id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16844v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16844v1
|
Think Big, Generate Quick: LLM-to-SLM for Fast Autoregressive Decoding
| 2024-02-26T18:59:28 | 2024-02-26T18:59:28 |
Benjamin Bergner, Andrii Skliar, Amelie Royer, Tijmen Blankevoort, Yuki Asano, Babak Ehteshami Bejnordi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have become ubiquitous in practice and are
widely used for generation tasks such as translation, summarization and
instruction following. However, their enormous size and reliance on
autoregressive decoding increase deployment costs and complicate their use in
latency-critical applications. In this work, we propose a hybrid approach that
combines language models of different sizes to increase the efficiency of
autoregressive decoding while maintaining high performance. Our method utilizes
a pretrained frozen LLM that encodes all prompt tokens once in parallel, and
uses the resulting representations to condition and guide a small language
model (SLM), which then generates the response more efficiently. We investigate
the combination of encoder-decoder LLMs with both encoder-decoder and
decoder-only SLMs from different model families and only require fine-tuning of
the SLM. Experiments with various benchmarks show substantial speedups of up to
$4\times$, with minor performance penalties of $1-2\%$ for translation and
summarization tasks compared to the LLM.
|
[
-0.1802087128162384,
-0.716180145740509,
0.46730470657348633,
0.3344767689704895,
-0.6532845497131348,
0.42366155982017517,
-0.41463592648506165,
-0.2242652326822281,
0.45415735244750977,
0.4651188552379608,
-0.3783341944217682,
-0.15549102425575256,
-0.48882052302360535,
0.3131045997142792,
-0.31094396114349365,
0.7992311716079712,
0.016047898679971695,
-0.11170517653226852,
-0.032786790281534195,
0.03725341334939003,
-0.3411891758441925,
-0.5425834655761719,
-0.6534231901168823,
-0.18765215575695038,
0.27526021003723145,
0.207563579082489,
0.7661749720573425,
0.8627876043319702,
0.24476954340934753,
0.302253782749176,
-0.035449180752038956,
0.3560686409473419,
-0.3901098668575287,
0.33136212825775146,
0.200839564204216,
-0.40554362535476685,
-0.6857563853263855,
-0.2769136130809784,
0.9165202975273132,
0.45437076687812805,
-0.30254581570625305,
0.3408082127571106,
-0.14032763242721558,
0.45748648047447205,
-0.706830620765686,
0.18929453194141388,
-0.779982328414917,
-0.0017526840092614293,
-0.08235587924718857,
-0.25802212953567505,
-0.5676012635231018,
-0.557770311832428,
-0.3477019965648651,
-0.2930438816547394,
0.1995059698820114,
0.24067386984825134,
0.3823339343070984,
0.3747384548187256,
-0.22986216843128204,
-0.11178360134363174,
-0.8655981421470642,
0.6360611915588379,
-1.0148978233337402,
0.47543105483055115,
-0.0682450458407402,
0.19461560249328613,
0.05128728598356247,
-0.7422401905059814,
-0.777051568031311,
-0.030218234285712242,
-0.1468353122472763,
0.02920803800225258,
-0.1497652232646942,
-0.08258380740880966,
0.4087032973766327,
0.5044395327568054,
-0.8376474380493164,
0.26022249460220337,
0.07026597112417221,
-0.2935589849948883,
0.6485117673873901,
0.6978468298912048,
0.20498375594615936,
-0.05213748663663864,
-0.04631504788994789,
-0.15918084979057312,
-0.7296222448348999,
-0.2229960411787033,
0.23976761102676392,
0.29383406043052673,
-0.10441683232784271,
0.5466816425323486,
-0.07439324259757996,
0.894368052482605,
0.2586224675178528,
-0.2931745648384094,
0.18040093779563904,
-0.6846034526824951,
-0.1294063776731491,
0.015250463038682938,
1.026756763458252,
0.1651700735092163,
-0.14693263173103333,
-0.23960593342781067,
-0.4972397983074188,
0.11287485063076019,
-0.2411312609910965,
-1.0311387777328491,
-0.2578383982181549,
0.03741766884922981,
-0.45555379986763,
0.06664274632930756,
-0.38692742586135864,
-0.7210921049118042,
0.013481158763170242,
-0.2231694459915161,
0.2909587621688843,
-0.31020474433898926,
-0.46475690603256226,
0.39058545231819153,
0.083591029047966,
0.31453096866607666,
0.10396337509155273,
-0.9446418881416321,
0.15685011446475983,
0.3226172924041748,
0.878536581993103,
-0.20934554934501648,
-0.15166091918945312,
-0.9613351225852966,
0.19928684830665588,
-0.4713211953639984,
0.564497172832489,
-0.24891658127307892,
-0.411374032497406,
-0.01175286527723074,
-0.3147331178188324,
-0.23141323029994965,
-0.5728407502174377,
-0.04066852107644081,
-0.6505112648010254,
-0.09967976063489914,
-0.02701530046761036,
-0.4305974543094635,
0.4031936526298523,
-0.00018067397468257695,
-0.7381748557090759,
0.839516818523407,
0.01455510314553976,
-0.7729864716529846,
0.21137551963329315,
-0.3211885094642639,
-0.7409614324569702,
0.4315544366836548,
-0.12323573231697083,
-0.2394726723432541,
0.3087221384048462,
0.3398638069629669,
0.5334253311157227,
-0.48921898007392883,
0.315477579832077,
0.0012021774891763926,
-0.11083096265792847,
0.19150622189044952,
-0.3061085343360901,
0.4976387321949005,
0.4528413414955139,
-0.14541837573051453,
0.01318374089896679,
-0.7845062017440796,
0.04727805033326149,
0.37771090865135193,
-0.6134303212165833,
-0.178676038980484,
-0.19351133704185486,
-0.11735966801643372,
0.08366981893777847,
0.5911389589309692,
-0.3588297665119171,
0.20256991684436798,
-0.35540953278541565,
0.46040695905685425,
0.372737318277359,
-0.060981374233961105,
0.520797848701477,
-0.057865314185619354,
0.7168276906013489,
0.054454654455184937,
-0.0544125996530056,
-0.6501734256744385,
-0.01253132801502943,
-1.0646291971206665,
-0.3365016579627991,
0.36168885231018066,
0.4200705885887146,
-1.2195208072662354,
0.6384832859039307,
-0.34674617648124695,
-0.30780741572380066,
-0.6984960436820984,
0.14027179777622223,
0.4210129678249359,
0.37351152300834656,
0.2530699074268341,
-0.12979695200920105,
-0.4446876049041748,
-0.7953222393989563,
-0.2762520909309387,
-0.1366952657699585,
0.0710969939827919,
-0.06321179121732712,
0.2626868486404419,
-0.16686932742595673,
0.8015908002853394,
-0.6281099915504456,
0.18995121121406555,
-0.5749046802520752,
0.2978217303752899,
0.17724886536598206,
0.4347253739833832,
0.3418927788734436,
-0.31854376196861267,
-0.5392296314239502,
-0.22979450225830078,
-0.6037986874580383,
-0.05108516290783882,
-0.08590532839298248,
0.013094021938741207,
0.36520469188690186,
0.6413111090660095,
-0.8543044924736023,
-0.03861797973513603,
0.3584621250629425,
-0.31190595030784607,
0.49361473321914673,
-0.5798835158348083,
-0.13568656146526337,
-1.170728325843811,
0.05079095810651779,
-0.24726232886314392,
-0.35701504349708557,
-0.5909607410430908,
0.19494417309761047,
0.28436926007270813,
-0.4758908748626709,
-0.4204261004924774,
0.4703238904476166,
-0.9081927537918091,
-0.15847933292388916,
-0.2640037536621094,
-0.09203340858221054,
0.00974955689162016,
0.21654798090457916,
0.1458875685930252,
1.0544151067733765,
0.4565489888191223,
-0.5695987343788147,
0.2544594407081604,
0.02548263967037201,
-0.2055724859237671,
-0.11826293170452118,
-0.6300498843193054,
0.35609740018844604,
-0.29407840967178345,
0.49368539452552795,
-0.6116135716438293,
-0.2029605209827423,
-0.10342398285865784,
-0.16151288151741028,
0.3525516092777252,
0.11746423691511154,
-1.0348269939422607,
-0.5472375750541687,
-0.23635904490947723,
0.6293894052505493,
0.9280880689620972,
-0.6162174344062805,
0.9018639326095581,
0.33938074111938477,
-0.3254796266555786,
-0.20207811892032623,
-0.6436249017715454,
0.14038681983947754,
-0.08310159295797348,
-0.6556435823440552,
0.14668066799640656,
-0.385003000497818,
-0.16091804206371307,
-0.10708814114332199,
0.3764817416667938,
0.3097245991230011,
-0.16690115630626678,
-0.17052927613258362,
0.27116528153419495,
-0.40047040581703186,
-0.16022998094558716,
0.1359962671995163,
-0.262912392616272,
-0.003338966751471162,
-0.4340091049671173,
0.723942220211029,
-0.10758690536022186,
-0.02787073142826557,
-0.1676379144191742,
0.8173381686210632,
0.7869631052017212,
-0.5044482946395874,
0.7787218689918518,
0.5680665373802185,
-0.11548592150211334,
-0.45120516419410706,
-0.6418784856796265,
-0.30354827642440796,
-0.49769270420074463,
0.19300472736358643,
-0.3190126121044159,
-0.8849024176597595,
0.5753041505813599,
0.01564430631697178,
0.17608638107776642,
0.23331648111343384,
0.8037936091423035,
0.3298896253108978,
1.1277649402618408,
0.7563475966453552,
-0.18155546486377716,
0.2877413034439087,
-0.2810583710670471,
0.43329572677612305,
-0.6119323968887329,
-0.18542315065860748,
-0.3446367681026459,
0.09623068571090698,
-0.12101291865110397,
-0.6887636780738831,
0.4110628068447113,
0.005876785144209862,
-0.10884817689657211,
0.3154023289680481,
-0.30007204413414,
0.48493722081184387,
0.3530665934085846,
-0.18065594136714935,
0.4751163721084595,
-0.030366763472557068,
-0.11716276407241821,
-0.027535993605852127,
-1.2579221725463867,
-0.33060422539711,
0.9239171147346497,
0.25936320424079895,
0.8998401761054993,
-0.04577966406941414,
0.7602391242980957,
0.19055911898612976,
0.0006798363756388426,
-0.7272903323173523,
0.8327293992042542,
-0.3364284336566925,
-0.03460443764925003,
-0.06776676326990128,
-0.5195948481559753,
-0.6035991907119751,
0.2697520852088928,
-0.24596759676933289,
-0.18217937648296356,
-0.0811758041381836,
0.4530029892921448,
-0.713472306728363,
0.26736700534820557,
-0.636843204498291,
0.5002170205116272,
-0.2831666171550751,
-0.20591484010219574,
-0.16021163761615753,
-0.4237958788871765,
0.565687358379364,
-0.27575913071632385,
0.12101197987794876,
0.09287392348051071,
-0.10153044015169144,
0.6924062371253967,
-0.5076952576637268,
0.682201087474823,
-0.03813283517956734,
-0.1654818058013916,
0.23053988814353943,
0.22547641396522522,
0.8865243196487427,
0.044834040105342865,
-0.03651576116681099,
-0.037900809198617935,
-0.47903648018836975,
-0.15258429944515228,
-0.5112380981445312,
0.706705629825592,
-0.6681252121925354,
-0.4983403980731964,
-0.1800633817911148,
-0.7186170816421509,
-0.1475074589252472,
0.036289770156145096,
0.5473922491073608,
0.5940508842468262,
0.07124795764684677,
-0.14285972714424133,
0.977059006690979,
-0.13678644597530365,
0.8250223398208618,
0.772007405757904,
-0.1535683274269104,
-0.41823312640190125,
1.0337220430374146,
0.04278715327382088,
0.3759016990661621,
0.23829448223114014,
-0.038562774658203125,
-0.37362581491470337,
-0.7490920424461365,
-0.5859289169311523,
0.5733301639556885,
-0.5511773228645325,
-0.4518478512763977,
-0.9878026247024536,
-0.29789280891418457,
-0.5454676747322083,
-0.17652422189712524,
-0.6078644394874573,
-0.149821937084198,
-0.49040529131889343,
0.12506872415542603,
0.2746523916721344,
0.5667712688446045,
-0.17191433906555176,
0.46714451909065247,
-0.9078854322433472,
0.46890559792518616,
0.4693267345428467,
-0.06207111477851868,
0.23268838226795197,
-0.4748989939689636,
-0.4953354597091675,
-0.21959097683429718,
0.18651409447193146,
-0.6005806922912598,
0.7566246390342712,
0.07085540890693665,
0.43434321880340576,
0.05283701792359352,
0.245809406042099,
0.6235135197639465,
-0.6956080794334412,
0.8130515217781067,
0.5729125738143921,
-0.8954551815986633,
0.377821683883667,
-0.172173872590065,
0.6981485486030579,
0.2835008203983307,
0.14873330295085907,
-0.18846645951271057,
-0.5272554755210876,
-0.38735437393188477,
-1.1310384273529053,
0.5914754867553711,
0.017258621752262115,
0.0009984724456444383,
-0.17789161205291748,
0.23093490302562714,
0.2543850839138031,
0.17435075342655182,
-0.4674489200115204,
-0.062114983797073364,
-0.1842743158340454,
-0.2032071053981781,
-0.30159348249435425,
-0.5766306519508362,
-0.04336075112223625,
-0.10121672600507736,
0.4443112313747406,
-0.3310467302799225,
0.3601280450820923,
-0.11470413208007812,
-0.43595898151397705,
-0.24787820875644684,
0.16182991862297058,
0.4245905578136444,
0.45825448632240295,
0.028167542070150375,
0.19679096341133118,
0.19044728577136993,
-0.3015703856945038,
0.2650744616985321,
0.10249333083629608,
-0.2914455235004425,
0.21644197404384613,
0.368187814950943,
1.0704164505004883,
0.11175621300935745,
-0.6043772101402283,
0.3629084527492523,
-0.30214327573776245,
-0.11824405193328857,
-0.24338126182556152,
0.046739187091588974,
0.1646275669336319,
0.2567307949066162,
0.5144161581993103,
-0.2813737988471985,
-0.0835191085934639,
-0.4027325510978699,
-0.07631509006023407,
0.3691502511501312,
0.557475745677948,
-0.47746574878692627,
0.7589357495307922,
0.4223649203777313,
-0.355174720287323,
0.6627207398414612,
-0.3442460894584656,
-0.4005701243877411,
0.48574867844581604,
0.8377683162689209,
1.0559213161468506,
-0.06007012724876404,
0.05063527449965477,
0.3814791142940521,
0.20244990289211273,
-0.24128641188144684,
0.24997559189796448,
-0.0686621367931366,
-0.5526284575462341,
-0.7422991991043091,
-0.9169779419898987,
-0.15425366163253784,
0.2816348373889923,
-0.6201686263084412,
-0.019103143364191055,
-0.36218103766441345,
-0.14625944197177887,
-0.2846163809299469,
-0.21440111100673676,
-0.7100213766098022,
0.017807960510253906,
0.2955769896507263,
0.8660928606987,
-0.9223024845123291,
0.9459492564201355,
0.4831799566745758,
-0.04706921428442001,
-1.0061473846435547,
0.11520272493362427,
-0.32108935713768005,
-0.6846802234649658,
0.6637688875198364,
-0.04172296077013016,
-0.3038690686225891,
0.24508456885814667,
-0.3126892149448395,
-0.9375446438789368,
1.1070841550827026,
0.5787174701690674,
-1.020482063293457,
-0.3134288489818573,
-0.01947658695280552,
0.3666043281555176,
-0.7315555810928345,
0.268221914768219,
0.7253480553627014,
0.14801113307476044,
-0.01881439797580242,
-0.9200672507286072,
0.20517370104789734,
-0.08754592388868332,
0.4359968900680542,
0.268175333738327,
-0.826190710067749,
0.9916528463363647,
-0.32182440161705017,
-0.3378291130065918,
0.012269186787307262,
0.8610965609550476,
0.42265835404396057,
-0.08683192729949951,
0.5185019373893738,
0.46057799458503723,
0.5443176627159119,
0.2246883362531662,
0.8984488844871521,
-0.7289091944694519,
0.12943649291992188,
1.0930836200714111,
-0.27075663208961487,
0.8363523483276367,
0.4597679674625397,
0.13993200659751892,
0.2351243644952774,
0.46884778141975403,
0.36642950773239136,
0.6557653546333313,
-0.03123173490166664,
-0.5054317712783813,
-0.5444633364677429,
0.04913870617747307,
-0.5905389189720154,
0.05544519051909447,
0.40539851784706116,
-0.3425322473049164,
-0.33958935737609863,
0.18772287666797638,
0.08009085059165955,
0.038203269243240356,
-0.3760001063346863,
0.8022466897964478,
0.1440497487783432,
-0.7496666312217712,
0.8312989473342896,
0.07892105728387833,
0.8819514513015747,
-0.7703904509544373,
0.1316038817167282,
-0.4677184522151947,
0.14695674180984497,
0.1006089597940445,
-0.48321717977523804,
0.14973540604114532,
0.10122670233249664,
-0.38433271646499634,
-0.4066975712776184,
0.7729722261428833,
-0.7696465253829956,
-0.521770179271698,
0.25527799129486084,
0.6613133549690247,
0.058079879730939865,
0.3313506841659546,
-0.49580663442611694,
0.45646631717681885,
-0.07782325893640518,
-0.19193512201309204,
0.4372970759868622,
0.2828603982925415,
0.21968215703964233,
0.6077136397361755,
0.7487172484397888,
0.34571242332458496,
0.4180513322353363,
0.036432113498449326,
1.126677393913269,
-0.684984564781189,
-0.6965765357017517,
-0.8875225782394409,
0.3521086871623993,
0.15243814885616302,
-0.09325562417507172,
0.7067016959190369,
0.5163410902023315,
0.3799968659877777,
-0.22600647807121277,
0.7886923551559448,
0.03569053113460541,
0.2697645425796509,
-0.8642817735671997,
0.6792439818382263,
-0.3362007737159729,
0.22664900124073029,
0.21462738513946533,
-0.8964548110961914,
-0.023707227781414986,
0.17756132781505585,
-0.017400968819856644,
-0.273157000541687,
0.5476850271224976,
0.7966465950012207,
0.08216855674982071,
-0.22943991422653198,
0.34856298565864563,
0.2484760582447052,
0.24224203824996948,
0.6596472263336182,
0.7418377995491028,
-0.19853709638118744,
0.5213591456413269,
-0.13312338292598724,
-0.11866290122270584,
-0.3554357588291168,
-0.9942389726638794,
-1.0392637252807617,
-0.37762871384620667,
-0.42182430624961853,
-0.3594475984573364,
0.07999490201473236,
0.8460381031036377,
0.6896249651908875,
-0.3616580069065094,
-0.26680365204811096,
-0.012002820149064064,
-0.2637771666049957,
0.1110660508275032,
-0.1865069568157196,
0.2425728440284729,
-0.4306514859199524,
-0.6000856757164001,
0.6418638825416565,
0.30502113699913025,
0.221694678068161,
-0.5793601870536804,
-0.2674301862716675,
0.18077853322029114,
0.19666428864002228,
0.7516892552375793,
0.3125743269920349,
-0.472858190536499,
0.21692481637001038,
0.009116141125559807,
-0.1157427504658699,
-0.18273743987083435,
1.2091916799545288,
-0.8869926333427429,
0.4329301416873932,
0.5687612295150757,
0.6464120745658875,
0.7588003277778625,
-0.14546477794647217,
0.7860419750213623,
-0.42021864652633667,
0.38142842054367065,
0.4953936040401459,
0.3348177671432495,
0.45173606276512146,
-0.5005194544792175,
-0.04144728556275368,
0.14566093683242798,
-0.42282766103744507,
-0.90550696849823,
0.3345142900943756,
-0.6979454755783081,
-0.16403017938137054,
1.1664340496063232,
-0.13388054072856903,
-0.3662853538990021,
0.1848643720149994,
0.232804536819458,
0.13647395372390747,
-0.5694403648376465,
0.2865907549858093,
0.23271562159061432,
-0.10904360562562943,
-0.331587553024292,
-0.1805099993944168,
0.3891344666481018,
0.435085266828537,
-0.6233071684837341,
0.35902276635169983,
0.5184575319290161,
0.29935798048973083,
0.044287294149398804,
0.8429316878318787,
0.07005006074905396,
0.1346559375524521,
0.1980542093515396,
0.1060255691409111,
-0.35384035110473633,
-0.33232244849205017,
-0.4632547199726105,
0.11856206506490707,
0.1775849312543869,
-0.07132311165332794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16843v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16843v1
|
Multi-LoRA Composition for Image Generation
| 2024-02-26T18:59:18 | 2024-02-26T18:59:18 |
Ming Zhong, Yelong Shen, Shuohang Wang, Yadong Lu, Yizhu Jiao, Siru Ouyang, Donghan Yu, Jiawei Han, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG
|
Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) is extensively utilized in text-to-image models
for the accurate rendition of specific elements like distinct characters or
unique styles in generated images. Nonetheless, existing methods face
challenges in effectively composing multiple LoRAs, especially as the number of
LoRAs to be integrated grows, thus hindering the creation of complex imagery.
In this paper, we study multi-LoRA composition through a decoding-centric
perspective. We present two training-free methods: LoRA Switch, which
alternates between different LoRAs at each denoising step, and LoRA Composite,
which simultaneously incorporates all LoRAs to guide more cohesive image
synthesis. To evaluate the proposed approaches, we establish ComposLoRA, a new
comprehensive testbed as part of this research. It features a diverse range of
LoRA categories with 480 composition sets. Utilizing an evaluation framework
based on GPT-4V, our findings demonstrate a clear improvement in performance
with our methods over the prevalent baseline, particularly evident when
increasing the number of LoRAs in a composition.
|
[
-0.373007595539093,
-0.5233916640281677,
0.3122122585773468,
0.3022247850894928,
-0.5435577034950256,
0.16995537281036377,
-0.04492897912859917,
-0.6222915649414062,
0.2623980641365051,
0.4133363664150238,
-0.4895361363887787,
-0.47526317834854126,
-0.5535735487937927,
0.27207621932029724,
-0.4249057471752167,
0.9163988828659058,
-0.11986596137285233,
-0.3266447186470032,
0.030651194974780083,
-0.40868255496025085,
-0.9029788970947266,
-0.38613757491111755,
-0.5740488171577454,
-0.16688397526741028,
0.6470311880111694,
0.45095089077949524,
0.2742973268032074,
0.36313962936401367,
0.4497368037700653,
0.26329946517944336,
0.18504635989665985,
0.5803409814834595,
-0.632455050945282,
0.13553112745285034,
0.014471218921244144,
-0.6364952325820923,
-0.5751413702964783,
-0.018445195630192757,
0.7060386538505554,
0.42743656039237976,
-0.016901155933737755,
0.10674314200878143,
0.1402275115251541,
0.7002139091491699,
-1.0812441110610962,
-0.14763836562633514,
-0.8459797501564026,
0.36213287711143494,
0.10687802731990814,
-0.2901175022125244,
-0.6854680180549622,
-0.17027541995048523,
-0.10056956112384796,
-0.980903148651123,
0.15591299533843994,
-0.3592369258403778,
0.33030006289482117,
0.3244086802005768,
-0.27966371178627014,
-0.16685698926448822,
-0.7975912094116211,
0.868282675743103,
-0.4166337847709656,
0.14201050996780396,
-0.14472952485084534,
0.24515382945537567,
0.23931702971458435,
-0.3593234121799469,
-0.4355962872505188,
0.3384413421154022,
0.2836388945579529,
0.6188853979110718,
-0.29584917426109314,
-0.4926064610481262,
0.0029608351178467274,
0.2582637667655945,
-0.11007342487573624,
0.12394542992115021,
-0.12542927265167236,
-0.018499033525586128,
0.3673413097858429,
0.10237814486026764,
0.19657638669013977,
-0.21063819527626038,
-0.4401940405368805,
-0.4307858347892761,
-0.8414338231086731,
-0.15714381635189056,
0.379262775182724,
0.30734509229660034,
-0.27176156640052795,
0.4559607207775116,
0.18968543410301208,
0.5654478669166565,
0.290939599275589,
-0.4735333025455475,
0.32049769163131714,
-0.43109065294265747,
-0.1707167625427246,
0.07644007354974747,
0.7450639009475708,
0.4877500832080841,
-0.1777355968952179,
-0.01396841648966074,
-0.07204190641641617,
0.5576332211494446,
0.07392764091491699,
-0.9004282355308533,
-0.004419880453497171,
-0.04904238507151604,
-0.5253403186798096,
-0.5015413761138916,
-0.15467026829719543,
-0.8880890011787415,
-0.31698206067085266,
-0.2763666808605194,
0.6066884994506836,
-0.492063045501709,
-0.048035889863967896,
0.1289568543434143,
-0.1665879487991333,
0.41969290375709534,
0.6053348183631897,
-0.9857419729232788,
0.09473615139722824,
0.14087025821208954,
0.7359617948532104,
-0.4049288332462311,
-0.49326714873313904,
-0.8374384641647339,
0.47347208857536316,
-0.3571140766143799,
1.0785232782363892,
-0.26875340938568115,
-0.3605717718601227,
-0.10702367126941681,
-0.12555624544620514,
-0.2364273965358734,
-0.40783628821372986,
0.2684737741947174,
-0.4558665156364441,
0.25490787625312805,
-0.15683415532112122,
-0.08250367641448975,
0.03574937954545021,
0.1652260273694992,
-1.0393422842025757,
0.946122944355011,
0.29438522458076477,
-0.910950243473053,
0.2649939954280853,
-0.8186854720115662,
-0.6574152708053589,
-0.18266986310482025,
-0.2562682628631592,
-0.5266088843345642,
0.3078445494174957,
0.5564783811569214,
0.06810705363750458,
-0.20020036399364471,
-0.5033636093139648,
0.06572278589010239,
-0.4701213240623474,
0.496650367975235,
-0.330802857875824,
0.43392258882522583,
0.05278109759092331,
-0.39873000979423523,
0.025991281494498253,
-1.0167421102523804,
0.04785900563001633,
0.10809731483459473,
-0.4197545349597931,
-0.29983991384506226,
-0.04739174619317055,
0.05925258994102478,
0.04442846029996872,
0.16065089404582977,
-0.324863463640213,
0.15115241706371307,
-0.04317875951528549,
0.49269941449165344,
0.723433792591095,
0.286215603351593,
0.5463173985481262,
-0.5538368821144104,
0.4394572079181671,
0.28548508882522583,
0.22163386642932892,
-0.3675364553928375,
-0.5414146780967712,
-1.0053749084472656,
-0.35990387201309204,
0.0715753510594368,
0.3986305892467499,
-1.0961143970489502,
0.36210328340530396,
-0.2578152120113373,
-0.4463730752468109,
-0.4035513997077942,
0.23825664818286896,
0.33942872285842896,
0.29543250799179077,
0.5145986676216125,
-0.6009876132011414,
-0.5181463956832886,
-0.5360845327377319,
0.1359749287366867,
0.14230681955814362,
0.2969732880592346,
0.032143834978342056,
0.39880046248435974,
-0.26040327548980713,
0.753351628780365,
-0.6113911867141724,
-0.4597192704677582,
-0.2299167811870575,
0.04576287791132927,
0.22599732875823975,
0.4510950446128845,
0.7729159593582153,
-0.477480411529541,
-0.62852942943573,
0.07181019335985184,
-0.8054222464561462,
0.32356423139572144,
-0.19278593361377716,
-0.3622214198112488,
0.2544606029987335,
0.27875396609306335,
-0.40033259987831116,
0.20880594849586487,
0.8717993497848511,
-0.03609117120504379,
0.2857016623020172,
-0.4092854857444763,
0.3244296908378601,
-1.323499083518982,
0.05089336633682251,
-0.18188205361366272,
0.019983721897006035,
-0.639589250087738,
0.33810415863990784,
-0.18629613518714905,
-0.12485850602388382,
-0.6503949761390686,
0.039658255875110626,
-0.4260508716106415,
-0.3453480899333954,
-0.10605740547180176,
0.028271237388253212,
0.483754962682724,
0.5128118395805359,
0.0009418864501640201,
0.6117449402809143,
0.520780086517334,
-0.4962979257106781,
0.16656257212162018,
0.5099524855613708,
-0.5565148591995239,
1.0215671062469482,
-0.6674060225486755,
0.5790377855300903,
-0.16496695578098297,
0.2845320403575897,
-0.793685257434845,
-0.3449266850948334,
0.3172394633293152,
0.09437060356140137,
-0.12328284233808517,
-0.2684519588947296,
-0.3960438370704651,
0.08711209148168564,
-0.4375016391277313,
0.6013478636741638,
0.6969483494758606,
-0.5681623816490173,
0.6557923555374146,
0.041469473391771317,
0.029590023681521416,
-0.4912380278110504,
-0.9797364473342896,
-0.0333528108894825,
-0.38650351762771606,
-0.4321696162223816,
0.4645809531211853,
-0.2679077088832855,
0.16240309178829193,
-0.11530924588441849,
0.2605435252189636,
0.03578953817486763,
0.011974730528891087,
0.3650398552417755,
0.35089895129203796,
-0.34555745124816895,
-0.37152791023254395,
0.11728254705667496,
0.04555344209074974,
-0.40694287419319153,
0.08849214017391205,
0.419806569814682,
0.07456622272729874,
-0.6868171691894531,
-0.36606115102767944,
0.7022018432617188,
0.632093071937561,
-0.31245186924934387,
0.3512752950191498,
0.7396148443222046,
0.02356708236038685,
-0.5379775762557983,
-0.014337792061269283,
0.11867397278547287,
-0.4317704737186432,
0.21845388412475586,
-0.49517759680747986,
-0.6255835890769958,
0.6744289398193359,
0.074349045753479,
-0.06703268736600876,
0.4895485043525696,
0.5762885808944702,
-0.21589282155036926,
0.6099986433982849,
0.5512658953666687,
0.09493215382099152,
0.6332221031188965,
-0.6452141404151917,
0.1005917564034462,
-1.0086474418640137,
-0.1847868412733078,
-0.2730603516101837,
-0.5359483957290649,
-0.6029924154281616,
-0.7975472807884216,
0.757858395576477,
-0.24206754565238953,
0.008154064416885376,
0.32533887028694153,
-0.6665021181106567,
0.49210330843925476,
0.48011940717697144,
0.5401174426078796,
0.7740564942359924,
0.6447537541389465,
0.4488993287086487,
-0.062246862798929214,
-0.5758204460144043,
0.06910970062017441,
1.0864812135696411,
0.011786953546106815,
1.1733781099319458,
0.3185441493988037,
0.933304488658905,
0.2468465268611908,
0.1473495066165924,
-0.8978322148323059,
0.5065213441848755,
-0.6592841148376465,
-0.16612184047698975,
-0.23726920783519745,
-0.23697113990783691,
-1.0953748226165771,
0.4363427460193634,
-0.45870181918144226,
-0.06310594826936722,
0.44666698575019836,
0.060325950384140015,
-0.388120174407959,
0.15992917120456696,
-0.644649088382721,
0.6008294820785522,
-0.21725031733512878,
-0.29915478825569153,
-0.1732545644044876,
-0.39879751205444336,
0.37415602803230286,
-0.3191584050655365,
0.2053043097257614,
0.1394905298948288,
0.048551492393016815,
0.5367830395698547,
-0.06498922407627106,
1.0782641172409058,
0.01839659921824932,
-0.45227617025375366,
0.4488399922847748,
-0.14058630168437958,
0.30105066299438477,
-0.1828816682100296,
-0.16809354722499847,
-0.1378764808177948,
0.04532458260655403,
-0.2894654870033264,
-0.3816024363040924,
0.6008712649345398,
-1.2232288122177124,
-0.03478572517633438,
-0.21907296776771545,
-0.6194114089012146,
-0.2768126428127289,
0.1920279711484909,
0.5406469106674194,
0.536098301410675,
-0.49833425879478455,
0.12310194969177246,
0.5928449034690857,
-0.2279621660709381,
0.5704492926597595,
-0.11025835573673248,
-0.05526399239897728,
-0.8423434495925903,
0.9803467392921448,
-0.10143746435642242,
0.35176727175712585,
0.34951362013816833,
0.06060503050684929,
0.038607072085142136,
-0.5149182081222534,
-0.6708648800849915,
-0.027454933151602745,
-1.2557077407836914,
-0.3129930794239044,
-0.19123168289661407,
-0.09959644824266434,
-0.15773363411426544,
-0.23863446712493896,
-0.401419460773468,
-0.10669472068548203,
-0.4729180335998535,
0.5720367431640625,
0.29272857308387756,
0.7508407235145569,
0.15031097829341888,
0.5044714212417603,
-0.7613292932510376,
0.6970738768577576,
0.6497867703437805,
0.16284766793251038,
-0.0555085651576519,
-0.43084290623664856,
-0.29769596457481384,
-0.06282811611890793,
-0.2573855519294739,
-0.6355336904525757,
0.11950773745775223,
0.39636772871017456,
0.4709840416908264,
0.05720994994044304,
-0.0873493105173111,
0.6247081160545349,
-0.2584891617298126,
0.6114993095397949,
0.6067603826522827,
-0.9241663217544556,
0.3884378969669342,
-0.3200584053993225,
0.4502786695957184,
0.5913028717041016,
-0.19686491787433624,
-0.29561492800712585,
-0.09196638315916061,
-0.3299424350261688,
-0.533215343952179,
0.4548328220844269,
0.06450638175010681,
0.3482048213481903,
0.23071114718914032,
0.0947042852640152,
0.3633151948451996,
-0.010503249242901802,
-0.8749184012413025,
0.0658709779381752,
-0.719836413860321,
-0.17655803263187408,
0.1107097640633583,
-0.034021783620119095,
-0.45128217339515686,
-0.06717515736818314,
0.36494776606559753,
-0.4919396936893463,
0.390594482421875,
0.08897930383682251,
-0.32047978043556213,
-0.09908335655927658,
0.39516741037368774,
0.5918481945991516,
0.3935810923576355,
0.022705407813191414,
0.22789235413074493,
-0.10395530611276627,
-0.34837672114372253,
0.40016594529151917,
-0.3455725610256195,
-0.48187991976737976,
-0.014058200642466545,
0.5835059285163879,
1.1008683443069458,
0.2594424784183502,
-0.2292153537273407,
0.5535961985588074,
0.20515687763690948,
-0.3842152953147888,
-0.008298971690237522,
0.2271360456943512,
-0.03332312032580376,
-0.019289793446660042,
0.3529578745365143,
0.37934383749961853,
-0.0973859652876854,
-0.7453087568283081,
-0.3066674768924713,
0.22714264690876007,
0.09745215624570847,
-0.46439728140830994,
0.24300314486026764,
0.37658634781837463,
0.3276132643222809,
0.39044642448425293,
-0.06231817230582237,
-0.17200680077075958,
0.4954049587249756,
0.9012920260429382,
0.670093834400177,
-0.03545258194208145,
0.48012691736221313,
0.35830631852149963,
0.13177086412906647,
-0.1218266636133194,
0.4257160723209381,
0.27203506231307983,
-0.8405786156654358,
-0.6485182642936707,
-0.4582855701446533,
-0.6874674558639526,
0.14642131328582764,
-0.5481268763542175,
0.3248877227306366,
-0.3300451338291168,
-0.03779071941971779,
-0.11745207756757736,
-0.39479950070381165,
-0.5445004105567932,
0.07678840309381485,
0.1485762894153595,
0.4760172963142395,
-1.1274715662002563,
0.5640177130699158,
0.7397319078445435,
-0.3802313804626465,
-0.6102089285850525,
-0.06527914106845856,
-0.551380455493927,
-0.7532340884208679,
0.4556632936000824,
0.025332871824502945,
-0.5480682849884033,
0.07015254348516464,
-0.45130375027656555,
-0.6595626473426819,
1.1891261339187622,
0.5769747495651245,
-0.19792556762695312,
-0.12545564770698547,
0.3311060965061188,
0.4695527255535126,
-0.670158326625824,
-0.25029832124710083,
0.41285440325737,
0.3448783755302429,
0.4400148093700409,
-0.4323875308036804,
-0.07510890066623688,
-0.05425656959414482,
0.19114887714385986,
-0.15508171916007996,
-0.6759103536605835,
1.2089660167694092,
-0.10799851268529892,
-0.15147018432617188,
0.4703291058540344,
0.2993101179599762,
0.425033837556839,
0.07829967886209488,
0.6394622921943665,
0.6373052000999451,
0.5206080079078674,
0.23279233276844025,
0.7337172627449036,
-0.11446942389011383,
0.16332033276557922,
1.2186709642410278,
-0.3475789427757263,
0.791816771030426,
0.6579742431640625,
-0.005556586664170027,
0.8625590205192566,
0.3651442527770996,
-0.2161620706319809,
1.0278511047363281,
-0.19774343073368073,
-0.3846970498561859,
-0.19938552379608154,
-0.11934219300746918,
-0.5396748185157776,
0.8571473956108093,
0.1304209679365158,
-0.2323315143585205,
-0.3126480281352997,
0.13003288209438324,
-0.3853490948677063,
-0.008881835266947746,
-0.3032839596271515,
0.7605818510055542,
-0.13648514449596405,
-0.7555674910545349,
0.7084830403327942,
-0.05640758201479912,
0.6534102559089661,
-0.4399169385433197,
-0.150173157453537,
-0.44638410210609436,
0.3142983913421631,
-0.36572954058647156,
-0.6067461371421814,
-0.10498159378767014,
-0.1777101457118988,
-0.21025414764881134,
-0.06530965119600296,
0.790070652961731,
-0.26767614483833313,
-0.49193334579467773,
0.05434723570942879,
0.7688378095626831,
-0.11201857030391693,
0.1206805482506752,
-0.3816937804222107,
0.6879521608352661,
-0.0443807914853096,
0.08190114051103592,
0.32235199213027954,
0.37447088956832886,
-0.19552597403526306,
0.06097106263041496,
0.6263700723648071,
0.015315909869968891,
0.09011389315128326,
0.3878321647644043,
0.9062682390213013,
-0.40464162826538086,
-0.5640010237693787,
-0.5539000630378723,
0.2658410370349884,
0.12008403986692429,
-0.07861482352018356,
0.45040711760520935,
0.38234448432922363,
0.41006359457969666,
-0.5928769707679749,
1.2197707891464233,
-0.09376926720142365,
-0.10457206517457962,
-0.8942082524299622,
0.4088549017906189,
-0.28844109177589417,
-0.12092582881450653,
-0.48053598403930664,
-1.2135248184204102,
-0.21723146736621857,
0.5435966849327087,
0.08388467133045197,
-0.1279057413339615,
0.7137144804000854,
0.45624738931655884,
-0.38451123237609863,
-0.3501109778881073,
0.3527055084705353,
-0.17448976635932922,
0.2167174369096756,
0.8643879294395447,
1.1321204900741577,
-0.8149409294128418,
0.6264320611953735,
-0.12364272028207779,
-0.0597856380045414,
-0.3521798253059387,
-1.2087314128875732,
-0.7867202162742615,
-0.38792183995246887,
-0.4014516770839691,
-0.1625075489282608,
-0.2447250783443451,
0.3167877793312073,
0.8628376722335815,
-0.5991272926330566,
-0.1567823886871338,
0.09019137173891068,
-0.005589201580733061,
-0.35375121235847473,
-0.0696488618850708,
0.3124529719352722,
-0.10181847959756851,
-0.7400578856468201,
0.5012911558151245,
0.3582920432090759,
0.09455843269824982,
-0.3709774613380432,
-0.18320724368095398,
0.10045888274908066,
0.13039164245128632,
1.0209472179412842,
0.13417944312095642,
-0.3315989673137665,
-0.31124046444892883,
-0.06983322650194168,
-0.16862984001636505,
0.5598276853561401,
0.8425255417823792,
-0.5479418635368347,
0.2682245075702667,
0.5235395431518555,
0.5811740756034851,
0.7266713976860046,
0.053319208323955536,
0.024979842826724052,
-0.9257817268371582,
0.3358023762702942,
-0.3033817708492279,
0.35760197043418884,
0.5971817374229431,
-0.018463101238012314,
0.44149187207221985,
0.4348059296607971,
-0.10579883307218552,
-0.4886184334754944,
0.4285498261451721,
-1.6521157026290894,
-0.11711340397596359,
1.0467182397842407,
0.060740675777196884,
-0.18938042223453522,
0.2823212742805481,
-0.3183334767818451,
0.2188400775194168,
-0.2851405441761017,
0.5943232178688049,
0.3634965717792511,
-0.2838229835033417,
-0.30913615226745605,
-0.115562304854393,
-0.06513764709234238,
0.2046201229095459,
-1.2658329010009766,
-0.25936999917030334,
0.7892342209815979,
0.3769768178462982,
0.545840322971344,
0.6575850248336792,
-0.17356452345848083,
0.4738253057003021,
0.04082248732447624,
0.1530228853225708,
0.07416840642690659,
-0.18276596069335938,
-0.19430489838123322,
0.36714181303977966,
0.35544076561927795,
-0.2192157357931137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16840v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16840v1
|
MobiLlama: Towards Accurate and Lightweight Fully Transparent GPT
| 2024-02-26T18:59:03 | 2024-02-26T18:59:03 |
Omkar Thawakar, Ashmal Vayani, Salman Khan, Hisham Cholakal, Rao M. Anwer, Michael Felsberg, Tim Baldwin, Eric P. Xing, Fahad Shahbaz Khan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
"Bigger the better" has been the predominant trend in recent Large Language
Models (LLMs) development. However, LLMs do not suit well for scenarios that
require on-device processing, energy efficiency, low memory footprint, and
response efficiency. These requisites are crucial for privacy, security, and
sustainable deployment. This paper explores the "less is more" paradigm by
addressing the challenge of designing accurate yet efficient Small Language
Models (SLMs) for resource constrained devices. Our primary contribution is the
introduction of an accurate and fully transparent open-source 0.5 billion
(0.5B) parameter SLM, named MobiLlama, catering to the specific needs of
resource-constrained computing with an emphasis on enhanced performance with
reduced resource demands. MobiLlama is a SLM design that initiates from a
larger model and applies a careful parameter sharing scheme to reduce both the
pre-training and the deployment cost. Our work strives to not only bridge the
gap in open-source SLMs but also ensures full transparency, where complete
training data pipeline, training code, model weights, and over 300 checkpoints
along with evaluation codes is available at :
https://github.com/mbzuai-oryx/MobiLlama.
|
[
-0.18626591563224792,
-0.5424624085426331,
0.6342097520828247,
0.1911873072385788,
-0.3281181752681732,
-0.07019960135221481,
-0.42664337158203125,
-0.3703542649745941,
0.23740175366401672,
0.527031421661377,
-0.359534353017807,
-0.479064017534256,
-0.5332257151603699,
-0.32918864488601685,
-0.12939709424972534,
0.8951438665390015,
-0.1963176727294922,
-0.10835786908864975,
-0.04193740338087082,
-0.3648860454559326,
-0.27961480617523193,
-0.22636327147483826,
-0.5919894576072693,
-0.379903107881546,
0.5833998322486877,
0.31652384996414185,
0.7836899757385254,
0.7361565828323364,
0.31080934405326843,
0.27905938029289246,
-0.07716068625450134,
0.15314073860645294,
-0.48810556530952454,
0.11061855405569077,
-0.2002486288547516,
-0.4221898913383484,
-0.4387997090816498,
0.07375446707010269,
0.597023606300354,
0.5129892826080322,
-0.5225216150283813,
0.6484604477882385,
0.035640161484479904,
0.8671875596046448,
-0.8644869923591614,
0.09220560640096664,
-1.0293521881103516,
-0.06328519433736801,
-0.26245781779289246,
0.3442592918872833,
-0.5225744247436523,
-0.35895678400993347,
-0.339923232793808,
-0.5521227717399597,
0.0037190038710832596,
0.043602172285318375,
0.6007755398750305,
0.3550453782081604,
-0.37370505928993225,
-0.11333402991294861,
-0.726669430732727,
0.8892558813095093,
-0.41541483998298645,
0.3666834831237793,
0.40945541858673096,
0.42034679651260376,
-0.0777321308851242,
-0.7917651534080505,
-0.5657482147216797,
-0.18538016080856323,
0.18826453387737274,
-0.1857832968235016,
-0.15807673335075378,
0.06174994632601738,
0.17724791169166565,
0.0075487056747078896,
-0.7232025265693665,
0.09732986986637115,
-0.35474953055381775,
-0.4732572138309479,
0.5567731261253357,
0.2601560652256012,
-0.17840071022510529,
0.20306475460529327,
-0.5182575583457947,
0.20954832434654236,
-1.0883314609527588,
-0.21147286891937256,
0.35978418588638306,
0.25523248314857483,
-0.4218605160713196,
0.3608536124229431,
-0.1178610548377037,
0.7959861159324646,
-0.33645811676979065,
-0.471050888299942,
0.09533651918172836,
-0.4210231900215149,
-0.47951504588127136,
-0.09848340600728989,
0.8570736646652222,
0.11087317764759064,
-0.05736294016242027,
0.030370736494660378,
-0.028266122564673424,
0.11802852153778076,
0.09951604157686234,
-1.2178311347961426,
-0.13257306814193726,
0.24844077229499817,
-0.6762409210205078,
-0.0902504175901413,
-0.10788058489561081,
-0.8374987244606018,
-0.6108483672142029,
-0.23515509068965912,
0.1871449202299118,
-0.0295658428221941,
-0.22353285551071167,
0.07667918503284454,
0.37166887521743774,
0.01796369068324566,
0.4305787980556488,
-0.900847315788269,
0.2915197014808655,
0.7456650733947754,
1.3778913021087646,
0.08561448752880096,
0.056201133877038956,
-0.5294384360313416,
0.5175561904907227,
-0.04940832406282425,
0.5358713269233704,
-0.5273745059967041,
-0.6439047455787659,
-0.2531431317329407,
-0.2099727988243103,
-0.3217207193374634,
-0.4100683033466339,
0.7433306574821472,
-0.23219797015190125,
-0.1510951668024063,
-0.05985131114721298,
-0.2961615324020386,
-0.24644041061401367,
-0.07455670833587646,
-0.6175202131271362,
0.6329005360603333,
-0.03006526455283165,
-0.46640491485595703,
0.0754084512591362,
-0.7420365810394287,
-0.24375109374523163,
0.02521943300962448,
-0.1926679164171219,
-0.6258211135864258,
0.2388632446527481,
-0.024281095713377,
0.38960158824920654,
-0.3037153482437134,
0.05144203454256058,
-0.43783554434776306,
-0.3506043553352356,
0.13601304590702057,
-0.35461944341659546,
0.7616129517555237,
0.8190472722053528,
-0.3960011601448059,
0.04019009321928024,
-0.6682308912277222,
0.34808069467544556,
-0.01799592562019825,
-0.12645457684993744,
-0.12034759670495987,
-0.09762053191661835,
0.11917673796415329,
0.006949907168745995,
0.5222251415252686,
-0.6566068530082703,
0.21136976778507233,
0.007017940748482943,
0.86832594871521,
0.873199999332428,
-0.5522435307502747,
0.6232078671455383,
-0.32781699299812317,
0.5130065083503723,
-0.5640140175819397,
0.5338476896286011,
-0.3914770483970642,
-0.6123665571212769,
-0.5139358639717102,
-0.7401590347290039,
0.5363401770591736,
0.42745304107666016,
-0.4142095446586609,
0.008565242402255535,
-0.3121531009674072,
-0.7620288133621216,
-0.7035887837409973,
0.476240873336792,
0.3763873279094696,
0.4276023507118225,
0.04172851890325546,
0.029601797461509705,
-0.5580264329910278,
-0.8548537492752075,
-0.1425040364265442,
-0.25344347953796387,
-0.022608894854784012,
0.20433050394058228,
0.5508032441139221,
-0.47882264852523804,
0.532310962677002,
-0.4661361575126648,
-0.41040006279945374,
-0.018237460404634476,
-0.17062102258205414,
0.2285216897726059,
0.598456084728241,
0.3333790600299835,
-0.5892656445503235,
-0.6353898048400879,
0.4251656234264374,
-0.38113123178482056,
-0.05677524209022522,
0.2639698088169098,
0.2375827431678772,
0.16723057627677917,
0.16384541988372803,
-0.9805632829666138,
0.23385576903820038,
1.1165690422058105,
0.0101748276501894,
0.196611687541008,
-0.41830548644065857,
-0.2456301897764206,
-0.9101550579071045,
0.2849538028240204,
-0.1287788599729538,
-0.43979522585868835,
-0.4658559560775757,
0.4249820411205292,
0.24579697847366333,
-0.3449954688549042,
-0.4710667133331299,
0.6702787280082703,
-0.6538277864456177,
-0.03775348141789436,
-0.33841264247894287,
-0.04026849567890167,
0.13761435449123383,
0.3182802200317383,
-0.2216711789369583,
1.0485814809799194,
0.3539474308490753,
-0.37065136432647705,
0.3719669580459595,
-0.3652363419532776,
-0.4268960654735565,
0.554780125617981,
-0.7333890795707703,
0.33940887451171875,
0.10907194763422012,
0.2890520989894867,
-0.7880424857139587,
-0.08560540527105331,
0.1841115802526474,
-0.0794912651181221,
0.150710329413414,
-0.29718366265296936,
-0.7400505542755127,
-0.05085860937833786,
-0.46953195333480835,
0.49912911653518677,
0.8590609431266785,
-0.4401678740978241,
0.557600736618042,
0.8170687556266785,
-0.14874449372291565,
-0.2449953407049179,
-0.748856782913208,
-0.1104518324136734,
-0.09241639822721481,
-0.8261610269546509,
0.2765052616596222,
-0.10204985737800598,
-0.12074985355138779,
-0.4734082520008087,
-0.14913029968738556,
-0.273050457239151,
0.0864742174744606,
0.5809922218322754,
0.0716710314154625,
-0.12891070544719696,
0.2007516771554947,
0.011060155928134918,
-0.10062971711158752,
-0.30542808771133423,
-0.4203799366950989,
0.45235010981559753,
-0.28998449444770813,
-0.3942044675350189,
-0.6871458888053894,
0.1990034282207489,
0.3182160556316376,
-0.08605208247900009,
0.8126813769340515,
0.5855346322059631,
-0.2704519033432007,
-0.2746245563030243,
-0.5586621165275574,
0.10610581934452057,
-0.556354820728302,
0.019197644665837288,
-0.260252445936203,
-0.9404716491699219,
0.619701087474823,
-0.12596598267555237,
-0.028599441051483154,
0.09067539125680923,
0.7192856073379517,
-0.07928874343633652,
0.9485495090484619,
0.6569394469261169,
-0.048140451312065125,
0.5272122025489807,
-0.1771133989095688,
-0.049631088972091675,
-0.7752628922462463,
-0.4679117202758789,
-0.7402967810630798,
-0.42364564538002014,
-0.5904655456542969,
-0.7407213449478149,
0.3764747381210327,
-0.11659104377031326,
-0.20049352943897247,
0.2694777548313141,
-0.7636129260063171,
0.5855909585952759,
0.1787281036376953,
0.18393509089946747,
0.5017776489257812,
0.047041140496730804,
-0.0625171810388565,
-0.06217154487967491,
-0.6915025115013123,
-0.762904703617096,
1.3129373788833618,
0.4830721616744995,
1.0975054502487183,
0.142593652009964,
0.42612946033477783,
0.08063379675149918,
0.6142305135726929,
-0.40948763489723206,
0.557580828666687,
0.11995723843574524,
-0.6514278650283813,
-0.20396623015403748,
-0.7284858226776123,
-1.2060887813568115,
0.5799756646156311,
0.18679682910442352,
-0.6452658772468567,
0.03178365156054497,
0.2531222999095917,
-0.42302122712135315,
0.3730960488319397,
-1.079542875289917,
0.8863520622253418,
-0.05679578334093094,
-0.5040500164031982,
-0.22377616167068481,
-0.3964442014694214,
0.37517204880714417,
-0.08453122526407242,
0.4615979790687561,
-0.393840491771698,
-0.8279668688774109,
0.42996206879615784,
-0.8282047510147095,
0.7851531505584717,
-0.3643460273742676,
-0.14597105979919434,
0.42204850912094116,
0.056193482130765915,
0.9725164771080017,
0.10533999651670456,
-0.1925152838230133,
0.31434953212738037,
-0.21208404004573822,
-0.7193523645401001,
-0.3645537197589874,
0.9397870898246765,
-0.4849134683609009,
-0.3832961320877075,
-0.18947601318359375,
-0.4478912949562073,
0.033938582986593246,
0.23897144198417664,
0.25996097922325134,
0.09543218463659286,
-0.054134003818035126,
0.13913604617118835,
1.0365567207336426,
0.10804441571235657,
0.4471453130245209,
0.5424733757972717,
-0.4445348083972931,
-0.2974512279033661,
1.0868544578552246,
0.20302210748195648,
0.07196823507547379,
0.38233110308647156,
0.15939734876155853,
-0.31825441122055054,
-0.9764012098312378,
-0.5703714489936829,
0.24512667953968048,
-0.20825190842151642,
-0.31524452567100525,
-0.39610856771469116,
0.07929772883653641,
-0.26193884015083313,
0.07296928018331528,
-0.6618797183036804,
-0.5249581933021545,
-0.19427992403507233,
-0.12266090512275696,
0.3326950669288635,
0.4924173653125763,
-0.03744322061538696,
0.795168399810791,
-0.5268906950950623,
-0.028606994077563286,
0.2598072588443756,
0.5380513668060303,
-0.16913120448589325,
-0.47681546211242676,
-0.3741348683834076,
0.16531285643577576,
-0.47082147002220154,
-0.574322521686554,
0.19760440289974213,
0.2505839765071869,
0.46724897623062134,
0.293222576379776,
-0.18034105002880096,
0.5579496622085571,
-0.4879058301448822,
0.5858702063560486,
0.3379497826099396,
-0.9339783787727356,
0.5106085538864136,
-0.4368559718132019,
0.2736252248287201,
0.7166624665260315,
0.055797360837459564,
-0.19223225116729736,
-0.18025361001491547,
-0.512166440486908,
-0.3788444995880127,
0.23383434116840363,
0.3186023533344269,
0.28398630023002625,
0.5282876491546631,
0.1627701073884964,
0.3627009391784668,
0.6393663883209229,
-0.7394315600395203,
-0.2810407876968384,
-0.2636975347995758,
-0.3407912850379944,
0.0060968948528170586,
-0.09321160614490509,
-0.1772404909133911,
-0.16036471724510193,
0.4961354732513428,
-0.040330324321985245,
0.23834443092346191,
-0.13101452589035034,
-0.3370058238506317,
0.12643040716648102,
0.13418810069561005,
1.122847557067871,
0.7388356924057007,
0.060334932059049606,
0.26983487606048584,
0.09632416069507599,
-0.7741718888282776,
0.26363956928253174,
-0.0637751892209053,
-0.41870737075805664,
0.37255460023880005,
0.1087084412574768,
0.8463279604911804,
-0.012313743121922016,
-0.7201719880104065,
0.7011586427688599,
0.14607660472393036,
-0.07451115548610687,
-0.18058475852012634,
0.05788835138082504,
0.07209927588701248,
0.16453394293785095,
0.15727181732654572,
0.13569311797618866,
0.01332284789532423,
-0.4683386981487274,
-0.0423240102827549,
0.732241153717041,
-0.24094170331954956,
-0.5210586786270142,
0.7240396738052368,
0.45118093490600586,
-0.18854014575481415,
0.11934994161128998,
-0.20873290300369263,
-0.0044006472453475,
0.39119744300842285,
0.24335791170597076,
0.7262864708900452,
-0.4963580071926117,
0.40427011251449585,
-0.038868315517902374,
0.8058185577392578,
-0.22834953665733337,
0.3075557351112366,
-0.2657022476196289,
-0.25992462038993835,
-0.5766577124595642,
-0.4748251736164093,
-0.49084803462028503,
0.19019664824008942,
-0.2657696008682251,
0.09051377326250076,
-0.9996365308761597,
-0.40697094798088074,
-0.4781007170677185,
0.05870696157217026,
-0.43397030234336853,
-0.1507689505815506,
-0.0958305299282074,
0.9330055117607117,
-0.38733920454978943,
1.1421993970870972,
0.484335333108902,
-0.10685748606920242,
-0.6836610436439514,
-0.6178517937660217,
-0.14277121424674988,
-1.1456559896469116,
0.22246570885181427,
0.1915169507265091,
-0.021288491785526276,
-0.2975861132144928,
-0.5793600082397461,
-0.6167629957199097,
1.129143476486206,
1.0800753831863403,
-0.747401237487793,
0.08788642287254333,
0.14138871431350708,
0.42777514457702637,
-0.2867570221424103,
0.346570760011673,
0.159670889377594,
0.7007259726524353,
0.023769591003656387,
-1.0789819955825806,
0.09940355271100998,
0.07323398441076279,
0.26066622138023376,
0.4778563678264618,
-1.1463148593902588,
1.0387617349624634,
-0.3622440993785858,
-0.3122453987598419,
0.30580419301986694,
0.39111724495887756,
0.13369515538215637,
0.5160959959030151,
0.13724404573440552,
0.6220804452896118,
1.0456867218017578,
-0.053777310997247696,
1.0947794914245605,
-0.17561160027980804,
0.47764140367507935,
1.066283106803894,
-0.366083025932312,
0.7655547857284546,
0.5562540292739868,
-0.3218158483505249,
0.5730478763580322,
0.5705291032791138,
0.2078441083431244,
0.5466196537017822,
0.19538132846355438,
-0.4644491374492645,
0.02104894630610943,
-0.14247764647006989,
-0.5462230443954468,
-0.08752307295799255,
0.13906605541706085,
-0.3863954544067383,
-0.11431725323200226,
-0.01261576171964407,
0.3384276032447815,
0.1430753618478775,
-0.7551408410072327,
0.44313427805900574,
0.4145229160785675,
-0.10563210397958755,
0.6460215449333191,
0.20645572245121002,
0.666941225528717,
-0.6234959959983826,
0.264362096786499,
-0.35939833521842957,
0.011890207417309284,
-0.47572052478790283,
-0.30057522654533386,
0.30355364084243774,
0.13357238471508026,
-0.238364115357399,
-0.40836235880851746,
0.731261670589447,
-0.35075342655181885,
-0.5376470685005188,
-0.028574712574481964,
0.31665509939193726,
0.14452776312828064,
-0.3429920971393585,
-0.6435689926147461,
0.6098056435585022,
-0.16788698732852936,
-0.05758114904165268,
0.4865860939025879,
0.2539365589618683,
0.2089776247739792,
0.9698051810264587,
0.6699767708778381,
0.40775159001350403,
0.35762736201286316,
-0.33536607027053833,
0.49988460540771484,
-0.39852285385131836,
-0.5239088535308838,
-1.0149410963058472,
0.3314317464828491,
-0.17169688642024994,
-0.08561767637729645,
0.7374381422996521,
0.7928911447525024,
0.6409777998924255,
0.07912661135196686,
0.6928445100784302,
0.2484765499830246,
0.37135833501815796,
-0.5491043925285339,
0.7829431295394897,
-0.31272411346435547,
0.45810675621032715,
0.021649425849318504,
-1.0073236227035522,
0.0965224951505661,
0.7074527144432068,
-0.04145020991563797,
0.05289405956864357,
0.5379212498664856,
0.8702196478843689,
-0.03478676825761795,
0.11478135734796524,
0.4542260468006134,
0.096737340092659,
0.04206395521759987,
0.7869982123374939,
0.5521851181983948,
-0.46544498205184937,
0.8180854320526123,
-0.0596560500562191,
-0.18832316994667053,
-0.29715901613235474,
-0.9621655344963074,
-0.7439277172088623,
-0.3678339719772339,
-0.23518306016921997,
-0.05834197625517845,
0.048850979655981064,
0.6330245733261108,
0.946150541305542,
-0.5886417627334595,
-0.46640413999557495,
-0.11439328640699387,
0.7260653972625732,
-0.05948273092508316,
-0.06937087327241898,
0.009549153037369251,
0.059340767562389374,
-0.5795007348060608,
0.24993187189102173,
0.3707422614097595,
0.09074199199676514,
-0.4281599819660187,
-0.20475423336029053,
0.35005825757980347,
0.019620323553681374,
0.5787674784660339,
0.3823443651199341,
-0.32696908712387085,
-0.03682412952184677,
-0.5019211769104004,
-0.43104255199432373,
-0.004367389250546694,
0.9001610279083252,
-0.6471250653266907,
0.22284755110740662,
0.34632402658462524,
0.7475045919418335,
0.7651541233062744,
-0.375260591506958,
0.3722032606601715,
-0.5578280687332153,
0.5517547130584717,
0.10006023198366165,
0.28176799416542053,
0.26475825905799866,
-0.05857997387647629,
0.5930219888687134,
0.33643510937690735,
-0.48937466740608215,
-1.2074767351150513,
0.4751843512058258,
-0.9359824657440186,
-0.08038413524627686,
1.1440613269805908,
-0.12864801287651062,
-0.31509169936180115,
-0.016256794333457947,
-0.1881006360054016,
-0.2593347728252411,
-0.6526455283164978,
0.5247581601142883,
0.31184664368629456,
0.03980405256152153,
-0.12720833718776703,
-0.6250463128089905,
0.3821749985218048,
0.3252018988132477,
-0.7972278594970703,
-0.021539274603128433,
0.18299166858196259,
0.250038206577301,
0.04563016816973686,
0.8003317713737488,
-0.012358536943793297,
0.18783891201019287,
0.036648258566856384,
-0.035603687167167664,
-0.34355440735816956,
-0.24353572726249695,
-0.2816365361213684,
0.44358140230178833,
0.23448790609836578,
-0.35836294293403625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16837v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16837v1
|
Do Large Language Models Latently Perform Multi-Hop Reasoning?
| 2024-02-26T18:57:54 | 2024-02-26T18:57:54 |
Sohee Yang, Elena Gribovskaya, Nora Kassner, Mor Geva, Sebastian Riedel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We study whether Large Language Models (LLMs) latently perform multi-hop
reasoning with complex prompts such as "The mother of the singer of
'Superstition' is". We look for evidence of a latent reasoning pathway where an
LLM (1) latently identifies "the singer of 'Superstition'" as Stevie Wonder,
the bridge entity, and (2) uses its knowledge of Stevie Wonder's mother to
complete the prompt. We analyze these two hops individually and consider their
co-occurrence as indicative of latent multi-hop reasoning. For the first hop,
we test if changing the prompt to indirectly mention the bridge entity instead
of any other entity increases the LLM's internal recall of the bridge entity.
For the second hop, we test if increasing this recall causes the LLM to better
utilize what it knows about the bridge entity. We find strong evidence of
latent multi-hop reasoning for the prompts of certain relation types, with the
reasoning pathway used in more than 80% of the prompts. However, the
utilization is highly contextual, varying across different types of prompts.
Also, on average, the evidence for the second hop and the full multi-hop
traversal is rather moderate and only substantial for the first hop. Moreover,
we find a clear scaling trend with increasing model size for the first hop of
reasoning but not for the second hop. Our experimental findings suggest
potential challenges and opportunities for future development and applications
of LLMs.
|
[
-0.20434445142745972,
-0.8203453421592712,
1.008333683013916,
0.31808239221572876,
-0.13133805990219116,
0.15109944343566895,
0.024674396961927414,
-0.6581221222877502,
0.20182661712169647,
0.36678048968315125,
-0.6815381050109863,
0.0705474466085434,
-0.5025153756141663,
0.09447415173053741,
-0.2732624411582947,
0.7333843111991882,
0.13939976692199707,
-0.14776620268821716,
0.014179271645843983,
0.2216987907886505,
-0.3938641846179962,
-0.7079118490219116,
-0.7052091360092163,
-0.22538256645202637,
0.8317784667015076,
0.4159213900566101,
0.7777040600776672,
0.30246466398239136,
0.5321976542472839,
0.1885480284690857,
-0.46175795793533325,
0.23329760134220123,
-0.24455496668815613,
0.5379377007484436,
-0.20726631581783295,
-0.7893326282501221,
-0.4389864206314087,
0.10211333632469177,
0.8859205842018127,
0.8331277370452881,
0.10072925686836243,
0.01558274682611227,
-0.1463751196861267,
0.4032737612724304,
-0.35539138317108154,
-0.07805341482162476,
-1.00693941116333,
-0.04065442457795143,
-0.3020135760307312,
-0.3815179467201233,
-0.45733335614204407,
-0.28760409355163574,
0.26770368218421936,
-0.10305656492710114,
-0.2053142488002777,
0.3755838871002197,
0.6056914329528809,
0.20952026546001434,
-0.7278950810432434,
-0.4644644558429718,
-0.7682334184646606,
0.6920490860939026,
-0.4452742338180542,
0.4556135833263397,
0.20790310204029083,
0.39296066761016846,
-0.45238420367240906,
-0.48275333642959595,
-0.7691342830657959,
-0.6705429553985596,
-0.20089974999427795,
-0.18938936293125153,
-0.1794912964105606,
-0.08920229971408844,
0.8643761277198792,
0.40833574533462524,
-0.5038813352584839,
0.06565199792385101,
-0.18758800625801086,
-0.2512824237346649,
0.33248183131217957,
0.27536097168922424,
0.2759033143520355,
-0.21645990014076233,
-0.413769394159317,
0.28214380145072937,
-1.0267122983932495,
0.3322807252407074,
0.21037855744361877,
0.3973028063774109,
-0.2255702018737793,
0.6552727818489075,
0.30404266715049744,
0.8254579305648804,
-0.07318775355815887,
-0.5618882775306702,
0.20656520128250122,
-0.304180771112442,
0.13269728422164917,
0.14715397357940674,
0.777805507183075,
0.04215691611170769,
0.4433688223361969,
-0.14088530838489532,
-0.15080690383911133,
-0.08833799511194229,
-0.17779600620269775,
-0.5223889946937561,
-0.12349685281515121,
0.2704341411590576,
-0.3987549841403961,
0.10787737369537354,
-0.1651463359594345,
-0.23463542759418488,
-0.5504451990127563,
-0.07081825286149979,
0.2675738036632538,
-0.4018182158470154,
-0.34436070919036865,
0.14067743718624115,
-0.11004247516393661,
0.0895816832780838,
0.2755371332168579,
-0.7576336860656738,
-0.21604125201702118,
0.6231043338775635,
1.0554463863372803,
0.17313344776630402,
-0.5777742862701416,
-0.9775469303131104,
0.21034599840641022,
-0.45233336091041565,
0.8156986832618713,
-0.8114109039306641,
-0.2424260824918747,
-0.4020228385925293,
0.020739775151014328,
-0.26624953746795654,
-0.36300143599510193,
0.5466956496238708,
-0.6806172728538513,
-0.08209540694952011,
-0.4189426302909851,
-0.35389646887779236,
-0.056798405945301056,
0.3449893295764923,
-0.7320393323898315,
0.6857046484947205,
-0.10142070800065994,
-0.8455590009689331,
0.12016376107931137,
-0.5403158664703369,
-0.5132862329483032,
-0.26035749912261963,
-0.396136611700058,
-0.25454506278038025,
0.184594988822937,
-0.04117036983370781,
0.5143532752990723,
-0.5824766159057617,
0.5480048060417175,
-0.40754520893096924,
-0.4633963704109192,
0.4732377231121063,
-0.5640546083450317,
0.9579036235809326,
0.039914991706609726,
-0.3411194086074829,
-0.22025690972805023,
-0.8730227947235107,
-0.2814992666244507,
0.16758646070957184,
-0.5493108630180359,
-0.47498002648353577,
-0.026856714859604836,
-0.47204315662384033,
0.5384597778320312,
-0.06526948511600494,
-0.5439246892929077,
0.7331715226173401,
-0.2852185070514679,
0.19381290674209595,
0.6419895887374878,
0.18914349377155304,
0.07301396876573563,
-0.37092283368110657,
0.567962110042572,
0.18942464888095856,
0.030099021270871162,
-0.7569435834884644,
-0.8791370987892151,
-0.5699259042739868,
0.04227961227297783,
0.08126816898584366,
0.5537164211273193,
-0.5811250805854797,
0.05007857829332352,
-0.026375101879239082,
-0.31354811787605286,
-0.18375670909881592,
-0.2628554701805115,
0.34789490699768066,
0.3678629398345947,
0.41448935866355896,
0.1096993088722229,
-0.5251961350440979,
-0.8798602819442749,
-0.37805795669555664,
-0.40316903591156006,
0.08602068573236465,
0.4857024550437927,
0.35295894742012024,
-0.12414255738258362,
0.7879567742347717,
-0.34734684228897095,
0.041061315685510635,
-0.08201199769973755,
0.3660701513290405,
0.6860535144805908,
0.3534875810146332,
0.7350560426712036,
-0.8381367921829224,
-0.20353096723556519,
-0.2627454102039337,
-0.6898477673530579,
-0.2153615653514862,
-0.539974570274353,
0.008366672322154045,
-0.13597670197486877,
0.5095500946044922,
-0.7310769557952881,
-0.034053340554237366,
0.7523414492607117,
-0.6215296387672424,
1.0167489051818848,
-0.011470743454992771,
0.1749301552772522,
-0.9755606055259705,
-0.1792224496603012,
-0.2600577175617218,
0.1053272932767868,
-0.6462018489837646,
-0.013423892669379711,
0.04655837267637253,
0.3369567096233368,
-0.16331325471401215,
0.4976899027824402,
-0.6254661679267883,
-0.20336291193962097,
-0.13253268599510193,
-0.021757090464234352,
-0.056380052119493484,
0.18820224702358246,
0.08957767486572266,
0.8351126313209534,
0.9367402195930481,
-0.7186391353607178,
0.4995836317539215,
-0.11851871758699417,
-0.24634645879268646,
0.6396255493164062,
-0.5132296085357666,
0.22615359723567963,
-0.11977554857730865,
0.43388235569000244,
-1.081568956375122,
-0.009426141157746315,
0.14686931669712067,
-0.3836054801940918,
0.22393469512462616,
-0.3746344745159149,
-0.6219388842582703,
-0.6531384587287903,
0.1095590889453888,
0.18409721553325653,
0.09809333086013794,
-0.495980441570282,
0.8424379229545593,
0.06264857202768326,
-0.17270615696907043,
-0.4196757674217224,
-0.8216914534568787,
0.24405698478221893,
-0.24035616219043732,
-0.7507253885269165,
0.08373624831438065,
-0.30324897170066833,
-0.465183824300766,
-0.26586830615997314,
-0.025802867487072945,
0.18951906263828278,
0.26329779624938965,
0.20780891180038452,
0.49697768688201904,
-0.4005769193172455,
0.3165138065814972,
-0.07174281775951385,
-0.11378617584705353,
0.3796527683734894,
-0.5095815658569336,
0.4193372130393982,
-0.24534691870212555,
-0.5791640877723694,
-0.14845581352710724,
0.46105411648750305,
0.7989885807037354,
-0.19133971631526947,
0.9487436413764954,
0.39920371770858765,
-0.30781200528144836,
0.1953125298023224,
-0.6999603509902954,
-0.2041301727294922,
-0.376593679189682,
-0.11393201351165771,
-1.073570966720581,
-1.2506879568099976,
0.7801392674446106,
-0.11388170719146729,
0.06960758566856384,
0.5466554760932922,
0.3691837787628174,
-0.11461617797613144,
0.941047191619873,
0.26856574416160583,
0.18425434827804565,
0.19577382504940033,
-0.29348620772361755,
0.272215336561203,
-1.1669806241989136,
-0.29664430022239685,
-0.6953318119049072,
-0.28124406933784485,
-0.6067768931388855,
-0.6686075925827026,
0.6437835693359375,
0.38269442319869995,
-0.302756667137146,
0.0020887001883238554,
0.0951087698340416,
0.47304192185401917,
0.5731924176216125,
-0.2720309793949127,
0.6797890067100525,
-0.23771171271800995,
-0.732729434967041,
0.13533563911914825,
-0.7236101627349854,
-0.4694729447364807,
1.0531080961227417,
0.37739408016204834,
0.8037991523742676,
0.44702666997909546,
0.5065440535545349,
-0.12288523465394974,
0.07840129733085632,
-0.7104412913322449,
0.5617261528968811,
0.17731936275959015,
-0.9659104943275452,
-0.2805924117565155,
-0.633353590965271,
-0.8659427165985107,
0.2000526487827301,
-0.38182052969932556,
-1.100069522857666,
0.23756149411201477,
0.3113133907318115,
-0.7845141291618347,
0.6768313050270081,
-0.5993552803993225,
0.5785899758338928,
-0.41928520798683167,
-0.2361835241317749,
0.0760120153427124,
-0.7848874926567078,
0.8296964168548584,
-0.27748462557792664,
0.33115682005882263,
0.052371688187122345,
0.2322845160961151,
0.6824933290481567,
-0.2031448781490326,
0.6491039991378784,
-0.018207214772701263,
-0.4080263674259186,
0.486959308385849,
0.4413430988788605,
0.9541239738464355,
-0.0678609162569046,
0.10930271446704865,
-0.03448458015918732,
-0.2859293818473816,
-0.13672278821468353,
-0.7269486784934998,
0.7583383917808533,
-0.5178869962692261,
-0.7710106372833252,
-0.5169457197189331,
-0.40261706709861755,
-0.5231666564941406,
0.008031859062612057,
0.01665184274315834,
0.3315543830394745,
0.3659850060939789,
0.3445630669593811,
0.8090964555740356,
-0.11551607400178909,
0.3943638801574707,
0.6145838499069214,
-0.3031480610370636,
0.0689103752374649,
0.5514662861824036,
0.21209979057312012,
0.4249532222747803,
0.4169766902923584,
0.6123737096786499,
-0.35656318068504333,
-0.5228063464164734,
-0.5090605616569519,
0.41834959387779236,
-0.6271238327026367,
0.12591621279716492,
-1.01897394657135,
-0.23267529904842377,
-0.17890703678131104,
0.1605745255947113,
-0.29950666427612305,
-0.3876360058784485,
0.05312518775463104,
-0.01211596466600895,
0.3428288400173187,
0.7593820691108704,
-0.1257975548505783,
0.14609621465206146,
-1.1987082958221436,
0.46796101331710815,
0.6999495625495911,
0.3993855118751526,
0.4382628798484802,
-0.5427027344703674,
-0.10615216195583344,
-0.1601003110408783,
-0.01859249733388424,
-1.1385960578918457,
-0.4603983759880066,
0.038904838263988495,
0.8061516284942627,
0.5921213626861572,
-0.11687126755714417,
0.5749672651290894,
-0.6263336539268494,
0.9907128214836121,
0.4296850860118866,
-0.738461971282959,
0.5501785278320312,
-0.5371326208114624,
0.23845268785953522,
0.09453073143959045,
0.7504784464836121,
-0.7629832029342651,
-0.4825862646102905,
-0.6400163769721985,
-0.6266934871673584,
0.6374024152755737,
0.009412255138158798,
0.00015484722098335624,
-0.059079576283693314,
0.18912971019744873,
0.06222120299935341,
0.06561009585857391,
-0.8824576735496521,
-0.38497990369796753,
0.31103938817977905,
0.5101916790008545,
-0.027931883931159973,
-0.5563125014305115,
0.09849502891302109,
-0.07499965280294418,
0.5011734366416931,
-0.26672932505607605,
0.061636097729206085,
0.024318262934684753,
0.1777854561805725,
-0.3126351237297058,
0.5410448908805847,
0.4385245144367218,
0.7249784469604492,
-0.12314654886722565,
0.4892716705799103,
0.02646017260849476,
-0.4407050609588623,
0.23144225776195526,
-0.030130557715892792,
-0.21343782544136047,
-0.13786202669143677,
0.8033696413040161,
0.8235655426979065,
0.30504876375198364,
-0.5624040961265564,
0.38446375727653503,
-0.04479926452040672,
-0.0696040615439415,
-0.06447421759366989,
0.22359509766101837,
0.44703495502471924,
0.796757161617279,
0.5665491819381714,
0.12564301490783691,
0.017544066533446312,
-0.9715389609336853,
-0.10216735303401947,
0.4429641366004944,
-0.04802851378917694,
-0.2172519415616989,
0.6769000291824341,
-0.2103542983531952,
-0.3097137212753296,
0.507760763168335,
-0.442918062210083,
-0.7115746140480042,
0.30472230911254883,
0.5410842895507812,
0.7036760449409485,
-0.32219669222831726,
-0.12609247863292694,
0.41646862030029297,
0.42531535029411316,
-0.045276153832674026,
0.5771403312683105,
-0.060413070023059845,
-0.7294536828994751,
-0.7741281986236572,
-0.7446746826171875,
-0.2895970940589905,
0.31846103072166443,
-0.12456037104129791,
0.05637682229280472,
-0.07729494571685791,
-0.18409189581871033,
0.09766696393489838,
-0.2714739441871643,
-0.5335084795951843,
0.10136192291975021,
0.41137295961380005,
0.8508539795875549,
-0.9591665267944336,
0.6259369850158691,
0.7329398393630981,
-0.4262685775756836,
-1.3219225406646729,
0.3897474706172943,
0.19215209782123566,
-0.5051918625831604,
0.8848254084587097,
0.0008085955050773919,
-0.5038974285125732,
-0.1408437043428421,
-0.33692851662635803,
-1.091862440109253,
0.737062931060791,
0.19670051336288452,
-0.9470330476760864,
-0.31625643372535706,
-0.15112927556037903,
0.2894602417945862,
-0.5525220036506653,
0.5698702931404114,
0.5952497124671936,
0.6404836773872375,
0.7386550307273865,
-1.3527389764785767,
0.08202139288187027,
-0.06210607662796974,
-0.09330104291439056,
0.043057046830654144,
-0.7167409658432007,
1.3874680995941162,
-0.7973556518554688,
-0.05554259568452835,
-0.18494465947151184,
0.42714250087738037,
0.797895073890686,
0.23342329263687134,
0.802991509437561,
0.3544662892818451,
1.0253561735153198,
-0.08594904094934464,
1.0004268884658813,
-0.17930205166339874,
0.15180721879005432,
1.2475672960281372,
-0.24885982275009155,
0.6952793598175049,
0.5251185894012451,
-0.4389191269874573,
0.7860456109046936,
0.7306755185127258,
0.4074055850505829,
0.06580532342195511,
0.34455591440200806,
0.04359672591090202,
-0.6202966570854187,
-0.07726337015628815,
-0.526249885559082,
0.5449680089950562,
0.34736326336860657,
-0.48336440324783325,
-0.008849904872477055,
-0.0006097754230722785,
0.17027100920677185,
-0.3738139569759369,
-0.4329281747341156,
0.477090984582901,
0.33764928579330444,
-0.875643253326416,
0.61723792552948,
-0.20300765335559845,
0.47330009937286377,
-0.5982019305229187,
0.002162552671507001,
-0.08091718703508377,
-0.11480705440044403,
-0.137507826089859,
-0.9685697555541992,
0.19546523690223694,
0.12971742451190948,
-0.20390307903289795,
-0.039496615529060364,
0.6046831607818604,
-0.31497377157211304,
-0.3480874300003052,
0.484663724899292,
0.953283965587616,
0.41741934418678284,
-0.3045269846916199,
-0.5475198030471802,
-0.06145784258842468,
-0.2184375524520874,
-0.5301021933555603,
-0.043098948895931244,
0.9065080285072327,
-0.3267180621623993,
0.7357566952705383,
0.8712109923362732,
0.6052402257919312,
0.3382602632045746,
0.6108561754226685,
1.0194923877716064,
-0.9396204352378845,
-0.76422119140625,
-1.1423479318618774,
0.3796732425689697,
0.11242768168449402,
0.06141746789216995,
0.6740815043449402,
0.6253450512886047,
0.5690984725952148,
0.13967108726501465,
0.7223823666572571,
0.09552282094955444,
0.6436247825622559,
-0.9711973071098328,
0.23761077225208282,
-0.6679366230964661,
0.46253761649131775,
-0.4429451823234558,
-1.012213945388794,
-0.14198565483093262,
0.4480164349079132,
-0.5367995500564575,
0.15428544580936432,
1.1281228065490723,
0.6091776490211487,
-0.09859119355678558,
0.2857055366039276,
0.21016521751880646,
0.5911154747009277,
0.2613702714443207,
1.009913682937622,
1.4422999620437622,
0.01810569316148758,
0.5666385293006897,
0.35586628317832947,
-0.26501795649528503,
-0.30789706110954285,
-0.9830060601234436,
-1.0456452369689941,
-0.5355896949768066,
-0.12764565646648407,
-0.40186113119125366,
-0.12055251002311707,
1.0415643453598022,
0.6246908903121948,
-0.6543868184089661,
-0.013182486407458782,
0.22202429175376892,
0.4234318435192108,
-0.18943464756011963,
-0.16788752377033234,
0.20997008681297302,
-0.10789497196674347,
-0.26094305515289307,
0.5576315522193909,
0.5801864266395569,
0.33092179894447327,
-0.6683401465415955,
0.003077868139371276,
-0.49162861704826355,
0.06709475070238113,
0.6444163918495178,
-0.11517059803009033,
-0.8784278631210327,
-0.4201694428920746,
0.17203444242477417,
0.04745504632592201,
0.03456056863069534,
1.151655673980713,
-0.6923788785934448,
0.3184821903705597,
0.39545342326164246,
0.31302013993263245,
0.26055118441581726,
-0.10157979279756546,
0.1319064497947693,
-0.6180103421211243,
-0.21208618581295013,
0.24011829495429993,
0.5172703862190247,
0.14185261726379395,
-0.4803476929664612,
0.14945726096630096,
0.5598278641700745,
-0.43159717321395874,
-0.6311330795288086,
0.626423716545105,
-0.6836265921592712,
-0.2271662801504135,
1.3347375392913818,
-0.22665482759475708,
-0.2881605327129364,
-0.3274691700935364,
-0.17921900749206543,
-0.06695478409528732,
-0.23060595989227295,
0.5753516554832458,
1.0017424821853638,
-0.5633576512336731,
-0.36883240938186646,
-0.590587854385376,
0.2878679633140564,
0.031054241582751274,
-0.445608526468277,
0.16799256205558777,
0.5439700484275818,
-0.012536885216832161,
0.6620139479637146,
0.9507296085357666,
0.2682756781578064,
0.23256678879261017,
0.1818801462650299,
-0.565268874168396,
-0.07664869725704193,
-0.9704614877700806,
-0.03631095588207245,
0.26641619205474854,
0.33922719955444336,
0.2106037735939026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16836v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16836v1
|
PhyGrasp: Generalizing Robotic Grasping with Physics-informed Large Multimodal Models
| 2024-02-26T18:57:52 | 2024-02-26T18:57:52 |
Dingkun Guo, Yuqi Xiang, Shuqi Zhao, Xinghao Zhu, Masayoshi Tomizuka, Mingyu Ding, Wei Zhan
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Robotic grasping is a fundamental aspect of robot functionality, defining how
robots interact with objects. Despite substantial progress, its
generalizability to counter-intuitive or long-tailed scenarios, such as objects
with uncommon materials or shapes, remains a challenge. In contrast, humans can
easily apply their intuitive physics to grasp skillfully and change grasps
efficiently, even for objects they have never seen before.
This work delves into infusing such physical commonsense reasoning into
robotic manipulation. We introduce PhyGrasp, a multimodal large model that
leverages inputs from two modalities: natural language and 3D point clouds,
seamlessly integrated through a bridge module. The language modality exhibits
robust reasoning capabilities concerning the impacts of diverse physical
properties on grasping, while the 3D modality comprehends object shapes and
parts. With these two capabilities, PhyGrasp is able to accurately assess the
physical properties of object parts and determine optimal grasping poses.
Additionally, the model's language comprehension enables human instruction
interpretation, generating grasping poses that align with human preferences. To
train PhyGrasp, we construct a dataset PhyPartNet with 195K object instances
with varying physical properties and human preferences, alongside their
corresponding language descriptions. Extensive experiments conducted in the
simulation and on the real robots demonstrate that PhyGrasp achieves
state-of-the-art performance, particularly in long-tailed cases, e.g., about
10% improvement in success rate over GraspNet. Project page:
https://sites.google.com/view/phygrasp
|
[
-0.1713283509016037,
-0.7309259176254272,
0.757442057132721,
-0.08587631583213806,
-0.1401769369840622,
-0.18485037982463837,
-0.16108471155166626,
-0.4304507076740265,
0.22531327605247498,
0.16142228245735168,
-0.2456692010164261,
-0.22892138361930847,
-0.6478179693222046,
-0.14660164713859558,
-0.1714552491903305,
0.8531745672225952,
0.1124892458319664,
-0.14028674364089966,
-0.027189578860998154,
-0.20784342288970947,
0.02083410881459713,
-0.4782382547855377,
-0.0423460491001606,
-0.6616175174713135,
0.7351555228233337,
0.16572493314743042,
1.2504686117172241,
0.482430636882782,
0.45187878608703613,
0.33574438095092773,
-0.013329900801181793,
0.3141557276248932,
-0.04865866154432297,
-0.2867085635662079,
-0.6761856079101562,
-0.3461460769176483,
-0.3165181577205658,
-0.07634930312633514,
0.48844894766807556,
1.1553655862808228,
-0.13962988555431366,
-0.20193712413311005,
0.17773592472076416,
0.4046279788017273,
-0.9355635643005371,
-0.03735734522342682,
-0.4922487139701843,
0.09538861364126205,
-0.12664391100406647,
0.025451401248574257,
-0.23627276718616486,
0.00464117806404829,
0.17742660641670227,
-1.0535951852798462,
0.11699012666940689,
-0.11399852484464645,
0.9904391169548035,
0.14332373440265656,
-0.7825106382369995,
-0.0024477506522089243,
-0.6677483320236206,
0.7535101771354675,
-0.45235487818717957,
0.6800413131713867,
0.5333694815635681,
0.5200288891792297,
-0.382956862449646,
-0.5956326127052307,
-0.6879541277885437,
-0.39636915922164917,
0.015217430889606476,
0.1273467242717743,
0.04763362929224968,
0.5228039622306824,
0.49950623512268066,
0.13476164638996124,
-0.584581732749939,
-0.09904094785451889,
-0.5184386968612671,
-0.15467886626720428,
0.6816521883010864,
0.030295372009277344,
0.3367280066013336,
-0.30870476365089417,
-0.5756238102912903,
-0.3981366753578186,
-0.42066970467567444,
0.35256966948509216,
0.5461153984069824,
0.21889826655387878,
-0.071749746799469,
1.100504755973816,
-0.38810956478118896,
0.9505993723869324,
-0.013549712486565113,
-0.20478370785713196,
0.41075098514556885,
-0.18529745936393738,
-0.277631938457489,
-0.61966472864151,
0.9290547370910645,
0.5009805560112,
0.3705381751060486,
0.00803315918892622,
-0.015698930248618126,
-0.17364852130413055,
0.4307173192501068,
-0.3460882604122162,
-0.6526339650154114,
0.5679163932800293,
-0.478355348110199,
0.3635660707950592,
0.3128575384616852,
-0.5944303274154663,
-0.7712931632995605,
-0.6295303106307983,
0.593246340751648,
-0.6962200403213501,
-0.5729857683181763,
0.7912470698356628,
-0.3294595181941986,
0.1347275972366333,
0.595234751701355,
-0.9819778203964233,
0.23603646457195282,
0.8327171802520752,
0.8665253520011902,
0.007277380675077438,
-0.8315801024436951,
-0.5672891736030579,
0.4289999008178711,
-0.1860024631023407,
0.5872848033905029,
-0.3765346109867096,
-0.20946180820465088,
-0.16629458963871002,
0.0006854406674392521,
-0.23402950167655945,
-0.5209407806396484,
0.1939789056777954,
-0.10637637227773666,
0.041499242186546326,
0.09409144520759583,
-0.2510533034801483,
-0.43111446499824524,
0.2914843261241913,
-0.7030617594718933,
0.6106577515602112,
0.12797559797763824,
-0.46317237615585327,
0.628442645072937,
-0.7278971672058105,
-0.7278492450714111,
0.02258387580513954,
0.14856064319610596,
-0.23813118040561676,
0.20360955595970154,
0.08298509567975998,
0.5533556938171387,
0.04664762318134308,
0.3280216157436371,
-0.7558709383010864,
0.1328313946723938,
0.12652765214443207,
-0.07852549850940704,
0.4872797429561615,
0.2877316474914551,
0.0764864832162857,
0.3284354507923126,
-0.190455362200737,
-0.24448342621326447,
-0.02886304445564747,
-0.003830046858638525,
-0.4194244146347046,
0.0046251374296844006,
-0.08440717309713364,
0.3247516453266144,
0.4326595067977905,
-0.4505457282066345,
0.40205082297325134,
-0.5517461895942688,
0.3341227173805237,
0.2549509108066559,
-0.18147213757038116,
0.9470690488815308,
-0.1705167293548584,
0.2987770438194275,
-0.4176371395587921,
0.618227481842041,
-0.0632273480296135,
-0.4533293545246124,
-0.12264644354581833,
-0.42672374844551086,
-0.23781083524227142,
0.3420118987560272,
-0.8823212385177612,
0.3132721781730652,
0.006208521779626608,
-0.4180350601673126,
0.05769576504826546,
0.3656538426876068,
0.14793865382671356,
0.41709405183792114,
0.30603939294815063,
-0.17143023014068604,
-0.03574218973517418,
-1.0339823961257935,
-0.3049227297306061,
-0.2860524654388428,
-0.6161879301071167,
0.08409067988395691,
0.5152808427810669,
0.30851319432258606,
1.0390312671661377,
-0.521243691444397,
-0.14669182896614075,
-0.239792138338089,
0.20788240432739258,
0.3704322576522827,
0.4701255261898041,
0.40357375144958496,
-1.16372811794281,
0.07654303312301636,
0.3239027261734009,
-0.7463878393173218,
0.2896985113620758,
-0.3470379114151001,
-0.20270031690597534,
-0.21712836623191833,
0.0877460390329361,
-1.2074238061904907,
0.25601932406425476,
0.4016614258289337,
-0.41796875,
0.6326143145561218,
-0.3136058747768402,
0.11441885679960251,
-0.7344191670417786,
0.29244425892829895,
0.4113721251487732,
-0.01886902004480362,
-0.5699238777160645,
0.3297745883464813,
0.20955458283424377,
-0.1283315271139145,
-0.9078391790390015,
0.5765728950500488,
-0.487210214138031,
-0.2945835590362549,
-0.3338164985179901,
0.16652587056159973,
0.15426278114318848,
0.5427631735801697,
0.36267054080963135,
0.3488636612892151,
0.40329450368881226,
-0.7555702924728394,
0.5284724235534668,
-0.05819473788142204,
-0.1771809458732605,
0.6608058214187622,
-0.8149669170379639,
-0.14406052231788635,
0.05547880008816719,
0.05830955505371094,
-0.7054247260093689,
-0.6149412989616394,
0.621053159236908,
-0.5188196897506714,
0.030811075121164322,
-0.4614908695220947,
-0.7077751159667969,
-0.5470696687698364,
-0.15528294444084167,
0.33537593483924866,
0.16914398968219757,
-0.5042469501495361,
1.1869550943374634,
0.3298965096473694,
0.07628455758094788,
-0.5861423015594482,
-0.4612622857093811,
-0.046557266265153885,
-0.27721163630485535,
-0.5686233043670654,
0.012888096272945404,
-0.1600244790315628,
-0.2840033173561096,
-0.18990018963813782,
-0.28039079904556274,
-0.27817681431770325,
0.13130629062652588,
0.20161551237106323,
0.014358355663716793,
0.5092196464538574,
0.14573125541210175,
0.24261625111103058,
0.055534977465867996,
0.057751864194869995,
-0.3726215660572052,
0.6625399589538574,
-0.12811343371868134,
-0.8716723322868347,
-0.6001762747764587,
-0.11604627966880798,
0.6598681211471558,
-0.13600881397724152,
0.27059587836265564,
0.4679138660430908,
-0.5065138936042786,
-0.0002077534154523164,
-0.16627275943756104,
-0.3408714234828949,
-0.5292553901672363,
0.5020166039466858,
-0.7480301856994629,
-0.38474059104919434,
0.17737825214862823,
-0.15368834137916565,
0.24195349216461182,
0.05477520823478699,
0.48641085624694824,
-0.2940443158149719,
1.2400422096252441,
0.41855013370513916,
0.1399698406457901,
0.4934885501861572,
-0.4546247720718384,
-0.08877355605363846,
-0.6877367496490479,
-0.5965138673782349,
-0.2786993682384491,
-0.44116324186325073,
0.0791817307472229,
-0.701143205165863,
0.3510949909687042,
0.2920234501361847,
-0.2596169114112854,
0.5995416641235352,
-0.4113691747188568,
0.4699007272720337,
0.4517706036567688,
0.42841553688049316,
0.20672546327114105,
0.06742776185274124,
-0.03634268790483475,
0.0468062162399292,
-0.557807981967926,
-0.47177061438560486,
0.7539030909538269,
0.31705039739608765,
0.6468670964241028,
0.03766332194209099,
0.1277594268321991,
0.1891847550868988,
-0.18051917850971222,
-1.0531859397888184,
0.601722002029419,
0.018041450530290604,
-0.4825287461280823,
-0.22206537425518036,
-0.46255403757095337,
-1.3166260719299316,
0.6792149543762207,
-0.2526308000087738,
-0.6396465301513672,
-0.06414107233285904,
0.35648512840270996,
-0.30810484290122986,
0.7094321250915527,
-0.8299482464790344,
0.8739110827445984,
-0.5669069886207581,
-0.5746638178825378,
-0.7066117525100708,
-0.6787678599357605,
0.39314332604408264,
0.48624005913734436,
0.20112106204032898,
-0.09574781358242035,
-0.3808175027370453,
0.29418081045150757,
-0.20355047285556793,
0.8415494561195374,
-0.3474736511707306,
-0.3755818009376526,
0.18945994973182678,
0.4264813959598541,
0.21485619246959686,
0.14442260563373566,
0.15428125858306885,
0.1733478158712387,
-0.149814635515213,
-0.6517990827560425,
-0.9831279516220093,
0.3389221429824829,
-0.7379530668258667,
-0.41853833198547363,
-0.2488129436969757,
-0.9485980272293091,
-0.2980782091617584,
0.20116333663463593,
-0.13114438951015472,
0.38801711797714233,
0.20943371951580048,
-0.0297258161008358,
0.5743399858474731,
-0.12887117266654968,
0.21666236221790314,
0.23751261830329895,
-0.33821606636047363,
-0.1736178696155548,
0.8728703856468201,
-0.27019792795181274,
0.4665434658527374,
0.7021097540855408,
0.3985234797000885,
-0.5039440989494324,
-0.5839090943336487,
-0.44714856147766113,
0.35971492528915405,
-0.4545360207557678,
-0.012856733053922653,
-0.646711528301239,
0.2315521538257599,
-0.1407809555530548,
-0.35109907388687134,
-0.350580096244812,
-0.6093308329582214,
-0.017935650423169136,
-0.039449937641620636,
0.26014113426208496,
0.7083790302276611,
-0.27558863162994385,
0.4432685375213623,
-0.6533826589584351,
0.7395163178443909,
0.4586382806301117,
0.3061075508594513,
-0.25357940793037415,
-0.448220431804657,
-0.14912164211273193,
0.3603802025318146,
-0.2021884024143219,
-0.6009333729743958,
0.30901744961738586,
0.0690009817481041,
0.6186228394508362,
0.5156790614128113,
-0.12921014428138733,
0.4633674621582031,
-0.02235548198223114,
0.7368538975715637,
0.6145774126052856,
-0.7684940099716187,
0.6527632474899292,
-0.6866050958633423,
0.4886589050292969,
0.0873858854174614,
0.6051303744316101,
-0.46810948848724365,
-0.2916814088821411,
-0.5000273585319519,
-0.6197676062583923,
0.4150868356227875,
-0.08898754417896271,
0.16861221194267273,
0.2422657459974289,
0.20757532119750977,
0.2917426526546478,
0.3130996823310852,
-0.5073273777961731,
0.31793412566185,
-0.33110859990119934,
-0.20029501616954803,
0.06451313197612762,
0.29365435242652893,
-0.23784025013446808,
-0.2125571370124817,
0.1063656136393547,
-0.3976571559906006,
-0.14235445857048035,
-0.0756431370973587,
-0.33397525548934937,
0.18834327161312103,
-0.1138615757226944,
0.5236629843711853,
0.8430110216140747,
-0.07691441476345062,
0.27715641260147095,
0.09044608473777771,
-0.569533109664917,
-0.24246665835380554,
0.018077416345477104,
0.16019992530345917,
-0.3141975402832031,
0.3552462160587311,
0.3014167249202728,
0.17281094193458557,
-0.8142521977424622,
0.374836802482605,
0.42278391122817993,
-0.42117705941200256,
0.022550901398062706,
0.011818645521998405,
-0.14878614246845245,
0.29093536734580994,
0.47267141938209534,
0.31215834617614746,
0.29435741901397705,
-0.34632936120033264,
0.17729593813419342,
0.5331768989562988,
0.027105288580060005,
-0.7030268311500549,
0.5091780424118042,
0.14398644864559174,
0.04306480661034584,
0.4280320107936859,
-0.1138186901807785,
-0.4762488901615143,
0.530005693435669,
0.08798683434724808,
0.4755208194255829,
-0.1365382969379425,
0.35343533754348755,
0.6105757355690002,
0.3209775984287262,
-0.2202974110841751,
0.07502395659685135,
-0.3305223882198334,
-0.8660072088241577,
-0.5592465996742249,
-0.22980734705924988,
-0.513187050819397,
-0.17384439706802368,
-0.36481231451034546,
0.25303977727890015,
-0.7717041969299316,
-0.16113589704036713,
-0.3527020812034607,
-0.07937312871217728,
-0.43079686164855957,
0.07894598692655563,
0.11563756316900253,
0.732903242111206,
-0.8043026924133301,
0.7919594645500183,
1.0995063781738281,
-0.573418915271759,
-0.4932688772678375,
-0.16939422488212585,
0.11512648314237595,
-0.7609015107154846,
0.6067931652069092,
-0.14021232724189758,
-0.408006489276886,
-0.4194464385509491,
-0.8147187232971191,
-0.6701251268386841,
0.8744766712188721,
0.41178399324417114,
-0.4213120639324188,
-0.045574549585580826,
0.15198929607868195,
0.20065028965473175,
0.24687430262565613,
0.27960485219955444,
0.19246092438697815,
0.5390210151672363,
0.2852742373943329,
-1.24917733669281,
-0.40672701597213745,
-0.2860967218875885,
-0.31224530935287476,
0.4826902747154236,
-0.7096695303916931,
0.7856137156486511,
-0.36034199595451355,
-0.10150448232889175,
0.061066608875989914,
0.6141660213470459,
0.6377640962600708,
0.3505375385284424,
0.7385324239730835,
0.6707623600959778,
0.6476672291755676,
0.07764951139688492,
1.1649138927459717,
0.026142489165067673,
0.18588249385356903,
0.9000154137611389,
-0.3649178445339203,
0.7457583546638489,
0.5751385688781738,
-0.1614285409450531,
0.2717732787132263,
0.2547881007194519,
0.12628571689128876,
0.35357892513275146,
0.0808355063199997,
-0.20408280193805695,
-0.5513380169868469,
-0.16527453064918518,
-0.07514884322881699,
0.5216883420944214,
0.5293523073196411,
0.2638915479183197,
-0.28921371698379517,
0.553320050239563,
0.013104237616062164,
0.41271862387657166,
-0.49639683961868286,
0.3698784112930298,
-0.05186775326728821,
-0.5381518006324768,
0.19549989700317383,
-0.21254627406597137,
0.8761981725692749,
-0.8474618792533875,
-0.04824250563979149,
0.13849033415317535,
0.31281131505966187,
-0.20076951384544373,
-1.4093782901763916,
0.174577534198761,
-0.42863839864730835,
-0.03789859265089035,
-0.3633905053138733,
0.8977879285812378,
-0.2727033197879791,
0.02052765153348446,
0.26860421895980835,
0.3980405330657959,
0.16508443653583527,
-0.24825799465179443,
-0.7773672938346863,
-0.014466734603047371,
-0.49158260226249695,
-0.04446719214320183,
0.5290579795837402,
0.5074270367622375,
0.002499842317774892,
1.1850996017456055,
0.6110390424728394,
0.08822862058877945,
-0.09258486330509186,
0.013628369197249413,
0.6910257935523987,
-0.4783942699432373,
-0.3103652894496918,
-0.4446178674697876,
0.582460880279541,
-0.09188663214445114,
-0.3762252926826477,
0.8166730999946594,
0.5737363696098328,
1.094853401184082,
-0.180116206407547,
0.4801119267940521,
-0.3140391707420349,
0.1882697492837906,
-0.70684415102005,
0.3990864157676697,
-0.706730306148529,
-0.35319963097572327,
-0.28091150522232056,
-0.6448453068733215,
-0.4878607392311096,
0.8031224608421326,
-0.5859088897705078,
0.21349452435970306,
0.4772696793079376,
0.5514042973518372,
-0.4560057818889618,
-0.28052207827568054,
0.5559048652648926,
-0.044580332934856415,
0.24734064936637878,
0.9221783876419067,
1.166793704032898,
-0.05875692889094353,
0.628001868724823,
-0.4055069386959076,
-0.1784200668334961,
-0.007717487867921591,
-0.7717067003250122,
-0.7760008573532104,
-0.527740478515625,
-0.2254256010055542,
-0.10478650778532028,
-0.11679629236459732,
0.9275132417678833,
0.9785475730895996,
-0.43488001823425293,
-0.49913546442985535,
0.029139691963791847,
0.14711838960647583,
-0.3759273290634155,
-0.17395150661468506,
0.08202983438968658,
-0.20801417529582977,
-0.9777296781539917,
0.41490691900253296,
0.2829590439796448,
-0.06911656260490417,
-0.08390185981988907,
-0.22163504362106323,
-0.33025601506233215,
-0.5721703767776489,
0.8970364928245544,
0.7430954575538635,
-0.7366379499435425,
-0.2087118774652481,
0.10098955780267715,
-0.002023731591179967,
-0.14445483684539795,
0.9904762506484985,
-0.864612877368927,
0.5910130739212036,
0.5517260432243347,
0.4489670395851135,
0.3970091640949249,
0.10833097994327545,
0.6593461632728577,
-0.45751553773880005,
0.5077934265136719,
0.20511727035045624,
0.6284911036491394,
0.29492610692977905,
-0.11714361608028412,
0.4116238057613373,
0.28329527378082275,
-0.3119024336338043,
-0.28660884499549866,
0.5580074787139893,
-1.0882539749145508,
-0.5981938242912292,
1.0927387475967407,
0.14048640429973602,
-0.3629004955291748,
-0.33046501874923706,
-0.42447352409362793,
0.125226229429245,
-0.33857330679893494,
0.5774322748184204,
0.30642154812812805,
-0.11241944879293442,
-0.40028175711631775,
-0.4367585778236389,
0.11417076736688614,
0.5640257000923157,
-0.6710605621337891,
0.11876130104064941,
0.7655284404754639,
0.14187709987163544,
0.24374282360076904,
0.15013034641742706,
-0.07195226103067398,
0.6033482551574707,
-0.18906180560588837,
0.4039502739906311,
-0.2548304796218872,
-0.6513311862945557,
-0.2670527398586273,
0.40437081456184387,
0.10330985486507416,
-0.2657356858253479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16835v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16835v1
|
Eight Methods to Evaluate Robust Unlearning in LLMs
| 2024-02-26T18:57:37 | 2024-02-26T18:57:37 |
Aengus Lynch, Phillip Guo, Aidan Ewart, Stephen Casper, Dylan Hadfield-Menell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine unlearning can be useful for removing harmful capabilities and
memorized text from large language models (LLMs), but there are not yet
standardized methods for rigorously evaluating it. In this paper, we first
survey techniques and limitations of existing unlearning evaluations. Second,
we apply a comprehensive set of tests for the robustness and competitiveness of
unlearning in the "Who's Harry Potter" (WHP) model from Eldan and Russinovich
(2023). While WHP's unlearning generalizes well when evaluated with the
"Familiarity" metric from Eldan and Russinovich, we find i)
higher-than-baseline amounts of knowledge can reliably be extracted, ii) WHP
performs on par with the original model on Harry Potter Q&A tasks, iii) it
represents latent knowledge comparably to the original model, and iv) there is
collateral unlearning in related domains. Overall, our results highlight the
importance of comprehensive unlearning evaluation that avoids ad-hoc metrics.
|
[
-0.11004672944545746,
-0.6974570155143738,
0.2792058289051056,
-0.17913858592510223,
-0.22778980433940887,
0.45549657940864563,
-0.5903138518333435,
-0.24876587092876434,
-0.4841272532939911,
0.38724255561828613,
-0.42043277621269226,
-0.3538113832473755,
-0.5507822036743164,
-0.03859651833772659,
-0.3264053761959076,
0.9550893902778625,
0.04561774060130119,
0.13439060747623444,
-0.5370371341705322,
-0.0728333368897438,
-0.265560120344162,
-0.2765848636627197,
-0.18534721434116364,
-0.8247795701026917,
0.40479761362075806,
0.5157002806663513,
0.5924978256225586,
0.7881443500518799,
0.7466093897819519,
0.3875909447669983,
-0.47581055760383606,
0.2533377707004547,
-0.7110504508018494,
0.36863958835601807,
-0.28723809123039246,
-0.25243133306503296,
-0.3072272837162018,
-0.04019736126065254,
0.5396193861961365,
1.1847238540649414,
-0.37542974948883057,
0.2538052499294281,
0.6880613565444946,
0.6370148658752441,
-0.8027328252792358,
0.10671637207269669,
-0.8139374852180481,
-0.03770672529935837,
-0.0821407213807106,
-0.08319991827011108,
-0.38993290066719055,
-0.07876774668693542,
0.2724018692970276,
-0.5830642580986023,
0.03693912550806999,
-0.12619945406913757,
0.751176655292511,
0.20472733676433563,
-0.5592138171195984,
-0.30373701453208923,
-0.7987257242202759,
1.2850239276885986,
-0.4998169243335724,
0.5567426085472107,
0.6199546456336975,
0.31739258766174316,
-0.2957369089126587,
-0.835487961769104,
-0.23785080015659332,
-0.35981833934783936,
0.26949211955070496,
0.31286177039146423,
-0.24859124422073364,
-0.0026139328256249428,
0.27369439601898193,
0.4758101999759674,
-0.3696523904800415,
0.39377886056900024,
-0.5458757877349854,
-0.16925613582134247,
0.46784189343452454,
0.04763107746839523,
0.26173749566078186,
0.0007585658458992839,
-0.5162649154663086,
-0.09966151416301727,
-0.4946311116218567,
0.20132553577423096,
0.40185579657554626,
0.05355214327573776,
0.23319290578365326,
0.6210705637931824,
-0.16746503114700317,
0.28124716877937317,
-0.15961603820323944,
-0.6590783596038818,
0.32352423667907715,
-0.033076316118240356,
-0.13991928100585938,
-0.5424551963806152,
0.6793913841247559,
0.5654030442237854,
0.6891819834709167,
-0.781078040599823,
-0.41417112946510315,
-0.03621215000748634,
0.3042259216308594,
-0.5708484053611755,
-0.14318203926086426,
0.07053744047880173,
-0.7924531102180481,
-0.1608562022447586,
-0.01684618927538395,
-0.9194276928901672,
-0.5144280791282654,
-0.18581414222717285,
0.36515671014785767,
-0.5002648830413818,
-0.25209805369377136,
-0.22769661247730255,
-0.46570393443107605,
0.29065755009651184,
0.2527124881744385,
-0.8289220929145813,
0.1348128765821457,
0.5052995085716248,
0.46666911244392395,
-0.79664546251297,
-0.6152122020721436,
-0.20812897384166718,
0.00827592983841896,
-0.3509778082370758,
0.7760468125343323,
-0.3599894046783447,
-0.4956468939781189,
0.16181188821792603,
-0.022597430273890495,
-0.008049998432397842,
-1.0675092935562134,
0.4669255018234253,
-0.566875696182251,
0.13297444581985474,
-0.3638491928577423,
-0.7424412965774536,
-0.22640007734298706,
0.24140118062496185,
-0.4537872076034546,
0.8761004209518433,
0.08231593668460846,
-0.7209372520446777,
0.526648223400116,
-0.13928966224193573,
-0.30380409955978394,
-0.09007379412651062,
0.2514127492904663,
-0.46188366413116455,
0.08542608469724655,
-0.02710292860865593,
0.5143272876739502,
-0.24913012981414795,
0.32186540961265564,
-0.6122115850448608,
-0.5089318752288818,
0.24898084998130798,
-0.7666078805923462,
0.9775729775428772,
0.3874273896217346,
-0.2753395736217499,
-0.08349040150642395,
-0.8429532051086426,
0.11778418719768524,
0.15590590238571167,
-0.584879994392395,
-0.3000129759311676,
-0.10663843899965286,
-0.31757915019989014,
-0.11087208986282349,
0.40739014744758606,
-0.45277854800224304,
-0.011349795386195183,
-0.28268545866012573,
0.08251486718654633,
0.6024401187896729,
0.20631729066371918,
0.5352147817611694,
-0.6821419596672058,
0.517877995967865,
-0.19723886251449585,
0.23488453030586243,
-0.13144135475158691,
-0.3467648923397064,
-0.7593858242034912,
-0.24533061683177948,
0.08398768305778503,
0.6433343291282654,
-0.7150732278823853,
0.4571465849876404,
0.008898177184164524,
-0.734016478061676,
-0.18397673964500427,
0.6609638929367065,
0.7524667382240295,
0.625925600528717,
0.3167053461074829,
-0.15602529048919678,
-0.37801700830459595,
-0.5255709886550903,
-0.47289958596229553,
-0.3316502273082733,
-0.14169469475746155,
-0.2239333838224411,
0.43332818150520325,
-0.31864285469055176,
0.5254526138305664,
0.010277030058205128,
0.03554559126496315,
-0.24314211308956146,
0.07948745042085648,
-0.015031223185360432,
0.18999500572681427,
-0.14533942937850952,
-0.2931419312953949,
-0.33476173877716064,
0.18841783702373505,
-1.1306071281433105,
-0.0015530353412032127,
0.13430669903755188,
0.2588474750518799,
0.039284270256757736,
0.6195654273033142,
-0.3653428256511688,
0.4551008641719818,
0.21480202674865723,
0.08359505236148834,
0.6047698259353638,
-0.42469456791877747,
0.17701011896133423,
-0.7765661478042603,
0.1088336706161499,
-0.2087477445602417,
-0.08510065078735352,
-0.6599218845367432,
0.27263641357421875,
-0.051265325397253036,
0.25907182693481445,
-0.5666550993919373,
0.4635859429836273,
-0.8669331073760986,
-0.012194103561341763,
-0.39530229568481445,
0.3173602819442749,
0.038732483983039856,
0.5013731718063354,
-0.21744175255298615,
0.6973639130592346,
0.35428306460380554,
-0.5915192365646362,
0.328008770942688,
0.07415923476219177,
-0.5166724324226379,
0.15244095027446747,
-0.555548906326294,
0.12077578902244568,
-0.16224822402000427,
-0.376930832862854,
-1.1590914726257324,
0.1656910479068756,
-0.29991406202316284,
-0.3568858206272125,
0.35736700892448425,
0.05670011416077614,
-0.42122501134872437,
-0.22757533192634583,
-0.5357644557952881,
0.14749577641487122,
0.9903550148010254,
-0.6511067152023315,
0.37201523780822754,
0.5843165516853333,
0.07836411893367767,
-0.9493768215179443,
-0.468212366104126,
-0.28399646282196045,
-0.5561057329177856,
-0.3174307346343994,
0.12585952877998352,
0.03325486555695534,
-0.5852319002151489,
-0.21693314611911774,
-0.25024938583374023,
-0.2544543147087097,
0.25275859236717224,
0.3168518841266632,
0.16068297624588013,
0.1174507886171341,
-0.0430995412170887,
-0.07141146063804626,
-0.12249965220689774,
0.08082947134971619,
0.28850793838500977,
0.27910616993904114,
-0.013714645057916641,
-0.3977926969528198,
-0.21326944231987,
0.008023937232792377,
0.6085004210472107,
-0.1374390423297882,
0.5411705374717712,
0.7086750864982605,
-0.5716431736946106,
-0.4348015785217285,
-0.5680363178253174,
-0.2622288763523102,
-0.5156984925270081,
0.5876045227050781,
0.08192169666290283,
-0.8198125958442688,
0.7973613142967224,
-0.4897991716861725,
0.24846626818180084,
0.2564392387866974,
0.7008945941925049,
-0.32173386216163635,
0.8400662541389465,
0.781800389289856,
0.19784891605377197,
0.2672428488731384,
-0.2457272857427597,
0.32061031460762024,
-0.7255498766899109,
-0.6348204612731934,
-0.5118631720542908,
-0.0126563161611557,
-0.5978655219078064,
-0.12036991119384766,
0.26789408922195435,
0.7230674028396606,
-0.35609170794487,
0.23788246512413025,
-0.1702277958393097,
0.6893430352210999,
0.5143318176269531,
-0.032393794506788254,
0.6966844797134399,
0.23436568677425385,
-0.5472985506057739,
-0.15347173810005188,
-0.4866006672382355,
-0.7853303551673889,
1.324533462524414,
0.4638984799385071,
0.8586801886558533,
0.11036276072263718,
0.4821396768093109,
0.17467844486236572,
0.3892420828342438,
-0.7081212401390076,
0.5122150182723999,
-0.19749881327152252,
-0.3851599395275116,
-0.46482813358306885,
-0.49203163385391235,
-1.204874873161316,
0.20451237261295319,
-0.2926134467124939,
-1.0144648551940918,
-0.04890255630016327,
-0.059993524104356766,
-0.2776913642883301,
0.5115445256233215,
-0.7386582493782043,
0.603166937828064,
0.006928315386176109,
-0.26104989647865295,
-0.05438340827822685,
-0.38627752661705017,
0.5281094312667847,
-0.3637358546257019,
0.03671790286898613,
-0.040335338562726974,
-0.09358807653188705,
1.0130665302276611,
-0.23093436658382416,
0.7184176445007324,
0.015670286491513252,
-0.08048815280199051,
0.37824031710624695,
0.11870337277650833,
0.27125734090805054,
-0.3031633794307709,
-0.03771883249282837,
0.24169708788394928,
0.1895035207271576,
-0.0896432027220726,
-0.65595942735672,
0.4900646507740021,
-0.8522500395774841,
-0.4683879613876343,
-0.25413745641708374,
-0.5430846810340881,
-0.5103172659873962,
0.3540191352367401,
0.5211556553840637,
0.08497844636440277,
-0.3542798161506653,
0.2781505882740021,
0.7644661664962769,
-0.3316510021686554,
0.736888587474823,
0.5551252961158752,
-0.34631192684173584,
-0.38680359721183777,
0.9166781902313232,
0.13741271197795868,
0.20819564163684845,
0.27410486340522766,
0.341856986284256,
-0.5364746451377869,
-0.7041414380073547,
-0.008735837414860725,
0.30605989694595337,
-1.008200764656067,
-0.3001807928085327,
-0.3983105719089508,
-0.20711389183998108,
-0.3683149516582489,
-0.017563166096806526,
-0.39866188168525696,
-0.14855919778347015,
-0.22286619246006012,
-0.13399498164653778,
0.005274351220577955,
1.0295097827911377,
-0.09866822510957718,
0.38718485832214355,
-0.6972245573997498,
0.042793720960617065,
0.4940963387489319,
0.16755028069019318,
0.4150315523147583,
-0.8899440169334412,
-0.23014400899410248,
-0.18948298692703247,
-0.5994395017623901,
-0.7555668354034424,
0.379917174577713,
0.009866375476121902,
0.8934313058853149,
0.8622673749923706,
0.18636390566825867,
0.6786808967590332,
-0.383664071559906,
0.5837495923042297,
0.18330328166484833,
-0.7394468188285828,
0.0216162521392107,
-0.5111629366874695,
0.016178788617253304,
0.6851454377174377,
0.4894215166568756,
-0.30619779229164124,
-0.31328603625297546,
-0.5427796840667725,
-0.6676684617996216,
0.21472832560539246,
-0.15953902900218964,
-0.016446048393845558,
0.07458315789699554,
0.4432743489742279,
0.1505502611398697,
0.2589685618877411,
-0.5407366156578064,
-0.30678799748420715,
0.2869873642921448,
0.029308198019862175,
-0.04307765141129494,
-0.41842254996299744,
0.04976530000567436,
-0.35034751892089844,
0.5276329517364502,
0.17067734897136688,
0.031958699226379395,
-0.25684598088264465,
-0.24590995907783508,
-0.22230279445648193,
0.23996426165103912,
0.16147881746292114,
1.044389009475708,
-0.2807265818119049,
0.13043946027755737,
0.5000059604644775,
-0.5055169463157654,
0.04467158764600754,
-0.3907594382762909,
0.0010106643894687295,
-0.2959734797477722,
0.8939275145530701,
0.20671457052230835,
0.048528656363487244,
-0.8974480628967285,
0.6841133832931519,
0.11077861487865448,
-0.1872854232788086,
-0.27366727590560913,
0.08399073779582977,
0.006829029880464077,
0.18814539909362793,
0.16519470512866974,
-0.143421471118927,
0.11291445791721344,
-0.6573266386985779,
0.5505200028419495,
0.5674211978912354,
-0.4959721267223358,
-0.14301371574401855,
0.43472960591316223,
-0.12915289402008057,
-0.1200573518872261,
0.6680735349655151,
-0.28477874398231506,
-0.35949912667274475,
0.4300868511199951,
0.6129125356674194,
0.543452262878418,
-0.4726589322090149,
0.12023074179887772,
0.169295072555542,
0.5152508020401001,
-0.30746978521347046,
0.12710502743721008,
-0.021417291834950447,
-0.6399273872375488,
-0.48491171002388,
-0.4382174015045166,
-0.4566948115825653,
0.3281141519546509,
-0.9774549007415771,
0.15324199199676514,
-0.48699110746383667,
-0.04816509038209915,
-0.2220960557460785,
0.2566626965999603,
-0.5454266667366028,
0.029299309477210045,
-0.2569207549095154,
0.6810389161109924,
-0.7973734140396118,
0.7380933165550232,
0.5841720700263977,
-0.21857693791389465,
-0.7332931756973267,
0.08372616022825241,
0.22077195346355438,
-1.075873851776123,
0.3119208514690399,
0.049317967146635056,
-0.027674248442053795,
-0.31636008620262146,
-0.19946269690990448,
-0.6349446177482605,
1.1120070219039917,
0.43594983220100403,
-0.574224591255188,
0.11566650122404099,
-0.048549920320510864,
0.5507000684738159,
0.06419576704502106,
0.5800299644470215,
0.6559353470802307,
0.23188172280788422,
0.06475961208343506,
-0.9363418817520142,
-0.24436195194721222,
-0.2703603506088257,
-0.19858968257904053,
-0.09657648205757141,
-0.45877113938331604,
0.7887995839118958,
-0.4615023732185364,
-0.28101250529289246,
0.2851034998893738,
0.5955755114555359,
0.23418009281158447,
0.419222891330719,
0.5299343466758728,
0.5552579164505005,
1.103560209274292,
0.03344648703932762,
0.5882917642593384,
-0.07277090102434158,
0.4911808371543884,
0.8106561303138733,
-0.2615950107574463,
0.8951499462127686,
0.3267691731452942,
-0.16431206464767456,
0.2601434886455536,
0.46626734733581543,
0.01878977194428444,
0.6047190427780151,
0.35409626364707947,
-0.1455555409193039,
-0.4394676089286804,
-0.11794040352106094,
-0.17115336656570435,
0.6797829866409302,
0.06281064450740814,
-0.06877996772527695,
-0.5041556358337402,
0.15614382922649384,
0.405241996049881,
0.31244951486587524,
-0.21545995771884918,
0.9148083925247192,
0.17736512422561646,
-0.7486573457717896,
0.627601146697998,
0.13986210525035858,
0.7567319869995117,
-0.4637347161769867,
-0.10204537212848663,
-0.44286489486694336,
0.4531983435153961,
-0.15548250079154968,
-0.534637987613678,
0.22861914336681366,
0.21096038818359375,
-0.07563658058643341,
-0.14605456590652466,
0.881389856338501,
-0.478148877620697,
-0.2669079303741455,
0.6105955839157104,
1.0286507606506348,
0.3321421146392822,
0.1405603587627411,
-0.61688232421875,
-0.14327429234981537,
0.020502224564552307,
-0.22429344058036804,
0.6389603614807129,
0.5566943287849426,
-0.030062053352594376,
1.0075944662094116,
0.5867013931274414,
0.027229398488998413,
-0.045510563999414444,
0.15442751348018646,
0.7956911325454712,
-0.4604443311691284,
0.07955595850944519,
-0.9051182866096497,
0.31945809721946716,
0.14025676250457764,
-0.38731062412261963,
1.2109571695327759,
0.3253902494907379,
0.8064936399459839,
0.27717551589012146,
0.609697699546814,
0.6568308472633362,
0.5562456846237183,
-0.465599924325943,
0.7899317145347595,
-0.6388581395149231,
0.4941765367984772,
-0.3776448667049408,
-1.030079960823059,
-0.22528193891048431,
0.501618504524231,
-0.008903424255549908,
0.5181595087051392,
0.9058807492256165,
0.6117585301399231,
0.10004077851772308,
-0.055164411664009094,
0.8338218331336975,
-0.010344095528125763,
0.06746350973844528,
0.3505520820617676,
1.2086381912231445,
-0.18279896676540375,
0.6753319501876831,
-0.4355098307132721,
-0.4951338768005371,
0.2692336440086365,
-0.9167047739028931,
-1.3160691261291504,
-0.5806381106376648,
-0.2530197501182556,
-0.5202659368515015,
0.06129273772239685,
0.5944355726242065,
0.38603028655052185,
-0.6837639808654785,
-0.36932629346847534,
0.33479782938957214,
0.3112475275993347,
-0.3023328185081482,
-0.12852643430233002,
0.38818973302841187,
-0.5274114012718201,
-0.5420894026756287,
0.5209475755691528,
0.19826407730579376,
0.04067257046699524,
-0.41291502118110657,
-0.10314540565013885,
0.27289852499961853,
-0.13897168636322021,
0.41746458411216736,
0.29377487301826477,
-0.5527714490890503,
0.047295231372117996,
0.21426977217197418,
0.11993411183357239,
-0.19392240047454834,
0.7495306730270386,
-0.47012558579444885,
0.2814428508281708,
0.5246790051460266,
0.6475834250450134,
-0.02425282821059227,
0.03325214609503746,
0.2593928277492523,
-0.5303682088851929,
-0.22391414642333984,
0.002520441310480237,
0.510794997215271,
0.3012673556804657,
-0.07321012020111084,
0.2801992893218994,
0.3175670802593231,
-0.9042862057685852,
-0.9919370412826538,
-0.17859527468681335,
-0.667879045009613,
-0.3887878656387329,
1.4064443111419678,
-0.4370429515838623,
-0.3210639953613281,
-0.6513185501098633,
0.40515434741973877,
0.34000059962272644,
-0.14294038712978363,
0.7474140524864197,
0.655659019947052,
0.08374742418527603,
-0.012651368975639343,
-0.5280038118362427,
0.4007919132709503,
0.37247326970100403,
-0.6211503148078918,
0.2943534553050995,
0.13437116146087646,
0.4585648775100708,
0.11598360538482666,
0.5433593392372131,
-0.2943798303604126,
0.06543491780757904,
-0.08593727648258209,
0.03768502175807953,
-0.1441701352596283,
-0.7115120887756348,
-0.4471679627895355,
0.09657322615385056,
0.3474361002445221,
-0.06774596869945526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16832v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16832v1
|
Mysterious Projections: Multimodal LLMs Gain Domain-Specific Visual Capabilities Without Richer Cross-Modal Projections
| 2024-02-26T18:56:48 | 2024-02-26T18:56:48 |
Gaurav Verma, Minje Choi, Kartik Sharma, Jamelle Watson-Daniels, Sejoon Oh, Srijan Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) like LLaVA and GPT-4(V) enable
general-purpose conversations about images with the language modality. As
off-the-shelf MLLMs may have limited capabilities on images from domains like
dermatology and agriculture, they must be fine-tuned to unlock domain-specific
applications. The prevalent architecture of current open-source MLLMs comprises
two major modules: an image-language (cross-modal) projection network and a
large language model. It is desirable to understand the roles of these two
modules in modeling domain-specific visual attributes to inform the design of
future models and streamline the interpretability efforts on the current
models. To this end, via experiments on 4 datasets and under 2 fine-tuning
settings, we find that as the MLLM is fine-tuned, it indeed gains
domain-specific visual capabilities, but the updates do not lead to the
projection extracting relevant domain-specific visual attributes. Our results
indicate that the domain-specific visual attributes are modeled by the LLM,
even when only the projection is fine-tuned. Through this study, we offer a
potential reinterpretation of the role of cross-modal projections in MLLM
architectures. Projection webpage:
https://claws-lab.github.io/projection-in-MLLMs/
|
[
-0.43301960825920105,
-0.5821276307106018,
0.6498221755027771,
0.03312669321894646,
-0.14589881896972656,
0.1343020796775818,
-0.18270033597946167,
-0.7815693616867065,
0.048922330141067505,
0.6250473260879517,
-0.5055217742919922,
-0.4721544086933136,
-0.6249862909317017,
-0.022389309480786324,
-0.2646881341934204,
0.9467138051986694,
-0.032225046306848526,
0.11875191330909729,
-0.4035798907279968,
-0.22431857883930206,
-0.32057201862335205,
-0.41895225644111633,
-0.11253183335065842,
-0.12525448203086853,
0.8761462569236755,
0.07222060114145279,
0.9677578210830688,
0.5935723185539246,
0.6551356911659241,
0.2710702419281006,
0.22330142557621002,
0.5075675845146179,
-0.5047203898429871,
0.1483609676361084,
-0.19519470632076263,
-0.38552793860435486,
-0.5485171675682068,
0.08225514739751816,
0.7058471441268921,
0.7630982398986816,
0.179373636841774,
0.14833799004554749,
0.22285200655460358,
0.5671874284744263,
-0.5855683088302612,
0.3271264135837555,
-0.7661231756210327,
-0.010398602113127708,
-0.21900592744350433,
-0.500397801399231,
-0.44061538577079773,
0.33967551589012146,
0.18133953213691711,
-0.5001435875892639,
0.23071984946727753,
0.24021713435649872,
0.9518749713897705,
0.15208452939987183,
-0.7533085346221924,
-0.0952812135219574,
-0.7766513228416443,
1.0585492849349976,
-0.42353570461273193,
0.4610802233219147,
0.16668447852134705,
0.4338195323944092,
-0.08088147640228271,
-0.7557859420776367,
-0.275092214345932,
-0.32687175273895264,
-0.10118058323860168,
-0.09228957444429398,
-0.3130463659763336,
0.12463034689426422,
0.1478690207004547,
0.1907753050327301,
-0.5922914743423462,
0.13495901226997375,
-0.3595845103263855,
-0.302423357963562,
0.4349534213542938,
0.31772151589393616,
0.32243090867996216,
-0.10546106845140457,
-0.7365249395370483,
0.2247191071510315,
-0.985399067401886,
-0.13950592279434204,
0.17056867480278015,
0.2722378075122833,
-0.15866386890411377,
0.7247323393821716,
0.06958863139152527,
0.9476831555366516,
-0.18292050063610077,
-0.26023200154304504,
0.1382523775100708,
-0.3880048990249634,
-0.4074527323246002,
-0.5657558441162109,
0.49547144770622253,
0.45930635929107666,
0.292741060256958,
-0.1361793875694275,
-0.38007983565330505,
0.10949411988258362,
0.34176933765411377,
-0.4255341589450836,
-0.18939156830310822,
-0.09432482719421387,
-0.5891163945198059,
-0.2613624036312103,
-0.16407209634780884,
-0.49129748344421387,
-0.4275325536727905,
-0.39914682507514954,
0.46493786573410034,
-0.25738924741744995,
-0.22977490723133087,
-0.16862276196479797,
-0.04209263250231743,
0.2389305680990219,
0.5619850754737854,
-0.8640026450157166,
-0.06741905957460403,
0.5187158584594727,
0.6258639693260193,
-0.5477829575538635,
-0.41091927886009216,
-0.09844053536653519,
0.19982275366783142,
-0.3760891556739807,
0.7211880087852478,
-0.8922900557518005,
-0.17126840353012085,
0.21847254037857056,
0.16280244290828705,
-0.11616066098213196,
-0.48899635672569275,
0.3205890655517578,
-0.7057228088378906,
0.07868780940771103,
-0.2833158075809479,
-0.23773913085460663,
-0.34539249539375305,
0.3905584514141083,
-0.6842731237411499,
0.49154266715049744,
0.13534364104270935,
-0.5011268258094788,
0.576347291469574,
-0.4364638924598694,
-0.010743343271315098,
0.061535581946372986,
-0.49293288588523865,
-0.20978637039661407,
0.36697953939437866,
0.16215939819812775,
0.6853128671646118,
-0.4228733777999878,
0.15348467230796814,
-0.3177807927131653,
-0.01766038127243519,
0.48326265811920166,
-0.6042272448539734,
0.41277259588241577,
0.24715660512447357,
-0.1587071567773819,
0.4148878753185272,
-0.6439040303230286,
-0.008489023894071579,
0.08850125223398209,
-0.30041712522506714,
-0.3102680742740631,
-0.026502516120672226,
0.1264934092760086,
0.25488731265068054,
0.32357022166252136,
-0.2688163220882416,
0.29380443692207336,
0.026205183938145638,
0.24744658172130585,
0.8915755748748779,
-0.25418952107429504,
0.5838043689727783,
-0.3439776301383972,
0.6350196003913879,
0.17597217857837677,
0.3737388551235199,
-0.38475361466407776,
-0.8156679272651672,
-0.7619200944900513,
-0.5092422962188721,
-0.0021967028733342886,
0.2150241732597351,
-1.0605850219726562,
-0.30787450075149536,
-0.2293318510055542,
-0.36066702008247375,
-0.3358217477798462,
0.23749399185180664,
0.3741314113140106,
0.22431296110153198,
0.34731364250183105,
-0.19626876711845398,
-0.40485304594039917,
-1.307661771774292,
-0.22331023216247559,
0.11134463548660278,
0.18546363711357117,
0.5223410725593567,
0.4099181592464447,
-0.32448938488960266,
0.6625736355781555,
-0.3370235860347748,
-0.49688300490379333,
-0.31137749552726746,
-0.12617342174053192,
0.0878969207406044,
0.22045567631721497,
0.8250163197517395,
-1.063642978668213,
-0.5142808556556702,
0.05266059562563896,
-0.8298664093017578,
-0.05359393358230591,
-0.16847644746303558,
0.11535976082086563,
0.2121637612581253,
0.16705961525440216,
-0.7261092662811279,
0.386820912361145,
1.0600146055221558,
-0.35789263248443604,
0.6907389163970947,
-0.23637400567531586,
0.07856010645627975,
-0.6802751421928406,
-0.1356949806213379,
0.06748931109905243,
-0.37406492233276367,
-0.7001063823699951,
0.3995235860347748,
0.09860461205244064,
0.02948571741580963,
-0.5631389021873474,
0.392236590385437,
-0.860805094242096,
-0.3393175005912781,
-0.26742348074913025,
0.05189419910311699,
0.22717195749282837,
0.5909183025360107,
-0.15680259466171265,
0.7097610831260681,
0.898790717124939,
-0.3723877966403961,
0.34550485014915466,
0.005275620147585869,
-0.4709370732307434,
0.5280318260192871,
-0.3056449890136719,
-0.05793456360697746,
-0.01149690616875887,
0.11641661822795868,
-0.8401870727539062,
-0.25040942430496216,
0.2743823826313019,
-0.14667001366615295,
0.514860987663269,
0.0033322584349662066,
-0.21085822582244873,
-0.09640204906463623,
-0.34867870807647705,
0.6588062047958374,
0.27748459577560425,
-0.5200112462043762,
0.833206295967102,
0.4189285635948181,
0.15691745281219482,
-0.5887387990951538,
-0.7970346808433533,
0.26041239500045776,
-0.12699978053569794,
-0.6934196949005127,
0.36752039194107056,
0.04406579211354256,
-0.2658579647541046,
0.1229868158698082,
0.12424051016569138,
0.0753093883395195,
-0.12850086390972137,
0.5132491588592529,
0.49698320031166077,
-0.40110647678375244,
0.038841862231492996,
-0.1662169247865677,
0.08478684723377228,
-0.09580133855342865,
-0.21918955445289612,
0.2759908437728882,
-0.12837658822536469,
-0.7120396494865417,
-0.1468137502670288,
0.404451459646225,
0.7824074625968933,
-0.25494930148124695,
0.5851213335990906,
0.5536814332008362,
-0.11392363160848618,
-0.19227519631385803,
-0.49371078610420227,
0.05839460343122482,
-0.4964921772480011,
0.5560719966888428,
-0.591356635093689,
-0.9145449995994568,
0.3573032319545746,
-0.14487405121326447,
-0.0634239912033081,
0.4685748517513275,
0.80643230676651,
-0.0991184413433075,
1.196413278579712,
0.8826665282249451,
0.3501069247722626,
0.49416282773017883,
-0.28905898332595825,
0.025530142709612846,
-1.1130573749542236,
-0.4807698726654053,
0.000942061364185065,
-0.46316879987716675,
-0.552211582660675,
-0.850945770740509,
0.41206759214401245,
-0.27499672770500183,
0.17278189957141876,
-0.018004082143306732,
-0.35522857308387756,
0.31701183319091797,
0.5319213271141052,
0.04405013471841812,
0.324260413646698,
0.23139673471450806,
-0.18551048636436462,
-0.3079492151737213,
-0.6205030083656311,
-0.4794180989265442,
1.0803223848342896,
0.4121073782444,
0.9009350538253784,
-0.001584748737514019,
0.18173587322235107,
0.4426954984664917,
0.2583532929420471,
-0.7227588295936584,
0.6835287809371948,
-0.3059302270412445,
-0.585986852645874,
-0.06512504816055298,
-0.2097092717885971,
-0.9173938035964966,
0.5072185397148132,
-0.3692496418952942,
-0.5907149314880371,
0.5275039672851562,
0.261859267950058,
0.017234614118933678,
0.5046715140342712,
-0.5710809230804443,
0.7398782968521118,
-0.3348706066608429,
-0.44076359272003174,
-0.37133657932281494,
-0.503238320350647,
0.36276859045028687,
-0.27849820256233215,
0.10340651869773865,
-0.2749297022819519,
-0.19277319312095642,
0.2406461089849472,
0.0006615153979510069,
1.1215791702270508,
-0.14330221712589264,
-0.3644590675830841,
0.15323707461357117,
0.2685200572013855,
0.395682156085968,
-0.2520774304866791,
0.20347769558429718,
0.4471181035041809,
-0.16025196015834808,
-0.36163073778152466,
-0.5819778442382812,
0.9576495289802551,
-0.8162091374397278,
-0.8702817559242249,
-0.29456353187561035,
-0.7937831878662109,
-0.32873451709747314,
0.005104501266032457,
0.003846267005428672,
0.5381478071212769,
-0.2090863287448883,
0.28408074378967285,
0.2712201774120331,
-0.41557246446609497,
0.22162476181983948,
0.3282172679901123,
-0.5833926200866699,
-0.1380944401025772,
1.032477855682373,
0.01609736494719982,
0.6569317579269409,
0.47790223360061646,
-0.08617253601551056,
-0.009299004450440407,
-0.6806129217147827,
-0.464190274477005,
0.22299018502235413,
-0.8589107394218445,
-0.2604653239250183,
-0.40542086958885193,
-0.05975271761417389,
-0.3012208342552185,
-0.01667593978345394,
-0.19846460223197937,
-0.5429302453994751,
-0.2839371860027313,
0.09906510263681412,
-0.05249258130788803,
0.8407894968986511,
-0.1261005848646164,
0.01179576013237238,
-0.642414391040802,
0.4379722774028778,
0.44777071475982666,
0.11778479069471359,
-0.13162176311016083,
-0.5018295645713806,
-0.43103891611099243,
0.2560081481933594,
-0.3584737181663513,
-0.6745754480361938,
0.5995346307754517,
0.487298846244812,
0.5749837160110474,
0.4779278337955475,
-0.32291364669799805,
0.6129072904586792,
-0.6247787475585938,
0.9497728943824768,
0.1963803470134735,
-0.5415126085281372,
0.263401061296463,
-0.2655241787433624,
0.2872999906539917,
-0.19084958732128143,
0.30285194516181946,
-0.1948232799768448,
-0.5597250461578369,
-0.12759527564048767,
-0.6030057072639465,
0.4688301384449005,
0.06594472378492355,
0.3482292592525482,
0.19302907586097717,
0.06201149523258209,
0.35481974482536316,
0.1955113708972931,
-0.7441047430038452,
-0.2664160132408142,
-0.2901211082935333,
0.07789690047502518,
-0.13805852830410004,
-0.6342145800590515,
-0.4226887822151184,
-0.09235963970422745,
0.30505186319351196,
-0.2529922127723694,
0.27968084812164307,
0.04764464870095253,
-0.2291756123304367,
-0.1734924018383026,
0.2283712476491928,
0.8706989288330078,
0.8249540328979492,
0.00041049893479794264,
0.49000370502471924,
-0.08442090451717377,
-0.4027818739414215,
-0.19601790606975555,
-0.15853050351142883,
-0.1319606751203537,
-0.009099607355892658,
0.5806992650032043,
1.1490235328674316,
0.17089323699474335,
-0.4754658043384552,
0.5357303619384766,
0.19067850708961487,
-0.1131085753440857,
-0.10534389317035675,
-0.007581582758575678,
-0.09833315759897232,
0.671028733253479,
0.6142609119415283,
0.507154107093811,
0.09717676043510437,
-0.5998073220252991,
-0.012102282606065273,
0.7822085022926331,
-0.43014511466026306,
-0.7162207961082458,
0.6901706457138062,
0.10710728168487549,
-0.09968646615743637,
0.29937270283699036,
0.28014490008354187,
-0.3354002833366394,
0.39306655526161194,
0.6343612670898438,
0.7221673727035522,
-0.03894077241420746,
0.3271063566207886,
-0.2090316265821457,
0.34272220730781555,
0.334137886762619,
0.06620532274246216,
0.06479396671056747,
-0.9255238771438599,
-0.48562952876091003,
-0.6278844475746155,
-0.2577924132347107,
0.0032206049654632807,
-0.326150119304657,
0.12882862985134125,
-0.21544644236564636,
-0.3836939334869385,
0.06753586232662201,
-0.5256797671318054,
-0.9150538444519043,
0.1502600610256195,
0.4643125534057617,
0.7365688681602478,
-0.6789512038230896,
1.1042547225952148,
0.7337656617164612,
-0.2406291514635086,
-0.556492805480957,
-0.20127394795417786,
0.06559709459543228,
-1.249138355255127,
1.0858912467956543,
0.023708419874310493,
-0.2592203617095947,
-0.15989379584789276,
-0.6311729550361633,
-0.8187456727027893,
1.0956698656082153,
0.6191790699958801,
-0.47873905301094055,
-0.3714122474193573,
0.5204148292541504,
0.5017110705375671,
-0.6529456973075867,
-0.15077322721481323,
0.04121014475822449,
0.5322930216789246,
0.04969959706068039,
-1.071213722229004,
0.12456823885440826,
-0.10024890303611755,
0.11136399209499359,
0.051213111728429794,
-0.421446293592453,
0.9893943667411804,
-0.5887883901596069,
-0.23782488703727722,
0.12879468500614166,
0.5092567205429077,
-0.018627889454364777,
0.13329316675662994,
0.4416270852088928,
0.2074633538722992,
0.2524448037147522,
-0.10160436481237411,
1.2084170579910278,
-0.3774150013923645,
0.29227063059806824,
0.8251153826713562,
-0.1777830868959427,
0.671743631362915,
0.8453752398490906,
-0.003596738912165165,
0.40358588099479675,
0.27037182450294495,
-0.22873668372631073,
0.7357524633407593,
-0.13894569873809814,
-0.23053546249866486,
-0.5137759447097778,
-0.41999107599258423,
-0.4783701002597809,
0.6468805074691772,
0.5029293894767761,
-0.7052373886108398,
-0.14901402592658997,
0.22333748638629913,
-0.5117023587226868,
-0.19319984316825867,
-0.2915869653224945,
0.4019585847854614,
0.3746742308139801,
-0.3208402991294861,
0.6243943572044373,
-0.17226870357990265,
0.5311152935028076,
-0.6576067209243774,
-0.22466860711574554,
-0.049626272171735764,
0.12461759150028229,
-0.2919023633003235,
-0.7915869951248169,
0.2505187392234802,
-0.29968956112861633,
-0.11201121658086777,
-0.4650864899158478,
1.0170390605926514,
-0.46188655495643616,
-0.4040127992630005,
0.41634657979011536,
0.8294997215270996,
0.0706794485449791,
-0.01901862770318985,
-0.6512480974197388,
0.3064746856689453,
-0.014740468934178352,
-0.34702885150909424,
0.49201500415802,
0.650020182132721,
-0.1565718948841095,
0.7963343858718872,
0.6225143671035767,
0.26974740624427795,
0.14705924689769745,
0.09864964336156845,
1.036132574081421,
-0.5245459675788879,
0.114668108522892,
-0.7778513431549072,
0.495540976524353,
0.17618483304977417,
-0.03732285276055336,
0.8593857288360596,
0.44025367498397827,
0.7122797966003418,
-0.44285258650779724,
0.543249785900116,
0.12068913877010345,
0.05605568736791611,
-0.5848196148872375,
0.5105426907539368,
-0.971733033657074,
0.32885345816612244,
-0.10000207275152206,
-0.9916128516197205,
-0.5868754386901855,
0.26888948678970337,
-0.2983367443084717,
-0.03547195717692375,
0.6890653371810913,
0.9091485738754272,
-0.08815384656190872,
-0.5378770232200623,
0.9255656003952026,
0.32614243030548096,
0.357342392206192,
0.4163563847541809,
1.143162727355957,
0.03362466022372246,
0.5791425108909607,
-0.00518896384164691,
-0.09507907181978226,
-0.23565298318862915,
-0.8137819170951843,
-0.8701077699661255,
-0.7245872020721436,
-0.09191367030143738,
-0.048322226852178574,
0.05345853418111801,
0.613836944103241,
0.6847588419914246,
-0.618751049041748,
-0.07056305557489395,
0.3554838299751282,
-0.02328239008784294,
-0.017120664939284325,
-0.20992374420166016,
0.25417038798332214,
-0.15476258099079132,
-0.6820669174194336,
0.36656585335731506,
0.7471346259117126,
0.0568670816719532,
-0.7554124593734741,
-0.008694141171872616,
-0.04162121191620827,
0.010974305681884289,
0.8418923020362854,
0.0681077316403389,
-1.118899941444397,
-0.4827677607536316,
0.09771375358104706,
-0.3317470848560333,
0.23054006695747375,
0.8838303089141846,
-0.8019868731498718,
0.4986414313316345,
0.22489574551582336,
0.3654458820819855,
0.2776525616645813,
-0.32110336422920227,
0.7337054014205933,
-0.6299274563789368,
0.16772246360778809,
-0.027153458446264267,
0.5788738131523132,
0.4841741919517517,
-0.1349164843559265,
0.3325324058532715,
0.2488093376159668,
-0.47690078616142273,
-0.7528314590454102,
0.5530378222465515,
-1.0707200765609741,
-0.29107049107551575,
1.2140955924987793,
-0.19667968153953552,
-0.11600092798471451,
-0.09360852092504501,
-0.45961958169937134,
-0.07993356138467789,
-0.08969827741384506,
0.6709386706352234,
0.40809497237205505,
-0.2372446060180664,
-0.31329450011253357,
-0.6057087182998657,
0.45729026198387146,
0.16803914308547974,
-0.4992010295391083,
-0.1254468560218811,
0.6503191590309143,
0.09818824380636215,
0.25752779841423035,
0.43306559324264526,
-0.08122751116752625,
-0.026472432538866997,
-0.15412984788417816,
-0.13076163828372955,
-0.22224794328212738,
-0.4659828543663025,
-0.0926215872168541,
0.38623282313346863,
0.23241591453552246,
-0.1699501872062683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16830v1
|
SKILL: Similarity-aware Knowledge distILLation for Speech Self-Supervised Learning
| 2024-02-26T18:56:42 | 2024-02-26T18:56:42 |
Luca Zampierin, Ghouthi Boukli Hacene, Bac Nguyen, Mirco Ravanelli
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Self-supervised learning (SSL) has achieved remarkable success across various
speech-processing tasks. To enhance its efficiency, previous works often
leverage the use of compression techniques. A notable recent attempt is
DPHuBERT, which applies joint knowledge distillation (KD) and structured
pruning to learn a significantly smaller SSL model. In this paper, we
contribute to this research domain by introducing SKILL, a novel method that
conducts distillation across groups of layers instead of distilling individual
arbitrarily selected layers within the teacher network. The identification of
the layers to distill is achieved through a hierarchical clustering procedure
applied to layer similarity measures. Extensive experiments demonstrate that
our distilled version of WavLM Base+ not only outperforms DPHuBERT but also
achieves state-of-the-art results in the 30M parameters model class across
several SUPERB tasks.
|
[
-0.2218886762857437,
-0.6516812443733215,
0.3663652241230011,
0.2203192114830017,
-0.3266533613204956,
0.28489169478416443,
-0.1697874665260315,
-0.061964280903339386,
0.041285544633865356,
0.20526322722434998,
-0.502629280090332,
-0.5559859871864319,
-0.7488839626312256,
-0.14338718354701996,
-0.5025273561477661,
0.8201951384544373,
0.42430979013442993,
0.06707587838172913,
-0.41158220171928406,
0.12424962222576141,
-0.41794341802597046,
-0.7343319058418274,
-0.6504402160644531,
-0.5617335438728333,
0.5807943940162659,
0.43754538893699646,
0.1058969795703888,
0.7023365497589111,
0.4228658676147461,
0.4112056791782379,
-0.20657329261302948,
0.07880925387144089,
-0.5080229640007019,
0.3251216411590576,
-0.15941128134727478,
-0.41870003938674927,
-0.32143405079841614,
0.23796455562114716,
0.3920210897922516,
0.898363471031189,
-0.5440899729728699,
0.29688549041748047,
0.5515165328979492,
0.9110903739929199,
-0.5416163802146912,
0.3422996997833252,
-1.0107769966125488,
0.033689528703689575,
-0.2212878167629242,
-0.05946516990661621,
-0.2324056476354599,
-0.15031060576438904,
0.18305589258670807,
-0.43954354524612427,
0.48027855157852173,
-0.24538686871528625,
0.2380106896162033,
0.8112236261367798,
-0.18841703236103058,
-0.17115217447280884,
-0.6406779885292053,
0.8535560965538025,
-0.6213352084159851,
0.3011529743671417,
0.5598174929618835,
0.5974345803260803,
-0.016801336780190468,
-1.0580906867980957,
-0.4646996557712555,
-0.02642882615327835,
0.16669873893260956,
0.18413153290748596,
0.05929894372820854,
-0.019614599645137787,
0.25353506207466125,
0.4562221169471741,
-0.31691664457321167,
0.0032213167287409306,
-0.7093106508255005,
-0.13765943050384521,
0.6886683702468872,
-0.23393435776233673,
-0.1511157751083374,
0.058959268033504486,
-0.45211929082870483,
-0.28490424156188965,
-0.265728235244751,
0.05371716618537903,
0.3146965801715851,
0.39396268129348755,
0.25942882895469666,
0.19176767766475677,
-0.33812642097473145,
0.7220714092254639,
0.32686203718185425,
-0.5662673115730286,
0.30039817094802856,
0.13678425550460815,
-0.312109112739563,
0.5747620463371277,
0.5147599577903748,
-0.0667187049984932,
0.37092718482017517,
0.03514353558421135,
0.05760253965854645,
-0.10214097797870636,
0.129611536860466,
-0.6332962512969971,
-0.9563894867897034,
0.008895400911569595,
-0.39028704166412354,
-0.5196122527122498,
0.017506558448076248,
-0.254728227853775,
-0.323985755443573,
-0.4557682275772095,
0.5450559258460999,
-0.40680885314941406,
-0.4329991638660431,
-0.032151781022548676,
-0.34606823325157166,
-0.15880131721496582,
0.0016119882930070162,
-0.9701881408691406,
0.45823806524276733,
0.6656813025474548,
0.810426652431488,
-0.3936777710914612,
-0.5397843718528748,
-0.42996010184288025,
0.06599482893943787,
-0.1963505744934082,
0.34624096751213074,
-0.2702257037162781,
-0.4532549977302551,
-0.6216737627983093,
-0.4406820237636566,
0.06073460355401039,
-0.8226062655448914,
0.5235899090766907,
-0.3323942720890045,
0.02502080425620079,
-0.16023702919483185,
-0.7469412684440613,
-0.2818453907966614,
-0.12515735626220703,
-0.4911773204803467,
1.1971008777618408,
0.15245391428470612,
-0.7512403130531311,
0.5640091896057129,
-0.3053949177265167,
-0.5066502690315247,
0.18507120013237,
-0.1945059448480606,
-0.5499145984649658,
0.23615604639053345,
0.19790561497211456,
0.7267589569091797,
0.13445022702217102,
0.24473722279071808,
-0.3507126271724701,
-0.20682476460933685,
-0.08870794624090195,
-0.6592138409614563,
0.7852684259414673,
0.28944337368011475,
-0.2137000411748886,
-0.1370537281036377,
-1.0235700607299805,
0.09609171748161316,
0.024560073390603065,
-0.1342117339372635,
-0.7204112410545349,
-0.18473316729068756,
-0.2927154302597046,
0.3776567876338959,
0.3162792921066284,
-0.4691064655780792,
0.17866250872612,
-0.12286879867315292,
0.6943350434303284,
0.63351970911026,
0.024805596098303795,
0.24436485767364502,
-0.2428964078426361,
0.18224874138832092,
0.3106865882873535,
0.17738062143325806,
0.10026568919420242,
-0.42747652530670166,
-0.3903849124908447,
-0.45163851976394653,
0.4566234350204468,
0.28525346517562866,
-0.6109400391578674,
0.5711830854415894,
-0.08122967183589935,
-0.8871589303016663,
-0.7977791428565979,
0.44459351897239685,
0.40693482756614685,
0.9079123139381409,
0.64070063829422,
-0.2568713426589966,
-0.2604372799396515,
-0.8465960025787354,
0.014685755595564842,
-0.17101484537124634,
-0.023165816441178322,
0.10639401525259018,
0.12925846874713898,
0.3581278920173645,
1.052272081375122,
-0.6793496608734131,
-0.745613157749176,
0.06747189909219742,
0.27131062746047974,
0.26197004318237305,
0.6778960227966309,
0.5424809455871582,
-0.9607150554656982,
-0.878031849861145,
-0.21149764955043793,
-0.5241103768348694,
-0.17030398547649384,
0.25710204243659973,
0.20700597763061523,
-0.2557680308818817,
0.671941876411438,
-0.16565047204494476,
0.14276519417762756,
0.6153646111488342,
0.08053100109100342,
0.3382495939731598,
-0.36564943194389343,
0.13012193143367767,
-1.0392966270446777,
-0.1408781111240387,
-0.07504355162382126,
-0.32831403613090515,
-0.6079082489013672,
-0.37418332695961,
0.08538517355918884,
-0.05390433967113495,
-0.556490957736969,
-0.10878174751996994,
-0.4614088535308838,
-0.09969726204872131,
-0.3889261484146118,
-0.027143502607941628,
0.011959822848439217,
0.5753582119941711,
0.10045487433671951,
0.6931556463241577,
0.8120360970497131,
-0.5304927825927734,
0.6451701521873474,
0.019947918131947517,
-0.47576767206192017,
0.5725568532943726,
-0.7193257212638855,
0.2949253022670746,
0.029526202008128166,
-0.057460717856884,
-1.0208238363265991,
0.024174880236387253,
-0.16146835684776306,
-0.3589491546154022,
0.41054779291152954,
-0.5232676863670349,
-0.07619146257638931,
-0.43775564432144165,
0.09006631374359131,
0.4283500015735626,
0.8637442588806152,
-0.5327162742614746,
0.3973546624183655,
0.39185357093811035,
-0.23341022431850433,
-0.6240918636322021,
-0.879429280757904,
-0.1290951818227768,
-0.6212419867515564,
-0.42128056287765503,
0.5141850709915161,
-0.05170423910021782,
-0.027243580669164658,
0.16061046719551086,
-0.44117531180381775,
-0.49879980087280273,
0.3571929931640625,
0.36191055178642273,
-0.20724926888942719,
0.024156948551535606,
0.2509117126464844,
0.22117644548416138,
-0.06225615367293358,
-0.09856698662042618,
-0.5905895233154297,
0.45039117336273193,
0.12414460629224777,
-0.6992209553718567,
-0.5737359523773193,
0.228147491812706,
0.39057931303977966,
-0.22247138619422913,
0.5807090997695923,
0.5991581678390503,
0.00040754128713160753,
-0.6067023873329163,
-0.6394232511520386,
-0.46803557872772217,
-0.5461296439170837,
0.2786989212036133,
-0.6033464670181274,
-1.0064233541488647,
0.38348281383514404,
-0.1168324425816536,
-0.20887358486652374,
0.30208465456962585,
0.27983585000038147,
-0.3978434205055237,
0.7480607628822327,
0.6044639348983765,
-0.3986121714115143,
0.4471399486064911,
-0.27358201146125793,
-0.027699731290340424,
-0.6041003465652466,
-0.2082456350326538,
-0.40466904640197754,
-0.49895527958869934,
-0.24794995784759521,
-0.462838739156723,
0.5372201204299927,
0.3181730806827545,
0.012360945343971252,
0.22938649356365204,
-0.8678299784660339,
0.5889952182769775,
0.9751317501068115,
0.15124747157096863,
0.3558979034423828,
0.14427751302719116,
-0.155498668551445,
-0.07698316872119904,
-0.8514509201049805,
0.06490354984998703,
0.8645450472831726,
0.20740218460559845,
0.6565815806388855,
-0.17581836879253387,
1.3313153982162476,
0.49830561876296997,
-0.1981518715620041,
-0.7144959568977356,
0.37952160835266113,
-0.38283222913742065,
-0.4159083664417267,
-0.6200208067893982,
-0.5057460069656372,
-0.7469521760940552,
0.3817247152328491,
0.06498517841100693,
-0.2357301115989685,
0.039780594408512115,
0.39885473251342773,
-0.3144351840019226,
0.20024697482585907,
-0.7861811518669128,
0.5150865912437439,
-0.03020671382546425,
-0.10364215821027756,
-0.4338577687740326,
-0.54058438539505,
0.16254810988903046,
-0.1747014820575714,
0.09886057674884796,
-0.28284451365470886,
0.3492017090320587,
0.6724576950073242,
-0.5178170204162598,
0.935644268989563,
-0.5920947790145874,
-0.11628737300634384,
0.5542964935302734,
0.08113188296556473,
0.17071764171123505,
-0.35831376910209656,
-0.10929428040981293,
0.26468726992607117,
0.10043809562921524,
-0.33965662121772766,
-0.7953758239746094,
0.8418586850166321,
-0.609993577003479,
-0.7987964749336243,
-0.1410779058933258,
-0.3011603057384491,
-0.18391923606395721,
0.18056945502758026,
0.08852019906044006,
0.4429745376110077,
0.10053061693906784,
0.4625049829483032,
0.6152851581573486,
0.29658418893814087,
0.45705363154411316,
0.5026317834854126,
0.08553507924079895,
-0.11884086579084396,
1.0664687156677246,
0.565209150314331,
0.3525732755661011,
0.17958775162696838,
0.45846569538116455,
-0.45905792713165283,
-0.776763916015625,
-0.01378508098423481,
-0.1933821439743042,
-0.6755071878433228,
-0.12414321303367615,
-0.4201379418373108,
-0.5553654432296753,
-0.5771765112876892,
0.18422602117061615,
-0.5700204372406006,
-0.54355388879776,
-0.2229013592004776,
-0.1378118246793747,
0.4094260036945343,
0.634571373462677,
-0.2734646797180176,
0.18988266587257385,
-0.6803743243217468,
0.26402390003204346,
0.9060625433921814,
0.3140580356121063,
0.13970305025577545,
-0.7153186798095703,
-0.21679002046585083,
0.03228018805384636,
-0.18025913834571838,
-0.7378701567649841,
0.3280692398548126,
0.7053258419036865,
0.7900839447975159,
0.19858227670192719,
0.36561280488967896,
0.736137330532074,
-0.5870586633682251,
0.8267847895622253,
0.13393054902553558,
-0.879863977432251,
0.7928332686424255,
-0.06013360619544983,
0.21209341287612915,
0.7693054676055908,
0.6016212105751038,
-0.30141201615333557,
-0.35315728187561035,
-0.7758736610412598,
-0.7184051871299744,
0.3017783761024475,
0.17096881568431854,
0.008625442162156105,
0.02229238860309124,
0.3750227093696594,
0.10874170064926147,
0.3128456175327301,
-0.416412889957428,
-0.4044419527053833,
-0.3991939425468445,
-0.4026934802532196,
-0.113540880382061,
-0.1724974811077118,
-0.07398299872875214,
-0.4768298268318176,
0.6887801289558411,
-0.04131322726607323,
-0.42056936025619507,
0.4564809501171112,
-0.13925062119960785,
0.2731063663959503,
0.14496393501758575,
0.04570688679814339,
0.5187590718269348,
-0.056794021278619766,
0.4920075833797455,
0.2044888585805893,
-0.5751742124557495,
0.28404420614242554,
-0.10474776476621628,
0.16810011863708496,
-0.25298526883125305,
0.4853883683681488,
0.59636390209198,
0.20272068679332733,
-0.0832081213593483,
0.5440551042556763,
0.09354890137910843,
-0.5760926604270935,
-0.14693790674209595,
0.4955669343471527,
0.14810626208782196,
0.47642311453819275,
0.5815194845199585,
-0.17038123309612274,
0.44552499055862427,
-0.3157684803009033,
0.5102288722991943,
0.14747737348079681,
-0.5727147459983826,
-0.07655543088912964,
0.47894325852394104,
0.26104816794395447,
-0.09284993261098862,
0.5443011522293091,
-0.10867831110954285,
-0.3919561505317688,
0.4858831465244293,
0.3180614411830902,
0.7292014956474304,
-0.6381208300590515,
0.1334824413061142,
0.22035162150859833,
-0.1700567603111267,
-0.1757008135318756,
0.17638589441776276,
-0.6238395571708679,
-0.6163416504859924,
-0.5384079813957214,
-0.7021536231040955,
-0.15175500512123108,
0.03542567417025566,
-0.8550258874893188,
-0.09728855639696121,
-0.41086021065711975,
-0.15646784007549286,
0.2996656894683838,
0.1359650194644928,
-0.41444021463394165,
0.16317972540855408,
0.10305391252040863,
0.6007311344146729,
-1.0062958002090454,
1.5415633916854858,
0.38692665100097656,
-0.19307439029216766,
-1.2418386936187744,
-0.182613804936409,
0.050794146955013275,
-0.6758036613464355,
0.9947856068611145,
-0.09162109345197678,
-0.2070554494857788,
0.486847847700119,
-0.34663447737693787,
-0.5814520120620728,
1.4150408506393433,
0.2969263792037964,
-0.8208593726158142,
0.2570687234401703,
0.06523575633764267,
0.4636726677417755,
-0.2601291239261627,
-0.13484323024749756,
0.6640267372131348,
0.08274781703948975,
0.4224643111228943,
-1.2456766366958618,
-0.3739013969898224,
-0.0640021339058876,
0.00498482258990407,
-0.20819558203220367,
-0.5898112058639526,
0.8725444674491882,
0.0653378814458847,
-0.14162170886993408,
-0.5145670771598816,
0.8154067397117615,
0.17947319149971008,
0.29605621099472046,
0.7824707627296448,
0.595693051815033,
1.0717475414276123,
0.10975085198879242,
0.3312608599662781,
-0.24088764190673828,
0.3486635088920593,
1.5944417715072632,
-0.2682403326034546,
0.8102474212646484,
0.48224377632141113,
-0.41094261407852173,
0.47389695048332214,
0.22542928159236908,
-0.1142456978559494,
0.8427730798721313,
0.2594321668148041,
-0.3050757944583893,
-0.36387205123901367,
-0.06009894236922264,
-0.5162357687950134,
0.6958440542221069,
0.07113723456859589,
-0.22685976326465607,
-0.12196741998195648,
0.1016203835606575,
-0.4280780851840973,
0.4502798020839691,
-0.39933764934539795,
1.1138676404953003,
0.3453803062438965,
-0.5447255373001099,
0.536003828048706,
-0.38267064094543457,
0.7323722243309021,
-0.49617013335227966,
-0.13449974358081818,
0.09827500581741333,
0.012820734642446041,
-0.250651091337204,
-0.9396998286247253,
0.3225347101688385,
-0.2733175456523895,
-0.3135606050491333,
-0.3059766888618469,
1.0255591869354248,
-0.812654435634613,
-0.31627750396728516,
0.33330631256103516,
0.5962971448898315,
0.24059832096099854,
-0.3790678083896637,
-0.6293414235115051,
-0.26053130626678467,
-0.08274973928928375,
0.056223314255476,
0.3663705587387085,
0.5580605268478394,
0.24817298352718353,
0.7760193943977356,
0.5899161696434021,
0.33643585443496704,
0.3012489080429077,
0.34807804226875305,
0.8887253403663635,
-0.23279544711112976,
-0.6338309645652771,
-0.9841399192810059,
0.3894462287425995,
-0.30888980627059937,
-0.016572153195738792,
0.8557103872299194,
0.4042871296405792,
1.0641716718673706,
-0.15536372363567352,
0.8164182305335999,
0.08151848614215851,
0.7496810555458069,
-0.418474942445755,
0.947661280632019,
-0.35580793023109436,
0.10690426081418991,
-0.26137369871139526,
-0.9038369655609131,
0.11938930302858353,
0.7601156830787659,
-0.20433363318443298,
0.029187435284256935,
0.3357180058956146,
0.5493691563606262,
-0.20757853984832764,
-0.053570881485939026,
0.7691597938537598,
0.05345000699162483,
0.22944208979606628,
0.410123348236084,
0.7928671836853027,
-0.14901301264762878,
0.3493412137031555,
-0.8437929749488831,
-0.3109731376171112,
0.05768737196922302,
-1.0573304891586304,
-0.9865292906761169,
-1.0982271432876587,
-0.5006257891654968,
0.1273607611656189,
-0.008723211474716663,
0.8578508496284485,
1.1645493507385254,
-0.6530786752700806,
-0.009895012713968754,
-0.05399994179606438,
0.013372039422392845,
-0.5821118950843811,
-0.19972757995128632,
0.4745790362358093,
-0.3556986451148987,
-0.5756266117095947,
0.6321067810058594,
0.03958350047469139,
0.11102670431137085,
-0.4249163568019867,
0.1499086171388626,
0.10029385983943939,
-0.2828889787197113,
0.38805726170539856,
-0.024324633181095123,
-0.46355822682380676,
-0.1944524645805359,
-0.5027196407318115,
0.10013552010059357,
-0.07655571401119232,
0.7989282011985779,
-0.8391274809837341,
0.3440698981285095,
0.4799039363861084,
0.39229491353034973,
0.673767626285553,
0.14512953162193298,
0.24903962016105652,
-1.3460571765899658,
0.3418882489204407,
0.36133354902267456,
0.1973603069782257,
0.30332446098327637,
-0.28872042894363403,
0.34988319873809814,
0.3312530517578125,
-0.6242620944976807,
-0.5811134576797485,
0.13271136581897736,
-0.9419441819190979,
-0.3346761167049408,
0.8247696757316589,
-0.48802947998046875,
-0.07879720628261566,
-0.07739614695310593,
-0.2297927588224411,
0.3924647867679596,
-0.32305073738098145,
1.0326563119888306,
0.6439186334609985,
0.002583612920716405,
-0.32382434606552124,
-0.288495272397995,
0.7180972695350647,
0.20002371072769165,
-0.4089488983154297,
0.05520826205611229,
0.2896615266799927,
0.5242453813552856,
0.08931183069944382,
0.6153807044029236,
0.018838591873645782,
-0.03165075555443764,
0.07963530719280243,
-0.06767365336418152,
-0.7265200018882751,
-0.6431304812431335,
-0.2031022608280182,
0.603310763835907,
0.20545272529125214,
-0.33473798632621765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16829v1
|
GISTEmbed: Guided In-sample Selection of Training Negatives for Text Embedding Fine-tuning
| 2024-02-26T18:55:15 | 2024-02-26T18:55:15 |
Aivin V. Solatorio
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Embedding models are integral to AI applications like semantic search,
personalized recommendations, and retrieval augmented generation for LLMs,
necessitating high-quality training data. However, the limited scalability of
manual data curation prompts the need for automated methods to ensure data
integrity. Traditional unsupervised triplet mining automates training data
generation, crucial for embedding model training, yet inadvertently injects
biases and noise, thereby degrading model performance. Addressing this, we
introduce GISTEmbed, a novel strategy that enhances in-batch negative selection
during contrastive training through a guide model. This approach departs from
reliance on random sampling and equal utility assumption of batch negatives,
significantly reducing noise from data quality issues and improving model
fine-tuning. Benchmarked against the Massive Text Embedding Benchmark (MTEB),
GISTEmbed showcases consistent performance improvements across various model
sizes and achieves state-of-the-art results in select categories. This
framework enables significant enhancements for smaller models by leveraging the
capabilities of powerful yet resource-intensive large models. GISTEmbed can
potentially revolutionize the creation of highly efficient, smaller models,
democratizing access to advanced AI technologies. Making these technologies
more accessible and cost-effective, especially for applications constrained by
resources, significantly expands the impact and accessibility of
state-of-the-art AI solutions across diverse sectors.
|
[
-0.4940020740032196,
-0.6838977336883545,
0.3126872777938843,
-0.050175782293081284,
-0.630346953868866,
-0.0693880096077919,
-0.008523114025592804,
-0.312309205532074,
0.27632027864456177,
0.5829401612281799,
-0.5030040740966797,
-0.6925168037414551,
-0.7451351284980774,
-0.2870938181877136,
-0.41147854924201965,
1.2747597694396973,
0.03414732962846756,
0.4747447073459625,
-0.27264031767845154,
-0.4100263714790344,
-0.6299629211425781,
-0.4252777695655823,
-0.7014457583427429,
-0.4257901608943939,
0.23474228382110596,
0.513258695602417,
0.703911304473877,
0.6640019416809082,
0.3748038113117218,
0.13549566268920898,
0.009140942245721817,
0.2175375372171402,
-0.31596553325653076,
0.5963759422302246,
-0.3098057210445404,
-0.3549971282482147,
-0.1510254293680191,
0.14921006560325623,
0.36249014735221863,
0.46792808175086975,
-0.08764934539794922,
0.266207218170166,
0.5224280953407288,
0.5187804102897644,
-0.7166447043418884,
0.019603321328759193,
-0.5687861442565918,
0.016575582325458527,
-0.12220292538404465,
-0.1914851814508438,
-0.22757375240325928,
-0.6019167900085449,
0.19753164052963257,
-0.36288589239120483,
0.6195753216743469,
-0.07240062952041626,
0.9327952265739441,
0.5813330411911011,
-0.29869794845581055,
-0.5042685270309448,
-0.3681659996509552,
0.7774907946586609,
-0.6383782625198364,
0.11841435730457306,
0.44095560908317566,
0.2233051359653473,
-0.013339023105800152,
-0.5321609377861023,
-0.17420066893100739,
-0.21133384108543396,
-0.003790666116401553,
-0.13803212344646454,
0.2533423602581024,
0.1552305668592453,
0.2258719801902771,
0.441837877035141,
-0.32414084672927856,
0.16403456032276154,
-0.29484617710113525,
-0.11145111173391342,
0.2815514802932739,
-0.132552370429039,
0.2833327651023865,
0.010190286673605442,
-0.11744026839733124,
-0.10031162947416306,
-0.6761032938957214,
-0.34218230843544006,
0.49041011929512024,
0.4577661454677582,
-0.019456710666418076,
0.497427761554718,
-0.14953623712062836,
0.6320966482162476,
0.022773053497076035,
0.33962520956993103,
0.23963208496570587,
-0.21976034343242645,
-0.26104626059532166,
0.11650746315717697,
0.5010358691215515,
0.3665405809879303,
0.16080237925052643,
0.03752101957798004,
-0.3853549361228943,
0.11413867026567459,
0.23826947808265686,
-1.1657968759536743,
-0.5836004614830017,
0.0022979590576142073,
-0.15546739101409912,
-0.6377861499786377,
-0.1270577609539032,
-0.843122124671936,
-0.7663192749023438,
-0.3340066075325012,
0.6500848531723022,
-0.667543351650238,
0.06538704037666321,
0.08784764260053635,
-0.4864668548107147,
0.022934764623641968,
0.3232627511024475,
-1.0912744998931885,
0.208102747797966,
0.5860427021980286,
1.0911147594451904,
0.1667778640985489,
-0.21198460459709167,
-0.8299307227134705,
0.13337698578834534,
-0.48295822739601135,
0.6651018857955933,
-0.7800397276878357,
-0.2953670620918274,
0.020411834120750427,
-0.31731489300727844,
0.2244352102279663,
-0.49698111414909363,
0.62876296043396,
-0.4705657362937927,
0.2828066051006317,
-0.07635288685560226,
-0.4891994595527649,
-0.1933469921350479,
0.5845363736152649,
-0.6931313276290894,
1.04836905002594,
0.24080528318881989,
-0.8618111610412598,
0.7046651840209961,
-0.6781222224235535,
-0.516670286655426,
-0.1471046507358551,
-0.43841245770454407,
-0.7130773663520813,
0.014940633438527584,
0.6299598217010498,
0.7990615963935852,
-0.37893247604370117,
0.3114568591117859,
-0.5469508171081543,
-0.5787564516067505,
-0.6078576445579529,
-0.21637997031211853,
0.5978085398674011,
-0.023336371406912804,
-0.4938669800758362,
-0.0018367980374023318,
-0.4610127806663513,
-0.0437203124165535,
0.07244370877742767,
-0.08039595931768417,
-0.8473924994468689,
0.10775059461593628,
-0.2259729951620102,
0.24763765931129456,
-0.07437429577112198,
-0.39579638838768005,
0.3919788599014282,
-0.40532344579696655,
0.4665023684501648,
0.9066643714904785,
0.16894939541816711,
0.6342409253120422,
-0.4201720654964447,
0.5102015733718872,
0.057546310126781464,
0.0718509778380394,
-0.18654152750968933,
-0.4209229648113251,
-0.7502967715263367,
-0.3741380572319031,
0.5436514616012573,
0.3151438534259796,
-0.970681369304657,
0.3738337457180023,
-0.21985872089862823,
-0.6283966898918152,
-0.8794645071029663,
0.21192708611488342,
0.33945417404174805,
0.5424233078956604,
0.7158307433128357,
-0.20486941933631897,
-0.4266793727874756,
-1.1811885833740234,
-0.13331420719623566,
0.2759428322315216,
-0.17279453575611115,
0.21147799491882324,
0.4981546700000763,
-0.5174273252487183,
0.6692684888839722,
-0.5052788853645325,
-0.5247176885604858,
-0.10635518282651901,
0.2888680696487427,
0.31595101952552795,
0.7500467300415039,
0.5227930545806885,
-0.707141637802124,
-0.5300977826118469,
-0.24216878414154053,
-0.6046356558799744,
-0.024184634909033775,
-0.2139100432395935,
-0.3310880661010742,
0.13119760155677795,
0.49836423993110657,
-0.2340596616268158,
0.38833048939704895,
0.6267063617706299,
-0.1722528487443924,
0.2767016589641571,
-0.3388834297657013,
0.17226631939411163,
-1.015901803970337,
-0.06802486628293991,
0.31314682960510254,
-0.16426947712898254,
-0.4133886694908142,
0.08196704089641571,
0.4405895471572876,
-0.002131102606654167,
-0.19049662351608276,
0.41025200486183167,
-0.6915574073791504,
0.12088298797607422,
-0.056943248957395554,
0.15695106983184814,
0.06526734679937363,
0.46078383922576904,
-0.36530229449272156,
0.9370968341827393,
0.63200843334198,
-0.9382060766220093,
0.004229055251926184,
0.33971622586250305,
-0.3751299977302551,
0.6160426735877991,
-0.5902831554412842,
0.0082776490598917,
-0.16097751259803772,
0.25014570355415344,
-0.8059795498847961,
-0.08693825453519821,
0.34847378730773926,
-0.23102664947509766,
0.6218557953834534,
-0.4791679084300995,
-0.5409814715385437,
-0.14120735228061676,
-0.8925747871398926,
0.41986384987831116,
0.48419931530952454,
-0.8692620396614075,
0.44175904989242554,
0.6057590842247009,
-0.2571331262588501,
-0.4980136752128601,
-0.7021100521087646,
0.06938520818948746,
-0.11889989674091339,
-0.5473968386650085,
0.4434884786605835,
-0.07992030680179596,
0.10690468549728394,
-0.14165888726711273,
-0.14539216458797455,
0.053226079791784286,
0.2952342629432678,
0.14372582733631134,
0.29285410046577454,
-0.020251011475920677,
0.3477489650249481,
0.5253089666366577,
-0.24704022705554962,
-0.2403034269809723,
-0.4198431968688965,
0.7697087526321411,
0.051387105137109756,
-0.4964459240436554,
-0.33671876788139343,
0.18837116658687592,
0.5086153745651245,
-0.10011722892522812,
0.554347038269043,
0.8136990070343018,
-0.3191322982311249,
-0.38736745715141296,
-0.45522910356521606,
-0.2501746416091919,
-0.447079598903656,
0.3706868290901184,
-0.10375296324491501,
-0.6926952004432678,
0.07899295538663864,
-0.07780227065086365,
0.1255330890417099,
0.4579904079437256,
0.4696500599384308,
-0.06071789190173149,
1.2558871507644653,
0.6514936685562134,
-0.34474465250968933,
0.7382749319076538,
-0.4394921660423279,
-0.0729917660355568,
-1.020224928855896,
-0.1053144782781601,
-0.7111673355102539,
-0.6005341410636902,
-0.7923474907875061,
-0.28487858176231384,
0.3327689468860626,
0.0671602115035057,
-0.39139804244041443,
0.05201330408453941,
-0.9894982576370239,
0.6640028953552246,
0.9394385814666748,
0.3636520802974701,
-0.04487985745072365,
-0.053264789283275604,
-0.32048583030700684,
-0.09114602208137512,
-0.4969671070575714,
-0.6212899088859558,
1.1719691753387451,
0.06638267636299133,
0.830985963344574,
-0.05999835580587387,
0.8615509271621704,
0.5475537776947021,
0.44372451305389404,
-0.6879921555519104,
0.35140231251716614,
-0.10773642361164093,
-0.5313454270362854,
-0.2532610297203064,
-0.08935485035181046,
-0.6945545077323914,
0.41997769474983215,
-0.23336048424243927,
-0.5556910037994385,
0.05008798837661743,
0.4551394581794739,
-0.3520733118057251,
0.5406455397605896,
-0.9572169780731201,
0.6004078388214111,
-0.06370215117931366,
-0.4655872881412506,
-0.3221328556537628,
-0.5869221091270447,
0.2867737114429474,
-0.1326499879360199,
-0.028732337057590485,
-0.07778675854206085,
-0.1797173023223877,
0.7680994868278503,
-0.15815813839435577,
0.6811412572860718,
-0.5752567052841187,
0.010472767055034637,
-0.13946034014225006,
0.1767358034849167,
0.8436694741249084,
0.19611182808876038,
-0.44662603735923767,
0.2219475507736206,
-0.12141825258731842,
-0.5443004965782166,
-0.38506075739860535,
0.8934453725814819,
-0.8158971071243286,
-0.6802909970283508,
-0.3727400302886963,
-0.1316368281841278,
-0.3128052353858948,
0.21765835583209991,
0.36866599321365356,
0.5206977725028992,
-0.06352249532938004,
0.40743371844291687,
0.6812085509300232,
-0.2868613004684448,
0.24584992229938507,
-0.022359061986207962,
0.06465068459510803,
-0.5365799069404602,
0.8933082222938538,
0.1395646035671234,
0.10113368928432465,
0.2730894088745117,
0.1190730556845665,
-0.2053481936454773,
-0.9418204426765442,
-0.47623196244239807,
0.0770542174577713,
-0.7127935886383057,
-0.30098995566368103,
-0.6934258937835693,
-0.15517650544643402,
-0.2553400993347168,
-0.34593117237091064,
-0.16268177330493927,
-0.36896735429763794,
-0.5088781714439392,
-0.21029424667358398,
-0.039635952562093735,
0.675084114074707,
-0.0036994609981775284,
0.17558206617832184,
-0.6899187564849854,
0.506083607673645,
0.1539902687072754,
0.6136156916618347,
-0.10456426441669464,
-0.4331435561180115,
-0.4833180904388428,
0.23920616507530212,
-0.42987388372421265,
-0.6587223410606384,
0.46505600214004517,
0.1786540001630783,
0.6226412057876587,
0.20887702703475952,
0.15905866026878357,
0.5724292993545532,
-0.4072399139404297,
0.7967716455459595,
0.021695075556635857,
-0.7590169310569763,
0.8074362277984619,
-0.27376753091812134,
0.09673221409320831,
0.8281280398368835,
0.4217992424964905,
-0.4378364682197571,
-0.38056430220603943,
-0.6502872705459595,
-1.125125527381897,
0.7541962265968323,
0.1494363397359848,
0.17515072226524353,
0.08047882467508316,
0.15940816700458527,
0.34532999992370605,
0.37459418177604675,
-0.2953856587409973,
-0.05818089842796326,
-0.31883421540260315,
-0.1959342360496521,
-0.11516401916742325,
-0.32877981662750244,
-0.07413820177316666,
-0.45703086256980896,
1.1519254446029663,
-0.19779324531555176,
0.12280198186635971,
0.11689067631959915,
-0.4039061367511749,
0.22746886312961578,
0.014590488746762276,
0.4776547849178314,
0.16202469170093536,
-0.44496431946754456,
0.010580453090369701,
0.24302831292152405,
-0.6601166129112244,
0.09934503585100174,
0.10175016522407532,
-0.2788339853286743,
0.10398393124341965,
0.0389411486685276,
0.5562247633934021,
0.2322205901145935,
-0.30997756123542786,
0.5183826684951782,
-0.18469053506851196,
-0.08426403254270554,
-0.13210925459861755,
0.39631766080856323,
-0.33850914239883423,
0.21424221992492676,
0.38065725564956665,
0.5027197003364563,
0.21398189663887024,
-0.14894284307956696,
0.3244997560977936,
0.5982732176780701,
-0.5466413497924805,
-0.015393123030662537,
0.5254429578781128,
0.33914485573768616,
-0.31095731258392334,
0.7036899328231812,
-0.09722570329904556,
-0.27019813656806946,
0.6277143955230713,
0.16060228645801544,
1.1145777702331543,
-0.03035615384578705,
0.09790978580713272,
0.375691682100296,
0.3082626163959503,
-0.24299782514572144,
-0.09017109870910645,
-0.16079986095428467,
-0.7408407926559448,
0.030243560671806335,
-0.3901914060115814,
-0.6938234567642212,
0.16059429943561554,
-0.798176646232605,
0.7054209113121033,
-0.6115522384643555,
-0.10169261693954468,
-0.05573316663503647,
0.1661383956670761,
-0.7341811656951904,
0.181471586227417,
0.014845308847725391,
0.7926738858222961,
-0.5097799301147461,
0.9605240225791931,
0.593328595161438,
-0.3883488178253174,
-0.27041566371917725,
0.17194269597530365,
0.10180006921291351,
-0.7470724582672119,
0.10838018357753754,
0.47251760959625244,
-0.05618816241621971,
0.14852885901927948,
-0.8064451217651367,
-0.5833495855331421,
1.2808551788330078,
0.5562716722488403,
-0.4587838053703308,
-0.0169973187148571,
-0.41112852096557617,
0.32835474610328674,
-0.19117653369903564,
0.5378784537315369,
0.6518047451972961,
0.30056288838386536,
0.10199953615665436,
-0.33355477452278137,
0.031299952417612076,
-0.4334386885166168,
0.0706103965640068,
0.3659776449203491,
-0.40940141677856445,
0.841474711894989,
-0.20007240772247314,
-0.23847037553787231,
0.004518772475421429,
0.21551160514354706,
0.307977557182312,
0.04019187018275261,
0.352075457572937,
0.429778516292572,
1.0832643508911133,
0.0023389568086713552,
1.1199500560760498,
-0.5181765556335449,
0.3477066159248352,
1.2635397911071777,
-0.1588989794254303,
0.5463451743125916,
0.45361414551734924,
0.3432552218437195,
0.3320680260658264,
0.8003514409065247,
-0.29799532890319824,
0.8776904344558716,
0.11610956490039825,
-0.15730857849121094,
-0.15502408146858215,
-0.04178677126765251,
-0.5690271258354187,
-0.03874628245830536,
0.37049219012260437,
-0.4442984461784363,
-0.5693689584732056,
-0.11954396963119507,
-0.015225264243781567,
-0.039852824062108994,
-0.22257140278816223,
0.5747771263122559,
-0.1589379757642746,
-0.48287495970726013,
0.6128860116004944,
0.09149853885173798,
1.2227243185043335,
-0.5947823524475098,
-0.157429039478302,
-0.34809011220932007,
0.2801869213581085,
-0.1364469677209854,
-0.6513972878456116,
0.11571402847766876,
-0.1696006804704666,
-0.04824811592698097,
-0.4123845100402832,
0.7273869514465332,
-0.27258118987083435,
-0.2977565824985504,
0.2620558440685272,
0.2997770607471466,
-0.20454441010951996,
-0.3108823299407959,
-0.5889793038368225,
-0.28729715943336487,
0.189568430185318,
-0.2531565725803375,
0.48568081855773926,
0.5254697203636169,
-0.05643570423126221,
0.8119850158691406,
0.729667603969574,
0.12012128531932831,
-0.3772697150707245,
0.1003098264336586,
1.1318730115890503,
-0.8088324069976807,
-0.6882525086402893,
-1.1959400177001953,
0.4330902695655823,
-0.3787664473056793,
-0.2623063027858734,
0.5964165329933167,
0.6116628646850586,
0.8262913823127747,
-0.0003728409647010267,
0.9936349987983704,
0.2694254517555237,
0.3983369469642639,
-0.5582156181335449,
0.861132025718689,
-0.47854769229888916,
0.34637436270713806,
-0.4330384433269501,
-0.6302068829536438,
-0.5003544092178345,
0.5882981419563293,
-0.3421381115913391,
-0.0449397973716259,
0.5612296462059021,
1.0371284484863281,
-0.20649650692939758,
0.17756137251853943,
0.33591344952583313,
0.1209295466542244,
0.7620365619659424,
0.23321498930454254,
0.6747974753379822,
-0.492500364780426,
0.5208698511123657,
-0.029672598466277122,
-0.14501702785491943,
-0.40674009919166565,
-0.8722410202026367,
-0.9470489025115967,
-0.5384929776191711,
-0.25002139806747437,
-0.17276166379451752,
0.13617856800556183,
1.1085224151611328,
0.7343246340751648,
-0.8104629516601562,
0.2152295857667923,
-0.10041365027427673,
0.31761953234672546,
-0.06549946218729019,
-0.17518989741802216,
0.24689219892024994,
-0.5752760171890259,
-0.7324458360671997,
0.09798677265644073,
0.22928999364376068,
0.2663525938987732,
-0.1838894486427307,
-0.13268087804317474,
-0.29049935936927795,
0.03165708854794502,
0.4876926839351654,
-0.07726742327213287,
-0.15537934005260468,
-0.29189395904541016,
-0.5722107887268066,
-0.32006847858428955,
0.12396140396595001,
0.5593590140342712,
-0.9817451238632202,
0.2583565413951874,
0.34121614694595337,
0.8217759728431702,
0.7086927890777588,
-0.039409901946783066,
0.5461803078651428,
-0.9010175466537476,
0.24205158650875092,
0.515033483505249,
0.4315588176250458,
0.40402382612228394,
-0.33709320425987244,
0.7726439237594604,
0.0106987114995718,
-0.41167134046554565,
-0.68431556224823,
-0.0988420844078064,
-0.48687928915023804,
-0.2580508887767792,
1.1977651119232178,
0.23213008046150208,
0.05431186780333519,
-0.21778470277786255,
-0.4468526244163513,
0.22276808321475983,
-0.7167819738388062,
0.919021725654602,
0.7177516222000122,
0.17107129096984863,
0.14610333740711212,
-0.6852726340293884,
0.4865194261074066,
0.19682155549526215,
-0.48392054438591003,
-0.08940522372722626,
0.5743854641914368,
0.1676815003156662,
-0.04404863342642784,
0.5186198949813843,
0.06688854843378067,
0.025147322565317154,
-0.11224672198295593,
0.08518891036510468,
-0.24839651584625244,
-0.30206426978111267,
-0.47839441895484924,
0.3332054316997528,
0.006944988388568163,
-0.5738581418991089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16827v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16827v2
|
A Survey on Data Selection for Language Models
| 2024-02-26T18:54:35 | 2024-03-08T20:04:01 |
Alon Albalak, Yanai Elazar, Sang Michael Xie, Shayne Longpre, Nathan Lambert, Xinyi Wang, Niklas Muennighoff, Bairu Hou, Liangming Pan, Haewon Jeong, Colin Raffel, Shiyu Chang, Tatsunori Hashimoto, William Yang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
A major factor in the recent success of large language models is the use of
enormous and ever-growing text datasets for unsupervised pre-training. However,
naively training a model on all available data may not be optimal (or
feasible), as the quality of available text data can vary. Filtering out data
can also decrease the carbon footprint and financial costs of training models
by reducing the amount of training required. Data selection methods aim to
determine which candidate data points to include in the training dataset and
how to appropriately sample from the selected data points. The promise of
improved data selection methods has caused the volume of research in the area
to rapidly expand. However, because deep learning is mostly driven by empirical
evidence and experimentation on large-scale data is expensive, few
organizations have the resources for extensive data selection research.
Consequently, knowledge of effective data selection practices has become
concentrated within a few organizations, many of which do not openly share
their findings and methodologies. To narrow this gap in knowledge, we present a
comprehensive review of existing literature on data selection methods and
related research areas, providing a taxonomy of existing approaches. By
describing the current landscape of research, this work aims to accelerate
progress in data selection by establishing an entry point for new and
established researchers. Additionally, throughout this review we draw attention
to noticeable holes in the literature and conclude the paper by proposing
promising avenues for future research.
|
[
-0.6781463027000427,
-0.7105730772018433,
0.6114338636398315,
-0.12881039083003998,
-0.15986602008342743,
0.2391454577445984,
-0.3511817157268524,
-0.4434470534324646,
-0.083705835044384,
0.5966833233833313,
-0.3843124508857727,
-0.4538446068763733,
-0.4684896171092987,
-0.003462183056399226,
-0.530125081539154,
0.856543779373169,
-0.09561622887849808,
0.16393525898456573,
-0.34613683819770813,
0.052511125802993774,
-0.39760643243789673,
-0.5604907274246216,
-0.5739201307296753,
-0.4638747572898865,
0.41756802797317505,
0.3494897484779358,
0.4334940016269684,
0.5516529083251953,
0.50956791639328,
0.08590254932641983,
-0.2484888881444931,
0.11311964690685272,
-0.4661494195461273,
0.2958278954029083,
0.05492687225341797,
-0.32096007466316223,
-0.12882505357265472,
0.12930195033550262,
0.6434518098831177,
1.131690502166748,
0.015996567904949188,
0.17281430959701538,
0.005011938977986574,
0.9047549366950989,
-0.7650241255760193,
0.02569250389933586,
-0.7073877453804016,
0.20142582058906555,
-0.525595486164093,
0.18633952736854553,
-0.295012891292572,
-0.36816272139549255,
0.391541987657547,
-0.2804467976093292,
0.2529480755329132,
0.14379939436912537,
0.3467607796192169,
-0.10502178221940994,
-0.40188199281692505,
-0.33146318793296814,
-0.9993903040885925,
0.9637811779975891,
-0.41820886731147766,
0.4054103195667267,
0.6473811268806458,
0.2627701461315155,
0.0718032494187355,
-0.5087448358535767,
-0.15738874673843384,
-0.26270556449890137,
0.1152275949716568,
-0.0888272374868393,
-0.15797768533229828,
-0.08913574367761612,
0.14015154540538788,
0.442376971244812,
-0.7912464141845703,
0.31195998191833496,
-0.43156948685646057,
-0.03653433173894882,
0.6121873259544373,
-0.04097922146320343,
0.04697750508785248,
0.1856917142868042,
0.045011136680841446,
-0.2846584618091583,
-0.8812863826751709,
-0.10805311053991318,
0.39025911688804626,
0.4145161807537079,
0.3237200379371643,
0.38279563188552856,
-0.4956052005290985,
0.9509323239326477,
-0.5456091165542603,
0.22958716750144958,
0.29396265745162964,
-0.509575366973877,
-0.2645476758480072,
-0.22348792850971222,
0.720586359500885,
0.04052989184856415,
0.2784663438796997,
-0.15707264840602875,
-0.3099944293498993,
-0.25691795349121094,
0.05413336306810379,
-0.6501316428184509,
-0.24421744048595428,
0.2138822376728058,
-0.5309798121452332,
-0.2662063539028168,
0.03482051566243172,
-1.1121035814285278,
-0.32528963685035706,
-0.3200158178806305,
-0.24362511932849884,
-0.005207964684814215,
-0.5766706466674805,
0.11185228079557419,
0.06284857541322708,
-0.08227238059043884,
0.10302905738353729,
-0.738450288772583,
0.3403700292110443,
0.35917574167251587,
0.6108788251876831,
-0.2407313883304596,
-0.14521189033985138,
-0.15639938414096832,
-0.13971492648124695,
-0.6952711343765259,
0.8289296627044678,
-0.9122937321662903,
-0.55339115858078,
0.27095454931259155,
-0.2903033494949341,
0.014236262068152428,
-0.5313917994499207,
0.488667368888855,
-0.7893345355987549,
0.27233490347862244,
-0.19369952380657196,
-0.5281598567962646,
-0.22880463302135468,
0.10585056990385056,
-0.8439756631851196,
0.9430070519447327,
0.236764594912529,
-0.9012062549591064,
0.6698603630065918,
-0.406556636095047,
-0.4363821744918823,
-0.11281724274158478,
-0.28112825751304626,
-0.5354095101356506,
0.04319953918457031,
0.5250406861305237,
0.5607156753540039,
-0.7102938890457153,
0.4664551615715027,
-0.4296937882900238,
-0.2784753441810608,
0.25351133942604065,
-0.4315057396888733,
0.7534520626068115,
0.5465495586395264,
-0.1408427506685257,
-0.14267154037952423,
-0.7726097106933594,
0.08741725236177444,
0.17840160429477692,
-0.2683059275150299,
-0.4896044135093689,
0.10650862753391266,
0.14299948513507843,
0.09285204112529755,
-0.06463424116373062,
-0.3376374840736389,
0.3024727404117584,
-0.16905878484249115,
0.30882498621940613,
0.48405665159225464,
-0.09394945204257965,
0.550204336643219,
-0.21340858936309814,
0.6870633959770203,
-0.15094950795173645,
0.21571822464466095,
0.05485166236758232,
-0.2044195830821991,
-0.5899397730827332,
-0.0063805123791098595,
0.6065412759780884,
0.23183587193489075,
-0.7472928166389465,
0.4978257715702057,
-0.11129533499479294,
-0.682854950428009,
-0.4807223379611969,
0.2823905646800995,
0.21444348990917206,
0.08481883257627487,
0.280926376581192,
-0.12616987526416779,
-0.5802883505821228,
-0.7128155827522278,
0.01884165033698082,
-0.12204708158969879,
0.11002649366855621,
0.44000300765037537,
0.4017777442932129,
-0.11398540437221527,
1.086596131324768,
-0.7514727711677551,
-0.07008075714111328,
-0.48942258954048157,
-0.098636195063591,
0.29053184390068054,
0.3233861029148102,
0.7310832738876343,
-0.8444464802742004,
-0.3390725255012512,
0.04170699417591095,
-0.401922345161438,
0.12786366045475006,
0.009873601607978344,
-0.06321301311254501,
-0.08113136887550354,
0.5998325347900391,
-0.5888656973838806,
0.2826811373233795,
0.652336835861206,
-0.13440179824829102,
0.2392551153898239,
-0.04647934064269066,
0.1362362504005432,
-0.8223848938941956,
0.4679408073425293,
0.05461570993065834,
-0.011280911974608898,
-0.6010329127311707,
-0.31354376673698425,
0.07150813192129135,
-0.05603431165218353,
-0.1461794525384903,
0.6045249104499817,
-0.5573986172676086,
0.002215018030256033,
-0.13914863765239716,
-0.08062217384576797,
-0.27106449007987976,
0.22173400223255157,
0.22663064301013947,
0.5398591160774231,
0.8976849317550659,
-0.728657066822052,
0.35048651695251465,
0.3948747515678406,
-0.7706608772277832,
0.01493102591484785,
-0.3904472291469574,
0.1864248514175415,
-0.15315479040145874,
0.3275361955165863,
-0.8613830208778381,
-0.10612229257822037,
-0.04094097763299942,
-0.3328917920589447,
0.3197617530822754,
-0.21719662845134735,
-0.5272656083106995,
-0.4163435697555542,
-0.021536685526371002,
0.3721833825111389,
0.4127872586250305,
-0.3430362641811371,
0.035320889204740524,
0.6882340908050537,
-0.4246310889720917,
-0.52781742811203,
-0.6921347975730896,
0.031020991504192352,
-0.22513295710086823,
-0.047244761139154434,
-0.07026117295026779,
-0.09013915061950684,
-0.30537205934524536,
-0.21654967963695526,
-0.08030207455158234,
-0.33321666717529297,
0.10824248194694519,
-0.37681150436401367,
0.30381911993026733,
-0.05821097269654274,
0.16619685292243958,
0.01353510469198227,
-0.06765173375606537,
0.06835228204727173,
-0.26798316836357117,
0.5597236752510071,
0.4604472219944,
-0.3379197120666504,
0.18055443465709686,
0.24529938399791718,
0.45877721905708313,
-0.5850710868835449,
0.5843615531921387,
0.2694050371646881,
-0.27935293316841125,
-0.44245612621307373,
-0.6197685599327087,
-0.14437642693519592,
-0.3420006334781647,
0.5316076874732971,
-0.024479912593960762,
-0.8518968224525452,
0.14439880847930908,
-0.10296178609132767,
0.16595704853534698,
0.2214045375585556,
0.28817039728164673,
0.15257441997528076,
0.9822461009025574,
0.6871362924575806,
-0.40454161167144775,
0.6114069223403931,
-0.2567857801914215,
0.41841813921928406,
-0.5774205327033997,
-0.1290493607521057,
-1.0118412971496582,
0.027268214151263237,
-0.46930819749832153,
-0.1763232797384262,
0.0719434916973114,
-0.1051710993051529,
0.0348694883286953,
0.051256999373435974,
-0.5351693630218506,
0.4244547188282013,
0.3735920190811157,
-0.11030732840299606,
0.23748286068439484,
0.1425141841173172,
0.07862034440040588,
0.0466294139623642,
-0.6432459354400635,
-0.306076318025589,
1.374300241470337,
0.3133808970451355,
0.6910881996154785,
-0.30536597967147827,
0.2733913064002991,
-0.01909777522087097,
0.06569833308458328,
-0.4628097414970398,
0.47536322474479675,
-0.25555604696273804,
-0.9042874574661255,
-0.5138547420501709,
-0.6575824022293091,
-1.1777851581573486,
0.20297569036483765,
-0.21314899623394012,
-0.45161527395248413,
0.18817731738090515,
0.02124873176217079,
-0.22449760138988495,
0.3780663013458252,
-0.43041664361953735,
0.6120353937149048,
-0.18623507022857666,
0.09469319880008698,
-0.1286775916814804,
-0.4204624891281128,
0.2177450805902481,
-0.5380039215087891,
0.4234044849872589,
-0.18812169134616852,
0.35048946738243103,
0.9352569580078125,
0.14095333218574524,
0.5481734871864319,
-0.2860677242279053,
-0.07674780488014221,
0.22715575993061066,
-0.057701386511325836,
0.4577370285987854,
-0.08524277806282043,
-0.18758133053779602,
0.21619613468647003,
-0.17181287705898285,
-0.16284283995628357,
-0.3601272702217102,
0.42661359906196594,
-0.4569813907146454,
-0.1448744684457779,
-0.24188122153282166,
-0.3942298889160156,
-0.8294321298599243,
0.12440889328718185,
0.2698368430137634,
0.318962424993515,
-0.2503323256969452,
0.729910135269165,
0.8220095038414001,
-0.2679234445095062,
0.281981498003006,
0.3865729570388794,
-0.33346375823020935,
-0.36404111981391907,
0.7696844935417175,
0.3888995349407196,
0.18290846049785614,
0.3811519145965576,
0.12887240946292877,
-0.2872508466243744,
-1.1027148962020874,
-0.1743593066930771,
-0.05718080326914787,
-0.43464112281799316,
-0.1264238953590393,
-0.584281325340271,
-0.3137059509754181,
-0.4420596659183502,
0.08294369280338287,
-0.49711260199546814,
-0.31533753871917725,
-0.25684431195259094,
-0.24772317707538605,
0.32178616523742676,
0.6032038927078247,
0.195935919880867,
0.2692510485649109,
-0.49623918533325195,
0.22953417897224426,
0.12608522176742554,
0.39198559522628784,
0.11836229264736176,
-0.21006794273853302,
-0.4198596775531769,
0.03391038998961449,
0.03792949765920639,
-0.4180826246738434,
0.3977092206478119,
0.029321569949388504,
0.8203385472297668,
0.2407303899526596,
0.06189484894275665,
0.4839564859867096,
-0.3890271782875061,
0.5565614104270935,
0.19656354188919067,
-0.3801780641078949,
0.80238938331604,
-0.358246386051178,
0.1734282523393631,
0.8283798098564148,
0.48346856236457825,
-0.5765892863273621,
-0.2083338052034378,
-0.5801208019256592,
-1.0713653564453125,
0.6842924952507019,
0.37497997283935547,
0.10075756907463074,
0.3944849967956543,
0.12124623358249664,
0.3220580816268921,
0.40438273549079895,
-0.463297963142395,
-0.40326404571533203,
0.2745504677295685,
-0.030733589082956314,
-0.2983006536960602,
-0.031162556260824203,
0.09917977452278137,
-0.25497087836265564,
0.6478169560432434,
-0.10693362355232239,
-0.05430885776877403,
-0.13684020936489105,
0.07281315326690674,
-0.029885899275541306,
0.3129730522632599,
-0.07057555764913559,
0.9020269513130188,
-0.022016704082489014,
-0.20374782383441925,
-0.058355893939733505,
-0.7367252707481384,
0.008510426618158817,
0.27338916063308716,
-0.44225937128067017,
0.12402293086051941,
0.16894777119159698,
0.8902603387832642,
-0.03265960142016411,
-0.6920304894447327,
0.48578977584838867,
-0.17868931591510773,
-0.35375353693962097,
-0.18978531658649445,
0.11527556926012039,
-0.1416616290807724,
0.03389604762196541,
0.35248252749443054,
-0.10475894063711166,
0.13989973068237305,
-0.49278196692466736,
0.05441749840974808,
0.4852287471294403,
-0.29700395464897156,
-0.01006009615957737,
0.27572470903396606,
0.19875457882881165,
0.183545783162117,
0.9077386856079102,
0.17816737294197083,
-0.009913674555718899,
0.5070012807846069,
0.14547426998615265,
0.682986855506897,
-0.2560841143131256,
0.2509692907333374,
0.29519638419151306,
0.25276124477386475,
-0.3875940442085266,
0.1623023897409439,
0.014787894673645496,
-0.782058596611023,
-0.4987683892250061,
-0.5907940864562988,
-0.39122915267944336,
0.7393302321434021,
-0.7358038425445557,
0.2732057273387909,
-0.21951037645339966,
-0.12031298130750656,
-0.11705563217401505,
0.28571975231170654,
-0.8515673875808716,
0.4510727524757385,
0.2047397941350937,
1.0627046823501587,
-0.9118124842643738,
0.8116562962532043,
0.6232811212539673,
-0.17843912541866302,
-0.39429569244384766,
0.01735822856426239,
-0.12054287642240524,
-0.6126522421836853,
0.32749688625335693,
-0.1460622251033783,
0.27768296003341675,
-0.015797404572367668,
-0.7637458443641663,
-1.0210493803024292,
0.7132522463798523,
0.3669738173484802,
-0.5875235199928284,
-0.12364562600851059,
0.08033246546983719,
0.3494907319545746,
-0.30261877179145813,
0.1971558928489685,
0.897950291633606,
0.4451638460159302,
0.2998039722442627,
-0.7514327764511108,
-0.3859799802303314,
-0.22889702022075653,
0.1211526021361351,
0.23303936421871185,
-0.3923057019710541,
0.709134042263031,
0.20706287026405334,
0.05261604115366936,
-0.0024714013561606407,
0.4530722200870514,
0.358275830745697,
0.2277607023715973,
0.5985605716705322,
0.11896084994077682,
0.7791178822517395,
0.0072700162418186665,
0.7097175121307373,
-0.17559336125850677,
0.3610951006412506,
0.895397961139679,
-0.41866254806518555,
0.7234655022621155,
0.4690042734146118,
-0.5026286244392395,
-0.011324409395456314,
1.0471479892730713,
-0.3377399444580078,
0.7547292113304138,
0.2569562494754791,
-0.0401107557117939,
-0.2152853012084961,
-0.22407808899879456,
-0.4149319529533386,
0.5141527652740479,
0.44171491265296936,
-0.29273316264152527,
-0.16945147514343262,
0.1174318864941597,
-0.04966998100280762,
-0.2743966579437256,
-0.12995804846286774,
0.7897828221321106,
-0.009277479723095894,
-0.6525478959083557,
0.2804643213748932,
-0.2964886724948883,
0.48137685656547546,
-0.8937190771102905,
0.05522392690181732,
-0.25133490562438965,
-0.1083870604634285,
-0.182147815823555,
-0.8754885196685791,
0.10165801644325256,
0.1970648467540741,
-0.01595200225710869,
-0.4140821695327759,
0.794414758682251,
-0.4055943191051483,
-0.3672774136066437,
0.2856614887714386,
0.8529412150382996,
0.25746431946754456,
-0.2869774401187897,
-0.5206149816513062,
0.21012724936008453,
0.22966426610946655,
-0.5914093852043152,
0.3327849507331848,
0.32946473360061646,
0.00524804787710309,
0.6089358329772949,
0.7924627065658569,
0.5503957271575928,
-0.37295252084732056,
0.23779098689556122,
1.0256788730621338,
-0.6437615156173706,
-0.551199197769165,
-0.6143872141838074,
0.4027811884880066,
-0.22398778796195984,
-0.4586373567581177,
0.5566080212593079,
0.6734813451766968,
1.0109840631484985,
0.12559911608695984,
1.256746530532837,
-0.020125703886151314,
0.8606078028678894,
-0.6968851089477539,
0.80720454454422,
-0.3982977271080017,
0.14842483401298523,
-0.29957664012908936,
-1.2232747077941895,
-0.333130419254303,
0.617059051990509,
-0.39584991335868835,
0.3771152198314667,
0.6664840579032898,
0.6302251815795898,
-0.04818775877356529,
0.15611021220684052,
0.391075074672699,
-0.011726733297109604,
0.24393384158611298,
0.2729882597923279,
0.8375272154808044,
-0.10480698943138123,
0.4441538155078888,
-0.1669629067182541,
-0.21342724561691284,
-0.14872312545776367,
-0.6591964364051819,
-0.9135237336158752,
-0.77658611536026,
-0.22673003375530243,
0.1192125529050827,
-0.1132664903998375,
0.7460148930549622,
1.043472409248352,
-0.8781235814094543,
-0.26495519280433655,
-0.1602049022912979,
0.08010175079107285,
-0.01597723737359047,
-0.06968022137880325,
0.32086634635925293,
-0.3109283745288849,
-0.5909340381622314,
0.46462222933769226,
-0.10379235446453094,
0.032349471002817154,
-0.3553430140018463,
0.09885399788618088,
-0.18028105795383453,
-0.18138937652111053,
0.3479979932308197,
0.2750079929828644,
-0.17158374190330505,
0.35027360916137695,
-0.01167925912886858,
-0.04621138051152229,
0.007643756922334433,
1.0500832796096802,
-0.6196901798248291,
0.29983657598495483,
0.4867454469203949,
0.9166538715362549,
0.5775279402732849,
-0.5465014576911926,
0.57722407579422,
-0.6987610459327698,
0.05734550207853317,
0.46974611282348633,
0.3006654381752014,
0.37595394253730774,
-0.31650951504707336,
0.6373961567878723,
-0.04901738837361336,
-0.6498400568962097,
-0.9793805480003357,
0.0360896922647953,
-0.3889850974082947,
-0.6949915289878845,
1.2860143184661865,
0.23778539896011353,
-0.024568894878029823,
-0.3429560363292694,
-0.1647624373435974,
0.0385233610868454,
-0.2778991460800171,
0.5850815176963806,
0.9017634987831116,
-0.0873647928237915,
-0.13564646244049072,
-1.1172301769256592,
0.6394134163856506,
0.1387900710105896,
-1.0262731313705444,
0.4960126578807831,
0.4755443334579468,
-0.06050187721848488,
-0.12912361323833466,
0.4959750771522522,
-0.10741526633501053,
-0.18250612914562225,
-0.18779335916042328,
0.025082800537347794,
0.2348373681306839,
-0.45055314898490906,
-0.4693583548069,
0.05091684311628342,
0.31095415353775024,
0.04647282510995865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16823v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16823v2
|
Language Agents as Optimizable Graphs
| 2024-02-26T18:48:27 | 2024-02-27T11:03:10 |
Mingchen Zhuge, Wenyi Wang, Louis Kirsch, Francesco Faccio, Dmitrii Khizbullin, Jürgen Schmidhuber
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MA
|
Various human-designed prompt engineering techniques have been proposed to
improve problem solvers based on Large Language Models (LLMs), yielding many
disparate code bases. We unify these approaches by describing LLM-based agents
as computational graphs. The nodes implement functions to process multimodal
data or query LLMs, and the edges describe the information flow between
operations. Graphs can be recursively combined into larger composite graphs
representing hierarchies of inter-agent collaboration (where edges connect
operations of different agents). Our novel automatic graph optimizers (1)
refine node-level LLM prompts (node optimization) and (2) improve agent
orchestration by changing graph connectivity (edge optimization). Experiments
demonstrate that our framework can be used to efficiently develop, integrate,
and automatically improve various LLM agents. The code can be found at
https://github.com/metauto-ai/gptswarm.
|
[
-0.524582028388977,
-0.9102964997291565,
0.735711932182312,
0.16945137083530426,
0.23330506682395935,
0.6538123488426208,
-0.3034590482711792,
-0.22204522788524628,
0.3220040500164032,
0.4080753028392792,
-0.7876684665679932,
-0.43854227662086487,
-0.18339598178863525,
0.45036575198173523,
0.09894663840532303,
0.608195424079895,
-0.07427892088890076,
-0.1188139095902443,
-0.3308333158493042,
-0.020395519211888313,
-0.3124271333217621,
-0.1886243373155594,
-0.9886355400085449,
-0.5419472455978394,
0.6923713684082031,
0.4944855272769928,
0.9518933296203613,
0.6886369585990906,
0.21621249616146088,
0.49628081917762756,
0.10685863345861435,
0.5887507200241089,
-0.4638124704360962,
0.3637004494667053,
-0.04342646151781082,
-0.22642746567726135,
-0.4703097641468048,
-0.11519972234964371,
0.45447641611099243,
0.7968222498893738,
0.09745396673679352,
-0.1364600956439972,
0.1056058332324028,
0.6357985734939575,
-0.3557921051979065,
0.6537452340126038,
-0.3239676058292389,
-0.08443044871091843,
0.06527382135391235,
-0.5479920506477356,
-0.4999713599681854,
-0.5043213963508606,
-0.26751673221588135,
-0.7751088738441467,
-0.13529513776302338,
0.16914108395576477,
0.5029237866401672,
0.5311699509620667,
-0.25961196422576904,
-0.3662659525871277,
-0.5735756754875183,
0.46580371260643005,
-0.3506180942058563,
0.14593513309955597,
0.19571463763713837,
0.5673404932022095,
-0.717211902141571,
-0.709276556968689,
-0.38332444429397583,
-0.35993948578834534,
-0.07744330167770386,
-0.09952600300312042,
-0.4504944980144501,
0.4718645215034485,
0.17544817924499512,
-0.054384440183639526,
-0.64300537109375,
0.28070494532585144,
0.007762303575873375,
-0.41621366143226624,
0.535323441028595,
0.45381322503089905,
0.7382431030273438,
0.2004295289516449,
0.13022682070732117,
-0.035057708621025085,
-0.5224652290344238,
0.07222913205623627,
0.2225172519683838,
0.5352731347084045,
0.05153817683458328,
0.22405754029750824,
-0.3750784993171692,
0.7645800709724426,
-0.05838002264499664,
-0.07719951868057251,
0.3324664235115051,
-0.18323735892772675,
0.21944080293178558,
-0.3051460385322571,
0.8288406133651733,
0.2711416482925415,
0.5735547542572021,
-0.337866872549057,
-0.2612382769584656,
0.1192471832036972,
-0.05883561447262764,
-0.6898201107978821,
-0.24946174025535583,
0.1970801204442978,
-0.14502498507499695,
-0.3127211630344391,
-0.3295450806617737,
-0.5866904258728027,
-0.6005510091781616,
-0.36658740043640137,
0.1366690695285797,
-0.2939940392971039,
-0.17948980629444122,
-0.1848277598619461,
-0.1866462230682373,
0.106292724609375,
0.3180951476097107,
-0.6499985456466675,
0.2262965589761734,
0.7088226675987244,
0.9543344974517822,
0.11907123029232025,
-0.5162190198898315,
-0.6262243986129761,
0.09310387820005417,
-0.5128937363624573,
0.8006296157836914,
-0.6953781843185425,
-0.5109825134277344,
0.004561793524771929,
0.006712989881634712,
-0.0812663808465004,
-0.33533716201782227,
0.40401706099510193,
-0.5648123025894165,
-0.046841394156217575,
-0.2440868616104126,
-0.339191734790802,
0.05892482027411461,
0.1759055107831955,
-0.7704878449440002,
0.7653434872627258,
0.21422992646694183,
-0.5365328788757324,
-0.234254851937294,
-1.0347050428390503,
-0.37277159094810486,
0.2628561556339264,
-0.10465547442436218,
-0.1351860612630844,
-0.08094886690378189,
0.3289855122566223,
0.19768927991390228,
-0.4762949049472809,
0.23009273409843445,
-0.16885215044021606,
-0.3914130628108978,
0.18498815596103668,
-0.050313301384449005,
0.8102291822433472,
0.4953489899635315,
-0.11272038519382477,
0.5878089666366577,
-0.48138952255249023,
0.19113069772720337,
0.2507970333099365,
-0.3606683611869812,
0.10349492728710175,
0.09959111362695694,
-0.23836347460746765,
-0.0937030166387558,
0.20762641727924347,
-0.23993214964866638,
0.3499046862125397,
-0.30953073501586914,
0.815239429473877,
0.8946976661682129,
-0.21572650969028473,
0.5085763931274414,
-0.430877685546875,
0.886637270450592,
-0.5152513384819031,
0.1643921285867691,
-0.3294179439544678,
-0.4131145179271698,
-0.6269029378890991,
-0.45005470514297485,
-0.17359107732772827,
0.5346813797950745,
-1.2632745504379272,
0.254424512386322,
-0.03624629229307175,
-0.49011361598968506,
-0.2767138183116913,
0.026131847873330116,
0.17575660347938538,
0.6237800717353821,
0.1290706843137741,
0.07693134993314743,
-0.4188639223575592,
-0.7443692684173584,
-0.2082843780517578,
-0.23934057354927063,
0.2232082635164261,
0.4564051032066345,
0.1422131508588791,
-0.5899979472160339,
1.3102744817733765,
-0.5774195194244385,
0.13864687085151672,
-0.37470996379852295,
0.0554487369954586,
0.3428363502025604,
0.15181495249271393,
0.5750747919082642,
-0.5210014581680298,
-0.7508154511451721,
0.09253261238336563,
-0.7460839748382568,
-0.7118191719055176,
0.1396028995513916,
-0.1587645411491394,
0.139406219124794,
0.7817004323005676,
-0.8220515251159668,
-0.10191553831100464,
0.35063034296035767,
-0.26315030455589294,
0.6867524981498718,
-0.13885626196861267,
0.15569138526916504,
-0.9035385847091675,
-0.18489697575569153,
-0.18132416903972626,
-0.3662222921848297,
-0.7724599838256836,
0.1835545301437378,
-0.19366714358329773,
-0.5620172619819641,
-0.2323148548603058,
0.728398323059082,
-0.7959966659545898,
-0.020116621628403664,
-0.5650649666786194,
0.25747743248939514,
-0.09050542116165161,
0.6290183663368225,
-0.43400731682777405,
1.0940985679626465,
0.9157301783561707,
-0.4580519199371338,
0.867115318775177,
-0.036535896360874176,
0.207511767745018,
0.5297104120254517,
-0.756644606590271,
0.5106244683265686,
-0.4008732736110687,
0.3167443871498108,
-1.1351524591445923,
-0.4340571165084839,
0.5108432173728943,
-0.3814637362957001,
0.23374004662036896,
-0.06422646343708038,
-0.536426305770874,
-0.4933127164840698,
-0.43230652809143066,
0.37657058238983154,
0.4618620276451111,
-0.5567406415939331,
0.8625454902648926,
0.4340518116950989,
-0.2668236792087555,
-0.44985052943229675,
-0.17866551876068115,
0.34343791007995605,
-0.17959941923618317,
-0.9683960676193237,
0.21159236133098602,
-0.19200004637241364,
-0.44859039783477783,
0.15129142999649048,
0.32479918003082275,
-0.11511288583278656,
0.18129560351371765,
0.14521293342113495,
-0.04009588435292244,
-0.04073503986001015,
0.356616735458374,
-0.056501224637031555,
-0.4439445436000824,
0.027920300140976906,
-0.4911439120769501,
0.8174738883972168,
-0.5044868588447571,
-0.29342398047447205,
-0.39309489727020264,
0.4192076027393341,
0.4890355169773102,
-0.33093103766441345,
0.35465294122695923,
0.4710053503513336,
-0.2500074505805969,
-0.36472442746162415,
-0.293183833360672,
-0.16262148320674896,
-0.6259405016899109,
0.4772011339664459,
-0.6017731428146362,
-1.0143100023269653,
0.6354967951774597,
-0.398722380399704,
-0.047096531838178635,
0.20765915513038635,
0.4986964464187622,
0.004667768254876137,
1.1370131969451904,
0.644340455532074,
-0.2021714150905609,
0.5973760485649109,
-0.062240708619356155,
0.06690111011266708,
-0.34757938981056213,
0.03457029536366463,
-0.7282359600067139,
-0.13496705889701843,
-0.657182514667511,
-0.43561989068984985,
0.5657135248184204,
-0.057901155203580856,
-0.2851496636867523,
0.19023601710796356,
-0.5681313276290894,
0.8706822395324707,
0.4161294400691986,
-0.16499459743499756,
0.052640680223703384,
-0.01773330196738243,
-0.06391653418540955,
0.34713155031204224,
-0.908951997756958,
-0.6143877506256104,
0.6636000871658325,
0.37295061349868774,
0.9941359758377075,
-0.006886232644319534,
0.7001475691795349,
0.46292075514793396,
0.33205446600914,
-0.8439128994941711,
0.756522536277771,
0.22223979234695435,
-0.12633678317070007,
-0.5796756148338318,
-0.6560119986534119,
-1.2768288850784302,
0.16713525354862213,
0.13501304388046265,
-0.7324433326721191,
-0.16190692782402039,
0.09232582151889801,
0.06512366980314255,
0.005970429163426161,
-0.8499614000320435,
0.8661938309669495,
-0.1787116676568985,
-0.08461156487464905,
-0.14716032147407532,
-0.5170389413833618,
-0.13380932807922363,
0.11517730355262756,
0.4343697428703308,
-0.23145896196365356,
-0.04131193831562996,
0.40472283959388733,
-0.7733134627342224,
0.8363391757011414,
-0.272930771112442,
-0.08123882859945297,
0.6211426258087158,
0.11618882417678833,
0.7765955924987793,
-0.4089652895927429,
-0.07481560111045837,
-0.1649521291255951,
-0.4601220488548279,
-0.4766908884048462,
-0.8490468859672546,
0.6083917617797852,
-0.8887187838554382,
-0.8058421015739441,
-0.00863761268556118,
-0.793790876865387,
-0.2293926328420639,
0.2504865527153015,
-0.10669906437397003,
0.5921297073364258,
-0.20379801094532013,
-0.2978101372718811,
0.20845165848731995,
-0.17584989964962006,
0.7190884351730347,
0.3858576714992523,
-0.1261993646621704,
-0.3855886161327362,
0.934395432472229,
-0.08120845258235931,
0.19104614853858948,
0.3477648198604584,
0.2364700883626938,
-0.279550164937973,
-0.397555410861969,
-0.4152159094810486,
0.32664185762405396,
-0.9772443771362305,
-0.09899615496397018,
-0.4721619188785553,
-0.011691969819366932,
-0.43904173374176025,
-0.3729713559150696,
-0.08305833488702774,
-0.22757147252559662,
-0.2283077836036682,
-0.09509547799825668,
0.4424143135547638,
0.6559092998504639,
-0.07883970439434052,
0.5130994915962219,
-0.5675726532936096,
0.01681743748486042,
0.3367970287799835,
0.1700977385044098,
-0.14042630791664124,
0.03102831356227398,
-0.2794094383716583,
-0.1750551164150238,
-0.14261433482170105,
-1.036704659461975,
0.2569997310638428,
0.2115166038274765,
0.8240473866462708,
0.19868552684783936,
-0.011667910031974316,
0.27561116218566895,
-0.5751820206642151,
0.3917613625526428,
0.12152240425348282,
-1.0404222011566162,
0.430215448141098,
-0.6134535670280457,
0.22680972516536713,
0.3498896360397339,
0.22701402008533478,
-0.5972502827644348,
-0.40150344371795654,
-0.12558986246585846,
-0.6671521663665771,
0.7380549907684326,
0.12069191038608551,
0.07003054022789001,
-0.04954567179083824,
0.4370371997356415,
-0.12148904800415039,
0.15046855807304382,
-0.4489873945713043,
-0.28853297233581543,
-0.17158624529838562,
-0.37393176555633545,
-0.13942106068134308,
-0.042597588151693344,
-0.15887725353240967,
0.13005490601062775,
0.5182895660400391,
-0.6004107594490051,
0.1474015712738037,
0.013413039036095142,
-0.16743816435337067,
-0.1385682076215744,
0.2221713662147522,
0.5248053669929504,
0.902734637260437,
0.15226133167743683,
0.303821325302124,
0.05288074165582657,
-0.16249996423721313,
0.41335541009902954,
0.16401013731956482,
-0.08454366028308868,
-0.16908542811870575,
0.40278270840644836,
0.8024176955223083,
-0.3033885657787323,
-0.7211067080497742,
0.10878033936023712,
-0.029171500355005264,
0.11499754339456558,
-0.13235387206077576,
0.28986048698425293,
0.23355822265148163,
0.5742699503898621,
0.3687889873981476,
-0.3150351643562317,
0.13115395605564117,
-0.6568834185600281,
0.136885404586792,
0.5581469535827637,
-0.2216644436120987,
-0.19981157779693604,
0.5312672257423401,
0.6600069999694824,
-0.9129605293273926,
0.5402519702911377,
-0.4633654057979584,
-0.6126759648323059,
0.7901203036308289,
0.4671127200126648,
1.0578407049179077,
-0.2877778708934784,
0.4302513301372528,
-0.071003757417202,
0.3154159486293793,
0.31594568490982056,
0.09697139263153076,
0.026758616790175438,
-0.7382376194000244,
-0.5934728384017944,
-0.2521057426929474,
-0.5057896375656128,
-0.4728366732597351,
0.14200235903263092,
0.3795645236968994,
-0.3990631401538849,
-0.3115021884441376,
-0.047883231192827225,
0.018158474937081337,
-0.5020170211791992,
-0.18129798769950867,
0.024906696751713753,
0.6334375143051147,
-0.7010015845298767,
0.466961532831192,
0.8835598826408386,
-0.3500784635543823,
-0.7996389865875244,
-0.16968350112438202,
-0.05751435458660126,
-0.9647568464279175,
0.4521154463291168,
0.17351524531841278,
-0.5245600938796997,
0.21326403319835663,
-0.6035833358764648,
-0.7575106620788574,
1.0682624578475952,
0.7417183518409729,
-0.4913576543331146,
0.004016629420220852,
0.277330607175827,
0.565898597240448,
-0.585181713104248,
0.6269145011901855,
0.4328976571559906,
0.5698373317718506,
0.08085472136735916,
-0.9891243577003479,
0.18528755009174347,
-0.37039729952812195,
-0.04820738732814789,
0.37910252809524536,
-0.8006948828697205,
0.8499273657798767,
-0.3082052171230316,
-0.358999639749527,
-0.12804414331912994,
0.45738181471824646,
0.17281357944011688,
0.4376983642578125,
0.6150343418121338,
0.22630612552165985,
1.0032012462615967,
-0.11676756292581558,
1.0877183675765991,
-0.5521532893180847,
0.30772045254707336,
0.735712468624115,
-0.16632717847824097,
-0.1340152770280838,
0.2432219535112381,
-0.12026015669107437,
0.4202636778354645,
0.7455379962921143,
0.27299296855926514,
0.2725399136543274,
0.47999438643455505,
-0.11472635716199875,
-0.2989951968193054,
-0.46840932965278625,
-0.18682648241519928,
0.19515739381313324,
0.21257981657981873,
0.02297275885939598,
-0.37438932061195374,
-0.07044956088066101,
0.16678504645824432,
0.10266264528036118,
-0.3815014660358429,
0.6733933091163635,
0.01005496270954609,
-0.5353757739067078,
0.6339805722236633,
0.09775853902101517,
0.30784711241722107,
-0.3407931923866272,
0.05030336603522301,
-0.32019296288490295,
-0.2088523954153061,
-0.24295155704021454,
-0.548859179019928,
0.1159130111336708,
-0.18189379572868347,
0.03860849887132645,
-0.1563502997159958,
0.9763532280921936,
-0.3276311755180359,
-0.15124598145484924,
0.30622437596321106,
0.7920411229133606,
0.35067981481552124,
-0.07281660288572311,
-0.7381008267402649,
0.1534533053636551,
-0.17901986837387085,
-0.19825565814971924,
-0.0777256041765213,
0.6113699674606323,
-0.2113550454378128,
1.0564712285995483,
0.5052059292793274,
-0.07934442907571793,
-0.22384795546531677,
0.4220290780067444,
1.1711794137954712,
-0.7336916327476501,
-0.748235285282135,
-1.0588772296905518,
0.2728591859340668,
-0.04896765574812889,
0.13854849338531494,
0.4773033857345581,
0.2779313027858734,
0.32597440481185913,
0.090424545109272,
0.7451707720756531,
0.2188473641872406,
0.20094771683216095,
-0.4723074734210968,
0.50426185131073,
-0.386788010597229,
0.14600326120853424,
-0.35273733735084534,
-1.1618247032165527,
-0.05532220005989075,
0.27059924602508545,
-0.04435061290860176,
0.24510470032691956,
0.4955821931362152,
1.0382510423660278,
0.3048863410949707,
-0.1460079699754715,
0.18380127847194672,
0.12543007731437683,
0.7020189762115479,
0.688880980014801,
1.2104145288467407,
0.25157326459884644,
0.5733751654624939,
0.12900696694850922,
-0.47355470061302185,
-0.26955747604370117,
-0.7034204006195068,
-1.1154859066009521,
-0.501373827457428,
-0.3296906352043152,
-0.10947846621274948,
0.11706224083900452,
1.1283031702041626,
0.5916022658348083,
-0.32019633054733276,
-0.4196220934391022,
-0.19233915209770203,
0.6137626767158508,
0.048871204257011414,
-0.24957707524299622,
0.18730777502059937,
-0.7561046481132507,
-0.839802622795105,
0.7581380009651184,
0.37013375759124756,
0.043864794075489044,
-0.41075804829597473,
-0.47037363052368164,
0.37539154291152954,
0.22522081434726715,
0.5424522161483765,
0.3867740333080292,
-0.4078821539878845,
-0.26237305998802185,
0.0750560536980629,
-0.1715492159128189,
0.11640122532844543,
0.9149983525276184,
-0.6125842928886414,
0.4426042437553406,
0.635701596736908,
0.7661840915679932,
0.21402870118618011,
0.15400108695030212,
0.6705721020698547,
-0.6232956647872925,
0.16437968611717224,
0.15847419202327728,
0.3672786355018616,
0.30954256653785706,
-0.27169716358184814,
0.6663666367530823,
0.2426341027021408,
-0.6209785342216492,
-0.8000024557113647,
0.5194240808486938,
-0.7405369877815247,
-0.43306997418403625,
1.0328619480133057,
0.0610915943980217,
-0.38860806822776794,
-0.19780629873275757,
-0.3799729347229004,
0.2442123144865036,
-0.6497220993041992,
0.5105812549591064,
0.5497079491615295,
-0.5720435976982117,
-0.19715867936611176,
-0.16844405233860016,
0.5935006141662598,
0.13705764710903168,
-1.1005353927612305,
-0.008868370205163956,
0.7021034359931946,
0.09097987413406372,
0.3064207136631012,
1.0084953308105469,
0.2469784915447235,
0.031304992735385895,
0.0021304418332874775,
0.18799622356891632,
-0.5541486740112305,
-0.49495211243629456,
-0.19579853117465973,
0.11777932196855545,
0.3251684308052063,
-0.05000504478812218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16822v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16822v1
|
Rainbow Teaming: Open-Ended Generation of Diverse Adversarial Prompts
| 2024-02-26T18:47:27 | 2024-02-26T18:47:27 |
Mikayel Samvelyan, Sharath Chandra Raparthy, Andrei Lupu, Eric Hambro, Aram H. Markosyan, Manish Bhatt, Yuning Mao, Minqi Jiang, Jack Parker-Holder, Jakob Foerster, Tim Rocktäschel, Roberta Raileanu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly prevalent across many
real-world applications, understanding and enhancing their robustness to user
inputs is of paramount importance. Existing methods for identifying adversarial
prompts tend to focus on specific domains, lack diversity, or require extensive
human annotations. To address these limitations, we present Rainbow Teaming, a
novel approach for producing a diverse collection of adversarial prompts.
Rainbow Teaming casts adversarial prompt generation as a quality-diversity
problem, and uses open-ended search to generate prompts that are both effective
and diverse. It can uncover a model's vulnerabilities across a broad range of
domains including, in this paper, safety, question answering, and
cybersecurity. We also demonstrate that fine-tuning on synthetic data generated
by Rainbow Teaming improves the safety of state-of-the-art LLMs without hurting
their general capabilities and helpfulness, paving the path to open-ended
self-improvement.
|
[
-0.7155597805976868,
-1.0108124017715454,
0.16730406880378723,
0.23175136744976044,
0.18227729201316833,
0.3675236105918884,
-0.10332253575325012,
-0.3237195909023285,
-0.1621152013540268,
0.4503328204154968,
-0.9454571008682251,
-0.40983083844184875,
-0.420081228017807,
0.237337127327919,
-0.2815714180469513,
1.2666751146316528,
0.017937079071998596,
0.03708825260400772,
0.14791540801525116,
-0.2163771241903305,
-0.5242950916290283,
-0.439609557390213,
-0.7397213578224182,
-0.014640548266470432,
0.8565474152565002,
0.3795551061630249,
1.1066842079162598,
0.48362523317337036,
0.3677554428577423,
0.3387150466442108,
-0.08330678194761276,
0.4963166117668152,
-0.8391236066818237,
0.5189893245697021,
-0.35194098949432373,
-0.44281241297721863,
0.03603718429803848,
0.12562496960163116,
0.4556766748428345,
0.5564545392990112,
0.08515127003192902,
0.04203000292181969,
0.14571349322795868,
0.45731857419013977,
-0.6474570631980896,
-0.45525848865509033,
-0.86545729637146,
0.29015806317329407,
-0.219673752784729,
-0.3847316801548004,
-0.3655173182487488,
-0.28871190547943115,
0.1825314462184906,
-0.725537896156311,
0.31410521268844604,
0.23904047906398773,
0.5093837976455688,
0.13392841815948486,
-0.3146986663341522,
-0.37129929661750793,
-0.6595653295516968,
0.6145406365394592,
-0.18094785511493683,
-0.052172109484672546,
-0.02145303227007389,
0.7472465634346008,
-0.5675031542778015,
-0.47469013929367065,
-0.5227764248847961,
-0.013373835012316704,
0.39175596833229065,
0.12744124233722687,
-0.4287545084953308,
0.007449472788721323,
0.055563077330589294,
0.32835954427719116,
-0.759213924407959,
0.4005640149116516,
-0.29810941219329834,
-0.15701431035995483,
0.6624352931976318,
0.36227142810821533,
0.8131192922592163,
0.3008212149143219,
-0.5459344387054443,
-0.04625339061021805,
-0.7212179899215698,
0.20082424581050873,
0.6122123599052429,
0.5977509617805481,
0.002241673180833459,
0.6939452290534973,
0.011819769628345966,
0.4995976686477661,
-0.09135754406452179,
0.21618129312992096,
-0.19148854911327362,
-0.28391408920288086,
-0.06440476328134537,
-0.18714824318885803,
0.8129292130470276,
0.4480151832103729,
0.2434530109167099,
-0.45224428176879883,
-0.2901650667190552,
-0.00824170932173729,
0.3066067099571228,
-0.4579489231109619,
-0.1987319141626358,
0.41939663887023926,
-0.32527655363082886,
-0.4374391436576843,
-0.06743942946195602,
-0.8904812932014465,
-0.8279799818992615,
-0.08454634994268417,
0.24970217049121857,
-0.42066851258277893,
-0.046435046941041946,
-0.20254234969615936,
-0.5608320236206055,
-0.012227778322994709,
0.20198765397071838,
-0.8161609768867493,
-0.04352622851729393,
0.65152508020401,
0.6884532570838928,
-0.23397697508335114,
-0.6231694221496582,
-0.9243390560150146,
-0.08247905969619751,
-0.31215864419937134,
0.4727771580219269,
-0.24674755334854126,
-0.32686540484428406,
-0.005300571676343679,
-0.4744452238082886,
0.3526792824268341,
-0.5352703332901001,
0.05870781093835831,
-0.7178320288658142,
0.492832750082016,
-0.3111293315887451,
-0.21354562044143677,
0.15580853819847107,
0.33072274923324585,
-0.6196749806404114,
0.6364014148712158,
0.22273167967796326,
-0.6278077363967896,
0.2720610797405243,
-0.8372119069099426,
-0.29463624954223633,
0.4499778747558594,
-0.17393243312835693,
-0.23505452275276184,
-0.18265435099601746,
0.34885266423225403,
0.16369317471981049,
-0.44703879952430725,
0.21014712750911713,
-0.6188876628875732,
-0.15416212379932404,
0.5102226734161377,
-0.3643918037414551,
1.1804403066635132,
0.2436310201883316,
-0.3724987506866455,
0.5512972474098206,
-0.4042463004589081,
-0.05140450969338417,
0.12187755852937698,
-0.22291716933250427,
-0.0832715854048729,
-0.3821992576122284,
-0.0458679124712944,
0.2029327005147934,
0.2320581078529358,
-0.5211836099624634,
0.08444797247648239,
-0.34019505977630615,
0.23497658967971802,
1.081608533859253,
-0.1062684953212738,
0.3921099901199341,
-0.4342438578605652,
0.8090813159942627,
-0.030323514714837074,
0.5310937762260437,
-0.1256512552499771,
-0.7323901653289795,
-0.3179207444190979,
-0.5484872460365295,
0.23521049320697784,
0.8025893568992615,
-1.2485605478286743,
0.42732006311416626,
0.14237624406814575,
-0.43101435899734497,
-0.6134638786315918,
0.4072208106517792,
0.45634907484054565,
0.529310405254364,
0.36013367772102356,
0.28221631050109863,
-0.6705600619316101,
-0.8829914331436157,
-0.43007737398147583,
0.035309799015522,
-0.1677141636610031,
0.46233707666397095,
0.45331132411956787,
-0.4008554220199585,
1.0121325254440308,
-0.3628791570663452,
-0.0024887246545404196,
-0.3111705482006073,
0.23993177711963654,
-0.05655624344944954,
0.21643976867198944,
0.5274795293807983,
-0.9465975165367126,
-0.40842926502227783,
-0.25579607486724854,
-0.945995569229126,
-0.11711198836565018,
-0.18176522850990295,
-0.36430615186691284,
0.05755285918712616,
0.2893357276916504,
-0.34935784339904785,
0.011378028430044651,
0.7189175486564636,
-0.6421350836753845,
0.462268590927124,
-0.02564224600791931,
0.1708345115184784,
-1.0707346200942993,
-0.03464185819029808,
-0.019171489402651787,
-0.12929673492908478,
-0.7330422401428223,
0.48393529653549194,
-0.1615152508020401,
-0.5198055505752563,
-0.577143669128418,
0.6796777248382568,
-0.28479793667793274,
0.010226255282759666,
-0.16509909927845,
0.26948630809783936,
-0.27412328124046326,
0.3324034512042999,
-0.4439200162887573,
0.97868812084198,
0.7488627433776855,
-0.5027063488960266,
0.8387579917907715,
0.18710032105445862,
-0.02206592820584774,
0.44762393832206726,
-0.5395442843437195,
-0.11167039722204208,
-0.18492969870567322,
0.2104814052581787,
-0.8911579251289368,
-0.2503198981285095,
0.2956693172454834,
-0.49160653352737427,
0.09431463479995728,
0.13522250950336456,
-0.5839501619338989,
-0.3761924207210541,
-0.47964563965797424,
0.4913155436515808,
0.5311936140060425,
-0.957524836063385,
0.33416369557380676,
0.5241294503211975,
-0.21931159496307373,
-0.7045720219612122,
-0.6557654142379761,
0.3300369083881378,
-0.2622509300708771,
-0.9630898833274841,
0.20492351055145264,
-0.19475267827510834,
-0.3433094620704651,
-0.1939627230167389,
0.21908988058567047,
-0.02781934291124344,
0.5498335361480713,
0.19028322398662567,
0.39506664872169495,
-0.20890295505523682,
-0.029151316732168198,
-0.25026413798332214,
0.11044763773679733,
-0.11683520674705505,
-0.2227400541305542,
0.5564186573028564,
-0.2547602951526642,
-0.24292656779289246,
0.030741969123482704,
0.8307923674583435,
0.4352525770664215,
-0.2985701262950897,
0.8409373164176941,
0.6468999981880188,
-0.3700847327709198,
-0.7463952898979187,
-0.22194384038448334,
-0.16107608377933502,
-0.5752610564231873,
0.06450802087783813,
-0.015266643837094307,
-1.2599022388458252,
0.6637431979179382,
0.11623860895633698,
0.2846352756023407,
0.19411562383174896,
0.5837889313697815,
-0.1397681087255478,
1.1064441204071045,
0.4430660605430603,
0.06479275971651077,
0.41404083371162415,
0.019965417683124542,
0.08720915764570236,
-0.5244563221931458,
-0.2602132260799408,
-0.1834900826215744,
-0.4049350619316101,
-0.5354057550430298,
-0.21629396080970764,
0.7243250608444214,
0.1893526166677475,
-0.33861830830574036,
0.11936227977275848,
-0.43487855792045593,
0.5881035327911377,
0.8795102834701538,
0.28341978788375854,
-0.21567222476005554,
-0.12794211506843567,
-0.113436758518219,
0.13100814819335938,
-0.7427287697792053,
-0.28674766421318054,
1.083662986755371,
0.3975386321544647,
0.49575406312942505,
0.4268379509449005,
0.8348366022109985,
0.32767951488494873,
0.21974140405654907,
-0.34267720580101013,
0.5899231433868408,
-0.2274961620569229,
-0.6095606088638306,
-0.6335263848304749,
-0.8354905247688293,
-1.2491382360458374,
0.15837529301643372,
-0.3245333731174469,
-0.5503251552581787,
-0.26055672764778137,
0.15054070949554443,
-0.6934313178062439,
0.3428967297077179,
-0.4332774877548218,
0.8027210831642151,
-0.33389976620674133,
-0.07244229316711426,
0.2368718385696411,
-0.5153650045394897,
0.7121793627738953,
-0.05877946317195892,
0.18427394330501556,
0.1295374482870102,
-0.15888172388076782,
0.40668243169784546,
-0.3512381911277771,
0.8624093532562256,
-0.09639996290206909,
-0.2637924551963806,
0.3748074471950531,
0.14740274846553802,
0.4283647835254669,
0.05944003164768219,
-0.07506009191274643,
-0.003622754942625761,
-0.8092555999755859,
-0.4365557134151459,
-0.6701327562332153,
0.6703956723213196,
-0.6790735721588135,
-0.6608407497406006,
-0.20833535492420197,
-0.923495352268219,
-0.28509095311164856,
0.11993589252233505,
0.4224056899547577,
0.3433864712715149,
-0.22618764638900757,
0.06881219893693924,
0.8409656882286072,
-0.5711967945098877,
0.5770313143730164,
0.3185003399848938,
-0.08268938213586807,
-0.7859163880348206,
1.0069985389709473,
-0.08734722435474396,
0.25723615288734436,
0.11630961298942566,
0.06277884542942047,
-0.36177659034729004,
-0.604132890701294,
-0.7117096185684204,
-0.10277289897203445,
-0.7922409772872925,
-0.339048832654953,
-0.37102341651916504,
-0.08318499475717545,
-0.4914872646331787,
-0.48033618927001953,
-0.010036783292889595,
-0.35680529475212097,
-0.44606325030326843,
0.16258029639720917,
0.42259299755096436,
0.44817084074020386,
-0.012623879127204418,
0.13625900447368622,
-0.8418627977371216,
0.6513276696205139,
0.6984196305274963,
0.2821367681026459,
-0.32955828309059143,
-0.13351187109947205,
0.0975925400853157,
0.18991412222385406,
-0.3880763351917267,
-1.0238534212112427,
0.3392806053161621,
-0.031753670424222946,
0.8201830983161926,
-0.0029045725241303444,
0.29611703753471375,
0.33869656920433044,
-0.23343414068222046,
1.058284044265747,
0.5447551012039185,
-0.9566441178321838,
0.6681743860244751,
-0.6990779042243958,
0.33021944761276245,
0.3882380425930023,
0.4000382423400879,
-0.28703242540359497,
-0.596397876739502,
-0.4794265329837799,
-0.8662989735603333,
0.5451817512512207,
0.4169355630874634,
-0.23901018500328064,
-0.04877340421080589,
-0.08425240218639374,
0.0009524456108920276,
0.16278275847434998,
-0.5937963128089905,
-0.463168740272522,
-0.24119795858860016,
-0.2611342668533325,
-0.04872196912765503,
0.1675236076116562,
-0.5349506139755249,
0.2942127287387848,
0.5219547152519226,
-0.24957554042339325,
-0.15912245213985443,
0.0038814342115074396,
0.037369001656770706,
-0.2496955543756485,
0.29513972997665405,
0.6382637619972229,
0.22538740932941437,
0.36590272188186646,
0.19513770937919617,
0.27115634083747864,
0.033251818269491196,
0.07439599931240082,
0.15882986783981323,
-0.27684286236763,
-0.2134033590555191,
0.32855772972106934,
0.5777209997177124,
-0.06220267340540886,
-0.9335674047470093,
0.46916505694389343,
-0.141495943069458,
-0.023937314748764038,
0.06984230875968933,
0.3787955641746521,
-0.12784408032894135,
0.5136451125144958,
0.49840211868286133,
0.24522119760513306,
0.22224979102611542,
-0.8346878290176392,
0.3228374719619751,
0.7950702905654907,
-0.057809583842754364,
0.1613491326570511,
0.6011610627174377,
0.40385422110557556,
-0.5852168202400208,
0.4763696789741516,
-0.2688688337802887,
-0.7872076034545898,
0.6603088974952698,
0.45634788274765015,
1.0057579278945923,
-0.3608482778072357,
0.2947933077812195,
-0.027865195646882057,
0.3193255364894867,
0.01535172387957573,
0.4510745406150818,
0.10444055497646332,
-0.5422888398170471,
0.09134619683027267,
-0.33155950903892517,
-0.531528115272522,
0.15174882113933563,
-0.40359288454055786,
0.24196113646030426,
-0.6399326324462891,
-0.058139365166425705,
0.050369177013635635,
-0.2800617516040802,
-0.38172775506973267,
0.23647189140319824,
0.3942037522792816,
0.819528341293335,
-0.595511257648468,
0.18726585805416107,
0.4505312442779541,
-0.4194744825363159,
-0.4023761451244354,
-0.12511272728443146,
0.1074516549706459,
-0.8046610951423645,
0.5538879632949829,
0.1570013165473938,
-0.06146418675780296,
-0.2818869352340698,
-0.5837633609771729,
-0.5427885055541992,
1.0204966068267822,
0.545107901096344,
-0.3968300223350525,
-0.07747407257556915,
0.42487481236457825,
0.5021696090698242,
-0.3631448447704315,
0.10463477671146393,
0.09603812545537949,
0.35274794697761536,
-0.03272494301199913,
-0.865782618522644,
0.2165602743625641,
-0.3720233738422394,
-0.011233271099627018,
0.09871692210435867,
-0.5608015060424805,
1.176937460899353,
-0.28973332047462463,
-0.4014657437801361,
-0.034027643501758575,
0.7169389724731445,
0.6852070093154907,
0.31734421849250793,
0.5819149613380432,
0.26081573963165283,
0.9977232813835144,
0.008779441937804222,
0.9622882008552551,
-0.1355496346950531,
-0.1747918725013733,
0.9361059665679932,
-0.11536668241024017,
0.4180441200733185,
0.26345929503440857,
0.18462011218070984,
0.1634126901626587,
0.5466800928115845,
-0.30310875177383423,
0.3557385802268982,
0.43496739864349365,
-0.5295522212982178,
-0.4021355211734772,
-0.032105930149555206,
-0.2701486051082611,
0.14544324576854706,
0.214935302734375,
-0.47740718722343445,
-0.42252403497695923,
0.2503175735473633,
-0.2683068811893463,
0.1691548079252243,
-0.48128747940063477,
0.8143543004989624,
-0.11207265406847,
-0.9835037589073181,
0.7905346751213074,
-0.10660790652036667,
0.9544341564178467,
-0.4679125249385834,
0.08705756813287735,
-0.023168493062257767,
0.024803942069411278,
-0.1453581154346466,
-1.1423639059066772,
0.0632961094379425,
0.23117464780807495,
-0.2588553726673126,
-0.29249536991119385,
0.45737624168395996,
-0.5033212900161743,
-0.12296054512262344,
0.21304106712341309,
0.21183522045612335,
-0.17964521050453186,
-0.1442481130361557,
-0.777240514755249,
-0.12545527517795563,
-0.012173635885119438,
-0.013147742487490177,
0.3584028482437134,
0.5239277482032776,
0.0968618392944336,
1.0224533081054688,
0.9097802639007568,
0.06476005911827087,
0.3309977948665619,
-0.056114714592695236,
0.8737776279449463,
-0.44884809851646423,
-0.5898894667625427,
-0.9572560787200928,
0.634331464767456,
-0.2441670000553131,
-0.7263909578323364,
0.8948598504066467,
0.4978761374950409,
0.574104368686676,
-0.0040773446671664715,
1.0865521430969238,
0.4121744930744171,
0.3893764019012451,
-0.39120903611183167,
0.7693192362785339,
-0.3460386097431183,
0.3258801996707916,
0.032014261931180954,
-0.4646173119544983,
-0.29852837324142456,
0.07108109444379807,
0.1021663099527359,
-0.020287785679101944,
0.24467752873897552,
0.7878567576408386,
0.09190046042203903,
0.38300439715385437,
0.2587875723838806,
-0.09315527975559235,
0.5310566425323486,
0.6804830431938171,
1.05506432056427,
-0.2767128348350525,
0.9386863112449646,
0.022601205855607986,
-0.5078960657119751,
-0.12022118270397186,
-0.6663650274276733,
-1.1736268997192383,
-0.4083854556083679,
-0.2693014442920685,
-0.5083746910095215,
0.24762652814388275,
0.8455604910850525,
0.421695739030838,
-0.7667468190193176,
0.08481325209140778,
-0.3068431317806244,
0.20747986435890198,
0.058458372950553894,
-0.22920747101306915,
-0.1922718584537506,
-0.6222245693206787,
-0.3916301131248474,
0.72932368516922,
0.0818452388048172,
0.3048192262649536,
-0.5931329727172852,
-0.15395142138004303,
0.18810983002185822,
0.17400352656841278,
0.48754143714904785,
0.4688248634338379,
-0.7328919172286987,
-0.03880930319428444,
0.08406302332878113,
-0.27440565824508667,
-0.39794501662254333,
0.6930651068687439,
-0.5382681488990784,
0.32427510619163513,
0.6020990610122681,
0.9557700157165527,
-0.2310090959072113,
-0.14964815974235535,
1.0775803327560425,
-0.9132657051086426,
-0.33688580989837646,
0.45728036761283875,
0.33455216884613037,
0.3678811192512512,
-0.5793837904930115,
0.29727447032928467,
0.05404992774128914,
-0.49139922857284546,
-1.0917834043502808,
0.4937603175640106,
-0.7139617204666138,
-0.6794290542602539,
1.3202227354049683,
-0.2567012906074524,
-0.16224952042102814,
-0.2533087134361267,
-0.3067066967487335,
0.3680279552936554,
-0.3477790653705597,
0.9098497033119202,
0.46622154116630554,
-0.011145070195198059,
-0.043124567717313766,
0.09347791224718094,
0.5705165266990662,
0.2777703106403351,
-1.0182000398635864,
0.27372413873672485,
0.4317094385623932,
0.031493935734033585,
0.19189774990081787,
0.19982850551605225,
0.2651382088661194,
0.6590980291366577,
0.10646212100982666,
-0.22067822515964508,
-0.3315485417842865,
-0.603835940361023,
-0.42295753955841064,
0.5893004536628723,
-0.3357263505458832,
-0.15674638748168945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16819v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16819v2
|
Nemotron-4 15B Technical Report
| 2024-02-26T18:43:45 | 2024-02-27T15:22:57 |
Jupinder Parmar, Shrimai Prabhumoye, Joseph Jennings, Mostofa Patwary, Sandeep Subramanian, Dan Su, Chen Zhu, Deepak Narayanan, Aastha Jhunjhunwala, Ayush Dattagupta, Vibhu Jawa, Jiwei Liu, Ameya Mahabaleshwarkar, Osvald Nitski, Annika Brundyn, James Maki, Miguel Martinez, Jiaxuan You, John Kamalu, Patrick LeGresley, Denys Fridman, Jared Casper, Ashwath Aithal, Oleksii Kuchaiev, Mohammad Shoeybi, Jonathan Cohen, Bryan Catanzaro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce Nemotron-4 15B, a 15-billion-parameter large multilingual
language model trained on 8 trillion text tokens. Nemotron-4 15B demonstrates
strong performance when assessed on English, multilingual, and coding tasks: it
outperforms all existing similarly-sized open models on 4 out of 7 downstream
evaluation areas and achieves competitive performance to the leading open
models in the remaining ones. Specifically, Nemotron-4 15B exhibits the best
multilingual capabilities of all similarly-sized models, even outperforming
models over four times larger and those explicitly specialized for multilingual
tasks.
|
[
-0.517406165599823,
-0.5325036644935608,
0.38312068581581116,
0.5199272036552429,
-0.08535183221101761,
0.0760413259267807,
-0.26393958926200867,
-0.8462188839912415,
0.06653700023889542,
0.4405031204223633,
-0.3443029820919037,
-0.3094462454319,
-0.6577212810516357,
0.604892373085022,
-0.35517916083335876,
1.0314996242523193,
0.2548312842845917,
0.5202120542526245,
0.11549973487854004,
0.026469970121979713,
-0.3168070614337921,
-0.7362719774246216,
-0.6705557703971863,
-0.49504101276397705,
0.902241587638855,
0.6566857099533081,
0.5467578768730164,
0.5821157097816467,
1.0329478979110718,
0.3117251992225647,
-0.2004789412021637,
0.0496218167245388,
-0.2917039096355438,
-0.18603716790676117,
-0.20082108676433563,
0.04450390487909317,
-0.8883376121520996,
-0.10928816348314285,
0.8937457203865051,
0.5324000120162964,
-0.35288119316101074,
0.17363956570625305,
-0.14679020643234253,
0.2670121490955353,
-0.2664780914783478,
-0.058591749519109726,
-0.4356558918952942,
-0.10344745963811874,
-0.3490092158317566,
0.010318901389837265,
-0.6300795078277588,
-0.10017484426498413,
-0.19392110407352448,
-0.5015887022018433,
0.17566828429698944,
0.24150674045085907,
1.3207937479019165,
-0.25499194860458374,
-0.7191362977027893,
-0.09556343406438828,
-0.4185149669647217,
1.0912034511566162,
-0.8767973184585571,
0.8607909083366394,
0.28936639428138733,
0.43860483169555664,
0.21042336523532867,
-1.1118942499160767,
-0.4089849889278412,
-0.44555342197418213,
0.18420828878879547,
-0.044789962470531464,
-0.2070303112268448,
0.07363025844097137,
0.18833152949810028,
0.3166061043739319,
-0.6480002403259277,
0.47109857201576233,
-0.7410419583320618,
-0.3730992376804352,
0.45808860659599304,
0.16959542036056519,
0.3750770390033722,
-0.3168712854385376,
-0.32767418026924133,
0.08051659166812897,
-0.6013246178627014,
-0.47129106521606445,
0.7395687103271484,
0.4629803001880646,
-0.2834043502807617,
0.3827604353427887,
-0.3493238091468811,
1.0207109451293945,
-0.006407341919839382,
-0.005565928760915995,
0.5127639770507812,
-0.7426842451095581,
-0.055498868227005005,
-0.1343909651041031,
0.8615536689758301,
0.19639484584331512,
-0.1293788105249405,
-0.026025040075182915,
-0.4350675940513611,
-0.3473604917526245,
0.4482285976409912,
-1.3824015855789185,
-0.11707069724798203,
-0.02744588628411293,
-0.6591218113899231,
-0.11638691276311874,
-0.1470547765493393,
-0.8806049227714539,
-0.033087510615587234,
-0.35127314925193787,
0.43250665068626404,
-0.5464772582054138,
-0.17529909312725067,
0.11735599488019943,
-0.06628279387950897,
0.15015548467636108,
0.3376408517360687,
-1.3752304315567017,
0.6569972038269043,
0.43202394247055054,
1.0120552778244019,
-0.12693071365356445,
-0.7201146483421326,
-0.6619912981987,
-0.07925905287265778,
-0.5188990831375122,
0.9693816304206848,
-0.7149670124053955,
-0.019529981538653374,
-0.3749631643295288,
0.252816379070282,
-0.1332382708787918,
-0.5257251858711243,
0.5092724561691284,
-0.4786878228187561,
0.18671226501464844,
-0.056439030915498734,
-0.29606565833091736,
-0.5673936605453491,
0.5891459584236145,
-1.0165807008743286,
0.9300202131271362,
0.062480684369802475,
-0.5610767602920532,
0.41599056124687195,
-0.7710533738136292,
-0.24845142662525177,
0.31718307733535767,
-0.005697735585272312,
-0.30900391936302185,
-0.05195729061961174,
0.012638328596949577,
0.5146138668060303,
-0.7382739186286926,
0.34376004338264465,
-0.18383948504924774,
-0.21583402156829834,
0.012793502770364285,
-0.356440931558609,
0.5555391907691956,
0.3793019652366638,
-0.2040349245071411,
0.24034206569194794,
-0.6339682936668396,
-0.21710056066513062,
0.04536417871713638,
-0.34861308336257935,
0.2009228616952896,
-0.8091483116149902,
0.1888568103313446,
0.4758232533931732,
0.5611045956611633,
-0.9769802689552307,
-0.2546349763870239,
-0.36073964834213257,
0.4893496334552765,
0.3359766900539398,
-0.038463130593299866,
0.5326550602912903,
-0.23821070790290833,
1.016486644744873,
-0.09432704001665115,
0.14383380115032196,
-0.40814438462257385,
-0.6437199115753174,
-0.3251516819000244,
-0.31085115671157837,
0.39343512058258057,
0.23815064132213593,
-0.6177893877029419,
-0.34718000888824463,
-0.0503227524459362,
-0.8559790253639221,
-0.07980282604694366,
0.28544703125953674,
0.4655638039112091,
0.24625031650066376,
0.42087531089782715,
-0.035031091421842575,
-0.43120139837265015,
-1.0873292684555054,
-0.1724492758512497,
0.024256885051727295,
0.3688666522502899,
0.22139595448970795,
0.6796461343765259,
-0.3481312096118927,
-0.061185769736766815,
-0.13701719045639038,
-0.1541304588317871,
-0.7595741748809814,
0.22886008024215698,
0.48965984582901,
0.5166016817092896,
0.7481302618980408,
-0.6465474367141724,
-0.31734222173690796,
0.7363659739494324,
-0.5626128315925598,
-0.007247846107929945,
0.05021623894572258,
-0.12484578788280487,
0.2795615792274475,
0.7445002198219299,
-0.36142104864120483,
-0.20777298510074615,
1.2696453332901,
-0.3033226430416107,
0.32703110575675964,
-0.703072726726532,
0.261437326669693,
-1.1372181177139282,
0.15170957148075104,
-0.044510312378406525,
0.050200361758470535,
-0.5582544207572937,
0.09970753639936447,
0.7056793570518494,
-0.3540325164794922,
-0.5801323652267456,
0.80650794506073,
-0.6790528297424316,
-0.07633449882268906,
-0.070484958589077,
0.13915759325027466,
0.1443585604429245,
0.29928427934646606,
-0.10815700888633728,
0.4878278970718384,
0.3864048421382904,
-0.7283324003219604,
0.8364529609680176,
0.3164200782775879,
-0.21652883291244507,
0.5325818657875061,
-0.764639139175415,
-0.059364669024944305,
0.038397304713726044,
0.09378974884748459,
-0.6698794960975647,
-0.580437421798706,
-0.37969809770584106,
-0.5576863288879395,
0.39199206233024597,
0.044244952499866486,
-0.4059206247329712,
-0.48879683017730713,
-0.10002177953720093,
0.7572330236434937,
0.11343821883201599,
-0.45451775193214417,
0.8189721703529358,
0.30825403332710266,
-0.3638093173503876,
-0.42861393094062805,
-0.9700625538825989,
0.3945879340171814,
-0.114597387611866,
-0.573861837387085,
0.5070244669914246,
0.11133498698472977,
0.1652214378118515,
-0.1028815358877182,
0.3549884557723999,
-0.23955489695072174,
-0.05918579921126366,
0.1692323535680771,
0.2372354120016098,
-0.10559061169624329,
0.16813981533050537,
-0.03991207107901573,
-0.30268946290016174,
-0.11817751824855804,
-0.0522746741771698,
0.7233275771141052,
-0.20599332451820374,
-0.41934219002723694,
-0.4415097236633301,
0.1470315307378769,
0.6253764629364014,
-0.48699015378952026,
0.8294357657432556,
0.5839977264404297,
-0.4474990665912628,
-0.17744962871074677,
-0.3436218202114105,
-0.26424768567085266,
-0.5041496157646179,
0.7810698747634888,
-0.4863933026790619,
-0.825210452079773,
0.6382062435150146,
0.15907976031303406,
0.14777569472789764,
0.43679100275039673,
0.7041344046592712,
0.5634437203407288,
1.1866075992584229,
0.5483245253562927,
0.37029293179512024,
0.5909671783447266,
-0.10238873958587646,
0.4299132525920868,
-0.546657919883728,
-0.8843056559562683,
-0.8306089639663696,
-0.2717675268650055,
-0.6942382454872131,
-0.40895378589630127,
0.23133857548236847,
-0.4097404181957245,
-0.5604473948478699,
0.658305287361145,
-0.2670822739601135,
0.2038315236568451,
0.5941083431243896,
-0.267671138048172,
0.1388595551252365,
-0.4450456202030182,
-0.35910293459892273,
0.04297822713851929,
-0.8945925831794739,
-0.5330845713615417,
1.0313570499420166,
0.36954930424690247,
0.7479657530784607,
0.4762421250343323,
0.67570561170578,
-0.16744963824748993,
0.2716396749019623,
-0.6059123873710632,
0.510212242603302,
-0.19133511185646057,
-1.310481071472168,
-0.33489322662353516,
-0.5050276517868042,
-1.041351079940796,
0.33773767948150635,
-0.06701545417308807,
-0.48234573006629944,
-0.1286875158548355,
0.04520164057612419,
-0.28743642568588257,
0.3453283905982971,
-0.8648494482040405,
1.3522082567214966,
-0.3353380262851715,
-0.18136098980903625,
-0.3043437898159027,
-0.39585283398628235,
0.27211251854896545,
-0.38670864701271057,
0.368420273065567,
-0.259629487991333,
-0.15331533551216125,
0.6943798065185547,
-0.08783518522977829,
0.32359743118286133,
-0.03677946701645851,
-0.013148823752999306,
-0.09986855089664459,
0.029050955548882484,
0.17433936893939972,
0.029686693102121353,
-0.4826783239841461,
0.47753432393074036,
0.12107166647911072,
-0.5514974594116211,
-0.336947500705719,
0.9371069073677063,
-0.7430526614189148,
-0.1469908207654953,
-0.5042253732681274,
-0.5046018958091736,
-0.052660081535577774,
0.5399003624916077,
0.3316441774368286,
1.081074833869934,
-0.31574901938438416,
0.594917893409729,
0.16416287422180176,
-0.7851986885070801,
0.9312136769294739,
0.5570273995399475,
-0.5587897300720215,
-0.7172349095344543,
0.9261011481285095,
0.2579505145549774,
0.48187676072120667,
0.5697458982467651,
0.015282177366316319,
-0.33464136719703674,
-0.7302648425102234,
-0.7365694642066956,
0.5052250623703003,
-0.5399243235588074,
-0.42968013882637024,
-0.9726004600524902,
-0.340469092130661,
-0.44992244243621826,
-0.003062406787648797,
-0.7088288068771362,
-0.23303978145122528,
-0.15395113825798035,
-0.3992651700973511,
0.19847650825977325,
1.156487226486206,
-0.26525911688804626,
0.32612159848213196,
-1.092009425163269,
0.3178839683532715,
0.22031071782112122,
0.4262899160385132,
-0.011486566625535488,
-0.973787784576416,
-0.6662992238998413,
-0.07070817053318024,
-0.5242403745651245,
-0.6356937885284424,
0.7425869107246399,
0.1785106658935547,
0.8113446235656738,
0.4164107143878937,
-0.3650647699832916,
0.5046362280845642,
-0.799308717250824,
0.8822503089904785,
0.27019840478897095,
-1.1983247995376587,
0.11755794286727905,
-0.6324612498283386,
0.5990957617759705,
0.12614142894744873,
0.30667194724082947,
-0.5782672762870789,
-0.25120073556900024,
-0.7374265193939209,
-0.5628936290740967,
0.9815284609794617,
0.07420262694358826,
0.5353329181671143,
-0.3571375012397766,
0.04492417350411415,
0.2917032837867737,
0.18388311564922333,
-0.8572009205818176,
0.32494524121284485,
-0.19721654057502747,
-0.1660960167646408,
-0.26360148191452026,
-0.4023580253124237,
0.255628764629364,
-0.038863442838191986,
0.7923722863197327,
-0.18209514021873474,
0.38903823494911194,
-0.3592086434364319,
0.10045402497053146,
0.12932032346725464,
-0.0009374181972816586,
0.7971661686897278,
0.9303046464920044,
-0.025661630555987358,
0.2626943290233612,
0.6304998397827148,
-0.6391494870185852,
-0.009866932407021523,
0.2804667055606842,
0.3056160509586334,
-0.029670758172869682,
0.6753923296928406,
0.7296122908592224,
0.39284747838974,
-0.7419360876083374,
0.5119822025299072,
-0.07859557121992111,
-0.5577788949012756,
0.02434118092060089,
-0.4477616846561432,
0.253728449344635,
-0.011981277726590633,
0.06828410178422928,
-0.229614719748497,
0.20641563832759857,
-0.3952135443687439,
0.26833462715148926,
0.25657394528388977,
-0.44265565276145935,
-0.6709870100021362,
0.6611790657043457,
0.3202584981918335,
-0.09299673140048981,
0.3283558189868927,
-0.2510511875152588,
-0.4400988221168518,
0.6561827063560486,
0.7273812890052795,
0.4714033603668213,
-0.6642683744430542,
0.3728610873222351,
0.6261435747146606,
0.605150580406189,
-0.22271449863910675,
0.4825672507286072,
0.46101507544517517,
-0.8469657897949219,
-0.6803163886070251,
-0.670867919921875,
-0.7217916250228882,
-0.16936522722244263,
-0.8252299427986145,
0.5338483452796936,
-0.6139086484909058,
-0.297594279050827,
0.29513946175575256,
0.03735443949699402,
-0.5071530938148499,
0.42981821298599243,
0.14200298488140106,
0.8881338834762573,
-0.6608608961105347,
0.7668490409851074,
1.056155800819397,
-0.394945353269577,
-1.1003072261810303,
-0.634590208530426,
-0.11830786615610123,
-0.6710787415504456,
0.9317322969436646,
0.3526841998100281,
-0.21136316657066345,
0.015010329894721508,
-0.37565451860427856,
-1.166814923286438,
0.9623060822486877,
0.7059817314147949,
-0.4221057593822479,
0.122186079621315,
-0.3084182143211365,
0.38164156675338745,
-0.10785461217164993,
0.45462262630462646,
0.1420132964849472,
0.4960367977619171,
0.06154628470540047,
-1.3810874223709106,
-0.20893977582454681,
-0.43693551421165466,
-0.08909370005130768,
0.6196858286857605,
-1.0097728967666626,
1.1951091289520264,
-0.1757175326347351,
0.23732148110866547,
0.13884858787059784,
0.5394207835197449,
0.2364676296710968,
0.25430047512054443,
0.05978568270802498,
0.4922046959400177,
0.8103934526443481,
0.027440138161182404,
1.3751130104064941,
-0.4867303967475891,
0.2349606603384018,
0.8874310255050659,
-0.35948315262794495,
0.6042570471763611,
0.31626075506210327,
0.3262428939342499,
0.6926124095916748,
0.5555354952812195,
0.13215933740139008,
0.3336801826953888,
-0.14234794676303864,
-0.05902609974145889,
-0.2611098885536194,
-0.32436031103134155,
-0.2888883650302887,
0.6194780468940735,
0.10228153318166733,
-0.17067956924438477,
-0.18637371063232422,
0.20445245504379272,
0.20099563896656036,
0.07190204411745071,
-0.3482381999492645,
0.5712462663650513,
0.16096118092536926,
-0.637078583240509,
0.4101119935512543,
0.5191067457199097,
0.41419926285743713,
-0.6160671710968018,
-0.1310271918773651,
-0.2039671689271927,
0.47831109166145325,
-0.11205479502677917,
-0.5233683586120605,
0.2358717918395996,
0.048576295375823975,
0.11038050800561905,
-0.5657452940940857,
0.38474559783935547,
-0.04657362028956413,
-0.5680628418922424,
0.6938701272010803,
0.3684672713279724,
0.1399577558040619,
0.016114698722958565,
-0.43294277787208557,
0.21378403902053833,
-0.1273173987865448,
-0.23149904608726501,
0.3072243630886078,
1.0116260051727295,
-0.049119915813207626,
0.8581889271736145,
0.5392714738845825,
0.14521236717700958,
0.04879457503557205,
0.268012136220932,
0.7231938242912292,
-1.0656678676605225,
-0.6253105998039246,
-0.8005041480064392,
0.1755845695734024,
-0.14775581657886505,
-0.5994516611099243,
1.201749563217163,
0.6867455244064331,
0.8259446620941162,
0.17418931424617767,
0.3626891076564789,
0.11174965649843216,
0.5514899492263794,
-0.4776424467563629,
0.29231932759284973,
-0.6607775688171387,
-0.18452979624271393,
-0.348755419254303,
-1.047737717628479,
-0.5791130065917969,
0.5214588046073914,
-0.3853316605091095,
0.6092530488967896,
1.098355770111084,
0.7590699791908264,
0.04172130301594734,
0.30739879608154297,
0.7485511898994446,
0.04031228646636009,
0.49809953570365906,
0.571125328540802,
0.9990934133529663,
-0.2348974496126175,
0.6758480072021484,
-0.09118041396141052,
-0.08887120336294174,
-0.28573280572891235,
-1.0159097909927368,
-1.0790587663650513,
-0.40127304196357727,
0.0623137429356575,
-0.08004500716924667,
-0.317952424287796,
0.8430549502372742,
0.9301097989082336,
-0.9066381454467773,
-0.42560943961143494,
0.0015124401543289423,
-0.1790066659450531,
-0.1369483470916748,
-0.053155310451984406,
-0.22379742562770844,
-0.34498971700668335,
-1.0225639343261719,
0.41520509123802185,
0.6278688311576843,
0.040636442601680756,
-0.18214967846870422,
-0.4552725553512573,
-0.3684259355068207,
0.2231438159942627,
0.30802467465400696,
-0.20526786148548126,
-0.37544432282447815,
-0.043197665363550186,
0.30264654755592346,
-0.23366281390190125,
-0.3231394588947296,
0.5837496519088745,
-0.2563380002975464,
0.3247763216495514,
0.5479604005813599,
0.6931800246238708,
0.7951301336288452,
-0.09465520828962326,
0.891552209854126,
-0.21962179243564606,
0.4944364130496979,
0.3801339268684387,
0.4333489239215851,
0.6810511350631714,
-0.09768100827932358,
0.2870854139328003,
0.006201865151524544,
-0.7618414163589478,
-0.885905385017395,
0.022771798074245453,
-0.9163471460342407,
-0.3298003375530243,
1.3584845066070557,
-0.034322597086429596,
0.031169485300779343,
0.15105319023132324,
-0.256111204624176,
0.010347402654588223,
-0.44478315114974976,
0.03286424279212952,
0.8031013607978821,
-0.01668737269937992,
-0.31967151165008545,
-0.919033944606781,
0.12341176718473434,
0.41379284858703613,
-0.9063946604728699,
-0.4561786949634552,
0.5981537699699402,
0.027654141187667847,
0.09426549822092056,
0.3708339035511017,
-0.3434044420719147,
0.34846431016921997,
0.30749034881591797,
0.44816839694976807,
-0.21948093175888062,
-0.7487710118293762,
-0.3894442915916443,
0.2841542065143585,
0.31632766127586365,
-0.1838662475347519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16817v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16817v1
|
Investigating the Effectiveness of HyperTuning via Gisting
| 2024-02-26T18:42:26 | 2024-02-26T18:42:26 |
Jason Phang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Gisting (Mu et al., 2023) is a simple method for training models to compress
information into fewer token representations using a modified attention mask,
and can serve as an economical approach to training Transformer-based
hypernetworks. We introduce HyperLlama, a set of Gisting-based hypernetworks
built on Llama-2 models that generates task-specific soft prefixes based on
few-shot inputs. In experiments across P3, Super-NaturalInstructions and Symbol
Tuning datasets, we show that HyperLlama models can effectively compress
information from few-shot examples into soft prefixes. However, they still
underperform multi-task fine-tuned language models with full attention over
few-shot in-context examples. We also show that HyperLlama-generated soft
prefixes can serve as better initializations for further prefix tuning.
Overall, Gisting-based hypernetworks are economical and easy to implement, but
have mixed empirical performance.
|
[
-0.2847617566585541,
-0.696282684803009,
0.22804248332977295,
0.027509799227118492,
-0.42201098799705505,
-0.24874240159988403,
-0.6076862215995789,
-0.3539527654647827,
0.40742215514183044,
0.30373188853263855,
-0.5840750336647034,
-0.27989959716796875,
-0.6571166515350342,
0.21814940869808197,
-0.5105246305465698,
1.1499181985855103,
0.31513863801956177,
-0.33064544200897217,
0.3658938705921173,
-0.03128161281347275,
-0.3369901180267334,
-0.36202800273895264,
-0.40388473868370056,
-0.5291035771369934,
0.7323510050773621,
0.6728672385215759,
1.0850762128829956,
0.9678106904029846,
0.5440483093261719,
0.28413334488868713,
-0.27309495210647583,
0.30625119805336,
-0.7116838693618774,
0.09188925474882126,
0.15104319155216217,
-0.7051994204521179,
-0.2417316734790802,
0.12062381953001022,
0.47085121273994446,
0.530597448348999,
-0.005050606559962034,
0.5739249587059021,
0.34701263904571533,
0.5903512835502625,
-0.8664662837982178,
0.17169855535030365,
-0.9523594379425049,
0.05867023393511772,
-0.4333292245864868,
0.010487462393939495,
-0.14296841621398926,
-0.31332868337631226,
0.05808417499065399,
-0.7177568674087524,
0.35076069831848145,
-0.039825405925512314,
1.4082648754119873,
0.4966121017932892,
0.08128976821899414,
-0.11886656284332275,
-0.6756923198699951,
0.515734851360321,
-0.5854317545890808,
0.1939002424478531,
0.5877385139465332,
0.2848019003868103,
0.034151218831539154,
-0.9349663257598877,
-0.3160535395145416,
0.025746924802660942,
-0.31966230273246765,
0.06457754969596863,
-0.17102289199829102,
0.21983447670936584,
0.6320711374282837,
0.435524046421051,
-0.6288092136383057,
-0.052851270884275436,
-0.320147842168808,
0.06082601100206375,
0.11403461545705795,
0.12887302041053772,
-0.11777900904417038,
-0.2134743332862854,
-0.28321829438209534,
0.06307808309793472,
-0.9392050504684448,
-0.19486910104751587,
0.34928998351097107,
0.3281506896018982,
-0.01064606849104166,
0.5541936755180359,
-0.3456132113933563,
0.6731194853782654,
0.297583669424057,
-0.041545622050762177,
-0.170784592628479,
-0.13370902836322784,
-0.6217811703681946,
-0.08024752140045166,
0.4340805411338806,
0.08454462885856628,
0.7695665955543518,
-0.2748200297355652,
0.05119176208972931,
-0.10862764716148376,
0.26685893535614014,
-0.7464683055877686,
-0.28715288639068604,
-0.07886099815368652,
-0.078973688185215,
-0.3429352343082428,
0.09143632650375366,
-0.5636732578277588,
-0.24303200840950012,
-0.6186410784721375,
0.23955115675926208,
-0.2210354208946228,
-0.1004810631275177,
0.16632011532783508,
-0.08639749884605408,
0.09430035203695297,
0.03464296832680702,
-1.1441165208816528,
0.13816823065280914,
0.8397783041000366,
1.2183023691177368,
0.07365480065345764,
-0.2729015648365021,
-0.4969140887260437,
0.3143516778945923,
-0.31322985887527466,
0.6822776794433594,
-0.3153362572193146,
-0.13846033811569214,
0.09650272876024246,
0.03311749920248985,
-0.04225887730717659,
-0.6172172427177429,
0.11759458482265472,
-0.40273454785346985,
-0.2774587571620941,
-0.008181813172996044,
-0.2505786120891571,
-0.1731836348772049,
0.3408239781856537,
-0.8083878755569458,
1.236743688583374,
0.06947488337755203,
-0.4922736883163452,
0.2754294276237488,
-0.5155383944511414,
-0.40807676315307617,
0.32832080125808716,
0.022976916283369064,
-0.5657742619514465,
0.4549636244773865,
0.006737189367413521,
0.556920051574707,
-0.5205087661743164,
0.32994842529296875,
-0.11253279447555542,
-0.5838529467582703,
0.10865475237369537,
-0.35555458068847656,
0.5270294547080994,
-0.007166782394051552,
-0.6673177480697632,
-0.032832395285367966,
-0.569957435131073,
0.23200291395187378,
0.03870082274079323,
-0.4361993372440338,
-0.3307951092720032,
-0.43806594610214233,
0.18001513183116913,
0.1505199372768402,
-0.04536878317594528,
-0.2546103596687317,
0.4308939576148987,
-0.5331819653511047,
0.3896263539791107,
0.6626334190368652,
-0.33339962363243103,
0.32589101791381836,
-0.27608171105384827,
0.41701996326446533,
-0.08224958181381226,
0.3193756639957428,
-0.15638455748558044,
-0.5321715474128723,
-1.273500919342041,
-0.29762813448905945,
0.43235698342323303,
0.20659905672073364,
-0.8784320950508118,
0.2209078073501587,
-0.41580134630203247,
-0.6444647908210754,
-0.4424305856227875,
0.40114638209342957,
0.5057408809661865,
0.5020884275436401,
0.3370647132396698,
-0.14957940578460693,
-0.461010605096817,
-1.0364576578140259,
-0.10348021984100342,
-0.0035247011110186577,
0.1925654113292694,
-0.09839604794979095,
0.42343080043792725,
-0.1117405891418457,
0.8686923980712891,
-0.6346065402030945,
-0.42194706201553345,
-0.16169878840446472,
0.377292275428772,
0.4219624996185303,
0.35090672969818115,
0.3813151717185974,
-0.5261722207069397,
-0.45209547877311707,
-0.03278502821922302,
-0.7081748247146606,
-0.01582605391740799,
-0.11934737116098404,
-0.19429057836532593,
-0.10606680810451508,
0.1749110370874405,
-0.8133067488670349,
0.5321967601776123,
0.570457398891449,
0.07464377582073212,
0.844457745552063,
-0.02739342860877514,
-0.04002586752176285,
-0.7186755537986755,
0.15779268741607666,
0.26667460799217224,
-0.3267720639705658,
-0.7938029170036316,
0.21468617022037506,
0.255315899848938,
-0.3557910621166229,
-0.6838647723197937,
0.3648050129413605,
-0.7150258421897888,
0.017380302771925926,
-0.6556441783905029,
-0.5043343901634216,
-0.03942699357867241,
0.9456438422203064,
-0.011277716606855392,
0.9706827998161316,
0.5991038084030151,
-0.6344724297523499,
0.36629366874694824,
0.06076294928789139,
-0.4331338107585907,
0.4390612542629242,
-0.9706422090530396,
0.4377441704273224,
-0.02581024542450905,
0.08646462857723236,
-0.6660826802253723,
-0.27399247884750366,
0.36997222900390625,
-0.004429004620760679,
0.18542298674583435,
-0.7203414440155029,
-0.5586114525794983,
-0.40419819951057434,
-0.3278730809688568,
0.33328258991241455,
0.480061411857605,
-0.6157907247543335,
0.4121243953704834,
0.11270402371883392,
-0.14414292573928833,
-0.4528920650482178,
-0.7888484597206116,
0.27574753761291504,
-0.4832456111907959,
-0.424024760723114,
0.2974294126033783,
0.10709734261035919,
0.22174857556819916,
-0.12782789766788483,
-0.01602671481668949,
-0.21831652522087097,
0.2884119749069214,
0.6192942261695862,
0.09170492738485336,
-0.3734765946865082,
0.2529599666595459,
-0.2142794281244278,
-0.4152846336364746,
-0.3374134600162506,
-0.4827086329460144,
0.41168248653411865,
-0.18846356868743896,
-0.19962342083454132,
-0.507745623588562,
0.38890376687049866,
0.5374066829681396,
-0.19971418380737305,
0.40744274854660034,
0.6126119494438171,
-0.6115150451660156,
-0.26989036798477173,
-0.5498343706130981,
-0.3467007875442505,
-0.5506022572517395,
0.23688194155693054,
-0.4815182685852051,
-0.9232840538024902,
0.14822497963905334,
-0.38665345311164856,
0.07785617560148239,
0.17016033828258514,
0.8671920895576477,
-0.0759183019399643,
0.6927125453948975,
0.7507126331329346,
-0.10773573815822601,
0.5654318332672119,
-0.6071127653121948,
-0.15688395500183105,
-0.7429553866386414,
0.13741828501224518,
-0.6191403269767761,
-0.6265156865119934,
-0.2748488783836365,
-0.3463321030139923,
0.5626709461212158,
0.10059116035699844,
-0.18402177095413208,
0.7724442481994629,
-0.5497245788574219,
0.9396969079971313,
0.7425044775009155,
0.0971345454454422,
0.20461878180503845,
0.329901784658432,
0.18953099846839905,
-0.025065023452043533,
-0.9454623460769653,
-0.5517377853393555,
1.0343472957611084,
0.08614715188741684,
1.0198074579238892,
-0.03757033869624138,
0.4386776089668274,
0.15817973017692566,
0.26609569787979126,
-0.936332106590271,
0.2977648973464966,
-0.004512657877057791,
-0.4866099953651428,
-0.3755664527416229,
-0.1251084804534912,
-1.0076525211334229,
0.13603956997394562,
-0.2705901265144348,
-0.678684413433075,
0.16703814268112183,
0.33126553893089294,
-0.5997753739356995,
0.1523103266954422,
-0.6274610161781311,
0.5009610652923584,
-0.05016900599002838,
-0.5654050707817078,
-0.20865057408809662,
-0.3891890347003937,
0.3772337734699249,
-0.09114313125610352,
-0.18884140253067017,
-0.2529224753379822,
0.12464052438735962,
0.8328709602355957,
-0.3546634912490845,
0.9517672657966614,
-0.0021351641044020653,
-0.07855693995952606,
0.31338757276535034,
0.06849054247140884,
0.5374141335487366,
0.20447449386119843,
-0.030319200828671455,
0.3091025650501251,
-0.3993159830570221,
-0.3335804045200348,
-0.7979806661605835,
0.7490857839584351,
-0.5847225189208984,
-0.7992631196975708,
-0.18416231870651245,
-0.5390724539756775,
-0.23595821857452393,
-0.05802352353930473,
0.28571048378944397,
0.5738751292228699,
0.1653347760438919,
0.1547439694404602,
0.5654362440109253,
0.49159157276153564,
0.4965520203113556,
0.1474953442811966,
0.2630513906478882,
-0.2544809877872467,
0.7620345950126648,
0.4472910761833191,
0.04900645837187767,
-0.15583200752735138,
0.2995148003101349,
-0.06445737928152084,
-0.15415145456790924,
-0.6138904690742493,
0.4397676885128021,
-0.6094006896018982,
-0.5821965932846069,
-0.2178734689950943,
-0.21693173050880432,
-0.11170250922441483,
-0.05994395911693573,
-0.4322407841682434,
-0.4602600932121277,
-0.15355508029460907,
0.027726517990231514,
0.3666025698184967,
0.6770582795143127,
-0.10067382454872131,
0.8365657329559326,
-0.6511067748069763,
0.40656864643096924,
0.5852088928222656,
0.37368786334991455,
0.025502068921923637,
-0.37479400634765625,
-0.9360906481742859,
0.0986512154340744,
-0.391127347946167,
-0.854670524597168,
0.1377030611038208,
0.5902513861656189,
0.19508618116378784,
0.4869684875011444,
-0.27969059348106384,
1.0174500942230225,
-0.5776412487030029,
0.5995401740074158,
0.3402037024497986,
-0.911858320236206,
0.5887569189071655,
-0.06760036200284958,
0.48439937829971313,
0.49995389580726624,
0.5303009152412415,
-0.6942476034164429,
-0.3375204801559448,
-0.534990131855011,
-0.6562892198562622,
0.5700116753578186,
0.2811816930770874,
0.24007710814476013,
-0.06068126857280731,
0.4865887463092804,
0.11553149670362473,
-0.0874832421541214,
-0.4873036742210388,
-0.31453919410705566,
-0.0451122410595417,
-0.11661547422409058,
0.013177059590816498,
-0.3348766565322876,
-0.3519609868526459,
-0.3490470051765442,
0.7272558808326721,
-0.48448967933654785,
0.2921451926231384,
0.0034831291995942593,
-0.602444052696228,
-0.015476545318961143,
0.12072170525789261,
0.6161518692970276,
0.34903475642204285,
0.2041310966014862,
0.45741894841194153,
0.1666712611913681,
-0.4689614772796631,
0.5638979077339172,
-0.2553291320800781,
-0.19308961927890778,
0.34461119771003723,
0.18701933324337006,
0.9169676899909973,
0.40959227085113525,
-0.16852012276649475,
0.30650296807289124,
0.14928022027015686,
-0.16882626712322235,
0.22908595204353333,
0.3371175527572632,
0.07983755320310593,
0.25757986307144165,
0.30204716324806213,
-0.26031261682510376,
0.1263156533241272,
-0.2591916620731354,
0.0490972101688385,
0.145496666431427,
-0.5251919031143188,
-0.5010181665420532,
0.5646611452102661,
0.22821882367134094,
-0.19397932291030884,
0.5217994451522827,
0.1846737116575241,
-0.37300974130630493,
0.7180440425872803,
0.5191065073013306,
0.8944162726402283,
0.08404559642076492,
0.028711596503853798,
0.37365061044692993,
0.43851834535598755,
-0.18667379021644592,
-0.15621480345726013,
-0.1650913804769516,
-0.26800569891929626,
-0.546089231967926,
-0.2593702971935272,
-0.4085794687271118,
0.19117547571659088,
-0.5639100670814514,
0.4425922930240631,
-0.38947683572769165,
-0.696444034576416,
0.04477953165769577,
-0.258063405752182,
-0.9568833112716675,
0.14584161341190338,
0.28768593072891235,
0.6735802292823792,
-0.8751360177993774,
0.9259601831436157,
0.7798522114753723,
-0.2747211456298828,
-0.708212673664093,
0.02536487579345703,
0.12442696839570999,
-0.7410275340080261,
0.748838484287262,
0.2977626323699951,
-0.19731606543064117,
0.40154317021369934,
-0.6505939364433289,
-0.9520695209503174,
0.9711983799934387,
0.5565443634986877,
-0.7339124083518982,
-0.30493953824043274,
0.4881613254547119,
0.1657068282365799,
0.1473432034254074,
0.3710029125213623,
0.6249053478240967,
0.5563042163848877,
-0.1797802597284317,
-0.89894038438797,
-0.1456088274717331,
-0.22983989119529724,
0.2190726101398468,
0.07043889164924622,
-0.6414905190467834,
0.569794237613678,
0.006384902633726597,
-0.5569814443588257,
-0.04699471965432167,
0.9034608006477356,
-0.10956429690122604,
-0.18891151249408722,
0.4613766372203827,
0.6795545220375061,
0.7338256239891052,
-0.3532215654850006,
0.8594872355461121,
-0.45530322194099426,
0.6424808502197266,
1.074027419090271,
-0.09314675629138947,
0.2610276937484741,
0.5284372568130493,
0.18338237702846527,
0.2655460834503174,
0.3294200003147125,
0.027626466006040573,
0.4978453814983368,
0.5409020185470581,
-0.042509984225034714,
-0.28394845128059387,
-0.31129634380340576,
-0.3056372404098511,
0.5098836421966553,
0.21335043013095856,
0.06771865487098694,
-0.5424888134002686,
0.3421902358531952,
0.1641337275505066,
-0.36206895112991333,
-0.2262110412120819,
0.8205302953720093,
0.15611332654953003,
-0.6191524267196655,
1.0492385625839233,
0.1916043609380722,
0.9851222038269043,
-0.7565486431121826,
0.1442064791917801,
-0.48325014114379883,
-0.03892954811453819,
-0.21818841993808746,
-0.5610288977622986,
0.37080565094947815,
0.38693395256996155,
-0.12214097380638123,
-0.11341242492198944,
0.8633298277854919,
-0.4181678295135498,
-0.35021233558654785,
-0.17048196494579315,
0.6043185591697693,
0.11291143298149109,
-0.22400636970996857,
-0.6373587250709534,
-0.07945993542671204,
-0.5699422359466553,
-0.590183436870575,
0.18208783864974976,
0.3142782151699066,
-0.012723066844046116,
0.6346995830535889,
0.6619239449501038,
0.19367405772209167,
0.30340418219566345,
0.1525888890028,
0.742843508720398,
-0.5987842679023743,
-0.5068029761314392,
-1.0505107641220093,
0.3935507535934448,
0.10338866710662842,
-0.6089085936546326,
0.5409844517707825,
0.5075428485870361,
0.5087000131607056,
-0.280595988035202,
0.6691632270812988,
0.19423963129520416,
-0.2612166404724121,
-0.5932190418243408,
0.683742105960846,
-0.27689898014068604,
-0.42727139592170715,
0.020642844960093498,
-0.9299320578575134,
-0.3392951786518097,
0.39591729640960693,
-0.020922575145959854,
-0.2144588977098465,
0.6112967729568481,
1.1012006998062134,
-0.2953531742095947,
-0.07088043540716171,
0.6250531673431396,
-0.1930040419101715,
0.012164640240371227,
0.794775128364563,
0.8019570708274841,
-0.45904383063316345,
0.48714199662208557,
-0.2913972735404968,
-0.04883524775505066,
-0.35481494665145874,
-0.7155507206916809,
-0.9429752230644226,
-0.5437183380126953,
-0.5534295439720154,
-0.09463139623403549,
0.39774268865585327,
0.9342771172523499,
1.2910016775131226,
-0.4732755720615387,
-0.3701341450214386,
0.16185598075389862,
0.05275873839855194,
-0.42047515511512756,
-0.12838822603225708,
0.27011680603027344,
-0.47856754064559937,
-0.7957740426063538,
0.2193700075149536,
0.33326342701911926,
0.12527228891849518,
-0.2520483732223511,
-0.02587335929274559,
-0.2249714583158493,
0.12806905806064606,
0.4324382543563843,
0.22181425988674164,
-0.5258434414863586,
-0.34623828530311584,
-0.1301029920578003,
-0.5020546913146973,
0.16809548437595367,
1.0000455379486084,
-0.7404459714889526,
0.0831664651632309,
0.2362387627363205,
0.7350861430168152,
0.5891172885894775,
-0.1389089673757553,
0.3377632796764374,
-0.8975278735160828,
0.3055257201194763,
-0.20960880815982819,
0.3498696982860565,
0.14484643936157227,
-0.25428563356399536,
0.8638559579849243,
0.35436680912971497,
-0.326287180185318,
-0.48405539989471436,
0.1196889579296112,
-0.6322548389434814,
-0.0011588922934606671,
1.3180394172668457,
-0.19203412532806396,
-0.4196019768714905,
-0.03679823502898216,
-0.21162199974060059,
0.4078082740306854,
-0.03313435986638069,
0.7767120003700256,
0.7678778171539307,
0.2825500965118408,
0.00390105159021914,
-0.4258407652378082,
0.47028666734695435,
0.5810773372650146,
-0.910336971282959,
0.1742747575044632,
0.25754210352897644,
0.10727673023939133,
0.007685357704758644,
0.2476927638053894,
0.2826331853866577,
0.4974072575569153,
-0.3590618073940277,
0.08324407041072845,
-0.5640775561332703,
-0.7554736137390137,
-0.4301854074001312,
0.3458036184310913,
-0.003206590423360467,
-0.17451037466526031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17793v1
|
A Surprising Failure? Multimodal LLMs and the NLVR Challenge
| 2024-02-26T18:37:18 | 2024-02-26T18:37:18 |
Anne Wu, Kianté Brantley, Yoav Artzi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This study evaluates three state-of-the-art MLLMs -- GPT-4V, Gemini Pro, and
the open-source model IDEFICS -- on the compositional natural language vision
reasoning task NLVR. Given a human-written sentence paired with a synthetic
image, this task requires the model to determine the truth value of the
sentence with respect to the image. Despite the strong performance demonstrated
by these models, we observe they perform poorly on NLVR, which was constructed
to require compositional and spatial reasoning, and to be robust for semantic
and systematic biases.
|
[
-0.3417580723762512,
-0.6490285992622375,
0.9300802946090698,
0.4933702349662781,
-0.24138590693473816,
0.24333015084266663,
0.10670514404773712,
-0.4137800633907318,
-0.28120821714401245,
0.5500585436820984,
-0.9608038663864136,
-0.6837430000305176,
-0.47241947054862976,
0.5255323648452759,
-0.3851078450679779,
0.8958114385604858,
-0.28992199897766113,
0.0651121586561203,
-0.7305700778961182,
-0.37323471903800964,
-0.678235650062561,
-0.33695003390312195,
-0.24563691020011902,
-0.16322633624076843,
0.4988059103488922,
0.1380011886358261,
0.6079870462417603,
0.16746270656585693,
0.992556631565094,
0.29074376821517944,
0.056419748812913895,
0.7015273571014404,
-0.151967853307724,
0.198103666305542,
-0.0069048963487148285,
-0.5511369705200195,
-0.13577701151371002,
0.03424055501818657,
0.6612147092819214,
0.5262684226036072,
-0.062358029186725616,
-0.07347659021615982,
-0.22585302591323853,
0.9482041001319885,
-0.5259130597114563,
0.1677800565958023,
-0.7382634282112122,
0.31734126806259155,
0.09016537666320801,
-0.03410014137625694,
-0.3422609567642212,
-0.1689792424440384,
0.35324838757514954,
-0.8003957867622375,
0.09789878875017166,
0.3076125383377075,
0.7331557273864746,
0.743293046951294,
-0.5733998417854309,
-0.37474873661994934,
-0.7346314191818237,
0.846483588218689,
-0.6588447690010071,
0.16949562728405,
0.1179194226861,
0.3247242271900177,
-0.21393410861492157,
-0.6456116437911987,
-0.7548238039016724,
-0.6054375767707825,
0.09613864868879318,
0.2875930070877075,
-0.25707530975341797,
0.1542801409959793,
0.2493181973695755,
0.20296166837215424,
-0.6303395628929138,
0.002651033690199256,
-0.44513118267059326,
-0.19594824314117432,
0.39136824011802673,
0.7107988595962524,
0.2800901234149933,
-0.33207401633262634,
-0.7652794122695923,
0.0286551620811224,
-0.5583915710449219,
-0.1592855602502823,
0.45402777194976807,
0.06113453209400177,
-0.2510591149330139,
0.9243922829627991,
0.049461036920547485,
1.0445877313613892,
-0.3069460988044739,
-0.37627309560775757,
0.3173205852508545,
-0.6786645650863647,
-0.34987831115722656,
-0.2846057415008545,
0.8307427167892456,
0.8919140100479126,
0.10287565737962723,
-0.0011552729411050677,
-0.29322633147239685,
0.45507198572158813,
0.23342013359069824,
-0.19476278126239777,
-0.17985250055789948,
0.44963163137435913,
-0.26724421977996826,
-0.363223671913147,
0.014298048801720142,
-0.26443904638290405,
-0.3880085349082947,
-0.5040779113769531,
0.7328740954399109,
-0.5265066027641296,
-0.009141634218394756,
0.12999333441257477,
-0.36306384205818176,
0.3379039764404297,
0.5875616073608398,
-0.8129382133483887,
-0.006675867363810539,
0.4275127947330475,
0.8886582851409912,
-0.523228645324707,
-0.3738440275192261,
-0.08260108530521393,
0.0022550246212631464,
-0.3829461336135864,
0.9109551310539246,
-0.0926971286535263,
-0.46573537588119507,
-0.25462454557418823,
-0.15908469259738922,
-0.2769671678543091,
-0.6421712636947632,
0.6320094466209412,
-0.1470927596092224,
0.41058534383773804,
-0.4576096534729004,
-0.4940890073776245,
-0.19079582393169403,
0.7616917490959167,
-0.7387580871582031,
1.0538558959960938,
0.13497255742549896,
-1.0185644626617432,
0.363300085067749,
-0.7036440372467041,
-0.36557537317276,
0.022550849243998528,
-0.389757364988327,
-0.36993682384490967,
0.0586126372218132,
0.0834684744477272,
0.43310415744781494,
-0.21746298670768738,
0.3795434534549713,
-0.13868670165538788,
-0.4727727472782135,
0.4264070689678192,
-0.6439548134803772,
0.8311472535133362,
0.0524388886988163,
-0.35948941111564636,
0.327065110206604,
-0.954597532749176,
-0.2845654785633087,
0.39074504375457764,
-0.5875629782676697,
-0.06513858586549759,
0.13468316197395325,
-0.012633830308914185,
0.26726034283638,
0.0002142678276868537,
-0.6035534143447876,
0.20658206939697266,
-0.1771213710308075,
0.40997937321662903,
0.7675048112869263,
-0.14976581931114197,
0.43172964453697205,
-0.4416446089744568,
0.4589694142341614,
0.07146807760000229,
0.3581137955188751,
-0.28984373807907104,
-0.8641244173049927,
-0.8270757794380188,
-0.2760108709335327,
-0.19150908291339874,
0.8153207898139954,
-1.1922900676727295,
0.01732444390654564,
-0.13319119811058044,
-0.3331747353076935,
-0.46268218755722046,
0.1876073181629181,
0.3063657879829407,
0.6304578185081482,
0.2750101685523987,
-0.17467401921749115,
-0.48704591393470764,
-1.2345757484436035,
-0.10051410645246506,
-0.18239657580852509,
0.12179306149482727,
0.2189466953277588,
0.6973890662193298,
-0.5121136903762817,
0.8711462616920471,
-0.2622259259223938,
-0.6676929593086243,
-0.21410496532917023,
0.06341557949781418,
0.09417527168989182,
0.18746572732925415,
0.6226797103881836,
-0.7771611213684082,
-0.21726232767105103,
-0.12093755602836609,
-0.9862107038497925,
0.09832951426506042,
-0.01829942688345909,
0.1738167703151703,
0.6280640363693237,
0.3664579391479492,
-0.797684907913208,
0.49644777178764343,
0.9090884923934937,
-0.3333483934402466,
0.8906360864639282,
-0.4135209619998932,
-0.027472885325551033,
-0.6987763047218323,
-0.15978918969631195,
0.17516343295574188,
-0.13281555473804474,
-0.5120673775672913,
-0.15031380951404572,
-0.14859114587306976,
0.287445604801178,
-0.6208231449127197,
0.35307997465133667,
-0.39355501532554626,
-0.20030958950519562,
-0.18603667616844177,
0.11575242131948471,
0.18499766290187836,
0.5675021409988403,
-0.12574617564678192,
0.42670977115631104,
0.5517967343330383,
-0.4075804054737091,
0.9561260938644409,
0.18469353020191193,
-0.6175427436828613,
0.7367538213729858,
-0.6056640148162842,
0.10445474833250046,
-0.5249523520469666,
0.21471449732780457,
-1.1871751546859741,
-0.4257241487503052,
0.36094728112220764,
-0.2136356085538864,
-0.044168513268232346,
0.1716977059841156,
-0.604741096496582,
-0.44819915294647217,
-0.33061638474464417,
0.2245999574661255,
0.03614599257707596,
-0.4029041826725006,
0.8918101787567139,
-0.010232415050268173,
0.3163708746433258,
-0.6534770131111145,
-1.0631046295166016,
0.3872632682323456,
-0.1907050758600235,
-0.7816210389137268,
0.27143749594688416,
-0.23912115395069122,
-0.574845016002655,
0.29969334602355957,
0.12208227068185806,
0.22235462069511414,
0.023113399744033813,
0.26451006531715393,
0.5725159049034119,
-0.10526891052722931,
-0.08062108606100082,
-0.32128164172172546,
0.049155715852975845,
0.23389066755771637,
-0.021733447909355164,
-0.07000317424535751,
-0.6150413751602173,
-0.7486869692802429,
-0.4322708249092102,
0.3734935224056244,
0.7906069159507751,
-0.0902748852968216,
0.7334864139556885,
0.878898561000824,
-0.1845265030860901,
-0.21893323957920074,
-0.587696373462677,
0.004390896763652563,
-0.42669549584388733,
0.27716267108917236,
-0.2561036944389343,
-0.9834282994270325,
0.32119208574295044,
0.2962285578250885,
0.02530388906598091,
0.34869635105133057,
0.6229852437973022,
-0.525925874710083,
0.8864620327949524,
0.3012246787548065,
0.42955461144447327,
0.12395097315311432,
-0.31481701135635376,
0.1694740355014801,
-0.7820134162902832,
-0.7198563814163208,
0.06046763062477112,
-0.4453897774219513,
-0.4510129690170288,
-0.6426379084587097,
0.7003923654556274,
-0.44238921999931335,
-0.12792685627937317,
-0.018579700961709023,
-0.47738274931907654,
0.3037385046482086,
1.0348446369171143,
0.12092019617557526,
0.3943409025669098,
0.046797532588243484,
-0.592011570930481,
-0.1306685358285904,
-0.6490839123725891,
-0.4550721347332001,
0.9930123686790466,
0.22919867932796478,
0.7247392535209656,
0.31005045771598816,
0.26816698908805847,
0.11225743591785431,
0.26437386870384216,
-0.7079926133155823,
0.5671796798706055,
-0.1940387338399887,
-0.8117574453353882,
-0.13108965754508972,
-0.2007865309715271,
-0.6229082942008972,
0.5593583583831787,
-0.45464256405830383,
-0.4606717824935913,
-0.056823745369911194,
0.14398899674415588,
-0.3222252428531647,
0.36177125573158264,
-0.5897855758666992,
1.1370447874069214,
-0.5815496444702148,
-0.31452831625938416,
0.257488489151001,
-1.0571401119232178,
0.708111584186554,
0.021959614008665085,
0.295848548412323,
-0.4294079542160034,
-0.06034804508090019,
0.4531329274177551,
-0.20732954144477844,
0.8223641514778137,
-0.09576418995857239,
0.002996784169226885,
0.5940336585044861,
0.13491617143154144,
0.2735225558280945,
-0.0967218279838562,
0.3186505138874054,
0.017618514597415924,
-0.06933616101741791,
-0.12776508927345276,
-0.6794958710670471,
0.4778776466846466,
-0.5712021589279175,
-0.5109025835990906,
-0.44770559668540955,
-0.4937947392463684,
-0.22317388653755188,
-0.10264553874731064,
0.29799485206604004,
0.4880478084087372,
-0.12667086720466614,
0.23260624706745148,
0.5632162094116211,
-0.18452094495296478,
0.5519096851348877,
0.21372713148593903,
-0.35849958658218384,
-0.604716420173645,
0.659396231174469,
-0.2700427174568176,
0.475929319858551,
0.3368513584136963,
0.03276043385267258,
-0.4510629177093506,
-0.7526161670684814,
-0.5419115424156189,
0.07207413762807846,
-1.0816532373428345,
-0.16191454231739044,
-0.49633219838142395,
-0.14442381262779236,
0.12928985059261322,
-0.013409344479441643,
-0.3854333162307739,
-0.30020299553871155,
-0.4631195068359375,
-0.24443528056144714,
0.09133566915988922,
0.9032655954360962,
0.002517123706638813,
-0.029370691627264023,
-0.8765620589256287,
0.472408264875412,
0.3758203983306885,
0.14300590753555298,
-0.3896593451499939,
-0.38528409600257874,
-0.005409061908721924,
-0.169093519449234,
-0.4363968074321747,
-0.675559401512146,
0.29740336537361145,
-0.03885382413864136,
0.7309306263923645,
0.22546789050102234,
-0.18153692781925201,
0.3883230984210968,
-0.3912203013896942,
0.9941713809967041,
0.44490811228752136,
-0.6251328587532043,
0.5896698236465454,
-0.4237861931324005,
0.43888112902641296,
0.45580586791038513,
0.1476229429244995,
-0.2877611815929413,
-0.3415253460407257,
-0.18131287395954132,
-0.7688292264938354,
0.3156678378582001,
0.3927278220653534,
0.10358916968107224,
-0.10165845602750778,
0.21242795884609222,
0.04620835557579994,
0.15327559411525726,
-1.0842746496200562,
-0.38644254207611084,
-0.25343260169029236,
-0.4960656762123108,
0.03769252076745033,
-0.28631266951560974,
-0.09873117506504059,
-0.4205659329891205,
0.4259893596172333,
-0.3494233787059784,
0.16440612077713013,
0.5873027443885803,
-0.029322808608412743,
0.08735712617635727,
0.06994009017944336,
1.03984534740448,
0.5119423270225525,
-0.2866306006908417,
0.2713644504547119,
0.08625385165214539,
-0.22191503643989563,
0.2864973247051239,
-0.14323724806308746,
-0.26589399576187134,
0.08382554352283478,
0.6825209856033325,
1.2395771741867065,
0.35710299015045166,
-0.9894379377365112,
0.7497762441635132,
-0.23614268004894257,
-0.8136721849441528,
-0.4436376392841339,
-0.06863877922296524,
0.2568107843399048,
0.3465040624141693,
0.36741772294044495,
0.6085983514785767,
-0.06814496964216232,
-0.5237480401992798,
-0.19947995245456696,
0.701165497303009,
-0.4046241343021393,
-0.26216381788253784,
0.9671666622161865,
0.041008513420820236,
0.03118167631328106,
0.7834199070930481,
-0.22432774305343628,
-0.6222232580184937,
0.5946952104568481,
0.31937140226364136,
0.7165250182151794,
0.18070334196090698,
0.17473340034484863,
0.16637136042118073,
0.7479555606842041,
-0.2443973273038864,
0.4405304789543152,
0.15509682893753052,
-1.1051322221755981,
-0.7031875252723694,
-0.46907275915145874,
-0.6748784184455872,
-0.08929373323917389,
-0.23195944726467133,
0.14166118204593658,
-0.4009702503681183,
-0.30099424719810486,
-0.2257874459028244,
-0.45251214504241943,
-0.8645179867744446,
0.26292330026626587,
0.37914255261421204,
0.7137770056724548,
-0.8330901265144348,
0.49405524134635925,
0.861614465713501,
-0.2705255150794983,
-0.5401848554611206,
-0.5280941128730774,
0.15933941304683685,
-0.6310902833938599,
0.9472688436508179,
0.19968441128730774,
-0.25904297828674316,
-0.2245596945285797,
-0.5652900338172913,
-0.7174196243286133,
1.1597225666046143,
0.6052350401878357,
-0.4285750091075897,
-0.232435941696167,
0.15896549820899963,
0.473812073469162,
-0.4105530381202698,
-0.10890112072229385,
0.44533681869506836,
0.7031452059745789,
0.29866060614585876,
-1.0739102363586426,
-0.15341418981552124,
-0.09421868622303009,
-0.044683799147605896,
-0.21090015769004822,
-0.4611334502696991,
0.8786724209785461,
-0.7102094888687134,
-0.16276268661022186,
0.061662834137678146,
0.45227494835853577,
0.48431074619293213,
0.49846887588500977,
0.5337140560150146,
0.9438852071762085,
0.4730711281299591,
-0.2356104552745819,
1.29612135887146,
0.2644500732421875,
0.18021529912948608,
0.9871997833251953,
-0.31909510493278503,
0.7615306377410889,
0.6113202571868896,
-0.3167915940284729,
0.5413560271263123,
0.3957992196083069,
-0.2506098449230194,
0.6766502261161804,
0.22408005595207214,
-0.5138651132583618,
-0.19876566529273987,
0.23947469890117645,
0.19953973591327667,
0.7590364217758179,
0.39647603034973145,
-0.1892775446176529,
0.05210793763399124,
0.3381578326225281,
-0.5755398869514465,
-0.0014445451088249683,
-0.19216568768024445,
0.6745322942733765,
0.24749326705932617,
-0.7762940526008606,
0.35913151502609253,
0.11237658560276031,
0.7430275082588196,
-0.26150763034820557,
-0.08872777223587036,
-0.005387512501329184,
0.187739759683609,
-0.24262814223766327,
-0.8329837322235107,
0.4918924570083618,
-0.2013273686170578,
-0.04257960990071297,
-0.15558841824531555,
0.6990039348602295,
-0.3047562837600708,
-0.6559264063835144,
0.2637413442134857,
0.5346278548240662,
0.0629810243844986,
-0.26573100686073303,
-0.7360127568244934,
0.44060856103897095,
0.049948014318943024,
-0.17206445336341858,
-0.06772958487272263,
0.13306285440921783,
0.07829361408948898,
1.0491414070129395,
0.5644358992576599,
-0.26649096608161926,
0.4240109324455261,
0.2120029777288437,
0.6503735184669495,
-0.7341039180755615,
-0.1279722899198532,
-1.089460849761963,
0.7381858229637146,
0.1209251806139946,
-0.15319252014160156,
0.8867968320846558,
0.45798563957214355,
0.6706525087356567,
-0.2424013763666153,
0.8498634696006775,
0.33502355217933655,
0.20344975590705872,
-0.806259274482727,
0.18429899215698242,
-0.5920078754425049,
0.27602335810661316,
-0.09490735083818436,
-1.0047005414962769,
-0.7661909461021423,
0.6076309680938721,
0.05360366776585579,
-0.08016711473464966,
0.9511117339134216,
0.635667085647583,
0.27689439058303833,
-0.09337235242128372,
0.44812384247779846,
-0.030320972204208374,
0.17244264483451843,
0.7212757468223572,
1.3620415925979614,
-0.3245619833469391,
0.6032814979553223,
-0.3417237401008606,
0.08002184331417084,
-0.16256390511989594,
-1.2160871028900146,
-0.9494571089744568,
-0.5818698406219482,
-0.4636354446411133,
-0.2682666778564453,
-0.13944636285305023,
0.775681734085083,
0.4451148211956024,
-0.4427076578140259,
0.28184449672698975,
-0.23834510147571564,
0.087506964802742,
0.15719270706176758,
-0.21338343620300293,
0.1795508712530136,
-0.08315242826938629,
-0.6008602976799011,
0.667131781578064,
0.7480143904685974,
0.40901896357536316,
-0.6283859610557556,
-0.16697679460048676,
-0.053745195269584656,
-0.020045485347509384,
0.8381705284118652,
-0.15382014214992523,
-1.2852391004562378,
-0.2233513444662094,
0.17566214501857758,
-0.29179173707962036,
0.15753602981567383,
0.6167420744895935,
-0.7164060473442078,
0.5428903102874756,
0.3058364689350128,
0.4664416015148163,
0.4892243444919586,
-0.05399441719055176,
0.34753474593162537,
-0.6948413252830505,
0.010223514400422573,
0.3738638758659363,
0.6464397311210632,
0.8932075500488281,
-0.01092408038675785,
0.3907720744609833,
0.631153404712677,
-0.45696449279785156,
-0.6185662150382996,
0.1738385707139969,
-1.3857049942016602,
-0.3573595881462097,
1.1693538427352905,
0.04205234721302986,
-0.3280068039894104,
-0.12602095305919647,
-0.4965822994709015,
-0.31208741664886475,
0.16753657162189484,
0.4057435989379883,
0.8997376561164856,
-0.3760734796524048,
-0.33844971656799316,
-0.8097100853919983,
0.31707754731178284,
0.12458838522434235,
-0.5506020188331604,
-0.4935920834541321,
0.735881507396698,
0.43823331594467163,
0.1877354383468628,
0.7299776673316956,
-0.05947330221533775,
0.22326397895812988,
0.1292937994003296,
0.042460519820451736,
-0.3100597858428955,
-0.28144311904907227,
-0.3015408515930176,
0.24450667202472687,
0.06633759289979935,
-0.18834049999713898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16810v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16810v1
|
OncoGPT: A Medical Conversational Model Tailored with Oncology Domain Expertise on a Large Language Model Meta-AI (LLaMA)
| 2024-02-26T18:33:13 | 2024-02-26T18:33:13 |
Fujian Jia, Xin Liu, Lixi Deng, Jiwen Gu, Chunchao Pu, Tunan Bai, Mengjiang Huang, Yuanzhi Lu, Kang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the past year, there has been a growing trend in applying Large Language
Models (LLMs) to the field of medicine, particularly with the advent of
advanced language models such as ChatGPT developed by OpenAI. However, there is
limited research on LLMs specifically addressing oncology-related queries. The
primary aim of this research was to develop a specialized language model that
demonstrates improved accuracy in providing advice related to oncology. We
performed an extensive data collection of online question-answer interactions
centered around oncology, sourced from reputable doctor-patient platforms.
Following data cleaning and anonymization, a dataset comprising over 180K+
oncology-related conversations was established. The conversations were
categorized and meticulously reviewed by field specialists and clinicians to
ensure precision. Employing the LLaMA model and other selected open-source
datasets, we conducted iterative fine-tuning to enhance the model's proficiency
in basic medical conversation and specialized oncology knowledge. We observed a
substantial enhancement in the model's understanding of genuine patient
inquiries and its reliability in offering oncology-related advice through the
utilization of real online question-answer interactions in the fine-tuning
process. We release database and models to the research community
(https://github.com/OncoGPT1).
|
[
-0.0822441354393959,
-1.1528247594833374,
0.9859858155250549,
-0.1423175185918808,
-0.19867630302906036,
0.014621851034462452,
-0.2644886076450348,
-0.268964558839798,
0.15268225967884064,
0.9321283102035522,
-0.5614579916000366,
-0.6547414064407349,
-0.692406415939331,
-0.09049642086029053,
-0.033080536872148514,
1.1485005617141724,
0.26040568947792053,
0.40557795763015747,
-0.172957181930542,
-0.1105680987238884,
-0.1674114316701889,
-0.39429914951324463,
-1.1092395782470703,
-0.36169686913490295,
0.6711141467094421,
0.6011697053909302,
0.7054343223571777,
0.6434629559516907,
0.7332592606544495,
0.1068667396903038,
-0.23840971291065216,
0.14476823806762695,
-0.5931578278541565,
0.06029023230075836,
-0.09326494485139847,
-0.4007725715637207,
-0.8384773135185242,
-0.3407762944698334,
-0.0035053773317486048,
0.72526615858078,
-0.7113763093948364,
-0.17721174657344818,
-0.09734995663166046,
0.14390237629413605,
-0.44378042221069336,
0.17715802788734436,
-0.9037304520606995,
0.10827530920505524,
0.0038875832688063383,
-0.2409789115190506,
-0.07782741636037827,
-0.4486556053161621,
0.23925337195396423,
-0.657889723777771,
-0.0976109728217125,
-0.1497630774974823,
0.4736414849758148,
0.2951076626777649,
-0.4690452814102173,
-0.6320582032203674,
-0.5441311597824097,
0.504338264465332,
-1.0020920038223267,
0.0878257229924202,
0.6692330241203308,
0.48481646180152893,
-0.05270041525363922,
-1.112160563468933,
-0.30659979581832886,
-0.4105333983898163,
-0.025443485006690025,
0.22580456733703613,
-0.3152538239955902,
0.476086288690567,
0.08336616307497025,
0.2130042463541031,
-0.3104916512966156,
0.18023578822612762,
-0.25172755122184753,
-0.09628722071647644,
0.5355933308601379,
0.41493022441864014,
0.3389832079410553,
0.1972208470106125,
-0.13210533559322357,
0.4935830533504486,
-0.7841610908508301,
-0.2105470895767212,
-0.1580677032470703,
0.1982221156358719,
0.08205871284008026,
0.737291157245636,
-0.4112034738063812,
0.7899990081787109,
0.09231371432542801,
-0.11177437752485275,
-0.38554707169532776,
-0.5541349053382874,
-0.21173684298992157,
0.12787576019763947,
0.8092759847640991,
0.4197562336921692,
0.40265047550201416,
-0.21238131821155548,
0.4965898096561432,
-0.10578841716051102,
0.3883959650993347,
-0.7489908337593079,
-0.37256184220314026,
0.3295510411262512,
-0.35629400610923767,
-0.4670427739620209,
-0.23322097957134247,
-0.6748802065849304,
-0.4337700605392456,
0.22577063739299774,
0.19417616724967957,
-0.15902477502822876,
-0.047662731260061264,
0.3560458719730377,
0.31179162859916687,
-0.09428507089614868,
0.3206222653388977,
-0.6738056540489197,
0.20998291671276093,
0.6378419995307922,
0.7159909009933472,
0.14298298954963684,
0.10238773375749588,
-0.5574734807014465,
0.3480221629142761,
0.018428348004817963,
0.8803471922874451,
-1.1339343786239624,
-0.4510839879512787,
-0.020294230431318283,
-0.03950260579586029,
-0.11965375393629074,
-0.20198121666908264,
0.623595118522644,
-0.29049235582351685,
0.4643914997577667,
-0.3823707699775696,
-0.5223535299301147,
-0.1297464221715927,
0.6970993876457214,
-0.2511783838272095,
0.5089482665061951,
0.0026671483647078276,
-0.8088437914848328,
0.050542958080768585,
-0.9920059442520142,
0.006529575679451227,
0.22410047054290771,
-0.25051945447921753,
-0.3920075297355652,
-0.17375482618808746,
0.48059165477752686,
0.5448700189590454,
-0.6567612290382385,
0.29463815689086914,
-0.23138479888439178,
-0.09352687746286392,
0.2547706663608551,
-0.08239223062992096,
0.6963817477226257,
0.4159431457519531,
-0.10971934348344803,
0.06159292533993721,
-0.5939756631851196,
0.1887943297624588,
0.06198218837380409,
-0.26144424080848694,
-0.2072228491306305,
-0.08876964449882507,
-0.3310750126838684,
0.05968528240919113,
0.1581134796142578,
-0.7904124855995178,
0.5471316576004028,
-0.5679702162742615,
0.822830080986023,
0.012264600023627281,
0.3546672463417053,
-0.031333763152360916,
-0.35982924699783325,
0.5757191777229309,
-0.27118632197380066,
0.32892298698425293,
-0.33038491010665894,
-0.9142025113105774,
-0.5202207565307617,
-0.23276396095752716,
0.23325425386428833,
0.7563943862915039,
-0.6314418911933899,
0.03930016979575157,
-0.2700415849685669,
-0.5739624500274658,
-0.5146632790565491,
-0.1531594693660736,
0.485243558883667,
0.5171226263046265,
0.32474657893180847,
-0.5922098159790039,
-0.3594619035720825,
-0.700635552406311,
-0.15673501789569855,
-0.05911905691027641,
-0.001449289615266025,
0.8251423239707947,
0.047966957092285156,
-0.5880012512207031,
0.9264862537384033,
-0.7639365196228027,
-0.30302852392196655,
-0.18503670394420624,
0.022933892905712128,
-0.020280184224247932,
-0.004648102447390556,
0.2584947645664215,
-0.44905295968055725,
-0.6122926473617554,
0.5339630842208862,
-0.5634408593177795,
-0.36321061849594116,
0.21272848546504974,
0.0028689929749816656,
-0.31205299496650696,
0.3973982632160187,
-0.6153544187545776,
0.37344974279403687,
0.6606858372688293,
-0.3011806905269623,
-0.03614138811826706,
-0.4695284962654114,
0.3506247401237488,
-1.187162160873413,
0.19908031821250916,
-0.25364020466804504,
-0.33422958850860596,
-0.8633900284767151,
0.057013873010873795,
-0.40894898772239685,
-0.18911555409431458,
-0.37924307584762573,
0.44714969396591187,
-0.21106794476509094,
0.12107713520526886,
-0.3966761827468872,
0.05903645604848862,
-0.23345065116882324,
0.441550076007843,
0.1532547026872635,
0.5703608989715576,
0.4066149890422821,
-0.5295289754867554,
0.37821006774902344,
0.550767719745636,
-0.34355437755584717,
0.4401243031024933,
-0.8952978253364563,
0.5169907808303833,
0.2820245623588562,
0.2866446375846863,
-0.8957239389419556,
-0.3217509388923645,
0.3895469009876251,
-0.2795214056968689,
-0.0935496911406517,
-0.3494800925254822,
-0.11662070453166962,
-0.05039472132921219,
0.21728603541851044,
0.4335957467556,
0.2811698019504547,
0.007942293770611286,
0.4751625955104828,
0.5748291611671448,
-0.7879708409309387,
-0.3712235391139984,
-0.7898155450820923,
0.17865023016929626,
-0.017482096329331398,
-0.6329519748687744,
0.25251930952072144,
-0.06355124711990356,
-0.2860775887966156,
-0.03462506830692291,
0.4928036332130432,
-0.4662417471408844,
-0.06408191472291946,
0.007305520586669445,
-0.218109130859375,
-0.131906196475029,
0.2670117914676666,
0.1050162985920906,
-0.02076544612646103,
-0.10293004661798477,
-0.139637291431427,
0.7251248359680176,
0.15054263174533844,
-0.6394501328468323,
-0.22817441821098328,
0.22878840565681458,
0.529723048210144,
-0.1739536076784134,
0.8080158829689026,
0.37379226088523865,
-0.26057833433151245,
0.22787633538246155,
-0.51039719581604,
-0.3868916630744934,
-0.371714323759079,
0.42851758003234863,
-0.15933795273303986,
-1.1070178747177124,
0.5571607351303101,
-0.18011297285556793,
0.05030243843793869,
0.17740613222122192,
1.0608725547790527,
0.17547056078910828,
1.0234843492507935,
0.454141765832901,
0.0004677079850807786,
0.2604888081550598,
-0.05746718868613243,
0.2574981451034546,
-0.6896024346351624,
-0.33720752596855164,
-0.44741418957710266,
0.15409636497497559,
-0.5140851140022278,
-0.6193851828575134,
0.6552019715309143,
-0.41062498092651367,
-0.39496946334838867,
0.08082070201635361,
-0.5873514413833618,
0.31591126322746277,
0.12588167190551758,
0.5252102017402649,
0.5993661880493164,
0.05853498354554176,
0.11739679425954819,
-0.04614455997943878,
-1.0634499788284302,
-0.38905271887779236,
1.4930325746536255,
0.4021146893501282,
0.6584376096725464,
0.08008632063865662,
0.06585461646318436,
0.2644224464893341,
0.15598343312740326,
-0.7473744750022888,
0.34945744276046753,
-0.12393997609615326,
-0.5955141186714172,
-0.19354692101478577,
-0.5611969232559204,
-1.1560131311416626,
-0.0655326247215271,
-0.17344245314598083,
-0.7732447981834412,
-0.12390978634357452,
0.18364132940769196,
-0.6146909594535828,
0.3133557438850403,
-0.1662888377904892,
0.8031222224235535,
-0.34594130516052246,
-0.2848854064941406,
-0.2133347988128662,
-0.6559460759162903,
0.27085423469543457,
-0.10304862260818481,
0.15132759511470795,
-0.046723686158657074,
-0.16128186881542206,
0.21223758161067963,
-0.5530642867088318,
0.9072219133377075,
0.0949225202202797,
-0.2614842355251312,
0.37183427810668945,
0.012697892263531685,
0.8156951665878296,
0.030355852097272873,
-0.1747252494096756,
0.2984553277492523,
0.04811091721057892,
-0.3912319540977478,
-0.48014938831329346,
0.7072741389274597,
-0.6093039512634277,
-0.4921248257160187,
-0.03611685708165169,
-0.4847353994846344,
-0.5009263157844543,
-0.11070872843265533,
0.5127138495445251,
0.35420629382133484,
-0.3743363916873932,
0.16905292868614197,
0.6270536780357361,
-0.4208086133003235,
-0.20609888434410095,
0.628643810749054,
-0.15538527071475983,
-0.3627171218395233,
0.5364766716957092,
0.07942674309015274,
0.42631086707115173,
0.3731166422367096,
0.4317565858364105,
-0.022693131119012833,
-0.6410507559776306,
-0.34024420380592346,
0.08946366608142853,
-0.6930756568908691,
-0.02228235825896263,
-1.0842167139053345,
-0.23112539947032928,
-0.5157833695411682,
0.05560428276658058,
-0.2423180192708969,
-0.4451010525226593,
-0.11436732113361359,
-0.03652782365679741,
0.6550695896148682,
0.8239295482635498,
0.436361163854599,
0.6301304697990417,
-0.9737533330917358,
-0.20047171413898468,
0.4100364148616791,
0.10232662409543991,
-0.1860986351966858,
-0.8416632413864136,
-0.18643659353256226,
0.4213251769542694,
-0.2754584550857544,
-0.8266748189926147,
0.4164005219936371,
0.46729665994644165,
0.6207736134529114,
0.35798126459121704,
-0.10455391556024551,
0.3686348795890808,
-0.20826902985572815,
0.719690203666687,
0.023378318175673485,
-0.6498405337333679,
0.587801456451416,
-0.8312486410140991,
0.353484183549881,
0.37221774458885193,
0.46359995007514954,
-0.714378833770752,
-0.36928898096084595,
-0.6821357011795044,
-0.4850640296936035,
0.6454329490661621,
0.4204609990119934,
0.10358891636133194,
0.1446520835161209,
0.5480421781539917,
0.0960257351398468,
0.31704291701316833,
-0.4576657712459564,
0.03994348272681236,
-0.03443761169910431,
-0.43091386556625366,
0.08763258159160614,
-0.3116428852081299,
-0.5146260261535645,
-0.08530452847480774,
0.39143818616867065,
-0.34586653113365173,
0.49231863021850586,
0.19426272809505463,
0.19358105957508087,
-0.06831765174865723,
0.4451358914375305,
0.6282768845558167,
0.6739965081214905,
0.1051221638917923,
-0.1832442283630371,
0.7584441304206848,
-0.5823795795440674,
-0.304975301027298,
-0.18620651960372925,
0.04187208041548729,
-0.4128466546535492,
0.5392354726791382,
0.881467878818512,
0.20751793682575226,
-0.7818208336830139,
0.45019835233688354,
-0.13420666754245758,
-0.1876560002565384,
0.019699692726135254,
0.13239218294620514,
0.04520509019494057,
0.10979745537042618,
-0.010927672497928143,
-0.19481857120990753,
0.3191850185394287,
-0.7252903580665588,
0.1525968760251999,
0.45544156432151794,
-0.7195633053779602,
-0.1440538763999939,
0.6262468099594116,
0.26448312401771545,
-0.3080781102180481,
0.4274015724658966,
0.33752742409706116,
-0.5872175693511963,
0.6568330526351929,
0.3345849812030792,
0.41785022616386414,
-0.21023789048194885,
0.26223674416542053,
0.3301599621772766,
0.08869439363479614,
-0.16137070953845978,
0.2549467980861664,
0.11711659282445908,
-0.6665881276130676,
-0.2076198309659958,
-0.22188472747802734,
-0.8949252963066101,
-0.04759441316127777,
-0.3001422882080078,
0.18005354702472687,
-0.6235407590866089,
-0.3839475214481354,
-0.13154883682727814,
0.048003263771533966,
-0.34338146448135376,
0.2996802031993866,
-0.14910359680652618,
0.5888888835906982,
-0.5140836238861084,
1.0834063291549683,
0.8089816570281982,
-0.3599205017089844,
-0.8754645586013794,
0.17276646196842194,
-0.18944306671619415,
-0.9931273460388184,
0.34496140480041504,
-0.20418275892734528,
-0.020278887823224068,
0.2876574397087097,
-0.6217951774597168,
-0.9208536148071289,
1.2589448690414429,
0.5309385657310486,
-0.6460574269294739,
0.10164658725261688,
0.3943072259426117,
0.8860543966293335,
-0.7405412793159485,
0.7584131360054016,
0.46098199486732483,
0.4861873388290405,
0.3738206923007965,
-1.2747802734375,
-0.07135079056024551,
0.012118699960410595,
-0.37032613158226013,
-0.04253028705716133,
-0.8588093519210815,
0.8185228705406189,
-0.37706664204597473,
-0.12532159686088562,
0.20985570549964905,
0.01573232375085354,
0.046036262065172195,
0.445774644613266,
0.15832379460334778,
0.6494207978248596,
0.8908783197402954,
-0.23599302768707275,
1.2920405864715576,
-0.5123388171195984,
0.38467681407928467,
0.8017189502716064,
-0.3105059862136841,
0.5418992042541504,
0.11939458549022675,
-0.1512756645679474,
0.42730480432510376,
0.5212226510047913,
0.15965917706489563,
0.6070795059204102,
-0.005601921584457159,
-0.28989681601524353,
-0.4284392297267914,
-0.3709889352321625,
-0.5045269131660461,
0.40665656328201294,
0.5005781054496765,
-0.5811461806297302,
0.14457334578037262,
0.08025553822517395,
0.218379408121109,
0.025713350623846054,
-0.37510421872138977,
1.118253231048584,
0.08770587295293808,
-0.733708918094635,
0.4005904495716095,
0.069101482629776,
0.45547589659690857,
-0.8259663581848145,
0.0282154344022274,
-0.4245300590991974,
0.22956624627113342,
-0.27020683884620667,
-0.743685245513916,
0.43596068024635315,
0.23352055251598358,
0.11254475265741348,
0.27967822551727295,
0.7992247939109802,
-0.7274389266967773,
-0.6604388952255249,
0.25338828563690186,
0.5069120526313782,
0.44368383288383484,
-0.11629406362771988,
-0.7972303032875061,
0.07240872830152512,
0.10062538832426071,
-0.16863055527210236,
0.17658130824565887,
0.2816832363605499,
-0.09882976114749908,
1.0611170530319214,
0.49364161491394043,
0.19075609743595123,
-0.20000290870666504,
-0.0261396337300539,
0.9082369208335876,
-0.4198743999004364,
-0.24804849922657013,
-0.6717334985733032,
0.270140677690506,
-0.05089687183499336,
-0.42431288957595825,
0.5499000549316406,
0.20551930367946625,
0.43538814783096313,
0.11643814295530319,
0.9328641891479492,
0.05810637027025223,
0.600647509098053,
-0.6812748312950134,
0.8721029162406921,
-0.5347435474395752,
0.39187198877334595,
-0.042855046689510345,
-0.6209157705307007,
-0.378471702337265,
0.5388725996017456,
-0.6327938437461853,
0.25563672184944153,
0.4838694930076599,
1.0511000156402588,
-0.015566947869956493,
0.06096978485584259,
0.5538693070411682,
0.4267258942127228,
0.41181322932243347,
0.7985883951187134,
0.572312593460083,
-0.45801854133605957,
0.6230455636978149,
0.10629226267337799,
-0.1313554346561432,
-0.3460642695426941,
-0.7067095637321472,
-0.9174845814704895,
-0.2543434500694275,
-0.30385032296180725,
-0.08974093198776245,
0.420381098985672,
1.1015921831130981,
0.7823030352592468,
-0.7665265202522278,
-0.07544558495283127,
-0.12475566565990448,
-0.2899570167064667,
0.1067517101764679,
-0.036317236721515656,
0.1629665344953537,
0.12836192548274994,
-0.6747738122940063,
0.5204123258590698,
0.21713514626026154,
-0.17886528372764587,
-0.2037326693534851,
-0.2159237414598465,
-0.21683456003665924,
0.3617478311061859,
0.4233671724796295,
0.28104621171951294,
-0.5978772044181824,
-0.0778336301445961,
0.1682179570198059,
-0.3433307707309723,
0.26433125138282776,
1.0098192691802979,
-0.4407725930213928,
0.49326106905937195,
0.3155982196331024,
0.6633835434913635,
0.5330290198326111,
0.22851356863975525,
0.8246568441390991,
-0.47394561767578125,
-0.05080801621079445,
0.31159526109695435,
0.13342508673667908,
0.35093215107917786,
-0.7496877908706665,
0.6082296967506409,
0.09191925078630447,
-0.8168306946754456,
-0.557481586933136,
0.2411535680294037,
-1.042781949043274,
-0.29304465651512146,
1.423195242881775,
-0.4159913659095764,
0.11771110445261002,
-0.5257962346076965,
-0.7388507127761841,
0.21616755425930023,
-0.3919515907764435,
0.9217590093612671,
0.5285961627960205,
-0.16269409656524658,
-0.5110275149345398,
-0.3945562541484833,
0.5198981761932373,
0.30314725637435913,
-1.0804716348648071,
-0.04978210851550102,
0.20135192573070526,
0.4015246331691742,
-0.2049526870250702,
0.9750613570213318,
0.04942922666668892,
0.20097914338111877,
-0.2569941580295563,
0.022903883829712868,
-0.3033261001110077,
-0.052528902888298035,
-0.08468359708786011,
0.28419193625450134,
0.16812382638454437,
0.1988895833492279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16797v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16797v2
|
Set the Clock: Temporal Alignment of Pretrained Language Models
| 2024-02-26T18:10:56 | 2024-06-09T19:47:15 |
Bowen Zhao, Zander Brumbaugh, Yizhong Wang, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Noah A. Smith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) are trained on web text originating from many points in
time and, in general, without any explicit temporal grounding. This work
investigates the temporal chaos of pretrained LMs and explores various methods
to align their internal knowledge to a target time, which we call "temporal
alignment." To do this, we first automatically construct a dataset containing
20K time-sensitive questions and their answers for each year from 2000 to 2023.
Based on this dataset, we empirically show that pretrained LMs (e.g., LLaMa2),
despite having a recent pretraining cutoff (e.g., 2022), mostly answer
questions using earlier knowledge (e.g., in 2019). We then develop several
methods, from prompting to finetuning, to align LMs to use their most recent
knowledge when answering questions, and investigate various factors in this
alignment. Our experiments demonstrate that aligning LLaMa2 to the year 2022
can enhance its performance by up to 62% according to that year's answers. This
improvement occurs even without explicitly mentioning time information,
indicating the possibility of aligning models' internal sense of time after
pretraining. Finally, we find that alignment to a historical time is also
possible, with up to 2.8$\times$ the performance of the unaligned LM in 2010 if
finetuning models to that year. These findings hint at the sophistication of
LMs' internal knowledge organization and the necessity of tuning them properly.
|
[
-0.13815265893936157,
-0.5712293386459351,
0.6094407439231873,
0.0642966702580452,
-0.262519896030426,
0.18168164789676666,
-0.08173874765634537,
-0.729458212852478,
-0.19891855120658875,
0.14903071522712708,
-0.9795917868614197,
0.008942424319684505,
-0.23012888431549072,
-0.020550301298499107,
-0.22101563215255737,
1.046243667602539,
-0.18754097819328308,
-0.004052473232150078,
-0.1996043622493744,
0.05167609080672264,
-0.37801387906074524,
-0.35557079315185547,
-0.3276785910129547,
-0.6826720237731934,
0.5486129522323608,
0.13525086641311646,
0.8580666184425354,
1.088499903678894,
0.5639426708221436,
0.21943217515945435,
0.07987857609987259,
0.08410341292619705,
-0.4635576903820038,
0.09285790473222733,
0.032526854425668716,
-0.5405928492546082,
-0.4909401834011078,
0.01620982214808464,
0.48817723989486694,
0.6338937282562256,
-0.22090363502502441,
0.40007930994033813,
-0.028133008629083633,
0.5046191215515137,
-0.608444094657898,
-0.07968545705080032,
-0.8473129272460938,
0.19658556580543518,
-0.5080096125602722,
-0.5277246832847595,
-0.05142473429441452,
-0.6202749609947205,
0.13844959437847137,
-0.8081771731376648,
-0.06086767092347145,
0.020444074645638466,
1.1792036294937134,
0.711425244808197,
-0.29573798179626465,
-0.04270021617412567,
-0.8534203171730042,
0.7583611607551575,
-0.9022813439369202,
0.48208481073379517,
0.4482646882534027,
0.33359432220458984,
-0.10243762284517288,
-0.6719325184822083,
-0.6871339082717896,
0.06535360962152481,
0.15254969894886017,
0.13245612382888794,
0.053359996527433395,
-0.29419854283332825,
0.2937110960483551,
0.25729939341545105,
-0.7721008062362671,
0.4538779854774475,
-0.09523466974496841,
-0.05851031467318535,
0.24542534351348877,
0.3860926032066345,
0.28233444690704346,
0.4258458912372589,
-0.32819169759750366,
-0.01768270507454872,
-0.6426519751548767,
0.2109151929616928,
0.5903258323669434,
0.1926589161157608,
-0.052807774394750595,
0.6335806846618652,
0.04857301339507103,
0.9189690947532654,
0.3195478022098541,
-0.20580604672431946,
0.058064140379428864,
-0.4168071448802948,
-0.09201521426439285,
0.2584306597709656,
0.6110072135925293,
0.5530237555503845,
0.7246702909469604,
-0.2142167091369629,
-0.2797743082046509,
0.13147619366645813,
0.4981658160686493,
-0.710817813873291,
-0.04430510848760605,
0.21943117678165436,
-0.10519606620073318,
-0.27548953890800476,
-0.3282932639122009,
-0.5460613965988159,
-0.20871199667453766,
-0.6517703533172607,
0.4747236967086792,
-0.2678866982460022,
-0.09201525896787643,
0.08828228712081909,
0.26210740208625793,
0.3165684640407562,
0.2797660231590271,
-0.9214679598808289,
0.2149462103843689,
0.5725258588790894,
0.5312455892562866,
-0.08280105888843536,
-0.26949813961982727,
-0.18516258895397186,
0.28543993830680847,
-0.5675864815711975,
0.6941608786582947,
-0.5242605209350586,
0.08278175443410873,
0.07171067595481873,
-0.09763996303081512,
-0.07625944912433624,
-0.2986304759979248,
0.1173340231180191,
-1.0317579507827759,
0.5555363893508911,
-0.17978230118751526,
-0.6089157462120056,
0.3395855724811554,
0.12370768189430237,
-0.43808555603027344,
1.1898952722549438,
-0.35544803738594055,
-0.7993568181991577,
0.2588341534137726,
-0.3100205957889557,
-0.2932717502117157,
-0.3079240620136261,
-0.0920635461807251,
-0.40587419271469116,
-0.1471671313047409,
0.4370828866958618,
0.11456847190856934,
-0.15418921411037445,
0.29094192385673523,
-0.12717308104038239,
-0.25691986083984375,
0.5496790409088135,
-0.2384333610534668,
0.8072835206985474,
0.5316212177276611,
-0.3085649013519287,
-0.090587317943573,
-0.6411016583442688,
0.378764271736145,
0.1894073784351349,
-0.23048730194568634,
-0.05373328924179077,
0.1421559900045395,
-0.441045343875885,
0.2559034824371338,
0.7621433734893799,
-0.3026791512966156,
0.3333396017551422,
-0.5406973361968994,
0.3459566831588745,
0.9897879362106323,
-0.15174224972724915,
0.4555824100971222,
-0.8010871410369873,
0.4601267874240875,
0.13508188724517822,
0.31316760182380676,
-0.15480074286460876,
-0.15267108380794525,
-0.7768558263778687,
0.5127333998680115,
-0.03317824751138687,
0.8100049495697021,
-0.34194186329841614,
0.4879242479801178,
-0.5717500448226929,
-0.5337632298469543,
-0.4547918140888214,
0.120437391102314,
0.3942483365535736,
0.682919979095459,
0.29906976222991943,
-0.2037409245967865,
-0.7155076265335083,
-0.6625347137451172,
-0.22665295004844666,
-0.2119625061750412,
0.2197481393814087,
-0.06074681878089905,
0.16686363518238068,
0.018001683056354523,
1.0332249402999878,
-0.4919491708278656,
0.12464365363121033,
0.32626983523368835,
0.07908165454864502,
0.33666685223579407,
0.456613689661026,
0.18598909676074982,
-0.3247741758823395,
-0.20171086490154266,
-0.03982803225517273,
-0.6280469298362732,
-0.5169516801834106,
-0.018337802961468697,
-0.14388929307460785,
0.1883024424314499,
0.6793224811553955,
-0.3726464509963989,
0.1135251373052597,
0.5901791453361511,
0.006056686397641897,
0.6374108195304871,
0.12317021191120148,
0.04510798677802086,
-1.2017624378204346,
0.05452951788902283,
-0.4401017725467682,
-0.21419905126094818,
-0.6481871604919434,
-0.477898508310318,
0.03984076529741287,
-0.11225530505180359,
-0.31596696376800537,
0.7248987555503845,
-0.6220435500144958,
0.06236954405903816,
-0.15475642681121826,
0.3467467129230499,
-0.24514007568359375,
0.4480673670768738,
-0.07349202781915665,
0.8156181573867798,
0.1348293125629425,
-0.7692579030990601,
-0.05429127439856529,
0.08870545029640198,
-0.802239716053009,
0.15332891047000885,
-0.47739893198013306,
0.6778223514556885,
-0.07198473066091537,
-0.11200577765703201,
-0.761021077632904,
0.032482728362083435,
0.017390768975019455,
-0.32384708523750305,
0.3537216782569885,
0.009101683273911476,
-0.36662521958351135,
-0.18847045302391052,
0.11173912137746811,
0.6021094918251038,
0.43653103709220886,
-0.3431468904018402,
0.35211706161499023,
0.37600743770599365,
-0.19829659163951874,
-0.9880052804946899,
-0.4770311415195465,
-0.23688896000385284,
-0.18778103590011597,
-0.5574285387992859,
0.5452162623405457,
-0.38959163427352905,
-0.46028509736061096,
0.03412019833922386,
-0.41034743189811707,
0.02657603845000267,
0.13614244759082794,
0.1363595575094223,
0.23514842987060547,
-0.5597602725028992,
0.30955103039741516,
-0.3130650818347931,
-0.10456445068120956,
-0.231376513838768,
-0.5009858012199402,
0.9845470190048218,
0.02421739511191845,
-0.4896595776081085,
-0.5904873013496399,
-0.1422441601753235,
0.4032934010028839,
-0.2916623651981354,
0.7529110312461853,
0.423396497964859,
-0.5462130308151245,
0.15392780303955078,
-0.9813282489776611,
-0.1297314316034317,
-0.45471328496932983,
0.1309092938899994,
-0.08445794880390167,
-0.928668737411499,
0.5853694677352905,
0.14191848039627075,
0.3904467821121216,
0.2828142046928406,
0.6334096789360046,
-0.4126616418361664,
1.0436747074127197,
0.6644675135612488,
-0.09604981541633606,
1.0504631996154785,
0.3244757652282715,
0.17515094578266144,
-0.6288914680480957,
-0.30047768354415894,
-0.5711823105812073,
-0.5577696561813354,
-0.3025847375392914,
-0.22918207943439484,
0.12304907292127609,
0.4861152768135071,
-0.7725896239280701,
0.24006745219230652,
-0.28766992688179016,
0.6248067617416382,
0.34946975111961365,
-0.01787203922867775,
0.2538418173789978,
-0.09832877665758133,
-0.1797088384628296,
-0.250600129365921,
-0.5062434673309326,
-0.7477253079414368,
1.0727944374084473,
0.15087883174419403,
0.8424744606018066,
0.19266599416732788,
0.4299785792827606,
-0.07293747365474701,
0.059099651873111725,
-0.26802003383636475,
0.37823721766471863,
0.06470704078674316,
-0.634946882724762,
-0.3550153076648712,
-0.24719306826591492,
-0.9940512180328369,
-0.34375280141830444,
-0.1695484071969986,
-0.9928078055381775,
0.018540799617767334,
0.32671666145324707,
-0.48996707797050476,
0.29166191816329956,
-0.5851783156394958,
0.6980862617492676,
-0.8235957026481628,
-0.3303663432598114,
0.03551027923822403,
-0.8894164562225342,
0.16963942348957062,
-0.17973074316978455,
0.19109795987606049,
-0.5326611995697021,
-0.061949968338012695,
0.8669157028198242,
-0.43630456924438477,
1.040060043334961,
0.11778629571199417,
-0.19034788012504578,
-0.0009945346973836422,
0.19166019558906555,
0.646334707736969,
-0.19199378788471222,
0.09450320154428482,
-0.05901432782411575,
0.433700293302536,
-0.26602813601493835,
-0.6663739085197449,
0.5220401287078857,
-1.068490982055664,
-0.7564610838890076,
-0.5117034316062927,
-0.764393150806427,
-0.37382766604423523,
0.3506990969181061,
0.2659880816936493,
0.42468371987342834,
-0.2758268415927887,
-0.2781285345554352,
0.6447567939758301,
0.09303772449493408,
0.686725914478302,
0.7316169142723083,
-0.6263022422790527,
-0.21800349652767181,
0.3930896818637848,
0.15680155158042908,
0.405629426240921,
0.7900816798210144,
0.18313215672969818,
-0.2745763659477234,
-0.37083306908607483,
-0.21900580823421478,
0.3089130222797394,
-0.5176150798797607,
-0.25021684169769287,
-0.5618463158607483,
-0.42853856086730957,
-0.6757875680923462,
-0.11959338933229446,
-0.36995214223861694,
-0.6095033288002014,
-0.4165056049823761,
0.023309718817472458,
0.23160722851753235,
0.6144083738327026,
0.09041439741849899,
0.6193137764930725,
-0.7497240900993347,
-0.06205543130636215,
0.3263649642467499,
0.21258807182312012,
-0.09369096159934998,
-0.6462976932525635,
-0.3237721920013428,
0.11174006760120392,
-0.31491488218307495,
-0.8694728016853333,
0.041358355432748795,
0.2536911368370056,
0.5888117551803589,
0.657909631729126,
-0.1215495765209198,
1.1428238153457642,
-0.7776925563812256,
0.7789595127105713,
0.05746147781610489,
-0.8026689887046814,
0.5427967309951782,
-0.31449782848358154,
0.7184348106384277,
0.3794819414615631,
0.4502462148666382,
-0.6264118552207947,
-0.26314306259155273,
-0.35104674100875854,
-0.46868500113487244,
0.6392675638198853,
0.04094437509775162,
-0.0055841407738626,
0.19751299917697906,
0.476725310087204,
0.03361106663942337,
0.22827553749084473,
-0.7955718040466309,
-0.03967539221048355,
-0.06347621977329254,
-0.4082031846046448,
-0.19723312556743622,
-0.23717616498470306,
-0.3986462950706482,
-0.1299695521593094,
0.7303786873817444,
-0.013413453474640846,
0.33035096526145935,
-0.10100686550140381,
-0.382724404335022,
-0.6086821556091309,
0.27869537472724915,
0.7777731418609619,
1.2031346559524536,
-0.20630937814712524,
0.2738775312900543,
0.309075266122818,
-0.3308226466178894,
0.21331200003623962,
0.16092844307422638,
-0.05772358924150467,
-0.37104764580726624,
0.7221629023551941,
0.825402021408081,
0.2703617811203003,
-0.4593668580055237,
0.08471963554620743,
0.04750955477356911,
0.3933405578136444,
-0.5768101811408997,
-0.03075641207396984,
0.07022999972105026,
0.5259845852851868,
0.1942412108182907,
-0.2291887402534485,
-0.7937308549880981,
-0.4950565993785858,
-0.04133877158164978,
0.4004058241844177,
-0.43077772855758667,
-0.5534552931785583,
0.7927451729774475,
-0.18040665984153748,
-0.5406442880630493,
0.6543144583702087,
0.26728591322898865,
-0.5908438563346863,
0.38770005106925964,
0.8840579986572266,
0.6065995693206787,
-0.6131190061569214,
-0.2532724440097809,
0.31349316239356995,
0.5160810947418213,
-0.1053871214389801,
0.3251144587993622,
0.027354024350643158,
-1.1972068548202515,
-0.42964786291122437,
-0.9419381618499756,
-0.04728322848677635,
0.17957930266857147,
-0.6756220459938049,
0.1577042192220688,
-0.4048977196216583,
-0.550101637840271,
-0.2873101234436035,
0.1971741020679474,
-0.8619374632835388,
0.20419207215309143,
-0.012030569836497307,
0.845469057559967,
-0.7300503253936768,
0.8686490058898926,
0.6062723398208618,
-0.2487844079732895,
-0.6830297708511353,
0.10933737456798553,
0.2529873549938202,
-1.2816107273101807,
0.6384620070457458,
-0.06024367734789848,
-0.3147909343242645,
0.2862624228000641,
-0.5747729539871216,
-1.1406751871109009,
1.18973708152771,
0.4552713632583618,
-0.9573749899864197,
-0.39484933018684387,
0.15288104116916656,
0.6316326260566711,
-0.2591650187969208,
-0.026972102001309395,
0.4080274999141693,
0.2991154193878174,
-0.1487373560667038,
-1.19484281539917,
-0.17442362010478973,
-0.3513055443763733,
-0.25432103872299194,
0.4755176305770874,
-0.4415193796157837,
0.7900511622428894,
-0.32864466309547424,
-0.6191820502281189,
0.17610344290733337,
0.6763099431991577,
-0.030329883098602295,
0.21437932550907135,
0.4448044002056122,
0.8900212645530701,
1.0383360385894775,
-0.3586556613445282,
0.808462381362915,
-0.5313335061073303,
-0.15276913344860077,
1.4178228378295898,
-0.412972629070282,
0.7322718501091003,
0.6254063844680786,
-0.29712021350860596,
0.4177781343460083,
0.7814896106719971,
0.3384106755256653,
0.6049155592918396,
0.015688391402363777,
-0.15757259726524353,
-0.5299020409584045,
-0.10477298498153687,
-0.7480259537696838,
0.0832875669002533,
0.09126369655132294,
0.03005870245397091,
-0.07528003305196762,
-0.2700101137161255,
0.23625221848487854,
-0.013075264170765877,
-0.18461795151233673,
0.9158564209938049,
0.15713171660900116,
-0.9119749665260315,
0.37646469473838806,
-0.42940962314605713,
0.2546565532684326,
-0.8497402667999268,
0.41284558176994324,
-0.18411201238632202,
0.4046098291873932,
0.020103221759200096,
-0.842816948890686,
0.17793317139148712,
0.018821878358721733,
-0.2797747254371643,
-0.3724847435951233,
0.34939539432525635,
-0.536639392375946,
-0.3213643431663513,
0.1430387943983078,
0.5961561799049377,
0.04354841262102127,
0.2940576672554016,
-0.5511173009872437,
0.1406424641609192,
-0.22392934560775757,
-0.05283847823739052,
0.3534582555294037,
0.504657506942749,
-0.1498054414987564,
0.712785542011261,
0.6879816651344299,
0.11862201243638992,
0.4798441529273987,
0.0845174789428711,
0.717510461807251,
-0.5609250068664551,
-0.3098219335079193,
-0.9621809720993042,
0.35178348422050476,
0.22831043601036072,
-0.5481963157653809,
0.5642185211181641,
0.45278695225715637,
0.9047580361366272,
0.18510958552360535,
0.30991247296333313,
0.2545895278453827,
0.48215192556381226,
-0.981713056564331,
0.6222500801086426,
-0.6861878037452698,
0.32171812653541565,
-0.06437757611274719,
-1.0330804586410522,
-0.13206887245178223,
0.3948216140270233,
-0.4863418638706207,
0.172268807888031,
0.7702564597129822,
0.9009677767753601,
0.21353182196617126,
0.10173717886209488,
0.06862332671880722,
0.2679210901260376,
0.25377342104911804,
0.6227815747261047,
1.205353021621704,
-0.1234750971198082,
0.6298922896385193,
-0.4202166199684143,
0.01311603095382452,
-0.08249838650226593,
-1.2024399042129517,
-0.8482791185379028,
-0.8278112411499023,
-0.16696882247924805,
-0.2848049998283386,
0.4829515516757965,
0.9515308141708374,
0.45179224014282227,
-0.8128326535224915,
-0.41902709007263184,
0.34176868200302124,
-0.208439439535141,
-0.2197939157485962,
-0.11623426526784897,
0.3499293029308319,
-0.5351746678352356,
-0.5102124214172363,
0.3940107524394989,
0.05555224418640137,
0.3805959224700928,
0.13337194919586182,
0.03891333192586899,
-0.4853247404098511,
-0.018528075888752937,
0.09087395668029785,
0.36933019757270813,
-0.6520655155181885,
-0.4066447913646698,
0.33975598216056824,
-0.23415611684322357,
0.21342253684997559,
0.9760838150978088,
-0.4439660310745239,
0.4818086624145508,
0.3655737042427063,
0.5167038440704346,
0.564944326877594,
0.17493200302124023,
0.7693089842796326,
-0.7279857397079468,
0.04297001659870148,
0.3597382605075836,
0.24285989999771118,
0.2257770150899887,
-0.17810262739658356,
0.3181532621383667,
0.04338690638542175,
-0.9544258117675781,
-0.8446371555328369,
0.2510429322719574,
-0.7542033195495605,
-0.16018220782279968,
0.6878331303596497,
0.29119130969047546,
-0.13906408846378326,
-0.1495765894651413,
0.17743125557899475,
0.7335183620452881,
0.080152727663517,
1.007493495941162,
1.0202957391738892,
-0.09256255626678467,
-0.03952694684267044,
-0.6042919158935547,
0.6558927297592163,
0.5458428859710693,
-0.7768352627754211,
-0.036253683269023895,
0.21201519668102264,
0.3592126667499542,
0.2228868305683136,
0.7159520387649536,
-0.1790844053030014,
0.11986615508794785,
-0.2990780174732208,
0.0416279174387455,
-0.05110227316617966,
-0.3613246977329254,
-0.21598634123802185,
-0.31980100274086,
0.12925823032855988,
0.0703870952129364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16795v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16795v2
|
If in a Crowdsourced Data Annotation Pipeline, a GPT-4
| 2024-02-26T18:08:52 | 2024-06-28T19:33:48 |
Zeyu He, Chieh-Yang Huang, Chien-Kuang Cornelia Ding, Shaurya Rohatgi, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent studies indicated GPT-4 outperforms online crowd workers in data
labeling accuracy, notably workers from Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk).
However, these studies were criticized for deviating from standard
crowdsourcing practices and emphasizing individual workers' performances over
the whole data-annotation process. This paper compared GPT-4 and an ethical and
well-executed MTurk pipeline, with 415 workers labeling 3,177 sentence segments
from 200 scholarly articles using the CODA-19 scheme. Two worker interfaces
yielded 127,080 labels, which were then used to infer the final labels through
eight label-aggregation algorithms. Our evaluation showed that despite best
practices, MTurk pipeline's highest accuracy was 81.5%, whereas GPT-4 achieved
83.6%. Interestingly, when combining GPT-4's labels with crowd labels collected
via an advanced worker interface for aggregation, 2 out of the 8 algorithms
achieved an even higher accuracy (87.5%, 87.0%). Further analysis suggested
that, when the crowd's and GPT-4's labeling strengths are complementary,
aggregating them could increase labeling accuracy.
|
[
-0.4173769950866699,
-0.2698934078216553,
0.6830024719238281,
0.22089742124080658,
-0.3073604106903076,
0.3582592308521271,
-0.03770934417843819,
-0.861113965511322,
0.23500245809555054,
0.28342220187187195,
-0.22315317392349243,
-0.5407393574714661,
-0.773566722869873,
0.7559231519699097,
-0.23855288326740265,
1.4789520502090454,
0.07483354210853577,
-0.05850718542933464,
-0.05182397738099098,
-0.47411468625068665,
-0.024611888453364372,
-0.690944254398346,
-0.3881039321422577,
-0.2549979090690613,
0.982324481010437,
0.08994929492473602,
0.8711994290351868,
1.021162986755371,
0.5183553695678711,
0.4006361961364746,
0.09586120396852493,
0.14370931684970856,
-0.5025203824043274,
-0.1560887098312378,
-0.14604005217552185,
-0.2500985264778137,
-0.36404046416282654,
0.7678837776184082,
0.347979873418808,
0.39583003520965576,
0.023196766152977943,
0.5218143463134766,
0.037844449281692505,
0.7916948795318604,
-0.5078714489936829,
0.13500337302684784,
-0.3834768533706665,
0.019708998501300812,
-1.001474142074585,
0.05823146924376488,
-0.34373602271080017,
-0.6990534663200378,
0.0738164409995079,
-1.079700231552124,
0.3153269588947296,
0.0294181015342474,
0.907058596611023,
0.46116968989372253,
-0.10439541935920715,
-0.3532743752002716,
-0.17830520868301392,
0.6961069703102112,
-0.5868270397186279,
0.246280238032341,
0.823871374130249,
-0.021192708984017372,
0.2978818118572235,
-1.0572909116744995,
-0.5529715418815613,
0.24288409948349,
-0.05871184170246124,
0.3472614884376526,
0.015699485316872597,
0.2081671804189682,
0.39947351813316345,
0.292934775352478,
-0.45709943771362305,
0.34855541586875916,
-0.7765762209892273,
-0.3392096757888794,
0.5963107347488403,
-0.059990208595991135,
-0.19056063890457153,
-0.2404823899269104,
-0.41592276096343994,
0.05935480445623398,
-0.3624800145626068,
-0.08714655041694641,
0.9097817540168762,
0.051570478826761246,
0.11726384609937668,
0.5808865427970886,
-0.4052838385105133,
1.010037899017334,
0.0752924308180809,
0.012510126456618309,
0.7927373051643372,
-0.482191264629364,
-0.14245525002479553,
-0.104521244764328,
1.0015019178390503,
0.4200901389122009,
0.18201376497745514,
-0.2187798172235489,
-0.1097482442855835,
-0.0011286441003903747,
0.3479343354701996,
-0.6233640313148499,
-0.4747283458709717,
0.20979993045330048,
-0.4869869351387024,
-0.40603262186050415,
0.28431814908981323,
-0.5801835656166077,
-0.46041738986968994,
-0.4243529438972473,
0.3853051960468292,
-0.09891021996736526,
0.15845030546188354,
-0.2995170056819916,
-0.36363816261291504,
-0.010072415694594383,
0.40360915660858154,
-0.6822644472122192,
-0.0625772550702095,
1.0017303228378296,
1.3626930713653564,
-0.29308661818504333,
-0.407989501953125,
-0.9369266629219055,
0.02786741778254509,
-0.2641505300998688,
0.8902571797370911,
-0.6839633584022522,
-0.13347767293453217,
-0.0628194808959961,
-0.2456672489643097,
0.018016787245869637,
-0.327686071395874,
0.7281908988952637,
-0.552603006362915,
0.47046273946762085,
-0.7066968083381653,
-0.6737263202667236,
-0.32011088728904724,
0.17497514188289642,
-1.0261539220809937,
1.0235862731933594,
0.25530189275741577,
-1.1071527004241943,
0.8414493799209595,
-0.9349517226219177,
-0.11356761306524277,
0.524972140789032,
-0.05427858233451843,
-0.5116744637489319,
-0.33020856976509094,
0.23129519820213318,
0.5680755972862244,
0.20821556448936462,
0.20798154175281525,
-0.3562185764312744,
-0.5471621751785278,
0.5042436718940735,
-0.1772453486919403,
0.9660452008247375,
0.39528316259384155,
-0.4843708872795105,
-0.11712337285280228,
-0.30339252948760986,
-0.006076475139707327,
-0.44679176807403564,
-0.6801720857620239,
-0.25732937455177307,
-0.3370131850242615,
-0.18166609108448029,
0.2348071038722992,
-0.07603461295366287,
-0.6821133494377136,
0.16346216201782227,
0.01899312622845173,
0.3680294156074524,
0.9917364716529846,
-0.15944747626781464,
0.2431623339653015,
-0.47804468870162964,
0.36457452178001404,
-0.5754960775375366,
0.08553716540336609,
0.17242179811000824,
-0.9919865727424622,
-0.2926360070705414,
-0.4501940906047821,
0.7027324438095093,
0.42314764857292175,
-1.0025228261947632,
0.16192685067653656,
-0.343761146068573,
-0.6944571137428284,
-0.8491566181182861,
0.08229139447212219,
0.3243606388568878,
0.6597409248352051,
0.33801019191741943,
-0.3700435757637024,
-0.3676246702671051,
-0.9581000208854675,
-0.7130042910575867,
-0.33824214339256287,
-0.3317233622074127,
-0.11186666786670685,
0.3711709976196289,
-0.05099676549434662,
0.8672381639480591,
-0.1244916170835495,
-0.3549462556838989,
0.3650366961956024,
0.6367700099945068,
0.20420204102993011,
0.22637853026390076,
0.3250329792499542,
-0.48684000968933105,
-0.4868583679199219,
-0.07974249124526978,
-0.6794682741165161,
-0.34419867396354675,
0.06862220913171768,
-0.25102823972702026,
0.40375614166259766,
-0.22250592708587646,
-0.35536521673202515,
0.36881035566329956,
0.6796781420707703,
-0.31981757283210754,
0.5120227932929993,
-0.06575342267751694,
0.5569460391998291,
-0.5118324160575867,
0.050360240042209625,
0.1817544400691986,
-0.2455926388502121,
-0.49024316668510437,
-0.17811521887779236,
0.045533373951911926,
0.16078895330429077,
-0.2419147938489914,
-0.04872428998351097,
-0.4248257875442505,
-0.16966399550437927,
-0.1494864970445633,
0.3320577144622803,
0.0504736565053463,
0.2673403322696686,
0.003921438939869404,
0.8028436899185181,
0.12161850929260254,
-0.15272730588912964,
0.5211790800094604,
0.27643418312072754,
-0.3739449977874756,
0.7653895616531372,
-0.32502907514572144,
0.6804447174072266,
0.16666516661643982,
0.6352460980415344,
-0.829629123210907,
-0.20668192207813263,
0.42561817169189453,
-0.5378980040550232,
-0.32691261172294617,
-0.23106731474399567,
-0.7622374296188354,
-0.5387095808982849,
-0.542752742767334,
0.31522440910339355,
0.3772504925727844,
-0.5782431960105896,
0.25453633069992065,
0.42097365856170654,
-0.35138848423957825,
-0.5459164381027222,
-1.0205150842666626,
0.28386950492858887,
-0.37851592898368835,
-0.597103476524353,
0.047425877302885056,
0.32399916648864746,
-0.11384844034910202,
-0.1465837061405182,
0.1448676586151123,
-0.171611949801445,
-0.2814112901687622,
0.2287435382604599,
0.1400609165430069,
0.07608244568109512,
0.12273299694061279,
-0.39290478825569153,
-0.32182419300079346,
0.011797930113971233,
-0.23766115307807922,
-0.012929883785545826,
-0.18227076530456543,
-0.3059762418270111,
-0.633442759513855,
0.09796962141990662,
0.17847934365272522,
-0.2615644335746765,
0.5773176550865173,
1.0059374570846558,
-0.07863443344831467,
0.5997740626335144,
-0.9251713156700134,
-0.13009127974510193,
-0.5006400942802429,
-0.02487216703593731,
-0.20457279682159424,
-0.8631974458694458,
0.3616008460521698,
0.0830962136387825,
0.5029389262199402,
0.5481932163238525,
0.42841577529907227,
-0.26870205998420715,
0.49035605788230896,
0.025129299610853195,
-0.17456863820552826,
0.1720464825630188,
-0.10548481345176697,
0.09457442909479141,
-0.586493194103241,
-0.27116063237190247,
-0.7046934366226196,
-0.6092292666435242,
-0.7684499025344849,
-0.7243655920028687,
0.3885903060436249,
-0.3896697163581848,
-0.19438819587230682,
0.09391362220048904,
-0.97259920835495,
0.4076187312602997,
0.8485779166221619,
0.11073683947324753,
0.6657549738883972,
0.0337463915348053,
0.6083589196205139,
-0.21373872458934784,
-0.4468214809894562,
-0.7330775260925293,
1.121641755104065,
0.2966533303260803,
0.18772061169147491,
-0.027465160936117172,
0.6242899894714355,
0.5895561575889587,
0.822109580039978,
-0.2577860355377197,
0.12676949799060822,
0.007915751077234745,
-0.9085853695869446,
-0.5229495167732239,
-0.3413323163986206,
-0.9150984287261963,
0.389416366815567,
-0.03910183906555176,
-0.7399530410766602,
0.27790576219558716,
0.1643858402967453,
-0.2905803918838501,
0.3918300271034241,
-0.99678635597229,
0.705158531665802,
-0.11719748377799988,
-0.3276388347148895,
0.05772896856069565,
-0.8741462230682373,
0.26456570625305176,
-0.45555058121681213,
0.628959596157074,
-0.19139759242534637,
-0.40071022510528564,
1.243920087814331,
-0.7452201843261719,
0.7739658951759338,
-0.4677424430847168,
0.003885328071191907,
0.6431021690368652,
-0.2996126711368561,
0.9037303328514099,
-0.16471777856349945,
-0.4880017936229706,
0.6319843530654907,
-0.2146235555410385,
-0.6115502715110779,
-0.2282143235206604,
0.4058815836906433,
-0.6728104948997498,
-0.35278964042663574,
-0.5965897440910339,
-0.34567487239837646,
-0.05551394075155258,
0.0025197851937264204,
0.4548461437225342,
0.3947911858558655,
0.2876657247543335,
0.09422308206558228,
0.1388731151819229,
0.10822927951812744,
0.5721165537834167,
0.23466171324253082,
0.19257351756095886,
-0.7450701594352722,
0.9259058833122253,
0.5869450569152832,
0.041469279676675797,
-0.05271507427096367,
0.15393894910812378,
-0.5562832951545715,
-0.5347709059715271,
-0.8356754183769226,
0.050992030650377274,
-0.485217422246933,
-0.4093344807624817,
-0.9121440649032593,
0.33165478706359863,
-0.13028882443904877,
-0.2552686929702759,
-0.25672584772109985,
-0.3719179332256317,
-0.148240327835083,
-0.6331368088722229,
0.8445621728897095,
0.8787223100662231,
-0.37067633867263794,
0.20809601247310638,
-0.6283832788467407,
0.11059896647930145,
0.34155306220054626,
0.5500470399856567,
-0.45910006761550903,
-0.36388707160949707,
-0.3346177041530609,
0.12227065116167068,
-0.2642234265804291,
-1.025542974472046,
-0.07757958769798279,
0.0002194308181060478,
0.3735162019729614,
0.4848455786705017,
0.04782616347074509,
0.8043918609619141,
-0.2508229911327362,
0.8356568217277527,
0.16680021584033966,
-1.013496994972229,
-0.08482720702886581,
-0.7574493885040283,
0.16796325147151947,
0.7176448106765747,
0.36270958185195923,
-0.5557534098625183,
-0.7111963629722595,
-0.7514645457267761,
-0.8360660672187805,
0.7785608768463135,
0.6955883502960205,
-0.1576882004737854,
0.2243012934923172,
0.13866350054740906,
0.7339702248573303,
0.1597609519958496,
-0.8496531844139099,
-0.15633217990398407,
-0.6493982076644897,
-0.01535837259143591,
0.04665862396359444,
0.04281089827418327,
-0.11344463378190994,
-0.11958584934473038,
0.5429283976554871,
0.08811195939779282,
0.1161385327577591,
0.13913603127002716,
0.06377453356981277,
0.03922303766012192,
0.027715349569916725,
0.3492950201034546,
1.0738285779953003,
-0.021563975140452385,
0.35465583205223083,
0.26682260632514954,
-0.6214306950569153,
0.005318093113601208,
0.5301940441131592,
-0.1333530992269516,
0.09829821437597275,
0.5269457697868347,
0.5602680444717407,
-0.39678725600242615,
-0.31707215309143066,
0.34667330980300903,
0.300169974565506,
-0.5142109394073486,
-0.006821236573159695,
-0.2763260006904602,
0.26335740089416504,
0.10153055191040039,
0.7166005969047546,
0.12567993998527527,
0.5299554467201233,
-0.08816726505756378,
0.21141666173934937,
0.002540897112339735,
-0.13981321454048157,
-0.2710011303424835,
0.7175542712211609,
0.5715713500976562,
-0.2608380615711212,
0.6857814192771912,
-0.380188524723053,
-0.38983091711997986,
0.3601300120353699,
-0.06524807214736938,
0.4652225971221924,
-0.2405954748392105,
0.5348455905914307,
0.2528286874294281,
0.4705847203731537,
-0.30455607175827026,
-0.11716233193874359,
-0.0259235892444849,
-0.34631261229515076,
-0.9270744919776917,
-0.10771214962005615,
-0.5436183214187622,
-0.08081614226102829,
-0.5371366739273071,
-0.17424939572811127,
-0.12666527926921844,
-0.3905097544193268,
0.12776696681976318,
0.07757306843996048,
-0.8744368553161621,
0.19648830592632294,
-0.0587606318295002,
0.2940331697463989,
-0.983095645904541,
0.46314430236816406,
0.8159354329109192,
-0.36794301867485046,
-0.8188754916191101,
-0.2907365560531616,
0.16967648267745972,
-0.5609912276268005,
0.3702646493911743,
0.3841880261898041,
0.06865409016609192,
0.05082239583134651,
-0.6332308650016785,
-0.9221497774124146,
1.0854341983795166,
0.2208193838596344,
-0.4788104295730591,
0.5253133773803711,
0.0526759997010231,
0.519332230091095,
0.08704793453216553,
0.360719233751297,
0.47944918274879456,
1.0522191524505615,
-0.15307730436325073,
-1.0733964443206787,
0.12305358797311783,
-0.1141994446516037,
-0.30255624651908875,
0.05765910819172859,
-0.8748939633369446,
0.465943306684494,
-0.07425852119922638,
-0.15077784657478333,
-0.3180476725101471,
0.690775990486145,
0.5327489376068115,
0.7487527132034302,
0.6355780959129333,
0.582236647605896,
1.2089767456054688,
-0.30155912041664124,
0.9685733914375305,
0.3644289970397949,
0.24899102747440338,
0.6489304304122925,
-0.10804031044244766,
0.3873675763607025,
0.38710978627204895,
-0.5577291250228882,
0.44724711775779724,
1.0761414766311646,
-0.2599758803844452,
0.36666417121887207,
0.19331303238868713,
-0.11340832710266113,
0.08000499755144119,
0.03905227407813072,
-0.4223090410232544,
0.14659222960472107,
0.0852353498339653,
-0.18277214467525482,
0.13053637742996216,
-0.0748206302523613,
0.27185797691345215,
-0.038293905556201935,
-0.19380080699920654,
0.696999192237854,
-0.1317366659641266,
-0.6752078533172607,
0.3330512046813965,
-0.011473068036139011,
0.7636166214942932,
0.10588885843753815,
0.05169441178441048,
-0.1648724526166916,
-0.40382441878318787,
-0.5987435579299927,
-0.8482164144515991,
0.24828247725963593,
0.3760632276535034,
0.11283184587955475,
-0.4611755609512329,
0.45137330889701843,
-0.23957738280296326,
-0.38451099395751953,
-0.278613805770874,
0.5001312494277954,
0.7080748081207275,
-0.2953858971595764,
-0.44698798656463623,
0.1958429366350174,
0.17707887291908264,
-0.36287036538124084,
0.03178832679986954,
0.6595968008041382,
0.033904220908880234,
0.4356659948825836,
0.7479249835014343,
-0.10951552540063858,
0.2326958030462265,
0.0033181090839207172,
0.6621870994567871,
-0.5682422518730164,
-0.5934588313102722,
-0.8266541361808777,
0.5681177973747253,
-0.5552798509597778,
-0.4062478542327881,
0.6291275024414062,
0.817503035068512,
0.8657311201095581,
-0.057371970266103745,
1.0023616552352905,
-0.15615281462669373,
0.564763069152832,
-0.4105531573295593,
0.48937639594078064,
0.06978322565555573,
-0.12611263990402222,
-0.48142141103744507,
-0.9212139844894409,
-0.28142687678337097,
0.5928145051002502,
-0.5219588279724121,
0.34319859743118286,
0.7584906220436096,
0.26631590723991394,
0.15525417029857635,
0.30846700072288513,
-0.03982231765985489,
-0.05964045226573944,
0.29924046993255615,
0.13780884444713593,
0.6920398473739624,
0.011352358385920525,
0.792339563369751,
-0.38210543990135193,
-0.3429313898086548,
-0.009867818094789982,
-0.9960364699363708,
-0.7613686323165894,
-0.5762735605239868,
-0.48888227343559265,
-0.13106805086135864,
0.19410677254199982,
0.5280459523200989,
0.6810089349746704,
-0.532950758934021,
0.16390793025493622,
0.2412954568862915,
-0.12139680981636047,
-0.3938750922679901,
-0.22233867645263672,
0.5513437986373901,
-0.138176828622818,
-0.8495876789093018,
0.03711621090769768,
0.2221623659133911,
-0.2665518522262573,
-0.06324020773172379,
-0.11562959849834442,
-0.1141439899802208,
-0.4152301847934723,
0.41369175910949707,
0.05241049826145172,
-0.6487374901771545,
-0.36249151825904846,
-0.3796992301940918,
-0.1752810776233673,
0.1513829529285431,
0.7872719168663025,
-0.7935567498207092,
0.48848989605903625,
0.41999930143356323,
0.8129614591598511,
0.6206878423690796,
0.8852785229682922,
0.46877434849739075,
-0.5492871403694153,
-0.039455268532037735,
0.3301917314529419,
-0.04916422814130783,
0.6640148758888245,
-0.4622296392917633,
1.0620614290237427,
0.48067763447761536,
-1.0046231746673584,
-0.5139561295509338,
-0.2735706567764282,
-0.8207547664642334,
0.09119666367769241,
1.1274927854537964,
-0.21753884851932526,
0.17125371098518372,
-0.6927069425582886,
-0.22794927656650543,
0.3410378098487854,
-0.8206268548965454,
0.9912334680557251,
0.9130146503448486,
-0.3770392835140228,
0.05613670498132706,
-0.8077390193939209,
0.45346125960350037,
0.12270794063806534,
-0.7880778908729553,
-0.11965014040470123,
0.761249840259552,
0.23471437394618988,
0.16113422811031342,
0.9511036276817322,
-0.04431268572807312,
0.01546446979045868,
-0.05223964527249336,
0.23023439943790436,
-0.3677862584590912,
0.46371084451675415,
0.2602393627166748,
0.2600145936012268,
0.0019165088888257742,
-0.5261409282684326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16786v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16786v2
|
Political Compass or Spinning Arrow? Towards More Meaningful Evaluations for Values and Opinions in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-26T18:00:49 | 2024-06-05T10:17:53 |
Paul Röttger, Valentin Hofmann, Valentina Pyatkin, Musashi Hinck, Hannah Rose Kirk, Hinrich Schütze, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Much recent work seeks to evaluate values and opinions in large language
models (LLMs) using multiple-choice surveys and questionnaires. Most of this
work is motivated by concerns around real-world LLM applications. For example,
politically-biased LLMs may subtly influence society when they are used by
millions of people. Such real-world concerns, however, stand in stark contrast
to the artificiality of current evaluations: real users do not typically ask
LLMs survey questions. Motivated by this discrepancy, we challenge the
prevailing constrained evaluation paradigm for values and opinions in LLMs and
explore more realistic unconstrained evaluations. As a case study, we focus on
the popular Political Compass Test (PCT). In a systematic review, we find that
most prior work using the PCT forces models to comply with the PCT's
multiple-choice format. We show that models give substantively different
answers when not forced; that answers change depending on how models are
forced; and that answers lack paraphrase robustness. Then, we demonstrate that
models give different answers yet again in a more realistic open-ended answer
setting. We distill these findings into recommendations and open challenges in
evaluating values and opinions in LLMs.
|
[
-0.3416772782802582,
-0.39103108644485474,
0.7336838841438293,
-0.010961824096739292,
-0.5620172619819641,
0.28052687644958496,
-0.4156322777271271,
-0.29380956292152405,
0.1116257756948471,
0.4606315791606903,
-0.5696102976799011,
-0.34432199597358704,
-0.5617764592170715,
0.18943853676319122,
-0.14968642592430115,
1.0685330629348755,
0.13691306114196777,
0.3745233118534088,
-0.07737653702497482,
-0.28294235467910767,
-0.27562275528907776,
-0.6925978660583496,
-0.19376900792121887,
-0.5267190933227539,
0.5755543112754822,
0.30030813813209534,
1.1873167753219604,
0.4476841688156128,
0.6248587369918823,
0.19994252920150757,
-0.19353385269641876,
0.07170268148183823,
-0.5996711254119873,
0.07347527891397476,
-0.31465309858322144,
-0.3816535174846649,
-0.15817902982234955,
0.6055163741111755,
0.44571125507354736,
0.8117537498474121,
0.13020485639572144,
0.28718504309654236,
0.03700457885861397,
0.7993623614311218,
-0.5355731844902039,
0.20076535642147064,
-0.866861879825592,
-0.09218452125787735,
-0.11216060817241669,
-0.01000137161463499,
-0.2668944001197815,
-0.6165282130241394,
0.3633100390434265,
-0.45041558146476746,
-0.19595271348953247,
0.14807675778865814,
0.8976072669029236,
-0.15075182914733887,
-0.610123336315155,
-0.5148316621780396,
-0.7487769722938538,
1.073814868927002,
-0.5353928804397583,
0.3126058876514435,
0.10732297599315643,
0.41739875078201294,
-0.13591526448726654,
-0.448417603969574,
-0.5266462564468384,
-0.39792564511299133,
0.2649264633655548,
0.18168410658836365,
-0.0016037754248827696,
-0.03659097105264664,
-0.09365354478359222,
0.33319687843322754,
-0.17779196798801422,
-0.04696698859333992,
-0.2917294502258301,
0.1581781506538391,
0.6037552952766418,
0.26126864552497864,
-0.12486211210489273,
-0.5102726221084595,
-0.34751075506210327,
-0.27074795961380005,
-1.0989967584609985,
0.1528320610523224,
0.612553596496582,
0.5881630182266235,
0.1670284867286682,
0.7738673090934753,
0.10875029116868973,
0.5205773115158081,
0.4036325514316559,
0.07942333072423935,
0.0016380648594349623,
-0.297555148601532,
-0.03459453582763672,
-0.29842349886894226,
0.7050665616989136,
0.7087906002998352,
0.5533340573310852,
0.21340860426425934,
-0.2857162654399872,
-0.027470888569951057,
0.0029827586840838194,
-0.741280198097229,
0.0750712901353836,
0.23271574079990387,
-0.689734697341919,
-0.40019655227661133,
0.3092136085033417,
-0.9102357029914856,
-0.8432217836380005,
-0.5935899019241333,
-0.01750766485929489,
-0.18948662281036377,
-0.39011168479919434,
0.08509301394224167,
-0.013278050348162651,
0.4973183572292328,
0.5157521963119507,
-0.557209312915802,
0.028611162677407265,
1.100078821182251,
0.836306095123291,
-0.3531792163848877,
-0.07490408420562744,
-0.42085984349250793,
-0.4710475504398346,
-0.42744165658950806,
0.856513500213623,
-0.96326744556427,
-0.42970290780067444,
0.10488367825746536,
-0.02644171565771103,
0.10065972059965134,
-0.5648812651634216,
0.2495088428258896,
-0.5907459855079651,
0.3159749209880829,
-0.9504298567771912,
-0.3894522488117218,
-0.015135658904910088,
0.4100888967514038,
-0.6133908033370972,
0.8036351203918457,
0.05761761590838432,
-0.6806622743606567,
0.6208839416503906,
-0.48338285088539124,
-0.18858899176120758,
-0.046742331236600876,
-0.43886473774909973,
-0.2835787534713745,
0.3135607838630676,
-0.11354678869247437,
0.22873081266880035,
-0.7207932472229004,
0.36296817660331726,
-0.6498832702636719,
-0.29235976934432983,
0.6802458763122559,
-0.6439939141273499,
0.997891366481781,
0.2672097682952881,
-0.3159452974796295,
0.16664455831050873,
-0.7329442501068115,
0.10788261890411377,
-0.1921645551919937,
-0.3394363522529602,
-0.26950696110725403,
0.18240053951740265,
0.1242440864443779,
0.4572846591472626,
0.05218090862035751,
-0.7038163542747498,
0.15883873403072357,
-0.36190155148506165,
0.40523388981819153,
1.188966155052185,
-0.07953428477048874,
0.4593453109264374,
-0.5501947999000549,
0.767961859703064,
-0.31216859817504883,
0.09644699841737747,
0.48533886671066284,
-0.4557381570339203,
-0.6005653142929077,
-0.18749336898326874,
0.11406555026769638,
0.5053806900978088,
-0.6259452104568481,
0.11991406977176666,
-0.23910212516784668,
-0.6775190830230713,
-0.8122686743736267,
-0.08662130683660507,
0.08496727049350739,
0.2608169615268707,
0.06956060975790024,
0.01255798153579235,
-0.2539522051811218,
-0.6980679035186768,
-0.7444131970405579,
-0.5157821178436279,
-0.17151057720184326,
0.3851414918899536,
0.7282711863517761,
0.27760082483291626,
0.9379609823226929,
-0.24607880413532257,
0.03296712413430214,
-0.3523656129837036,
0.19587430357933044,
0.4554522633552551,
0.03565753251314163,
0.1777249425649643,
-0.6651948690414429,
-0.5028574466705322,
0.07127010077238083,
-0.4184854030609131,
-0.24546730518341064,
-0.32491353154182434,
0.18437813222408295,
0.0639946311712265,
0.10985273867845535,
-0.7022165060043335,
0.27708783745765686,
0.49109673500061035,
-0.3613062798976898,
0.723077654838562,
0.13941709697246552,
0.3692499101161957,
-0.7273135185241699,
0.04394261911511421,
-0.181731179356575,
-0.14345736801624298,
-0.5500269532203674,
0.0636105090379715,
-0.020859552547335625,
0.1534484475851059,
-0.577470064163208,
0.3306286633014679,
-0.45303377509117126,
0.014082138426601887,
-0.29841408133506775,
0.3766767680644989,
-0.04420606791973114,
-0.0273024532943964,
0.08668707311153412,
0.7007318735122681,
0.16440925002098083,
-0.2554550766944885,
0.5911827683448792,
0.030930275097489357,
-0.5012051463127136,
1.0077074766159058,
-0.6810436844825745,
0.25460100173950195,
-0.2653020918369293,
0.13940423727035522,
-1.0593699216842651,
0.009061520919203758,
0.09373857080936432,
-0.20623642206192017,
-0.15170833468437195,
-0.15736296772956848,
-0.33732882142066956,
-0.09423665702342987,
-0.7554408311843872,
0.18894712626934052,
0.48580020666122437,
-0.6288666725158691,
0.3927336037158966,
0.46431511640548706,
0.0630936473608017,
-0.5403420329093933,
-0.3794670104980469,
0.09903664141893387,
-0.42246320843696594,
-0.5344566106796265,
-0.06741221994161606,
-0.08037005364894867,
-0.7660576105117798,
-0.07470998913049698,
-0.14809595048427582,
0.01752607524394989,
-0.0968158021569252,
0.09936687350273132,
0.27989357709884644,
-0.2121858298778534,
0.21013136208057404,
-0.2863571047782898,
0.03335022181272507,
-0.002191597828641534,
-0.13887465000152588,
0.4518990218639374,
-0.6977099776268005,
-0.636665940284729,
-0.21058084070682526,
0.35774797201156616,
0.9748717546463013,
-0.35789304971694946,
0.5598373413085938,
0.08633974939584732,
0.013499625027179718,
0.041304778307676315,
-0.5197848677635193,
-0.16139793395996094,
-0.4834657907485962,
0.33469030261039734,
-0.23338072001934052,
-0.9548372030258179,
0.5287140011787415,
-0.12229105830192566,
0.3399072587490082,
0.4534376561641693,
0.744786262512207,
-0.08309826254844666,
0.9525483846664429,
0.16160503029823303,
0.06274434179067612,
0.16829568147659302,
0.13243885338306427,
0.5365245938301086,
-0.7204999327659607,
-0.11271563917398453,
-0.703642725944519,
-0.22951754927635193,
-0.8896099328994751,
-0.4055350720882416,
0.45400938391685486,
-0.2012265920639038,
-0.2362322062253952,
-0.08971080183982849,
-0.5672343969345093,
0.4505607783794403,
0.1501350998878479,
-0.14494936168193817,
0.4374089241027832,
-0.20798799395561218,
0.02218579314649105,
-0.2524549663066864,
-0.5300446152687073,
-0.8392794728279114,
1.2068021297454834,
0.264622300863266,
0.9469852447509766,
0.011356099508702755,
0.2930075228214264,
-0.07409839332103729,
0.6710096597671509,
-0.9490851759910583,
0.542394757270813,
-0.01432078704237938,
-0.7733191847801208,
-0.48772919178009033,
-0.2830302119255066,
-0.9761728048324585,
0.7699013352394104,
-0.2345799058675766,
-0.40816760063171387,
0.26239344477653503,
-0.03179216757416725,
-0.28280168771743774,
0.48673737049102783,
-0.10733400285243988,
0.5652313232421875,
-0.3974013030529022,
-0.3653803765773773,
0.024740738794207573,
-0.5811553597450256,
0.3244606554508209,
0.0213264599442482,
0.36624354124069214,
-0.31712642312049866,
-0.05183427408337593,
0.5233740210533142,
-0.4761750400066376,
0.7775188684463501,
-0.04941948503255844,
-0.014751801267266273,
0.40141451358795166,
0.022940943017601967,
0.374642014503479,
0.06541670858860016,
-0.4207479953765869,
-0.04948972165584564,
0.31225311756134033,
-0.17331302165985107,
-0.5428281426429749,
0.7532234787940979,
-0.7563849091529846,
-0.9485865831375122,
-0.8388497829437256,
-0.6131631731987,
-0.08649254590272903,
0.10472080111503601,
0.2381569743156433,
0.14599129557609558,
-0.2954500913619995,
0.4821814298629761,
0.5493643283843994,
-0.2050660401582718,
0.16228370368480682,
0.38612568378448486,
-0.3563643991947174,
-0.3765302002429962,
0.501670777797699,
0.4336148798465729,
0.6176339983940125,
0.07607205212116241,
0.5920241475105286,
-0.33360061049461365,
-0.3121910095214844,
-0.4470060467720032,
0.3184717297554016,
-0.7969616055488586,
-0.10617181658744812,
-0.053111832588911057,
0.15896326303482056,
-0.2383379489183426,
-0.301257848739624,
-0.693335771560669,
-0.5475045442581177,
-0.3163524568080902,
-0.0796755775809288,
0.41893836855888367,
0.9913687705993652,
0.04248139634728432,
0.08255086839199066,
-0.23548410832881927,
0.0718516856431961,
0.21083101630210876,
0.3228873014450073,
-0.22050374746322632,
-0.42646417021751404,
0.24596887826919556,
0.09395308047533035,
-0.3734123408794403,
-1.2359230518341064,
0.11703402549028397,
-0.005366381257772446,
0.2818564772605896,
0.4329098165035248,
0.412447452545166,
0.7794559001922607,
-0.5847739577293396,
0.9802184700965881,
0.06291812658309937,
-0.8572742342948914,
0.045436691492795944,
-0.27568620443344116,
0.5073909759521484,
0.8471794724464417,
0.3620590269565582,
-0.7393890619277954,
-0.5398845076560974,
-0.3364615738391876,
-0.6875478625297546,
0.21029284596443176,
-0.02828959748148918,
0.2535809874534607,
-0.16027969121932983,
0.43301811814308167,
0.13219894468784332,
0.4401703178882599,
-0.993472158908844,
0.0054528312757611275,
-0.3532164990901947,
-0.06424164772033691,
0.12848800420761108,
-0.0634133368730545,
-0.08558764308691025,
-0.27810877561569214,
0.4442991018295288,
-0.06877632439136505,
0.0019108488922938704,
0.2786257266998291,
0.1318649798631668,
-0.2189898043870926,
0.625327467918396,
0.36263614892959595,
0.9317461252212524,
-0.1578003466129303,
0.32509657740592957,
0.19073760509490967,
-0.14732931554317474,
0.2418089061975479,
-0.2857385575771332,
-0.31453680992126465,
0.13965649902820587,
0.22875778377056122,
0.4308423101902008,
-0.08354377746582031,
-0.431645929813385,
0.778612494468689,
0.13207365572452545,
-0.13998210430145264,
-0.37267640233039856,
-0.4955902695655823,
0.16611774265766144,
-0.008906095288693905,
0.16146546602249146,
-0.08641703426837921,
-0.0759291723370552,
-0.8299705982208252,
-0.13166838884353638,
1.0241578817367554,
-0.551994800567627,
-0.3369204103946686,
0.36319929361343384,
0.20019245147705078,
-0.415902704000473,
0.4428880512714386,
-0.14521348476409912,
-0.7615991830825806,
0.47348910570144653,
0.3433939516544342,
0.843223512172699,
-0.3150627315044403,
0.2879236042499542,
-0.08969748020172119,
0.8035477995872498,
0.023338770493865013,
0.5500912666320801,
0.2898894250392914,
-0.5437090992927551,
-0.4498286545276642,
-0.37088820338249207,
-0.6563308238983154,
0.44798269867897034,
-0.6063264012336731,
0.37775442004203796,
-0.7442494034767151,
-0.23147521913051605,
-0.27651676535606384,
0.15747487545013428,
-0.49889224767684937,
-0.12973777949810028,
-0.284493625164032,
0.7655060887336731,
-0.8879213929176331,
0.6323425769805908,
0.46145159006118774,
-0.13806559145450592,
-0.46517714858055115,
-0.08244670927524567,
0.28614315390586853,
-0.6140965819358826,
0.520069420337677,
0.11658601462841034,
-0.6188192367553711,
-0.6478250622749329,
-0.5566709637641907,
-0.743508517742157,
0.7976972460746765,
0.2525942027568817,
-0.4300905466079712,
0.19292277097702026,
0.4948113262653351,
0.5669605731964111,
-0.5557174682617188,
0.3752225637435913,
0.5865591168403625,
0.7970833778381348,
0.13046050071716309,
-0.8894819617271423,
0.022048063576221466,
0.13851462304592133,
0.011647481471300125,
0.07785304635763168,
-0.8412260413169861,
1.1009026765823364,
-0.14911003410816193,
-0.22406154870986938,
0.09011127799749374,
0.5239793062210083,
0.41837477684020996,
0.20567910373210907,
0.5907385349273682,
-0.12777858972549438,
0.8018055558204651,
-0.06809557229280472,
1.0253700017929077,
-0.2639208734035492,
0.39673376083374023,
0.9483560919761658,
-0.7980167865753174,
0.8583436608314514,
0.8564856648445129,
-0.16596576571464539,
0.24415211379528046,
0.6809097528457642,
-0.07566814869642258,
0.33232367038726807,
0.6730640530586243,
-0.254973441362381,
-0.3693213164806366,
-0.09589114785194397,
-0.24416430294513702,
0.537418007850647,
0.16756877303123474,
0.005629553459584713,
-0.2538350224494934,
-0.23750126361846924,
0.4843144118785858,
0.4498445689678192,
-0.17877702414989471,
0.3151170611381531,
0.19058364629745483,
-0.7832415103912354,
0.45417067408561707,
0.03462638705968857,
0.4276224970817566,
-0.44823139905929565,
-0.08241540938615799,
-0.004361617844551802,
0.08307825773954391,
-0.11793366819620132,
-0.9400330781936646,
0.23490215837955475,
0.2814246714115143,
0.12953878939151764,
-0.40749484300613403,
0.443889856338501,
-0.3006832003593445,
-0.6228775382041931,
0.09277521073818207,
0.5492300391197205,
0.10737196356058121,
-0.01595521904528141,
-0.7009233832359314,
0.20127274096012115,
-0.052854906767606735,
-0.5708463191986084,
0.18030790984630585,
0.4234671890735626,
-0.025899697095155716,
0.6946386694908142,
0.6900217533111572,
0.2964639961719513,
-0.1766037493944168,
-0.19726118445396423,
0.8319680690765381,
-0.39576494693756104,
-0.32970985770225525,
-0.9419732093811035,
0.32925945520401,
-0.1843460649251938,
-0.5349282622337341,
0.9055114984512329,
0.47510722279548645,
0.8294061422348022,
0.043025851249694824,
0.8697916865348816,
0.08669354021549225,
0.5700876116752625,
-0.4622458815574646,
0.8002405762672424,
-0.2572844326496124,
0.5653753876686096,
-0.38835716247558594,
-0.775143027305603,
-0.42610612511634827,
0.9775845408439636,
-0.6571094393730164,
0.2612084150314331,
0.7768853902816772,
0.632889986038208,
0.1875118762254715,
0.1410742700099945,
0.34402352571487427,
0.10706430673599243,
0.5168119668960571,
0.5392539501190186,
1.3324497938156128,
-0.01766277849674225,
0.4345763027667999,
-0.04984384402632713,
-0.4510178565979004,
0.05550503358244896,
-1.3225107192993164,
-1.1411819458007812,
-0.4637831449508667,
-0.2000349760055542,
-0.4999234676361084,
0.03185832500457764,
1.3477720022201538,
0.4952319860458374,
-0.7349863648414612,
-0.8272144198417664,
0.20910678803920746,
0.3901820480823517,
-0.06017952412366867,
-0.1932668387889862,
0.4378628134727478,
-0.06230916827917099,
-0.6581421494483948,
0.098038449883461,
0.23115846514701843,
-0.24934150278568268,
-0.5347371697425842,
0.028111131861805916,
-0.1601191610097885,
0.4024129807949066,
0.6493126749992371,
0.12433161586523056,
-0.9058124423027039,
-0.7885070443153381,
0.19239577651023865,
0.12900620698928833,
0.17657318711280823,
0.976859986782074,
-0.4857964813709259,
0.4357011020183563,
0.44544729590415955,
0.4681864380836487,
0.044959906488657,
0.0055913846008479595,
0.5544078946113586,
-0.1041778028011322,
-0.16043494641780853,
0.4482237696647644,
0.15706424415111542,
0.41181930899620056,
-0.13883467018604279,
0.07088442146778107,
0.1439124494791031,
-0.6155365705490112,
-0.8776147365570068,
0.5516613721847534,
-0.7846314907073975,
-0.33812475204467773,
1.4244089126586914,
-0.07932130992412567,
-0.09894701093435287,
-0.13872069120407104,
-0.14395107328891754,
-0.14735372364521027,
-0.26755210757255554,
0.8107694387435913,
1.0989207029342651,
-0.2296363115310669,
-0.13327006995677948,
-0.5546374917030334,
0.45103633403778076,
0.350534588098526,
-0.5672647953033447,
0.3607131838798523,
0.5312267541885376,
0.3762553632259369,
-0.11256379634141922,
0.4034471809864044,
-0.41977980732917786,
0.23442833125591278,
-0.42484036087989807,
-0.29524433612823486,
0.19426031410694122,
-0.24939942359924316,
-0.5926464200019836,
0.32162219285964966,
0.4859824776649475,
0.12522107362747192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16775v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16775v2
|
A Comprehensive Evaluation of Quantization Strategies for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-26T17:45:36 | 2024-06-06T13:38:26 |
Renren Jin, Jiangcun Du, Wuwei Huang, Wei Liu, Jian Luan, Bin Wang, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Increasing the number of parameters in large language models (LLMs) usually
improves performance in downstream tasks but raises compute and memory costs,
making deployment difficult in resource-limited settings. Quantization
techniques, which reduce the bits needed for model weights or activations with
minimal performance loss, have become popular due to the rise of LLMs. However,
most quantization studies use pre-trained LLMs, and the impact of quantization
on instruction-tuned LLMs and the relationship between perplexity and benchmark
performance of quantized LLMs are not well understood. Evaluation of quantized
LLMs is often limited to language modeling and a few classification tasks,
leaving their performance on other benchmarks unclear. To address these gaps,
we propose a structured evaluation framework consisting of three critical
dimensions: (1) knowledge \& capacity, (2) alignment, and (3) efficiency, and
conduct extensive experiments across ten diverse benchmarks. Our experimental
results indicate that LLMs with 4-bit quantization can retain performance
comparable to their non-quantized counterparts, and perplexity can serve as a
proxy metric for quantized LLMs on most benchmarks. Furthermore, quantized LLMs
with larger parameter scales can outperform smaller LLMs. Despite the memory
savings achieved through quantization, it can also slow down the inference
speed of LLMs. Consequently, substantial engineering efforts and hardware
support are imperative to achieve a balanced optimization of decoding speed and
memory consumption in the context of quantized LLMs.
|
[
-0.2926006317138672,
-0.7230264544487,
0.8103915452957153,
0.3416404128074646,
-0.39398449659347534,
0.15300697088241577,
-0.3343283534049988,
0.02254665456712246,
-0.3002862334251404,
0.43028751015663147,
-0.1487191617488861,
-0.5750920176506042,
-0.47137635946273804,
0.1542150378227234,
-0.394520103931427,
0.7935364842414856,
-0.05763617157936096,
0.06440486013889313,
-0.37824133038520813,
-0.1007177084684372,
-0.06273902952671051,
-0.7485665678977966,
-0.48998308181762695,
-0.06638126075267792,
0.4051174223423004,
0.1279841512441635,
0.8304060697555542,
0.8047307133674622,
0.5055019855499268,
0.3484202027320862,
-0.23063914477825165,
-0.16404029726982117,
-0.3543934226036072,
0.08720280230045319,
0.20675420761108398,
-0.7222212553024292,
-0.6637302041053772,
-0.03061569109559059,
1.0726959705352783,
0.8094803094863892,
-0.250521719455719,
0.19411584734916687,
-0.0024738237261772156,
0.652190625667572,
-0.9417917132377625,
-0.16205178201198578,
-0.3560898005962372,
0.07875487208366394,
-0.2898770570755005,
-0.22343949973583221,
-0.15373669564723969,
-0.5426653027534485,
0.21012553572654724,
-0.4975854754447937,
-0.01452782191336155,
-0.05381729453802109,
0.5730468034744263,
0.2984195351600647,
-0.4558791518211365,
-0.06634524464607239,
-0.798723578453064,
0.9516991376876831,
-0.8858976364135742,
0.5285247564315796,
0.1759202927350998,
0.14674519002437592,
0.12176747620105743,
-0.606947660446167,
-0.42088231444358826,
-0.07247341424226761,
0.1342209130525589,
-0.1446898877620697,
-0.2131763994693756,
0.36306920647621155,
0.595385730266571,
0.5728424787521362,
-0.5877751708030701,
0.08811099082231522,
-0.07611976563930511,
-0.22683732211589813,
0.4923689365386963,
0.2622607350349426,
0.08519216626882553,
0.008004890754818916,
-0.2564026117324829,
-0.12326095998287201,
-0.8093625903129578,
-0.015076828189194202,
0.5321141481399536,
-0.08925770968198776,
0.026407917961478233,
0.3348994255065918,
-0.3653925061225891,
0.7441374063491821,
-0.11442576348781586,
-0.27778178453445435,
0.15549339354038239,
-0.3616907298564911,
-0.29206985235214233,
-0.1384032517671585,
0.7812250852584839,
-0.0173410065472126,
0.0880667045712471,
-0.23423369228839874,
-0.47600728273391724,
-0.17458581924438477,
0.10310685634613037,
-1.1077550649642944,
-0.06923659145832062,
0.22170427441596985,
-0.3501039147377014,
-0.08249610662460327,
-0.3772641122341156,
-0.46907052397727966,
-0.30724507570266724,
-0.23472225666046143,
0.5830413103103638,
-0.6542625427246094,
-0.17823857069015503,
0.348855197429657,
0.008192339912056923,
0.20321619510650635,
0.19064879417419434,
-0.8175800442695618,
0.37186217308044434,
0.8668290972709656,
0.7028103470802307,
0.05773964524269104,
-0.009049874730408192,
-0.43683481216430664,
0.1130228042602539,
-0.40972083806991577,
0.5937379598617554,
-0.6052411198616028,
-0.17574802041053772,
0.06613408774137497,
-0.43983539938926697,
0.1474146544933319,
-0.6411939263343811,
0.3630014955997467,
-0.778359591960907,
-0.2180132418870926,
-0.3233545124530792,
-0.6235841512680054,
-0.12470831722021103,
0.2303888350725174,
-0.8302149772644043,
0.5445812344551086,
0.1623566448688507,
-0.5991374254226685,
0.263904869556427,
-0.33184587955474854,
-0.38324087858200073,
0.20304036140441895,
-0.05786454677581787,
-0.4032556414604187,
0.5337263345718384,
0.12736563384532928,
0.3534976840019226,
-0.6462664604187012,
0.301896333694458,
-0.29472699761390686,
-0.7845147848129272,
0.4751637578010559,
-0.7411492466926575,
0.5951612591743469,
0.08860626071691513,
-0.3233059346675873,
0.10480216890573502,
-0.8921259641647339,
0.2318287342786789,
-0.04775571823120117,
-0.7045530676841736,
-0.34737497568130493,
0.12146924436092377,
-0.43854793906211853,
-0.20684877038002014,
0.3936552107334137,
-0.16310688853263855,
0.029881009832024574,
-0.6101878881454468,
0.6847339272499084,
0.583825945854187,
-0.139565110206604,
0.43464773893356323,
-0.020358998328447342,
0.8472827076911926,
-0.046038996428251266,
0.322296142578125,
-0.2663910984992981,
0.12440445274114609,
-1.0248020887374878,
-0.40947189927101135,
0.6312698721885681,
0.35032063722610474,
-0.6691927313804626,
0.3155840039253235,
-0.43535786867141724,
0.02470974251627922,
-0.5429040193557739,
0.09409312158823013,
0.7149043083190918,
-0.1802726686000824,
0.09993934631347656,
-0.1851276457309723,
-0.3944755792617798,
-1.0123393535614014,
-0.3134339451789856,
0.05719912797212601,
-0.2735249996185303,
-0.02133173868060112,
0.23143959045410156,
0.11377127468585968,
0.6418231129646301,
-0.13919103145599365,
0.2622998058795929,
0.06349514424800873,
0.21472203731536865,
0.17752525210380554,
0.2872883379459381,
0.12605580687522888,
-0.5285811424255371,
-0.19795669615268707,
-0.04132489114999771,
-0.49283748865127563,
-0.084368035197258,
0.159355029463768,
0.06256368011236191,
0.3382973074913025,
0.5514881014823914,
-0.4764404892921448,
0.21286097168922424,
0.6436605453491211,
-0.004859611392021179,
0.5579834580421448,
-0.12133457511663437,
0.029131079092621803,
-0.7487786412239075,
-0.055568598210811615,
-0.03020811639726162,
-0.12778669595718384,
-0.47177013754844666,
0.1919945329427719,
0.2341960370540619,
0.020662551745772362,
-0.2380194216966629,
0.27435770630836487,
-0.6588915586471558,
-0.3499787151813507,
0.04518403485417366,
0.318539559841156,
0.16299095749855042,
0.4303174912929535,
-0.2160533219575882,
0.9327427744865417,
0.47121039032936096,
-0.4372316300868988,
0.38860949873924255,
-0.25292691588401794,
-0.5914992094039917,
0.61907559633255,
-0.7015060186386108,
0.17931878566741943,
0.08074227720499039,
0.04080125316977501,
-0.8058540225028992,
0.13916508853435516,
-0.26803329586982727,
-0.15470197796821594,
0.3307693302631378,
-0.05855076387524605,
-0.8519862294197083,
-0.12584418058395386,
-0.5169170498847961,
0.8396762013435364,
0.4924468994140625,
-0.2573104500770569,
0.5913364887237549,
0.0778314471244812,
-0.012590834870934486,
-0.37768518924713135,
-0.3852972090244293,
0.09237860888242722,
-0.5309761166572571,
-0.533781886100769,
0.24536943435668945,
-0.02540595829486847,
-0.25959768891334534,
-0.1147211417555809,
-0.38722842931747437,
0.04207558184862137,
0.26347681879997253,
-0.011623753234744072,
-0.03930697590112686,
-0.45561081171035767,
0.36988601088523865,
0.09639202058315277,
-0.17226232588291168,
0.2941606640815735,
-0.5232790112495422,
0.6301898956298828,
-0.5079025030136108,
-0.26779183745384216,
-0.2828611731529236,
0.1121625155210495,
0.37031489610671997,
-0.45178499817848206,
0.6199966669082642,
0.5651774406433105,
-0.16417837142944336,
-0.18123909831047058,
-0.7372220158576965,
-0.013703770935535431,
-0.4916847348213196,
0.6269487142562866,
-0.6526330709457397,
-1.1004718542099,
0.3509116768836975,
-0.37908846139907837,
-0.2509390711784363,
0.11309144645929337,
0.4404243528842926,
0.01984679326415062,
1.1673824787139893,
0.535364031791687,
0.09488148242235184,
0.174455925822258,
-0.27851319313049316,
0.48985546827316284,
-1.0536056756973267,
0.020126458257436752,
-0.47258734703063965,
-0.21543529629707336,
-0.6918765306472778,
-0.5214199423789978,
0.5281912684440613,
0.6200282573699951,
-0.505778431892395,
0.09568776935338974,
-0.17883458733558655,
0.4991726875305176,
0.3868868947029114,
0.050309520214796066,
0.4149855673313141,
0.05018359422683716,
-0.12406136840581894,
0.03242392838001251,
-0.8515909314155579,
-0.6758404970169067,
1.227128028869629,
0.4865211546421051,
0.6429648399353027,
0.31468281149864197,
0.5827107429504395,
-0.15602317452430725,
0.10433890670537949,
-0.8725444078445435,
0.6525311470031738,
-0.268932044506073,
-0.2761800289154053,
-0.6642298102378845,
-0.5932444334030151,
-0.7899717092514038,
0.40523767471313477,
-0.13574667274951935,
-0.5833961367607117,
-0.06742261350154877,
0.02898353338241577,
-0.6351783275604248,
0.08880101144313812,
-0.6120187044143677,
0.7491002082824707,
-0.3302376866340637,
-0.3448050618171692,
-0.41172266006469727,
-0.3635212182998657,
0.4399425983428955,
-0.3127761483192444,
0.21170859038829803,
0.030094152316451073,
-0.3652304410934448,
0.7324957847595215,
-0.3811798095703125,
0.6099075078964233,
0.0900535136461258,
-0.36993494629859924,
-0.04716721922159195,
0.2071225643157959,
0.3341951370239258,
0.096758171916008,
-0.13103757798671722,
0.24467644095420837,
0.2659708857536316,
-0.5009053945541382,
-0.884601891040802,
0.6982496976852417,
-0.7055343985557556,
-0.8886324167251587,
-0.015863832086324692,
-0.7249377369880676,
-0.5738123655319214,
0.04723314195871353,
0.06058012321591377,
0.49589332938194275,
0.06542997062206268,
0.4099343419075012,
0.9247426986694336,
-0.5427480340003967,
0.3899163007736206,
0.5586569905281067,
0.020068516954779625,
-0.5501248240470886,
0.9671095609664917,
0.04708683863282204,
0.521879255771637,
0.5579835772514343,
0.2858060300350189,
-0.2309914082288742,
-0.8363567590713501,
-0.03817734122276306,
0.26516851782798767,
-0.6543012857437134,
-0.28869885206222534,
-0.4062846302986145,
-0.27947181463241577,
-0.31093674898147583,
0.1369670182466507,
-0.41562899947166443,
-0.3118618130683899,
-0.20675818622112274,
0.06908877938985825,
0.11154881864786148,
0.3488864302635193,
0.11238422244787216,
0.5439599752426147,
-0.7702146768569946,
0.12079517543315887,
0.4479924142360687,
0.5628326535224915,
0.171339750289917,
-0.5426555275917053,
-0.5233158469200134,
-0.08809266984462738,
-0.2942105829715729,
-0.5596109628677368,
0.10866719484329224,
0.060580722987651825,
0.36483439803123474,
0.5299755930900574,
-0.06616754829883575,
0.8931494951248169,
-0.4680570960044861,
0.4798710346221924,
0.12591087818145752,
-1.38341224193573,
0.35226839780807495,
-0.13604477047920227,
0.40325602889060974,
0.27847206592559814,
0.4794919490814209,
-0.1607976257801056,
-0.15694653987884521,
-0.38686317205429077,
-0.8563805818557739,
0.5672692656517029,
0.029706591740250587,
0.20068423449993134,
0.1493791788816452,
0.4505237638950348,
-0.23594780266284943,
0.41397523880004883,
-0.5874766111373901,
0.02352706529200077,
0.1705871820449829,
-0.06397277861833572,
0.07648330181837082,
-0.7315117120742798,
-0.12211207300424576,
-0.14095577597618103,
0.25593721866607666,
-0.025862202048301697,
0.05727306753396988,
-0.23553426563739777,
-0.11872432380914688,
0.024636585265398026,
0.3196125626564026,
0.5402756929397583,
0.7171000242233276,
-0.07798448950052261,
0.14177416265010834,
0.20928683876991272,
-0.1364445686340332,
0.17477788031101227,
-0.041883207857608795,
0.09124702960252762,
-0.29584938287734985,
0.6192869544029236,
1.1442148685455322,
0.4554152488708496,
-0.6566689610481262,
0.6053673028945923,
0.056376732885837555,
-0.23463952541351318,
-0.14877158403396606,
0.1260012984275818,
0.09942851960659027,
0.5492464303970337,
0.15666019916534424,
-0.5263698101043701,
0.21028614044189453,
-0.474383682012558,
-0.164366215467453,
0.6527619361877441,
0.03467973321676254,
-0.41539087891578674,
0.3372035622596741,
0.06562294065952301,
-0.2882564663887024,
0.6310421228408813,
-0.2240656614303589,
-0.5476502180099487,
0.49385786056518555,
0.4207003712654114,
0.8279363512992859,
-0.33696073293685913,
0.07947109639644623,
0.2523738741874695,
0.24991711974143982,
-0.01705506071448326,
0.1236061081290245,
-0.37886470556259155,
-0.5702759027481079,
-0.7737176418304443,
-1.035252332687378,
-0.14947396516799927,
0.27654144167900085,
-0.6995277404785156,
0.05783404782414436,
-0.5905895233154297,
-0.2625742554664612,
-0.1295095980167389,
0.21649989485740662,
-0.5253642201423645,
0.14937695860862732,
0.19462266564369202,
0.6443982124328613,
-0.46300381422042847,
0.8190097808837891,
0.4904244542121887,
-0.12494824081659317,
-0.8499394655227661,
0.17653295397758484,
-0.28634113073349,
-0.7824782729148865,
0.7866767644882202,
-0.07411544024944305,
-0.06218142434954643,
0.14465074241161346,
-0.37384477257728577,
-1.0799143314361572,
0.9669042825698853,
0.5586773753166199,
-0.9036542773246765,
0.0006064824992790818,
0.31568533182144165,
0.6057515144348145,
0.014169475063681602,
0.3995327055454254,
1.0492613315582275,
0.5069509744644165,
0.09602352231740952,
-0.8046398162841797,
0.19948813319206238,
0.056086789816617966,
0.6146166920661926,
0.4274502694606781,
-0.5771528482437134,
0.8432875871658325,
-0.0281131062656641,
-0.481621652841568,
0.2845599055290222,
0.42340975999832153,
0.4746116101741791,
-0.08577756583690643,
0.35209089517593384,
0.640048623085022,
0.496380090713501,
-0.15034142136573792,
1.0327012538909912,
-0.4672040045261383,
0.1810220628976822,
0.6892038583755493,
-0.24241352081298828,
0.7985121607780457,
0.511832594871521,
-0.6909745931625366,
0.19966720044612885,
0.4632156491279602,
0.12238399684429169,
0.32658451795578003,
0.8430113792419434,
-0.3676747977733612,
-0.33656758069992065,
0.12613651156425476,
-0.08039401471614838,
0.2895631194114685,
0.3914967179298401,
-0.006882956717163324,
-0.13409502804279327,
-0.013768114149570465,
-0.02603744901716709,
-0.03281674534082413,
-0.16216342151165009,
0.7403241991996765,
0.10122789442539215,
-0.39121270179748535,
1.1047989130020142,
0.15059354901313782,
0.5341896414756775,
-0.4448159337043762,
0.041396625339984894,
-0.45564383268356323,
0.0336812362074852,
-0.1328851282596588,
-0.43535280227661133,
0.1289311647415161,
-0.051008693873882294,
-0.11425010114908218,
-0.14326035976409912,
0.14632034301757812,
-0.28593820333480835,
-0.49064379930496216,
0.1641005277633667,
0.29390597343444824,
0.15090827643871307,
-0.3543168306350708,
-0.37060537934303284,
0.5089749097824097,
-0.11561596393585205,
-0.42209768295288086,
0.610487163066864,
0.9139875173568726,
-0.23030710220336914,
0.6571276783943176,
0.5000874400138855,
0.2263072431087494,
0.02608209289610386,
0.321943461894989,
0.846307635307312,
-0.7447390556335449,
-0.07908394932746887,
-1.0168787240982056,
0.29059740900993347,
0.282622754573822,
-0.11086833477020264,
0.7234171628952026,
0.5499345660209656,
0.7692751288414001,
0.23916514217853546,
0.5239085555076599,
0.4232468008995056,
0.091771699488163,
-0.8078876733779907,
0.38980016112327576,
-0.6271597743034363,
0.7238537073135376,
-0.12921690940856934,
-1.1165435314178467,
-0.2864898443222046,
0.5016088485717773,
-0.3750283420085907,
0.21422281861305237,
0.8162202835083008,
0.6261889338493347,
0.37056660652160645,
-0.22231145203113556,
0.6374350190162659,
0.3116440176963806,
0.17268073558807373,
0.8052377700805664,
1.0782290697097778,
-0.45665377378463745,
0.5775374174118042,
-0.2593311667442322,
-0.33919385075569153,
-0.048125483095645905,
-0.8595250844955444,
-0.8204663395881653,
-0.5083000659942627,
-0.4471176564693451,
-0.06765680015087128,
0.14123770594596863,
0.25305208563804626,
0.7590233683586121,
-0.5032865405082703,
-0.46522626280784607,
-0.11693529784679413,
0.09403952956199646,
0.07658230513334274,
-0.22097349166870117,
0.37167972326278687,
-0.5213173031806946,
-0.7873178720474243,
0.08499091863632202,
0.5672698020935059,
-0.0583798885345459,
-0.6186419725418091,
-0.0026982775889337063,
0.2775305509567261,
0.16005194187164307,
0.8879162073135376,
-0.11615989357233047,
-0.8224446177482605,
0.05849706381559372,
-0.04139415919780731,
-0.08261336386203766,
-0.12061597406864166,
0.8438030481338501,
-0.7505330443382263,
0.18029870092868805,
0.3348652720451355,
0.6725762486457825,
0.5057093501091003,
0.06109621375799179,
0.632338285446167,
-0.5995199680328369,
0.05474197864532471,
0.29949134588241577,
0.06580515950918198,
0.2075795829296112,
-0.23421402275562286,
0.2640984058380127,
-0.08822780847549438,
-0.5288007259368896,
-0.9325739741325378,
0.07134871929883957,
-0.5470907688140869,
-0.3153148591518402,
1.1148793697357178,
-0.22649380564689636,
-0.24801695346832275,
0.33306530117988586,
0.2675255537033081,
0.10051349550485611,
-0.08937215805053711,
0.6037081480026245,
0.7334380149841309,
0.0795070081949234,
-0.34374961256980896,
-0.5876415371894836,
0.478407084941864,
0.5564691424369812,
-0.6421130895614624,
-0.03196297958493233,
0.4860662519931793,
0.23194186389446259,
0.0054337759502232075,
0.352757066488266,
-0.24413764476776123,
0.09705385565757751,
-0.0849742740392685,
0.13094839453697205,
0.11030219495296478,
-0.20147141814231873,
-0.703819215297699,
0.04210778698325157,
0.3154168128967285,
-0.03000943921506405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16767v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16767v1
|
CorpusBrain++: A Continual Generative Pre-Training Framework for Knowledge-Intensive Language Tasks
| 2024-02-26T17:35:44 | 2024-02-26T17:35:44 |
Jiafeng Guo, Changjiang Zhou, Ruqing Zhang, Jiangui Chen, Maarten de Rijke, Yixing Fan, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Knowledge-intensive language tasks (KILTs) typically require retrieving
relevant documents from trustworthy corpora, e.g., Wikipedia, to produce
specific answers. Very recently, a pre-trained generative retrieval model for
KILTs, named CorpusBrain, was proposed and reached new state-of-the-art
retrieval performance. However, most existing research on KILTs, including
CorpusBrain, has predominantly focused on a static document collection,
overlooking the dynamic nature of real-world scenarios, where new documents are
continuously being incorporated into the source corpus. To address this gap, it
is crucial to explore the capability of retrieval models to effectively handle
the dynamic retrieval scenario inherent in KILTs.
In this work, we first introduce the continual document learning (CDL) task
for KILTs and build a novel benchmark dataset named KILT++ based on the
original KILT dataset for evaluation. Then, we conduct a comprehensive study
over the use of pre-trained CorpusBrain on KILT++. Unlike the promising results
in the stationary scenario, CorpusBrain is prone to catastrophic forgetting in
the dynamic scenario, hence hampering the retrieval performance. To alleviate
this issue, we propose CorpusBrain++, a continual generative pre-training
framework. Empirical results demonstrate the significant effectiveness and
remarkable efficiency of CorpusBrain++ in comparison to both traditional and
generative IR methods.
|
[
-0.3026283085346222,
-0.7335060238838196,
0.34793442487716675,
0.3404633104801178,
-0.1385791003704071,
0.4483245611190796,
-0.4545404613018036,
-0.6317762136459351,
0.1099412590265274,
0.31160077452659607,
-0.356692910194397,
-0.5533149242401123,
-0.7104155421257019,
-0.13728846609592438,
-0.7290219664573669,
0.8443326354026794,
-0.17989572882652283,
-0.004439199343323708,
-0.33057498931884766,
-0.2829652428627014,
-0.801525354385376,
-0.598734974861145,
-0.8722299337387085,
-0.327891081571579,
0.9229236245155334,
0.26719826459884644,
0.4203800857067108,
0.18232540786266327,
0.21892490983009338,
0.23491725325584412,
-0.04038483649492264,
0.06570395827293396,
-0.5813961029052734,
0.48797792196273804,
0.13104255497455597,
-0.7386627793312073,
0.010934696532785892,
-0.08574803173542023,
0.7438026666641235,
0.7034862041473389,
-0.12475408613681793,
0.15259963274002075,
0.018843399360775948,
0.4881478250026703,
-0.9901881217956543,
-0.04561062157154083,
-0.6445032954216003,
0.14173422753810883,
-0.46749943494796753,
-0.06842033565044403,
-0.44264766573905945,
-0.49648576974868774,
0.12781278789043427,
-0.9885141849517822,
0.14812253415584564,
-0.34094133973121643,
0.9175103902816772,
-0.0206854660063982,
-0.44192761182785034,
-0.6947786211967468,
-0.6911371946334839,
0.6756595969200134,
-0.153949573636055,
0.7509543895721436,
0.5499274730682373,
0.14352552592754364,
-0.016077879816293716,
-0.914537787437439,
-0.5295120477676392,
-0.7308326959609985,
-0.2951030731201172,
0.36152103543281555,
0.5084496736526489,
-0.20958250761032104,
0.08573251217603683,
-0.10151021182537079,
-0.6441935896873474,
-0.07969944179058075,
-0.33852797746658325,
-0.13279862701892853,
0.1364791989326477,
-0.058881402015686035,
0.20598408579826355,
0.043295979499816895,
-0.2870916724205017,
-0.28605422377586365,
-0.8381022810935974,
0.038540568202733994,
0.2698638141155243,
-0.2053242027759552,
0.14955011010169983,
0.06534184515476227,
0.0998246893286705,
0.7722787261009216,
0.018861664459109306,
0.0420907698571682,
0.4553627371788025,
-0.39056262373924255,
0.20686101913452148,
0.1744890660047531,
0.2560783326625824,
-0.45314061641693115,
0.4237315058708191,
-0.4096372425556183,
-0.19361305236816406,
0.2766916751861572,
0.6432716846466064,
-0.5613370537757874,
-0.40667104721069336,
0.32789698243141174,
-0.07150435447692871,
-0.5738762021064758,
-0.46661368012428284,
-0.5623075366020203,
-0.055751774460077286,
-0.5684173107147217,
0.41471612453460693,
-0.7888690829277039,
-0.5680572390556335,
0.011558787897229195,
-0.06704878807067871,
0.13855235278606415,
0.3158797323703766,
-0.7711831331253052,
0.22673842310905457,
0.6605613231658936,
0.629723310470581,
-0.35580798983573914,
-0.4646212160587311,
-0.5802780389785767,
0.04105377197265625,
-0.4471830427646637,
0.7797671556472778,
-0.8298702239990234,
-0.5321396589279175,
0.07174019515514374,
0.0705568939447403,
-0.3986750543117523,
-0.5481612086296082,
0.7344359159469604,
-0.9825922846794128,
0.1079125851392746,
-0.1439533829689026,
-0.4335711598396301,
0.07330948114395142,
0.7113982439041138,
-0.5640034079551697,
1.156013011932373,
0.1839390993118286,
-0.6690167188644409,
0.4923699200153351,
-0.5325236320495605,
-0.5574570894241333,
0.34841635823249817,
-0.1555873453617096,
-0.22568388283252716,
-0.31170064210891724,
-0.32241395115852356,
0.30719953775405884,
0.033488254994153976,
0.5812972187995911,
-0.30417582392692566,
-0.4391685724258423,
0.24955041706562042,
-0.4489874541759491,
0.6747364401817322,
0.22721713781356812,
-0.2484656274318695,
-0.0274247694760561,
-0.862289547920227,
0.06751399487257004,
-0.06622707843780518,
-0.5578830242156982,
-0.6026630401611328,
-0.08596359938383102,
0.15802614390850067,
0.16437657177448273,
0.4478898048400879,
-0.7177543044090271,
-0.10299301147460938,
-0.12688902020454407,
0.06812901794910431,
0.5787618160247803,
-0.4163227677345276,
0.45095890760421753,
-0.2637332081794739,
0.36699625849723816,
0.0040915245190262794,
0.12729956209659576,
-0.22874505817890167,
0.17423544824123383,
-0.7214275002479553,
-0.10096074640750885,
0.4719932973384857,
0.7254942059516907,
-0.7577304840087891,
-0.001488753710873425,
-0.5256198048591614,
-0.7296270132064819,
-0.34926271438598633,
0.34433820843696594,
0.5980684757232666,
0.48067161440849304,
0.29202723503112793,
-0.3067328631877899,
-0.6204984784126282,
-0.30812692642211914,
0.28959402441978455,
-0.1240483820438385,
0.07724446803331375,
0.34342193603515625,
0.24223387241363525,
-0.1350400596857071,
0.5068366527557373,
-0.14918316900730133,
-0.06885220110416412,
-0.09388444572687149,
0.5187520980834961,
0.10410325974225998,
0.7147085070610046,
0.5091551542282104,
-1.335971474647522,
-0.4711376428604126,
-0.026766600087285042,
-1.0756694078445435,
0.15064576268196106,
-0.23169872164726257,
-0.36131811141967773,
0.21110205352306366,
0.3935387134552002,
-1.0411204099655151,
-0.029112722724676132,
0.4607661962509155,
-0.16634303331375122,
0.9377565979957581,
-0.4206622242927551,
0.1758570671081543,
-0.902369499206543,
0.46361225843429565,
-0.4222058355808258,
-0.18876342475414276,
-0.5007619261741638,
0.14279626309871674,
0.5886613130569458,
-0.22944240272045135,
-0.4874745011329651,
0.5281095504760742,
-0.33564016222953796,
0.28103840351104736,
-0.012124517001211643,
0.4073237180709839,
0.13221250474452972,
0.3424040973186493,
0.2034682184457779,
0.7395283579826355,
0.5661043524742126,
-0.8180732131004333,
0.4397849440574646,
0.293520987033844,
-0.3530481457710266,
0.4324517548084259,
-0.44564563035964966,
-0.11295270174741745,
-0.35009071230888367,
0.44791164994239807,
-0.7369999289512634,
-0.18026046454906464,
-0.10673201084136963,
-0.5090914964675903,
0.866098165512085,
0.021111177280545235,
-0.5619004964828491,
-0.4174785912036896,
-0.1841762214899063,
0.5012317895889282,
0.3845779597759247,
-0.5098029971122742,
0.6116821765899658,
0.3003046214580536,
-0.19699090719223022,
-0.783439576625824,
-0.346523642539978,
0.004736057948321104,
-0.06486285477876663,
-0.48512306809425354,
0.5037015676498413,
-0.17727096378803253,
0.11684651672840118,
0.04715411365032196,
-0.1963590830564499,
-0.0497443787753582,
0.31950563192367554,
0.16863691806793213,
0.20197823643684387,
-0.12917114794254303,
0.45538628101348877,
-0.24926629662513733,
-0.24526438117027283,
-0.15406817197799683,
-0.5627385973930359,
0.7686800360679626,
0.11805950850248337,
-0.24180768430233002,
-0.0494588203728199,
0.3058774769306183,
0.5549513697624207,
-0.47174835205078125,
0.6148515939712524,
0.9378302693367004,
-0.05584061145782471,
0.14977455139160156,
-1.0318262577056885,
-0.06758076697587967,
-0.4327757656574249,
0.3830905258655548,
-0.5080256462097168,
-0.906822919845581,
0.4116532802581787,
-0.3943837285041809,
-0.11099687963724136,
0.20657441020011902,
0.18310120701789856,
-0.6038959622383118,
0.45010748505592346,
0.602730929851532,
-0.20087380707263947,
0.6416833996772766,
-0.23854506015777588,
-0.25839298963546753,
-0.6139451861381531,
-0.3454030752182007,
-0.4403601288795471,
-0.11123798787593842,
-0.4372936487197876,
0.09272467344999313,
0.3113400936126709,
0.32976198196411133,
-0.17242391407489777,
0.8823245167732239,
-0.3404887914657593,
0.3629211187362671,
0.4765966832637787,
0.11722078174352646,
-0.22699853777885437,
-0.2348957061767578,
-0.4612143337726593,
0.40305715799331665,
-0.738899827003479,
-0.06584242731332779,
1.2394200563430786,
-0.06778276711702347,
0.4507196545600891,
0.03671086207032204,
0.5949668288230896,
0.26340341567993164,
0.5180764198303223,
-0.17880794405937195,
0.4296458959579468,
-0.2865014374256134,
-0.7767232656478882,
-0.2837723195552826,
-0.41367337107658386,
-1.3928273916244507,
0.0035436684265732765,
-0.2214311808347702,
-0.7844016551971436,
0.1441870629787445,
0.17617589235305786,
-0.26928001642227173,
-0.04299426078796387,
-0.8138035535812378,
0.9668641686439514,
-0.4548935890197754,
-0.7270845770835876,
-0.5710078477859497,
-0.6866474151611328,
0.14723385870456696,
-0.5419600605964661,
0.07910978049039841,
0.1297319382429123,
0.1415344774723053,
0.5656751394271851,
0.17093917727470398,
0.6253143548965454,
-0.42393749952316284,
-0.040586553514003754,
0.36202409863471985,
0.210060715675354,
0.8164836168289185,
0.15661607682704926,
-0.3181547522544861,
0.04135352745652199,
0.4239427149295807,
-0.673311173915863,
-0.5768060088157654,
0.9360365271568298,
-0.6779768466949463,
-0.4449060559272766,
-0.11299482733011246,
-0.22856326401233673,
-0.27928227186203003,
0.04953808709979057,
0.10713190585374832,
0.6978312730789185,
-0.16084398329257965,
0.4995250999927521,
0.9690807461738586,
-0.27126115560531616,
0.25733599066734314,
0.7876723408699036,
-0.09048841148614883,
-0.22491224110126495,
1.0698457956314087,
0.36579543352127075,
0.029660962522029877,
0.601239025592804,
-0.2038489282131195,
-0.13493691384792328,
-0.45734667778015137,
-0.46459341049194336,
0.08803428709506989,
-0.6350436806678772,
0.03334749862551689,
-0.9114318490028381,
-0.25463390350341797,
-0.23053644597530365,
-0.276019424200058,
-0.3494054973125458,
-0.20889192819595337,
-0.03758938983082771,
-0.013746460899710655,
0.1273319572210312,
0.21795378625392914,
0.13069690763950348,
0.18671216070652008,
-0.9840274453163147,
0.21923862397670746,
0.14863266050815582,
0.3867427110671997,
0.11427376419305801,
-0.3399752676486969,
-0.4341433048248291,
-0.0979820191860199,
-0.24920716881752014,
-0.4732648730278015,
0.16537290811538696,
0.09860678017139435,
0.6785507202148438,
-0.05024556815624237,
-0.16928498446941376,
0.5644611716270447,
-0.39886417984962463,
0.6334129571914673,
0.00004299584907130338,
-0.3477719724178314,
0.39939063787460327,
-0.35891488194465637,
0.6797544956207275,
0.8017714619636536,
0.9166132211685181,
-0.5358294248580933,
-0.5199214816093445,
-0.6738775968551636,
-1.153100848197937,
0.44889405369758606,
0.40820547938346863,
0.3788796663284302,
-0.11892379075288773,
0.4483211934566498,
0.2892647981643677,
0.2102094441652298,
-0.5553039908409119,
0.09723471105098724,
-0.23771832883358002,
-0.3249417841434479,
-0.10763324052095413,
-0.4351251423358917,
0.18891707062721252,
-0.09657289832830429,
0.8003095388412476,
0.2328045815229416,
0.2711411118507385,
-0.002414754359051585,
-0.6045293211936951,
0.29507407546043396,
0.14782078564167023,
0.5702234506607056,
0.6705889105796814,
-0.4334086775779724,
0.15083743631839752,
0.5108608603477478,
-0.865028977394104,
0.1639309823513031,
0.28446391224861145,
-0.14117391407489777,
0.14592424035072327,
0.415712833404541,
0.460064172744751,
0.45331791043281555,
-0.8521255850791931,
0.4671359360218048,
-0.058176711201667786,
-0.035358726978302,
-1.1845906972885132,
0.06520222127437592,
0.2240743786096573,
-0.049536462873220444,
0.27454015612602234,
0.25936102867126465,
-0.18968549370765686,
-0.3116951584815979,
0.5017581582069397,
0.19377057254314423,
-0.36395302414894104,
-0.30781179666519165,
0.4399532377719879,
0.21943630278110504,
-0.16735538840293884,
0.6157066822052002,
-0.18212690949440002,
-0.35338830947875977,
0.6557363271713257,
0.44593682885169983,
0.5099192261695862,
-0.11498019099235535,
0.13061273097991943,
0.6229061484336853,
-0.060940470546483994,
-0.07729427516460419,
0.10749316215515137,
-0.8216120600700378,
-0.7623497843742371,
-0.47131872177124023,
-0.9139724373817444,
-0.007861572317779064,
0.22156542539596558,
-0.3579539954662323,
0.17067715525627136,
-0.10401777923107147,
-0.16398724913597107,
-0.09908191859722137,
-0.06288642436265945,
-0.8364307284355164,
0.4670872986316681,
0.08144903182983398,
0.9073967933654785,
-0.3110283315181732,
1.3866182565689087,
0.4822107255458832,
-0.5714905858039856,
-0.6231847405433655,
-0.1006917804479599,
-0.26938119530677795,
-0.5405632853507996,
1.065239667892456,
0.2089592069387436,
-0.16661076247692108,
0.04532621428370476,
-0.33672621846199036,
-1.0409088134765625,
1.1723772287368774,
0.2869771122932434,
-0.5622203946113586,
-0.2143680304288864,
-0.025142258033156395,
0.5673601031303406,
-0.04534497857093811,
0.37400808930397034,
0.4168095886707306,
0.5263489484786987,
0.05878769978880882,
-0.6549636125564575,
-0.28735119104385376,
-0.5815367102622986,
-0.21147635579109192,
0.464089035987854,
-0.5495919585227966,
0.4250733554363251,
0.5638939738273621,
-0.2089758962392807,
0.06627432256937027,
0.25534361600875854,
0.12984198331832886,
0.20347128808498383,
0.6492441296577454,
0.455441415309906,
0.7864726185798645,
-0.02359486185014248,
1.1277023553848267,
-0.6256236433982849,
-0.09264801442623138,
1.2900428771972656,
-0.2991819381713867,
0.9570417404174805,
0.24739523231983185,
-0.014257223345339298,
0.5290213227272034,
0.495165079832077,
0.09590208530426025,
0.4732649028301239,
0.12467829138040543,
-0.8463413119316101,
-0.367521196603775,
-0.14206001162528992,
-0.21847732365131378,
0.24305544793605804,
0.5708363652229309,
-0.12243257462978363,
-0.22239382565021515,
0.42042121291160583,
-0.01751655898988247,
0.1005919948220253,
-0.12417847663164139,
0.6838164925575256,
-0.03555109351873398,
-0.9501490592956543,
0.911900520324707,
-0.39525341987609863,
0.8202475309371948,
-1.1744436025619507,
0.20567816495895386,
-0.24873629212379456,
0.17832285165786743,
0.007658233866095543,
-0.5785057544708252,
0.4360964000225067,
-0.005422740709036589,
-0.03881284222006798,
-0.30230310559272766,
1.0301263332366943,
-0.549209475517273,
-0.3874852955341339,
0.7534241080284119,
0.1178068220615387,
0.15128715336322784,
0.21540483832359314,
-0.44566142559051514,
-0.02416864223778248,
-0.2414575070142746,
-0.3594816029071808,
0.6915291547775269,
0.4924450218677521,
-0.0819903314113617,
0.9766601920127869,
0.7176852226257324,
-0.005502539221197367,
-0.011701577343046665,
0.13330745697021484,
1.0136216878890991,
-0.3686141073703766,
-0.09507561475038528,
-0.43311384320259094,
0.5114392638206482,
-0.071872778236866,
-0.20290607213974,
0.39126020669937134,
0.5543633699417114,
1.0452630519866943,
-0.12417668104171753,
0.5938965678215027,
-0.14996379613876343,
0.3011079430580139,
-0.4718003273010254,
1.0061196088790894,
-0.6189835667610168,
-0.005657179281115532,
-0.004942494444549084,
-0.6294010877609253,
-0.2129128873348236,
0.21715250611305237,
-0.2906135618686676,
-0.12121623009443283,
0.7671674489974976,
0.9721587300300598,
-0.16909344494342804,
0.06329402327537537,
0.5062111020088196,
0.0033899375703185797,
-0.022184139117598534,
0.5020927786827087,
0.7768993377685547,
-0.18561209738254547,
0.9755607843399048,
-0.03831329941749573,
0.1022670567035675,
0.12211736291646957,
-0.6179425120353699,
-0.33498910069465637,
-0.8350285291671753,
-0.14743264019489288,
-0.27575212717056274,
0.6767761707305908,
0.7432105541229248,
0.876282811164856,
-0.8985466957092285,
-0.09977602958679199,
-0.483040452003479,
-0.15735439956188202,
0.027917707338929176,
-0.20617058873176575,
0.4479822516441345,
-0.9490693211555481,
-0.2988492250442505,
0.5234596133232117,
0.08352812379598618,
-0.13031071424484253,
-0.11067076027393341,
-0.09163839370012283,
-0.624829888343811,
-0.20776614546775818,
0.6722477078437805,
0.29286977648735046,
-0.24069944024085999,
-0.36524978280067444,
-0.07358327507972717,
-0.1810440868139267,
-0.04772089421749115,
0.7396256923675537,
-1.2551110982894897,
0.4893096685409546,
0.27866560220718384,
1.0386302471160889,
1.0708913803100586,
-0.3446960747241974,
0.5818332433700562,
-0.8424205780029297,
0.32643288373947144,
0.2885919511318207,
0.09836942702531815,
0.25818347930908203,
-0.28177034854888916,
0.4800190031528473,
0.33994370698928833,
-0.4784447252750397,
-0.4007059931755066,
0.26403680443763733,
-0.7845482230186462,
-0.23282018303871155,
0.9235352277755737,
-0.5796950459480286,
-0.17579849064350128,
-0.2622798979282379,
-0.2059049904346466,
0.4533246159553528,
-0.11446703970432281,
0.8508076071739197,
0.7897018194198608,
0.5110374689102173,
-0.1985199898481369,
-0.7036154270172119,
0.3871019184589386,
0.8291062116622925,
-0.5286841988563538,
-0.10890737920999527,
0.21947741508483887,
0.35827112197875977,
0.49818941950798035,
0.684589147567749,
-0.19873274862766266,
0.3360682725906372,
0.21420741081237793,
0.1049702987074852,
0.02070564776659012,
-0.3846223056316376,
0.2432049661874771,
0.5864735245704651,
0.09261449426412582,
0.021002760156989098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16751v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16751v1
|
Value Preferences Estimation and Disambiguation in Hybrid Participatory Systems
| 2024-02-26T17:16:28 | 2024-02-26T17:16:28 |
Enrico Liscio, Luciano C. Siebert, Catholijn M. Jonker, Pradeep K. Murukannaiah
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Understanding citizens' values in participatory systems is crucial for
citizen-centric policy-making. We envision a hybrid participatory system where
participants make choices and provide motivations for those choices, and AI
agents estimate their value preferences by interacting with them. We focus on
situations where a conflict is detected between participants' choices and
motivations, and propose methods for estimating value preferences while
addressing detected inconsistencies by interacting with the participants. We
operationalize the philosophical stance that "valuing is deliberatively
consequential." That is, if a participant's choice is based on a deliberation
of value preferences, the value preferences can be observed in the motivation
the participant provides for the choice. Thus, we propose and compare value
estimation methods that prioritize the values estimated from motivations over
the values estimated from choices alone. Then, we introduce a disambiguation
strategy that addresses the detected inconsistencies between choices and
motivations by directly interacting with the participants. We evaluate the
proposed methods on a dataset of a large-scale survey on energy transition. The
results show that explicitly addressing inconsistencies between choices and
motivations improves the estimation of an individual's value preferences. The
disambiguation strategy does not show substantial improvements when compared to
similar baselines--however, we discuss how the novelty of the approach can open
new research avenues and propose improvements to address the current
limitations.
|
[
-0.4214860796928406,
-0.3066236078739166,
0.779545247554779,
-0.23090782761573792,
-0.1387728750705719,
0.3954479992389679,
-0.23304428160190582,
-0.47863537073135376,
0.7067552208900452,
0.05314677208662033,
-0.39329394698143005,
-0.038757991045713425,
-0.6085246801376343,
-0.055262066423892975,
0.10651851445436478,
0.7768408060073853,
0.048719435930252075,
0.20246325433254242,
-0.4236011803150177,
-0.10323023796081543,
-0.4790351092815399,
-0.38612329959869385,
-0.2155037373304367,
-0.6554588675498962,
0.4045162796974182,
0.632840096950531,
0.7298443913459778,
-0.07152806967496872,
0.09059049934148788,
0.31450286507606506,
-0.21277248859405518,
0.13694597780704498,
-0.4716157615184784,
0.24695321917533875,
-0.34264683723449707,
-0.4486674964427948,
0.15313488245010376,
0.45686015486717224,
0.3672119379043579,
0.7718214988708496,
0.011828321032226086,
0.3400808274745941,
-0.21133606135845184,
0.5894531011581421,
-1.054368495941162,
0.2910831570625305,
-0.655707061290741,
0.16276158392429352,
-0.237976536154747,
-0.2685370147228241,
-0.047725725919008255,
-0.5444936752319336,
0.051785022020339966,
-0.39509356021881104,
-0.1686220020055771,
-0.0839293897151947,
0.5324183702468872,
0.5475304126739502,
-0.4645608365535736,
-0.10092244297266006,
-0.9081816077232361,
0.9447993040084839,
-0.27833181619644165,
0.21618427336215973,
0.5463967323303223,
0.3726198077201843,
-0.12447692453861237,
-0.3706238567829132,
-0.8985978364944458,
-0.10277275741100311,
-0.17123199999332428,
0.31439363956451416,
0.011495472863316536,
0.27995923161506653,
0.24870207905769348,
0.5887744426727295,
-0.20673830807209015,
0.1298280507326126,
-0.37884092330932617,
-0.4049757421016693,
0.700799286365509,
0.19700415432453156,
-0.15532642602920532,
-0.492683082818985,
-0.39138466119766235,
-0.12462823837995529,
-0.3712417483329773,
0.6693370342254639,
0.6774212718009949,
0.19343161582946777,
0.036823175847530365,
0.6374515295028687,
-0.23346562683582306,
0.37561091780662537,
0.39086589217185974,
-0.1324959248304367,
0.4289413094520569,
-0.46250036358833313,
-0.09310945123434067,
0.3025122284889221,
0.33581987023353577,
0.47842463850975037,
-0.18314173817634583,
0.07729154080152512,
-0.02779780700802803,
0.15898650884628296,
-0.08560973405838013,
-0.5355196595191956,
-0.2894199788570404,
0.43740135431289673,
-0.4873577058315277,
-0.15617522597312927,
0.16587476432323456,
-0.5883046984672546,
-0.43606269359588623,
-0.7139166593551636,
0.5568602085113525,
-0.002566738985478878,
-0.5421368479728699,
0.021624663844704628,
-0.4153226912021637,
-0.20490868389606476,
0.5865219831466675,
-1.1357200145721436,
-0.06598766893148422,
0.45366808772087097,
0.6285033822059631,
0.025667941197752953,
-0.15649770200252533,
-0.4073934853076935,
-0.10619385540485382,
0.08044534921646118,
0.8098660707473755,
-0.8601348400115967,
-0.6547110676765442,
-0.35069772601127625,
-0.14444434642791748,
0.13546130061149597,
-0.6893835067749023,
0.23689332604408264,
-0.3992007374763489,
0.29320529103279114,
-0.6970356702804565,
-0.48517531156539917,
0.1393330693244934,
0.37437331676483154,
-0.62977135181427,
1.1642030477523804,
0.1729336380958557,
-0.7074687480926514,
0.7660620212554932,
-0.8255018591880798,
-0.2227160781621933,
0.11999745666980743,
-0.2051992118358612,
-0.10405430942773819,
0.049179401248693466,
-0.3922087848186493,
0.07844121754169464,
-0.08861749619245529,
0.30785709619522095,
-0.2211480736732483,
-0.04796002060174942,
0.21374362707138062,
-0.5638662576675415,
0.7872704863548279,
0.29839077591896057,
-0.21280930936336517,
0.44789955019950867,
-0.6159067153930664,
-0.09121312946081161,
-0.15277646481990814,
-0.333978533744812,
-0.6807811260223389,
0.3474273681640625,
-0.19243955612182617,
0.01526991929858923,
0.6630980372428894,
-0.6249112486839294,
0.14454522728919983,
-0.1312376707792282,
0.27905765175819397,
0.9683260321617126,
-0.00016117397171910852,
0.4540487229824066,
-0.10458989441394806,
0.40847429633140564,
0.05759531259536743,
0.5983548760414124,
0.018024826422333717,
-0.16198915243148804,
-0.430315226316452,
-0.042534299194812775,
0.1736142337322235,
0.2601839601993561,
-0.652833104133606,
0.24507148563861847,
0.14652539789676666,
-0.3162975609302521,
-0.38944771885871887,
-0.404725581407547,
-0.09244038164615631,
0.5660696029663086,
0.5679892897605896,
0.16761542856693268,
-0.41072019934654236,
-0.8486424684524536,
-0.04174718260765076,
-0.6097615957260132,
-0.03263122960925102,
0.19710196554660797,
0.4573696553707123,
0.1868503838777542,
0.9626418352127075,
-0.376730352640152,
0.5934973359107971,
0.12224308401346207,
0.3044734597206116,
0.09894543886184692,
0.47982603311538696,
0.30068865418434143,
-1.3630625009536743,
-0.3854029178619385,
-0.13859844207763672,
-0.14048321545124054,
0.1490330994129181,
0.028454596176743507,
-0.15686166286468506,
-0.2786957621574402,
-0.0700179934501648,
-0.20732614398002625,
0.4330020248889923,
0.33783626556396484,
-0.17391526699066162,
0.6148462891578674,
-0.14729593694210052,
0.5335519313812256,
-0.8862327933311462,
0.14073018729686737,
0.07135599851608276,
-0.11560530960559845,
-0.41248056292533875,
-0.2992285192012787,
-0.22560186684131622,
0.17615419626235962,
-0.5459568500518799,
0.36968404054641724,
-0.18418928980827332,
-0.0635327398777008,
-0.24477767944335938,
-0.2100229412317276,
-0.03049454279243946,
0.14331911504268646,
0.2381276935338974,
0.7947276830673218,
0.05986782908439636,
-0.4756085276603699,
0.5182980298995972,
0.1350245475769043,
-0.21486438810825348,
0.8241934180259705,
-0.255778968334198,
-0.05204181373119354,
-0.14148543775081635,
0.268795907497406,
-0.8567481637001038,
-0.1609184890985489,
0.49192240834236145,
-0.3249991238117218,
0.043049078434705734,
-0.23202472925186157,
-0.2809346616268158,
-0.17800918221473694,
-0.30017122626304626,
0.4394245743751526,
0.13918434083461761,
-0.3622903823852539,
0.30662158131599426,
0.8655898571014404,
0.11770542711019516,
-0.5665186643600464,
-0.17540451884269714,
-0.08647837489843369,
-0.3556440770626068,
-0.2012040913105011,
0.33148446679115295,
-0.21884101629257202,
-0.4678269326686859,
-0.14811952412128448,
-0.2719748914241791,
0.02658136561512947,
0.1511615365743637,
0.3596183657646179,
0.22823216021060944,
0.2845019996166229,
0.3924896717071533,
0.3579566478729248,
-0.5760844945907593,
0.05413743481040001,
-0.2232506424188614,
0.38751035928726196,
0.018488306552171707,
-0.4834698438644409,
-0.15311092138290405,
0.49245738983154297,
0.7312930822372437,
-0.22149023413658142,
0.5585706830024719,
0.21339187026023865,
-0.31525400280952454,
0.18384359776973724,
-0.3764476776123047,
-0.1241784542798996,
-0.4221515357494354,
-0.09355024993419647,
-0.23534910380840302,
-1.0596307516098022,
0.4908651113510132,
-0.41090378165245056,
0.14737413823604584,
0.42365124821662903,
0.5925862789154053,
-0.3497968912124634,
0.7126243710517883,
0.46336856484413147,
0.05652840435504913,
0.6442857384681702,
-0.0696239322423935,
0.10204953700304031,
-0.695155680179596,
-0.5250443816184998,
-0.6181873083114624,
-0.7642587423324585,
-0.7502524256706238,
-0.5263826847076416,
0.8874877691268921,
-0.15795613825321198,
-0.36966317892074585,
0.215530127286911,
-0.6624658703804016,
0.4200746417045593,
0.5133869647979736,
0.07970430701971054,
0.3487401008605957,
-0.38332241773605347,
0.332411527633667,
-0.22516781091690063,
-0.383154958486557,
-0.34833917021751404,
0.8252416849136353,
0.04796376824378967,
0.7179082036018372,
0.21253320574760437,
0.7227752208709717,
0.45635855197906494,
0.24258145689964294,
-1.0423208475112915,
0.2333686649799347,
0.41056880354881287,
-0.7567156553268433,
-0.6655256748199463,
-0.5087109208106995,
-1.171444296836853,
0.3684122562408447,
-0.24487753212451935,
-0.7963229417800903,
0.7023141384124756,
0.319532185792923,
-0.6083276867866516,
0.2806127667427063,
-0.4714948534965515,
1.0567023754119873,
-0.41821587085723877,
-0.352210134267807,
-0.6302918791770935,
-0.8382183909416199,
0.08960367739200592,
0.3446584641933441,
0.01926230452954769,
-0.2854447066783905,
0.1693444848060608,
0.4147966206073761,
-0.6446530222892761,
0.6548686027526855,
-0.4663168489933014,
-0.009083431214094162,
0.3078404366970062,
-0.2824411988258362,
0.27882176637649536,
0.11089108884334564,
-0.5210946202278137,
0.16438016295433044,
0.3730751872062683,
-0.5670168995857239,
-0.568026602268219,
0.5624166131019592,
-0.6561280488967896,
-0.6935033798217773,
-0.6279844045639038,
-0.23058174550533295,
-0.17957808077335358,
0.006567356176674366,
0.26222068071365356,
-0.05239883437752724,
-0.4771505296230316,
-0.062373075634241104,
0.8314719796180725,
0.11461693793535233,
0.3894558250904083,
0.324733167886734,
0.14424823224544525,
-0.05483942851424217,
0.7341306805610657,
0.38077181577682495,
0.624647319316864,
0.59552001953125,
0.47023218870162964,
-0.5723405480384827,
-0.4334715008735657,
-0.525137722492218,
-0.26206034421920776,
-0.371127724647522,
-0.13083165884017944,
-0.2362845242023468,
0.230103000998497,
-0.08465941995382309,
-0.17982977628707886,
-0.43990978598594666,
-0.49095940589904785,
-0.3197270631790161,
-0.2561456859111786,
0.2648109197616577,
0.40083932876586914,
-0.4357435405254364,
-0.2973414957523346,
-0.6838846206665039,
0.05138985067605972,
0.4733221232891083,
0.06595165282487869,
-0.22408722341060638,
-0.21014325320720673,
-0.46051719784736633,
0.3153168261051178,
-0.2843482494354248,
-1.0687954425811768,
-0.12930947542190552,
-0.6003115177154541,
0.6617112755775452,
0.2870590388774872,
0.6731067895889282,
0.6656577587127686,
-0.08487121015787125,
1.0130770206451416,
0.4280969500541687,
-1.1043418645858765,
0.7936816811561584,
-0.06774748116731644,
-0.07588684558868408,
1.0866299867630005,
0.4283667504787445,
-0.6431311368942261,
0.17142871022224426,
-0.6673959493637085,
-0.8678953647613525,
0.4488644599914551,
-0.05006461963057518,
0.14673198759555817,
-0.05263310298323631,
0.27910301089286804,
0.30560657382011414,
0.6292003989219666,
-0.6044411063194275,
-0.2880561053752899,
-0.5245012044906616,
0.21079282462596893,
0.20798613131046295,
0.12769940495491028,
-0.4298407733440399,
-0.2970983386039734,
0.47493284940719604,
-0.23247940838336945,
-0.13538435101509094,
0.10284139215946198,
0.21042896807193756,
-0.4535370469093323,
0.42423248291015625,
0.5214001536369324,
0.8068944215774536,
-0.24332158267498016,
0.23051036894321442,
0.1801948845386505,
-0.1022028774023056,
0.5243085026741028,
0.203688845038414,
-0.3525502681732178,
-0.048498671501874924,
-0.3834809362888336,
0.7426621913909912,
0.17238035798072815,
-0.48356661200523376,
0.41546037793159485,
0.1615910828113556,
0.05269777774810791,
-0.39753928780555725,
0.005305948201566935,
-0.08093439787626266,
0.34555479884147644,
0.27353283762931824,
0.4077054262161255,
0.4208172559738159,
-0.832597553730011,
-0.3923007547855377,
0.6333677768707275,
-0.33170923590660095,
-0.35903382301330566,
0.4665234684944153,
0.5865127444267273,
-0.2977309226989746,
0.1298808753490448,
-0.2232753187417984,
-0.4834464490413666,
0.5569505095481873,
-0.1199025958776474,
0.7577865123748779,
-0.3157307505607605,
0.45040544867515564,
0.2738642394542694,
0.24765130877494812,
0.03169701620936394,
0.178190216422081,
-0.5360072255134583,
-0.8671830296516418,
-0.3225867450237274,
-0.36917081475257874,
-0.8712044954299927,
0.09668227285146713,
-0.8284193873405457,
0.0483253076672554,
-0.26321202516555786,
-0.3136763274669647,
0.06269492208957672,
0.21867448091506958,
-0.5466490387916565,
0.09990275651216507,
0.17952802777290344,
0.5788251161575317,
-1.060546636581421,
0.5138958096504211,
0.6939480900764465,
-0.6294867396354675,
-0.7666954398155212,
0.23023682832717896,
0.10845692455768585,
-0.4582405686378479,
0.5708760023117065,
-0.38704541325569153,
-0.29410046339035034,
-0.2896271049976349,
-0.492792010307312,
-0.8084502220153809,
1.161675214767456,
0.45568549633026123,
-0.4622386395931244,
0.2263418585062027,
-0.0844392254948616,
0.24042168259620667,
0.049668747931718826,
0.4336661696434021,
0.49411648511886597,
1.1529680490493774,
0.18843567371368408,
-1.0927523374557495,
-0.2582678496837616,
-0.09262372553348541,
-0.10878374427556992,
0.6542845368385315,
-1.159698724746704,
0.6548742055892944,
-0.09167920798063278,
-0.30729636549949646,
-0.21123634278774261,
0.5503586530685425,
-0.009933194145560265,
0.9773927330970764,
0.7635298371315002,
0.2990296185016632,
1.0597070455551147,
-0.024871325120329857,
0.6191025972366333,
-0.1617823988199234,
0.5569639801979065,
0.9288452863693237,
-0.49327802658081055,
0.5259968638420105,
0.9247872829437256,
-0.7470867037773132,
0.41653621196746826,
1.027981162071228,
0.39755699038505554,
0.604138195514679,
0.23079507052898407,
-0.622614324092865,
-0.4843136668205261,
-0.23976540565490723,
-0.49080851674079895,
0.3894376754760742,
0.23813462257385254,
-0.010262039490044117,
-0.18536165356636047,
-0.04559813812375069,
-0.11269774287939072,
0.12560731172561646,
-0.09649905562400818,
0.7502091526985168,
-0.2654299736022949,
-0.7348883152008057,
0.03334533050656319,
-0.16533352434635162,
0.37277546525001526,
-0.5168049335479736,
-0.15107056498527527,
-0.05182874575257301,
-0.31048768758773804,
-0.3677161931991577,
-0.9019107222557068,
0.20658528804779053,
-0.10304814577102661,
-0.6509474515914917,
-0.4356594383716583,
0.17936494946479797,
-0.3893354535102844,
-0.1455436497926712,
-0.09874926507472992,
0.4714558720588684,
0.16838856041431427,
0.08694645017385483,
-0.6792649030685425,
0.07021314650774002,
0.1265842765569687,
-0.1340498924255371,
0.5827385783195496,
0.36066243052482605,
-0.041212230920791626,
0.06275637447834015,
0.7371013760566711,
-0.10576508939266205,
-0.4117576479911804,
-0.10595666617155075,
1.0949251651763916,
-0.25532102584838867,
-0.4671873152256012,
-0.7121903896331787,
0.7723667025566101,
-0.21373888850212097,
-0.5196875333786011,
0.5061808824539185,
0.8058339357376099,
1.052512288093567,
0.3375290334224701,
1.0023932456970215,
-0.23503969609737396,
0.5131770372390747,
-0.49060752987861633,
0.1340164840221405,
-0.479338139295578,
0.3277520537376404,
-0.0832262933254242,
-0.8341545462608337,
0.26158666610717773,
0.7345691323280334,
-0.6622164249420166,
-0.14769771695137024,
0.2562939524650574,
0.533207356929779,
-0.10111335664987564,
0.09081272780895233,
0.2755662798881531,
-0.29438215494155884,
0.3744111955165863,
0.3315984606742859,
1.0480234622955322,
0.000574896635953337,
-0.0026878828648477793,
-0.17695455253124237,
-0.5082207322120667,
-0.35210883617401123,
-0.8403127193450928,
-0.2666378319263458,
-0.7086899280548096,
-0.34391286969184875,
-0.39076942205429077,
-0.07268685102462769,
1.503846526145935,
0.7959463596343994,
-0.6973217129707336,
-0.21947164833545685,
0.23090116679668427,
0.557751476764679,
-0.17699548602104187,
-0.24524736404418945,
0.1722196489572525,
0.11688582599163055,
-1.054301142692566,
0.3340647518634796,
0.5516847968101501,
-0.172173872590065,
-0.6685789823532104,
-0.24994707107543945,
-0.1704808473587036,
0.17873400449752808,
0.4934374988079071,
0.7740190029144287,
-0.7325689792633057,
-0.6637583374977112,
-0.19744214415550232,
0.21555115282535553,
0.2865777909755707,
1.0078380107879639,
-0.7224007248878479,
0.8661357760429382,
0.6825469732284546,
0.4103798270225525,
0.785617470741272,
0.1692652404308319,
-0.08008749037981033,
-0.24093732237815857,
0.07706330716609955,
0.5680215358734131,
0.2317432016134262,
0.23084889352321625,
-0.5944848656654358,
0.15161937475204468,
0.5106261968612671,
-0.8006647825241089,
-0.5927491784095764,
0.5362377166748047,
-0.9419593214988708,
-0.2032083421945572,
0.6915558576583862,
-0.17152713239192963,
0.07829129695892334,
-0.11572989076375961,
-0.26460257172584534,
0.18414300680160522,
-0.5816410183906555,
1.03468656539917,
0.575049877166748,
-0.6346176266670227,
-0.0985938236117363,
-0.2432737648487091,
0.22233399748802185,
0.2884150743484497,
-0.845116913318634,
-0.08948976546525955,
1.007523775100708,
0.09987135976552963,
0.4495331943035126,
0.7445119619369507,
0.2163008451461792,
0.2611929476261139,
-0.04575589671730995,
-0.004207578022032976,
0.04203888773918152,
-0.0835115909576416,
-0.002191235776990652,
0.17487362027168274,
-0.11035089939832687,
-0.5245400667190552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16717v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16717v1
|
CodeChameleon: Personalized Encryption Framework for Jailbreaking Large Language Models
| 2024-02-26T16:35:59 | 2024-02-26T16:35:59 |
Huijie Lv, Xiao Wang, Yuansen Zhang, Caishuang Huang, Shihan Dou, Junjie Ye, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR
|
Adversarial misuse, particularly through `jailbreaking' that circumvents a
model's safety and ethical protocols, poses a significant challenge for Large
Language Models (LLMs). This paper delves into the mechanisms behind such
successful attacks, introducing a hypothesis for the safety mechanism of
aligned LLMs: intent security recognition followed by response generation.
Grounded in this hypothesis, we propose CodeChameleon, a novel jailbreak
framework based on personalized encryption tactics. To elude the intent
security recognition phase, we reformulate tasks into a code completion format,
enabling users to encrypt queries using personalized encryption functions. To
guarantee response generation functionality, we embed a decryption function
within the instructions, which allows the LLM to decrypt and execute the
encrypted queries successfully. We conduct extensive experiments on 7 LLMs,
achieving state-of-the-art average Attack Success Rate (ASR). Remarkably, our
method achieves an 86.6\% ASR on GPT-4-1106.
|
[
-0.34434765577316284,
-0.7060778737068176,
0.4166790544986725,
0.15161266922950745,
-0.09329746663570404,
0.38262253999710083,
-0.34481081366539,
-0.2739144265651703,
0.34117111563682556,
1.1332241296768188,
-0.25960206985473633,
-0.6344231963157654,
-0.5866588950157166,
0.0316336490213871,
-0.44259291887283325,
0.9992435574531555,
0.2815411686897278,
-0.14868803322315216,
0.21591143310070038,
-0.05924627557396889,
-0.6748260855674744,
-0.8136819005012512,
-0.4552047848701477,
-0.24202488362789154,
0.3593144714832306,
0.23861651122570038,
0.8180806636810303,
0.6001316905021667,
0.5250117182731628,
0.34781235456466675,
-0.12933026254177094,
-0.0677519142627716,
-0.2907954752445221,
0.37938132882118225,
0.07466515898704529,
-0.8274519443511963,
-0.2488359957933426,
-0.27759674191474915,
-0.09806535392999649,
0.29571664333343506,
-0.40598753094673157,
-0.16917505860328674,
-0.15736809372901917,
0.7452529072761536,
-0.7727482318878174,
0.055717114359140396,
-1.1368944644927979,
0.1735275834798813,
-0.250628262758255,
-0.1442531943321228,
-0.6493792533874512,
-0.4592171013355255,
-0.051277123391628265,
-0.2559836804866791,
0.008598494343459606,
0.04985148832201958,
0.15124134719371796,
0.08195731043815613,
-0.21453051269054413,
-0.657339870929718,
-0.3639918863773346,
0.4848453104496002,
-0.7610504627227783,
-0.047711361199617386,
0.6909111142158508,
0.40928328037261963,
-0.366189181804657,
-0.675497829914093,
-0.38868337869644165,
-0.5012190341949463,
0.019154444336891174,
-0.2806690037250519,
-0.13329951465129852,
0.2775149643421173,
0.2641279995441437,
0.13568651676177979,
-0.6579129695892334,
0.03441750630736351,
-0.31549614667892456,
-0.21096378564834595,
0.8025376200675964,
0.21192768216133118,
0.5756632089614868,
-0.21956896781921387,
-0.15403078496456146,
0.15349958837032318,
-0.8069243431091309,
0.24744103848934174,
0.5412731170654297,
0.15262795984745026,
-0.017874030396342278,
0.5839940905570984,
0.006677152123302221,
0.7000630497932434,
-0.025051768869161606,
0.038988709449768066,
0.12731710076332092,
0.09040794521570206,
-0.31826213002204895,
0.6475083231925964,
0.905337929725647,
0.17009933292865753,
0.5576819777488708,
-0.45312511920928955,
-0.21193809807300568,
-0.015816228464245796,
0.5148630738258362,
-0.857428789138794,
-0.3550376892089844,
0.4308657646179199,
-0.3432973325252533,
-0.8412591218948364,
0.11062128841876984,
-0.7748958468437195,
-0.6833825707435608,
0.33851203322410583,
-0.05713756009936333,
-0.3876742422580719,
-0.03669097647070885,
0.3002828061580658,
0.08222663402557373,
0.09874499589204788,
-0.05879772827029228,
-1.2879552841186523,
0.391461580991745,
0.8423157930374146,
0.7497873902320862,
-0.04505957290530205,
-0.21276313066482544,
-0.4769551455974579,
0.25389304757118225,
-0.20452548563480377,
0.35186246037483215,
-0.6894719004631042,
-0.6796009540557861,
0.0762147530913353,
-0.14380194246768951,
-0.16982589662075043,
-0.47558778524398804,
0.2911364734172821,
-1.0723706483840942,
-0.3212578296661377,
0.0017970349872484803,
-0.5666546821594238,
-0.10493742674589157,
0.31468015909194946,
-0.907766580581665,
0.16509473323822021,
-0.33406370878219604,
-0.731781005859375,
-0.05868382379412651,
-0.6678244471549988,
-0.594281017780304,
0.14931172132492065,
-0.393502801656723,
-0.47835633158683777,
0.19026243686676025,
0.3532841205596924,
0.3602190911769867,
-0.18127988278865814,
0.44332319498062134,
-0.420881450176239,
-0.4043373167514801,
0.7134950160980225,
-0.3649652302265167,
0.8639388084411621,
0.3703223466873169,
-0.5766967535018921,
-0.006425168830901384,
-0.7102836966514587,
0.2579963803291321,
0.5355650782585144,
-0.3914808928966522,
-0.3997052311897278,
0.17017851769924164,
-0.07560382783412933,
-0.14101485908031464,
0.3398143947124481,
-0.5020595788955688,
0.5190333127975464,
-0.622035801410675,
1.0224266052246094,
0.7172558307647705,
0.06330864131450653,
0.3403354585170746,
0.11670076847076416,
0.5667705535888672,
-0.28024300932884216,
-0.04411257430911064,
-0.5837206840515137,
-0.3309590220451355,
-0.13132427632808685,
-0.1511876881122589,
0.19805145263671875,
0.6543238162994385,
-0.4041730761528015,
0.42831143736839294,
-0.050459686666727066,
-0.45083579421043396,
-0.34228256344795227,
0.2874828577041626,
0.6821652054786682,
0.1629544049501419,
0.25759199261665344,
-0.2782931923866272,
-0.5361911058425903,
-0.8198820352554321,
-0.6332991123199463,
-0.03472036123275757,
0.06610049307346344,
0.4632135331630707,
0.4682450592517853,
-0.4772966504096985,
0.7451208233833313,
-0.7155634760856628,
-0.12160448729991913,
-0.38689643144607544,
-0.06909987330436707,
0.16029424965381622,
0.5704232454299927,
0.6231689453125,
-1.0060935020446777,
-0.24652650952339172,
-0.08489246666431427,
-0.8958162665367126,
0.06891719251871109,
0.14948047697544098,
0.12258599698543549,
0.006045403424650431,
0.5280990600585938,
-0.775683581829071,
0.4357680380344391,
0.5266741514205933,
-0.3889755308628082,
0.5280333757400513,
-0.13225726783275604,
0.1497947722673416,
-1.0472347736358643,
-0.18774493038654327,
-0.20302554965019226,
-0.1259630024433136,
-0.7224598526954651,
0.42899590730667114,
0.14303848147392273,
-0.4861641228199005,
-0.2979152500629425,
0.12908154726028442,
-0.3383598029613495,
0.0036280937492847443,
-0.37511515617370605,
0.05262860283255577,
-0.3290488123893738,
0.357943594455719,
-0.2534997761249542,
0.7778085470199585,
0.3662542700767517,
-0.27851319313049316,
0.4883672297000885,
0.5136860609054565,
-0.26592379808425903,
-0.08900440484285355,
-0.8561622500419617,
0.49992573261260986,
0.1359773576259613,
0.10301967710256577,
-0.9143653512001038,
-0.6581118702888489,
0.086084745824337,
-0.5486576557159424,
0.08236677199602127,
-0.2556770443916321,
-0.3199099898338318,
-0.26035502552986145,
-0.5311421751976013,
0.5169579386711121,
0.5446860194206238,
-0.703120231628418,
0.29307904839515686,
0.4900316298007965,
-0.09348324686288834,
-0.4956778287887573,
-0.8700209259986877,
0.5313357710838318,
-0.30996382236480713,
-0.8090813159942627,
0.3134351074695587,
-0.13181017339229584,
-0.31440269947052,
-0.33091849088668823,
-0.07124105840921402,
-0.22847622632980347,
0.34082454442977905,
0.2587704360485077,
0.16505609452724457,
0.02153673581779003,
-0.35422420501708984,
-0.0506790466606617,
-0.03710067272186279,
0.29244881868362427,
-0.12371335923671722,
0.8825783729553223,
-0.15467941761016846,
-0.3444293439388275,
-0.26132476329803467,
0.13687235116958618,
0.7177148461341858,
-0.5928520560264587,
0.64630126953125,
-0.007437756285071373,
-0.30775782465934753,
-0.12024327367544174,
-0.4641602039337158,
-0.20833735167980194,
-0.5600056648254395,
0.39770713448524475,
-0.4968586564064026,
-0.9691358208656311,
0.5296540856361389,
0.023581016808748245,
-0.006440821103751659,
-0.30582115054130554,
0.5070921182632446,
0.20673327147960663,
1.2092496156692505,
0.3622162342071533,
-0.6004436612129211,
0.30976027250289917,
-0.042999640107154846,
0.30224764347076416,
-0.781405508518219,
-0.39529314637184143,
-0.5153384208679199,
-0.13392551243305206,
-0.7574537992477417,
0.030658738687634468,
0.01563306897878647,
0.0988461822271347,
-0.35979923605918884,
0.6825267672538757,
-0.5514650344848633,
0.4982684850692749,
0.22200839221477509,
0.23375262320041656,
0.3605705201625824,
0.045712344348430634,
0.18791194260120392,
-0.0948057547211647,
-0.22389833629131317,
-0.4792170226573944,
1.3508882522583008,
0.17040927708148956,
1.2023884057998657,
0.3123663663864136,
0.9509266018867493,
0.41562652587890625,
0.047616954892873764,
-0.6041185259819031,
0.6705856323242188,
-0.09824808686971664,
-0.44188249111175537,
-0.07630646228790283,
-0.38947224617004395,
-1.078207015991211,
0.4235866963863373,
0.12047142535448074,
-1.2173949480056763,
-0.2732731103897095,
0.30760571360588074,
-0.2547716796398163,
0.19534653425216675,
-0.5618606209754944,
0.7745189666748047,
-0.4944014251232147,
-0.11239992827177048,
-0.11099747568368912,
-0.6708148717880249,
0.8066065907478333,
-0.29126375913619995,
0.24185429513454437,
0.030440179631114006,
-0.019385529682040215,
0.6006536483764648,
-0.7247235774993896,
0.7351574897766113,
-0.32074978947639465,
0.20273619890213013,
0.138498917222023,
0.38131624460220337,
0.8974084258079529,
0.37447312474250793,
0.003517888253554702,
-0.01978471875190735,
-0.2791816294193268,
-0.127143993973732,
-0.6587660312652588,
0.8735010623931885,
-0.5722782015800476,
-0.9348817467689514,
-0.15335172414779663,
-0.36628758907318115,
-0.20768824219703674,
0.1621495634317398,
0.43448546528816223,
0.3213951289653778,
0.055167004466056824,
0.42440930008888245,
0.8418570756912231,
-0.2502126395702362,
0.5203787088394165,
0.430691123008728,
-0.30800196528434753,
-0.589742124080658,
0.7218396067619324,
-0.18407554924488068,
0.07263945043087006,
0.16699150204658508,
0.09651262313127518,
0.029152924194931984,
-0.7680953741073608,
-0.29804015159606934,
-0.15045422315597534,
-0.4839223325252533,
-0.31963208317756653,
-0.7017554044723511,
-0.394191175699234,
-0.38736584782600403,
-0.3843851089477539,
-0.3315237760543823,
-0.03882888704538345,
0.11137082427740097,
-0.10549766570329666,
0.13381952047348022,
0.4163912534713745,
0.5453894734382629,
0.437309205532074,
-0.8353999257087708,
0.39168068766593933,
0.2921757400035858,
0.05119991675019264,
-0.08876382559537888,
-0.322733610868454,
0.05796420946717262,
-0.11155765503644943,
-0.24471446871757507,
-1.1771068572998047,
0.42412492632865906,
-0.02138601429760456,
0.419540137052536,
0.251217782497406,
0.029644198715686798,
0.4077620208263397,
-0.612240731716156,
0.622120201587677,
0.2658708691596985,
-1.0394444465637207,
0.8054783940315247,
-0.21334101259708405,
0.1659102886915207,
0.5957630276679993,
-0.032980505377054214,
-0.3991653621196747,
-0.5220931768417358,
-0.4472077190876007,
-1.0696728229522705,
0.5273737907409668,
0.4675527513027191,
0.31481486558914185,
0.07696270942687988,
0.503703773021698,
-0.08840706944465637,
0.6244398355484009,
-0.8389855027198792,
-0.28203389048576355,
-0.18961983919143677,
-0.3163131773471832,
0.14023181796073914,
-0.36347609758377075,
-0.19242611527442932,
0.08502958714962006,
0.3601526916027069,
-0.07939477264881134,
0.17610621452331543,
-0.019829651340842247,
-0.3952026069164276,
0.28726527094841003,
0.4906356632709503,
0.6175527572631836,
0.4114346206188202,
-0.08185221254825592,
-0.0038159906398504972,
-0.09396935999393463,
-0.848684549331665,
0.3835054039955139,
0.163760244846344,
-0.26321330666542053,
-0.3860761821269989,
0.5608198046684265,
0.5785895586013794,
0.23892304301261902,
-0.9444538950920105,
0.5906592607498169,
-0.403677374124527,
0.0995989665389061,
-0.5330385565757751,
0.49300265312194824,
-0.1189330518245697,
0.20390355587005615,
0.3731192648410797,
0.13827195763587952,
0.19658415019512177,
-0.3854615390300751,
0.2591172456741333,
0.5123112201690674,
-0.2017049938440323,
-0.33392128348350525,
0.9915919303894043,
0.0422755591571331,
-0.5049465298652649,
0.5750331878662109,
-0.09084700047969818,
-0.6348971128463745,
0.9560782313346863,
0.8391757607460022,
1.1286756992340088,
-0.405619740486145,
0.037050969898700714,
0.043832991272211075,
0.532066285610199,
-0.1262548863887787,
0.19522033631801605,
-0.014785908162593842,
-0.764085590839386,
-0.0249035581946373,
-0.4668683409690857,
-0.18625764548778534,
0.3162956237792969,
-0.7265577912330627,
0.01910175010561943,
-0.7335466146469116,
0.06622722744941711,
-0.02750333398580551,
-0.363781213760376,
-0.2798236906528473,
0.13794921338558197,
0.13987073302268982,
0.9768636226654053,
-0.31504467129707336,
0.8706235885620117,
0.6433987021446228,
-0.1881365329027176,
-0.8801615834236145,
0.22608427703380585,
0.15447945892810822,
-1.0055102109909058,
0.4664008617401123,
0.4851646423339844,
0.04686715826392174,
-0.20176076889038086,
-0.6204418540000916,
-0.7227271199226379,
1.087789535522461,
0.5709401965141296,
-0.9802913665771484,
-0.07511033862829208,
0.20245592296123505,
0.28046050667762756,
-0.5666502714157104,
-0.0827992707490921,
1.0121639966964722,
0.33141282200813293,
-0.24751269817352295,
-0.5121827125549316,
0.2721814811229706,
-0.1841394305229187,
0.2914178967475891,
0.21956826746463776,
-0.48361194133758545,
0.651852011680603,
-0.5367150902748108,
0.27729541063308716,
0.3502640426158905,
0.4037116467952728,
0.5863164663314819,
0.29044705629348755,
0.39414843916893005,
0.3972436189651489,
0.6528517007827759,
-0.020817343145608902,
1.0286344289779663,
-0.7968865036964417,
0.2879825830459595,
1.0858180522918701,
-0.26170679926872253,
0.6323876976966858,
0.27426862716674805,
-0.03250443935394287,
0.1439054012298584,
0.31512850522994995,
-0.15020513534545898,
0.885136067867279,
0.45425790548324585,
-0.3691149353981018,
0.03212794288992882,
0.3943476676940918,
-0.4154778718948364,
0.681134819984436,
0.34115949273109436,
-0.6170353889465332,
0.03270072862505913,
0.4534986913204193,
0.3916592299938202,
0.20049116015434265,
-0.5961992144584656,
0.7091381549835205,
0.1713208258152008,
-0.6834871768951416,
0.5799314379692078,
0.1874811202287674,
0.6250039339065552,
-0.6442648768424988,
0.27637389302253723,
-0.08369915187358856,
0.27430227398872375,
-0.5605787038803101,
-0.7238477468490601,
0.11939215660095215,
0.21569080650806427,
0.016460545361042023,
0.2779041528701782,
0.9722517132759094,
-0.36314523220062256,
-0.07894545048475266,
0.5011506676673889,
-0.19296972453594208,
-0.13247628509998322,
-0.24042335152626038,
-0.6515423059463501,
0.47407034039497375,
0.2425033301115036,
-0.6815049052238464,
0.42372140288352966,
-0.18141065537929535,
0.158763125538826,
0.9063916802406311,
0.5333429574966431,
-0.013084776699543,
0.1008855327963829,
-0.0025368237402290106,
0.9192653894424438,
-0.8199672102928162,
-0.6660049557685852,
-1.345637559890747,
0.22461940348148346,
-0.12714631855487823,
-0.07550442963838577,
0.709694504737854,
0.5722951292991638,
0.6434531211853027,
-0.12660878896713257,
1.2338443994522095,
-0.0970316231250763,
-0.0769430622458458,
-0.7008335590362549,
0.7785371541976929,
-0.13847902417182922,
0.7807613611221313,
-0.22916683554649353,
-0.703967809677124,
-0.13105234503746033,
0.4041508138179779,
-0.40340715646743774,
0.0876920148730278,
0.4228929579257965,
0.7617673277854919,
0.19201835989952087,
0.35553449392318726,
0.43831804394721985,
0.20496191084384918,
0.7713831067085266,
0.7477095127105713,
0.5500850081443787,
-0.30533453822135925,
0.7403465509414673,
-0.12410791218280792,
-0.23436085879802704,
-0.24699260294437408,
-0.39697086811065674,
-1.1758816242218018,
-0.18489019572734833,
0.005773311480879784,
-0.46295711398124695,
0.33798468112945557,
0.9537085294723511,
0.4263909161090851,
-0.6980451345443726,
-0.15631498396396637,
-0.4688403010368347,
-0.09323703497648239,
0.19549457728862762,
-0.21630364656448364,
0.1440955549478531,
-0.3162153363227844,
-0.3625611364841461,
0.5878697633743286,
0.4734393060207367,
-0.18489067256450653,
-0.21045255661010742,
-0.08101603388786316,
0.2924860715866089,
0.17118456959724426,
0.3536868989467621,
0.5320340991020203,
-0.6967509388923645,
-0.16598334908485413,
-0.26830434799194336,
-0.40633857250213623,
0.10333389043807983,
1.0768938064575195,
-0.49336421489715576,
0.4586564898490906,
0.20615790784358978,
1.1093688011169434,
0.4776751697063446,
-0.05446885898709297,
0.4915916323661804,
-0.6411411166191101,
0.31183794140815735,
0.29492393136024475,
0.538883626461029,
0.11376594752073288,
-0.6957080364227295,
0.3440091609954834,
0.13152071833610535,
-0.6894146203994751,
-0.8437917828559875,
0.5830225944519043,
-0.7229021191596985,
-0.3272976577281952,
0.8817972540855408,
-0.4286811649799347,
-0.48709115386009216,
-0.024897471070289612,
-0.2793402373790741,
-0.37530508637428284,
-0.4954043924808502,
0.928054928779602,
0.45157042145729065,
-0.15167999267578125,
0.10178931057453156,
-0.6103134155273438,
0.42997005581855774,
0.16820603609085083,
-0.8999853134155273,
0.11477923393249512,
0.0824451893568039,
0.446705162525177,
0.14714135229587555,
0.686987042427063,
-0.27170807123184204,
0.448047935962677,
-0.16177985072135925,
-0.09392347931861877,
-0.337196409702301,
-0.17556749284267426,
-0.3822747468948364,
0.6379256248474121,
0.13323602080345154,
-0.10871308296918869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16714v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16714v2
|
Quantum linear algebra is all you need for Transformer architectures
| 2024-02-26T16:31:28 | 2024-05-31T03:34:57 |
Naixu Guo, Zhan Yu, Matthew Choi, Aman Agrawal, Kouhei Nakaji, Alán Aspuru-Guzik, Patrick Rebentrost
|
quant-ph
|
quant-ph, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Generative machine learning methods such as large-language models are
revolutionizing the creation of text and images. While these models are
powerful they also harness a large amount of computational resources. The
transformer is a key component in large language models that aims to generate a
suitable completion of a given partial sequence. In this work, we investigate
transformer architectures under the lens of fault-tolerant quantum computing.
The input model is one where trained weight matrices are given as block
encodings and we construct the query, key, and value matrices for the
transformer. We show how to prepare a block encoding of the self-attention
matrix, with a new subroutine for the row-wise application of the softmax
function. In addition, we combine quantum subroutines to construct important
building blocks in the transformer, the residual connection and layer
normalization, and the feed-forward neural network. Our subroutines prepare an
amplitude encoding of the transformer output, which can be measured to obtain a
prediction. Based on common open-source large-language models, we provide
insights into the behavior of important parameters determining the run time of
the quantum algorithm. We discuss the potential and challenges for obtaining a
quantum advantage.
|
[
-0.10691700875759125,
-0.6466677188873291,
0.6847420930862427,
0.16562248766422272,
-0.1446145623922348,
0.3478879928588867,
0.2506359815597534,
-0.05335591733455658,
0.04920320212841034,
0.2415313571691513,
-0.14825809001922607,
0.15077640116214752,
-0.6231049299240112,
-0.08822941035032272,
-0.6682776212692261,
0.7416588068008423,
-0.22853749990463257,
-0.005217425525188446,
-0.04336331784725189,
0.013392037712037563,
-0.5925367474555969,
-0.2311234325170517,
-0.4396742880344391,
-0.3805612027645111,
0.09630458056926727,
0.0045979637652635574,
1.1067070960998535,
0.44600909948349,
0.3265085220336914,
0.4249397814273834,
0.15741510689258575,
-0.36871662735939026,
-0.646988570690155,
0.3073013722896576,
-0.35403385758399963,
-0.5962034463882446,
-0.3012215793132782,
-0.5171195864677429,
0.9165869355201721,
0.5899778008460999,
-0.07923558354377747,
0.19708776473999023,
-0.0023123696446418762,
0.9438843727111816,
-0.5706596374511719,
0.039295412600040436,
-0.5242446660995483,
0.572943925857544,
-0.07628993690013885,
0.06529402732849121,
-0.39544469118118286,
-0.4266607463359833,
-0.12389985471963882,
-0.5140414237976074,
0.15635725855827332,
-0.03520119562745094,
0.5493012070655823,
0.20700982213020325,
-0.5198273062705994,
-0.002195577835664153,
-1.1514018774032593,
0.9452117681503296,
-0.22811980545520782,
1.036989688873291,
-0.15539401769638062,
0.44060271978378296,
-0.06828705221414566,
-0.7868961691856384,
-0.5483548045158386,
0.021543366834521294,
-0.08167241513729095,
0.299051433801651,
-0.8284575939178467,
-0.10160242766141891,
0.0722113847732544,
0.6327288746833801,
-0.7573517560958862,
-0.33607447147369385,
-0.5659371614456177,
-0.07979554682970047,
0.3052516579627991,
0.18440558016300201,
0.03756454214453697,
-0.21088555455207825,
-0.20636163651943207,
-0.2765847146511078,
-0.5327820777893066,
-0.20316743850708008,
-0.06443078070878983,
-0.08492988348007202,
0.11060366779565811,
0.3595510721206665,
0.06650955229997635,
0.30598941445350647,
0.27272745966911316,
0.21053801476955414,
-0.17141716182231903,
-0.1497066617012024,
-0.3894064128398895,
0.09307057410478592,
0.9620909690856934,
-0.3562026917934418,
0.15920990705490112,
-0.48824983835220337,
-0.42953357100486755,
0.06904172152280807,
0.8770711421966553,
-0.6006315350532532,
-0.45789170265197754,
0.288568913936615,
-0.5052233338356018,
-0.06741882115602493,
-0.5204768180847168,
-0.6876050233840942,
-0.22166116535663605,
-0.18152645230293274,
0.8967995047569275,
-0.4745190739631653,
-0.11177720129489899,
-0.0534750260412693,
-0.008378393948078156,
0.3348329961299896,
0.051131367683410645,
-0.6603879928588867,
0.3223716616630554,
0.5298290252685547,
0.48898839950561523,
0.28260770440101624,
-0.05466058477759361,
-0.3110862970352173,
0.169411301612854,
-0.645107090473175,
0.411378413438797,
-0.2087727040052414,
-0.4375900626182556,
0.08945056796073914,
-0.24419493973255157,
0.05002962425351143,
-0.39295101165771484,
0.5805880427360535,
-1.014628291130066,
-0.037709906697273254,
0.20255325734615326,
-0.33891215920448303,
-0.22283536195755005,
-0.021090177819132805,
-0.7787799835205078,
0.5136268734931946,
0.4671298563480377,
-0.35373225808143616,
-0.4147578775882721,
-0.5464417934417725,
-0.7800731658935547,
0.2401503473520279,
-0.07676995545625687,
-0.7100763916969299,
0.5173276662826538,
-0.069980189204216,
0.32070523500442505,
-0.41995733976364136,
0.27338719367980957,
-0.0645408183336258,
-0.39834052324295044,
0.5941312313079834,
-0.29047179222106934,
0.40507328510284424,
0.27670130133628845,
-0.5538845658302307,
0.19007869064807892,
-0.9009771943092346,
-0.012363016605377197,
0.48705336451530457,
-0.19887755811214447,
-0.05926042050123215,
0.16541865468025208,
0.07349403202533722,
0.05503164976835251,
0.390360027551651,
-0.5426607131958008,
-0.052077390253543854,
-0.0495375357568264,
0.7367004156112671,
0.9216004610061646,
-0.5147888660430908,
0.5637896060943604,
0.09950502216815948,
0.810500979423523,
-0.009433354251086712,
0.3895889222621918,
-0.17755451798439026,
-0.13031479716300964,
-1.1179511547088623,
0.09151393175125122,
0.3040415644645691,
0.5987241864204407,
-0.8881955146789551,
0.34465456008911133,
-0.5333461165428162,
-0.6043418049812317,
-0.5822233557701111,
0.18867279589176178,
0.6268529891967773,
0.18399493396282196,
0.492433100938797,
-0.17266340553760529,
-0.6286523342132568,
-1.1940207481384277,
-0.14692874252796173,
0.01939503103494644,
-0.031033603474497795,
0.003804778214544058,
0.18664534389972687,
-0.31503042578697205,
0.6017654538154602,
-0.5152034759521484,
-0.1861519068479538,
-0.055755164474248886,
-0.209570974111557,
0.2973138988018036,
0.6156603693962097,
-0.21353910863399506,
-0.8094951510429382,
-0.2534882426261902,
0.05778152123093605,
-0.9166164398193359,
0.7000855207443237,
-0.023051610216498375,
-0.4248349368572235,
0.03784012049436569,
0.34981998801231384,
-0.5975335836410522,
0.20222923159599304,
0.601826548576355,
-0.09057662636041641,
0.2383386641740799,
0.020916402339935303,
-0.03338773921132088,
-1.0601081848144531,
-0.04324335604906082,
0.003159424988552928,
-0.3962332010269165,
-0.7593721747398376,
0.3737984001636505,
0.20987382531166077,
-0.3468973636627197,
0.0102532422170043,
-0.07172948122024536,
-0.06378812342882156,
-0.055854011327028275,
-0.25232452154159546,
-0.11082620918750763,
-0.0643291026353836,
0.40592923760414124,
-0.20955650508403778,
0.5090364217758179,
0.5780977606773376,
-0.40230512619018555,
0.4415275454521179,
0.1634892076253891,
-0.011616808362305164,
0.4513741135597229,
-1.0050705671310425,
0.17601926624774933,
-0.10091373324394226,
0.09183329343795776,
-0.7356163859367371,
0.20623746514320374,
0.0019014234421774745,
-0.3403457999229431,
0.2536133825778961,
0.12530885636806488,
-0.3503323495388031,
-0.5372289419174194,
-0.17258964478969574,
0.5467982888221741,
0.8628812432289124,
-0.4125286042690277,
1.3305786848068237,
0.1758994609117508,
0.23733370006084442,
-0.37815526127815247,
-0.650748074054718,
-0.0018633464351296425,
0.12417634576559067,
-0.5500721335411072,
0.18000905215740204,
0.012276527471840382,
0.07660359144210815,
0.2550393342971802,
0.033561285585165024,
-0.04748653247952461,
0.27517759799957275,
0.590359091758728,
0.3391996920108795,
-0.5476107001304626,
0.18500323593616486,
0.0816115140914917,
-0.2982221245765686,
0.17047198116779327,
-0.6783871054649353,
0.544461190700531,
-0.533301055431366,
-0.2506358325481415,
-0.2177656888961792,
0.3763123154640198,
0.5646846890449524,
-0.30546918511390686,
0.5589643716812134,
0.5626528263092041,
-0.34676066040992737,
-0.26090168952941895,
-0.3014501631259918,
-0.027539176866412163,
-0.5556614398956299,
0.4403283894062042,
-0.5438626408576965,
-1.1123627424240112,
0.15179955959320068,
0.041508998721838,
0.034162819385528564,
0.6276131272315979,
0.5824084281921387,
-0.022529352456331253,
1.0224509239196777,
0.8204160928726196,
-0.1092468872666359,
0.3208348751068115,
-0.033442702144384384,
0.864205539226532,
-0.6500571966171265,
0.14034323394298553,
-0.2838813066482544,
-0.519519031047821,
-0.6653275489807129,
-0.31337785720825195,
0.5817520618438721,
0.25007861852645874,
-0.46910399198532104,
0.5190878510475159,
-0.7031447887420654,
0.23171573877334595,
0.7718595266342163,
-0.07988166064023972,
0.20053048431873322,
-0.09884554892778397,
0.2560236155986786,
0.23985496163368225,
-0.5790023803710938,
-0.25601789355278015,
1.0142569541931152,
0.5543454885482788,
0.8604441285133362,
0.254636287689209,
0.5500022768974304,
0.12763266265392303,
-0.08526096493005753,
-0.6585016846656799,
0.449161171913147,
-0.03922000527381897,
-0.2972685992717743,
-0.288766086101532,
-0.49025389552116394,
-0.9243998527526855,
0.024081414565443993,
-0.13876743614673615,
-0.2827201783657074,
0.20665901899337769,
0.23435699939727783,
-0.40712055563926697,
0.16512897610664368,
-0.6998506784439087,
0.8760420680046082,
0.07097961753606796,
-0.2218198925256729,
-0.535433292388916,
-0.462477445602417,
0.6237052083015442,
-0.39154189825057983,
0.21491332352161407,
0.5339404940605164,
0.3471987545490265,
0.5472092032432556,
0.02587788924574852,
0.5182079672813416,
0.22811582684516907,
-0.19710606336593628,
0.15206214785575867,
0.6651396155357361,
0.26384276151657104,
0.06873903423547745,
0.2119768261909485,
0.09621024876832962,
-0.031984198838472366,
-0.5404040217399597,
-0.40561699867248535,
0.6556875705718994,
-1.0029295682907104,
-0.5454865097999573,
-0.2614108622074127,
-0.5301766395568848,
-0.2895827293395996,
0.18973150849342346,
-0.20904260873794556,
0.46250709891319275,
-0.11122670024633408,
0.20036357641220093,
0.9251391887664795,
-0.12087352573871613,
0.5039944648742676,
0.43664389848709106,
-0.30947333574295044,
-0.4617847800254822,
1.171932339668274,
0.01552577968686819,
0.10938851535320282,
0.7444362044334412,
0.1507662534713745,
0.005090909544378519,
-0.27224212884902954,
-0.47758445143699646,
0.012641822919249535,
-0.8772408366203308,
-0.5458435416221619,
-0.5565426349639893,
-0.49601152539253235,
-0.30707886815071106,
-0.29608026146888733,
-0.6038382649421692,
-0.381526917219162,
0.10452985763549805,
0.030240580439567566,
0.26139184832572937,
1.0992826223373413,
-0.09478821605443954,
0.1484045684337616,
-1.1176668405532837,
0.421650767326355,
0.9790231585502625,
0.4058273434638977,
0.4093834161758423,
-0.27321475744247437,
-0.5818673372268677,
-0.40394508838653564,
-0.7883133888244629,
-0.6774724721908569,
-0.005189156625419855,
0.193686842918396,
0.26223865151405334,
0.2505625784397125,
-0.0731365755200386,
0.42541876435279846,
-0.916128933429718,
0.7386611700057983,
0.33140093088150024,
-1.49269700050354,
0.5028820037841797,
0.058955829590559006,
0.3106057345867157,
0.056450486183166504,
0.5694130659103394,
-0.4794386327266693,
-0.45397666096687317,
-0.44593513011932373,
-0.5440331697463989,
0.3517993092536926,
0.17580923438072205,
0.24017038941383362,
0.1741126924753189,
0.18915320932865143,
-0.2579527795314789,
-0.0285466518253088,
-0.8348657488822937,
-0.22093652188777924,
-0.6120274662971497,
-0.3468647301197052,
-0.13615088164806366,
-0.2819443643093109,
-0.16498877108097076,
0.04178141802549362,
0.7776104807853699,
-0.10700278729200363,
0.45405903458595276,
0.0784730315208435,
-0.25942015647888184,
-0.6061403155326843,
0.4997454583644867,
0.3703776001930237,
0.8366090059280396,
0.1386706680059433,
0.39735811948776245,
0.026442717760801315,
-0.4081774652004242,
0.06746452301740646,
0.28060775995254517,
-0.16457179188728333,
-0.071552574634552,
0.2385057806968689,
0.9250702261924744,
0.4100586473941803,
-0.682979166507721,
0.30059781670570374,
-0.23735861480236053,
-0.09788554906845093,
-0.3733288645744324,
-0.21673902869224548,
0.3187907636165619,
0.6597435474395752,
0.5878314971923828,
-0.2021321803331375,
0.4030999541282654,
-0.37596508860588074,
0.046570513397455215,
0.6014867424964905,
-0.5277482867240906,
-0.4806656837463379,
0.7874959111213684,
-0.17736667394638062,
-0.2932471036911011,
0.5856463313102722,
-0.23410587012767792,
-0.8653311133384705,
0.24253840744495392,
0.7475717663764954,
0.9266335964202881,
-0.435488224029541,
-0.004926454275846481,
0.2612449824810028,
0.4959771931171417,
0.43342459201812744,
0.21584296226501465,
-0.04958996921777725,
-0.4893038272857666,
-0.5345902442932129,
-1.2545162439346313,
-0.26278793811798096,
-0.30351343750953674,
-0.41403841972351074,
-0.10412732511758804,
-0.5735798478126526,
0.12246865034103394,
-0.10135143995285034,
-0.366946280002594,
-0.5844870805740356,
0.11263705044984818,
0.3962642252445221,
0.3157727122306824,
-0.8189277648925781,
0.7903493642807007,
0.5523194670677185,
-0.16373714804649353,
-1.0319534540176392,
-0.47791871428489685,
-0.37644726037979126,
-0.9328681826591492,
0.758370041847229,
-0.19527657330036163,
0.03409489244222641,
0.1277981996536255,
-0.16249026358127594,
-0.8995319604873657,
1.0305596590042114,
0.2533971965312958,
-0.8057440519332886,
0.014140687882900238,
0.1908615678548813,
0.3302169442176819,
0.3622983694076538,
0.2523916959762573,
0.566888153553009,
0.1513032615184784,
-0.1212126687169075,
-0.7657578587532043,
0.37475553154945374,
-0.14238041639328003,
0.5702285766601562,
0.7561930418014526,
-0.5204033851623535,
1.1185470819473267,
0.24100333452224731,
-0.13983763754367828,
-0.11407408863306046,
1.1967037916183472,
-0.03582063689827919,
-0.1561904400587082,
0.5350223779678345,
0.7303482890129089,
0.34472838044166565,
-0.030475249513983727,
0.9387442469596863,
-0.49746206402778625,
0.421082079410553,
0.48264017701148987,
-0.004410258028656244,
0.9167765974998474,
0.234582781791687,
-0.7132361531257629,
0.665982186794281,
-0.13738761842250824,
-0.1461770087480545,
0.22529441118240356,
0.2582342028617859,
-0.2680806815624237,
-0.2630655765533447,
0.03418070077896118,
-0.3316207528114319,
0.2784248888492584,
0.15653003752231598,
-0.428549200296402,
-0.18121285736560822,
0.26900869607925415,
-0.21780215203762054,
0.04259585961699486,
-0.6037817597389221,
0.6747010350227356,
0.29537060856819153,
-0.39997389912605286,
0.6037103533744812,
-0.024313097819685936,
0.5373252034187317,
-0.5076203942298889,
-0.14388993382453918,
-0.13350680470466614,
0.5777074098587036,
-0.21006342768669128,
-0.6737785935401917,
0.32016894221305847,
-0.383101224899292,
-0.38985633850097656,
-0.21737155318260193,
0.7208923697471619,
-0.21100392937660217,
-0.7708121538162231,
0.10994123667478561,
0.3579767346382141,
-0.14175382256507874,
-0.041402239352464676,
-0.4629247188568115,
0.3002239465713501,
-0.21593615412712097,
-0.0707562267780304,
0.38663503527641296,
0.3818342089653015,
0.13873881101608276,
0.4632691442966461,
0.42265716195106506,
-0.4439099431037903,
0.5472117066383362,
-0.35550418496131897,
0.9910776019096375,
-0.6915157437324524,
-0.26856672763824463,
-0.6876062750816345,
0.3105628192424774,
0.46344080567359924,
0.09180370718240738,
0.8269594311714172,
0.5164702534675598,
0.5235292315483093,
-0.27971869707107544,
0.573707640171051,
-0.002376631135120988,
0.16700394451618195,
-0.26659706234931946,
0.6716914176940918,
-0.4740084111690521,
-0.32474419474601746,
-0.029009254649281502,
-0.8931217789649963,
-0.023775627836585045,
0.4183395504951477,
0.030079934746026993,
-0.24718472361564636,
0.5972299575805664,
0.5303127765655518,
-0.06178054213523865,
0.20903849601745605,
0.3492675721645355,
0.3358367383480072,
0.4565471410751343,
1.2237662076950073,
0.7493038773536682,
-0.8676280379295349,
0.6851215362548828,
-0.36924630403518677,
-0.17666296660900116,
-0.08943658322095871,
-0.6015339493751526,
-0.5587426424026489,
-0.6673832535743713,
-0.3746854066848755,
-0.5315665006637573,
0.09678911417722702,
0.43762800097465515,
0.4096817076206207,
-0.8512516617774963,
-0.21142695844173431,
-0.3555411696434021,
0.27761855721473694,
-0.15622100234031677,
-0.24480801820755005,
0.42837369441986084,
-0.5028083920478821,
-0.5131920576095581,
0.30547699332237244,
0.2873380482196808,
-0.17832499742507935,
-0.5817402005195618,
0.06286302208900452,
0.23915039002895355,
0.151078000664711,
0.8631176352500916,
0.42019587755203247,
-0.38746845722198486,
-0.03648065775632858,
0.08982191979885101,
-0.17719222605228424,
0.07325748354196548,
0.5442299246788025,
-1.100272297859192,
0.461162269115448,
0.3103162944316864,
1.0137790441513062,
0.30026382207870483,
-0.5109081268310547,
0.6102454662322998,
-0.2869892716407776,
-0.30331161618232727,
0.38996797800064087,
0.3264942467212677,
0.2604283392429352,
-0.3413086235523224,
0.12422861158847809,
0.01668914034962654,
-0.7460229992866516,
-0.5580573081970215,
0.14546535909175873,
-0.9308844208717346,
-0.2589888870716095,
0.5554271936416626,
0.10427755117416382,
-0.6935470700263977,
0.24372713267803192,
0.1557191163301468,
0.3378518223762512,
0.03333660960197449,
0.6199783086776733,
0.2418777495622635,
0.12736915051937103,
-0.31576913595199585,
-0.41118431091308594,
0.1056007444858551,
0.6782971620559692,
-0.47405216097831726,
-0.18955542147159576,
0.269416868686676,
-0.0329134501516819,
0.8644137978553772,
0.2873879373073578,
-0.08751863986253738,
0.4359550178050995,
0.11263779550790787,
0.2872374951839447,
0.22225435078144073,
-0.08292928338050842,
-0.7018371224403381,
0.42770814895629883,
0.14533822238445282,
-0.20495596528053284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16705v1
|
SelectIT: Selective Instruction Tuning for Large Language Models via Uncertainty-Aware Self-Reflection
| 2024-02-26T16:21:53 | 2024-02-26T16:21:53 |
Liangxin Liu, Xuebo Liu, Derek F. Wong, Dongfang Li, Ziyi Wang, Baotian Hu, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Instruction tuning (IT) is crucial to tailoring large language models (LLMs)
towards human-centric interactions. Recent advancements have shown that the
careful selection of a small, high-quality subset of IT data can significantly
enhance the performance of LLMs. Despite this, common approaches often rely on
additional models or data sets, which increases costs and limits widespread
adoption. In this work, we propose a novel approach, termed SelectIT, that
capitalizes on the foundational capabilities of the LLM itself. Specifically,
we exploit the intrinsic uncertainty present in LLMs to more effectively select
high-quality IT data, without the need for extra resources. Furthermore, we
introduce a novel IT dataset, the Selective Alpaca, created by applying
SelectIT to the Alpaca-GPT4 dataset. Empirical results demonstrate that IT
using Selective Alpaca leads to substantial model ability enhancement. The
robustness of SelectIT has also been corroborated in various foundation models
and domain-specific tasks. Our findings suggest that longer and more
computationally intensive IT data may serve as superior sources of IT, offering
valuable insights for future research in this area. Data, code, and scripts are
freely available at https://github.com/Blue-Raincoat/SelectIT.
|
[
-0.2838131785392761,
-0.7157343029975891,
0.46245434880256653,
0.2521863281726837,
-0.23238469660282135,
0.2666367292404175,
-0.49642235040664673,
-0.39090946316719055,
0.14636747539043427,
0.6040840148925781,
-0.5679060816764832,
-0.5473768711090088,
-0.5972249507904053,
-0.2340170443058014,
-0.43697723746299744,
0.6365960836410522,
-0.09342179447412491,
-0.1525605171918869,
0.27564746141433716,
-0.06459899246692657,
-0.4274386763572693,
-0.17539328336715698,
-0.6926957368850708,
0.029728811234235764,
0.11664922535419464,
0.6923825144767761,
0.6644459962844849,
0.9692250490188599,
0.5301050543785095,
0.26637423038482666,
0.24103134870529175,
0.18345268070697784,
-0.4014776349067688,
0.11236121505498886,
-0.26339325308799744,
-0.3272744119167328,
-0.34949955344200134,
0.07809694111347198,
0.8914726972579956,
0.4675508737564087,
-0.25913646817207336,
0.2595081031322479,
0.10362353175878525,
0.6021500825881958,
-0.7738192677497864,
0.136618971824646,
-0.9011549353599548,
-0.17856869101524353,
-0.3406713604927063,
0.04035751149058342,
-0.3596560060977936,
-0.26668471097946167,
0.14691004157066345,
-0.6721118092536926,
0.3297829031944275,
0.1902322769165039,
0.7298434376716614,
0.641072690486908,
-0.25268590450286865,
-0.09688068926334381,
-0.7686882615089417,
0.8493797779083252,
-0.5890455842018127,
0.5310529470443726,
0.7287424802780151,
0.3581356704235077,
-0.053421784192323685,
-0.3319568336009979,
-0.22298265993595123,
-0.21846695244312286,
0.2847054600715637,
0.07589224725961685,
0.12525272369384766,
0.04679853841662407,
-0.06989745050668716,
0.5019403696060181,
-0.2873598337173462,
0.2708218991756439,
-0.4099028706550598,
-0.2843576669692993,
0.43341711163520813,
-0.06555506587028503,
0.14205877482891083,
0.2617340683937073,
-0.09686747193336487,
-0.36017975211143494,
-0.6460334658622742,
-0.10386603325605392,
0.40629008412361145,
0.4238446354866028,
0.012707876041531563,
0.5148251056671143,
-0.3790772259235382,
0.7724342942237854,
0.07006719708442688,
0.024333277717232704,
-0.04393180459737778,
-0.16337716579437256,
-0.18198032677173615,
-0.05705094709992409,
0.7595236301422119,
0.07714300602674484,
0.06595710664987564,
-0.1493389755487442,
-0.10788129270076752,
-0.017350036650896072,
0.2721206843852997,
-0.8040012717247009,
-0.28717246651649475,
0.22226344048976898,
0.04566793888807297,
-0.10359282046556473,
-0.10646100342273712,
-0.8379202485084534,
-0.17190268635749817,
-0.2609383761882782,
0.26922622323036194,
-0.6009217500686646,
-0.36633700132369995,
0.16007103025913239,
0.20637474954128265,
0.31848081946372986,
0.24107755720615387,
-1.2269902229309082,
0.2038084864616394,
0.5371949672698975,
0.5919054746627808,
-0.6222074627876282,
-0.39046913385391235,
-0.5500512719154358,
0.3812033236026764,
-0.5392733216285706,
0.764998733997345,
-1.0496762990951538,
-0.3564050495624542,
-0.2541819214820862,
-0.3181164860725403,
-0.28744423389434814,
-0.558899998664856,
0.5818871259689331,
-0.6008632183074951,
0.09584315866231918,
-0.24756711721420288,
-0.4802502989768982,
-0.01197061501443386,
0.17418286204338074,
-0.9384360909461975,
1.2225924730300903,
0.486274778842926,
-0.4920347034931183,
0.5344887375831604,
-0.5463367104530334,
-0.43952950835227966,
-0.12297794222831726,
-0.3768523037433624,
-0.48865005373954773,
0.08337999135255814,
0.3713470697402954,
0.25969281792640686,
-0.44487619400024414,
0.14440228044986725,
-0.26579850912094116,
-0.27765557169914246,
0.052930548787117004,
-0.5351279973983765,
0.4512347877025604,
0.23698922991752625,
-0.49782276153564453,
0.045272111892700195,
-0.921261727809906,
0.4006829857826233,
0.09302017837762833,
-0.49717187881469727,
-0.16788250207901,
0.006485354155302048,
-0.2636208236217499,
-0.03637891262769699,
0.34514549374580383,
-0.43170884251594543,
0.2796478271484375,
-0.1794254183769226,
0.46479079127311707,
0.8932933807373047,
-0.2899523377418518,
0.708198606967926,
-0.18569700419902802,
0.6093273162841797,
-0.28051134943962097,
0.4176570773124695,
0.18296074867248535,
-0.3032052516937256,
-0.8639618754386902,
-0.5695616006851196,
0.3700871467590332,
0.5414559245109558,
-0.6286303997039795,
0.25911712646484375,
-0.22333168983459473,
-0.2181759774684906,
-0.9128807783126831,
0.3955851197242737,
0.23377758264541626,
0.4286259412765503,
0.38625234365463257,
0.05664549395442009,
-0.3098331391811371,
-0.8900361657142639,
-0.021632300689816475,
-0.12907101213932037,
0.07960861921310425,
0.3109499216079712,
0.07693213224411011,
-0.1971909999847412,
0.9601805210113525,
-0.36094728112220764,
-0.3215501606464386,
-0.164674773812294,
-0.17465907335281372,
0.18381108343601227,
0.5507099628448486,
0.5471024513244629,
-0.5314271450042725,
-0.5400264263153076,
-0.019443275406956673,
-0.33322468400001526,
-0.11936876177787781,
-0.11539094150066376,
-0.5792130827903748,
-0.042863987386226654,
0.17027553915977478,
-0.40424755215644836,
0.18847906589508057,
0.7715733051300049,
-0.20574335753917694,
0.3118845224380493,
-0.12033899128437042,
0.3440978229045868,
-0.9765276312828064,
-0.1652068942785263,
-0.13991005718708038,
-0.1589789092540741,
-0.21242211759090424,
0.2964031398296356,
0.4248058795928955,
0.24935729801654816,
-0.3603277802467346,
0.6348504424095154,
-0.5580117702484131,
0.02291461080312729,
-0.19002293050289154,
-0.11024016886949539,
-0.08968638628721237,
0.2969312071800232,
0.14557626843452454,
1.2808289527893066,
0.5723047852516174,
-0.630379319190979,
-0.06921914219856262,
0.18658028542995453,
-0.39551880955696106,
0.20044942200183868,
-0.43906429409980774,
0.2655077278614044,
0.30077579617500305,
-0.2985841631889343,
-0.5413626432418823,
-0.5184499621391296,
0.17203249037265778,
-0.061225391924381256,
0.5985785126686096,
-0.11972636729478836,
-0.347013384103775,
-0.20026232302188873,
-0.2695683240890503,
0.38804343342781067,
0.3863700330257416,
-0.6637258529663086,
0.8670229911804199,
0.3876132369041443,
-0.15336918830871582,
-0.6872230172157288,
-0.4905049204826355,
0.08531492203474045,
-0.155520960688591,
-0.3936505913734436,
0.33382460474967957,
-0.4927166998386383,
-0.12553814053535461,
-0.2490137219429016,
-0.30439436435699463,
-0.1751646250486374,
0.3512094020843506,
0.10456070303916931,
0.22112144529819489,
-0.1734943985939026,
-0.030759239569306374,
0.509627640247345,
-0.16867315769195557,
-0.15773959457874298,
-0.31408408284187317,
0.43298301100730896,
-0.2868689000606537,
-0.566634476184845,
-0.32028043270111084,
0.46345531940460205,
0.431797593832016,
-0.39117231965065,
0.5655964016914368,
0.5304421186447144,
-0.0742744654417038,
-0.6548136472702026,
-0.7737296223640442,
-0.2781635820865631,
-0.5740130543708801,
0.3594277501106262,
-0.2780778408050537,
-1.0832645893096924,
0.4142043888568878,
0.060036551207304,
0.1572134643793106,
0.25960537791252136,
0.41738569736480713,
0.10843237489461899,
0.9144963622093201,
0.7663089632987976,
-0.3874351382255554,
0.8669559955596924,
-0.26438793540000916,
-0.06561551243066788,
-0.8069525361061096,
0.17933392524719238,
-0.43352237343788147,
-0.08189413696527481,
-0.3098171055316925,
-0.48226386308670044,
0.2594330310821533,
-0.07531865686178207,
-0.3361472189426422,
0.065465547144413,
-0.6701949238777161,
0.7516726851463318,
0.9240454435348511,
0.23063667118549347,
0.24901574850082397,
0.1287716180086136,
0.03153963014483452,
-0.04126185178756714,
-0.49320825934410095,
-0.5146887302398682,
1.2275519371032715,
0.08032098412513733,
0.9088910818099976,
0.04432300850749016,
0.5905989408493042,
0.20803573727607727,
0.3212001323699951,
-0.5721006989479065,
0.4484529197216034,
-0.20914718508720398,
-0.7110437750816345,
-0.4320445954799652,
-0.40811654925346375,
-0.8342890739440918,
0.0790531188249588,
-0.13125376403331757,
-0.7689487934112549,
-0.06373625993728638,
0.3886283040046692,
-0.5695641040802002,
0.262963205575943,
-0.936339259147644,
0.5893867611885071,
-0.4109707474708557,
-0.5162826180458069,
-0.20865923166275024,
-0.39353394508361816,
0.11112898588180542,
-0.2061053365468979,
0.005680593196302652,
-0.2732457220554352,
-0.08950957655906677,
0.556372880935669,
-0.2030816674232483,
0.8791192173957825,
0.12616251409053802,
-0.19185404479503632,
0.4188464879989624,
0.3639516830444336,
0.6081963181495667,
0.12935477495193481,
-0.43762335181236267,
0.1563926637172699,
-0.09419754892587662,
-0.5280125141143799,
-0.47654989361763,
0.8020915985107422,
-0.9405317306518555,
-0.8632570505142212,
-0.16551095247268677,
-0.6112367510795593,
-0.4328858554363251,
0.32332444190979004,
0.2086464762687683,
0.1773868352174759,
0.03418141230940819,
0.12079578638076782,
0.7584829926490784,
0.051821932196617126,
0.45291590690612793,
0.6620081067085266,
0.09158867597579956,
-0.4801017940044403,
1.124016523361206,
0.255560040473938,
0.4143331050872803,
0.4206773042678833,
0.2704830765724182,
-0.07846299558877945,
-0.9336130023002625,
-0.6504560708999634,
0.18762393295764923,
-0.6760278940200806,
-0.16607564687728882,
-0.42894506454467773,
-0.1382068544626236,
-0.21489600837230682,
-0.15907588601112366,
-0.7044950723648071,
-0.5150483846664429,
-0.5140944123268127,
-0.295295774936676,
0.47694092988967896,
0.45287054777145386,
0.22622673213481903,
0.6359513998031616,
-0.7399740815162659,
0.14244072139263153,
0.47758764028549194,
0.7115742564201355,
-0.44138315320014954,
-0.4090805649757385,
-0.25622478127479553,
0.10486738383769989,
-0.06474191695451736,
-0.7391049861907959,
0.2968440055847168,
0.5772773027420044,
0.7869485020637512,
0.4094817340373993,
0.16978412866592407,
0.5144920945167542,
-0.3821675479412079,
0.5545606017112732,
-0.47641322016716003,
-0.889704704284668,
0.7615140676498413,
-0.494339257478714,
0.20370396971702576,
0.9978814125061035,
0.08187251538038254,
0.18418662250041962,
-0.5559521317481995,
-0.36228305101394653,
-0.8794538974761963,
0.8314408659934998,
0.10427623987197876,
0.10916436463594437,
-0.022919610142707825,
0.5993906855583191,
0.4159178137779236,
0.26973557472229004,
-0.5250688791275024,
-0.04627300053834915,
-0.08665574342012405,
-0.577431321144104,
0.23368586599826813,
-0.20514586567878723,
-0.1811041533946991,
-0.08147861063480377,
0.8964653611183167,
-0.47976425290107727,
0.173003688454628,
-0.1482163369655609,
-0.15136756002902985,
-0.22163641452789307,
0.25031059980392456,
0.30878350138664246,
0.7269449830055237,
-0.1867818832397461,
-0.0861113965511322,
0.16282691061496735,
-0.761305570602417,
0.010621351189911366,
0.07945286482572556,
-0.279403418302536,
-0.47601038217544556,
0.2297835350036621,
0.7877203226089478,
0.11531081795692444,
-0.7100203633308411,
0.30697745084762573,
-0.25508466362953186,
0.16463345289230347,
-0.2538820505142212,
0.5671299695968628,
-0.27760744094848633,
0.36620110273361206,
0.3162221610546112,
0.0037443118635565042,
0.1672065705060959,
-0.16842064261436462,
0.00779217341914773,
0.44580167531967163,
-0.19330716133117676,
-0.3076314330101013,
0.7256742715835571,
0.1916787177324295,
-0.1601029336452484,
0.7487592697143555,
-0.17589187622070312,
-0.14629203081130981,
0.6536577343940735,
0.5675308108329773,
0.8422695994377136,
-0.46853670477867126,
0.27864450216293335,
0.2685299515724182,
0.5302496552467346,
-0.19507996737957,
0.3432202637195587,
-0.1622907668352127,
-0.85495924949646,
-0.5737695693969727,
-0.5689737796783447,
-0.6035932302474976,
0.22534309327602386,
-0.6580949425697327,
0.1459890604019165,
-0.7305911183357239,
-0.1950637847185135,
-0.5751482844352722,
-0.15926764905452728,
-0.7649542689323425,
0.15452134609222412,
0.028666766360402107,
0.7883118987083435,
-0.7273687124252319,
0.9798721671104431,
0.5360410213470459,
-0.15645235776901245,
-0.9341050982475281,
-0.02843933179974556,
-0.20588092505931854,
-0.9776691198348999,
0.14255017042160034,
0.06159254163503647,
-0.19646339118480682,
0.06647489964962006,
-0.558821976184845,
-1.3682504892349243,
1.0003832578659058,
0.8432714343070984,
-0.6633898019790649,
-0.06666366755962372,
0.1124933660030365,
0.2216244637966156,
-0.2255529761314392,
0.370233952999115,
1.0038375854492188,
0.39758262038230896,
0.11167821288108826,
-0.7106918692588806,
0.019406231120228767,
-0.14233587682247162,
-0.12273448705673218,
0.24293534457683563,
-1.0780866146087646,
0.5972937345504761,
-0.15748101472854614,
-0.05355997756123543,
-0.20377835631370544,
0.7271618843078613,
0.25910282135009766,
-0.1407819390296936,
0.4404933750629425,
0.37206408381462097,
0.9013004899024963,
-0.03509441763162613,
1.0267831087112427,
-0.5910205245018005,
0.12191861867904663,
1.280704379081726,
-0.32436180114746094,
0.9145395159721375,
0.32502609491348267,
-0.14604957401752472,
0.12681588530540466,
0.8969034552574158,
0.20955440402030945,
0.5371962785720825,
-0.32960236072540283,
-0.27932456135749817,
-0.6334967613220215,
0.1731693297624588,
-0.22485308349132538,
0.6260854005813599,
0.6552586555480957,
-0.2547135651111603,
-0.01594553329050541,
-0.04151448979973793,
-0.025977039709687233,
-0.06958365440368652,
-0.269027978181839,
0.7173193693161011,
-0.1394636183977127,
-0.7301153540611267,
0.5638988018035889,
-0.2287435084581375,
0.5014230608940125,
-0.7711682915687561,
-0.06410343945026398,
-0.17195942997932434,
0.11810478568077087,
0.12131042033433914,
-0.5479402542114258,
0.05584503710269928,
-0.2539677023887634,
-0.18991604447364807,
-0.18978871405124664,
0.4927902817726135,
-0.4376564919948578,
-0.6808677315711975,
0.32303449511528015,
0.34701648354530334,
-0.2714173495769501,
-0.12820935249328613,
-0.6418353319168091,
0.3167496621608734,
0.15330888330936432,
-0.4978020191192627,
0.3946819305419922,
0.3439057469367981,
-0.24144014716148376,
0.9630659222602844,
0.42148736119270325,
0.14983350038528442,
0.19204124808311462,
0.05863827466964722,
1.0499913692474365,
-0.4512987434864044,
-0.5007197260856628,
-0.7041053771972656,
0.2654578685760498,
-0.08168245851993561,
-0.3865829408168793,
0.5989065766334534,
0.42516469955444336,
0.846892237663269,
0.09739592671394348,
0.9420711398124695,
0.2362404614686966,
0.5510186553001404,
-0.6630215644836426,
0.6009467244148254,
-0.15543873608112335,
0.4197775721549988,
-0.0730702131986618,
-0.9979320764541626,
-0.11823629587888718,
0.7085670232772827,
-0.4612899720668793,
0.20339620113372803,
0.5521809458732605,
0.8514503836631775,
-0.2377677857875824,
0.13669461011886597,
0.20548687875270844,
0.12746621668338776,
0.39683645963668823,
0.24879471957683563,
0.6502002477645874,
-0.1568862944841385,
0.5326271057128906,
-0.4072555899620056,
-0.3861984312534332,
-0.044735878705978394,
-0.8095975518226624,
-0.8952807784080505,
-0.5293713212013245,
-0.4210810959339142,
-0.019975194707512856,
0.06286478042602539,
1.0982701778411865,
1.0244351625442505,
-0.9242843985557556,
-0.030891330912709236,
0.008918246254324913,
0.12093424797058105,
-0.3094629943370819,
-0.1908445805311203,
0.43342679738998413,
-0.3456589877605438,
-0.8812240958213806,
0.7115774750709534,
0.12974762916564941,
0.05478961393237114,
-0.0670316219329834,
0.0921836569905281,
0.08144289255142212,
0.21837365627288818,
0.3611578941345215,
0.3056723177433014,
-0.45618563890457153,
-0.48373278975486755,
0.03241082280874252,
0.04480239003896713,
0.11197756975889206,
0.7372038960456848,
-0.6445308327674866,
0.4516754746437073,
0.1182105541229248,
1.072938084602356,
0.5802253484725952,
-0.10671059042215347,
0.5600273609161377,
-0.7842345237731934,
-0.023419953882694244,
0.38196784257888794,
0.4623265266418457,
0.35499507188796997,
-0.6311337351799011,
0.5972437858581543,
-0.16488294303417206,
-0.6386919021606445,
-0.4830579161643982,
0.18515774607658386,
-0.8606399893760681,
-0.16604262590408325,
1.3136677742004395,
0.08080467581748962,
-0.4488210082054138,
0.0671645924448967,
-0.4079490900039673,
-0.0520026832818985,
-0.7509408593177795,
1.0356018543243408,
0.6756855249404907,
-0.01896578259766102,
-0.3303684592247009,
-0.6964365243911743,
0.4512060880661011,
0.5044758915901184,
-0.8401654362678528,
0.02315489761531353,
0.5872414112091064,
0.45849841833114624,
-0.15066100656986237,
0.5784727334976196,
0.12212764471769333,
0.24652153253555298,
-0.17558497190475464,
0.006524801254272461,
-0.17750652134418488,
-0.4611406922340393,
0.012559322640299797,
0.15038761496543884,
0.3918423056602478,
-0.19731277227401733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00821v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00821v1
|
Social Media as a Sensor: Analyzing Twitter Data for Breast Cancer Medication Effects Using Natural Language Processing
| 2024-02-26T16:17:19 | 2024-02-26T16:17:19 |
Seibi Kobara, Alireza Rafiei, Masoud Nateghi, Selen Bozkurt, Rishikesan Kamaleswaran, Abeed Sarker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
Breast cancer is a significant public health concern and is the leading cause
of cancer-related deaths among women. Despite advances in breast cancer
treatments, medication non-adherence remains a major problem. As electronic
health records do not typically capture patient-reported outcomes that may
reveal information about medication-related experiences, social media presents
an attractive resource for enhancing our understanding of the patients'
treatment experiences. In this paper, we developed natural language processing
(NLP) based methodologies to study information posted by an automatically
curated breast cancer cohort from social media. We employed a transformer-based
classifier to identify breast cancer patients/survivors on X (Twitter) based on
their self-reported information, and we collected longitudinal data from their
profiles. We then designed a multi-layer rule-based model to develop a breast
cancer therapy-associated side effect lexicon and detect patterns of medication
usage and associated side effects among breast cancer patients. 1,454,637 posts
were available from 583,962 unique users, of which 62,042 were detected as
breast cancer members using our transformer-based model. 198 cohort members
mentioned breast cancer medications with tamoxifen as the most common. Our side
effect lexicon identified well-known side effects of hormone and chemotherapy.
Furthermore, it discovered a subject feeling towards cancer and medications,
which may suggest a pre-clinical phase of side effects or emotional distress.
This analysis highlighted not only the utility of NLP techniques in
unstructured social media data to identify self-reported breast cancer posts,
medication usage patterns, and treatment side effects but also the richness of
social data on such clinical questions.
|
[
-0.017781050875782967,
-1.0346976518630981,
0.58909672498703,
0.22062452137470245,
-0.24385645985603333,
0.3218291401863098,
0.18015940487384796,
-0.5014704465866089,
0.7260648012161255,
0.8279954791069031,
-0.7298740744590759,
-1.22028386592865,
-0.9951528310775757,
0.1217985600233078,
-0.6533524990081787,
0.9892333745956421,
0.010535039938986301,
0.15028584003448486,
0.11881822347640991,
-0.09773396700620651,
-0.29911768436431885,
-0.12357025593519211,
-0.95698481798172,
-0.22620680928230286,
0.8821954131126404,
0.08013492077589035,
0.36356255412101746,
0.280720978975296,
0.6850075125694275,
0.22113659977912903,
0.19889965653419495,
0.1945895403623581,
-0.3306879997253418,
-0.05964937433600426,
-0.18033941090106964,
-0.20930753648281097,
-0.1746930032968521,
-0.11099835485219955,
0.2726246118545532,
0.5561285018920898,
0.028403688222169876,
0.3500804901123047,
0.08103232085704803,
0.6554731130599976,
-0.4277415871620178,
-0.021306024864315987,
-0.2614133954048157,
0.2177209109067917,
-0.07553757727146149,
-0.40485790371894836,
0.00500089256092906,
-0.6321439743041992,
0.008239014074206352,
-0.5142394304275513,
0.2889261841773987,
-0.19305174052715302,
0.7208827137947083,
0.26756027340888977,
-0.5368101000785828,
-0.5602506399154663,
-0.6354041695594788,
0.47934678196907043,
-0.5914176106452942,
0.13167044520378113,
0.6002861857414246,
0.5352779030799866,
-0.3563609719276428,
-0.7294455766677856,
-0.27468937635421753,
0.252396821975708,
-0.3341989815235138,
-0.0383932963013649,
-0.5140368938446045,
0.039444200694561005,
-0.012544097378849983,
0.2999075949192047,
-0.7063736319541931,
-0.01576889120042324,
-0.41453272104263306,
-0.36654970049858093,
0.5324174761772156,
0.14850302040576935,
0.7255218625068665,
-0.5030547380447388,
-0.04653025045990944,
0.49654439091682434,
-0.4259920120239258,
0.15539772808551788,
-0.08619923144578934,
0.47535496950149536,
-0.369325190782547,
0.8402161598205566,
-0.20080728828907013,
0.7218623757362366,
-0.22726474702358246,
0.3658190369606018,
-0.16562417149543762,
-0.37132155895233154,
-0.27417510747909546,
0.1530938595533371,
1.2745872735977173,
0.597473680973053,
-0.1443091481924057,
-0.04782060161232948,
0.47460025548934937,
0.24025602638721466,
0.355148583650589,
-0.7971749901771545,
-0.3709665834903717,
0.3469056487083435,
-0.707463264465332,
-0.195105642080307,
-0.1856687217950821,
-0.8257269263267517,
-0.6585466265678406,
-0.07562210410833359,
0.6257266998291016,
-0.4284222722053528,
-0.19261300563812256,
0.44379130005836487,
-0.21925118565559387,
-0.1891094148159027,
-0.0009288720320910215,
-0.6586748361587524,
0.603192925453186,
0.7723413109779358,
1.2871564626693726,
0.12688671052455902,
0.16995610296726227,
-0.3907386064529419,
0.14487557113170624,
-0.05468448996543884,
1.0611995458602905,
-0.31008508801460266,
-0.4310002028942108,
0.14205582439899445,
0.15336771309375763,
-0.35590335726737976,
-0.4055003821849823,
0.5716213583946228,
-0.2345590740442276,
0.278955340385437,
-0.6646038889884949,
-0.8240591883659363,
0.043476298451423645,
0.09243184328079224,
-0.7286333441734314,
0.5494731664657593,
0.10499846935272217,
-0.7409147620201111,
0.4001029431819916,
-0.7319126725196838,
-0.5949776768684387,
0.15222276747226715,
0.010273384861648083,
-0.27879804372787476,
0.19166050851345062,
0.30197450518608093,
0.8254421949386597,
-0.0349823422729969,
0.295941025018692,
-0.2601768672466278,
-0.4615417420864105,
0.2689686417579651,
0.109308622777462,
0.8022518754005432,
0.18356165289878845,
0.10074210166931152,
0.042162179946899414,
-0.7405278086662292,
-0.30131739377975464,
0.14615966379642487,
-0.07731585204601288,
-0.6283659934997559,
0.029184533283114433,
0.020617201924324036,
0.0977926179766655,
-0.06921936571598053,
-0.7745461463928223,
0.002855211729183793,
-0.44661322236061096,
0.5309082865715027,
0.40336674451828003,
0.6182959675788879,
0.06717604398727417,
-0.3713633120059967,
0.2181527018547058,
-0.24915683269500732,
0.4631115198135376,
0.27512407302856445,
-0.8162279725074768,
-0.1304769665002823,
-0.18201351165771484,
0.005192617420107126,
0.16463252902030945,
-0.6575129628181458,
0.2786054015159607,
-0.06743329763412476,
-0.35148411989212036,
-0.7631787657737732,
0.17001326382160187,
0.13586550951004028,
0.6759545207023621,
0.6254353523254395,
-0.009286955930292606,
-0.7561086416244507,
-0.7218141555786133,
-0.5354478359222412,
-0.053664498031139374,
0.09090793132781982,
-0.059930797666311264,
0.2565470039844513,
-0.5486086010932922,
0.8161584138870239,
-0.7941955924034119,
-0.31994426250457764,
-0.13976788520812988,
0.37840771675109863,
0.07311003655195236,
0.029995331540703773,
0.3522581458091736,
-0.4769193232059479,
-0.4312729835510254,
-0.05963531509041786,
-0.6397855281829834,
-0.527952253818512,
0.03730889409780502,
-0.4287070333957672,
-0.23968780040740967,
0.1525307297706604,
-0.43406474590301514,
0.40677985548973083,
0.5881084203720093,
-0.3007145822048187,
-0.10838665813207626,
0.1313718855381012,
0.1587916761636734,
-1.2935220003128052,
-0.07915257662534714,
0.5604386329650879,
-0.03461306542158127,
-0.6679638028144836,
-0.6830286979675293,
-0.33010488748550415,
0.016275683417916298,
-0.23910042643547058,
0.5157732367515564,
0.04617982730269432,
0.1900406926870346,
-0.19359630346298218,
-0.37175852060317993,
0.3171428143978119,
-0.10676226764917374,
0.17668510973453522,
-0.011975410394370556,
0.020267317071557045,
-0.4742017388343811,
0.18857741355895996,
0.09947053343057632,
-0.3202345371246338,
0.4844443202018738,
-0.4722695052623749,
-0.24851879477500916,
-0.08410152792930603,
0.12105745822191238,
-1.1719528436660767,
-0.2889735996723175,
0.7166392803192139,
-0.6203572154045105,
-0.100031279027462,
-0.21348786354064941,
-0.3645694851875305,
-0.46263206005096436,
-0.15795356035232544,
-0.1917184442281723,
0.04022059962153435,
-0.1064240112900734,
0.5703712105751038,
0.5234951972961426,
-0.30114221572875977,
-0.11843979358673096,
-0.7559930086135864,
0.24808292090892792,
-0.17075389623641968,
-0.39381664991378784,
0.2572631537914276,
0.17523840069770813,
-0.13251225650310516,
0.3378329277038574,
0.17132678627967834,
-0.1336294710636139,
-0.1581796556711197,
0.27239617705345154,
0.09671980142593384,
0.11953224986791611,
0.4190390706062317,
0.494983434677124,
-0.14234459400177002,
0.3396340310573578,
0.2253527045249939,
0.5775033831596375,
0.18033450841903687,
-0.2157767117023468,
-0.5068501234054565,
0.7084682583808899,
0.2078707218170166,
0.09704332798719406,
0.8002817034721375,
0.7957597970962524,
-0.6920046806335449,
-0.04611501097679138,
-0.4330112338066101,
-0.20442184805870056,
-0.3667580783367157,
-0.14229445159435272,
0.18435077369213104,
-0.9611663222312927,
0.4784901738166809,
0.09180748462677002,
-0.06443297863006592,
0.4333004951477051,
0.6299980282783508,
-0.18986967206001282,
0.9523593783378601,
0.33262330293655396,
-0.2050704061985016,
0.38836669921875,
-0.23611168563365936,
0.28665485978126526,
-0.17349156737327576,
-0.09969991445541382,
-0.12087766081094742,
-0.3628958463668823,
-0.647014319896698,
-0.2956990599632263,
0.4302934408187866,
-0.6209225058555603,
-0.18310067057609558,
0.40193605422973633,
-0.6940889358520508,
-0.0281328484416008,
0.32865697145462036,
0.5714860558509827,
0.4007228910923004,
0.06333800405263901,
0.46800580620765686,
-0.09201404452323914,
-0.5449933409690857,
-0.28560563921928406,
0.9681966304779053,
0.2768634557723999,
0.4927487373352051,
-0.010719546116888523,
0.8495128154754639,
0.41789236664772034,
0.3493809998035431,
-0.6674373149871826,
0.44716793298721313,
-0.35076838731765747,
-0.5456414818763733,
-0.017306586727499962,
-0.6638555526733398,
-0.9597796201705933,
-0.21740420162677765,
-0.4169335663318634,
-0.5812817811965942,
0.11104972660541534,
-0.21621285378932953,
-0.8557789325714111,
0.11761154979467392,
-1.021773338317871,
0.9442378282546997,
-0.4390651285648346,
-0.28710296750068665,
0.13727547228336334,
-0.8741838932037354,
0.16055963933467865,
-0.15650734305381775,
0.305995374917984,
-0.3548015356063843,
0.2382313311100006,
0.740622878074646,
-0.5951213240623474,
0.8704882264137268,
-0.13953693211078644,
0.2396654486656189,
0.35085782408714294,
-0.11401998996734619,
-0.14146679639816284,
-0.08602068573236465,
0.13826510310173035,
0.21519675850868225,
0.48514822125434875,
-0.3748224377632141,
-0.5996687412261963,
0.7425492405891418,
-0.68731290102005,
0.061373308300971985,
-0.27788516879081726,
-0.3591548800468445,
-0.18976199626922607,
0.09902658313512802,
0.5104114413261414,
0.07745339721441269,
-0.3131835460662842,
-0.20576545596122742,
0.14622533321380615,
-0.3974337875843048,
0.2502775490283966,
0.6444440484046936,
-0.3809882700443268,
-0.034953948110342026,
0.6895194053649902,
0.5529378652572632,
-0.16396698355674744,
0.6468791365623474,
0.7636241316795349,
-0.19261981546878815,
-0.2575794756412506,
-0.09897740185260773,
0.36109474301338196,
-0.29993924498558044,
-0.08799150586128235,
-0.9273588061332703,
-0.27025750279426575,
-0.6016277074813843,
-0.0004588872252497822,
-0.2792470157146454,
-0.10621366649866104,
-0.41041332483291626,
-0.36165332794189453,
0.8798444867134094,
0.8796284794807434,
-0.0692925825715065,
0.5047239661216736,
-1.0817182064056396,
0.46657267212867737,
0.13196079432964325,
0.5299156904220581,
-0.15470752120018005,
0.11648432165384293,
-0.3384764790534973,
0.07444547116756439,
0.060632526874542236,
-0.9944387078285217,
0.5446007251739502,
0.21783049404621124,
0.208017498254776,
0.4449843168258667,
0.17182716727256775,
0.46502983570098877,
-0.11628393828868866,
0.3587549328804016,
0.16998018324375153,
-0.5702927708625793,
0.6344074010848999,
-0.6540459990501404,
0.34878912568092346,
0.6500208377838135,
0.7494590878486633,
-1.0874799489974976,
-0.19023071229457855,
-0.2451559156179428,
-0.6745458841323853,
0.44551190733909607,
0.33408042788505554,
0.16888491809368134,
-0.30984532833099365,
0.38723698258399963,
0.16632579267024994,
0.22078147530555725,
-0.3663770258426666,
-0.025444116443395615,
-0.30835968255996704,
-0.4800187647342682,
0.05957844853401184,
-0.2452358454465866,
-0.11057335883378983,
-0.27199360728263855,
0.4142559766769409,
0.16494876146316528,
0.381054162979126,
0.00035542063415050507,
0.06992507725954056,
-0.23121334612369537,
0.21818488836288452,
0.028208864852786064,
0.18953093886375427,
-0.6402618288993835,
0.2948403060436249,
-0.19728228449821472,
-0.621411144733429,
-0.36312752962112427,
0.4733930230140686,
-0.036231182515621185,
0.06983484327793121,
0.5749295353889465,
0.2960849106311798,
0.15805090963840485,
-0.4601946175098419,
0.2863699495792389,
-0.30817463994026184,
0.08620396256446838,
-0.09499016404151917,
-0.1746598780155182,
0.29889214038848877,
0.05612805113196373,
0.26238852739334106,
-0.22370555996894836,
0.5808448195457458,
-0.5806968808174133,
0.2013026624917984,
0.2222113311290741,
-0.8309010863304138,
-0.4333980977535248,
0.12633013725280762,
-0.009533625096082687,
-0.3010987341403961,
0.08718365430831909,
0.27970561385154724,
-0.1426045000553131,
0.3317519426345825,
0.19451871514320374,
0.5397610664367676,
-0.5355677604675293,
0.5558249950408936,
0.3324018120765686,
0.08350516855716705,
0.034902676939964294,
0.3024500906467438,
0.18288499116897583,
-0.7793782353401184,
-0.25368040800094604,
-0.6011368036270142,
-0.3114171326160431,
-0.10517299920320511,
-0.5925919413566589,
0.20430295169353485,
-0.6224982738494873,
-0.6764134764671326,
0.372537225484848,
0.09192655235528946,
-0.34305962920188904,
0.36389636993408203,
-0.1046484187245369,
0.24319946765899658,
-1.336011290550232,
0.3330315947532654,
0.6658897995948792,
-0.34016573429107666,
-0.6609275341033936,
-0.2591770887374878,
0.5008214712142944,
-0.7034156322479248,
0.016438128426671028,
0.3462063670158386,
-0.12030334025621414,
-0.20846246182918549,
-0.4554901421070099,
-0.5534487366676331,
0.8925380110740662,
0.07488539814949036,
-0.3663293719291687,
0.10702385753393173,
0.6511717438697815,
1.0093212127685547,
-0.29351961612701416,
0.15949998795986176,
0.5641855597496033,
0.16137221455574036,
0.35673657059669495,
-0.28844380378723145,
0.035649627447128296,
-0.48328545689582825,
-0.2244933396577835,
0.35103467106819153,
-0.3601158559322357,
0.5611646771430969,
0.0814410001039505,
-0.39358052611351013,
-0.07600666582584381,
-0.12702499330043793,
-0.0011126287281513214,
0.7668253183364868,
0.04588112607598305,
0.6418471932411194,
0.5743139982223511,
-0.015609798952937126,
1.0367063283920288,
-0.0540660060942173,
0.269883930683136,
0.7509863376617432,
-0.2443006932735443,
0.8098703622817993,
0.3836413025856018,
-0.1775772124528885,
0.6418651342391968,
0.7562348246574402,
0.11511001735925674,
0.4445640742778778,
-0.09561414271593094,
-0.46065717935562134,
-0.10035348683595657,
-0.5609984993934631,
-0.1970597356557846,
0.04996313154697418,
0.5944241881370544,
-0.6618521213531494,
-0.42799586057662964,
0.335065633058548,
0.2679476737976074,
0.11366454511880875,
-0.2034149020910263,
0.8412099480628967,
0.405307412147522,
-0.10279110074043274,
0.059356290847063065,
-0.10059282928705215,
0.27113473415374756,
-0.5372269749641418,
-0.04573753848671913,
0.13053558766841888,
0.1622905731201172,
-0.6749688386917114,
-0.8290590047836304,
0.9501400589942932,
0.05257253721356392,
-0.16534146666526794,
-0.1408318728208542,
1.0544275045394897,
-0.25043532252311707,
-1.0137382745742798,
0.6662708520889282,
0.6332240104675293,
-0.05289428308606148,
-0.34288981556892395,
-0.8121346831321716,
0.07901884615421295,
-0.31722357869148254,
-0.21401450037956238,
0.18882790207862854,
0.2874510884284973,
-0.0971897765994072,
0.39063891768455505,
0.6396852731704712,
0.3211279809474945,
-0.1665896475315094,
0.36598682403564453,
0.749659538269043,
-0.5214360356330872,
0.03184996545314789,
-1.1220003366470337,
0.26789912581443787,
-0.14469939470291138,
-0.19212259352207184,
0.9090420603752136,
0.45407795906066895,
0.20665228366851807,
0.36688539385795593,
0.7063829898834229,
0.21712055802345276,
1.1481050252914429,
-0.4614376723766327,
0.9970158338546753,
-0.46333926916122437,
0.34902918338775635,
-0.44909074902534485,
-0.3072902262210846,
-0.6975252628326416,
0.41004225611686707,
-0.8637956380844116,
-0.10524408519268036,
0.466215580701828,
0.6605679988861084,
0.23075847327709198,
0.34211447834968567,
-0.15579818189144135,
0.32922688126564026,
0.3157489597797394,
0.5269097685813904,
0.6419848799705505,
-0.5436619520187378,
0.038979921489953995,
-0.258607417345047,
-0.04562578350305557,
-0.2257334291934967,
-0.5040149092674255,
-0.9515100717544556,
-0.4809514880180359,
-0.10333619266748428,
-0.5051782131195068,
0.14729630947113037,
1.3081285953521729,
0.24195650219917297,
-0.7175992131233215,
-0.13284440338611603,
-0.014534728601574898,
0.3680082857608795,
-0.17944489419460297,
-0.23434586822986603,
0.44389134645462036,
0.4248105585575104,
-0.2972814738750458,
0.14329946041107178,
0.24396122992038727,
-0.12540842592716217,
0.12760789692401886,
0.24062947928905487,
-0.569604218006134,
-0.04859641566872597,
0.6408254504203796,
0.11745811998844147,
-0.15213774144649506,
0.13237552344799042,
0.3353273570537567,
-0.1784065216779709,
0.003921829164028168,
0.5970743298530579,
-0.5126426219940186,
0.7422005534172058,
0.4177600145339966,
0.4070381820201874,
0.519973635673523,
0.1431562453508377,
0.429071307182312,
-0.40623125433921814,
-0.6709800362586975,
0.24036286771297455,
0.2592231333255768,
0.4792785942554474,
-0.4808371961116791,
0.2002047300338745,
0.39750605821609497,
-0.19648854434490204,
-0.23168595135211945,
-0.08885721117258072,
-1.1330732107162476,
-0.5304116010665894,
1.2707706689834595,
0.303933322429657,
-0.4704623222351074,
-0.4885247051715851,
-0.4189758598804474,
0.5747131109237671,
-0.6210447549819946,
0.9397074580192566,
0.6810840368270874,
-0.25042688846588135,
-0.3700389564037323,
-0.68870609998703,
0.3239416182041168,
-0.2672206461429596,
-0.6588367223739624,
-0.35166066884994507,
0.375853031873703,
0.33171772956848145,
-0.09395993500947952,
1.0197784900665283,
-0.06835189461708069,
-0.10048708319664001,
-0.5657237768173218,
-0.05115411803126335,
0.10405610501766205,
0.4135158956050873,
-0.12484902143478394,
0.12925253808498383,
-0.5981681942939758,
0.01752658374607563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16700v1
|
Generating Effective Ensembles for Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-02-26T16:14:47 | 2024-02-26T16:14:47 |
Itay Etelis, Avi Rosenfeld, Abraham Itzhak Weinberg, David Sarne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, transformer models have revolutionized Natural Language
Processing (NLP), achieving exceptional results across various tasks, including
Sentiment Analysis (SA). As such, current state-of-the-art approaches for SA
predominantly rely on transformer models alone, achieving impressive accuracy
levels on benchmark datasets. In this paper, we show that the key for further
improving the accuracy of such ensembles for SA is to include not only
transformers, but also traditional NLP models, despite the inferiority of the
latter compared to transformer models. However, as we empirically show, this
necessitates a change in how the ensemble is constructed, specifically relying
on the Hierarchical Ensemble Construction (HEC) algorithm we present. Our
empirical studies across eight canonical SA datasets reveal that ensembles
incorporating a mix of model types, structured via HEC, significantly
outperform traditional ensembles. Finally, we provide a comparative analysis of
the performance of the HEC and GPT-4, demonstrating that while GPT-4 closely
approaches state-of-the-art SA methods, it remains outperformed by our proposed
ensemble strategy.
|
[
-0.5971473455429077,
-0.0739821195602417,
0.18391674757003784,
0.23204492032527924,
-0.13608570396900177,
0.7180039286613464,
-0.19412752985954285,
-0.5488325953483582,
0.11017239838838577,
0.03866026550531387,
-0.3563876748085022,
-0.7691270112991333,
-0.7718981504440308,
0.1045069545507431,
-0.5166166424751282,
1.340718150138855,
0.3042147755622864,
-0.1238742396235466,
-0.19464559853076935,
-0.34638693928718567,
-0.0012205814709886909,
-0.5006493926048279,
-0.4632314145565033,
-0.43347153067588806,
0.3517346680164337,
-0.04388953745365143,
0.8486109972000122,
-0.03443748503923416,
0.762580156326294,
0.33184415102005005,
-0.3146846294403076,
0.24389700591564178,
-0.2650732696056366,
0.15770278871059418,
-0.12268536537885666,
-0.3613559305667877,
-0.49283334612846375,
0.11578337848186493,
0.5787534117698669,
0.5660054087638855,
-0.2667115032672882,
0.04444331303238869,
0.24364176392555237,
0.7434154748916626,
-0.8069328665733337,
0.15552261471748352,
-0.7679792642593384,
0.31683221459388733,
-0.2693388760089874,
-0.09428039938211441,
-0.5964586734771729,
-0.2395920753479004,
0.36932551860809326,
-0.2741864025592804,
0.43300867080688477,
-0.024722924456000328,
0.8595913052558899,
0.1929328888654709,
-0.24605663120746613,
-0.14744165539741516,
-0.7626223564147949,
1.0584990978240967,
-0.9057790637016296,
0.1922898292541504,
-0.09231975674629211,
0.34560447931289673,
0.120770663022995,
-0.5594049692153931,
-0.3997371792793274,
0.1860300600528717,
-0.15950851142406464,
0.65532386302948,
-0.5182135701179504,
0.0392126627266407,
-0.0672668069601059,
0.666963517665863,
-0.21810629963874817,
0.03776365518569946,
-0.2651729881763458,
-0.10794609785079956,
0.5281602144241333,
0.043344128876924515,
0.030245058238506317,
-0.6980234980583191,
-0.4374638497829437,
-0.27156129479408264,
-0.37250134348869324,
0.09058795124292374,
0.5203151106834412,
0.34189367294311523,
0.07247631251811981,
0.2790914475917816,
0.15150786936283112,
0.3456098735332489,
0.39655712246894836,
0.011873619630932808,
0.491131454706192,
-0.19250968098640442,
-0.18656998872756958,
-0.15922634303569794,
1.0652600526809692,
0.407022625207901,
0.11787544190883636,
-0.27605628967285156,
-0.5637233853340149,
0.428419291973114,
0.8279274702072144,
-0.4109252989292145,
-0.5083252787590027,
0.3268727660179138,
-0.6403083205223083,
-0.7645853757858276,
0.20876237750053406,
-1.2361018657684326,
-0.31838610768318176,
-0.2981603443622589,
0.2876772880554199,
-0.4103770852088928,
-0.35160771012306213,
-0.24795028567314148,
-0.3778650164604187,
0.4500725269317627,
-0.09431280195713043,
-0.9730255007743835,
0.6165336966514587,
0.7856793999671936,
0.8900651931762695,
-0.3872418701648712,
-0.05807848647236824,
-0.1928957849740982,
-0.3389141857624054,
-0.5484281778335571,
1.0049704313278198,
-0.6921248435974121,
-0.675116777420044,
0.1891525387763977,
-0.42405444383621216,
-0.1452234983444214,
-0.6610588431358337,
0.8936836123466492,
-0.5373731255531311,
0.4795767366886139,
-0.22278155386447906,
-0.46204960346221924,
-0.0391998253762722,
0.3001720607280731,
-0.7011793255805969,
1.2367191314697266,
0.1850988119840622,
-0.9786245822906494,
0.370841383934021,
-0.7422587275505066,
-0.5139803886413574,
-0.2635032534599304,
-0.10764984786510468,
-0.5976185202598572,
0.4308997690677643,
0.7213466167449951,
0.5239826440811157,
-0.192613422870636,
0.07563716173171997,
-0.14560578763484955,
-0.27372366189956665,
0.05357017740607262,
-0.2855414152145386,
0.48784178495407104,
0.2860129177570343,
-0.3201383948326111,
0.19826829433441162,
-0.6166774034500122,
-0.1356857866048813,
-0.28264734148979187,
-0.10909835994243622,
-0.37580710649490356,
0.24816690385341644,
0.0069170198403298855,
0.05593298375606537,
-0.06614384800195694,
-0.4296117126941681,
0.05825399234890938,
-0.6660911440849304,
0.41271308064460754,
0.9233534336090088,
-0.0028213905170559883,
0.9281459450721741,
-0.13396836817264557,
0.6689020991325378,
0.05510709062218666,
0.09039207547903061,
-0.05266105383634567,
-0.4603886902332306,
-0.47813695669174194,
-0.3067522346973419,
0.3638042211532593,
0.3576395511627197,
-0.7809903621673584,
0.6385241746902466,
-0.3921439051628113,
-0.5788387656211853,
-0.6267243027687073,
-0.21519063413143158,
-0.05536682903766632,
0.44592466950416565,
0.48909878730773926,
-0.3036804497241974,
-0.7178023457527161,
-0.8421273231506348,
-0.5106275081634521,
-0.3238365352153778,
-0.025949232280254364,
-0.14688263833522797,
0.43466368317604065,
-0.20262616872787476,
1.1294302940368652,
-0.36907759308815,
-0.11124693602323532,
-0.4096459746360779,
0.4672373831272125,
0.3350818157196045,
0.22083210945129395,
0.634823739528656,
-0.5556992888450623,
-0.2470683455467224,
0.020696846768260002,
-0.6696111559867859,
0.13702674210071564,
-0.06157296523451805,
-0.18336211144924164,
0.25579166412353516,
-0.057455867528915405,
-0.6508305668830872,
0.10597723722457886,
0.6426184773445129,
0.14212626218795776,
0.45916715264320374,
0.23575735092163086,
0.15856382250785828,
-1.135460376739502,
-0.2604888379573822,
0.5373140573501587,
-0.09989695996046066,
-0.6558692455291748,
0.09857264161109924,
-0.12200777977705002,
0.13328146934509277,
-0.04324007406830788,
-0.03059845231473446,
-0.15374191105365753,
-0.13036632537841797,
-0.03835374489426613,
-0.0653071478009224,
-0.10845892876386642,
0.4123500883579254,
-0.005835500080138445,
0.45660731196403503,
0.6004138588905334,
-0.13987118005752563,
0.026410328224301338,
0.14460298418998718,
-0.46626633405685425,
0.6633335947990417,
-0.5810733437538147,
0.11928810179233551,
-0.224537193775177,
0.5896050930023193,
-1.0903056859970093,
-0.33082059025764465,
0.05903519317507744,
-0.5016934871673584,
0.3073486387729645,
0.026232095435261726,
-0.3168780207633972,
-0.591249942779541,
-0.7428447008132935,
0.04929665848612785,
0.9535232782363892,
-0.8441798090934753,
1.0575932264328003,
0.31276336312294006,
-0.003621872514486313,
-0.7528030872344971,
-0.6172896027565002,
0.22092002630233765,
-0.48330923914909363,
-0.5780901312828064,
0.5409061312675476,
0.4718942642211914,
-0.36130228638648987,
-0.15687765181064606,
-0.3388049900531769,
0.0907694548368454,
-0.10470395535230637,
0.05749465525150299,
0.40904301404953003,
-0.1852724552154541,
0.12298402935266495,
0.08368416875600815,
-0.17193545401096344,
0.06822893023490906,
-0.3146992027759552,
0.5129856467247009,
-0.4523231089115143,
-0.10027286410331726,
-0.5285043716430664,
0.23796015977859497,
0.7352225184440613,
-0.37727856636047363,
0.5955583453178406,
0.7705969214439392,
-0.20762883126735687,
-0.4093811511993408,
-0.43731555342674255,
-0.17550429701805115,
-0.4880237281322479,
0.021647287532687187,
-0.13792288303375244,
-0.6859764456748962,
0.4689393639564514,
-0.10131192952394485,
0.43524426221847534,
0.6143000721931458,
0.41041433811187744,
-0.45093414187431335,
1.14888334274292,
0.341708779335022,
-0.620203971862793,
0.3875569701194763,
-0.2915278971195221,
0.6250368356704712,
-0.7107677459716797,
0.036753516644239426,
-0.6841393709182739,
-0.472400963306427,
-1.0550185441970825,
-0.14545248448848724,
0.5748075246810913,
-0.25676974654197693,
-0.06881450861692429,
0.19336995482444763,
-0.6981459856033325,
0.19271263480186462,
0.4728456437587738,
-0.09112253785133362,
0.15959639847278595,
0.24877071380615234,
0.21315206587314606,
0.0461655929684639,
-0.7512811422348022,
-0.6432385444641113,
0.890805184841156,
0.5353507399559021,
0.6373772621154785,
0.06232759729027748,
1.0031930208206177,
0.26073387265205383,
0.34421423077583313,
-0.8669536113739014,
0.26578861474990845,
-0.508617639541626,
-0.3280063271522522,
-0.022270066663622856,
-0.37751519680023193,
-0.7129355669021606,
0.551004946231842,
-0.17435793578624725,
-0.4809202551841736,
0.3394220471382141,
0.1754070222377777,
-0.532122015953064,
0.30039334297180176,
-0.5096716284751892,
0.5169520974159241,
0.3096403479576111,
-0.009831231087446213,
-0.019235167652368546,
-0.6613143682479858,
0.4140397906303406,
0.06623023003339767,
0.3145735561847687,
0.3303000330924988,
0.14920182526111603,
0.7095551490783691,
-0.36736610531806946,
0.9109408855438232,
-0.22171486914157867,
-0.3835706412792206,
0.6060463786125183,
-0.2631881535053253,
0.7202356457710266,
-0.20818668603897095,
-0.38901785016059875,
0.22020214796066284,
-0.17680050432682037,
-0.35093843936920166,
-0.7869532108306885,
0.5708209276199341,
-0.9192448258399963,
-0.27397555112838745,
-0.31884855031967163,
-0.31961414217948914,
-0.4949488341808319,
-0.548973560333252,
0.46950745582580566,
0.5578321218490601,
-0.06462167203426361,
0.27766695618629456,
0.46130985021591187,
-0.033651985228061676,
0.6169895529747009,
-0.2943314015865326,
0.15449978411197662,
-0.5385258793830872,
0.7408307790756226,
0.10834740102291107,
0.2422853261232376,
0.2712289094924927,
0.37984681129455566,
-0.38558176159858704,
-0.44228270649909973,
-0.4491389989852905,
-0.2737218737602234,
-0.768191933631897,
-0.16138845682144165,
-0.7316398620605469,
0.045411087572574615,
-0.6465550661087036,
-0.15901653468608856,
-0.30781090259552,
-0.38717618584632874,
0.07826270163059235,
-0.270357608795166,
0.261380672454834,
0.7221753597259521,
0.007598658557981253,
0.6298744082450867,
-0.9140610098838806,
0.3066619038581848,
0.29990509152412415,
0.1470390409231186,
0.1169310063123703,
-0.32618868350982666,
0.0972629114985466,
-0.24178524315357208,
-0.39812639355659485,
-0.7729705572128296,
0.4597841501235962,
0.22960802912712097,
0.35034647583961487,
0.3441118001937866,
-0.0488152951002121,
0.603172242641449,
-0.4348142743110657,
1.2012923955917358,
0.2710987627506256,
-1.056944727897644,
0.3504982888698578,
-0.5824512243270874,
0.3151664435863495,
0.6248456239700317,
0.2311147004365921,
-0.3476632833480835,
-0.46388769149780273,
-0.7835562229156494,
-0.9804524779319763,
0.5051705241203308,
0.5142207741737366,
0.2694494128227234,
-0.1354583352804184,
0.23449395596981049,
0.08876416832208633,
0.37288880348205566,
-0.7907900810241699,
0.0004656888486351818,
-0.6697793006896973,
-0.6687259078025818,
-0.11658811569213867,
0.04510127753019333,
0.08146028965711594,
-0.1686694473028183,
0.8066255450248718,
-0.20109088718891144,
0.25201913714408875,
0.013569091446697712,
0.17554998397827148,
-0.10580673813819885,
0.4833441972732544,
-0.05925207957625389,
0.05226163938641548,
-0.0028404800686985254,
0.21088998019695282,
0.32592853903770447,
-0.15484759211540222,
-0.15149985253810883,
-0.22338488698005676,
0.013770361430943012,
0.035282034426927567,
0.6651235222816467,
0.6959910988807678,
0.20045310258865356,
-0.22732123732566833,
0.5314151644706726,
0.19671310484409332,
-0.17285262048244476,
-0.1921616643667221,
0.07848489284515381,
0.024120425805449486,
0.12181498110294342,
0.3347344994544983,
0.7260663509368896,
0.32418927550315857,
-0.5775311589241028,
0.11378012597560883,
0.43421998620033264,
-0.5160191655158997,
-0.4490033984184265,
0.05769747868180275,
0.3047981560230255,
-0.06169794127345085,
0.5822415351867676,
-0.22874097526073456,
-0.8718171715736389,
0.4452691674232483,
0.28964757919311523,
1.032187819480896,
-0.2900274693965912,
0.44763678312301636,
0.37442293763160706,
0.38735079765319824,
-0.4452417492866516,
-0.004280184395611286,
-0.1805153489112854,
-0.9164981842041016,
-0.631885290145874,
-0.6846184730529785,
-0.3307443857192993,
-0.2675914764404297,
-0.8685882687568665,
0.02765662781894207,
-0.34584856033325195,
-0.1286037564277649,
-0.01542133279144764,
-0.28099435567855835,
-0.43265020847320557,
0.32685768604278564,
0.07515647262334824,
0.644193708896637,
-0.8735221028327942,
0.33349403738975525,
0.6524430513381958,
-0.14090348780155182,
-0.8102043271064758,
0.2599712610244751,
0.12326429039239883,
-0.3440583050251007,
0.29846522212028503,
0.13982641696929932,
-0.3423636555671692,
-0.13826696574687958,
-0.6621788144111633,
-0.6585496664047241,
0.814842939376831,
-0.31205135583877563,
-0.6954180598258972,
0.003631936851888895,
0.02007891610264778,
1.0129984617233276,
-0.3166632354259491,
0.22879362106323242,
0.8620473146438599,
0.5098798871040344,
0.2575153112411499,
-0.5759958624839783,
-0.44342392683029175,
-0.32140645384788513,
-0.058018386363983154,
0.472788542509079,
-0.432086706161499,
0.7032497525215149,
0.13732799887657166,
-0.18779879808425903,
0.015864815562963486,
0.8951625823974609,
0.032353971153497696,
0.1944817155599594,
0.8929431438446045,
0.6125661730766296,
0.9211803078651428,
-0.3010914623737335,
1.3407788276672363,
-0.06312491744756699,
0.4733108580112457,
0.9630258083343506,
-0.41622546315193176,
0.8930419683456421,
0.37626054883003235,
-0.4125007092952728,
0.9063716530799866,
0.5636169910430908,
-0.2117430716753006,
0.5244165658950806,
0.09341698884963989,
-0.3930666744709015,
-0.40777498483657837,
0.2323981523513794,
0.023003725335001945,
0.7072715163230896,
0.2654094994068146,
-0.2898194491863251,
-0.2104341834783554,
-0.12061672657728195,
-0.1833678036928177,
0.2225417047739029,
-0.35101985931396484,
0.8607317209243774,
0.07889155298471451,
-0.7290412187576294,
0.19826412200927734,
-0.18481741845607758,
1.136061191558838,
-0.30508720874786377,
0.29604753851890564,
0.12814071774482727,
0.17016413807868958,
-0.6340246200561523,
-0.6544379591941833,
0.48252299427986145,
0.21067824959754944,
-0.09030303359031677,
-0.17395971715450287,
0.8236103653907776,
-0.023496896028518677,
-0.6674339175224304,
0.16410957276821136,
0.5708215832710266,
-0.17380045354366302,
-0.04056787118315697,
-0.44572746753692627,
-0.1890566051006317,
-0.05182107537984848,
-0.3894610106945038,
0.1839955598115921,
0.10533908754587173,
-0.0873015969991684,
0.175555020570755,
0.6580923795700073,
-0.08343929052352905,
-0.2092442810535431,
0.5622863173484802,
0.6706675887107849,
-0.5436722040176392,
-0.4372674226760864,
-0.9096617102622986,
0.7203769087791443,
-0.4337306320667267,
-0.32264605164527893,
0.6983057856559753,
0.13881631195545197,
0.49623820185661316,
-0.03217180445790291,
1.0259093046188354,
-0.007821990177035332,
0.49958550930023193,
-0.286782830953598,
0.516868531703949,
-0.34663042426109314,
0.3584935665130615,
-0.7275996804237366,
-1.0314826965332031,
-0.4609806537628174,
0.7928070425987244,
-0.3650994598865509,
0.20719347894191742,
0.5329257249832153,
0.7265983819961548,
0.047663550823926926,
0.8485569357872009,
0.0754486694931984,
0.17913265526294708,
0.5673376321792603,
0.074821338057518,
1.3294837474822998,
-0.5003834366798401,
0.34110918641090393,
-0.46121498942375183,
-0.21592076122760773,
0.3147319257259369,
-0.9290550947189331,
-0.9036559462547302,
-0.38260209560394287,
-0.20086893439292908,
-0.11885439604520798,
-0.07845018804073334,
1.0902280807495117,
0.5703321099281311,
-0.7987995743751526,
-0.03523227944970131,
-0.1545514613389969,
-0.17153339087963104,
-0.46177205443382263,
-0.2559927999973297,
0.31903254985809326,
-0.7065276503562927,
-0.8038874268531799,
0.45403236150741577,
0.23514720797538757,
-0.2705104947090149,
-0.3029715120792389,
0.22891630232334137,
0.21427319943904877,
0.28974035382270813,
1.0675525665283203,
-0.40966829657554626,
-0.6945630311965942,
-0.5213280916213989,
0.09209293872117996,
0.19928719103336334,
0.38871002197265625,
0.7307661771774292,
-0.955908477306366,
0.032868485897779465,
0.5895985960960388,
0.6940460205078125,
0.15114058554172516,
0.2404894232749939,
0.5326734185218811,
-1.0014548301696777,
-0.5171738266944885,
0.35775962471961975,
0.4877302646636963,
0.48542678356170654,
-0.1885373592376709,
0.573024332523346,
0.02105322666466236,
-0.4476759731769562,
-0.6586915850639343,
-0.051921430975198746,
-1.055717945098877,
-0.30322280526161194,
1.0168191194534302,
0.15003368258476257,
-0.0978727787733078,
0.14465783536434174,
-0.24367853999137878,
0.015091508626937866,
-0.6727848649024963,
0.9884032011032104,
0.7977493405342102,
-0.2454136461019516,
0.09137995541095734,
-0.03924599289894104,
0.3226486146450043,
0.5352849364280701,
-0.9488795399665833,
-0.06714774668216705,
0.4035939574241638,
-0.05518275871872902,
0.6172153949737549,
0.16264532506465912,
-0.32002076506614685,
0.07531808316707611,
-0.1205381527543068,
0.0663238912820816,
0.6608796119689941,
-0.3302296996116638,
-0.4309306740760803,
0.789749801158905,
-0.126641184091568,
0.005866378080099821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16696v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16696v2
|
Look Before You Leap: Towards Decision-Aware and Generalizable Tool-Usage for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-26T16:11:03 | 2024-02-28T03:31:28 |
Anchun Gui, Jian Li, Yong Dai, Nan Du, Han Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tool-augmented large language models (LLMs) are attracting widespread
attention when accessing up-to-date knowledge and alleviating hallucination
issues. Nowadays, advanced closed-source LLMs (e.g., ChatGPT) have demonstrated
surprising tool-usage capabilities through prompting and in-context learning
techniques. To empower the capabilities of open-source LLMs (e.g., LLaMA) in
manipulating tools, current efforts focus on either template-driven or
token-triggered tool-usage. However, the former hampers LLMs' flexibility to
address diverse user's queries due to constrained tool interactions, while the
latter limits the generalizability when engaging with new tools, since
tool-usage learning is based on task- and tool-specific datasets. To alleviate
these concerns, in this paper, we propose a decision-aware and generalizable
tool-usage framework (DEER). Specifically, we first construct the tool-usage
samples with multiple decision branches via an automatic generation pipeline,
thereby inspiring the decision-making awareness of LLMs under diverse
scenarios. Meanwhile, we propose a novel tool sampling strategy to enhance the
generalizability of LLMs over unseen tools. Extensive experiments demonstrate
that our proposed DEER is effective and significantly outperforms baselines
across various datasets.
|
[
-0.3319351077079773,
-0.578643262386322,
0.556088387966156,
0.027124684303998947,
-0.3881756663322449,
0.2712426781654358,
-0.15358880162239075,
-0.2831401526927948,
0.09803930670022964,
0.41774383187294006,
-0.5570330619812012,
-0.894558846950531,
-0.404408723115921,
-0.2370361089706421,
-0.6017708778381348,
0.5387793779373169,
0.14684079587459564,
-0.36449626088142395,
-0.10599710047245026,
-0.2070470005273819,
-0.39165636897087097,
-0.43847256898880005,
-0.5056494474411011,
-0.1733960062265396,
0.6546314358711243,
0.27787214517593384,
0.7444483041763306,
0.35401731729507446,
0.14552266895771027,
0.25024524331092834,
-0.14865636825561523,
0.23020213842391968,
-0.22850489616394043,
-0.041367266327142715,
-0.2779132127761841,
-0.4927966892719269,
-0.5559069514274597,
-0.09305439889431,
0.2620088458061218,
0.707845151424408,
-0.3610365390777588,
0.24901250004768372,
0.04939283803105354,
0.09092649072408676,
-0.8613706827163696,
0.14560943841934204,
-1.103553056716919,
0.14999641478061676,
-0.23286104202270508,
-0.16378135979175568,
-0.4075402021408081,
-0.000009669928658695426,
0.2694561779499054,
-0.9111303687095642,
0.24202728271484375,
0.002105729654431343,
0.543765664100647,
0.20499219000339508,
-0.3372321128845215,
-0.17882877588272095,
-0.5796347856521606,
0.9015761613845825,
-0.651436984539032,
0.6472394466400146,
0.5953370928764343,
0.43264633417129517,
-0.29290542006492615,
-0.6994178891181946,
-0.4467419385910034,
0.10201406478881836,
0.11074889451265335,
-0.24107353389263153,
-0.2814435064792633,
-0.023234860971570015,
0.2999873757362366,
0.09474928677082062,
-0.4480421543121338,
0.34441375732421875,
0.01928984373807907,
-0.3256460130214691,
0.4306412935256958,
0.06904101371765137,
0.02326822653412819,
0.05438421294093132,
-0.19176504015922546,
-0.0536981001496315,
-0.8810471296310425,
0.04946449398994446,
0.2725464701652527,
0.5160462260246277,
0.08674567937850952,
0.563305675983429,
0.034997545182704926,
0.7668160200119019,
0.17079830169677734,
-0.01501768734306097,
0.42794737219810486,
-0.25320693850517273,
-0.7072474360466003,
-0.2585720419883728,
0.575694739818573,
0.28549444675445557,
0.44202134013175964,
-0.04557691514492035,
-0.14684785902500153,
-0.27082517743110657,
0.28373295068740845,
-0.6369173526763916,
-0.14090517163276672,
0.19563749432563782,
0.007403525989502668,
-0.3129790425300598,
-0.35255998373031616,
-0.613386332988739,
-0.622696042060852,
-0.2653941512107849,
0.11608648300170898,
-0.35516512393951416,
-0.4603472352027893,
0.3231430649757385,
0.1955089569091797,
0.5644851922988892,
0.5956916213035583,
-0.6963755488395691,
0.019529376178979874,
0.5994560718536377,
0.8457139730453491,
-0.184499591588974,
-0.169932022690773,
-0.8362078666687012,
0.3767821788787842,
-0.5509781837463379,
0.5831724405288696,
-0.6508535742759705,
-0.8571565747261047,
0.1258602738380432,
-0.173335000872612,
0.12924914062023163,
-0.5695326924324036,
0.22211216390132904,
-0.7835063934326172,
0.2024746686220169,
-0.16055090725421906,
-0.20482730865478516,
-0.4210549592971802,
0.4875282943248749,
-0.5265368223190308,
1.0076154470443726,
0.1332460343837738,
-0.8367080092430115,
1.0210343599319458,
-0.6602023243904114,
-0.4857769012451172,
0.15208667516708374,
-0.3822229504585266,
-0.3822982907295227,
0.03549324721097946,
0.5827797651290894,
0.5462204217910767,
0.06182832270860672,
0.4505758285522461,
-0.42856907844543457,
-0.18223577737808228,
-0.22649243474006653,
-0.13980591297149658,
0.770122766494751,
0.10967212170362473,
-0.10794790834188461,
0.34246817231178284,
-0.5915732979774475,
0.06756163388490677,
0.09692549705505371,
-0.48836371302604675,
-0.47054263949394226,
0.2047862410545349,
-0.1811610758304596,
0.14680267870426178,
-0.018455862998962402,
-0.35664793848991394,
0.3048875331878662,
-0.5526333451271057,
0.1520494669675827,
0.8905318975448608,
-0.10648484528064728,
0.2855552136898041,
0.08689714968204498,
0.7688594460487366,
0.2162259966135025,
-0.013126335106790066,
-0.21146324276924133,
-0.2557981014251709,
-0.668732225894928,
-0.31119710206985474,
0.3123100996017456,
0.5289475321769714,
-0.7042355537414551,
0.62428218126297,
-0.059696026146411896,
-0.4516999423503876,
-0.2717421054840088,
0.26703014969825745,
0.07228705286979675,
0.3082369863986969,
0.27488675713539124,
-0.2897247076034546,
-0.6476303339004517,
-0.688054084777832,
-0.35107555985450745,
-0.4482913911342621,
-0.24979190528392792,
0.5135440826416016,
0.19237877428531647,
-0.4236550033092499,
1.3736591339111328,
-0.5062805414199829,
-0.1546609252691269,
-0.452243834733963,
-0.11715902388095856,
0.26937663555145264,
0.2775486409664154,
0.4402288794517517,
-0.6983727812767029,
-0.30978140234947205,
0.09425774216651917,
-0.4009052813053131,
-0.002552432008087635,
-0.1087934821844101,
-0.19253157079219818,
0.07772383838891983,
0.6103832721710205,
-0.6597191691398621,
0.38300251960754395,
0.3707267642021179,
-0.2740798890590668,
0.6557475924491882,
-0.07602142542600632,
-0.27159544825553894,
-1.0889719724655151,
0.05229613557457924,
-0.007560781668871641,
-0.3822658061981201,
-0.5208515524864197,
-0.12667502462863922,
0.046436622738838196,
0.10058283060789108,
-0.6472541093826294,
0.6109779477119446,
-0.3927668631076813,
-0.29297390580177307,
0.08163571357727051,
0.0034642498940229416,
-0.158569797873497,
0.2660364508628845,
-0.012575448490679264,
0.924801230430603,
0.7896064519882202,
-0.7124049663543701,
-0.1662922352552414,
0.38388073444366455,
-0.4457394778728485,
0.3685915768146515,
-0.5019806027412415,
0.24328552186489105,
0.02896863967180252,
0.16981232166290283,
-0.6098527312278748,
-0.17814412713050842,
0.29029569029808044,
-0.28301122784614563,
0.19016599655151367,
-0.4602105915546417,
-0.6122573614120483,
-0.2781359553337097,
-0.24309992790222168,
0.1495549976825714,
0.39109688997268677,
-0.786651074886322,
0.9715518355369568,
0.3859386444091797,
-0.10750587284564972,
-0.8289113640785217,
-0.5775356292724609,
0.21979224681854248,
-0.4916015565395355,
-0.3837096095085144,
-0.07717590034008026,
-0.2700686752796173,
-0.2763034403324127,
-0.4085260033607483,
-0.16065946221351624,
0.026340682059526443,
0.19694586098194122,
0.13354894518852234,
0.3607386648654938,
-0.035456277430057526,
0.5049779415130615,
0.057398684322834015,
0.15148155391216278,
0.005533041898161173,
-0.40943312644958496,
0.6622846722602844,
-0.03594203293323517,
-0.8903568387031555,
0.15295745432376862,
-0.007654853630810976,
0.5088987350463867,
-0.5201467275619507,
0.09813781082630157,
0.5477087497711182,
-0.20236222445964813,
-0.37224799394607544,
-0.6150186657905579,
0.027508443221449852,
-0.5438075661659241,
0.44676104187965393,
-0.33615145087242126,
-0.9690451622009277,
0.30032598972320557,
-0.4190743863582611,
0.705379068851471,
0.08121807128190994,
0.6605376601219177,
0.09438473731279373,
1.0026363134384155,
0.8779826164245605,
-0.0525117851793766,
0.5883132219314575,
-0.2012762427330017,
0.2040552794933319,
-0.769265353679657,
-0.06583420187234879,
-0.19050543010234833,
-0.20042777061462402,
-0.2397991120815277,
-0.8565827012062073,
0.20513927936553955,
0.06531168520450592,
-0.2352718710899353,
0.1406807005405426,
-0.3138609826564789,
0.6745089292526245,
0.2680020332336426,
-0.31712764501571655,
0.3907768130302429,
0.06126804277300835,
-0.44624313712120056,
0.16168467700481415,
-0.6512323617935181,
-0.4208545684814453,
1.374729037284851,
0.23005995154380798,
0.6700329780578613,
-0.1412619948387146,
0.779516339302063,
0.2678396701812744,
0.18140551447868347,
-1.1709754467010498,
0.7489244937896729,
0.14858338236808777,
-0.5178430080413818,
-0.30780380964279175,
-0.0893973633646965,
-1.1771594285964966,
0.5530107021331787,
0.09370261430740356,
-0.7538725137710571,
0.3231201767921448,
0.24469062685966492,
-0.38354507088661194,
0.575461745262146,
-0.6323573589324951,
0.4691368341445923,
-0.3101949393749237,
-0.04939361661672592,
-0.2474909871816635,
-0.2753894031047821,
0.315842866897583,
-0.35359513759613037,
0.47262415289878845,
-0.26906201243400574,
-0.4603936970233917,
0.42295363545417786,
-0.0025830992963165045,
1.0499783754348755,
-0.29124534130096436,
-0.23804034292697906,
0.35500702261924744,
0.43740227818489075,
0.6524171233177185,
-0.044962987303733826,
-0.02321288362145424,
0.1136699914932251,
-0.3463754951953888,
-0.014096352271735668,
-0.385231614112854,
0.42605024576187134,
-0.35828959941864014,
-0.8500977158546448,
-0.3962603509426117,
-0.5480266809463501,
-0.5622084140777588,
0.3851553499698639,
-0.12045688927173615,
0.36026135087013245,
-0.4224018454551697,
-0.012320146895945072,
0.5429177284240723,
-0.3528997004032135,
0.42074283957481384,
0.7127173542976379,
-0.7957013249397278,
-0.11200957745313644,
0.6895799040794373,
-0.05284728854894638,
0.19426393508911133,
-0.02310493029654026,
0.25367385149002075,
-0.2919647693634033,
-0.8105756044387817,
-0.38045424222946167,
0.09568961709737778,
-0.6818356513977051,
-0.11397794634103775,
-0.6576238870620728,
0.0651564672589302,
-0.1549464762210846,
-0.384855180978775,
-0.037644192576408386,
-0.1344192773103714,
-0.37946760654449463,
-0.30443423986434937,
0.44176730513572693,
0.6057994961738586,
-0.06200327351689339,
0.2673519253730774,
-0.5126485824584961,
0.021291961893439293,
0.5839145183563232,
0.43853437900543213,
-0.02177937515079975,
-0.36007365584373474,
-0.17318212985992432,
-0.19221557676792145,
-0.19422496855258942,
-0.32650700211524963,
0.4690430164337158,
0.23268353939056396,
0.7772367596626282,
0.48989468812942505,
0.019300552085042,
0.4759347438812256,
-0.47369763255119324,
0.6912847757339478,
0.1725209802389145,
-0.8033119440078735,
0.6486005783081055,
-0.5197224617004395,
0.4356030523777008,
0.22947382926940918,
0.2528219223022461,
-0.47445419430732727,
-0.4152698814868927,
-0.6995063424110413,
-0.9492195844650269,
0.5656672716140747,
-0.08722363412380219,
0.21702641248703003,
0.13456319272518158,
-0.12830360233783722,
0.28624024987220764,
0.40838801860809326,
-0.38106703758239746,
0.14807090163230896,
-0.19707295298576355,
0.15374664962291718,
-0.16199077665805817,
0.10444077104330063,
-0.12151575088500977,
-0.3450128138065338,
0.42373254895210266,
-0.5718991756439209,
-0.3407687246799469,
-0.15546786785125732,
-0.3333502411842346,
-0.007201279513537884,
0.4830121397972107,
-0.016758255660533905,
0.7818701267242432,
-0.16943074762821198,
0.0800887793302536,
0.619374692440033,
-0.38590675592422485,
0.011994983069598675,
-0.0027328836731612682,
-0.17273464798927307,
0.040721774101257324,
0.11626218259334564,
0.6754265427589417,
0.41208404302597046,
-0.9788296222686768,
0.3095352351665497,
0.07195331901311874,
-0.11590968072414398,
-0.2486564964056015,
0.24200426042079926,
0.4398464262485504,
0.36305227875709534,
0.0682843029499054,
-0.027437007054686546,
0.14647696912288666,
-0.3287632465362549,
0.16580377519130707,
0.6728488206863403,
-0.15875381231307983,
-0.1303166151046753,
0.35690435767173767,
0.2275211215019226,
-0.2748507559299469,
0.45771095156669617,
-0.1195797473192215,
-0.25347641110420227,
0.2641002833843231,
0.30102819204330444,
0.9967516660690308,
-0.20284375548362732,
0.265830934047699,
0.27334821224212646,
0.12068678438663483,
0.19787509739398956,
0.09244949370622635,
-0.2780921161174774,
-0.8116503357887268,
-0.45388689637184143,
-0.5906489491462708,
-0.5289053320884705,
0.18908709287643433,
-0.5088258385658264,
0.6162122488021851,
-0.6849240660667419,
-0.3092908263206482,
-0.17178702354431152,
-0.2246248722076416,
-0.8420058488845825,
0.013342905789613724,
0.04251076653599739,
1.2447617053985596,
-0.38602712750434875,
0.9913045763969421,
0.6967534422874451,
-0.006899741478264332,
-0.65691739320755,
0.14700327813625336,
0.2594729959964752,
-1.0514461994171143,
0.44347676634788513,
0.12898172438144684,
-0.3470119833946228,
-0.006033703684806824,
-0.6885315179824829,
-0.7124941349029541,
1.1582547426223755,
0.45593997836112976,
-0.6671810746192932,
-0.25762054324150085,
-0.1424100250005722,
0.24109378457069397,
-0.295819491147995,
0.010346113704144955,
0.8449103236198425,
0.47966712713241577,
0.5440382957458496,
-0.8909719586372375,
-0.27144184708595276,
-0.014038663357496262,
-0.04213031381368637,
0.13507774472236633,
-0.2270299196243286,
0.6770114898681641,
-0.528656542301178,
-0.4468396008014679,
-0.3942153751850128,
0.3275829255580902,
0.5690752267837524,
0.13031652569770813,
0.9435549974441528,
0.4914698004722595,
0.8807932734489441,
0.34448766708374023,
0.8346070647239685,
0.09569226950407028,
0.06485527753829956,
1.1676833629608154,
-0.37347549200057983,
0.9995476007461548,
0.33013391494750977,
-0.33712393045425415,
0.33975887298583984,
0.5787950158119202,
-0.025655904784798622,
0.3029427230358124,
0.232060506939888,
-0.22694820165634155,
-0.7380785942077637,
0.08046943694353104,
-0.3557164967060089,
0.6316018104553223,
0.6220961213111877,
-0.26359158754348755,
-0.5950406789779663,
-0.2644990086555481,
0.09532225877046585,
-0.24974873661994934,
-0.3048287630081177,
0.8806062936782837,
0.07739922404289246,
-0.26178908348083496,
0.6385006904602051,
-0.312675803899765,
0.845303475856781,
-0.872661292552948,
0.07927997410297394,
0.09782685339450836,
0.0058839814737439156,
-0.11016577482223511,
-1.0800623893737793,
0.1776331216096878,
0.17480836808681488,
-0.11333894729614258,
-0.23917336761951447,
0.7934841513633728,
-0.3198314607143402,
-0.6840152144432068,
0.408906489610672,
0.9345093965530396,
0.13933992385864258,
-0.16118937730789185,
-0.5863335728645325,
0.01595464162528515,
0.07888249307870865,
-0.3031940460205078,
0.6045638918876648,
0.2748306691646576,
-0.11987947672605515,
0.9758692383766174,
0.8084321022033691,
0.21313337981700897,
-0.08723962306976318,
0.20635543763637543,
1.0833120346069336,
-0.45350322127342224,
-0.5676044225692749,
-0.6063404083251953,
0.5053284764289856,
-0.025197159498929977,
-0.21826042234897614,
0.6624045372009277,
0.5162593722343445,
0.9261904954910278,
0.058546554297208786,
1.0706766843795776,
0.0696810781955719,
0.7105560898780823,
-0.3741897940635681,
0.7202101349830627,
-0.619289219379425,
0.3180471360683441,
-0.15501828491687775,
-0.7291952967643738,
-0.38510462641716003,
0.4218002259731293,
-0.5262786746025085,
0.027590196579694748,
0.09922477602958679,
0.9057661294937134,
-0.33653637766838074,
-0.1730264276266098,
0.4443061649799347,
0.012219231575727463,
0.7357267737388611,
0.33416444063186646,
0.6505610942840576,
0.4095681607723236,
0.7173683047294617,
0.2443891316652298,
-0.10696792602539062,
-0.24901825189590454,
-1.1133317947387695,
-0.9253106713294983,
-0.3661578595638275,
-0.21804989874362946,
0.1030348688364029,
-0.08630964905023575,
1.1250633001327515,
0.8595253825187683,
-0.7792835235595703,
-0.3208152651786804,
0.0041830032132565975,
0.21861644089221954,
-0.044314756989479065,
-0.07976925373077393,
0.25395888090133667,
-0.488277405500412,
-0.5886582732200623,
0.6205727458000183,
0.17681649327278137,
0.16963981091976166,
-0.4261017143726349,
-0.09378054738044739,
-0.23972788453102112,
0.1504676192998886,
0.7931494116783142,
0.36742982268333435,
-0.8281205892562866,
-0.21136881411075592,
-0.2146507203578949,
0.25229236483573914,
0.304938942193985,
0.8250232338905334,
-1.276626706123352,
0.7481110692024231,
0.1985250860452652,
0.5988309383392334,
0.3303143084049225,
-0.09070191532373428,
0.730208694934845,
-0.8752371668815613,
0.09670800715684891,
0.3804001808166504,
0.3848101496696472,
0.46110567450523376,
-0.15250514447689056,
0.4569965898990631,
0.004364970605820417,
-0.1308930516242981,
-0.8490890860557556,
0.42801985144615173,
-0.7446345090866089,
-0.145645871758461,
1.1738990545272827,
-0.19446516036987305,
0.24861755967140198,
-0.36868348717689514,
-0.4488944709300995,
0.016021965071558952,
-0.49118921160697937,
0.5762238502502441,
0.540030300617218,
0.0678296610713005,
-0.1485794633626938,
-0.49030062556266785,
0.4526679813861847,
0.16136348247528076,
-0.8700555562973022,
0.5712732076644897,
0.5303366780281067,
0.3731507658958435,
-0.0764642283320427,
0.3838041424751282,
-0.045070163905620575,
-0.010003892704844475,
-0.2795206904411316,
-0.019908741116523743,
-0.36097896099090576,
-0.2578248977661133,
-0.3022516071796417,
0.001632794039323926,
0.4123605787754059,
-0.181990846991539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16694v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16694v2
|
HumanEval-XL: A Multilingual Code Generation Benchmark for Cross-lingual Natural Language Generalization
| 2024-02-26T16:09:00 | 2024-03-24T15:41:21 |
Qiwei Peng, Yekun Chai, Xuhong Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.PL, cs.SE
|
Large language models (LLMs) have made significant progress in generating
codes from textual prompts. However, existing benchmarks have mainly
concentrated on translating English prompts to multilingual codes or have been
constrained to very limited natural languages (NLs). These benchmarks have
overlooked the vast landscape of massively multilingual NL to multilingual
code, leaving a critical gap in the evaluation of multilingual LLMs. In
response, we introduce HumanEval-XL, a massively multilingual code generation
benchmark specifically crafted to address this deficiency. HumanEval-XL
establishes connections between 23 NLs and 12 programming languages (PLs), and
comprises of a collection of 22,080 prompts with an average of 8.33 test cases.
By ensuring parallel data across multiple NLs and PLs, HumanEval-XL offers a
comprehensive evaluation platform for multilingual LLMs, allowing the
assessment of the understanding of different NLs. Our work serves as a
pioneering step towards filling the void in evaluating NL generalization in the
area of multilingual code generation. We make our evaluation code and data
publicly available at \url{https://github.com/FloatAI/humaneval-xl}.
|
[
-0.4949009120464325,
-0.4671380817890167,
0.22690331935882568,
0.5587614178657532,
-0.14192929863929749,
0.19878360629081726,
-0.5007771253585815,
-0.3862583339214325,
-0.11708185821771622,
0.4770183265209198,
-0.4235462546348572,
-0.8361758589744568,
-0.21548177301883698,
0.8383198976516724,
0.209135502576828,
1.018507957458496,
0.08292905986309052,
0.2478458434343338,
-0.1264551728963852,
-0.7356823086738586,
-0.34111058712005615,
-0.6058278679847717,
-0.48444128036499023,
0.18082483112812042,
0.8058693408966064,
0.31645989418029785,
0.6776822805404663,
0.6102687120437622,
0.3850353956222534,
0.23766376078128815,
0.12374533712863922,
0.19940052926540375,
-0.4457819163799286,
0.02655460499227047,
-0.03881317004561424,
-0.2859652638435364,
-0.3372426927089691,
-0.1991889774799347,
0.8990055918693542,
0.6353726983070374,
-0.05035490542650223,
0.14967234432697296,
-0.11619263887405396,
0.6693252921104431,
-0.5754556059837341,
0.06052924692630768,
-0.45449772477149963,
0.3210015594959259,
-0.2182403802871704,
-0.20225286483764648,
-0.3750465512275696,
-0.8262054324150085,
-0.30124691128730774,
-0.48951637744903564,
-0.0658259317278862,
0.043366312980651855,
0.4850122332572937,
0.21159179508686066,
-0.5279613733291626,
-0.16757287085056305,
-0.3488121032714844,
1.0549513101577759,
-0.5418329834938049,
0.724963366985321,
0.36106517910957336,
0.3853150010108948,
-0.006297066807746887,
-0.6488471031188965,
-0.325577050447464,
-0.3816084861755371,
0.3095991909503937,
-0.0730196088552475,
-0.533908486366272,
-0.2273150384426117,
0.45622509717941284,
0.24823760986328125,
-0.9761083722114563,
0.14712980389595032,
-0.31425338983535767,
-0.5240569114685059,
0.570618748664856,
0.18522489070892334,
0.4513150453567505,
-0.14562636613845825,
-0.20886112749576569,
-0.1407819390296936,
-0.8099957704544067,
0.369232714176178,
0.6456922292709351,
0.43459779024124146,
-0.358807772397995,
0.3424047827720642,
-0.1803845912218094,
0.6931343674659729,
-0.264132559299469,
-0.07321880012750626,
0.610350489616394,
-0.5800300240516663,
0.04086950793862343,
-0.06082049384713173,
0.9796196818351746,
0.547465443611145,
0.2536506652832031,
-0.13736602663993835,
-0.2693317234516144,
0.11973202973604202,
0.15838080644607544,
-0.898651123046875,
0.08108855038881302,
0.13383682072162628,
-0.3539368808269501,
-0.2050458788871765,
-0.34040567278862,
-0.8260513544082642,
-0.18067342042922974,
-0.1948343813419342,
-0.08237531781196594,
-0.21633057296276093,
-0.19399280846118927,
0.24340732395648956,
0.20253166556358337,
0.42462778091430664,
0.051693134009838104,
-0.5327857136726379,
0.06435316056013107,
0.6272326707839966,
0.549297571182251,
-0.06442049145698547,
-0.35828179121017456,
-1.3506664037704468,
-0.2950682044029236,
-0.5818716883659363,
0.7938382029533386,
-0.9087206721305847,
-0.32899734377861023,
0.24492061138153076,
0.14444655179977417,
0.27264976501464844,
-0.5786296725273132,
0.8357070684432983,
-0.5147904753684998,
0.09941547363996506,
-0.6029847860336304,
-0.26119762659072876,
-0.01805456541478634,
0.3719031512737274,
-0.7319366335868835,
1.1183674335479736,
0.0014567392645403743,
-0.9192355871200562,
0.4183666706085205,
-0.5005134344100952,
-0.3040623068809509,
0.28068310022354126,
-0.5981477499008179,
-0.46359628438949585,
-0.17371438443660736,
0.19631320238113403,
0.28672149777412415,
-0.5852415561676025,
0.482702374458313,
-0.48757946491241455,
-0.14573660492897034,
-0.07617482542991638,
-0.2973267734050751,
0.8661986589431763,
0.31086811423301697,
-0.28494027256965637,
0.2809631824493408,
-0.7596625685691833,
0.15283708274364471,
0.03498001769185066,
-0.5748026371002197,
-0.4223681390285492,
-0.3504292964935303,
0.16727802157402039,
0.3137394189834595,
0.15237613022327423,
-0.7308233380317688,
0.2790467441082001,
-0.25131481885910034,
0.19776490330696106,
0.5638816356658936,
-0.18994642794132233,
0.32821980118751526,
-0.19024698436260223,
0.7839975953102112,
-0.24833425879478455,
0.11556211113929749,
-0.27714648842811584,
-0.631533145904541,
-0.24278967082500458,
-0.21963052451610565,
0.2506360411643982,
0.5548149347305298,
-0.7811971306800842,
0.29897341132164,
-0.1364874690771103,
-0.3723103106021881,
-0.45278823375701904,
0.30768483877182007,
0.5880964994430542,
0.3174084424972534,
0.28450071811676025,
-0.035033103078603745,
-0.6031545400619507,
-1.103248119354248,
-0.3005272150039673,
0.08636850863695145,
-0.16987191140651703,
0.24060890078544617,
0.4022630453109741,
-0.7517693042755127,
0.7263630628585815,
0.03155073896050453,
0.08233610540628433,
-0.29306986927986145,
0.30992817878723145,
0.25413185358047485,
0.4664275646209717,
0.7670331597328186,
-0.6139087080955505,
-0.4931624233722687,
0.2789768576622009,
-0.8035102486610413,
-0.3627242147922516,
-0.12875422835350037,
-0.24386516213417053,
0.4597657322883606,
0.4837680160999298,
-0.0711544081568718,
0.14560885727405548,
0.8956264853477478,
-0.09679284691810608,
0.7947366833686829,
-0.37520459294319153,
0.22265338897705078,
-1.0050482749938965,
0.40380895137786865,
-0.10759013146162033,
-0.17225107550621033,
-0.3880305290222168,
0.26597246527671814,
0.4843147397041321,
-0.2053801417350769,
-0.41020941734313965,
0.5871607661247253,
-0.49248045682907104,
-0.27376601099967957,
0.06570848822593689,
0.031697943806648254,
0.06111852079629898,
0.5003305673599243,
-0.03898739069700241,
0.9901319146156311,
0.6821177005767822,
-0.45151349902153015,
0.6296706795692444,
0.1232515498995781,
-0.13802243769168854,
0.6554852724075317,
-0.763388454914093,
0.12706713378429413,
0.0241822749376297,
0.2517298758029938,
-0.5163131356239319,
-0.08377747237682343,
0.015954891219735146,
-0.2767501771450043,
-0.0495816245675087,
-0.15692271292209625,
-0.5769477486610413,
-0.49815765023231506,
-0.5416533946990967,
0.7103189826011658,
0.43205124139785767,
-0.49176687002182007,
0.3659467399120331,
0.2974606156349182,
-0.4426174461841583,
-0.7788735032081604,
-0.4561023414134979,
0.37119385600090027,
-0.1382436901330948,
-0.6151753664016724,
-0.08656035363674164,
-0.5041128993034363,
-0.2492988109588623,
-0.30095401406288147,
0.1440325230360031,
-0.0419873483479023,
-0.1805417686700821,
-0.12278483062982559,
0.11987744271755219,
-0.40265628695487976,
0.1040632352232933,
0.3608957529067993,
-0.20805896818637848,
0.2897941768169403,
-0.4266541004180908,
0.39077433943748474,
-0.5769270658493042,
-0.3822549283504486,
-0.0011935216607525945,
0.6367174386978149,
0.657077968120575,
-0.6454813480377197,
0.31639590859413147,
0.802291214466095,
-0.38423123955726624,
-0.23437799513339996,
-0.5484610199928284,
0.18363817036151886,
-0.416591614484787,
0.3601575493812561,
-0.39302322268486023,
-0.9359632134437561,
0.7223870158195496,
-0.07629097998142242,
0.45169028639793396,
0.2960089147090912,
0.6675688028335571,
0.5737887620925903,
1.1547811031341553,
0.7520537972450256,
-0.1396132856607437,
-0.04807307571172714,
0.01594218611717224,
-0.05635702610015869,
-0.567489743232727,
-0.12042931467294693,
-0.7900599241256714,
0.07594500482082367,
-0.7873022556304932,
-0.6371836066246033,
0.4363531172275543,
0.03746689110994339,
-0.2291298806667328,
0.33579617738723755,
-0.38252121210098267,
0.5147424936294556,
0.5003059506416321,
-0.29423093795776367,
0.3493116497993469,
0.030724845826625824,
-0.8053456544876099,
-0.25367605686187744,
-0.6921244263648987,
-0.5094797611236572,
1.1213669776916504,
0.29595237970352173,
0.5643422603607178,
0.06088755279779434,
0.8244367837905884,
0.3414230942726135,
0.3229977786540985,
-0.5132247805595398,
0.3696736991405487,
0.008398463949561119,
-0.2838246524333954,
-0.2097417116165161,
-0.8017765879631042,
-1.2193349599838257,
0.12488588690757751,
-0.13802464306354523,
-0.32284194231033325,
0.07191888988018036,
-0.1156497374176979,
-0.5185103416442871,
0.30929046869277954,
-0.3140813112258911,
1.0982767343521118,
-0.4102509021759033,
-0.6839802265167236,
-0.17452372610569,
-0.6691911220550537,
0.24442794919013977,
-0.587116539478302,
0.5272517204284668,
-0.14434392750263214,
-0.10387256741523743,
0.623737096786499,
-0.3548828363418579,
0.718701183795929,
-0.08511579036712646,
-0.6450693011283875,
0.08507504314184189,
0.09799192100763321,
0.4835602939128876,
0.44483375549316406,
-0.2933758795261383,
0.23651519417762756,
-0.2115810066461563,
-0.613516092300415,
-0.10999104380607605,
0.6696363687515259,
-0.5539491176605225,
-0.1020989641547203,
-0.20017069578170776,
-0.6291855573654175,
-0.3232128322124481,
0.33751484751701355,
0.34582415223121643,
0.8948674201965332,
-0.27857261896133423,
0.20347648859024048,
0.7818987965583801,
-1.069206953048706,
0.42478257417678833,
0.618433952331543,
-0.33307379484176636,
-0.6708983182907104,
0.9298170804977417,
-0.2638344168663025,
-0.04021194577217102,
0.447910338640213,
0.2924489974975586,
-0.5051466822624207,
-0.2780803143978119,
-0.7966524958610535,
0.21176031231880188,
-0.6171721816062927,
-0.49393537640571594,
-0.766086757183075,
0.23488600552082062,
-0.3559531569480896,
-0.3957190215587616,
-0.3605004549026489,
0.18044117093086243,
0.20536059141159058,
0.015473448671400547,
0.29054540395736694,
0.8102235794067383,
-0.4468856155872345,
-0.5853476524353027,
-1.3414212465286255,
0.47873663902282715,
0.36305108666419983,
0.5447657108306885,
-0.31208014488220215,
-0.2514764070510864,
-0.2158041149377823,
0.21745052933692932,
-0.0700620636343956,
-0.6308273077011108,
0.393874853849411,
0.13521833717823029,
0.8377748727798462,
0.40625235438346863,
0.47405806183815,
0.4979657828807831,
-0.6758954524993896,
0.5539101958274841,
0.41428375244140625,
-0.851674497127533,
0.29857978224754333,
-0.6923893094062805,
0.3765626549720764,
0.42801791429519653,
0.4609913229942322,
-0.7901264429092407,
-0.6650646924972534,
-0.3569355309009552,
-0.660315752029419,
0.48784926533699036,
0.1074656993150711,
0.20110666751861572,
-0.1898273229598999,
-0.1810598224401474,
0.5415555238723755,
0.15240250527858734,
-0.8579726219177246,
-0.06322824209928513,
-0.058881282806396484,
0.1440979689359665,
-0.03806234151124954,
-0.23159851133823395,
-0.06790038198232651,
-0.20842500030994415,
0.17880471050739288,
-0.3396286070346832,
0.1314544826745987,
0.01788058876991272,
-0.1236405074596405,
-0.23126013576984406,
0.4014836549758911,
0.8773451447486877,
0.5219932198524475,
-0.12695974111557007,
0.018661683425307274,
0.23100756108760834,
-0.34099504351615906,
-0.04670625925064087,
0.18427962064743042,
0.08210887014865875,
0.09138675034046173,
0.4364762306213379,
0.6173420548439026,
0.33983519673347473,
-0.9228588342666626,
0.5093898773193359,
-0.34239229559898376,
-0.21443511545658112,
0.0050192223861813545,
-0.4398830235004425,
-0.03933849185705185,
0.11561781167984009,
0.42737776041030884,
0.15229378640651703,
0.17728355526924133,
-0.36077502369880676,
0.5132704377174377,
0.23424001038074493,
-0.12603269517421722,
-0.41944757103919983,
0.8055030107498169,
0.6508702635765076,
-0.06015969067811966,
0.49718913435935974,
-0.5645864009857178,
-0.5299071669578552,
0.6417558193206787,
0.3672299385070801,
0.9875554442405701,
-0.17904755473136902,
0.2925136387348175,
0.7541214227676392,
0.4445110857486725,
0.16886718571186066,
0.45785292983055115,
-0.24631136655807495,
-0.4648348391056061,
-0.7232578992843628,
-0.7261914014816284,
-0.5097050666809082,
-0.05645213648676872,
-0.8025771379470825,
0.13354502618312836,
-0.15263745188713074,
0.0687803402543068,
-0.26266399025917053,
0.012653004378080368,
-0.5927661061286926,
-0.19255486130714417,
0.4708974063396454,
1.0227437019348145,
-0.7804341912269592,
0.718423068523407,
0.8822349905967712,
-0.29619041085243225,
-0.6398341655731201,
-0.23394392430782318,
-0.21524657309055328,
-0.7221704125404358,
0.7096843719482422,
0.31989848613739014,
-0.16319407522678375,
-0.24619121849536896,
-0.5063298344612122,
-0.4626177251338959,
0.5074618458747864,
0.6915526986122131,
-0.6992173790931702,
0.26534149050712585,
0.4777943193912506,
0.5846471190452576,
-0.2193189561367035,
0.17880061268806458,
0.302145391702652,
0.685351550579071,
-0.2719518542289734,
-1.0043871402740479,
-0.04064568504691124,
-0.6254775524139404,
0.0032318474259227514,
0.1444164514541626,
-0.34689727425575256,
0.7710778117179871,
-0.4498060345649719,
-0.11757519096136093,
0.001340921618975699,
0.40038833022117615,
0.4506273567676544,
0.34014683961868286,
0.32889145612716675,
0.4919298589229584,
0.8724495768547058,
0.06411571800708771,
1.0973972082138062,
-0.5600384473800659,
0.270681768655777,
0.7066159248352051,
-0.6598618030548096,
0.6548371315002441,
0.12531909346580505,
-0.13513337075710297,
0.28729429841041565,
0.46236443519592285,
0.040311381220817566,
0.19376936554908752,
0.29120466113090515,
-0.2841552197933197,
-0.4170863926410675,
-0.20222091674804688,
-0.8228054642677307,
0.1806906908750534,
0.10842400789260864,
0.08002348989248276,
-0.5194129347801208,
0.2395579218864441,
0.10931715369224548,
0.2386290282011032,
-0.26943764090538025,
0.6191257238388062,
-0.15912611782550812,
-0.647301435470581,
1.1031073331832886,
0.06634584814310074,
0.8583064079284668,
-0.7604038715362549,
-0.1743309050798416,
-0.6065875291824341,
-0.028016258031129837,
-0.07067710161209106,
-0.6746466755867004,
0.3070662319660187,
0.4484044909477234,
0.014966627582907677,
-0.4905729293823242,
0.25789645314216614,
-0.41492852568626404,
-0.5258691310882568,
0.6922522783279419,
0.4576994478702545,
0.0767650231719017,
-0.007693388964980841,
-0.7643020153045654,
0.38425856828689575,
0.2821459174156189,
-0.05688038840889931,
0.33325785398483276,
0.7986258268356323,
-0.2277960330247879,
0.5974206924438477,
0.8738741278648376,
-0.20575979351997375,
0.2404588758945465,
0.16526755690574646,
0.9354488253593445,
-0.670560359954834,
-0.4586130380630493,
-0.5672059655189514,
0.2988077402114868,
0.1502324938774109,
-0.5465951561927795,
0.7911439538002014,
0.8888501524925232,
0.9555051326751709,
-0.2897472083568573,
0.8229081630706787,
0.11372344940900803,
0.27920466661453247,
-0.33606043457984924,
0.6451196670532227,
-0.6705252528190613,
0.14666767418384552,
-0.36255893111228943,
-0.9172961711883545,
-0.4993848502635956,
0.3811301290988922,
-0.20713868737220764,
-0.1441991627216339,
0.5883775949478149,
0.7732267379760742,
0.16292773187160492,
-0.06961625069379807,
0.649276077747345,
-0.044725120067596436,
0.10478914529085159,
0.6824166178703308,
0.8676495552062988,
-0.24650493264198303,
0.9039506316184998,
-0.15482352674007416,
-0.27078959345817566,
-0.05240705981850624,
-0.962242066860199,
-0.8006125688552856,
-0.36976227164268494,
-0.3008697032928467,
-0.09567208588123322,
-0.023858454078435898,
1.0216790437698364,
0.4371837377548218,
-0.9201973676681519,
-0.35737329721450806,
-0.10161346197128296,
0.09525740146636963,
-0.09485341608524323,
-0.13032659888267517,
0.10460731387138367,
-0.575912594795227,
-0.859142541885376,
0.3606456518173218,
0.502553403377533,
-0.3034282922744751,
-0.1469375193119049,
-0.4751737713813782,
0.07516702264547348,
0.035922445356845856,
0.6609593033790588,
0.6322629451751709,
-0.5714329481124878,
0.07696675509214401,
0.19257275760173798,
-0.44599875807762146,
0.06087309867143631,
0.8122566342353821,
-0.723939061164856,
0.4682059586048126,
0.41622206568717957,
0.8706347942352295,
-0.19884668290615082,
-0.2548421025276184,
0.7577523589134216,
-0.7799726128578186,
0.18173518776893616,
0.31806454062461853,
0.4548380970954895,
0.28592967987060547,
-0.0627763494849205,
0.47329139709472656,
0.10958575457334518,
-0.5287860035896301,
-0.9608485102653503,
0.25615039467811584,
-0.9371967911720276,
0.04498342052102089,
1.2799588441848755,
-0.20683467388153076,
-0.10403182357549667,
-0.20474909245967865,
-0.21413831412792206,
-0.024520771577954292,
-0.5689530968666077,
0.3269509971141815,
0.17099697887897491,
0.31981587409973145,
0.004726385697722435,
-0.5559995770454407,
0.3994434177875519,
0.4532802999019623,
-0.9044816493988037,
0.3386090099811554,
0.7682927846908569,
0.12411749362945557,
0.09856735914945602,
0.5249500274658203,
-0.2796611487865448,
0.621107816696167,
0.044281575828790665,
0.48715341091156006,
0.04226607456803322,
-0.2694929838180542,
-0.5352184176445007,
0.021624645218253136,
-0.1705414354801178,
0.01792653650045395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16689v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16689v1
|
Adaptation of Biomedical and Clinical Pretrained Models to French Long Documents: A Comparative Study
| 2024-02-26T16:05:33 | 2024-02-26T16:05:33 |
Adrien Bazoge, Emmanuel Morin, Beatrice Daille, Pierre-Antoine Gourraud
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, pretrained language models based on BERT have been introduced for
the French biomedical domain. Although these models have achieved
state-of-the-art results on biomedical and clinical NLP tasks, they are
constrained by a limited input sequence length of 512 tokens, which poses
challenges when applied to clinical notes. In this paper, we present a
comparative study of three adaptation strategies for long-sequence models,
leveraging the Longformer architecture. We conducted evaluations of these
models on 16 downstream tasks spanning both biomedical and clinical domains.
Our findings reveal that further pre-training an English clinical model with
French biomedical texts can outperform both converting a French biomedical BERT
to the Longformer architecture and pre-training a French biomedical Longformer
from scratch. The results underscore that long-sequence French biomedical
models improve performance across most downstream tasks regardless of sequence
length, but BERT based models remain the most efficient for named entity
recognition tasks.
|
[
-0.0625736266374588,
-0.388820618391037,
1.0026206970214844,
0.3472501337528229,
-0.17335723340511322,
-0.08449544757604599,
-0.3217950761318207,
-0.9237640500068665,
0.15573303401470184,
0.6849855780601501,
-0.35448575019836426,
-0.3690595030784607,
-0.8347455859184265,
0.4070686101913452,
-0.09708679467439651,
1.1285291910171509,
-0.20452044904232025,
0.41928985714912415,
-0.36261314153671265,
-0.11864300817251205,
-0.33588719367980957,
-0.8120786547660828,
-0.7849602103233337,
-0.27934154868125916,
0.9310080409049988,
-0.35013264417648315,
0.278609037399292,
0.29640471935272217,
0.9126120209693909,
0.30154743790626526,
0.13696233928203583,
-0.041102174669504166,
-0.4670238792896271,
-0.0680944100022316,
-0.3901025056838989,
-0.370632141828537,
-0.7536365985870361,
-0.4577295184135437,
0.6627728343009949,
0.7453413009643555,
0.2575521171092987,
-0.2057846188545227,
0.0857388898730278,
0.8340332508087158,
-0.4314127564430237,
0.10231354087591171,
-0.1303693801164627,
-0.2352641224861145,
-0.12802831828594208,
-0.1271032840013504,
-0.6261016726493835,
-0.10498996078968048,
0.5420506596565247,
-0.6635849475860596,
0.26539042592048645,
-0.2847592830657959,
0.7626906633377075,
0.07073754817247391,
-0.29993778467178345,
-0.4844229817390442,
-0.6942344307899475,
0.6229899525642395,
-0.8257367014884949,
0.7136852741241455,
0.2951052188873291,
0.19772465527057648,
-0.3490549325942993,
-1.0453168153762817,
-0.13265736401081085,
-0.33501121401786804,
-0.04415207728743553,
0.17192623019218445,
-0.22907088696956635,
0.2899526357650757,
0.2165052741765976,
-0.2019163817167282,
-0.7417200803756714,
0.5711519122123718,
-0.7208840250968933,
-0.15268096327781677,
0.6162765622138977,
-0.4193635880947113,
0.07219310104846954,
-0.10891775041818619,
-0.41259413957595825,
-0.18746517598628998,
-0.6208153367042542,
0.06009211391210556,
-0.13960450887680054,
0.27537456154823303,
-0.046368155628442764,
0.28215718269348145,
0.06818468123674393,
0.5372762680053711,
-0.03645889833569527,
-0.04940352588891983,
0.3366072177886963,
-0.10245631635189056,
-0.2639314830303192,
0.07735496759414673,
0.7013619542121887,
0.06627730280160904,
0.43055155873298645,
-0.2727186381816864,
-0.23196770250797272,
-0.16845786571502686,
0.6213632225990295,
-0.8449220061302185,
-0.23833391070365906,
0.3471141755580902,
-0.7269797921180725,
0.12752924859523773,
-0.34869569540023804,
-0.6091247797012329,
-0.2029067426919937,
-0.3136477470397949,
0.6475830674171448,
-0.6840801239013672,
0.4178612530231476,
0.4837349057197571,
-0.04053708165884018,
0.2748601734638214,
0.6310765743255615,
-0.7222947478294373,
0.5479486584663391,
0.5419221520423889,
0.8351898789405823,
-0.4420362114906311,
-0.0876375138759613,
-0.45468366146087646,
0.004306468181312084,
-0.10527846962213516,
0.7753975987434387,
-0.20436522364616394,
-0.7066048979759216,
-0.03925143927335739,
0.4206632375717163,
-0.38288724422454834,
-0.48179614543914795,
0.6915628910064697,
-0.5339304208755493,
0.21721892058849335,
-0.16089408099651337,
-0.7112056016921997,
0.05390579625964165,
-0.14758096635341644,
-0.7433850169181824,
0.6335556507110596,
0.26651909947395325,
-0.46508777141571045,
0.32994550466537476,
-1.0155627727508545,
-0.6636338829994202,
0.09509596228599548,
-0.0804843083024025,
-0.5234044790267944,
0.2308938205242157,
0.38735082745552063,
0.7106491327285767,
-0.19954636693000793,
0.21360313892364502,
-0.3809494376182556,
-0.21714848279953003,
0.11579880118370056,
-0.08172748237848282,
0.7115110754966736,
-0.0030963749159127474,
-0.10908038169145584,
0.09761546552181244,
-0.9368551969528198,
-0.15094448626041412,
0.13692091405391693,
-0.23283907771110535,
-0.40498489141464233,
0.1523706465959549,
0.2187555730342865,
0.1554933339357376,
-0.1123262345790863,
-0.6225804090499878,
0.23790481686592102,
-0.4357655346393585,
0.7815148234367371,
0.450320303440094,
-0.06513029336929321,
0.30988848209381104,
-0.44626036286354065,
0.39777010679244995,
-0.07224726676940918,
0.002608978422358632,
-0.1853218823671341,
-0.1842886209487915,
-0.5723176598548889,
-0.6701196432113647,
0.6400251984596252,
0.7146041989326477,
-0.4514213502407074,
0.5484505295753479,
-0.6488710045814514,
-0.4101063311100006,
-0.5402491092681885,
-0.09535933285951614,
0.23571376502513885,
0.4737838804721832,
0.7592812180519104,
-0.7560852766036987,
-0.18493309617042542,
-0.8801719546318054,
-0.052995115518569946,
-0.06452016532421112,
-0.06482728570699692,
0.35661637783050537,
0.8413506746292114,
-0.36417001485824585,
0.4505403935909271,
-0.17264364659786224,
-0.14221321046352386,
-0.1630956381559372,
0.09105955809354782,
0.361501544713974,
0.6744410991668701,
0.9076918959617615,
-0.5068089962005615,
-0.12119892984628677,
-0.1069747731089592,
-0.511760950088501,
0.12553825974464417,
-0.30330246686935425,
-0.08697851002216339,
0.024140911176800728,
0.6151614189147949,
-0.6816210150718689,
0.6170789003372192,
0.4608035981655121,
-0.0009739231318235397,
0.4407378137111664,
-0.5378548502922058,
-0.0017904540291056037,
-1.124537467956543,
0.14487920701503754,
-0.14948461949825287,
-0.7055379748344421,
-0.747146725654602,
-0.2593890130519867,
0.28093430399894714,
-0.22425386309623718,
-0.4547947943210602,
0.7775929570198059,
-0.5030418634414673,
0.16898927092552185,
-0.11542478203773499,
-0.2559727728366852,
0.21264733374118805,
0.1958920955657959,
0.5904351472854614,
0.4330920875072479,
0.5058140158653259,
-0.6355200409889221,
0.10259123146533966,
0.446469247341156,
-0.4844149947166443,
0.11098936200141907,
-0.9083361625671387,
0.25919362902641296,
-0.2723628878593445,
0.5563887357711792,
-0.6849384307861328,
-0.1524820625782013,
-0.2044881135225296,
-0.31107375025749207,
0.7303726077079773,
-0.08982419222593307,
-0.20640069246292114,
-0.6149685978889465,
-0.024454686790704727,
0.4867943823337555,
0.7156746983528137,
-0.3459583818912506,
0.3027629554271698,
-0.24489471316337585,
-0.6865352988243103,
-0.39590469002723694,
-0.7682943344116211,
-0.06247016787528992,
-0.10114612430334091,
-0.47616082429885864,
0.6270114183425903,
0.08898082375526428,
0.3382313549518585,
-0.27490586042404175,
0.05478087067604065,
-0.13714052736759186,
0.0597224235534668,
0.16647198796272278,
0.34885329008102417,
-0.6355875730514526,
0.49720823764801025,
0.12980355322360992,
0.08113345503807068,
0.037336792796850204,
-0.40010878443717957,
0.23637208342552185,
0.36443114280700684,
-0.48404476046562195,
-0.4369890093803406,
0.6217254400253296,
0.5902665853500366,
-0.3544727861881256,
0.8969544172286987,
0.36057278513908386,
-0.3886597454547882,
-0.10372795164585114,
-0.6218851804733276,
-0.21344223618507385,
-0.3917445242404938,
0.8338183164596558,
-0.24748821556568146,
-0.8648115396499634,
0.3286121189594269,
-0.3478599190711975,
-0.10300015658140182,
0.47099408507347107,
0.5071789622306824,
-0.37553849816322327,
0.5474081635475159,
0.8412683606147766,
0.025898391380906105,
0.3624551296234131,
-0.035019345581531525,
0.3093215525150299,
-0.5701584219932556,
0.06643827259540558,
-0.5988513231277466,
-0.14142411947250366,
-0.537541925907135,
-0.6123148798942566,
0.37977418303489685,
0.15415246784687042,
-0.15587417781352997,
0.2732667326927185,
-0.2852350175380707,
0.06456796079874039,
0.27692773938179016,
0.5486935377120972,
-0.09054555743932724,
-0.08936525136232376,
0.08038868755102158,
0.10730352252721786,
-0.7863116264343262,
-0.6256440877914429,
1.2211096286773682,
0.5972005128860474,
0.5438452363014221,
0.0012788664316758513,
0.9880969524383545,
0.17101261019706726,
0.4593171179294586,
-0.7441530227661133,
0.1099037453532219,
-0.5207410454750061,
-0.5273629426956177,
-0.3143802583217621,
-0.010315613821148872,
-1.1067031621932983,
-0.3469327986240387,
-0.38068825006484985,
-0.7120397090911865,
0.5605655312538147,
0.03915239870548248,
-0.7207451462745667,
0.03201119229197502,
-0.5056530237197876,
1.0977683067321777,
-0.6137845516204834,
-0.23863354325294495,
0.0822618305683136,
-0.7925639748573303,
-0.1699819713830948,
-0.7316405773162842,
0.2557179629802704,
0.07697036117315292,
0.06309407204389572,
0.8330137133598328,
-0.23766884207725525,
0.775793731212616,
-0.08174238353967667,
-0.006902812048792839,
-0.06429876387119293,
-0.25994327664375305,
0.4128909111022949,
-0.03555479273200035,
-0.12030938267707825,
0.15751709043979645,
0.41924965381622314,
-0.7920309901237488,
-0.4358021318912506,
0.37137842178344727,
-0.9111291170120239,
-0.5770358443260193,
-0.3686460852622986,
-0.2974949777126312,
-0.4436822533607483,
0.44261977076530457,
0.5479414463043213,
0.623423159122467,
-0.6314705014228821,
0.16982296109199524,
0.5817123651504517,
-0.6161906123161316,
0.44183462858200073,
0.4531105160713196,
-0.05014467611908913,
-0.10043314099311829,
0.28274115920066833,
-0.28468865156173706,
0.4541494846343994,
0.7418983578681946,
-0.1795620620250702,
-0.3392811119556427,
-1.0015980005264282,
-0.2532297372817993,
0.6379151344299316,
-0.5765083432197571,
0.015954531729221344,
-0.724132239818573,
-0.4342103898525238,
-0.7549030184745789,
-0.40666645765304565,
-0.40969130396842957,
-0.333679735660553,
-0.4661281108856201,
0.09424281120300293,
0.31068155169487,
0.5697418451309204,
0.10389240086078644,
0.29401007294654846,
-1.2934517860412598,
0.30597299337387085,
0.16745933890342712,
0.30209678411483765,
-0.4151986837387085,
-0.6704708337783813,
-0.2963002324104309,
-0.11472877860069275,
-0.015137054026126862,
-0.9634777903556824,
0.29185229539871216,
0.488543301820755,
0.45607247948646545,
0.2123371809720993,
-0.26515939831733704,
0.7232204079627991,
-1.10015070438385,
0.46974608302116394,
0.17524965107440948,
-0.6930014491081238,
0.5507716536521912,
-0.26351094245910645,
0.1660064309835434,
0.6540284752845764,
0.8507869839668274,
-0.16377006471157074,
0.19943967461585999,
-0.3243728578090668,
-0.6200277209281921,
0.334348201751709,
0.09733618050813675,
0.18272235989570618,
-0.04880722612142563,
0.6189925670623779,
0.36588332056999207,
-0.09432747960090637,
-0.5854795575141907,
0.269265741109848,
-0.038465727120637894,
-0.3009192943572998,
-0.5802709460258484,
-0.2017204612493515,
-0.10492132604122162,
-0.18832682073116302,
0.4383440613746643,
-0.08497519791126251,
0.6795515418052673,
0.8442780375480652,
-0.38322633504867554,
0.34941962361335754,
0.4317249059677124,
0.6116635799407959,
0.7950034141540527,
-0.3034719228744507,
-0.4686656892299652,
0.033281609416007996,
-0.5863255262374878,
0.03758646920323372,
0.63128662109375,
0.2165217250585556,
0.28686654567718506,
0.9589008688926697,
1.0580980777740479,
0.2821241617202759,
-0.7114065289497375,
0.550963819026947,
0.10907130688428879,
-0.32311221957206726,
-0.16662226617336273,
-0.20916081964969635,
0.13264617323875427,
0.1985383778810501,
-0.19977401196956635,
-0.06596726179122925,
0.12569473683834076,
-0.49300622940063477,
0.25812554359436035,
0.1466369479894638,
-0.39402103424072266,
-0.3615714907646179,
0.7152323126792908,
0.30989688634872437,
-0.1812625676393509,
0.5553404688835144,
0.367921382188797,
-0.27548182010650635,
0.5096734762191772,
0.7291570901870728,
0.789452850818634,
-0.256515771150589,
-0.035260848701000214,
0.14697769284248352,
-0.0803394764661789,
-0.2786619961261749,
0.09932255744934082,
-0.029754988849163055,
-0.6033097505569458,
-0.7415462732315063,
-0.8442933559417725,
-0.0723995566368103,
0.17405292391777039,
-0.9139400720596313,
0.4309987723827362,
-0.27723562717437744,
-0.4355196952819824,
0.5572076439857483,
-0.3498312532901764,
-1.0110405683517456,
0.38855689764022827,
0.3422568142414093,
1.217401385307312,
-0.5911267399787903,
1.1366842985153198,
0.7975449562072754,
-0.07190641015768051,
-0.3977471590042114,
-0.47541844844818115,
-0.3904935419559479,
-0.8016971945762634,
0.8669077754020691,
-0.002682776190340519,
0.2024117112159729,
-0.12022162973880768,
-0.1371283233165741,
-0.722528338432312,
0.799212634563446,
0.11471062898635864,
-1.0434234142303467,
-0.6516495943069458,
0.2307998090982437,
0.8197004199028015,
-0.2729644179344177,
0.032898351550102234,
0.4048766493797302,
0.08590979129076004,
-0.24591614305973053,
-1.4065577983856201,
-0.19590073823928833,
-0.1349303275346756,
-0.18418852984905243,
0.24269703030586243,
-0.324622243642807,
0.44032204151153564,
-0.2970229983329773,
0.21027922630310059,
0.5354130268096924,
0.5436252951622009,
0.07241221517324448,
0.2634448707103729,
0.30991655588150024,
0.22000128030776978,
0.7021182179450989,
0.07532509416341782,
1.1378518342971802,
-0.2791459858417511,
0.1004081517457962,
1.0425735712051392,
-0.6207954287528992,
0.9427194595336914,
0.30517780780792236,
-0.4410492181777954,
0.6973457932472229,
0.5342870354652405,
0.07855115830898285,
0.4870850741863251,
0.23491884768009186,
-0.17982858419418335,
-0.19088047742843628,
0.30055108666419983,
-0.5440331697463989,
0.5059905052185059,
0.48813581466674805,
-0.7441453337669373,
0.09755181521177292,
0.3311513662338257,
0.011115441098809242,
-0.12184902280569077,
-0.35448071360588074,
0.836227297782898,
0.40001899003982544,
-0.6328200697898865,
0.6047260761260986,
-0.16596128046512604,
0.2734087407588959,
-0.8487259745597839,
0.15795032680034637,
0.1141190305352211,
0.3965910077095032,
0.10040219873189926,
-0.17840883135795593,
-0.07340801507234573,
0.0016822207253426313,
-0.29697173833847046,
-0.2542308568954468,
0.8779929280281067,
-0.09665759652853012,
-0.7016087770462036,
0.4676724970340729,
0.5815370678901672,
0.09757525473833084,
0.0040756706148386,
-0.7872380614280701,
-0.25120657682418823,
-0.26537925004959106,
-0.21254976093769073,
0.45865634083747864,
0.38653260469436646,
-0.28822678327560425,
0.368233323097229,
0.5511538982391357,
0.43005186319351196,
0.0343223474919796,
0.11277386546134949,
0.8076245784759521,
-0.8783968687057495,
-0.4648226201534271,
-0.7125549912452698,
0.2525416910648346,
0.01159731112420559,
-0.0897790938615799,
0.24032631516456604,
0.43882283568382263,
0.6265959143638611,
-0.44419845938682556,
0.7470221519470215,
0.40572455525398254,
0.7467635273933411,
-0.7395582795143127,
0.626914918422699,
-0.529808521270752,
-0.0691419243812561,
-0.22765181958675385,
-0.8133889436721802,
-0.4045056700706482,
0.5137085318565369,
-0.39690902829170227,
0.1280391812324524,
0.882307767868042,
0.434160977602005,
-0.21597464382648468,
-0.08021978288888931,
0.17563015222549438,
0.2706054747104645,
0.3942761719226837,
0.9668855667114258,
0.47573569416999817,
-0.3118559718132019,
-0.1959022730588913,
-0.15476426482200623,
-0.16858914494514465,
-0.14334219694137573,
-1.1176588535308838,
-1.0739216804504395,
-0.3708474040031433,
-0.23104368150234222,
-0.4120390713214874,
0.5009369850158691,
0.8787778615951538,
0.8330417275428772,
-1.071774959564209,
0.15596088767051697,
0.26428094506263733,
-0.5194823741912842,
0.05768582597374916,
-0.061339233070611954,
0.8072225451469421,
-0.2761199474334717,
-0.523958146572113,
0.5185359716415405,
0.4701576232910156,
0.3449449837207794,
0.30965495109558105,
0.11715663969516754,
-0.09118739515542984,
0.27306655049324036,
0.7270346283912659,
0.5728856921195984,
-0.5683534741401672,
-0.3057350218296051,
0.21186354756355286,
-0.18853759765625,
0.23031990230083466,
0.9893388152122498,
-0.8933553695678711,
0.5196980834007263,
0.2245168387889862,
0.902525782585144,
0.6444950699806213,
-0.12447268515825272,
0.6832335591316223,
-0.29301539063453674,
0.2661072611808777,
0.5830166339874268,
0.4656642973423004,
0.23763759434223175,
-0.18448248505592346,
0.3814759850502014,
0.1039755716919899,
-0.7929326891899109,
-0.74327152967453,
-0.06899304687976837,
-1.2525688409805298,
-0.3794713318347931,
0.8696196675300598,
-0.37530362606048584,
-0.24579006433486938,
-0.08463679999113083,
-0.11008752882480621,
0.34813544154167175,
0.08913722634315491,
0.619479238986969,
0.6458497643470764,
-0.30900999903678894,
0.23812249302864075,
-0.800980806350708,
0.7500287890434265,
0.5807241797447205,
-0.8475961089134216,
-0.42227602005004883,
0.1498962938785553,
0.21248047053813934,
0.09898710995912552,
0.8245556950569153,
-0.3016110062599182,
0.4916350245475769,
-0.44415193796157837,
0.10507982969284058,
0.3141368329524994,
-0.24741055071353912,
-0.40446004271507263,
-0.28940728306770325,
0.01295259315520525,
0.11468949168920517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16671v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16671v6
|
StructLM: Towards Building Generalist Models for Structured Knowledge Grounding
| 2024-02-26T15:47:01 | 2024-04-24T21:13:24 |
Alex Zhuang, Ge Zhang, Tianyu Zheng, Xinrun Du, Junjie Wang, Weiming Ren, Stephen W. Huang, Jie Fu, Xiang Yue, Wenhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Structured data sources, such as tables, graphs, and databases, are
ubiquitous knowledge sources. Despite the demonstrated capabilities of large
language models (LLMs) on plain text, their proficiency in interpreting and
utilizing structured data remains limited. Our investigation reveals a notable
deficiency in LLMs' ability to process structured data, e.g., ChatGPT lags
behind state-of-the-art (SoTA) model by an average of 35%. To augment the
Structured Knowledge Grounding (SKG) capabilities in LLMs, we have developed a
comprehensive instruction tuning dataset comprising 1.1 million examples.
Utilizing this dataset, we train a series of models, referred to as StructLM,
based on the Mistral and the CodeLlama model family, ranging from 7B to 34B
parameters. Our StructLM series surpasses task-specific models on 16 out of 18
evaluated datasets and establishes new SoTA performance on 8 SKG tasks.
Furthermore, StructLM demonstrates strong generalization across 6 novel
held-out SKG tasks, outperforming TableLlama by an average of 35\% and Flan-UL2
20B by an average of 10\%. Contrary to expectations, we observe that scaling
model size offers marginal benefits, with StructLM-34B showing only slight
improvements over StructLM-7B. This suggests that structured knowledge
grounding is still a challenging task and requires more innovative design to
push to a new level.
|
[
0.0871153324842453,
-1.048194408416748,
0.6412531137466431,
0.20610280334949493,
-0.23083285987377167,
0.0493917390704155,
-0.15662170946598053,
-0.22232434153556824,
-0.2636328637599945,
0.44628509879112244,
-0.3583093583583832,
-0.9787241816520691,
-0.47617509961128235,
-0.461916446685791,
-0.3165043592453003,
1.1511152982711792,
-0.025357555598020554,
0.23026160895824432,
-0.4748859107494354,
0.052597496658563614,
-0.6101167798042297,
-0.7478090524673462,
-0.3797314465045929,
-0.48008662462234497,
0.17425905168056488,
0.37379908561706543,
0.6678370237350464,
0.9859344959259033,
0.33508431911468506,
0.14903973042964935,
-0.285137414932251,
0.21505200862884521,
-0.8019247651100159,
-0.05416804179549217,
-0.18062877655029297,
-0.46581000089645386,
-0.7219845056533813,
-0.15777622163295746,
0.6315401196479797,
1.006035327911377,
-0.460612952709198,
0.10219193994998932,
0.2544098198413849,
0.7762618064880371,
-0.06413637101650238,
0.39858925342559814,
-0.5470041036605835,
0.001794097595848143,
-0.1078307256102562,
-0.12296696752309799,
-0.556979238986969,
-0.29798784852027893,
-0.13419167697429657,
-0.6074000597000122,
0.3451487421989441,
0.2610943615436554,
0.7548665404319763,
0.4704868793487549,
-0.4096614718437195,
-0.3814588189125061,
-0.5121628642082214,
0.5111322402954102,
-0.7765564322471619,
0.6183270215988159,
0.3568083643913269,
0.13470710813999176,
-0.6303671598434448,
-0.9169183373451233,
0.1086629256606102,
-0.47318223118782043,
-0.03837144374847412,
-0.08436625450849533,
0.21096743643283844,
0.41405391693115234,
0.5440592765808105,
0.4942593276500702,
-0.6450884342193604,
-0.001156270271167159,
-0.6482029557228088,
-0.009901399724185467,
0.5098337531089783,
0.34560829401016235,
0.2743166387081146,
-0.026570336893200874,
-0.4136849045753479,
0.19204306602478027,
-0.9219760894775391,
0.25010108947753906,
0.31403443217277527,
0.20744745433330536,
-0.12411957234144211,
0.4819996654987335,
-0.27041107416152954,
0.9896275401115417,
-0.05014108121395111,
-0.0951230600476265,
-0.0016199733363464475,
-0.09661731868982315,
-0.6298679113388062,
-0.11984335631132126,
0.35706639289855957,
0.20068463683128357,
0.17378897964954376,
-0.4113542139530182,
0.021439306437969208,
0.20279791951179504,
0.5029695630073547,
-0.6920394897460938,
-0.6476056575775146,
-0.09693107008934021,
-0.4481799304485321,
-0.3742881119251251,
0.03667375445365906,
-0.36381766200065613,
-0.24109458923339844,
-0.6193756461143494,
0.22090576589107513,
-0.5341746211051941,
-0.14659257233142853,
0.19220717251300812,
-0.1779070943593979,
0.1178964152932167,
0.42940956354141235,
-0.7716579437255859,
0.2289775013923645,
0.5855125188827515,
0.6775394678115845,
-0.14068561792373657,
-0.024468472227454185,
-0.13869649171829224,
0.36978891491889954,
-0.6244505643844604,
0.9284827709197998,
-0.7689253687858582,
-0.4681681990623474,
-0.18963471055030823,
-0.11300434917211533,
-0.2662850618362427,
-0.47065427899360657,
0.5229746103286743,
-0.4465535581111908,
0.07486478239297867,
-0.19932349026203156,
-0.6348133087158203,
-0.09529425948858261,
0.3127239942550659,
-0.458173930644989,
1.3713963031768799,
0.37944892048835754,
-0.7292235493659973,
0.42398375272750854,
-0.49795278906822205,
-0.4583124816417694,
0.11351848393678665,
-0.6072529554367065,
-0.07186444848775864,
0.4185206890106201,
-0.13655531406402588,
0.4303900897502899,
-0.34398236870765686,
0.7791171073913574,
-0.3005101978778839,
-0.6048589944839478,
-0.3680834174156189,
-0.05330142378807068,
0.49215006828308105,
0.2121960073709488,
-0.2555752992630005,
0.31185731291770935,
-0.9020153284072876,
0.3579704463481903,
-0.12324544042348862,
-0.9101430177688599,
-0.3955298364162445,
0.37970104813575745,
-0.2878064513206482,
0.22595317661762238,
0.15897783637046814,
-0.012198329903185368,
0.6259345412254333,
-0.48547741770744324,
0.5781233906745911,
0.8314096927642822,
-0.1764860898256302,
0.4400576949119568,
-0.2526875436306,
0.39080265164375305,
0.029911458492279053,
-0.011775042861700058,
0.12138985097408295,
-0.42137253284454346,
-0.6682815551757812,
-0.270364910364151,
0.14164958894252777,
0.3355743885040283,
-0.6398589611053467,
0.1512589007616043,
-0.4138454794883728,
-0.5963221788406372,
-0.3867568075656891,
0.2593021094799042,
0.4519365727901459,
0.7279078960418701,
0.5102158188819885,
0.1682092249393463,
-0.6185972690582275,
-1.104198932647705,
-0.29580602049827576,
-0.1804370880126953,
-0.3509574234485626,
0.4059188663959503,
0.29911771416664124,
-0.2536114454269409,
0.9822363257408142,
-0.5151207447052002,
-0.081502765417099,
-0.1779637485742569,
-0.030355121940374374,
0.4913099706172943,
0.4926716387271881,
0.2574467658996582,
-0.7836554050445557,
-0.38324442505836487,
0.01607474312186241,
-1.041996955871582,
-0.08593152463436127,
0.29554253816604614,
-0.15295696258544922,
0.17779812216758728,
0.6507409811019897,
-0.48266905546188354,
0.47631266713142395,
0.4401824176311493,
-0.5518511533737183,
0.7464686632156372,
-0.14233949780464172,
0.006260327994823456,
-0.8935751914978027,
-0.007700752466917038,
-0.33920562267303467,
-0.10197380185127258,
-0.96771240234375,
0.2725220322608948,
0.3019464612007141,
-0.049680184572935104,
-0.3490299880504608,
0.2978399395942688,
-0.42136815190315247,
-0.007297031581401825,
-0.0629652813076973,
-0.21492907404899597,
0.006145245395600796,
0.7615545988082886,
0.046666912734508514,
0.7484614253044128,
0.4506010413169861,
-0.7783617973327637,
0.10922204703092575,
0.18054373562335968,
-0.39363938570022583,
0.3385690450668335,
-0.9527361392974854,
0.27163660526275635,
-0.054382048547267914,
0.11011853069067001,
-0.9737393856048584,
-0.21089300513267517,
0.1864393800497055,
-0.20269836485385895,
0.35340195894241333,
-0.4405834376811981,
-0.39983898401260376,
-0.23848167061805725,
0.007823792286217213,
0.16492651402950287,
0.40764957666397095,
-0.3083850145339966,
0.8339362144470215,
0.2282497137784958,
-0.1335453987121582,
-0.3433133661746979,
-0.5704011917114258,
-0.016203653067350388,
-0.21839582920074463,
-1.039458155632019,
0.2938671112060547,
-0.1752341389656067,
-0.2505107522010803,
0.025794394314289093,
-0.6899442076683044,
-0.08274950832128525,
0.22845153510570526,
0.44942113757133484,
0.3431973159313202,
-0.43293145298957825,
0.3633759319782257,
-0.020643560215830803,
0.1331070065498352,
0.028520852327346802,
-0.5958516597747803,
0.6342818737030029,
-0.31447160243988037,
-0.2540707290172577,
0.2029528170824051,
0.18524925410747528,
0.3470708727836609,
0.13459216058254242,
0.780512273311615,
0.10114962607622147,
-0.36896607279777527,
-0.43500351905822754,
-0.4006804823875427,
0.059350062161684036,
-0.48965197801589966,
0.39930057525634766,
-0.5590877532958984,
-1.0455048084259033,
0.37304627895355225,
-0.0364866741001606,
0.0945342406630516,
0.3854106366634369,
0.4481298327445984,
-0.22320953011512756,
0.9508978724479675,
0.7534245848655701,
0.05422213673591614,
0.29502514004707336,
-0.2236257642507553,
0.11425603926181793,
-0.6847490072250366,
-0.4170414209365845,
-0.4236162602901459,
-0.2503027021884918,
-0.22450006008148193,
-0.4939749836921692,
0.24557900428771973,
0.5425116419792175,
-0.2754432260990143,
0.16374917328357697,
-0.6706129312515259,
0.3242246210575104,
0.49480822682380676,
0.20860934257507324,
0.3154968321323395,
0.20781210064888,
-0.370735764503479,
0.07987307012081146,
-1.0403857231140137,
-0.7285263538360596,
1.1027816534042358,
0.3442884385585785,
1.0871285200119019,
-0.25098681449890137,
0.2834576368331909,
0.4034731686115265,
0.3918869197368622,
-0.6413040161132812,
0.4633893668651581,
-0.12631690502166748,
-0.5431281328201294,
-0.24384324252605438,
-0.6009877920150757,
-0.46891331672668457,
0.2800541818141937,
0.139600932598114,
-0.4851594567298889,
0.04601459205150604,
0.3093491196632385,
-0.08259314298629761,
0.2684185802936554,
-0.7437061071395874,
0.9127954244613647,
-0.10901755839586258,
-0.34370550513267517,
-0.11037781089544296,
-0.4983125627040863,
0.44437602162361145,
0.17536123096942902,
0.3395363688468933,
-0.022093025967478752,
0.2640887498855591,
0.9572507739067078,
-0.21964070200920105,
0.7586626410484314,
-0.4790031611919403,
-0.2936127781867981,
0.040960609912872314,
-0.06048880144953728,
0.6895291209220886,
-0.009525428526103497,
-0.2110566347837448,
0.3990201950073242,
-0.04300650954246521,
-0.48863887786865234,
-0.5506405830383301,
0.520326554775238,
-0.7455599308013916,
-0.869202196598053,
-0.07850407063961029,
-0.8603485822677612,
-0.34099653363227844,
0.07741410285234451,
0.34735241532325745,
0.5407434105873108,
-0.21596671640872955,
0.6017838716506958,
0.9310910105705261,
0.048822253942489624,
-0.12431902438402176,
0.4866544306278229,
0.03984633460640907,
-0.2697563171386719,
0.6345213055610657,
0.4357609748840332,
0.21587374806404114,
0.21156099438667297,
0.030220113694667816,
-0.23818685114383698,
-0.922065019607544,
-0.3812909722328186,
-0.08761337399482727,
-0.7353214621543884,
-0.29826778173446655,
-0.6859560012817383,
-0.3999142050743103,
-0.5306743383407593,
-0.3121284246444702,
0.0033402866683900356,
-0.39803647994995117,
-0.26270654797554016,
-0.39482396841049194,
0.1007980927824974,
0.9808476567268372,
0.34144920110702515,
0.5170875787734985,
-0.4876004755496979,
0.36760425567626953,
0.1760476976633072,
0.48551860451698303,
-0.14471566677093506,
-0.7218818664550781,
-0.41636204719543457,
0.2633337378501892,
-0.044186532497406006,
-0.8046312928199768,
0.09041207283735275,
0.3212728202342987,
0.8386878967285156,
0.37139683961868286,
-0.030129071325063705,
0.919909656047821,
-0.7285202145576477,
0.5954809784889221,
-0.1535545140504837,
-0.7408645749092102,
0.6693361401557922,
-0.6212719678878784,
-0.14960193634033203,
0.4149852693080902,
0.18912935256958008,
-0.44321438670158386,
-0.49264946579933167,
-0.7918952107429504,
-0.9492702484130859,
0.7888060212135315,
-0.08920912444591522,
-0.14013879001140594,
0.15074940025806427,
0.5261489152908325,
-0.056653935462236404,
0.463849276304245,
-0.6495383977890015,
-0.07754510641098022,
-0.4334658086299896,
-0.4189346134662628,
0.05223652347922325,
-0.5390758514404297,
-0.22763605415821075,
-0.19173379242420197,
0.5202288627624512,
-0.14238032698631287,
0.15198425948619843,
0.04748521000146866,
-0.5248749852180481,
0.11246698349714279,
0.45285388827323914,
0.677362859249115,
0.8559798002243042,
-0.29535719752311707,
0.3434355556964874,
0.3140823543071747,
-0.4461139738559723,
0.23031672835350037,
-0.1326376348733902,
-0.36173638701438904,
-0.283609539270401,
0.4231996536254883,
0.8536238670349121,
0.6629298329353333,
-0.4053961932659149,
0.03257322311401367,
0.28787875175476074,
-0.4757617712020874,
-0.13046663999557495,
0.5312028527259827,
0.25939956307411194,
0.18196535110473633,
0.5472307801246643,
-0.1458350270986557,
-0.04867028445005417,
-0.36210551857948303,
0.2312604784965515,
0.3243170380592346,
-0.26627737283706665,
-0.32236433029174805,
0.6522363424301147,
-0.06621053069829941,
-0.2711476981639862,
0.5308414697647095,
0.05904017388820648,
-0.43376579880714417,
0.6401804089546204,
0.8510738611221313,
0.28413739800453186,
-0.30279773473739624,
0.021790169179439545,
0.11945751309394836,
0.5524354577064514,
-0.3192239999771118,
0.27094459533691406,
-0.047906599938869476,
-0.5007383227348328,
-0.25543439388275146,
-0.8927003145217896,
-0.27513182163238525,
0.1475340723991394,
-0.7657588124275208,
0.15423429012298584,
-0.794359028339386,
0.22855204343795776,
-0.4928770363330841,
0.22367292642593384,
-0.7184164524078369,
0.27025142312049866,
-0.24581551551818848,
1.2463232278823853,
-0.987954318523407,
1.0774388313293457,
0.9712328314781189,
-0.21754716336727142,
-0.9808326363563538,
-0.4598180055618286,
-0.17876936495304108,
-0.9206798672676086,
0.856228768825531,
0.10070434212684631,
0.08368147164583206,
0.353880375623703,
-0.764885425567627,
-0.7662073373794556,
1.155608892440796,
0.42167744040489197,
-0.5629012584686279,
-0.671018123626709,
0.11478473246097565,
0.5351118445396423,
-0.5024573802947998,
-0.16030541062355042,
0.6808503866195679,
0.4936540722846985,
0.16345739364624023,
-0.4106588065624237,
0.08347634226083755,
-0.45279398560523987,
0.13141405582427979,
0.05956554785370827,
-0.36150676012039185,
0.9397742748260498,
0.1733630746603012,
-0.44796136021614075,
-0.31563085317611694,
0.5758731961250305,
0.6103259921073914,
0.22670510411262512,
0.35071638226509094,
0.8339380025863647,
0.9621022343635559,
-0.14261065423488617,
0.8002322912216187,
-0.24760718643665314,
0.09699900448322296,
1.2915239334106445,
-0.23342755436897278,
0.6525086164474487,
0.3110067546367645,
-0.1601783186197281,
0.7137588262557983,
0.6876650452613831,
-0.1902776062488556,
0.43262866139411926,
0.27941152453422546,
0.14838813245296478,
-0.4121045172214508,
0.19366104900836945,
-0.6434361338615417,
0.04288255795836449,
0.6207078695297241,
-0.24720260500907898,
-0.2918028235435486,
-0.09801699221134186,
-0.007478018291294575,
-0.02454967051744461,
-0.5334600210189819,
0.7851821780204773,
0.07617311179637909,
-0.31329038739204407,
0.6032364964485168,
0.028060195967555046,
0.4757396876811981,
-0.8309240341186523,
-0.12265080958604813,
-0.38317063450813293,
0.015483573079109192,
-0.34882137179374695,
-0.3222561180591583,
0.32143524289131165,
-0.0019219964742660522,
-0.49824175238609314,
-0.3087153136730194,
1.0571733713150024,
-0.49971163272857666,
-0.4295172691345215,
0.22183144092559814,
0.2753429710865021,
0.11978121101856232,
-0.11008873581886292,
-0.35940244793891907,
0.0008484172285534441,
0.06162805110216141,
-0.30912309885025024,
0.34240642189979553,
0.42019185423851013,
-0.2657289505004883,
0.6226879358291626,
0.8609680533409119,
0.2387406975030899,
0.16329358518123627,
-0.15399372577667236,
1.213687777519226,
-0.8856166005134583,
-0.7062320709228516,
-0.8521447777748108,
0.6439579725265503,
-0.039528850466012955,
0.03967698663473129,
0.8934035897254944,
0.5794556140899658,
0.6699849367141724,
-0.0515386238694191,
0.7969759702682495,
-0.164112389087677,
0.3291099965572357,
-0.8093938231468201,
0.7661015391349792,
-0.3774177134037018,
0.2906951308250427,
-0.024606261402368546,
-0.8248622417449951,
-0.10637935250997543,
0.7362744808197021,
-0.4197193682193756,
-0.18113140761852264,
0.6350314021110535,
0.7317056059837341,
-0.07668333500623703,
-0.03665829077363014,
0.5254731178283691,
0.4859512746334076,
0.5227789282798767,
0.6208108067512512,
1.0083922147750854,
-0.24316376447677612,
0.5599770545959473,
0.3440006375312805,
-0.3376678228378296,
-0.40120983123779297,
-0.7428767085075378,
-1.2077126502990723,
-0.24876901507377625,
0.050603028386831284,
-0.19989550113677979,
0.21550209820270538,
0.6758838891983032,
0.8294321894645691,
-0.7904371023178101,
-0.1116437315940857,
-0.28310132026672363,
0.31851890683174133,
-0.08032295852899551,
-0.23210270702838898,
0.45013949275016785,
-0.6432557106018066,
-0.1540461629629135,
0.8768547773361206,
0.27575942873954773,
-0.028378954157233238,
0.010861232876777649,
-0.16080957651138306,
-0.015192694962024689,
-0.07787226140499115,
0.6077325344085693,
0.038986895233392715,
-0.5715066194534302,
-0.4285881221294403,
0.12226111441850662,
-0.32593220472335815,
0.16549229621887207,
0.9145715236663818,
-0.7238379716873169,
-0.15928667783737183,
0.4260790944099426,
0.4683927595615387,
0.37859654426574707,
0.2925947904586792,
0.6160932183265686,
-0.9326739311218262,
0.11562933027744293,
0.10529863089323044,
0.3456544578075409,
0.0692686066031456,
-0.38201791048049927,
0.7390908002853394,
0.39531373977661133,
-0.6301522850990295,
-1.0061397552490234,
0.19461767375469208,
-0.5534974932670593,
-0.3289548456668854,
1.1329128742218018,
-0.14495933055877686,
-0.2562867999076843,
-0.3841278553009033,
-0.155833438038826,
0.20802530646324158,
-0.11613070219755173,
0.7838460206985474,
0.8275032639503479,
0.031989846378564835,
0.06884127110242844,
-0.6661340594291687,
0.6392014622688293,
0.18384499847888947,
-0.8829614520072937,
0.319317489862442,
0.7814577221870422,
0.49228039383888245,
-0.06266192346811295,
0.8198699355125427,
0.07778111100196838,
0.08761412650346756,
0.07611829787492752,
0.10531572252511978,
-0.7046557068824768,
-0.7574856877326965,
-0.1823691427707672,
0.5723809003829956,
0.04939700663089752,
0.2129829227924347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16667v1
|
RepoAgent: An LLM-Powered Open-Source Framework for Repository-level Code Documentation Generation
| 2024-02-26T15:39:52 | 2024-02-26T15:39:52 |
Qinyu Luo, Yining Ye, Shihao Liang, Zhong Zhang, Yujia Qin, Yaxi Lu, Yesai Wu, Xin Cong, Yankai Lin, Yingli Zhang, Xiaoyin Che, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; F.2.2
|
Generative models have demonstrated considerable potential in software
engineering, particularly in tasks such as code generation and debugging.
However, their utilization in the domain of code documentation generation
remains underexplored. To this end, we introduce RepoAgent, a large language
model powered open-source framework aimed at proactively generating,
maintaining, and updating code documentation. Through both qualitative and
quantitative evaluations, we have validated the effectiveness of our approach,
showing that RepoAgent excels in generating high-quality repository-level
documentation. The code and results are publicly accessible at
https://github.com/OpenBMB/RepoAgent.
|
[
-0.19981910288333893,
-0.4215724468231201,
0.4121721386909485,
0.2742112874984741,
-0.16965800523757935,
-0.03557533770799637,
-0.11129726469516754,
-0.2083510160446167,
0.20055551826953888,
0.7389764189720154,
-0.588158905506134,
-0.9045775532722473,
-0.07658819854259491,
0.12683585286140442,
-0.7361265420913696,
0.857524037361145,
-0.11841912567615509,
0.05331452935934067,
-0.3828909397125244,
-0.17759642004966736,
-0.2248740941286087,
-0.2745141088962555,
-0.31881824135780334,
-0.27287018299102783,
0.30033403635025024,
0.4308810234069824,
0.5669769048690796,
0.5513511896133423,
0.5407934784889221,
0.2074383795261383,
0.34186244010925293,
-0.07436330616474152,
-0.5201326608657837,
0.7904075384140015,
-0.2907756567001343,
-0.6521860361099243,
-0.42367735505104065,
-0.0841369703412056,
0.4640052318572998,
0.33886945247650146,
-0.5760162472724915,
0.3483249545097351,
-0.03401585668325424,
0.7833567261695862,
-0.6022085547447205,
-0.014803344383835793,
-0.515399694442749,
-0.15266633033752441,
-0.08225555717945099,
-0.2704581618309021,
-0.6143869161605835,
-0.5996033549308777,
-0.3226875364780426,
-0.7829294800758362,
0.2531798481941223,
-0.07650981843471527,
0.6756971478462219,
0.3221384584903717,
0.15154248476028442,
-0.382005512714386,
-0.35202890634536743,
0.690130889415741,
-0.756193995475769,
0.42115750908851624,
0.2877996861934662,
0.27925345301628113,
-0.40413254499435425,
-1.2792668342590332,
-0.31159740686416626,
-0.7867115139961243,
0.0545271635055542,
0.14800500869750977,
-0.3323845863342285,
0.05098594352602959,
0.05726735666394234,
0.7562885284423828,
-0.6340674161911011,
0.19982320070266724,
-0.20208291709423065,
-0.24181286990642548,
0.35978618264198303,
-0.033017657697200775,
0.6071725487709045,
-0.09669508039951324,
-0.30655044317245483,
0.07545969635248184,
-1.129196047782898,
-0.45393475890159607,
0.4343480169773102,
0.09128456562757492,
-0.08332212269306183,
0.7922285795211792,
0.11855284124612808,
0.5971157550811768,
-0.2820459008216858,
0.011848118156194687,
-0.023168325424194336,
-0.052331455051898956,
-0.2078942507505417,
0.08983109891414642,
0.5784441232681274,
0.06195275858044624,
-0.004455713089555502,
-0.1885443776845932,
-0.5460931658744812,
-0.05611700937151909,
0.6628589034080505,
-1.0037634372711182,
-0.4144360423088074,
0.5710164308547974,
-0.6754760146141052,
-0.6781070828437805,
0.11185424029827118,
-0.653225302696228,
-0.5940827131271362,
-0.1485140025615692,
0.010725878179073334,
-0.48983049392700195,
-0.48746299743652344,
-0.2332482635974884,
-0.24755153059959412,
-0.06655760854482651,
0.23486630618572235,
-0.5678159594535828,
-0.3425312638282776,
0.8764814138412476,
0.8654767870903015,
0.20952586829662323,
-0.36656761169433594,
-0.5540865659713745,
0.19427666068077087,
-0.5801512598991394,
0.6015738248825073,
-0.48429998755455017,
-0.6988279223442078,
0.22389884293079376,
-0.07866505533456802,
0.40983062982559204,
-0.441754013299942,
-0.10076478868722916,
-0.6394681930541992,
0.11722960323095322,
0.23135247826576233,
-0.5847206711769104,
0.27344387769699097,
0.14743122458457947,
-0.8959886431694031,
0.8174275159835815,
0.6999066472053528,
-0.5665664076805115,
0.23706325888633728,
-0.6095432043075562,
-0.4027750492095947,
0.3263184428215027,
-0.32080477476119995,
-0.40168875455856323,
0.21667353808879852,
-0.2649275064468384,
-0.0348912812769413,
-0.5161449909210205,
0.3680792450904846,
-0.13757655024528503,
-0.11440230906009674,
0.1649438440799713,
-0.09644465148448944,
0.8281022906303406,
0.3587270975112915,
-0.3144071698188782,
0.4042721688747406,
-0.9825460314750671,
-0.08760452270507812,
0.04787380248308182,
-0.664610743522644,
-0.2644460201263428,
-0.22662079334259033,
-0.25166499614715576,
-0.10911957919597626,
0.40501222014427185,
-0.5395044088363647,
0.5618245005607605,
-0.30699729919433594,
0.594944953918457,
0.6746870279312134,
0.07469972223043442,
0.5703687071800232,
-0.18633651733398438,
1.0294301509857178,
-0.4181668162345886,
0.11990053951740265,
-0.6972008943557739,
-0.45771390199661255,
-0.6292977333068848,
-0.37580448389053345,
0.3864865303039551,
0.23717212677001953,
-0.8974373936653137,
0.19090691208839417,
-0.08467419445514679,
-0.7596160173416138,
-0.7623122930526733,
0.21047528088092804,
0.6964215040206909,
0.552944540977478,
0.2696495056152344,
0.006676194258034229,
-0.6177861094474792,
-0.6525613069534302,
0.010464316233992577,
-0.4721561074256897,
-0.23695600032806396,
0.20560312271118164,
0.48305028676986694,
-0.47950172424316406,
0.8773380517959595,
-0.43064576387405396,
-0.22637955844402313,
-0.23237812519073486,
0.5500541925430298,
-0.03114010952413082,
0.5614594221115112,
0.6029155254364014,
-0.6103089451789856,
0.13582928478717804,
0.12298461049795151,
-0.8808122873306274,
-0.35169801115989685,
-0.07334014773368835,
-0.40229663252830505,
0.5666758418083191,
0.6222264766693115,
-0.6806532144546509,
0.24071379005908966,
0.8993402719497681,
-0.07196547091007233,
0.6301078200340271,
-0.4310361444950104,
0.2031390368938446,
-1.3913745880126953,
0.3192599415779114,
-0.2243114411830902,
0.003412450198084116,
-0.24068859219551086,
0.6719740629196167,
0.1967054307460785,
-0.5690778493881226,
-0.2678036093711853,
0.3395902216434479,
-0.5229026079177856,
-0.2877750098705292,
-0.2692249119281769,
0.2670721411705017,
0.16798993945121765,
0.07519714534282684,
-0.10295162349939346,
1.0541189908981323,
0.3004172742366791,
-0.48073330521583557,
0.4725474715232849,
0.06895874440670013,
-0.32600879669189453,
0.38301604986190796,
-0.664762020111084,
0.10588058084249496,
0.21279409527778625,
0.23004838824272156,
-0.9841892123222351,
-0.6032506227493286,
-0.006461009383201599,
-0.5139342546463013,
0.3835746645927429,
-0.5232831239700317,
-0.4290955066680908,
-0.3667849898338318,
-0.24045220017433167,
0.030254224315285683,
0.7262195348739624,
-0.7280774712562561,
0.7064286470413208,
0.39269447326660156,
-0.07852814346551895,
-0.4510420858860016,
-0.8938938975334167,
-0.03510604053735733,
0.283025860786438,
-0.7443934679031372,
0.3912522494792938,
0.30240580439567566,
-0.4311893582344055,
0.10419066250324249,
-0.13526587188243866,
0.06895634531974792,
0.13908270001411438,
0.6087216138839722,
0.2663131654262543,
-0.4145044684410095,
0.4705115258693695,
0.03422924131155014,
-0.2134966403245926,
0.022588564082980156,
-0.6985387802124023,
0.7035324573516846,
-0.21562150120735168,
-0.6821427345275879,
-0.10860814899206161,
0.1070258840918541,
0.7191328406333923,
-0.410853773355484,
0.6141100525856018,
0.18204672634601593,
-0.22150428593158722,
-0.39951056241989136,
-0.2953205108642578,
-0.0761859118938446,
-0.4598574638366699,
0.14762678742408752,
-0.32286083698272705,
-0.9237191081047058,
0.5801899433135986,
-0.2486419975757599,
0.44897523522377014,
0.2335067242383957,
0.5361908674240112,
0.22712509334087372,
0.6762453317642212,
0.7118819952011108,
0.10070504993200302,
0.4878779351711273,
-0.38745006918907166,
0.11804435402154922,
-0.48566851019859314,
-0.1593887060880661,
-0.7250831723213196,
0.08783887326717377,
-0.6627163887023926,
-0.2843806743621826,
0.029464896768331528,
0.39556068181991577,
-0.06962921470403671,
0.5732578039169312,
-0.8327212333679199,
0.061192162334918976,
0.5968505144119263,
-0.18500083684921265,
0.2511940002441406,
-0.1263890117406845,
-0.1374560296535492,
0.2576276659965515,
-0.6266423463821411,
-0.6565998792648315,
0.9545398950576782,
0.46414685249328613,
0.9901313781738281,
0.2135562151670456,
1.200416088104248,
0.46613532304763794,
0.8428799510002136,
-0.4444424510002136,
0.5728971362113953,
0.013558020815253258,
-0.4341767728328705,
-0.33240556716918945,
-0.4410168528556824,
-1.0489517450332642,
0.033561259508132935,
0.17907032370567322,
-0.26384809613227844,
0.19572825729846954,
0.5572845935821533,
-0.007737199310213327,
0.17065659165382385,
-0.5882424712181091,
0.8839648365974426,
-0.1525873839855194,
-0.3415948152542114,
-0.45828866958618164,
-0.12017828226089478,
0.4017382562160492,
-0.11027128994464874,
0.1983659565448761,
0.17900718748569489,
-0.2299990952014923,
0.351809561252594,
-0.8547477722167969,
0.4912341237068176,
-0.36014503240585327,
-0.6800462007522583,
0.6191277503967285,
0.6082106828689575,
0.5056383013725281,
0.26617738604545593,
-0.25608253479003906,
0.2588196098804474,
-0.2926211953163147,
-0.16180452704429626,
-0.42956727743148804,
1.0949479341506958,
-0.5394746661186218,
-0.6766281127929688,
0.14709073305130005,
-0.24952375888824463,
0.21269354224205017,
0.34033656120300293,
0.3269442319869995,
0.5028513073921204,
-0.2769794166088104,
0.22114142775535583,
0.6487798690795898,
-0.5444915294647217,
0.18734601140022278,
0.6737052202224731,
-0.7635895609855652,
-0.4784270226955414,
1.0575977563858032,
-0.10644886642694473,
0.20247220993041992,
0.28954243659973145,
-0.08379596471786499,
-0.06096697971224785,
-0.3814890682697296,
-0.48807722330093384,
0.10636363923549652,
-0.9234153032302856,
-0.4064480662345886,
-0.1653004139661789,
-0.14186877012252808,
-0.5156518816947937,
-0.46895909309387207,
-0.4258628785610199,
-0.5804442167282104,
-0.29964807629585266,
-0.25860366225242615,
0.4817431569099426,
0.839037299156189,
-0.01919468864798546,
-0.021625161170959473,
-0.8950145840644836,
0.5321205854415894,
0.08226551860570908,
0.411508709192276,
-0.23284690082073212,
-0.25974735617637634,
-0.07140304148197174,
0.08997083455324173,
-0.1651497185230255,
-0.8193120956420898,
0.33853989839553833,
-0.17606517672538757,
0.641139566898346,
0.24482908844947815,
0.11970895528793335,
0.2748239040374756,
-0.23881272971630096,
0.9762924313545227,
0.4302031397819519,
-0.7704125642776489,
1.0284359455108643,
-0.32622119784355164,
0.13019129633903503,
0.4239307940006256,
0.134568452835083,
-0.05159716680645943,
-0.9592626690864563,
-0.5908553004264832,
-1.0264337062835693,
0.4088326096534729,
0.11739777028560638,
0.10967306792736053,
-0.3068371117115021,
0.35237473249435425,
0.1068439930677414,
0.32848528027534485,
-0.5155194997787476,
0.044495172798633575,
-0.5338459610939026,
-0.17555873095989227,
0.45014744997024536,
-0.31134843826293945,
-0.32265129685401917,
0.3772929012775421,
0.6454116106033325,
-0.012543631717562675,
0.08059676736593246,
0.24577710032463074,
-0.43760770559310913,
-0.23782868683338165,
0.2814983129501343,
0.7544964551925659,
1.0447180271148682,
-0.16426177322864532,
-0.04721306264400482,
-0.4252539277076721,
-0.5696066617965698,
-0.003101225243881345,
0.2347269505262375,
-0.2270960807800293,
0.19409427046775818,
0.5157545804977417,
0.3367310166358948,
0.3116801381111145,
-0.8493280410766602,
0.3871334493160248,
0.042787741869688034,
-0.3240737318992615,
-0.40505146980285645,
0.27499303221702576,
0.13454526662826538,
0.18334440886974335,
0.43125447630882263,
-0.18197879195213318,
-0.10725662857294083,
-0.3406171202659607,
0.220942422747612,
0.2193666249513626,
-0.2974482774734497,
0.0869707390666008,
0.7484331727027893,
0.5956855416297913,
-0.4972901940345764,
0.8675677180290222,
-0.026052201166749,
0.03996077924966812,
0.7609522938728333,
0.4817466139793396,
1.0584523677825928,
-0.16517207026481628,
0.24940752983093262,
0.28164994716644287,
0.2692371904850006,
0.02557235024869442,
0.3304058909416199,
-0.2316630631685257,
-0.35916441679000854,
-0.24081525206565857,
-0.8647106289863586,
-0.43543052673339844,
-0.022123465314507484,
-0.7794071435928345,
0.038851261138916016,
-0.43599486351013184,
-0.17541490495204926,
-0.0929471105337143,
-0.4740191102027893,
-0.038387481123209,
-0.2555370032787323,
-0.09925099462270737,
1.3705909252166748,
-0.37271052598953247,
0.8485323786735535,
0.8881621360778809,
-0.9966467022895813,
-0.5973695516586304,
0.08159074932336807,
-0.2345033586025238,
-0.7537896037101746,
0.675737738609314,
0.14026054739952087,
-0.2854897975921631,
0.3237146735191345,
-0.6598674058914185,
-0.46536001563072205,
1.4874316453933716,
0.5510696172714233,
-0.7133685350418091,
0.1123976856470108,
-0.06715266406536102,
0.6604645848274231,
-0.44590631127357483,
-0.13633838295936584,
0.1987135112285614,
0.3421255648136139,
-0.17679353058338165,
-0.5111793279647827,
-0.00817036908119917,
-0.41982024908065796,
0.44582659006118774,
0.203764870762825,
-0.3333449363708496,
0.7152948975563049,
-0.37807735800743103,
-0.2674560844898224,
0.48178619146347046,
0.7367109656333923,
0.8096481561660767,
0.10467123985290527,
0.10033140331506729,
0.6171141862869263,
0.8147073984146118,
-0.16835899651050568,
1.4432458877563477,
-0.9703894853591919,
0.21399755775928497,
0.9471760988235474,
-0.33334022760391235,
0.7425671219825745,
0.4055151343345642,
0.0583556666970253,
0.9265977144241333,
0.31169548630714417,
-0.21754872798919678,
0.35724374651908875,
0.29727843403816223,
-0.2857299745082855,
-0.06347546726465225,
-0.02295449562370777,
-0.5614919066429138,
-0.08643843978643417,
0.1152452602982521,
-0.8445919156074524,
-0.1360008716583252,
0.13364587724208832,
-0.15679535269737244,
0.18157878518104553,
-0.4116488993167877,
0.5867990255355835,
0.10642538964748383,
-0.9564806222915649,
0.6068099737167358,
0.09655334055423737,
0.1363126039505005,
-0.5273648500442505,
-0.47103437781333923,
-0.4206503927707672,
0.2907925546169281,
-0.3287781774997711,
-1.028587818145752,
0.13183477520942688,
0.21615251898765564,
-0.20290914177894592,
-0.3658446967601776,
0.9164964556694031,
-0.13640092313289642,
0.0425492525100708,
0.3782573640346527,
0.27000823616981506,
0.0854269489645958,
0.1868591457605362,
-0.5376886129379272,
0.04937707632780075,
0.018983682617545128,
-0.5763368010520935,
0.3911522626876831,
0.49961376190185547,
0.0739276260137558,
0.946733295917511,
0.777009904384613,
-0.0908326506614685,
-0.0789993405342102,
0.7109690308570862,
0.9983169436454773,
-0.30011454224586487,
-0.36529526114463806,
-0.7736114263534546,
0.6766629815101624,
-0.03614463284611702,
-0.2587774395942688,
0.7002124190330505,
0.6821420788764954,
0.6398824453353882,
-0.32383793592453003,
0.9650911092758179,
-0.14548389613628387,
0.23550096154212952,
-0.5477758049964905,
0.7527154684066772,
-0.39254847168922424,
0.4706718921661377,
0.1667841076850891,
-0.7255032062530518,
-0.20557618141174316,
0.6454125046730042,
-0.022852832451462746,
-0.1356113702058792,
0.3113933503627777,
1.14569890499115,
0.2333115041255951,
-0.02159750647842884,
0.1958225965499878,
0.13520757853984833,
0.38016778230667114,
0.1410081684589386,
1.035841464996338,
-0.04238785058259964,
0.8155112266540527,
-0.07260746508836746,
-0.3622494637966156,
-0.36516350507736206,
-0.8544710278511047,
-0.7114560604095459,
-0.40337857604026794,
-0.20241932570934296,
-0.7842821478843689,
0.15596698224544525,
0.523080587387085,
0.47181814908981323,
-0.6170939803123474,
-0.12060669809579849,
-0.9894788861274719,
0.2740674912929535,
0.04637811332941055,
-0.2962666153907776,
-0.03837045282125473,
-0.7269418835639954,
-0.30469220876693726,
0.38874495029449463,
0.6171990036964417,
0.0374118909239769,
-0.8763667345046997,
-0.31828081607818604,
0.20184433460235596,
-0.14076533913612366,
0.37453770637512207,
0.443317174911499,
-0.6820614337921143,
0.2034042328596115,
0.02257315255701542,
-0.6047989130020142,
-0.21043503284454346,
1.0479049682617188,
-0.5784014463424683,
0.2874160706996918,
0.5970091819763184,
0.3349781334400177,
0.20560936629772186,
0.08997519314289093,
0.8824637532234192,
-0.7945258617401123,
0.07709954679012299,
0.20300500094890594,
0.5193098783493042,
0.12102960050106049,
-0.39996203780174255,
0.7883349657058716,
0.02670183777809143,
-0.7307897806167603,
-0.9923731684684753,
0.3905603885650635,
-0.5034233331680298,
-0.6459406614303589,
1.241753339767456,
-0.5379915833473206,
-0.22648362815380096,
0.18541687726974487,
-0.18962043523788452,
0.2805148661136627,
-0.2740330696105957,
0.6559894680976868,
0.43018728494644165,
-0.029528280720114708,
-0.27442121505737305,
-0.2374788522720337,
0.3743307590484619,
-0.26270097494125366,
-0.9499449729919434,
0.38789767026901245,
0.7582212686538696,
0.27619901299476624,
0.6040990948677063,
0.5915557146072388,
-0.3488443195819855,
0.5790868997573853,
0.46014338731765747,
0.5254446864128113,
-0.4803425371646881,
-0.2783414125442505,
-0.2066335678100586,
0.3325873017311096,
0.3152046501636505,
-0.038829904049634933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16654v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16654v1
|
GigaPevt: Multimodal Medical Assistant
| 2024-02-26T15:26:56 | 2024-02-26T15:26:56 |
Pavel Blinov, Konstantin Egorov, Ivan Sviridov, Nikolay Ivanov, Stepan Botman, Evgeniy Tagin, Stepan Kudin, Galina Zubkova, Andrey Savchenko
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, 68T07, I.2.1
|
Building an intelligent and efficient medical assistant is still a
challenging AI problem. The major limitation comes from the data modality
scarceness, which reduces comprehensive patient perception. This demo paper
presents the GigaPevt, the first multimodal medical assistant that combines the
dialog capabilities of large language models with specialized medical models.
Such an approach shows immediate advantages in dialog quality and metric
performance, with a 1.18\% accuracy improvement in the question-answering task.
|
[
-0.3546759784221649,
-0.9751787781715393,
0.9169326424598694,
-0.050658807158470154,
-0.3969481587409973,
0.11304759234189987,
0.30468037724494934,
-0.3160306513309479,
0.5559691786766052,
0.33208224177360535,
-0.707109808921814,
-0.008774581365287304,
-0.5029478073120117,
-0.2876812815666199,
0.119715616106987,
0.8633277416229248,
0.144142746925354,
0.5150472521781921,
-0.31569403409957886,
-0.35855454206466675,
-0.6758847832679749,
-0.36001303791999817,
-0.603713870048523,
-0.08769608289003372,
0.5760535001754761,
0.12307145446538925,
1.0436748266220093,
0.2374339997768402,
0.6852951049804688,
0.43213531374931335,
0.3920954167842865,
0.4530836045742035,
0.010383964516222477,
-0.15201294422149658,
0.17425218224525452,
-0.4394388496875763,
-0.7621374130249023,
0.06727399677038193,
0.4214441776275635,
0.6095292568206787,
-0.2923745810985565,
-0.040431082248687744,
-0.5365197658538818,
0.3203237056732178,
-0.031911272555589676,
0.14569777250289917,
-0.1670231968164444,
0.03459809720516205,
-0.0035857302136719227,
-0.5160306692123413,
-0.16294385492801666,
-0.2964414358139038,
0.10694818943738937,
-0.70241779088974,
-0.21103410422801971,
-0.0514918714761734,
0.6275959610939026,
0.562613308429718,
-0.7386248111724854,
-0.22240884602069855,
-0.685763418674469,
0.5251238346099854,
-0.6776053309440613,
0.5592159628868103,
0.32512643933296204,
0.5153807997703552,
0.08348610997200012,
-0.8220918774604797,
-0.6412392258644104,
-0.5241789221763611,
0.18714742362499237,
0.4358966052532196,
-0.16339929401874542,
0.2318004071712494,
0.1872229129076004,
0.4002906084060669,
-0.7766739130020142,
-0.09314551204442978,
-0.7428879141807556,
-0.3222164213657379,
0.24073933064937592,
0.48247188329696655,
0.5628488659858704,
-0.17146320641040802,
-0.5413959622383118,
0.11560352146625519,
-0.25597870349884033,
-0.32829177379608154,
0.015406448394060135,
-0.21578332781791687,
0.1234595999121666,
0.5764318704605103,
0.09959414601325989,
0.669379711151123,
-0.3571552038192749,
-0.5620138049125671,
0.5309522151947021,
-0.3938831388950348,
-0.4019758403301239,
-0.3634524941444397,
0.5755980014801025,
0.49571284651756287,
-0.34582990407943726,
-0.14110320806503296,
-0.028689544647932053,
0.23440450429916382,
0.5728738307952881,
-0.6587603688240051,
-0.17020083963871002,
0.39408478140830994,
-0.45222175121307373,
-0.2012108564376831,
-0.2545710504055023,
-0.2877344787120819,
-0.2939629852771759,
-0.2975725829601288,
0.6918044090270996,
-0.6114488840103149,
-0.19202877581119537,
0.03302241489291191,
0.05948999151587486,
-0.04112694784998894,
0.8033460378646851,
-0.5067394971847534,
0.07968173176050186,
0.32866814732551575,
1.048087477684021,
-0.10530561953783035,
-0.016715247184038162,
-0.731760561466217,
0.009342774748802185,
-0.3549731373786926,
0.8821355700492859,
-0.5361413359642029,
-0.303181529045105,
-0.46795952320098877,
0.019236549735069275,
-0.2126253992319107,
-0.3779143989086151,
0.36446166038513184,
-0.38638871908187866,
0.5023903846740723,
-0.08293183892965317,
-0.3976902365684509,
-0.4248174726963043,
0.3824041783809662,
-0.6689935326576233,
0.4888099730014801,
0.4394289553165436,
-0.5199097394943237,
0.44782760739326477,
-1.042907476425171,
-0.22844640910625458,
0.5553714632987976,
-0.2904130518436432,
-0.07097999006509781,
0.0928317978978157,
0.23779985308647156,
0.5245949625968933,
-0.4223160743713379,
0.2925495207309723,
-0.05869879573583603,
-0.1354750096797943,
0.3797813057899475,
-0.7000885009765625,
0.533161461353302,
0.4021412134170532,
0.32219836115837097,
0.29377496242523193,
-0.8649948239326477,
-0.09559320658445358,
0.09210655093193054,
-0.6753464937210083,
-0.2194787859916687,
-0.2189956158399582,
0.35273122787475586,
0.35688257217407227,
0.05460449308156967,
-0.5933295488357544,
0.6551636457443237,
-0.09149353206157684,
0.5970837473869324,
0.6234806776046753,
-0.20200228691101074,
0.011318744160234928,
-0.5764244198799133,
0.8738381266593933,
-0.15888887643814087,
0.31091785430908203,
-0.16874650120735168,
-0.6408111453056335,
-0.24394062161445618,
-0.8645637631416321,
0.14981934428215027,
0.8970871567726135,
-1.3451659679412842,
-0.07026104629039764,
-0.12207352370023727,
-0.47994592785835266,
-0.7629057168960571,
-0.047327421605587006,
0.12071333825588226,
0.34185412526130676,
0.19672295451164246,
-0.4920797646045685,
-0.12988786399364471,
-1.186289668083191,
0.33118936419487,
-0.18731622397899628,
-0.11614187061786652,
0.5874830484390259,
0.23496712744235992,
-0.5914965271949768,
0.339534193277359,
-0.6158949732780457,
-0.3861527442932129,
-0.42020973563194275,
0.150953471660614,
0.3030278980731964,
0.4863860309123993,
0.6823410987854004,
-1.056636929512024,
-0.25246670842170715,
0.143682599067688,
-0.5385483503341675,
-0.05160481110215187,
-0.2737247347831726,
0.4978170096874237,
-0.08852668106555939,
0.29411080479621887,
-0.8155645132064819,
0.06326717883348465,
0.87766033411026,
-0.33969584107398987,
0.5914565324783325,
-0.6527233123779297,
0.5184019804000854,
-1.5013375282287598,
0.09089811891317368,
-0.22250328958034515,
-0.47059231996536255,
-0.9727321267127991,
-0.12624511122703552,
0.057661253958940506,
-0.2470996230840683,
-0.4396781921386719,
0.22893118858337402,
-0.2253902703523636,
0.08610393851995468,
-0.2844582796096802,
0.035727716982364655,
-0.17012114822864532,
0.5896971821784973,
-0.2485429346561432,
1.1424213647842407,
0.49850642681121826,
-0.43000128865242004,
0.7580146193504333,
0.4657716453075409,
-0.300251305103302,
0.8942443132400513,
-0.7819257378578186,
0.23304004967212677,
-0.1549115777015686,
0.13340896368026733,
-1.202982783317566,
-0.555279016494751,
-0.10094890743494034,
-0.49102258682250977,
0.13755322992801666,
0.016701962798833847,
-0.40688657760620117,
-0.43075618147850037,
-0.20667538046836853,
0.48568838834762573,
0.36178767681121826,
-0.2361329346895218,
0.7372879981994629,
0.4477793574333191,
-0.35446035861968994,
-0.22439029812812805,
-0.7776453495025635,
0.16178284585475922,
-0.09070923924446106,
-0.8119953274726868,
-0.10874051600694656,
-0.4838356077671051,
0.048876043409109116,
-0.5276405811309814,
0.12455181777477264,
-0.2509872317314148,
-0.1537095606327057,
0.031245898455381393,
0.6262226700782776,
-0.1727709323167801,
0.6846146583557129,
-0.01727685146033764,
-0.1805703043937683,
-0.10112243890762329,
0.04068044573068619,
0.6939124464988708,
-0.26922959089279175,
-0.6081625819206238,
-0.6564911007881165,
0.5807381868362427,
0.9782124161720276,
-0.0790095254778862,
0.4112967252731323,
0.6854949593544006,
-0.0456918366253376,
0.5811038017272949,
-0.8078855872154236,
-0.01813579723238945,
-0.4669407606124878,
0.5730190873146057,
-0.40529900789260864,
-0.7307153940200806,
0.4012087881565094,
-0.13459980487823486,
-0.009643692523241043,
0.1913391351699829,
0.7027193307876587,
0.13776427507400513,
1.2729429006576538,
0.5063791275024414,
0.24518145620822906,
0.43302831053733826,
-0.050665874034166336,
-0.054786317050457,
-1.0232230424880981,
-0.21466860175132751,
-0.01595715805888176,
0.016678033396601677,
-0.7264467477798462,
-0.7027336955070496,
0.9286473393440247,
-0.5972081422805786,
0.17905043065547943,
0.28978997468948364,
-0.3991737961769104,
-0.0643831416964531,
0.544244110584259,
0.3730370104312897,
0.1919175684452057,
-0.3969648778438568,
0.03327770531177521,
-0.06810081005096436,
-0.7835428714752197,
-0.2877745032310486,
0.8972352147102356,
0.4028714895248413,
0.697053074836731,
0.4430152177810669,
0.26811233162879944,
0.29905495047569275,
0.07109379768371582,
-0.9279295206069946,
0.46001961827278137,
-0.09785030782222748,
-0.539290189743042,
-0.2201368361711502,
-0.543687641620636,
-0.7335088849067688,
0.6117203831672668,
-0.39872249960899353,
-0.822613537311554,
0.03476003557443619,
0.23567986488342285,
-0.553757905960083,
0.16146087646484375,
-0.9462102055549622,
0.7879034280776978,
0.010450169444084167,
-0.4079474210739136,
-0.22708065807819366,
-0.6264326572418213,
0.2619556784629822,
-0.1001562774181366,
0.23771530389785767,
0.023849716410040855,
-0.08379217237234116,
0.5803831219673157,
-0.42291730642318726,
0.3749014139175415,
-0.11096826195716858,
0.18041223287582397,
-0.04059108719229698,
0.22975867986679077,
0.4876053035259247,
0.1607753485441208,
0.3274552822113037,
-0.23816832900047302,
0.18685539066791534,
-0.5483428835868835,
-0.5308690667152405,
0.494806706905365,
-0.48565107583999634,
-0.5799458026885986,
-0.18232481181621552,
-1.0392749309539795,
-0.4643568694591522,
0.27208390831947327,
-0.039643075317144394,
0.8976129293441772,
-0.30530256032943726,
0.22596357762813568,
0.738369882106781,
-0.5305245518684387,
0.22261971235275269,
0.3118479251861572,
-0.128462553024292,
-0.5307562947273254,
0.9405883550643921,
0.3410990238189697,
0.5910265445709229,
0.26539334654808044,
0.3484382927417755,
-0.005085726734250784,
-0.4598532021045685,
-0.8590763211250305,
0.11994783580303192,
-0.5939373970031738,
-0.1180296242237091,
-1.1246321201324463,
-0.04442228004336357,
-0.23392048478126526,
-0.24983875453472137,
-0.43137210607528687,
-0.5780327320098877,
0.17057757079601288,
0.03858378157019615,
0.1198447048664093,
0.8329434990882874,
-0.0441276952624321,
0.4500698149204254,
-0.895166277885437,
0.3917504549026489,
0.8921895027160645,
0.20148569345474243,
-0.5312976837158203,
-0.06325924396514893,
0.13863226771354675,
-0.17335526645183563,
-0.03192754089832306,
-0.7441129088401794,
0.3978298604488373,
-0.19954267144203186,
0.5572704672813416,
0.5009265542030334,
-0.616409420967102,
0.4798602759838104,
-0.36008068919181824,
1.0478698015213013,
0.5849243402481079,
-0.57194983959198,
0.36050906777381897,
-0.5286157727241516,
0.6511554718017578,
0.2402721345424652,
0.022767307236790657,
-0.4845558702945709,
-0.0682254359126091,
-0.646064817905426,
-0.6138310432434082,
0.5823280215263367,
0.1678723841905594,
0.11361593753099442,
0.10383657366037369,
-0.21071995794773102,
0.35757580399513245,
0.40450751781463623,
-0.4505308270454407,
0.10126446932554245,
-0.16767321527004242,
0.0350663922727108,
-0.19710931181907654,
-0.26546013355255127,
-0.118500255048275,
-0.36637023091316223,
0.4355168342590332,
-0.45497360825538635,
0.5555916428565979,
0.22803716361522675,
-0.1565689891576767,
0.19667179882526398,
0.4206291139125824,
1.1587646007537842,
0.9074913263320923,
-0.12680818140506744,
0.13990053534507751,
0.5318682193756104,
-0.8361921310424805,
-0.11846619099378586,
0.044131990522146225,
0.26971235871315,
-0.03580176830291748,
0.36916399002075195,
0.8443462252616882,
-0.3011329770088196,
-0.7861185073852539,
0.7516241073608398,
-0.2653012275695801,
-0.13943946361541748,
-0.16740825772285461,
0.006277797278016806,
0.09242243319749832,
0.357912540435791,
0.07558927685022354,
0.16756920516490936,
0.558026134967804,
-0.6976871490478516,
0.19587892293930054,
0.5713298320770264,
-0.4575085937976837,
-0.09083649516105652,
0.8384881615638733,
0.09593408554792404,
-0.2844659686088562,
0.398357629776001,
0.14689914882183075,
-0.3776589632034302,
0.48153364658355713,
0.3754081428050995,
0.6422886848449707,
-0.4897615611553192,
0.4096240699291229,
0.016942638903856277,
0.4710889756679535,
0.2410689741373062,
0.4005125164985657,
-0.07537650316953659,
-0.40660223364830017,
-0.4044051766395569,
-0.21600031852722168,
-0.4832124412059784,
-0.0008252704283222556,
-0.27671828866004944,
-0.04059906676411629,
-0.3010804057121277,
-0.21554602682590485,
0.440647155046463,
-0.14974261820316315,
-0.6944268345832825,
0.27610811591148376,
-0.18965870141983032,
0.5118299126625061,
-0.6340038776397705,
0.8927950263023376,
0.9205288290977478,
-0.5438262820243835,
-0.5876803994178772,
-0.29096150398254395,
0.012830968014895916,
-1.037692904472351,
0.4118116796016693,
0.019110357388854027,
-0.1748945415019989,
-0.4148356020450592,
-0.5666250586509705,
-0.5203147530555725,
1.1245819330215454,
0.27907130122184753,
-0.2602117657661438,
0.1752997785806656,
-0.008451107889413834,
0.5724854469299316,
-0.44965115189552307,
0.5623989105224609,
0.30021411180496216,
0.49459564685821533,
0.36973902583122253,
-1.3396345376968384,
0.0166983250528574,
-0.4334660470485687,
0.1362973004579544,
0.1229436844587326,
-0.9071134328842163,
1.1106762886047363,
-0.2842370569705963,
0.12961319088935852,
-0.2040565013885498,
0.24307265877723694,
-0.22141912579536438,
0.23307164013385773,
0.6571294665336609,
0.2525935173034668,
0.8105794787406921,
-0.0031505499500781298,
1.1663148403167725,
0.05595411732792854,
0.043370116502046585,
0.6759599447250366,
-0.06331953406333923,
0.2134813368320465,
0.6065633893013,
-0.036696404218673706,
0.15109418332576752,
0.28385090827941895,
0.1373881995677948,
0.3907887935638428,
-0.19383424520492554,
-0.3398689925670624,
-0.4173583686351776,
-0.02423744834959507,
-0.44324058294296265,
0.4946558475494385,
0.5040601491928101,
-0.15341420471668243,
-0.009428044781088829,
0.5978299975395203,
-0.006300092674791813,
-0.39436814188957214,
-0.14887374639511108,
1.0600824356079102,
-0.2744120955467224,
-0.44883662462234497,
0.39628273248672485,
-0.39409586787223816,
0.44519007205963135,
-0.7965406775474548,
-0.29437920451164246,
-0.040648575872182846,
0.15651588141918182,
-0.05024150758981705,
-0.45758870244026184,
0.0622878260910511,
-0.6633539795875549,
0.055240195244550705,
-0.01798379234969616,
0.664750337600708,
-0.39719030261039734,
-0.43849602341651917,
-0.22988690435886383,
0.6439992785453796,
0.4481485188007355,
0.09026367217302322,
-0.6295279860496521,
-0.007021061610430479,
-0.07036914676427841,
-0.3911820948123932,
0.13616327941417694,
0.18303604423999786,
0.07509541511535645,
1.0464943647384644,
0.6727340817451477,
0.010038187727332115,
-0.014936411753296852,
-0.053895026445388794,
1.1170755624771118,
-0.3990768492221832,
-0.6319802403450012,
-0.5487144589424133,
0.3711462616920471,
-0.24299810826778412,
-0.34521055221557617,
0.30841028690338135,
0.4526991844177246,
0.16444118320941925,
-0.1880522221326828,
0.7905197739601135,
-0.27251237630844116,
0.503402829170227,
-0.5729824304580688,
0.5768448114395142,
-0.940364420413971,
0.04064696654677391,
-0.20773696899414062,
-0.5785458087921143,
-0.33884453773498535,
0.7632465958595276,
-0.03538757935166359,
0.1259545087814331,
0.810102105140686,
0.809371829032898,
-0.3099691867828369,
-0.10179876536130905,
1.0002788305282593,
0.18697363138198853,
0.4980258047580719,
0.6314387917518616,
0.7401934266090393,
-0.3136449158191681,
0.20710736513137817,
-0.0063630822114646435,
-0.6702519059181213,
-0.3144765794277191,
-0.34269461035728455,
-0.9995136857032776,
-0.694133996963501,
-0.07736163586378098,
-0.20178760588169098,
-0.05552174523472786,
1.261601209640503,
0.8735096454620361,
-0.3794126510620117,
0.24075156450271606,
0.4301298260688782,
-0.21625027060508728,
-0.39151424169540405,
-0.1819487065076828,
0.3258236050605774,
-0.00890803150832653,
-0.7024878859519958,
0.5762277841567993,
0.5808413624763489,
0.032070934772491455,
-0.5521991848945618,
0.09854155033826828,
-0.40120044350624084,
0.6721431612968445,
0.8355844020843506,
-0.1267561912536621,
-0.4312802851200104,
-0.4072924554347992,
-0.08762088418006897,
-0.1005084440112114,
0.34521394968032837,
0.7658669948577881,
-0.49342942237854004,
0.8988270163536072,
0.44590774178504944,
0.544467568397522,
0.4634014070034027,
-0.08532513678073883,
0.3980309069156647,
-0.2298109084367752,
0.36735251545906067,
0.3072583079338074,
0.4042736291885376,
0.22336271405220032,
-0.4486068785190582,
0.544447660446167,
0.23529870808124542,
-0.6503910422325134,
-0.6558042764663696,
0.3149232566356659,
-1.5872409343719482,
-0.18212264776229858,
1.013827919960022,
0.016171956434845924,
-0.08892650157213211,
-0.28932011127471924,
-1.024359107017517,
-0.04838917776942253,
-0.3509076237678528,
0.6743060946464539,
0.5718692541122437,
-0.29321882128715515,
-0.24728350341320038,
-1.221933126449585,
0.16216757893562317,
0.2209978550672531,
-1.1153746843338013,
-0.3097255527973175,
0.6056064367294312,
0.273245245218277,
0.3570423424243927,
1.036094069480896,
-0.05254114419221878,
0.7019694447517395,
0.2056562602519989,
-0.01875370927155018,
-0.47855591773986816,
-0.24772754311561584,
0.05936325713992119,
0.3578729033470154,
-0.0870685949921608,
-0.431673139333725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16650v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16650v1
|
ESG Sentiment Analysis: comparing human and language model performance including GPT
| 2024-02-26T15:22:30 | 2024-02-26T15:22:30 |
Karim Derrick
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE, cs.CY
|
In this paper we explore the challenges of measuring sentiment in relation to
Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) social media. ESG has grown in
importance in recent years with a surge in interest from the financial sector
and the performance of many businesses has become based in part on their ESG
related reputations. The use of sentiment analysis to measure ESG related
reputation has developed and with it interest in the use of machines to do so.
The era of digital media has created an explosion of new media sources, driven
by the growth of social media platforms. This growing data environment has
become an excellent source for behavioural insight studies across many
disciplines that includes politics, healthcare and market research. Our study
seeks to compare human performance with the cutting edge in machine performance
in the measurement of ESG related sentiment. To this end researchers classify
the sentiment of 150 tweets and a reliability measure is made. A gold standard
data set is then established based on the consensus of 3 researchers and this
data set is then used to measure the performance of different machine
approaches: one based on the VADER dictionary approach to sentiment
classification and then multiple language model approaches, including Llama2,
T5, Mistral, Mixtral, FINBERT, GPT3.5 and GPT4.
|
[
-0.47985050082206726,
-0.8732125759124756,
0.5327956080436707,
0.2327789068222046,
-0.4394081234931946,
0.5765912532806396,
-0.05610084906220436,
-0.43936625123023987,
0.1734824776649475,
0.28149497509002686,
-0.34938177466392517,
-0.6992081999778748,
-0.9803462028503418,
0.1489132046699524,
-0.34579163789749146,
1.0547486543655396,
0.17589953541755676,
0.12841807305812836,
-0.1545821875333786,
-0.3843190371990204,
0.01663758046925068,
-0.7410686016082764,
-0.9085237383842468,
-0.33581703901290894,
0.3857516050338745,
-0.027223924174904823,
0.44449207186698914,
0.006652590818703175,
0.6734140515327454,
0.35498395562171936,
-0.4874294400215149,
0.17072317004203796,
-0.38063761591911316,
0.041268590837717056,
-0.33014431595802307,
0.10866674035787582,
-0.4210169315338135,
0.06489962339401245,
0.44523701071739197,
0.22631587088108063,
-0.29167771339416504,
0.3792695999145508,
0.4073294699192047,
0.7710972428321838,
-0.21681593358516693,
0.2986443340778351,
-0.5198079347610474,
-0.03494754806160927,
0.012658897787332535,
-0.12659789621829987,
0.03388537839055061,
-0.5586651563644409,
0.16380129754543304,
-0.21111656725406647,
0.14475050568580627,
-0.10135770589113235,
1.125220775604248,
0.30142733454704285,
-0.4067423641681671,
-0.4861733019351959,
-0.6060210466384888,
0.9228367805480957,
-0.8095343708992004,
0.1993696391582489,
-0.102816641330719,
0.295260488986969,
0.36784839630126953,
-0.6600209474563599,
-0.5165829062461853,
-0.03680768236517906,
0.1451653242111206,
0.3892917335033417,
-0.21112225949764252,
0.11325066536664963,
0.23461653292179108,
0.30157050490379333,
-0.5759544968605042,
-0.21045535802841187,
-0.3028505742549896,
-0.06002433970570564,
0.6332361102104187,
0.001870148815214634,
0.14712963998317719,
-0.4918738007545471,
-0.47358861565589905,
-0.17952944338321686,
-0.49685612320899963,
-0.022057291120290756,
0.7140737771987915,
0.2533353567123413,
0.0037042489275336266,
0.4031352400779724,
-0.2209261655807495,
0.32974809408187866,
-0.054267507046461105,
-0.11986314505338669,
0.39327749609947205,
-0.330745667219162,
-0.20791545510292053,
-0.19014017283916473,
0.9719603061676025,
0.6844361424446106,
0.39204347133636475,
-0.02305789291858673,
-0.3224269151687622,
0.5349630117416382,
0.46598315238952637,
-0.7311693429946899,
0.19209396839141846,
0.025214415043592453,
-0.6641549468040466,
-0.6866939067840576,
0.4561198949813843,
-1.0326684713363647,
-0.6392241716384888,
-0.2111649215221405,
0.3129303455352783,
-0.035447247326374054,
-0.5519845485687256,
0.16514898836612701,
-0.3567225933074951,
0.6856123208999634,
0.10641364753246307,
-0.6248853206634521,
0.42838147282600403,
0.991372287273407,
1.0178357362747192,
0.07962103188037872,
-0.02450805902481079,
-0.14248359203338623,
-0.08639047294855118,
0.02695762738585472,
0.9860658049583435,
-0.40610137581825256,
-0.721643328666687,
0.07295338809490204,
-0.05839866027235985,
-0.09322987496852875,
-0.3602518141269684,
0.8141152858734131,
-0.3080514967441559,
0.223935067653656,
-0.8021756410598755,
-0.5614880323410034,
-0.38896289467811584,
0.4371330738067627,
-0.5428224205970764,
1.0806161165237427,
0.0048170736990869045,
-0.9314945340156555,
0.44972023367881775,
-0.9478583335876465,
-0.41606566309928894,
-0.05607333779335022,
-0.18912546336650848,
-0.4930647015571594,
0.22203411161899567,
0.24612252414226532,
0.5078951716423035,
-0.35066890716552734,
0.09958622604608536,
-0.5980842709541321,
-0.3776231110095978,
0.1357966512441635,
-0.29052814841270447,
0.6010159850120544,
0.18634572625160217,
-0.4542444348335266,
-0.11283468455076218,
-0.42342525720596313,
0.09834989905357361,
0.05290502682328224,
-0.1409481316804886,
-0.04460824280977249,
0.44606658816337585,
0.3875649869441986,
0.509676456451416,
0.24108445644378662,
-0.509315013885498,
0.03604311868548393,
-0.006736468523740768,
0.8143908381462097,
0.9535315036773682,
0.31704315543174744,
0.03524719178676605,
-0.17246632277965546,
0.6259692311286926,
-0.19229935109615326,
0.19784313440322876,
0.46752169728279114,
-0.6477445960044861,
-0.5094868540763855,
0.09070699661970139,
0.14632943272590637,
0.576448380947113,
-0.4635502099990845,
0.2673967182636261,
-0.5872306227684021,
-0.6556985974311829,
-0.8446371555328369,
-0.05082639306783676,
0.10982292145490646,
0.34617412090301514,
0.10659320652484894,
-0.34014248847961426,
-0.3181731700897217,
-0.8846230506896973,
-0.8361481428146362,
-0.7084408402442932,
-0.1328972429037094,
0.45675280690193176,
0.3617502748966217,
-0.42806553840637207,
0.5759071707725525,
-0.24373281002044678,
-0.13144735991954803,
-0.27711138129234314,
0.5414836406707764,
-0.011057274416089058,
-0.24827076494693756,
0.5584549903869629,
-0.7313580513000488,
-0.5064185857772827,
0.15499533712863922,
-0.818291425704956,
-0.2646758556365967,
0.29287979006767273,
0.3201914131641388,
0.5430793166160583,
0.2996605634689331,
-0.3797701299190521,
0.09803134202957153,
0.9462646245956421,
-0.5608073472976685,
0.3139369785785675,
0.1699647158384323,
0.6755194664001465,
-1.0426514148712158,
0.11535544693470001,
0.42674872279167175,
-0.2474488615989685,
-0.4167816638946533,
-0.15747545659542084,
-0.16120776534080505,
-0.1189221739768982,
-0.5466256737709045,
0.3800204396247864,
-0.11434346437454224,
-0.22219619154930115,
-0.1486162543296814,
0.028021929785609245,
-0.033183302730321884,
0.09375375509262085,
-0.13780902326107025,
0.709579348564148,
0.516385555267334,
-0.17119188606739044,
0.3463473618030548,
-0.11634936183691025,
-0.17143794894218445,
0.835017204284668,
-0.9745345115661621,
0.45845305919647217,
0.04065350070595741,
-0.12416218221187592,
-1.165229320526123,
-0.17114396393299103,
0.08156448602676392,
-0.8866869211196899,
0.01376317534595728,
-0.03736267611384392,
-0.7789315581321716,
-0.3244972229003906,
-0.533200740814209,
-0.4015670418739319,
0.6626670956611633,
-0.2134803980588913,
0.7757324576377869,
0.679215669631958,
-0.2127223163843155,
-0.47405630350112915,
-0.6104499101638794,
0.29417160153388977,
-0.745833694934845,
-0.8178524971008301,
0.09656035900115967,
0.3014782965183258,
-0.5199368000030518,
0.19726955890655518,
-0.0944206640124321,
0.24096645414829254,
0.13061439990997314,
0.21330398321151733,
0.02811780385673046,
-0.023490674793720245,
-0.025739677250385284,
-0.1405801773071289,
-0.12601198256015778,
0.3560578227043152,
0.06352659314870834,
0.34846144914627075,
-0.8536198139190674,
-0.1964300274848938,
-0.3553544580936432,
0.32796066999435425,
0.8753899335861206,
-0.052746765315532684,
0.9464980959892273,
0.8042047619819641,
-0.389315128326416,
0.1511685699224472,
-0.6369287967681885,
-0.07960637658834457,
-0.5028347969055176,
0.4257126450538635,
0.0970396026968956,
-0.8716628551483154,
0.659723699092865,
-0.10525695234537125,
-0.14188925921916962,
0.618095874786377,
0.5799758434295654,
-0.1990862339735031,
1.1296906471252441,
0.5867782831192017,
-0.4988883435726166,
0.4127793610095978,
-0.07716400921344757,
0.41662564873695374,
-0.43920835852622986,
-0.004130899906158447,
-0.4268994927406311,
-0.1406683325767517,
-0.93675696849823,
0.04586738720536232,
0.2527063190937042,
-0.19486597180366516,
-0.2838982045650482,
0.10111305862665176,
-0.4412344694137573,
0.18781901895999908,
0.1461583971977234,
0.0015484156319871545,
0.19063492119312286,
0.11450047791004181,
0.23791873455047607,
-0.08098699152469635,
-0.36589309573173523,
-1.2365567684173584,
0.9038843512535095,
0.5041598081588745,
0.5071544051170349,
0.08766573667526245,
0.6930818557739258,
0.6235696077346802,
0.5725342035293579,
-0.6999472379684448,
0.6451404094696045,
-0.2799331843852997,
-0.4774834215641022,
-0.2514615058898926,
-0.45279815793037415,
-0.5528129935264587,
0.22859948873519897,
-0.04144686833024025,
-0.5985433459281921,
-0.46985143423080444,
-0.11835829168558121,
-0.279526948928833,
0.47944000363349915,
-0.7889745235443115,
0.8300434350967407,
-0.16132515668869019,
-0.24493694305419922,
-0.21925164759159088,
-0.36701035499572754,
-0.02590039186179638,
0.24430754780769348,
0.19604268670082092,
-0.14517313241958618,
-0.10350925475358963,
0.9306965470314026,
-0.15761935710906982,
0.7252588272094727,
-0.34836652874946594,
0.10599344968795776,
0.44292566180229187,
-0.5730226635932922,
0.47528329491615295,
-0.03133797645568848,
-0.09910765290260315,
0.46803969144821167,
-0.10503807663917542,
-0.3751148581504822,
-0.27112919092178345,
0.8264513611793518,
-1.0647075176239014,
-0.34308353066444397,
-0.5851063132286072,
0.23947325348854065,
-0.3541536033153534,
-0.2540719509124756,
0.24335463345050812,
-0.06599994003772736,
-0.5056524872779846,
0.2546882927417755,
0.38916707038879395,
-0.1604444831609726,
0.44862979650497437,
0.1917693167924881,
0.0889059379696846,
-0.47973284125328064,
0.819405734539032,
0.3933389186859131,
0.23561160266399384,
0.019646907225251198,
0.22099089622497559,
-0.6313682794570923,
-0.18827329576015472,
-0.13193918764591217,
0.2973981201648712,
-0.6676404476165771,
-0.11312934011220932,
-0.6900616884231567,
-0.20027826726436615,
-0.4476693868637085,
-0.1358715444803238,
-0.3891568183898926,
-0.008957765065133572,
-0.1476716846227646,
-0.41641104221343994,
0.5942539572715759,
0.9640589356422424,
0.05990035459399223,
0.3909097909927368,
-0.6173161864280701,
0.23305363953113556,
0.45400118827819824,
0.3673161268234253,
-0.24192644655704498,
-0.24864642322063446,
-0.009269081056118011,
-0.1881731152534485,
-0.6643840670585632,
-1.2099332809448242,
0.524124026298523,
-0.039750367403030396,
0.5070708990097046,
0.4609234631061554,
-0.4494743347167969,
0.5707049369812012,
-0.049210209399461746,
1.0672080516815186,
-0.07963065803050995,
-1.0991907119750977,
0.38574010133743286,
-0.6782134175300598,
-0.22223985195159912,
0.5712367296218872,
0.28637269139289856,
-0.9447059631347656,
-0.3321114182472229,
-1.006880760192871,
-0.9918758273124695,
0.22269907593727112,
0.04270901903510094,
-0.06147775799036026,
-0.09605079889297485,
0.19915829598903656,
-0.2212725281715393,
0.3869992196559906,
-0.5099601149559021,
-0.10127007961273193,
-0.013144632801413536,
-0.03833220899105072,
-0.21677227318286896,
-0.2531954348087311,
0.085807666182518,
-0.050315920263528824,
0.6024166345596313,
0.015473300591111183,
0.3995974361896515,
-0.0739535242319107,
0.16459672152996063,
-0.06355872005224228,
0.3575406074523926,
0.2784968614578247,
0.624487042427063,
-0.2375245988368988,
-0.10433913767337799,
0.29406657814979553,
-0.41608014702796936,
0.018768204376101494,
-0.07254228740930557,
-0.05790351331233978,
0.07085689902305603,
0.12198265641927719,
0.4777924120426178,
-0.04552995413541794,
-0.2564105987548828,
0.46276620030403137,
-0.19488973915576935,
-0.428931325674057,
-0.4070482850074768,
-0.2306244671344757,
0.37527161836624146,
0.15828098356723785,
0.3173086643218994,
0.1738082617521286,
0.14250610768795013,
-0.48209336400032043,
0.045445386320352554,
0.2764160633087158,
-0.6406382918357849,
-0.44742536544799805,
0.46644994616508484,
0.2984625995159149,
-0.295175164937973,
0.530296802520752,
-0.2992543876171112,
-0.6480244398117065,
0.6335495114326477,
-0.07985681295394897,
1.2363981008529663,
-0.17990818619728088,
0.3413340747356415,
0.44038063287734985,
0.3585962951183319,
-0.4249950051307678,
0.5147632360458374,
0.4328419268131256,
-0.7332954406738281,
-0.5078362822532654,
-0.5681883692741394,
-0.4717537462711334,
0.32729092240333557,
-0.7922315001487732,
0.18177717924118042,
-0.3448624312877655,
-0.5952702760696411,
-0.21657301485538483,
0.4337776303291321,
-0.8510948419570923,
0.15597069263458252,
0.16556301712989807,
0.4200819730758667,
-1.3940926790237427,
0.4222824275493622,
0.8889017105102539,
-0.20015236735343933,
-0.6067174673080444,
0.215439572930336,
0.26011383533477783,
-0.5281199812889099,
0.1522779017686844,
0.3739917278289795,
-0.5006517767906189,
-0.1270386278629303,
-0.5163245797157288,
-0.3804353177547455,
1.1477792263031006,
0.10327350348234177,
-0.27875980734825134,
0.26493650674819946,
-0.006445157341659069,
0.9452154636383057,
-0.09854499995708466,
0.05460455268621445,
0.6896867752075195,
0.6230560541152954,
-0.23158584535121918,
-0.7586073279380798,
-0.13481877744197845,
-0.19679395854473114,
0.09453251212835312,
0.07020818442106247,
-0.8872113227844238,
0.4777941405773163,
0.15212129056453705,
-0.4787435531616211,
-0.2780870497226715,
0.44257229566574097,
0.4316014349460602,
0.3547859191894531,
0.5839726328849792,
0.6606028079986572,
0.7060406804084778,
-0.3723551034927368,
1.2948299646377563,
-0.3651859760284424,
0.9436625242233276,
0.3279936611652374,
-0.289673388004303,
0.9062802791595459,
0.6577444076538086,
-0.49809035658836365,
0.20144863426685333,
0.7605873346328735,
0.13885413110256195,
0.5360973477363586,
0.12767736613750458,
-0.3964552581310272,
-0.0665571391582489,
-0.11052578687667847,
-0.28529804944992065,
0.35301265120506287,
0.4692789912223816,
-0.42574334144592285,
-0.1388726830482483,
-0.2684054672718048,
0.007584599778056145,
0.17069941759109497,
-0.33067724108695984,
0.8533090949058533,
0.14103543758392334,
-0.395815908908844,
0.02953440323472023,
0.13882532715797424,
0.9261288642883301,
-0.38255974650382996,
0.12766827642917633,
-0.02946508675813675,
0.07598105818033218,
-0.13932041823863983,
-0.9781073331832886,
0.660433292388916,
0.30448105931282043,
0.28660422563552856,
-0.3760908544063568,
0.8365331292152405,
0.11664050817489624,
-0.612628161907196,
0.5686882734298706,
0.8258370161056519,
0.1417669951915741,
-0.30236107110977173,
-0.8941372036933899,
0.04125514626502991,
-0.24628689885139465,
-0.5913721919059753,
0.15341700613498688,
0.6270043253898621,
0.2525993287563324,
0.5291954278945923,
0.32002612948417664,
0.26295700669288635,
-0.1994686871767044,
0.28600001335144043,
0.7674811482429504,
-0.7786630392074585,
-0.46916550397872925,
-1.180699348449707,
0.4012243449687958,
-0.454814076423645,
-0.3022499084472656,
0.751102089881897,
0.2801658809185028,
0.7585457563400269,
-0.049679242074489594,
1.151206135749817,
-0.20096930861473083,
0.6849780082702637,
-0.2129065841436386,
0.973929226398468,
-0.3163711428642273,
0.07916756719350815,
-0.5981209874153137,
-0.7872850894927979,
-0.027824819087982178,
0.7627090215682983,
-0.5593353509902954,
0.30094069242477417,
0.49436479806900024,
0.9942255616188049,
0.14259321987628937,
0.044050998985767365,
0.23933719098567963,
-0.07533298432826996,
0.4392264485359192,
0.27202698588371277,
1.010035753250122,
-0.3320944309234619,
0.33069726824760437,
0.12071862071752548,
-0.06716299802064896,
-0.15465664863586426,
-1.0293208360671997,
-0.8611894249916077,
-0.5274083018302917,
-0.2717416286468506,
-0.5287368893623352,
0.22534258663654327,
0.7180721163749695,
0.3919244408607483,
-0.6346685886383057,
-0.05083846300840378,
0.039745889604091644,
0.007830921560525894,
-0.3206094801425934,
-0.3400228023529053,
0.3696325123310089,
-0.07023544609546661,
-0.551226019859314,
-0.2804083526134491,
0.35177433490753174,
-0.05314323306083679,
-0.3512563109397888,
-0.055469803512096405,
0.2016909420490265,
0.18460288643836975,
0.7440831065177917,
0.14127768576145172,
-0.7619931697845459,
-0.6907986998558044,
0.20146872103214264,
-0.24014364182949066,
-0.04425397887825966,
0.6247285604476929,
-0.36236435174942017,
0.09204376488924026,
0.5611653327941895,
0.6103115677833557,
0.2801920771598816,
0.2628035247325897,
0.24671736359596252,
-0.5621501207351685,
-0.37414324283599854,
0.22258728742599487,
0.3879563808441162,
0.7422307133674622,
-0.2230105996131897,
0.591353714466095,
0.31430819630622864,
-0.8080105185508728,
-0.49046871066093445,
0.09117055684328079,
-1.030447244644165,
0.015966076403856277,
1.5666520595550537,
0.06525726616382599,
-0.09749013185501099,
0.07779234647750854,
-0.2669033110141754,
0.1902456283569336,
-0.7355791330337524,
1.2905937433242798,
1.174106240272522,
-0.1073574647307396,
-0.020372072234749794,
-0.6994454860687256,
0.46189841628074646,
-0.05738463252782822,
-0.7990737557411194,
-0.19434437155723572,
0.09578673541545868,
0.37054258584976196,
0.011645613238215446,
0.7932173013687134,
-0.4707796573638916,
0.00030621339101344347,
-0.15580181777477264,
-0.039522625505924225,
0.21215276420116425,
0.07485540211200714,
-0.5100550651550293,
0.36699923872947693,
0.028328953310847282,
-0.1341923475265503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16929v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16929v2
|
LangGPT: Rethinking Structured Reusable Prompt Design Framework for LLMs from the Programming Language
| 2024-02-26T15:05:16 | 2024-06-29T14:19:08 |
Ming Wang, Yuanzhong Liu, Xiaoyu Liang, Songlian Li, Yijie Huang, Xiaoming Zhang, Sijia Shen, Chaofeng Guan, Daling Wang, Shi Feng, Huaiwen Zhang, Yifei Zhang, Minghui Zheng, Chi Zhang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
LLMs have demonstrated commendable performance across diverse domains.
Nevertheless, formulating high-quality prompts to instruct LLMs proficiently
poses a challenge for non-AI experts. Existing research in prompt engineering
suggests somewhat scattered optimization principles and designs empirically
dependent prompt optimizers. Unfortunately, these endeavors lack a structured
design template, incurring high learning costs and resulting in low
reusability. In addition, it is not conducive to the iterative updating of
prompts. Inspired by structured reusable programming languages, we propose
LangGPT, a dual-layer prompt design framework as the programming language for
LLMs. LangGPT has an easy-to-learn normative structure and provides an extended
structure for migration and reuse. Experiments illustrate that LangGPT
significantly enhances the performance of LLMs. Moreover, the case study shows
that LangGPT leads LLMs to generate higher-quality responses. Furthermore, we
analyzed the ease of use and reusability of LangGPT through a user survey in
our online community.
|
[
-0.2838782072067261,
-0.8214374780654907,
0.7006329298019409,
0.4931384027004242,
-0.3129790723323822,
0.38087236881256104,
-0.09197039902210236,
-0.09708963334560394,
0.10293389111757278,
0.2513006329536438,
-0.7352254390716553,
-0.5952562093734741,
-0.12038130313158035,
0.19494573771953583,
-0.010801929049193859,
0.9330866932868958,
-0.13910573720932007,
-0.19433356821537018,
-0.22644244134426117,
0.007722131442278624,
-0.5641373991966248,
-0.414590448141098,
-1.186073899269104,
-0.09546208381652832,
0.8939740061759949,
0.3687959313392639,
0.40409329533576965,
0.2875494956970215,
0.1572771519422531,
0.20864082872867584,
-0.08386311680078506,
-0.012279774993658066,
-0.27044910192489624,
0.32746976613998413,
0.15277543663978577,
-0.2721116244792938,
-0.49087798595428467,
-0.227579265832901,
0.45156410336494446,
0.7715516686439514,
-0.23248085379600525,
0.04390835762023926,
0.4405542016029358,
0.6383992433547974,
-0.2122192233800888,
0.5328856706619263,
-0.16877005994319916,
0.2535145580768585,
0.08909006416797638,
-0.4445515275001526,
-0.39516884088516235,
-0.5842212438583374,
-0.10560814291238785,
-0.720233142375946,
0.1461760699748993,
0.2656124234199524,
0.04042059928178787,
0.253362238407135,
-0.21716958284378052,
-0.40552660822868347,
-0.2548086941242218,
0.5514584183692932,
-0.5065654516220093,
0.34828081727027893,
-0.18982264399528503,
0.4048587381839752,
-0.32615554332733154,
-0.7276932001113892,
-0.050948865711688995,
-0.5091701745986938,
-0.13615082204341888,
0.21441270411014557,
0.11920522153377533,
0.13529928028583527,
0.2143673598766327,
0.21957208216190338,
-0.8886839747428894,
0.29276907444000244,
0.10160500556230545,
-0.2581820785999298,
0.2699064016342163,
0.2934955954551697,
0.6381180882453918,
-0.005781077314168215,
-0.6121030449867249,
0.2665746808052063,
-0.9910362362861633,
0.4906212091445923,
0.39207586646080017,
0.6379510164260864,
-0.1393997073173523,
0.24546486139297485,
0.012361008673906326,
0.72940993309021,
-0.05793044716119766,
-0.2040330022573471,
0.06506085395812988,
-0.11471905559301376,
0.06556400656700134,
0.03179055452346802,
0.5580787658691406,
0.48425084352493286,
0.13040021061897278,
-0.09274230897426605,
-0.5064294934272766,
-0.3542344868183136,
0.1453438550233841,
-0.8809341788291931,
-0.34560146927833557,
0.1424509435892105,
-0.5172964334487915,
-0.3003719449043274,
-0.20414161682128906,
-0.7647911906242371,
-0.42688700556755066,
-0.31273066997528076,
-0.10182253271341324,
-0.11000814288854599,
-0.20298418402671814,
0.1169586256146431,
0.051429178565740585,
0.16927222907543182,
0.5387471318244934,
-0.7556336522102356,
-0.05841381475329399,
0.8320262432098389,
0.8086966276168823,
-0.22913949191570282,
-0.19949404895305634,
-0.5207412242889404,
-0.22236871719360352,
-0.06455905735492706,
0.974768877029419,
-0.5322727560997009,
-0.8232669234275818,
0.025825925171375275,
0.010348971001803875,
0.0211078692227602,
-0.27605876326560974,
0.6684161424636841,
-0.6221883893013,
0.5261502861976624,
-0.4243547320365906,
-0.443363755941391,
0.149461567401886,
0.25301459431648254,
-0.5092988610267639,
0.8588218092918396,
0.2901061177253723,
-0.5415918827056885,
0.43344229459762573,
-0.649993896484375,
-0.47848421335220337,
0.4811294674873352,
-0.19641247391700745,
-0.36073607206344604,
0.15659119188785553,
0.3303305208683014,
0.030105730518698692,
-0.26257070899009705,
0.35021069645881653,
0.056099358946084976,
-0.5326066613197327,
0.05498170107603073,
-0.4625348448753357,
0.7597041726112366,
0.38230496644973755,
-0.009531368501484394,
0.2640431821346283,
-0.7180836796760559,
0.19910815358161926,
-0.09659393876791,
-0.9837154150009155,
0.12056693434715271,
0.022576238960027695,
0.03623579442501068,
-0.03425750508904457,
0.2075428068637848,
-0.4477105140686035,
0.44472625851631165,
-0.3043122887611389,
0.5628532767295837,
0.9075772762298584,
0.054230742156505585,
0.5479799509048462,
-0.38681671023368835,
0.9151940941810608,
-0.46429646015167236,
0.14048916101455688,
-0.29436084628105164,
-0.5508280396461487,
-0.41679495573043823,
-0.3745432496070862,
-0.20676164329051971,
0.8098830580711365,
-0.8427454829216003,
0.12039835751056671,
0.13120640814304352,
-0.20991221070289612,
-0.2241193950176239,
0.14746366441249847,
0.24323219060897827,
0.7278598546981812,
0.23743557929992676,
-0.036248330026865005,
-0.4197327494621277,
-0.7229362726211548,
-0.4517594873905182,
-0.3673170804977417,
-0.2887726128101349,
0.4167104661464691,
-0.003954988904297352,
-0.13394050300121307,
1.0055630207061768,
-0.41353824734687805,
0.2687700390815735,
-0.5383443832397461,
-0.017634529620409012,
0.5192430019378662,
0.41584765911102295,
0.4684353172779083,
-0.43439918756484985,
-0.5747020244598389,
-0.33983829617500305,
-0.8495346307754517,
-0.7320889830589294,
-0.2615997791290283,
0.04366658255457878,
0.0037522315979003906,
0.4218677282333374,
-0.6374941468238831,
-0.0014344806550070643,
0.07331386208534241,
-0.2049223780632019,
0.8009083271026611,
-0.03463105112314224,
0.16306544840335846,
-1.0591553449630737,
0.03605091571807861,
-0.165705606341362,
-0.08635582774877548,
-0.4356669485569,
0.21160195767879486,
0.06970848143100739,
-0.6525211334228516,
-0.6288489103317261,
0.846819281578064,
-0.6098143458366394,
-0.07604910433292389,
-0.35614168643951416,
0.08821715414524078,
0.08506642282009125,
0.5802075862884521,
-0.23990780115127563,
1.2097713947296143,
0.6248098015785217,
-0.41830703616142273,
0.5610618591308594,
0.0674658715724945,
-0.2570330500602722,
0.9250440001487732,
-0.9980517029762268,
0.2393772453069687,
-0.4073856472969055,
0.30498331785202026,
-1.1118069887161255,
-0.0653739869594574,
0.5135184526443481,
-0.1952480673789978,
0.26214298605918884,
-0.36477363109588623,
-0.2885970175266266,
-0.2971692383289337,
-0.474267840385437,
0.4204185903072357,
0.7532960772514343,
-0.6622220873832703,
0.3564382791519165,
-0.10377143323421478,
-0.5533758997917175,
-0.4125627279281616,
-0.4265957474708557,
0.29841288924217224,
-0.3148636221885681,
-0.7353826761245728,
0.07588255405426025,
-0.20187623798847198,
-0.0662032812833786,
-0.18481190502643585,
-0.25246527791023254,
0.26007041335105896,
0.2405649572610855,
0.07704697549343109,
0.033187370747327805,
-0.4278215765953064,
0.3105616867542267,
-0.08885160833597183,
-0.40734732151031494,
0.22715571522712708,
-0.5644674897193909,
0.44973060488700867,
-0.19165128469467163,
-0.5762609839439392,
-0.5016841292381287,
0.6926301717758179,
0.31628209352493286,
0.04058453068137169,
0.34067481756210327,
0.45642831921577454,
-0.005351365078240633,
-0.4216999113559723,
-0.3097919225692749,
-0.08716605603694916,
-0.5757882595062256,
0.3297460675239563,
-0.6161288022994995,
-1.0736051797866821,
0.4701722264289856,
-0.16647285223007202,
0.27946141362190247,
-0.19697709381580353,
0.3570304214954376,
-0.1915811449289322,
0.6358348727226257,
0.6073570847511292,
0.03793954849243164,
0.7356212139129639,
0.3334895074367523,
0.4578867256641388,
-0.5971778035163879,
-0.31475400924682617,
-0.36087414622306824,
-0.21707622706890106,
-0.3114627003669739,
-0.25779274106025696,
0.42300355434417725,
0.09381674975156784,
-0.4158857762813568,
0.04030127450823784,
-0.6619342565536499,
0.5772523283958435,
0.5928558111190796,
-0.009049570187926292,
0.13262085616588593,
0.14366286993026733,
-0.025348911061882973,
-0.03183843567967415,
-0.7662482857704163,
-0.8567398190498352,
0.5675974488258362,
0.2915073335170746,
1.19057297706604,
0.2064169943332672,
0.7707564830780029,
0.2856644093990326,
0.28890663385391235,
-0.8041182160377502,
0.7984687685966492,
0.018561221659183502,
0.01305041927844286,
-0.08996009826660156,
-0.42430388927459717,
-0.8858345150947571,
0.10900174826383591,
0.4751867949962616,
-0.4926536977291107,
-0.10204572975635529,
0.18367193639278412,
-0.4579019248485565,
0.26069769263267517,
-0.8214899897575378,
0.7663009166717529,
-0.33343741297721863,
-0.39851388335227966,
0.3723849058151245,
-0.46413514018058777,
0.024350184947252274,
0.07002213597297668,
0.03815102204680443,
-0.10194770246744156,
-0.22285690903663635,
0.5122787356376648,
-0.617891252040863,
1.083718180656433,
-0.35484543442726135,
-0.460214763879776,
0.42005476355552673,
0.19780509173870087,
0.4926724135875702,
0.588576078414917,
-0.10975543409585953,
-0.42104482650756836,
-0.2852572500705719,
-0.39610788226127625,
-0.86849445104599,
0.8004835844039917,
-0.5145596265792847,
-0.9314689636230469,
-0.14466120302677155,
-0.3005100190639496,
-0.06349138915538788,
0.09097179025411606,
0.12703868746757507,
0.6844316124916077,
-0.22534452378749847,
-0.1623108834028244,
0.5687227249145508,
-0.505705714225769,
0.49467429518699646,
0.43334370851516724,
-0.10489914566278458,
-0.17181940376758575,
0.8790566325187683,
-0.26697126030921936,
0.1793963462114334,
0.5138900279998779,
0.09831975400447845,
-0.5207442045211792,
-0.3957724869251251,
-0.7115607857704163,
-0.18257175385951996,
-0.7805185317993164,
0.046876851469278336,
-0.4874266982078552,
-0.20824378728866577,
-0.18857470154762268,
-0.6547092795372009,
-0.045428838580846786,
-0.39535894989967346,
-0.46708619594573975,
-0.23360125720500946,
0.22555294632911682,
0.4023647904396057,
0.03542642295360565,
0.37751251459121704,
-0.4960881769657135,
0.03833113983273506,
0.4435111880302429,
0.42979228496551514,
-0.16256900131702423,
-0.17682838439941406,
0.29923292994499207,
-0.29126960039138794,
-0.05174482613801956,
-0.7259854078292847,
0.1341499388217926,
0.052018821239471436,
0.8826446533203125,
-0.02175181731581688,
-0.09537903219461441,
0.21340900659561157,
-0.5002829432487488,
1.0337361097335815,
0.11908149719238281,
-0.6009625792503357,
0.6805541515350342,
-0.41951191425323486,
0.4981091320514679,
0.4621719717979431,
0.12049727141857147,
-0.8822948932647705,
-0.17698021233081818,
-0.19930627942085266,
-0.9760181903839111,
0.38699251413345337,
-0.1558089554309845,
0.25720852613449097,
0.0385289192199707,
0.6351915597915649,
0.3816449046134949,
0.3816136121749878,
-0.6631380319595337,
-0.19111023843288422,
-0.47437745332717896,
-0.22716520726680756,
0.016463663429021835,
-0.6097201108932495,
-0.00024314112670253962,
0.18922895193099976,
0.357433021068573,
-0.20008043944835663,
0.5206893086433411,
-0.02764439769089222,
-0.12300287932157516,
0.31172850728034973,
0.6695964336395264,
0.4421967566013336,
0.5589874386787415,
-0.08396175503730774,
0.3813415765762329,
0.023105960339307785,
-0.25149643421173096,
0.4612056612968445,
-0.1490127593278885,
-0.3710881769657135,
-0.2545713186264038,
0.44574546813964844,
0.7157148122787476,
0.35416021943092346,
-0.4543974697589874,
0.2782835066318512,
-0.14612089097499847,
0.00159071187954396,
-0.21850787103176117,
0.10027942806482315,
0.052380576729774475,
0.1120355948805809,
0.19756324589252472,
-0.06995376199483871,
-0.04443808272480965,
-0.39148709177970886,
0.29262247681617737,
0.2552286684513092,
-0.25242871046066284,
-0.2570857107639313,
0.8838853240013123,
0.6725217700004578,
-0.8412519693374634,
0.6878681778907776,
-0.39500075578689575,
-0.4813021123409271,
0.45010966062545776,
0.6478881239891052,
0.9284603595733643,
0.055844977498054504,
0.461164265871048,
0.3708457946777344,
0.21343961358070374,
0.1245603933930397,
0.4217866361141205,
-0.1767924576997757,
-0.32206833362579346,
-0.2780863344669342,
-0.505262017250061,
-0.4271399676799774,
-0.2741166055202484,
-0.13251537084579468,
0.1670871376991272,
-0.7861828207969666,
-0.05138185992836952,
-0.7224008440971375,
-0.13022036850452423,
-0.44145631790161133,
-0.22256478667259216,
-0.025092046707868576,
0.8856335878372192,
-0.7169782519340515,
0.2629942297935486,
0.8233652710914612,
-0.4406544268131256,
-0.6667358875274658,
-0.13880984485149384,
0.243307963013649,
-1.0286970138549805,
0.5215288996696472,
0.22329284250736237,
-0.13189290463924408,
0.07975446432828903,
-0.36778298020362854,
-0.5186742544174194,
1.0012260675430298,
0.3734343647956848,
-0.3878895342350006,
-0.10811666399240494,
0.08651865273714066,
0.40289542078971863,
-0.25476863980293274,
0.1994873583316803,
0.2573355436325073,
0.3651652932167053,
0.17667117714881897,
-0.6645606160163879,
0.34823906421661377,
-0.3234105706214905,
0.05306077003479004,
0.06729467213153839,
-0.6763546466827393,
1.0143623352050781,
-0.2854413688182831,
-0.6238003969192505,
0.2622397243976593,
0.37443670630455017,
0.5410282611846924,
0.3024502396583557,
0.22950837016105652,
0.24432863295078278,
0.9111694097518921,
-0.07244442403316498,
0.8663293719291687,
-0.32311058044433594,
0.2735147774219513,
0.8353078365325928,
-0.24806581437587738,
0.20583270490169525,
0.5292679071426392,
-0.23748236894607544,
0.4474554657936096,
0.8154429793357849,
0.15621498227119446,
0.5000117421150208,
0.5411347150802612,
-0.6649798154830933,
-0.27215316891670227,
-0.091635562479496,
-0.562093198299408,
-0.19096580147743225,
0.12058982253074646,
-0.05769549310207367,
-0.591047465801239,
-0.0889393612742424,
0.06818555295467377,
-0.01337351556867361,
-0.14920315146446228,
0.5348759293556213,
0.2901790738105774,
-0.545170783996582,
0.3255927860736847,
-0.08360181003808975,
0.7150242924690247,
-0.4181550145149231,
-0.024377433583140373,
-0.698941171169281,
-0.11473841965198517,
-0.1791020929813385,
-1.0166512727737427,
0.05406498163938522,
-0.01767883263528347,
-0.11847139149904251,
-0.8399899005889893,
0.8325138092041016,
-0.15982738137245178,
-0.4913208782672882,
-0.05840987339615822,
0.9882068634033203,
0.28771916031837463,
0.07007738202810287,
-0.7847324013710022,
0.04811728000640869,
0.03781358152627945,
-0.4372728168964386,
0.18097002804279327,
0.4677886664867401,
0.012431958690285683,
0.939294695854187,
0.6551010608673096,
-0.047714054584503174,
-0.07339281588792801,
0.4710067808628082,
0.8352110385894775,
-0.5996590256690979,
-0.6581432223320007,
-0.855145275592804,
0.5447070598602295,
0.049436941742897034,
-0.22875426709651947,
0.6061349511146545,
0.5234090089797974,
0.4689764082431793,
-0.1763576716184616,
0.9032872319221497,
-0.014313499443233013,
0.3007194399833679,
-0.7156754732131958,
0.5421020984649658,
-0.41044485569000244,
0.7103216052055359,
-0.18545421957969666,
-0.9940939545631409,
-0.4519979655742645,
0.5694474577903748,
-0.150391086935997,
0.3560057282447815,
0.5245677828788757,
1.0897107124328613,
0.03863256052136421,
0.06712941080331802,
0.16156171262264252,
-0.2704232335090637,
0.8962898850440979,
0.9828529357910156,
1.2472450733184814,
0.20049497485160828,
0.3033134639263153,
0.10053814202547073,
-0.4289996922016144,
-0.268682599067688,
-1.055504322052002,
-0.9487499594688416,
-0.32087698578834534,
-0.29729515314102173,
0.05207102373242378,
0.24818524718284607,
0.9978590607643127,
0.40031445026397705,
-0.4776192307472229,
-0.12569577991962433,
-0.1846199780702591,
0.3807513117790222,
0.001880057156085968,
-0.2756281793117523,
0.3677266836166382,
-0.6934511661529541,
-0.36207467317581177,
0.7075682282447815,
0.3143988251686096,
0.2757106125354767,
-0.1257660835981369,
0.016194725409150124,
0.43054619431495667,
-0.35079315304756165,
0.7628856301307678,
0.46603113412857056,
-0.5610803365707397,
-0.4638228118419647,
0.2260742336511612,
-0.28404268622398376,
0.12185309827327728,
1.1542619466781616,
-0.712722897529602,
0.07521457970142365,
0.6443432569503784,
0.8048985600471497,
-0.1941402554512024,
0.22649428248405457,
0.6230192184448242,
-0.9397556781768799,
-0.01497092004865408,
0.1343051791191101,
0.4512192904949188,
0.3331647217273712,
-0.4953441321849823,
0.3374202847480774,
0.27669650316238403,
-0.5821468830108643,
-0.6451308131217957,
0.4430960416793823,
-0.9649344682693481,
-0.21522729098796844,
1.1996214389801025,
-0.12500612437725067,
-0.03014034405350685,
-0.3185581564903259,
-0.6987835168838501,
-0.15259726345539093,
-0.7176321744918823,
0.6165656447410583,
0.5465068221092224,
-0.4503403902053833,
-0.7118708491325378,
-0.4751700162887573,
0.5352475643157959,
0.28044813871383667,
-0.7404118776321411,
0.08498982340097427,
0.620998203754425,
0.6245414614677429,
-0.25809547305107117,
1.0010796785354614,
0.11828760802745819,
0.24100469052791595,
0.01933194138109684,
-0.11110616475343704,
-0.45003288984298706,
-0.2799729108810425,
-0.22962097823619843,
0.5517710447311401,
0.39495712518692017,
-0.07083991169929504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16632v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16632v1
|
Domain Embeddings for Generating Complex Descriptions of Concepts in Italian Language
| 2024-02-26T15:04:35 | 2024-02-26T15:04:35 |
Alessandro Maisto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we propose a Distributional Semantic resource enriched with
linguistic and lexical information extracted from electronic dictionaries,
designed to address the challenge of bridging the gap between the continuous
semantic values represented by distributional vectors and the discrete
descriptions offered by general semantics theory. Recently, many researchers
have concentrated on the nexus between embeddings and a comprehensive theory of
semantics and meaning. This often involves decoding the representation of word
meanings in Distributional Models into a set of discrete, manually constructed
properties such as semantic primitives or features, using neural decoding
techniques. Our approach introduces an alternative strategy grounded in
linguistic data. We have developed a collection of domain-specific
co-occurrence matrices, derived from two sources: a classification of Italian
nouns categorized into 4 semantic traits and 20 concrete noun sub-categories,
and a list of Italian verbs classified according to their semantic classes. In
these matrices, the co-occurrence values for each word are calculated
exclusively with a defined set of words pertinent to a particular lexical
domain. The resource comprises 21 domain-specific matrices, one comprehensive
matrix, and a Graphical User Interface. Our model facilitates the generation of
reasoned semantic descriptions of concepts by selecting matrices directly
associated with concrete conceptual knowledge, such as a matrix based on
location nouns and the concept of animal habitats. We assessed the utility of
the resource through two experiments, achieving promising outcomes in both: the
automatic classification of animal nouns and the extraction of animal features.
|
[
-0.7626124024391174,
-0.7209476232528687,
0.3910151720046997,
0.08251964300870895,
-0.3881150782108307,
0.001893243519589305,
-0.2494698017835617,
-0.41260603070259094,
0.5191470384597778,
0.09489767998456955,
-0.3173663318157196,
-0.5193002223968506,
-0.5193016529083252,
0.11835099756717682,
-0.34989145398139954,
0.8837219476699829,
-0.039021629840135574,
0.1812700629234314,
-0.2938658595085144,
-0.03194359689950943,
-0.22562694549560547,
-0.4408554434776306,
-0.25178784132003784,
-0.2659672200679779,
0.45650503039360046,
-0.17830733954906464,
0.5651615262031555,
0.6462761163711548,
0.485687255859375,
0.25320929288864136,
-0.0334358848631382,
0.4717954695224762,
-0.10106946527957916,
-0.1254056692123413,
-0.6003587245941162,
-0.24196897447109222,
-0.407173752784729,
-0.07476402074098587,
0.4570457637310028,
0.8189242482185364,
-0.264374315738678,
-0.2564440965652466,
-0.0178045816719532,
0.1566290259361267,
-0.8495880365371704,
0.4223659336566925,
-0.7292383909225464,
0.12197824567556381,
-0.015577835030853748,
-0.49437206983566284,
-0.2909269630908966,
-0.2166750282049179,
0.3458651006221771,
-0.7969833612442017,
0.2353602945804596,
-0.16674472391605377,
0.9929614663124084,
0.1704070121049881,
-0.16433121263980865,
-0.8872905373573303,
-0.6240015029907227,
0.6678467392921448,
-0.3252338171005249,
0.1559130698442459,
0.3642585575580597,
0.13855861127376556,
-0.23565831780433655,
-0.526495635509491,
-0.7884745001792908,
-0.29289573431015015,
-0.11531384289264679,
0.006731568835675716,
-0.1921035200357437,
-0.027239732444286346,
-0.2101786881685257,
0.34186869859695435,
-0.21787293255329132,
-0.1802837997674942,
0.04279987886548042,
-0.16269150376319885,
0.660409152507782,
0.19214285910129547,
0.5088576078414917,
0.04177746921777725,
-0.27247655391693115,
-0.1370658129453659,
-0.785651445388794,
-0.3955550789833069,
0.3252250552177429,
0.2404581904411316,
-0.11018405109643936,
0.8045682907104492,
-0.03138696402311325,
0.5795724391937256,
-0.08893299102783203,
-0.02414322830736637,
0.3421176075935364,
-0.36738064885139465,
0.1801585853099823,
0.04587957635521889,
0.5832046270370483,
0.2531786859035492,
0.31457963585853577,
-0.4455126225948334,
-0.12844721972942352,
0.28115972876548767,
0.33606868982315063,
-0.5264030694961548,
-0.03622125834226608,
-0.11402115225791931,
0.05641869455575943,
-0.19886131584644318,
0.1676858514547348,
-0.6293772459030151,
-0.123947374522686,
-0.2570723593235016,
0.28595006465911865,
-0.5605131983757019,
-0.2846052944660187,
0.4112011194229126,
-0.3405839502811432,
0.1693439781665802,
0.2734051048755646,
-0.9227349758148193,
0.4532175362110138,
0.5429428219795227,
0.8000128269195557,
-0.24946434795856476,
-0.06417491286993027,
0.10837819427251816,
0.6072220206260681,
-0.25942251086235046,
0.8164815306663513,
-0.6668502688407898,
-0.5673840641975403,
0.296317458152771,
-0.0692770704627037,
-0.03790324553847313,
-0.5959693789482117,
0.2137066274881363,
-0.4964689314365387,
-0.05223977938294411,
0.007267555221915245,
-0.8071019053459167,
-0.22728551924228668,
0.32577890157699585,
-0.8279323577880859,
0.6003682017326355,
-0.08431003987789154,
-0.8592468500137329,
0.2383352518081665,
-0.8293869495391846,
-0.46257561445236206,
0.17418566346168518,
-0.49756336212158203,
-0.16195838153362274,
0.2333085834980011,
-0.31134647130966187,
0.6785767078399658,
-0.3406999111175537,
0.2990535497665405,
-0.26471734046936035,
0.16669361293315887,
0.518910825252533,
-0.03790910542011261,
0.38276755809783936,
0.27528780698776245,
-0.5214005708694458,
-0.5348482131958008,
-0.7970432043075562,
0.020161837339401245,
0.09409395605325699,
-0.19077524542808533,
-0.7401038408279419,
0.39038243889808655,
-0.04368959367275238,
0.03350849449634552,
0.32661452889442444,
-0.44819164276123047,
0.04635391756892204,
-0.36467042565345764,
0.4708351492881775,
0.4237760603427887,
-0.09763479232788086,
0.5941739678382874,
0.010529099963605404,
0.2856835126876831,
0.5383682250976562,
-0.24259434640407562,
0.05614400655031204,
-0.3337002396583557,
-0.8173354268074036,
-0.49961626529693604,
0.22245419025421143,
0.5076526999473572,
-0.9060981869697571,
0.8173214793205261,
-0.4527231454849243,
-0.26611828804016113,
-0.23221957683563232,
-0.13229550421237946,
0.36277538537979126,
0.044871214777231216,
0.22570517659187317,
-0.2811989188194275,
-0.16413459181785583,
-1.0477869510650635,
0.31857675313949585,
0.05126788094639778,
0.18047845363616943,
0.4472362995147705,
0.7692971229553223,
-0.1770535111427307,
1.1106940507888794,
-0.7698063254356384,
-0.3191266655921936,
-0.13905075192451477,
0.05834036320447922,
-0.028161440044641495,
0.4914739429950714,
0.6250874400138855,
-0.8898270130157471,
-0.018917305395007133,
0.302358478307724,
-0.8913223743438721,
0.30552783608436584,
0.06090619042515755,
-0.28892186284065247,
-0.13501806557178497,
-0.09302996844053268,
-0.7215880155563354,
0.39792442321777344,
0.12287931144237518,
-0.28760647773742676,
0.06700441986322403,
-0.2652454376220703,
-0.1878191977739334,
-1.5111640691757202,
-0.09047486633062363,
0.050518739968538284,
0.11177603155374527,
-0.45395275950431824,
0.21487721800804138,
-0.35309645533561707,
0.15912215411663055,
-0.533599317073822,
0.5379054546356201,
-0.38931041955947876,
-0.05494635924696922,
0.0580856017768383,
0.2566913366317749,
0.08409718424081802,
0.3567325472831726,
0.5474755764007568,
0.6087172627449036,
0.4227384030818939,
-0.7798096537590027,
0.42788779735565186,
0.38560035824775696,
-0.22683674097061157,
0.5769620537757874,
-0.5512913465499878,
0.027937529608607292,
-0.03392798453569412,
0.06109840050339699,
-0.5077216625213623,
-0.06439171731472015,
0.34823891520500183,
-0.42253348231315613,
0.16730210185050964,
0.07653064280748367,
-0.5243406891822815,
0.022771822288632393,
-0.045960038900375366,
0.37986335158348083,
0.03576432168483734,
-0.22607074677944183,
0.4530593454837799,
0.7503477334976196,
-0.01237515639513731,
-0.3897587060928345,
-0.7284676432609558,
0.041713036596775055,
-0.27075400948524475,
-0.49052664637565613,
0.6029173135757446,
0.04672814533114433,
-0.40869230031967163,
0.32136979699134827,
0.3787391185760498,
-0.5265599489212036,
0.3272921144962311,
0.04225323721766472,
0.17858201265335083,
-0.051935505121946335,
0.4381955564022064,
0.29865899682044983,
0.05876375734806061,
-0.04256253316998482,
-0.5567507743835449,
0.5860046148300171,
0.06700822710990906,
-0.20583142340183258,
-0.36845898628234863,
0.7834132313728333,
0.1897391527891159,
-0.171900674700737,
0.771863579750061,
0.4870242774486542,
-0.7183288931846619,
-0.5573400855064392,
-0.043913621455430984,
-0.09629250317811966,
-0.3665691912174225,
0.3214370012283325,
-0.7594813108444214,
-0.68797767162323,
0.571643054485321,
-0.28098148107528687,
-0.21898168325424194,
0.5535039901733398,
0.6353312134742737,
-0.1469879150390625,
0.9055047631263733,
0.7316271066665649,
0.19604423642158508,
0.2512362003326416,
-0.8640488386154175,
0.3039817214012146,
-0.6929993033409119,
-0.6170525550842285,
-0.7108656167984009,
-0.1707807183265686,
-0.6238633394241333,
-0.46366310119628906,
0.2398284673690796,
0.06070021912455559,
-0.029635364189743996,
0.25511136651039124,
-0.47428786754608154,
0.1999654471874237,
0.38233983516693115,
0.19915711879730225,
0.17368313670158386,
0.4683678448200226,
-0.5608116984367371,
0.036935653537511826,
-0.646364688873291,
-0.7070761919021606,
0.7652402520179749,
0.06504034250974655,
0.803300142288208,
0.20509496331214905,
0.7336550951004028,
0.45821669697761536,
-0.12335507571697235,
-1.0273339748382568,
0.38665008544921875,
-0.37663733959198,
-0.6174893975257874,
-0.08861640840768814,
-0.3195664584636688,
-0.8352867960929871,
0.07640887796878815,
-0.10126082599163055,
-0.44653934240341187,
0.661932647228241,
-0.1606522649526596,
-0.20779837667942047,
0.22816039621829987,
-0.5101079344749451,
0.5084856152534485,
-0.02708013355731964,
-0.2767212390899658,
-0.4374904930591583,
-0.03680671751499176,
-0.08646921813488007,
-0.05041956156492233,
0.2969765067100525,
-0.16648127138614655,
-0.4002496898174286,
0.4281984865665436,
-0.5744147300720215,
0.8914618492126465,
-0.046785708516836166,
-0.2644179165363312,
0.445887953042984,
0.05509703978896141,
0.22708077728748322,
0.026819994673132896,
-0.08458248525857925,
0.25745847821235657,
0.09805919229984283,
-0.4040827453136444,
-0.5377503633499146,
0.6811091899871826,
-1.048798680305481,
-0.19787070155143738,
-0.36517855525016785,
-0.401777446269989,
-0.17306280136108398,
-0.12447536736726761,
0.262752890586853,
0.633003294467926,
-0.46950584650039673,
-0.07020270079374313,
0.6620583534240723,
-0.43045783042907715,
0.3301699757575989,
0.3338424265384674,
0.40017077326774597,
-0.43173232674598694,
1.032480001449585,
0.1975674033164978,
0.10889004170894623,
0.601664662361145,
-0.2042836844921112,
-0.36986595392227173,
-0.5059830546379089,
-0.4355866014957428,
0.11447219550609589,
-0.6315755248069763,
-0.24804072082042694,
-0.6599970459938049,
-0.13296067714691162,
-0.09152615815401077,
-0.1837102770805359,
-0.29034554958343506,
-0.635160505771637,
-0.41459208726882935,
-0.1836889237165451,
0.31977254152297974,
0.8574396967887878,
-0.1452029049396515,
0.24725915491580963,
-0.6606054306030273,
0.20465126633644104,
0.11391666531562805,
0.18850870430469513,
-0.030657446011900902,
-0.023976538330316544,
-0.6483769416809082,
0.36610180139541626,
-0.24557483196258545,
-0.8062987327575684,
0.6425616145133972,
0.5916220545768738,
0.7425886988639832,
0.4165858030319214,
0.023808984085917473,
0.6593956351280212,
-0.6497459411621094,
0.7947806119918823,
0.3514726161956787,
-0.9265232086181641,
0.6570590734481812,
-0.2787034213542938,
-0.34290191531181335,
0.29337164759635925,
0.6396386623382568,
-0.0501154363155365,
-0.21863839030265808,
-0.5833007097244263,
-0.7811086177825928,
0.49017900228500366,
0.271859735250473,
0.557191789150238,
-0.6574879884719849,
0.49737557768821716,
0.21610680222511292,
0.29766032099723816,
-0.321599543094635,
-0.2295398861169815,
-0.2915441691875458,
-0.43929600715637207,
-0.03520709276199341,
-0.13820327818393707,
-0.27421730756759644,
-0.22041377425193787,
0.5252891778945923,
-0.26543229818344116,
0.6592603325843811,
0.2139900028705597,
-0.4225159287452698,
0.41115573048591614,
0.15689189732074738,
0.5263592004776001,
0.5927239656448364,
0.15274818241596222,
0.490470826625824,
-0.05826421082019806,
-0.452990859746933,
0.3041728734970093,
-0.017470233142375946,
-0.2447633594274521,
0.47707557678222656,
0.27182435989379883,
0.6624240279197693,
0.23008263111114502,
-0.5611575841903687,
0.5399264097213745,
0.14078187942504883,
-0.007479301653802395,
-0.6959970593452454,
-0.12410511821508408,
0.17781522870063782,
0.16355235874652863,
0.14097853004932404,
-0.19045230746269226,
0.47244715690612793,
-0.6914947032928467,
0.38945016264915466,
0.3095392882823944,
-0.22329682111740112,
-0.6300703883171082,
0.23835358023643494,
0.2718621492385864,
0.02861107885837555,
0.5059501528739929,
-0.4838942885398865,
-0.43688708543777466,
0.7105876207351685,
0.49528464674949646,
0.9687625765800476,
-0.033569514751434326,
0.5828178524971008,
0.330608993768692,
-0.18865907192230225,
-0.021088218316435814,
0.2566807270050049,
-0.26153770089149475,
-1.4234561920166016,
-0.037777308374643326,
-0.8429840207099915,
-0.07129175961017609,
-0.3530997335910797,
-0.7386323809623718,
0.14330914616584778,
-0.4499320685863495,
-0.3668424189090729,
0.18390877544879913,
0.019660549238324165,
-0.661575436592102,
0.18331019580364227,
0.1667158007621765,
0.728351891040802,
-0.7913704514503479,
0.9668586850166321,
0.9369824528694153,
-0.6944496035575867,
-0.6615571975708008,
-0.3778632879257202,
-0.3244056701660156,
-0.6684380173683167,
1.0707331895828247,
-0.34212449193000793,
-0.28472721576690674,
0.05090600624680519,
-0.36609476804733276,
-0.6237243413925171,
1.1090452671051025,
0.4285350739955902,
-0.4574872553348541,
-0.09262203425168991,
0.5010411143302917,
0.6021217703819275,
-0.9017133116722107,
0.22430437803268433,
0.33165597915649414,
0.3394899368286133,
0.33926811814308167,
-0.5870057344436646,
-0.14945465326309204,
-0.48746851086616516,
0.25092238187789917,
-0.1531383991241455,
-0.21360309422016144,
0.7016939520835876,
-0.007589035667479038,
-0.4037243127822876,
0.1803172379732132,
0.42382240295410156,
-0.06260974705219269,
0.16306324303150177,
0.22162367403507233,
0.9598814845085144,
0.5571994185447693,
-0.26933395862579346,
1.130977749824524,
-0.40467098355293274,
0.4955548644065857,
0.8759673833847046,
-0.13748320937156677,
0.9129577875137329,
0.4620319604873657,
-0.19601354002952576,
0.7502819299697876,
0.7508200407028198,
-0.02139095589518547,
0.8803331851959229,
0.44018661975860596,
-0.7084866166114807,
-0.32429200410842896,
-0.6763836145401001,
-0.46542978286743164,
0.4611021876335144,
0.835533082485199,
-0.46532711386680603,
-0.306318998336792,
0.06752609461545944,
-0.10600516945123672,
0.06564778089523315,
-0.20918212831020355,
1.1102352142333984,
0.1819210946559906,
-0.20689402520656586,
0.5493781566619873,
-0.14333678781986237,
0.4428868591785431,
-0.42405980825424194,
-0.2924553155899048,
-0.16919513046741486,
0.32725051045417786,
-0.14720524847507477,
-0.6332007050514221,
0.43965157866477966,
-0.05666006729006767,
-0.26468876004219055,
-0.1752789169549942,
0.21738316118717194,
-0.4371437728404999,
-0.37576597929000854,
0.5007583498954773,
0.5735175609588623,
0.2925841510295868,
0.21502439677715302,
-0.6240834593772888,
-0.0738779827952385,
-0.3003670573234558,
0.0666581392288208,
0.07999137043952942,
0.7764337062835693,
-0.004164356738328934,
0.5548953413963318,
0.4091733992099762,
0.30391404032707214,
0.20605333149433136,
0.11724428087472916,
0.9838728308677673,
-0.6386898159980774,
-0.4311118423938751,
-0.694611668586731,
0.4448337256908417,
-0.13522331416606903,
-0.1747269183397293,
0.2329828292131424,
0.484784871339798,
1.0314452648162842,
-0.21231359243392944,
0.9109742045402527,
-0.40715423226356506,
-0.013164086267352104,
-0.4303639531135559,
0.6058882474899292,
-0.528675377368927,
0.22923268377780914,
0.09705030173063278,
-0.9934595823287964,
-0.2174990028142929,
0.8383168578147888,
-0.06559628993272781,
-0.2453460395336151,
0.7250229716300964,
0.8144664764404297,
0.060997795313596725,
-0.276155024766922,
0.3969653844833374,
0.19429722428321838,
0.11351963132619858,
0.41621363162994385,
1.0884253978729248,
-0.24080809950828552,
0.10571549832820892,
-0.142597958445549,
-0.024545593187212944,
0.040817975997924805,
-0.5298588871955872,
-0.6566447615623474,
-0.9058857560157776,
-0.34496474266052246,
-0.14602495729923248,
0.2835233509540558,
0.9176880717277527,
0.7279438376426697,
-0.9969561100006104,
-0.25779372453689575,
-0.19018685817718506,
0.15008258819580078,
0.03693057969212532,
-0.21633702516555786,
0.3120575249195099,
-0.5012909770011902,
-1.0114593505859375,
-0.030124107375741005,
0.30573055148124695,
0.004336053505539894,
-0.4954684376716614,
-0.21623419225215912,
-0.28319934010505676,
0.2036956548690796,
0.6638088822364807,
-0.11977896839380264,
-0.5546824932098389,
-0.3471214771270752,
-0.1267779916524887,
-0.23253685235977173,
-0.20181554555892944,
0.7395522594451904,
-0.545613706111908,
0.34456557035446167,
0.5692093372344971,
0.6552573442459106,
0.27831190824508667,
-0.4181640148162842,
0.7839354872703552,
-0.47820812463760376,
0.36677587032318115,
0.26096582412719727,
0.504443347454071,
0.24485114216804504,
-0.24657531082630157,
0.486458957195282,
0.5521517992019653,
0.2863767445087433,
-0.3964245319366455,
0.3588782548904419,
-1.0096334218978882,
-0.32120493054389954,
1.0122038125991821,
-0.7466140985488892,
-0.4064292907714844,
-0.07179056107997894,
0.1464841216802597,
0.2440938651561737,
-0.26173675060272217,
0.9113665223121643,
0.7713547945022583,
0.18561482429504395,
0.1356889009475708,
-0.24423407018184662,
0.48294031620025635,
-0.1625111699104309,
-0.7942174077033997,
-0.45353737473487854,
0.6678612232208252,
0.2560788691043854,
0.5613452792167664,
0.016533199697732925,
-0.41453853249549866,
0.13301682472229004,
0.04118170589208603,
0.3155497908592224,
0.06972628831863403,
-0.20456017553806305,
-0.08678320795297623,
0.20602817833423615,
-0.08755188435316086,
-0.30611181259155273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16617v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16617v2
|
Long-Context Language Modeling with Parallel Context Encoding
| 2024-02-26T14:47:35 | 2024-06-11T18:54:13 |
Howard Yen, Tianyu Gao, Danqi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extending large language models (LLMs) to process longer inputs is crucial
for a wide range of applications. However, the substantial computational cost
of transformers and limited generalization of positional encoding restrict the
size of their context window. We introduce Context Expansion with Parallel
Encoding (CEPE), a framework that can be applied to any existing decoder-only
LLMs to extend their context window. CEPE employs a small encoder to process
long inputs chunk by chunk, enabling the frozen decoder to utilize additional
contexts via cross-attention. CEPE is efficient, generalizable, and versatile:
trained with 8K-token documents, it extends the context window of LLAMA-2 to
128K tokens, offering 10x the throughput with only 1/6 of the memory. CEPE
yields strong performance on language modeling and in-context learning. CEPE
also excels in retrieval-augmented applications, while existing long-context
models degenerate with retrieved contexts. We further introduce a CEPE variant
that can extend the context window of instruction-tuned models using only
unlabeled data, and showcase its effectiveness on LLAMA-2-CHAT, leading to a
strong instruction-following model that can leverage very long contexts on
downstream tasks.
|
[
-0.22510719299316406,
-0.6504226326942444,
0.7757454514503479,
0.4528287351131439,
-0.22296416759490967,
-0.0763896256685257,
-0.8832502365112305,
-0.7337365746498108,
-0.04131714999675751,
0.4868738651275635,
-0.3113223910331726,
-0.4780867397785187,
-0.7915450930595398,
0.06789129227399826,
-0.4968258738517761,
0.4883976876735687,
0.03803922235965729,
-0.15280793607234955,
-0.2988930344581604,
0.0599697045981884,
-0.52711421251297,
-0.6563056111335754,
-0.5371049642562866,
-0.28343379497528076,
0.38589608669281006,
0.6971791982650757,
0.4035276174545288,
0.5895420908927917,
0.008542629890143871,
0.32404735684394836,
-0.17673298716545105,
-0.0004930388531647623,
-0.6533790230751038,
0.051999665796756744,
-0.27488094568252563,
-0.2932831645011902,
-0.66205233335495,
-0.30051401257514954,
0.7174590229988098,
0.7716848254203796,
-0.11598096042871475,
0.10841168463230133,
0.41947805881500244,
0.4567524790763855,
-0.6932221055030823,
0.18711066246032715,
-0.5398470759391785,
-0.2815271019935608,
-0.26615744829177856,
-0.06569791585206985,
-0.5823961496353149,
0.32035350799560547,
0.20166608691215515,
-0.29233306646347046,
-0.21558472514152527,
-0.11244512349367142,
0.3524855673313141,
0.05081084743142128,
-0.5953173637390137,
-0.16455988585948944,
-0.7099421620368958,
1.0962855815887451,
-0.5252770185470581,
0.5937735438346863,
0.24025124311447144,
0.24891190230846405,
-0.2904694080352783,
-0.8187745809555054,
-0.2694424092769623,
-0.06323757767677307,
0.06600282341241837,
-0.16351202130317688,
-0.027076730504631996,
0.21772311627864838,
0.19186462461948395,
0.2667241394519806,
-0.23595532774925232,
0.4086262285709381,
-0.36663731932640076,
0.020461667329072952,
0.3066374957561493,
0.16365019977092743,
0.26702407002449036,
0.3018110394477844,
-0.748813271522522,
0.08422257006168365,
-0.6462671160697937,
0.08027845621109009,
-0.08282297104597092,
0.1305401474237442,
-0.3422904908657074,
0.3826713562011719,
-0.3823949098587036,
0.8220438957214355,
-0.07981275767087936,
-0.07267221808433533,
0.12516552209854126,
-0.10076943784952164,
-0.42142051458358765,
-0.024265533313155174,
0.48304179310798645,
0.48893508315086365,
-0.07812687754631042,
-0.2416219711303711,
-0.11706972867250443,
-0.09111957997083664,
-0.1306583732366562,
-1.0434457063674927,
0.35252439975738525,
0.296007364988327,
-0.30183637142181396,
-0.018456116318702698,
-0.26396647095680237,
-0.9133159518241882,
-0.03641461580991745,
-0.33215466141700745,
-0.13433639705181122,
-0.3363897502422333,
-0.13600777089595795,
0.3904080390930176,
0.016388818621635437,
0.2462240606546402,
0.29075247049331665,
-1.0129296779632568,
0.6555302739143372,
0.8837102055549622,
0.5467687249183655,
-0.42054060101509094,
-0.5293096303939819,
-0.6810979843139648,
0.3770957887172699,
-0.10591491311788559,
0.6603190302848816,
-1.010608196258545,
-0.461380273103714,
0.030920619145035744,
0.3766269087791443,
-0.05871408432722092,
-0.3007608652114868,
0.6084305047988892,
-0.5794628262519836,
0.13136166334152222,
-0.25814586877822876,
-0.8446348309516907,
-0.038107361644506454,
0.16815748810768127,
-0.47308266162872314,
0.9809795022010803,
0.05739433690905571,
-0.5381072163581848,
0.01847948133945465,
-0.7238525152206421,
-0.2255086451768875,
0.08806505799293518,
-0.30226510763168335,
0.15689441561698914,
0.36501315236091614,
0.2931590676307678,
0.5159561634063721,
-0.6750271320343018,
0.3150116503238678,
-0.35004177689552307,
-0.5570681095123291,
-0.07597873359918594,
-0.48782700300216675,
0.49033647775650024,
-0.018755434080958366,
-0.26551806926727295,
0.065975122153759,
-0.5839306116104126,
-0.05670546740293503,
0.06876442581415176,
-0.614215075969696,
-0.3821170926094055,
0.145066037774086,
0.1780852973461151,
0.20023225247859955,
0.6231472492218018,
-0.7652050256729126,
0.08860481530427933,
-0.27438053488731384,
0.5232312679290771,
0.49171867966651917,
-0.3551853895187378,
0.7080243825912476,
0.018839776515960693,
0.3025083541870117,
0.03131236881017685,
0.07172965258359909,
-0.44778934121131897,
-0.2924731373786926,
-0.641210675239563,
-0.29100149869918823,
0.1608951836824417,
0.4653797447681427,
-0.3825111389160156,
0.27560535073280334,
-0.5582701563835144,
0.012138617224991322,
0.09949935972690582,
0.17520618438720703,
0.2906073331832886,
0.6033312678337097,
0.3691363036632538,
-0.25968262553215027,
-0.5882114768028259,
-0.9533118605613708,
-0.17251917719841003,
0.11558759957551956,
-0.21224230527877808,
0.36863428354263306,
0.15598759055137634,
-0.3696673810482025,
0.835736095905304,
-0.3037518262863159,
-0.036908332258462906,
-0.1916106939315796,
-0.3629109263420105,
0.33112940192222595,
0.4720531105995178,
0.4329468905925751,
-0.5429994463920593,
-0.5080375075340271,
0.06502436101436615,
-0.6153586506843567,
-0.037418581545352936,
0.016552159562706947,
0.02463068999350071,
0.11447227746248245,
0.8609641790390015,
-0.5731833577156067,
0.15542659163475037,
0.8274861574172974,
-0.3816744387149811,
0.33479079604148865,
-0.1624269336462021,
-0.03590612858533859,
-1.061530590057373,
-0.06402936577796936,
-0.21892109513282776,
-0.5854486227035522,
-0.7130475044250488,
0.14708305895328522,
0.45833301544189453,
-0.3340297341346741,
-0.7084674835205078,
0.7810131311416626,
-0.7496967911720276,
-0.18424125015735626,
-0.7005984783172607,
0.08719050139188766,
0.00956975668668747,
0.5958422422409058,
0.33084356784820557,
0.7777612209320068,
0.7399861812591553,
-0.43005573749542236,
0.1930370181798935,
-0.16016347706317902,
-0.3621344268321991,
0.13324032723903656,
-0.6275482177734375,
0.2153232991695404,
-0.10009496659040451,
0.5202810168266296,
-0.5504745244979858,
-0.2814774811267853,
-0.14332766830921173,
-0.007246366236358881,
0.4500528573989868,
-0.251232773065567,
-0.46099111437797546,
-0.23736853897571564,
-0.216415673494339,
0.7257577776908875,
0.526273787021637,
-0.915678083896637,
0.4704555571079254,
0.231736958026886,
-0.15174725651741028,
-0.7538273334503174,
-0.41487810015678406,
0.3145061135292053,
-0.3139520585536957,
-0.4995731711387634,
0.6603014469146729,
0.05055360868573189,
0.03923659771680832,
-0.135895237326622,
-0.08473526686429977,
-0.05088171362876892,
0.005143729038536549,
0.21684499084949493,
-0.06225672364234924,
-0.20576684176921844,
0.15289129316806793,
0.23755718767642975,
0.04586393013596535,
0.09432151168584824,
-0.33016452193260193,
0.8193631172180176,
-0.33064085245132446,
-0.13738946616649628,
-0.2727590501308441,
0.6964660882949829,
0.7272014617919922,
0.031045593321323395,
0.7349624633789062,
0.27096259593963623,
-0.5192146301269531,
-0.2506452202796936,
-0.4243597984313965,
-0.07523339241743088,
-0.5280739665031433,
0.6678099036216736,
-0.5355073809623718,
-1.118851900100708,
0.5250109434127808,
-0.3954591453075409,
-0.052553340792655945,
0.20982834696769714,
0.6687067151069641,
0.06786954402923584,
0.7778131365776062,
1.0264265537261963,
-0.3015153110027313,
0.6779680848121643,
0.012808054685592651,
-0.201364204287529,
-1.139484167098999,
-0.13893860578536987,
-0.05084289237856865,
-0.09779276698827744,
-0.2980571389198303,
-0.8117423057556152,
0.044487014412879944,
0.3864589035511017,
-0.06139611452817917,
0.5524070262908936,
-0.2715073823928833,
0.9457995295524597,
0.22384601831436157,
0.25019532442092896,
0.1412171870470047,
-0.09756212681531906,
-0.08316729962825775,
0.19980251789093018,
-0.7192541360855103,
-0.5389308929443359,
1.1834254264831543,
0.7651333808898926,
0.478061705827713,
-0.12185533344745636,
0.6844950914382935,
0.0017143968725576997,
0.2825676500797272,
-0.5885425209999084,
0.5927860736846924,
-0.1423870474100113,
-0.39931049942970276,
-0.3892366290092468,
0.11892828345298767,
-0.7422824501991272,
0.2571011483669281,
0.19112488627433777,
-1.0399123430252075,
0.42238378524780273,
0.07027532905340195,
-0.24564053118228912,
0.3463778793811798,
-0.6427851319313049,
0.686616837978363,
-0.153405100107193,
-0.4989074170589447,
-0.5195171236991882,
-0.36877959966659546,
0.41590580344200134,
-0.15805654227733612,
0.1366851031780243,
-0.3571566641330719,
-0.4304872751235962,
0.4850042462348938,
-0.45409494638442993,
1.0540471076965332,
-0.07921218872070312,
-0.30863791704177856,
0.2741396427154541,
-0.2036007195711136,
0.6979829668998718,
0.265611857175827,
-0.17011989653110504,
0.34657686948776245,
-0.037043824791908264,
-0.7228835821151733,
-0.4030516445636749,
1.0326931476593018,
-0.4671604037284851,
-0.9285385608673096,
-0.07964367419481277,
-0.5785069465637207,
-0.25006556510925293,
0.17579533159732819,
0.15776433050632477,
0.37229976058006287,
-0.22355292737483978,
0.4021153151988983,
0.27024245262145996,
-0.27377182245254517,
0.7453289031982422,
0.3349176049232483,
-0.14375314116477966,
-0.07668770849704742,
0.42549046874046326,
-0.2991836965084076,
0.228362575173378,
0.4492744505405426,
0.12483874708414078,
-0.23639418184757233,
-0.41456425189971924,
-0.4111332595348358,
-0.005070258863270283,
-0.7705631256103516,
-0.019091002643108368,
-0.5386129021644592,
-0.08350750803947449,
-0.2227036952972412,
-0.09901273250579834,
-0.5424125790596008,
-0.32710719108581543,
-0.2830985188484192,
0.11889386922121048,
0.2780974507331848,
0.21215905249118805,
0.0013053745497018099,
0.39770618081092834,
-0.8232646584510803,
0.1209767758846283,
0.5107150077819824,
0.46251624822616577,
0.15331237018108368,
-0.48085007071495056,
-0.3864455223083496,
-0.08289017528295517,
-0.06777208298444748,
-0.9408050775527954,
0.34268641471862793,
0.13709422945976257,
0.30069342255592346,
0.3317469358444214,
-0.05970623716711998,
0.7088350057601929,
-0.91566401720047,
0.5914750099182129,
0.2387767732143402,
-0.9317039251327515,
0.16277097165584564,
-0.4206793010234833,
0.5016766786575317,
0.41430363059043884,
0.12905000150203705,
-0.39562615752220154,
-0.014796577394008636,
-0.2116309255361557,
-0.7987403273582458,
0.5228514075279236,
0.0536210760474205,
0.4439018964767456,
-0.3624348044395447,
0.3098178207874298,
0.13852113485336304,
-0.10926718264818192,
-0.4828011095523834,
0.12447548657655716,
0.056791212409734726,
0.020699186250567436,
-0.10425057262182236,
-0.7083515524864197,
-0.09149337559938431,
-0.2594625651836395,
0.201647087931633,
-0.22550155222415924,
0.4608100354671478,
0.20981477200984955,
-0.23480288684368134,
0.1475333273410797,
0.5817210078239441,
0.6110759973526001,
0.7275416254997253,
-0.13761505484580994,
0.05115148425102234,
0.6089581251144409,
-0.1670411229133606,
-0.16883262991905212,
0.05643300712108612,
0.43590208888053894,
-0.17695166170597076,
0.14553655683994293,
0.8566690683364868,
0.5777329206466675,
-0.7840719223022461,
0.5716251134872437,
-0.08897896856069565,
0.04841884970664978,
-0.48615562915802,
-0.10652346163988113,
0.4427837133407593,
0.41439422965049744,
0.34930506348609924,
-0.333698034286499,
0.24984268844127655,
-0.5679431557655334,
0.19817519187927246,
0.24248859286308289,
-0.24086420238018036,
-0.36287930607795715,
0.6518213152885437,
0.5779619812965393,
-0.19875720143318176,
0.4980570673942566,
0.2102750986814499,
-0.38482311367988586,
0.7237517833709717,
0.9163570404052734,
0.7657087445259094,
0.01433979719877243,
-0.3968501687049866,
0.29141950607299805,
0.027473369613289833,
-0.1831739842891693,
0.15898454189300537,
-0.5750895738601685,
-0.5558344125747681,
-0.7465972900390625,
-0.6957798004150391,
-0.418404221534729,
0.38589921593666077,
-0.6084281206130981,
0.45099321007728577,
-0.23681539297103882,
-0.09318643063306808,
-0.42417559027671814,
-0.24408218264579773,
-0.7755110263824463,
0.04820100590586662,
0.5520976185798645,
1.2181328535079956,
-0.6123508810997009,
1.4518579244613647,
0.4344293177127838,
0.4384269118309021,
-0.2630889117717743,
-0.022173525765538216,
-0.31250903010368347,
-0.6348250508308411,
0.5016466975212097,
0.5393158197402954,
-0.15298371016979218,
-0.06941957771778107,
-0.35602134466171265,
-1.069843053817749,
1.1261628866195679,
0.3379034698009491,
-1.2252042293548584,
-0.2875938415527344,
0.20541948080062866,
0.4265846014022827,
-0.7092136740684509,
0.019703155383467674,
0.7098951935768127,
0.10577037930488586,
-0.34476903080940247,
-1.0386953353881836,
0.24399316310882568,
-0.10020826756954193,
0.1972952038049698,
0.1344357132911682,
-0.677867591381073,
0.5637927651405334,
-0.06052320823073387,
-0.28651267290115356,
0.13976949453353882,
0.8299264907836914,
0.34810665249824524,
0.1157718300819397,
0.5757638216018677,
0.3352726995944977,
0.38639312982559204,
0.2490779608488083,
1.1331709623336792,
-0.7495349049568176,
0.2523384094238281,
1.4379210472106934,
-0.277883380651474,
1.0784351825714111,
0.6912071108818054,
0.13938771188259125,
0.5635092854499817,
0.6209233403205872,
0.3881826102733612,
0.40454792976379395,
-0.06777899712324142,
-0.4128763973712921,
-0.3637179136276245,
0.0722222626209259,
-0.30357876420021057,
0.37851566076278687,
0.687785804271698,
-0.49359339475631714,
-0.316694051027298,
0.10848797857761383,
-0.11930130422115326,
0.15159659087657928,
-0.29543718695640564,
0.3683949112892151,
0.37422454357147217,
-0.4577299952507019,
0.719012439250946,
0.3091629147529602,
0.8347935676574707,
-0.14218690991401672,
0.1304454505443573,
-0.1420505940914154,
0.12801477313041687,
0.08310361951589584,
-0.5224472880363464,
0.3089101314544678,
0.046823613345623016,
-0.28207993507385254,
-0.2667910158634186,
0.8346878886222839,
-0.6290042400360107,
-0.3457953631877899,
0.6766837239265442,
0.2922774851322174,
0.0685737133026123,
-0.015512007288634777,
-0.5081443190574646,
0.33662497997283936,
-0.31909918785095215,
-0.5012205243110657,
0.5389983654022217,
0.1899496465921402,
-0.33554109930992126,
0.5406001806259155,
0.41279336810112,
-0.3020051121711731,
0.18763910233974457,
0.011593743227422237,
1.041092038154602,
-0.7242493629455566,
-0.4648829698562622,
-0.9329178929328918,
0.36362776160240173,
-0.2385254055261612,
-0.036107029765844345,
0.5528565645217896,
0.7024550437927246,
0.8405417203903198,
-0.03316689282655716,
0.4975837469100952,
0.19202682375907898,
0.3079664409160614,
-0.4269714951515198,
0.3720511496067047,
-0.4429398775100708,
0.4072483777999878,
0.10951267182826996,
-1.0459991693496704,
-0.04646855592727661,
-0.06262341141700745,
-0.4064989387989044,
-0.26529306173324585,
0.6224023699760437,
0.4230291545391083,
-0.3908080756664276,
-0.15464861690998077,
0.5036935210227966,
0.008434467948973179,
0.0978982076048851,
1.0535374879837036,
0.6909402012825012,
-0.4401540458202362,
0.38241127133369446,
-0.2643018960952759,
-0.3200414776802063,
-0.2445029765367508,
-0.9721631407737732,
-1.011136770248413,
-0.348285049200058,
-0.06398867070674896,
0.03465088829398155,
-0.005175094585865736,
0.8527949452400208,
0.9609723687171936,
-0.5690693855285645,
-0.45157361030578613,
-0.14097103476524353,
-0.04217812418937683,
-0.013727457262575626,
-0.13743890821933746,
0.2740609645843506,
-0.5006784796714783,
-1.242451548576355,
0.9897562265396118,
0.39907920360565186,
-0.029621198773384094,
0.03189075365662575,
-0.2580786347389221,
0.21080514788627625,
0.19768907129764557,
1.0096790790557861,
0.5820944309234619,
-0.7206606268882751,
-0.2524164617061615,
0.0261966772377491,
-0.025392746552824974,
0.11459029465913773,
0.6707380414009094,
-0.8433189392089844,
0.23345577716827393,
0.4638248383998871,
0.6268650889396667,
0.7942559123039246,
-0.023569969460368156,
0.9575831294059753,
-0.740607500076294,
0.542048990726471,
-0.06176341697573662,
0.5396038889884949,
0.11067641526460648,
-0.4573810398578644,
0.16757771372795105,
-0.1367739737033844,
-0.4406149089336395,
-0.8853792548179626,
0.3775085210800171,
-0.8543974757194519,
-0.5875380635261536,
1.2308603525161743,
-0.09441068768501282,
-0.5490916967391968,
0.14673613011837006,
0.11542631685733795,
0.0028559225611388683,
-0.42801663279533386,
0.45806509256362915,
0.6480494737625122,
-0.1100754365324974,
-0.3123478293418884,
-0.4675441384315491,
0.3431447148323059,
0.5153827667236328,
-0.7046053409576416,
0.37973400950431824,
0.36425483226776123,
0.50946444272995,
-0.1419723629951477,
0.6734088063240051,
-0.33049073815345764,
0.27420157194137573,
-0.14988361299037933,
-0.06253033131361008,
-0.058469854295253754,
-0.5363382697105408,
-0.44915345311164856,
0.32084622979164124,
-0.04004037007689476,
-0.32572227716445923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16608v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16608v1
|
PAQA: Toward ProActive Open-Retrieval Question Answering
| 2024-02-26T14:40:34 | 2024-02-26T14:40:34 |
Pierre Erbacher, Jian-Yun Nie, Philippe Preux, Laure Soulier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Conversational systems have made significant progress in generating natural
language responses. However, their potential as conversational search systems
is currently limited due to their passive role in the information-seeking
process. One major limitation is the scarcity of datasets that provide labelled
ambiguous questions along with a supporting corpus of documents and relevant
clarifying questions. This work aims to tackle the challenge of generating
relevant clarifying questions by taking into account the inherent ambiguities
present in both user queries and documents. To achieve this, we propose PAQA,
an extension to the existing AmbiNQ dataset, incorporating clarifying
questions. We then evaluate various models and assess how passage retrieval
impacts ambiguity detection and the generation of clarifying questions. By
addressing this gap in conversational search systems, we aim to provide
additional supervision to enhance their active participation in the
information-seeking process and provide users with more accurate results.
|
[
-0.4052388072013855,
-1.1126080751419067,
0.6279603242874146,
0.04699511453509331,
-0.059003692120313644,
-0.24700817465782166,
0.06989894062280655,
-0.2215137928724289,
0.10132075101137161,
0.6226322650909424,
-0.7327031493186951,
-0.04677692428231239,
-0.3415389358997345,
0.040907811373472214,
-0.5590736865997314,
0.5417780876159668,
-0.10420002788305283,
-0.19909262657165527,
-0.11129852384328842,
-0.059551212936639786,
-0.38580575585365295,
-0.4677547514438629,
-0.7758030891418457,
-0.06619944423437119,
0.495685875415802,
0.5020450949668884,
1.1611303091049194,
0.13211697340011597,
0.3752923309803009,
0.195582315325737,
-0.291003555059433,
0.44513577222824097,
-0.35301682353019714,
0.5201265215873718,
-0.1697269082069397,
-0.7218785285949707,
-0.10421492159366608,
-0.3031283915042877,
0.7008539438247681,
0.8872988820075989,
-0.304837703704834,
0.05504155904054642,
-0.17780226469039917,
0.5760761499404907,
-1.0727533102035522,
-0.05628260225057602,
-0.49246034026145935,
0.14583496749401093,
-0.450933039188385,
-0.1936822235584259,
-0.21958452463150024,
-0.45878344774246216,
0.270387202501297,
-0.9620334506034851,
0.13763408362865448,
-0.04975196346640587,
1.0013048648834229,
0.2897157371044159,
-0.9086223244667053,
-0.6564690470695496,
-0.7074279189109802,
0.2997828722000122,
-0.6305273771286011,
0.42706307768821716,
0.3597044050693512,
0.5403689742088318,
-0.3495001494884491,
-0.9671550393104553,
-0.7844206094741821,
0.159999281167984,
-0.2536121606826782,
0.30438271164894104,
-0.3902069628238678,
0.061985984444618225,
0.0009317127987742424,
0.6062247157096863,
-0.40360063314437866,
-0.33201807737350464,
-0.5046922564506531,
-0.12392500787973404,
0.32151538133621216,
0.1073383092880249,
0.16817235946655273,
-0.1851213276386261,
-0.16162721812725067,
-0.03504249453544617,
-0.7365621328353882,
0.388335257768631,
0.773936927318573,
0.35457801818847656,
0.46491140127182007,
0.6590888500213623,
-0.49607279896736145,
0.6626960039138794,
0.069233238697052,
0.556090235710144,
0.08857233822345734,
-0.5349221229553223,
-0.11296966671943665,
-0.16844281554222107,
0.4409792721271515,
0.009022178128361702,
0.06970855593681335,
-0.05875184386968613,
-0.06616651266813278,
-0.6354407668113708,
0.567197322845459,
-0.4154030680656433,
-0.19768306612968445,
0.46095743775367737,
-0.26840054988861084,
0.0883609876036644,
0.4816174805164337,
-0.6353040933609009,
-0.35769397020339966,
-0.3178848922252655,
0.6597297787666321,
-0.18157964944839478,
-0.3893316388130188,
0.269527405500412,
-0.1453583538532257,
0.24041377007961273,
0.5877269506454468,
-0.5685282349586487,
0.35003527998924255,
0.34871748089790344,
0.3944063186645508,
0.3382492959499359,
0.3087773621082306,
-0.9405466318130493,
0.09458418190479279,
-0.3215605616569519,
0.4190870225429535,
-0.8052349090576172,
-0.5896050930023193,
0.17528994381427765,
0.20551250874996185,
-0.04608255997300148,
-0.866895854473114,
0.945464551448822,
-0.9663326144218445,
0.5676596760749817,
-0.6394732594490051,
-0.1546373963356018,
-0.36275362968444824,
0.35939568281173706,
-0.6620423197746277,
1.1052137613296509,
0.017764460295438766,
-0.592509925365448,
0.02691032737493515,
-0.7700287699699402,
-0.05744148790836334,
0.2569272816181183,
-0.15055739879608154,
-0.24852800369262695,
0.009398384019732475,
0.48576876521110535,
-0.058781128376722336,
-0.23588067293167114,
0.4705100953578949,
0.15752938389778137,
-0.3889395296573639,
0.4958016872406006,
-0.37457871437072754,
0.8323873281478882,
0.31241464614868164,
-0.18791478872299194,
0.06386388838291168,
-0.35929444432258606,
0.2520473301410675,
-0.2551122009754181,
-0.6535817384719849,
-0.3193036615848541,
-0.05823774263262749,
-0.4159577190876007,
-0.06731143593788147,
0.27128875255584717,
-0.41622307896614075,
0.10920415073633194,
-0.6218512654304504,
-0.05769495293498039,
0.4850384294986725,
0.4573124647140503,
0.33684608340263367,
-0.1947791874408722,
0.7042200565338135,
0.28538110852241516,
0.3019351661205292,
-0.32450318336486816,
-0.6419190168380737,
-1.048912763595581,
0.1186143234372139,
0.358993798494339,
0.6283515691757202,
-1.009822964668274,
0.22932645678520203,
0.19055397808551788,
-0.24063177406787872,
-1.0113778114318848,
-0.024451732635498047,
0.4972285032272339,
0.6712163686752319,
0.5575091242790222,
-0.48540547490119934,
-0.43782129883766174,
-0.8966737389564514,
-0.33773860335350037,
-0.44721823930740356,
-0.3636012077331543,
0.7511763572692871,
0.3654908835887909,
0.06057629734277725,
0.9697690010070801,
-0.5184597969055176,
-0.11440388113260269,
0.46391937136650085,
0.13377846777439117,
0.3469778597354889,
0.3018459379673004,
0.09816339612007141,
-1.3999431133270264,
-0.21960943937301636,
-0.2597312033176422,
-0.7323349118232727,
-0.3752434253692627,
0.04080008342862129,
-0.3551817238330841,
-0.2870866060256958,
0.555808961391449,
-0.7485794425010681,
0.635120153427124,
0.07501910626888275,
-0.30531561374664307,
0.6533316373825073,
-0.15816625952720642,
0.3966987133026123,
-0.5714216232299805,
0.4236065149307251,
-0.5913642644882202,
0.09239451587200165,
-0.8086162209510803,
0.23139673471450806,
0.18495191633701324,
-0.2252141684293747,
-0.5168682932853699,
0.7856219410896301,
-0.42053020000457764,
0.11041051149368286,
0.011240050196647644,
0.46711060404777527,
0.16520366072654724,
0.2223847508430481,
-0.06654448807239532,
0.8886547088623047,
0.41534703969955444,
-1.0058740377426147,
0.16767701506614685,
0.7145455479621887,
-0.16182883083820343,
0.3354520797729492,
-0.7347825765609741,
0.10732139647006989,
-0.30492112040519714,
0.2685544788837433,
-1.1622295379638672,
-0.43562906980514526,
0.6514390707015991,
-0.5018404722213745,
-0.05597076192498207,
-0.04382623732089996,
-0.5722460746765137,
-0.31497037410736084,
0.09152930229902267,
0.7328537106513977,
0.0344933420419693,
-0.6769707202911377,
0.4590734839439392,
0.1857161521911621,
-0.29265519976615906,
-0.9197385907173157,
-0.19822606444358826,
0.05917878821492195,
0.029997562989592552,
-0.7457045316696167,
0.3615884482860565,
0.10192771255970001,
-0.4330465793609619,
0.11338218301534653,
-0.2971329092979431,
-0.19626328349113464,
0.12876930832862854,
0.16447846591472626,
-0.06078048050403595,
-0.14470773935317993,
0.5154557824134827,
-0.003739887150004506,
0.2238573431968689,
-0.016331104561686516,
-0.10095921158790588,
0.41394633054733276,
-0.19119985401630402,
-0.6547673940658569,
-0.12106823921203613,
0.47354599833488464,
0.04893925040960312,
-0.7586072087287903,
0.7437396049499512,
0.562745213508606,
-0.2549184560775757,
0.22093799710273743,
-0.3771219551563263,
-0.2752409279346466,
-0.5300858020782471,
-0.11748167872428894,
-0.587646484375,
-0.9749107360839844,
0.66624915599823,
0.09455427527427673,
-0.13656063377857208,
0.23203924298286438,
0.5371714234352112,
-0.23322062194347382,
0.8992542624473572,
0.28502747416496277,
0.8152207136154175,
0.3431658148765564,
0.11264598369598389,
0.44694045186042786,
-0.8278299570083618,
-0.5482739210128784,
-0.6083600521087646,
-0.18004260957241058,
-0.40387600660324097,
-0.5832574367523193,
0.656194269657135,
0.26132678985595703,
-0.06503450870513916,
0.002944405423477292,
-0.3569314479827881,
0.1743444949388504,
1.0455585718154907,
0.33815792202949524,
0.33384138345718384,
-0.46459293365478516,
-0.06309661269187927,
0.1361086517572403,
-0.35004526376724243,
-0.6371939182281494,
0.9374164342880249,
0.11837069690227509,
0.6059018969535828,
0.8075506687164307,
0.4221726953983307,
0.08694741874933243,
-0.09735140204429626,
-0.5732027888298035,
0.5300655961036682,
0.24962343275547028,
-1.251765251159668,
-0.4609118402004242,
-0.3410717248916626,
-1.3079710006713867,
0.4540013074874878,
-0.1476564109325409,
-0.6275681257247925,
0.4832911491394043,
0.05280980467796326,
-0.4326479136943817,
-0.04892108589410782,
-0.6729603409767151,
0.7579417824745178,
-0.0974479466676712,
-0.4861270785331726,
0.2268664836883545,
-0.8700060248374939,
0.46546217799186707,
-0.034365542232990265,
-0.025822004303336143,
0.03439393639564514,
-0.33770886063575745,
0.5568570494651794,
-0.47648829221725464,
0.6727563142776489,
-0.420463889837265,
-0.19197113811969757,
0.7722066640853882,
0.09545639157295227,
0.29688552021980286,
0.206586092710495,
-0.3504042625427246,
-0.5152682662010193,
0.15288525819778442,
-0.6051137447357178,
-0.6817091703414917,
0.14746692776679993,
-0.4169124960899353,
-1.1259430646896362,
-0.16571179032325745,
-0.41036468744277954,
-0.3600008189678192,
0.31161755323410034,
-0.10574661195278168,
0.2684556543827057,
-0.08498811721801758,
0.4736420512199402,
0.8814162611961365,
-0.3924664556980133,
-0.009612757712602615,
0.7646366357803345,
-0.15889036655426025,
0.170689195394516,
0.2573901414871216,
0.06971472501754761,
0.023960411548614502,
0.5008143782615662,
0.031191768124699593,
-0.5537581443786621,
-0.46747562289237976,
-0.26270976662635803,
0.2604208290576935,
-0.7065094709396362,
-0.07444103807210922,
-0.6115137338638306,
-0.14369508624076843,
-0.6353850364685059,
0.24995382130146027,
0.07609786093235016,
-0.433327853679657,
-0.5096389055252075,
0.1840844601392746,
0.005952458828687668,
0.35494014620780945,
0.18707497417926788,
0.5086366534233093,
-0.7967015504837036,
0.38890478014945984,
0.4803653061389923,
0.09130468219518661,
-0.1843581348657608,
-0.6830230355262756,
0.14031539857387543,
0.167477086186409,
-0.6442710161209106,
-1.289591908454895,
0.1609744280576706,
0.3081701695919037,
0.8272885084152222,
0.355375736951828,
0.6815193295478821,
0.5985028743743896,
-0.06960088759660721,
0.8739502429962158,
-0.12224742025136948,
-0.5978754162788391,
0.8494558930397034,
-0.4724183678627014,
0.5397436618804932,
0.7786048650741577,
0.6392020583152771,
-0.5402063131332397,
-0.3946334719657898,
-0.6219393610954285,
-1.1069203615188599,
0.6689199209213257,
0.6454686522483826,
-0.019442828372120857,
-0.14059455692768097,
0.49776652455329895,
-0.09238572418689728,
0.44131314754486084,
-0.4899592697620392,
-0.08325573801994324,
-0.09254071861505508,
-0.018509717658162117,
0.35412776470184326,
-0.16985724866390228,
-0.2061065137386322,
0.23115874826908112,
0.8286449313163757,
-0.10249398648738861,
0.2180563360452652,
0.5226485133171082,
0.13293704390525818,
-0.07966452091932297,
0.6569067239761353,
-0.015081841498613358,
0.4408171772956848,
-0.30601033568382263,
0.07425566017627716,
-0.08587025851011276,
-0.2632245421409607,
0.0793176218867302,
0.18642409145832062,
-0.2834828794002533,
0.06770370900630951,
-0.0376649908721447,
0.517311155796051,
0.041410982608795166,
-1.147753357887268,
0.5993877053260803,
-0.2788931429386139,
-0.20207303762435913,
-0.3969033658504486,
0.26935410499572754,
0.04237029701471329,
0.35046693682670593,
0.5382781624794006,
-0.15565665066242218,
0.4773583710193634,
-0.8240734338760376,
0.3035557270050049,
0.3846137225627899,
-0.5768647789955139,
-0.014639719389379025,
0.6455086469650269,
0.38833925127983093,
-0.5133718252182007,
0.954424262046814,
-0.18149195611476898,
-0.3737000823020935,
0.49125936627388,
0.12757496535778046,
0.3853188157081604,
-0.25652265548706055,
0.19158893823623657,
0.3626668155193329,
0.109853595495224,
0.2297702431678772,
0.6156107783317566,
-0.32231080532073975,
-0.5409538149833679,
-0.06495561450719833,
-0.48740705847740173,
-0.7757949233055115,
0.037452906370162964,
-0.844388484954834,
0.2950863838195801,
-0.039324190467596054,
-0.35769766569137573,
-0.10024716705083847,
0.026394829154014587,
-0.45620471239089966,
0.32265621423721313,
-0.19433753192424774,
1.114396572113037,
-0.42268553376197815,
0.5892773866653442,
0.7668566703796387,
-0.5814587473869324,
-0.6714935302734375,
0.30597004294395447,
-0.0003957590088248253,
-0.4893999695777893,
0.603364884853363,
0.07931987196207047,
0.00920121744275093,
-0.07003343105316162,
-0.33142969012260437,
-0.6596503257751465,
1.018936038017273,
0.2860269844532013,
-0.13394683599472046,
-0.4590698480606079,
0.044730294495821,
0.6079988479614258,
-0.09792745113372803,
0.4447113871574402,
0.514294445514679,
0.6578782200813293,
0.41223540902137756,
-0.9550167918205261,
-0.038898296654224396,
-0.48226869106292725,
-0.5790168642997742,
0.35032325983047485,
-0.5185133814811707,
0.886207640171051,
-0.13752931356430054,
-0.5390248894691467,
0.3555184006690979,
0.45583146810531616,
0.06241614744067192,
0.48923709988594055,
0.45216768980026245,
0.2980780601501465,
1.1776138544082642,
-0.2983764708042145,
0.8347498178482056,
0.19886639714241028,
-0.17957662045955658,
1.3324958086013794,
-0.11617480963468552,
0.9761332273483276,
0.5766844153404236,
-0.16790656745433807,
0.2894100844860077,
0.7695757746696472,
0.33130666613578796,
0.35863494873046875,
0.18040622770786285,
-0.7494673132896423,
-0.3964253067970276,
-0.34895169734954834,
-0.3482731580734253,
0.47023749351501465,
0.6415666341781616,
-0.2771543562412262,
-0.30253303050994873,
-0.19109131395816803,
-0.16036880016326904,
0.3612745702266693,
-0.03257221356034279,
0.7055758833885193,
-0.22084355354309082,
-1.157514214515686,
0.39854276180267334,
0.008164463564753532,
0.17211495339870453,
-0.5768724679946899,
0.11310847103595734,
-0.28271952271461487,
-0.0027819841634482145,
-0.19866609573364258,
-1.0240657329559326,
0.27427223324775696,
-0.2550928294658661,
0.016430076211690903,
-0.018571533262729645,
0.6045612692832947,
-0.42712628841400146,
-0.005842097569257021,
0.10326516628265381,
0.845443069934845,
0.32022824883461,
-0.27168869972229004,
-0.6628599762916565,
-0.2546793222427368,
0.13584010303020477,
-0.23970285058021545,
-0.11833447217941284,
0.5979828834533691,
-0.16951358318328857,
0.7530045509338379,
0.47828543186187744,
-0.2309345006942749,
0.2811734974384308,
-0.0643656849861145,
0.9492770433425903,
-0.3335595428943634,
-0.4705740213394165,
-0.14684563875198364,
0.5160778760910034,
-0.027527913451194763,
-0.2819928228855133,
0.7044616341590881,
0.5440739989280701,
0.6534695029258728,
0.11795513331890106,
0.6463281512260437,
-0.2527507245540619,
0.7508072257041931,
-0.4703250825405121,
0.19198626279830933,
-0.6421014070510864,
0.5398415923118591,
0.12784677743911743,
-0.7285817861557007,
-0.10803765058517456,
0.21618644893169403,
-0.5036894679069519,
-0.10823603719472885,
0.3473234176635742,
1.1739733219146729,
-0.21524152159690857,
0.2054571658372879,
0.06866413354873657,
-0.013739668764173985,
0.5086329579353333,
0.5391027927398682,
1.083831548690796,
-0.836333692073822,
1.0284053087234497,
0.22547166049480438,
-0.0555250346660614,
-0.4232029616832733,
-0.5521485209465027,
-0.5614588260650635,
-0.8262411952018738,
-0.14377059042453766,
-0.08936955034732819,
0.36581119894981384,
0.2973889708518982,
0.6081885695457458,
-0.6314926147460938,
0.008324522525072098,
-0.06334692984819412,
0.15064860880374908,
0.02468911185860634,
-0.30586084723472595,
0.15457797050476074,
-0.46310749650001526,
-0.7987768054008484,
0.46916791796684265,
-0.124513179063797,
0.11342965066432953,
0.052989162504673004,
-0.15546941757202148,
-0.7188546061515808,
0.3139033019542694,
0.08264778554439545,
0.48750630021095276,
-0.7065154314041138,
-0.1502435952425003,
0.1448114663362503,
0.17729851603507996,
-0.03210394084453583,
0.8006385564804077,
-0.8356385827064514,
0.8633111119270325,
0.4386306405067444,
0.7835421562194824,
0.6502911448478699,
0.5057522654533386,
0.6919175982475281,
-1.2017817497253418,
-0.10995764285326004,
0.4587204158306122,
-0.21269653737545013,
0.2576603591442108,
-0.37569376826286316,
0.6246517300605774,
-0.18642672896385193,
-0.4273954927921295,
-0.806041955947876,
0.42700403928756714,
-0.7728312015533447,
-0.38054436445236206,
0.8845135569572449,
-0.24671879410743713,
0.06587551534175873,
-0.45878633856773376,
-0.49025118350982666,
0.23401394486427307,
-0.41259732842445374,
0.5148128867149353,
0.7106423377990723,
-0.3092641830444336,
-0.17689961194992065,
-0.6658763885498047,
0.37498340010643005,
0.5761439800262451,
-0.6728005409240723,
0.22153060138225555,
0.504697322845459,
-0.35978248715400696,
0.322688490152359,
0.8855438232421875,
-0.30838409066200256,
0.5699320435523987,
-0.09569810330867767,
-0.3911360204219818,
0.10185226052999496,
-0.20171064138412476,
-0.011422498151659966,
0.5380845069885254,
0.18848296999931335,
-0.1935003250837326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16602v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16602v2
|
Rethinking Negative Instances for Generative Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-02-26T14:30:37 | 2024-06-19T03:16:58 |
Yuyang Ding, Juntao Li, Pinzheng Wang, Zecheng Tang, Bowen Yan, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities for
generalizing in unseen tasks. In the Named Entity Recognition (NER) task,
recent advancements have seen the remarkable improvement of LLMs in a broad
range of entity domains via instruction tuning, by adopting entity-centric
schema. In this work, we explore the potential enhancement of the existing
methods by incorporating negative instances into training. Our experiments
reveal that negative instances contribute to remarkable improvements by (1)
introducing contextual information, and (2) clearly delineating label
boundaries. Furthermore, we introduce an efficient longest common subsequence
(LCS) matching algorithm, which is tailored to transform unstructured
predictions into structured entities. By integrating these components, we
present GNER, a Generative NER system that shows improved zero-shot performance
across unseen entity domains. Our comprehensive evaluation illustrates our
system's superiority, surpassing state-of-the-art (SoTA) methods by 9 $F_1$
score in zero-shot evaluation.
|
[
-0.43856456875801086,
-0.6598576903343201,
0.6014435291290283,
-0.4034930169582367,
-0.4106471836566925,
-0.11134989559650421,
-0.2889861762523651,
-0.6364798545837402,
0.2560860812664032,
0.3685489296913147,
-0.40206101536750793,
-0.6522964835166931,
-0.43976113200187683,
0.22650015354156494,
-0.6430665850639343,
0.9986086487770081,
0.16324932873249054,
-0.1674596220254898,
-0.24618051946163177,
-0.23505492508411407,
-0.5075207352638245,
-0.6483283638954163,
-0.7444555163383484,
-0.5838422179222107,
0.6230085492134094,
0.5954132080078125,
0.26548659801483154,
0.4955521523952484,
0.1596621423959732,
0.224544495344162,
0.1614743322134018,
-0.1802883893251419,
-0.5804576873779297,
0.29909995198249817,
-0.32805171608924866,
-0.2597884237766266,
-0.19231756031513214,
-0.17747507989406586,
0.36049583554267883,
0.4507933259010315,
-0.24650952219963074,
0.09356909245252609,
-0.1884433925151825,
0.363186776638031,
-0.7264779806137085,
0.01123636681586504,
-0.9580025672912598,
0.22891169786453247,
-0.4514772295951843,
-0.3963027894496918,
-0.6511260867118835,
0.1788913756608963,
0.08390146493911743,
-0.8056228160858154,
0.7864975929260254,
-0.0404583178460598,
1.1373082399368286,
0.05378846079111099,
-0.3193425238132477,
-0.28703704476356506,
-0.813413679599762,
0.8362572193145752,
-0.5797656774520874,
0.6679264307022095,
-0.16440679132938385,
0.21599392592906952,
-0.2745434641838074,
-0.12399918586015701,
-0.7477726936340332,
-0.15195900201797485,
0.0833662897348404,
0.11733952164649963,
-0.3624271750450134,
0.10885556042194366,
0.3666907846927643,
0.41850703954696655,
-0.34872668981552124,
0.639255940914154,
-0.26618853211402893,
-0.15275610983371735,
0.4858986735343933,
0.04954610764980316,
0.38615936040878296,
0.07782807946205139,
-0.251708447933197,
0.11594358831644058,
-0.9926601052284241,
-0.26627835631370544,
0.27237460017204285,
0.518402636051178,
-0.030186384916305542,
0.8242602944374084,
-0.249346524477005,
0.7322657704353333,
0.30678796768188477,
0.05681324005126953,
0.3842877447605133,
0.21573123335838318,
-0.46265482902526855,
0.29632413387298584,
0.26554450392723083,
0.4138251543045044,
0.313742995262146,
-0.6135798096656799,
-0.06889011710882187,
0.4683089256286621,
0.3010137379169464,
-1.0793530941009521,
-0.15895166993141174,
-0.00508077023550868,
0.04594035446643829,
-0.10127712786197662,
-0.2945016324520111,
-0.7093710899353027,
-0.48651936650276184,
-0.7820290327072144,
0.4778958559036255,
-0.5627248287200928,
0.06334348767995834,
-0.08489543199539185,
-0.15900301933288574,
0.5025426745414734,
0.6231154203414917,
-0.7740720510482788,
0.21550901234149933,
0.6823385953903198,
0.4666396379470825,
0.16130103170871735,
0.06216253712773323,
-0.7579026222229004,
0.2449922114610672,
-0.4988904297351837,
0.9195124506950378,
-0.5784445405006409,
-0.2587795853614807,
-0.24245423078536987,
-0.03181159868836403,
0.0702466368675232,
-0.7055246829986572,
0.3394146263599396,
-0.7158025503158569,
0.04137871786952019,
-0.054405663162469864,
-0.9099113941192627,
-0.2187355011701584,
0.3812786340713501,
-0.2616848945617676,
0.5331583023071289,
0.056195709854364395,
-0.5409239530563354,
0.776317834854126,
-0.3089938461780548,
-0.532575249671936,
0.48012518882751465,
-0.4609650671482086,
-0.6679845452308655,
0.5414241552352905,
0.16251857578754425,
0.5143027901649475,
-0.23877982795238495,
0.10669732093811035,
-0.3808029592037201,
-0.6931504011154175,
-0.07272662967443466,
-0.21303972601890564,
0.4127625823020935,
-0.23455263674259186,
-0.38914361596107483,
-0.17982244491577148,
-0.9159400463104248,
0.12988026440143585,
0.062263719737529755,
-0.07585633546113968,
-0.7846495509147644,
-0.17599937319755554,
-0.3265426456928253,
0.05599025636911392,
-0.3643088936805725,
-0.6875978112220764,
0.2204757183790207,
-0.3349744975566864,
0.44813960790634155,
0.5723835825920105,
0.10354677587747574,
0.5755589604377747,
0.20033910870552063,
0.4658563435077667,
0.20949426293373108,
-0.22135677933692932,
-0.11773248016834259,
-0.10366855561733246,
-1.1869862079620361,
-0.2144923061132431,
0.3693200945854187,
0.46037471294403076,
-0.9313126802444458,
0.16427521407604218,
-0.3204704821109772,
-0.48642703890800476,
-0.1870240569114685,
0.023129018023610115,
0.46495020389556885,
0.8887819051742554,
0.841742217540741,
-0.32374048233032227,
-0.7209388613700867,
-1.0080238580703735,
-0.06755753606557846,
0.007171842269599438,
-0.0164114348590374,
0.7670807838439941,
0.5960311889648438,
-0.4373760521411896,
0.6152710914611816,
-0.2785450220108032,
-0.5705283880233765,
-0.1741047203540802,
0.06752534955739975,
0.32724320888519287,
0.3524706959724426,
0.24936170876026154,
-0.4836426079273224,
-0.45657822489738464,
-0.1386878937482834,
-0.8499374389648438,
0.11539008468389511,
-0.1816684901714325,
0.018951505422592163,
0.3345358669757843,
0.7108930349349976,
-0.6294990181922913,
0.4482487142086029,
0.26698699593544006,
-0.07825721055269241,
0.5056018829345703,
-0.06349389255046844,
-0.17544661462306976,
-0.7765450477600098,
-0.10424727201461792,
0.3270567059516907,
0.02055308222770691,
-0.7077359557151794,
0.05169215425848961,
0.22244884073734283,
-0.17670060694217682,
-0.4108318090438843,
0.5370815992355347,
-0.9178574681282043,
-0.1484214812517166,
-0.06937279552221298,
0.1844393014907837,
-0.07387841492891312,
0.3403802514076233,
0.07841940224170685,
0.9091048836708069,
0.6594206690788269,
-0.8459101319313049,
-0.03842630982398987,
0.11531893908977509,
-0.3461555242538452,
1.0350624322891235,
-0.6257620453834534,
0.35530683398246765,
-0.6210607290267944,
0.16409963369369507,
-0.311828076839447,
-0.13183651864528656,
0.26133647561073303,
-0.2652176022529602,
0.7989355325698853,
-0.3672204315662384,
-0.04302743822336197,
-0.29230251908302307,
-0.07626251876354218,
0.454794704914093,
0.3340182900428772,
-0.444399893283844,
0.41538986563682556,
0.32423362135887146,
0.13582803308963776,
-0.6877819299697876,
-0.6267167925834656,
0.5676934719085693,
-0.3765875995159149,
0.06505134701728821,
0.8167380690574646,
0.38179025053977966,
-0.009507473558187485,
0.14461643993854523,
-0.34444132447242737,
0.0964214876294136,
0.05622090771794319,
0.31167078018188477,
0.2411498874425888,
-0.309785932302475,
0.45736971497535706,
-0.06494694948196411,
-0.41202855110168457,
-0.4327234625816345,
-0.28421804308891296,
0.3912309408187866,
-0.1398213803768158,
-0.189538836479187,
-0.5138353705406189,
0.09242214262485504,
0.2683001458644867,
-0.11344621330499649,
0.7679574489593506,
0.2538773715496063,
-0.4879378378391266,
-0.3719627559185028,
-0.5240386128425598,
0.035265643149614334,
-0.3820582330226898,
0.28335508704185486,
-0.4857744872570038,
-1.0923811197280884,
0.18032895028591156,
0.12895755469799042,
-0.40528684854507446,
0.43590009212493896,
0.09609249979257584,
-0.10092122852802277,
0.4727506637573242,
0.8048909306526184,
-0.10668138414621353,
0.40926292538642883,
-0.42992737889289856,
0.6269782781600952,
-1.1862012147903442,
-0.21715611219406128,
-0.37170782685279846,
-0.14632655680179596,
-0.47314584255218506,
-0.3848791718482971,
0.23899461328983307,
0.49296486377716064,
-0.3263508677482605,
0.8061325550079346,
-0.548399031162262,
0.722856879234314,
0.3162647485733032,
-0.028018232434988022,
0.16434086859226227,
-0.08710253983736038,
-0.081060990691185,
-0.2681840658187866,
-0.31747278571128845,
-0.38356250524520874,
0.8519837260246277,
0.022203411906957626,
0.6274848580360413,
0.0682123601436615,
1.1190030574798584,
0.32832401990890503,
0.8300026059150696,
-1.0379784107208252,
0.6735625863075256,
-0.4559873342514038,
-0.4756288230419159,
-0.3914051353931427,
-0.3284974694252014,
-0.8438482880592346,
0.25350362062454224,
-0.187380850315094,
-0.8466468453407288,
0.36118680238723755,
0.15349464118480682,
-0.33479398488998413,
0.16919246315956116,
-0.7001568675041199,
0.7585815787315369,
-0.14202284812927246,
-0.11909840255975723,
0.06667947769165039,
-0.07390710711479187,
0.1621541827917099,
0.005954062566161156,
-0.08319654315710068,
-0.11659540235996246,
0.06116895005106926,
0.2802738845348358,
-0.18784016370773315,
0.5829542279243469,
-0.4575585126876831,
-0.313467413187027,
0.219363272190094,
-0.04471259191632271,
0.5119330883026123,
0.1497061848640442,
-0.18286818265914917,
0.462411105632782,
-0.7044126391410828,
-0.13665375113487244,
-0.6715968251228333,
0.7547318935394287,
-0.5060383081436157,
-0.6533297896385193,
-0.35999733209609985,
-0.07400716841220856,
-0.04939010366797447,
0.36556506156921387,
0.37054288387298584,
0.6685724258422852,
-0.32541149854660034,
0.26187556982040405,
0.5851997137069702,
-0.40214648842811584,
0.11063849925994873,
0.7145482897758484,
-0.006971736438572407,
-0.29226553440093994,
0.9053916335105896,
0.40250787138938904,
-0.07933958619832993,
0.8064190149307251,
-0.406764954328537,
-0.41820135712623596,
-0.7255299091339111,
-0.7066246867179871,
0.1765487790107727,
-0.5211166143417358,
-0.6452335119247437,
-0.7448179721832275,
-0.33454617857933044,
-0.177058145403862,
-0.2456199675798416,
-0.19409343600273132,
-0.12325049936771393,
-0.5976069569587708,
-0.23823857307434082,
0.03794312849640846,
0.36359965801239014,
0.0747569128870964,
-0.05321011319756508,
-0.47586315870285034,
0.5026269555091858,
0.3331393003463745,
0.40557560324668884,
0.16870371997356415,
-0.46577832102775574,
-0.002177255693823099,
-0.05336447432637215,
-0.12393949925899506,
-0.790440022945404,
0.3027280867099762,
0.4893118739128113,
0.5610766410827637,
0.2964852452278137,
0.049956247210502625,
1.0370593070983887,
-0.8301169872283936,
0.39771726727485657,
0.22495201230049133,
-1.0556453466415405,
0.4723314940929413,
-0.19594909250736237,
-0.06285493075847626,
0.5479329228401184,
0.19769670069217682,
-0.6554561257362366,
-0.2120114266872406,
-0.5638324022293091,
-1.125749111175537,
0.5252386331558228,
0.16576005518436432,
0.4190119504928589,
-0.29182106256484985,
0.6072763800621033,
0.16029483079910278,
0.20086710155010223,
-0.6977218985557556,
-0.29791155457496643,
-0.13361045718193054,
0.1424735188484192,
-0.4764155447483063,
-0.23044393956661224,
0.326440691947937,
-0.1217421367764473,
1.0696614980697632,
-0.048272378742694855,
0.348646342754364,
0.2844826877117157,
-0.4030429720878601,
-0.07676543295383453,
0.9195494651794434,
0.47264453768730164,
0.20370540022850037,
-0.03158951550722122,
0.3120865821838379,
0.3569897711277008,
0.0528571680188179,
0.4535887539386749,
0.1702490746974945,
-0.725621223449707,
0.07531904429197311,
0.18243221938610077,
0.799433171749115,
0.2876272201538086,
-0.3794730007648468,
0.36369383335113525,
0.009024819359183311,
-0.09446317702531815,
-0.5554840564727783,
0.2744159400463104,
0.031782593578100204,
0.15851350128650665,
0.32210054993629456,
-0.03966567665338516,
0.2057115137577057,
-0.47732335329055786,
0.19166123867034912,
0.6281388998031616,
-0.6579194068908691,
-0.37281590700149536,
0.434498131275177,
-0.0012434154050424695,
-0.4622010290622711,
0.8524318337440491,
-0.594204306602478,
-0.5083046555519104,
0.6254771947860718,
0.7831261157989502,
0.9100388288497925,
0.03851234167814255,
0.5196191072463989,
0.4597356915473938,
0.07941807806491852,
0.11787009984254837,
-0.03818819671869278,
-0.3093527853488922,
-1.0606870651245117,
-0.4081769287586212,
-0.6471332907676697,
-0.3980500400066376,
0.65499347448349,
-0.6868160367012024,
0.4270015060901642,
-0.277084082365036,
-0.07495612651109695,
0.49489253759384155,
-0.21681372821331024,
-0.7939265966415405,
0.30770203471183777,
0.3642711937427521,
0.5348027348518372,
-0.6511716842651367,
0.6925851702690125,
0.7943233251571655,
-0.4689716398715973,
-0.6449778079986572,
-0.0709294006228447,
-0.21688562631607056,
-0.6075061559677124,
0.7009298801422119,
0.7005609273910522,
-0.21261705458164215,
0.21354025602340698,
-0.3026845455169678,
-0.9067798256874084,
0.954544186592102,
0.36136141419410706,
-0.9995278120040894,
0.049082282930612564,
-0.06725529581308365,
0.8398270010948181,
-0.22716744244098663,
0.21650785207748413,
0.2798641622066498,
0.08757326006889343,
-0.09024472534656525,
-0.45146939158439636,
0.031718213111162186,
-0.31758373975753784,
0.2500942349433899,
0.6563205122947693,
-0.31238001585006714,
0.8055705428123474,
-0.5458422899246216,
-0.7863682508468628,
0.1993389129638672,
0.5072787404060364,
0.21342527866363525,
0.40328678488731384,
0.38185301423072815,
1.0937737226486206,
0.6625464558601379,
0.024851053953170776,
0.8201958537101746,
0.04662695527076721,
0.5066367983818054,
1.4346630573272705,
-0.6262710094451904,
0.6306161880493164,
0.6139076948165894,
0.03922053053975105,
0.8633083701133728,
0.15188246965408325,
-0.3619593679904938,
0.49599066376686096,
0.5953312516212463,
-0.29291287064552307,
-0.4867076575756073,
-0.5014145970344543,
-0.5209618806838989,
0.5009744167327881,
0.44085240364074707,
-0.32504212856292725,
-0.6209567189216614,
-0.10124045610427856,
-0.0952528864145279,
0.01734728366136551,
-0.3114467263221741,
0.6941583156585693,
0.1866096407175064,
-0.37131738662719727,
0.4998972415924072,
0.1507783830165863,
0.818149209022522,
-0.04217630252242088,
-0.3346310257911682,
-0.07944700121879578,
0.3939994275569916,
-0.19832465052604675,
-0.3837873637676239,
0.07464687526226044,
0.14615631103515625,
-0.1994345486164093,
-0.11273752152919769,
0.9501016139984131,
-0.2852252125740051,
-0.42325282096862793,
0.4870087802410126,
0.4282592236995697,
0.09595748037099838,
-0.08243829756975174,
-0.3703935742378235,
-0.350582093000412,
-0.3363046646118164,
0.08045122772455215,
0.311535507440567,
0.5263522267341614,
-0.14272679388523102,
0.503886878490448,
0.53028804063797,
-0.11833018809556961,
-0.2179996520280838,
0.48605355620384216,
0.5918756723403931,
-0.9198837876319885,
-0.1929318904876709,
-0.9075190424919128,
0.2381725013256073,
-0.11341048777103424,
-0.24181590974330902,
0.773958146572113,
0.7710855603218079,
1.2613508701324463,
-0.11392774432897568,
0.645291805267334,
-0.10961078852415085,
0.4964149296283722,
-0.32577991485595703,
0.2631981372833252,
-0.5737756490707397,
0.22118830680847168,
-0.35587015748023987,
-1.0180784463882446,
-0.5740196704864502,
0.4746170938014984,
-0.5297685861587524,
-0.016560573130846024,
0.20461994409561157,
0.7062867283821106,
-0.12104983627796173,
-0.07008936256170273,
0.4310482442378998,
0.2565816044807434,
0.38104405999183655,
0.6484147310256958,
1.0100511312484741,
-0.7325932383537292,
0.24991072714328766,
-0.41318127512931824,
0.15047158300876617,
-0.23901109397411346,
-0.9828503727912903,
-0.7764165997505188,
-0.11923733353614807,
-0.4558533728122711,
-0.023065073415637016,
0.4525409936904907,
0.6731919050216675,
0.5617234110832214,
-1.1066131591796875,
0.27578553557395935,
-0.594537615776062,
-0.04264379292726517,
-0.07784812152385712,
-0.31501665711402893,
0.12560217082500458,
-0.2394307404756546,
-0.43249720335006714,
0.47931191325187683,
0.5716177821159363,
0.21182012557983398,
0.1667482852935791,
0.050400301814079285,
0.17271654307842255,
-0.09811863303184509,
0.7041638493537903,
0.47769537568092346,
-0.6823199391365051,
-0.6498472094535828,
0.05425529554486275,
-0.025251323357224464,
0.05099797993898392,
0.7204310894012451,
-0.9461904168128967,
0.25326967239379883,
-0.05594523996114731,
0.5540133118629456,
0.5936463475227356,
0.11180878430604935,
0.23135530948638916,
-0.6147081255912781,
-0.11011555790901184,
0.3848338723182678,
0.3381565511226654,
0.6074360609054565,
-0.4962458610534668,
0.4814758002758026,
0.14413730800151825,
-0.23802657425403595,
-0.8009278774261475,
0.21521902084350586,
-0.6396286487579346,
0.002042433712631464,
1.0078928470611572,
-0.043185293674468994,
0.14752720296382904,
-0.2300787717103958,
0.2114638090133667,
0.3121386766433716,
-0.5334002375602722,
0.8174617886543274,
0.34346112608909607,
-0.3033711612224579,
-0.14906704425811768,
-0.27797824144363403,
-0.014340868219733238,
0.3089076280593872,
-0.5864059925079346,
-0.15122617781162262,
0.6753992438316345,
0.4175248146057129,
0.26227685809135437,
0.7865635752677917,
-0.06960572302341461,
0.060893308371305466,
-0.265282541513443,
0.2803443968296051,
-0.20595228672027588,
-0.6734405159950256,
-0.48808056116104126,
0.11855562776327133,
-0.1510045826435089,
-0.010297562927007675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16596v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16596v1
|
Semantic change detection for Slovene language: a novel dataset and an approach based on optimal transport
| 2024-02-26T14:27:06 | 2024-02-26T14:27:06 |
Marko Pranjić, Kaja Dobrovoljc, Senja Pollak, Matej Martinc
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
In this paper, we focus on the detection of semantic changes in Slovene, a
less resourced Slavic language with two million speakers. Detecting and
tracking semantic changes provides insights into the evolution of the language
caused by changes in society and culture. Recently, several systems have been
proposed to aid in this study, but all depend on manually annotated gold
standard datasets for evaluation. In this paper, we present the first Slovene
dataset for evaluating semantic change detection systems, which contains
aggregated semantic change scores for 104 target words obtained from more than
3000 manually annotated sentence pairs. We evaluate several existing semantic
change detection methods on this dataset and also propose a novel approach
based on optimal transport that improves on the existing state-of-the-art
systems with an error reduction rate of 22.8%.
|
[
-0.37152597308158875,
-0.6055564284324646,
0.2552487254142761,
0.05530109256505966,
-0.3509431779384613,
-0.5817087292671204,
-0.22430367767810822,
-0.542605459690094,
0.36890774965286255,
0.7460697293281555,
-0.8449194431304932,
-0.5717960596084595,
-0.6935822367668152,
0.36932501196861267,
-0.33450281620025635,
0.6745877861976624,
-0.09410460293292999,
0.022805774584412575,
0.15788652002811432,
-0.5096305012702942,
-0.6648725271224976,
-0.04727935418486595,
-0.244329035282135,
-0.37164604663848877,
0.35446757078170776,
0.3645123541355133,
0.5017045736312866,
0.4773370027542114,
0.5141464471817017,
0.24645568430423737,
-0.2262209951877594,
0.16466909646987915,
-0.24350395798683167,
0.3533724844455719,
-0.3793048560619354,
-0.2790016233921051,
-0.041835300624370575,
-0.38254600763320923,
0.9543176889419556,
0.6712047457695007,
0.1288161426782608,
0.5458072423934937,
-0.4205726683139801,
0.8942149877548218,
-0.7083017230033875,
0.5383522510528564,
-1.0214885473251343,
0.10021334141492844,
-0.7329794764518738,
-0.34415480494499207,
-0.4567190110683441,
-0.019902227446436882,
-0.0008170147775672376,
-0.7585145831108093,
-0.19642984867095947,
0.12389998137950897,
0.44522932171821594,
0.44027137756347656,
-0.6566256880760193,
-0.3035464584827423,
-0.5239789485931396,
0.8085337281227112,
-0.39725324511528015,
0.5388652086257935,
0.04156110808253288,
0.16674591600894928,
-0.5465735793113708,
-0.3939721882343292,
-0.30990004539489746,
-0.1316748857498169,
0.050736039876937866,
-0.08787525445222855,
-0.5670909881591797,
-0.35512927174568176,
0.07281868159770966,
-0.3350675702095032,
-0.6173986196517944,
0.11014095693826675,
-0.24288253486156464,
-0.40818408131599426,
0.7172971963882446,
0.4579888582229614,
0.4065046012401581,
-0.13297532498836517,
-0.27367836236953735,
-0.16083204746246338,
-0.6925998330116272,
-0.1868606060743332,
0.3703233599662781,
0.41138821840286255,
0.432390034198761,
0.7317151427268982,
-0.6697084903717041,
1.0869531631469727,
-0.32438185811042786,
-0.159071147441864,
0.5804895162582397,
-0.7529602646827698,
0.02045907825231552,
0.30850422382354736,
0.46639230847358704,
0.6092608571052551,
0.1432543247938156,
-0.31402310729026794,
-0.3044857680797577,
0.4237031936645508,
-0.1475173681974411,
-0.49113503098487854,
-0.2717650234699249,
-0.3944351375102997,
-0.41286954283714294,
-0.15219952166080475,
-0.2836185097694397,
-0.6402792930603027,
-0.3954055905342102,
-0.3460502326488495,
0.1484869420528412,
-0.4034632444381714,
-0.3674739897251129,
0.7101739645004272,
0.023127302527427673,
0.43247148394584656,
0.5295908451080322,
-0.9726783633232117,
0.4398767352104187,
0.5036217570304871,
0.7809005975723267,
-0.364335834980011,
0.0015634861774742603,
-0.522693932056427,
0.0025269438046962023,
-0.5112635493278503,
1.3277839422225952,
-0.4108304977416992,
-0.12033601105213165,
-0.16337423026561737,
0.18188683688640594,
-0.06238485872745514,
-0.47157740592956543,
0.6879225373268127,
-0.5593770742416382,
0.23119713366031647,
-0.16111034154891968,
-0.6117305159568787,
-0.007695714943110943,
0.16940754652023315,
-0.5192613005638123,
1.025478482246399,
0.36098769307136536,
-1.0158122777938843,
0.8422384858131409,
-0.7968763113021851,
-0.3215813934803009,
0.33456677198410034,
0.637718677520752,
-0.3767581582069397,
-0.06535760313272476,
-0.1327248066663742,
-0.10589253157377243,
0.11342781782150269,
0.10633902251720428,
-0.0648011714220047,
-0.2990516722202301,
0.07080734521150589,
-0.01909773238003254,
0.8773816823959351,
0.38093239068984985,
-0.0918632373213768,
-0.08762416988611221,
-0.8213416934013367,
0.147011399269104,
-0.13162806630134583,
-0.44290173053741455,
-0.7763065099716187,
0.11035540699958801,
0.40936657786369324,
0.2699662148952484,
0.36419010162353516,
-1.0203971862792969,
0.3760520815849304,
-0.5867435336112976,
0.11616845428943634,
0.6570858359336853,
0.08160622417926788,
0.6377577781677246,
-0.0513017401099205,
0.13341911137104034,
0.16924165189266205,
0.15865735709667206,
0.085816390812397,
-0.9036900997161865,
-0.6599205136299133,
0.21043863892555237,
0.3273967504501343,
0.5320728421211243,
-0.5709946751594543,
0.5506956577301025,
-0.42139342427253723,
-0.12337731570005417,
-0.4880026876926422,
0.04299845173954964,
-0.1929495483636856,
0.3835703730583191,
0.3738442659378052,
-0.15658670663833618,
-0.6353060603141785,
-0.7445240616798401,
-0.5803595185279846,
-0.37497708201408386,
0.16522856056690216,
-0.08327663689851761,
0.5788052082061768,
-0.39198681712150574,
1.0872602462768555,
-0.48750168085098267,
-0.29280903935432434,
0.040466565638780594,
0.002564036287367344,
-0.24637708067893982,
0.5036699771881104,
0.44865304231643677,
-0.9090417623519897,
-0.25346848368644714,
0.07926502078771591,
-0.3802379071712494,
-0.5786839127540588,
0.04643738642334938,
-0.37026160955429077,
0.3819314241409302,
0.40263769030570984,
-0.4196937382221222,
0.21650724112987518,
0.42005297541618347,
-0.779595673084259,
0.21118338406085968,
-0.21914328634738922,
0.018726546317338943,
-0.715084433555603,
-0.28184160590171814,
-0.18539904057979584,
-0.33224689960479736,
-0.6948454976081848,
-0.2941824793815613,
-0.078884057700634,
0.22310064733028412,
-0.6645599603652954,
0.7023135423660278,
-0.155167818069458,
-0.33748307824134827,
-0.11415503174066544,
0.3980841338634491,
-0.2715073525905609,
0.049210891127586365,
-0.09983713924884796,
0.4512639343738556,
0.42929956316947937,
-0.39208224415779114,
0.5475245118141174,
0.5539523959159851,
-0.5958575010299683,
0.49948766827583313,
-0.12350203841924667,
0.04774868115782738,
-0.3794388473033905,
0.20540310442447662,
-1.0507094860076904,
-0.09395483136177063,
0.674000084400177,
-0.3877617418766022,
-0.06680858135223389,
-0.3044392466545105,
-0.5878189206123352,
-0.03761197626590729,
0.02982538752257824,
-0.12189647555351257,
0.35450026392936707,
-0.06987178325653076,
0.12668843567371368,
0.70860755443573,
-0.1248689815402031,
0.052659157663583755,
-0.9288660287857056,
0.5846706628799438,
-0.26870983839035034,
-1.0548698902130127,
0.12594611942768097,
0.04266587644815445,
-0.41301295161247253,
0.3830988109111786,
-0.005672542843967676,
-0.2809692919254303,
0.3020884394645691,
-0.2389335185289383,
0.21746912598609924,
-0.013018588535487652,
0.5867509245872498,
0.3840034306049347,
-0.5726717114448547,
-0.14858375489711761,
-0.7829638123512268,
0.323951780796051,
-0.1567065566778183,
-0.059987638145685196,
-0.5931534767150879,
0.3486461341381073,
0.4936351776123047,
-0.25836023688316345,
0.8059607744216919,
0.746807336807251,
-0.19787649810314178,
0.2332848459482193,
-0.26474979519844055,
0.0718844011425972,
-0.30490294098854065,
0.39177265763282776,
-0.4112919569015503,
-0.7745291590690613,
0.39537644386291504,
-0.38976001739501953,
-0.07433611154556274,
0.7359923720359802,
0.6566987037658691,
0.361833393573761,
1.200475811958313,
0.3660925030708313,
0.2023119330406189,
0.6522060632705688,
0.157809779047966,
0.09555727243423462,
-0.6869128942489624,
-0.42900350689888,
-0.6469774842262268,
-0.13237440586090088,
-1.1749546527862549,
-0.2764306664466858,
0.32295823097229004,
-0.4698505103588104,
-0.1556738317012787,
0.5263060927391052,
-0.45979225635528564,
0.27524280548095703,
0.2658795714378357,
-0.0748928114771843,
0.5195364952087402,
-0.11784045398235321,
0.03866034373641014,
-0.11006125062704086,
-0.6462659239768982,
-0.5644914507865906,
0.9644200801849365,
-0.16230574250221252,
0.7008998990058899,
0.28902751207351685,
0.7005146741867065,
0.6418908834457397,
-0.05059024691581726,
-0.6928909420967102,
0.7651477456092834,
-0.22833089530467987,
-0.3443228304386139,
-0.5313614010810852,
-0.5456288456916809,
-1.124131679534912,
0.4533538818359375,
-0.4314868748188019,
-0.6399598121643066,
0.0851653590798378,
-0.07892461866140366,
0.494037926197052,
0.20041969418525696,
-0.7106191515922546,
0.9819880127906799,
0.13520897924900055,
-0.18200035393238068,
-0.11364354938268661,
-0.74200439453125,
0.1494065225124359,
-0.09912905842065811,
0.082941934466362,
-0.37808653712272644,
-0.3099422752857208,
0.7224385738372803,
-0.31332337856292725,
0.22185443341732025,
-0.45558640360832214,
0.12300878763198853,
0.2094886600971222,
0.1724136918783188,
0.6786026954650879,
-0.3103129267692566,
-0.26488783955574036,
-0.16391442716121674,
0.26797837018966675,
-0.5355209708213806,
-0.563520610332489,
0.6472173929214478,
-0.40930089354515076,
-0.0004577390500344336,
-0.3965814411640167,
-0.5936765074729919,
-0.04987913742661476,
0.12882840633392334,
0.11745920032262802,
0.3087424337863922,
-0.10669790953397751,
-0.03156014531850815,
0.4643603563308716,
-0.09610681235790253,
0.15672148764133453,
0.9300826787948608,
-0.09133518487215042,
0.17998436093330383,
0.8494126796722412,
0.3411111533641815,
0.10628063976764679,
0.16685326397418976,
0.4393131136894226,
-0.524678111076355,
-0.7438022494316101,
-0.7445220947265625,
0.10500116646289825,
-0.6196691393852234,
0.1479693055152893,
-0.6707817316055298,
0.4851697087287903,
-0.6075438261032104,
0.10491521656513214,
-0.3813278079032898,
-0.5179811120033264,
-0.06544238328933716,
0.28458815813064575,
0.45181557536125183,
0.8766381740570068,
-0.017424363642930984,
-0.09465590864419937,
-0.5721901655197144,
-0.2299858182668686,
0.15772227942943573,
0.1877405345439911,
-0.666698157787323,
-0.5444402694702148,
-0.20201407372951508,
0.14316494762897491,
0.049140505492687225,
-0.6852436065673828,
0.49613654613494873,
0.20507432520389557,
0.5049076676368713,
-0.08347450196743011,
0.39137551188468933,
0.46302416920661926,
-0.45623841881752014,
0.8239440321922302,
-0.0029483800753951073,
-0.8949745297431946,
0.6695989370346069,
-0.14715349674224854,
0.587986171245575,
0.5182199478149414,
-0.22197771072387695,
-0.8260741233825684,
-0.4091435670852661,
-0.35342320799827576,
-0.5617039203643799,
0.782820999622345,
0.26698562502861023,
0.2034638226032257,
0.04066387563943863,
0.18213829398155212,
0.05783421918749809,
0.013395668007433414,
-0.4415489733219147,
-0.08194710314273834,
0.010496177710592747,
-0.17308039963245392,
0.10813473910093307,
0.02201458439230919,
0.16914086043834686,
-0.25710955262184143,
0.6268067955970764,
-0.06301338970661163,
0.15196938812732697,
0.035428959876298904,
-0.47912174463272095,
0.019028915092349052,
0.4974523186683655,
0.9061940908432007,
0.48283034563064575,
-0.007632613182067871,
0.0344940721988678,
0.5052337050437927,
-0.40894022583961487,
0.35138073563575745,
-0.309492826461792,
-0.6497324109077454,
0.4366215467453003,
0.15665462613105774,
1.074254035949707,
0.213546022772789,
-0.6071293950080872,
0.6759454607963562,
0.09049060195684433,
-0.1386726349592209,
-0.3974696397781372,
0.07059766352176666,
-0.17820602655410767,
0.07596272230148315,
-0.06073950231075287,
0.43509089946746826,
0.46011245250701904,
-0.29178956151008606,
0.2791414260864258,
0.17207244038581848,
-0.5468128323554993,
-0.34504494071006775,
0.3382608890533447,
0.04635598883032799,
-0.3237890303134918,
0.2841370701789856,
-0.6864343881607056,
-0.4366593062877655,
0.042435936629772186,
0.41223663091659546,
0.590267539024353,
-0.3623952567577362,
0.4558151364326477,
0.08203145861625671,
0.2753891944885254,
-0.2319062501192093,
-0.019850140437483788,
-0.06690533459186554,
-1.0738976001739502,
-0.3610781729221344,
-0.5643818378448486,
-0.36504626274108887,
-0.4220096468925476,
-0.6456974744796753,
0.532656729221344,
0.2967124879360199,
-0.14819951355457306,
-0.06368497014045715,
0.029371723532676697,
-0.3301166892051697,
-0.057328034192323685,
0.19636228680610657,
0.9113885760307312,
-1.244002342224121,
0.8109776973724365,
0.9604210257530212,
0.04576120153069496,
-0.10525181889533997,
-0.3772764205932617,
0.07963201403617859,
-0.619640588760376,
1.1342835426330566,
-0.11745410412549973,
-0.44566383957862854,
0.0030457540415227413,
-0.2700759172439575,
-0.7746872901916504,
0.7372012138366699,
0.5051993131637573,
-0.19669963419437408,
0.3457321226596832,
0.1704391986131668,
0.7377324104309082,
-0.33550912141799927,
-0.05785162374377251,
0.7627171277999878,
0.8564372062683105,
0.17973724007606506,
-0.5263242125511169,
-0.412444144487381,
-0.1886908859014511,
0.27115410566329956,
0.7522715926170349,
-0.4774864912033081,
0.6565998792648315,
0.21717515587806702,
-0.3072807192802429,
-0.03470141068100929,
0.26483702659606934,
-0.36587610840797424,
0.46632593870162964,
0.7996909022331238,
0.5998808145523071,
0.8552089929580688,
-0.1728290617465973,
0.7885933518409729,
-0.3307001292705536,
0.583595871925354,
0.8156024813652039,
-0.4708945155143738,
0.5981388092041016,
0.48397985100746155,
-0.05846831202507019,
0.5272158980369568,
0.6165847182273865,
0.1917584240436554,
0.8341931700706482,
0.46054255962371826,
-0.6123940348625183,
-0.548429548740387,
-0.20111183822155,
-0.12103096395730972,
0.8647481799125671,
0.2909248471260071,
0.034185998141765594,
-0.6541849374771118,
0.4215374290943146,
0.32936814427375793,
-0.21738667786121368,
-0.32433921098709106,
0.877127468585968,
-0.5945819616317749,
-0.5015190839767456,
0.3670961260795593,
0.024439770728349686,
0.32653969526290894,
-0.6171611547470093,
0.02194053679704666,
-0.01457943208515644,
0.16005544364452362,
-0.0808374285697937,
-0.8950888514518738,
0.6187924742698669,
-0.03736284747719765,
-0.03658235818147659,
-0.47159314155578613,
0.9893807172775269,
-0.6532153487205505,
-0.6718488335609436,
0.4083353579044342,
0.05891932174563408,
0.48540812730789185,
0.10620231926441193,
-0.587531328201294,
0.3802335858345032,
0.023058440536260605,
-0.15552188456058502,
0.5021814703941345,
0.5128616094589233,
-0.27830857038497925,
0.6988682150840759,
0.6060124039649963,
0.400158166885376,
0.3517806828022003,
-0.1498202085494995,
0.8612061142921448,
-0.2910915017127991,
-0.49330317974090576,
-0.4208146035671234,
0.2909213900566101,
-0.20453442633152008,
-0.4713536500930786,
0.5803512334823608,
0.4136718213558197,
0.7654091119766235,
0.05001068487763405,
0.5993533134460449,
0.04486298933625221,
0.631632924079895,
-0.6801168322563171,
0.23537011444568634,
-0.4053751826286316,
0.3209396302700043,
-0.264093816280365,
-0.892190158367157,
-0.5598021149635315,
0.8490278720855713,
-0.37512534856796265,
-0.6573854684829712,
0.6283016204833984,
0.9456876516342163,
0.2173701822757721,
0.21498261392116547,
0.46575841307640076,
0.27511298656463623,
0.2285417914390564,
0.3848503828048706,
0.5203962922096252,
-0.5551046133041382,
0.3639092743396759,
0.16391581296920776,
-0.20318228006362915,
-0.3224918842315674,
-0.7813732028007507,
-0.19659928977489471,
-0.7706352472305298,
-0.5601953864097595,
-0.2314537912607193,
0.43917298316955566,
0.9078382253646851,
0.4557933807373047,
-0.8971496224403381,
0.029514305293560028,
-0.2941550016403198,
0.013074216432869434,
0.024683302268385887,
-0.18769244849681854,
0.15325799584388733,
-0.5648946166038513,
-0.5056090354919434,
0.3960343301296234,
0.6197927594184875,
-0.13930794596672058,
-0.2046024650335312,
0.03479187563061714,
-0.31863078474998474,
-0.08835587650537491,
0.7325320243835449,
-0.012096541002392769,
-0.5561840534210205,
-0.8150615096092224,
-0.003156398655846715,
-0.0251785721629858,
-0.030051957815885544,
0.740511417388916,
-0.733578085899353,
0.8869092464447021,
0.8355424404144287,
0.4391095042228699,
0.7857082486152649,
-0.22640620172023773,
-0.01514079887419939,
-0.09854782372713089,
0.4531016945838928,
0.05554632097482681,
0.3101954162120819,
0.41994309425354004,
-0.03927548974752426,
0.4107967019081116,
0.7791856527328491,
-0.6758179664611816,
-0.616645336151123,
0.26960819959640503,
-0.9947060346603394,
0.12982982397079468,
1.0981656312942505,
-0.277578741312027,
-0.38501080870628357,
-0.734366238117218,
-0.2997475862503052,
-0.07956176996231079,
-0.4240391254425049,
0.4783298373222351,
0.746239960193634,
-0.40233173966407776,
0.058058515191078186,
-0.37254199385643005,
0.22415991127490997,
0.06020418554544449,
-0.7698620557785034,
0.0360427089035511,
0.6881786584854126,
0.5217588543891907,
-0.017685724422335625,
0.5811452269554138,
-0.19120776653289795,
-0.023118719458580017,
0.060407690703868866,
-0.20289091765880585,
0.187002032995224,
-0.16387632489204407,
-0.2336731106042862,
-0.21547822654247284,
-0.30300912261009216,
-0.3957393765449524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16578v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16578v1
|
Multi-Bit Distortion-Free Watermarking for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-26T14:01:34 | 2024-02-26T14:01:34 |
Massieh Kordi Boroujeny, Ya Jiang, Kai Zeng, Brian Mark
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Methods for watermarking large language models have been proposed that
distinguish AI-generated text from human-generated text by slightly altering
the model output distribution, but they also distort the quality of the text,
exposing the watermark to adversarial detection. More recently, distortion-free
watermarking methods were proposed that require a secret key to detect the
watermark. The prior methods generally embed zero-bit watermarks that do not
provide additional information beyond tagging a text as being AI-generated. We
extend an existing zero-bit distortion-free watermarking method by embedding
multiple bits of meta-information as part of the watermark. We also develop a
computationally efficient decoder that extracts the embedded information from
the watermark with low bit error rate.
|
[
-0.5222975015640259,
-0.7984592914581299,
0.4620960056781769,
0.0035483408719301224,
-0.7272453904151917,
-0.06319309026002884,
0.00025539533817209303,
-0.577970564365387,
0.3577538728713989,
0.6794013977050781,
-0.537788450717926,
-0.24215824902057648,
-0.8942400217056274,
-0.13670822978019714,
-0.5579349398612976,
0.7818703055381775,
0.258678674697876,
0.055026546120643616,
0.06001180410385132,
-0.2676090598106384,
-0.0607542023062706,
-0.8187305331230164,
-0.34519538283348083,
-0.13828837871551514,
0.11112583428621292,
0.13649152219295502,
0.9233947992324829,
1.0125946998596191,
0.45863038301467896,
0.1786068230867386,
-0.22822251915931702,
0.18522585928440094,
-0.11765186488628387,
0.3034883737564087,
0.037130504846572876,
-0.41661882400512695,
-0.35449641942977905,
0.03871574252843857,
0.8613861203193665,
0.2922988533973694,
0.2960142195224762,
0.10456164926290512,
0.007970115169882774,
0.6117250323295593,
-0.9454032778739929,
0.4081532955169678,
-0.7104048132896423,
0.1119265928864479,
-0.3681212067604065,
-0.15642739832401276,
-0.5173035860061646,
-0.1410137116909027,
-0.25257542729377747,
-0.5713813304901123,
0.3264453709125519,
0.08260651677846909,
1.0315696001052856,
0.30750077962875366,
-0.3794574439525604,
-0.23797987401485443,
-1.0928537845611572,
0.8165696263313293,
-0.97944176197052,
0.4316372573375702,
0.4622512757778168,
0.20337630808353424,
0.13990363478660583,
-0.5496814250946045,
-0.7584115862846375,
0.1850453019142151,
0.2108374387025833,
-0.019110068678855896,
-0.31022533774375916,
0.05979965254664421,
0.3036252558231354,
0.46469417214393616,
-0.286984920501709,
-0.48983752727508545,
-0.08960577845573425,
-0.34350061416625977,
0.7388474941253662,
0.054177213460206985,
0.2207174301147461,
0.16716930270195007,
-0.20771998167037964,
-0.579058825969696,
-0.9606232643127441,
-0.42382803559303284,
0.5531733632087708,
0.40268054604530334,
0.12305109202861786,
0.4289582669734955,
-0.011156752705574036,
0.5462988615036011,
-0.1128542348742485,
-0.06294965744018555,
0.15268339216709137,
-0.12101465463638306,
-0.13204137980937958,
0.1223692074418068,
1.088212013244629,
-0.0042682429775595665,
0.3794640302658081,
-0.16965758800506592,
-0.36654165387153625,
-0.0011622707825154066,
0.13709570467472076,
-1.029012680053711,
-0.23004503548145294,
-0.1077832281589508,
-0.5436980128288269,
-0.2803958058357239,
0.3129810392856598,
-0.9431716203689575,
-0.6655403971672058,
-0.001206678687594831,
0.6775150299072266,
-0.2543167471885681,
-0.36233240365982056,
0.14002780616283417,
-0.3603435754776001,
0.10935436934232712,
0.10753612965345383,
-0.8095414638519287,
0.2447851598262787,
0.4143020212650299,
0.7179522514343262,
0.20518964529037476,
-0.07632561028003693,
-0.4733227491378784,
0.46946510672569275,
-0.34517601132392883,
0.7011886835098267,
-0.7807134985923767,
-0.3067217469215393,
-0.02326022833585739,
-0.06397252529859543,
0.3618071973323822,
-0.4519319236278534,
0.3542822599411011,
-0.811058521270752,
0.11751985549926758,
-0.2648145258426666,
-0.7284837365150452,
-0.28355932235717773,
0.09111394733190536,
-1.2766835689544678,
0.7172333598136902,
-0.059268563985824585,
-1.0236512422561646,
0.11775138974189758,
-0.7166339159011841,
-0.4259204864501953,
-0.1164856031537056,
0.014927392825484276,
-0.8540849685668945,
0.1049235388636589,
0.38629764318466187,
0.18919260799884796,
-0.17475882172584534,
0.05187380686402321,
-0.46887752413749695,
-0.2048291265964508,
0.4471597373485565,
-1.2155954837799072,
0.7770658731460571,
-0.07143791019916534,
-0.5557201504707336,
-0.0045951842330396175,
-0.8007146120071411,
0.13557428121566772,
0.39323267340660095,
-0.46714550256729126,
-0.5606873631477356,
0.06350316852331161,
0.12862272560596466,
0.07382868975400925,
0.20407767593860626,
-0.5174509286880493,
0.3789166212081909,
-0.17248572409152985,
0.5236692428588867,
0.7612581253051758,
0.05206923186779022,
0.2953628897666931,
-0.069745734333992,
0.46219944953918457,
0.11979546397924423,
0.26658502221107483,
-0.2188417911529541,
-0.6505496501922607,
-0.9076220989227295,
-0.39374202489852905,
0.7284225225448608,
0.39095091819763184,
-0.8291929364204407,
0.41978198289871216,
-0.2625944912433624,
-0.35070493817329407,
-0.8381359577178955,
0.07460270822048187,
0.45178326964378357,
-0.10502902418375015,
0.5884115099906921,
-0.4057217836380005,
-0.15132646262645721,
-0.8482997417449951,
-0.34594041109085083,
0.04746804013848305,
-0.004082976840436459,
0.4523964524269104,
0.6419117450714111,
-0.11049623042345047,
0.7191559672355652,
-0.70582115650177,
-0.34537696838378906,
-0.13837361335754395,
0.3427930772304535,
-0.3403944671154022,
0.5421963334083557,
0.550014078617096,
-0.9195526838302612,
-0.568352222442627,
-0.3709046244621277,
-0.28434285521507263,
0.04513268172740936,
-0.02870171144604683,
-0.046149808913469315,
0.057442959398031235,
0.4633252024650574,
-0.6022732853889465,
0.5644233226776123,
0.923542857170105,
-0.6582899689674377,
0.4838518500328064,
-0.29583439230918884,
0.094337597489357,
-1.1171094179153442,
0.04217463731765747,
-0.3349008560180664,
-0.46267569065093994,
-0.740766167640686,
0.1311570703983307,
0.28502193093299866,
-0.025120757520198822,
-0.19032664597034454,
0.5099212527275085,
-0.6093635559082031,
0.05808296054601669,
-0.5259974598884583,
-0.13281512260437012,
0.18131940066814423,
0.3324538767337799,
0.151504784822464,
0.7074291110038757,
0.6040599346160889,
-0.3587218225002289,
0.45513737201690674,
-0.07608495652675629,
-0.15724317729473114,
0.36703744530677795,
-0.6916154623031616,
0.3590351939201355,
-0.21100464463233948,
0.1502830684185028,
-0.904036283493042,
0.02966681867837906,
0.3703509569168091,
-0.4030531048774719,
0.5222612023353577,
-0.325888454914093,
-0.6559059619903564,
0.14532539248466492,
-0.4186200797557831,
0.6029345989227295,
0.18634091317653656,
-0.3976169228553772,
0.47225603461265564,
0.26783671975135803,
0.0693126916885376,
-0.4855026304721832,
-0.9672096371650696,
0.19864611327648163,
-0.1495593637228012,
-0.3725976049900055,
0.6988425850868225,
-0.20941691100597382,
0.11438117176294327,
0.3633640706539154,
-0.07243030518293381,
-0.5580496788024902,
0.06330089271068573,
0.24405929446220398,
0.09795396775007248,
-0.24359075725078583,
-0.14117279648780823,
0.15745887160301208,
-0.2649281919002533,
-0.1269608587026596,
-0.3514821231365204,
0.7021239399909973,
-0.03910760208964348,
-0.6080590486526489,
-0.5759403109550476,
0.768034815788269,
0.8831679224967957,
-0.5485984683036804,
1.0714119672775269,
0.7276215553283691,
-0.7829367518424988,
-0.14125476777553558,
-0.2909547984600067,
-0.23608924448490143,
-0.4333796799182892,
0.08741343766450882,
0.08065719902515411,
-0.7705517411231995,
0.4508894085884094,
0.16228318214416504,
-0.04967021569609642,
0.6339479088783264,
0.1585932821035385,
0.24015136063098907,
1.0356717109680176,
0.8317456841468811,
-0.47075796127319336,
0.6833415627479553,
-0.40086081624031067,
0.23310954868793488,
-0.9097620248794556,
0.1497156172990799,
-0.6439406871795654,
-0.27826008200645447,
-0.27158066630363464,
-0.4417266547679901,
0.10507486760616302,
0.37211644649505615,
-0.3176177442073822,
0.24188746511936188,
-0.5336669087409973,
0.546281635761261,
1.079798936843872,
0.09236397594213486,
0.22867590188980103,
0.029827548190951347,
0.0767892375588417,
0.007685776334255934,
-0.22561801970005035,
-0.38576212525367737,
1.1393473148345947,
0.010890745557844639,
0.753607451915741,
0.212701678276062,
0.605174720287323,
0.4470686614513397,
0.2776794135570526,
-0.5202122926712036,
0.21502096951007843,
-0.11806333065032959,
-1.099727749824524,
-0.5040642619132996,
-0.501886248588562,
-0.8593917489051819,
0.2954845726490021,
-0.4372948408126831,
-0.5500481724739075,
-0.02166782133281231,
0.23799318075180054,
-0.28156259655952454,
0.5977441072463989,
-0.364603191614151,
0.7673863768577576,
-0.09834157675504684,
-0.03149624541401863,
-0.187140092253685,
-0.4303283393383026,
0.08198779821395874,
-0.07689716666936874,
0.355353981256485,
0.05255268141627312,
0.009369571693241596,
0.7643202543258667,
-0.27070677280426025,
0.7777987122535706,
-0.5803762078285217,
-0.09754899144172668,
0.37682363390922546,
0.39227041602134705,
0.7068217396736145,
0.05064966529607773,
0.14469794929027557,
0.2047581970691681,
-0.00242545735090971,
-0.2949717342853546,
-0.5159581899642944,
0.23373687267303467,
-0.6561948657035828,
-0.45354142785072327,
-0.4073691964149475,
-0.3922899067401886,
-0.03329237923026085,
0.46663984656333923,
0.2803012728691101,
0.3519885838031769,
0.21707622706890106,
0.42799055576324463,
0.6547558307647705,
-0.36984142661094666,
0.6531376242637634,
0.4819331467151642,
0.24971653521060944,
-0.7330634593963623,
1.021881103515625,
0.14043112099170685,
0.37495556473731995,
0.3333790600299835,
0.34359854459762573,
-0.18343019485473633,
-0.6142633557319641,
-0.6842923760414124,
0.1633596271276474,
-0.5704216361045837,
-0.5456206798553467,
-0.26003116369247437,
-0.48950159549713135,
-0.3228837251663208,
0.20985691249370575,
-0.8580870032310486,
-0.5122862458229065,
-0.4159257411956787,
0.24540983140468597,
0.250072717666626,
0.8590526580810547,
-0.01852283999323845,
0.4922371506690979,
-1.0269660949707031,
0.5501717329025269,
0.24782684445381165,
0.5565959215164185,
0.07811543345451355,
-0.4031703770160675,
-0.2140560895204544,
0.40155351161956787,
-0.6028453707695007,
-1.0716749429702759,
0.45643001794815063,
0.4012976586818695,
0.38171952962875366,
0.8797587156295776,
0.29634371399879456,
0.5014641284942627,
-0.62985759973526,
0.9863308072090149,
0.09691502898931503,
-1.3520805835723877,
0.31404614448547363,
0.07173796743154526,
0.1376911699771881,
0.06131463870406151,
0.16822053492069244,
-0.5091912150382996,
-0.37404942512512207,
-0.6825644969940186,
-0.8970476388931274,
0.6345389485359192,
0.24321435391902924,
0.4421216547489166,
0.1767655313014984,
0.3015245795249939,
0.004665662534534931,
0.2708425521850586,
-1.1190382242202759,
-0.5701418519020081,
-0.447356641292572,
-0.16560521721839905,
0.14873051643371582,
-0.5114280581474304,
-0.07043559849262238,
-0.04810898378491402,
0.84619140625,
-0.16957272589206696,
0.6130570769309998,
0.2057672142982483,
-0.11941353976726532,
-0.11691274493932724,
0.355042427778244,
0.7470492720603943,
0.08198050409555435,
0.03560434654355049,
0.4177071750164032,
-0.1502111852169037,
-0.5276206135749817,
0.19669266045093536,
0.010610259138047695,
-0.378868967294693,
0.10817883908748627,
0.6149798631668091,
0.8266295790672302,
-0.32543647289276123,
-0.24616806209087372,
0.843420147895813,
-0.1512368619441986,
-0.14645648002624512,
-0.01110438909381628,
-0.005064543802291155,
0.27921798825263977,
0.3013693392276764,
0.3573058545589447,
-0.023150144144892693,
0.20574429631233215,
-0.21910738945007324,
0.061034947633743286,
0.7749382853507996,
-0.4994947910308838,
-0.47936689853668213,
0.8236861824989319,
-0.11955929547548294,
-0.23252907395362854,
0.6329087615013123,
-0.4139033854007721,
-0.7314731478691101,
0.3106909394264221,
0.7357054948806763,
0.9223596453666687,
-0.47104740142822266,
-0.0473489910364151,
0.11698709428310394,
0.5868958234786987,
-0.12887878715991974,
0.38886556029319763,
-0.00845564715564251,
-0.9183623194694519,
-0.30516427755355835,
-0.5301598310470581,
-0.32421186566352844,
0.5032593011856079,
-0.6139587163925171,
-0.0687771737575531,
-0.45423540472984314,
-0.2879501283168793,
0.03868355602025986,
-0.31454041600227356,
-0.462939590215683,
0.1837548017501831,
0.5005506873130798,
0.6808173656463623,
-0.782401978969574,
0.9488945007324219,
0.34675610065460205,
-0.15013021230697632,
-0.5062592029571533,
0.24140208959579468,
-0.015343422070145607,
-0.4554881155490875,
0.19789840281009674,
0.1278758943080902,
-0.16970272362232208,
-0.1617174595594406,
-0.698279619216919,
-1.112130880355835,
0.7878090739250183,
0.8303128480911255,
-0.3400692939758301,
0.1281927227973938,
0.5437992811203003,
0.35548365116119385,
-0.18583278357982635,
-0.10305596143007278,
0.18341408669948578,
0.549677848815918,
-0.3342466950416565,
-0.6725090742111206,
0.2507512867450714,
-0.24401907622814178,
-0.06421991437673569,
0.29303282499313354,
-0.6384454965591431,
0.951171338558197,
0.11522891372442245,
-0.37596070766448975,
-0.15108779072761536,
0.5357949137687683,
-0.28193753957748413,
-0.08459369093179703,
0.491504043340683,
0.4952865540981293,
0.6731517910957336,
-0.1758219599723816,
0.7860617637634277,
-0.6058164238929749,
0.5994817018508911,
0.761049211025238,
0.060854122042655945,
0.8938151597976685,
0.41962602734565735,
-0.06755643337965012,
0.36355555057525635,
0.20151469111442566,
-0.19191017746925354,
0.7084878087043762,
0.22516673803329468,
-0.3849288523197174,
-0.3208905756473541,
0.07339807599782944,
-0.4645005166530609,
0.32264792919158936,
0.48155975341796875,
-0.6512751579284668,
-0.03003380447626114,
-0.153789684176445,
-0.060323964804410934,
-0.2920290231704712,
-0.1579950600862503,
0.8175815939903259,
-0.03046450950205326,
-0.10877912491559982,
0.5406435132026672,
0.4679846167564392,
0.8018551468849182,
-0.3567216694355011,
-0.2074344903230667,
-0.008947499096393585,
0.28603115677833557,
-0.04390789195895195,
-0.7690879702568054,
0.44060686230659485,
-0.033629391342401505,
-0.31640657782554626,
-0.10442689806222916,
0.6442564725875854,
-0.5674034953117371,
-0.46128109097480774,
0.28871020674705505,
0.29808568954467773,
0.13178779184818268,
-0.6147819757461548,
-0.6354935169219971,
0.08631549775600433,
-0.12203643471002579,
-0.5425242185592651,
0.1000574380159378,
0.4636417031288147,
0.08427172899246216,
0.7010815739631653,
0.5971671342849731,
0.3212786316871643,
0.3222716450691223,
0.09526988118886948,
0.723681628704071,
-0.7684891223907471,
-0.42020753026008606,
-1.2267742156982422,
0.20132577419281006,
-0.047748200595378876,
-0.062318116426467896,
0.5938796401023865,
0.6181127429008484,
0.6481314301490784,
-0.21427762508392334,
1.199915885925293,
0.035392846912145615,
-0.07222079485654831,
-0.47293761372566223,
0.9589385986328125,
-0.5252195596694946,
-0.0645400807261467,
-0.6203566789627075,
-0.9134172797203064,
-0.649712324142456,
0.6119765043258667,
0.344428688287735,
-0.02757357805967331,
0.47605574131011963,
0.6619322896003723,
-0.19238421320915222,
0.00499135022982955,
0.3300846815109253,
-0.2510620653629303,
0.662524402141571,
0.4592735469341278,
0.6637789011001587,
-0.678816556930542,
0.9055221080780029,
-0.3657759726047516,
-0.024620432406663895,
-0.1374930888414383,
-1.007844090461731,
-0.8242841362953186,
-0.707854151725769,
-0.38639718294143677,
-0.41171446442604065,
-0.0652475357055664,
0.6901975870132446,
0.9360809326171875,
-1.0967652797698975,
0.3041348457336426,
0.04193710535764694,
0.10500632971525192,
-0.3180047273635864,
-0.23193605244159698,
0.6912285685539246,
0.24654439091682434,
-0.7692002654075623,
0.15259699523448944,
0.23413696885108948,
0.6492889523506165,
-0.42488735914230347,
-0.12274094671010971,
0.22135388851165771,
0.4632917046546936,
0.3752554655075073,
-0.04474277421832085,
-0.42335784435272217,
-0.49901336431503296,
-0.21292340755462646,
0.006442219018936157,
0.08563903719186783,
0.9344544410705566,
-0.2598566710948944,
0.33577027916908264,
0.3574497103691101,
0.6494079828262329,
0.4912124276161194,
-0.1053510531783104,
0.24393142759799957,
-0.9428513646125793,
0.11485514789819717,
0.15350037813186646,
0.4661077558994293,
0.4425836205482483,
-0.3100082278251648,
-0.016455627977848053,
0.4844563901424408,
-0.2903856039047241,
-0.7328332662582397,
0.1137368232011795,
-0.6614009141921997,
-0.40724891424179077,
1.2035760879516602,
-0.4040060043334961,
-0.13302156329154968,
0.013677727431058884,
-0.26541993021965027,
0.41051486134529114,
-0.36713361740112305,
0.8591673970222473,
1.03519868850708,
0.12673525512218475,
-0.026381468400359154,
-0.4108045697212219,
0.581733226776123,
-0.018863840028643608,
-0.7587849497795105,
0.5140963196754456,
0.2419622838497162,
0.38560232520103455,
0.4955659806728363,
0.3388693928718567,
-0.3697192966938019,
0.03130899742245674,
0.37990671396255493,
0.29884666204452515,
-0.2407214194536209,
-0.6536054015159607,
-0.2958994507789612,
0.17228896915912628,
0.1817852407693863,
-0.32991862297058105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16568v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16568v1
|
Two-stage Generative Question Answering on Temporal Knowledge Graph Using Large Language Models
| 2024-02-26T13:47:09 | 2024-02-26T13:47:09 |
Yifu Gao, Linbo Qiao, Zhigang Kan, Zhihua Wen, Yongquan He, Dongsheng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Temporal knowledge graph question answering (TKGQA) poses a significant
challenge task, due to the temporal constraints hidden in questions and the
answers sought from dynamic structured knowledge. Although large language
models (LLMs) have made considerable progress in their reasoning ability over
structured data, their application to the TKGQA task is a relatively unexplored
area. This paper first proposes a novel generative temporal knowledge graph
question answering framework, GenTKGQA, which guides LLMs to answer temporal
questions through two phases: Subgraph Retrieval and Answer Generation. First,
we exploit LLM's intrinsic knowledge to mine temporal constraints and
structural links in the questions without extra training, thus narrowing down
the subgraph search space in both temporal and structural dimensions. Next, we
design virtual knowledge indicators to fuse the graph neural network signals of
the subgraph and the text representations of the LLM in a non-shallow way,
which helps the open-source LLM deeply understand the temporal order and
structural dependencies among the retrieved facts through instruction tuning.
Experimental results demonstrate that our model outperforms state-of-the-art
baselines, even achieving 100\% on the metrics for the simple question type.
|
[
-0.09946315735578537,
-1.2628567218780518,
0.8857237696647644,
0.08288706094026566,
-0.33276912569999695,
0.47471773624420166,
0.07805850356817245,
-0.3489479124546051,
-0.19270597398281097,
0.32255467772483826,
-0.8053697943687439,
-0.7497221231460571,
-0.3989575207233429,
-0.17462749779224396,
-0.19749030470848083,
0.6010136604309082,
-0.21135655045509338,
-0.1134261041879654,
-0.3965797424316406,
0.07995621114969254,
-0.31109461188316345,
-0.25857558846473694,
-0.8042770624160767,
-0.7500861883163452,
0.5536512732505798,
0.21399058401584625,
0.41198888421058655,
0.4898572564125061,
-0.1894250214099884,
0.18668149411678314,
-0.3550163805484772,
0.13255012035369873,
-0.4985225200653076,
0.14955148100852966,
-0.0741254910826683,
-0.37862658500671387,
-0.3520727753639221,
-0.27509620785713196,
0.674713671207428,
0.9399244785308838,
0.06470846384763718,
0.3765295445919037,
0.014377239160239697,
0.3340260684490204,
-0.24273589253425598,
0.7855368852615356,
-0.6128801107406616,
0.3436141610145569,
-0.1899445652961731,
-0.30609023571014404,
-0.2793489992618561,
-0.5307004451751709,
-0.0029977643862366676,
-0.7752903699874878,
0.27461472153663635,
-0.055745888501405716,
0.7968599796295166,
0.3361547291278839,
-0.7991989850997925,
-0.005984358489513397,
-0.6236254572868347,
0.4451932907104492,
-0.5433778762817383,
0.4688459634780884,
0.4011369049549103,
0.41147974133491516,
-0.18593427538871765,
-0.9201085567474365,
-0.5449150204658508,
-0.19544070959091187,
0.029030393809080124,
0.25577226281166077,
0.018676888197660446,
0.106136754155159,
0.2293718308210373,
0.225006103515625,
-0.8297249674797058,
0.21050132811069489,
-0.1429077535867691,
-0.19499114155769348,
0.16902966797351837,
0.30733922123908997,
0.20934471487998962,
-0.35179007053375244,
-0.2679589092731476,
0.14866524934768677,
-0.6062660217285156,
0.056344181299209595,
0.23626810312271118,
0.03469787910580635,
0.04842163249850273,
0.828319787979126,
-0.4263862669467926,
0.7189985513687134,
0.17465701699256897,
0.03871496021747589,
-0.013479392975568771,
-0.4611205458641052,
0.07664752751588821,
-0.13986200094223022,
0.543914258480072,
0.27527421712875366,
0.35531163215637207,
-0.4042210876941681,
0.16905717551708221,
-0.08873302489519119,
0.009951061569154263,
-0.7769506573677063,
-0.1968313753604889,
0.35015183687210083,
-0.24416299164295197,
-0.2577623724937439,
-0.3492959141731262,
-0.6902981996536255,
-0.2381916046142578,
-0.14570698142051697,
0.4619590640068054,
-0.4193396270275116,
-0.33905336260795593,
-0.1084299087524414,
-0.15420767664909363,
0.5317450165748596,
0.3538878858089447,
-0.6350588798522949,
-0.042089179158210754,
0.7668924331665039,
0.5909194946289062,
0.4386754035949707,
0.0329454205930233,
-0.594458281993866,
0.45550790429115295,
-0.47012898325920105,
0.6380951404571533,
-0.6156585216522217,
-0.24061506986618042,
-0.02580813318490982,
-0.07282570004463196,
-0.27707138657569885,
-0.4133363366127014,
0.07797354459762573,
-1.1903010606765747,
0.22328732907772064,
-0.30386030673980713,
-0.6874306201934814,
-0.05685791000723839,
0.5737447142601013,
-0.4197682738304138,
1.1737511157989502,
0.46723324060440063,
-0.8110746741294861,
0.24513807892799377,
-0.4308057129383087,
-0.4431077539920807,
0.3631151616573334,
-0.13460147380828857,
-0.2330525815486908,
-0.1708059459924698,
0.5596306920051575,
0.25838857889175415,
-0.13024646043777466,
0.37461110949516296,
-0.26011207699775696,
-0.05912437289953232,
0.16214202344417572,
-0.06815363466739655,
0.6364096403121948,
0.08635728806257248,
-0.06917617470026016,
-0.023308707401156425,
-0.5379123091697693,
0.4585685729980469,
0.3281846344470978,
-0.5446879863739014,
-0.14340482652187347,
0.13314522802829742,
-0.38439518213272095,
0.1550818830728531,
0.404848575592041,
-0.7632620334625244,
0.4260730445384979,
-0.2867881655693054,
0.7368270754814148,
0.6148812770843506,
0.4564352333545685,
0.1948554664850235,
-0.03710142523050308,
0.7228272557258606,
-0.04564756155014038,
0.2519039213657379,
0.09391366690397263,
-0.48560160398483276,
-0.5964162945747375,
0.33545982837677,
0.4030543863773346,
0.6664374470710754,
-1.3835833072662354,
0.11925489455461502,
-0.42808085680007935,
-0.39190903306007385,
-0.2572796046733856,
0.004177324008196592,
0.43918874859809875,
0.7983623147010803,
0.4036003053188324,
0.09018006920814514,
-0.3216078579425812,
-0.7385314702987671,
0.010275959968566895,
-0.7086167931556702,
-0.26796045899391174,
0.5087308883666992,
0.4532029926776886,
0.09000243991613388,
0.9935875535011292,
-0.7627115249633789,
0.05146685987710953,
-0.3216572105884552,
0.2566148340702057,
0.00590085331350565,
-0.011027894914150238,
0.43108946084976196,
-0.7972373366355896,
-0.29090777039527893,
-0.019828181713819504,
-0.850480318069458,
-0.3840554356575012,
0.14766521751880646,
-0.1116320863366127,
0.09588632732629776,
0.7172500491142273,
-0.5589869618415833,
0.11529305577278137,
0.49218347668647766,
-0.3853550851345062,
0.4728011190891266,
0.060918260365724564,
0.0039000301621854305,
-1.191512942314148,
-0.09524039924144745,
-0.4283607602119446,
-0.2754008173942566,
-0.5800368785858154,
0.10994516313076019,
0.030583901330828667,
-0.2134528011083603,
-0.2050410807132721,
0.7364202737808228,
-0.17659784853458405,
0.016931043937802315,
0.020207328721880913,
0.20912782847881317,
0.023205900564789772,
0.6640754342079163,
-0.09019211679697037,
0.4475182592868805,
0.10005982220172882,
-0.4944141209125519,
0.381634384393692,
0.37027406692504883,
-0.5083954334259033,
0.176371231675148,
-0.9107656478881836,
0.4554038941860199,
-0.31921476125717163,
0.28215673565864563,
-0.9240710735321045,
-0.21291175484657288,
0.2547798156738281,
-0.5583982467651367,
0.44247856736183167,
-0.6442139744758606,
-0.7085145711898804,
-0.549610435962677,
0.139648899435997,
0.5389776825904846,
0.41098836064338684,
-0.42150747776031494,
0.8336681127548218,
0.12198993563652039,
-0.3639258146286011,
-0.47125422954559326,
-0.49792230129241943,
-0.03642678260803223,
0.14089100062847137,
-0.8708006143569946,
0.3110051453113556,
0.040808070451021194,
-0.006917312741279602,
0.4430466294288635,
-0.40028461813926697,
-0.049152132123708725,
-0.0049915011040866375,
-0.0840156227350235,
0.09845148772001266,
-0.2512233555316925,
0.21422356367111206,
0.3340683877468109,
-0.20480939745903015,
0.04156817868351936,
-0.7613133788108826,
0.7493684887886047,
0.15875008702278137,
-0.2375757247209549,
0.14207975566387177,
0.4205077886581421,
0.352865606546402,
-0.35005277395248413,
0.8842937350273132,
0.745635986328125,
-0.3109097182750702,
-0.181697279214859,
-0.40613415837287903,
0.06442578881978989,
-0.4191875159740448,
0.6562724709510803,
-0.44759514927864075,
-1.3351225852966309,
0.563939094543457,
-0.03820836916565895,
0.015245795249938965,
0.46720024943351746,
0.6407992243766785,
-0.30259573459625244,
0.9925706386566162,
0.2865898609161377,
0.1799798607826233,
0.44657865166664124,
-0.2864598035812378,
0.11524579674005508,
-0.7523859739303589,
-0.7106873989105225,
-0.3732988238334656,
-0.1123250275850296,
-0.3271084129810333,
-0.5008464455604553,
0.9061861038208008,
0.3769277334213257,
-0.4781440496444702,
-0.05409178137779236,
0.05086951330304146,
0.3509143590927124,
0.5825870633125305,
0.3637230396270752,
0.3000243008136749,
-0.11336526274681091,
-0.282162606716156,
0.24005605280399323,
-1.0031673908233643,
-0.16915778815746307,
0.7975531816482544,
0.21229378879070282,
0.6393067836761475,
0.07503776252269745,
0.28551438450813293,
0.01884239912033081,
0.03041200153529644,
-0.5900912880897522,
0.709742546081543,
-0.2488614320755005,
-0.6509793400764465,
-0.4727093577384949,
-0.8083845376968384,
-0.73305743932724,
0.04201953858137131,
-0.058151353150606155,
-0.5551440119743347,
-0.13838259875774384,
0.26578736305236816,
-0.24608497321605682,
0.38713541626930237,
-0.6205781102180481,
0.9368235468864441,
-0.22423194348812103,
0.024435367435216904,
-0.06468420475721359,
-0.7453208565711975,
0.26213890314102173,
0.07770445942878723,
-0.10170424729585648,
-0.15731118619441986,
-0.0017088595777750015,
0.6432772874832153,
-0.42958369851112366,
0.908913791179657,
-0.44201117753982544,
0.026812279596924782,
0.3986796736717224,
0.12567469477653503,
0.6543142199516296,
0.07878826558589935,
0.14087681472301483,
0.0705777183175087,
0.19030821323394775,
-0.5352969169616699,
-0.8049418330192566,
0.3205450177192688,
-0.7558683156967163,
-0.6944138407707214,
-0.09825234860181808,
-0.6609082221984863,
-0.539697527885437,
0.13655012845993042,
0.20678851008415222,
0.6332898139953613,
-0.26385167241096497,
0.12294600903987885,
0.7973257303237915,
-0.47249338030815125,
0.14889727532863617,
0.5282859206199646,
-0.26431092619895935,
-0.29116854071617126,
0.5482185482978821,
0.22976593673229218,
0.48894721269607544,
0.9334267377853394,
0.3909153640270233,
-0.5844841599464417,
-0.5227153897285461,
-0.5960677862167358,
0.2692137658596039,
-0.669230580329895,
-0.10298360884189606,
-0.9811890125274658,
-0.5118021368980408,
-0.5996265411376953,
0.2519546151161194,
-0.04874415695667267,
-0.6363304257392883,
-0.11368893086910248,
-0.1935802847146988,
0.320049524307251,
0.5131621956825256,
0.3614501953125,
0.09214411675930023,
-0.8411471247673035,
0.6596257090568542,
0.879542350769043,
0.32354435324668884,
0.09183263033628464,
-0.38890132308006287,
-0.13041843473911285,
-0.0930543765425682,
-0.11291896551847458,
-0.8900970816612244,
-0.08518543094396591,
0.20428138971328735,
0.5167475938796997,
0.14408324658870697,
0.10685694217681885,
0.4985034167766571,
-0.5704330801963806,
0.7571404576301575,
-0.2453250288963318,
-0.6387141346931458,
0.5399421453475952,
-0.5969944000244141,
0.6256120204925537,
0.14019575715065002,
0.22416114807128906,
-0.8187656998634338,
-0.39229416847229004,
-0.2757395803928375,
-0.8336130380630493,
0.6073989868164062,
0.21130144596099854,
-0.06587506085634232,
0.09036461263895035,
0.6092605590820312,
-0.1352667659521103,
0.3001442551612854,
-0.5245572924613953,
-0.14773806929588318,
-0.4453543424606323,
-0.21637970209121704,
0.082051120698452,
-0.4994014501571655,
-0.1348499059677124,
-0.11541423946619034,
0.4730795919895172,
-0.2719361186027527,
0.3895581066608429,
-0.026460478082299232,
-0.1055336520075798,
-0.201386496424675,
0.5864784717559814,
0.10791226476430893,
0.6152633428573608,
-0.07561703771352768,
0.08750960975885391,
0.20438870787620544,
-0.34701040387153625,
0.04954401031136513,
0.44193387031555176,
-0.5966084003448486,
-0.3638811409473419,
0.6734786629676819,
0.7001698613166809,
-0.0008874140330590308,
-0.2402450144290924,
0.22428303956985474,
0.10962843894958496,
-0.31994640827178955,
-0.3186410367488861,
-0.014733010903000832,
0.4243263304233551,
0.5884736180305481,
0.5310542583465576,
-0.7063010334968567,
-0.3989500403404236,
-0.45285773277282715,
-0.18297897279262543,
0.3144012689590454,
-0.19383367896080017,
-0.2436046153306961,
0.9715451598167419,
-0.006163551937788725,
-0.12592996656894684,
0.9307821989059448,
-0.2135821133852005,
-0.909742534160614,
0.7887140512466431,
0.48732316493988037,
0.7858482003211975,
-0.06791367381811142,
0.5528532266616821,
0.2678532898426056,
0.4490492641925812,
0.34139347076416016,
0.5954321622848511,
-0.1163627952337265,
-0.7458887100219727,
-0.7135158777236938,
-0.7651541829109192,
-0.23453502357006073,
0.19619061052799225,
-0.40088948607444763,
-0.30992406606674194,
-0.333363801240921,
0.006532383617013693,
-0.11347547918558121,
0.11333679407835007,
-0.6045995354652405,
0.09746365994215012,
-0.034595102071762085,
0.7596650123596191,
-0.7814300656318665,
0.7676387429237366,
0.6438177227973938,
-0.28616371750831604,
-0.9285652041435242,
0.024639243260025978,
-0.16816166043281555,
-0.8736644387245178,
0.6978316307067871,
-0.2612268030643463,
0.12916535139083862,
0.21899138391017914,
-0.6783376932144165,
-0.7470238208770752,
1.3465595245361328,
0.38522598147392273,
-0.40708234906196594,
-0.4465974271297455,
0.3803633749485016,
0.6149424910545349,
-0.003393013495951891,
-0.15938831865787506,
0.42932847142219543,
0.5700092315673828,
0.4471554458141327,
-0.6169211864471436,
0.013989494182169437,
-0.33389732241630554,
-0.007298940792679787,
0.3907804787158966,
-0.6759848594665527,
0.7239059805870056,
-0.16326916217803955,
-0.38189560174942017,
0.17367543280124664,
0.6660752296447754,
0.22091180086135864,
0.43270143866539,
0.698663592338562,
0.7181960940361023,
0.5568110942840576,
-0.36599165201187134,
1.1355448961257935,
-0.15247078239917755,
0.2588576078414917,
1.0972752571105957,
-0.07020357251167297,
0.2926827669143677,
0.12162447720766068,
-0.21475285291671753,
0.5047862529754639,
0.8961305618286133,
0.1723087579011917,
0.414036363363266,
0.14742033183574677,
-0.37858694791793823,
-0.6079427599906921,
-0.34984636306762695,
-0.48494917154312134,
0.18958589434623718,
0.27229222655296326,
-0.009024846367537975,
-0.49195167422294617,
-0.04331814497709274,
-0.023099657148122787,
-0.21992680430412292,
-0.43646812438964844,
0.6595160365104675,
0.08311551809310913,
-0.511675238609314,
0.17642749845981598,
0.07149844616651535,
-0.1589866429567337,
-0.8655600547790527,
-0.1415671855211258,
-0.4406347870826721,
-0.08185002207756042,
0.05509389191865921,
-0.9472842812538147,
-0.027521753683686256,
0.0573648102581501,
-0.32184773683547974,
-0.22943337261676788,
0.5528720021247864,
-0.6546887159347534,
-0.6053621172904968,
0.22926729917526245,
0.6327769160270691,
-0.21141594648361206,
0.0025698307435959578,
-0.5725254416465759,
-0.32704976201057434,
-0.2954409122467041,
-0.28901901841163635,
0.1274474710226059,
0.625186026096344,
-0.20161062479019165,
0.8117623925209045,
0.3212091028690338,
-0.07321614027023315,
0.36180806159973145,
0.39674946665763855,
0.9652231931686401,
-0.45715489983558655,
-0.5599751472473145,
-0.4227796792984009,
0.1314394772052765,
0.19319449365139008,
-0.0019660124089568853,
0.6754671335220337,
0.3350309133529663,
0.8338233232498169,
0.16457852721214294,
0.654111921787262,
-0.3544902503490448,
0.49193522334098816,
-0.9749448895454407,
0.4745657444000244,
-0.5448128581047058,
0.08860890567302704,
-0.2307223528623581,
-0.8575860261917114,
-0.08797860890626907,
-0.11044808477163315,
-0.40294525027275085,
0.28368672728538513,
0.6470600366592407,
0.7564494609832764,
0.19186465442180634,
-0.10241381824016571,
0.10366927087306976,
0.6524048447608948,
0.43906670808792114,
1.0825129747390747,
1.0486490726470947,
-0.050095926970243454,
0.9490430355072021,
-0.20235301554203033,
-0.010946397669613361,
0.10362787544727325,
-0.6410660147666931,
-0.9476199150085449,
-0.6085876822471619,
-0.290075421333313,
-0.5069224238395691,
0.12291442602872849,
0.6208292245864868,
0.37917762994766235,
-0.5966057777404785,
0.3524785339832306,
0.16815677285194397,
0.20435753464698792,
-0.15457996726036072,
-0.25852179527282715,
0.7373965382575989,
-0.023778656497597694,
-0.5092190504074097,
0.4937995970249176,
0.13647451996803284,
0.04247330501675606,
-0.15045148134231567,
0.21792270243167877,
-0.2276923656463623,
-0.18390671908855438,
0.6945659518241882,
0.39676806330680847,
-0.45388293266296387,
-0.718708336353302,
0.2771342098712921,
0.12016050517559052,
-0.1523057073354721,
0.9931074976921082,
-0.6647050976753235,
0.4969450831413269,
0.714508593082428,
0.6527426242828369,
1.003669023513794,
0.13281257450580597,
0.33189526200294495,
-1.0921039581298828,
-0.22496777772903442,
0.3306022882461548,
0.0746421217918396,
0.08128371089696884,
-0.3306894600391388,
0.4906769394874573,
0.33549532294273376,
-0.3977183997631073,
-0.3523271977901459,
0.621955156326294,
-1.000784993171692,
-0.47773078083992004,
1.1034947633743286,
-0.037346385419368744,
-0.11959142237901688,
-0.44769081473350525,
0.2087201178073883,
0.6446791887283325,
0.035706065595149994,
0.7481557130813599,
0.645209550857544,
-0.07037154585123062,
-0.21456794440746307,
-0.5829156041145325,
0.08958444744348526,
0.13867051899433136,
-0.6298094391822815,
-0.10009251534938812,
0.6052445769309998,
0.3947705328464508,
-0.22331486642360687,
0.8509001731872559,
-0.2919273376464844,
0.12477091699838638,
0.034332163631916046,
-0.2767500877380371,
-0.6675624251365662,
-0.4263090491294861,
-0.007001358084380627,
0.6102526187896729,
-0.06011350452899933,
-0.08961942791938782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16567v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16567v2
|
Aligning Large Language Models to a Domain-specific Graph Database
| 2024-02-26T13:46:51 | 2024-02-28T07:24:19 |
Yuanyuan Liang, Keren Tan, Tingyu Xie, Wenbiao Tao, Siyuan Wang, Yunshi Lan, Weining Qian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB
|
Graph Databases (Graph DB) are widely applied in various fields, including
finance, social networks, and medicine. However, translating Natural Language
(NL) into the Graph Query Language (GQL), commonly known as NL2GQL, proves to
be challenging due to its inherent complexity and specialized nature. Some
approaches have sought to utilize Large Language Models (LLMs) to address
analogous tasks like text2SQL. Nevertheless, when it comes to NL2GQL taskson a
particular domain, the absence of domain-specific NL-GQL data pairs makes it
difficult to establish alignment between LLMs and the graph DB. To address this
challenge, we propose a well-defined pipeline. Specifically, we utilize ChatGPT
to create NL-GQL data pairs based on the given graph DB with self-instruct.
Then, we use the created data to fine-tune LLMs, thereby achieving alignment
between LLMs and the graph DB. Additionally, during inference, we propose a
method that extracts relevant schema to the queried NL as the input context to
guide LLMs for generating accurate GQLs.We evaluate our method on two
constructed datasets deriving from graph DBs in finance domain and medicine
domain, namely FinGQL and MediGQL. Experimental results demonstrate that our
method significantly outperforms a set of baseline methods, with improvements
of 5.90 and 6.36 absolute points on EM, and 6.00 and 7.09 absolute points on
EX, respectively.
|
[
0.004148908890783787,
-0.9445207118988037,
0.4490099549293518,
-0.2186746448278427,
-0.20342320203781128,
0.41401246190071106,
-0.24406294524669647,
-0.47390785813331604,
0.3100050687789917,
0.837620198726654,
-0.4224946200847626,
-0.8007116913795471,
-0.3445869982242584,
-0.09791795164346695,
-0.27992215752601624,
0.9985759854316711,
0.006065459456294775,
0.07921653240919113,
-0.1265219897031784,
-0.10757315158843994,
-0.4993163049221039,
-0.5350176692008972,
-0.8162175416946411,
-0.36164742708206177,
0.34748417139053345,
0.09504999220371246,
1.0033187866210938,
0.6952180862426758,
0.4110583961009979,
0.1446811407804489,
0.11095145344734192,
0.7083981037139893,
-0.7845972180366516,
0.11368085443973541,
-0.29179686307907104,
-0.017589060589671135,
-0.5293747186660767,
-0.38735231757164,
0.562199056148529,
1.056601881980896,
-0.14667001366615295,
0.03938876464962959,
0.2808496654033661,
0.7240320444107056,
-0.24791017174720764,
0.48833131790161133,
-0.6305147409439087,
-0.09376093745231628,
-0.2571716010570526,
-0.019512895494699478,
-0.4859500825405121,
-0.44147810339927673,
0.1537841558456421,
-0.6332911849021912,
0.1854691356420517,
0.37573373317718506,
1.1733940839767456,
0.04060531407594681,
-0.7784856557846069,
-0.2880934774875641,
-0.46309754252433777,
0.39634910225868225,
-0.7884817123413086,
0.46255019307136536,
0.21025681495666504,
0.3580619692802429,
-0.5218775272369385,
-0.9321346879005432,
-0.40949150919914246,
0.357211709022522,
-0.4785642623901367,
-0.10203927755355835,
-0.26503247022628784,
0.05255717784166336,
0.06803303956985474,
0.1320965737104416,
-0.8825123906135559,
0.36030277609825134,
-0.14729271829128265,
-0.29989850521087646,
0.7359704971313477,
0.3740793764591217,
0.26888585090637207,
-0.2136577069759369,
-0.1382254660129547,
0.04164821654558182,
-1.0139671564102173,
-0.14306874573230743,
0.2525673508644104,
0.8282050490379333,
0.10150782018899918,
0.8136708736419678,
-0.1609984189271927,
0.8938373923301697,
0.030791698023676872,
0.08662518113851547,
0.3344021737575531,
-0.6521559357643127,
-0.2397211492061615,
0.056344855576753616,
1.1145048141479492,
0.6078664660453796,
0.5059654116630554,
-0.4472264051437378,
-0.054918862879276276,
-0.04107917472720146,
0.16058586537837982,
-0.7284361720085144,
-0.33012843132019043,
0.467955082654953,
-0.05666417255997658,
-0.09852389246225357,
-0.3848304748535156,
-0.7383919954299927,
-0.5411455631256104,
-0.4149101674556732,
0.273171603679657,
-0.46892261505126953,
-0.061956118792295456,
0.08299171924591064,
0.2545472979545593,
0.2721601128578186,
0.12253373116254807,
-1.0097763538360596,
0.34480270743370056,
0.8103805184364319,
0.8805888295173645,
-0.25777214765548706,
0.07895796000957489,
-0.6049780249595642,
0.566010594367981,
-0.5899234414100647,
0.59360271692276,
-0.38328078389167786,
-0.30153653025627136,
0.19915659725666046,
0.24423536658287048,
-0.28624340891838074,
-0.43227314949035645,
0.4749015271663666,
-0.6128811240196228,
0.43599292635917664,
-0.16286389529705048,
-0.9923751950263977,
0.11206015199422836,
0.1763935387134552,
-0.42508625984191895,
1.073459506034851,
0.3147071599960327,
-0.8594598174095154,
0.25204065442085266,
-0.5201290845870972,
-0.6878582239151001,
0.10098717361688614,
-0.33598965406417847,
-0.5385695099830627,
-0.41887158155441284,
0.648432195186615,
0.39002344012260437,
-0.36381277441978455,
0.5513169169425964,
-0.35279107093811035,
-0.1751200258731842,
0.11145854741334915,
0.019923962652683258,
0.9430502653121948,
-0.021898137405514717,
0.03680548816919327,
0.09514129161834717,
-0.4529198110103607,
0.30782967805862427,
0.25973746180534363,
0.03479241207242012,
-0.31190550327301025,
0.22209443151950836,
-0.18885016441345215,
0.11245889961719513,
0.24715225398540497,
-0.4297284185886383,
0.49157893657684326,
-0.6643874645233154,
0.8784970045089722,
0.6061168909072876,
0.04494830220937729,
0.30605044960975647,
0.004669283051043749,
0.34198254346847534,
-0.43158605694770813,
-0.04951085150241852,
0.22728748619556427,
-0.4424837827682495,
-0.29531505703926086,
-0.44771361351013184,
0.5270881056785583,
0.6162320375442505,
-0.661003589630127,
0.5970249772071838,
-0.6730574369430542,
-0.36384260654449463,
-0.49344903230667114,
0.04265926405787468,
0.20912212133407593,
0.9748129844665527,
0.35974180698394775,
-0.3120482861995697,
-0.3783254027366638,
-0.8652658462524414,
-0.1224384754896164,
-0.10089743137359619,
-0.22141987085342407,
0.7195598483085632,
0.09706487506628036,
-0.24190247058868408,
1.086399793624878,
-0.8525975942611694,
-0.45374035835266113,
0.012858150526881218,
-0.2750266492366791,
0.5062349438667297,
0.42654654383659363,
0.6165120601654053,
-0.4004635810852051,
-0.7431854009628296,
0.3913052976131439,
-0.8475366830825806,
-0.15215112268924713,
0.2012007087469101,
-0.7449721693992615,
0.09875525534152985,
0.5185650587081909,
-0.8185482025146484,
0.07577871531248093,
0.6358941793441772,
-0.4568726718425751,
0.45851677656173706,
-0.08270610868930817,
-0.07874421775341034,
-1.2075012922286987,
0.18977494537830353,
-0.05404243990778923,
-0.5524429678916931,
-0.5943647623062134,
-0.18108953535556793,
0.061443306505680084,
-0.21126613020896912,
0.04621552675962448,
0.8173577189445496,
-0.4940914213657379,
-0.22709040343761444,
0.122203029692173,
0.4851307272911072,
0.3802510201931,
0.42553186416625977,
-0.09055466204881668,
0.7095386385917664,
0.6745544075965881,
-0.2635326385498047,
0.47242048382759094,
0.6377550363540649,
-0.3256916105747223,
0.5972045660018921,
-0.6983513236045837,
0.38099151849746704,
0.1183062344789505,
0.3608122169971466,
-1.187845230102539,
-0.36520788073539734,
0.4556015431880951,
-0.33208250999450684,
0.4693301022052765,
-0.6727688312530518,
-0.4764883518218994,
-0.4419551491737366,
0.22583816945552826,
0.06052388250827789,
0.3528386354446411,
-0.49184679985046387,
0.5839195847511292,
0.5461340546607971,
-0.3954082131385803,
-0.6871594190597534,
-0.4335118532180786,
0.2624095380306244,
-0.2190691977739334,
-0.9395443797111511,
0.46549201011657715,
0.3453802764415741,
0.058115825057029724,
0.21548645198345184,
0.014519802294671535,
-0.06481786072254181,
-0.17859326303005219,
0.029874682426452637,
0.627361536026001,
-0.4401533007621765,
0.2379019856452942,
0.0795741081237793,
-0.03675524890422821,
-0.05288982391357422,
-0.7563530802726746,
0.6924387216567993,
0.2315097600221634,
-0.46549543738365173,
-0.14996236562728882,
0.3250407874584198,
0.2883468568325043,
-0.48207321763038635,
0.7474890351295471,
0.24753238260746002,
-0.32304847240448,
-0.10031570494174957,
-0.2464509755373001,
-0.10046166926622391,
-0.45836424827575684,
0.40872249007225037,
-0.1389627456665039,
-1.0241533517837524,
0.6222458481788635,
-0.048849329352378845,
0.04879264160990715,
0.4321669042110443,
0.6577171087265015,
-0.019559910520911217,
1.1119301319122314,
0.15037617087364197,
-0.09863261133432388,
0.33787986636161804,
-0.14124830067157745,
0.5740804076194763,
-0.7847521305084229,
-0.010973210446536541,
-0.46863770484924316,
-0.1815473437309265,
-0.4542866349220276,
-0.4349527060985565,
0.21333345770835876,
0.029541270807385445,
-0.378630667924881,
0.36781927943229675,
-0.5001710057258606,
0.4799097776412964,
0.1907450258731842,
0.06802038103342056,
0.2519437074661255,
0.206857830286026,
-0.135834202170372,
0.006186868529766798,
-0.611271321773529,
-0.43023213744163513,
1.3212848901748657,
0.05903485044836998,
0.6853299736976624,
0.3013650178909302,
0.5659716129302979,
0.1521429717540741,
0.27183735370635986,
-0.6983199119567871,
0.23618169128894806,
-0.3746345639228821,
-0.4507208466529846,
-0.4955720007419586,
-0.642653226852417,
-1.2696361541748047,
0.24881725013256073,
-0.03774704411625862,
-1.0000730752944946,
0.009389584884047508,
0.16263221204280853,
-0.3824494779109955,
-0.012611965648829937,
-0.808898389339447,
1.3257205486297607,
-0.30479612946510315,
-0.5408134460449219,
0.2497195601463318,
-0.5984453558921814,
0.23114240169525146,
-0.27145904302597046,
0.32564374804496765,
-0.2880993187427521,
0.2802588939666748,
0.37612342834472656,
-0.577286422252655,
0.7817593216896057,
-0.15251804888248444,
-0.27251163125038147,
0.3567325174808502,
0.18777644634246826,
0.9758299589157104,
0.03553608059883118,
-0.06525219976902008,
0.20795148611068726,
0.10857374966144562,
-0.4351837635040283,
-0.701361894607544,
0.6473230719566345,
-0.5466142892837524,
-0.429451584815979,
-0.06839018315076828,
-0.5442866086959839,
-0.6975331902503967,
0.3747131824493408,
0.06516268104314804,
0.543933629989624,
-0.2082461714744568,
-0.037814460694789886,
0.286453515291214,
-0.029156433418393135,
-0.08351927995681763,
0.4941137731075287,
-0.5183455348014832,
-0.3728199005126953,
0.7573323845863342,
0.18641798198223114,
0.5255976915359497,
0.13223879039287567,
0.09999143332242966,
-0.7547751069068909,
-0.5934621691703796,
-0.6150623559951782,
0.4021957814693451,
-0.5456291437149048,
-0.4225948750972748,
-0.6165149211883545,
-0.27029770612716675,
-0.6924001574516296,
-0.13878901302814484,
-0.27634739875793457,
-0.34792405366897583,
-0.05474548786878586,
-0.06491901725530624,
0.48673397302627563,
0.3186454176902771,
0.1923067420721054,
0.21196915209293365,
-0.7539538741111755,
0.1102505698800087,
0.13243351876735687,
0.39591577649116516,
-0.20961745083332062,
-0.4529227018356323,
-0.27096354961395264,
0.1728074997663498,
0.07610055059194565,
-0.7418137788772583,
0.5613649487495422,
0.400142639875412,
0.4291641116142273,
0.23947151005268097,
0.08274359256029129,
0.7960739731788635,
-0.705653727054596,
0.5508238673210144,
0.09039826691150665,
-0.7946087718009949,
0.40349727869033813,
-0.48678991198539734,
-0.21057502925395966,
0.33303728699684143,
0.25463253259658813,
-0.8411960005760193,
-0.384525328874588,
-0.43331918120384216,
-1.116207242012024,
0.37497204542160034,
0.2643621265888214,
0.11618444323539734,
-0.08358287811279297,
0.4265475571155548,
-0.009969978593289852,
0.1747170239686966,
-0.4111446440219879,
-0.06383376568555832,
0.010360315442085266,
-0.5863229036331177,
-0.06402972340583801,
0.15639282763004303,
-0.46088990569114685,
-0.07535789906978607,
0.5714070796966553,
-0.6744481325149536,
0.022452400997281075,
-0.020424438640475273,
0.08855531364679337,
-0.06988006085157394,
-0.0443754568696022,
-0.0629829540848732,
0.7678385972976685,
-0.132450670003891,
0.05434709042310715,
-0.09825300425291061,
-0.13914985954761505,
-0.04072904959321022,
0.37164437770843506,
-0.12252668291330338,
-0.09410998225212097,
0.2736966907978058,
0.5899648666381836,
-0.047497496008872986,
-0.7958835363388062,
0.51820307970047,
0.03384113311767578,
-0.02818605862557888,
0.027000026777386665,
-0.08920152485370636,
0.4889143109321594,
0.29338523745536804,
0.100102499127388,
-0.39112943410873413,
-0.07121391594409943,
-0.2991744577884674,
0.2606114149093628,
0.7098899483680725,
-0.33318302035331726,
-0.07411220669746399,
0.7608646750450134,
0.09592835605144501,
-0.10768101364374161,
0.9744699001312256,
-0.2084457129240036,
-0.37146124243736267,
0.5218753814697266,
0.7273877859115601,
0.6245419383049011,
0.06502217054367065,
0.07738550007343292,
0.46061575412750244,
-0.06322905421257019,
0.05177163705229759,
0.1497637927532196,
0.5641975402832031,
-1.0285933017730713,
-0.8499069809913635,
-0.5375792384147644,
-0.3495568037033081,
-0.17674045264720917,
-0.5057258009910583,
0.2770025432109833,
-0.24538031220436096,
-0.28506648540496826,
0.3969503343105316,
-0.04190732538700104,
-0.6358611583709717,
-0.011048058047890663,
-0.02603694051504135,
0.46234190464019775,
-0.7976671457290649,
1.0154424905776978,
0.3488995134830475,
-0.22911207377910614,
-1.1223981380462646,
-0.38137951493263245,
0.09132347255945206,
-1.1716636419296265,
0.42372235655784607,
-0.28756922483444214,
0.08605700731277466,
0.2380005568265915,
-0.5701125860214233,
-1.0394855737686157,
1.0080301761627197,
0.6994845867156982,
-0.7895243167877197,
-0.1813299059867859,
0.2347632795572281,
0.6857483386993408,
-0.5266356468200684,
-0.19427204132080078,
0.45365282893180847,
0.22282573580741882,
0.22901880741119385,
-0.9675639271736145,
0.16003839671611786,
-0.07366524636745453,
-0.2662171423435211,
0.6505499482154846,
-0.550430953502655,
0.636341392993927,
-0.15185138583183289,
-0.37501367926597595,
-0.2115410715341568,
0.46814054250717163,
0.033734992146492004,
0.017796937376260757,
0.2328673005104065,
0.4036547839641571,
1.3310636281967163,
-0.16678687930107117,
1.1072968244552612,
-0.5468436479568481,
0.7523127794265747,
1.3826014995574951,
-0.74602210521698,
0.6494246125221252,
0.364364892244339,
-0.395040363073349,
0.3364385664463043,
0.8089377880096436,
-0.10363568365573883,
0.2797934412956238,
0.21451561152935028,
0.07485645264387131,
-0.29631271958351135,
-0.17314760386943817,
-0.4439033567905426,
0.2930759787559509,
0.5128218531608582,
-0.36731746792793274,
-0.1277477741241455,
-0.60600745677948,
0.24398840963840485,
-0.10244525969028473,
0.014608380384743214,
0.6244283318519592,
0.07215386629104614,
-0.577758252620697,
0.6204879283905029,
-0.13620810210704803,
0.014370813965797424,
-0.7082122564315796,
0.18544535338878632,
-0.3987123966217041,
-0.005044314078986645,
-0.22889672219753265,
-0.934853196144104,
0.3944571912288666,
-0.08533375710248947,
0.15992431342601776,
0.054220180958509445,
0.6695864796638489,
-0.6029267907142639,
-0.4794091582298279,
0.29711857438087463,
0.5813177227973938,
0.023042798042297363,
0.03837379068136215,
-0.6112783551216125,
-0.3271889388561249,
0.05635067820549011,
0.015855317935347557,
0.40964624285697937,
0.722365140914917,
-0.1519308239221573,
0.5248143672943115,
0.8051488995552063,
0.07193535566329956,
-0.12210113555192947,
0.18641553819179535,
0.8895058631896973,
-0.48889437317848206,
-0.46868783235549927,
-0.9232651591300964,
0.09867005795240402,
-0.35184767842292786,
-0.1232120618224144,
0.6241759061813354,
0.8597792387008667,
0.4761701822280884,
0.22732645273208618,
0.713627278804779,
-0.08110053092241287,
0.6037057042121887,
-0.7069500684738159,
0.5455976724624634,
-0.399177223443985,
0.14652924239635468,
-0.3717336356639862,
-0.9029035568237305,
-0.4229355454444885,
0.4403282701969147,
-0.29247474670410156,
-0.33616021275520325,
0.5046019554138184,
1.0437873601913452,
-0.0051316251046955585,
-0.17170202732086182,
-0.06291593611240387,
0.2334367036819458,
0.6135781407356262,
0.685138463973999,
0.38414573669433594,
-0.2528129518032074,
0.5739568471908569,
0.18432392179965973,
0.09658455103635788,
-0.1382756382226944,
-0.9425039291381836,
-0.6805480122566223,
-0.15761487185955048,
-0.5689241290092468,
-0.8926674127578735,
0.18111956119537354,
0.9395046234130859,
0.5588020086288452,
-0.851453423500061,
-0.20047074556350708,
0.15679149329662323,
0.07627277821302414,
-0.2617908716201782,
-0.21715115010738373,
0.9465962052345276,
-0.2114362120628357,
-0.7030137181282043,
0.3274122178554535,
0.35954728722572327,
0.030509229749441147,
-0.09448535740375519,
-0.03590976446866989,
-0.0698382705450058,
-0.014448009431362152,
0.5685633420944214,
0.33032888174057007,
-0.5073150992393494,
-0.7536975741386414,
0.0629657506942749,
-0.4182412028312683,
0.3808366358280182,
0.5423092842102051,
-0.47438928484916687,
0.4403328001499176,
0.3545934557914734,
0.7050023674964905,
0.5657572150230408,
0.23494350910186768,
0.7050735354423523,
-0.9598626494407654,
-0.14501602947711945,
0.21334822475910187,
0.4539310038089752,
0.4742562770843506,
-0.386939138174057,
0.8633529543876648,
0.17466998100280762,
-0.6607711911201477,
-0.7540993094444275,
0.2952297329902649,
-1.1240930557250977,
-0.191964790225029,
1.183991551399231,
-0.031620223075151443,
-0.28170469403266907,
-0.23041772842407227,
-0.3519487977027893,
0.22646786272525787,
-0.210817351937294,
0.5654577016830444,
0.6640326380729675,
-0.29553934931755066,
0.30954092741012573,
-0.4815646708011627,
0.42238348722457886,
0.15557660162448883,
-0.7278704643249512,
0.5494954586029053,
0.6955516338348389,
0.30533432960510254,
-0.12292370200157166,
0.8106717467308044,
-0.1622810810804367,
-0.31904205679893494,
-0.1487489640712738,
-0.03749547153711319,
0.21770796179771423,
0.278438925743103,
0.1553633213043213,
0.19638307392597198,
-0.036288924515247345,
0.05678677558898926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00820v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00820v1
|
Retrieval Augmented Generation Systems: Automatic Dataset Creation, Evaluation and Boolean Agent Setup
| 2024-02-26T12:56:17 | 2024-02-26T12:56:17 |
Tristan Kenneweg, Philip Kenneweg, Barbara Hammer
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) systems have seen huge popularity in
augmenting Large-Language Model (LLM) outputs with domain specific and time
sensitive data. Very recently a shift is happening from simple RAG setups that
query a vector database for additional information with every user input to
more sophisticated forms of RAG. However, different concrete approaches compete
on mostly anecdotal evidence at the moment. In this paper we present a rigorous
dataset creation and evaluation workflow to quantitatively compare different
RAG strategies. We use a dataset created this way for the development and
evaluation of a boolean agent RAG setup: A system in which a LLM can decide
whether to query a vector database or not, thus saving tokens on questions that
can be answered with internal knowledge. We publish our code and generated
dataset online.
|
[
-0.5333821177482605,
-0.5937327146530151,
0.3213188350200653,
0.02259318344295025,
0.16084061563014984,
0.5194599032402039,
0.016909727826714516,
-0.3660244047641754,
0.20213934779167175,
0.6048122048377991,
-0.18880894780158997,
0.018083930015563965,
-0.18664295971393585,
0.3059820234775543,
-0.3292863667011261,
1.1249991655349731,
-0.06508791446685791,
-0.05453404784202576,
-0.2833600640296936,
-0.25620096921920776,
-0.700311541557312,
-0.36615797877311707,
-0.7570751309394836,
-0.485715389251709,
0.09793466329574585,
0.07796509563922882,
0.6797518134117126,
0.47795358300209045,
0.5502919554710388,
0.3774706721305847,
0.030586013570427895,
0.703752338886261,
-0.6329711079597473,
0.4862200617790222,
-0.6635808348655701,
-0.38548749685287476,
-0.2336449921131134,
-0.17516618967056274,
0.5194189548492432,
0.45755600929260254,
-0.11333946138620377,
0.688401460647583,
-0.32913365960121155,
0.6269407272338867,
-0.9025285840034485,
-0.18227486312389374,
-0.7554101943969727,
0.07496944069862366,
-0.11451156437397003,
-0.332491934299469,
-0.36315417289733887,
-0.5160412192344666,
-0.16224700212478638,
-0.495309978723526,
0.3967604637145996,
0.22379949688911438,
0.8955110907554626,
0.3476223647594452,
-0.5017273426055908,
-0.4333655834197998,
-0.9885479807853699,
0.5849952697753906,
-0.4370262324810028,
0.21344713866710663,
0.28563520312309265,
0.7000313997268677,
-0.42898309230804443,
-0.9097371697425842,
-0.676276683807373,
-0.31683677434921265,
0.08005564659833908,
0.11775290220975876,
0.026512466371059418,
-0.37650778889656067,
0.3672505021095276,
0.44798150658607483,
-0.6867074966430664,
-0.23703086376190186,
-0.29686737060546875,
-0.23655132949352264,
0.7793628573417664,
0.36766597628593445,
0.04274829477071762,
-0.3630121350288391,
-0.49520573019981384,
-0.18461070954799652,
-0.6443206071853638,
-0.2952183485031128,
0.3912874758243561,
0.26352253556251526,
0.16086462140083313,
1.0566105842590332,
-0.2551058232784271,
0.8360477089881897,
0.37517863512039185,
-0.06748586893081665,
0.16113317012786865,
-0.43575096130371094,
-0.13853289186954498,
-0.1648070365190506,
0.5944124460220337,
0.17887622117996216,
0.06032034009695053,
-0.20348523557186127,
-0.8185217380523682,
0.26097556948661804,
0.5637138485908508,
-0.6177458763122559,
-0.02971629612147808,
0.18578878045082092,
-0.30195704102516174,
-0.5510770678520203,
-0.07311603426933289,
-0.43756967782974243,
-0.709953784942627,
-0.5207746028900146,
0.8205351233482361,
-0.22293131053447723,
-0.2657693028450012,
-0.07988377660512924,
-0.3586512506008148,
0.3722856342792511,
0.015858452767133713,
-0.26823216676712036,
0.4030177593231201,
0.6652593612670898,
0.49316397309303284,
-0.28508344292640686,
0.05528930574655533,
-0.8750001788139343,
0.14743052423000336,
-0.8023982644081116,
1.0377589464187622,
-0.657176673412323,
-0.4616035223007202,
-0.015728874132037163,
-0.12935923039913177,
0.15752221643924713,
-0.8102807998657227,
0.5090994238853455,
-1.222167730331421,
0.3747091591358185,
-0.16544649004936218,
-0.7319647073745728,
0.03802136331796646,
0.29078447818756104,
-0.6891249418258667,
1.2911564111709595,
0.3145866394042969,
-0.7591469287872314,
0.4873499274253845,
-0.6919437050819397,
-0.353254109621048,
0.41159895062446594,
-0.19622202217578888,
-0.2580972909927368,
-0.020430216565728188,
0.22379270195960999,
0.29913514852523804,
-0.378176212310791,
0.0667920932173729,
-0.08734622597694397,
-0.39454010128974915,
0.40599173307418823,
-0.25257501006126404,
0.9253590106964111,
0.4885340631008148,
-0.33252206444740295,
-0.26195964217185974,
-0.9297058582305908,
0.13357096910476685,
0.20575909316539764,
-0.4837609827518463,
-0.27594640851020813,
-0.22102247178554535,
-0.24186637997627258,
0.013635601848363876,
0.43609586358070374,
-0.6066731810569763,
0.2899998724460602,
-0.30131739377975464,
-0.11301440745592117,
0.5766254663467407,
0.4175359606742859,
0.2502515912055969,
-0.6237929463386536,
0.6396573781967163,
-0.33952778577804565,
0.06971710920333862,
0.1121257096529007,
-0.288056343793869,
-0.7121044993400574,
-0.18827520310878754,
0.6415093541145325,
0.6386550068855286,
-1.5463905334472656,
0.2923097312450409,
-0.13576717674732208,
-0.4313790202140808,
-0.4394735097885132,
0.0011748133692890406,
0.5772796869277954,
0.5854884386062622,
0.006338153500109911,
-0.16770857572555542,
-0.6514856815338135,
-0.7304810881614685,
0.06095845624804497,
-0.2086729109287262,
-0.14582017064094543,
0.438322514295578,
0.5726251006126404,
-0.3852626085281372,
1.0560499429702759,
-0.43272292613983154,
0.15896156430244446,
-0.03290970250964165,
0.24850474298000336,
0.22875426709651947,
0.10945845395326614,
0.44461655616760254,
-0.8295960426330566,
-0.334596186876297,
0.03989220783114433,
-0.9597259759902954,
-0.2017086148262024,
0.10408283770084381,
-0.33741894364356995,
0.39428219199180603,
0.2271604686975479,
-0.3506143391132355,
0.7016332149505615,
0.4880409836769104,
-0.3271092474460602,
0.7601180672645569,
-0.3031400740146637,
0.4807174801826477,
-1.0578933954238892,
0.2234911024570465,
-0.42842695116996765,
-0.5347285270690918,
-0.5423451066017151,
0.1476517617702484,
-0.13256050646305084,
-0.19875285029411316,
-0.2825270891189575,
0.8696596026420593,
-0.5016038417816162,
-0.5180554986000061,
-0.5865490436553955,
0.09830931574106216,
0.24465055763721466,
0.20730239152908325,
-0.2748458683490753,
1.1592011451721191,
0.29691222310066223,
-0.9082931876182556,
0.6417621970176697,
0.3879568874835968,
-0.3022657632827759,
0.6789150834083557,
-0.6099076271057129,
0.43369534611701965,
-0.09636810421943665,
0.15782247483730316,
-0.7567592263221741,
-0.23115293681621552,
0.1785542070865631,
-0.6100937128067017,
0.41776925325393677,
-0.16113243997097015,
-0.6462661027908325,
-0.33271726965904236,
-0.17075352370738983,
0.35623490810394287,
0.42199844121932983,
-0.8248291611671448,
0.5908714532852173,
0.6729739904403687,
0.005513205658644438,
-0.6569324731826782,
-0.19145917892456055,
0.3610987067222595,
-0.057612743228673935,
-0.663780152797699,
0.1244674026966095,
-0.03556160256266594,
-0.5226535201072693,
0.16454996168613434,
0.12833932042121887,
0.17933952808380127,
-0.025972528383135796,
0.06331375241279602,
0.25339239835739136,
-0.13081054389476776,
0.2799987494945526,
-0.10108061879873276,
-0.04467276111245155,
-0.09504637867212296,
-0.0537891685962677,
0.5081523060798645,
-0.0926937535405159,
-0.3084518015384674,
0.19704510271549225,
0.1853334605693817,
0.09311773627996445,
-0.4561106264591217,
0.5369361639022827,
0.5522059202194214,
-0.3734242916107178,
-0.608512282371521,
-0.5889877676963806,
0.03446171060204506,
-0.5213602781295776,
-0.14845433831214905,
-0.48713916540145874,
-0.4666701853275299,
0.4505369961261749,
-0.07924249768257141,
0.244202122092247,
0.44393667578697205,
0.8139835000038147,
0.050273869186639786,
0.9374170899391174,
0.3995569348335266,
0.46545809507369995,
0.1520482897758484,
-0.39095205068588257,
-0.007597469724714756,
-0.8911609649658203,
-0.03368712589144707,
-0.371150940656662,
-0.04354183375835419,
-0.7190049886703491,
-0.5740258693695068,
0.5102634429931641,
-0.07473527640104294,
-0.4134220480918884,
0.17355667054653168,
-0.6017460823059082,
0.43717363476753235,
0.45841366052627563,
0.011456663720309734,
0.2786964774131775,
0.047763705253601074,
-0.06995247304439545,
0.38918551802635193,
-0.6185526847839355,
-0.8172561526298523,
1.3443022966384888,
-0.030154405161738396,
0.6496817469596863,
0.24869444966316223,
0.6734986305236816,
0.8441880941390991,
0.5373300313949585,
-0.5727306604385376,
0.6529077291488647,
-0.07539841532707214,
-0.8046689629554749,
-0.3858228027820587,
-0.5862581729888916,
-1.1673641204833984,
0.05915030464529991,
-0.4114765524864197,
-0.22810670733451843,
0.340891033411026,
-0.027587836608290672,
-0.20934200286865234,
0.17615607380867004,
-0.6584660410881042,
0.25960227847099304,
-0.24065539240837097,
-0.4875820577144623,
0.2263861745595932,
-0.4765068292617798,
0.294033408164978,
-0.3322347104549408,
0.02749559096992016,
0.029902806505560875,
-0.23244361579418182,
0.7175047993659973,
-0.5217931866645813,
0.32164958119392395,
-0.33063527941703796,
-0.08280021697282791,
0.6729282140731812,
0.36488083004951477,
0.5577570796012878,
0.06050587072968483,
-0.4691953957080841,
-0.25733035802841187,
0.08635441958904266,
-0.2326788604259491,
-0.7499028444290161,
0.42363080382347107,
-0.5411338210105896,
-0.27364614605903625,
-0.40883368253707886,
-0.5223305821418762,
-0.377964049577713,
0.2514895498752594,
0.15539272129535675,
0.7791467308998108,
-0.2648482918739319,
-0.037194736301898956,
0.6767848134040833,
-0.3240690529346466,
0.20671100914478302,
0.7665790319442749,
-0.5809996724128723,
-0.46546685695648193,
1.206734299659729,
0.07844541221857071,
0.07641448080539703,
0.3237672746181488,
0.26776739954948425,
-0.3694833517074585,
-0.279285728931427,
-0.5952049493789673,
0.2584226727485657,
-0.6227588057518005,
-0.4293202757835388,
-0.2692478895187378,
-0.26780447363853455,
-0.5038577914237976,
0.13448309898376465,
-0.25506067276000977,
-0.4970182478427887,
0.17618770897388458,
0.0839134156703949,
0.5775352716445923,
1.116303563117981,
-0.34631767868995667,
-0.03765068203210831,
-0.6219207048416138,
0.6553272604942322,
0.402214914560318,
0.3798537254333496,
-0.2944492995738983,
-0.5189514756202698,
-0.3278955817222595,
0.07509563118219376,
-0.20711855590343475,
-0.8558637499809265,
0.2475391924381256,
0.050004541873931885,
0.5774752497673035,
0.06539128720760345,
0.20976445078849792,
0.3820677697658539,
-0.5950651168823242,
0.663960874080658,
-0.2863538861274719,
-0.6017367243766785,
0.37699273228645325,
-0.42439529299736023,
0.004381385166198015,
0.522875189781189,
0.18668246269226074,
-0.15736913681030273,
-0.1830522119998932,
-0.6586448550224304,
-0.6087031364440918,
0.4597615599632263,
0.4676879644393921,
-0.31606486439704895,
0.08854737132787704,
0.4830569624900818,
0.1473512351512909,
0.366265207529068,
-0.05798272788524628,
-0.3289482295513153,
-0.07227731496095657,
-0.08814336359500885,
0.14870622754096985,
0.017242316156625748,
-0.33924543857574463,
0.2074703723192215,
0.772747278213501,
0.030986931174993515,
0.29209306836128235,
-0.010947824455797672,
-0.10768742114305496,
-0.0942646712064743,
0.0359857939183712,
0.20579926669597626,
0.9540303349494934,
-0.2941647469997406,
-0.10599781572818756,
0.13631384074687958,
-0.42665937542915344,
0.41452452540397644,
0.20779962837696075,
-0.45438042283058167,
0.16670441627502441,
0.23568560183048248,
0.6953756809234619,
-0.2039330005645752,
-0.7064800262451172,
0.3803900182247162,
-0.3088162839412689,
-0.22551992535591125,
-0.40022897720336914,
0.08281267434358597,
-0.38157644867897034,
0.3371869623661041,
0.34694430232048035,
-0.2523343563079834,
0.390951007604599,
-0.4884023666381836,
0.3741552233695984,
0.36795860528945923,
0.11307115107774734,
-0.036463093012571335,
0.4325340688228607,
0.09490104764699936,
-0.5664133429527283,
0.30222487449645996,
-0.67945396900177,
-0.4160554111003876,
0.4566958546638489,
0.38613200187683105,
0.8428127765655518,
-0.2613215744495392,
0.4727908670902252,
0.19626054167747498,
0.2376267910003662,
0.19951944053173065,
0.5528513789176941,
-0.014262842945754528,
-0.7003604769706726,
-0.5288423895835876,
-0.8207353353500366,
-0.6165739297866821,
0.10647102445363998,
-0.6845423579216003,
0.07571391016244888,
-0.1943334937095642,
-0.42166996002197266,
-0.014331710524857044,
0.38388311862945557,
-0.9184046387672424,
0.3031114339828491,
-0.13745228946208954,
0.7504823803901672,
-0.7140076756477356,
0.21617156267166138,
1.0245941877365112,
-0.3231271505355835,
-0.7043329477310181,
-0.13553713262081146,
-0.33743464946746826,
-0.8640944957733154,
0.742331326007843,
-0.3695274591445923,
-0.21517619490623474,
-0.297260582447052,
-0.5240500569343567,
-1.0080115795135498,
0.8172692656517029,
0.24551428854465485,
-0.18860745429992676,
0.16119319200515747,
0.11449311673641205,
0.7583065629005432,
-0.26186949014663696,
0.17459914088249207,
0.5461013913154602,
0.42146623134613037,
0.22048835456371307,
-0.8517704606056213,
-0.012831087224185467,
-0.3052564859390259,
0.14799892902374268,
0.32434725761413574,
-0.4021223783493042,
0.7455992698669434,
-0.017870889976620674,
-0.42644575238227844,
0.03175286948680878,
0.6381855010986328,
0.4522800147533417,
0.4880976378917694,
0.6438342928886414,
0.6019955277442932,
0.7474030256271362,
0.12896735966205597,
1.273507833480835,
-0.3031156063079834,
0.09094774723052979,
1.2364298105239868,
-0.5658140182495117,
0.7861281633377075,
0.01498326100409031,
-0.1500599980354309,
0.19285176694393158,
0.5098407864570618,
-0.022167546674609184,
0.3036888539791107,
0.3613416254520416,
-0.3596321940422058,
-0.15533101558685303,
-0.29181692004203796,
-0.296472430229187,
0.47951385378837585,
0.3038994073867798,
0.06666453927755356,
-0.2763853967189789,
0.1198929101228714,
-0.3119380474090576,
0.06704558432102203,
-0.32724106311798096,
1.004116177558899,
-0.17135314643383026,
-0.7911598682403564,
0.6315126419067383,
-0.07615333050489426,
0.11144553869962692,
-0.32580918073654175,
-0.2839372456073761,
-0.3663409352302551,
0.10865605622529984,
-0.32262155413627625,
-0.9004284143447876,
0.19503100216388702,
0.40584638714790344,
-0.1878044307231903,
0.09499474614858627,
0.9689412713050842,
-0.1762104332447052,
-0.6593230366706848,
-0.10011286288499832,
0.6739992499351501,
0.33346423506736755,
0.36290988326072693,
-0.6746439933776855,
-0.027160365134477615,
-0.26190418004989624,
-0.3727686405181885,
0.05958793684840202,
0.7353683114051819,
-0.20244932174682617,
0.6137779951095581,
0.6652738451957703,
0.38440340757369995,
0.18489374220371246,
0.20385602116584778,
0.9630485773086548,
-0.44087114930152893,
-0.21483741700649261,
-0.1177184134721756,
0.3220680356025696,
-0.21612192690372467,
-0.1601359099149704,
0.9326286315917969,
0.7151750922203064,
0.6253988742828369,
0.2721797227859497,
0.9213526248931885,
-0.16964545845985413,
1.1594045162200928,
-0.39578619599342346,
0.5816924571990967,
-0.5419943332672119,
0.3581845164299011,
-0.09977123141288757,
-0.9868730306625366,
0.2627107501029968,
0.39519017934799194,
-0.056818801909685135,
0.17548762261867523,
0.21614977717399597,
1.0040781497955322,
0.07464110106229782,
-0.13581962883472443,
0.11626261472702026,
0.10713683813810349,
0.5222710967063904,
0.06468426436185837,
1.0779492855072021,
-0.4968201816082001,
0.4673348367214203,
-0.1880389004945755,
-0.3929339647293091,
-0.09159663319587708,
-0.860934317111969,
-0.8101022243499756,
-0.5427663922309875,
-0.0605400986969471,
-0.5353162884712219,
0.2201979011297226,
0.7452310919761658,
0.33823031187057495,
-0.6388728022575378,
-0.2521566152572632,
0.32392963767051697,
-0.013802873902022839,
0.06526510417461395,
-0.24024198949337006,
0.41920825839042664,
-0.42044371366500854,
-0.4510791003704071,
0.528114378452301,
0.02543392777442932,
-0.1486230194568634,
-0.4706656038761139,
-0.026774244382977486,
-0.22837072610855103,
0.38396555185317993,
0.6869137287139893,
0.4773114025592804,
-0.14097926020622253,
-0.18097428977489471,
0.00012722301471512765,
-0.10543974488973618,
-0.16716252267360687,
0.6382691264152527,
-1.1021108627319336,
0.7857092618942261,
0.6637510657310486,
0.922119140625,
0.618872344493866,
0.17214953899383545,
0.7138228416442871,
-0.7757752537727356,
-0.21224640309810638,
0.5102882385253906,
0.13645105063915253,
0.4885680675506592,
-0.2340354025363922,
0.8823236227035522,
-0.08672907948493958,
-0.8951807618141174,
-1.1164350509643555,
0.12346614897251129,
-0.663074254989624,
-0.13781601190567017,
1.2361198663711548,
0.2958671450614929,
-0.30478331446647644,
-0.253389447927475,
-0.2573871314525604,
0.4044245779514313,
-0.15020905435085297,
0.7482115626335144,
0.12872637808322906,
-0.21365231275558472,
0.6403633952140808,
-0.5500500202178955,
0.46912434697151184,
-0.07823453098535538,
-0.8376765251159668,
-0.26480376720428467,
0.6380460262298584,
0.21313601732254028,
0.2798650562763214,
0.5747808814048767,
0.025568347424268723,
0.26681604981422424,
0.10673779249191284,
0.055121321231126785,
-0.24454598128795624,
-0.3336637020111084,
-0.09639836102724075,
0.09724392741918564,
-0.20721377432346344,
-0.26048579812049866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16539v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16539v1
|
Integrating Large Language Models with Graphical Session-Based Recommendation
| 2024-02-26T12:55:51 | 2024-02-26T12:55:51 |
Naicheng Guo, Hongwei Cheng, Qianqiao Liang, Linxun Chen, Bing Han
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs), various
explorations have arisen to utilize LLMs capability of context understanding on
recommender systems. While pioneering strategies have primarily transformed
traditional recommendation tasks into challenges of natural language
generation, there has been a relative scarcity of exploration in the domain of
session-based recommendation (SBR) due to its specificity. SBR has been
primarily dominated by Graph Neural Networks, which have achieved many
successful outcomes due to their ability to capture both the implicit and
explicit relationships between adjacent behaviors. The structural nature of
graphs contrasts with the essence of natural language, posing a significant
adaptation gap for LLMs. In this paper, we introduce large language models with
graphical Session-Based recommendation, named LLMGR, an effective framework
that bridges the aforementioned gap by harmoniously integrating LLMs with Graph
Neural Networks (GNNs) for SBR tasks. This integration seeks to leverage the
complementary strengths of LLMs in natural language understanding and GNNs in
relational data processing, leading to a more powerful session-based
recommender system that can understand and recommend items within a session.
Moreover, to endow the LLM with the capability to empower SBR tasks, we design
a series of prompts for both auxiliary and major instruction tuning tasks.
These prompts are crafted to assist the LLM in understanding graph-structured
data and align textual information with nodes, effectively translating nuanced
user interactions into a format that can be understood and utilized by LLM
architectures. Extensive experiments on three real-world datasets demonstrate
that LLMGR outperforms several competitive baselines, indicating its
effectiveness in enhancing SBR tasks and its potential as a research direction
for future exploration.
|
[
-0.37563908100128174,
-1.1370644569396973,
1.0837478637695312,
-0.0017938959645107388,
-0.26418158411979675,
0.1474108248949051,
-0.3391677141189575,
-0.3327265679836273,
0.01876741647720337,
0.6352364420890808,
-0.534684956073761,
-0.7339008450508118,
-0.41306525468826294,
-0.18167683482170105,
-0.028307674452662468,
1.0213217735290527,
-0.24327988922595978,
0.005144699942320585,
-0.35572507977485657,
-0.047559939324855804,
-0.9863400459289551,
-0.5182024240493774,
-0.9075307846069336,
-0.7406764626502991,
0.8039378523826599,
0.10815486311912537,
0.5708774328231812,
0.4308792054653168,
0.343693345785141,
0.3685840666294098,
-0.23350593447685242,
0.42293134331703186,
-0.7989979386329651,
0.0374581441283226,
-0.14784479141235352,
-0.15272220969200134,
-0.5318148136138916,
-0.5179401636123657,
0.5696337819099426,
0.721663773059845,
-0.12607501447200775,
-0.11815636605024338,
0.33010348677635193,
0.4972081482410431,
-0.3297133147716522,
0.6202120780944824,
-0.33286428451538086,
-0.0011491215554997325,
0.037169694900512695,
-0.19446291029453278,
-0.5557317733764648,
-0.2302461564540863,
0.3306320905685425,
-0.5273663997650146,
0.07066130638122559,
0.3347807228565216,
0.5539637207984924,
-0.21661916375160217,
-0.6147142052650452,
-0.0940561592578888,
-0.7219846844673157,
0.48351913690567017,
-0.6053565740585327,
0.30169767141342163,
0.2151983231306076,
0.527327299118042,
-0.5132168531417847,
-0.7044020295143127,
-0.2195826917886734,
-0.38337311148643494,
-0.25899800658226013,
-0.2659372389316559,
-0.5197729468345642,
0.33501002192497253,
0.25549039244651794,
0.19464091956615448,
-0.624890923500061,
0.21078848838806152,
-0.1457209587097168,
0.0077095963060855865,
0.3563307523727417,
0.3371211588382721,
0.4966842532157898,
-0.024950727820396423,
-0.09863085299730301,
0.015866408124566078,
-0.6058286428451538,
-0.032103437930345535,
-0.03503164276480675,
0.618456244468689,
-0.2160434126853943,
0.4934084713459015,
-0.00793405994772911,
1.0544710159301758,
0.1110004261136055,
-0.10220742970705032,
-0.12966908514499664,
-0.27778148651123047,
-0.2513618767261505,
0.14447371661663055,
0.8162738084793091,
0.530750572681427,
0.41231054067611694,
-0.5062661170959473,
-0.20551219582557678,
-0.22841714322566986,
0.30062124133110046,
-0.835110604763031,
-0.16509577631950378,
-0.23156343400478363,
-0.35504379868507385,
0.008545693941414356,
-0.035403188318014145,
-0.4345857501029968,
-0.5635097026824951,
-0.6469017267227173,
0.33068645000457764,
-0.5380531549453735,
0.001855274778790772,
0.010965325869619846,
-0.16713017225265503,
-0.09389572590589523,
0.44722259044647217,
-0.9102897644042969,
0.5062263607978821,
0.8381272554397583,
1.126609206199646,
-0.36099937558174133,
-0.2254260778427124,
-0.5780820846557617,
0.4210890829563141,
-0.11539126932621002,
0.8289499878883362,
-0.6112558841705322,
-0.5287637710571289,
0.10963437706232071,
0.36241307854652405,
-0.070589579641819,
-0.3865056037902832,
0.1258164346218109,
-0.7331089377403259,
-0.009846954606473446,
-0.22508932650089264,
-0.5105579495429993,
-0.49861815571784973,
0.25652772188186646,
-0.49510279297828674,
0.8116664886474609,
0.3742789924144745,
-0.451285719871521,
0.3039948344230652,
-0.6561303734779358,
-0.5475528240203857,
0.25290676951408386,
-0.12246806174516678,
-0.07454438507556915,
0.17834609746932983,
0.44464972615242004,
0.5055226683616638,
-0.37430065870285034,
0.6414967775344849,
-0.6012867093086243,
-0.636357307434082,
0.2381455898284912,
-0.35875076055526733,
0.39397144317626953,
-0.10637284070253372,
-0.15312515199184418,
0.6950485706329346,
-0.27161505818367004,
0.003999554086476564,
0.052935127168893814,
-0.1946837157011032,
-0.3500487804412842,
-0.06480179727077484,
0.32710617780685425,
-0.06953713297843933,
0.07763651013374329,
-0.13288073241710663,
0.25347885489463806,
-0.2876518666744232,
0.7572082877159119,
0.8851693272590637,
0.16970321536064148,
0.3250489830970764,
-0.2299000471830368,
0.5214572548866272,
-0.17717798054218292,
-0.2788792550563812,
-0.20501497387886047,
-0.21071194112300873,
-0.6412383317947388,
-0.13283385336399078,
0.06739193201065063,
0.42161568999290466,
-0.8226993680000305,
0.6636161208152771,
-0.4987744688987732,
-0.3300853669643402,
-0.04060833901166916,
0.23950114846229553,
0.21492141485214233,
0.45559653639793396,
0.3834148943424225,
-0.3561626076698303,
-0.3867841362953186,
-0.6448919177055359,
0.08332847058773041,
-0.09335795789957047,
-0.05024806037545204,
0.8829787373542786,
0.2033902108669281,
-0.5104159116744995,
0.86553555727005,
-0.6427430510520935,
-0.24160338938236237,
-0.6420440077781677,
-0.1467527598142624,
0.5020292401313782,
0.22322814166545868,
0.430391788482666,
-0.32480674982070923,
-0.6144179701805115,
0.193329855799675,
-0.7460032105445862,
0.014359325170516968,
-0.027762791141867638,
-0.3060416579246521,
-0.15247313678264618,
0.5906684398651123,
-0.39121246337890625,
0.056588999927043915,
0.2915315628051758,
-0.3958292603492737,
0.1950591504573822,
-0.4649965465068817,
-0.09802675247192383,
-0.9396963119506836,
-0.03626208007335663,
0.3867104947566986,
-0.4977404773235321,
-0.5508043766021729,
-0.1308857947587967,
-0.2097025215625763,
-0.24392582476139069,
-0.03528611361980438,
0.8123736381530762,
-0.41306939721107483,
-0.035784024745225906,
-0.4897017776966095,
0.44456493854522705,
0.013728542253375053,
0.5086786150932312,
-0.16767607629299164,
0.8639304637908936,
0.5871759057044983,
-0.5675885677337646,
0.5726754665374756,
0.3647927939891815,
-0.32752305269241333,
0.47683823108673096,
-0.8724444508552551,
0.3089873492717743,
-0.19330845773220062,
0.5190514326095581,
-1.09030020236969,
-0.06263921409845352,
0.2846669852733612,
0.31713616847991943,
0.44403642416000366,
-0.5049774050712585,
-0.24055109918117523,
-0.311385840177536,
-0.051636334508657455,
0.26555129885673523,
0.17566749453544617,
-0.686019241809845,
0.6811888813972473,
0.3693638741970062,
-0.4481465518474579,
-0.37551969289779663,
-0.4710440933704376,
0.46957603096961975,
-0.2692411541938782,
-0.5422320365905762,
0.6007523536682129,
0.04654403775930405,
-0.10815323144197464,
0.028877466917037964,
0.017681580036878586,
0.32775890827178955,
-0.017842767760157585,
0.4286049008369446,
0.6161067485809326,
-0.4602256119251251,
0.0806678757071495,
-0.04598246142268181,
-0.29036208987236023,
0.010124575346708298,
-0.6370144486427307,
0.7554503679275513,
-0.29885369539260864,
-0.37366771697998047,
-0.2809561789035797,
0.10260505229234695,
0.4115285277366638,
0.06279954314231873,
0.6004825234413147,
0.6732398271560669,
-0.01619122363626957,
0.006435841787606478,
-0.5521386861801147,
-0.14672470092773438,
-0.5238909125328064,
0.5850478410720825,
-0.299606055021286,
-1.3773059844970703,
0.17104779183864594,
-0.23738376796245575,
-0.28712302446365356,
0.07156310975551605,
0.45891502499580383,
0.03841366618871689,
1.0682251453399658,
0.7936462759971619,
-0.5130218863487244,
0.8881756067276001,
-0.2869816720485687,
0.3573833107948303,
-1.0491888523101807,
-0.030544763430953026,
-0.06999218463897705,
-0.41846320033073425,
-0.7138116955757141,
-0.27682217955589294,
0.28224462270736694,
-0.0343564935028553,
-0.4523566961288452,
0.15943075716495514,
-0.3401229977607727,
0.5831193327903748,
0.5575738549232483,
0.3976241946220398,
0.07984670251607895,
0.18002310395240784,
-0.13612721860408783,
0.11119590699672699,
-0.709528923034668,
-0.5528458952903748,
0.8552401065826416,
0.2168121486902237,
0.7432389855384827,
0.08177889883518219,
0.3391978442668915,
0.42760032415390015,
0.31144165992736816,
-1.0253779888153076,
0.7311009168624878,
-0.29524412751197815,
0.012612894177436829,
-0.27290570735931396,
-0.41997408866882324,
-0.9947852492332458,
0.1225811019539833,
-0.09990473836660385,
-1.1270482540130615,
-0.005140834487974644,
-0.06000716611742973,
-0.21074895560741425,
0.26049500703811646,
-0.4155193269252777,
1.0992529392242432,
-0.45416924357414246,
-0.5016660094261169,
-0.2592434287071228,
-0.34525927901268005,
0.18255606293678284,
0.16406302154064178,
0.03901633992791176,
-0.224678173661232,
0.16664662957191467,
0.5495282411575317,
-0.07852340489625931,
0.8269764184951782,
-0.24596533179283142,
0.00785771943628788,
0.14745746552944183,
0.1667259782552719,
0.6724326014518738,
0.044042639434337616,
-0.07327906787395477,
0.04125168174505234,
-0.19949907064437866,
-0.02414349839091301,
-0.6861936450004578,
0.9667317271232605,
-0.7056776285171509,
-0.830984354019165,
-0.20414738357067108,
-0.6062694787979126,
-0.3223404288291931,
0.3775685131549835,
-0.2997801899909973,
0.6020206212997437,
-0.5177476406097412,
0.11324067413806915,
0.4407230019569397,
-0.19433510303497314,
0.26222673058509827,
0.2798042595386505,
-0.641941249370575,
-0.7094340324401855,
1.0266897678375244,
-0.136719211935997,
-0.05511884763836861,
0.3914996385574341,
0.11740436404943466,
-0.3794790804386139,
-0.6741387844085693,
-0.6254822015762329,
0.3831103444099426,
-0.7321422696113586,
-0.03215019032359123,
-0.5816658139228821,
-0.04397750273346901,
-0.2541123330593109,
-0.334087997674942,
0.4579392671585083,
0.09164983034133911,
-0.3107932507991791,
-0.2545498013496399,
0.6161136627197266,
0.7505753040313721,
0.38161033391952515,
0.7235614657402039,
-0.7044475674629211,
0.21890275180339813,
0.22132481634616852,
0.44666558504104614,
0.1461487114429474,
-0.4746280312538147,
-0.31290584802627563,
-0.12791572511196136,
-0.22733984887599945,
-0.5175232887268066,
0.40341493487358093,
0.09171170741319656,
0.6915470361709595,
0.6796649098396301,
-0.32573816180229187,
0.8382270932197571,
-0.7442619204521179,
0.6181756258010864,
0.11990279704332352,
-0.7160333395004272,
0.31387826800346375,
-0.5296360850334167,
0.2663136124610901,
0.5340871214866638,
0.35625430941581726,
-0.8170157670974731,
-0.03320429474115372,
-0.22427138686180115,
-0.8393935561180115,
0.8241812586784363,
-0.3728548288345337,
0.4110070765018463,
0.12019680440425873,
0.40639567375183105,
-0.10660798102617264,
0.17788472771644592,
-0.569733738899231,
-0.0492524579167366,
0.0633636862039566,
-0.23685072362422943,
-0.6376466751098633,
-0.3118373155593872,
-0.20772483944892883,
-0.1377124935388565,
0.6118744611740112,
-0.500992476940155,
0.23306412994861603,
-0.27815136313438416,
-0.10882405191659927,
-0.037599287927150726,
0.27210602164268494,
0.17666150629520416,
0.765721321105957,
-0.2665356397628784,
0.1299627423286438,
0.3761451244354248,
-0.08547011762857437,
0.20173487067222595,
0.1960347294807434,
-0.07582058012485504,
-0.17336982488632202,
0.2202947586774826,
1.2956730127334595,
0.45330870151519775,
-0.5594034790992737,
0.18725314736366272,
-0.0847349539399147,
0.22316701710224152,
-0.007820281200110912,
0.3186476230621338,
0.37109971046447754,
0.2697303295135498,
0.0558890700340271,
-0.3409934937953949,
0.09459060430526733,
-0.6046704053878784,
-0.022686153650283813,
0.7115316390991211,
-0.7422265410423279,
0.03551158308982849,
0.31337061524391174,
0.12629686295986176,
-0.4911844730377197,
0.7839789986610413,
0.10337428003549576,
-0.3794406056404114,
0.32252979278564453,
0.9643102884292603,
1.0107288360595703,
0.3453928530216217,
0.11380168795585632,
0.2674783170223236,
-0.08639170229434967,
-0.08540327101945877,
-0.0872352346777916,
-0.17142312228679657,
-0.545971691608429,
-0.438577800989151,
-0.5436727404594421,
-0.4912094473838806,
0.047081876546144485,
-0.44246840476989746,
0.32634902000427246,
-0.4211723208427429,
-0.41323915123939514,
-0.06346439570188522,
-0.18234647810459137,
-0.44853585958480835,
-0.23282985389232635,
0.20590424537658691,
0.672651469707489,
-0.5568518042564392,
0.583658754825592,
0.6641386151313782,
-0.2177792340517044,
-0.580559492111206,
-0.05636119470000267,
0.006350261624902487,
-0.7248202562332153,
0.5247711539268494,
0.30356547236442566,
-0.24131134152412415,
0.03627113625407219,
-0.17791204154491425,
-0.7325378656387329,
1.2057936191558838,
0.4601927101612091,
-0.6011644005775452,
-0.212815061211586,
-0.019997671246528625,
0.577264130115509,
-0.5097619295120239,
0.364052414894104,
0.5192288160324097,
0.5205087661743164,
0.18480156362056732,
-0.626966118812561,
0.3493613600730896,
-0.1106000617146492,
0.471050888299942,
0.42702531814575195,
-0.47059008479118347,
0.4954415559768677,
-0.14138105511665344,
-0.10605444759130478,
-0.06143598258495331,
0.6362655162811279,
0.31641602516174316,
0.3342002034187317,
0.47501787543296814,
0.12802158296108246,
0.723875105381012,
-0.08142558485269547,
1.0860450267791748,
-0.4166136085987091,
-0.011621926911175251,
1.1214940547943115,
-0.43358781933784485,
0.6482065916061401,
0.35144996643066406,
-0.2929762005805969,
0.8434685468673706,
0.7676379680633545,
-0.28540143370628357,
0.31470629572868347,
0.35168731212615967,
-0.27642467617988586,
-0.2986071705818176,
-0.43010273575782776,
-0.22349578142166138,
0.17738258838653564,
0.37529876828193665,
-0.2743859589099884,
-0.22305314242839813,
0.05925693362951279,
0.001338953385129571,
-0.0958237424492836,
-0.3390956223011017,
1.1580976247787476,
0.2297416627407074,
-0.6506194472312927,
0.3951859772205353,
0.14084956049919128,
0.6242997646331787,
-0.8518294095993042,
-0.17477862536907196,
-0.02590351179242134,
0.21955262124538422,
0.03658704087138176,
-0.7020465731620789,
-0.2347499281167984,
-0.04015375301241875,
-0.14798423647880554,
-0.2524071931838989,
0.9389702081680298,
-0.3278806507587433,
-0.6619483232498169,
0.47174984216690063,
0.6369467377662659,
-0.03413115814328194,
0.007600031793117523,
-0.48709046840667725,
-0.04689597710967064,
-0.06272396445274353,
0.04439479112625122,
0.6375094056129456,
0.456328421831131,
-0.07238104939460754,
0.7636691331863403,
0.6679915189743042,
0.06377902626991272,
-0.5542289018630981,
0.23628388345241547,
0.8634810447692871,
-0.6824071407318115,
-0.5602410435676575,
-1.0963621139526367,
0.030948733910918236,
-0.03009345382452011,
0.055009111762046814,
0.7565615177154541,
0.5834405422210693,
0.504341185092926,
0.05553235858678818,
0.7723090052604675,
0.30972039699554443,
-0.07465590536594391,
-0.6190149188041687,
0.5831642746925354,
-0.3314672112464905,
0.3380652368068695,
-0.29581043124198914,
-1.0095796585083008,
-0.12588734924793243,
0.4885944426059723,
-0.6775906682014465,
0.4435630738735199,
0.38239651918411255,
0.8211246132850647,
-0.34164637327194214,
0.042581431567668915,
0.12420423328876495,
0.05985977500677109,
0.49867308139801025,
0.6000047922134399,
0.713853657245636,
0.11990024149417877,
0.3668518364429474,
0.12668520212173462,
-0.14494138956069946,
-0.4931142032146454,
-0.9080820679664612,
-1.0263781547546387,
-0.2368551641702652,
-0.18083621561527252,
-0.39081135392189026,
0.29444581270217896,
1.1783629655838013,
0.5176244378089905,
-0.8687397241592407,
-0.609910786151886,
-0.22034727036952972,
0.29386091232299805,
-0.2494630068540573,
-0.24463295936584473,
0.5293018817901611,
-0.35931894183158875,
-0.5662541389465332,
0.72672039270401,
0.442444771528244,
0.25615862011909485,
-0.32460081577301025,
-0.09278473258018494,
0.04296041652560234,
-0.22128084301948547,
0.7236526012420654,
0.020930545404553413,
-0.6966124176979065,
-0.3198886513710022,
-0.08890783041715622,
-0.08276922255754471,
0.056009333580732346,
1.1089892387390137,
-0.8802965879440308,
0.3302861750125885,
0.22561109066009521,
0.7062143087387085,
0.8472593426704407,
-0.13216957449913025,
0.8511657118797302,
-0.4679126441478729,
-0.16050633788108826,
-0.1312403380870819,
0.5408358573913574,
0.3594493269920349,
-0.3314584493637085,
0.44133254885673523,
-0.05477317050099373,
-0.4542027413845062,
-0.8330841660499573,
-0.006708474364131689,
-1.0554085969924927,
-0.2933971583843231,
1.1800557374954224,
-0.16473744809627533,
-0.00528502743691206,
-0.16307224333286285,
-0.6253355145454407,
0.1702088564634323,
-0.4611767530441284,
0.7049520015716553,
0.6971787810325623,
-0.39868423342704773,
-0.022785894572734833,
-0.5393562912940979,
0.09998150914907455,
0.012634812854230404,
-0.6496083736419678,
0.4274325966835022,
0.7323535680770874,
0.10015163570642471,
-0.18378286063671112,
0.4932842254638672,
0.4098348319530487,
0.03188798949122429,
-0.3117774426937103,
-0.31711432337760925,
-0.4032759964466095,
-0.20156066119670868,
-0.4879668653011322,
0.10980580747127533,
0.31781652569770813,
0.2880452275276184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16515v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16515v1
|
LLM-based Privacy Data Augmentation Guided by Knowledge Distillation with a Distribution Tutor for Medical Text Classification
| 2024-02-26T11:52:55 | 2024-02-26T11:52:55 |
Yiping Song, Juhua Zhang, Zhiliang Tian, Yuxin Yang, Minlie Huang, Dongsheng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
As sufficient data are not always publically accessible for model training,
researchers exploit limited data with advanced learning algorithms or expand
the dataset via data augmentation (DA). Conducting DA in private domain
requires private protection approaches (i.e. anonymization and perturbation),
but those methods cannot provide protection guarantees. Differential privacy
(DP) learning methods theoretically bound the protection but are not skilled at
generating pseudo text samples with large models. In this paper, we transfer
DP-based pseudo sample generation task to DP-based generated samples
discrimination task, where we propose a DP-based DA method with a LLM and a
DP-based discriminator for text classification on private domains. We construct
a knowledge distillation model as the DP-based discriminator: teacher models,
accessing private data, teaches students how to select private samples with
calibrated noise to achieve DP. To constrain the distribution of DA's
generation, we propose a DP-based tutor that models the noised private
distribution and controls samples' generation with a low privacy cost. We
theoretically analyze our model's privacy protection and empirically verify our
model.
|
[
-0.007294982206076384,
-0.40048661828041077,
0.6014973521232605,
-0.3456897735595703,
-0.26763638854026794,
0.26197224855422974,
0.10797461867332458,
-0.49718421697616577,
-0.19684909284114838,
0.5769479870796204,
-0.5410013198852539,
-0.648909866809845,
-0.8059254288673401,
0.14028504490852356,
-0.3450384736061096,
1.2345733642578125,
0.22386357188224792,
0.20944075286388397,
-0.37698423862457275,
0.16935716569423676,
-0.08740077912807465,
-0.8544556498527527,
-0.24617968499660492,
-0.08277317881584167,
0.17084719240665436,
0.3444631099700928,
0.28813475370407104,
0.7326396703720093,
0.35135382413864136,
0.3331223130226135,
-0.28490620851516724,
0.4616048038005829,
-0.5104537606239319,
0.22415904700756073,
-0.1963939368724823,
-0.761936604976654,
-0.40217456221580505,
0.18222679197788239,
0.35765978693962097,
0.6957810521125793,
-0.04738584905862808,
-0.013218558393418789,
0.20387835800647736,
0.8195412158966064,
-0.6993817090988159,
0.04289954528212547,
-0.5858929753303528,
0.14998415112495422,
-0.15601767599582672,
-0.11625955998897552,
-0.2921086847782135,
-0.6616864204406738,
0.339812308549881,
-0.39765557646751404,
0.6235122680664062,
0.007993744686245918,
0.5407723188400269,
0.44910621643066406,
-0.569395899772644,
-0.2840311527252197,
-0.808615505695343,
0.8132946491241455,
-0.37586137652397156,
0.2507050335407257,
0.7342913150787354,
0.41447713971138,
-0.025477210059762,
-0.8531296849250793,
-0.5452527403831482,
-0.2006298005580902,
-0.1125335618853569,
-0.0004860424087382853,
0.03818002715706825,
0.20379549264907837,
0.19284047186374664,
0.8593699932098389,
-0.09922356903553009,
0.19540947675704956,
-0.47457846999168396,
-0.06279634684324265,
0.8289206027984619,
0.08780702948570251,
0.06038946658372879,
-0.006105954758822918,
-0.4778701663017273,
0.008488792926073074,
-0.5242790579795837,
-0.3424600660800934,
0.6464412212371826,
-0.16801975667476654,
-0.13592258095741272,
0.5268367528915405,
-0.01383731234818697,
0.6711081266403198,
0.4179672300815582,
-0.5758494138717651,
0.2869409918785095,
-0.1729968786239624,
-0.16300393640995026,
0.1902947723865509,
0.5753225088119507,
0.20808999240398407,
0.004769773688167334,
0.03857158496975899,
-0.14068657159805298,
-0.10192643851041794,
0.1180911660194397,
-0.8928002119064331,
-0.6706517934799194,
0.13049820065498352,
-0.4091950058937073,
-0.7400209903717041,
-0.11740216612815857,
-0.8901738524436951,
-0.8101527094841003,
-0.2630847096443176,
0.20688509941101074,
-0.20698772370815277,
-0.20632904767990112,
0.2648944556713104,
-0.10655765235424042,
-0.5056228041648865,
0.09640040993690491,
-1.0301172733306885,
0.5931045413017273,
0.420705109834671,
0.7162203788757324,
-0.4102861285209656,
-0.029558895155787468,
-0.2715449035167694,
0.3839420974254608,
0.02502991259098053,
0.48883798718452454,
-0.25258100032806396,
-0.5563856363296509,
-0.14266058802604675,
0.004146498627960682,
0.1722756326198578,
-0.7155184745788574,
0.2528690695762634,
-0.48648661375045776,
0.5557048320770264,
0.004410687834024429,
-0.843632161617279,
-0.21363051235675812,
-0.05805010348558426,
-0.6481615304946899,
0.6864914894104004,
0.288971483707428,
-1.106520175933838,
0.4885443449020386,
-0.5525099635124207,
-0.2365337759256363,
0.20670586824417114,
-0.41465887427330017,
-0.7900684475898743,
0.13673827052116394,
0.15330375730991364,
0.6433518528938293,
-0.004969464614987373,
0.33147376775741577,
-0.27877190709114075,
-0.22673404216766357,
0.37856191396713257,
-0.6442680358886719,
0.9973354339599609,
0.19706867635250092,
-0.35610613226890564,
-0.2742709517478943,
-1.0893720388412476,
-0.372655987739563,
0.041706632822752,
-0.26224321126937866,
-0.5900270342826843,
-0.2093808650970459,
-0.3517298102378845,
-0.07499928772449493,
0.35363680124282837,
-0.5373349189758301,
0.14618578553199768,
-0.5022683143615723,
0.2668604552745819,
0.8712899088859558,
0.3157806098461151,
0.607158899307251,
-0.4751521348953247,
0.44199705123901367,
0.2824695110321045,
0.19743721187114716,
0.2640441954135895,
-0.4735090136528015,
-0.26485177874565125,
-0.6950756907463074,
0.4785792827606201,
0.4204021096229553,
-0.5875626802444458,
0.7111925482749939,
-0.15529058873653412,
-0.2868189513683319,
-0.5405035018920898,
0.20171694457530975,
0.297896146774292,
0.7526615858078003,
0.3253273069858551,
-0.1609712839126587,
-0.30620211362838745,
-0.6451494693756104,
0.14970234036445618,
0.043413545936346054,
-0.14871886372566223,
0.34178948402404785,
0.1810242086648941,
-0.17649859189987183,
0.803701639175415,
-0.982824981212616,
-0.5558732748031616,
-0.1269480139017105,
-0.2714182734489441,
-0.02065400592982769,
0.4531285762786865,
0.5915818214416504,
-0.9651328325271606,
-0.5046442747116089,
-0.33630529046058655,
-0.6020050048828125,
-0.31668680906295776,
0.17790909111499786,
-0.13363945484161377,
0.03574386611580849,
-0.022933682426810265,
-0.16169080138206482,
0.6461576819419861,
0.5554143190383911,
-0.19333526492118835,
0.3171040713787079,
-0.5991261005401611,
0.12757617235183716,
-1.1806061267852783,
-0.19601187109947205,
-0.028305936604738235,
-0.46994391083717346,
-0.71430903673172,
-0.13117502629756927,
0.00680543715134263,
-0.1453816294670105,
-0.49046608805656433,
0.40314149856567383,
-0.4496568441390991,
0.24973104894161224,
-0.7508246302604675,
-0.22275210916996002,
0.17865504324436188,
0.14510229229927063,
0.2403527796268463,
0.6247206926345825,
0.7245022654533386,
-0.9214372038841248,
0.3067653179168701,
0.4014689028263092,
-0.22255726158618927,
0.6086530089378357,
-0.2833925187587738,
0.1503712236881256,
-0.1276298612356186,
0.23477323353290558,
-0.8964517712593079,
-0.16700005531311035,
0.3568819761276245,
-0.16009657084941864,
0.4217820167541504,
-0.21015852689743042,
-0.5482102632522583,
-0.2141106128692627,
-0.3217734694480896,
0.24550509452819824,
0.8566912412643433,
-1.102913498878479,
0.2130081206560135,
0.6851295232772827,
-0.07880765944719315,
-0.6594864726066589,
-0.8096233010292053,
-0.26555028557777405,
-0.4114738404750824,
-0.3613159954547882,
0.7079293131828308,
-0.21751806139945984,
-0.28733551502227783,
-0.05019759014248848,
-0.24450118839740753,
-0.5186468362808228,
0.15116602182388306,
0.3410683870315552,
0.42575275897979736,
0.4041302502155304,
0.012875749729573727,
0.649084210395813,
-0.17032776772975922,
-0.011088050901889801,
-0.3252254128456116,
0.1557605266571045,
0.7133371233940125,
-0.26359328627586365,
-0.6605653166770935,
0.1732359081506729,
0.007443142589181662,
0.15572352707386017,
0.7329853177070618,
0.16904838383197784,
-0.2622298002243042,
-0.5073080658912659,
-0.4772524833679199,
-0.4812225103378296,
-0.5188252925872803,
0.05440560728311539,
-0.15367363393306732,
-0.687004804611206,
0.07487090677022934,
-0.273362398147583,
0.07255252450704575,
0.06118493527173996,
0.5944252610206604,
0.16228322684764862,
0.7218383550643921,
0.6910063028335571,
-0.10500090569257736,
0.33048245310783386,
-0.272175133228302,
-0.08326827734708786,
-0.4103565812110901,
-0.18063098192214966,
-0.31040897965431213,
-0.3830067813396454,
-0.5826375484466553,
-0.24356085062026978,
0.3591364324092865,
-0.10750457644462585,
0.14832471311092377,
-0.05302809923887253,
-1.1266263723373413,
0.6500381827354431,
0.7421814203262329,
0.6182209849357605,
0.6730738878250122,
0.21225525438785553,
0.117203488945961,
-0.19367371499538422,
-0.29754891991615295,
-0.33108875155448914,
1.5161077976226807,
0.2750975787639618,
0.754882276058197,
-0.033195387572050095,
1.2834489345550537,
0.2883988916873932,
0.11574997752904892,
-0.346537321805954,
0.5046704411506653,
-0.4867791533470154,
-0.7093855738639832,
0.04782328009605408,
-0.5815799236297607,
-0.5898142457008362,
-0.003972431179136038,
-0.15619532763957977,
-0.5354326963424683,
0.5126085877418518,
0.2542983293533325,
-0.2169593721628189,
0.3221709728240967,
-0.5724431872367859,
0.23862925171852112,
-0.11063974350690842,
-0.5276026129722595,
-0.05477068945765495,
-0.5120104551315308,
0.6166488528251648,
-0.38814374804496765,
0.17870262265205383,
0.1608646810054779,
0.0035897062625736,
0.5457607507705688,
-0.5717642903327942,
1.0000568628311157,
-0.7380450963973999,
-0.25948864221572876,
0.19680504500865936,
-0.1560734510421753,
0.34444764256477356,
0.22326594591140747,
-0.020036255940794945,
0.23514796793460846,
0.04416633024811745,
-0.1488877236843109,
-0.4257238507270813,
0.7758263945579529,
-0.7455106973648071,
-0.7445967197418213,
-0.41230136156082153,
-0.46563026309013367,
-0.08364810049533844,
-0.006972235627472401,
0.4149263799190521,
-0.007041270844638348,
0.38856828212738037,
0.04187415540218353,
0.866596519947052,
-0.34417054057121277,
-0.01964833214879036,
0.7635022401809692,
0.019804663956165314,
-0.3568620979785919,
0.9869505167007446,
0.21104362607002258,
0.17365799844264984,
0.36509600281715393,
0.5501129627227783,
-0.8097462058067322,
-1.0103555917739868,
-0.23605801165103912,
0.13510727882385254,
-0.6111376881599426,
-0.09803012013435364,
-0.633967399597168,
-0.41523277759552,
-0.4831293523311615,
0.1360885053873062,
-0.03612304851412773,
-0.5946348905563354,
-0.4944632053375244,
-0.4379775822162628,
0.6619346141815186,
0.6450986266136169,
-0.42885923385620117,
0.3844243288040161,
-0.6582140326499939,
0.6570912599563599,
0.32440733909606934,
0.11284875869750977,
-0.28649094700813293,
-0.6900915503501892,
-0.01844235509634018,
0.014994479715824127,
-0.5859603881835938,
-0.961108922958374,
0.38013654947280884,
0.16029919683933258,
0.4771299660205841,
0.2933778464794159,
0.6151105761528015,
0.2567444145679474,
-0.5766671299934387,
0.7819131016731262,
0.040528133511543274,
-0.6234539151191711,
0.46622002124786377,
0.054527994245290756,
-0.4236765205860138,
0.6104483008384705,
0.47974103689193726,
0.24024835228919983,
-0.5371319055557251,
-0.6124808192253113,
-0.6539055109024048,
0.6628657579421997,
0.059358540922403336,
0.2338782399892807,
0.18979506194591522,
0.6229886412620544,
0.6612957715988159,
0.3471253514289856,
-0.8401861786842346,
-0.638112485408783,
-0.14725205302238464,
-0.5052145719528198,
0.0802532508969307,
-0.24090281128883362,
-0.29004526138305664,
-0.27490830421447754,
0.5793628096580505,
0.15622708201408386,
-0.023706607520580292,
0.2705885171890259,
0.13566070795059204,
0.24782051146030426,
0.09122923016548157,
0.2502163052558899,
0.3631686270236969,
-0.10349874943494797,
0.1396218091249466,
-0.05479078367352486,
-0.9412663578987122,
0.5738987922668457,
0.6421912312507629,
-0.413502037525177,
0.06559361517429352,
-0.35701289772987366,
0.4548863172531128,
-0.2818969786167145,
-0.2312135100364685,
0.6824396252632141,
-0.0878540426492691,
-0.5991213321685791,
-0.22707203030586243,
0.4565514624118805,
-0.22205613553524017,
0.2008817046880722,
0.31353622674942017,
-0.3147906959056854,
0.49962249398231506,
0.12115075439214706,
0.469659686088562,
0.1303204447031021,
-0.07573647052049637,
-0.17034073173999786,
1.02588951587677,
0.0929492712020874,
-0.0227753184735775,
0.22568586468696594,
-0.1906055361032486,
-0.0870518833398819,
0.2673490345478058,
0.43237021565437317,
0.7271517515182495,
-0.5066428780555725,
0.23871198296546936,
0.08303161710500717,
-0.29261043667793274,
-0.20543259382247925,
0.37589141726493835,
-0.4011309742927551,
-0.4357052743434906,
-0.16987131536006927,
-0.5555312037467957,
-0.5281838178634644,
0.34641462564468384,
-0.6141266822814941,
0.24027462303638458,
-0.5463447570800781,
-0.0646081268787384,
0.030571267008781433,
0.2631217837333679,
-0.3259526193141937,
0.4630647897720337,
-0.0261201374232769,
0.3443971574306488,
-0.6488150954246521,
1.0363749265670776,
0.43553435802459717,
-0.12499169260263443,
-0.497346431016922,
0.22155126929283142,
0.1497553586959839,
-0.6723884344100952,
0.7325426936149597,
0.046473532915115356,
0.11837872117757797,
0.0844385102391243,
-0.34084364771842957,
-0.23600780963897705,
1.1097338199615479,
0.4559445381164551,
-0.9174832105636597,
-0.09974123537540436,
0.43560680747032166,
0.6372756958007812,
0.08238643407821655,
-0.22370974719524384,
0.14319445192813873,
0.09716034680604935,
-0.03016527183353901,
-0.4781036376953125,
0.0979624092578888,
0.16839344799518585,
-0.23798878490924835,
-0.040412936359643936,
-0.26994824409484863,
0.719744086265564,
-0.10431535542011261,
-0.21942861378192902,
-0.08014897257089615,
0.4550936818122864,
0.5670259594917297,
0.6839429140090942,
0.5327838659286499,
0.41411277651786804,
1.027319312095642,
0.25344645977020264,
0.8839356303215027,
-0.588674783706665,
0.22926418483257294,
1.0438313484191895,
-0.38675829768180847,
0.2393016368150711,
0.34173572063446045,
-0.3602583706378937,
0.3398457169532776,
0.5204120874404907,
-0.13764993846416473,
0.959925651550293,
0.4937477111816406,
-0.8249143958091736,
0.31112170219421387,
-0.04840269312262535,
-0.5272325873374939,
0.12070295214653015,
0.1427592933177948,
-0.7848798632621765,
0.04118432477116585,
0.22429583966732025,
-0.22409316897392273,
0.3830133080482483,
-0.18107469379901886,
1.002664566040039,
0.22518189251422882,
-0.12362534552812576,
0.47254759073257446,
-0.04520818963646889,
0.8197710514068604,
-0.4359598159790039,
0.08617573231458664,
-0.09544537961483002,
0.4727248549461365,
-0.36888059973716736,
-0.5410478115081787,
0.3411056399345398,
0.20926399528980255,
-0.28701794147491455,
-0.052348289638757706,
0.8368905782699585,
-0.4359852373600006,
-0.44339317083358765,
0.10055391490459442,
0.4127257168292999,
0.23506249487400055,
0.10659153014421463,
-0.6291297078132629,
-0.474427193403244,
0.09225226193666458,
-0.1626947820186615,
0.687464714050293,
0.47471973299980164,
0.2932382822036743,
0.3688730299472809,
0.6726747751235962,
0.4422719180583954,
0.0669277161359787,
0.0895272046327591,
0.9558748602867126,
-0.21151421964168549,
-0.7446330189704895,
-1.0723364353179932,
0.24663762748241425,
-0.17643435299396515,
0.06634176522493362,
0.7865171432495117,
0.5225545763969421,
0.775754451751709,
-0.1897605061531067,
1.077309250831604,
0.291569322347641,
0.9962084293365479,
-0.4871119260787964,
0.905341386795044,
-0.48244041204452515,
0.47208526730537415,
-0.08667635917663574,
-0.7468453645706177,
-0.13661684095859528,
0.4894062578678131,
-0.3303985595703125,
-0.17012415826320648,
0.45825499296188354,
0.6298812031745911,
-0.14324744045734406,
0.0775706022977829,
0.3454730808734894,
-0.0490366667509079,
0.3070424795150757,
0.49080145359039307,
0.8195923566818237,
-0.19639912247657776,
0.37327641248703003,
-0.8934479355812073,
-0.3686802089214325,
0.25943928956985474,
-0.6514379978179932,
-1.0972942113876343,
-0.5003496408462524,
-0.48958057165145874,
-0.4311125874519348,
0.11161021143198013,
0.647020697593689,
0.8957096338272095,
-0.593008279800415,
0.1463927924633026,
-0.4421718418598175,
-0.03172248229384422,
0.023979635909199715,
-0.2295672595500946,
0.5507852435112,
0.05690845847129822,
-1.2238173484802246,
0.32562190294265747,
-0.02319764904677868,
0.5385550260543823,
-0.39414072036743164,
0.11207518726587296,
0.22582578659057617,
-0.21058957278728485,
0.088104248046875,
-0.01786975748836994,
-0.20169347524642944,
0.19579921662807465,
-0.18030664324760437,
-0.021250909194350243,
-0.019552117213606834,
0.6046884655952454,
-0.6630799174308777,
0.4325973689556122,
0.28338202834129333,
0.767455518245697,
0.42902711033821106,
0.19166648387908936,
0.4378874599933624,
-1.0979588031768799,
0.34574052691459656,
0.28995856642723083,
0.05298832058906555,
0.23875762522220612,
-1.0221009254455566,
0.27525830268859863,
0.4519365429878235,
-0.8353135585784912,
-1.1328028440475464,
0.27139583230018616,
-0.5318820476531982,
-0.46826639771461487,
0.9257506132125854,
-0.41110652685165405,
-0.23057831823825836,
-0.3550873398780823,
-0.34311261773109436,
0.24011625349521637,
-0.36129963397979736,
1.1373437643051147,
0.2759275436401367,
-0.11957807838916779,
0.03638921305537224,
-0.27643993496894836,
0.8061695694923401,
-0.012659487314522266,
-0.8933632969856262,
0.10421895980834961,
0.5823983550071716,
0.4610750377178192,
-0.10311739146709442,
0.8406095504760742,
-0.2610112130641937,
-0.07286754250526428,
-0.1408340185880661,
-0.19734804332256317,
-0.4788440465927124,
-0.29950565099716187,
-0.33805495500564575,
0.1969873309135437,
-0.04093356803059578,
-0.6946854591369629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16508v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16508v2
|
Pre-training Cross-lingual Open Domain Question Answering with Large-scale Synthetic Supervision
| 2024-02-26T11:42:29 | 2024-06-16T08:18:25 |
Fan Jiang, Tom Drummond, Trevor Cohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Cross-lingual open domain question answering (CLQA) is a complex problem,
comprising cross-lingual retrieval from a multilingual knowledge base, followed
by answer generation in the query language. Both steps are usually tackled by
separate models, requiring substantial annotated datasets, and typically
auxiliary resources, like machine translation systems to bridge between
languages. In this paper, we show that CLQA can be addressed using a single
encoder-decoder model. To effectively train this model, we propose a
self-supervised method based on exploiting the cross-lingual link structure
within Wikipedia. We demonstrate how linked Wikipedia pages can be used to
synthesise supervisory signals for cross-lingual retrieval, through a form of
cloze query, and generate more natural questions to supervise answer
generation. Together, we show our approach, \texttt{CLASS}, outperforms
comparable methods on both supervised and zero-shot language adaptation
settings, including those using machine translation.
|
[
-0.8088764548301697,
-0.9648043513298035,
0.2965875267982483,
-0.0020525006111711264,
-0.1576651930809021,
-0.23373451828956604,
-0.36649197340011597,
-0.5217342376708984,
0.19051221013069153,
0.6241752505302429,
-0.89992755651474,
-0.4596691429615021,
-0.3169780373573303,
0.372601717710495,
-0.4552052915096283,
1.0745680332183838,
-0.15675675868988037,
0.24549855291843414,
-0.29665398597717285,
0.09805482625961304,
-0.19646427035331726,
-0.4469728469848633,
-0.7471097111701965,
0.16647325456142426,
0.6108351349830627,
0.45320695638656616,
0.4984421730041504,
0.2771247625350952,
0.06282897293567657,
0.2285374402999878,
0.24890510737895966,
0.3790642023086548,
-0.6824765801429749,
-0.009906756691634655,
-0.5748944282531738,
-0.31338825821876526,
-0.19119934737682343,
-0.06060193479061127,
0.5224801301956177,
0.795882523059845,
0.10223884880542755,
0.4565832018852234,
0.026214251294732094,
0.3252384662628174,
-0.7024589776992798,
-0.025065399706363678,
-0.738176703453064,
0.08525660634040833,
-0.0774865373969078,
-0.1664622724056244,
-0.5061246752738953,
-0.23859903216362,
0.25739914178848267,
-1.0158816576004028,
0.3061593472957611,
0.11548389494419098,
0.5133536458015442,
0.09578081220388412,
-0.6147473454475403,
-0.47817161679267883,
-0.5382459759712219,
0.49866071343421936,
-0.5025104880332947,
0.5437641143798828,
0.19331520795822144,
0.4138237237930298,
-0.08656726032495499,
-0.8756934404373169,
-0.7094187140464783,
0.030370090156793594,
-0.2041715532541275,
0.12920233607292175,
0.21659648418426514,
-0.036166515201330185,
0.19333654642105103,
0.19930899143218994,
-0.7779638767242432,
0.01336325891315937,
-0.823150098323822,
-0.2817831337451935,
0.6432715058326721,
-0.008669939823448658,
0.5659586191177368,
-0.10867471247911453,
-0.4910261034965515,
0.024180157110095024,
-0.7415592074394226,
-0.01695437543094158,
0.29040706157684326,
0.13196299970149994,
0.239368736743927,
0.5410464406013489,
-0.48080307245254517,
0.7762671113014221,
0.4489496946334839,
0.25095802545547485,
-0.07782474160194397,
-0.2825849950313568,
-0.08971158415079117,
0.4618036150932312,
0.7393314242362976,
0.21483644843101501,
0.774429976940155,
-0.32998913526535034,
0.2417348176240921,
-0.36168476939201355,
0.4050922989845276,
-0.7473915219306946,
-0.2774198651313782,
0.24006962776184082,
-0.07511651515960693,
0.10190638154745102,
-0.025980589911341667,
-0.7777079939842224,
0.09487005323171616,
-0.2602986991405487,
0.557662308216095,
-0.22824621200561523,
-0.2336944192647934,
0.09688697755336761,
-0.05434345081448555,
0.5061626434326172,
0.22472329437732697,
-0.9492684006690979,
0.13682039082050323,
0.3616551458835602,
0.3674464821815491,
-0.33377334475517273,
-0.6592365503311157,
-0.6715101599693298,
0.4459645450115204,
-0.47656330466270447,
0.4213799238204956,
-0.3135201036930084,
-0.27029407024383545,
0.2875009775161743,
0.24335798621177673,
-0.2546667754650116,
-0.4636287987232208,
0.2619844079017639,
-1.0546287298202515,
0.4823656380176544,
-0.1444718837738037,
-0.37962207198143005,
0.005978852976113558,
0.42529886960983276,
-0.6269325613975525,
1.027143120765686,
0.05826186388731003,
-1.0631036758422852,
0.18417911231517792,
-0.7262128591537476,
-0.3911333978176117,
-0.2029726356267929,
0.09392232447862625,
0.06839469820261002,
-0.29627305269241333,
0.720167875289917,
0.25931093096733093,
-0.22524122893810272,
0.25341513752937317,
-0.20924676954746246,
-0.13448466360569,
0.11756888031959534,
-0.1613248586654663,
0.9534868001937866,
0.005738538224250078,
-0.29383936524391174,
0.1506022810935974,
-0.7804011702537537,
0.3776525557041168,
0.05981553718447685,
-0.2526243031024933,
-0.5798896551132202,
-0.5464891791343689,
-0.17610231041908264,
0.43495655059814453,
0.5217795968055725,
-0.6803170442581177,
-0.013041428290307522,
-0.5092164874076843,
0.08193693310022354,
0.5427133440971375,
0.3187806010246277,
0.549784243106842,
0.09621365368366241,
0.46478015184402466,
0.12392816692590714,
0.29243573546409607,
0.05021446943283081,
-0.25318601727485657,
-0.8622961640357971,
0.05882371589541435,
0.2647935152053833,
0.5214481949806213,
-1.1882092952728271,
0.05368548259139061,
-0.1363276094198227,
-0.5003974437713623,
-0.750904381275177,
0.4206279218196869,
0.5254952311515808,
0.588931143283844,
0.8066097497940063,
-0.20549319684505463,
-0.390418142080307,
-0.9371711611747742,
-0.40056487917900085,
-0.053774915635585785,
-0.20328357815742493,
0.18068960309028625,
0.583458423614502,
-0.12961456179618835,
0.9262450933456421,
-0.5350569486618042,
-0.19482827186584473,
-0.0698116198182106,
0.10449036210775375,
0.06675421446561813,
0.4381609261035919,
0.3327235281467438,
-1.0256214141845703,
-0.9174985289573669,
0.021164776757359505,
-0.9455417990684509,
-0.12119148671627045,
0.04491981118917465,
-0.6792586445808411,
0.185203418135643,
0.664931058883667,
-0.777934193611145,
0.19116626679897308,
0.31424519419670105,
0.08510994911193848,
0.8102477192878723,
-0.11036953330039978,
0.1272101253271103,
-1.042922854423523,
0.03587060421705246,
-0.2970650792121887,
-0.13981053233146667,
-0.8480150699615479,
0.24459528923034668,
0.10934452712535858,
-0.17984285950660706,
-0.6530098915100098,
0.5477809906005859,
-0.615080714225769,
0.0047104256227612495,
-0.1033935695886612,
0.39387431740760803,
-0.08796599507331848,
0.7478650212287903,
0.47343650460243225,
0.7622037529945374,
0.6261993646621704,
-0.7180739641189575,
0.6078072190284729,
0.5250492095947266,
-0.22767160832881927,
0.5700890421867371,
-0.7144373655319214,
0.19995389878749847,
-0.20748285949230194,
0.23004725575447083,
-0.7645241022109985,
-0.39487791061401367,
0.23922589421272278,
-0.4093207120895386,
0.21801269054412842,
-0.13043737411499023,
-0.3966750502586365,
-0.46739330887794495,
-0.10192063450813293,
0.6278759241104126,
0.18546608090400696,
-0.9306676983833313,
0.4792795181274414,
0.32931312918663025,
-0.26199519634246826,
-0.8278907537460327,
-0.49498385190963745,
-0.18508470058441162,
-0.06981129944324493,
-0.7451226711273193,
0.08963847905397415,
-0.15809229016304016,
0.07805423438549042,
0.16129976511001587,
-0.2565020024776459,
-0.4094066321849823,
-0.15309305489063263,
-0.04128297045826912,
0.10531537234783173,
-0.36180463433265686,
0.05791821330785751,
0.20669275522232056,
0.17255109548568726,
0.6081144213676453,
-0.5670267343521118,
0.46334582567214966,
0.11949919909238815,
-0.42625144124031067,
-0.013738220557570457,
0.627217173576355,
0.38934263586997986,
-0.6144230961799622,
0.6716597676277161,
0.73879474401474,
-0.19023074209690094,
-0.7649579048156738,
-0.29249587655067444,
-0.253864586353302,
-0.48085981607437134,
0.2118234783411026,
-0.41877973079681396,
-0.9710271954536438,
0.2953440248966217,
0.07501200586557388,
0.006459706462919712,
0.46201974153518677,
0.7280285954475403,
-0.10981810092926025,
0.6527034044265747,
0.461905837059021,
0.03773251920938492,
0.1635485291481018,
-0.1452498435974121,
0.21726055443286896,
-0.5372310280799866,
-0.28041231632232666,
-0.19639399647712708,
0.05531150475144386,
-0.5253229141235352,
-0.44018951058387756,
0.7752829194068909,
0.10719722509384155,
-0.387241929769516,
0.46451130509376526,
-0.38389700651168823,
0.34350109100341797,
0.9909234642982483,
0.14298665523529053,
0.3213053345680237,
-0.043521419167518616,
-0.2163713127374649,
0.28449031710624695,
-0.9198494553565979,
-0.03544953092932701,
1.032151460647583,
-0.013841687701642513,
0.9599593281745911,
-0.024766599759459496,
0.8102000951766968,
0.07655815035104752,
0.12708009779453278,
-0.41066354513168335,
0.5746852159500122,
0.16335898637771606,
-1.083011269569397,
-0.747121274471283,
-0.40411603450775146,
-0.7778535485267639,
0.4025539755821228,
-0.18099676072597504,
-0.3739497661590576,
0.12512359023094177,
0.13624459505081177,
-0.022720137611031532,
0.18278443813323975,
-0.5994415283203125,
1.2752478122711182,
-0.28337180614471436,
-0.4068659543991089,
-0.17365092039108276,
-0.8981910347938538,
0.6521690487861633,
-0.31889620423316956,
0.09833291918039322,
0.34304001927375793,
0.3432311713695526,
0.663015604019165,
-0.3318806290626526,
0.9833353757858276,
-0.18821850419044495,
-0.36972954869270325,
0.7368263602256775,
0.09396755695343018,
0.1513390839099884,
0.2661268711090088,
0.2446114718914032,
0.0882439836859703,
0.3272564709186554,
-0.4575992822647095,
-0.6752914786338806,
0.6481330394744873,
-0.7782968878746033,
-0.9169896245002747,
-0.1729835569858551,
-0.6599881649017334,
-0.5206766128540039,
0.38594838976860046,
0.3626932203769684,
0.2699892818927765,
-0.3126758635044098,
0.027757715433835983,
0.8642902374267578,
-0.3941127061843872,
0.12444335222244263,
0.5737072229385376,
-0.29707372188568115,
-0.4043673574924469,
0.5910422205924988,
0.06662154197692871,
0.58062744140625,
0.4560609757900238,
-0.14158953726291656,
-0.4840402901172638,
-0.06479620188474655,
-0.8031060695648193,
0.2392905205488205,
-0.9499034285545349,
-0.07513204962015152,
-0.6385348439216614,
-0.5550163984298706,
-0.5822869539260864,
-0.14579205214977264,
-0.17524376511573792,
-0.36054784059524536,
-0.0687626302242279,
0.008516224101185799,
0.13600407540798187,
0.3700946569442749,
0.030597912147641182,
0.18312066793441772,
-0.8692567944526672,
0.6227224469184875,
0.5868359208106995,
0.15049736201763153,
-0.0040106684900820255,
-0.40641823410987854,
-0.3542434573173523,
0.23004089295864105,
0.010907064191997051,
-0.9603502750396729,
0.20338954031467438,
0.30785611271858215,
0.6614062190055847,
0.18579816818237305,
0.5595046281814575,
0.6474986672401428,
-0.7526947259902954,
0.669216513633728,
0.1094779297709465,
-0.7657274007797241,
0.6076396107673645,
-0.19885684549808502,
0.31037917733192444,
0.41802161931991577,
1.1771180629730225,
-0.5596016645431519,
-0.37167906761169434,
-0.24556097388267517,
-0.543279767036438,
0.6374145746231079,
-0.14331881701946259,
0.08348541706800461,
-0.2310781180858612,
0.1895192414522171,
0.1171012595295906,
0.16762463748455048,
-0.805076539516449,
-0.07919824868440628,
-0.39344221353530884,
-0.20543669164180756,
0.09069544821977615,
-0.07642590999603271,
-0.2645152509212494,
-0.19212870299816132,
0.8018739819526672,
-0.3795906901359558,
-0.06647557020187378,
0.5055055618286133,
-0.5481827855110168,
-0.13279369473457336,
0.37212130427360535,
-0.05393141880631447,
0.6641600728034973,
-0.04803253337740898,
0.04629623517394066,
0.45352569222450256,
-0.19984927773475647,
0.00820924248546362,
0.05732262507081032,
-0.32815778255462646,
0.06728048622608185,
0.3404211699962616,
0.5562315583229065,
0.18195123970508575,
-0.7437219023704529,
0.4995843470096588,
0.29612547159194946,
-0.2520797848701477,
-0.4442542791366577,
0.10205879807472229,
0.13186776638031006,
0.2008332759141922,
0.3701670169830322,
-0.6073353886604309,
0.19259174168109894,
-0.6412148475646973,
0.32464799284935,
0.42729103565216064,
-0.19741322100162506,
-0.21524420380592346,
0.9051015377044678,
0.08221376687288284,
0.18073108792304993,
0.622248649597168,
0.16878095269203186,
-0.7268635630607605,
0.496797114610672,
0.7874395847320557,
0.5859177708625793,
-0.2589882016181946,
0.3257722854614258,
0.6624212861061096,
0.30518949031829834,
0.1786828637123108,
0.27931690216064453,
-0.29124054312705994,
-0.5538167357444763,
-0.44889116287231445,
-0.762122631072998,
-0.5438472628593445,
-0.26537635922431946,
-0.826140284538269,
0.04314237833023071,
-0.2237965613603592,
0.2850073277950287,
-0.10716386884450912,
-0.2442651391029358,
-0.627030074596405,
0.5676199793815613,
0.09945958852767944,
1.184384822845459,
-0.711125910282135,
1.0248454809188843,
0.6655660271644592,
-0.5525768995285034,
-0.7110447883605957,
0.03763854131102562,
-0.4769566059112549,
-0.6347658634185791,
0.9588888883590698,
0.04959253594279289,
-0.27440184354782104,
0.2464236319065094,
-0.6156187653541565,
-0.7075999975204468,
0.7882243990898132,
0.14259642362594604,
-0.21834973990917206,
-0.49958258867263794,
0.5208078026771545,
0.6576939821243286,
-0.33302226662635803,
-0.029047943651676178,
0.27947449684143066,
0.38334399461746216,
-0.13339954614639282,
-1.0597658157348633,
0.020100414752960205,
-0.11064422875642776,
-0.32512906193733215,
0.051867928355932236,
-0.4260976016521454,
0.7144230604171753,
-0.1332085132598877,
-0.24669018387794495,
-0.10081574320793152,
0.8478479385375977,
-0.06334181874990463,
0.30166324973106384,
0.5734973549842834,
0.3291994035243988,
0.47734880447387695,
0.24683624505996704,
0.7896803617477417,
-0.510099470615387,
0.23589584231376648,
1.3040651082992554,
-0.15874086320400238,
0.9206442832946777,
0.4107973575592041,
0.10934112966060638,
0.5311468243598938,
0.4734538495540619,
0.024796731770038605,
0.5575243234634399,
0.1310129016637802,
-0.2685840427875519,
-0.4868808686733246,
-0.11770451068878174,
-0.3455491364002228,
0.44948670268058777,
0.3249114751815796,
-0.28052961826324463,
-0.5334004163742065,
0.018300632014870644,
-0.3316516578197479,
0.1772218942642212,
-0.6818999648094177,
0.722418487071991,
0.18334506452083588,
-0.9784976243972778,
0.8484673500061035,
-0.12747077643871307,
0.39983290433883667,
-0.7753614187240601,
0.06433269381523132,
-0.08440829068422318,
-0.08202002197504044,
-0.20938840508460999,
-0.8272584676742554,
0.18720053136348724,
0.14307397603988647,
-0.0995698869228363,
-0.030343072488904,
0.7352131009101868,
-1.0068813562393188,
-0.3275439143180847,
0.4335367679595947,
0.6988610625267029,
0.1530984342098236,
-0.00792531669139862,
-0.3586823046207428,
-0.6062188148498535,
-0.2444579303264618,
-0.1428430825471878,
0.3268803358078003,
0.7610623240470886,
-0.3403262495994568,
0.5857710838317871,
0.727521538734436,
-0.2444332242012024,
0.6557908654212952,
-0.2442825734615326,
1.0466299057006836,
-0.5060166120529175,
-0.531650722026825,
-0.46660053730010986,
0.16433081030845642,
-0.09939049929380417,
-0.24463430047035217,
1.0657745599746704,
0.5657265782356262,
1.5346484184265137,
-0.5077630281448364,
0.7265958786010742,
-0.07927041500806808,
0.5346726775169373,
-0.6055489778518677,
0.6224164366722107,
-0.6325942277908325,
-0.3713921308517456,
-0.04227658361196518,
-0.8591358065605164,
0.02230233885347843,
0.2545812726020813,
-0.4195369482040405,
-0.166173055768013,
0.6368458867073059,
0.9338679909706116,
-0.38984715938568115,
-0.10127567499876022,
0.27383166551589966,
0.1383940577507019,
-0.07854590564966202,
0.8069863319396973,
0.8673997521400452,
-0.1433827131986618,
0.9061781764030457,
-0.2692345678806305,
0.22309008240699768,
0.029694071039557457,
-0.4811561703681946,
-1.271700382232666,
-0.5966103076934814,
-0.027567801997065544,
-0.4048566222190857,
0.12299353629350662,
0.7737570405006409,
0.6000391244888306,
-1.0492093563079834,
-0.08255402743816376,
0.3253779411315918,
-0.05546421557664871,
-0.05418764427304268,
-0.19093886017799377,
0.5546552538871765,
-0.535287618637085,
-0.9436103701591492,
0.4415167570114136,
-0.05032540112733841,
-0.3745264410972595,
-0.5092655420303345,
-0.04387525096535683,
-0.3905384838581085,
0.047260966151952744,
0.5470854043960571,
0.4160720407962799,
-0.553267240524292,
-0.25097644329071045,
0.21580158174037933,
-0.2088553011417389,
-0.10537676513195038,
0.6341642141342163,
-0.5630090832710266,
0.531599760055542,
0.46482816338539124,
1.103163719177246,
0.8229868412017822,
0.2414139062166214,
0.5590339303016663,
-0.7669125199317932,
-0.17523939907550812,
0.07113679498434067,
0.17001374065876007,
0.14814764261245728,
-0.371834397315979,
0.467608243227005,
0.10024964064359665,
-0.3384326994419098,
-0.48727288842201233,
0.3921370208263397,
-0.7788386940956116,
-0.4640430212020874,
1.065536618232727,
-0.3352811336517334,
-0.5046495199203491,
-0.2335939258337021,
-0.18004444241523743,
0.4281904995441437,
0.2031409591436386,
0.5616809129714966,
0.5415549874305725,
0.2161530703306198,
-0.1560116559267044,
-0.5916177034378052,
0.3927381634712219,
0.2743872106075287,
-0.7600461840629578,
-0.04538904130458832,
0.6164429783821106,
0.6156578660011292,
0.22183004021644592,
0.5503005385398865,
-0.04186885803937912,
0.5147792100906372,
-0.033659402281045914,
0.14626716077327728,
-0.14409227669239044,
-0.48406916856765747,
0.10180439800024033,
0.40074172616004944,
-0.16674454510211945,
-0.21326830983161926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16499v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16499v1
|
LLMArena: Assessing Capabilities of Large Language Models in Dynamic Multi-Agent Environments
| 2024-02-26T11:31:48 | 2024-02-26T11:31:48 |
Junzhe Chen, Xuming Hu, Shuodi Liu, Shiyu Huang, Wei-Wei Tu, Zhaofeng He, Lijie Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have revealed their
potential for achieving autonomous agents possessing human-level intelligence.
However, existing benchmarks for evaluating LLM Agents either use static
datasets, potentially leading to data leakage or focus only on single-agent
scenarios, overlooking the complexities of multi-agent interactions. There is a
lack of a benchmark that evaluates the diverse capabilities of LLM agents in
multi-agent, dynamic environments. To this end, we introduce LLMArena, a novel
and easily extensible framework for evaluating the diverse capabilities of LLM
in multi-agent dynamic environments. LLMArena encompasses seven distinct gaming
environments, employing Trueskill scoring to assess crucial abilities in LLM
agents, including spatial reasoning, strategic planning, numerical reasoning,
risk assessment, communication, opponent modeling, and team collaboration. We
conduct an extensive experiment and human evaluation among different sizes and
types of LLMs, showing that LLMs still have a significant journey ahead in
their development towards becoming fully autonomous agents, especially in
opponent modeling and team collaboration. We hope LLMArena could guide future
research towards enhancing these capabilities in LLMs, ultimately leading to
more sophisticated and practical applications in dynamic, multi-agent settings.
The code and data will be available.
|
[
-0.2401634007692337,
-0.7933779358863831,
0.6918909549713135,
0.5535315871238708,
0.04108882322907448,
0.6128498911857605,
-0.3477764129638672,
-0.6351066827774048,
0.16097454726696014,
0.4364725649356842,
-0.43068620562553406,
-0.6954518556594849,
-0.39531221985816956,
0.11731550842523575,
-0.1900043934583664,
0.4881419241428375,
-0.028585195541381836,
-0.04195186495780945,
-0.23706138134002686,
-0.27378517389297485,
-0.4457758069038391,
-0.5581969022750854,
-0.5617750287055969,
-0.29735660552978516,
0.46261847019195557,
0.31889110803604126,
0.44537293910980225,
0.6172614097595215,
0.7107272148132324,
0.5542006492614746,
-0.01815827377140522,
0.32666724920272827,
-0.7354370951652527,
0.5512036681175232,
-0.2223537415266037,
-0.4066927433013916,
-0.6281917691230774,
-0.08877817541360855,
0.8144777417182922,
0.42914968729019165,
-0.25551629066467285,
0.2912311553955078,
-0.13813215494155884,
0.14109216630458832,
-0.5604990124702454,
0.2969849705696106,
-0.6443060636520386,
0.15967810153961182,
-0.10829394310712814,
-0.015150854364037514,
-0.1966782510280609,
-0.11871252208948135,
0.1302080899477005,
-0.7063329815864563,
-0.16660836338996887,
-0.08773194253444672,
0.40531960129737854,
0.43013763427734375,
-0.4892926514148712,
-0.27160751819610596,
-0.6886172890663147,
0.6858401298522949,
-0.6135355234146118,
0.2703506052494049,
-0.09683847427368164,
0.6131747364997864,
-0.40951842069625854,
-0.6187944412231445,
-0.5369716286659241,
-0.49337562918663025,
0.45273321866989136,
0.2617780864238739,
-0.2875198423862457,
0.06660117208957672,
0.2649487853050232,
-0.047792043536901474,
-0.37550899386405945,
0.41949278116226196,
-0.12866635620594025,
-0.13929416239261627,
0.8940192461013794,
0.528378963470459,
0.3291109800338745,
0.14898532629013062,
-0.43277519941329956,
-0.12372883409261703,
-0.39428019523620605,
0.18150770664215088,
0.4764961898326874,
0.4280779957771301,
-0.19379985332489014,
0.44991010427474976,
-0.2241579294204712,
0.45950978994369507,
-0.17858795821666718,
-0.3850111961364746,
0.3119563162326813,
-0.4121600389480591,
-0.03166965767741203,
-0.03406834229826927,
0.9442929029464722,
0.2461378276348114,
0.07652053982019424,
-0.4025217592716217,
-0.14159102737903595,
0.1441488415002823,
0.3286077082157135,
-0.6536331176757812,
-0.08442036062479019,
0.211877703666687,
-0.20138728618621826,
-0.5346618294715881,
-0.15193603932857513,
-1.2342814207077026,
-0.8051485419273376,
0.23926734924316406,
0.2306451052427292,
0.029619382694363594,
-0.4602416455745697,
0.18673133850097656,
0.046598706394433975,
0.17589238286018372,
0.3747960329055786,
-0.5904830694198608,
0.32068341970443726,
0.6788488030433655,
0.7917117476463318,
-0.6310371160507202,
-0.8044799566268921,
-0.6590539813041687,
0.004681257996708155,
-0.4484619200229645,
0.9057460427284241,
-0.5334497094154358,
-0.3670606315135956,
-0.022106608375906944,
-0.1564231514930725,
0.2038182020187378,
-0.49928227066993713,
0.5002244710922241,
-0.5083467960357666,
-0.3981912434101105,
-0.09717386960983276,
-0.2877921462059021,
-0.11996790021657944,
0.5011618137359619,
-0.8610866665840149,
0.87459397315979,
-0.12701646983623505,
-0.2696201801300049,
0.4009752571582794,
-0.7668801546096802,
-0.2743777930736542,
0.27211812138557434,
-0.15430866181850433,
-0.1384437084197998,
0.09164541959762573,
-0.16380518674850464,
0.25847163796424866,
-0.42498382925987244,
0.3297065794467926,
-0.5827687978744507,
-0.36866047978401184,
0.5228064060211182,
-0.5170457363128662,
0.5141804218292236,
-0.048381976783275604,
-0.42276716232299805,
0.4329146146774292,
-0.7269001603126526,
0.2888837158679962,
-0.045643601566553116,
-0.5175836086273193,
-0.0005706986412405968,
0.2802099287509918,
-0.03598490729928017,
0.39007988572120667,
0.4661834239959717,
-0.39898407459259033,
0.2934204041957855,
-0.23309531807899475,
0.2555345594882965,
0.6192108988761902,
-0.1344119757413864,
0.4335598349571228,
-0.13595956563949585,
0.6992924809455872,
-0.39573702216148376,
0.2250124216079712,
0.14052551984786987,
-0.4629875719547272,
-0.5658305287361145,
-0.6130951046943665,
0.16805578768253326,
0.7231302261352539,
-0.649561882019043,
0.39950090646743774,
-0.3373115062713623,
-0.8491823077201843,
-0.4220610558986664,
0.18133556842803955,
0.4399787187576294,
0.12221533805131912,
0.1784977912902832,
-0.1635676920413971,
-0.4620351791381836,
-0.6626831889152527,
-0.07374141365289688,
-0.4271804392337799,
0.09901061654090881,
0.31323716044425964,
0.5536410212516785,
-0.38363397121429443,
0.7699597477912903,
-0.02721993997693062,
-0.23949062824249268,
-0.4586011469364166,
-0.07286790013313293,
0.1320483386516571,
0.22587630152702332,
0.4160507619380951,
-0.6127674579620361,
-0.2400362640619278,
0.13587893545627594,
-1.04055655002594,
-0.403296560049057,
-0.000622284656856209,
-0.05924474447965622,
-0.2043544054031372,
0.36459389328956604,
-0.6148940324783325,
0.3873245418071747,
0.7968277335166931,
-0.46115532517433167,
0.6909491419792175,
-0.2419552057981491,
0.37153685092926025,
-0.7685232758522034,
0.06588485836982727,
-0.3783891201019287,
-0.29577773809432983,
-0.6523672938346863,
0.5066648125648499,
-0.2902905344963074,
0.13997524976730347,
-0.4739655554294586,
0.8231081366539001,
-0.505020022392273,
-0.35046932101249695,
-0.2681034803390503,
0.3088383972644806,
-0.13206812739372253,
0.23166514933109283,
-0.02993006631731987,
1.06178617477417,
0.5404080748558044,
-0.4329134225845337,
0.8858989477157593,
0.08947454392910004,
-0.5618674755096436,
0.2622385025024414,
-0.7614071369171143,
0.07841392606496811,
0.22016078233718872,
0.1496409773826599,
-0.9826894402503967,
-0.19808191061019897,
-0.03981871157884598,
-0.24286077916622162,
-0.23208756744861603,
-0.01103358156979084,
-0.6331409215927124,
-0.2395995557308197,
-0.29958322644233704,
0.3337176442146301,
0.31758996844291687,
-0.35159528255462646,
0.9950315356254578,
0.6782982349395752,
0.12746556103229523,
-0.5586249232292175,
-0.655849039554596,
0.44359347224235535,
-0.4779801666736603,
-0.5363751649856567,
0.21154814958572388,
-0.2667613625526428,
-0.6117327809333801,
-0.22005870938301086,
0.19034667313098907,
-0.33241403102874756,
0.4026489853858948,
0.34898409247398376,
0.10749775916337967,
-0.2493390142917633,
0.10431285947561264,
-0.22772084176540375,
-0.11583007127046585,
0.02796461246907711,
-0.013831223361194134,
0.48363813757896423,
-0.4516676366329193,
-0.3439532220363617,
-0.014813100919127464,
0.3193255066871643,
0.8049241304397583,
-0.32929694652557373,
0.7345962524414062,
0.4350344240665436,
-0.27862364053726196,
-0.38286399841308594,
-0.6549561023712158,
0.02708026021718979,
-0.49661993980407715,
0.7823184728622437,
-0.43148893117904663,
-0.930480420589447,
1.020052433013916,
-0.3089694678783417,
0.022649262100458145,
0.17716467380523682,
0.8355705142021179,
0.1749810129404068,
0.8692908883094788,
0.6941121816635132,
0.1450127214193344,
0.12545019388198853,
-0.00009173480066237971,
0.03257733955979347,
-0.6482950448989868,
-0.3391346335411072,
-0.34278881549835205,
-0.2718632221221924,
-0.5316174626350403,
-0.6443134546279907,
0.4257933497428894,
-0.11651525646448135,
-0.2129741609096527,
0.13356798887252808,
-0.12584485113620758,
0.8107966184616089,
0.022264689207077026,
-0.15899688005447388,
0.4263286292552948,
-0.22885052859783173,
-0.27094337344169617,
0.06458307057619095,
-0.5512365102767944,
-0.6559682488441467,
0.8821251392364502,
0.46957769989967346,
0.6242402791976929,
0.5587460398674011,
0.4808216989040375,
0.2959224581718445,
0.23603801429271698,
-0.7843491435050964,
0.781263530254364,
0.08322037011384964,
-0.6729207634925842,
-0.6322477459907532,
-0.6091699600219727,
-0.9443610310554504,
0.471527099609375,
-0.6050631999969482,
-0.8735466003417969,
0.0066482606343925,
-0.19944091141223907,
-0.5814335942268372,
0.34578588604927063,
-0.48190557956695557,
0.7907727956771851,
-0.5058651566505432,
-0.7407973408699036,
-0.15294693410396576,
-0.2546558976173401,
0.439663827419281,
-0.4080554246902466,
0.11014870554208755,
-0.4827939569950104,
-0.6189807653427124,
0.5816943049430847,
-0.048416923731565475,
0.7971020340919495,
0.01618337444961071,
-0.19043190777301788,
0.10935069620609283,
0.3608078956604004,
0.22832827270030975,
0.3032042980194092,
-0.4759827256202698,
0.30014386773109436,
0.0042236424051225185,
-0.2409730702638626,
-0.6374570727348328,
0.7878919243812561,
-0.8765884041786194,
-0.36921367049217224,
-0.5469306111335754,
-0.6132100224494934,
-0.540168046951294,
0.3067845106124878,
-0.009199249558150768,
0.21424932777881622,
-0.5289011597633362,
0.20086312294006348,
0.5449520945549011,
-0.220441073179245,
0.41495174169540405,
0.876350462436676,
-0.3448355495929718,
-0.23310865461826324,
0.6632741689682007,
0.03482063114643097,
-0.006049969233572483,
0.15586145222187042,
0.07367567718029022,
-0.39309632778167725,
-0.8237879276275635,
-0.3659481704235077,
0.02463834173977375,
-0.6646058559417725,
-0.18982543051242828,
-0.47126442193984985,
-0.0028771895449608564,
0.062321584671735764,
-0.033462293446063995,
-0.6778081059455872,
-0.015069110319018364,
-0.042870812118053436,
-0.15121112763881683,
0.14601066708564758,
1.0167522430419922,
-0.0538647435605526,
0.33393070101737976,
-0.6561776399612427,
-0.007657366804778576,
0.45384854078292847,
0.4833998680114746,
0.13829420506954193,
-0.1420382261276245,
-0.005657898262143135,
-0.17880961298942566,
0.10652525722980499,
-0.9450100064277649,
0.3573448359966278,
0.06508413702249527,
1.00300931930542,
0.14999011158943176,
-0.0545787438750267,
0.6164458394050598,
-0.5779089331626892,
0.768284797668457,
0.040731530636548996,
-0.9678298234939575,
0.023586835712194443,
-0.42521652579307556,
0.28946352005004883,
0.8205461502075195,
0.04121507331728935,
-0.29200509190559387,
-0.2166951447725296,
-0.25456035137176514,
-0.6912908554077148,
0.4412704408168793,
0.042357418686151505,
0.09080204367637634,
0.17255659401416779,
0.20459061861038208,
-0.034244563430547714,
0.2818044126033783,
-0.5849733948707581,
0.030910411849617958,
0.24834513664245605,
-0.12401405721902847,
-0.19353467226028442,
-0.24775995314121246,
-0.07788784056901932,
-0.04281473159790039,
0.24484644830226898,
-0.14539453387260437,
0.19212910532951355,
-0.0799848809838295,
-0.06668876856565475,
0.03041347861289978,
0.11886332929134369,
0.6545904278755188,
0.7994143962860107,
0.012174840085208416,
0.11025114357471466,
0.7281208634376526,
-0.45448383688926697,
0.4723633825778961,
0.04520779475569725,
0.28140684962272644,
-0.4433341324329376,
0.9037215709686279,
0.6011428833007812,
0.3906990885734558,
-1.1557811498641968,
0.595622718334198,
-0.4054824411869049,
-0.05565004050731659,
-0.29274696111679077,
0.24874545633792877,
0.1346588134765625,
0.7106282711029053,
0.32450243830680847,
-0.12392476946115494,
0.15381410717964172,
-0.5852088332176208,
0.2929806709289551,
0.295105904340744,
-0.4596102237701416,
-0.27903124690055847,
0.31910961866378784,
0.29507237672805786,
-0.2922261655330658,
0.3518899083137512,
-0.37210720777511597,
-0.4425402581691742,
0.7761226296424866,
0.4365096688270569,
0.8653545379638672,
-0.3848455548286438,
0.14824987947940826,
0.09533549100160599,
0.41063743829727173,
-0.07948549836874008,
0.1707032024860382,
0.16131797432899475,
-0.8194543719291687,
-0.5943698883056641,
-0.5559371709823608,
-0.41923439502716064,
-0.007297187112271786,
-0.17677167057991028,
0.03638698160648346,
-0.4993590712547302,
-0.4633295238018036,
-0.17283381521701813,
0.31029993295669556,
-0.5305098295211792,
-0.24586431682109833,
0.17055122554302216,
1.0322996377944946,
-0.5537010431289673,
0.72669917345047,
0.7403392791748047,
-0.16527391970157623,
-0.6703571677207947,
0.011266647838056087,
0.12497777491807938,
-0.7045488357543945,
0.6394833922386169,
-0.04158413037657738,
-0.6333103179931641,
-0.20648905634880066,
-0.4154786169528961,
-0.7946486473083496,
1.1158205270767212,
0.4493732452392578,
-0.5111984014511108,
-0.10715235024690628,
0.08015736937522888,
0.8206169605255127,
-0.6161091923713684,
0.5322161912918091,
0.5152802467346191,
0.561767578125,
0.06461700797080994,
-1.021671175956726,
-0.18639853596687317,
-0.413096159696579,
-0.1959795504808426,
-0.08636705577373505,
-0.8609297275543213,
0.8111735582351685,
-0.19705724716186523,
-0.08362957835197449,
0.1877497136592865,
0.6332083344459534,
0.4683276414871216,
0.14644348621368408,
0.563288152217865,
0.27760547399520874,
0.9152583479881287,
-0.023697512224316597,
0.8524711728096008,
-0.21276310086250305,
0.1570146530866623,
0.9103071689605713,
-0.8603997230529785,
0.9408870935440063,
0.033095065504312515,
-0.013197465799748898,
0.41123923659324646,
0.24713067710399628,
0.09128487855195999,
0.34637320041656494,
0.5014347434043884,
-0.3773694336414337,
-0.5370941162109375,
-0.18544374406337738,
-0.08840040862560272,
1.046695351600647,
0.380376935005188,
0.24290016293525696,
-0.24798065423965454,
0.061128027737140656,
0.015041420236229897,
0.2652840316295624,
-0.14012260735034943,
0.789395809173584,
-0.2235618680715561,
-0.40941742062568665,
0.28146398067474365,
-0.018692785874009132,
0.816501796245575,
-0.8499190211296082,
-0.1643756628036499,
-0.19356989860534668,
0.2691570520401001,
-0.012947375886142254,
-0.8837692737579346,
0.13036049902439117,
0.26795580983161926,
0.03654080629348755,
0.1162119135260582,
0.6522316932678223,
-0.40606480836868286,
-0.4381803870201111,
0.8093265295028687,
0.7355812788009644,
0.1075703576207161,
0.21958288550376892,
-0.7481476068496704,
0.687233567237854,
-0.2891947627067566,
-0.12982426583766937,
0.22163842618465424,
0.5430086255073547,
-0.05130310729146004,
1.038805365562439,
0.5789303183555603,
0.26037612557411194,
-0.011281121522188187,
-0.1875099539756775,
0.7527372241020203,
-0.4336037039756775,
-0.5564253330230713,
-0.9041787981987,
0.20101326704025269,
-0.28869667649269104,
-0.4704693555831909,
0.8957081437110901,
0.48173046112060547,
0.17939957976341248,
0.17123901844024658,
0.7187511920928955,
0.2847486138343811,
0.2867763936519623,
-0.40941116213798523,
1.0429922342300415,
-0.44977647066116333,
0.2514488697052002,
-0.2136671096086502,
-0.8705980181694031,
-0.2648172080516815,
0.6645593047142029,
-0.34817928075790405,
0.04611052945256233,
0.3674226701259613,
0.6710569262504578,
-0.03317314758896828,
-0.17920266091823578,
0.624550461769104,
0.2787972390651703,
0.5525500178337097,
0.7704282402992249,
1.2590241432189941,
-0.013991993851959705,
0.5070005059242249,
0.13389988243579865,
-0.5610312223434448,
-0.0392836257815361,
-1.1795655488967896,
-1.1262952089309692,
-0.4661458432674408,
-0.15472786128520966,
-0.19256320595741272,
0.2807385325431824,
1.0029728412628174,
0.8596436381340027,
-0.5787438750267029,
-0.6101750135421753,
0.3013964295387268,
0.1257011890411377,
-0.1584925800561905,
-0.144718736410141,
-0.06888312846422195,
-0.044208962470293045,
-0.5756234526634216,
0.9025251865386963,
0.3528740406036377,
-0.14788366854190826,
-0.6947190761566162,
-0.2216704785823822,
-0.08703216910362244,
0.27813780307769775,
0.5855302214622498,
0.2234109491109848,
-0.5471389889717102,
-0.08959249407052994,
0.09687182307243347,
-0.27671781182289124,
-0.24174843728542328,
0.5356621742248535,
-0.8380127549171448,
0.3567943274974823,
0.4780448079109192,
0.6855898499488831,
0.12840239703655243,
-0.23107050359249115,
0.5508049130439758,
-0.3092893064022064,
0.315960556268692,
0.3662809133529663,
0.09499122947454453,
0.24002976715564728,
-0.16227896511554718,
0.5450015068054199,
-0.10249870270490646,
-0.5506832599639893,
-0.9576644897460938,
0.0872645229101181,
-0.9267277717590332,
-0.096296027302742,
1.1119006872177124,
-0.258989542722702,
-0.28920772671699524,
-0.2602563500404358,
-0.05832625553011894,
-0.03427208587527275,
-0.5047398805618286,
0.7125464081764221,
0.7849639058113098,
0.08291980624198914,
-0.029034752398729324,
-0.8796494007110596,
0.48978638648986816,
-0.02137450873851776,
-1.0962499380111694,
0.17030736804008484,
0.4751738905906677,
0.030586756765842438,
0.3448328375816345,
0.6267257332801819,
0.01105784997344017,
0.24348632991313934,
0.15803059935569763,
0.03940218314528465,
-0.3394107222557068,
-0.5451953411102295,
-0.2942638695240021,
0.2988174259662628,
-0.00811159610748291,
0.14091020822525024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16482v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16482v1
|
On Languaging a Simulation Engine
| 2024-02-26T11:01:54 | 2024-02-26T11:01:54 |
Han Liu, Liantang Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL
|
Language model intelligence is revolutionizing the way we program materials
simulations. However, the diversity of simulation scenarios renders it
challenging to precisely transform human language into a tailored simulator.
Here, using three functionalized types of language model, we propose a
language-to-simulation (Lang2Sim) framework that enables interactive navigation
on languaging a simulation engine, by taking a scenario instance of water
sorption in porous matrices. Unlike line-by-line coding of a target simulator,
the language models interpret each simulator as an assembly of invariant tool
function and its variant input-output pair. Lang2Sim enables the precise
transform of textual description by functionalizing and sequentializing the
language models of, respectively, rationalizing the tool categorization,
customizing its input-output combinations, and distilling the simulator input
into executable format. Importantly, depending on its functionalized type, each
language model features a distinct processing of chat history to best balance
its memory limit and information completeness, thus leveraging the model
intelligence to unstructured nature of human request. Overall, this work
establishes language model as an intelligent platform to unlock the era of
languaging a simulation engine.
|
[
-0.12452565133571625,
-0.7581495046615601,
0.8392159938812256,
0.3172732889652252,
-0.0618051141500473,
0.1974904090166092,
-0.2519654929637909,
-0.08765817433595657,
-0.09869053214788437,
0.7249976992607117,
-0.30508336424827576,
-0.28220194578170776,
-0.31267184019088745,
-0.4808117747306824,
-0.3176705241203308,
0.6841603517532349,
-0.1389440894126892,
0.07685955613851547,
-0.2927705943584442,
0.12985099852085114,
-0.11963839828968048,
-0.5777600407600403,
-0.687484622001648,
-0.4785310924053192,
0.20484057068824768,
0.32047533988952637,
0.5879818201065063,
0.5280073881149292,
0.16524603962898254,
0.41044703125953674,
0.18476781249046326,
0.09841286391019821,
-0.5474926829338074,
0.050062984228134155,
-0.43945732712745667,
-0.8177621960639954,
-0.21783001720905304,
-0.09963154047727585,
0.8180586099624634,
0.5519763231277466,
-0.32883742451667786,
0.1915365308523178,
0.17814351618289948,
0.25376060605049133,
-0.4328044652938843,
0.5190362334251404,
-0.5186049938201904,
-0.19993901252746582,
-0.07026205956935883,
-0.5881047248840332,
-0.6359524130821228,
0.16770127415657043,
-0.14919598400592804,
-0.586132287979126,
-0.19439643621444702,
0.3392866849899292,
0.9828055500984192,
0.3226359486579895,
-0.04900459572672844,
-0.1027243435382843,
-1.2628803253173828,
0.9664965867996216,
-0.8203928470611572,
0.2792755663394928,
0.2805855870246887,
0.7940557599067688,
-0.34334099292755127,
-0.8775113224983215,
-0.577183723449707,
0.03770580142736435,
-0.05843031033873558,
0.11060436069965363,
0.16493399441242218,
0.15848173201084137,
0.0760417953133583,
-0.13552561402320862,
-0.5534491539001465,
0.037152986973524094,
-0.43822214007377625,
-0.06621028482913971,
0.6382450461387634,
0.09969083219766617,
0.6939772963523865,
0.1352982372045517,
-0.4191407561302185,
-0.2597006559371948,
-0.4843689799308777,
-0.0038270815275609493,
0.24302107095718384,
0.6049003005027771,
-0.06381937116384506,
0.6416262984275818,
0.012776093557476997,
0.38005730509757996,
-0.6642968654632568,
-0.2597852945327759,
-0.12068580836057663,
0.1269955039024353,
-0.38422855734825134,
0.20549681782722473,
0.7677825093269348,
0.186060830950737,
0.14704930782318115,
-0.37542998790740967,
-0.23958824574947357,
-0.15412098169326782,
0.25451958179473877,
-1.181480884552002,
-0.09636908769607544,
0.21856945753097534,
-0.4478795826435089,
-0.2120155394077301,
-0.15893758833408356,
-0.8202064633369446,
-0.4463581442832947,
-0.20566733181476593,
0.4838678538799286,
-0.35203251242637634,
-0.5627124309539795,
0.5073037147521973,
-0.09515540301799774,
0.061088234186172485,
0.33613264560699463,
-0.8359200358390808,
0.6707108020782471,
0.6874316334724426,
0.7527867555618286,
0.10486768186092377,
-0.19282639026641846,
-0.45302730798721313,
0.6146241426467896,
-0.09794815629720688,
0.7141144275665283,
-0.8691689968109131,
-0.7655662894248962,
-0.29425638914108276,
-0.1399647444486618,
-0.1954973340034485,
-0.4456072747707367,
-0.029441773891448975,
-0.5121515393257141,
0.20247647166252136,
0.10729917883872986,
-0.46899574995040894,
-0.6384870409965515,
0.2617497146129608,
-0.5607770085334778,
1.0004122257232666,
0.08287052810192108,
-0.45887863636016846,
-0.21677124500274658,
-0.6467694044113159,
-0.11545827984809875,
0.1973552107810974,
-0.5252101421356201,
-0.2579404413700104,
-0.08948858827352524,
-0.4716704785823822,
0.18743586540222168,
-0.661273181438446,
0.6242390871047974,
-0.324066698551178,
-0.46531325578689575,
0.3040919303894043,
-0.2601110339164734,
0.4424227476119995,
0.20140333473682404,
-0.4435567557811737,
-0.056513380259275436,
-0.36758285760879517,
0.07954774051904678,
0.12051496654748917,
-0.3901480436325073,
-0.2924906313419342,
0.44428691267967224,
0.33356812596321106,
0.16998901963233948,
0.10819970816373825,
-0.41250112652778625,
0.29548394680023193,
-0.5329499244689941,
0.4405215382575989,
0.3655029833316803,
0.03734198957681656,
0.72803795337677,
-0.23574644327163696,
0.5754009485244751,
-0.17767679691314697,
-0.24979816377162933,
-0.1349666714668274,
-0.5534490346908569,
-0.8374671936035156,
-0.23361127078533173,
0.3043438792228699,
0.8693817257881165,
-0.7745082974433899,
-0.2534801959991455,
-0.5033615827560425,
-0.6228504180908203,
-0.33442869782447815,
0.0032677706331014633,
0.3630025386810303,
0.27182120084762573,
0.39570143818855286,
0.04303944483399391,
-0.537594735622406,
-0.7523314356803894,
-0.31172701716423035,
-0.7017149925231934,
-0.1642521768808365,
0.6948139071464539,
0.27350419759750366,
-0.39459681510925293,
1.1955264806747437,
-0.28155168890953064,
-0.10573681443929672,
-0.4104243516921997,
0.483540803194046,
-0.1481252908706665,
0.5932446718215942,
0.6515877842903137,
-0.8623871207237244,
-0.2556559145450592,
0.29687097668647766,
-0.6851606369018555,
-0.06649565696716309,
-0.21900905668735504,
-0.38958168029785156,
0.007185199297964573,
0.7984833717346191,
-0.3747032582759857,
0.28213226795196533,
0.6103280782699585,
0.0787043645977974,
0.19627046585083008,
-0.22233733534812927,
0.12046536058187485,
-1.144679307937622,
0.43221181631088257,
-0.2985304892063141,
0.02413114160299301,
-0.5761709809303284,
0.2947429418563843,
-0.1806749850511551,
-0.3863293528556824,
-0.5471715331077576,
1.179508090019226,
-0.4503415822982788,
-0.26658129692077637,
-0.14780811965465546,
0.0569629967212677,
0.0723147764801979,
0.44211331009864807,
0.10973663628101349,
0.8270223736763,
0.5366024374961853,
-0.6202145218849182,
0.14619985222816467,
-0.25134795904159546,
-0.16947656869888306,
-0.1808411329984665,
-0.376049280166626,
-0.03409960865974426,
-0.14628858864307404,
0.007009963970631361,
-0.9886002540588379,
-0.22927486896514893,
0.0457158237695694,
-0.22468923032283783,
0.6162749528884888,
-0.2836454212665558,
-0.8602961897850037,
-0.08169598877429962,
0.05436126887798309,
0.5068300366401672,
0.7400846481323242,
-0.14800907671451569,
1.4149181842803955,
0.4345996379852295,
-0.5198137760162354,
-0.0606912337243557,
-0.8194590210914612,
0.08691432327032089,
-0.33550843596458435,
-0.5316741466522217,
0.3321443498134613,
-0.22313226759433746,
-0.30198994278907776,
-0.13235227763652802,
0.04515175521373749,
-0.3714180290699005,
0.26982393860816956,
0.29040801525115967,
0.22204656898975372,
-0.1857193112373352,
0.012181765399873257,
0.3392704129219055,
-0.06399048119783401,
0.26436880230903625,
-0.1618899703025818,
0.8399134874343872,
-0.15414726734161377,
-0.4612247943878174,
-0.18394964933395386,
0.1855221390724182,
0.7370213866233826,
-0.30927973985671997,
0.4272383153438568,
0.1491622030735016,
-0.6985560059547424,
-0.2709370255470276,
-0.4017302989959717,
-0.3123970925807953,
-0.5827949047088623,
0.4302383065223694,
-0.5203458666801453,
-0.7240733504295349,
0.5652462244033813,
-0.5944070219993591,
0.22016431391239166,
-0.026370618492364883,
0.37888601422309875,
-0.17613323032855988,
1.2949002981185913,
0.614008903503418,
0.07335957884788513,
0.15194465219974518,
-0.25425708293914795,
0.6765638589859009,
-0.4344511330127716,
-0.49232029914855957,
-0.5205503106117249,
-0.4319588840007782,
-0.2717849612236023,
-0.8555830121040344,
0.2531440258026123,
0.2902015149593353,
-0.11410245299339294,
0.14446966350078583,
-0.11414345353841782,
0.28215786814689636,
0.061306994408369064,
-0.12964442372322083,
0.041433703154325485,
0.26417601108551025,
-0.42225122451782227,
-0.10959333181381226,
-0.8697530627250671,
-0.885307788848877,
0.38787442445755005,
0.5667657852172852,
0.9302645921707153,
0.14823514223098755,
0.7869558334350586,
-0.07269389927387238,
0.6562422513961792,
-0.7703052759170532,
0.9624866247177124,
-0.07074970006942749,
-0.6088101863861084,
-0.36827465891838074,
-0.23748032748699188,
-0.688812255859375,
0.05103927478194237,
0.20773804187774658,
-0.8385137319564819,
0.02839449793100357,
0.19600464403629303,
-0.49827542901039124,
0.6005174517631531,
-0.8600353002548218,
0.8167023658752441,
-0.47382721304893494,
-0.5893972516059875,
-0.2959716320037842,
-0.4133753776550293,
0.2902750074863434,
0.10297131538391113,
0.7440563440322876,
-0.28274005651474,
-0.15824808180332184,
0.274270623922348,
-0.29828280210494995,
0.8312220573425293,
-0.22110974788665771,
-0.13271088898181915,
0.5597511529922485,
0.7703220248222351,
0.1699841469526291,
0.043125782161951065,
-0.28296926617622375,
-0.07533980160951614,
-0.1276654303073883,
-0.24873526394367218,
-0.6937947273254395,
0.6935323476791382,
-0.6281257271766663,
-0.6052895784378052,
-0.15001216530799866,
-0.5080017447471619,
-0.17290669679641724,
0.27355632185935974,
-0.18234337866306305,
0.3630198836326599,
-0.348594069480896,
-0.08112651109695435,
0.5341132283210754,
-0.3730255961418152,
0.5083364844322205,
0.6480521559715271,
-0.6899946331977844,
0.31567272543907166,
1.4666284322738647,
0.08725009113550186,
0.07167758047580719,
0.5797173380851746,
0.023975521326065063,
-0.24565932154655457,
-0.15021367371082306,
-0.7448360323905945,
0.24258948862552643,
-0.4619896709918976,
-0.2038041204214096,
-0.7898852229118347,
-0.6210346221923828,
-0.03528990596532822,
-0.30400389432907104,
-0.6581889986991882,
-0.07963588088750839,
-0.31043630838394165,
-0.02463790774345398,
0.2814090847969055,
0.4527699649333954,
0.277291476726532,
0.21321113407611847,
-0.9537070393562317,
0.06875357776880264,
0.41192927956581116,
0.4707782566547394,
-0.14802728593349457,
-0.39163634181022644,
-0.09019991755485535,
0.37589868903160095,
0.14842535555362701,
-0.6560643315315247,
0.4780275225639343,
0.32734358310699463,
0.46463873982429504,
0.39832279086112976,
-0.1825776994228363,
0.6298778653144836,
-0.6740276217460632,
0.6625801920890808,
-0.17082004249095917,
-0.7568525671958923,
0.5091778039932251,
-0.43966183066368103,
0.06244311481714249,
0.3418712913990021,
0.2309873402118683,
-0.4240972399711609,
-0.362819105386734,
-0.4901401698589325,
-0.7082458138465881,
0.7291026711463928,
0.17478324472904205,
0.13924016058444977,
0.01272993441671133,
0.224026620388031,
-0.11841119080781937,
0.1341228187084198,
-0.4082808792591095,
0.005947840865701437,
-0.12790091335773468,
-0.04285319894552231,
0.10858199745416641,
-0.3421754240989685,
-0.07402102649211884,
0.06771637499332428,
0.9011637568473816,
-0.19068419933319092,
0.12957718968391418,
-0.24670115113258362,
-0.1945285201072693,
0.07762457430362701,
0.27823778986930847,
0.4984866976737976,
0.1307155191898346,
-0.22029727697372437,
0.2802221179008484,
0.13096825778484344,
-0.2834078371524811,
0.08957419544458389,
0.13648131489753723,
-0.16439320147037506,
-0.03407958894968033,
-0.11546870321035385,
0.8699372410774231,
0.6539374589920044,
-1.1056910753250122,
0.23593908548355103,
-0.19485098123550415,
-0.07102558016777039,
-0.10700175166130066,
0.4381042420864105,
0.42724844813346863,
0.23808306455612183,
0.18368566036224365,
0.07354982942342758,
0.5064032077789307,
-0.6648824214935303,
-0.11719045042991638,
0.2331038862466812,
-0.3510701358318329,
-0.3485352396965027,
0.8088232278823853,
0.26808464527130127,
-0.4344863295555115,
0.44517582654953003,
-0.457391619682312,
-0.5661333203315735,
0.6380575895309448,
0.46345630288124084,
0.7135639786720276,
-0.536816418170929,
0.15097467601299286,
0.49472564458847046,
0.2468450367450714,
-0.34830859303474426,
0.4960915148258209,
0.07194641977548599,
-0.7391486763954163,
-0.2872548997402191,
-0.7805350422859192,
-0.28075870871543884,
0.18431630730628967,
-0.5340062975883484,
0.41583383083343506,
-0.47565820813179016,
-0.022110778838396072,
-0.33373430371284485,
-0.2499617040157318,
-0.4407442510128021,
0.22204984724521637,
0.25502994656562805,
0.9223878383636475,
-0.915752649307251,
0.9261149168014526,
1.093826413154602,
-0.22707612812519073,
-0.8280184864997864,
-0.3415055572986603,
-0.1275268942117691,
-0.7066823244094849,
0.47202548384666443,
0.2763470709323883,
-0.473489910364151,
0.4015587270259857,
-0.5968905687332153,
-0.9329093098640442,
1.2591049671173096,
0.5474408864974976,
-0.45019254088401794,
-0.22491808235645294,
0.31721392273902893,
0.5045151114463806,
-0.3748001158237457,
0.32591772079467773,
0.5757169723510742,
0.5092551112174988,
-0.06118849664926529,
-0.9894185066223145,
-0.08591736108064651,
-0.7105422019958496,
0.548068106174469,
-0.002574001206085086,
-0.7250646352767944,
0.5957881212234497,
-0.19550110399723053,
-0.6833393573760986,
0.40138372778892517,
0.4488043487071991,
0.5883392691612244,
0.0698452815413475,
0.5205116868019104,
0.35551297664642334,
0.4104628264904022,
-0.12346819043159485,
1.077810525894165,
-0.5360276699066162,
0.2052781730890274,
1.1227434873580933,
-0.752193033695221,
0.9321448802947998,
0.5650653839111328,
0.0219611506909132,
0.7415745854377747,
0.5080317258834839,
0.29431623220443726,
0.5019088387489319,
0.3841328024864197,
-0.4464772343635559,
-0.382313996553421,
-0.3140796720981598,
-0.2348364293575287,
0.47942960262298584,
0.8031639456748962,
0.07861920446157455,
-0.41976308822631836,
0.140085831284523,
0.09203609079122543,
0.25012773275375366,
-0.11223071813583374,
0.634024441242218,
-0.06162300705909729,
-0.6580238342285156,
0.21492373943328857,
0.5599678158760071,
0.23086553812026978,
-0.6541097164154053,
-0.3293922245502472,
-0.07637742906808853,
-0.017009304836392403,
0.028878910467028618,
-0.615224301815033,
0.1976470947265625,
-0.1872902363538742,
-0.22384794056415558,
-0.5640591382980347,
0.8617827296257019,
-0.7174408435821533,
-0.30017733573913574,
0.5006014108657837,
0.41504982113838196,
0.5300071835517883,
-0.045682262629270554,
-0.5661795735359192,
0.24932947754859924,
-0.024609893560409546,
-0.34437572956085205,
0.33023881912231445,
0.5979426503181458,
-0.3080385625362396,
0.9556012749671936,
0.5790473222732544,
-0.09521988034248352,
0.03842638432979584,
0.30855581164360046,
1.0562294721603394,
-0.30137816071510315,
-0.6138493418693542,
-0.5840758681297302,
0.736707866191864,
-0.020505081862211227,
0.3386116325855255,
0.4634929597377777,
1.0450196266174316,
0.5846464037895203,
-0.09569785743951797,
0.8116918206214905,
0.08290081471204758,
0.4553074240684509,
-0.4200647175312042,
1.0573030710220337,
-0.632632851600647,
0.47099292278289795,
0.2033766210079193,
-0.8229545950889587,
-0.02105848677456379,
0.7816471457481384,
-0.06640956550836563,
0.15643395483493805,
0.5260053873062134,
1.1221667528152466,
-0.3319931924343109,
-0.18054673075675964,
0.19224616885185242,
0.4434894025325775,
0.3540034890174866,
0.07585583627223969,
0.442103773355484,
-0.3119083046913147,
0.46872469782829285,
-0.13402943313121796,
-0.19437535107135773,
-0.48032209277153015,
-0.8091431260108948,
-0.7832219004631042,
-0.497620165348053,
-0.17369185388088226,
-0.29473596811294556,
-0.0143659096211195,
0.6182260513305664,
0.8764321208000183,
-0.5958687663078308,
-0.8127159476280212,
-0.20681630074977875,
-0.14861616492271423,
0.09944304823875427,
-0.26125437021255493,
-0.2635190188884735,
-0.3005138039588928,
-0.8581370115280151,
0.5900423526763916,
0.7405666708946228,
0.24564647674560547,
-0.5404459834098816,
-0.28511136770248413,
-0.0923735648393631,
0.3496217429637909,
0.4419867992401123,
0.59674072265625,
-0.5577533841133118,
-0.1276240199804306,
0.121427983045578,
-0.45910224318504333,
-0.21869568526744843,
0.8664688467979431,
-0.8680270314216614,
0.773109495639801,
0.42068246006965637,
0.7809312343597412,
0.8756359815597534,
-0.22767916321754456,
0.8187769651412964,
-0.8194231390953064,
0.46559906005859375,
0.3501429557800293,
0.3919442892074585,
0.1803411990404129,
-0.30592426657676697,
0.43411046266555786,
0.07623280584812164,
-0.13258199393749237,
-1.0345945358276367,
0.2150018960237503,
-0.8305000066757202,
-0.42751553654670715,
1.2862346172332764,
-0.1086878702044487,
-0.33369502425193787,
0.01866636984050274,
-0.4297589957714081,
0.2818867564201355,
-0.27033841609954834,
0.6919548511505127,
0.6591967344284058,
0.01678040251135826,
-0.22941143810749054,
-0.7279808521270752,
0.397489994764328,
0.4001859128475189,
-1.0328788757324219,
-0.07854071259498596,
0.19375577569007874,
0.22830736637115479,
0.26229238510131836,
0.7223522067070007,
-0.03283188119530678,
0.1356326788663864,
-0.022930718958377838,
0.3927609622478485,
0.14321891963481903,
-0.5197480916976929,
0.19792698323726654,
-0.1487809270620346,
0.10428255051374435,
0.301286518573761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16472v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16472v2
|
mEdIT: Multilingual Text Editing via Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-26T10:33:36 | 2024-04-17T16:59:30 |
Vipul Raheja, Dimitris Alikaniotis, Vivek Kulkarni, Bashar Alhafni, Dhruv Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
We introduce mEdIT, a multi-lingual extension to CoEdIT -- the recent
state-of-the-art text editing models for writing assistance. mEdIT models are
trained by fine-tuning multi-lingual large, pre-trained language models (LLMs)
via instruction tuning. They are designed to take instructions from the user
specifying the attributes of the desired text in the form of natural language
instructions, such as Grammatik korrigieren (German) or Parafrasee la oraci\'on
(Spanish). We build mEdIT by curating data from multiple publicly available
human-annotated text editing datasets for three text editing tasks (Grammatical
Error Correction (GEC), Text Simplification, and Paraphrasing) across diverse
languages belonging to six different language families. We detail the design
and training of mEdIT models and demonstrate their strong performance on many
multi-lingual text editing benchmarks against other multilingual LLMs. We also
find that mEdIT generalizes effectively to new languages over multilingual
baselines. We publicly release our data, code, and trained models at
https://github.com/vipulraheja/medit.
|
[
-0.04025280475616455,
-0.6803895235061646,
0.5301384925842285,
0.21144917607307434,
0.05272641032934189,
0.14401625096797943,
-0.6335690021514893,
-0.4495793879032135,
0.07770868390798569,
0.5268990397453308,
-0.8665928840637207,
-0.8027724027633667,
-0.4641048014163971,
0.439100980758667,
0.13191664218902588,
1.2482357025146484,
-0.3957194983959198,
0.6126512289047241,
-0.0813247486948967,
-0.2399304360151291,
-0.5029621720314026,
-0.5742648243904114,
-0.7222175002098083,
-0.14243696630001068,
0.7396096587181091,
0.8457496762275696,
0.5121792554855347,
0.5510017275810242,
0.7601678371429443,
0.35154107213020325,
0.16580408811569214,
0.5514329671859741,
-0.41394761204719543,
-0.14566734433174133,
-0.1678626388311386,
-0.4134175181388855,
-0.864197850227356,
0.15635284781455994,
0.5356712937355042,
0.5682470202445984,
-0.02192220836877823,
0.11859352141618729,
-0.13361872732639313,
0.700069785118103,
-0.47560635209083557,
-0.09774487465620041,
-0.37384602427482605,
-0.10092341154813766,
-0.03310587257146835,
-0.2552427649497986,
-0.65009605884552,
-0.4868144094944,
-0.21960234642028809,
-0.8628650307655334,
0.22274848818778992,
0.02560599334537983,
0.7945308685302734,
0.4125615358352661,
-0.29112738370895386,
-0.28902938961982727,
-0.4771820306777954,
0.6145966649055481,
-0.5237507820129395,
0.4153982102870941,
0.5590660572052002,
-0.06675747781991959,
-0.1292571723461151,
-0.6138268113136292,
-0.18885834515094757,
-0.1636408120393753,
-0.11400427669286728,
0.2486674040555954,
0.01032582949846983,
0.4868663251399994,
0.07078354805707932,
0.46590349078178406,
-0.495187908411026,
0.24926094710826874,
-0.36300402879714966,
-0.09884107112884521,
0.412300705909729,
0.04854244366288185,
0.5854436159133911,
0.14466431736946106,
-0.17440064251422882,
0.16450658440589905,
-0.6045305132865906,
-0.15131835639476776,
0.5243281126022339,
0.09036897122859955,
-0.3276718258857727,
0.7996008396148682,
-0.008134536445140839,
0.8280026316642761,
0.09191177040338516,
0.11658194661140442,
0.14005348086357117,
-0.28612634539604187,
-0.2983052432537079,
0.012361650355160236,
0.8059108853340149,
0.6404348015785217,
0.48875692486763,
-0.3781934976577759,
-0.0880298912525177,
0.1339801847934723,
0.18030110001564026,
-0.7121375799179077,
-0.4160338044166565,
-0.060512591153383255,
-0.3605811297893524,
-0.3856702446937561,
-0.08335287123918533,
-0.7716466188430786,
-0.45318081974983215,
-0.4534234404563904,
0.32319149374961853,
-0.4879680871963501,
-0.0577922984957695,
0.47142279148101807,
0.06594465672969818,
-0.07995616644620895,
0.20877835154533386,
-0.9855174422264099,
0.4305087924003601,
0.6904098987579346,
0.7122719287872314,
-0.24822759628295898,
-0.7297523617744446,
-0.6741661429405212,
-0.015423883683979511,
-0.2869482934474945,
1.026658535003662,
-0.831514835357666,
-0.40995272994041443,
-0.15604977309703827,
0.22972437739372253,
-0.30728501081466675,
-0.2786054313182831,
0.7126784920692444,
-0.3915829658508301,
0.5280009508132935,
-0.01849321834743023,
-0.703166663646698,
-0.04136393591761589,
0.14597183465957642,
-0.8444178700447083,
1.1320558786392212,
0.23582294583320618,
-0.8264838457107544,
0.29826125502586365,
-1.2415893077850342,
-0.6377266049385071,
-0.17427419126033783,
0.08112610131502151,
-0.337242990732193,
0.2525261640548706,
0.44348305463790894,
0.38190335035324097,
-0.26847511529922485,
0.10643915832042694,
0.07600639015436172,
-0.24564754962921143,
0.10476875305175781,
-0.4397512972354889,
0.5939626097679138,
-0.011310633271932602,
0.021128619089722633,
0.3566901683807373,
-0.9980719089508057,
0.007761448621749878,
-0.27219200134277344,
-0.7049905061721802,
-0.34531667828559875,
-0.2903798818588257,
0.5785236954689026,
0.2743895947933197,
0.1611686646938324,
-0.792363166809082,
0.5901585817337036,
-0.4480452239513397,
0.47917670011520386,
0.6632093787193298,
0.09618444740772247,
0.44791895151138306,
-0.4521329998970032,
0.9000582695007324,
-0.3161937892436981,
0.36382508277893066,
-0.19271577894687653,
-0.3666192591190338,
-0.636705219745636,
-0.4986494183540344,
0.5850859880447388,
0.8738698363304138,
-0.6746845841407776,
-0.0260572861880064,
-0.1670740693807602,
-0.30463775992393494,
-0.9558138847351074,
0.41356170177459717,
0.44052577018737793,
0.4515490233898163,
0.2951943576335907,
0.24830137193202972,
-0.6773861646652222,
-0.8008915185928345,
-0.4755156338214874,
0.14870180189609528,
0.22282561659812927,
-0.05076180770993233,
0.42690524458885193,
-0.4979425370693207,
0.5798282027244568,
-0.2598525583744049,
-0.18774381279945374,
-0.35752394795417786,
0.21567009389400482,
0.0515880361199379,
0.5731359124183655,
0.5087605714797974,
-0.7479208111763,
-0.6031867861747742,
0.2983959913253784,
-0.5069659352302551,
-0.43224847316741943,
-0.3233487606048584,
-0.41457104682922363,
0.2983287572860718,
0.6930766701698303,
-0.4185985028743744,
0.0976250171661377,
0.9222817420959473,
-0.4944167733192444,
0.5973320603370667,
-0.5378013849258423,
0.537327766418457,
-1.5551602840423584,
0.04811609163880348,
-0.15478815138339996,
-0.32671383023262024,
-0.5602785348892212,
0.12219962477684021,
0.4911114573478699,
-0.0571395568549633,
-0.3455352783203125,
0.5140038728713989,
-0.544696033000946,
0.5106436610221863,
-0.22143492102622986,
-0.10324951261281967,
0.14021237194538116,
0.588287889957428,
-0.07479250431060791,
0.9769253730773926,
0.25293996930122375,
-0.29441046714782715,
0.4079076945781708,
0.21137703955173492,
-0.1870950311422348,
0.7509547472000122,
-0.5105723142623901,
0.22271005809307098,
0.05319451168179512,
-0.16860127449035645,
-0.7735019326210022,
-0.4421056807041168,
0.10315613448619843,
-0.31135597825050354,
0.44245949387550354,
-0.24463951587677002,
-0.6434510350227356,
-0.04331950843334198,
-0.31957706809043884,
0.3457772135734558,
-0.01640099659562111,
-0.5700657963752747,
0.7225612998008728,
0.2132670283317566,
-0.37959712743759155,
-0.4981316030025482,
-0.6303234100341797,
0.16776828467845917,
-0.07390616089105606,
-0.6071748733520508,
0.2633182406425476,
-0.3879620134830475,
-0.07094172388315201,
-0.013353708200156689,
0.2388477623462677,
-0.3597061038017273,
-0.013378432020545006,
0.31600067019462585,
0.6217725872993469,
-0.1912722885608673,
0.39734533429145813,
0.44933485984802246,
-0.37369680404663086,
-0.16336330771446228,
-0.03743351250886917,
0.20871850848197937,
-0.1495133340358734,
-0.33768120408058167,
-0.4819115698337555,
0.6834085583686829,
0.7764254212379456,
-0.5711226463317871,
0.44184938073158264,
0.6038698554039001,
-0.42091670632362366,
0.18870583176612854,
-0.7751533389091492,
0.051635369658470154,
-0.4518762528896332,
0.5833798050880432,
-0.4491593539714813,
-0.9488529562950134,
0.38606593012809753,
-0.3535316288471222,
0.43962323665618896,
0.3837801516056061,
0.4753267467021942,
-0.045945942401885986,
1.042075276374817,
1.1536929607391357,
-0.10274502635002136,
0.5789192914962769,
0.01638639345765114,
-0.1657673418521881,
-0.6536391973495483,
0.10324124991893768,
-0.4238949120044708,
-0.40082111954689026,
-0.6891880631446838,
-0.3213340640068054,
0.36297884583473206,
-0.1620836853981018,
0.036410633474588394,
-0.010277882218360901,
-0.43568405508995056,
0.917826235294342,
0.5418307185173035,
0.16648444533348083,
0.39038676023483276,
0.014049574732780457,
-0.30851733684539795,
-0.28910624980926514,
-0.899277925491333,
-0.4733683466911316,
1.0504670143127441,
0.16728228330612183,
0.9939318299293518,
-0.24446390569210052,
0.5837743282318115,
0.10188589990139008,
0.5896428227424622,
-0.6745855212211609,
0.18323001265525818,
-0.5197171568870544,
-0.44507551193237305,
-0.006006290204823017,
-0.27099478244781494,
-0.6148155927658081,
-0.05396849662065506,
-0.4403603672981262,
-0.33694693446159363,
0.03589097410440445,
0.38826945424079895,
-0.36417898535728455,
0.40083324909210205,
-1.1517776250839233,
1.1459029912948608,
-0.31315597891807556,
-0.3975398540496826,
-0.28342336416244507,
-0.5789293050765991,
0.04017094150185585,
-0.1026558130979538,
0.3463970124721527,
0.07446445524692535,
-0.16344451904296875,
0.6785545945167542,
-0.36337459087371826,
0.8828395009040833,
0.03337009623646736,
-0.0354066826403141,
-0.20827369391918182,
0.15407657623291016,
0.3736768364906311,
0.17713530361652374,
-0.15314295887947083,
0.01557366643100977,
0.07117215543985367,
-0.26841631531715393,
-0.5365332961082458,
0.7131546139717102,
-0.6053150296211243,
-0.11044491827487946,
-0.19206102192401886,
-0.7791178226470947,
-0.3306809961795807,
0.2762240171432495,
0.5239546895027161,
0.5839606523513794,
-0.4531283676624298,
-0.06253941357135773,
0.5323147773742676,
-0.33199402689933777,
0.18009693920612335,
0.5739296078681946,
-0.1415969580411911,
-0.5652812123298645,
0.7048326730728149,
-0.2023405283689499,
0.291210800409317,
0.5111740231513977,
0.23939959704875946,
0.0822511613368988,
-0.1628578007221222,
-0.7550879120826721,
0.4839099645614624,
-0.7395672798156738,
-0.181492879986763,
-0.5452314615249634,
-0.08963252604007721,
-0.09899958968162537,
-0.4548755884170532,
-0.4544883370399475,
-0.505365788936615,
-0.09790647774934769,
-0.22760656476020813,
0.724237859249115,
1.0299392938613892,
-0.17146067321300507,
0.5779985785484314,
-0.7690009474754333,
0.49427857995033264,
-0.06943047791719437,
0.7724347114562988,
-0.7804404497146606,
-0.273847758769989,
-0.5943694114685059,
0.01195549312978983,
-0.04646557569503784,
-0.9188340306282043,
0.04297969862818718,
0.4409884810447693,
0.32096385955810547,
-0.042728669941425323,
-0.33596086502075195,
0.6702051758766174,
-0.9410435557365417,
0.43575620651245117,
0.04130283743143082,
-0.8051201701164246,
0.5818434953689575,
-0.280372679233551,
0.5529702305793762,
0.835996150970459,
0.14232420921325684,
-1.0661815404891968,
-0.5529667735099792,
-0.2688464820384979,
-0.4553598165512085,
0.675775408744812,
-0.24965639412403107,
0.18534807860851288,
0.13311146199703217,
0.5500321388244629,
0.34419143199920654,
0.17486776411533356,
-0.6553022861480713,
-0.07479062676429749,
0.014318079687654972,
-0.763705849647522,
0.004337298218160868,
-0.5083839297294617,
-0.10628443956375122,
-0.4300915598869324,
0.7870500683784485,
-0.00559011148288846,
0.07702967524528503,
0.2575296461582184,
-0.273720383644104,
-0.29535728693008423,
0.5320727825164795,
0.8551647067070007,
0.7051928043365479,
-0.020433655008673668,
-0.04566445201635361,
0.20787988603115082,
-0.9452131390571594,
0.07594257593154907,
0.25857892632484436,
0.01679590344429016,
0.15961900353431702,
0.3963624835014343,
0.706721842288971,
0.6284070611000061,
-0.5764620900154114,
0.3402485251426697,
-0.4540892243385315,
-0.43017494678497314,
0.028044451028108597,
-0.08882788568735123,
0.0027998255100101233,
0.003927876241505146,
-0.29001811146736145,
0.3011334240436554,
0.08293595165014267,
0.06724758446216583,
0.02608763799071312,
0.04534241557121277,
-0.2936396896839142,
-0.32164278626441956,
0.7608063817024231,
0.354562908411026,
-0.44054871797561646,
0.46824419498443604,
0.009172002784907818,
-0.48537036776542664,
0.24443146586418152,
0.44234445691108704,
0.8962315917015076,
-0.46803414821624756,
0.17237162590026855,
0.22505202889442444,
0.6690354347229004,
0.01157743576914072,
0.5102596282958984,
0.3081050217151642,
-0.49790439009666443,
-0.7069475650787354,
-0.4374392628669739,
-0.520026683807373,
0.1174626424908638,
-0.582096517086029,
0.3971761465072632,
-0.2546113431453705,
-0.0892985537648201,
0.013601448386907578,
-0.19109603762626648,
-0.6496723890304565,
0.028075002133846283,
-0.22281084954738617,
1.0753461122512817,
-0.9258542060852051,
0.7002286314964294,
1.2847322225570679,
-0.15430083870887756,
-0.6917267441749573,
-0.3263545334339142,
-0.05320347473025322,
-0.6363911032676697,
0.12470986694097519,
0.08787686377763748,
-0.39159759879112244,
0.05642231926321983,
-0.604563295841217,
-0.3496917188167572,
0.5819427967071533,
0.6743632555007935,
-0.6410714983940125,
-0.20796604454517365,
0.09070777893066406,
0.49726179242134094,
-0.2598309814929962,
-0.03470651060342789,
0.6555168032646179,
0.4440333843231201,
-0.5375990271568298,
-0.914639949798584,
-0.36464956402778625,
-0.7002438306808472,
-0.2702765464782715,
0.25145313143730164,
-0.4248010218143463,
0.6733866930007935,
-0.2738914489746094,
0.1921994537115097,
0.08350206166505814,
0.2482360601425171,
-0.19734348356723785,
-0.04183987155556679,
0.3486553728580475,
0.43209508061408997,
0.8627598285675049,
-0.022313181310892105,
1.130030870437622,
-0.7248501777648926,
0.10970647633075714,
1.3494802713394165,
0.11901971697807312,
0.7216826677322388,
0.5943955779075623,
0.3144708573818207,
0.46279141306877136,
0.750079333782196,
0.054020870476961136,
0.24985802173614502,
-0.27631303668022156,
-0.36855900287628174,
-0.17327651381492615,
0.1598528027534485,
-0.12217264622449875,
0.4101216495037079,
0.26329752802848816,
-0.3319508731365204,
-0.09351380914449692,
0.3629666268825531,
0.5250884890556335,
0.35450294613838196,
-0.2970399260520935,
0.7994229793548584,
-0.1993357092142105,
-0.6082074642181396,
0.28382232785224915,
0.42296019196510315,
0.682165265083313,
-0.7338805198669434,
-0.2814544141292572,
-0.1459341049194336,
0.2612602710723877,
-0.24947673082351685,
-0.4917198717594147,
0.07738220691680908,
0.461232453584671,
-0.4891325831413269,
-0.32094696164131165,
0.5891638398170471,
-0.7613788843154907,
-1.076686978340149,
0.17385834455490112,
0.4816403388977051,
-0.059940043836832047,
0.06699804216623306,
-0.7244392037391663,
-0.037546683102846146,
-0.1387343853712082,
-0.26811012625694275,
-0.07154839485883713,
0.5587520599365234,
-0.005381749011576176,
0.4144095182418823,
0.5178118348121643,
0.3930233120918274,
0.296111524105072,
0.451131135225296,
0.7024040818214417,
-0.3541189730167389,
-0.6176871657371521,
-0.9810090065002441,
0.6224703192710876,
-0.0318203829228878,
-0.5870704650878906,
0.513861358165741,
0.7406452298164368,
0.9206892848014832,
-0.33497437834739685,
0.8867554068565369,
0.18651627004146576,
0.6470699906349182,
-0.800886869430542,
0.9067178964614868,
-0.486566424369812,
-0.1903148591518402,
-0.19789308309555054,
-0.6257224678993225,
-0.6629016995429993,
0.5706904530525208,
-0.42918774485588074,
0.08677061647176743,
0.9234024882316589,
0.9418923258781433,
-0.34125277400016785,
0.022915713489055634,
0.13764114677906036,
0.10761503875255585,
0.06879708915948868,
0.525811493396759,
0.5411661863327026,
-0.3133472502231598,
0.32135605812072754,
-0.3563351333141327,
-0.39329349994659424,
-0.04205963760614395,
-0.7127869129180908,
-1.0594145059585571,
-0.4186929762363434,
-0.27255508303642273,
0.1028488278388977,
0.12459991872310638,
1.3085061311721802,
0.6379283666610718,
-0.7933180332183838,
-0.23510697484016418,
0.01574191078543663,
0.09044298529624939,
-0.3170202970504761,
-0.13988178968429565,
0.384480357170105,
-0.5751584768295288,
-0.827587366104126,
0.4572821259498596,
0.36188557744026184,
-0.05492835119366646,
0.09580755233764648,
-0.1032688245177269,
-0.42810115218162537,
0.007288798689842224,
0.5214371681213379,
0.04116436094045639,
-0.4430554509162903,
-0.1608569175004959,
0.1354684978723526,
-0.3255480229854584,
0.38170304894447327,
1.0576213598251343,
-0.17652671039104462,
0.7368812561035156,
0.16101513803005219,
0.8589257597923279,
-0.06097511202096939,
-0.15294097363948822,
0.8074666857719421,
-0.8737716674804688,
0.15164411067962646,
-0.023090209811925888,
0.3731078803539276,
0.42162296175956726,
-0.5059148073196411,
0.5665289163589478,
0.0338045135140419,
-0.6901146173477173,
-0.6724216341972351,
0.005167342256754637,
-0.7544979453086853,
-0.07013943046331406,
1.0007717609405518,
-0.04484114795923233,
-0.1630087047815323,
0.09116112440824509,
-0.9029263257980347,
0.4526483416557312,
-0.11497607827186584,
0.5625121593475342,
1.0536882877349854,
-0.14191293716430664,
-0.35786208510398865,
-0.9148725867271423,
0.8042373657226562,
0.3746175765991211,
-1.108619213104248,
0.2126215249300003,
0.754310667514801,
0.3785923421382904,
-0.3507855236530304,
0.6312780380249023,
-0.11498788744211197,
0.859587550163269,
-0.3335034251213074,
0.4726845920085907,
-0.3152574300765991,
-0.4385938048362732,
-0.5228500962257385,
-0.22501571476459503,
0.21938423812389374,
-0.22594115138053894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16470v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16470v1
|
Unveiling Vulnerability of Self-Attention
| 2024-02-26T10:31:45 | 2024-02-26T10:31:45 |
Khai Jiet Liong, Hongqiu Wu, Hai Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) are shown to be vulnerable to minor word
changes, which poses a big threat to real-world systems. While previous studies
directly focus on manipulating word inputs, they are limited by their means of
generating adversarial samples, lacking generalization to versatile real-world
attack. This paper studies the basic structure of transformer-based PLMs, the
self-attention (SA) mechanism. (1) We propose a powerful perturbation technique
\textit{HackAttend}, which perturbs the attention scores within the SA matrices
via meticulously crafted attention masks. We show that state-of-the-art PLMs
fall into heavy vulnerability that minor attention perturbations $(1\%)$ can
produce a very high attack success rate $(98\%)$. Our paper expands the
conventional text attack of word perturbations to more general structural
perturbations. (2) We introduce \textit{S-Attend}, a novel smoothing technique
that effectively makes SA robust via structural perturbations. We empirically
demonstrate that this simple yet effective technique achieves robust
performance on par with adversarial training when facing various text
attackers. Code is publicly available at \url{github.com/liongkj/HackAttend}.
|
[
-0.3349609673023224,
-0.9359855651855469,
0.2947176694869995,
0.31775984168052673,
-0.1373465210199356,
0.012581910938024521,
0.029752496629953384,
-0.07186803966760635,
0.24598155915737152,
0.7611982822418213,
-0.9068818688392639,
-0.0805995836853981,
-0.6875443458557129,
0.02468549832701683,
-0.4953489303588867,
1.0848994255065918,
0.19670884311199188,
-0.32048436999320984,
-0.03480315953493118,
0.057665057480335236,
-0.306816428899765,
-0.7659010887145996,
-0.24330483376979828,
-0.10828743875026703,
0.7029561996459961,
0.18885129690170288,
0.748020350933075,
0.6113349199295044,
0.843363881111145,
0.35961735248565674,
0.054036762565374374,
-0.3801780939102173,
-0.7276635766029358,
0.32037585973739624,
-0.21717004477977753,
-0.7472906112670898,
-0.4421861469745636,
0.15223699808120728,
0.5722677707672119,
0.3190256357192993,
0.3153005838394165,
0.3497052490711212,
0.36718305945396423,
0.6003919243812561,
-0.6726477146148682,
-0.3400769829750061,
-0.9010851383209229,
0.1267153024673462,
-0.711966872215271,
-0.11003044247627258,
-0.5116134881973267,
0.3590884506702423,
0.062323153018951416,
-0.14140719175338745,
0.38950109481811523,
-0.10465959459543228,
0.751147985458374,
0.7244369983673096,
-0.05149807780981064,
0.12105268985033035,
-0.6994655132293701,
0.6129231452941895,
-0.45506414771080017,
0.3086949586868286,
0.33326125144958496,
0.2139020562171936,
-0.31767040491104126,
-0.8298419117927551,
-0.3290382921695709,
-0.2597559690475464,
-0.23094280064105988,
0.15936172008514404,
-0.4035439193248749,
0.36528268456459045,
0.43249788880348206,
0.5688530802726746,
-0.45488929748535156,
-0.017422795295715332,
-0.28574419021606445,
-0.24328595399856567,
0.5031958818435669,
0.13663725554943085,
0.3899030089378357,
-0.24297134578227997,
-0.6554118394851685,
-0.2533022165298462,
-0.8256161212921143,
-0.022886358201503754,
0.5558062791824341,
0.12012287974357605,
-0.10601773858070374,
0.4668155908584595,
0.09999106079339981,
0.6505926847457886,
0.3494264781475067,
0.22102506458759308,
-0.24193403124809265,
-0.29285386204719543,
-0.34059762954711914,
-0.20107029378414154,
0.9744532108306885,
-0.13581326603889465,
0.12473990023136139,
-0.292111337184906,
-0.19631901383399963,
0.15604549646377563,
0.7386271953582764,
-0.5834735035896301,
-0.4674648642539978,
0.14845697581768036,
-0.20287474989891052,
-0.6171461939811707,
0.06346534937620163,
-0.8848202228546143,
-0.20115424692630768,
0.226980522274971,
0.7172870635986328,
-0.25628048181533813,
0.18559756875038147,
-0.11754274368286133,
0.24404089152812958,
0.3382943868637085,
-0.01448364369571209,
-0.7589864730834961,
0.3024576008319855,
0.385326087474823,
0.8030809760093689,
-0.03896072879433632,
-0.5627842545509338,
-0.492170125246048,
0.10832838714122772,
-0.14369340240955353,
0.9883789420127869,
-0.22211827337741852,
-0.36907926201820374,
-0.353192538022995,
-0.1774592399597168,
-0.1715528815984726,
-0.18778561055660248,
0.45197051763534546,
-0.47487539052963257,
0.15181148052215576,
0.11844035238027573,
-0.10908882319927216,
0.18697459995746613,
0.1166703999042511,
-0.7022132277488708,
0.8734126687049866,
0.062140677124261856,
-0.9176633358001709,
-0.23351532220840454,
-0.6988707780838013,
-0.7293649911880493,
-0.039388321340084076,
0.10472545027732849,
-0.6472057104110718,
0.3651788532733917,
0.3634798228740692,
0.29670223593711853,
-0.018809301778674126,
-0.14229446649551392,
-0.34646907448768616,
-0.25636887550354004,
0.5617011189460754,
-0.6789478659629822,
0.4864630699157715,
0.10071265697479248,
-0.4427405595779419,
0.27965596318244934,
-0.6622439026832581,
-0.21731318533420563,
0.3342007100582123,
0.01513529010117054,
-0.27297914028167725,
0.02189638651907444,
-0.2406952679157257,
0.46250689029693604,
0.15529635548591614,
-0.4106004536151886,
0.2024255096912384,
-0.8799769878387451,
0.4632842242717743,
0.9495777487754822,
0.1294393390417099,
0.5451281070709229,
-0.09300585091114044,
0.6252737641334534,
-0.1585000604391098,
0.45855793356895447,
-0.6488741040229797,
-0.029193762689828873,
-0.895950436592102,
-0.394788533449173,
0.5055384039878845,
0.29339179396629333,
-0.5756444334983826,
0.27522337436676025,
0.012524391524493694,
-0.4980374872684479,
-0.980809211730957,
0.07674757391214371,
0.5060606002807617,
0.37116071581840515,
0.3863551914691925,
-0.07918046414852142,
-0.44127294421195984,
-0.8814823627471924,
-0.8862711787223816,
0.15229852497577667,
-0.15382617712020874,
-0.042463064193725586,
0.198902428150177,
-0.09308818727731705,
0.7875239849090576,
-0.6709973216056824,
-0.802601158618927,
-0.13541695475578308,
0.03725762665271759,
-0.024248769506812096,
0.3350416421890259,
0.4487205147743225,
-0.5819965600967407,
-0.402056485414505,
-0.5280247330665588,
-0.36315494775772095,
-0.2703454792499542,
-0.3507230281829834,
0.035663824528455734,
-0.08026604354381561,
0.81121426820755,
-0.3166378438472748,
0.8324013352394104,
0.5586321949958801,
-0.23319607973098755,
0.3198505640029907,
0.012294561602175236,
-0.13969513773918152,
-0.9099002480506897,
-0.06462236493825912,
-0.14235740900039673,
-0.2805348038673401,
-0.8476817607879639,
0.31866031885147095,
0.04932764545083046,
-0.35661280155181885,
-0.6749396920204163,
0.3975074291229248,
-0.5355002880096436,
0.16713584959506989,
-0.628508985042572,
0.12510627508163452,
-0.1636592149734497,
0.5906431674957275,
-0.47980308532714844,
0.6975958347320557,
0.5600760579109192,
-0.599780261516571,
-0.029566172510385513,
0.24901975691318512,
0.10361991077661514,
0.3163554072380066,
-0.9090697169303894,
0.5988985896110535,
-0.22005695104599,
0.2434741109609604,
-1.2721952199935913,
-0.24401681125164032,
0.2747032046318054,
-0.5513256192207336,
0.5372549295425415,
-0.01867794059216976,
-0.25413960218429565,
-0.5422131419181824,
-0.7645576596260071,
0.36238089203834534,
0.1571739763021469,
-0.5357546806335449,
0.8697218298912048,
0.4290044605731964,
-0.04348401352763176,
-0.38354575634002686,
-0.91631019115448,
0.38150253891944885,
-0.1311034858226776,
-0.554301917552948,
0.3704066574573517,
-0.0825376957654953,
0.06312814354896545,
-0.27331167459487915,
-0.25839322805404663,
0.2911526560783386,
0.4214564859867096,
0.40584298968315125,
0.1389869898557663,
0.04936876893043518,
-0.12927748262882233,
-0.15062056481838226,
-0.4127747714519501,
0.26324695348739624,
-0.16093342006206512,
0.6973539590835571,
-0.09072759747505188,
-0.4069162905216217,
-0.6297271251678467,
0.3719165027141571,
0.6740715503692627,
-0.49647241830825806,
0.41558974981307983,
0.4258946180343628,
-0.24041754007339478,
-0.10565599799156189,
-0.7231703400611877,
-0.6500799059867859,
-0.6145601868629456,
0.5437049865722656,
-0.7021886110305786,
-0.9399685263633728,
0.4743815064430237,
0.017269250005483627,
-0.15336373448371887,
0.5504465103149414,
0.48795732855796814,
-0.3703674077987671,
1.0371698141098022,
0.7852837443351746,
-0.33816322684288025,
0.5033547878265381,
-0.04688195511698723,
0.39943209290504456,
-0.9164230823516846,
0.10614932328462601,
-0.594050407409668,
-0.5104174613952637,
-0.5462320446968079,
-0.28603044152259827,
0.44648873805999756,
-0.09566619992256165,
-0.021268807351589203,
0.5516920685768127,
-0.5874364376068115,
0.409812867641449,
0.4179563522338867,
-0.013366171158850193,
0.011927629821002483,
-0.13916996121406555,
0.09273636341094971,
-0.38354504108428955,
-0.8349796533584595,
-0.23570877313613892,
0.9847677946090698,
0.6027305722236633,
1.3033894300460815,
-0.05511903390288353,
0.6591852903366089,
0.287962406873703,
0.2948686182498932,
-0.49559736251831055,
0.5860661268234253,
-0.10141496360301971,
-0.5039923787117004,
-0.36139827966690063,
-0.13052529096603394,
-0.8944975733757019,
0.2953793704509735,
-0.14675197005271912,
-0.7927759885787964,
0.06352397054433823,
0.34836244583129883,
-0.41342994570732117,
0.2081931233406067,
-0.6460217237472534,
0.7794654369354248,
-0.31204307079315186,
-0.34907791018486023,
-0.14547981321811676,
-0.8886042833328247,
0.2367485910654068,
-0.24519586563110352,
0.13642317056655884,
0.1364540457725525,
0.1317840963602066,
0.5526382327079773,
-0.1593640297651291,
1.1909427642822266,
0.19883476197719574,
-0.037992823868989944,
0.09706437587738037,
0.5026752352714539,
0.742155134677887,
-0.047617021948099136,
0.4256271421909332,
0.32677704095840454,
-0.46638691425323486,
-0.33323290944099426,
-0.7402381300926208,
0.708272397518158,
-0.710468053817749,
-1.092368245124817,
-0.663653552532196,
-0.4392675459384918,
-0.18181633949279785,
0.1739020198583603,
0.5216693878173828,
0.24589787423610687,
-0.034979239106178284,
0.1579684466123581,
0.7412998676300049,
0.04598313197493553,
0.693955659866333,
0.6530699729919434,
0.022361645475029945,
-0.49342769384384155,
0.7655457258224487,
0.20293328166007996,
0.4096906781196594,
0.4427301585674286,
0.2927635908126831,
-0.16832385957241058,
-0.14245742559432983,
-0.13745202124118805,
0.257441908121109,
-0.3493780195713043,
-0.4721718430519104,
-0.853760838508606,
-0.40171676874160767,
-0.5941563248634338,
-0.158840611577034,
-0.5558276176452637,
-0.19770409166812897,
-0.32107651233673096,
-0.11581066995859146,
-0.033250752836465836,
0.6777133941650391,
0.07972382754087448,
0.6700522303581238,
-0.6081311702728271,
0.45351850986480713,
0.44556018710136414,
0.3711140751838684,
-0.15384742617607117,
-0.7473199367523193,
-0.08542343974113464,
-0.34930384159088135,
-0.5208890438079834,
-1.1473392248153687,
0.21789008378982544,
0.22642309963703156,
0.4856114983558655,
0.4706311821937561,
0.17466630041599274,
0.6172504425048828,
-0.6341486573219299,
0.7059453129768372,
0.06151490658521652,
-1.044179916381836,
0.8729041218757629,
-0.20467296242713928,
0.7165486812591553,
0.6239806413650513,
0.058832380920648575,
-0.37227752804756165,
-0.8793542385101318,
-0.9194758534431458,
-0.8077902793884277,
0.9610550403594971,
0.21712471544742584,
0.4081284701824188,
0.171916201710701,
0.3828388750553131,
-0.2160070687532425,
0.075042225420475,
-1.085690975189209,
-0.5193369388580322,
-0.3749805986881256,
-0.05917246639728546,
0.10309538245201111,
-0.5773106813430786,
0.042122188955545425,
-0.0012617525644600391,
0.5424147844314575,
-0.05459937825798988,
0.30824434757232666,
0.5446585416793823,
-0.22685490548610687,
-0.07859113812446594,
0.11952952295541763,
0.6900621652603149,
-0.020524047315120697,
0.11154462397098541,
0.34986579418182373,
0.3517420291900635,
-0.6209821105003357,
0.08456029742956161,
-0.023467253893613815,
-0.3458654582500458,
-0.2849220037460327,
0.4159567952156067,
0.8282880187034607,
0.4918121099472046,
-0.10123315453529358,
0.6156214475631714,
-0.10780728608369827,
-0.1068178042769432,
0.10039889067411423,
-0.03119819425046444,
-0.28256016969680786,
-0.052503667771816254,
0.40581828355789185,
0.13367553055286407,
0.1464845985174179,
-0.3461311161518097,
0.33816367387771606,
0.4840591251850128,
-0.6968457698822021,
-0.6189640164375305,
0.9876289367675781,
0.14720813930034637,
-0.7594107389450073,
-0.01223132386803627,
0.21778853237628937,
-0.951324999332428,
0.20752368867397308,
0.8601738810539246,
1.0761370658874512,
-0.9567448496818542,
-0.03234605863690376,
0.04569561779499054,
0.8950620293617249,
0.3752354383468628,
-0.05934319272637367,
-0.16617369651794434,
-0.29079124331474304,
-0.4418070614337921,
-0.5145599246025085,
-0.10290274024009705,
0.4123144745826721,
-0.4398984909057617,
0.2516363561153412,
-0.5670059323310852,
-0.14657756686210632,
-0.1070811077952385,
-0.4327299892902374,
-0.48489993810653687,
0.3108161985874176,
0.054000210016965866,
0.719559907913208,
-0.6623480916023254,
0.5843867659568787,
0.6358263492584229,
-0.1749340295791626,
-0.6106657385826111,
0.5794840455055237,
-0.1545134037733078,
-0.5580894947052002,
0.25576913356781006,
0.16318060457706451,
-0.24013744294643402,
0.13844460248947144,
-0.5479021072387695,
-1.1466211080551147,
0.4490470886230469,
0.5059711337089539,
-0.5330353379249573,
-0.06555082648992538,
0.3661295175552368,
0.468899130821228,
0.057315893471241,
0.12323244661092758,
0.5009938478469849,
0.4068988561630249,
-0.41614824533462524,
-0.5217807292938232,
0.07368168979883194,
0.0856996476650238,
0.035788729786872864,
0.34856289625167847,
-1.1264784336090088,
0.592881977558136,
0.0037371963262557983,
-0.27224987745285034,
-0.3465663194656372,
1.013802409172058,
-0.2621918320655823,
-0.08667372167110443,
0.4817940890789032,
0.531944751739502,
0.25239086151123047,
-0.11677464097738266,
0.971429169178009,
-0.4894667863845825,
0.29968342185020447,
1.1674461364746094,
-0.07085192948579788,
0.5099279880523682,
0.6257999539375305,
-0.3362303674221039,
0.2322462648153305,
0.11661502718925476,
-0.03913315758109093,
0.7233759760856628,
0.3230869174003601,
-0.047242842614650726,
-0.13540266454219818,
0.29266712069511414,
-0.10210462659597397,
0.7634183168411255,
0.29886889457702637,
-0.08913014084100723,
-0.3225781321525574,
0.4343145191669464,
0.07017987221479416,
0.2376880645751953,
-0.3786851167678833,
0.8588190674781799,
0.23288804292678833,
-0.633629560470581,
0.2795810401439667,
-0.04760551080107689,
0.6253212690353394,
-0.8025856018066406,
0.24639974534511566,
-0.11962839215993881,
0.2611502408981323,
-0.11225590109825134,
-0.3888108730316162,
0.3647693395614624,
-0.21833355724811554,
-0.22430764138698578,
-0.14852109551429749,
1.18212890625,
-0.21860253810882568,
-0.4731996953487396,
0.3291955590248108,
-0.02656264789402485,
-0.30769798159599304,
-0.3984096646308899,
-0.5985976457595825,
0.16824419796466827,
0.011007566004991531,
-0.5140683650970459,
0.5829256176948547,
0.03487087041139603,
0.09908904135227203,
0.6747395992279053,
0.4956086575984955,
-0.05560964345932007,
0.19892148673534393,
0.02418620139360428,
1.0805258750915527,
-0.6182256937026978,
-0.7271597981452942,
-1.1714414358139038,
0.3680596649646759,
0.032430436462163925,
-0.31565630435943604,
1.056864857673645,
0.2763172686100006,
0.6782532930374146,
-0.11629211902618408,
0.5593809485435486,
0.42851510643959045,
0.42819610238075256,
-0.24799925088882446,
0.9237694144248962,
-0.24876825511455536,
0.18423029780387878,
-0.41948962211608887,
-0.6800991892814636,
-0.47010353207588196,
0.4120240807533264,
-0.35564082860946655,
-0.17697197198867798,
0.7353327870368958,
0.7188142538070679,
0.165027916431427,
-0.08411377668380737,
0.44218698143959045,
0.5271836519241333,
0.24660293757915497,
0.3095632791519165,
0.6593729853630066,
-0.6617932915687561,
0.6524133682250977,
-0.2448197454214096,
-0.3488709330558777,
-0.2627323567867279,
-0.8183979988098145,
-1.1188232898712158,
-0.5138511657714844,
-0.36277663707733154,
-0.4108492136001587,
0.2639109194278717,
0.4035145938396454,
0.5772485136985779,
-0.7207146286964417,
0.2699924111366272,
-0.07445070892572403,
0.0009861522121354938,
0.007903965190052986,
-0.26130616664886475,
0.5191662311553955,
-0.5861729383468628,
-0.4029102027416229,
0.7394501566886902,
0.6619377136230469,
0.1627708524465561,
-0.5847647190093994,
0.5700890421867371,
-0.10036533325910568,
0.4493514597415924,
0.2908872961997986,
0.16009743511676788,
-0.5853548049926758,
-0.31736457347869873,
0.09160776436328888,
-0.28621116280555725,
0.08004818111658096,
0.9810227155685425,
-0.9175601601600647,
0.37236344814300537,
0.15787363052368164,
0.7422780990600586,
0.5628054141998291,
0.06336972117424011,
0.45028814673423767,
-1.0530344247817993,
0.19392165541648865,
0.2971216142177582,
0.12136667221784592,
0.25981777906417847,
-0.786843478679657,
0.23845791816711426,
0.23486211895942688,
-0.5037039518356323,
-0.8991188406944275,
0.35885339975357056,
-0.6618242859840393,
-0.19183510541915894,
0.8216117024421692,
0.036577410995960236,
-0.7398909330368042,
0.007153958082199097,
-0.33413082361221313,
0.06907268613576889,
0.01975979469716549,
0.9924366474151611,
0.589115560054779,
0.1413867324590683,
0.011963095515966415,
-0.09895476698875427,
0.6932225227355957,
0.661937415599823,
-0.5181359648704529,
0.1666206568479538,
-0.07764264196157455,
0.2671948969364166,
0.2813063859939575,
0.50877445936203,
-0.2892087697982788,
0.3241207003593445,
-0.0901261568069458,
-0.009145770221948624,
-0.18823665380477905,
-0.6068350672721863,
-0.6696829795837402,
0.5075900554656982,
-0.2299552708864212,
-0.38784652948379517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16459v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16459v3
|
Defending LLMs against Jailbreaking Attacks via Backtranslation
| 2024-02-26T10:03:33 | 2024-06-06T19:21:44 |
Yihan Wang, Zhouxing Shi, Andrew Bai, Cho-Jui Hsieh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although many large language models (LLMs) have been trained to refuse
harmful requests, they are still vulnerable to jailbreaking attacks which
rewrite the original prompt to conceal its harmful intent. In this paper, we
propose a new method for defending LLMs against jailbreaking attacks by
``backtranslation''. Specifically, given an initial response generated by the
target LLM from an input prompt, our backtranslation prompts a language model
to infer an input prompt that can lead to the response. The inferred prompt is
called the backtranslated prompt which tends to reveal the actual intent of the
original prompt, since it is generated based on the LLM's response and not
directly manipulated by the attacker. We then run the target LLM again on the
backtranslated prompt, and we refuse the original prompt if the model refuses
the backtranslated prompt. We explain that the proposed defense provides
several benefits on its effectiveness and efficiency. We empirically
demonstrate that our defense significantly outperforms the baselines, in the
cases that are hard for the baselines, and our defense also has little impact
on the generation quality for benign input prompts. Our implementation is based
on our library for LLM jailbreaking defense algorithms at
\url{https://github.com/YihanWang617/llm-jailbreaking-defense}, and the code
for reproducing our experiments is available at
\url{https://github.com/YihanWang617/LLM-Jailbreaking-Defense-Backtranslation}.
|
[
-0.06564928591251373,
-0.7916387915611267,
0.7942271828651428,
0.12905393540859222,
-0.23689807951450348,
0.45273181796073914,
-0.16278156638145447,
-0.3021065592765808,
0.1461031585931778,
0.8248094916343689,
-0.6375150084495544,
-0.5543025732040405,
-0.5762438774108887,
0.15298353135585785,
-0.3268313407897949,
1.025163173675537,
-0.07284454256296158,
0.12814103066921234,
-0.020826775580644608,
0.11750180274248123,
-0.7400128841400146,
-0.6319847702980042,
-0.633251965045929,
-0.31525909900665283,
0.6824389100074768,
0.4111538827419281,
0.48539236187934875,
0.4207718074321747,
0.4639015197753906,
0.2448463886976242,
-0.2611945569515228,
-0.1316545158624649,
-0.3849610388278961,
0.6007778644561768,
-0.2613009214401245,
-0.6118922829627991,
-0.23664365708827972,
-0.13639476895332336,
0.44363582134246826,
0.08694415539503098,
-0.06945676356554031,
-0.10474532097578049,
-0.17176403105258942,
0.7425052523612976,
-0.6704187989234924,
-0.5702787041664124,
-0.9007055759429932,
0.14513938128948212,
-0.45766040682792664,
0.006237577181309462,
-0.8614262938499451,
-0.4031607508659363,
-0.5072146058082581,
-0.05359257385134697,
0.02331334911286831,
0.023231983184814453,
0.730442464351654,
0.16529473662376404,
-0.12583142518997192,
-0.14977069199085236,
-0.4058811366558075,
0.3751491606235504,
-0.6959472298622131,
0.37655848264694214,
0.430143803358078,
0.3436020612716675,
-0.5820827484130859,
-0.426875501871109,
-0.3771395981311798,
-0.5674874782562256,
0.007888415828347206,
-0.018957126885652542,
-0.5189903378486633,
0.03950699791312218,
0.46407681703567505,
0.09268368035554886,
-0.6091116666793823,
0.4044104516506195,
-0.345890074968338,
-0.45376160740852356,
0.47621476650238037,
0.24375790357589722,
0.5271914005279541,
-0.0024089894723147154,
-0.41137635707855225,
0.07890179008245468,
-1.4289790391921997,
0.23229433596134186,
0.5237110257148743,
0.2895427644252777,
-0.09355059266090393,
0.7958551049232483,
-0.062408462166786194,
0.5875522494316101,
0.31945350766181946,
-0.17381586134433746,
0.0787004753947258,
-0.13611888885498047,
0.043309688568115234,
0.1467181146144867,
0.6714955568313599,
0.3225020468235016,
0.11916854977607727,
-0.4496535360813141,
-0.4325825870037079,
-0.2422075718641281,
0.3670252859592438,
-0.9991767406463623,
-0.01118865329772234,
0.26569974422454834,
-0.47091028094291687,
-0.6252511739730835,
-0.05902789905667305,
-0.755969762802124,
-0.7090322971343994,
0.5715644359588623,
0.19869078695774078,
-0.45854100584983826,
0.1101013720035553,
-0.17223496735095978,
0.0547807440161705,
0.19518505036830902,
0.04779883846640587,
-0.9608112573623657,
0.3072494566440582,
0.8633620738983154,
1.0335359573364258,
-0.15654951333999634,
-0.19267450273036957,
-0.9998023509979248,
0.2749730050563812,
-0.21566163003444672,
0.6990785598754883,
-0.15409260988235474,
-0.5963210463523865,
-0.20410169661045074,
0.16196006536483765,
0.060263536870479584,
-0.557123601436615,
0.3616196811199188,
-0.9532613158226013,
-0.27468565106391907,
-0.062114715576171875,
-0.3591531813144684,
0.0006758650415576994,
0.40264832973480225,
-0.8775787353515625,
0.34318968653678894,
-0.2829345166683197,
-0.5708165764808655,
0.08294063061475754,
-0.3585405647754669,
-0.7233035564422607,
-0.026114068925380707,
0.1154722049832344,
-0.5473336577415466,
0.2544417977333069,
0.3708193600177765,
0.21880508959293365,
-0.1552741974592209,
0.2774706184864044,
-0.4297252893447876,
-0.18264001607894897,
0.6621701717376709,
-0.4220731854438782,
0.9794365167617798,
0.5799744129180908,
-0.2631181478500366,
0.26923951506614685,
-0.603135347366333,
-0.3245360553264618,
0.4078643023967743,
-0.4632939398288727,
-0.30482903122901917,
0.10633073002099991,
-0.5355549454689026,
0.08303682506084442,
0.2894897758960724,
-1.172995686531067,
0.2662043273448944,
-0.833046555519104,
0.5093003511428833,
0.8926791548728943,
-0.002206880832090974,
0.28844723105430603,
-0.09963612258434296,
0.6550264358520508,
-0.19469891488552094,
-0.077146977186203,
-0.49957266449928284,
-0.2683012783527374,
-0.04889833554625511,
-0.3324018716812134,
0.12823708355426788,
0.8225591778755188,
-0.6996354460716248,
0.12092091888189316,
0.1377788931131363,
-0.28464505076408386,
-0.3807987868785858,
0.25371813774108887,
0.5643466711044312,
0.5464538931846619,
0.3733072578907013,
-0.08202728629112244,
-0.7107167840003967,
-0.7012282013893127,
-0.6502562165260315,
-0.3140488266944885,
0.0909285619854927,
-0.13328681886196136,
0.22096265852451324,
-0.1141614243388176,
0.64267897605896,
-0.42715510725975037,
0.15315386652946472,
-0.44281241297721863,
-0.3455090820789337,
0.26618847250938416,
0.6113455295562744,
0.5364519953727722,
-0.3821803033351898,
-0.281361848115921,
-0.2886629104614258,
-0.6692354083061218,
-0.46192923188209534,
-0.14433614909648895,
-0.031456369906663895,
0.12616585195064545,
0.6868167519569397,
-0.8627730011940002,
0.44440996646881104,
0.4658893644809723,
-0.6365315318107605,
0.66867995262146,
0.20373493432998657,
-0.11504735797643661,
-1.0380866527557373,
-0.19880357384681702,
-0.35900357365608215,
-0.47147732973098755,
-0.5670966506004333,
0.4966468811035156,
0.12221403419971466,
-0.3665362298488617,
-0.6518980860710144,
0.691328763961792,
-0.14533446729183197,
0.035176072269678116,
-0.36101606488227844,
-0.06597457081079483,
-0.0854959562420845,
0.12659677863121033,
-0.24355006217956543,
0.8613267540931702,
0.2792350947856903,
-0.16888901591300964,
0.7515621185302734,
0.14497531950473785,
-0.02187565714120865,
0.5673946738243103,
-0.8951169848442078,
0.36258143186569214,
0.09934070706367493,
0.38378235697746277,
-1.2235161066055298,
0.17297443747520447,
0.7822319269180298,
-0.609749972820282,
0.376591295003891,
-0.6116576790809631,
-0.39426133036613464,
-0.39290663599967957,
-0.44068917632102966,
0.22917674481868744,
0.4556474983692169,
-0.8736209273338318,
0.4684072732925415,
-0.0014427737332880497,
-0.21640656888484955,
-0.6025934219360352,
-0.7652257680892944,
0.5021385550498962,
-0.5089660882949829,
-0.799755334854126,
0.36983636021614075,
-0.3822210431098938,
-0.4373718500137329,
-0.1750483363866806,
-0.11895527690649033,
0.13864992558956146,
0.5752779841423035,
0.43526533246040344,
0.4300134778022766,
-0.20868895947933197,
-0.2094653695821762,
0.0017533410573378205,
-0.17765094339847565,
0.5278789401054382,
-0.49596258997917175,
0.6702688336372375,
0.23769603669643402,
-0.44350478053092957,
-0.36121025681495667,
0.4492587149143219,
0.47873151302337646,
-0.14546312391757965,
0.7899408936500549,
0.20488236844539642,
-0.08308684080839157,
0.076085165143013,
-0.5023305416107178,
-0.2506844699382782,
-0.5405776500701904,
0.1990075260400772,
-0.5676525831222534,
-0.8832628130912781,
0.422585666179657,
0.006910289637744427,
0.2534169554710388,
0.040324028581380844,
0.7083173990249634,
-0.15176920592784882,
1.0107448101043701,
0.3663099408149719,
-0.36974355578422546,
0.5738481879234314,
0.23883117735385895,
0.046447087079286575,
-0.6775146126747131,
-0.15303963422775269,
-0.5586726665496826,
-0.1670205444097519,
-0.4042293429374695,
0.20328621566295624,
-0.12658892571926117,
0.012232009321451187,
-0.20017918944358826,
0.4428146481513977,
-0.18773478269577026,
0.5021076798439026,
0.22032681107521057,
0.3569144904613495,
0.2161273956298828,
0.04000581055879593,
-0.2941713333129883,
-0.01022920198738575,
-0.3006771504878998,
-0.498245507478714,
1.2008984088897705,
0.6507011651992798,
0.999830424785614,
0.3722677230834961,
1.1805509328842163,
0.33292683959007263,
0.35918012261390686,
-0.7146600484848022,
0.648603081703186,
0.10855258256196976,
-0.6170542240142822,
0.0470074862241745,
-0.5076773166656494,
-1.0282775163650513,
0.42223700881004333,
0.05771584436297417,
-1.0687850713729858,
-0.2222096025943756,
0.3435963988304138,
-0.520137369632721,
0.6144803166389465,
-0.5189294815063477,
0.7129742503166199,
-0.43348008394241333,
-0.4542325735092163,
-0.20379385352134705,
-0.6493756771087646,
0.5537325143814087,
-0.002464383840560913,
0.1247725561261177,
0.01451344508677721,
0.20909620821475983,
0.809583306312561,
-0.7400841116905212,
0.9724965691566467,
-0.38938453793525696,
-0.4454718828201294,
0.15005679428577423,
0.28551185131073,
0.8468925356864929,
0.3838804364204407,
0.10545006394386292,
-0.12330996990203857,
-0.25462979078292847,
-0.2849784195423126,
-0.5546173453330994,
0.6763654947280884,
-0.5186185240745544,
-1.268460750579834,
-0.15191330015659332,
-0.45133599638938904,
0.053446099162101746,
0.384859561920166,
0.4709051847457886,
0.2001538872718811,
-0.14258763194084167,
-0.14793874323368073,
0.7555388808250427,
-0.3197087049484253,
0.46462395787239075,
0.6692642569541931,
-0.3296377658843994,
-0.4561300277709961,
0.7895054221153259,
-0.1271558701992035,
0.331133633852005,
0.20528177917003632,
0.3642038106918335,
-0.13146938383579254,
-0.9427335262298584,
-0.6434454917907715,
0.1409865915775299,
-0.5978512167930603,
-0.5291450023651123,
-0.630284309387207,
-0.21640248596668243,
-0.46413615345954895,
-0.11324393004179001,
-0.2666666507720947,
-0.4619436264038086,
0.0936654582619667,
-0.18796342611312866,
0.49564656615257263,
0.4178957939147949,
-0.3687075674533844,
0.37676456570625305,
-0.8578868508338928,
0.5265690088272095,
0.22009415924549103,
0.009814941324293613,
-0.14375905692577362,
-0.8441921472549438,
-0.18240733444690704,
-0.03221488371491432,
-0.28941988945007324,
-1.2234084606170654,
0.3227505087852478,
-0.3714089095592499,
0.5277602672576904,
0.08818616718053818,
0.05974959209561348,
0.30737459659576416,
-0.7640947699546814,
0.5299465656280518,
0.2622675895690918,
-0.881069004535675,
0.7148441076278687,
-0.10006165504455566,
0.15891078114509583,
0.6173128485679626,
-0.12601080536842346,
-0.5483929514884949,
-0.5979581475257874,
-0.38618576526641846,
-0.9703596234321594,
0.4676225781440735,
-0.28977686166763306,
0.22402077913284302,
0.14653761684894562,
0.410430908203125,
0.04326509311795235,
0.14845477044582367,
-0.871372401714325,
-0.05008331313729286,
-0.23413485288619995,
-0.1326891928911209,
0.13656680285930634,
-0.45258209109306335,
-0.26688459515571594,
0.05767984688282013,
0.5551412105560303,
0.35414209961891174,
0.02291135862469673,
-0.018361568450927734,
-0.562309980392456,
0.017829595133662224,
0.37779027223587036,
0.6418706774711609,
0.1145470142364502,
-0.06958097964525223,
0.3738164007663727,
0.18968287110328674,
-0.7577320337295532,
0.6904628872871399,
0.11996796727180481,
-0.6473300457000732,
-0.2236318141222,
0.3236878216266632,
0.6029321551322937,
-0.24614952504634857,
-0.6592704653739929,
0.4597412943840027,
-0.13849198818206787,
0.0777672603726387,
-0.29188740253448486,
0.005172729957848787,
-0.1878187507390976,
0.38830098509788513,
0.13606040179729462,
-0.057092711329460144,
-0.1217552125453949,
-0.35061562061309814,
0.27075889706611633,
0.4953089952468872,
-0.2832711935043335,
-0.4132268726825714,
0.605534553527832,
0.04244665056467056,
-0.6018801331520081,
0.5846996307373047,
-0.1368303745985031,
-0.7387187480926514,
0.6150529384613037,
1.1526668071746826,
1.065803050994873,
-0.3825667202472687,
-0.13320671021938324,
0.1303240805864334,
0.6712411046028137,
0.14314310252666473,
0.18633146584033966,
-0.006841479334980249,
-0.7809292078018188,
-0.32937195897102356,
-0.17450696229934692,
-0.34857532382011414,
0.15146778523921967,
-0.37684184312820435,
-0.008882632479071617,
-0.9123630523681641,
0.04194611683487892,
-0.48493149876594543,
-0.4352602958679199,
-0.23237696290016174,
-0.15026594698429108,
0.39601394534111023,
0.9800364971160889,
-0.6132005453109741,
0.8452768325805664,
0.5949583053588867,
-0.2619938552379608,
-0.5374097228050232,
0.10543762892484665,
0.3970002233982086,
-0.8214305639266968,
0.8190540671348572,
0.23234200477600098,
-0.4245361387729645,
-0.1638229489326477,
-0.8943151831626892,
-0.9309605956077576,
0.5798785090446472,
0.43742525577545166,
-0.6742680668830872,
0.1666698008775711,
-0.18045806884765625,
0.0501260980963707,
-0.3007849454879761,
-0.23623301088809967,
0.7276293039321899,
0.4116414189338684,
-0.08986420929431915,
-0.36178770661354065,
0.5614033341407776,
-0.22607053816318512,
-0.24131892621517181,
0.2566678822040558,
-0.415711909532547,
0.8482697010040283,
-0.5408620238304138,
-0.19775789976119995,
0.4925074875354767,
0.7393726706504822,
0.743424654006958,
0.34552761912345886,
0.3218947649002075,
0.6133290529251099,
0.4622925817966461,
-0.09976112842559814,
0.9400907754898071,
-0.04332796111702919,
-0.06332269310951233,
1.197873592376709,
-0.3867686092853546,
0.637174665927887,
0.7411289215087891,
0.10000985115766525,
0.6028527617454529,
0.34541797637939453,
-0.3602682650089264,
0.8104566931724548,
0.6266371011734009,
-0.16492585837841034,
0.1804107129573822,
0.23350733518600464,
-0.3501526117324829,
0.2153778225183487,
0.36168810725212097,
-0.2353900521993637,
-0.3137248456478119,
0.4595755636692047,
0.6179230213165283,
0.3646131753921509,
-0.32156625390052795,
0.7309637665748596,
0.0621049627661705,
-0.5367602705955505,
0.7920411825180054,
0.35651877522468567,
0.6623906493186951,
-0.6137477159500122,
0.22028134763240814,
-0.38582220673561096,
0.10649532824754715,
-0.33107712864875793,
-0.6581819653511047,
0.3011140525341034,
0.4800696074962616,
-0.17196442186832428,
-0.20612235367298126,
0.8397727608680725,
-0.11348071694374084,
-0.08977958559989929,
0.3931078612804413,
0.07482217997312546,
0.03469165042042732,
0.04146542772650719,
-0.5444245934486389,
0.29794809222221375,
0.06426563858985901,
-0.4957118332386017,
0.44541123509407043,
0.10217223316431046,
-0.06915193051099777,
0.6196252703666687,
0.7065591216087341,
0.3267199695110321,
0.10454989224672318,
-0.003781464882194996,
1.0416308641433716,
-0.8708304762840271,
-0.615451455116272,
-1.6452813148498535,
0.28625521063804626,
0.05613398179411888,
0.1395452618598938,
1.0835994482040405,
0.4835716485977173,
0.7566744089126587,
0.2932523488998413,
0.8961851000785828,
0.06353991478681564,
0.36780431866645813,
-0.936543881893158,
0.6799650192260742,
-0.10276681929826736,
0.6683015823364258,
-0.3404105007648468,
-0.4608183801174164,
-0.2342299520969391,
0.3599187135696411,
-0.55710369348526,
-0.3180643320083618,
0.44885748624801636,
0.7796207666397095,
0.28389546275138855,
-0.13243556022644043,
0.21592916548252106,
0.24393883347511292,
0.6630329489707947,
0.7902398705482483,
1.360337495803833,
-0.06761622428894043,
0.6409361958503723,
-0.08110988140106201,
-0.061965763568878174,
-0.09344043582677841,
-0.7425124645233154,
-1.101664662361145,
0.21951107680797577,
0.1457616686820984,
-0.9218011498451233,
0.4952167570590973,
0.9310154318809509,
0.3497443199157715,
-0.8393551111221313,
-0.29744192957878113,
0.022345609962940216,
0.5016935467720032,
-0.14835593104362488,
-0.1295069307088852,
-0.06740308552980423,
-0.3216344714164734,
-0.08439214527606964,
1.0428662300109863,
0.1927233338356018,
0.08379587531089783,
-0.24004684388637543,
-0.04496759921312332,
-0.10498393326997757,
0.01714768260717392,
0.43794718384742737,
0.6695884466171265,
-0.7728544473648071,
-0.3656577169895172,
-0.09307139366865158,
-0.20534740388393402,
0.17022842168807983,
0.934700071811676,
-0.7905965447425842,
0.153532937169075,
0.38113072514533997,
1.0711718797683716,
0.3370792269706726,
-0.10800369083881378,
0.7055935263633728,
-0.8074120879173279,
0.4230521321296692,
0.042304620146751404,
0.49364134669303894,
0.30886971950531006,
-0.641141414642334,
0.19339784979820251,
0.3716370761394501,
-0.2713277041912079,
-0.9561703205108643,
0.6892854571342468,
-0.30256006121635437,
-0.48993444442749023,
0.9546497464179993,
-0.45106223225593567,
-0.4449904263019562,
-0.14089465141296387,
-0.31529664993286133,
-0.024229906499385834,
-0.602053165435791,
0.6876251697540283,
0.5560091137886047,
0.28145936131477356,
-0.23062796890735626,
-0.3040612041950226,
0.21841606497764587,
0.3785214424133301,
-0.6614552140235901,
0.38506317138671875,
0.3726966679096222,
0.47872117161750793,
0.07061397284269333,
0.39637452363967896,
-0.36662057042121887,
0.45103588700294495,
-0.22739902138710022,
-0.06893359124660492,
-0.353134423494339,
-0.36489593982696533,
-0.8167262673377991,
0.25507184863090515,
0.3084620237350464,
-0.326809287071228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16458v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16458v2
|
ID-XCB: Data-independent Debiasing for Fair and Accurate Transformer-based Cyberbullying Detection
| 2024-02-26T10:02:29 | 2024-02-27T12:52:24 |
Peiling Yi, Arkaitz Zubiaga
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Swear words are a common proxy to collect datasets with cyberbullying
incidents. Our focus is on measuring and mitigating biases derived from
spurious associations between swear words and incidents occurring as a result
of such data collection strategies. After demonstrating and quantifying these
biases, we introduce ID-XCB, the first data-independent debiasing technique
that combines adversarial training, bias constraints and debias fine-tuning
approach aimed at alleviating model attention to bias-inducing words without
impacting overall model performance. We explore ID-XCB on two popular
session-based cyberbullying datasets along with comprehensive ablation and
generalisation studies. We show that ID-XCB learns robust cyberbullying
detection capabilities while mitigating biases, outperforming state-of-the-art
debiasing methods in both performance and bias mitigation. Our quantitative and
qualitative analyses demonstrate its generalisability to unseen data.
|
[
-0.612079918384552,
-1.1680183410644531,
0.15475672483444214,
0.21276576817035675,
-0.3777172267436981,
0.3131326138973236,
0.13558615744113922,
-0.2728363573551178,
0.3855120837688446,
0.20163054764270782,
-0.465247243642807,
-0.48695820569992065,
-0.9790107011795044,
-0.19811992347240448,
-0.8767580986022949,
1.231898546218872,
0.4653799533843994,
0.19690309464931488,
-0.2844173014163971,
0.21248853206634521,
-0.4584600627422333,
-0.36714112758636475,
-0.8339431285858154,
-0.2505280077457428,
0.2586738169193268,
0.14323793351650238,
0.9732113480567932,
0.6600505709648132,
0.5186344981193542,
0.1730412393808365,
-0.2074078470468521,
0.021173613145947456,
-0.6569455862045288,
-0.13661691546440125,
-0.5481492877006531,
-0.3461042642593384,
-0.48215511441230774,
0.040288738906383514,
0.26160556077957153,
0.2917312681674957,
0.13661929965019226,
0.16295641660690308,
0.03169291839003563,
0.49028754234313965,
-0.7501844167709351,
0.07475411891937256,
-0.8978555798530579,
-0.055484455078840256,
-0.6059234142303467,
0.1931193768978119,
-0.23734310269355774,
-0.5180198550224304,
-0.17844073474407196,
-0.32342782616615295,
0.28059911727905273,
0.07630369067192078,
0.6879870295524597,
0.4025854170322418,
-0.5221264958381653,
-0.18008527159690857,
-0.37282228469848633,
0.6935146450996399,
-0.4844972789287567,
0.3151639997959137,
0.7346914410591125,
0.09733465313911438,
-0.06388741731643677,
-0.5073514580726624,
-0.7247389554977417,
0.13882435858249664,
-0.03877226635813713,
-0.03415385261178017,
-0.45430004596710205,
0.31265872716903687,
0.11993943154811859,
0.3415645956993103,
-0.2643487751483917,
0.3515367805957794,
-0.4167596995830536,
-0.21242685616016388,
0.7344778180122375,
0.2688949406147003,
-0.06470032781362534,
-0.25602269172668457,
-0.659612774848938,
-0.13148191571235657,
-0.5595983266830444,
0.18607647716999054,
0.7398325204849243,
0.392855703830719,
-0.4475826025009155,
0.018892982974648476,
-0.14510634541511536,
0.25607064366340637,
0.5187898278236389,
-0.12494639307260513,
0.18521960079669952,
-0.10158511251211166,
-0.216196671128273,
0.23421745002269745,
0.8573761582374573,
0.41874784231185913,
0.11940250545740128,
-0.28990963101387024,
0.022176619619131088,
0.7205818295478821,
0.4025905728340149,
-0.8829545974731445,
-0.5146874189376831,
0.30288562178611755,
-0.3531544804573059,
-1.0132595300674438,
0.11684094369411469,
-1.1050716638565063,
-0.9430872797966003,
-0.3410537838935852,
0.3256901502609253,
-0.23827816545963287,
-0.4631936550140381,
-0.23193910717964172,
-0.2183992564678192,
-0.14254792034626007,
-0.02439376711845398,
-0.5560173392295837,
0.5242156982421875,
0.5986467599868774,
0.49620917439460754,
-0.5978043675422668,
0.357232928276062,
-0.6092042326927185,
-0.3508119285106659,
-0.2922493517398834,
0.6216555237770081,
-0.6098144054412842,
-0.20408666133880615,
-0.11984745413064957,
-0.13448108732700348,
0.4956492483615875,
-0.6647708415985107,
0.9160416722297668,
-0.49998655915260315,
-0.3265184462070465,
-0.06571587175130844,
-0.2937430739402771,
-0.2421046495437622,
0.2637427747249603,
-0.5848398208618164,
1.046938419342041,
0.07718468457460403,
-0.8344440460205078,
0.8371540904045105,
-0.2043788731098175,
-0.6309548020362854,
0.0001401148474542424,
-0.026642724871635437,
-0.7929812669754028,
0.2910080552101135,
0.32269951701164246,
0.2916705012321472,
-0.43047255277633667,
0.6664279699325562,
-0.837530791759491,
-0.3754614591598511,
0.21315181255340576,
-0.8100775480270386,
1.183247447013855,
0.07695133239030838,
-0.8229135870933533,
-0.04092344641685486,
-1.111055850982666,
0.29479169845581055,
-0.014330090954899788,
0.10736499726772308,
-0.6756152510643005,
0.018544120714068413,
0.005431610159575939,
0.41847431659698486,
-0.38320285081863403,
-0.888740062713623,
-0.201198548078537,
-0.07619835436344147,
0.03894348815083504,
0.9068275690078735,
-0.16582931578159332,
-0.14899180829524994,
-0.22196950018405914,
0.4711417555809021,
0.42622414231300354,
0.12743154168128967,
0.17877891659736633,
-0.16858117282390594,
-0.39863845705986023,
-0.7543318271636963,
0.39476969838142395,
0.2562406659126282,
-0.7659146785736084,
0.42538514733314514,
-0.23050186038017273,
-0.4770665764808655,
-0.8087961077690125,
0.10766614973545074,
0.7580549120903015,
0.35940614342689514,
0.4624999761581421,
-0.4018884599208832,
-0.5513456463813782,
-0.7706191539764404,
-0.257473349571228,
-0.12402606010437012,
0.2390349805355072,
0.09063807874917984,
0.31015074253082275,
-0.04395349323749542,
1.0158380270004272,
-0.3380023241043091,
-0.6825566291809082,
0.12446750700473785,
0.23619715869426727,
-0.04800443723797798,
0.2683987617492676,
0.7533811926841736,
-0.96330326795578,
-0.7596058249473572,
-0.41586214303970337,
-0.6244416832923889,
-0.4533539414405823,
-0.27296558022499084,
0.07251755148172379,
-0.07839497923851013,
0.4851849675178528,
-0.038568805903196335,
0.94386887550354,
0.552396297454834,
-0.5992964506149292,
0.5909269452095032,
0.3016052544116974,
0.20194056630134583,
-0.3008767068386078,
-0.1183297261595726,
-0.11212358623743057,
-0.5198358297348022,
-0.6549622416496277,
0.010956023819744587,
0.17398618161678314,
0.22998666763305664,
-0.5374886393547058,
0.6001291871070862,
-0.32659775018692017,
0.45481544733047485,
-0.6436885595321655,
0.5997689366340637,
-0.00673172390088439,
0.48122844099998474,
-0.12218895554542542,
0.2794356048107147,
0.8411841988563538,
-0.7641472816467285,
0.38235804438591003,
0.4298127293586731,
-0.25570622086524963,
1.272786259651184,
-0.4635144770145416,
0.2808726727962494,
-0.2595720589160919,
-0.09823720157146454,
-1.0971359014511108,
0.14232894778251648,
0.28778567910194397,
-0.4886942207813263,
0.27878648042678833,
-0.07384321093559265,
-0.2810458540916443,
-0.6545559167861938,
-0.5194008350372314,
0.30145376920700073,
0.19791679084300995,
-1.0589462518692017,
0.10627329349517822,
0.7794594764709473,
0.18085458874702454,
-0.7767550349235535,
-0.5125094652175903,
0.10674681514501572,
-0.31845906376838684,
-0.39018598198890686,
0.5510754585266113,
-0.15271714329719543,
-0.5572423934936523,
-0.2376091182231903,
-0.36043673753738403,
-0.2657199800014496,
0.28514689207077026,
0.4848213195800781,
0.10468784719705582,
0.45997029542922974,
-0.051785096526145935,
0.5687633156776428,
-0.024812743067741394,
0.5225792527198792,
0.09271007031202316,
0.32737940549850464,
0.3639811873435974,
-0.17560698091983795,
-0.37533125281333923,
0.1783866286277771,
0.2690246105194092,
0.15977448225021362,
0.40151798725128174,
0.5976278781890869,
-0.328887015581131,
-0.3103916645050049,
-0.4393019676208496,
-0.3370513916015625,
-0.4645083546638489,
0.29553934931755066,
-0.35689210891723633,
-0.2652253806591034,
0.24161368608474731,
0.22996185719966888,
0.009663754142820835,
-0.2828589677810669,
0.5562251806259155,
0.25021469593048096,
1.1416926383972168,
0.4577668607234955,
-0.29526233673095703,
0.312727689743042,
0.12157143652439117,
0.3468523919582367,
-0.44260117411613464,
0.08963318169116974,
-0.18239344656467438,
-0.7330990433692932,
-0.45179131627082825,
-0.0038750171661376953,
0.3123459815979004,
0.001034214161336422,
-0.04743129387497902,
0.1807451844215393,
-0.5123413801193237,
0.388651579618454,
0.47368162870407104,
0.5249264240264893,
0.3923850655555725,
-0.06084110587835312,
0.14661791920661926,
-0.19363202154636383,
-0.14945891499519348,
0.06473632156848907,
1.234512209892273,
0.0974867194890976,
0.8310543298721313,
0.10169602185487747,
0.5348635315895081,
0.7140262126922607,
0.49088960886001587,
-0.6821539998054504,
0.468648225069046,
-0.2380157858133316,
-1.2232335805892944,
0.09566638618707657,
-0.23584741353988647,
-0.7955279350280762,
0.42753544449806213,
-0.37075284123420715,
-0.7476337552070618,
0.33748647570610046,
0.31367117166519165,
-0.21374614536762238,
0.6213008165359497,
-0.2150464951992035,
0.37727412581443787,
-0.1390713006258011,
-0.8467521071434021,
-0.4809996485710144,
-0.5851392149925232,
0.6752439141273499,
-0.30923789739608765,
0.39319750666618347,
-0.009686789475381374,
0.3635994493961334,
0.6179195642471313,
-0.3894224762916565,
1.0640404224395752,
-0.4721713960170746,
-0.1638772189617157,
0.6640372276306152,
0.19894134998321533,
0.4065453112125397,
0.23959702253341675,
0.05365629494190216,
0.5078890919685364,
-0.13640791177749634,
0.013350184075534344,
-0.26585251092910767,
0.759663999080658,
-0.42992332577705383,
-0.6985031366348267,
-0.27970701456069946,
-0.5667489767074585,
-0.08489610254764557,
0.3506224453449249,
0.0478539876639843,
0.3342408537864685,
-0.3230378329753876,
0.376086562871933,
0.7476053237915039,
0.12297305464744568,
0.3271125257015228,
0.4264829754829407,
-0.3648722767829895,
-0.5758673548698425,
0.7892613410949707,
-0.06158805266022682,
0.11995621770620346,
0.23270821571350098,
0.19990606606006622,
-0.18668028712272644,
-0.426653116941452,
-0.2490648478269577,
0.01458828803151846,
-0.5174253582954407,
-0.5903205275535583,
-0.6603001952171326,
0.2243603616952896,
-0.5580512881278992,
-0.0673559159040451,
-0.31168845295906067,
-0.4585045576095581,
0.028165720403194427,
-0.301450252532959,
0.3187147378921509,
0.32461225986480713,
-0.4604610502719879,
0.6516369581222534,
-0.3120839595794678,
0.837546169757843,
0.0633755698800087,
0.4165867865085602,
-0.2481684684753418,
-0.7989394664764404,
-0.11058653891086578,
0.1496930867433548,
-0.7302191853523254,
-1.001693606376648,
0.2792833149433136,
0.05541427433490753,
0.20262393355369568,
0.8511921763420105,
0.492726594209671,
0.6451192498207092,
0.17210809886455536,
0.522682249546051,
0.10726096481084824,
-1.1227684020996094,
0.1787651628255844,
-0.23760975897312164,
-0.2124146968126297,
0.514163613319397,
0.5946364402770996,
-0.30475565791130066,
-0.39110007882118225,
-0.8480595350265503,
-0.7000426650047302,
0.7584433555603027,
0.04853324219584465,
0.015224882401525974,
-0.3188130855560303,
0.1306343376636505,
0.32795611023902893,
0.5478922128677368,
-0.8589965105056763,
-0.8700667023658752,
-0.16035297513008118,
-0.16395533084869385,
0.4995519518852234,
-0.2375829815864563,
-0.15645425021648407,
-0.1961364895105362,
1.1146048307418823,
-0.1588713675737381,
-0.04909370094537735,
-0.17833630740642548,
-0.3142148554325104,
0.060706619173288345,
0.04435577988624573,
-0.04480141028761864,
0.17213457822799683,
0.06173068284988403,
0.03435805067420006,
0.1460680365562439,
-0.8448034524917603,
0.3101324439048767,
-0.011849808506667614,
-0.40803465247154236,
0.1455773413181305,
-0.3547004759311676,
0.699375569820404,
-0.08084164559841156,
-0.5805467963218689,
0.8229622840881348,
-0.04179788753390312,
-0.1467551738023758,
-0.22383040189743042,
-0.05070192739367485,
-0.34258413314819336,
0.1256798952817917,
-0.031350959092378616,
-0.13705697655677795,
0.25120100378990173,
-0.19482049345970154,
0.32780635356903076,
0.7631455659866333,
-0.7607385516166687,
-0.44775617122650146,
1.1501283645629883,
0.1520218849182129,
0.1136462390422821,
0.5689613819122314,
-0.513983964920044,
-0.23904483020305634,
0.4915523827075958,
0.6266460418701172,
0.909891664981842,
-0.3531220853328705,
0.3762930929660797,
0.3605918288230896,
0.2528668940067291,
0.3669988811016083,
0.23961324989795685,
-0.1582994908094406,
-0.6756766438484192,
0.10026796907186508,
-0.2948232591152191,
-0.18665733933448792,
0.41240233182907104,
-0.8503508567810059,
0.9153100252151489,
-0.8932152390480042,
-0.5853717923164368,
0.011319327168166637,
-0.10932182520627975,
-0.7997031211853027,
0.7249481081962585,
0.41973060369491577,
0.6592704653739929,
-0.8413092494010925,
0.6576964259147644,
0.4093264937400818,
-0.0712408795952797,
-0.19062376022338867,
-0.4017558693885803,
0.6066059470176697,
-0.7509686946868896,
0.6525599360466003,
0.13338306546211243,
-0.04664313793182373,
-0.06403930485248566,
-0.5791440606117249,
-0.8240981101989746,
0.6624237298965454,
0.19916680455207825,
-0.5378670692443848,
0.07944555580615997,
0.3038788437843323,
0.45423752069473267,
0.11462601274251938,
0.6086581945419312,
0.9332144260406494,
0.47414252161979675,
-0.4724269509315491,
-0.6948410272598267,
0.1368853747844696,
-0.07695549726486206,
-0.3413594663143158,
0.42166051268577576,
-0.7849095463752747,
0.6046236753463745,
-0.1422480344772339,
-0.3620639443397522,
-0.17882244288921356,
0.6181591153144836,
-0.16607289016246796,
0.4044210612773895,
0.5696855783462524,
0.6726788282394409,
0.7451683282852173,
-0.30298465490341187,
0.5490840673446655,
-0.23211254179477692,
0.08457359671592712,
1.3369191884994507,
-0.023663314059376717,
0.013252587988972664,
0.3566962480545044,
-0.375316858291626,
0.5648016929626465,
0.17574456334114075,
-0.17529082298278809,
0.6053208708763123,
0.497905969619751,
-0.2589217722415924,
-0.03792392835021019,
-0.21818092465400696,
0.019914640113711357,
0.7720130085945129,
0.48630350828170776,
-0.36441999673843384,
-0.2211776077747345,
0.2670484781265259,
0.7379014492034912,
0.23742444813251495,
-0.607922375202179,
0.8191136717796326,
-0.06650924682617188,
-0.4818180203437805,
0.7449241876602173,
-0.15659716725349426,
1.0052807331085205,
-0.47000017762184143,
0.2076231688261032,
-0.2325843870639801,
0.6035507917404175,
-0.47180289030075073,
-0.53815096616745,
0.3291623890399933,
-0.06754475831985474,
-0.2609383463859558,
-0.0022264013532549143,
0.7400882840156555,
-0.3031662404537201,
-0.2061029076576233,
0.4452833831310272,
0.14995452761650085,
0.07305454462766647,
-0.3698396384716034,
-0.5401954054832458,
0.00589556060731411,
0.160330131649971,
-0.021778825670480728,
0.44866859912872314,
0.2980118691921234,
-0.3399530053138733,
0.5672566890716553,
0.433218389749527,
0.10711532086133957,
0.09087567031383514,
-0.2281053066253662,
0.8549049496650696,
-0.44258880615234375,
-0.6526224613189697,
-0.8240168690681458,
0.6219550967216492,
-0.25053009390830994,
-0.44545963406562805,
0.761469841003418,
0.2862149775028229,
1.089120626449585,
0.17751376330852509,
0.9188404083251953,
-0.42366859316825867,
0.6446810960769653,
0.06068500131368637,
0.576113224029541,
-0.1548018455505371,
-0.1255999356508255,
-0.7039740681648254,
-0.7098075151443481,
-0.2420833855867386,
0.1855173408985138,
-0.13076157867908478,
-0.20412220060825348,
0.6174001097679138,
0.8267374038696289,
-0.06969042867422104,
0.19538454711437225,
0.5229772329330444,
0.2439819723367691,
0.5362279415130615,
0.08133712410926819,
0.11043994873762131,
-0.8092004656791687,
0.7321174740791321,
-0.47855880856513977,
-0.5590412020683289,
-0.030533235520124435,
-0.8664814829826355,
-1.2031545639038086,
-0.22355008125305176,
-0.7156846523284912,
-0.41903457045555115,
0.0795094445347786,
0.7264782190322876,
0.5798341035842896,
-1.0360358953475952,
0.20358264446258545,
0.2369915246963501,
0.2971091568470001,
-0.6802279949188232,
-0.3396350145339966,
0.09339290857315063,
-0.20881147682666779,
-1.0289753675460815,
0.3991016447544098,
-0.1760314404964447,
-0.21425890922546387,
-0.24110448360443115,
0.4805225729942322,
-0.052298251539468765,
0.27375054359436035,
0.5721828937530518,
0.042042285203933716,
-0.20262779295444489,
-0.29164794087409973,
-0.31334879994392395,
0.24102680385112762,
0.29481494426727295,
0.628645122051239,
-1.1314736604690552,
0.6831833124160767,
0.49176716804504395,
0.7063347101211548,
0.32112863659858704,
0.1812080591917038,
0.1546688973903656,
-1.1022465229034424,
0.17206890881061554,
-0.19028012454509735,
0.17499466240406036,
0.24187661707401276,
-0.4430171549320221,
0.42761102318763733,
0.41892296075820923,
-0.4472472369670868,
-0.9769837260246277,
0.1119588166475296,
-0.42157813906669617,
-0.20941954851150513,
0.8918077945709229,
-0.07725945115089417,
-0.06430649012327194,
-0.3989531397819519,
-0.2594040334224701,
0.1402389258146286,
-0.3978661596775055,
1.4004685878753662,
0.4886428117752075,
0.2583637833595276,
0.41617000102996826,
-0.05099543556571007,
0.5325661897659302,
0.2681487500667572,
-0.7633746862411499,
0.5020779371261597,
0.44091060757637024,
0.2296522855758667,
0.1788731962442398,
0.2166222482919693,
-0.3097319006919861,
0.26300156116485596,
0.17382711172103882,
0.11343330889940262,
-0.17548483610153198,
-0.4738354980945587,
-0.2535889744758606,
0.14294762909412384,
-0.6206250786781311,
-0.13930413126945496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16457v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16457v2
|
RetrievalQA: Assessing Adaptive Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Short-form Open-Domain Question Answering
| 2024-02-26T09:59:04 | 2024-06-05T05:23:21 |
Zihan Zhang, Meng Fang, Ling Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Adaptive retrieval-augmented generation (ARAG) aims to dynamically determine
the necessity of retrieval for queries instead of retrieving indiscriminately
to enhance the efficiency and relevance of the sourced information. However,
previous works largely overlook the evaluation of ARAG approaches, leading to
their effectiveness being understudied. This work presents a benchmark,
RetrievalQA, comprising 1,271 short-form questions covering new world and
long-tail knowledge. The knowledge necessary to answer the questions is absent
from LLMs; therefore, external information must be retrieved to answer
correctly. This makes RetrievalQA a suitable testbed to evaluate existing ARAG
methods. We observe that calibration-based methods heavily rely on threshold
tuning, while vanilla prompting is inadequate for guiding LLMs to make reliable
retrieval decisions. Based on our findings, we propose Time-Aware Adaptive
Retrieval (TA-ARE), a simple yet effective method that helps LLMs assess the
necessity of retrieval without calibration or additional training. The dataset
and code will be available at https://github.com/hyintell/RetrievalQA
|
[
-0.5422832369804382,
-1.0770961046218872,
0.46325647830963135,
0.16020123660564423,
-0.3965388238430023,
0.33937400579452515,
0.010718829929828644,
-0.537476658821106,
0.1236930638551712,
0.12497774511575699,
-0.5777234435081482,
-0.2422131597995758,
-0.35438272356987,
0.36943089962005615,
-0.15502703189849854,
0.41490015387535095,
-0.23747675120830536,
-0.2754652500152588,
-0.41722193360328674,
-0.42556658387184143,
-0.5540681481361389,
-0.003099963767454028,
-0.734819769859314,
-0.19890402257442474,
0.18875084817409515,
0.334297776222229,
0.4367094039916992,
0.24809172749519348,
0.23483294248580933,
0.09803418070077896,
-0.2552514374256134,
0.7176173329353333,
-0.2868480980396271,
0.15050570666790009,
-0.1332807093858719,
-0.27213114500045776,
-0.4437156617641449,
-0.01101616956293583,
0.6406271457672119,
0.6250041127204895,
-0.22568711638450623,
0.7733852863311768,
0.15936821699142456,
0.7797812223434448,
-1.1092525720596313,
-0.14608410000801086,
-0.8175193071365356,
0.1441878229379654,
-0.03225991874933243,
-0.5498600006103516,
-0.32208573818206787,
-0.6799262166023254,
0.25089287757873535,
-0.8527308106422424,
0.10579370707273483,
0.4033104479312897,
0.45286017656326294,
0.49546217918395996,
-0.7248620390892029,
-0.38666847348213196,
-0.4508751630783081,
0.7283334136009216,
-0.42624494433403015,
0.42927873134613037,
0.4031365215778351,
0.6237525939941406,
-0.26166024804115295,
-0.8435699343681335,
-0.3249714970588684,
-0.17298384010791779,
0.3764916956424713,
0.3881278932094574,
-0.34702810645103455,
-0.20180442929267883,
0.23456470668315887,
0.48141834139823914,
-0.4972935616970062,
-0.1679459661245346,
-0.2080342322587967,
-0.22664445638656616,
0.2923416793346405,
0.047978322952985764,
0.018701406195759773,
-0.29229748249053955,
-0.6953433752059937,
0.21661196649074554,
-0.8762596249580383,
0.12523941695690155,
0.27734053134918213,
0.214500293135643,
0.1322290003299713,
0.4922005832195282,
-0.3758373260498047,
0.7287362813949585,
0.1607484370470047,
0.3016897141933441,
0.10743163526058197,
-0.3323819637298584,
-0.080411396920681,
0.007783686742186546,
0.3857848346233368,
0.25961166620254517,
0.1320992410182953,
-0.19113628566265106,
-0.15629258751869202,
-0.4426184892654419,
0.33911505341529846,
-0.5342027544975281,
0.24687817692756653,
0.1224612146615982,
-0.17196062207221985,
0.09166864305734634,
-0.19317170977592468,
-0.6418051719665527,
-0.18244823813438416,
-0.06169000267982483,
0.9555660486221313,
-0.3575136065483093,
-0.02048749476671219,
0.11226321756839752,
-0.20866145193576813,
0.3966447114944458,
0.3445712625980377,
-0.2958313226699829,
0.368723601102829,
0.3547625243663788,
0.7908684611320496,
-0.3615730404853821,
-0.04129275679588318,
-0.9861076474189758,
0.07854636013507843,
-0.45692315697669983,
0.9183520674705505,
-0.2874797284603119,
-0.43024933338165283,
-0.06279632449150085,
-0.06397247314453125,
0.1023160070180893,
-0.6718720197677612,
0.5598479509353638,
-1.113061785697937,
0.24332097172737122,
-0.5275014638900757,
-0.3664376735687256,
-0.2605153024196625,
0.5530178546905518,
-0.7722471952438354,
1.3038629293441772,
0.310650110244751,
-0.4346620440483093,
0.6028261780738831,
-0.6751942038536072,
-0.1416676789522171,
0.30955761671066284,
0.10096076875925064,
-0.24888844788074493,
-0.015135716646909714,
0.6962341666221619,
0.07902975380420685,
-0.5810727477073669,
-0.11076704412698746,
-0.11311837285757065,
-0.6207235455513,
0.03144527226686478,
-0.37493956089019775,
0.6340177655220032,
0.3353014588356018,
-0.2941327691078186,
-0.3318842053413391,
-0.8036923408508301,
0.5331758856773376,
0.018635204061865807,
-0.5194885730743408,
-0.31546077132225037,
0.09667079150676727,
-0.5444818139076233,
-0.22940827906131744,
0.30781304836273193,
-0.5752524733543396,
0.16602590680122375,
-0.45347195863723755,
0.31416210532188416,
0.7722310423851013,
0.5476351976394653,
0.3286072015762329,
-0.669009804725647,
0.8868271112442017,
-0.08953802287578583,
0.157255619764328,
0.3353681266307831,
-0.2895335853099823,
-0.5865016579627991,
0.2343500703573227,
0.47200459241867065,
0.46305978298187256,
-1.1498339176177979,
-0.017823580652475357,
-0.25009194016456604,
-0.43316206336021423,
-0.4209258258342743,
0.26585230231285095,
0.38598746061325073,
0.6380774974822998,
0.6055200099945068,
-0.3849603533744812,
-0.669988751411438,
-0.48529261350631714,
-0.5426245927810669,
-0.30392879247665405,
0.08197712898254395,
0.6506174206733704,
0.5185206532478333,
0.19260206818580627,
0.8742387294769287,
-0.2960345447063446,
0.10677307099103928,
0.22944164276123047,
0.07246750593185425,
-0.0802871361374855,
-0.03473367169499397,
0.4533141851425171,
-0.7919895052909851,
-0.37235644459724426,
-0.36834147572517395,
-0.8015850782394409,
-0.2509492039680481,
0.27561429142951965,
-0.2891123294830322,
0.07194195687770844,
0.46717092394828796,
-0.4478950500488281,
0.3726375997066498,
0.344594806432724,
-0.08134710043668747,
0.5785614848136902,
-0.047940175980329514,
0.5102511048316956,
-0.8052042126655579,
0.33041617274284363,
-0.28939545154571533,
-0.36499789357185364,
-0.11068534851074219,
0.2165440022945404,
0.16929402947425842,
-0.08155835419893265,
-0.8539624810218811,
1.1418225765228271,
-0.7908478379249573,
-0.20418062806129456,
-0.2129848450422287,
0.43641266226768494,
0.20942388474941254,
0.22215664386749268,
-0.34786257147789,
1.2675511837005615,
0.12228076159954071,
-1.0158181190490723,
0.3686932325363159,
0.2531530559062958,
-0.6625059843063354,
0.3115035891532898,
-0.6018540859222412,
0.4571593701839447,
0.030834954231977463,
0.11210019141435623,
-0.7212071418762207,
-0.0695074200630188,
0.16776002943515778,
-0.5292676091194153,
-0.16983523964881897,
-0.37582001090049744,
-0.48320654034614563,
-0.33806923031806946,
-0.3220348060131073,
0.7823693156242371,
0.6449481248855591,
-0.7519404888153076,
0.614196240901947,
0.08313348144292831,
0.07720925658941269,
-0.8968722820281982,
-0.32488134503364563,
-0.13702614605426788,
-0.25379690527915955,
-0.37390121817588806,
0.2823949456214905,
-0.11387810111045837,
-0.2220735251903534,
-0.04263477027416229,
-0.518036425113678,
0.11332860589027405,
0.2753884196281433,
-0.04932532459497452,
-0.04984793812036514,
-0.3618435263633728,
0.2643803358078003,
0.15420371294021606,
0.18791551887989044,
0.08463545888662338,
-0.22086822986602783,
0.27290740609169006,
0.05530494078993797,
-0.40038517117500305,
0.15582111477851868,
0.17996323108673096,
0.2975235879421234,
-0.48926836252212524,
0.49242550134658813,
0.42943817377090454,
-0.4813889265060425,
-0.46165692806243896,
-0.5861642360687256,
0.012412087060511112,
-0.4744126796722412,
-0.06572811305522919,
-0.3647392988204956,
-0.7722567915916443,
0.5035579204559326,
-0.24401040375232697,
-0.005065741948783398,
0.3626813590526581,
0.39585214853286743,
-0.01893841102719307,
0.7481268048286438,
0.38853907585144043,
0.3642275035381317,
0.2695457339286804,
-0.024912122637033463,
-0.18401268124580383,
-0.9996480345726013,
-0.22616539895534515,
-0.4008690118789673,
-0.10796176642179489,
-0.27206748723983765,
-0.39670294523239136,
0.7071908712387085,
0.4248789846897125,
-0.40603750944137573,
-0.03154100477695465,
-0.5009158849716187,
0.5083122849464417,
0.5245943665504456,
0.36229175329208374,
0.4338388741016388,
-0.11022879183292389,
-0.04073520004749298,
0.25073739886283875,
-0.5556987524032593,
-0.4509509205818176,
1.231196641921997,
-0.19614891707897186,
0.7116725444793701,
0.2891278862953186,
0.4799674153327942,
0.7346577644348145,
-0.008939497172832489,
-0.7199518084526062,
0.6196686029434204,
0.11797413975000381,
-0.6656890511512756,
-0.2636026442050934,
-0.5475861430168152,
-1.164608359336853,
0.05046625807881355,
-0.12246397882699966,
-0.4187455475330353,
0.028041688725352287,
0.2729358375072479,
-0.6876485347747803,
0.15304477512836456,
-0.6538808941841125,
0.3798607587814331,
-0.1916791945695877,
-0.23349879682064056,
-0.06296154856681824,
-0.4369043707847595,
0.2779707610607147,
-0.17854107916355133,
-0.059361882507801056,
-0.2958574593067169,
-0.3035857081413269,
0.9794801473617554,
-0.20085063576698303,
0.37447622418403625,
-0.458814799785614,
0.2551824450492859,
0.9046701192855835,
0.2712741494178772,
0.3564565181732178,
0.08661061525344849,
-0.35753893852233887,
-0.3449724316596985,
0.4237131178379059,
-0.6336637139320374,
-0.7326210737228394,
0.5366172790527344,
-0.6957386136054993,
-0.7442946434020996,
-0.515372097492218,
-0.29426005482673645,
-0.5545629858970642,
0.27162009477615356,
0.09769538044929504,
0.34057021141052246,
-0.30858781933784485,
0.1853329837322235,
0.6730909943580627,
-0.2139633446931839,
0.22036585211753845,
0.6423863768577576,
-0.16595380008220673,
-0.3291296064853668,
0.5349083542823792,
0.15206559002399445,
0.2870647609233856,
0.43540939688682556,
0.24826297163963318,
-0.5353557467460632,
-0.5211777091026306,
-0.5321271419525146,
-0.03288925439119339,
-0.6872311234474182,
-0.5399510860443115,
-0.2964266240596771,
-0.1028783991932869,
-0.4028269052505493,
0.2562960386276245,
0.032116468995809555,
-0.556144654750824,
-0.25677046179771423,
0.08420982211828232,
0.6354678273200989,
0.2796657383441925,
-0.0010767545318230987,
0.186527818441391,
-0.7978386282920837,
0.5692781209945679,
0.5382106900215149,
0.37570929527282715,
-0.02134857326745987,
-0.6678076386451721,
-0.14483998715877533,
0.18311302363872528,
-0.48006492853164673,
-0.6769728064537048,
-0.0789177343249321,
0.5939121842384338,
0.6802851557731628,
-0.33155572414398193,
0.3990026116371155,
0.7376945614814758,
-0.48366764187812805,
0.8372156023979187,
-0.3917882442474365,
-0.8806183338165283,
0.8841181993484497,
-0.0781979188323021,
0.5321782827377319,
0.7261559963226318,
0.5253270268440247,
-0.3253432810306549,
0.15763229131698608,
-0.32855522632598877,
-0.7844130992889404,
0.4077873229980469,
-0.10467017441987991,
-0.17080266773700714,
-0.2540630102157593,
0.8218247294425964,
0.22353611886501312,
0.1385038048028946,
-0.4343492388725281,
-0.03632531687617302,
0.012062178924679756,
0.0824340209364891,
0.16784317791461945,
-0.10996027290821075,
0.003428798634558916,
0.22742503881454468,
0.7081408500671387,
-0.2702941596508026,
0.34788796305656433,
0.28458794951438904,
-0.4549925923347473,
-0.32376769185066223,
0.4075263738632202,
0.21450218558311462,
0.9549965858459473,
-0.40455392003059387,
0.017107443884015083,
0.51255202293396,
-0.5197718143463135,
0.39967694878578186,
-0.02298223227262497,
-0.14547407627105713,
-0.24825800955295563,
0.16611185669898987,
0.43960845470428467,
-0.07466715574264526,
-0.7873702645301819,
0.5209270119667053,
-0.1545247733592987,
-0.10808901488780975,
-0.45707887411117554,
0.23110586404800415,
-0.4131518602371216,
0.20210199058055878,
0.6803618669509888,
-0.08691283315420151,
0.12777072191238403,
-0.44796761870384216,
0.17817078530788422,
0.42535102367401123,
-0.38058072328567505,
-0.031365323811769485,
0.7541044354438782,
0.11452948302030563,
-0.2718311548233032,
0.6318650245666504,
-0.17161624133586884,
-0.1068497970700264,
0.43572670221328735,
0.26508790254592896,
0.6579387187957764,
-0.009855782613158226,
-0.018089551478624344,
0.32584983110427856,
0.22770093381404877,
0.00701666297391057,
0.7143033146858215,
-0.24728639423847198,
-0.5318225026130676,
-0.6277115941047668,
-0.6382521390914917,
-0.6844973564147949,
0.11716805398464203,
-0.8653165102005005,
0.14347895979881287,
-0.48374825716018677,
-0.3827981650829315,
-0.26079753041267395,
0.21947021782398224,
-0.6683880686759949,
0.31438860297203064,
-0.374996155500412,
1.323302149772644,
-0.4699685275554657,
0.3097478747367859,
0.6687398552894592,
-0.236135795712471,
-0.4431430399417877,
-0.027772650122642517,
-0.1692780703306198,
-1.1089738607406616,
0.432158499956131,
-0.11106912791728973,
-0.3886513113975525,
0.1873985081911087,
-0.5509440302848816,
-0.789089560508728,
1.3316758871078491,
0.3696633577346802,
0.08705258369445801,
-0.2976769506931305,
-0.08757749944925308,
0.4040212631225586,
0.10443859547376633,
0.2142844945192337,
0.3713751435279846,
0.26028841733932495,
-0.08998490124940872,
-0.8262485861778259,
0.09809345752000809,
-0.3023449182510376,
-0.21112194657325745,
0.44229191541671753,
-0.7336556315422058,
0.46343815326690674,
-0.15882913768291473,
-0.3930693566799164,
0.423794686794281,
0.6980044841766357,
0.47322526574134827,
0.4116179049015045,
0.6937625408172607,
0.4305155277252197,
0.598008394241333,
-0.12687508761882782,
0.7613518238067627,
-0.3093160390853882,
0.02620411105453968,
0.98030686378479,
-0.15750589966773987,
0.9589490294456482,
0.5667513608932495,
-0.15525633096694946,
0.31458476185798645,
0.7192861437797546,
0.3327016532421112,
0.5355989336967468,
0.22470642626285553,
-0.5396111607551575,
-0.33319586515426636,
-0.06971289962530136,
-0.4465523362159729,
0.44046398997306824,
0.22937346994876862,
0.03431502357125282,
-0.3442307412624359,
0.1588997095823288,
-0.5247978568077087,
0.16080723702907562,
-0.37743058800697327,
0.6515780091285706,
0.06324716657400131,
-0.9650871157646179,
0.8334838151931763,
-0.10952703654766083,
0.38274452090263367,
-0.589937150478363,
-0.19814209640026093,
-0.33336344361305237,
-0.11912740021944046,
-0.014159109443426132,
-0.6998280882835388,
-0.004356355406343937,
0.048303283751010895,
-0.07051513344049454,
0.018593333661556244,
0.6422260999679565,
0.05524200573563576,
-0.21891632676124573,
0.1736619770526886,
1.0365668535232544,
0.11884766817092896,
-0.056750986725091934,
-0.5846646428108215,
-0.30779707431793213,
-0.186993807554245,
-0.22850501537322998,
0.11051218956708908,
0.5005747079849243,
-0.21897827088832855,
0.8476665019989014,
0.39111319184303284,
0.18289715051651,
0.35295748710632324,
-0.05361759290099144,
0.4824489653110504,
-0.6171078085899353,
-0.32146474719047546,
-0.42931464314460754,
0.21858122944831848,
0.3460216522216797,
-0.39369332790374756,
0.683607280254364,
0.5968888998031616,
0.6635271906852722,
0.28786900639533997,
0.5274117588996887,
-0.012934505008161068,
0.976538360118866,
-0.8024667501449585,
0.4687568247318268,
-0.8954361081123352,
0.39014846086502075,
0.04353771358728409,
-1.0465480089187622,
-0.04793122410774231,
0.03480935096740723,
-0.3924742043018341,
0.28667309880256653,
0.5199803709983826,
0.6739887595176697,
-0.19033117592334747,
0.058276787400245667,
0.10435982048511505,
-0.20169787108898163,
0.23137691617012024,
0.7379438281059265,
1.2231526374816895,
-0.7271241545677185,
0.8015763163566589,
-0.05891481786966324,
-0.11916597932577133,
-0.051664166152477264,
-0.9344572424888611,
-0.609968900680542,
-0.5466395020484924,
-0.23033511638641357,
-0.459919810295105,
0.4492439031600952,
0.8863909840583801,
0.40697476267814636,
-0.4410383105278015,
0.01245729997754097,
0.20712634921073914,
-0.03025401569902897,
-0.28849664330482483,
-0.16534683108329773,
0.5611556768417358,
-0.23054049909114838,
-0.4417155981063843,
0.5956214070320129,
-0.059718839824199677,
0.15906627476215363,
0.02211477980017662,
0.08626522868871689,
-0.3053652346134186,
-0.0071989125572144985,
0.5844765901565552,
0.575780987739563,
-0.6230127215385437,
-0.6273419857025146,
0.2486158311367035,
0.13097797334194183,
0.245487779378891,
0.5715809464454651,
-1.2597594261169434,
0.5117066502571106,
0.36602815985679626,
0.8510119915008545,
0.5469526648521423,
0.39714980125427246,
0.3080902695655823,
-0.961070716381073,
-0.22900958359241486,
0.5162950754165649,
0.1492667943239212,
0.14461681246757507,
-0.16011083126068115,
0.5725868344306946,
0.11484033614397049,
-0.6869208812713623,
-0.8822178840637207,
0.08116866648197174,
-0.8795275092124939,
-0.10957727581262589,
1.0448312759399414,
0.004441425669938326,
-0.2519542872905731,
-0.06192013993859291,
0.0016780068399384618,
0.24076710641384125,
-0.20652735233306885,
0.735192060470581,
0.571145236492157,
-0.25708115100860596,
-0.21874970197677612,
-0.5012988448143005,
0.32515639066696167,
0.44993913173675537,
-0.7225908041000366,
-0.14337310194969177,
0.36229535937309265,
0.3362080752849579,
-0.001373527804389596,
0.6910426616668701,
-0.1785261332988739,
0.7377119660377502,
-0.14070160686969757,
-0.23943521082401276,
-0.16278214752674103,
-0.08496614545583725,
-0.14281168580055237,
0.16584639251232147,
0.4790302813053131,
-0.23176681995391846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16444v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16444v1
|
ShieldLM: Empowering LLMs as Aligned, Customizable and Explainable Safety Detectors
| 2024-02-26T09:43:02 | 2024-02-26T09:43:02 |
Zhexin Zhang, Yida Lu, Jingyuan Ma, Di Zhang, Rui Li, Pei Ke, Hao Sun, Lei Sha, Zhifang Sui, Hongning Wang, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The safety of Large Language Models (LLMs) has gained increasing attention in
recent years, but there still lacks a comprehensive approach for detecting
safety issues within LLMs' responses in an aligned, customizable and
explainable manner. In this paper, we propose ShieldLM, an LLM-based safety
detector, which aligns with general human safety standards, supports
customizable detection rules, and provides explanations for its decisions. To
train ShieldLM, we compile a large bilingual dataset comprising 14,387
query-response pairs, annotating the safety of responses based on various
safety standards. Through extensive experiments, we demonstrate that ShieldLM
surpasses strong baselines across four test sets, showcasing remarkable
customizability and explainability. Besides performing well on standard
detection datasets, ShieldLM has also been shown to be effective in real-world
situations as a safety evaluator for advanced LLMs. We release ShieldLM at
\url{https://github.com/thu-coai/ShieldLM} to support accurate and explainable
safety detection under various safety standards, contributing to the ongoing
efforts to enhance the safety of LLMs.
|
[
-0.44863182306289673,
-0.6490423083305359,
0.47837626934051514,
0.025321045890450478,
-0.23460695147514343,
0.4425123929977417,
0.13657626509666443,
-0.4392140209674835,
0.04245913401246071,
0.5729420185089111,
-0.4722537398338318,
-0.7983697056770325,
-0.5401204228401184,
-0.005098357796669006,
-0.40837225317955017,
0.9433788061141968,
-0.08845584094524384,
-0.1391221135854721,
0.02025877684354782,
-0.13223174214363098,
-0.3375963568687439,
-0.6930877566337585,
-0.7778108716011047,
-0.5213629603385925,
0.6621993184089661,
0.07229620218276978,
0.5761253833770752,
0.8078480958938599,
0.4253239333629608,
0.2986936569213867,
-0.041516635566949844,
0.35829609632492065,
-0.2224399298429489,
0.3350273072719574,
-0.3086671531200409,
-0.1614513397216797,
-0.7399014234542847,
-0.16708427667617798,
0.3817560374736786,
0.5209452509880066,
-0.1486084908246994,
0.029312970116734505,
0.19848191738128662,
0.25254544615745544,
-0.6742120385169983,
-0.014842081815004349,
-0.5404689908027649,
-0.02255275286734104,
-0.15623369812965393,
-0.2347142994403839,
-0.5259079933166504,
-0.18294738233089447,
-0.3151535093784332,
-0.2736421227455139,
-0.08437447249889374,
0.634684145450592,
0.5136455297470093,
0.2686978578567505,
-0.7650048136711121,
-0.19352306425571442,
-0.22888273000717163,
0.8261508345603943,
-0.4185362458229065,
0.42731913924217224,
0.3830482065677643,
0.6832597851753235,
-0.35731106996536255,
-0.5410890579223633,
-0.3517029881477356,
0.00014124542940407991,
-0.18776194751262665,
0.10361593216657639,
-0.27872857451438904,
0.12710995972156525,
0.23403340578079224,
-0.23744329810142517,
-0.7919443249702454,
0.5370453596115112,
0.12706901133060455,
-0.5694860219955444,
0.9308199882507324,
0.5297523140907288,
0.477924644947052,
0.20465442538261414,
-0.6618290543556213,
0.06945221871137619,
-0.9890243411064148,
0.04040131717920303,
0.4754736125469208,
0.18327660858631134,
-0.3727760314941406,
0.19919537007808685,
-0.2975655496120453,
0.8949525952339172,
-0.15366622805595398,
-0.1634325236082077,
0.1784985065460205,
0.10236473381519318,
-0.22859270870685577,
0.34162992238998413,
0.9389907717704773,
0.4877590537071228,
0.08556295186281204,
-0.16041462123394012,
-0.4049055278301239,
0.08266653120517731,
-0.01298395823687315,
-0.7142574191093445,
-0.013650101609528065,
0.2299318015575409,
-0.310380756855011,
-0.5604435801506042,
-0.015596547164022923,
-0.6159989237785339,
-0.7872955799102783,
-0.1489948332309723,
0.202951118350029,
0.028923844918608665,
-0.27701279520988464,
0.4725976586341858,
0.12396036833524704,
0.4897083044052124,
0.1838792860507965,
-0.8791986107826233,
0.16468793153762817,
0.9369866251945496,
0.6202850937843323,
-0.34725484251976013,
-0.020602446049451828,
-1.0402026176452637,
0.2515600919723511,
-0.31051141023635864,
0.9421249628067017,
-0.37022578716278076,
-0.30470505356788635,
0.27545279264450073,
0.21809783577919006,
-0.10452549904584885,
-0.20312872529029846,
0.7557657361030579,
-0.6038275957107544,
0.0877792090177536,
-0.11347918957471848,
-0.4627482295036316,
0.03661196678876877,
0.4213273227214813,
-0.390485942363739,
0.7058265209197998,
-0.23072104156017303,
-1.0118578672409058,
0.18349917232990265,
-0.4954015016555786,
-0.7063485980033875,
0.09097756445407867,
-0.18967710435390472,
-0.575657308101654,
-0.26755619049072266,
0.22146663069725037,
0.45253682136535645,
-0.1601368486881256,
0.4449039399623871,
-0.6038421988487244,
-0.35371753573417664,
0.5197921991348267,
-0.3793063759803772,
1.096758484840393,
0.4075906276702881,
-0.144780233502388,
0.5070297122001648,
-0.5016270279884338,
0.011072794906795025,
-0.07531020790338516,
-0.388201504945755,
-0.15640370547771454,
0.13034629821777344,
0.028126278892159462,
0.26567620038986206,
0.38140231370925903,
-0.7688430547714233,
-0.48768940567970276,
-0.1974332332611084,
0.2373342663049698,
0.838978111743927,
-0.19857896864414215,
0.2540208697319031,
-0.44086953997612,
0.6478528380393982,
-0.3281382620334625,
0.5107587575912476,
-0.08146289736032486,
-0.278453528881073,
-0.5269856452941895,
-0.5911700129508972,
-0.1598903387784958,
0.6828281283378601,
-0.5564409494400024,
0.7955158352851868,
0.10342700779438019,
-0.15882517397403717,
-0.5017553567886353,
0.2603367865085602,
0.7308986783027649,
0.9139823317527771,
0.28871235251426697,
0.16105374693870544,
-0.9288812875747681,
-0.827261745929718,
-0.41727373003959656,
-0.11237789690494537,
-0.20070014894008636,
-0.07133376598358154,
0.3694964647293091,
-0.30351853370666504,
1.1445375680923462,
-0.35323336720466614,
0.09265939891338348,
-0.4177481532096863,
-0.3029967248439789,
0.01683642715215683,
0.32697832584381104,
0.40277567505836487,
-0.691931962966919,
-0.45872485637664795,
0.12912513315677643,
-1.0999559164047241,
-0.603802502155304,
0.35144272446632385,
-0.24713541567325592,
0.3422470986843109,
0.7205988168716431,
-0.25284773111343384,
0.14392191171646118,
0.6574333906173706,
-0.5976187586784363,
0.554567813873291,
-0.14966319501399994,
-0.2662849426269531,
-1.1429756879806519,
-0.004762445576488972,
-0.16284602880477905,
-0.6302887201309204,
-0.8767814040184021,
0.14158661663532257,
0.393962562084198,
0.1354943960905075,
-0.9083693623542786,
0.959879994392395,
-0.24124695360660553,
-0.09137921780347824,
-0.5006632804870605,
0.30694061517715454,
0.0676058977842331,
-0.026197189465165138,
0.2087312936782837,
0.35801491141319275,
0.6056930422782898,
-0.5106775760650635,
0.41870999336242676,
0.12895727157592773,
-0.41648897528648376,
0.7787665128707886,
-0.6819721460342407,
0.07047327607870102,
-0.09397977590560913,
0.3266970217227936,
-0.6924335956573486,
-0.5417109131813049,
0.2121170163154602,
-0.16690869629383087,
0.19703197479248047,
-0.2298847734928131,
-0.29060763120651245,
-0.3580979108810425,
-0.5106979608535767,
-0.07057170569896698,
0.7529135346412659,
-0.928822934627533,
0.544445276260376,
0.684362530708313,
0.12096444517374039,
-0.9026753306388855,
-0.5708367824554443,
-0.0245648305863142,
-0.6183890700340271,
-0.6623788475990295,
0.051921334117650986,
-0.26523733139038086,
-0.6070255041122437,
-0.17276638746261597,
-0.21232718229293823,
0.09876091778278351,
0.5194786190986633,
0.4836358428001404,
0.6743728518486023,
0.048666320741176605,
0.27561187744140625,
0.056480538100004196,
-0.47410666942596436,
0.19596724212169647,
0.20902153849601746,
0.567457914352417,
-0.3252493441104889,
-0.5125511288642883,
-0.24192602932453156,
0.18117313086986542,
0.37062743306159973,
-0.2020288109779358,
0.5336288809776306,
0.6456812024116516,
-0.3833378553390503,
-0.17058391869068146,
-0.4459976851940155,
-0.15593409538269043,
-0.6056053638458252,
0.14622093737125397,
-0.45245200395584106,
-1.1506239175796509,
0.5402157306671143,
0.08092284202575684,
0.056287191808223724,
0.16679412126541138,
0.5606108903884888,
-0.4605112373828888,
1.377554178237915,
0.38795822858810425,
-0.2257853001356125,
0.22840021550655365,
0.451808363199234,
0.2585524022579193,
-0.9939551949501038,
-0.4686581790447235,
-0.5139160752296448,
-0.07514729350805283,
-0.5163446068763733,
-0.11802911758422852,
0.4013242721557617,
0.0409955270588398,
-0.7423903346061707,
0.35144439339637756,
-0.35187602043151855,
0.5546388030052185,
0.1678353250026703,
0.16178801655769348,
0.4963514506816864,
-0.25929176807403564,
0.003857733216136694,
0.1836383044719696,
-0.5419549345970154,
-0.7046416997909546,
0.8123634457588196,
0.5293819308280945,
1.3790146112442017,
0.2657880187034607,
0.9819827079772949,
0.18054647743701935,
0.5214679837226868,
-0.6213918328285217,
0.6896529793739319,
-0.05869831144809723,
-0.6226143836975098,
-0.06306257843971252,
-0.2848333418369293,
-1.1749159097671509,
0.39038217067718506,
-0.4182768762111664,
-0.7050080895423889,
-0.1824241280555725,
0.2578427791595459,
-0.1233484148979187,
0.13797084987163544,
-0.554309070110321,
0.7467721104621887,
-0.6810939311981201,
-0.3228338658809662,
0.08397433161735535,
-0.6029403209686279,
0.6360275149345398,
-0.09741954505443573,
0.46927374601364136,
-0.6267874836921692,
-0.25841814279556274,
0.5928323268890381,
-0.3401299715042114,
1.1954213380813599,
-0.018931161612272263,
-0.022231072187423706,
0.11680971086025238,
0.09303253889083862,
0.5551583170890808,
-0.14513900876045227,
-0.08920459449291229,
-0.11220977455377579,
-0.2868930697441101,
-0.290615975856781,
-0.3980501890182495,
0.9254494905471802,
-0.3106439411640167,
-0.8625108599662781,
-0.4230656623840332,
-0.8786544799804688,
-0.21811698377132416,
0.1223892942070961,
0.10936591029167175,
0.23154932260513306,
0.02280081808567047,
0.07199554145336151,
0.9569040536880493,
-0.36332735419273376,
0.5962380170822144,
0.9263657331466675,
-0.5534847974777222,
-0.07191327959299088,
0.7656576633453369,
-0.31589287519454956,
0.09080728888511658,
0.43153607845306396,
0.31700706481933594,
-0.7489941716194153,
-0.5260072350502014,
-0.22272782027721405,
0.013722782954573631,
-0.7575168013572693,
-0.34237605333328247,
-0.6429224610328674,
-0.30112987756729126,
-0.24714772403240204,
-0.536234438419342,
0.0352897047996521,
-0.15571795403957367,
0.08414371311664581,
-0.4471207559108734,
0.4031273126602173,
0.5300969481468201,
-0.06396396458148956,
0.16008919477462769,
-0.5729597210884094,
0.06317487359046936,
0.4173276424407959,
0.2531992495059967,
-0.5689719915390015,
-0.47554099559783936,
0.041646234691143036,
-0.3425430655479431,
0.11297018080949783,
-0.7319478988647461,
0.39883193373680115,
-0.22352389991283417,
0.9816715717315674,
0.5130487084388733,
0.6642223000526428,
0.14431409537792206,
-0.2695716917514801,
0.39739224314689636,
0.3791605234146118,
-0.96877121925354,
0.4846388101577759,
-0.341814786195755,
0.0593750961124897,
0.07011443376541138,
0.3068908452987671,
-0.390002578496933,
-0.5249615907669067,
-0.2534531056880951,
-0.597305953502655,
0.22254303097724915,
-0.16857171058654785,
0.05780938267707825,
-0.12100747227668762,
-0.2367919534444809,
-0.006536493077874184,
-0.08024799078702927,
-0.58842533826828,
0.14259587228298187,
0.11196025460958481,
-0.5507587790489197,
0.014160210266709328,
-0.28364863991737366,
-0.6092110276222229,
0.21401789784431458,
0.4941299855709076,
-0.24377353489398956,
-0.10817942768335342,
-0.20810700953006744,
-0.414271742105484,
0.2944585084915161,
0.48352083563804626,
0.6345502138137817,
0.40280020236968994,
-0.2022271454334259,
0.8576224446296692,
0.4269874095916748,
-0.24598869681358337,
0.21615910530090332,
0.17962652444839478,
-0.10900003463029861,
-0.21150995790958405,
0.7246646285057068,
0.6408413648605347,
0.22900818288326263,
-0.914267897605896,
0.39895036816596985,
0.0860704556107521,
-0.1095309779047966,
-0.12827807664871216,
0.4036766588687897,
0.1800713986158371,
0.3298737108707428,
0.09448742121458054,
-0.38700446486473083,
0.02110154740512371,
-0.35597583651542664,
0.2811511158943176,
0.7919890880584717,
-0.4491889774799347,
-0.07249514013528824,
0.9599870443344116,
0.4225427508354187,
-0.4277074337005615,
-0.026407437399029732,
-0.26501521468162537,
-0.6465194821357727,
0.5630735754966736,
0.7735992670059204,
0.9157034754753113,
-0.49979743361473083,
0.2215084433555603,
0.1619214564561844,
0.4629114270210266,
0.05749383196234703,
0.17587058246135712,
0.1320578008890152,
-0.9353147745132446,
-0.33493733406066895,
-0.6538868546485901,
-0.5398054122924805,
-0.07663208991289139,
-0.56182861328125,
0.10836134105920792,
-0.5504305958747864,
-0.029420960694551468,
-0.18699166178703308,
-0.2785540819168091,
-0.4336817264556885,
0.011456530541181564,
0.18288791179656982,
1.0448143482208252,
-1.0601646900177002,
0.8806565403938293,
0.43863460421562195,
-0.1027257964015007,
-0.5444148182868958,
-0.3000388741493225,
0.3497380316257477,
-1.2099127769470215,
0.6370034217834473,
0.2899807095527649,
-0.5328593254089355,
-0.32500961422920227,
-0.39485183358192444,
-0.4649891257286072,
1.222813606262207,
0.6035869717597961,
-0.7383198142051697,
0.3670922517776489,
0.1296231597661972,
0.44653797149658203,
-0.5824329853057861,
0.003353503765538335,
0.7185351252555847,
0.4953489303588867,
-0.1352558135986328,
-0.8265626430511475,
0.39915797114372253,
-0.048961058259010315,
-0.06687109172344208,
0.20263075828552246,
-0.40775033831596375,
0.48904237151145935,
-0.11304455995559692,
-0.16704274713993073,
-0.13210679590702057,
0.11585354059934616,
0.5978240370750427,
0.7967965602874756,
0.48672255873680115,
0.41029462218284607,
0.9089019298553467,
-0.25225192308425903,
1.235919713973999,
-0.18324056267738342,
0.15666063129901886,
1.3760721683502197,
-0.5153801441192627,
0.9300300478935242,
0.3482845425605774,
0.06479893624782562,
0.5416908860206604,
0.6001360416412354,
0.3653176426887512,
0.47319889068603516,
0.13430076837539673,
-0.9177418947219849,
-0.6651912927627563,
-0.2610515058040619,
-0.15451426804065704,
0.2185359001159668,
0.4019356071949005,
-0.4240185618400574,
-0.3229046165943146,
0.32784321904182434,
0.32346242666244507,
0.09391990303993225,
-0.49814456701278687,
0.43261611461639404,
0.14077922701835632,
-0.46332231163978577,
0.44807881116867065,
-0.11732910573482513,
0.6773381233215332,
-0.5196887850761414,
0.25702276825904846,
-0.40834861993789673,
0.30334657430648804,
-0.4762096107006073,
-1.2463189363479614,
0.34260663390159607,
0.23604294657707214,
0.23423823714256287,
-0.40738800168037415,
1.3179872035980225,
-0.47645461559295654,
-0.1758064180612564,
0.5272735357284546,
0.3329211473464966,
0.17004545032978058,
0.22515913844108582,
-0.4942728579044342,
0.4701758623123169,
-0.1552821695804596,
-0.04898352548480034,
0.6047717928886414,
-0.15852095186710358,
-0.38370320200920105,
1.1129230260849,
0.632260799407959,
-0.4785929024219513,
0.22957584261894226,
-0.05411186441779137,
0.7495495080947876,
-0.3503011465072632,
-0.38757917284965515,
-0.8961891531944275,
0.7744002938270569,
-0.32072317600250244,
0.23421849310398102,
0.7898471355438232,
0.5419228076934814,
0.4597221314907074,
-0.08111073821783066,
1.015418291091919,
0.042615633457899094,
0.4505002796649933,
-0.664396345615387,
0.8181336522102356,
-0.05597466602921486,
0.47193536162376404,
0.2664683163166046,
-0.5323202610015869,
-0.5165887475013733,
0.63190758228302,
-0.4279192090034485,
-0.29591530561447144,
0.5514386296272278,
1.0482240915298462,
0.04560145363211632,
-0.4407815933227539,
0.574061393737793,
-0.0428607314825058,
0.6621823310852051,
0.6681789755821228,
0.908370852470398,
0.009758823551237583,
0.7873877286911011,
0.0009939271258190274,
-0.27939966320991516,
-0.40194734930992126,
-1.1693445444107056,
-1.3659930229187012,
-0.2306242287158966,
-0.4007354974746704,
-0.41971299052238464,
0.25651663541793823,
0.6980758905410767,
0.714156985282898,
-0.6846960186958313,
-0.10955756902694702,
0.01982494257390499,
0.578782320022583,
0.05794937536120415,
-0.2050016224384308,
0.27708548307418823,
-0.45803332328796387,
-0.5704118013381958,
0.8058885931968689,
0.3204444944858551,
0.06166881322860718,
-0.14088252186775208,
-0.5859174728393555,
0.24241051077842712,
0.029042918235063553,
0.7614389657974243,
0.6087085008621216,
-0.6409426927566528,
-0.6607786417007446,
-0.16837313771247864,
-0.300544410943985,
-0.3622960150241852,
0.39591652154922485,
-0.5012882351875305,
0.6388472318649292,
0.5800073146820068,
0.6883546710014343,
0.4817836582660675,
-0.2728462219238281,
0.4882538616657257,
-0.7643582820892334,
0.16355687379837036,
-0.0419558510184288,
0.6667348742485046,
0.3578440546989441,
-0.2016141265630722,
0.7061188220977783,
-0.07531710714101791,
-0.5357319712638855,
-0.9298241138458252,
0.6186389327049255,
-1.1128904819488525,
-0.1319427639245987,
1.0502375364303589,
-0.3373059928417206,
-0.199105903506279,
-0.5861819982528687,
-0.1369680017232895,
0.12503933906555176,
-0.16742616891860962,
0.5343531966209412,
0.33069875836372375,
-0.3034578263759613,
-0.29540786147117615,
-0.5013017654418945,
0.5033547878265381,
0.10111229121685028,
-1.2433433532714844,
0.015128744766116142,
0.40006789565086365,
0.7090743780136108,
-0.1384091079235077,
0.4853563904762268,
-0.0928858295083046,
0.2714855968952179,
-0.24033519625663757,
0.028915049508213997,
-0.415566086769104,
-0.01283124927431345,
-0.39936184883117676,
-0.03122209943830967,
0.10710068047046661,
-0.5265710949897766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16438v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16438v2
|
Language-Specific Neurons: The Key to Multilingual Capabilities in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-26T09:36:05 | 2024-06-06T08:14:46 |
Tianyi Tang, Wenyang Luo, Haoyang Huang, Dongdong Zhang, Xiaolei Wang, Xin Zhao, Furu Wei, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable multilingual capabilities
without being pre-trained on specially curated multilingual parallel corpora.
It remains a challenging problem to explain the underlying mechanisms by which
LLMs process multilingual texts. In this paper, we delve into the composition
of Transformer architectures in LLMs to pinpoint language-specific regions.
Specially, we propose a novel detection method, language activation probability
entropy (LAPE), to identify language-specific neurons within LLMs. Based on
LAPE, we conduct comprehensive experiments on several representative LLMs, such
as LLaMA-2, BLOOM, and Mistral. Our findings indicate that LLMs' proficiency in
processing a particular language is predominantly due to a small subset of
neurons, primarily situated in the models' top and bottom layers. Furthermore,
we showcase the feasibility to "steer" the output language of LLMs by
selectively activating or deactivating language-specific neurons. Our research
provides important evidence to the understanding and exploration of the
multilingual capabilities of LLMs.
|
[
-0.40042388439178467,
-0.5576461553573608,
0.5234034657478333,
0.2461903989315033,
-0.014303188771009445,
0.2438584417104721,
-0.5796833634376526,
-0.20605003833770752,
0.22071069478988647,
0.18895810842514038,
-0.3605227768421173,
-0.47637224197387695,
-0.5261004567146301,
0.09955576807260513,
-0.4029594361782074,
0.6581708788871765,
0.05493259057402611,
0.03730395436286926,
-0.22913047671318054,
-0.04822072014212608,
-0.1614687144756317,
-0.5287267565727234,
-0.5823290348052979,
-0.5951974987983704,
0.7949496507644653,
0.12026958167552948,
0.22462445497512817,
0.308019757270813,
0.24067391455173492,
0.3815702795982361,
-0.37919092178344727,
-0.12958869338035583,
-0.3030437231063843,
0.09069009870290756,
-0.024228304624557495,
-0.8565325140953064,
-0.5562319755554199,
-0.49342769384384155,
0.8611311912536621,
0.5039602518081665,
-0.16003645956516266,
0.07437268644571304,
0.12591469287872314,
0.296946257352829,
-0.5694292187690735,
-0.012266058474779129,
-1.119493007659912,
0.18596670031547546,
-0.4102112948894501,
-0.2734290659427643,
-0.5690670609474182,
0.26652586460113525,
-0.26848721504211426,
-0.20326197147369385,
0.30525749921798706,
-0.27934592962265015,
0.46318045258522034,
0.03935849666595459,
-0.26729023456573486,
0.10750274360179901,
-0.5308333039283752,
0.7331172823905945,
-0.6163368225097656,
0.4300745129585266,
0.27248138189315796,
-0.09296303242444992,
0.07287074625492096,
-0.392281711101532,
-0.5864642262458801,
-0.1725199967622757,
-0.07076948881149292,
-0.10136867314577103,
-0.24692946672439575,
-0.1341669261455536,
0.143206387758255,
0.17911845445632935,
-0.7340838313102722,
0.48410120606422424,
-0.24254897236824036,
-0.3247262239456177,
0.30691489577293396,
-0.014055109582841396,
0.5842949151992798,
0.11827434599399567,
-0.12354331463575363,
-0.006315654143691063,
-0.7127718329429626,
0.07377500832080841,
0.36878716945648193,
0.30873483419418335,
-0.24901221692562103,
0.4781295955181122,
0.2044442892074585,
0.5756034255027771,
-0.28237923979759216,
-0.2680898606777191,
0.4267280697822571,
0.05330798402428627,
-0.14018620550632477,
0.1472340226173401,
0.9941772818565369,
-0.396698534488678,
0.46172353625297546,
-0.3748895525932312,
-0.42440178990364075,
-0.23302605748176575,
0.19333656132221222,
-0.4520064890384674,
0.023237120360136032,
0.31874972581863403,
-0.21073533594608307,
-0.333211213350296,
-0.48243850469589233,
-0.47111374139785767,
-0.40078890323638916,
0.00946072954684496,
0.14714276790618896,
-0.318723201751709,
-0.7277829647064209,
-0.08475480228662491,
-0.08433879166841507,
0.19621215760707855,
-0.27096182107925415,
-1.2405332326889038,
0.02393040992319584,
0.5906935930252075,
0.7909446954727173,
-0.48885729908943176,
-0.8134706020355225,
-0.11799964308738708,
0.23530709743499756,
-0.4704959988594055,
0.8429884910583496,
-0.6920866966247559,
0.0576857328414917,
0.21680516004562378,
0.1558677703142166,
-0.20896995067596436,
-0.5805178880691528,
0.2773965895175934,
-0.8860288858413696,
-0.28876370191574097,
-0.23019756376743317,
-0.12374139577150345,
-0.03271375969052315,
0.30515754222869873,
-0.7317519783973694,
0.7646923661231995,
-0.14361417293548584,
-0.904119610786438,
0.1975305676460266,
-0.3724896311759949,
-0.6426569223403931,
0.10836154222488403,
-0.49009254574775696,
-0.12230762094259262,
0.4095465838909149,
0.16405676305294037,
0.543518602848053,
-0.3298659026622772,
0.25469809770584106,
-0.08408071100711823,
-0.1259390115737915,
0.4488549828529358,
-0.6615535020828247,
0.6286676526069641,
0.016319235786795616,
-0.1854744404554367,
0.4192163050174713,
-0.7499920725822449,
-0.03786826878786087,
0.37603068351745605,
-0.4273155629634857,
-0.2191036343574524,
-0.004593311809003353,
0.061371028423309326,
0.1383572220802307,
0.4643678665161133,
-0.37350350618362427,
0.16299405694007874,
-0.1915120780467987,
0.5457683205604553,
0.6870334148406982,
-0.28171783685684204,
0.6931309103965759,
0.022858532145619392,
0.6360475420951843,
0.22208459675312042,
-0.22439250349998474,
-0.23852898180484772,
-0.5661903619766235,
-0.5858249068260193,
-0.5393463373184204,
0.18784911930561066,
0.6239432096481323,
-0.661793053150177,
0.4515398442745209,
-0.32764410972595215,
-0.40633425116539,
-0.40989235043525696,
0.34216031432151794,
0.15691706538200378,
-0.0005938098765909672,
0.1074824184179306,
-0.22022849321365356,
-0.21740373969078064,
-1.019894003868103,
-0.16935952007770538,
-0.017620069906115532,
-0.08494433015584946,
-0.033003393560647964,
0.2706984281539917,
-0.03673448786139488,
0.5689242482185364,
-0.16870929300785065,
-0.11741764843463898,
-0.5454326868057251,
-0.14610256254673004,
0.3488289415836334,
0.24658070504665375,
0.3436129093170166,
-0.8141762614250183,
-0.3512270152568817,
0.38347887992858887,
-0.851141631603241,
-0.058413565158843994,
-0.3007851839065552,
0.11146107316017151,
-0.05330267548561096,
0.5826718807220459,
-0.6469640731811523,
0.16524122655391693,
0.7041832804679871,
0.040262289345264435,
0.4033423960208893,
-0.48494598269462585,
-0.13188700377941132,
-0.7777762413024902,
0.09633469581604004,
-0.0154524901881814,
0.14248408377170563,
-0.8794463276863098,
-0.023910442367196083,
0.30053916573524475,
-0.023041045293211937,
-0.3350231945514679,
0.5283885598182678,
-0.5044374465942383,
-0.2702188789844513,
-0.37580960988998413,
0.12064972519874573,
-0.2449440062046051,
0.7026737928390503,
0.3222254812717438,
0.6476395726203918,
0.9047424793243408,
-0.5865931510925293,
0.24054054915905,
-0.05062799155712128,
-0.7866811752319336,
0.05693364888429642,
-0.5627539157867432,
0.003397581400349736,
-0.2616557776927948,
-0.08323854953050613,
-1.076552152633667,
-0.11637411266565323,
-0.19400179386138916,
-0.21112988889217377,
0.6037153601646423,
-0.17047837376594543,
-0.3926808834075928,
-0.20958466827869415,
0.08767495304346085,
0.6822212338447571,
0.27192312479019165,
-0.36680084466934204,
0.663413405418396,
0.5763208866119385,
-0.34215670824050903,
-0.6528658866882324,
-0.9324925541877747,
0.2004157155752182,
-0.20817410945892334,
-0.6111289262771606,
0.3969991207122803,
0.12217219918966293,
-0.10352621227502823,
-0.2788950800895691,
0.11347461491823196,
-0.04412142559885979,
0.15639610588550568,
0.12253721803426743,
-0.004094617906957865,
-0.3948282301425934,
0.2760189473628998,
0.09276258945465088,
-0.11281272023916245,
-0.052637092769145966,
-0.027757953852415085,
1.094621181488037,
-0.06875377148389816,
-0.64093416929245,
-0.36120134592056274,
0.328931987285614,
0.8983981013298035,
-0.6626230478286743,
0.8399466276168823,
0.8296599388122559,
-0.35220256447792053,
-0.3085821568965912,
-0.4908587336540222,
-0.2928038239479065,
-0.4857836365699768,
0.8191341161727905,
-0.7238292694091797,
-0.7657536268234253,
0.9491322040557861,
-0.03682095184922218,
-0.25299686193466187,
0.42061567306518555,
0.972854733467102,
0.3859071731567383,
0.8024216294288635,
0.6719598174095154,
-0.4221351444721222,
0.5231465101242065,
-0.16687342524528503,
0.5766583681106567,
-1.0261166095733643,
-0.38064172863960266,
-0.46589598059654236,
-0.3153470456600189,
-0.556022047996521,
-0.36431780457496643,
0.29404357075691223,
0.13359224796295166,
-0.1632850021123886,
0.28912198543548584,
-0.4790911376476288,
0.6002346873283386,
0.3910551369190216,
-0.29425907135009766,
0.17635346949100494,
0.4445827007293701,
-0.5553235411643982,
0.1633821427822113,
-0.8250933885574341,
-0.4122409522533417,
0.7271906733512878,
0.5985274910926819,
0.6982888579368591,
-0.00861115101724863,
0.4601556658744812,
0.06779395043849945,
0.0850057378411293,
-0.7594212889671326,
0.5839092135429382,
-0.06811165809631348,
-0.6268163919448853,
-0.32207125425338745,
-0.3102433979511261,
-0.928896427154541,
0.44107457995414734,
-0.028665775433182716,
-0.9819614291191101,
0.22517651319503784,
-0.28198716044425964,
-0.15576322376728058,
0.7414981722831726,
-0.533690333366394,
0.8217518329620361,
-0.44630467891693115,
-0.2745063602924347,
-0.2862941026687622,
-0.15816451609134674,
0.1615990698337555,
-0.3182975649833679,
0.30898550152778625,
-0.2003759741783142,
-0.10796806216239929,
0.5663023591041565,
0.36063361167907715,
0.9300633668899536,
0.0933324322104454,
-0.6221604943275452,
0.23235836625099182,
0.28828179836273193,
0.4368678629398346,
-0.11570315808057785,
-0.1105804368853569,
0.4142617881298065,
-0.36303332448005676,
-0.1885768324136734,
-0.17123763263225555,
0.9811488389968872,
-0.775000810623169,
-0.5950732827186584,
-0.2260357141494751,
-0.6499509215354919,
-0.2432127594947815,
0.12103033810853958,
0.40445834398269653,
0.20947661995887756,
-0.1960465908050537,
-0.03488968685269356,
0.5586349368095398,
-0.4580039381980896,
0.77837735414505,
0.42622074484825134,
-0.33245787024497986,
-0.1375264823436737,
1.0850666761398315,
-0.03556857258081436,
0.03259173780679703,
0.6115156412124634,
0.04238923639059067,
-0.011644131503999233,
-0.8042504191398621,
-0.33876317739486694,
0.3178371489048004,
-0.7526629567146301,
-0.058492619544267654,
-0.6427666544914246,
-0.3799549341201782,
-0.22002825140953064,
-0.03529643639922142,
-0.4225460886955261,
-0.11299969255924225,
-0.2578011751174927,
-0.1063438132405281,
-0.005365775898098946,
0.7696938514709473,
-0.040155280381441116,
0.29934173822402954,
-0.6833301186561584,
0.253581702709198,
0.425368070602417,
0.3871555030345917,
0.36494114995002747,
-0.55931156873703,
-0.19035901129245758,
-0.036019813269376755,
-0.02638893388211727,
-0.7827402353286743,
0.45085370540618896,
0.2627256214618683,
0.8504517674446106,
0.5477521419525146,
-0.503327488899231,
0.22434046864509583,
-0.718546986579895,
0.8278677463531494,
0.3433040976524353,
-0.8607829213142395,
0.2689431607723236,
-0.23570400476455688,
0.4123727083206177,
-0.04544191062450409,
0.4573967456817627,
-0.5165648460388184,
-0.4680896997451782,
-0.30687668919563293,
-0.8444095849990845,
0.7371493577957153,
-0.04404601827263832,
0.4228876829147339,
-0.19974854588508606,
0.21758054196834564,
-0.07019856572151184,
0.06824794411659241,
-0.9365589618682861,
-0.1393468976020813,
0.2716682553291321,
0.032246481627225876,
-0.12405317276716232,
-0.4358985126018524,
-0.169866144657135,
-0.009976200759410858,
0.3935544490814209,
-0.129991352558136,
0.37331366539001465,
-0.07001489400863647,
-0.16367127001285553,
-0.06015440821647644,
0.48303189873695374,
0.771498441696167,
0.6982906460762024,
0.06426192075014114,
0.3783711791038513,
0.40027695894241333,
-0.43662887811660767,
0.1406228393316269,
-0.5060726404190063,
0.061816953122615814,
-0.08351071923971176,
0.696711540222168,
0.9195876121520996,
-0.13984128832817078,
-0.47418197989463806,
0.4562765657901764,
-0.00007695369276916608,
0.05460848659276962,
-0.23979729413986206,
0.11168237030506134,
0.31977400183677673,
0.416533499956131,
0.4961038827896118,
0.21278955042362213,
-0.22342824935913086,
-0.4931371510028839,
-0.007414672523736954,
0.58380126953125,
-0.35582974553108215,
-0.6122608780860901,
0.3633986711502075,
-0.05829432234168053,
-0.37890875339508057,
0.5128122568130493,
-0.17633040249347687,
-0.671796977519989,
0.7522284388542175,
0.9340349435806274,
0.957930326461792,
-0.4535486102104187,
0.10232070833444595,
0.24095982313156128,
0.490813285112381,
-0.0018460034625604749,
0.1542450338602066,
0.0814894512295723,
-1.2235592603683472,
-0.7133002281188965,
-0.8502805233001709,
0.3063894212245941,
0.35313305258750916,
-0.4957071542739868,
0.043081313371658325,
-0.1490926444530487,
-0.27907925844192505,
0.1294277310371399,
-0.6862308382987976,
-0.5763497948646545,
-0.05736960470676422,
0.6620253324508667,
0.9227045774459839,
-1.053520679473877,
1.224603533744812,
0.6412715911865234,
-0.0031346145551651716,
-0.4250352382659912,
-0.10229551047086716,
-0.23057885468006134,
-1.1394151449203491,
0.9216166734695435,
-0.14618593454360962,
-0.19447104632854462,
-0.1544445902109146,
-0.3536613881587982,
-0.5743628144264221,
0.7715067863464355,
0.5718112587928772,
-0.7330207824707031,
-0.018848109990358353,
0.3795641362667084,
0.4755786061286926,
-0.4433259963989258,
0.3272664546966553,
0.5985909104347229,
0.34395962953567505,
-0.03479093313217163,
-0.8430015444755554,
-0.09703172743320465,
-0.2738420069217682,
0.20041340589523315,
0.26269060373306274,
-0.3960683345794678,
0.7282511591911316,
-0.3012485206127167,
0.03907955810427666,
-0.20122916996479034,
0.5867822170257568,
0.24010729789733887,
-0.1880367249250412,
0.3561055064201355,
0.5049600005149841,
0.8812339305877686,
0.027053579688072205,
1.0784022808074951,
-0.579846203327179,
0.11123154312372208,
0.8944383859634399,
-0.25928300619125366,
1.1579924821853638,
0.5642097592353821,
-0.1755206435918808,
0.4148224890232086,
0.34640738368034363,
0.09276740998029709,
0.6481748223304749,
0.4422720670700073,
-0.5804761052131653,
-0.49894979596138,
-0.05026508867740631,
-0.31795230507850647,
0.5418506264686584,
0.6151459813117981,
-0.26648449897766113,
0.04510592296719551,
0.19910234212875366,
-0.033950868993997574,
-0.2751239538192749,
-0.26947182416915894,
0.746471643447876,
0.17893090844154358,
-0.584797203540802,
0.607112467288971,
0.09330468624830246,
0.7631844282150269,
-0.7449619770050049,
0.2998981177806854,
-0.2782638370990753,
0.17571189999580383,
-0.3195124864578247,
-0.8604908585548401,
0.09617133438587189,
0.07571721076965332,
-0.2596997320652008,
-0.1205323189496994,
0.7798354625701904,
-0.6194113492965698,
-0.4120529890060425,
0.6196627020835876,
0.5406441688537598,
0.09113410860300064,
-0.31880903244018555,
-0.3584824502468109,
0.3337087631225586,
0.11109926551580429,
-0.44367310404777527,
0.5648325085639954,
0.6332536339759827,
0.09079881757497787,
0.6445261240005493,
0.4994562864303589,
0.29840412735939026,
0.14257767796516418,
0.452616423368454,
0.6647191047668457,
-0.494119256734848,
-0.18493081629276276,
-1.0032274723052979,
0.4425484240055084,
0.16114771366119385,
-0.10738255083560944,
0.6031611561775208,
0.4665999412536621,
0.7510024309158325,
-0.25822290778160095,
0.804122805595398,
0.05918993055820465,
-0.15127010643482208,
-0.44654741883277893,
1.0048028230667114,
-0.6716019511222839,
0.48423293232917786,
0.2187289297580719,
-0.9685900807380676,
-0.3913564383983612,
0.6150377988815308,
-0.33452269434928894,
0.06432030349969864,
0.725088357925415,
0.9830750823020935,
-0.1642121970653534,
-0.2319430708885193,
0.6075381636619568,
0.284170925617218,
0.2205331176519394,
0.47117865085601807,
0.8246419429779053,
-0.16968569159507751,
0.501282274723053,
-0.0073064775206148624,
-0.22342565655708313,
0.15178129076957703,
-0.8113892674446106,
-0.9674264788627625,
-0.7561435103416443,
-0.3954216241836548,
-0.10660551488399506,
-0.4473399817943573,
0.4339464604854584,
0.5548058748245239,
-0.9712664484977722,
-0.5664345026016235,
-0.07978571206331253,
0.30326753854751587,
-0.08664371073246002,
-0.11807893216609955,
0.39136701822280884,
-0.7070516347885132,
-0.5168573260307312,
0.6560402512550354,
0.5357626080513,
-0.1802377849817276,
-0.3399800956249237,
0.0718316063284874,
-0.22369888424873352,
-0.09971674531698227,
0.5041519403457642,
0.18262194097042084,
-0.7290611267089844,
0.1881689727306366,
0.03987763077020645,
-0.21496939659118652,
0.18966707587242126,
0.9987700581550598,
-0.4023492932319641,
0.26060840487480164,
0.8228394985198975,
0.5713357925415039,
0.4164394438266754,
-0.8031350374221802,
0.49392449855804443,
-0.9270867705345154,
0.44082772731781006,
0.17177903652191162,
0.6283120512962341,
0.31290048360824585,
0.004919928032904863,
0.04984961077570915,
0.02097095362842083,
-0.4529018998146057,
-0.6959980130195618,
0.12210365384817123,
-0.8760332465171814,
-0.36406832933425903,
1.3850629329681396,
-0.050691988319158554,
-0.4622727930545807,
0.09071525931358337,
0.020543180406093597,
0.07471980899572372,
-0.007854405790567398,
0.5061662793159485,
0.7330349087715149,
0.23802615702152252,
-0.32165494561195374,
-0.5469775199890137,
0.38018688559532166,
0.40793681144714355,
-0.4788554012775421,
0.04532089829444885,
-0.1562415361404419,
0.23707135021686554,
0.5692216157913208,
0.5653735399246216,
-0.07319045066833496,
-0.06026522442698479,
-0.018090322613716125,
0.5017319321632385,
0.2208593189716339,
-0.5887266993522644,
-0.543430745601654,
0.5008731484413147,
0.24425368010997772,
0.011646786704659462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16431v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16431v1
|
RoCoIns: Enhancing Robustness of Large Language Models through Code-Style Instructions
| 2024-02-26T09:30:55 | 2024-02-26T09:30:55 |
Yuansen Zhang, Xiao Wang, Zhiheng Xi, Han Xia, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased remarkable capabilities in
following human instructions. However, recent studies have raised concerns
about the robustness of LLMs when prompted with instructions combining textual
adversarial samples. In this paper, drawing inspiration from recent works that
LLMs are sensitive to the design of the instructions, we utilize instructions
in code style, which are more structural and less ambiguous, to replace
typically natural language instructions. Through this conversion, we provide
LLMs with more precise instructions and strengthen the robustness of LLMs.
Moreover, under few-shot scenarios, we propose a novel method to compose
in-context demonstrations using both clean and adversarial samples
(\textit{adversarial context method}) to further boost the robustness of the
LLMs. Experiments on eight robustness datasets show that our method
consistently outperforms prompting LLMs with natural language instructions. For
example, with gpt-3.5-turbo, our method achieves an improvement of 5.68\% in
test set accuracy and a reduction of 5.66 points in Attack Success Rate (ASR).
|
[
-0.167796790599823,
-1.0605581998825073,
0.33057382702827454,
0.0598297081887722,
-0.32798290252685547,
-0.04013974219560623,
-0.868770956993103,
-0.22041352093219757,
0.058992162346839905,
0.5075684189796448,
-0.44315463304519653,
-0.7180570960044861,
-0.5811145901679993,
0.18154099583625793,
-0.3988163471221924,
1.0485777854919434,
-0.038896381855010986,
0.1582537144422531,
0.09609217941761017,
0.054197024554014206,
-0.2866456210613251,
-0.574974775314331,
-0.4970635771751404,
-0.13756932318210602,
0.4010927677154541,
0.46103930473327637,
0.7049667835235596,
0.6100131273269653,
0.5411219000816345,
0.34853389859199524,
-0.07000893354415894,
0.24936267733573914,
-0.578852653503418,
0.2499227374792099,
0.14086829125881195,
-0.6044568419456482,
-0.4893465042114258,
-0.06402771174907684,
0.4242177903652191,
0.32192641496658325,
-0.0462367981672287,
-0.16484598815441132,
0.39472708106040955,
0.5258235335350037,
-0.5584302544593811,
0.2523331344127655,
-0.8166642189025879,
-0.21389061212539673,
-0.04864020645618439,
-0.558422327041626,
-0.7609847187995911,
-0.3227665424346924,
-0.07193969935178757,
-0.5383957028388977,
0.050079602748155594,
-0.352557897567749,
0.6214190125465393,
0.13598333299160004,
-0.11619632691144943,
-0.4421025216579437,
-0.5522744059562683,
0.8877835869789124,
-0.7716109752655029,
-0.032837554812431335,
0.2067711502313614,
0.3833216428756714,
-0.5103792548179626,
-0.780064582824707,
-0.3170158863067627,
-0.5715886354446411,
-0.04006208851933479,
-0.14023321866989136,
-0.17590263485908508,
0.12054542452096939,
0.4004884362220764,
0.028267601504921913,
-0.42355552315711975,
0.15603885054588318,
-0.09871530532836914,
-0.1950225830078125,
0.548953115940094,
0.05512852594256401,
0.46870002150535583,
-0.07616807520389557,
-0.44155657291412354,
-0.4649121165275574,
-1.0257655382156372,
0.09811826795339584,
0.4608616530895233,
0.6191097497940063,
-0.3759166896343231,
0.4994998872280121,
-0.2988162040710449,
0.7655639052391052,
0.08271099627017975,
-0.37404438853263855,
-0.07220382243394852,
-0.19874973595142365,
-0.24761514365673065,
0.046779535710811615,
0.916015088558197,
0.34811466932296753,
0.44122228026390076,
-0.04296748712658882,
-0.2902337908744812,
0.02315334975719452,
0.5214290618896484,
-1.0419385433197021,
-0.27427616715431213,
0.04337445646524429,
-0.4379771053791046,
-0.630447268486023,
0.07807648181915283,
-0.6983430981636047,
-0.2697345018386841,
-0.2920205593109131,
0.392428994178772,
-0.5533485412597656,
0.29671207070350647,
-0.014004495926201344,
0.08687413483858109,
0.30975452065467834,
0.4601714611053467,
-1.0073926448822021,
0.2451317459344864,
0.8656866550445557,
0.6107956767082214,
0.06386850774288177,
-0.013388178311288357,
-0.835389256477356,
0.03616545349359512,
-0.6148676872253418,
0.5975155234336853,
-0.575661838054657,
-0.46865102648735046,
0.10411364585161209,
-0.042067669332027435,
0.21333707869052887,
-0.2992033064365387,
0.7002416253089905,
-0.5669853091239929,
0.11996956914663315,
-0.26159268617630005,
-0.36809179186820984,
-0.13962982594966888,
0.4011565148830414,
-0.48503127694129944,
0.7743492126464844,
-0.08531136810779572,
-0.7389206290245056,
0.203785240650177,
-0.6436728239059448,
-0.7022899389266968,
-0.013223170302808285,
-0.3374926447868347,
-0.34921902418136597,
-0.046877581626176834,
0.442119836807251,
0.638568103313446,
-0.018274417147040367,
0.03360476344823837,
-0.6057417392730713,
-0.654739499092102,
0.5500502586364746,
-0.7661409378051758,
0.9407021403312683,
0.1272323727607727,
-0.4994160234928131,
0.18265019357204437,
-0.5599578022956848,
0.20479610562324524,
0.10011881589889526,
-0.2918035387992859,
-0.19242173433303833,
-0.02697031758725643,
0.04153832420706749,
-0.08244975656270981,
0.028632713481783867,
-0.16312086582183838,
0.4548894166946411,
-0.519701361656189,
0.6290301084518433,
0.7937297224998474,
-0.012722110375761986,
0.5661401748657227,
-0.302562415599823,
0.5791118741035461,
-0.5167931914329529,
0.17103905975818634,
-0.34884214401245117,
-0.5390240550041199,
-0.49016863107681274,
-0.5217516422271729,
0.10786594450473785,
0.593926727771759,
-0.8509108424186707,
0.43916547298431396,
-0.34353193640708923,
-0.3331550359725952,
0.017560452222824097,
0.47150272130966187,
0.45332714915275574,
0.42443084716796875,
0.32645270228385925,
-0.10124552249908447,
-0.49058932065963745,
-0.718734622001648,
-0.21573986113071442,
-0.23648154735565186,
-0.2644544839859009,
0.05225808545947075,
0.5358120799064636,
-0.21285280585289001,
0.5910352468490601,
-0.24128635227680206,
0.13120125234127045,
-0.3681531250476837,
0.11216019839048386,
0.12950044870376587,
0.4554923474788666,
0.5937016010284424,
-0.7248822450637817,
-0.553616464138031,
-0.16949284076690674,
-0.558526873588562,
-0.048667848110198975,
-0.08847223967313766,
-0.01175285130739212,
0.178772434592247,
0.6674977540969849,
-0.3167370855808258,
0.29487869143486023,
0.5698179006576538,
0.18139493465423584,
0.39601239562034607,
-0.18771715462207794,
0.2915121912956238,
-1.2127792835235596,
-0.2880464494228363,
-0.009263656102120876,
-0.20719848573207855,
-0.7411013841629028,
0.43542996048927307,
0.13072888553142548,
-0.03907892107963562,
-0.5461293458938599,
0.31487807631492615,
-0.39297568798065186,
0.31340715289115906,
-0.3110447824001312,
0.1575649380683899,
0.07456637918949127,
0.3837890326976776,
0.04703518748283386,
0.8646870851516724,
0.8171922564506531,
-0.548534095287323,
0.40567073225975037,
0.08038077503442764,
-0.2855404019355774,
0.5311356782913208,
-0.7426791191101074,
0.28085416555404663,
0.14189495146274567,
0.583148181438446,
-0.9420377612113953,
-0.43529707193374634,
0.2378595918416977,
-0.509726345539093,
0.8148157596588135,
-0.37452396750450134,
-0.494333952665329,
0.03919791057705879,
-0.7726867198944092,
0.15090470016002655,
0.6348850727081299,
-0.6668106317520142,
0.3815358877182007,
-0.06062129884958267,
-0.10588434338569641,
-0.662447452545166,
-0.9656897187232971,
0.48662155866622925,
-0.44835054874420166,
-0.6958420872688293,
0.270923376083374,
-0.20803780853748322,
-0.40698760747909546,
-0.4337763488292694,
0.22301362454891205,
-0.084349125623703,
0.3131333589553833,
0.29273226857185364,
0.45531436800956726,
-0.3469899892807007,
-0.10756831616163254,
-0.2504280209541321,
-0.14846019446849823,
0.033243898302316666,
-0.3418138027191162,
0.39945438504219055,
-0.14925594627857208,
-0.38802865147590637,
-0.7346043586730957,
0.3248024880886078,
0.4677368104457855,
-0.09830525517463684,
0.672473132610321,
0.5496154427528381,
-0.3300996720790863,
-0.40858030319213867,
-0.2647799253463745,
-0.380854994058609,
-0.5693939924240112,
0.1948452889919281,
-0.23923076689243317,
-0.9388880133628845,
0.24800607562065125,
0.12489582598209381,
0.027292367070913315,
0.037817489355802536,
0.6889895796775818,
-0.07676626741886139,
0.8855178952217102,
0.4473344385623932,
-0.3312775492668152,
0.6250303983688354,
-0.27547138929367065,
0.3090682029724121,
-0.6623052358627319,
0.14251616597175598,
-0.702512800693512,
-0.1411273330450058,
-0.738709568977356,
-0.6167291402816772,
0.40555787086486816,
0.15237833559513092,
-0.07405854761600494,
0.5183340907096863,
-0.4627649784088135,
0.4848191738128662,
0.33757176995277405,
0.3290346562862396,
0.09111934155225754,
0.18921959400177002,
0.09335354715585709,
-0.05167301371693611,
-0.7403728365898132,
-0.9215824604034424,
1.2431467771530151,
0.37093430757522583,
1.2611662149429321,
0.0998355969786644,
0.8669488430023193,
0.08219730854034424,
0.506219744682312,
-0.7849678993225098,
0.4432632327079773,
-0.2830531597137451,
-0.41292521357536316,
-0.24069170653820038,
-0.4603511691093445,
-0.6396996974945068,
-0.16546794772148132,
-0.23333503305912018,
-0.9121768474578857,
-0.129844531416893,
0.18031054735183716,
-0.43574029207229614,
0.1788661777973175,
-0.6506785750389099,
0.6595547795295715,
-0.22829852998256683,
-0.4034416973590851,
-0.0823291689157486,
-0.4860648512840271,
0.4864785373210907,
0.09594392776489258,
0.29719045758247375,
0.3696731626987457,
-0.11474116891622543,
0.48615193367004395,
-0.5232142210006714,
1.123773217201233,
0.17994512617588043,
-0.4019368290901184,
0.489424467086792,
0.20212557911872864,
0.8428547978401184,
0.23751592636108398,
-0.07429683208465576,
-0.0882406011223793,
-0.3117651045322418,
-0.3530798554420471,
-0.7830614447593689,
0.9459777474403381,
-0.42665520310401917,
-0.5785585641860962,
0.02137555554509163,
-0.5428274869918823,
-0.134287029504776,
-0.07237320393323898,
0.4279669523239136,
1.0724955797195435,
-0.21733541786670685,
0.51576828956604,
0.9455057382583618,
-0.34122583270072937,
0.49853548407554626,
0.1836545616388321,
0.32376036047935486,
-0.4031723439693451,
0.6717472076416016,
-0.27940571308135986,
0.6469445824623108,
0.746661365032196,
0.16198381781578064,
-0.43679776787757874,
-0.5972641706466675,
-0.5405476689338684,
-0.21061131358146667,
-0.9320638179779053,
-0.3466467559337616,
-0.3493522107601166,
0.03651950880885124,
-0.5193616151809692,
-0.6272752285003662,
-0.3639029562473297,
-0.40546905994415283,
-0.12522529065608978,
-0.00813243631273508,
0.42504289746284485,
0.7056133151054382,
0.22252942621707916,
0.25919196009635925,
-0.7096574902534485,
0.4406597316265106,
0.5008556842803955,
0.12010448426008224,
-0.2123321145772934,
-0.6908401250839233,
-0.0900506004691124,
0.2638280987739563,
-0.0842120349407196,
-0.8750984072685242,
0.11644160747528076,
0.06985466182231903,
0.4169209599494934,
0.5670412182807922,
0.12518054246902466,
0.7090930938720703,
-0.41807955503463745,
0.8510959148406982,
-0.011508418247103691,
-0.8926945328712463,
0.6014224886894226,
-0.5394115447998047,
0.07718505710363388,
0.6146525144577026,
0.09574694186449051,
-0.1277030110359192,
-0.536714494228363,
-0.5333783626556396,
-0.44644829630851746,
0.4606863558292389,
0.20589153468608856,
0.3983014225959778,
0.028028052300214767,
0.38052135705947876,
-0.3018571734428406,
-0.21474093198776245,
-0.6196378469467163,
-0.1735474318265915,
-0.10427164286375046,
-0.3307070732116699,
-0.08216302841901779,
-0.2877468466758728,
-0.5860264301300049,
0.07009744644165039,
0.5504458546638489,
-0.4152613580226898,
0.1443396508693695,
0.16321642696857452,
-0.050055719912052155,
0.023407727479934692,
0.6350804567337036,
0.9485519528388977,
0.5127996802330017,
0.07227593660354614,
0.23699940741062164,
0.4475734531879425,
-0.3514408767223358,
0.14214187860488892,
-0.07724838703870773,
-0.21505871415138245,
-0.16680455207824707,
0.8994864821434021,
0.41365084052085876,
0.4440636932849884,
-0.6025343537330627,
0.7228967547416687,
-0.37483909726142883,
-0.10849226266145706,
-0.1323263943195343,
0.33796972036361694,
-0.05740136280655861,
0.08374977856874466,
0.12025489658117294,
0.07171966135501862,
0.039048533886671066,
-0.7089171409606934,
0.2678883969783783,
0.6835043430328369,
-0.4988047778606415,
-0.09530812501907349,
0.6019333600997925,
0.14431972801685333,
-0.3072551190853119,
0.09583169221878052,
-0.27640363574028015,
-0.781100332736969,
0.5554358959197998,
0.5047209858894348,
0.8829846382141113,
-0.017224211245775223,
0.06729541718959808,
0.24582737684249878,
0.4336800277233124,
-0.2624431550502777,
0.026969293132424355,
-0.11842090636491776,
-0.42353901267051697,
-0.49527525901794434,
-0.3550862967967987,
-0.42634445428848267,
-0.02600247971713543,
-0.6824308037757874,
0.42630720138549805,
-0.5878922939300537,
0.1612207442522049,
-0.4384905695915222,
0.021337922662496567,
-0.31217485666275024,
0.1635911762714386,
0.24417640268802643,
1.01780366897583,
-0.6147862672805786,
1.0028207302093506,
0.5839952230453491,
-0.1012100875377655,
-1.0367579460144043,
0.1465761959552765,
0.29646629095077515,
-0.7383043169975281,
0.5199540853500366,
0.11956111341714859,
-0.39841973781585693,
-0.4490041732788086,
-0.9295459985733032,
-0.35246729850769043,
0.9339128136634827,
0.4547780156135559,
-0.4652443528175354,
0.374889075756073,
-0.15389278531074524,
0.5481500625610352,
-0.4549115300178528,
0.2545521855354309,
0.33299702405929565,
0.39692914485931396,
0.1309387981891632,
-0.564393937587738,
0.22456897795200348,
-0.15597181022167206,
0.05701150372624397,
-0.04930949583649635,
-0.5117902755737305,
0.6073203682899475,
-0.4236351549625397,
-0.2366466075181961,
0.3948521912097931,
0.7134964466094971,
0.354936420917511,
-0.07716977596282959,
0.4262261986732483,
0.2184268683195114,
0.6277353167533875,
-0.026895925402641296,
1.4289278984069824,
-0.5301356315612793,
0.05871045961976051,
1.0872230529785156,
-0.13607774674892426,
0.9324652552604675,
0.3894362151622772,
0.049708399921655655,
0.6829622387886047,
0.3415631055831909,
0.21251653134822845,
0.27926206588745117,
0.23260848224163055,
-0.2911255657672882,
-0.2984059453010559,
0.1614275872707367,
-0.4154055416584015,
0.4746185839176178,
0.2291111797094345,
-0.2790553867816925,
-0.04653976485133171,
-0.28951841592788696,
0.40136483311653137,
0.47416701912879944,
-0.015141538344323635,
0.5802909731864929,
0.1215265765786171,
-0.47953861951828003,
0.8544461131095886,
0.13623303174972534,
0.7957369685173035,
-0.8028500080108643,
-0.268650084733963,
-0.10483906418085098,
0.24104899168014526,
-0.11903586238622665,
-0.538927435874939,
-0.09767811000347137,
0.36330386996269226,
0.06906100362539291,
-0.39831218123435974,
0.7130361199378967,
-0.4389263689517975,
-0.5302361249923706,
0.19997911155223846,
-0.07339832931756973,
-0.04076056554913521,
-0.017043108120560646,
-0.49675464630126953,
0.3211471140384674,
0.00046931731048971415,
-0.14965665340423584,
0.3243688941001892,
0.4897488057613373,
-0.03832989186048508,
0.7170806527137756,
0.591134250164032,
0.14611662924289703,
-0.08716543018817902,
0.2396131455898285,
0.9628892540931702,
-0.41361767053604126,
-0.35885152220726013,
-1.0711442232131958,
0.3228396773338318,
-0.0556023009121418,
-0.1650410145521164,
0.8714138269424438,
0.3212011158466339,
0.7340676784515381,
-0.006318955682218075,
0.7471516728401184,
0.018762722611427307,
0.09926773607730865,
-0.950832724571228,
0.6715404987335205,
-0.23814736306667328,
0.6210952401161194,
-0.27001965045928955,
-0.6157110929489136,
-0.37818074226379395,
0.6164446473121643,
-0.12377092987298965,
0.166402205824852,
0.5985503792762756,
1.2237595319747925,
-0.0188957117497921,
-0.018152201548218727,
0.2476949542760849,
0.18604576587677002,
0.5643142461776733,
0.676400363445282,
0.7335505485534668,
-0.43791869282722473,
0.7978342771530151,
-0.44413891434669495,
-0.353438138961792,
-0.2607966959476471,
-1.0467405319213867,
-1.1835914850234985,
-0.21072472631931305,
-0.30542364716529846,
-0.34887421131134033,
0.09277797490358353,
0.9499859809875488,
0.8779537081718445,
-0.8997436761856079,
-0.191199392080307,
0.012959981337189674,
0.09704575687646866,
-0.21102890372276306,
-0.21698643267154694,
0.2254994958639145,
-0.6626060605049133,
-0.6308639049530029,
0.8267209529876709,
0.29619431495666504,
0.04886418953537941,
-0.34047865867614746,
-0.29188188910484314,
0.2005169689655304,
0.015248573385179043,
0.5223543643951416,
-0.00847652368247509,
-0.7074992656707764,
-0.5028554797172546,
-0.012983974069356918,
-0.46765825152397156,
-0.0324014313519001,
1.0745261907577515,
-0.4598332345485687,
0.4565419554710388,
0.5644493103027344,
0.5267435312271118,
0.05491011217236519,
0.13259008526802063,
0.787868857383728,
-0.7286900281906128,
0.34638887643814087,
0.05356071516871452,
0.45642614364624023,
0.48290568590164185,
-0.37813007831573486,
0.23684298992156982,
-0.05675360560417175,
-0.29116493463516235,
-0.6623265147209167,
0.18153178691864014,
-1.0879064798355103,
-0.2924579381942749,
1.3420332670211792,
-0.35861676931381226,
-0.40369999408721924,
0.12602651119232178,
-0.2933417558670044,
0.08334585279226303,
-0.4220706820487976,
0.7600904703140259,
0.6154604554176331,
0.07252082228660583,
0.049909066408872604,
-0.5638226866722107,
0.5870652198791504,
0.24209977686405182,
-0.7646872401237488,
0.1471710503101349,
0.3377661406993866,
0.26578545570373535,
0.012621046975255013,
0.368792861700058,
-0.2920372486114502,
0.33250054717063904,
0.06118950620293617,
-0.21490561962127686,
-0.08628708869218826,
-0.464802086353302,
-0.7029157876968384,
0.16973759233951569,
0.248085156083107,
-0.05312361940741539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00818v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00818v2
|
DenseMamba: State Space Models with Dense Hidden Connection for Efficient Large Language Models
| 2024-02-26T09:21:59 | 2024-03-05T14:31:03 |
Wei He, Kai Han, Yehui Tang, Chengcheng Wang, Yujie Yang, Tianyu Guo, Yunhe Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) face a daunting challenge due to the excessive
computational and memory requirements of the commonly used Transformer
architecture. While state space model (SSM) is a new type of foundational
network architecture offering lower computational complexity, their performance
has yet to fully rival that of Transformers. This paper introduces DenseSSM, a
novel approach to enhance the flow of hidden information between layers in
SSMs. By selectively integrating shallowlayer hidden states into deeper layers,
DenseSSM retains fine-grained information crucial for the final output. Dense
connections enhanced DenseSSM still maintains the training parallelizability
and inference efficiency. The proposed method can be widely applicable to
various SSM types like RetNet and Mamba. With similar model size, DenseSSM
achieves significant improvements, exemplified by DenseRetNet outperforming the
original RetNet with up to 5% accuracy improvement on public benchmarks. code
is avalaible at https://github.com/WailordHe/DenseSSM
|
[
-0.30065590143203735,
-0.9221920967102051,
0.6445281505584717,
0.2635652422904968,
-0.29768380522727966,
0.2598098814487457,
-0.3403433859348297,
-0.10239549726247787,
0.616418719291687,
0.8728691339492798,
-0.31367671489715576,
-0.5115802884101868,
-0.5157682299613953,
-0.44758543372154236,
-0.4889058768749237,
0.2375306636095047,
-0.08456884324550629,
-0.024504125118255615,
-0.21826115250587463,
-0.04754599928855896,
-0.2547787129878998,
-0.44353988766670227,
-0.5730980038642883,
-0.4908597469329834,
0.4537872076034546,
0.49041837453842163,
0.7783249020576477,
0.5895411372184753,
0.3445987105369568,
0.4374522864818573,
-0.47102388739585876,
0.3753843307495117,
-0.6655836701393127,
0.3958975076675415,
-0.06632879376411438,
-0.5783671736717224,
-0.35382744669914246,
-0.4229069948196411,
1.2154818773269653,
0.975553572177887,
-0.3303186893463135,
-0.03308380767703056,
-0.031174151226878166,
0.9211351275444031,
-0.6718361973762512,
0.05044285207986832,
-0.5717900395393372,
0.19624808430671692,
-0.2713642716407776,
-0.06367821991443634,
-0.4930827021598816,
-0.3972319960594177,
-0.0686713233590126,
-0.27520495653152466,
-0.01585427299141884,
-0.05889506638050079,
0.898188591003418,
0.4205470681190491,
-0.5745739936828613,
0.18783339858055115,
-1.106074571609497,
0.7693904638290405,
-0.6390471458435059,
0.4513019919395447,
0.13420137763023376,
0.5866258144378662,
-0.327501505613327,
-0.5878185629844666,
-0.335483193397522,
-0.12166722118854523,
0.051719509065151215,
0.11255127936601639,
-0.19400668144226074,
0.07260195165872574,
0.08910185098648071,
0.48623138666152954,
-0.3861764073371887,
0.34311068058013916,
-0.3688259720802307,
-0.1529260128736496,
0.5360038876533508,
0.46420425176620483,
0.14696751534938812,
-0.00798511691391468,
-0.5271756649017334,
0.29038238525390625,
-0.6693639755249023,
-0.2453419715166092,
0.31059950590133667,
0.4640321433544159,
-0.3638051152229309,
0.6887305378913879,
-0.4272918999195099,
0.7159454226493835,
-0.13903987407684326,
-0.024703996255993843,
0.12559710443019867,
-0.08751270920038223,
-0.37623804807662964,
0.03569329157471657,
0.7174519896507263,
-0.29930350184440613,
-0.018380772322416306,
-0.11212630569934845,
-0.18731272220611572,
-0.09372735768556595,
0.25543197989463806,
-1.023963451385498,
-0.11002396792173386,
0.11159949004650116,
-0.609727144241333,
-0.1482744961977005,
-0.1648496687412262,
-0.5408744812011719,
-0.660272479057312,
-0.1697182059288025,
0.1985916942358017,
-0.450937420129776,
-0.6215065717697144,
0.25908544659614563,
0.20559576153755188,
0.1335807591676712,
0.23976841568946838,
-0.6646009087562561,
0.6716287136077881,
0.5468698143959045,
1.0952234268188477,
-0.22083434462547302,
0.022149112075567245,
-0.23719123005867004,
0.5136876106262207,
-0.47831353545188904,
0.7083038091659546,
-0.6677902936935425,
-0.1426156610250473,
-0.32444626092910767,
-0.1354883462190628,
-0.025622166693210602,
-0.4652863144874573,
0.374470978975296,
-0.7518242001533508,
-0.2120860069990158,
-0.04580065235495567,
-0.8096619248390198,
-0.310506135225296,
-0.10525169223546982,
-0.8260672092437744,
1.062452793121338,
-0.02562708593904972,
-0.4103899896144867,
-0.12253791838884354,
-0.5694988965988159,
-0.44091394543647766,
0.211151584982872,
-0.07289955019950867,
-0.4564778208732605,
0.1882081776857376,
0.12142059206962585,
0.8218050599098206,
-0.18473473191261292,
0.4863754212856293,
-0.6076758503913879,
-0.8074130415916443,
0.26025086641311646,
-0.18109643459320068,
0.6028280258178711,
0.5215822458267212,
-0.10000891238451004,
0.1502605378627777,
-0.8723797798156738,
-0.0880337730050087,
0.35305267572402954,
-0.4467099606990814,
-0.3457418382167816,
0.09519142657518387,
-0.23000863194465637,
0.0010109483264386654,
0.2477770745754242,
-0.3703843355178833,
0.08701932430267334,
-0.42982834577560425,
0.45911407470703125,
0.6096848249435425,
-0.10291203111410141,
0.8553263545036316,
0.16792649030685425,
0.5730190873146057,
0.3527131974697113,
-0.043782610446214676,
0.013165125623345375,
-0.19771043956279755,
-0.8569148182868958,
-0.5656343698501587,
0.33299848437309265,
0.3632082939147949,
-0.6812990307807922,
0.515417754650116,
-0.2765159010887146,
-0.8806616067886353,
-0.20282167196273804,
0.24033981561660767,
0.05494723469018936,
0.2812647521495819,
0.2851693630218506,
-0.05036487057805061,
-0.5761728286743164,
-0.9807891249656677,
-0.20949824154376984,
0.2120322287082672,
0.21553343534469604,
0.5784865617752075,
0.25225114822387695,
-0.5830202698707581,
0.6652124524116516,
-0.7277117371559143,
-0.2201082706451416,
-0.531875729560852,
-0.5458487272262573,
0.30648213624954224,
0.6161633133888245,
0.37882357835769653,
-0.3296070396900177,
-0.2914418876171112,
-0.1286090463399887,
-0.7505312561988831,
0.06907828152179718,
-0.021899297833442688,
-0.1639374941587448,
-0.20016205310821533,
0.6841913461685181,
-0.6756834983825684,
-0.01392106432467699,
0.7694438099861145,
-0.21756240725517273,
0.19473901391029358,
-0.05204441398382187,
-0.1852424591779709,
-1.2584320306777954,
-0.08326397091150284,
-0.04998066648840904,
-0.2778097689151764,
-0.5387187004089355,
0.16307847201824188,
0.245555579662323,
-0.5834013819694519,
-0.4748099744319916,
0.6058126091957092,
-0.8677517175674438,
-0.3783436715602875,
-0.26390835642814636,
0.3872110843658447,
-0.10222961008548737,
0.5216513276100159,
-0.2533290386199951,
0.6394544243812561,
0.9329339861869812,
-0.5321701169013977,
0.423757404088974,
-0.05224491283297539,
-0.5108392834663391,
0.12475725263357162,
-0.545804500579834,
-0.00727917579934001,
-0.051143378019332886,
0.5309619307518005,
-1.1044878959655762,
-0.11747711896896362,
-0.01638050563633442,
0.023218000307679176,
0.4316386580467224,
-0.2239324301481247,
-0.4911241829395294,
-0.19346468150615692,
0.0587138831615448,
0.38070183992385864,
0.3567682206630707,
-0.45958998799324036,
0.9491376876831055,
0.688504159450531,
-0.08928399533033371,
-0.44598188996315,
-0.8733714818954468,
0.4133240282535553,
-0.16263224184513092,
-0.7514916658401489,
0.13688310980796814,
0.1089632511138916,
0.013905033469200134,
-0.02646390162408352,
-0.1709900051355362,
-0.3100987672805786,
0.4444775879383087,
0.4453226625919342,
0.06245387718081474,
-0.6026625633239746,
0.026443786919116974,
0.6288989782333374,
-0.20830051600933075,
-0.12155362218618393,
-0.22518834471702576,
0.8037025928497314,
-0.41924819350242615,
-0.2794211804866791,
-0.5459978580474854,
0.3906010687351227,
0.2704479992389679,
-0.1151379942893982,
1.1258411407470703,
0.6579168438911438,
-0.3630009591579437,
-0.5352675914764404,
-0.6409966945648193,
-0.1691582202911377,
-0.5463261604309082,
0.5065749883651733,
-0.49376219511032104,
-1.456390142440796,
0.525485634803772,
-0.5119544863700867,
-0.3995942175388336,
0.07784681022167206,
0.35975512862205505,
-0.09820202738046646,
0.9624400734901428,
0.6809878945350647,
-0.017879819497466087,
0.6044593453407288,
-0.26478099822998047,
0.20149454474449158,
-0.7978426814079285,
-0.24942484498023987,
-0.4272795021533966,
-0.5517568588256836,
-0.25652891397476196,
-0.651863694190979,
0.016427965834736824,
0.347000390291214,
-0.1800527721643448,
0.36530423164367676,
-0.28281962871551514,
0.6245964765548706,
0.050387054681777954,
0.29692527651786804,
0.10400465875864029,
0.21480399370193481,
-0.5042722821235657,
-0.006668107584118843,
-1.0703097581863403,
-0.4178105294704437,
0.6643109917640686,
0.5310214757919312,
0.9594356417655945,
0.27935177087783813,
0.6810081005096436,
0.05227166414260864,
0.046059731394052505,
-0.7336411476135254,
1.0254408121109009,
-0.22625043988227844,
-0.30718448758125305,
-0.3002545237541199,
-0.8314785957336426,
-0.9462661147117615,
0.3701932430267334,
-0.2235639989376068,
-0.4356260597705841,
0.08723557740449905,
-0.03208151087164879,
-0.36678579449653625,
0.6492005586624146,
-0.9002394676208496,
0.3499429523944855,
-0.04393746703863144,
-0.24213525652885437,
-0.5158717036247253,
-0.4535514712333679,
0.6135160326957703,
0.011386731639504433,
-0.2514503598213196,
-0.2705613970756531,
-0.4076617360115051,
0.8224862217903137,
-0.46333104372024536,
0.9720832109451294,
-0.20970797538757324,
-0.0717928484082222,
0.2598777413368225,
0.2666420042514801,
0.5752255916595459,
0.04598265141248703,
-0.23628772795200348,
0.45469701290130615,
-0.5110766887664795,
-0.6324904561042786,
-0.47883933782577515,
1.1505323648452759,
-0.9275727868080139,
-0.4276334345340729,
-0.1279444545507431,
-0.6552172899246216,
-0.3539178967475891,
0.40934979915618896,
-0.40509742498397827,
0.41681206226348877,
-0.05133213475346565,
0.6419464349746704,
0.9256522059440613,
-0.4478687644004822,
0.22960799932479858,
0.6451404094696045,
-0.10179685801267624,
-0.2660216689109802,
0.6708351969718933,
0.09125825017690659,
0.1746935397386551,
0.5101518630981445,
0.13941125571727753,
-0.27722665667533875,
-0.6936905384063721,
-0.275355726480484,
0.49708127975463867,
-0.7092270851135254,
-0.27383115887641907,
-0.8309429883956909,
-0.5664910078048706,
-0.2139415293931961,
-0.12371423840522766,
-0.7010324597358704,
-0.5680170059204102,
-0.32246774435043335,
-0.23378843069076538,
0.2253391444683075,
0.6748716235160828,
0.1831410974264145,
0.64188551902771,
-0.6442565321922302,
0.3535979986190796,
0.24605199694633484,
0.8002962470054626,
0.17265596985816956,
-0.520351231098175,
-0.5183309316635132,
-0.17513920366764069,
0.10868939757347107,
-0.6777362823486328,
0.17792236804962158,
0.03675941750407219,
0.6425958275794983,
0.46755450963974,
-0.2704252302646637,
0.9624804258346558,
-0.4347257614135742,
0.6962112188339233,
0.12537223100662231,
-0.940226674079895,
0.49314385652542114,
-0.2163357138633728,
0.4735215902328491,
0.19068732857704163,
0.22814308106899261,
-0.25315380096435547,
-0.37127962708473206,
-0.4610198438167572,
-0.67246413230896,
0.6516585350036621,
0.0017490778118371964,
0.11358010768890381,
0.18370409309864044,
0.4517739415168762,
-0.14086443185806274,
0.006350748240947723,
-0.40225863456726074,
-0.35322076082229614,
-0.06963933259248734,
-0.018603099510073662,
-0.07006298005580902,
-0.5192683935165405,
0.07661324739456177,
-0.12498120963573456,
0.5634385347366333,
-0.12557394802570343,
0.23322899639606476,
-0.11517948657274246,
-0.30761614441871643,
-0.19195736944675446,
0.16343733668327332,
0.7305421233177185,
0.6192407608032227,
0.15020032227039337,
0.46754151582717896,
0.38653624057769775,
-0.4310363829135895,
0.24897021055221558,
-0.1395208239555359,
-0.3255750238895416,
-0.010336639359593391,
0.06655184179544449,
1.1424270868301392,
0.6039189696311951,
-0.36045005917549133,
0.33162161707878113,
-0.10856711119413376,
-0.08214002102613449,
-0.22523458302021027,
0.47856810688972473,
0.6169136166572571,
0.5176756381988525,
0.23392239212989807,
0.3053357005119324,
-0.15794892609119415,
-0.03881717473268509,
0.001866961014457047,
0.4381951689720154,
-0.4989670515060425,
-0.0738711953163147,
0.6439423561096191,
0.2563249468803406,
-0.10529041290283203,
0.4349149167537689,
0.20432384312152863,
-0.23345883190631866,
0.5100209712982178,
0.5753899812698364,
0.7480030059814453,
-0.3113415837287903,
0.19026903808116913,
0.2806133031845093,
0.40651145577430725,
-0.17560383677482605,
0.23736566305160522,
-0.18466180562973022,
-0.8720070719718933,
-0.5812436938285828,
-0.6979975700378418,
-0.25282150506973267,
0.278003990650177,
-0.4732053279876709,
0.21245867013931274,
-0.7851071357727051,
-0.04748300462961197,
-0.5355849862098694,
0.24245786666870117,
-0.38829031586647034,
0.14765077829360962,
0.2112036645412445,
1.1570829153060913,
-0.8161830306053162,
1.0863897800445557,
0.4445545971393585,
-0.05431612581014633,
-0.9792152643203735,
-0.3639857769012451,
-0.17162926495075226,
-0.8029661774635315,
0.3993304967880249,
-0.06885351985692978,
-0.3911697268486023,
0.008477730676531792,
-0.47551363706588745,
-1.2826664447784424,
1.2144016027450562,
0.7127792835235596,
-0.7676663994789124,
0.40742024779319763,
0.13439153134822845,
0.36553332209587097,
-0.2963414788246155,
0.23412489891052246,
0.2346445769071579,
0.4063568711280823,
-0.028105154633522034,
-0.1311703473329544,
0.3728480339050293,
-0.1818893551826477,
0.5343219637870789,
0.36918818950653076,
-1.016937494277954,
0.4680081307888031,
-0.22494007647037506,
-0.43801942467689514,
0.1528690904378891,
1.2188265323638916,
0.40092459321022034,
-0.18046672642230988,
0.6623358130455017,
0.5660457015037537,
0.8586452603340149,
-0.07687827944755554,
0.7152975797653198,
-0.21639887988567352,
0.17344097793102264,
1.0472270250320435,
-0.6107109785079956,
0.8467832207679749,
0.3595215976238251,
-0.003748600371181965,
0.6244295835494995,
0.4756379723548889,
-0.026107560843229294,
0.28168338537216187,
0.16527384519577026,
-0.12164541333913803,
-0.49819743633270264,
0.13359364867210388,
-0.49508482217788696,
0.3145819306373596,
0.5004444718360901,
-0.14042750000953674,
-0.07797468453645706,
-0.25608259439468384,
0.09187241643667221,
0.013179153203964233,
-0.27824142575263977,
0.6103829145431519,
0.30494678020477295,
-0.1669791042804718,
0.5893790125846863,
0.13250130414962769,
0.6471584439277649,
-0.8052563667297363,
0.25185900926589966,
-0.5680516958236694,
0.2090635895729065,
-0.45031240582466125,
-0.747421145439148,
0.3420145809650421,
-0.16279634833335876,
-0.19576603174209595,
-0.20363254845142365,
1.1236971616744995,
-0.5966162085533142,
-0.46742919087409973,
0.5504773259162903,
0.4975024163722992,
0.14363642036914825,
0.02306430973112583,
-0.7899953722953796,
0.31966641545295715,
-0.3965388238430023,
-0.40843817591667175,
0.3574518859386444,
0.468307226896286,
0.034096088260412216,
1.0148698091506958,
0.7299146056175232,
0.4846150279045105,
0.2886929512023926,
0.5070301294326782,
0.9702993631362915,
-0.8501823544502258,
-0.7775086760520935,
-0.643442690372467,
0.18639247119426727,
-0.26062217354774475,
0.1134253442287445,
0.9492882490158081,
0.7450926899909973,
0.37512442469596863,
-0.02065192349255085,
0.40441474318504333,
0.446247935295105,
0.4690558612346649,
-0.47114789485931396,
1.0708907842636108,
-0.5036019682884216,
0.6010997891426086,
-0.18847669661045074,
-1.055938482284546,
-0.1979909986257553,
0.2746507525444031,
-0.09287867695093155,
0.0981547012925148,
0.6400179862976074,
1.0131349563598633,
-0.40787965059280396,
-0.0065004657953977585,
0.456595778465271,
0.6474482417106628,
0.09990178793668747,
0.5030971765518188,
0.983296811580658,
-0.5155462622642517,
0.6048070788383484,
-0.28297489881515503,
-0.09648588299751282,
-0.3450559973716736,
-0.6858767867088318,
-0.8719265460968018,
-0.4543272852897644,
-0.3407941162586212,
-0.27046021819114685,
-0.24052748084068298,
0.36161696910858154,
0.9935696721076965,
-0.6969580054283142,
-0.5005078315734863,
0.09023022651672363,
0.3182939887046814,
-0.2376558929681778,
-0.2526834011077881,
0.16839700937271118,
-0.0861240103840828,
-0.3641573488712311,
0.9467164874076843,
0.5276766419410706,
-0.1456831842660904,
-0.5185686349868774,
-0.17355836927890778,
-0.2032395750284195,
0.34115421772003174,
0.6959682703018188,
-0.09617451578378677,
-0.5335955023765564,
0.019304968416690826,
-0.2196466326713562,
-0.34410011768341064,
-0.12255974113941193,
0.8865283727645874,
-0.7412233948707581,
-0.005040218587964773,
0.5691729784011841,
0.9389141201972961,
0.9658432602882385,
-0.30746859312057495,
0.3665107190608978,
-0.8100370168685913,
0.37266647815704346,
0.1437090039253235,
0.7113839387893677,
0.37177392840385437,
-0.3482883870601654,
0.34434449672698975,
0.17661964893341064,
-0.2501588463783264,
-0.8578182458877563,
0.38808077573776245,
-1.2544020414352417,
-0.4736838638782501,
1.116837739944458,
0.07481022924184799,
-0.415700763463974,
-0.06414487957954407,
0.034068889915943146,
0.23727421462535858,
-0.38560664653778076,
0.4988202154636383,
0.25294575095176697,
0.2924140393733978,
-0.3971690833568573,
-0.18973217904567719,
0.06535620987415314,
0.6481303572654724,
-0.8225848078727722,
-0.24252505600452423,
0.3043724000453949,
0.22249189019203186,
-0.04612835869193077,
0.45716238021850586,
-0.15306180715560913,
-0.09943247586488724,
-0.07181239873170853,
-0.12496119737625122,
-0.3609387278556824,
-0.404407262802124,
-0.4663124978542328,
0.40453365445137024,
-0.39894425868988037,
0.13451677560806274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16420v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16420v2
|
Predicting Sustainable Development Goals Using Course Descriptions -- from LLMs to Conventional Foundation Models
| 2024-02-26T09:19:46 | 2024-04-23T12:49:57 |
Lev Kharlashkin, Melany Macias, Leo Huovinen, Mika Hämäläinen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present our work on predicting United Nations sustainable development
goals (SDG) for university courses. We use an LLM named PaLM 2 to generate
training data given a noisy human-authored course description input as input.
We use this data to train several different smaller language models to predict
SDGs for university courses. This work contributes to better university level
adaptation of SDGs. The best performing model in our experiments was BART with
an F1-score of 0.786.
|
[
-0.27241697907447815,
-0.5092652440071106,
0.67596834897995,
-0.15917307138442993,
-0.2609788477420807,
0.1949395388364792,
-0.13146649301052094,
-0.5605865120887756,
0.20813512802124023,
0.6912342309951782,
-0.5640496015548706,
-0.7229975461959839,
-0.5201379060745239,
0.01899694837629795,
-0.2508273124694824,
1.1404870748519897,
-0.023345261812210083,
0.27660271525382996,
-0.45452675223350525,
0.2898816764354706,
-0.4635215997695923,
0.014691988937556744,
-0.763102650642395,
-0.6630752682685852,
0.2568891644477844,
0.6637690663337708,
0.5660133957862854,
0.7428058385848999,
0.47719043493270874,
0.0507991798222065,
-0.07631652057170868,
-0.2318006157875061,
-0.3954821228981018,
-0.30312663316726685,
-0.16298942267894745,
-0.3543177843093872,
-0.13186240196228027,
0.18635086715221405,
0.5975083708763123,
0.8619720339775085,
0.1386910378932953,
0.3850516974925995,
0.25355958938598633,
0.6663675308227539,
-0.18841196596622467,
0.20989136397838593,
-0.3067445456981659,
0.18414202332496643,
0.16749921441078186,
0.03791167959570885,
-0.29766714572906494,
-0.390471875667572,
0.07397448271512985,
-0.21523822844028473,
0.32529935240745544,
-0.07415448874235153,
0.6301355361938477,
0.32359328866004944,
-0.3743850588798523,
-0.3454979360103607,
-0.4252769351005554,
0.8672728538513184,
-0.32909494638442993,
0.2309141308069229,
0.5553736090660095,
0.021852971985936165,
-0.37717893719673157,
-0.43371719121932983,
-0.23813924193382263,
-0.08049257844686508,
0.12525726854801178,
0.3220576047897339,
0.2807758152484894,
0.3471904993057251,
0.15463030338287354,
0.49746739864349365,
-0.48230648040771484,
0.25605785846710205,
-0.7519586086273193,
-0.21506008505821228,
1.0914380550384521,
0.2575925588607788,
-0.2711794078350067,
-0.22003832459449768,
-0.9127663969993591,
0.2967061996459961,
-0.8759769797325134,
0.4254497289657593,
0.31205132603645325,
0.4372331202030182,
-0.36364108324050903,
0.33700060844421387,
-0.3730619251728058,
0.4805099368095398,
-0.13149340450763702,
-0.4185979664325714,
-0.39424291253089905,
-0.2066608965396881,
-0.11472856998443604,
0.09965720027685165,
0.2815106213092804,
0.7739806771278381,
0.2665320634841919,
-0.13592401146888733,
-0.27080798149108887,
0.22947128117084503,
0.04800625890493393,
-0.7547680735588074,
-0.6518533229827881,
-0.03589264303445816,
-0.527320384979248,
-0.20649150013923645,
0.05273539572954178,
-0.9305855631828308,
-0.5069781541824341,
-0.7655093669891357,
-0.07240868359804153,
0.10371487587690353,
0.21050849556922913,
0.06751004606485367,
0.048095956444740295,
0.3061660826206207,
0.5957075357437134,
-0.7733892798423767,
0.4748636484146118,
0.25570306181907654,
1.016852855682373,
-0.3146795332431793,
0.1397853046655655,
-0.1573178619146347,
0.07148806750774384,
-0.128374382853508,
0.577302098274231,
-0.3392271399497986,
-0.7706374526023865,
-0.06927131861448288,
-0.08247755467891693,
0.3222500681877136,
-0.2085825502872467,
0.8612586259841919,
-0.07728169858455658,
0.07033143192529678,
-0.676132321357727,
-0.7346946001052856,
-0.15567058324813843,
-0.024726133793592453,
-0.394357293844223,
1.369248390197754,
0.3318687081336975,
-0.49525710940361023,
0.4742615222930908,
-0.7585471272468567,
-0.43271175026893616,
0.35881760716438293,
-0.1567094326019287,
-0.4285176694393158,
0.17126978933811188,
-0.17537635564804077,
0.7823779582977295,
-0.4955662488937378,
0.6621250510215759,
-0.30161523818969727,
-0.48781248927116394,
-0.1254080832004547,
-0.09014345705509186,
0.8900030851364136,
0.1909252107143402,
-0.13004226982593536,
0.056771617382764816,
-0.8410548567771912,
0.1733933985233307,
-0.02581540122628212,
-0.6826834678649902,
0.016338814049959183,
0.1563338041305542,
0.19401924312114716,
0.08931615203619003,
0.5208150148391724,
-0.6557965278625488,
0.49039942026138306,
0.17737551033496857,
0.3792436420917511,
1.301174283027649,
-0.06307221949100494,
0.33739545941352844,
-0.36908891797065735,
0.5816893577575684,
-0.3724640905857086,
-0.050099726766347885,
0.33796992897987366,
-0.7449333667755127,
-0.45487791299819946,
-0.045741498470306396,
0.2922424376010895,
0.4332098066806793,
-0.05127909779548645,
0.4288730323314667,
-0.16346386075019836,
-0.48178282380104065,
-0.06459275633096695,
0.4316073954105377,
0.059130627661943436,
0.45264536142349243,
0.31956541538238525,
-0.323025107383728,
-0.6514648199081421,
-0.43028825521469116,
-0.15377821028232574,
-0.3694647252559662,
0.020781537517905235,
0.33913347125053406,
0.7982957363128662,
-0.38760554790496826,
1.076910376548767,
-0.5451387763023376,
-0.4168742597103119,
-0.16471558809280396,
-0.2411832958459854,
0.030929721891880035,
0.3825765550136566,
0.4970654845237732,
-1.0417981147766113,
-0.4226846396923065,
-0.23326118290424347,
-0.594517707824707,
-0.08607082068920135,
-0.08136406540870667,
0.3151935040950775,
-0.12269774079322815,
0.30446574091911316,
-0.4122422933578491,
0.5732536911964417,
0.4998895823955536,
-0.4582967162132263,
0.7842273712158203,
-0.034632131457328796,
0.014286904595792294,
-0.7553125023841858,
-0.35471266508102417,
0.546205461025238,
-0.2722392678260803,
-0.43301868438720703,
-0.20042933523654938,
-0.12020010501146317,
-0.23290316760540009,
-0.2504388093948364,
0.8100292682647705,
-0.25584980845451355,
-0.4866771996021271,
-0.18726582825183868,
0.1554734855890274,
-0.14859068393707275,
0.1826629936695099,
0.1241096705198288,
0.7996863126754761,
0.68569415807724,
-0.7382605671882629,
0.3988681137561798,
0.2668203115463257,
-0.4982774257659912,
0.3263843357563019,
-0.6957355737686157,
0.028600845485925674,
-0.022320855408906937,
0.2480347752571106,
-1.0699578523635864,
-0.4237101078033447,
-0.24824900925159454,
-0.2914052903652191,
0.11793416738510132,
0.0614684522151947,
-0.3176170885562897,
-0.8672614097595215,
-0.2955748438835144,
-0.2125912457704544,
0.3710879385471344,
-0.7521664500236511,
0.20020952820777893,
0.33496400713920593,
-0.08310923725366592,
-0.14033213257789612,
-0.7032602429389954,
-0.09990526735782623,
-0.47847220301628113,
-0.2402542382478714,
0.4366564452648163,
-0.42191967368125916,
-0.12828794121742249,
-0.24804115295410156,
-0.39138954877853394,
0.3572813868522644,
0.40570467710494995,
0.7406218647956848,
0.2856502830982208,
0.003220894606783986,
0.056892480701208115,
-0.08485724031925201,
0.06234502047300339,
0.3962608873844147,
-0.2266579419374466,
0.15772728621959686,
-0.09668876975774765,
0.163043811917305,
-0.38182663917541504,
0.13484318554401398,
0.4637654721736908,
0.19765621423721313,
0.6951794624328613,
0.36968865990638733,
-0.6036098003387451,
-0.16142912209033966,
-0.16932301223278046,
-0.3229326903820038,
-0.4751449525356293,
0.2349725365638733,
-0.6659849286079407,
-0.9047451615333557,
0.46708735823631287,
-0.7102558612823486,
0.11896119266748428,
0.2575077712535858,
0.35358554124832153,
-0.24999253451824188,
0.9727414846420288,
1.1148980855941772,
-0.2618313133716583,
0.4845476746559143,
-0.5044591426849365,
-0.04428449645638466,
-0.8064124584197998,
-0.39758816361427307,
-0.3663601577281952,
-0.35419920086860657,
-0.5089487433433533,
-0.08019562065601349,
0.04431922361254692,
1.0881773233413696,
-0.11980712413787842,
0.4374890625476837,
-0.7446014881134033,
0.5935462117195129,
0.27672702074050903,
-0.20655781030654907,
-0.07680398225784302,
0.09607118368148804,
-0.20625197887420654,
-0.14179661870002747,
-0.3801450729370117,
-1.0269052982330322,
1.4101314544677734,
0.5231121182441711,
0.68680340051651,
0.13307620584964752,
0.8440718054771423,
1.0925832986831665,
0.64665287733078,
-0.63114333152771,
0.6381602883338928,
-0.26108819246292114,
-0.5250576734542847,
-0.33130696415901184,
-0.3060271441936493,
-0.6192166209220886,
-0.08026665449142456,
-0.07148748636245728,
-1.0415716171264648,
-0.29479193687438965,
-0.051978304982185364,
-0.2873762547969818,
0.19791767001152039,
-0.3804990351200104,
0.7509599328041077,
-0.3437858819961548,
-0.15236347913742065,
-0.12802082300186157,
-0.531493067741394,
0.22268356382846832,
-0.07415775954723358,
0.4955897927284241,
-0.5421081781387329,
0.13705819845199585,
1.1463863849639893,
0.12523016333580017,
0.9947646260261536,
-0.36433935165405273,
-0.1667366474866867,
0.48895931243896484,
-0.36487889289855957,
0.40778714418411255,
0.3574804365634918,
-0.44491276144981384,
0.07751847058534622,
-0.08171723037958145,
-0.6886810660362244,
0.13059309124946594,
0.8459356427192688,
-1.0443309545516968,
-0.6653661727905273,
-0.4541950523853302,
-0.36634767055511475,
0.002176327630877495,
0.07760106027126312,
0.2196236401796341,
-0.12110507488250732,
-0.6887388229370117,
-0.2612507939338684,
0.6263309717178345,
0.08636922389268875,
0.3799654245376587,
0.4004206657409668,
-0.19771578907966614,
-0.42799022793769836,
0.7680500149726868,
0.043526336550712585,
0.47280967235565186,
0.37727174162864685,
0.5024710297584534,
-0.7558034658432007,
-0.7510755658149719,
-0.6434890031814575,
0.032496772706508636,
-0.9165442585945129,
-0.5352907180786133,
-0.022022249177098274,
-0.15894414484500885,
-0.6368618607521057,
-0.6755194067955017,
0.09219084680080414,
-0.22342506051063538,
-0.8259104490280151,
-0.5267760753631592,
0.40741798281669617,
1.1559866666793823,
-0.29821979999542236,
0.45767590403556824,
-0.3289036452770233,
0.24752257764339447,
0.07304133474826813,
0.1477225422859192,
-0.6952111124992371,
-0.6229546070098877,
-0.17992635071277618,
0.5306984782218933,
-0.7177966833114624,
-0.6867070198059082,
0.21084709465503693,
0.5562387704849243,
0.35432374477386475,
0.6603719592094421,
0.16340374946594238,
0.4216538369655609,
-0.13034583628177643,
1.0078718662261963,
0.6776387095451355,
-0.7845097780227661,
0.9738209247589111,
-0.2657848596572876,
0.05881496146321297,
0.41403138637542725,
0.581422746181488,
-0.13128122687339783,
-0.014012143947184086,
-0.5328157544136047,
-0.3896556496620178,
0.40958288311958313,
-0.4225442409515381,
0.15330518782138824,
0.05030272528529167,
0.892399251461029,
0.5458912253379822,
-0.06097792461514473,
-1.0705984830856323,
-0.4853716194629669,
0.09659650176763535,
-0.27398431301116943,
-0.3485831916332245,
-0.291375070810318,
0.06791055202484131,
-0.40119823813438416,
0.6309972405433655,
-0.23710279166698456,
0.13723812997341156,
-0.25420820713043213,
0.2289394736289978,
-0.55909264087677,
0.27052101492881775,
0.688889741897583,
0.6548395156860352,
-0.21811600029468536,
0.013079934753477573,
0.4005853533744812,
-0.5235670208930969,
0.3206876516342163,
-0.053110308945178986,
-0.25266212224960327,
-0.06513027101755142,
0.011415284126996994,
0.41932177543640137,
0.13483454287052155,
-0.61382657289505,
-0.0027414080686867237,
0.0826062485575676,
-0.31786346435546875,
-0.5402215719223022,
0.16818290948867798,
0.09222718328237534,
0.15054897964000702,
0.41814330220222473,
0.12123720347881317,
-0.0383773036301136,
-0.7233482003211975,
0.2259354442358017,
0.12337435781955719,
-0.4102267026901245,
-0.19905906915664673,
1.0260006189346313,
0.3206256330013275,
-0.35139891505241394,
0.380300909280777,
-0.19467392563819885,
-0.6219714879989624,
0.5718339681625366,
0.808381199836731,
0.31992873549461365,
-0.35060927271842957,
0.3706727623939514,
0.5716196298599243,
0.08617834001779556,
-0.30524182319641113,
0.6440691947937012,
-0.1466522365808487,
-0.6059543490409851,
-0.1251058727502823,
-1.3159236907958984,
-0.5033566951751709,
0.21365907788276672,
-0.7293992042541504,
0.5756205320358276,
-0.738572359085083,
-0.23198162019252777,
0.24376986920833588,
0.8315402269363403,
-0.8792404532432556,
0.7318522930145264,
-0.03924737870693207,
0.6840925812721252,
-1.0492247343063354,
1.0802079439163208,
0.8761199116706848,
-0.3346157371997833,
-0.6240624189376831,
-0.5787959694862366,
0.07376137375831604,
-0.7973117232322693,
0.6582210659980774,
0.3561508357524872,
0.026749487966299057,
0.1148747131228447,
-0.5366258025169373,
-0.9536873698234558,
1.3119025230407715,
0.4570189416408539,
-0.898252010345459,
-0.06275301426649094,
0.48302632570266724,
0.20944809913635254,
-0.5125325322151184,
-0.36591652035713196,
0.6031050086021423,
0.5681822896003723,
-0.04350149631500244,
-0.584064781665802,
-0.20654414594173431,
0.25326433777809143,
-0.11978787928819656,
0.49753516912460327,
-0.44056758284568787,
0.8034329414367676,
-0.8024190664291382,
-0.23447197675704956,
0.2851427495479584,
0.8771328330039978,
0.12878026068210602,
0.4379792809486389,
0.1504870504140854,
0.7791208028793335,
0.9385573267936707,
-0.47571632266044617,
1.0786491632461548,
-0.1713222861289978,
0.5611538887023926,
0.7307133078575134,
-0.020945459604263306,
0.7618326544761658,
0.36262112855911255,
-0.7751408815383911,
0.288614422082901,
1.1786949634552002,
-0.21692197024822235,
0.6241512894630432,
0.6644778251647949,
-0.3550114333629608,
-0.06320474296808243,
-0.1419631838798523,
-0.2758522927761078,
0.5179937481880188,
0.5569626092910767,
-0.4076400399208069,
0.08361560106277466,
0.09902121126651764,
-0.3004398047924042,
0.30972397327423096,
-0.8682699203491211,
0.5438781976699829,
0.29976001381874084,
-0.3741951584815979,
0.2983148992061615,
0.43827614188194275,
0.6671758890151978,
-0.1926046758890152,
-0.14800846576690674,
0.008232059888541698,
0.445178747177124,
-0.3160436451435089,
-0.8891478776931763,
0.12803129851818085,
-0.11794906109571457,
-0.34334567189216614,
-0.4834945499897003,
0.6409918069839478,
-0.5668619275093079,
-0.585328221321106,
0.18086034059524536,
0.05909910798072815,
0.7052968144416809,
0.36377912759780884,
-0.7912272214889526,
-0.1089361235499382,
0.31021445989608765,
0.22406770288944244,
0.37880945205688477,
0.09105810523033142,
-0.1892336905002594,
0.7040414214134216,
0.49834349751472473,
0.13329437375068665,
0.12155305594205856,
-0.18789982795715332,
0.4183275103569031,
-0.7129201292991638,
-0.5696389079093933,
-0.6332200765609741,
0.21395787596702576,
0.0779658854007721,
-0.4943865239620209,
0.7519422769546509,
0.7035143971443176,
1.0737532377243042,
0.03949282690882683,
0.9238801002502441,
-0.023595105856657028,
0.14681506156921387,
-0.41326087713241577,
0.45459118485450745,
-0.23569384217262268,
0.254901260137558,
0.04419444873929024,
-1.277930498123169,
0.043784767389297485,
0.8040685653686523,
-0.3433085083961487,
0.21886834502220154,
0.10077879577875137,
0.18830911815166473,
0.24937862157821655,
0.3302284777164459,
0.465210884809494,
-0.4709106385707855,
0.17952191829681396,
0.5499355792999268,
0.5721964836120605,
-0.20094922184944153,
-0.06546871364116669,
-0.42820093035697937,
-0.09606090188026428,
-0.3220263421535492,
-0.5993666052818298,
-0.9994013905525208,
-0.4379667043685913,
-0.8988761305809021,
-0.32547053694725037,
0.1309983730316162,
0.5707811117172241,
0.7203273177146912,
-1.047133445739746,
-0.28350380063056946,
-0.48182642459869385,
0.36155232787132263,
0.018781736493110657,
-0.27212217450141907,
0.5026761889457703,
0.33728697896003723,
-0.4147648811340332,
0.1834392100572586,
0.005730787292122841,
0.46287861466407776,
-0.6029213666915894,
-0.6177914142608643,
-0.20376978814601898,
-0.10083736479282379,
0.4279663562774658,
0.3216618299484253,
-1.0197484493255615,
-0.7828505635261536,
-0.3938244879245758,
-0.0023265236523002386,
-0.18379639089107513,
0.6353033185005188,
-0.7271043062210083,
-0.16991859674453735,
-0.2511122226715088,
0.3387666940689087,
0.5105927586555481,
-0.0019380456069484353,
0.38114574551582336,
-0.7539008259773254,
-0.1779576987028122,
0.2615469992160797,
0.5110878944396973,
0.6342056393623352,
-0.5387982726097107,
0.7786183953285217,
0.0723562240600586,
-0.4820129871368408,
-0.7315823435783386,
0.36315110325813293,
-0.9245332479476929,
-0.0720108151435852,
0.9795776009559631,
-0.4860553443431854,
0.09942606091499329,
-0.0021486280020326376,
-0.06193723902106285,
0.14287300407886505,
-0.3055907189846039,
0.9101873636245728,
0.6815487742424011,
-0.29604390263557434,
-0.32534998655319214,
-0.5219440460205078,
0.6936970949172974,
0.03756585717201233,
-0.839085578918457,
0.015795299783349037,
0.6385203003883362,
0.5102519989013672,
-0.017226118594408035,
0.5000400543212891,
0.28906938433647156,
0.1642744541168213,
0.013740230351686478,
0.13995465636253357,
0.25523361563682556,
-0.5348737239837646,
-0.10670944303274155,
0.04310400411486626,
0.1672680675983429,
0.018012361600995064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05574v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05574v2
|
HealMe: Harnessing Cognitive Reframing in Large Language Models for Psychotherapy
| 2024-02-26T09:10:34 | 2024-03-22T07:34:38 |
Mengxi Xiao, Qianqian Xie, Ziyan Kuang, Zhicheng Liu, Kailai Yang, Min Peng, Weiguang Han, Jimin Huang
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, J.4
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can play a vital role in psychotherapy by
adeptly handling the crucial task of cognitive reframing and overcoming
challenges such as shame, distrust, therapist skill variability, and resource
scarcity. Previous LLMs in cognitive reframing mainly converted negative
emotions to positive ones, but these approaches have limited efficacy, often
not promoting clients' self-discovery of alternative perspectives. In this
paper, we unveil the Helping and Empowering through Adaptive Language in Mental
Enhancement (HealMe) model. This novel cognitive reframing therapy method
effectively addresses deep-rooted negative thoughts and fosters rational,
balanced perspectives. Diverging from traditional LLM methods, HealMe employs
empathetic dialogue based on psychotherapeutic frameworks. It systematically
guides clients through distinguishing circumstances from feelings,
brainstorming alternative viewpoints, and developing empathetic, actionable
suggestions. Moreover, we adopt the first comprehensive and expertly crafted
psychological evaluation metrics, specifically designed to rigorously assess
the performance of cognitive reframing, in both AI-simulated dialogues and
real-world therapeutic conversations. Experimental results show that our model
outperforms others in terms of empathy, guidance, and logical coherence,
demonstrating its effectiveness and potential positive impact on psychotherapy.
|
[
-0.32457152009010315,
-0.9113144278526306,
0.7403972148895264,
0.16720977425575256,
-0.3050910234451294,
0.010345995426177979,
-0.48037803173065186,
-0.5766674876213074,
0.410189688205719,
0.554253339767456,
-0.6702014803886414,
-0.325033962726593,
-0.8105151057243347,
0.05758165195584297,
0.06834807991981506,
0.8236086368560791,
0.11359450966119766,
0.4923058748245239,
0.026986094191670418,
-0.3762383460998535,
-1.030571699142456,
-0.1309753656387329,
-0.9223061203956604,
-0.6261892318725586,
0.362911581993103,
0.4040490388870239,
0.5159758925437927,
0.04331377148628235,
0.3530794680118561,
0.30718129873275757,
0.2179509550333023,
0.006890775635838509,
-0.5395476818084717,
0.3393150568008423,
-0.6476828455924988,
-0.7153753638267517,
-0.5971918106079102,
0.16358323395252228,
0.252414733171463,
0.4922979176044464,
-0.6959701776504517,
0.09894728660583496,
-0.10484062880277634,
0.5134058594703674,
-0.5521019101142883,
0.03891463950276375,
-0.9113878607749939,
0.0016052783466875553,
0.07121194154024124,
0.055574677884578705,
-0.5447564721107483,
-0.2491905689239502,
0.13474109768867493,
-0.44484743475914,
-0.06067271903157234,
0.08316868543624878,
0.31897637248039246,
0.4429580271244049,
-0.5094845294952393,
-0.14796122908592224,
-0.7031636834144592,
0.9834486246109009,
-1.0557502508163452,
0.3835636377334595,
0.3533796966075897,
0.5119335055351257,
-0.17062406241893768,
-0.6407172083854675,
-0.2974953353404999,
-0.23271121084690094,
0.0036696160677820444,
0.3248819410800934,
-0.34591013193130493,
0.09039479494094849,
0.2638336718082428,
0.5169396996498108,
-0.036524590104818344,
0.07937481999397278,
-0.090569868683815,
-0.2502524256706238,
0.45214787125587463,
0.4653487205505371,
0.40949690341949463,
0.21944226324558258,
-0.3944190442562103,
0.22989816963672638,
-0.24133148789405823,
-0.14120295643806458,
-0.5165191292762756,
0.18580560386180878,
-0.08680492639541626,
0.21004094183444977,
-0.057737912982702255,
0.440274178981781,
0.08877529948949814,
-0.4885152280330658,
-0.10392475128173828,
0.0864710882306099,
-0.39750343561172485,
0.1424073725938797,
0.4165634214878082,
0.6124283075332642,
0.10961014032363892,
-0.16478833556175232,
0.11607532203197479,
0.27242511510849,
0.7797272801399231,
-1.0164474248886108,
-0.12885406613349915,
0.15484409034252167,
-0.4034906029701233,
-0.23232266306877136,
-0.6632153987884521,
-0.8461978435516357,
-0.528072714805603,
-0.2720022201538086,
0.2547873556613922,
-0.7138116359710693,
-0.42003804445266724,
0.43484556674957275,
-0.021475480869412422,
0.22330045700073242,
0.5366498231887817,
-0.7394993901252747,
0.4467211067676544,
0.4328652024269104,
0.5916439294815063,
0.37241673469543457,
-0.06079835444688797,
-0.3927731215953827,
0.23706617951393127,
-0.16263531148433685,
0.8126450181007385,
-0.8674672842025757,
-0.16773132979869843,
-0.17337295413017273,
0.1688779592514038,
0.07779952883720398,
-0.3126395642757416,
0.7575948238372803,
-0.36479711532592773,
0.3895012438297272,
-0.17565879225730896,
-0.6002923250198364,
-0.38132792711257935,
0.6585499048233032,
-0.3666319251060486,
0.4497194290161133,
0.289364218711853,
-0.6044279336929321,
0.1954316943883896,
-0.6165493130683899,
-0.3509252071380615,
0.15255849063396454,
-0.001458451384678483,
-0.11620907485485077,
0.6265497803688049,
0.13149023056030273,
0.164251446723938,
-0.8900518417358398,
0.19790875911712646,
-0.5829747319221497,
-0.046695586293935776,
0.32565736770629883,
-0.5199374556541443,
0.534786581993103,
0.19134421646595,
-0.265730082988739,
0.1980719268321991,
-0.6014825701713562,
0.28294357657432556,
0.23670335114002228,
-0.12191303819417953,
-0.5952702164649963,
-0.3632359206676483,
-0.0630720779299736,
0.3190074563026428,
0.05032467842102051,
-0.7721560001373291,
0.14859136939048767,
-0.7080414295196533,
0.6156163215637207,
0.49579012393951416,
0.17201359570026398,
0.34710806608200073,
-0.4014229476451874,
0.6978520750999451,
-0.12966519594192505,
0.16580703854560852,
-0.34379562735557556,
-0.41092509031295776,
-0.4329912066459656,
-0.6400875449180603,
-0.1870039403438568,
0.4201945960521698,
-0.5173501372337341,
0.028041550889611244,
0.0897313579916954,
-0.7864555716514587,
-1.094668984413147,
-0.04128701612353325,
0.36891114711761475,
0.8693279027938843,
0.5883457660675049,
-0.4914548099040985,
-0.4126049876213074,
-1.0665247440338135,
-0.44500651955604553,
0.14804351329803467,
0.13707242906093597,
0.3718591034412384,
0.15133142471313477,
-0.538006603717804,
0.4162084758281708,
-0.5090479254722595,
-0.25785669684410095,
-0.06504330784082413,
-0.15632350742816925,
0.08508360385894775,
0.2638170123100281,
0.25435876846313477,
-0.2487824708223343,
-0.20923028886318207,
-0.2821027934551239,
-0.6755783557891846,
-0.1053612232208252,
-0.3077983260154724,
-0.32811108231544495,
0.009407933801412582,
0.2502744793891907,
-0.3123880922794342,
0.3806551694869995,
0.36929911375045776,
-0.6354012489318848,
0.2603703737258911,
-0.33083024621009827,
0.37163519859313965,
-1.1716980934143066,
-0.03811124339699745,
-0.2161223441362381,
-0.3229946792125702,
-0.5000999569892883,
0.11583534628152847,
-0.08689109981060028,
0.013755198568105698,
-0.25101909041404724,
0.5033684968948364,
-0.4252460300922394,
0.3964661657810211,
-0.5740265846252441,
0.4680134356021881,
0.021877694875001907,
0.4764953851699829,
-0.02700112760066986,
0.07757909595966339,
0.40276220440864563,
-0.11688269674777985,
0.6081509590148926,
0.24879077076911926,
-0.2759152948856354,
1.112830638885498,
-0.3533812165260315,
0.3302946090698242,
0.03622276708483696,
0.5986181497573853,
-0.7951536178588867,
0.0651136115193367,
0.1787380576133728,
-0.09422926604747772,
0.3112044930458069,
-0.029305126518011093,
-0.012284958735108376,
-0.22714360058307648,
-0.19447767734527588,
0.7412189841270447,
0.4962575137615204,
-0.3892413079738617,
0.5434994101524353,
0.2695608139038086,
-0.08658241480588913,
-0.36549291014671326,
-0.7288135290145874,
0.34080150723457336,
-0.40875566005706787,
-0.6825016140937805,
0.33260872960090637,
-0.24206148087978363,
-0.3565705418586731,
-0.194600448012352,
0.1420454978942871,
0.20578154921531677,
0.2141236513853073,
0.16798296570777893,
0.0901980996131897,
-0.12142191082239151,
0.23296557366847992,
0.22276732325553894,
-0.4556494951248169,
0.14635267853736877,
-0.24683180451393127,
0.5208622217178345,
-0.36490437388420105,
-0.569884717464447,
-0.4210606813430786,
0.3195433020591736,
0.8100520968437195,
-0.32684049010276794,
0.8136981725692749,
0.8211231827735901,
-0.5630260109901428,
-0.1880200356245041,
-0.7952957153320312,
-0.42397642135620117,
-0.35822126269340515,
0.5577945113182068,
-0.2695299983024597,
-0.9394489526748657,
0.39571458101272583,
-0.4057377278804779,
-0.005315580405294895,
-0.12041716277599335,
0.840940535068512,
0.20833927392959595,
0.9597789645195007,
0.5545236468315125,
-0.13279852271080017,
0.5351677536964417,
0.055013447999954224,
0.3855087161064148,
-1.2305420637130737,
-0.0031307849567383528,
0.024414585903286934,
-0.4787046015262604,
-0.31983712315559387,
-0.3964563012123108,
0.10756188631057739,
0.18323633074760437,
-0.5385814905166626,
-0.1364382654428482,
-0.7530004382133484,
0.08809331059455872,
0.22285427153110504,
0.4284065365791321,
0.39247339963912964,
-0.16147851943969727,
-0.04342057555913925,
-0.6259220838546753,
-0.4973369538784027,
-0.5204387903213501,
0.8139254450798035,
0.4934932291507721,
0.5864393711090088,
0.2550922930240631,
0.46937069296836853,
0.04699292778968811,
1.1428223848342896,
-1.169897198677063,
0.4033651351928711,
0.2391081601381302,
-0.6522734761238098,
-0.054643675684928894,
-0.16708238422870636,
-0.9210877418518066,
0.3869273066520691,
-0.28338882327079773,
-0.7618314623832703,
0.0048926896415650845,
-0.027673816308379173,
-0.2923319339752197,
0.38063910603523254,
-0.6520613431930542,
0.7602859735488892,
-0.24310515820980072,
-0.33153975009918213,
-0.9197526574134827,
-0.42757707834243774,
0.5497941374778748,
-0.1368013322353363,
0.5062648057937622,
-0.18129342794418335,
-0.19470950961112976,
0.412346214056015,
-0.4289763867855072,
0.8002122640609741,
-0.34543299674987793,
-0.2357141226530075,
0.11819592118263245,
0.5713458061218262,
0.21464617550373077,
0.15053506195545197,
-0.2861853837966919,
-0.043408725410699844,
0.1941847801208496,
-0.6405267119407654,
-0.8478309512138367,
0.8031209111213684,
-0.44992056488990784,
-0.9126515984535217,
-0.1132611334323883,
-0.603900134563446,
-0.5445088744163513,
0.3704459071159363,
-0.15325668454170227,
0.3844677209854126,
-0.5298969149589539,
-0.09163486212491989,
0.28795915842056274,
-0.5579450130462646,
0.09518913924694061,
1.1741713285446167,
-0.3903709053993225,
-0.8156585693359375,
0.6295313239097595,
-0.17816950380802155,
0.46847236156463623,
0.13261961936950684,
0.3838571608066559,
0.11316857486963272,
-0.39180803298950195,
0.07288938015699387,
0.40532439947128296,
-0.6652516722679138,
-0.35379666090011597,
-0.17562514543533325,
0.08362668752670288,
-0.2942269742488861,
-0.3352019190788269,
-0.48768487572669983,
-0.30578097701072693,
0.3480032980442047,
-0.2859332263469696,
0.4861237406730652,
0.5685876607894897,
-0.15034456551074982,
-0.014115139842033386,
-0.7883281707763672,
0.11518649011850357,
0.1463770866394043,
0.4355776906013489,
0.4783768057823181,
-0.6442731618881226,
-0.419376015663147,
0.28269052505493164,
-0.39548856019973755,
-0.9105643033981323,
0.571047306060791,
-0.1380283534526825,
0.32026320695877075,
0.37563639879226685,
0.04614061862230301,
0.554500937461853,
-0.49880141019821167,
0.5897860527038574,
0.4325252175331116,
-0.6623161435127258,
0.7157770395278931,
-0.28570058941841125,
0.4484502673149109,
0.5239155292510986,
-0.0904432013630867,
-0.9222709536552429,
-0.4798692762851715,
-0.6487845778465271,
-0.8532086610794067,
0.6283924579620361,
-0.2307993769645691,
0.3054286539554596,
-0.2366105169057846,
0.7148043513298035,
-0.035751618444919586,
0.13655714690685272,
-0.5424612164497375,
-0.01165054365992546,
-0.10920116305351257,
-0.5796415209770203,
0.03305777907371521,
-0.2567596137523651,
-0.6459888815879822,
-0.19140630960464478,
0.7033771872520447,
-0.08170640468597412,
0.3984283208847046,
0.43226760625839233,
-0.013071127235889435,
-0.30552729964256287,
0.4718475341796875,
0.421438992023468,
0.10130330175161362,
0.022776683792471886,
0.20912013947963715,
0.6715095639228821,
-0.44396406412124634,
0.02786444127559662,
-0.10258873552083969,
0.44016462564468384,
-0.5890141129493713,
0.6401503682136536,
0.5611503720283508,
0.4075925946235657,
-0.6392184495925903,
0.21627122163772583,
-0.29844337701797485,
0.2534606456756592,
-0.2284952700138092,
0.10089529305696487,
0.43903976678848267,
0.6690132021903992,
-0.15052223205566406,
0.17893870174884796,
0.12163745611906052,
-0.7232476472854614,
-0.024323156103491783,
0.46928682923316956,
-0.7408991456031799,
-0.3577048182487488,
0.46795377135276794,
0.18072734773159027,
-0.6708172559738159,
0.8373730182647705,
0.2903115153312683,
-0.43629321455955505,
0.29394567012786865,
0.9412534236907959,
0.9514203071594238,
-0.3967617452144623,
-0.08151817321777344,
0.2955070436000824,
0.30878546833992004,
0.20847316086292267,
-0.0425141341984272,
-0.054072070866823196,
-1.0658639669418335,
-0.2176680862903595,
-0.5146231055259705,
-0.3122749924659729,
0.009609158150851727,
-1.001346468925476,
-0.08738449960947037,
-0.5444539785385132,
-0.3447674810886383,
-0.20353765785694122,
0.12833081185817719,
-0.618406355381012,
0.2855864465236664,
0.2839914560317993,
1.071967601776123,
-0.5694296956062317,
0.900600016117096,
0.8475168943405151,
-0.4000285267829895,
-0.7846798896789551,
-0.193191260099411,
0.1954452246427536,
-1.1682435274124146,
0.1042415127158165,
0.02600325085222721,
-0.2992735803127289,
0.012944212183356285,
-0.420768141746521,
-0.6646844744682312,
1.4713290929794312,
0.7294213175773621,
-0.4353064298629761,
0.23408369719982147,
-0.09605512022972107,
0.8381617665290833,
-0.6363542675971985,
0.6709426641464233,
0.7206574082374573,
0.5700907111167908,
-0.07000064104795456,
-0.7160802483558655,
0.6189002990722656,
-0.30185988545417786,
-0.07230839878320694,
0.11840444058179855,
-1.0037007331848145,
0.000427717313868925,
-0.29365259408950806,
-0.07430680841207504,
0.05412694811820984,
0.21496105194091797,
0.20244018733501434,
0.3308175504207611,
0.4861423671245575,
0.7590364217758179,
1.0177432298660278,
0.15595699846744537,
1.021385908126831,
-0.5506703853607178,
0.0093700485303998,
1.287356972694397,
-0.19675539433956146,
0.7284151911735535,
0.511476457118988,
-0.009531869553029537,
0.7019192576408386,
0.35291996598243713,
0.0879409909248352,
0.36780574917793274,
0.09125541150569916,
-0.5048408508300781,
-0.3795100152492523,
-0.3511919379234314,
-0.1351645290851593,
0.1544487476348877,
0.5521633625030518,
-0.35989445447921753,
-0.06672204285860062,
0.2764020562171936,
0.2598806917667389,
0.3216341435909271,
-0.19395725429058075,
0.7000755667686462,
0.6524789929389954,
-0.683901846408844,
0.5484688878059387,
0.12899786233901978,
0.4450431764125824,
-0.5305068492889404,
-0.050229381769895554,
-0.27567341923713684,
0.5623750686645508,
-0.3172926902770996,
-0.6275051236152649,
0.489097535610199,
-0.2247798591852188,
-0.3473934531211853,
-0.3892253339290619,
0.8167855739593506,
-0.4267083704471588,
-0.36207547783851624,
0.6930596828460693,
0.3514612317085266,
-0.04894278198480606,
-0.03227824717760086,
-0.8869701027870178,
-0.04220208153128624,
0.09508610516786575,
-0.192345529794693,
0.4080318808555603,
0.6336016058921814,
0.026580989360809326,
0.9132151007652283,
0.3600634038448334,
-0.09364266693592072,
-0.5847477316856384,
0.3244931697845459,
0.7343882322311401,
-0.9400418996810913,
-0.10366344451904297,
-0.9021954536437988,
0.5639510750770569,
0.05777948349714279,
-0.11025246232748032,
0.729292631149292,
0.1062779426574707,
0.42649731040000916,
0.19554908573627472,
0.46503642201423645,
0.20251913368701935,
0.35937821865081787,
-0.2602582573890686,
0.5033139586448669,
-0.49894002079963684,
0.4745045006275177,
-0.36205190420150757,
-0.7203219532966614,
-0.28166037797927856,
0.6486862301826477,
-0.6899856925010681,
0.03915717452764511,
0.7329779267311096,
0.6991952657699585,
0.1898864507675171,
0.37556177377700806,
0.4546971321105957,
0.8391066789627075,
0.5223773717880249,
0.9770965576171875,
0.8806445598602295,
-0.29173868894577026,
0.14659737050533295,
0.010953661054372787,
-0.596088707447052,
0.10382512211799622,
-0.6949422955513,
-0.5990118384361267,
-0.18323583900928497,
-0.15710821747779846,
-0.45410871505737305,
-0.26712533831596375,
1.1212913990020752,
0.6042392253875732,
-0.5165040493011475,
0.05808713287115097,
-0.019575800746679306,
0.10664741694927216,
-0.20824924111366272,
-0.25806933641433716,
-0.0608941912651062,
-0.31974083185195923,
-0.3657922148704529,
0.4808453619480133,
0.6292499303817749,
-0.31968843936920166,
-0.3375076949596405,
-0.07832295447587967,
0.059617746621370316,
0.4735521376132965,
0.5801082849502563,
-0.10953819006681442,
-0.6212462782859802,
-0.36373353004455566,
-0.3302425742149353,
-0.02193007618188858,
0.13836371898651123,
0.8298534750938416,
-0.9191665053367615,
0.7552501559257507,
-0.16654346883296967,
0.5039538145065308,
0.6750971078872681,
-0.2622133195400238,
1.0721508264541626,
0.07889305800199509,
0.24195364117622375,
0.2709352374076843,
0.49528419971466064,
0.2658703923225403,
-0.43590644001960754,
0.36991938948631287,
0.052694424986839294,
-0.5599495768547058,
-0.735798716545105,
0.5648311376571655,
-0.7841660976409912,
-0.43041953444480896,
0.7336147427558899,
-0.3045419156551361,
-0.13469646871089935,
0.017487965524196625,
-0.821109414100647,
0.2069835066795349,
-0.13033179938793182,
1.0068080425262451,
0.7339453101158142,
-0.27398574352264404,
-0.13663135468959808,
-0.3005691170692444,
0.355543315410614,
0.7467835545539856,
-0.7074779272079468,
0.17162810266017914,
0.5119963884353638,
0.611553966999054,
0.030719934031367302,
0.7423586249351501,
-0.26798301935195923,
-0.03518537059426308,
-0.07082906365394592,
0.10556595772504807,
0.011565013788640499,
0.3403950035572052,
-0.40130481123924255,
-0.06946714967489243,
0.26576024293899536,
0.4915527105331421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16406v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16406v1
|
From RAGs to riches: Using large language models to write documents for clinical trials
| 2024-02-26T08:59:05 | 2024-02-26T08:59:05 |
Nigel Markey, Ilyass El-Mansouri, Gaetan Rensonnet, Casper van Langen, Christoph Meier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Clinical trials require numerous documents to be written -- protocols,
consent forms, clinical study reports and others. Large language models (LLMs)
offer the potential to rapidly generate first versions of these documents,
however there are concerns about the quality of their output Here we report an
evaluation of LLMs in generating parts of one such document, clinical trial
protocols. We find that an offthe-shelf LLM delivers reasonable results,
especially when assessing content relevance and the correct use of terminology.
However, deficiencies remain: specifically clinical thinking and logic, and
appropriate use of references. To improve performance, we used
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) to prompt an LLM with accurate up-to-date
information. As a result of using RAG, the writing quality of the LLM improves
substantially, which has implications for the practical useability of LLMs in
clinical trial-related writing.
|
[
0.26309388875961304,
-0.3646027445793152,
0.8891058564186096,
0.13725091516971588,
-0.2513686716556549,
0.0021274336613714695,
-0.25845128297805786,
-0.36426565051078796,
0.495089590549469,
0.9272223114967346,
0.1936921775341034,
-0.39015334844589233,
-0.8520604372024536,
0.1784282624721527,
-0.5968138575553894,
1.150398850440979,
-0.1184544712305069,
0.4354804456233978,
-0.20243316888809204,
-0.17009708285331726,
-0.3685746192932129,
-0.4116206467151642,
-0.6391796469688416,
-0.40254244208335876,
0.8808661103248596,
0.40983226895332336,
0.5374219417572021,
0.5480590462684631,
0.9870638251304626,
0.3224579095840454,
0.05497552454471588,
0.039428289979696274,
-0.9108608365058899,
0.39887258410453796,
-0.22663259506225586,
-0.5519590973854065,
-0.7184454798698425,
0.05740673094987869,
0.4369998276233673,
0.7653173804283142,
-0.31566888093948364,
0.08127652853727341,
-0.19166895747184753,
0.7488966584205627,
-0.6502380967140198,
-0.1442040652036667,
-0.6312873363494873,
-0.07508149743080139,
-0.35591360926628113,
-0.5102642774581909,
-0.6588851809501648,
-0.36581936478614807,
0.15611395239830017,
-0.6601845026016235,
0.32801151275634766,
0.050969064235687256,
0.8020431399345398,
-0.3391033113002777,
-0.23137696087360382,
-1.0434489250183105,
-0.7245904207229614,
0.6573469638824463,
-1.0550119876861572,
0.14994369447231293,
0.5486854910850525,
0.33301371335983276,
-0.4487740695476532,
-1.1679284572601318,
-0.38526543974876404,
-0.7213850021362305,
-0.17440710961818695,
0.22329875826835632,
0.2565213739871979,
0.07921053469181061,
0.40114283561706543,
0.5827757716178894,
-0.4306563436985016,
0.07280409336090088,
-0.4636565148830414,
-0.09264931082725525,
0.8363989591598511,
0.44122231006622314,
0.14139336347579956,
-0.10332046449184418,
-0.017520496621727943,
-0.14117051661014557,
-0.9977778196334839,
-0.3772183060646057,
0.14508043229579926,
0.45728376507759094,
0.234223410487175,
1.0198636054992676,
-0.009115776978433132,
0.4457351565361023,
-0.3291721045970917,
-0.6964212656021118,
-0.06856942176818848,
-0.4172342121601105,
-0.33067867159843445,
-0.03405856713652611,
0.4681210517883301,
0.4939078092575073,
0.17384010553359985,
-0.38839486241340637,
-0.5872765779495239,
-0.07624662667512894,
0.6209166646003723,
-0.869049072265625,
-0.09204528480768204,
0.330870121717453,
-0.6862812638282776,
-0.40055662393569946,
-0.2083646059036255,
-0.49029895663261414,
-0.7631650567054749,
-0.2960679531097412,
0.7490921020507812,
-0.4442240595817566,
-0.01201917976140976,
0.2574796676635742,
-0.5429834723472595,
0.07285600155591965,
0.46619388461112976,
-0.5868692398071289,
0.4756329357624054,
0.4965037405490875,
0.7756339907646179,
0.10233617573976517,
0.05788156017661095,
-0.9304554462432861,
0.3817194104194641,
-0.5567166209220886,
0.7470138669013977,
-0.07135283946990967,
-0.7798816561698914,
0.3012642562389374,
-0.1832505464553833,
0.16768264770507812,
-0.5930981040000916,
0.6133261322975159,
-0.5596460700035095,
0.038509827107191086,
-0.275382936000824,
-0.9242966771125793,
0.5649492740631104,
0.035038236528635025,
-0.5507501363754272,
0.4166397154331207,
0.3378818929195404,
-0.6270590424537659,
0.4716367721557617,
-0.329170823097229,
-0.6493735313415527,
0.3622203767299652,
-0.2420690655708313,
-0.43319419026374817,
0.5234877467155457,
-0.2810112535953522,
0.4237314462661743,
-0.3423280119895935,
0.2764874994754791,
-0.1743493676185608,
-0.24290713667869568,
0.5392261743545532,
0.014739098027348518,
0.42076048254966736,
0.34135711193084717,
-0.19872339069843292,
-0.26160791516304016,
-0.7240206003189087,
-0.26242464780807495,
0.26150083541870117,
-0.5636947154998779,
-0.3819824159145355,
-0.10857381671667099,
0.26628270745277405,
-0.08264446258544922,
0.006478986702859402,
-0.6891397833824158,
0.2030036449432373,
-0.38498660922050476,
0.31193792819976807,
0.38434404134750366,
-0.059817589819431305,
0.17142531275749207,
-0.7632731199264526,
0.4052240550518036,
-0.3736792802810669,
-0.02288469858467579,
-0.22677339613437653,
-0.3276873528957367,
-0.9269525408744812,
-0.05059065669775009,
0.6806170344352722,
0.18621329963207245,
-0.6448405385017395,
0.014303193427622318,
-0.24902448058128357,
-0.5991971492767334,
-0.17309170961380005,
0.026369161903858185,
0.5025901794433594,
0.5632121562957764,
0.081358902156353,
-0.4939132034778595,
-0.436134934425354,
-0.8058292865753174,
-0.3258993923664093,
-0.10570507496595383,
-0.010522100143134594,
0.4398730993270874,
0.818394124507904,
-0.006967469118535519,
0.6384081244468689,
-0.6360671520233154,
-0.5670915842056274,
-0.3188517987728119,
0.35659754276275635,
0.01837022602558136,
0.2582068145275116,
0.46000760793685913,
-0.50411456823349,
-0.36074936389923096,
-0.05886754393577576,
-0.4471081495285034,
-0.18824559450149536,
-0.2840834856033325,
-0.026425931602716446,
0.2268925905227661,
0.7285767197608948,
-0.4883248209953308,
0.4328967332839966,
0.3819400370121002,
-0.3425499498844147,
0.7204146385192871,
-0.7128472328186035,
0.2567918300628662,
-0.9182734489440918,
0.530316948890686,
-0.007415677420794964,
-0.43372222781181335,
-0.5368621945381165,
0.0460001602768898,
0.21803796291351318,
-0.12868282198905945,
-0.18382732570171356,
0.5998194813728333,
-0.6288895606994629,
0.024107379838824272,
-0.4333963692188263,
0.3221680223941803,
0.17026767134666443,
-0.28723761439323425,
0.0024483795277774334,
0.7381113767623901,
0.20141065120697021,
-0.4075717031955719,
0.13347788155078888,
0.33649125695228577,
-0.375876784324646,
0.24624383449554443,
-0.7378581166267395,
-0.09856762737035751,
-0.1565033495426178,
0.10596715658903122,
-0.8974538445472717,
-0.5200801491737366,
-0.430528849363327,
-0.4415472745895386,
0.6831159591674805,
0.018699849024415016,
-0.5456052422523499,
-0.3167016804218292,
-0.2800508141517639,
-0.16731882095336914,
0.623417317867279,
0.04995294287800789,
0.417666494846344,
0.45173144340515137,
-0.5270853042602539,
-0.31180205941200256,
-0.6579667925834656,
0.4437057673931122,
-0.004310411401093006,
-0.38018617033958435,
0.13344693183898926,
0.07988861948251724,
-0.35423552989959717,
-0.12703531980514526,
0.24244461953639984,
-0.07480031251907349,
-0.061656564474105835,
0.008277147077023983,
0.12949921190738678,
-0.3027985692024231,
0.21907861530780792,
-0.11265499889850616,
0.05339640751481056,
0.02626330591738224,
0.29359468817710876,
0.36451977491378784,
0.3773082494735718,
-0.2826104164123535,
0.2507891058921814,
0.6665353775024414,
0.5147932767868042,
-0.015624357387423515,
0.6663060784339905,
0.05229118838906288,
-0.2812090218067169,
-0.3894698917865753,
-0.8194357752799988,
-0.16681279242038727,
-0.4037570655345917,
0.2674485743045807,
0.05720798298716545,
-0.6982985734939575,
0.33491483330726624,
-0.1956247091293335,
0.1307898610830307,
0.38362255692481995,
0.7560633420944214,
-0.19806602597236633,
0.5975559949874878,
0.635315477848053,
0.4316328465938568,
0.18515831232070923,
-0.22828078269958496,
0.23601192235946655,
-0.8604487180709839,
-0.0722292810678482,
-0.6947601437568665,
-0.025271518155932426,
-0.30515822768211365,
-0.8176637887954712,
0.7284597158432007,
0.07547151297330856,
0.04370174556970596,
0.15866462886333466,
-0.20013640820980072,
0.26310715079307556,
0.4768276512622833,
0.17698368430137634,
0.5304981470108032,
-0.12915031611919403,
0.02452770434319973,
-0.18149970471858978,
-0.8235365748405457,
-0.928362250328064,
1.5360476970672607,
0.36323902010917664,
0.9203311204910278,
0.021051106974482536,
0.6440695524215698,
0.17503413558006287,
0.9634339809417725,
-0.598924458026886,
0.41073077917099,
-0.3651353120803833,
-0.6375853419303894,
-0.21054328978061676,
-0.2884395718574524,
-1.0548115968704224,
-0.04487927258014679,
-0.47655189037323,
-0.28759756684303284,
-0.030297134071588516,
-0.030449537560343742,
-0.6156922578811646,
-0.07375188916921616,
-0.4831406772136688,
0.5170588493347168,
-0.20931094884872437,
-0.3195814788341522,
-0.2008550614118576,
-0.586519718170166,
0.44668182730674744,
-0.43696388602256775,
0.1340211182832718,
0.16888783872127533,
-0.16443540155887604,
0.7924392819404602,
-0.5057351589202881,
0.6489041447639465,
0.31155067682266235,
-0.13595795631408691,
0.2871965169906616,
0.16835249960422516,
0.5742766261100769,
0.15327322483062744,
-0.07393799722194672,
-0.28175416588783264,
0.05142442137002945,
-0.26759976148605347,
-0.339743047952652,
0.6252384185791016,
-0.4256986379623413,
-0.589266300201416,
-0.505409300327301,
-0.7601504921913147,
-0.3405560851097107,
0.31023693084716797,
0.1785886138677597,
0.9408624172210693,
-0.41094470024108887,
0.3493064045906067,
0.6178273558616638,
-0.6056053042411804,
0.05806587636470795,
0.7651382684707642,
-0.1873352974653244,
-0.5565456748008728,
0.6260471940040588,
0.2265160083770752,
0.7030085325241089,
0.1745581030845642,
0.27178919315338135,
-0.20104514062404633,
-1.0231828689575195,
-0.1883447915315628,
0.6592400670051575,
-0.7257512807846069,
-0.2182646095752716,
-0.755292534828186,
-0.27282848954200745,
-0.956824779510498,
-0.325652152299881,
-0.3937854468822479,
-0.5010106563568115,
-0.08544589579105377,
0.3585139811038971,
0.25365203619003296,
0.911101758480072,
-0.09159737825393677,
0.32667988538742065,
-1.0555413961410522,
0.43986523151397705,
0.053396545350551605,
0.3444331884384155,
-0.15409502387046814,
-0.6551886200904846,
-0.42593294382095337,
-0.1716957539319992,
-0.44757768511772156,
-0.7040190696716309,
0.4517553746700287,
0.041087839752435684,
0.5161131620407104,
0.26403480768203735,
-0.08026488125324249,
0.509723424911499,
-0.6658942103385925,
0.7332772612571716,
0.25037306547164917,
-0.5831798911094666,
0.5496459603309631,
-0.6255844235420227,
-0.13818661868572235,
0.6219613552093506,
0.30910825729370117,
-0.41367655992507935,
-0.6907090544700623,
-0.6503517031669617,
-0.8208872079849243,
0.4197632372379303,
0.39502522349357605,
0.023694036528468132,
0.013911967165768147,
0.2951350808143616,
0.17385217547416687,
0.38016653060913086,
-0.3732733726501465,
-0.041389916092157364,
0.3438473343849182,
0.03622761368751526,
-0.32343220710754395,
-0.6223610043525696,
-0.5264956951141357,
0.12856559455394745,
0.6313186883926392,
-0.048598531633615494,
-0.08197317272424698,
0.6145057678222656,
-0.0018854544032365084,
-0.22641737759113312,
0.1565277874469757,
0.6667834520339966,
1.2219327688217163,
-0.2501232624053955,
-0.10764245688915253,
-0.09849951416254044,
-0.6905896067619324,
-0.1149248331785202,
0.05729033797979355,
-0.03240808844566345,
0.13172811269760132,
0.7400597929954529,
0.40575504302978516,
0.1181049570441246,
-1.0905890464782715,
0.6584498286247253,
-0.19505161046981812,
-0.274111807346344,
-0.15202629566192627,
0.06624161452054977,
0.29395410418510437,
0.03298962861299515,
0.0835522711277008,
-0.17235037684440613,
0.31400567293167114,
-0.6208211183547974,
0.20172123610973358,
0.3725481629371643,
-0.02790660969913006,
0.24842095375061035,
0.5615997910499573,
0.26200783252716064,
-0.2388308346271515,
0.5222007036209106,
0.05862940102815628,
-0.06397701799869537,
0.5627427101135254,
0.695614755153656,
0.6305349469184875,
0.09585626423358917,
0.29272446036338806,
0.36537855863571167,
0.2973904311656952,
-0.3548251688480377,
0.09542107582092285,
0.42375537753105164,
-0.4235897362232208,
-0.5563510060310364,
-0.7953495383262634,
-0.6457451581954956,
0.29311662912368774,
-0.36631783843040466,
0.4065842032432556,
-0.17781388759613037,
-0.23521889746189117,
0.24182510375976562,
-0.03352426737546921,
-0.4189043641090393,
0.19020511209964752,
0.01014107558876276,
1.1499578952789307,
-0.6725412011146545,
0.5658707618713379,
0.5723177194595337,
-0.4864930212497711,
-0.9127931594848633,
-0.40009304881095886,
-0.3311837613582611,
-0.5898979306221008,
0.6623844504356384,
-0.34190601110458374,
0.25270599126815796,
-0.3859615921974182,
-0.4228280782699585,
-0.8204788565635681,
1.0515048503875732,
0.14132018387317657,
-0.7113898992538452,
-0.08833647519350052,
0.37274986505508423,
0.7806060910224915,
-0.359857976436615,
0.1879042237997055,
0.5378014445304871,
0.23256917297840118,
0.30102774500846863,
-1.1000100374221802,
-0.12630461156368256,
-0.1505260169506073,
0.024524973705410957,
0.043110523372888565,
-0.302068829536438,
0.9657302498817444,
-0.5608590841293335,
-0.03983225300908089,
0.5370286107063293,
0.39943546056747437,
0.47781437635421753,
0.4752410054206848,
0.1393767148256302,
0.4679953455924988,
0.6020517945289612,
-0.051996201276779175,
1.3610589504241943,
-0.1691618412733078,
0.3141036331653595,
1.0183165073394775,
-0.6504291892051697,
0.601188063621521,
0.49177825450897217,
-0.10190071910619736,
0.03497431427240372,
0.12848366796970367,
0.2382918745279312,
0.38896146416664124,
0.5796451568603516,
-0.16282016038894653,
-0.1475067436695099,
-0.07645286619663239,
-0.3944726884365082,
0.028361434116959572,
0.41516074538230896,
-0.7831786870956421,
-0.3449487090110779,
0.08980539441108704,
0.16276195645332336,
0.25600188970565796,
-0.09313417971134186,
0.7626758217811584,
0.3575173616409302,
-0.7732371687889099,
0.37917348742485046,
0.05564183369278908,
0.13816167414188385,
-0.8759093284606934,
-0.2515186071395874,
-0.2327922135591507,
0.4221040904521942,
-0.09182364493608475,
-0.7228432893753052,
0.27034762501716614,
0.20921547710895538,
0.05112417787313461,
-0.11814554035663605,
0.9161959886550903,
-0.3387851417064667,
-0.7105911374092102,
0.00028725905576720834,
0.4460883140563965,
0.29958799481391907,
0.22307270765304565,
-0.3832933008670807,
0.15745767951011658,
-0.4802872836589813,
-0.4530505836009979,
0.49143218994140625,
0.6377027630805969,
0.2182239592075348,
0.48479458689689636,
0.6886540651321411,
0.9362618923187256,
-0.17492251098155975,
0.23730657994747162,
0.8968914151191711,
-0.5877802968025208,
-0.23254765570163727,
-0.4991505742073059,
0.35261809825897217,
-0.32254964113235474,
-0.5848711729049683,
0.8298452496528625,
0.8474457859992981,
0.33194029331207275,
-0.15334947407245636,
0.7528619766235352,
-0.049448855221271515,
0.6127028465270996,
-0.5040348768234253,
0.9559187889099121,
-0.5689535140991211,
0.05785379558801651,
-0.39636290073394775,
-0.5791673064231873,
-0.4487694799900055,
0.37273937463760376,
-0.09107198566198349,
-0.03891706466674805,
0.8090124726295471,
0.7787264585494995,
0.07620241492986679,
-0.011422345414757729,
0.5022848844528198,
0.482412189245224,
0.6298792958259583,
0.5170551538467407,
0.6609216332435608,
-0.6029741168022156,
0.21297429502010345,
-0.1161559522151947,
-0.4519288241863251,
-0.22718338668346405,
-1.1327319145202637,
-0.7430365085601807,
-0.36583462357521057,
-0.10222963988780975,
-0.920579195022583,
0.19211328029632568,
0.7126593589782715,
0.42323535680770874,
-0.5513020753860474,
-0.4446389973163605,
0.09714597463607788,
-0.3986739218235016,
0.23614688217639923,
-0.11959290504455566,
0.34854602813720703,
-0.6946002840995789,
-0.47977718710899353,
0.0871853455901146,
0.4038349688053131,
-0.030386880040168762,
-0.4042503535747528,
-0.1314726024866104,
-0.17189815640449524,
0.3472459614276886,
0.7564648389816284,
-0.09118246287107468,
-0.21834956109523773,
-0.005531282164156437,
-0.034119948744773865,
-0.5381863713264465,
-0.14393943548202515,
1.1810396909713745,
-0.3964316248893738,
0.4644624888896942,
0.5384732484817505,
0.5688400864601135,
0.5517110228538513,
-0.20316079258918762,
0.76549232006073,
-0.1760292798280716,
-0.08807164430618286,
0.737515389919281,
0.5230302810668945,
0.3925873637199402,
-0.18197059631347656,
0.4852721095085144,
0.17590312659740448,
-1.0300350189208984,
-0.9775476455688477,
-0.2551959753036499,
-0.9028652906417847,
-0.2758776843547821,
1.4272785186767578,
-0.07074271887540817,
-0.2552456557750702,
-0.12200623750686646,
-0.41385555267333984,
0.15961000323295593,
-0.044002316892147064,
0.8995433449745178,
0.8415089845657349,
0.0004626477893907577,
0.5409565567970276,
-0.868539571762085,
0.6051824688911438,
0.2589570879936218,
-0.8692026734352112,
0.30846887826919556,
0.6100970506668091,
0.33576375246047974,
0.18449586629867554,
1.2796257734298706,
-0.49830299615859985,
0.28133344650268555,
0.1454778015613556,
-0.06552880257368088,
0.2564440965652466,
-0.14514048397541046,
0.10105471312999725,
0.034894153475761414,
0.34983396530151367,
0.45257705450057983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16389v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16389v1
|
MoZIP: A Multilingual Benchmark to Evaluate Large Language Models in Intellectual Property
| 2024-02-26T08:27:50 | 2024-02-26T08:27:50 |
Shiwen Ni, Minghuan Tan, Yuelin Bai, Fuqiang Niu, Min Yang, Bowen Zhang, Ruifeng Xu, Xiaojun Chen, Chengming Li, Xiping Hu, Ye Li, Jianping Fan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance in
various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, there is limited
understanding of how well LLMs perform in specific domains (e.g, the
intellectual property (IP) domain). In this paper, we contribute a new
benchmark, the first Multilingual-oriented quiZ on Intellectual Property
(MoZIP), for the evaluation of LLMs in the IP domain. The MoZIP benchmark
includes three challenging tasks: IP multiple-choice quiz (IPQuiz), IP question
answering (IPQA), and patent matching (PatentMatch). In addition, we also
develop a new IP-oriented multilingual large language model (called MoZi),
which is a BLOOMZ-based model that has been supervised fine-tuned with
multilingual IP-related text data. We evaluate our proposed MoZi model and four
well-known LLMs (i.e., BLOOMZ, BELLE, ChatGLM and ChatGPT) on the MoZIP
benchmark. Experimental results demonstrate that MoZi outperforms BLOOMZ, BELLE
and ChatGLM by a noticeable margin, while it had lower scores compared with
ChatGPT. Notably, the performance of current LLMs on the MoZIP benchmark has
much room for improvement, and even the most powerful ChatGPT does not reach
the passing level. Our source code, data, and models are available at
\url{https://github.com/AI-for-Science/MoZi}.
|
[
-0.35173699259757996,
-0.5584686994552612,
0.21610389649868011,
0.5498248934745789,
-0.06530426442623138,
0.15762293338775635,
-0.36522480845451355,
-0.6284629702568054,
0.03189240023493767,
0.4552597999572754,
-0.36335575580596924,
-0.5760675668716431,
-0.6307054758071899,
0.06243526190519333,
-0.19464021921157837,
0.7784700393676758,
-0.06936587393283844,
0.1731112003326416,
-0.46321067214012146,
-0.23498989641666412,
-0.027444584295153618,
-0.7514294981956482,
-0.4514891505241394,
-0.6191554665565491,
0.3092687129974365,
0.1393127143383026,
0.39165574312210083,
0.24615919589996338,
0.7676180005073547,
0.1930222362279892,
-0.27048274874687195,
0.17200762033462524,
-0.2653290927410126,
0.1043260395526886,
-0.1767299920320511,
-0.4542219340801239,
-0.3880811333656311,
0.06888768821954727,
0.5494860410690308,
0.5270376205444336,
-0.06307973712682724,
0.35527291893959045,
-0.01945577934384346,
0.7200016975402832,
-0.7744781374931335,
0.3222402334213257,
-0.6954916715621948,
0.11238985508680344,
-0.38152551651000977,
-0.1685316413640976,
-0.5116739273071289,
-0.0398857519030571,
0.11613556742668152,
-0.19882668554782867,
0.12005303055047989,
0.22104808688163757,
0.8418197631835938,
-0.06779373437166214,
-0.44200557470321655,
0.004922474734485149,
-0.38662928342819214,
0.6581681966781616,
-0.7403236627578735,
0.28769633173942566,
0.17401979863643646,
0.15898700058460236,
-0.2051827311515808,
-0.682037889957428,
-0.7756751775741577,
-0.5587906241416931,
0.41863879561424255,
0.1131163164973259,
-0.22316059470176697,
-0.23044125735759735,
0.2608215808868408,
0.5049417614936829,
-0.6021342277526855,
0.13968321681022644,
-0.18696381151676178,
-0.2606133222579956,
0.589859127998352,
-0.051332518458366394,
0.41780006885528564,
0.02100825309753418,
-0.7134604454040527,
-0.09141001850366592,
-1.078202724456787,
0.0804075375199318,
0.5082314014434814,
0.3177507519721985,
-0.05242051184177399,
0.7220761775970459,
-0.3321443796157837,
0.5029249787330627,
-0.4493115544319153,
-0.16564705967903137,
0.5650045871734619,
-0.14139989018440247,
0.09434830397367477,
-0.3608890175819397,
0.933135449886322,
0.33260247111320496,
0.4537392556667328,
-0.19193994998931885,
-0.10150939226150513,
-0.4125584661960602,
-0.14049115777015686,
-0.8752555251121521,
-0.2650401294231415,
0.09501510113477707,
-0.30065205693244934,
0.08322921395301819,
-0.1289324164390564,
-0.7371537685394287,
-0.48621058464050293,
0.005176158621907234,
0.5146358609199524,
-0.6412048935890198,
-0.24856087565422058,
0.18999458849430084,
-0.17850416898727417,
0.29593268036842346,
0.21417903900146484,
-0.870069682598114,
0.19671590626239777,
0.8301680088043213,
1.102332592010498,
-0.5034927725791931,
-0.7886119484901428,
-0.434221088886261,
0.10769850015640259,
0.006737316492944956,
1.006083607673645,
-0.4476941227912903,
-0.22170035541057587,
0.06449129432439804,
-0.15724986791610718,
-0.22293588519096375,
-0.7783679962158203,
0.4587121605873108,
-0.7313074469566345,
0.02904113382101059,
-0.04761359840631485,
-0.5520776510238647,
-0.1290653496980667,
0.7131040692329407,
-0.7830911874771118,
0.751675009727478,
-0.07095682621002197,
-0.7135594487190247,
0.29559290409088135,
-0.8517017364501953,
-0.6043616533279419,
0.20571663975715637,
0.012093952856957912,
-0.21849828958511353,
-0.21605491638183594,
0.25612592697143555,
0.2698333263397217,
-0.6915199756622314,
0.16614766418933868,
-0.48411425948143005,
-0.13616493344306946,
0.3214629292488098,
-0.5741838812828064,
1.0277125835418701,
-0.032948173582553864,
-0.2508024275302887,
-0.1189948320388794,
-0.6931778788566589,
0.27931511402130127,
0.11319111287593842,
-0.4492269456386566,
-0.02354198694229126,
0.12090165913105011,
-0.06399425119161606,
0.31072914600372314,
0.45681238174438477,
-0.5609634518623352,
0.44726669788360596,
-0.19814567267894745,
0.5656260251998901,
0.6243704557418823,
-0.14546877145767212,
0.040102988481521606,
-0.43130022287368774,
0.7050343751907349,
-0.1360466033220291,
-0.01889749802649021,
-0.3396168649196625,
-0.6712049245834351,
-0.7655044198036194,
-0.37395328283309937,
0.614303469657898,
0.6899316906929016,
-0.6923443078994751,
0.04140637442469597,
-0.5993965268135071,
-0.5424663424491882,
-0.3467005491256714,
0.17731106281280518,
0.3521554470062256,
0.1389787346124649,
0.26120734214782715,
-0.287782222032547,
0.025146886706352234,
-1.0798518657684326,
-0.33957839012145996,
-0.3208366334438324,
-0.09733536839485168,
0.4422965943813324,
0.7744176983833313,
-0.06599857658147812,
0.5672138929367065,
-0.3634882867336273,
-0.4270791709423065,
-0.24798494577407837,
0.5459337830543518,
0.14839929342269897,
0.14938686788082123,
0.6629440784454346,
-0.837754487991333,
-0.6861388087272644,
0.14252705872058868,
-0.415872722864151,
-0.3008054196834564,
0.2852846384048462,
0.04866911843419075,
0.06756255030632019,
0.1899983286857605,
-0.6639412641525269,
0.045961085706949234,
0.766767144203186,
-0.10401638597249985,
0.8731319308280945,
-0.05949379503726959,
0.41454362869262695,
-0.8884360790252686,
0.2342393398284912,
-0.20299309492111206,
-0.08218146860599518,
-0.3938021957874298,
0.5082319378852844,
0.1957360804080963,
-0.32205939292907715,
-0.8225314021110535,
0.7324613928794861,
-0.4254514276981354,
0.04721027612686157,
-0.16306456923484802,
0.10317457467317581,
0.07719363272190094,
0.5473386645317078,
-0.145320862531662,
1.3491861820220947,
0.5683687925338745,
-0.4753555953502655,
0.6642544865608215,
0.09584971517324448,
-0.7500947713851929,
0.2956239879131317,
-0.602722704410553,
0.17808574438095093,
0.3012166917324066,
-0.09163044393062592,
-0.7104800939559937,
-0.020779957994818687,
-0.08037103712558746,
-0.40910401940345764,
0.165781632065773,
-0.3323293626308441,
-0.9130614995956421,
-0.2899802625179291,
-0.30212005972862244,
0.27666714787483215,
0.30997559428215027,
-0.6865649223327637,
0.5597754716873169,
0.487786203622818,
-0.37025579810142517,
-0.6950367093086243,
-0.7104945778846741,
0.32097309827804565,
-0.22779183089733124,
-1.0186278820037842,
0.7180479168891907,
-0.20292581617832184,
-0.20293286442756653,
-0.21055354177951813,
0.23179107904434204,
-0.3961262106895447,
0.14915525913238525,
0.11877638101577759,
0.06806710362434387,
-0.3550436794757843,
0.18145230412483215,
-0.32726413011550903,
-0.012113356962800026,
0.11600138247013092,
-0.12348726391792297,
0.8603761196136475,
-0.33969128131866455,
-0.5539425611495972,
-0.18594126403331757,
0.3858954906463623,
0.7824323773384094,
-0.5064829587936401,
0.8187316656112671,
0.2184341847896576,
-0.2271803766489029,
-0.37646231055259705,
-0.5326752066612244,
0.24813991785049438,
-0.41981571912765503,
0.29747337102890015,
-0.5650376081466675,
-0.8971459865570068,
0.6072400212287903,
-0.3461708724498749,
-0.01244112104177475,
0.5326305031776428,
0.7247681617736816,
0.15219374001026154,
0.875212550163269,
0.8633955121040344,
-0.4326631426811218,
0.3211159110069275,
-0.13777562975883484,
0.515478253364563,
-0.7089880108833313,
-0.22184346616268158,
-0.6144879460334778,
-0.18259087204933167,
-0.3562438488006592,
-0.4811885356903076,
0.3471759557723999,
0.1793903410434723,
-0.012539371848106384,
0.43001219630241394,
0.05721983686089516,
0.5394889116287231,
0.8095784783363342,
-0.11210859566926956,
0.521575391292572,
0.016962852329015732,
-0.2579544186592102,
-0.04693493992090225,
-0.5514957904815674,
-0.6776787638664246,
1.083597183227539,
0.10175158828496933,
0.6466072201728821,
0.38056862354278564,
0.3376767337322235,
0.4967595338821411,
0.3419765532016754,
-0.7259371280670166,
0.587018609046936,
-0.17074786126613617,
-0.6314971446990967,
-0.15419676899909973,
-0.3424701690673828,
-0.701431155204773,
0.30158862471580505,
-0.15337763726711273,
-1.0176538228988647,
-0.11958617717027664,
0.04075995087623596,
-0.14203545451164246,
0.39493367075920105,
-0.7438369393348694,
0.9356860518455505,
-0.49642130732536316,
-0.46842285990715027,
-0.2596355974674225,
-0.2199416607618332,
0.4523356258869171,
-0.16860699653625488,
-0.018423087894916534,
-0.5270812511444092,
0.07163899391889572,
0.5638327598571777,
-0.18026258051395416,
0.3585115075111389,
0.16495540738105774,
-0.09082997590303421,
0.21623757481575012,
-0.02388019487261772,
0.36620160937309265,
-0.0014593706000596285,
-0.5075856447219849,
0.4477514922618866,
0.018151555210351944,
-0.23613645136356354,
-0.4560590088367462,
0.7043121457099915,
-0.5210655927658081,
-0.8012161254882812,
-0.5607824325561523,
-0.5373950004577637,
-0.362350195646286,
0.2873150706291199,
0.28618529438972473,
0.08842092007398605,
-0.3175865113735199,
0.35031768679618835,
0.38526859879493713,
-0.3760617673397064,
0.25640997290611267,
0.8890309929847717,
-0.23401181399822235,
-0.058093540370464325,
0.927270233631134,
0.05661017447710037,
0.3002147078514099,
0.6347254514694214,
0.11597901582717896,
-0.17843696475028992,
-0.7728930115699768,
-0.49501344561576843,
0.02193734049797058,
-0.6858025789260864,
-0.2844511568546295,
-0.6804987192153931,
-0.4614374041557312,
-0.49879705905914307,
0.3382522165775299,
-0.24215708673000336,
-0.31619390845298767,
0.11104132980108261,
0.24617309868335724,
0.16271966695785522,
0.20763519406318665,
0.07439462840557098,
0.05853036791086197,
-0.8073771595954895,
0.3176470696926117,
0.3620520234107971,
0.5101351141929626,
-0.22190473973751068,
-0.49942559003829956,
-0.17612740397453308,
0.14833195507526398,
-0.5433979630470276,
-0.6467357873916626,
0.40499022603034973,
0.46938127279281616,
0.6010570526123047,
0.3381180763244629,
0.1117233857512474,
0.515271008014679,
-0.8746200203895569,
1.040313959121704,
0.0598425567150116,
-1.082445740699768,
0.3728492856025696,
-0.29469034075737,
0.09447264671325684,
0.5109956860542297,
0.25765153765678406,
-0.5587322115898132,
-0.2581029236316681,
-0.3846367597579956,
-0.9118198752403259,
0.47860556840896606,
0.14699497818946838,
0.4497539699077606,
0.019598519429564476,
0.03611055761575699,
0.09201072156429291,
0.4244609773159027,
-1.123996615409851,
-0.20916679501533508,
0.30356159806251526,
0.24004748463630676,
0.15380756556987762,
-0.33615922927856445,
-0.1498366892337799,
0.08477719873189926,
0.8743323683738708,
-0.13897758722305298,
0.2874377369880676,
-0.22103704512119293,
-0.3050847053527832,
0.24420228600502014,
0.48311811685562134,
0.5543389916419983,
0.7365237474441528,
-0.08509001135826111,
0.17577533423900604,
0.0916036069393158,
-0.3985816240310669,
0.1326702982187271,
0.22163593769073486,
-0.2633105516433716,
-0.1523575484752655,
0.5627520680427551,
0.571657657623291,
-0.2623911201953888,
-1.2330811023712158,
0.8538952469825745,
0.017838051542639732,
-0.1000477746129036,
-0.26043692231178284,
0.3318951427936554,
0.07058877497911453,
0.423979789018631,
0.43334949016571045,
-0.11710304021835327,
0.14120063185691833,
-0.5704831480979919,
0.15497371554374695,
0.6508580446243286,
0.055282268673181534,
-0.17324092984199524,
0.6096704602241516,
0.20025292038917542,
-0.5144476294517517,
0.6026825308799744,
-0.3427177965641022,
-0.8085643649101257,
0.7041990756988525,
0.5727381706237793,
0.7954865097999573,
0.05438408628106117,
0.20066693425178528,
0.16829930245876312,
0.45065975189208984,
-0.12670519948005676,
0.2250666469335556,
0.032730814069509506,
-0.8863558173179626,
-0.3764178156852722,
-0.41156771779060364,
-0.7118111252784729,
0.3732948303222656,
-0.42958980798721313,
0.3684600591659546,
-0.24956877529621124,
-0.16954405605793,
0.0920967236161232,
0.07576893270015717,
-0.545127272605896,
-0.05044679716229439,
0.1709156334400177,
1.1561589241027832,
-0.6468989253044128,
0.9414730668067932,
0.5015341639518738,
-0.17483548820018768,
-0.2515380382537842,
0.2737019658088684,
-0.13330873847007751,
-0.8735755681991577,
0.7146135568618774,
0.42652666568756104,
-0.26261457800865173,
-0.13221637904644012,
-0.6231082677841187,
-0.8042270541191101,
0.8761237263679504,
0.6423096656799316,
-0.36401617527008057,
0.36780425906181335,
0.34239447116851807,
0.5388572216033936,
-0.29734623432159424,
-0.012293915264308453,
0.35190191864967346,
0.3190262019634247,
-0.17116820812225342,
-0.866381049156189,
-0.5040834546089172,
-0.7635676860809326,
-0.28597500920295715,
0.1489604264497757,
-0.9374956488609314,
0.9756729602813721,
-0.23857271671295166,
-0.2939775288105011,
0.3071369230747223,
0.6607365012168884,
0.3010976314544678,
0.22195559740066528,
0.3634234666824341,
0.6006910800933838,
0.6432115435600281,
-0.34341228008270264,
1.1233233213424683,
-0.7223530411720276,
0.40532469749450684,
1.2188917398452759,
-0.7260227799415588,
1.2191107273101807,
0.4746706783771515,
-0.42114779353141785,
0.379058837890625,
0.33665403723716736,
-0.31298956274986267,
0.4596203565597534,
0.43823981285095215,
-0.48325467109680176,
-0.10078321397304535,
-0.2706535756587982,
-0.40420377254486084,
0.4503028690814972,
0.12447140365839005,
-0.1668798327445984,
-0.04553263261914253,
0.0565364733338356,
-0.11624903231859207,
-0.056492120027542114,
0.04337327927350998,
0.38762378692626953,
-0.10429996252059937,
-0.6989110112190247,
0.22956867516040802,
0.5225881934165955,
0.6474546194076538,
-0.7610354423522949,
0.10399474203586578,
-0.28265640139579773,
0.16164009273052216,
0.30141767859458923,
-0.8975901007652283,
0.026077179238200188,
0.2119775414466858,
-0.2888544797897339,
-0.2596210539340973,
0.3471091091632843,
-0.4192604422569275,
-0.512525737285614,
0.4474821090698242,
0.43799811601638794,
0.14714105427265167,
-0.28158000111579895,
-0.734241783618927,
-0.13584478199481964,
-0.12385085225105286,
-0.38282540440559387,
0.3424704074859619,
0.48883989453315735,
-0.02179146558046341,
1.176830530166626,
0.6089012026786804,
0.2333063930273056,
0.2113042026758194,
0.2124621570110321,
0.6554755568504333,
-0.5374993681907654,
-0.33952438831329346,
-0.869110643863678,
0.21077768504619598,
-0.11810564994812012,
-0.574493408203125,
0.7786778807640076,
0.7071911096572876,
0.8029980659484863,
-0.038732584565877914,
0.8071141242980957,
-0.05104013904929161,
0.36930009722709656,
-0.7212368249893188,
0.6742763519287109,
-0.6600871086120605,
0.2613251209259033,
-0.10409820824861526,
-0.9068991541862488,
-0.3483911454677582,
0.4158856272697449,
-0.22055503726005554,
-0.034072425216436386,
0.6833317279815674,
0.7320302128791809,
-0.027435341849923134,
-0.0579332672059536,
0.31436887383461,
0.005805823486298323,
0.46863922476768494,
0.6740276217460632,
0.8811919689178467,
-0.40665775537490845,
0.4998193085193634,
-0.38663992285728455,
-0.029699992388486862,
-0.03859330713748932,
-1.187110424041748,
-0.8946479558944702,
-0.48327720165252686,
-0.4200301170349121,
-0.1118292436003685,
-0.07168528437614441,
0.804200291633606,
0.6328966021537781,
-0.8736980557441711,
-0.1569480299949646,
0.22073133289813995,
0.15288299322128296,
-0.3345917761325836,
-0.20464153587818146,
0.3050021827220917,
-0.09371870756149292,
-0.8991588950157166,
0.35068801045417786,
0.6697114109992981,
0.07444341480731964,
-0.29229530692100525,
0.11705522239208221,
-0.2789766490459442,
-0.04028572514653206,
0.636142373085022,
0.219776913523674,
-0.7414296269416809,
-0.04424291476607323,
0.07719486206769943,
-0.16420643031597137,
0.17060044407844543,
0.9401988983154297,
-0.38974034786224365,
0.4436253607273102,
0.5826218128204346,
0.740088701248169,
0.4551679790019989,
-0.1724628359079361,
0.685613214969635,
-0.5147899985313416,
0.27221032977104187,
0.3753822147846222,
0.6864745020866394,
0.35703620314598083,
-0.038156505674123764,
0.511655330657959,
0.11289941519498825,
-0.4197981059551239,
-0.6709375381469727,
0.25988826155662537,
-0.6909911632537842,
-0.18529164791107178,
1.2388066053390503,
-0.5321357250213623,
-0.026858223602175713,
0.1442393809556961,
0.01790456846356392,
-0.2115059643983841,
-0.09160041064023972,
1.0061577558517456,
1.1411478519439697,
0.11048248410224915,
-0.28820183873176575,
-0.6211713552474976,
0.02309555746614933,
0.3424265384674072,
-0.9956302046775818,
0.18903866410255432,
0.2781229615211487,
0.1538446694612503,
0.19087214767932892,
0.5451921224594116,
-0.1650238037109375,
0.214911550283432,
-0.1452714502811432,
0.28392356634140015,
-0.12098177522420883,
-0.5073181390762329,
-0.12657995522022247,
0.4673736095428467,
0.11413294821977615,
-0.10556279122829437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16382v1
|
Immunization against harmful fine-tuning attacks
| 2024-02-26T08:08:03 | 2024-02-26T08:08:03 |
Domenic Rosati, Jan Wehner, Kai Williams, Łukasz Bartoszcze, Jan Batzner, Hassan Sajjad, Frank Rudzicz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Approaches to aligning large language models (LLMs) with human values has
focused on correcting misalignment that emerges from pretraining. However, this
focus overlooks another source of misalignment: bad actors might purposely
fine-tune LLMs to achieve harmful goals. In this paper, we present an emerging
threat model that has arisen from alignment circumvention and fine-tuning
attacks. However, lacking in previous works is a clear presentation of the
conditions for effective defence. We propose a set of conditions for effective
defence against harmful fine-tuning in LLMs called "Immunization conditions,"
which help us understand how we would construct and measure future defences.
Using this formal framework for defence, we offer a synthesis of different
research directions that might be persued to prevent harmful fine-tuning
attacks and provide a demonstration of how to use these conditions
experimentally showing early results of using an adversarial loss to immunize
LLama2-7b-chat.
|
[
-0.22500017285346985,
-1.0504379272460938,
0.13193881511688232,
-0.306456059217453,
-0.1546960473060608,
0.14921113848686218,
-0.15897274017333984,
-0.66651850938797,
0.02231784164905548,
0.5117496252059937,
-0.4265289306640625,
-0.09016965329647064,
-0.872174859046936,
-0.1627907156944275,
-0.36599525809288025,
1.2557014226913452,
0.16649696230888367,
-0.08608841150999069,
0.24751874804496765,
0.10734635591506958,
-0.6002475619316101,
-0.7151833176612854,
-0.628125786781311,
-0.2834765315055847,
0.624011218547821,
0.4719280004501343,
0.8526843786239624,
0.4425186216831207,
0.7164803743362427,
0.2159571647644043,
-0.07239127159118652,
-0.005875248461961746,
-0.6320870518684387,
0.23632052540779114,
-0.39442771673202515,
-0.8846753239631653,
-0.3335334062576294,
0.30187976360321045,
0.47770896553993225,
0.44834378361701965,
-0.14988861978054047,
-0.17181970179080963,
0.11451274901628494,
0.38838592171669006,
-0.6846634745597839,
-0.608794093132019,
-1.3053678274154663,
-0.05165727064013481,
-0.6120657324790955,
-0.2357179969549179,
-0.3997024893760681,
-0.03597905859351158,
-0.19368533790111542,
-0.4890228807926178,
-0.28210946917533875,
0.18664653599262238,
1.1531062126159668,
0.4257739782333374,
-0.2724668085575104,
-0.1431933045387268,
-0.3235017657279968,
0.652609646320343,
-0.9741281867027283,
-0.24266181886196136,
0.6488601565361023,
0.2750995457172394,
-0.6764755249023438,
-0.13935039937496185,
-0.3519468605518341,
-0.14533856511116028,
0.2804604172706604,
0.022374829277396202,
-0.7247616648674011,
0.20815512537956238,
0.1610070914030075,
0.03402623534202576,
-0.3228404223918915,
0.6379989385604858,
-0.5401313900947571,
-0.2768746018409729,
0.5311347246170044,
0.3438775837421417,
0.5984327793121338,
0.07243692874908447,
-0.34721827507019043,
0.012821872718632221,
-1.1025731563568115,
0.18671287596225739,
0.7060002088546753,
0.5413855910301208,
-0.16676510870456696,
0.6604071855545044,
-0.1444813758134842,
0.6910505890846252,
0.444565087556839,
-0.25463077425956726,
-0.5384880900382996,
-0.36538955569267273,
-0.20367233455181122,
0.23918069899082184,
0.5402737855911255,
0.7405831813812256,
0.5800753831863403,
-0.2370425909757614,
-0.32282814383506775,
0.30666816234588623,
0.6005042791366577,
-0.9301058650016785,
0.022818399593234062,
0.1816631555557251,
-0.18191206455230713,
-0.7806829810142517,
-0.12219996005296707,
-0.3725372552871704,
-0.5099664330482483,
-0.14729517698287964,
0.4210202991962433,
-0.41754814982414246,
-0.15232667326927185,
0.30297335982322693,
0.20396754145622253,
0.15837031602859497,
-0.11603192239999771,
-0.9956708550453186,
0.20273426175117493,
0.8731184601783752,
0.5363113880157471,
-0.16554105281829834,
0.015612520277500153,
-0.6564260125160217,
0.46201637387275696,
-0.3899577558040619,
0.7398596405982971,
-0.4554922878742218,
-0.45462891459465027,
-0.17244291305541992,
-0.17784398794174194,
0.13695184886455536,
-0.6050923466682434,
0.5822610259056091,
-0.4621070325374603,
-0.0032809784170240164,
0.06654362380504608,
-0.42730146646499634,
-0.01428034994751215,
0.5989680886268616,
-0.18793770670890808,
0.36079972982406616,
-0.2416992038488388,
-0.7760100364685059,
0.20882950723171234,
-0.18738238513469696,
-0.6386289000511169,
-0.06370115280151367,
-0.009415783919394016,
-0.553387463092804,
0.040017515420913696,
-0.15219314396381378,
0.4149598479270935,
-0.4596613645553589,
0.41151484847068787,
-0.7468119263648987,
-0.1654072403907776,
0.20303085446357727,
-0.3628150224685669,
0.7632184624671936,
0.41652488708496094,
-0.17847777903079987,
0.36855795979499817,
-0.42530569434165955,
0.07188581675291061,
0.11916033178567886,
-0.2917539179325104,
-0.34352657198905945,
0.04057784378528595,
-0.5586566925048828,
0.24307575821876526,
0.20992964506149292,
-0.3530624508857727,
0.22597834467887878,
-0.9130558967590332,
0.6439051032066345,
0.7065631151199341,
0.11992058157920837,
0.4242129921913147,
-0.6377617120742798,
0.4877474308013916,
0.11213798820972443,
0.5447331666946411,
-0.027681425213813782,
-0.3543650209903717,
-0.6114283204078674,
-0.1604827642440796,
0.09241128712892532,
0.912100613117218,
-0.4161093235015869,
0.31904542446136475,
-0.030495647341012955,
-0.42819568514823914,
-0.5798758864402771,
0.09961576759815216,
0.5442097187042236,
0.19650009274482727,
0.10851381719112396,
-0.11058879643678665,
-0.5806828737258911,
-1.0190926790237427,
-0.6013274788856506,
-0.1511814296245575,
0.06729334592819214,
-0.2813258171081543,
0.24600906670093536,
-0.34090501070022583,
0.20005415380001068,
-0.07691028714179993,
-0.204568549990654,
0.02828947640955448,
-0.13887913525104523,
0.13962994515895844,
0.7870693802833557,
0.6517472267150879,
-0.42760589718818665,
-0.26344460248947144,
0.16866403818130493,
-0.368958055973053,
-0.1549190878868103,
-0.015320313163101673,
-0.2145032286643982,
-0.05050263553857803,
0.9831145405769348,
-0.5651524662971497,
0.54775470495224,
0.30076709389686584,
-0.21761676669120789,
0.4048192501068115,
0.2367137223482132,
0.11905936896800995,
-1.1381453275680542,
-0.18914806842803955,
-0.10566216707229614,
-0.2228442132472992,
-0.8249049186706543,
0.33578526973724365,
-0.11783009767532349,
-0.09085147827863693,
-0.5326251983642578,
0.4522964060306549,
0.1272691786289215,
0.6034590601921082,
-0.6028743982315063,
0.010044889524579048,
-0.04327281937003136,
0.031309064477682114,
-0.6802619099617004,
0.7395817637443542,
0.49459102749824524,
-0.9188897609710693,
0.0038454069290310144,
-0.08231021463871002,
-0.35824912786483765,
1.0268311500549316,
-0.8225102424621582,
-0.13967034220695496,
0.10589166730642319,
0.05597104877233505,
-0.618995189666748,
-0.30658701062202454,
0.5505412220954895,
-0.43616315722465515,
0.666791558265686,
-0.12224534898996353,
-0.33131253719329834,
-0.21546506881713867,
-0.2872749865055084,
0.5075646042823792,
0.3797405958175659,
-0.2509828805923462,
0.19920460879802704,
0.7345740795135498,
-0.17519569396972656,
-0.6372627019882202,
-0.6466241478919983,
0.41021400690078735,
-0.8387172818183899,
-0.7218726873397827,
0.6868717670440674,
-0.13712550699710846,
-0.5283122658729553,
-0.2724684476852417,
-0.0644339844584465,
0.16253787279129028,
0.68216872215271,
0.035576093941926956,
0.01640060357749462,
-0.11835626512765884,
-0.057210348546504974,
-0.12603047490119934,
-0.3361261188983917,
0.0956735759973526,
-0.31226420402526855,
0.2832830846309662,
0.09708213806152344,
-0.7826725840568542,
-0.38342735171318054,
0.48366209864616394,
0.5180776119232178,
-0.08918274194002151,
0.5983571410179138,
0.3976532220840454,
-0.5711548924446106,
0.15894494950771332,
-0.6032109260559082,
-0.47954061627388,
-0.459382563829422,
0.4882388710975647,
-0.2840525805950165,
-0.9247283935546875,
0.5555371046066284,
-0.021739883348345757,
0.05125439167022705,
0.3862249255180359,
0.6378443241119385,
-0.2953512966632843,
1.134003758430481,
0.5894253253936768,
-0.1509575992822647,
0.4815819263458252,
0.33801066875457764,
0.38583868741989136,
-0.669954240322113,
-0.19721831381320953,
-0.4918670058250427,
-0.22695709764957428,
-0.5296343564987183,
0.018998119980096817,
0.33363109827041626,
0.5025956034660339,
-0.6286426186561584,
0.3729097843170166,
-0.5365740656852722,
0.7695366740226746,
0.5698909759521484,
0.119356669485569,
-0.12556932866573334,
-0.40816783905029297,
-0.13472233712673187,
0.04883231595158577,
-0.7194353938102722,
-0.6477628350257874,
0.9184353351593018,
0.48590049147605896,
1.0174590349197388,
0.48499858379364014,
0.47168171405792236,
0.20581744611263275,
0.19496853649616241,
-0.6473445296287537,
0.28650492429733276,
-0.1451767235994339,
-0.6759506464004517,
-0.03902898728847504,
0.007745266426354647,
-1.243605136871338,
0.19161614775657654,
-0.36168619990348816,
-1.073684573173523,
-0.11177903413772583,
0.34740105271339417,
-0.5561866164207458,
0.34323060512542725,
-0.6484889984130859,
0.8272385001182556,
-0.5204439759254456,
-0.409732460975647,
-0.23640672862529755,
-0.8015847206115723,
0.5208145976066589,
-0.14321769773960114,
0.030145810917019844,
-0.49095338582992554,
0.3366537094116211,
0.44143664836883545,
-0.12704691290855408,
1.2509318590164185,
0.07587368041276932,
-0.3902360498905182,
0.2046060860157013,
0.17125284671783447,
0.4452929198741913,
0.04562803730368614,
0.016389667987823486,
0.060748595744371414,
0.15400324761867523,
-0.6131238341331482,
-0.050545789301395416,
0.6892613768577576,
-0.5639969706535339,
-1.3882359266281128,
-0.3037416934967041,
-0.5156267881393433,
-0.06385079771280289,
0.4323902130126953,
0.32913461327552795,
-0.06335943192243576,
-0.3983861207962036,
0.12798184156417847,
0.8934909701347351,
-0.32996273040771484,
0.19979247450828552,
0.7507340908050537,
0.04544764384627342,
-0.29062342643737793,
0.7480671405792236,
-0.09858562052249908,
0.7861118316650391,
0.2779098451137543,
0.09188603609800339,
0.07413148134946823,
-0.7248648405075073,
-0.019486574456095695,
-0.07056628167629242,
-0.48338067531585693,
-0.9067025780677795,
-0.12773707509040833,
-0.1368350237607956,
-0.44484588503837585,
-0.19818498194217682,
-0.16786813735961914,
-0.05968526378273964,
-0.23691752552986145,
0.04249829798936844,
0.09132800251245499,
0.6945079565048218,
-0.17350931465625763,
0.49840331077575684,
-0.48481062054634094,
0.12298040091991425,
0.08746462315320969,
0.19976361095905304,
-0.22843554615974426,
-0.749163806438446,
-0.35152512788772583,
0.48374229669570923,
-0.8080199956893921,
-0.6011460423469543,
0.11724220216274261,
0.08765257894992828,
0.7775583863258362,
0.5715932846069336,
0.1634412705898285,
0.570510983467102,
-0.6227250695228577,
0.27494895458221436,
0.2795036733150482,
-0.7369454503059387,
0.6304096579551697,
-0.4412042200565338,
0.43716543912887573,
0.4767303168773651,
-0.02082817070186138,
-0.4474332928657532,
-0.7453545331954956,
-0.42660483717918396,
-0.5721996426582336,
0.3279993534088135,
-0.01887720637023449,
0.18756228685379028,
-0.17362433671951294,
0.46752217411994934,
-0.1905592679977417,
-0.0993150994181633,
-0.6198220252990723,
0.19255582988262177,
-0.10909503698348999,
-0.22017572820186615,
0.08847878873348236,
-0.23835331201553345,
-0.7873626947402954,
-0.17350655794143677,
0.847592294216156,
0.01304842159152031,
-0.08154980093240738,
-0.09392703324556351,
-0.13571661710739136,
-0.35871922969818115,
0.3104713261127472,
0.941565215587616,
0.08933224529027939,
0.06732932478189468,
0.3192090690135956,
0.2212752252817154,
-0.21252821385860443,
0.415842741727829,
0.030344748869538307,
-0.07983728498220444,
-0.8394793272018433,
0.2760103940963745,
0.7357473969459534,
0.4216555058956146,
-0.5235772132873535,
0.6164497137069702,
0.1621106117963791,
0.07122772932052612,
0.009713311679661274,
0.31550735235214233,
0.07683154940605164,
0.23992647230625153,
-0.07484956085681915,
0.21827717125415802,
-0.13514502346515656,
-0.3925624191761017,
0.27893635630607605,
1.0929936170578003,
-0.41749000549316406,
-0.29181715846061707,
0.7634081840515137,
0.06574834883213043,
-0.2657601535320282,
0.24255436658859253,
-0.0778258666396141,
-0.465512216091156,
0.740346372127533,
0.7546356320381165,
0.5143755674362183,
-0.5056458115577698,
-0.3892936706542969,
0.16476763784885406,
0.8227012753486633,
0.24059408903121948,
-0.15711230039596558,
0.5027756094932556,
-0.7927746176719666,
-0.18194732069969177,
-0.2756540775299072,
-0.15462179481983185,
0.2677738666534424,
-0.6171219348907471,
0.4066568911075592,
-0.4580850303173065,
-0.2784721851348877,
0.3097345530986786,
-0.2661180794239044,
-0.4013898968696594,
-0.14397495985031128,
0.4612326920032501,
0.8467189073562622,
-0.6817686557769775,
0.8832399845123291,
0.3764176666736603,
-0.4673427641391754,
-0.38730311393737793,
0.18808810412883759,
0.25679048895835876,
-0.9283020496368408,
0.43819576501846313,
0.2875957787036896,
-0.3652333915233612,
-0.3093430697917938,
-0.7128837704658508,
-0.8686344027519226,
0.6864879727363586,
0.7643972039222717,
-0.5312851667404175,
0.19434410333633423,
0.15998391807079315,
0.27183178067207336,
-0.25765979290008545,
-0.37333181500434875,
0.6907855868339539,
0.43058353662490845,
-0.360461950302124,
-0.9061619639396667,
0.09004466980695724,
-0.27898427844047546,
-0.12599501013755798,
0.4052719175815582,
-0.650244414806366,
0.7085502743721008,
-0.3861076831817627,
-0.37471431493759155,
0.3015991747379303,
0.4810733497142792,
0.0028980837669223547,
0.045830320566892624,
0.13696782290935516,
0.7725650072097778,
0.5788940787315369,
-0.1925583779811859,
1.0493886470794678,
-0.5154685378074646,
-0.1915328949689865,
0.9529339075088501,
0.0052165621891617775,
0.5986645817756653,
0.4879288971424103,
-0.03200993314385414,
-0.026655681431293488,
0.8269327878952026,
0.14951451122760773,
0.7491728663444519,
0.6619961857795715,
-0.22972716391086578,
-0.2831073999404907,
-0.13427624106407166,
-0.46664947271347046,
0.5210543870925903,
0.7426209449768066,
0.12801815569400787,
-0.18188084661960602,
0.047686029225587845,
0.4150952994823456,
0.348692923784256,
-0.3169814348220825,
0.9469773173332214,
0.12345710396766663,
-0.8073775768280029,
0.9325538277626038,
0.1514555960893631,
0.9608311057090759,
-0.6760147213935852,
0.2603340446949005,
0.09203188866376877,
0.26134273409843445,
-0.09285400807857513,
-0.6784274578094482,
0.4229656457901001,
-0.290808767080307,
-0.2392370104789734,
0.2569306492805481,
0.735745370388031,
-0.4647999405860901,
-0.23861339688301086,
0.12110499292612076,
0.042476825416088104,
-0.19732913374900818,
0.18633396923542023,
-0.8260136246681213,
0.18800833821296692,
-0.08156327158212662,
0.1305028796195984,
0.7351909875869751,
0.4084970951080322,
-0.27203285694122314,
0.8080480098724365,
0.42067721486091614,
0.09424472600221634,
-0.01713215932250023,
-0.05482173338532448,
0.8132408261299133,
-0.3851860463619232,
-0.3241455852985382,
-1.2407500743865967,
0.2581614851951599,
-0.013975239358842373,
-0.30921614170074463,
0.5720987915992737,
0.21471434831619263,
0.675325334072113,
0.2963731288909912,
0.565459668636322,
0.32317689061164856,
0.33792436122894287,
-0.5522691011428833,
0.7894492745399475,
-0.43878814578056335,
0.2819787859916687,
-0.17727597057819366,
-0.4084157943725586,
-0.5921922326087952,
0.342332124710083,
-0.1219291165471077,
-0.2907329201698303,
0.3412870764732361,
0.9900915622711182,
-0.058572426438331604,
-0.2980635166168213,
0.44674772024154663,
0.30406078696250916,
0.5594110488891602,
0.6523972153663635,
0.9141619205474854,
-0.21892043948173523,
0.46419471502304077,
-0.1819727122783661,
-0.22240418195724487,
-0.3528497815132141,
-1.0792115926742554,
-1.0488722324371338,
-0.5656805634498596,
-0.16056816279888153,
-0.5300275683403015,
0.4386886656284332,
0.7272765636444092,
0.7131785750389099,
-1.0260437726974487,
-0.016325559467077255,
0.07002626359462738,
-0.0039457892999053,
0.13483557105064392,
-0.08350291848182678,
-0.15650036931037903,
-0.5091999769210815,
-0.33655112981796265,
0.340005487203598,
0.3148724138736725,
0.5535845160484314,
-0.28494128584861755,
0.0664607435464859,
-0.3086486756801605,
0.4180404543876648,
0.48881587386131287,
0.6030123829841614,
-1.1771464347839355,
-0.6069785356521606,
-0.5632609724998474,
-0.34756582975387573,
-0.062370944768190384,
0.42289701104164124,
-0.2957010865211487,
0.2508263885974884,
-0.04175681993365288,
0.8984335660934448,
-0.284650057554245,
-0.1925594061613083,
0.8993680477142334,
-0.6353593468666077,
0.4631129801273346,
0.2735117971897125,
0.3524944484233856,
0.3400599956512451,
-0.6005048155784607,
0.35267341136932373,
-0.21467596292495728,
-0.40400606393814087,
-0.9633471965789795,
0.7697904109954834,
-0.6460223197937012,
-0.29097819328308105,
1.0832808017730713,
0.040474794805049896,
-0.06612259894609451,
0.030125807970762253,
-0.38900646567344666,
0.29929640889167786,
-0.19124849140644073,
1.1786208152770996,
0.7061111927032471,
0.23450638353824615,
0.3986286222934723,
-0.4129500985145569,
0.6687560677528381,
0.608579695224762,
-0.9315929412841797,
-0.07005080580711365,
0.1276177614927292,
0.18811237812042236,
-0.11145227402448654,
0.16924723982810974,
-0.17523716390132904,
0.3338453769683838,
-0.22868482768535614,
-0.09128326177597046,
0.22224603593349457,
-0.13901254534721375,
-0.20715314149856567,
-0.11518681794404984,
0.3565482497215271,
-0.19627180695533752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16380v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16380v1
|
An Automated End-to-End Open-Source Software for High-Quality Text-to-Speech Dataset Generation
| 2024-02-26T07:58:33 | 2024-02-26T07:58:33 |
Ahmet Gunduz, Kamer Ali Yuksel, Kareem Darwish, Golara Javadi, Fabio Minazzi, Nicola Sobieski, Sebastien Bratieres
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Data availability is crucial for advancing artificial intelligence
applications, including voice-based technologies. As content creation,
particularly in social media, experiences increasing demand, translation and
text-to-speech (TTS) technologies have become essential tools. Notably, the
performance of these TTS technologies is highly dependent on the quality of the
training data, emphasizing the mutual dependence of data availability and
technological progress. This paper introduces an end-to-end tool to generate
high-quality datasets for text-to-speech (TTS) models to address this critical
need for high-quality data. The contributions of this work are manifold and
include: the integration of language-specific phoneme distribution into sample
selection, automation of the recording process, automated and human-in-the-loop
quality assurance of recordings, and processing of recordings to meet specified
formats. The proposed application aims to streamline the dataset creation
process for TTS models through these features, thereby facilitating
advancements in voice-based technologies.
|
[
-0.28493133187294006,
-0.6769307851791382,
0.1687845140695572,
0.12991705536842346,
-0.35778582096099854,
0.16889646649360657,
-0.34794411063194275,
-0.22457073628902435,
0.1339491903781891,
0.6486259698867798,
-0.5970390439033508,
-0.8407378196716309,
-0.39699476957321167,
0.043667688965797424,
-1.1128382682800293,
0.7799654603004456,
0.11014918982982635,
-0.2072366178035736,
-0.2575724720954895,
-0.11486323922872543,
-0.42208150029182434,
-0.39780041575431824,
-0.5103252530097961,
-0.0780518427491188,
0.022557811811566353,
0.6492301821708679,
0.995416522026062,
0.9149489998817444,
0.22798392176628113,
0.19081531465053558,
0.132035493850708,
0.1527043730020523,
-0.5044500827789307,
0.5266416668891907,
-0.29899391531944275,
-0.19293709099292755,
-0.5134884119033813,
0.029781106859445572,
0.6029526591300964,
0.4223378598690033,
-0.3215387761592865,
0.5258155465126038,
-0.024201642721891403,
0.4501737058162689,
-0.15268321335315704,
-0.34175926446914673,
-0.518534779548645,
-0.09973552078008652,
-0.37411490082740784,
-0.2593947947025299,
-0.39606374502182007,
-0.6665823459625244,
0.17254699766635895,
-0.7242968082427979,
0.04156740754842758,
-0.18716374039649963,
0.8241087794303894,
0.618233859539032,
-0.005385810509324074,
-0.27104610204696655,
-0.7809720039367676,
0.5418299436569214,
-0.7930430769920349,
0.6964040398597717,
0.4064943790435791,
0.5571489930152893,
-0.19299374520778656,
-0.718065619468689,
-0.5715972185134888,
0.04190150275826454,
0.3650215268135071,
0.1991552859544754,
0.11850986629724503,
-0.16543427109718323,
-0.21113866567611694,
0.3342430889606476,
-0.7708286046981812,
0.16506551206111908,
-0.2866831421852112,
-0.05344172939658165,
0.5048142671585083,
-0.14187438786029816,
0.37374621629714966,
-0.008094452321529388,
0.2068171203136444,
0.05637826770544052,
-0.5743788480758667,
-0.07658824324607849,
0.5078354477882385,
0.7119414210319519,
-0.31331443786621094,
0.9385331273078918,
-0.24034331738948822,
0.7404569983482361,
-0.3054172396659851,
-0.027757743373513222,
0.3241484463214874,
-0.33710232377052307,
-0.3606591820716858,
0.18243828415870667,
0.7518799901008606,
-0.013705955818295479,
0.28091517090797424,
-0.26548531651496887,
-0.27883049845695496,
-0.16670945286750793,
0.12408861517906189,
-0.4677368104457855,
0.3678537905216217,
0.6079279184341431,
-0.3365003764629364,
-0.3813537657260895,
0.07775674760341644,
-0.5748903155326843,
-0.13305887579917908,
-0.6605910658836365,
0.4606655538082123,
-0.361960232257843,
-0.466002494096756,
0.0402570515871048,
-0.09361935406923294,
-0.08543083816766739,
0.1453980654478073,
-0.5291303992271423,
0.23097704350948334,
0.43123361468315125,
1.0885943174362183,
-0.24195639789104462,
-0.16263441741466522,
-0.7958759665489197,
0.36156582832336426,
-0.5423504710197449,
0.5311383008956909,
-0.3967142105102539,
-0.4944932460784912,
0.048566658049821854,
-0.0451534129679203,
0.2766242027282715,
-0.5784406661987305,
0.6836982369422913,
-0.2133449763059616,
0.32303091883659363,
0.1753809154033661,
-0.5982111692428589,
0.17371022701263428,
-0.3101702928543091,
-0.5687645673751831,
1.3327616453170776,
0.3426930010318756,
-0.37301066517829895,
0.17538142204284668,
-0.5748740434646606,
-0.49009978771209717,
0.12145775556564331,
-0.318530410528183,
-0.6568388342857361,
0.0704796314239502,
0.1656850278377533,
0.5515977740287781,
-0.6712288856506348,
0.5657000541687012,
-0.12728430330753326,
-0.29991698265075684,
0.20208178460597992,
-0.4082644283771515,
0.7843710780143738,
0.37493187189102173,
-0.17324386537075043,
0.14697818458080292,
-0.9293584823608398,
0.28299006819725037,
0.16499367356300354,
-0.35015296936035156,
0.049518950283527374,
0.1807095855474472,
0.3082864582538605,
0.31737029552459717,
0.16263407468795776,
-0.6376757621765137,
-0.18770551681518555,
-0.14480279386043549,
0.6595844626426697,
0.5126386284828186,
-0.3318513333797455,
0.0023049688898026943,
-0.34337401390075684,
0.37970149517059326,
-0.08572539687156677,
0.2924906611442566,
-0.4675314724445343,
-0.40181970596313477,
-0.5645598769187927,
-0.22152815759181976,
0.44575515389442444,
0.7320523858070374,
-0.608523428440094,
0.9184834957122803,
-0.5647696852684021,
-0.7311412692070007,
-0.9047683477401733,
-0.10125758498907089,
0.12183654308319092,
0.3925130069255829,
0.2565751075744629,
0.03405346721410751,
-0.4157642424106598,
-0.68658047914505,
0.18719936907291412,
0.01954568922519684,
-0.39671292901039124,
0.09663853049278259,
0.16468961536884308,
-0.060931023210287094,
1.5022027492523193,
-0.0010168221779167652,
-0.3196953237056732,
-0.1301967054605484,
0.007692600134760141,
0.1511610597372055,
0.44591575860977173,
0.6026322841644287,
-0.6275925040245056,
-0.19227014482021332,
0.08419794589281082,
-0.8160395622253418,
-0.3188735544681549,
-0.028467796742916107,
-0.4231492578983307,
0.1433638334274292,
0.30852243304252625,
-0.306643009185791,
0.31454038619995117,
0.8329405188560486,
-0.2693924605846405,
0.44796639680862427,
-0.004277452826499939,
0.22781124711036682,
-1.51931893825531,
0.44529634714126587,
0.11068663001060486,
-0.39725011587142944,
-0.6471211314201355,
-0.5220226049423218,
-0.29970690608024597,
-0.5320845246315002,
-0.5791049599647522,
0.2468872219324112,
0.047867029905319214,
-0.6794296503067017,
0.009633630514144897,
0.23336249589920044,
-0.030293982475996017,
0.04045527055859566,
0.024841345846652985,
1.1973140239715576,
0.6403148174285889,
-0.4511007070541382,
0.5402697920799255,
0.6054253578186035,
-0.05557406693696976,
0.7133204340934753,
-0.8389554619789124,
0.14907485246658325,
0.005808048415929079,
-0.08513359725475311,
-0.6642260551452637,
-0.5773369073867798,
0.05911839008331299,
-1.0330824851989746,
-0.14441320300102234,
-0.12778609991073608,
-0.7589889764785767,
-0.11945831775665283,
-0.0653514489531517,
-0.08447389304637909,
0.6152599453926086,
-0.6222318410873413,
0.3251335322856903,
0.6569827198982239,
-0.6496866345405579,
-0.2534756064414978,
-0.6627964973449707,
0.41648751497268677,
0.20316734910011292,
-0.679310142993927,
0.4027126431465149,
0.021652286872267723,
-0.04027339071035385,
0.02062288671731949,
0.22935856878757477,
-0.2916231155395508,
-0.3354375958442688,
0.0952395349740982,
0.20319344103336334,
-0.0053206211887300014,
0.20600931346416473,
0.41512560844421387,
-0.12693026661872864,
-0.1091701090335846,
-0.7029471397399902,
0.3916494846343994,
0.40828800201416016,
-0.47954967617988586,
-0.7369265556335449,
0.6173956394195557,
0.9783077239990234,
-0.31036731600761414,
0.33344566822052,
0.28225278854370117,
-0.533130943775177,
-0.3243512511253357,
-0.2888733148574829,
0.19077080488204956,
-0.5016037225723267,
0.2808123230934143,
-0.014897382818162441,
-0.40119731426239014,
0.32492950558662415,
0.054342057555913925,
0.47345539927482605,
0.34289273619651794,
0.3560783565044403,
-0.15350311994552612,
0.9140680432319641,
0.38352254033088684,
-0.17486487329006195,
0.6313835382461548,
-0.15330348908901215,
-0.12324171513319016,
-0.30976563692092896,
-0.12720537185668945,
-0.758459746837616,
0.09994692355394363,
-0.17470258474349976,
-0.15191540122032166,
0.39318135380744934,
-0.32083797454833984,
-0.41847342252731323,
0.27489322423934937,
-0.9236608147621155,
0.1598244607448578,
0.7254616022109985,
0.14465346932411194,
0.35631224513053894,
0.3693239390850067,
0.37882182002067566,
0.11280008405447006,
-0.3569427728652954,
-0.6068912744522095,
1.1442317962646484,
0.3235000669956207,
0.6060622334480286,
-0.027060361579060555,
0.49388349056243896,
0.6708118319511414,
-0.2648845314979553,
-0.47741955518722534,
0.5234836339950562,
-0.3408631682395935,
-0.2883005440235138,
-0.6799445748329163,
-0.40650317072868347,
-0.42914530634880066,
-0.5087239742279053,
-0.02619544416666031,
-0.3753073811531067,
-0.01580246165394783,
0.11879125237464905,
-0.13021975755691528,
0.18556152284145355,
-0.5500704646110535,
0.6409677267074585,
-0.14664052426815033,
-0.4012627601623535,
0.10180618613958359,
-0.7258185744285583,
-0.03908824920654297,
-0.1877439171075821,
0.11192449182271957,
-0.2237689197063446,
0.1974766105413437,
0.868401825428009,
-0.49906831979751587,
0.5010828375816345,
-0.25020813941955566,
-0.2986389696598053,
0.6429058313369751,
-0.2834852337837219,
0.3595552444458008,
-0.020519979298114777,
-0.3444518446922302,
0.37733784317970276,
-0.17169985175132751,
-0.22856202721595764,
-0.3860471546649933,
0.3390829265117645,
-0.8721469640731812,
0.1335044652223587,
0.17231038212776184,
-0.3629024922847748,
-0.18270888924598694,
0.1985609531402588,
0.5670595169067383,
0.5993404388427734,
-0.05121523141860962,
0.14994476735591888,
0.7316462397575378,
-0.5314098596572876,
0.18039602041244507,
0.24809828400611877,
-0.246771901845932,
-0.7582910656929016,
1.2060381174087524,
0.3680308163166046,
0.4409196078777313,
-0.0441448800265789,
-0.13005922734737396,
-0.4557659924030304,
-0.6915587186813354,
-0.8334286212921143,
0.03290092945098877,
-0.48618441820144653,
-0.16434155404567719,
-0.26765868067741394,
-0.552710235118866,
-0.5150560736656189,
-0.22181731462478638,
-0.617339551448822,
-0.4391224980354309,
-0.44828900694847107,
0.12016024440526962,
0.7430272102355957,
0.5941201448440552,
0.0559445396065712,
0.45768240094184875,
-0.8886452913284302,
0.5957432985305786,
-0.07438313215970993,
0.6576831340789795,
-0.3888152539730072,
-0.6811624765396118,
-0.4984687864780426,
0.2827472686767578,
-0.0368310809135437,
-0.767699658870697,
0.2834377586841583,
0.48678767681121826,
0.25301405787467957,
0.14773279428482056,
0.05544804781675339,
0.3611964285373688,
-0.35053902864456177,
0.8239649534225464,
0.10221099853515625,
-1.0039149522781372,
0.9574630856513977,
-0.7215576171875,
0.09789140522480011,
0.4184388518333435,
0.010688233189284801,
-0.7780182957649231,
-0.6071028113365173,
-0.3002380132675171,
-0.8329680562019348,
0.7404342889785767,
0.5496237277984619,
-0.11076798290014267,
0.24860146641731262,
0.3389231264591217,
0.4187605082988739,
0.37203821539878845,
-0.2810787856578827,
-0.09218143671751022,
-0.6901309490203857,
-0.7034412026405334,
0.11936165392398834,
0.2302849441766739,
0.1600407063961029,
-0.03778894618153572,
0.9596489071846008,
-0.12115544825792313,
0.39464616775512695,
0.04601290076971054,
-0.04415284842252731,
-0.12692351639270782,
0.36052754521369934,
0.2627289593219757,
0.46380671858787537,
-0.1566992551088333,
-0.4630127251148224,
-0.19284839928150177,
-0.6541847586631775,
0.32352861762046814,
0.22282162308692932,
-0.359815388917923,
0.3896314203739166,
-0.052586790174245834,
0.6284633278846741,
-0.3379509449005127,
-0.8260051012039185,
0.4453135132789612,
0.04863147810101509,
-0.14193494617938995,
-0.5990437865257263,
-0.032360512763261795,
-0.06640873104333878,
-0.05748920887708664,
0.569113552570343,
-0.18397335708141327,
-0.0550227016210556,
-0.3193257749080658,
0.5072468519210815,
-0.08234261721372604,
-0.20259864628314972,
-0.18007950484752655,
0.8552999496459961,
0.4207635521888733,
-0.5330255627632141,
0.7024846076965332,
0.007616455666720867,
0.17282308638095856,
0.5382647514343262,
0.25283151865005493,
0.8458765745162964,
-0.4816088080406189,
0.23133361339569092,
0.16175486147403717,
0.05193732678890228,
-0.11156366020441055,
0.708386242389679,
0.2968304455280304,
-0.18028123676776886,
-0.6201725006103516,
-0.5202342867851257,
-0.6397178173065186,
0.2294452041387558,
-0.6403979063034058,
0.744510293006897,
-0.05553145334124565,
-0.37788811326026917,
-0.1990475356578827,
-0.7075598835945129,
-0.3662837743759155,
0.509088397026062,
0.04453788697719574,
0.922649085521698,
-0.6713014245033264,
0.6562567353248596,
0.3105636537075043,
-0.3460548222064972,
-0.4078409969806671,
-0.11336815357208252,
-0.028014887124300003,
-0.4107636511325836,
0.188627690076828,
-0.051821500062942505,
-0.050659336149692535,
0.49287259578704834,
-0.5465469360351562,
-0.9108719229698181,
0.954804003238678,
0.730591893196106,
-0.6689963340759277,
-0.2873125970363617,
0.6937953233718872,
0.40856513381004333,
-0.05401020124554634,
0.1549532413482666,
0.5715202689170837,
0.23246407508850098,
0.12113311141729355,
-0.9968797564506531,
-0.31069523096084595,
-0.27739420533180237,
-0.2415996789932251,
0.18544645607471466,
-0.147913858294487,
0.38650640845298767,
0.040953703224658966,
-0.2702944278717041,
-0.1363644152879715,
0.6829981803894043,
0.15976399183273315,
0.2388276904821396,
0.2831292450428009,
0.42527830600738525,
0.497758150100708,
-0.23248116672039032,
0.3349536061286926,
-0.47663190960884094,
0.1605350822210312,
1.0511966943740845,
-0.1988077312707901,
0.9339691996574402,
-0.04922940582036972,
-0.09985002875328064,
-0.15149986743927002,
0.7501038908958435,
-0.033914655447006226,
0.4127337634563446,
0.06649386137723923,
-0.3361269235610962,
0.10549131780862808,
-0.48464494943618774,
-0.3259270191192627,
0.39245256781578064,
0.6641225218772888,
-0.36716777086257935,
-0.11964933574199677,
0.2835084795951843,
-0.27371910214424133,
0.05908557027578354,
-0.026088373735547066,
0.734005331993103,
-0.34203603863716125,
-0.47399574518203735,
0.5228027105331421,
-0.3713652491569519,
0.6253450512886047,
-0.5327329039573669,
-0.03969019651412964,
0.08283151686191559,
-0.38603079319000244,
-0.3094240725040436,
-1.125490665435791,
0.56873619556427,
0.3862803876399994,
-0.14399519562721252,
-0.15336014330387115,
0.4563447833061218,
-0.5047531127929688,
-0.37072184681892395,
0.243943452835083,
0.6459036469459534,
0.3389870822429657,
0.08160709589719772,
-0.45051059126853943,
0.2658498287200928,
-0.20753279328346252,
-0.2961103916168213,
-0.09039249271154404,
0.41405126452445984,
0.19576388597488403,
0.6597447395324707,
0.8012626767158508,
0.3219190239906311,
0.18837545812129974,
0.3363330662250519,
0.663054883480072,
-0.4028572738170624,
-0.691916286945343,
-0.4698018729686737,
0.7283352613449097,
-0.3324570059776306,
-0.28969189524650574,
0.07636114954948425,
0.7795551419258118,
0.6569911241531372,
0.3248661160469055,
1.5065642595291138,
-0.2007969170808792,
1.0138729810714722,
-0.36775580048561096,
0.9216811656951904,
-0.4520924687385559,
0.014938121661543846,
-0.2501428425312042,
-0.6391409039497375,
-0.02050662599503994,
0.05511164292693138,
0.31930670142173767,
-0.11909118294715881,
0.1835726797580719,
0.6789456605911255,
-0.131363183259964,
0.1891782134771347,
0.40611138939857483,
-0.07690533250570297,
0.5427107810974121,
0.17093509435653687,
0.5116450786590576,
-0.38587164878845215,
0.8223177194595337,
0.14036451280117035,
-0.31809425354003906,
0.02545776404440403,
-0.5820096731185913,
-0.48291975259780884,
-1.000901699066162,
-0.19725970923900604,
-0.3843125104904175,
0.46867620944976807,
1.0846843719482422,
0.7739179134368896,
-0.5285124182701111,
-0.16457822918891907,
-0.30546626448631287,
-0.40372225642204285,
-0.1034785732626915,
-0.20617464184761047,
0.2823568284511566,
-0.2958057224750519,
-0.8028238415718079,
0.40659233927726746,
0.3065682649612427,
0.4615667760372162,
-0.2653350234031677,
-0.13165102899074554,
0.18039312958717346,
0.14992748200893402,
0.4840656518936157,
0.3510023355484009,
-0.4187752306461334,
-0.07708371430635452,
0.11856207996606827,
0.016191357746720314,
0.26056405901908875,
0.5541927814483643,
-0.7174745798110962,
0.4581294059753418,
0.37022727727890015,
0.9223684072494507,
0.026467612013220787,
-0.03392315283417702,
0.8003721833229065,
-0.9273224472999573,
-0.004161059390753508,
0.2552579641342163,
0.11914734542369843,
0.42831218242645264,
-0.3185197412967682,
0.5221856236457825,
0.06818884611129761,
-0.653016209602356,
-0.9716655015945435,
0.06339272856712341,
-0.7863409519195557,
0.08788345009088516,
1.0261896848678589,
0.035374321043491364,
-0.05546896159648895,
-0.29763785004615784,
-0.398391455411911,
0.90897536277771,
-0.6604253649711609,
0.6850534677505493,
0.48511749505996704,
0.08024973422288895,
-0.04181276634335518,
-0.9704873561859131,
0.3588261902332306,
-0.036096345633268356,
-1.3009393215179443,
0.5113235116004944,
0.48078539967536926,
-0.007623522542417049,
-0.05641339719295502,
0.3817251920700073,
-0.24363325536251068,
0.3744703233242035,
-0.20791034400463104,
0.32134073972702026,
-0.28217267990112305,
-0.3197166919708252,
-0.10627973824739456,
-0.0642494484782219,
-0.23412208259105682,
-0.44958093762397766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16379v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16379v3
|
TEaR: Improving LLM-based Machine Translation with Systematic Self-Refinement
| 2024-02-26T07:58:12 | 2024-06-21T07:35:53 |
Zhaopeng Feng, Yan Zhang, Hao Li, Bei Wu, Jiayu Liao, Wenqiang Liu, Jun Lang, Yang Feng, Jian Wu, Zuozhu Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved impressive results in Machine
Translation (MT). However, careful evaluations by human reveal that the
translations produced by LLMs still contain multiple errors. Importantly,
feeding back such error information into the LLMs can lead to self-refinement
and result in improved translation performance. Motivated by these insights, we
introduce a systematic LLM-based self-refinement translation framework, named
\textbf{TEaR}, which stands for \textbf{T}ranslate, \textbf{E}stimate,
\textbf{a}nd \textbf{R}efine, marking a significant step forward in this
direction. Our findings demonstrate that 1) our self-refinement framework
successfully assists LLMs in improving their translation quality across a wide
range of languages, whether it's from high-resource languages to low-resource
ones or whether it's English-centric or centered around other languages; 2)
TEaR exhibits superior systematicity and interpretability; 3) different
estimation strategies yield varied impacts, directly affecting the
effectiveness of the final corrections. Additionally, traditional neural
translation models and evaluation models operate separately, often focusing on
singular tasks due to their limited capabilities, while general-purpose LLMs
possess the capability to undertake both tasks simultaneously. We further
conduct cross-model correction experiments to investigate the potential
relationship between the translation and evaluation capabilities of
general-purpose LLMs. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/fzp0424/self_correct_mt
|
[
0.1801500916481018,
-0.46219006180763245,
0.5886475443840027,
0.44417864084243774,
-0.11481431126594543,
0.2978246212005615,
-0.3942178189754486,
-0.5331825613975525,
0.296363890171051,
0.718149721622467,
-0.7698875069618225,
-0.5878132581710815,
-0.3917663097381592,
0.47527191042900085,
-0.40723517537117004,
1.1095163822174072,
-0.5005502700805664,
0.4254462718963623,
0.0350554920732975,
-0.3970493972301483,
-0.25392451882362366,
-0.16965383291244507,
-0.3071337938308716,
-0.47436487674713135,
0.8998262286186218,
0.42875936627388,
0.388048380613327,
0.8994051814079285,
0.7906144261360168,
0.37629079818725586,
0.09138857573270798,
0.3065294325351715,
-0.4922899901866913,
0.4438158869743347,
-0.2305687814950943,
-0.5690769553184509,
-0.5613107085227966,
0.07335957884788513,
0.6620402932167053,
0.4447285830974579,
-0.1743190884590149,
0.2959204316139221,
0.30209407210350037,
1.0280507802963257,
-0.39806026220321655,
-0.3370359539985657,
-0.5503593683242798,
0.10305807739496231,
-0.2690593898296356,
-0.017729919403791428,
-0.464177668094635,
-0.19900912046432495,
0.0853402316570282,
-0.29765915870666504,
0.3035179674625397,
-0.05009869858622551,
0.8119432330131531,
0.7044233679771423,
-0.22151558101177216,
-0.16748416423797607,
-0.6282047033309937,
0.8030017018318176,
-0.8903605937957764,
0.3525330424308777,
-0.09921894967556,
0.17953325808048248,
-0.15219682455062866,
-0.6993825435638428,
-0.16530683636665344,
-0.2919478118419647,
-0.026173332706093788,
0.26493513584136963,
0.14060257375240326,
0.16797170042991638,
-0.008190028369426727,
0.695466935634613,
-0.4742598533630371,
0.205137699842453,
-0.3704523742198944,
-0.19199424982070923,
0.6948795318603516,
0.10755644738674164,
0.47529104351997375,
-0.21071287989616394,
-0.7493151426315308,
0.23041091859340668,
-0.7922371625900269,
-0.4623481333255768,
0.2560267150402069,
0.18229638040065765,
-0.06009780615568161,
0.4472077190876007,
-0.32470956444740295,
0.4088505804538727,
0.207369863986969,
-0.15871410071849823,
0.3181494176387787,
-0.39707326889038086,
-0.29370105266571045,
-0.11541470885276794,
0.8742783665657043,
0.45219796895980835,
0.018847597762942314,
-0.41243496537208557,
-0.5231621861457825,
-0.09231448173522949,
0.4795653522014618,
-0.5694095492362976,
-0.11916768550872803,
0.3407686650753021,
-0.5287104249000549,
-0.49134561419487,
-0.27743786573410034,
-0.45696738362312317,
-0.37318751215934753,
-0.48889124393463135,
0.3880244195461273,
-0.37009397149086,
-0.13542833924293518,
0.24537768959999084,
0.1922542303800583,
0.004088373854756355,
0.4584406316280365,
-0.5918567180633545,
0.1152539849281311,
0.4612235426902771,
0.9538627862930298,
-0.42450323700904846,
-0.6512787938117981,
-0.37155216932296753,
0.004610366187989712,
-0.4318738281726837,
0.895037829875946,
0.02577512338757515,
0.0661429837346077,
0.020506372675299644,
-0.1451825350522995,
-0.09242110699415207,
-0.7720544934272766,
0.4950334429740906,
-0.3080708086490631,
0.12133011221885681,
-0.11062069982290268,
-0.35782817006111145,
-0.3212861716747284,
0.41255247592926025,
-0.6203744411468506,
0.9631510376930237,
0.022668149322271347,
-0.46946850419044495,
0.21234698593616486,
-0.5218888521194458,
-0.4834877848625183,
-0.19788603484630585,
0.18014705181121826,
-0.539252519607544,
0.515306830406189,
0.08249343186616898,
0.2908373773097992,
-0.44847428798675537,
0.09252411872148514,
-0.5506308078765869,
-0.16492314636707306,
0.28430965542793274,
-0.22532325983047485,
0.32844364643096924,
0.16104304790496826,
-0.6096175312995911,
0.4247587323188782,
-0.6917607188224792,
0.16057592630386353,
0.03804357722401619,
-0.4739946126937866,
0.049366019666194916,
-0.09685321152210236,
-0.2146177887916565,
0.46055924892425537,
0.19073782861232758,
-0.4723972976207733,
0.420858770608902,
-0.40198054909706116,
0.35139936208724976,
0.8562055826187134,
-0.2990865707397461,
0.4765060544013977,
-0.20581524074077606,
0.5680054426193237,
-0.031726349145174026,
0.27402809262275696,
-0.21099328994750977,
0.05485444888472557,
-1.2081345319747925,
-0.19331546127796173,
0.5553622245788574,
0.4125017821788788,
-0.5871257185935974,
0.1824728399515152,
-0.05018742382526398,
-0.3711704611778259,
-1.0189520120620728,
0.6095027327537537,
0.5807300209999084,
0.4936390519142151,
0.617431104183197,
-0.3820953369140625,
-0.508805513381958,
-0.9078865647315979,
-0.43563130497932434,
-0.06766828894615173,
0.27172690629959106,
-0.04451511427760124,
0.27045243978500366,
-0.5162973999977112,
0.546735942363739,
-0.17996804416179657,
-0.7675323486328125,
-0.39228805899620056,
0.16562530398368835,
0.04907447472214699,
0.3087298572063446,
0.07136742025613785,
-0.22179953753948212,
-0.35514798760414124,
-0.11387301236391068,
-0.8840828537940979,
-0.5145721435546875,
-0.40908291935920715,
-0.28725799918174744,
0.43076378107070923,
0.5157777070999146,
-0.3956752419471741,
0.21509578824043274,
0.8463631272315979,
-0.15105926990509033,
0.8393916487693787,
-0.36353570222854614,
0.10359711199998856,
-0.7800453901290894,
-0.011164679192006588,
0.03627132251858711,
-0.29279235005378723,
-0.5012524724006653,
0.19585829973220825,
0.21502681076526642,
0.468208372592926,
-0.6609715819358826,
0.29075637459754944,
-0.6820098757743835,
-0.19462697207927704,
-0.42371854186058044,
0.29847806692123413,
0.0981890931725502,
0.38777655363082886,
-0.3199324905872345,
0.5242646336555481,
0.22530634701251984,
-0.4148600101470947,
0.45774444937705994,
-0.09805835038423538,
-0.10935894399881363,
0.472321093082428,
-0.613093376159668,
0.3672855496406555,
0.190082386136055,
0.3370359241962433,
-0.72430819272995,
-0.0979287326335907,
0.6033574342727661,
-0.2283293604850769,
0.5542990565299988,
-0.13584384322166443,
-0.4631756544113159,
-0.1474807858467102,
-0.2562481462955475,
0.3184036314487457,
0.12940247356891632,
-0.6717143058776855,
0.6541804671287537,
0.006340621504932642,
0.018235260620713234,
-0.6002300977706909,
-0.8481130003929138,
0.32332098484039307,
-0.15909235179424286,
-0.7750357389450073,
0.40427008271217346,
-0.3119165897369385,
-0.13985538482666016,
-0.09077680110931396,
-0.3333478569984436,
0.08414957672357559,
0.09996684640645981,
0.18917083740234375,
0.17007014155387878,
-0.14218588173389435,
0.2522192597389221,
-0.061220526695251465,
-0.28836262226104736,
-0.04895642399787903,
-0.5598043203353882,
0.3836474120616913,
-0.26756107807159424,
-0.47129732370376587,
-0.37248915433883667,
0.12066905945539474,
0.562874972820282,
-0.5056139826774597,
0.3292330205440521,
0.6029130816459656,
-0.07894189655780792,
-0.5492926836013794,
-0.8447074294090271,
-0.11053375899791718,
-0.45940276980400085,
0.38338175415992737,
-0.4921521842479706,
-0.7848072648048401,
0.43672579526901245,
-0.32731202244758606,
0.020564967766404152,
0.6974929571151733,
0.514789879322052,
-0.3847965598106384,
0.9845790863037109,
0.6258516311645508,
-0.12247338145971298,
0.1578180491924286,
-0.3806409537792206,
0.00162403448484838,
-1.155423641204834,
-0.04306415840983391,
-0.3612716794013977,
-0.6958135366439819,
-0.38551580905914307,
-0.6336659789085388,
-0.040920864790678024,
0.33469414710998535,
0.13979564607143402,
0.19982683658599854,
-0.41038164496421814,
0.4539657235145569,
0.34348738193511963,
0.13830994069576263,
0.35179752111434937,
-0.06108466163277626,
-0.4605046808719635,
-0.16580449044704437,
-0.699769914150238,
-0.5663691759109497,
0.978564977645874,
0.6599259972572327,
0.884984016418457,
-0.13244140148162842,
1.0395891666412354,
0.14694947004318237,
0.7782759666442871,
-0.7676662802696228,
0.39948123693466187,
-0.27007344365119934,
-0.4898506999015808,
-0.09946747869253159,
-0.6103797554969788,
-0.5257731080055237,
0.35401451587677,
0.11355031281709671,
-0.20196790993213654,
-0.17629143595695496,
0.26101401448249817,
-0.12182743102312088,
0.31116899847984314,
-0.6399877071380615,
0.9456921815872192,
-0.7864280939102173,
-0.3305591940879822,
-0.4802081286907196,
-0.5869059562683105,
0.4810973107814789,
-0.3820240795612335,
0.18925288319587708,
-0.25198349356651306,
-0.15169858932495117,
0.4343522787094116,
-0.47185543179512024,
0.9583373069763184,
0.13271962106227875,
-0.34797313809394836,
0.18892620503902435,
0.35213392972946167,
0.49928197264671326,
-0.25327402353286743,
-0.020959144458174706,
0.3745104968547821,
-0.4208081066608429,
-0.30763640999794006,
-0.7738324999809265,
0.7383818030357361,
-0.5555315613746643,
-0.5818517208099365,
-0.36116138100624084,
-0.5059598684310913,
0.0732252299785614,
0.3255482316017151,
0.26143941283226013,
0.23524263501167297,
0.06697978079319,
-0.11952593177556992,
0.4439276158809662,
-0.14668694138526917,
0.2927864193916321,
0.8601865768432617,
-0.5049833655357361,
-0.7643145322799683,
0.8648539185523987,
0.29617437720298767,
0.5030258893966675,
0.04400493577122688,
0.17428575456142426,
-0.3421393632888794,
-0.8224654197692871,
-0.7899829745292664,
0.7475438714027405,
-0.7890338897705078,
-0.4073006212711334,
-0.37120506167411804,
0.061444029211997986,
-0.19099484384059906,
-0.003605005331337452,
-0.7242365479469299,
-0.34662064909935,
-0.10875007510185242,
-0.16760684549808502,
-0.015556473284959793,
1.1355185508728027,
-0.24383430182933807,
0.13351696729660034,
-0.9367342591285706,
0.32146188616752625,
-0.07325560599565506,
0.618104100227356,
-0.3296970725059509,
-0.6557660698890686,
-0.520416259765625,
-0.030245859175920486,
-0.450003445148468,
-0.9447633624076843,
0.4198942184448242,
0.1925465315580368,
0.33466872572898865,
0.15171034634113312,
-0.05126376822590828,
0.9393235445022583,
-0.7457216382026672,
0.520203173160553,
0.3764083981513977,
-1.0290913581848145,
0.5782135128974915,
-0.19913677871227264,
0.3313682973384857,
0.6198652386665344,
0.03809418901801109,
-0.769206702709198,
-0.5818356871604919,
-0.5105729103088379,
-0.9385433197021484,
0.6820423603057861,
-0.18498767912387848,
-0.1068350151181221,
0.1272636353969574,
0.47059381008148193,
0.0532519556581974,
-0.004026898182928562,
-0.8789990544319153,
-0.24427112936973572,
0.12152611464262009,
-0.3389122486114502,
-0.09255961328744888,
-0.39863142371177673,
-0.07848010212182999,
0.13689276576042175,
0.9663084745407104,
-0.29294246435165405,
-0.058557722717523575,
0.5875213742256165,
-0.6023032069206238,
-0.47037845849990845,
0.15293200314044952,
0.5525880455970764,
0.5172349214553833,
0.0038625155575573444,
0.12615054845809937,
0.4525814354419708,
-0.1664043366909027,
0.2593615651130676,
-0.11116354167461395,
-0.27852863073349,
0.1447092443704605,
0.4336285889148712,
0.4783361852169037,
0.39833760261535645,
-0.3709104657173157,
0.20404914021492004,
0.06870727241039276,
-0.22988811135292053,
-0.08182326704263687,
-0.223069965839386,
0.04603760316967964,
0.41500386595726013,
0.14584767818450928,
0.2660638093948364,
0.15281617641448975,
-0.21688741445541382,
0.39939507842063904,
0.03520023822784424,
-0.6578918099403381,
-0.38965553045272827,
0.42471951246261597,
0.4538516700267792,
-0.2504895031452179,
0.5256766080856323,
-0.11611577123403549,
-0.8650961518287659,
0.04116208851337433,
0.39647969603538513,
1.3569660186767578,
-0.48358845710754395,
0.22595281898975372,
0.24873857200145721,
0.4596169888973236,
-0.2602589428424835,
0.04694204777479172,
0.23837891221046448,
-0.5007520914077759,
-0.9069361090660095,
-0.7120771408081055,
-0.3776499032974243,
-0.09476207196712494,
-0.3713195323944092,
0.25865045189857483,
-0.3790924549102783,
-0.10795637965202332,
-0.4913710653781891,
-0.06948073953390121,
-0.370869517326355,
0.35721737146377563,
0.21202558279037476,
0.8239935636520386,
-0.4278833866119385,
0.7411441802978516,
0.6539576053619385,
-0.5671256184577942,
-0.7652937769889832,
0.10494530946016312,
0.2278440296649933,
-0.6248287558555603,
0.9317226409912109,
0.38889577984809875,
-0.4213864505290985,
-0.11957760900259018,
-0.25062090158462524,
-1.0215845108032227,
0.9745142459869385,
0.4521424174308777,
-0.9629332423210144,
-0.02850881777703762,
0.3372258245944977,
0.652947187423706,
-0.41152048110961914,
0.1991311013698578,
0.5327836871147156,
0.33744943141937256,
-0.20596259832382202,
-0.9043256044387817,
0.12766867876052856,
-0.15337178111076355,
-0.17718815803527832,
0.20871947705745697,
-0.8591182231903076,
0.3599278926849365,
-0.4094572067260742,
-0.1750326007604599,
0.1252259910106659,
0.8472399711608887,
0.04607059434056282,
0.12371675670146942,
0.4900006055831909,
0.9408895373344421,
0.6162524223327637,
-0.13078822195529938,
0.9399994611740112,
-0.36032575368881226,
0.37591660022735596,
1.3621584177017212,
-0.14581844210624695,
0.8239680528640747,
0.35593852400779724,
0.06002712994813919,
0.5720636248588562,
0.5790896415710449,
-0.08302608877420425,
0.23906587064266205,
0.44293925166130066,
-0.05128403380513191,
-0.2884964346885681,
0.02588692307472229,
-0.07498040795326233,
0.3678007423877716,
-0.07682577520608902,
-0.7500152587890625,
-0.15419435501098633,
-0.21021553874015808,
0.12751489877700806,
-0.02629072032868862,
-0.11505277454853058,
0.7097025513648987,
0.3909984230995178,
-0.8040273189544678,
0.6737704873085022,
0.14494110643863678,
0.6033743023872375,
-0.36840757727622986,
0.13524609804153442,
-0.3621610403060913,
0.6161417365074158,
-0.41207581758499146,
-0.4409378170967102,
0.46505871415138245,
0.18636052310466766,
-0.20507661998271942,
-0.5561846494674683,
0.7877292633056641,
-0.569941520690918,
-0.46707046031951904,
0.7513484358787537,
0.4753709137439728,
0.10871493071317673,
-0.3226451873779297,
-1.0291262865066528,
0.3703007996082306,
0.20779703557491302,
-0.33847576379776,
0.23223508894443512,
0.4529109597206116,
0.3017437756061554,
0.8469312787055969,
0.5094534754753113,
0.33012720942497253,
0.18638798594474792,
0.41193339228630066,
0.5898927450180054,
-0.8517085313796997,
0.040205903351306915,
-0.8631498217582703,
0.9122564792633057,
0.09449151903390884,
-0.4467051923274994,
0.8810653686523438,
0.5124397873878479,
0.9043848514556885,
0.052335407584905624,
0.7365366816520691,
0.4228089153766632,
0.5967696309089661,
-0.5577090978622437,
0.6444779634475708,
-0.6579201221466064,
0.3248690664768219,
-0.1671011596918106,
-0.9501170516014099,
-0.4491037130355835,
0.45156726241111755,
-0.2687607407569885,
-0.10635069757699966,
0.8980770111083984,
0.6823651194572449,
0.3102623224258423,
-0.3390706181526184,
0.22904570400714874,
0.5099748373031616,
0.3338923454284668,
0.22337500751018524,
0.972454845905304,
-0.6662777066230774,
0.8773784041404724,
-0.45521971583366394,
-0.12617796659469604,
-0.17657385766506195,
-0.678581178188324,
-0.5952686071395874,
-0.1415659338235855,
-0.7514131665229797,
-0.5208840370178223,
0.039825815707445145,
0.9360981583595276,
0.6244974732398987,
-0.654202401638031,
-0.37275245785713196,
-0.052357178181409836,
0.011423110030591488,
-0.19411517679691315,
-0.10252159088850021,
0.09580720961093903,
-1.1187496185302734,
-0.6342499852180481,
0.6874473094940186,
0.5576594471931458,
-0.12136612832546234,
-0.4837743937969208,
-0.3597441613674164,
-0.028451737016439438,
-0.08446872979402542,
0.4836866557598114,
-0.06859586387872696,
-1.1157842874526978,
-0.27048400044441223,
0.13393227756023407,
-0.34395071864128113,
0.22172564268112183,
0.6874189972877502,
-0.5288057327270508,
0.6030656099319458,
0.29465556144714355,
0.6752526760101318,
0.36225005984306335,
-0.1964670717716217,
0.9000161290168762,
-0.5718423128128052,
-0.5746470093727112,
0.014739646576344967,
0.515715479850769,
0.6374281644821167,
-0.13514213263988495,
0.7475889921188354,
0.30340564250946045,
-0.6951093673706055,
-0.7278401255607605,
0.25993287563323975,
-0.6151784658432007,
-0.1072717234492302,
1.2053111791610718,
-0.39106687903404236,
-0.3819724917411804,
0.20299431681632996,
-0.30654293298721313,
0.43389564752578735,
-0.0868225246667862,
0.8638217449188232,
0.720776379108429,
0.028986049816012383,
-0.19003652036190033,
-0.3246285021305084,
0.38924938440322876,
0.8312768340110779,
-0.652906596660614,
0.2538659870624542,
0.5005214214324951,
0.46010705828666687,
0.20446620881557465,
0.2882537841796875,
-0.25703197717666626,
0.17398357391357422,
-0.4451395273208618,
0.4719678461551666,
0.09533525258302689,
-0.5195277333259583,
-0.7826026678085327,
-0.13013367354869843,
0.17314890027046204,
0.001286478596739471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16367v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16367v2
|
Unraveling Babel: Exploring Multilingual Activation Patterns of LLMs and Their Applications
| 2024-02-26T07:44:56 | 2024-06-17T17:57:32 |
Weize Liu, Yinlong Xu, Hongxia Xu, Jintai Chen, Xuming Hu, Jian Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have achieved tremendous breakthroughs
in the field of NLP, but still lack understanding of their internal activities
when processing different languages. We designed a method to convert dense LLMs
into fine-grained MoE architectures, and then visually studied the multilingual
activation patterns of LLMs through expert activation frequency heatmaps.
Through comprehensive experiments on different model families, different model
sizes, and different variants, we analyzed the distribution of high-frequency
activated experts, multilingual shared experts, whether the activation patterns
of different languages are related to language families, and the impact of
instruction tuning on activation patterns. We further explored leveraging the
discovered differences in expert activation frequencies to guide unstructured
pruning in two different ways. Experimental results demonstrated that our
method significantly outperformed random expert pruning and even exceeded the
performance of the original unpruned models in some languages. Additionally, we
found that configuring different pruning rates for different layers based on
activation level differences could achieve better results. Our findings reveal
the multilingual processing mechanisms within LLMs and utilize these insights
to offer new perspectives for applications such as model pruning.
|
[
-0.3287717401981354,
-0.9881616234779358,
0.21038387715816498,
0.47082820534706116,
-0.17699947953224182,
0.22307324409484863,
-0.5325812101364136,
-0.4601428806781769,
0.023211130872368813,
0.4523094892501831,
-0.40540987253189087,
-0.6253498792648315,
-0.48920199275016785,
0.07952669262886047,
-0.28020191192626953,
0.4744255244731903,
0.032435301691293716,
0.19087067246437073,
-0.12867684662342072,
-0.045564860105514526,
-0.49545344710350037,
-0.5199332237243652,
-0.7216935753822327,
-0.5794578790664673,
0.24317757785320282,
0.36132296919822693,
0.4859878122806549,
0.3437756896018982,
0.3649936616420746,
0.4255332052707672,
-0.334021657705307,
0.4334137439727783,
-0.49770909547805786,
0.14964520931243896,
0.018209297209978104,
-0.49885159730911255,
-0.4365544319152832,
-0.15052692592144012,
0.5791765451431274,
0.7508864998817444,
-0.29306089878082275,
0.16746029257774353,
0.24736341834068298,
0.5521387457847595,
-0.3757040500640869,
0.4156566858291626,
-0.7124606370925903,
0.138059601187706,
-0.32672759890556335,
-0.6120305061340332,
-0.706376314163208,
0.15872375667095184,
-0.1755828708410263,
-0.2974546551704407,
0.2773105204105377,
0.0105361333116889,
0.5139034390449524,
0.27219656109809875,
-0.5364094972610474,
-0.04186925292015076,
-0.6978322267532349,
0.9962197542190552,
-0.7269445657730103,
0.3457963168621063,
0.2387629747390747,
-0.06066669151186943,
-0.3441823720932007,
-0.2876151502132416,
-0.06592487543821335,
0.0031023044139146805,
-0.140952467918396,
0.011175929568707943,
-0.1175772100687027,
-0.016747836023569107,
0.17364242672920227,
0.1778823435306549,
-0.4989427924156189,
0.43808242678642273,
-0.36136141419410706,
-0.11639823764562607,
0.7541413307189941,
-0.05325988680124283,
0.3997534215450287,
0.011529481038451195,
-0.4279303252696991,
0.10366936028003693,
-0.7546753883361816,
0.04458048194646835,
0.2959766387939453,
0.15947018563747406,
-0.057830147445201874,
0.5194731950759888,
-0.07196033000946045,
0.8753350377082825,
-0.11714716255664825,
-0.21803812682628632,
0.2813054025173187,
-0.029664143919944763,
-0.0571761280298233,
0.1499498337507248,
0.7508183717727661,
0.3918793201446533,
0.6450315117835999,
-0.3411465883255005,
-0.201149120926857,
-0.33393508195877075,
-0.008288877084851265,
-0.6881581544876099,
-0.09940129518508911,
0.19729217886924744,
-0.31029748916625977,
-0.20281653106212616,
-0.2944197952747345,
-0.6168220043182373,
-0.09662550687789917,
-0.2383914440870285,
0.08590314537286758,
-0.5118730068206787,
-0.628689706325531,
0.44210758805274963,
-0.07941070199012756,
0.17328310012817383,
0.08928176015615463,
-0.9425954818725586,
0.017185810953378677,
0.6236692070960999,
0.5939772129058838,
-0.18483078479766846,
-0.44899889826774597,
-0.16688652336597443,
0.3343924880027771,
-0.43700698018074036,
0.5931511521339417,
-0.6621499061584473,
-0.3504153788089752,
0.19698628783226013,
-0.18471834063529968,
-0.23824216425418854,
-0.6845846772193909,
0.15174171328544617,
-1.0242128372192383,
-0.09869081526994705,
0.10885592550039291,
-0.4332727789878845,
-0.4895074665546417,
0.2899682819843292,
-0.5967118144035339,
1.2172541618347168,
-0.13942170143127441,
-0.36206328868865967,
0.1589146852493286,
-0.663468599319458,
-0.4733118414878845,
0.13391146063804626,
-0.08088167011737823,
-0.054879821836948395,
0.49146413803100586,
0.21973159909248352,
0.6098175048828125,
-0.2298993021249771,
0.35496798157691956,
0.008905265480279922,
-0.1388564556837082,
0.3232903480529785,
-0.5870192050933838,
0.8956398367881775,
0.04369860887527466,
-0.12410876899957657,
0.265959233045578,
-0.6841183304786682,
0.08540203422307968,
0.2066974639892578,
-0.5531083345413208,
-0.44637662172317505,
0.04274970293045044,
0.07411341369152069,
0.30475708842277527,
0.30721011757850647,
-0.34498131275177,
0.4290943443775177,
-0.5126317143440247,
0.5434808135032654,
0.6411179304122925,
0.16030418872833252,
0.42834171652793884,
0.050425972789525986,
0.5089227557182312,
0.1818869411945343,
-0.01905006915330887,
-0.2180064469575882,
-0.682125449180603,
-0.7061852216720581,
-0.07603252679109573,
0.20874212682247162,
0.38375532627105713,
-0.6983755230903625,
0.15044011175632477,
-0.277927964925766,
-0.26878994703292847,
-0.6601885557174683,
0.5862292051315308,
0.6327500939369202,
0.21598568558692932,
0.44150468707084656,
-0.39751136302948,
-0.20083849132061005,
-0.9274041056632996,
-0.40662577748298645,
0.06887176632881165,
0.05930353328585625,
0.08312258124351501,
0.244175985455513,
-0.11489281803369522,
0.9729059338569641,
-0.3430306911468506,
-0.265460729598999,
-0.422897607088089,
0.3419334888458252,
0.2329041212797165,
0.512663722038269,
0.5035059452056885,
-0.9136021137237549,
-0.5325937867164612,
0.24982860684394836,
-0.5380247831344604,
-0.04736577719449997,
-0.05204511433839798,
-0.0091475248336792,
0.19737175107002258,
0.8383706212043762,
-0.5004131197929382,
0.17246513068675995,
0.6334329843521118,
-0.12486446648836136,
0.4807159900665283,
-0.2766261398792267,
-0.02209262177348137,
-0.8763937950134277,
-0.18316487967967987,
0.07914731651544571,
-0.013570570386946201,
-0.8119667172431946,
0.3873365819454193,
0.11527916043996811,
-0.022890649735927582,
-0.7054170370101929,
0.6728618741035461,
-0.8806473016738892,
-0.17761023342609406,
-0.19504810869693756,
-0.13792233169078827,
-0.041914504021406174,
0.8746750354766846,
0.14023157954216003,
0.6131108403205872,
0.5086110830307007,
-0.5049866437911987,
0.3537803590297699,
0.08741161227226257,
-0.6446052193641663,
-0.16478374600410461,
-0.5756045579910278,
0.09973496943712234,
-0.042404260486364365,
-0.2795313894748688,
-0.8821685910224915,
-0.1671719253063202,
-0.10674072057008743,
-0.19763417541980743,
0.5378947854042053,
-0.4677765667438507,
-0.6833482384681702,
-0.05499297007918358,
-0.09021104872226715,
0.6377399563789368,
0.4787057638168335,
-0.24486857652664185,
0.6443119645118713,
0.4748978912830353,
-0.15567883849143982,
-0.40751326084136963,
-0.6666730046272278,
-0.06513554602861404,
-0.37154915928840637,
-0.706744372844696,
0.38785675168037415,
-0.15063875913619995,
-0.5289461612701416,
-0.24522899091243744,
-0.07315600663423538,
-0.09906339645385742,
0.39169013500213623,
0.17479334771633148,
-0.018164701759815216,
-0.2878062427043915,
0.0032107047736644745,
0.08435731381177902,
-0.1931455284357071,
0.15508118271827698,
-0.02049175649881363,
0.9763060808181763,
-0.06545045971870422,
-0.641954779624939,
-0.3363732397556305,
0.4006006419658661,
0.5557276010513306,
-0.7423319816589355,
0.6788868308067322,
0.7843151688575745,
-0.16277605295181274,
-0.30193349719047546,
-0.5805262923240662,
-0.13152246177196503,
-0.5571209788322449,
0.4521876573562622,
-0.47128623723983765,
-0.6616883873939514,
0.48396533727645874,
-0.4508726894855499,
0.35612788796424866,
0.18529772758483887,
0.7431784272193909,
0.10655897855758667,
1.1783466339111328,
0.7839627861976624,
-0.08406920731067657,
0.6818030476570129,
-0.38172706961631775,
0.13401705026626587,
-0.8611834645271301,
-0.30130288004875183,
-0.31264379620552063,
-0.4952450096607208,
-0.2833894193172455,
-0.6978574395179749,
0.39307138323783875,
0.5052061676979065,
0.17074789106845856,
-0.015668008476495743,
-0.381073534488678,
0.6515923738479614,
0.5090039968490601,
0.01938345469534397,
0.3195779323577881,
0.42134976387023926,
-0.10423927754163742,
0.11117309331893921,
-0.9518129825592041,
-0.3100523054599762,
0.9201217889785767,
0.22760486602783203,
0.6398501992225647,
0.1654946357011795,
0.5043208599090576,
0.05514691770076752,
0.3215317130088806,
-0.8911597728729248,
0.6127256155014038,
-0.10497942566871643,
-0.6744135618209839,
-0.39747950434684753,
-0.14973270893096924,
-1.06354558467865,
0.5021617412567139,
-0.09300646930932999,
-0.668578028678894,
0.18165898323059082,
0.10625952482223511,
-0.09211444854736328,
0.19368398189544678,
-0.9700675010681152,
0.759722113609314,
-0.4312669038772583,
-0.346713125705719,
-0.4458679258823395,
-0.29378828406333923,
0.3119697570800781,
-0.09057898074388504,
0.5404874682426453,
-0.30321502685546875,
0.03646305575966835,
0.7363706827163696,
0.04446844011545181,
1.1319432258605957,
-0.017957810312509537,
-0.46082058548927307,
0.16355806589126587,
0.247394397854805,
0.43815621733665466,
0.03849346190690994,
-0.43645426630973816,
0.4292907416820526,
-0.5178982615470886,
-0.47091007232666016,
-0.3789302408695221,
0.7374419569969177,
-0.713741660118103,
-0.8382132649421692,
0.08914948254823685,
-0.7746205925941467,
-0.40128692984580994,
0.3212471902370453,
-0.03356239199638367,
0.5905442237854004,
-0.11171804368495941,
0.10270023345947266,
0.6426864266395569,
-0.020505627617239952,
0.6198115348815918,
0.8778367638587952,
-0.2533600628376007,
0.1003129854798317,
0.9666874408721924,
0.025197232142090797,
0.21682167053222656,
0.4919135272502899,
0.019413011148571968,
0.07439003884792328,
-1.072693943977356,
-0.4066559970378876,
0.1785859316587448,
-0.6662982106208801,
0.08838020265102386,
-0.4604834020137787,
-0.0494256392121315,
-0.3697604537010193,
-0.22542616724967957,
-0.21382132172584534,
-0.1547129601240158,
-0.2459542453289032,
-0.06976328790187836,
0.3764949142932892,
0.625137448310852,
0.16636922955513,
0.4497722089290619,
-0.8931043148040771,
0.2883952558040619,
0.14905916154384613,
0.08361459523439407,
0.037111442536115646,
-0.35655611753463745,
-0.464969664812088,
0.07873993366956711,
-0.033458154648542404,
-0.9613476991653442,
0.6954982876777649,
0.4072536826133728,
0.7120609879493713,
0.6010759472846985,
-0.15190373361110687,
0.8226689696311951,
-0.7971832156181335,
0.6003236174583435,
-0.030355172231793404,
-0.6464307308197021,
0.23959650099277496,
-0.3322981894016266,
0.3714989721775055,
0.18597565591335297,
0.43347206711769104,
-0.5539657473564148,
-0.4463810622692108,
-0.502337634563446,
-1.2686622142791748,
0.6939015984535217,
-0.21963562071323395,
0.10257048904895782,
0.0900653675198555,
0.2881873846054077,
0.021446915343403816,
0.16843874752521515,
-0.5596103072166443,
-0.3611244261264801,
0.2924794554710388,
0.0013671012129634619,
-0.37022191286087036,
-0.525165319442749,
-0.4694593846797943,
-0.05576500669121742,
0.514451801776886,
-0.1641121506690979,
0.033172473311424255,
-0.22201740741729736,
-0.6046769618988037,
-0.15475055575370789,
0.326309472322464,
0.387479692697525,
0.6194927096366882,
-0.02518075332045555,
0.02532237023115158,
0.13631810247898102,
-0.21397598087787628,
-0.16878139972686768,
-0.14963534474372864,
-0.08713484555482864,
0.10305818170309067,
0.7388607859611511,
0.7198956608772278,
0.7054693102836609,
-0.5509691834449768,
0.03966229036450386,
0.14995799958705902,
-0.02453421615064144,
-0.2533915638923645,
0.19612568616867065,
0.3346917927265167,
0.24531404674053192,
0.3672690689563751,
0.058439046144485474,
-0.1498851180076599,
-0.5698864459991455,
-0.03266352787613869,
0.6288414001464844,
-0.2151121348142624,
-0.444930762052536,
0.3240101635456085,
0.5009928941726685,
-0.45810356736183167,
0.7062996029853821,
0.021767470985651016,
-0.4633966386318207,
0.6888270974159241,
0.5762708187103271,
0.6492506861686707,
-0.3753066956996918,
0.02857086807489395,
0.10323009639978409,
0.4499076306819916,
0.10019344091415405,
0.27885177731513977,
-0.16316576302051544,
-0.9985335469245911,
-0.7449325919151306,
-0.7491492033004761,
-0.01597617380321026,
0.005980330985039473,
-0.8186001777648926,
0.0840994268655777,
-0.04550127312541008,
0.09885185211896896,
0.1140337586402893,
-0.11193336546421051,
-0.7287923693656921,
-0.1939874142408371,
0.08777234703302383,
1.1251611709594727,
-0.893317461013794,
1.02930748462677,
0.9768723249435425,
-0.043360188603401184,
-0.6684866547584534,
-0.2036067247390747,
0.13787947595119476,
-1.1374304294586182,
0.789626955986023,
0.09313762933015823,
-0.07526490092277527,
0.4109744429588318,
-0.271455854177475,
-0.820012629032135,
0.8983585834503174,
0.31053605675697327,
-0.6400994062423706,
-0.06425902992486954,
0.24066780507564545,
0.4263709783554077,
-0.20864450931549072,
0.2530961334705353,
0.5799752473831177,
0.6162242293357849,
-0.1746649444103241,
-0.7401796579360962,
-0.28293707966804504,
-0.4944034516811371,
-0.11839645355939865,
0.3491068184375763,
-0.619826078414917,
0.6292986273765564,
-0.056119419634342194,
-0.20081742107868195,
-0.20586997270584106,
0.5346230864524841,
0.073457732796669,
0.03490344062447548,
0.45336684584617615,
0.327549546957016,
0.48234352469444275,
-0.08954478800296783,
0.9139538407325745,
-0.9054228663444519,
0.21134203672409058,
0.761410117149353,
-0.21432827413082123,
0.9114435315132141,
0.5978512763977051,
0.021487759426236153,
0.3761853575706482,
0.6483646035194397,
0.0967608392238617,
0.22466987371444702,
-0.038865696638822556,
-0.29818907380104065,
-0.586154580116272,
-0.18172809481620789,
-0.3072889745235443,
0.3147517144680023,
0.8444274663925171,
-0.12963148951530457,
-0.27783578634262085,
0.17545564472675323,
0.028002658858895302,
-0.1318754404783249,
-0.4464135468006134,
0.7721976041793823,
0.09481111913919449,
-0.5930068492889404,
0.6328524351119995,
0.26426926255226135,
0.7188071012496948,
-0.7598924040794373,
0.06904744356870651,
-0.159845769405365,
0.17187431454658508,
-0.29568350315093994,
-0.7928828597068787,
0.06703894585371017,
-0.019515497609972954,
-0.16830669343471527,
-0.8295580148696899,
0.6750324368476868,
-0.6913657784461975,
-0.39361387491226196,
0.5269443392753601,
0.7249501943588257,
0.35629531741142273,
-0.07107627391815186,
-0.8538576364517212,
0.14993387460708618,
0.16249465942382812,
-0.7905369400978088,
0.522795557975769,
0.5917630791664124,
-0.269878625869751,
0.7839949131011963,
0.7854145169258118,
0.07549580186605453,
0.38288262486457825,
0.21730546653270721,
0.7271032333374023,
-0.598583459854126,
-0.09917113184928894,
-0.8013393878936768,
0.6589460372924805,
0.13873355090618134,
-0.34094151854515076,
1.080998182296753,
0.5260633826255798,
1.0548204183578491,
-0.2329576015472412,
0.3049243092536926,
0.25431880354881287,
0.03530700504779816,
-0.8495739102363586,
0.5947092175483704,
-0.7311398386955261,
0.3837951421737671,
0.16347207129001617,
-0.6952385902404785,
-0.278868168592453,
0.2528902590274811,
-0.2931579053401947,
-0.010680079460144043,
0.46612289547920227,
0.9888291954994202,
-0.05645662546157837,
-0.36369532346725464,
0.4014412462711334,
0.5024089217185974,
0.27755221724510193,
0.2340242713689804,
0.637984573841095,
0.15290062129497528,
0.5081129670143127,
-0.4243236482143402,
-0.1544080227613449,
-0.4849090576171875,
-0.6288694143295288,
-0.8785702586174011,
-0.47384968400001526,
-0.273272842168808,
0.07197964191436768,
-0.18788284063339233,
0.7767232060432434,
0.693846583366394,
-0.7030667066574097,
-0.5479200482368469,
0.10271181911230087,
0.2495238184928894,
-0.48884183168411255,
-0.22460319101810455,
0.33737653493881226,
-0.46990546584129333,
-1.0810481309890747,
0.9413862228393555,
0.36979520320892334,
-0.16697724163532257,
-0.3779100775718689,
0.106862872838974,
-0.2512756288051605,
-0.14628084003925323,
0.7332053184509277,
0.2879359722137451,
-0.6854864358901978,
0.33022579550743103,
-0.16269946098327637,
0.10135019570589066,
-0.006183611694723368,
1.1190301179885864,
-0.6304556727409363,
0.411835253238678,
0.5631479024887085,
0.33435550332069397,
0.30981603264808655,
-0.12977366149425507,
0.6418061852455139,
-1.0328490734100342,
0.5370336174964905,
0.22648335993289948,
0.6072500944137573,
0.02384427934885025,
-0.08653155714273453,
0.37382322549819946,
-0.061630334705114365,
-0.3093279004096985,
-0.9425466060638428,
0.42041096091270447,
-0.8861030340194702,
-0.5907006859779358,
1.477152943611145,
-0.10725615918636322,
-0.4056870639324188,
-0.29099133610725403,
-0.1119827851653099,
0.13598030805587769,
-0.3053250014781952,
0.6629916429519653,
0.8139278292655945,
-0.14520396292209625,
-0.09549729526042938,
-0.6713114380836487,
0.46750760078430176,
0.6294806599617004,
-0.36141881346702576,
0.13928961753845215,
0.2835853695869446,
0.12171680480241776,
0.4196404814720154,
0.40882858633995056,
-0.1460895538330078,
0.04855429381132126,
-0.30739349126815796,
0.350101113319397,
-0.3712223470211029,
-0.38007497787475586,
-0.5622684359550476,
0.4440873861312866,
0.27991268038749695,
0.11024167388677597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16364v1
|
Where Do We Go from Here? Multi-scale Allocentric Relational Inference from Natural Spatial Descriptions
| 2024-02-26T07:33:28 | 2024-02-26T07:33:28 |
Tzuf Paz-Argaman, Sayali Kulkarni, John Palowitch, Jason Baldridge, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
When communicating routes in natural language, the concept of {\em acquired
spatial knowledge} is crucial for geographic information retrieval (GIR) and in
spatial cognitive research. However, NLP navigation studies often overlook the
impact of such acquired knowledge on textual descriptions. Current navigation
studies concentrate on egocentric local descriptions (e.g., `it will be on your
right') that require reasoning over the agent's local perception. These
instructions are typically given as a sequence of steps, with each action-step
explicitly mentioning and being followed by a landmark that the agent can use
to verify they are on the right path (e.g., `turn right and then you will
see...'). In contrast, descriptions based on knowledge acquired through a map
provide a complete view of the environment and capture its overall structure.
These instructions (e.g., `it is south of Central Park and a block north of a
police station') are typically non-sequential, contain allocentric relations,
with multiple spatial relations and implicit actions, without any explicit
verification. This paper introduces the Rendezvous (RVS) task and dataset,
which includes 10,404 examples of English geospatial instructions for reaching
a target location using map-knowledge. Our analysis reveals that RVS exhibits a
richer use of spatial allocentric relations, and requires resolving more
spatial relations simultaneously compared to previous text-based navigation
benchmarks.
|
[
-0.6704980134963989,
-0.7552043199539185,
1.409376859664917,
0.26528629660606384,
0.1469956636428833,
-0.23953013122081757,
-0.29728561639785767,
-0.5909192562103271,
0.18595394492149353,
0.6466456651687622,
-0.7245493531227112,
-0.5136123299598694,
-0.4112631678581238,
-0.043252456933259964,
-0.08053159713745117,
0.7024069428443909,
-0.09943036735057831,
-0.1621684581041336,
-0.362724632024765,
-0.003971833270043135,
-0.2879193127155304,
-0.6890661120414734,
-0.46426329016685486,
-0.2968549430370331,
0.7233741879463196,
0.5782619118690491,
0.671864926815033,
0.5028401613235474,
0.4418005347251892,
0.34788966178894043,
-0.03558866307139397,
0.1533094197511673,
-0.3684772849082947,
-0.04903526231646538,
-0.3360759913921356,
-0.2691636383533478,
0.08909103274345398,
0.1517561376094818,
0.4980928897857666,
0.9882249236106873,
-0.09782186895608902,
-0.06468173861503601,
-0.3542000353336334,
0.6079661250114441,
-0.8680984377861023,
0.030390772968530655,
-0.36504244804382324,
-0.021635740995407104,
0.001764669199474156,
-0.3755407929420471,
-0.3796670436859131,
-0.42310184240341187,
0.6646707653999329,
-0.9405394792556763,
0.16695944964885712,
0.4724172353744507,
0.8314359188079834,
0.11312549561262131,
-0.7986395359039307,
-0.4450761675834656,
-1.1014244556427002,
0.8851341605186462,
-0.09902875125408173,
0.3311627209186554,
0.696403443813324,
0.5562828779220581,
-0.38140952587127686,
-0.7678084969520569,
-0.48762717843055725,
-0.35033291578292847,
-0.3927611708641052,
0.03446267917752266,
0.009328104555606842,
-0.010061264038085938,
0.1574709266424179,
-0.17835545539855957,
-0.4246474802494049,
-0.39854732155799866,
-0.5559894442558289,
0.10739476978778839,
0.6993936896324158,
-0.0008001388632692397,
0.18722890317440033,
-0.2523960769176483,
-0.8191666603088379,
0.035805728286504745,
-0.6156045794487,
0.10195349156856537,
0.014467894099652767,
0.4094044268131256,
-0.09157435595989227,
0.6023922562599182,
-0.0913718193769455,
0.8159289956092834,
0.02505861595273018,
0.06237039715051651,
-0.048061273992061615,
-0.6520678997039795,
0.07283336669206619,
-0.04243099316954613,
0.9848809242248535,
0.5381242036819458,
0.42815834283828735,
-0.4550441801548004,
0.024530751630663872,
-0.5123016834259033,
0.5287401080131531,
-0.17144069075584412,
-0.08165211975574493,
0.07124410569667816,
-0.2648911476135254,
0.3623978793621063,
-0.0637807622551918,
-0.8742550015449524,
-0.1759287714958191,
-0.6163029074668884,
0.3536829650402069,
-0.5851287245750427,
-0.22641396522521973,
0.0056016515009105206,
-0.11822360008955002,
0.4011138379573822,
0.15415583550930023,
-0.7961834073066711,
0.2847273349761963,
0.6123733520507812,
0.9243676662445068,
0.05295087397098541,
-0.7377442717552185,
-0.14984960854053497,
0.3204989731311798,
-0.23798078298568726,
1.1580801010131836,
-0.47367799282073975,
-0.338852196931839,
-0.04921627417206764,
0.019208237528800964,
-0.3653314411640167,
-0.14687296748161316,
0.36233559250831604,
-0.4056262671947479,
0.2001301795244217,
-0.608902633190155,
-0.08884964883327484,
-0.48882099986076355,
0.4185129404067993,
-0.5834888219833374,
1.084242582321167,
-0.12079457938671112,
-0.6099030375480652,
0.34389498829841614,
-0.7087172269821167,
-0.5738024711608887,
-0.19173572957515717,
-0.04836646839976311,
0.07736712694168091,
-0.07712405920028687,
0.4331199526786804,
0.20795099437236786,
-0.13380464911460876,
0.06625445187091827,
-0.1333504021167755,
-0.28493791818618774,
0.13259334862232208,
-0.01292745117098093,
0.5248429775238037,
0.10408985614776611,
-0.31160038709640503,
-0.009634404443204403,
-0.5401113629341125,
-0.05329803749918938,
0.07234260439872742,
-0.10289689153432846,
-0.58200603723526,
0.16424092650413513,
-0.10360094904899597,
0.20882271230220795,
0.3229667544364929,
-0.36426112055778503,
0.10646726191043854,
-0.16568706929683685,
0.22170107066631317,
0.43046510219573975,
0.4084267318248749,
1.3442409038543701,
-0.18338556587696075,
0.4079568684101105,
-0.2697638273239136,
0.4147488474845886,
-0.10582016408443451,
-0.819685161113739,
-0.2367030829191208,
-0.09875333309173584,
-0.27244701981544495,
0.5203971266746521,
-0.5211769938468933,
0.21339567005634308,
-0.5220586657524109,
-0.7727169990539551,
0.06322349607944489,
-0.5430524349212646,
0.0943344384431839,
0.39460062980651855,
0.6153814196586609,
0.19199980795383453,
-0.5507315993309021,
-0.5041127800941467,
-0.16008077561855316,
-0.2803417146205902,
-0.23618297278881073,
0.3962993919849396,
0.5700315237045288,
-0.048203304409980774,
0.9667149782180786,
-0.49228495359420776,
-0.2940385937690735,
-0.31635600328445435,
0.09733811765909195,
-0.0024258701596409082,
0.24901914596557617,
0.49099308252334595,
-0.8021087050437927,
-0.3993188440799713,
-0.03321013227105141,
-0.727509081363678,
0.33981001377105713,
-0.29600104689598083,
-0.7288534641265869,
-0.41459426283836365,
0.5300264954566956,
-0.9337567687034607,
0.3206952214241028,
0.18809114396572113,
-0.4757445752620697,
0.4464588165283203,
-0.37288227677345276,
0.4791567027568817,
-0.9050701260566711,
-0.0033874374348670244,
0.009594929404556751,
0.05640219897031784,
-0.5598616003990173,
0.18695133924484253,
-0.2656151354312897,
-0.07665169984102249,
-0.1313718557357788,
0.3919123709201813,
-0.75390625,
-0.48587387800216675,
0.27618542313575745,
0.7344472408294678,
0.1410999745130539,
0.4369232952594757,
0.23491059243679047,
0.5818886160850525,
0.6368222832679749,
-0.5811238884925842,
0.38478749990463257,
0.34661707282066345,
0.03726845234632492,
0.7685545682907104,
-0.16495782136917114,
-0.08317416906356812,
-0.44037970900535583,
0.4650447368621826,
-1.3263782262802124,
-0.03767143562436104,
0.07805156707763672,
-0.5486431121826172,
0.0572747103869915,
-0.3112380802631378,
-0.14372292160987854,
-0.296653687953949,
0.015799010172486305,
0.3513619005680084,
0.04333679378032684,
-0.6063789129257202,
1.072147250175476,
0.448236882686615,
0.07348411530256271,
-0.628462553024292,
-0.6656765341758728,
0.13404300808906555,
-0.19784285128116608,
-0.4930436611175537,
0.04827729985117912,
0.36775654554367065,
-0.3704242706298828,
-0.1012733057141304,
0.04255491495132446,
-0.45003175735473633,
-0.19109389185905457,
0.4915987551212311,
0.3161104619503021,
-0.1730528324842453,
-0.014321396127343178,
-0.48470833897590637,
0.007696520537137985,
0.40378323197364807,
-0.3263198435306549,
0.24597065150737762,
0.08085542172193527,
-0.260501891374588,
-0.33102232217788696,
0.6095427870750427,
0.7736079096794128,
-0.32919180393218994,
0.9210193157196045,
0.3670864999294281,
-0.3194275498390198,
0.1895119845867157,
-0.2934814393520355,
-0.23887035250663757,
-0.3880504071712494,
0.10195372253656387,
-0.5659300684928894,
-0.4613553285598755,
0.46238431334495544,
-0.3928104639053345,
0.16847118735313416,
0.1743391901254654,
-0.061383720487356186,
-0.2826964557170868,
0.5041074156761169,
0.5094422101974487,
0.1295347958803177,
0.18944579362869263,
-0.2616089880466461,
0.7916219234466553,
-0.7900454998016357,
-0.6903712153434753,
-0.7410898208618164,
-0.47654932737350464,
-0.6276822090148926,
-0.6707176566123962,
0.2531013488769531,
0.20495575666427612,
-0.363736093044281,
0.522379994392395,
-0.4965935945510864,
0.5750030875205994,
0.5684193968772888,
-0.12702912092208862,
0.220889151096344,
0.1078832820057869,
-0.3207351267337799,
-0.24772219359874725,
-0.830193281173706,
-0.3370199203491211,
1.119919776916504,
-0.07492264360189438,
0.6671311855316162,
0.07101172208786011,
0.6248367428779602,
-0.112228624522686,
0.3802037239074707,
-0.7824053764343262,
0.5818634033203125,
0.39853668212890625,
-0.582221269607544,
-0.48432984948158264,
-0.3285647928714752,
-1.1984877586364746,
0.34865254163742065,
-0.37297993898391724,
-0.8529013991355896,
0.14973340928554535,
-0.1723552644252777,
-0.4078783392906189,
0.4346579611301422,
-0.6613630056381226,
0.8736092448234558,
-0.2583673596382141,
-0.3577858507633209,
-0.0036518550477921963,
-0.9045901298522949,
0.23601941764354706,
0.35516586899757385,
0.6914351582527161,
-0.06506163626909256,
0.061582643538713455,
0.3789326846599579,
0.01549253799021244,
0.43964120745658875,
-0.29008397459983826,
0.13270746171474457,
0.37175270915031433,
0.17161743342876434,
0.30593544244766235,
-0.12090189754962921,
0.1677599847316742,
0.2603791058063507,
-0.1510993242263794,
-0.17239724099636078,
-0.5755215287208557,
0.9381693601608276,
-0.7422435283660889,
0.032856933772563934,
-0.3609783947467804,
-0.49496474862098694,
-0.20243605971336365,
-0.06857433170080185,
0.35638442635536194,
0.4056220054626465,
-0.10835423320531845,
-0.4490951597690582,
0.4992905855178833,
-0.18819071352481842,
0.48605674505233765,
0.42144662141799927,
-0.17937412858009338,
-0.22212480008602142,
0.5330422520637512,
-0.06204883009195328,
-0.021008387207984924,
0.7204822897911072,
-0.08129178732633591,
-1.0894238948822021,
-0.13076753914356232,
-0.25384628772735596,
0.4823862910270691,
-0.8032121062278748,
0.08974900096654892,
-0.5358362793922424,
0.028075462207198143,
-0.33244580030441284,
-0.5558028817176819,
-0.4867153465747833,
-0.34065312147140503,
0.08020903170108795,
-0.10024154186248779,
0.291402667760849,
1.059292197227478,
-0.23463864624500275,
0.42848458886146545,
-0.7216970324516296,
0.21941716969013214,
0.09039177745580673,
-0.10406522452831268,
0.10158870369195938,
-0.12745539844036102,
-0.2514927089214325,
-0.12534591555595398,
-0.25769227743148804,
-1.1203863620758057,
0.1716146469116211,
-0.005505773704499006,
0.5530467629432678,
0.293409526348114,
0.22618065774440765,
0.8668805956840515,
-0.8899173140525818,
0.8216536045074463,
0.13538409769535065,
-0.4404017925262451,
0.6802681088447571,
-0.22735853493213654,
0.18959808349609375,
0.3347820043563843,
0.7756625413894653,
-0.46249717473983765,
-0.37206733226776123,
-0.38015058636665344,
-0.99757319688797,
0.256119966506958,
0.054952725768089294,
-0.24474668502807617,
-0.19519807398319244,
0.7296634912490845,
-0.5097447037696838,
-0.10825135558843613,
-0.8615871071815491,
-0.27618446946144104,
0.07134991884231567,
-0.07171281427145004,
-0.2759305536746979,
-0.047257859259843826,
-0.4316791892051697,
0.0029597540851682425,
0.22411945462226868,
-0.09494040161371231,
0.5790914297103882,
0.407631516456604,
0.017964867874979973,
-0.0695301964879036,
0.27280786633491516,
0.3663179874420166,
1.0939751863479614,
0.04604572430253029,
0.3887946903705597,
-0.092147096991539,
-0.23380567133426666,
0.2217639833688736,
0.18424779176712036,
-0.11753050237894058,
0.11466034501791,
0.5530400276184082,
0.3630468249320984,
0.5133848190307617,
-0.41085562109947205,
0.684705913066864,
-0.10439997911453247,
-0.014254426583647728,
-0.5081011056900024,
-0.4762079417705536,
0.1009177565574646,
0.44097867608070374,
0.5812193751335144,
0.1897778958082199,
0.3595990538597107,
-0.3008936047554016,
0.23066172003746033,
0.5444702506065369,
-0.3669900596141815,
-0.14664429426193237,
0.7567635774612427,
-0.024877769872546196,
-0.04719298705458641,
0.7523708343505859,
-0.0893341675400734,
-0.4235633611679077,
0.2651096284389496,
0.3637891411781311,
0.5599497556686401,
-0.05793903023004532,
0.2475873827934265,
1.0685912370681763,
0.5231801271438599,
-0.13810749351978302,
0.07353445887565613,
-0.36642664670944214,
-0.48128020763397217,
-0.7470956444740295,
-0.6721590757369995,
-0.24594691395759583,
-0.4539874494075775,
-0.8402748107910156,
-0.10294915735721588,
-0.3574361205101013,
-0.32955288887023926,
-0.3309931755065918,
-0.27984973788261414,
-0.48103323578834534,
0.1695835143327713,
0.10703352093696594,
0.839640736579895,
-0.8802798390388489,
0.28128811717033386,
0.8989633321762085,
-0.2432512491941452,
-0.7949817180633545,
0.19913552701473236,
-0.020509004592895508,
-0.7674458622932434,
0.5472120046615601,
0.26682373881340027,
-0.25966203212738037,
-0.1412617415189743,
-0.6755585670471191,
-1.0044869184494019,
0.9714697003364563,
-0.1936940997838974,
-0.48965945839881897,
-0.4007030427455902,
0.12012771517038345,
0.3185195326805115,
-0.24990259110927582,
0.3320942521095276,
0.8119238018989563,
0.4984738826751709,
0.35276854038238525,
-0.8264728784561157,
0.24180465936660767,
0.30094075202941895,
0.032758768647909164,
0.3283693492412567,
-0.2327977418899536,
0.6175199151039124,
-0.8210113048553467,
-0.13580700755119324,
0.14377722144126892,
0.350523442029953,
0.3945503234863281,
0.26598966121673584,
0.38403138518333435,
0.7077924609184265,
0.6223957538604736,
-0.4752374589443207,
1.173985481262207,
-0.19724388420581818,
0.3954353928565979,
1.196237325668335,
-0.0935787558555603,
1.1641037464141846,
0.892733633518219,
-0.2499919831752777,
0.8640914559364319,
0.8449593782424927,
0.32843607664108276,
0.9232776165008545,
0.14932389557361603,
-0.4119270145893097,
-0.259636253118515,
0.05456084758043289,
-0.05372949317097664,
0.36948078870773315,
0.518479585647583,
0.053817473351955414,
-0.47319483757019043,
-0.01174435019493103,
-0.12167607992887497,
0.1559583693742752,
-0.2702239155769348,
0.8036883473396301,
-0.1085619181394577,
-0.9017419815063477,
0.4574716091156006,
-0.2868688702583313,
0.152439147233963,
-0.7454886436462402,
-0.10361208766698837,
-0.18122820556163788,
0.039365727454423904,
-0.10348764061927795,
-1.051605224609375,
0.30785417556762695,
-0.5020886659622192,
-0.08876589685678482,
-0.2698361575603485,
0.2557630240917206,
-0.4800456464290619,
0.0027288622222840786,
0.6162878274917603,
0.5586292147636414,
0.45340028405189514,
-0.26555511355400085,
-0.4665314257144928,
-0.30284422636032104,
-0.10323519259691238,
-0.10116436332464218,
0.057990435510873795,
0.9284698963165283,
0.020696695894002914,
0.778580367565155,
0.7128702998161316,
0.16800397634506226,
0.3681896924972534,
-0.21053926646709442,
0.5596005320549011,
-0.8291116952896118,
-0.6293665766716003,
-0.5630797147750854,
0.5485427975654602,
-0.013539670966565609,
-0.01180380117148161,
0.7161149382591248,
0.40618428587913513,
0.6234588027000427,
0.10524152219295502,
0.611189067363739,
-0.1295938491821289,
0.2873322665691376,
-0.44861075282096863,
0.3028825521469116,
-0.5867926478385925,
0.05849367752671242,
0.06028527021408081,
-1.0275624990463257,
-0.34273093938827515,
1.0383281707763672,
-0.5368473529815674,
-0.10605589300394058,
1.0563870668411255,
0.641956090927124,
-0.21656392514705658,
-0.22213177382946014,
0.06258423626422882,
0.025107121095061302,
0.012934346683323383,
0.8452118039131165,
1.0933506488800049,
-0.3930245637893677,
0.7756165266036987,
-0.09739653021097183,
-0.36090439558029175,
0.1517304927110672,
-0.5791755318641663,
-0.6750086545944214,
-0.5511435866355896,
-0.012200087308883667,
-0.35739997029304504,
-0.24148529767990112,
0.531008780002594,
0.8684428334236145,
-0.46289828419685364,
-0.30039864778518677,
-0.14129741489887238,
0.24799282848834991,
-0.20336288213729858,
-0.26784810423851013,
0.10922515392303467,
-0.4766075909137726,
-0.5424765944480896,
0.5139776468276978,
0.49155744910240173,
0.06269270926713943,
-0.2688414454460144,
-0.23232506215572357,
-0.5721573829650879,
-0.20002061128616333,
0.5344371795654297,
0.386929988861084,
-0.7989637851715088,
-0.10990964621305466,
0.20685547590255737,
-0.2876705825328827,
0.09588491171598434,
0.9488363265991211,
-0.5392329692840576,
0.3947800099849701,
0.13665302097797394,
0.3891357183456421,
0.6620863080024719,
-0.023886896669864655,
0.7085841298103333,
-0.8183431625366211,
0.2552306354045868,
-0.030900370329618454,
0.3166302442550659,
0.5683593153953552,
-0.32377251982688904,
0.5108869075775146,
0.18685433268547058,
-0.9433670043945312,
-0.13772545754909515,
0.17397823929786682,
-0.9231030941009521,
-0.17683380842208862,
1.2028430700302124,
-0.2501732409000397,
-0.485263854265213,
-0.33948683738708496,
-0.22265635430812836,
0.04213075339794159,
-0.19369783997535706,
0.6095650792121887,
0.4907376766204834,
-0.5422230958938599,
-0.21150526404380798,
-0.6988277435302734,
0.5040208101272583,
-0.05730259045958519,
-0.6807183027267456,
0.008632142096757889,
0.8476693034172058,
0.21671387553215027,
0.7456380128860474,
0.8125104904174805,
0.055056653916835785,
0.015528104268014431,
0.02652127481997013,
0.06773228198289871,
0.6355686187744141,
-0.649706244468689,
0.22309376299381256,
0.15754550695419312,
-0.03735698387026787,
-0.5831446647644043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16363v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16363v6
|
LLM Inference Unveiled: Survey and Roofline Model Insights
| 2024-02-26T07:33:05 | 2024-05-01T20:42:28 |
Zhihang Yuan, Yuzhang Shang, Yang Zhou, Zhen Dong, Zhe Zhou, Chenhao Xue, Bingzhe Wu, Zhikai Li, Qingyi Gu, Yong Jae Lee, Yan Yan, Beidi Chen, Guangyu Sun, Kurt Keutzer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The field of efficient Large Language Model (LLM) inference is rapidly
evolving, presenting a unique blend of opportunities and challenges. Although
the field has expanded and is vibrant, there hasn't been a concise framework
that analyzes the various methods of LLM Inference to provide a clear
understanding of this domain. Our survey stands out from traditional literature
reviews by not only summarizing the current state of research but also by
introducing a framework based on roofline model for systematic analysis of LLM
inference techniques. This framework identifies the bottlenecks when deploying
LLMs on hardware devices and provides a clear understanding of practical
problems, such as why LLMs are memory-bound, how much memory and computation
they need, and how to choose the right hardware. We systematically collate the
latest advancements in efficient LLM inference, covering crucial areas such as
model compression (e.g., Knowledge Distillation and Quantization), algorithm
improvements (e.g., Early Exit and Mixture-of-Expert), and both hardware and
system-level enhancements. Our survey stands out by analyzing these methods
with roofline model, helping us understand their impact on memory access and
computation. This distinctive approach not only showcases the current research
landscape but also delivers valuable insights for practical implementation,
positioning our work as an indispensable resource for researchers new to the
field as well as for those seeking to deepen their understanding of efficient
LLM deployment. The analyze tool, LLM-Viewer, is open-sourced.
|
[
-0.41936150193214417,
-0.8512996435165405,
0.7023722529411316,
0.2797117829322815,
0.05168099328875542,
0.11088725179433823,
-0.15520277619361877,
-0.5062277913093567,
-0.2334192991256714,
0.5442623496055603,
-0.6132389307022095,
-0.6736084222793579,
-0.5254272818565369,
-0.27368518710136414,
-0.4605044424533844,
0.6233662366867065,
0.1924772560596466,
0.12447936832904816,
-0.4232785105705261,
0.09206101298332214,
-0.14494949579238892,
-0.22232870757579803,
-0.32283705472946167,
-0.23466818034648895,
0.39938271045684814,
0.3095504343509674,
0.3988838195800781,
0.8213964700698853,
0.49896684288978577,
0.2261229008436203,
-0.32064908742904663,
0.10319819301366806,
-0.35060611367225647,
-0.03095950558781624,
0.24674248695373535,
-0.6114225387573242,
-0.5985845923423767,
-0.06942321360111237,
0.6970775127410889,
0.9981013536453247,
-0.12748119235038757,
0.4459814429283142,
0.22917389869689941,
0.6420102119445801,
-0.9292482137680054,
-0.03885729983448982,
-0.820096492767334,
-0.10125629603862762,
-0.4405139088630676,
-0.24321997165679932,
-0.5263611674308777,
-0.2093397080898285,
0.036212023347616196,
-0.4818704128265381,
0.24057109653949738,
0.19716407358646393,
0.6249145269393921,
0.47442564368247986,
-0.3682160973548889,
-0.10794906318187714,
-0.586778461933136,
0.8583118319511414,
-0.841413140296936,
0.5271413922309875,
-0.011633974500000477,
0.5159422159194946,
-0.33675307035446167,
-0.742218554019928,
-0.21066322922706604,
-0.2271565943956375,
0.3696078658103943,
0.15575715899467468,
-0.3232976198196411,
0.22590427100658417,
0.16266080737113953,
0.3726300597190857,
-0.37426215410232544,
0.47829562425613403,
-0.04972967505455017,
-0.025890659540891647,
0.31918948888778687,
0.17239001393318176,
0.13695374131202698,
-0.18299612402915955,
-0.5357540845870972,
0.18942765891551971,
-1.0265166759490967,
-0.09343293309211731,
0.39938610792160034,
0.07058669626712799,
-0.07847873866558075,
0.5636677742004395,
-0.1335211843252182,
0.8563404083251953,
-0.263943076133728,
-0.2369394749403,
-0.001472064875997603,
-0.21291550993919373,
-0.27570950984954834,
-0.13751330971717834,
0.7230114936828613,
0.5710731744766235,
-0.010503224097192287,
-0.17147782444953918,
-0.26985734701156616,
-0.16145718097686768,
-0.032829031348228455,
-0.810276210308075,
-0.17428097128868103,
0.28029006719589233,
-0.5614689588546753,
-0.2354479283094406,
-0.18122407793998718,
-0.9193673133850098,
-0.6774632334709167,
-0.1221432089805603,
-0.07849643379449844,
-0.2309865951538086,
-0.34158939123153687,
0.05038158968091011,
-0.28208690881729126,
0.47220858931541443,
0.4655943512916565,
-0.5636963844299316,
0.2761571705341339,
0.9642113447189331,
0.7868238091468811,
-0.3608923852443695,
-0.0680570974946022,
-0.3798268735408783,
-0.010671484284102917,
-0.22683611512184143,
1.0010907649993896,
-0.4033803343772888,
-0.09224633872509003,
-0.04205987602472305,
-0.22787019610404968,
-0.07194988429546356,
-0.7219381332397461,
0.45615530014038086,
-0.6344469785690308,
-0.14052286744117737,
-0.05854593962430954,
-0.6243599653244019,
-0.04228372126817703,
0.19288191199302673,
-0.5899630188941956,
1.080277681350708,
-0.10313399881124496,
-1.0054042339324951,
0.1338651478290558,
-0.43812355399131775,
0.056632332503795624,
0.08637917041778564,
-0.06161634996533394,
-0.314757764339447,
0.4395975172519684,
0.28985366225242615,
0.541378378868103,
-0.7478769421577454,
0.2765271067619324,
-0.6445127725601196,
-0.26034030318260193,
0.19493083655834198,
-0.46143755316734314,
0.9686390161514282,
0.44020500779151917,
-0.34974923729896545,
0.11942149698734283,
-0.7930492758750916,
-0.06774821132421494,
-0.045265525579452515,
-0.3058016002178192,
-0.2669944167137146,
0.40847906470298767,
-0.006452672183513641,
-0.2561596930027008,
0.4229598939418793,
-0.4721572995185852,
0.09595290571451187,
-0.16547639667987823,
0.31067031621932983,
0.6105111241340637,
-0.09343975782394409,
0.49661535024642944,
0.018318990245461464,
0.7741903066635132,
-0.13947391510009766,
0.22552838921546936,
-0.15332159399986267,
-0.2921009361743927,
-0.3920583724975586,
-0.3802221417427063,
0.20643334090709686,
0.726859450340271,
-0.4231976568698883,
0.08626656234264374,
-0.1908222883939743,
-0.5515187978744507,
-0.5192493796348572,
0.09229237586259842,
0.39913445711135864,
0.5160471200942993,
0.10929210484027863,
0.37364333868026733,
-0.6190399527549744,
-1.0069348812103271,
-0.2962965965270996,
-0.23686814308166504,
-0.12358717620372772,
0.38274526596069336,
0.25262001156806946,
-0.0692608579993248,
0.9727357625961304,
-0.5930792689323425,
0.2344648838043213,
-0.5857375264167786,
-0.03678356483578682,
0.24585454165935516,
0.18442034721374512,
0.5950647592544556,
-0.5157459378242493,
-0.29023656249046326,
-0.06834843754768372,
-0.7501575946807861,
-0.5767158269882202,
-0.02480837143957615,
0.005225783679634333,
0.0049621290527284145,
0.7223459482192993,
-0.5023869276046753,
0.22357109189033508,
0.9288676977157593,
-0.12145181745290756,
0.797938883304596,
0.07565981149673462,
-0.08303287625312805,
-0.8631499409675598,
-0.006162220146507025,
0.008515015244483948,
-0.09875597059726715,
-0.6706854104995728,
0.259661465883255,
0.155843585729599,
0.209598571062088,
-0.27773064374923706,
0.42575034499168396,
-0.9173404574394226,
-0.34198692440986633,
-0.37495455145835876,
0.2770597040653229,
-0.08873321115970612,
0.06568373739719391,
-0.18103301525115967,
0.9988350868225098,
0.6240297555923462,
-0.4979185163974762,
0.12172792851924896,
-0.11661805957555771,
-0.6186025142669678,
0.26449358463287354,
-0.533761203289032,
-0.11049799621105194,
-0.04306231439113617,
0.24859952926635742,
-1.1235612630844116,
-0.13979093730449677,
0.09507156908512115,
-0.33551856875419617,
0.17824338376522064,
-0.22422465682029724,
-0.4969100058078766,
-0.3001798391342163,
-0.336360901594162,
0.3948501646518707,
0.5424624085426331,
-0.6118378043174744,
0.6940982937812805,
0.5901804566383362,
0.022025540471076965,
-0.842146098613739,
-0.659454345703125,
0.2605249583721161,
-0.4409390985965729,
-0.7457186579704285,
0.2546079456806183,
-0.13686373829841614,
-0.676288366317749,
-0.226226806640625,
-0.1361866295337677,
-0.1097402349114418,
0.4609966278076172,
0.22451584041118622,
0.28228759765625,
-0.587938666343689,
-0.057350002229213715,
0.07573311030864716,
0.11402471363544464,
0.4303795397281647,
-0.187481090426445,
0.390146940946579,
-0.24451260268688202,
-0.2701984941959381,
-0.21568694710731506,
0.09797976166009903,
0.5714508295059204,
-0.13177624344825745,
0.6627892255783081,
0.323102205991745,
-0.11391576379537582,
-0.5112101435661316,
-0.9175394177436829,
0.011296724900603294,
-0.42797088623046875,
0.3983996510505676,
-0.4555149972438812,
-0.9178851842880249,
0.6947304010391235,
-0.6430433392524719,
0.21890965104103088,
0.434678316116333,
0.33447352051734924,
-0.13570387661457062,
0.820793628692627,
0.8024653196334839,
0.07685953378677368,
0.3553801476955414,
-0.1608797013759613,
-0.0036319345235824585,
-1.1251662969589233,
-0.23144707083702087,
-0.5812522172927856,
-0.056531570851802826,
-0.37970876693725586,
-0.6023989915847778,
0.2700115144252777,
0.3958806097507477,
0.11681268364191055,
0.11951906979084015,
-0.271441251039505,
0.38038161396980286,
0.2449546754360199,
0.029683370143175125,
0.49181637167930603,
-0.17712296545505524,
-0.24708347022533417,
0.06760737299919128,
-0.7749188542366028,
-0.5439251065254211,
1.133594274520874,
0.550347626209259,
0.6725687384605408,
0.039723943918943405,
0.4776381552219391,
0.06326960027217865,
0.5010815858840942,
-0.8382942080497742,
0.7853237986564636,
0.00656277546659112,
-0.6978400349617004,
-0.20743055641651154,
-0.5507369637489319,
-0.7809596657752991,
0.17743651568889618,
0.16108618676662445,
-0.76494961977005,
0.08285848051309586,
0.2777683138847351,
-0.21383926272392273,
0.5322684049606323,
-0.48302197456359863,
0.6700523495674133,
-0.3131418824195862,
-0.3635667860507965,
-0.2554153800010681,
-0.4710116982460022,
0.8324097394943237,
-0.20162372291088104,
0.31427809596061707,
-0.3534460961818695,
-0.37072333693504333,
0.5961631536483765,
-0.380700021982193,
0.8536068201065063,
-0.4432845115661621,
-0.3552229404449463,
0.3796001374721527,
-0.1809224933385849,
0.4728861451148987,
-0.19154322147369385,
-0.35698366165161133,
0.26761168241500854,
0.06997193396091461,
-0.30952778458595276,
-0.48751410841941833,
0.5864765048027039,
-0.603011965751648,
-0.6177802681922913,
-0.090509332716465,
-0.7133380770683289,
-0.35868382453918457,
-0.04301800578832626,
0.20713233947753906,
0.23920698463916779,
-0.369620680809021,
0.18414406478405,
0.820618748664856,
-0.5726397633552551,
0.40642642974853516,
0.5056440830230713,
-0.5208784341812134,
-0.3028130531311035,
0.5163248181343079,
0.001268418156541884,
0.36874404549598694,
0.4678443372249603,
0.1432129144668579,
-0.2794296145439148,
-1.1381467580795288,
-0.4318106770515442,
0.3045123517513275,
-0.6904302835464478,
-0.12039576470851898,
-0.6107639074325562,
-0.11929105222225189,
-0.13667809963226318,
0.17100593447685242,
-0.4321180284023285,
-0.4039756655693054,
-0.11650295555591583,
-0.050525594502687454,
0.31005558371543884,
0.7967143058776855,
0.10110972821712494,
0.7696235179901123,
-0.49594220519065857,
0.18213222920894623,
-0.10014277696609497,
0.12852828204631805,
0.12988944351673126,
-0.4588314890861511,
-0.32309794425964355,
-0.08944477885961533,
-0.16467484831809998,
-0.8621000051498413,
0.195653036236763,
0.07083924114704132,
0.7420864701271057,
0.5101144909858704,
0.057122278958559036,
0.809317946434021,
-0.4510021209716797,
0.6707130670547485,
0.06440742313861847,
-0.7217119336128235,
0.26193490624427795,
-0.550480842590332,
0.4161686897277832,
0.5126228332519531,
0.25577449798583984,
-0.10576917976140976,
-0.33575722575187683,
-0.2981283664703369,
-0.9020442962646484,
0.337342232465744,
-0.1827436238527298,
-0.21080514788627625,
0.07192150503396988,
0.35745590925216675,
0.06372930854558945,
0.27752870321273804,
-0.48662590980529785,
-0.3409370481967926,
0.20486418902873993,
-0.05263674259185791,
0.14603739976882935,
-0.399416446685791,
0.07557827234268188,
-0.20095033943653107,
0.46840447187423706,
-0.20505984127521515,
0.30501288175582886,
-0.05947037786245346,
-0.3054056465625763,
0.1744016706943512,
0.20533771812915802,
0.39532721042633057,
0.8641514778137207,
-0.4294610619544983,
0.30899637937545776,
0.3242316246032715,
-0.37441959977149963,
-0.2645629048347473,
0.13664712011814117,
-0.22036495804786682,
-0.08627139031887054,
0.32349714636802673,
0.7257332801818848,
0.3318924903869629,
-0.760478138923645,
0.3791881203651428,
0.0029202618170529604,
-0.3688485324382782,
-0.47391366958618164,
-0.0427263118326664,
0.4345773160457611,
0.5029784440994263,
0.545293927192688,
-0.030466655269265175,
0.2925177216529846,
-0.27548032999038696,
0.07105860114097595,
0.7721065282821655,
-0.15762846171855927,
-0.18853062391281128,
0.7664668560028076,
0.051714010536670685,
-0.01241481862962246,
0.5494998693466187,
0.09814397990703583,
-0.3860497772693634,
0.6564933061599731,
0.4294041097164154,
1.0097739696502686,
-0.059236425906419754,
0.03327374905347824,
0.17888391017913818,
0.35451510548591614,
-0.12259434163570404,
0.11579243838787079,
-0.2805679440498352,
-0.7134178876876831,
-0.7806033492088318,
-0.8392165303230286,
-0.5471969842910767,
0.13850869238376617,
-0.6135536432266235,
0.0028432621620595455,
-0.35918405652046204,
-0.11581315845251083,
-0.1215941458940506,
-0.033151526004076004,
-0.4251025319099426,
-0.10844109207391739,
0.3122163414955139,
1.4751583337783813,
-0.6598132848739624,
0.8543742299079895,
0.3814917206764221,
0.17129802703857422,
-0.6233311891555786,
0.03577074036002159,
0.26849037408828735,
-0.8715978860855103,
0.6103125810623169,
0.2684834599494934,
-0.5300758481025696,
0.08230341970920563,
-0.6104792356491089,
-0.8166319131851196,
1.210042953491211,
0.5144974589347839,
-0.7100502252578735,
-0.10752217471599579,
0.12024088203907013,
0.35264548659324646,
-0.5126331448554993,
0.506614625453949,
0.6266511678695679,
0.5726748704910278,
0.10262324661016464,
-0.6529386639595032,
0.04940953105688095,
-0.21045514941215515,
-0.019140759482979774,
0.16406261920928955,
-0.45166411995887756,
0.4409008026123047,
-0.2462698519229889,
-0.22273261845111847,
0.3359634280204773,
0.7945337295532227,
0.4958485960960388,
0.6106003522872925,
0.6348119974136353,
0.47750455141067505,
0.7591605186462402,
-0.0629439502954483,
1.0555269718170166,
-0.6002086400985718,
-0.03798026591539383,
1.0781036615371704,
-0.21296906471252441,
1.0958003997802734,
0.6138148903846741,
-0.19475096464157104,
0.5043895840644836,
0.6514933109283447,
-0.024042904376983643,
0.21839042007923126,
0.3488229811191559,
-0.38368290662765503,
-0.36463379859924316,
-0.13085944950580597,
-0.14368918538093567,
0.5205370187759399,
0.4957142472267151,
-0.2895294427871704,
-0.3137724995613098,
-0.1370663344860077,
0.12394054234027863,
-0.20487765967845917,
-0.345593124628067,
0.585655689239502,
0.2484925240278244,
-0.7423328161239624,
0.500074028968811,
-0.027419593185186386,
0.785978376865387,
-0.6169703602790833,
0.20038345456123352,
-0.1551671028137207,
0.3392997682094574,
-0.31573909521102905,
-0.6179770231246948,
0.25730130076408386,
0.19149212539196014,
-0.12907621264457703,
-0.28531140089035034,
0.4991249442100525,
-0.05459980294108391,
-0.3393403887748718,
0.5474768877029419,
0.695024311542511,
0.45309099555015564,
-0.28198641538619995,
-0.6172901391983032,
0.25170987844467163,
0.012794211506843567,
-0.4896622598171234,
0.46592992544174194,
0.4421845078468323,
0.05314130336046219,
0.8438452482223511,
0.6266928911209106,
0.201463982462883,
0.34982866048812866,
0.18697968125343323,
0.8685423135757446,
-0.6049177646636963,
-0.02910795249044895,
-0.8532787561416626,
0.6722003221511841,
-0.10915740579366684,
-0.20055517554283142,
0.9760884046554565,
0.7755863666534424,
0.36162105202674866,
0.02025504969060421,
0.7192032933235168,
0.21273772418498993,
0.46099138259887695,
-0.6075737476348877,
0.6144129633903503,
-0.6151561737060547,
0.8736593127250671,
-0.13424941897392273,
-0.9933041334152222,
-0.3266621232032776,
0.1463288962841034,
-0.4183817505836487,
-0.1559818983078003,
0.6689472198486328,
1.008988618850708,
-0.09805398434400558,
-0.12802773714065552,
0.26670074462890625,
0.3743396997451782,
0.05183469131588936,
0.4240018427371979,
1.0441328287124634,
-0.14350208640098572,
0.6924384832382202,
-0.15424413979053497,
-0.4932141900062561,
-0.15449920296669006,
-1.2318994998931885,
-0.8346561193466187,
-0.26151132583618164,
-0.3077316880226135,
-0.10538164526224136,
0.1759643256664276,
0.5287250280380249,
0.5862675905227661,
-0.6257174611091614,
-0.6234274506568909,
-0.43794259428977966,
0.15340960025787354,
-0.14250649511814117,
-0.25155210494995117,
0.2672272026538849,
-0.24146656692028046,
-0.5755779147148132,
0.7406145930290222,
0.33308640122413635,
-0.30951330065727234,
-0.43706026673316956,
-0.1488921344280243,
-0.0237506665289402,
0.1014207974076271,
0.6082257032394409,
0.22802190482616425,
-0.8517549633979797,
0.12453953921794891,
0.25808829069137573,
0.026384377852082253,
0.0751124769449234,
0.6820006370544434,
-0.7598207592964172,
0.042656052857637405,
0.6752299070358276,
0.8942865133285522,
0.5637660026550293,
-0.019096557050943375,
0.6421283483505249,
-0.4526405334472656,
-0.16777923703193665,
-0.07523097842931747,
0.3277612328529358,
0.27038007974624634,
-0.20305690169334412,
0.4744720458984375,
0.13082581758499146,
-0.6437995433807373,
-1.0862199068069458,
0.4199087619781494,
-1.053794503211975,
-0.529128909111023,
1.1758975982666016,
-0.11177030950784683,
-0.33668947219848633,
-0.09662959724664688,
0.04908018559217453,
0.11070466041564941,
-0.1636972427368164,
0.501633882522583,
0.42508649826049805,
-0.16901347041130066,
-0.6792336106300354,
-0.8892107009887695,
0.3028222918510437,
0.40842247009277344,
-0.9092892408370972,
0.38366398215293884,
0.5912108421325684,
0.29593387246131897,
-0.19436541199684143,
0.3494080603122711,
0.055295832455158234,
0.0011544495355337858,
0.12701471149921417,
0.12097346782684326,
-0.09667303413152695,
-0.3721769452095032,
-0.4079740643501282,
0.4832220673561096,
0.28560012578964233,
-0.09455971419811249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16361v1
|
Layer-wise Regularized Dropout for Neural Language Models
| 2024-02-26T07:31:35 | 2024-02-26T07:31:35 |
Shiwen Ni, Min Yang, Ruifeng Xu, Chengming Li, Xiping Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Among the various pre-trained neural language models that are popular today,
dropout is already an indispensable regularization technique. To solve the
inconsistency between training and inference caused by the randomness of
dropout, some studies use consistency training to regularize dropout at the
output layer. In this paper, we propose a novel Layer-wise Regularized Dropout
(LR-Drop), which is specially designed for Transformer-based Language models.
Specifically, LR-Drop layer-wise regularizes each Transformer layer using the
consistency training strategy. Each training sample passes through the two
siamese sub-models sampled by dropout, and then LR-Drop forces the hidden
states, multi-head attention matrices, and output distribution of the two
siamese sub-models to be consistent. The proposed LR-Drop can be regarded as a
"self-distillation" framework, in which each sub-model generated by dropout is
the other's "teacher" model and "student" model. Through extensive experiments
on 8 natural language understanding datasets, 6 neural machine translation
datasets, and 1 abstractive summarization dataset (a total of 15 datasets), we
show that LR-Drop achieves superior performances, including state-of-the-art
results.
|
[
-0.36965665221214294,
-0.5566646456718445,
0.19368872046470642,
0.09564179182052612,
-0.12853111326694489,
-0.028968358412384987,
-0.49785810708999634,
-0.04257754981517792,
0.1896694153547287,
0.40414875745773315,
-0.7262158989906311,
-0.34708693623542786,
-0.5172460079193115,
0.1342366635799408,
-0.573676347732544,
1.2103691101074219,
-0.1316784769296646,
-0.020758215337991714,
-0.09832191467285156,
0.11452577263116837,
-0.7291481494903564,
-0.178009033203125,
-0.6006823182106018,
-0.7001490592956543,
0.748214840888977,
0.346573144197464,
0.5427578091621399,
0.8876073956489563,
0.5693124532699585,
0.26683831214904785,
-0.20233359932899475,
-0.10007333010435104,
-0.3903200924396515,
-0.15416325628757477,
0.02530333399772644,
-0.4847453236579895,
-0.09164302051067352,
0.23782828450202942,
0.8104413747787476,
0.7901026010513306,
-0.4741053581237793,
-0.09663893282413483,
0.20651650428771973,
0.5526890158653259,
-0.6573688387870789,
-0.022364430129528046,
-0.4049091339111328,
0.40543344616889954,
-0.08106327801942825,
0.3086085021495819,
-0.4127947688102722,
-0.2641267478466034,
0.06630496680736542,
-0.4417091906070709,
0.3730827569961548,
-0.4087804853916168,
0.9451825618743896,
0.3696942627429962,
0.07409437000751495,
0.3644309341907501,
-0.9322797656059265,
0.853969156742096,
-0.9881525635719299,
0.6082993149757385,
0.5137925744056702,
0.4269605278968811,
0.15046757459640503,
-0.8031196594238281,
-0.6207379102706909,
-0.28996211290359497,
-0.16555166244506836,
0.20574823021888733,
0.22371502220630646,
0.08847226947546005,
-0.04123372212052345,
0.4206198453903198,
-0.13877224922180176,
0.1326206922531128,
-0.399672269821167,
-0.11678938567638397,
0.228962242603302,
-0.10408180207014084,
0.30372604727745056,
0.029901957139372826,
-0.28663066029548645,
-0.05227058753371239,
-0.6154828071594238,
0.05293235182762146,
0.2138517200946808,
0.36619365215301514,
-0.10041359812021255,
0.08620436489582062,
-0.22433771193027496,
0.40505334734916687,
0.3137734830379486,
-0.2092297226190567,
0.024581419304013252,
-0.1942232996225357,
-0.2390027940273285,
-0.053035736083984375,
0.8304885029792786,
0.31476902961730957,
0.4090096652507782,
-0.28681740164756775,
-0.28077366948127747,
-0.2735304534435272,
0.10008713603019714,
-0.9781574010848999,
-0.6959218382835388,
0.137333944439888,
-0.5572764873504639,
-0.3803793787956238,
-0.10535942763090134,
-0.5021485090255737,
-0.11337121576070786,
-0.20126822590827942,
0.31586959958076477,
-0.2381959855556488,
-0.41147562861442566,
0.15351027250289917,
0.14703360199928284,
0.006058712024241686,
0.12085653096437454,
-0.8506832718849182,
0.5130284428596497,
0.3483302593231201,
0.7916260957717896,
-0.5005919933319092,
-0.40415382385253906,
-0.5244309902191162,
0.09474659711122513,
-0.2874484360218048,
0.26822957396507263,
-0.3794940710067749,
0.08743865042924881,
-0.03884312883019447,
-0.14408768713474274,
-0.4322807490825653,
-0.5905030965805054,
0.42519235610961914,
-0.42539599537849426,
0.3817262053489685,
0.09590798616409302,
-0.5256680250167847,
-0.24676163494586945,
0.1441645324230194,
-0.6015983819961548,
1.0391521453857422,
-0.28919172286987305,
-0.7680282592773438,
0.09281417727470398,
-0.32524359226226807,
-0.49069201946258545,
0.03544745594263077,
-0.29531043767929077,
-0.5985639095306396,
0.19501712918281555,
0.16485148668289185,
0.43629270792007446,
-0.2326766550540924,
0.7165626287460327,
0.001470352173782885,
-0.36910831928253174,
-0.02862796001136303,
-0.5060360431671143,
0.6802859902381897,
0.21092963218688965,
-0.38643497228622437,
-0.3147687613964081,
-0.9914934635162354,
0.223850280046463,
0.18000474572181702,
-0.37891775369644165,
-0.3968835175037384,
-0.06779643893241882,
0.332723468542099,
0.34597623348236084,
-0.0029794585425406694,
-0.6896952390670776,
0.06858937442302704,
-0.26120302081108093,
0.7732039093971252,
0.5656722187995911,
-0.06957922130823135,
0.5874261260032654,
-0.04183335602283478,
0.33481672406196594,
0.47216472029685974,
0.16062277555465698,
-0.06893441081047058,
-0.24012809991836548,
-0.9356050491333008,
-0.5051473379135132,
0.7005066871643066,
0.4950312376022339,
-0.5398665070533752,
0.6273128390312195,
-0.26347649097442627,
-0.2526370882987976,
-0.5088371634483337,
0.07240777462720871,
0.7013314962387085,
0.7637932300567627,
0.3273189663887024,
-0.3068457245826721,
-0.3617627024650574,
-1.091553807258606,
-0.07125966250896454,
0.24436774849891663,
-0.0008701894548721611,
-0.0007574030896648765,
0.24554704129695892,
-0.19334794580936432,
1.3544389009475708,
-0.3023940920829773,
-0.6202553510665894,
-0.4409416913986206,
-0.13109879195690155,
0.19404394924640656,
0.8776480555534363,
0.40708625316619873,
-0.4794178605079651,
-0.5053051114082336,
-0.0313718356192112,
-0.538253128528595,
-0.011672083288431168,
-0.10189266502857208,
-0.15341928601264954,
-0.004446479957550764,
0.31813564896583557,
-0.49079832434654236,
0.4204840064048767,
0.4748653471469879,
0.3271738588809967,
0.15769051015377045,
-0.20886355638504028,
-0.3034608066082001,
-1.3846323490142822,
0.0915999785065651,
0.124921515583992,
-0.24035793542861938,
-1.071102499961853,
-0.2866557538509369,
0.3349932134151459,
0.15599501132965088,
-0.38919663429260254,
0.3231329619884491,
-0.4443119168281555,
0.40240973234176636,
0.016391286626458168,
0.199946328997612,
0.36066052317619324,
0.4696708023548126,
0.2458430528640747,
0.3226180970668793,
0.4467090964317322,
-0.3977340757846832,
-0.09722685068845749,
0.12521861493587494,
-0.1719123274087906,
0.16042475402355194,
-0.8277105093002319,
0.3383576273918152,
-0.2456539422273636,
0.3871456980705261,
-0.91927170753479,
-0.09015249460935593,
0.1837283819913864,
0.06411516666412354,
0.39977553486824036,
-0.2892034649848938,
-0.2846756875514984,
-0.09049529582262039,
-0.26768791675567627,
0.3566819131374359,
0.32037025690078735,
-0.5830804705619812,
0.6917260885238647,
0.22907251119613647,
0.07517805695533752,
-0.8118031024932861,
-1.2045024633407593,
-0.03647593781352043,
-0.09720887988805771,
-0.34332719445228577,
0.26759546995162964,
-0.2668984830379486,
0.24555310606956482,
-0.06164216622710228,
-0.3149997293949127,
-0.47168320417404175,
-0.024662677198648453,
-0.12721724808216095,
0.1753806471824646,
-0.2607709765434265,
-0.09899599850177765,
0.2595124840736389,
-0.0892067551612854,
0.0062305014580488205,
-0.2616024911403656,
0.5433364510536194,
0.056488171219825745,
-0.21877793967723846,
-1.054125189781189,
0.31512901186943054,
0.12956203520298004,
-0.2733422517776489,
0.9332169890403748,
0.549547553062439,
-0.4805438816547394,
-0.2520412802696228,
-0.7358954548835754,
-0.6422833800315857,
-0.46137088537216187,
0.5552474856376648,
-0.5299606919288635,
-0.6907186508178711,
0.8339927196502686,
0.24902863800525665,
0.0632711723446846,
0.2886951267719269,
0.19123022258281708,
-0.015427906066179276,
0.8296118378639221,
0.8757596611976624,
-0.338329553604126,
0.6020817160606384,
-0.7041527032852173,
0.5863246321678162,
-0.734210193157196,
-0.29261142015457153,
-0.28089138865470886,
-0.353730171918869,
-0.4256800711154938,
-0.042435597628355026,
-0.08164116740226746,
0.37642744183540344,
0.07785724848508835,
0.23289614915847778,
-0.4908904433250427,
0.9574524164199829,
0.5361169576644897,
-0.07246527820825577,
0.35319557785987854,
0.08047322928905487,
-0.3921568989753723,
-0.36226075887680054,
-0.7657334208488464,
0.02427375316619873,
0.4688754379749298,
0.39627182483673096,
0.7707824110984802,
-0.1650840789079666,
1.094704508781433,
-0.021225713193416595,
0.1689556986093521,
-0.5960104465484619,
0.2975606322288513,
-0.19623307883739471,
-0.23306332528591156,
-0.24106968939304352,
-0.6992727518081665,
-0.6749757528305054,
0.14586129784584045,
0.13217982649803162,
-0.5318194031715393,
0.3626590073108673,
0.14740824699401855,
-0.34491869807243347,
0.3293645977973938,
-0.6184659600257874,
0.898352861404419,
0.09399610757827759,
0.00791825819760561,
0.11186531186103821,
-0.9291287660598755,
0.3904472589492798,
-0.05020231008529663,
0.12418405711650848,
-0.07305676490068436,
0.1328412890434265,
0.45981165766716003,
-0.510069727897644,
0.8502545356750488,
-0.264203816652298,
-0.294294148683548,
0.28007057309150696,
0.44173088669776917,
0.6558875441551208,
0.04224886745214462,
0.1305345594882965,
0.43312326073646545,
-0.17300772666931152,
-0.05134456604719162,
-0.896643877029419,
0.6532751321792603,
-0.963807225227356,
-0.15756860375404358,
-0.11344693601131439,
-0.638074517250061,
0.027348894625902176,
0.3972669839859009,
0.42286139726638794,
0.56377112865448,
0.20071633160114288,
0.3523859977722168,
0.540826678276062,
0.16984963417053223,
0.790022611618042,
0.36529967188835144,
-0.20995181798934937,
-0.6794537901878357,
1.1216555833816528,
0.43265020847320557,
0.5402911901473999,
0.3184485137462616,
0.5727968811988831,
-0.471701443195343,
-0.7042672038078308,
-0.38621193170547485,
0.1774551272392273,
-0.6980735063552856,
-0.15866675972938538,
-0.6602761149406433,
-0.8265672922134399,
-0.25829264521598816,
0.15031972527503967,
-0.7372561097145081,
-0.6309002637863159,
-0.07310862839221954,
-0.010697255842387676,
0.07899203151464462,
0.7404499053955078,
-0.01697724312543869,
0.2718558609485626,
-0.7614033818244934,
0.20229585468769073,
0.25398772954940796,
0.5678998231887817,
0.0632699653506279,
-0.9273402094841003,
-0.4520544707775116,
0.006430414039641619,
-0.0027210204862058163,
-0.4957783818244934,
0.3388616144657135,
0.6363730430603027,
0.6233223676681519,
0.4557105600833893,
0.08856745064258575,
0.5696336030960083,
-0.6285963654518127,
0.5359252691268921,
0.442058801651001,
-0.9016711711883545,
0.6165779829025269,
-0.4522508680820465,
0.39535975456237793,
0.6287398934364319,
-0.004091279115527868,
-0.7475745677947998,
-0.6802991628646851,
-0.41824349761009216,
-1.0042736530303955,
0.7977526187896729,
0.5391948819160461,
0.11166412383317947,
-0.14188943803310394,
0.49471715092658997,
0.01695719175040722,
0.26430025696754456,
-0.985886812210083,
-0.6365450620651245,
-0.3033887445926666,
-0.47605186700820923,
-0.02506449818611145,
0.0019403154728934169,
0.08209412544965744,
-0.2610228359699249,
0.5327308773994446,
-0.033684954047203064,
-0.3634564280509949,
0.01971224881708622,
-0.16811978816986084,
0.03721984848380089,
0.1303359717130661,
0.6239414811134338,
0.4726276397705078,
-0.10830390453338623,
0.354653537273407,
0.10021083056926727,
-0.8457176685333252,
0.11086440831422806,
-0.007508737966418266,
-0.7231720685958862,
0.028308235108852386,
-0.07177914679050446,
0.6129319071769714,
0.062317442148923874,
-0.3691452145576477,
0.4058975577354431,
-0.26059603691101074,
-0.22277510166168213,
-0.0009448844939470291,
-0.08237908035516739,
0.09595774114131927,
0.02780141681432724,
0.4715975224971771,
0.3844726085662842,
0.280582070350647,
0.09934897720813751,
0.17282739281654358,
0.2049695998430252,
-0.3745163083076477,
-0.2636997103691101,
0.6485264301300049,
0.2082287222146988,
-0.3062703609466553,
0.5860971808433533,
0.1632177233695984,
-0.31295186281204224,
0.6240857243537903,
0.655463457107544,
1.2611290216445923,
-0.13439041376113892,
0.22348740696907043,
0.25239863991737366,
0.35444405674934387,
-0.4511532485485077,
-0.07545644789934158,
-0.09128361940383911,
-0.7613797783851624,
-0.5971043705940247,
-0.5361315608024597,
-0.39256784319877625,
0.5510547161102295,
-0.906609058380127,
-0.047989509999752045,
-0.5583442449569702,
0.002486168872565031,
-0.1787600815296173,
-0.04133206605911255,
-0.323064923286438,
0.335850328207016,
-0.003228419227525592,
0.41596904397010803,
-0.8402203917503357,
0.9765834212303162,
0.3564959466457367,
-0.5395281314849854,
-1.067652940750122,
0.23523618280887604,
-0.28220346570014954,
-0.2185119390487671,
0.6604103446006775,
0.3948676884174347,
-0.24545811116695404,
0.1705603003501892,
-0.39890384674072266,
-1.080831527709961,
0.6736595034599304,
0.7864144444465637,
-0.8409993052482605,
0.16724784672260284,
0.20516200363636017,
0.4300593435764313,
-0.502409040927887,
0.37460944056510925,
0.7073721885681152,
0.23325520753860474,
-0.07164916396141052,
-0.7153394818305969,
-0.1889379918575287,
-0.4131328761577606,
0.6059901118278503,
0.2380027174949646,
-0.7320614457130432,
0.9189081788063049,
-0.1220019981265068,
-0.2142624706029892,
-0.07975596934556961,
0.7776167988777161,
0.1858433336019516,
-0.012743569910526276,
0.504052460193634,
0.7235214710235596,
0.44779130816459656,
0.02261636219918728,
0.7628754377365112,
-0.5526937246322632,
0.6511839032173157,
1.3585352897644043,
-0.020590579137206078,
0.928335964679718,
0.472781777381897,
-0.04601825773715973,
0.26428335905075073,
0.6064783930778503,
0.2040272355079651,
0.7048951387405396,
0.2650676369667053,
0.06121838837862015,
-0.24950702488422394,
-0.0957873985171318,
-0.28597623109817505,
0.26439809799194336,
-0.2702055871486664,
-0.17976661026477814,
-0.14913785457611084,
-0.07710819691419601,
0.17419928312301636,
0.05319829285144806,
-0.07250609993934631,
0.5930732488632202,
0.08617720007896423,
-0.6840696334838867,
0.8086345791816711,
-0.059118498116731644,
0.6056398749351501,
-0.19991549849510193,
-0.05386669188737869,
-0.8371465802192688,
0.4672194719314575,
-0.2801067531108856,
-0.3625759482383728,
0.002587036695331335,
-0.15657877922058105,
-0.4904845058917999,
-0.3078260123729706,
0.5334394574165344,
-0.9924114942550659,
-0.560285210609436,
0.3451078534126282,
0.5481476187705994,
0.1867692619562149,
0.10445418208837509,
-0.5568996071815491,
0.02438274212181568,
-0.25441378355026245,
-0.35159745812416077,
0.3751547336578369,
0.37726521492004395,
0.14845497906208038,
0.5132916569709778,
0.513167142868042,
0.09335573762655258,
0.5249598026275635,
0.9256938695907593,
0.863562822341919,
-0.2720987796783447,
-0.46791577339172363,
-0.9588544368743896,
0.3528512418270111,
-0.09066373854875565,
-0.1074124202132225,
0.6035153269767761,
0.5833354592323303,
0.7454169988632202,
-0.1283787339925766,
0.6559603810310364,
0.14411328732967377,
0.5582754611968994,
-0.40607306361198425,
1.0306576490402222,
-0.5311024188995361,
0.27207690477371216,
-0.09891726076602936,
-1.1651301383972168,
-0.2958005964756012,
0.81064373254776,
0.08273954689502716,
0.4762856960296631,
0.7422304749488831,
0.6409254670143127,
-0.23517824709415436,
-0.2668924033641815,
0.4746754765510559,
0.23614177107810974,
0.2690071761608124,
0.2926574647426605,
0.6832786798477173,
-0.7106989026069641,
0.5603993535041809,
-0.8299038410186768,
0.09678780287504196,
0.026284195482730865,
-0.8113208413124084,
-1.0348495244979858,
-0.3982681632041931,
-0.5870361924171448,
-0.10920827835798264,
0.13720887899398804,
0.7145561575889587,
0.8681501746177673,
-0.9840973615646362,
-0.2110223025083542,
-0.42712676525115967,
-0.008693846873939037,
-0.32565605640411377,
-0.25586551427841187,
0.34932827949523926,
-0.4910956025123596,
-0.8205502033233643,
0.3963121771812439,
0.20075403153896332,
0.031613029539585114,
-0.4583221673965454,
0.02899125963449478,
-0.3237435221672058,
-0.028554443269968033,
0.10807805508375168,
0.06981928646564484,
-0.8956273198127747,
-0.36328941583633423,
-0.06205960735678673,
-0.3016793131828308,
0.30399590730667114,
0.7882188558578491,
-0.5328164100646973,
0.3051697611808777,
0.3711816072463989,
0.7384355068206787,
0.4617740511894226,
-0.16627362370491028,
0.44113659858703613,
-1.290872573852539,
0.18853358924388885,
0.1211969330906868,
0.16977845132350922,
0.38836023211479187,
-0.2987392544746399,
0.41681480407714844,
0.31831276416778564,
-0.3499642014503479,
-0.8525748252868652,
0.05877652019262314,
-0.730032742023468,
0.2721291482448578,
0.9103990197181702,
-0.2674793303012848,
-0.3658539354801178,
-0.0663890689611435,
0.15669311583042145,
0.2817738354206085,
-0.4641340970993042,
0.8752622008323669,
0.5373000502586365,
0.29447779059410095,
-0.6769453883171082,
-0.5011590123176575,
0.48696109652519226,
0.7047635316848755,
-0.7080281972885132,
0.07987187802791595,
0.3205072581768036,
0.5259883999824524,
0.3222881257534027,
0.4628535509109497,
0.2796112895011902,
0.1085587814450264,
-0.3594525158405304,
0.4776782989501953,
-0.16459296643733978,
-0.7587078809738159,
-0.4670608639717102,
0.05279608443379402,
-0.3798693120479584,
-0.5126741528511047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16358v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16358v2
|
An Integrated Data Processing Framework for Pretraining Foundation Models
| 2024-02-26T07:22:51 | 2024-04-23T06:18:32 |
Yiding Sun, Feng Wang, Yutao Zhu, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jiaxin Mao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
The ability of the foundation models heavily relies on large-scale, diverse,
and high-quality pretraining data. In order to improve data quality,
researchers and practitioners often have to manually curate datasets from
difference sources and develop dedicated data cleansing pipeline for each data
repository. Lacking a unified data processing framework, this process is
repetitive and cumbersome. To mitigate this issue, we propose a data processing
framework that integrates a Processing Module which consists of a series of
operators at different granularity levels, and an Analyzing Module which
supports probing and evaluation of the refined data. The proposed framework is
easy to use and highly flexible. In this demo paper, we first introduce how to
use this framework with some example use cases and then demonstrate its
effectiveness in improving the data quality with an automated evaluation with
ChatGPT and an end-to-end evaluation in pretraining the GPT-2 model. The code
and demonstration videos are accessible on GitHub.
|
[
-0.4806104898452759,
-0.7011067271232605,
0.1770259290933609,
0.2506537139415741,
-0.3914299011230469,
0.010735050775110722,
-0.02890819124877453,
-0.3543422222137451,
0.0067197238095104694,
0.6384983062744141,
-0.7443354725837708,
-0.4313125014305115,
-0.5949432253837585,
-0.267311692237854,
-0.8537431955337524,
0.9681190848350525,
-0.13910597562789917,
0.15739484131336212,
-0.14173327386379242,
0.18864765763282776,
-0.3889923393726349,
-0.2829991579055786,
-0.349996954202652,
-0.65108323097229,
-0.1000615730881691,
0.31458428502082825,
0.8303102850914001,
0.685093343257904,
0.5593589544296265,
0.3135274350643158,
0.13571962714195251,
-0.22146588563919067,
-0.7667405009269714,
-0.10252954065799713,
-0.4023677408695221,
-0.23041079938411713,
-0.600846529006958,
0.10367655754089355,
0.49969708919525146,
0.9677011966705322,
-0.2641080319881439,
0.10787184536457062,
0.26812490820884705,
0.7578221559524536,
-0.5314995646476746,
0.18265017867088318,
-0.28402748703956604,
0.22691147029399872,
-0.15927569568157196,
-0.0927385613322258,
-0.015104332007467747,
-0.14088217914104462,
0.34059521555900574,
-0.5920984148979187,
0.40938839316368103,
-0.5756675004959106,
0.6896299719810486,
0.4227631092071533,
-0.28800395131111145,
-0.0776958167552948,
-0.5674770474433899,
0.32730719447135925,
-0.41841089725494385,
0.3387303054332733,
0.3376174867153168,
0.4971398115158081,
-0.1566772311925888,
-1.1416001319885254,
-0.12508271634578705,
0.158408060669899,
-0.40901926159858704,
-0.01604234240949154,
0.042021363973617554,
0.26733532547950745,
0.08082336187362671,
0.761683464050293,
-0.7169987559318542,
-0.14827190339565277,
-0.3272944390773773,
-0.1961245983839035,
0.5193339586257935,
-0.0452595092356205,
-0.07913435250520706,
0.2501356601715088,
-0.3219238221645355,
-0.20417487621307373,
-0.46011289954185486,
0.18707789480686188,
0.4129600524902344,
0.3059692084789276,
0.048883505165576935,
0.3567660450935364,
-0.7049559354782104,
0.9588665962219238,
-0.06093728169798851,
0.192851260304451,
0.2862355411052704,
-0.31736624240875244,
-0.612842321395874,
-0.35425570607185364,
0.4495491683483124,
-0.03516489267349243,
0.22396427392959595,
-0.3573511838912964,
-0.528696596622467,
0.1513374298810959,
0.4284704029560089,
-1.2114704847335815,
-0.5984736680984497,
0.40232038497924805,
-0.350974440574646,
-0.4085940420627594,
0.33082544803619385,
-0.7358973026275635,
-0.0616629496216774,
-0.7714444398880005,
0.6212142109870911,
-0.22284547984600067,
-0.5757282376289368,
0.5585098266601562,
0.03242165595293045,
-0.07725188136100769,
0.3142124116420746,
-0.6811311841011047,
0.6049109101295471,
0.7746821641921997,
0.670214831829071,
-0.13293056190013885,
0.018305374309420586,
-0.7147209644317627,
-0.06434997171163559,
-0.0976877212524414,
0.7986660003662109,
-0.7305892109870911,
-0.5439476370811462,
-0.33970770239830017,
-0.10338686406612396,
-0.15671098232269287,
-0.6061432361602783,
0.32913944125175476,
-0.5180822610855103,
0.17642106115818024,
-0.06470628827810287,
-0.4587957561016083,
-0.1297222524881363,
0.40139007568359375,
-0.7236177921295166,
1.1126186847686768,
0.6026132702827454,
-0.4803815186023712,
0.5359212756156921,
-0.867408037185669,
-0.3785095810890198,
0.11561941355466843,
-0.24744157493114471,
-0.47645050287246704,
-0.0010465712985023856,
0.4739721417427063,
0.5429773330688477,
-0.3575109541416168,
0.6907168626785278,
-0.20695960521697998,
-0.6968610286712646,
-0.2679135501384735,
-0.09263049811124802,
0.6487698554992676,
0.18032655119895935,
-0.42783322930336,
0.17402403056621552,
-0.8987426161766052,
0.378634512424469,
-0.35311970114707947,
-0.3931790590286255,
0.3280559480190277,
-0.28013116121292114,
0.16355587542057037,
0.2774231731891632,
0.000996974529698491,
-0.08430906385183334,
0.23125575482845306,
-0.06944681704044342,
0.3596650958061218,
0.6272488832473755,
-0.18889875710010529,
0.2729524075984955,
-0.24097013473510742,
0.5776099562644958,
0.20635300874710083,
0.25248751044273376,
-0.1384280025959015,
0.016021857038140297,
-0.5941751599311829,
-0.5353149175643921,
0.41881033778190613,
0.3198204040527344,
-0.6986716985702515,
0.40024179220199585,
-0.3391110301017761,
-0.46949151158332825,
-0.33344289660453796,
0.23547199368476868,
0.3817237913608551,
0.5222417116165161,
0.519917905330658,
-0.6349872946739197,
-0.6123924851417542,
-0.7615249156951904,
-0.08213701844215393,
0.07730460166931152,
-0.07447188347578049,
-0.04835934937000275,
0.5523456931114197,
-0.4264311194419861,
1.3202096223831177,
-0.259640097618103,
-0.130288228392601,
0.09610850363969803,
0.32643458247184753,
0.3663075864315033,
0.8639540076255798,
0.49291688203811646,
-1.1495567560195923,
-0.15005935728549957,
-0.07693832367658615,
-0.7325765490531921,
-0.05751971900463104,
0.3549448251724243,
-0.40303921699523926,
-0.6723085045814514,
0.4753006398677826,
-0.47963204979896545,
0.5453647375106812,
0.4704189598560333,
-0.3212481439113617,
0.6291117072105408,
0.25093623995780945,
0.5027502775192261,
-0.6356068849563599,
0.3673954904079437,
-0.34470483660697937,
-0.2866656184196472,
-0.5840224623680115,
0.14915423095226288,
-0.14485102891921997,
-0.43004676699638367,
-0.24783772230148315,
0.26241621375083923,
-0.19464616477489471,
-0.4595499336719513,
-0.15711060166358948,
-0.44493603706359863,
0.16028037667274475,
0.1522810459136963,
0.23977088928222656,
0.7465780377388,
0.7330014109611511,
-0.6866661310195923,
0.34455162286758423,
0.12581075727939606,
-0.5264075398445129,
0.7350060343742371,
-0.8608578443527222,
0.12707090377807617,
-0.1017691120505333,
0.3044607937335968,
-0.9889888167381287,
-0.5401132702827454,
0.23945452272891998,
-0.14849695563316345,
0.24836018681526184,
-0.6104122400283813,
-0.5090059041976929,
-0.21410048007965088,
-0.09303063899278641,
0.18609575927257538,
0.19836601614952087,
-0.6048462390899658,
0.6129836440086365,
0.08713875710964203,
-0.15168121457099915,
-0.7124617099761963,
-0.6471149325370789,
-0.21061021089553833,
-0.112870953977108,
-0.8849068284034729,
0.47321242094039917,
-0.02356910891830921,
0.10851690173149109,
0.27855148911476135,
-0.35054609179496765,
-0.6602291464805603,
0.19210797548294067,
0.17403005063533783,
-0.03660392761230469,
-0.25500020384788513,
0.04182160273194313,
0.15439046919345856,
-0.3671220541000366,
-0.11946018785238266,
-0.610115110874176,
0.5511082410812378,
-0.012978342361748219,
-0.6034523248672485,
-0.3622480034828186,
0.0743592381477356,
0.4899280369281769,
-0.36268067359924316,
0.4466194808483124,
0.6642731428146362,
-0.6062846183776855,
-0.1614646315574646,
-0.4049876928329468,
-0.14082840085029602,
-0.4871846139431,
0.37039288878440857,
-0.5854722261428833,
-0.7529730796813965,
0.3068712055683136,
-0.3376402258872986,
0.12312319874763489,
0.12480334937572479,
0.2616294324398041,
-0.029776429757475853,
0.7216050028800964,
0.5603168606758118,
0.03191359341144562,
0.43515297770500183,
-0.5648086071014404,
0.09794140607118607,
-0.3056718707084656,
-0.08401136100292206,
-0.4924348294734955,
-0.24183018505573273,
0.1516854465007782,
-0.1899508684873581,
0.19340530037879944,
0.6181055903434753,
-0.33202803134918213,
0.32451552152633667,
-0.5459280014038086,
0.6580452919006348,
0.08578013628721237,
0.3427988290786743,
0.4212038815021515,
0.15277902781963348,
0.1539217084646225,
0.31829574704170227,
-0.43254488706588745,
-0.6138489246368408,
1.2219139337539673,
0.15610232949256897,
0.6667015552520752,
-0.19900304079055786,
0.5915584564208984,
0.2891615927219391,
0.6117258071899414,
-0.4189952313899994,
0.28935888409614563,
-0.20212213695049286,
-0.7691243290901184,
-0.25014764070510864,
-0.5467561483383179,
-0.5975858569145203,
0.5194751024246216,
-0.011244991794228554,
-0.683339536190033,
0.2345944344997406,
0.2845142185688019,
-0.3309246897697449,
0.13521307706832886,
-0.6954444050788879,
1.123765468597412,
-0.05295867845416069,
-0.33621546626091003,
-0.17706789076328278,
-0.37961915135383606,
0.4867880940437317,
-0.27979418635368347,
0.16881129145622253,
-0.11621412634849548,
0.3714465796947479,
0.6073842644691467,
-0.7887991666793823,
0.5612834692001343,
-0.6086322665214539,
0.02321389690041542,
0.31089770793914795,
-0.03291361778974533,
0.29358819127082825,
0.3833777904510498,
-0.4307355284690857,
-0.03818895295262337,
0.18345309793949127,
-0.6063043475151062,
-0.6096857190132141,
0.3272958993911743,
-0.5675379633903503,
-0.1869305968284607,
-0.013881802558898926,
-0.36274483799934387,
-0.416606605052948,
0.20648084580898285,
0.347644180059433,
0.3857373595237732,
-0.3612363934516907,
0.45872846245765686,
0.5041635036468506,
0.3467281460762024,
0.09547515213489532,
0.3879089653491974,
-0.1958620548248291,
-0.29270070791244507,
0.5391496419906616,
0.14433985948562622,
0.0725536197423935,
0.2162467986345291,
-0.18713024258613586,
-0.28419411182403564,
-0.7099851965904236,
-0.4724746644496918,
-0.4089556634426117,
-0.6479803323745728,
-0.1965470016002655,
-0.5620866417884827,
-0.07753152400255203,
-0.2875222861766815,
-0.230645552277565,
-0.5233560800552368,
-0.24217644333839417,
-0.1859729290008545,
-0.21502207219600677,
0.09834519028663635,
0.47534245252609253,
-0.04485326632857323,
0.9913257956504822,
-0.6900615692138672,
0.37637048959732056,
0.41778022050857544,
0.6548838019371033,
-0.2192966789007187,
-0.1259337216615677,
-0.35367628931999207,
0.24313803017139435,
-0.06363864988088608,
-0.3261766731739044,
-0.047273263335227966,
0.21833381056785583,
0.4041140377521515,
0.36797022819519043,
-0.22252494096755981,
0.9451240301132202,
0.007061127107590437,
0.43770188093185425,
0.020759737119078636,
-1.0786644220352173,
0.524933397769928,
-0.24457009136676788,
-0.011956957168877125,
1.0917811393737793,
0.15469741821289062,
-0.062201254069805145,
0.295833945274353,
-0.5378119349479675,
-0.8130468726158142,
0.783203125,
0.250301331281662,
-0.27115023136138916,
0.5276380181312561,
0.5108451247215271,
0.40664827823638916,
0.4944519102573395,
-0.5042117238044739,
0.12894755601882935,
-0.3780585825443268,
-0.14449548721313477,
-0.013137790374457836,
0.08521771430969238,
-0.34228000044822693,
-0.26631343364715576,
0.7174257040023804,
-0.18073396384716034,
-0.10350381582975388,
-0.15808245539665222,
-0.6431559920310974,
0.09895483404397964,
0.0957249328494072,
-0.26824748516082764,
1.003756046295166,
-0.18097271025180817,
-0.27293631434440613,
-0.22452066838741302,
-0.6898475289344788,
0.4335375130176544,
0.5596289038658142,
-0.04473220556974411,
-0.17449511587619781,
0.5307888388633728,
0.5562413334846497,
0.4439261555671692,
-0.4655773639678955,
0.5786406397819519,
-0.1975013017654419,
-0.09143131971359253,
0.02333110198378563,
0.3880845904350281,
-0.04274975508451462,
0.12133695185184479,
0.26735731959342957,
0.10015532374382019,
0.3728812336921692,
-0.3332061469554901,
0.7177447080612183,
-0.05417468026280403,
-0.25490695238113403,
-0.2923171818256378,
0.3645131289958954,
0.26447033882141113,
0.1650131195783615,
0.8231005668640137,
-0.1273893266916275,
-0.26541855931282043,
0.5731712579727173,
0.09794344007968903,
0.5294790863990784,
-0.32157251238822937,
0.3203025460243225,
0.15830306708812714,
0.03779837116599083,
-0.273321270942688,
0.3638603985309601,
-0.27482691407203674,
-0.5688288807868958,
-0.7439349889755249,
-0.8369299173355103,
-0.2055848091840744,
0.2545640766620636,
-0.9363411068916321,
0.4795706868171692,
-0.48318547010421753,
-0.019210411235690117,
-0.037526361644268036,
0.000025784969693631865,
-1.114720106124878,
0.8099958896636963,
-0.3277319669723511,
0.8416983485221863,
-0.8301763534545898,
0.7168444395065308,
0.7093518972396851,
-0.19782376289367676,
-0.5689918398857117,
-0.2582402229309082,
-0.010994491167366505,
-0.5305464267730713,
0.4923661947250366,
0.3921814560890198,
-0.002879250328987837,
0.1402522176504135,
-0.4476410150527954,
-0.7229822278022766,
0.9445080161094666,
0.7417319416999817,
-0.6672395467758179,
0.028141682967543602,
0.44441211223602295,
0.40871378779411316,
-0.28635188937187195,
0.43072113394737244,
1.1339287757873535,
0.5719837546348572,
0.17674511671066284,
-0.7757701277732849,
-0.34136858582496643,
-0.4429372251033783,
-0.18644669651985168,
0.1170828714966774,
-0.22081249952316284,
0.8703570365905762,
0.23213693499565125,
-0.3100126385688782,
-0.05604495108127594,
0.36672139167785645,
0.05361685901880264,
0.14642789959907532,
0.6880343556404114,
0.9107397198677063,
0.7893354892730713,
-0.4726018011569977,
0.6667529940605164,
-0.33920973539352417,
0.6471510529518127,
1.0213168859481812,
-0.22005346417427063,
0.1835942268371582,
0.021381545811891556,
-0.4253815710544586,
0.21048994362354279,
0.9364598393440247,
0.21647652983665466,
0.5966018438339233,
0.2586168050765991,
-0.3122820258140564,
-0.2796926200389862,
0.16740204393863678,
-0.685002863407135,
0.4278590977191925,
0.30935803055763245,
-0.23755455017089844,
-0.584976315498352,
-0.13075792789459229,
-0.200680673122406,
-0.2646700143814087,
-0.3173723518848419,
0.499931663274765,
-0.17785875499248505,
-0.32324352860450745,
0.28532421588897705,
-0.10660556703805923,
0.5109608173370361,
-0.8205020427703857,
-0.018869319930672646,
-0.12286153435707092,
0.13999131321907043,
-0.6697775721549988,
-0.6669895648956299,
0.48552456498146057,
0.003442599903792143,
-0.15781299769878387,
-0.31843334436416626,
0.6251824498176575,
-0.24779216945171356,
-0.2362828403711319,
0.4630206525325775,
0.6690054535865784,
0.25107651948928833,
-0.3812659978866577,
-0.7151552438735962,
0.09525420516729355,
-0.15651646256446838,
-0.728775143623352,
0.28518030047416687,
0.34196561574935913,
0.06906116753816605,
0.3521732985973358,
0.9972168803215027,
-0.11817297339439392,
-0.13789735734462738,
0.23781439661979675,
1.1912779808044434,
-0.2894841134548187,
-0.6931748390197754,
-0.6080281138420105,
0.9263362288475037,
-0.1112789437174797,
-0.3941086530685425,
-0.11560360342264175,
0.678491473197937,
1.0337804555892944,
0.03771209716796875,
0.8497461080551147,
-0.2814865708351135,
0.3345153033733368,
-0.5386835932731628,
0.5882113575935364,
-0.1598644107580185,
0.2887466847896576,
-0.26656022667884827,
-1.2597317695617676,
-0.14023536443710327,
0.7587521076202393,
-0.1877393126487732,
0.2884259819984436,
0.28098782896995544,
0.6497182846069336,
-0.5835782289505005,
0.39003875851631165,
0.08144291490316391,
-0.06783747673034668,
0.6208313703536987,
0.2684050500392914,
0.5596926808357239,
-0.4468224048614502,
0.3179802894592285,
-0.3986090123653412,
-0.40765494108200073,
0.009720707312226295,
-0.7780206799507141,
-0.6365922689437866,
-0.30718114972114563,
-0.2526162266731262,
-0.12753690779209137,
0.24336518347263336,
0.6363043785095215,
1.3539994955062866,
-0.7794893980026245,
-0.11981291323900223,
-0.35514694452285767,
-0.343065470457077,
-0.3074052035808563,
-0.2421809583902359,
0.42903584241867065,
-0.28039491176605225,
-0.5633232593536377,
0.5571212768554688,
0.16946128010749817,
0.004701269790530205,
-0.06550723314285278,
-0.04670140519738197,
0.22308988869190216,
-0.4793558716773987,
0.42693576216697693,
0.07518721371889114,
0.09761246293783188,
-0.15495558083057404,
-0.42887941002845764,
0.19878439605236053,
0.055583491921424866,
1.0857818126678467,
-0.960809588432312,
0.5832544565200806,
0.3061410188674927,
0.8906062245368958,
0.8818739652633667,
0.38259661197662354,
0.6262035369873047,
-0.7490875720977783,
0.27340736985206604,
0.3638543486595154,
0.4123224914073944,
0.4214850068092346,
-0.49705401062965393,
1.032355785369873,
0.26419204473495483,
-0.23391985893249512,
-0.8458653688430786,
0.10995030403137207,
-0.45196786522865295,
-0.1709970384836197,
0.5076619386672974,
-0.5210684537887573,
0.22364704310894012,
-0.1239231526851654,
-0.0074766855686903,
0.2906744182109833,
-0.04118496924638748,
0.40684774518013,
1.0659493207931519,
-0.3647727370262146,
0.20280854403972626,
-0.4490048587322235,
0.3674629330635071,
0.22214600443840027,
-1.2322416305541992,
-0.06239824369549751,
0.42897582054138184,
0.5348078012466431,
-0.22619496285915375,
0.8592305779457092,
-0.3660951554775238,
0.31415340304374695,
0.04550373926758766,
-0.040927641093730927,
-0.35184597969055176,
-0.5856190323829651,
-0.4100988209247589,
0.27939802408218384,
-0.49629056453704834,
0.0237721037119627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16354v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16354v2
|
Language-guided Skill Learning with Temporal Variational Inference
| 2024-02-26T07:19:23 | 2024-05-27T14:31:38 |
Haotian Fu, Pratyusha Sharma, Elias Stengel-Eskin, George Konidaris, Nicolas Le Roux, Marc-Alexandre Côté, Xingdi Yuan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We present an algorithm for skill discovery from expert demonstrations. The
algorithm first utilizes Large Language Models (LLMs) to propose an initial
segmentation of the trajectories. Following that, a hierarchical variational
inference framework incorporates the LLM-generated segmentation information to
discover reusable skills by merging trajectory segments. To further control the
trade-off between compression and reusability, we introduce a novel auxiliary
objective based on the Minimum Description Length principle that helps guide
this skill discovery process. Our results demonstrate that agents equipped with
our method are able to discover skills that help accelerate learning and
outperform baseline skill learning approaches on new long-horizon tasks in
BabyAI, a grid world navigation environment, as well as ALFRED, a household
simulation environment.
|
[
-0.10730314254760742,
-0.7625529766082764,
0.5712673664093018,
0.14643597602844238,
-0.01728079840540886,
0.2838619351387024,
-0.1841968148946762,
-0.37384483218193054,
0.13187678158283234,
0.3594546318054199,
-0.9890323877334595,
-0.7231590151786804,
-0.37736135721206665,
-0.3614721894264221,
-0.05414370819926262,
0.610228955745697,
0.01176392287015915,
-0.3625556230545044,
-0.21314634382724762,
0.1808757483959198,
-0.23221157491207123,
0.06292489916086197,
-0.8430882692337036,
-0.5217472314834595,
0.7292457818984985,
0.8334951400756836,
0.5106578469276428,
0.9924721121788025,
-0.15502934157848358,
0.33614084124565125,
-0.19779621064662933,
0.49566370248794556,
-0.41158682107925415,
0.05913664773106575,
-0.04818512871861458,
-0.7222428917884827,
-0.18912602961063385,
-0.17446111142635345,
0.7320072054862976,
0.9689014554023743,
-0.3621651828289032,
-0.22443228960037231,
-0.1122703105211258,
0.37031683325767517,
-0.4258619248867035,
0.3501054644584656,
-0.38890931010246277,
0.45362555980682373,
-0.07737001031637192,
-0.45275935530662537,
-0.21555742621421814,
-0.16810715198516846,
0.2945284843444824,
-0.9945683479309082,
0.4747295379638672,
-0.13448865711688995,
0.7248724699020386,
0.45851585268974304,
-0.47095823287963867,
-0.17468003928661346,
-0.6158944368362427,
1.1316702365875244,
-0.5688172578811646,
0.5075498223304749,
0.48421087861061096,
0.49628663063049316,
-0.44880419969558716,
-0.4492577016353607,
-0.2734014391899109,
-0.31253066658973694,
0.025349151343107224,
-0.07505372166633606,
0.454483300447464,
0.16059021651744843,
0.3525489866733551,
0.17420315742492676,
-0.3831452429294586,
0.5973321199417114,
-0.1206873431801796,
-0.1585036963224411,
0.6968339681625366,
0.3221353590488434,
0.10689308494329453,
0.055301859974861145,
-0.010188538581132889,
-0.12032946199178696,
-0.650437593460083,
0.260788232088089,
0.4495297074317932,
0.1781042367219925,
-0.34353846311569214,
0.37704384326934814,
-0.28468430042266846,
0.7149684429168701,
-0.08221900463104248,
-0.6669866442680359,
0.3512006402015686,
0.053896427154541016,
-0.027666345238685608,
-0.42256370186805725,
0.43437209725379944,
0.14583362638950348,
0.04309831187129021,
-0.24431166052818298,
-0.1547432392835617,
-0.32933756709098816,
0.019857529550790787,
-0.45054110884666443,
-0.11148399114608765,
-0.3394626975059509,
-0.4118826687335968,
-0.3052484691143036,
-0.24185213446617126,
-0.7654591798782349,
-0.5144712924957275,
-0.2601889967918396,
-0.0640324205160141,
-0.4513850212097168,
-0.14485007524490356,
0.14564166963100433,
-0.2919641435146332,
0.42132917046546936,
0.3290877640247345,
-0.9566906094551086,
0.155105859041214,
0.744007408618927,
0.6545453667640686,
-0.0820436030626297,
-0.6049205660820007,
-0.568893313407898,
0.04723028838634491,
-0.4476129412651062,
0.7144584059715271,
-0.674704909324646,
-0.5789282917976379,
0.1308327466249466,
0.09572848677635193,
0.08022721856832504,
-0.5364704132080078,
0.37573713064193726,
-0.5900180339813232,
0.14345434308052063,
-0.19086118042469025,
-0.5822411775588989,
-0.31955486536026,
-0.07984612882137299,
-0.5539687275886536,
0.97445148229599,
0.49838805198669434,
-0.3068535029888153,
0.8478471636772156,
-0.6528186798095703,
-0.6153585314750671,
0.1546342819929123,
-0.3514847755432129,
-0.5203121900558472,
0.12217546999454498,
0.1349043995141983,
0.4330882132053375,
-0.18109917640686035,
0.019552212208509445,
-0.0008098740945570171,
-0.3415452241897583,
-0.093455009162426,
-0.4296991229057312,
0.3546580970287323,
0.03644822537899017,
-0.2844257056713104,
-0.07969680428504944,
-0.6973816752433777,
-0.07620905339717865,
0.08881331980228424,
-0.5800888538360596,
-0.18931089341640472,
0.4728773534297943,
-0.332278311252594,
0.05056862160563469,
0.31264224648475647,
-0.31831133365631104,
0.44228944182395935,
-0.48742344975471497,
0.13244150578975677,
0.6224257349967957,
0.2852987051010132,
0.3751714527606964,
-0.41092249751091003,
0.8109175562858582,
-0.13655102252960205,
0.19333307445049286,
-0.13493871688842773,
-0.3155348300933838,
-0.7653619050979614,
-0.16074535250663757,
-0.0190923810005188,
0.40567317605018616,
-1.0599662065505981,
0.4945119023323059,
-0.22389160096645355,
-0.34082746505737305,
-0.30247557163238525,
0.1314287930727005,
0.501690685749054,
0.36336925625801086,
0.24049989879131317,
-0.1606699377298355,
-0.5529230833053589,
-0.9984098076820374,
-0.036150477826595306,
-0.08613818883895874,
-0.12340850383043289,
0.587826132774353,
0.23444487154483795,
-0.40640443563461304,
0.6016342639923096,
-0.6278558373451233,
0.09377798438072205,
-0.15006329119205475,
0.6378187537193298,
0.18481694161891937,
0.39566147327423096,
0.49067223072052,
-0.6401217579841614,
-0.3394496440887451,
0.13850022852420807,
-0.7520206570625305,
-0.30999836325645447,
-0.44666412472724915,
0.10281061381101608,
-0.08028848469257355,
0.5849145650863647,
-0.1618604212999344,
0.33531489968299866,
0.22654202580451965,
-0.16216710209846497,
0.43153679370880127,
-0.337582528591156,
0.10099326074123383,
-0.7577892541885376,
-0.3978559970855713,
0.03168409317731857,
-0.18325288593769073,
-0.4795265793800354,
0.12663844227790833,
-0.23864343762397766,
0.31491586565971375,
-0.29596376419067383,
0.5443528294563293,
-0.6086520552635193,
-0.2780924141407013,
-0.5440484285354614,
0.11135157942771912,
-0.3232349753379822,
0.6579300761222839,
0.27125704288482666,
0.8289745450019836,
0.6421252489089966,
-0.593073844909668,
-0.03669044375419617,
0.051060643047094345,
-0.3624025583267212,
0.3266447186470032,
-0.33803170919418335,
0.23853106796741486,
-0.088515505194664,
-0.2193501591682434,
-0.5682165622711182,
-0.3289373815059662,
-0.02976253628730774,
-0.25799989700317383,
0.32504862546920776,
-0.47113800048828125,
-0.20739446580410004,
-0.3359232544898987,
-0.03986003249883652,
0.26806509494781494,
0.5735065937042236,
-0.4212242662906647,
0.7369414567947388,
0.3456369936466217,
-0.07628729194402695,
-0.8735672831535339,
-0.3692680895328522,
-0.10585065931081772,
-0.16501185297966003,
-0.4323280155658722,
0.4418487548828125,
0.06555678695440292,
0.10028506815433502,
-0.30756524205207825,
-0.14411874115467072,
-0.18760575354099274,
0.4664626717567444,
0.41622957587242126,
-0.03564447909593582,
-0.10019905865192413,
0.17931102216243744,
0.35029903054237366,
-0.05917058885097504,
-0.09312549233436584,
-0.22832119464874268,
0.4787431061267853,
0.017606817185878754,
-0.3986169695854187,
-0.2589881122112274,
0.375227153301239,
0.4719652235507965,
0.019266018643975258,
0.5681464672088623,
0.5158456563949585,
-0.2587268054485321,
-0.5316881537437439,
-0.49496909976005554,
-0.07819642871618271,
-0.5215376615524292,
0.6081984639167786,
-0.4447311758995056,
-0.8771557807922363,
0.4553232789039612,
-0.30819207429885864,
0.09415875375270844,
0.26272162795066833,
0.18665145337581635,
0.05763465538620949,
0.8678829073905945,
0.9871996641159058,
-0.07049304991960526,
0.7806011438369751,
-0.6380226612091064,
-0.13379283249378204,
-0.7363007068634033,
-0.6347212195396423,
-0.24030564725399017,
-0.27842164039611816,
-0.4858275055885315,
-0.7876716256141663,
0.4023304581642151,
0.027256028726696968,
-0.22101770341396332,
-0.07708962261676788,
-0.10947859287261963,
0.7248315215110779,
0.7080347537994385,
0.2993236780166626,
0.05073227360844612,
-0.01758112944662571,
-0.33308351039886475,
-0.09116113185882568,
-0.8726161122322083,
-0.31664037704467773,
0.8490360379219055,
0.3437630832195282,
0.8387256860733032,
-0.1934085190296173,
0.999087929725647,
0.3589203357696533,
0.19969968497753143,
-1.077406644821167,
0.694891095161438,
-0.15233087539672852,
-0.10780815035104752,
-0.6928389668464661,
-0.45754703879356384,
-1.0637532472610474,
-0.09968019276857376,
-0.09737800806760788,
-0.5199337601661682,
0.1755979210138321,
0.17321521043777466,
-0.32444143295288086,
0.1362219750881195,
-0.4288409650325775,
0.5833823680877686,
-0.38667237758636475,
-0.5390065908432007,
-0.3612237274646759,
-0.6194302439689636,
0.055470727384090424,
0.07531053572893143,
0.11256551742553711,
-0.054728858172893524,
-0.3104894161224365,
0.7069480419158936,
-0.22411620616912842,
1.0524805784225464,
-0.5085428357124329,
-0.15306444466114044,
0.07060683518648148,
0.22695392370224,
0.34371620416641235,
-0.14579959213733673,
0.09854134172201157,
-0.2738661766052246,
-0.496166467666626,
-0.3875448703765869,
-0.7660449147224426,
0.548798143863678,
-0.8271998763084412,
-0.594819962978363,
-0.06254643201828003,
-0.522883951663971,
-0.249346524477005,
-0.006491458974778652,
0.004504416603595018,
0.1814042627811432,
-0.4023702144622803,
0.14945866167545319,
0.7896326780319214,
-0.15638667345046997,
0.47063571214675903,
0.902463972568512,
0.07254531234502792,
-0.058177534490823746,
0.7919504046440125,
-0.08786213397979736,
-0.028857318684458733,
0.7723896503448486,
0.24798625707626343,
-0.1403234302997589,
-0.8153969645500183,
-0.07587436586618423,
0.18456366658210754,
-0.6743449568748474,
0.06456749141216278,
-0.28130441904067993,
-0.055777620524168015,
0.07276104390621185,
-0.3928019404411316,
-0.28359025716781616,
-0.1761995404958725,
-0.30318301916122437,
-0.30762025713920593,
0.07857921719551086,
0.7646907567977905,
-0.2960021197795868,
0.6486018300056458,
-0.6053142547607422,
0.19903582334518433,
0.6824895143508911,
0.1410202980041504,
0.013995474204421043,
-0.3717547059059143,
-0.6296980977058411,
0.02600378729403019,
-0.3041680157184601,
-0.6421485543251038,
0.38312578201293945,
0.3796108663082123,
1.0238463878631592,
0.6929203271865845,
-0.39128148555755615,
0.46386900544166565,
-0.5346589684486389,
0.9740093350410461,
-0.07477568835020065,
-0.8784717321395874,
0.571568489074707,
-0.45180875062942505,
0.18960689008235931,
0.1622048020362854,
0.5285193920135498,
-0.5929381847381592,
-0.1435146927833557,
-0.6918061971664429,
-0.8657785058021545,
0.350619375705719,
-0.15538977086544037,
-0.2230997383594513,
0.007726306561380625,
0.5834171772003174,
0.43365198373794556,
0.21528704464435577,
-0.37133824825286865,
-0.16476184129714966,
-0.009801138192415237,
-0.22980722784996033,
-0.3211086690425873,
-0.3033476173877716,
-0.17131617665290833,
0.009677257388830185,
0.47782742977142334,
-0.38180842995643616,
0.28975218534469604,
-0.043884892016649246,
-0.2060626894235611,
-0.0843980684876442,
0.2133641541004181,
0.6144738793373108,
0.6337586045265198,
0.05556156486272812,
-0.06065330281853676,
0.2276197224855423,
-0.18555256724357605,
0.33565768599510193,
0.1729041337966919,
0.004468678496778011,
-0.22403737902641296,
0.8620840907096863,
0.9594234228134155,
0.44856610894203186,
-0.6482646465301514,
0.2923766076564789,
0.218439519405365,
-0.2672453820705414,
-0.4187608063220978,
0.4517437517642975,
-0.06324269622564316,
0.5890989303588867,
0.4598540663719177,
-0.35210636258125305,
0.18059049546718597,
-0.43421539664268494,
0.35350504517555237,
0.33395302295684814,
-0.2421218305826187,
-0.3125362992286682,
0.4120391607284546,
0.009628692641854286,
-0.6076313853263855,
0.5296408534049988,
-0.26678648591041565,
-0.47237586975097656,
0.7388379573822021,
0.05832180008292198,
0.9396315813064575,
-0.48156216740608215,
0.5220768451690674,
-0.10030130296945572,
0.13659881055355072,
-0.01504337228834629,
0.48440471291542053,
-0.43692147731781006,
-0.8013861179351807,
-0.5695661306381226,
-0.26307249069213867,
-0.39782899618148804,
0.03896366059780121,
-0.5224365592002869,
-0.011364530771970749,
-0.13980698585510254,
0.01903337985277176,
0.006635034456849098,
0.050422120839357376,
-0.9142434597015381,
0.28146517276763916,
0.1384744644165039,
0.742715060710907,
-1.1241933107376099,
0.6639665961265564,
0.40536588430404663,
-0.2236638367176056,
-0.7577857971191406,
0.19450031220912933,
-0.0770357996225357,
-0.9973440170288086,
0.8965181708335876,
-0.20176385343074799,
-0.34979018568992615,
-0.2494969666004181,
-0.7421718835830688,
-0.5101109743118286,
1.2512660026550293,
0.25460103154182434,
-0.44003403186798096,
-0.4460338056087494,
0.02777111530303955,
0.6437357664108276,
-0.612992525100708,
0.27647605538368225,
0.6321958899497986,
0.21486051380634308,
0.16608662903308868,
-0.7361608147621155,
-0.22345800697803497,
-0.07106634229421616,
0.07296580821275711,
0.03202589228749275,
-0.48494771122932434,
0.7487683892250061,
-0.4100243151187897,
-0.0022448445670306683,
0.14055293798446655,
0.7931355834007263,
0.1358645260334015,
0.42115625739097595,
0.6856839656829834,
0.44514572620391846,
0.8738975524902344,
0.12415885925292969,
0.878341019153595,
-0.06636766344308853,
0.18554793298244476,
1.1833975315093994,
0.0033687325194478035,
0.6098484992980957,
0.3673110008239746,
0.03813342750072479,
1.0516414642333984,
0.8214801549911499,
0.2395631968975067,
0.7701767086982727,
0.4289584159851074,
-0.3453425467014313,
-0.41528570652008057,
-0.1526728719472885,
-0.1281026005744934,
0.4009363055229187,
0.6214429140090942,
-0.48781684041023254,
-0.20295478403568268,
0.18962126970291138,
-0.016935620456933975,
-0.006893900688737631,
-0.23904584348201752,
0.8223410844802856,
-0.14271102845668793,
-0.7085939049720764,
0.6382837295532227,
-0.04618336632847786,
0.4597315490245819,
-0.6223971843719482,
-0.4628470838069916,
-0.29375845193862915,
-0.1781577318906784,
-0.005625342950224876,
-0.6784781217575073,
-0.11167700588703156,
-0.5151283144950867,
-0.16789746284484863,
-0.14563091099262238,
0.41875505447387695,
-0.4917677342891693,
-0.08924807608127594,
0.25895097851753235,
0.7506231665611267,
0.1283242404460907,
0.3929682970046997,
-0.2281678169965744,
-0.46838119626045227,
0.031177956610918045,
-0.10962095856666565,
0.055835410952568054,
0.6149125099182129,
0.030739400535821915,
1.064736008644104,
0.13733448088169098,
0.12024358659982681,
0.2738335430622101,
-0.01274389773607254,
0.8814654350280762,
-0.5514256954193115,
-0.5462331175804138,
-0.30211061239242554,
0.4464673697948456,
-0.2811666429042816,
-0.1555454134941101,
0.4579223394393921,
0.4917178153991699,
0.8192160129547119,
-0.3643212616443634,
0.8759005665779114,
0.14307518303394318,
0.5075903534889221,
-0.9291224479675293,
0.13242939114570618,
-0.6125856041908264,
0.379352331161499,
0.08382365852594376,
-0.37617227435112,
0.01642475835978985,
0.6670050024986267,
-0.5230989456176758,
0.18457534909248352,
0.6653697490692139,
0.8879358172416687,
-0.11979161202907562,
-0.2673655152320862,
0.5292848944664001,
-0.03153344616293907,
0.42043429613113403,
0.923691987991333,
0.9667578935623169,
0.11378281563520432,
0.10470002889633179,
-0.395963579416275,
-0.5013768076896667,
-0.28168895840644836,
-1.0008844137191772,
-1.0037691593170166,
-0.6403659582138062,
-0.35420507192611694,
0.07855958491563797,
0.3640028238296509,
0.9511259198188782,
0.9085482358932495,
-0.36456525325775146,
-0.4649707078933716,
-0.20272204279899597,
0.42390525341033936,
-0.6030617952346802,
-0.20039944350719452,
0.3098723292350769,
-0.3578402101993561,
-0.7617923617362976,
0.9589203596115112,
-0.04217616096138954,
0.17777875065803528,
-0.26329484581947327,
-0.20902149379253387,
-0.044433046132326126,
-0.15406754612922668,
0.38485220074653625,
0.7038903832435608,
-0.568358838558197,
-0.4207068979740143,
-0.04834479093551636,
0.42149975895881653,
-0.027649573981761932,
1.2185790538787842,
-0.732813835144043,
0.3712059259414673,
0.4033876657485962,
0.6186590194702148,
0.6225078105926514,
-0.29345065355300903,
0.7128388285636902,
-1.2079371213912964,
0.3035818338394165,
0.3387436866760254,
0.39806556701660156,
0.17002341151237488,
-0.34469282627105713,
0.5023528933525085,
0.23814603686332703,
-0.45921626687049866,
-0.4777035713195801,
0.5404017567634583,
-0.661207377910614,
-0.10772401839494705,
1.0819754600524902,
-0.4088646471500397,
-0.11488663405179977,
-0.20867307484149933,
-0.1731463223695755,
0.3386782705783844,
-0.2355394810438156,
0.957192599773407,
0.3930789530277252,
-0.17987492680549622,
-0.44406428933143616,
-0.3439139127731323,
0.6833612322807312,
0.06201055645942688,
-0.7294315695762634,
-0.2028837949037552,
0.480949729681015,
0.19127494096755981,
0.0685715302824974,
0.2941046357154846,
0.33614110946655273,
0.3709436058998108,
0.12825913727283478,
0.04406081885099411,
-0.27826136350631714,
-0.6632022857666016,
-0.19210070371627808,
0.08536411821842194,
0.32134804129600525,
-0.303791880607605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16352v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16352v1
|
MathGenie: Generating Synthetic Data with Question Back-translation for Enhancing Mathematical Reasoning of LLMs
| 2024-02-26T07:17:25 | 2024-02-26T07:17:25 |
Zimu Lu, Aojun Zhou, Houxing Ren, Ke Wang, Weikang Shi, Junting Pan, Mingjie Zhan, Hongsheng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited great potential in mathematical
reasoning. However, there remains a performance gap in this area between
existing open-source models and closed-source models such as GPT-4. In this
paper, we introduce MathGenie, a novel method for generating diverse and
reliable math problems from a small-scale problem-solution dataset (denoted as
seed data). We augment the ground-truth solutions of our seed data and train a
back-translation model to translate the augmented solutions back into new
questions. Subsequently, we generate code-integrated solutions for the new
questions. To ensure the correctness of the code-integrated solutions, we
employ rationale-based strategy for solution verification. Various pretrained
models, ranging from 7B to 70B, are trained on the newly curated data to test
the effectiveness of the proposed augmentation technique, resulting in a family
of models known as MathGenieLM. These models consistently outperform previous
open-source models across five representative mathematical reasoning datasets,
achieving state-of-the-art performance. In particular, MathGenieLM-InternLM2
achieves an accuracy of 87.7% on GSM8K and 55.7% on MATH, securing the best
overall score among open-source language models.
|
[
-0.4047054946422577,
-0.5052311420440674,
0.608308732509613,
0.35046902298927307,
-0.03216855227947235,
0.004983754828572273,
-0.3389528691768646,
-0.13355068862438202,
-0.07370118051767349,
0.45821264386177063,
-0.8691384196281433,
-0.6908485889434814,
-0.3616809546947479,
0.20378464460372925,
-0.0832286924123764,
0.7340556383132935,
-0.4139430522918701,
0.5345355868339539,
-0.5989545583724976,
-0.2692122459411621,
-0.349254846572876,
-0.579357385635376,
-0.12605020403862,
-0.44562509655952454,
0.08556026220321655,
0.3332134187221527,
0.6019511222839355,
0.28165203332901,
0.6844715476036072,
0.24088791012763977,
0.05250053107738495,
0.47862476110458374,
-0.5390154123306274,
0.007208315655589104,
-0.23285239934921265,
-0.9119625091552734,
-0.22083324193954468,
0.2399151623249054,
0.4833361804485321,
0.7574663758277893,
-0.14631186425685883,
0.23836606740951538,
-0.27987492084503174,
0.4332917630672455,
-0.39897578954696655,
0.03267434611916542,
-0.6856176257133484,
0.06826799362897873,
-0.11646967381238937,
-0.1716858297586441,
-0.454248309135437,
-0.9221899509429932,
-0.37934979796409607,
-0.7198407053947449,
0.2539536952972412,
-0.23357237875461578,
0.6124672293663025,
0.3532032370567322,
-0.17433279752731323,
-0.3573557734489441,
-0.8726756572723389,
0.9623699188232422,
-0.8163132667541504,
0.2910487949848175,
0.07279246300458908,
0.5851194858551025,
-0.46495458483695984,
-0.6612575054168701,
-0.5495628714561462,
-0.06775535643100739,
-0.024212144315242767,
0.17700451612472534,
-0.11680429428815842,
-0.42248496413230896,
0.6342239379882812,
0.41264307498931885,
-0.6984768509864807,
-0.32474279403686523,
-0.40978682041168213,
-0.055817801505327225,
0.6408885717391968,
0.12304335087537766,
0.49760928750038147,
0.1286533772945404,
-0.015517611987888813,
-0.14445997774600983,
-1.1284929513931274,
-0.24769994616508484,
0.5057108402252197,
0.050626933574676514,
0.059470340609550476,
0.9008656740188599,
-0.028756175190210342,
0.5868366360664368,
-0.21614249050617218,
-0.10891427099704742,
0.3587571978569031,
-0.24950098991394043,
-0.06284633278846741,
-0.05919431149959564,
0.3829258680343628,
-0.001039427239447832,
0.4008604884147644,
-0.07994778454303741,
-0.3074818253517151,
0.37428051233291626,
-0.1923665851354599,
-1.0142308473587036,
-0.20453011989593506,
0.2281624972820282,
-0.16538089513778687,
-0.441769003868103,
-0.08219625055789948,
-0.4256969094276428,
0.0030533000826835632,
-0.5028862357139587,
0.34457600116729736,
-0.5309075117111206,
-0.2082584649324417,
0.30316266417503357,
0.00758895929902792,
0.14747768640518188,
0.5338886976242065,
-0.617192268371582,
0.09020194411277771,
0.7522666454315186,
0.6375555396080017,
0.1045294776558876,
0.0859622210264206,
-0.6269515752792358,
-0.0699818804860115,
-0.626209020614624,
0.5667251944541931,
-0.5839391350746155,
-0.3567808270454407,
-0.14760592579841614,
-0.18554769456386566,
-0.13199104368686676,
-0.7620779275894165,
0.5957241058349609,
-0.5178207755088806,
0.45563703775405884,
-0.15583008527755737,
-0.6876527667045593,
0.04193088412284851,
0.3202742338180542,
-0.4144270718097687,
0.995427131652832,
0.2226596176624298,
-0.6027729511260986,
0.002528364071622491,
-0.5005244016647339,
-0.06612103432416916,
0.211837500333786,
-0.5399705171585083,
-0.24108664691448212,
0.32772746682167053,
0.4194425344467163,
-0.07319775968790054,
-0.4552275836467743,
0.3052959144115448,
-0.44184431433677673,
-0.2544470727443695,
0.36351752281188965,
-0.37811899185180664,
0.7447714805603027,
0.2976059317588806,
-0.04528895020484924,
-0.06409583985805511,
-0.8308827877044678,
0.2808164656162262,
0.3445090055465698,
-0.0206548310816288,
-0.3208160400390625,
-0.2771264910697937,
-0.39919593930244446,
0.39597293734550476,
0.18475906550884247,
-0.852103054523468,
0.2950824499130249,
-0.5597773790359497,
0.2987932860851288,
0.5524894595146179,
-0.19083748757839203,
0.23906776309013367,
-0.35966870188713074,
0.7307141423225403,
-0.14156930148601532,
-0.08773376047611237,
-0.28885117173194885,
-0.7907005548477173,
-0.48247581720352173,
-0.14826324582099915,
0.5699014067649841,
0.7268728613853455,
-0.9179285764694214,
0.09113970398902893,
-0.5190727710723877,
-0.46552392840385437,
-0.4013260006904602,
0.17039941251277924,
0.1340010166168213,
0.44420814514160156,
0.30835747718811035,
0.3597058653831482,
-0.2752760648727417,
-0.845280110836029,
-0.1814505010843277,
0.056899625808000565,
-0.3063715696334839,
0.5398238897323608,
0.613898515701294,
-0.32540056109428406,
0.983144998550415,
-0.7594126462936401,
0.023895008489489555,
-0.17837920784950256,
0.3351726531982422,
0.4732919931411743,
0.49407780170440674,
0.5209717154502869,
-0.7224555015563965,
-0.26494380831718445,
-0.0033169074449688196,
-0.9283764958381653,
-0.5495803356170654,
0.10037318617105484,
-0.3474712073802948,
-0.012515717186033726,
0.2959270775318146,
-0.6849783658981323,
0.29711416363716125,
0.7136974334716797,
-0.09895125031471252,
0.4483754336833954,
-0.10546483844518661,
0.1733018457889557,
-1.1989699602127075,
0.1028425395488739,
0.07040105760097504,
-0.187697172164917,
-0.4238448143005371,
0.27235499024391174,
0.07024198770523071,
-0.5377107262611389,
-0.2718120813369751,
0.49602025747299194,
-0.06661979109048843,
-0.10644397884607315,
-0.06876000016927719,
0.14274565875530243,
-0.08511626720428467,
0.2893960177898407,
-0.19807901978492737,
1.130147099494934,
0.09249027073383331,
-0.20945711433887482,
0.5760990977287292,
0.3582679033279419,
-0.24692848324775696,
0.42843231558799744,
-0.7740468978881836,
0.2124965637922287,
-0.17912179231643677,
0.2714861333370209,
-0.9754098057746887,
-0.33732494711875916,
0.2210037112236023,
-0.6515522003173828,
0.01110043004155159,
-0.4391269087791443,
-0.6541661620140076,
-0.3260852098464966,
-0.060405001044273376,
0.7703368067741394,
0.8270359039306641,
-0.7947181463241577,
0.8915449976921082,
-0.0015983299817889929,
-0.46398797631263733,
-0.20095112919807434,
-0.526024580001831,
-0.09134082496166229,
0.011371325701475143,
-1.3391516208648682,
0.3426178991794586,
-0.25908079743385315,
-0.47241443395614624,
0.2128644585609436,
-0.11637639999389648,
0.02733035758137703,
-0.10309931635856628,
-0.02636384218931198,
0.45376428961753845,
-0.3741494119167328,
0.2325228601694107,
0.2449447065591812,
-0.26436084508895874,
0.19798754155635834,
-0.5480853915214539,
0.49283546209335327,
-0.05363190174102783,
-0.5485691428184509,
0.13074086606502533,
0.4085438549518585,
0.4334962069988251,
-0.3746730387210846,
0.5193477869033813,
0.3948958218097687,
-0.6150000095367432,
-0.45730623602867126,
-0.37311169505119324,
-0.326235294342041,
-0.43252474069595337,
-0.0704522356390953,
-0.608956515789032,
-0.8057732582092285,
0.48875194787979126,
-0.4882912039756775,
0.20250506699085236,
0.46562373638153076,
0.6030401587486267,
0.07741264253854752,
1.3597713708877563,
0.15658563375473022,
0.30983734130859375,
-0.053412485867738724,
-0.3525457978248596,
0.20764851570129395,
-0.4348919689655304,
-0.17287658154964447,
-0.43002355098724365,
-0.06204359978437424,
-0.4280358552932739,
-0.7133610248565674,
0.5455114841461182,
0.1430775374174118,
0.14158956706523895,
0.04019598662853241,
-0.25394052267074585,
0.5673173069953918,
0.2530937194824219,
-0.04681950807571411,
0.31218138337135315,
0.23253361880779266,
-0.33232414722442627,
-0.2783184051513672,
-0.6366316676139832,
-0.47023963928222656,
1.0404245853424072,
0.2792915105819702,
0.9222062230110168,
0.26599934697151184,
0.7305231690406799,
-0.10939547419548035,
0.6917135715484619,
-0.530498743057251,
0.4506203234195709,
-0.18874269723892212,
-0.5395841002464294,
-0.12049313634634018,
-1.05210542678833,
-0.542527973651886,
0.36562860012054443,
-0.04496929422020912,
-0.40002021193504333,
-0.07107175886631012,
0.1607430875301361,
-0.29814884066581726,
0.13630862534046173,
-0.5464949607849121,
0.7422869205474854,
-0.2997353672981262,
-0.3994167149066925,
-0.18977169692516327,
-0.24450185894966125,
0.7869937419891357,
-0.28376004099845886,
0.39882102608680725,
-0.19509416818618774,
0.28045642375946045,
0.3558110296726227,
-0.7160295844078064,
0.4659039080142975,
-0.1253582388162613,
-0.5392868518829346,
0.3133789002895355,
0.22804056107997894,
0.7548329830169678,
0.20927461981773376,
0.16174432635307312,
0.2242114245891571,
-0.08977845311164856,
-0.287637859582901,
-1.0228173732757568,
0.8978316783905029,
-0.6488678455352783,
-0.7250250577926636,
-0.27682754397392273,
-0.6422548890113831,
-0.37852227687835693,
0.10742480307817459,
0.17944501340389252,
0.7151086926460266,
0.2691110372543335,
0.11442521214485168,
0.9516706466674805,
-0.34789949655532837,
-0.09507058560848236,
0.3362289071083069,
-0.5403007864952087,
-0.7055548429489136,
0.9596343636512756,
0.06917155534029007,
0.27160555124282837,
0.16558784246444702,
0.23750311136245728,
-0.29558059573173523,
-0.269783616065979,
-0.7553874850273132,
0.4468044638633728,
-0.7944552302360535,
-0.17128600180149078,
-0.4683021008968353,
-0.4516591429710388,
-0.33678701519966125,
-0.03900051862001419,
-0.32849031686782837,
-0.6479517817497253,
0.04953794181346893,
0.10411930829286575,
0.2573195695877075,
0.3191007375717163,
-0.0893222838640213,
-0.03763972595334053,
-0.9393858313560486,
0.380542516708374,
0.3741772174835205,
0.23801442980766296,
-0.4927619397640228,
-0.5040839314460754,
0.08318841457366943,
0.34197065234184265,
-0.05789477378129959,
-0.6908213496208191,
0.4027356505393982,
-0.21357321739196777,
0.4688935875892639,
-0.2140684723854065,
-0.23003536462783813,
0.4082988500595093,
-0.5874085426330566,
0.4694690704345703,
0.2117365449666977,
-0.8696532845497131,
0.6572704315185547,
-0.4169508218765259,
0.25465431809425354,
0.1865837574005127,
0.19181305170059204,
-0.28945255279541016,
-0.15482938289642334,
-0.557866632938385,
-0.47483640909194946,
0.4879922866821289,
0.6570063233375549,
0.09433670341968536,
0.20381468534469604,
0.4316312074661255,
0.08502107113599777,
0.1757088303565979,
-0.33196699619293213,
-0.08077418804168701,
-0.19829413294792175,
-0.6282504200935364,
0.1022752895951271,
-0.06965720653533936,
-0.25142529606819153,
-0.23545604944229126,
0.8655755519866943,
-0.2952040433883667,
0.16773100197315216,
-0.02184763364493847,
-0.16319337487220764,
-0.3683663010597229,
0.12277054786682129,
0.7766854763031006,
0.8465015888214111,
-0.24109888076782227,
-0.02701035514473915,
0.16323423385620117,
-0.3412610590457916,
0.3855968117713928,
0.47795140743255615,
-0.32239028811454773,
0.2175329327583313,
0.21537092328071594,
0.44993919134140015,
-0.01527198776602745,
-0.7457401752471924,
0.6026185750961304,
-0.23171237111091614,
-0.47036606073379517,
-0.5697231292724609,
0.11463691294193268,
-0.018260475248098373,
0.10553576052188873,
0.249107226729393,
0.06422138214111328,
-0.15094976127147675,
-0.21287687122821808,
0.2945813834667206,
0.4075116515159607,
0.07979297637939453,
-0.2299073338508606,
0.5923486948013306,
0.13146516680717468,
-0.07723774760961533,
0.5941416025161743,
-0.21433967351913452,
-0.4956526756286621,
0.6056708097457886,
0.675288736820221,
0.6601017117500305,
-0.27600499987602234,
0.2664574384689331,
0.4857293665409088,
0.27162134647369385,
0.04622829705476761,
0.6973493695259094,
0.20018430054187775,
-0.9346332550048828,
-0.8203890919685364,
-0.4421263337135315,
-0.3464241325855255,
0.2624989151954651,
-0.36560845375061035,
0.23503197729587555,
-0.31115221977233887,
0.017722245305776596,
-0.06678247451782227,
-0.17675665020942688,
-0.46398818492889404,
0.18443435430526733,
0.15264981985092163,
1.102493405342102,
-0.8837843537330627,
0.6501529216766357,
0.7539857625961304,
-0.2861168086528778,
-0.8138763904571533,
-0.15499143302440643,
-0.21453697979450226,
-0.913811445236206,
0.8425848484039307,
0.10964787751436234,
-0.11062178015708923,
0.1910220831632614,
-0.7862608432769775,
-0.8757955431938171,
0.9789825081825256,
0.5664335489273071,
-0.6531468629837036,
0.11898642033338547,
0.32827818393707275,
0.3628910481929779,
-0.3341398239135742,
0.20210310816764832,
0.3347650170326233,
0.3679252564907074,
0.6786929368972778,
-0.42478787899017334,
-0.11212996393442154,
-0.5206244587898254,
0.06525378674268723,
0.5546445846557617,
-0.27751630544662476,
0.8472719192504883,
-0.12643976509571075,
-0.16654978692531586,
0.21320052444934845,
0.5708549618721008,
0.760791540145874,
0.34334295988082886,
0.3272755742073059,
0.982243001461029,
0.7062923908233643,
-0.28729379177093506,
1.0012736320495605,
-0.504359245300293,
0.30777209997177124,
0.8712628483772278,
-0.31995889544487,
0.3846321702003479,
0.2875174880027771,
-0.061647891998291016,
0.43473392724990845,
0.34630489349365234,
-0.20718705654144287,
0.36075925827026367,
0.5026738047599792,
-0.36637943983078003,
-0.6257119178771973,
-0.03901375085115433,
-0.5556275844573975,
0.09634093940258026,
0.4732261896133423,
-0.2248920351266861,
-0.48733505606651306,
-0.045649562031030655,
-0.04419973865151405,
0.19121097028255463,
-0.14290252327919006,
0.36799970269203186,
0.2605632543563843,
-0.6500289440155029,
0.5178738832473755,
0.2751094400882721,
0.15551869571208954,
-0.592773973941803,
-0.4537615180015564,
-0.45659372210502625,
0.31836092472076416,
-0.08445718884468079,
-0.44968679547309875,
0.1367773711681366,
0.06136257201433182,
-0.03770074620842934,
0.078864187002182,
0.6629735827445984,
-0.6208915710449219,
-0.996012270450592,
-0.2678926885128021,
0.6931191682815552,
0.01134679839015007,
0.10792320966720581,
-0.4687310755252838,
0.08760687708854675,
-0.06263622641563416,
0.1974058598279953,
0.03023713082075119,
0.7091103792190552,
-0.15039533376693726,
0.6789553761482239,
1.054405689239502,
0.1633186787366867,
0.11223913729190826,
0.21957235038280487,
1.035064935684204,
-0.36024823784828186,
-0.41341620683670044,
-0.7631835341453552,
0.29440581798553467,
-0.19171787798404694,
-0.2151922583580017,
0.9112467169761658,
0.5960558652877808,
0.8726998567581177,
-0.13099020719528198,
0.9275650382041931,
0.36005961894989014,
0.38537541031837463,
-0.6997162699699402,
0.03556232899427414,
-0.3715366721153259,
0.39028120040893555,
-0.03814663365483284,
-0.9654015302658081,
-0.3509860932826996,
0.716816782951355,
-0.6406164169311523,
0.09171740710735321,
0.5405514240264893,
0.8321821093559265,
-0.3231264650821686,
0.2711528539657593,
0.269217848777771,
-0.04068811982870102,
0.5344511270523071,
0.805380642414093,
1.192539095878601,
-0.32015717029571533,
0.5112499594688416,
-0.18894167244434357,
-0.37471455335617065,
-0.03514930233359337,
-0.6443883180618286,
-0.9626259207725525,
0.03276591747999191,
-0.28333917260169983,
-0.45170485973358154,
-0.1107836663722992,
1.1427594423294067,
0.4547184705734253,
-0.875373125076294,
0.06361125409603119,
-0.47107961773872375,
-0.04068777710199356,
0.08840198814868927,
-0.2098439335823059,
0.06887737661600113,
-0.4986230134963989,
-0.6009519696235657,
0.3854265511035919,
0.20141655206680298,
0.16427475214004517,
-0.3444824814796448,
-0.0810709148645401,
0.3536122739315033,
0.3843621015548706,
0.3646092414855957,
0.030010422691702843,
-0.45613253116607666,
0.012477430514991283,
0.15313246846199036,
-0.09690424054861069,
-0.049965668469667435,
1.1752514839172363,
-0.6093841195106506,
0.18624483048915863,
0.5033284425735474,
0.8610780835151672,
0.3992016613483429,
0.13983593881130219,
0.7912418842315674,
-0.6060401201248169,
0.0625409409403801,
0.37041670083999634,
0.4910033941268921,
0.3184714913368225,
-0.23309069871902466,
0.6643034219741821,
0.6387033462524414,
-0.17367087304592133,
-0.8155393600463867,
0.4330664277076721,
-0.3746103048324585,
-0.2813051640987396,
1.2724107503890991,
-0.18763621151447296,
-0.20953470468521118,
0.36201012134552,
-0.16519588232040405,
-0.09144589304924011,
-0.0901435911655426,
0.6029038429260254,
0.7436973452568054,
0.11418162286281586,
-0.1062488853931427,
-0.4953177869319916,
0.2655150890350342,
0.4915957450866699,
-0.94676673412323,
-0.14266365766525269,
0.6890559792518616,
0.1834307312965393,
0.27239152789115906,
0.22602184116840363,
-0.40394914150238037,
0.23741067945957184,
0.03263623267412186,
-0.05316198617219925,
-0.3080516755580902,
-0.27979400753974915,
-0.10865484923124313,
0.30833399295806885,
-0.12391914427280426,
0.023065105080604553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16347v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16347v1
|
CodeS: Towards Building Open-source Language Models for Text-to-SQL
| 2024-02-26T07:00:58 | 2024-02-26T07:00:58 |
Haoyang Li, Jing Zhang, Hanbing Liu, Ju Fan, Xiaokang Zhang, Jun Zhu, Renjie Wei, Hongyan Pan, Cuiping Li, Hong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DB
|
Language models have shown promising performance on the task of translating
natural language questions into SQL queries (Text-to-SQL). However, most of the
state-of-the-art (SOTA) approaches rely on powerful yet closed-source large
language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, which may have the
limitations of unclear model architectures, data privacy risks, and expensive
inference overheads. To address the limitations, we introduce CodeS, a series
of pre-trained language models with parameters ranging from 1B to 15B,
specifically designed for the text-to-SQL task. CodeS is a fully open-source
language model, which achieves superior accuracy with much smaller parameter
sizes. This paper studies the research challenges in building CodeS. To enhance
the SQL generation abilities of CodeS, we adopt an incremental pre-training
approach using a specifically curated SQL-centric corpus. Based on this, we
address the challenges of schema linking and rapid domain adaptation through
strategic prompt construction and a bi-directional data augmentation technique.
We conduct comprehensive evaluations on multiple datasets, including the widely
used Spider benchmark, the newly released BIRD benchmark, robustness-diagnostic
benchmarks such as Spider-DK, Spider-Syn, Spider-Realistic, and Dr.Spider, as
well as two real-world datasets created for financial and academic
applications. The experimental results show that our CodeS achieves new SOTA
accuracy and robustness on nearly all challenging text-to-SQL benchmarks.
|
[
-0.15101474523544312,
-0.6330158114433289,
0.4031006395816803,
0.17155933380126953,
-0.2590153217315674,
0.06612367182970047,
-0.3521043062210083,
-0.4410972595214844,
-0.10916665941476822,
0.7854394316673279,
-0.40021732449531555,
-0.5803321003913879,
-0.342781126499176,
0.35801348090171814,
-0.5243154168128967,
1.2594965696334839,
0.07900585979223251,
0.19631655514240265,
-0.20604687929153442,
-0.15132810175418854,
-0.2270144373178482,
-1.0210814476013184,
-0.08284828811883926,
0.44790512323379517,
0.11699022352695465,
0.3159196674823761,
0.7331101894378662,
0.45816925168037415,
0.5120285749435425,
0.1507686972618103,
0.10585930198431015,
0.2153603881597519,
-0.5603135228157043,
0.05971710383892059,
-0.3737884759902954,
-0.44863253831863403,
-0.4925660789012909,
-0.19683657586574554,
0.36541813611984253,
0.572791337966919,
-0.1379566192626953,
0.23824718594551086,
-0.0162564218044281,
0.7533039450645447,
-0.40772634744644165,
0.40843361616134644,
-0.7556101083755493,
-0.09576788544654846,
-0.2894584536552429,
-0.36960068345069885,
-0.622111976146698,
-0.7436888217926025,
-0.014468376524746418,
-0.4076155424118042,
0.05096862092614174,
0.06270378082990646,
0.8745938539505005,
0.15237192809581757,
-0.35030317306518555,
-0.687105119228363,
-0.5439258813858032,
0.43388035893440247,
-0.7023143768310547,
0.39365729689598083,
0.27861127257347107,
0.26364773511886597,
-0.1657513529062271,
-0.8167530298233032,
-0.3464255630970001,
-0.44193220138549805,
-0.16467371582984924,
-0.3341616988182068,
-0.012373434379696846,
-0.2010500133037567,
0.29668766260147095,
0.36916857957839966,
-0.5846808552742004,
-0.1078968420624733,
-0.32713499665260315,
0.142391175031662,
0.6673949956893921,
0.021293828263878822,
0.254877507686615,
0.07621222734451294,
-0.15465685725212097,
0.07346198707818985,
-0.9516460299491882,
-0.24782319366931915,
0.30576053261756897,
0.7000169157981873,
-0.06956797093153,
0.7710088491439819,
-0.22939513623714447,
0.7479972243309021,
-0.14241798222064972,
0.3371630012989044,
0.03230724483728409,
-0.7871963381767273,
-0.12164488434791565,
-0.22577284276485443,
0.5936177372932434,
0.028517553582787514,
0.5939746499061584,
-0.39060598611831665,
-0.2004140168428421,
0.18087293207645416,
0.4042074382305145,
-0.7358759045600891,
-0.3360263407230377,
0.33288249373435974,
-0.4122646152973175,
-0.3812657296657562,
-0.30788466334342957,
-0.7179152369499207,
-0.3654438853263855,
-0.3623810410499573,
0.3616103529930115,
-0.3536107838153839,
-0.28851282596588135,
0.16952258348464966,
0.2579829692840576,
0.2127196192741394,
0.04983328655362129,
-0.6749039888381958,
0.22121505439281464,
0.4016594886779785,
0.5073729157447815,
-0.053906187415122986,
-0.10752231627702713,
-0.4721165895462036,
0.1322561800479889,
-0.610797643661499,
0.6424579620361328,
-0.5422140955924988,
-0.37443605065345764,
0.16726425290107727,
-0.02074672281742096,
0.20881393551826477,
-0.3365575969219208,
0.2483575940132141,
-0.640402615070343,
0.26142966747283936,
-0.12859471142292023,
-0.5181202292442322,
0.3275565207004547,
0.021905802190303802,
-0.5932751893997192,
0.9371220469474792,
0.32379722595214844,
-0.6913980841636658,
0.3167004883289337,
-0.782053530216217,
-0.4884091019630432,
0.206894651055336,
-0.5136805772781372,
-0.38831189274787903,
0.15140503644943237,
0.06520547717809677,
0.3325236439704895,
-0.6083895564079285,
0.2721901834011078,
-0.20294766128063202,
-0.28043124079704285,
0.245452418923378,
0.0733075886964798,
0.8600099086761475,
0.4234294295310974,
-0.13344243168830872,
0.2590978741645813,
-0.7903361916542053,
0.29273179173469543,
0.3536595106124878,
-0.2648703157901764,
-0.17422854900360107,
0.10034559667110443,
-0.008428092114627361,
-0.06493448466062546,
0.10360708832740784,
-0.11009051650762558,
0.3302907943725586,
-0.45118653774261475,
0.5221538543701172,
0.5003774166107178,
-0.20741496980190277,
0.5222823023796082,
-0.08765457570552826,
0.4419257938861847,
-0.061561815440654755,
0.2218826860189438,
-0.34343624114990234,
-0.2728188931941986,
-0.3670977056026459,
-0.2025349736213684,
0.37856605648994446,
0.5177738666534424,
-0.9176192879676819,
0.5648525953292847,
-0.32302504777908325,
-0.5337322950363159,
-0.262240469455719,
-0.06684866547584534,
0.32513412833213806,
0.05445181205868721,
0.4469182789325714,
-0.3933285176753998,
-0.6762400269508362,
-0.41360795497894287,
-0.4950321912765503,
-0.03660203889012337,
-0.09853357076644897,
0.35406672954559326,
0.4163873493671417,
-0.04247521609067917,
1.0078887939453125,
-0.6940565705299377,
-0.2499465048313141,
-0.09969764947891235,
-0.22142156958580017,
0.20696760714054108,
0.470378577709198,
0.598344624042511,
-0.6116055846214294,
-0.5317520499229431,
0.09957777708768845,
-0.6768050789833069,
0.09440242499113083,
0.03251398727297783,
-0.037933479994535446,
0.4675390124320984,
0.6342229247093201,
-0.4777701795101166,
0.3862844407558441,
0.526961624622345,
-0.5237768292427063,
0.7632758021354675,
-0.15451616048812866,
0.1393742710351944,
-1.1492139101028442,
0.13676555454730988,
-0.004478632006794214,
-0.07146169990301132,
-0.6559271812438965,
0.38245001435279846,
0.23430278897285461,
-0.4990207254886627,
-0.23977141082286835,
0.2898350656032562,
-0.6621379852294922,
-0.1973201036453247,
0.09278255701065063,
-0.2078227996826172,
-0.07331540435552597,
0.45435798168182373,
0.25192394852638245,
1.0815883874893188,
0.5253309011459351,
-0.5976809859275818,
0.10461430251598358,
0.3956342041492462,
-0.5747472643852234,
0.48554837703704834,
-0.5800756216049194,
0.36985698342323303,
0.09808725118637085,
0.2075936496257782,
-0.5688579082489014,
-0.10818690061569214,
0.06493572145700455,
-0.43911853432655334,
0.2728164792060852,
-0.39832744002342224,
-0.7291771173477173,
-0.06136126071214676,
-0.11847531050443649,
0.3676879107952118,
0.6003963947296143,
-0.5261436700820923,
0.3698630928993225,
0.46991369128227234,
-0.32644540071487427,
-0.39524388313293457,
-0.7883291840553284,
0.29448679089546204,
0.19401174783706665,
-0.391166627407074,
0.2675971984863281,
0.002445487305521965,
-0.0702342540025711,
0.046285685151815414,
-0.056935835629701614,
-0.4408339262008667,
-0.20361217856407166,
-0.06646913290023804,
0.44131529331207275,
-0.4185188412666321,
0.30146706104278564,
-0.06673090904951096,
-0.05701253563165665,
-0.058257631957530975,
-0.6259707808494568,
0.48136448860168457,
-0.13106200098991394,
-0.3158402442932129,
0.08478198945522308,
0.3975546360015869,
0.3391415476799011,
-0.7317206263542175,
0.6978070735931396,
-0.11847071349620819,
-0.16568154096603394,
-0.44785967469215393,
-0.28147050738334656,
-0.1699943244457245,
-0.4276856780052185,
0.43110913038253784,
-0.6546786427497864,
-1.0503308773040771,
0.16690902411937714,
-0.1249641701579094,
0.1394532322883606,
0.13883954286575317,
0.5614473223686218,
0.10559272021055222,
0.673414409160614,
0.8600634336471558,
0.31632423400878906,
0.4050200879573822,
0.09869188815355301,
0.526698112487793,
-0.09714896231889725,
-0.16087685525417328,
-1.1267523765563965,
0.45019516348838806,
-0.4894748628139496,
-0.781852662563324,
0.09962303936481476,
0.07210774719715118,
-0.32124805450439453,
0.7310803532600403,
-0.7824877500534058,
0.6634896993637085,
0.05593841150403023,
0.02727590501308441,
0.4706431031227112,
0.12245506793260574,
0.16229407489299774,
0.035947758704423904,
-0.6443127989768982,
-0.3462558686733246,
1.2565650939941406,
0.243521586060524,
0.9883840084075928,
0.1696494221687317,
0.5733347535133362,
0.28350624442100525,
0.18392302095890045,
-0.3109276592731476,
0.5154939293861389,
-0.3205729126930237,
-0.7268999218940735,
-0.2309841513633728,
-0.6183640360832214,
-0.6896211504936218,
-0.24917343258857727,
-0.22345592081546783,
-0.4202164113521576,
0.20891506969928741,
0.10051586478948593,
-0.1619836688041687,
0.11977160722017288,
-0.812883734703064,
0.9236419796943665,
-0.23871059715747833,
-0.4157821238040924,
0.009434802457690239,
-0.57267826795578,
0.15362200140953064,
-0.33000174164772034,
0.2710492014884949,
0.13216863572597504,
-0.09462927281856537,
0.31039750576019287,
-0.49836108088493347,
0.7039189338684082,
-0.1314227432012558,
-0.28781822323799133,
0.4110220670700073,
0.06912636011838913,
0.7554696798324585,
-0.08431749045848846,
-0.21771377325057983,
0.37439489364624023,
0.33498892188072205,
-0.5771753787994385,
-0.3817983567714691,
0.41378214955329895,
-0.3885532021522522,
-0.16372328996658325,
-0.24479436874389648,
-0.41618186235427856,
-0.3809581995010376,
0.17172695696353912,
0.08909682929515839,
0.502575159072876,
-0.0990997850894928,
0.20955756306648254,
0.6754084229469299,
-0.48581650853157043,
0.11552871018648148,
0.5599188804626465,
-0.3281850814819336,
-0.25725144147872925,
0.7525377869606018,
0.04247983172535896,
0.2868490219116211,
0.3591490387916565,
-0.25745540857315063,
-0.5527402758598328,
-0.7267724275588989,
-0.5834586024284363,
0.10608337819576263,
-0.6673204302787781,
-0.4090954065322876,
-0.5016157627105713,
-0.33427727222442627,
-0.5457485318183899,
-0.08290402591228485,
-0.3708125054836273,
-0.2700311243534088,
-0.20397458970546722,
-0.00812053494155407,
0.6947017908096313,
0.7258049845695496,
0.39213696122169495,
-0.15814067423343658,
-0.9780454039573669,
0.11636601388454437,
-0.12349281460046768,
0.8873617053031921,
-0.23865991830825806,
-0.20471961796283722,
-0.47625732421875,
-0.21371006965637207,
0.34283092617988586,
-1.0264291763305664,
0.1585395187139511,
0.09125672280788422,
0.3561945855617523,
-0.28450456261634827,
0.31408870220184326,
0.5561061501502991,
-0.5521875619888306,
0.7135072946548462,
0.17516416311264038,
-0.9794962406158447,
0.6860437989234924,
-0.3688967227935791,
-0.016082480549812317,
0.7305269241333008,
0.38670364022254944,
-0.0030114229302853346,
-0.29064634442329407,
-0.33300966024398804,
-0.5454800724983215,
0.7103272080421448,
0.29151013493537903,
0.21133019030094147,
-0.046689968556165695,
0.46312084794044495,
0.1602822095155716,
0.34220582246780396,
-0.7565568685531616,
-0.03592995926737785,
-0.21191419661045074,
-0.2384905219078064,
0.005614323541522026,
-0.23824289441108704,
0.03185812756419182,
-0.11584282666444778,
0.35943523049354553,
-0.4670448303222656,
0.22691847383975983,
0.003385283285751939,
-0.18944327533245087,
0.17416919767856598,
0.4306465685367584,
0.31017160415649414,
0.6664392948150635,
-0.0974837988615036,
-0.20795206725597382,
0.1877407282590866,
-0.33655020594596863,
0.06830063462257385,
0.14684458076953888,
0.011051386594772339,
-0.11319289356470108,
0.027609191834926605,
0.3436855375766754,
0.08966135233640671,
-0.8660697937011719,
0.6433896422386169,
-0.1405886858701706,
-0.16972586512565613,
-0.0996473878622055,
-0.1769818663597107,
0.14807195961475372,
-0.0037799354176968336,
0.11967936903238297,
0.09539030492305756,
-0.013613303191959858,
-0.6743815541267395,
0.36276766657829285,
0.35741665959358215,
-0.4405097961425781,
-0.1749216765165329,
0.5929534435272217,
0.4449518918991089,
-0.28307345509529114,
0.504977822303772,
-0.28849148750305176,
-0.17592297494411469,
0.3726264238357544,
0.5390568375587463,
0.7646329402923584,
0.0028380975127220154,
-0.020596884191036224,
0.35086438059806824,
0.33852362632751465,
-0.11763252317905426,
0.6985514760017395,
-0.1704540252685547,
-0.3853839635848999,
-0.6804722547531128,
-0.6016527414321899,
-0.4461532533168793,
-0.19601917266845703,
-0.5699480175971985,
0.5261589884757996,
-0.46485602855682373,
0.12829270958900452,
-0.23342517018318176,
-0.033245258033275604,
-0.40113958716392517,
0.01995099149644375,
-0.23918679356575012,
1.287503957748413,
-0.559211254119873,
1.2318601608276367,
0.5858827829360962,
-0.7525524497032166,
-0.8372572064399719,
-0.19040296971797943,
-0.37845656275749207,
-0.5314670205116272,
0.24779681861400604,
-0.2203167974948883,
0.13811931014060974,
0.1806766539812088,
-0.6485918164253235,
-0.6416361927986145,
0.57975834608078,
0.5024299025535583,
-0.6412543058395386,
-0.34660452604293823,
0.24575337767601013,
0.5865988731384277,
-0.4443238377571106,
0.11089463531970978,
0.6769577860832214,
0.14883404970169067,
-0.08998113125562668,
-0.9293986558914185,
0.172951802611351,
-0.2966620624065399,
-0.012674286030232906,
0.41219010949134827,
-0.18983906507492065,
0.8404663801193237,
-0.41826146841049194,
-0.2566632628440857,
0.2368299663066864,
0.46213388442993164,
0.3270084261894226,
0.16386915743350983,
0.26601386070251465,
0.21308748424053192,
0.46094024181365967,
-0.10054510831832886,
1.109316110610962,
-0.6588199138641357,
0.3281652629375458,
1.2079198360443115,
-0.5910560488700867,
0.9169920086860657,
0.27961069345474243,
-0.5002644062042236,
0.5055192112922668,
0.28535914421081543,
-0.0921190083026886,
0.355091392993927,
0.44529709219932556,
-0.03328483924269676,
0.0549345463514328,
0.039106909185647964,
-0.6858923435211182,
0.10742852091789246,
0.3110280930995941,
-0.2722418010234833,
-0.14841334521770477,
-0.2968268394470215,
-0.04873836040496826,
0.4202724099159241,
0.03784286975860596,
0.813054084777832,
0.00608373899012804,
-0.47218483686447144,
0.4321404993534088,
-0.14183694124221802,
0.6027239561080933,
-0.8491190671920776,
-0.08756640553474426,
-0.27075520157814026,
0.11610579490661621,
-0.2770004868507385,
-0.65000319480896,
0.6573179364204407,
0.34556934237480164,
-0.03938308358192444,
-0.3369777798652649,
0.7460137009620667,
-0.38563790917396545,
-0.15855151414871216,
0.17553389072418213,
0.3847724497318268,
0.18190523982048035,
-0.24438954889774323,
-0.5290572047233582,
0.19552020728588104,
0.14278261363506317,
0.05833657458424568,
0.44888150691986084,
0.5333446860313416,
0.019759181886911392,
0.30755674839019775,
0.9030174016952515,
0.1830950379371643,
0.04370703175663948,
0.10938259214162827,
0.8827305436134338,
-0.7896782755851746,
-0.6753491759300232,
-0.5322108268737793,
0.43335863947868347,
-0.03361809253692627,
-0.17523770034313202,
0.5782559514045715,
0.8126019239425659,
0.7417460680007935,
-0.3170877695083618,
0.725579023361206,
-0.15976785123348236,
0.6568500995635986,
-0.5668242573738098,
0.9109784960746765,
-0.4868037700653076,
0.5693057179450989,
-0.18506471812725067,
-0.8882486820220947,
-0.3031964600086212,
0.24227066338062286,
-0.12807157635688782,
0.06034082919359207,
0.694653332233429,
1.011846661567688,
0.3978153169155121,
0.18687257170677185,
0.20611004531383514,
0.22323693335056305,
0.38194578886032104,
0.5536813735961914,
0.7887648344039917,
-0.393196165561676,
0.9677454233169556,
0.06800612807273865,
-0.2795562148094177,
-0.194350466132164,
-0.8601167798042297,
-0.7703113555908203,
-0.6900556683540344,
-0.39791521430015564,
-0.6277243494987488,
0.2626301646232605,
0.8224074840545654,
0.7928014993667603,
-0.9169099926948547,
-0.4233206510543823,
-0.33324405550956726,
-0.07226774096488953,
-0.09868033975362778,
-0.14776267111301422,
0.3298577666282654,
-0.6129023432731628,
-0.41713863611221313,
0.31377193331718445,
0.37743034958839417,
0.05500958859920502,
-0.24977634847164154,
-0.1683240830898285,
-0.08191759139299393,
0.3467736542224884,
0.7064531445503235,
0.3437885344028473,
-0.29952847957611084,
-0.07578855752944946,
0.10167521983385086,
-0.4839721918106079,
0.003436919068917632,
0.9371474385261536,
-0.7367788553237915,
0.27984902262687683,
0.3984880745410919,
0.703703761100769,
0.3540850877761841,
-0.12379557639360428,
0.6608145236968994,
-0.7538490891456604,
0.0490221343934536,
0.48025402426719666,
0.021780697628855705,
0.05786610022187233,
-0.33312803506851196,
0.8928243517875671,
-0.007861712947487831,
-0.4915516674518585,
-1.1641974449157715,
0.28176969289779663,
-0.7932314872741699,
-0.5514125823974609,
0.9538983106613159,
-0.09791550040245056,
-0.054536737501621246,
-0.3400193750858307,
-0.10066591948270798,
-0.02699255384504795,
0.0006070695235393941,
0.46976831555366516,
0.33883392810821533,
0.05683407559990883,
-0.04700392112135887,
-0.36399468779563904,
0.8771085739135742,
0.1645662784576416,
-1.196988582611084,
0.36226460337638855,
0.4121381640434265,
0.269162118434906,
-0.004414027091115713,
0.8556210398674011,
-0.6043898463249207,
0.31282752752304077,
0.37775367498397827,
0.2313639372587204,
-0.032182712107896805,
-0.2864757478237152,
-0.3639673590660095,
0.31150752305984497,
0.2743612229824066,
0.024788154289126396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16333v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16333v2
|
Unveiling the Truth and Facilitating Change: Towards Agent-based Large-scale Social Movement Simulation
| 2024-02-26T06:28:54 | 2024-06-17T05:37:35 |
Xinyi Mou, Zhongyu Wei, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Social media has emerged as a cornerstone of social movements, wielding
significant influence in driving societal change. Simulating the response of
the public and forecasting the potential impact has become increasingly
important. However, existing methods for simulating such phenomena encounter
challenges concerning their efficacy and efficiency in capturing the behaviors
of social movement participants. In this paper, we introduce a hybrid framework
HiSim for social media user simulation, wherein users are categorized into two
types. Core users are driven by Large Language Models, while numerous ordinary
users are modeled by deductive agent-based models. We further construct a
Twitter-like environment to replicate their response dynamics following trigger
events. Subsequently, we develop a multi-faceted benchmark SoMoSiMu-Bench for
evaluation and conduct comprehensive experiments across real-world datasets.
Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness and flexibility of our
method.
|
[
-0.08121778815984726,
-0.9285971522331238,
0.4213241636753082,
0.16615433990955353,
0.0009426870965398848,
0.6789621114730835,
-0.16144196689128876,
-0.060841601341962814,
0.5239635109901428,
0.3096165359020233,
-0.6456376314163208,
-0.18218424916267395,
-0.3378349542617798,
-0.21467392146587372,
-0.6370816826820374,
0.5264768600463867,
-0.006199617870151997,
-0.14688217639923096,
0.11139644682407379,
-0.1999479979276657,
-0.08112894743680954,
-0.3962627649307251,
-0.6128107905387878,
-0.39510393142700195,
0.5110083818435669,
0.3643086552619934,
0.6190399527549744,
0.19905583560466766,
0.26217183470726013,
0.35341349244117737,
0.06530443578958511,
0.27796998620033264,
-0.95648193359375,
-0.10781659930944443,
-0.38789403438568115,
-0.20971748232841492,
-0.10309083759784698,
0.2271297723054886,
0.7661639451980591,
0.2905927002429962,
-0.2296212911605835,
0.3100297451019287,
-0.03553888201713562,
0.28299418091773987,
-0.48232409358024597,
-0.06536619365215302,
-0.23905543982982635,
-0.25662118196487427,
-0.044825468212366104,
-0.1315065324306488,
-0.07557910680770874,
-0.23271436989307404,
-0.2515997290611267,
-0.4494302570819855,
0.018512681126594543,
0.037430744618177414,
0.4787718653678894,
-0.11604514718055725,
-0.8189602494239807,
0.2527468800544739,
-1.3568655252456665,
0.5006048679351807,
-0.5584220886230469,
0.28544455766677856,
-0.10070597380399704,
0.8916362524032593,
-0.26451459527015686,
-0.7113582491874695,
-0.925665557384491,
-0.0638921707868576,
0.45293980836868286,
0.1763375997543335,
0.14938077330589294,
-0.284274160861969,
0.42792612314224243,
-0.0853603333234787,
-0.18600501120090485,
-0.11453332751989365,
-0.3925236463546753,
0.1110529899597168,
0.9466660022735596,
0.44592317938804626,
0.21024206280708313,
-0.0977599024772644,
-0.6934220194816589,
-0.34726962447166443,
-0.43516066670417786,
0.16529247164726257,
0.45276227593421936,
0.3043605089187622,
-0.4758369028568268,
0.5342124104499817,
-0.24311448633670807,
0.19849859178066254,
-0.0024291027802973986,
-0.4372202754020691,
0.4592536389827728,
-0.24464944005012512,
0.005123382434248924,
-0.2611866593360901,
0.769266664981842,
0.6642576456069946,
0.11451564729213715,
-0.072966068983078,
-0.17044676840305328,
0.2730454206466675,
0.16501542925834656,
-0.9623730182647705,
0.204803928732872,
0.18435634672641754,
-0.6333401799201965,
-0.11335332691669464,
0.13720549643039703,
-0.7814106345176697,
-0.9011204242706299,
-0.42086464166641235,
0.5154873132705688,
-0.4838508069515228,
-0.8814312219619751,
0.06595240533351898,
-0.20533986389636993,
0.21159781515598297,
0.7767728567123413,
-0.21596434712409973,
0.4546409249305725,
0.5494571924209595,
0.8947802782058716,
-0.15393495559692383,
-0.4469078481197357,
-0.3793499171733856,
0.42464715242385864,
-0.1611146628856659,
0.5713816285133362,
-0.5565962195396423,
-0.39111950993537903,
0.28275561332702637,
-0.18873389065265656,
-0.28850868344306946,
-0.33562222123146057,
0.21365462243556976,
-0.7609719634056091,
-0.5323688983917236,
-0.7130663990974426,
-0.6636869311332703,
-0.016028806567192078,
0.33514404296875,
-0.6122170686721802,
0.9716634154319763,
0.11413263529539108,
-0.608909547328949,
0.2864697575569153,
-0.9044370651245117,
-0.31750911474227905,
-0.041503436863422394,
-0.28647246956825256,
-0.22305989265441895,
0.05172592028975487,
-0.43399059772491455,
0.3407345116138458,
-0.3239838778972626,
0.21003691852092743,
-0.4624723792076111,
-0.4884953498840332,
0.41949108242988586,
0.012864372693002224,
0.5129983425140381,
0.09951094537973404,
-0.4629949629306793,
0.3316084146499634,
-0.7099940180778503,
-0.43579697608947754,
0.2149452120065689,
-0.043129801750183105,
-0.08437050133943558,
0.21344441175460815,
0.47223854064941406,
0.5526983737945557,
-0.18315818905830383,
-0.8328670263290405,
0.30997857451438904,
0.4645349681377411,
0.44879940152168274,
0.7014830708503723,
0.252742201089859,
0.4296608567237854,
-0.45149144530296326,
0.4203730821609497,
0.1454934924840927,
0.10447826981544495,
0.14994637668132782,
-0.387926310300827,
0.07224217057228088,
-0.2585880160331726,
0.21377922594547272,
0.18711766600608826,
-1.1214042901992798,
-0.14892394840717316,
-0.3665328621864319,
-0.48446762561798096,
-0.3217622935771942,
0.10296466946601868,
-0.13335807621479034,
0.11550477147102356,
0.18453872203826904,
0.14797718822956085,
-0.41046878695487976,
-0.46149033308029175,
-0.3771751821041107,
-0.49129271507263184,
0.0437484048306942,
0.06343544274568558,
0.7346525192260742,
-0.5747621059417725,
1.0278210639953613,
-0.12521149218082428,
-0.04898277670145035,
-0.5716448426246643,
0.5243933200836182,
-0.36014482378959656,
0.15628890693187714,
0.48742884397506714,
-1.214118480682373,
-0.40191030502319336,
-0.196483314037323,
-0.6002870798110962,
-0.13528993725776672,
-0.45768311619758606,
-0.15295204520225525,
-0.05217892676591873,
0.528106153011322,
-0.3910638689994812,
0.6412115097045898,
0.5144851207733154,
-0.3183072507381439,
0.5336848497390747,
-0.015051521360874176,
0.6913536190986633,
-1.3490560054779053,
0.14656385779380798,
0.21474067866802216,
-0.28849947452545166,
-0.7471014857292175,
0.05095360428094864,
0.07923038303852081,
-0.23639434576034546,
-0.6406605243682861,
0.5648900270462036,
-0.2852039933204651,
-0.2677850127220154,
-0.49698930978775024,
-0.12742416560649872,
-0.46902114152908325,
0.14339739084243774,
-0.09539102762937546,
0.5504239201545715,
0.22233906388282776,
-0.47276681661605835,
0.27802929282188416,
-0.10436002165079117,
-0.17837531864643097,
0.4234335124492645,
-0.6724205017089844,
0.021598530933260918,
-0.19679448008537292,
0.39959532022476196,
-1.0044397115707397,
-0.447744756937027,
0.15506300330162048,
-0.19791410863399506,
-0.015400711447000504,
-0.035827651619911194,
-1.1430379152297974,
-0.5460246801376343,
-0.458149254322052,
0.20400673151016235,
0.667016863822937,
-0.3019833266735077,
1.2165446281433105,
0.5531547665596008,
0.5383908748626709,
0.01782715693116188,
-0.26875805854797363,
0.2897205948829651,
-0.23437730967998505,
-0.6838319897651672,
0.17161372303962708,
-0.024412397295236588,
-0.3973269760608673,
-0.1521005779504776,
0.04764346033334732,
0.35880979895591736,
-0.06757291406393051,
0.5396518111228943,
-0.13960497081279755,
0.14100931584835052,
-0.125325009226799,
-0.11378323286771774,
0.05786724388599396,
-0.07527248561382294,
0.16352315247058868,
0.6765172481536865,
0.030237911269068718,
-0.5017575025558472,
-0.6334654092788696,
0.5572961568832397,
0.7817330360412598,
-0.15336643159389496,
0.7168753147125244,
0.6841906905174255,
-0.4076201319694519,
-0.13841618597507477,
-0.521589457988739,
-0.4054531455039978,
-0.48805707693099976,
0.1651742309331894,
-0.17725016176700592,
-0.6732512712478638,
0.7967085242271423,
-0.7704670429229736,
0.24165204167366028,
-0.22184617817401886,
0.8360004425048828,
-0.12943808734416962,
1.016281247138977,
0.5516812801361084,
0.10895194113254547,
0.5857855677604675,
-0.34475988149642944,
-0.017924148589372635,
-0.5017662048339844,
-0.13690361380577087,
-0.33058789372444153,
-0.7682399153709412,
-0.40487831830978394,
-0.7867480516433716,
0.47012436389923096,
-0.19269849359989166,
0.14426684379577637,
0.514805793762207,
0.3663990795612335,
-0.004510028287768364,
0.40122002363204956,
-0.0334165096282959,
0.190324068069458,
0.08113539963960648,
0.09640021622180939,
-0.05813811346888542,
-0.5393866896629333,
-0.5888531804084778,
0.7413151860237122,
0.16355301439762115,
1.0531511306762695,
0.2389155477285385,
0.7101442813873291,
0.607100248336792,
0.8212605714797974,
-0.42030906677246094,
0.8997536897659302,
0.4681040048599243,
-0.8086687922477722,
-0.24563667178153992,
-0.5681666135787964,
-0.722046434879303,
0.4127252399921417,
-0.5505421161651611,
-0.721146821975708,
0.20949646830558777,
0.2631605565547943,
-0.17663215100765228,
0.5705371499061584,
-0.45884162187576294,
0.599795401096344,
0.04623284935951233,
-0.640885055065155,
-0.5085623264312744,
-0.5719063878059387,
-0.05240819230675697,
0.06149408221244812,
0.5005138516426086,
-0.29130974411964417,
0.024749068543314934,
0.5670207738876343,
-0.36063194274902344,
1.1987735033035278,
-0.33030593395233154,
0.17794106900691986,
0.5517227053642273,
-0.0036614323034882545,
0.43425846099853516,
-0.16239912807941437,
-0.07494394481182098,
-0.12980809807777405,
-0.1541966050863266,
-0.5104981660842896,
-0.6322541832923889,
0.5790348649024963,
-0.8805379271507263,
-0.3675491213798523,
-0.06059853732585907,
-0.3729907274246216,
-0.16293521225452423,
-0.11023322492837906,
-0.021768298000097275,
0.31767240166664124,
-0.6554638743400574,
0.07068590074777603,
0.2949466407299042,
0.19233857095241547,
0.4108492136001587,
0.8594186305999756,
-0.38455307483673096,
-0.1526937186717987,
0.6837461590766907,
0.4431556165218353,
0.09604881703853607,
0.005100672598928213,
0.5370240807533264,
-0.22528298199176788,
-0.18172532320022583,
-0.6002745032310486,
0.2550355792045593,
-0.21049712598323822,
0.12251047790050507,
-0.7349266409873962,
0.17012815177440643,
-0.45574766397476196,
-0.1352972686290741,
-0.34416255354881287,
-0.028743479400873184,
0.3359094560146332,
-0.1204964891076088,
0.12265985459089279,
0.5219981074333191,
-0.32997480034828186,
0.5982680320739746,
-0.47338950634002686,
0.4991081655025482,
0.3479192554950714,
0.07145678997039795,
0.02744501456618309,
-0.22975920140743256,
-0.374835342168808,
0.28486716747283936,
-0.3933878540992737,
-1.3708909749984741,
0.09284955263137817,
-0.058448463678359985,
0.5250570178031921,
0.589150071144104,
0.4570586383342743,
0.578800618648529,
-0.5087913870811462,
0.6242276430130005,
0.21293342113494873,
-0.5140726566314697,
0.36255329847335815,
-0.6023352146148682,
-0.09742748737335205,
0.5703199505805969,
0.47870248556137085,
-0.7002927660942078,
-0.2926054298877716,
-0.7110595107078552,
-0.5880613923072815,
0.49857965111732483,
0.40184077620506287,
0.340609610080719,
0.1349816471338272,
0.280011922121048,
-0.029009299352765083,
0.34981492161750793,
-0.31593191623687744,
-0.1730857938528061,
-0.07856600731611252,
-0.011546486057341099,
-0.14405176043510437,
-0.028030620887875557,
-0.1989772468805313,
-0.23735672235488892,
0.48529252409935,
-0.10792424529790878,
-0.038626138120889664,
-0.03336751088500023,
-0.002737359842285514,
-0.46024370193481445,
-0.12283340841531754,
0.29118990898132324,
0.7817760109901428,
-0.25328949093818665,
-0.06396013498306274,
-0.12765440344810486,
-0.3477685749530792,
0.29854467511177063,
0.0014144678134471178,
-0.5507134795188904,
0.002615265781059861,
0.08472298085689545,
0.5165190100669861,
0.21316975355148315,
-0.6932085156440735,
0.6216670274734497,
0.018039898946881294,
-0.5025016665458679,
-0.2242581844329834,
0.06003636494278908,
0.46975964307785034,
0.523198127746582,
0.5724612474441528,
-0.13735926151275635,
0.3043849468231201,
-1.0301120281219482,
0.017613854259252548,
0.05177101492881775,
-0.3454348146915436,
-0.8118939399719238,
0.8364548087120056,
0.33551692962646484,
-0.6042063236236572,
-0.03181375563144684,
-0.17997430264949799,
-0.41701656579971313,
0.5577779412269592,
0.49456292390823364,
0.5852258801460266,
-0.38571402430534363,
0.3902074098587036,
0.1436549723148346,
0.1837068349123001,
-0.35070809721946716,
0.5099027156829834,
-0.006095442920923233,
-0.826968789100647,
-0.29252809286117554,
-0.23376621305942535,
-0.5168888568878174,
-0.03968039155006409,
-0.5729225277900696,
0.2432565689086914,
-0.3347698152065277,
-0.5109907388687134,
0.17818115651607513,
0.026103325188159943,
-0.4799266755580902,
-0.10928763449192047,
0.0741816982626915,
0.982607364654541,
-1.2891708612442017,
0.6589674353599548,
1.3607852458953857,
-0.18858642876148224,
-0.49599161744117737,
0.32930320501327515,
0.4308936893939972,
-0.47054457664489746,
0.17287223041057587,
0.3303682804107666,
-0.29397812485694885,
-0.21223551034927368,
-0.7934854030609131,
-0.24354560673236847,
1.0029903650283813,
0.34305980801582336,
-0.3478753864765167,
0.30482709407806396,
0.22501805424690247,
0.8530657887458801,
-0.3425934612751007,
0.16980484127998352,
0.2710845172405243,
0.3504771292209625,
0.5215508341789246,
-0.5195251107215881,
0.011691300198435783,
-0.21159827709197998,
0.32291513681411743,
0.1358705759048462,
-1.0440378189086914,
0.7769655585289001,
-0.22411224246025085,
-0.46289193630218506,
-0.34555137157440186,
0.7174152135848999,
0.2966182231903076,
0.7939523458480835,
0.8165020942687988,
0.20110081136226654,
0.27883943915367126,
0.314513236284256,
0.9352290630340576,
-0.3660489320755005,
0.3505295217037201,
0.7880533337593079,
-0.8458822965621948,
0.8104235529899597,
0.32234349846839905,
0.0356249138712883,
0.5188643932342529,
0.36762234568595886,
0.4767667353153229,
0.2737841308116913,
0.2806599736213684,
-0.3953142762184143,
-0.5160713791847229,
-0.007355874869972467,
-0.30578044056892395,
0.4253443777561188,
0.19509944319725037,
0.07587574422359467,
-0.3030453324317932,
-0.008033737540245056,
0.04027315229177475,
0.4620254933834076,
-0.38411739468574524,
0.6141005754470825,
-0.014241285622119904,
-0.1513582468032837,
0.08299144357442856,
0.34308484196662903,
0.46395882964134216,
-0.6282140016555786,
-0.16900336742401123,
-0.022073283791542053,
0.11612875014543533,
0.09805038571357727,
-0.42438963055610657,
0.15648315846920013,
-0.1931086778640747,
0.012317951768636703,
-0.2708165943622589,
0.8997200131416321,
-0.2397322803735733,
-0.3223128318786621,
0.6185730695724487,
0.8712348341941833,
-0.0438593327999115,
-0.1066974550485611,
-0.6120755076408386,
0.20033816993236542,
-0.33130505681037903,
-0.42972779273986816,
0.46715062856674194,
0.5680158734321594,
-0.40056079626083374,
0.6694378852844238,
0.7407785654067993,
-0.26531895995140076,
-0.0754934772849083,
0.1954626739025116,
1.1008962392807007,
-0.447685569524765,
-0.6412363648414612,
-0.7702540755271912,
0.359963595867157,
-0.6845424175262451,
-0.16236449778079987,
0.8336669206619263,
0.5195786952972412,
0.3699871599674225,
0.05699540302157402,
0.6271319389343262,
-0.2261064499616623,
0.6363542675971985,
0.1158001720905304,
0.5486947894096375,
-0.6006947159767151,
-0.12963411211967468,
-0.39178627729415894,
-0.5948745012283325,
0.3407396972179413,
0.25473859906196594,
-0.13595949113368988,
-0.06768224388360977,
0.06148850545287132,
0.7092359662055969,
-0.21668893098831177,
0.14702171087265015,
0.4737282693386078,
0.22873029112815857,
0.23303082585334778,
0.06046105921268463,
1.0752125978469849,
-0.09752834588289261,
0.2343420386314392,
0.04293777421116829,
-0.5997257232666016,
-0.6080695986747742,
-0.5199782252311707,
-1.2231817245483398,
-0.6647899150848389,
-0.34942135214805603,
-0.6182749271392822,
0.21496376395225525,
1.250583291053772,
0.9561915993690491,
-0.5047157406806946,
-0.5855060815811157,
0.5376346707344055,
-0.1283711940050125,
-0.5679357051849365,
-0.2039758414030075,
0.062206096947193146,
0.3066405653953552,
-0.43495574593544006,
0.08946086466312408,
0.1639658808708191,
0.0273975171148777,
-0.32720983028411865,
-0.185176283121109,
-0.2799323797225952,
0.375625342130661,
0.8000000715255737,
0.5189877152442932,
-0.23488043248653412,
-0.21544155478477478,
0.01725194975733757,
-0.13418591022491455,
-0.2454608827829361,
1.088188648223877,
-0.6921700835227966,
0.14283396303653717,
0.46046221256256104,
0.7027528882026672,
0.7218244671821594,
0.3825553059577942,
0.4711475968360901,
-0.512878954410553,
-0.05580100044608116,
-0.0507986806333065,
0.15419341623783112,
0.18480494618415833,
-0.08427957445383072,
0.5543556213378906,
0.5524413585662842,
-0.15643267333507538,
-0.8071525692939758,
0.26943978667259216,
-0.9259329438209534,
-0.26587221026420593,
1.5687639713287354,
0.07896494120359421,
-0.36864423751831055,
-0.17111501097679138,
-0.31505540013313293,
0.24533657729625702,
-0.7933546304702759,
0.8678094148635864,
0.2924566864967346,
-0.0007703725714236498,
-0.22099702060222626,
-0.5091407895088196,
0.07380643486976624,
-0.04148578643798828,
-0.7639507055282593,
-0.014555505476891994,
0.5133752822875977,
0.33313941955566406,
0.1836618185043335,
0.9973447322845459,
0.1808125525712967,
0.19080187380313873,
0.1370001882314682,
0.03513128310441971,
-0.052775438874959946,
-0.2888985574245453,
0.1649249643087387,
0.2541292607784271,
-0.4132292568683624,
-0.059477247297763824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16319v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16319v1
|
Data-freeWeight Compress and Denoise for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-26T05:51:47 | 2024-02-26T05:51:47 |
Runyu Peng, Yunhua Zhou, Qipeng Guo, Yang Gao, Hang Yan, Xipeng Qiu, Dahua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are reshaping the research landscape in
artificial intelligence, particularly as model parameters scale up
significantly, unlocking remarkable capabilities across various domains.
Nevertheless, the scalability of model parameters faces constraints due to
limitations in GPU memory and computational speed. To address these
constraints, various weight compression methods have emerged, such as Pruning
and Quantization. Given the low-rank nature of weight matrices in language
models, the reduction of weights through matrix decomposition undoubtedly holds
significant potential and promise. In this paper, drawing upon the intrinsic
structure of LLMs, we propose a novel approach termed Data-free Joint Rank-k
Approximation for compressing the parameter matrices. Significantly, our method
is characterized by without necessitating additional involvement of any corpus,
while simultaneously preserving orthogonality in conjunction with pruning and
quantization methods. We achieve a model pruning of 80% parameters while
retaining 93.43% of the original performance without any calibration data.
Additionally, we explore the fundamental properties of the weight matrix of
LLMs undergone Rank-k Approximation and conduct comprehensive experiments to
elucidate our hypothesis.
|
[
-0.3588767647743225,
-0.5935938954353333,
0.4936445355415344,
0.03518850356340408,
-0.4255692958831787,
0.1669749617576599,
-0.6304371356964111,
0.010145426727831364,
0.27598506212234497,
0.42864271998405457,
-0.3547569513320923,
-0.6064372658729553,
-0.6744669675827026,
-0.05069011449813843,
-0.5014910697937012,
0.6612300872802734,
0.03193236142396927,
-0.0037538325414061546,
-0.35336706042289734,
-0.13385309278964996,
-0.2481013834476471,
-0.7715330719947815,
-0.4813038110733032,
-0.15578103065490723,
0.30949321389198303,
0.21303389966487885,
0.6704143285751343,
0.5958881378173828,
0.2841528356075287,
0.2800774872303009,
-0.19393488764762878,
-0.07106456160545349,
-0.6084360480308533,
0.28679051995277405,
0.6461786031723022,
-0.6037765741348267,
-0.7396946549415588,
0.16302651166915894,
1.3372541666030884,
1.2248830795288086,
-0.2223464697599411,
0.16846491396427155,
0.1211354210972786,
0.7512256503105164,
-0.6560322642326355,
0.4206324815750122,
-0.5571876168251038,
-0.21296672523021698,
0.09888521581888199,
0.04668422043323517,
-0.608400285243988,
-0.33527979254722595,
-0.5581518411636353,
-0.6741378903388977,
0.14147762954235077,
-0.14923006296157837,
0.8551315069198608,
0.4658782184123993,
-0.17610187828540802,
0.35261571407318115,
-0.9518020749092102,
1.1829073429107666,
-0.9148827791213989,
0.5796985030174255,
0.5000668168067932,
0.18828707933425903,
-0.16215011477470398,
-0.28228121995925903,
-0.45969200134277344,
-0.5569681525230408,
0.061554789543151855,
-0.05122867226600647,
-0.30241987109184265,
0.29862889647483826,
0.24603387713432312,
0.4201960861682892,
-0.45792293548583984,
0.1793261468410492,
-0.27258890867233276,
0.0065330155193805695,
0.6861366033554077,
-0.17149050533771515,
0.31294265389442444,
-0.00012684967077802867,
-0.10126593708992004,
-0.33618709444999695,
-0.9976269602775574,
-0.06703618913888931,
0.40774980187416077,
0.2892671525478363,
-0.04058073088526726,
0.5294525623321533,
-0.24124173820018768,
0.7001681327819824,
-0.17597715556621552,
-0.3165609836578369,
-0.0645860806107521,
-0.11212970316410065,
-0.33211979269981384,
-0.18300725519657135,
0.6718113422393799,
0.3600609600543976,
0.3941788971424103,
-0.4454663395881653,
-0.04612315073609352,
0.17848360538482666,
0.029214665293693542,
-0.9179218411445618,
-0.29472586512565613,
0.2292068749666214,
-0.752819836139679,
-0.14407408237457275,
-0.24041275680065155,
-0.7023264765739441,
-0.15104450285434723,
-0.46506044268608093,
0.3910115361213684,
-0.21938778460025787,
-0.24969646334648132,
0.04959249123930931,
0.19508524239063263,
0.09738019108772278,
0.42243072390556335,
-0.7489309310913086,
0.6468673348426819,
0.6332290172576904,
0.6280465722084045,
-0.03586927056312561,
0.1334332823753357,
-0.6911529302597046,
0.22094178199768066,
-0.3674534261226654,
0.3997861444950104,
-0.7531968951225281,
-0.31222596764564514,
-0.44987305998802185,
-0.22027014195919037,
-0.0030067656189203262,
-0.6413114070892334,
0.4796539843082428,
-0.5581037402153015,
-0.3495471179485321,
0.022412525489926338,
-0.5805559158325195,
-0.23689445853233337,
0.1605105847120285,
-0.8660151958465576,
0.8011999726295471,
0.12136323004961014,
-0.4592038094997406,
0.16680265963077545,
-0.09870060533285141,
-0.16513001918792725,
0.050680793821811676,
0.09721701592206955,
-0.45643967390060425,
0.4324660301208496,
0.4675480127334595,
0.42195895314216614,
-0.4287603795528412,
0.2756751775741577,
-0.6923881769180298,
-0.5389688014984131,
0.1735895723104477,
-0.4222029447555542,
0.6664987206459045,
0.08152494579553604,
0.19974391162395477,
0.002782222116366029,
-0.7803952693939209,
0.2177632749080658,
0.12068872898817062,
-0.46333733201026917,
-0.5637862682342529,
0.02405705116689205,
-0.26777610182762146,
-0.06255712360143661,
0.1305299699306488,
-0.5001998543739319,
0.5903431177139282,
-0.5131531357765198,
0.37070491909980774,
0.5034782886505127,
-0.049723003059625626,
0.6523528099060059,
-0.2824395000934601,
0.6324576735496521,
-0.2705245018005371,
0.020231548696756363,
0.32001733779907227,
-0.341487854719162,
-0.8365110754966736,
-0.7368346452713013,
0.6904376745223999,
0.35203322768211365,
-0.49082252383232117,
0.40811094641685486,
-0.7957835793495178,
-0.5148744583129883,
-0.766523540019989,
0.23609088361263275,
0.23545122146606445,
-0.02556869387626648,
0.22529639303684235,
-0.034549031406641006,
-0.45477768778800964,
-0.9241875410079956,
-0.1642705351114273,
-0.2623046934604645,
-0.529041588306427,
0.09053510427474976,
0.2605963349342346,
0.38062670826911926,
0.8082500696182251,
-0.3554348051548004,
-0.03248283267021179,
-0.3597021996974945,
0.13516896963119507,
0.22292611002922058,
0.6445985436439514,
0.35718923807144165,
-0.49384668469429016,
-0.2415391057729721,
-0.4078981876373291,
-0.5006110072135925,
-0.32673054933547974,
0.2173832654953003,
0.2426304668188095,
0.06356354057788849,
0.5185384154319763,
-0.7363477945327759,
0.4785045385360718,
0.781065821647644,
0.09666702151298523,
0.2631186246871948,
-0.3175136148929596,
0.07595843821763992,
-0.9933192729949951,
0.24520564079284668,
-0.07630366086959839,
-0.17405979335308075,
-0.8704443573951721,
0.1856202930212021,
0.011851388029754162,
-0.3696002662181854,
-0.19378477334976196,
0.5989535450935364,
-0.6894041895866394,
-0.17353050410747528,
-0.22867698967456818,
0.039007917046546936,
-0.05877131223678589,
0.6856748461723328,
-0.0025455416180193424,
0.5439773797988892,
0.44635236263275146,
-0.6184946894645691,
-0.01858733966946602,
0.15140336751937866,
-0.3639110028743744,
0.1441183090209961,
-0.6184925436973572,
-0.027721043676137924,
-0.34484031796455383,
0.35216885805130005,
-0.9201748371124268,
0.18055595457553864,
0.18549717962741852,
-0.41510865092277527,
0.48757901787757874,
-0.5727560520172119,
-0.7801889777183533,
-0.07503165304660797,
-0.6590441465377808,
0.6153814196586609,
0.7781504988670349,
-0.21778897941112518,
0.4902462363243103,
0.6366889476776123,
-0.49607187509536743,
-0.3327732980251312,
-0.5469424724578857,
0.14311741292476654,
-0.2547501027584076,
-0.2698511481285095,
0.453605055809021,
-0.39107391238212585,
-0.4198831021785736,
-0.11427702009677887,
0.023284167051315308,
-0.07404446601867676,
0.22640936076641083,
0.2993104159832001,
0.3102415204048157,
-0.0019454772118479013,
-0.0151671776548028,
0.19912895560264587,
-0.1040017306804657,
-0.07260188460350037,
0.07097950577735901,
0.6311661601066589,
0.17164340615272522,
-0.15735581517219543,
-0.40897589921951294,
0.44724732637405396,
0.7433173060417175,
-0.14041756093502045,
0.7273080348968506,
0.4255484640598297,
-0.4218786656856537,
-0.2362862378358841,
-0.41118961572647095,
-0.1145864874124527,
-0.4351530373096466,
0.19465652108192444,
-0.17656761407852173,
-0.9141300916671753,
0.5652647614479065,
-0.106802798807621,
-0.07213843613862991,
0.23518559336662292,
0.551593542098999,
0.3105885684490204,
1.311975359916687,
0.537750780582428,
-0.26240435242652893,
0.16310010850429535,
-0.3798735737800598,
0.49500027298927307,
-1.0026345252990723,
0.0872083529829979,
-0.5990361571311951,
-0.5052857398986816,
-0.49124839901924133,
-0.5426281690597534,
0.479755163192749,
0.47617703676223755,
0.2302306443452835,
0.13834786415100098,
-0.33159902691841125,
0.3818765878677368,
0.5612088441848755,
-0.04254106432199478,
0.3498947024345398,
0.3684386610984802,
0.02133033238351345,
-0.2019607424736023,
-0.6683855056762695,
-0.16499219834804535,
1.0754562616348267,
0.25610077381134033,
0.790242612361908,
-0.007330714724957943,
0.5789265036582947,
0.06534648686647415,
0.372970849275589,
-0.9508325457572937,
0.8698485493659973,
-0.2651466727256775,
-0.15011608600616455,
-0.3431798219680786,
-0.7943559288978577,
-1.0204386711120605,
0.16653499007225037,
-0.13814674317836761,
-0.7772789597511292,
0.050600964576005936,
-0.12185896188020706,
-0.3437715470790863,
0.4151843190193176,
-0.5381631255149841,
0.36132189631462097,
0.3270342946052551,
-0.05256115272641182,
-0.4018856883049011,
-0.3708336353302002,
0.5363194942474365,
0.008800674229860306,
0.3403507471084595,
-0.34051474928855896,
-0.16463975608348846,
1.0705642700195312,
-0.5966889262199402,
0.7682245373725891,
-0.4499365985393524,
-0.20669199526309967,
0.10495773702859879,
0.356219083070755,
0.41100603342056274,
-0.014125573448836803,
-0.10550197958946228,
0.3151971399784088,
0.12868736684322357,
-0.33187195658683777,
-0.7058155536651611,
0.7579350471496582,
-0.6792391538619995,
-0.4443908929824829,
0.17362819612026215,
-0.9825936555862427,
-0.41301724314689636,
-0.027795998379588127,
-0.3480265736579895,
0.5373515486717224,
0.1124415174126625,
0.4253876209259033,
0.35271018743515015,
-0.3750336170196533,
0.6400167346000671,
0.4126046597957611,
-0.22768400609493256,
-0.6939069032669067,
1.0051164627075195,
0.3746660351753235,
0.18449147045612335,
0.5295710563659668,
0.12076859921216965,
-0.039409246295690536,
-0.9580816030502319,
-0.2711471915245056,
0.3912627100944519,
-0.4940897226333618,
-0.3792880177497864,
-0.5410194993019104,
-0.3260653614997864,
-0.5346763134002686,
-0.10316368192434311,
-0.41019245982170105,
-0.8568430542945862,
0.05796611309051514,
0.25566449761390686,
0.2787872850894928,
0.5601661205291748,
0.05820607766509056,
0.46668103337287903,
-0.948360800743103,
0.48354366421699524,
0.19078871607780457,
0.34553202986717224,
0.24860180914402008,
-0.4030073285102844,
-0.24394287168979645,
0.12574650347232819,
0.1682749092578888,
-0.4854353666305542,
0.7782077193260193,
0.3276366591453552,
0.5933791399002075,
0.1683078110218048,
0.3260641396045685,
0.5665247440338135,
-0.23466575145721436,
0.7645025253295898,
-0.16764019429683685,
-0.8020485043525696,
0.12840569019317627,
-0.20044171810150146,
0.4266076683998108,
0.5572811961174011,
0.30831247568130493,
-0.3466981053352356,
-0.641773521900177,
-0.4146674573421478,
-0.9198241233825684,
0.5059778094291687,
0.3374165892601013,
-0.07182137668132782,
0.17234410345554352,
0.3487013876438141,
0.1054593026638031,
0.3354891240596771,
-0.743261992931366,
-0.3137809634208679,
0.2736496031284332,
-0.39325979351997375,
-0.0036423620767891407,
-0.5198207497596741,
0.07155867666006088,
-0.4792190194129944,
0.5699118375778198,
0.07395674288272858,
0.36317530274391174,
-0.1859140247106552,
-0.3992580473423004,
-0.030078284442424774,
0.35285598039627075,
0.5115600228309631,
0.4129493534564972,
-0.3142518401145935,
0.1394481062889099,
0.060638945549726486,
-0.5700661540031433,
0.2977677583694458,
0.14052872359752655,
-0.35782235860824585,
-0.08875100314617157,
0.21541687846183777,
0.4964754581451416,
0.4138091206550598,
-0.5552350878715515,
0.39463478326797485,
-0.30056658387184143,
-0.2943020164966583,
-0.02405567839741707,
-0.18367554247379303,
-0.031338535249233246,
-0.07081012427806854,
0.4516579210758209,
-0.25725865364074707,
-0.09718630462884903,
-0.09750280529260635,
0.10443662106990814,
0.6689658164978027,
-0.009599260054528713,
-0.4850221872329712,
0.5984972715377808,
-0.027130383998155594,
0.06471046060323715,
0.6340399980545044,
-0.12784859538078308,
-0.3430860638618469,
0.38196995854377747,
0.33245763182640076,
0.8534841537475586,
-0.2538992464542389,
-0.0059682815335690975,
0.4976058304309845,
0.3183479905128479,
-0.11023835092782974,
0.18052150309085846,
-0.28607887029647827,
-0.5966628789901733,
-0.9290369153022766,
-1.0078649520874023,
-0.2880152761936188,
0.3902062475681305,
-0.4692974090576172,
0.15217936038970947,
-0.7323630452156067,
0.17839978635311127,
-0.27960488200187683,
0.29026731848716736,
-0.10293490439653397,
0.019602134823799133,
0.4260038733482361,
0.6574699282646179,
-0.6422955989837646,
1.2358886003494263,
0.16955943405628204,
-0.15472953021526337,
-0.8860767483711243,
-0.17871321737766266,
-0.25778135657310486,
-0.6855061054229736,
0.7032625079154968,
0.09518981724977493,
0.0998968631029129,
0.19873347878456116,
-0.41308873891830444,
-1.127624750137329,
0.7980753183364868,
0.9423167109489441,
-0.4612118601799011,
-0.18490581214427948,
0.19786633551120758,
0.22796545922756195,
-0.06109309941530228,
0.09843325614929199,
0.359487384557724,
0.6859208941459656,
0.03743770718574524,
-0.9414154887199402,
0.15849700570106506,
-0.4078395366668701,
0.031051885336637497,
0.45195573568344116,
-0.47726675868034363,
0.933398962020874,
0.166287362575531,
-0.288055419921875,
0.2497958391904831,
0.5108413100242615,
0.27308201789855957,
-0.28331151604652405,
0.7253103256225586,
0.8780084848403931,
0.5352977514266968,
0.12810392677783966,
0.8540095686912537,
-0.6579277515411377,
0.39566728472709656,
0.6364787817001343,
-0.24689649045467377,
0.9064428806304932,
0.5149413347244263,
-0.3690354824066162,
0.35290879011154175,
0.2534428536891937,
-0.0912814736366272,
0.294808030128479,
0.38177916407585144,
-0.26412343978881836,
-0.2845064401626587,
-0.17279459536075592,
-0.22667041420936584,
0.5122820734977722,
0.17380750179290771,
-0.009449939243495464,
-0.42473727464675903,
-0.0730142667889595,
0.2971610128879547,
-0.1295151263475418,
-0.6477264761924744,
0.5250652432441711,
0.03754103183746338,
-0.6006625294685364,
1.0772804021835327,
0.1447652280330658,
0.6440850496292114,
-0.6302387118339539,
-0.10327156633138657,
-0.2559163570404053,
0.05138234421610832,
0.17735636234283447,
-0.2581753134727478,
0.2334761917591095,
-0.16219019889831543,
-0.12078225612640381,
-0.5570757985115051,
0.7269701361656189,
-0.7467657327651978,
-0.7637290954589844,
0.22406679391860962,
0.35582974553108215,
0.2873179316520691,
-0.305279940366745,
-0.32904472947120667,
0.3442555367946625,
-0.2677799463272095,
-0.36822307109832764,
0.6640512943267822,
-0.16567771136760712,
-0.0604654960334301,
0.8246999979019165,
0.6234540939331055,
0.574537992477417,
-0.03256440535187721,
0.05209915712475777,
0.8987429738044739,
-0.4817335903644562,
-0.24639709293842316,
-0.8513116240501404,
0.16173526644706726,
0.07355639338493347,
0.3080635964870453,
0.6522229909896851,
0.4443642497062683,
0.5760729908943176,
-0.012302360497415066,
0.3690744936466217,
0.07922250777482986,
0.4596632719039917,
-0.6178824305534363,
0.9828463196754456,
-0.6360090374946594,
0.22210440039634705,
-0.23182110488414764,
-0.9189668893814087,
-0.6003941893577576,
0.2645348608493805,
-0.1616501659154892,
0.1747969537973404,
0.5412936806678772,
0.8433170318603516,
-0.009341083467006683,
-0.4936472177505493,
0.6186695694923401,
0.3344883918762207,
0.19143632054328918,
0.5858931541442871,
0.4307379722595215,
-0.33956795930862427,
0.7562102675437927,
-0.3812386095523834,
-0.13378500938415527,
-0.13200025260448456,
-0.7740616202354431,
-0.8563693761825562,
-0.5217703580856323,
-0.4379773736000061,
-0.07715310156345367,
-0.2434404045343399,
0.68885338306427,
0.8987760543823242,
-0.6989845037460327,
-0.3845460116863251,
0.017382927238941193,
0.15311570465564728,
-0.2623257637023926,
-0.2016175240278244,
0.4768296778202057,
0.06777241080999374,
-0.8366971611976624,
0.7155205011367798,
0.34405583143234253,
-0.036059483885765076,
-0.3832855522632599,
-0.03272749111056328,
-0.16310171782970428,
0.04507272318005562,
0.5316603779792786,
0.0930427759885788,
-0.5709725022315979,
-0.09509330987930298,
-0.17019054293632507,
0.2090333104133606,
-0.03008013404905796,
0.7755815386772156,
-1.164176344871521,
0.14872193336486816,
0.5395249128341675,
0.6195963621139526,
0.28081679344177246,
-0.08193939179182053,
0.7498986721038818,
-0.9436445236206055,
0.4614684581756592,
0.28519129753112793,
0.31521594524383545,
0.3387616276741028,
-0.031975701451301575,
0.30432868003845215,
0.2521277666091919,
-0.44604697823524475,
-1.2295011281967163,
0.09871909767389297,
-1.1870615482330322,
-0.33057403564453125,
1.1069790124893188,
-0.03505706414580345,
-0.6579492688179016,
0.2714728116989136,
0.02810186706483364,
0.4181705713272095,
-0.3046775758266449,
0.6426319479942322,
0.5981705784797668,
0.29467079043388367,
-0.44172146916389465,
-0.6002821922302246,
0.41232168674468994,
0.5089712738990784,
-0.5418835878372192,
0.5998812913894653,
0.3587258458137512,
0.066826231777668,
-0.10203474760055542,
0.39463889598846436,
-0.11272276192903519,
-0.07527173310518265,
-0.019456205889582634,
0.402300626039505,
-0.1143818199634552,
-0.2403324693441391,
-0.48249712586402893,
0.5324122905731201,
0.2494979053735733,
0.0040784310549497604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16315v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16315v2
|
Finer: Investigating and Enhancing Fine-Grained Visual Concept Recognition in Large Vision Language Models
| 2024-02-26T05:43:51 | 2024-03-11T18:49:40 |
Jeonghwan Kim, Heng Ji
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recent advances in instruction-tuned Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs)
have imbued the models with the ability to generate high-level, image-grounded
explanations with ease. While such capability is largely attributed to the rich
world knowledge contained within the Large Language Models (LLMs), our work
reveals their shortcomings in fine-grained visual categorization (FGVC) across
six different benchmark settings. Most recent state-of-the-art LVLMs like
LLaVa-1.5, InstructBLIP and GPT-4V not only severely deteriorate in terms of
classification performance, e.g., average drop of 65.58 in EM for Stanford Dogs
for LLaVA-1.5, but also struggle to generate an accurate explanation with
detailed attributes based on the concept that appears within an input image
despite their capability to generate holistic image-level descriptions.
In-depth analyses show that instruction-tuned LVLMs exhibit modality gap,
showing discrepancy when given textual and visual inputs that correspond to the
same concept, preventing the image modality from leveraging the rich parametric
knowledge within the LLMs. In an effort to further the community's endeavor in
this direction, we propose a multiple granularity attribute-centric evaluation
benchmark, Finer, which aims to establish a ground to evaluate LVLMs'
fine-grained visual comprehension ability and provide significantly improved
explainability.
|
[
-0.6160758137702942,
-0.9135630130767822,
0.5527044534683228,
-0.314090758562088,
-0.35551539063453674,
-0.3444763720035553,
-0.35423144698143005,
-0.6683833599090576,
-0.37613025307655334,
0.3518001437187195,
-0.2600465714931488,
-0.4841068983078003,
-0.5933144092559814,
-0.08462367206811905,
-0.2948581874370575,
0.6475221514701843,
-0.040564265102148056,
0.0764344334602356,
-0.43876710534095764,
0.0058277626521885395,
-0.3288196921348572,
-0.10131192952394485,
-0.5986011624336243,
-0.452786922454834,
0.5862112045288086,
0.39188820123672485,
0.7144216299057007,
0.7113548517227173,
0.9310069680213928,
0.32947418093681335,
-0.287956565618515,
0.4694087505340576,
-0.38409608602523804,
-0.40850016474723816,
-0.0726499855518341,
-0.33535313606262207,
-0.5861645936965942,
-0.04091336950659752,
0.5865325331687927,
0.6176846027374268,
0.07785212248563766,
0.13016542792320251,
0.18910108506679535,
0.6384226679801941,
-0.9204234480857849,
0.3677367568016052,
-0.8269155025482178,
0.21152272820472717,
-0.27601906657218933,
-0.32493406534194946,
-0.190924271941185,
-0.021658677607774734,
0.24358722567558289,
-0.6273577213287354,
0.37794429063796997,
-0.1432563066482544,
1.3299751281738281,
0.2839765250682831,
-0.06782907992601395,
-0.08458039164543152,
-0.46211013197898865,
0.6563191413879395,
-0.5069273114204407,
0.4994179904460907,
0.4481201171875,
0.39857032895088196,
-0.03094157762825489,
-0.9433029890060425,
-0.44413700699806213,
-0.33750119805336,
0.08763251453638077,
0.024773042649030685,
-0.15157854557037354,
0.24073325097560883,
0.14762677252292633,
0.7680023312568665,
-0.2810721695423126,
0.35202106833457947,
-0.47547081112861633,
-0.2941116392612457,
0.5355097055435181,
0.3377375602722168,
-0.07486148178577423,
0.0395282506942749,
-0.2821427285671234,
-0.1099834144115448,
-0.479026734828949,
0.5263356566429138,
-0.1225508600473404,
0.23026196658611298,
0.03219228610396385,
0.4102133810520172,
-0.5560228228569031,
0.8256267309188843,
0.28182026743888855,
-0.38362303376197815,
0.39812901616096497,
-0.26172274351119995,
-0.5254528522491455,
-0.21239124238491058,
0.5367524027824402,
0.7021965384483337,
0.19526848196983337,
0.05375521630048752,
-0.3519470989704132,
-0.009422359056770802,
0.2027376890182495,
-1.1102023124694824,
-0.22361211478710175,
-0.0723080113530159,
-0.7029967904090881,
-0.3155244290828705,
0.10364799946546555,
-0.502516508102417,
-0.614478349685669,
-0.39836829900741577,
0.5456333756446838,
-0.4514276087284088,
0.20168864727020264,
0.2937806248664856,
-0.10256604105234146,
0.6209972500801086,
0.8342783451080322,
-0.8259668946266174,
0.12037007510662079,
0.7270877957344055,
0.6735750436782837,
-0.049428462982177734,
-0.4590565264225006,
-0.6325919032096863,
0.004279635846614838,
-0.40579190850257874,
0.8257113695144653,
-0.8615780472755432,
-0.08394287526607513,
-0.09428095817565918,
0.19325582683086395,
0.1861383020877838,
-0.6328597068786621,
0.4041006565093994,
-0.119161456823349,
-0.21913325786590576,
-0.24557466804981232,
-0.3707049489021301,
-0.14753220975399017,
0.5046188235282898,
-0.2829321026802063,
0.8044954538345337,
-0.0346352756023407,
-0.682507336139679,
0.5945723652839661,
-0.11040886491537094,
-0.12237203121185303,
0.2555079460144043,
-0.3803609013557434,
-0.28368380665779114,
0.5535760521888733,
0.2799704372882843,
0.8623644709587097,
-0.23679667711257935,
0.17163754999637604,
-0.48258349299430847,
-0.5365591049194336,
0.17198939621448517,
-0.8275638222694397,
0.05024102330207825,
0.11852654069662094,
0.0019615571945905685,
0.14034056663513184,
-0.9048676490783691,
0.11414496600627899,
0.10191429406404495,
-0.20713810622692108,
-0.494682252407074,
-0.07204992324113846,
-0.23000343143939972,
0.047008298337459564,
0.36316755414009094,
-0.30728602409362793,
0.187702015042305,
-0.2793138325214386,
0.355745404958725,
0.7245902419090271,
-0.26628378033638,
0.41101527214050293,
0.03392769768834114,
0.0690574198961258,
0.15045151114463806,
0.4333013594150543,
-0.2331218719482422,
-0.32016173005104065,
-0.86055988073349,
-0.3521718680858612,
0.1326318085193634,
0.2772601246833801,
-0.745600163936615,
0.08887982368469238,
-0.24364247918128967,
-0.4925195872783661,
-0.35868212580680847,
0.13095274567604065,
0.6007161140441895,
0.4271198809146881,
0.2591615617275238,
-0.6375691294670105,
-0.07904218137264252,
-1.1012033224105835,
0.08431006222963333,
0.06407798081636429,
-0.011853785254061222,
0.4534633159637451,
0.5336741209030151,
-0.2959500253200531,
0.5962807536125183,
-0.5671431422233582,
-0.37929388880729675,
-0.030265558511018753,
0.06493601948022842,
-0.1847427636384964,
0.23587311804294586,
0.3814699053764343,
-0.6399745345115662,
-0.13479550182819366,
0.5942578315734863,
-0.5442779660224915,
0.0838816836476326,
0.09431702643632889,
0.03614482283592224,
-0.008943584747612476,
0.6913644671440125,
-0.3782802224159241,
0.7273645401000977,
0.10100146383047104,
-0.35365599393844604,
0.5337421894073486,
-0.3960551917552948,
0.19594749808311462,
-0.5671149492263794,
-0.2184586375951767,
0.1932058185338974,
-0.13914145529270172,
-0.49605995416641235,
0.4040682315826416,
0.16293102502822876,
0.1802283227443695,
-0.6167513132095337,
0.6143360733985901,
-0.278800904750824,
-0.3191527724266052,
-0.19442737102508545,
0.22500455379486084,
0.2902452349662781,
0.2989971935749054,
0.11075981706380844,
0.807100772857666,
0.7986111044883728,
-0.7563724517822266,
0.2835281491279602,
0.11263490468263626,
-0.37076878547668457,
0.7440459132194519,
-0.6172163486480713,
-0.198647603392601,
-0.15821930766105652,
0.10364706069231033,
-0.6123083233833313,
-0.5423961877822876,
-0.045263346284627914,
-0.25228452682495117,
0.48768630623817444,
-0.07080063968896866,
-0.23082740604877472,
-0.3684132397174835,
-0.47468701004981995,
0.3406412899494171,
0.45480403304100037,
-0.586558997631073,
0.3875507712364197,
0.014876965433359146,
0.0789463222026825,
-0.44370847940444946,
-0.7240414619445801,
0.11098821461200714,
-0.36739614605903625,
-0.6021753549575806,
0.27389848232269287,
0.03541499003767967,
-0.2927494943141937,
-0.19143147766590118,
-0.3187797963619232,
-0.3305153548717499,
0.11970224231481552,
0.10597869753837585,
0.019483335316181183,
-0.38305631279945374,
0.34536978602409363,
-0.3060661852359772,
-0.008893954567611217,
-0.17337241768836975,
-0.011341952718794346,
0.3786351978778839,
-0.7679491639137268,
-0.22122706472873688,
-0.55131596326828,
-0.0763847678899765,
0.5794517993927002,
-0.49282559752464294,
0.3755030035972595,
1.2050992250442505,
-0.18061327934265137,
-0.0949670821428299,
-0.43790096044540405,
0.04762405529618263,
-0.4652666747570038,
0.6095870137214661,
-0.5845322608947754,
-0.8868510723114014,
0.39009207487106323,
-0.08112227916717529,
-0.2024216502904892,
0.3580540120601654,
0.45386749505996704,
-0.1478106528520584,
0.7914026379585266,
0.5581802725791931,
0.39589789509773254,
0.6206444501876831,
-0.29981860518455505,
-0.022724488750100136,
-0.9344209432601929,
-0.47206881642341614,
-0.26447468996047974,
-0.17686982452869415,
-0.48047465085983276,
-0.7136212587356567,
0.15857088565826416,
0.3576399087905884,
-0.21823053061962128,
-0.2938319742679596,
-0.503943145275116,
0.7090441584587097,
0.4635707139968872,
0.31906670331954956,
0.2831078767776489,
0.19889628887176514,
0.14173732697963715,
0.030843719840049744,
-0.4245172441005707,
-0.4665086269378662,
0.6356685161590576,
0.5519208312034607,
1.036397933959961,
-0.3055773377418518,
0.6405687928199768,
0.19350114464759827,
-0.1992158442735672,
-1.2013355493545532,
0.6551478505134583,
-0.674525260925293,
-0.011338888667523861,
-0.12731106579303741,
-0.2515054941177368,
-0.7109264731407166,
0.3208906650543213,
-0.12211340665817261,
-0.862633466720581,
0.3181641101837158,
0.24930821359157562,
-0.2974982261657715,
0.18928740918636322,
-0.742501974105835,
0.9885650277137756,
-0.2971910238265991,
-0.5420681238174438,
-0.1665458381175995,
-0.445710688829422,
0.5466511249542236,
-0.05282389000058174,
0.07346761971712112,
-0.13313886523246765,
0.04358982667326927,
0.273438960313797,
-0.5989676713943481,
0.892540454864502,
-0.06860492378473282,
-0.4533754289150238,
0.13901041448116302,
-0.0736960917711258,
0.3712368607521057,
-0.03501363843679428,
0.26913386583328247,
0.25885701179504395,
-0.1078445315361023,
-0.3041435182094574,
-0.555838406085968,
0.613798201084137,
-0.5364705920219421,
-0.5871798992156982,
-0.0056856488808989525,
-0.5263134241104126,
-0.14358989894390106,
0.027023285627365112,
0.2825838029384613,
0.8487878441810608,
-0.0014457999495789409,
0.4037262499332428,
0.890480101108551,
-0.2744723856449127,
0.3037041425704956,
0.27768945693969727,
-0.13247336447238922,
-0.30608808994293213,
1.0847113132476807,
-0.15895086526870728,
0.4651666581630707,
0.34020328521728516,
0.3084966540336609,
-0.04921753332018852,
-0.9095175862312317,
-0.3363111615180969,
-0.24881641566753387,
-0.9487254023551941,
-0.30666810274124146,
-0.22401803731918335,
-0.25686734914779663,
0.029229333624243736,
-0.37982338666915894,
-0.34204789996147156,
-0.2880961298942566,
-0.3341643810272217,
0.16406145691871643,
0.31153741478919983,
0.6517017483711243,
0.14036943018436432,
0.37148603796958923,
-0.7649203538894653,
0.5069818496704102,
0.5747342109680176,
0.668864905834198,
0.08419991284608841,
-0.7587490081787109,
-0.33348268270492554,
0.06242280453443527,
-0.3051105737686157,
-0.1981281042098999,
0.030755722895264626,
0.5697193741798401,
0.4398523271083832,
0.7845219373703003,
-0.36445480585098267,
1.3884731531143188,
-0.627251923084259,
0.7921944260597229,
0.31529346108436584,
-0.9326590299606323,
0.7356328964233398,
-0.05999130755662918,
0.3590080142021179,
0.49532803893089294,
-0.3079162836074829,
-0.11185163259506226,
-0.40925878286361694,
-0.4414648115634918,
-0.7577021718025208,
0.5803707838058472,
0.09756290912628174,
0.1011023223400116,
0.060127388685941696,
0.3154710531234741,
0.3292907178401947,
0.05556333437561989,
-0.6116346716880798,
0.09911923855543137,
-0.15594780445098877,
-0.057757653295993805,
0.05018726363778114,
-0.17344720661640167,
0.05685519427061081,
-0.5221957564353943,
0.48710864782333374,
-0.37708839774131775,
0.04359735921025276,
0.28092697262763977,
-0.10284756869077682,
0.07364080846309662,
0.35874035954475403,
0.6310158967971802,
0.5935408473014832,
-0.21348923444747925,
0.4115605354309082,
0.1790395975112915,
-0.6220396757125854,
-0.2798236012458801,
0.0827828049659729,
-0.19402404129505157,
-0.16961455345153809,
0.6714975833892822,
1.0950703620910645,
0.008301351219415665,
-0.6048641204833984,
0.5632694959640503,
-0.25061503052711487,
-0.2993629574775696,
0.10511959344148636,
0.29442474246025085,
-0.2958664000034332,
0.5313816070556641,
0.10321178287267685,
0.18714675307273865,
0.2561216354370117,
-0.5743488073348999,
0.08458583056926727,
0.706578254699707,
-0.5307664275169373,
-0.14530184864997864,
0.2835802435874939,
0.13882403075695038,
0.07274016737937927,
0.20967620611190796,
-0.26487329602241516,
-0.2720479965209961,
0.612847626209259,
0.21160981059074402,
0.7480636835098267,
0.09160301834344864,
0.2244706153869629,
0.15162383019924164,
0.23424793779850006,
-0.13539667427539825,
0.15643608570098877,
-0.1700347363948822,
-0.6523148417472839,
-0.2626612186431885,
-0.8860136270523071,
-0.07509816437959671,
0.36389991641044617,
-0.7039975523948669,
0.2537904381752014,
-0.4031609296798706,
-0.052248239517211914,
0.2807290852069855,
-0.039708420634269714,
-0.8103085160255432,
0.3851134181022644,
0.6757892966270447,
0.9462286233901978,
-0.6751259565353394,
0.5916506052017212,
0.8519554138183594,
-0.46913260221481323,
-0.6846520900726318,
0.12918713688850403,
-0.3110933303833008,
-0.99222731590271,
0.7516449689865112,
0.4140022397041321,
-0.2771400511264801,
-0.29799121618270874,
-0.8248690366744995,
-0.5360118746757507,
1.1621776819229126,
0.11033206433057785,
-0.5704778432846069,
0.055130843073129654,
0.05155515670776367,
0.580051839351654,
-0.37077122926712036,
0.07366625964641571,
0.6820751428604126,
0.48873406648635864,
0.336171954870224,
-1.0770750045776367,
-0.23321321606636047,
-0.06279299408197403,
0.2298520803451538,
0.15619967877864838,
-0.641380786895752,
0.753119170665741,
-0.3977874517440796,
-0.007854393683373928,
0.22054682672023773,
0.4686121344566345,
0.03672650456428528,
0.7579699158668518,
0.2564733624458313,
0.6666611433029175,
0.7851828336715698,
-0.3648401200771332,
0.9940038323402405,
0.12195613235235214,
0.37348583340644836,
1.0003952980041504,
-0.042985618114471436,
0.8976001143455505,
0.5367419123649597,
-0.10805311799049377,
0.14456495642662048,
0.7359805703163147,
-0.21287401020526886,
0.617080807685852,
0.10915075242519379,
0.07594966888427734,
-0.6204463839530945,
-0.44478100538253784,
-0.4003543555736542,
0.7523489594459534,
0.5693597793579102,
-0.3652188777923584,
-0.2973294258117676,
0.12461495399475098,
-0.3727477490901947,
-0.14628085494041443,
-1.0692014694213867,
0.8803317546844482,
0.12790058553218842,
-0.21794643998146057,
0.9749739766120911,
-0.18003493547439575,
0.633707582950592,
-0.4444926977157593,
-0.007663872558623552,
-0.2573413550853729,
0.4658568799495697,
-0.356258749961853,
-1.0694791078567505,
0.051391780376434326,
0.041304443031549454,
-0.10563194006681442,
0.08726054430007935,
0.8822197318077087,
-0.3680156171321869,
-0.5311107039451599,
-0.1335153430700302,
0.39250895380973816,
0.27042052149772644,
-0.040831368416547775,
-0.6205011010169983,
0.2725551724433899,
-0.12057826668024063,
0.07872530072927475,
0.18490993976593018,
0.9735647439956665,
-0.3465791940689087,
0.6970958113670349,
0.15824787318706512,
-0.002760239178314805,
0.01301930658519268,
0.36598142981529236,
0.7891282439231873,
-0.6172047853469849,
-0.15350264310836792,
-0.8401908278465271,
0.3899284303188324,
-0.06952454894781113,
-0.27977055311203003,
0.545449435710907,
0.36814451217651367,
0.956085205078125,
-0.2606663703918457,
0.45951932668685913,
-0.05781061574816704,
-0.3261171579360962,
-0.7867221832275391,
0.29389074444770813,
-0.9807029962539673,
0.19044773280620575,
-0.37341997027397156,
-0.7057132124900818,
-0.34323543310165405,
0.6350693106651306,
-0.27083343267440796,
-0.12669184803962708,
0.7193310260772705,
0.5788027048110962,
-0.39693161845207214,
-0.33351612091064453,
0.6625577211380005,
0.24795643985271454,
0.1382562518119812,
0.5748680830001831,
1.1577422618865967,
-0.3172559440135956,
0.533919095993042,
-0.1947130560874939,
-0.017614824697375298,
-0.29352089762687683,
-0.7524304986000061,
-1.040494680404663,
-0.31454768776893616,
-0.41659146547317505,
0.05004695802927017,
0.0719604343175888,
0.5047528743743896,
0.5990439653396606,
-0.5515193343162537,
0.23446089029312134,
-0.21983517706394196,
-0.08584444969892502,
-0.045004718005657196,
-0.19484342634677887,
0.34503883123397827,
-0.4619874060153961,
-0.5760663747787476,
-0.01701122336089611,
0.5735072493553162,
0.18917642533779144,
-0.2665434777736664,
-0.1868501901626587,
0.33758315443992615,
-0.0637628436088562,
0.9929036498069763,
-0.0009308158187195659,
-1.2809280157089233,
-0.4522136449813843,
-0.3026469647884369,
-0.11684609949588776,
0.2879202365875244,
0.519225001335144,
-0.6799870729446411,
0.47491365671157837,
0.4426655173301697,
0.5826106071472168,
0.1078263372182846,
0.05254693701863289,
0.12042637914419174,
-0.7763690948486328,
0.19061094522476196,
-0.09549643844366074,
0.48873621225357056,
0.39262983202934265,
-0.16173602640628815,
0.4324542284011841,
0.03305087611079216,
-0.3606412708759308,
-0.6879843473434448,
0.38880833983421326,
-1.175233244895935,
-0.29948678612709045,
1.3066223859786987,
-0.07561669498682022,
-0.3579164743423462,
0.22073784470558167,
-0.4827273488044739,
-0.05977565795183182,
-0.3093082010746002,
0.5316135287284851,
0.6045904159545898,
-0.010976806282997131,
-0.2987767457962036,
-0.6717228889465332,
0.4302566349506378,
0.00035079914960078895,
-0.9147521257400513,
0.33285874128341675,
0.751532793045044,
0.13368931412696838,
-0.012739344500005245,
0.3169017434120178,
-0.05077763646841049,
0.4123002886772156,
0.009312177076935768,
-0.04182365909218788,
-0.25491735339164734,
-0.4758125841617584,
-0.4702915549278259,
-0.0019837748259305954,
0.27144020795822144,
-0.28189244866371155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04771v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04771v1
|
QASE Enhanced PLMs: Improved Control in Text Generation for MRC
| 2024-02-26T05:34:16 | 2024-02-26T05:34:16 |
Lin Ai, Zheng Hui, Zizhou Liu, Julia Hirschberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To address the challenges of out-of-control generation in generative models
for machine reading comprehension (MRC), we introduce the Question-Attended
Span Extraction (QASE) module. Integrated during the fine-tuning of pre-trained
generative language models (PLMs), QASE enables these PLMs to match SOTA
extractive methods and outperform leading LLMs like GPT-4 in MRC tasks, without
significant increases in computational costs.
|
[
-0.5633770823478699,
-0.7495158910751343,
0.5169800519943237,
-0.11603126674890518,
-0.1611059010028839,
0.2939120829105377,
0.2895190715789795,
-0.33708834648132324,
0.03498386591672897,
0.7746658325195312,
-0.9317650198936462,
-0.19504794478416443,
-0.5323342084884644,
0.6263371109962463,
-0.4426877796649933,
0.9703234434127808,
-0.13598404824733734,
-0.08116122335195541,
-0.32720357179641724,
0.17793422937393188,
-0.18219120800495148,
-0.506841778755188,
-0.6956314444541931,
-0.08001304417848587,
0.3461899757385254,
0.621764600276947,
0.6431405544281006,
0.39031094312667847,
0.69328773021698,
0.24148358404636383,
-0.2518477737903595,
0.6026248931884766,
-0.15488389134407043,
0.4335117042064667,
-0.01540749054402113,
-0.6701543927192688,
-0.7184191942214966,
0.08831813186407089,
0.7468239665031433,
0.35903075337409973,
-0.0919824168086052,
0.08940036594867706,
0.10866258293390274,
0.988609254360199,
-0.5864241719245911,
-0.2152920514345169,
-0.363021582365036,
0.13301153481006622,
-0.19657328724861145,
-0.5592268705368042,
-0.5445160865783691,
-0.6904674768447876,
0.15535882115364075,
-0.6908823847770691,
0.31976592540740967,
0.15754033625125885,
1.1398394107818604,
0.3285321295261383,
-0.42394644021987915,
-0.44160670042037964,
-0.38269945979118347,
0.7032560706138611,
-0.5094702839851379,
0.37458500266075134,
0.741287112236023,
0.25692218542099,
-0.3130771517753601,
-1.2469947338104248,
-0.8546640872955322,
-0.06049507483839989,
0.02230505831539631,
0.5216403007507324,
0.08713584393262863,
0.2942504286766052,
0.2847464978694916,
0.6235548257827759,
-0.7091212868690491,
-0.1429838091135025,
-0.4831412434577942,
0.07298989593982697,
0.40697339177131653,
0.3546135425567627,
0.4859696924686432,
-0.42896491289138794,
-0.29925692081451416,
0.024265091866254807,
-0.9281566739082336,
0.058580562472343445,
0.32509666681289673,
-0.16080620884895325,
0.33664965629577637,
0.8201732635498047,
-0.2133854478597641,
0.6807877421379089,
0.05277537927031517,
0.013376262038946152,
0.04639454931020737,
-0.5339460372924805,
-0.3387303948402405,
-0.3063662648200989,
0.4652286767959595,
0.06618605554103851,
0.15346677601337433,
0.05797497183084488,
-0.24750107526779175,
-0.2282920479774475,
0.2480396181344986,
-0.777920126914978,
-0.40375420451164246,
0.4600173532962799,
-0.4495519995689392,
-0.14988155663013458,
0.3756318986415863,
-1.0008256435394287,
-0.10659802705049515,
-0.1325439214706421,
0.46186381578445435,
-0.40974950790405273,
-0.050013601779937744,
0.19971174001693726,
-0.4439347982406616,
0.22944410145282745,
0.14620886743068695,
-0.953962504863739,
0.3141055405139923,
0.41581010818481445,
0.8138749599456787,
-0.34217438101768494,
-0.06744962930679321,
-0.7433708310127258,
0.2108689397573471,
-0.20126043260097504,
0.9224824905395508,
-0.43249475955963135,
-0.4351522624492645,
-0.13912540674209595,
0.08952517062425613,
-0.4026067852973938,
-0.886975109577179,
0.46305930614471436,
-1.0743539333343506,
0.7817115187644958,
-0.16182436048984528,
-0.6886284351348877,
-0.03334345296025276,
-0.02126273140311241,
-0.7052330374717712,
1.291558861732483,
0.4654771387577057,
-0.7917219996452332,
0.20589368045330048,
-0.8002606630325317,
-0.5292227864265442,
0.22874711453914642,
0.08018650114536285,
-0.713469922542572,
-0.07496242970228195,
0.4972154498100281,
0.2692275941371918,
-0.17608360946178436,
0.11315827816724777,
-0.008715642616152763,
-0.08713164925575256,
0.41963663697242737,
-0.1911918818950653,
0.8926554918289185,
0.5836521983146667,
-0.35163694620132446,
0.4701772928237915,
-0.8910443186759949,
0.4306280016899109,
0.028121059760451317,
-0.7821569442749023,
-0.05037122592329979,
0.0684586837887764,
-0.24714241921901703,
0.45405876636505127,
0.2051355540752411,
-0.26707252860069275,
0.1907910257577896,
-0.45457756519317627,
0.6814531087875366,
0.6030734777450562,
0.4278551936149597,
0.36284640431404114,
-0.3529837429523468,
0.9968939423561096,
-0.34557855129241943,
0.12394171208143234,
-0.2618410885334015,
-0.5001608729362488,
-0.9538528919219971,
-0.6695868968963623,
0.3883872926235199,
0.7548668384552002,
-1.089012622833252,
0.5570952296257019,
0.21257707476615906,
-0.057550590485334396,
-0.8587216734886169,
0.016771653667092323,
0.27597931027412415,
0.3874828815460205,
0.6261460185050964,
-0.21514318883419037,
-0.5219927430152893,
-0.5655022263526917,
-0.10040993243455887,
0.025458691641688347,
-0.33053523302078247,
0.04758220538496971,
0.4326200485229492,
0.0902794823050499,
0.9625568389892578,
-0.58250892162323,
-0.16297286748886108,
-0.7149199843406677,
0.16540312767028809,
-0.11419236660003662,
0.42202380299568176,
0.04775257781147957,
-0.8959735035896301,
-0.6262443661689758,
-0.25667500495910645,
-0.5081567764282227,
-0.556886613368988,
-0.2568502724170685,
-0.2418561726808548,
0.1263730525970459,
0.7880232334136963,
-0.6086591482162476,
0.27360156178474426,
0.5016719102859497,
-0.4593445658683777,
0.7066335678100586,
-0.263197660446167,
0.34762972593307495,
-1.1693118810653687,
0.08517690002918243,
-0.2986909747123718,
-0.3683672249317169,
-0.5201048851013184,
0.3719698190689087,
0.38123977184295654,
-0.026410304009914398,
-0.31557348370552063,
0.019340194761753082,
-0.6255714893341064,
-0.1908302754163742,
-0.2680317163467407,
0.33701154589653015,
0.5519982576370239,
0.23528343439102173,
-0.005712773185223341,
1.4307368993759155,
0.2722514867782593,
-0.693670392036438,
0.03432362526655197,
0.6637769937515259,
-0.4248102307319641,
0.24303704500198364,
-0.637732982635498,
0.2429729849100113,
-0.20487341284751892,
-0.0271115992218256,
-1.0051584243774414,
-0.2168479710817337,
0.0861399918794632,
-0.47817736864089966,
0.36548304557800293,
0.29519832134246826,
-0.42196211218833923,
-0.4266969859600067,
-0.2674570381641388,
-0.12021911889314651,
0.6273961663246155,
-0.6714226007461548,
0.541103184223175,
0.18030717968940735,
-0.6412262916564941,
-0.09222277998924255,
-0.7320377826690674,
-0.1702636033296585,
-0.20750828087329865,
-0.3422848880290985,
0.2755650579929352,
-0.22142961621284485,
0.007440584246069193,
-0.37285569310188293,
0.047345273196697235,
-0.15692123770713806,
0.18984392285346985,
-0.12577715516090393,
0.18480058014392853,
-0.3099922239780426,
0.09414991736412048,
0.5904284119606018,
0.0648016408085823,
-0.04300671070814133,
0.01046966016292572,
0.7747258543968201,
0.20720162987709045,
-0.08223965018987656,
-0.7631363272666931,
0.6869229078292847,
0.5646562576293945,
-0.7967589497566223,
0.6531782150268555,
0.15861067175865173,
0.12222851067781448,
-0.2266533076763153,
-0.2395658791065216,
-0.27227845788002014,
-0.5671542286872864,
0.4478227198123932,
-0.7440094947814941,
-1.14525306224823,
0.334022581577301,
-0.2252737581729889,
-0.111955925822258,
0.6036916375160217,
0.36135929822921753,
-0.44139328598976135,
1.2494491338729858,
0.6727299094200134,
0.2524178624153137,
0.6215237975120544,
-0.11625951528549194,
-0.12677636742591858,
-0.9026263356208801,
-0.13373474776744843,
-0.8090962767601013,
0.043641239404678345,
-0.23078221082687378,
-0.2705051004886627,
0.40281233191490173,
0.6076214909553528,
-0.171411395072937,
0.17308759689331055,
-0.3378872275352478,
0.33640310168266296,
0.7498860359191895,
0.13330091536045074,
0.5131105780601501,
-0.04388992115855217,
-0.2212628722190857,
-0.1747901886701584,
-0.7843003869056702,
-0.7089895009994507,
0.9532796740531921,
0.4472157657146454,
0.2579435408115387,
0.1670321524143219,
0.5953109264373779,
0.2756750285625458,
0.16822011768817902,
-0.5278435349464417,
0.5724294781684875,
-0.07912766188383102,
-0.7498957514762878,
-0.26999789476394653,
-0.4965467154979706,
-0.7744019627571106,
0.20409592986106873,
-0.1590539813041687,
-0.40813148021698,
0.1818847805261612,
0.1367247849702835,
-0.7314897775650024,
0.13396058976650238,
-0.679919421672821,
0.8064329028129578,
-0.03681746497750282,
0.0055663553066551685,
-0.23111462593078613,
-0.7945424914360046,
0.1375146359205246,
-0.09689446538686752,
-0.16228033602237701,
0.25448864698410034,
-0.04423174262046814,
0.8058686852455139,
-0.40130725502967834,
0.5686604380607605,
0.03701627999544144,
-0.011194306425750256,
0.7586066722869873,
0.13079416751861572,
0.6143842339515686,
-0.19430866837501526,
0.01992887444794178,
-0.4525420665740967,
0.05383763089776039,
-0.44716596603393555,
-0.4614412188529968,
0.010507304221391678,
-0.6478567719459534,
-0.5302593111991882,
-0.16972988843917847,
-0.3586370050907135,
-0.32500457763671875,
0.19158554077148438,
0.3513231575489044,
0.30512186884880066,
0.05651300400495529,
0.0003095838474109769,
0.9346831440925598,
-0.44654321670532227,
0.4684658944606781,
0.602802038192749,
-0.05291367322206497,
-0.6390493512153625,
0.7641427516937256,
-0.13523834943771362,
0.8039107918739319,
0.6428450345993042,
0.014818047173321247,
-0.46720749139785767,
-0.8361754417419434,
-0.4500992000102997,
-0.024058427661657333,
-0.5908710956573486,
-0.2511378526687622,
-0.9044275283813477,
-0.36436930298805237,
-0.5565292239189148,
0.1208362802863121,
-0.07056013494729996,
-0.6050153970718384,
-0.737567663192749,
-0.39413905143737793,
0.3127202093601227,
0.7799690961837769,
0.11351002007722855,
0.844247579574585,
-1.0697150230407715,
0.5622290372848511,
0.3261122703552246,
0.0124457823112607,
-0.41465482115745544,
-0.7580117583274841,
-0.11833909153938293,
-0.4101281464099884,
-0.6375082731246948,
-1.172970175743103,
0.6984398365020752,
0.49592575430870056,
0.3752910792827606,
0.40216079354286194,
-0.019727464765310287,
0.562214195728302,
-0.4317304790019989,
0.9153962731361389,
-0.005081565584987402,
-0.9852627515792847,
0.689296305179596,
-0.10125000774860382,
0.26040926575660706,
0.5445936918258667,
0.5702783465385437,
-0.24620582163333893,
-0.6225952506065369,
-0.4238058626651764,
-0.7204530239105225,
0.4945771396160126,
0.029372232034802437,
-0.3504447937011719,
-0.22184334695339203,
0.5145346522331238,
0.25300949811935425,
0.29253634810447693,
-0.6736575365066528,
0.06914950162172318,
-0.1296677440404892,
-0.46582508087158203,
-0.008002938702702522,
-0.6723737120628357,
0.26315608620643616,
-0.15345318615436554,
0.6541225910186768,
-0.04985576495528221,
0.12676702439785004,
0.6039741039276123,
-0.20152641832828522,
-0.3172544240951538,
0.36253276467323303,
0.7355830073356628,
0.5111398100852966,
-0.18161480128765106,
0.26010969281196594,
-0.06519778817892075,
-0.66485196352005,
-0.11786417663097382,
0.09039581567049026,
-0.3902644217014313,
-0.4055688679218292,
0.22460240125656128,
0.5673964023590088,
-0.4998464584350586,
-0.8776046633720398,
0.1893497109413147,
0.02180241420865059,
-0.3545422852039337,
-0.0018049542559310794,
0.1474790871143341,
-0.1636820137500763,
0.41136932373046875,
0.3502217233181,
-0.16716530919075012,
0.19251520931720734,
-0.16393812000751495,
0.6393266916275024,
0.2473011463880539,
-0.30140239000320435,
-0.1821821630001068,
0.7783685922622681,
0.16215799748897552,
0.03126547858119011,
0.713821291923523,
-0.32280582189559937,
-0.8393168449401855,
0.4762020409107208,
0.7786516547203064,
0.7846514582633972,
-0.339239239692688,
0.3021785616874695,
0.26323574781417847,
0.581107497215271,
0.004718507640063763,
0.7622919082641602,
-0.01595265604555607,
-0.684379518032074,
-0.75919109582901,
-0.5787094831466675,
-0.2601260840892792,
0.11375855654478073,
-0.7044509053230286,
-0.0726737380027771,
-0.27690353989601135,
-0.02044108137488365,
-0.3115406930446625,
0.21000346541404724,
-0.0787353590130806,
0.3403829336166382,
-0.23176708817481995,
0.9008275866508484,
-0.8985884189605713,
1.1086487770080566,
0.5740228295326233,
-0.6400854587554932,
-0.818469762802124,
0.04078810662031174,
-0.47638586163520813,
-0.45170724391937256,
0.5818491578102112,
-0.1802341639995575,
0.07721424847841263,
0.4564804136753082,
-0.39166954159736633,
-0.7439509630203247,
0.9957135319709778,
-0.02211691252887249,
-0.42586904764175415,
0.09020360559225082,
0.2122844159603119,
0.36250677704811096,
-0.10538080334663391,
0.043455883860588074,
0.7754148244857788,
0.404920756816864,
-0.2074718475341797,
-0.718147337436676,
-0.09539616852998734,
-0.025745194405317307,
-0.260867178440094,
0.2905144989490509,
-0.4068489372730255,
0.8784900307655334,
-0.1438288390636444,
-0.3538057804107666,
0.4067896008491516,
1.0510417222976685,
0.3142130374908447,
0.2310977578163147,
0.18540538847446442,
0.6031031012535095,
0.8770923614501953,
-0.005906476639211178,
1.1515793800354004,
0.07363065332174301,
0.03427043557167053,
1.1211293935775757,
-0.2254209816455841,
1.0374314785003662,
0.6869726777076721,
-0.4139731526374817,
0.34845396876335144,
0.8370298147201538,
0.23247407376766205,
0.7939092516899109,
0.005475613288581371,
-0.44545552134513855,
-0.22741331160068512,
0.20168067514896393,
-0.27070051431655884,
0.1360451877117157,
0.40255865454673767,
-0.4937187433242798,
0.17348644137382507,
0.10403311997652054,
-0.20743528008460999,
0.2447073757648468,
-0.3897668719291687,
0.9464258551597595,
0.03679496794939041,
-0.8677282333374023,
0.620194673538208,
0.04581630229949951,
0.4237542450428009,
-0.5902231335639954,
-0.022989653050899506,
-0.3991389572620392,
0.13557155430316925,
-0.13618457317352295,
-0.6931427717208862,
0.4374624788761139,
-0.08986490964889526,
-0.38360878825187683,
-0.3442251980304718,
0.8222026824951172,
-0.6060503125190735,
-0.023203978314995766,
-0.08285669982433319,
0.781833291053772,
0.130050390958786,
-0.21790243685245514,
-0.6127368807792664,
-0.21106670796871185,
0.3168680667877197,
-0.5117555856704712,
0.3583286702632904,
0.302642285823822,
-0.010542280040681362,
0.7175836563110352,
0.4570748507976532,
0.17603260278701782,
0.5942396521568298,
0.052739161998033524,
0.8453262448310852,
-0.7022865414619446,
-0.5054528713226318,
-0.6125658750534058,
0.4170580208301544,
-0.04832812398672104,
-0.433117151260376,
0.6367299556732178,
0.6035619974136353,
0.6202275156974792,
-0.25105994939804077,
0.8313369750976562,
-0.0937335267663002,
0.9107815623283386,
-0.8296083807945251,
0.6785091161727905,
-0.6667746901512146,
0.017774663865566254,
-0.04382135719060898,
-0.5935887694358826,
-0.3094179034233093,
0.5488026738166809,
-0.17229117453098297,
-0.18079738318920135,
1.053503394126892,
0.7539080381393433,
0.20875750482082367,
0.31235623359680176,
0.3074701428413391,
-0.0993073433637619,
0.3350389301776886,
0.43039369583129883,
1.1410363912582397,
-0.32377177476882935,
0.4800399839878082,
-0.06531062722206116,
-0.3254222273826599,
0.1506470888853073,
-0.6515389084815979,
-1.0196934938430786,
-0.553787887096405,
-0.36488470435142517,
-0.3504582941532135,
0.0951148197054863,
0.7199603915214539,
0.33342647552490234,
-1.12175714969635,
-0.03334597125649452,
-0.4765154719352722,
-0.011106764897704124,
-0.32878822088241577,
-0.33112719655036926,
0.6608530879020691,
-0.619459867477417,
-0.7482779026031494,
0.6237159967422485,
0.34254345297813416,
0.3437321186065674,
-0.009668347425758839,
0.02611638605594635,
-0.31457817554473877,
0.007543760351836681,
0.6646535992622375,
0.25634458661079407,
-0.3332159221172333,
0.017438510432839394,
0.19315968453884125,
-0.2339482456445694,
0.16700924932956696,
0.8961113691329956,
-0.4786020517349243,
0.27313676476478577,
0.721250593662262,
0.7284051775932312,
0.40312477946281433,
0.2636193037033081,
0.6750385165214539,
-0.7237004637718201,
0.03325490653514862,
0.3824531137943268,
0.14369407296180725,
0.06317956000566483,
-0.26833590865135193,
0.24902956187725067,
0.21225790679454803,
-0.6509276628494263,
-0.6463416814804077,
0.40300968289375305,
-0.8222365975379944,
-0.48787692189216614,
0.9364574551582336,
-0.2918040156364441,
-0.19439581036567688,
-0.2926916778087616,
-0.5354716777801514,
0.3190058767795563,
-0.018116123974323273,
0.7085285782814026,
0.44300130009651184,
-0.24986915290355682,
-0.6250495314598083,
-0.8976866602897644,
0.8482417464256287,
0.8377819061279297,
-1.187727928161621,
-0.07902510464191437,
0.4505847692489624,
0.040018435567617416,
-0.25938060879707336,
0.6849525570869446,
-0.42539122700691223,
0.2128848135471344,
-0.34109559655189514,
0.2793619930744171,
0.0033477405086159706,
-0.497389554977417,
-0.2532837986946106,
0.6785812973976135,
0.23050440847873688,
-0.3240770995616913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16313v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16313v1
|
Chain-of-Discussion: A Multi-Model Framework for Complex Evidence-Based Question Answering
| 2024-02-26T05:31:34 | 2024-02-26T05:31:34 |
Mingxu Tao, Dongyan Zhao, Yansong Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Open-ended question answering requires models to find appropriate evidence to
form well-reasoned, comprehensive and helpful answers. In practical
applications, models also need to engage in extended discussions on potential
scenarios closely relevant to the question. With augmentation of retrieval
module, open-source Large Language Models (LLMs) can produce coherent answers
often with different focuses, but are still sub-optimal in terms of reliable
evidence selection and in-depth question analysis. In this paper, we propose a
novel Chain-of-Discussion framework to leverage the synergy among multiple
open-source LLMs aiming to provide \textbf{more correct} and \textbf{more
comprehensive} answers for open-ended QA, although they are not strong enough
individually. Our experiments show that discussions among multiple LLMs play a
vital role in enhancing the quality of answers. We release our data and code at
\url{https://github.com/kobayashikanna01/Chain-of-Discussion}.
|
[
-0.6744980812072754,
-1.02003812789917,
0.9339067935943604,
-0.11969208717346191,
-0.23898544907569885,
0.129839226603508,
-0.2748722732067108,
-0.6395045518875122,
0.27349284291267395,
0.43409961462020874,
-0.3320815861225128,
-0.37921953201293945,
-0.27963805198669434,
-0.0046485052444040775,
-0.38389521837234497,
0.8639506697654724,
-0.18815554678440094,
0.5343454480171204,
-0.21916751563549042,
-0.5508288741111755,
-0.3748844861984253,
-0.5722541213035583,
-0.37187156081199646,
-0.2682136297225952,
0.8389537334442139,
0.32311826944351196,
0.7020283341407776,
0.18885253369808197,
0.5809828639030457,
0.2882218360900879,
-0.10751093178987503,
0.2593304514884949,
-0.4326254427433014,
0.4582594037055969,
-0.7205424904823303,
-0.4622969627380371,
-0.651192307472229,
-0.3373929560184479,
0.42175546288490295,
0.7398495078086853,
-0.3704196512699127,
0.3059660494327545,
-0.059996847063302994,
0.28598859906196594,
-0.8442344665527344,
-0.410684734582901,
-0.79482102394104,
-0.31374064087867737,
0.24883303046226501,
-0.18443937599658966,
-0.40418946743011475,
-0.45954105257987976,
0.2736549973487854,
-0.33897027373313904,
-0.36676350235939026,
-0.08444347232580185,
0.7068870663642883,
-0.22097453474998474,
-0.4662521481513977,
-0.3323204219341278,
-0.8668015003204346,
0.4216121435165405,
-1.0825105905532837,
0.10065817087888718,
-0.08273039758205414,
0.30005520582199097,
-0.2694041132926941,
-0.7523393630981445,
-0.6941108703613281,
0.1218685507774353,
0.06959712505340576,
0.2637332081794739,
-0.04955306276679039,
0.21270953118801117,
-0.033179719001054764,
0.7093669176101685,
-0.35433897376060486,
0.2004014402627945,
-0.3548140227794647,
0.1318620890378952,
0.42962512373924255,
0.19991044700145721,
0.17156203091144562,
0.16152538359165192,
-0.3017232120037079,
0.09840609133243561,
-0.6064417362213135,
-0.1116924062371254,
0.2581876516342163,
0.13975217938423157,
0.23094210028648376,
0.748340368270874,
-0.4339791238307953,
0.8709536790847778,
-0.09503757208585739,
0.060224734246730804,
0.05034717917442322,
-0.6606667041778564,
-0.20095360279083252,
-0.18946997821331024,
0.7856186628341675,
0.3902629613876343,
-0.12905330955982208,
-0.0199857447296381,
-0.05791570618748665,
-0.2175779640674591,
0.19774557650089264,
-0.8832222819328308,
-0.006577692925930023,
0.5277858972549438,
-0.6235296130180359,
-0.13982607424259186,
0.4711111783981323,
-0.8205643892288208,
-0.050551097840070724,
-0.15899917483329773,
0.5015221238136292,
0.17976076900959015,
-0.5016818642616272,
0.42032676935195923,
-0.21109648048877716,
0.013929751701653004,
0.48227834701538086,
-0.21384233236312866,
0.5390075445175171,
0.5528250336647034,
0.6796771883964539,
0.1256401538848877,
0.043350327759981155,
-0.6890007853507996,
0.27711132168769836,
-0.29413098096847534,
0.7379145622253418,
-0.6181766390800476,
-0.07971574366092682,
0.11955589801073074,
-0.10579047352075577,
0.1728900969028473,
-0.410133957862854,
0.612113356590271,
-0.8763698935508728,
0.7665155529975891,
-0.3356098234653473,
-0.6239267587661743,
-0.2866206169128418,
0.7097428441047668,
-0.7324504256248474,
0.6863987445831299,
-0.25334876775741577,
-0.7752537727355957,
0.0021454240195453167,
-0.6396580934524536,
-0.17654579877853394,
-0.04384086653590202,
-0.22832895815372467,
-0.0870329961180687,
0.08596108853816986,
0.3383773863315582,
0.22842064499855042,
-0.6192394495010376,
0.5010789036750793,
-0.7512577772140503,
-0.13680686056613922,
0.3844951391220093,
-0.257820725440979,
0.37378618121147156,
0.3443193733692169,
-0.02932722494006157,
0.5005882978439331,
-0.6806347966194153,
0.2781868278980255,
-0.15397782623767853,
-0.405511736869812,
-0.7727782130241394,
-0.03571334853768349,
-0.3729270398616791,
0.5038649439811707,
0.1982189267873764,
-0.6989097595214844,
0.2667284905910492,
-0.3467603027820587,
0.3618927001953125,
0.6181575059890747,
0.3051711916923523,
0.25582948327064514,
-0.5769367218017578,
0.4471675753593445,
0.10441489517688751,
0.33678415417671204,
-0.3888710141181946,
-0.5255367755889893,
-0.678381085395813,
-0.045590728521347046,
0.17587706446647644,
0.254779577255249,
-0.7054739594459534,
0.35005807876586914,
-0.2136557251214981,
-0.40164005756378174,
-0.6266719698905945,
-0.011599955148994923,
0.5324663519859314,
0.37973886728286743,
0.5475921034812927,
-0.45424574613571167,
-0.4817950427532196,
-0.7485665082931519,
-0.1001596674323082,
-0.3494251072406769,
-0.052136681973934174,
0.2138735055923462,
0.3571489751338959,
0.13545863330364227,
0.8916621804237366,
-0.5394744277000427,
0.12457537651062012,
-0.09394778311252594,
-0.07136932015419006,
0.39395999908447266,
0.11173055320978165,
0.2117282599210739,
-0.5984678268432617,
-0.26311424374580383,
0.06304097920656204,
-0.6732528209686279,
0.25097525119781494,
0.011449082754552364,
-0.5214060544967651,
-0.1498619168996811,
0.28560173511505127,
-0.6938459873199463,
0.14478299021720886,
0.5372276306152344,
-0.04437717795372009,
0.46677449345588684,
-0.07101471722126007,
0.3178088068962097,
-1.4899550676345825,
0.25934430956840515,
-0.19691671431064606,
-0.12059344351291656,
-0.5467254519462585,
0.5894300937652588,
-0.14024917781352997,
0.13793441653251648,
-0.21014782786369324,
0.4554700553417206,
-0.34482479095458984,
0.06630029529333115,
-0.21609389781951904,
0.5544660091400146,
0.11694330722093582,
0.4483957290649414,
0.16915565729141235,
0.5968495607376099,
0.30697891116142273,
-0.5450202226638794,
0.41680657863616943,
0.44521716237068176,
-0.33803313970565796,
0.4953477084636688,
-0.8606647253036499,
0.17208260297775269,
0.025134891271591187,
0.34008076786994934,
-0.8911499381065369,
-0.3285270631313324,
0.1814710944890976,
-0.21497438848018646,
-0.12372767180204391,
-0.019459793344140053,
-0.6767450571060181,
-0.4584665596485138,
-0.4944884777069092,
0.5258848667144775,
0.24962173402309418,
-0.6751205921173096,
0.3865342438220978,
0.48660966753959656,
-0.41738247871398926,
-0.6878075003623962,
-0.2378552258014679,
0.009836236014962196,
0.1206318661570549,
-0.8494633436203003,
0.09759970009326935,
-0.3729925751686096,
-0.4015997350215912,
0.1444314569234848,
-0.19616608321666718,
-0.19299837946891785,
-0.12378813326358795,
-0.215488001704216,
0.2927643954753876,
-0.5339917540550232,
0.5213789939880371,
0.08477045595645905,
0.3914906084537506,
0.12077809870243073,
-0.3256341814994812,
0.6182436347007751,
-0.1950894445180893,
-0.6758736371994019,
0.04696207493543625,
0.6127365827560425,
0.6103748083114624,
-0.40717098116874695,
0.5791052579879761,
0.12437903136014938,
-0.31214749813079834,
-0.06140611320734024,
-0.7733484506607056,
-0.4021552801132202,
-0.4473782479763031,
0.3848534822463989,
-0.3028433620929718,
-1.3301289081573486,
0.7694835662841797,
-0.12557795643806458,
0.2411939799785614,
0.2743171155452728,
0.8076221942901611,
0.07662827521562576,
0.9916355013847351,
0.27906081080436707,
0.13953888416290283,
0.16802223026752472,
0.2223314642906189,
0.3598652780056,
-0.8560253381729126,
-0.3234727084636688,
-0.5646023154258728,
-0.08043160289525986,
-0.16468624770641327,
-0.44945210218429565,
0.5074575543403625,
0.39364224672317505,
-0.07025105506181717,
-0.04182979092001915,
-0.436529278755188,
0.37424424290657043,
0.38832297921180725,
0.32896238565444946,
0.6397340893745422,
-0.19397477805614471,
-0.25072047114372253,
0.51429682970047,
-0.9108588099479675,
-0.5048595666885376,
0.8969267010688782,
0.3651965260505676,
0.8553516268730164,
0.35053879022598267,
0.3260178565979004,
-0.2497003972530365,
0.22755925357341766,
-0.4432007372379303,
0.6148735284805298,
0.2576545178890228,
-0.8936472535133362,
-0.3008350431919098,
-0.45212966203689575,
-0.7955702543258667,
0.6340696811676025,
-0.27550190687179565,
-0.5608364343643188,
0.04204469546675682,
-0.03748556599020958,
-0.47886449098587036,
0.683160126209259,
-0.17452087998390198,
0.7004427313804626,
-0.18896153569221497,
-0.5798262357711792,
-0.502103328704834,
-0.8851820826530457,
0.6946240067481995,
0.07217612862586975,
0.22907307744026184,
0.13596151769161224,
0.12327485531568527,
0.5705215930938721,
-0.5599257946014404,
0.4959959387779236,
0.1030270978808403,
-0.4434574246406555,
0.765823245048523,
-0.13392673432826996,
0.3945893347263336,
0.19745326042175293,
-0.07686574757099152,
-0.19263513386249542,
0.07474283128976822,
-0.2353370040655136,
-0.7468017339706421,
0.7294573187828064,
-0.5655773878097534,
-0.7457279562950134,
-0.21309204399585724,
-0.38811230659484863,
-0.2764776647090912,
0.10785383731126785,
-0.24159711599349976,
0.5221055150032043,
-0.24612867832183838,
0.17348656058311462,
0.718139111995697,
-0.23419421911239624,
0.1519923210144043,
0.4294566810131073,
-0.5140523314476013,
-0.7443342804908752,
0.39878931641578674,
-0.24640177190303802,
0.6046655774116516,
0.38539987802505493,
0.283222496509552,
-0.1928093433380127,
-0.568739116191864,
-0.31125205755233765,
0.2594362497329712,
-1.0277405977249146,
-0.42441874742507935,
-0.792946457862854,
-0.20522430539131165,
-0.27819007635116577,
0.2346320003271103,
-0.10888664424419403,
-0.6117327213287354,
-0.06052552908658981,
-0.33316728472709656,
0.4189258813858032,
0.7006381154060364,
0.13855543732643127,
0.14522728323936462,
-1.1598249673843384,
0.3339044451713562,
0.41165250539779663,
0.5227287411689758,
0.33738192915916443,
-0.13355623185634613,
-0.24251149594783783,
0.26282376050949097,
-0.42093566060066223,
-0.8966644406318665,
-0.10101237893104553,
-0.10769406706094742,
0.7149505019187927,
0.27515605092048645,
0.2500254511833191,
0.9554803967475891,
-0.23092862963676453,
0.9195001721382141,
0.5722862482070923,
-0.7474470734596252,
0.506912887096405,
-0.3883630931377411,
0.30176886916160583,
0.6602088809013367,
0.5022364258766174,
-0.5499656796455383,
-0.7119669318199158,
-0.3826768100261688,
-0.890438973903656,
0.4038766324520111,
0.034196898341178894,
-0.09504752606153488,
-0.1463731974363327,
0.22132548689842224,
0.3229568898677826,
0.42274126410484314,
-0.6888759732246399,
0.04315108433365822,
0.22192703187465668,
-0.12194658070802689,
0.43491414189338684,
-0.3474176824092865,
-0.4519582986831665,
-0.18431256711483002,
0.732835054397583,
-0.23226848244667053,
0.0436093807220459,
0.453582227230072,
-0.025761475786566734,
-0.36443042755126953,
0.7072505354881287,
0.49110159277915955,
0.9274500608444214,
-0.12272097170352936,
0.24113838374614716,
0.17305432260036469,
-0.04660014435648918,
0.09469395130872726,
-0.11898592114448547,
-0.01362419780343771,
-0.06438777595758438,
0.38872525095939636,
0.6367982029914856,
0.08098442107439041,
-0.7451820969581604,
0.487673819065094,
-0.140940323472023,
-0.31845593452453613,
-0.040533263236284256,
0.008023841306567192,
0.18375511467456818,
0.3920430541038513,
0.35046637058258057,
0.056643303483724594,
0.2628954350948334,
-0.8411179184913635,
0.38990238308906555,
0.5276698470115662,
-0.45105305314064026,
-0.11181408166885376,
0.4576292037963867,
0.4195236265659332,
-0.09947420656681061,
0.5949953198432922,
0.08848154544830322,
-0.55284184217453,
0.3963925838470459,
0.2594897747039795,
0.6264962553977966,
-0.10659750550985336,
0.12423313409090042,
0.4731338620185852,
0.11606306582689285,
-0.29365238547325134,
0.7584431767463684,
0.05216265469789505,
-0.5737529993057251,
-0.8161841034889221,
-0.38698121905326843,
-0.5923683047294617,
0.05423068627715111,
-0.7759057283401489,
0.3444140553474426,
-0.3265935480594635,
-0.1665043830871582,
-0.3308553099632263,
-0.15858161449432373,
-0.18382062017917633,
-0.07116426527500153,
-0.06429768353700638,
0.9923872947692871,
-0.4640631675720215,
0.7575400471687317,
0.6852328777313232,
-0.7639922499656677,
-0.7048861980438232,
-0.053781576454639435,
-0.5431338548660278,
-0.1568686068058014,
0.234114870429039,
-0.0346943698823452,
-0.22280487418174744,
-0.290865421295166,
-0.648865282535553,
-0.8184204697608948,
1.13321852684021,
0.35914120078086853,
-0.6695556044578552,
-0.1461227983236313,
-0.04094589874148369,
0.7590957283973694,
-0.5368285775184631,
0.7769325971603394,
-0.12886004149913788,
0.3891274631023407,
0.4316661059856415,
-1.1748205423355103,
0.27578574419021606,
-0.3473059833049774,
-0.2813773453235626,
0.18772529065608978,
-0.7416383028030396,
0.8321074843406677,
-0.3820529878139496,
-0.023869534954428673,
0.5349277853965759,
0.7263339161872864,
0.4539388418197632,
0.4103590250015259,
0.4188709557056427,
0.4379996061325073,
0.6232999563217163,
0.20411783456802368,
0.7530180215835571,
-0.3812243938446045,
0.3062978982925415,
1.5545918941497803,
-0.5319584608078003,
1.0367622375488281,
0.6229529976844788,
-0.10265379399061203,
0.8107531666755676,
0.616151750087738,
0.22393451631069183,
0.33264487981796265,
0.44945183396339417,
-0.2038416862487793,
-0.4474378526210785,
-0.16527368128299713,
-0.49574190378189087,
-0.10448398441076279,
0.1272679567337036,
-0.2634190320968628,
-0.25356486439704895,
-0.13949579000473022,
-0.16670392453670502,
0.2684095799922943,
-0.25424763560295105,
0.8858059048652649,
0.09733332693576813,
-0.9689335823059082,
0.37012624740600586,
-0.0027229697443544865,
0.5131034851074219,
-0.7301766872406006,
-0.2676037549972534,
-0.02777884341776371,
0.12032555043697357,
-0.2005101591348648,
-0.9192466139793396,
0.06335438787937164,
-0.16731439530849457,
-0.1685793399810791,
0.08073174953460693,
0.6981219053268433,
-0.8304991722106934,
-0.19460375607013702,
0.4890702962875366,
0.8152952790260315,
-0.09441135078668594,
0.0343051441013813,
-0.4607781171798706,
-0.03269854933023453,
-0.42693236470222473,
-0.20272302627563477,
0.2866491377353668,
0.4889909625053406,
-0.1101454421877861,
0.5893117189407349,
0.7736414670944214,
-0.1094333752989769,
0.20224355161190033,
0.13623645901679993,
1.348572850227356,
-0.2557193338871002,
-0.47667551040649414,
-0.7251659035682678,
0.6220411658287048,
-0.4681515395641327,
-0.06125946715474129,
0.7436457872390747,
0.6521320343017578,
0.9165492057800293,
0.058874569833278656,
0.7620867490768433,
0.017627529799938202,
0.5232943892478943,
-0.5667380094528198,
0.40728941559791565,
-0.6373791694641113,
0.34315255284309387,
-0.41718629002571106,
-0.9081138372421265,
-0.23813998699188232,
0.44138020277023315,
-0.0016649068566039205,
-0.02918984927237034,
0.9171984195709229,
0.4941631257534027,
-0.19644470512866974,
0.35608434677124023,
0.16366983950138092,
0.3379829525947571,
0.4807891249656677,
0.626399576663971,
1.175683617591858,
-0.4941360354423523,
0.6639280319213867,
0.038361094892024994,
-0.11474882066249847,
-0.02273903414607048,
-0.6991846561431885,
-0.8437264561653137,
-0.4361479580402374,
-0.3421609401702881,
-0.4511791169643402,
0.2623874247074127,
1.0734574794769287,
0.5305415987968445,
-0.6773408651351929,
-0.5167784690856934,
-0.11822061240673065,
0.29671740531921387,
-0.23516595363616943,
-0.15575675666332245,
0.15165752172470093,
-0.19199509918689728,
-0.3983302414417267,
0.26977303624153137,
0.21601037681102753,
-0.35122883319854736,
-0.4288196563720703,
-0.1912558376789093,
-0.7625949382781982,
0.1682765781879425,
0.741733968257904,
0.057223837822675705,
-0.7746977806091309,
-0.3191488981246948,
0.1254000961780548,
0.10643433779478073,
0.14082835614681244,
1.0784120559692383,
-0.5682429075241089,
0.5292697548866272,
0.7612286806106567,
0.7104213237762451,
0.37567463517189026,
0.13849911093711853,
0.8480690717697144,
-0.4294585883617401,
-0.1784186214208603,
0.29862743616104126,
0.3528652787208557,
-0.00874347984790802,
-0.1423063725233078,
0.50971919298172,
-0.01874348521232605,
-0.6389874219894409,
-0.9523932337760925,
0.4800776243209839,
-0.9824376106262207,
-0.6230939626693726,
1.146951675415039,
-0.36822864413261414,
0.05940704047679901,
-0.15180474519729614,
-0.33998802304267883,
0.15978960692882538,
-0.43960434198379517,
0.5327472686767578,
0.8755228519439697,
-0.013390598818659782,
-0.21634434163570404,
-0.17982642352581024,
-0.1407504677772522,
0.2826549708843231,
-1.0850814580917358,
0.1070309653878212,
0.6603038907051086,
0.08481460809707642,
0.32883206009864807,
0.6410505771636963,
-0.3008551597595215,
0.07093653082847595,
-0.419339120388031,
-0.10760325938463211,
0.07776062190532684,
-0.43772172927856445,
-0.27576500177383423,
0.668219268321991,
0.2791615128517151,
0.00981143955141306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16311v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16311v3
|
Cross-domain Chinese Sentence Pattern Parsing
| 2024-02-26T05:30:48 | 2024-04-08T03:22:41 |
Jingsi Yu, Cunliang Kong, Liner Yang, Meishan Zhang, Lin Zhu, Yujie Wang, Haozhe Lin, Maosong Sun, Erhong Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sentence Pattern Structure (SPS) parsing is a syntactic analysis method
primarily employed in language teaching.Existing SPS parsers rely heavily on
textbook corpora for training, lacking cross-domain capability.To overcome this
constraint, this paper proposes an innovative approach leveraging large
language models (LLMs) within a self-training framework. Partial syntactic
rules from a source domain are combined with target domain sentences to
dynamically generate training data, enhancing the adaptability of the parser to
diverse domains.Experiments conducted on textbook and news domains demonstrate
the effectiveness of the proposed method, outperforming rule-based baselines by
1.68 points on F1 metrics.
|
[
0.20089741051197052,
-0.7183904051780701,
0.5777835845947266,
0.46945032477378845,
-0.4045392870903015,
-0.09507454186677933,
-0.13713298738002777,
-0.2005072385072708,
0.06449337303638458,
0.4529709219932556,
-0.5692881941795349,
-0.48446598649024963,
-0.3872077763080597,
0.326960027217865,
-0.46593397855758667,
0.8137331604957581,
-0.010099900886416435,
0.4391539394855499,
-0.06904900074005127,
0.1804683655500412,
-0.3366970717906952,
-0.7775067090988159,
-0.6345419883728027,
-0.015942823141813278,
0.3176345229148865,
0.4233466386795044,
0.3683209717273712,
0.8114562034606934,
0.26055026054382324,
0.25163155794143677,
-0.02910824865102768,
0.4002391993999481,
-0.16762864589691162,
0.09520761668682098,
-0.502720832824707,
-0.4034363031387329,
-0.2783247232437134,
-0.06930115073919296,
0.8041101694107056,
0.8810964226722717,
-0.07144754379987717,
-0.05898687615990639,
0.1511789858341217,
0.4737808406352997,
-0.25077560544013977,
0.025946617126464844,
-0.6727179884910583,
0.4554443359375,
-0.29159319400787354,
-0.5863624215126038,
-0.7623199820518494,
-0.08658754080533981,
0.19496965408325195,
-0.5633893013000488,
0.44471320509910583,
0.020071275532245636,
0.7708849906921387,
-0.19515784084796906,
-0.48218151926994324,
-0.40273967385292053,
-0.32144293189048767,
0.7815260887145996,
-0.7240387797355652,
0.5046137571334839,
0.06799936294555664,
0.23710164427757263,
-0.28401029109954834,
-0.9146594405174255,
-0.38957148790359497,
-0.11789628118276596,
-0.30513763427734375,
-0.18347753584384918,
0.25862863659858704,
-0.19697874784469604,
0.11918655782938004,
0.5633400678634644,
-0.7163763046264648,
-0.20006349682807922,
-0.1933646947145462,
-0.012490187771618366,
0.7917437553405762,
0.3105790615081787,
0.6735380291938782,
-0.3705013692378998,
-0.7104955315589905,
0.11925176531076431,
-0.8609434962272644,
0.32042306661605835,
0.07519348710775375,
0.8953394293785095,
-0.15169917047023773,
0.5140432715415955,
-0.07749057561159134,
0.8290267586708069,
0.20962035655975342,
-0.2217400074005127,
0.08578290790319443,
-0.3290136754512787,
-0.5077632665634155,
-0.024340881034731865,
0.5161187648773193,
0.11854865401983261,
0.30120640993118286,
-0.23619511723518372,
-0.21973910927772522,
-0.06158881261944771,
0.1488589197397232,
-0.6525081396102905,
-0.15221698582172394,
-0.004430445376783609,
-0.622652530670166,
-0.14781454205513,
-0.04170771688222885,
-0.638528048992157,
-0.1268955022096634,
-0.4693658947944641,
0.03803275525569916,
-0.6830730438232422,
-0.06192329525947571,
0.37827134132385254,
-0.1050010621547699,
0.24955813586711884,
0.3793374001979828,
-1.018168568611145,
0.40749067068099976,
0.6086550951004028,
1.0275112390518188,
-0.3631307780742645,
-0.6858934164047241,
-0.6967864036560059,
0.5268906950950623,
-0.22505643963813782,
0.9100096821784973,
-0.5646101236343384,
-0.25477421283721924,
0.24448871612548828,
0.18490569293498993,
-0.3292471766471863,
-0.37113597989082336,
0.38115811347961426,
-0.30747905373573303,
0.27636727690696716,
-0.16774962842464447,
-0.8566579818725586,
0.07293971627950668,
0.21633824706077576,
-0.364398330450058,
1.1388189792633057,
0.2047625184059143,
-0.5546274185180664,
0.2956783175468445,
-0.4682069718837738,
-0.8163104057312012,
0.2440626621246338,
-0.40858787298202515,
-0.2682151794433594,
-0.15876078605651855,
0.17049483954906464,
0.8086152672767639,
-0.031250834465026855,
0.5419771075248718,
-0.20806361734867096,
-0.18568550050258636,
-0.06416293978691101,
-0.12053543329238892,
1.0078184604644775,
0.34229305386543274,
-0.23954877257347107,
0.24573452770709991,
-0.9107473492622375,
0.09144365042448044,
0.3721546530723572,
-0.37646016478538513,
-0.4985959231853485,
0.04487309604883194,
-0.1067572683095932,
0.44293656945228577,
0.16418002545833588,
-0.4834907054901123,
0.4243777096271515,
-0.3972010016441345,
0.4398542642593384,
0.6711528301239014,
-0.08276671171188354,
0.3022945821285248,
-0.13606421649456024,
0.4361824691295624,
0.2553471028804779,
0.009833840653300285,
-0.41725239157676697,
-0.27423277497291565,
-0.8045915961265564,
-0.37870141863822937,
0.02188144437968731,
0.45156538486480713,
-0.8894103169441223,
0.6098379492759705,
-0.13408681750297546,
-0.41351377964019775,
-0.10089332610368729,
0.25314125418663025,
0.26293376088142395,
0.1740918904542923,
0.47933733463287354,
-0.13582682609558105,
-0.6646535396575928,
-0.6236691474914551,
-0.7077594995498657,
0.18546687066555023,
0.18365667760372162,
-0.22310224175453186,
0.29305121302604675,
0.11149187386035919,
0.8969070315361023,
-0.47043946385383606,
-0.36585092544555664,
-0.8407467603683472,
-0.21410660445690155,
-0.03202512860298157,
0.48571541905403137,
0.613692581653595,
-0.6880961060523987,
-0.7203730344772339,
-0.10393641144037247,
-0.7220332622528076,
-0.09119734913110733,
-0.2760557234287262,
-0.08897416293621063,
0.12116406857967377,
0.9015412926673889,
-0.6329132914543152,
0.4060545861721039,
0.49705731868743896,
-0.7052331566810608,
0.4731760621070862,
-0.013682487420737743,
-0.2699926197528839,
-1.0525920391082764,
-0.3043557107448578,
0.4244232177734375,
-0.4698947072029114,
-0.8701471090316772,
0.22041645646095276,
0.1297565996646881,
-0.23690880835056305,
-0.6509722471237183,
0.41803377866744995,
-0.6987868547439575,
-0.2943805754184723,
-0.2967507839202881,
0.059482503682374954,
0.14200909435749054,
0.5597516894340515,
0.43821197748184204,
0.7563650012016296,
0.4562113285064697,
-0.6128591895103455,
0.318483829498291,
0.20868244767189026,
-0.29633432626724243,
0.19159086048603058,
-0.46877896785736084,
-0.11354228854179382,
0.12585479021072388,
0.3904968798160553,
-0.9146814346313477,
0.11422967910766602,
0.3023739755153656,
-0.059043947607278824,
0.08000785112380981,
0.019670184701681137,
-0.36231350898742676,
-0.14086565375328064,
-0.24740777909755707,
0.353810578584671,
-0.07382494956254959,
-0.7630981206893921,
0.6977517604827881,
0.12573844194412231,
-0.2296561449766159,
-0.3742504417896271,
-0.6712722778320312,
0.18785832822322845,
-0.12249498814344406,
-0.7925584316253662,
0.4298379421234131,
-0.03605600818991661,
-0.09677287191152573,
-0.12390024214982986,
-0.028826072812080383,
0.026165716350078583,
-0.02714608982205391,
-0.003813708433881402,
0.19145679473876953,
-0.603853166103363,
-0.08529378473758698,
0.005513309966772795,
0.17930299043655396,
0.00400268891826272,
-0.3010202646255493,
0.7998753786087036,
0.049676313996315,
-0.26182374358177185,
-0.6691028475761414,
0.5237929224967957,
0.19582125544548035,
-0.31947314739227295,
0.525250256061554,
-0.12172742187976837,
-0.22276467084884644,
-1.073486328125,
-0.07422219961881638,
0.11623857170343399,
-0.5771228671073914,
0.27181535959243774,
-0.6728217005729675,
-0.7930532097816467,
0.12332285195589066,
-0.14089854061603546,
-0.12507200241088867,
0.36272329092025757,
0.6047219634056091,
0.2182527780532837,
0.5656675696372986,
0.8795391321182251,
-0.014091776683926582,
0.5939743518829346,
0.11137012392282486,
0.45081642270088196,
-0.27538418769836426,
-0.18851809203624725,
-0.30812591314315796,
0.2512766718864441,
-0.21581503748893738,
-0.4383106529712677,
-0.1534678190946579,
-0.1488926261663437,
-0.32886403799057007,
0.5383139252662659,
-0.3916628956794739,
0.45788097381591797,
0.5703344345092773,
0.06928782910108566,
0.3211301267147064,
0.3071031868457794,
-0.12673811614513397,
0.02852397970855236,
-0.8025823831558228,
-0.520024836063385,
0.6819963455200195,
0.518186092376709,
0.6679961085319519,
-0.12049499899148941,
0.5295788049697876,
0.45862963795661926,
-0.14979815483093262,
-0.7992939949035645,
0.9005287885665894,
-0.6723645329475403,
-0.250131756067276,
-0.5563115477561951,
-0.3756793141365051,
-0.6737440228462219,
0.6009464859962463,
0.21513038873672485,
-0.3685641586780548,
0.1112423688173294,
-0.25429028272628784,
-0.3492058217525482,
0.4033019542694092,
-0.6769879460334778,
0.9502366781234741,
-0.3323418200016022,
-0.07309716194868088,
0.21863435208797455,
-0.6404051184654236,
0.23359930515289307,
0.06416437774896622,
0.15305641293525696,
0.06104746460914612,
0.24498659372329712,
0.6373972296714783,
-0.5233580470085144,
1.2175275087356567,
-0.06631691008806229,
-0.48890742659568787,
0.4282680153846741,
0.2234194129705429,
0.379408597946167,
-0.22315165400505066,
-0.009549422189593315,
0.1632743626832962,
0.01031306479126215,
-0.4327617883682251,
-0.5718541741371155,
0.3534151315689087,
-0.7300168871879578,
-0.6934665441513062,
-0.6770355701446533,
-0.6244428753852844,
-0.3006804585456848,
0.2533078193664551,
-0.016810234636068344,
0.3269859552383423,
0.008025797083973885,
-0.16142559051513672,
0.3684988021850586,
-0.227300226688385,
0.4226274788379669,
0.7481286525726318,
0.014902300201356411,
-0.1858348846435547,
0.8353312015533447,
0.03910506144165993,
0.34173583984375,
0.44733598828315735,
0.13973726332187653,
0.055159442126750946,
-0.5921269655227661,
-0.4220900237560272,
0.3653670847415924,
-0.8571213483810425,
-0.1867399960756302,
-0.6679063439369202,
-0.7327101230621338,
-0.9035292267799377,
-0.2229786366224289,
-0.16775551438331604,
-0.38102075457572937,
-0.21294322609901428,
-0.21204593777656555,
-0.030900994315743446,
0.8323386311531067,
0.1510680466890335,
0.5849918723106384,
-0.7878045439720154,
0.3785741925239563,
0.07166517525911331,
0.3210529386997223,
-0.14491678774356842,
-0.7441681623458862,
-0.30073681473731995,
-0.1885327398777008,
-0.2572740614414215,
-0.7085781097412109,
0.667671799659729,
0.23263424634933472,
0.5792083144187927,
0.3546018600463867,
-0.11322843283414841,
0.8436896800994873,
-0.9151351451873779,
1.0770617723464966,
0.23057034611701965,
-1.324276328086853,
0.7689042687416077,
-0.3105345666408539,
-0.10889343917369843,
0.138218954205513,
0.3735728859901428,
-0.7348980903625488,
-0.4499516785144806,
-0.3809104561805725,
-0.668991208076477,
1.01868736743927,
-0.048131655901670456,
0.06790703535079956,
-0.02053375542163849,
0.5507810711860657,
0.2482711672782898,
-0.11202434450387955,
-1.1303669214248657,
-0.24199077486991882,
-0.3270362615585327,
-0.467465341091156,
0.008005611598491669,
-0.32777512073516846,
-0.04688981920480728,
-0.30183088779449463,
0.775908350944519,
-0.19170264899730682,
-0.0008133069495670497,
0.21390627324581146,
-0.22053225338459015,
-0.31732845306396484,
0.038735754787921906,
0.4754931628704071,
0.6306449174880981,
0.13924311101436615,
0.21047261357307434,
-0.0264760609716177,
-0.43915295600891113,
0.14757175743579865,
-0.03535010293126106,
-0.13019241392612457,
0.0788656547665596,
0.4906182885169983,
0.5283411145210266,
-0.05934682488441467,
-0.6270387172698975,
0.7517734169960022,
-0.008575391955673695,
-0.17256289720535278,
-0.35258960723876953,
0.13054363429546356,
-0.16218122839927673,
0.38504424691200256,
0.4397391974925995,
-0.3353751599788666,
-0.036082781851291656,
-0.7868428826332092,
0.5842940807342529,
0.1433776468038559,
0.06628633290529251,
-0.3513745069503784,
0.27253949642181396,
0.20882898569107056,
-0.28693321347236633,
0.181051567196846,
0.06201311945915222,
-0.6882449984550476,
0.5960381627082825,
1.0939773321151733,
0.6569647192955017,
-0.47806698083877563,
0.2872619032859802,
0.1463838517665863,
0.14669565856456757,
-0.25773775577545166,
0.27753302454948425,
0.1438041478395462,
-0.8517913818359375,
-0.4482380449771881,
-0.5523598790168762,
-0.3435498774051666,
0.18334054946899414,
-0.49682897329330444,
0.6882624626159668,
-0.6086002588272095,
0.46723583340644836,
0.07480137795209885,
-0.04195931926369667,
-0.2321675717830658,
0.7926585674285889,
0.3483979403972626,
1.180152416229248,
-0.9470798373222351,
1.1945310831069946,
0.7492583394050598,
-0.43910959362983704,
-0.8900009989738464,
0.21105793118476868,
-0.20784281194210052,
-1.0949264764785767,
1.0984210968017578,
0.175461083650589,
-0.11911672353744507,
-0.3294689357280731,
-0.6636878848075867,
-0.9057692885398865,
0.8881900310516357,
0.24891327321529388,
-0.5605716109275818,
-0.4290788471698761,
0.6169179677963257,
0.45953962206840515,
-0.8354354500770569,
-0.26073360443115234,
0.4949447810649872,
-0.04056357219815254,
-0.13111382722854614,
-0.6486691832542419,
0.4233056604862213,
-0.37501952052116394,
0.016302090138196945,
-0.11178220063447952,
-1.0267621278762817,
1.1609904766082764,
0.17400473356246948,
-0.27624276280403137,
0.14519102871418,
0.9871206879615784,
0.3861680328845978,
0.4058595597743988,
0.6246448755264282,
0.3906453251838684,
0.5729711055755615,
0.32739388942718506,
0.7498857378959656,
-0.4785546362400055,
0.3303248882293701,
1.1657336950302124,
-0.6036649346351624,
0.7527815699577332,
0.4071722626686096,
-0.17404873669147491,
0.8245885968208313,
0.6796472668647766,
-0.13045689463615417,
0.6109392642974854,
0.31283289194107056,
-0.08472999930381775,
-0.4667098820209503,
0.07578445971012115,
-0.3779538869857788,
0.44175228476524353,
0.40925347805023193,
-0.4749360680580139,
-0.3892674148082733,
-0.04443371295928955,
-0.04945094883441925,
0.2839733064174652,
-0.3329485356807709,
0.5252030491828918,
0.3287125527858734,
-0.5146026611328125,
0.36599624156951904,
0.24765199422836304,
0.5527130961418152,
-0.9031208157539368,
-0.08038642257452011,
-0.2348395735025406,
0.22860753536224365,
-0.2644714117050171,
-0.6548452377319336,
0.26187020540237427,
0.03569584712386131,
-0.02579009346663952,
-0.39575037360191345,
0.8071684837341309,
-0.5591368675231934,
-0.4595774710178375,
0.45831790566444397,
0.6219627857208252,
0.047164395451545715,
0.16347090899944305,
-0.6263102889060974,
-0.13573530316352844,
0.04315575957298279,
-0.33313673734664917,
0.4647253155708313,
1.1039927005767822,
-0.01796930655837059,
0.6251364350318909,
0.5894112586975098,
0.19746434688568115,
0.12440328299999237,
0.17960745096206665,
1.1013531684875488,
-1.2199063301086426,
-0.9268264174461365,
-0.8755487203598022,
0.24221082031726837,
-0.10990370810031891,
-0.33741554617881775,
1.1362327337265015,
0.6371570229530334,
1.0575443506240845,
-0.006727189756929874,
0.9795404076576233,
0.20842722058296204,
0.6727694869041443,
-0.6063753962516785,
0.35123980045318604,
-0.6070842146873474,
0.34909337759017944,
-0.14496365189552307,
-0.6365293264389038,
-0.5029685497283936,
0.6776188611984253,
-0.3640316128730774,
-0.08905568718910217,
0.8956374526023865,
0.4780820906162262,
-0.09516827017068863,
0.3878472149372101,
0.40855881571769714,
0.029193289577960968,
0.3115682005882263,
0.3821165859699249,
1.1359812021255493,
-0.2426808774471283,
0.37127453088760376,
-0.16219277679920197,
-0.011595855467021465,
-0.1558104157447815,
-0.7387170791625977,
-1.3334373235702515,
-0.39359092712402344,
-0.16308815777301788,
-0.36131390929222107,
0.38653406500816345,
0.9949537515640259,
0.6051462888717651,
-0.8882533311843872,
-0.5248969197273254,
-0.1780548095703125,
-0.24834610521793365,
-0.17056027054786682,
-0.2902188003063202,
0.5957741737365723,
-0.9445439577102661,
-0.5635942220687866,
0.7319700717926025,
0.18823586404323578,
0.08686051517724991,
-0.17012666165828705,
0.13355675339698792,
-0.424235075712204,
0.21793416142463684,
0.9423398971557617,
0.01592116244137287,
-0.5529686808586121,
-0.3604823350906372,
0.05310114100575447,
-0.46400585770606995,
0.1522357016801834,
1.3339992761611938,
-0.40781837701797485,
-0.18087933957576752,
0.27688708901405334,
0.7345880270004272,
0.11750935763120651,
0.11435455083847046,
0.6327123045921326,
-0.8027834892272949,
0.24363508820533752,
-0.015052209608256817,
0.6270408034324646,
0.39398643374443054,
-0.7176381945610046,
0.5238783359527588,
0.6305750012397766,
-0.30187520384788513,
-0.8207286596298218,
0.18985873460769653,
-1.0078920125961304,
-0.8779418468475342,
1.4501668214797974,
-0.4952348470687866,
-0.3394632637500763,
-0.14256006479263306,
-0.1148478090763092,
0.2613191306591034,
-0.18854545056819916,
0.6083254218101501,
0.6205658912658691,
-0.1405888944864273,
-0.017028406262397766,
-0.12744247913360596,
0.5636608004570007,
0.6881911158561707,
-0.8553861975669861,
0.3073270916938782,
0.3329501152038574,
0.5369230508804321,
-0.06198090687394142,
0.741283655166626,
-0.01645415648818016,
0.12693390250205994,
0.012825360521674156,
-0.03908809646964073,
0.14737476408481598,
-0.6337383389472961,
-0.37090858817100525,
0.3869868218898773,
-0.32362326979637146,
-0.015091825276613235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16288v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16288v1
|
PerLTQA: A Personal Long-Term Memory Dataset for Memory Classification, Retrieval, and Synthesis in Question Answering
| 2024-02-26T04:09:53 | 2024-02-26T04:09:53 |
Yiming Du, Hongru Wang, Zhengyi Zhao, Bin Liang, Baojun Wang, Wanjun Zhong, Zezhong Wang, Kam-Fai Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Long-term memory plays a critical role in personal interaction, considering
long-term memory can better leverage world knowledge, historical information,
and preferences in dialogues. Our research introduces PerLTQA, an innovative QA
dataset that combines semantic and episodic memories, including world
knowledge, profiles, social relationships, events, and dialogues. This dataset
is collected to investigate the use of personalized memories, focusing on
social interactions and events in the QA task. PerLTQA features two types of
memory and a comprehensive benchmark of 8,593 questions for 30 characters,
facilitating the exploration and application of personalized memories in Large
Language Models (LLMs). Based on PerLTQA, we propose a novel framework for
memory integration and generation, consisting of three main components: Memory
Classification, Memory Retrieval, and Memory Synthesis. We evaluate this
framework using five LLMs and three retrievers. Experimental results
demonstrate that BERT-based classification models significantly outperform LLMs
such as ChatGLM3 and ChatGPT in the memory classification task. Furthermore,
our study highlights the importance of effective memory integration in the QA
task.
|
[
-0.5471084713935852,
-0.9252172112464905,
0.7836231589317322,
0.1897742599248886,
0.11958449333906174,
0.15459473431110382,
-0.1392592340707779,
-0.17137281596660614,
0.09291702508926392,
0.6168233156204224,
-0.4325898289680481,
-0.6037318110466003,
0.04760124161839485,
-0.24544528126716614,
-0.5515934824943542,
0.7269524931907654,
-0.07665608078241348,
-0.17848320305347443,
-0.10511381179094315,
-0.3775227665901184,
-0.5591136813163757,
-1.2297649383544922,
-0.6605370044708252,
-0.04861888289451599,
0.8499755263328552,
0.38925036787986755,
0.38690948486328125,
0.01599368080496788,
0.10314290970563889,
0.21872468292713165,
-0.08898136019706726,
0.22465966641902924,
-0.6951388716697693,
0.1776687651872635,
-0.1403488665819168,
-0.45579585433006287,
-0.4222942590713501,
-0.23875634372234344,
0.652474582195282,
0.3498137593269348,
-0.09871364384889603,
0.3873690068721771,
-0.10385826975107193,
0.3657962381839752,
-0.6437538266181946,
-0.1631750762462616,
-0.55528724193573,
0.241484135389328,
-0.17360298335552216,
-0.11564519256353378,
-0.23983846604824066,
-0.49019086360931396,
0.2974783182144165,
-0.31448522210121155,
-0.02748981863260269,
-0.05926124006509781,
0.7146739959716797,
0.09196911007165909,
-0.44835349917411804,
-0.19973124563694,
-0.9707441329956055,
0.8537561893463135,
-0.654224157333374,
0.4037373960018158,
0.3975062668323517,
0.5890427827835083,
-0.27521812915802,
-0.842767596244812,
-0.7093033790588379,
0.06688234210014343,
0.2947019934654236,
0.08338478952646255,
-0.024846568703651428,
-0.013122879900038242,
0.05824282392859459,
0.12411152571439743,
-0.4201858937740326,
-0.18463827669620514,
-0.2964564859867096,
-0.14595654606819153,
0.48833152651786804,
0.496733158826828,
0.3259400427341461,
0.1142365112900734,
-0.38887858390808105,
0.16050580143928528,
-0.6714743375778198,
0.17219038307666779,
0.27549850940704346,
-0.04955299571156502,
0.3435913920402527,
0.34156954288482666,
-0.36966538429260254,
0.31464773416519165,
0.016496628522872925,
-0.1298082023859024,
0.1376258134841919,
-0.34622475504875183,
-0.07044130563735962,
-0.012193356640636921,
0.6452672481536865,
0.11871184408664703,
0.277606725692749,
-0.3596498370170593,
-0.028315920382738113,
-0.34555965662002563,
0.1595923751592636,
-0.5841605067253113,
-0.22618404030799866,
0.20075145363807678,
-0.3225005269050598,
-0.08688231557607651,
-0.17465396225452423,
-0.5142145752906799,
-0.07888202369213104,
0.06779701262712479,
0.5742505192756653,
-0.4361029267311096,
0.11349163949489594,
0.1786087304353714,
-0.020581020042300224,
0.32782304286956787,
0.39436450600624084,
-0.6883237361907959,
0.5761973261833191,
0.31843793392181396,
0.2059997171163559,
-0.3614731729030609,
-0.35365670919418335,
-0.46241965889930725,
0.39617061614990234,
-0.1123443990945816,
0.8576255440711975,
-0.5517850518226624,
-0.3483647108078003,
0.1306452602148056,
-0.05952470004558563,
0.20471562445163727,
-0.8528464436531067,
0.3251372277736664,
-0.8647063374519348,
0.4835423529148102,
-0.4776845872402191,
-0.5781335234642029,
-0.42035195231437683,
0.20373140275478363,
-0.5426127910614014,
1.042047142982483,
0.32205069065093994,
-0.5355457663536072,
0.014285529963672161,
-0.41855454444885254,
-0.08027706295251846,
0.2484462708234787,
-0.29029712080955505,
-0.16792596876621246,
-0.06352783739566803,
0.11952811479568481,
0.5174702405929565,
-0.3724643290042877,
0.296929270029068,
-0.13162946701049805,
-0.6063475608825684,
0.7662326693534851,
-0.2206287831068039,
0.345553457736969,
0.2114771604537964,
0.07050588726997375,
-0.11679299920797348,
-0.5394470691680908,
0.07238428294658661,
0.0692693293094635,
-0.8095150589942932,
-0.2967202067375183,
-0.04950755462050438,
0.06506392359733582,
0.20473109185695648,
0.6794114708900452,
-0.7416167855262756,
-0.13026633858680725,
-0.15665757656097412,
0.6001320481300354,
0.7024213671684265,
0.41603994369506836,
0.27434322237968445,
-0.3896264433860779,
0.335624635219574,
0.3017275035381317,
0.17048245668411255,
-0.36457282304763794,
-0.3955649435520172,
-0.7441688776016235,
0.1425648182630539,
0.31703847646713257,
0.648750364780426,
-0.4431213140487671,
0.31075143814086914,
-0.04904404282569885,
0.05612662807106972,
-0.1926070749759674,
0.2779409885406494,
0.3910067677497864,
0.4827856123447418,
0.4758323132991791,
-0.3450396955013275,
-0.526681125164032,
-1.0027296543121338,
-0.0410408154129982,
-0.28461429476737976,
-0.2265361100435257,
0.6961730122566223,
0.18818412721157074,
-0.291678786277771,
1.0215915441513062,
-0.5430746078491211,
-0.081544890999794,
-0.0274246446788311,
-0.1860591322183609,
0.06309472769498825,
0.22945396602153778,
0.2574566900730133,
-0.9014298915863037,
-0.2931492030620575,
-0.3375646471977234,
-0.5740229487419128,
0.21503214538097382,
-0.28552916646003723,
-0.4171336889266968,
-0.008539083413779736,
0.18564008176326752,
-0.34099727869033813,
0.22745081782341003,
0.2254122942686081,
-0.5714487433433533,
0.5387057662010193,
-0.032761767506599426,
0.21715214848518372,
-1.0597174167633057,
-0.17060041427612305,
-0.3391113877296448,
-0.2765079140663147,
-0.5831429958343506,
-0.23001624643802643,
0.04488411918282509,
0.03075423836708069,
-0.6290727257728577,
0.9834848046302795,
-0.08045992255210876,
0.014941176399588585,
0.13755005598068237,
-0.04336711764335632,
-0.11228295415639877,
0.7325534820556641,
-0.2261984795331955,
0.759552001953125,
0.06953617185354233,
-0.640343427658081,
0.37325456738471985,
0.6681029796600342,
-0.2854410707950592,
0.3731527030467987,
-0.4338681697845459,
0.6030296087265015,
-0.0016305268509313464,
0.05914413928985596,
-1.1952489614486694,
-0.1310957968235016,
-0.017240310087800026,
-0.49539047479629517,
-0.027804823592305183,
0.29415157437324524,
-0.6238464117050171,
-0.1398710161447525,
-0.2502764165401459,
0.49114659428596497,
0.8831263184547424,
-0.6571420431137085,
0.8662264943122864,
0.39545848965644836,
-0.38748717308044434,
-0.3036651611328125,
-0.5996859669685364,
0.12486859411001205,
-0.39605653285980225,
-0.5877254605293274,
0.4842417240142822,
-0.26666155457496643,
-0.03753579407930374,
0.16905829310417175,
-0.046912048012018204,
-0.3803415894508362,
-0.1381770521402359,
0.2112911194562912,
0.09772507846355438,
-0.37600669264793396,
0.44096195697784424,
0.1783234179019928,
0.1765488237142563,
-0.17361986637115479,
-0.03598200902342796,
0.7679396867752075,
-0.007084334269165993,
-0.14305484294891357,
-0.3701600432395935,
0.4444228410720825,
0.4413197934627533,
-0.12234710901975632,
0.6309153437614441,
0.519467830657959,
-0.30695822834968567,
-0.11104247719049454,
-1.1749773025512695,
-0.12213803082704544,
-0.5090385675430298,
0.27455106377601624,
-0.6221906542778015,
-1.2717070579528809,
0.8165876269340515,
-0.12934067845344543,
0.07007955759763718,
0.017065059393644333,
0.5431194305419922,
-0.616439163684845,
0.8340561985969543,
0.2807229459285736,
-0.2912575900554657,
0.4777836501598358,
-0.022609293460845947,
0.0005311646964401007,
-1.2216770648956299,
-0.054749760776758194,
0.046082090586423874,
-0.46652716398239136,
-0.17573553323745728,
-0.5282378196716309,
0.36483362317085266,
0.00790325179696083,
-0.894451379776001,
-0.06225084140896797,
-0.2521229088306427,
0.3197581470012665,
0.6307913661003113,
0.20603932440280914,
0.28095293045043945,
0.0048013352788984776,
0.1043931394815445,
0.04284031316637993,
-0.6001930832862854,
-0.6078717708587646,
1.1888271570205688,
0.5048013925552368,
0.7360706329345703,
0.11298727244138718,
0.993622899055481,
0.1774202585220337,
-0.09166840463876724,
-0.4040376543998718,
0.8437018394470215,
-0.26753783226013184,
-0.5392844080924988,
-0.42227494716644287,
-0.2744385600090027,
-0.953930675983429,
-0.14382603764533997,
-0.09999170899391174,
-0.9266252517700195,
0.06561946868896484,
0.017947284504771233,
-0.7779174447059631,
0.06650662422180176,
-0.6105368137359619,
0.6778503060340881,
-0.3982190787792206,
-0.25719064474105835,
-0.25657713413238525,
-0.44930264353752136,
0.3656424283981323,
-0.11748581379652023,
-0.28613999485969543,
-0.1984158456325531,
-0.1421424001455307,
0.9569529294967651,
0.0651778131723404,
0.7072381377220154,
-0.14479641616344452,
0.3678922951221466,
0.4653016924858093,
0.05105571448802948,
0.3364025354385376,
0.1286230832338333,
0.1527683287858963,
-0.10217441618442535,
0.5077376961708069,
-0.42736342549324036,
-0.5820327401161194,
0.7652745842933655,
-0.8549529910087585,
-0.6666730642318726,
-0.01712166704237461,
-0.6041075587272644,
-0.5541244149208069,
-0.17675724625587463,
-0.20544812083244324,
0.3076033294200897,
-0.4568653404712677,
0.2521956264972687,
1.079988956451416,
-0.7761209607124329,
0.16791687905788422,
0.536173939704895,
-0.253423810005188,
-0.4313015341758728,
0.9130743741989136,
0.1972639560699463,
-0.0002606862981338054,
0.4449005424976349,
0.1300627738237381,
-0.2115064263343811,
-0.5168145298957825,
-0.13410545885562897,
0.4052291512489319,
-0.7006353735923767,
-0.06591396033763885,
-0.8128622174263,
-0.359104186296463,
-0.20548075437545776,
-0.08888331800699234,
-0.21906812489032745,
-0.37325143814086914,
-0.19129320979118347,
-0.02149260602891445,
0.3118087351322174,
0.5754056572914124,
0.5417097806930542,
0.08972491323947906,
-1.0697563886642456,
0.3730897307395935,
0.8035382628440857,
0.04932599142193794,
0.06721373647451401,
-0.37588706612586975,
-0.12621986865997314,
-0.25691312551498413,
-0.23932591080665588,
-1.028424620628357,
0.40258121490478516,
0.10448876768350601,
0.7003847360610962,
0.11892801523208618,
-0.11464037746191025,
0.6261075139045715,
-0.5216194987297058,
0.8380429148674011,
0.02545228973031044,
-0.7297517657279968,
0.29049763083457947,
-0.3172706663608551,
0.6608206033706665,
0.5221515893936157,
0.347423791885376,
-0.7412264943122864,
-0.2902280390262604,
-0.6009836196899414,
-0.9990511536598206,
0.27781981229782104,
0.10619997978210449,
0.3183060586452484,
-0.0202981848269701,
0.7968341112136841,
-0.016619665548205376,
0.1649475395679474,
-0.19735923409461975,
-0.03701026737689972,
0.2213270515203476,
-0.4424089193344116,
0.06781795620918274,
-0.7309596538543701,
-0.09143554419279099,
-0.16780982911586761,
0.365134596824646,
-0.08252529799938202,
0.642117977142334,
0.17279499769210815,
0.047289080917835236,
0.3050708472728729,
0.35610321164131165,
0.14920775592327118,
0.6014018654823303,
-0.2544560432434082,
-0.03223221376538277,
0.8112202882766724,
-0.34843915700912476,
0.1797208935022354,
-0.2775232493877411,
-0.19596825540065765,
-0.2525278627872467,
-0.07849110662937164,
0.3514840304851532,
0.30114829540252686,
-1.0014339685440063,
0.1953420788049698,
-0.4254492521286011,
-0.06854210793972015,
-0.9043105244636536,
0.15261958539485931,
0.5662785172462463,
0.5576297044754028,
0.4075077176094055,
-0.6943008303642273,
0.26985928416252136,
-0.7311968803405762,
0.3331732451915741,
0.2374660223722458,
-0.23811458051204681,
-0.433925986289978,
0.5634720325469971,
0.09870075434446335,
-0.07918326556682587,
0.8843444585800171,
-0.08581841737031937,
-0.46813660860061646,
0.4650189280509949,
0.42656612396240234,
0.8105090260505676,
-0.31686925888061523,
0.05825554206967354,
0.4428097605705261,
-0.3693791925907135,
0.0698939859867096,
0.7464457750320435,
-0.24267183244228363,
-1.034454107284546,
-0.22736406326293945,
-0.9429590702056885,
-0.4243010878562927,
0.2700033187866211,
-0.500878632068634,
-0.04242715984582901,
-0.5758921504020691,
-0.2914721369743347,
-0.2487558275461197,
0.1046777218580246,
-0.8128484487533569,
0.2897658348083496,
0.40163668990135193,
0.7787050008773804,
-0.5171471834182739,
1.1831003427505493,
0.6781545281410217,
-0.27271348237991333,
-0.7857436537742615,
-0.12426508218050003,
-0.244955375790596,
-0.48303136229515076,
0.9920578598976135,
-0.30056458711624146,
0.028221333399415016,
-0.07115624099969864,
-0.33606570959091187,
-0.9765189290046692,
1.338410496711731,
0.02816036157310009,
-0.47858506441116333,
-0.3917487859725952,
0.05295354872941971,
0.5223258137702942,
-0.6608765125274658,
-0.015389186330139637,
0.743493914604187,
0.3121330738067627,
0.3370071351528168,
-0.7449723482131958,
0.14086014032363892,
-0.03760022670030594,
0.23950523138046265,
0.05874126777052879,
-0.929844856262207,
0.8403656482696533,
0.0007769902003929019,
-0.33279693126678467,
0.23673196136951447,
0.7675343155860901,
0.34354981780052185,
0.168157160282135,
0.2575993537902832,
0.4276849627494812,
0.7685313820838928,
0.086626335978508,
0.7259817719459534,
-0.19647955894470215,
-0.11975134164094925,
1.476503610610962,
-0.3078362047672272,
1.0861754417419434,
0.3721013367176056,
-0.22944629192352295,
0.6194552183151245,
0.5252540707588196,
0.3133590817451477,
0.482063889503479,
0.1815079003572464,
-0.47654613852500916,
-0.2459731101989746,
0.12813034653663635,
-0.14770852029323578,
0.27555036544799805,
0.5454735159873962,
-0.28959229588508606,
-0.000930363719817251,
0.010084860026836395,
-0.2085738331079483,
-0.13904006779193878,
-0.07995884865522385,
0.9901384711265564,
0.09951459616422653,
-0.41938549280166626,
0.49470093846321106,
-0.25532960891723633,
0.6438378691673279,
-0.4612458050251007,
-0.12764811515808105,
-0.3198932409286499,
0.28467971086502075,
-0.15100137889385223,
-0.9127161502838135,
0.1896422952413559,
-0.15669605135917664,
-0.05507078766822815,
-0.10671427845954895,
0.7753275036811829,
-0.5472039580345154,
-0.025840600952506065,
0.21766652166843414,
0.6324809193611145,
0.24509760737419128,
-0.17369124293327332,
-0.5517157316207886,
-0.0414370521903038,
0.06614752858877182,
-0.4493095874786377,
0.7358791828155518,
0.397212415933609,
-0.19047334790229797,
0.7087953090667725,
0.44788146018981934,
-0.14174070954322815,
0.220079243183136,
-0.12273278087377548,
1.0784627199172974,
-1.1506608724594116,
-0.3485782742500305,
-0.5606508255004883,
0.3717089891433716,
0.10497075319290161,
-0.4274749755859375,
0.7228808403015137,
0.6579157114028931,
0.6918161511421204,
-0.019387373700737953,
0.9020342826843262,
0.24970920383930206,
0.7962727546691895,
-0.41590163111686707,
0.5841389298439026,
-0.29443299770355225,
0.10245965421199799,
0.21111860871315002,
-0.7438796758651733,
0.06403980404138565,
0.3504709303379059,
-0.49745824933052063,
-0.239206001162529,
0.519072413444519,
0.68998122215271,
0.11074279993772507,
-0.07922615110874176,
0.5702186822891235,
0.2592703700065613,
0.3879581689834595,
1.1691625118255615,
1.2151124477386475,
-0.38150671124458313,
0.5677215456962585,
-0.016986753791570663,
0.0763549953699112,
-0.13792243599891663,
-0.23458155989646912,
-0.9618768095970154,
-0.9507168531417847,
-0.17237606644630432,
-0.24365009367465973,
0.2834247946739197,
0.9424533247947693,
0.5694257020950317,
-0.790128231048584,
-0.31422096490859985,
0.34408265352249146,
-0.04460463300347328,
0.19147637486457825,
-0.23132547736167908,
0.2109738290309906,
-0.3671971261501312,
-0.5695788860321045,
0.36246880888938904,
0.44064727425575256,
0.0798780769109726,
-0.483310729265213,
-0.12157298624515533,
-0.22250151634216309,
0.3957348167896271,
0.6665055751800537,
0.513534665107727,
-0.638326108455658,
-0.31290775537490845,
0.20560449361801147,
-0.12568941712379456,
0.2416498064994812,
0.5897892713546753,
-1.140568733215332,
0.4130471348762512,
0.7209939956665039,
0.7442839741706848,
0.9410498142242432,
0.05134614184498787,
0.7271412014961243,
-0.3567783534526825,
-0.1325456202030182,
0.6254262924194336,
0.12913984060287476,
0.15913273394107819,
-0.5645534992218018,
0.36035972833633423,
-0.34777963161468506,
-0.7481399774551392,
-0.6456369161605835,
0.28785574436187744,
-0.9321471452713013,
-0.35692301392555237,
1.1354402303695679,
-0.367199569940567,
-0.46222391724586487,
-0.40868711471557617,
-0.32397714257240295,
-0.20293639600276947,
-0.5232942700386047,
0.8343712687492371,
0.8268148899078369,
-0.5701581239700317,
-0.28966352343559265,
-0.68784499168396,
0.443185418844223,
0.31292349100112915,
-0.643561065196991,
-0.3634583353996277,
0.5050395727157593,
0.49318182468414307,
0.10584650933742523,
0.9218266010284424,
-0.2507580816745758,
0.4683918058872223,
-0.2914900481700897,
0.10418695211410522,
0.10432616621255875,
-0.23532867431640625,
-0.08657370507717133,
0.44982534646987915,
0.19370539486408234,
-0.08173459768295288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16278v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16278v3
|
A Self-matching Training Method with Annotation Embedding Models for Ontology Subsumption Prediction
| 2024-02-26T03:46:01 | 2024-03-10T10:04:41 |
Yukihiro Shiraishi, Ken Kaneiwa
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recently, ontology embeddings representing entities in a low-dimensional
space have been proposed for ontology completion. However, the ontology
embeddings for concept subsumption prediction do not address the difficulties
of similar and isolated entities and fail to extract the global information of
annotation axioms from an ontology. In this paper, we propose a self-matching
training method for the two ontology embedding models: Inverted-index Matrix
Embedding (InME) and Co-occurrence Matrix Embedding (CoME). The two embeddings
capture the global and local information in annotation axioms by means of the
occurring locations of each word in a set of axioms and the co-occurrences of
words in each axiom. The self-matching training method increases the robustness
of the concept subsumption prediction when predicted superclasses are similar
to subclasses and are isolated to other entities in an ontology. Our evaluation
experiments show that the self-matching training method with InME outperforms
the existing ontology embeddings for the GO and FoodOn ontologies and that the
method with the concatenation of CoME and OWL2Vec* outperforms them for the
HeLiS ontology.
|
[
-0.2654135823249817,
-0.08730150759220123,
0.47134995460510254,
-0.22453661262989044,
-0.3262001872062683,
0.0761270523071289,
0.3595065772533417,
-0.5459780693054199,
0.5976859331130981,
0.7157328128814697,
-0.7091188430786133,
-0.4064768850803375,
-0.3206349313259125,
0.09118946641683578,
-0.17505015432834625,
0.5002683997154236,
-0.027405323460698128,
0.17057576775550842,
-0.634526252746582,
-0.21142974495887756,
-0.6250081062316895,
-0.5956614017486572,
-0.08880985528230667,
-0.40005141496658325,
-0.000504923053085804,
0.4735090136528015,
0.40408918261528015,
0.8751101493835449,
0.6460175514221191,
0.19208811223506927,
0.41055527329444885,
0.13385917246341705,
-0.2731046974658966,
0.029031381011009216,
-0.43483757972717285,
-0.39276444911956787,
-0.23932664096355438,
0.3430061936378479,
0.26683828234672546,
0.332088440656662,
-0.2801355719566345,
0.1342170089483261,
0.149129256606102,
-0.09516685456037521,
-0.8463069200515747,
0.14433853328227997,
-0.7600260376930237,
0.7241156697273254,
0.062463223934173584,
-0.3564222455024719,
-0.19758503139019012,
0.0565301887691021,
0.21807609498500824,
-0.9086599946022034,
0.00710969278588891,
0.5030768513679504,
0.7718899846076965,
0.42513754963874817,
-0.01768377609550953,
-0.3595392107963562,
-0.08329106122255325,
0.8394393920898438,
-0.7655665278434753,
0.44859206676483154,
0.6387960910797119,
0.14850680530071259,
-0.1408921629190445,
-0.6384950280189514,
-0.8138996362686157,
-0.0838414803147316,
-0.39829427003860474,
0.32409536838531494,
0.1643512099981308,
-0.1509951651096344,
0.001443364075385034,
0.271481454372406,
-0.35125449299812317,
0.1608203947544098,
0.10656633973121643,
-0.14608949422836304,
0.312894731760025,
0.16221550107002258,
0.2957157790660858,
-0.2774238586425781,
-1.1245723962783813,
-0.11749768257141113,
-0.7895896434783936,
-0.510789692401886,
-0.001148753333836794,
0.4979666769504547,
-0.06735081970691681,
0.48650193214416504,
0.029330026358366013,
0.2736339569091797,
-0.07930109649896622,
-0.18852859735488892,
0.4219187796115875,
-0.6314677000045776,
-0.22087830305099487,
0.3543974757194519,
0.5408220291137695,
0.3028382658958435,
0.21756982803344727,
-0.3162611126899719,
0.11768149584531784,
0.029376421123743057,
0.20772522687911987,
-0.47773200273513794,
-0.11924175173044205,
-0.11741321533918381,
-0.23387004435062408,
-0.09088744223117828,
-0.0769944116473198,
-0.40120482444763184,
-0.2304859608411789,
-0.1853625476360321,
0.943718433380127,
-0.31571024656295776,
-0.13564728200435638,
-0.13992148637771606,
-0.12249298393726349,
0.26316019892692566,
0.13317207992076874,
-1.0378153324127197,
0.41575905680656433,
0.7469947338104248,
0.8671095371246338,
0.09793303906917572,
-0.4713432192802429,
-0.24063707888126373,
0.5007667541503906,
-0.27788978815078735,
0.9631388783454895,
-0.6716995239257812,
-0.06235764920711517,
-0.07912735641002655,
-0.29340988397598267,
-0.14741426706314087,
-0.44787561893463135,
0.356507807970047,
-0.4281167984008789,
-0.023890124633908272,
-0.25094547867774963,
-1.080810308456421,
-0.3461618721485138,
0.4378223419189453,
-0.18870185315608978,
1.003019094467163,
0.1615806668996811,
-1.0334069728851318,
0.7199325561523438,
-0.5273149609565735,
-0.09898114204406738,
0.33339011669158936,
-0.39958906173706055,
-0.452679306268692,
-0.39219024777412415,
0.13430115580558777,
0.7377800941467285,
-0.27328309416770935,
-0.4629063308238983,
-0.7361558675765991,
-0.2186248004436493,
0.04308203607797623,
0.3772103190422058,
0.3767091929912567,
-0.03957730159163475,
-0.20500709116458893,
-0.34381598234176636,
-0.5237142443656921,
0.17195072770118713,
0.13542582094669342,
0.09909874200820923,
-0.8504941463470459,
-0.00005363484888221137,
-0.3126457929611206,
0.48715803027153015,
0.18275086581707,
-0.7376409769058228,
0.4256398677825928,
-0.502439558506012,
0.5302926898002625,
0.7145686745643616,
0.1100223958492279,
0.3379557132720947,
-0.08082611858844757,
0.23078931868076324,
0.21386107802391052,
0.08281952142715454,
-0.09611335396766663,
-0.3766250014305115,
-0.5234900116920471,
-0.31770020723342896,
0.5317279696464539,
0.5259692072868347,
-0.404958039522171,
0.7792220115661621,
-0.2055187076330185,
-0.42544397711753845,
-0.6412014961242676,
0.12636607885360718,
0.5322504043579102,
0.5788705348968506,
0.7589667439460754,
-0.47835466265678406,
-0.8935744762420654,
-0.6778548955917358,
-0.142316997051239,
0.06033611670136452,
0.2479824721813202,
0.264416366815567,
0.89663165807724,
-0.26436367630958557,
0.9950027465820312,
-0.48212045431137085,
-1.0060908794403076,
0.10397102683782578,
-0.09285392612218857,
-0.20292000472545624,
0.6189285516738892,
0.44807663559913635,
-0.42205941677093506,
-0.542594313621521,
-0.20042291283607483,
-0.9118772745132446,
0.3710457980632782,
0.31751736998558044,
-0.20052982866764069,
-0.10379552096128464,
0.6720491051673889,
-0.11442714929580688,
0.5932601690292358,
0.30844390392303467,
-0.2948276400566101,
-0.2572339177131653,
-0.31792691349983215,
-0.1374126672744751,
-1.3558293581008911,
-0.5023441910743713,
-0.41735583543777466,
-0.39727282524108887,
-0.16322572529315948,
0.19789113104343414,
0.1704951375722885,
0.29398488998413086,
-0.41566675901412964,
0.471756249666214,
-0.46420636773109436,
-0.3264937698841095,
-0.28666335344314575,
0.4139549136161804,
-0.0303706843405962,
0.21706326305866241,
0.02224111370742321,
0.6436575055122375,
0.6696656942367554,
-0.5635866522789001,
0.1239008903503418,
0.7179733514785767,
-0.5545659065246582,
0.5028426647186279,
-0.27154219150543213,
0.37085917592048645,
0.051129814237356186,
0.3632090091705322,
-1.024797797203064,
-0.008079972118139267,
0.4747718572616577,
-0.15968719124794006,
0.20008090138435364,
-0.26161450147628784,
-0.36734890937805176,
-0.21821163594722748,
-0.2192188948392868,
0.3005436062812805,
0.30480095744132996,
-0.8912385106086731,
0.8312995433807373,
0.39651936292648315,
0.3554569482803345,
-0.8760654926300049,
-0.9077489972114563,
0.10035097599029541,
-0.09744758158922195,
-0.2628099322319031,
0.4737696945667267,
0.022405194118618965,
0.31513282656669617,
0.2604126036167145,
0.08414119482040405,
0.4338856637477875,
0.29193490743637085,
0.45373180508613586,
-0.03692082688212395,
-0.0009545601205900311,
0.1869870275259018,
0.11485686898231506,
-0.49960920214653015,
-0.20464900135993958,
-0.6353724002838135,
0.4999978244304657,
0.3174864649772644,
-0.481263130903244,
-0.2562492787837982,
0.39350542426109314,
-0.2576500475406647,
-0.12777647376060486,
0.6340881586074829,
0.45036575198173523,
-0.6416903138160706,
-0.1849917620420456,
-0.43569836020469666,
-0.23506402969360352,
-0.41368770599365234,
0.29769882559776306,
-0.5951951742172241,
-0.4627011716365814,
0.24148902297019958,
0.08113788813352585,
0.12251520901918411,
0.5552620887756348,
0.43107253313064575,
-0.18056297302246094,
0.791226327419281,
0.6508734226226807,
0.1847088634967804,
0.37781113386154175,
-0.5745733380317688,
-0.06014816462993622,
-1.1040878295898438,
-0.3260631859302521,
-0.4866139590740204,
-0.16250115633010864,
-0.4173591136932373,
-0.3889583647251129,
-0.020957844331860542,
-0.2066173553466797,
-0.1318540722131729,
0.5712730288505554,
-0.4286043345928192,
0.34046289324760437,
0.6894460916519165,
-0.08561057597398758,
0.22931928932666779,
0.19768497347831726,
-0.6071279048919678,
-0.2679612338542938,
-0.7212293148040771,
-0.20591917634010315,
1.139634132385254,
0.18049649894237518,
0.8810231685638428,
0.07138688862323761,
0.9418017864227295,
0.4094952344894409,
0.5062282681465149,
-0.5493412613868713,
0.33477553725242615,
-0.44894394278526306,
-0.5978285670280457,
-0.030395731329917908,
-0.34056684374809265,
-0.6420549750328064,
0.24309909343719482,
-0.6087149381637573,
-0.6524702906608582,
0.46065589785575867,
0.09908264875411987,
-0.422180712223053,
0.21486254036426544,
-0.5160214900970459,
0.7431704998016357,
0.05002019926905632,
0.15609297156333923,
-0.27798691391944885,
-0.5443929433822632,
-0.19768036901950836,
0.009857033379375935,
0.05433489382266998,
-0.4031515121459961,
-0.21341025829315186,
0.8694064617156982,
-0.38543233275413513,
0.8050423264503479,
-0.026594731956720352,
-0.03007255494594574,
0.22464078664779663,
-0.05491870641708374,
0.3098183870315552,
0.1178506463766098,
-0.011510048061609268,
0.5684018135070801,
0.10030962526798248,
-0.2847108542919159,
-0.6201277375221252,
0.469105988740921,
-0.9354718327522278,
-0.32230648398399353,
-0.6897852420806885,
-0.13299021124839783,
-0.09326313436031342,
0.15378639101982117,
0.7228249907493591,
0.21708475053310394,
0.039826035499572754,
-0.09722448140382767,
0.47602036595344543,
0.5446200966835022,
0.37098315358161926,
0.5262615084648132,
-0.104171983897686,
-0.7449067234992981,
0.7676762342453003,
0.6041590571403503,
0.15933190286159515,
0.6691880822181702,
0.33762413263320923,
-0.5681002140045166,
-0.11009600758552551,
-0.3878116309642792,
-0.04454325884580612,
-0.8729639053344727,
-0.5766257643699646,
-0.9092636108398438,
-0.3205418288707733,
-0.5483520030975342,
-0.11961193382740021,
-0.3642469048500061,
-0.26711922883987427,
-0.12140059471130371,
0.00304197589866817,
0.279314786195755,
0.6789398789405823,
-0.3586759567260742,
0.2334357649087906,
-0.6111677289009094,
0.1098640114068985,
0.6341556310653687,
0.19829459488391876,
0.156919926404953,
-0.8367370963096619,
-0.5129971504211426,
0.005594071000814438,
-0.22559958696365356,
-0.5988949537277222,
-0.01111243199557066,
0.507840096950531,
0.6243821978569031,
0.5758926272392273,
0.10202422738075256,
0.7411535978317261,
-0.3656904697418213,
0.2680651545524597,
0.13683079183101654,
-0.8984950184822083,
0.43297725915908813,
0.3008164167404175,
-0.3736892640590668,
0.5941200852394104,
0.5492551326751709,
-0.24858839809894562,
-0.09480337053537369,
-0.6052439212799072,
-0.604340136051178,
0.7190007567405701,
0.23737137019634247,
0.21339711546897888,
0.016152391210198402,
0.6823089718818665,
0.3020285665988922,
0.05765361711382866,
-0.6325005292892456,
-0.25603076815605164,
-0.44422197341918945,
-0.4505576193332672,
0.004056788515299559,
-0.27859485149383545,
-0.0889338031411171,
-0.028399748727679253,
0.8891639113426208,
-0.2344268262386322,
0.3808595538139343,
0.15552844107151031,
0.03506028279662132,
-0.18304897844791412,
-0.2037457972764969,
0.07600629329681396,
0.33466511964797974,
-0.34587666392326355,
0.20067159831523895,
0.4726695120334625,
-0.706453263759613,
0.2974050045013428,
0.056964319199323654,
-0.3153724670410156,
-0.32426947355270386,
0.5032416582107544,
0.583377480506897,
0.20581583678722382,
-0.21358658373355865,
0.5244958400726318,
-0.2177862524986267,
0.01775110326707363,
-0.6300919055938721,
0.36873719096183777,
-0.09525176882743835,
0.2883138656616211,
0.16938942670822144,
-0.206466943025589,
0.1820085495710373,
-0.6610023975372314,
0.03107980452477932,
0.5226898193359375,
-0.6377260684967041,
-0.03946077078580856,
0.4605560898780823,
-0.26674458384513855,
-0.19651490449905396,
0.5243292450904846,
-0.22667276859283447,
-0.6176100969314575,
0.29212260246276855,
0.9332184195518494,
0.9598269462585449,
-0.2743030786514282,
-0.08840568363666534,
0.43524718284606934,
0.31667089462280273,
-0.0633389875292778,
0.4670073986053467,
-0.08279743045568466,
-1.0127793550491333,
-0.27641141414642334,
-0.5707621574401855,
-0.5996241569519043,
-0.33910414576530457,
-0.5080335736274719,
0.26420363783836365,
-0.2825179398059845,
0.019495967775583267,
0.07961703836917877,
0.26593947410583496,
-0.5967297554016113,
0.29914718866348267,
0.01061347033828497,
0.7569462656974792,
-0.8290731906890869,
0.6796404719352722,
0.9368019104003906,
-0.5894753932952881,
-0.8490977883338928,
0.14614616334438324,
-0.47769734263420105,
-0.8744017481803894,
0.473829060792923,
0.26738470792770386,
-0.018739143386483192,
0.06711483746767044,
-0.5129812359809875,
-1.3093390464782715,
1.1577955484390259,
0.26440930366516113,
-0.3933880925178528,
0.10346655547618866,
0.02184935100376606,
0.14807341992855072,
-0.892710268497467,
0.3629412055015564,
0.23563186824321747,
0.2329905480146408,
0.1342933028936386,
-0.43283385038375854,
0.2600178122520447,
0.2553074359893799,
-0.02547581121325493,
0.0809173434972763,
-0.7293527126312256,
0.828822910785675,
-0.1427137702703476,
-0.13016317784786224,
0.05474945530295372,
0.9946841597557068,
-0.03222990036010742,
0.23210956156253815,
0.7832062840461731,
1.001354455947876,
0.46479177474975586,
0.18509691953659058,
0.44393613934516907,
-0.26829463243484497,
0.8420569896697998,
1.3407773971557617,
-0.38610726594924927,
1.0371180772781372,
0.11427000164985657,
-0.1877507120370865,
0.6413410305976868,
0.6109519004821777,
-0.1254386603832245,
0.879264771938324,
-0.09497717767953873,
0.27847978472709656,
-0.7415152788162231,
-0.20898760855197906,
-0.7678139209747314,
0.726594090461731,
0.6078689694404602,
-0.22368048131465912,
-0.31458809971809387,
0.1531536728143692,
-0.12737928330898285,
-0.09966223686933517,
-0.14960168302059174,
1.0117298364639282,
0.2585485875606537,
-0.44455575942993164,
0.34649595618247986,
-0.06300002336502075,
0.35459762811660767,
-0.42032530903816223,
-0.3223462402820587,
-0.24784933030605316,
0.3495514392852783,
-0.2005658745765686,
-0.6204005479812622,
0.11445401608943939,
-0.6808565258979797,
0.04857253283262253,
0.09029658883810043,
0.6468220949172974,
-0.2839595079421997,
-0.43312665820121765,
0.6694391369819641,
0.13284510374069214,
0.0897376537322998,
0.2033223956823349,
-0.7110766172409058,
-0.6228938102722168,
-0.4115789234638214,
0.14974266290664673,
0.3917829394340515,
0.31575027108192444,
0.12023507803678513,
0.5222228169441223,
0.44556960463523865,
-0.34934788942337036,
-0.08562672138214111,
-0.2022806853055954,
0.6831762790679932,
-0.6191232204437256,
-0.8401276469230652,
-0.9258458614349365,
-0.23036617040634155,
0.06813637167215347,
-0.3759041130542755,
0.6535238027572632,
0.44005465507507324,
0.8475326299667358,
0.16341789066791534,
0.5984290838241577,
0.06314968317747116,
0.7740763425827026,
-0.5734217166900635,
0.4171145558357239,
-0.8744229674339294,
-0.029228614643216133,
-0.23872646689414978,
-0.9695944786071777,
0.0016902473289519548,
0.9156535267829895,
-0.0930776298046112,
0.28172674775123596,
0.42582717537879944,
0.48962733149528503,
-0.3346809148788452,
0.02422129549086094,
0.31056198477745056,
0.3423042297363281,
-0.10834222286939621,
0.41140732169151306,
0.802621603012085,
-0.6475045680999756,
0.29888883233070374,
-0.37557628750801086,
-0.20501789450645447,
-0.6190064549446106,
-0.8298187851905823,
-0.9677941799163818,
-0.5263862013816833,
-0.38596081733703613,
-0.5400744080543518,
-0.03151771426200867,
1.1085925102233887,
0.7759071588516235,
-0.8121125102043152,
0.16325899958610535,
0.03723808377981186,
0.09079846739768982,
-0.452054888010025,
-0.060517292469739914,
0.587320864200592,
-0.14006106555461884,
-0.3204355537891388,
0.2848426401615143,
0.5253578424453735,
0.3292294144630432,
-0.6489717364311218,
0.1887885332107544,
-0.6725321412086487,
0.4193326532840729,
0.22399665415287018,
0.10370296239852905,
-0.5552930235862732,
-0.5648611783981323,
-0.10301212221384048,
-0.12154195457696915,
0.24714212119579315,
0.42463576793670654,
-0.8390865921974182,
0.49643710255622864,
0.20704399049282074,
0.4314185082912445,
0.462613046169281,
-0.0749380886554718,
0.03523898497223854,
-0.7641450762748718,
0.07044708728790283,
-0.11927785724401474,
0.48994123935699463,
0.28147539496421814,
-0.36131393909454346,
0.7980742454528809,
0.36925095319747925,
-0.23300078511238098,
-0.6739106178283691,
0.2754001021385193,
-0.654079794883728,
0.10998383164405823,
0.7288930416107178,
-0.5971388220787048,
-0.38808944821357727,
-0.5141928195953369,
0.17488396167755127,
0.3103611171245575,
0.02590876631438732,
0.7897540330886841,
0.3032820224761963,
0.08759205788373947,
0.28947800397872925,
-0.07660608738660812,
0.19624684751033783,
0.5229610204696655,
-0.5721283555030823,
-0.28349563479423523,
-0.3169158399105072,
0.39409396052360535,
0.6355425119400024,
0.5368183255195618,
0.28708720207214355,
0.012715484015643597,
0.2387986034154892,
0.39187607169151306,
-0.16799671947956085,
-0.19040000438690186,
0.2737651467323303,
0.000597081147134304,
-0.16601452231407166,
-0.47338443994522095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16261v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16261v2
|
UniRetriever: Multi-task Candidates Selection for Various Context-Adaptive Conversational Retrieval
| 2024-02-26T02:48:43 | 2024-02-28T06:43:48 |
Hongru Wang, Boyang Xue, Baohang Zhou, Rui Wang, Fei Mi, Weichao Wang, Yasheng Wang, Kam-Fai Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Conversational retrieval refers to an information retrieval system that
operates in an iterative and interactive manner, requiring the retrieval of
various external resources, such as persona, knowledge, and even response, to
effectively engage with the user and successfully complete the dialogue.
However, most previous work trained independent retrievers for each specific
resource, resulting in sub-optimal performance and low efficiency. Thus, we
propose a multi-task framework function as a universal retriever for three
dominant retrieval tasks during the conversation: persona selection, knowledge
selection, and response selection. To this end, we design a dual-encoder
architecture consisting of a context-adaptive dialogue encoder and a candidate
encoder, aiming to attention to the relevant context from the long dialogue and
retrieve suitable candidates by simply a dot product. Furthermore, we introduce
two loss constraints to capture the subtle relationship between dialogue
context and different candidates by regarding historically selected candidates
as hard negatives. Extensive experiments and analysis establish
state-of-the-art retrieval quality both within and outside its training domain,
revealing the promising potential and generalization capability of our model to
serve as a universal retriever for different candidate selection tasks
simultaneously.
|
[
-0.29843881726264954,
-0.47302135825157166,
0.6305944323539734,
0.2022324502468109,
-0.28351834416389465,
0.051488664001226425,
-0.2875927984714508,
-0.32023924589157104,
0.13331900537014008,
0.55519038438797,
-0.5586365461349487,
-0.03157379478216171,
-0.4538462162017822,
0.04189561679959297,
-0.3708782494068146,
0.8582582473754883,
0.3304018974304199,
0.025097163394093513,
-0.36559510231018066,
-0.3224407136440277,
-0.8853479027748108,
-0.6699091792106628,
-0.6078450679779053,
-0.3833991289138794,
0.38790163397789,
0.5382239818572998,
0.3794192969799042,
0.05012066289782524,
0.35394713282585144,
0.25285056233406067,
0.04447229579091072,
-0.07604077458381653,
-0.5592601895332336,
0.4782934784889221,
-0.40407562255859375,
-0.16517634689807892,
0.02407032810151577,
-0.30579930543899536,
0.48080411553382874,
0.504603385925293,
-0.3509896397590637,
0.11653014272451401,
0.3923613131046295,
0.5500967502593994,
-0.9503976106643677,
-0.046374689787626266,
-0.8164004683494568,
0.060428641736507416,
-0.08997022360563278,
-0.4907217025756836,
-0.39980584383010864,
-0.18960066139698029,
0.41341957449913025,
-0.42399439215660095,
0.3203992545604706,
-0.02425198256969452,
0.30729585886001587,
0.12874701619148254,
-0.8225767016410828,
-0.3178153932094574,
-0.6738625168800354,
0.7095178961753845,
-0.33231642842292786,
0.6404521465301514,
0.08191689848899841,
0.37943193316459656,
0.09388654679059982,
-0.5244982242584229,
-0.28810590505599976,
-0.07577304542064667,
-0.07368499040603638,
0.2853323519229889,
-0.1378687173128128,
0.17898115515708923,
-0.1817796379327774,
0.29537463188171387,
-0.42328155040740967,
-0.080824114382267,
-0.3038036823272705,
-0.3654453754425049,
0.24305017292499542,
0.1551271378993988,
-0.05817783251404762,
-0.07262684404850006,
-0.5458195209503174,
0.035529207438230515,
-0.5507354736328125,
0.15204468369483948,
0.23113630712032318,
0.48861441016197205,
0.3684387803077698,
0.44093936681747437,
-0.42536166310310364,
0.6673403382301331,
0.13980387151241302,
0.21784771978855133,
0.058342333883047104,
-0.45443594455718994,
-0.09681747853755951,
0.028235051780939102,
0.7475025057792664,
0.13542453944683075,
-0.17935651540756226,
-0.3442053496837616,
-0.1352527141571045,
-0.15822932124137878,
0.5727912783622742,
-0.8501348495483398,
-0.04514259472489357,
0.08377723395824432,
-0.48111584782600403,
0.020959796383976936,
0.01271664910018444,
-0.9995920658111572,
-0.34493520855903625,
-0.31348350644111633,
0.498789519071579,
-0.1979239583015442,
-0.28066757321357727,
0.1352439820766449,
-0.2348477691411972,
0.046483591198921204,
0.20280127227306366,
-0.7143832445144653,
0.2378089427947998,
0.31305405497550964,
0.44534921646118164,
-0.2630458176136017,
-0.07885768264532089,
-0.7666423916816711,
0.03921130672097206,
0.034865230321884155,
0.7175838351249695,
-0.9940844178199768,
-0.6351701617240906,
0.06657004356384277,
0.01139578502625227,
-0.4018871784210205,
-0.4219728112220764,
0.8995039463043213,
-0.7740760445594788,
0.1956629902124405,
-0.3988514244556427,
-0.23871509730815887,
-0.38317614793777466,
0.2618938684463501,
-0.5764074921607971,
0.8055025935173035,
-0.026034709066152573,
-0.6004530191421509,
0.15996533632278442,
-0.8568236827850342,
-0.3764939606189728,
0.09910104423761368,
-0.3247968256473541,
-0.022811859846115112,
0.08930433541536331,
0.1094307079911232,
0.48089519143104553,
-0.6571490168571472,
0.41791853308677673,
-0.24238958954811096,
-0.513512134552002,
0.19008269906044006,
-0.4340370297431946,
0.6589338183403015,
0.1295633167028427,
-0.35620948672294617,
0.0324830487370491,
-0.4780263900756836,
0.13754840195178986,
0.05897415429353714,
-0.6798639893531799,
-0.18218126893043518,
0.06796962767839432,
0.24146722257137299,
0.3079231381416321,
0.29175451397895813,
-0.8848610520362854,
-0.07768484205007553,
0.01595001481473446,
0.26889970898628235,
0.5292388200759888,
-0.00431755231693387,
0.4757978022098541,
-0.10025838762521744,
0.3602740168571472,
0.1883917897939682,
0.05103158578276634,
-0.09804099053144455,
-0.2564306855201721,
-0.8007766008377075,
0.007059827446937561,
0.12009643763303757,
0.7483991384506226,
-0.6912585496902466,
0.3676852583885193,
-0.22633977234363556,
-0.16453422605991364,
-0.587211549282074,
0.340941846370697,
0.7418895363807678,
0.6338260173797607,
0.3358871042728424,
-0.5190668106079102,
-0.6977788209915161,
-0.9693246483802795,
-0.3611311614513397,
0.11341998726129532,
-0.09112446010112762,
0.590853214263916,
0.35659193992614746,
-0.3527040183544159,
1.1003704071044922,
-0.4692125916481018,
-0.7133908867835999,
-0.22629094123840332,
-0.00563574256375432,
0.12119050323963165,
0.4537927210330963,
0.32705506682395935,
-1.1582046747207642,
-0.33001479506492615,
-0.03748215734958649,
-0.7201033234596252,
0.26443663239479065,
-0.04858499392867088,
-0.23125915229320526,
-0.10159162431955338,
0.22245004773139954,
-0.6180635094642639,
0.3722187578678131,
0.21983231604099274,
-0.12777023017406464,
0.351649671792984,
-0.3100283741950989,
0.3574979901313782,
-0.9884738922119141,
0.42634040117263794,
-0.03749852627515793,
-0.05903282389044762,
-0.7133504748344421,
0.0014381182845681906,
0.1706601232290268,
-0.19314540922641754,
-0.30142271518707275,
0.5155367255210876,
-0.5566303730010986,
-0.020012952387332916,
-0.12953367829322815,
0.2432132065296173,
0.08694787323474884,
0.8301389217376709,
0.19949056208133698,
0.8140465021133423,
0.528442919254303,
-0.9054161906242371,
0.4582761824131012,
0.5462552309036255,
-0.15001727640628815,
1.1688951253890991,
-0.6126866936683655,
0.6288611888885498,
-0.39685940742492676,
0.31740376353263855,
-1.069618821144104,
-0.09042994678020477,
0.05010515823960304,
-0.23730264604091644,
0.18709369003772736,
-0.20081503689289093,
-0.3047688603401184,
-0.5443305373191833,
-0.07237038016319275,
0.46584659814834595,
0.20120728015899658,
-0.6512107253074646,
0.6641018390655518,
0.48103800415992737,
-0.1565924435853958,
-0.664793074131012,
-0.48672932386398315,
0.10384991019964218,
-0.2265416383743286,
-0.3311859667301178,
0.42666977643966675,
-0.3540676534175873,
0.22870813310146332,
-0.2728310823440552,
-0.28441476821899414,
-0.3086353838443756,
-0.14696669578552246,
0.22008752822875977,
0.1295415163040161,
-0.06331602483987808,
0.08269573748111725,
-0.08724627643823624,
-0.20955635607242584,
-0.17466798424720764,
-0.39949309825897217,
0.2409830242395401,
-0.07031171768903732,
-0.6062219738960266,
-0.314972460269928,
0.7350795269012451,
0.39989998936653137,
-0.4320153594017029,
0.446392685174942,
0.6546888947486877,
-0.23201212286949158,
0.3172684609889984,
-1.0008047819137573,
-0.2970716655254364,
-0.4556661546230316,
0.43115416169166565,
-0.6042547225952148,
-1.079799771308899,
0.5433459281921387,
-0.08985549956560135,
0.0584346279501915,
0.174615278840065,
0.38355356454849243,
0.15202124416828156,
1.1929080486297607,
0.6484730243682861,
-0.06430720537900925,
0.39859867095947266,
0.02616485394537449,
0.1581982970237732,
-1.1813530921936035,
-0.6441157460212708,
-0.6211082339286804,
-0.223445862531662,
-0.1735014021396637,
-0.23000425100326538,
0.45534077286720276,
-0.06247381493449211,
-0.33474358916282654,
0.4300890266895294,
-0.8990604877471924,
0.4133046269416809,
0.945944607257843,
0.18807362020015717,
0.3507864773273468,
-0.1775512546300888,
-0.14860571920871735,
-0.21802577376365662,
-0.479380339384079,
-0.2702271640300751,
1.1010560989379883,
-0.1787792146205902,
0.6509058475494385,
0.3055054843425751,
0.478469580411911,
0.23071692883968353,
-0.1224144846200943,
-0.5602465867996216,
0.5321346521377563,
-0.17194513976573944,
-0.8617915511131287,
-0.09017792344093323,
-0.4440571963787079,
-1.0805710554122925,
0.689887523651123,
0.026848768815398216,
-1.1859880685806274,
0.44723227620124817,
0.18303100764751434,
-0.5428167581558228,
0.0972738116979599,
-0.4641300141811371,
1.0408177375793457,
-0.3167881965637207,
-0.10982337594032288,
-0.4115239083766937,
-0.9528614282608032,
0.15909439325332642,
-0.13773590326309204,
-0.02718237414956093,
-0.08619215339422226,
0.14320126175880432,
0.6585773229598999,
0.39952346682548523,
0.6994540095329285,
-0.49987557530403137,
0.2503598630428314,
0.2864111065864563,
0.2648310363292694,
0.3293207585811615,
0.13241060078144073,
-0.2816160321235657,
-0.2073652148246765,
0.2607772946357727,
-0.1777186095714569,
-0.4555809497833252,
0.5266537666320801,
-0.5290875434875488,
-0.6913139224052429,
-0.08619671314954758,
-0.29494813084602356,
-0.33344778418540955,
0.44581615924835205,
0.2785385251045227,
0.6158368587493896,
-0.7860319018363953,
0.6224488615989685,
0.6483519077301025,
-0.043034691363573074,
0.3290225565433502,
0.648691713809967,
0.307944655418396,
-0.18280181288719177,
0.9302790760993958,
-0.3308463394641876,
-0.007126359269022942,
0.6738860607147217,
-0.08901090919971466,
-0.5617259740829468,
-0.23917779326438904,
-0.4205566942691803,
-0.16735178232192993,
-0.7274446487426758,
-0.35365399718284607,
-0.8590104579925537,
-0.10627119243144989,
-0.2890479564666748,
0.009256698191165924,
-0.474496454000473,
-0.06444474309682846,
-0.6021748781204224,
0.26386281847953796,
-0.1208513155579567,
0.46356919407844543,
0.07308603823184967,
0.25274986028671265,
-0.7507199048995972,
0.36658230423927307,
0.6004688143730164,
0.3672944903373718,
-0.15242229402065277,
-0.5762604475021362,
-0.06409838050603867,
0.40358006954193115,
-0.6883277297019958,
-0.8058323264122009,
0.1616644710302353,
0.5517182946205139,
0.8753126263618469,
0.43618062138557434,
0.2119988650083542,
0.5693172216415405,
-0.4745505750179291,
0.38923272490501404,
0.3294222354888916,
-0.6593796610832214,
0.5699787139892578,
-0.22688153386116028,
0.4454802870750427,
0.9917606115341187,
0.15102459490299225,
-0.8435037136077881,
-0.0004778424627147615,
-0.22062082588672638,
-0.5917261242866516,
0.9889935255050659,
0.16721130907535553,
0.3380242586135864,
0.04801280051469803,
0.12742699682712555,
0.2034808248281479,
0.4083930552005768,
-0.4582471251487732,
-0.11201086640357971,
-0.3041384816169739,
-0.0231875479221344,
0.05944276228547096,
-0.4541495442390442,
-0.36902180314064026,
-0.07341349124908447,
0.44912832975387573,
-0.44604867696762085,
0.6880515217781067,
0.15852780640125275,
-0.23118187487125397,
0.05831878259778023,
0.7266448736190796,
0.1555711179971695,
0.4315229058265686,
-0.29594719409942627,
-0.12494659423828125,
0.0655905231833458,
-0.2167244255542755,
0.18659785389900208,
0.42460185289382935,
0.257750540971756,
-0.052927203476428986,
-0.4032873511314392,
0.8421235680580139,
0.7489819526672363,
-0.7536819577217102,
0.7265843749046326,
-0.2577354609966278,
-0.03192150220274925,
-0.3862856924533844,
0.021401936188340187,
0.052702583372592926,
0.45323216915130615,
0.8571072816848755,
0.1868300437927246,
0.5892581343650818,
-0.46435049176216125,
0.18827314674854279,
0.7647173404693604,
-0.4777260422706604,
-0.23264746367931366,
0.9178612232208252,
0.5625787973403931,
-0.4366363286972046,
0.7769798040390015,
-0.36373424530029297,
-0.370299756526947,
0.3541181981563568,
0.6695911884307861,
0.9113480448722839,
-0.19368240237236023,
0.1917477548122406,
0.2487146109342575,
-0.22621381282806396,
-0.21893922984600067,
0.1971183717250824,
-0.4051271975040436,
-0.8095579743385315,
-0.03201445937156677,
-0.4755314886569977,
-0.3560326099395752,
-0.059655819088220596,
-1.0283408164978027,
-0.10887900739908218,
0.03304443508386612,
-0.3398047089576721,
-0.1772567331790924,
-0.12743180990219116,
-1.0475480556488037,
0.07447942346334457,
0.0371420718729496,
0.565155565738678,
-0.2277982532978058,
0.6485992074012756,
0.6105834245681763,
-0.24881519377231598,
-0.16728603839874268,
-0.20599418878555298,
0.24514855444431305,
-0.5992099046707153,
0.44507816433906555,
0.2879757881164551,
-0.2585621774196625,
0.13080796599388123,
-0.06914578378200531,
-1.0741612911224365,
1.1894501447677612,
0.6610615849494934,
-0.45621660351753235,
-0.34458833932876587,
-0.16632536053657532,
0.27061501145362854,
-0.40026140213012695,
0.42024362087249756,
0.5440344214439392,
0.14741425216197968,
0.38132792711257935,
-1.2091789245605469,
0.08062492311000824,
-0.3114812672138214,
0.2932671010494232,
0.10371725261211395,
-0.7030514478683472,
0.5283702611923218,
-0.26867687702178955,
-0.33496689796447754,
0.3456384539604187,
0.3564085364341736,
0.19982247054576874,
0.12073571234941483,
0.4479997754096985,
0.14813776314258575,
0.601385772228241,
-0.024740444496273994,
0.7811126708984375,
-0.3162730932235718,
0.2705685794353485,
1.0875247716903687,
-0.234497532248497,
0.8029488921165466,
0.3636740446090698,
0.016573188826441765,
0.42397215962409973,
0.419838547706604,
0.35638564825057983,
0.7576480507850647,
-0.30652570724487305,
-0.42704975605010986,
-0.5054947137832642,
-0.21715308725833893,
-0.19126541912555695,
0.6450170874595642,
0.4231884777545929,
-0.11591031402349472,
-0.23188282549381256,
0.2899410128593445,
-0.32216015458106995,
-0.07836548984050751,
0.0037430862430483103,
0.8213789463043213,
0.0394277423620224,
-0.9521340727806091,
0.4204554855823517,
-0.07635911554098129,
0.9457605481147766,
-0.46216899156570435,
0.032162245362997055,
-0.006877053529024124,
0.3861391544342041,
0.04642391949892044,
-0.6910640597343445,
-0.021697813645005226,
-0.41585099697113037,
-0.027132626622915268,
-0.2811833620071411,
0.879970908164978,
-0.663236677646637,
-0.13814470171928406,
0.5569041967391968,
0.5713934302330017,
0.02443045936524868,
-0.49130409955978394,
-0.9294463992118835,
-0.0007501544896513224,
0.15301749110221863,
-0.22449682652950287,
0.352160781621933,
0.14241738617420197,
0.3097130060195923,
0.7395338416099548,
0.45566487312316895,
-0.4143868386745453,
-0.18849867582321167,
0.21464107930660248,
0.798231840133667,
-0.5891188979148865,
-0.5697519183158875,
-0.42688605189323425,
0.44580310583114624,
-0.18562091886997223,
-0.41402071714401245,
0.4908267557621002,
0.5877025723457336,
0.5544652938842773,
0.016011523082852364,
0.6375243663787842,
-0.14119772613048553,
0.6207995414733887,
-0.16084587574005127,
0.33565253019332886,
-0.5921608805656433,
0.012820912525057793,
-0.30624863505363464,
-0.9917201399803162,
0.08488918095827103,
0.5205197930335999,
0.11165801435709,
0.186655655503273,
0.6111288666725159,
0.7798753380775452,
-0.22603070735931396,
0.2074597030878067,
0.194479838013649,
-0.3188098967075348,
0.2500263452529907,
0.9799768924713135,
0.6283110976219177,
-0.28874897956848145,
0.9621195197105408,
0.04481044039130211,
-0.039006803184747696,
-0.4898560047149658,
-0.45577120780944824,
-0.7765681743621826,
-0.9879835844039917,
-0.0744374617934227,
-0.047978248447179794,
0.21373499929904938,
0.7195780873298645,
0.9339735507965088,
-0.6896376609802246,
-0.29067790508270264,
0.1367701292037964,
-0.07674703747034073,
-0.0953807607293129,
-0.2146965116262436,
0.04093443229794502,
-0.32208433747291565,
-0.6798382997512817,
0.7589671015739441,
0.33864423632621765,
-0.3033294379711151,
-0.07126950472593307,
-0.18440139293670654,
-0.344676673412323,
-0.17483019828796387,
0.5278525948524475,
0.5894377827644348,
-0.6979618668556213,
-0.40430891513824463,
0.014469420537352562,
-0.16026778519153595,
0.20079809427261353,
1.1259340047836304,
-0.9016959071159363,
0.7666239142417908,
0.10493215918540955,
0.9060774445533752,
0.6437087655067444,
0.05339685082435608,
0.6443995237350464,
-0.9538156390190125,
0.18471060693264008,
0.4232863485813141,
0.25970083475112915,
0.543788731098175,
-0.5174780488014221,
0.4143483638763428,
0.11679358780384064,
-0.6899878978729248,
-0.6109380722045898,
0.26668375730514526,
-0.7691471576690674,
-0.25757545232772827,
1.164399266242981,
0.13796979188919067,
0.3100295066833496,
-0.47031906247138977,
-0.3561154305934906,
0.16181311011314392,
-0.7262076735496521,
0.6319518089294434,
0.3747032880783081,
-0.3444460928440094,
-0.14687031507492065,
-0.7008090019226074,
0.36152219772338867,
0.5291476845741272,
-0.4764120876789093,
-0.0528828464448452,
0.5645803809165955,
0.37181973457336426,
0.22718146443367004,
1.1330410242080688,
0.05927242711186409,
0.4416661560535431,
-0.1509198248386383,
-0.03200575336813927,
0.23773141205310822,
-0.3086893856525421,
-0.18855781853199005,
0.24464687705039978,
-0.08827511966228485,
-0.39595702290534973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16248v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16248v1
|
Topic-to-essay generation with knowledge-based content selection
| 2024-02-26T02:14:42 | 2024-02-26T02:14:42 |
Jieyong Wang, Chunyao Song, Yihao Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The topic-to-essay generation task is a challenging natural language
generation task that aims to generate paragraph-level text with high semantic
coherence based on a given set of topic words. Previous work has focused on the
introduction of external knowledge, ignoring the insufficient generated text
diversity. In order to improve the generation diversity, we propose a novel
copy mechanism model with a content selection module that integrates rich
semantic knowledge from the language model into the decoder. Furthermore, we
introduce the improved prefix tuning method to train the model, enabling it to
adapt to varying input complexities. In addition, we have contributed a new
Chinese dataset for TEG tasks. Experimental results demonstrate that the
proposed model can improve the generated text diversity by 35\% to 59\%
compared to the state-of-the-art method, while maintaining a high level of
topic consistency.
|
[
-0.38364362716674805,
-0.7753440141677856,
0.4722982347011566,
0.0975358635187149,
-0.5649112462997437,
-0.09832008183002472,
-0.2711866796016693,
-0.18584151566028595,
0.11071120202541351,
0.7307128310203552,
-0.6642047762870789,
-0.40384548902511597,
-0.6424258351325989,
0.31359484791755676,
-0.4579542875289917,
1.3132717609405518,
-0.06837758421897888,
-0.2661797106266022,
-0.1310466229915619,
0.5462130904197693,
-0.5358628034591675,
0.11499189585447311,
-0.9337162971496582,
-0.191319078207016,
0.4000832140445709,
0.48336511850357056,
0.13717402517795563,
0.6611783504486084,
0.31682804226875305,
0.1752854436635971,
-0.058254674077034,
0.35107260942459106,
-0.69196617603302,
0.11122346669435501,
-0.5538836121559143,
-0.34644678235054016,
-0.2015918344259262,
-0.20413140952587128,
0.7450351119041443,
0.5267006158828735,
0.16188879311084747,
-0.09603188186883926,
0.31719139218330383,
0.3701155185699463,
-0.4802234470844269,
-0.24885205924510956,
-1.0370426177978516,
-0.00261325784958899,
-0.19923943281173706,
-0.18792691826820374,
-0.5144597887992859,
-0.3497489392757416,
0.27615663409233093,
-0.7738158702850342,
0.5163384675979614,
0.00682762311771512,
0.8177235126495361,
-0.10150495171546936,
-0.6462811827659607,
-0.3202325403690338,
-0.6042308211326599,
0.7979078888893127,
-0.5062425136566162,
0.05032995343208313,
0.3072037398815155,
-0.21044166386127472,
-0.1279025822877884,
-0.9104023575782776,
-0.6852537989616394,
-0.06079735979437828,
0.1426498293876648,
0.2697392404079437,
0.13840395212173462,
-0.05430137366056442,
0.07395713031291962,
0.6263933181762695,
-0.49475041031837463,
-0.23090992867946625,
-0.4524497985839844,
-0.2618732154369354,
0.6940289735794067,
0.06960426270961761,
0.4601325988769531,
-0.3986664116382599,
-0.43971893191337585,
-0.0452493317425251,
-0.5937932729721069,
-0.13247224688529968,
0.5734797716140747,
0.3240182399749756,
0.19533246755599976,
0.499347448348999,
-0.4176690876483917,
0.5022428631782532,
0.42873114347457886,
-0.1174725890159607,
-0.0865766778588295,
-0.6776649951934814,
0.17070673406124115,
0.14941653609275818,
0.35930150747299194,
0.4272536337375641,
-0.010689646936953068,
-0.1628410816192627,
-0.22968779504299164,
-0.06281282752752304,
0.5601297616958618,
-0.8159399032592773,
-0.04390815645456314,
0.025636576116085052,
-0.42429810762405396,
-0.33504146337509155,
0.37961286306381226,
-0.6696495413780212,
0.2587628960609436,
-0.3173060417175293,
0.43328791856765747,
-0.7184339761734009,
-0.2637856602668762,
0.13056804239749908,
-0.4604790508747101,
0.15808247029781342,
0.32495662569999695,
-0.8999775052070618,
0.12238048762083054,
0.9147635102272034,
0.7776042222976685,
-0.7694305181503296,
-0.4550100564956665,
-0.39199209213256836,
0.6039949059486389,
-0.26395711302757263,
1.0589796304702759,
-0.32567453384399414,
-0.4468328654766083,
0.09239942580461502,
0.047908518463373184,
-0.13308307528495789,
-0.3861517310142517,
0.7165282964706421,
-0.3791302740573883,
0.5938056707382202,
-0.4980356693267822,
-0.8096181750297546,
-0.08779026567935944,
0.14702248573303223,
-0.5802118182182312,
1.0299537181854248,
0.22003859281539917,
-0.8661902546882629,
0.6375676393508911,
-0.5940972566604614,
-0.7639095783233643,
0.05112266540527344,
0.09825653582811356,
-0.4507025480270386,
0.21230918169021606,
-0.015777183696627617,
0.3317406475543976,
-0.3092612326145172,
0.53666090965271,
-0.05645916238427162,
-0.33909183740615845,
-0.060555215924978256,
-0.25722289085388184,
0.4685925543308258,
0.42063772678375244,
-0.22894400358200073,
-0.0535661056637764,
-0.7648665308952332,
-0.21347759664058685,
0.13104720413684845,
-0.48269134759902954,
-0.3811458945274353,
-0.12920016050338745,
-0.020336788147687912,
0.2510826289653778,
0.29403120279312134,
-0.48282262682914734,
0.03686743974685669,
-0.36030319333076477,
0.2346733957529068,
0.5915682315826416,
0.4850445091724396,
0.4264768958091736,
-0.8359561562538147,
0.24786339700222015,
0.06990959495306015,
-0.23768699169158936,
-0.2654063105583191,
-0.5679230093955994,
-0.7843624949455261,
0.021224332973361015,
0.04444732144474983,
0.4835781455039978,
-0.8176999092102051,
0.6725504994392395,
-0.039187241345644,
-0.3754720389842987,
-0.216314435005188,
0.04934012517333031,
0.13592442870140076,
0.531809389591217,
0.335592657327652,
-0.23705606162548065,
-0.1315319538116455,
-0.6767494678497314,
-0.09895052015781403,
-0.15346479415893555,
0.04254419356584549,
0.234944686293602,
0.40773987770080566,
0.1603354811668396,
0.8148149251937866,
-0.7939069867134094,
-0.1621316820383072,
-0.5978795886039734,
0.5061101317405701,
-0.22648648917675018,
0.6664218306541443,
0.445885568857193,
-0.7171695828437805,
-0.5130077004432678,
-0.09641622751951218,
-0.4052373170852661,
-0.2751239538192749,
-0.2281573861837387,
-0.6989728808403015,
0.19467447698116302,
0.4441087543964386,
-0.5778176188468933,
0.16376735270023346,
0.06478807330131531,
-0.6484386920928955,
0.45350995659828186,
-0.15056680142879486,
0.3329469859600067,
-1.977289080619812,
-0.026744412258267403,
0.040037404745817184,
0.15534909069538116,
-0.6609208583831787,
0.06717250496149063,
-0.11794710159301758,
-0.33337053656578064,
-0.45870324969291687,
0.491512656211853,
-0.1629275381565094,
0.3407105505466461,
-0.7148571610450745,
-0.10964665561914444,
0.24923446774482727,
0.41170021891593933,
0.27511149644851685,
0.6625939011573792,
0.42971646785736084,
-0.6876034736633301,
0.0855555608868599,
0.5104688405990601,
-0.18562468886375427,
0.670224130153656,
-0.3665471076965332,
0.1353878378868103,
-0.2207104116678238,
0.10140247642993927,
-0.9040926098823547,
-0.26786941289901733,
0.040652792900800705,
-0.31137341260910034,
0.47254034876823425,
0.07335323840379715,
-0.08894020318984985,
-0.044716332107782364,
-0.3383500874042511,
0.16868552565574646,
0.5078876614570618,
-0.4163433909416199,
0.3085074722766876,
0.012276003137230873,
-0.5565604567527771,
-0.31092125177383423,
-0.49025097489356995,
0.08939313143491745,
-0.3562026619911194,
-0.8617790937423706,
0.7928440570831299,
-0.09786220639944077,
0.027848729863762856,
0.11873126775026321,
0.09278596937656403,
-0.1331997811794281,
0.05840574949979782,
-0.2852373719215393,
0.09848634153604507,
-0.33317995071411133,
0.34425535798072815,
0.601534903049469,
0.0703083798289299,
-0.03233868628740311,
-0.8437755107879639,
0.4433760643005371,
0.560581386089325,
-0.19211383163928986,
-0.28745609521865845,
0.9392262697219849,
0.17479009926319122,
-0.315929114818573,
0.706682026386261,
0.6108130216598511,
-0.3339952230453491,
-0.9776965975761414,
-0.33096155524253845,
-0.49378305673599243,
-0.4417975842952728,
0.5896807312965393,
-0.3411579132080078,
-0.9076024293899536,
0.28055456280708313,
-0.1956835389137268,
0.18778441846370697,
0.7565061450004578,
0.4925520420074463,
0.034488245844841,
0.29241126775741577,
0.7961264848709106,
0.24528785049915314,
0.6242249011993408,
-0.064078688621521,
0.08095189183950424,
-0.42805761098861694,
-0.09090713411569595,
-0.5732854008674622,
-0.15909452736377716,
-0.46679380536079407,
-0.425455242395401,
-0.07633596658706665,
-0.04527994245290756,
-0.06098468229174614,
0.16608861088752747,
-0.4682212471961975,
0.174799844622612,
0.6380258202552795,
0.14149652421474457,
0.42038634419441223,
0.3554741144180298,
0.04378969967365265,
-0.08948222547769547,
-0.6941465735435486,
-0.5316796898841858,
1.0760202407836914,
-0.14965198934078217,
0.3897562623023987,
-0.17433682084083557,
0.8703455924987793,
0.4400091767311096,
-0.14615346491336823,
-0.36472323536872864,
0.8062008619308472,
-0.6207318902015686,
-0.4643065333366394,
-0.38807767629623413,
-0.3343859612941742,
-0.7617883086204529,
0.012669190764427185,
-0.2987040579319,
-0.5354416370391846,
-0.17946280539035797,
-0.1685182750225067,
-0.1952965259552002,
0.5136728882789612,
-0.39657479524612427,
0.692305326461792,
0.13003769516944885,
-0.522944986820221,
-0.36020392179489136,
-0.28423646092414856,
0.424070805311203,
-0.26232048869132996,
-0.40692371129989624,
0.12649035453796387,
0.1791556179523468,
0.7424457669258118,
-0.2879297733306885,
0.6174057126045227,
0.07003321498632431,
-0.3751876652240753,
0.702729344367981,
-0.24359609186649323,
0.5081678628921509,
0.191700279712677,
-0.3236995339393616,
-0.17115715146064758,
-0.4981240928173065,
-0.259386271238327,
-0.4517865777015686,
0.5414946675300598,
-0.8025957345962524,
-0.9462219476699829,
0.0037856418639421463,
-0.6426404714584351,
0.05950867757201195,
0.12017950415611267,
0.737467348575592,
0.315759539604187,
-0.26468610763549805,
0.2530306875705719,
0.9254364371299744,
-0.36992761492729187,
0.5178903341293335,
0.27558183670043945,
0.10575345903635025,
-0.4878356158733368,
1.2867460250854492,
0.12013334780931473,
0.4651002287864685,
0.6091286540031433,
0.10502757132053375,
-0.047322649508714676,
-0.7914707660675049,
-0.3289974629878998,
0.07093355804681778,
-0.6409069895744324,
0.058623526245355606,
-1.0506832599639893,
-0.5030244588851929,
-0.5103873014450073,
-0.3607681691646576,
-0.3492884039878845,
-0.4066522419452667,
-0.5772133469581604,
-0.22469140589237213,
0.28577205538749695,
0.5840810537338257,
0.14425557851791382,
0.3088569939136505,
-0.6860891580581665,
0.507282018661499,
0.3335486948490143,
0.2994094491004944,
-0.12277860939502716,
-0.7430868744850159,
-0.2064022272825241,
-0.32321494817733765,
-0.7228723764419556,
-0.8784447312355042,
0.07677098363637924,
0.2141261249780655,
0.5357089638710022,
0.3989375829696655,
0.26135075092315674,
0.13467885553836823,
-0.13337565958499908,
1.0486853122711182,
-0.033504702150821686,
-0.9846770763397217,
0.8360292911529541,
-0.45134902000427246,
0.27662473917007446,
0.5834864377975464,
0.28591135144233704,
-0.4592572748661041,
-0.8366761803627014,
-0.4636504054069519,
-0.7922744154930115,
0.8519411087036133,
0.3105814754962921,
0.2814134955406189,
-0.08091853559017181,
0.4728739857673645,
0.798193097114563,
0.0897156223654747,
-0.799123227596283,
0.08866822719573975,
-0.4068143665790558,
-0.29824984073638916,
0.18027305603027344,
-0.22251735627651215,
0.29271337389945984,
0.10062237083911896,
1.0255924463272095,
-0.28726086020469666,
0.3254148066043854,
0.2687179148197174,
0.152321919798851,
-0.24568520486354828,
0.36085233092308044,
0.7075412273406982,
0.3996630609035492,
0.03101697377860546,
-0.008373039774596691,
0.32125037908554077,
-0.7165208458900452,
0.03969994932413101,
0.1342892348766327,
-0.7710815668106079,
0.06618142873048782,
0.2559027075767517,
0.9673780202865601,
-0.3067292273044586,
-0.14692163467407227,
0.2536332607269287,
-0.1302536129951477,
-0.6263718605041504,
-0.0027154043782502413,
0.44827067852020264,
0.12388527393341064,
0.04836257919669151,
0.323158323764801,
-0.09619978815317154,
0.08547397702932358,
-0.4387061893939972,
0.546437680721283,
0.28611043095588684,
-0.19505557417869568,
-0.2530607581138611,
0.5209272503852844,
0.47410282492637634,
-0.21569523215293884,
0.5772057771682739,
-0.541100263595581,
-0.41245168447494507,
0.7160953879356384,
0.8442621231079102,
1.0979743003845215,
-0.03050892986357212,
0.42975693941116333,
0.5959445238113403,
0.28457802534103394,
-0.2973051369190216,
0.5585068464279175,
0.03218811750411987,
-0.7686947584152222,
-0.4587181508541107,
-0.6028432846069336,
-0.25882837176322937,
0.3401990234851837,
-0.36612316966056824,
0.6418682932853699,
-0.1792968213558197,
-0.04599527642130852,
-0.43355849385261536,
0.1520039141178131,
-0.10245657712221146,
0.4830262064933777,
0.10640932619571686,
0.7388272285461426,
-0.7685438990592957,
0.8536693453788757,
0.8522533774375916,
-0.26034823060035706,
-0.8005341291427612,
0.6788740158081055,
-0.46139422059059143,
-0.09892348200082779,
0.3018782436847687,
0.03586525842547417,
0.2589508891105652,
0.045548584312200546,
-0.2512449026107788,
-0.7321874499320984,
1.1934324502944946,
0.3658686578273773,
-0.18150176107883453,
-0.14710833132266998,
0.4788062870502472,
0.2778528034687042,
-0.5815399885177612,
-0.10499260574579239,
0.08930496126413345,
0.424296110868454,
0.3455449342727661,
-0.4440862834453583,
0.18895453214645386,
-0.34456366300582886,
0.014245433732867241,
0.10269129276275635,
-0.8889180421829224,
1.072523832321167,
-0.05080496892333031,
-0.15493983030319214,
-0.08272721618413925,
1.0229570865631104,
0.32596322894096375,
0.5598440170288086,
0.32914817333221436,
0.6658874154090881,
0.6859166622161865,
-0.002593971323221922,
0.7556216716766357,
-0.6210311055183411,
0.05785543471574783,
0.907415509223938,
-0.2852855324745178,
0.47408249974250793,
0.4063790440559387,
0.2848424017429352,
0.37355247139930725,
0.4488663673400879,
-0.3064902722835541,
0.6493825316429138,
0.14740675687789917,
-0.4665546417236328,
-0.3588505983352661,
-0.4332554042339325,
-0.449167937040329,
0.4331763982772827,
-0.02971411496400833,
-0.44922512769699097,
-0.20563088357448578,
0.0031655861530452967,
-0.23518137633800507,
0.30900368094444275,
-0.31084272265434265,
1.0959817171096802,
0.02481723390519619,
-1.3520585298538208,
-0.016010651364922523,
0.30896127223968506,
0.740897536277771,
-0.8005523681640625,
-0.06339837610721588,
-0.3288367688655853,
-0.1260155886411667,
0.003667242359369993,
-0.7350261807441711,
0.5656214952468872,
-0.010383384302258492,
-0.4414442777633667,
-0.33184266090393066,
1.414322018623352,
-0.7397886514663696,
-0.5283747911453247,
0.08484897017478943,
0.5853034257888794,
-0.22273693978786469,
0.06428878754377365,
-0.1654922217130661,
-0.3407615125179291,
0.1989533007144928,
-0.30648964643478394,
0.2712351679801941,
0.851311206817627,
-0.09627414494752884,
0.11489362269639969,
0.5259171724319458,
0.13063649833202362,
-0.10961485654115677,
-0.2545652985572815,
0.588026225566864,
-0.8126147389411926,
-0.9777283072471619,
-0.7341315746307373,
0.4580948054790497,
-0.2013741284608841,
-0.5584231019020081,
0.5243178009986877,
0.5310409069061279,
0.9923239946365356,
-0.1744234561920166,
1.1737903356552124,
-0.07455851882696152,
0.3803347051143646,
-0.6036306619644165,
0.8732258677482605,
-0.5885853171348572,
-0.01105949841439724,
-0.34313109517097473,
-0.9963726997375488,
0.2932118773460388,
0.195530965924263,
-0.15072819590568542,
-0.024233270436525345,
0.8671522736549377,
0.6806030869483948,
-0.12069738656282425,
0.47852596640586853,
0.32568204402923584,
-0.2788817286491394,
0.1442175656557083,
0.741131067276001,
1.0224605798721313,
-0.2242111712694168,
0.5245004892349243,
-0.16699248552322388,
0.0996440127491951,
0.1136014312505722,
-0.9794861078262329,
-1.1254677772521973,
-0.759832501411438,
-0.490224152803421,
-0.24984779953956604,
0.12667027115821838,
0.8749077320098877,
0.5484986901283264,
-0.69171541929245,
-0.07567442953586578,
-0.39086073637008667,
0.1263151615858078,
-0.03592737764120102,
-0.20627687871456146,
0.2655464708805084,
-0.49912336468696594,
-0.7221100330352783,
-0.015924762934446335,
0.24194087088108063,
0.08136454224586487,
0.07970567047595978,
-0.025726867839694023,
-0.22869321703910828,
0.47354111075401306,
0.4110008478164673,
-0.2512884736061096,
-0.3306097090244293,
-0.21442723274230957,
-0.11765505373477936,
-0.22504156827926636,
0.027728445827960968,
1.0506494045257568,
-0.2252839207649231,
-0.04300757497549057,
0.6735420823097229,
0.8108784556388855,
0.4172956943511963,
0.01579090766608715,
0.828301191329956,
-0.6471260786056519,
-0.13321420550346375,
-0.02585277147591114,
0.26270002126693726,
0.354723185300827,
-0.6062189936637878,
0.1366204172372818,
0.6370322704315186,
-0.2652905583381653,
-0.33797988295555115,
0.19476357102394104,
-0.8158506155014038,
-0.6914708614349365,
1.1304484605789185,
-0.17512138187885284,
-0.029779352247714996,
-0.06265091150999069,
-0.44829124212265015,
0.8511027097702026,
-0.6335490345954895,
1.025501012802124,
0.8296048641204834,
0.3442309498786926,
-0.0784740000963211,
-0.1525535136461258,
0.6689964532852173,
0.6187787055969238,
-1.1710087060928345,
-0.062897689640522,
0.305742084980011,
0.28787538409233093,
0.024865373969078064,
0.3262138366699219,
0.09646341949701309,
0.35353884100914,
0.09896252304315567,
0.0223495252430439,
-0.06561312079429626,
-0.31484338641166687,
0.03891640901565552,
0.702369213104248,
-0.034524787217378616,
0.1733451932668686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16247v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16247v1
|
Learning Translations: Emergent Communication Pretraining for Cooperative Language Acquisition
| 2024-02-26T02:13:36 | 2024-02-26T02:13:36 |
Dylan Cope, Peter McBurney
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.MA
|
In Emergent Communication (EC) agents learn to communicate with one another,
but the protocols that they develop are specialised to their training
community. This observation led to research into Zero-Shot Coordination (ZSC)
for learning communication strategies that are robust to agents not encountered
during training. However, ZSC typically assumes that no prior data is available
about the agents that will be encountered in the zero-shot setting. In many
cases, this presents an unnecessarily hard problem and rules out communication
via preestablished conventions. We propose a novel AI challenge called a
Cooperative Language Acquisition Problem (CLAP) in which the ZSC assumptions
are relaxed by allowing a 'joiner' agent to learn from a dataset of
interactions between agents in a target community. We propose and compare two
methods for solving CLAPs: Imitation Learning (IL), and Emergent Communication
pretraining and Translation Learning (ECTL), in which an agent is trained in
self-play with EC and then learns from the data to translate between the
emergent protocol and the target community's protocol.
|
[
-0.07682482153177261,
-0.8401877284049988,
0.6091140508651733,
0.43684306740760803,
-0.19259893894195557,
0.6375129222869873,
-0.2557600736618042,
-0.736859917640686,
0.3588378131389618,
0.14200103282928467,
-0.5699185132980347,
-0.37298858165740967,
-0.6567953824996948,
0.0023463747929781675,
-0.20524875819683075,
0.8840306997299194,
-0.06433455646038055,
0.02902238816022873,
-0.025268178433179855,
-0.14087975025177002,
-0.09351266920566559,
-0.38767126202583313,
-0.731830358505249,
-0.5631722807884216,
0.43054044246673584,
0.8337239623069763,
0.46026480197906494,
0.462682843208313,
0.2328706979751587,
0.45734766125679016,
0.20822598040103912,
-0.013814370147883892,
-0.5202475786209106,
0.16831746697425842,
-0.15660478174686432,
-0.819831371307373,
-0.2812798321247101,
0.19462554156780243,
0.3967607915401459,
0.8632667064666748,
-0.2309393286705017,
0.07234501093626022,
-0.13884104788303375,
0.5837706327438354,
-0.5265475511550903,
0.6336559653282166,
-0.42213764786720276,
0.12835071980953217,
-0.16073666512966156,
-0.14795106649398804,
-0.52346271276474,
-0.04956789314746857,
0.2732865810394287,
-0.6412534117698669,
0.007087408099323511,
0.023928137496113777,
0.7174673676490784,
-0.09386243671178818,
-0.4026522934436798,
-0.30836421251296997,
-0.917625367641449,
0.5985189080238342,
-0.3462933301925659,
0.1633118987083435,
0.5059253573417664,
0.20660756528377533,
-0.36462152004241943,
-0.5065168738365173,
-0.8220338225364685,
-0.025134874507784843,
0.24190452694892883,
0.46857526898384094,
-0.21141408383846283,
0.11362295597791672,
-0.29503223299980164,
0.13715891540050507,
-0.4580039381980896,
0.22670458257198334,
-0.4198378324508667,
-0.17028360068798065,
0.45404955744743347,
-0.11616624146699905,
0.3742831349372864,
0.11923662573099136,
-0.5550099611282349,
-0.3256806433200836,
-0.46346515417099,
0.16521532833576202,
0.22674307227134705,
0.4201519787311554,
-0.6274291276931763,
0.23988614976406097,
-0.07959183305501938,
0.5461109280586243,
0.3076269328594208,
0.23673661053180695,
0.35372620820999146,
-0.20204567909240723,
0.06917344778776169,
-0.06735880672931671,
0.8205440044403076,
-0.017431864514946938,
0.2715912163257599,
-0.43211254477500916,
-0.17050877213478088,
0.2041027694940567,
0.042318083345890045,
-0.07778819650411606,
-0.18823184072971344,
0.3014816641807556,
-0.12212084233760834,
-0.34075507521629333,
0.03371553122997284,
-0.4040580987930298,
0.19077157974243164,
-0.13293775916099548,
0.5965662002563477,
-0.3445451557636261,
-0.49352169036865234,
-0.1416226476430893,
-0.17071425914764404,
0.6867297887802124,
0.26840493083000183,
-0.8787311315536499,
0.3940812647342682,
0.5145083069801331,
0.8431025743484497,
0.08113274723291397,
-0.855377197265625,
-0.5798993706703186,
0.1659563034772873,
-0.5636623501777649,
0.858576774597168,
-0.21963870525360107,
-0.2566140592098236,
-0.06426140666007996,
-0.09208038449287415,
-0.30794256925582886,
-0.20256617665290833,
-0.19767799973487854,
-0.5733611583709717,
0.0623183511197567,
0.12713660299777985,
-0.4656723439693451,
0.09988361597061157,
0.1585359126329422,
-0.3559344410896301,
0.37655559182167053,
0.4875129461288452,
-0.39121654629707336,
0.15125532448291779,
-0.5161489844322205,
-0.5970815420150757,
0.31244874000549316,
-0.41379719972610474,
-0.1477603167295456,
0.002892198972404003,
-0.18833370506763458,
0.17484770715236664,
0.1442512720823288,
-0.11290059238672256,
-0.07300266623497009,
-0.14828327298164368,
0.06948558986186981,
-0.056025877594947815,
0.8157863020896912,
0.22774836421012878,
-0.5572389364242554,
0.18810434639453888,
-0.524141788482666,
0.18098075687885284,
0.25472015142440796,
-0.0663347989320755,
-0.09327007830142975,
0.13512036204338074,
-0.47407954931259155,
0.3416602611541748,
0.36821699142456055,
-0.5398942828178406,
0.0426236055791378,
-0.5481067299842834,
0.3660224974155426,
0.7462894320487976,
-0.011827699840068817,
0.9075965285301208,
-0.506915807723999,
0.48316293954849243,
0.4059477150440216,
0.37873849272727966,
-0.3468327820301056,
-0.3834180235862732,
-0.8001933693885803,
0.21594518423080444,
0.06083766371011734,
0.6283403038978577,
-1.3496501445770264,
0.4594694674015045,
-0.04404865950345993,
-0.5816184878349304,
-0.7117791771888733,
0.1724596619606018,
0.6681141257286072,
0.1696704626083374,
0.5045221447944641,
-0.5980558395385742,
-0.42664170265197754,
-0.39456281065940857,
0.1847197711467743,
-0.5260753631591797,
0.18399764597415924,
0.27151724696159363,
0.17661207914352417,
0.001229502260684967,
0.8552262187004089,
-0.025446157902479172,
-0.5817100405693054,
-0.685152530670166,
0.5602806210517883,
-0.004141473677009344,
0.6321514844894409,
0.5122875571250916,
-0.7426432967185974,
-0.930046558380127,
0.252007395029068,
-0.6785770058631897,
0.07465731352567673,
-0.23397785425186157,
0.2576574981212616,
0.19253124296665192,
0.6558603048324585,
-0.47928744554519653,
0.40141478180885315,
1.1087419986724854,
-0.11970683187246323,
0.7557007074356079,
-0.5034130811691284,
0.05107424780726433,
-0.9614622592926025,
-0.1451510190963745,
-0.4963676631450653,
-0.46917057037353516,
-0.7546409368515015,
0.31475767493247986,
-0.11506012082099915,
0.10615868121385574,
-0.7561937570571899,
0.5611630082130432,
-0.9422746896743774,
-0.014796744100749493,
-0.3261669874191284,
0.4789207875728607,
-0.45641911029815674,
0.6099948287010193,
0.20631815493106842,
0.6690517067909241,
0.7973842024803162,
-0.6990645527839661,
0.31967484951019287,
0.44762688875198364,
-0.08736437559127808,
0.3923080265522003,
-0.6493677496910095,
0.4428881108760834,
-0.1453181356191635,
0.3837558925151825,
-0.7140758037567139,
-0.025748735293745995,
0.4491325318813324,
-0.8184593319892883,
0.1761891394853592,
-0.10985863953828812,
-0.13211943209171295,
-0.2639957368373871,
0.012952075339853764,
0.5271220207214355,
0.5469866394996643,
-0.49977314472198486,
0.35231247544288635,
0.27482450008392334,
0.08886121958494186,
-0.8335787057876587,
-0.4916229248046875,
-0.0025289678014814854,
0.2579760253429413,
-0.25709068775177,
0.06901124864816666,
-0.14813411235809326,
-0.1047934964299202,
0.0011346989776939154,
0.09850053489208221,
-0.2933526635169983,
0.1840193271636963,
0.12749074399471283,
-0.04800204560160637,
-0.16847990453243256,
-0.1438005417585373,
-0.160767063498497,
-0.3003082871437073,
-0.0818982720375061,
-0.3269360065460205,
0.6901730895042419,
-0.19459620118141174,
-0.32677724957466125,
-0.4687623083591461,
0.5499505996704102,
0.4855908155441284,
-0.19912408292293549,
1.0424275398254395,
0.28117889165878296,
0.18902599811553955,
-0.40709272027015686,
-0.2880660593509674,
-0.143906369805336,
-0.48861464858055115,
0.12431845813989639,
-0.2728758454322815,
-0.6164197325706482,
0.5469404458999634,
-0.33383649587631226,
-0.10730869323015213,
0.021462395787239075,
0.14751394093036652,
-0.2926948368549347,
0.774143636226654,
0.984581470489502,
-0.16281980276107788,
0.6531461477279663,
-0.23648211359977722,
0.07832062989473343,
-0.5749640464782715,
-0.150639608502388,
-0.4923168122768402,
-0.2175716906785965,
-0.32775989174842834,
-0.7226976752281189,
0.12116090953350067,
0.14174146950244904,
-0.12257519364356995,
0.7709984183311462,
0.036037202924489975,
0.6536778211593628,
0.584483802318573,
0.10550770163536072,
0.32413575053215027,
-0.16739721596240997,
-0.32731255888938904,
0.18782535195350647,
-0.9511296153068542,
-0.15598775446414948,
0.8994548916816711,
-0.03065899759531021,
0.5140385031700134,
0.28152143955230713,
1.1454713344573975,
0.0319928377866745,
0.447306752204895,
-0.7545388340950012,
0.3611598312854767,
0.10206777602434158,
-0.2730529010295868,
-0.4145936667919159,
-0.642286479473114,
-1.403738021850586,
0.06765931844711304,
-0.35779619216918945,
-0.7441123723983765,
0.3676542341709137,
0.07124944776296616,
-0.08827655762434006,
0.23693574965000153,
-0.6893864870071411,
0.612951397895813,
-0.2351241409778595,
-0.24938493967056274,
-0.3123909533023834,
-1.1567624807357788,
-0.012686623260378838,
-0.08315844088792801,
0.4138188064098358,
0.049316730350255966,
0.10607395321130753,
0.3060533106327057,
-0.17077545821666718,
1.0252654552459717,
-0.04636843129992485,
0.00966711062937975,
0.4370071291923523,
0.25664612650871277,
0.47830021381378174,
-0.39341291785240173,
-0.019906867295503616,
0.07710724323987961,
-0.031110772863030434,
-0.8991145491600037,
-0.6336489915847778,
-0.03921814262866974,
-1.1265456676483154,
-0.5170310139656067,
-0.5339037775993347,
-0.22968260943889618,
-0.10978525876998901,
0.31676021218299866,
0.4420897662639618,
0.053835466504096985,
-0.6708570122718811,
0.16405941545963287,
0.21881912648677826,
0.05423406884074211,
0.6008340120315552,
1.0813226699829102,
-0.0025197172071784735,
-0.20533901453018188,
0.9363399147987366,
-0.09289943426847458,
0.8237979412078857,
0.36247292160987854,
-0.04098247364163399,
-0.14235174655914307,
-0.6681132316589355,
-0.25582972168922424,
0.2732798159122467,
-0.38704827427864075,
-0.13960593938827515,
-0.45944350957870483,
-0.4309432804584503,
-0.4890110194683075,
-0.2601970136165619,
-0.5302189588546753,
-0.13485419750213623,
-0.19963908195495605,
0.08584769815206528,
-0.357265442609787,
0.8030481338500977,
-0.5978320837020874,
0.7632372379302979,
-1.070809245109558,
0.02788403257727623,
0.045120153576135635,
0.2910906672477722,
0.02417290396988392,
-0.1851404458284378,
-0.3773513734340668,
0.3289169669151306,
-0.35867178440093994,
-1.0747987031936646,
0.36436212062835693,
0.2942367196083069,
0.733443558216095,
0.5488726496696472,
0.3834880292415619,
0.6082851886749268,
-0.5928683280944824,
0.6100781559944153,
0.421687513589859,
-1.0256831645965576,
0.5692053437232971,
-0.18821139633655548,
0.2239847034215927,
0.6917814612388611,
0.6580394506454468,
-0.609504759311676,
-0.6752564907073975,
-1.1183570623397827,
-0.7586575150489807,
0.6948509216308594,
0.22031289339065552,
0.19747190177440643,
-0.45628681778907776,
0.17529548704624176,
-0.019011851400136948,
0.1366075873374939,
-0.7680082321166992,
-0.24029535055160522,
0.15374591946601868,
0.0012338688829913735,
-0.6758147478103638,
0.20377306640148163,
-0.12965869903564453,
-0.11311465501785278,
0.31686246395111084,
-0.12296313792467117,
0.1572408825159073,
0.42648735642433167,
-0.4021722078323364,
-0.406432181596756,
0.2890785336494446,
0.35697269439697266,
0.39376991987228394,
0.13398975133895874,
0.12723147869110107,
-0.19893188774585724,
-0.32748082280158997,
0.49495723843574524,
-0.37050995230674744,
-0.04933673143386841,
-0.19754499197006226,
0.40860188007354736,
0.69303297996521,
0.40772491693496704,
-0.5324940085411072,
0.9277839660644531,
0.04690483212471008,
-0.3128547966480255,
-0.334432452917099,
0.12059559673070908,
-0.02340303547680378,
0.32539987564086914,
0.24215450882911682,
0.21368782222270966,
-0.40777239203453064,
-0.8947572112083435,
0.4327959418296814,
0.3357815742492676,
-0.5135175585746765,
-0.7394942045211792,
0.3325697183609009,
0.4638647735118866,
-0.7536426186561584,
0.7477521896362305,
-0.4138643741607666,
-0.6061160564422607,
0.7293183207511902,
0.8640676736831665,
0.6882901191711426,
-0.6869947910308838,
0.783593475818634,
0.18802016973495483,
0.37480786442756653,
-0.20521123707294464,
0.1376807987689972,
-0.5863507390022278,
-1.1234467029571533,
-0.3050091564655304,
-0.14026254415512085,
-0.7781254649162292,
-0.23406589031219482,
-0.6701071858406067,
0.019058160483837128,
-0.3649287521839142,
0.13270409405231476,
-0.3553234934806824,
-0.019238043576478958,
-0.6813762784004211,
-0.20505082607269287,
-0.019350070506334305,
0.715999186038971,
-0.9976183176040649,
0.9416468143463135,
0.5199676156044006,
-0.5570412278175354,
-1.0121877193450928,
-0.039705790579319,
-0.17011556029319763,
-0.8735848665237427,
0.45427191257476807,
-0.13166983425617218,
-0.10815010964870453,
0.5512612462043762,
-0.7993241548538208,
-0.7096534967422485,
0.9436087608337402,
0.2938142418861389,
-0.3687385022640228,
0.005026225000619888,
0.07484505325555801,
0.5964640378952026,
-0.3923583924770355,
0.32525578141212463,
0.324693888425827,
0.28375929594039917,
0.2095605880022049,
-1.1123262643814087,
-0.400714248418808,
-0.18267500400543213,
-0.6843436360359192,
-0.01950169913470745,
-1.0052275657653809,
0.9835676550865173,
-0.5563474893569946,
-0.5651223659515381,
0.26650381088256836,
0.8333700895309448,
-0.034731119871139526,
0.37652403116226196,
0.4491511583328247,
0.05627782270312309,
0.544136106967926,
0.16179761290550232,
0.8054187297821045,
-0.21260736882686615,
0.3729693591594696,
1.4633256196975708,
-0.4358772337436676,
1.0413352251052856,
0.5526638627052307,
-0.13413524627685547,
0.7254500389099121,
0.24781545996665955,
0.3495732545852661,
0.1610252410173416,
0.022567780688405037,
-0.4634547829627991,
-0.13450473546981812,
0.05011468380689621,
-0.23994217813014984,
0.803325891494751,
0.4237746298313141,
0.033518653362989426,
-0.4971258044242859,
-0.11444294452667236,
-0.25019824504852295,
0.4139946401119232,
0.03931185603141785,
1.0499780178070068,
0.14238150417804718,
-0.6383177042007446,
0.31705135107040405,
-0.28402993083000183,
0.48360195755958557,
-0.7623620629310608,
-0.025915898382663727,
-0.29750654101371765,
0.1873111128807068,
-0.022173434495925903,
-0.4986046552658081,
0.10236658900976181,
-0.4852040708065033,
0.14732585847377777,
-0.1822742223739624,
0.24456089735031128,
-0.813781201839447,
0.1301157921552658,
0.7090336084365845,
1.105168342590332,
0.4346475601196289,
0.2631828486919403,
-0.7736536264419556,
-0.16867858171463013,
-0.3106570541858673,
0.08827507495880127,
0.4643860161304474,
0.43783849477767944,
0.029564188793301582,
0.7719583511352539,
0.6097093820571899,
0.5229538083076477,
0.15272238850593567,
-0.19346146285533905,
0.6936694383621216,
-0.3779941201210022,
-0.7198324799537659,
-0.40054890513420105,
0.19141510128974915,
-0.03687174245715141,
0.029595471918582916,
0.7688048481941223,
0.16212831437587738,
1.021828532218933,
-0.06847546994686127,
0.5204156041145325,
-0.16098979115486145,
0.13963299989700317,
-0.1814192682504654,
0.7735161185264587,
-0.17028166353702545,
-0.11135964095592499,
-0.28351911902427673,
-0.7791216373443604,
-0.20869030058383942,
0.8286730051040649,
-0.05682385340332985,
-0.14976610243320465,
0.8460509777069092,
0.46627065539360046,
0.0456201434135437,
-0.11078241467475891,
0.6066668629646301,
0.34865328669548035,
0.34682855010032654,
0.8504904508590698,
0.9278572201728821,
-0.4514031708240509,
0.5221801996231079,
-0.25769734382629395,
-0.5247128009796143,
0.13176366686820984,
-0.789218008518219,
-0.6359469294548035,
-0.7023044228553772,
-0.20188504457473755,
-0.17631796002388,
0.2269999384880066,
1.1509242057800293,
0.8196858763694763,
-0.6830089092254639,
-0.5397508144378662,
-0.375530481338501,
0.25982382893562317,
-0.5643453001976013,
-0.17634941637516022,
0.06638778746128082,
-0.8285222053527832,
-0.807914137840271,
0.7333151698112488,
0.1590377390384674,
0.44276222586631775,
-0.06980594247579575,
-0.27685824036598206,
-0.4718814194202423,
0.08178610354661942,
0.4914085566997528,
1.1465798616409302,
-0.2729869484901428,
-0.39608481526374817,
-0.21629281342029572,
0.0029336989391595125,
0.23047707974910736,
0.8141072988510132,
-0.761653482913971,
0.5276702046394348,
0.22473467886447906,
0.5335618257522583,
0.3051832616329193,
0.04771234467625618,
0.8393366932868958,
-0.9235637187957764,
0.6678634285926819,
0.1991344541311264,
-0.18976010382175446,
0.02259398065507412,
-0.2134537249803543,
0.18541035056114197,
0.3554849624633789,
-0.47449859976768494,
-0.5167771577835083,
0.378156453371048,
-0.9206122756004333,
-0.1368437260389328,
0.8306609392166138,
-0.5166016221046448,
-0.5714778304100037,
-0.6084949970245361,
0.013932816684246063,
0.490422785282135,
-0.16182951629161835,
0.8497282266616821,
0.5081761479377747,
0.014159727841615677,
-0.26402947306632996,
-0.09502299129962921,
0.48115116357803345,
0.5431473851203918,
-0.587821900844574,
-0.09284351766109467,
0.12415547668933868,
0.2042551338672638,
0.3311639130115509,
1.1949362754821777,
-0.11425674706697464,
0.4310668110847473,
0.25312185287475586,
0.07924596965312958,
0.08643605560064316,
-0.6531533002853394,
-0.1738085001707077,
-0.05952920392155647,
0.04448787495493889,
-0.2810526192188263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04770v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04770v1
|
Social Orientation: A New Feature for Dialogue Analysis
| 2024-02-26T01:55:45 | 2024-02-26T01:55:45 |
Todd Morrill, Zhaoyuan Deng, Yanda Chen, Amith Ananthram, Colin Wayne Leach, Kathleen McKeown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
There are many settings where it is useful to predict and explain the success
or failure of a dialogue. Circumplex theory from psychology models the social
orientations (e.g., Warm-Agreeable, Arrogant-Calculating) of conversation
participants and can be used to predict and explain the outcome of social
interactions. Our work is novel in its systematic application of social
orientation tags to modeling conversation outcomes. In this paper, we introduce
a new data set of dialogue utterances machine-labeled with social orientation
tags. We show that social orientation tags improve task performance, especially
in low-resource settings, on both English and Chinese language benchmarks. We
also demonstrate how social orientation tags help explain the outcomes of
social interactions when used in neural models. Based on these results showing
the utility of social orientation tags for dialogue outcome prediction tasks,
we release our data sets, code, and models that are fine-tuned to predict
social orientation tags on dialogue utterances.
|
[
-0.28755101561546326,
-0.5581051111221313,
0.5468245148658752,
0.634730339050293,
-0.19358126819133759,
0.3788597285747528,
-0.3442196846008301,
-0.26060909032821655,
0.7376583218574524,
0.25570908188819885,
-0.4184965193271637,
-0.7309650182723999,
-0.5138127207756042,
-0.305428147315979,
-0.16549716889858246,
0.9859138131141663,
0.3094765841960907,
0.3358166515827179,
-0.2840069830417633,
-0.37327471375465393,
-0.33809715509414673,
-0.7806533575057983,
-0.8783562779426575,
-0.5769935846328735,
0.7147719264030457,
0.48717200756073,
0.8651998043060303,
0.5492193698883057,
0.3804726302623749,
0.3652658760547638,
-0.26185014843940735,
-0.15513072907924652,
-0.39966338872909546,
0.0689067393541336,
0.052216436713933945,
-0.4407806694507599,
-0.8195926547050476,
0.13403761386871338,
0.6953837871551514,
0.8956128358840942,
-0.3201213479042053,
0.08824752271175385,
0.44124212861061096,
0.620311975479126,
-0.1922321915626526,
0.29834964871406555,
-0.4250771403312683,
-0.07568123936653137,
-0.024659691378474236,
-0.2590492069721222,
-0.1509605050086975,
-0.6139243841171265,
0.3740624487400055,
-0.30265098810195923,
0.29889771342277527,
0.03761539235711098,
0.5439561009407043,
-0.13651227951049805,
-0.2625093162059784,
-0.14531703293323517,
-0.7943572402000427,
0.6672993898391724,
-0.5480940341949463,
0.168216273188591,
0.2908022403717041,
0.3893815875053406,
-0.23407377302646637,
-0.22929511964321136,
-0.5211939215660095,
0.08191434293985367,
-0.11748971045017242,
-0.0801006555557251,
0.26121753454208374,
0.3100799024105072,
0.08320757746696472,
0.0881289392709732,
-0.32099777460098267,
-0.14029060304164886,
-0.22227755188941956,
-0.05749955028295517,
0.8172828555107117,
0.2883104383945465,
0.2873791456222534,
-0.2617911994457245,
-0.30107712745666504,
0.013376913964748383,
-0.21618063747882843,
0.41837653517723083,
0.3093678057193756,
0.29136762022972107,
-0.49678748846054077,
0.336140900850296,
-0.45149293541908264,
0.21969236433506012,
0.26359236240386963,
-0.33360522985458374,
0.34959548711776733,
-0.33767643570899963,
0.043529558926820755,
0.222764253616333,
0.6278243064880371,
0.8831937909126282,
0.19237083196640015,
-0.009393278509378433,
0.19919410347938538,
0.2541026771068573,
-0.10457921773195267,
-0.505531370639801,
-0.3131343424320221,
0.19256873428821564,
-0.7159128189086914,
-0.54890376329422,
-0.28506267070770264,
-0.7034001350402832,
-0.7290699481964111,
-0.360932320356369,
-0.23403282463550568,
-0.4973069429397583,
-0.6553846597671509,
0.0898103341460228,
-0.48709431290626526,
0.6766572594642639,
0.5305796265602112,
-0.6770732402801514,
0.25440463423728943,
1.0867732763290405,
0.9991897940635681,
-0.13795137405395508,
-0.12615486979484558,
-0.4704669117927551,
-0.031205803155899048,
0.04995322600007057,
0.7616316676139832,
-0.8675029277801514,
-0.42578214406967163,
0.19513261318206787,
0.22721520066261292,
-0.0004966224078088999,
0.09789945930242538,
0.31027641892433167,
-0.03427688777446747,
-0.05343351513147354,
-0.34677383303642273,
-0.24367550015449524,
-0.19958645105361938,
0.18780717253684998,
-0.40689289569854736,
0.5537903904914856,
-0.08951574563980103,
-0.5902419090270996,
0.2821558713912964,
-0.6710099577903748,
-0.4051024913787842,
0.49185484647750854,
-0.3078629672527313,
-0.12213952094316483,
0.24456894397735596,
-0.5010241866111755,
0.45375531911849976,
-0.19983994960784912,
0.3786749243736267,
-0.7582374811172485,
-0.23825235664844513,
0.6286363005638123,
-0.13545653223991394,
0.8438511490821838,
0.10086794197559357,
-0.2230452299118042,
-0.07907171547412872,
-0.6827202439308167,
0.18445734679698944,
-0.12058727443218231,
-0.19163255393505096,
-0.5496760606765747,
0.4868904948234558,
-0.1734660118818283,
-0.04316980391740799,
0.33894360065460205,
-0.6649574041366577,
-0.1447405219078064,
-0.18393510580062866,
0.35168588161468506,
0.6989781260490417,
-0.27563124895095825,
0.7853818535804749,
-0.19555456936359406,
0.5806393027305603,
-0.19953112304210663,
0.2832522392272949,
0.11119918525218964,
-0.728900134563446,
-0.5740864276885986,
-0.11266832053661346,
0.05382511019706726,
0.46423834562301636,
-0.8609799146652222,
0.31912994384765625,
-0.2049129158258438,
-0.7346237897872925,
-0.37055233120918274,
0.05486264452338219,
0.6877822279930115,
0.1867235153913498,
-0.20004115998744965,
-0.7349932193756104,
-0.4486570954322815,
-0.7705957293510437,
-0.5577205419540405,
-0.48239007592201233,
0.05488501489162445,
0.44734740257263184,
-0.15097187459468842,
-0.1255108267068863,
0.7721614241600037,
-0.47097885608673096,
0.06573383510112762,
-0.624083936214447,
0.40197914838790894,
0.13797302544116974,
0.48575854301452637,
0.38802704215049744,
-0.7874229550361633,
-0.5985480546951294,
0.09351466596126556,
-0.5804420709609985,
-0.01608482003211975,
0.17374448478221893,
-0.3876184821128845,
0.16167780756950378,
0.24802149832248688,
-0.3444623649120331,
0.5633082389831543,
0.5342932939529419,
-0.3414972722530365,
0.33610236644744873,
0.1040024682879448,
-0.039461810141801834,
-0.9587974548339844,
-0.39866432547569275,
0.5894644856452942,
-0.0441221222281456,
-0.9787513613700867,
-0.46476611495018005,
-0.21545125544071198,
-0.12099163234233856,
-0.5747994184494019,
0.33990707993507385,
-0.26549726724624634,
-0.036321137100458145,
-0.11499903351068497,
0.18631164729595184,
0.08842727541923523,
0.8481467962265015,
0.36099711060523987,
0.2618557810783386,
0.20491540431976318,
-0.42516666650772095,
0.24310298264026642,
0.18741096556186676,
-0.42450183629989624,
0.7399039268493652,
-0.658517062664032,
0.4302141070365906,
-0.46673089265823364,
0.08923586457967758,
-1.4670205116271973,
-0.3193747103214264,
0.20154395699501038,
-0.7735487222671509,
0.2584574818611145,
-0.30193647742271423,
-0.009637923911213875,
0.0480082705616951,
-0.5037856698036194,
0.43136608600616455,
0.4249626696109772,
-0.26848769187927246,
0.6431581974029541,
0.6702299118041992,
-0.4125528931617737,
-0.3592432141304016,
-0.19042259454727173,
-0.37166738510131836,
-0.5276683568954468,
-0.7211502194404602,
0.07788466662168503,
-0.1103580892086029,
-0.36552560329437256,
-0.495748370885849,
0.2722287178039551,
-0.054987650364637375,
0.39184772968292236,
0.43257683515548706,
0.5669921636581421,
-0.12884460389614105,
-0.19868837296962738,
-0.13890594244003296,
-0.12621797621250153,
0.25935277342796326,
0.19822919368743896,
0.8390742540359497,
-0.2508825361728668,
0.04673905298113823,
-0.45751670002937317,
0.49245452880859375,
0.3204021751880646,
-0.0388178676366806,
0.7738192081451416,
0.503875195980072,
-0.16547183692455292,
0.3451904356479645,
-0.44158950448036194,
0.25363659858703613,
-0.5551732182502747,
0.405327171087265,
-0.09101566672325134,
-0.7233853936195374,
0.4594849646091461,
-0.06625957787036896,
-0.038603659719228745,
-0.13903330266475677,
0.2725829780101776,
-0.5504810214042664,
1.483237624168396,
0.9423109292984009,
-0.0269162580370903,
0.9153695106506348,
0.016806768253445625,
0.5312871932983398,
-1.0298722982406616,
-0.2802393436431885,
-0.6425613760948181,
-0.46823564171791077,
-0.9555363655090332,
-0.22160588204860687,
0.45053133368492126,
0.03668871521949768,
-0.026269106194376945,
0.2517722547054291,
-0.76258385181427,
0.3969978392124176,
0.45628035068511963,
-0.05761146545410156,
0.09093644469976425,
0.14819467067718506,
0.35620811581611633,
-0.1603253185749054,
-0.4132464528083801,
-0.5869640707969666,
0.7733690738677979,
0.5506494045257568,
0.7649545073509216,
0.179016575217247,
0.734804093837738,
0.2368653416633606,
0.5430867075920105,
-0.8523174524307251,
0.7689176797866821,
0.018945449963212013,
-0.3871115446090698,
-0.3324950039386749,
-0.044172514230012894,
-0.7875396013259888,
0.05047330632805824,
-0.10604619234800339,
-1.172655701637268,
0.5502380728721619,
0.18469606339931488,
-0.4569549858570099,
-0.2496335506439209,
-1.0010827779769897,
0.7109348773956299,
-0.2455170899629593,
-0.2559957802295685,
-0.010440299287438393,
-0.6971232891082764,
0.1610090285539627,
0.42456290125846863,
0.14478527009487152,
-0.48826074600219727,
0.3301946222782135,
0.9818148612976074,
-0.02043256349861622,
1.1406675577163696,
-0.42084166407585144,
0.17012043297290802,
0.27182283997535706,
-0.023781098425388336,
0.26018720865249634,
0.08956069499254227,
-0.14485985040664673,
0.5363407731056213,
0.3175392150878906,
-0.2795063853263855,
-0.6944333910942078,
0.5350400805473328,
-0.7806087732315063,
-0.7332432270050049,
-0.5144728422164917,
-0.4219251871109009,
-0.03551405668258667,
-0.16142678260803223,
0.0914117619395256,
0.48005351424217224,
-0.3705950677394867,
0.22815310955047607,
0.4703415632247925,
-0.3200713098049164,
0.3952186107635498,
0.4987722635269165,
-0.2574237883090973,
-0.5089259743690491,
1.120801329612732,
0.16061219573020935,
0.4373137950897217,
-0.10393837094306946,
0.11571069806814194,
-0.15683135390281677,
-0.32880887389183044,
0.022036761045455933,
0.396748811006546,
-0.6035791635513306,
-0.08951251953840256,
-0.6289334893226624,
-0.27689194679260254,
-0.5823895931243896,
-0.3298519253730774,
-0.13453517854213715,
-0.6172913312911987,
0.24969035387039185,
0.04026895388960838,
0.19383396208286285,
0.4563913643360138,
0.0690089613199234,
0.7553482055664062,
-0.4853120744228363,
-0.07268789410591125,
0.017642712220549583,
0.3802579343318939,
-0.08014579862356186,
-0.09158699959516525,
-0.48808011412620544,
0.28295063972473145,
-0.6095584630966187,
-0.9697024822235107,
0.5888672471046448,
0.034660134464502335,
0.3275633454322815,
0.4971698820590973,
0.055364590138196945,
0.4881463646888733,
-0.30771034955978394,
0.6608633399009705,
0.36017459630966187,
-0.8174291253089905,
0.5308005213737488,
-0.4090637266635895,
0.07417323440313339,
0.508767306804657,
0.43249720335006714,
-0.8774218559265137,
-0.33304041624069214,
-0.7644526958465576,
-0.6636225581169128,
0.9005895256996155,
0.1153765320777893,
0.12313135713338852,
-0.10679727792739868,
0.4193779528141022,
-0.05872014909982681,
0.4702225923538208,
-0.44873034954071045,
-0.41578158736228943,
-0.12732505798339844,
-0.2614319622516632,
-0.2270527482032776,
-0.5313352942466736,
-0.3242294490337372,
-0.44786906242370605,
0.46729934215545654,
-0.26592984795570374,
0.7508761286735535,
-0.025917716324329376,
0.24793241918087006,
-0.08752621710300446,
0.30409836769104004,
0.23790903389453888,
0.4251788258552551,
-0.44884929060935974,
-0.024434413760900497,
-0.07652829587459564,
-0.3241567015647888,
0.10740308463573456,
-0.06415853649377823,
0.06740836799144745,
0.11498762667179108,
-0.04226391017436981,
0.5745776295661926,
-0.04720766842365265,
-0.10183253884315491,
0.43497851490974426,
-0.4183546006679535,
0.11683468520641327,
-0.7205036878585815,
0.35935360193252563,
0.12393859773874283,
0.36233261227607727,
-0.02588680200278759,
-0.014421187341213226,
0.35862550139427185,
-0.8559125065803528,
-0.2723529636859894,
0.6997637152671814,
-0.4641541838645935,
-0.615180492401123,
0.3215273916721344,
0.6369688510894775,
-1.0853022336959839,
0.3046165406703949,
-0.29256659746170044,
-0.7311598658561707,
0.7551057934761047,
0.40799057483673096,
1.093705415725708,
-0.4383816421031952,
0.65345299243927,
0.15012212097644806,
-0.1244291216135025,
0.24823465943336487,
0.4214927852153778,
-0.4873695373535156,
-1.085966944694519,
-0.2167910933494568,
-0.6391533017158508,
-0.5951180458068848,
-0.16625072062015533,
-0.9376174807548523,
0.35743555426597595,
-0.6015416979789734,
-0.28236207365989685,
0.46222802996635437,
-0.05490542948246002,
-0.699309766292572,
-0.151910662651062,
0.5158374905586243,
0.5876664519309998,
-0.8696576952934265,
0.8875909447669983,
0.7446408271789551,
0.09212850034236908,
-0.6166155338287354,
-0.15929923951625824,
0.1916806995868683,
-0.8709205985069275,
0.4687664806842804,
0.43389609456062317,
-0.3652808666229248,
-0.3023393750190735,
-0.8128750920295715,
-0.9890927076339722,
0.9246333241462708,
0.05413789674639702,
-0.2909446954727173,
-0.19148029386997223,
0.3915629982948303,
0.6688698530197144,
-0.7538877129554749,
0.4068251848220825,
0.8759580850601196,
0.2621555030345917,
0.11309022456407547,
-0.7265118360519409,
-0.06957141309976578,
-0.5567495822906494,
0.40153661370277405,
0.013528980314731598,
-0.9140229225158691,
0.5427500605583191,
0.0813203826546669,
-0.3115917444229126,
0.13943015038967133,
0.7257035374641418,
0.23963992297649384,
0.963378369808197,
0.6014732122421265,
-0.17472802102565765,
0.5764911770820618,
-0.3814299702644348,
0.9804103374481201,
-0.351801335811615,
0.17484457790851593,
1.052223563194275,
-0.4914591312408447,
0.5044375061988831,
0.3450368344783783,
0.005763482768088579,
0.6606351733207703,
0.37070074677467346,
0.5156150460243225,
0.39001521468162537,
-0.1517208069562912,
-0.35933423042297363,
-0.3112603425979614,
-0.45804914832115173,
-0.16908703744411469,
0.5776711106300354,
0.7212774157524109,
-0.2610781192779541,
0.297357439994812,
-0.12415061146020889,
0.25872817635536194,
-0.01280185952782631,
-0.08818431198596954,
1.014930248260498,
0.0589631013572216,
-0.7634456157684326,
0.4067947268486023,
-0.11851709336042404,
0.5729833841323853,
-0.2612329125404358,
-0.1371796876192093,
-0.20825327932834625,
0.272623211145401,
-0.3454376757144928,
-0.9059597253799438,
0.26514559984207153,
-0.4116605818271637,
-0.19733580946922302,
-0.09944355487823486,
0.8715759515762329,
-0.5573258399963379,
-0.4128352105617523,
0.35497260093688965,
0.26033133268356323,
0.2652425169944763,
0.12194667011499405,
-0.6382951736450195,
0.0960027202963829,
0.16739515960216522,
0.09317068010568619,
0.4590813219547272,
0.7130062580108643,
-0.04610714316368103,
0.5192861557006836,
0.43667280673980713,
-0.04946877062320709,
-0.12069357186555862,
-0.1763344705104828,
0.8227039575576782,
-0.8405879735946655,
-0.5346865057945251,
-0.6926959156990051,
0.581754744052887,
-0.5010240077972412,
-0.18919368088245392,
0.6902152299880981,
0.22992154955863953,
0.5853127241134644,
0.47440221905708313,
0.8681788444519043,
-0.1769820600748062,
0.4764772653579712,
0.028360826894640923,
0.5243901014328003,
-0.26883065700531006,
0.15803903341293335,
-0.4974044859409332,
-0.7710940837860107,
0.2602595388889313,
0.6560530066490173,
-0.7156882286071777,
-0.2469789981842041,
0.5480496287345886,
0.7680760622024536,
0.29820486903190613,
0.4340415596961975,
0.18524424731731415,
-0.01734786666929722,
0.3904285728931427,
0.38685503602027893,
1.0716674327850342,
-0.08269234001636505,
0.2600313425064087,
-0.6262626647949219,
-0.523792564868927,
-0.2441299706697464,
-0.5706291794776917,
-1.0752863883972168,
-0.6936190724372864,
-0.44849130511283875,
-0.8274475336074829,
-0.03315184265375137,
1.006970763206482,
0.5126439332962036,
-0.3407481014728546,
-0.5518761277198792,
0.3910433351993561,
0.40807631611824036,
-0.19275210797786713,
-0.2988417446613312,
-0.1527237445116043,
-0.3253624141216278,
-0.6686562895774841,
-0.03173064813017845,
0.35142579674720764,
-0.1377280056476593,
-0.14634637534618378,
-0.33979251980781555,
-0.03929440677165985,
0.1510303020477295,
0.5859859585762024,
0.3034095764160156,
-0.326463520526886,
-0.4927249848842621,
-0.03433331102132797,
0.059750746935606,
0.38316839933395386,
0.8668667078018188,
-0.43024104833602905,
0.41007667779922485,
0.3724919259548187,
0.05557284131646156,
0.21885114908218384,
0.1898273378610611,
0.9557427763938904,
-0.503084659576416,
0.3162544071674347,
0.003968956880271435,
0.34709030389785767,
0.40747272968292236,
-0.6043165326118469,
0.46542903780937195,
0.11613636463880539,
-0.5590437650680542,
-0.842013418674469,
0.13626518845558167,
-1.084824562072754,
0.36735543608665466,
1.307865023612976,
-0.14835941791534424,
-0.7808616757392883,
-0.32454726099967957,
-0.2862575054168701,
0.3412673771381378,
-0.7143287658691406,
0.8138934373855591,
0.8457395434379578,
-0.2620113790035248,
-0.11539536714553833,
-0.2608313262462616,
0.7209158539772034,
0.6282880306243896,
-0.3492623567581177,
0.06230280548334122,
0.3203827738761902,
0.21127155423164368,
0.5350367426872253,
0.8968506455421448,
0.005549274384975433,
0.37738069891929626,
-0.46089303493499756,
0.18047118186950684,
0.5177881717681885,
-0.17736637592315674,
-0.27517417073249817,
0.06120583415031433,
0.16274845600128174,
-0.3449608385562897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00815v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00815v2
|
RAM-EHR: Retrieval Augmentation Meets Clinical Predictions on Electronic Health Records
| 2024-02-25T23:10:20 | 2024-06-04T05:11:19 |
Ran Xu, Wenqi Shi, Yue Yu, Yuchen Zhuang, Bowen Jin, May D. Wang, Joyce C. Ho, Carl Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, q-bio.OT
|
We present RAM-EHR, a Retrieval AugMentation pipeline to improve clinical
predictions on Electronic Health Records (EHRs). RAM-EHR first collects
multiple knowledge sources, converts them into text format, and uses dense
retrieval to obtain information related to medical concepts. This strategy
addresses the difficulties associated with complex names for the concepts.
RAM-EHR then augments the local EHR predictive model co-trained with
consistency regularization to capture complementary information from patient
visits and summarized knowledge. Experiments on two EHR datasets show the
efficacy of RAM-EHR over previous knowledge-enhanced baselines (3.4% gain in
AUROC and 7.2% gain in AUPR), emphasizing the effectiveness of the summarized
knowledge from RAM-EHR for clinical prediction tasks. The code will be
published at \url{https://github.com/ritaranx/RAM-EHR}.
|
[
-0.025599978864192963,
-0.5712621808052063,
0.7511353492736816,
-0.23232734203338623,
-0.09397455304861069,
0.0999794751405716,
-0.006939416751265526,
-0.6886441111564636,
0.4242909252643585,
0.6254810094833374,
-0.25819358229637146,
-0.5146163702011108,
-0.5257320404052734,
-0.24060674011707306,
-0.20619556307792664,
1.2340843677520752,
0.0352323055267334,
0.37955179810523987,
-0.14947998523712158,
-0.05291417986154556,
-0.9041303396224976,
-0.5326206088066101,
-0.6141319274902344,
-0.5122958421707153,
0.6698237061500549,
0.48262840509414673,
0.5912871360778809,
0.8702590465545654,
1.1658706665039062,
0.16619367897510529,
0.26986244320869446,
0.2583937644958496,
-0.41657090187072754,
0.3763776421546936,
0.26471102237701416,
-0.372848778963089,
-0.8305779695510864,
-0.7418619394302368,
0.476676344871521,
0.5178197622299194,
-0.6530061364173889,
0.13746154308319092,
-0.42291978001594543,
0.8297415375709534,
-0.8154728412628174,
0.13974173367023468,
-0.6656937599182129,
0.001744886627420783,
-0.21682412922382355,
-0.6227845549583435,
-0.272071897983551,
-0.23034101724624634,
0.29314520955085754,
-0.540212869644165,
0.42936623096466064,
0.2850976884365082,
0.8094703555107117,
0.44122350215911865,
-0.2570699155330658,
-0.009244694374501705,
-0.9135774374008179,
0.6666378974914551,
-0.201759472489357,
0.6889814734458923,
0.594700813293457,
0.9023261666297913,
0.3032371997833252,
-1.0377737283706665,
-0.1818564534187317,
-0.2023838758468628,
-0.21693436801433563,
0.33478379249572754,
-0.09605252742767334,
0.3032211363315582,
0.30284571647644043,
0.514751136302948,
-0.5548220276832581,
-0.2378588169813156,
-0.8074227571487427,
-0.15223786234855652,
0.6122785806655884,
0.4124581515789032,
0.2163878083229065,
0.10634110867977142,
-0.39305049180984497,
0.025685615837574005,
-0.6603925228118896,
-0.2815660834312439,
-0.37242764234542847,
0.057118237018585205,
0.14010708034038544,
0.5511652827262878,
-0.16498927772045135,
0.5930373072624207,
0.34595799446105957,
-0.1504126638174057,
0.5681138038635254,
-0.19756485521793365,
-0.13635799288749695,
0.5917256474494934,
0.3190808594226837,
0.373025506734848,
-0.3890989124774933,
-0.02157744951546192,
-0.4125438630580902,
0.23058786988258362,
0.5453485250473022,
-0.822007417678833,
-0.5748622417449951,
0.3021553158760071,
-0.5536391139030457,
-0.025271372869610786,
0.10698763281106949,
-0.5799824595451355,
-0.4316960871219635,
-0.19903720915317535,
0.8410720229148865,
-0.6710940003395081,
0.14278139173984528,
0.36656108498573303,
-0.2690204679965973,
-0.08083537220954895,
0.6747792363166809,
-0.7171273827552795,
0.7456815242767334,
0.8237380385398865,
0.5728603005409241,
-0.14458589255809784,
0.07662727683782578,
-0.8000199198722839,
0.3727048635482788,
0.0244763046503067,
0.7137443423271179,
-0.45400089025497437,
-0.3611609637737274,
-0.166498601436615,
-0.34443238377571106,
0.13388295471668243,
-0.8131054639816284,
0.6026570796966553,
-0.6695965528488159,
0.041744694113731384,
-0.06065187603235245,
-0.772277295589447,
0.005838478449732065,
0.17710313200950623,
-0.9149186015129089,
0.5476284623146057,
0.011739869602024555,
-0.6827031373977661,
0.5149548053741455,
-0.5276538729667664,
-0.4307471215724945,
0.22956310212612152,
-0.3382604122161865,
-0.5258526802062988,
-0.15347826480865479,
0.13215045630931854,
0.2633098065853119,
-0.3067151606082916,
0.12518253922462463,
-0.03951052203774452,
-0.2796182632446289,
0.0796944722533226,
-0.01900065690279007,
0.09378955513238907,
0.41845935583114624,
0.31332191824913025,
-0.016512012109160423,
-0.6664806604385376,
0.0050398060120642185,
-0.1947614550590515,
-0.2914216220378876,
-0.4052245616912842,
-0.03071659244596958,
-0.020474212244153023,
0.01253290381282568,
0.3809286653995514,
-0.6510180830955505,
-0.23139914870262146,
-0.06389536708593369,
-0.12501953542232513,
0.2560829222202301,
0.20263077318668365,
0.24019445478916168,
-0.905748188495636,
0.5420111417770386,
0.2033732682466507,
0.3182262182235718,
-0.4650951623916626,
-0.6374454498291016,
-0.28735944628715515,
-0.43721699714660645,
0.48854508996009827,
0.745223879814148,
-0.20430317521095276,
0.3641972243785858,
-0.5472272038459778,
-0.4143002927303314,
-0.9624682664871216,
-0.12210605293512344,
0.3708456754684448,
1.0020779371261597,
0.8671823740005493,
-0.5619103312492371,
-0.8884364366531372,
-0.80081707239151,
-0.11486011743545532,
-0.3228769600391388,
-0.11430200189352036,
0.28920164704322815,
0.1653745174407959,
-0.44185927510261536,
0.5601881742477417,
-0.7241214513778687,
-0.7498990893363953,
-0.24015440046787262,
0.12229862064123154,
0.17927074432373047,
0.5989289879798889,
0.012720232829451561,
-0.8753337860107422,
-0.5296201705932617,
0.2341345101594925,
-0.5744119882583618,
0.16576047241687775,
0.1168791875243187,
0.13270221650600433,
-0.3176259994506836,
0.0869741290807724,
-0.6209044456481934,
0.528775691986084,
-0.0334947369992733,
0.06249861419200897,
0.4183655083179474,
-0.4923138916492462,
0.41260939836502075,
-0.9993677735328674,
-0.04110191762447357,
-0.13534972071647644,
-0.2775936722755432,
-0.6488286256790161,
-0.10768496245145798,
0.2205689400434494,
0.13671371340751648,
-0.061974260956048965,
0.5425706505775452,
-0.360981822013855,
0.10708322376012802,
-0.03364284336566925,
-0.034990739077329636,
0.12892746925354004,
-0.30966299772262573,
0.07249314337968826,
0.6073159575462341,
0.45443445444107056,
-0.46760278940200806,
0.268784761428833,
0.5381582379341125,
-0.24948593974113464,
0.5808321237564087,
-0.6883233189582825,
-0.001038379967212677,
-0.3617803156375885,
0.19360238313674927,
-0.553639829158783,
-0.44871827960014343,
-0.22361740469932556,
-0.6979746222496033,
0.5962876081466675,
-0.05679137259721756,
-0.2865162193775177,
-0.4709247648715973,
-0.24399225413799286,
0.35159507393836975,
0.8632330894470215,
-0.31849247217178345,
0.5686946511268616,
0.7049036622047424,
-0.11247487366199493,
-0.7274653315544128,
-0.8745121359825134,
-0.06375925242900848,
-0.030468445271253586,
-0.3654297888278961,
0.8211873173713684,
-0.07450833916664124,
-0.38770872354507446,
0.20025786757469177,
-0.08112825453281403,
-0.5922659635543823,
-0.3274724781513214,
0.2238929718732834,
0.6480439305305481,
-0.4616507589817047,
0.43234625458717346,
0.0996447280049324,
-0.18337686359882355,
0.0935005322098732,
-0.18418706953525543,
0.23266582190990448,
0.028624016791582108,
-0.5468481183052063,
-0.6078757643699646,
0.28422975540161133,
0.24672038853168488,
-0.09359388053417206,
0.6403422951698303,
0.5468934774398804,
-0.8865635395050049,
0.34003332257270813,
-1.036716103553772,
-0.5671406984329224,
-0.3991382122039795,
0.43665724992752075,
-0.17272703349590302,
-0.8477413654327393,
0.5790395140647888,
0.06634066253900528,
-0.06627070158720016,
0.44399505853652954,
0.3148678243160248,
-0.07954013347625732,
1.3498471975326538,
0.44739893078804016,
0.1154063269495964,
0.2919185161590576,
-0.15508195757865906,
-0.13682931661605835,
-1.0292162895202637,
-0.49221935868263245,
-0.29649990797042847,
-0.2275456041097641,
-0.49665871262550354,
-0.48588648438453674,
0.7701157331466675,
0.017078159376978874,
-0.27955877780914307,
0.2610678970813751,
-0.4183923602104187,
0.24214239418506622,
0.13806770741939545,
0.7375063300132751,
0.5803974866867065,
-0.014597264118492603,
0.0651683509349823,
-0.305122435092926,
-0.5487219095230103,
-0.10367589443922043,
1.3895807266235352,
0.22990138828754425,
0.6988894939422607,
-0.01605144515633583,
0.8957160115242004,
0.3546115458011627,
0.4808833599090576,
-0.6767637729644775,
0.13792365789413452,
-0.05139598622918129,
-0.6855472922325134,
0.00778696034103632,
-0.39617985486984253,
-1.1452929973602295,
-0.06695936620235443,
-0.35990530252456665,
-0.5826308131217957,
0.02115362510085106,
0.34131455421447754,
-0.8023889660835266,
0.21880997717380524,
-0.4966833293437958,
0.6512712836265564,
-0.3248770534992218,
-0.28766930103302,
-0.6707146167755127,
-0.9911731481552124,
0.17757633328437805,
-0.29191625118255615,
0.13071691989898682,
0.16644813120365143,
-0.2775050699710846,
0.4653753340244293,
-0.67057204246521,
0.27820268273353577,
0.04248890280723572,
0.5496067404747009,
0.12961216270923615,
-0.14709649980068207,
0.378275066614151,
0.05284116044640541,
-0.34652256965637207,
-0.15890049934387207,
0.14266268908977509,
-0.30118095874786377,
-0.8435237407684326,
0.492240846157074,
-0.5731258392333984,
-0.293279767036438,
-0.36348089575767517,
-0.49562638998031616,
-0.26169443130493164,
0.2600073516368866,
0.04057255759835243,
0.5271844267845154,
-0.31871888041496277,
0.21981768310070038,
0.8678168058395386,
0.07773319631814957,
-0.5052853226661682,
0.5641408562660217,
-0.35906311869621277,
-0.748624324798584,
0.7819758653640747,
0.10385684669017792,
0.10908926278352737,
0.9621583223342896,
0.18258138000965118,
-0.3838098347187042,
-0.6330690383911133,
-0.3538287878036499,
0.31592053174972534,
-0.5516296625137329,
-0.4265657365322113,
-0.710558295249939,
-0.3673071563243866,
-0.29020461440086365,
0.08440874516963959,
-0.13207580149173737,
-0.4320802092552185,
-0.4083859622478485,
-0.21967056393623352,
0.6574576497077942,
0.8529953956604004,
-0.10726199299097061,
0.41547447443008423,
-1.2281001806259155,
0.33595094084739685,
0.08649671822786331,
0.19900107383728027,
-0.2674349546432495,
-0.6424562931060791,
-0.4316534101963043,
-0.14688140153884888,
-0.4305349588394165,
-0.8055064082145691,
0.610495924949646,
0.15039125084877014,
0.443092405796051,
0.5832039713859558,
-0.022397560998797417,
1.1284165382385254,
-0.8365870118141174,
0.395739883184433,
0.42328259348869324,
-0.26798900961875916,
0.827628493309021,
-0.2980448603630066,
-0.10377218574285507,
0.874946653842926,
0.435029536485672,
-0.28089794516563416,
0.06899170577526093,
-0.8501588106155396,
-0.788516104221344,
0.1775454431772232,
-0.15267276763916016,
-0.12210244685411453,
-0.10730952024459839,
0.6068106293678284,
0.2913074493408203,
0.3886701464653015,
0.2017437368631363,
-0.40711668133735657,
0.18753758072853088,
-0.4026557505130768,
0.0037387246266007423,
-0.10373475402593613,
-0.029248351231217384,
-0.4414021968841553,
0.46525120735168457,
0.19789984822273254,
0.415022611618042,
0.5291237235069275,
-0.06583767384290695,
-0.4562247097492218,
0.15403485298156738,
0.19687627255916595,
0.7341105341911316,
-0.5215427875518799,
0.1172628179192543,
0.31721216440200806,
-0.8521174192428589,
-0.35100671648979187,
0.31944918632507324,
-0.13760744035243988,
0.18218842148780823,
-0.06540032476186752,
0.8204387426376343,
0.18317370116710663,
-0.7006280422210693,
0.32784709334373474,
-0.0359472818672657,
0.1432410478591919,
-0.5614854097366333,
-0.04752670228481293,
-0.3720821440219879,
0.07590315490961075,
0.4750487804412842,
0.399556040763855,
0.5691810250282288,
-0.28567007184028625,
0.6908773183822632,
0.28534770011901855,
-0.6558809876441956,
-0.40852707624435425,
0.9521852135658264,
-0.2739793062210083,
-0.23420748114585876,
0.46575114130973816,
0.19745951890945435,
-0.2571829557418823,
0.4359804093837738,
0.7921873927116394,
0.5947009921073914,
-0.3545965552330017,
-0.04838842153549194,
0.4951664209365845,
-0.03462275117635727,
-0.46109315752983093,
0.5269469618797302,
0.1028706505894661,
-0.5173713564872742,
-0.4337322413921356,
-0.30013176798820496,
-0.6967936754226685,
0.0011967492755502462,
-0.9798518419265747,
0.6246766448020935,
-0.4336729347705841,
-0.5032918453216553,
-0.2049999088048935,
0.04137769713997841,
-0.644923985004425,
0.2986484467983246,
0.06675201654434204,
0.9633249640464783,
-0.34056276082992554,
0.7571183443069458,
0.8342654705047607,
-0.5091527700424194,
-0.7960295677185059,
-0.004457101691514254,
0.04861871898174286,
-0.743342399597168,
0.5946168899536133,
0.14538393914699554,
0.16408184170722961,
0.008918991312384605,
-0.09316614270210266,
-0.8392492532730103,
1.409899115562439,
0.1940518617630005,
-0.41239914298057556,
0.10551908612251282,
-0.12654928863048553,
0.7165436148643494,
-0.3017410337924957,
0.5069553256034851,
0.323928564786911,
0.40592697262763977,
0.11553922295570374,
-1.1453882455825806,
-0.025151241570711136,
-0.1446853131055832,
-0.3134056031703949,
0.31068554520606995,
-0.36821210384368896,
0.7285287380218506,
-0.6733943223953247,
0.06295771896839142,
0.18332403898239136,
0.7747926712036133,
0.4789917767047882,
0.6805368661880493,
0.0927153155207634,
0.8638646006584167,
1.1709073781967163,
0.041252799332141876,
1.343679428100586,
-0.38515955209732056,
0.09442087262868881,
1.0830128192901611,
-0.43750789761543274,
1.1133259534835815,
0.41591301560401917,
-0.29068639874458313,
0.7163809537887573,
0.41974157094955444,
0.2517448365688324,
0.6168784499168396,
-0.13633815944194794,
-0.5149838924407959,
-0.1520974487066269,
-0.3900816738605499,
-0.6462346315383911,
-0.07172565162181854,
0.6201938390731812,
-0.24601007997989655,
0.0989793911576271,
-0.14617778360843658,
-0.16017335653305054,
-0.11867604404687881,
-0.5112748742103577,
0.8048459887504578,
0.1862170696258545,
-0.548102617263794,
0.28539326786994934,
-0.3008507490158081,
0.33191192150115967,
-0.5937951803207397,
-0.2959858179092407,
0.3508332073688507,
0.579723596572876,
-0.2964805066585541,
-0.6197377443313599,
0.345936119556427,
-0.44546300172805786,
-0.31063488125801086,
-0.02755192667245865,
1.16721510887146,
-0.4725660979747772,
-0.25185737013816833,
0.14940941333770752,
0.7325040698051453,
0.18401971459388733,
0.053062304854393005,
-0.7405278086662292,
-0.2451344132423401,
-0.4148513674736023,
0.3369993269443512,
0.48609450459480286,
0.41579172015190125,
-0.016628094017505646,
0.6809971928596497,
0.6530495285987854,
0.5941031575202942,
0.012661096639931202,
0.14650551974773407,
0.7702363133430481,
-0.3321636915206909,
-0.31259047985076904,
-0.45742568373680115,
0.36197689175605774,
-0.06103380396962166,
-0.05992197245359421,
0.40210026502609253,
0.9445710182189941,
0.7329229116439819,
-0.13256826996803284,
0.7383139729499817,
0.1363876610994339,
1.0716294050216675,
-0.27612414956092834,
0.8038569688796997,
-0.5627614855766296,
0.3362043797969818,
0.02972516417503357,
-0.4814927279949188,
-0.4933604598045349,
0.42994797229766846,
-0.38991695642471313,
-0.025186052545905113,
0.69206702709198,
0.6368019580841064,
-0.09392820298671722,
0.023576034232974052,
0.39681270718574524,
0.16735319793224335,
-0.17355035245418549,
0.3339948058128357,
0.6312280893325806,
-0.7207619547843933,
0.23260830342769623,
-0.4963235557079315,
-0.17117352783679962,
-0.3460819721221924,
-0.5242299437522888,
-0.3646034002304077,
-0.34345829486846924,
-0.40631115436553955,
-0.4225319027900696,
0.48637130856513977,
1.2386980056762695,
0.7129139304161072,
-1.067999243736267,
-0.07684578001499176,
-0.0008727030945010483,
0.07377315312623978,
-0.30464860796928406,
-0.18131694197654724,
0.28896355628967285,
-0.2536654770374298,
-0.1621592938899994,
0.3651270270347595,
0.18789692223072052,
-0.19656260311603546,
0.20411095023155212,
-0.2190563976764679,
0.05278436839580536,
-0.31445056200027466,
0.3536631166934967,
0.3107759356498718,
-0.5067858695983887,
-0.06540870666503906,
0.3046889901161194,
-0.26149433851242065,
0.5250464677810669,
0.7365766167640686,
-1.0919256210327148,
0.5261468291282654,
0.656090497970581,
0.7762315273284912,
0.5897892713546753,
0.3902103006839752,
0.446038156747818,
-0.4328081011772156,
-0.38204100728034973,
0.5151312947273254,
0.44983190298080444,
0.3851928412914276,
-0.5474713444709778,
0.3124759793281555,
0.1051507517695427,
-0.7171597480773926,
-0.7563011050224304,
-0.055709224194288254,
-1.003366231918335,
0.41580578684806824,
0.6833786964416504,
0.047210901975631714,
-0.13679952919483185,
-0.3826235830783844,
-0.10716096311807632,
0.32143861055374146,
-0.6764264106750488,
0.8896368145942688,
-0.07310809940099716,
-0.5275946855545044,
-0.014083091169595718,
-1.1204053163528442,
0.464616060256958,
0.5218847393989563,
-0.8083301782608032,
-0.3758317530155182,
0.6650928258895874,
0.2591729164123535,
0.2837054133415222,
0.830156147480011,
-0.47045713663101196,
0.6854735612869263,
-0.37969332933425903,
-0.013505769893527031,
0.11922476440668106,
-0.4604741036891937,
-0.44149404764175415,
-0.05420457199215889,
0.1087035983800888,
-0.1277332305908203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16211v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16211v1
|
HypoTermQA: Hypothetical Terms Dataset for Benchmarking Hallucination Tendency of LLMs
| 2024-02-25T22:23:37 | 2024-02-25T22:23:37 |
Cem Uluoglakci, Tugba Taskaya Temizel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hallucinations pose a significant challenge to the reliability and alignment
of Large Language Models (LLMs), limiting their widespread acceptance beyond
chatbot applications. Despite ongoing efforts, hallucinations remain a
prevalent challenge in LLMs. The detection of hallucinations itself is also a
formidable task, frequently requiring manual labeling or constrained
evaluations. This paper introduces an automated scalable framework that
combines benchmarking LLMs' hallucination tendencies with efficient
hallucination detection. We leverage LLMs to generate challenging tasks related
to hypothetical phenomena, subsequently employing them as agents for efficient
hallucination detection. The framework is domain-agnostic, allowing the use of
any language model for benchmark creation or evaluation in any domain. We
introduce the publicly available HypoTermQA Benchmarking Dataset, on which
state-of-the-art models' performance ranged between 3% and 11%, and evaluator
agents demonstrated a 6% error rate in hallucination prediction. The proposed
framework provides opportunities to test and improve LLMs. Additionally, it has
the potential to generate benchmarking datasets tailored to specific domains,
such as law, health, and finance.
|
[
-0.2840469777584076,
-0.7263481020927429,
0.8501853942871094,
0.17429772019386292,
-0.06746319681406021,
0.013362305238842964,
-0.2855120897293091,
-0.3392270505428314,
0.4569268822669983,
0.4963364899158478,
-0.7303894758224487,
-0.6123637557029724,
-0.43970349431037903,
0.24047139286994934,
-0.5603188276290894,
0.3974091708660126,
-0.07922259718179703,
0.1378898173570633,
-0.3495425879955292,
-0.019302142783999443,
-0.3995515704154968,
-0.7754561305046082,
-0.2741098403930664,
-0.30026429891586304,
0.2355104684829712,
0.178585022687912,
0.8787778615951538,
0.46829813718795776,
0.4902348518371582,
0.33550533652305603,
0.3373659551143646,
0.270129919052124,
-0.4730496108531952,
0.5261634588241577,
-0.016652826219797134,
-0.2296978384256363,
-0.4051904082298279,
-0.004578109364956617,
0.29336556792259216,
0.578137993812561,
-0.49505579471588135,
0.07675354182720184,
-0.18056164681911469,
0.28493574261665344,
-0.5741114020347595,
-0.0948297381401062,
-0.9311104416847229,
0.2023744136095047,
0.12896385788917542,
-0.364041805267334,
-0.18154175579547882,
-0.5561134219169617,
0.10523387789726257,
-0.42649030685424805,
0.1635560691356659,
0.504766583442688,
0.795082688331604,
0.7909807562828064,
-0.1430148035287857,
-0.4907904863357544,
-0.3087233304977417,
0.5954885482788086,
-0.5983129143714905,
0.7174193263053894,
0.5396101474761963,
0.5988661050796509,
-0.3498678207397461,
-0.7668989896774292,
-0.7211146950721741,
-0.7010136842727661,
-0.11889617145061493,
-0.2964073121547699,
-0.19643165171146393,
-0.07656760513782501,
0.3342761993408203,
0.31280696392059326,
-0.7908791303634644,
0.10429759323596954,
0.04103412479162216,
-0.4955545961856842,
0.40119466185569763,
0.46721136569976807,
0.03216952830553055,
-0.4207639694213867,
-0.2393653392791748,
-0.050223466008901596,
-0.4599209725856781,
-0.5469956994056702,
0.31462815403938293,
0.31685757637023926,
0.09873493015766144,
0.7207980155944824,
-0.3060849606990814,
0.3963613510131836,
-0.11709123849868774,
-0.111027292907238,
0.5174182653427124,
0.07275621592998505,
-0.2714146375656128,
0.09727687388658524,
0.5490601062774658,
0.26203206181526184,
0.02012271247804165,
-0.5731037855148315,
-0.3979075849056244,
0.2200840711593628,
0.5624796748161316,
-0.8649694323539734,
-0.467878133058548,
0.563806414604187,
-0.2665099501609802,
-0.0728646069765091,
-0.2691991925239563,
-0.8123462796211243,
-0.8244760632514954,
-0.5866056680679321,
0.7505558729171753,
-0.5178074240684509,
-0.11980976909399033,
0.2692989706993103,
-0.027704710140824318,
0.20246712863445282,
0.21492379903793335,
-0.45737364888191223,
0.521037757396698,
0.705899715423584,
0.8784667253494263,
-0.7256293296813965,
-0.36826980113983154,
-0.602432370185852,
-0.18979862332344055,
-0.2952830195426941,
0.7999077439308167,
-0.2849014401435852,
-0.10598274320363998,
0.12409280240535736,
0.11544662714004517,
-0.02145090326666832,
-0.841996967792511,
0.5024844408035278,
-0.1617962270975113,
0.034772176295518875,
-0.19713442027568817,
-0.7546645998954773,
0.027912979945540428,
0.4724236726760864,
-0.5614858865737915,
1.1286982297897339,
0.224515900015831,
-0.5067497491836548,
0.36418381333351135,
-0.21624651551246643,
-0.13203944265842438,
0.3445388376712799,
-0.4722514748573303,
-0.48173150420188904,
-0.05728325620293617,
0.06452007591724396,
0.5236294269561768,
-0.4513383209705353,
0.6002721190452576,
-0.37474504113197327,
-0.659996509552002,
0.3689374327659607,
-0.30959558486938477,
0.4758625030517578,
0.018825268372893333,
-0.6095608472824097,
0.21897584199905396,
-0.7944092154502869,
-0.007657919079065323,
0.018214993178844452,
0.2523849308490753,
-0.16370061039924622,
0.08397487550973892,
-0.026194823905825615,
0.16406802833080292,
0.1438322514295578,
-0.1902768909931183,
-0.08766499906778336,
-0.1272888034582138,
0.07066801190376282,
0.6600668430328369,
0.04337954893708229,
-0.08972010016441345,
-0.45894789695739746,
0.6271756887435913,
-0.23550722002983093,
0.05620386451482773,
0.2714797556400299,
-0.2023605853319168,
-0.8281514048576355,
-0.666042685508728,
0.08276519179344177,
0.42368486523628235,
-0.9271204471588135,
0.7437326908111572,
-0.29274624586105347,
-0.35409483313560486,
-0.565919041633606,
-0.12708339095115662,
0.26978158950805664,
0.6702845096588135,
0.45101821422576904,
0.1086445078253746,
-0.6930607557296753,
-1.0985910892486572,
-0.19129861891269684,
-0.3103572130203247,
-0.3173040747642517,
0.243147611618042,
0.66063392162323,
-0.4742831289768219,
0.6641007661819458,
-0.4754623770713806,
-0.45321589708328247,
0.1681712567806244,
0.17098841071128845,
0.11814262717962265,
0.20941512286663055,
0.3247504234313965,
-0.6962412595748901,
-0.005082792602479458,
-0.27209293842315674,
-0.9999428391456604,
-0.30253729224205017,
0.06105656176805496,
-0.28716176748275757,
0.2555842399597168,
0.5457028150558472,
-0.4505743384361267,
0.3553183674812317,
0.4247857332229614,
-0.27385443449020386,
0.7754344940185547,
0.006621947977691889,
0.2871914207935333,
-0.9012396931648254,
-0.11793224513530731,
-0.08156286180019379,
-0.10951919108629227,
-0.6228132247924805,
-0.05478862300515175,
0.010419742204248905,
0.3139299154281616,
-0.385785847902298,
0.4018446207046509,
-0.27429652214050293,
-0.1706729531288147,
-0.24848157167434692,
0.20615240931510925,
-0.4185430705547333,
0.5858903527259827,
0.32884812355041504,
0.7241860032081604,
0.5816200375556946,
-0.4219813346862793,
0.47024300694465637,
0.25647425651550293,
-0.41973236203193665,
0.5217916965484619,
-0.44928157329559326,
0.06976014375686646,
0.20422713458538055,
-0.024186957627534866,
-0.9008572101593018,
-0.4537051022052765,
0.4378572404384613,
-0.1917957365512848,
-0.2971147894859314,
0.17752109467983246,
-0.7753833532333374,
-0.34679827094078064,
-0.38893380761146545,
0.2323000431060791,
0.6361374855041504,
-0.7556765079498291,
0.6701689958572388,
0.4288139045238495,
0.18516089022159576,
-0.5055291056632996,
-0.44600051641464233,
0.29981669783592224,
-0.44608283042907715,
-0.26772016286849976,
0.4880039095878601,
-0.08522409945726395,
-0.33555373549461365,
-0.17309562861919403,
-0.23612476885318756,
0.1450004279613495,
0.01994853839278221,
0.5740657448768616,
0.2996762990951538,
-0.07770448178052902,
0.22740668058395386,
-0.0719316229224205,
0.24722304940223694,
0.34154003858566284,
-0.24934673309326172,
0.8239026665687561,
-0.19920939207077026,
-0.352372407913208,
-0.5200739502906799,
-0.01943049393594265,
0.47419673204421997,
0.46552643179893494,
0.4578987658023834,
0.24003943800926208,
-0.9333699345588684,
-0.3675084412097931,
-0.7867032885551453,
-0.3755152225494385,
-0.5131880044937134,
0.2935899794101715,
-0.6707369685173035,
-0.7091166973114014,
0.5163469314575195,
-0.1029585599899292,
-0.3686409592628479,
0.10936396569013596,
0.9542162418365479,
0.16914406418800354,
0.7462020516395569,
0.35391882061958313,
0.08748845756053925,
-0.052896060049533844,
0.028799403458833694,
0.2047346830368042,
-0.6046576499938965,
-0.33473098278045654,
-0.4750185012817383,
-0.030205506831407547,
-0.6812294125556946,
-0.5615435838699341,
0.28937584161758423,
-0.3716827929019928,
-0.18196773529052734,
0.5911359786987305,
-0.5194804668426514,
0.37114042043685913,
0.09731479734182358,
0.07916378974914551,
0.32648637890815735,
0.08910436928272247,
-0.2968212068080902,
-0.10166532546281815,
-0.42436498403549194,
-0.75892573595047,
0.8910213708877563,
0.2710086703300476,
0.6507501602172852,
0.046819768846035004,
0.7408131957054138,
0.6778271794319153,
0.3760013282299042,
-0.8720117807388306,
0.718647837638855,
0.3485446274280548,
-0.45360636711120605,
-0.5343155264854431,
-0.4231884181499481,
-0.6185141205787659,
0.5740162134170532,
-0.259553462266922,
-0.9409176111221313,
0.2930569648742676,
-0.07856044918298721,
-0.3046250641345978,
0.09652960300445557,
-0.23456618189811707,
0.6600111722946167,
-0.16707909107208252,
-0.3722325563430786,
-0.06046080216765404,
-0.34818053245544434,
0.4683397710323334,
-0.47860410809516907,
0.04099079594016075,
-0.5237061977386475,
-0.1288679987192154,
0.6258805990219116,
-0.39834412932395935,
0.6124160289764404,
-0.05673378333449364,
-0.3536844551563263,
-0.11023261398077011,
0.22814497351646423,
0.2920573055744171,
0.2380857914686203,
-0.41872671246528625,
0.16790437698364258,
0.07754377275705338,
-0.1767762154340744,
-0.4761383533477783,
0.6756019592285156,
-0.5710300207138062,
-0.6575489044189453,
-0.5379989147186279,
-0.5878027677536011,
-0.5822242498397827,
-0.07998968660831451,
0.21392595767974854,
0.0014638088177889585,
-0.42093759775161743,
-0.15471230447292328,
0.503931999206543,
-0.05318465456366539,
0.1694180816411972,
0.4114129841327667,
-0.34254467487335205,
-0.3574884533882141,
0.8094871044158936,
-0.15837587416172028,
-0.21485771238803864,
0.059635452926158905,
-0.09304176270961761,
-0.5140427947044373,
-0.6066611409187317,
-0.22964230179786682,
0.3166070580482483,
-0.79472815990448,
-0.321040540933609,
-0.8262655138969421,
-0.20324866473674774,
-0.4083177149295807,
-0.01736966148018837,
-0.19833196699619293,
-0.27686232328414917,
-0.040732257068157196,
-0.07161654531955719,
0.3562987148761749,
0.3552097678184509,
0.11364267021417618,
0.0695735365152359,
-0.04631693288683891,
0.7371320724487305,
0.3001094162464142,
0.2899666130542755,
-0.07269696146249771,
-0.6486324667930603,
0.0685812458395958,
-0.10237279534339905,
-0.013863521628081799,
-0.6850730776786804,
0.6665106415748596,
0.03700406849384308,
0.6067518591880798,
0.25480473041534424,
0.4236414432525635,
0.7710033655166626,
-0.4936347007751465,
0.6368499994277954,
0.06304149329662323,
-1.16283118724823,
0.3377201557159424,
0.06532708555459976,
-0.14594194293022156,
0.7617384791374207,
0.7319816946983337,
-0.4890805780887604,
-0.640659511089325,
-0.2656715512275696,
-0.5975023508071899,
0.5283051133155823,
0.507862389087677,
-0.11008095741271973,
-0.06775826960802078,
0.46762615442276,
0.5140307545661926,
0.3875032067298889,
-0.4794972240924835,
-0.028788121417164803,
-0.07121804356575012,
-0.14048700034618378,
-0.044372424483299255,
0.021199287846684456,
-0.22333616018295288,
-0.4643193185329437,
0.6839861869812012,
-0.2097989320755005,
0.20623722672462463,
0.03808878734707832,
-0.36898505687713623,
-0.0641930103302002,
-0.205228790640831,
0.41984793543815613,
0.8067310452461243,
-0.5223037600517273,
0.2888835072517395,
0.3453623354434967,
-0.36766067147254944,
0.32813724875450134,
0.07400714606046677,
0.09882640838623047,
0.19351476430892944,
0.316304087638855,
0.6665964722633362,
-0.027992986142635345,
-1.1296244859695435,
0.45746150612831116,
-0.3433821499347687,
-0.5342503786087036,
-0.6677748560905457,
0.09218563884496689,
0.03724953904747963,
0.3282145857810974,
0.5007243156433105,
-0.37196922302246094,
0.42938151955604553,
-0.43549177050590515,
0.5620056390762329,
0.35865840315818787,
-0.20699457824230194,
-0.1675712764263153,
0.6799426674842834,
-0.18648238480091095,
-0.5442308783531189,
0.6926639080047607,
-0.3815978765487671,
-0.6443215608596802,
0.6623172163963318,
0.2624017298221588,
1.0516222715377808,
-0.08866298943758011,
0.17516076564788818,
0.21466320753097534,
0.2696753144264221,
-0.21729512512683868,
0.4289458096027374,
-0.04076596349477768,
-0.7087603807449341,
0.04189329221844673,
-0.7219244241714478,
-0.8108904957771301,
0.23923049867153168,
-0.6209676861763,
0.494393527507782,
-0.13111551105976105,
-0.25370651483535767,
0.10045457631349564,
-0.07212284207344055,
-0.6701464056968689,
0.13602155447006226,
0.3576612174510956,
0.6061729788780212,
-0.6702916622161865,
0.980719268321991,
0.2885042130947113,
-0.05375191196799278,
-0.25174644589424133,
0.5814141631126404,
0.1643676459789276,
-0.8373242616653442,
0.3553111255168915,
0.37951356172561646,
-0.4536711275577545,
-0.3314577341079712,
-0.4838988482952118,
-0.6192492246627808,
1.1692333221435547,
0.4644329249858856,
-0.5958953499794006,
-0.02488391473889351,
0.2508056163787842,
0.7719277739524841,
-0.6017912030220032,
-0.06702356040477753,
0.9311789274215698,
0.4880625903606415,
0.2839168906211853,
-0.6794408559799194,
0.5436342358589172,
-0.16269691288471222,
-0.02886897139251232,
-0.09178490191698074,
-0.2730080783367157,
0.6464855670928955,
0.025540314614772797,
-0.18535779416561127,
0.33879736065864563,
0.6873882412910461,
0.5013110637664795,
0.4245356321334839,
0.6168100237846375,
0.3870644271373749,
1.0822112560272217,
-0.0691022202372551,
0.6789335012435913,
-0.4525008797645569,
0.1440763622522354,
1.1755971908569336,
-0.8176637291908264,
0.8552701473236084,
0.5003650784492493,
-0.021378932520747185,
0.33059605956077576,
0.7880070209503174,
-0.24398250877857208,
0.4597504138946533,
0.8079614043235779,
-0.17721518874168396,
-0.4033252000808716,
-0.11063258349895477,
-0.3348577916622162,
0.35555121302604675,
0.44065073132514954,
-0.07706765085458755,
0.0472126379609108,
0.16866448521614075,
-0.27040404081344604,
-0.03165656700730324,
0.10606750100851059,
0.53531813621521,
-0.009186974726617336,
-0.6433902382850647,
1.0187879800796509,
-0.24414297938346863,
0.8604755997657776,
-0.25553154945373535,
-0.05820907652378082,
-0.2800789475440979,
0.03250198811292648,
-0.09836262464523315,
-0.19221410155296326,
0.2376178801059723,
-0.031830817461013794,
0.1776735931634903,
0.06872457265853882,
0.4109344184398651,
-0.33204635977745056,
-0.3700411915779114,
0.5181415677070618,
0.7531095743179321,
0.5837018489837646,
-0.20511852204799652,
-0.5420801639556885,
0.2600642144680023,
-0.32444098591804504,
-0.06765569746494293,
0.21224236488342285,
0.5579943060874939,
-0.17954635620117188,
0.8024569749832153,
0.253315269947052,
0.07514896243810654,
-0.048006631433963776,
0.22205910086631775,
0.8752379417419434,
-0.6780107021331787,
-0.26851192116737366,
-0.7875854969024658,
-0.10040269792079926,
-0.2650141417980194,
-0.30667737126350403,
0.706953763961792,
0.6376826167106628,
0.5953426361083984,
-0.0007544395048171282,
0.5274621248245239,
0.07838121056556702,
0.37795397639274597,
-0.5592402815818787,
0.8009908199310303,
-0.7415088415145874,
0.3802555501461029,
-0.1438564956188202,
-0.978919267654419,
-0.27178195118904114,
0.5241374969482422,
-0.16696564853191376,
-0.09723217785358429,
0.96209716796875,
1.1167854070663452,
0.11339588463306427,
0.07809608429670334,
0.6381915807723999,
0.1019359827041626,
0.002669714856892824,
0.23967063426971436,
1.130128026008606,
-0.25663283467292786,
0.2849620580673218,
-0.3629094064235687,
-0.10961131006479263,
-0.3473857641220093,
-0.8966593742370605,
-1.1650573015213013,
-0.8330015540122986,
-0.612505316734314,
-0.36270448565483093,
0.448773592710495,
1.2988570928573608,
0.735014021396637,
-0.9533018469810486,
-0.42044490575790405,
0.12889108061790466,
0.032130081206560135,
-0.29469770193099976,
-0.20622843503952026,
0.5490758419036865,
-0.3840625286102295,
-0.7073404788970947,
0.36629435420036316,
0.1443515568971634,
0.10575252771377563,
-0.43008697032928467,
-0.19649288058280945,
0.17232784628868103,
0.32206499576568604,
0.528587281703949,
-0.08556697517633438,
-1.0050315856933594,
-0.20057928562164307,
0.12936340272426605,
-0.30689024925231934,
0.0010428689420223236,
0.7093449831008911,
-0.9441116452217102,
0.025877399370074272,
0.14636985957622528,
0.6867551207542419,
0.31651487946510315,
-0.17340630292892456,
0.2941097915172577,
-0.4231718182563782,
0.12275893241167068,
0.568397581577301,
0.35757526755332947,
0.30188822746276855,
-0.4482457637786865,
0.7139739990234375,
0.0573447160422802,
-0.33914172649383545,
-1.2850251197814941,
-0.17181040346622467,
-0.9109530448913574,
-0.5086590647697449,
1.1072804927825928,
0.15553708374500275,
-0.23993341624736786,
-0.278825581073761,
-0.019947011023759842,
0.013384412042796612,
-0.2230014055967331,
1.3326263427734375,
0.740180253982544,
-0.3422442078590393,
0.08602594584226608,
-0.5351883172988892,
0.7822058796882629,
0.4497818350791931,
-0.9560158848762512,
0.26260918378829956,
0.685364305973053,
-0.042485788464546204,
0.03866574913263321,
0.45948299765586853,
0.12421494722366333,
0.2168874591588974,
-0.033575914800167084,
0.2757010757923126,
0.2044006586074829,
-0.3615187704563141,
-0.3909817636013031,
0.2967483103275299,
-0.19243337213993073,
-0.0855192169547081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16200v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16200v1
|
IR2: Information Regularization for Information Retrieval
| 2024-02-25T21:25:06 | 2024-02-25T21:25:06 |
Jianyou Wang, Kaicheng Wang, Xiaoyue Wang, Weili Cao, Ramamohan Paturi, Leon Bergen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Effective information retrieval (IR) in settings with limited training data,
particularly for complex queries, remains a challenging task. This paper
introduces IR2, Information Regularization for Information Retrieval, a
technique for reducing overfitting during synthetic data generation. This
approach, representing a novel application of regularization techniques in
synthetic data creation for IR, is tested on three recent IR tasks
characterized by complex queries: DORIS-MAE, ArguAna, and WhatsThatBook.
Experimental results indicate that our regularization techniques not only
outperform previous synthetic query generation methods on the tasks considered
but also reduce cost by up to 50%. Furthermore, this paper categorizes and
explores three regularization methods at different stages of the query
synthesis pipeline-input, prompt, and output-each offering varying degrees of
performance improvement compared to models where no regularization is applied.
This provides a systematic approach for optimizing synthetic data generation in
data-limited, complex-query IR scenarios. All code, prompts and synthetic data
are available at
https://github.com/Info-Regularization/Information-Regularization.
|
[
-0.5310139060020447,
-0.8378818035125732,
0.11001593619585037,
0.21039199829101562,
-0.07623810321092606,
0.11226632446050644,
-0.274890661239624,
-0.5464835166931152,
0.1825495958328247,
0.3866954743862152,
-0.24709093570709229,
-0.254689484834671,
-0.2174096405506134,
0.07976687699556351,
-0.286930650472641,
0.8998348712921143,
-0.014784184284508228,
0.3095467984676361,
0.06522106379270554,
0.05153854563832283,
-0.40081384778022766,
-0.356519490480423,
-0.5085813403129578,
-0.133172407746315,
0.6500342488288879,
0.7430055737495422,
0.4274573028087616,
0.7062707543373108,
0.9579735994338989,
0.0965469479560852,
0.251630961894989,
0.5048073530197144,
-1.066473126411438,
0.5707674622535706,
-0.06006230041384697,
-0.6880951523780823,
0.131149560213089,
0.07398948073387146,
0.8466776013374329,
0.5656665563583374,
0.04495296999812126,
0.1785425841808319,
-0.18591047823429108,
1.0289381742477417,
-0.9346341490745544,
-0.0036988297943025827,
-0.7958696484565735,
0.09393583983182907,
-0.2550908625125885,
-0.5042480230331421,
-0.3953300714492798,
-0.47906261682510376,
-0.09123339504003525,
-0.6630187034606934,
0.6220760941505432,
0.5466300249099731,
0.8419760465621948,
0.4063359200954437,
-0.3713880181312561,
0.00845494493842125,
-1.2385395765304565,
0.8492971062660217,
-0.14893865585327148,
0.4873863756656647,
0.6163926124572754,
0.5566704869270325,
-0.37875041365623474,
-0.9398769736289978,
-0.6511121392250061,
-0.09279493987560272,
-0.27466556429862976,
0.25016528367996216,
-0.21973620355129242,
0.1763128638267517,
0.48395904898643494,
0.1990734040737152,
-0.7762153744697571,
-0.5065316557884216,
-0.8462116718292236,
0.15691421926021576,
0.43785661458969116,
-0.23119805753231049,
-0.158009335398674,
0.059127822518348694,
-0.36269140243530273,
-0.2188720554113388,
-0.5858545899391174,
-0.09892959147691727,
0.3472954332828522,
0.19621339440345764,
0.6937636137008667,
0.832118809223175,
-0.48850950598716736,
0.5937538743019104,
-0.055813129991292953,
-0.04258644953370094,
-0.1446167230606079,
-0.4462207853794098,
0.07631012052297592,
-0.0041739726439118385,
0.3300776481628418,
0.5214994549751282,
0.3782743215560913,
-0.17329522967338562,
-0.4458896517753601,
0.077109195291996,
0.16883830726146698,
-0.9345658421516418,
-0.125529944896698,
0.11922832578420639,
-0.43345412611961365,
0.010792813263833523,
0.49302229285240173,
-0.6400033831596375,
-0.022864848375320435,
-0.5781949758529663,
0.39942845702171326,
-0.33087417483329773,
-0.007359651383012533,
0.1295931339263916,
-0.4073823094367981,
0.3803412914276123,
0.15936614573001862,
-0.44534263014793396,
0.6559619307518005,
0.4453887343406677,
0.5453333258628845,
-0.19485047459602356,
0.15678474307060242,
-0.704559326171875,
0.4018511176109314,
-0.3828178644180298,
0.7132424116134644,
-0.6316983103752136,
-0.062455639243125916,
-0.3047963082790375,
-0.2799772024154663,
0.13246259093284607,
-0.7701900005340576,
0.2095637321472168,
-0.7882131934165955,
0.10505864024162292,
0.1254899501800537,
-0.32407817244529724,
0.0001231297355843708,
0.3216109573841095,
-0.6057787537574768,
1.3872092962265015,
0.2180267870426178,
-0.5363359451293945,
0.08376536518335342,
-0.4974955916404724,
-0.5168378353118896,
-0.18421941995620728,
-0.12753698229789734,
-0.1985745131969452,
-0.04023806378245354,
-0.38638824224472046,
-0.1864089071750641,
-0.7946748733520508,
0.10103029757738113,
0.4226624369621277,
-0.6288974285125732,
-0.1824205368757248,
0.09826773405075073,
-0.10672258585691452,
0.5942152142524719,
-0.23473401367664337,
-0.4351557195186615,
-0.8197919130325317,
0.5608081221580505,
-0.035932913422584534,
-0.6877989768981934,
-0.47406548261642456,
-0.09669521450996399,
0.3134145438671112,
-0.27598124742507935,
0.173868790268898,
-0.7155049443244934,
0.5905695557594299,
-0.3469195067882538,
0.25688987970352173,
0.09915440529584885,
0.2356644719839096,
0.296252578496933,
-0.31035488843917847,
0.4088784158229828,
-0.20072680711746216,
0.3902398943901062,
-0.001128936419263482,
-0.38501840829849243,
-0.9902769327163696,
-0.1514693796634674,
0.8430310487747192,
0.7440752387046814,
-0.6583088040351868,
0.1299123615026474,
-0.10837934166193008,
-0.5188840627670288,
-0.4499041736125946,
-0.022259686142206192,
0.5991172194480896,
0.2910902202129364,
0.8465694785118103,
-0.06911635398864746,
-0.9246374368667603,
-0.9315363168716431,
-0.49367713928222656,
-0.08012859523296356,
-0.30072906613349915,
0.3739127814769745,
0.31046730279922485,
-0.46260932087898254,
0.9440184831619263,
-0.7176288962364197,
-0.5605412721633911,
0.01845322735607624,
0.3872476816177368,
-0.0861952006816864,
1.120999813079834,
0.47806164622306824,
-1.0262365341186523,
-0.5959439873695374,
-0.05205296725034714,
-0.20933613181114197,
0.26963186264038086,
-0.22765162587165833,
-0.4619308114051819,
-0.12300475686788559,
0.4795638620853424,
-0.5419330596923828,
0.5209819078445435,
-0.1022602766752243,
-0.01972281001508236,
-0.020994804799556732,
-0.19171029329299927,
0.4425452649593353,
-0.7904826402664185,
0.34684470295906067,
0.08246719837188721,
-0.25937220454216003,
-0.6333093643188477,
0.15843264758586884,
0.08238523453474045,
-0.17768147587776184,
0.26207518577575684,
0.40223371982574463,
-0.612504243850708,
0.011419717222452164,
-0.0069822161458432674,
-0.08709027618169785,
0.2912195324897766,
0.3443624675273895,
-0.24871502816677094,
0.8116675615310669,
0.1266918033361435,
-0.4067593812942505,
0.27840667963027954,
0.22763334214687347,
-0.22616539895534515,
0.11519666761159897,
-0.694809079170227,
0.3560067415237427,
-0.6626183986663818,
0.2308896780014038,
-1.2356106042861938,
-0.6122130155563354,
0.09840864688158035,
-0.6200032234191895,
0.6019188761711121,
-0.47173112630844116,
-0.7127089500427246,
0.047767311334609985,
-0.5636293888092041,
0.6199963688850403,
0.7505204677581787,
-0.3781359791755676,
0.5630797147750854,
0.19154886901378632,
-0.08071335405111313,
-0.34634873270988464,
-0.8938995599746704,
0.06387721002101898,
0.10072281211614609,
-0.7119267582893372,
0.7020847201347351,
-0.2370561808347702,
-0.34536391496658325,
-0.1809604912996292,
-0.28556838631629944,
-0.47861409187316895,
-0.1447104513645172,
-0.4269498586654663,
0.12033922225236893,
-0.21615272760391235,
0.1390693038702011,
0.21352994441986084,
-0.10710189491510391,
-0.4252965450286865,
-0.19308161735534668,
0.4801928997039795,
0.3826131224632263,
0.010100303217768669,
-0.597825288772583,
0.6651996970176697,
0.3548496961593628,
-0.2703339457511902,
0.5574514269828796,
0.6071223020553589,
-0.6366099715232849,
0.036873288452625275,
-1.1550382375717163,
-0.48559603095054626,
-0.38628602027893066,
0.09351316839456558,
-0.33279111981391907,
-0.4081604778766632,
0.26312437653541565,
-0.13125233352184296,
-0.10358446836471558,
0.22091014683246613,
-0.05116754397749901,
-0.1311950832605362,
1.4608855247497559,
0.4947957694530487,
0.35288482904434204,
0.6846746802330017,
-0.5479835867881775,
0.20537596940994263,
-0.6590356826782227,
-0.770972728729248,
-0.7913030385971069,
-0.538486123085022,
-0.5739266872406006,
-0.5724846720695496,
0.6401298642158508,
0.37853655219078064,
-0.10932373255491257,
0.00422091968357563,
-0.6118872165679932,
0.6757534146308899,
0.8972027897834778,
0.26222336292266846,
0.20321601629257202,
0.46867844462394714,
0.46538570523262024,
-0.19673871994018555,
-0.629219651222229,
-0.003017718903720379,
0.9084444642066956,
-0.1572049856185913,
1.0995172262191772,
0.24978457391262054,
0.4146564304828644,
0.3450024127960205,
-0.1599365919828415,
-0.9063118696212769,
0.04545113816857338,
-0.00044023292139172554,
-0.4625801146030426,
-0.12979857623577118,
-0.5902573466300964,
-0.9712932109832764,
-0.060808971524238586,
-0.4022673964500427,
-0.17651572823524475,
0.47980189323425293,
0.13279029726982117,
-0.2857021689414978,
-0.23563836514949799,
-1.0012134313583374,
0.24735243618488312,
0.11731711775064468,
-0.3955160677433014,
-0.3027641177177429,
-0.8623338937759399,
-0.20819590985774994,
-0.2200823873281479,
-0.09884415566921234,
0.2875140905380249,
-0.20331653952598572,
0.6945282816886902,
-0.3125569820404053,
0.29810306429862976,
-0.27428945899009705,
0.6379609107971191,
0.3964219391345978,
0.2814554274082184,
1.0060921907424927,
0.10053468495607376,
-0.3210986852645874,
-0.4100492596626282,
0.08559272438287735,
-0.5201799273490906,
-0.9079455137252808,
0.6648252010345459,
-0.6093598008155823,
-0.5243647694587708,
-0.3643500804901123,
-0.4523014724254608,
-0.20865851640701294,
0.45802852511405945,
0.21705001592636108,
0.2851525545120239,
0.3583468496799469,
0.7867737412452698,
0.9618621468544006,
0.06997751444578171,
-0.38920968770980835,
0.6247698664665222,
0.4285736083984375,
-0.45864957571029663,
1.0113104581832886,
0.5646253824234009,
0.100151926279068,
0.40676844120025635,
0.0899244025349617,
-0.03628819063305855,
-0.5958728790283203,
0.03660908341407776,
0.26257121562957764,
-0.3822070062160492,
-0.6374446749687195,
-0.550455629825592,
-0.08770392090082169,
-0.6386969089508057,
0.17563223838806152,
-0.3442608416080475,
-0.8575485944747925,
-0.26079225540161133,
0.12604868412017822,
0.356606125831604,
0.6031736135482788,
-0.14850585162639618,
0.1294689029455185,
-0.5080959796905518,
0.5551943778991699,
0.041645511984825134,
0.35862186551094055,
-0.3256845474243164,
-0.24637910723686218,
-0.1612796187400818,
-0.024863796308636665,
-0.050949111580848694,
-0.4028179943561554,
0.12494917213916779,
0.5493178367614746,
0.4668598771095276,
0.1947331577539444,
0.4519462287425995,
0.9110530018806458,
-0.37097904086112976,
0.4398099482059479,
-0.023135414347052574,
-0.25211527943611145,
0.9188804030418396,
-0.1847720891237259,
-0.05953867733478546,
0.7304372191429138,
0.6019866466522217,
-0.22462737560272217,
-0.20520099997520447,
-0.37042883038520813,
-1.1856703758239746,
0.7839052677154541,
0.7151793837547302,
0.11233265697956085,
0.01599428802728653,
1.0087355375289917,
-0.07938078045845032,
0.14868515729904175,
-0.26908406615257263,
-0.5032403469085693,
0.03561398759484291,
-0.1443309634923935,
0.6095097661018372,
-0.7369309663772583,
-0.23367610573768616,
-0.2373390644788742,
0.6902891397476196,
-0.032239221036434174,
0.3864978551864624,
0.6219541430473328,
0.11337148398160934,
-0.34231463074684143,
-0.2186892330646515,
0.3700614273548126,
0.4126540720462799,
-0.4304964244365692,
0.01265741791576147,
-0.22466832399368286,
-0.48766183853149414,
-0.22867970168590546,
0.16858060657978058,
-0.32742372155189514,
0.044525086879730225,
0.09327403455972672,
0.3744564652442932,
-0.4030603766441345,
-0.7007235884666443,
0.24969810247421265,
-0.24334004521369934,
0.060017745941877365,
-0.3816441595554352,
0.4219965636730194,
-0.7863741517066956,
0.31409528851509094,
0.7984276413917542,
0.36470961570739746,
0.658614993095398,
-0.6161508560180664,
0.07762569189071655,
0.3413117527961731,
-0.16472703218460083,
0.03991944342851639,
0.6913197636604309,
-0.12274128198623657,
-0.14911937713623047,
0.7221270799636841,
-0.08832544833421707,
0.037979234009981155,
0.5761025547981262,
0.5925734043121338,
0.259231835603714,
-0.1430310755968094,
-0.2871425747871399,
0.7971094250679016,
0.2051059752702713,
-0.4116375744342804,
0.6506844162940979,
-0.1933048516511917,
-0.33931541442871094,
0.005177509039640427,
-0.19684773683547974,
-0.22811643779277802,
0.0022726119495928288,
-0.8670129776000977,
0.47592103481292725,
-0.5431205034255981,
-0.35216280817985535,
0.03827567398548126,
-0.007534235715866089,
-0.4014644920825958,
0.15131117403507233,
-0.444572389125824,
0.937023937702179,
-0.07891053706407547,
0.5063764452934265,
0.5711751580238342,
-0.536465048789978,
-0.5271620750427246,
0.14816269278526306,
-0.5776179432868958,
-0.3403501510620117,
0.7279691696166992,
0.0019673090428113937,
-0.09829895198345184,
0.3560000956058502,
-0.7623416781425476,
-0.9814397692680359,
1.0687782764434814,
0.3317391872406006,
-0.45907148718833923,
-0.2610761821269989,
0.14113697409629822,
0.6015876531600952,
-0.06928059458732605,
0.3176742196083069,
0.6383442878723145,
0.8647696375846863,
0.2904544472694397,
-0.45995059609413147,
-0.18103013932704926,
-0.4409521818161011,
0.2734012007713318,
0.21073035895824432,
-0.7873785495758057,
0.607911229133606,
-0.15604378283023834,
-0.39123106002807617,
0.5736075043678284,
0.2914640009403229,
-0.026282671838998795,
0.21011118590831757,
0.17565587162971497,
-0.005551897455006838,
0.7207320332527161,
-0.40382692217826843,
1.0295062065124512,
-0.6190475821495056,
0.44333669543266296,
0.804311215877533,
0.050048720091581345,
0.6335194110870361,
0.7479267120361328,
0.08779757469892502,
-0.09656549990177155,
0.5722869634628296,
-0.24300801753997803,
0.6258689761161804,
0.43965932726860046,
-0.15293161571025848,
-0.18847359716892242,
-0.4854889512062073,
-0.407329797744751,
0.08979093283414841,
0.38394802808761597,
-0.1399466097354889,
-0.08945217728614807,
0.048154931515455246,
-0.032047804445028305,
-0.07904157787561417,
0.23607267439365387,
0.9351769685745239,
-0.4607910215854645,
-0.8401252627372742,
1.0110009908676147,
0.34055235981941223,
0.35778579115867615,
-0.7430716753005981,
-0.5642352104187012,
-0.614107608795166,
0.10708346217870712,
-0.46350815892219543,
-0.41916441917419434,
0.18534639477729797,
0.017178116366267204,
-0.4617064297199249,
0.011721791699528694,
0.536586344242096,
-0.5624961256980896,
-0.3658689558506012,
0.05386572703719139,
0.08087796717882156,
0.320481538772583,
-0.20741930603981018,
-0.5322617888450623,
-0.0026969651225954294,
0.25002557039260864,
-0.4830886423587799,
0.0820411741733551,
0.4832667410373688,
-0.12266024202108383,
0.5396085977554321,
0.7712138891220093,
0.07940763980150223,
0.0386657640337944,
-0.01783232018351555,
1.1358473300933838,
-0.6599701046943665,
-0.09566617757081985,
-0.15556953847408295,
0.20387136936187744,
0.06434529274702072,
-0.10818792879581451,
0.45940864086151123,
1.1557828187942505,
0.9563473463058472,
-0.02964644320309162,
0.7963166236877441,
-0.2202383130788803,
0.6264225840568542,
-0.7339809536933899,
0.3305085003376007,
-0.6590167284011841,
0.30552858114242554,
0.16566713154315948,
-1.218930721282959,
-0.7448828220367432,
0.7592817544937134,
0.19282212853431702,
-0.03713611140847206,
0.3619363605976105,
1.2668002843856812,
-0.20065349340438843,
-0.4498222768306732,
-0.007577124517410994,
0.28776997327804565,
0.20979653298854828,
-0.08678929507732391,
0.7178110480308533,
-0.9120810031890869,
0.7998542189598083,
-0.20138466358184814,
-0.18672345578670502,
-0.48901060223579407,
-0.047067999839782715,
-0.5878248810768127,
-0.47491708397865295,
-0.19183284044265747,
-0.465096116065979,
0.37467363476753235,
1.1090507507324219,
0.8212711811065674,
-0.8159538507461548,
-0.052351776510477066,
-0.16498054563999176,
-0.2020799219608307,
0.31698301434516907,
-0.31286370754241943,
0.030215004459023476,
-0.5707505941390991,
-0.912760317325592,
0.5218968987464905,
-0.08753756433725357,
0.3414340913295746,
-0.08959850668907166,
0.11789879947900772,
-0.4106578528881073,
0.13074107468128204,
0.39294159412384033,
0.2561810612678528,
-0.29128938913345337,
-0.31992626190185547,
0.18216030299663544,
-0.0026375618763267994,
0.3590530753135681,
1.0143723487854004,
-0.8826726675033569,
0.7487550377845764,
0.8722034692764282,
0.4596071243286133,
0.9003247022628784,
0.46800756454467773,
0.5355648994445801,
-1.0368765592575073,
0.31055745482444763,
0.47752687335014343,
-0.15707913041114807,
0.11854308098554611,
-0.7465412616729736,
1.1090548038482666,
0.11905979365110397,
-0.40605974197387695,
-1.019132375717163,
0.1409173160791397,
-0.7758370637893677,
-0.11165016144514084,
1.3101307153701782,
0.22761653363704681,
0.03701872378587723,
-0.10581725090742111,
-0.5979911684989929,
0.3480753004550934,
-0.6503998637199402,
0.816798746585846,
0.06554756313562393,
-0.4218716621398926,
0.4245198965072632,
-0.726405680179596,
0.5980262756347656,
0.37254661321640015,
-0.4470943212509155,
-0.3064672350883484,
0.653146505355835,
0.1849711537361145,
0.2646099328994751,
0.1761353313922882,
-0.07526029646396637,
0.232571542263031,
-0.24884693324565887,
0.03521975874900818,
0.005151417572051287,
-0.640067458152771,
0.3718286156654358,
-0.10874946415424347,
0.06964569538831711,
0.004276571795344353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16194v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16194v1
|
ASEM: Enhancing Empathy in Chatbot through Attention-based Sentiment and Emotion Modeling
| 2024-02-25T20:36:51 | 2024-02-25T20:36:51 |
Omama Hamad, Ali Hamdi, Khaled Shaban
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Effective feature representations play a critical role in enhancing the
performance of text generation models that rely on deep neural networks.
However, current approaches suffer from several drawbacks, such as the
inability to capture the deep semantics of language and sensitivity to minor
input variations, resulting in significant changes in the generated text. In
this paper, we present a novel solution to these challenges by employing a
mixture of experts, multiple encoders, to offer distinct perspectives on the
emotional state of the user's utterance while simultaneously enhancing
performance. We propose an end-to-end model architecture called ASEM that
performs emotion analysis on top of sentiment analysis for open-domain
chatbots, enabling the generation of empathetic responses that are fluent and
relevant. In contrast to traditional attention mechanisms, the proposed model
employs a specialized attention strategy that uniquely zeroes in on sentiment
and emotion nuances within the user's utterance. This ensures the generation of
context-rich representations tailored to the underlying emotional tone and
sentiment intricacies of the text. Our approach outperforms existing methods
for generating empathetic embeddings, providing empathetic and diverse
responses. The performance of our proposed model significantly exceeds that of
existing models, enhancing emotion detection accuracy by 6.2% and lexical
diversity by 1.4%.
|
[
-0.43474915623664856,
-0.7443429827690125,
0.2899583578109741,
0.2805134057998657,
-0.19004641473293304,
0.21625138819217682,
-0.4064364731311798,
-0.3570229709148407,
0.3837259113788605,
0.43238258361816406,
-0.584352433681488,
-0.5004205703735352,
-0.7638816833496094,
0.14021098613739014,
-0.25101253390312195,
0.745886504650116,
0.13536423444747925,
-0.23451200127601624,
-0.4396567940711975,
-0.23140311241149902,
-0.28261932730674744,
-0.6109451651573181,
-0.7777427434921265,
-0.15715691447257996,
0.25144362449645996,
0.4704189896583557,
0.5693185925483704,
0.2078271210193634,
0.6497079730033875,
0.3493916094303131,
-0.15126866102218628,
0.22671981155872345,
-0.4808124601840973,
0.34091252088546753,
0.05538197234272957,
-0.3514063060283661,
-0.7343701720237732,
-0.18961328268051147,
0.11628083139657974,
0.24642714858055115,
-0.14391407370567322,
-0.036003969609737396,
0.20657546818256378,
0.548656165599823,
-0.7315554022789001,
-0.03174203634262085,
-0.5434563755989075,
0.15451645851135254,
0.25809749960899353,
-0.2762611210346222,
-0.44177085161209106,
-0.03326083719730377,
0.28121671080589294,
-0.29384055733680725,
0.05429242551326752,
-0.020790917798876762,
0.5488176941871643,
0.4984845817089081,
-0.3648874759674072,
-0.3391018509864807,
-0.5137022137641907,
0.7775704264640808,
-0.7852112650871277,
0.2065451592206955,
-0.012250779196619987,
0.22480595111846924,
0.32851195335388184,
-0.301120400428772,
-0.5621918439865112,
-0.04108147323131561,
0.20714344084262848,
0.6906585693359375,
-0.28924140334129333,
0.2252551019191742,
0.1599280834197998,
0.34689271450042725,
-0.356564998626709,
-0.1279856264591217,
0.08196675777435303,
0.215900257229805,
0.6753926873207092,
0.2989857494831085,
0.4849835932254791,
-0.012760203331708908,
-0.29590678215026855,
-0.1317235231399536,
-0.05613650754094124,
0.08808815479278564,
0.5169565081596375,
0.40419259667396545,
-0.35598334670066833,
0.5877930521965027,
-0.008272473700344563,
0.16233903169631958,
-0.10724375396966934,
0.30725201964378357,
0.32298484444618225,
0.14643225073814392,
-0.33481863141059875,
0.043726008385419846,
0.9690233469009399,
0.8237258791923523,
0.3874116539955139,
0.12339582294225693,
-0.2133820354938507,
0.3975011110305786,
0.6081143617630005,
-0.9281138777732849,
-0.08929689973592758,
0.6053597331047058,
-0.5839204788208008,
-0.5176084041595459,
-0.09050658345222473,
-1.0973197221755981,
-0.4741825759410858,
-0.13971871137619019,
0.24834172427654266,
-0.47927409410476685,
-0.40679216384887695,
0.29471129179000854,
-0.1802055686712265,
-0.0235883891582489,
0.34877052903175354,
-0.6990810632705688,
0.50392085313797,
0.4650617241859436,
0.8184860348701477,
-0.008991144597530365,
0.10338842868804932,
-0.23924407362937927,
-0.06945405900478363,
0.0005225854110904038,
0.6496667265892029,
-1.1042474508285522,
-0.5150752663612366,
0.11616170406341553,
-0.34975677728652954,
0.09921552240848541,
-0.29088112711906433,
0.43462511897087097,
-0.33180803060531616,
0.24985849857330322,
0.21237912774085999,
-0.6710619330406189,
-0.3060535490512848,
0.43840065598487854,
-0.2878323495388031,
0.8361114859580994,
-0.031434956938028336,
-0.6559097766876221,
-0.07538086175918579,
-1.1790189743041992,
-0.5044217109680176,
-0.13935884833335876,
0.05792095884680748,
-0.36555275321006775,
0.509479820728302,
0.373935341835022,
0.460883229970932,
-0.4225236773490906,
-0.09766693413257599,
-0.35480183362960815,
0.013149465434253216,
0.37336376309394836,
-0.35342010855674744,
0.33991187810897827,
0.10820464789867401,
-0.26788052916526794,
0.44773125648498535,
-0.4869672358036041,
-0.08839384466409683,
0.07278091460466385,
0.0706171989440918,
-0.3269263207912445,
0.010171258822083473,
0.2165898084640503,
0.25368642807006836,
0.38202282786369324,
-0.8531712293624878,
-0.2099771797657013,
-0.6605526208877563,
0.34548595547676086,
0.6916325092315674,
-0.017946669831871986,
0.6707713603973389,
0.08071085065603256,
0.7336390018463135,
0.2613518238067627,
0.3386068344116211,
-0.5129261612892151,
-0.545137882232666,
-0.7931432723999023,
-0.4182298183441162,
-0.07176871597766876,
0.5036008954048157,
-0.24297849833965302,
0.6658322215080261,
-0.02892163209617138,
-0.45533034205436707,
-1.098877191543579,
-0.1887841820716858,
0.49041497707366943,
0.4355129599571228,
0.38649559020996094,
-0.687082052230835,
-0.3603850305080414,
-0.720123291015625,
-0.3687264621257782,
0.012929342687129974,
-0.2646932303905487,
0.7417289614677429,
0.18632613122463226,
-0.6084164977073669,
0.9267078042030334,
-0.5058768391609192,
-0.22438643872737885,
-0.21136407554149628,
0.14302198588848114,
-0.15630018711090088,
0.33925649523735046,
0.28526705503463745,
-0.6845045685768127,
-0.6650362014770508,
0.28302231431007385,
-0.8446417450904846,
-0.14540019631385803,
-0.10655363649129868,
-0.28633183240890503,
0.24888160824775696,
0.2339278608560562,
-0.671764075756073,
0.46349257230758667,
0.45258912444114685,
-0.37479522824287415,
-0.1704898625612259,
-0.03769766911864281,
0.30644723773002625,
-1.2561436891555786,
0.09732761234045029,
0.019086768850684166,
-0.14317885041236877,
-0.7333325743675232,
0.22378674149513245,
-0.0844903364777565,
-0.4165155589580536,
-0.35530272126197815,
0.7474963068962097,
-0.2818434536457062,
0.07511685788631439,
-0.3941187262535095,
0.34393519163131714,
0.13460120558738708,
0.5649476051330566,
0.003820231184363365,
0.10329762101173401,
0.7581419348716736,
-0.22275106608867645,
0.4581363797187805,
0.5181366801261902,
0.4483034014701843,
0.6332234740257263,
-0.7043745517730713,
0.40832850337028503,
-0.15995387732982635,
0.11021776497364044,
-1.058573603630066,
-0.30164775252342224,
0.35324862599372864,
-1.0429490804672241,
0.2892705202102661,
0.07474390417337418,
-0.3328043520450592,
-0.3384544551372528,
-0.32518211007118225,
0.16509275138378143,
0.8824881315231323,
-0.21791040897369385,
1.221924901008606,
0.4269270896911621,
-0.4074830412864685,
-0.33532458543777466,
-0.45964255928993225,
0.04642489552497864,
-0.15077748894691467,
-0.7963891625404358,
-0.07651662081480026,
-0.0444682240486145,
-0.2157193273305893,
-0.005089812912046909,
-0.017922861501574516,
0.03157886490225792,
0.2138485461473465,
0.46193596720695496,
0.006325937807559967,
-0.091349758207798,
0.2238672524690628,
0.3423667252063751,
-0.12012910842895508,
0.22982384264469147,
0.07377322763204575,
0.6359162330627441,
0.01720908284187317,
-0.4537847340106964,
-0.6556852459907532,
0.6874250173568726,
0.684862494468689,
-0.5478878021240234,
0.6427173018455505,
0.6021484136581421,
-0.41773033142089844,
-0.10177399963140488,
-0.3994836211204529,
-0.5799261927604675,
-0.4800454378128052,
0.37522923946380615,
-0.2976587116718292,
-0.8802576065063477,
0.6819765567779541,
-0.07120587676763535,
0.16654077172279358,
0.17831455171108246,
0.7239790558815002,
-0.1586860716342926,
1.3726732730865479,
0.49815139174461365,
-0.21737894415855408,
0.497514009475708,
0.13133470714092255,
0.49398764967918396,
-0.88984215259552,
-0.19042246043682098,
-0.2909291386604309,
-0.5392624735832214,
-0.4600801169872284,
-0.5542452335357666,
0.11710145324468613,
-0.3541078269481659,
-0.36731037497520447,
-0.14227107167243958,
-0.6964494585990906,
0.1800972819328308,
0.5028036832809448,
0.3574289381504059,
-0.030227715149521828,
-0.08312024921178818,
0.47543224692344666,
-0.049576785415410995,
-0.41273561120033264,
-0.6920844912528992,
1.0974993705749512,
0.5607349872589111,
0.7046694159507751,
-0.02986239083111286,
0.7741150259971619,
0.18638046085834503,
0.4713270366191864,
-0.8455820083618164,
0.5548354983329773,
-0.12361220270395279,
-0.3657267689704895,
-0.21432572603225708,
-0.36753785610198975,
-0.6650781631469727,
0.11682137101888657,
-0.08948037028312683,
-0.7121551632881165,
-0.1066153272986412,
0.2727176547050476,
-0.46142762899398804,
-0.0404433012008667,
-0.7006681561470032,
0.8307362198829651,
-0.021366743370890617,
-0.20432095229625702,
-0.42126208543777466,
-0.9397916793823242,
-0.013008072972297668,
0.09224990755319595,
-0.007473696954548359,
-0.2618197500705719,
-0.10217910259962082,
0.44027185440063477,
-0.2699296772480011,
1.0009011030197144,
-0.4204581677913666,
0.01806248165667057,
0.532357394695282,
0.19615131616592407,
0.3763829171657562,
0.0872536450624466,
-0.10299815237522125,
0.1454552859067917,
-0.7513773441314697,
-0.286275714635849,
-0.7370659708976746,
0.4945453703403473,
-0.9249519109725952,
-0.3696151375770569,
0.0736469030380249,
-0.5749701857566833,
-0.23731975257396698,
-0.15111535787582397,
0.06819673627614975,
0.38888952136039734,
-0.258167028427124,
0.2597525119781494,
0.6138648986816406,
-0.5622777938842773,
0.192826047539711,
0.2615274488925934,
0.061400849372148514,
-0.331021785736084,
0.8788573145866394,
-0.5029019117355347,
0.13739776611328125,
0.4056035578250885,
0.08313588052988052,
-0.14338549971580505,
0.0673433467745781,
-0.22789853811264038,
-0.08380004018545151,
-0.4615401029586792,
-0.3784014880657196,
-1.2271562814712524,
-0.04579399153590202,
-0.5478841662406921,
-0.669629693031311,
-0.7352519631385803,
-0.02098805643618107,
-0.5380309224128723,
-0.05807222053408623,
0.7498852610588074,
0.36030927300453186,
0.2147839069366455,
0.6852448582649231,
-1.0179213285446167,
0.3026345372200012,
0.17503561079502106,
0.26900848746299744,
0.2171226590871811,
-0.6377732157707214,
-0.11205220222473145,
0.13158266246318817,
-0.4088761806488037,
-0.8005434274673462,
0.9283849596977234,
0.29196083545684814,
0.16690053045749664,
0.682094156742096,
0.1966615915298462,
0.41045916080474854,
-0.3640224039554596,
0.7120480537414551,
0.3238736689090729,
-1.2535641193389893,
0.7076057195663452,
-0.45154839754104614,
0.2665562927722931,
0.2547787129878998,
0.18487638235092163,
-0.5287358164787292,
-0.8634575605392456,
-0.7854642868041992,
-1.1521306037902832,
0.7668124437332153,
0.5171489715576172,
0.6650784015655518,
-0.08460194617509842,
0.05938555300235748,
0.04696009308099747,
0.2691918611526489,
-0.3189879059791565,
-0.03395790234208107,
-0.30218496918678284,
-0.8877403140068054,
0.020826110616326332,
-0.2053985595703125,
-0.04191458970308304,
0.19325774908065796,
0.3399355709552765,
-0.2563929557800293,
0.7232185006141663,
0.04758066684007645,
-0.07843592017889023,
-0.11085935682058334,
0.004476077854633331,
0.22924169898033142,
-0.34794604778289795,
-0.14065790176391602,
-0.18905384838581085,
0.2267063707113266,
-0.1518726348876953,
-0.34676676988601685,
-0.06991789489984512,
0.4549727737903595,
-0.17967669665813446,
0.19726791977882385,
0.9187929630279541,
0.2545901834964752,
-0.8300102353096008,
0.6231275200843811,
-0.11659952998161316,
0.2065686732530594,
-0.1145198717713356,
0.04977017641067505,
0.3269883394241333,
0.5623986124992371,
0.04452352970838547,
0.3034013509750366,
0.520301342010498,
-0.46441033482551575,
0.19197122752666473,
0.20027336478233337,
-0.7115067839622498,
-0.5042634606361389,
0.718087911605835,
0.8044681549072266,
-0.5188676118850708,
0.6822242140769958,
0.19262172281742096,
-0.705779492855072,
0.8475515842437744,
0.42118752002716064,
1.2371947765350342,
-0.6006377935409546,
0.06405039876699448,
0.16722099483013153,
-0.07736321538686752,
0.318575382232666,
0.601241946220398,
-0.1014467179775238,
-0.947268009185791,
0.08037246763706207,
-0.507767379283905,
-0.6682068109512329,
-0.6313692331314087,
-0.9765723347663879,
0.14126715064048767,
-0.35876280069351196,
-0.3169601559638977,
-0.3380294144153595,
-0.4720381498336792,
-0.7724074125289917,
0.43923425674438477,
0.39838916063308716,
0.6144094467163086,
-0.9010812044143677,
0.204861119389534,
0.8719844222068787,
-0.16111810505390167,
-0.34418877959251404,
-0.03411898389458656,
-0.08048443496227264,
-0.7115896940231323,
0.07272909581661224,
0.4979795217514038,
-0.21609732508659363,
0.15187717974185944,
-0.5213625431060791,
-0.36327505111694336,
0.7139841914176941,
0.24832452833652496,
-0.5287182927131653,
0.2071600705385208,
-0.0028795446269214153,
0.9276913404464722,
-0.7756372690200806,
0.7836339473724365,
0.30943694710731506,
0.14014171063899994,
0.1284288763999939,
-0.4305097758769989,
-0.05745663121342659,
-0.6215871572494507,
-0.011513282544910908,
0.09597562253475189,
-0.8681093454360962,
0.5950700044631958,
-0.18859973549842834,
-0.10263141989707947,
-0.2315872758626938,
0.6541950702667236,
0.3023051619529724,
0.34539496898651123,
0.3497805893421173,
0.47315913438796997,
0.5751893520355225,
0.07565603405237198,
1.1021316051483154,
-0.702212929725647,
0.2051125019788742,
0.960482120513916,
-0.49765968322753906,
0.983063817024231,
0.2383066713809967,
0.243105947971344,
0.24061442911624908,
0.636158287525177,
0.10712239146232605,
0.38128745555877686,
-0.1560591459274292,
-0.3550127148628235,
-0.35387152433395386,
-0.3197854161262512,
-0.013487384654581547,
0.5588626265525818,
0.4620300233364105,
-0.6537231206893921,
0.21743722259998322,
0.25306496024131775,
-0.029728112742304802,
0.11129526048898697,
-0.36120861768722534,
0.9465850591659546,
0.23387685418128967,
-0.22178426384925842,
-0.07528380304574966,
-0.23561164736747742,
0.7193974852561951,
-0.23526602983474731,
0.1463530957698822,
-0.283670574426651,
0.2738402485847473,
-0.06524208933115005,
-0.8590089082717896,
0.24272790551185608,
0.3496732711791992,
-0.082657590508461,
-0.31486183404922485,
0.8758560419082642,
-0.4850892722606659,
-0.4163224697113037,
0.7218307852745056,
0.46820515394210815,
0.10261042416095734,
-0.47329291701316833,
-0.5026919841766357,
0.1646442711353302,
-0.047359928488731384,
-0.6214310526847839,
0.050726085901260376,
0.8872258067131042,
0.30441296100616455,
0.6963891386985779,
0.31061607599258423,
-0.41035962104797363,
-0.2266693264245987,
0.4036969840526581,
1.028197169303894,
-0.6468019485473633,
-0.541764497756958,
-1.1379002332687378,
1.0642528533935547,
-0.3790828287601471,
-0.3856539726257324,
0.5149977803230286,
0.2781551778316498,
0.3466608226299286,
-0.19380387663841248,
0.904116690158844,
0.06837205588817596,
0.4291110038757324,
0.12841565907001495,
0.7296954989433289,
-0.7631354331970215,
-0.30963611602783203,
-0.5621829628944397,
-0.6793768405914307,
-0.4254225194454193,
0.6777040958404541,
-0.06416157633066177,
0.059296030551195145,
0.34961846470832825,
0.6932623982429504,
0.13066759705543518,
0.24511761963367462,
0.5306882262229919,
0.2877863347530365,
0.20936915278434753,
0.6539838314056396,
0.8124658465385437,
-0.3149649202823639,
0.27063262462615967,
0.17863823473453522,
-0.35037311911582947,
-0.5665766596794128,
-0.4146096110343933,
-1.0564017295837402,
-0.2600597143173218,
-0.38049033284187317,
-0.09500458836555481,
-0.051041826605796814,
1.1073856353759766,
0.38211289048194885,
-0.6597574949264526,
0.026423385366797447,
-0.027624614536762238,
-0.3172386586666107,
0.14685207605361938,
-0.22293035686016083,
0.05611675977706909,
-0.4197919964790344,
-1.0049667358398438,
0.050857093185186386,
0.6583279967308044,
-0.1086457297205925,
0.028233608230948448,
-0.12941840291023254,
0.508293628692627,
0.648566484451294,
0.8297039866447449,
-0.2654409110546112,
-0.505679190158844,
-0.2836621105670929,
0.25492429733276367,
-0.17330734431743622,
0.23261873424053192,
0.47788968682289124,
-0.4255675673484802,
0.7897195219993591,
0.39141374826431274,
0.8470216989517212,
0.1365337371826172,
0.1730642020702362,
0.8695598244667053,
-0.8064463138580322,
0.10258866846561432,
0.5905776023864746,
0.2797182500362396,
0.42459574341773987,
-0.5272946953773499,
0.39501050114631653,
-0.13042162358760834,
-0.439247727394104,
-0.8472760319709778,
0.2097364217042923,
-1.169753909111023,
0.07410629838705063,
1.1042057275772095,
-0.32713839411735535,
-0.22612906992435455,
0.30117547512054443,
-0.5336645245552063,
0.6077632904052734,
-1.048383116722107,
0.95362788438797,
0.37140846252441406,
-0.23539507389068604,
-0.25560513138771057,
-0.19061174988746643,
0.15186190605163574,
0.4897465407848358,
-0.9792433381080627,
0.29336321353912354,
0.3007555305957794,
-0.24832193553447723,
0.15373244881629944,
0.4218690097332001,
0.026765726506710052,
0.0404510572552681,
0.2547004818916321,
0.7417537569999695,
0.22918139398097992,
-0.19667725265026093,
-0.34425219893455505,
0.2600767910480499,
-0.27715355157852173,
-0.33180922269821167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16192v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16192v2
|
Defending Large Language Models against Jailbreak Attacks via Semantic Smoothing
| 2024-02-25T20:36:03 | 2024-02-28T23:11:33 |
Jiabao Ji, Bairu Hou, Alexander Robey, George J. Pappas, Hamed Hassani, Yang Zhang, Eric Wong, Shiyu Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aligned large language models (LLMs) are vulnerable to jailbreaking attacks,
which bypass the safeguards of targeted LLMs and fool them into generating
objectionable content. While initial defenses show promise against token-based
threat models, there do not exist defenses that provide robustness against
semantic attacks and avoid unfavorable trade-offs between robustness and
nominal performance. To meet this need, we propose SEMANTICSMOOTH, a
smoothing-based defense that aggregates the predictions of multiple
semantically transformed copies of a given input prompt. Experimental results
demonstrate that SEMANTICSMOOTH achieves state-of-the-art robustness against
GCG, PAIR, and AutoDAN attacks while maintaining strong nominal performance on
instruction following benchmarks such as InstructionFollowing and AlpacaEval.
The codes will be publicly available at
https://github.com/UCSB-NLP-Chang/SemanticSmooth.
|
[
-0.3603666424751282,
-1.131870985031128,
0.5327318906784058,
0.06465774774551392,
-0.11979055404663086,
-0.12085723131895065,
-0.19041527807712555,
-0.45917874574661255,
0.2908485531806946,
0.915992796421051,
-0.6646878719329834,
-0.47873353958129883,
-0.9772289991378784,
-0.10060351341962814,
-0.7829651832580566,
0.8534454107284546,
0.22730322182178497,
-0.310261070728302,
-0.09324797242879868,
0.07640693336725235,
-0.7203018665313721,
-0.41467443108558655,
-0.3872501850128174,
-0.0698959231376648,
0.4308708906173706,
0.21390105783939362,
0.9251790046691895,
0.533102810382843,
0.5641672611236572,
0.3946596086025238,
0.22343069314956665,
0.0032617049291729927,
-0.29143786430358887,
0.652877151966095,
-0.23794542253017426,
-0.14260675013065338,
-0.5073270797729492,
-0.20948097109794617,
0.3397308886051178,
0.2313908040523529,
-0.2037186473608017,
-0.25050756335258484,
-0.31864404678344727,
0.41594836115837097,
-0.7214785814285278,
-0.19320102035999298,
-1.3222616910934448,
-0.22938935458660126,
-0.6009579300880432,
0.07588239759206772,
-0.6615781188011169,
0.10127903521060944,
-0.030492199584841728,
-0.5109794735908508,
-0.08647245168685913,
0.1552264243364334,
0.9537930488586426,
0.38184991478919983,
-0.2841508090496063,
-0.21247117221355438,
-0.16912543773651123,
0.6208775639533997,
-0.8793333172798157,
0.22305400669574738,
0.6398154497146606,
0.3507736623287201,
-1.010940670967102,
-0.708784818649292,
-0.48781251907348633,
-0.417923241853714,
0.09681180864572525,
0.04306655749678612,
-0.5090416073799133,
0.32456985116004944,
0.3455462157726288,
0.05123821645975113,
-0.4830152988433838,
0.5443185567855835,
-0.2950550615787506,
-0.5840422511100769,
0.4356382489204407,
0.1957257241010666,
0.6458610892295837,
-0.23816055059432983,
-0.5227537155151367,
-0.11609440296888351,
-0.5921980738639832,
0.007640647701919079,
0.5670445561408997,
0.3518644869327545,
-0.13623809814453125,
0.7257463932037354,
-0.2954769730567932,
0.8204755783081055,
-0.08616640418767929,
-0.4327647387981415,
-0.06571318209171295,
-0.033852215856313705,
-0.0640803650021553,
0.17027266323566437,
0.84957355260849,
0.4318994879722595,
0.1168876513838768,
-0.4594130218029022,
-0.2635734975337982,
0.40077829360961914,
0.5301111340522766,
-0.9053208231925964,
-0.1711619794368744,
0.4146783947944641,
-0.07219265401363373,
-0.3425889313220978,
0.1455375850200653,
-0.8557575345039368,
-0.47556087374687195,
0.12833371758460999,
0.3304201662540436,
-0.6950311064720154,
0.08113997429609299,
0.3448428511619568,
-0.019759120419621468,
0.12026523798704147,
0.07842135429382324,
-1.0868721008300781,
0.47090664505958557,
1.0070369243621826,
0.728503406047821,
-0.3122834861278534,
-0.2675471305847168,
-0.8404541611671448,
0.37456128001213074,
-0.0350341796875,
0.8494611382484436,
-0.5893240571022034,
-0.6873568892478943,
-0.06910229474306107,
-0.08338795602321625,
-0.19709493219852448,
-0.30403026938438416,
1.006367564201355,
-0.6623381972312927,
-0.0031340536661446095,
0.260552316904068,
-0.7364346385002136,
0.16459845006465912,
0.45245662331581116,
-0.8284978270530701,
0.9391704201698303,
-0.11187611520290375,
-1.0285671949386597,
0.1936730593442917,
-0.37061992287635803,
-0.4460829794406891,
-0.18681010603904724,
0.006156284827739,
-0.30759504437446594,
0.16373935341835022,
0.47016429901123047,
0.32594841718673706,
-0.14681051671504974,
0.25224360823631287,
-0.5514797568321228,
-0.04451322183012962,
0.29899001121520996,
-0.377259224653244,
0.5011352300643921,
0.29349666833877563,
-0.12675172090530396,
0.44416847825050354,
-0.7624841332435608,
-0.07216662913560867,
0.14721262454986572,
-0.04119357466697693,
-0.5084065794944763,
0.14359554648399353,
-0.40124955773353577,
0.3413272202014923,
0.15974517166614532,
-0.7821207642555237,
0.25736185908317566,
-0.6135369539260864,
0.5538618564605713,
0.8398595452308655,
-0.0986403077840805,
0.27338868379592896,
-0.22766953706741333,
0.44526591897010803,
0.008851553313434124,
0.16126134991645813,
-0.3721048831939697,
-0.5268280506134033,
-0.4402972459793091,
-0.6646713614463806,
0.2678597569465637,
0.549511730670929,
-0.785237193107605,
0.36649248003959656,
-0.3061818480491638,
-0.48110681772232056,
-0.4512946903705597,
0.3109457194805145,
0.23672063648700714,
0.6966537833213806,
0.4405929744243622,
-0.18470481038093567,
-0.34650611877441406,
-0.890975296497345,
-0.5864518284797668,
-0.1956777423620224,
-0.12960664927959442,
-0.20427879691123962,
0.28639912605285645,
-0.40202638506889343,
0.7841376066207886,
-0.5128788948059082,
-0.12197394669055939,
0.025610053911805153,
-0.10173245519399643,
0.028675636276602745,
0.5991215705871582,
0.5992616415023804,
-0.44297555088996887,
0.03945038467645645,
-0.38877034187316895,
-0.3893918991088867,
-0.38262560963630676,
0.04286035895347595,
-0.40031030774116516,
0.10141429305076599,
0.8231731057167053,
-0.849091112613678,
0.42810046672821045,
0.6435511708259583,
-0.6291784644126892,
0.5201481580734253,
-0.05549731105566025,
-0.17407754063606262,
-1.0998808145523071,
-0.4293982684612274,
-0.0881488174200058,
-0.4345394968986511,
-0.5796062350273132,
0.341165691614151,
-0.11961749941110611,
-0.11745774745941162,
-0.34822332859039307,
0.7020982503890991,
0.1712067574262619,
0.16359035670757294,
-0.420359343290329,
0.21797741949558258,
-0.012211451306939125,
0.05603395402431488,
-0.21173380315303802,
0.4913301169872284,
0.59812331199646,
-0.41937384009361267,
0.4024502635002136,
0.09329774975776672,
-0.24911491572856903,
0.54385906457901,
-0.8614250421524048,
0.15784573554992676,
0.09908726811408997,
0.4091375470161438,
-0.9624100923538208,
-0.37546294927597046,
0.11123666912317276,
-0.5154395699501038,
0.3958718180656433,
-0.2650756537914276,
-0.5820648074150085,
-0.3058850169181824,
-0.3866141140460968,
0.19070406258106232,
0.5268770456314087,
-0.4321686923503876,
0.6750807166099548,
0.38906553387641907,
-0.1900065541267395,
-0.5659459829330444,
-0.571313738822937,
0.33605629205703735,
-0.3879205584526062,
-0.9153090715408325,
0.34691858291625977,
0.20963892340660095,
-0.444299578666687,
-0.13215431571006775,
-0.16218477487564087,
0.1584906131029129,
0.5823858976364136,
0.4083823561668396,
0.5001814961433411,
0.11492166668176651,
-0.1701197773218155,
0.1071685403585434,
-0.47992584109306335,
0.3415072560310364,
-0.7204296588897705,
0.6034941077232361,
0.1634180247783661,
-0.5307321548461914,
-0.27101898193359375,
0.2753399908542633,
0.7258778810501099,
-0.028681078925728798,
0.7456348538398743,
0.6527014374732971,
-0.30714496970176697,
-0.1363592892885208,
-0.6032683253288269,
-0.23103250563144684,
-0.5326870083808899,
0.4235764443874359,
-0.3424648940563202,
-1.1641597747802734,
0.5938454270362854,
0.04143111780285835,
0.2988288104534149,
0.5539625883102417,
0.7433329224586487,
0.15975016355514526,
0.850389838218689,
0.4050743281841278,
-0.264120876789093,
0.36948564648628235,
0.3423808515071869,
0.14403438568115234,
-0.5162362456321716,
-0.2707221806049347,
-0.6613989472389221,
0.0068483198992908,
-0.8271198272705078,
-0.2930426001548767,
0.10355062037706375,
-0.00000964705668593524,
-0.12258506566286087,
0.5439591407775879,
-0.21762940287590027,
0.2849632799625397,
0.42451515793800354,
0.0619293712079525,
0.19836267828941345,
-0.12641575932502747,
-0.30329322814941406,
-0.030060583725571632,
-0.373105525970459,
-0.3475254476070404,
0.9513163566589355,
0.4817095398902893,
1.0011277198791504,
0.23008351027965546,
0.7673258781433105,
0.45279887318611145,
-0.15539385378360748,
-0.7078206539154053,
0.5518997311592102,
-0.12293531745672226,
-0.5051928162574768,
-0.18751005828380585,
-0.5522657036781311,
-0.8032304048538208,
0.418075293302536,
-0.23363767564296722,
-1.1671737432479858,
-0.2958020567893982,
0.09932930022478104,
-0.13791309297084808,
0.4155650734901428,
-0.6140081882476807,
0.8347844481468201,
-0.26516371965408325,
-0.3628179430961609,
-0.24677854776382446,
-0.6660777926445007,
0.6359817981719971,
-0.18918459117412567,
0.39744168519973755,
-0.577692449092865,
0.04086774215102196,
0.7697581052780151,
-0.7810255885124207,
0.7985752820968628,
-0.1713097244501114,
-0.18717609345912933,
0.06002793461084366,
0.36898666620254517,
0.4789498448371887,
0.1483924388885498,
0.10632046312093735,
0.004310650750994682,
0.1175023764371872,
-0.7250765562057495,
-0.575977087020874,
0.9787492752075195,
-0.4833963215351105,
-0.9340671300888062,
-0.20208650827407837,
-0.7946658134460449,
-0.3593657314777374,
0.3012807369232178,
0.27864062786102295,
0.536024808883667,
-0.007036454509943724,
-0.229326069355011,
0.7634927034378052,
-0.14871840178966522,
0.4248240888118744,
0.23574203252792358,
-0.31576067209243774,
-0.39051002264022827,
0.7733432650566101,
-0.18845418095588684,
0.4607163369655609,
0.20579001307487488,
0.31027698516845703,
-0.1793355941772461,
-0.5098015069961548,
-0.3825066387653351,
-0.15399087965488434,
-0.6402871608734131,
-0.42007267475128174,
-0.6901536583900452,
0.02545703575015068,
-0.6025769114494324,
-0.21507087349891663,
-0.3699595630168915,
-0.7504833936691284,
0.4261090159416199,
-0.06261184811592102,
0.7646569609642029,
0.4093738794326782,
0.13613739609718323,
0.3217714726924896,
-0.6837993860244751,
0.444033145904541,
0.23799708485603333,
0.2027708739042282,
-0.17053784430027008,
-0.847148060798645,
0.11664732545614243,
-0.16281439363956451,
-0.22013354301452637,
-0.579999566078186,
0.325512558221817,
0.06165088713169098,
0.3949587643146515,
0.3709844648838043,
0.3028952479362488,
0.6424868106842041,
-0.6589680910110474,
0.5961920022964478,
0.26197922229766846,
-0.8189846873283386,
0.48458796739578247,
-0.4526400566101074,
0.38439708948135376,
0.7241472601890564,
-0.1003573015332222,
-0.2891891598701477,
-0.6788427829742432,
-0.5511879920959473,
-1.0347102880477905,
0.4698392450809479,
-0.008962283842265606,
0.4169716238975525,
-0.1553749442100525,
0.266869455575943,
0.07212451100349426,
0.07706684619188309,
-0.40905722975730896,
-0.03921554237604141,
-0.3371296226978302,
-0.21346639096736908,
0.3361063599586487,
-0.3086569011211395,
-0.2139849066734314,
-0.2094346582889557,
0.6134931445121765,
0.04071630910038948,
0.11493590474128723,
-0.010716503486037254,
-0.2714557647705078,
0.44060853123664856,
0.3512454032897949,
0.6783483624458313,
0.14264196157455444,
-0.06922276318073273,
0.3101872205734253,
0.0715111717581749,
-0.8441882729530334,
0.13778840005397797,
0.233278289437294,
-0.23542869091033936,
-0.22973750531673431,
0.5877147316932678,
0.840350866317749,
0.4059491455554962,
-0.8141360282897949,
0.40588364005088806,
-0.23292389512062073,
-0.017315179109573364,
-0.16118286550045013,
0.12873345613479614,
-0.14627555012702942,
-0.15022823214530945,
-0.0811559185385704,
-0.14161428809165955,
0.02760852500796318,
-0.4378107190132141,
0.33282938599586487,
0.39577120542526245,
-0.3931884765625,
-0.14712940156459808,
0.7033700346946716,
-0.09098908305168152,
0.018451234325766563,
0.6919489502906799,
0.18404081463813782,
-0.6595814824104309,
0.4313637614250183,
0.7487927079200745,
0.9116666316986084,
-0.13275837898254395,
-0.2693437933921814,
0.044615618884563446,
0.43493223190307617,
0.08158759027719498,
-0.1512427031993866,
0.014475986361503601,
-0.6557409763336182,
-0.2872236967086792,
-0.6672627925872803,
-0.31548771262168884,
-0.2018359899520874,
-0.5730253458023071,
0.3397662341594696,
-0.7059040665626526,
-0.23427936434745789,
-0.022034669294953346,
-0.41369199752807617,
-0.1739474982023239,
-0.13210757076740265,
0.25214728713035583,
1.2500232458114624,
-0.4779532849788666,
1.0213779211044312,
0.353723406791687,
-0.1191713809967041,
-0.5645401477813721,
-0.02375943399965763,
0.2659882605075836,
-0.7164782881736755,
0.3911850154399872,
0.2785578966140747,
-0.35550013184547424,
-0.4025043845176697,
-0.4715334475040436,
-0.7538842558860779,
0.678094208240509,
0.5871738791465759,
-0.3473037779331207,
-0.04569138586521149,
0.04868438094854355,
0.12324307858943939,
-0.11767672002315521,
0.0775168314576149,
0.8464857339859009,
0.466952383518219,
0.13075631856918335,
-0.8055195212364197,
0.05210975557565689,
-0.17254695296287537,
-0.1461707204580307,
0.4323742985725403,
-0.4561416804790497,
0.5738583207130432,
-0.09465941786766052,
0.056138962507247925,
0.22077623009681702,
0.8603865504264832,
0.3381563723087311,
0.11068469285964966,
0.4712546467781067,
1.0220186710357666,
0.66609126329422,
-0.40969642996788025,
1.2536638975143433,
-0.39591309428215027,
-0.12081354856491089,
1.2439305782318115,
-0.2869325280189514,
0.8264623284339905,
0.4904056489467621,
0.19764377176761627,
0.6490581631660461,
0.3290470838546753,
0.08297213166952133,
0.6274825930595398,
0.3574516475200653,
-0.15507322549819946,
-0.26835012435913086,
0.04865611717104912,
-0.1653796285390854,
0.657801628112793,
0.6154224276542664,
0.12298914790153503,
-0.30698275566101074,
0.13340438902378082,
0.7705211639404297,
0.2544618844985962,
-0.37458330392837524,
0.8226467967033386,
0.07489196211099625,
-0.6701890230178833,
0.3900676667690277,
0.4435315430164337,
0.8182284832000732,
-1.1088120937347412,
0.2783118188381195,
0.06217089667916298,
0.22295111417770386,
-0.27330482006073,
-0.5338984131813049,
0.2884925901889801,
0.03639868274331093,
-0.10508182644844055,
0.18250247836112976,
0.920029878616333,
-0.19805088639259338,
-0.44432902336120605,
0.47019162774086,
-0.06190898269414902,
-0.32265302538871765,
0.2352767288684845,
-0.6415896415710449,
0.4084410071372986,
-0.4746554493904114,
-0.1668972373008728,
0.695343554019928,
0.3079586327075958,
-0.33965954184532166,
0.8359073400497437,
0.6683469414710999,
-0.1136091873049736,
0.4900982975959778,
-0.05190105363726616,
1.0722761154174805,
-0.38466715812683105,
-0.568882942199707,
-1.2240523099899292,
0.25825560092926025,
-0.1828005611896515,
-0.2224830836057663,
1.077839732170105,
0.25517919659614563,
0.7163094878196716,
0.393002986907959,
0.5153979659080505,
-0.0893612951040268,
0.2851378917694092,
-0.9739254117012024,
0.5459688305854797,
0.013119570910930634,
0.3125966787338257,
-0.5194801092147827,
-0.5611957907676697,
-0.39184850454330444,
0.2937023937702179,
-0.42991578578948975,
-0.14710110425949097,
0.5435991287231445,
0.6854314804077148,
0.04131966829299927,
-0.04840940982103348,
0.34273043274879456,
0.28754425048828125,
0.6125423908233643,
0.44982415437698364,
0.6529642939567566,
-0.24052274227142334,
0.16313357651233673,
-0.17758852243423462,
-0.0710042342543602,
0.04037642478942871,
-1.1368359327316284,
-1.0417040586471558,
-0.3371128737926483,
-0.039725493639707565,
-0.8332450985908508,
0.1854110062122345,
0.9114010334014893,
0.6231900453567505,
-0.8779324889183044,
0.00437981728464365,
0.14554080367088318,
0.06630532443523407,
0.18274500966072083,
-0.17683526873588562,
0.34917768836021423,
-0.5662369132041931,
-0.3033403754234314,
0.6016603112220764,
0.25663161277770996,
-0.2378014475107193,
-0.35356834530830383,
0.056028857827186584,
-0.08322365581989288,
0.38577648997306824,
0.43290215730667114,
0.3570258319377899,
-0.9143606424331665,
-0.3777444660663605,
-0.28106367588043213,
-0.09463629871606827,
-0.37669554352760315,
0.9203604459762573,
-0.8216824531555176,
0.5661661028862,
0.34052813053131104,
1.010725975036621,
0.060225509107112885,
0.04612326622009277,
0.5734506249427795,
-0.6425200700759888,
0.7094454765319824,
-0.05542413145303726,
0.7110059857368469,
0.2466563880443573,
-0.2719976007938385,
0.187603160738945,
0.228188619017601,
-0.41193699836730957,
-0.7965409755706787,
0.5035996437072754,
-0.9870328307151794,
-0.2637118399143219,
0.9774749279022217,
-0.29440802335739136,
-0.49621620774269104,
-0.06256797164678574,
-0.06213405355811119,
-0.2523934841156006,
-0.5448887944221497,
0.774570882320404,
0.7856922745704651,
0.266760915517807,
0.2507566511631012,
-0.7264803051948547,
0.4703710079193115,
0.38314172625541687,
-0.6861788034439087,
0.18847142159938812,
0.5375972986221313,
0.16043241322040558,
0.018532924354076385,
0.09890756756067276,
-0.5611178874969482,
0.24234814941883087,
0.02539522759616375,
-0.2268162965774536,
-0.36863136291503906,
-0.29694274067878723,
-0.35465335845947266,
0.12083997577428818,
0.25075459480285645,
-0.0036316143814474344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16187v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16187v2
|
No Free Lunch in LLM Watermarking: Trade-offs in Watermarking Design Choices
| 2024-02-25T20:24:07 | 2024-05-25T20:51:49 |
Qi Pang, Shengyuan Hu, Wenting Zheng, Virginia Smith
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Advances in generative models have made it possible for AI-generated text,
code, and images to mirror human-generated content in many applications.
Watermarking, a technique that aims to embed information in the output of a
model to verify its source, is useful for mitigating the misuse of such
AI-generated content. However, we show that common design choices in LLM
watermarking schemes make the resulting systems surprisingly susceptible to
attack -- leading to fundamental trade-offs in robustness, utility, and
usability. To navigate these trade-offs, we rigorously study a set of simple
yet effective attacks on common watermarking systems, and propose guidelines
and defenses for LLM watermarking in practice.
|
[
-0.4603997766971588,
-0.49664226174354553,
0.5066499710083008,
-0.19273239374160767,
-0.6585662364959717,
0.10921648889780045,
0.49551522731781006,
-0.6716364622116089,
0.13673020899295807,
0.7470579147338867,
-0.41304031014442444,
-0.2737000286579132,
-0.724259614944458,
-0.10948634147644043,
-0.6250237226486206,
0.8143198490142822,
-0.0981159657239914,
-0.08117902278900146,
-0.5246886014938354,
-0.3218578100204468,
-0.43868422508239746,
-0.7606241703033447,
-0.7497163414955139,
-0.30616605281829834,
0.5718995332717896,
0.07800609618425369,
0.8148383498191833,
0.6984219551086426,
0.6864712834358215,
0.16958685219287872,
-0.030463818460702896,
0.10215912014245987,
-0.3705978989601135,
0.3440619111061096,
-0.14645124971866608,
-0.4789504110813141,
-0.18033257126808167,
0.13257507979869843,
0.23204143345355988,
0.21710142493247986,
0.4150075912475586,
0.19515587389469147,
0.1617940366268158,
0.9560484290122986,
-1.0491044521331787,
-0.04928380623459816,
-0.7449998259544373,
0.26758313179016113,
-0.39541083574295044,
-0.3692503869533539,
-0.4770630896091461,
-0.24755685031414032,
-0.20199935138225555,
-0.5461951494216919,
0.11353563517332077,
0.09562218934297562,
0.7370557188987732,
0.5780504941940308,
-0.10367907583713531,
-0.3681580424308777,
-0.7347900867462158,
0.7096415162086487,
-0.5840945243835449,
-0.016462715342640877,
0.40801283717155457,
0.386301726102829,
-0.023240523412823677,
-0.6649109125137329,
-0.3797653317451477,
-0.04073086753487587,
0.09016434848308563,
0.2931036353111267,
-0.678949773311615,
0.11638277024030685,
0.30770760774612427,
0.38874879479408264,
-0.3352043330669403,
0.09529991447925568,
0.05684715881943703,
-0.15475015342235565,
0.772077202796936,
0.2665289342403412,
0.6588408350944519,
0.1584315448999405,
-0.6279740333557129,
-0.29190418124198914,
-1.216827630996704,
-0.004590557422488928,
0.5428537726402283,
0.10585474222898483,
0.05908319726586342,
0.6346538662910461,
0.05088350549340248,
0.6493571400642395,
-0.2639772891998291,
0.18050223588943481,
-0.43882644176483154,
-0.02893969789147377,
-0.17407895624637604,
-0.12656426429748535,
0.6012054085731506,
0.5625224113464355,
0.32800719141960144,
-0.2801506817340851,
-0.5309534072875977,
-0.08886100351810455,
0.3936101198196411,
-0.670853316783905,
-0.22928503155708313,
0.05183956027030945,
-0.5040323138237,
-0.7051547169685364,
0.23909448087215424,
-0.6370274424552917,
-0.5503183603286743,
-0.022348467260599136,
0.620808482170105,
0.037798602133989334,
0.055003196001052856,
-0.09347564727067947,
-0.5659208297729492,
0.24864616990089417,
0.3413090109825134,
-0.6301870346069336,
0.14718042314052582,
0.5467510223388672,
0.9378111958503723,
-0.5115674138069153,
-0.05028650164604187,
-0.6384041905403137,
0.7017241716384888,
-0.26002025604248047,
1.0869542360305786,
-0.45510828495025635,
-0.9621611833572388,
-0.14311307668685913,
-0.27696359157562256,
0.211281880736351,
-0.7098323106765747,
0.18440411984920502,
-0.8780922293663025,
-0.18200799822807312,
-0.3532872200012207,
-0.6602110266685486,
-0.09631951153278351,
0.09360168129205704,
-1.1495479345321655,
0.4507179856300354,
-0.18781150877475739,
-1.0914138555526733,
0.23940788209438324,
-0.5462766289710999,
-0.5924354791641235,
0.14913327991962433,
-0.09407326579093933,
-0.62022465467453,
0.08452600240707397,
-0.027940183877944946,
0.27666613459587097,
-0.16030621528625488,
-0.1644279807806015,
-0.5564343333244324,
-0.5168503522872925,
0.5091003179550171,
-0.6464678049087524,
0.7792657017707825,
0.3200012147426605,
-0.3230248987674713,
0.0026610831264406443,
-0.6275877356529236,
0.04360956326127052,
0.5321041941642761,
-0.6682291626930237,
-0.5449015498161316,
0.09661268442869186,
-0.03239956870675087,
-0.17947876453399658,
0.18847377598285675,
-0.22553560137748718,
0.22887656092643738,
0.24021682143211365,
0.49772149324417114,
0.9764973521232605,
0.1382746547460556,
0.5193669199943542,
-0.7280740141868591,
0.6857442855834961,
-0.13023443520069122,
0.4196331202983856,
-0.03976805880665779,
-0.73792964220047,
-0.7416273951530457,
-0.4167243540287018,
0.2884373962879181,
0.6020536422729492,
-0.7939644455909729,
-0.11097539961338043,
0.11641859263181686,
-0.3455945551395416,
-0.3755112886428833,
0.3321245312690735,
0.5343073010444641,
0.1692528873682022,
0.37025555968284607,
-0.41193893551826477,
-0.34891852736473083,
-1.0282948017120361,
-0.5688965916633606,
-0.008251149207353592,
-0.16628317534923553,
0.3394078016281128,
0.52074134349823,
-0.03661210834980011,
1.087283730506897,
-0.6118700504302979,
0.01055188849568367,
-0.22099393606185913,
-0.020848073065280914,
-0.1094730943441391,
0.48398295044898987,
0.7351932525634766,
-0.8027569055557251,
-0.3940463662147522,
-0.42267635464668274,
-0.6012650728225708,
-0.1701650172472,
-0.2414589673280716,
-0.1386568546295166,
0.0551893524825573,
0.4020330607891083,
-0.7136724591255188,
0.7723303437232971,
0.43039828538894653,
-0.2092728167772293,
0.4909953773021698,
-0.10041695833206177,
-0.023871183395385742,
-0.9290604591369629,
0.05398142710328102,
-0.31342312693595886,
-0.1620757281780243,
-0.42681336402893066,
0.3670647442340851,
-0.06001412868499756,
-0.2761029899120331,
-0.4534251391887665,
0.7956873178482056,
-0.2969547510147095,
-0.10106760263442993,
-0.5284678936004639,
-0.37052375078201294,
0.36410391330718994,
0.13339389860630035,
-0.15043306350708008,
0.9624251127243042,
0.22790288925170898,
-0.6005144715309143,
0.1658312827348709,
-0.12410460412502289,
-0.15065611898899078,
0.7030417919158936,
-0.9181438684463501,
0.6004401445388794,
-0.02176523581147194,
0.11109556257724762,
-0.9132004976272583,
0.16156871616840363,
0.5657504200935364,
-0.24368999898433685,
0.5297260880470276,
-0.32638439536094666,
-0.5375134348869324,
-0.04395356774330139,
-0.6305185556411743,
0.3580292761325836,
0.2917190492153168,
-0.7799677848815918,
0.5092843174934387,
0.3116236925125122,
0.06175996735692024,
-0.3899153769016266,
-0.9302461743354797,
0.4096503257751465,
-0.3966010510921478,
-0.563617467880249,
0.8372833132743835,
-0.4623856544494629,
-0.47215190529823303,
0.16806699335575104,
-0.12147664278745651,
-0.20404402911663055,
0.5899963974952698,
0.5261187553405762,
0.3380102813243866,
0.016915809363126755,
-0.528677225112915,
-0.08123913407325745,
-0.3890906274318695,
-0.046352703124284744,
0.024117907509207726,
0.3615836501121521,
0.1640043556690216,
-0.934827446937561,
-0.5116259455680847,
0.7389878034591675,
0.5013847351074219,
-0.07592615485191345,
0.4725944399833679,
0.17183062434196472,
-0.4820309281349182,
-0.16030174493789673,
-0.2743358016014099,
-0.11305646598339081,
-0.5087946653366089,
-0.04836516082286835,
-0.05975376442074776,
-0.7506745457649231,
0.5223690867424011,
0.11686383187770844,
0.2145473212003708,
0.29730740189552307,
0.17953477799892426,
-0.3972458839416504,
0.8807868361473083,
0.5195866823196411,
-0.3338533639907837,
0.6724440455436707,
-0.15668371319770813,
0.13171879947185516,
-0.6931819915771484,
-0.023788267746567726,
-0.374654620885849,
-0.30317118763923645,
-0.3940698504447937,
-0.2047676295042038,
-0.014804466627538204,
0.11441265791654587,
-0.15676246583461761,
0.26962810754776,
-0.47427889704704285,
0.764875590801239,
1.0056238174438477,
-0.018873756751418114,
0.5183592438697815,
0.003455322002992034,
0.06717945635318756,
-0.008216247893869877,
-0.5880143046379089,
-0.6606812477111816,
1.1258617639541626,
-0.03736061602830887,
1.004433512687683,
0.09927813708782196,
1.0214922428131104,
0.770819902420044,
0.5500015020370483,
-0.5229176878929138,
0.4509776532649994,
-0.13578402996063232,
-0.6851174235343933,
-0.12325882911682129,
-0.27404993772506714,
-0.9565752744674683,
0.1718778908252716,
-0.09960241615772247,
-0.43322843313217163,
-0.11520165950059891,
0.1751551479101181,
-0.3899044692516327,
0.7486125230789185,
-0.7019608616828918,
0.42518147826194763,
-0.4644295275211334,
-0.450564444065094,
-0.19158470630645752,
-0.2935122847557068,
0.11285462975502014,
-0.02036888524889946,
0.1625569611787796,
0.030328508466482162,
-0.03148767724633217,
0.5839895606040955,
-0.131023108959198,
0.9481258392333984,
-0.07043778896331787,
-0.012953699566423893,
0.3987370729446411,
0.42634591460227966,
0.42956292629241943,
-0.018754342570900917,
0.21424910426139832,
0.19888368248939514,
-0.15478307008743286,
-0.41752728819847107,
-0.4602373540401459,
0.4163441061973572,
-0.6391711831092834,
-0.959380030632019,
-0.4017404019832611,
-0.37804022431373596,
0.08662236481904984,
0.22257870435714722,
0.39717748761177063,
0.10871727764606476,
-0.23880529403686523,
0.05945592373609543,
0.6185821294784546,
-0.3034178614616394,
0.7433358430862427,
0.32365211844444275,
0.08830984681844711,
-0.7008826732635498,
1.0223485231399536,
0.18301253020763397,
0.39110124111175537,
0.36675816774368286,
0.1105126291513443,
-0.10987106710672379,
-0.7146100401878357,
-0.6574491262435913,
-0.20030176639556885,
-0.8926366567611694,
-0.5541974902153015,
-0.11842165887355804,
-0.4909706711769104,
0.11764845252037048,
-0.3370200991630554,
-0.32039326429367065,
-0.4756604731082916,
-0.6146463751792908,
0.06790720671415329,
0.2011842429637909,
1.0409034490585327,
0.10767583549022675,
0.17785222828388214,
-0.7940407991409302,
0.2491699457168579,
0.7733949422836304,
0.2700931131839752,
0.17019274830818176,
-0.33536088466644287,
-0.030988816171884537,
0.07182800024747849,
-0.829762876033783,
-0.835736095905304,
0.0907038226723671,
0.09921768307685852,
0.7921270132064819,
0.6788616180419922,
0.15668825805187225,
0.1823914349079132,
-0.42707088589668274,
0.6755611896514893,
0.2918981611728668,
-0.8141734600067139,
0.5249748229980469,
-0.08906155824661255,
0.027321726083755493,
0.2715599238872528,
0.12433174252510071,
-0.30361464619636536,
-0.16148309409618378,
-0.5708657503128052,
-0.8152176737785339,
0.0935492068529129,
0.38588011264801025,
0.3648744523525238,
0.16351300477981567,
0.2858719229698181,
0.15455114841461182,
0.11058321595191956,
-0.9465472102165222,
-0.34498730301856995,
-0.5041241645812988,
0.18229427933692932,
0.3731837868690491,
-0.4277906119823456,
-0.47556403279304504,
-0.059718649834394455,
0.4652770161628723,
-0.04612526297569275,
0.4393940269947052,
-0.06300899386405945,
-0.22512967884540558,
0.10399448126554489,
0.21574540436267853,
0.5208108425140381,
0.11774986237287521,
-0.04795706272125244,
0.5074146389961243,
-0.016079410910606384,
-0.20810481905937195,
0.1865866780281067,
-0.10787118226289749,
-0.6263335943222046,
-0.1778925210237503,
0.4933052659034729,
0.6404853463172913,
0.2583003640174866,
-0.46814683079719543,
0.4344806969165802,
-0.06898795068264008,
-0.16487360000610352,
-0.0480039045214653,
0.4002271294593811,
0.3218955397605896,
0.3404505252838135,
0.3601384460926056,
0.06547825038433075,
0.1043691411614418,
-0.17920489609241486,
0.10288482904434204,
0.8314871191978455,
-0.009246109053492546,
-0.20506002008914948,
0.8249489068984985,
0.10422659665346146,
-0.4886058568954468,
0.5604512691497803,
0.11516586691141129,
-0.4101613163948059,
0.7545169591903687,
0.7161628603935242,
0.9852687120437622,
0.06238735467195511,
0.06654640287160873,
-0.14248473942279816,
0.2819850444793701,
0.13511718809604645,
0.11496806144714355,
-0.24575340747833252,
-0.8435736894607544,
0.16167156398296356,
-0.3425494134426117,
-0.9242743253707886,
0.09751075506210327,
-0.72465580701828,
0.06586018949747086,
-0.773457944393158,
-0.3019188344478607,
-0.20425072312355042,
-0.2742738425731659,
-0.6563018560409546,
-0.04655776172876358,
0.5237440466880798,
0.8127164840698242,
-0.545053243637085,
0.6855263113975525,
0.5210139751434326,
-0.5353420972824097,
-0.11779320985078812,
0.13873523473739624,
0.0508476160466671,
-1.0696841478347778,
0.3572026789188385,
0.24511116743087769,
-0.24003784358501434,
-0.1652878075838089,
-0.7899178862571716,
-0.9228311777114868,
1.1713781356811523,
0.7009438276290894,
-0.3664829730987549,
0.28613245487213135,
0.4669091999530792,
0.15234413743019104,
-0.2521342635154724,
-0.23284588754177094,
0.14048494398593903,
0.4261440634727478,
-0.07194767892360687,
-0.07808586210012436,
0.32292887568473816,
-0.42335042357444763,
0.033857401460409164,
-0.22103220224380493,
-0.5797215700149536,
0.5897918939590454,
-0.3082863390445709,
-0.3821597695350647,
0.133807972073555,
0.2450055480003357,
0.36212432384490967,
0.43857842683792114,
0.4821898639202118,
0.7757696509361267,
0.42468202114105225,
0.04962249472737312,
1.3044286966323853,
-0.24258054792881012,
0.1560516506433487,
0.8794011473655701,
-0.23721371591091156,
0.8149250745773315,
0.7662268280982971,
-0.29683297872543335,
0.2082592397928238,
0.7957233190536499,
-0.34445783495903015,
0.8972386121749878,
0.33005914092063904,
-0.4103560149669647,
-0.3058168292045593,
-0.1225711852312088,
-0.5265788435935974,
0.09244084358215332,
0.062326133251190186,
-0.24113206565380096,
-0.11223267763853073,
-0.4409458339214325,
-0.0002652617113199085,
-0.2403317242860794,
-0.09174788743257523,
0.7259969115257263,
0.3898778259754181,
-0.14534716308116913,
0.2157895416021347,
-0.08617918193340302,
0.8426626920700073,
-0.2624286115169525,
-0.10786017030477524,
-0.4790611267089844,
-0.1585407257080078,
-0.2042054533958435,
-0.8711568713188171,
0.3424072563648224,
0.03840691223740578,
-0.28718888759613037,
-0.4182354509830475,
0.8955408334732056,
0.15740910172462463,
-0.10607040673494339,
0.4309651851654053,
0.5259396433830261,
-0.13588234782218933,
-0.23208701610565186,
-0.7274800539016724,
0.06976441293954849,
-0.11562944203615189,
-0.3395942449569702,
0.6672225594520569,
-0.18705575168132782,
0.01684388518333435,
0.8719089031219482,
0.9216517806053162,
-0.008144422434270382,
0.020236430689692497,
0.23335035145282745,
0.8439158797264099,
-0.6332800984382629,
-0.29930177330970764,
-1.233359456062317,
0.22343018651008606,
-0.07459750026464462,
0.0569893941283226,
0.5158411264419556,
0.4721378684043884,
0.7972291707992554,
-0.17344295978546143,
1.2106140851974487,
0.3446178138256073,
-0.2326868325471878,
-0.6004672646522522,
1.124761939048767,
-0.6192349791526794,
0.4196873903274536,
-0.39826592803001404,
-0.7773339748382568,
-0.5581916570663452,
0.3285580277442932,
-0.01056994590908289,
-0.10818231105804443,
0.2799600660800934,
0.628268837928772,
-0.058477092534303665,
0.08984385430812836,
0.35045942664146423,
-0.6646490097045898,
0.6204094886779785,
0.49481111764907837,
1.2022814750671387,
-0.11862482130527496,
0.6376878023147583,
-0.33477434515953064,
-0.062045250087976456,
-0.1756955087184906,
-1.2134120464324951,
-0.7713053226470947,
-0.38930821418762207,
-0.2308226227760315,
-0.29436662793159485,
0.06057942286133766,
0.38546720147132874,
0.6879994869232178,
-0.8411238789558411,
0.08428476750850677,
-0.015361151657998562,
0.5540942549705505,
-0.059192731976509094,
-0.15983517467975616,
0.2983234226703644,
0.1733679473400116,
-0.22855515778064728,
0.15652163326740265,
0.3979172110557556,
0.8427202105522156,
-0.0314193069934845,
-0.24115842580795288,
0.2982255518436432,
0.3352243900299072,
0.32582786679267883,
0.30715471506118774,
-0.5511986613273621,
-0.416420042514801,
-0.08291097730398178,
-0.22152447700500488,
0.13439889252185822,
0.9598808884620667,
-0.3361597955226898,
0.2883386015892029,
0.3383399546146393,
0.9646113514900208,
0.2295367568731308,
-0.2893775999546051,
0.43363890051841736,
-0.5012560486793518,
0.035304680466651917,
-0.034674279391765594,
0.5324558615684509,
0.5855042934417725,
-0.28905755281448364,
0.4105929136276245,
0.5396665930747986,
-0.22085002064704895,
-0.7497276067733765,
0.4059560298919678,
-0.7415414452552795,
-0.47508010268211365,
0.9317159056663513,
-0.3529967665672302,
-0.04015420004725456,
0.04028850793838501,
-0.0688457116484642,
0.08088240772485733,
-0.13394613564014435,
1.1365057229995728,
0.7917412519454956,
-0.08753364533185959,
0.009473897516727448,
-0.5335820317268372,
0.4379713535308838,
0.18343855440616608,
-1.0093759298324585,
-0.08424599468708038,
0.03800414502620697,
0.5599110722541809,
-0.002553823869675398,
0.3946702778339386,
-0.086344413459301,
0.3364962339401245,
-0.07269719988107681,
0.06662046909332275,
-0.26455557346343994,
-0.16590896248817444,
-0.12663841247558594,
0.03032069280743599,
0.40580615401268005,
-0.5226852297782898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16168v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16168v1
|
Hitting "Probe"rty with Non-Linearity, and More
| 2024-02-25T18:33:25 | 2024-02-25T18:33:25 |
Avik Pal, Madhura Pawar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Structural probes learn a linear transformation to find how dependency trees
are embedded in the hidden states of language models. This simple design may
not allow for full exploitation of the structure of the encoded information.
Hence, to investigate the structure of the encoded information to its full
extent, we incorporate non-linear structural probes. We reformulate the design
of non-linear structural probes introduced by White et al. making its design
simpler yet effective. We also design a visualization framework that lets us
qualitatively assess how strongly two words in a sentence are connected in the
predicted dependency tree. We use this technique to understand which non-linear
probe variant is good at encoding syntactical information. Additionally, we
also use it to qualitatively investigate the structure of dependency trees that
BERT encodes in each of its layers. We find that the radial basis function
(RBF) is an effective non-linear probe for the BERT model than the linear
probe.
|
[
-0.30445048213005066,
-0.9885812401771545,
0.4211491644382477,
0.10832926630973816,
0.001157923019491136,
-0.17178158462047577,
0.17998060584068298,
-0.6014854311943054,
0.6542704701423645,
0.11506784707307816,
-0.464713990688324,
-0.3434029817581177,
-0.5366612672805786,
-0.10463865846395493,
-0.5275818705558777,
1.2519993782043457,
0.11181595176458359,
0.10770691931247711,
0.01546479668468237,
-0.27150049805641174,
-0.2433960735797882,
-0.2590474784374237,
-0.2552180290222168,
-0.2562377154827118,
1.0250160694122314,
0.03918870538473129,
0.6270684003829956,
0.8959329724311829,
0.3339329659938812,
0.19194228947162628,
-0.4173876941204071,
-0.298996239900589,
-0.6176626682281494,
0.31082287430763245,
-0.09330499917268753,
-0.5954482555389404,
-0.3054629862308502,
-0.11991593986749649,
0.6265823841094971,
1.2107834815979004,
0.3188525438308716,
0.3101252019405365,
-0.1623421460390091,
0.672592282295227,
-0.247918963432312,
0.20922517776489258,
-0.25154027342796326,
-0.058810681104660034,
-0.2468278557062149,
-0.4176959693431854,
-0.7353781461715698,
-0.2971380054950714,
0.2939496636390686,
-0.33703938126564026,
0.2536682188510895,
0.09189003705978394,
1.1089146137237549,
0.14319606125354767,
-1.008488416671753,
-0.183820903301239,
-0.8296113014221191,
0.7258862853050232,
-0.45629173517227173,
0.8581472039222717,
0.1569460779428482,
-0.1299557387828827,
-0.5867075324058533,
-0.631854236125946,
0.10998816043138504,
-0.8015298247337341,
-0.0889957994222641,
-0.0942797064781189,
-0.03636569157242775,
0.5026349425315857,
0.1749647557735443,
0.3724185526371002,
-0.7873817086219788,
-0.11690658330917358,
-0.31421732902526855,
-0.2736755609512329,
0.2509084641933441,
-0.08761423081159592,
0.33692970871925354,
-0.3948257863521576,
-0.4610055088996887,
-0.39789777994155884,
-0.47466620802879333,
0.2662827670574188,
0.3291302025318146,
0.53717440366745,
-0.010277274996042252,
0.7097412943840027,
0.33456653356552124,
0.733814537525177,
0.24756905436515808,
-0.05768957734107971,
0.13282372057437897,
-0.32331418991088867,
-0.16412129998207092,
0.01269916258752346,
0.47053584456443787,
-0.05424363538622856,
0.033915817737579346,
-0.1911202222108841,
-0.29888030886650085,
0.16072022914886475,
0.31514084339141846,
-0.6869486570358276,
-0.5281733870506287,
0.25057709217071533,
-0.7041414976119995,
-0.3923565447330475,
-0.03012341633439064,
-0.7854325771331787,
-0.07292930781841278,
-0.050350744277238846,
0.47235220670700073,
-0.4077731966972351,
-0.2886570394039154,
-0.06698314100503922,
-0.5233903527259827,
0.26463577151298523,
0.07404972612857819,
-0.9334604144096375,
0.38613468408584595,
0.38435566425323486,
0.7651069164276123,
0.4033767580986023,
0.020386582240462303,
-0.7341440916061401,
-0.013221756555140018,
-0.506800651550293,
0.7552676796913147,
-0.5465622544288635,
-0.4453763961791992,
-0.08495313674211502,
-0.1717170625925064,
0.24215519428253174,
-0.2903798222541809,
0.3326554000377655,
-0.5114461779594421,
0.371702641248703,
-0.4870043992996216,
-0.5834698677062988,
-0.4102581739425659,
0.3446899652481079,
-0.8445042371749878,
1.2774219512939453,
0.43167537450790405,
-0.8970966339111328,
0.3071898818016052,
-0.6822699308395386,
-0.4325125515460968,
0.013031701557338238,
-0.4817143678665161,
-0.4504092335700989,
0.4082042872905731,
-0.055981382727622986,
-0.05502358824014664,
0.14345401525497437,
0.21335053443908691,
-0.5258864760398865,
-0.302420437335968,
-0.10455363243818283,
0.10543915629386902,
0.8560865521430969,
-0.2263522744178772,
-0.5029791593551636,
0.31570687890052795,
-0.6420627236366272,
0.1787845492362976,
0.05387408658862114,
-0.5084375143051147,
-0.3941226005554199,
0.1639053374528885,
0.34540417790412903,
-0.24778927862644196,
0.1349058896303177,
-0.7009789347648621,
0.2727612555027008,
-0.5495803356170654,
0.29255276918411255,
0.7197668552398682,
0.1728503555059433,
0.5000576972961426,
-0.11616826802492142,
0.5264195203781128,
0.08595500141382217,
-0.02167433314025402,
-0.018721939995884895,
-0.5462667346000671,
-0.8304803967475891,
-0.13002608716487885,
0.47210636734962463,
0.3018971383571625,
-0.6184105277061462,
0.12442710250616074,
0.1295272260904312,
-0.5776309967041016,
-0.13370759785175323,
-0.1985016018152237,
0.5836840867996216,
0.6604076027870178,
0.34993425011634827,
-0.35169899463653564,
-0.7624767422676086,
-0.8058841824531555,
-0.3475829064846039,
-0.5523939728736877,
0.1490902155637741,
0.45580267906188965,
0.6449863910675049,
-0.0761757493019104,
0.8846131563186646,
-0.4125303030014038,
-0.24944791197776794,
-0.29495522379875183,
0.5690748691558838,
0.4675386846065521,
0.131895050406456,
0.8116112947463989,
-0.5848399996757507,
-0.4206444323062897,
0.05036864057183266,
-0.7633437514305115,
-0.0382821187376976,
-0.19037510454654694,
0.2015296220779419,
-0.017716538161039352,
0.49687230587005615,
-0.6765568256378174,
0.282169908285141,
0.3811214566230774,
-0.543063223361969,
0.5171198844909668,
-0.2053145170211792,
-0.3722253143787384,
-0.682206928730011,
0.2446233183145523,
0.18623346090316772,
-0.19612950086593628,
-0.9498439431190491,
0.09098275005817413,
0.3872884511947632,
-0.01998695731163025,
-0.2041516900062561,
0.3732519745826721,
-0.7416595220565796,
-0.3380548655986786,
-0.12106464058160782,
-0.08977682143449783,
-0.06119907647371292,
0.5293208360671997,
-0.30223143100738525,
0.7392845749855042,
0.3067644238471985,
-0.3910161256790161,
0.12649431824684143,
0.2070455253124237,
-0.15255539119243622,
0.09334327280521393,
-0.9031069874763489,
0.12683837115764618,
-0.5144575834274292,
0.44422420859336853,
-0.9971164464950562,
0.09099564701318741,
0.16404904425144196,
-0.7415422201156616,
0.33176085352897644,
-0.3821905851364136,
-0.3339475691318512,
0.028445813804864883,
-0.6771052479743958,
0.5449849963188171,
0.28188183903694153,
-0.4384003281593323,
0.4793798327445984,
0.28624117374420166,
0.22867165505886078,
-0.8077930808067322,
-0.640781581401825,
-0.05652235075831413,
-0.20791390538215637,
-0.67525714635849,
0.3181212842464447,
0.19485796988010406,
-0.2871071994304657,
0.16219975054264069,
-0.3700030744075775,
0.007757709827274084,
0.12261932343244553,
0.11983408778905869,
0.37275969982147217,
-0.807488203048706,
0.16933153569698334,
-0.11354713886976242,
-0.061307553201913834,
0.33691391348838806,
-0.5451747179031372,
0.3897863030433655,
-0.2264150232076645,
-0.17158527672290802,
-0.4836861193180084,
0.5079168677330017,
0.560393214225769,
-0.25725704431533813,
0.3714652359485626,
0.30494585633277893,
-0.3522998094558716,
-0.24224220216274261,
-0.17768922448158264,
-0.4678579866886139,
-0.49789270758628845,
0.601899266242981,
-0.46345388889312744,
-0.9011017680168152,
0.37607401609420776,
-0.04119514301419258,
-0.09643864631652832,
0.22569087147712708,
0.44165125489234924,
-0.3992387652397156,
0.8434543609619141,
1.0338462591171265,
-0.1553429365158081,
0.663334846496582,
-0.09986650198698044,
0.5858189463615417,
-0.6118371486663818,
-0.3067994713783264,
-0.6161851286888123,
-0.4108782112598419,
-0.7536699175834656,
-0.027498379349708557,
0.5565359592437744,
0.1620069444179535,
0.03877492994070053,
0.546862006187439,
-0.4053254723548889,
0.15138915181159973,
0.4443926215171814,
0.02510129101574421,
-0.1479305922985077,
-0.22046272456645966,
-0.332240492105484,
-0.14570419490337372,
-0.45720192790031433,
-0.15096120536327362,
1.0010082721710205,
0.6494826674461365,
0.863662838935852,
0.13052445650100708,
0.5039429068565369,
0.19761720299720764,
-0.11847688257694244,
-1.1462249755859375,
0.4159308969974518,
0.038504403084516525,
-0.6619526743888855,
-0.18328718841075897,
-0.4712026119232178,
-1.1052265167236328,
0.04734698310494423,
0.09159126877784729,
-0.5765526294708252,
0.604771614074707,
0.3987863063812256,
-0.05435081198811531,
0.22398428618907928,
-0.8802034854888916,
0.6289304494857788,
-0.48108458518981934,
-0.2352510243654251,
0.21236684918403625,
-0.7016435265541077,
0.06772417575120926,
0.3498094081878662,
-0.09546389430761337,
0.3413757383823395,
0.007708642166107893,
0.7678723931312561,
-0.16697260737419128,
0.9736912250518799,
-0.4595940411090851,
-0.05986206978559494,
0.03406664729118347,
0.5236720442771912,
0.4521782696247101,
0.09843958914279938,
0.14546960592269897,
-0.058438751846551895,
0.1534361094236374,
-0.5970141291618347,
-0.6171491742134094,
0.31631237268447876,
-0.6470625400543213,
-0.4477328658103943,
-0.5252276062965393,
-0.7598912119865417,
-0.09649699181318283,
0.2579461634159088,
-0.06785768270492554,
0.5759616494178772,
-0.23295284807682037,
0.2526111602783203,
0.8776319622993469,
-0.09097187966108322,
0.244181826710701,
0.2270219326019287,
-0.21467266976833344,
-0.009536153636872768,
0.7219333648681641,
0.1339704543352127,
0.24012136459350586,
0.8329118490219116,
0.11777270585298538,
-0.4424736201763153,
-0.670730471611023,
-0.34598949551582336,
0.5261748433113098,
-0.5118641257286072,
0.002674256218597293,
-0.4519508183002472,
-0.2776774764060974,
-0.32659080624580383,
0.1552681028842926,
-0.39602726697921753,
-0.5383418798446655,
-0.188841313123703,
-0.2587888538837433,
0.3915930390357971,
1.1527899503707886,
-0.040333136916160583,
-0.1042071133852005,
-0.4913906157016754,
0.09863077849149704,
0.046859078109264374,
0.19877947866916656,
-0.15122899413108826,
-0.33163610100746155,
-0.26936981081962585,
-0.13432545959949493,
-0.2572841942310333,
-1.132857084274292,
0.4146938920021057,
0.10881274193525314,
0.39301034808158875,
0.3841579258441925,
0.04044467583298683,
0.6028569936752319,
-0.4459899365901947,
0.6842063665390015,
-0.052983008325099945,
-0.9794091582298279,
0.6266766786575317,
-0.6345747113227844,
0.052547384053468704,
0.20680977404117584,
0.3366469144821167,
-0.5671455264091492,
-0.3228698968887329,
-0.2783230245113373,
-0.8472632765769958,
0.4888472259044647,
-0.04812408611178398,
0.03119814023375511,
0.04002193734049797,
0.5293012857437134,
-0.0301199983805418,
-0.02177385613322258,
-1.0469504594802856,
-0.3161160349845886,
-0.3378770351409912,
-0.24269035458564758,
0.3114602267742157,
-0.578947901725769,
-0.25012829899787903,
-0.023478632792830467,
0.14968055486679077,
-0.10641361773014069,
0.6986594796180725,
0.444031298160553,
-0.07345784455537796,
-0.2348402738571167,
0.06909364461898804,
0.7644875049591064,
0.4046327769756317,
-0.7024462819099426,
0.5451157689094543,
-0.10194540023803711,
-0.37601912021636963,
0.07010778784751892,
-0.3027161955833435,
-0.034823499619960785,
0.3241470158100128,
0.7491821646690369,
0.7008880376815796,
0.18714091181755066,
-0.38042405247688293,
0.44608527421951294,
0.049105651676654816,
-0.5457379221916199,
-0.27582335472106934,
-0.19783687591552734,
0.19071830809116364,
0.2855733036994934,
0.15247918665409088,
-0.0959402546286583,
0.1134471520781517,
-0.5944179892539978,
0.4597569704055786,
0.7501959204673767,
-0.5589182376861572,
-0.6543781161308289,
0.5383501648902893,
0.03305963799357414,
-0.5553681254386902,
0.6469617486000061,
0.029263023287057877,
-0.5056536197662354,
0.5432485938072205,
0.6863177418708801,
0.5368383526802063,
-0.16530941426753998,
0.21102431416511536,
0.1840922087430954,
0.4858960807323456,
0.33434566855430603,
0.6281353831291199,
-0.16954362392425537,
-0.5057607889175415,
-0.3956972062587738,
-0.1517249047756195,
-0.4222985506057739,
0.19841673970222473,
-0.9437448382377625,
0.3130483627319336,
-0.8982784748077393,
0.0771591067314148,
0.19639132916927338,
-0.0029578774701803923,
0.09324295073747635,
0.15497872233390808,
-0.12865830957889557,
0.9730314016342163,
-0.8857302665710449,
1.2354736328125,
0.7981098294258118,
-0.4889662265777588,
-0.7022350430488586,
0.11362838000059128,
0.03645103797316551,
-0.6554673910140991,
1.1127523183822632,
0.20146262645721436,
-0.25902536511421204,
-0.29165053367614746,
-0.3885689079761505,
-1.0589882135391235,
0.9171924591064453,
0.33675673604011536,
-0.2660365402698517,
-0.22437018156051636,
0.16213546693325043,
0.6475052237510681,
0.0793345719575882,
0.5797377824783325,
0.056902289390563965,
0.5467247366905212,
-0.16966058313846588,
-0.8100681304931641,
0.057237133383750916,
-0.37169763445854187,
0.169069305062294,
0.7535858750343323,
-0.3409140110015869,
1.1177128553390503,
-0.0776176005601883,
-0.3144502341747284,
-0.09427324682474136,
0.6683541536331177,
-0.02804800495505333,
0.13255706429481506,
0.6413145661354065,
0.5080624222755432,
0.5682557225227356,
0.016683856025338173,
0.806961178779602,
-0.23695108294487,
0.5449532270431519,
0.9570547342300415,
-0.036851346492767334,
0.7769837379455566,
0.9150688648223877,
-0.04760259389877319,
0.5548315644264221,
0.6638308167457581,
-0.17674122750759125,
0.5794850587844849,
0.3030581772327423,
-0.00661061005666852,
0.06309659034013748,
-0.33697494864463806,
-0.5151404142379761,
0.3350108861923218,
0.38373300433158875,
-0.33115315437316895,
-0.5821584463119507,
-0.19531303644180298,
0.11495959758758545,
-0.026910068467259407,
0.2642099857330322,
0.35314399003982544,
0.09867255389690399,
-0.3064446449279785,
0.7544302344322205,
0.16214323043823242,
0.4032144844532013,
-0.7829508185386658,
-0.115204356610775,
-0.27743616700172424,
0.24738334119319916,
-0.26824650168418884,
-0.6196824312210083,
0.5273697972297668,
-0.3331129252910614,
-0.37035879492759705,
-0.6311377882957458,
0.4683060050010681,
-0.17294065654277802,
-0.1273074895143509,
0.9461743831634521,
0.4812791347503662,
0.04886513575911522,
0.33828410506248474,
-0.4687052369117737,
0.054248109459877014,
0.23710982501506805,
-0.33930331468582153,
0.32589995861053467,
0.34780579805374146,
-0.019418129697442055,
0.5900424718856812,
0.5940812230110168,
0.06441570073366165,
0.2344960868358612,
-0.0624554306268692,
0.9816897511482239,
-0.9814050793647766,
-0.21778129041194916,
-0.5952512621879578,
0.5280414819717407,
0.385049968957901,
-0.4227418303489685,
0.6727414727210999,
0.5608955025672913,
0.9172796607017517,
-0.0025103420484811068,
0.30253762006759644,
-0.09361707419157028,
0.4915778338909149,
-0.40939539670944214,
0.4832453727722168,
-0.7314869165420532,
0.21219636499881744,
-0.08770034462213516,
-0.7248159646987915,
-0.44427725672721863,
0.5972926616668701,
-0.08562614023685455,
0.11009075492620468,
1.1622055768966675,
0.9829522371292114,
-0.15377923846244812,
0.13700918853282928,
0.12852194905281067,
0.680097758769989,
0.6514065861701965,
0.4913788139820099,
0.7674739360809326,
-0.45518967509269714,
0.5950539708137512,
-0.11772498488426208,
-0.4091185927391052,
-0.12054374814033508,
-0.6919682025909424,
-1.1398905515670776,
-0.6748312711715698,
0.05098653957247734,
-0.3225190341472626,
0.0026384235825389624,
0.5958184599876404,
0.7612698078155518,
-0.7642471790313721,
-0.5957179069519043,
-0.44135722517967224,
0.004943481646478176,
0.008068718947470188,
-0.24781069159507751,
0.4621395170688629,
-0.43945780396461487,
-0.3883626163005829,
0.9565683007240295,
0.35719501972198486,
0.010605367831885815,
-0.3647967278957367,
0.24533185362815857,
-0.46921420097351074,
-0.12288910150527954,
0.3503756821155548,
0.39322343468666077,
-0.6801368594169617,
-0.6454483866691589,
0.4089675843715668,
0.03000994399189949,
0.3073292374610901,
0.9622698426246643,
-0.882303774356842,
0.3682958483695984,
0.7319901585578918,
0.791310727596283,
0.6554560661315918,
-0.34965890645980835,
0.6865590810775757,
-0.8591713309288025,
0.24998536705970764,
0.3630101978778839,
0.21678826212882996,
0.06855790317058563,
-0.5400225520133972,
0.2084510773420334,
0.22668878734111786,
-0.45535603165626526,
-1.102547526359558,
0.6830882430076599,
-1.1792137622833252,
-0.2556755542755127,
0.8425883650779724,
-0.08888175338506699,
-0.39767929911613464,
-0.32938504219055176,
-0.02868572063744068,
0.16590137779712677,
-0.44191721081733704,
0.66745525598526,
0.49665138125419617,
-0.5076882243156433,
-0.34164664149284363,
-0.4548277258872986,
0.23099203407764435,
1.0290733575820923,
-0.49987146258354187,
-0.31316080689430237,
0.23250406980514526,
0.3899841606616974,
0.2921352982521057,
0.3278508484363556,
-0.20590738952159882,
0.06924253702163696,
0.1067311242222786,
-0.10100331157445908,
-0.0034583061933517456,
-0.4340219795703888,
-0.372517853975296,
0.34266698360443115,
0.302338182926178,
-0.44361263513565063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16914v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16914v2
|
DrAttack: Prompt Decomposition and Reconstruction Makes Powerful LLM Jailbreakers
| 2024-02-25T17:43:29 | 2024-03-01T07:26:50 |
Xirui Li, Ruochen Wang, Minhao Cheng, Tianyi Zhou, Cho-Jui Hsieh
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The safety alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs) is vulnerable to both
manual and automated jailbreak attacks, which adversarially trigger LLMs to
output harmful content. However, current methods for jailbreaking LLMs, which
nest entire harmful prompts, are not effective at concealing malicious intent
and can be easily identified and rejected by well-aligned LLMs. This paper
discovers that decomposing a malicious prompt into separated sub-prompts can
effectively obscure its underlying malicious intent by presenting it in a
fragmented, less detectable form, thereby addressing these limitations. We
introduce an automatic prompt \textbf{D}ecomposition and
\textbf{R}econstruction framework for jailbreak \textbf{Attack} (DrAttack).
DrAttack includes three key components: (a) `Decomposition' of the original
prompt into sub-prompts, (b) `Reconstruction' of these sub-prompts implicitly
by in-context learning with semantically similar but harmless reassembling
demo, and (c) a `Synonym Search' of sub-prompts, aiming to find sub-prompts'
synonyms that maintain the original intent while jailbreaking LLMs. An
extensive empirical study across multiple open-source and closed-source LLMs
demonstrates that, with a significantly reduced number of queries, DrAttack
obtains a substantial gain of success rate over prior SOTA prompt-only
attackers. Notably, the success rate of 78.0\% on GPT-4 with merely 15 queries
surpassed previous art by 33.1\%. The project is available at
https://github.com/xirui-li/DrAttack.
|
[
-0.16312187910079956,
-1.03962242603302,
0.5896524786949158,
-0.02420775219798088,
-0.1545886993408203,
0.5226556658744812,
-0.019024761393666267,
-0.24167655408382416,
0.2845097780227661,
0.509901762008667,
-0.8237550258636475,
-0.5324656963348389,
-0.3848925232887268,
0.12771359086036682,
-0.35097411274909973,
0.9582828283309937,
0.05942053720355034,
-0.27061226963996887,
0.05580604821443558,
-0.013026120141148567,
-0.8208184242248535,
-0.4429579973220825,
-0.5744787454605103,
0.07745685428380966,
0.5554709434509277,
0.4891433119773865,
0.5565791726112366,
0.6804074645042419,
0.41258934140205383,
0.36006292700767517,
-0.08482012152671814,
-0.03805333003401756,
-0.6856655478477478,
0.5473224520683289,
-0.16272613406181335,
-0.5025371313095093,
-0.3566524088382721,
0.1795164942741394,
0.30746763944625854,
-0.07103966921567917,
-0.22294095158576965,
-0.06583184003829956,
-0.23355726897716522,
0.8770299553871155,
-0.45779672265052795,
-0.1545594036579132,
-0.8008353114128113,
-0.008411901071667671,
-0.2877151370048523,
-0.07653031498193741,
-0.7025813460350037,
-0.0981491357088089,
-0.24063709378242493,
-0.40119031071662903,
0.04006173834204674,
0.2622920572757721,
0.6077167987823486,
0.33659976720809937,
-0.04546494409441948,
-0.09414277970790863,
-0.4373409152030945,
0.636050283908844,
-0.537367045879364,
0.07751098275184631,
0.24109923839569092,
0.5002853274345398,
-0.7321950197219849,
-0.6970258355140686,
-0.356393963098526,
-0.2945273816585541,
-0.07287555187940598,
-0.010795488953590393,
-0.516381561756134,
0.20745055377483368,
0.2840500771999359,
0.32855111360549927,
-0.6539821624755859,
0.32987383008003235,
-0.488640695810318,
-0.5574995279312134,
0.47177156805992126,
0.4221004247665405,
0.7826225161552429,
-0.4139665365219116,
-0.7016105055809021,
-0.045262858271598816,
-1.0703858137130737,
0.046565085649490356,
0.7447617650032043,
0.12561456859111786,
0.04307323321700096,
0.29083919525146484,
0.13785070180892944,
0.6879927515983582,
0.12235141545534134,
-0.39043161273002625,
-0.19618839025497437,
-0.32238999009132385,
-0.2835208475589752,
-0.03867369890213013,
0.9727594256401062,
0.30951228737831116,
-0.029874756932258606,
-0.012520771473646164,
-0.2788224220275879,
-0.22313132882118225,
0.2568083703517914,
-0.5710234642028809,
-0.5804862380027771,
0.33335843682289124,
-0.37194573879241943,
-0.5240573883056641,
-0.026203341782093048,
-0.8711545467376709,
-0.6678265333175659,
0.21571359038352966,
0.12243497371673584,
-0.6022409796714783,
-0.07271679490804672,
-0.07849408686161041,
-0.2621813714504242,
0.08678395301103592,
0.2423422634601593,
-0.6263392567634583,
0.1778598129749298,
0.7648212313652039,
0.8978283405303955,
0.008097578771412373,
-0.2763839066028595,
-0.453298956155777,
-0.062493421137332916,
-0.053623609244823456,
0.6891650557518005,
-0.3269343674182892,
-0.3507026731967926,
-0.293338418006897,
-0.04862164333462715,
-0.04392990842461586,
-0.5058536529541016,
0.3352999985218048,
-0.7295995354652405,
0.03508127108216286,
-0.07605089247226715,
-0.3211480379104614,
-0.24016274511814117,
0.3108431100845337,
-1.018267273902893,
0.6770776510238647,
0.13438966870307922,
-0.7100480794906616,
0.11204101890325546,
-0.3450719714164734,
-0.48159968852996826,
-0.10104716569185257,
-0.052646808326244354,
-0.4361153244972229,
0.214183509349823,
0.28997379541397095,
0.1794978529214859,
-0.10375942289829254,
0.27748239040374756,
-0.17465436458587646,
-0.3332400619983673,
0.29117634892463684,
-0.3841301500797272,
1.024382472038269,
0.4185584485530853,
-0.46767547726631165,
0.1811526119709015,
-0.6146152019500732,
-0.3156944811344147,
0.3805045187473297,
-0.14313776791095734,
-0.4482741951942444,
-0.09969088435173035,
-0.36518383026123047,
-0.057915013283491135,
0.18399542570114136,
-0.6360564827919006,
0.3857271373271942,
-0.5559279322624207,
0.7778124213218689,
1.000167965888977,
0.02412092313170433,
0.47064703702926636,
-0.08377674221992493,
0.86171954870224,
-0.10422545671463013,
0.10062967985868454,
-0.42625340819358826,
-0.12379960715770721,
-0.2977657616138458,
-0.85610032081604,
-0.030021365731954575,
0.7234694957733154,
-0.698337972164154,
0.040893591940402985,
0.08989731967449188,
-0.5807619094848633,
-0.4334844946861267,
0.08291585743427277,
0.4059436619281769,
0.7055099606513977,
0.3905463218688965,
0.17925293743610382,
-0.8030648231506348,
-0.9066677689552307,
-0.5710845589637756,
-0.3759489059448242,
0.20707044005393982,
0.06357337534427643,
0.40933290123939514,
-0.16385775804519653,
0.8162052035331726,
-0.5774983763694763,
-0.3869995176792145,
-0.5779368877410889,
-0.05812268704175949,
0.20174817740917206,
0.39460068941116333,
0.7728317379951477,
-0.5030248165130615,
-0.33139047026634216,
-0.6290563941001892,
-0.5556115508079529,
-0.2540898025035858,
-0.23037958145141602,
0.1819104552268982,
-0.022177496924996376,
0.6309980154037476,
-0.627720296382904,
0.4452103078365326,
0.13266432285308838,
-0.4550163447856903,
0.920613706111908,
-0.08841683715581894,
0.16247117519378662,
-0.8540230393409729,
-0.23569081723690033,
-0.3769858479499817,
-0.3578641712665558,
-0.5696951746940613,
0.5146225094795227,
0.04241784289479256,
-0.2546550929546356,
-0.45272794365882874,
0.33644115924835205,
-0.6379384398460388,
0.16369472444057465,
-0.2463117390871048,
0.24235138297080994,
0.007405558601021767,
0.10216143727302551,
-0.4317646920681,
1.047443151473999,
0.42895928025245667,
-0.11675231158733368,
0.5444950461387634,
0.12549181282520294,
-0.24754256010055542,
0.40019065141677856,
-0.7385515570640564,
0.3721242845058441,
-0.13138347864151,
0.3791217803955078,
-1.184375524520874,
-0.24276188015937805,
0.39567336440086365,
-0.23587092757225037,
0.40336817502975464,
-0.27918705344200134,
-0.394572913646698,
-0.32052138447761536,
-0.7716965079307556,
0.49654990434646606,
0.5218103528022766,
-0.5043842792510986,
0.43082141876220703,
0.5276708006858826,
-0.21044500172138214,
-0.7305569648742676,
-0.5841158628463745,
0.4539375901222229,
-0.5205296874046326,
-0.5178939700126648,
0.20514822006225586,
0.06834609806537628,
-0.4757775664329529,
-0.12452974915504456,
-0.1488812267780304,
0.15761491656303406,
0.4573351740837097,
0.3321351110935211,
0.4882858097553253,
0.011201494373381138,
-0.2676125168800354,
0.0340389646589756,
-0.30791181325912476,
0.07791637629270554,
-0.2648399770259857,
0.4799754023551941,
-0.006124621257185936,
-0.17384102940559387,
-0.38803258538246155,
0.4798520803451538,
0.8272122144699097,
-0.17941372096538544,
0.5948179364204407,
0.15012261271476746,
-0.18095286190509796,
-0.3267330527305603,
-0.37442249059677124,
-0.15388989448547363,
-0.5471925139427185,
0.25329113006591797,
-0.3983011543750763,
-0.9674341678619385,
0.5374932289123535,
-0.04600710794329643,
0.3232648968696594,
0.2118963748216629,
0.35167309641838074,
-0.09366139024496078,
0.8271504044532776,
0.7133406400680542,
-0.37297993898391724,
0.49219006299972534,
-0.042926035821437836,
0.3553260862827301,
-0.6195647716522217,
-0.2918022871017456,
-0.4079468846321106,
-0.4808054268360138,
-0.3904939889907837,
-0.2269715517759323,
0.25135624408721924,
-0.009138639084994793,
-0.04814201965928078,
0.733721911907196,
-0.6422502994537354,
0.7291997075080872,
0.37509796023368835,
0.2355172038078308,
0.2439722865819931,
-0.04632071405649185,
-0.1277633011341095,
-0.0659274160861969,
-0.49132615327835083,
-0.5676044821739197,
0.7458279132843018,
0.5306562185287476,
1.0157763957977295,
0.0762956514954567,
1.17021644115448,
0.35694360733032227,
0.016143042594194412,
-0.8648433685302734,
0.7947291135787964,
0.11434250324964523,
-0.5450224876403809,
-0.17028231918811798,
-0.384828120470047,
-0.8767899870872498,
0.1931331902742386,
0.17723345756530762,
-0.9737868309020996,
0.03129342570900917,
0.21504727005958557,
-0.5859478116035461,
0.47744202613830566,
-0.6036741137504578,
0.667701005935669,
-0.117706298828125,
-0.264304518699646,
-0.38184887170791626,
-0.7811782956123352,
0.6502383947372437,
-0.016804469749331474,
0.49892303347587585,
-0.39042043685913086,
0.01793619990348816,
0.8474693298339844,
-0.7549583315849304,
0.9651020169258118,
-0.3869771957397461,
-0.16818583011627197,
0.44683322310447693,
0.5135921239852905,
0.7383927702903748,
0.19850435853004456,
0.10880448669195175,
-0.08926104009151459,
-0.004837836604565382,
-0.24419791996479034,
-0.5066475868225098,
0.736071765422821,
-0.39994800090789795,
-1.0403858423233032,
-0.40072134137153625,
-0.7537439465522766,
0.26119282841682434,
0.21397699415683746,
0.26546716690063477,
0.4485863745212555,
-0.18667234480381012,
-0.37106025218963623,
0.7047279477119446,
-0.3892176151275635,
0.5204358696937561,
0.378052681684494,
-0.15720142424106598,
-0.6500954627990723,
0.6490916013717651,
-0.005574171897023916,
0.10876036435365677,
0.1787627786397934,
0.1222897544503212,
-0.08367049694061279,
-0.7116551399230957,
-0.41835877299308777,
0.08292606472969055,
-0.7080671191215515,
-0.5911763906478882,
-0.5845802426338196,
0.06132756173610687,
-0.3649579584598541,
-0.24932709336280823,
-0.22266094386577606,
-0.5685836672782898,
-0.15332700312137604,
-0.4745100438594818,
0.4667816460132599,
0.6536877155303955,
-0.3527316153049469,
0.3204955756664276,
-0.7792909145355225,
0.3702419698238373,
0.1277443766593933,
-0.1111917495727539,
-0.12073206901550293,
-0.5147407650947571,
0.062238454818725586,
-0.20102205872535706,
0.004134871996939182,
-1.2704408168792725,
0.3985396921634674,
0.017772939056158066,
0.4306184649467468,
0.26575905084609985,
0.4373631775379181,
0.7662414908409119,
-0.7386375069618225,
0.7949418425559998,
0.24137409031391144,
-0.758833110332489,
0.7493274211883545,
-0.21275919675827026,
0.03242900222539902,
0.8771871328353882,
0.041105784475803375,
-0.2409321814775467,
-0.7358404397964478,
-0.5071028470993042,
-1.1927372217178345,
0.6111094355583191,
-0.09478788822889328,
0.10554826259613037,
0.0029991341289132833,
0.4084150791168213,
0.1964375525712967,
0.014178477227687836,
-0.6570955514907837,
-0.43405529856681824,
-0.13694554567337036,
-0.27435120940208435,
0.2899720072746277,
-0.6219603419303894,
-0.37468212842941284,
-0.1262703537940979,
0.41804060339927673,
0.34145379066467285,
0.25918060541152954,
0.19130457937717438,
-0.546636164188385,
0.22103780508041382,
0.43248450756073,
0.5443138480186462,
0.23740144073963165,
-0.06429917365312576,
0.5647892951965332,
-0.14488345384597778,
-0.7541527152061462,
0.7004212141036987,
0.06055920943617821,
-0.32369178533554077,
-0.26250550150871277,
0.519891083240509,
0.4720209538936615,
0.10022025555372238,
-0.7726877927780151,
0.38816142082214355,
-0.16057313978672028,
0.10430794954299927,
-0.2388346791267395,
0.1383460909128189,
-0.3737431764602661,
0.3494490087032318,
0.38060566782951355,
-0.08541426062583923,
0.19368833303451538,
-0.667402982711792,
0.4827869236469269,
0.36533495783805847,
-0.29001981019973755,
-0.5444072484970093,
0.7293063998222351,
0.1234089583158493,
-0.3245750963687897,
0.6720115542411804,
-0.11801757663488388,
-0.8682836294174194,
0.5444444417953491,
0.8319190740585327,
1.1123007535934448,
-0.28138798475265503,
0.24362146854400635,
0.25337687134742737,
0.708094596862793,
0.06509703397750854,
0.18976740539073944,
-0.058267753571271896,
-0.3813590407371521,
-0.22272032499313354,
-0.38590317964553833,
-0.12556901574134827,
0.10659869760274887,
-0.4888633191585541,
0.07006547600030899,
-0.7363637089729309,
0.02840055152773857,
-0.30500227212905884,
-0.38645002245903015,
-0.18055492639541626,
-0.1735587865114212,
-0.11712846904993057,
1.0534441471099854,
-0.7933361530303955,
0.5112146139144897,
0.7002338171005249,
-0.2870140075683594,
-0.7912919521331787,
-0.0460258312523365,
0.4826042652130127,
-0.8341414332389832,
0.513158917427063,
0.430034339427948,
-0.14479829370975494,
0.039804138243198395,
-0.6959237456321716,
-0.7019158005714417,
0.8440627455711365,
0.508183479309082,
-0.6460321545600891,
0.02651580423116684,
-0.17582467198371887,
0.09885148704051971,
-0.005545862950384617,
0.03780842944979668,
1.0145342350006104,
0.6144663095474243,
-0.19982178509235382,
-0.7007895112037659,
0.6092605590820312,
0.04707356542348862,
-0.5644124150276184,
0.4430809020996094,
-0.5145657658576965,
0.6468044519424438,
-0.5107461214065552,
-0.5063869953155518,
0.19654950499534607,
0.5100238919258118,
0.33613812923431396,
0.22924478352069855,
0.48700159788131714,
0.6925972700119019,
0.6892093420028687,
-0.2063441425561905,
0.6433157920837402,
-0.07773172110319138,
0.17427843809127808,
1.0018669366836548,
-0.12727560102939606,
0.5108673572540283,
0.709493100643158,
-0.03709663078188896,
0.752000629901886,
0.4431392550468445,
-0.03539183735847473,
0.9606310129165649,
0.27457350492477417,
-0.16623783111572266,
-0.02113623358309269,
0.26340344548225403,
0.03519146144390106,
0.38527318835258484,
0.2954208552837372,
-0.12460190057754517,
-0.43259498476982117,
0.40436404943466187,
0.5118553042411804,
0.12288452684879303,
-0.19912824034690857,
0.933906078338623,
0.2019040435552597,
-0.5440678596496582,
0.6229641437530518,
0.003614212619140744,
0.4180586338043213,
-0.5398179292678833,
0.05441379174590111,
-0.2468232363462448,
0.024810578674077988,
-0.37171080708503723,
-0.6357100605964661,
0.419567734003067,
0.2244647741317749,
-0.06652826070785522,
-0.22002549469470978,
1.1296151876449585,
-0.0887426882982254,
0.15684746205806732,
0.17553025484085083,
0.21915695071220398,
0.0966450423002243,
-0.016845740377902985,
-0.6454487442970276,
0.20761986076831818,
0.14758683741092682,
-0.426363468170166,
0.3788183629512787,
0.20351962745189667,
0.09386146813631058,
0.6416500806808472,
0.5858970284461975,
-0.02279100939631462,
-0.11171519011259079,
-0.2816939949989319,
1.0806804895401,
-0.8546546697616577,
-0.3974420130252838,
-1.441662073135376,
0.6259954571723938,
-0.0664212629199028,
0.1781415194272995,
0.935788631439209,
0.37727105617523193,
0.4760098457336426,
0.08956780284643173,
0.6896911263465881,
-0.3008141815662384,
0.14568418264389038,
-0.5800111293792725,
0.7879706621170044,
-0.24569907784461975,
0.6363002061843872,
-0.3373109996318817,
-0.4166369140148163,
-0.26411172747612,
0.47319933772087097,
-0.3350711464881897,
-0.3852721154689789,
0.5455878973007202,
0.7565471529960632,
0.22259128093719482,
-0.2065974622964859,
0.19200001657009125,
0.17089824378490448,
0.5041958093643188,
0.45628154277801514,
1.047452449798584,
-0.2190588414669037,
0.617056131362915,
-0.15964028239250183,
-0.6306198239326477,
-0.25251540541648865,
-0.879994809627533,
-0.9286528825759888,
-0.17267610132694244,
-0.11111115664243698,
-0.3584155738353729,
0.0901469960808754,
0.7423905730247498,
0.3054371774196625,
-0.6920649409294128,
0.07732158154249191,
-0.11530563980340958,
0.5264402627944946,
-0.27399539947509766,
-0.24275344610214233,
0.3187973201274872,
-0.3327993154525757,
-0.3454709053039551,
1.0847276449203491,
0.609551191329956,
0.09037410467863083,
-0.31843405961990356,
0.3082004189491272,
-0.0011255572317168117,
0.1558607965707779,
0.3889332711696625,
0.4073916971683502,
-0.6497309803962708,
-0.33533769845962524,
0.1762526035308838,
-0.041272055357694626,
-0.04076993465423584,
0.8804064989089966,
-0.9938538074493408,
0.3884176015853882,
0.775550127029419,
0.5769917964935303,
0.07453058660030365,
0.0550626777112484,
0.8242361545562744,
-0.8190159797668457,
0.3532135784626007,
0.27334120869636536,
0.5593633651733398,
0.09448439627885818,
-0.6255231499671936,
0.4091867506504059,
0.3155761659145355,
-0.519913911819458,
-1.192784309387207,
0.6738253831863403,
-0.5717005133628845,
-0.6106995344161987,
0.8687094449996948,
-0.4582546651363373,
-0.4959079325199127,
-0.2569468021392822,
-0.4721168279647827,
0.018916787579655647,
-0.48278409242630005,
0.7543065547943115,
0.3605085611343384,
-0.07220563292503357,
-0.03832772746682167,
-0.34053030610084534,
0.5337939262390137,
0.203633114695549,
-0.5550612807273865,
0.3889884054660797,
0.6767133474349976,
0.47587940096855164,
0.11854224652051926,
0.5417744517326355,
-0.3358091115951538,
0.3708112835884094,
0.12870892882347107,
-0.22462916374206543,
-0.5507219433784485,
-0.5465844869613647,
-0.4461115300655365,
0.3045763671398163,
-0.0027201129123568535,
-0.24618665874004364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16159v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16159v5
|
DistALANER: Distantly Supervised Active Learning Augmented Named Entity Recognition in the Open Source Software Ecosystem
| 2024-02-25T17:40:49 | 2024-06-20T12:43:57 |
Somnath Banerjee, Avik Dutta, Aaditya Agrawal, Rima Hazra, Animesh Mukherjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the AI revolution in place, the trend for building automated systems to
support professionals in different domains such as the open source software
systems, healthcare systems, banking systems, transportation systems and many
others have become increasingly prominent. A crucial requirement in the
automation of support tools for such systems is the early identification of
named entities, which serves as a foundation for developing specialized
functionalities. However, due to the specific nature of each domain, different
technical terminologies and specialized languages, expert annotation of
available data becomes expensive and challenging. In light of these challenges,
this paper proposes a novel named entity recognition (NER) technique
specifically tailored for the open-source software systems. Our approach aims
to address the scarcity of annotated software data by employing a comprehensive
two-step distantly supervised annotation process. This process strategically
leverages language heuristics, unique lookup tables, external knowledge
sources, and an active learning approach. By harnessing these powerful
techniques, we not only enhance model performance but also effectively mitigate
the limitations associated with cost and the scarcity of expert annotators. It
is noteworthy that our model significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art
LLMs by a substantial margin. We also show the effectiveness of NER in the
downstream task of relation extraction.
|
[
-0.41551363468170166,
-0.725341260433197,
0.3836172819137573,
-0.19233302772045135,
-0.14781145751476288,
-0.022940242663025856,
-0.48910489678382874,
-0.7505748271942139,
0.39228880405426025,
0.5889124870300293,
-0.3102985918521881,
-0.5126643776893616,
-0.3325381577014923,
0.1678791493177414,
-0.2921128571033478,
1.030550241470337,
-0.11467644572257996,
-0.054753512144088745,
-0.003733194898813963,
-0.3115832507610321,
-0.20910173654556274,
-0.10694493353366852,
-0.7800343632698059,
0.05443938076496124,
0.7197173237800598,
0.4357589781284332,
0.6427192687988281,
0.5490191578865051,
0.6665392518043518,
0.30108949542045593,
0.001555616152472794,
0.20745500922203064,
-0.057741519063711166,
0.2795811891555786,
-0.00196602800861001,
-0.33240216970443726,
-0.6120560169219971,
-0.21946638822555542,
0.5548883080482483,
0.6042568683624268,
0.08167771995067596,
0.2571016550064087,
-0.10555345565080643,
0.6425756812095642,
-0.7861953377723694,
0.3454911410808563,
-0.8119127154350281,
0.05667174234986305,
-0.6380854845046997,
0.22826620936393738,
-0.24378730356693268,
-0.4277038276195526,
0.2900543808937073,
-0.9277510046958923,
0.07936467230319977,
-0.030428066849708557,
1.034964680671692,
0.4601377546787262,
0.019192101433873177,
-0.2732070982456207,
-0.9699731469154358,
0.6058230996131897,
-0.5162603259086609,
0.6003343462944031,
0.35578396916389465,
0.48816201090812683,
-0.04799102619290352,
-0.6822409629821777,
-0.42023342847824097,
-0.0752970352768898,
0.13471508026123047,
-0.2430136650800705,
-0.35172316431999207,
-0.08046304434537888,
0.08305977284908295,
0.2915281653404236,
-0.1627594381570816,
0.19201822578907013,
-0.574170708656311,
-0.2747996151447296,
0.32428643107414246,
-0.31532469391822815,
0.09294679760932922,
0.06678952276706696,
-0.43062618374824524,
0.45798519253730774,
-0.8477434515953064,
-0.2675654888153076,
0.3289317190647125,
0.5892618298530579,
0.10584992915391922,
0.6591297388076782,
-0.244127556681633,
0.6907811164855957,
0.17605088651180267,
-0.12525667250156403,
0.4554775357246399,
0.08631730079650879,
-0.19772383570671082,
0.18954652547836304,
0.6787505149841309,
-0.1727745234966278,
0.15233170986175537,
-0.5034897923469543,
-0.3148708939552307,
-0.3411294221878052,
0.23983599245548248,
-0.49230262637138367,
-0.7118803858757019,
0.1518951803445816,
-0.23439887166023254,
-0.11974754929542542,
0.05272311717271805,
-0.6636500954627991,
-0.42916399240493774,
-0.4252031147480011,
0.2507936656475067,
-0.4201541244983673,
-0.504972517490387,
-0.6410146355628967,
0.24892543256282806,
0.04498816654086113,
0.5017023682594299,
-0.5295637845993042,
0.1575542539358139,
0.6937966346740723,
0.8549728393554688,
-0.04271497577428818,
-0.016458678990602493,
-0.8961135745048523,
0.2824782133102417,
-0.27960205078125,
0.7913821339607239,
-0.5631368160247803,
-0.043606724590063095,
-0.15228167176246643,
0.09449835866689682,
0.3431750237941742,
-0.7646703124046326,
0.3160206973552704,
-1.0644539594650269,
-0.16901423037052155,
0.16011248528957367,
-0.4951079189777374,
-0.1573648452758789,
0.24130958318710327,
-0.9114254117012024,
1.0781848430633545,
0.2181863635778427,
-0.8996477723121643,
0.6233471632003784,
-0.5196911096572876,
-0.11749424785375595,
0.4614153802394867,
-0.3796965479850769,
-0.6948438286781311,
-0.20900477468967438,
0.1519067883491516,
0.4739537239074707,
-0.03955545648932457,
0.23636721074581146,
-0.5539200305938721,
-0.05470436066389084,
0.12039302289485931,
0.031523898243904114,
0.42258164286613464,
0.10846583545207977,
-0.2914266288280487,
0.24370905756950378,
-0.9022499322891235,
-0.207590252161026,
-0.018314644694328308,
-0.2928250730037689,
-1.0246095657348633,
-0.028369037434458733,
-0.11844432353973389,
-0.01254291832447052,
0.15448817610740662,
-0.5317462086677551,
0.2298090010881424,
-0.45116743445396423,
0.19139739871025085,
0.7107419967651367,
0.11695445328950882,
0.933295726776123,
0.36140286922454834,
0.28272444009780884,
0.07666637003421783,
0.1579703539609909,
0.11420567333698273,
-0.39653417468070984,
-0.7682324051856995,
-0.6596475839614868,
0.5936367511749268,
0.6123347878456116,
-0.9167584180831909,
0.4841369390487671,
-0.2922004163265228,
-0.4391014277935028,
-0.4394698739051819,
0.36773788928985596,
0.23593798279762268,
0.6327639222145081,
0.6144601106643677,
-0.13113470375537872,
-0.6280574202537537,
-0.8996027112007141,
0.006463636178523302,
-0.2743413746356964,
-0.21858027577400208,
0.4575698971748352,
0.39496326446533203,
-0.2122526913881302,
1.1748155355453491,
-0.48987072706222534,
-0.6679556369781494,
-0.007167746312916279,
-0.13644689321517944,
0.07179778069257736,
0.3847449719905853,
0.27940797805786133,
-0.9294759035110474,
-0.21573583781719208,
0.003367196535691619,
-0.7324037551879883,
-0.024785274639725685,
-0.02693670429289341,
-0.2838456332683563,
0.11421465128660202,
0.5964885950088501,
-0.5179657936096191,
0.19199255108833313,
0.20936204493045807,
-0.03287527710199356,
0.3374541997909546,
0.0420541949570179,
-0.2582627534866333,
-0.9475306868553162,
0.21067635715007782,
0.0319296233355999,
-0.07071544229984283,
-0.4536277949810028,
0.05068875849246979,
0.27686288952827454,
-0.04598449543118477,
-0.5353747010231018,
0.6813520789146423,
-1.0747917890548706,
-0.1913716048002243,
-0.21181634068489075,
0.2819472849369049,
-0.5310692191123962,
0.0887431874871254,
0.3722781240940094,
0.5048702359199524,
0.743962824344635,
-0.7016156911849976,
0.4858115613460541,
0.28489354252815247,
-0.0407310426235199,
0.5217945575714111,
-0.4110962152481079,
-0.020198624581098557,
0.08559975028038025,
0.010974492877721786,
-0.3526947498321533,
-0.34748589992523193,
0.6631765365600586,
-0.43004322052001953,
0.5010717511177063,
-0.5802251696586609,
-0.3259032666683197,
-0.23607513308525085,
0.10599593073129654,
0.29303619265556335,
0.4951722323894501,
-0.5708796381950378,
0.7812730669975281,
0.5919294953346252,
-0.2911582887172699,
-0.591558575630188,
-0.5436347723007202,
0.2107684463262558,
-0.17000851035118103,
-0.26633599400520325,
0.3252936005592346,
0.5064092874526978,
-0.5534505248069763,
0.26530584692955017,
-0.22588735818862915,
-0.31675201654434204,
0.09193902462720871,
0.5619593858718872,
0.5429054498672485,
-0.1653873771429062,
0.49393585324287415,
0.16734936833381653,
-0.40075087547302246,
-0.031151458621025085,
-0.42645105719566345,
-0.1620667278766632,
0.09512650221586227,
-0.30117538571357727,
-0.16329032182693481,
-0.017330104485154152,
0.12523819506168365,
-0.48256716132164,
0.6850888729095459,
0.6512123942375183,
-0.7312057614326477,
-0.38283687829971313,
-0.5546830892562866,
-0.10769162327051163,
-0.45282426476478577,
0.11455130577087402,
-0.20760376751422882,
-0.8973735570907593,
0.45085564255714417,
-0.4054286479949951,
0.18924961984157562,
0.5626884698867798,
0.12705272436141968,
0.4197063744068146,
0.1224474236369133,
0.6334862112998962,
-0.14089304208755493,
0.5325936675071716,
-0.14819498360157013,
0.1950676590204239,
-0.900312066078186,
-0.41108617186546326,
-0.46930599212646484,
-0.057541098445653915,
-0.349702924489975,
-0.6701935529708862,
0.31800577044487,
0.3307206630706787,
-0.23659153282642365,
0.3392490744590759,
-0.6241104006767273,
0.41392412781715393,
0.5050620436668396,
0.1620592325925827,
0.28816336393356323,
-0.03682926669716835,
0.04655512049794197,
-0.05297436937689781,
-0.17641687393188477,
-0.6568650603294373,
0.9555464386940002,
0.3856588304042816,
0.5435413122177124,
0.16674411296844482,
1.0879765748977661,
0.3133785128593445,
0.6795539855957031,
-0.7285121083259583,
0.6948614120483398,
0.1262742280960083,
-0.6618450284004211,
-0.40327948331832886,
-0.4829534888267517,
-0.8632342219352722,
-0.323286235332489,
-0.24081143736839294,
-0.5846607089042664,
0.14299072325229645,
0.04641617462038994,
-0.4661179184913635,
0.6074795722961426,
-0.3234163820743561,
0.5473251938819885,
-0.20628978312015533,
-0.48868048191070557,
0.22371666133403778,
-0.8471664190292358,
0.22761836647987366,
-0.20183998346328735,
0.2338307499885559,
-0.11942816525697708,
-0.5490896701812744,
0.6946864128112793,
-0.429940789937973,
0.64957594871521,
-0.4953936040401459,
-0.07543201744556427,
0.3938465416431427,
0.12158206105232239,
0.7719114422798157,
0.36950939893722534,
-0.07200997322797775,
0.31469789147377014,
-0.7262445092201233,
-0.23917578160762787,
-0.21956783533096313,
0.9850640892982483,
-0.5745491981506348,
-0.24410055577754974,
-0.40463966131210327,
-0.06657877564430237,
0.0030300559010356665,
0.5317043662071228,
-0.21626567840576172,
0.04993328079581261,
-0.19720691442489624,
-0.3895364999771118,
0.8426175713539124,
-0.17363284528255463,
0.4731154143810272,
0.5706712007522583,
-0.21779410541057587,
-0.6983558535575867,
0.8940873146057129,
0.19314521551132202,
-0.12521663308143616,
0.3753259479999542,
-0.4108183681964874,
-0.025194639340043068,
-0.6885443329811096,
-0.7646802663803101,
0.278646856546402,
-0.6126206517219543,
-0.4993496835231781,
-0.9122679233551025,
-0.06432799994945526,
-0.12955455482006073,
-0.17513638734817505,
-0.5529805421829224,
-0.48490601778030396,
-0.7494643330574036,
-0.14779476821422577,
0.699470579624176,
0.6085565686225891,
-0.039699189364910126,
-0.23224586248397827,
-1.0165469646453857,
0.36357948184013367,
0.18796437978744507,
0.5331246852874756,
-0.013273931108415127,
-0.07738886028528214,
-0.2629735469818115,
-0.19426961243152618,
0.06365066021680832,
-1.0753180980682373,
0.35284945368766785,
0.3164721131324768,
0.7296140789985657,
0.5772897005081177,
0.31255844235420227,
0.5559732913970947,
-0.534918487071991,
0.7158913016319275,
-0.08815284818410873,
-0.7232249975204468,
0.7423076033592224,
-0.1253126710653305,
-0.15478165447711945,
0.6470574736595154,
0.5715320110321045,
0.07600158452987671,
-0.24130968749523163,
-0.4714951515197754,
-1.3857754468917847,
0.611283004283905,
0.14576390385627747,
-0.03259650990366936,
-0.12591518461704254,
0.5918089151382446,
0.39840787649154663,
0.10463108867406845,
-0.6595556735992432,
-0.3721262812614441,
0.22275806963443756,
0.08502062410116196,
0.3963586688041687,
0.24734966456890106,
0.018340133130550385,
0.13559529185295105,
1.157720685005188,
-0.03291795775294304,
0.34092870354652405,
0.20271402597427368,
-0.19252772629261017,
-0.19258490204811096,
0.3245639204978943,
-0.003469737246632576,
0.16832034289836884,
-0.18940085172653198,
0.18293097615242004,
0.1877930611371994,
-0.37063929438591003,
-0.15944650769233704,
0.7293810248374939,
-0.3604620397090912,
0.3325347304344177,
0.15711091458797455,
0.5463193655014038,
0.14650452136993408,
-0.4738754630088806,
0.42243078351020813,
0.22499804198741913,
0.2400648146867752,
-0.8338400721549988,
0.010752491652965546,
-0.08132053166627884,
0.6725608706474304,
0.714213490486145,
0.36253878474235535,
0.26388558745384216,
-0.12414716184139252,
0.2730754613876343,
0.39192232489585876,
-0.6680002212524414,
-0.29107943177223206,
0.7257144451141357,
0.43190255761146545,
-0.2772632837295532,
0.90049147605896,
-0.4173438251018524,
-0.2989872992038727,
0.499424010515213,
0.1020837277173996,
1.1321308612823486,
-0.1238061711192131,
-0.10637757182121277,
0.4463079571723938,
0.06930095702409744,
-0.08088221400976181,
0.1322452276945114,
-0.4811503291130066,
-0.32520824670791626,
-0.3564561605453491,
-0.5391551852226257,
-0.4855526387691498,
-0.11086343973875046,
-0.5859280228614807,
0.5520114302635193,
-0.24064818024635315,
-0.3200201690196991,
0.2299240231513977,
-0.23640353977680206,
-0.43720805644989014,
0.047802697867155075,
0.44856753945350647,
0.8380143046379089,
-0.6541099548339844,
0.7635259628295898,
1.0896903276443481,
-0.6624068021774292,
-0.7441408634185791,
0.12681998312473297,
-0.10146410763263702,
-0.32880404591560364,
1.018627643585205,
0.16989202797412872,
0.14543266594409943,
-0.012459713034331799,
-0.24861115217208862,
-0.9405187964439392,
1.173113465309143,
0.1544298231601715,
-0.6625494360923767,
-0.2987191677093506,
-0.28161048889160156,
0.4546622931957245,
-0.15128619968891144,
0.4632089138031006,
-0.05151772126555443,
0.39082202315330505,
-0.017312463372945786,
-0.955543577671051,
0.1041591539978981,
-0.31658804416656494,
-0.1956925392150879,
0.8779654502868652,
-0.3935791850090027,
0.6022690534591675,
-0.609931468963623,
-0.2994278073310852,
0.04562791809439659,
1.049087405204773,
0.27073994278907776,
0.6373937726020813,
0.4138527512550354,
0.44589224457740784,
0.6669754981994629,
-0.10402645170688629,
0.5378625988960266,
-0.3364362120628357,
0.31622907519340515,
1.0571346282958984,
-0.5231544971466064,
1.0256924629211426,
0.6446923017501831,
-0.2945374846458435,
0.4842448830604553,
0.60573810338974,
-0.20924854278564453,
0.6680930852890015,
0.14272578060626984,
-0.47255611419677734,
-0.16751189529895782,
-0.018047252669930458,
-0.4130839407444,
0.03960064426064491,
0.3525945842266083,
-0.6673822999000549,
-0.21641145646572113,
0.2260286808013916,
0.05476519092917442,
-0.14675521850585938,
-0.5238739848136902,
0.9471118450164795,
-0.02437017671763897,
-0.39342740178108215,
0.22612623870372772,
-0.06226571649312973,
0.7278646230697632,
-0.5636167526245117,
-0.23651795089244843,
0.08447818458080292,
0.4062376022338867,
-0.3955143392086029,
-0.5788666605949402,
0.4205198884010315,
0.14534229040145874,
-0.06231469288468361,
0.12357527762651443,
0.8844462633132935,
-0.3718074858188629,
-0.42055466771125793,
0.42305368185043335,
0.5636129379272461,
0.26905906200408936,
-0.10696154832839966,
-0.5795404314994812,
-0.182632178068161,
-0.29887837171554565,
-0.2919694185256958,
0.27920645475387573,
0.5844892859458923,
-0.13848349452018738,
0.6044322848320007,
0.6413756012916565,
0.28935506939888,
-0.11603495478630066,
-0.21027135848999023,
1.1691159009933472,
-0.41930481791496277,
-0.4117935597896576,
-0.6553788185119629,
0.393232524394989,
-0.07553186267614365,
-0.16847427189350128,
0.8027111887931824,
0.8206509351730347,
0.9292123317718506,
0.004232443403452635,
0.7484495639801025,
-0.3327332139015198,
0.6588767766952515,
-0.2701430022716522,
0.540161669254303,
-0.3748892843723297,
0.6910343170166016,
-0.44995996356010437,
-0.9781846404075623,
-0.6478317379951477,
0.4076951742172241,
-0.5822164416313171,
-0.040753573179244995,
0.14770054817199707,
0.6172435879707336,
-0.28571587800979614,
-0.11004535853862762,
-0.09023568779230118,
0.047792620956897736,
0.03132350742816925,
0.34187328815460205,
0.7766067981719971,
-0.3702344298362732,
0.5485094785690308,
-0.42961975932121277,
-0.15243948996067047,
-0.04208049550652504,
-0.7314996123313904,
-0.806290864944458,
-0.4394087493419647,
-0.7019788026809692,
-0.37997162342071533,
0.36433538794517517,
1.1057556867599487,
0.6472479104995728,
-0.7763186097145081,
0.4978676736354828,
-0.263508141040802,
0.13482774794101715,
-0.2195856273174286,
-0.25776758790016174,
0.5135640501976013,
-0.10614341497421265,
-0.5074948668479919,
0.3611467480659485,
0.23728743195533752,
-0.0870087519288063,
-0.28364282846450806,
-0.12442391365766525,
-0.18322494626045227,
-0.2832815647125244,
0.21802806854248047,
0.49133211374282837,
-0.7425853610038757,
0.07853411883115768,
0.09991656988859177,
0.00488563347607851,
-0.014435871504247189,
0.5282432436943054,
-1.1353024244308472,
0.3276691138744354,
0.21804693341255188,
0.6342960596084595,
0.052352339029312134,
-0.052183929830789566,
0.015303054824471474,
-0.6932669878005981,
-0.06797774881124496,
0.5088838338851929,
0.16248513758182526,
0.5570154786109924,
-0.5223692655563354,
0.6902065277099609,
0.11017686128616333,
-0.7054566144943237,
-0.8152734637260437,
-0.0614226832985878,
-0.9777501225471497,
-0.0627470538020134,
1.190675973892212,
-0.4914187490940094,
-0.07423494011163712,
-0.42801687121391296,
-0.16613274812698364,
0.5637319684028625,
-0.763884961605072,
0.5549432635307312,
-0.036693040281534195,
-0.25700056552886963,
-0.31594589352607727,
-0.4330217242240906,
0.34425413608551025,
-0.14949123561382294,
-0.7958659529685974,
0.10634306818246841,
0.8411352038383484,
0.38479501008987427,
0.3167908191680908,
0.42587846517562866,
-0.16857531666755676,
0.1310347616672516,
-0.11239174753427505,
0.30401158332824707,
-0.32648545503616333,
-0.3185296058654785,
-0.22608673572540283,
0.30152401328086853,
0.3135972321033478,
-0.30607402324676514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16153v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16153v1
|
ChatMusician: Understanding and Generating Music Intrinsically with LLM
| 2024-02-25T17:19:41 | 2024-02-25T17:19:41 |
Ruibin Yuan, Hanfeng Lin, Yi Wang, Zeyue Tian, Shangda Wu, Tianhao Shen, Ge Zhang, Yuhang Wu, Cong Liu, Ziya Zhou, Ziyang Ma, Liumeng Xue, Ziyu Wang, Qin Liu, Tianyu Zheng, Yizhi Li, Yinghao Ma, Yiming Liang, Xiaowei Chi, Ruibo Liu, Zili Wang, Pengfei Li, Jingcheng Wu, Chenghua Lin, Qifeng Liu, Tao Jiang, Wenhao Huang, Wenhu Chen, Emmanouil Benetos, Jie Fu, Gus Xia, Roger Dannenberg, Wei Xue, Shiyin Kang, Yike Guo
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM, eess.AS
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate impressive capabilities in
text generation, we find that their ability has yet to be generalized to music,
humanity's creative language. We introduce ChatMusician, an open-source LLM
that integrates intrinsic musical abilities. It is based on continual
pre-training and finetuning LLaMA2 on a text-compatible music representation,
ABC notation, and the music is treated as a second language. ChatMusician can
understand and generate music with a pure text tokenizer without any external
multi-modal neural structures or tokenizers. Interestingly, endowing musical
abilities does not harm language abilities, even achieving a slightly higher
MMLU score. Our model is capable of composing well-structured, full-length
music, conditioned on texts, chords, melodies, motifs, musical forms, etc,
surpassing GPT-4 baseline. On our meticulously curated college-level music
understanding benchmark, MusicTheoryBench, ChatMusician surpasses LLaMA2 and
GPT-3.5 on zero-shot setting by a noticeable margin. Our work reveals that LLMs
can be an excellent compressor for music, but there remains significant
territory to be conquered. We release our 4B token music-language corpora
MusicPile, the collected MusicTheoryBench, code, model and demo in GitHub.
|
[
-0.12025519460439682,
-0.6024633646011353,
0.6001406908035278,
0.5035343766212463,
-0.06334912776947021,
0.48162540793418884,
-0.8059105277061462,
-0.5745933651924133,
0.20077486336231232,
0.3476170301437378,
-0.6711778044700623,
-0.5859875082969666,
-0.43262895941734314,
-0.2884281277656555,
-0.3548784554004669,
1.1410940885543823,
0.18869201838970184,
0.14210660755634308,
-0.19948026537895203,
0.08477357029914856,
-0.30911973118782043,
-0.45513468980789185,
-0.6332700848579407,
-0.34688928723335266,
0.6505355834960938,
0.3504413962364197,
0.19540295004844666,
0.1561311036348343,
0.7662889957427979,
0.32143667340278625,
-0.25644707679748535,
-0.03500126674771309,
-0.651669979095459,
0.247801274061203,
0.05382119119167328,
-0.7424538731575012,
-0.34453168511390686,
0.33384522795677185,
0.4444109797477722,
0.5585840344429016,
-0.2152758091688156,
0.2551462948322296,
-0.16095829010009766,
0.7088204622268677,
0.043881744146347046,
0.1429320126771927,
-0.9222692251205444,
0.2319473922252655,
-0.4993015229701996,
-0.30565163493156433,
-0.3104414641857147,
-0.40250685811042786,
-0.0651257261633873,
-0.9166024327278137,
-0.08131568878889084,
0.02913323976099491,
0.6364755630493164,
0.311536580324173,
-0.19632481038570404,
-0.5656389594078064,
-0.8654949069023132,
0.5505737066268921,
-0.38232091069221497,
0.18126972019672394,
0.3967829644680023,
0.7083667516708374,
-0.06791847199201584,
-0.774880051612854,
-0.5051733255386353,
-0.26626360416412354,
0.5009453296661377,
0.441639244556427,
-0.10264629125595093,
0.14862628281116486,
0.05355503037571907,
0.9723000526428223,
-0.4771290123462677,
-0.12058096379041672,
-0.6263731718063354,
-0.23642803728580475,
0.5898107290267944,
-0.020826665684580803,
0.4731544852256775,
-0.05845721438527107,
-0.32397565245628357,
0.0733184888958931,
-1.1194928884506226,
0.1666395217180252,
0.7686609029769897,
0.08360975235700607,
-0.18956446647644043,
0.6848501563072205,
0.40055158734321594,
0.5395687818527222,
-0.06004999577999115,
-0.3156035244464874,
0.08634128421545029,
-0.39922237396240234,
-0.00431162491440773,
0.04871126636862755,
0.9112951755523682,
0.008785959333181381,
0.39973682165145874,
-0.39941883087158203,
-0.3392783999443054,
0.2942168414592743,
0.1173262968659401,
-0.6368552446365356,
-0.4311348795890808,
0.2717231512069702,
-0.24904726445674896,
-0.3884812891483307,
-0.052306510508060455,
-0.0024007433094084263,
-0.2551696002483368,
-0.6626551747322083,
0.4494355618953705,
-0.6406623125076294,
-0.26305854320526123,
-0.05044209584593773,
-0.16929490864276886,
-0.13827405869960785,
0.03656116500496864,
-1.054477334022522,
0.16740486025810242,
0.9633193016052246,
1.0438616275787354,
-0.3320479393005371,
-0.22099457681179047,
-0.4084409773349762,
0.11471141129732132,
-0.47494396567344666,
0.7773482799530029,
-0.44782671332359314,
-0.5206452012062073,
-0.06130732595920563,
-0.3651953637599945,
0.0632956475019455,
-0.6931138634681702,
0.5018182992935181,
-0.5091063976287842,
0.27907630801200867,
0.10470807552337646,
-0.7445871829986572,
-0.13418182730674744,
-0.1353689283132553,
-0.4114404022693634,
0.7025802731513977,
0.16541650891304016,
-0.260407954454422,
0.051204122602939606,
-0.8029176592826843,
-0.3099677264690399,
0.056515246629714966,
-0.16656705737113953,
-0.06043710932135582,
0.5118151903152466,
-0.32370635867118835,
0.0868493840098381,
-0.22690825164318085,
0.5274108648300171,
-0.24607552587985992,
-0.6660718321800232,
0.6277705430984497,
-0.5969034433364868,
0.48176684975624084,
0.40055200457572937,
-0.05357324331998825,
0.2606147229671478,
-0.6322357058525085,
-0.21762710809707642,
0.01333619188517332,
-0.565096914768219,
0.13432806730270386,
0.010549438185989857,
0.5574977397918701,
0.08337090164422989,
0.3960188031196594,
-0.6404585838317871,
0.06834108382463455,
-0.5299433469772339,
0.7731636762619019,
0.9600102305412292,
-0.13339857757091522,
0.5387985110282898,
-0.5639075040817261,
0.5619871616363525,
-0.17407646775245667,
-0.2188631147146225,
-0.4424709379673004,
-0.4567795991897583,
-0.4616812765598297,
-0.31984618306159973,
0.2973414659500122,
0.42056745290756226,
-0.28891605138778687,
0.38792791962623596,
-0.2570534646511078,
-0.5695660710334778,
-0.5203652381896973,
0.37180548906326294,
0.12885083258152008,
0.20300500094890594,
0.11020782589912415,
-0.11810725927352905,
-0.6804998517036438,
-0.6208068132400513,
-0.2086140513420105,
-0.39780664443969727,
-0.43149417638778687,
0.38123711943626404,
0.047123633325099945,
-0.13655193150043488,
0.8325636982917786,
-0.30247676372528076,
-0.4987266957759857,
-0.22263053059577942,
0.18125657737255096,
0.7043537497520447,
0.5739277005195618,
0.486962229013443,
-0.49327170848846436,
-0.2812770903110504,
0.028950339183211327,
-0.6226404309272766,
-0.5123304724693298,
-0.08666541427373886,
-0.2811717391014099,
-0.06281813979148865,
0.27786368131637573,
-0.6483458280563354,
-0.3278963565826416,
0.6700952649116516,
-0.34222620725631714,
0.4378967881202698,
0.24494777619838715,
-0.09993346035480499,
-0.9806893467903137,
0.041402701288461685,
-0.2586967945098877,
-0.10049589723348618,
-0.5762920379638672,
-0.050411682575941086,
-0.2578207552433014,
-0.3880704939365387,
-0.347676157951355,
0.383081316947937,
-0.17129898071289062,
-0.2806294560432434,
-0.5743305087089539,
0.4319128394126892,
-0.14996209740638733,
0.4762791395187378,
0.15756233036518097,
0.6507671475410461,
0.7042255997657776,
-0.31945690512657166,
0.37139344215393066,
0.03812266141176224,
-0.48163342475891113,
0.7291969656944275,
-0.6884098649024963,
-0.044325996190309525,
0.12157592177391052,
0.21151131391525269,
-0.8030842542648315,
-0.47065266966819763,
0.18134059011936188,
-0.591118335723877,
0.5419358015060425,
-0.22541095316410065,
-0.3156813383102417,
-0.3044290542602539,
0.053992025554180145,
0.3931015431880951,
0.5760056972503662,
-0.5840423107147217,
0.47871825098991394,
0.5865195393562317,
-0.3853799104690552,
-0.08151281625032425,
-0.6875866055488586,
0.23174111545085907,
-0.3197952210903168,
-0.8353255391120911,
0.41278067231178284,
-0.540468156337738,
-0.3867456614971161,
-0.18265825510025024,
-0.25943994522094727,
0.12205611914396286,
0.31150567531585693,
0.4931316077709198,
0.3644943833351135,
-0.356630802154541,
0.41923654079437256,
-0.08612879365682602,
-0.14283965528011322,
0.17564372718334198,
-0.5469846725463867,
0.5177279114723206,
-0.22816923260688782,
-0.5673216581344604,
-0.37862762808799744,
0.14047308266162872,
0.5786086916923523,
-0.18584328889846802,
0.04631974920630455,
0.6008038520812988,
0.01752648502588272,
0.07858086377382278,
-0.3249678611755371,
-0.12812542915344238,
-0.4960280656814575,
0.11618571728467941,
-0.2648502290248871,
-1.2039378881454468,
0.40861210227012634,
-0.05568895488977432,
0.3457694947719574,
0.23749075829982758,
0.6711582541465759,
-0.40503236651420593,
0.612762987613678,
0.38031005859375,
0.026780715212225914,
0.7745050191879272,
-0.2598537802696228,
-0.14828117191791534,
-0.8439708352088928,
-0.1325467824935913,
-0.2935936748981476,
-0.4681876599788666,
-0.4958585798740387,
-0.41334688663482666,
0.4075077176094055,
-0.05883234366774559,
-0.2670840620994568,
-0.008662373758852482,
-0.3240889310836792,
0.6522811651229858,
0.45778486132621765,
0.026252472773194313,
0.294467031955719,
0.06401403993368149,
0.08436967432498932,
0.07983411103487015,
-0.25703340768814087,
-0.4305778741836548,
1.436406135559082,
0.4984544813632965,
0.7386151552200317,
0.42136693000793457,
0.826812744140625,
0.16469548642635345,
0.4939804971218109,
-1.0943819284439087,
0.21860577166080475,
0.04663785174489021,
-0.7916200160980225,
-0.06512308120727539,
-0.5348401069641113,
-0.566195547580719,
0.15200595557689667,
-0.10107792913913727,
-0.6547109484672546,
-0.3054681718349457,
0.019764086231589317,
-0.07202816009521484,
0.10119687765836716,
-0.5979903936386108,
0.5303857326507568,
-0.3996508717536926,
-0.3406946361064911,
-0.2251691371202469,
-0.3766910135746002,
0.7440686821937561,
-0.3280389606952667,
0.4544151723384857,
-0.5365361571311951,
-0.19167804718017578,
0.46502575278282166,
-0.19765673577785492,
0.786881148815155,
-0.10013773292303085,
-0.3380161225795746,
0.48533686995506287,
0.27598413825035095,
0.08370059728622437,
0.308766633272171,
-0.0055757551454007626,
0.3745582103729248,
-0.19312816858291626,
-0.33571290969848633,
-0.5629423260688782,
0.8664491176605225,
-0.8830790519714355,
-0.7039379477500916,
-0.06927695870399475,
-0.7143822312355042,
-0.2405766248703003,
-0.12132392078638077,
0.22012899816036224,
0.4457782804965973,
-0.249230295419693,
0.3330298960208893,
0.5465694069862366,
0.007536577060818672,
0.5425910353660583,
0.5628865957260132,
-0.5279147028923035,
-0.6531283855438232,
1.0477596521377563,
-0.18204784393310547,
0.09692209213972092,
0.29120975732803345,
0.34374240040779114,
-0.39475709199905396,
-0.42249324917793274,
-0.6493675112724304,
0.2774565517902374,
-0.5569539070129395,
-0.002086824970319867,
-0.4738309681415558,
-0.06697014719247818,
0.02642691507935524,
-0.05588366091251373,
-0.30050113797187805,
-0.7415030002593994,
-0.3941713571548462,
-0.24096354842185974,
0.38984617590904236,
0.7868984341621399,
-0.4967803955078125,
0.48140189051628113,
-0.8116108179092407,
0.20464012026786804,
0.30006107687950134,
0.42091742157936096,
-0.2189049869775772,
-0.8045598268508911,
-0.3471178710460663,
-0.09683170914649963,
-0.5780260562896729,
-0.7412379384040833,
0.006503457669168711,
0.6231642961502075,
0.46310675144195557,
0.6129100918769836,
-0.530189037322998,
0.5159152150154114,
-0.6255133152008057,
0.8287268280982971,
0.3500077724456787,
-1.1283518075942993,
0.5591146945953369,
-0.6660314798355103,
0.18472830951213837,
0.5283226370811462,
0.09623680263757706,
-0.700447678565979,
-0.728550136089325,
-0.44503358006477356,
-0.7422844767570496,
0.6130992770195007,
0.4942488968372345,
0.42608141899108887,
-0.05947180837392807,
0.07934489101171494,
0.10901754349470139,
0.38002270460128784,
-1.0456159114837646,
-0.053794220089912415,
-0.5269138216972351,
-0.4009536802768707,
-0.2774011492729187,
-0.012840860523283482,
-0.22758303582668304,
-0.09721115976572037,
0.860672652721405,
-0.17102836072444916,
0.10355595499277115,
-0.1071590781211853,
-0.027382059022784233,
-0.2517230212688446,
0.24673597514629364,
0.635199248790741,
0.5247628688812256,
-0.025383207947015762,
0.09808862209320068,
-0.36157694458961487,
-0.5374951958656311,
0.3363123834133148,
-0.0834139734506607,
0.10181084275245667,
-0.20085054636001587,
0.41311168670654297,
0.6357225775718689,
0.5095839500427246,
-0.8749082684516907,
0.506748616695404,
-0.11473871022462845,
-0.15230362117290497,
-0.6179062128067017,
0.33812329173088074,
0.5708135962486267,
0.10483452677726746,
0.43668901920318604,
0.06146983057260513,
0.05763829126954079,
-0.5349118113517761,
0.1518339216709137,
0.22001142799854279,
-0.749140739440918,
-0.5384063124656677,
0.8693743348121643,
0.12479501217603683,
-0.25097915530204773,
0.24070000648498535,
0.08948356658220291,
-0.2064117044210434,
0.5008377432823181,
0.8254504799842834,
0.9248602986335754,
0.1609220802783966,
0.06207427754998207,
0.29469022154808044,
0.16663531959056854,
0.20118007063865662,
0.4110110402107239,
-0.4991791546344757,
-0.4287033677101135,
-0.5098032355308533,
-0.9587030410766602,
-0.48459139466285706,
-0.1281268149614334,
-0.29533272981643677,
0.02522655762732029,
-0.42071688175201416,
-0.0609775185585022,
0.022019600495696068,
-0.1858285516500473,
-0.2668624222278595,
-0.24957025051116943,
0.3032163679599762,
0.9188632369041443,
-0.6905274391174316,
0.5768129229545593,
0.663672685623169,
-0.4244537651538849,
-0.6928229331970215,
-0.06459295749664307,
0.23615996539592743,
-0.5985788106918335,
0.7440084218978882,
0.24150340259075165,
0.10789065808057785,
0.12706686556339264,
-0.6503680348396301,
-0.900981068611145,
1.033469557762146,
0.3471532166004181,
-0.7146152853965759,
0.31698077917099,
-0.045342255383729935,
0.7194225192070007,
-0.26423993706703186,
0.3752382695674896,
0.42010241746902466,
0.6080774664878845,
0.5155569314956665,
-0.5561320185661316,
-0.5490015149116516,
-0.4610109329223633,
-0.08320154249668121,
0.13643060624599457,
-0.5930108428001404,
0.7716470956802368,
0.06969849020242691,
-0.4006238579750061,
0.42360469698905945,
0.7822417616844177,
0.4323998689651489,
0.29548129439353943,
0.15016598999500275,
0.5756343007087708,
0.9104133248329163,
-0.46735477447509766,
0.9446492195129395,
-0.6844482421875,
0.029124533757567406,
1.0446228981018066,
-0.1987220048904419,
0.643513560295105,
0.3672461211681366,
-0.22410552203655243,
0.539585530757904,
0.9446380138397217,
0.04480994865298271,
0.3356587290763855,
0.633642315864563,
-0.6520479321479797,
-0.4652651250362396,
-0.1901693195104599,
-0.3705908954143524,
0.7901796698570251,
0.39664337038993835,
-0.34465014934539795,
0.2387785166501999,
0.04532361030578613,
-0.16956952214241028,
0.23057681322097778,
-0.23437747359275818,
0.9071890711784363,
0.32699161767959595,
-0.5674878358840942,
0.2986678183078766,
-0.32736876606941223,
0.7519001364707947,
-0.707598090171814,
0.2538279592990875,
-0.15328581631183624,
-0.26660871505737305,
-0.14634117484092712,
-0.7913694381713867,
0.3307121694087982,
0.018184449523687363,
-0.16711798310279846,
-0.13334313035011292,
0.5667475461959839,
-0.5706191062927246,
-0.4538179337978363,
0.16921940445899963,
0.5077586770057678,
0.3318975567817688,
-0.1317926049232483,
-0.3904205858707428,
0.03951818868517876,
-0.2570030689239502,
-0.04083371162414551,
0.10226713865995407,
0.5277888178825378,
0.3642805814743042,
0.5129222869873047,
1.0964380502700806,
0.47309038043022156,
-0.17476928234100342,
0.1469123363494873,
0.7623869180679321,
-0.5622795820236206,
-0.5121885538101196,
-0.6982452869415283,
0.1832817792892456,
0.10145702213048935,
-0.17232646048069,
0.4706900417804718,
0.7874387502670288,
0.6997854709625244,
-0.15775416791439056,
0.7610186338424683,
0.07161611318588257,
0.285595566034317,
-0.7173426747322083,
0.8946723937988281,
-0.5673839449882507,
0.46594372391700745,
-0.12407996505498886,
-1.060787320137024,
-0.18487976491451263,
0.25168129801750183,
-0.08243194967508316,
-0.21148845553398132,
0.4000881612300873,
0.7192879915237427,
-0.13531087338924408,
0.30705422163009644,
0.47572940587997437,
0.09657438844442368,
0.3731648325920105,
0.7455378770828247,
1.3047348260879517,
-0.051443781703710556,
0.782040536403656,
-0.16497167944908142,
-0.20831768214702606,
0.03178334981203079,
-0.6398577094078064,
-0.9690214395523071,
-0.3425794243812561,
0.027600441128015518,
0.021535862237215042,
-0.2347339689731598,
1.0509412288665771,
0.7180846929550171,
-0.6150237917900085,
-0.5295523405075073,
-0.31332144141197205,
0.4566005766391754,
0.07830721139907837,
-0.26894471049308777,
0.030123678967356682,
-0.5104248523712158,
-0.9538692831993103,
0.9214993119239807,
0.6509509086608887,
0.17675964534282684,
-0.5707933902740479,
-0.28145283460617065,
0.3951648473739624,
0.17767663300037384,
0.6375724673271179,
0.2388250231742859,
-0.7556931376457214,
-0.14374864101409912,
0.189827561378479,
-0.1090441644191742,
0.24438101053237915,
0.935324490070343,
-0.3221428394317627,
0.4262925088405609,
0.42225807905197144,
0.4208493232727051,
0.4430672228336334,
-0.2412150800228119,
0.5413002967834473,
-0.5422789454460144,
0.0010946131078526378,
0.227876678109169,
0.41462087631225586,
0.3726016879081726,
-0.08145608752965927,
0.6009952425956726,
0.45685455203056335,
-0.6575819849967957,
-0.6064745783805847,
0.45521676540374756,
-1.1276333332061768,
-0.13474586606025696,
1.1676428318023682,
-0.18836019933223724,
-0.36703628301620483,
0.020753992721438408,
-0.38921552896499634,
0.11534716188907623,
-0.4227360486984253,
0.6925128102302551,
0.5738523602485657,
0.014544946141541004,
-0.06406547874212265,
-0.3833223879337311,
0.36472249031066895,
0.17515094578266144,
-0.660486102104187,
-0.1616201102733612,
0.7817826271057129,
0.13884319365024567,
0.3541100323200226,
0.6064368486404419,
-0.26997989416122437,
0.611809492111206,
-0.04398879408836365,
0.2845814824104309,
-0.268086314201355,
-0.31882014870643616,
-0.20039767026901245,
0.18675020337104797,
0.23300603032112122,
0.06275727599859238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16142v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16142v1
|
From Text to Transformation: A Comprehensive Review of Large Language Models' Versatility
| 2024-02-25T16:47:59 | 2024-02-25T16:47:59 |
Pravneet Kaur, Gautam Siddharth Kashyap, Ankit Kumar, Md Tabrez Nafis, Sandeep Kumar, Vikrant Shokeen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This groundbreaking study explores the expanse of Large Language Models
(LLMs), such as Generative Pre-Trained Transformer (GPT) and Bidirectional
Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT) across varied domains ranging
from technology, finance, healthcare to education. Despite their established
prowess in Natural Language Processing (NLP), these LLMs have not been
systematically examined for their impact on domains such as fitness, and
holistic well-being, urban planning, climate modelling as well as disaster
management. This review paper, in addition to furnishing a comprehensive
analysis of the vast expanse and extent of LLMs' utility in diverse domains,
recognizes the research gaps and realms where the potential of LLMs is yet to
be harnessed. This study uncovers innovative ways in which LLMs can leave a
mark in the fields like fitness and wellbeing, urban planning, climate
modelling and disaster response which could inspire future researches and
applications in the said avenues.
|
[
-0.29630303382873535,
-0.5578730702400208,
0.6584893465042114,
0.20635052025318146,
-0.04844028130173683,
0.2251223921775818,
-0.4701942503452301,
-0.4428153932094574,
-0.02509324997663498,
0.8497439026832581,
-0.3877129554748535,
-0.21752098202705383,
-0.9795854687690735,
0.22616492211818695,
-0.7485607862472534,
0.9446730613708496,
-0.06978324800729752,
0.11500512063503265,
-0.2119181901216507,
-0.040741465985774994,
-0.28309381008148193,
-0.7545692324638367,
-0.38647085428237915,
-0.5289254784584045,
0.2829343378543854,
0.018674101680517197,
0.8600653409957886,
0.052554305642843246,
0.6828272938728333,
0.2997288107872009,
-0.2260339856147766,
0.021212758496403694,
-0.5373117923736572,
0.04211616516113281,
-0.29147860407829285,
-0.22586590051651,
-0.20667769014835358,
-0.20297040045261383,
0.8472099304199219,
0.876200795173645,
0.02530665136873722,
0.05938282236456871,
0.39413055777549744,
0.6131002902984619,
-0.22078780829906464,
0.012361058965325356,
-0.6624433994293213,
-0.1681193709373474,
-0.06316246092319489,
-0.029825672507286072,
-0.2780923545360565,
-0.22939236462116241,
0.35162216424942017,
-0.03858951851725578,
-0.054490894079208374,
-0.0836351290345192,
0.6144586205482483,
0.284419447183609,
-0.7141655087471008,
-0.42453381419181824,
-1.3274602890014648,
0.9733355641365051,
-0.7715966105461121,
0.5117881298065186,
-0.01745682582259178,
0.32629695534706116,
-0.18833811581134796,
-0.8707189559936523,
-0.47976210713386536,
0.05601843073964119,
0.1985757201910019,
-0.027555380016565323,
-0.0795416533946991,
0.058711938560009,
-0.046300265938043594,
0.4731312394142151,
-0.25345101952552795,
0.39709770679473877,
-0.1447911411523819,
-0.0023567660246044397,
0.7046587467193604,
0.3539636731147766,
0.34795910120010376,
-0.058125924319028854,
-0.28184598684310913,
-0.1998223513364792,
-0.8241195678710938,
-0.09127429127693176,
0.03644431009888649,
0.33266136050224304,
-0.020848242565989494,
0.6670699715614319,
0.13732708990573883,
0.6254640817642212,
-0.5532558560371399,
-0.45448851585388184,
0.023306909948587418,
-0.39163315296173096,
-0.4899463951587677,
-0.2748619616031647,
0.771582305431366,
-0.1665327250957489,
0.13076943159103394,
-0.3468801975250244,
-0.21556356549263,
-0.26153695583343506,
0.32643699645996094,
-0.7174076437950134,
0.22991201281547546,
0.06885239481925964,
-0.4754600524902344,
0.025194788351655006,
-0.1049172580242157,
-0.791347086429596,
-0.35633185505867004,
-0.5102816820144653,
0.10445664077997208,
-0.48520123958587646,
-0.3269132077693939,
0.5520493984222412,
0.2715325355529785,
0.5808051228523254,
0.41081172227859497,
-0.9791170954704285,
0.183075413107872,
0.8625165224075317,
0.7498190402984619,
-0.22346779704093933,
-0.09915252029895782,
0.3774498701095581,
0.2508634328842163,
-0.09720253199338913,
0.7118006944656372,
-0.5313724875450134,
-0.573396623134613,
0.5290817618370056,
-0.1854463815689087,
-0.007571070920675993,
-0.388288676738739,
0.7506349682807922,
-0.5178492665290833,
0.02239127829670906,
-0.14602182805538177,
-0.4288281500339508,
-0.2684246003627777,
0.3948633670806885,
-0.7213817834854126,
0.8805209994316101,
0.06823848187923431,
-0.600763201713562,
0.15774478018283844,
-0.6843821406364441,
-0.6211862564086914,
0.006244754418730736,
0.026494069024920464,
-0.5065737962722778,
0.1341235190629959,
0.08857593685388565,
0.617041826248169,
-0.728282630443573,
0.5771904587745667,
-0.1195925697684288,
0.18063730001449585,
0.35294345021247864,
-0.6486145853996277,
0.686850905418396,
0.021678131073713303,
-0.14999209344387054,
0.2476104497909546,
-0.7998900413513184,
-0.15710031986236572,
0.1149836927652359,
-0.4401198625564575,
-0.299094021320343,
0.3252774477005005,
0.4243912696838379,
0.28663262724876404,
0.4345903694629669,
-0.3864545524120331,
0.24915440380573273,
-0.4263094663619995,
0.6952444314956665,
0.5673674941062927,
-0.35334286093711853,
0.5492719411849976,
-0.20676995813846588,
0.49498143792152405,
-0.41514602303504944,
0.052940718829631805,
0.02169576659798622,
-0.5372301936149597,
-0.6073692440986633,
-0.28790825605392456,
0.2222232222557068,
0.4224451184272766,
-0.7279683351516724,
0.5581874251365662,
-0.584932804107666,
-0.5994452238082886,
-0.3408423662185669,
0.012147410772740841,
-0.2569911777973175,
0.15395274758338928,
0.29695773124694824,
0.09603379666805267,
-0.642427384853363,
-0.7257339954376221,
-0.39403268694877625,
-0.07065638154745102,
-0.08155696839094162,
0.16444142162799835,
0.6354785561561584,
-0.8184649348258972,
1.0443071126937866,
-0.26324355602264404,
-0.14989690482616425,
-0.7019492387771606,
-0.2485376000404358,
0.19168931245803833,
0.13135769963264465,
0.5175482034683228,
-1.071137547492981,
-0.34129640460014343,
-0.03192548453807831,
-0.46040642261505127,
-0.05645240843296051,
-0.2461351603269577,
0.14192774891853333,
-0.11534315347671509,
0.38124722242355347,
-0.6010833382606506,
0.20440275967121124,
0.8878927230834961,
-0.12719684839248657,
0.6005527377128601,
-0.22161129117012024,
0.02298755943775177,
-1.1265079975128174,
0.09309498220682144,
-0.15773288905620575,
-0.21151751279830933,
-0.6903437972068787,
0.03930256515741348,
-0.1768631488084793,
-0.19733096659183502,
-0.20222952961921692,
0.7151323556900024,
-0.42711150646209717,
-0.02572423592209816,
-0.33015891909599304,
-0.07851654291152954,
-0.33273667097091675,
-0.20901215076446533,
0.020021848380565643,
0.6386944055557251,
0.3931063413619995,
-0.6017602682113647,
0.2886824607849121,
0.48338961601257324,
-0.4118814170360565,
0.1333458572626114,
-0.5325536727905273,
0.032307032495737076,
-0.09264017641544342,
0.19147224724292755,
-0.9350730776786804,
-0.2715723216533661,
-0.21704727411270142,
-0.048892125487327576,
0.294200599193573,
0.2569030523300171,
-0.9139073491096497,
-0.5650399327278137,
-0.15690776705741882,
0.38860490918159485,
0.6459852457046509,
-0.43000805377960205,
0.7041504979133606,
0.42748090624809265,
-0.3238784074783325,
-0.21949031949043274,
-0.7079463601112366,
0.4931870996952057,
-0.33795666694641113,
-0.4986531734466553,
0.38936153054237366,
-0.21141068637371063,
-0.2521284222602844,
-0.22615420818328857,
0.013831251300871372,
-0.05325913056731224,
0.2442813515663147,
0.15945322811603546,
0.3303203582763672,
-0.07452133297920227,
0.1812690943479538,
-0.13629472255706787,
-0.003010894637554884,
0.055987611413002014,
-0.4274357259273529,
0.6996310353279114,
-0.07050944864749908,
-0.3986343443393707,
0.22045718133449554,
0.3721659779548645,
0.6460674405097961,
-0.2652437388896942,
0.9608632326126099,
0.3474291265010834,
-0.42357486486434937,
-0.016189593821763992,
-0.4566468596458435,
0.14374583959579468,
-0.45473989844322205,
0.6553600430488586,
-0.004227273166179657,
-1.2903752326965332,
0.42884573340415955,
-0.5940136313438416,
0.1617775559425354,
0.674640417098999,
0.8280490040779114,
0.19072341918945312,
0.7394328117370605,
1.0850939750671387,
-0.2012234479188919,
0.5044605731964111,
-0.028171434998512268,
0.6229594349861145,
-0.9185492396354675,
-0.3358873426914215,
-0.6616206169128418,
-0.07385783642530441,
-0.7405323386192322,
-0.42323705554008484,
0.5399495959281921,
-0.12425418198108673,
-0.17892524600028992,
0.2693927586078644,
-0.4281533360481262,
0.07449047267436981,
0.006790750660002232,
-0.22369928658008575,
0.2762923836708069,
0.009102838113904,
0.21288788318634033,
-0.20171944797039032,
-0.621549665927887,
-0.984272301197052,
1.2041341066360474,
0.5873500108718872,
0.8700264096260071,
0.20755983889102936,
0.5190473794937134,
0.03933412581682205,
0.6582357287406921,
-0.8516002297401428,
0.5581330060958862,
-0.43104133009910583,
-0.6336053013801575,
-0.5661278963088989,
-0.23969228565692902,
-1.0790154933929443,
0.08041100949048996,
-0.37586361169815063,
-0.6293990612030029,
-0.19979003071784973,
-0.28565505146980286,
-0.14992564916610718,
0.774337649345398,
-0.28270667791366577,
0.3363945782184601,
-0.5670142769813538,
-0.11798901855945587,
-0.22149820625782013,
-0.4253390431404114,
0.3048986494541168,
-0.47156405448913574,
0.4867978096008301,
0.004910303745418787,
-0.06953185796737671,
0.7847649455070496,
0.030050551518797874,
0.8912712931632996,
0.29935088753700256,
-0.6570663452148438,
0.19124308228492737,
-0.06866148114204407,
0.2338535040616989,
-0.042154792696237564,
-0.2779639661312103,
0.4781445562839508,
-0.211704283952713,
-0.17383919656276703,
-0.20714779198169708,
0.6413246989250183,
-0.717815101146698,
-0.5911832451820374,
-0.2528932988643646,
-0.5922286510467529,
-0.5692963004112244,
0.40642303228378296,
0.0726991668343544,
0.05548323318362236,
-0.6256064772605896,
0.33639201521873474,
0.8252240419387817,
-0.43021532893180847,
0.6382275223731995,
0.2790803909301758,
-0.20273052155971527,
-0.3738817274570465,
0.5141281485557556,
0.0712115615606308,
0.24435314536094666,
0.622470498085022,
0.1464872509241104,
-0.37715935707092285,
-0.8078970313072205,
-0.07709640264511108,
0.34691616892814636,
-0.6980435848236084,
-0.20822301506996155,
-0.5427131056785583,
-0.4855518639087677,
-0.4953736364841461,
-0.3809065818786621,
-0.5064045190811157,
-0.013737034983932972,
-0.4550793766975403,
0.005636604502797127,
0.009512250311672688,
1.0686250925064087,
0.11195491999387741,
0.29971447587013245,
-0.9122453927993774,
0.2184392660856247,
0.4327247142791748,
0.4230935871601105,
-0.09146513044834137,
-0.4721880555152893,
-0.3304859399795532,
0.09091600030660629,
-0.4635393023490906,
-0.6665277481079102,
0.5871496200561523,
0.11911473423242569,
0.5704798102378845,
0.23537121713161469,
-0.25507137179374695,
0.25933173298835754,
-0.7975996732711792,
0.983255922794342,
0.44261983036994934,
-0.8893730044364929,
0.2598450481891632,
-0.24205833673477173,
0.29990944266319275,
0.24931442737579346,
0.5174740552902222,
-0.609984278678894,
0.017979618161916733,
-0.49173274636268616,
-1.1366331577301025,
0.2509826719760895,
0.15909278392791748,
0.5724329948425293,
0.27529376745224,
0.2188951075077057,
0.42155757546424866,
0.3266006410121918,
-0.895027220249176,
-0.19751082360744476,
-0.1294686496257782,
-0.18528157472610474,
-0.33589503169059753,
-0.5691629648208618,
-0.01451385673135519,
-0.30835700035095215,
0.4596203565597534,
-0.1201256811618805,
0.373904287815094,
0.12105704098939896,
-0.006353462114930153,
0.3217180073261261,
0.7280480861663818,
0.6152709126472473,
0.562074601650238,
0.1516088843345642,
0.14776882529258728,
0.10640676319599152,
-0.34306424856185913,
0.24641521275043488,
-0.003202912863343954,
0.054692987352609634,
-0.07094980031251907,
0.7202057242393494,
0.6195837259292603,
0.39231282472610474,
-0.5914732217788696,
0.12738846242427826,
0.2213328629732132,
-0.2194337099790573,
-0.2354351282119751,
-0.05116520822048187,
0.3512188196182251,
0.23295611143112183,
0.40006041526794434,
0.018411412835121155,
-0.019352642819285393,
-0.7746182680130005,
-0.23146435618400574,
0.4795268476009369,
-0.25357016921043396,
-0.4041050672531128,
0.6978108882904053,
0.2444603145122528,
-0.418529748916626,
0.4277428686618805,
0.37975236773490906,
-0.6441643834114075,
0.34827643632888794,
0.7071775794029236,
1.0484075546264648,
-0.2649829685688019,
0.027878541499376297,
0.11837117373943329,
0.4746231138706207,
-0.29724714159965515,
-0.05547713860869408,
0.2156837433576584,
-0.9671350717544556,
-0.4660266935825348,
-0.8220038414001465,
-0.3646160364151001,
0.329441636800766,
-0.395669549703598,
0.14538611471652985,
-0.3337993323802948,
-0.284390926361084,
-0.01290161069482565,
-0.3816729485988617,
-0.8588963150978088,
0.23687507212162018,
0.3694388270378113,
0.9114731550216675,
-0.7403904795646667,
0.7786920666694641,
0.8616654276847839,
0.0194901954382658,
-0.4211743175983429,
0.36487680673599243,
-0.39401450753211975,
-0.7359142899513245,
0.5956603288650513,
-0.033380597829818726,
-0.14676976203918457,
-0.043714385479688644,
-0.666632354259491,
-0.8078806400299072,
0.8304142951965332,
0.5567601919174194,
-0.7387192845344543,
-0.21043449640274048,
0.7120999693870544,
0.8507936596870422,
-0.2540024220943451,
0.10703567415475845,
0.6817762851715088,
0.5919541120529175,
-0.10979898273944855,
-1.124815583229065,
-0.20887045562267303,
0.16904914379119873,
0.33929091691970825,
0.09566091001033783,
-0.7070663571357727,
0.5947233438491821,
-0.12372778356075287,
-0.07273072749376297,
0.02377653308212757,
0.5997626185417175,
-0.18364030122756958,
0.010102381929755211,
0.17256668210029602,
0.230512797832489,
0.5198861360549927,
-0.11395459622144699,
1.23458731174469,
-0.18477684259414673,
0.5804385542869568,
0.5086043477058411,
-0.4501456916332245,
0.764328122138977,
0.5555169582366943,
-0.45821499824523926,
0.5744923949241638,
0.3902128040790558,
0.23069162666797638,
0.5289069414138794,
0.14376647770404816,
-0.40973564982414246,
-0.47296804189682007,
0.12787076830863953,
-0.1904417723417282,
0.5776956081390381,
0.5865926146507263,
-0.27867209911346436,
-0.3150050640106201,
0.31780561804771423,
-0.18843229115009308,
0.178067147731781,
-0.30890586972236633,
0.7126554250717163,
0.4377252459526062,
-0.2592836320400238,
0.3456282615661621,
0.17797698080539703,
0.7995333671569824,
-0.9565354585647583,
0.032694991677999496,
0.1571960300207138,
0.07852162420749664,
-0.10152250528335571,
-1.0442034006118774,
0.5126738548278809,
-0.17875057458877563,
-0.19449986517429352,
-0.7478773593902588,
1.041891098022461,
-0.21804359555244446,
-0.48745402693748474,
0.5424692630767822,
0.44447970390319824,
-0.27664515376091003,
0.03050888329744339,
-0.5332080125808716,
0.13474315404891968,
0.03526601940393448,
-0.34706130623817444,
0.3738989233970642,
0.5614577531814575,
0.1484319418668747,
0.8643128871917725,
0.5280135869979858,
0.11395701766014099,
-0.1462867707014084,
-0.12324007600545883,
0.8836181163787842,
-0.8549937605857849,
-0.28155505657196045,
-0.9846658706665039,
0.44513964653015137,
0.07714886963367462,
-0.20653605461120605,
0.7341644167900085,
0.444830983877182,
0.5509973168373108,
-0.273851603269577,
1.067813754081726,
0.03836346045136452,
0.23776303231716156,
-0.5115017294883728,
0.643182635307312,
-0.39185070991516113,
0.3854086399078369,
-0.25522029399871826,
-0.9300759434700012,
-0.45215317606925964,
0.4258662462234497,
-0.5875261425971985,
-0.0011179510038346052,
0.5343782305717468,
0.16283753514289856,
0.11044483631849289,
-0.10377984493970871,
0.5470685362815857,
0.06450441479682922,
0.7328673601150513,
0.49040305614471436,
0.7643803954124451,
-0.3093836009502411,
0.28499627113342285,
0.4397544860839844,
-0.10887309163808823,
-0.28758400678634644,
-0.9058258533477783,
-0.8879981637001038,
-0.6742908358573914,
-0.11670155823230743,
-0.1476939171552658,
-0.264156699180603,
0.6153242588043213,
0.48286131024360657,
-0.7247377038002014,
-0.17689141631126404,
0.021546518430113792,
0.14111457765102386,
0.12310399115085602,
-0.17747539281845093,
0.29179951548576355,
-0.09084051847457886,
-0.7186205983161926,
0.25655508041381836,
0.5267024636268616,
0.21966621279716492,
-0.6623899340629578,
-0.06746441125869751,
0.046669527888298035,
0.28765279054641724,
1.069916009902954,
0.17203554511070251,
-0.5846434831619263,
-0.2268754243850708,
-0.10060460865497589,
-0.27571216225624084,
0.07211748510599136,
1.1009174585342407,
-0.5980919599533081,
0.10147424042224884,
0.34821876883506775,
1.0410560369491577,
0.372313916683197,
-0.6401318907737732,
0.4669104814529419,
-0.4168297052383423,
0.036430466920137405,
0.39530685544013977,
0.3875467777252197,
0.6566286087036133,
-0.19679728150367737,
0.441718727350235,
0.19408254325389862,
-0.6900883316993713,
-0.6567628383636475,
0.3463047444820404,
-0.9235125184059143,
-0.323742538690567,
1.5934656858444214,
0.23145122826099396,
-0.041508935391902924,
-0.1537887454032898,
-0.33237043023109436,
0.16534459590911865,
0.15646232664585114,
0.9192601442337036,
0.7869419455528259,
-0.10598640888929367,
-0.05706222727894783,
-0.6282139420509338,
0.3970469832420349,
0.41709864139556885,
-0.9931780099868774,
0.16833902895450592,
0.12223884463310242,
0.3252338767051697,
0.13279059529304504,
0.4821489751338959,
-0.16818483173847198,
-0.48297762870788574,
-0.387267142534256,
0.18396176397800446,
0.30198803544044495,
-0.14190392196178436,
-0.41628164052963257,
0.0494547076523304,
0.27124887704849243,
0.32993677258491516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16141v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16141v1
|
PeriodicLoRA: Breaking the Low-Rank Bottleneck in LoRA Optimization
| 2024-02-25T16:43:41 | 2024-02-25T16:43:41 |
Xiangdi Meng, Damai Dai, Weiyao Luo, Zhe Yang, Shaoxiang Wu, Xiaochen Wang, Peiyi Wang, Qingxiu Dong, Liang Chen, Zhifang Sui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Supervised fine-tuning is the most common method to adapt large language
models (LLMs) to downstream tasks, but full fine-tuning LLMs requires massive
computational resources. Recently, parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT)
methods have been widely studied due to its cost-effectiveness. LoRA is one of
the most widely used methods, which assumes that the optimization process is
essentially low-dimensional. Although LoRA fine-tuning is effective, there is
still a performance gap compared to full fine-tuning, since its weight update
is limited to low-rank matrices. In order to break the low-rank bottleneck in
LoRA Optimization, we propose PeriodicLoRA (PLoRA), which accumulates low-rank
update matrices multiple times to achieve a higher update rank. PLoRA has
multiple training stages. During each stage, we still update only the LoRA
weights. However, at the end of each stage, we unload the LoRA weights into the
backbone parameters and then reinitialize the LoRA states. Experimental results
show that PLoRA has stronger learning ability, approximately 1.8 times that of
LoRA's learning ability at most, but it does not increase memory usage.
Further, we introduce a momentum-based unloading strategy for PLoRA to mitigate
the training instability.
|
[
-0.3905596435070038,
-0.9231834411621094,
0.4113638997077942,
0.39867356419563293,
-0.3967368006706238,
0.3106205463409424,
-0.5390452146530151,
-0.2606181800365448,
0.023038597777485847,
0.4265355169773102,
-0.6118742227554321,
-0.5409994125366211,
-0.4032304883003235,
0.0968407467007637,
-0.23097839951515198,
0.9772719740867615,
0.13858318328857422,
-0.0047299242578446865,
0.23296794295310974,
-0.12289032340049744,
-0.7561792135238647,
-0.0732744112610817,
-0.9666832685470581,
-0.457269549369812,
0.7873607277870178,
0.546440839767456,
0.6548702716827393,
0.6228423118591309,
0.3643086850643158,
0.3721740245819092,
-0.39317676424980164,
0.5445263981819153,
-0.931865930557251,
0.1236904114484787,
-0.19066891074180603,
-0.5772014856338501,
-0.6384536027908325,
-0.14420980215072632,
0.7465436458587646,
0.9947459697723389,
-0.24490270018577576,
0.20563191175460815,
0.1449992060661316,
0.914650022983551,
-0.7436723113059998,
0.14203879237174988,
-0.8826663494110107,
-0.013663975521922112,
-0.6021967530250549,
-0.3265988528728485,
-0.35771533846855164,
-0.38385698199272156,
-0.21357694268226624,
-0.919807493686676,
-0.19564862549304962,
0.14336282014846802,
0.8437869548797607,
0.8129737377166748,
-0.09053613990545273,
0.10799463093280792,
-0.6562243700027466,
0.7612719535827637,
-0.5652357935905457,
0.0582546629011631,
0.3799663186073303,
0.10470101237297058,
-0.41093137860298157,
-0.2973121106624603,
-0.3343515992164612,
0.047844115644693375,
0.36965811252593994,
0.01871645636856556,
-0.10037896782159805,
-0.04502308741211891,
0.19594132900238037,
0.4201437830924988,
-0.47996243834495544,
0.5017126202583313,
-0.5066552758216858,
0.35098573565483093,
0.5836489796638489,
-0.01906770095229149,
0.04771867021918297,
0.1807907521724701,
-0.21630877256393433,
-0.14235395193099976,
-0.8060768246650696,
0.006759508512914181,
0.480607807636261,
0.584796130657196,
-0.0827765092253685,
0.42184579372406006,
-0.2368588000535965,
0.6800913214683533,
0.336840957403183,
-0.0922890156507492,
0.2520811855792999,
0.000016472864444949664,
-0.22201882302761078,
0.21318355202674866,
0.43212300539016724,
-0.017706191167235374,
0.39052823185920715,
-0.03486350178718567,
-0.023771902546286583,
0.33017194271087646,
0.13085485994815826,
-0.6529088616371155,
-0.3056137263774872,
0.31327685713768005,
-0.35567420721054077,
-0.4811297357082367,
-0.00886513665318489,
-1.1722289323806763,
-0.4844532310962677,
-0.2490149438381195,
0.47719791531562805,
-0.40506699681282043,
0.1308271586894989,
0.3678397238254547,
0.38615357875823975,
-0.01828196458518505,
0.5678144693374634,
-0.8245251774787903,
0.28283941745758057,
0.7928752899169922,
0.7889831066131592,
-0.42665204405784607,
-0.4107225835323334,
-1.1860239505767822,
-0.08793887495994568,
-0.3681364357471466,
0.8669164776802063,
-0.4411672055721283,
-0.2945109009742737,
-0.08844367414712906,
-0.03426593914628029,
-0.2750542461872101,
-0.6905919909477234,
0.22784742712974548,
-0.6623866558074951,
0.11985164880752563,
-0.1051306501030922,
-0.2510664165019989,
0.03336271643638611,
-0.14560608565807343,
-0.7316974997520447,
1.1468040943145752,
0.20111308991909027,
-0.5473171472549438,
0.090668685734272,
-0.7869443297386169,
-0.258137047290802,
-0.06912904232740402,
0.07778743654489517,
-0.6799601316452026,
0.32434573769569397,
0.12264573574066162,
0.0006444303435273468,
-0.22252298891544342,
-0.046823643147945404,
-0.28099319338798523,
-0.5976422429084778,
0.18527807295322418,
-0.1813669204711914,
0.5632299184799194,
0.3693195879459381,
-0.2722603380680084,
0.35121843218803406,
-0.9722088575363159,
-0.12475509196519852,
0.09571173042058945,
-0.7184022068977356,
-0.3771304488182068,
0.0759357139468193,
-0.06903208792209625,
0.02432311698794365,
0.46284323930740356,
-0.39714521169662476,
0.6270081996917725,
-0.6036986708641052,
0.3973783552646637,
1.0083955526351929,
0.0532405860722065,
0.4482601284980774,
-0.31045863032341003,
0.298036128282547,
-0.030247295275330544,
0.26226896047592163,
0.12621532380580902,
-0.37537771463394165,
-0.9821586012840271,
-0.2248350977897644,
0.5442134737968445,
0.4333100914955139,
-0.764573872089386,
0.22245800495147705,
-0.16207468509674072,
-0.41216543316841125,
-0.6191624402999878,
0.7224687337875366,
0.40645673871040344,
0.10768193751573563,
0.49339690804481506,
-0.39075368642807007,
-0.29298844933509827,
-0.5293376445770264,
-0.2245642989873886,
0.004820115398615599,
0.40581464767456055,
-0.12128443270921707,
0.47038400173187256,
-0.15876469016075134,
0.8847190737724304,
-0.65139240026474,
-0.5945324301719666,
-0.1679045557975769,
0.273122102022171,
0.5071793794631958,
0.5220398902893066,
0.4191541075706482,
-0.5544289946556091,
-0.5144195556640625,
0.06262882798910141,
-0.5726573467254639,
-0.4603683352470398,
-0.2259892374277115,
-0.1583404690027237,
0.44294455647468567,
0.38982468843460083,
-0.440439909696579,
0.32306814193725586,
0.7142075300216675,
-0.378536581993103,
0.12890484929084778,
-0.37112200260162354,
-0.35302433371543884,
-0.6829448342323303,
-0.08061470091342926,
-0.08506248891353607,
-0.20282407104969025,
-0.3917085826396942,
0.16171254217624664,
-0.22674909234046936,
-0.19395790994167328,
-0.4388839900493622,
0.42928919196128845,
-0.4205126166343689,
-0.11513734608888626,
-0.42577144503593445,
0.3708442747592926,
-0.18766342103481293,
0.9616091251373291,
-0.2679535746574402,
0.8847696185112,
0.30263465642929077,
-0.4916943609714508,
0.09929363429546356,
0.25215524435043335,
-0.2654300332069397,
0.5608986616134644,
-0.6065350770950317,
0.09208285808563232,
-0.0681319609284401,
-0.09886165708303452,
-0.6494641900062561,
0.03828715533018112,
0.10791826993227005,
0.13102124631404877,
0.23951326310634613,
-0.037025336176157,
-0.542259156703949,
0.03910668194293976,
-0.48812228441238403,
0.22509698569774628,
0.48138102889060974,
-0.7733871936798096,
0.47914382815361023,
0.28999704122543335,
-0.03792029991745949,
-0.30740368366241455,
-0.14532120525836945,
-0.2301407903432846,
-0.36949262022972107,
-0.40882182121276855,
0.530026376247406,
-0.23915159702301025,
-0.47511085867881775,
-0.2909128665924072,
-0.18905121088027954,
0.287370502948761,
0.3242816925048828,
0.3010234534740448,
-0.021213361993432045,
0.04847637936472893,
0.07742776721715927,
0.05572756379842758,
-0.440360963344574,
-0.39537501335144043,
-0.18323567509651184,
0.941681981086731,
-0.3283984363079071,
-0.37548696994781494,
-0.5352187752723694,
0.04631061106920242,
0.6155503988265991,
-0.23695284128189087,
0.7961709499359131,
0.7073730230331421,
-0.18242155015468597,
-0.6119604706764221,
-0.381221741437912,
-0.1297961175441742,
-0.5498175621032715,
0.370576411485672,
-0.37277379631996155,
-0.6447808742523193,
0.4050215482711792,
-0.46101367473602295,
0.08466783910989761,
0.35988086462020874,
0.5669109225273132,
-0.15698809921741486,
0.7479592561721802,
0.7604439854621887,
-0.21864013373851776,
0.6214007139205933,
-0.3659589886665344,
-0.0430978424847126,
-0.7593304514884949,
-0.02690025418996811,
-0.5174499750137329,
-0.5620753765106201,
-0.5242897868156433,
-0.5231895446777344,
0.6824160218238831,
0.41512975096702576,
-0.4701143503189087,
0.22151224315166473,
-0.4419461786746979,
0.3457639813423157,
0.6197401285171509,
0.09365756064653397,
0.8463557958602905,
0.17325082421302795,
0.24009153246879578,
0.04397051781415939,
-0.6985774636268616,
-0.11808004230260849,
0.9430418610572815,
0.34061020612716675,
0.9261875152587891,
0.21569252014160156,
0.6411710977554321,
0.2811286747455597,
0.011843421496450901,
-0.5324984788894653,
0.654102623462677,
-0.5097700953483582,
-0.01091026421636343,
-0.44741693139076233,
-0.32831600308418274,
-1.1415637731552124,
0.35033050179481506,
-0.20642933249473572,
-0.7409853339195251,
0.30477479100227356,
-0.004340778570622206,
-0.49606722593307495,
0.24568939208984375,
-0.2676185369491577,
0.6985727548599243,
-0.2563416063785553,
-0.5690116286277771,
-0.4991491436958313,
-0.3727632761001587,
0.15236853063106537,
-0.5065411329269409,
0.2738153338432312,
-0.03636602684855461,
0.04810556024312973,
0.807941734790802,
-0.7158511281013489,
1.0300601720809937,
-0.12469631433486938,
-0.5436282753944397,
-0.0421297587454319,
0.038073278963565826,
0.6738165616989136,
0.15768831968307495,
0.11171603947877884,
0.17137393355369568,
0.08963596820831299,
-0.31740525364875793,
-0.5172871351242065,
0.7368313670158386,
-1.1060799360275269,
-0.38573339581489563,
-0.5640202760696411,
-0.5225849747657776,
-0.3288749158382416,
0.0024430861230939627,
0.14143452048301697,
0.00838954746723175,
0.14366766810417175,
0.19805610179901123,
0.8982077836990356,
-0.28376325964927673,
0.41902533173561096,
0.5622700452804565,
-0.5099499821662903,
-0.2039635330438614,
1.101670503616333,
0.13902929425239563,
0.15473145246505737,
0.2453165203332901,
0.15927164256572723,
0.359793096780777,
-0.7034686803817749,
-0.19143839180469513,
0.4020480215549469,
-0.31023648381233215,
-0.1727946698665619,
-0.08673517405986786,
-0.11281309276819229,
0.14308354258537292,
-0.2089790254831314,
-0.809106707572937,
-0.4429209232330322,
-0.35700973868370056,
0.47836655378341675,
0.6165319681167603,
0.4597846567630768,
-0.10222265124320984,
0.7964820861816406,
-0.38169991970062256,
0.4597284197807312,
0.31716975569725037,
0.3126477599143982,
-0.10937700420618057,
-0.4894028306007385,
-0.31465858221054077,
-0.15649528801441193,
-0.3893791139125824,
-0.6777533888816833,
0.47392234206199646,
0.3311755061149597,
0.18724068999290466,
0.5356656312942505,
-0.0838797464966774,
0.9894543290138245,
-0.4195926785469055,
0.4742136597633362,
-0.12957017123699188,
-0.982075572013855,
0.5612150430679321,
-0.5780537724494934,
0.3268126845359802,
0.7191041111946106,
-0.15929128229618073,
-0.2733196020126343,
-0.18314538896083832,
-0.31621086597442627,
-0.895440936088562,
0.5243952870368958,
0.1071801409125328,
-0.1727122664451599,
0.30294087529182434,
0.3084063231945038,
0.04680884629487991,
0.32290399074554443,
-0.526396632194519,
-0.2322176992893219,
0.0693027675151825,
-0.11102012544870377,
0.04843982309103012,
-0.013810202479362488,
-0.2150467187166214,
-0.23606932163238525,
0.912070631980896,
-0.35226109623908997,
-0.02857748046517372,
-0.2475501298904419,
-0.17958754301071167,
-0.42417997121810913,
0.2505623996257782,
0.5548715591430664,
0.5764457583427429,
-0.4352841079235077,
-0.13733705878257751,
0.4263656437397003,
-0.5148516893386841,
-0.19922968745231628,
0.08541944622993469,
-0.21427969634532928,
-0.21584706008434296,
0.17731766402721405,
0.6139559745788574,
0.7166192531585693,
-0.7715901136398315,
0.1156361922621727,
0.2664283514022827,
0.027218002825975418,
-0.4538173973560333,
0.23727703094482422,
-0.1262645274400711,
0.43028178811073303,
0.47316065430641174,
-0.05824270471930504,
-0.5141400694847107,
-0.523712694644928,
-0.07481694221496582,
0.3467751145362854,
-0.07323561608791351,
-0.24282333254814148,
0.6917727589607239,
0.0953177884221077,
-0.15587632358074188,
0.47214144468307495,
-0.14112456142902374,
-0.2530689239501953,
0.32614296674728394,
0.3985922932624817,
0.4050295650959015,
-0.13566496968269348,
0.21109363436698914,
0.024816786870360374,
0.20892737805843353,
-0.33853879570961,
0.58050137758255,
0.29497215151786804,
-0.5832202434539795,
-0.48036491870880127,
-0.9440226554870605,
-0.3344927132129669,
0.17865222692489624,
-0.6030290126800537,
0.22483733296394348,
-0.7185474634170532,
-0.1864904761314392,
-0.2360764592885971,
0.4802404046058655,
-0.3362899720668793,
-0.2903588116168976,
0.04866962507367134,
0.917053759098053,
-0.6677170395851135,
1.0214242935180664,
0.3658827245235443,
-0.5420020222663879,
-0.4584346115589142,
-0.26439517736434937,
0.14132532477378845,
-0.7015445232391357,
0.8780637979507446,
-0.3423498570919037,
-0.22797314822673798,
0.15851576626300812,
-0.467460572719574,
-1.0856356620788574,
1.208983063697815,
0.31778982281684875,
-0.7459047436714172,
-0.18295924365520477,
0.03454166278243065,
0.49971258640289307,
-0.24081629514694214,
-0.5211870074272156,
0.5554802417755127,
0.6641132831573486,
-0.12129004299640656,
-0.951032817363739,
-0.18224576115608215,
-0.12887652218341827,
0.18142543733119965,
0.16623647511005402,
-0.9966028332710266,
1.3128314018249512,
-0.0270115677267313,
-0.1106734573841095,
0.49056947231292725,
0.7823681235313416,
0.5042755007743835,
0.20622676610946655,
0.5615383982658386,
0.8183615207672119,
0.8818960785865784,
-0.14955547451972961,
0.6597615480422974,
-0.5143731236457825,
0.4082193970680237,
1.1754237413406372,
-0.5106908082962036,
1.0853034257888794,
0.6403039693832397,
-0.2089008241891861,
0.7714912295341492,
0.5873442888259888,
-0.2283218652009964,
0.6656444668769836,
0.2995302975177765,
0.048719607293605804,
-0.3785128593444824,
-0.08743202686309814,
-0.338794469833374,
0.6593493819236755,
0.3657660484313965,
-0.05225740000605583,
-0.4228160083293915,
0.13040180504322052,
0.32847845554351807,
0.25743475556373596,
-0.5080390572547913,
0.5633624196052551,
0.18491630256175995,
-0.535389244556427,
0.7397656440734863,
0.19620132446289062,
0.6599435210227966,
-0.5855979919433594,
-0.050970204174518585,
-0.342862069606781,
0.5028770565986633,
-0.23081260919570923,
-0.029841585084795952,
-0.02843846008181572,
-0.026076050475239754,
-0.015365760773420334,
-0.13760323822498322,
0.4824937880039215,
-0.3346341550350189,
-0.41334763169288635,
0.32281777262687683,
0.7112892866134644,
-0.005313832778483629,
-0.037059810012578964,
-0.5545453429222107,
0.4867267906665802,
-0.29908987879753113,
-0.32768866419792175,
0.6935219764709473,
0.10556920617818832,
-0.21011130511760712,
0.7567428946495056,
0.9414286613464355,
0.486530601978302,
-0.09994905441999435,
0.053992751985788345,
1.001584768295288,
-0.34202319383621216,
-0.49736449122428894,
-0.7223683595657349,
0.22036172449588776,
-0.017383350059390068,
-0.3114410936832428,
0.6454927921295166,
0.4314779043197632,
0.718409538269043,
0.08873330801725388,
0.38893428444862366,
0.33829325437545776,
0.3562694489955902,
-0.9152780175209045,
0.7044715881347656,
-0.5729620456695557,
0.6313415169715881,
-0.22345830500125885,
-1.1188474893569946,
-0.1704655885696411,
0.7946427464485168,
-0.4390290677547455,
-0.1282620131969452,
0.8471370339393616,
0.7037532925605774,
0.05656241253018379,
0.00009841995051829144,
0.19220028817653656,
0.590510368347168,
0.05308758467435837,
0.8122398257255554,
0.46240347623825073,
-0.31392237544059753,
0.28880956768989563,
-0.22550466656684875,
-0.14260490238666534,
-0.3044454753398895,
-0.8298166394233704,
-1.0183476209640503,
-0.40990957617759705,
-0.492082417011261,
-0.30063822865486145,
0.3416314125061035,
0.993810772895813,
0.6317775249481201,
-0.6562806367874146,
-0.2769662141799927,
0.09710972756147385,
0.13632412254810333,
-0.6026086211204529,
-0.19465835392475128,
0.6079943776130676,
-0.535680890083313,
-0.9307712912559509,
0.6948044896125793,
0.3562024235725403,
-0.3186824917793274,
-0.5076940655708313,
0.006507576908916235,
-0.2551124393939972,
-0.035859156399965286,
0.5006363391876221,
0.5492470264434814,
-0.4827333390712738,
-0.12892143428325653,
-0.3060775697231293,
0.03624014928936958,
0.0795767679810524,
0.5675342679023743,
-0.9977553486824036,
-0.009035398252308369,
0.27512305974960327,
0.5508595108985901,
0.5778475999832153,
0.17538133263587952,
0.3537583649158478,
-0.6840460896492004,
0.168166846036911,
-0.2842996418476105,
0.4355587065219879,
0.015401709824800491,
-0.1770910918712616,
0.7780802845954895,
0.25430017709732056,
-0.44545310735702515,
-0.9895169734954834,
0.12323984503746033,
-1.4275999069213867,
-0.5828487277030945,
1.1603206396102905,
0.22040605545043945,
-0.4400385320186615,
-0.15783347189426422,
-0.1728905588388443,
0.17043481767177582,
-0.47328126430511475,
1.068332314491272,
0.20550419390201569,
-0.07717939466238022,
-0.014745247550308704,
-0.6796894669532776,
0.6032224893569946,
0.5313974022865295,
-0.8986009955406189,
0.007294133305549622,
0.26363039016723633,
0.11462244391441345,
0.30072084069252014,
0.41513705253601074,
-0.08567367494106293,
0.06699401140213013,
-0.4068157970905304,
-0.34845465421676636,
-0.35014376044273376,
-0.5378081202507019,
-0.5099404454231262,
0.572270929813385,
0.1814221888780594,
0.008503626100718975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16139v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16139v3
|
What Generative Artificial Intelligence Means for Terminological Definitions
| 2024-02-25T16:36:51 | 2024-04-19T16:13:43 |
Antonio San Martín
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper examines the impact of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI)
tools like ChatGPT on the creation and consumption of terminological
definitions. From the terminologist's point of view, the strategic use of GenAI
tools can streamline the process of crafting definitions, reducing both time
and effort, while potentially enhancing quality. GenAI tools enable AI-assisted
terminography, notably post-editing terminography, where the machine produces a
definition that the terminologist then corrects or refines. However, the
potential of GenAI tools to fulfill all the terminological needs of a user,
including term definitions, challenges the very existence of terminological
definitions and resources as we know them. Unlike terminological definitions,
GenAI tools can describe the knowledge activated by a term in a specific
context. However, a main drawback of these tools is that their output can
contain errors. For this reason, users requiring reliability will likely still
resort to terminological resources for definitions. Nevertheless, with the
inevitable integration of AI into terminology work, the distinction between
human-created and AI-created content will become increasingly blurred.
|
[
-0.5409691333770752,
-0.5914424657821655,
0.2312011420726776,
0.10405050963163376,
-0.34947144985198975,
0.3233085572719574,
-0.01775241829454899,
-0.49937835335731506,
0.1704566478729248,
0.29892101883888245,
-0.4846987724304199,
-0.1861993372440338,
-0.5605884194374084,
0.28811612725257874,
-0.6748203039169312,
1.2229435443878174,
0.11265583336353302,
-0.291255921125412,
-0.5464034676551819,
-0.043394945561885834,
-0.43174588680267334,
-0.3138338327407837,
-0.8977293968200684,
-0.5730113983154297,
0.5235029458999634,
0.1310480386018753,
1.2283003330230713,
0.5761232972145081,
0.5744084715843201,
0.38911354541778564,
0.05988104268908501,
0.05846299231052399,
-0.3859173357486725,
-0.0255262553691864,
0.1974613219499588,
-0.625581681728363,
-0.3290756046772003,
0.20941300690174103,
0.4959748089313507,
0.6123468279838562,
-0.44734135270118713,
0.08413617312908173,
0.0893692672252655,
0.5788525342941284,
-0.21579815447330475,
0.18102602660655975,
-0.557351291179657,
0.31099846959114075,
-0.29316890239715576,
-0.4693742096424103,
0.0134048480540514,
-0.27473217248916626,
0.2674664258956909,
-0.9856112599372864,
0.4132208526134491,
-0.22265185415744781,
0.985090434551239,
0.6498545408248901,
0.03116072155535221,
-0.5753614902496338,
-0.9510508179664612,
0.3101828694343567,
-0.5751798748970032,
-0.01030238438397646,
0.2871566414833069,
0.37945935130119324,
-0.052876513451337814,
-0.7668938636779785,
-0.9283168911933899,
-0.32990849018096924,
-0.19046379625797272,
0.3686780333518982,
-0.19445869326591492,
0.44401541352272034,
0.3993191123008728,
0.5775690674781799,
-0.4272404611110687,
0.09659621119499207,
-0.6784893870353699,
-0.07247267663478851,
0.8084525465965271,
0.15350665152072906,
0.6941382884979248,
-0.3496745824813843,
-0.11004789173603058,
0.0609717033803463,
-0.5809065699577332,
-0.5014784336090088,
0.4916168451309204,
-0.09448839724063873,
0.01892007514834404,
0.6112703084945679,
-0.06259185820817947,
0.4178483784198761,
-0.29378199577331543,
0.006941488478332758,
0.29503539204597473,
-0.3738301396369934,
-0.42240121960639954,
-0.08488079160451889,
1.134096622467041,
0.08330676704645157,
0.2879754602909088,
-0.32846853137016296,
0.020407669246196747,
0.2141810655593872,
0.3815663754940033,
-0.5119273662567139,
-0.46223798394203186,
0.08179891109466553,
-0.2727404832839966,
-0.34545615315437317,
0.15381787717342377,
-0.8470566272735596,
-0.5549256205558777,
-0.3961579203605652,
0.45088618993759155,
-0.5673093199729919,
-0.13913710415363312,
-0.36595800518989563,
-0.44132351875305176,
0.35186415910720825,
0.3855289816856384,
-0.9736380577087402,
-0.2230985015630722,
0.7036914229393005,
1.0574911832809448,
0.35595566034317017,
-0.19714267551898956,
0.07381857931613922,
0.18483230471611023,
-0.45891889929771423,
0.7932784557342529,
-0.4487091898918152,
-0.9650601744651794,
-0.11717860400676727,
-0.49313437938690186,
-0.04525516554713249,
-0.5555337071418762,
-0.03482302650809288,
-0.3757514953613281,
0.1891573965549469,
0.15095733106136322,
-0.42281243205070496,
-0.25026410818099976,
0.08840320259332657,
-0.6179635524749756,
0.6366183161735535,
0.15191082656383514,
-0.24882465600967407,
0.5980442762374878,
-0.986416757106781,
-0.5445911288261414,
0.9882901906967163,
-0.5193210244178772,
-0.22578993439674377,
-0.030992528423666954,
-0.24303530156612396,
0.22108137607574463,
-0.18040530383586884,
0.486576646566391,
0.14181366562843323,
-0.043346963822841644,
0.5171773433685303,
-0.5338708162307739,
0.6973742246627808,
0.33441007137298584,
-0.38068264722824097,
0.2619631886482239,
-0.6844306588172913,
-0.030373791232705116,
-0.2377403974533081,
-0.13902506232261658,
-0.1694328933954239,
0.36548855900764465,
-0.15472064912319183,
0.011311325244605541,
0.170122429728508,
-0.3647567927837372,
0.11373579502105713,
-0.44042128324508667,
0.7075405716896057,
0.8548173308372498,
-0.22771114110946655,
0.14521490037441254,
-0.3086250424385071,
0.6721164584159851,
-0.3809134364128113,
0.6048446893692017,
0.16723665595054626,
-0.6921327710151672,
-0.9752987027168274,
-0.1651579737663269,
0.4910927712917328,
0.7523651123046875,
-1.1512784957885742,
0.3835691511631012,
-0.4041629433631897,
-0.7980465888977051,
-0.6992619633674622,
0.2875238358974457,
0.31192678213119507,
0.28469663858413696,
0.037941206246614456,
-0.3161531090736389,
-0.557498037815094,
-0.8535147309303284,
0.3218742311000824,
-0.43000149726867676,
-0.34691131114959717,
0.4061487019062042,
0.46939748525619507,
-0.46660494804382324,
0.9222782850265503,
-0.12248878180980682,
-0.4697219133377075,
-0.3248932361602783,
0.722011923789978,
-0.043177470564842224,
0.24989935755729675,
0.42986154556274414,
-1.023766040802002,
-0.12187314033508301,
0.26673611998558044,
-1.1878185272216797,
-0.027522968128323555,
-0.39481255412101746,
0.0015408756444230676,
0.1106700599193573,
0.3481626510620117,
-0.7548720836639404,
0.6306699514389038,
0.34125256538391113,
-0.33519184589385986,
0.611935555934906,
-0.41052302718162537,
0.17363227903842926,
-1.1561682224273682,
0.2202383577823639,
0.008995262905955315,
0.4351006746292114,
-0.7698180675506592,
0.3970387578010559,
-0.4786475896835327,
-0.11483742296695709,
-0.2470407634973526,
0.1970539540052414,
-0.017584145069122314,
-0.09918025135993958,
-0.2623136639595032,
0.22763529419898987,
-0.2125188112258911,
-0.007936877198517323,
-0.28257396817207336,
1.3246233463287354,
0.30533936619758606,
-0.6125492453575134,
0.6447525024414062,
0.7428218126296997,
-0.055994343012571335,
0.5208685994148254,
-0.883200466632843,
0.17259898781776428,
-0.02145051211118698,
-0.06962929666042328,
-0.7140316963195801,
-0.3426404595375061,
0.6288750171661377,
-0.8105893731117249,
0.00010348723299102858,
0.1347404420375824,
-0.7383871674537659,
-0.33958202600479126,
-0.10837758332490921,
0.37876591086387634,
0.5809181928634644,
-0.2621287405490875,
0.8210610151290894,
0.3328852355480194,
-0.12032786756753922,
-0.15315784513950348,
-0.8663968443870544,
0.5176575183868408,
-0.3566518723964691,
-0.48833993077278137,
0.4225896894931793,
-0.02541203238070011,
-0.4810963273048401,
0.08623239398002625,
0.3721102178096771,
0.03620351850986481,
0.2161235511302948,
0.4865342378616333,
0.6430377960205078,
-0.01091457437723875,
0.46063461899757385,
-0.2937644422054291,
-0.08923833072185516,
0.2123558074235916,
-0.005467262584716082,
0.6377444863319397,
-0.0032305808272212744,
-0.07986760139465332,
-0.6316118836402893,
0.2809089124202728,
0.5035951137542725,
-0.03861917182803154,
0.8275806903839111,
0.592072069644928,
-0.06530261039733887,
0.06783033907413483,
-0.4123806953430176,
0.34414368867874146,
-0.5147910714149475,
0.015394291840493679,
-0.2063407450914383,
-0.6983683705329895,
0.69806307554245,
0.17574362456798553,
-0.07052194327116013,
0.9319970607757568,
0.2857809066772461,
-0.35664117336273193,
0.761846661567688,
0.5403427481651306,
-0.06077176705002785,
0.3826497197151184,
-0.5311724543571472,
0.33831411600112915,
-1.0444740056991577,
-0.40362387895584106,
-0.4521535038948059,
-0.2877904772758484,
-1.0976811647415161,
-0.20986628532409668,
0.4499083161354065,
-0.24788786470890045,
-0.1796926110982895,
-0.021241847425699234,
-0.6816240549087524,
0.11430593580007553,
1.0058565139770508,
0.18576382100582123,
0.10641942918300629,
-0.10436414927244186,
0.5959078073501587,
0.3682672381401062,
-0.7764467597007751,
-0.5743032693862915,
1.2691422700881958,
0.040468480437994,
0.4903688132762909,
-0.08426516503095627,
0.5141062140464783,
0.752885103225708,
0.47497546672821045,
-0.9228894114494324,
0.6799963712692261,
-0.3672778904438019,
-0.16029134392738342,
-0.4420693814754486,
-0.4779963493347168,
-0.9613345265388489,
-0.2914424538612366,
-0.13469190895557404,
-0.45747464895248413,
0.16207319498062134,
0.14060407876968384,
-0.4965325891971588,
0.4472518563270569,
-0.6609085202217102,
0.6755387187004089,
-0.22832947969436646,
0.13244622945785522,
-0.509463906288147,
-0.4475666582584381,
0.09066994488239288,
-0.004187987186014652,
0.10825075954198837,
-0.10042520612478256,
0.03803272545337677,
1.0027302503585815,
-0.3158658742904663,
0.9398812055587769,
0.141781285405159,
0.09658296406269073,
0.5142315626144409,
-0.14919981360435486,
-0.17023222148418427,
-0.12369683384895325,
0.2089836150407791,
0.5394521951675415,
0.09123967587947845,
-0.3332238793373108,
-0.703441858291626,
0.17607177793979645,
-1.1759225130081177,
-0.8986079096794128,
-0.3907696008682251,
-0.4402996897697449,
0.005455553997308016,
-0.03395828604698181,
0.5026050209999084,
0.5536385178565979,
-0.28899475932121277,
-0.14704111218452454,
0.6009084582328796,
-0.3768259584903717,
0.18348830938339233,
-0.1430249959230423,
0.09289473295211792,
-0.35336369276046753,
1.234668493270874,
0.12697651982307434,
0.31429794430732727,
0.13402217626571655,
0.010936519131064415,
-0.03512836620211601,
-0.6551091074943542,
-0.4248720705509186,
-0.02042677253484726,
-0.6050013303756714,
-0.1821991205215454,
-0.22811241447925568,
-0.8105005025863647,
-0.23698267340660095,
-0.08146492391824722,
0.20133954286575317,
-0.16352297365665436,
-0.6301131844520569,
0.11679816246032715,
0.45767995715141296,
0.8366060853004456,
-0.017695173621177673,
0.4554249942302704,
-0.648805558681488,
0.43107476830482483,
0.6778254508972168,
0.3110259175300598,
-0.14631351828575134,
-0.22117294371128082,
0.07502390444278717,
0.24574491381645203,
-0.2112922966480255,
-0.5827715396881104,
0.2947543263435364,
0.6456579566001892,
0.4931596517562866,
0.6748007535934448,
-0.4146498441696167,
0.6214568614959717,
-0.17821604013442993,
1.0238010883331299,
0.08687807619571686,
-0.7797764539718628,
0.796995222568512,
-0.4750853180885315,
0.2985326051712036,
0.49125853180885315,
0.2441515177488327,
-0.9379547238349915,
-0.5075783729553223,
-0.7528482675552368,
-0.8373822569847107,
0.22140394151210785,
0.2188304364681244,
0.6390141248703003,
-0.15364588797092438,
0.6069349646568298,
0.3037160336971283,
0.327719122171402,
-0.3372071385383606,
-0.10771395266056061,
-0.3722728192806244,
-0.16498534381389618,
-0.11075937747955322,
-0.32558685541152954,
-0.24628597497940063,
-0.111727274954319,
0.71638023853302,
-0.07162129878997803,
0.5118648409843445,
0.14125971496105194,
0.10188205540180206,
0.0019957812037318945,
0.45747581124305725,
0.456963449716568,
0.8209259510040283,
0.21722035109996796,
-0.14214996993541718,
-0.18753322958946228,
-0.6130121350288391,
-0.17872515320777893,
0.36427369713783264,
-0.7880686521530151,
-0.04526370018720627,
0.435701847076416,
0.9750937223434448,
-0.20612606406211853,
-0.8093832731246948,
-0.1493934541940689,
0.17964765429496765,
-0.34068456292152405,
-0.7244791388511658,
0.26854267716407776,
-0.5155344605445862,
0.09956904500722885,
0.5089350938796997,
0.2838384211063385,
0.22834521532058716,
-0.6729211807250977,
0.15983793139457703,
0.5416634678840637,
-0.1610518991947174,
-0.2325427532196045,
0.6807789206504822,
0.2275628000497818,
-0.5198841094970703,
1.2174570560455322,
-0.37879741191864014,
-0.5558520555496216,
0.8369422554969788,
-0.023861248046159744,
1.0982201099395752,
-0.18817947804927826,
0.7568747401237488,
0.14236260950565338,
0.16721849143505096,
0.391273558139801,
-0.12032030522823334,
-0.11097197234630585,
-1.1260710954666138,
-0.35666537284851074,
-0.5843751430511475,
-0.3629242777824402,
0.18291139602661133,
-0.3447064757347107,
-0.07274680584669113,
-0.6529048681259155,
-0.12740203738212585,
0.18740135431289673,
-0.3733910322189331,
-0.5666507482528687,
0.14752690494060516,
0.2867290675640106,
0.6060827374458313,
-0.5360469818115234,
0.2632697522640228,
0.6542776226997375,
-0.7530604600906372,
-0.7886172533035278,
0.06555186957120895,
0.05828767642378807,
-1.0097991228103638,
0.5634604096412659,
0.09952957928180695,
0.063035748898983,
0.17795374989509583,
-0.32524392008781433,
-0.6806639432907104,
1.1481791734695435,
-0.1985657960176468,
-0.23905839025974274,
-0.22382426261901855,
0.48497703671455383,
1.0888943672180176,
-0.06555940955877304,
0.11093305796384811,
0.7440049052238464,
0.44364801049232483,
0.37674403190612793,
-1.0961724519729614,
-0.24720878899097443,
-0.6033509969711304,
0.21844814717769623,
0.3187149167060852,
-0.36299800872802734,
0.3229849338531494,
-0.20401784777641296,
-0.6510661244392395,
0.3389294445514679,
0.6389041543006897,
-0.1951667219400406,
0.25725406408309937,
0.24372875690460205,
0.7444828748703003,
0.37544140219688416,
-0.33391791582107544,
1.171860694885254,
-0.026300964877009392,
0.018086524680256844,
0.5322827100753784,
0.2745547294616699,
0.5581461787223816,
0.37436074018478394,
-0.5294606685638428,
0.5079364776611328,
0.7747775316238403,
-0.601050615310669,
0.15307430922985077,
0.0657530352473259,
-0.5208362936973572,
0.05798172205686569,
-0.5025027990341187,
-0.28233495354652405,
0.6443960070610046,
0.6215901374816895,
-0.28798818588256836,
-0.012616008520126343,
0.34251028299331665,
-0.18548239767551422,
-0.06431617587804794,
-0.619515061378479,
1.1113836765289307,
-0.16831010580062866,
-0.705957293510437,
0.3204194903373718,
-0.43884924054145813,
0.6411721110343933,
-0.4630827009677887,
-0.08853030204772949,
-0.14409290254116058,
-0.2016560584306717,
-0.2662276327610016,
-0.9683530926704407,
0.6160845756530762,
-0.1895366758108139,
0.26094621419906616,
-0.10357654839754105,
0.42479637265205383,
-0.26705849170684814,
-0.5449602007865906,
-0.14024212956428528,
0.7171170711517334,
0.03503398224711418,
0.12183918803930283,
-0.7210859060287476,
-0.3015252947807312,
-0.13671742379665375,
0.15628938376903534,
0.0391496866941452,
0.21201828122138977,
0.1305096447467804,
0.930843710899353,
0.4913261830806732,
0.24690763652324677,
-0.10573934763669968,
0.26272061467170715,
0.5928505659103394,
-0.3341037929058075,
-0.4059969484806061,
-0.9321027994155884,
0.16954255104064941,
-0.0049753072671592236,
-0.33485516905784607,
0.304728239774704,
0.31516605615615845,
0.9853470325469971,
0.1288747489452362,
1.1382222175598145,
-0.7829893231391907,
-0.20326665043830872,
-0.4890269637107849,
0.850954532623291,
-0.3469352722167969,
0.20814432203769684,
-0.0538129098713398,
-0.5718542337417603,
-0.31357821822166443,
0.2636220455169678,
-0.45711272954940796,
0.1393587589263916,
0.23566409945487976,
0.46063467860221863,
0.46237725019454956,
0.1580539494752884,
0.26362207531929016,
0.12286387383937836,
0.11737975478172302,
0.3681846559047699,
0.9504622220993042,
-0.16820479929447174,
0.5329874753952026,
-0.25252509117126465,
-0.356216698884964,
0.1258663833141327,
-0.3107472360134125,
-0.6963732242584229,
-0.8445241451263428,
-0.3950282037258148,
0.09907861799001694,
0.33021387457847595,
0.5678828358650208,
0.33314162492752075,
-0.7274787425994873,
-0.19379140436649323,
-0.4359111189842224,
-0.006123033817857504,
-0.15422575175762177,
-0.36699530482292175,
0.31546318531036377,
-0.46165502071380615,
-0.4418821334838867,
-0.1385277807712555,
0.42687636613845825,
0.18075445294380188,
-0.5312563180923462,
0.1367994099855423,
0.03300030529499054,
-0.08143104612827301,
0.6234000325202942,
0.5041394829750061,
-0.862167477607727,
-0.503105640411377,
-0.3674551248550415,
0.2542803883552551,
0.3560996651649475,
0.6600477695465088,
-0.8550351858139038,
0.6381425857543945,
0.2719258666038513,
0.5545151829719543,
-0.22718916833400726,
0.05290152505040169,
0.6549122333526611,
-0.5314748287200928,
0.025484714657068253,
0.2052791714668274,
0.12709254026412964,
0.32594677805900574,
-0.5705532431602478,
0.7661078572273254,
0.5235458016395569,
-0.46579721570014954,
-0.3487434685230255,
0.3788735568523407,
-0.7714990973472595,
-0.1830378919839859,
0.8900958299636841,
0.08232823014259338,
-0.04534834623336792,
0.06532712280750275,
-0.2209966778755188,
0.5351567268371582,
-0.22195152938365936,
1.5382357835769653,
0.570227324962616,
-0.423661470413208,
-0.5000061988830566,
-0.8507311940193176,
0.7254224419593811,
0.062023062258958817,
-1.1073062419891357,
-0.27981463074684143,
0.4659574031829834,
-0.09425315260887146,
0.5331313014030457,
0.34655264019966125,
0.006146167870610952,
0.5391062498092651,
0.04565160349011421,
0.10371098667383194,
-0.05890160799026489,
0.031174182891845703,
-0.005514014512300491,
0.1075565293431282,
-0.07113958150148392,
-0.16461972892284393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16132v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16132v1
|
LSTPrompt: Large Language Models as Zero-Shot Time Series Forecasters by Long-Short-Term Prompting
| 2024-02-25T16:14:26 | 2024-02-25T16:14:26 |
Haoxin Liu, Zhiyuan Zhao, Jindong Wang, Harshavardhan Kamarthi, B. Aditya Prakash
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Time-series forecasting (TSF) finds broad applications in real-world
scenarios. Prompting off-the-shelf Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrates
strong zero-shot TSF capabilities while preserving computational efficiency.
However, existing prompting methods oversimplify TSF as language next-token
predictions, overlooking its dynamic nature and lack of integration with
state-of-the-art prompt strategies such as Chain-of-Thought. Thus, we propose
LSTPrompt, a novel approach for prompting LLMs in zero-shot TSF tasks.
LSTPrompt decomposes TSF into short-term and long-term forecasting sub-tasks,
tailoring prompts to each. LSTPrompt guides LLMs to regularly reassess
forecasting mechanisms to enhance adaptability. Extensive evaluations
demonstrate consistently better performance of LSTPrompt than existing
prompting methods, and competitive results compared to foundation TSF models.
|
[
-0.2190089374780655,
-0.8322274684906006,
0.7151140570640564,
0.3910469114780426,
-0.6419590711593628,
0.24184760451316833,
-0.3092438280582428,
-0.33369573950767517,
0.3336416184902191,
0.1992998570203781,
-1.135890007019043,
-0.2626999020576477,
-0.2412627637386322,
0.13315808773040771,
-0.5230755805969238,
0.8767870664596558,
-0.025754675269126892,
-0.2545810639858246,
0.24244366586208344,
0.12397892773151398,
-0.6255884766578674,
-0.31134316325187683,
-0.6964459419250488,
-0.3876299560070038,
0.9112610816955566,
0.3856411278247833,
0.6343565583229065,
0.09563377499580383,
-0.05102495476603508,
0.057434916496276855,
0.2401605099439621,
-0.036880675703287125,
-0.308113157749176,
0.653364360332489,
-0.038448408246040344,
-0.2674415111541748,
-0.3258877098560333,
-0.2408709079027176,
0.6458057761192322,
0.5979364514350891,
-0.16020290553569794,
0.33236223459243774,
0.03416815027594566,
0.3520803153514862,
-0.42167410254478455,
0.1093091070652008,
-0.34608834981918335,
0.10899834334850311,
-0.09461183845996857,
-0.45230185985565186,
-0.5937904715538025,
-0.01799480803310871,
0.09041546285152435,
-0.14069217443466187,
0.18083986639976501,
0.10565992444753647,
0.3808600604534149,
0.17307978868484497,
-0.14871276915073395,
0.2326655238866806,
-0.8200206160545349,
0.8213560581207275,
-0.8241605758666992,
0.4025387763977051,
-0.11676134914159775,
0.5097194314002991,
-0.1800939440727234,
-0.6559320092201233,
-0.4483351707458496,
-0.3767626881599426,
0.29882481694221497,
0.19674168527126312,
-0.3516657054424286,
-0.2292405068874359,
0.31052401661872864,
-0.09633076936006546,
-0.6602595448493958,
0.40173861384391785,
-0.1985836625099182,
0.012480350211262703,
0.20951169729232788,
0.4364411234855652,
-0.07441608607769012,
0.07457291334867477,
-0.3762062191963196,
0.29167303442955017,
-0.8808627128601074,
0.034790314733982086,
0.05879438295960426,
0.9006684422492981,
-0.09144216775894165,
0.36300355195999146,
-0.2069903463125229,
0.9699547290802002,
-0.045568134635686874,
0.012927082367241383,
-0.28471988439559937,
0.07159636169672012,
-0.465270072221756,
0.31035199761390686,
0.6135678887367249,
0.4226548671722412,
0.40396469831466675,
-0.11444409191608429,
-0.2264585644006729,
-0.14203210175037384,
-0.13003942370414734,
-0.7519394159317017,
-0.02677040919661522,
0.5299918055534363,
-0.09772386401891708,
-0.525242030620575,
-0.4542950689792633,
-0.9682130217552185,
-0.4760042726993561,
-0.3140098750591278,
0.5909292697906494,
-0.17383632063865662,
-0.21938684582710266,
0.03352253511548042,
-0.14052942395210266,
-0.0088046258315444,
0.3568107783794403,
-0.7334012985229492,
0.1349758356809616,
0.7747489213943481,
1.1692960262298584,
-0.17902658879756927,
-0.45246487855911255,
-0.8354104161262512,
0.07343477755784988,
-0.24088160693645477,
0.961520254611969,
-0.2958708703517914,
-0.5927042961120605,
0.1177268773317337,
-0.07794211804866791,
0.20710209012031555,
-0.3057604730129242,
0.17602485418319702,
-0.14216986298561096,
0.3071557283401489,
-0.21486547589302063,
-0.32388636469841003,
0.3057931065559387,
0.44981759786605835,
-0.5461962819099426,
1.0236700773239136,
0.17151686549186707,
-0.536786675453186,
0.3981859087944031,
-0.8603467345237732,
-0.31442156434059143,
-0.0023514614440500736,
0.08848588913679123,
-0.12244144082069397,
0.09093620628118515,
0.5707682967185974,
0.9668793678283691,
-0.3611896336078644,
0.43320703506469727,
-0.5106645226478577,
-0.14302359521389008,
0.05437494441866875,
-0.6560615301132202,
0.5386906266212463,
0.19863289594650269,
-0.16676346957683563,
0.3598155677318573,
-0.2096354216337204,
-0.027016447857022285,
0.31660667061805725,
0.5039325952529907,
-0.17576570808887482,
-0.11458245664834976,
-0.19532567262649536,
0.04179878160357475,
-0.008267311379313469,
-0.3966858685016632,
0.5961236953735352,
-0.5225974321365356,
0.7756597399711609,
1.0297585725784302,
0.24014370143413544,
0.17953993380069733,
-0.3689976632595062,
0.9595165848731995,
0.0889720767736435,
0.3272576332092285,
-0.5389604568481445,
-0.3853898048400879,
-0.4833154082298279,
-0.1732386350631714,
0.0039077321998775005,
0.5322574377059937,
-0.7723447680473328,
-0.04186420887708664,
-0.30197399854660034,
-0.6790972352027893,
0.13805846869945526,
-0.2644128203392029,
0.04743042588233948,
0.5156440138816833,
0.11102695018053055,
0.19187380373477936,
-0.5141632556915283,
-0.3526359498500824,
-0.4540940821170807,
0.07667487859725952,
0.12981992959976196,
-0.21332630515098572,
0.2660049796104431,
0.281705766916275,
0.8268357515335083,
-0.6316811442375183,
0.05957246944308281,
-0.6351420283317566,
0.2568530738353729,
0.857517421245575,
-0.057226989418268204,
0.6832236051559448,
-0.17513462901115417,
-0.5491731762886047,
-0.3962599039077759,
-0.23829087615013123,
-0.17604056000709534,
-0.269270658493042,
0.1735074520111084,
0.3398878276348114,
0.6371788382530212,
-0.6952982544898987,
0.24961990118026733,
0.47617387771606445,
-0.533587634563446,
0.9563751816749573,
0.05488032475113869,
-0.20648567378520966,
-1.0221296548843384,
0.020526831969618797,
0.032242368906736374,
-0.5615971088409424,
-0.6127337217330933,
0.06957750022411346,
-0.1683850735425949,
-0.5520643591880798,
-0.8308485746383667,
1.0294415950775146,
-0.39176779985427856,
0.009845146909356117,
-0.22334544360637665,
0.09146223217248917,
-0.09727559983730316,
0.20705746114253998,
0.019655490294098854,
0.8844704031944275,
0.6287722587585449,
-0.7326462864875793,
0.6356260776519775,
-0.21304036676883698,
-0.39742645621299744,
0.4560384750366211,
-0.6315067410469055,
-0.08031921088695526,
-0.09718168526887894,
0.3043909966945648,
-0.6525496244430542,
-0.07698367536067963,
0.2437073290348053,
-0.08839014172554016,
0.35755908489227295,
-0.0025539409834891558,
-0.38457730412483215,
-0.7135265469551086,
-0.4102948009967804,
0.32710686326026917,
0.7093985080718994,
-0.719467043876648,
0.42720988392829895,
-0.5865928530693054,
-0.34971415996551514,
-0.6201401948928833,
-0.531274676322937,
0.26862379908561707,
-0.3439081609249115,
-0.07757017761468887,
0.09950070828199387,
-0.264850378036499,
-0.20971232652664185,
-0.11337513476610184,
-0.05280463397502899,
0.20512577891349792,
0.03538225218653679,
0.1717987358570099,
0.43392181396484375,
-0.23825563490390778,
0.0395030714571476,
-0.23363810777664185,
-0.22858352959156036,
-0.09430043399333954,
-0.6933692693710327,
0.8236272931098938,
0.11226239800453186,
-0.40467867255210876,
-0.37715986371040344,
0.27289366722106934,
0.5555068254470825,
0.07664889842271805,
0.42998820543289185,
0.5445892214775085,
-0.19264668226242065,
-0.6490082144737244,
-0.2354658842086792,
-0.4222615361213684,
-0.47879359126091003,
0.21337954699993134,
-0.16617248952388763,
-0.7700913548469543,
0.2914877235889435,
-0.19648316502571106,
0.2687280476093292,
0.1510717272758484,
0.6529104113578796,
0.0031491536647081375,
0.8430927991867065,
0.47469907999038696,
-0.2759924829006195,
0.699039876461029,
-0.10497400164604187,
0.46879664063453674,
-0.49284544587135315,
-0.01879846304655075,
-0.28052085638046265,
-0.41291719675064087,
0.07564892619848251,
-0.30892103910446167,
0.47263553738594055,
-0.20221048593521118,
-0.5475150346755981,
0.15610501170158386,
-0.4164516031742096,
0.6385154128074646,
0.39905625581741333,
-0.13508422672748566,
-0.02983725443482399,
0.07460356503725052,
0.002770134946331382,
-0.06427595019340515,
-0.6695424914360046,
0.11305327713489532,
0.8511233925819397,
0.2958303391933441,
0.6983806490898132,
-0.15094329416751862,
0.7913389205932617,
0.6290257573127747,
0.20970192551612854,
-1.3563145399093628,
0.5614957213401794,
-0.2159544974565506,
-0.2697828710079193,
-0.40152737498283386,
-0.07590347528457642,
-0.9238941073417664,
-0.29061591625213623,
0.1429446041584015,
-0.9915643334388733,
-0.03920112922787666,
0.39018580317497253,
-0.9093731045722961,
0.3896764814853668,
-0.4620838463306427,
0.6997736096382141,
-0.29483646154403687,
-0.2667767107486725,
0.007991478778421879,
-0.2624911963939667,
0.32818803191185,
-0.025388343259692192,
0.3260485529899597,
-0.41385045647621155,
-0.15831802785396576,
0.5409044027328491,
-0.3817668855190277,
1.085121750831604,
-0.38666391372680664,
-0.1934543251991272,
0.16702458262443542,
0.5229429602622986,
0.734019935131073,
-0.2033771276473999,
-0.2569103538990021,
-0.14380638301372528,
0.18641617894172668,
-0.3737013638019562,
-0.734146773815155,
0.7886905074119568,
-0.32305505871772766,
-0.7097606062889099,
-0.6020654439926147,
-0.49871864914894104,
-0.4637221097946167,
0.24307548999786377,
0.35197895765304565,
0.7299667000770569,
-0.201525017619133,
-0.30418044328689575,
0.3713743984699249,
0.0718376561999321,
0.9497091770172119,
0.40457385778427124,
-0.7409386038780212,
-0.29573988914489746,
0.7806851863861084,
0.03913979232311249,
0.5501177906990051,
0.31007876992225647,
0.4759097993373871,
-0.4026446044445038,
-0.30701592564582825,
-0.35229334235191345,
0.2496045082807541,
-0.5302938222885132,
-0.4215056598186493,
-0.08272039890289307,
-0.12048568576574326,
-0.37036025524139404,
-0.42797303199768066,
-0.11221112310886383,
-0.5228256583213806,
-0.452035516500473,
-0.12081873416900635,
0.7353254556655884,
0.7082370519638062,
0.1598774790763855,
0.34504565596580505,
-0.9419167637825012,
0.354255348443985,
0.1939975470304489,
0.4362331032752991,
0.1747143417596817,
-0.6137689352035522,
-0.12685605883598328,
-0.2064930498600006,
-0.14215748012065887,
-0.8530372381210327,
0.7693073749542236,
0.38262680172920227,
0.24284213781356812,
0.5084331631660461,
0.40813320875167847,
0.8357537984848022,
-0.5746626257896423,
1.2836540937423706,
0.5186216831207275,
-0.9901034832000732,
0.4843316078186035,
-0.5543771982192993,
0.6317566633224487,
-0.10634584724903107,
0.35320845246315,
-0.9041500687599182,
-0.3356175720691681,
-0.42830294370651245,
-0.8217925429344177,
0.7034531235694885,
-0.41575899720191956,
0.12828537821769714,
-0.06942324340343475,
0.22759920358657837,
0.2884921431541443,
0.0744573175907135,
-0.5263506770133972,
-0.07184751331806183,
-0.35477831959724426,
-0.22088925540447235,
-0.31777438521385193,
-0.32214534282684326,
0.04439057037234306,
-0.2057170569896698,
0.4858027696609497,
-0.27724501490592957,
0.4701133072376251,
0.28752484917640686,
0.2230920046567917,
-0.24791063368320465,
0.462879478931427,
0.770982563495636,
0.6633332967758179,
-0.19776684045791626,
0.01771247573196888,
0.40402182936668396,
-0.008502677083015442,
0.21568724513053894,
-0.21445168554782867,
-0.11407583206892014,
0.1635788232088089,
0.5202428698539734,
0.9499900341033936,
0.3285491168498993,
-0.6602543592453003,
0.3709178566932678,
0.15153709053993225,
-0.32110124826431274,
-0.6427633762359619,
-0.016476817429065704,
-0.01226675882935524,
0.3222421407699585,
0.4205656349658966,
-0.20628175139427185,
-0.28359925746917725,
-0.7068334817886353,
-0.1611310839653015,
0.3103467524051666,
-0.5376191735267639,
-0.3440952003002167,
0.7232237458229065,
0.017781110480427742,
-0.39086538553237915,
0.4145072102546692,
-0.09047123044729233,
-0.5733205676078796,
0.4615636467933655,
0.7932876348495483,
0.9521008729934692,
-0.3377712666988373,
0.3133116066455841,
0.2015155702829361,
0.01246226578950882,
-0.5086634755134583,
0.5861784815788269,
0.08317448198795319,
-0.2845490872859955,
-0.7994481921195984,
-0.5221871137619019,
-0.4438961446285248,
0.2948002815246582,
-0.5565560460090637,
0.614597737789154,
-0.7629372477531433,
-0.2300279587507248,
0.016553526744246483,
-0.24544475972652435,
-0.5061784386634827,
-0.024629751220345497,
0.35339081287384033,
1.404274582862854,
-0.8782047033309937,
0.8314182758331299,
0.27443164587020874,
-0.06207842752337456,
-0.837027370929718,
0.0949942097067833,
0.12912032008171082,
-0.977554976940155,
0.578055739402771,
0.12541814148426056,
0.05974183604121208,
0.15001225471496582,
-0.589976966381073,
-0.7324167490005493,
1.0293047428131104,
0.44302207231521606,
-0.7028527855873108,
-0.18234145641326904,
0.07172632962465286,
0.27250948548316956,
-0.33109354972839355,
0.059643447399139404,
0.5365768671035767,
0.6401762962341309,
0.1669437438249588,
-0.9305567741394043,
0.23912668228149414,
-0.06620607525110245,
-0.3713543713092804,
0.6407941579818726,
-0.5820043087005615,
0.666003942489624,
-0.4063619077205658,
-0.01626385748386383,
0.31381675601005554,
0.5233834385871887,
0.1048738956451416,
0.636664867401123,
0.521082878112793,
0.19958719611167908,
0.3863874673843384,
-0.10428798198699951,
0.9332802295684814,
-0.3042753040790558,
0.06341251730918884,
1.206342339515686,
-0.5938891768455505,
1.0701907873153687,
0.5599653720855713,
-0.2765851318836212,
0.6364281177520752,
0.6186185479164124,
-0.15981774032115936,
0.4301084578037262,
-0.020018354058265686,
-0.37483739852905273,
-0.47634512186050415,
-0.3653963506221771,
-0.29380276799201965,
0.10700731724500656,
0.5630508661270142,
0.039352480322122574,
-0.5722231268882751,
0.2452709823846817,
0.07810047268867493,
-0.23142527043819427,
-0.4376092851161957,
0.3979770243167877,
0.4429483413696289,
-0.7957794070243835,
0.735736608505249,
-0.40938934683799744,
0.5072229504585266,
-0.7116984724998474,
0.13908751308918,
-0.09102100878953934,
-0.09420927613973618,
-0.013989475555717945,
-0.9734959006309509,
0.40630215406417847,
0.00976740662008524,
-0.00807119905948639,
-0.6299680471420288,
0.5758628249168396,
-0.11704539507627487,
-0.5602183938026428,
0.2946111857891083,
0.5027073621749878,
-0.04784886911511421,
-0.29826584458351135,
-0.5468378067016602,
-0.13185612857341766,
-0.10406766831874847,
-0.3222287893295288,
0.2590382993221283,
0.3302189111709595,
-0.22120803594589233,
0.8724932074546814,
0.7256267666816711,
0.3671402931213379,
-0.3085930645465851,
0.47633904218673706,
0.6167291402816772,
-1.0053421258926392,
-0.45856142044067383,
-1.118698000907898,
0.2818310558795929,
0.3088383972644806,
0.04265787824988365,
0.4631941020488739,
0.053924452513456345,
0.08176949620246887,
-0.30507805943489075,
0.7499992251396179,
0.16646987199783325,
0.7251949310302734,
-0.5284548401832581,
0.5347467660903931,
-0.638866662979126,
0.1133785992860794,
0.07172904908657074,
-0.7030171155929565,
-0.505507230758667,
-0.4655517637729645,
-0.39767399430274963,
-0.2021786868572235,
0.7721600532531738,
0.4912133514881134,
-0.08651987463235855,
0.055660612881183624,
0.5107712149620056,
0.44077494740486145,
0.3498934507369995,
0.5290513634681702,
0.9536156058311462,
0.34620627760887146,
0.5103058815002441,
-0.19657252728939056,
0.05310796946287155,
-0.41860586404800415,
-1.5341233015060425,
-0.9632066488265991,
-0.4087589681148529,
-0.1276194006204605,
-0.1414775550365448,
0.0623139962553978,
1.4818485975265503,
0.39969927072525024,
-0.8692492246627808,
-0.12135736644268036,
-0.034479156136512756,
-0.09396336227655411,
-0.3897623121738434,
-0.20904850959777832,
0.36102110147476196,
-0.24916647374629974,
-0.5392448306083679,
0.5417090654373169,
0.23243099451065063,
0.32943737506866455,
-0.4851575791835785,
0.18869762122631073,
0.27264320850372314,
0.1209602802991867,
0.809493899345398,
0.5752139091491699,
-0.8441877961158752,
-0.22757427394390106,
0.17107021808624268,
0.6008339524269104,
-0.3593727648258209,
1.0556206703186035,
-1.0974551439285278,
0.259600430727005,
0.4305889904499054,
0.05924065411090851,
0.25845709443092346,
-0.254204660654068,
0.8191972970962524,
-0.9009315371513367,
0.48786747455596924,
0.4075172245502472,
0.43736669421195984,
0.13893523812294006,
-0.5456811189651489,
0.1877841204404831,
0.15810054540634155,
-0.39780062437057495,
-1.0838472843170166,
0.49099108576774597,
-0.9359495043754578,
-0.41306576132774353,
1.0164471864700317,
0.03905250132083893,
-0.37278860807418823,
-0.10071510076522827,
-0.2526489198207855,
0.07999110221862793,
-0.6958158016204834,
0.6343989372253418,
0.5519363880157471,
-0.13076293468475342,
-0.43944647908210754,
-0.659520149230957,
0.3214852511882782,
0.3242616355419159,
-0.36047452688217163,
0.4315603971481323,
0.13173958659172058,
0.1903606653213501,
-0.290551096200943,
0.4865124821662903,
0.3997338116168976,
0.29778745770454407,
-0.3406573235988617,
-0.35897502303123474,
-0.5958756804466248,
-0.47926995158195496,
-0.3459304869174957,
0.05505090951919556,
0.30702292919158936,
0.34044161438941956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16123v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16123v2
|
InstructEdit: Instruction-based Knowledge Editing for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-25T15:46:33 | 2024-04-28T12:03:38 |
Ningyu Zhang, Bozhong Tian, Siyuan Cheng, Xiaozhuan Liang, Yi Hu, Kouying Xue, Yanjie Gou, Xi Chen, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Knowledge editing for large language models can offer an efficient solution
to alter a model's behavior without negatively impacting the overall
performance. However, the current approaches encounter issues with limited
generalizability across tasks, necessitating one distinct editor for each task,
significantly hindering the broader applications. To address this, we take the
first step to analyze the multi-task generalization issue in knowledge editing.
Specifically, we develop an instruction-based editing technique, termed
InstructEdit, which facilitates the editor's adaptation to various task
performances simultaneously using simple instructions. With only one unified
editor for each LLM, we empirically demonstrate that InstructEdit can improve
the editor's control, leading to an average 14.86% increase in Reliability in
multi-task editing setting. Furthermore, experiments involving holdout unseen
task illustrate that InstructEdit consistently surpass previous strong
baselines. To further investigate the underlying mechanisms of
instruction-based knowledge editing, we analyze the principal components of the
editing gradient directions, which unveils that instructions can help control
optimization direction with stronger OOD generalization. Code and datasets are
available in https://github.com/zjunlp/EasyEdit.
|
[
0.09044653922319412,
-0.9451557397842407,
0.5966868996620178,
0.1454874724149704,
0.11621798574924469,
-0.20964139699935913,
-0.6155973672866821,
-0.1550891250371933,
-0.1699741631746292,
0.5439954400062561,
-0.5169594287872314,
-0.6261334419250488,
-0.7068811058998108,
-0.11211647838354111,
-0.2590729892253876,
0.9570915699005127,
-0.19323702156543732,
0.2608019709587097,
-0.3632506728172302,
-0.27089864015579224,
-0.6945521235466003,
-0.2493487447500229,
-0.8278580904006958,
-0.0991596132516861,
0.4016939699649811,
0.7367224097251892,
0.6245970726013184,
0.9888142943382263,
0.5842304825782776,
0.36115989089012146,
-0.025991013273596764,
0.16012516617774963,
-0.536919355392456,
0.19402599334716797,
-0.21854393184185028,
-0.5466887354850769,
-0.9400016069412231,
-0.2584008276462555,
0.6703051924705505,
0.6456028819084167,
-0.10971269011497498,
0.06251601874828339,
0.2781544625759125,
0.8670851588249207,
-0.7481663823127747,
0.13412576913833618,
-0.37241002917289734,
-0.21082335710525513,
0.012095141224563122,
0.022368887439370155,
-0.42430034279823303,
-0.22568078339099884,
0.09572865068912506,
-0.9046380519866943,
0.20972366631031036,
-0.13094906508922577,
0.11485333740711212,
0.4293251931667328,
-0.41687628626823425,
-0.3333381116390228,
-0.7655890583992004,
0.7592343688011169,
-0.6142117977142334,
0.5238513350486755,
0.15438948571681976,
-0.019618067890405655,
-0.1968810111284256,
-0.6099061965942383,
-0.3729465901851654,
-0.16697272658348083,
0.09663714468479156,
0.08302917331457138,
-0.1434386968612671,
0.5623227953910828,
0.35421222448349,
0.11576321721076965,
-0.36409351229667664,
0.16360297799110413,
-0.140742689371109,
-0.033467914909124374,
0.4216030240058899,
-0.01750906929373741,
0.5729265213012695,
0.08807222545146942,
-0.11990740150213242,
0.0004897398175671697,
-0.737366259098053,
-0.07091675698757172,
0.43375763297080994,
0.03657611086964607,
0.17452944815158844,
0.691867470741272,
-0.3929632306098938,
0.7433986067771912,
0.24808287620544434,
-0.11794321238994598,
-0.1271810233592987,
-0.2631915211677551,
-0.3068564832210541,
0.1084170937538147,
0.6230050921440125,
0.5980805158615112,
0.07047604769468307,
-0.12824350595474243,
-0.2771216928958893,
-0.45878085494041443,
0.23881734907627106,
-0.8896718621253967,
-0.3025496006011963,
0.2508733868598938,
-0.14495337009429932,
-0.15310996770858765,
-0.05024357885122299,
-0.7008368372917175,
-0.5828396677970886,
-0.4457992613315582,
0.3758356273174286,
-0.553908109664917,
-0.013086793944239616,
0.3714689612388611,
-0.22316575050354004,
-0.011790072545409203,
0.6878020167350769,
-0.8705644011497498,
0.17934922873973846,
0.7629220485687256,
0.5046147704124451,
-0.08158339560031891,
-0.6730275750160217,
-0.6230514645576477,
0.34284740686416626,
-0.3212137520313263,
0.4648628234863281,
-0.6737238764762878,
-0.20194348692893982,
-0.09222059696912766,
-0.23770107328891754,
-0.3591109812259674,
-0.2636897563934326,
0.3697563111782074,
-0.7606979608535767,
0.14817237854003906,
-0.2636669874191284,
-0.8876231908798218,
-0.303673654794693,
0.15570633113384247,
-0.6992014050483704,
0.9873903393745422,
-0.054507702589035034,
-0.6970967054367065,
0.2277858406305313,
-1.045194387435913,
-0.313895046710968,
-0.25061488151550293,
0.11181904375553131,
-0.12270306050777435,
0.09773663431406021,
0.5110753178596497,
0.4479733407497406,
-0.13985921442508698,
0.3102031648159027,
-0.03333748131990433,
-0.23207509517669678,
-0.12881304323673248,
-0.3610128164291382,
0.6858073472976685,
-0.24844203889369965,
-0.30982834100723267,
0.4446638226509094,
-0.8714630007743835,
-0.05271696671843529,
-0.09177758544683456,
-0.49026694893836975,
-0.6282537579536438,
-0.05798705294728279,
-0.2629581391811371,
-0.18128333985805511,
0.4230678975582123,
-0.5050418376922607,
0.9384981393814087,
-0.16319258511066437,
0.3210838735103607,
0.8721705079078674,
0.28460195660591125,
0.727945864200592,
-0.009599624201655388,
0.6668097972869873,
-0.22009849548339844,
0.35583773255348206,
-0.03891853988170624,
-0.32646918296813965,
-1.0311641693115234,
-0.08178764581680298,
0.2887569069862366,
0.8159114122390747,
-0.9273627996444702,
0.051640674471855164,
-0.21418742835521698,
-0.425374299287796,
-0.4444558620452881,
0.6100303530693054,
0.6930728554725647,
0.3371160924434662,
0.4512907564640045,
-0.022773198783397675,
-0.21950693428516388,
-0.8494731187820435,
-0.3880409896373749,
0.08520431071519852,
0.22315043210983276,
0.06436199694871902,
0.3732418715953827,
-0.3930177390575409,
0.7630830407142639,
-0.6370770931243896,
-0.025932710617780685,
-0.3078930974006653,
0.20157180726528168,
-0.08061526715755463,
0.6886797547340393,
0.5871660113334656,
-0.499277263879776,
-0.5102896690368652,
0.14494825899600983,
-0.5166918635368347,
-0.07204652577638626,
-0.28992417454719543,
-0.3883136510848999,
-0.061556726694107056,
0.6457446813583374,
-0.7523705959320068,
0.2361171394586563,
0.48043400049209595,
-0.0818207636475563,
0.6591341495513916,
-0.36420196294784546,
0.39321765303611755,
-0.9834314584732056,
-0.19048148393630981,
-0.1300324946641922,
-0.10198565572500229,
-0.8173445463180542,
0.2777356803417206,
0.43577390909194946,
-0.02318035252392292,
-0.270829975605011,
0.3161858916282654,
-0.5194722414016724,
0.3660997450351715,
-0.1449863463640213,
-0.05478440597653389,
-0.026954129338264465,
0.7841517925262451,
-0.2252344787120819,
0.9506705403327942,
0.6570796966552734,
-0.6017954349517822,
0.5257041454315186,
0.23906977474689484,
-0.3879545331001282,
0.47846519947052,
-0.6315655708312988,
0.7254043817520142,
-0.2170979529619217,
-0.04112979769706726,
-0.7599999308586121,
-0.4037248194217682,
0.3039044141769409,
-0.08673747628927231,
0.5274395942687988,
-0.25779351592063904,
-0.3857525885105133,
0.09507329761981964,
-0.388096421957016,
0.304551362991333,
-0.10605744272470474,
-0.5305293202400208,
0.760529637336731,
-0.04927162453532219,
-0.39761513471603394,
-0.9533893465995789,
-0.3458465337753296,
-0.026737170293927193,
0.024464620277285576,
-0.5344500541687012,
0.19464683532714844,
-0.36262285709381104,
-0.3325234353542328,
0.16698816418647766,
-0.19966332614421844,
-0.3126407265663147,
0.08123371005058289,
0.17688985168933868,
0.15485015511512756,
-0.2574101388454437,
0.44036865234375,
0.6023370623588562,
0.08346081525087357,
-0.06474518030881882,
-0.3713250458240509,
0.10855359584093094,
0.13128934800624847,
-0.5842168927192688,
-0.7085943222045898,
0.33355122804641724,
0.6680001616477966,
-0.4386281967163086,
0.6014143824577332,
0.3090510964393616,
-0.15199190378189087,
-0.31184113025665283,
-0.6805058717727661,
-0.07235633581876755,
-0.48189041018486023,
0.8351683020591736,
-0.3086140751838684,
-0.7640572786331177,
0.21828454732894897,
-0.22112023830413818,
0.32146894931793213,
0.39136722683906555,
0.08162729442119598,
0.08924854546785355,
1.0007435083389282,
0.822604775428772,
-0.22761115431785583,
0.6588583588600159,
-0.18609674274921417,
-0.1276107132434845,
-0.8408815860748291,
0.11546557396650314,
-0.44987037777900696,
-0.23296405375003815,
-0.20232045650482178,
-0.4551136791706085,
0.3491450846195221,
0.42174026370048523,
-0.11095607280731201,
0.12096898257732391,
-0.4664877653121948,
0.8341889381408691,
0.7120777368545532,
0.2373630851507187,
0.30858224630355835,
-0.39723289012908936,
0.07074519246816635,
0.13736267387866974,
-0.9542887210845947,
-0.3024386763572693,
1.20042884349823,
0.11453426629304886,
0.6863672137260437,
0.11786741018295288,
0.6959313750267029,
0.30257517099380493,
0.31533563137054443,
-0.8067680597305298,
0.6383893489837646,
-0.27623552083969116,
-0.48171576857566833,
-0.5230963230133057,
-0.22703509032726288,
-0.48563945293426514,
-0.08283016830682755,
-0.16201597452163696,
-0.46179038286209106,
0.16220153868198395,
0.6002213954925537,
-0.38094159960746765,
0.3669825494289398,
-1.1310415267944336,
1.0894626379013062,
-0.42757102847099304,
-0.367175430059433,
-0.34463801980018616,
-0.5129392147064209,
0.24882765114307404,
-0.02198576182126999,
0.19491000473499298,
0.32187530398368835,
0.006479338277131319,
0.8641575574874878,
-0.42136064171791077,
0.9496777653694153,
-0.38839805126190186,
0.030681399628520012,
0.2340293675661087,
0.1338820606470108,
0.8246258497238159,
-0.06037764251232147,
-0.13209354877471924,
-0.1631440818309784,
-0.17319491505622864,
-0.28757473826408386,
-1.0702775716781616,
0.7083168625831604,
-0.6384550333023071,
-0.9020405411720276,
0.11137314140796661,
-0.7026459574699402,
-0.33499467372894287,
0.3326753079891205,
0.06180063262581825,
0.7267523407936096,
-0.2159094512462616,
0.18090133368968964,
0.8020370602607727,
-0.26645708084106445,
0.20989200472831726,
0.24736885726451874,
-0.1764197200536728,
-0.44766542315483093,
0.8500924110412598,
0.09162986278533936,
0.4844565987586975,
0.639449417591095,
0.35520943999290466,
0.13920293748378754,
-0.7598319053649902,
-0.7618864178657532,
-0.005067669320851564,
-1.0693928003311157,
0.08164265751838684,
-0.5538367629051208,
0.24452322721481323,
-0.4457782208919525,
-0.26029813289642334,
-0.5275172591209412,
-0.6481040716171265,
-0.17862537503242493,
-0.2036992311477661,
0.4182471036911011,
1.208217740058899,
0.15231932699680328,
0.5908327698707581,
-0.8199552893638611,
0.12241996079683304,
0.639707088470459,
0.3147509694099426,
-0.08312097936868668,
-0.26864033937454224,
-0.4862366318702698,
0.01711975410580635,
-0.11414837837219238,
-1.0070675611495972,
-0.1949799656867981,
0.41807982325553894,
0.5830267667770386,
0.41473203897476196,
-0.039960265159606934,
0.7179981470108032,
-0.6546325087547302,
0.5351161360740662,
-0.038534294813871384,
-1.1691153049468994,
0.5822678804397583,
-0.3332446217536926,
0.46104490756988525,
0.4961809515953064,
0.18013662099838257,
-0.565790593624115,
-0.5125480890274048,
-0.11471804231405258,
-0.6646103858947754,
0.7659550905227661,
-0.2595624029636383,
0.26375171542167664,
0.24086980521678925,
0.6083709597587585,
0.24580492079257965,
0.2837286591529846,
-0.5018866658210754,
-0.3562169075012207,
-0.19767530262470245,
-0.17775098979473114,
0.10723889619112015,
-0.6620634198188782,
-0.2042461782693863,
-0.3045074939727783,
0.9152682423591614,
0.008353793993592262,
0.1982249617576599,
0.17665773630142212,
-0.3438829779624939,
-0.10133669525384903,
0.6997577548027039,
0.8133256435394287,
0.9039510488510132,
-0.1185479685664177,
-0.0700044184923172,
0.1763758808374405,
-0.6295099854469299,
-0.03713717311620712,
0.130310520529747,
-0.1734965741634369,
-0.2451988011598587,
0.6333251595497131,
1.0671358108520508,
0.3411388695240021,
-0.2994410991668701,
0.4145492613315582,
0.045682329684495926,
-0.13394473493099213,
0.15652121603488922,
0.40090876817703247,
0.030096745118498802,
0.3117004632949829,
0.04915120080113411,
0.2488870918750763,
0.13811449706554413,
-0.14381344616413116,
-0.08695471286773682,
0.24405089020729065,
-0.13778989017009735,
-0.20921550691127777,
0.7120475769042969,
0.4518197774887085,
-0.3347586393356323,
0.5502057671546936,
-0.2994207739830017,
-0.5886469483375549,
0.4692578911781311,
0.21930424869060516,
0.9020601511001587,
-0.4413403272628784,
-0.015200973488390446,
0.3046894073486328,
0.507002055644989,
-0.08851443976163864,
-0.011031565256416798,
0.1273282915353775,
-0.7775618433952332,
-0.736167848110199,
-0.16908492147922516,
-0.5538255572319031,
-0.027599206194281578,
-0.7628426551818848,
0.1487938016653061,
-0.4481993615627289,
0.10169093310832977,
0.12846699357032776,
-0.45626652240753174,
-0.567369818687439,
0.135152667760849,
-0.41776418685913086,
0.8455853462219238,
-0.597705066204071,
0.9233629107475281,
1.0463930368423462,
-0.1303519308567047,
-0.9153660535812378,
0.06851807236671448,
0.14439964294433594,
-0.6433772444725037,
0.48112305998802185,
0.0834173709154129,
-0.22550542652606964,
0.24601195752620697,
-0.6834955811500549,
-0.4674728512763977,
0.9379000663757324,
0.5385901927947998,
-0.8922541737556458,
-0.1301516443490982,
-0.013331987895071507,
0.30403125286102295,
-0.009637349285185337,
-0.08245512843132019,
0.5647393465042114,
0.48795896768569946,
-0.3420022130012512,
-0.8195227980613708,
-0.24194397032260895,
-0.13739152252674103,
-0.24297723174095154,
0.36255156993865967,
-0.374616414308548,
0.7017842531204224,
-0.3845778703689575,
0.14241135120391846,
-0.13299724459648132,
0.4688137173652649,
-0.3919879198074341,
0.12562213838100433,
0.5040867924690247,
0.5525267720222473,
0.8282883167266846,
0.2166094332933426,
1.1401031017303467,
-0.4715593457221985,
0.30606481432914734,
1.3511698246002197,
0.018262283876538277,
0.581872820854187,
0.3785947263240814,
0.08233173191547394,
0.24668271839618683,
0.12194729596376419,
0.31199824810028076,
0.3031390607357025,
-0.27388331294059753,
-0.4167485237121582,
-0.2116282880306244,
0.17530463635921478,
-0.11480347067117691,
0.4840306043624878,
0.17550915479660034,
-0.25688862800598145,
0.0027142250910401344,
0.2683762013912201,
0.3322719633579254,
-0.022313009947538376,
-0.6110871434211731,
0.8611872792243958,
-0.36873859167099,
-0.6490681171417236,
0.1770712435245514,
0.186427503824234,
0.3592320382595062,
-0.5953853130340576,
-0.29539310932159424,
-0.011954843066632748,
0.05524798110127449,
-0.07092837244272232,
-0.6060720682144165,
-0.04776868224143982,
0.10215087980031967,
-0.3298937678337097,
-0.3639834225177765,
0.863885760307312,
-0.7181990146636963,
-0.4880843460559845,
0.14543554186820984,
0.6105502247810364,
-0.30009621381759644,
-0.22449977695941925,
-0.5913738012313843,
-0.07474532723426819,
0.2023175209760666,
-0.6607789397239685,
0.12921792268753052,
0.503671407699585,
-0.05313611403107643,
0.6021440029144287,
0.4538685381412506,
0.12464526295661926,
0.19788758456707,
-0.009038165211677551,
0.8174760937690735,
-0.42131686210632324,
-0.23904263973236084,
-0.8538520932197571,
0.6374219059944153,
0.006921158172190189,
-0.3134077787399292,
0.709980309009552,
0.3822935223579407,
0.829972505569458,
-0.4410554766654968,
0.9545534253120422,
-0.04102617874741554,
0.3589555025100708,
-0.9031531810760498,
0.7629622220993042,
-0.4793480634689331,
0.14730113744735718,
-0.18566496670246124,
-0.9009565711021423,
-0.44741618633270264,
0.27821028232574463,
-0.5423918962478638,
-0.048661693930625916,
0.8330740332603455,
0.8090275526046753,
-0.10113129019737244,
-0.05350792407989502,
0.1608801633119583,
0.32291531562805176,
0.2256072461605072,
0.3137918710708618,
0.6085805892944336,
-0.037636756896972656,
0.42355626821517944,
-0.6570667028427124,
-0.15523947775363922,
-0.00010896645108005032,
-0.8403448462486267,
-0.8859128355979919,
-0.29213598370552063,
-0.541423499584198,
0.11773681640625,
0.4558649957180023,
1.1913628578186035,
0.4977881908416748,
-0.7215814590454102,
-0.06041865050792694,
-0.19222934544086456,
0.25113311409950256,
-0.5549977421760559,
-0.13577678799629211,
0.6227680444717407,
-0.28215500712394714,
-1.0212308168411255,
0.6427000164985657,
0.2696610689163208,
-0.23254255950450897,
0.11012036353349686,
-0.04736151918768883,
-0.07686547935009003,
-0.07517819106578827,
0.5668696165084839,
0.09309179335832596,
-0.41482844948768616,
-0.5064225792884827,
-0.0483173243701458,
-0.08462425321340561,
-0.017792413011193275,
1.0020748376846313,
-0.006083142012357712,
0.8889184594154358,
0.24698883295059204,
1.0276918411254883,
0.017227523028850555,
0.06632678210735321,
0.5938905477523804,
-1.0042766332626343,
0.02025393769145012,
-0.0010809676023200154,
0.30963802337646484,
0.19758954644203186,
-0.5432888269424438,
0.32659560441970825,
0.1555655151605606,
-0.7550037503242493,
-0.48282015323638916,
0.0707658976316452,
-1.0310499668121338,
-0.09307219833135605,
1.3348898887634277,
-0.2827655076980591,
-0.02291814610362053,
-0.029509423300623894,
-0.6733454465866089,
0.3782081604003906,
-0.44786855578422546,
0.4860808551311493,
1.0129444599151611,
-0.2507322132587433,
-0.31147611141204834,
-0.9678876399993896,
0.4876497983932495,
0.5239309668540955,
-0.8479129076004028,
0.26393136382102966,
0.9247439503669739,
0.37226080894470215,
-0.0789424479007721,
0.4290390908718109,
0.4583379924297333,
0.5640379190444946,
-0.23303112387657166,
0.40816447138786316,
-0.5070303678512573,
-0.4779396057128906,
-0.4008975625038147,
0.057973891496658325,
0.41744473576545715,
-0.27339035272598267
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.