374195,
0.6604212522506714,
-0.36248987913131714,
-0.23560059070587158,
-0.058575134724378586,
-0.7693329453468323,
-0.6528539657592773,
1.2812048196792603,
0.023759251460433006,
0.47407054901123047,
0.24965623021125793,
0.1978129893541336,
0.5450816750526428,
0.3926663398742676,
-0.5337488055229187,
0.4881221055984497,
-0.31926944851875305,
-0.2753428816795349,
-0.4238545298576355,
-0.47369587421417236,
-0.6000275015830994,
0.2595902383327484,
-0.3343632221221924,
-0.7521084547042847,
0.1898012012243271,
0.09395506232976913,
-0.27299439907073975,
0.6718244552612305,
-0.7719283103942871,
0.9417908787727356,
0.13712938129901886,
-0.31191280484199524,
-0.02653774619102478,
-0.29404690861701965,
0.228631392121315,
-0.20651838183403015,
0.61932772397995,
-0.04864615201950073,
0.05646052211523056,
0.849673330783844,
-0.5766482949256897,
0.5770093202590942,
-0.19588056206703186,
0.08178097754716873,
0.21997511386871338,
0.08291955292224884,
0.5239347219467163,
0.24922597408294678,
-0.2638125419616699,
0.23529046773910522,
0.1728353351354599,
-0.3407290577888489,
-0.9642907977104187,
0.4849048852920532,
-0.5238763689994812,
-0.5421625375747681,
-0.44452691078186035,
-0.7232643365859985,
-0.6632429957389832,
0.2236936241388321,
-0.1217695027589798,
0.6345095634460449,
-0.4015895128250122,
0.4272279143333435,
0.5091391205787659,
-0.04639063775539398,
0.4327964186668396,
0.6924329996109009,
0.016849439591169357,
-0.18606655299663544,
0.4583470821380615,
0.40468519926071167,
0.07328048348426819,
0.48233136534690857,
0.3969585597515106,
-0.4677159786224365,
-0.8822896480560303,
-0.6700177192687988,
-0.05456218123435974,
-0.5914004445075989,
-0.17848671972751617,
-0.7260216474533081,
0.11042730510234833,
-0.3940257430076599,
-0.25205567479133606,
-0.490947961807251,
-0.9256536364555359,
0.151783749461174,
-0.07608125358819962,
0.5364755988121033,
1.0862771272659302,
-0.3491474986076355,
0.0003350453625898808,
-0.7195830345153809,
0.3486696183681488,
0.40907007455825806,
0.7102317214012146,
-0.4513259530067444,
-0.47601109743118286,
-0.123481385409832,
0.16016307473182678,
-0.14225903153419495,
-0.8567201495170593,
-0.22132869064807892,
0.0604059062898159,
0.38494715094566345,
-0.1369987279176712,
0.08371127396821976,
0.8142303228378296,
-0.5763562321662903,
0.5730190277099609,
-0.3149257004261017,
-1.0118623971939087,
0.2751372754573822,
-0.3667225241661072,
0.19301210343837738,
0.8260198831558228,
-0.03060942143201828,
-0.8096487522125244,
-0.22221282124519348,
-0.665325403213501,
-0.5821504592895508,
0.6989501118659973,
0.14652734994888306,
-0.13388559222221375,
0.2961723804473877,
0.5517477989196777,
0.05100454017519951,
0.48911774158477783,
-0.5238757133483887,
-0.08353958278894424,
-0.17527037858963013,
-0.051367681473493576,
0.1889650672674179,
-0.5070855021476746,
0.17495422065258026,
-0.5119991302490234,
0.9056063294410706,
-0.018092170357704163,
-0.16987594962120056,
0.24687767028808594,
-0.45922550559043884,
-0.07531185448169708,
0.6145384907722473,
0.39995893836021423,
0.6512103080749512,
-0.6361887454986572,
-0.04560847580432892,
0.36535847187042236,
-0.30894923210144043,
-0.0889173299074173,
0.061817485839128494,
-0.5237380266189575,
-0.1779835969209671,
0.5114218592643738,
0.6394187211990356,
0.9261380434036255,
-0.6841861009597778,
0.4081750214099884,
-0.1572992503643036,
-0.2299790382385254,
0.23575769364833832,
0.025536902248859406,
0.03330292925238609,
-0.15514859557151794,
0.00029079525847919285,
0.43968862295150757,
0.10836201906204224,
-0.7504131197929382,
0.23779655992984772,
0.11194470524787903,
-0.2375265657901764,
-0.3268080949783325,
0.405292809009552,
0.20635882019996643,
-0.13194477558135986,
0.4235566556453705,
-0.3595254123210907,
-0.36976903676986694,
0.01204285491257906,
0.2495115101337433,
0.6004139184951782,
-0.10604257881641388,
0.2929745018482208,
0.1151113286614418,
0.4590793251991272,
-0.11307653784751892,
0.2323962301015854,
0.030418159440159798,
-0.7419875264167786,
-0.5503800511360168,
-0.6050437688827515,
-0.5408863425254822,
0.3135888874530792,
-0.36922308802604675,
0.16828429698944092,
-0.2579871714115143,
0.3728829324245453,
0.11242808401584625,
0.1532672643661499,
-0.4861210882663727,
0.10119908303022385,
-0.3379465639591217,
1.1078177690505981,
-0.670170247554779,
0.859470009803772,
0.8414720892906189,
-0.034085698425769806,
-0.7085126042366028,
-0.2934902310371399,
0.22676172852516174,
-0.3175837993621826,
-0.07985280454158783,
-0.14594824612140656,
-0.08189837634563446,
-0.06686607003211975,
-0.2681742012500763,
-0.7917309403419495,
0.8874139189720154,
0.503386914730072,
-0.3247801661491394,
0.05919314920902252,
0.21087737381458282,
0.5661813020706177,
-0.01388353668153286,
0.23080068826675415,
0.7838364839553833,
0.8334558010101318,
0.01644647680222988,
-0.7723845839500427,
-0.07810144126415253,
-0.4578346610069275,
-0.08132923394441605,
0.2537759840488434,
-0.49914711713790894,
0.7459443211555481,
-0.1691516637802124,
-0.3660915493965149,
-0.21860577166080475,
0.5650174617767334,
-0.33045849204063416,
-0.09164096415042877,
0.5238244533538818,
0.7898330688476562,
0.9127508997917175,
0.0021977038122713566,
0.9196100234985352,
-0.17301784455776215,
0.2538531422615051,
1.1543982028961182,
-0.43667206168174744,
0.6881279945373535,
0.21415820717811584,
-0.15220820903778076,
0.7678816318511963,
0.2913532555103302,
-0.008029279299080372,
0.3983903229236603,
-0.12393136322498322,
-0.2324133813381195,
-0.03352450951933861,
-0.13328781723976135,
-0.030144644901156425,
0.8550676107406616,
0.024802273139357567,
0.37029552459716797,
-0.4088255763053894,
-0.2726651728153229,
0.5857915878295898,
0.5614526867866516,
-0.05190743878483772,
0.8424022197723389,
-0.376154363155365,
-0.7050566077232361,
0.41939398646354675,
0.42992088198661804,
0.38020119071006775,
-0.4797140657901764,
-0.09870433062314987,
-0.15724827349185944,
-0.009368253871798515,
-0.15333545207977295,
-0.8836343288421631,
0.44187623262405396,
0.5486359596252441,
-0.22595807909965515,
-0.3064563572406769,
0.6370168924331665,
-0.344083696603775,
-0.6385493278503418,
0.23735648393630981,
0.549912691116333,
-0.19919545948505402,
-0.15129868686199188,
-0.5846566557884216,
-0.021132074296474457,
0.03916805610060692,
-0.38888052105903625,
0.2814502418041229,
0.7670302391052246,
-0.2439415603876114,
0.4891979694366455,
1.0535818338394165,
0.1022786870598793,
-0.21784937381744385,
0.0641208067536354,
0.8904611468315125,
-0.7569683194160461,
-0.3933444619178772,
-0.7425273656845093,
0.7421050071716309,
-0.32681238651275635,
-0.32067689299583435,
0.6790145039558411,
0.641498327255249,
0.8450944423675537,
0.11248467117547989,
0.8271291851997375,
-0.1509527862071991,
0.6030612587928772,
-0.7108954191207886,
0.8062459230422974,
-0.3891962170600891,
0.34723201394081116,
-0.31448736786842346,
-0.6248296499252319,
-0.4068661332130432,
0.08111505955457687,
-0.09599708765745163,
-0.1673043668270111,
1.0299193859100342,
0.6913639903068542,
-0.09492194652557373,
0.34971898794174194,
0.3732806444168091,
0.7495359778404236,
0.1153009682893753,
0.21243418753147125,
0.6410887837409973,
-0.42735543847084045,
0.19567517936229706,
-0.7960308194160461,
-0.3728793263435364,
0.23478193581104279,
-1.2038558721542358,
-0.8986992239952087,
-0.522466242313385,
-0.33180180191993713,
0.057886041700839996,
0.3415619432926178,
0.8383485078811646,
0.4585951864719391,
-0.665854275226593,
-0.12156070023775101,
0.1263367235660553,
0.33692044019699097,
-0.39419978857040405,
-0.1373981088399887,
0.660553514957428,
-0.11743873357772827,
-0.3737541735172272,
0.9469032883644104,
0.4416016936302185,
-0.2835794687271118,
0.3007573187351227,
0.39058414101600647,
-0.5298860669136047,
0.21840564906597137,
0.6716098785400391,
0.2498554289340973,
-0.34459632635116577,
-0.56391841173172,
-0.22909152507781982,
0.24354210495948792,
0.20265567302703857,
0.8945589065551758,
-0.9644982814788818,
0.4500526487827301,
0.35644298791885376,
0.5066453218460083,
0.18302187323570251,
0.1412176638841629,
0.4088013768196106,
-0.8748933672904968,
0.045240066945552826,
-0.11472035199403763,
0.47584304213523865,
0.6679115891456604,
-0.23314087092876434,
0.5482448935508728,
0.5970968008041382,
-0.4259989261627197,
-0.9983753561973572,
-0.18154267966747284,
-0.8215129971504211,
-0.40098774433135986,
1.0256550312042236,
-0.18323977291584015,
-0.5236107110977173,
-0.4349553883075714,
-0.027593648061156273,
0.3087824881076813,
-0.3143850862979889,
0.8872367143630981,
0.6911221146583557,
-0.014951975084841251,
0.19162945449352264,
-0.5312840342521667,
0.7611804604530334,
0.1999923437833786,
-0.888608992099762,
0.4208865165710449,
0.5671693086624146,
0.4061054587364197,
-0.10882151126861572,
0.5185829401016235,
-0.2480400651693344,
0.4055797755718231,
-0.14956167340278625,
0.27688175439834595,
-0.4871883690357208,
-0.39891403913497925,
-0.1583530455827713,
0.2826246917247772,
0.09307008981704712,
0.23768894374370575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00037v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00037v1
|
Evolving to the Future: Unseen Event Adaptive Fake News Detection on Social Media
| 2024-02-29T06:40:53 | 2024-02-29T06:40:53 |
Jiajun Zhang, Zhixun Li, Qiang Liu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the rapid development of social media, the wide dissemination of fake
news on social media is increasingly threatening both individuals and society.
In the dynamic landscape of social media, fake news detection aims to develop a
model trained on news reporting past events. The objective is to predict and
identify fake news about future events, which often relate to subjects entirely
different from those in the past. However, existing fake detection methods
exhibit a lack of robustness and cannot generalize to unseen events. To address
this, we introduce Future ADaptive Event-based Fake news Detection (FADE)
framework. Specifically, we train a target predictor through an adaptive
augmentation strategy and graph contrastive learning to make more robust
overall predictions. Simultaneously, we independently train an event-only
predictor to obtain biased predictions. Then we further mitigate event bias by
obtaining the final prediction by subtracting the output of the event-only
predictor from the output of the target predictor. Encouraging results from
experiments designed to emulate real-world social media conditions validate the
effectiveness of our method in comparison to existing state-of-the-art
approaches.
|
[
-0.2879970967769623,
-1.1141995191574097,
0.6236148476600647,
0.15251481533050537,
-0.3518439531326294,
0.5980936288833618,
0.42769041657447815,
-0.7607883214950562,
0.7699841260910034,
0.23084083199501038,
-0.9189471006393433,
-0.2875601351261139,
-0.5464814901351929,
-0.43938225507736206,
-0.763870120048523,
0.6667308807373047,
0.05327240005135536,
-0.09183767437934875,
-0.08873195201158524,
-0.22256077826023102,
-0.3502981662750244,
-0.20038393139839172,
-0.9034534692764282,
-0.0474105067551136,
0.29879891872406006,
0.3738856017589569,
0.7055104374885559,
0.40521863102912903,
-0.013616552576422691,
0.2728090286254883,
-0.06606343388557434,
0.23674003779888153,
-0.6433695554733276,
-0.034987445920705795,
-0.21349753439426422,
-0.08383416384458542,
-0.41410064697265625,
0.18209390342235565,
0.5298396944999695,
0.3163634240627289,
0.32431355118751526,
0.012988348491489887,
-0.17204394936561584,
0.585164487361908,
-0.8075910806655884,
-0.38011831045150757,
-0.7536665201187134,
0.1052069291472435,
-0.04307383671402931,
-0.2953287959098816,
-0.26185524463653564,
-0.47125282883644104,
-0.30398038029670715,
-0.7903745174407959,
0.3846033811569214,
-0.0998704805970192,
0.8538103103637695,
-0.1264762282371521,
-0.298610657453537,
-0.04834561049938202,
-0.8422238826751709,
0.5571463704109192,
-0.492155522108078,
0.5448195934295654,
0.20186752080917358,
0.49429094791412354,
-0.08300771564245224,
-1.0034786462783813,
-0.7407934069633484,
-0.016803154721856117,
0.2751011848449707,
0.4786927402019501,
-0.3722406029701233,
-0.4239618480205536,
-0.11580895632505417,
0.2462819665670395,
-0.5402482151985168,
0.1205517128109932,
-0.4042437970638275,
-0.34679585695266724,
0.5292810797691345,
-0.20520277321338654,
0.22429165244102478,
0.0308733768761158,
-0.36973774433135986,
0.18759872019290924,
-0.2757522761821747,
-0.3194248080253601,
0.6123498678207397,
0.0674426332116127,
-0.32574161887168884,
0.16539831459522247,
-0.45359697937965393,
0.329912006855011,
0.38947758078575134,
0.026206964626908302,
0.34000033140182495,
0.04613163694739342,
-0.10522644221782684,
-0.059550873935222626,
0.43813154101371765,
0.5974332690238953,
0.054661642760038376,
0.025992311537265778,
-0.14434020221233368,
0.19196340441703796,
0.28087615966796875,
-0.5240490436553955,
-0.3801248371601105,
0.09697042405605316,
-0.5904144048690796,
-0.7725738286972046,
-0.08242694288492203,
-1.0154500007629395,
-0.7452459931373596,
-0.08289402723312378,
0.7251023054122925,
-0.4417873024940491,
-0.3739627003669739,
-0.2961544692516327,
-0.4156891107559204,
0.1785067915916443,
0.6126477122306824,
-0.23923259973526,
0.033700477331876755,
0.4819355607032776,
0.9129412770271301,
-0.11301572620868683,
-0.1839299499988556,
-0.8249288201332092,
-0.0031732292845845222,
-0.6619120836257935,
0.9011573195457458,
-0.5276778936386108,
-0.1524917036294937,
0.1115151196718216,
0.03952743113040924,
0.2388894259929657,
-0.2910795211791992,
0.6458478569984436,
-0.9520078897476196,
0.1588854193687439,
-0.08147095888853073,
-0.4465647041797638,
-0.32232773303985596,
0.17733129858970642,
-0.6725708246231079,
0.748943030834198,
0.24305514991283417,
-0.655759871006012,
0.6837224960327148,
-0.65602046251297,
-0.57253497838974,
0.20628748834133148,
0.3662106990814209,
-0.771551787853241,
0.37347733974456787,
0.5506911873817444,
0.2656952142715454,
0.7620871663093567,
-0.1161942407488823,
-1.0234490633010864,
-0.5153797268867493,
0.25521308183670044,
-0.7897114753723145,
0.5209535360336304,
-0.011657103896141052,
-0.35630425810813904,
0.267527312040329,
-0.8964943289756775,
-0.27776628732681274,
0.2295064926147461,
-0.029042638838291168,
-0.1833028793334961,
0.12342090159654617,
0.09259770065546036,
0.22641697525978088,
-0.018617000430822372,
-0.44742539525032043,
-0.25981423258781433,
-0.16990594565868378,
0.2210639864206314,
1.2433629035949707,
0.3626791536808014,
0.6574657559394836,
-0.4348907172679901,
0.47397300601005554,
0.07208407670259476,
0.5666013956069946,
-0.3972107172012329,
-0.3335847854614258,
-0.9854021668434143,
-0.11404435336589813,
0.22980137169361115,
0.39147740602493286,
-1.0553313493728638,
0.13471859693527222,
-0.16793054342269897,
-0.2454298734664917,
-0.20818884670734406,
-0.15306295454502106,
-0.05895300209522247,
0.3783797323703766,
0.47685515880584717,
-0.09839990735054016,
-0.6932991147041321,
-0.4876282811164856,
-0.7372457981109619,
-0.06255237758159637,
0.2086251825094223,
-0.047665275633335114,
0.425743967294693,
-0.2628100514411926,
0.8140450716018677,
-0.1315469741821289,
-0.1598552167415619,
-0.06093189865350723,
-0.025186529383063316,
-0.13505405187606812,
0.4367305338382721,
0.48376238346099854,
-1.3525985479354858,
-0.5537203550338745,
0.007939866743981838,
-0.6162568926811218,
0.02788051776587963,
-0.33439934253692627,
0.009951277635991573,
0.36397063732147217,
0.8531583547592163,
-0.21970348060131073,
0.7558625936508179,
0.7714526057243347,
-0.3360157310962677,
0.43232178688049316,
0.21061600744724274,
0.2891347408294678,
-1.0085995197296143,
-0.32729482650756836,
-0.028551479801535606,
-0.7858441472053528,
-0.7873982191085815,
-0.20060549676418304,
0.12491396814584732,
-0.29103171825408936,
-0.5871701240539551,
0.9220626354217529,
-0.3783062696456909,
-0.13606685400009155,
-0.542294442653656,
0.07202599197626114,
0.01789228245615959,
0.07457542419433594,
-0.19348594546318054,
0.27436354756355286,
0.5984718799591064,
-0.6373472809791565,
0.36381080746650696,
-0.2829427123069763,
-0.24512216448783875,
0.6206647157669067,
-0.2807408273220062,
0.20127476751804352,
-0.26383471488952637,
0.42651358246803284,
-0.8978205919265747,
-0.4059445261955261,
0.613418459892273,
-1.1033847332000732,
0.3608644902706146,
-0.279277503490448,
-0.3890090584754944,
-0.6244124174118042,
-0.43539080023765564,
0.12018808722496033,
0.5693111419677734,
-0.6432293057441711,
0.9912552833557129,
0.18123342096805573,
-0.007882995530962944,
-0.5143656730651855,
-0.6120302081108093,
0.17229880392551422,
-0.13009563088417053,
-0.47203513979911804,
0.41535651683807373,
-0.12848684191703796,
-0.24267250299453735,
0.3372162878513336,
-0.5635676980018616,
-0.05794354900717735,
0.05543904006481171,
0.26081758737564087,
0.20866659283638,
-0.18895132839679718,
0.05146542936563492,
0.3451007306575775,
0.053670644760131836,
-0.335078626871109,
-0.4337439239025116,
0.39093640446662903,
0.17273104190826416,
-0.5806892514228821,
-0.7255411744117737,
0.4320705831050873,
0.7221086621284485,
-0.0011418148642405868,
0.8920254707336426,
0.8530546426773071,
-0.8453251719474792,
-0.32114192843437195,
-0.8194929361343384,
-0.26253604888916016,
-0.5788936614990234,
0.4524647295475006,
0.11568624526262283,
-0.6328433752059937,
0.7380265593528748,
-0.16746288537979126,
-0.04459794983267784,
0.379465788602829,
0.143708735704422,
-0.2158849984407425,
0.901713490486145,
0.9467442035675049,
-0.07025637477636337,
0.8813062310218811,
0.023300841450691223,
-0.06731488555669785,
-0.35212939977645874,
-0.17940497398376465,
0.17235876619815826,
-0.37267476320266724,
-0.5110452771186829,
-0.5040051341056824,
0.06472407281398773,
0.3031143248081207,
0.004021254368126392,
0.10082072764635086,
-0.14300814270973206,
0.6948084831237793,
0.4288133382797241,
0.5053493976593018,
0.21506308019161224,
0.10544820129871368,
0.4397551119327545,
0.06922800838947296,
-0.6110215187072754,
0.0405542366206646,
0.8940041065216064,
0.2679746150970459,
0.48996439576148987,
-0.20851095020771027,
0.46769800782203674,
0.9287413954734802,
0.7708046436309814,
-0.5467379093170166,
0.3804907500743866,
-0.05365843325853348,
-0.6027066111564636,
-0.14411848783493042,
-0.3352988064289093,
-0.585706889629364,
0.14173153042793274,
-0.29244086146354675,
-0.3776431381702423,
0.42043742537498474,
0.325296014547348,
-0.10080187767744064,
0.5677703022956848,
-0.5076575875282288,
0.5337725877761841,
-0.19145075976848602,
-0.30093055963516235,
-0.35444286465644836,
-0.5370700359344482,
0.33341240882873535,
-0.5222055315971375,
0.6421856880187988,
-0.1443115472793579,
-0.07110464572906494,
0.5385061502456665,
-0.03814079612493515,
1.1565719842910767,
-0.3146009147167206,
0.4351467490196228,
0.23267485201358795,
0.17355303466320038,
0.6736317276954651,
0.13831013441085815,
0.09724095463752747,
-0.03271894156932831,
-0.5694762468338013,
-0.7300436496734619,
-0.28093138337135315,
0.7832486629486084,
-0.3945296108722687,
-0.2647457420825958,
-0.4000036418437958,
-0.25887995958328247,
-0.28442028164863586,
0.4676564633846283,
0.458992063999176,
0.3493317663669586,
-0.5072727799415588,
-0.07603566348552704,
0.5649268627166748,
-0.37663698196411133,
0.6231005787849426,
0.6480690836906433,
-0.3115541338920593,
-0.6294400095939636,
0.9967589974403381,
0.16252821683883667,
0.27475643157958984,
0.21617209911346436,
0.11989051848649979,
-0.158013716340065,
-0.756477952003479,
-0.12444841861724854,
0.039255741983652115,
-0.9281873106956482,
-0.30034464597702026,
-0.5741441249847412,
-0.23189842700958252,
-0.7286611795425415,
-0.6932038068771362,
-0.36017757654190063,
-0.15936416387557983,
-0.6588703393936157,
-0.27913525700569153,
0.3269452750682831,
0.5134003758430481,
-0.43608036637306213,
0.4341381788253784,
-0.5874969959259033,
0.6480135321617126,
0.3776034414768219,
0.2733670771121979,
-0.25876274704933167,
-0.910311758518219,
-0.04841256141662598,
0.20124980807304382,
-0.5559764504432678,
-0.9610746502876282,
0.5334875583648682,
0.2623017430305481,
0.5937933921813965,
0.5544920563697815,
0.3226225972175598,
0.6448944211006165,
-0.28288525342941284,
0.5611094236373901,
0.25893455743789673,
-0.996458113193512,
0.7446355819702148,
-0.5311083197593689,
0.042312681674957275,
0.33344998955726624,
0.4921117126941681,
-0.475884348154068,
-0.5054820775985718,
-0.9009878039360046,
-0.7119308114051819,
0.5414593815803528,
0.08700219541788101,
0.630698561668396,
0.21957193315029144,
0.3874821364879608,
0.10536155849695206,
0.16686950623989105,
-1.2148176431655884,
-0.17726469039916992,
-0.41799259185791016,
0.07878363132476807,
-0.06879758834838867,
-0.16723249852657318,
0.18621239066123962,
-0.06275539100170135,
0.7763679623603821,
-0.2194768786430359,
0.2557498812675476,
-0.03373807668685913,
-0.13534781336784363,
-0.33709824085235596,
-0.1975080817937851,
0.6754453182220459,
0.8431669473648071,
-0.13620050251483917,
-0.21303461492061615,
0.3132208287715912,
-0.38786792755126953,
-0.24214962124824524,
0.2179703265428543,
-0.28860342502593994,
0.21173366904258728,
0.49450138211250305,
0.8367225527763367,
0.017939331009984016,
-0.3896990120410919,
0.7600527405738831,
0.25441786646842957,
-0.2329527735710144,
-0.6432022452354431,
-0.13741840422153473,
-0.019787093624472618,
0.5728425979614258,
0.972472071647644,
0.5729913711547852,
0.13500218093395233,
-0.8912830948829651,
0.47369590401649475,
0.19315588474273682,
-0.9887403845787048,
-0.4284496307373047,
0.878599226474762,
0.08667473495006561,
-0.3754390776157379,
0.21307165920734406,
-0.31239035725593567,
-0.7575980424880981,
0.6021401286125183,
0.511929452419281,
0.8340538740158081,
-0.4178408086299896,
0.40897512435913086,
-0.07787777483463287,
0.40700554847717285,
0.09086966514587402,
0.19021889567375183,
0.36493155360221863,
-0.7620418667793274,
-0.37685781717300415,
-0.7091788053512573,
-0.2512010335922241,
0.6363872289657593,
-0.30572912096977234,
0.46850261092185974,
-0.42659491300582886,
-0.12633973360061646,
0.023660821840167046,
-0.17066068947315216,
-0.1397974193096161,
0.45125725865364075,
0.2486562728881836,
0.7902782559394836,
-1.0957825183868408,
0.5505801439285278,
0.37370389699935913,
-0.011347051709890366,
-0.14436320960521698,
0.6037497520446777,
0.33842745423316956,
-0.7155128717422485,
0.14840850234031677,
0.22545906901359558,
0.1467989981174469,
0.035582296550273895,
-0.6956037282943726,
-0.6573830246925354,
0.9023817777633667,
0.5562427639961243,
-0.3192765712738037,
0.05443672090768814,
-0.36962997913360596,
0.41789141297340393,
-0.11875452101230621,
-0.19782190024852753,
-0.02240787260234356,
0.4044972062110901,
0.4294951558113098,
-0.28971925377845764,
-0.16511699557304382,
-0.05950532481074333,
-0.13867135345935822,
0.06639569997787476,
-0.7015151381492615,
0.7899507880210876,
-0.1888442039489746,
-0.5200897455215454,
0.05307464301586151,
1.1214613914489746,
0.04131557419896126,
0.9869875907897949,
0.3068307936191559,
0.2566147744655609,
0.6490125060081482,
-0.07726798206567764,
0.915989875793457,
0.12870298326015472,
0.10045573860406876,
1.0780227184295654,
-0.039731137454509735,
0.5490646958351135,
0.026275373995304108,
0.10093206912279129,
0.6507301330566406,
0.9183158278465271,
-0.17670650780200958,
0.6626416444778442,
-0.16282953321933746,
-0.35415396094322205,
-0.32727497816085815,
0.20347906649112701,
-0.4189436733722687,
0.16922599077224731,
0.4448834955692291,
-0.4429772198200226,
0.04221328720450401,
0.41619303822517395,
0.021242961287498474,
0.1412656456232071,
-0.8208341598510742,
0.3621217906475067,
-0.09565049409866333,
-0.10980682075023651,
0.2936457395553589,
0.013622986152768135,
0.7840279340744019,
-0.4418538212776184,
0.0021342658437788486,
-0.4893813729286194,
0.3117559552192688,
-0.19580848515033722,
-0.5111298561096191,
0.3832739293575287,
-0.4188338816165924,
-0.06707117706537247,
-0.038831133395433426,
1.309151530265808,
-0.09401808679103851,
-0.6490159034729004,
0.4053170084953308,
0.49364420771598816,
-0.18689914047718048,
-0.43626081943511963,
-0.7955753803253174,
0.10766100883483887,
-0.17723268270492554,
-0.17082098126411438,
0.34430912137031555,
0.36566707491874695,
-0.17818938195705414,
0.7834525108337402,
0.9239793419837952,
-0.042442239820957184,
0.2999904155731201,
-0.058805543929338455,
0.9863786101341248,
-0.3371504545211792,
-0.7289411425590515,
-0.7329835295677185,
0.30736419558525085,
-0.42879655957221985,
-0.03956110030412674,
0.7729197144508362,
0.6094253063201904,
0.7499325275421143,
-0.06501537561416626,
0.7132303714752197,
0.2074572890996933,
0.6437562704086304,
-0.33995506167411804,
0.775164008140564,
-0.8089220523834229,
-0.06172956898808479,
-0.3823598325252533,
-0.7385149598121643,
-0.22054177522659302,
0.1554093211889267,
0.06996317952871323,
0.36938437819480896,
0.38804376125335693,
0.504459023475647,
-0.21653863787651062,
-0.16424934566020966,
0.507108211517334,
0.1208638995885849,
0.1289130598306656,
0.04245365411043167,
1.0490751266479492,
-0.5309152603149414,
0.5914759635925293,
-0.13108757138252258,
-0.2588712275028229,
-0.6282235980033875,
-0.8403817415237427,
-0.7554105520248413,
-0.4010962247848511,
-0.5633165836334229,
-0.6014256477355957,
0.539131760597229,
0.22955875098705292,
0.9393755793571472,
-0.8620461821556091,
0.5392671227455139,
-0.28078269958496094,
0.2433432638645172,
-0.4772050082683563,
-0.3222472071647644,
0.34969598054885864,
0.09372469782829285,
-0.6744977831840515,
0.6611462831497192,
0.36627572774887085,
0.465199738740921,
0.037313077598810196,
0.11829571425914764,
-0.21161457896232605,
0.5287082195281982,
0.6879845261573792,
0.5047035217285156,
-0.3190888464450836,
-0.576677143573761,
-0.08558636158704758,
0.2776970863342285,
-0.05024770647287369,
0.5226417779922485,
-1.052364468574524,
0.3441779613494873,
0.336338609457016,
0.38995349407196045,
0.745820939540863,
0.13912729918956757,
0.433454692363739,
-0.7069398760795593,
0.09251409769058228,
0.26200374960899353,
-0.02416582591831684,
0.47887173295021057,
-0.43598711490631104,
0.13601718842983246,
0.8539186120033264,
-0.22192168235778809,
-1.0453212261199951,
0.3320183753967285,
-0.7985866069793701,
-0.6676621437072754,
1.0976303815841675,
0.22777092456817627,
-0.10638667643070221,
-0.5000475645065308,
0.2681868076324463,
0.38174521923065186,
-0.43561750650405884,
0.6928341388702393,
0.2696648836135864,
-0.01156049408018589,
-0.48233842849731445,
-0.6160037517547607,
0.47535377740859985,
-0.09232089668512344,
-0.8108646869659424,
-0.14289480447769165,
0.5245179533958435,
0.46336689591407776,
0.1270456463098526,
0.708669900894165,
0.003849081927910447,
0.6203107833862305,
0.3231546878814697,
-0.32968080043792725,
-0.11601133644580841,
-0.4893224835395813,
-0.29179418087005615,
0.18173743784427643,
-0.6161948442459106,
-0.2887841463088989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18877v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18877v1
|
Principal Component Analysis as a Sanity Check for Bayesian Phylolinguistic Reconstruction
| 2024-02-29T05:47:34 | 2024-02-29T05:47:34 |
Yugo Murawaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Bayesian approaches to reconstructing the evolutionary history of languages
rely on the tree model, which assumes that these languages descended from a
common ancestor and underwent modifications over time. However, this assumption
can be violated to different extents due to contact and other factors.
Understanding the degree to which this assumption is violated is crucial for
validating the accuracy of phylolinguistic inference. In this paper, we propose
a simple sanity check: projecting a reconstructed tree onto a space generated
by principal component analysis. By using both synthetic and real data, we
demonstrate that our method effectively visualizes anomalies, particularly in
the form of jogging.
|
[
-0.07875168323516846,
-0.8656830191612244,
0.7842763662338257,
-0.03537781536579132,
-0.31677982211112976,
0.16741782426834106,
0.018218662589788437,
0.030525142326951027,
0.244819775223732,
0.5316123962402344,
-0.6767847537994385,
-0.6227579116821289,
-0.10905665159225464,
-0.2331426441669464,
-0.2282126247882843,
0.7360011339187622,
0.19946782290935516,
-0.22243784368038177,
0.21722543239593506,
0.07153411209583282,
-0.3290580213069916,
-0.6040399074554443,
-0.2842452824115753,
-0.1545855551958084,
0.14872518181800842,
0.22951743006706238,
0.7956503033638,
0.8639492392539978,
0.34135088324546814,
0.3026440441608429,
-0.20450276136398315,
0.30254071950912476,
-0.4243294298648834,
-0.0018267174018546939,
-0.10421645641326904,
-0.554574728012085,
-0.6488123536109924,
0.04474000260233879,
0.771079421043396,
1.0339301824569702,
-0.04684865474700928,
-0.22537089884281158,
-0.03527653217315674,
0.6149816513061523,
-0.5506372451782227,
0.24952736496925354,
-0.45308205485343933,
0.17707660794258118,
-0.1782604157924652,
-0.5785914659500122,
-0.42193931341171265,
-0.7061600089073181,
0.21873925626277924,
-0.6861194372177124,
0.35244953632354736,
-0.08243454247713089,
0.9849664568901062,
0.21317103505134583,
-0.7428936958312988,
0.11225670576095581,
-1.1283795833587646,
0.6172970533370972,
-0.7165417671203613,
0.42832598090171814,
0.43128570914268494,
0.48874878883361816,
-0.7324445247650146,
-0.7051609754562378,
-0.72142094373703,
-0.32755759358406067,
-0.037700362503528595,
0.1305810511112213,
-0.09009719640016556,
0.3247525990009308,
0.3464193046092987,
0.5044509768486023,
-0.7502794861793518,
-0.11708880215883255,
-0.44204115867614746,
-0.13750775158405304,
0.5904346108436584,
-0.11070707440376282,
0.8255522847175598,
-0.43085822463035583,
-0.24332250654697418,
-0.4804956614971161,
-0.7351083755493164,
0.13648240268230438,
0.6124415397644043,
0.30738839507102966,
0.0012754074996337295,
0.3911657929420471,
0.029195794835686684,
0.8270706534385681,
0.11552935838699341,
-0.4307137727737427,
-0.005730143282562494,
-0.3154623508453369,
-0.27142032980918884,
0.09726973623037338,
0.21656297147274017,
0.43739867210388184,
0.5745602250099182,
-0.15288130939006805,
0.19662320613861084,
0.27558571100234985,
0.3565923571586609,
-0.42386722564697266,
-1.0887337923049927,
0.18700037896633148,
-0.5278452634811401,
0.05467495322227478,
0.1017146110534668,
-0.9305238127708435,
-0.3646581470966339,
-0.3829512894153595,
0.009187702089548111,
-0.6767218708992004,
-0.4683232307434082,
0.18154017627239227,
-0.05323229730129242,
0.16376423835754395,
0.4423103928565979,
-0.6602792739868164,
0.3353736400604248,
1.0671958923339844,
0.5340067744255066,
0.10178108513355255,
-0.35035350918769836,
-0.21955560147762299,
0.11063382029533386,
-0.6615999937057495,
1.1152904033660889,
-0.49738505482673645,
-0.617761492729187,
-0.0835176333785057,
0.20098814368247986,
-0.28985944390296936,
-0.5010684728622437,
0.4702456295490265,
-0.19161412119865417,
0.1625348925590515,
-0.3948093354701996,
-0.7570616006851196,
-0.8011322021484375,
-0.03827475756406784,
-0.3617144227027893,
0.7538913488388062,
0.26409095525741577,
-0.84180748462677,
0.6550908088684082,
0.11588194966316223,
-0.22194404900074005,
0.07643792033195496,
-0.3771822154521942,
-0.5924796462059021,
0.3335147202014923,
0.0981530025601387,
0.1070738136768341,
0.11565694212913513,
0.44845831394195557,
-0.7487335801124573,
-0.24424375593662262,
0.1070607453584671,
-0.3064756691455841,
1.3900548219680786,
0.08600644767284393,
-0.46980613470077515,
-0.027801088988780975,
-1.1656408309936523,
-0.019227731972932816,
-0.19242970645427704,
-0.23937465250492096,
-0.5890383720397949,
0.41183674335479736,
-0.3463912606239319,
-0.041225235909223557,
-0.1684814691543579,
-0.6624681949615479,
0.7253657579421997,
-0.4689745008945465,
0.013638687320053577,
0.6175842881202698,
0.54323410987854,
0.2646327316761017,
-0.292113721370697,
0.5522709488868713,
0.05107429251074791,
-0.13170823454856873,
-0.24071988463401794,
-0.639111340045929,
-0.5842013359069824,
-0.4286305010318756,
0.0027088518254458904,
0.5737687945365906,
-0.5300693511962891,
0.590653121471405,
-0.37565454840660095,
-0.4180663526058197,
-0.11209413409233093,
-0.07589562237262726,
0.14852462708950043,
0.4714127779006958,
0.016001945361495018,
-0.5197760462760925,
-0.6414288282394409,
-0.915756344795227,
-0.060343727469444275,
-0.8291283249855042,
-0.0982905775308609,
0.3236521780490875,
0.23239658772945404,
-0.06427481025457382,
1.056017518043518,
-0.491180419921875,
0.13659101724624634,
0.09270697087049484,
0.2541936933994293,
0.12784257531166077,
0.99056077003479,
0.9439006447792053,
-0.4222957491874695,
-0.20904694497585297,
0.19070816040039062,
-0.5515363216400146,
-0.3798093795776367,
-0.40618783235549927,
-0.17362035810947418,
0.007118759211152792,
0.38174667954444885,
-0.6588361263275146,
0.7767239212989807,
0.48841628432273865,
-0.5431743860244751,
0.5098029971122742,
-0.46311312913894653,
0.35290849208831787,
-0.8425312042236328,
0.42988383769989014,
-0.10229383409023285,
-0.07122769951820374,
-0.8161466121673584,
-0.08233820647001266,
0.06402327865362167,
-0.11345703899860382,
-0.005416973028331995,
0.041865136474370956,
-0.3701658844947815,
-0.2805955708026886,
-0.1536192148923874,
0.04048658907413483,
-0.3613797724246979,
0.6563718318939209,
-0.16489125788211823,
0.3791412115097046,
0.5101945400238037,
-0.26083260774612427,
0.23730243742465973,
-0.16305232048034668,
-0.17618247866630554,
0.6216655373573303,
-0.3115547001361847,
0.14073218405246735,
-0.5408985614776611,
0.4746522903442383,
-1.609967827796936,
-0.2683335542678833,
0.38025087118148804,
-0.3457674980163574,
0.4179648756980896,
-0.3428526520729065,
-0.3796711266040802,
-0.16844582557678223,
-0.2860528826713562,
0.4480818510055542,
0.44077613949775696,
-0.7277927398681641,
0.5246076583862305,
0.4345441460609436,
-0.028454294428229332,
-0.018796319141983986,
-0.39273908734321594,
-0.08264243602752686,
-0.4357258677482605,
-0.574547529220581,
0.17305749654769897,
0.039615221321582794,
-0.43873006105422974,
0.0026537899393588305,
-0.35256460309028625,
-0.369520366191864,
0.40336015820503235,
0.3625774383544922,
0.33162978291511536,
-0.4235962927341461,
-0.25292637944221497,
0.025267774239182472,
0.005323362071067095,
0.07454457879066467,
-0.43172571063041687,
0.22797885537147522,
0.12968549132347107,
-0.5681091547012329,
-0.707012414932251,
-0.07663053274154663,
0.6399591565132141,
-0.09897737205028534,
0.12035312503576279,
-0.0814795196056366,
-0.6110509634017944,
-0.2977703809738159,
-0.33511918783187866,
-0.22061003744602203,
-0.4063648283481598,
0.1338464468717575,
-0.15593522787094116,
-0.4667595624923706,
0.43248939514160156,
-0.3351415693759918,
-0.11033977568149567,
0.15746773779392242,
0.18400424718856812,
0.008665393106639385,
1.1128315925598145,
0.7580822706222534,
-0.06370683759450912,
0.2617330253124237,
-0.1343136578798294,
0.5331177115440369,
-0.58844393491745,
-0.27977854013442993,
-0.6805967092514038,
-0.208780437707901,
-0.9686552286148071,
-0.39321357011795044,
0.2278248518705368,
0.24480971693992615,
-0.16447021067142487,
0.2827399671077728,
-0.2532232701778412,
0.2947818338871002,
0.3667919635772705,
0.009076819755136967,
0.2109551578760147,
0.08913952112197876,
-0.22952929139137268,
-0.29326313734054565,
-0.6247676014900208,
-0.5787606239318848,
0.8056200742721558,
0.2990916669368744,
0.4645339846611023,
0.13025599718093872,
0.5941230654716492,
-0.09755110740661621,
0.36126258969306946,
-0.7004491090774536,
0.5678813457489014,
-0.17908355593681335,
-0.5500634908676147,
0.07081091403961182,
-0.2723865807056427,
-0.903569757938385,
0.4394426643848419,
0.15835309028625488,
-1.594810962677002,
0.9640042185783386,
0.5810477137565613,
-0.49835148453712463,
0.39036044478416443,
-0.6192407608032227,
0.8403655290603638,
-0.09695368260145187,
-0.09947273880243301,
-0.12042421847581863,
-0.495572954416275,
0.8824865221977234,
-0.12316204607486725,
0.007658762391656637,
0.027449270710349083,
0.4127207100391388,
0.3804822266101837,
-0.5728884339332581,
1.0805788040161133,
-0.2595040500164032,
-0.11875887960195541,
0.40162310004234314,
0.6648615598678589,
0.29590463638305664,
-0.20171594619750977,
0.328273206949234,
-0.32130423188209534,
0.2441912144422531,
-0.4421854317188263,
-0.8370642066001892,
0.6112635135650635,
-0.4921207129955292,
-0.7332578897476196,
-0.4896407425403595,
-0.529043436050415,
-0.36192819476127625,
-0.14310407638549805,
-0.16535788774490356,
0.23939798772335052,
-0.0902075543999672,
0.27916857600212097,
0.31421929597854614,
-0.3517686128616333,
0.26603686809539795,
0.36930349469184875,
-0.5124531388282776,
-0.03021729737520218,
0.8769579529762268,
0.2656000256538391,
-0.11292541027069092,
-0.007304000668227673,
0.17155469954013824,
0.22480201721191406,
-0.6353970170021057,
-0.08816839754581451,
0.31345799565315247,
-0.37133052945137024,
0.26913735270500183,
-0.35945263504981995,
0.11438560485839844,
-0.28349316120147705,
-0.08253635466098785,
-0.32962068915367126,
-0.7353602647781372,
0.05933118239045143,
-0.17568571865558624,
-0.007435258012264967,
0.6249147057533264,
-0.3832084834575653,
0.3911834955215454,
-0.6582146286964417,
-0.031656406819820404,
0.3973754048347473,
0.01586252637207508,
0.04987381398677826,
-0.1936168074607849,
0.15519565343856812,
0.08624260127544403,
-0.4054449796676636,
-1.2348357439041138,
0.5140380263328552,
0.2798793613910675,
0.6797343492507935,
0.5589509010314941,
-0.2407451719045639,
0.794887900352478,
-0.5101385116577148,
0.9071716070175171,
-0.327462762594223,
-0.7250267267227173,
0.6992936134338379,
-0.5168103575706482,
0.22598852217197418,
0.2351282238960266,
0.3956749141216278,
-0.32965901494026184,
-0.39780330657958984,
-0.8829733729362488,
-0.6211656928062439,
0.4080052375793457,
0.07317492365837097,
-0.45914599299430847,
0.14421384036540985,
0.5624807476997375,
-0.16096392273902893,
-0.10206712782382965,
-0.24517954885959625,
-0.043093543499708176,
-0.2417014092206955,
-0.038801129907369614,
-0.2528490722179413,
-0.016963977366685867,
0.07066319137811661,
-0.2543831467628479,
0.47786471247673035,
-0.1179637610912323,
-0.07899925112724304,
0.18099577724933624,
0.0008294945582747459,
-0.3349485397338867,
-0.07388581335544586,
0.5112740397453308,
0.9871156215667725,
-0.4647141993045807,
0.4999708831310272,
-0.13370247185230255,
-0.375794917345047,
0.08396940678358078,
0.10322567820549011,
-0.23093396425247192,
0.08584201335906982,
0.606576681137085,
0.5735270380973816,
0.3699795603752136,
-0.4875856637954712,
0.19297587871551514,
0.21305009722709656,
0.199996218085289,
0.16479253768920898,
-0.002063281601294875,
-0.1332075595855713,
0.2759018838405609,
0.23366498947143555,
0.12907272577285767,
0.13405835628509521,
-0.8691742420196533,
0.5119013786315918,
0.21201327443122864,
-0.014119117520749569,
-0.9663421511650085,
0.45650607347488403,
-0.3712455928325653,
-0.2752141058444977,
0.5385389924049377,
0.03244956582784653,
-0.9211168885231018,
0.6717056035995483,
0.4978969097137451,
0.9287912249565125,
-0.7465692162513733,
0.44996774196624756,
0.4274865388870239,
0.46869853138923645,
0.1458991914987564,
0.4453639090061188,
-0.22571948170661926,
-0.4962778389453888,
-0.3590371906757355,
-0.4137478172779083,
-0.2135879397392273,
0.05694819241762161,
-0.4522424042224884,
-0.10549557954072952,
-0.6624948978424072,
-0.026752792298793793,
0.2150593101978302,
0.007531120441854,
-0.2958369255065918,
0.2934206426143646,
0.07182370871305466,
0.8269182443618774,
-1.2037314176559448,
1.1831872463226318,
0.6389879584312439,
-0.22766488790512085,
-0.7757943272590637,
0.48473358154296875,
0.517716109752655,
-0.6107528209686279,
0.9835906624794006,
-0.3449561297893524,
-0.1016569510102272,
-0.18339285254478455,
-0.46237605810165405,
-0.8193328976631165,
0.7631231546401978,
0.46772629022598267,
-0.24964019656181335,
0.022229187190532684,
-0.08423680812120438,
0.8793514966964722,
-0.12022460252046585,
-0.46125730872154236,
0.7743527889251709,
0.3229559659957886,
-0.11570209264755249,
-0.7397849559783936,
0.0070871831849217415,
-0.19995583593845367,
0.3693200945854187,
0.11818893998861313,
-0.226382315158844,
1.103857159614563,
-0.05069650337100029,
-0.6497686505317688,
0.1284140795469284,
0.4769690930843353,
0.4851676821708679,
0.029690932482481003,
0.4777040481567383,
0.4688867926597595,
0.9811722040176392,
0.014565784484148026,
1.2148990631103516,
-0.6935603618621826,
0.5386227369308472,
0.9895639419555664,
-0.19558195769786835,
0.6736289858818054,
0.5153085589408875,
-0.25283896923065186,
0.4305645525455475,
0.7701406478881836,
0.016126958653330803,
0.5765126943588257,
0.3571081757545471,
-0.1657828986644745,
-0.22779852151870728,
0.084934301674366,
-0.2517511546611786,
0.5312380194664001,
0.47371146082878113,
-0.028133120387792587,
-0.3846091628074646,
-0.34415531158447266,
0.28279563784599304,
0.18398967385292053,
0.03112155757844448,
0.5185954570770264,
-0.10533963143825531,
-0.9734315276145935,
0.5200212597846985,
-0.21707655489444733,
-0.09972421079874039,
-0.3082120418548584,
-0.28783711791038513,
-0.46082431077957153,
0.37821635603904724,
-0.16395235061645508,
-0.44600072503089905,
0.31070253252983093,
-0.2212003916501999,
0.3069247901439667,
-0.0837007686495781,
0.7920111417770386,
-0.4835752248764038,
-0.3843398094177246,
0.09630860388278961,
0.4947959780693054,
0.19482611119747162,
0.38442134857177734,
-0.22387750446796417,
0.01582552306354046,
0.1261540800333023,
-0.13131724298000336,
-0.0501570962369442,
0.5664784908294678,
-0.07381448149681091,
0.5070407390594482,
0.5492738485336304,
0.3960670232772827,
0.24451106786727905,
-0.45395544171333313,
0.7090536952018738,
-0.4037124812602997,
-0.6569362878799438,
-0.7451198697090149,
0.5971285700798035,
0.03332461789250374,
-0.2724015712738037,
1.0598375797271729,
0.5767080187797546,
0.9020252823829651,
0.01920686848461628,
0.5021079778671265,
0.29714512825012207,
0.43120718002319336,
-0.5247145295143127,
0.5506845116615295,
-0.33136916160583496,
0.3286619484424591,
-0.49471941590309143,
-0.9830504059791565,
-0.5782368183135986,
1.0408384799957275,
-0.32827556133270264,
-0.02851313352584839,
0.9003530144691467,
0.8253949284553528,
-0.34956663846969604,
0.20706892013549805,
0.13649335503578186,
0.5766816139221191,
0.344066321849823,
0.41398265957832336,
0.7725269794464111,
-0.015159920789301395,
-0.025753261521458626,
-0.5360385179519653,
-0.5868317484855652,
-0.17449289560317993,
-0.962750256061554,
-0.6013548374176025,
-0.743545651435852,
-0.5728697776794434,
-0.5726804137229919,
0.30514559149742126,
0.9103472232818604,
0.656888484954834,
-1.0880329608917236,
-0.6158375144004822,
-0.14798687398433685,
0.04610629379749298,
-0.2657647728919983,
-0.1660124510526657,
0.7157203555107117,
-0.0638461783528328,
-0.6415197849273682,
0.6582485437393188,
0.5380584597587585,
0.28607437014579773,
-0.39662274718284607,
0.2579011023044586,
-0.29699328541755676,
0.061998654156923294,
0.3350403606891632,
0.6803458333015442,
-0.7157973051071167,
-0.7886887788772583,
-0.4819439947605133,
-0.015917085111141205,
0.21593579649925232,
1.2965742349624634,
-0.80459064245224,
0.7992759943008423,
0.8399816155433655,
0.6860924363136292,
0.3995097577571869,
0.05599376559257507,
0.8802662491798401,
-0.6159160137176514,
0.2506680488586426,
-0.07964394986629486,
0.6142849922180176,
0.3062669634819031,
-0.11893939971923828,
0.35727018117904663,
0.6981092691421509,
-0.5187901258468628,
-1.0643678903579712,
0.27296116948127747,
-1.1059712171554565,
-0.5046706795692444,
0.8667408227920532,
-0.5762878656387329,
-0.56241375207901,
-0.11190260201692581,
-0.46187645196914673,
0.32968205213546753,
0.17887753248214722,
1.1768895387649536,
0.6204455494880676,
-0.1762499064207077,
-0.1346205174922943,
-0.410125195980072,
0.6990850567817688,
0.25455570220947266,
-0.8037968873977661,
0.06089439615607262,
0.7805033922195435,
0.18333272635936737,
0.1654878854751587,
0.42476555705070496,
0.20070919394493103,
0.42016738653182983,
0.19812895357608795,
-0.4605678915977478,
0.44633588194847107,
-0.3755229413509369,
-0.522132158279419,
0.2852439880371094,
-0.1364203691482544,
-0.19857485592365265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18873v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18873v1
|
Reducing Hallucinations in Entity Abstract Summarization with Facts-Template Decomposition
| 2024-02-29T05:43:43 | 2024-02-29T05:43:43 |
Fangwei Zhu, Peiyi Wang, Zhifang Sui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Entity abstract summarization aims to generate a coherent description of a
given entity based on a set of relevant Internet documents. Pretrained language
models (PLMs) have achieved significant success in this task, but they may
suffer from hallucinations, i.e. generating non-factual information about the
entity. To address this issue, we decompose the summary into two components:
Facts that represent the factual information about the given entity, which PLMs
are prone to fabricate; and Template that comprises generic content with
designated slots for facts, which PLMs can generate competently. Based on the
facts-template decomposition, we propose SlotSum, an explainable framework for
entity abstract summarization. SlotSum first creates the template and then
predicts the fact for each template slot based on the input documents.
Benefiting from our facts-template decomposition, SlotSum can easily locate
errors and further rectify hallucinated predictions with external knowledge. We
construct a new dataset WikiFactSum to evaluate the performance of SlotSum.
Experimental results demonstrate that SlotSum could generate summaries that are
significantly more factual with credible external knowledge.
|
[
-0.8100758194923401,
-0.70086270570755,
0.8333837985992432,
0.08044002950191498,
-0.6291431188583374,
-0.21032491326332092,
-0.1966046690940857,
-0.334185928106308,
0.7405715584754944,
0.7195877432823181,
-0.4349752366542816,
-0.6623335480690002,
-0.4899062216281891,
0.12552477419376373,
-0.773970901966095,
1.224077820777893,
0.02890215441584587,
-0.12909309566020966,
-0.49177536368370056,
-0.10723935067653656,
-0.22790788114070892,
-0.49410223960876465,
-0.5137048363685608,
-0.09718770533800125,
0.3744461238384247,
0.3271940052509308,
0.48620912432670593,
0.5816685557365417,
0.23459844291210175,
0.33453676104545593,
0.1031523048877716,
0.5093163251876831,
-0.5626349449157715,
0.056710612028837204,
-0.173129603266716,
-0.3051573932170868,
-0.5900456309318542,
-0.2918488085269928,
0.4983811676502228,
0.8234887719154358,
-0.47435447573661804,
0.058439500629901886,
-0.06858204305171967,
0.48377081751823425,
-0.4081804156303406,
0.370425283908844,
-0.6907183527946472,
0.12817378342151642,
-0.05612390115857124,
-0.5719676613807678,
-0.37311893701553345,
-0.5401877164840698,
0.25321435928344727,
-0.9380013346672058,
0.5202550292015076,
0.12870407104492188,
0.9610273838043213,
0.14849808812141418,
-0.23451760411262512,
-0.5192448496818542,
-0.7417528629302979,
0.4182661771774292,
-0.4072886109352112,
0.2997298836708069,
0.26398003101348877,
0.07763717323541641,
-0.11402052640914917,
-0.758847713470459,
-0.7563146948814392,
-0.01779230311512947,
-0.28390488028526306,
0.16815362870693207,
0.027704333886504173,
-0.024998212233185768,
0.29522472620010376,
0.3882855772972107,
-0.7789859771728516,
-0.17428316175937653,
-0.664238452911377,
-0.2524690628051758,
0.5550166964530945,
0.18826623260974884,
0.39541393518447876,
-0.2406575232744217,
-0.38531631231307983,
0.1043977439403534,
-0.7279818654060364,
-0.4522803723812103,
0.2801779508590698,
0.11341368407011032,
-0.06974637508392334,
0.7154009342193604,
0.1570250689983368,
0.3277852237224579,
0.22822627425193787,
-0.5298740267753601,
0.19131237268447876,
-0.05282655358314514,
-0.10307583212852478,
0.621972382068634,
0.2868281304836273,
0.6175288558006287,
-0.1089140772819519,
-0.6202351450920105,
-0.27447929978370667,
0.3340100049972534,
0.5865751504898071,
-1.0135056972503662,
-0.25175222754478455,
0.36023131012916565,
-0.66617751121521,
-0.07595477998256683,
0.14425481855869293,
-0.8216150999069214,
-0.3864102065563202,
-0.5015068054199219,
0.4642823040485382,
-0.6853205561637878,
-0.37555167078971863,
0.024136561900377274,
-0.46760430932044983,
0.08589256554841995,
0.5617730617523193,
-0.6911321878433228,
0.4761243462562561,
0.7748549580574036,
1.0702871084213257,
-0.4248439371585846,
-0.05860939994454384,
-0.33575549721717834,
0.34067150950431824,
-0.29289892315864563,
1.1140415668487549,
-0.06109020859003067,
-0.44002074003219604,
-0.230107843875885,
-0.1582050770521164,
0.004509099293500185,
-0.5681555271148682,
0.33855289220809937,
-0.41587185859680176,
0.3114871680736542,
-0.43975481390953064,
-0.905947744846344,
-0.37255242466926575,
0.11981175094842911,
-0.7811518311500549,
0.5037335753440857,
-0.06891803443431854,
-0.9382708072662354,
0.4647873044013977,
-0.5558324456214905,
-0.5617198944091797,
-0.0355980210006237,
-0.44526052474975586,
-0.47637346386909485,
0.43931248784065247,
0.055947836488485336,
0.3052310645580292,
0.0009824460139498115,
0.43857261538505554,
-0.22836825251579285,
-0.3796871304512024,
0.2564849853515625,
0.14622078835964203,
0.48656994104385376,
0.1989022046327591,
-0.3205230236053467,
0.08181247860193253,
-0.8944980502128601,
-0.4939327836036682,
0.05054678022861481,
-0.021496156230568886,
-0.3854508399963379,
0.21826677024364471,
-0.19851185381412506,
0.11566809564828873,
-0.14836515486240387,
-0.11002250015735626,
-0.12544764578342438,
-0.5889111757278442,
-0.12306851148605347,
0.7560481429100037,
0.3356601893901825,
0.47836875915527344,
-0.5627415180206299,
0.34721994400024414,
0.3863148093223572,
-0.30305802822113037,
-0.19202129542827606,
-0.3470255732536316,
-0.9489549994468689,
-0.24192751944065094,
0.12438097596168518,
0.28635695576667786,
-0.8616142868995667,
0.7454094290733337,
-0.2910078763961792,
-0.33175966143608093,
-0.21787405014038086,
-0.20357106626033783,
0.012254142202436924,
0.8841515779495239,
0.35882338881492615,
-0.5506105422973633,
-0.7890733480453491,
-0.8892022967338562,
-0.15547749400138855,
-0.12560775876045227,
-0.06376323103904724,
-0.12332422286272049,
0.6404110193252563,
-0.09415305405855179,
0.666290819644928,
-0.5619911551475525,
-0.35069194436073303,
-0.30861160159111023,
0.33204683661460876,
-0.05803271383047104,
0.306965172290802,
0.610480546951294,
-0.6478657126426697,
0.003964233677834272,
-0.37634962797164917,
-0.9351513981819153,
0.2704795300960541,
-0.2788633704185486,
0.06721213459968567,
0.29041892290115356,
0.3341003656387329,
-1.0827903747558594,
0.4885922968387604,
0.013187269680202007,
-0.18501608073711395,
0.7041110396385193,
-0.11036209017038345,
0.011374893598258495,
-1.0465474128723145,
0.18983681499958038,
-0.09347184747457504,
-0.1871235966682434,
-0.323320597410202,
-0.17143963277339935,
-0.3417281210422516,
-0.23890917003154755,
-0.041945748031139374,
0.30676934123039246,
-0.37665656208992004,
-0.4148063361644745,
-0.33509281277656555,
0.4366290867328644,
0.0036043785512447357,
0.47991836071014404,
0.44348639249801636,
0.6216751337051392,
0.541264533996582,
-0.9533491730690002,
0.09125565737485886,
0.32505351305007935,
-0.5492914915084839,
0.3861654996871948,
-0.4583419859409332,
-0.19975760579109192,
-0.6549464464187622,
0.2889609932899475,
-0.6617873311042786,
-0.33093810081481934,
0.2384520173072815,
-0.34389957785606384,
0.20188000798225403,
0.07370017468929291,
-0.2587226927280426,
0.14450234174728394,
-0.4904756546020508,
-0.12222307175397873,
0.27998292446136475,
-0.5024822354316711,
0.745370090007782,
0.8572767972946167,
-0.2876269817352295,
-0.4514607787132263,
-0.4262527525424957,
0.11895973980426788,
-0.34258490800857544,
-0.44191715121269226,
0.684395968914032,
-0.1269119381904602,
-0.5276919603347778,
0.36757892370224,
-0.3380606770515442,
0.03264831751585007,
0.024636611342430115,
0.3577941954135895,
0.2692173719406128,
-0.36158278584480286,
0.22709695994853973,
0.2358909398317337,
-0.3645651340484619,
0.43812108039855957,
-0.3935376703739166,
0.4091758131980896,
-0.02418140321969986,
0.01889406144618988,
-0.2852557599544525,
0.5085022449493408,
0.4661145806312561,
0.013917312026023865,
1.044669508934021,
0.49775582551956177,
-0.6502887010574341,
-0.45686063170433044,
-0.4156947433948517,
-0.35875198245048523,
-0.34840402007102966,
0.25591498613357544,
-0.3451736569404602,
-0.6103711128234863,
0.613002359867096,
-0.007254625670611858,
0.2395051270723343,
0.6550999283790588,
0.6603442430496216,
0.04006064310669899,
0.8467363715171814,
0.5501303672790527,
0.21784304082393646,
0.07613330334424973,
-0.2561243176460266,
0.3556972146034241,
-0.37506839632987976,
-0.41924214363098145,
-0.29301413893699646,
0.13040108978748322,
-0.4200226068496704,
-0.30153417587280273,
0.5511424541473389,
-0.09725628793239594,
0.33972278237342834,
0.10881268978118896,
-0.4202064275741577,
0.3664453625679016,
0.3212496340274811,
0.019310778006911278,
0.28901880979537964,
0.27972593903541565,
-0.10715357214212418,
0.01391015574336052,
-0.7379220128059387,
-0.7052021622657776,
0.978138267993927,
0.14688652753829956,
0.4956033527851105,
0.18533959984779358,
0.7330672144889832,
0.3782943785190582,
0.30970099568367004,
-0.6501225829124451,
0.6229168176651001,
0.09052813053131104,
-0.5541584491729736,
-0.16223588585853577,
-0.6168257594108582,
-0.6847408413887024,
0.43369174003601074,
-0.4151802659034729,
-0.6084944605827332,
0.09124989062547684,
0.19525547325611115,
-0.5048035979270935,
0.2892749309539795,
-0.6481695771217346,
0.49080613255500793,
-0.1097622811794281,
0.0214037224650383,
-0.5044630169868469,
-0.3686218857765198,
0.7543727159500122,
0.06669280678033829,
0.28396883606910706,
0.03541780635714531,
0.09000877290964127,
0.8918410539627075,
-0.6237873435020447,
0.6110914349555969,
-0.16236115992069244,
-0.10023035109043121,
0.32418808341026306,
0.05582674220204353,
0.4063052833080292,
0.49763432145118713,
0.11897297948598862,
-0.006606033071875572,
-0.17957071959972382,
-0.1862344592809677,
-0.6702296733856201,
0.8141134977340698,
-0.6592533588409424,
-0.505045473575592,
-0.5955948829650879,
-0.3133394718170166,
-0.03168684244155884,
0.0613180473446846,
0.5688890814781189,
0.6883233189582825,
-0.36726582050323486,
-0.17002706229686737,
1.1161704063415527,
-0.23140379786491394,
0.21927818655967712,
0.3236254155635834,
-0.3024648129940033,
-0.40207213163375854,
0.9956766963005066,
0.4771677851676941,
-0.4049261808395386,
0.29626280069351196,
-0.2685836851596832,
-0.4287010431289673,
-0.718876302242279,
-0.2815726399421692,
0.3525150716304779,
-0.7482645511627197,
-0.12126406282186508,
-0.9551359415054321,
-0.22703836858272552,
-0.46452054381370544,
-0.12020468711853027,
-0.3318789303302765,
-0.8958147764205933,
-0.3460034728050232,
-0.5243269801139832,
0.152176633477211,
0.6693745851516724,
-0.08751384168863297,
0.01072848029434681,
-0.548128604888916,
0.813367486000061,
0.22953729331493378,
0.4023291766643524,
-0.04404361918568611,
-0.29577845335006714,
-0.26146915555000305,
-0.39630749821662903,
-0.12182006239891052,
-1.1177036762237549,
0.3778662383556366,
0.11562610417604446,
0.5036687254905701,
0.6819321513175964,
0.22081933915615082,
0.7873745560646057,
-0.37106576561927795,
0.6564468145370483,
0.23545557260513306,
-0.8677987456321716,
0.40818163752555847,
-0.07957891374826431,
-0.1909244954586029,
0.3280608355998993,
0.4415798485279083,
-0.2813497483730316,
-0.5334115028381348,
-0.8853867650032043,
-0.9924170970916748,
0.6358752846717834,
0.3282512128353119,
-0.22438855469226837,
-0.13664785027503967,
0.4570637345314026,
0.6003751754760742,
0.3857574164867401,
-0.6267988085746765,
-0.49500876665115356,
-0.49032309651374817,
-0.12207068502902985,
-0.0410393588244915,
-0.48066502809524536,
-0.27287617325782776,
-0.16441725194454193,
0.9968878030776978,
0.09217487275600433,
0.4842384457588196,
0.2622358202934265,
-0.5053677558898926,
-0.1332794725894928,
0.09619313478469849,
1.0054264068603516,
1.2182281017303467,
-0.3370618522167206,
0.6367506384849548,
0.24551719427108765,
-0.29287973046302795,
-0.1051798090338707,
0.14712689816951752,
-0.4568609297275543,
0.586654543876648,
0.42862486839294434,
0.9022637009620667,
0.24689950048923492,
-0.6023362278938293,
0.3693649172782898,
-0.3492812216281891,
-0.154380664229393,
-0.7986942529678345,
0.16411206126213074,
0.11762993037700653,
-0.07086597383022308,
0.2980509102344513,
0.21052023768424988,
0.36081406474113464,
-0.47536328434944153,
0.4238293170928955,
0.005934820510447025,
-0.060473937541246414,
-0.6213827729225159,
0.5354517698287964,
0.2248709499835968,
0.11519192904233932,
0.4545876979827881,
-0.492883563041687,
-0.3192596733570099,
0.32597970962524414,
0.6344651579856873,
0.7539981603622437,
0.051570530980825424,
0.40175068378448486,
0.4898942708969116,
0.3833635151386261,
-0.042332958430051804,
0.13779886066913605,
0.0023644992616027594,
-0.6256377100944519,
-0.34185531735420227,
-0.502892255783081,
-0.21488237380981445,
0.5027197003364563,
-0.7210318446159363,
0.10289786756038666,
-0.5643893480300903,
-0.14455251395702362,
0.23584288358688354,
-0.1301136463880539,
-0.3929269015789032,
0.1412140280008316,
0.1201600655913353,
0.7464255094528198,
-0.7717931866645813,
0.4886961579322815,
0.5913324356079102,
-0.5362581014633179,
-0.377015620470047,
-0.09100500494241714,
0.09491659700870514,
-0.3148448169231415,
0.15453018248081207,
0.25888487696647644,
-0.08781388401985168,
-0.2022230178117752,
-0.2414541244506836,
-0.6060206890106201,
0.8697070479393005,
0.5870633125305176,
-0.3360360264778137,
-0.23019938170909882,
-0.11496948450803757,
0.2547016441822052,
-0.431673139333725,
-0.0037230588495731354,
0.4181157648563385,
0.482555091381073,
-0.28207358717918396,
-0.42029044032096863,
0.19657468795776367,
-0.24830129742622375,
-0.15124806761741638,
0.13355469703674316,
-0.34212926030158997,
0.7687844038009644,
-0.18306876718997955,
-0.4828753173351288,
-0.24104434251785278,
1.0382848978042603,
0.34580186009407043,
0.46386513113975525,
0.5656740665435791,
0.6566060781478882,
1.0904016494750977,
0.02374478615820408,
0.8349594473838806,
-0.4282933473587036,
0.17123933136463165,
1.1561628580093384,
-0.2527846097946167,
0.3874461054801941,
0.5416499376296997,
0.21246615052223206,
0.7473007440567017,
0.4359065890312195,
0.04871948063373566,
0.4982280433177948,
0.02086256816983223,
-0.18059028685092926,
-0.2168269008398056,
0.015540624037384987,
-0.5735675692558289,
0.41298726201057434,
0.6358206868171692,
-0.22909443080425262,
-0.48326757550239563,
-0.025399530306458473,
0.1936642974615097,
0.01098624523729086,
-0.26510629057884216,
0.8844699263572693,
0.1781020313501358,
-0.9271025657653809,
0.19887924194335938,
0.3088891804218292,
0.17198218405246735,
-0.5931099653244019,
-0.18389223515987396,
-0.20408980548381805,
0.0566568449139595,
-0.2747490406036377,
-0.35144320130348206,
0.700992226600647,
0.07683663815259933,
-0.3542609214782715,
-0.10209668427705765,
0.9467569589614868,
-0.4759140610694885,
-0.32932981848716736,
-0.045552823692560196,
0.3853827118873596,
0.2967448830604553,
-0.20830006897449493,
-0.45015624165534973,
-0.07895995676517487,
-0.2852093279361725,
0.0007102480158209801,
0.2983759045600891,
0.5603078603744507,
0.031156955286860466,
0.5083158016204834,
0.4742894470691681,
0.14843158423900604,
-0.1497243493795395,
-0.19676892459392548,
0.9169869422912598,
-0.6535559892654419,
-0.9484847187995911,
-0.6377436518669128,
0.4448654055595398,
-0.37555959820747375,
-0.24610836803913116,
0.9005623459815979,
0.9429786205291748,
0.6218867897987366,
-0.29603445529937744,
0.8524810671806335,
0.0016788850771263242,
0.5157432556152344,
-0.7654372453689575,
0.9846195578575134,
-0.2592598795890808,
0.4253280758857727,
-0.02205570973455906,
-0.8913134336471558,
-0.09976337105035782,
0.724014937877655,
0.030927153304219246,
-0.15276287496089935,
0.8052222728729248,
0.7655825614929199,
-0.10799161344766617,
0.06838924437761307,
0.11068834364414215,
0.376099556684494,
-0.02562122792005539,
0.054462235420942307,
0.8485456109046936,
-0.2202681303024292,
0.40311431884765625,
-0.31139490008354187,
-0.03658130019903183,
-0.3700243830680847,
-0.698901355266571,
-1.0624622106552124,
-0.7797410488128662,
-0.6465775370597839,
-0.5832299590110779,
0.05632477626204491,
0.8830199241638184,
0.7007646560668945,
-0.9727665185928345,
-0.14962835609912872,
-0.03831903636455536,
0.5721675753593445,
-0.12198955565690994,
-0.2766612768173218,
0.6341652870178223,
-0.31027185916900635,
-0.1951533704996109,
0.39800122380256653,
0.545185923576355,
0.021746080368757248,
-0.21246857941150665,
-0.21199393272399902,
0.11345195025205612,
0.34317055344581604,
0.653633177280426,
0.11111632734537125,
-0.6221900582313538,
-0.1996050924062729,
-0.2835732400417328,
0.044808369129896164,
0.06096658855676651,
1.1162526607513428,
-0.7335472106933594,
0.4165332317352295,
0.3537469804286957,
0.3294694423675537,
0.7103239893913269,
0.00020353765285108238,
0.6039409041404724,
-0.8034114837646484,
0.14029687643051147,
0.12455065548419952,
0.4720775783061981,
0.21340084075927734,
-0.37807697057724,
0.3042261600494385,
0.4539676606655121,
0.009232338517904282,
-0.953035295009613,
0.08810657262802124,
-1.007162094116211,
-0.5468321442604065,
0.5576517581939697,
-0.057502381503582,
-0.37884241342544556,
-0.3366239070892334,
0.08659866452217102,
0.3705909252166748,
-0.3212733566761017,
1.4025862216949463,
0.48182711005210876,
-0.14725817739963531,
-0.07014722377061844,
-0.12323720753192902,
0.895866334438324,
0.1441141813993454,
-1.0774599313735962,
-0.11910894513130188,
0.7113300561904907,
0.27535438537597656,
0.32439371943473816,
0.7286432385444641,
-0.18695515394210815,
0.4195167124271393,
0.2802807688713074,
0.1550290584564209,
-0.15930087864398956,
-0.565121591091156,
-0.08969950675964355,
0.6101654171943665,
-0.08098883181810379,
0.17851915955543518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18865v1
|
Analyzing and Reducing Catastrophic Forgetting in Parameter Efficient Tuning
| 2024-02-29T05:27:45 | 2024-02-29T05:27:45 |
Weijieying Ren, Xinlong Li, Lei Wang, Tianxiang Zhao, Wei Qin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Existing research has shown that large language models (LLMs) exhibit
remarkable performance in language understanding and generation. However, when
LLMs are continuously fine-tuned on complex and diverse domain-specific
downstream tasks, the inference performance on historical tasks decreases
dramatically, which is known as a catastrophic forgetting problem. A trade-off
needs to be kept between learning plasticity and memory stability. Plenty of
existing works have explored strategies like memory replay, regularization and
parameter isolation, but little is known about the geometric connection of
various adjacent minima in the continual LLMs fine-tuning scenarios. In this
work, we investigate the geometric connections of different minima through the
lens of mode connectivity, which means different minima can be connected by a
low-loss valley. Through extensive experiments, we uncover the mode
connectivity phenomenon in the LLMs continual learning scenario and find that
it can strike a balance between plasticity and stability. Building upon these
findings, we propose a simple yet effective method called Interpolation-based
LoRA (I-LoRA), which constructs a dual-memory experience replay framework based
on LoRA parameter interpolations. Extensive experiments and analysis on eight
domain-specific CL benchmarks demonstrate that I-LoRA consistently show
significant improvement over the previous state-of-the-art approaches with up
to $11\%$ performance gains, providing a strong baseline and insights for
future research on the large language model continual learning problem. Our
code is available at \url{https://github.com/which47/LLMCL}.
|
[
-0.6164865493774414,
-1.2459189891815186,
0.5657708048820496,
0.038549717515707016,
-0.1872643679380417,
0.058510757982730865,
-0.3673549294471741,
-0.17273271083831787,
0.06848388910293579,
0.5273628234863281,
-0.7910276055335999,
-0.51649010181427,
-0.3250584900379181,
-0.16918328404426575,
-0.06832574307918549,
0.8220067620277405,
-0.06094152852892876,
-0.14846071600914001,
-0.1611013263463974,
-0.45512670278549194,
-0.5715648531913757,
-0.3959360718727112,
-1.2036714553833008,
-0.4218004643917084,
0.6972671151161194,
0.28757429122924805,
0.2963477075099945,
0.7232213020324707,
0.2618834674358368,
0.33420562744140625,
-0.2044256329536438,
0.4905420243740082,
-0.970886766910553,
0.047987598925828934,
-0.051382459700107574,
-0.6243596076965332,
-0.42753127217292786,
-0.16671358048915863,
1.0539807081222534,
0.7928491830825806,
-0.28875643014907837,
0.11951158195734024,
0.5037311315536499,
1.0140440464019775,
-0.29614296555519104,
0.20589487254619598,
-1.084788203239441,
-0.11975888162851334,
-0.25451916456222534,
-0.573059618473053,
-0.37704193592071533,
-0.32847464084625244,
-0.08761287480592728,
-0.48805832862854004,
0.1848536729812622,
0.14069050550460815,
0.9522727131843567,
0.5924158692359924,
-0.12190573662519455,
-0.15914414823055267,
-0.8447698354721069,
0.7240955829620361,
-0.7646756768226624,
0.2326204776763916,
0.4885860085487366,
0.34978151321411133,
-0.38985496759414673,
-0.2012108564376831,
-0.3177843689918518,
-0.30765777826309204,
0.23454059660434723,
0.032043274492025375,
0.010887977667152882,
0.06087789312005043,
0.2817029356956482,
0.1291927546262741,
-0.26736533641815186,
0.3962687849998474,
-0.4034215807914734,
-0.08526207506656647,
0.35904666781425476,
0.38010746240615845,
0.14240601658821106,
0.25604569911956787,
-0.10850448161363602,
0.14391374588012695,
-1.2224997282028198,
0.12811081111431122,
0.4850403964519501,
0.4301993250846863,
-0.3000197410583496,
0.34812411665916443,
-0.012996486388146877,
0.6354076266288757,
0.03398172929883003,
-0.45021432638168335,
-0.2059178501367569,
-0.0626971572637558,
0.07607635855674744,
-0.27262431383132935,
0.4826382100582123,
0.12399828433990479,
0.3107713758945465,
-0.17288337647914886,
-0.07490885257720947,
0.16882802546024323,
0.17221273481845856,
-0.3739132285118103,
-0.32771047949790955,
-0.09992925077676773,
-0.3936394453048706,
0.2823183238506317,
-0.23062480986118317,
-0.7432361245155334,
-0.040633197873830795,
-0.5889614224433899,
0.4485093951225281,
-0.7126099467277527,
-0.016786513850092888,
0.06923035532236099,
0.5144252181053162,
-0.10853973031044006,
0.30536162853240967,
-0.9227173328399658,
0.29846131801605225,
0.6158249378204346,
1.0101934671401978,
-0.22835591435432434,
-0.47837895154953003,
-0.6568596959114075,
0.29288700222969055,
-0.14033474028110504,
0.7513835430145264,
-0.23918035626411438,
-0.16131019592285156,
-0.0411062017083168,
-0.026306452229619026,
-0.2943398654460907,
-0.8575748205184937,
0.272086501121521,
-0.5222194790840149,
-0.13935592770576477,
-0.44810810685157776,
-0.4298662841320038,
-0.34166643023490906,
0.2770748734474182,
-0.7078256011009216,
1.0206327438354492,
-0.08593383431434631,
-0.46523168683052063,
0.2310277223587036,
-0.28364264965057373,
-0.10429873317480087,
-0.1875631958246231,
-0.29017317295074463,
-0.6848194003105164,
0.26670241355895996,
-0.07034380733966827,
0.08602960407733917,
-0.34360671043395996,
0.11366333812475204,
-0.5773322582244873,
-0.48532965779304504,
0.08773408830165863,
-0.49310800433158875,
0.29579833149909973,
-0.0544336773455143,
-0.23056477308273315,
0.12828892469406128,
-0.720634937286377,
-0.17090635001659393,
0.05168565362691879,
-0.6636158227920532,
-0.3333459198474884,
0.3159874379634857,
-0.26277658343315125,
0.2751220464706421,
0.08274774998426437,
-0.1501038372516632,
0.19158440828323364,
-0.25491929054260254,
0.5015318989753723,
0.9510113596916199,
0.08609017729759216,
0.09152282029390335,
-0.5855976939201355,
0.44939738512039185,
0.22778671979904175,
-0.011695672757923603,
-0.09496329724788666,
-0.31485259532928467,
-1.2311885356903076,
-0.1388999968767166,
0.09195201843976974,
0.42511647939682007,
-0.705484926700592,
0.30410686135292053,
-0.21828266978263855,
-0.2419964224100113,
-0.21904224157333374,
0.4171554744243622,
0.4610137939453125,
0.6241360902786255,
0.37477031350135803,
-0.15801793336868286,
-0.33517810702323914,
-0.7777367830276489,
-0.15513217449188232,
-0.19274874031543732,
0.20425593852996826,
0.39119386672973633,
0.25096237659454346,
-0.08505064994096756,
0.8661037683486938,
-0.3161424696445465,
-0.49580326676368713,
-0.13581664860248566,
-0.077915720641613,
0.25835907459259033,
0.4919408857822418,
0.7256173491477966,
-0.25518375635147095,
-0.45131179690361023,
-0.04052214324474335,
-0.6737820506095886,
-0.045140352100133896,
-0.2718890905380249,
-0.27350419759750366,
0.5128809213638306,
0.6972382068634033,
-0.35627445578575134,
0.27652597427368164,
0.7042398452758789,
-0.23092563450336456,
0.4094008505344391,
-0.4032759368419647,
-0.10874570161104202,
-0.7006962299346924,
0.13768212497234344,
0.08980853110551834,
-0.10027613490819931,
-0.27859121561050415,
-0.10557496547698975,
-0.060454025864601135,
0.09223011136054993,
-0.18117520213127136,
0.3992789685726166,
-0.4320615828037262,
0.07250124216079712,
-0.21787427365779877,
0.2813190817832947,
-0.33193814754486084,
0.8197255730628967,
-0.39688509702682495,
0.7836061716079712,
0.46025002002716064,
-0.8009980320930481,
-0.05583525821566582,
-0.08167432248592377,
-0.14505915343761444,
0.414662629365921,
-0.43660131096839905,
0.10282287001609802,
-0.2623676359653473,
0.07307877391576767,
-1.0363835096359253,
0.11622748523950577,
0.07926089316606522,
-0.00436725839972496,
0.3684457242488861,
-0.446731299161911,
-0.5146285891532898,
-0.03961425647139549,
-0.0870901420712471,
0.3717959523200989,
0.5438346862792969,
-0.5546191334724426,
0.6557410359382629,
0.4349631667137146,
-0.26303645968437195,
-0.14468900859355927,
-0.23238223791122437,
-0.08476543426513672,
-0.6402153968811035,
-0.5095092058181763,
0.040396202355623245,
-0.33578211069107056,
-0.13230063021183014,
-0.1265852451324463,
-0.14912289381027222,
-0.018952228128910065,
0.08628623932600021,
0.27545827627182007,
0.2958652377128601,
-0.45767873525619507,
0.012438061647117138,
0.47836223244667053,
-0.387683242559433,
-0.008403828367590904,
-0.1803215593099594,
0.8730752468109131,
-0.3950703740119934,
-0.47056785225868225,
-0.3964482247829437,
0.4783403277397156,
0.5617325901985168,
0.12992341816425323,
0.8567022681236267,
0.2975543141365051,
-0.34736356139183044,
-0.36369574069976807,
-0.8429732918739319,
-0.184373140335083,
-0.5560452342033386,
0.4077465236186981,
-0.4988877773284912,
-1.0164357423782349,
0.7422547936439514,
-0.4043540358543396,
0.09098515659570694,
0.3373206853866577,
0.5005121231079102,
-0.30801650881767273,
0.6797832250595093,
0.8740426301956177,
-0.1605222523212433,
0.3195968568325043,
-0.3336038291454315,
0.17033208906650543,
-0.7770445942878723,
-0.23906368017196655,
-0.24928249418735504,
-0.43416786193847656,
-0.36691275238990784,
-0.23312333226203918,
0.7827680706977844,
0.5728601217269897,
-0.2421608418226242,
0.06524690985679626,
0.012615553103387356,
0.47058671712875366,
0.3763611614704132,
0.23035144805908203,
0.5147873759269714,
0.30421918630599976,
-0.2537840008735657,
-0.3820876181125641,
-0.7989505529403687,
-0.419247031211853,
0.5637989044189453,
0.2688920497894287,
0.8342286944389343,
0.2729901075363159,
0.4148615896701813,
-0.02607719413936138,
0.029652351513504982,
-0.7099871039390564,
0.763314962387085,
-0.2948025166988373,
0.00363479508087039,
-0.23190058767795563,
-0.6081638932228088,
-0.9126504063606262,
0.12107009440660477,
-0.2049054205417633,
-0.8872691988945007,
-0.2055174857378006,
0.6143047213554382,
-0.4050810635089874,
0.4845408797264099,
-0.32005059719085693,
0.44893911480903625,
-0.08359038829803467,
-0.5164524912834167,
-0.6321221590042114,
-0.29273760318756104,
0.3399202525615692,
-0.28680551052093506,
-0.058157362043857574,
-0.3285435736179352,
-0.023863088339567184,
0.46155017614364624,
-0.27278876304626465,
0.9355742931365967,
0.05315948650240898,
-0.16596826910972595,
0.26331469416618347,
0.2856597304344177,
0.40390634536743164,
0.2603802978992462,
-0.046170398592948914,
0.31736889481544495,
-0.014733213931322098,
-0.4025324285030365,
-0.49155035614967346,
1.0486407279968262,
-0.6946676969528198,
-0.48171907663345337,
-0.0210524033755064,
-0.584729015827179,
-0.5575717091560364,
0.13414180278778076,
0.2657207250595093,
0.5503745079040527,
0.02230745740234852,
0.005827666725963354,
0.9844179153442383,
-0.20870590209960938,
0.654938280582428,
0.482032835483551,
-0.198635071516037,
-0.21139563620090485,
1.021899700164795,
0.41325104236602783,
0.47226306796073914,
0.06689846515655518,
0.15777447819709778,
-0.00794157013297081,
-0.6829314827919006,
-0.44336625933647156,
0.7971563339233398,
-0.6178545951843262,
-0.16448372602462769,
-0.44428011775016785,
-0.40146148204803467,
0.20207670331001282,
-0.24030548334121704,
-0.5510808229446411,
-0.17434406280517578,
-0.25031694769859314,
0.24346381425857544,
0.431670218706131,
0.6151056289672852,
-0.0284414179623127,
0.3946097195148468,
-0.685052752494812,
0.19719737768173218,
0.1300661563873291,
0.5573641061782837,
0.2501809597015381,
-0.5212816596031189,
-0.3544316291809082,
-0.10590525716543198,
-0.24759550392627716,
-0.2654865086078644,
0.2555912435054779,
0.48100653290748596,
0.5431490540504456,
0.5159385204315186,
-0.23806220293045044,
0.9928970336914062,
-0.6742057800292969,
0.4939058721065521,
0.1181560605764389,
-0.7352344989776611,
0.40273749828338623,
-0.6262585520744324,
0.384763240814209,
0.6780615448951721,
0.271310955286026,
-0.42155081033706665,
-0.21092909574508667,
-0.2509579658508301,
-0.8502315282821655,
0.47081997990608215,
-0.1854960322380066,
-0.059436406940221786,
0.15850147604942322,
0.7085720300674438,
0.2044583112001419,
-0.1287696212530136,
-0.4352226257324219,
-0.3838694989681244,
0.3816126883029938,
-0.01700173318386078,
0.0046922024339437485,
-0.4347047209739685,
-0.25558075308799744,
-0.31355640292167664,
0.6519367694854736,
-0.47672364115715027,
0.1831262707710266,
-0.3161714971065521,
0.002027590060606599,
-0.14661557972431183,
-0.2345498502254486,
0.7154948711395264,
0.858454167842865,
-0.02853519655764103,
-0.01625559851527214,
0.4108567237854004,
-0.46118220686912537,
-0.04201442003250122,
-0.2858089804649353,
-0.28426578640937805,
-0.2104225903749466,
0.1639847755432129,
0.6651512980461121,
0.3448657989501953,
-0.6404131650924683,
-0.09768971800804138,
-0.06581762433052063,
-0.0034192416351288557,
-0.5004083514213562,
0.24603894352912903,
0.18148218095302582,
0.2397490292787552,
0.16447976231575012,
0.1933576911687851,
-0.3478442430496216,
-0.4910072088241577,
0.2260393500328064,
0.5613230466842651,
-0.42451709508895874,
-0.4983012080192566,
0.6170268058776855,
0.036986880004405975,
-0.22121071815490723,
0.6983768939971924,
0.13043063879013062,
-0.2527182996273041,
0.38767290115356445,
0.8117727637290955,
0.5916925072669983,
0.031055942177772522,
-0.1386336386203766,
0.5721356272697449,
0.2860914468765259,
-0.10651890933513641,
0.2994336783885956,
0.06759382039308548,
-0.4214724004268646,
-0.4775206744670868,
-0.6035299897193909,
-0.1283303052186966,
0.21189145743846893,
-0.670013427734375,
0.2520315647125244,
-0.8510037660598755,
-0.17195512354373932,
-0.5732853412628174,
-0.06049763411283493,
-0.4333209991455078,
-0.11155833303928375,
-0.01704275608062744,
0.7846426367759705,
-0.7490406036376953,
1.0930752754211426,
0.233455628156662,
-0.28216758370399475,
-0.6517733931541443,
0.08475781977176666,
0.30312472581863403,
-0.7496835589408875,
0.30741021037101746,
-0.04156995937228203,
-0.6472403407096863,
0.011191866360604763,
-0.278672456741333,
-1.1336392164230347,
1.0127408504486084,
0.5745493769645691,
-0.6994059681892395,
-0.060077447444200516,
0.07504408806562424,
0.40072599053382874,
-0.1781163066625595,
-0.23820114135742188,
0.8152633309364319,
0.10699135065078735,
0.15635937452316284,
-0.8396884799003601,
-0.03369097411632538,
-0.1257181018590927,
0.09188488125801086,
0.5280446410179138,
-1.033789038658142,
0.7678345441818237,
-0.11009471863508224,
-0.2785651385784149,
0.46023568511009216,
0.6111015677452087,
0.5618810653686523,
0.12925902009010315,
0.5268945693969727,
0.7138941884040833,
0.6451685428619385,
-0.22733451426029205,
0.5995510220527649,
-0.35904595255851746,
0.5063760876655579,
1.155271053314209,
0.15474840998649597,
0.9508678317070007,
0.5407534241676331,
-0.19397681951522827,
0.31546542048454285,
0.5128757953643799,
0.3530288338661194,
0.5278412103652954,
0.19170387089252472,
-0.35749340057373047,
-0.3864639699459076,
0.10736243426799774,
-0.43842649459838867,
0.23223665356636047,
0.7187432050704956,
-0.024404125288128853,
-0.2781192362308502,
-0.16098742187023163,
0.3189840614795685,
0.1406838297843933,
-0.296355664730072,
0.5970767736434937,
0.32742276787757874,
-0.5904167294502258,
0.8747536540031433,
-0.2157401591539383,
0.6778395771980286,
-0.8863970041275024,
-0.09959651529788971,
-0.5093695521354675,
0.40161970257759094,
0.008183201774954796,
-0.268067866563797,
0.3995930850505829,
-0.36650457978248596,
-0.27675044536590576,
0.11727868020534515,
0.21863369643688202,
-0.6117493510246277,
-0.3872092366218567,
0.4699576199054718,
0.3185352087020874,
-0.08225920796394348,
0.3106972575187683,
-0.6310678124427795,
0.4561120867729187,
-0.03858913853764534,
-0.05522879585623741,
0.669955849647522,
0.39130038022994995,
-0.06900579482316971,
0.9843285083770752,
0.584596574306488,
0.28712260723114014,
0.3465428650379181,
-0.03731410577893257,
0.9040365219116211,
-0.5799248218536377,
-0.4014231860637665,
-0.9248282313346863,
0.270481675863266,
0.17164774239063263,
-0.5862794518470764,
0.7834913730621338,
0.4611266553401947,
0.6142873764038086,
-0.007789268624037504,
0.45049574971199036,
0.32390260696411133,
0.35255274176597595,
-1.0605275630950928,
0.8127711415290833,
-0.5475640892982483,
0.5734272599220276,
-0.20796792209148407,
-1.107022762298584,
-0.35179591178894043,
0.5155823826789856,
-0.142854243516922,
-0.05854695662856102,
0.7279375791549683,
0.8855639100074768,
-0.3318355977535248,
-0.34965869784355164,
0.4547445774078369,
0.4102194607257843,
0.33636748790740967,
0.7174107432365417,
0.7649310231208801,
-0.23610185086727142,
0.32510602474212646,
-0.15686821937561035,
-0.2711658775806427,
-0.17465908825397491,
-0.831643283367157,
-0.9676271677017212,
-0.7221086621284485,
-0.3105143904685974,
-0.5214334726333618,
0.10051001608371735,
0.6585880517959595,
0.6409360766410828,
-0.588351845741272,
-0.37527742981910706,
-0.0010339850559830666,
-0.08977865427732468,
-0.1719071865081787,
-0.14875394105911255,
0.4468056857585907,
-0.4920312762260437,
-0.5618327260017395,
0.5350763201713562,
0.7251203656196594,
-0.09668304771184921,
-0.4822174608707428,
-0.10381151735782623,
-0.04396877810359001,
0.24975895881652832,
0.6380978226661682,
0.6128799915313721,
-0.8882423043251038,
-0.43099144101142883,
-0.3734400272369385,
0.15792404115200043,
0.17850199341773987,
0.8337752223014832,
-0.8385905027389526,
0.2652386426925659,
0.07057967782020569,
0.7274816632270813,
0.5507156848907471,
-0.11778723448514938,
0.3995758295059204,
-0.37036511301994324,
0.30092957615852356,
-0.05122781917452812,
0.5468695759773254,
0.16410940885543823,
-0.15685611963272095,
0.4230709671974182,
0.1885800063610077,
-0.6559231281280518,
-0.5654719471931458,
0.4428909122943878,
-1.1106609106063843,
-0.03515002131462097,
0.9860188364982605,
-0.11337301135063171,
-0.1891593337059021,
-0.25699523091316223,
-0.22418245673179626,
-0.09443117678165436,
-0.13119949400424957,
1.111319899559021,
0.3773830235004425,
-0.283748984336853,
-0.1736166924238205,
-0.6536662578582764,
0.442055344581604,
0.5602497458457947,
-0.7164463400840759,
-0.09843676537275314,
0.5720999836921692,
0.527845561504364,
-0.12063882499933243,
0.5742063522338867,
0.007509388495236635,
-0.019211964681744576,
-0.13083602488040924,
-0.6379067301750183,
0.12127581238746643,
-0.6172897815704346,
-0.3599170446395874,
0.143682599067688,
0.2956045866012573,
0.08961755037307739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15407v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15407v1
|
X-AMR Annotation Tool
| 2024-02-29T05:16:19 | 2024-02-29T05:16:19 |
Shafiuddin Rehan Ahmed, Jon Z. Cai, Martha Palmer, James H. Martin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents a novel Cross-document Abstract Meaning Representation
(X-AMR) annotation tool designed for annotating key corpus-level event
semantics. Leveraging machine assistance through the Prodigy Annotation Tool,
we enhance the user experience, ensuring ease and efficiency in the annotation
process. Through empirical analyses, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our
tool in augmenting an existing event corpus, highlighting its advantages when
integrated with GPT-4. Code and annotations:
https://github.com/ahmeshaf/gpt_coref
|
[
-0.4427410364151001,
-0.2369384467601776,
0.502591609954834,
-0.18164144456386566,
-0.5656650066375732,
0.43507707118988037,
-0.10421029478311539,
-0.8469252586364746,
0.48378124833106995,
0.058631688356399536,
-0.6300960183143616,
-0.6990207433700562,
-0.7093634009361267,
0.11075396090745926,
-0.4674328565597534,
1.157080054283142,
-0.3364788889884949,
-0.4387640357017517,
0.09851080924272537,
-0.10118703544139862,
-0.07648652046918869,
-0.9853938221931458,
-0.9614096879959106,
-0.40192434191703796,
0.4535875916481018,
-0.03891339525580406,
0.8212237358093262,
0.6013787984848022,
0.49490490555763245,
0.16274456679821014,
0.2564290761947632,
-0.2880971431732178,
-0.10072112083435059,
0.014120034873485565,
-0.11041676998138428,
-0.23658429086208344,
-0.8162891864776611,
0.2105490267276764,
0.6889374852180481,
0.4316557049751282,
0.40428945422172546,
-0.012868351303040981,
-0.24155564606189728,
0.1619051694869995,
-0.6488170027732849,
0.6938397288322449,
-0.5078803300857544,
0.4057704508304596,
-0.7144508957862854,
-0.4224183261394501,
-0.014710635878145695,
-0.024048035964369774,
0.057030532509088516,
-0.984484851360321,
0.140546053647995,
0.07550695538520813,
0.9764288067817688,
0.05844832956790924,
-0.23676268756389618,
-0.15943250060081482,
-0.48315706849098206,
0.7205889821052551,
-0.28769680857658386,
0.4285517632961273,
0.23924104869365692,
0.46338406205177307,
0.34618160128593445,
-1.0186026096343994,
-0.947319507598877,
0.0889800563454628,
-0.41779935359954834,
-0.005541672930121422,
-0.2837916910648346,
0.2136741280555725,
0.15067407488822937,
0.5375123620033264,
-0.37869250774383545,
-0.20784235000610352,
-0.3325361907482147,
-0.3556181490421295,
0.7233313918113708,
0.42583730816841125,
0.39344969391822815,
-0.28462037444114685,
-0.06801656633615494,
-0.1000482439994812,
-0.6706424951553345,
-0.1595923900604248,
0.5406975150108337,
0.16469259560108185,
-0.3103543221950531,
0.4954783022403717,
-0.04941113665699959,
0.43482786417007446,
-0.1029011532664299,
0.14454124867916107,
0.7703447341918945,
-0.5996956825256348,
0.057926442474126816,
0.2478349804878235,
0.6711454391479492,
0.4274115264415741,
0.24017319083213806,
-0.43562307953834534,
-0.12059660255908966,
0.05547045171260834,
0.02041073516011238,
-0.6327913403511047,
-0.3902256190776825,
0.03557799756526947,
-0.4131143093109131,
-0.3168654441833496,
0.19295427203178406,
-0.8394294381141663,
-0.23969407379627228,
-0.34384799003601074,
0.5563969612121582,
-0.27618131041526794,
-0.18221953511238098,
-0.010826981626451015,
-0.6441652178764343,
0.46032989025115967,
0.43080106377601624,
-0.789167582988739,
0.41501519083976746,
0.8376607298851013,
0.8329647779464722,
-0.25706616044044495,
-0.11183619499206543,
-0.5086986422538757,
0.524778425693512,
0.04969573765993118,
0.694589376449585,
-0.836983323097229,
-0.7121639251708984,
-0.11152057349681854,
0.09569409489631653,
0.05013635382056236,
0.08280157297849655,
1.2012574672698975,
-0.4988915026187897,
0.07012511044740677,
-0.1246243417263031,
-0.514071524143219,
-0.42791271209716797,
0.2813504934310913,
-0.7595244646072388,
0.9020296931266785,
0.19232752919197083,
-0.9493561387062073,
0.5021539330482483,
-1.073488712310791,
-0.5509639382362366,
0.24970723688602448,
-0.8597128391265869,
-0.3615487217903137,
-0.2060256004333496,
0.32782211899757385,
0.38388121128082275,
0.08303000777959824,
-0.4253636598587036,
-0.17435429990291595,
-0.13578733801841736,
0.34880292415618896,
-0.11657072603702545,
0.44168296456336975,
-0.13590624928474426,
-0.5516401529312134,
0.2755047082901001,
-1.0499719381332397,
-0.05046121031045914,
-0.041577283293008804,
-0.15162286162376404,
-0.3918302655220032,
-0.0035862589720636606,
0.5551726222038269,
0.40857696533203125,
0.3918553590774536,
-0.8072521686553955,
0.22433911263942719,
-0.35803085565567017,
0.3147296905517578,
0.47837260365486145,
0.20118167996406555,
0.2780050039291382,
-0.17152057588100433,
0.7316933274269104,
-0.06652771681547165,
-0.06697362661361694,
-0.6684972643852234,
-0.7716152667999268,
-0.44679224491119385,
-0.2934513986110687,
0.3001985549926758,
0.6636778116226196,
-0.310854971408844,
0.5191501379013062,
-0.23734813928604126,
-0.19258730113506317,
-0.7311450839042664,
-0.24264848232269287,
0.39590808749198914,
0.43496382236480713,
0.45893287658691406,
-0.235173299908638,
-1.164281964302063,
-0.8688247799873352,
0.08976548910140991,
-0.3363321125507355,
0.04103939235210419,
0.050786733627319336,
0.6164141893386841,
-0.08985927700996399,
1.0263917446136475,
-0.43410226702690125,
-0.6038538813591003,
-0.059054382145404816,
0.6143877506256104,
-0.04062626138329506,
0.43428221344947815,
0.5527569651603699,
-0.8844518661499023,
-0.3921494781970978,
0.567362368106842,
-0.6401638984680176,
-0.36049285531044006,
-0.025148840621113777,
0.028455447405576706,
0.4581470787525177,
0.39904502034187317,
-0.409772664308548,
0.901485025882721,
0.4225202798843384,
-0.5594440698623657,
0.6745944023132324,
0.008214018307626247,
0.7488375306129456,
-0.6680086255073547,
0.24386164546012878,
-0.35088297724723816,
-0.2732425034046173,
-0.323527991771698,
0.06849022954702377,
0.24463577568531036,
0.008555589243769646,
-0.27924349904060364,
0.7979868650436401,
-0.5163325667381287,
-0.06935786455869675,
-0.6084772944450378,
0.29836514592170715,
0.12251176685094833,
0.18612051010131836,
0.4262542128562927,
0.7567392587661743,
0.3854520320892334,
-0.03423174098134041,
0.296569287776947,
0.4780596196651459,
0.07064242660999298,
0.45083603262901306,
-0.5289539098739624,
0.014695719815790653,
0.13135604560375214,
0.15256303548812866,
-0.8671194911003113,
-0.20331059396266937,
0.6611230373382568,
-0.6807575225830078,
0.40439486503601074,
-0.5180320739746094,
-0.7328133583068848,
-0.18830150365829468,
-0.48277831077575684,
0.3394995331764221,
0.5937883853912354,
-0.3315541744232178,
0.8913310170173645,
0.5269775986671448,
-0.30589956045150757,
-0.47589388489723206,
-0.6747896075248718,
0.48723849654197693,
-0.21506668627262115,
-0.8960184454917908,
0.5948204398155212,
0.23652462661266327,
-0.26665371656417847,
0.2587747573852539,
0.1455317884683609,
0.003309611463919282,
-0.36229825019836426,
0.47613272070884705,
0.19208134710788727,
-0.18686434626579285,
-0.21016672253608704,
0.40025758743286133,
-0.7753388285636902,
0.1593012809753418,
-0.40372586250305176,
0.04812994971871376,
-0.07929928600788116,
-0.6463337540626526,
-0.23021362721920013,
0.685221254825592,
0.2672313451766968,
-0.3853012025356293,
0.30143269896507263,
0.6415914297103882,
-0.5558328032493591,
0.29774796962738037,
-0.36896979808807373,
-0.043854545801877975,
-0.3578636646270752,
0.13440380990505219,
-0.7699184417724609,
-1.0303646326065063,
0.7925484776496887,
0.4275458753108978,
0.03236420825123787,
0.4396626055240631,
0.6704131364822388,
0.3105217218399048,
1.0843473672866821,
0.42288801074028015,
0.07398716360330582,
0.17077262699604034,
0.004572054836899042,
-0.011333242058753967,
-0.9138612151145935,
-0.19868925213813782,
-0.5874425768852234,
-0.3856465816497803,
-0.24699659645557404,
-0.6605111360549927,
0.322703093290329,
-0.413695752620697,
0.15116716921329498,
0.14136174321174622,
-0.3150741755962372,
0.3887149393558502,
0.4870249629020691,
-0.47111421823501587,
0.6736732125282288,
-0.4005023241043091,
-0.028864122927188873,
-0.3798025846481323,
-0.14601503312587738,
-0.7341700792312622,
1.0077470541000366,
0.30861562490463257,
0.7146517634391785,
-0.03321370109915733,
0.8017337918281555,
0.149139404296875,
0.28880754113197327,
-0.4575944244861603,
0.36907482147216797,
0.18274807929992676,
-0.9605646729469299,
-0.19320639967918396,
0.06978058069944382,
-0.8421866297721863,
0.393949419260025,
-0.2068643867969513,
-1.0916107892990112,
0.26752081513404846,
0.023193836212158203,
-0.35592857003211975,
0.44824886322021484,
-0.4590837359428406,
1.0797878503799438,
0.14115752279758453,
-0.04791492223739624,
-0.10447937250137329,
-0.7347557544708252,
0.28876954317092896,
-0.5350631475448608,
0.2223121076822281,
-0.23223967850208282,
-0.6730898022651672,
0.9325651526451111,
-0.3741188645362854,
0.9486600756645203,
-0.07108207792043686,
0.1334834098815918,
0.25315383076667786,
-0.20668475329875946,
0.655236005783081,
0.16028761863708496,
-0.14859196543693542,
0.12291882932186127,
0.06919646263122559,
-0.1688591092824936,
-0.5677664875984192,
0.5444298386573792,
-0.7161946296691895,
-0.38751405477523804,
-0.4696584939956665,
-0.43084651231765747,
0.12130284309387207,
0.027614902704954147,
0.22862353920936584,
0.4811292886734009,
-0.22925633192062378,
-0.18657591938972473,
0.29137375950813293,
0.14704453945159912,
0.4160916805267334,
0.5181079506874084,
-0.4462456703186035,
-0.5782515406608582,
0.44133391976356506,
0.24803155660629272,
-0.2568966746330261,
0.7285760045051575,
-0.16721634566783905,
-0.4529321491718292,
-0.8424452543258667,
-0.6824235916137695,
-0.06914722919464111,
-1.0333349704742432,
-0.14997370541095734,
-1.1902436017990112,
0.028900135308504105,
-0.29656097292900085,
-0.5820697546005249,
0.10931601375341415,
-1.0973492860794067,
-0.1894121915102005,
-0.5233890414237976,
0.6662279963493347,
0.27846282720565796,
-0.3680688440799713,
0.4982508718967438,
-1.0560340881347656,
0.1222667247056961,
-0.15854787826538086,
0.12185577303171158,
-0.2609768509864807,
-0.35484579205513,
-0.3799787759780884,
-0.6528418660163879,
-0.3225960433483124,
-1.0525707006454468,
0.17334778606891632,
0.3582397401332855,
0.9045281410217285,
0.42449983954429626,
0.10416100919246674,
0.385393887758255,
-0.5643061399459839,
0.872297465801239,
0.13968709111213684,
-1.1751344203948975,
0.7122830152511597,
-0.5587371587753296,
0.10811831802129745,
0.568855881690979,
0.45556655526161194,
-0.6662158966064453,
-0.6972816586494446,
-0.920464277267456,
-1.050318956375122,
0.5148981213569641,
0.421142041683197,
0.06361743062734604,
-0.23193244636058807,
0.42766621708869934,
0.5199978351593018,
0.1715366244316101,
-0.7042369246482849,
-0.6023740768432617,
-0.22653158009052277,
-0.2045179158449173,
0.06475427746772766,
-0.07070162147283554,
0.0007479566847905517,
-0.07479226589202881,
0.8623173236846924,
-0.08318252861499786,
0.10202194005250931,
0.16094380617141724,
-0.07883337140083313,
-0.3076708912849426,
0.31104400753974915,
0.2440354973077774,
0.7493812441825867,
-0.29379042983055115,
0.2928413450717926,
0.08026222139596939,
-0.607650876045227,
0.1971711963415146,
0.8591954708099365,
-0.14155961573123932,
0.20956024527549744,
0.6163798570632935,
0.6299291849136353,
0.4574468731880188,
-0.49618658423423767,
0.7318090796470642,
-0.07728581875562668,
-0.17224502563476562,
-0.5128042697906494,
-0.024553529918193817,
-0.013452568091452122,
0.08041665703058243,
0.7261908054351807,
-0.33929455280303955,
0.566729724407196,
-0.20279404520988464,
0.6946484446525574,
0.26404422521591187,
-0.6885871887207031,
-0.7050734758377075,
1.041518211364746,
0.401911199092865,
0.15166181325912476,
0.10256312787532806,
-0.696066677570343,
-0.5255495309829712,
0.1389954388141632,
0.3065601587295532,
1.0710633993148804,
0.11397149413824081,
-0.2036733329296112,
0.20790180563926697,
0.4969823360443115,
0.6790101528167725,
0.4386421740055084,
-0.0031165964901447296,
-0.42322856187820435,
-1.081445574760437,
-0.5747964382171631,
-0.5276873707771301,
-0.08230533450841904,
-0.36652639508247375,
0.5174208283424377,
-0.21328997611999512,
0.015173807740211487,
0.3445959687232971,
0.24742361903190613,
-0.4559769928455353,
0.13784755766391754,
0.41627880930900574,
1.0949193239212036,
-0.8521921038627625,
1.008901834487915,
1.1343121528625488,
-0.9591296911239624,
-0.43312186002731323,
-0.22937701642513275,
0.3892606794834137,
-0.7492060661315918,
0.8090522289276123,
-0.06688385456800461,
0.20209556818008423,
0.08243551850318909,
0.20422245562076569,
-0.6875966191291809,
1.0314909219741821,
-0.1431213915348053,
-0.5032188296318054,
0.06261224299669266,
0.19443748891353607,
0.28846049308776855,
-0.5173940658569336,
0.241450235247612,
0.5956053137779236,
0.9246946573257446,
0.1633996218442917,
-0.9923545122146606,
0.37762925028800964,
-0.3807089030742645,
-0.3232470452785492,
0.797408401966095,
0.06534897536039352,
0.44839993119239807,
-0.1172814592719078,
-0.27059322595596313,
0.17518271505832672,
1.0211156606674194,
0.0777822732925415,
0.6569277048110962,
0.2968192398548126,
0.6822458505630493,
0.6098006367683411,
-0.22199127078056335,
1.0582808256149292,
-0.3591145873069763,
0.12624859809875488,
1.054579496383667,
-0.1550210565328598,
0.5506740212440491,
0.4788348078727722,
-0.2634636163711548,
0.5107400417327881,
0.43035662174224854,
0.20816540718078613,
0.4013419449329376,
0.22594891488552094,
-0.7838894128799438,
-0.07879900187253952,
0.4810781478881836,
-0.4823472499847412,
0.06365229189395905,
0.5886139869689941,
-0.3609005808830261,
-0.6256352066993713,
0.30659329891204834,
0.37168580293655396,
-0.18083733320236206,
-0.3268142640590668,
0.5523493885993958,
0.07233958691358566,
-0.12332259118556976,
0.018404781818389893,
0.12595774233341217,
0.566375195980072,
-0.7629581689834595,
-0.15184760093688965,
0.25842708349227905,
0.2080947756767273,
-0.32078036665916443,
-1.1906516551971436,
0.735174834728241,
-0.19593439996242523,
-0.3306703567504883,
0.22010299563407898,
1.0599520206451416,
-0.19928748905658722,
-0.40871748328208923,
0.41158515214920044,
0.6447680592536926,
0.31776896119117737,
-0.22987745702266693,
-0.8395755887031555,
0.616145133972168,
-0.2532261908054352,
-0.19508765637874603,
0.32598569989204407,
0.8455303311347961,
-0.46274423599243164,
0.25381723046302795,
0.3766711354255676,
-0.004409899935126305,
0.29919126629829407,
0.149843230843544,
0.7190116047859192,
-0.8487484455108643,
-0.6793646216392517,
-0.8497216105461121,
0.7065014839172363,
-0.13885577023029327,
-0.3148954212665558,
0.6593329906463623,
0.7643531560897827,
0.8531116843223572,
0.0007551178568974137,
1.5503839254379272,
-0.41323626041412354,
0.5982725024223328,
-0.20598402619361877,
0.5187318325042725,
-0.031502123922109604,
-0.05363933742046356,
-0.3578701913356781,
-0.7077377438545227,
-0.7388358116149902,
0.48582935333251953,
-0.6041101217269897,
-0.02857075445353985,
0.6827948093414307,
0.6167560815811157,
-0.20544371008872986,
0.33946213126182556,
0.4618484377861023,
-0.1536361128091812,
0.4254562258720398,
0.36483851075172424,
1.0416244268417358,
-0.41913309693336487,
0.678062915802002,
-0.06337009370326996,
-0.6136617064476013,
-0.27574750781059265,
-1.3019479513168335,
-0.824079692363739,
-0.7692381739616394,
-0.8245700597763062,
-0.06111780181527138,
0.37146297097206116,
1.0478241443634033,
0.6832042932510376,
-0.7714534997940063,
0.08438551425933838,
0.3396257162094116,
-0.17442239820957184,
-0.21161654591560364,
-0.19881601631641388,
0.6116073131561279,
-0.7027303576469421,
-0.7980754375457764,
0.1682598888874054,
0.3960336148738861,
0.24659405648708344,
-0.14288365840911865,
-0.14084139466285706,
0.08624342828989029,
-0.14353500306606293,
0.6155077815055847,
0.38117316365242004,
-0.42364221811294556,
-0.7003743052482605,
-0.5201311707496643,
0.3083198666572571,
0.12061489373445511,
0.9353704452514648,
-0.9222577214241028,
0.06199256330728531,
0.4846365451812744,
0.6846972107887268,
0.7154117226600647,
-0.3148100972175598,
0.652779221534729,
-1.0357002019882202,
-0.12589511275291443,
0.01638008840382099,
0.5969789624214172,
0.30211636424064636,
-0.3122630715370178,
0.7789138555526733,
0.3760796785354614,
-0.4132192134857178,
-0.4845596253871918,
0.01054855715483427,
-1.306504249572754,
0.06890568882226944,
0.9726741909980774,
-0.2917047142982483,
-0.1557561457157135,
-0.7450072765350342,
-0.5381661653518677,
0.047454845160245895,
-0.4868173897266388,
0.4260326027870178,
0.7652544379234314,
-0.5398715138435364,
-0.3229005038738251,
-0.6413162350654602,
0.6509703397750854,
-0.41243019700050354,
-0.8310668468475342,
0.055069249123334885,
0.49035948514938354,
-0.0019755454268306494,
0.45366403460502625,
1.0180535316467285,
-0.7335816621780396,
0.5136790871620178,
0.06338589638471603,
0.44807517528533936,
-0.2772766053676605,
0.1516823172569275,
-0.2461795210838318,
0.31616508960723877,
0.15305857360363007,
-0.24596808850765228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18849v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18849v1
|
Enhancing Steganographic Text Extraction: Evaluating the Impact of NLP Models on Accuracy and Semantic Coherence
| 2024-02-29T04:53:06 | 2024-02-29T04:53:06 |
Mingyang Li, Maoqin Yuan, Luyao Li, Han Pengsihua
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This study discusses a new method combining image steganography technology
with Natural Language Processing (NLP) large models, aimed at improving the
accuracy and robustness of extracting steganographic text. Traditional Least
Significant Bit (LSB) steganography techniques face challenges in accuracy and
robustness of information extraction when dealing with complex character
encoding, such as Chinese characters. To address this issue, this study
proposes an innovative LSB-NLP hybrid framework. This framework integrates the
advanced capabilities of NLP large models, such as error detection, correction,
and semantic consistency analysis, as well as information reconstruction
techniques, thereby significantly enhancing the robustness of steganographic
text extraction. Experimental results show that the LSB-NLP hybrid framework
excels in improving the extraction accuracy of steganographic text, especially
in handling Chinese characters. The findings of this study not only confirm the
effectiveness of combining image steganography technology and NLP large models
but also propose new ideas for research and application in the field of
information hiding. The successful implementation of this interdisciplinary
approach demonstrates the great potential of integrating image steganography
technology with natural language processing technology in solving complex
information processing problems.
|
[
-0.1985107958316803,
-1.1611789464950562,
0.10096991062164307,
0.27395614981651306,
-0.660720705986023,
0.4026302993297577,
-0.285761296749115,
-1.1848329305648804,
0.47095590829849243,
0.5936758518218994,
-0.010235168039798737,
-0.7111587524414062,
-0.7727590203285217,
0.19145391881465912,
-0.5133909583091736,
0.550100564956665,
-0.025614485144615173,
0.3731446862220764,
0.3451140820980072,
0.07000679522752762,
-0.533915638923645,
-0.5211397409439087,
-0.6023759841918945,
0.08723761141300201,
-0.025843163952231407,
-0.23983938992023468,
1.0227915048599243,
0.6720184087753296,
0.860393226146698,
0.28346380591392517,
-0.3012717366218567,
0.3522651791572571,
-0.17695000767707825,
0.20282061398029327,
-0.33670803904533386,
-0.09241785109043121,
-0.43101149797439575,
-0.445290744304657,
0.8882092237472534,
0.3672868609428406,
0.07424245774745941,
-0.2614922821521759,
-0.024430369958281517,
0.3885236978530884,
-0.5024639368057251,
0.19900885224342346,
-0.5450643301010132,
0.04735790565609932,
-0.27886712551116943,
-0.359739750623703,
-0.4895506799221039,
-0.26629889011383057,
0.10198678076267242,
-0.4546440839767456,
0.24238498508930206,
0.3202359080314636,
1.146277904510498,
-0.04349159821867943,
-0.16602185368537903,
-0.3813534080982208,
-0.8925167322158813,
0.7979401350021362,
-0.9636295437812805,
0.44858822226524353,
0.18664641678333282,
0.19379496574401855,
-0.1658305674791336,
-0.7213423252105713,
-0.5461338758468628,
-0.008986817672848701,
0.06686251610517502,
0.08295172452926636,
-0.12794345617294312,
0.10189888626337051,
0.16417966783046722,
0.5657526850700378,
-0.3616352677345276,
0.24590115249156952,
-0.2820204794406891,
-0.572445273399353,
0.7358747124671936,
-0.16822966933250427,
0.7218735218048096,
-0.3559236526489258,
-0.5770937204360962,
-0.20869088172912598,
-0.45956355333328247,
-0.06038382276892662,
0.15247200429439545,
0.16790008544921875,
0.1253729909658432,
0.6106345057487488,
-0.008939160965383053,
0.5371915102005005,
-0.11770541965961456,
-0.3200887143611908,
-0.02662506327033043,
-0.5401140451431274,
-0.3424440026283264,
0.11608847230672836,
0.9199841022491455,
0.2024543583393097,
-0.33758553862571716,
-0.41567593812942505,
-0.32757359743118286,
0.02384478971362114,
-0.132036492228508,
-0.8078495860099792,
-0.09328342974185944,
0.04186522588133812,
-0.7024291753768921,
-0.32339900732040405,
0.3454599380493164,
-0.9804220795631409,
-0.49008819460868835,
-0.09720232337713242,
0.4330914616584778,
-0.6465898752212524,
-0.45197048783302307,
0.39800921082496643,
-0.3576726019382477,
0.3095732033252716,
0.4112095832824707,
-0.8943778872489929,
0.43497294187545776,
0.896026611328125,
0.9768222570419312,
-0.6169952750205994,
0.3254244923591614,
-0.3957907557487488,
0.45434337854385376,
-0.21573583781719208,
0.37054872512817383,
-0.36988645792007446,
-0.09614919871091843,
-0.1430806815624237,
0.14047305285930634,
0.2299509197473526,
-0.5820218324661255,
0.8204711079597473,
-0.8152746558189392,
0.08939998596906662,
-0.12103277444839478,
-0.6532015204429626,
-0.36476150155067444,
0.07684651762247086,
-1.3368446826934814,
0.8907354474067688,
-0.32934242486953735,
-0.7943804264068604,
0.16825444996356964,
-0.5379711985588074,
-0.5020065307617188,
0.3763338327407837,
-0.1499267965555191,
-0.611578643321991,
-0.11811099946498871,
0.1712622195482254,
0.44486311078071594,
-0.2996431589126587,
0.5899933576583862,
-0.31696608662605286,
-0.5198313593864441,
0.017257681116461754,
-0.6798909902572632,
1.078261375427246,
-0.06041369214653969,
-0.462832510471344,
-0.010136308148503304,
-0.8648907542228699,
-0.11154056340456009,
0.2678382396697998,
-0.38877415657043457,
-0.7647784352302551,
-0.3637809157371521,
0.19891393184661865,
0.07101455330848694,
0.5935888886451721,
-0.7219893932342529,
-0.082632876932621,
-0.491695374250412,
0.17268416285514832,
0.7037275433540344,
0.06056293100118637,
0.5987486243247986,
0.01167245116084814,
0.2450668066740036,
-0.12326347827911377,
-0.025902703404426575,
0.04271225258708,
-0.661953866481781,
-0.31966468691825867,
-0.5124852061271667,
0.6342330574989319,
0.47437870502471924,
-1.1623276472091675,
0.6204018592834473,
-0.12774160504341125,
-0.23702704906463623,
-0.4001002907752991,
0.2668044865131378,
0.3703423738479614,
0.5011141300201416,
0.3223550617694855,
-0.7062046527862549,
-0.6228967308998108,
-0.8262197375297546,
-0.4167446792125702,
0.1122952476143837,
0.2916859984397888,
-0.26946115493774414,
0.5076067447662354,
0.014724694192409515,
0.6498023867607117,
-0.12874315679073334,
-0.16856342554092407,
-0.2869127094745636,
0.31526222825050354,
0.12125264108181,
0.7276224493980408,
0.3051915466785431,
-1.2781668901443481,
-0.5095648765563965,
0.16896824538707733,
-0.860068678855896,
0.26023897528648376,
-0.04375259578227997,
-0.3589940667152405,
0.30678853392601013,
0.37374991178512573,
-0.49457848072052,
0.6232887506484985,
0.48976457118988037,
-0.2345057725906372,
0.7393667697906494,
-0.2592892348766327,
0.21417279541492462,
-0.9864471554756165,
0.0036096489056944847,
0.13724395632743835,
-0.3788367211818695,
-0.6126172542572021,
0.2938898205757141,
0.23300763964653015,
-0.05899941548705101,
-0.11352039873600006,
0.3092819154262543,
-0.7137898206710815,
-0.1262112557888031,
-0.18969300389289856,
0.01677936315536499,
0.3059561252593994,
0.2387034296989441,
0.37355688214302063,
0.5864499807357788,
0.2946584224700928,
-0.1845364272594452,
0.525441586971283,
-0.02311420999467373,
-0.42854082584381104,
0.19560353457927704,
-0.526496171951294,
0.09507261216640472,
-0.07572463154792786,
0.1709592044353485,
-0.9204750657081604,
-0.35729333758354187,
0.4374193847179413,
-0.06022937223315239,
0.589759349822998,
0.1547957956790924,
-0.9209527969360352,
-0.08265123516321182,
-0.5034744143486023,
-0.006038386840373278,
0.3897070586681366,
-0.44882932305336,
0.47871923446655273,
0.40569067001342773,
-0.21803487837314606,
-0.6443838477134705,
-0.6291490197181702,
0.48834356665611267,
-0.00630301283672452,
-0.9469519853591919,
0.7272184491157532,
0.02634161338210106,
-0.042970359325408936,
0.05892464518547058,
-0.15087231993675232,
-0.4621317982673645,
0.20951113104820251,
0.0025314241647720337,
0.760195255279541,
-0.35638004541397095,
0.01046125777065754,
0.34563007950782776,
-0.018291184678673744,
-0.12996579706668854,
-0.07765918225049973,
0.5768854022026062,
-0.296127587556839,
-0.23566199839115143,
-0.8779892921447754,
0.5355510115623474,
0.037337664514780045,
-0.24152100086212158,
1.0574244260787964,
0.9465446472167969,
-0.7156053781509399,
-0.0505007803440094,
-0.37372642755508423,
-0.17612428963184357,
-0.43028536438941956,
0.5052968263626099,
-0.10021468251943588,
-0.7116391062736511,
0.32193875312805176,
-0.051059797406196594,
0.3152351975440979,
0.3798018991947174,
0.19650228321552277,
-0.1185871884226799,
0.9100180268287659,
0.81032395362854,
0.05748623609542847,
0.7809221148490906,
-0.11278878152370453,
0.19784760475158691,
-0.5126994252204895,
-0.2615510821342468,
-0.27319109439849854,
-0.15142516791820526,
-0.17328251898288727,
-0.32649922370910645,
0.05873052030801773,
0.3064213991165161,
0.3024546802043915,
0.3743305206298828,
-0.508350670337677,
0.35557055473327637,
0.4984831213951111,
0.4996686577796936,
0.775259256362915,
0.4147563874721527,
0.08452542871236801,
-0.4070708751678467,
-0.4524974822998047,
-0.5887985229492188,
0.7977986931800842,
0.2906041741371155,
0.6604782342910767,
0.2035347819328308,
0.7202426195144653,
0.34374767541885376,
0.046167563647031784,
-0.49236568808555603,
0.5469727516174316,
-0.4052673280239105,
-0.7475553750991821,
-0.4241166412830353,
-0.40316256880760193,
-0.707253098487854,
0.45344650745391846,
-0.7087863683700562,
-0.6849619150161743,
0.06031499430537224,
0.03135019540786743,
-0.15809692442417145,
0.6264327764511108,
-0.7040135860443115,
0.6033413410186768,
-0.2763073146343231,
-0.6515015363693237,
0.06262191385030746,
-0.6595969796180725,
0.4795741140842438,
-0.16870778799057007,
0.3025607168674469,
0.2485421597957611,
-0.18805158138275146,
0.9319416284561157,
-0.18077509105205536,
0.8539049029350281,
0.04200899228453636,
-0.42473018169403076,
0.04874749854207039,
0.20903261005878448,
0.9066851139068604,
-0.1488625407218933,
-0.28051573038101196,
0.29195794463157654,
0.060652244836091995,
-0.2890115976333618,
-0.6056721806526184,
0.42277348041534424,
-0.4009421467781067,
-0.5171012878417969,
-0.1429474800825119,
-0.5613470673561096,
0.19936653971672058,
0.7240580320358276,
0.12389423698186874,
0.4554276466369629,
-0.095395527780056,
0.46264567971229553,
0.8433014750480652,
-0.35282278060913086,
0.5207915306091309,
-0.08401502668857574,
-0.17707625031471252,
-0.611551821231842,
0.935522735118866,
0.12077349424362183,
0.47920432686805725,
0.5195274353027344,
0.19347909092903137,
-0.2612534165382385,
-0.7671061754226685,
-0.45405635237693787,
0.33407506346702576,
-0.9297369718551636,
-0.037949271500110626,
-0.502072274684906,
-0.35910096764564514,
-0.5890119075775146,
-0.07641998678445816,
-0.30130159854888916,
-0.4590330421924591,
-0.41865915060043335,
0.17329315841197968,
0.02940458245575428,
0.5019404292106628,
0.146997332572937,
0.22002723813056946,
-0.7764672636985779,
0.5834241509437561,
-0.1408180147409439,
0.12717077136039734,
-0.03985368460416794,
-0.35184434056282043,
-0.21536068618297577,
0.06428992003202438,
-0.13811230659484863,
-0.8924216628074646,
0.6409642696380615,
-0.058497149497270584,
0.44580787420272827,
0.22261694073677063,
0.09104730188846588,
0.7449834942817688,
-0.02721952646970749,
0.696194052696228,
0.46345552802085876,
-1.0165200233459473,
0.2558596432209015,
-0.1631215363740921,
-0.09149438887834549,
0.27197083830833435,
0.09500331431627274,
-0.12177588045597076,
-0.4335172474384308,
-0.5606891512870789,
-0.8545405268669128,
0.5161014795303345,
0.34195467829704285,
-0.1868034303188324,
0.5360682606697083,
0.2929236888885498,
0.3374025523662567,
0.15000994503498077,
-1.1419507265090942,
-0.06185454875230789,
0.002177719958126545,
-0.4405968189239502,
0.3348364233970642,
-0.32571929693222046,
-0.15186245739459991,
-0.04576152190566063,
0.6742530465126038,
0.15455539524555206,
0.11486740410327911,
0.31870460510253906,
-0.2502341866493225,
0.011868719011545181,
0.1649281084537506,
0.3660854995250702,
0.3241366744041443,
-0.22619551420211792,
0.41452035307884216,
-0.07611139118671417,
-0.7725982666015625,
-0.14841103553771973,
-0.020183924585580826,
-0.4912630617618561,
0.31620466709136963,
0.6338056325912476,
0.4432778060436249,
0.17795705795288086,
-0.5297457575798035,
0.6219395399093628,
-0.11174488067626953,
-0.029730793088674545,
-0.10628160089254379,
-0.06844397634267807,
-0.021875526756048203,
0.259585976600647,
0.40782099962234497,
0.4101487994194031,
0.2834910750389099,
-0.41469284892082214,
0.2492195963859558,
0.6707628965377808,
-0.22331106662750244,
-0.285543292760849,
0.5262340903282166,
0.041741374880075455,
-0.2907826006412506,
-0.053794097155332565,
-0.06297947466373444,
-0.4036010503768921,
0.6893138289451599,
0.930244505405426,
0.6549342274665833,
0.026296330615878105,
0.2861200273036957,
0.16163451969623566,
0.6107339262962341,
-0.40985384583473206,
0.10184577852487564,
-0.08175981044769287,
-0.5430973172187805,
-0.38456282019615173,
-0.42921149730682373,
-0.23608459532260895,
-0.02924349159002304,
-0.6152833104133606,
0.43289902806282043,
-0.7890482544898987,
-0.04391571506857872,
0.038795046508312225,
0.10486806929111481,
-0.10937751084566116,
0.11524565517902374,
0.17619535326957703,
0.7037612199783325,
-0.5648400187492371,
0.851595401763916,
0.31284040212631226,
-0.12566329538822174,
-0.7555379271507263,
-0.13798555731773376,
-0.2646218538284302,
-0.645723819732666,
0.5808951258659363,
0.11720192432403564,
-0.23495447635650635,
-0.1360616385936737,
-0.8226130604743958,
-0.7459949851036072,
1.2012165784835815,
0.4430462419986725,
-0.5369476079940796,
-0.18474933505058289,
-0.09773113578557968,
0.5912798643112183,
-0.2331160455942154,
-0.28578659892082214,
0.1757037341594696,
0.35689035058021545,
0.20871128141880035,
-0.7027348279953003,
0.4419519305229187,
-0.18792781233787537,
-0.0037781617138534784,
0.014289158396422863,
-0.38279029726982117,
0.7271775603294373,
0.22016987204551697,
-0.7621569037437439,
0.2975504994392395,
0.7705963253974915,
0.26008808612823486,
0.2737146317958832,
0.3145545423030853,
0.041500918567180634,
0.8539722561836243,
0.10503661632537842,
0.831966757774353,
0.08026491105556488,
0.38082295656204224,
0.9626689553260803,
-0.03574977070093155,
0.9181025624275208,
0.622363805770874,
0.19806064665317535,
0.5899233818054199,
0.3442796468734741,
-0.1366305649280548,
0.4405238628387451,
-0.3055203855037689,
-0.24170935153961182,
-0.20618607103824615,
-0.0869789868593216,
-0.3905794620513916,
0.06709811091423035,
0.33574000000953674,
-0.6613019704818726,
-0.11267097294330597,
-0.09258810430765152,
0.06453285366296768,
0.041669197380542755,
-0.15913933515548706,
0.5471776127815247,
0.08561872690916061,
-0.3194120228290558,
0.5608168840408325,
0.3181757628917694,
1.0348049402236938,
-0.4785726070404053,
-0.17078888416290283,
0.440841943025589,
0.09633442759513855,
-0.34325945377349854,
-0.6870548725128174,
0.2697114050388336,
-0.18655149638652802,
0.06311378628015518,
-0.22481584548950195,
1.2620599269866943,
-0.5404644012451172,
-0.39871007204055786,
0.4391282796859741,
0.04386372119188309,
0.04396643489599228,
0.19291701912879944,
-0.827071487903595,
0.3016391098499298,
0.15671657025814056,
0.10847055166959763,
0.052892886102199554,
0.3010097146034241,
-0.11533662676811218,
0.29477912187576294,
1.003440499305725,
0.4848784804344177,
0.3650696575641632,
-0.07111052423715591,
0.5309053063392639,
-0.7713918685913086,
-0.4838138520717621,
-1.018200159072876,
0.24796342849731445,
-0.7436397075653076,
0.1856786012649536,
0.9031373858451843,
0.33185818791389465,
0.4520687758922577,
-0.05664283037185669,
0.7907984256744385,
-0.09451305866241455,
0.16653212904930115,
-0.7115013003349304,
0.6064515113830566,
-0.4350181221961975,
0.4486531615257263,
-0.802078902721405,
-0.7622082233428955,
-0.6287639737129211,
0.3293960988521576,
-0.16158385574817657,
-0.3746802806854248,
0.5226806998252869,
0.7382018566131592,
-0.05681825429201126,
0.42100125551223755,
0.416316956281662,
0.05745096132159233,
0.4894612431526184,
0.31552231311798096,
0.6119717955589294,
-0.748160719871521,
0.46915265917778015,
-0.4831876754760742,
-0.34650471806526184,
-0.29055216908454895,
-0.7556461095809937,
-0.8639662265777588,
-0.4658580422401428,
-0.10344331711530685,
-0.5734701156616211,
0.012994245626032352,
0.5694158673286438,
0.3998749256134033,
-0.7096391916275024,
-0.008408217690885067,
-0.1915619671344757,
0.3193577527999878,
-0.1599126011133194,
-0.27246612310409546,
0.671623706817627,
0.21863028407096863,
-0.7311078906059265,
0.10463293641805649,
0.692895770072937,
0.525039553642273,
-0.3360723555088043,
-0.007273657713085413,
-0.4169261157512665,
-0.10193087160587311,
0.5571596622467041,
0.2031223177909851,
-0.7132807374000549,
-0.21151964366436005,
0.1199231669306755,
-0.35553136467933655,
0.05900665745139122,
0.4437142610549927,
-0.08930948376655579,
0.7218469977378845,
0.73111891746521,
0.8185849189758301,
0.46378886699676514,
0.1400982141494751,
0.5779109001159668,
-0.4588300287723541,
0.3496153652667999,
0.08477400243282318,
0.3358372151851654,
0.3945198655128479,
-0.6144466996192932,
0.27171042561531067,
0.5070330500602722,
-0.05138157680630684,
-0.996782124042511,
0.09210516512393951,
-1.1956617832183838,
-0.3806869685649872,
0.9924659132957458,
-0.30005255341529846,
-0.546245276927948,
-0.35256749391555786,
-0.4782904088497162,
0.4584770202636719,
-0.41963133215904236,
0.6846452355384827,
0.793208122253418,
0.19049911201000214,
-0.13611234724521637,
-0.41730454564094543,
0.3120165169239044,
0.426993727684021,
-0.8040378093719482,
-0.25230592489242554,
0.20988978445529938,
0.12592408061027527,
0.5318635106086731,
0.35064753890037537,
-0.47424185276031494,
0.2775224447250366,
0.06461404263973236,
-0.011206253431737423,
0.003404023824259639,
-0.08077128231525421,
-0.3144114017486572,
0.4285818040370941,
-0.40442389249801636,
-0.0641118735074997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18838v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18838v2
|
When does word order matter and when doesn't it?
| 2024-02-29T04:11:10 | 2024-03-01T17:40:04 |
Xuanda Chen, Timothy O'Donnell, Siva Reddy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) may appear insensitive to word order changes in natural
language understanding (NLU) tasks. In this paper, we propose that linguistic
redundancy can explain this phenomenon, whereby word order and other linguistic
cues such as case markers provide overlapping and thus redundant information.
Our hypothesis is that models exhibit insensitivity to word order when the
order provides redundant information, and the degree of insensitivity varies
across tasks. We quantify how informative word order is using mutual
information (MI) between unscrambled and scrambled sentences. Our results show
the effect that the less informative word order is, the more consistent the
model's predictions are between unscrambled and scrambled sentences. We also
find that the effect varies across tasks: for some tasks, like SST-2, LMs'
prediction is almost always consistent with the original one even if the
Pointwise-MI (PMI) changes, while for others, like RTE, the consistency is near
random when the PMI gets lower, i.e., word order is really important.
|
[
-0.13289204239845276,
-0.7230337858200073,
0.5283807516098022,
0.31694266200065613,
-0.2801850438117981,
-0.28223204612731934,
0.001637316425330937,
-0.8057520389556885,
0.12388157099485397,
0.2658989727497101,
-0.3049142360687256,
0.02294248342514038,
-1.0896592140197754,
0.1123192235827446,
-0.5760392546653748,
0.9902670383453369,
0.020677058026194572,
-0.028366414830088615,
-0.3908672332763672,
-0.5967554450035095,
-0.6734700202941895,
-0.6922594308853149,
-0.33738309144973755,
-0.6242347359657288,
0.40951523184776306,
0.1751919984817505,
1.2771155834197998,
0.7821269631385803,
0.6279914379119873,
0.41571977734565735,
-0.1569719910621643,
-0.12755154073238373,
-0.39624717831611633,
0.13277047872543335,
-0.29661130905151367,
-0.7921587824821472,
-0.14491240680217743,
0.04308020696043968,
0.14820946753025055,
1.019026756286621,
-0.16487300395965576,
0.00910960789769888,
0.09395832568407059,
0.8544980883598328,
-0.7025129199028015,
0.4353027045726776,
-0.9782671928405762,
-0.11873780936002731,
0.008837061002850533,
-0.2083113193511963,
-0.2619573473930359,
-0.10959536582231522,
0.4387548565864563,
-0.4855080842971802,
0.2779955267906189,
0.08618936687707901,
0.9233667850494385,
0.24122844636440277,
-0.18570145964622498,
-0.343656986951828,
-0.6595162749290466,
0.6263450384140015,
-0.5405296087265015,
0.42816033959388733,
0.7692230343818665,
-0.21866565942764282,
-0.45732566714286804,
-0.38174405694007874,
-0.7345446944236755,
0.07618249207735062,
-0.2954710125923157,
0.31221675872802734,
-0.4180363118648529,
0.2518549859523773,
0.12467131018638611,
0.08765498548746109,
-0.47028785943984985,
0.17231130599975586,
-0.5175575017929077,
0.09519875049591064,
0.4167472720146179,
0.1559961438179016,
0.544789731502533,
-0.11376992613077164,
-0.3557402789592743,
0.10871976613998413,
-0.5907779932022095,
-0.009500526823103428,
0.3070041835308075,
0.2778506278991699,
-0.0673045814037323,
0.893618106842041,
-0.1540248841047287,
0.9849669933319092,
0.18073780834674835,
0.15456433594226837,
0.2554234564304352,
-0.3960376977920532,
-0.4732888638973236,
0.39701905846595764,
0.625711977481842,
0.4608481824398041,
0.2850494980812073,
-0.16278114914894104,
-0.14040513336658478,
0.41484951972961426,
0.4840987026691437,
-0.28823238611221313,
-0.2291722148656845,
0.2485545426607132,
-0.18253982067108154,
0.06411619484424591,
0.21561041474342346,
-0.07368537038564682,
-0.27940985560417175,
-0.37532681226730347,
0.6586982011795044,
-0.5124274492263794,
-0.13058224320411682,
0.3577854335308075,
-0.07962305098772049,
-0.10343066602945328,
0.23205097019672394,
-1.03720223903656,
0.1342833787202835,
0.8574710488319397,
0.5459507703781128,
-0.24085302650928497,
-0.692560076713562,
-0.34792110323905945,
0.09219473600387573,
-0.4324191212654114,
0.6406121253967285,
-0.616959273815155,
-0.054952964186668396,
-0.01861140877008438,
0.17866237461566925,
-0.38742494583129883,
-0.5513899922370911,
0.46799755096435547,
-0.6292529106140137,
0.5537813901901245,
-0.36074498295783997,
-0.7109425663948059,
-0.3435854911804199,
-0.2255527824163437,
-0.39904049038887024,
0.8971337080001831,
-0.09326587617397308,
-1.0622466802597046,
0.526245653629303,
-0.3759854733943939,
-0.5533338189125061,
0.04107149690389633,
-0.07958542555570602,
-0.10182986408472061,
0.5254298448562622,
-0.37552207708358765,
0.5133375525474548,
0.3556053340435028,
0.1878560185432434,
-0.17262907326221466,
-0.6363813877105713,
0.5025291442871094,
-0.24626733362674713,
0.5151857137680054,
-0.02690128982067108,
-0.1702238917350769,
-0.07155611366033554,
-0.6035611033439636,
-0.06170545890927315,
0.16560769081115723,
-0.6085145473480225,
-0.8945746421813965,
0.4281754195690155,
-0.2835499048233032,
0.18136201798915863,
0.13771431148052216,
-0.5151525139808655,
-0.17795448005199432,
-0.5492300391197205,
0.6212480068206787,
0.6265104413032532,
-0.17530997097492218,
0.6283007860183716,
-0.4992251992225647,
0.17513948678970337,
0.30169591307640076,
0.029772190377116203,
0.3378859758377075,
-0.7724109292030334,
-0.8500745892524719,
0.3062347173690796,
0.04702169448137283,
0.7574771642684937,
-0.4038393795490265,
0.18878795206546783,
-0.4068411588668823,
-0.1583808958530426,
-0.5724111199378967,
-0.19187940657138824,
0.5660747289657593,
0.2439073771238327,
0.4093996584415436,
-0.17218196392059326,
-0.49896425008773804,
-1.012335181236267,
-0.5627409815788269,
-0.41985055804252625,
0.11863291263580322,
-0.06239888817071915,
0.3020302951335907,
-0.26647132635116577,
0.7001051902770996,
-0.3394017815589905,
0.1437290459871292,
-0.41209977865219116,
0.3827185034751892,
0.18657797574996948,
0.11059526354074478,
0.2638988196849823,
-0.8190814852714539,
-0.05578707531094551,
-0.07305143028497696,
-0.40650996565818787,
-0.16537058353424072,
-0.13820472359657288,
-0.23285964131355286,
0.5851799249649048,
0.5764672756195068,
-0.7461550235748291,
0.503783643245697,
0.5789414048194885,
-0.3309285044670105,
0.12204849720001221,
-0.6381739377975464,
-0.015437745489180088,
-1.0883171558380127,
-0.49048981070518494,
-0.21605762839317322,
0.12091884016990662,
-0.9661504626274109,
-0.15762101113796234,
0.015664279460906982,
0.4868122339248657,
-0.15983472764492035,
0.3022580146789551,
-0.5591879487037659,
-0.15157370269298553,
-0.4456431269645691,
0.37370729446411133,
0.02568703703582287,
0.39521142840385437,
-0.2162916511297226,
0.5211870074272156,
-0.04274235665798187,
-0.7766919732093811,
-0.4086165428161621,
0.06963877379894257,
-0.6762282252311707,
0.259046345949173,
-0.46310076117515564,
-0.179082989692688,
-0.5591364502906799,
-0.4237287640571594,
-1.0768290758132935,
-0.0803215280175209,
0.06718287616968155,
-0.34692490100860596,
0.3933522701263428,
0.0875580832362175,
-0.4831281900405884,
-0.2358197271823883,
0.20662063360214233,
0.32787588238716125,
0.16127745807170868,
-0.2985782325267792,
0.14484252035617828,
0.5070278644561768,
-0.0697852075099945,
-0.6071706414222717,
-1.0427206754684448,
-0.332883358001709,
-0.04727892577648163,
-0.18201735615730286,
0.37844929099082947,
-0.271261990070343,
-0.6347929239273071,
-0.026315266266465187,
-0.3580196499824524,
-0.43383073806762695,
0.2399655133485794,
0.7082792520523071,
0.20578627288341522,
-0.047609612345695496,
0.5566069483757019,
0.05599919334053993,
0.21999545395374298,
0.17242392897605896,
-0.03381539136171341,
0.37157952785491943,
0.08228091150522232,
-0.28956907987594604,
-0.15394695103168488,
0.3773409128189087,
0.7266213893890381,
0.11652030050754547,
0.8472052812576294,
0.12669961154460907,
-0.3819833993911743,
0.1742469072341919,
-0.5617514848709106,
0.14454422891139984,
-0.4402734041213989,
0.5720514059066772,
-0.30798786878585815,
-0.8028334379196167,
0.37780502438545227,
0.8211766481399536,
0.2459842562675476,
0.41657620668411255,
0.3238818049430847,
-0.40940213203430176,
0.8832967281341553,
0.7029464840888977,
-0.17466571927070618,
0.6919965147972107,
0.2865807116031647,
0.23515497148036957,
-0.5561622381210327,
-0.05626900866627693,
-0.37544867396354675,
-0.27148565649986267,
-0.6746350526809692,
-0.15988391637802124,
-0.1524856984615326,
0.47709569334983826,
-0.20678925514221191,
0.42914628982543945,
-0.4088326692581177,
0.7574421763420105,
0.3527798056602478,
0.10921018570661545,
0.36026960611343384,
0.15522171556949615,
-0.00109718122985214,
-0.10795970261096954,
-0.9629995226860046,
-0.15679500997066498,
0.7229611873626709,
-0.04967745766043663,
0.37709492444992065,
0.30840185284614563,
0.38451817631721497,
0.2054441124200821,
0.1215425357222557,
-0.6950135231018066,
0.4849526584148407,
-0.2854714095592499,
-0.41882452368736267,
-0.2724255919456482,
-0.11108662188053131,
-1.5085444450378418,
0.48305466771125793,
-0.2965216040611267,
-0.7220475673675537,
0.20269358158111572,
-0.09258634597063065,
-0.26691487431526184,
0.031415797770023346,
-1.0794332027435303,
0.3814123868942261,
0.032889045774936676,
-0.06913754343986511,
-0.24794147908687592,
-0.5861355066299438,
0.16481471061706543,
0.017025664448738098,
0.26830121874809265,
-0.2917560935020447,
0.0300586000084877,
0.799096405506134,
-0.71627277135849,
0.7448331713676453,
0.30121490359306335,
0.13400542736053467,
0.10766587406396866,
0.25027722120285034,
0.48811548948287964,
-0.43058207631111145,
-0.10636676847934723,
0.2466641515493393,
-0.07834714651107788,
-0.43086710572242737,
-0.5428591966629028,
0.5918682813644409,
-0.7130807638168335,
-0.8720887303352356,
-0.4872443377971649,
-0.7496399283409119,
-0.0020708709489554167,
0.1368597149848938,
0.720887303352356,
0.4798983037471771,
0.17635273933410645,
-0.28079575300216675,
0.4774227440357208,
0.04571610316634178,
0.6970521211624146,
0.5455582737922668,
0.19125929474830627,
0.0726814940571785,
0.6527251601219177,
0.5663667917251587,
0.6692278385162354,
0.5564553737640381,
0.08369047939777374,
-0.043667636811733246,
-0.7305644750595093,
-0.006549906451255083,
0.42687276005744934,
-0.7635172009468079,
0.02181784249842167,
-0.7462223768234253,
-0.16565760970115662,
-0.1202656477689743,
-0.3503337800502777,
-0.16392287611961365,
-0.4919510781764984,
-0.4422161877155304,
-0.2625933587551117,
0.5901542901992798,
1.2047080993652344,
0.2297363132238388,
0.13250328600406647,
-0.6569698452949524,
0.12605540454387665,
0.1113496944308281,
0.27258339524269104,
-0.14355677366256714,
-0.8446125388145447,
-0.10683492571115494,
0.0005872722249478102,
0.18832485377788544,
-0.845862627029419,
0.3267253637313843,
0.07703191041946411,
0.6297234892845154,
0.40440303087234497,
-0.03553364798426628,
0.8672735691070557,
-0.4898975193500519,
0.4838313162326813,
0.2404649555683136,
-0.7660123705863953,
0.2375914752483368,
-0.3233213722705841,
0.9346001744270325,
0.574245035648346,
0.35531288385391235,
-0.6492977738380432,
-0.8776088953018188,
-0.5702488422393799,
-0.9090975522994995,
0.8617827892303467,
0.17320552468299866,
0.13068583607673645,
-0.45746415853500366,
0.4199754595756531,
0.2130199670791626,
0.12003176659345627,
-0.892008364200592,
-0.24812881648540497,
-0.023691361770033836,
0.007075258530676365,
-0.03469572961330414,
-0.6749053001403809,
-0.02727261558175087,
-0.054066002368927,
0.3873705267906189,
0.259734183549881,
0.4493841230869293,
0.16938160359859467,
-0.341874897480011,
-0.0499633327126503,
0.43711087107658386,
0.9517213106155396,
0.8137137293815613,
-0.1423710435628891,
0.17768411338329315,
0.14680354297161102,
-0.6193467378616333,
-0.17076699435710907,
-0.1541239470243454,
-0.10593331605195999,
0.13598071038722992,
0.7225408554077148,
0.9533817172050476,
0.6024160981178284,
-0.3588496744632721,
0.48398441076278687,
-0.02379927597939968,
-0.18975648283958435,
-0.10723457485437393,
0.09719031304121017,
0.15741877257823944,
0.3108876645565033,
0.011350431479513645,
0.20013102889060974,
-0.023659054189920425,
-0.7538445591926575,
-0.18013602495193481,
0.4979473650455475,
-0.2901701033115387,
-0.298647403717041,
0.46735304594039917,
-0.30091243982315063,
-0.4304236173629761,
0.6212685108184814,
-0.19694699347019196,
-0.4933604896068573,
0.5810943841934204,
0.5270981788635254,
0.6295356750488281,
-0.3121021091938019,
-0.04315852001309395,
0.18306367099285126,
0.5263137817382812,
-0.3447186052799225,
0.5317776799201965,
0.10914362221956253,
-0.9032288193702698,
-0.15281490981578827,
-0.46269258856773376,
-0.12493042647838593,
0.07566700130701065,
-0.7438711524009705,
-0.14728419482707977,
-0.3747340738773346,
-0.2201697826385498,
-0.07267216593027115,
-0.45742493867874146,
-0.46378472447395325,
0.10965359956026077,
-0.167374849319458,
0.49910569190979004,
-0.7527630925178528,
0.7715505361557007,
0.48774242401123047,
-0.17501837015151978,
-0.6254229545593262,
0.1809139996767044,
-0.07018521428108215,
-0.8450865745544434,
0.669954240322113,
0.22970379889011383,
-0.07558087259531021,
-0.3814714848995209,
-0.07944643497467041,
-1.192199945449829,
0.8323709964752197,
0.16681182384490967,
-0.4435577094554901,
0.04853044077754021,
0.3079987168312073,
0.703083872795105,
-0.2712666988372803,
0.21669885516166687,
0.39692679047584534,
0.2592671811580658,
-0.08328987658023834,
-0.8929064869880676,
-0.11013557016849518,
-0.07648556679487228,
0.14608825743198395,
0.6383785009384155,
-0.432839572429657,
0.9075313806533813,
-0.5806096792221069,
-0.7845227718353271,
-0.11469412595033646,
0.5037241578102112,
-0.19317562878131866,
0.0614481158554554,
0.4806731939315796,
0.4618631899356842,
0.7890505790710449,
-0.21517035365104675,
1.0849310159683228,
-0.09671751409769058,
-0.058908648788928986,
1.4905309677124023,
-0.027447383850812912,
1.1229870319366455,
0.5318300724029541,
-0.25618675351142883,
0.43651050329208374,
0.5637310147285461,
0.30908721685409546,
0.5215728282928467,
0.1604117900133133,
0.05403244122862816,
-0.02677704207599163,
0.05147181451320648,
-0.38033202290534973,
0.4376846253871918,
0.3939155340194702,
-0.4660610556602478,
-0.05680323392152786,
-0.11469811946153641,
0.1636660248041153,
-0.039232414215803146,
-0.29724496603012085,
0.782903254032135,
-0.054781224578619,
-0.7489385604858398,
0.7506610751152039,
-0.0558929517865181,
0.5082818865776062,
-0.5180784463882446,
0.29450860619544983,
-0.4406922459602356,
0.12491346895694733,
-0.22370508313179016,
-0.9768214225769043,
0.49769386649131775,
-0.5116071701049805,
-0.7707037925720215,
-0.1529274731874466,
0.4162999093532562,
-0.6452522873878479,
-0.36948204040527344,
0.6295767426490784,
0.3934195935726166,
0.12518268823623657,
0.07737095654010773,
-0.7156553268432617,
0.013797094114124775,
-0.16458429396152496,
-0.28552696108818054,
0.5956588983535767,
0.4455599784851074,
-0.1895071417093277,
0.6293150782585144,
0.36642783880233765,
0.036906056106090546,
0.3987116813659668,
-0.007527461741119623,
0.303602933883667,
-0.44566071033477783,
-0.3713093101978302,
-0.8660964369773865,
0.15911376476287842,
0.1051582545042038,
-0.3221237361431122,
0.7370243072509766,
0.1997031569480896,
1.0610922574996948,
0.010368157178163528,
0.5060133934020996,
0.31597551703453064,
0.29000580310821533,
-0.5780723094940186,
0.6767504811286926,
-0.5497575998306274,
0.29178401827812195,
-0.2516385316848755,
-0.8386526107788086,
-0.3629548251628876,
0.3569733500480652,
-0.41307005286216736,
-0.11771698296070099,
0.961074709892273,
0.7894504070281982,
0.0412098728120327,
0.21427416801452637,
0.44422465562820435,
0.47215431928634644,
-0.4555962085723877,
0.5819284319877625,
0.5221468210220337,
-0.4126429855823517,
0.39480674266815186,
-0.192795529961586,
0.14219734072685242,
-0.2028437703847885,
-0.5915244221687317,
-0.7049684524536133,
-0.8682085871696472,
-0.39628076553344727,
-0.5075130462646484,
0.31624317169189453,
0.8096868991851807,
0.29644688963890076,
-0.6545348167419434,
-0.2575680613517761,
-0.41747286915779114,
0.37693747878074646,
-0.20564040541648865,
-0.25733327865600586,
0.257441908121109,
-0.2042650729417801,
-0.6874582767486572,
0.2877228558063507,
0.5853718519210815,
0.362612247467041,
0.3572131097316742,
0.22044439613819122,
-0.5181851387023926,
0.42550748586654663,
0.740260899066925,
0.3470953404903412,
-1.0582616329193115,
-0.38741275668144226,
-0.2663787305355072,
-0.3970288336277008,
0.2625584900379181,
0.5046504735946655,
-0.49308985471725464,
0.5596162676811218,
0.7997896075248718,
0.2777242660522461,
-0.2068082094192505,
-0.0790337324142456,
0.5238195061683655,
-0.3078449070453644,
0.19187641143798828,
-0.3725256323814392,
0.6999009251594543,
0.1948850452899933,
-0.5052596926689148,
0.3533439338207245,
0.25417378544807434,
-0.454806923866272,
-0.6364728808403015,
0.4777759313583374,
-0.9294237494468689,
-0.6474263072013855,
1.2490019798278809,
0.04314512386918068,
-0.07147008925676346,
-0.3681508004665375,
0.19966378808021545,
0.15566377341747284,
-0.13922356069087982,
0.9505584836006165,
1.1201446056365967,
-0.27225881814956665,
0.062314242124557495,
-0.47780153155326843,
0.45955872535705566,
0.8434292078018188,
-0.49837881326675415,
0.3026520609855652,
0.4223893880844116,
0.190362349152565,
0.22761496901512146,
0.5916089415550232,
0.08954984694719315,
0.053728144615888596,
-0.20374886691570282,
-0.334964781999588,
0.14386320114135742,
-0.18808285892009735,
-0.4258149266242981,
0.08597026020288467,
0.033576469868421555,
-0.22807498276233673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18825v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18825v2
|
Utilizing Local Hierarchy with Adversarial Training for Hierarchical Text Classification
| 2024-02-29T03:20:45 | 2024-03-29T08:08:41 |
Zihan Wang, Peiyi Wang, Houfeng Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hierarchical text classification (HTC) is a challenging subtask of
multi-label classification due to its complex taxonomic structure. Nearly all
recent HTC works focus on how the labels are structured but ignore the
sub-structure of ground-truth labels according to each input text which
contains fruitful label co-occurrence information. In this work, we introduce
this local hierarchy with an adversarial framework. We propose a HiAdv
framework that can fit in nearly all HTC models and optimize them with the
local hierarchy as auxiliary information. We test on two typical HTC models and
find that HiAdv is effective in all scenarios and is adept at dealing with
complex taxonomic hierarchies. Further experiments demonstrate that the
promotion of our framework indeed comes from the local hierarchy and the local
hierarchy is beneficial for rare classes which have insufficient training data.
|
[
-0.37066763639450073,
-1.0306044816970825,
-0.1271873116493225,
-0.32122552394866943,
0.17687341570854187,
0.37231290340423584,
0.2013954222202301,
-0.45242488384246826,
0.011782540008425713,
0.308478444814682,
-0.27444249391555786,
-0.6824848055839539,
-0.6176416277885437,
-0.06479394435882568,
0.04108022525906563,
1.362056016921997,
-0.12918779253959656,
-0.4326022267341614,
-0.16412204504013062,
-0.25373315811157227,
-0.047369204461574554,
-1.2204797267913818,
-0.5049087405204773,
-0.48364222049713135,
0.7886489033699036,
0.2987402379512787,
1.2000433206558228,
1.1189782619476318,
0.6985704898834229,
0.22089868783950806,
-0.5169470310211182,
0.16302725672721863,
-0.5267068147659302,
0.16812945902347565,
0.04686233401298523,
-0.32645392417907715,
-0.676718533039093,
-0.005428279750049114,
0.3854776620864868,
0.6051917672157288,
-0.2557482123374939,
-0.11044692248106003,
-0.08244477957487106,
0.3755088448524475,
-1.1053588390350342,
0.0021809530444443226,
-0.4799685776233673,
0.4215388298034668,
-0.3145569860935211,
-0.49118027091026306,
-0.3489566147327423,
-0.2653456926345825,
0.3791148364543915,
-0.8466895818710327,
0.2873624563217163,
0.12341821193695068,
0.9631588459014893,
0.4146862328052521,
-0.7820425629615784,
-0.3371967673301697,
-0.7599837183952332,
0.5534417629241943,
-0.20436018705368042,
0.0023514507338404655,
0.5852720141410828,
0.30484944581985474,
-0.19587448239326477,
-0.4909321069717407,
-0.13553380966186523,
-0.07392603904008865,
-0.14383196830749512,
0.4071055054664612,
-0.22559994459152222,
0.15042558312416077,
-0.10103452205657959,
0.8117350339889526,
-0.6815176606178284,
0.30279308557510376,
0.01093378197401762,
-0.2682855427265167,
-0.11424261331558228,
0.17458008229732513,
0.24064230918884277,
-0.375154584646225,
-0.8455399870872498,
-0.04258031025528908,
-0.7879948616027832,
0.10359799861907959,
0.4357084035873413,
0.21093760430812836,
-0.050248000770807266,
0.17980776727199554,
-0.017059845849871635,
0.5815601944923401,
0.15739130973815918,
-0.28427115082740784,
0.32481542229652405,
-0.21630482375621796,
-0.3425664007663727,
0.30402371287345886,
0.562767744064331,
-0.34565600752830505,
-0.2705976366996765,
-0.18139614164829254,
-0.1298273801803589,
0.15188854932785034,
0.45150646567344666,
-0.8829043507575989,
-0.4223933517932892,
-0.03884496912360191,
-0.4089965522289276,
-0.9415760636329651,
-0.1672651171684265,
-0.5492054224014282,
-0.6340627074241638,
-0.0055313087068498135,
0.6217917799949646,
-0.05553459748625755,
-0.0756877139210701,
-0.1403326541185379,
-0.00027957369456999004,
-0.25005942583084106,
0.3004094660282135,
-0.9293347001075745,
0.13583999872207642,
0.3608646094799042,
0.8081384897232056,
-0.2601201832294464,
-0.5057939291000366,
-0.7781396508216858,
0.3237844705581665,
-0.17379005253314972,
0.5381583571434021,
-0.4614730477333069,
-0.2936088442802429,
0.02759678289294243,
-0.19850394129753113,
-0.1682882308959961,
-0.6169878244400024,
0.6227129697799683,
-0.7258700132369995,
0.07513099163770676,
0.16334420442581177,
-0.18113988637924194,
0.060996998101472855,
0.6193692684173584,
-0.5705598592758179,
1.0890135765075684,
0.14005190134048462,
-1.5544567108154297,
0.14054648578166962,
-0.3160047233104706,
-0.8156821727752686,
0.11365009844303131,
-0.018810106441378593,
-0.7465312480926514,
-0.4650723934173584,
0.4052574038505554,
0.5206796526908875,
-0.10777997970581055,
0.19724616408348083,
-0.32224172353744507,
-0.4866686165332794,
-0.3851276934146881,
-0.5026043057441711,
0.9012590050697327,
0.36835232377052307,
-0.4370768964290619,
0.11217007040977478,
-0.8144319653511047,
-0.4202963709831238,
-0.03761071711778641,
-0.7654517292976379,
-0.8621588349342346,
-0.2451384961605072,
-0.20067961513996124,
0.1843671202659607,
0.11699395626783371,
-0.3436523973941803,
0.4715110957622528,
-0.5438492298126221,
0.1437300145626068,
0.6732193827629089,
0.2897229790687561,
0.7751343846321106,
-0.42376863956451416,
0.5827370285987854,
0.27676141262054443,
0.14858689904212952,
-0.07488100975751877,
-0.4308840036392212,
-0.4690033793449402,
-0.5762779712677002,
0.3414449095726013,
0.5599753856658936,
-1.2729624509811401,
0.4625495672225952,
-0.10698284953832626,
-0.651554524898529,
-0.400602787733078,
-0.19462934136390686,
0.33719223737716675,
0.6555802226066589,
0.3639358878135681,
0.04584338888525963,
-0.5323472023010254,
-0.8646217584609985,
0.10992322862148285,
-0.22279061377048492,
0.2056385576725006,
0.21013613045215607,
0.8466706871986389,
-0.6522212028503418,
0.6275287866592407,
-0.45525896549224854,
-0.49323564767837524,
0.06505577266216278,
0.881083071231842,
-0.15227434039115906,
0.33787840604782104,
0.46351388096809387,
-0.9843103885650635,
-0.18697568774223328,
0.4006049335002899,
-0.9278609156608582,
0.34142404794692993,
-0.12987971305847168,
-0.23610439896583557,
0.09826669096946716,
0.1819785237312317,
-0.3296579122543335,
0.6856046915054321,
0.4345855414867401,
-0.006491163745522499,
0.39091482758522034,
-0.5092030167579651,
0.3221294581890106,
-1.2028464078903198,
-0.33382514119148254,
0.03174940496683121,
-0.10105763375759125,
-0.7042750120162964,
0.4452384114265442,
0.03209047019481659,
0.0071196467615664005,
-0.40802472829818726,
0.2676651179790497,
-0.16151508688926697,
0.1206645667552948,
-0.3262050151824951,
-0.20728690922260284,
-0.1344241350889206,
0.6830465197563171,
0.16475892066955566,
0.6160421371459961,
0.6477823853492737,
-0.747678816318512,
0.5499904751777649,
0.2948117256164551,
-0.3020183742046356,
0.5153653621673584,
-0.25769487023353577,
-0.1476723849773407,
-0.16282470524311066,
0.49252185225486755,
-0.5444111824035645,
-0.2614394724369049,
0.11690984666347504,
-0.5229824781417847,
0.19060976803302765,
-0.1553356647491455,
-0.6629560589790344,
-0.3619886338710785,
-0.24078892171382904,
0.6509358286857605,
0.37960824370384216,
-1.1179181337356567,
0.36784347891807556,
0.6771484017372131,
0.10271812975406647,
-0.6136904954910278,
-0.4977377653121948,
0.06388689577579498,
-0.31526219844818115,
-0.45541468262672424,
0.5933356881141663,
0.059112124145030975,
0.1315610110759735,
-0.15323373675346375,
-0.184738889336586,
-0.3830162584781647,
0.3536519408226013,
0.3545093238353729,
0.08331339061260223,
-0.4516153931617737,
0.008708413690328598,
-0.2579845190048218,
0.09705810993909836,
-0.1874639093875885,
-0.28834837675094604,
0.06538556516170502,
-0.35292577743530273,
0.09305474162101746,
-0.6415101885795593,
0.08754829317331314,
0.8014160990715027,
-0.18229208886623383,
0.6972552537918091,
0.650795578956604,
-0.6780917048454285,
-0.11535219103097916,
0.20927812159061432,
0.25868722796440125,
-0.43099358677864075,
0.46180588006973267,
-0.4664135277271271,
-0.7427718639373779,
0.22883480787277222,
0.05321710184216499,
-0.24649640917778015,
0.3061555027961731,
0.7664973735809326,
-0.0486169159412384,
1.2840429544448853,
0.5445128083229065,
-0.3341830372810364,
0.25530996918678284,
-0.3084624409675598,
-0.004114795010536909,
-0.5561442375183105,
-0.17023485898971558,
-0.7088140845298767,
-0.03768115118145943,
-0.7379186749458313,
-0.05554800480604172,
0.5028689503669739,
-0.037241607904434204,
-0.633421003818512,
0.6090701818466187,
-0.4874323308467865,
0.309914767742157,
0.7128481864929199,
0.13878057897090912,
0.28799599409103394,
0.3545832633972168,
-0.11397731304168701,
-0.14444448053836823,
-0.9536217451095581,
-0.17519989609718323,
0.45488908886909485,
0.7691911458969116,
1.0491080284118652,
0.12729741632938385,
0.8533331751823425,
0.33269527554512024,
0.4813578128814697,
-0.8731868863105774,
-0.012150206603109837,
-0.2575121223926544,
-0.649032473564148,
-0.05815082788467407,
-0.8460196852684021,
-0.959014892578125,
0.558559238910675,
-0.15469062328338623,
-0.46835169196128845,
0.4994177222251892,
0.015646126121282578,
-0.3251253068447113,
0.6556295156478882,
-0.5267223715782166,
0.9129894971847534,
-0.021142683923244476,
-0.10214482992887497,
0.3420342803001404,
-0.6853821873664856,
0.2498122900724411,
-0.10189589858055115,
0.4884151220321655,
0.5111848711967468,
0.17400898039340973,
0.8262634873390198,
-0.3964823782444,
0.9022037982940674,
-0.015647035092115402,
-0.3643481433391571,
0.20931969583034515,
0.16147974133491516,
0.5897663831710815,
-0.23169229924678802,
-0.09023651480674744,
-0.12012290954589844,
-0.16217385232448578,
-0.45876848697662354,
-0.40194565057754517,
0.6166343092918396,
-1.066709041595459,
-0.2740820348262787,
-0.8857114911079407,
-0.4533587098121643,
-0.3066251575946808,
0.1840435415506363,
0.7726438641548157,
0.5915424823760986,
-0.06901232153177261,
0.5723478198051453,
0.6670891046524048,
0.01817946694791317,
0.017230365425348282,
-0.0028752756770700216,
0.368655800819397,
-0.6144196391105652,
1.0849114656448364,
0.00972314178943634,
0.27558356523513794,
0.741466224193573,
0.40008705854415894,
-0.03273916617035866,
-0.49737921357154846,
-0.5205207467079163,
-0.4795896112918854,
-0.9391890168190002,
-0.4814407229423523,
-0.4911693036556244,
-0.4922637641429901,
-0.29659077525138855,
-0.33892449736595154,
-0.19960281252861023,
-0.24862517416477203,
-0.2790209949016571,
-0.05648716539144516,
-0.2205825001001358,
1.0101622343063354,
0.32641908526420593,
0.6066842675209045,
-0.6075018644332886,
0.7200605273246765,
0.2879766523838043,
-0.08495457470417023,
0.11923511326313019,
-0.7352280020713806,
-0.37756994366645813,
0.15938861668109894,
-0.5460290312767029,
-0.7153474688529968,
0.29659974575042725,
0.05163232237100601,
0.40238064527511597,
0.24750135838985443,
0.4731857180595398,
0.6973203420639038,
-0.31747663021087646,
0.380260705947876,
0.17217698693275452,
-0.5066362619400024,
0.5285988450050354,
-0.6708658933639526,
0.5047711730003357,
0.3838197886943817,
0.7684298753738403,
-0.15432560443878174,
-0.710392415523529,
-0.5424841046333313,
-0.8767006397247314,
0.8144914507865906,
0.7320136427879333,
-0.3132103979587555,
0.15453550219535828,
0.2847755253314972,
-0.001156949670985341,
0.1195300966501236,
-0.9570226669311523,
-0.47803857922554016,
-0.23401904106140137,
-0.23186330497264862,
0.3484990894794464,
0.10419417172670364,
-0.08855432271957397,
-0.3536466956138611,
0.6954777240753174,
0.09932195395231247,
-0.2228216975927353,
0.24290831387043,
-0.07248135656118393,
-0.1053052470088005,
0.3178221881389618,
0.04784347116947174,
0.19972023367881775,
-0.3466314673423767,
0.6376656293869019,
-0.07029872387647629,
-0.5969444513320923,
0.2838191092014313,
-0.0237067099660635,
-0.4432954490184784,
-0.33892732858657837,
0.526305079460144,
0.5709350109100342,
0.2921540141105652,
0.09641055017709732,
0.5052425861358643,
-0.11278746277093887,
-0.41352578997612,
0.43495675921440125,
-0.12523187696933746,
-0.30331486463546753,
-0.14459013938903809,
0.27689117193222046,
0.738469123840332,
0.37488603591918945,
-0.7860929369926453,
0.2552563548088074,
0.021588513627648354,
-0.4383634626865387,
-0.027695706114172935,
0.5069321393966675,
0.2748086750507355,
-0.0512375645339489,
0.22577738761901855,
-0.4208841621875763,
-0.9905388355255127,
0.8583433032035828,
0.7367116808891296,
0.6089401841163635,
-0.3477996587753296,
0.4757702946662903,
0.29449179768562317,
0.24898679554462433,
0.04933777078986168,
-0.47432973980903625,
-0.2663831114768982,
-0.4350624978542328,
0.09102245420217514,
-0.6095023155212402,
-0.5611819624900818,
0.19101423025131226,
-0.7149302959442139,
0.027626890689134598,
-0.42263558506965637,
0.09735402464866638,
0.29190319776535034,
-0.07076789438724518,
-0.20247864723205566,
0.42584651708602905,
0.02723425254225731,
0.5317783355712891,
-0.4991399049758911,
0.9678816199302673,
1.0107146501541138,
-0.22636620700359344,
-0.27849695086479187,
0.45761486887931824,
0.08231987059116364,
-0.5224488377571106,
0.9261988401412964,
0.21964338421821594,
-0.6288408041000366,
-0.07098568230867386,
-0.18680167198181152,
-0.5619765520095825,
0.7133328914642334,
-0.09606179594993591,
-0.005008595995604992,
-0.20506122708320618,
-0.1981736272573471,
0.8207442760467529,
-0.40225687623023987,
-0.24958471953868866,
0.28148943185806274,
0.1811242401599884,
0.5693894624710083,
-0.645496666431427,
-0.1415255069732666,
-0.27219337224960327,
-0.060492098331451416,
0.19240862131118774,
-0.21678504347801208,
0.8138041496276855,
-0.2451453059911728,
-0.23517070710659027,
0.20208555459976196,
0.5195044279098511,
0.020379571244120598,
0.276315838098526,
0.39790603518486023,
0.4731486439704895,
0.8538961410522461,
-0.026016732677817345,
0.9450783133506775,
0.25826430320739746,
0.6302807331085205,
1.1002590656280518,
-0.22681333124637604,
0.7932105660438538,
-0.12007898092269897,
0.1506340652704239,
0.3048817217350006,
1.0192854404449463,
0.04257631674408913,
0.7086031436920166,
0.1937837153673172,
-0.2953835427761078,
-0.3215126693248749,
-0.2849244773387909,
-0.5412817001342773,
0.33759990334510803,
0.09635572135448456,
0.290004163980484,
-0.3334880769252777,
0.25337034463882446,
-0.0734965056180954,
0.13714072108268738,
-0.42723456025123596,
0.6729034185409546,
-0.24625620245933533,
-0.43779802322387695,
1.0730384588241577,
0.28720083832740784,
0.826106071472168,
-0.21692802011966705,
0.1510850489139557,
-0.11378347873687744,
0.6563587784767151,
-0.20180730521678925,
-0.3887844979763031,
0.1890949308872223,
-0.14878924190998077,
-0.26899489760398865,
-0.26134955883026123,
0.6202077865600586,
-0.4108549952507019,
-0.1387346386909485,
0.22480502724647522,
0.1029728427529335,
-0.2775576114654541,
-0.09698746353387833,
-0.5639945268630981,
-0.5011336803436279,
-0.35458236932754517,
-0.22561168670654297,
0.3514358699321747,
0.565076470375061,
-0.053610607981681824,
0.5794981122016907,
0.37531378865242004,
0.0870504379272461,
-0.23837777972221375,
0.00016954858438111842,
0.6356761455535889,
-0.5785761475563049,
-0.9364573955535889,
-0.6897261738777161,
-0.18807466328144073,
0.11780214309692383,
-0.40333154797554016,
0.8312814831733704,
0.6862572431564331,
0.90857994556427,
0.048017192631959915,
0.7612924575805664,
0.292074054479599,
0.13056400418281555,
-0.3301134407520294,
0.7904925346374512,
-0.7965726852416992,
0.18601685762405396,
-0.13053110241889954,
-0.3814246952533722,
-0.5500848889350891,
0.5026428699493408,
-0.17678187787532806,
0.024856222793459892,
0.934734046459198,
0.4298105537891388,
-0.1515558660030365,
0.21643251180648804,
0.3078811764717102,
0.2729593515396118,
0.1187383159995079,
0.8004809617996216,
1.1995495557785034,
-0.5936496257781982,
0.9041426777839661,
-0.37523865699768066,
-0.4826231300830841,
-0.21163611114025116,
-0.4715801775455475,
-1.37057363986969,
-0.4090408682823181,
-0.3608037233352661,
-0.470363587141037,
0.40058833360671997,
0.6304200887680054,
1.0161398649215698,
-0.7895106077194214,
0.03301764652132988,
-0.03836524114012718,
0.35011547803878784,
0.09716638922691345,
-0.21461090445518494,
0.5839980840682983,
-0.15860126912593842,
-0.4361991882324219,
0.20736777782440186,
0.31666359305381775,
0.47582390904426575,
-0.017435044050216675,
-0.16860301792621613,
-0.30767908692359924,
-0.3566139042377472,
0.6503784656524658,
0.1389833241701126,
-0.35668787360191345,
-0.09773144870996475,
-0.03447344899177551,
-0.6912630200386047,
0.3498813807964325,
0.8692585825920105,
-0.7546179890632629,
0.2811812162399292,
0.5799463987350464,
0.9399375915527344,
0.23446549475193024,
0.20039770007133484,
0.3023136556148529,
-1.0674036741256714,
0.07073452323675156,
0.27301257848739624,
0.24005772173404694,
0.19569818675518036,
-0.586797833442688,
0.24809260666370392,
0.4432549476623535,
-0.4743679165840149,
-0.7033947706222534,
0.33263617753982544,
-0.42695605754852295,
-0.5787597894668579,
1.0828627347946167,
-0.1463783085346222,
-0.3242645263671875,
-0.3420374393463135,
-0.34471452236175537,
0.11842834204435349,
-0.12656861543655396,
0.678249180316925,
0.8020851612091064,
0.1065814420580864,
0.35377398133277893,
-0.4663611054420471,
0.5723788738250732,
0.13276788592338562,
-1.1094406843185425,
0.08258320391178131,
0.21150505542755127,
-0.24296320974826813,
0.4267573952674866,
0.539871871471405,
-0.07141141593456268,
0.36752378940582275,
0.11605169624090195,
-0.2461816668510437,
0.02581261657178402,
-0.9098809957504272,
-0.3725980818271637,
0.5522017478942871,
-0.17669732868671417,
-0.2003549188375473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18815v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18815v2
|
How do Large Language Models Handle Multilingualism?
| 2024-02-29T02:55:26 | 2024-05-24T07:59:10 |
Yiran Zhao, Wenxuan Zhang, Guizhen Chen, Kenji Kawaguchi, Lidong Bing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities across
diverse languages. This study explores how LLMs handle multilingualism. Based
on observed language ratio shifts among layers and the relationships between
network structures and certain capabilities, we hypothesize the LLM's
multilingual workflow ($\texttt{MWork}$): LLMs initially understand the query,
converting multilingual inputs into English for task-solving. In the
intermediate layers, they employ English for thinking and incorporate
multilingual knowledge with self-attention and feed-forward structures,
respectively. In the final layers, LLMs generate responses aligned with the
original language of the query. To verify $\texttt{MWork}$, we introduce
Parallel Language-specific Neuron Detection ($\texttt{PLND}$) to identify
activated neurons for inputs in different languages without any labeled data.
Using $\texttt{PLND}$, we validate $\texttt{MWork}$ through extensive
experiments involving the deactivation of language-specific neurons across
various layers and structures. Moreover, $\texttt{MWork}$ allows fine-tuning of
language-specific neurons with a small dataset, enhancing multilingual
abilities in a specific language without compromising others. This approach
results in an average improvement of $3.6\%$ for high-resource languages and
$2.3\%$ for low-resource languages across all tasks with just $400$ documents.
|
[
-0.43612217903137207,
-0.7357887029647827,
0.4281477630138397,
0.5517538785934448,
-0.01170122530311346,
0.12489259243011475,
-0.8304532766342163,
-0.4402405023574829,
0.2597690224647522,
0.36101701855659485,
-0.46641820669174194,
-0.3661317527294159,
-0.5276626348495483,
0.4242513179779053,
-0.015813542529940605,
0.8072351813316345,
-0.17081040143966675,
0.26033157110214233,
0.028281087055802345,
-0.3788079619407654,
-0.28021007776260376,
-0.6516935229301453,
-0.7641395330429077,
-0.7036643624305725,
1.0108026266098022,
0.21895863115787506,
0.5275894999504089,
0.5657681226730347,
0.33581677079200745,
0.41783323884010315,
-0.3759279251098633,
0.23221828043460846,
-0.33649754524230957,
0.07607187330722809,
-0.25547730922698975,
-0.6103736758232117,
-0.6310375928878784,
-0.2890429198741913,
0.7797631025314331,
0.7082741856575012,
-0.2894321084022522,
0.20872633159160614,
0.19312968850135803,
0.5021823644638062,
-0.5053227543830872,
0.21699687838554382,
-0.7188330292701721,
0.16667231917381287,
-0.5409348607063293,
0.026137923821806908,
-0.5839052200317383,
0.3833625018596649,
-0.3627728819847107,
-0.35362568497657776,
-0.04937174916267395,
-0.11435713618993759,
0.4488978385925293,
-0.10305940359830856,
-0.5416419506072998,
-0.10828378796577454,
-0.48361024260520935,
0.6611871719360352,
-0.5710228681564331,
0.5612632632255554,
0.6364191770553589,
0.12122701108455658,
-0.0724283903837204,
-0.29071009159088135,
-0.5524858832359314,
-0.25957751274108887,
-0.07780370116233826,
-0.015837952494621277,
0.05114879831671715,
0.07651866227388382,
0.4369843304157257,
0.2312304973602295,
-0.7249583005905151,
0.6116121411323547,
-0.24730007350444794,
-0.32177838683128357,
0.3764432370662689,
0.02906402014195919,
0.4900486469268799,
-0.09422611445188522,
-0.10676079988479614,
0.06414863467216492,
-0.6128032207489014,
0.015094156377017498,
0.5635863542556763,
0.41564488410949707,
-0.18529553711414337,
0.5641250014305115,
-0.05482446774840355,
0.7181470990180969,
-0.2917529344558716,
-0.27785083651542664,
0.37110424041748047,
-0.3847390413284302,
-0.2651338577270508,
-0.0035464507527649403,
0.8537029027938843,
-0.0035132516641169786,
0.5647783279418945,
-0.17711074650287628,
-0.4758027195930481,
-0.2173483818769455,
0.02932511270046234,
-0.588469922542572,
-0.0035682818852365017,
0.019413921982049942,
-0.3677756190299988,
0.10894882678985596,
-0.6387495994567871,
-0.36683711409568787,
-0.29164576530456543,
-0.23222273588180542,
0.2234368920326233,
-0.1889093667268753,
-0.6504478454589844,
0.1433352530002594,
0.3070862591266632,
-0.05116840824484825,
0.03871313855051994,
-1.0348035097122192,
0.1500965803861618,
0.5312172174453735,
0.8061460852622986,
-0.303680956363678,
-0.896809995174408,
-0.43132635951042175,
0.2890506386756897,
-0.40906819701194763,
0.6591188311576843,
-0.3751790225505829,
0.08330865204334259,
0.13126936554908752,
0.3678983151912689,
-0.2656719386577606,
-0.6207616925239563,
0.19724948704242706,
-0.785183846950531,
-0.06787149608135223,
-0.45565110445022583,
-0.09260837733745575,
-0.11391789466142654,
0.6662129163742065,
-0.7802088856697083,
0.6801596283912659,
-0.4566516876220703,
-0.8511137962341309,
0.057980719953775406,
-0.5492419600486755,
-0.601658284664154,
-0.024183528497815132,
0.031087040901184082,
0.04772821068763733,
0.1499100625514984,
0.2523704171180725,
0.454247385263443,
-0.3266618251800537,
0.26914769411087036,
-0.2963973879814148,
-0.10183848440647125,
0.1358025074005127,
-0.5453028082847595,
0.7830155491828918,
0.06387180089950562,
-0.22448590397834778,
0.07347708195447922,
-0.527728796005249,
0.0556829534471035,
0.20883239805698395,
-0.6322996020317078,
-0.24286924302577972,
-0.02981531247496605,
0.0683526024222374,
0.47877153754234314,
0.1707604080438614,
-0.5853311419487,
0.10857987403869629,
-0.3787260949611664,
0.5386982560157776,
0.651672899723053,
-0.4020695686340332,
0.3741629719734192,
-0.10770117491483688,
0.5374823808670044,
0.14945414662361145,
-0.15714962780475616,
-0.20486995577812195,
-0.43286094069480896,
-0.6353660225868225,
-0.1509135365486145,
0.156270831823349,
0.6301816701889038,
-0.8807296752929688,
-0.13038715720176697,
-0.21508045494556427,
-0.1388307362794876,
-0.3355264961719513,
0.4584720730781555,
0.43158388137817383,
0.2380802482366562,
0.40391433238983154,
-0.049550142139196396,
-0.2107645869255066,
-1.2449777126312256,
-0.18955126404762268,
-0.07264378666877747,
0.18052254617214203,
0.1328321248292923,
0.33186861872673035,
-0.12591926753520966,
0.08711354434490204,
-0.08533090353012085,
-0.1761181354522705,
-0.4239051043987274,
0.08514837175607681,
0.31903746724128723,
0.3335789144039154,
0.46649986505508423,
-0.6508641839027405,
-0.6593111157417297,
0.6503296494483948,
-0.8399351835250854,
-0.1323636770248413,
-0.07771673053503036,
-0.031308744102716446,
0.38747796416282654,
0.5377636551856995,
-0.7668313384056091,
0.07978320121765137,
0.7057765126228333,
0.034237612038850784,
0.5836668610572815,
-0.4245601296424866,
0.15498137474060059,
-1.1225613355636597,
-0.07890233397483826,
0.033629897981882095,
-0.09857270866632462,
-0.6658267378807068,
0.2057599574327469,
0.2784678041934967,
0.049870993942022324,
-0.363337904214859,
0.5307005047798157,
-0.7507973909378052,
-0.1951647698879242,
-0.37983226776123047,
0.10297294706106186,
-0.08606045693159103,
0.571820855140686,
0.05718725919723511,
0.5933895111083984,
0.6343735456466675,
-0.37809720635414124,
0.34881356358528137,
-0.06644005328416824,
-0.4214443862438202,
0.4297523498535156,
-0.528153121471405,
0.14706046879291534,
-0.31969141960144043,
-0.030811166390776634,
-0.91038978099823,
-0.11776356399059296,
-0.07545222342014313,
-0.21581685543060303,
0.3629200756549835,
-0.3543543517589569,
-0.9820106029510498,
-0.31823498010635376,
0.15412861108779907,
0.5958364605903625,
-0.03558224067091942,
-0.5258282423019409,
0.735465943813324,
0.33176326751708984,
-0.35329270362854004,
-0.8047110438346863,
-1.0144479274749756,
0.4037744700908661,
0.04490404203534126,
-0.7344852685928345,
0.12176401913166046,
-0.1684439331293106,
-0.309928834438324,
-0.2606557011604309,
0.1565040647983551,
-0.20752912759780884,
0.10808596760034561,
-0.14684522151947021,
-0.04309086129069328,
-0.4178107976913452,
0.3194679021835327,
0.12338912487030029,
0.13704662024974823,
0.20989912748336792,
-0.35005033016204834,
0.8987006545066833,
-0.07798631489276886,
-0.5178404450416565,
-0.26298782229423523,
0.44082343578338623,
0.7942988276481628,
-0.6824557185173035,
0.8804855346679688,
0.819855272769928,
-0.410293847322464,
-0.3248954713344574,
-0.6746248602867126,
-0.10647149384021759,
-0.46891289949417114,
0.7728620767593384,
-0.7539297938346863,
-0.8221938610076904,
1.0102806091308594,
0.23284317553043365,
-0.019257761538028717,
0.3212329149246216,
1.036422848701477,
0.061247024685144424,
0.9769344329833984,
0.3802715241909027,
-0.11177805066108704,
0.3177005350589752,
-0.05166804417967796,
0.24325911700725555,
-0.7940807938575745,
-0.2654653489589691,
-0.3367907404899597,
-0.4521371126174927,
-0.6431077718734741,
-0.380994975566864,
0.20404799282550812,
0.043996550142765045,
-0.036432746797800064,
0.30722376704216003,
-0.12552441656589508,
0.6226235628128052,
0.23375043272972107,
-0.10033447295427322,
0.2225079983472824,
0.27712899446487427,
-0.5522091388702393,
0.012542211450636387,
-0.6699230074882507,
-0.24293266236782074,
0.8365452289581299,
0.3009827733039856,
0.6569111943244934,
0.27620142698287964,
0.49974390864372253,
-0.0490715466439724,
0.38301655650138855,
-0.6673882007598877,
0.6183313727378845,
-0.2552023231983185,
-0.5739490985870361,
-0.18395498394966125,
-0.48386213183403015,
-0.9014468789100647,
0.7641656398773193,
-0.06273005902767181,
-0.6666765809059143,
0.008092151023447514,
0.0287786852568388,
0.017165817320346832,
0.7313696146011353,
-0.8136557340621948,
0.8903059959411621,
-0.5020925998687744,
-0.49476301670074463,
-0.39873838424682617,
-0.2190537005662918,
0.24060875177383423,
-0.31386345624923706,
0.46295619010925293,
-0.14814943075180054,
0.030834490433335304,
0.5029656887054443,
0.20074430108070374,
0.8766502141952515,
0.004050695337355137,
-0.5530734062194824,
0.02621564455330372,
0.36893773078918457,
0.4483375549316406,
0.15928132832050323,
-0.28321564197540283,
0.3472895622253418,
-0.21350856125354767,
-0.4083697497844696,
-0.2776758372783661,
1.0629205703735352,
-0.6502805948257446,
-0.72164386510849,
-0.179142564535141,
-0.9609872698783875,
-0.2412395477294922,
0.4724786579608917,
0.011363317258656025,
0.2832884192466736,
0.06271630525588989,
0.032855771481990814,
0.48636192083358765,
-0.3884405195713043,
0.6691443920135498,
0.8421681523323059,
-0.3937235176563263,
-0.25642675161361694,
0.7758938670158386,
0.29423415660858154,
0.3487281799316406,
0.42287367582321167,
0.19013065099716187,
-0.17157818377017975,
-0.697100043296814,
-0.5888127088546753,
0.4495929777622223,
-0.7632567882537842,
0.10648659616708755,
-0.8505600690841675,
-0.027057085186243057,
-0.40550506114959717,
0.18740928173065186,
-0.3795033097267151,
-0.058532655239105225,
-0.01933453232049942,
-0.1379549503326416,
-0.12003088742494583,
0.7037505507469177,
0.017412416636943817,
0.18724492192268372,
-0.7276855111122131,
0.25095134973526,
0.28153273463249207,
0.39242246747016907,
0.21131207048892975,
-0.48124703764915466,
-0.508033812046051,
0.1636921912431717,
0.04704173281788826,
-0.7463455200195312,
0.37500423192977905,
0.2083934098482132,
0.6904826760292053,
0.08810430020093918,
-0.4720367193222046,
0.45318058133125305,
-0.8021610975265503,
0.6007101535797119,
0.08880042284727097,
-0.7470024824142456,
0.11344243586063385,
-0.4142766296863556,
0.631229817867279,
0.18246133625507355,
0.40235990285873413,
-0.7547795176506042,
-0.35778719186782837,
-0.015479566529393196,
-0.6887418031692505,
0.7865805625915527,
-0.0430031344294548,
0.35430923104286194,
-0.17580413818359375,
0.26600706577301025,
-0.1505657285451889,
0.2415456473827362,
-1.0729844570159912,
-0.15114618837833405,
0.06397746503353119,
0.010342629626393318,
-0.30591338872909546,
-0.28947487473487854,
-0.31271204352378845,
-0.17225348949432373,
0.2882829010486603,
-0.36847490072250366,
0.09031440317630768,
-0.1974773406982422,
-0.44839122891426086,
-0.027391944080591202,
0.38585174083709717,
0.7374312281608582,
0.857674241065979,
0.21140314638614655,
0.45922404527664185,
0.19767950475215912,
-0.2925712466239929,
0.17566227912902832,
0.0022406417410820723,
0.15917439758777618,
-0.13985536992549896,
0.5181553363800049,
0.7773805856704712,
-0.06948709487915039,
-0.4619958996772766,
0.3328203856945038,
-0.08774235844612122,
-0.16449138522148132,
-0.0033971599768847227,
-0.37695953249931335,
0.5868576765060425,
0.31925174593925476,
0.23387697339057922,
0.05722499266266823,
-0.14132928848266602,
-0.38113105297088623,
-0.10034812241792679,
0.4322863817214966,
0.0023620715364813805,
-0.6135157942771912,
0.4110012352466583,
-0.11393038928508759,
-0.4095952808856964,
0.5613221526145935,
-0.22323976457118988,
-0.5882264971733093,
0.702394425868988,
0.8260722160339355,
0.7767540216445923,
-0.369925320148468,
0.13530556857585907,
0.3295612037181854,
0.7368427515029907,
-0.16649141907691956,
0.22378264367580414,
0.04079683870077133,
-1.007374882698059,
-0.9341351985931396,
-0.6515731811523438,
0.0714874416589737,
0.18476645648479462,
-0.5479544997215271,
-0.11561644077301025,
-0.31521332263946533,
-0.14213328063488007,
0.2990747392177582,
-0.3995974063873291,
-0.6186953186988831,
-0.0420941524207592,
0.4581820070743561,
0.8783886432647705,
-0.8832255601882935,
1.1497048139572144,
0.96439129114151,
-0.13321535289287567,
-0.638777494430542,
-0.013430940918624401,
0.015010449104011059,
-0.9955018758773804,
1.0188941955566406,
0.18528389930725098,
-0.21876035630702972,
-0.09855151176452637,
-0.12520606815814972,
-0.7377455830574036,
0.46897774934768677,
0.7267257571220398,
-0.5751368999481201,
0.16370998322963715,
0.2694333791732788,
0.6665461659431458,
-0.19562841951847076,
0.1915207803249359,
0.23325851559638977,
0.5464863777160645,
-0.24625028669834137,
-1.2816102504730225,
-0.13168364763259888,
-0.3747888505458832,
-0.013686888851225376,
0.2993618845939636,
-0.582058846950531,
1.0485974550247192,
-0.18247966468334198,
-0.019792979583144188,
-0.3528669774532318,
0.3791639804840088,
0.01518205925822258,
-0.0831136554479599,
0.4578039050102234,
0.5661288499832153,
0.7333621978759766,
0.004108157940208912,
1.0907946825027466,
-0.5015842914581299,
0.2517227530479431,
1.0498727560043335,
-0.5023238658905029,
0.9113267660140991,
0.5707144141197205,
0.014025633223354816,
0.3888912498950958,
0.4302710294723511,
0.16598495841026306,
0.20500066876411438,
0.21805816888809204,
-0.28948143124580383,
-0.4932267367839813,
-0.2536289691925049,
-0.08439401537179947,
0.5782338380813599,
0.2848374545574188,
-0.20871098339557648,
-0.2683781087398529,
0.40647879242897034,
0.11900962144136429,
0.057189323008060455,
-0.38450026512145996,
0.7147142887115479,
0.12519040703773499,
-0.8211915493011475,
0.7818604707717896,
0.2954886555671692,
0.740868866443634,
-0.7317414879798889,
0.26119399070739746,
-0.3350478708744049,
0.2551313042640686,
-0.23085685074329376,
-0.9035197496414185,
0.1662404090166092,
-0.06904355436563492,
-0.4229842722415924,
-0.4471319913864136,
0.4823229908943176,
-0.8317831754684448,
-0.5371842384338379,
0.796747624874115,
0.6137080192565918,
-0.0035293386317789555,
-0.12357237190008163,
-0.7322542667388916,
0.19857706129550934,
-0.08457615226507187,
-0.3105262815952301,
0.6041232943534851,
0.5001260042190552,
-0.1811583936214447,
0.72278892993927,
0.5825926661491394,
0.4147147536277771,
0.10240089148283005,
0.36885184049606323,
0.6741374731063843,
-0.3865571618080139,
-0.37690219283103943,
-0.9421093463897705,
0.127627432346344,
0.05576641857624054,
-0.16567781567573547,
0.8279796838760376,
0.4711484909057617,
1.0874372720718384,
-0.07983890175819397,
0.36064615845680237,
0.04966232553124428,
0.009766153059899807,
-0.508892834186554,
0.7911536693572998,
-0.8615326881408691,
0.21688450872898102,
0.1111154556274414,
-0.8185810446739197,
-0.3120005130767822,
0.4355705678462982,
-0.36006560921669006,
0.11568094044923782,
0.9198737144470215,
0.9548285007476807,
-0.13709816336631775,
-0.22909677028656006,
0.4279719889163971,
0.3401387631893158,
0.2805318236351013,
0.5778011679649353,
0.7266870141029358,
0.059839777648448944,
0.47798487544059753,
-0.2481415569782257,
-0.04928244277834892,
0.3484373390674591,
-0.703262209892273,
-1.0105171203613281,
-0.2669050693511963,
-0.16484308242797852,
-0.24418310821056366,
-0.07110603898763657,
0.7852942943572998,
0.6569738388061523,
-0.8438326716423035,
-0.6447017192840576,
0.263999342918396,
0.24992874264717102,
-0.274833083152771,
-0.09852973371744156,
0.2458043247461319,
-0.5605913996696472,
-0.760813295841217,
0.58189457654953,
0.409159392118454,
-0.21261531114578247,
-0.42998969554901123,
0.07323057949542999,
-0.54295814037323,
-0.27123990654945374,
0.7813929915428162,
0.11986222118139267,
-0.7873936295509338,
0.07295837253332138,
0.22987666726112366,
-0.28793007135391235,
0.07685548812150955,
0.8688156604766846,
-0.13175462186336517,
0.4803428649902344,
0.48626306653022766,
0.7616133093833923,
0.3467386066913605,
-0.5656296610832214,
0.5468632578849792,
-0.7770472764968872,
0.37703004479408264,
0.13227297365665436,
0.5825309157371521,
0.4715351164340973,
-0.220517098903656,
0.024609118700027466,
0.15378037095069885,
-0.510041356086731,
-0.747381329536438,
0.23405906558036804,
-0.6647878289222717,
-0.21050477027893066,
1.2222797870635986,
-0.22175614535808563,
-0.3836727440357208,
0.030121946707367897,
-0.01325604971498251,
-0.10056789964437485,
0.010840279050171375,
0.5278140306472778,
0.9950193762779236,
0.14457948505878448,
-0.4160860776901245,
-0.7447906136512756,
0.1924770176410675,
0.6250566244125366,
-0.5943993926048279,
0.1850314438343048,
0.22385859489440918,
0.3460514545440674,
0.29155561327934265,
0.6220743060112,
-0.023560285568237305,
0.04180430248379707,
-0.3760942816734314,
0.2272053360939026,
-0.09189791977405548,
-0.4295707941055298,
-0.3463442921638489,
0.3190510869026184,
0.0981767401099205,
0.005287882871925831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18807v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18807v1
|
On the Decision-Making Abilities in Role-Playing using Large Language Models
| 2024-02-29T02:22:23 | 2024-02-29T02:22:23 |
Chenglei Shen, Guofu Xie, Xiao Zhang, Jun Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are now increasingly utilized for role-playing
tasks, especially in impersonating domain-specific experts, primarily through
role-playing prompts. When interacting in real-world scenarios, the
decision-making abilities of a role significantly shape its behavioral
patterns. In this paper, we concentrate on evaluating the decision-making
abilities of LLMs post role-playing thereby validating the efficacy of
role-playing. Our goal is to provide metrics and guidance for enhancing the
decision-making abilities of LLMs in role-playing tasks. Specifically, we first
use LLMs to generate virtual role descriptions corresponding to the 16
personality types of Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (abbreviated as MBTI)
representing a segmentation of the population. Then we design specific
quantitative operations to evaluate the decision-making abilities of LLMs post
role-playing from four aspects: adaptability, exploration$\&$exploitation
trade-off ability, reasoning ability, and safety. Finally, we analyze the
association between the performance of decision-making and the corresponding
MBTI types through GPT-4. Extensive experiments demonstrate stable differences
in the four aspects of decision-making abilities across distinct roles,
signifying a robust correlation between decision-making abilities and the roles
emulated by LLMs. These results underscore that LLMs can effectively
impersonate varied roles while embodying their genuine sociological
characteristics.
|
[
-0.4574733376502991,
-0.7668554782867432,
0.9195711612701416,
0.3908802568912506,
0.08246180415153503,
0.25440794229507446,
-0.327334463596344,
-0.3466600477695465,
0.1451386660337448,
0.4159155488014221,
-0.27752137184143066,
-0.27270758152008057,
-0.5602467060089111,
0.10468398034572601,
0.18053129315376282,
0.8330000042915344,
0.1453426480293274,
0.3514937460422516,
-0.44878411293029785,
0.24326427280902863,
-0.831963300704956,
-0.7617278695106506,
-1.0030276775360107,
-0.23495601117610931,
0.4997667074203491,
0.27500855922698975,
0.7283255457878113,
0.16641546785831451,
0.5567827820777893,
0.3582017719745636,
-0.13628391921520233,
0.1380523294210434,
-0.5415799021720886,
0.12041017413139343,
-0.5909358263015747,
-0.6708201766014099,
-0.6937573552131653,
0.18618136644363403,
0.7172148823738098,
0.13856141269207,
-0.061942558735609055,
0.21749995648860931,
0.0013163178227841854,
0.23859266936779022,
-0.3794732391834259,
0.34889206290245056,
-0.6694006323814392,
0.0676243007183075,
0.01021407637745142,
-0.29452216625213623,
-0.48261773586273193,
-0.20768842101097107,
0.23317299783229828,
-0.21714867651462555,
-0.21137037873268127,
0.10809887200593948,
0.42597195506095886,
0.05834217369556427,
-0.168683722615242,
-0.32246923446655273,
-0.8262626528739929,
0.5375403761863708,
-0.7969055771827698,
0.21803507208824158,
0.685093104839325,
0.4432927966117859,
-0.2232041209936142,
-0.10760267823934555,
-0.29085856676101685,
-0.40251946449279785,
-0.23328396677970886,
0.11967805027961731,
0.2840176522731781,
0.21278570592403412,
0.6441420316696167,
0.08434993028640747,
-0.017865465953946114,
0.3848254382610321,
-0.40893101692199707,
-0.06560587137937546,
0.7524498105049133,
0.13644841313362122,
0.25447016954421997,
-0.04461462423205376,
-0.0836821049451828,
0.03260493278503418,
-0.6360686421394348,
0.3230709433555603,
0.4516979157924652,
0.08517372608184814,
0.06294026970863342,
0.6009783148765564,
0.17688992619514465,
0.47278571128845215,
0.22505517303943634,
-0.40113234519958496,
-0.02818579226732254,
-0.007446844596415758,
-0.3711034655570984,
-0.081632100045681,
0.4060356914997101,
0.48705339431762695,
0.43706345558166504,
0.001417575404047966,
-0.29972928762435913,
-0.2769435942173004,
0.36030125617980957,
-0.5386056900024414,
0.008224972523748875,
-0.02350725792348385,
-0.6918120980262756,
-0.30838489532470703,
-0.08034651726484299,
-0.7352124452590942,
-0.5511908531188965,
-0.32287994027137756,
0.853348970413208,
-0.40531405806541443,
-0.40752941370010376,
-0.01045224443078041,
-0.20873260498046875,
0.2886227071285248,
0.342909574508667,
-0.81092369556427,
0.3694157004356384,
0.513935923576355,
0.8037543892860413,
-0.20603594183921814,
-0.35140883922576904,
-0.6106351017951965,
0.2263094186782837,
-0.48454731702804565,
0.4673987925052643,
-0.7167348861694336,
-0.5837001204490662,
-0.06811995059251785,
-0.2629672586917877,
-0.2644357681274414,
-0.6840230226516724,
0.6145533323287964,
-0.571494460105896,
-0.25021371245384216,
-0.45581620931625366,
-0.48631948232650757,
-0.1895826756954193,
0.46511515974998474,
-0.6803475022315979,
0.7116636633872986,
0.05972808226943016,
-0.3601744771003723,
0.7808879017829895,
-0.7601272463798523,
-0.3872365355491638,
0.09306156635284424,
-0.3308276832103729,
-0.3706972897052765,
0.2617711126804352,
-0.011936667375266552,
0.7767269611358643,
-0.1688094437122345,
0.19890272617340088,
-0.49551865458488464,
-0.2913837432861328,
0.6959631443023682,
-0.15420378744602203,
0.5048534274101257,
-0.30703282356262207,
-0.16135935485363007,
0.17754293978214264,
-0.250839501619339,
-0.006714913062751293,
-0.12175103276968002,
-0.366542786359787,
-0.339960515499115,
0.4080978035926819,
-0.450336754322052,
0.5488264560699463,
-0.01607266440987587,
-0.2088843435049057,
0.10725461691617966,
-0.038649242371320724,
0.19977369904518127,
0.8228607773780823,
0.15427380800247192,
0.29552018642425537,
-0.44539985060691833,
0.6387581825256348,
-0.25577548146247864,
0.3529449999332428,
0.20347295701503754,
-0.4067363739013672,
-0.5602867007255554,
-0.5046717524528503,
0.21941401064395905,
0.6952235102653503,
-0.8406867980957031,
0.4872819185256958,
-0.04399322718381882,
-0.49502629041671753,
-0.2306259423494339,
-0.12395381182432175,
0.42177683115005493,
0.04573950543999672,
0.2737291753292084,
-0.11327677965164185,
-0.5928789377212524,
-0.8949443101882935,
-0.33157914876937866,
-0.3873293101787567,
0.11217277497053146,
0.5281665921211243,
0.6161948442459106,
-0.09972025454044342,
0.7629539370536804,
-0.2577025890350342,
-0.15424923598766327,
-0.49373897910118103,
-0.267201691865921,
0.16364961862564087,
0.4050278961658478,
0.5385389924049377,
-0.6497384309768677,
-0.45841583609580994,
0.10181975364685059,
-0.6204519867897034,
-0.150494784116745,
-0.35316672921180725,
-0.28314635157585144,
0.2044903039932251,
0.39247384667396545,
-0.8124873042106628,
0.4237057864665985,
0.30343157052993774,
-0.540881335735321,
0.9607474207878113,
-0.29612332582473755,
0.4849378168582916,
-0.3982393443584442,
-0.05377570539712906,
-0.01185753382742405,
-0.03285490348935127,
-0.6058328151702881,
0.160452201962471,
-0.11403758823871613,
0.33468717336654663,
-0.13413605093955994,
0.32920560240745544,
-0.5268508195877075,
-0.50982666015625,
0.0720268040895462,
0.015013229101896286,
-0.3796599209308624,
0.26944661140441895,
-0.04691055789589882,
0.7729505300521851,
0.8063133955001831,
-0.850028395652771,
0.10214812308549881,
0.06609102338552475,
-0.5903950929641724,
0.49365800619125366,
-0.40674567222595215,
-0.11061745882034302,
-0.18599924445152283,
0.10000265389680862,
-0.8835541605949402,
-0.09214023500680923,
-0.022880617529153824,
-0.18521572649478912,
0.4254859685897827,
-0.32646307349205017,
-0.6163634061813354,
-0.2742063105106354,
-0.17268644273281097,
0.06536445766687393,
0.4701579213142395,
-0.06694109737873077,
0.91673743724823,
0.48019465804100037,
-0.4010309875011444,
-0.35646530985832214,
-0.5084922313690186,
0.13289602100849152,
-0.4770948588848114,
-0.3437974452972412,
0.4914278984069824,
-0.44558829069137573,
-0.5685763955116272,
-0.3500571846961975,
-0.08440984040498734,
0.0444071926176548,
0.16093625128269196,
0.0717226043343544,
0.46637600660324097,
0.09012576937675476,
-0.15118001401424408,
0.08887647837400436,
0.05116482079029083,
0.16311822831630707,
0.31913095712661743,
0.3595576584339142,
0.024091703817248344,
-0.32325223088264465,
0.02931373380124569,
0.12738125026226044,
0.767710268497467,
-0.3639456331729889,
0.7358610033988953,
0.31649085879325867,
-0.11520086228847504,
-0.08501448482275009,
-0.7499497532844543,
-0.123931385576725,
-0.4041914939880371,
0.4295271039009094,
-0.42945146560668945,
-0.9215490818023682,
0.666241466999054,
-0.032186370342969894,
0.18431486189365387,
0.13860972225666046,
0.5290068984031677,
-0.09272494912147522,
1.1803349256515503,
0.26478055119514465,
0.2130132019519806,
0.30115872621536255,
-0.04185065999627113,
0.2749614119529724,
-0.9452084302902222,
-0.3360935151576996,
-0.042707886546850204,
-0.4805759787559509,
-0.6446989178657532,
-0.702002763748169,
0.5701251029968262,
0.0766427144408226,
-0.36223167181015015,
0.08087221533060074,
-0.0875321626663208,
0.4028893709182739,
0.14006726443767548,
0.19717861711978912,
0.031831588596105576,
-0.29229381680488586,
0.052205514162778854,
-0.15980879962444305,
-0.5326657891273499,
-0.5373969674110413,
0.7444329857826233,
0.5241025686264038,
0.415091335773468,
0.4883977174758911,
0.528333842754364,
0.3836532235145569,
0.552524745464325,
-0.8253741264343262,
0.9121136665344238,
0.0733766108751297,
-0.6363482475280762,
-0.32577505707740784,
-0.37738654017448425,
-0.37240108847618103,
0.5788147449493408,
-0.7578404545783997,
-0.737700879573822,
-0.0010403655469417572,
0.09607893973588943,
-0.5540465116500854,
0.36188068985939026,
-0.8466106057167053,
0.6127774715423584,
-0.4926412105560303,
-0.4471493661403656,
-0.49426743388175964,
-0.27625492215156555,
0.368117094039917,
-0.16246168315410614,
0.31369808316230774,
0.00703428266569972,
-0.42048656940460205,
0.4178791046142578,
0.39585378766059875,
0.7777549624443054,
-0.4611954689025879,
-0.009092889726161957,
0.13326765596866608,
0.36931079626083374,
0.38524729013442993,
0.10064470767974854,
-0.5515289902687073,
0.15892396867275238,
0.16863100230693817,
0.12116454541683197,
-0.6862304210662842,
0.58542799949646,
-0.5218538045883179,
-0.96600741147995,
-0.33905306458473206,
-0.1694711446762085,
-0.4820724129676819,
0.12136808782815933,
-0.04353930056095123,
0.19740226864814758,
-0.7910798788070679,
0.2479751855134964,
0.6299511194229126,
-0.4386756420135498,
0.40256714820861816,
0.52535480260849,
-0.4980410039424896,
-0.33750638365745544,
0.6577399373054504,
0.49501797556877136,
0.2835588753223419,
0.3984174430370331,
0.2572711110115051,
-0.1902603954076767,
-0.7166436910629272,
-0.2868889570236206,
0.2427835911512375,
-0.3938279449939728,
-0.1803281307220459,
-0.5026107430458069,
-0.108982153236866,
-0.13645361363887787,
-0.19313518702983856,
0.21601292490959167,
0.008620222099125385,
0.04758932441473007,
-0.4528592824935913,
0.007706507109105587,
0.7764859199523926,
-0.06724093109369278,
0.2703169882297516,
-0.5729019641876221,
-0.07826221734285355,
0.28875336050987244,
0.4442206919193268,
0.2098240852355957,
-0.28002285957336426,
-0.2836655080318451,
-0.22530010342597961,
0.06522248685359955,
-0.9478758573532104,
0.14762751758098602,
-0.04306834936141968,
0.9414862990379333,
0.2652001976966858,
-0.36318454146385193,
0.5061296224594116,
-0.48926761746406555,
0.68257737159729,
-0.08888237923383713,
-0.8641034960746765,
0.17154616117477417,
-0.5058800578117371,
-0.10651085525751114,
0.3732503354549408,
0.22356170415878296,
-0.2083899825811386,
-0.15557095408439636,
-0.5073087215423584,
-0.48550471663475037,
0.8954638242721558,
0.3848775625228882,
-0.02208123728632927,
-0.07628588378429413,
0.3037089407444,
0.10569299757480621,
0.27976030111312866,
-0.7427587509155273,
-0.027597002685070038,
0.1471901834011078,
0.37709861993789673,
-0.16531522572040558,
-0.4779008626937866,
-0.0028769720811396837,
-0.4767409861087799,
0.6045817732810974,
0.13471421599388123,
0.20883437991142273,
0.04645388200879097,
0.006165128666907549,
0.15656311810016632,
0.3297322988510132,
0.5208613276481628,
0.7847563028335571,
-0.16006551682949066,
0.05382097512483597,
0.605340301990509,
-0.15063698589801788,
-0.05720873922109604,
-0.10073254257440567,
0.17305561900138855,
-0.3760216534137726,
0.41616788506507874,
0.6264034509658813,
0.3877623975276947,
-0.8379596471786499,
0.3449484705924988,
0.1795056164264679,
-0.10646767169237137,
-0.38433048129081726,
0.4106651246547699,
0.12836062908172607,
0.36069455742836,
0.10279759019613266,
0.005409481469541788,
0.19461259245872498,
-0.9085118770599365,
0.05636143311858177,
0.4619904160499573,
0.0761507973074913,
-0.17109684646129608,
0.046215858310461044,
0.21991778910160065,
-0.48386350274086,
0.16095973551273346,
-0.3310031294822693,
-0.4494238495826721,
0.7141662240028381,
0.5526525974273682,
0.7881454825401306,
-0.5359018445014954,
0.31934359669685364,
0.3371848464012146,
0.45715269446372986,
-0.1511882245540619,
0.14566156268119812,
0.09128052741289139,
-0.8008244633674622,
-0.6718457937240601,
-0.3360138535499573,
-0.22880443930625916,
0.16527444124221802,
-0.5139983296394348,
0.25164926052093506,
-0.7530962228775024,
-0.5276516675949097,
-0.08525550365447998,
-0.04405637085437775,
-0.8593437075614929,
0.2142762690782547,
-0.06737276911735535,
0.7809333205223083,
-0.5205426216125488,
0.37162095308303833,
0.7469415664672852,
-0.31129780411720276,
-0.477375328540802,
0.025928089395165443,
-0.09589709341526031,
-0.6404291391372681,
0.6352807283401489,
0.06942527741193771,
-0.07711923122406006,
-0.13263723254203796,
-0.3799033761024475,
-0.8390474915504456,
1.1655654907226562,
0.11408025771379471,
-0.45926618576049805,
-0.1838136911392212,
-0.1738017499446869,
0.651821494102478,
-0.6277095675468445,
0.630864679813385,
0.7982698678970337,
0.7294594049453735,
-0.07732849568128586,
-1.0270806550979614,
0.01639096438884735,
0.025093965232372284,
0.008799402043223381,
0.18601670861244202,
-0.5585211515426636,
0.6340698599815369,
-0.3100370764732361,
-0.07231072336435318,
-0.022586077451705933,
0.31152552366256714,
0.42634889483451843,
0.07265605032444,
0.8870493173599243,
0.2024572789669037,
0.5930862426757812,
0.2021767646074295,
0.7969574332237244,
-0.10601966828107834,
-0.08453626185655594,
0.7927381992340088,
-0.4849857687950134,
0.8015373945236206,
0.07589141279459,
-0.04667221009731293,
0.6774137616157532,
0.3676218092441559,
-0.08579277992248535,
0.2910611927509308,
0.194159597158432,
-0.12418100982904434,
-0.5340401530265808,
0.23244695365428925,
0.10073164105415344,
0.7662407755851746,
0.7781463265419006,
-0.6127678751945496,
0.18492290377616882,
-0.22309908270835876,
0.24701236188411713,
-0.030307486653327942,
-0.5621323585510254,
0.7791296243667603,
-0.09826802462339401,
-0.8534175753593445,
-0.026515262201428413,
-0.012830223888158798,
0.668539822101593,
-0.6891671419143677,
-0.3478930592536926,
0.2901078164577484,
-0.0027053782250732183,
-0.28789836168289185,
-1.2275985479354858,
0.18317145109176636,
0.07663079351186752,
-0.3708743155002594,
-0.2968760132789612,
0.748217761516571,
-0.21736837923526764,
-0.2394781857728958,
0.5025057792663574,
0.7243242263793945,
0.182648703455925,
0.06200319156050682,
-0.6297017335891724,
0.14860157668590546,
0.0102083133533597,
-0.044515762478113174,
0.49406126141548157,
0.379337877035141,
-0.16032476723194122,
0.5764606595039368,
0.5899157524108887,
0.30038681626319885,
-0.46219122409820557,
0.12580211460590363,
0.5068016052246094,
-0.6674194931983948,
-0.5704469084739685,
-1.0342745780944824,
0.5021541118621826,
-0.5311338901519775,
-0.19996319711208344,
0.7244572043418884,
0.5669935941696167,
0.6904208660125732,
-0.1698780059814453,
0.9827172756195068,
-0.3262055516242981,
0.28791433572769165,
-0.591132402420044,
0.5883839726448059,
-0.08425654470920563,
0.2731534242630005,
-0.3653961718082428,
-0.8325201272964478,
0.044542718678712845,
0.721228837966919,
-0.681252658367157,
0.43983444571495056,
0.4450531005859375,
0.7867745757102966,
0.048889514058828354,
-0.2439788430929184,
0.5994805693626404,
0.35356366634368896,
0.4252011775970459,
0.30339646339416504,
0.8338302373886108,
0.3275218904018402,
0.22110027074813843,
0.21603542566299438,
-0.6514682769775391,
-0.27355632185935974,
-0.9018830060958862,
-1.2516363859176636,
-0.4423488974571228,
0.008836998604238033,
-0.13464775681495667,
-0.15840381383895874,
0.9777348041534424,
0.6607226133346558,
-0.22033026814460754,
-0.4331963062286377,
0.39814338088035583,
0.1358805000782013,
-0.5816106200218201,
-0.2862006425857544,
0.06978219002485275,
-0.1704387068748474,
-0.406330943107605,
0.40914440155029297,
0.39227527379989624,
-0.1223175972700119,
-0.3964260518550873,
-0.06062270700931549,
-0.2232378125190735,
0.5302547216415405,
1.2062404155731201,
-0.01793840527534485,
-0.5765849947929382,
-0.3093685507774353,
-0.05234510451555252,
0.1513855755329132,
-0.2813509702682495,
0.9704412817955017,
-0.43678048253059387,
0.3472024202346802,
0.4628845751285553,
0.33818551898002625,
0.20035743713378906,
-0.12819552421569824,
0.6934327483177185,
-0.24082571268081665,
-0.3277682960033417,
0.27491286396980286,
0.4005182385444641,
0.32369598746299744,
-0.4860704243183136,
0.4693376421928406,
-0.09381566941738129,
-0.7707872986793518,
-0.4934079349040985,
0.28453147411346436,
-0.6632692217826843,
-0.2361854761838913,
1.4488298892974854,
-0.09246813505887985,
0.15997445583343506,
-0.11567148566246033,
-0.5877535343170166,
-0.053722623735666275,
-0.40687525272369385,
0.7829121351242065,
1.0137007236480713,
-0.36905521154403687,
-0.2719738781452179,
-0.7312701940536499,
0.8167738914489746,
0.16482284665107727,
-0.716948926448822,
0.13153387606143951,
0.669922411441803,
0.17140109837055206,
0.068492092192173,
0.6223807334899902,
-0.1069742813706398,
0.04609903320670128,
-0.37719711661338806,
-0.2646715044975281,
0.03693171590566635,
-0.3595712184906006,
-0.021270643919706345,
-0.12412142753601074,
0.26177626848220825,
0.23453305661678314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00839v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00839v1
|
ToolNet: Connecting Large Language Models with Massive Tools via Tool Graph
| 2024-02-29T02:04:00 | 2024-02-29T02:04:00 |
Xukun Liu, Zhiyuan Peng, Xiaoyuan Yi, Xing Xie, Lirong Xiang, Yuchen Liu, Dongkuan Xu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
While achieving remarkable progress in a broad range of tasks, large language
models (LLMs) remain significantly limited in properly using massive external
tools. Existing in-context learning approaches simply format tools into a list
of plain text descriptions and input them to LLMs, from which, LLMs generate a
sequence of tool calls to solve problems step by step. Such a paradigm ignores
the intrinsic dependency between tools and offloads all reasoning loads to
LLMs, making them restricted to a limited number of specifically designed
tools. It thus remains challenging for LLMs to operate on a library of massive
tools, casting a great limitation when confronted with real-world scenarios.
This paper proposes ToolNet, a plug-and-play framework that scales up the
number of tools to thousands with a moderate increase in token consumption.
ToolNet organizes tools into a directed graph. Each node represents a tool, and
weighted edges denote tool transition. Starting from an initial tool node, an
LLM navigates in the graph by iteratively choosing the next one from its
successors until the task is resolved. Extensive experiments show that ToolNet
can achieve impressive results in challenging multi-hop tool learning datasets
and is resilient to tool failures.
|
[
-0.2986156642436981,
-0.4924601912498474,
0.5848727226257324,
0.2994648218154907,
-0.005040768068283796,
0.37732431292533875,
-0.21609501540660858,
-0.23794110119342804,
0.021066339686512947,
0.5646923184394836,
-0.46084439754486084,
-0.4377630650997162,
-0.46211254596710205,
0.07795867323875427,
-0.5471590161323547,
0.6236395835876465,
0.07164066284894943,
-0.09235620498657227,
-0.2803810238838196,
-0.07493411749601364,
-0.6425454020500183,
-0.2684650421142578,
-1.0388100147247314,
-0.4918688237667084,
0.7186225056648254,
0.43652909994125366,
0.667823851108551,
0.6493699550628662,
0.39860010147094727,
0.3892814517021179,
-0.04814132675528526,
0.12528270483016968,
-0.5569098591804504,
0.19627955555915833,
-0.1779266893863678,
-0.534511923789978,
-0.3979117274284363,
-0.2502281665802002,
0.6106758117675781,
1.0544217824935913,
0.10816480964422226,
0.2867104411125183,
-0.01397339254617691,
0.25420230627059937,
-0.23118245601654053,
0.09688398241996765,
-0.6946295499801636,
0.0054258545860648155,
-0.25390350818634033,
0.034666210412979126,
-0.5309320092201233,
0.17640157043933868,
0.09713080525398254,
-0.5549529790878296,
-0.08714153617620468,
0.11253621429204941,
0.37898874282836914,
0.14374563097953796,
-0.5719243288040161,
-0.1150856614112854,
-0.7151615619659424,
0.5217541456222534,
-0.6285006403923035,
0.34712764620780945,
0.32246553897857666,
0.4032374918460846,
-0.4480738639831543,
-0.963970422744751,
-0.36299553513526917,
-0.2096042037010193,
0.10454889386892319,
-0.26522549986839294,
0.13779579102993011,
-0.2617744505405426,
0.456685870885849,
0.042563408613204956,
-0.586603581905365,
0.48587849736213684,
-0.349993497133255,
-0.07737128436565399,
0.4539124071598053,
0.3110285997390747,
0.21796321868896484,
0.05263020470738411,
-0.19474071264266968,
-0.11969433724880219,
-0.9000776410102844,
-0.15772391855716705,
0.3208603262901306,
0.7042607069015503,
-0.12538301944732666,
0.3524211645126343,
0.1743425875902176,
0.9235001802444458,
-0.18729807436466217,
-0.3011401295661926,
0.18168017268180847,
-0.12755636870861053,
-0.2621171474456787,
0.031139925122261047,
0.7281947135925293,
-0.025369122624397278,
0.01900056004524231,
-0.26544222235679626,
-0.21267658472061157,
-0.40522557497024536,
0.31180500984191895,
-0.8868042230606079,
-0.12480252236127853,
0.3132821321487427,
-0.08867703378200531,
-0.3293288052082062,
-0.20056995749473572,
-0.3139931261539459,
-0.7623662948608398,
-0.29448401927948,
0.48680320382118225,
-0.061210811138153076,
-0.5015785098075867,
0.0338609404861927,
-0.026453400030732155,
0.09938272088766098,
0.3903881311416626,
-0.3868088126182556,
0.2974455952644348,
0.7806310057640076,
1.4730339050292969,
-0.10998056828975677,
-0.23286427557468414,
-0.7942385077476501,
0.1127796471118927,
-0.42214542627334595,
0.3167576789855957,
-0.4632529616355896,
-0.5062348246574402,
0.005689640995115042,
0.43882113695144653,
0.09571382403373718,
-0.49265676736831665,
-0.051849279552698135,
-0.5793105959892273,
-0.06823151558637619,
-0.0535571426153183,
-0.496590793132782,
-0.22110971808433533,
0.3636908531188965,
-0.8700003027915955,
1.0538229942321777,
0.15626348555088043,
-0.7939050793647766,
0.0856032595038414,
-0.5557417273521423,
-0.6510071754455566,
0.19320306181907654,
-0.10997986793518066,
-0.2470277100801468,
0.03229536488652229,
-0.1956905722618103,
0.6998350620269775,
-0.5054430961608887,
0.5020006895065308,
-0.6617575883865356,
-0.45900759100914,
0.002070832531899214,
-0.13907980918884277,
1.0319271087646484,
0.0486508347094059,
-0.23225070536136627,
0.3962172865867615,
-0.664395272731781,
-0.4011420011520386,
0.266235888004303,
-0.38990968465805054,
-0.30594292283058167,
-0.03101213276386261,
0.21102309226989746,
0.57883620262146,
-0.03130988031625748,
-0.6075855493545532,
0.4429249167442322,
-0.48595067858695984,
0.8003350496292114,
0.8417696356773376,
-0.44400277733802795,
0.3400062024593353,
-0.01345895417034626,
0.4963304400444031,
0.07636738568544388,
-0.08017229288816452,
-0.2319466918706894,
-0.1925116330385208,
-0.6829093098640442,
0.06213338300585747,
0.40630438923835754,
0.5294480919837952,
-0.8693594932556152,
0.43499934673309326,
-0.4628657400608063,
-0.6278868317604065,
-0.1256522238254547,
0.24248963594436646,
-0.04886438697576523,
0.4592728614807129,
0.07985605299472809,
-0.5456687808036804,
-0.3121485114097595,
-0.6048463582992554,
0.18056878447532654,
-0.09376921504735947,
-0.30642619729042053,
0.42925581336021423,
0.4985591173171997,
-0.1162099689245224,
0.9341625571250916,
-0.27437737584114075,
-0.3501730263233185,
-0.5065425634384155,
-0.14886265993118286,
0.429154634475708,
0.3861956298351288,
0.23136933147907257,
-0.6549243330955505,
-0.47199365496635437,
0.2669826149940491,
-0.4314214587211609,
-0.05319471284747124,
-0.4199475944042206,
-0.10819835215806961,
-0.1839352250099182,
0.9528645873069763,
-0.22840942442417145,
0.11307654529809952,
0.736412525177002,
-0.24683667719364166,
0.6493383646011353,
-0.10820747911930084,
-0.5253579020500183,
-1.3673642873764038,
0.36223098635673523,
-0.022249974310398102,
-0.635573148727417,
-0.5395593643188477,
-0.058697715401649475,
-0.017844557762145996,
-0.3906218409538269,
-0.5371097922325134,
0.8515226244926453,
-0.23179763555526733,
-0.2785112261772156,
-0.1785217821598053,
0.28649693727493286,
-0.022905932739377022,
0.3243725597858429,
-0.13116960227489471,
0.8253265023231506,
0.8912423253059387,
-0.3993989825248718,
0.6659389138221741,
0.18567217886447906,
-0.14818644523620605,
0.35730594396591187,
-0.7886845469474792,
0.11822285503149033,
0.2291015237569809,
0.5714885592460632,
-0.7845235466957092,
-0.22972828149795532,
-0.013837259262800217,
-0.015093372203409672,
0.3097130358219147,
-0.4053787887096405,
-0.7907496690750122,
-0.3000997006893158,
-0.12484864145517349,
0.3344098627567291,
0.08981896191835403,
-0.643336296081543,
0.8965423107147217,
0.2650890052318573,
-0.18162506818771362,
-0.48424214124679565,
-0.4938203692436218,
0.5601214170455933,
-0.24721622467041016,
-0.5604760050773621,
-0.0053883944638073444,
-0.01179128885269165,
-0.13720129430294037,
-0.16763362288475037,
-0.10919249057769775,
0.1259477436542511,
0.2262498289346695,
0.3878049850463867,
0.17502550780773163,
-0.06042446941137314,
0.5270717144012451,
-0.22173239290714264,
0.0030654266010969877,
0.2352764755487442,
-0.6505146026611328,
0.6675124764442444,
0.062063734978437424,
-0.5109632611274719,
0.17425954341888428,
0.26288819313049316,
0.8427769541740417,
-0.11504171043634415,
0.7297431826591492,
0.8481043577194214,
-0.18498441576957703,
-0.46951398253440857,
-0.4047287106513977,
-0.1612502783536911,
-0.5420200228691101,
0.6045172810554504,
-0.47731950879096985,
-1.06427001953125,
0.5068933963775635,
-0.8006470799446106,
0.41419801115989685,
0.03815364092588425,
0.5636462569236755,
0.1622033268213272,
1.0049861669540405,
0.645772397518158,
-0.1914471834897995,
0.5439666509628296,
-0.32766857743263245,
0.24798598885536194,
-0.9095743894577026,
0.10692915320396423,
-0.27487677335739136,
-0.46393463015556335,
-0.3857782483100891,
-0.5232058167457581,
0.4144919514656067,
-0.06522073596715927,
-0.4298535883426666,
0.46831631660461426,
-0.20517221093177795,
0.49076491594314575,
0.5983489155769348,
-0.0009409136255271733,
0.19825422763824463,
-0.19154274463653564,
-0.4094724655151367,
0.5219910740852356,
-0.9813578724861145,
-0.21325384080410004,
1.1077042818069458,
0.3837989866733551,
0.5539573431015015,
0.17512977123260498,
0.5121762752532959,
0.13173465430736542,
0.22075776755809784,
-0.9700518846511841,
0.7390515208244324,
-0.06386345624923706,
-0.5147569179534912,
-0.40471193194389343,
-0.5680989623069763,
-0.9544185996055603,
0.2460850179195404,
-0.06285472959280014,
-0.6754403710365295,
-0.11736618727445602,
-0.03740067780017853,
-0.1103500947356224,
0.5201997756958008,
-0.5418081283569336,
0.9076361060142517,
-0.25393158197402954,
-0.5819870829582214,
-0.06893724948167801,
-0.8093934655189514,
0.21406571567058563,
-0.2966098487377167,
0.4212031662464142,
-0.008355257101356983,
0.09821105003356934,
0.5962410569190979,
-0.48093661665916443,
1.1711888313293457,
0.02457059733569622,
-0.25600871443748474,
0.0028842645697295666,
0.4895068407058716,
0.796823263168335,
0.042412396520376205,
0.08885694295167923,
0.010055223479866982,
-0.14124031364917755,
-0.33307209610939026,
-0.5050340890884399,
0.7848328948020935,
-0.5924015045166016,
-0.46925848722457886,
-0.14820200204849243,
-0.7426788806915283,
-0.4270111322402954,
0.43236595392227173,
-0.24557451903820038,
0.9864388704299927,
-0.02084529399871826,
0.22141869366168976,
0.4293572008609772,
-0.3454095423221588,
0.4887908399105072,
0.08871382474899292,
-0.523954451084137,
0.00013871757255401462,
0.9786710143089294,
0.14821040630340576,
0.48557695746421814,
0.10891443490982056,
0.20158632099628448,
-0.14485183358192444,
-0.377469003200531,
-0.53501296043396,
0.2843312621116638,
-0.8047195672988892,
-0.2159387618303299,
-0.4610339403152466,
-0.02304871939122677,
-0.12995953857898712,
-0.2750087380409241,
-0.3308737874031067,
-0.366550087928772,
-0.18386921286582947,
-0.04825829342007637,
0.4522544741630554,
0.8873203992843628,
0.06948524713516235,
0.32551538944244385,
-0.5153310298919678,
-0.1753225326538086,
0.4634121060371399,
0.6419708728790283,
0.352632075548172,
-0.3285681903362274,
-0.4801803529262543,
-0.4024883806705475,
-0.1002642959356308,
-0.5408350229263306,
0.22566303610801697,
0.14366188645362854,
0.06319240480661392,
0.44197434186935425,
0.07353298366069794,
0.529803991317749,
-0.6899018883705139,
0.576574981212616,
0.3140307664871216,
-0.8020756840705872,
0.18389900028705597,
-0.45160701870918274,
0.5751407742500305,
0.1837429404258728,
0.3466554284095764,
-0.883270800113678,
-0.5115941762924194,
-0.5172722339630127,
-1.1705039739608765,
0.6422251462936401,
-0.24460330605506897,
0.13871660828590393,
0.1294105350971222,
0.13203337788581848,
0.12127596884965897,
0.09555128961801529,
-0.5964404344558716,
-0.03637655824422836,
-0.08173713088035583,
-0.11279948800802231,
-0.18277624249458313,
0.2632480263710022,
-0.2862298786640167,
-0.17923608422279358,
0.5974319577217102,
-0.5376488566398621,
-0.12137917429208755,
-0.3112018406391144,
-0.297866553068161,
0.2130371630191803,
0.05744433030486107,
0.25253036618232727,
0.8979246616363525,
0.10849880427122116,
0.5065126419067383,
0.33915677666664124,
-0.35330629348754883,
0.08531167358160019,
-0.06070505455136299,
0.05920349061489105,
-0.13170599937438965,
0.4637732207775116,
0.8328067660331726,
0.29382529854774475,
-0.8081793189048767,
0.5008420348167419,
0.029273957014083862,
-0.07472562789916992,
-0.3176272213459015,
0.035537220537662506,
0.6971361637115479,
0.3991847038269043,
0.159631609916687,
-0.10476333647966385,
-0.01871984824538231,
-0.40285706520080566,
0.1659931093454361,
0.4698812961578369,
-0.6825322508811951,
-0.21010588109493256,
0.4287372827529907,
0.4528399109840393,
-0.48475080728530884,
0.5775412321090698,
-0.17116716504096985,
-0.39775389432907104,
0.5278065800666809,
0.5562739968299866,
0.7947190403938293,
0.26031655073165894,
0.21404731273651123,
0.3085920810699463,
0.30789709091186523,
-0.11750490218400955,
-0.13987630605697632,
-0.013687671162188053,
-0.548481822013855,
-0.8152748346328735,
-0.5238518714904785,
-0.3773059844970703,
0.18096338212490082,
-0.23693837225437164,
0.2528301775455475,
-0.5567458868026733,
-0.2187855839729309,
-0.24000629782676697,
-0.13810153305530548,
-0.7859535217285156,
-0.15286490321159363,
-0.04894942045211792,
1.1066865921020508,
-0.9310907125473022,
0.8709968328475952,
0.6864725947380066,
-0.1386251449584961,
-1.0432865619659424,
-0.2858707904815674,
0.3089350163936615,
-0.6816743612289429,
0.6208541393280029,
0.3397464156150818,
-0.15566621720790863,
0.3135855197906494,
-0.4791332483291626,
-0.6824655532836914,
1.1066508293151855,
0.36681947112083435,
-0.6249673366546631,
-0.04053299501538277,
-0.015168838202953339,
0.20452356338500977,
-0.3463303744792938,
0.1487359255552292,
0.3795267641544342,
0.39610615372657776,
0.3052893280982971,
-1.1131147146224976,
0.28998035192489624,
-0.05242336541414261,
0.0795244574546814,
0.26837602257728577,
-0.42022448778152466,
0.7359841465950012,
-0.021086422726511955,
-0.06959082186222076,
-0.4586924910545349,
0.23042109608650208,
0.012439055368304253,
-0.14700068533420563,
0.8291360139846802,
0.43043211102485657,
0.4369269907474518,
0.07896366715431213,
0.75007164478302,
-0.09796037524938583,
0.2363279163837433,
1.0670816898345947,
-0.35927844047546387,
0.6960676312446594,
0.37312889099121094,
-0.22465698421001434,
0.3120708763599396,
0.6276747584342957,
0.08823228627443314,
-0.06022767722606659,
0.551711916923523,
-0.333369642496109,
-0.5592772364616394,
-0.3410249352455139,
-0.04800545796751976,
0.44061478972435,
0.3178790807723999,
-0.1523430496454239,
-0.30587247014045715,
0.17382556200027466,
0.11089217662811279,
-0.3690944015979767,
-0.3010236322879791,
0.8452513813972473,
0.14277209341526031,
-0.12424396723508835,
0.2821865975856781,
-0.22293861210346222,
0.536196768283844,
-0.7017869353294373,
-0.16701161861419678,
0.022761525586247444,
0.016089795157313347,
-0.12921981513500214,
-0.5874279141426086,
0.12755684554576874,
-0.2820061445236206,
0.10608942806720734,
-0.2011871039867401,
0.6959161162376404,
-0.38070914149284363,
-0.6962059140205383,
0.5175495147705078,
0.6843066215515137,
0.07435131818056107,
0.14425309002399445,
-0.6239000558853149,
0.1780470460653305,
-0.35907405614852905,
-0.3596594035625458,
0.6895908117294312,
0.5966724157333374,
-0.16998286545276642,
0.9646602869033813,
0.6376489400863647,
0.30088019371032715,
-0.12382753193378448,
0.30811166763305664,
1.006576418876648,
-0.2865159809589386,
-0.5743669867515564,
-0.6787219047546387,
0.489003449678421,
-0.2757684588432312,
-0.08684182167053223,
0.6178297400474548,
0.32799404859542847,
0.9568516612052917,
0.2222943902015686,
0.798954963684082,
-0.1859588474035263,
0.3179579973220825,
-0.14588305354118347,
0.6176929473876953,
-0.701143741607666,
0.23516251146793365,
-0.14566776156425476,
-0.7989264726638794,
-0.4313758909702301,
0.4026780128479004,
-0.16191041469573975,
-0.08908672630786896,
0.5601436495780945,
0.7271689176559448,
-0.4702460765838623,
-0.40367391705513,
0.3383617699146271,
0.2930488884449005,
0.5210292339324951,
0.2955658435821533,
0.3242279887199402,
0.09864077717065811,
0.6741704940795898,
-0.007525722961872816,
-0.2093396633863449,
-0.20649626851081848,
-1.0208306312561035,
-1.041007399559021,
-0.6187808513641357,
-0.19554652273654938,
-0.3226834237575531,
-0.25820186734199524,
1.1134730577468872,
0.8947811722755432,
-0.5677077174186707,
-0.6660194396972656,
-0.12158738821744919,
0.2979445159435272,
-0.26222503185272217,
-0.20230995118618011,
0.31466808915138245,
-0.34581229090690613,
-0.5432844758033752,
0.49296942353248596,
0.4387802183628082,
-0.32063019275665283,
-0.754101574420929,
0.13089284300804138,
-0.24559077620506287,
-0.07482890039682388,
0.6898170709609985,
0.27138668298721313,
-0.5027830004692078,
-0.41446009278297424,
-0.15988481044769287,
0.1667829006910324,
-0.2005406618118286,
1.01662015914917,
-0.8917371034622192,
0.6172856092453003,
0.3539583384990692,
1.051267385482788,
0.4798893928527832,
-0.5022591352462769,
0.7056726813316345,
-1.1216808557510376,
0.18808209896087646,
0.058144960552453995,
0.3572451174259186,
0.43534034490585327,
0.03734244033694267,
0.5810050964355469,
0.10135216265916824,
-0.47641029953956604,
-1.006472110748291,
0.6003443598747253,
-0.7782150506973267,
-0.46909838914871216,
1.0480070114135742,
-0.19107678532600403,
-0.06745372712612152,
-0.5191961526870728,
-0.20753686130046844,
0.12907572090625763,
-0.1766110360622406,
0.49894431233406067,
0.6178799867630005,
0.012377847917377949,
-0.09675765782594681,
-0.8620438575744629,
0.18539880216121674,
-0.012850113213062286,
-0.4749130606651306,
0.33746910095214844,
0.32326647639274597,
0.24846385419368744,
0.21151743829250336,
0.32808637619018555,
0.3646616041660309,
-0.12765707075595856,
-0.028657663613557816,
-0.09931065887212753,
-0.5520685315132141,
-0.4388158917427063,
-0.16893541812896729,
0.20562511682510376,
0.2167525738477707,
0.1793213039636612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18797v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18797v1
|
ARTiST: Automated Text Simplification for Task Guidance in Augmented Reality
| 2024-02-29T01:58:49 | 2024-02-29T01:58:49 |
Guande Wu, Jing Qian, Sonia Castelo, Shaoyu Chen, Joao Rulff, Claudio Silva
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, H.1.2; I.2.7
|
Text presented in augmented reality provides in-situ, real-time information
for users. However, this content can be challenging to apprehend quickly when
engaging in cognitively demanding AR tasks, especially when it is presented on
a head-mounted display. We propose ARTiST, an automatic text simplification
system that uses a few-shot prompt and GPT-3 models to specifically optimize
the text length and semantic content for augmented reality. Developed out of a
formative study that included seven users and three experts, our system
combines a customized error calibration model with a few-shot prompt to
integrate the syntactic, lexical, elaborative, and content simplification
techniques, and generate simplified AR text for head-worn displays. Results
from a 16-user empirical study showed that ARTiST lightens the cognitive load
and improves performance significantly over both unmodified text and text
modified via traditional methods. Our work constitutes a step towards
automating the optimization of batch text data for readability and performance
in augmented reality.
|
[
-0.2694968283176422,
-0.7464332580566406,
0.7441737055778503,
0.2326188087463379,
-0.6785135269165039,
-0.07068333774805069,
-0.05811981111764908,
-0.6832767724990845,
0.31574180722236633,
0.5745817422866821,
-0.5827665328979492,
-0.4286895990371704,
-0.745019793510437,
0.5323508977890015,
-0.16544672846794128,
0.9474784135818481,
-0.47934985160827637,
-0.5962762832641602,
0.022243982180953026,
-0.0696740448474884,
-0.7959238886833191,
0.21678732335567474,
-0.45278656482696533,
-0.0726405680179596,
0.7058168053627014,
0.6312494277954102,
0.8793097734451294,
1.002647042274475,
0.814949631690979,
0.24680790305137634,
0.056594133377075195,
0.6180645823478699,
-0.29376721382141113,
0.20216064155101776,
0.004999309312552214,
0.09725195169448853,
-0.42731359601020813,
-0.13849827647209167,
0.19024141132831573,
0.5155242085456848,
0.22604462504386902,
0.46275588870048523,
0.03859622776508331,
0.7598609328269958,
-0.8591120839118958,
-0.03634461760520935,
-0.00421370891854167,
0.06453432887792587,
-0.047322630882263184,
-0.3663989305496216,
-0.029466964304447174,
-0.18202443420886993,
0.3201240301132202,
-1.2261714935302734,
-0.03584587946534157,
0.6105644702911377,
0.5292416214942932,
0.7502697110176086,
-0.2813522219657898,
-0.13304869830608368,
-0.8104498386383057,
0.7572449445724487,
-0.289437860250473,
0.2995828092098236,
0.15934564173221588,
0.1911289095878601,
0.1943085640668869,
-0.6751951575279236,
-0.8579759001731873,
0.05487876757979393,
-0.165333554148674,
-0.10456060618162155,
-0.09809315204620361,
0.1911676526069641,
0.44246262311935425,
0.21305008232593536,
-0.5498546361923218,
-0.6520254015922546,
-0.31131839752197266,
-0.07352899014949799,
0.39245492219924927,
0.05406973510980606,
0.7576332092285156,
-0.159059077501297,
-0.4199274480342865,
-0.14854876697063446,
-0.6359893679618835,
-0.24642065167427063,
0.2724071741104126,
0.11314046382904053,
0.008372141979634762,
0.9272575378417969,
-0.10565216839313507,
0.9422834515571594,
-0.12283498048782349,
-0.18596966564655304,
0.010213060304522514,
-0.21139925718307495,
-0.2305217683315277,
0.017097236588597298,
0.6904774904251099,
0.7102261185646057,
0.009450075216591358,
-0.20606498420238495,
-0.3479609489440918,
-0.04511237144470215,
0.28924545645713806,
-0.7203370332717896,
-0.38749703764915466,
0.012043429538607597,
-0.23150292038917542,
0.048899706453084946,
-0.2723475694656372,
-0.3821827471256256,
-0.698868453502655,
-0.6188971400260925,
0.7452765703201294,
-0.3132213056087494,
-0.014489812776446342,
0.1644846647977829,
-0.1978699415922165,
-0.5671283006668091,
0.7171374559402466,
-0.6657841801643372,
0.02426716312766075,
0.28135043382644653,
0.9830917119979858,
-0.4082812964916229,
-0.275748610496521,
-0.5421358942985535,
0.46481776237487793,
-0.5603207349777222,
1.013109564781189,
-0.4213092625141144,
-0.4792725741863251,
-0.41116318106651306,
-0.39970850944519043,
0.1493377685546875,
-0.42468753457069397,
0.6667578220367432,
-0.5008930563926697,
0.005383291747421026,
-0.39005979895591736,
-0.3349796235561371,
-0.1488066017627716,
0.2517620623111725,
-0.9946759343147278,
0.7737711071968079,
0.04619221389293671,
-0.7866231203079224,
0.5623974800109863,
-0.8008854985237122,
-0.1803130954504013,
0.42736345529556274,
-0.38095977902412415,
-0.30529382824897766,
-0.06722189486026764,
0.46447986364364624,
0.28444838523864746,
0.08371423929929733,
-0.4966981112957001,
0.26858747005462646,
-0.8891224265098572,
-0.34710824489593506,
-0.05979565158486366,
0.19118985533714294,
0.385040819644928,
-0.4556417167186737,
-0.116123728454113,
-0.8265926837921143,
-0.1824730932712555,
-0.23167216777801514,
-0.22521205246448517,
-0.44317132234573364,
-0.11396574229001999,
0.3857065737247467,
-0.05666954442858696,
0.4014001786708832,
-0.47053658962249756,
0.2758258581161499,
-0.41693875193595886,
-0.3245787024497986,
0.4211789667606354,
0.1352221667766571,
0.6476207971572876,
-0.31556642055511475,
0.6673219203948975,
-0.0465715229511261,
-0.13182519376277924,
-0.35278555750846863,
-0.5502944588661194,
-0.5712413191795349,
-0.46742740273475647,
0.13933078944683075,
0.8630983233451843,
-1.1952065229415894,
-0.0637945830821991,
-0.1539868861436844,
-0.0333162285387516,
-0.32420969009399414,
0.7885880470275879,
0.4370664954185486,
0.6794463992118835,
0.28254958987236023,
-0.3055095374584198,
-0.43006715178489685,
-0.7179140448570251,
-0.7896481156349182,
-0.09980273991823196,
-0.15464343130588531,
0.19016966223716736,
0.29674673080444336,
-0.3293478488922119,
1.0018810033798218,
-0.3939358592033386,
-0.7054013013839722,
-0.03570037707686424,
0.5461601614952087,
0.1298239827156067,
0.5898343324661255,
0.43256476521492004,
-0.8500324487686157,
-0.5305783152580261,
-0.03645117208361626,
-0.7475746870040894,
-0.20776717364788055,
-0.2841418385505676,
-0.1940802037715912,
0.061286699026823044,
0.41251620650291443,
-0.5926429033279419,
0.7843369245529175,
0.3578614294528961,
-0.4766005873680115,
0.2396371215581894,
-0.3191797733306885,
0.3975135385990143,
-0.5726439356803894,
-0.011183186434209347,
0.21395625174045563,
-0.2996768355369568,
-0.4782414734363556,
-0.06849083304405212,
-0.15973901748657227,
-0.11030206084251404,
-0.43399953842163086,
0.7310789227485657,
-0.5882619023323059,
0.320033997297287,
-0.5960326194763184,
0.21902255713939667,
0.29930293560028076,
0.487648069858551,
0.13709570467472076,
1.048867106437683,
0.30727148056030273,
-0.5882304310798645,
0.4733729660511017,
0.26890355348587036,
-0.5835819244384766,
0.7719742655754089,
-0.7603490948677063,
0.3093462288379669,
-0.1900666058063507,
-0.05821453034877777,
-0.9874296188354492,
-0.38936927914619446,
0.6186597347259521,
-0.07471299916505814,
0.006137227173894644,
-0.08273782581090927,
-0.9381606578826904,
-0.0009461912559345365,
0.015600095503032207,
0.9394657611846924,
0.227559432387352,
-0.4285217523574829,
1.081358790397644,
-0.0275783222168684,
-0.17287592589855194,
-0.31983625888824463,
-0.7263576984405518,
0.2560361921787262,
-0.032166313380002975,
-0.614213228225708,
0.37694481015205383,
-0.2765456438064575,
-0.34495222568511963,
-0.1263578236103058,
-0.06904568523168564,
0.226394921541214,
-0.41073787212371826,
0.3118573725223541,
0.3345229923725128,
0.12098948657512665,
0.1248706579208374,
0.09238994866609573,
-0.1527944654226303,
-0.2796008884906769,
0.1112385168671608,
-0.049763187766075134,
-0.06814876198768616,
-0.37925493717193604,
-0.8647449612617493,
0.6484010219573975,
0.2021513283252716,
0.2046109288930893,
0.38889774680137634,
0.6317626237869263,
-0.30802249908447266,
0.07127980142831802,
-0.49458977580070496,
0.08259938657283783,
-0.5002604126930237,
-0.09712635725736618,
-0.44013723731040955,
-0.5874529480934143,
0.38848361372947693,
-0.23622174561023712,
0.22040008008480072,
0.5665650963783264,
0.29018038511276245,
-0.2917969822883606,
1.3303003311157227,
0.8975541591644287,
0.5762003660202026,
0.6205803751945496,
-0.3202984631061554,
0.3109901547431946,
-0.7238373160362244,
-0.15100769698619843,
0.05270828679203987,
-0.520734965801239,
-0.09197554737329483,
-0.1996317356824875,
0.782333254814148,
0.046628642827272415,
-0.3152844309806824,
0.30666330456733704,
-0.9357202053070068,
0.8147963285446167,
0.5285152196884155,
0.47469085454940796,
0.5714177489280701,
-0.011754103004932404,
0.1175592839717865,
-0.20195308327674866,
-0.24538414180278778,
-0.8419661521911621,
0.8895007371902466,
0.10346795618534088,
0.8651018738746643,
0.20450320839881897,
0.640377402305603,
0.4408247768878937,
0.0775381326675415,
-0.7403302192687988,
0.28159862756729126,
0.01663803867995739,
-0.475178062915802,
-0.1203383058309555,
-0.14618133008480072,
-0.21533389389514923,
-0.1327264904975891,
-0.34664031863212585,
-0.5218115448951721,
0.41053736209869385,
0.6082696318626404,
-0.782737672328949,
0.21730633080005646,
-1.190456748008728,
0.8043384552001953,
0.14841561019420624,
-0.2997010052204132,
0.27457261085510254,
-0.5580464005470276,
0.16090402007102966,
-0.12681370973587036,
0.2416120022535324,
-0.19626976549625397,
-0.43606022000312805,
0.8485676646232605,
-0.5813137292861938,
0.6953362822532654,
-0.08358693867921829,
-0.15396302938461304,
0.3681991994380951,
0.38108861446380615,
0.7981615662574768,
-0.023537732660770416,
0.1305130273103714,
-0.23474346101284027,
0.09149770438671112,
-0.34751322865486145,
-0.7098053097724915,
0.6122474670410156,
-0.6603134274482727,
-0.2735142111778259,
-0.2660975158214569,
-0.6887772083282471,
0.020178398117423058,
0.3272966146469116,
0.4417040944099426,
0.5116848945617676,
0.11138242483139038,
-0.27898815274238586,
0.783801257610321,
0.06297692656517029,
0.5160868167877197,
-0.11672176420688629,
-0.1536099761724472,
-0.3999890685081482,
0.8965558409690857,
-0.19639907777309418,
-0.15420502424240112,
0.21313752233982086,
-0.0935303345322609,
-0.25303706526756287,
-0.37857213616371155,
-0.9741277694702148,
0.026119275018572807,
-0.905718982219696,
-0.13298186659812927,
-0.6097571849822998,
0.5270718336105347,
-0.12498726695775986,
-0.45139190554618835,
-0.1052405908703804,
-0.5849722027778625,
-0.8418611884117126,
0.23795248568058014,
0.688332736492157,
0.813853919506073,
0.009390815161168575,
0.828926146030426,
-0.5855380296707153,
0.9451471567153931,
0.7272831201553345,
0.5340136885643005,
-0.44049403071403503,
-0.3757266104221344,
-0.2748667001724243,
-0.03485698997974396,
-0.3224410116672516,
-0.5593119263648987,
0.405409038066864,
0.5063776969909668,
0.10136525332927704,
0.3134307563304901,
0.0036045738961547613,
0.8079256415367126,
-0.7687361240386963,
0.933331310749054,
0.4327273368835449,
-0.8797243237495422,
0.6850932836532593,
-0.3397727906703949,
0.4579457640647888,
0.7857639193534851,
0.024877702817320824,
-0.4211772680282593,
-0.18111789226531982,
-0.389193594455719,
-0.8526326417922974,
0.6711331009864807,
0.38053208589553833,
0.19950193166732788,
0.14633411169052124,
0.5450139045715332,
0.10499422997236252,
0.2522222101688385,
-0.5142232179641724,
-0.49635595083236694,
-0.24182146787643433,
-0.4712052345275879,
-0.01766723208129406,
-0.25301501154899597,
-0.49889078736305237,
-0.3139651119709015,
0.47257786989212036,
-0.14825057983398438,
0.4038352072238922,
0.42554083466529846,
-0.32778018712997437,
-0.44646647572517395,
-0.04062306508421898,
0.8510535359382629,
0.9620423316955566,
-0.17681513726711273,
0.12455067783594131,
0.04361608996987343,
-0.8533465266227722,
0.040745802223682404,
0.07089102268218994,
-0.21566852927207947,
0.27673375606536865,
0.3298497498035431,
0.972611665725708,
-0.17110902070999146,
-0.7884451746940613,
0.7115328907966614,
-0.00044395061559043825,
-0.055673275142908096,
-0.30211666226387024,
-0.0043329461477696896,
-0.6451753973960876,
0.36589911580085754,
0.805202066898346,
0.5601464509963989,
0.5720645785331726,
-0.15053455531597137,
0.10674494504928589,
-0.027022620663046837,
-0.269756555557251,
-0.029166996479034424,
1.0168616771697998,
0.180385023355484,
-0.45878925919532776,
0.031287096440792084,
-0.21669498085975647,
-0.30239972472190857,
0.27634134888648987,
0.16134771704673767,
0.9659635424613953,
0.37242093682289124,
0.10806011408567429,
-0.032011013478040695,
0.2339489459991455,
-0.3293548822402954,
0.6046759486198425,
-0.17977958917617798,
-0.30226558446884155,
-0.8535683155059814,
-0.34543970227241516,
-0.7309921979904175,
-0.49343839287757874,
-0.15045197308063507,
0.3709225356578827,
-0.4396754205226898,
-0.15500077605247498,
-0.04968947172164917,
0.08721337467432022,
-0.7514722347259521,
0.45433974266052246,
0.27752137184143066,
0.747346043586731,
-0.7600335478782654,
0.09330520033836365,
0.8906444907188416,
-0.47766581177711487,
-0.7617760896682739,
-0.23111028969287872,
0.08501237630844116,
-0.556667685508728,
0.9382264018058777,
-0.09694521129131317,
-0.5715053677558899,
0.2556127905845642,
-0.8395861387252808,
-0.44348663091659546,
0.8092061877250671,
0.3546448349952698,
-0.41331011056900024,
-0.1669909954071045,
0.06791936606168747,
0.5518609285354614,
-0.5045665502548218,
0.2961326241493225,
0.32992905378341675,
0.479929655790329,
0.35795357823371887,
-0.7575960159301758,
-0.1371372789144516,
-0.42958348989486694,
0.2222534567117691,
0.15447819232940674,
-0.10751688480377197,
0.5403319001197815,
-0.2618667781352997,
-0.17812201380729675,
0.09105122089385986,
0.8480545878410339,
0.42359381914138794,
0.4968836307525635,
0.6049664616584778,
0.6516165137290955,
0.21583068370819092,
-0.05624759942293167,
1.0760257244110107,
-0.27225854992866516,
0.11251350492238998,
0.7622405886650085,
0.27334484457969666,
0.5925436615943909,
0.6847925186157227,
0.3807569444179535,
0.7067650556564331,
0.7189485430717468,
0.2720387578010559,
0.816842794418335,
-0.25370875000953674,
-0.5755369067192078,
-0.32710403203964233,
-0.0025670831091701984,
-0.05690613016486168,
0.02875044010579586,
0.1494756042957306,
-0.34350210428237915,
-0.09734494984149933,
0.44460779428482056,
-0.23633942008018494,
0.1242116242647171,
-0.3998936414718628,
0.7450798153877258,
-0.052157703787088394,
-0.36691027879714966,
0.4854508936405182,
-0.20855818688869476,
0.7197886109352112,
0.04068990424275398,
-0.42770275473594666,
-0.009113851934671402,
-0.04524989798665047,
-0.29092299938201904,
-0.7578051686286926,
0.2892650067806244,
0.03627874702215195,
-0.21657952666282654,
-0.6704510450363159,
0.44777822494506836,
-0.4491015076637268,
-0.73161381483078,
-0.48099443316459656,
0.27227866649627686,
0.21002303063869476,
-0.45224207639694214,
-0.6246297955513,
0.3236819803714752,
-0.3143814504146576,
-0.23528118431568146,
-0.33732175827026367,
0.6913794875144958,
0.04789408668875694,
0.6351487040519714,
0.3393176794052124,
0.21183575689792633,
0.01352828647941351,
0.015396825037896633,
0.7640404105186462,
-0.5229382514953613,
-0.508490800857544,
-0.5573897361755371,
0.5795263648033142,
0.1545904278755188,
-0.4600971043109894,
0.5754083395004272,
0.7158689498901367,
0.600789487361908,
-0.17246031761169434,
0.5871283411979675,
-0.043964311480522156,
0.9025469422340393,
-0.34766337275505066,
0.7524740099906921,
-0.917499303817749,
0.5260448455810547,
-0.7155368328094482,
-0.951227605342865,
-0.7531077265739441,
0.5517431497573853,
-0.17485716938972473,
0.026776308193802834,
0.5838179588317871,
0.4821458160877228,
-0.18059025704860687,
-0.23403704166412354,
0.1844681352376938,
-0.5362253785133362,
-0.03542555496096611,
0.25946488976478577,
0.4821467399597168,
-0.8445874452590942,
0.7988659739494324,
-0.6319741606712341,
-0.06762707233428955,
-0.20799659192562103,
-1.0465848445892334,
-0.9303459525108337,
-0.6409553289413452,
-0.8266832232475281,
-0.0219983272254467,
-0.13680149614810944,
0.9929197430610657,
0.4702674448490143,
-0.5341130495071411,
0.1470215618610382,
-0.007457426283508539,
-0.00595702463760972,
-0.269413024187088,
-0.161751851439476,
0.6163226962089539,
0.006466597784310579,
-0.8384672999382019,
0.1740490198135376,
0.3627806007862091,
0.41068094968795776,
-0.07522962987422943,
-0.041251808404922485,
0.15491102635860443,
-0.05286373198032379,
0.6843583583831787,
0.3617976903915405,
-0.7611388564109802,
-0.30944281816482544,
0.015759719535708427,
-0.17585426568984985,
0.01779777742922306,
0.6571409702301025,
-0.9188267588615417,
0.9378962516784668,
0.5438748598098755,
0.3690946102142334,
0.16170479357242584,
0.2604849338531494,
0.4403993785381317,
-1.0455405712127686,
0.17994174361228943,
0.24977774918079376,
-0.02298709563910961,
0.3170047104358673,
-0.6817160248756409,
0.36901071667671204,
0.23895971477031708,
-0.5188753008842468,
-0.6827675104141235,
-0.04641267657279968,
-1.2798070907592773,
0.06351915746927261,
1.0563682317733765,
0.2751455008983612,
-0.31632891297340393,
-0.23810938000679016,
-0.7752402424812317,
0.23714551329612732,
-0.3406827449798584,
0.6936478614807129,
0.5122328996658325,
-0.32429930567741394,
-0.8695883750915527,
-0.6946642994880676,
0.8753256797790527,
0.09107786417007446,
-0.4229709506034851,
-0.33379754424095154,
0.6955969929695129,
-0.042359352111816406,
0.34386733174324036,
0.5206061601638794,
0.2967761158943176,
0.6161073446273804,
-0.17767977714538574,
0.32382646203041077,
-0.2187858670949936,
-0.36541512608528137,
-0.08331125229597092,
-0.13422317802906036,
-0.12472578883171082,
-0.3136599361896515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18792v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18792v1
|
MPAT: Building Robust Deep Neural Networks against Textual Adversarial Attacks
| 2024-02-29T01:49:18 | 2024-02-29T01:49:18 |
Fangyuan Zhang, Huichi Zhou, Shuangjiao Li, Hongtao Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Deep neural networks have been proven to be vulnerable to adversarial
examples and various methods have been proposed to defend against adversarial
attacks for natural language processing tasks. However, previous defense
methods have limitations in maintaining effective defense while ensuring the
performance of the original task. In this paper, we propose a malicious
perturbation based adversarial training method (MPAT) for building robust deep
neural networks against textual adversarial attacks. Specifically, we construct
a multi-level malicious example generation strategy to generate adversarial
examples with malicious perturbations, which are used instead of original
inputs for model training. Additionally, we employ a novel training objective
function to ensure achieving the defense goal without compromising the
performance on the original task. We conduct comprehensive experiments to
evaluate our defense method by attacking five victim models on three benchmark
datasets. The result demonstrates that our method is more effective against
malicious adversarial attacks compared with previous defense methods while
maintaining or further improving the performance on the original task.
|
[
-0.17981579899787903,
-1.17330002784729,
0.2828989624977112,
-0.048490289598703384,
-0.3446148633956909,
-0.04537666216492653,
-0.059389397501945496,
0.1454831063747406,
-0.24795183539390564,
0.8486263155937195,
-0.49462205171585083,
-0.41132649779319763,
-0.8641926050186157,
-0.2556878626346588,
-0.3875953257083893,
1.1266249418258667,
0.40172937512397766,
0.1351405382156372,
-0.059081390500068665,
-0.012636978179216385,
-0.5879188179969788,
-0.7523894309997559,
-0.9056100845336914,
-0.04117196798324585,
0.5323852300643921,
0.10669132322072983,
0.5197456479072571,
0.512920081615448,
0.825349748134613,
0.38712045550346375,
0.17011895775794983,
0.24452976882457733,
-0.5046754479408264,
0.5354731678962708,
0.11731957644224167,
-0.4776400625705719,
-0.24402987957000732,
0.1342717409133911,
0.4321998357772827,
0.01179279014468193,
-0.023907175287604332,
0.04340565204620361,
0.017113253474235535,
0.38812097907066345,
-0.7965483665466309,
-0.3504713475704193,
-0.9560425877571106,
0.10926138609647751,
-0.32927966117858887,
-0.2826382517814636,
-0.6977062821388245,
-0.05357471480965614,
-0.15286774933338165,
-0.24407346546649933,
-0.023410717025399208,
-0.46048736572265625,
0.8787384629249573,
0.5505707263946533,
-0.48225656151771545,
0.031347669661045074,
-0.4317896068096161,
0.7456343173980713,
-1.0166079998016357,
-0.140333354473114,
0.36838576197624207,
0.3298782408237457,
-0.5012577176094055,
-0.7860968708992004,
-0.3425794541835785,
-0.5881305932998657,
-0.08834747225046158,
0.05171820521354675,
-0.4056404232978821,
0.07300049066543579,
0.31599321961402893,
0.07921034097671509,
-0.6035098433494568,
-0.09118319302797318,
0.2327994555234909,
-0.24913720786571503,
0.4775923192501068,
0.010796872898936272,
0.5207476615905762,
-0.19116449356079102,
-0.7045425772666931,
-0.5358635187149048,
-0.568668782711029,
0.030604708939790726,
0.8890832662582397,
0.4118680953979492,
0.2488521933555603,
0.5158635377883911,
0.10442589968442917,
0.4171801507472992,
-0.20076628029346466,
-0.1527736783027649,
-0.1346348226070404,
-0.07268386334180832,
-0.2287512719631195,
0.02373480796813965,
0.9789302349090576,
-0.14142940938472748,
0.22647568583488464,
-0.1274385005235672,
-0.3920462727546692,
0.3045799136161804,
0.7056779265403748,
-0.9147796034812927,
-0.5492941737174988,
-0.022161327302455902,
-0.37120163440704346,
-0.9034210443496704,
-0.03565472736954689,
-0.979375422000885,
-0.7896389365196228,
0.0084481630474329,
0.5773361921310425,
-0.7612518072128296,
-0.062096793204545975,
-0.07825074344873428,
-0.008554902859032154,
-0.04800485074520111,
-0.07684768736362457,
-0.5506742596626282,
0.4883615970611572,
0.543618381023407,
0.32987385988235474,
0.21743136644363403,
-0.516352117061615,
-1.0174251794815063,
-0.08145194500684738,
0.038781825453042984,
0.6407233476638794,
-0.47411584854125977,
-0.18222343921661377,
-0.2000378668308258,
-0.4425079822540283,
-0.11407585442066193,
-0.24939318001270294,
0.8129149079322815,
-0.4688337445259094,
0.22139449417591095,
-0.013859737664461136,
0.01988815888762474,
-0.3270942270755768,
0.5417977571487427,
-0.5328975319862366,
0.86036616563797,
-0.36809486150741577,
-0.8716384768486023,
0.10391729325056076,
-0.6266857385635376,
-0.8666722178459167,
-0.15987098217010498,
0.024370279163122177,
-0.8812186121940613,
0.08216305077075958,
0.7445176243782043,
0.6235318183898926,
-0.019796710461378098,
0.038077425211668015,
-0.27630963921546936,
-0.16364634037017822,
0.23855562508106232,
-1.0085010528564453,
0.9594921469688416,
0.17518694698810577,
-0.5773513317108154,
0.22968581318855286,
-0.8081793785095215,
-0.05223455652594566,
0.5163227915763855,
-0.2788392901420593,
-0.4973733425140381,
0.18234339356422424,
-0.23482762277126312,
-0.11468879878520966,
0.14827726781368256,
-0.535641074180603,
0.2532213628292084,
-0.5492555499076843,
0.41059356927871704,
0.7311379313468933,
0.3816611170768738,
-0.017327990382909775,
-0.21549275517463684,
0.5561877489089966,
-0.27471038699150085,
0.19422240555286407,
-0.3289335370063782,
-0.21617962419986725,
-0.5872372388839722,
-0.41454774141311646,
0.34699130058288574,
0.5726797580718994,
-0.8905183672904968,
0.20736414194107056,
0.032469213008880615,
-0.4859760105609894,
-0.36877650022506714,
0.15488289296627045,
0.5851067304611206,
0.4344947636127472,
0.5438628792762756,
0.1902168244123459,
-0.631070077419281,
-0.6925261616706848,
-0.49380210041999817,
-0.1174633577466011,
0.014162232168018818,
0.07281725108623505,
0.5357465744018555,
-0.012127844616770744,
0.2550695240497589,
-0.28987663984298706,
-0.3648608922958374,
-0.053165264427661896,
0.2936537265777588,
-0.1118793711066246,
0.46684399247169495,
0.7099162340164185,
-0.878005862236023,
-0.3252921402454376,
-0.16173039376735687,
-0.5565052032470703,
0.014381171204149723,
-0.39801299571990967,
-0.12963134050369263,
-0.35234227776527405,
0.37062376737594604,
-0.4414903521537781,
0.2916318476200104,
0.408064603805542,
-0.40424931049346924,
0.40666458010673523,
0.08011758327484131,
0.21582254767417908,
-1.2315857410430908,
-0.04946799576282501,
0.006051143165677786,
-0.39914947748184204,
-0.6568750739097595,
0.6331110000610352,
-0.19361348450183868,
-0.4113892614841461,
-0.5695334076881409,
0.026727931573987007,
0.017875688150525093,
0.5266966223716736,
-0.26022785902023315,
-0.1766481101512909,
0.09766725450754166,
0.5112527012825012,
-0.5503487586975098,
0.5665170550346375,
0.5777571201324463,
-0.4127497375011444,
0.5991578698158264,
0.14156584441661835,
0.26381170749664307,
0.5392075181007385,
-0.6280781030654907,
0.27086272835731506,
-0.04861898347735405,
0.03879368677735329,
-1.1561673879623413,
0.0804542750120163,
0.49083852767944336,
-0.8754439949989319,
0.6193561553955078,
-0.2273511439561844,
-0.46040430665016174,
-0.21985815465450287,
-0.37912553548812866,
0.2448139190673828,
0.29106244444847107,
-0.5909422636032104,
0.7975375652313232,
0.05285162478685379,
0.10353925824165344,
-0.8425368070602417,
-0.9632081389427185,
0.5563457012176514,
-0.5045700073242188,
-0.5224030613899231,
0.14730635285377502,
0.2258637547492981,
-0.05335598066449165,
-0.09807416051626205,
-0.02362486533820629,
0.09863992035388947,
0.4816930890083313,
0.0875818133354187,
-0.04636988043785095,
-0.5101853609085083,
-0.23327723145484924,
-0.3287164270877838,
-0.10269824415445328,
0.32959142327308655,
-0.3368935286998749,
0.75384920835495,
0.004771293140947819,
-0.5226233005523682,
-0.7375044822692871,
0.3313363194465637,
0.7418385744094849,
-0.6892824172973633,
0.5767963528633118,
0.7199544310569763,
-0.49504873156547546,
-0.4143969416618347,
-0.553267240524292,
-0.2937173843383789,
-0.5153061747550964,
0.5963038206100464,
-0.4206785261631012,
-0.3284846246242523,
0.17367734014987946,
0.11293336749076843,
-0.04673070088028908,
0.45404621958732605,
0.23736806213855743,
0.07725340873003006,
1.0898618698120117,
0.18331164121627808,
-0.1112968921661377,
0.3034370243549347,
-0.2804414927959442,
-0.0337696447968483,
-0.6354257464408875,
-0.12389451265335083,
-0.4823356866836548,
-0.4801166355609894,
-0.20825296640396118,
-0.021764589473605156,
-0.022257991135120392,
-0.07595306634902954,
-0.47215375304222107,
0.6357885599136353,
-0.708222508430481,
0.39949876070022583,
0.5927199125289917,
0.39869821071624756,
-0.1613396406173706,
0.17655685544013977,
-0.31394731998443604,
-0.21108561754226685,
-0.4523439109325409,
-0.42397451400756836,
1.1217809915542603,
0.4281730055809021,
0.7227639555931091,
0.34146684408187866,
0.5973715782165527,
0.5356405377388,
0.2068292498588562,
-0.5446946620941162,
0.7128250002861023,
-0.7134693264961243,
-0.11001010239124298,
-0.0831756591796875,
-0.6500912308692932,
-0.7714585065841675,
0.2974476218223572,
-0.217719167470932,
-0.7228115797042847,
-0.13303323090076447,
-0.013431580737233162,
-0.22694332897663116,
0.8018331527709961,
-0.6036767363548279,
0.8837620615959167,
-0.6069580912590027,
-0.293998122215271,
0.053419504314661026,
-0.3848433494567871,
0.3329242467880249,
0.10055181384086609,
-0.39248716831207275,
0.2309647500514984,
0.07593243569135666,
0.5536574721336365,
-0.34981197118759155,
0.8501031994819641,
-0.5291151404380798,
0.20235565304756165,
0.2515248954296112,
0.3072752058506012,
0.7777191400527954,
0.2334812581539154,
-0.16512514650821686,
-0.2660548985004425,
-0.42314791679382324,
-0.6066761612892151,
-0.6554588675498962,
0.7235681414604187,
-0.6685765981674194,
-0.8605389595031738,
-0.5180180668830872,
-0.4253943860530853,
-0.25603732466697693,
0.29004156589508057,
0.27596163749694824,
0.5480487942695618,
-0.17553390562534332,
0.5049760937690735,
0.7115100622177124,
-0.2234731912612915,
0.6113284826278687,
0.1245943158864975,
0.44812098145484924,
-0.7463386058807373,
1.0429478883743286,
-0.27846580743789673,
0.07963977009057999,
0.6370512843132019,
0.4294934570789337,
-0.1466367542743683,
-0.9367913603782654,
-0.3049616515636444,
-0.25739920139312744,
-0.47862008213996887,
-0.5162760019302368,
-0.6221953630447388,
-0.2100543975830078,
-0.47137391567230225,
0.10278720408678055,
-0.412823885679245,
0.0353756807744503,
-0.12827695906162262,
0.23244264721870422,
0.10377347469329834,
0.5889079570770264,
0.5401504635810852,
0.5319210886955261,
-0.5422581434249878,
0.1800771951675415,
0.4218426048755646,
-0.009979083202779293,
0.11716490238904953,
-0.49674564599990845,
0.133274108171463,
0.35098594427108765,
-0.7098677754402161,
-0.8638935089111328,
0.33782902359962463,
-0.07262113690376282,
0.7118471264839172,
0.3898221552371979,
0.27589091658592224,
0.47815313935279846,
-0.3554811179637909,
0.8493469953536987,
0.0950850322842598,
-0.7521567344665527,
0.6483068466186523,
-0.5333314538002014,
0.3977360427379608,
0.6767590045928955,
0.21904653310775757,
0.032102715224027634,
-0.3180732727050781,
-0.5587614178657532,
-0.638198971748352,
0.47117048501968384,
0.5132216215133667,
0.34048572182655334,
0.33904072642326355,
0.34546026587486267,
-0.23048578202724457,
0.176733136177063,
-0.9147775173187256,
-0.260926753282547,
-0.4907202124595642,
-0.12542624771595,
0.11369577050209045,
-0.18694576621055603,
-0.22698575258255005,
-0.046405188739299774,
0.8368088006973267,
0.07400862127542496,
0.012658877298235893,
0.2734929621219635,
-0.10698894411325455,
0.24044840037822723,
0.16770730912685394,
0.6899225115776062,
0.02047831192612648,
0.007686758413910866,
0.35702744126319885,
0.23915214836597443,
-0.6881464719772339,
0.3836480677127838,
0.506768524646759,
-0.049753349274396896,
-0.46322572231292725,
0.45662403106689453,
0.7201440930366516,
-0.21019993722438812,
-0.36698079109191895,
0.7036546468734741,
-0.40774351358413696,
-0.2105780839920044,
-0.0794672816991806,
-0.014848272316157818,
-0.20792365074157715,
0.1475747525691986,
0.3047500252723694,
0.6445590257644653,
0.03308871388435364,
-0.19041480123996735,
0.42683687806129456,
0.5410560965538025,
-0.6605495810508728,
-0.012588275596499443,
0.8272331953048706,
-0.07401006668806076,
-0.5049985647201538,
0.38307687640190125,
-0.056441530585289,
-0.947871744632721,
0.7009111642837524,
0.5956798791885376,
0.9151831865310669,
-0.43660634756088257,
0.08948331326246262,
-0.06503269821405411,
0.7541800737380981,
0.292597234249115,
-0.015451090410351753,
0.06314323097467422,
-0.3220066726207733,
-0.3544667661190033,
-0.5847723484039307,
0.04265611618757248,
0.7872940897941589,
-0.2643137276172638,
0.1804451197385788,
-0.726190984249115,
-0.17206166684627533,
-0.0314880907535553,
0.04401247203350067,
-0.1866568624973297,
0.5286046862602234,
0.2197485864162445,
0.48546120524406433,
-0.45686182379722595,
0.618983268737793,
0.9169754385948181,
-0.4761990010738373,
-0.5399603843688965,
0.4282897710800171,
0.2683461308479309,
-0.4107205867767334,
0.2635796070098877,
0.032653674483299255,
-0.13533881306648254,
-0.311740905046463,
-0.3092781603336334,
-0.526010274887085,
0.6030991077423096,
0.6531961560249329,
-0.03233909606933594,
0.11332830786705017,
0.2897534966468811,
0.5944756269454956,
-0.13343192636966705,
-0.013512248173356056,
0.1282389760017395,
0.37850165367126465,
-0.07286123931407928,
-0.04504283890128136,
0.3790473937988281,
-0.566224992275238,
-0.14936693012714386,
0.3496682941913605,
-0.7389535307884216,
0.8688516020774841,
0.17063207924365997,
0.05058029294013977,
0.3646601438522339,
0.5528477430343628,
-0.033876173198223114,
0.035547979176044464,
0.6247817873954773,
0.856315016746521,
0.4559337794780731,
-0.2250615507364273,
1.2629733085632324,
0.0633300244808197,
-0.06200069561600685,
1.1542948484420776,
0.09769555181264877,
0.6635969281196594,
0.3087524473667145,
-0.0018939117435365915,
0.1531752645969391,
0.44458600878715515,
-0.5746867060661316,
0.4871015250682831,
0.46310222148895264,
-0.26468247175216675,
-0.18527396023273468,
0.08116143196821213,
-0.3904935419559479,
0.6900794506072998,
0.16625458002090454,
-0.40812256932258606,
-0.18415634334087372,
0.3169706165790558,
0.35321372747421265,
0.6181502938270569,
-0.15312427282333374,
0.588519811630249,
-0.18178892135620117,
-0.5801218152046204,
0.5291760563850403,
0.1411292552947998,
0.6034120321273804,
-0.9184299111366272,
0.018882164731621742,
0.09316478669643402,
0.5704997777938843,
-0.1148444265127182,
-0.2723575830459595,
0.10144264250993729,
-0.13836710155010223,
-0.014725953340530396,
-0.015674211084842682,
0.956131637096405,
-0.06761667132377625,
-0.4005274176597595,
0.20019188523292542,
-0.03918196260929108,
-0.4344555139541626,
-0.3684568405151367,
-0.7566496729850769,
-0.3430310785770416,
0.1404765099287033,
-0.40631526708602905,
0.3972456157207489,
0.22022497653961182,
0.3187689781188965,
0.5064228177070618,
0.879231870174408,
0.25066685676574707,
-0.013008936308324337,
0.07174010574817657,
0.8116013407707214,
-0.12883581221103668,
-0.3204776346683502,
-1.2828383445739746,
0.5912563800811768,
-0.32860809564590454,
-0.44698283076286316,
0.8937570452690125,
0.42236363887786865,
0.5271815657615662,
0.17588244378566742,
0.7548036575317383,
0.2696569859981537,
-0.015001529827713966,
-0.42395907640457153,
1.105440378189087,
-0.5932656526565552,
0.5501596331596375,
-0.24054458737373352,
-0.8443482518196106,
-0.5892639756202698,
0.28167301416397095,
-0.28227803111076355,
0.15359875559806824,
0.7048856616020203,
0.6853787302970886,
-0.19194410741329193,
0.04172063618898392,
0.40896546840667725,
0.3691839575767517,
0.6690656542778015,
0.44638535380363464,
0.8315677642822266,
-0.8553996682167053,
1.0409982204437256,
-0.4885200560092926,
-0.06923466175794601,
0.2640111744403839,
-0.926609218120575,
-1.2153288125991821,
-0.1900067925453186,
-0.23400260508060455,
-0.6092483997344971,
0.5508151054382324,
0.5427477359771729,
0.7690680027008057,
-1.0140659809112549,
0.18715766072273254,
-0.1302197277545929,
-0.23330536484718323,
-0.2270725965499878,
-0.28819936513900757,
0.5196520090103149,
-0.3373298943042755,
-0.5353507399559021,
0.768799364566803,
0.0018963452894240618,
-0.003694508457556367,
-0.3307414650917053,
0.3570310175418854,
-0.698622465133667,
0.16404470801353455,
0.20633630454540253,
0.05618803948163986,
-0.519862174987793,
-0.2067948281764984,
-0.1637270301580429,
-0.2863645851612091,
-0.06210765242576599,
0.7596314549446106,
-0.7363821268081665,
0.40643760561943054,
0.3804478645324707,
1.3440492153167725,
0.12584471702575684,
0.058614734560251236,
0.5566598176956177,
-1.1153513193130493,
0.21018573641777039,
0.5455308556556702,
0.42925330996513367,
0.42899277806282043,
-0.7296174168586731,
0.16327032446861267,
0.28200018405914307,
-0.43362176418304443,
-0.9945166707038879,
0.21801762282848358,
-0.6247462034225464,
-0.44190704822540283,
0.9800280928611755,
-0.3210452198982239,
-0.12521283328533173,
0.21859177947044373,
-0.42188310623168945,
0.25571316480636597,
-0.4721233546733856,
0.644993245601654,
0.4635930061340332,
0.41548556089401245,
-0.0007118151406757534,
-0.3389977514743805,
0.44381216168403625,
0.6849590539932251,
-0.7334399819374084,
-0.07975216954946518,
-0.09676042944192886,
-0.05004561319947243,
0.13085144758224487,
-0.21833449602127075,
-0.1229872852563858,
0.3165989816188812,
0.39843088388442993,
-0.26326847076416016,
-0.5588892102241516,
-0.33701419830322266,
-0.2937101125717163,
0.6673994064331055,
-0.19373266398906708,
-0.45715537667274475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18789v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18789v1
|
FlexLLM: A System for Co-Serving Large Language Model Inference and Parameter-Efficient Finetuning
| 2024-02-29T01:33:08 | 2024-02-29T01:33:08 |
Xupeng Miao, Gabriele Oliaro, Xinhao Cheng, Mengdi Wu, Colin Unger, Zhihao Jia
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT) is a widely used technique to adapt
large language models for different tasks. Service providers typically create
separate systems for users to perform PEFT model finetuning and inference
tasks. This is because existing systems cannot handle workloads that include a
mix of inference and PEFT finetuning requests. As a result, shared GPU
resources are underutilized, leading to inefficiencies. To address this
problem, we present FlexLLM, the first system that can serve inference and
parameter-efficient finetuning requests in the same iteration. Our system
leverages the complementary nature of these two tasks and utilizes shared GPU
resources to run them jointly, using a method called co-serving. To achieve
this, FlexLLM introduces a novel token-level finetuning mechanism, which breaks
down the finetuning computation of a sequence into smaller token-level
computations and uses dependent parallelization and graph pruning, two static
compilation optimizations, to minimize the memory overhead and latency for
co-serving. Compared to existing systems, FlexLLM's co-serving approach reduces
the activation GPU memory overhead by up to 8x, and the end-to-end GPU memory
requirement of finetuning by up to 36% while maintaining a low inference
latency and improving finetuning throughput. For example, under a heavy
inference workload, FlexLLM can still preserve more than 80% of the peak
finetuning throughput, whereas existing systems cannot make any progress with
finetuning. The source code of FlexLLM is publicly available at
https://github.com/flexflow/FlexFlow.
|
[
-0.7120301127433777,
-1.223270058631897,
0.5251760482788086,
0.18462421000003815,
-0.24190063774585724,
0.015228421427309513,
-0.3851839303970337,
-0.25881263613700867,
-0.1639086902141571,
0.5631601214408875,
-0.6887469291687012,
-0.11267551779747009,
-0.04239446297287941,
-0.12915313243865967,
-0.3083769381046295,
0.8274899125099182,
0.22318072617053986,
0.020587705075740814,
-0.22663675248622894,
-0.23394577205181122,
-0.3004063069820404,
-0.2157408893108368,
-0.9781481027603149,
-0.5462779998779297,
0.5099015235900879,
0.6687307953834534,
1.1546434164047241,
0.54489666223526,
0.23688969016075134,
0.31821301579475403,
0.09175730496644974,
0.2919699251651764,
-0.8496869206428528,
0.04237303137779236,
-0.2888799011707306,
-0.35920509696006775,
-0.3398405611515045,
-0.05349680781364441,
0.6487749814987183,
0.9065352082252502,
-0.24437907338142395,
0.18921440839767456,
0.2964271306991577,
0.43377578258514404,
-0.6289661526679993,
-0.022717619314789772,
-0.41259145736694336,
-0.06545645743608475,
-0.10044801235198975,
-0.033746156841516495,
-0.5892344117164612,
-0.4211060106754303,
0.10474181175231934,
-0.6903316974639893,
0.3812929391860962,
0.30853021144866943,
0.854059636592865,
0.37870949506759644,
0.059042904525995255,
0.41702714562416077,
-0.7332054972648621,
0.8540273904800415,
-0.5574330687522888,
0.5213621854782104,
0.07462146133184433,
0.5219694375991821,
-0.18268486857414246,
-0.9641413688659668,
-0.5094310641288757,
0.03185472637414932,
-0.16561871767044067,
-0.19142460823059082,
0.026022426784038544,
0.32366618514060974,
0.10019312798976898,
0.6460485458374023,
-0.5514447093009949,
0.21505506336688995,
0.07619588822126389,
-0.07139085978269577,
0.4396956264972687,
0.07521893084049225,
0.3435003459453583,
0.2639516592025757,
-0.7286912798881531,
-0.14171025156974792,
-0.81231689453125,
-0.10862264782190323,
0.10064785927534103,
0.41892996430397034,
-0.13912184536457062,
0.44786781072616577,
0.02186654508113861,
0.6051919460296631,
0.23464590311050415,
0.27150583267211914,
-0.10557142645120621,
-0.05473828688263893,
-0.898909866809845,
0.023939670994877815,
0.8828902244567871,
0.10997240245342255,
-0.16493216156959534,
-0.3222212791442871,
-0.1711176633834839,
-0.15206339955329895,
-0.07808861136436462,
-0.8003411293029785,
-0.17546963691711426,
0.24155226349830627,
-0.2632087767124176,
0.3065638840198517,
0.13692706823349,
-0.7167432904243469,
-0.42227861285209656,
-0.33403635025024414,
0.4398753345012665,
-0.5108723044395447,
-0.34095993638038635,
0.09284360706806183,
-0.15095068514347076,
0.46373042464256287,
0.40675997734069824,
-1.0330334901809692,
0.9381441473960876,
1.2688401937484741,
0.8940140008926392,
-0.445207804441452,
-0.36481398344039917,
-1.1977680921554565,
0.16534073650836945,
0.13313594460487366,
0.5659521818161011,
-0.4444443881511688,
-0.09319362789392471,
-0.4330736994743347,
0.14179083704948425,
-0.18476293981075287,
-0.6714106798171997,
0.44722455739974976,
-0.39406833052635193,
-0.03936318680644035,
0.068128801882267,
-0.8826335072517395,
-0.16212324798107147,
-0.09540267288684845,
-0.8716611266136169,
1.0256539583206177,
0.023731498047709465,
-0.31717851758003235,
0.1645868420600891,
-0.4636448323726654,
-0.39476925134658813,
0.484697163105011,
-0.30323609709739685,
-0.49530065059661865,
0.26975226402282715,
0.0862351581454277,
0.5835388898849487,
-0.7140610814094543,
0.4433860182762146,
-0.5382256507873535,
-0.6975114941596985,
-0.06176900118589401,
-0.6634699106216431,
0.5424870848655701,
0.387207567691803,
-0.44124144315719604,
0.267658531665802,
-0.43771761655807495,
0.1821250319480896,
0.086830735206604,
-0.3808269500732422,
-0.20267407596111298,
-0.09739870578050613,
0.41097283363342285,
-0.4016530513763428,
0.11307009309530258,
-0.45689287781715393,
0.08711648732423782,
-0.5369485020637512,
0.5153789520263672,
0.6432452201843262,
-0.4958551824092865,
0.6407673954963684,
-0.3180581033229828,
0.31036609411239624,
-0.567406952381134,
0.29518088698387146,
-0.027705291286110878,
-0.31849220395088196,
-0.6698037981987,
-0.46829232573509216,
0.06379344314336777,
0.3070068061351776,
-0.4911569058895111,
0.010111149400472641,
0.02847527153789997,
-0.3531329929828644,
-0.5070977807044983,
0.03034939616918564,
0.4357905983924866,
0.340347558259964,
0.5293393731117249,
0.08002222329378128,
-0.27031126618385315,
-0.7199798822402954,
-0.3524315357208252,
0.17450261116027832,
0.17975610494613647,
0.46134939789772034,
-0.09500060230493546,
-0.013448408804833889,
0.6608966588973999,
-0.5843164324760437,
0.07209078967571259,
-0.2637302279472351,
0.13395759463310242,
0.37378790974617004,
0.7135859131813049,
0.500933825969696,
-0.7659090757369995,
-0.6873375177383423,
0.1571122109889984,
-0.20154303312301636,
-0.13515843451023102,
-0.10420463979244232,
-0.06500415503978729,
0.1635880321264267,
0.38872143626213074,
-0.42689424753189087,
-0.14047974348068237,
0.8286781907081604,
-0.6240758895874023,
0.5197386741638184,
-0.45017027854919434,
-0.13740409910678864,
-0.6147856116294861,
-0.06897711008787155,
-0.20106956362724304,
-0.7088764905929565,
-0.39965152740478516,
0.42168018221855164,
-0.26317739486694336,
-0.18034915626049042,
-0.395243376493454,
0.7050424814224243,
-0.5063678026199341,
-0.02400258369743824,
-0.20156832039356232,
-0.3805851340293884,
0.27386581897735596,
0.47497808933258057,
-0.11950324475765228,
0.822211742401123,
0.6189183592796326,
-0.37953415513038635,
0.3822065591812134,
-0.2969202995300293,
-0.08228561282157898,
0.3932804465293884,
-0.6351099610328674,
0.23209215700626373,
0.1891978681087494,
-0.14845027029514313,
-1.1230883598327637,
-0.18620771169662476,
0.24205759167671204,
0.15516087412834167,
0.29036855697631836,
-0.27241405844688416,
-0.43189024925231934,
-0.20169931650161743,
-0.10016632825136185,
0.3091650605201721,
0.5126750469207764,
-0.978245198726654,
0.7678080201148987,
0.406025230884552,
-0.106793612241745,
-0.4651296138763428,
-0.7874407768249512,
-0.119822196662426,
-0.19794917106628418,
-0.6573713421821594,
0.3692339062690735,
-0.05154627561569214,
0.03321129456162453,
-0.005355039611458778,
-0.23444399237632751,
-0.2884071171283722,
0.2220286875963211,
0.37904855608940125,
0.2935720980167389,
-0.4536387324333191,
-0.0973009467124939,
0.2929728627204895,
-0.060891516506671906,
-0.20382966101169586,
-0.42389360070228577,
0.9895842671394348,
-0.5610283017158508,
-0.4370627701282501,
-0.691521406173706,
0.36626484990119934,
0.6019776463508606,
-0.09934671968221664,
0.7008004784584045,
1.0183485746383667,
-0.26334381103515625,
-0.3402400612831116,
-0.8024610280990601,
-0.18278315663337708,
-0.5287730693817139,
-0.05049613118171692,
-0.4785078167915344,
-1.1502048969268799,
0.42317959666252136,
-0.34537914395332336,
0.018700631335377693,
0.4541069269180298,
0.5572156310081482,
-0.04559039697051048,
0.8411399126052856,
0.4391711950302124,
0.22964772582054138,
0.5971396565437317,
-0.46374213695526123,
-0.25213250517845154,
-0.41299083828926086,
-0.034366052597761154,
-0.27492907643318176,
-0.3499179184436798,
-0.3693791627883911,
-0.693000853061676,
-0.03802235424518585,
0.192522332072258,
-0.5307562351226807,
0.08255904167890549,
-0.5089308619499207,
0.6640881299972534,
0.6115230917930603,
0.27844035625457764,
0.37892991304397583,
0.149262934923172,
-0.5161888599395752,
0.29197272658348083,
-0.8437132835388184,
-0.3561500608921051,
0.63010573387146,
0.3222622871398926,
1.0904386043548584,
0.02661903202533722,
0.5870324969291687,
0.2124163657426834,
0.28565654158592224,
-0.6959185600280762,
0.6126934289932251,
-0.45757821202278137,
-0.28709208965301514,
-0.5524311661720276,
-0.4765298664569855,
-0.6855842471122742,
0.2816515862941742,
-0.1834241896867752,
-0.5627757906913757,
0.19352035224437714,
0.3497794568538666,
-0.6895809769630432,
0.43434059619903564,
-1.2402149438858032,
1.0031214952468872,
-0.12572020292282104,
-1.046545386314392,
-0.40452444553375244,
-0.4094265103340149,
0.06011800840497017,
0.23774343729019165,
-0.10397365689277649,
-0.4066440761089325,
0.037635836750268936,
0.4242212176322937,
-0.9604172110557556,
0.7585306763648987,
-0.577536404132843,
0.0737079605460167,
0.36086970567703247,
-0.011210300028324127,
0.5193552374839783,
0.40847548842430115,
-0.2801271080970764,
-0.19189172983169556,
0.23409095406532288,
-0.3491973578929901,
-0.4422871768474579,
1.030831217765808,
-0.7743709087371826,
-0.6633223295211792,
-0.26713743805885315,
-0.701438844203949,
-0.06138686463236809,
0.5009980797767639,
-0.2198074907064438,
0.21309161186218262,
-0.4560379981994629,
0.2557929456233978,
0.5102148652076721,
-0.26304370164871216,
0.5563376545906067,
0.2779523730278015,
-0.2504662871360779,
-0.28258323669433594,
0.8401486873626709,
-0.11729554086923599,
0.3272224962711334,
0.39313966035842896,
0.4873538017272949,
-0.3799520432949066,
-0.6305151581764221,
-0.47719141840934753,
0.23120610415935516,
-0.19422121345996857,
-0.1956273913383484,
-0.28078290820121765,
-0.090804323554039,
-0.03815671429038048,
-0.2310427725315094,
-0.6774135828018188,
-0.2928657829761505,
-0.2514115571975708,
0.25042083859443665,
0.5232647657394409,
0.25812840461730957,
0.019285885617136955,
0.6166537404060364,
-0.547110915184021,
0.4758012592792511,
0.46924686431884766,
0.7970808744430542,
-0.0059746685437858105,
-0.0556132048368454,
-0.11388875544071198,
-0.07751145213842392,
-0.10449670255184174,
-0.31673747301101685,
0.25305208563804626,
0.5433509349822998,
0.5445700287818909,
0.5033907294273376,
0.0902208462357521,
0.9819286465644836,
-0.5838494300842285,
0.4890687167644501,
0.4006669223308563,
-0.9320392608642578,
-0.013596766628324986,
-0.10909544676542282,
0.3497261106967926,
0.7266261577606201,
0.18152694404125214,
-0.43248450756073,
-0.32801908254623413,
-0.2641361653804779,
-0.6350997686386108,
0.896581768989563,
-0.19413447380065918,
0.05680849403142929,
0.07411044090986252,
0.5280078649520874,
0.5777977108955383,
-0.2704823613166809,
-0.3104349970817566,
-0.2796808183193207,
-0.053555190563201904,
-0.19455744326114655,
-0.03449445217847824,
-0.07077696174383163,
-0.2132793366909027,
-0.5281498432159424,
0.45549723505973816,
-0.5019018054008484,
0.22191055119037628,
0.0565398670732975,
-0.09833207726478577,
-0.17276296019554138,
0.28810009360313416,
0.08984442800283432,
0.5763614773750305,
-0.2176411747932434,
0.47171613574028015,
0.22410273551940918,
-0.5443282127380371,
0.037647537887096405,
0.6991075873374939,
-0.10642322897911072,
-0.2103436291217804,
-0.3155658543109894,
1.0450119972229004,
0.31822943687438965,
-0.8154278993606567,
0.2567782998085022,
-0.36089929938316345,
0.0400223508477211,
0.055989883840084076,
0.48406752943992615,
0.38543400168418884,
0.6535094380378723,
0.4441607594490051,
0.014760904014110565,
0.09384327381849289,
-0.36301666498184204,
0.23018909990787506,
0.5162594318389893,
-0.2645307183265686,
-0.19905713200569153,
0.9676269292831421,
-0.019552549347281456,
-0.1182195320725441,
0.40268611907958984,
-0.08429019898176193,
0.10943783074617386,
0.44178086519241333,
0.7583586573600769,
0.7244464159011841,
-0.17646323144435883,
0.22528178989887238,
-0.041506871581077576,
-0.27097997069358826,
-0.4160321354866028,
0.5348352789878845,
-0.048396576195955276,
-0.5022163391113281,
-0.7205535173416138,
-0.8419467210769653,
-0.570563793182373,
0.06675438582897186,
-0.4923604130744934,
0.4172590970993042,
-0.7166703343391418,
-0.14757661521434784,
0.10974329710006714,
0.06501524895429611,
-0.7547216415405273,
0.050409384071826935,
0.42314374446868896,
0.8746181726455688,
-0.5424402356147766,
0.9230780601501465,
0.7028172016143799,
-0.06629420816898346,
-0.8721905946731567,
-0.4134451746940613,
-0.19410981237888336,
-0.7789204120635986,
0.1312442421913147,
0.07277043163776398,
-0.28363755345344543,
0.23965932428836823,
-0.3540576100349426,
-0.6302341222763062,
1.167482852935791,
1.0287233591079712,
-0.7486735582351685,
-0.10384315252304077,
0.44122326374053955,
0.2344609797000885,
-0.27233853936195374,
0.11253660172224045,
0.5597536563873291,
0.49522262811660767,
0.30843496322631836,
-0.953482449054718,
0.4701179563999176,
0.18224424123764038,
-0.16930551826953888,
0.17656999826431274,
-0.8861027956008911,
0.967200517654419,
-0.21549567580223083,
-0.34958013892173767,
0.20615026354789734,
0.6300057768821716,
0.23254704475402832,
0.35107511281967163,
0.6099227666854858,
0.6894088387489319,
1.0275849103927612,
-0.33552175760269165,
0.952195942401886,
-0.18343563377857208,
0.7825103998184204,
1.5020091533660889,
-0.07766592502593994,
0.7816129326820374,
0.7665917277336121,
-0.07448426634073257,
0.16385860741138458,
0.517193078994751,
-0.07352860271930695,
0.4397509694099426,
0.10182925313711166,
-0.3015665113925934,
-0.3097921907901764,
-0.12522058188915253,
-0.1415008306503296,
0.15508589148521423,
0.4004085958003998,
-0.36074838042259216,
-0.3741828203201294,
0.07179544121026993,
0.03431640937924385,
-0.16399085521697998,
-0.644156813621521,
0.6408395171165466,
0.23572321236133575,
-0.7845939993858337,
0.9963683485984802,
-0.031418394297361374,
0.5740468502044678,
-0.30539941787719727,
-0.007666018791496754,
-0.21580758690834045,
0.4800068736076355,
-0.3101978302001953,
-0.6990593075752258,
0.5013520121574402,
-0.13940119743347168,
0.02636200189590454,
-0.48493292927742004,
0.7263860702514648,
-0.5096681118011475,
-0.2168715000152588,
0.3063898980617523,
0.6038552522659302,
0.0044864024966955185,
-0.1594591587781906,
-0.7667381763458252,
0.2634270191192627,
-0.37762245535850525,
-0.21092021465301514,
0.21121101081371307,
0.26825565099716187,
0.16039392352104187,
0.49502983689308167,
0.5179494619369507,
-0.09629642218351364,
0.30828338861465454,
0.3903505802154541,
0.9373746514320374,
-0.3875769078731537,
-0.3758084774017334,
-1.1607484817504883,
0.0860135480761528,
0.1240895539522171,
0.16221442818641663,
0.5373134613037109,
0.9305682182312012,
0.6722119450569153,
0.025405943393707275,
0.4671887457370758,
-0.014511500485241413,
0.06021590530872345,
-0.3518061935901642,
0.8526044487953186,
-0.5892407298088074,
0.13435713946819305,
-0.024666599929332733,
-0.862585723400116,
-0.4085555672645569,
0.29422086477279663,
-0.46576058864593506,
-0.316599577665329,
0.4687943756580353,
0.6666524410247803,
-0.6191773414611816,
0.21668313443660736,
0.28816351294517517,
0.17684298753738403,
0.18019095063209534,
0.6443238258361816,
0.46425390243530273,
-0.1796797513961792,
0.5456451177597046,
-0.19526676833629608,
-0.10510297119617462,
-0.4057298004627228,
-0.6336805820465088,
-0.7263572216033936,
-0.2601073980331421,
-0.21841628849506378,
-0.22759951651096344,
0.09498010575771332,
0.9595560431480408,
0.8680800795555115,
-0.8491614460945129,
-0.35542240738868713,
-0.44954925775527954,
0.2853185832500458,
-0.599905788898468,
-0.28615355491638184,
0.5270160436630249,
-0.4223255515098572,
-1.0087088346481323,
0.27982065081596375,
0.3868345618247986,
-0.15818265080451965,
-0.300740510225296,
-0.31693458557128906,
-0.2949512004852295,
-0.006428014952689409,
0.537059485912323,
0.5230910181999207,
-0.6018781661987305,
-0.39784544706344604,
-0.05522993952035904,
-0.03240272402763367,
0.29183658957481384,
0.7545998096466064,
-0.71067214012146,
0.34789803624153137,
0.5804353952407837,
1.1328396797180176,
0.9267878532409668,
-0.17955882847309113,
0.60956871509552,
-0.5163437724113464,
0.1557183563709259,
0.15320418775081635,
0.44413790106773376,
0.18488062918186188,
-0.317643940448761,
0.32337212562561035,
0.27434033155441284,
-0.415598601102829,
-0.7378329038619995,
0.08442898839712143,
-1.187868356704712,
-0.2945491671562195,
0.8685621023178101,
-0.21462595462799072,
-0.43941521644592285,
-0.05870968475937843,
-0.2904220521450043,
0.5313209295272827,
-0.48143553733825684,
0.29965293407440186,
0.30424147844314575,
-0.449362188577652,
-0.5264013409614563,
-0.28886017203330994,
0.40497371554374695,
0.5968459844589233,
-0.7109073400497437,
0.27446556091308594,
0.31802818179130554,
0.4304981827735901,
-0.2536384165287018,
0.39768344163894653,
0.16076034307479858,
0.22362291812896729,
-0.2394936978816986,
-0.2523154616355896,
-0.1928817331790924,
-0.17429396510124207,
-0.13390766084194183,
0.605624258518219,
0.10783512890338898,
-0.019460508599877357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18766v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18766v2
|
Advancing Generative AI for Portuguese with Open Decoder Gervásio PT*
| 2024-02-29T00:19:13 | 2024-03-05T10:44:03 |
Rodrigo Santos, João Silva, Luís Gomes, João Rodrigues, António Branco
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To advance the neural decoding of Portuguese, in this paper we present a
fully open Transformer-based, instruction-tuned decoder model that sets a new
state of the art in this respect. To develop this decoder, which we named
Gerv\'asio PT*, a strong LLaMA~2 7B model was used as a starting point, and its
further improvement through additional training was done over language
resources that include new instruction data sets of Portuguese prepared for
this purpose, which are also contributed in this paper. All versions of
Gerv\'asio are open source and distributed for free under an open license,
including for either research or commercial usage, and can be run on
consumer-grade hardware, thus seeking to contribute to the advancement of
research and innovation in language technology for Portuguese.
|
[
0.02887282520532608,
-0.5713411569595337,
0.055683109909296036,
0.3580940067768097,
-0.3866294026374817,
-0.19242221117019653,
-0.4457913041114807,
-0.3429034352302551,
0.1190851554274559,
0.40631556510925293,
-0.19819656014442444,
-0.625490128993988,
-0.8543068170547485,
0.24461983144283295,
-0.3795226812362671,
0.8217129707336426,
-0.02309074066579342,
0.291734904050827,
-0.11878654360771179,
0.015492047183215618,
-0.3678770661354065,
-0.2780798077583313,
-0.9314241409301758,
-0.24924235045909882,
0.22150801122188568,
0.32441216707229614,
0.37009984254837036,
0.8209835290908813,
0.2833390235900879,
0.38698720932006836,
-0.19661444425582886,
0.1178373396396637,
-0.5074504017829895,
0.029227236285805702,
-0.1220657080411911,
-0.5882869958877563,
-0.5185465216636658,
-0.4411648213863373,
0.5806733965873718,
0.19396467506885529,
-0.2145538181066513,
-0.12990573048591614,
0.10582078248262405,
0.3769063949584961,
-0.5794499516487122,
0.5498023629188538,
-0.3969443440437317,
-0.051419079303741455,
-0.05033714696764946,
-0.22289589047431946,
-0.5983884930610657,
-0.5440157055854797,
-0.23648618161678314,
-0.8006725311279297,
0.29681622982025146,
-0.5470461845397949,
0.6896684765815735,
0.43818724155426025,
-0.19120903313159943,
-0.4758298397064209,
-0.7061903476715088,
0.48957905173301697,
-0.1530839502811432,
0.3285318911075592,
-0.0006237668567337096,
0.4618580639362335,
0.024288665503263474,
-0.5834142565727234,
-0.3314182162284851,
-0.32183024287223816,
0.38835781812667847,
0.36239176988601685,
-0.819019615650177,
0.13483926653862,
0.1642889678478241,
0.47110599279403687,
-0.29070451855659485,
0.2999647259712219,
-0.6459833979606628,
-0.12871859967708588,
0.3267395496368408,
-0.15861263871192932,
0.2154855579137802,
0.24039755761623383,
-0.2446257770061493,
-0.30521902441978455,
-0.9814150333404541,
-0.08572402596473694,
0.6488550305366516,
-0.031231939792633057,
-0.18416181206703186,
0.556879997253418,
-0.13955892622470856,
0.6988149881362915,
-0.19154655933380127,
0.22932639718055725,
0.28980952501296997,
0.00502184359356761,
-0.24144579470157623,
0.16518643498420715,
0.7643863558769226,
0.05390853062272072,
0.4655497074127197,
-0.1673864722251892,
-0.2825410068035126,
0.6139116287231445,
0.3482459485530853,
-0.60821932554245,
-0.3577754497528076,
0.006615029647946358,
-0.461467981338501,
-0.3296939432621002,
0.31729021668434143,
-0.6645216941833496,
-0.11748547106981277,
-0.011036052368581295,
0.2190741002559662,
-0.7122295498847961,
-0.25724926590919495,
0.30699092149734497,
-0.12147743254899979,
0.4877825081348419,
0.4342516362667084,
-0.9312214851379395,
0.152418315410614,
0.8163686394691467,
0.6052336692810059,
0.1564340889453888,
-0.22439709305763245,
-0.4808741509914398,
0.14923502504825592,
-0.34082159399986267,
0.8833131194114685,
-0.6754679679870605,
-0.9024678468704224,
0.2057659775018692,
0.1888306438922882,
0.16680791974067688,
-0.5193478465080261,
0.9156441688537598,
-0.4264294505119324,
0.41735419631004333,
0.01526484452188015,
-0.19533012807369232,
-0.291801780462265,
0.05299656093120575,
-0.5494385361671448,
0.8594103455543518,
0.09300599992275238,
-0.5205874443054199,
0.010451620444655418,
-1.062536358833313,
-0.5337240695953369,
0.15141350030899048,
-0.0887179896235466,
-0.2826097905635834,
0.37030571699142456,
0.42832687497138977,
0.07859768718481064,
-0.40011146664619446,
0.2929705083370209,
0.1711573749780655,
-0.48212599754333496,
0.1464836448431015,
-0.7080080509185791,
0.997578501701355,
0.2192373275756836,
-0.11945309489965439,
0.3946865200996399,
-0.8167436122894287,
-0.2009076327085495,
0.11777429282665253,
-0.49237605929374695,
-0.11132374405860901,
0.13496951758861542,
-0.2390087991952896,
-0.2969032824039459,
0.3168064057826996,
-0.7357710599899292,
0.3814740478992462,
-0.6033024787902832,
0.520151674747467,
0.7888281941413879,
-0.3122178912162781,
0.41884341835975647,
0.040709804743528366,
0.7117412686347961,
0.04877151921391487,
0.27734676003456116,
-0.42490699887275696,
-0.836011528968811,
-1.01042640209198,
-0.27012142539024353,
0.49814853072166443,
0.6572689414024353,
-1.091199517250061,
0.49972161650657654,
-0.43377694487571716,
-0.2996022701263428,
-1.1282888650894165,
-0.2966654896736145,
0.7221792340278625,
0.5214130282402039,
0.4950999617576599,
-0.2512151598930359,
-0.5611690878868103,
-0.7594735622406006,
0.20346428453922272,
0.06518638879060745,
-0.559485912322998,
0.1405881941318512,
0.4409916400909424,
-0.3392674922943115,
0.3671130836009979,
-0.48002249002456665,
-0.2318193018436432,
-0.14280952513217926,
-0.04455156251788139,
0.3317812979221344,
0.5984721779823303,
0.5794355273246765,
-0.40389689803123474,
-0.33907127380371094,
0.2930639386177063,
-0.8332724571228027,
-0.23814202845096588,
0.5723112225532532,
0.007721953094005585,
0.2954585552215576,
0.3427247703075409,
-0.3275250196456909,
0.2615331709384918,
0.5985180139541626,
-0.2173650562763214,
0.030432261526584625,
-0.7489450573921204,
0.09802094101905823,
-1.2848410606384277,
0.20214353501796722,
-0.08958166092634201,
0.1748284250497818,
-0.7334070205688477,
0.17727121710777283,
0.004356541205197573,
-0.21466635167598724,
-0.5162367224693298,
0.12323356419801712,
-0.5699031949043274,
-0.013699647970497608,
-0.39855676889419556,
-0.2801917791366577,
-0.27873867750167847,
0.2620120346546173,
0.21472543478012085,
0.6991953253746033,
1.0150598287582397,
-0.4519491195678711,
0.3690623641014099,
0.3799718916416168,
-0.0763702318072319,
0.32122892141342163,
-0.99504554271698,
0.4119851291179657,
-0.44915592670440674,
0.027404863387346268,
-0.5457886457443237,
-0.09879930317401886,
0.6450269818305969,
-0.7701199054718018,
0.4345998167991638,
-0.4643685519695282,
-0.16026780009269714,
-0.5125959515571594,
-0.06183211877942085,
0.18973270058631897,
0.6617947816848755,
-0.5949422121047974,
0.5770227909088135,
0.34968796372413635,
0.18662229180335999,
-0.7412719130516052,
-0.5769859552383423,
0.06149544194340706,
0.010234038345515728,
-0.5715720653533936,
0.30017969012260437,
0.11306660622358322,
-0.10473130643367767,
0.10957727581262589,
0.12243612855672836,
-0.17185574769973755,
-0.04122927039861679,
0.3299727439880371,
0.3381258547306061,
-0.5941483378410339,
-0.11180227994918823,
0.2621908485889435,
-0.5445781946182251,
0.04678484424948692,
-0.5511792302131653,
0.5558379888534546,
-0.16328921914100647,
-0.11905920505523682,
-0.5588796734809875,
0.31417351961135864,
0.252071350812912,
-0.43290042877197266,
0.37067103385925293,
0.4684463143348694,
-0.2701546847820282,
-0.17031265795230865,
-0.02890889346599579,
0.21684207022190094,
-0.5310270190238953,
0.13192525506019592,
-0.5099934339523315,
-1.0887974500656128,
0.41735994815826416,
0.22867974638938904,
-0.28604617714881897,
0.5336534380912781,
0.6674211621284485,
0.08452487736940384,
0.7895079255104065,
0.9401470422744751,
-0.23104022443294525,
0.5685504078865051,
-0.5134363174438477,
-0.15935559570789337,
-0.5607312917709351,
-0.4080207347869873,
-0.7651047110557556,
-0.24280866980552673,
-0.6322079300880432,
-0.614422082901001,
0.4994485080242157,
-0.14019878208637238,
-0.07389877736568451,
0.27749499678611755,
-0.8902176022529602,
0.6824968457221985,
0.899949312210083,
0.12247498333454132,
0.26418769359588623,
0.006586884614080191,
0.2225196659564972,
0.4017801880836487,
-0.6749683618545532,
-0.3149096667766571,
1.1167387962341309,
0.28183451294898987,
0.739968478679657,
0.03275512531399727,
0.5325320959091187,
0.3012233078479767,
0.23526398837566376,
-0.6481544971466064,
0.40896400809288025,
-0.41012701392173767,
-0.10363246500492096,
-0.23891089856624603,
-0.2289627194404602,
-1.2940022945404053,
0.1737784445285797,
-0.004663100466132164,
-0.43655988574028015,
0.12355710566043854,
0.3929148316383362,
-0.1441953182220459,
0.09113100171089172,
-0.7791169285774231,
0.9261783957481384,
-0.14116829633712769,
0.1358775943517685,
-0.2435457408428192,
-0.666806161403656,
0.14838740229606628,
0.5397700667381287,
-0.4321518838405609,
0.117556132376194,
-0.1450527012348175,
0.45434054732322693,
-0.40991464257240295,
0.6547170877456665,
-0.5840877890586853,
-0.1650054007768631,
0.5623490810394287,
-0.1208825632929802,
0.28064221143722534,
-0.10903586447238922,
0.0747682973742485,
0.5379632115364075,
-0.29795607924461365,
-0.39320626854896545,
-0.3945636749267578,
0.43221837282180786,
-1.1643457412719727,
-0.36633434891700745,
-0.2985876500606537,
-0.3093690276145935,
0.1663191169500351,
0.11665093898773193,
0.4846314787864685,
0.30393168330192566,
-0.4278580844402313,
0.299000084400177,
0.9225244522094727,
-0.3152228891849518,
0.42474043369293213,
0.5382835268974304,
0.31728631258010864,
-0.6544505953788757,
0.9474397897720337,
-0.328233540058136,
-0.24232038855552673,
0.7860673666000366,
0.15183188021183014,
-0.24194219708442688,
-0.74957674741745,
-0.6398724317550659,
0.10336710512638092,
-0.45852944254875183,
-0.4634424149990082,
-0.47936370968818665,
-0.0816643238067627,
-0.4775603711605072,
-0.10509141534566879,
-0.2407606989145279,
-0.16855016350746155,
-0.6021767854690552,
-0.056556858122348785,
0.41482555866241455,
0.8168781995773315,
-0.023504892364144325,
0.6685396432876587,
-0.7449699640274048,
0.23062419891357422,
0.15007391571998596,
0.3053140640258789,
-0.24276089668273926,
-0.36624038219451904,
-0.06334428489208221,
0.2157168835401535,
-0.24977214634418488,
-0.893166184425354,
0.5935126543045044,
0.1358417123556137,
0.6308093070983887,
0.6307911276817322,
-0.288266122341156,
0.29173925518989563,
-0.4791469871997833,
0.46628832817077637,
0.12762807309627533,
-0.9729511141777039,
0.9083595275878906,
-0.5698245763778687,
0.3139860928058624,
0.2069365233182907,
0.3906172513961792,
-0.17078091204166412,
0.0298753809183836,
-0.5863966941833496,
-0.5417810082435608,
0.7870926856994629,
0.07361993938684464,
0.1569422036409378,
-0.008831530809402466,
0.1495652049779892,
0.2130466103553772,
0.19665966928005219,
-0.5628565549850464,
0.23597027361392975,
-0.7370554804801941,
-0.29702886939048767,
-0.058615636080503464,
-0.2545405626296997,
-0.11069595068693161,
-0.3201962113380432,
0.49949294328689575,
-0.36258435249328613,
0.8825147747993469,
-0.19303879141807556,
-0.1474558264017105,
-0.06580830365419388,
0.2086283564567566,
0.6989618539810181,
0.22504131495952606,
0.08626456558704376,
-0.11731884628534317,
0.053629618138074875,
-0.5157006978988647,
-0.013504590839147568,
0.2990415096282959,
-0.29092729091644287,
-0.10543927550315857,
0.038561489433050156,
1.0387308597564697,
0.09703798592090607,
-0.604561448097229,
0.5891488790512085,
-0.015116558410227299,
-0.027796732261776924,
-0.3705841600894928,
0.4245028495788574,
-0.1188693568110466,
0.3963553309440613,
0.02128542773425579,
0.03872666135430336,
0.1498498171567917,
-0.32429495453834534,
-0.11364356428384781,
0.2161816507577896,
-0.5216119289398193,
-0.526689350605011,
0.960057258605957,
0.4714512228965759,
-0.5032282471656799,
0.9267958402633667,
-0.15885882079601288,
-0.3440110385417938,
0.6691040992736816,
0.859149694442749,
1.0518521070480347,
-0.529535710811615,
0.20722365379333496,
0.06949466466903687,
0.33506619930267334,
0.011934289708733559,
0.7480072975158691,
-0.2722901403903961,
-0.890544056892395,
-0.5116923451423645,
-0.6296694278717041,
-0.43510910868644714,
-0.09678078442811966,
-0.7184682488441467,
0.3432672321796417,
-0.14687973260879517,
0.2637439966201782,
-0.3794155418872833,
-0.49148038029670715,
-0.37836527824401855,
0.08397484570741653,
0.24476097524166107,
1.0844051837921143,
-0.6421706676483154,
1.4711806774139404,
0.7838886976242065,
-0.3990045487880707,
-0.2135637402534485,
-0.2399328202009201,
-0.3773147165775299,
-1.1671228408813477,
0.2698497772216797,
0.14349216222763062,
-0.10703269392251968,
0.23549023270606995,
-0.6515422463417053,
-0.5538544654846191,
0.9993167519569397,
0.6423123478889465,
-0.23447000980377197,
-0.19091171026229858,
0.11218314617872238,
0.8647040724754333,
-0.32294198870658875,
0.2741406559944153,
0.5312463045120239,
0.4044695198535919,
0.14382952451705933,
-0.6633080840110779,
-0.3816424012184143,
-0.6721101403236389,
0.16094915568828583,
0.3365158438682556,
-0.585159182548523,
0.725324809551239,
-0.10316302627325058,
-0.09415704011917114,
0.3176229000091553,
0.9929384589195251,
-0.17421890795230865,
0.023566959425807,
0.13528302311897278,
0.771859347820282,
0.4705740511417389,
-0.5219525694847107,
1.123102068901062,
-0.4035097062587738,
0.029990607872605324,
0.8092657327651978,
0.23825573921203613,
0.774345338344574,
-0.04129091277718544,
-0.03054032288491726,
0.43285390734672546,
0.21964578330516815,
-0.4467921853065491,
0.5252681970596313,
0.07680535316467285,
-0.3662056028842926,
0.18461763858795166,
-0.08114618062973022,
-0.4026000499725342,
0.8322532773017883,
0.5027945041656494,
-0.5616127252578735,
-0.1976253092288971,
0.05502527952194214,
0.0863317921757698,
0.06424985080957413,
-0.520523726940155,
0.7072575688362122,
-0.2679373025894165,
-0.5953181385993958,
0.6458810567855835,
0.23647737503051758,
0.7488704323768616,
-0.730875551700592,
-0.15952858328819275,
-0.09893427044153214,
0.2441076636314392,
0.08431608974933624,
-0.8092350959777832,
0.4306056499481201,
0.31097888946533203,
-0.057605259120464325,
-0.5031447410583496,
0.7131675481796265,
-0.2660200893878937,
-0.28023761510849,
0.1831531673669815,
0.4382319152355194,
0.2797856032848358,
-0.08541031926870346,
-0.47337526082992554,
0.31601303815841675,
0.0840325579047203,
0.14283281564712524,
-0.008849228732287884,
0.5109103918075562,
0.0677282065153122,
0.44459742307662964,
0.5361935496330261,
0.02086000144481659,
0.13155721127986908,
0.08402344584465027,
1.040759801864624,
-0.5402247309684753,
-0.5343488454818726,
-0.6629306077957153,
0.6006478667259216,
0.02353532798588276,
-0.6186695694923401,
0.5260509848594666,
0.5903281569480896,
1.1081821918487549,
-0.36057722568511963,
0.7098962068557739,
-0.19430583715438843,
0.13111166656017303,
-0.402463436126709,
0.6817348003387451,
-0.03735059127211571,
-0.08731576055288315,
0.14812014997005463,
-0.8247334361076355,
-0.33043810725212097,
0.5811123251914978,
-0.19373294711112976,
-0.2660287022590637,
0.28956592082977295,
0.8614349961280823,
-0.02084120735526085,
0.08238474279642105,
0.3433695137500763,
0.4154227375984192,
0.17628540098667145,
0.8399633765220642,
0.9059834480285645,
-0.3529299199581146,
0.6448397040367126,
-0.03226422145962715,
-0.3446742296218872,
-0.13139386475086212,
-0.5474072098731995,
-0.6266490817070007,
-0.3997909128665924,
-0.09290920197963715,
-0.3854718506336212,
0.52794349193573,
0.6517396569252014,
0.16869211196899414,
-0.9856755137443542,
-0.374395489692688,
-0.2895174026489258,
0.05120042711496353,
-0.23999296128749847,
-0.13728715479373932,
0.21593888103961945,
-0.08447930961847305,
-1.2049633264541626,
0.7138514518737793,
0.3168661892414093,
0.016175929456949234,
-0.28316497802734375,
-0.15361323952674866,
0.2379269003868103,
-0.17918990552425385,
0.5980076789855957,
0.6101943254470825,
-0.4979381561279297,
-0.2296868860721588,
0.01969950646162033,
0.22795246541500092,
0.5303000807762146,
0.699077308177948,
-0.915187418460846,
0.6501884460449219,
0.6477035284042358,
0.5712370872497559,
0.3840618133544922,
-0.08140549063682556,
0.7488691806793213,
-0.5463302135467529,
0.43136513233184814,
0.48409101366996765,
0.406974196434021,
0.2790263593196869,
-0.22178378701210022,
0.6335755586624146,
0.32976341247558594,
-0.38353773951530457,
-0.46974077820777893,
0.06378864496946335,
-1.1426399946212769,
-0.036323100328445435,
1.0796535015106201,
-0.17648546397686005,
-0.5531277060508728,
0.3580065071582794,
-0.30808910727500916,
0.6384626030921936,
-0.5180075168609619,
0.7369353771209717,
0.029302846640348434,
-0.13466201722621918,
-0.08860959112644196,
-0.11840598285198212,
0.13516101241111755,
-0.19054573774337769,
-0.8156225681304932,
-0.40977445244789124,
0.7438703179359436,
-0.07526177912950516,
0.0575534962117672,
0.4852495789527893,
-0.24476951360702515,
0.4253084063529968,
0.2985064685344696,
0.3584027588367462,
-0.3456229865550995,
-0.7387310862541199,
-0.6985408067703247,
0.35772305727005005,
-0.1028110533952713,
-0.679306149482727
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.