id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01620v2 | MAGDi: Structured Distillation of Multi-Agent Interaction Graphs Improves Reasoning in Smaller Language Models | 2024-02-02T18:35:14 | 2024-06-07T18:13:16 | Justin Chih-Yao Chen, Swarnadeep Saha, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-agent interactions between Large Language Model (LLM) agents have shown
major improvements on diverse reasoning tasks. However, these involve long
generations from multiple models across several rounds, making them expensive.
Moreover, these multi-agent approaches fail to provide a final, single model
for efficient inference. To address this, we introduce MAGDi, a new method for
structured distillation of the reasoning interactions between multiple LLMs
into smaller LMs. MAGDi teaches smaller models by representing multi-agent
interactions as graphs, augmenting a base student model with a graph encoder,
and distilling knowledge using three objective functions: next-token
prediction, a contrastive loss between correct and incorrect reasoning, and a
graph-based objective to model the interaction structure. Experiments on seven
widely used commonsense and math reasoning benchmarks show that MAGDi improves
the reasoning capabilities of smaller models, outperforming several methods
that distill from a single teacher and multiple teachers. Moreover, MAGDi also
demonstrates an order of magnitude higher efficiency over its teachers. We
conduct extensive analyses to show that MAGDi (1) enhances the generalizability
to out-of-domain tasks, (2) scales positively with the size and strength of the
base student model, and (3) obtains larger improvements (via our multi-teacher
training) when applying self-consistency -- an inference technique that relies
on model diversity. | [
0.022694489,
0.031206781,
-0.0113660423,
0.056780044,
-0.0329687148,
-0.0015925996,
0.0406379849,
-0.0314631723,
0.0289231967,
-0.0343291573,
-0.0116810724,
0.0057998514,
-0.0137578789,
0.0008584817,
0.0302886236,
-0.0562180616,
0.0330669656,
-0.05209307,
0.0018231453,
-0.0349331722,
-0.0151373837,
0.0043546404,
-0.0120037599,
0.0433341824,
-0.0123658255,
-0.0298302863,
-0.0356905684,
-0.0144800674,
0.0112843774,
-0.0107906321,
-0.0311278105,
0.0521667525,
0.0731891468,
0.0064187055,
0.0000021058,
-0.0448392071,
-8.447e-7,
-0.009307188,
-0.0449209511,
-0.0045642308,
0.0115638599,
-0.0036045853,
0.0330942161,
0.0031573554,
-0.0420298949,
-0.024953831,
0.013873253,
0.0007100476,
0.0766889006,
0.0649945736,
0.0134520195,
-0.0694579408,
0.0089217108,
-0.002596823,
0.0106640151,
-0.0440089703,
0.0427692235,
0.073259078,
0.0223870985,
-0.017654296,
-0.0653111264,
0.0154673196,
0.0730707794,
-0.0190348588,
0.0033861597,
0.0494606718,
0.0132634453,
-0.0084949937,
0.0119956844,
0.0877679214,
0.0116698379,
0.0071462989,
-0.0408510976,
0.0073436769,
0.0385143347,
0.0405397005,
-0.062907815,
0.0066305157,
-0.0025804443,
0.0081534833,
-0.0008747151,
-0.0410614647,
0.0299999453,
0.0197959747,
-0.0451911651,
0.0763443857,
-0.0228078458,
-0.0117561938,
0.0262289811,
0.0125096953,
-0.0367327929,
-0.0323453732,
0.0001173693,
0.0516114496,
-0.0218168497,
0.0242196284,
-0.0272739809,
-0.0037783026,
-0.021499496,
-0.0107248435,
0.012860503,
0.0290842522,
0.0227441583,
0.0524044856,
-0.0127156992,
0.0691000372,
0.0132635478,
0.0835964158,
-0.024842659,
-0.0119148949,
-0.0688747615,
0.0033652452,
-0.0280920621,
0.0828070417,
-0.0016318409,
-0.0131204212,
-0.0298158955,
0.0165008791,
-0.0340156071,
0.0160194915,
0.0312427208,
0.0160624012,
0.0002871304,
-0.0295164641,
-0.0346433409,
0.084036231,
-0.0460615046,
0.0260143802,
0.0336875096,
-0.0453249551,
-0.0393199287,
-0.0008139959,
0.0133530004,
-0.0175235551,
-0.0018344664,
0.0612296313,
-0.028460538,
-0.0167363938,
-0.0215380881,
-0.0285896398,
0.0264589433,
-0.0847955272,
0.0079117361,
-0.0874862596,
0.0553821586,
-0.0019888857,
-0.0070392899,
-0.0709033385,
0.0223855097,
-0.0332768932,
-0.024384765,
0.0780809298,
0.0056411675,
0.0133666219,
-0.0003301332,
0.0148760797,
-0.0670400783,
0.0736647472,
0.0178424995,
-0.0105706658,
0.018509699,
-0.013594389,
-0.0183486659,
0.0212644376,
0.021013407,
0.0256069526,
0.02647244,
0.0006261629,
-0.0310999341,
0.0474262312,
0.0001564109,
0.038254492,
-0.0749277174,
-0.0285776462,
0.0470673777,
0.0533135347,
-0.0025361376,
-0.0231979191,
0.0323572867,
0.0223480649,
0.0161802638,
0.0197711587,
-0.081915319,
0.0240053777,
0.0045243432,
0.0052889162,
0.0036861186,
0.0125142811,
-0.0295545626,
-0.0371052027,
0.0072342651,
0.0004713154,
0.0441952124,
0.0157662015,
0.0714170188,
-0.0006973642,
-0.0327265635,
0.0426773876,
0.0480168164,
-0.0405636169,
0.0223118067,
-0.0530114025,
0.0151742129,
0.051999215,
0.0484971777,
0.0057216967,
-0.0457345322,
0.0005128207,
0.0175357088,
0.0227374416,
0.0193916932,
-0.0349625684,
0.0102954088,
-0.0619204044,
-0.0413041152,
-0.0197863989,
-0.0104864733,
0.0219250415,
0.0284355097,
-0.005893602,
0.0028983487,
-0.0629047006,
0.017505968,
0.0112579716,
-0.0444904976,
-0.0119762802,
-0.0475681201,
0.0026812768,
0.0287507642,
0.0066370131,
0.0044890968,
-0.0045284457,
0.0095166443,
-0.0052712485,
-0.0151050473,
0.0046395487,
-0.0426685102,
-0.1132073179,
0.0409763008,
-0.0145354131,
-0.033669997,
0.0091709038,
-0.0563129932,
-0.0317661427,
0.0610921085,
-0.0124923522,
0.0424148515,
-0.0168342944,
-0.0020651768,
-0.0082624145,
-0.0248005111,
0.0273610558,
0.0796448961,
-0.0265806559,
-0.0352462605,
0.0035026707,
0.0477935858,
-0.0149663249,
-0.0309184957,
0.0286898222,
0.0213828422,
-0.000762481,
0.0240014698,
-0.0089145973,
0.0175769683,
-0.0491942316,
-0.0088276137,
-0.0368734896,
-0.0234483592,
-0.0075285789,
0.0184277743,
-0.000646541,
-0.0123533178,
0.0293572377,
-0.0030180139,
-0.0185938571,
0.0216258671,
-0.0017031871,
0.0278937537,
-0.0055202469,
0.0025521086,
-0.0425297543,
-0.0080308923,
-0.0380881131,
-0.026301166,
0.0683464855,
0.0189745352,
0.0183005724,
-0.029225545,
0.0123872524,
-0.05890093,
0.0296690855,
-0.0256246477,
-0.0222080536,
0.0450181663,
-0.0257608276,
0.0125688743,
0.1047218069,
-0.0367992669,
0.0785591751,
0.042813044,
-0.0311790369,
-0.078458488,
0.0290241148,
-0.0233145263,
0.0090882322,
-0.0717389062,
-0.0002586835,
-0.067923896,
0.0286535397,
-0.0101894652,
0.0001426286,
-0.0666027144,
0.0054624863,
0.0232074261,
-0.025232628,
-0.0110410787,
-0.0236204732,
0.0057184151,
0.0012911232,
-0.0386093557,
0.0044360459,
0.0990761295,
0.0255809538,
-0.01736084,
-0.0229509231,
0.0088644074,
-0.0211122446,
0.072148636,
-0.0001198292,
-0.0043379124,
-0.0187539347,
-0.0185461584,
-0.0788362846,
-0.0355206281,
0.0621806867,
-0.0047998074,
0.0429395773,
-0.0616873577,
0.0062139835,
0.0068569239,
-0.0399714336,
-0.0252290163,
0.0157680493,
-0.0286571607,
0.042764321,
-0.011580077,
-0.0212493744,
-0.0459822491,
-0.0195581056,
-0.0037726895,
-0.0183405522,
-0.0265574474,
-0.0010860134,
-0.0209921394,
0.0255604126,
0.0205576122,
0.0159770306,
0.0086888783,
-0.0932508409,
0.0568378903,
0.0629549548,
0.0452332012,
-0.0646826997,
-0.0105858361,
0.0115423137,
-0.0166667812,
0.0015966536,
0.0057163467,
0.016891893,
0.0622897111,
-0.0726368055,
0.0007712778,
0.1070184782,
0.0024076651,
-0.0070644873,
-0.0012053574,
-0.0299417693,
0.0629289523,
0.0101680337,
-0.0017788626,
-0.0530582704,
-0.0565596819,
0.011459155,
0.0004994025,
0.0495625585,
-0.0584950112,
0.0159753971,
-0.1102879345,
0.0090008192,
0.0478465222,
-0.0124545377,
-0.0128335012,
-0.0572055057,
-0.006306597,
-0.0227269456,
0.008798751,
0.0204476714,
0.0185531247,
0.006226073,
0.0053934637,
0.0142748188,
-0.038281247,
0.0303899441,
-0.0248642247,
0.0203676075,
-0.0031368271,
0.004358307,
0.0105037298,
-0.0610461161,
0.0484432727,
0.0435284525,
0.0034567034,
-0.0126758665,
0.0472311936,
-0.0182429627,
0.0119170938,
-0.0108145233,
0.0417950004,
-0.0411412977,
-0.0190773513,
0.0225148797,
0.0962254778,
0.0048139738,
-0.0533897951,
0.0059617846,
0.0013143043,
-0.018968869,
0.0559938699,
0.0402880274,
0.0030411654,
-0.0626640767,
-0.0648314208,
-0.0398460329,
-0.0442149714,
-0.022945758,
0.0319854468,
0.0144902794,
0.0075667691,
0.0045241895,
-0.0603516214,
0.0584072322,
0.0307213422,
-0.0190117266,
-0.0046610162,
0.0506634228,
0.023621656,
0.0016518735,
0.0154715367,
-0.0465385579,
0.0061910069,
0.0207194984,
0.0070993477,
-0.0021755083,
0.0006296856,
-0.0147017399,
0.0021594188,
-0.0862156451,
-0.0871210545,
-0.031462647,
0.0441060625,
0.0206478946,
0.0852503777,
0.0131715713,
-0.0015287471,
0.0366184488,
-0.0201569125,
-0.0153382104,
0.0038307616,
0.0445765406,
-0.0414223671,
0.0355725586,
0.0547473766,
-0.0417487398,
0.009311527,
0.0047907447,
0.0640825331,
-0.0612791516,
-0.0098980796,
0.0082407482,
0.0220891982,
-0.0147920027,
0.0392977037,
-0.0039381078,
-0.0417317115,
0.0170356594,
-0.0430864617,
-0.0188638512,
-0.036382053,
0.0072953491,
0.0211070701,
-0.0067723263,
0.0464433916,
-0.0294557381,
0.0171029177,
0.0211635232,
0.0294852797,
0.0215158537,
0.0053832568,
0.001334605,
0.0535352454,
-0.0146517428,
-0.0254950467,
-0.0091233728,
0.0084399916,
0.023083888,
-0.000498539,
0.0476366207,
0.0445702448,
-0.0076643014,
-0.0007720119,
-0.0260439292,
-0.0686315522,
-0.0529246479,
0.0009742042,
0.0227133855,
0.0260740425,
0.0634679049,
0.0201641098,
-0.0374829173,
0.0074657789,
0.0079463013,
0.0605088808,
0.0064870249,
-0.0573089197,
0.0503352508,
0.0298195258,
0.0238051359,
-0.0182090811,
0.0527085252,
-0.003268502,
0.0428593308,
-0.0101961084,
0.0093239471,
-0.0361802839,
-0.0658917874,
-0.0118436767,
0.0371855795,
0.0151162865,
0.0378289782,
-0.0545715094,
-0.077401787,
-0.0443826877,
0.0206821859,
-0.0140466057,
-0.0043893033,
0.0331876948,
0.0426229984,
-0.0180815831,
-0.0563197397,
-0.0024178568,
0.0315228365,
-0.0372877568,
-0.0248366967,
0.0057231137,
-6.14991608e-33,
-0.0370479897,
-0.0513991676,
0.0528110415,
-0.0033291571,
-0.0292672142,
-0.022543598,
-0.0533389039,
-0.0096756676,
-0.0637577176,
0.0380353481,
0.016579533,
0.0295464732,
-0.0040052412,
0.0173477679,
0.0058125691,
-0.0143654682,
0.0281091388,
0.0172893405,
0.0013469661,
0.0194576476,
0.017542962,
0.005157894,
0.0583422333,
-0.0475533418,
0.0064929933,
-0.0022777433,
0.0052815452,
0.0447721593,
-0.0520261303,
0.0495861173,
0.0215687286,
0.0529338233,
0.00884494,
-0.0417727679,
-0.0164240561,
-0.0171191245,
-0.072105065,
-0.0645035729,
0.0287239719,
0.0231402945,
-0.0714088902,
-0.0353507213,
0.0289834589,
0.0214754883,
0.0048862197,
-0.0750966519,
0.0372964405,
-0.0038102781,
-0.023831429,
0.0595484376,
-0.0313842744,
0.0109516429,
-0.0383002013,
-0.0224066712,
0.0039439723,
0.0308679249,
-0.0047125332,
-0.0187369063,
-0.0492681041,
0.0266647749,
0.0251484197,
-0.0149355577,
0.0548470542,
0.0235735197,
0.0232364498,
0.0587446168,
0.0086963009,
-0.003963328,
-0.0444161631,
-0.0325839818,
0.0218253639,
0.0922697932,
0.017875718,
0.05379498,
-0.016614221,
-0.0014013459,
-0.0893207863,
-0.0025969082,
0.0317126885,
0.0632285625,
-0.0079076877,
0.0017746902,
-0.0108853094,
-0.048949115,
-0.0380688049,
-0.0088269273,
-0.0101420069,
-0.0530336164,
0.0168989003,
-0.013459594,
-0.0104765696,
-0.008756957,
0.0194194932,
-0.0723788142,
-0.0344993956,
0.055566892,
-0.0184049513,
0.0118827289,
-0.0143660381,
0.0281439573,
-0.0502467938,
-0.0345507078,
0.0175503641,
-0.0149874091,
0.0073849279,
0.0368967578,
0.0641118437,
0.0039547179,
-0.0129289199,
-0.0290687047,
-0.0476909131,
-0.0262560192,
0.0137544619,
-0.0019791285,
0.0381977148,
0.0436056256,
-0.0218545683,
0.0328321569,
0.0254698899,
-0.0173990242,
-0.0281505398,
0.0203459412,
-0.0153659619,
0.0049613072,
-0.0283354707,
-0.0041363128,
-0.0642354861,
-0.0117184445,
0.0392580777,
-0.0274442155,
-0.0247572884,
0.0184581168,
2.686e-7,
0.0304206349,
0.0379970297,
0.0135567151,
0.0133403288,
0.0065633636,
0.0594400764,
-0.0368378237,
-0.0056224256,
0.0356756076,
-0.0546149015,
0.0188927818,
0.1010847241,
0.022001151,
0.0408411585,
-0.0548804961,
0.0292398743,
-0.0436564274,
-0.0257136226,
-0.0270716511,
-0.0087891808,
0.045522213,
0.0501737222,
0.0590312853,
-0.0085111996,
-0.0180995371,
-0.0461567417,
0.05379292,
0.0069176634,
-0.0049478766,
0.0110189561,
-0.0633527711,
-0.0351136178,
0.0254842155,
0.0543431528,
0.0295160152,
0.0092132026,
-0.0323527418,
0.0490813926,
-0.040269997,
-0.0176317636,
-0.0079403054,
-0.0226705149,
-0.0043409602,
-0.0389738716,
0.0662966669,
-0.065888755,
-0.0435230769,
0.0306478739,
-0.0256983135,
-0.0154285813,
-0.0031404779,
0.0071772397,
0.0035752852,
0.0110499104,
0.001123757,
-0.0142093664,
0.0198262893,
-0.0210155789,
0.008502136,
-0.0101230973,
-0.0428726971,
-0.0815418959,
-0.0000859004,
-0.0212245584,
0.0196907204,
-0.0212789811,
0.0012025731,
2.32555532e-34,
0.0356467515,
0.0008856651,
0.0361807197,
0.0462658741,
0.0494084544,
-0.0475866385,
-0.0483632088,
0.0098129353,
0.046799887,
-0.0776066259,
-0.035541635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01619v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01619v1 | KB-Plugin: A Plug-and-play Framework for Large Language Models to Induce Programs over Low-resourced Knowledge Bases | 2024-02-02T18:32:24 | 2024-02-02T18:32:24 | Jiajie Zhang, Shulin Cao, Linmei Hu, Ling Feng, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Program induction (PI) has become a promising paradigm for using knowledge
bases (KBs) to help large language models (LLMs) answer complex
knowledge-intensive questions. Nonetheless, PI typically relies on a large
number of parallel question-program pairs to make the LLM aware of the schema
of the given KB, and is thus challenging for many low-resourced KBs that lack
annotated data. To this end, we propose KB-Plugin, a plug-and-play framework
that enables LLMs to induce programs over any low-resourced KB. Firstly,
KB-Plugin adopts self-supervised learning to encode the detailed schema
information of a given KB into a pluggable module, namely schema plugin.
Secondly, KB-Plugin utilizes abundant annotated data from a rich-resourced KB
to train another pluggable module, namely PI plugin, which can help the LLM
extract question-relevant schema information from the schema plugin of any KB
and utilize this information to induce programs over this KB. Experiments on
five heterogeneous KBQA datasets show that KB-Plugin achieves better or
comparable performance with 25$\times$ smaller backbone LLM compared to SoTA PI
methods for low-resourced KBs, and even approaches the performance of
supervised methods. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/THU-KEG/KB-Plugin. | [
0.0070608165,
0.0330496579,
-0.0118665518,
0.0419889428,
-0.0071523725,
0.0393429026,
-0.0173680838,
-0.0199511722,
0.0453921705,
-0.0506235026,
-0.0231155995,
0.0517477132,
-0.0298141688,
0.0419824161,
0.0294322837,
-0.0013613886,
0.0319158621,
-0.0463426001,
-0.0141500803,
-0.0158812739,
-0.0087898644,
0.0271330681,
-0.005644158,
0.0211665258,
-0.0074257804,
-0.0175935943,
-0.0217976999,
-0.0182911903,
-0.0433076657,
-0.0286661386,
0.0024571698,
0.0617456622,
0.0348556526,
0.0336190574,
0.0000020505,
-0.0624894649,
-0.0284614041,
0.0080379285,
-0.0663051307,
0.0306314006,
-0.0121637611,
-0.0217731744,
0.0121127721,
0.006484447,
-0.059913978,
-0.0261295289,
0.0299882218,
0.0259598158,
0.0681988001,
0.0548550822,
0.0038022546,
-0.0206383113,
0.0371287726,
-0.0118493456,
0.0205317773,
-0.0027306534,
0.0200472604,
0.0346387476,
-0.0048038107,
0.0388978757,
0.0102641853,
0.038868729,
0.0270157773,
-0.0231305659,
0.0260747522,
0.0410410091,
-0.0642779768,
0.0010576113,
-0.0179787949,
0.0982180014,
-0.0352640077,
-0.0361320451,
0.0018805638,
-0.0091470191,
0.0138757527,
0.0234765187,
-0.0412586406,
0.0214568824,
0.0117054014,
-0.001772562,
0.0581254512,
-0.0145654753,
0.0374407731,
-0.0225702487,
-0.0234318413,
0.0874843374,
0.0315188207,
-0.0594361015,
0.0233426969,
0.0049087135,
-0.0273988601,
-0.0373393297,
-0.0545678958,
0.0302926134,
-0.0096663842,
0.0393559113,
0.0051872367,
-0.0095493663,
0.0384823307,
-0.0336214192,
0.0186376385,
0.0407022014,
-0.0349228345,
0.0547495037,
-0.0736634433,
0.0413456708,
0.0068245782,
0.0069060517,
-0.0174867641,
0.0089794165,
-0.0671789423,
-0.0092341043,
-0.0550731085,
0.0452614911,
-0.0004343747,
0.0070334128,
0.0023171215,
0.0799722075,
-0.0051907524,
0.0474294387,
0.0261520371,
-0.0139741357,
-0.0058779139,
-0.0019534077,
-0.0240951478,
0.0426500849,
-0.0491784997,
-0.0112594785,
-0.0229797047,
-0.0106590698,
-0.017105611,
0.0123214908,
0.0091265012,
-0.0134798177,
0.0090599721,
0.0222204383,
-0.0053344383,
-0.0167385861,
-0.0457978249,
-0.0312893353,
0.0042468631,
-0.0445392728,
-0.0232772622,
-0.1040100008,
0.0414750241,
0.0209975895,
-0.0135749886,
-0.0226295106,
0.0191874169,
0.007672172,
-0.0056009451,
0.0695505142,
-0.0443748049,
0.0108606126,
0.0208970364,
0.0124861179,
-0.0370287932,
0.0769465789,
-0.0171214864,
0.0069414484,
0.0191819575,
-0.0238127708,
-0.0149576059,
0.0393928774,
0.0533513911,
0.0331298634,
0.0160154011,
0.0435681343,
0.0481198132,
0.0318319462,
-0.0078533636,
0.0167457182,
-0.0067679496,
0.030966064,
0.0138666853,
0.0610107705,
0.0109972125,
0.0349624716,
0.076220192,
0.0303777345,
0.0391354002,
-0.0214293748,
-0.0761099681,
0.0421331711,
-0.0510820784,
0.0236228853,
0.0111725163,
0.0280236788,
-0.0312521122,
-0.0381040797,
-0.0015491274,
-0.0174329784,
-0.0376049615,
-0.0014781677,
0.0661748201,
0.0533126928,
-0.0116052786,
0.0622877032,
0.0337231904,
-0.0307857338,
-0.0087536983,
-0.0504038446,
0.0597561076,
0.0488531813,
0.0459396504,
-0.0747153312,
-0.0190222785,
-0.0056239231,
0.0056900405,
0.0466722175,
0.0268720277,
-0.0494790636,
-0.0348169021,
-0.0188394319,
-0.0160760451,
-0.0593075529,
0.0197316837,
0.0105886832,
0.0476273932,
-0.0124059562,
0.0261650085,
-0.0297938753,
0.0034960047,
0.0458229817,
-0.0533645339,
-0.0190037265,
-0.0020920555,
0.0229277201,
0.0136717763,
0.006378809,
0.0052123494,
0.0110342605,
0.0521587059,
-0.0417102426,
-0.0374066457,
-0.0275164992,
0.0027960034,
-0.0946940184,
0.0456771515,
0.0355026945,
0.0039949929,
-0.0242755897,
-0.0409646705,
-0.0442527682,
0.0318997465,
0.0093969963,
0.0644376054,
-0.050288409,
0.0020602271,
0.0246363096,
0.000205939,
-0.0274122395,
0.083440192,
0.0203663651,
0.0136118997,
0.0411049835,
-0.0050493772,
0.0161748379,
0.003974169,
-0.0231007934,
-0.0003497048,
-0.0203356389,
0.0199305918,
0.0083819842,
0.0018086658,
-0.0698166415,
-0.0126928231,
-0.1015423238,
0.0224740524,
-0.0055034081,
0.017360311,
0.0003920775,
0.0178038329,
0.0045988765,
-0.0156896077,
-0.053170573,
0.0122831482,
0.0024442978,
0.0348682664,
0.01525045,
0.0304026194,
-0.012687901,
-0.0068255896,
-0.0099922651,
-0.0101584103,
0.0498195104,
-0.0044653681,
0.0249930434,
-0.05473499,
0.0326806083,
-0.0282426216,
0.00992388,
-0.0090344409,
-0.0360764265,
0.0164936297,
-0.0556495264,
0.0222140383,
0.0506860986,
-0.0319470242,
-0.0139204087,
0.0614909306,
0.0104289427,
-0.0891409814,
0.0274665523,
0.0013632132,
-0.0212076604,
-0.0238736589,
-0.027363671,
0.0036460231,
0.0715102628,
-0.0260018073,
-0.0200043656,
-0.0353884362,
0.0290605333,
-0.0009431522,
-0.0094997287,
-0.0413403697,
0.0010497142,
0.0208643749,
0.0257451199,
-0.0174441095,
-0.0548365526,
0.0801350921,
-0.0364054404,
-0.0243343953,
-0.0134875579,
0.0107544558,
-0.0503475703,
0.0817960501,
0.0019720842,
0.0083280886,
-0.0139347678,
0.0098174084,
-0.0459896177,
0.0298143271,
-0.0083527155,
-0.0189477149,
0.0772604495,
-0.0150620854,
0.0335857645,
0.0092280721,
-0.0364828445,
-0.0703096911,
-0.0153156323,
-0.0207393672,
0.0006930071,
0.0008840808,
-0.0060662702,
0.0464940071,
-0.0101341773,
0.0080115376,
0.0396786146,
0.0055302321,
-0.0172340684,
-0.0050675417,
0.0086273989,
0.0329694897,
0.0012402833,
0.0013713848,
0.0192589797,
0.0713016987,
0.0302745216,
-0.0116296867,
-0.0248763245,
-0.0126275495,
0.0208672378,
0.0008361491,
-0.046026174,
-0.0318073183,
0.010664125,
0.0029155442,
-0.0699603558,
-0.0272755343,
0.1205500439,
0.0499149151,
-0.0382336006,
-0.016275296,
-0.0271315612,
0.0302301925,
0.0504086353,
0.0667514727,
-0.0958284363,
-0.0315159634,
-0.0289584436,
0.0286904927,
0.0101734903,
-0.0197638758,
-0.009688112,
-0.1500795633,
0.0233483631,
0.0089413626,
-0.0647477135,
-0.0273671877,
-0.0620991886,
-0.0169165861,
0.0022615278,
-0.0321092121,
0.0099024884,
-0.0183606949,
0.0117840087,
-0.0019877085,
-0.0128337182,
-0.0458670817,
0.0310634356,
-0.0117024314,
0.0840380788,
0.0429457165,
-0.0055994247,
-0.0067265332,
0.0017690893,
-0.0034063796,
-0.0131841842,
-0.0235799905,
-0.0172112714,
0.0301234089,
-0.0011022302,
-0.017284859,
0.0235250238,
0.0458843336,
-0.0531629287,
-0.0083022034,
0.0391018465,
0.1089217514,
-0.0183140393,
-0.021554498,
0.0097183753,
-0.0352055393,
0.0098772552,
0.0783718899,
0.0463583656,
-0.0146591114,
0.0040130727,
-0.0357779264,
-0.0388711169,
-0.0409372076,
-0.0299113262,
0.0332040936,
0.0026970236,
-0.0042590289,
-0.0874549001,
-0.0113083813,
0.0522683114,
0.0193207543,
0.0281631593,
0.0289872009,
-0.0023962331,
0.0025490723,
-0.0620584339,
0.0336501189,
-0.0683346987,
-0.0358695537,
-0.0431896262,
-0.0669738874,
0.0259780847,
-0.0543523841,
-0.0171832144,
-0.0390633382,
-0.0872261971,
-0.0473959036,
-0.0103115868,
0.0882642493,
0.0082597258,
0.0557726063,
-0.0324649699,
-0.0137184262,
0.0454473197,
0.0484049469,
-0.0726164505,
-0.0401825309,
0.0261717476,
-0.0039339196,
-0.0102130873,
0.0620673075,
-0.0577886328,
0.0077137393,
-0.0018145181,
0.0477896184,
-0.0292530265,
-0.0234541744,
0.0331985913,
0.0277774818,
-0.0126679754,
-0.0008237277,
-0.0023494146,
-0.0381927975,
0.0014429385,
-0.0049749357,
-0.0380403772,
-0.0467132255,
0.0228303745,
-0.0073818513,
-0.0266320929,
0.0381451733,
-0.036071755,
-0.029409755,
0.0125393085,
0.0173790287,
0.0065656132,
0.0320708565,
0.0230255611,
0.0533857159,
0.0068335612,
-0.0266540404,
0.0290070772,
0.0214079898,
0.0236496739,
-0.0437085666,
0.0450943336,
0.0040913052,
0.0068563065,
-0.0392722897,
0.0127328653,
-0.0201834328,
-0.0577270389,
-0.0011317231,
0.0300217308,
0.0651965216,
-0.008112289,
0.0331454687,
-0.0377595723,
-0.0317015015,
0.0089557534,
-0.0004557684,
0.0215354152,
-0.0099726804,
0.0414648168,
0.0350768715,
-0.0234194938,
0.0011936104,
0.0855325982,
-0.0083290851,
0.043259114,
0.0353381708,
0.0192749295,
-0.0532181673,
-0.0241960026,
0.0072570108,
0.0296518654,
-0.0486952364,
0.0256872457,
-0.0241169333,
-0.085164018,
-0.0255083945,
-0.0124133984,
-0.0718924627,
0.0259812567,
0.0259395726,
0.0566435605,
0.0220665466,
-0.0124956705,
-0.0438374244,
0.0471644625,
-0.0421081223,
-0.0530110337,
0.0330883041,
-6.319389304e-33,
-0.0218053218,
-0.0179578308,
0.0234427359,
-0.0060050674,
0.0073927585,
0.0260636955,
-0.0481744222,
0.0168779287,
-0.0076404,
0.0069250264,
-0.0137300519,
-0.0113691362,
-0.0110359946,
0.0100430157,
0.0323634706,
-0.0330130495,
0.0029431295,
-0.0043973001,
-0.0133209974,
0.0332271643,
0.014785978,
0.014775537,
0.0108134309,
-0.0083269114,
0.0386282876,
-0.0153359119,
0.0138344318,
0.0355193503,
-0.041911155,
0.0647911504,
-0.0216978956,
0.0562739037,
0.0390566066,
-0.0384574868,
0.0072490103,
0.0114547843,
-0.0809532702,
-0.0426847376,
0.0368319601,
-0.0259730071,
-0.0270191729,
-0.0270475112,
0.0353207812,
-0.0127347866,
0.0429892093,
-0.0088961516,
0.024349397,
-0.0338688791,
-0.0052769799,
-0.005733951,
-0.0579675734,
-0.0097281225,
0.0021599773,
-0.0221935324,
0.03044945,
-0.0065630605,
0.0150903063,
0.0232781004,
-0.0250879657,
0.0268147532,
-0.0038381352,
0.0537130944,
0.0514794849,
0.0027149064,
0.0219800901,
0.0100697083,
0.0042670774,
-0.0075691747,
-0.0163525753,
-0.0097774854,
0.0184604395,
0.0332714505,
0.0522688255,
0.0370597653,
0.0244196765,
0.0208427049,
-0.0516552255,
0.0125859324,
0.0444323793,
0.0041229897,
-0.0098894238,
-0.0145883299,
-0.028317159,
-0.0191705991,
-0.055552505,
0.0005636354,
-0.0535702258,
-0.0470167771,
0.0239661485,
0.0019497868,
-0.02187673,
-0.0119117647,
-0.0007481424,
-0.0439154021,
0.0059790127,
0.0558241792,
0.0034656783,
0.0004852174,
-0.0110756718,
0.0605220832,
-0.0644828007,
-0.0219870601,
0.0327552892,
-0.0375415422,
0.0216977149,
0.0483677872,
0.0452655926,
0.0029959856,
-0.0650109574,
-0.0089414483,
-0.0676036254,
-0.0005310317,
-0.0055483831,
0.0256374162,
0.0051664608,
0.0426447242,
0.0233977754,
0.0185448155,
0.0170473773,
-0.0071570962,
-0.0268529821,
-0.0237332787,
0.0034396257,
-0.00055654,
-0.0376392938,
0.0171896443,
-0.0693365559,
0.0071211844,
-0.031002013,
-0.0499956906,
-0.0107826609,
-0.0170207955,
2.772e-7,
0.0613252111,
0.0391693227,
-0.003543461,
0.0200922228,
0.0207554717,
0.0187995695,
-0.0415179059,
0.0010355018,
0.037601307,
-0.0348068997,
0.0226185247,
0.0468880944,
0.0239746235,
0.0335612409,
-0.1187512055,
-0.014565059,
-0.0212210398,
0.0188056733,
-0.0811388642,
-0.0199309438,
0.0576535985,
0.0833589509,
0.0292503107,
0.0029806595,
-0.0003998935,
-0.0332902931,
0.0378953442,
0.0060662497,
-0.0217703544,
0.0367603749,
-0.0321640372,
0.0701870173,
-0.0209889039,
0.0551033244,
-0.0321501084,
0.0279888678,
0.0025058044,
0.0527347326,
0.0089859068,
-0.0161860939,
0.0054024882,
-0.0433409847,
0.0239112899,
-0.0665609613,
0.0919503942,
-0.0726963505,
0.0046223085,
0.0084868073,
-0.0004242735,
-0.0454466566,
-0.0117500825,
-0.0622698925,
-0.0062280921,
0.0073496304,
0.03037435,
-0.0168015249,
-0.0177347139,
-0.060651768,
-0.0244884565,
0.0391633511,
-0.0072705382,
-0.0544108227,
-0.0542599186,
-0.0249514207,
-0.0182019137,
-0.0495600514,
0.0311194621,
3.000027117e-34,
0.0346036814,
-0.0157408621,
0.032959491,
0.0300443992,
0.0206251442,
-0.0298565719,
-0.0126903085,
-0.0213665441,
0.0252325535,
-0.0934709907,
0.0145045044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01618v1 | Style Vectors for Steering Generative Large Language Model | 2024-02-02T18:31:15 | 2024-02-02T18:31:15 | Kai Konen, Sophie Jentzsch, Diaoulé Diallo, Peer Schütt, Oliver Bensch, Roxanne El Baff, Dominik Opitz, Tobias Hecking | cs.CL | cs.CL | This research explores strategies for steering the output of large language
models (LLMs) towards specific styles, such as sentiment, emotion, or writing
style, by adding style vectors to the activations of hidden layers during text
generation. We show that style vectors can be simply computed from recorded
layer activations for input texts in a specific style in contrast to more
complex training-based approaches. Through a series of experiments, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of activation engineering using such style
vectors to influence the style of generated text in a nuanced and
parameterisable way, distinguishing it from prompt engineering. The presented
research constitutes a significant step towards developing more adaptive and
effective AI-empowered interactive systems. | [
0.0159442853,
0.0386417434,
-0.0120711029,
0.0306671709,
-0.012832012,
0.0128770843,
0.0211616792,
0.0134086721,
0.0140392622,
-0.0430889763,
-0.0556593947,
-0.0430174768,
-0.0219074562,
0.0441896245,
0.0207328852,
-0.0441030115,
-0.0240586493,
-0.007600863,
0.0226140171,
-0.0002658683,
0.0387914144,
0.0344151445,
-0.0062476425,
0.0484618656,
-0.0072738896,
-0.0321869962,
0.0000322474,
0.0453670621,
0.014088314,
-0.0139544783,
0.0357897729,
0.0362852253,
0.0078069689,
0.0369762331,
0.0000017724,
-0.0154268621,
0.0329627581,
-0.0365043506,
0.0481870659,
0.0256749541,
0.0757290423,
0.0127999019,
-0.0363404863,
0.0037803408,
-0.026174916,
-0.0284991544,
0.059531685,
0.0817941651,
0.062152151,
0.0791578069,
-0.0155323306,
-0.02845929,
-0.0012996024,
-0.0210702438,
0.0153210564,
0.0241074264,
0.0027269444,
-0.0213206131,
-0.013188513,
0.0084285839,
0.0185167044,
0.0365422368,
0.0193972457,
-0.0701049939,
0.0151534695,
0.0153445154,
-0.0127565116,
0.0021265191,
0.0045227366,
0.0823024064,
-0.0013996304,
-0.0102914181,
0.003525439,
-0.0264946949,
0.0183669534,
-0.01163474,
-0.040244244,
0.0077944514,
-0.0104519296,
0.015386357,
-0.010956632,
0.0187801477,
0.0214813165,
0.0300340075,
0.0253631286,
-0.0017566198,
0.0140591124,
-0.0103204995,
-0.0355287194,
0.0110885995,
0.0009123574,
-0.0493595898,
0.029936878,
0.0130706038,
-0.0267576799,
0.0155118359,
-0.0454988927,
-0.0156790856,
-0.0153469387,
-0.0724638551,
0.0802261978,
0.0138492798,
-0.000191574,
-0.0001635843,
-0.0236657672,
0.0323348492,
-0.0550938845,
-0.0160088763,
-0.0195239969,
0.0145523651,
-0.0236278307,
-0.0321863219,
-0.0115630487,
-0.0057878355,
-0.019404849,
-0.0366915725,
-0.0377442054,
0.0237205867,
-0.0149725107,
-0.0003316145,
-0.0049926834,
0.0290856212,
-0.0125948228,
-0.0167557131,
-0.0001133627,
0.0079520531,
-0.0286052618,
0.0083249025,
0.0113038886,
-0.0083814431,
0.0073764618,
0.0360053927,
0.0213972293,
-0.0096330848,
-0.0308369789,
0.0103007024,
-0.0387284607,
0.0130903441,
-0.0703120828,
-0.0249356925,
0.0068502855,
-0.0144310826,
0.0290611275,
-0.0470408164,
-0.0078812949,
-0.0052326564,
-0.0126344329,
-0.0446668044,
0.0019660499,
0.0197396427,
-0.0107996669,
0.0096739791,
0.0205320306,
-0.0175844859,
0.0393303894,
-0.0035553891,
0.0269267205,
0.047045242,
0.0531259365,
0.0960110798,
0.0105012907,
-0.0108082285,
0.0592889711,
0.0547556691,
0.006796753,
0.0250026397,
-0.0715478435,
-0.0653143674,
-0.0070595881,
0.0514564551,
0.0406830758,
0.0589698628,
-0.0171821341,
0.0205473527,
0.1015913859,
-0.0078651169,
0.0279341955,
0.0490792096,
0.0570762977,
0.0140425358,
0.0150890127,
-0.0095940782,
0.0122019397,
0.0300977603,
-0.0158829205,
0.0217606127,
0.0206711199,
0.0068194205,
-0.0428196602,
-0.061771024,
-0.0032103902,
0.008999709,
0.0034962029,
0.0103319138,
0.0120998807,
0.0406736955,
-0.0395060591,
-0.0355026461,
0.0283326469,
-0.0833601877,
0.0160139725,
-0.0530784652,
0.0395070165,
0.1260631084,
0.0364661738,
0.0058212387,
-0.0131670283,
0.0039645243,
0.0052362056,
0.0920827836,
0.0238679014,
-0.0248802453,
0.0127753355,
-0.07296253,
0.0088362731,
-0.0191660374,
0.0118218241,
0.0160651524,
-0.0319969468,
0.0155244013,
0.0081316782,
-0.0052710306,
-0.0624583475,
0.0368397683,
-0.0256742723,
-0.082067959,
0.0333259925,
0.000551186,
-0.0065900087,
0.0075050388,
-0.0564586967,
-0.0045614559,
-0.0310492422,
-0.0610704459,
-0.049878601,
0.0398039967,
-0.0278491825,
-0.0307812244,
-0.0289086141,
-0.0077505703,
-0.0052023754,
-0.0034051971,
-0.0368237197,
-0.0332962424,
0.0136728268,
-0.0489725508,
0.0132088689,
-0.0334824845,
-0.0108234491,
-0.0066399663,
0.0047127185,
-0.0347777791,
0.0236306023,
0.0125162099,
-0.0432608686,
0.0223900154,
0.0342935659,
-0.0106340749,
0.0167707335,
-0.0220242366,
0.0045552878,
0.0447416604,
-0.0020967554,
0.0338523276,
0.0137363467,
-0.0171068646,
-0.0561251007,
-0.0783900917,
-0.0187369399,
-0.0281170756,
-0.002831958,
0.0289673097,
0.017386863,
-0.0332580879,
0.0074268258,
-0.06046905,
-0.0058236341,
-0.0172556229,
0.0005751377,
0.0298454165,
-0.0158492047,
-0.0087224953,
-0.0657912716,
-0.0047117537,
0.0060857888,
0.0342091508,
0.0469465107,
0.0192907769,
-0.0539964586,
-0.0108822491,
-0.0185057446,
0.0000207572,
-0.0057434118,
-0.0678058565,
0.0217729956,
-0.0369670913,
0.0504341461,
0.0878807753,
0.0457144342,
0.0712261274,
0.04687161,
0.0072706398,
-0.0532077141,
0.0204971582,
-0.029915465,
0.0257852804,
-0.0168413445,
-0.0200442336,
0.0280541368,
0.0491196625,
0.0370341875,
0.0194451585,
-0.0487984158,
0.0191406775,
0.0248524416,
-0.0515707806,
0.0295885336,
-0.0257439967,
-0.0197585449,
0.0168182608,
-0.000451318,
-0.0451383516,
0.0427407883,
-0.0168353282,
-0.0190105494,
-0.0071557909,
-0.0069734827,
-0.0133955562,
0.0582531057,
-0.003688416,
0.0164988879,
-0.0059110853,
-0.0096066045,
-0.0272339378,
0.004505265,
0.0222936869,
-0.0201918539,
0.0299987253,
-0.0335500799,
-0.0186277591,
0.0262793135,
-0.0465304479,
-0.0466056615,
-0.0252535921,
0.0021304043,
-0.0153310951,
0.0553442538,
-0.0644182414,
0.0206432343,
-0.0137824621,
0.0179086942,
0.0388377793,
-0.04293276,
-0.0307364576,
-0.0018488807,
0.026166888,
0.0547866896,
-0.0040633972,
-0.0247648768,
-0.0228159893,
0.0106356619,
0.0260856543,
-0.0020349363,
0.0162670072,
-0.0480484553,
-0.0072334502,
0.0503110625,
-0.0197317358,
-0.033101704,
-0.0127769876,
0.0505655408,
-0.0610584617,
-0.0097782062,
0.130003646,
0.0334420018,
-0.071246624,
-0.0138246529,
-0.0039958539,
0.0601157248,
0.0073872465,
0.0562737212,
-0.0401114598,
-0.0124366023,
-0.0089627858,
0.0283271447,
-0.0132641494,
0.0166275688,
0.0125726936,
-0.100531362,
0.032741446,
0.013601467,
-0.009317914,
-0.0266754013,
0.0055651497,
0.0062467097,
0.0297337752,
-0.018255448,
-0.0128006684,
0.0036579857,
-0.0183694195,
0.0202330593,
-0.0206119642,
-0.0387935005,
-0.0409979634,
-0.0138113191,
0.054613065,
0.0835183933,
0.0735525638,
0.0073566027,
-0.0616198517,
0.021736607,
-0.0000366925,
0.0312947258,
-0.020026546,
0.0437765159,
0.0052306126,
-0.0086691538,
-0.0495975129,
0.0455826856,
0.0261715092,
0.0236331988,
-0.0079178251,
0.0084551498,
-0.0532865189,
-0.0487627126,
-0.0440754369,
0.0066894558,
0.0374477543,
0.0289201494,
0.0527567901,
-0.0965628177,
-0.0547342971,
-0.0648867339,
0.016575627,
-0.0840350762,
-0.0698486567,
-0.0215707403,
-0.0210546814,
-0.0257238857,
-0.109006092,
-0.0380652435,
-0.0054812953,
0.0575757623,
0.0016438948,
-0.0395146348,
0.014678807,
-0.0100842696,
-0.0070365467,
-0.0088535985,
0.0182079747,
0.0065405923,
-0.0157068539,
-0.0525618196,
0.0329518989,
-0.0865313858,
0.0112334695,
0.0127792247,
-0.0159666501,
-0.0645917431,
0.029176211,
0.0477043316,
0.0068828748,
0.0329286791,
-0.009833849,
-0.1187497824,
0.0923301876,
0.0605327673,
0.0200960282,
0.0069080666,
0.0206628274,
0.049777966,
-0.007412422,
0.0185751263,
-0.0278326403,
0.0586438403,
0.0468133204,
0.0317684039,
-0.0050362963,
-0.0025616235,
-0.0127723338,
-0.0092500085,
0.0183297396,
-0.0398607738,
0.0011890915,
-0.0454131179,
-0.013369225,
-0.0270932987,
-0.0315915979,
-0.0587998293,
-0.0078220917,
-0.0025140676,
0.0165194683,
-0.050105691,
0.0089682909,
0.0239790026,
0.0202159937,
-0.0587061867,
0.0300193708,
0.0145263989,
0.052518215,
0.0129509782,
0.0349715091,
-0.0323350728,
0.0811841786,
-0.0203043222,
0.0166076124,
0.0052236142,
0.0530338772,
0.0321130604,
-0.0084521482,
-0.0228283312,
0.0459124707,
-0.0406948105,
-0.0183066968,
-0.0213077366,
0.0223239306,
0.0385181159,
0.0000894773,
0.082353957,
-0.0355930068,
0.0098223053,
-0.0055819284,
0.0214960929,
0.0304527637,
-0.0444798619,
0.0004804751,
-0.0073179854,
-0.016619835,
-0.0408891067,
0.0529066026,
-0.026018789,
0.0391793326,
-0.0079972455,
0.0083904434,
-0.0204067882,
-0.008963827,
0.0622783676,
-0.0058700237,
0.0195935946,
0.0143879885,
-0.0291659683,
-0.0412400961,
0.0343590751,
0.0020126132,
0.0102923065,
-0.0293496083,
0.038289547,
0.0437590033,
0.0015592854,
-0.0031726994,
-0.0510243289,
0.0134420404,
-0.0633417219,
-0.0172152147,
-0.030239271,
-5.713949837e-33,
-0.0226446912,
-0.03563587,
-0.0160456635,
0.0573992357,
-0.0438620374,
-0.0119898636,
-0.0483316444,
0.025358215,
0.0285370219,
0.0552227572,
-0.0321315974,
-0.0049826629,
-0.0019936888,
0.0487143323,
0.0220854077,
0.0146109052,
0.0625858679,
-0.0009500791,
-0.0363021642,
0.0505651422,
0.0481233336,
0.0006677143,
0.0244816728,
-0.0841290653,
0.0022378431,
-0.0313059948,
-0.0341831073,
0.0073999334,
0.0178368185,
0.03599995,
-0.0138709228,
0.0319274142,
0.0076459809,
-0.039919924,
-0.0029534949,
0.027724525,
0.0020540331,
-0.0299803149,
-0.0159583651,
0.0201064125,
-0.0373572037,
-0.0527289063,
0.0494707264,
0.0132346787,
-0.0272181965,
0.0251722261,
0.040502537,
0.0039748489,
0.0010357534,
-0.1381399184,
-0.0849304497,
0.0241307132,
-0.0141768008,
-0.0310715213,
0.0050436174,
-0.0041703964,
-0.0059475354,
0.0012493491,
-0.0699006468,
0.0057280757,
-0.0104386061,
0.01919684,
0.0163593777,
0.079451561,
0.0075510507,
0.0558695607,
0.0308798086,
0.0649861544,
-0.0917828307,
0.0300400313,
0.0404000431,
0.0082849227,
0.0059538628,
0.0507362522,
-0.003668241,
-0.0134283686,
0.0142862163,
0.0252926145,
0.0550719611,
-0.0273309425,
0.0487854294,
0.0260352232,
-0.0108104749,
-0.004579342,
-0.049513083,
-0.0236707758,
-0.0263206884,
-0.0090746777,
-0.0000629633,
0.0221672207,
-0.0028659764,
-0.0413020849,
-0.0015422503,
0.0275300853,
-0.0263163783,
0.0114110364,
-0.071976535,
0.0742136165,
-0.0109097902,
-0.0365989655,
-0.0049684434,
-0.0087802,
0.021588495,
0.0079620294,
0.003660321,
0.0185210761,
0.0316440091,
0.0596410632,
-0.0667253733,
0.0033379672,
-0.0241806824,
0.0195397157,
0.0239206459,
-0.0260648821,
0.0095280772,
-0.0240040533,
-0.034996178,
0.0272285696,
-0.0075045642,
0.0479051247,
0.0024066388,
-0.0395450667,
0.0022018172,
0.0097350599,
-0.082019113,
-0.0037351237,
-0.0271917563,
0.0124358814,
-0.0002371079,
-0.067801483,
-0.0155954268,
0.0070369295,
2.494e-7,
-0.0055462406,
0.0585142337,
0.0028117888,
0.0670714155,
0.0303935148,
0.0474737845,
0.0428462662,
0.0135700684,
0.02585195,
0.0305097271,
0.0060185329,
0.0199065208,
0.0544607416,
-0.0056410632,
-0.1055639461,
-0.0080842813,
-0.0429526195,
0.0602377392,
-0.0320439674,
-0.0039111101,
0.0708664954,
0.0389364064,
0.0164844226,
-0.0076359226,
0.0539027043,
-0.0190335102,
0.0646503717,
-0.0090128751,
0.0357671939,
0.018388547,
0.0238971617,
-0.0313897468,
-0.0254833605,
-0.0293741859,
-0.0098279919,
-0.0289168544,
-0.0197718088,
0.063553676,
0.0117221484,
-0.0128092067,
0.0069115069,
0.0218662508,
0.0242380444,
-0.0390839465,
0.0432283916,
-0.0001667912,
-0.0211542193,
-0.0544053428,
0.0243352223,
-0.0268078595,
0.0081149517,
-0.0566180944,
-0.0309996735,
0.0216584913,
0.0094888629,
-0.0187369119,
-0.0279279165,
-0.0769380629,
-0.0573228076,
-0.035510134,
-0.029905593,
-0.0203776099,
-0.0530003272,
0.0515461937,
-0.0032512196,
-0.0066318493,
0.0136316018,
2.068268305e-34,
0.0246912204,
-0.0372520946,
-0.0065057804,
0.0359936394,
0.044543691,
0.0428833067,
0.0210872497,
0.0092544677,
0.0533942766,
-0.1056307629,
-0.0102176219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01613v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01613v1 | Nomic Embed: Training a Reproducible Long Context Text Embedder | 2024-02-02T18:23:18 | 2024-02-02T18:23:18 | Zach Nussbaum, John X. Morris, Brandon Duderstadt, Andriy Mulyar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This technical report describes the training of nomic-embed-text-v1, the
first fully reproducible, open-source, open-weights, open-data, 8192 context
length English text embedding model that outperforms both OpenAI Ada-002 and
OpenAI text-embedding-3-small on short and long-context tasks. We release the
training code and model weights under an Apache 2 license. In contrast with
other open-source models, we release a training data loader with 235 million
curated text pairs that allows for the full replication of nomic-embed-text-v1.
You can find code and data to replicate the model at
https://github.com/nomic-ai/contrastors | [
-0.0287391469,
0.0207973439,
0.0171902087,
0.0802318677,
-0.034917593,
-0.0157953482,
0.0354989842,
-0.00834045,
0.0071267718,
-0.0168973599,
-0.0209429283,
-0.0096223019,
0.02279591,
0.01654974,
0.0477149487,
-0.0620042421,
0.0040856814,
-0.00399923,
-0.0168455634,
0.0113050435,
0.0135878706,
-0.0051891459,
0.0206305534,
0.0266557112,
-0.0156869888,
-0.0302507542,
-0.0207844079,
-0.0052759675,
0.0582018793,
-0.0483367555,
0.0131275039,
0.016232226,
0.0565946922,
-0.0091268383,
0.0000017906,
-0.018765701,
0.0047948821,
0.0211185832,
-0.0027559854,
-0.017281279,
0.0598921701,
-0.0477061085,
-0.0004733885,
0.0362763368,
-0.0036957618,
0.008116168,
0.0187924877,
0.0543395616,
0.0196734127,
0.0678324774,
-0.0072067375,
-0.0441131257,
0.0439369828,
-0.0676735565,
0.0116295777,
-0.0008826577,
0.0208350606,
-0.0441850722,
0.0131078344,
0.0573402122,
-0.0551071391,
0.0139159933,
0.0728745684,
0.0093373172,
0.0208989941,
0.0638132766,
-0.037166182,
0.0357654542,
0.007512352,
0.1268729866,
0.0278555918,
0.0201054104,
-0.0118050091,
0.005699323,
-0.0298562534,
-0.0694515258,
-0.0073499493,
0.020676814,
0.0084659709,
0.0535143316,
0.0269280914,
0.0295538642,
0.0255897585,
0.0022168013,
-0.0092755798,
-0.0122524891,
0.0027730698,
-0.0536440499,
-0.0193912424,
-0.0231936406,
-0.0414700061,
-0.0056796153,
0.0344159827,
0.0226727799,
0.010425915,
0.0225401148,
-0.0593016669,
-0.0792237967,
0.0423371047,
-0.0434173271,
-0.013931198,
0.035614036,
-0.0513760149,
0.0567864329,
-0.0551103391,
0.0284946542,
-0.0240940321,
-0.006383785,
-0.0244810581,
-0.0440502241,
-0.012071508,
0.0129956277,
-0.0273045413,
-0.0029747221,
-0.0824515596,
-0.0704656169,
-0.0168102402,
0.0100802844,
-0.0061221044,
0.039429076,
0.0246464759,
0.0217611864,
-0.0298924986,
-0.0005438633,
0.0093139941,
0.0100173661,
-0.044971358,
0.0079590306,
-0.0168692376,
-0.0198142845,
-0.0166992471,
0.038584061,
0.0269723684,
-0.0473357625,
-0.0132640498,
0.0374391526,
-0.0126069114,
-0.0564927123,
-0.0424161367,
0.0008787004,
-0.043456912,
-0.0213338472,
-0.0574337803,
-0.0626179427,
0.0071334406,
-0.0316152088,
0.0120553207,
-0.0203832127,
0.0112292506,
0.0330987945,
-0.0252189226,
0.0784425959,
0.0062132836,
-0.0601552352,
0.0155439703,
0.0345353708,
0.0351984762,
0.0568730645,
0.0121255806,
-0.0077162376,
0.0473335609,
0.0308155902,
-0.0340670571,
-0.0046118484,
0.0224467237,
0.0073975334,
-0.0217401963,
0.0280154794,
0.0360670798,
0.0686173216,
0.058393117,
0.079529658,
-0.0131246289,
-0.0531882904,
0.0161972698,
0.0380826294,
0.0887786001,
0.0025565338,
0.0667339712,
0.0104754185,
-0.0400426909,
-0.00898025,
-0.0181263983,
0.0004088969,
-0.0048184753,
0.0279500075,
0.0660662949,
0.0314445421,
-0.0412245877,
-0.0092508281,
0.002026052,
-0.0741143227,
0.0185899884,
-0.0235022511,
0.0400217548,
-0.0120029338,
-0.0713432133,
-0.0186266489,
0.014321208,
-0.0148081277,
0.022314731,
0.0118479626,
0.0426994748,
0.0855445638,
0.0272250157,
-0.0448770374,
0.0312865004,
-0.0363926254,
0.0169923194,
0.059659224,
-0.0260542352,
-0.0198786631,
0.050309144,
-0.0819664076,
-0.0071103689,
-0.023939522,
0.0120619722,
0.0123860603,
0.0031328008,
0.0801869929,
0.0586497411,
0.0085634114,
0.0139386598,
0.0391008593,
-0.0466320775,
-0.0493061543,
0.0009935696,
0.0096033411,
0.0078787059,
0.0439686663,
-0.0121773183,
0.0101731615,
0.0332115814,
-0.0804449394,
-0.0311290901,
-0.0150963645,
-0.0749655217,
-0.0778671727,
0.0358777456,
-0.0430639461,
0.0149056269,
0.0327337757,
-0.0369338579,
-0.0412865207,
-0.006616639,
0.0233631358,
0.0239540692,
-0.0203624032,
-0.0310858171,
0.0144508155,
0.0257898886,
-0.0060196877,
0.0653135404,
-0.0016142939,
-0.0003215907,
0.0399220251,
0.053482186,
0.0101436935,
-0.0409990177,
-0.0314668752,
-0.0219560824,
0.0205799434,
-0.0009444355,
-0.0348385312,
-0.0105673447,
-0.0432525128,
-0.0154379187,
-0.1040510535,
0.0141871758,
-0.0184535086,
-0.0157030988,
0.0165188201,
0.000457652,
0.0078527089,
0.0024849707,
-0.0326001272,
0.0025146622,
-0.0287394989,
0.0056298561,
0.0224177763,
0.0032727711,
0.0144966953,
-0.0445698574,
-0.0034826971,
-0.0167491883,
0.0504810996,
-0.0271066241,
0.0073240125,
-0.0357767567,
0.0266360845,
0.0227925126,
0.0107504353,
-0.0242762044,
-0.0162222367,
-0.0163595602,
0.004647613,
0.0744434223,
0.0545021109,
0.0279384218,
0.0115309171,
0.0067606336,
0.0252157897,
-0.020491261,
0.0170141011,
0.0113523426,
0.040189825,
-0.0241102539,
0.002374704,
-0.0233299062,
0.0510320328,
-0.0002570864,
-0.0111463089,
-0.0608864799,
-0.029752899,
-0.0184840746,
0.0092532001,
-0.0066968226,
-0.0234639943,
-0.0378037579,
-0.0127318278,
-0.0401395857,
-0.0121309068,
0.0541989356,
-0.0371770896,
-0.0029066824,
-0.0470467545,
-0.0432654545,
-0.0693441108,
0.0307015013,
-0.0194540508,
0.0168931484,
0.0189194381,
0.0141627528,
-0.0030680532,
-0.0130304368,
-0.0186235365,
0.0018993914,
0.0535474867,
0.0131314779,
-0.0089128921,
-0.0144870086,
-0.0593608133,
-0.0272238888,
-0.0477050059,
-0.0438346975,
0.0390172154,
0.0364942439,
-0.0007837591,
0.0118195228,
-0.0308562219,
0.0093939006,
0.088248536,
-0.0030566277,
0.0031863991,
-0.0189345963,
0.0488364473,
0.0270181354,
0.0059516174,
-0.0259991642,
-0.0181778427,
0.0459351391,
0.0272069909,
0.0036236483,
-0.0250761174,
-0.0619551763,
-0.0175225288,
-0.0309131034,
-0.0178876519,
-0.0084428908,
0.0063649304,
0.0325036496,
-0.033379361,
-0.0022611395,
0.0991939977,
0.0130993081,
-0.090228267,
0.0024338779,
-0.0514736511,
0.0176417809,
0.0011823404,
-0.0114695877,
-0.1040164679,
-0.0661316961,
-0.0139017487,
0.010059284,
0.0445713848,
-0.0184027459,
0.0062873554,
-0.0750171915,
-0.0249735322,
0.0218250938,
-0.0410438888,
-0.0328923538,
-0.0534510277,
-0.0007087827,
-0.0311424676,
0.0097784279,
-0.0023518093,
-0.0098511847,
-0.0199143831,
-0.0112004001,
0.0200923905,
-0.066830948,
0.0073254826,
-0.062094897,
0.0531199872,
0.0321837477,
0.0256512053,
0.007389856,
-0.0129374806,
0.0290465318,
-0.0647554845,
0.0066874856,
-0.0264649168,
0.1036298424,
-0.0483219996,
0.0361406915,
-0.0278115589,
0.0374632813,
-0.040084254,
-0.0082459031,
0.0332040526,
0.0758874863,
0.0450394452,
0.0142906168,
-0.0421459451,
-0.0207806081,
0.053831473,
0.0581033826,
0.0042245248,
-0.0299206264,
-0.0280315075,
-0.0214625336,
0.0183088426,
-0.0376615264,
-0.0110366018,
-0.0400944687,
-0.0059825722,
0.0098857982,
-0.0543842651,
-0.061623618,
0.0172484647,
0.0325283743,
0.0014726245,
0.0000627276,
-0.0562797375,
-0.0277671814,
-0.0389991254,
0.0043580956,
-0.0118934978,
0.0524364524,
-0.0454313084,
0.0391254723,
0.0527650416,
-0.0048203343,
0.0120388605,
-0.0069771339,
-0.029549202,
-0.0445624106,
-0.0182346795,
0.0375954285,
0.0058571072,
0.0518229157,
-0.0068779308,
-0.0012585354,
0.084766373,
-0.0001392335,
-0.0101163862,
0.0196002498,
0.0436417609,
0.011999486,
0.0139181074,
0.0375204161,
-0.0291176327,
0.00063359,
-0.003481352,
-0.0056282082,
-0.012307493,
-0.0018714757,
-0.0242666565,
-0.0766442418,
0.0064769024,
-0.0019099695,
0.0080843568,
-0.0476386212,
0.0336822756,
-0.0383442864,
-0.0030297977,
-0.0314187631,
0.046730645,
0.0513405539,
-0.0119428802,
0.009033123,
0.0224147383,
-0.0010688021,
0.0187975466,
-0.0201079603,
0.0613181032,
0.0489550196,
0.0293751247,
0.0071393936,
0.0302886721,
-0.0245716944,
-0.0243904497,
-0.0484151356,
0.0514337234,
-0.0147603974,
0.0333686024,
0.0158310588,
-0.0063466434,
-0.0017126751,
0.0291277282,
-0.040390037,
0.0476638749,
-0.0218004268,
-0.0024872131,
0.0576692149,
-0.0152814006,
0.0221378691,
0.0022437933,
0.0013661878,
-0.0169502664,
0.0382114425,
-0.0424521826,
-0.024644509,
0.0114257541,
0.0362129956,
-0.0001646929,
0.0267059691,
0.0928751156,
-0.0139672561,
0.0300573613,
0.045000121,
0.01307269,
-0.0363461263,
0.0164632369,
0.0328397043,
0.0721296147,
-0.0355380438,
-0.0041355095,
0.007206507,
-0.0645106807,
0.0338879414,
-0.0188971125,
-0.034708444,
0.0151910111,
0.0240015164,
0.0066518546,
0.0067297365,
-0.0094022006,
-0.0104754101,
0.0288363602,
-0.0242457539,
-0.0607362948,
-0.0365435444,
-5.739131865e-33,
-0.0024602253,
-0.0140153272,
0.0069063166,
-0.0635247454,
-0.058149308,
0.0613774918,
-0.0416084044,
-0.011492894,
-0.0236303378,
0.0151291396,
-0.0146923494,
0.0184229966,
-0.0051679886,
0.0585247725,
-0.0233163517,
-0.0210604481,
0.0307282582,
0.0145751415,
0.0138404788,
0.0218413193,
0.0189871583,
0.0330503434,
-0.0200501811,
-0.0562999956,
0.0364655778,
0.0143538546,
0.0143138794,
0.0123289693,
0.0358010121,
0.0745422766,
-0.0430030152,
0.0442760624,
0.0242837444,
-0.0363214053,
-0.0250317324,
0.0575898252,
-0.0903557315,
0.0038899309,
-0.0336994939,
-0.0400838628,
-0.0771853626,
-0.0622909255,
0.01959466,
-0.0054547628,
0.0234693214,
-0.0288235489,
0.0596922897,
-0.0253090095,
-0.0241820533,
0.0229323525,
-0.0520363562,
0.0399602763,
-0.001928219,
0.0003451587,
0.0359232426,
-0.0058266502,
0.0523994491,
0.0530455336,
-0.0878925622,
-0.0218380392,
-0.0214892272,
0.0152557734,
0.0050363536,
0.0059918175,
0.0045374464,
0.030082671,
-0.019151004,
-0.0037617758,
-0.0322570913,
-0.0365084484,
-0.0083962968,
0.0088050794,
0.0467118397,
0.0607904308,
0.0479932427,
-0.0145254228,
-0.0488371737,
0.0143947201,
-0.0015903569,
0.0022064787,
0.0099718357,
0.0308047514,
-0.0356472991,
-0.015488538,
0.0062685423,
-0.047815863,
-0.0223782416,
-0.0556127317,
0.0164436027,
0.0476736166,
-0.0180096216,
-0.0071759694,
0.0288550835,
-0.0209990293,
0.0035182571,
0.0523896664,
0.0271514319,
0.0180134978,
0.0206295699,
0.0246402826,
-0.0644121766,
-0.0049370131,
0.049810946,
0.0436376557,
0.0168330949,
-0.0113856653,
0.0578997694,
0.0228003822,
-0.0641535223,
-0.0062504318,
-0.0183294863,
-0.0254826974,
-0.0162638798,
0.0430877842,
0.0113903088,
0.0018624393,
-0.0043963031,
0.067133829,
0.0187398214,
0.0032898209,
-0.018377427,
-0.0495597906,
-0.0135810422,
0.0008177143,
-0.015638046,
-0.0002126618,
-0.0257615205,
0.0537747033,
0.0503848121,
-0.063519977,
-0.0017889685,
0.0112197166,
2.29e-7,
0.0033256512,
-0.0105091892,
0.0544324331,
-0.0443102196,
0.0282181259,
0.0310611613,
0.0091719152,
0.0738166273,
-0.0443704873,
0.0144821359,
0.0077010705,
0.0291463323,
0.0229880624,
-0.0075290105,
-0.0882340446,
0.0240979437,
-0.048589848,
0.004375678,
-0.0417792164,
0.0023889476,
0.060043674,
0.1218595728,
0.0134260952,
0.0326234549,
0.0160054006,
-0.040667735,
0.0483186543,
-0.0132645164,
0.0418327339,
-0.0308822747,
-0.0476731174,
0.0254254621,
-0.0388356261,
-0.0447736755,
-0.0197798107,
0.0426396169,
-0.0207586065,
0.0737477094,
0.0222311765,
-0.0520897657,
0.0225913655,
0.0103029534,
-0.0336654708,
-0.0233864486,
0.0716367885,
-0.039225556,
-0.0278188344,
-0.0026761335,
-0.0074869459,
-0.0116118332,
0.0303672552,
0.0210572146,
-0.0220862646,
-0.0081715658,
0.0073215836,
-0.0232180431,
-0.0028090731,
-0.1031137854,
-0.0298041068,
-0.0101317102,
-0.0621484928,
0.0206660964,
-0.0514777377,
0.0148205934,
0.0546021834,
-0.0486274771,
0.0347148515,
2.181354995e-34,
0.0262917411,
-0.0322065763,
-0.0105382856,
0.0363023207,
0.0187550876,
-0.0380798094,
-0.0112238713,
-0.0447751954,
0.0625484139,
-0.0650375858,
-0.0351265036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01828v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01828v1 | Retrieval Augmented End-to-End Spoken Dialog Models | 2024-02-02T18:23:09 | 2024-02-02T18:23:09 | Mingqiu Wang, Izhak Shafran, Hagen Soltau, Wei Han, Yuan Cao, Dian Yu, Laurent El Shafey | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | We recently developed SLM, a joint speech and language model, which fuses a
pretrained foundational speech model and a large language model (LLM), while
preserving the in-context learning capability intrinsic to the pretrained LLM.
In this paper, we apply SLM to speech dialog applications where the dialog
states are inferred directly from the audio signal.
Task-oriented dialogs often contain domain-specific entities, i.e.,
restaurants, hotels, train stations, and city names, which are difficult to
recognize, however, critical for the downstream applications. Inspired by the
RAG (retrieval-augmented generation) paradigm, we propose a retrieval augmented
SLM (ReSLM) that overcomes this weakness. We first train a speech retriever to
retrieve text entities mentioned in the audio. The retrieved entities are then
added as text inputs to the underlying SLM to bias model predictions. We
evaluated ReSLM on speech MultiWoz task (DSTC-11 challenge), and found that
this retrieval augmentation boosts model performance, achieving joint goal
accuracy (38.6% vs 32.7%), slot error rate (20.6% vs 24.8%) and ASR word error
rate (5.5% vs 6.7%). While demonstrated on dialog state tracking, our approach
is broadly applicable to other speech tasks requiring contextual information or
domain-specific entities, such as contextual ASR with biasing capability. | [
0.0097549008,
0.0700295568,
0.0159913003,
0.0522064082,
0.0178400986,
-0.0235948544,
0.0150897764,
-0.022314528,
0.0188361071,
-0.0673104972,
-0.0646581054,
-0.0460148454,
-0.0347727984,
0.0337721109,
0.0169574283,
-0.031503398,
0.0497836992,
-0.0515900552,
0.0005919592,
0.0176496375,
0.032708101,
0.0070226807,
-0.0222285874,
0.0382378772,
-0.0261195991,
0.0185229871,
-0.0240412075,
0.0374674946,
0.0114537571,
-0.0330721699,
0.0223399214,
-0.0055560735,
0.0707647875,
0.0243572779,
0.0000018695,
-0.0544903986,
-0.0363881066,
0.0126503278,
-0.0691511035,
-0.0279169474,
-0.002219388,
0.0169947334,
-0.0005749485,
0.0536271371,
0.0113184666,
-0.0255535077,
-0.001156091,
0.0648274571,
0.0411664173,
0.0848931447,
-0.0036543775,
-0.0282138232,
0.0230863858,
-0.0420428254,
-0.0061552497,
-0.0578316115,
-0.0119991917,
-0.0252154078,
-0.0271587595,
0.0474022329,
0.0312036164,
0.0375754312,
0.0039368123,
0.0035059173,
-0.0118502965,
0.0010411211,
-0.0416258164,
-0.0004798253,
-0.0317037739,
0.0684586167,
0.0302059259,
-0.0063048578,
0.0321335867,
0.0122741433,
-0.0176680665,
-0.0262987707,
-0.0426804461,
-0.0000880195,
-0.0013840356,
0.0178584103,
-0.036951568,
0.0193612594,
0.0129253715,
0.0113713406,
-0.0380248539,
0.0314288549,
0.0143201454,
-0.0308706723,
-0.0105194263,
-0.0139757162,
-0.0022755617,
-0.0355655812,
0.0183231365,
0.0190989859,
-0.0819579288,
0.0316938832,
-0.0172660649,
-0.0033528914,
-0.000794122,
-0.0108727217,
0.0151234735,
0.029409945,
-0.074289754,
0.0414342657,
0.0058818734,
0.033390671,
-0.0173788331,
-0.0202837493,
-0.032234218,
-0.0254647154,
-0.0167924203,
0.0070907939,
-0.0501860082,
0.0296450816,
-0.0693758801,
-0.034686055,
-0.0046780226,
0.0115224971,
-0.0099418908,
0.0014657422,
-0.0065822648,
0.0412962101,
-0.0552511588,
-0.0312695019,
-0.0087257316,
0.0307915006,
0.0029892076,
0.05802821,
0.0313837789,
-0.023896303,
-0.0253913552,
0.0256422795,
0.0481828153,
-0.0162950717,
0.0069318623,
0.050798215,
-0.0316882618,
-0.0449320078,
-0.0365969092,
-0.0328344926,
-0.0275286026,
-0.0716077387,
-0.0151911955,
-0.0245031044,
0.0308520086,
-0.0187649969,
-0.0184282325,
-0.0250389632,
0.0288716331,
0.0039108517,
0.0175228715,
0.0333262719,
-0.0020700383,
0.0012262693,
0.0573447905,
0.0078189,
0.0024320793,
0.0462259725,
0.0238443892,
0.0345036201,
0.0264632069,
0.0072770482,
-0.0003339932,
0.0331339948,
0.0418215878,
0.013733183,
-0.0120021636,
0.0278197173,
-0.013094021,
-0.0047267047,
0.0176760666,
0.0608610101,
-0.0438617468,
0.0120206065,
0.0441221409,
0.0449057631,
0.0649607033,
-0.0168413687,
-0.0010401165,
0.0353179686,
-0.027098557,
-0.0271063857,
-0.0195419248,
-0.0049012285,
-0.0238192659,
0.0210510343,
0.0760254934,
0.0213962533,
-0.0179039873,
-0.02632921,
0.0211427845,
-0.0107604777,
-0.003906013,
0.0604972951,
0.0563286059,
0.0205407646,
-0.0856274962,
0.0430614725,
-0.0114887059,
-0.0617027804,
-0.0018582676,
-0.0450639538,
0.0058222129,
0.0484628603,
0.0318361185,
-0.029328268,
-0.0215514526,
-0.0391450413,
-0.0026030955,
0.0436344072,
0.0114036044,
0.0026768749,
0.0643811375,
-0.0628417432,
-0.0185355674,
0.0346367881,
0.0139957238,
0.0548507608,
0.014835285,
0.0134385489,
0.0627145395,
0.0174949709,
0.0261872318,
-0.0290140044,
0.0128057478,
-0.0252047181,
0.0132066896,
0.0039189216,
0.0413041413,
0.0490720794,
-0.0436080731,
-0.0072312276,
0.0489924029,
-0.0137245199,
-0.0039994107,
0.0341652781,
-0.0856766924,
-0.0375088565,
0.0198514126,
0.0496630818,
0.031492684,
0.0118989209,
-0.0063305455,
-0.0863590762,
0.0180073027,
-0.032659784,
0.052559521,
-0.0707221553,
0.0322932936,
0.050450284,
0.0069626393,
-0.0255291574,
0.0183271002,
0.0358811244,
-0.0067472304,
0.0339797735,
0.0436532013,
0.004990072,
-0.0837879106,
-0.0131005459,
0.003621985,
-0.0130639663,
0.0489658974,
0.036043223,
-0.0312338471,
-0.0442562923,
-0.0238072313,
-0.1070961878,
0.0196734425,
-0.0303282365,
-0.0042051221,
-0.0226634592,
0.0143103199,
-0.0060502444,
-0.0439157821,
-0.0094910515,
-0.0468732528,
0.0574139319,
-0.0256036986,
-0.0380643345,
0.0524823852,
-0.0145271625,
-0.0645775199,
0.0365469828,
0.0256958697,
-0.0022980603,
-0.02942116,
-0.0053886417,
-0.0534881726,
0.0368157737,
-0.0082678488,
0.0477328077,
-0.0418327041,
-0.0084715057,
-0.0013661559,
-0.0090177543,
0.0074836123,
0.041920349,
0.0261777192,
0.0040910984,
-0.0158818737,
-0.0556961074,
-0.0942835957,
0.0493123531,
0.0034193019,
-0.0010536899,
-0.026350962,
0.0431861393,
0.0277055521,
0.0240682811,
0.0103808576,
0.0223251749,
0.007003969,
-0.02415484,
0.0197480731,
-0.0343791619,
-0.0318333954,
-0.0427915379,
-0.0607371852,
0.0599054396,
-0.0121687958,
-0.028739335,
0.0202621594,
-0.0826734677,
-0.0271806084,
-0.0377461091,
-0.0406529978,
-0.0422280207,
0.0421120711,
-0.0320792496,
0.0163754784,
0.0035949852,
-0.0557000116,
-0.0091045266,
0.0033179622,
-0.0107655581,
-0.0761768594,
0.0863624662,
0.0011696768,
0.0161876138,
0.0012779715,
-0.0665296391,
-0.061238315,
-0.0079187611,
-0.0189794134,
-0.0176219381,
-0.0156158134,
-0.0073587094,
-0.0388218425,
0.0077665593,
0.022074718,
0.0477540344,
0.0125336424,
0.0081652477,
-0.0261231419,
0.0362157449,
0.0679504499,
0.055269327,
-0.0367860869,
-0.0045917537,
0.0353205241,
0.0187469628,
0.0561258309,
-0.0286889933,
-0.0261017364,
-0.017158797,
0.0414260477,
0.0138601009,
-0.0144385733,
0.031484738,
0.0390033759,
-0.0719040185,
-0.0253790934,
0.0950064287,
0.0131565006,
-0.0074101198,
-0.0622185729,
0.0007224791,
0.0067772684,
0.0321240984,
0.0207433179,
-0.0641620606,
-0.054994531,
0.0570055768,
0.0343443491,
0.0138283772,
0.0263246354,
-0.0000041505,
-0.1073661447,
0.0458126962,
0.020814484,
-0.0440961719,
-0.041061081,
-0.0245582592,
0.0001737973,
0.0265079215,
0.0435269028,
0.0381616019,
-0.0239099506,
-0.0229197331,
0.0346828252,
0.0005470405,
-0.0156019134,
0.0081416219,
-0.0341016427,
0.0702531189,
0.0730654076,
0.0217379145,
0.0211585686,
0.001927322,
0.0237716604,
-0.0029123556,
0.0155541478,
0.0134727526,
0.0393586159,
-0.0399068072,
-0.0166394468,
-0.0146746468,
0.033007741,
0.0126473932,
-0.0117314002,
0.0154394666,
0.0079436842,
-0.0389544182,
0.0422050767,
-0.0106732594,
0.0027782847,
0.0252819099,
0.0428887941,
0.0072323638,
-0.0064504035,
-0.0068619139,
-0.0022307488,
0.0124680996,
-0.0236675553,
0.0008170399,
-0.0038754069,
0.00405927,
0.0110538686,
-0.0399756357,
-0.0308255516,
-0.0183983091,
0.03900069,
0.0137478849,
0.0185124353,
-0.011587793,
0.0027541451,
-0.0426317155,
0.0394830145,
-0.0450822264,
0.0269383714,
-0.0677710697,
0.0030700408,
0.0668228269,
-0.0764628798,
-0.0344558544,
0.053275872,
-0.0613639094,
-0.0582160875,
-0.026156202,
0.0396352857,
0.0179447886,
0.080486767,
-0.0058355103,
-0.0212270953,
0.0394827388,
0.0024877477,
-0.0730022788,
-0.0035541861,
0.0551079102,
0.0303726867,
-0.0396051519,
0.0133141596,
-0.0868973061,
0.0509070903,
-0.0374696776,
0.0366723165,
-0.0286545437,
-0.0676304847,
-0.0203657635,
0.0083122682,
0.0713934302,
0.0233677514,
0.0042100362,
-0.0597588681,
0.0779898167,
0.0002779917,
0.0119337635,
-0.0488364995,
0.000017121,
0.0078893211,
-0.0218372606,
0.0070373365,
-0.007492838,
-0.0189988781,
0.039330069,
-0.0224031247,
0.0034591218,
0.0071367305,
-0.0080579054,
0.0147571275,
0.0054533822,
-0.0097244978,
0.0540235005,
0.0420300998,
0.0464789793,
-0.0187600274,
0.0738568082,
-0.0067070923,
-0.0146367019,
-0.0025225398,
0.0060688234,
-0.0548456982,
-0.0402486771,
-0.0328199752,
0.0402862057,
0.0229532309,
-0.0093004387,
0.054300569,
0.0086217104,
0.0228845682,
-0.0411039591,
0.0362394266,
-0.0110724531,
-0.0448967479,
0.0353069603,
0.0164131578,
-0.0164076146,
0.0432896614,
0.0305364802,
0.0223039631,
0.0282068569,
-0.0167468302,
0.0122141279,
-0.0452791713,
-0.0608732142,
0.0084080789,
0.0471379571,
-0.0200494248,
-0.015054238,
-0.0137774004,
-0.0700953677,
0.0251675192,
-0.0066084825,
-0.0223423913,
-0.0330238529,
0.0213397481,
0.0258581322,
-0.012264587,
-0.0078376373,
-0.0056079952,
-0.0408974998,
-0.0258262064,
-0.0142762782,
0.011396992,
-5.952675842e-33,
-0.050942339,
-0.01132409,
0.0464155599,
-0.033278551,
-0.0441165939,
-0.0039015869,
-0.0388926454,
0.0098078884,
-0.0095797377,
-0.0432382189,
-0.0124813644,
0.0221576001,
0.021718014,
0.0656038523,
-0.0378743671,
-0.0109600248,
0.0887172446,
0.0010309973,
0.0026926303,
0.0056427391,
0.043252375,
0.0590247251,
0.0121627254,
-0.0636213049,
-0.0085468236,
-0.021366993,
0.0059284153,
0.0015885298,
0.0114349611,
0.0437738597,
0.0050131776,
0.0357518941,
-0.020122584,
-0.0486439653,
-0.0139107546,
0.042632021,
-0.0743323341,
0.0055643828,
0.011118344,
0.0144609064,
0.0167699642,
0.0047110501,
0.0018022622,
-0.0024512529,
0.0148946214,
0.0171062723,
0.0052481452,
-0.0040928596,
-0.0232369155,
-0.0121609606,
-0.0212518405,
0.0179889407,
0.0000150153,
-0.0516759716,
0.0300636962,
0.0511424057,
0.0478713773,
-0.0099602668,
-0.0444101691,
0.0022541645,
-0.003124027,
0.0072053717,
0.0260949563,
0.0581800342,
-0.0184593257,
0.0654062927,
0.0374724865,
-0.0292205121,
-0.0290062837,
-0.0738713667,
0.0140271131,
0.0618454628,
-0.0397115052,
0.0429731049,
0.007346346,
-0.0191204194,
-0.0234276839,
0.0202140845,
0.0102575077,
0.0303491615,
0.0156175867,
0.0294389054,
-0.0403740257,
0.0073382999,
-0.0552702323,
0.0083110984,
-0.0341279805,
-0.0276536178,
0.0907152593,
0.0859324113,
0.001175011,
0.0092070969,
0.0747412294,
0.0015030294,
-0.00034934,
0.0269598272,
-0.0208350625,
-0.0348065831,
-0.0497899465,
0.0588097721,
-0.0479876213,
-0.0350423194,
0.0797816738,
0.0278417971,
-0.0209038872,
-0.0276425332,
-0.0278602075,
0.0198589955,
-0.0705331117,
0.0380320996,
-0.0292326361,
0.0571063831,
-0.0298909377,
0.0259131044,
0.0404234678,
-0.0062669413,
-0.0138984807,
0.0854230002,
-0.0121981101,
0.0016902164,
-0.0462929308,
-0.0655728281,
0.0134986341,
0.0004431136,
-0.0347378701,
0.0392301828,
0.0260184277,
-0.0361651406,
0.0153741241,
-0.021974057,
0.0082088746,
-0.0035378432,
2.71e-7,
-0.0252931062,
0.0033678268,
0.0347339548,
-0.0046735052,
0.0009944078,
0.0377480388,
-0.0161710419,
0.0087026376,
0.0439868905,
0.0084706247,
-0.0072789504,
0.0044424622,
0.0697436631,
0.0135717532,
-0.1069470048,
-0.0156777669,
-0.0618038699,
0.0197358951,
-0.032259807,
-0.0403519124,
0.0252762437,
0.0925170034,
-0.023822384,
-0.0202914756,
0.0239285473,
-0.0474084057,
0.059282396,
-0.0259982422,
-0.0121315271,
-0.0006484933,
-0.0018449435,
0.0473619029,
-0.0301681012,
-0.0358625092,
-0.0196767338,
0.0611060299,
0.0038713755,
0.0690205842,
0.0100635495,
-0.0911520123,
-0.0134152155,
0.0493590832,
0.0070721172,
-0.0168416128,
0.0506288819,
-0.0217413045,
0.0132174054,
-0.0445749275,
-0.0638103262,
-0.0306032524,
-0.0199858211,
0.0030919518,
0.0040873112,
-0.0020359536,
0.0047788494,
0.0048239338,
0.0068201469,
-0.133180216,
-0.0234061424,
-0.0054590628,
-0.064876169,
-0.0178766679,
-0.048650939,
-0.0112257767,
-0.0144830113,
-0.0308765378,
-0.0065756761,
2.1631082e-34,
0.0352605842,
-0.0078221895,
0.0057779709,
0.0503623597,
0.0398076661,
-0.0225605406,
-0.0352197476,
0.0074477601,
0.0159100685,
-0.0569690466,
-0.0219376031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01826v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01826v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Analyzing Blood Pressure Variations Across Biological Sex from Scientific Literature | 2024-02-02T18:15:51 | 2024-02-02T18:15:51 | Yuting Guo, Seyedeh Somayyeh Mousavi, Reza Sameni, Abeed Sarker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Hypertension, defined as blood pressure (BP) that is above normal, holds
paramount significance in the realm of public health, as it serves as a
critical precursor to various cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) and significantly
contributes to elevated mortality rates worldwide. However, many existing BP
measurement technologies and standards might be biased because they do not
consider clinical outcomes, comorbidities, or demographic factors, making them
inconclusive for diagnostic purposes. There is limited data-driven research
focused on studying the variance in BP measurements across these variables. In
this work, we employed GPT-35-turbo, a large language model (LLM), to
automatically extract the mean and standard deviation values of BP for both
males and females from a dataset comprising 25 million abstracts sourced from
PubMed. 993 article abstracts met our predefined inclusion criteria (i.e.,
presence of references to blood pressure, units of blood pressure such as mmHg,
and mention of biological sex). Based on the automatically-extracted
information from these articles, we conducted an analysis of the variations of
BP values across biological sex. Our results showed the viability of utilizing
LLMs to study the BP variations across different demographic factors. | [
0.0049383882,
0.085422866,
0.0007384067,
0.0028860993,
0.0002329929,
0.0181041937,
0.0347655639,
0.0278634056,
-0.0061306376,
0.0003927051,
0.0239290725,
-0.0603706762,
0.0246534552,
0.0292101391,
-0.0071780435,
-0.0425423943,
-0.0227811728,
-0.0028696375,
0.1057922021,
-0.0222994834,
-0.0105170701,
-0.0092527643,
0.010119536,
0.0353232622,
0.0516353212,
-0.0259250477,
0.0583971739,
-0.0315930955,
0.018874716,
-0.0444002189,
-0.0091926875,
0.0662951693,
-0.0020316297,
-0.0057013412,
0.0000018414,
-0.0832929313,
-0.0039376044,
0.0712630451,
0.0234566741,
0.0096780807,
0.0746931508,
-0.0513952561,
-0.015281924,
0.0002157114,
-0.0225370973,
-0.0685622394,
0.038514562,
0.0004428764,
-0.0051856283,
0.012769768,
-0.023751758,
0.007731162,
-0.025686983,
-0.0577025525,
0.0400914848,
-0.0576646961,
0.0728674307,
0.0171594713,
0.0248820819,
0.0332628749,
-0.010581838,
0.0309420116,
-0.0373974741,
0.041716069,
-0.0289030671,
0.0271852296,
-0.0347327627,
-0.0311307274,
0.0016980902,
0.0560842827,
-0.0195726007,
0.0191183407,
0.0591893904,
0.0095200734,
0.0024815747,
0.0084143868,
-0.0758729428,
0.0063606389,
-0.0332134403,
-0.0193677898,
-0.006379372,
-0.0376105309,
0.021516772,
-0.0276218615,
-0.023250794,
0.02365187,
0.01533808,
-0.0153463772,
0.0259313975,
-0.003053559,
-0.0399210639,
-0.0399847552,
0.0409927256,
-0.0229875538,
0.0041931197,
-0.0018529173,
0.0225670394,
-0.0519241057,
0.0794828236,
-0.0721314028,
0.0517061092,
0.0340511464,
0.0475135855,
0.0283074919,
-0.0075603598,
-0.005240825,
-0.045580864,
-0.0093444521,
-0.0485790968,
0.0132211484,
-0.064598918,
-0.0097522251,
0.0068351813,
0.000660258,
0.0140459994,
0.0216406118,
-0.1118842363,
-0.0212258063,
-0.0189815369,
-0.0248252731,
-0.00724898,
0.0031357186,
0.0022839941,
0.0047498918,
0.0038294366,
0.048875019,
0.0024225484,
0.0247425176,
-0.0384192802,
-0.0206216574,
0.0283403322,
-0.0152250528,
0.0232201647,
0.0149803851,
0.0320400111,
0.0332024209,
0.013492249,
0.0257756002,
0.0119085694,
-0.0154953646,
-0.0379182547,
-0.0051664612,
-0.0071028122,
-0.0937774628,
0.0680201352,
0.0303477664,
0.0168516915,
-0.0324184969,
-0.0002088784,
0.0108802961,
-0.0353988707,
0.0309578441,
-0.0148236891,
0.0280301515,
0.0451731645,
-0.0040848749,
0.0136929611,
0.0727744848,
0.0511971563,
-0.0554903299,
0.0166764744,
-0.0204160549,
-0.0143788112,
0.0563588738,
0.024841601,
-0.0255741421,
-0.0355522409,
0.009536189,
0.0324265771,
0.0584311374,
0.0166578982,
0.0322541445,
0.0205225404,
-0.0025679774,
0.0317041166,
0.0894271582,
0.0124210985,
0.0664162412,
0.0245084502,
-0.0434960574,
0.0110440291,
-0.0386108793,
-0.0108626019,
-0.0236340687,
-0.0067293881,
0.028747404,
-0.0312043391,
0.0176883228,
0.0091248173,
-0.0341612101,
-0.0546012409,
-0.0023812018,
-0.0145233627,
-0.0411475524,
0.0490463004,
-0.0409087352,
0.0145582547,
0.0346941017,
0.0181537997,
-0.0356714465,
-0.0000615295,
0.0091391336,
-0.0026529394,
0.0132048838,
-0.0111014685,
-0.038053561,
0.047071293,
-0.0207234416,
0.024771411,
0.0102889426,
0.0159714688,
0.0084511312,
0.0290272553,
-0.0316711366,
-0.0023396036,
0.0356863104,
0.0260069855,
-0.0048913164,
-0.0114486394,
0.039328523,
0.002800371,
-0.0398011468,
-0.071284391,
0.0165669117,
-0.1002538651,
-0.0073283683,
0.0335413665,
-0.0355216525,
0.0127965678,
-0.0252974182,
-0.0136891631,
0.0344593152,
-0.0180924144,
-0.0462731235,
-0.0476947278,
-0.0260503199,
0.0497963578,
0.0318891369,
0.0353151821,
-0.0864491984,
-0.0158404931,
-0.0274137277,
-0.0383087061,
-0.0128222844,
-0.0173295699,
-0.0288085155,
0.0112533756,
0.0115324557,
-0.0219767895,
0.0175882094,
0.0218401309,
-0.0223663896,
-0.0043984852,
0.0306005571,
-0.0023930899,
0.0318989567,
-0.0545936711,
0.0070218337,
-0.0172891412,
-0.0164624881,
-0.0098261004,
0.0205638334,
0.007039899,
0.0212376751,
-0.0068384823,
0.0000398992,
-0.0307342689,
-0.0752007142,
-0.0026221799,
0.0319246054,
0.0256339703,
0.0086912522,
0.0280587897,
-0.0340608805,
0.0061383005,
-0.0206625685,
-0.0059436532,
0.0187836811,
0.0530369356,
0.0509283356,
-0.0152210509,
0.0339198411,
-0.0304704905,
-0.014269325,
-0.0579094067,
0.036207106,
0.0346451104,
0.0113851763,
0.0330672525,
0.0019419935,
-0.0479244106,
-0.0268203691,
0.0259843729,
-0.0438111946,
0.0056868256,
0.0141275292,
0.0730860233,
0.0465447195,
0.0065250737,
-0.0438138731,
0.045837339,
-0.0107501773,
-0.0084140748,
-0.0014805533,
-0.0524554215,
0.010653642,
0.0212172195,
-0.0548736341,
-0.0215240866,
0.0579945967,
0.0097505543,
-0.0078772325,
0.0089930696,
0.0207689907,
-0.0350029916,
0.0080863619,
-0.0928170234,
0.0175448023,
-0.0301253684,
0.0512880832,
0.018606469,
-0.0283305198,
0.0465110391,
-0.004596788,
0.0276962928,
-0.0456710532,
0.0011421699,
-0.0446852222,
-0.0320976675,
-0.0301480107,
0.0095373578,
0.0310182963,
0.0050667105,
0.0070915679,
-0.0005226723,
0.0350328423,
-0.0541522354,
0.0641796142,
-0.057289511,
0.0208724253,
0.0191360302,
-0.0323908888,
-0.0060147252,
-0.0117108058,
-0.0424473844,
-0.0016853815,
0.0325759873,
-0.03292083,
-0.0146912104,
0.0490955822,
0.0119969789,
0.0281061586,
-0.023198083,
-0.0169670135,
0.0072912467,
-0.0310555305,
0.0649767146,
-0.0391945392,
-0.0001683895,
-0.0327088386,
0.0305339098,
0.046950601,
-0.0172459614,
0.0327799693,
0.00364733,
0.0500414148,
-0.0273104552,
-0.0260948222,
-0.0097900331,
-0.024973968,
-0.0279587116,
-0.0293092374,
0.0159580689,
0.1210441589,
0.0291663557,
-0.0520376302,
-0.0237984918,
-0.0630595163,
-0.0083713084,
-0.0166930407,
0.0019027557,
-0.0416280553,
0.0052726325,
0.0082066674,
0.0412483998,
0.0017637978,
-0.029848,
-0.0270938091,
-0.0384735316,
0.0116457473,
0.0356065258,
-0.0373777226,
0.0306811631,
-0.0839696154,
0.0310976245,
-0.0582488552,
-0.0136987567,
-0.0320838951,
-0.0262153614,
0.0077501144,
0.0036635732,
-0.1004030183,
-0.0788517743,
0.0591952428,
-0.0224879626,
0.0331119113,
0.0449221469,
0.0482050776,
-0.0216905288,
0.0098281633,
0.0400211364,
-0.0268621314,
-0.0412102267,
-0.0446518026,
0.0558368862,
0.0587422885,
-0.0076095746,
-0.0711328685,
0.0912941471,
-0.0267561395,
0.0220899694,
0.0050753998,
0.0505476147,
0.036326427,
-0.0453559905,
-0.0393875092,
0.0287307501,
0.0189768746,
0.0614567213,
-0.0106821684,
-0.0140585238,
-0.0119988592,
0.0004712821,
-0.0332897864,
0.0579901263,
-0.0693514794,
-0.0191933475,
-0.0388963558,
-0.0595861226,
-0.0065926895,
0.0058617517,
0.0654890463,
-0.0101434505,
0.0361636877,
0.0103143696,
0.0913447961,
-0.0191333499,
-0.0195508283,
0.0435174815,
0.023776304,
0.0041803536,
-0.0074111153,
0.0039948164,
0.0659335554,
0.0488200001,
-0.0276290048,
0.0735206008,
-0.0550035499,
-0.013733875,
-0.0127645694,
0.0386154875,
0.0284770727,
0.0038411021,
0.0014413873,
-0.0154764578,
0.0248848796,
0.0188326016,
-0.0070256526,
-0.0049421759,
-0.0653113797,
0.0135838948,
0.0271984693,
-0.0072485977,
-0.0030671039,
0.0455929674,
-0.0251024105,
-0.0091599608,
0.0009911659,
-0.0353312716,
0.0319798402,
0.047738798,
-0.0017908014,
-0.0103196166,
-0.0280679036,
-0.0267032571,
-0.0056686127,
-0.0686598718,
0.0134547539,
-0.0248038415,
0.0372001752,
-0.0100404229,
0.0080164336,
-0.0252421144,
-0.0472451262,
-0.0470757298,
-0.0337619707,
-0.0756671801,
0.0691052824,
-0.0245168395,
0.0073556104,
0.0512223318,
-0.0305939224,
0.0132711809,
-0.0066805901,
-0.0158733036,
0.0374934152,
0.0006964338,
0.0169498418,
-0.024383381,
0.0267708618,
-0.0392364301,
0.0062348503,
-0.0585023388,
0.0110385381,
-0.0007861969,
0.0636098161,
0.0066468166,
-0.0022212728,
0.0412201881,
-0.0180594325,
-0.0156202549,
-0.0537693948,
0.00049254,
-0.0210729539,
0.0701669678,
0.0602020212,
0.0023186796,
-0.0137481242,
-0.043055173,
0.0841224939,
0.0325322933,
-0.002231817,
0.024583621,
-0.1068072096,
-0.0002294075,
0.0184874702,
0.0109544871,
-0.0163914952,
-0.0895250216,
-0.0029651087,
-0.0748486444,
-0.0554745719,
0.0383158252,
0.0211144779,
-0.0220012944,
0.0190832298,
-0.076981388,
0.0752257705,
-0.0617663451,
-0.0371651947,
-0.0210408252,
0.0549781322,
-0.0535370931,
-0.0222032182,
0.0084264651,
-5.403398923e-33,
0.0034291274,
-0.0228224583,
-0.0034184442,
-0.0258411486,
0.0042624758,
0.0476620272,
-0.0354321748,
0.0124980351,
0.0394765809,
0.0912609994,
-0.0275649913,
-0.0127847167,
0.038092237,
0.0055446364,
0.0377784185,
-0.0247138813,
0.0064275414,
-0.0036279168,
0.0293990765,
-0.0327456407,
0.0008280373,
0.0475599989,
0.0220888499,
-0.0634412244,
0.0396180712,
0.0308421366,
0.0070442976,
-0.0299105234,
0.0193887465,
0.0504927486,
-0.0073585808,
0.0791030973,
0.0092038019,
-0.0080466513,
-0.0055048722,
0.0125381853,
-0.0662766919,
-0.0341357253,
0.040767964,
-0.0564937592,
0.0346410125,
0.0197153427,
0.0649025887,
-0.0013773568,
-0.0189509615,
-0.0608091019,
0.0465672687,
-0.0797631368,
0.0021529624,
-0.014255017,
-0.0186038595,
0.0183549114,
-0.001786172,
0.0538165458,
0.0201314967,
0.0003784674,
-0.0742907152,
0.0191207808,
-0.0623526089,
-0.0139544969,
0.0609541386,
0.0268503651,
-0.00610347,
-0.0165121388,
0.0502071306,
0.0042749234,
-0.0070328079,
-0.0396038257,
0.0012426754,
-0.0183503237,
-0.0207116604,
0.0106554208,
0.0438227467,
0.0416461043,
0.013406314,
-0.0421885177,
-0.1019051298,
0.0406763218,
-0.0013522481,
-0.0243207291,
0.0035368332,
-0.0145827821,
-0.0028381213,
0.0006607065,
-0.0036450343,
-0.0211849157,
-0.0171889383,
-0.0483476371,
-0.01945474,
-0.0130076008,
0.0020489506,
0.0100624934,
0.0311047919,
-0.0276069492,
-0.0651408359,
-0.0179152973,
0.0379235744,
-0.0391441658,
0.0210270807,
-0.0025761321,
-0.0146360714,
0.0071653426,
-0.0001956012,
0.0353143588,
0.0349419005,
-0.0124951107,
-0.0165262874,
-0.016162375,
-0.0489661247,
-0.0311925989,
-0.0164117552,
-0.0032679501,
-0.0162716545,
0.0459253564,
-0.0002054238,
-0.0103921471,
0.017284058,
0.0386607163,
0.0392924435,
0.020234853,
-0.0127548892,
0.0480211638,
-0.0081231566,
0.0175741147,
-0.0237583108,
-0.0180564001,
0.0048222849,
0.0005822899,
0.0416921191,
-0.0150206732,
0.004107058,
-0.0389427245,
2.525e-7,
0.0718091205,
0.0511524342,
0.0131410006,
-0.0053386199,
0.0204466172,
-0.0039918101,
-0.0402005203,
0.0030845308,
0.0553651154,
-0.0228686035,
0.0274076313,
0.0001414982,
0.0227720309,
0.0412966944,
-0.0224666782,
-0.0116494903,
-0.0546624586,
-0.0370711572,
-0.0193814859,
-0.0290054865,
0.0251594,
0.0630279034,
-0.0463000461,
-0.0214115996,
-0.0052276324,
0.0270793904,
0.0339258462,
-0.0497425273,
-0.0162846986,
0.0669484809,
-0.01267373,
-0.0100501217,
0.0431455858,
0.0515660122,
-0.0153407604,
-0.0173091888,
0.034021806,
0.0739367604,
-0.0232177619,
0.0881648213,
0.0304998755,
-0.0116480822,
0.0331922136,
-0.0814162418,
0.0482511073,
-0.0572346412,
-0.0544911474,
-0.0757062733,
-0.0021746559,
-0.0305764452,
0.0774954036,
-0.0316178203,
0.0019203359,
0.0278693214,
-0.0018364704,
0.0366412103,
-0.0161988214,
0.0039062854,
-0.000211386,
0.0198170692,
-0.0423112512,
-0.0271757226,
-0.0006160481,
0.0259176977,
-0.0155280158,
-0.0523760132,
0.0182122532,
2.12976319e-34,
0.0308202133,
0.0308853872,
-0.0316558033,
-0.0125481281,
0.0357555747,
-0.0134013155,
-0.0154062565,
0.0172355417,
-0.0218695365,
-0.0710123926,
0.0038452125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01592v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01592v1 | Towards Sustainable Workplace Mental Health: A Novel Approach to Early Intervention and Support | 2024-02-02T17:35:49 | 2024-02-02T17:35:49 | David W. Vinson, Mihael Arcan, David-Paul Niland, Fionn Delahunty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Employee well-being is a critical concern in the contemporary workplace, as
highlighted by the American Psychological Association's 2021 report, indicating
that 71% of employees experience stress or tension. This stress contributes
significantly to workplace attrition and absenteeism, with 61% of attrition and
16% of sick days attributed to poor mental health. A major challenge for
employers is that employees often remain unaware of their mental health issues
until they reach a crisis point, resulting in limited utilization of corporate
well-being benefits. This research addresses this challenge by presenting a
groundbreaking stress detection algorithm that provides real-time support
preemptively. Leveraging automated chatbot technology, the algorithm
objectively measures mental health levels by analyzing chat conversations,
offering personalized treatment suggestions in real-time based on linguistic
biomarkers. The study explores the feasibility of integrating these innovations
into practical learning applications within real-world contexts and introduces
a chatbot-style system integrated into the broader employee experience
platform. This platform, encompassing various features, aims to enhance overall
employee well-being, detect stress in real time, and proactively engage with
individuals to improve support effectiveness, demonstrating a 22% increase when
assistance is provided early. Overall, the study emphasizes the importance of
fostering a supportive workplace environment for employees' mental health. | [
0.0688396022,
0.0037695302,
-0.0499602966,
-0.0636318177,
-0.0275991578,
0.0253606327,
0.0361022465,
0.0613932759,
0.1383939236,
-0.036443457,
0.0661256388,
0.0777153075,
-0.0116997696,
0.035217572,
0.0039802711,
-0.0477738865,
-0.0260578245,
0.0461418591,
0.067093581,
0.0480532013,
0.0226978865,
0.0412156656,
-0.0449199975,
0.0522646718,
-0.0539071411,
-0.0238497425,
0.0554428436,
0.0249291584,
0.0561080985,
-0.0051305867,
0.0043029455,
0.031351801,
-0.0410535,
0.0082481494,
0.0000025002,
-0.0052885497,
-0.0237193238,
0.0043556988,
-0.0108492877,
-0.0838940889,
0.0473685861,
-0.0518195666,
-0.0268779695,
0.0519872494,
-0.0101792263,
0.0064375848,
0.0156524591,
0.0147791086,
0.0606556237,
0.0116971256,
-0.0460212901,
0.0488716997,
-0.0480373167,
0.018514134,
-0.0255107824,
0.0129963942,
0.035539709,
-0.0312228464,
0.0541292876,
-0.0945662931,
0.0179855712,
-0.0025606453,
-0.0520532839,
-0.0004844225,
-0.0419636965,
0.0048936,
-0.0017391989,
-0.0486342572,
-0.0025410254,
0.0539071523,
-0.0362759605,
0.0356581584,
0.0017556151,
-0.0423459634,
0.0779606029,
0.0007794162,
0.0049893935,
-0.0153036388,
-0.0373624787,
-0.0252373237,
0.0160427764,
0.0311347507,
-0.0123095158,
-0.0224144757,
0.0690705553,
-0.0013484251,
-0.0097712837,
-0.0348452777,
0.0270032883,
-0.0051758531,
0.0024335177,
-0.0209535081,
0.0460288227,
0.0494394638,
-0.031092735,
-0.0164137892,
-0.0224827379,
-0.0763055384,
-0.0016729648,
-0.0360953771,
-0.0383963361,
0.0589454323,
-0.0375843756,
-0.0020619072,
0.0582891181,
0.01053969,
0.0297413282,
-0.0726398826,
-0.0312907659,
0.0273944065,
-0.0348683558,
0.0205085408,
-0.0383972973,
-0.0148515739,
0.0120292231,
-0.0281367395,
-0.0772706643,
0.0258325282,
-0.0313700996,
-0.0217317455,
-0.0055634556,
-0.027115697,
0.0168111715,
0.064633213,
0.059742298,
-0.0032701055,
-0.0293920524,
-0.0215162076,
0.0197116919,
-0.0977018699,
0.0471263863,
0.0211948678,
0.0054373294,
0.0274860784,
0.0384666175,
0.0202097278,
0.009944967,
-0.0658055246,
-0.0523826368,
-0.0279392265,
-0.0278351977,
-0.0118931821,
0.0172289629,
-0.0336097516,
0.0467633493,
-0.0193783157,
-0.0167510435,
0.0303171054,
0.0390196517,
-0.01117313,
-0.014469686,
-0.0124530261,
-0.0793725327,
-0.0182377622,
0.0088321194,
0.0375962369,
-0.0000635994,
0.0108244689,
0.000588961,
0.0185131915,
0.0469810925,
-0.0473461263,
0.0003206625,
0.0298348889,
-0.0264918711,
-0.0728241354,
0.0828913152,
-0.0301188268,
-0.0580414981,
0.0290375333,
-0.0468938574,
-0.0130813206,
-0.0420830175,
0.0910920054,
0.0121375909,
0.0637447983,
-0.0047424105,
0.0385556109,
-0.0388784297,
0.053566426,
-0.0210092105,
-0.0562760048,
-0.0053848941,
0.0096381372,
-0.0261194445,
-0.0483866706,
0.010509599,
0.0057985517,
-0.0325265415,
-0.081515789,
-0.0336495042,
-0.0249371268,
0.0200087652,
0.0176293887,
-0.0033598326,
-0.0378361344,
0.0086438255,
0.0248862319,
0.0315858722,
-0.037319839,
-0.0383162126,
-0.0517678149,
0.0184483249,
0.113309145,
0.015450825,
-0.0354068652,
-0.0123943407,
-0.0433704481,
-0.006594541,
0.0134311989,
0.0273208022,
0.0158982091,
0.0211397968,
0.0191202797,
0.0040404005,
0.0322162621,
0.0194198322,
-0.0034373354,
-0.0095327748,
0.041528631,
-0.060866978,
0.0236226078,
-0.0131565034,
0.0322013386,
0.0247955397,
-0.0408504456,
-0.013019192,
0.0138940588,
0.0293747783,
0.0778192133,
0.0110652521,
0.0043788119,
-0.010861475,
-0.0357395411,
-0.0211843606,
0.0449899137,
0.0171371643,
-0.0041760858,
0.0191256478,
0.022679599,
-0.0301740076,
0.0561203286,
-0.0150626516,
0.024382852,
0.0053007975,
-0.0114697805,
0.0237164255,
0.0026405531,
-0.040038459,
-0.0376521386,
0.0508739091,
-0.0229109228,
-0.0135503998,
0.0068130945,
0.0144467251,
-0.0638503209,
-0.0247801822,
-0.0292073954,
-0.0487488769,
0.0017639418,
-0.0111740213,
-0.0064645573,
-0.0123681165,
-0.0280355047,
0.0370414667,
-0.0392930806,
0.0105773136,
-0.1451461613,
-0.0140308682,
-0.0020722533,
-0.0667921752,
0.0109519577,
-0.0022346652,
-0.0263638869,
-0.0510366373,
-0.0117821069,
0.0531774536,
0.0505475439,
0.0277825445,
0.0011017777,
-0.0032723707,
-0.0109036537,
-0.0260823164,
-0.005614487,
-0.0286605731,
-0.0324557386,
0.0735647753,
-0.0146437762,
-0.0598798022,
-0.0379064642,
-0.0334217064,
-0.0158118624,
-0.0023448989,
-0.0512322746,
0.0057258634,
-0.0116873169,
0.046093978,
0.0562610216,
0.0141786542,
0.0496078618,
-0.0103805419,
0.0232195929,
0.0249805078,
-0.0030053987,
-0.009962922,
0.0241600554,
-0.0156740732,
-0.0430980474,
-0.0102512334,
-0.0013693204,
0.0224037953,
0.0131393764,
-0.0468643717,
0.0298794582,
-0.0239093658,
0.0154707311,
-0.037095096,
0.0227228068,
-0.020103449,
-0.0018676321,
0.0271539725,
-0.0044693667,
-0.0214482266,
0.0227545667,
0.0141278133,
-0.0718453452,
-0.0553142838,
-0.0129887937,
0.0227290522,
-0.0362301394,
0.0068265651,
0.0527960099,
-0.0147369998,
0.0514872186,
-0.0246517602,
-0.0412146039,
-0.0628755242,
-0.0900113657,
-0.0372582078,
-0.0077790371,
0.0300984979,
0.0014783655,
-0.0462057516,
-0.0153075559,
-0.0853056982,
0.0160398893,
0.0352082551,
0.0158590768,
-0.070039168,
-0.0432151929,
0.0349528939,
0.0286237504,
0.0380156599,
-0.0124456678,
0.0232248381,
-0.0302300937,
0.0275148116,
0.017206585,
0.0448769368,
0.0193910357,
0.0565006882,
0.0665792972,
-0.0126310904,
0.0134223681,
0.0244750604,
-0.0309843495,
-0.0189503524,
0.0136346687,
0.00744393,
-0.0138882995,
-0.0093040382,
0.0077882912,
-0.0083704386,
0.0845367163,
-0.0158593897,
-0.0082563031,
0.0204748455,
-0.0454828404,
-0.05531599,
0.0116237886,
0.0135726007,
0.0090369852,
-0.0141444895,
0.0004191784,
0.0440318026,
-0.0065104272,
-0.032176964,
0.0318686664,
0.0063023758,
0.0589672476,
-0.0233551376,
-0.0097169597,
-0.00618276,
0.0144700101,
0.0204269551,
0.0057717599,
-0.0063966848,
-0.049956385,
0.0181757379,
-0.0167330429,
-0.0027286762,
-0.0584951863,
-0.0067075933,
0.0639026091,
-0.0056926641,
0.0022194884,
0.0438646227,
0.1014421582,
0.0179300047,
0.0122945122,
0.0143188406,
0.061078243,
0.0199690145,
-0.0053515201,
0.0790601298,
-0.0102780797,
0.0149676781,
-0.0392501689,
0.0388316177,
-0.0720288083,
0.0405894816,
0.0245593898,
0.0335191675,
0.0293140486,
-0.0242610145,
-0.0192140266,
0.0717896,
0.0434102379,
0.0093896156,
-0.0045467271,
-0.069012098,
0.0067249606,
0.03115125,
0.0460949354,
0.0182331204,
-0.0280381273,
-0.0084249284,
-0.0485413745,
-0.0061524524,
-0.0453845114,
-0.073884815,
0.0454528034,
-0.0239191204,
-0.025408756,
-0.052395191,
-0.0120200487,
0.0476595759,
-0.0066262414,
-0.0077587729,
0.0215340368,
0.0798902363,
-0.0259797201,
-0.0092382077,
-0.0155727407,
0.0219812803,
0.0013435353,
0.0098346286,
-0.0380098261,
0.0282697771,
0.0509507321,
0.0182203613,
0.0024472664,
-0.0563990027,
0.0106837889,
0.0173476487,
0.0257302914,
0.0030352029,
-0.0830212906,
0.0230940655,
0.0157025959,
0.0671307296,
-0.0192776788,
-0.0053390409,
-0.0286734775,
0.0293344278,
0.0102033662,
0.0090691457,
0.0392444767,
-0.0150376912,
-0.0003743437,
0.039401684,
-0.0205097124,
0.0011438815,
-0.0445992351,
0.0022857212,
-0.0137334624,
0.0110571263,
-0.0135232443,
-0.0163469296,
0.0029435938,
-0.0329559222,
0.0072106994,
0.024052009,
0.0211865474,
-0.0323622562,
-0.0108197983,
-0.0178492907,
0.0235578101,
-0.0148970336,
0.009812247,
-0.0312822387,
-0.0188784655,
0.0141310748,
0.0589563847,
-0.0116897905,
0.026710622,
0.0005471106,
0.0837574825,
-0.0296023525,
0.0006945758,
0.0050988686,
0.0643971488,
-0.0354356244,
-0.0830758959,
0.0161628295,
0.0059506358,
0.037012089,
0.0296607688,
0.0469481982,
-0.0064846762,
-0.0337971188,
-0.0067282827,
-0.0158817843,
-0.0554556288,
0.0014100841,
-0.0196561515,
-0.0235743374,
-0.0276729316,
-0.0287023727,
-0.0099923396,
-0.0152874077,
0.0050362749,
0.0344522521,
0.0051227403,
-0.0197365712,
0.0216071457,
0.0253986418,
0.0340112075,
-0.024935253,
0.0074682934,
-0.0358149186,
-0.0352197476,
0.0495102443,
-0.0281503871,
-0.0265459754,
-0.0039289175,
0.0244196076,
0.0348286591,
0.0136948144,
-0.0180655792,
-0.0578127876,
0.033394143,
-0.0247595496,
0.0146277389,
-0.0103087435,
-5.762188452e-33,
0.0173978992,
-0.0019037513,
-0.0139051434,
0.0268280283,
0.0343691073,
-0.0011415861,
0.037557736,
0.0058271615,
-0.0047979299,
0.0068557626,
0.023631135,
0.1043004468,
-0.0282516088,
-0.023944417,
-0.0122025898,
0.0023726183,
0.0206756461,
-0.0356701612,
-0.0053139543,
0.0213668197,
0.0131248021,
0.0770736858,
0.0475301929,
-0.0886000916,
0.0082706753,
0.0171883069,
-0.003970088,
0.0029655679,
0.051027853,
0.006000489,
-0.0102445381,
0.0755877793,
0.0032552185,
0.0387095213,
0.0381760933,
0.0762866437,
-0.0232120585,
-0.0714237466,
-0.0323628634,
0.0170858726,
-0.0308580901,
-0.0118919555,
-0.0277110077,
-0.0158304647,
-0.0015924466,
-0.0541457757,
0.0316282585,
-0.0604858287,
0.0457055233,
0.0036573585,
-0.0139921559,
-0.0054111728,
-0.0292660668,
0.0079286946,
-0.029847471,
0.0862128437,
-0.0419238731,
-0.0094252499,
-0.056326542,
-0.0147205116,
-0.006011873,
-0.0405351408,
-0.0126944762,
-0.0460277535,
0.0119850636,
0.0119852647,
-0.0018410229,
0.0005766482,
0.0116800535,
0.0242897794,
0.0068674651,
0.0209732037,
0.0696285814,
-0.0004239444,
0.0199373141,
-0.0361066423,
-0.0335292965,
0.0086969798,
0.0780483708,
-0.0349401608,
0.032513082,
0.0309654661,
-0.0291057155,
-0.0089614745,
0.0044114483,
0.0239237752,
-0.0193198994,
-0.0336410254,
0.0097786337,
0.0212608185,
-0.0272391085,
-0.0705342069,
-0.0312211066,
-0.032208927,
0.0573167019,
0.0085280715,
0.0230144169,
-0.0170195196,
0.0104004489,
-0.0465692095,
-0.05212681,
0.0036462282,
-0.0134222815,
0.0351043753,
0.0669183657,
-0.0379462689,
0.027537398,
-0.0284307562,
0.0072790678,
-0.0108758975,
0.0247053169,
0.1003259644,
0.0063875057,
-0.0116300387,
-0.0341357216,
0.0067735268,
0.0106112091,
0.0457191244,
0.0717758685,
0.0175028685,
-0.0526856408,
0.0298883561,
-0.0145383812,
-0.0252584033,
-0.0403171256,
-0.056305185,
-0.0030709102,
0.0097773196,
0.033239238,
-0.0808565542,
-0.0020666814,
-0.0653621852,
3.046e-7,
-0.0059889611,
0.0440704189,
-0.0362106562,
-0.0236002356,
0.0234898049,
0.0092197796,
0.0168873966,
0.0069848974,
0.0239730943,
0.0157849938,
0.0098822741,
-0.0127515849,
0.0371301696,
0.0285797343,
0.0377116986,
-0.0865918696,
0.0007723316,
-0.0453717932,
-0.0182857625,
0.0160282161,
0.0861072317,
0.0466811694,
0.0241208524,
-0.0299542863,
-0.0057472191,
-0.0116832666,
0.0070098853,
-0.039039582,
0.0140262572,
0.0092783794,
0.0004945109,
0.0176857691,
-0.0238120463,
0.0105859917,
-0.0036988279,
0.0073135924,
0.0000351632,
0.036503002,
-0.0355299935,
0.0197369307,
0.0300068595,
0.0137319574,
0.0081243617,
-0.0197005793,
0.0255470108,
-0.1124023125,
-0.0489879102,
-0.0150910495,
-0.0542856231,
-0.0477446094,
0.0234328415,
-0.0247900803,
-0.0415011495,
0.0426766835,
0.0135705573,
0.0142169381,
0.0087174317,
-0.0051974296,
-0.0055736289,
-0.0008244039,
-0.0554055348,
-0.0634532943,
0.0131179336,
-0.0045653782,
-0.0492966287,
-0.0169859417,
0.0140898833,
2.213213876e-34,
-0.0079015428,
0.0705171898,
-0.0266123582,
0.0378937982,
0.0049234275,
-0.0012074275,
-0.0031011358,
0.0199427158,
0.0044772713,
-0.0081259171,
-0.0149786631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01591v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01591v2 | BAT: Learning to Reason about Spatial Sounds with Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T17:34:53 | 2024-05-25T17:05:11 | Zhisheng Zheng, Puyuan Peng, Ziyang Ma, Xie Chen, Eunsol Choi, David Harwath | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Spatial sound reasoning is a fundamental human skill, enabling us to navigate
and interpret our surroundings based on sound. In this paper we present BAT,
which combines the spatial sound perception ability of a binaural acoustic
scene analysis model with the natural language reasoning capabilities of a
large language model (LLM) to replicate this innate ability. To address the
lack of existing datasets of in-the-wild spatial sounds, we synthesized a
binaural audio dataset using AudioSet and SoundSpaces 2.0. Next, we developed
SpatialSoundQA, a spatial sound-based question-answering dataset, offering a
range of QA tasks that train BAT in various aspects of spatial sound perception
and reasoning. The acoustic front end encoder of BAT is a novel spatial audio
encoder named Spatial Audio Spectrogram Transformer, or Spatial-AST, which by
itself achieves strong performance across sound event detection, spatial
localization, and distance estimation. By integrating Spatial-AST with LLaMA-2
7B model, BAT transcends standard Sound Event Localization and Detection (SELD)
tasks, enabling the model to reason about the relationships between the sounds
in its environment. Our experiments demonstrate BAT's superior performance on
both spatial sound perception and reasoning, showcasing the immense potential
of LLMs in navigating and interpreting complex spatial audio environments. | [
0.0116651719,
0.0466137752,
0.0075793136,
0.0520652756,
-0.0115584228,
-0.0086139329,
0.0483364277,
-0.0482852794,
-0.0379369296,
-0.0098542152,
-0.0604433529,
0.0231987368,
0.0219505876,
0.0448601283,
0.0271410588,
-0.0617055371,
0.0241808593,
-0.0493218303,
0.0212348811,
-0.0201809388,
-0.0223566834,
0.0116293132,
-0.0736225471,
0.0674301386,
-0.0237035509,
-0.0022596144,
-0.0077913082,
0.0059147966,
0.0093410844,
-0.0452674516,
0.0090592736,
0.0091886967,
0.0823909864,
-0.0046771863,
0.0000016204,
-0.0361571386,
0.0247703549,
-0.0050921231,
-0.0007893019,
-0.0152957952,
-0.0694373697,
0.0074268654,
-0.0089968853,
0.037071947,
-0.018728625,
-0.031628523,
0.0437425822,
-0.0086913723,
0.0312827565,
0.0181689598,
-0.0084479172,
-0.0997218266,
0.0039863009,
-0.0248033963,
0.0547972172,
-0.0052188421,
-0.0004910385,
-0.0115341945,
0.0300939269,
0.0540041216,
-0.0340604149,
0.0229834504,
0.0381109826,
0.0157469846,
0.0270524938,
0.05787668,
-0.013260833,
-0.0140786879,
-0.0320402421,
0.0864676237,
0.0406003334,
-0.0380340777,
-0.0067564496,
0.054657951,
-0.0149998609,
-0.0326081626,
-0.0748088732,
0.028015824,
-0.0100092227,
0.0135507332,
-0.0593165793,
0.0148480879,
0.0184528939,
-0.0334612466,
0.0047762897,
0.0803078413,
0.0033789068,
-0.0176313594,
-0.0276985783,
-0.0331593379,
-0.0081221201,
-0.0383207202,
0.0277997144,
0.0624936782,
-0.0326178782,
0.0059962203,
0.0228396636,
0.0282746945,
-0.0178897195,
-0.0246501639,
-0.0260615796,
0.0206796639,
-0.060184814,
0.0884869024,
-0.0469039828,
0.0268924665,
-0.0165894516,
0.0183535498,
-0.0203247238,
-0.0415171944,
-0.010672844,
-0.0252128579,
-0.0538306944,
-0.0003487294,
-0.0513087213,
-0.0529284626,
0.0098744752,
-0.0185894743,
-0.0420380458,
0.0231862739,
0.0016366364,
0.0601332597,
0.016986765,
-0.0184803735,
0.0161577314,
0.0148157794,
-0.0264818557,
0.0759505108,
-0.0431142971,
-0.0138327247,
-0.0278655421,
0.029253494,
0.0473179482,
-0.0130790062,
-0.0003096376,
0.0765419751,
0.0045512444,
-0.0207665078,
-0.0097428253,
-0.0055005299,
-0.0367972143,
-0.0279572234,
-0.0009849578,
-0.0685170963,
0.0305460356,
-0.0084663238,
-0.053489536,
-0.0116262967,
-0.0005228884,
0.0034451189,
0.0219414197,
0.0932508931,
-0.0144694243,
0.0464013927,
0.0819259658,
0.0109557062,
0.0180516094,
0.0164679885,
0.081417039,
0.0076628667,
0.0123108551,
-0.0160274245,
-0.0231207963,
0.028951453,
-0.0036817987,
-0.0138325533,
-0.0500885732,
0.0141335344,
-0.0184162837,
0.0496872589,
0.0081163533,
0.0201509744,
-0.0402980894,
-0.0339881629,
0.0372460485,
0.1044767797,
-0.0156357978,
-0.000404206,
0.0418610722,
0.0012975259,
-0.0285008084,
-0.063562341,
-0.0308178701,
0.0669744387,
-0.0082036052,
-0.0136045301,
0.0635712147,
0.0031638262,
-0.0338856541,
-0.0179808103,
-0.0363144763,
0.0056873565,
-0.0001193083,
0.0535205267,
0.0248274021,
0.0181972776,
-0.0263413973,
0.075958021,
-0.0120738298,
-0.0387578867,
-0.0311292876,
-0.0152207147,
0.1061508432,
0.0349688306,
0.0101567386,
-0.0466043055,
-0.0283844024,
-0.0086439997,
0.0157611519,
0.0464992784,
0.0303547401,
-0.0196988676,
0.0306071006,
-0.0179708749,
-0.0630458891,
-0.0049458821,
0.0052390946,
0.0218465589,
0.0409123935,
0.0285799,
0.0033166269,
-0.0587615259,
0.0438796282,
-0.003574244,
0.025265472,
-0.028586138,
-0.0236020852,
0.0145050967,
0.0212033689,
-0.0096973795,
0.0038524496,
0.0129062748,
0.038965635,
-0.0258353967,
-0.0018365898,
0.0446897559,
-0.0546208769,
-0.0507300645,
0.0381965153,
-0.0394633822,
0.0123490104,
0.0569172129,
-0.0256728623,
-0.0165711045,
0.0393029861,
-0.0504378527,
0.0061065676,
-0.0228338484,
-0.0214322899,
0.0228564348,
0.0206047762,
-0.0056148414,
0.0188897029,
0.033206366,
0.0061337291,
-0.0733568892,
0.0320674703,
0.0584916323,
-0.0118169701,
0.0347604342,
0.01262704,
-0.0155929038,
-0.011273019,
-0.0338757001,
-0.0033533466,
-0.0367084816,
-0.0031605866,
-0.073506549,
0.0041403533,
-0.004658388,
-0.0030518929,
0.0180079248,
-0.046035707,
-0.0142863737,
-0.048869025,
-0.0397031233,
-0.0270076003,
-0.0048433305,
0.0154741975,
-0.0058090128,
-0.0605613329,
-0.0472069643,
-0.0184382685,
-0.0108749364,
0.0001147162,
0.0116112987,
0.0088810911,
0.0107362233,
-0.0388455689,
-0.0203420036,
-0.0342990048,
0.0160197262,
0.0083656451,
-0.0114943823,
0.0452671498,
-0.0401318893,
-0.009840535,
0.0428376161,
-0.0199229196,
-0.0016778788,
0.0484522916,
-0.0022634561,
-0.0408392288,
0.0354850963,
0.0138416365,
0.040947523,
-0.0304739289,
-0.0030687102,
-0.0407863744,
0.039444495,
0.0241252277,
-0.0037614987,
-0.0145500377,
-0.0007044083,
0.0061526722,
-0.0081048142,
-0.072056815,
-0.0503262877,
-0.0016579109,
0.0647766516,
-0.0549801476,
-0.0149171846,
0.0240471214,
-0.0663148165,
-0.025093725,
-0.0724018738,
-0.0065881526,
-0.0363387018,
0.0799755603,
-0.0183032341,
0.0048252475,
-0.0215182286,
-0.0381366313,
0.0155722406,
-0.0335432775,
0.0005845464,
-0.0284772124,
0.0056927926,
-0.0301495027,
0.0192284118,
0.0002154267,
-0.0197956227,
-0.0417919457,
0.0111131324,
-0.073244065,
0.0068350146,
-0.0573628321,
-0.0268309359,
0.0041641816,
0.0348349921,
0.04538491,
0.0644644052,
-0.0031924639,
-0.0042821649,
-0.0133034056,
0.0300064292,
0.0678218454,
0.1011071578,
-0.0220680591,
0.0012795961,
-0.0298109781,
0.0303912126,
-0.0159422792,
0.0006813597,
-0.0667453408,
0.0822853148,
0.0354312845,
0.0364722274,
-0.0271905232,
0.0441042706,
0.0613439456,
-0.0539980084,
-0.0409599803,
0.0836298168,
0.0735772848,
0.0154133411,
0.0126277115,
-0.0241261534,
0.0044660531,
0.0349669755,
-0.0132016419,
-0.0192082543,
-0.061558038,
0.0251472276,
-0.0136054,
0.0831686258,
0.0274439044,
0.0033330412,
-0.072777085,
0.0704471841,
0.0045647379,
-0.1142105684,
-0.061141111,
-0.012830033,
0.0040630661,
0.0019651521,
-0.0083941743,
-0.0013339473,
0.0041005309,
-0.0054802005,
0.0089285579,
-0.0154560711,
0.0164230261,
0.0372846983,
-0.0240833424,
0.0233740974,
0.0490841344,
0.0465956181,
-0.0119740739,
-0.0549032874,
-0.0183662642,
0.0276813079,
0.0195590556,
0.0065036514,
0.0480626002,
0.0416340269,
-0.0217570513,
0.0201651193,
0.0384220704,
-0.0670417547,
-0.0300228447,
0.0321684442,
0.0741381794,
-0.0254403036,
0.0285961293,
-0.0331963561,
0.0695085078,
-0.021417737,
0.0759951472,
0.0397502296,
0.0380859151,
-0.0421346575,
-0.0125674084,
-0.0680909082,
-0.0320620276,
-0.0069242739,
-0.0010369688,
0.0401451848,
0.0014705693,
-0.0508341379,
0.0033207119,
0.0364386812,
0.0381605998,
0.0044158641,
-0.0119395666,
0.0015253937,
0.0012814756,
-0.0589944012,
0.0515336059,
-0.022303449,
0.0406071022,
0.0172833484,
0.0229400676,
0.0621081106,
-0.0654652417,
-0.0231506471,
0.0368388891,
-0.0504218601,
-0.0441786088,
-0.0258236565,
-0.016892096,
0.0242550205,
0.033369299,
-0.0356287919,
-0.0058562369,
0.0558941998,
-0.0090269623,
-0.0486344881,
0.0482037775,
0.0433103666,
0.0233564191,
0.0104441373,
0.0091419239,
-0.0505802073,
0.0256096274,
-0.0144127887,
0.0206070356,
0.0058669383,
-0.0023029563,
-0.0271058735,
-0.0412714779,
0.0647698119,
0.0187444575,
-0.0189404972,
-0.0326000527,
0.0461531393,
-0.0114738606,
0.0520110987,
-0.0381335802,
0.0229718238,
0.0150205139,
0.0272657406,
-0.0269096997,
-0.0075838747,
0.0203107353,
-0.0000894147,
0.0002971214,
0.0324499905,
0.0461797789,
-0.054838758,
0.003085376,
-0.014573006,
0.0093705179,
0.0000623809,
-0.0123036411,
0.043154195,
0.0243695192,
0.0264576077,
0.0074400241,
-0.0146784009,
-0.0377162956,
0.0260873176,
-0.0525057986,
-0.0742159411,
0.0347711146,
0.0424301215,
0.0548557602,
-0.0107366061,
-0.016784111,
0.0109736538,
0.0072538406,
0.0189534109,
0.0128948977,
-0.0226188563,
-0.0142015442,
0.0731703937,
0.0355249792,
-0.0107192853,
-0.0168927778,
0.0376963876,
-0.0169792995,
0.0316672288,
-0.021137936,
0.0330301747,
-0.0256196782,
-0.0299967155,
-0.0242041387,
0.043543078,
-0.0065872362,
0.0237658489,
0.0203906186,
-0.0755315423,
-0.0139066717,
-0.0014284902,
-0.015449754,
-0.0041369949,
0.0549196489,
0.0299973954,
0.0136392852,
-0.0314534232,
0.0411964543,
-0.0383637883,
-0.0021814879,
-0.033644449,
0.0110177016,
-5.488309288e-33,
-0.0208075307,
-0.049050767,
0.0526804924,
-0.0103933653,
0.0076638535,
-0.0217772592,
-0.0629002601,
-0.0328861773,
-0.0220063701,
0.0060585663,
0.0242776293,
0.02687083,
0.0063016401,
0.019256847,
0.0364215076,
-0.011011729,
0.0145504288,
-0.0110462364,
0.0192160998,
-0.0159944557,
0.0668301806,
0.007365895,
0.0306117926,
-0.0501902513,
-0.0651179701,
0.0220699701,
-0.0010773508,
0.0154791437,
-0.0631302744,
0.0551423952,
-0.0277323574,
0.0161626171,
-0.0144541375,
-0.0338099487,
-0.0086773857,
0.0296660997,
-0.1028194129,
-0.0456595644,
-0.0043308553,
0.0264990479,
-0.034397278,
-0.0157955363,
0.0463292487,
0.0104751047,
0.0036538781,
-0.0235780496,
0.0363684855,
-0.0291742608,
-0.0121715525,
-0.0110390494,
-0.0363414995,
-0.0016113321,
-0.0424184985,
-0.0561653078,
0.0108259004,
0.026424516,
0.0068221013,
0.0211495683,
-0.0228513461,
0.0566763319,
0.0031338155,
0.0170742925,
0.0393284634,
-0.00485422,
-0.0103780311,
0.0452502631,
0.0769757703,
-0.0917901173,
-0.0205387883,
0.0033257066,
0.0272744521,
0.0373713113,
0.0471039042,
-0.0006631915,
0.0193832517,
0.0127714314,
-0.0507891811,
0.0080948342,
-0.0385879725,
0.0125005301,
0.0242655352,
0.0282580014,
-0.0203666948,
-0.0155435791,
-0.0337333567,
0.018628085,
-0.0419202149,
0.0094026616,
0.0490181483,
0.0077626808,
0.0438283347,
0.0020841586,
0.0197626799,
-0.0242315643,
0.0269710105,
0.0379993841,
-0.0218905378,
-0.0026085321,
0.0217858776,
0.0427492633,
-0.0298118405,
0.0345197394,
0.0797334611,
0.016126534,
0.0174988769,
0.0016799027,
0.0112416511,
0.0540320911,
-0.0450713336,
-0.0105753029,
-0.0208500344,
-0.0287320986,
0.0041211941,
0.0184797719,
0.0240284987,
0.0158800296,
-0.0492904335,
0.0168510005,
-0.0572420619,
0.0141416946,
-0.0557372309,
-0.0273726415,
-0.0813588202,
0.0320569687,
-0.0162738897,
0.003685619,
-0.0235874485,
-0.0671145245,
0.0028858872,
-0.0788565278,
-0.0260237604,
0.0189658459,
2.536e-7,
-0.0086991349,
0.0036400184,
0.0158570781,
-0.0045225993,
0.0430806279,
0.0153701678,
-0.0181411635,
0.0251990613,
0.0087302234,
-0.0156368036,
0.0019820423,
0.0552830994,
0.0578666069,
0.022493355,
-0.1000741795,
0.0401405506,
-0.0577827394,
0.0140815303,
-0.0557743758,
-0.0063543287,
0.0716144368,
0.0715066344,
-0.0085766772,
-0.0256239157,
0.0320356525,
-0.0325941555,
0.0095605245,
-0.0064472621,
0.0495504439,
-0.042496074,
0.0184682533,
-0.0346810706,
-0.0076144421,
-0.0124372169,
-0.0209730938,
-0.00935842,
0.0123222442,
0.0418674536,
-0.0151536558,
-0.0760548562,
-0.0122344373,
0.0411404856,
-0.0086903675,
-0.0670365915,
0.1018824056,
-0.0294033438,
-0.0280956291,
0.0341596566,
-0.0186390597,
-0.0232473183,
-0.015027239,
0.0127855521,
0.0317251161,
-0.0685020909,
0.0110980738,
-0.0219888687,
0.003028041,
-0.1074199602,
-0.0210128874,
0.0363396071,
-0.0447720438,
0.0121405357,
-0.0095908688,
-0.0267007779,
0.0160846934,
-0.008346769,
-0.0462775305,
1.633618134e-34,
0.0002108294,
-0.0089221066,
0.027392732,
-0.0146529125,
-0.0107777994,
-0.0133355046,
-0.0224721581,
-0.023003703,
0.0269706193,
-0.0160070527,
-0.0101367105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01586v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01586v2 | TrustAgent: Towards Safe and Trustworthy LLM-based Agents through Agent Constitution | 2024-02-02T17:26:23 | 2024-02-18T04:11:55 | Wenyue Hua, Xianjun Yang, Zelong Li, Wei Cheng, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.MA | The emergence of LLM-based agents has garnered considerable attention, yet
their trustworthiness remains an under-explored area. As agents can directly
interact with the physical environment, their reliability and safety is
critical. This paper presents an Agent-Constitution-based agent framework,
TrustAgent, an initial investigation into improving the safety dimension of
trustworthiness in LLM-based agents. This framework consists of threefold
strategies: pre-planning strategy which injects safety knowledge to the model
prior to plan generation, in-planning strategy which bolsters safety during
plan generation, and post-planning strategy which ensures safety by
post-planning inspection. Through experimental analysis, we demonstrate how
these approaches can effectively elevate an LLM agent's safety by identifying
and preventing potential dangers. Furthermore, we explore the intricate
relationships between safety and helpfulness, and between the model's reasoning
ability and its efficacy as a safe agent. This paper underscores the imperative
of integrating safety awareness and trustworthiness into the design and
deployment of LLM-based agents, not only to enhance their performance but also
to ensure their responsible integration into human-centric environments. Data
and code are available at https://github.com/agiresearch/TrustAgent. | [
-0.0127455285,
0.0219046883,
0.0164981876,
0.0305874627,
-0.0267628357,
-0.0235719904,
-0.0340472013,
-0.0241211299,
0.0378317423,
-0.0042167725,
-0.0000302219,
0.0287099723,
-0.0435233004,
0.007970647,
0.0093422774,
0.0116454354,
0.0467741303,
-0.0496429317,
-0.0010838413,
0.0206371509,
-0.0080072964,
-0.0382721387,
-0.0127355075,
0.0088016586,
-0.0262427069,
-0.0036152452,
-0.0437341444,
0.0186889227,
0.0652584359,
-0.0405529067,
-0.0041409163,
-0.0083438465,
0.0454949625,
-0.0053292466,
0.0000021198,
-0.0473873988,
-0.011647257,
0.0013379807,
-0.0105127636,
-0.0834444165,
0.0179034509,
0.0210864265,
-0.0291922092,
0.0304288585,
-0.0407599472,
0.0593476333,
-0.0003288393,
0.0315552466,
0.0368270651,
0.0502948128,
0.0063941306,
0.0600577816,
0.0507507436,
0.0486680456,
0.0166346692,
-0.0663534626,
-0.0098364726,
-0.0201652888,
0.032921873,
0.0113875251,
0.008647711,
-0.0378350504,
0.0191269647,
-0.0118612032,
0.0102332802,
0.0104455017,
0.0249981303,
-0.0591915362,
-0.0505253971,
0.0218028408,
0.038763389,
0.0186768137,
0.0247050337,
0.0203381702,
-0.0048489706,
0.0292327963,
0.0142187001,
0.010143958,
-0.0068273987,
-0.0095513454,
-0.0234914646,
0.0068149553,
0.0247897785,
0.0174626783,
0.0196491927,
0.1310977936,
-0.0220434107,
0.0270761922,
0.0162214767,
-0.0141796591,
0.0596624389,
-0.0458276905,
-0.0079761781,
0.0681648329,
-0.0587185472,
0.0186827984,
-0.0105236592,
0.0681485385,
0.033754088,
-0.0202826578,
-0.0230670683,
-0.0219421592,
0.0072681541,
0.0080598667,
-0.0006053945,
0.0298503414,
0.0087962039,
0.0552895367,
0.0028411236,
0.0110668829,
-0.0050975475,
0.0233750604,
-0.0029721202,
0.0195862595,
0.0129494825,
0.0337825157,
0.0005688535,
0.0514143407,
-0.0336931981,
0.0529981889,
-0.01706017,
0.009269462,
0.0266686361,
-0.0052704029,
-0.0723542795,
-0.0988084152,
-0.0332373157,
0.0058397311,
0.0005075149,
-0.0454840325,
0.0037948014,
-0.0043893442,
-0.0327602327,
-0.0097594773,
-0.036046274,
0.1056251004,
0.0136493137,
-0.0535698943,
-0.0651896521,
-0.0424160175,
0.0474099703,
-0.0541750789,
0.0017320362,
-0.0306833461,
0.0013112053,
-0.0317413881,
-0.0400342979,
-0.0669808984,
0.0444298945,
-0.0112641621,
0.0023247453,
0.0379352942,
-0.0586117133,
0.0109498603,
-0.0281337462,
0.0657878816,
-0.0631073862,
-0.0041778451,
0.045744136,
0.0478044674,
0.0275203902,
0.0262239743,
0.0670796335,
0.0019663428,
-0.0362277851,
0.0119621996,
0.0774540678,
0.0033444725,
-0.0461805612,
0.0175274517,
-0.03580584,
-0.0022313665,
-0.0118015772,
0.0311966967,
0.0627112985,
0.0204524621,
-0.016000269,
-0.0327370428,
-0.0159998871,
0.0509401672,
-0.0175977368,
-0.0432059839,
-0.0854512379,
0.0537050851,
-0.055617705,
-0.0140184239,
-0.0994247571,
0.0505112894,
-0.0328809991,
-0.0351165459,
-0.008697629,
-0.0527725928,
0.0611537509,
-0.0027630213,
0.0016827144,
0.0040824981,
-0.0189036466,
0.0079516657,
-0.0150891272,
-0.0325441062,
-0.0423513837,
-0.0771138743,
0.0519715771,
0.0952120349,
0.0140812872,
-0.0085955393,
-0.0820166543,
-0.0048931134,
-0.0049283374,
-0.0211195946,
-0.0410384312,
-0.00924257,
0.0444071293,
-0.0262342189,
-0.0628276616,
0.0036546988,
0.025827663,
0.0398518443,
0.0107815005,
0.0212539639,
-0.0154648023,
-0.0115345838,
0.0024875216,
0.0476706326,
-0.0119950688,
-0.0061437231,
-0.0580798723,
0.0038087831,
0.0184031762,
0.0008113167,
0.0157138221,
-0.0074130814,
0.0693514496,
0.0411980376,
-0.0334704109,
0.0394744687,
0.0080876928,
0.0550869294,
0.0098971594,
-0.0354669765,
0.0126893315,
0.0255161412,
-0.0088293226,
-0.0143452054,
-0.0351908505,
0.0017239859,
-0.0115601746,
-0.0333534591,
0.0194301698,
0.0009952687,
-0.0427068993,
-0.004216915,
0.0079158563,
-0.0044195419,
-0.0826916918,
-0.0007337336,
0.0720550492,
0.0160309859,
-0.0209064372,
0.0270998944,
-0.0079163006,
0.0102423914,
0.0444162264,
0.0068724225,
0.0438082665,
-0.0125484373,
-0.0067945262,
0.0084467577,
-0.0134943686,
-0.0232912451,
-0.0027478428,
-0.0166641958,
-0.0506211184,
-0.0033645653,
0.0037490434,
0.0146210967,
0.0949007422,
-0.0108025894,
-0.0141426157,
0.0385834761,
-0.0169316083,
-0.0643751919,
-0.0091723055,
0.0429720469,
0.0024024351,
-0.0178475752,
0.0106109306,
-0.0205441359,
-0.0547020584,
0.0441333912,
-0.040974535,
-0.022530539,
-0.0137591017,
-0.0440216549,
0.021204602,
0.0232675504,
-0.0650486872,
-0.0005259549,
-0.0094338721,
0.0164677165,
0.0840243399,
-0.0290265158,
-0.0400356315,
0.0100539736,
-0.0050894842,
-0.0126816062,
-0.0214720089,
0.0210449323,
-0.0156352073,
0.0056213499,
-0.0577206239,
0.0253180079,
0.0162843503,
0.0025490825,
0.0431128629,
-0.0609372631,
0.063376449,
-0.0497985035,
-0.0256848857,
0.0840625539,
0.0060802866,
-0.0393968746,
0.0397490226,
-0.0152624669,
0.0091118449,
0.0302483775,
-0.0466951653,
-0.0223721042,
0.0490588173,
-0.0020168361,
-0.0185673889,
-0.01227111,
0.0145251742,
-0.0062375828,
-0.0526885726,
0.005371063,
-0.0158722308,
0.0093358988,
-0.0608209781,
-0.0297051184,
0.0039018649,
-0.0440793969,
-0.0561335012,
-0.0019213629,
-0.027896598,
0.0181678254,
-0.086928241,
-0.0205914825,
-0.0217331368,
-0.0231254362,
0.0373429768,
-0.0303239077,
-0.0048381728,
0.0024134836,
-0.0322968476,
-0.0478785411,
-0.0081733502,
0.0311737321,
0.0661854893,
0.0017255091,
0.0517428443,
0.0731095821,
-0.0098153912,
-0.0521799214,
-0.0585580543,
-0.0159941446,
-0.0012913063,
0.0442858413,
0.027731033,
0.0484403521,
0.0640108585,
0.0041719624,
-0.017717883,
0.015539608,
0.0004275018,
0.0142778829,
0.0310432427,
-0.0516357794,
-0.0086529786,
0.003510962,
0.0185117871,
-0.0105357952,
-0.0068609267,
0.0158175994,
0.0121193938,
-0.0191463698,
-0.0446327329,
0.0274605826,
0.001128959,
0.0917117074,
0.0002821971,
0.0061111706,
-0.009444003,
-0.0429443754,
-0.0030594291,
-0.0106537985,
0.0279324763,
0.0309806298,
0.0295871999,
-0.0537579954,
0.0002560664,
-0.0259637386,
-0.0133990981,
-0.0000719441,
-0.0694916695,
0.0278828964,
0.0774158239,
0.0067506433,
-0.0336135961,
-0.0588987246,
-0.0206507575,
0.0506081469,
0.0630537122,
-0.012782136,
-0.0185399558,
-0.027150834,
0.0421961062,
0.0015085585,
0.0121124685,
-0.029093286,
-0.0680845976,
0.0499808677,
0.0655465052,
-0.0625236183,
-0.0257441569,
-0.0667020082,
0.0029484252,
0.0454100333,
0.0433913767,
-0.0340332426,
0.0277431253,
-0.0416952819,
-0.0071005872,
-0.0261137318,
0.010289629,
-0.0056139831,
0.0245547034,
-0.0402055159,
-0.0202557724,
-0.0269102268,
-0.0463305116,
-0.0049129715,
-0.0004758964,
0.0048011001,
-0.0684525073,
0.0083825812,
0.0525335707,
-0.0155123724,
-0.0130930282,
0.0005568518,
0.0389313251,
0.0221204963,
0.0610396303,
0.0317606293,
-0.0497855693,
0.0241187643,
0.0155381169,
-0.0139680943,
-0.0173044614,
0.025050696,
0.0853161812,
0.0339345597,
-0.0092176255,
-0.0424678177,
0.0081261424,
0.0633351132,
-0.0192327183,
-0.0673063472,
0.009133162,
0.0308828726,
0.0008722736,
0.022297021,
0.0135387713,
-0.0509956181,
-0.0001500464,
0.0236900151,
0.0080072721,
-0.0617837757,
-0.0224511065,
0.0023034362,
0.036798615,
-0.0009808734,
0.0244398881,
0.0658901706,
-0.0001932783,
0.0437906496,
0.005455886,
0.029018499,
-0.0246098749,
0.062830016,
-0.0190898031,
-0.0051125656,
0.0436422303,
-0.0408614948,
0.0114072049,
0.0117388265,
0.040583171,
0.0469967127,
0.0040936288,
-0.0075835031,
0.0185548682,
0.0126910834,
-0.003147058,
0.0324153602,
-0.0180902686,
0.0049747773,
0.0465344451,
0.0065018185,
-0.0166639946,
-0.0061267712,
-0.0506002568,
0.0261449032,
-0.0580193028,
-0.0639418736,
0.0336565822,
0.0650055781,
0.0233742874,
0.0796382576,
0.0025432061,
-0.083607167,
0.029969262,
-0.0172689818,
-0.0043268148,
0.0233286787,
-0.0130864698,
0.0330672078,
0.0329808891,
-0.0128688281,
-0.0161798596,
0.0189702604,
-0.0122913569,
0.0317397155,
-0.0496727303,
-0.0621683858,
-0.0448031873,
-0.0150506506,
0.0148883564,
0.0208711941,
-0.0223553553,
-0.0711171255,
-0.0654718876,
-0.0143344477,
0.0227620807,
0.0402312241,
-0.0114589659,
-0.0285643861,
0.0019141324,
-0.0068685361,
0.0256502163,
-0.0419582389,
-0.0043226182,
-0.094590649,
-0.0044079572,
0.0248784684,
0.012110346,
-5.414204288e-33,
0.0156492442,
-0.0594658591,
0.0518413037,
0.0451299921,
0.0135178911,
-0.0425216481,
-0.0153150866,
0.0134655191,
0.0105247712,
-0.002507736,
-0.0214279331,
0.0155202923,
0.0276561324,
-0.061431814,
0.0265975893,
-0.0171532147,
-0.009978516,
0.0000421606,
-0.0010102349,
-0.0300981794,
-0.0236369856,
0.023544427,
0.0143010141,
-0.0661893263,
0.0357567444,
-0.0168372504,
-0.0447870865,
0.0373825431,
-0.081108205,
0.0251782872,
0.0135053033,
-0.0142471567,
0.0064411266,
0.0275147986,
-0.0204031542,
0.0233372431,
-0.0127229942,
-0.0568932407,
-0.0187267605,
-0.0218792837,
-0.0942578912,
-0.0471094698,
0.0055606151,
-0.0054101488,
-0.0541686602,
0.0067872303,
0.0142390393,
-0.0140040852,
0.0133163268,
-0.0099468222,
-0.0278519597,
0.0104375379,
0.003941773,
-0.0395545177,
0.0418456011,
-0.0019531993,
-0.0037751219,
-0.0341007635,
-0.0432848334,
0.0109220855,
-0.0256752819,
-0.0817002654,
0.0207061656,
-0.0230510961,
-0.0399598777,
0.0529188626,
0.019075999,
0.0181705095,
-0.0291665774,
-0.0082221637,
-0.0288254693,
0.1249169633,
0.0062396978,
0.069803372,
-0.0677867308,
-0.0107513294,
-0.0608375818,
0.0787532032,
0.0371414497,
0.0824726224,
0.0235263985,
-0.0009757472,
-0.0332957357,
0.0158405043,
0.0193628222,
0.0181771554,
-0.0042456803,
-0.0384030454,
-0.002163853,
0.0214599762,
-0.0124279065,
-0.0325585678,
-0.0320222378,
0.0049984548,
0.0301454291,
0.0030881225,
0.030322846,
-0.0322178975,
-0.0128899664,
0.0244158674,
-0.0415098369,
-0.027611604,
-0.0396843553,
-0.0333859138,
0.0356721357,
0.0184975248,
-0.0007527808,
0.0711780265,
0.0165790711,
-0.0033679453,
-0.0286201648,
0.0209796242,
0.0530403182,
-0.0611824468,
0.0128661562,
-0.0367185287,
0.0021220981,
0.0388713256,
-0.0159051064,
-0.0475364923,
0.0043088626,
0.0540747717,
-0.0217955727,
0.0110512944,
-0.0084267771,
-0.0242898688,
-0.0127172042,
0.0042730523,
0.0187659878,
-0.0299946386,
0.0171483625,
-0.0079340851,
2.928e-7,
-0.0563278422,
0.0184100885,
0.0066754199,
0.0143277869,
0.0279840808,
0.057536263,
-0.0492600314,
0.0580670796,
-0.0409261361,
-0.0369901098,
0.0683496594,
0.0248060357,
0.0172801763,
0.0565172844,
-0.0032116254,
-0.0090106679,
0.0418051444,
-0.0277975369,
-0.0168536548,
-0.0060519488,
0.0576037876,
-0.0016569804,
0.0169740655,
-0.0379049629,
0.0255238209,
-0.0222220849,
0.0050458186,
-0.0781816766,
0.0098837567,
-0.0084602926,
0.0264252797,
0.03165498,
0.0105269281,
0.0448400453,
0.0120488619,
-0.005553578,
-0.0654089972,
0.0938923284,
-0.0113551645,
-0.0338130146,
0.0053199227,
-0.0713621676,
0.0169545747,
0.0020245456,
0.0075725638,
0.0224935804,
0.0013099947,
0.0478213094,
-0.0428799205,
-0.0147537384,
-0.0331604257,
-0.0124472938,
0.0259967204,
-0.0279242638,
-0.0157395434,
-0.0041592568,
-0.0232890621,
-0.0051021781,
0.0388126783,
-0.0156272724,
0.0079420395,
-0.1112807095,
0.0266793091,
0.0524134301,
-0.0051714601,
-0.0517617017,
-0.0244242344,
2.147726213e-34,
-0.043066252,
-0.0152537273,
-0.0374477245,
0.0419053733,
0.0527367964,
0.0441857278,
0.0056857406,
0.0000424318,
0.0356308408,
0.0190599281,
-0.0276323725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01582v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01582v1 | Automating Sound Change Prediction for Phylogenetic Inference: A Tukanoan Case Study | 2024-02-02T17:20:16 | 2024-02-02T17:20:16 | Kalvin Chang, Nathaniel R. Robinson, Anna Cai, Ting Chen, Annie Zhang, David R. Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We describe a set of new methods to partially automate linguistic
phylogenetic inference given (1) cognate sets with their respective protoforms
and sound laws, (2) a mapping from phones to their articulatory features and
(3) a typological database of sound changes. We train a neural network on these
sound change data to weight articulatory distances between phones and predict
intermediate sound change steps between historical protoforms and their modern
descendants, replacing a linguistic expert in part of a parsimony-based
phylogenetic inference algorithm. In our best experiments on Tukanoan
languages, this method produces trees with a Generalized Quartet Distance of
0.12 from a tree that used expert annotations, a significant improvement over
other semi-automated baselines. We discuss potential benefits and drawbacks to
our neural approach and parsimony-based tree prediction. We also experiment
with a minimal generalization learner for automatic sound law induction,
finding it comparably effective to sound laws from expert annotation. Our code
is publicly available at https://github.com/cmu-llab/aiscp. | [
-0.0105779879,
0.0839199126,
-0.0502472706,
-0.0167650487,
-0.0256410614,
0.0002839587,
-0.0063220849,
-0.0033268773,
-0.0661940724,
0.001708203,
-0.0343760401,
-0.0413663462,
0.0884004235,
-0.0018647033,
0.0474803299,
-0.0206909478,
0.0159392636,
-0.0277620051,
0.0414166711,
0.0035042595,
-0.0356442742,
-0.0001506186,
-0.0406850651,
0.0339631103,
-0.0501862355,
-0.0268477425,
-0.0401989855,
-0.0127700726,
0.0220288057,
-0.0238401107,
-0.0193214584,
-0.0026220395,
-0.0061586364,
0.0805365667,
0.000001457,
-0.0477643199,
0.0492652953,
-0.0021327094,
-0.0409516245,
0.0257741623,
0.0045791152,
0.0760883763,
-0.0080445074,
-0.0245741531,
-0.0044798856,
0.0033458422,
0.0935668647,
-0.0800298229,
-0.006531646,
0.0530765876,
-0.0023969319,
-0.0798958167,
0.0582117252,
-0.001604378,
0.0169729143,
0.0255951565,
0.0222200323,
-0.0115195196,
0.0163158718,
-0.0380878374,
0.012295817,
0.0316862538,
-0.004776041,
0.0069198115,
-0.0441172943,
-0.0146756805,
0.0190273039,
-0.0848209783,
0.0136822956,
0.0105734617,
0.0360679328,
-0.0590774082,
-0.0441033952,
0.0292174332,
-0.0355850682,
-0.0146694286,
0.0090102861,
0.0034479618,
-0.0380335152,
0.004394277,
0.0622007437,
-0.031318713,
0.0114727439,
-0.0266338587,
-0.0077208676,
0.0363456234,
0.0490080938,
-0.0373549759,
0.0042886203,
-0.0272626001,
0.029848177,
-0.010144894,
0.031644959,
0.0362080522,
-0.0288690347,
0.0018587962,
0.0857689083,
-0.0149495415,
0.0237100497,
-0.036532443,
0.0228301864,
0.0241601486,
-0.0719629079,
-0.0180117656,
-0.0508453213,
-0.0178460404,
0.019350294,
-0.0713628829,
0.0215955414,
0.0027216198,
-0.0499682315,
-0.0443274044,
0.0112550473,
-0.0135876164,
-0.0181646775,
0.0445502251,
0.0061572948,
-0.0348892026,
-0.0019900796,
-0.0222001821,
-0.0077337893,
-0.0407103635,
-0.0216391683,
0.0316141807,
0.0021271307,
-0.0097328527,
-0.0349097028,
0.0613719001,
-0.0367689282,
-0.0820758492,
0.0149638383,
0.0102986032,
0.0100973519,
0.0490283966,
0.0170308203,
0.0471902117,
-0.0129842954,
-0.0048222267,
-0.0073997607,
0.0046636104,
-0.0616227984,
0.0178887099,
-0.0458842739,
-0.0289844386,
0.0282633994,
-0.026263576,
-0.0330675542,
-0.0236166287,
-0.0495930575,
-0.050962165,
-0.0002843459,
0.0269383658,
-0.0510784462,
0.0444085598,
0.0407544598,
-0.0069307005,
-0.00105512,
-0.0088922726,
0.0426727831,
-0.034167707,
0.038444072,
-0.0403577089,
-0.0586614795,
0.015928356,
-0.0201166421,
-0.0393148176,
-0.0052121538,
-0.0280741062,
-0.00244383,
0.0249631535,
-0.0062312745,
0.0193599518,
-0.0082989512,
-0.0320516154,
0.0060455995,
0.0653180256,
0.0438778922,
0.0471150056,
0.0785749927,
-0.0507325418,
-0.0085171554,
0.0131996376,
0.0265223403,
-0.0390349217,
-0.0262792055,
-0.0121920127,
-0.0351421461,
0.0165616851,
0.0070173773,
-0.0188272297,
0.0005162924,
-0.0312323105,
-0.0361053348,
-0.0208135638,
0.0330255814,
0.0173293687,
0.0038876501,
0.0128128687,
0.041162543,
-0.0120704165,
-0.0155268498,
-0.0125449933,
0.1070073843,
-0.0042664944,
-0.0460451506,
-0.065750584,
0.0165947434,
0.0457038619,
-0.0159381852,
0.0484183952,
0.0020792552,
-0.0519415848,
0.012610428,
-0.0099595757,
-0.0090075769,
0.0417033024,
0.0477300882,
0.0673868433,
-0.0202550404,
0.0514194109,
0.0311386213,
-0.0311815068,
0.0051015858,
0.0198002234,
-0.0331791267,
-0.0119788013,
-0.0068440912,
0.0181764755,
0.0442665704,
0.0553507246,
-0.0112070208,
0.023234129,
0.0210353378,
-0.0025865056,
0.0283610895,
0.031997852,
-0.0394549891,
0.0222318508,
0.0975090191,
0.0216068216,
0.0126525201,
-0.0325189382,
0.0266940594,
-0.024612736,
0.0515042655,
-0.0419932865,
0.0683517754,
-0.0078483839,
0.0260805655,
-0.0614125878,
-0.0223798044,
0.00506486,
0.0426585302,
0.0769914463,
0.0068614241,
-0.0051214807,
-0.0245208517,
0.011668561,
-0.032691244,
0.0173166059,
0.0232233554,
-0.0173720159,
-0.0650062636,
0.0032167304,
-0.027680533,
-0.014524729,
0.0222718101,
-0.0540063344,
-0.0367932059,
-0.0066776783,
0.0904065669,
-0.0161886942,
-0.0024236962,
-0.0020751024,
-0.0179347489,
0.0071228789,
0.0043471605,
-0.0573124364,
0.0159878414,
0.0025326887,
-0.03476822,
-0.0263460763,
-0.0500219874,
-0.027652828,
0.0040420289,
0.0510953367,
0.0175625756,
-0.074865602,
-0.0336450934,
-0.0702854767,
-0.0813017413,
-0.0039427807,
0.0091047389,
0.0018923401,
0.0208821148,
-0.015690079,
0.008617932,
-0.0466454476,
-0.0351309031,
-0.058917731,
0.0434578173,
-0.0124187516,
-0.0167524386,
-0.022009464,
-0.0153828124,
0.0116274031,
-0.0405972973,
-0.0079690265,
-0.0379850455,
0.0673025027,
-0.0042266143,
-0.0355141312,
-0.0232712086,
-0.0195442997,
0.0164891742,
0.0153927403,
0.0443531759,
-0.0672544613,
-0.0260577239,
0.0423867553,
-0.0379413962,
-0.0401302762,
0.0886608884,
-0.0274056327,
-0.0178403035,
-0.0078572398,
-0.0251565445,
-0.0569122583,
0.0911549628,
0.0173647497,
-0.0206868798,
0.0428795405,
-0.0279050451,
-0.0103660729,
0.031712383,
0.0752085373,
0.000472623,
-0.0083787534,
-0.0687764511,
0.0217592996,
-0.0149092842,
0.0115374671,
0.0096203145,
0.0610107705,
-0.0481400006,
0.0301801208,
-0.0304779541,
-0.0144912163,
0.0439048521,
0.0257313401,
-0.0172792915,
0.023741005,
0.0252781846,
0.0484673828,
0.0044196495,
0.0648832172,
-0.0167883188,
0.049703069,
-0.0139385154,
0.0409044474,
0.085557811,
-0.0272455364,
-0.0107288044,
0.0269512143,
-0.0671601295,
0.0202616528,
-0.0057817567,
-0.0216492061,
-0.0411792584,
0.0004247413,
-0.0026962985,
0.0186570846,
0.035877727,
0.0295831803,
0.0261562504,
0.033935871,
0.046641577,
0.0062178159,
0.0234528296,
0.0003512734,
-0.030354837,
-0.0504141785,
0.0002107505,
0.0184935629,
0.0111680981,
0.0380371697,
-0.0425171219,
0.0225363337,
-0.0842508078,
-0.0158577338,
0.0305276252,
-0.0510166585,
0.0239439644,
-0.0451028571,
0.0147616342,
-0.002219033,
-0.0437960215,
0.0669901073,
0.0160267651,
0.0073986039,
0.0349636972,
-0.0919240415,
-0.0149616851,
0.0040760334,
-0.034895096,
-0.0095588919,
0.0489650369,
0.031418696,
-0.0296248458,
-0.0285020359,
0.0870629773,
-0.0130293788,
0.0141304983,
-0.0135285351,
-0.0112406127,
0.1066821143,
0.0311327744,
0.0387955345,
0.0107234661,
-0.0025679241,
0.0033353963,
0.0443028659,
0.0853625983,
0.0092048394,
-0.0618354902,
0.0143008577,
0.0107186325,
-0.0492636301,
0.0014669524,
0.02878532,
-0.02343316,
-0.0044285217,
-0.0106528308,
0.007172755,
0.0315998867,
0.0104527157,
0.0187405534,
0.0067312075,
-0.0858913213,
-0.1082845628,
0.013926575,
0.0127368588,
0.0157096088,
0.0561563112,
-0.0267137643,
-0.0122253904,
-0.0082975049,
-0.0380215272,
-0.0032293049,
0.0345067568,
0.0253232829,
0.0037461002,
0.0048352964,
0.0761858299,
0.0062711341,
-0.0040614209,
-0.0041069784,
0.0121544385,
-0.0798859671,
-0.0044512688,
0.0062333471,
0.0164593458,
0.0238640197,
0.0180261657,
-0.0499269813,
0.0147660384,
0.026781708,
-0.0061675622,
0.0260007214,
0.044153586,
-0.0471157357,
-0.0128828958,
0.0255516823,
-0.0491623133,
0.0200578813,
-0.0064488892,
0.0134171369,
0.0020503828,
-0.0313303582,
0.0155377844,
0.0011676733,
0.0295151249,
-0.0388709977,
-0.0469013639,
-0.0045572147,
0.0158069599,
0.0378897674,
0.0211557783,
-0.0053246533,
0.0163396746,
-0.0123898685,
0.0715558454,
0.0024511376,
-0.038258303,
0.0293651111,
0.0346057639,
-0.009106501,
0.0682263225,
0.0775173679,
0.0818450302,
-0.0248615798,
-0.0038174826,
-0.0194695219,
0.0491977334,
-0.0658038557,
0.035797596,
-0.0168015063,
-0.0331315398,
0.0047959602,
0.0174831711,
0.0030322319,
-0.0260622259,
0.0138550084,
-0.0105180293,
0.0069527146,
0.0145000359,
0.0494824201,
0.0043114624,
0.0248967838,
-0.0235879235,
-0.021071339,
0.0078925034,
0.021066336,
-0.0417890362,
-0.0290023051,
-0.0292962994,
0.0231718961,
-0.0348552689,
0.0367103517,
0.0037172181,
-0.0220692195,
0.0455890447,
-0.0270554628,
0.0105280718,
0.0124127315,
-0.0389257148,
-0.038577307,
-0.0014349091,
-0.0383557007,
-0.0513093174,
-0.0235458706,
-0.0577363297,
-0.0019897758,
0.0200339705,
0.0102038598,
0.0249016918,
0.0476866327,
0.0238085594,
0.0313575231,
0.0227887332,
0.0071382094,
-0.0238776393,
-0.0087410603,
0.0298204962,
-0.0140620647,
-4.533887956e-33,
0.004844212,
0.0022634175,
-0.0130657228,
0.0464914218,
-0.0070661223,
-0.0081740757,
-0.0393335111,
0.0039471993,
-0.030567728,
0.0137479119,
0.0542987883,
-0.0096242866,
-0.0125950268,
-0.0457062908,
0.0448608696,
0.0429313742,
0.0267480072,
-0.0312941596,
0.036834728,
-0.0118954508,
0.024209559,
0.0049970746,
0.0612584464,
-0.0411411896,
0.0233465526,
0.065059118,
0.005877926,
0.0062173991,
-0.0626266897,
-0.003354976,
0.0059523308,
0.0231927335,
-0.0206991471,
0.031906262,
0.026769327,
-0.0423702002,
-0.0855232701,
-0.029286664,
-0.002942248,
0.0092305178,
0.0124303615,
0.0133463973,
0.0358612835,
0.017814666,
-0.0257803798,
0.0180217717,
0.0242715385,
-0.0842688158,
-0.0023997107,
-0.0396666639,
-0.0460155159,
0.0495702289,
-0.0216144286,
-0.0044408916,
0.0219013672,
0.0710750297,
-0.0215327088,
-0.0222679637,
-0.0312050357,
0.0885926262,
0.0270860326,
-0.0236561522,
0.0441197678,
0.0021830508,
-0.0374059938,
0.0081085945,
0.1108283028,
-0.0694368482,
0.0111505734,
0.0343453437,
0.0016624165,
0.0282006878,
0.019628074,
-0.0306639988,
0.033442501,
-0.0368318148,
-0.0282298066,
-0.0238899086,
0.0669459552,
-0.0066031679,
-0.0384753272,
0.0355448201,
-0.0196132809,
0.0008429068,
-0.0086693214,
-0.0591366254,
-0.0067268126,
-0.0254390836,
-0.030002892,
-0.0486914441,
0.0415926054,
0.0385655165,
-0.0194978807,
-0.0082133021,
-0.00934726,
-0.0344167463,
-0.026090689,
0.0081451535,
0.0035837428,
0.0229704343,
0.0230666138,
-0.0021027063,
0.0348955728,
0.0067757829,
0.0286627114,
-0.0203874297,
-0.0134568475,
0.0555506423,
-0.033895988,
-0.0012692781,
0.0141037041,
-0.0972988978,
0.0119475182,
0.0368036516,
0.0447395518,
0.018892901,
0.0209165141,
-0.0214826763,
0.0528339557,
0.0219968706,
-0.0163908582,
0.0286271032,
-0.0633163676,
-0.0121223051,
-0.0211624354,
0.0012536445,
0.0329366401,
0.0374997333,
-0.0325340554,
0.0012755982,
-0.0044427677,
0.0367341973,
2.488e-7,
0.0207335539,
-0.0124932388,
0.0655082166,
-0.0114580607,
0.0346695669,
-0.0285227578,
-0.0487660691,
-0.0549960062,
0.008457168,
-0.0338252485,
0.0302883256,
-0.0287746117,
0.0709167272,
0.0571746938,
-0.0548558086,
-0.0205272753,
-0.1239747033,
-0.0113770226,
-0.0606073588,
-0.0129073728,
-0.0220222119,
0.0749799386,
-0.020916136,
-0.0764015839,
-0.0133043732,
0.0197968204,
0.0106731122,
-0.0087705869,
0.0372906923,
-0.0359815508,
0.0135680791,
-0.0998996124,
0.0099812299,
-0.0005475763,
-0.0467339009,
0.0247703549,
-0.0103982659,
-0.0328604877,
-0.0012631248,
0.0186981168,
0.0343078487,
0.0348849669,
-0.0255045462,
-0.0189118106,
0.0158706214,
0.0540241227,
-0.0027811613,
-0.0203539729,
-0.0351739749,
0.0198997557,
0.0051255003,
0.0052685249,
0.0464521423,
0.0041957949,
-0.0017912549,
-0.0117386524,
-0.0284973085,
-0.0182759855,
-0.0311844014,
0.0578911193,
-0.0465706624,
-0.0394064561,
0.0056590596,
0.0006483836,
0.0099972757,
0.0142074982,
0.0245691761,
1.674546689e-34,
0.0011804292,
-0.0335387215,
0.0339708626,
0.0175738502,
-0.0257921796,
-0.0422667265,
0.0542261936,
0.0439414829,
0.0523653291,
-0.0075834952,
-0.0194200948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01579v1 | How Paralingual are Paralinguistic Representations? A Case Study in Speech Emotion Recognition | 2024-02-02T17:17:42 | 2024-02-02T17:17:42 | Orchid Chetia Phukan, Gautam Siddharth Kashyap, Arun Balaji Buduru, Rajesh Sharma | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Pre-trained Models (PTMs) have facilitated substantial progress in the field
of Speech Emotion Recognition (SER). SER is an area with applications ranging
from HumanComputer Interaction to Healthcare. Recent studies have leveraged
various PTM representations as input features for downstream models for SER.
PTM specifically pre-trained for paralinguistic tasks have obtained
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance for SER. However, such PTM haven't been
evaluated for SER in multilingual settings and experimented only with English.
So, we fill this gap, by performing a comprehensive comparative study of five
PTMs (TRILLsson, wav2vec2, XLS-R, x-vector, Whisper) for assessing the
effectiveness of paralingual PTM (TRILLsson) for SER across multiple languages.
Representations from TRILLsson achieved the best performance among all the
PTMs. This demonstrates that TRILLsson is able to effectively capture the
various paralinguistic features from speech data for better SER. We also show
that downstream models using TRILLsson representations achieve SOTA performance
in terms of accuracy across various multi-lingual datasets. | [
-0.0125423763,
0.0260122977,
-0.0014782201,
0.0289227013,
0.00320582,
0.024734823,
0.0230450388,
-0.0340260006,
-0.0357043296,
-0.0411362164,
-0.109884046,
-0.0042460766,
0.0017459949,
-0.0323228911,
-0.0068028304,
-0.0891902968,
0.0537069775,
0.0085292319,
0.0304776914,
-0.0228382871,
0.0114876907,
0.0173852127,
-0.0459849574,
0.0444826595,
0.0205380823,
0.0100630242,
-0.0303545743,
0.0143396538,
0.0191279538,
-0.0145347295,
0.0044294903,
0.0221026856,
0.0325400047,
0.0189313479,
0.0000020274,
-0.0238552876,
0.0039207088,
-0.0152095305,
-0.0196235403,
0.0326648057,
0.0724798739,
0.0144539941,
-0.0275157206,
0.0081951311,
-0.0213067308,
-0.0198558327,
0.0526827425,
0.0215942413,
0.0672782958,
0.0212977007,
-0.0254328884,
0.010151403,
0.0112954006,
0.0056312899,
-0.006117132,
-0.0125707826,
-0.0216253102,
-0.0348391198,
0.0204477645,
-0.0613909736,
-0.0252546389,
0.0489169955,
-0.007642475,
0.0373019911,
-0.0386299081,
-0.0090390267,
-0.0186745692,
-0.0533698648,
-0.0356882848,
0.0499909297,
-0.0841152519,
0.0009401294,
-0.0539165884,
0.0013682998,
-0.0251070783,
-0.0308362488,
-0.0131427022,
-0.0227775816,
0.0345612504,
-0.0120089501,
0.0211744253,
0.0707693323,
-0.0113827381,
-0.00331074,
0.0138980784,
0.0113515835,
-0.0037761657,
-0.033019267,
0.0518587045,
-0.0155366613,
0.0040458683,
0.0481834859,
0.0107644647,
-0.0387076847,
-0.0266750231,
-0.0019163614,
-0.0060819555,
-0.0686013401,
-0.0182689521,
-0.0827206746,
0.0337560177,
0.0187827256,
-0.0944810435,
-0.003926598,
-0.0130579378,
0.0436938517,
-0.0074519878,
0.0129816625,
-0.0138576049,
-0.0064407028,
-0.0271304175,
0.0358546712,
-0.0107619315,
0.0354963727,
-0.0166259483,
-0.0058844341,
-0.0803157911,
-0.0023612189,
-0.0394074507,
-0.0009947963,
0.0204828307,
0.0084320102,
0.0115438215,
0.0151469558,
0.0073208571,
0.0423210971,
0.0080454722,
0.0568089485,
-0.054837428,
-0.1051121652,
0.0518352427,
-0.0041667363,
0.0263984613,
-0.0220062882,
0.0542699359,
0.0378821976,
0.0001799083,
-0.0584315062,
-0.0314614363,
0.0239010528,
0.0059408136,
-0.0716127381,
0.0052798302,
-0.0129842162,
0.0604441613,
-0.0072459881,
0.027993571,
-0.0348325595,
-0.0141542917,
-0.0335487984,
-0.0283873565,
0.0573670901,
0.0044848286,
0.0057376609,
-0.003395074,
0.004731636,
-0.0094915777,
0.035137184,
0.0144553725,
0.0295935385,
0.026420353,
-0.068045035,
-0.0075196354,
0.0143005876,
0.0032653494,
-0.0366952009,
-0.0247388743,
-0.0092650149,
0.0369787551,
-0.0024754212,
0.0610131435,
0.0154564232,
-0.0095490981,
-0.0451922938,
0.0670393407,
0.0585399084,
0.0005857197,
0.0182407554,
0.0498761013,
-0.0027074087,
0.0416628197,
-0.0234404877,
-0.0382145457,
-0.0142270438,
-0.0255585406,
0.005707467,
0.0066506853,
0.0130999573,
-0.0375168361,
-0.0425880812,
-0.004487766,
-0.042420648,
-0.0176678449,
0.0456223004,
0.039119482,
-0.0367797725,
-0.044482436,
0.0410679281,
0.0275027007,
-0.0788936019,
0.0204033386,
-0.0277946834,
-0.0048043928,
0.0609198213,
-0.0299898479,
-0.0257253665,
-0.0138525348,
-0.0381722748,
0.0089050625,
0.0057109352,
0.015148459,
0.0234656669,
0.1172498763,
-0.0438345037,
0.0037096783,
-0.0028708535,
-0.0050698961,
0.0451242253,
-0.0249695163,
0.0591717996,
-0.0151642645,
0.00122678,
-0.0015678018,
-0.0140434448,
-0.0592924654,
-0.0500798263,
-0.0097837169,
-0.0011395531,
0.0636880919,
0.0530509092,
-0.0401793942,
-0.0043082526,
0.0279203542,
-0.032554552,
0.0483017713,
0.0645908639,
-0.0069615119,
-0.0193692669,
0.0269632358,
0.0183253195,
0.0214619562,
0.0695608631,
-0.0199917033,
-0.0161725152,
0.0700783581,
-0.0026941993,
0.0668025315,
-0.0488342233,
0.0031368744,
-0.0451492667,
0.0581844486,
0.0596855208,
-0.0365154296,
0.0159738008,
0.0086427145,
-0.0263672043,
0.0118747,
-0.0082005328,
-0.0285364613,
-0.0699115023,
0.0175052397,
-0.0071898336,
0.0294259451,
-0.0012985448,
-0.0274628922,
-0.0027707445,
-0.034716323,
-0.0925478935,
-0.0147831272,
-0.0022916477,
-0.0017111871,
-0.0254075527,
-0.00339125,
-0.0381645747,
-0.0307694208,
-0.0399409793,
-0.0062350966,
0.0235220362,
0.0106599191,
-0.0245177522,
-0.0225149356,
-0.0102528781,
-0.0718362555,
0.0311999675,
0.0089409165,
0.0076098978,
-0.0298512038,
0.000274079,
-0.0134948604,
0.0060503162,
-0.0234056078,
0.0266164001,
0.0145970546,
-0.0720374212,
-0.0174931679,
-0.0210792739,
-0.0025900225,
-0.0015455135,
-0.0275857355,
0.0446572602,
0.0270508621,
-0.0194945373,
-0.027842667,
0.0381853916,
-0.0113641052,
-0.0282607414,
-0.0230981912,
-0.0002397996,
-0.0326263867,
0.0529705435,
0.029142011,
0.0168547854,
-0.0486526079,
-0.0039139651,
0.0118822213,
-0.0267302264,
-0.0243476462,
-0.0192505084,
-0.0246548839,
0.0121408887,
0.0444205627,
-0.0430429429,
0.0132618519,
-0.0751889944,
-0.0608335547,
-0.0885160416,
-0.0226057079,
-0.0165267065,
0.0480820537,
-0.0587390549,
0.0076670418,
-0.0290379357,
-0.0053908164,
-0.0023106085,
-0.0075042481,
-0.0118478341,
-0.0702229366,
-0.0029569138,
0.0098908171,
-0.0430811904,
0.0305906497,
-0.018563455,
-0.0126277059,
-0.0469456054,
-0.0620219409,
0.0082582589,
-0.0350757539,
0.0135632623,
0.0034901216,
0.0023370681,
0.0287481751,
-0.0121411039,
0.0133281434,
-0.0014427069,
0.000470138,
0.0050234501,
-0.0018679891,
0.0566698536,
0.0095392941,
0.0244543143,
0.0283568669,
0.0023616489,
0.0855421349,
-0.0134947821,
-0.0395633802,
0.0585712641,
0.0249512848,
0.0145480102,
-0.0091979867,
-0.0001744878,
-0.0192998275,
-0.0390959047,
0.0807887092,
0.1149860024,
-0.0025306325,
-0.0413240939,
0.0025641348,
-0.0101303058,
-0.0141877867,
0.0142139466,
-0.0017692053,
-0.0007742694,
-0.0002801356,
0.0055397353,
0.0181813315,
0.007695002,
0.0066781631,
0.0040430878,
-0.0691522285,
0.0564360619,
0.0212832261,
-0.0004818214,
-0.0386764854,
-0.0301003344,
-0.0133160707,
-0.0195739903,
0.0542613342,
-0.0498567075,
-0.023482481,
-0.0385988988,
0.0412180163,
-0.0448882654,
-0.04254191,
0.0567906722,
-0.0384576321,
0.0043728254,
0.0022789023,
0.0546958372,
-0.0245272107,
-0.0843694061,
0.0114217177,
-0.0075526289,
-0.0050876332,
-0.0195201728,
0.006965931,
0.0248913504,
-0.0219359547,
0.0070585846,
0.0081442818,
-0.0557696372,
0.0139794871,
-0.0226855632,
0.0829183012,
-0.0375305228,
-0.0043025981,
0.006092187,
0.0642920136,
0.0417820364,
0.0468849875,
0.0272820424,
-0.0344910398,
-0.036681626,
0.0278789476,
0.0325371996,
0.0470184423,
-0.057401713,
0.0341046788,
-0.0141226817,
-0.0484264977,
-0.0286815073,
-0.0708397552,
-0.0137978615,
0.0447515734,
-0.0065882839,
0.0331856161,
-0.0298579596,
0.0031573672,
-0.0474286452,
0.0392817557,
0.0672838092,
0.0163060054,
0.0001558668,
0.0085935025,
0.0443137176,
-0.0127426777,
-0.0351237394,
-0.0284345038,
-0.0312996656,
-0.0586384535,
0.0530966446,
0.0303687882,
0.0094367443,
0.020730814,
-0.0068763737,
-0.0247417856,
0.0735817775,
-0.0128971757,
-0.0587273724,
0.0255560745,
0.0986052454,
0.0230513848,
-0.0367048085,
0.0077662226,
-0.0141144786,
0.0311786253,
0.0106980382,
-0.0164645314,
0.0326597989,
-0.02186835,
-0.0359541215,
0.025278246,
0.0945682079,
0.0140889017,
-0.0003383394,
-0.0233874265,
0.0208496265,
-0.0214037895,
0.0790211037,
-0.0468742922,
-0.0610616542,
0.0022911641,
0.0127301905,
-0.038324587,
-0.0256363545,
-0.0364021212,
-0.0209126193,
0.014405123,
0.0766877756,
0.0153914886,
0.0278394595,
-0.007695253,
0.0599016212,
0.0010707908,
0.0693937466,
-0.0132026989,
-0.0088171139,
-0.0273981206,
0.0083134379,
-0.015900597,
-0.0038123713,
0.0080437195,
0.0505537316,
-0.0140735619,
-0.0711788759,
-0.0089116516,
-0.0164211746,
0.0478893928,
-0.0153947286,
0.0814615414,
-0.0242425911,
0.0401399992,
-0.0037123361,
0.0133779729,
-0.0696236491,
0.011845611,
0.0175985917,
-0.0355299674,
-0.0458194837,
-0.0182040557,
0.0249278322,
0.024514474,
0.0498892702,
0.0062826467,
0.009380023,
-0.0412115827,
-0.0333244726,
0.0387809239,
-0.0221748501,
-0.028649075,
0.0261674728,
-0.0591235086,
-0.0554948561,
0.0263811387,
-0.0387935005,
-0.0382993482,
-0.0361361802,
0.0274423752,
0.0469745696,
-0.0119163031,
0.0290179476,
0.0044557224,
-0.0196096189,
-0.0412028432,
-0.0275038425,
0.0547266528,
-6.242425281e-33,
0.0109142028,
0.0399913527,
-0.0306751784,
0.0329567492,
-0.0256637987,
0.0354659855,
-0.0247191284,
0.0242857542,
-0.0107667325,
0.0083438586,
0.0011595064,
-0.0210221391,
0.023731526,
-0.001265595,
0.013564541,
-0.0438455455,
0.0355652384,
-0.0313013084,
0.0602009483,
0.0015884184,
0.0299439002,
0.0479356945,
0.0917505771,
-0.0887114182,
0.0203774087,
0.0307678748,
-0.0007352321,
-0.025741946,
0.061939355,
0.034830153,
-0.0198752601,
0.0747433379,
-0.0107466187,
0.0164695438,
-0.0171288643,
0.0149060553,
-0.0443280488,
-0.0332231522,
0.0235335454,
0.0518935472,
-0.0467326753,
-0.0065427129,
0.0050710649,
0.0299025774,
-0.0421809033,
-0.0084739225,
-0.002396089,
-0.0256677624,
0.0311812777,
-0.0474843718,
-0.0376564488,
0.0009334051,
-0.008617131,
0.0127584795,
0.08429005,
0.0847773552,
-0.0320665799,
0.0151458886,
-0.0519863293,
-0.0187793076,
-0.0184652265,
-0.0088875415,
0.0452908017,
-0.046409566,
0.0118424334,
0.0559744611,
0.0665218458,
-0.0215175282,
0.0198168457,
0.060270641,
0.049092859,
0.0669392273,
0.037461035,
0.0373114347,
-0.0216617342,
-0.001265374,
0.0072677112,
-0.0078970445,
0.0779443607,
-0.0027192333,
0.0348127745,
0.0124091888,
-0.0162106603,
-0.004683333,
-0.0535254814,
-0.0362626016,
-0.016798187,
-0.067722857,
0.0651034862,
-0.0428402014,
0.043652758,
0.0094581917,
0.0495664142,
-0.0047731763,
0.0129966382,
0.0114914495,
-0.009699624,
0.0280828811,
0.0083881225,
0.0116195604,
-0.0153528005,
-0.0213659108,
0.001660453,
0.0047069006,
0.0851478055,
-0.0303212311,
-0.038429182,
0.0457974747,
-0.02774572,
-0.006558903,
-0.0063151945,
0.0379839987,
0.0169803295,
0.0069524823,
0.0303130914,
0.0242117178,
-0.0138850464,
0.0010249881,
-0.0200243983,
-0.0145327933,
-0.0143623129,
-0.0035436542,
0.014303633,
0.0596341379,
-0.0305624548,
-0.0036630253,
-0.0154602062,
-0.0123803513,
0.0406165384,
-0.0334656276,
0.000215873,
-0.0097787948,
2.879e-7,
-0.0073469188,
0.0247797184,
0.0300288051,
-0.0415425375,
-0.0014629851,
0.0227082651,
-0.0295401849,
0.0277098492,
0.0183953345,
0.0045891893,
-0.0013104185,
-0.0116961692,
0.0907123461,
0.0509985052,
-0.068332471,
-0.0580915436,
-0.0686381161,
0.0256699026,
-0.0226055272,
0.0340778492,
0.0664099753,
0.0970511064,
0.0213697124,
-0.0240722355,
0.0009591423,
0.0198849924,
0.0232984107,
-0.0627769977,
-0.0350766107,
-0.0024297338,
-0.0298212506,
-0.0572571754,
-0.017104663,
0.0160439033,
-0.0180923399,
0.0511512086,
0.012566735,
0.0409239717,
-0.0067239497,
-0.0878740102,
0.021275457,
0.0342464484,
-0.0433860309,
-0.0741082132,
0.0440713577,
0.0009455194,
-0.0270000491,
0.0128149437,
-0.0193136092,
0.019108912,
0.0596001334,
-0.048694618,
-0.0053570834,
0.0359211825,
-0.0036785312,
-0.0355689637,
-0.0347390063,
-0.0360308401,
-0.0092037581,
0.0617932603,
-0.0464824513,
-0.0366504863,
-0.0210171696,
0.0102902027,
0.0649038628,
-0.0194837376,
0.004838068,
2.038760872e-34,
0.0179323666,
-0.0441341251,
0.0372802764,
0.0317684263,
0.0053221118,
-0.0057227709,
0.0603151917,
0.0169586036,
0.0452414267,
-0.008684502,
0.0096969269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01577v1 | Deep Active Learning for Data Mining from Conflict Text Corpora | 2024-02-02T17:16:23 | 2024-02-02T17:16:23 | Mihai Croicu | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, stat.ML | High-resolution event data on armed conflict and related processes have
revolutionized the study of political contention with datasets like UCDP GED,
ACLED etc. However, most of these datasets limit themselves to collecting
spatio-temporal (high-resolution) and intensity data. Information on dynamics,
such as targets, tactics, purposes etc. are rarely collected owing to the
extreme workload of collecting data. However, most datasets rely on a rich
corpus of textual data allowing further mining of further information connected
to each event. This paper proposes one such approach that is inexpensive and
high performance, leveraging active learning - an iterative process of
improving a machine learning model based on sequential (guided) human input.
Active learning is employed to then step-wise train (fine-tuning) of a large,
encoder-only language model adapted for extracting sub-classes of events
relating to conflict dynamics. The approach shows performance similar to human
(gold-standard) coding while reducing the amount of required human annotation
by as much as 99%. | [
0.0127184112,
0.0518014729,
0.0028687436,
0.006827387,
0.00774972,
0.0383960009,
0.0215986483,
-0.0257779993,
0.0010689418,
-0.0323536992,
0.0591488816,
-0.0217339918,
-0.0227275081,
0.0738809109,
0.0005136079,
-0.0553739965,
0.0416611023,
-0.0174769685,
0.0537167266,
0.0071241246,
-0.0212819893,
-0.0019020779,
-0.0465981402,
0.0160410367,
-0.0387298726,
0.0477224961,
-0.064108938,
-0.0344642885,
0.0236132145,
-0.0094971294,
-0.0031155669,
0.0093905032,
0.0518899523,
0.0318118483,
0.0000020048,
-0.0402196683,
-0.0094490005,
-0.03650086,
-0.0357049145,
0.0073725805,
0.0203293953,
-0.0311308242,
-0.003649309,
-0.0088527137,
-0.0501416959,
-0.042928867,
0.0268156584,
0.0156089142,
0.069035165,
0.0717699155,
-0.0190139432,
-0.0134184845,
0.0314062424,
-0.0129636349,
-0.0535713844,
-0.0283252038,
0.0168205276,
-0.0203792285,
-0.0370084494,
0.0384929404,
0.0281024389,
0.0262595974,
0.0281696636,
0.0005384545,
-0.0272924155,
0.0259989947,
-0.0422969088,
0.0277804621,
0.0253012236,
0.014199785,
0.001889038,
-0.0112054236,
0.0130581297,
-0.0295963213,
-0.0173137188,
-0.0130221639,
0.0006836726,
-0.0117044132,
-0.0190283135,
0.0326157473,
0.0236848574,
-0.0005303189,
0.0026098371,
0.0165932346,
-0.0155701777,
-0.0062989658,
-0.0448184386,
-0.0228048973,
0.0349432528,
0.0121135414,
-0.0221631136,
-0.0208702497,
0.0196469631,
0.0352880172,
-0.0437097326,
-0.0163747724,
-0.0210784506,
-0.0192645509,
0.013822305,
-0.1004735306,
-0.0258020889,
-0.0098031508,
-0.0225630105,
0.0765552744,
0.0215289518,
-0.0181361437,
0.0254127625,
0.0302036516,
0.0159865394,
-0.021255333,
-0.0775792599,
0.0008692446,
-0.0145367002,
0.0323161297,
0.0077457991,
-0.0082175629,
-0.063991636,
-0.0134237688,
-0.0037875737,
0.0109044639,
-0.0174964629,
0.0058173207,
-0.0503653958,
-0.0076754992,
-0.0358319841,
-0.0178637728,
-0.0332038142,
0.0451861955,
-0.0367414765,
-0.0555987023,
0.0337165408,
-0.0113040255,
0.0131858652,
-0.0010422572,
-0.0061840429,
0.0495317057,
-0.0417400375,
-0.0065239188,
-0.0697824731,
0.0249172766,
0.0492125079,
0.0165432058,
0.0055639907,
-0.0698255226,
0.035700798,
-0.03132312,
0.0031114588,
-0.065810807,
-0.0109255863,
-0.0060499045,
-0.0267068446,
0.0670426637,
-0.050215546,
0.0017478069,
0.0572199337,
-0.0100134145,
0.0340837836,
0.0844845548,
0.0671837181,
0.0348979458,
0.0670106113,
-0.0073822429,
0.0097838826,
0.0135597913,
-0.0284277387,
0.0210828763,
-0.0567081496,
0.0146038299,
-0.0699172541,
-0.0196259599,
-0.0296844933,
-0.0243717302,
-0.0101735163,
-0.0434969738,
0.0612082258,
-0.0048809662,
-0.0512013026,
0.0105266916,
0.0206430275,
0.0472815111,
0.0216936022,
-0.018569367,
0.0371261314,
-0.0066252891,
-0.0195459891,
-0.0418623574,
0.0188476723,
0.0335407443,
-0.0249148645,
-0.0427408479,
-0.0016643798,
-0.0318775438,
0.0149752125,
0.0241326913,
0.0608004592,
-0.0133695044,
-0.0010864921,
0.0220360905,
0.0816202387,
-0.0296013504,
0.0061697513,
-0.0399589241,
-0.0354080722,
0.0072237053,
0.0167059414,
-0.0752806216,
-0.0776035041,
-0.0823571533,
0.0678141862,
-0.0054528397,
0.0223941728,
-0.0254431982,
0.0526147559,
-0.0550173298,
-0.0480444096,
0.0245596785,
0.0104575213,
-0.0012813482,
-0.0096148169,
0.0062400647,
-0.0184892826,
0.0226505063,
-0.0653640628,
0.0598803237,
0.0024106826,
-0.0433004051,
0.0271847174,
0.0419086888,
0.0596171953,
0.027226001,
-0.0013345018,
-0.0388088189,
0.0389115922,
-0.0344794244,
-0.0048819953,
0.0065267929,
0.0585306548,
0.0853112116,
0.0037336841,
-0.009205387,
-0.0266558994,
0.0008847389,
-0.0296240915,
-0.0068008346,
0.0006606269,
-0.018633619,
-0.0425654724,
-0.0118216043,
0.0142179606,
-0.0304610804,
-0.0005605503,
-0.0710968971,
0.0753246844,
-0.0072077825,
-0.0157191232,
0.0270722825,
-0.0309489723,
0.0591665991,
-0.0099374913,
0.0036595794,
0.0353932194,
-0.0092989765,
-0.0030213783,
0.027381653,
-0.0246914215,
0.0169882439,
-0.0276345368,
-0.0275956579,
-0.0107512521,
-0.0196038894,
-0.0107784318,
0.0515721925,
-0.0226866677,
-0.0244551357,
0.011857748,
0.0164447092,
0.0100846291,
-0.0278176256,
0.0043156329,
0.0259758513,
0.0114596086,
0.0430736654,
-0.0413397737,
-0.0081481067,
-0.0164489672,
0.0566553883,
0.0322758108,
-0.0468673557,
-0.0111735631,
0.0187197793,
-0.0204335321,
0.0535800382,
-0.0394415781,
-0.0773360208,
0.0570876338,
-0.0231049918,
-0.0390927494,
0.0331594795,
0.0387730822,
0.1083377823,
0.0349942371,
-0.0264865384,
-0.0307111517,
0.0325515568,
-0.0717323869,
-0.0345295034,
-0.0667198449,
-0.0131584061,
-0.0205468275,
0.0264814273,
0.0285256729,
0.0363216102,
-0.0142236529,
-0.0173358284,
-0.0213337652,
-0.0135697555,
-0.0638048649,
0.0034671079,
0.0006386747,
0.0515337959,
-0.0117807593,
-0.0061469511,
0.071418263,
0.0297082923,
0.0157780219,
-0.0430743061,
-0.0224330239,
-0.0271281004,
0.0613449365,
0.0126794577,
0.0073799868,
-0.0074763377,
-0.0208640434,
-0.0336591676,
-0.0576523915,
0.026261963,
-0.0413303375,
0.0079090176,
-0.0396206342,
-0.0011352407,
-0.0203635413,
0.0055296249,
-0.0425599553,
-0.0424614251,
0.0133825466,
0.0366695412,
-0.0039147367,
0.0020186137,
-0.0084080184,
0.0392741263,
0.0303445905,
0.0439570211,
0.0475521013,
-0.0302863419,
-0.0424654372,
0.0416239351,
0.0313069187,
-0.0477225147,
-0.0251078382,
-0.024211321,
-0.0431487523,
0.0204955433,
-0.0208143517,
-0.0049747797,
-0.0479833856,
-0.0015379619,
0.054953564,
-0.0434909612,
0.027140094,
-0.0139949881,
0.0031648246,
-0.0525084361,
0.0263537467,
0.0879796818,
0.0636222437,
-0.0742002353,
0.019638475,
0.0214370973,
-0.0147696743,
0.0058459849,
-0.0019493671,
-0.0496539697,
0.0186293051,
0.0030848826,
0.0115354732,
-0.020954486,
-0.0785476938,
0.0149836298,
-0.0723246932,
-0.0167571288,
-0.0065803141,
-0.0259479154,
-0.0417539366,
-0.0711167008,
0.0130476719,
-0.0466650464,
-0.0335987993,
-0.0199456885,
0.0207059346,
-0.000952226,
0.0475589558,
-0.0868351087,
-0.0686533675,
-0.007721982,
-0.0475718528,
0.0222011842,
0.0155010801,
0.0568892211,
-0.0148954242,
0.0638013557,
0.0580768101,
-0.0383138135,
-0.0300201271,
0.0131706139,
0.0800587535,
-0.0060873372,
-0.0414852761,
0.0128184091,
0.0291413926,
0.0153653463,
-0.0087373639,
0.0198172126,
0.0383930579,
-0.0437025689,
0.0644566417,
0.0065917708,
-0.0186867081,
0.0555703118,
-0.009637366,
-0.0107808542,
-0.0127456672,
0.005400979,
-0.0048144548,
0.0497253649,
-0.0395606384,
-0.0470788442,
0.032278724,
-0.0169152673,
-0.0457073897,
-0.0243560709,
-0.0783972219,
0.0631489307,
0.0665258542,
0.0041725147,
0.0124952178,
0.0430010222,
-0.0125604821,
-0.0391016714,
0.0035569761,
0.0078071295,
0.0008142716,
-0.0008515704,
-0.1001123637,
-0.0293905605,
0.0328073241,
-0.0196780134,
0.0544297881,
-0.038738925,
-0.0305521507,
0.0327598825,
-0.0067152334,
0.0190400835,
0.0258078612,
-0.0194370709,
-0.0439245626,
0.0118784364,
0.0127860149,
0.0191165749,
-0.0336894318,
0.0351530202,
-0.0238333847,
0.0185421072,
0.0076105762,
-0.0072711045,
0.0171954837,
0.0430876315,
-0.0537363552,
-0.1120995283,
-0.0819359794,
0.0138244256,
-0.0542402118,
0.0920859575,
-0.0044046235,
-0.0944098607,
-0.0567184053,
0.0162233673,
-0.014177653,
0.0068506608,
0.0126641728,
0.0266500879,
-0.0056723538,
0.023932904,
-0.0274503697,
0.0616792515,
0.0152092595,
0.0324564315,
-0.0385271534,
0.0456164964,
-0.0010484633,
0.0501350611,
-0.0052348301,
0.0275194626,
-0.005022719,
0.0446841046,
-0.0133915059,
0.0086141964,
-0.0114321467,
0.0270420201,
0.0325901806,
0.0609731488,
0.0319089703,
0.014202062,
-0.0398837626,
-0.0279724672,
-0.0420774519,
0.0265055858,
0.0860362425,
-0.0366684943,
0.0139387324,
-0.0184037052,
-0.0157553796,
0.01277347,
0.0062616845,
-0.007641328,
-0.0280086715,
-0.019977171,
0.0545020662,
-0.0264986996,
0.0763668418,
0.0700515658,
0.0076876087,
0.0507479198,
0.0484585725,
-0.0319802538,
-0.0037652492,
-0.0225840323,
0.0457243659,
0.0395505093,
-0.017933432,
0.006089035,
-0.012296509,
-0.0381121039,
-0.0000524892,
-0.0076758787,
-0.0114526022,
0.0035677801,
0.0336707272,
0.0370078348,
0.0057513737,
0.0990789309,
-0.0654868484,
0.0322721638,
0.0204687621,
-0.0068212561,
0.032883022,
-5.865100411e-33,
-0.0278431233,
-0.0167355873,
0.0005376291,
-0.0161571745,
-0.0342573412,
0.0213789959,
-0.0444347709,
-0.0376077928,
-0.0196664166,
0.0280566625,
0.0042671133,
-0.005984982,
0.0182921849,
0.0014030865,
0.0060374402,
-0.0191104878,
0.0288287755,
0.0125448313,
0.0029680936,
0.0147038111,
0.0897115469,
-0.007019747,
0.0235466473,
-0.1191503927,
-0.002421485,
0.0286803059,
0.0003221909,
0.001165515,
0.0720010996,
0.0562556833,
-0.0305069257,
0.0002021467,
0.0190721359,
-0.0368875451,
0.0098184692,
-0.0389252454,
-0.0405034386,
0.0216571037,
-0.0317581259,
0.0319293663,
0.0192050505,
0.012595538,
-0.0071941321,
0.0135023464,
0.0069695762,
0.0077276402,
0.0621009991,
-0.0450660847,
-0.0063357917,
-0.0640478358,
-0.0478523746,
0.0408823565,
-0.0816573054,
0.0018953562,
-0.0019346441,
-0.0129000284,
0.0240836721,
0.005991227,
-0.0915780887,
0.0249002296,
-0.0105103748,
0.0466932282,
-0.0096408529,
-0.0171654169,
0.0061158752,
0.0748169348,
-0.0051181824,
0.0121827815,
-0.0323018208,
0.0250578504,
0.0218898766,
0.0280972142,
0.0227356199,
0.0833198279,
0.0317994282,
-0.0360293463,
-0.1068930253,
0.0143589163,
0.0744794607,
0.0196904838,
0.009740673,
0.0189747829,
0.0007965798,
-0.0181500241,
0.0220902488,
-0.0136593562,
-0.0030843976,
-0.0164070521,
-0.0189583041,
-0.0300997011,
-0.0295598004,
0.0490999706,
0.0303017404,
0.0131247463,
0.034427207,
0.0339418612,
0.010295636,
0.0493259802,
-0.0192319471,
-0.0003624701,
-0.0265537631,
-0.0566543154,
0.0103560658,
-0.0118482104,
0.0436801985,
0.0141578317,
0.0187359639,
0.0268032625,
-0.0176752079,
0.0182393398,
0.0038140903,
0.0047872663,
-0.0102900537,
0.0531038605,
0.000953525,
-0.022220809,
0.0096292663,
0.0352257602,
0.0363220014,
-0.0484537706,
0.0407815501,
-0.0052845427,
-0.0283094011,
-0.0014561536,
0.0096036643,
-0.0130555024,
-0.0353264622,
0.0417229682,
-0.0059424392,
-0.0450531542,
-0.0068823025,
-0.0492026471,
2.641e-7,
0.0241114404,
0.0518388152,
0.0179154761,
-0.0103908451,
-0.0045407349,
0.0425707847,
-0.0005079787,
0.0383615494,
-0.0003125933,
-0.0120631643,
0.0446322896,
0.0449812375,
0.0343521237,
0.0667643324,
-0.0706479698,
-0.0535652898,
-0.0431377031,
0.0018871463,
-0.0850456133,
0.0100446437,
0.0365341231,
0.0404915139,
0.0596507564,
-0.0237244051,
-0.0227988493,
-0.0289929584,
0.0087420195,
0.0028708517,
-0.0531935692,
0.0343473814,
0.02293979,
-0.0207678434,
-0.055828888,
0.037368264,
-0.0219638962,
-0.0119635956,
0.016671313,
0.0466648228,
-0.0134791844,
-0.0104656843,
-0.0181700438,
-0.0545174293,
-0.0171312634,
-0.0117293149,
0.0831959769,
-0.0335069746,
-0.0468125045,
0.0057349415,
-0.036982812,
0.0024460356,
0.0301373545,
0.0139342397,
-0.0082989531,
0.0165324658,
-0.0178042836,
0.0130066946,
-0.0037527627,
-0.0472700261,
-0.0077875517,
-0.0073678358,
-0.0424093232,
-0.0120822834,
0.0343736261,
0.0422225706,
0.0219804794,
0.0572701469,
0.0417802818,
2.315137501e-34,
0.0291864183,
0.059803661,
-0.0130799459,
0.0005552491,
0.0178865865,
0.0162530206,
-0.0160966273,
-0.0028953522,
0.0097103436,
-0.0071700891,
0.008582551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01825v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01825v2 | Fractal Patterns May Illuminate the Success of Next-Token Prediction | 2024-02-02T17:09:33 | 2024-05-22T16:19:13 | Ibrahim Alabdulmohsin, Vinh Q. Tran, Mostafa Dehghani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We study the fractal structure of language, aiming to provide a precise
formalism for quantifying properties that may have been previously suspected
but not formally shown. We establish that language is: (1) self-similar,
exhibiting complexities at all levels of granularity, with no particular
characteristic context length, and (2) long-range dependent (LRD), with a Hurst
parameter of approximately H=0.7. Based on these findings, we argue that
short-term patterns/dependencies in language, such as in paragraphs, mirror the
patterns/dependencies over larger scopes, like entire documents. This may shed
some light on how next-token prediction can capture the structure of text
across multiple levels of granularity, from words and clauses to broader
contexts and intents. In addition, we carry out an extensive analysis across
different domains and architectures, showing that fractal parameters are
robust. Finally, we demonstrate that the tiny variations in fractal parameters
seen across LLMs improve upon perplexity-based bits-per-byte (BPB) in
predicting their downstream performance. We hope these findings offer a fresh
perspective on language and the mechanisms underlying the success of LLMs. | [
-0.0007373157,
-0.0051052794,
-0.0393622294,
0.0220813081,
-0.086827457,
0.0049643982,
-0.0284229591,
0.069324106,
-0.0567673966,
-0.0177856535,
0.0503834113,
-0.1222547814,
0.0075028501,
0.0592628233,
0.0293325074,
-0.0432207957,
0.0335926004,
-0.0502976105,
0.0059616198,
0.0031308588,
0.0041115005,
-0.0497822538,
0.0343118012,
0.0070736264,
-0.0231767986,
-0.020418074,
-0.0524100475,
0.022261057,
-0.0092058768,
-0.0217057895,
-0.033323504,
0.0295714792,
-0.0433431119,
0.0417426452,
0.0000018703,
-0.0805810466,
0.0039391858,
-0.0088476324,
0.0048820726,
0.0348870642,
0.009009636,
0.0021293086,
-0.0332362279,
-0.0067607271,
-0.0092487885,
-0.0072479751,
0.0217878576,
0.0720003992,
0.0019911483,
0.0994209349,
-0.0303017329,
-0.0477984101,
0.0337704122,
0.0105932597,
0.0408057198,
0.028195262,
0.0223289635,
-0.0273004249,
0.0061387122,
0.0042756014,
-0.0273270197,
-0.0150471339,
0.0119622173,
0.0062144441,
-0.0250681937,
0.0445699058,
0.0227155462,
0.000758249,
-0.000078134,
0.03755242,
-0.0089540537,
0.00930769,
0.0370167084,
-0.0029973844,
-0.0174032077,
0.0339345261,
-0.0477058515,
0.0016174909,
-0.0325566493,
0.0206278805,
0.0358931646,
0.0049652136,
0.0258036312,
-0.0070261052,
-0.0510290526,
0.066071637,
-0.0077877762,
-0.0382007211,
-0.050998006,
-0.0574763566,
0.0481291339,
-0.0634153113,
-0.0219626762,
-0.0018540127,
0.0301613417,
-0.0018355401,
-0.0409127921,
0.0184042696,
0.0517938361,
-0.01933931,
0.0293313712,
0.0228052754,
-0.0082205534,
0.0395484567,
-0.0135167167,
-0.0110704778,
-0.0567220449,
0.039905943,
-0.0087283626,
0.0344989114,
0.005757146,
0.0107957274,
-0.0071503776,
0.066116184,
0.0087074339,
-0.0249169357,
-0.0299068578,
0.0055843629,
0.0271183699,
-0.0121456319,
-0.036110539,
-0.0270853862,
0.0344565399,
-0.0063829911,
-0.0456664748,
-0.0196755063,
-0.0486666746,
-0.0102615394,
-0.0050348053,
-0.0202411748,
-0.01985351,
0.0368116461,
-0.0030299618,
0.0014204457,
-0.0037263387,
0.0892444029,
0.038516473,
-0.0366075113,
-0.0383233652,
-0.0181741435,
-0.0128852241,
-0.0268810373,
0.0112349,
-0.0556358732,
-0.0375968404,
0.0321064033,
-0.0364904106,
0.0225940719,
-0.0175649282,
0.0287028048,
-0.0171485338,
0.0863158405,
-0.0251350831,
0.0027844252,
-0.0313495584,
0.0002922786,
-0.0130798537,
0.0605409965,
0.0372696742,
0.0491589792,
0.0489582792,
-0.0092260065,
-0.0077965073,
0.0255651977,
-0.0206994042,
0.0058609513,
-0.0355570093,
-0.0024269449,
0.0193852764,
0.0102988183,
0.0357380174,
0.0652229711,
-0.0246918816,
-0.0575825237,
0.0427801386,
0.1079499871,
0.0304200836,
0.0236629471,
0.0013627536,
0.0245863646,
0.0272352565,
0.0553096309,
-0.018231729,
-0.0032312553,
0.0408402868,
0.0270271953,
0.0768020377,
0.0420568511,
-0.0039727837,
-0.0572083443,
-0.0475809723,
-0.0326827131,
-0.0100982534,
-0.0884206742,
0.0311251152,
-0.0093243867,
-0.0487058498,
0.0415910929,
0.0186834726,
-0.0176776871,
-0.0347609594,
-0.054781545,
0.0278403461,
0.0888969675,
0.0500884205,
-0.0417606682,
0.0137378601,
0.0115828738,
0.011407068,
0.0160260331,
-0.0229745712,
0.0366935469,
0.0112948595,
-0.0549272262,
0.0010055214,
0.0218746141,
-0.0123144323,
0.0324128196,
-0.0033184381,
0.0284842998,
-0.0164797902,
-0.015531077,
0.0000534875,
0.0126925819,
0.04859161,
0.0195412859,
0.0198723357,
-0.0014038676,
0.0491819084,
0.0089359246,
-0.028835332,
0.0249243658,
0.041532699,
-0.0386780053,
-0.0270813368,
-0.0190370604,
-0.062129885,
0.0008347376,
0.010941226,
0.0127403615,
0.0315540545,
-0.0126112578,
0.0070796851,
-0.0144949201,
0.0240121372,
-0.0680723414,
0.0799785405,
-0.0222369339,
0.0268094484,
0.0034768602,
0.0515069366,
-0.0303281862,
0.0295423362,
-0.0145122064,
0.0421316251,
-0.0136798089,
0.0371571966,
0.0371788554,
0.0213872958,
0.0123447329,
0.0218268689,
-0.0250890777,
-0.0057015186,
0.0198667478,
-0.0252307206,
-0.0289335568,
-0.0517882109,
0.0064938087,
-0.0239393152,
-0.0143548651,
0.0314031504,
0.0042642732,
0.0032085853,
-0.0442457013,
-0.0463243686,
-0.0127224531,
0.0235864241,
0.004690601,
-0.0063065151,
0.0708632767,
-0.0133523205,
-0.0604956076,
-0.0188550204,
-0.0235624257,
-0.0380472392,
0.0523932539,
-0.0080296798,
-0.0165134873,
-0.0581966117,
0.0399505086,
0.0015354665,
-0.0230718851,
-0.042810943,
-0.0499427244,
0.0186361726,
-0.0589214005,
0.0560144,
0.031842526,
0.031537205,
0.0199263096,
0.0111371512,
-0.0049926396,
-0.0055152806,
-0.0179707743,
-0.0269712638,
0.0898609906,
-0.0543546826,
-0.033263389,
0.0245841704,
0.0720298588,
0.0031657282,
0.0092726937,
-0.0110554984,
0.0414354317,
0.0212400537,
0.0017779465,
0.048937019,
0.0114420895,
-0.0580106713,
0.0568560846,
-0.013365671,
-0.1000115797,
0.0342599824,
-0.0150460061,
0.0005260604,
0.0092578642,
-0.017700972,
-0.0449655429,
0.0912997574,
0.0415562764,
-0.0023548375,
0.0183524583,
-0.0514743775,
-0.0278329439,
0.0055534639,
-0.0199650303,
-0.0156798456,
0.0393087789,
0.0037347774,
0.006108514,
-0.0006133982,
-0.0281080678,
-0.0131982872,
-0.014710499,
0.0415367261,
-0.0208694078,
0.0422032699,
-0.0524516888,
-0.0247844886,
0.0238617063,
-0.0074000335,
0.0180222299,
-0.0391290709,
-0.0308501888,
-0.0217048638,
0.0718719587,
0.0299644843,
0.0011250551,
0.0672129616,
0.0044792043,
0.0347308964,
0.054741405,
0.0280113686,
0.0129581178,
0.0000104827,
-0.0120037049,
0.0108979363,
-0.03294985,
-0.0512363799,
0.0708899051,
0.063884154,
-0.0441418886,
0.0074029248,
0.1135173962,
-0.0082775662,
-0.0021222555,
0.0019459444,
-0.0291052591,
0.0633281991,
0.0120119881,
-0.011327859,
-0.0672598183,
-0.0081620617,
0.0105658313,
0.0030072599,
-0.0065764668,
-0.0312440637,
0.0098701129,
-0.0495091006,
0.0239727218,
-0.0008611226,
0.0017455387,
0.0096460888,
-0.0588753447,
-0.0101882983,
0.0417266078,
-0.0260693282,
0.0149217127,
-0.0213035215,
-0.0068507046,
0.0127770929,
-0.0661090016,
0.0316954143,
-0.0048137642,
-0.0269250721,
0.019566413,
0.0092820683,
0.02346031,
-0.0270213354,
0.0007188261,
-0.0238324068,
0.0316278152,
0.0262042917,
-0.0235236101,
0.0802523345,
0.0490585566,
0.0057022241,
-0.044337295,
-0.0405723676,
-0.0140071269,
-0.0083446279,
-0.0125773354,
0.0381625965,
-0.0387891084,
-0.0683339834,
-0.0664244369,
-0.008206035,
-0.0541178286,
0.0829034746,
0.0188438036,
-0.0222513117,
-0.1190482974,
-0.0397256836,
0.0428180136,
-0.0483843908,
0.0112506347,
-0.0041249897,
0.0190923642,
-0.0358784758,
-0.0380998887,
-0.021676233,
-0.0403682962,
0.0661038309,
-0.0043404247,
0.0338363312,
0.0301623866,
-0.0112726567,
-0.0695492253,
-0.056401398,
0.019828042,
0.0120102083,
-0.0757463947,
-0.002033435,
0.0073052784,
-0.0124492981,
-0.0096275415,
-0.0014037272,
-0.0669604316,
-0.0556565337,
0.0260820854,
0.0061287484,
0.0193799436,
0.0103935776,
0.0404901132,
-0.0405110791,
0.0522098951,
0.0442032963,
-0.0588531978,
0.0253920499,
0.0173692964,
-0.0074389358,
0.0092234043,
0.0342313163,
0.0036845903,
0.0031757487,
-0.0310556479,
0.015484646,
-0.0193193182,
-0.0341396891,
0.0113682561,
-0.0045035048,
0.0277113672,
0.0026542791,
-0.0024639415,
0.0506040789,
0.028613437,
-0.0246410202,
0.0321491361,
-0.0133923292,
-0.0297134016,
-0.008179469,
-0.0072428491,
-0.0290543512,
0.0002761346,
-0.0150671899,
-0.0065505868,
0.0331946686,
0.0072620269,
-0.0503341779,
0.0124288695,
0.0467674248,
-0.0397538953,
0.0295695513,
-0.0080670789,
-0.019402191,
0.0407089964,
-0.0215968993,
0.0261979606,
0.0159174707,
0.0075305668,
-0.0034415654,
0.0445354842,
-0.089081943,
-0.0480578728,
0.0010898357,
-0.015816994,
0.01103009,
-0.0064812684,
0.0348882116,
-0.0518334694,
0.0298825111,
-0.0083051594,
0.0107742809,
-0.0108619742,
-0.0076950332,
0.0039807926,
0.0243839584,
-0.0530276299,
-0.0056330143,
0.0593470819,
0.0209684037,
0.0002461064,
0.0098720174,
-0.0190250017,
-0.0241836309,
-0.0290296786,
-0.0074739256,
0.0523901731,
0.0094122523,
-0.0122866053,
-0.0697311834,
-0.0559951775,
0.0770904645,
0.0134982932,
0.0207877755,
-0.0257186517,
0.0277586617,
0.0709218606,
0.0083871353,
-0.0450300276,
-0.033011999,
0.0094976099,
0.0132791651,
-0.0019890305,
0.0077639259,
-5.764431442e-33,
0.0023514426,
-0.036201492,
-0.003212407,
0.0533689298,
0.0133384401,
0.0085523603,
-0.0057076914,
-0.0116606038,
0.0395744033,
-0.0081465356,
-0.022064697,
0.0081120636,
0.0124410763,
0.0123761911,
0.0322353803,
-0.0152624492,
0.0253512524,
-0.0277225804,
0.0092425318,
0.0247215498,
0.0004398637,
0.0116341254,
0.0277624168,
-0.0184565447,
-0.0132272653,
-0.0005228983,
0.0236866362,
-0.0142952409,
0.0172573365,
0.0290726274,
-0.0141303334,
0.0140145458,
0.0284957234,
-0.0238827933,
-0.0432699621,
0.0302548222,
-0.0460446589,
-0.0485373139,
0.0004888228,
0.0114726266,
0.0045397864,
-0.0444893464,
0.0627120361,
-0.0095268432,
-0.0530551821,
-0.0227270629,
0.0271688923,
0.0247550309,
-0.0107313516,
-0.0362515189,
-0.0229787268,
0.0459583737,
-0.0021595031,
0.0201978385,
-0.0082551474,
-0.019779576,
0.0279085841,
-0.011889128,
-0.0567289628,
0.0596916787,
-0.0131753227,
0.072676383,
-0.0171610713,
0.0267520323,
0.009464453,
0.0865156353,
0.1305291951,
0.0185998827,
-0.0009911733,
-0.0178061277,
0.0392064638,
-0.004449409,
-0.0035562066,
0.0077741784,
0.0741471648,
0.0207430795,
-0.0676453412,
0.0250309035,
0.0250598956,
0.0332402214,
0.0044567711,
0.0058170757,
-0.0827059224,
-0.0247755833,
0.009885083,
0.0635035634,
0.004670369,
-0.0493951514,
0.0174252503,
-0.0379086994,
0.0585921854,
-0.0136338556,
-0.0023603973,
-0.0396576859,
-0.0367451459,
-0.0460204668,
-0.0272844341,
0.0295259561,
0.0042525223,
0.0129743498,
-0.016571654,
-0.0443429798,
-0.0342003182,
-0.0139635131,
0.0167129599,
0.0095705921,
0.0045656054,
0.0109076099,
-0.1265535206,
-0.0119189704,
0.0297947656,
-0.0279821064,
0.0296460185,
-0.0452506468,
0.0487655289,
-0.0054190457,
0.0079061417,
0.0281602647,
0.0148832817,
-0.0032404431,
-0.0351577587,
-0.0428735204,
-0.0143034207,
0.0607933961,
-0.0489262529,
-0.0208674688,
-0.1006198078,
0.0378638878,
0.0063565038,
-0.0808451846,
-0.0302961525,
0.0454935357,
2.708e-7,
0.0339917876,
0.0844952613,
0.056082163,
0.0276840776,
0.0317610465,
0.0105102733,
-0.0140965944,
0.0059015197,
-0.0444934703,
-0.00319552,
-0.0075268387,
-0.0190972853,
0.0181479473,
0.0091480194,
-0.1354997903,
0.0572695769,
-0.0383734815,
-0.012906923,
-0.0503294691,
0.0499609746,
0.0205072165,
0.0649330765,
0.0014671832,
-0.0017473749,
0.0013161381,
-0.055318106,
0.0214610193,
-0.0211779661,
0.0165455267,
0.020857675,
-0.0113785034,
-0.0448011197,
-0.0010384653,
0.009698065,
0.0193634816,
0.008264333,
-0.0248074159,
0.0160017144,
0.0080883019,
0.0032244013,
0.0193562303,
-0.0466057397,
-0.0098819435,
-0.0405646637,
0.052618444,
0.0254828874,
-0.0564927459,
-0.0043348605,
0.0173060503,
-0.0029458839,
0.014341386,
0.0445528328,
-0.0227878056,
0.0219563302,
0.0028407054,
-0.0530724227,
0.0469276905,
-0.0371884406,
-0.0243114792,
0.0300838761,
-0.0228677243,
-0.0501271039,
-0.1099808887,
0.0293846745,
0.0456906594,
-0.0481676236,
-0.0200590212,
2.841390251e-34,
0.0578550622,
-0.0269870739,
0.0095129358,
0.0380321257,
-0.0036591599,
-0.0313223153,
0.0136118168,
0.0420675427,
0.0145934047,
-0.0498531163,
-0.0330046006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01822v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01822v2 | Building Guardrails for Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T16:35:00 | 2024-05-29T12:57:01 | Yi Dong, Ronghui Mu, Gaojie Jin, Yi Qi, Jinwei Hu, Xingyu Zhao, Jie Meng, Wenjie Ruan, Xiaowei Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As Large Language Models (LLMs) become more integrated into our daily lives,
it is crucial to identify and mitigate their risks, especially when the risks
can have profound impacts on human users and societies. Guardrails, which
filter the inputs or outputs of LLMs, have emerged as a core safeguarding
technology. This position paper takes a deep look at current open-source
solutions (Llama Guard, Nvidia NeMo, Guardrails AI), and discusses the
challenges and the road towards building more complete solutions. Drawing on
robust evidence from previous research, we advocate for a systematic approach
to construct guardrails for LLMs, based on comprehensive consideration of
diverse contexts across various LLMs applications. We propose employing
socio-technical methods through collaboration with a multi-disciplinary team to
pinpoint precise technical requirements, exploring advanced neural-symbolic
implementations to embrace the complexity of the requirements, and developing
verification and testing to ensure the utmost quality of the final product. | [
0.0229296051,
0.1093415618,
-0.0501866527,
0.0632097349,
-0.0362375118,
-0.033442311,
0.0076895463,
0.024274243,
0.052227024,
-0.0300230626,
0.0210824087,
-0.0299914312,
-0.027908938,
0.0491696522,
0.0555135794,
-0.0257069301,
0.0545484722,
-0.0676601008,
0.0072435346,
0.0040628961,
0.0163452756,
0.0174357239,
0.0393290929,
0.0392678566,
-0.0228685159,
-0.0170795061,
0.0063491496,
-0.0095786275,
0.0245955326,
-0.0180958714,
-0.0018659625,
0.0193461124,
0.0057777381,
0.0914692283,
0.0000022735,
-0.0593208559,
-0.0078331772,
0.0128645655,
0.001795695,
0.0028870637,
0.0271923281,
-0.0352230109,
-0.0478083491,
0.0268605482,
-0.0230527893,
0.0181389991,
0.0352500379,
0.0228240117,
0.0805794895,
0.0590950698,
-0.0087387348,
-0.0114976335,
0.0345328152,
0.0016243944,
-0.0646219254,
-0.0161173549,
0.0343110748,
-0.0228859168,
0.0034828719,
-0.0021417532,
-0.0040399013,
0.0601419806,
0.0428870022,
-0.0300691668,
-0.0373627245,
0.0066319015,
-0.057269495,
-0.0293097347,
-0.035898935,
0.0658642128,
-0.0525157861,
-0.0334403515,
0.0303823855,
-0.0140959583,
0.0052996832,
-0.0256622769,
-0.0179634914,
0.0421376824,
-0.0019072532,
0.0259806029,
0.0209688507,
-0.0177638829,
0.056874536,
0.0257560238,
-0.0043022982,
0.0825198889,
0.0246800724,
-0.0235340279,
0.0125320796,
-0.0154679175,
0.0244501773,
-0.063778542,
0.05354321,
0.0347698666,
-0.0332623832,
0.0174675677,
-0.0526546761,
-0.0357384905,
0.030138297,
-0.0847119465,
0.0267873239,
0.0295654479,
-0.0026202593,
0.0166056249,
-0.0044991993,
0.0395188667,
-0.0480297767,
0.0488859378,
0.0220200904,
0.0107432371,
-0.005402056,
-0.0087345596,
-0.0255979616,
0.029446248,
-0.0347370803,
0.0116975419,
0.013095852,
0.0393804125,
-0.0576863848,
0.0472697206,
-0.0283307377,
0.0077503747,
0.0555936694,
-0.0250122808,
0.0046037249,
-0.0146782035,
-0.0150724659,
0.004498038,
-0.0242834501,
-0.0656153336,
0.026747236,
0.0314610377,
-0.0462215245,
-0.004895471,
0.0018526677,
0.1069914922,
0.0398307964,
0.0019115676,
-0.0608157031,
-0.0562746488,
-0.0118702371,
-0.0555835031,
0.0172944088,
-0.0543324873,
-0.0110446652,
-0.0278654899,
-0.006834202,
-0.0973167717,
-0.0037126285,
0.0250022616,
-0.0030154057,
0.0292730834,
-0.0033561375,
-0.023021521,
0.0321477316,
0.0410510972,
0.018798897,
0.0659563467,
0.0621605776,
0.0107731931,
0.0592401549,
0.0043071313,
0.0122150732,
0.062433593,
-0.0043462226,
0.0256459918,
-0.079588905,
-0.0110067995,
0.0028235279,
0.0095418794,
-0.0099000931,
0.0997535959,
0.0060304599,
-0.0494812988,
0.083073698,
0.0554670319,
-0.0347539149,
0.0141074732,
0.0298824329,
-0.0016816078,
-0.0087902118,
-0.0271864515,
-0.0315982401,
-0.0091179507,
-0.0424556285,
-0.0250018761,
-0.0258923061,
0.0727785155,
-0.0119657023,
-0.02332405,
-0.0218453147,
-0.0337176062,
0.0331756659,
0.0034022194,
0.0192712266,
-0.0307970196,
-0.0066177035,
0.0478167757,
0.004920667,
-0.0317825153,
0.0158532988,
-0.0773961246,
0.0309985671,
0.0688280016,
0.0475321747,
-0.0278896894,
-0.0115183899,
-0.029362021,
-0.0208153538,
0.0602321588,
0.0068340725,
-0.0037062459,
0.0254746862,
-0.0545228161,
0.0141366543,
0.0255298689,
0.0197460633,
0.0143449539,
0.0106263384,
0.044273071,
-0.0018934254,
0.0298083369,
-0.0792543963,
0.0397597812,
-0.0292822719,
-0.0372423939,
-0.0197460093,
0.0088409102,
-0.0057991454,
0.0259784013,
-0.0076919799,
0.0084717581,
0.0349702947,
-0.0229582619,
0.002216286,
-0.0328708813,
-0.0473084152,
0.054808367,
0.068881385,
-0.0263736453,
0.0012719821,
0.0584275946,
-0.0319412164,
-0.0133421645,
0.0614301339,
-0.018133482,
0.014754409,
-0.0288932994,
0.0052100555,
-0.0448820591,
0.0255053882,
-0.0224832855,
0.0110804206,
-0.0047898968,
-0.0331569463,
0.0397666544,
-0.033917807,
0.0347491652,
-0.0253465809,
-0.0723158643,
0.0178139545,
-0.0080026733,
0.0563688427,
0.0061445707,
0.0208331551,
-0.0174010992,
0.0046377908,
-0.0355288908,
-0.0152363842,
-0.0181196742,
0.0213447455,
0.0008603242,
-0.0208974816,
-0.0270616356,
-0.0174517129,
0.0139019797,
0.0021311131,
0.0001907214,
-0.0086898366,
0.0213955957,
-0.0152817853,
-0.0737314746,
-0.0232519507,
-0.0136646284,
-0.0364893563,
0.044573158,
-0.0153353494,
-0.0408000499,
-0.0676916614,
-0.0025382296,
-0.0279023312,
0.0533042401,
0.009448817,
-0.0128612453,
0.0362252668,
0.0255279485,
0.0073366119,
0.0294917673,
-0.0128383311,
0.0066879471,
0.0831521675,
-0.0097287549,
-0.0444768518,
-0.0118021555,
0.0175974518,
-0.0017530518,
-0.0240123961,
0.0112484451,
0.0088803684,
0.052388832,
-0.012840908,
-0.0198637694,
-0.0550078787,
0.0495191142,
-0.0619842522,
-0.0210637394,
-0.0122472644,
-0.0819197521,
-0.048825305,
0.0498514138,
-0.0040760487,
-0.0380822271,
0.0874425322,
-0.0350742675,
0.0148878787,
-0.0076671853,
-0.0375752598,
-0.0462850332,
0.0534482747,
-0.0264792088,
0.0297530219,
0.0601847544,
-0.0124544669,
-0.0297165923,
-0.0143749379,
-0.0144739086,
-0.0142151676,
0.0315483324,
-0.0638634115,
-0.0058448715,
-0.0082281148,
-0.0392888375,
-0.0282027535,
-0.0319512598,
-0.0609601028,
0.028453663,
0.0152828367,
-0.0010754575,
0.0308658592,
0.0190197844,
-0.0062969197,
0.0097889146,
0.0010916645,
-0.0043114405,
-0.035679426,
0.0003282374,
0.0293377377,
-0.021497706,
0.0550311096,
-0.0115849087,
0.0137326084,
0.0440589003,
0.0211372618,
-0.0241499972,
-0.0468185991,
-0.0168498401,
0.052821096,
-0.0139892343,
-0.0089721121,
0.0429587029,
0.0177182071,
-0.068907246,
0.0008314807,
0.0696056336,
0.0117749879,
-0.0237204172,
0.0347442664,
-0.0433324352,
0.0385580137,
0.0227914639,
0.0407355055,
-0.0927337036,
-0.0006502002,
0.0320210829,
0.0063894778,
-0.0115361325,
-0.0148336301,
-0.0294256415,
-0.0716526806,
0.0438569635,
0.0317740068,
-0.0552656874,
0.0062317229,
-0.0080820527,
-0.0243747476,
-0.0013016018,
0.0341290496,
-0.0027238973,
-0.0093799513,
-0.0478913896,
0.0171212498,
-0.0598311685,
-0.0251787249,
0.0138266981,
-0.0583072379,
0.0426551662,
0.0386666805,
0.0193070583,
-0.0187784061,
-0.0559158176,
0.064503774,
-0.0062253978,
-0.0042010313,
-0.0056528719,
0.0144203575,
0.0237409454,
-0.0231382772,
-0.0227186643,
0.0123446984,
-0.0293339025,
-0.0397372581,
0.0185952876,
0.1072970554,
-0.0299944188,
-0.0258499123,
-0.0356941968,
-0.014414411,
0.015595587,
0.0433111042,
0.0096969176,
-0.0534710288,
-0.0383361727,
-0.0423288308,
-0.0146863088,
-0.0325857587,
-0.051568035,
-0.0061204853,
0.0047131851,
-0.0570528656,
-0.0355088077,
-0.0183834583,
-0.0240286663,
0.0066536181,
0.0500982925,
-0.0209201854,
0.0801161453,
-0.0362369008,
0.0147584798,
0.0140152946,
-0.0771291927,
0.0469809994,
-0.0369082876,
0.0732603148,
-0.0072146384,
0.0073559945,
0.0012299366,
0.0332170129,
-0.0568907745,
-0.1061406434,
0.0153261451,
0.0697770193,
0.0343789682,
-0.005440522,
-0.0251152683,
-0.0754228458,
0.073128581,
0.0327253751,
-0.0279120877,
0.0098252092,
0.0349066965,
-0.0571044944,
0.0049189948,
0.0381045304,
-0.0168666616,
-0.0335150287,
-0.0002381908,
-0.0015988896,
-0.0417024456,
-0.0284417141,
-0.0108800065,
0.0286439322,
-0.013373266,
-0.0544013977,
0.0053860154,
-0.0481074415,
0.0111475941,
-0.0119443852,
-0.000664523,
-0.0057537886,
0.0354891159,
0.0045361351,
-0.0131717762,
-0.0021346163,
-0.0191367082,
0.0014488001,
0.0414891727,
-0.0214717183,
0.0274371691,
0.0078022047,
0.0520059951,
0.033285547,
0.0036405616,
-0.0047861235,
0.0478875935,
-0.0304746125,
0.0469174609,
-0.034918543,
0.0208725948,
0.0071844091,
0.0106287533,
-0.0286164116,
0.0401411615,
-0.0011817206,
-0.0700799376,
-0.0047747516,
0.0440792665,
0.0493408479,
0.0286728926,
0.0333863981,
-0.0374746472,
0.0011664996,
-0.0311702155,
-0.0177817717,
-0.0098598553,
-0.0558000132,
0.0068403687,
0.0129678408,
-0.0205388907,
0.0065877466,
0.0410561264,
0.0014602329,
0.0441382155,
0.0193628352,
-0.0262310859,
-0.0325981043,
-0.0281284507,
0.0228174403,
0.0120527241,
-0.0777534992,
-0.0376497209,
-0.1120008752,
-0.0772297233,
-0.0029906842,
0.0406703763,
-0.022905929,
-0.01393383,
-0.0030525629,
0.0001372921,
0.037541192,
-0.0107843429,
-0.0306726266,
-0.0279122535,
-0.0211969372,
-0.0091293883,
0.0029961008,
-6.64329163e-33,
-0.0013918936,
-0.0273014791,
0.0339697786,
-0.0085348086,
0.0047550863,
-0.007161492,
-0.0166181959,
-0.0013202281,
-0.0015082911,
-0.0054337564,
-0.0033348284,
-0.0062866169,
0.0125394044,
-0.0087905983,
0.0334414132,
-0.0120837856,
0.0184688475,
0.0033659798,
-0.0001371897,
0.0283053759,
0.0369057991,
-0.0140787298,
0.0179120488,
-0.0913355798,
0.0625141338,
0.0115745533,
-0.0081186583,
0.0242836848,
-0.0653155372,
0.0670472234,
-0.0182762798,
0.0480418317,
0.0076840785,
-0.041517809,
-0.0096644023,
0.0351401903,
-0.0283020493,
-0.0363650583,
0.0198599175,
0.0331087336,
-0.0150740258,
-0.0704038888,
0.0654003471,
-0.0086935451,
-0.0309980344,
0.0395700932,
0.0073063327,
-0.0131722428,
-0.0041512749,
-0.0264343508,
-0.0530231334,
0.0125586456,
-0.01441315,
0.0201119892,
0.0146174226,
0.0128316525,
-0.0083644781,
-0.0124114919,
-0.0809785053,
0.0074459175,
0.0042842552,
-0.0069420235,
0.0900626779,
0.0189106781,
-0.0223004743,
0.0480010733,
-0.0047935937,
-0.0217125975,
0.0042144507,
-0.0177229643,
0.0573106296,
0.0383548439,
0.0376315154,
0.0218796376,
0.0145194698,
-0.0477732569,
-0.0837703645,
0.0139568038,
-0.0058692,
0.0693420842,
0.0287025794,
0.029072579,
-0.0319387615,
-0.0337887146,
-0.0184871163,
-0.0495966151,
-0.0157175157,
-0.005804901,
0.0246481001,
-0.0037677449,
-0.0223979522,
0.0027187357,
0.0209225342,
-0.0654195845,
-0.0221039541,
0.0024990756,
0.0149401464,
-0.0229838658,
0.0266112406,
0.045683492,
-0.0235296898,
-0.0157088451,
-0.0358345471,
-0.0281577129,
0.0546021648,
-0.0176733006,
0.0271186791,
0.0655880868,
-0.0579335317,
0.0287059899,
-0.0364356264,
0.0448868759,
0.043826323,
0.0284769293,
0.0105716549,
-0.0239885524,
0.0207004175,
0.0135685196,
0.0619036034,
-0.0164905917,
0.0134830354,
0.0807533711,
0.0054644984,
0.0165912956,
-0.010830855,
-0.0095830811,
-0.0311376303,
0.0783907697,
0.0789849386,
-0.0759272277,
-0.0096536884,
-0.0216476992,
2.876e-7,
0.0060915831,
0.0438520536,
0.0393359102,
0.0047804723,
0.026862165,
0.0574631579,
-0.0134992283,
0.0374369435,
-0.0377791859,
0.0049043801,
-0.0165423118,
0.024471093,
0.0478016511,
0.0502349697,
-0.0741532072,
0.0052376296,
-0.0679342523,
0.006387325,
-0.0751543865,
-0.0105136549,
0.0417936929,
0.0644063577,
0.0240375753,
-0.0348316319,
-0.0214104205,
-0.0718101934,
0.0138099408,
-0.0080246814,
0.0256812032,
0.0146488464,
0.04875388,
0.0335687175,
0.0047986093,
0.000264097,
-0.002426004,
0.0285267737,
-0.0495604761,
0.071030274,
-0.0039107925,
0.0045131608,
0.0113742808,
-0.056580767,
-0.0268546641,
-0.0635678694,
0.0607445538,
0.0291679297,
-0.0195364673,
-0.0487359352,
0.0239395257,
-0.0400727913,
0.0284751263,
-0.0241020396,
-0.0018939892,
-0.0020386658,
0.0068476228,
-0.0244176537,
0.0059529631,
-0.0470214859,
-0.0369243249,
-0.0039977231,
-0.0185931958,
-0.0291902833,
-0.0209553204,
0.0444149934,
-0.0101705426,
-0.0452940576,
0.0255424604,
2.709047954e-34,
0.0074084569,
-0.0267149489,
0.0019925346,
0.0189181771,
0.0196038354,
0.0284826271,
-0.0473528169,
0.0056763007,
0.0030272959,
-0.0208506435,
-0.0218610223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01535v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01535v2 | An Empirical Analysis of Diversity in Argument Summarization | 2024-02-02T16:26:52 | 2024-02-14T10:51:08 | Michiel van der Meer, Piek Vossen, Catholijn M. Jonker, Pradeep K. Murukannaiah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Presenting high-level arguments is a crucial task for fostering participation
in online societal discussions. Current argument summarization approaches miss
an important facet of this task -- capturing diversity -- which is important
for accommodating multiple perspectives. We introduce three aspects of
diversity: those of opinions, annotators, and sources. We evaluate approaches
to a popular argument summarization task called Key Point Analysis, which shows
how these approaches struggle to (1) represent arguments shared by few people,
(2) deal with data from various sources, and (3) align with subjectivity in
human-provided annotations. We find that both general-purpose LLMs and
dedicated KPA models exhibit this behavior, but have complementary strengths.
Further, we observe that diversification of training data may ameliorate
generalization. Addressing diversity in argument summarization requires a mix
of strategies to deal with subjectivity. | [
0.0421890281,
-0.0002276112,
0.0396163873,
0.023496788,
0.005325079,
0.0221053548,
-0.0338071659,
-0.0372554176,
-0.0075020157,
-0.0756919533,
0.0077124252,
-0.0328449607,
0.0107170753,
-0.0124089038,
-0.006154025,
-0.107820116,
-0.0076091224,
0.020665694,
0.0661180392,
-0.0275947396,
0.0321693309,
-0.0060824025,
-0.0326968469,
0.0568543077,
-0.0181349181,
-0.0213009808,
-0.0058745253,
-0.014826146,
0.0844317004,
-0.012155449,
0.0072932248,
0.0359104685,
-0.0066462047,
-0.0083379736,
0.0000015089,
-0.0348142795,
0.0120360767,
-0.0169672947,
0.0003281071,
0.0319799036,
0.0306672752,
0.0269464683,
0.029756628,
0.0246271137,
-0.0096108271,
0.012456038,
0.0262953341,
0.1106156558,
0.0986927375,
0.0606025234,
0.004057704,
-0.0428630076,
-0.0033386038,
-0.0238411278,
-0.0511139892,
-0.0064118477,
0.0037706192,
0.0152375586,
-0.0223224331,
0.022288546,
0.0297855139,
0.0073250174,
-0.0239948481,
-0.0040001171,
0.0273136608,
0.0117220078,
-0.0415486135,
-0.0160673205,
0.0191356838,
0.0701721534,
0.0275865532,
0.0086915959,
0.050606858,
-0.0138752973,
0.0370830223,
0.0051597916,
-0.0790754035,
0.0779184997,
-0.0200069938,
0.0385202169,
0.0134612452,
0.051436808,
-0.0013147874,
0.0032799565,
0.0368525051,
0.0121510038,
-0.0231891237,
-0.0138305556,
0.0073876455,
0.0359583199,
-0.0367738903,
-0.0427366272,
0.004716381,
0.0286118072,
0.0374268815,
0.0116834482,
-0.0019007473,
0.0118899737,
0.0555343255,
-0.1253924221,
0.0216423515,
-0.0499700531,
0.0128787337,
0.063232407,
-0.0095282234,
-0.0388684571,
0.0056366939,
0.0128311403,
0.0112698255,
-0.0167588592,
-0.0594636947,
-0.0001332811,
0.025135288,
0.0521678217,
-0.0040995697,
-0.0039299116,
-0.0010764274,
-0.0044583934,
-0.036764022,
-0.0238056108,
-0.0015760445,
0.0313678533,
0.0477331467,
-0.0112285968,
-0.0294515174,
0.0550104268,
-0.0830873474,
-0.00510544,
0.0124465209,
-0.0285843518,
-0.0028559389,
0.0510919727,
0.0145135066,
0.0175094418,
-0.0235529207,
-0.0097462116,
-0.0184341371,
0.0057251938,
-0.0294965338,
-0.0348165892,
-0.0254846234,
-0.0190450456,
0.0189840365,
-0.0727158412,
0.0016078656,
-0.0059651053,
-0.0245637819,
-0.0291097891,
0.0102924965,
0.0297600329,
-0.0429388583,
0.004140405,
0.0127340639,
0.004438905,
0.0916143209,
0.0189829301,
-0.0413711704,
0.0563516878,
0.0120913442,
0.021228943,
0.0434299372,
0.026407009,
0.0076429369,
0.0026839469,
-0.006788847,
-0.001046302,
0.0600637086,
-0.0095512429,
-0.056977693,
0.0033119661,
0.0205680765,
0.055504173,
-0.0362125151,
-0.0187069923,
0.0290292744,
0.0868359804,
-0.0131903682,
-0.007863882,
-0.020151427,
0.0405550636,
0.0581151322,
0.0333318114,
0.0218438897,
0.0228283983,
-0.0258134678,
0.0038258715,
0.0516785122,
0.0124354623,
-0.0182735417,
-0.0586119741,
-0.0428397283,
0.0029678557,
-0.0281077549,
-0.0043726768,
-0.0156423356,
0.0016441126,
0.0223546196,
0.0567900352,
0.0100353658,
-0.0664029866,
-0.0336899534,
-0.0147231743,
0.0099236118,
-0.0052677952,
-0.0345092975,
-0.0249933284,
-0.0234061945,
-0.0466910414,
0.0528954528,
0.0645058751,
0.0835497528,
-0.036126107,
-0.0353878625,
-0.0464111827,
-0.0369786024,
-0.0277220793,
0.0277547576,
0.0416609198,
0.004584101,
-0.0504681803,
0.0406212322,
-0.0116309822,
-0.0194897726,
0.0132938866,
0.0144805461,
0.0204938091,
-0.0122955749,
-0.0002843474,
0.0285240375,
0.0838255808,
-0.0076605156,
0.0125657823,
0.0205416847,
-0.0309421476,
-0.0209797006,
0.0253783911,
-0.0227057207,
0.0022691595,
0.0430978797,
-0.0838797912,
-0.0337862633,
-0.0061074076,
-0.0215125196,
-0.0383214392,
0.0325970091,
-0.0374657437,
-0.0398591794,
0.0067327516,
-0.0279373955,
0.0054687886,
-0.0174294207,
-0.0597326793,
0.0788077191,
0.0090230079,
-0.0206121746,
-0.0007199586,
-0.0505322404,
0.0143598234,
-0.0677739829,
-0.0301418621,
-0.0040477035,
0.026166711,
0.0251066815,
0.0524950065,
-0.0476227738,
-0.021040434,
-0.0253810622,
-0.1120354459,
-0.0070831021,
-0.0216378756,
0.0107617285,
0.03828739,
-0.0288172215,
0.0091351457,
-0.007140615,
-0.0712626278,
-0.052136533,
-0.0206705481,
0.0390668549,
0.0485109873,
0.0190206245,
0.0687305033,
-0.049157735,
-0.0142638683,
0.0012029681,
0.0637134388,
0.0218181126,
-0.0425418653,
-0.0096189082,
-0.002445067,
-0.03397182,
-0.022747539,
-0.016629342,
0.0355096459,
0.0317688994,
0.0314858444,
0.0555760786,
0.0460559316,
0.030349059,
0.0243046843,
0.0131622665,
0.0299118664,
-0.0755904689,
-0.0303165484,
-0.0066905222,
0.0638207644,
0.0162496511,
-0.033921808,
0.0546229109,
0.0758540109,
-0.0062617669,
0.0172018912,
-0.0837649927,
0.0325438567,
-0.0393496603,
-0.0251199193,
-0.0612545498,
-0.0295598842,
-0.0104748718,
-0.0026235548,
-0.0366355255,
0.0312969238,
0.04071692,
-0.0042349123,
0.0577319153,
0.0127139743,
-0.0140237967,
-0.0613420345,
0.0180414394,
-0.0155938696,
0.0064708875,
-0.0075091943,
-0.0053781462,
-0.013815539,
-0.0101426318,
0.0649917722,
-0.0344283208,
0.0946251228,
-0.0293914638,
-0.0052551958,
-0.0199212264,
-0.0115173934,
-0.0195096601,
-0.0253887828,
-0.0433199443,
-0.0037770453,
-0.0059518828,
0.0346961692,
0.0154835824,
0.0028191525,
0.0163148791,
-0.0147704706,
-0.0087017324,
0.0049346248,
0.0214729719,
0.0371643566,
0.0378979892,
0.02786595,
0.0620425716,
-0.0220732018,
-0.0065178252,
0.0647114962,
0.0074995211,
-0.0382093638,
-0.0052486947,
-0.0476899631,
-0.0226504542,
-0.0754861459,
-0.0547320992,
-0.0334150828,
0.0655774623,
-0.0142233167,
0.067651093,
0.070686318,
0.0213426165,
-0.015731819,
-0.0133155715,
-0.0434921496,
0.0107342033,
0.0009699325,
-0.0112602357,
-0.0544731133,
0.0026874531,
-0.0534412898,
0.0368395001,
-0.0249292888,
-0.0568074882,
0.0067581744,
-0.102455996,
0.0133643467,
0.0000176754,
0.0071776933,
-0.006449508,
-0.0506602153,
0.0151240667,
-0.0505276695,
-0.0225762147,
0.0083962874,
-0.0040796348,
0.0190044418,
0.0570811927,
-0.0815059468,
0.0142996432,
-0.017354453,
-0.0315062553,
0.0360596217,
0.014468723,
0.0221189503,
-0.0115744453,
-0.0005294663,
0.0483010635,
0.0116562396,
0.009934606,
0.0197363961,
0.0321061835,
-0.0020976414,
0.0031940774,
-0.0131659638,
0.0268994886,
-0.0004378851,
-0.0430815406,
0.0127867535,
0.0238293577,
0.009782427,
-0.0134866638,
-0.0250705611,
0.0479839966,
-0.0400349386,
0.0656721815,
0.0446221977,
0.0187245961,
-0.0403380878,
-0.0557761416,
0.0028779586,
-0.0622357465,
-0.0380248167,
0.0055009122,
-0.0000133864,
0.0155594638,
-0.0863730162,
-0.0568778478,
-0.0165444016,
-0.0286132041,
-0.019485129,
-0.0183599386,
0.0071308082,
0.025984874,
0.0079485066,
0.0260875728,
-0.0088628158,
-0.037745811,
-0.0101909433,
-0.0205682889,
0.0114676366,
-0.0086033223,
-0.023803398,
0.0003932875,
-0.0376498327,
-0.0633070767,
0.0038887868,
0.058977142,
0.0193020012,
0.0309493821,
0.0379384086,
-0.0548770688,
0.0383558683,
0.0190526061,
0.0635410771,
0.007142304,
0.0415127687,
0.0497680195,
-0.0077013955,
-0.0054564634,
-0.0288093202,
0.041713573,
-0.0227852333,
0.0243966784,
-0.064497672,
-0.0216149949,
-0.0213350803,
0.0260715932,
0.0176080596,
0.0243435856,
-0.056542512,
-0.0500403531,
-0.0376385227,
-0.0346223749,
-0.0039068554,
-0.023349449,
0.0280360691,
-0.0435020402,
-0.0354275629,
-0.0133714294,
0.0114974482,
0.0023446297,
0.0627654418,
-0.0543861464,
0.016953079,
0.0301567744,
-0.042682495,
-0.0483247228,
-0.0054244911,
-0.0678984746,
0.0510877259,
-0.0224866029,
0.0127309542,
0.0137470085,
-0.0111840824,
-0.0214751195,
-0.0090221912,
0.0383333154,
0.0145775117,
-0.0740839615,
-0.0314692222,
-0.0183509346,
0.0302690212,
0.0307492036,
-0.0061465483,
0.0728212968,
0.0012046724,
-0.013325097,
0.0077485442,
0.0173927434,
0.0158233382,
0.0072789188,
0.0078579634,
0.0254931021,
-0.013691755,
-0.0056465524,
0.0756934211,
-0.0744596869,
0.0303530209,
-0.0056814528,
-0.0144951157,
-0.0671120808,
-0.0353287607,
-0.0178947654,
0.0057640006,
0.0148346387,
-0.0141274603,
-0.052251339,
0.0143414335,
0.0337732807,
-0.0025086501,
0.0393546484,
0.0073977187,
0.0218626484,
0.0283124428,
0.0024768861,
0.0316140838,
-0.0518743284,
-0.004818798,
-0.0005019443,
0.0321885347,
0.0059050187,
-5.783352493e-33,
-0.0166464746,
-0.024770733,
-0.0417699069,
0.0593659952,
-0.0185126625,
0.0100630429,
-0.0266792271,
0.0632751808,
-0.0137997577,
0.0308723543,
0.0193428174,
0.0225493871,
0.0169520974,
0.010445212,
0.0180179588,
-0.0193172526,
0.0253847819,
-0.0034386637,
-0.0388834216,
0.0228200462,
0.0154485526,
-0.0332658105,
0.0318943597,
-0.0467204973,
0.0804343522,
-0.0088206902,
-0.0192585196,
0.0053032506,
0.0217264872,
0.0426174253,
0.0042361757,
0.0507927984,
0.0522952229,
-0.0609978028,
-0.0185034759,
0.0249954145,
-0.02809765,
-0.0354436673,
0.0319830552,
-0.0532632284,
-0.0286666248,
-0.0623686649,
0.0490678214,
0.0101541029,
0.0097339563,
-0.0579350553,
0.0595122054,
-0.0402412303,
-0.0163105465,
-0.0752695054,
-0.0115939975,
0.060839694,
-0.0296666306,
0.0113402801,
-0.0112566929,
0.0291742161,
0.0176862888,
0.0330946483,
-0.0515457243,
0.0457135886,
0.0320734419,
0.0015085707,
0.0211444385,
-0.0218470078,
-0.0008598152,
0.071754992,
-0.020690484,
0.0211517401,
-0.0544067919,
-0.000812274,
-0.0483764708,
0.0187727362,
0.0623681471,
0.084205851,
0.0015683142,
0.0454238653,
-0.0515728779,
0.0203060154,
0.0281964075,
-0.0198102854,
0.0209171753,
-0.0169631988,
-0.0176156368,
0.0193075147,
-0.0372433439,
-0.0389566906,
-0.0056097703,
-0.0168507416,
-0.0402242541,
0.0123321442,
-0.0590941608,
0.0321176574,
-0.0102696717,
-0.0240007173,
0.0080957413,
-0.0041760253,
0.0082406458,
0.0259404015,
0.0256795585,
-0.0251904819,
-0.0390482135,
0.0337774456,
-0.0011216666,
-0.0121403476,
0.0428590737,
0.002409792,
0.0418714955,
-0.0316356905,
-0.0410179906,
-0.0128887184,
0.0130938021,
0.0415021628,
-0.0322769806,
0.0339399353,
0.0058471481,
0.0180874988,
0.0016034499,
0.0548822097,
0.0071385275,
0.0364354514,
0.0114975479,
-0.02578279,
-0.0108746896,
-0.0108446684,
-0.0159470625,
0.0127729625,
0.0467744134,
0.0111788856,
0.0231612213,
-0.0174840968,
-0.0161402002,
-0.0157028008,
2.124e-7,
0.0564576611,
0.046796225,
0.0402478054,
-0.038553521,
-0.0020254918,
0.0367703065,
0.0301298797,
0.0349898376,
0.0087296339,
-0.0665564165,
-0.0089411689,
0.046088662,
0.0281442087,
0.0659635589,
-0.0863614827,
-0.0798953474,
-0.0691397339,
-0.0082078977,
-0.006084214,
0.0054695616,
0.0721872523,
0.0327623002,
-0.0161852855,
0.0091432091,
-0.0453155786,
0.0274550319,
0.0761045367,
-0.0319876857,
-0.0550667048,
0.0108261118,
0.0877213627,
-0.0630981699,
0.0189584773,
0.0019544221,
-0.0170589108,
-0.0117120678,
0.0491058566,
0.0309623685,
0.0384034552,
-0.0721435472,
0.013595839,
-0.0099765947,
0.0401667394,
-0.0261056758,
0.051848311,
-0.0917273685,
-0.048480019,
-0.0605700389,
-0.0441948622,
0.0124517661,
0.0264509786,
0.0006540256,
-0.0057153651,
0.0073181773,
-0.0143029867,
-0.02755934,
0.0052675051,
-0.07951691,
-0.080345951,
0.0014377239,
-0.0189538859,
-0.0289139487,
0.0116511462,
-0.0396312475,
0.0078424904,
-0.0148707042,
0.0009614559,
1.337896357e-34,
0.0517028198,
-0.017903354,
-0.0147348018,
0.0028982884,
0.0179911349,
0.0164821818,
-0.009512064,
-0.0241962653,
0.0137449587,
-0.0210322198,
0.0044719838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01528v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01528v2 | Decoding Speculative Decoding | 2024-02-02T16:15:24 | 2024-04-26T04:52:57 | Minghao Yan, Saurabh Agarwal, Shivaram Venkataraman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Speculative Decoding is a widely used technique to speed up inference for
Large Language Models (LLMs) without sacrificing quality. When performing
inference, speculative decoding uses a smaller draft model to generate
speculative tokens and then uses the target LLM to verify those draft tokens.
The speedup provided by speculative decoding heavily depends on the choice of
the draft model. In this work, we perform a detailed study comprising over 350
experiments with LLaMA-65B and OPT-66B using speculative decoding and delineate
the factors that affect the performance gain provided by speculative decoding.
Our experiments indicate that the performance of speculative decoding depends
heavily on the latency of the draft model, and the draft model's capability in
language modeling does not correlate strongly with its performance in
speculative decoding. Based on these insights we explore a new design space for
draft models and design hardware-efficient draft models for speculative
decoding. Our newly designed draft model for LLaMA-65B can provide 60% higher
throughput than existing draft models and can generalize further to the LLaMA-2
model family and supervised fine-tuned models. | [
0.0196587779,
0.0634133369,
0.0058515035,
0.0222828556,
-0.0304488055,
0.0013357366,
0.0071259774,
0.0148209771,
-0.0519811511,
-0.0084563866,
0.0073920423,
-0.0698815882,
0.014484724,
0.0152512388,
0.0127328811,
0.0144853555,
0.0341640376,
-0.0650136694,
0.024516793,
-0.0308250058,
-0.032896556,
0.024931062,
0.023381941,
0.0263432115,
0.0322102606,
0.010950407,
-0.0298579875,
0.0067061679,
-0.0463759899,
-0.0516204461,
-0.0094708279,
0.0298290905,
0.0069549154,
0.01976051,
0.0000020462,
-0.0013248096,
-0.007433563,
0.0081947651,
-0.0517545342,
0.0859795287,
0.0767330453,
-0.0267864112,
-0.051985383,
0.0208343454,
0.0127358222,
-0.0440570973,
0.0614318922,
-0.0165539868,
-0.0244242195,
0.0501734801,
-0.0027302972,
-0.0401510596,
0.0388482884,
-0.0101313731,
-0.0632871762,
-0.058240395,
0.023173552,
-0.0085615041,
-0.0171611086,
0.0212548301,
-0.0051960936,
0.0263120625,
0.0402493998,
0.0106004803,
-0.0445375703,
0.024151234,
0.0102207884,
-0.0228363611,
-0.0085240416,
0.0091010556,
-0.025644483,
-0.0874086246,
-0.0035390013,
0.0043129679,
-0.0333569683,
-0.0327399522,
-0.0286596976,
0.037091922,
-0.0499366,
0.0173105188,
0.0963051468,
0.0192608275,
0.0536654703,
-0.0000954994,
-0.0496433638,
0.0754210204,
0.0389401913,
0.0038397729,
-0.0398364067,
0.0049934615,
-0.000793458,
-0.0684860796,
0.0223066583,
-0.0013336276,
-0.0409667715,
0.0009746627,
-0.0689293221,
-0.0447647646,
0.0177573245,
-0.0574272946,
0.0321104601,
0.0888204798,
-0.0010898465,
-0.0042039556,
-0.034441907,
-0.0278403182,
-0.068207927,
0.0222827923,
-0.0460582785,
-0.0008936654,
0.0389304347,
-0.0222555082,
-0.0415751636,
0.0374976844,
-0.0369548686,
-0.0360097326,
-0.0215830263,
-0.0015343826,
0.0439728014,
-0.005309239,
0.0272759795,
-0.0243368819,
-0.0337991565,
-0.0186296888,
0.0291173905,
0.0143975383,
-0.0100165932,
0.0364245698,
-0.0230910443,
-0.094894819,
-0.0105667673,
0.0173206683,
0.0064375824,
-0.0190360546,
0.002958457,
0.0534693599,
-0.0126223937,
-0.0438856669,
-0.0233927201,
-0.026182292,
0.038017612,
-0.0512446761,
0.017121017,
-0.0563655943,
0.0306502394,
0.0239737425,
0.010006953,
-0.0129449433,
-0.023747053,
0.0153896278,
0.0099614374,
0.0408024527,
-0.0242641084,
0.0036603587,
0.0128628109,
0.0013012975,
0.0061097913,
0.1244232953,
0.0152873648,
0.0390036441,
0.0157963969,
-0.0090100011,
-0.0387461632,
0.0690903962,
0.0454893708,
-0.0082475794,
-0.0253617186,
-0.0178450346,
0.0116915172,
-0.001964953,
0.0324871242,
0.057596691,
-0.0516151004,
-0.0163401533,
0.0435835496,
0.067484878,
0.0089065563,
-0.0108145997,
0.0154915359,
0.0203044787,
0.0235072169,
-0.0019020913,
-0.0122648478,
0.0246347152,
-0.0182161704,
0.0214096028,
0.0551069826,
0.0574791543,
-0.0065944595,
0.0068847216,
-0.0299087781,
-0.0318679512,
-0.01942713,
0.0175137818,
0.0708093196,
-0.0174244568,
-0.0537928008,
0.0464954376,
0.0269738212,
-0.0311738849,
-0.0436525494,
-0.0682960004,
0.0463042893,
0.0646258518,
0.0470930114,
0.0457357727,
0.0221485626,
0.0381472483,
-0.0305715073,
0.0259601045,
0.0247899871,
0.0116131678,
0.011962845,
-0.0424141325,
-0.0052004526,
0.0573297553,
0.0401026383,
0.0523118638,
0.0654977337,
0.0055419621,
-0.0039628069,
-0.0099359723,
-0.0234936476,
0.0138911922,
0.0128928758,
0.0327739753,
0.0063337963,
-0.0110201621,
0.0273025539,
-0.0137718469,
-0.0026693251,
0.0215289611,
0.0404919498,
-0.0535163507,
0.0205835812,
-0.002226447,
-0.0596503727,
-0.0114023378,
0.0150495432,
0.0156390741,
0.0223945081,
0.0306472629,
0.00890039,
-0.0357107967,
0.0342023,
-0.0338930786,
0.0694550648,
-0.0412732586,
0.0463596098,
-0.010624717,
0.0429892726,
0.0112544233,
0.0393726788,
-0.0456088185,
-0.0114987418,
0.0028197132,
0.000348721,
0.0086988695,
-0.0160773247,
-0.0183703303,
0.0392536111,
-0.0027396528,
-0.0096838623,
-0.0416507758,
-0.0183533467,
0.0234210938,
-0.00452442,
-0.0710815266,
-0.0071701035,
-0.0482992381,
0.0385903642,
0.0099551883,
-0.0008821118,
-0.0078850547,
-0.0107664019,
0.0034114628,
-0.0110077523,
-0.0055028074,
0.0205880608,
-0.0323368534,
-0.0108190384,
-0.057386566,
-0.0201126058,
-0.0390372574,
0.0211162604,
0.0639109164,
-0.0380763002,
-0.0403731167,
-0.082118839,
0.0110244127,
0.0538578369,
0.0136880986,
-0.0076492797,
-0.0340044275,
0.0222224649,
-0.0359143354,
-0.0129795596,
-0.0035808496,
-0.0295216907,
-0.0001977158,
0.0286002178,
0.0276843142,
-0.0418050103,
-0.0102172801,
0.0150700724,
-0.0144049544,
-0.0578835011,
-0.0588711202,
-0.0369891301,
0.0808542967,
-0.0071484623,
-0.0062477393,
-0.0487179421,
-0.0232522544,
-0.0019458599,
-0.0352925323,
-0.0102932323,
-0.0336875245,
-0.0041847215,
0.0688512996,
-0.0203790199,
-0.0735555217,
0.0502114892,
-0.0657378063,
0.0017102306,
0.0015099683,
0.0141105903,
-0.021860294,
0.0335118771,
-0.0210336931,
0.0234521814,
-0.0267576929,
-0.0359739624,
0.0265542194,
0.0283272527,
0.0022080063,
-0.0464858562,
0.0391046703,
-0.051159732,
0.0377760306,
-0.0459719226,
-0.0175511334,
-0.0055643935,
-0.004958218,
-0.0652332008,
-0.0028971569,
0.0627067462,
-0.0345730409,
0.0152797513,
0.0481360815,
-0.0863237604,
0.0468687788,
-0.0080138016,
0.0223512575,
-0.0208683107,
0.0046265661,
0.0157602075,
-0.0268170983,
0.0367462523,
-0.0445864908,
0.0089370301,
0.0451538786,
0.0323452204,
0.0208193567,
-0.0766251907,
0.0061636735,
0.0584738776,
0.0167731829,
-0.0036919375,
0.0687738359,
0.0432520509,
-0.045449134,
-0.0039020677,
0.0768723115,
0.0033691253,
-0.04829254,
-0.0023883409,
0.0158548523,
0.0508474745,
-0.0083904257,
0.0185625758,
-0.0722184852,
-0.0251039416,
0.0546702147,
0.0123573206,
-0.005163393,
0.0231373962,
-0.0255659539,
-0.091584675,
0.0502343588,
0.0213754904,
-0.0085696541,
0.0075682811,
-0.0418693908,
-0.0540826805,
0.0463107526,
0.0501888953,
0.0418639556,
0.039986793,
-0.0111382408,
0.0141439456,
-0.020024607,
-0.0462016091,
0.0356171094,
0.0023364334,
0.0901679024,
0.0223717578,
-0.0348245017,
0.0193624925,
-0.0189651921,
0.0093830442,
-0.015461145,
-0.011981531,
-0.0097679179,
-0.0221498534,
-0.0064808019,
0.0033116722,
0.0042341221,
-0.0027718411,
-0.0281610359,
0.0008123862,
-0.0523777977,
0.0227080546,
-0.0215638336,
-0.0322135426,
-0.0112180356,
-0.0231510419,
-0.0137675004,
0.0302410349,
0.0152526069,
-0.0072280806,
-0.0424553789,
-0.0474349521,
-0.0463832989,
-0.089667961,
0.0003168646,
0.0173821207,
0.0381751694,
-0.0493015684,
0.0006527393,
0.0295046121,
0.0047985106,
0.0206856169,
0.002043132,
0.0535187051,
0.0248500593,
-0.0336223021,
-0.0666529536,
0.0015109564,
-0.0223776903,
0.0464760363,
-0.0576973781,
0.0145687563,
0.0295906104,
-0.0125000356,
-0.0152528295,
0.0366125889,
-0.105833821,
-0.0657543689,
0.0036045825,
0.0313900225,
0.0335073657,
0.0051455768,
-0.0392728448,
-0.0733121634,
0.0022369199,
0.0212534834,
-0.0576701351,
0.0296660773,
0.0073782634,
-0.0413249135,
0.0196706913,
0.0261905286,
-0.0159925539,
0.0101085659,
-0.0094408253,
0.0025603634,
0.0126809021,
-0.0192706119,
0.008505933,
0.0294294506,
0.0097514279,
-0.0475372188,
-0.0277103595,
0.0333928168,
0.0839630887,
-0.0138000529,
0.0158980116,
0.0082372976,
0.0019262142,
0.0143694039,
-0.0329079144,
-0.004688872,
-0.0130627593,
0.0350868441,
0.0384550318,
0.0287040975,
0.0002179825,
-0.0235474426,
0.0258705001,
0.0512234084,
-0.0391428359,
-0.0102298344,
-0.003613366,
0.005974832,
0.0448479727,
-0.0528690107,
-0.0241043232,
-0.003896872,
0.0144048501,
-0.0445820689,
0.0195457079,
-0.0212328117,
-0.0470930785,
-0.0389142483,
0.0268775877,
0.0425751321,
0.0288711265,
0.0313640945,
-0.0032332074,
0.007941626,
-0.0147939157,
0.0107400985,
-0.0145911556,
-0.0206682105,
0.0689300671,
0.0081246151,
-0.0170532446,
0.0062937201,
0.0356097259,
0.0416795574,
0.0496376269,
-0.0025776075,
0.0115946895,
-0.0046619512,
-0.0555864982,
-0.0397125483,
0.03338309,
-0.0531902425,
-0.021396799,
-0.0204426982,
-0.0437532701,
0.0076251733,
0.0018505461,
0.008419605,
-0.0115965111,
-0.0076067322,
0.0704824626,
0.0112157613,
-0.0388539135,
-0.0088279704,
-0.0295729805,
0.034023799,
-0.0148235857,
0.0200725216,
-6.692465497e-33,
-0.0135873621,
-0.0074574198,
0.0251271278,
-0.0650125593,
-0.0013411024,
-0.0109570008,
-0.0318659469,
-0.0269776825,
-0.0213673897,
-0.0149784386,
-0.0325920172,
0.0354230292,
0.046777565,
0.0204218049,
-0.0119938338,
0.0171958599,
0.0635808706,
-0.0152199194,
-0.0126985684,
-0.0149577809,
0.0233527459,
0.0204719789,
0.0156821385,
0.0145394662,
-0.0192437191,
-0.0380432829,
-0.00498203,
-0.0520924218,
-0.0241647847,
0.0567462035,
-0.0364269614,
0.022376759,
0.0215292051,
-0.0037137424,
-0.0190146007,
0.0127092479,
-0.088605471,
0.0464235917,
0.0474126823,
0.0496795066,
0.0231987331,
-0.0543830842,
-0.0345807523,
0.0625422895,
-0.0365092382,
0.0158205368,
-0.0552475341,
-0.0033354242,
-0.0543203242,
-0.0290732421,
0.009612917,
0.0225081276,
0.0314354002,
0.0501715317,
0.0993643329,
-0.0064423983,
-0.0308033898,
0.012632533,
-0.0409956686,
0.0165271759,
-0.0045646997,
0.0618779995,
0.0740287006,
0.0050259759,
-0.0297405664,
0.0198170282,
0.0244192109,
-0.0473826081,
-0.0514468923,
0.0126525834,
0.0473097451,
0.0069760811,
-0.0072574485,
0.0213979501,
0.0788080022,
-0.0569556989,
-0.0559029877,
-0.0058544897,
0.039556779,
0.0248300601,
0.0832214653,
0.0396964028,
-0.029903261,
-0.0505214594,
-0.0574896038,
-0.0428065173,
-0.0529548079,
-0.0228835307,
0.0214671306,
0.0486079827,
-0.0318628103,
-0.0158511885,
0.0529699847,
-0.0472231619,
-0.0078249667,
0.0095881606,
-0.0023076059,
0.0395179056,
-0.0268101096,
0.0385587551,
-0.0050925771,
-0.0483071692,
0.0355411284,
-0.0255587921,
0.0031703138,
-0.0204235669,
-0.0207222626,
0.0295812115,
-0.0780689344,
0.0035219081,
-0.0348931327,
0.024596462,
0.0203201398,
0.0202395599,
0.0614187159,
0.0017469818,
0.0167294536,
0.0187758282,
-0.0417458564,
0.0451933481,
-0.0207349136,
0.0077928696,
0.0221134406,
0.0625204891,
-0.0031463997,
0.0221695565,
-0.0543975905,
0.0103248022,
0.0344904885,
-0.0449579507,
-0.0360421725,
0.0597450659,
2.713e-7,
0.0377636142,
0.0572138317,
0.0627138242,
0.0231167506,
0.0192424487,
0.0027909379,
-0.0008409653,
0.0008229612,
0.0140812919,
-0.0122425258,
-0.0250646677,
0.0199345369,
0.057906691,
0.0126606552,
-0.0579812713,
-0.0110062854,
-0.0228444673,
0.025713468,
-0.0382700264,
-0.063439846,
0.0039322064,
0.117777735,
-0.0391894467,
-0.0275740623,
0.0448505059,
0.0092375055,
-0.0021801535,
0.0041810805,
-0.0317788757,
0.0118519561,
-0.0136798546,
0.0065036314,
-0.009116617,
0.0341281295,
0.0085484395,
-0.0132419895,
-0.0485145934,
0.0772399157,
0.0044723679,
-0.0272971075,
0.018093884,
-0.0293018743,
-0.0340003669,
-0.0217721835,
0.0538766272,
0.0045958464,
-0.016158279,
-0.0556622148,
-0.0190137252,
-0.025939934,
-0.0456162877,
-0.0116325952,
0.0557149239,
0.0561124012,
0.0304307081,
-0.0169530939,
0.0019624783,
-0.0592256561,
-0.0508135743,
-0.0254849494,
-0.053856317,
-0.0476525351,
-0.0521171018,
0.0259463117,
0.0339029841,
-0.0518902391,
0.027452277,
2.732571157e-34,
0.0640037283,
0.0125203356,
-0.0050320243,
0.1022951379,
-0.0108620264,
-0.0458047874,
0.0374292731,
0.047135815,
-0.0204219129,
-0.0595923141,
-0.0216281619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01521v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01521v1 | K-Level Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T16:07:05 | 2024-02-02T16:07:05 | Yadong Zhang, Shaoguang Mao, Tao Ge, Xun Wang, Yan Xia, Man Lan, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their proficiency in
complex reasoning tasks, their performance in dynamic, interactive, and
competitive scenarios - such as business strategy and stock market analysis -
remains underexplored. To bridge this gap, we formally explore the dynamic
reasoning capabilities of LLMs for decision-making in rapidly evolving
environments. We introduce two game theory-based pilot challenges that mirror
the complexities of real-world dynamic decision-making. These challenges are
well-defined, enabling clear, controllable, and precise evaluation of LLMs'
dynamic reasoning abilities. Through extensive experiments, we find that
existing reasoning methods tend to falter in dynamic settings that require
k-level thinking - a key concept not tackled by previous works. To address
this, we propose a novel reasoning approach for LLMs, named "K-Level
Reasoning". This approach adopts the perspective of rivals to recursively
employ k-level thinking based on available historical information, which
significantly improves the prediction accuracy of rivals' subsequent moves and
informs more strategic decision-making. This research not only sets a robust
quantitative benchmark for the assessment of dynamic reasoning but also
markedly enhances the proficiency of LLMs in dynamic contexts. | [
0.0430647247,
0.0389436819,
-0.0324203968,
0.0049967025,
-0.0585107692,
0.0193798598,
-0.0028395634,
0.0323961526,
0.0076250569,
-0.0355285257,
0.0273958091,
-0.0373802818,
0.0012719866,
0.0606898069,
0.0113838315,
-0.0250810534,
0.0060607377,
-0.082746543,
0.0399996117,
-0.0460653119,
-0.026257081,
-0.019769514,
-0.0215915088,
-0.0026788965,
0.0140723689,
-0.0148060815,
-0.0216199066,
-0.0341818705,
0.024816528,
-0.0438595451,
-0.0320228077,
0.0109106433,
0.0274145957,
0.0030156001,
0.0000021456,
-0.0567941032,
-0.0180700291,
-0.0464153439,
-0.0749611557,
0.0069110598,
0.0008569105,
0.0158398896,
0.0145606576,
0.0086246021,
-0.037067879,
0.0099777607,
-0.0090600932,
0.008045244,
0.0599248633,
0.0460648611,
0.0278007463,
-0.0397997499,
0.0079646297,
-0.0290408116,
-0.0350497961,
-0.0908876583,
0.0259812791,
0.0135349948,
0.0080330549,
-0.0092364531,
0.017236514,
0.0298355799,
0.0044032638,
-0.0026846312,
-0.0480902717,
0.0385864824,
0.0046572625,
0.0611960292,
-0.001897902,
0.0267060678,
-0.0113906404,
0.0268316381,
0.0081682298,
-0.003732451,
-0.0193483382,
-0.004027212,
-0.0278280694,
0.0438916869,
-0.0203802194,
-0.0012079063,
0.0117256679,
0.0211075302,
0.0531585999,
0.0201686397,
-0.0374088138,
0.1248620152,
-0.0251662377,
-0.0292170774,
0.0197341982,
-0.026662074,
0.0229817424,
-0.0762441903,
-0.0186836179,
0.0772358328,
-0.0379702523,
0.0355823301,
0.0431223512,
0.0414674394,
-0.0221092999,
-0.0663266629,
0.0097964397,
0.021165261,
0.0827723145,
0.0708958134,
-0.0215686597,
0.0402345397,
-0.010341974,
-0.0042324262,
0.0179069471,
0.0101508694,
-0.0610348657,
-0.0342549272,
-0.0076477178,
0.0385027938,
-0.0054292572,
0.0189262237,
-0.0316417888,
0.0237325989,
-0.054776039,
0.0575521402,
-0.0490688831,
0.0074483482,
0.0238934085,
-0.0559844747,
-0.0915091634,
-0.0183389708,
-0.0246859565,
0.0074760867,
-0.0048322529,
-0.028663883,
0.0163338929,
-0.0476943254,
-0.0296157096,
-0.0358118862,
0.002765191,
0.0861369222,
-0.0037209014,
0.0384725444,
-0.0507647172,
-0.0436886102,
-0.007860817,
-0.0895856172,
-0.0259057637,
-0.0624925308,
0.0014838686,
0.008441302,
-0.0223659966,
-0.0201947652,
0.011655625,
-0.0143392161,
-0.0239989925,
0.0791107565,
0.0490795448,
0.0247516446,
-0.0081299189,
0.0113030439,
0.0072085503,
0.0876818448,
0.0286164954,
0.010557333,
0.0062938104,
0.0376080833,
-0.0144694122,
0.0237265248,
-0.018630974,
-0.0166504756,
-0.0594542101,
0.0223610494,
0.0131394397,
0.0208042227,
-0.0478974804,
-0.0068621249,
-0.0318230279,
-0.0041244077,
0.0690587983,
0.0172592383,
0.0393937565,
0.0436728522,
0.02397855,
-0.0059007341,
-0.0400361158,
-0.0307257604,
0.0001120392,
0.0107815303,
-0.0482716858,
0.0039511602,
-0.0460731052,
0.0200791024,
-0.0011621735,
-0.0366988629,
-0.0251739658,
0.0215486791,
0.0142554985,
0.0243773479,
0.0564195588,
-0.0136213973,
-0.0078270389,
0.049869962,
0.0054464624,
0.0104443757,
-0.0017152809,
-0.0418779589,
0.0176341068,
0.090778932,
0.0569235422,
-0.0381979831,
-0.0366440527,
-0.0157575291,
-0.0208970625,
0.027383063,
0.0552603379,
-0.0290927775,
-0.0321061313,
-0.0208872762,
-0.0342665128,
-0.0094017889,
0.0081544565,
0.0253816415,
-0.0045888685,
0.0452982113,
-0.0064081256,
-0.0209751148,
0.0248117037,
-0.0146988072,
-0.0316004492,
-0.0385026,
-0.0400624722,
0.0252526291,
0.0098535502,
-0.0030529448,
0.0031782025,
0.0205805302,
-0.0062412084,
-0.0239639226,
-0.0295570139,
0.0368232988,
0.0076650409,
-0.0098137753,
0.0244979076,
0.0123922396,
-0.0241683796,
-0.0270867553,
-0.0249230135,
0.012626023,
0.0763420314,
0.0037037297,
0.0293915253,
-0.019056946,
-0.0071892105,
-0.0360061713,
-0.0220519453,
-0.0169362724,
0.1166582182,
0.0294971913,
-0.0082985871,
0.0241078772,
-0.0167878009,
-0.0043353424,
-0.0399888568,
0.0206178613,
0.0544336736,
-0.0072435914,
-0.0124159791,
0.0023917593,
-0.0430461206,
-0.0451542288,
-0.0028733716,
-0.0351855904,
0.0114283385,
0.0119234081,
0.015847126,
-0.0066164257,
-0.0370802172,
0.0092838267,
0.0319275074,
-0.0123250196,
0.0112951174,
0.0457514487,
0.0336557701,
0.0482756011,
0.0291848835,
-0.0111247692,
0.0351710208,
-0.0116432803,
-0.0529564805,
0.0489285663,
0.0150603214,
0.0278572366,
-0.0100443577,
-0.009240875,
-0.0644814745,
0.0193383899,
-0.0215509888,
-0.0044307206,
0.0136276744,
-0.0537435226,
-0.0199792106,
0.0699614584,
0.0017435497,
0.0014035848,
0.0441791452,
-0.0824032426,
-0.0534800552,
0.0396031551,
-0.0269233473,
-0.005234363,
-0.0840509683,
-0.0089379959,
-0.0196972862,
0.0917678252,
-0.0152030392,
-0.0006841549,
-0.0472897254,
0.0259143766,
-0.0046051675,
0.0250363238,
-0.08173199,
0.0025542574,
0.0212996565,
0.1041026786,
-0.0109052053,
0.0158814713,
0.0963156745,
0.0308317114,
0.0103489356,
-0.0217830166,
0.028338667,
-0.0332307369,
0.0771953166,
-0.0585136339,
-0.006060096,
-0.0314456783,
-0.004800424,
-0.047332067,
-0.0662418008,
0.0562916994,
-0.026798686,
0.0427664369,
-0.0765583143,
-0.0149660083,
0.0108476458,
-0.0335970558,
-0.0538811572,
0.0000129094,
-0.0736293048,
0.0244098846,
-0.0094363084,
0.0028864085,
-0.0620153733,
0.026663905,
0.0343909748,
-0.0443065241,
-0.0079583675,
-0.0294524729,
0.0027094642,
0.0047397334,
0.0330000855,
0.0360154696,
0.0423618369,
-0.0263705775,
0.0736528486,
0.0369336791,
0.0540779494,
-0.0227660108,
-0.005165875,
0.0351878293,
0.0070051178,
-0.0078187827,
-0.0031632038,
0.0353695042,
-0.0325096548,
-0.0799444467,
0.0072693359,
0.0551099256,
0.0281096846,
0.0477437489,
0.0019185878,
-0.0313030444,
0.014779985,
0.0220428295,
0.0584193394,
-0.0609922893,
-0.044800844,
-0.0047193295,
-0.0061114249,
-0.0024198464,
-0.0776284114,
-0.001985515,
-0.1518506706,
0.0208750479,
-0.0001714847,
0.0140018407,
-0.0031041263,
0.0036097241,
0.0009252547,
-0.038496431,
-0.0381020494,
0.0413455926,
0.0269041769,
-0.0139889186,
0.0176350605,
-0.0310983751,
-0.0205209367,
0.0611205846,
-0.0144641073,
-0.0090916809,
0.02780913,
0.0397669524,
0.0070366804,
-0.0376911759,
0.0025516192,
0.0035062404,
0.0259221308,
0.0196911339,
0.0102902846,
-0.0006270061,
-0.000600914,
0.0214127041,
-0.0128059192,
-0.0018481129,
-0.0129414303,
0.0300232079,
0.0819697082,
-0.0022071204,
-0.0361448415,
0.0335241929,
0.0132586788,
-0.0203499254,
0.0416587628,
-0.0235849023,
-0.0252968986,
-0.0485755168,
-0.0662607998,
-0.0247604083,
-0.0473465025,
-0.0231882669,
0.0133965882,
0.0080308774,
0.0011304418,
-0.0597346015,
-0.0190908331,
0.0365985744,
0.0427825972,
0.0051834388,
0.0093974667,
0.016421454,
0.0375180729,
-0.0598120876,
-0.0114135128,
-0.0395631343,
0.0366638936,
0.0050007585,
0.0195228606,
-0.0151825994,
-0.059201885,
-0.0390591286,
0.0076151118,
-0.0618230924,
-0.0739098489,
0.0040872069,
0.0398934297,
0.0322905742,
0.0339551419,
-0.021843737,
-0.0127161704,
0.0496670641,
-0.02632761,
0.0055771582,
-0.0179492142,
0.0332684331,
0.003086155,
0.0254315101,
0.0462235175,
-0.0417145267,
-0.0081061209,
0.033233773,
0.0177922659,
-0.0467927866,
0.0205510184,
-0.0239758249,
-0.0159440823,
0.0125310216,
0.0415434986,
-0.0751474723,
0.0003769766,
0.0460539572,
0.0137919653,
-0.0589216985,
0.0108918361,
-0.0045739161,
0.0264178105,
0.0070384559,
0.0188605916,
0.0060565979,
0.0151658189,
-0.02341743,
0.0088768881,
0.0147114741,
0.0479895473,
0.0385443978,
0.062560305,
-0.0091253715,
0.0117902141,
0.0161108188,
-0.0076184114,
0.0663500801,
-0.0047086901,
0.0309388228,
0.0373984091,
-0.0485731848,
-0.0379573032,
-0.0406275727,
-0.0498671755,
-0.0974832103,
0.0710206404,
0.0334784538,
0.0290085375,
-0.0015312786,
-0.0458532758,
-0.0717820972,
0.0064848061,
0.0283059925,
-0.0318105295,
-0.0029742427,
-0.0828586817,
0.0299562402,
0.0427605957,
-0.0252961088,
0.0174115393,
0.0498030744,
-0.0159885902,
0.0283718668,
-0.0479915403,
-0.0452784002,
0.0028783632,
-0.0245219693,
-0.0024085464,
0.0638862923,
0.0123811699,
0.038581159,
-0.0972780138,
-0.0514370687,
0.0103351437,
0.0214607678,
-0.0084811859,
-0.0024106179,
-0.0009782579,
0.0485126227,
0.0506916344,
-0.0047374195,
-0.0428422019,
0.0388122052,
-0.0271051135,
0.0162150823,
-0.0032698538,
-6.251674952e-33,
0.0209869668,
-0.015051594,
0.0444822721,
-0.0478508212,
-0.0245370623,
-0.0083593028,
-0.0409590676,
-0.0164624359,
-0.0131494422,
0.0178792477,
-0.0232646372,
0.007441184,
0.0028039941,
-0.0135059422,
0.0299749263,
-0.0320510827,
-0.0208930373,
0.0177158248,
-0.0498971716,
0.0139538758,
0.0480489209,
0.0026684827,
0.0456266552,
-0.0235980134,
0.0013076146,
0.0131925764,
-0.0119076194,
0.0377972722,
-0.0690115765,
0.0355441272,
0.0023129329,
-0.0128977587,
0.0229718238,
-0.0854272321,
0.0175237469,
-0.0164601412,
-0.0178386718,
-0.0071578203,
-0.002393719,
-0.0064514624,
0.0225479417,
0.0035591591,
-0.0103816828,
0.0364606231,
0.0086953314,
-0.0198637974,
0.0262453128,
-0.0732529014,
0.003894065,
0.0128537053,
-0.0263979882,
0.0268483274,
-0.0581441559,
0.0383095816,
0.0384892486,
0.0224584211,
-0.0041773408,
0.0053959698,
-0.0437197611,
0.0810794681,
0.03265284,
-0.0107756713,
0.0648828,
0.0134093752,
0.0257263035,
0.0575622842,
-0.0208154265,
0.0212109182,
-0.0374925323,
0.0048954966,
-0.0323277451,
0.0778173432,
0.0380060449,
0.0170988441,
0.0163203012,
-0.0046662297,
-0.0687814876,
-0.0045027575,
0.055739779,
0.0501930043,
0.0305589568,
0.0140375681,
-0.0369901918,
-0.0518632717,
-0.0142221227,
0.0138040949,
-0.0415893607,
-0.0166075416,
0.0166358408,
0.0009463344,
-0.0110523757,
0.0281474739,
0.0058328402,
-0.0291504078,
-0.0443210229,
0.0055350224,
0.021400664,
0.0186391696,
0.0048175952,
0.0163617358,
-0.0193264857,
-0.0090176668,
-0.036834009,
-0.0176911969,
0.003445568,
0.0035298013,
-0.014783999,
0.0168168321,
-0.0092843063,
-0.0182950925,
-0.039097812,
0.0271120202,
0.0296118725,
-0.0111899925,
0.0410192572,
0.0111232642,
0.0218005497,
-0.0108606117,
0.0296907816,
-0.027580779,
0.0114352861,
0.0435473323,
-0.014715191,
0.0079347864,
0.0078524221,
-0.0170731638,
-0.0193886701,
0.0062173787,
-0.018376017,
-0.0423917621,
-0.012272113,
0.0423937067,
2.836e-7,
-0.0028183085,
0.0595558621,
-0.0197150111,
0.0123791592,
0.0163911171,
0.066563502,
-0.0603437088,
-0.0418027006,
0.0145805916,
-0.0187349953,
0.0282007456,
0.0532920286,
0.0593775213,
0.0567811169,
-0.0457156748,
-0.0125553571,
-0.0423634164,
-0.0102723558,
-0.0712032318,
-0.0205658898,
0.0314150974,
0.0172646195,
0.0353071578,
-0.0046651759,
0.037942268,
-0.0860095471,
0.0469768979,
-0.0152619071,
0.036861062,
0.0209032968,
0.0130827688,
-0.0155480374,
-0.0150426161,
0.0398711786,
-0.0034064993,
0.0369083248,
-0.0299230032,
0.0384170972,
0.0189906154,
-0.0280499049,
-0.0321085602,
-0.0504512899,
-0.0099775661,
-0.0699302107,
0.1175867915,
-0.0639757067,
-0.0332363173,
0.0020767099,
0.0382618643,
-0.035766013,
-0.0154679511,
0.008390666,
-0.0157805607,
0.0073120664,
-0.0232286397,
-0.0147969993,
0.041619163,
-0.0707443133,
-0.0162687637,
0.0176590309,
-0.0515098423,
-0.0129641006,
-0.0243279412,
0.0156017346,
0.0287430752,
0.0048676459,
0.0224207714,
2.557767571e-34,
0.0427636169,
0.0262012314,
-0.0288993791,
0.0000413174,
0.0774278343,
0.0105360998,
-0.0162882935,
0.0139452294,
0.0487467647,
-0.0853400752,
-0.0273214579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01513v1 | Multilingual Gradient Word-Order Typology from Universal Dependencies | 2024-02-02T15:54:19 | 2024-02-02T15:54:19 | Emi Baylor, Esther Ploeger, Johannes Bjerva | cs.CL | cs.CL | While information from the field of linguistic typology has the potential to
improve performance on NLP tasks, reliable typological data is a prerequisite.
Existing typological databases, including WALS and Grambank, suffer from
inconsistencies primarily caused by their categorical format. Furthermore,
typological categorisations by definition differ significantly from the
continuous nature of phenomena, as found in natural language corpora. In this
paper, we introduce a new seed dataset made up of continuous-valued data,
rather than categorical data, that can better reflect the variability of
language. While this initial dataset focuses on word-order typology, we also
present the methodology used to create the dataset, which can be easily adapted
to generate data for a broader set of features and languages. | [
0.0078679994,
0.1115000695,
-0.0317605063,
0.0416570939,
-0.0188312549,
0.0209222976,
0.0063544703,
0.0020781008,
-0.0023597006,
-0.0471155718,
0.0128041832,
-0.0782622397,
0.0414588824,
0.0187914278,
0.0350072421,
-0.0718783289,
0.0168422125,
0.0092170686,
-0.0069227656,
0.0055732871,
-0.0000051995,
0.0214406252,
-0.0089501087,
0.0288271122,
-0.0605183281,
-0.0250278208,
0.0286432765,
-0.0062019136,
0.0296986029,
-0.0243754238,
0.0578844324,
0.0522530042,
0.0066549499,
-0.0173615199,
0.000001785,
-0.0445645452,
-0.0304729808,
-0.0078283492,
0.0376794115,
-0.0459450781,
-0.0012393777,
-0.0296653174,
-0.0399132669,
0.0270552151,
-0.0440388173,
-0.0282475911,
0.046415545,
0.0048739444,
0.0183503702,
0.0249654595,
-0.0201765299,
-0.0878579989,
0.0310891122,
0.0122911269,
-0.0054462198,
0.0215250757,
0.0054690745,
-0.0050774631,
-0.0149004413,
0.0112736048,
-0.0249254946,
-0.0059338273,
0.0016280591,
0.0073975609,
-0.023205895,
-0.002858036,
-0.0128904227,
-0.0273311585,
-0.0111001022,
0.0705902576,
-0.0255904663,
-0.0156002091,
0.0131144803,
-0.0111099361,
-0.0118542667,
0.0115143619,
-0.0009930194,
0.0645887703,
-0.0183272753,
0.031939473,
0.0769352391,
0.0287352987,
-0.0085814819,
0.0091737751,
-0.0662460029,
0.1109037399,
0.0156926978,
-0.0409880131,
-0.002599827,
-0.0317865349,
-0.0195058025,
-0.0294528734,
0.0014616175,
-0.0398762971,
0.005033168,
0.0072259558,
-0.0152953388,
-0.028780181,
0.0226857103,
-0.0669298545,
0.0288225636,
-0.0274196938,
-0.0197634511,
0.0129011329,
0.0408376418,
0.0295151845,
0.0117580723,
-0.0348195396,
-0.0098205917,
-0.0169133414,
-0.0285019688,
-0.0030144821,
0.0197412129,
0.0111446157,
-0.0345172398,
0.0383269824,
-0.0637181401,
0.0009834998,
-0.0249013156,
-0.0123755513,
0.0224944875,
0.0089404816,
-0.0064373841,
-0.0079560205,
-0.0273880772,
0.0038848936,
-0.0172597077,
0.0169951487,
-0.0394539088,
-0.0451788865,
0.0407847054,
0.0088916514,
0.0202545896,
0.0130966166,
0.0087995594,
0.0416918173,
0.0499107502,
-0.0126384934,
-0.0365359187,
-0.0022733344,
-0.0198609792,
0.0020894627,
-0.013166368,
-0.0908770338,
0.020122122,
0.0306575652,
-0.017581461,
-0.0380701683,
0.0001542474,
0.0088849301,
-0.0624756664,
0.0711972713,
-0.0487678871,
-0.015754953,
-0.0294882674,
-0.0511001535,
0.0068446579,
0.0576250143,
0.0241194461,
-0.0434789136,
0.0983957723,
-0.0304896235,
-0.0192266833,
0.0250504389,
-0.0283501167,
0.0033220274,
-0.0436252318,
-0.0101748966,
-0.005544445,
0.0238066763,
0.0405528136,
0.0295016579,
0.0053751701,
-0.0333087593,
0.0388782248,
0.0617190748,
0.0497690402,
-0.0132375518,
0.0139653599,
0.0032946346,
-0.0093749687,
0.029735228,
0.0228137877,
-0.0577421412,
0.0034456674,
-0.0158996526,
-0.0419557169,
0.0763817206,
0.0009754522,
-0.0450588912,
-0.0425561368,
-0.0280386209,
0.0081509678,
-0.0413956568,
0.0346166342,
0.0077852188,
0.0097403647,
0.0208178852,
0.0574901216,
-0.0553371683,
-0.0357417166,
0.0395716131,
0.0095794769,
0.0754184872,
-0.0106064575,
-0.0373421051,
-0.0227086749,
0.0375575013,
-0.0027537316,
0.0120408563,
-0.0086616334,
-0.0484638736,
0.041543711,
-0.0361824408,
0.0134921297,
0.0395865068,
0.0024172012,
0.0290208235,
-0.0142586846,
0.0460889339,
-0.0218682569,
0.0127455015,
-0.0424979627,
0.0256705526,
-0.0339080766,
-0.0220606793,
0.042433504,
-0.0022724059,
0.0350065641,
0.0479522496,
-0.0353499278,
0.0185873508,
0.0404442921,
-0.0527751409,
0.0048755794,
0.0456156321,
-0.0289983358,
-0.0131781725,
0.0258666929,
-0.0155801717,
0.0048675351,
-0.0053293831,
-0.0268883649,
-0.0184330959,
0.016417373,
0.0433499888,
0.0597777665,
-0.0410405472,
0.0252300408,
0.0100228023,
0.0385269858,
-0.0441909283,
0.0298399236,
0.0010179506,
0.0740455836,
-0.028998889,
-0.0290647112,
0.0119559662,
0.0405049063,
0.0408878662,
0.0655545294,
0.0113603612,
0.0260484293,
0.0274524502,
0.0090559609,
-0.0108368704,
-0.0011032742,
-0.096375145,
0.0162185952,
-0.0118333846,
0.0341448151,
0.0084962863,
0.0400567316,
-0.0125447903,
-0.007520766,
-0.0176175553,
0.0068233516,
0.0086310087,
0.0189911649,
0.0674587637,
-0.0387600623,
0.0015675101,
-0.0123213064,
-0.0259842481,
0.0006768866,
0.0468393452,
-0.0585616715,
0.0102874888,
-0.0189159401,
-0.0140272109,
-0.0129501065,
0.0517654344,
0.0033925723,
-0.059235841,
0.0090862056,
0.0193443242,
0.0462940149,
0.0116961924,
0.0379097611,
0.0281014889,
0.0218565017,
-0.0212876424,
-0.0124675548,
-0.0383469351,
-0.0194462985,
0.0618309006,
0.0178052019,
-0.0306488033,
-0.0062654959,
0.0995765924,
0.0197219048,
-0.0537473373,
0.0008087204,
0.0180007759,
-0.0803221911,
-0.010696765,
-0.0500437841,
0.0234274305,
-0.0570279732,
0.0266530216,
0.0080703693,
-0.0298575033,
0.0146268308,
-0.0025911913,
0.013203823,
-0.0548456386,
-0.0298300739,
-0.0575830974,
0.0347182639,
-0.01184431,
-0.0079210214,
-0.0006500645,
-0.0253218897,
-0.0441427119,
-0.018370593,
0.0190631282,
-0.0014660908,
0.0290966127,
-0.0619744882,
-0.0042457497,
-0.0162239578,
-0.0733080134,
-0.0211936794,
-0.0807562023,
0.0327036455,
-0.0135058574,
0.0548218563,
-0.0473985747,
0.0313238055,
-0.0016372113,
0.0159628782,
0.0499446206,
-0.0382091552,
-0.0012113084,
0.0095338244,
0.1023278907,
-0.0004726159,
0.0072469367,
0.0094042597,
0.0517651737,
-0.0119832577,
0.0299083386,
-0.0073220897,
0.0270421784,
-0.0098268185,
0.0138698462,
0.0337021127,
-0.0267963614,
-0.0608920082,
-0.0225748718,
-0.003131452,
-0.0122831715,
0.025803851,
0.0996482521,
0.0471006036,
-0.0196442958,
0.0420938171,
0.0091122789,
0.0468596034,
0.0252583921,
0.0030514942,
-0.044895798,
0.0213454645,
-0.0014221705,
0.0005476226,
-0.0333419256,
-0.0271212943,
-0.0072053364,
-0.0693755075,
0.0057755769,
-0.0104847308,
-0.0069964146,
0.0091112815,
-0.0270658433,
-0.0186413787,
-0.0097334357,
-0.0144377975,
-0.0038689298,
-0.0118925963,
0.0117612816,
0.0386728905,
-0.0676068589,
-0.0516114607,
0.0047836518,
-0.0314545222,
-0.0077712173,
0.0051531144,
0.0470699854,
-0.0810812563,
-0.0161135159,
0.0316800326,
-0.0311120469,
-0.0489272401,
-0.0042664409,
0.0225841384,
-0.0000149653,
-0.0212792978,
-0.0197057277,
0.0217274372,
-0.0599543005,
0.0061349082,
0.0077457246,
0.0453957953,
-0.0075357719,
-0.0047356212,
-0.0433100313,
-0.0451369323,
0.0450008325,
0.0168219786,
-0.0159817375,
-0.0751637891,
0.0009010751,
-0.0428874791,
0.0034681493,
-0.0325979255,
-0.0590894148,
0.0368349329,
-0.0002964509,
-0.057068672,
-0.0922087356,
-0.0646567792,
-0.0202731527,
0.0456537567,
0.0017320238,
-0.014712655,
0.0184558965,
-0.0272421166,
-0.054949116,
0.0187097304,
0.0709817484,
-0.0165150017,
-0.045804847,
-0.0403977633,
0.0778208375,
0.0261321124,
-0.0401364602,
-0.0002708466,
0.0091888309,
-0.0527142882,
0.0618697107,
0.0055983476,
0.0152626662,
0.0136352591,
0.0110158836,
-0.0284571033,
0.0844795033,
0.0372575931,
0.0083671603,
-0.0018939566,
0.0250721574,
-0.0137760239,
0.0079649538,
0.024199754,
-0.0090787765,
0.0374270976,
-0.0342077017,
0.00886341,
0.0073373215,
-0.0148218609,
0.009251344,
-0.0445010662,
0.0196048189,
-0.0220916178,
-0.0416775644,
-0.0703511536,
0.0088332081,
-0.0673801526,
-0.0392381512,
-0.0203189552,
0.0422937907,
0.0151888421,
0.011328686,
-0.0696450174,
-0.0231729466,
0.0019424157,
0.0182506125,
-0.0085527841,
0.0396425426,
0.0806877017,
0.017875582,
-0.013016629,
-0.0067015104,
-0.0178142581,
0.0244397763,
-0.075696595,
0.046656549,
-0.043067269,
-0.0134751201,
0.0015776543,
-0.0341389477,
-0.0363947749,
0.0916729793,
-0.0088046817,
0.027903432,
-0.0052212006,
0.0029605683,
0.0728648528,
-0.0476530381,
0.0617393591,
-0.0230283383,
-0.0041666655,
0.0050045983,
0.0245217159,
0.0320064574,
-0.0073342319,
-0.0164512079,
0.0093701268,
-0.062412668,
0.0227497481,
0.1172210202,
0.0495085865,
-0.0281361453,
0.0339314714,
-0.0186149068,
-0.0095574912,
0.0362654291,
0.0274008606,
0.0007489771,
0.0125200003,
0.0324667096,
-0.0830163434,
-0.0488130376,
0.0420158505,
0.0145628983,
0.004742451,
0.0307393372,
0.0261245146,
0.1089081541,
0.0298934747,
0.031531617,
-0.0524787121,
-0.0097411564,
-0.0450678878,
-0.0494426116,
0.000614971,
-6.20732355e-33,
0.0036923443,
-0.0430424362,
-0.0619211867,
-0.0279489402,
0.0223170184,
0.0250058938,
0.0485081114,
-0.010171961,
0.0005238251,
0.0149326799,
-0.0422656499,
0.0202840958,
0.0188110098,
0.0274052136,
0.0686258078,
0.0342027992,
-0.0351528078,
-0.0179154836,
0.0182277877,
-0.0141576622,
0.0744543672,
0.0340390503,
0.1238752156,
-0.0641337633,
0.0494456068,
0.0052579362,
0.0101496596,
-0.0083749723,
0.0408097729,
0.0342676789,
-0.012149442,
0.0793244168,
0.0520683229,
-0.0205943137,
0.0071900878,
-0.0075612413,
-0.0183783025,
-0.0516715646,
0.000363152,
0.0240441505,
-0.0422074161,
-0.0006766238,
0.0164797455,
-0.0202630516,
-0.0199342202,
0.0048997584,
0.0305589736,
-0.018646773,
-0.0289219078,
-0.0210646242,
-0.0461362973,
0.051733166,
0.0118974149,
0.0240028072,
0.0155834844,
0.0116214175,
-0.0130849127,
-0.0043708072,
-0.0580611601,
0.0278318357,
-0.0130216926,
0.070278272,
0.001756864,
0.0017974956,
0.0063157538,
0.0389882401,
-0.0200927835,
0.0043491786,
0.0301968437,
0.019183008,
0.0025916907,
0.015169342,
-0.0187960751,
0.0429985002,
0.0672626644,
-0.0493079126,
-0.0537858643,
0.026918795,
0.0480450951,
-0.0328904465,
-0.0053304904,
-0.023479145,
-0.0525389649,
-0.0405321158,
-0.0118625984,
-0.0496157892,
0.0163895674,
-0.0185761955,
0.0006843348,
-0.0459512398,
0.022301469,
0.016692441,
-0.0007565487,
-0.0261730775,
-0.1013100445,
0.0427164733,
-0.0142134726,
0.0421418697,
0.0257923622,
0.0403819978,
-0.0473031029,
-0.0301043149,
-0.027611725,
0.0462588482,
0.053155899,
0.0158788171,
0.0179357994,
0.0216641668,
-0.0524125211,
-0.0106643708,
-0.0010648197,
-0.0024152221,
-0.0411057957,
0.0676860362,
0.0133415582,
0.0043078638,
0.0026800218,
0.0521304123,
0.0685406774,
0.0030784318,
-0.0212461241,
0.0108706634,
-0.0129914833,
0.0436636508,
-0.0247995947,
-0.0304027572,
-0.0070187831,
0.0410907641,
0.0254210681,
-0.0128141837,
-0.0029629571,
-0.0217028614,
2.674e-7,
0.0078514097,
0.0597672947,
0.0197633151,
0.0303333178,
0.0381238349,
0.0126820365,
0.0041636727,
0.0330311693,
-0.0813711658,
-0.0259352475,
0.0017829853,
-0.0497681424,
0.0264824945,
0.0391530544,
-0.1178240031,
-0.0352056473,
-0.0244704522,
0.0079736337,
-0.0540235899,
-0.0176892374,
0.0479788072,
0.1373099834,
0.0007071837,
0.0099617252,
-0.0332370028,
0.0230385922,
0.0318945535,
-0.0153731005,
-0.0040226178,
-0.0248895567,
0.0371458083,
-0.0337213278,
0.0212937891,
-0.0122733265,
-0.0246879067,
0.0361915492,
-0.0085876007,
-0.0028482201,
-0.0240715686,
-0.0197967291,
0.0196246412,
-0.0265526343,
-0.0376578234,
-0.0924026668,
0.062290106,
0.0282346644,
-0.0471407659,
-0.0209225006,
-0.0137611777,
0.0365397818,
0.0169828143,
-0.0417921171,
-0.02335798,
0.0190154742,
0.0229553469,
-0.0470921397,
-0.0261438899,
-0.0462342128,
-0.0284065213,
0.0240052585,
0.0085232304,
-0.0174661893,
0.0394120887,
0.0120953657,
0.0393716395,
-0.0107588684,
0.0148947462,
2.841603539e-34,
0.0329101086,
0.0019855492,
0.0285701752,
0.0141011029,
0.0233898666,
-0.0399859473,
0.0220186766,
0.0160085857,
-0.0082552945,
-0.0405723639,
-0.0142665068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01512v1 | Distractor Generation for Multiple-Choice Questions: A Survey of Methods, Datasets, and Evaluation | 2024-02-02T15:53:31 | 2024-02-02T15:53:31 | Elaf Alhazmi, Quan Z. Sheng, Wei Emma Zhang, Munazza Zaib, Ahoud Alhazmi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Distractors are important in learning evaluation. This paper surveys
distractor generation tasks using English multiple-choice question datasets for
textual and multimodal contexts. In particular, this paper presents a thorough
literature review of the recent studies on distractor generation tasks,
discusses multiple choice components and their characteristics, analyzes the
related datasets, and summarizes the evaluation metrics of distractor
generation. Our investigation reveals that more than half of datasets are
human-generated from educational sources in specific domains such as Science
and English, which are largely text-based, with a lack of open domain and
multimodal datasets. | [
-0.0039329086,
-0.0194388535,
-0.0255731028,
0.0124780498,
-0.0156783909,
0.0076464997,
0.0812034756,
-0.0143918544,
0.0642424002,
-0.0328356624,
-0.0241037477,
-0.0177513249,
-0.050801862,
-0.066625163,
0.0514299609,
-0.0861281529,
0.0263487808,
-0.0286566969,
0.0148437228,
0.0198529605,
-0.0203655772,
-0.0357038528,
-0.0329935327,
0.003542125,
-0.0050090603,
-0.0581785105,
-0.0221810471,
-0.0096784867,
0.0358575284,
-0.0717052221,
0.036472898,
0.0581059605,
-0.0129139405,
-0.0279015917,
0.0000020408,
-0.0437883921,
0.0007427532,
-0.0261070859,
-0.0120774172,
-0.0066742329,
0.0295918882,
0.0896211341,
0.0414304137,
-0.003612089,
-0.0145684779,
0.0100517785,
0.0383190438,
0.0206496883,
0.0506489351,
0.0218596384,
0.0063689598,
0.0115226274,
0.0047510103,
0.0366216563,
0.06764213,
0.0172310993,
-0.0403029025,
0.0119915847,
-0.0103286561,
0.0507935435,
-0.0531625487,
0.0075270054,
0.0048794271,
0.0372901186,
0.0129531603,
0.0241725091,
-0.0375688337,
-0.0567604974,
-0.021809116,
0.1001564413,
0.0050154869,
0.0079415347,
-0.0265207198,
-0.0217221007,
0.0222723093,
0.0708868802,
-0.0615882054,
0.0408728048,
-0.045715183,
-0.0237375274,
0.0169629604,
-0.0220862255,
-0.0283551347,
0.0010475507,
0.0242688302,
-0.0285756122,
0.0285958908,
-0.0300617088,
0.0388098583,
0.0034062918,
0.0065202806,
-0.0514538735,
0.0198994298,
0.0151514271,
-0.0828375295,
0.0140054096,
-0.0483768806,
-0.0940143168,
0.0350415893,
-0.0220529456,
0.012254633,
0.0315529145,
-0.0521934889,
0.0127397859,
-0.0006260218,
0.0434789024,
-0.0523860194,
0.0346488431,
-0.0008944474,
0.0425038375,
-0.0144804977,
0.014843964,
0.0041794642,
0.0142822117,
-0.037872307,
-0.0239271633,
-0.0086803455,
0.0129602812,
-0.0088559724,
0.0047923368,
-0.0083439192,
0.0230549145,
0.0069325552,
0.0170063246,
-0.0402443148,
0.0302095935,
-0.0315788388,
-0.0077449423,
-0.0085430956,
-0.010127929,
0.0140890153,
0.0516295843,
0.0310023464,
-0.0627963245,
0.0031734298,
0.0715272352,
-0.0242521744,
-0.0268868189,
-0.0274185743,
-0.0220647845,
0.0251368526,
-0.0456679501,
0.0519460253,
-0.0075251684,
0.0003895567,
0.008679484,
0.006704093,
-0.0188531522,
0.0347764343,
0.0632912517,
0.0496762507,
0.0195153076,
-0.0128438873,
-0.031739153,
0.0367643423,
-0.01051661,
-0.0049153632,
0.054578159,
0.0201272219,
0.013973074,
0.0646149293,
-0.0784165263,
0.0215803385,
0.0149171697,
-0.0331024155,
-0.0458746329,
0.0310542025,
0.0052497606,
0.0426948518,
0.0258605126,
-0.0057942746,
0.050514441,
-0.0074951593,
0.0241673421,
0.0450263806,
0.0094858287,
0.0211408567,
-0.0111979796,
-0.0018026845,
0.0019156543,
0.0095951157,
0.0853733867,
-0.009463626,
0.0246126056,
-0.0143154841,
0.0086019784,
0.0165223423,
0.0411179885,
-0.002124191,
-0.0532061048,
-0.0200689305,
0.039942693,
-0.0079475138,
0.0325686485,
0.0431101546,
-0.0111328661,
-0.0717105865,
0.0299194865,
-0.000448651,
-0.06960655,
0.0146697341,
0.0064199823,
0.0724732429,
0.0568310097,
0.0068243034,
-0.0571536534,
-0.0746680647,
-0.0079036159,
0.064809382,
0.029292522,
0.0138617512,
-0.0408071764,
0.0145112881,
-0.0702457428,
-0.0374519415,
-0.037743587,
-0.0188655294,
-0.0128584355,
0.0193760954,
-0.0073762019,
-0.0276696756,
-0.0051698498,
-0.0386188291,
0.0515928045,
-0.0147752846,
-0.0510107651,
-0.0069628474,
0.0146948798,
0.0233435649,
0.0055501717,
-0.0120909447,
-0.0024196133,
0.0145944227,
-0.0008097175,
0.0508853123,
0.0053935987,
-0.0276421048,
0.0023483306,
0.0408599749,
-0.0661469996,
-0.0199518148,
0.0237795673,
0.0156483818,
-0.0041634026,
0.0098085571,
-0.050656423,
-0.029839281,
0.0290486682,
0.0160933509,
0.0010395187,
0.0051478082,
-0.0259880386,
0.089799203,
0.0214774273,
0.0601243265,
0.0526166223,
0.050001137,
0.0242083129,
-0.0157705415,
0.0162769649,
-0.0263298247,
-0.0235114992,
0.0211633891,
0.006403876,
0.0133901751,
-0.1428514868,
0.0016037177,
-0.0114972489,
0.033144664,
-0.0076531856,
0.0102543253,
0.0202876329,
-0.0494269207,
-0.0020668413,
0.0046574902,
-0.02262027,
0.0219433624,
-0.0179656073,
0.0133197065,
-0.0115531171,
-0.0576206855,
0.0437819511,
-0.0204810072,
0.0006976511,
-0.0205178335,
0.0465203039,
0.0451889671,
0.0070852055,
-0.0124559384,
0.0518973321,
0.029579306,
-0.0153799802,
0.032859005,
0.0262365397,
0.0836117938,
-0.0100495908,
0.1067444161,
0.039733015,
0.0399425514,
0.0296582431,
0.0360531211,
-0.0431981422,
-0.0519018434,
0.0185612384,
-0.0129407579,
0.0038386781,
0.0282234978,
-0.0621709861,
0.0320824422,
0.0112491315,
0.0417562239,
-0.0113136256,
-0.0099575389,
0.033304628,
-0.0234830193,
-0.0507475846,
-0.0540812872,
0.0175622422,
-0.0643360391,
0.0459042378,
-0.0162762161,
-0.0196909625,
0.0357243642,
0.0089338906,
0.0214739349,
-0.0631266609,
0.0596439838,
0.0013128869,
-0.0008826273,
-0.0446601324,
-0.0027447932,
0.0561614819,
-0.0229075551,
-0.0250925459,
0.0035056819,
0.0267002769,
-0.0267105456,
0.0505247489,
-0.0616899244,
-0.0561254695,
0.0338596553,
0.0056486209,
-0.0503703244,
-0.0197518319,
0.0329327099,
-0.0577808209,
0.0071915383,
0.0227965303,
-0.0303041954,
-0.0488900505,
0.0633510798,
0.010121068,
-0.0112205567,
-0.0223221909,
0.0060377703,
0.0840775967,
0.0315918252,
0.0712105185,
-0.0091918539,
-0.055432193,
-0.0071851369,
0.052042976,
0.0425778292,
-0.0595125072,
0.0106897447,
0.0355531648,
0.0344664343,
-0.0333383903,
0.0054040472,
0.0261891242,
0.088180542,
-0.0397017188,
-0.0188503731,
0.0556528755,
0.0322059579,
-0.0109217297,
-0.0252704415,
-0.0387550294,
-0.0405889004,
0.0341039523,
-0.0354460962,
-0.0304640718,
-0.0370214432,
-0.0432331711,
0.0158808548,
-0.0079183755,
-0.0102294013,
0.0105988979,
-0.0926873609,
0.0449025854,
-0.0133189028,
-0.0936679319,
0.0287347678,
-0.0301859565,
-0.0104568563,
-0.0000902016,
-0.0131733213,
0.0032491789,
0.0215522069,
0.0257031713,
0.0500783436,
0.02228285,
-0.00037756,
-0.0528672598,
-0.0377549268,
-0.0307849739,
-0.0298087243,
0.0057957801,
-0.0224937256,
-0.075430885,
-0.0047517153,
-0.0723382756,
-0.009597647,
0.0103766536,
0.0682627037,
0.0054388684,
-0.0016437575,
-0.0741358995,
0.0432851091,
-0.0050396468,
-0.0491507724,
0.0911442563,
0.0593553632,
-0.0007400102,
-0.0174135212,
-0.0134980306,
0.0128504923,
0.0168376956,
0.012830426,
0.0392637067,
-0.074723132,
0.0295888856,
-0.0224300809,
0.0679482743,
-0.0806481317,
-0.0019705044,
0.0102407504,
-0.0487397686,
-0.0142702078,
-0.0413047187,
-0.0513985679,
0.06160748,
0.0305560138,
0.0181735046,
0.0181938056,
0.0133468462,
0.003919947,
-0.0149846515,
0.0321436226,
0.0332283787,
-0.0193239655,
-0.0023255637,
-0.0734992623,
-0.0370999873,
0.0066412091,
0.0091792066,
0.0668169335,
-0.0283069946,
-0.0159863923,
0.0240563937,
0.0504490174,
0.0098662516,
-0.0533473194,
0.0671551228,
-0.0157349687,
-0.0551926605,
-0.0142026432,
-0.0139238639,
-0.0052986052,
-0.037947271,
-0.0306821689,
-0.0013785419,
-0.0463772975,
0.0000894217,
-0.0168105587,
0.0325356387,
0.0160222277,
-0.0416248292,
0.0128689483,
0.0200796667,
0.0169739779,
0.0175148267,
-0.0675323904,
-0.005077628,
-0.0552410893,
0.0027693345,
-0.0048065833,
-0.0526734479,
0.0058445591,
-0.0071459543,
0.0137346312,
-0.0251453128,
0.0031578983,
-0.0176416039,
-0.0433805808,
-0.012066829,
-0.0465309806,
0.0504451767,
0.0420376733,
0.0192667749,
0.0203532726,
0.0125279073,
-0.0182515141,
-0.0139336782,
0.0286112092,
0.0487921759,
0.0448754542,
0.1022804379,
0.0127408644,
-0.0298846085,
0.0322522298,
-0.0097227376,
-0.0031728605,
0.0138056427,
-0.0223277882,
0.0088650249,
0.0164450873,
-0.0068204659,
0.0284806415,
0.0305638015,
-0.0136413248,
-0.0246180035,
0.0424738638,
0.007177555,
-0.0209973529,
0.0244746227,
0.0105638811,
0.0263240747,
-0.0551144145,
0.0586110353,
-0.0290103815,
-0.0019835248,
0.0150921922,
-0.0216189586,
-0.0875271708,
0.0026053532,
-0.0366917737,
0.0555655472,
0.022358302,
0.0173570924,
-0.057702411,
-0.0292767119,
0.0035842427,
0.0136657497,
0.0394504778,
-0.0088766692,
0.0394313112,
0.0280588996,
-0.0365183353,
-0.0069560208,
0.0039284797,
0.0587169193,
-0.0742238015,
-0.0131070996,
-0.0474429801,
-5.735589953e-33,
-0.0306082461,
-0.0688581839,
0.047900442,
-0.0328185484,
-0.009928273,
-0.0166757274,
-0.0517106317,
0.0399920084,
0.0061799302,
-0.0212031938,
0.0136233699,
-0.0371298976,
0.0033954328,
0.0586115271,
0.0298168082,
-0.0459278412,
-0.0102997161,
-0.0123245427,
-0.0258138683,
0.0208625086,
0.0636575222,
-0.03125396,
0.0399875678,
-0.0309668835,
0.0346022509,
-0.0361022577,
0.012223836,
-0.0477164909,
-0.0123310713,
0.0457732156,
-0.0500546768,
0.0931414291,
0.0113451593,
-0.0586931333,
-0.0229192544,
0.0500012189,
-0.0182811152,
-0.0801762938,
0.0045792717,
0.0086115627,
-0.066117458,
-0.0610373467,
0.0448417775,
0.0211609025,
-0.0183004029,
-0.0184123814,
0.0574518144,
0.0110017071,
-0.0208674222,
0.016939424,
-0.095243901,
-0.000587364,
-0.0498242602,
-0.0141892079,
0.0048490977,
0.0686642751,
-0.0138922529,
-0.0069828872,
-0.0371691063,
0.0782671496,
0.0162401758,
-0.0178007912,
0.0266476087,
0.0122919921,
0.0027182975,
0.0531101227,
0.0492853634,
-0.0005407942,
0.025852982,
-0.0228640325,
-0.0070691053,
0.0495537259,
0.0517574884,
0.0578051992,
0.0220540389,
-0.0040255468,
-0.0269873329,
0.0380479433,
-0.030286165,
0.0001109528,
0.0029577825,
-0.0533310287,
0.0171448756,
-0.0117995832,
-0.0087003773,
0.0112706581,
-0.0391953774,
0.0062696398,
0.0547029227,
-0.0673132017,
0.0148706548,
-0.0056732935,
0.0163541287,
0.0106066195,
0.0266200453,
0.0052707116,
-0.0028399504,
0.0592420027,
-0.0006808842,
-0.0489986241,
-0.0171460416,
-0.0062385695,
0.0355380587,
0.0060887709,
0.0440876298,
0.0008763084,
-0.0227540135,
-0.0216188394,
-0.0401422009,
0.0036640866,
-0.0488618873,
0.0115410499,
0.0378397182,
0.0009325449,
0.0395600609,
-0.0097483378,
-0.0397328436,
0.0090414146,
0.0094303396,
-0.019873878,
-0.0251856297,
-0.0585450307,
-0.0036960917,
0.0104291802,
0.0024363536,
0.0082215425,
-0.0366952606,
-0.016690582,
0.0244629458,
-0.0702038109,
0.009998871,
0.0027179981,
2.512e-7,
0.0247365981,
0.0518481806,
-0.0072062407,
0.0168807358,
0.0017496959,
0.0221596882,
0.0025663339,
-0.0064985016,
0.0231496915,
-0.01277564,
-0.0434034802,
-0.0138730491,
-0.020595938,
0.0149383061,
-0.0493836887,
-0.0594324097,
0.0543073714,
0.0148043903,
-0.0280020926,
0.0568631105,
0.0943306908,
-0.0196599234,
-0.0065206052,
-0.022030646,
-0.0342367776,
0.0410991162,
-0.0051743807,
-0.0157686044,
-0.0102170529,
-0.0147736715,
0.0234339982,
-0.0006060855,
-0.0210253354,
0.0473331288,
-0.0223780926,
-0.07968501,
0.0355269946,
-0.0198704936,
0.0303282645,
-0.0425473936,
-0.0006390609,
0.0177866146,
-0.0064428924,
-0.0139239384,
0.0373821706,
-0.0082502002,
-0.0161459316,
0.0510623641,
-0.0473471433,
-0.006757665,
0.0031347258,
-0.0179352481,
0.0049568028,
-0.0352740958,
-0.0118721258,
0.0211189836,
0.0023256799,
-0.0048540854,
-0.0163082015,
0.0482913591,
-0.0249603428,
-0.0407809205,
-0.0153385699,
-0.0460979007,
0.0113055622,
-0.0101401173,
-0.0235783365,
1.294508332e-34,
-0.0173098594,
0.0218929797,
0.0496554263,
0.0212158468,
-0.0149287079,
-0.0552676171,
0.0246300977,
-0.0095921606,
0.032586161,
-0.0498836227,
-0.0092451163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01510v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01510v1 | A Hybrid Strategy for Chat Transcript Summarization | 2024-02-02T15:44:28 | 2024-02-02T15:44:28 | Pratik K. Biswas | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68, I.7 | Text summarization is the process of condensing a piece of text to fewer
sentences, while still preserving its content. Chat transcript, in this
context, is a textual copy of a digital or online conversation between a
customer (caller) and agent(s). This paper presents an indigenously (locally)
developed hybrid method that first combines extractive and abstractive
summarization techniques in compressing ill-punctuated or un-punctuated chat
transcripts to produce more readable punctuated summaries and then optimizes
the overall quality of summarization through reinforcement learning. Extensive
testing, evaluations, comparisons, and validation have demonstrated the
efficacy of this approach for large-scale deployment of chat transcript
summarization, in the absence of manually generated reference (annotated)
summaries. | [
0.0755719319,
-0.0046465453,
-0.0156048127,
-0.0300218314,
-0.019763194,
0.0142101031,
-0.039195139,
0.0063714916,
-0.0056363475,
-0.0172532704,
0.0035326385,
0.0024042549,
0.0284179915,
0.0163752325,
-0.0252179727,
-0.1241116002,
0.0314884931,
-0.0042892061,
0.0297291409,
0.0268727075,
0.0386082083,
0.0059106108,
0.0157499537,
0.0255394075,
0.0143938288,
0.0001139984,
-0.0246805307,
0.0133193955,
0.0295835175,
-0.0084828213,
0.0014563767,
-0.0106855333,
-0.0302086193,
0.0345499031,
0.000001695,
-0.055348698,
-0.0530362241,
-0.012657444,
0.014116372,
0.0111465845,
0.087297231,
-0.0015482657,
-0.0354961529,
0.0456977002,
-0.01448787,
0.0064589833,
0.0402603485,
0.0697421432,
0.0734260753,
0.08266747,
-0.0221280437,
-0.013910397,
0.0192147847,
0.0105383033,
-0.0126215797,
-0.0157120675,
-0.0125617273,
0.0492751077,
0.0386152864,
-0.0326387025,
0.0182886235,
0.0357302092,
0.0012197413,
-0.0389239378,
-0.0406387448,
0.0370255932,
-0.0581206009,
-0.0219797324,
-0.026172692,
0.0350145362,
0.013746039,
0.0173629411,
0.0410973541,
0.0188947245,
0.0079387445,
-0.0275164191,
-0.0860557035,
0.0279044025,
-0.0240664482,
0.0284882579,
-0.0409997366,
0.0420201682,
-0.0475945324,
0.0078143207,
-0.0513979532,
-0.0500978008,
-0.0343041942,
-0.0293726232,
-0.0462154187,
0.0111675691,
0.0298741274,
-0.0419857502,
0.0607111081,
0.0268393792,
-0.0307391509,
-0.0196583085,
-0.0153718544,
-0.0623251908,
0.0195934754,
-0.0366271138,
0.0021258763,
0.0062910626,
0.03041761,
0.0504901744,
-0.0118733654,
0.005376704,
0.051285781,
0.0030707282,
-0.0355907381,
0.0062540956,
-0.0389150828,
-0.0171550587,
-0.0326448232,
0.0542856157,
0.0003290358,
-0.0367952287,
-0.0620789528,
0.0406288542,
0.0309636146,
0.0095207579,
0.0102031762,
-0.012954399,
-0.0420287102,
0.0351542942,
0.0167706013,
-0.007771356,
-0.0347013436,
-0.0088851042,
0.0340311751,
-0.0494269244,
0.0204353891,
0.0240128264,
0.0488022342,
0.0200024694,
-0.0507588275,
0.0474010371,
-0.0431789123,
-0.0277877916,
0.0035539996,
-0.0380442105,
0.0011320936,
-0.0004162969,
-0.0375045314,
-0.037589632,
-0.00706163,
-0.0169320256,
-0.0416189879,
0.048880782,
-0.002837366,
0.0067958087,
-0.0249122456,
0.0191153903,
-0.0236957613,
0.0107581699,
0.0464245342,
0.0012484925,
-0.004092251,
0.0540401116,
0.0552899353,
0.0662473813,
0.0665741786,
0.0255763959,
0.0305881295,
0.0335346833,
-0.0076444498,
0.0052174889,
0.0112675736,
-0.0163776986,
-0.0211700108,
-0.0417317152,
0.0287804455,
0.0729534179,
-0.0454267301,
0.0565115474,
0.060742043,
0.0714198574,
-0.0136688529,
0.0075341635,
0.0191979073,
0.0802825019,
0.023693094,
0.0715302676,
0.0016619756,
0.029498985,
-0.0072364719,
0.0437584519,
0.1044269726,
0.0174766984,
-0.0156453997,
-0.0557791032,
0.0361012705,
-0.0183823165,
0.0412149616,
0.006039124,
0.0177806169,
-0.0004494211,
-0.035125345,
0.0029659059,
-0.0020218121,
-0.0468651615,
-0.0188830718,
-0.0382699259,
0.0109177483,
0.0609688014,
0.0337749794,
-0.0339225121,
-0.0177151579,
-0.041592665,
-0.0393810309,
0.0328145027,
0.0255255904,
-0.0276122801,
-0.0208522528,
-0.0379239731,
-0.0287060086,
0.03600353,
-0.0229962282,
-0.0088650491,
-0.0042406889,
0.0114537291,
0.0246184412,
0.0527094193,
-0.0529526547,
0.0099556157,
-0.0126422225,
-0.0082730697,
0.0016562075,
-0.0124849565,
0.0351070762,
0.0400914885,
-0.0141491126,
-0.0059125712,
0.0021878944,
0.0203187652,
-0.0247989688,
0.0574346259,
-0.0470517948,
-0.041842591,
0.0155458879,
-0.0676582828,
0.0164636858,
0.0038720896,
-0.0389248356,
-0.0511533692,
0.0086039566,
-0.0605365932,
0.0648939386,
-0.0407216586,
0.020060705,
0.0050412556,
-0.008209764,
-0.012757251,
0.0097511858,
0.0019902438,
-0.0243323781,
0.0102113103,
-0.0776960179,
-0.0198900085,
-0.039862521,
0.0455036014,
0.0185825564,
-0.0108222533,
0.0176681019,
0.0685023889,
0.0286374148,
-0.0383087359,
-0.0337943509,
-0.1111611128,
-0.0054628565,
-0.0174034741,
0.0108479988,
0.0314978398,
0.0714401156,
-0.033312127,
-0.044575002,
-0.0033669684,
-0.039338626,
0.0445169881,
0.0097175129,
0.0339540876,
0.0350692198,
0.0159612671,
-0.0647661388,
-0.0171931311,
0.0179845095,
0.0376923643,
0.0140456213,
-0.0525936596,
-0.0431631468,
-0.0132112103,
-0.0037953439,
-0.0299751293,
0.0168043673,
-0.0426757149,
-0.0143806832,
-0.0037589055,
0.0411244966,
0.0312995091,
0.0510185026,
0.0137583334,
-0.0097395563,
0.0183356889,
-0.0506738983,
0.0073167933,
-0.0330449119,
-0.0067228083,
0.003130734,
-0.0334292427,
0.0465145931,
0.0265435372,
-0.0015642009,
0.0263104662,
-0.018609805,
0.009060543,
-0.0271061901,
-0.0315435156,
-0.0298900884,
-0.0135446163,
-0.0365772881,
0.0118306968,
-0.0334919021,
-0.0486083776,
0.0764627978,
0.0368902721,
0.0073932013,
-0.0875707492,
-0.0445903838,
-0.0381344557,
0.0280572232,
-0.0086330473,
0.0342637561,
-0.0106455758,
-0.0720955729,
-0.0399270952,
-0.0511422865,
0.0478589162,
-0.02140259,
0.0194578171,
0.0016967346,
-0.0090412609,
-0.0043433174,
-0.0334219784,
-0.0262100287,
-0.0390245952,
-0.0069518993,
0.0081033725,
0.0472019315,
-0.006450926,
-0.0665086731,
0.054823339,
0.0451305658,
0.0450363792,
-0.0138520664,
-0.0308675207,
0.003187648,
0.0491000079,
0.0309164878,
-0.015255074,
0.0122421933,
-0.0450315885,
0.0358928181,
0.0390398391,
0.016623361,
-0.0344555303,
0.0459817462,
-0.0373305678,
-0.0078193508,
-0.0874373019,
-0.0002428693,
0.0016334536,
0.0430404879,
-0.0194446277,
0.0084281219,
0.0956838503,
0.0275268219,
-0.0443645082,
-0.0272327401,
-0.0395470113,
0.0296679456,
-0.0091051133,
0.0485058837,
-0.0742884427,
0.0079275938,
0.001859555,
0.0456057079,
0.0114997067,
-0.0168709029,
-0.0009531053,
-0.0849666595,
0.0269868933,
0.0196322389,
-0.0981981009,
0.0160736609,
-0.02240422,
-0.0015487702,
-0.011630591,
0.0211897958,
0.0098157106,
-0.0261290539,
0.005096551,
0.0237901602,
-0.0927162841,
0.0322684646,
-0.0747343898,
-0.0208406951,
0.0148778679,
0.0858011171,
0.0421753936,
0.0316564403,
0.0440214761,
0.0162026454,
-0.006613479,
-0.0046878527,
-0.0008822342,
0.0700599253,
0.0219131801,
0.0167424213,
-0.0244892612,
0.0235723108,
0.0614959113,
0.013257849,
0.0282728299,
0.0048498879,
0.0266298968,
-0.0091803158,
-0.0427721925,
0.0425669923,
0.0270563737,
0.0333895199,
0.0268160105,
-0.0208102725,
-0.0712972656,
-0.0323904455,
-0.0233159475,
-0.0577326342,
-0.0144680385,
-0.0110247005,
-0.0551293045,
-0.0262495782,
-0.1096054018,
-0.0677737519,
-0.0058373888,
-0.0252036937,
-0.0206152517,
-0.0049342844,
0.0264067035,
0.0443407483,
-0.0329286866,
-0.0649475902,
-0.0076193302,
-0.0061846911,
-0.0245891754,
0.0142218471,
0.0159708392,
-0.0523045734,
0.0097027188,
-0.0196130425,
-0.0275367629,
-0.0293971449,
-0.0107711442,
0.0325713418,
0.014155807,
0.0734902844,
-0.0024931848,
0.0024473891,
0.0597864538,
0.0339821726,
-0.0221761353,
-0.0086254058,
0.0320510156,
0.0760936737,
-0.0151221501,
0.0085270284,
-0.0718092322,
0.0427064896,
-0.0573549233,
0.0189415254,
-0.0510342717,
-0.016312927,
-0.000542703,
0.0275089405,
-0.0059230342,
-0.0079354867,
-0.0173919331,
0.0071740965,
0.0001736245,
-0.0202278364,
-0.0129760774,
-0.0083716037,
0.0400630645,
-0.0232954901,
0.028423829,
0.0101248603,
0.0587484315,
-0.0181118138,
0.025725361,
-0.0276088323,
0.0106566055,
0.0160726756,
-0.0176094417,
-0.0307648722,
0.0001634624,
-0.0271292031,
-0.0076133339,
0.0081609646,
0.0505603775,
-0.0135043683,
0.0190659836,
0.0106646176,
-0.017899368,
0.021980254,
0.0357188024,
-0.0774689764,
0.0358232185,
-0.0214040466,
0.0485687107,
0.0430046692,
-0.0247988924,
0.0613578744,
0.0102264555,
0.0153927226,
-0.0141327335,
0.0169863943,
0.0025966587,
-0.0255799014,
-0.0842613056,
0.0138713764,
0.003443609,
0.0113966037,
0.0525658578,
-0.080940485,
0.0009655998,
-0.0045749564,
-0.0521365814,
-0.0381094366,
-0.0202552676,
0.0074046012,
0.0397765264,
0.013730661,
-0.0326269194,
-0.019063361,
-0.0051532234,
0.0039717034,
0.0273568667,
0.0345632471,
-0.0033735812,
0.0358851366,
-0.0067242095,
0.0184259135,
0.0086516459,
-0.0542290919,
-0.0478803962,
-0.0244635846,
0.0108433124,
0.0124324672,
-5.531671805e-33,
-0.0134128742,
-0.0206766333,
-0.0165384822,
0.0269221254,
-0.0651161447,
0.0038322432,
-0.032926783,
-0.0445622355,
0.0525800027,
-0.0173960235,
-0.0349922776,
0.0197398588,
0.03039895,
0.0234607626,
-0.005516801,
0.0417821035,
0.0528777093,
-0.0182818174,
-0.023409117,
0.0628741831,
0.0268251654,
0.030126946,
-0.0056721675,
-0.0550329387,
0.0170100909,
-0.0006634855,
-0.0108999796,
0.0070381546,
0.0802181885,
0.0452195555,
-0.0079700891,
-0.0261975266,
0.0085421056,
-0.0264471788,
-0.0506024398,
0.0304393843,
-0.0841978565,
-0.0294027813,
0.0126194824,
-0.0003889546,
-0.0296486765,
-0.0115660308,
0.0394933596,
-0.0364769362,
0.031172365,
-0.00999525,
0.0442766994,
-0.0401919857,
-0.0356006473,
-0.0591472387,
-0.0336502418,
0.0339840688,
-0.0620051026,
0.0030022627,
0.0242490564,
0.0720820576,
0.0114704622,
-0.0422874875,
-0.0198178422,
0.0532222427,
0.0246091988,
0.0147287063,
0.0279288981,
0.0531632043,
0.0045837788,
0.0510174818,
0.0065171518,
-0.0053832494,
-0.020632958,
-0.0026976224,
-0.0191779993,
-0.0025402976,
-0.0126077002,
0.0200166218,
0.0143541656,
0.005165664,
-0.0286223888,
0.0778103471,
0.0394387506,
0.0047676894,
0.0334729329,
0.0373756401,
-0.0326786153,
0.0108987819,
0.0013927553,
0.0291713066,
0.0164802764,
-0.0443065912,
-0.0149951037,
0.0283173323,
-0.0696089268,
-0.0325353593,
0.0256932024,
-0.048683472,
0.016278971,
-0.0254851077,
-0.0334974378,
0.0345349126,
-0.0276499502,
-0.0591494814,
-0.009608632,
0.0028651669,
0.0346079543,
0.0147991246,
-0.0133013641,
0.0190726537,
0.0469322875,
-0.001325228,
-0.0466924012,
0.0211580228,
0.055539988,
0.0520493388,
-0.043067608,
-0.007000749,
0.0126292333,
-0.0127964318,
0.0007210757,
0.0331420489,
0.0049056439,
0.0009060143,
-0.0092544053,
-0.0106914584,
0.0039085629,
0.0099235997,
-0.0463761464,
0.0311385989,
-0.0242669228,
0.034696579,
0.0089229075,
-0.0374450199,
-0.0135435611,
0.0138098728,
2.405e-7,
-0.0040008612,
0.0637843311,
0.0772509202,
-0.0309420992,
-0.004269131,
0.0130635537,
0.0165934786,
0.0104360068,
0.0134865334,
0.0341476426,
0.0752914399,
0.0210178774,
0.0566147715,
0.0235842951,
-0.1591324955,
-0.0557938442,
-0.1043780595,
-0.0568864755,
-0.0375257432,
0.0110937124,
0.0549138151,
0.0484053753,
-0.0020635254,
0.0129923485,
-0.0078919586,
-0.0003417549,
-0.002593328,
-0.0086957514,
-0.0191215612,
0.0111257089,
0.049734734,
0.000444448,
-0.0210193731,
-0.0589348972,
0.001657685,
-0.0210261904,
0.0413313359,
0.0355512835,
0.0248330086,
0.0084019052,
0.0218334924,
-0.0131590124,
0.0399665572,
0.0133752842,
0.0224425532,
-0.0584384501,
-0.0239508301,
-0.0259673502,
-0.0312180482,
-0.0348758921,
-0.0216386579,
-0.0014635543,
-0.0439647846,
0.0690937936,
-0.022930393,
0.0208498128,
0.0018685415,
-0.0811570436,
-0.020469049,
0.0337358639,
0.0175935589,
-0.0370536447,
-0.0185086839,
0.0258580502,
-0.0038094036,
-0.0426164344,
0.0266944468,
1.910643926e-34,
0.0514830314,
-0.000977245,
-0.0287382863,
0.0123422351,
0.0248450469,
-0.0214834698,
0.0559511371,
0.0229056217,
0.0659610182,
-0.0548515618,
-0.0090901367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01505v1 | Code-Switched Language Identification is Harder Than You Think | 2024-02-02T15:38:47 | 2024-02-02T15:38:47 | Laurie Burchell, Alexandra Birch, Robert P. Thompson, Kenneth Heafield | cs.CL | cs.CL | Code switching (CS) is a very common phenomenon in written and spoken
communication but one that is handled poorly by many natural language
processing applications. Looking to the application of building CS corpora, we
explore CS language identification (LID) for corpus building. We make the task
more realistic by scaling it to more languages and considering models with
simpler architectures for faster inference. We also reformulate the task as a
sentence-level multi-label tagging problem to make it more tractable. Having
defined the task, we investigate three reasonable models for this task and
define metrics which better reflect desired performance. We present empirical
evidence that no current approach is adequate and finally provide
recommendations for future work in this area. | [
0.0199300852,
0.0412724614,
-0.0212705899,
0.0395075753,
-0.0352546982,
0.0323593169,
0.0110873608,
0.0028098079,
0.0403632782,
-0.0409684181,
-0.0351133943,
0.0086029954,
0.0008330652,
0.0313373022,
0.044735387,
0.0358197205,
0.0672831088,
-0.0330381244,
0.0123573961,
0.0368810073,
0.0254327599,
0.0025595673,
0.0215246808,
0.0257485062,
0.0019531639,
-0.0093945516,
0.0372354351,
0.0281560086,
-0.0072416281,
-0.0198548585,
0.0523199551,
0.0344548523,
-0.0281451866,
0.0593740158,
0.0000015046,
-0.0178174768,
-0.0795570984,
-0.0367894992,
-0.0297094733,
-0.0113827409,
0.0555974394,
-0.0447404794,
0.000635387,
0.0345420912,
-0.0024864874,
-0.0458594859,
0.0833112672,
-0.0455982871,
0.0283681452,
0.0809044391,
-0.0161996614,
-0.0317079648,
-0.0466863252,
0.0121186795,
-0.0182337593,
-0.063733682,
0.0124466717,
0.0029049274,
0.0248677731,
-0.0321737193,
0.0024160245,
0.033544559,
-0.0435063317,
0.0081721442,
-0.0293808319,
-0.0198743381,
-0.0620310567,
0.0142543167,
-0.0081714131,
0.0074862768,
-0.0731137395,
-0.0654385164,
0.0393695496,
-0.0013633284,
-0.0308395457,
-0.0767789632,
0.0116040679,
0.0135002984,
-0.0543877818,
0.004856356,
0.0668071806,
0.0207498893,
0.0470035858,
0.0027050909,
-0.0406343155,
0.0597869679,
0.0203173738,
0.022587169,
-0.0185298771,
-0.0010133652,
0.0176918823,
-0.0654256791,
0.0218747966,
-0.0035187374,
-0.0578666516,
0.0181250758,
-0.0357492007,
-0.0437315181,
-0.0291029718,
-0.0177554488,
0.0027549739,
0.0129155703,
-0.0333774909,
0.0386164077,
-0.0599773638,
0.0171383023,
0.0040255808,
-0.0218078252,
-0.0260216594,
-0.034984611,
-0.0444998853,
0.011282281,
-0.0578580759,
-0.015606341,
0.0303754099,
0.0209706947,
-0.0128563941,
0.0116704302,
0.0179228019,
0.0124105569,
-0.0348771662,
-0.0908176824,
0.0097344192,
0.0221238807,
0.080899626,
0.0075490219,
-0.0067090904,
-0.0209920388,
-0.022183137,
-0.0776342899,
-0.026182279,
0.0647703111,
0.004902327,
-0.0135354428,
0.0282683168,
0.023326559,
-0.008032972,
-0.0099142138,
-0.0760537535,
-0.0164124891,
-0.0291418135,
-0.0410373434,
-0.0173144247,
-0.0759177133,
-0.0028638127,
0.0168848727,
0.039358601,
-0.0776827112,
-0.0186235756,
-0.0271794386,
-0.0009403974,
0.0786908194,
-0.0478716008,
-0.0131727522,
0.016828781,
-0.0152825369,
-0.0092054559,
0.0736090466,
0.0414282531,
-0.0026972555,
0.0921765789,
-0.0327586085,
0.0390447415,
0.0860462859,
-0.0436290391,
0.0202092621,
0.0122731123,
-0.0451457351,
0.0634773001,
-0.0378421172,
0.0084331147,
0.025993526,
-0.0078932615,
0.0094735241,
-0.0252478924,
0.0181695186,
-0.0185505711,
-0.0017938856,
0.0226988196,
0.0089081516,
-0.0123260813,
0.0161595158,
0.0249271058,
-0.0281416476,
-0.0129462369,
-0.013574359,
-0.0008768971,
-0.0023744483,
-0.0170444604,
0.0169406999,
-0.0414015055,
-0.0483386852,
0.0240611155,
-0.0356335193,
0.0436139815,
-0.0024882855,
0.0113954507,
0.0243014228,
0.0222651418,
-0.0413579866,
0.0319822989,
-0.0482076034,
-0.0109056123,
0.0293220524,
0.0367634892,
-0.0365907103,
0.0120054772,
-0.0234173071,
0.0163374376,
0.0332677811,
0.0113905454,
-0.0380452387,
0.0377729014,
-0.0326514542,
0.0167246908,
0.0311729033,
0.0046232524,
0.0445678271,
0.0107087605,
0.0004318417,
-0.0055662682,
-0.0308764558,
-0.0070947446,
0.0357186086,
-0.0265550204,
0.0016004358,
0.0623796247,
-0.0101543646,
0.0358500853,
-0.0119384145,
-0.0226913467,
0.0073285592,
-0.0401555412,
-0.0336655602,
0.0124443192,
0.0217256658,
0.0185921192,
-0.0411766469,
0.0407754853,
-0.0192083903,
-0.0240346305,
0.0327061675,
-0.0226293858,
-0.0635780469,
0.0590047203,
-0.0340913832,
0.0334400125,
-0.0118041569,
0.0507496074,
-0.0137806991,
-0.0041344594,
-0.013925367,
0.0221976954,
0.0294334851,
0.0486493967,
-0.0022327083,
-0.0126652727,
0.0634222776,
-0.0122416178,
-0.0311381668,
0.0188064557,
-0.0340925753,
-0.0226535201,
0.0273971576,
0.0065404624,
-0.0092612086,
-0.0088221496,
-0.0572733134,
-0.0018867903,
-0.0428780913,
0.0599304996,
0.0066295764,
0.000197469,
-0.0264574196,
-0.0291093048,
-0.0345800892,
-0.0033921921,
-0.0131699117,
0.0147324391,
0.0104134381,
-0.0126106683,
-0.0512471907,
-0.0627413169,
0.0038474817,
-0.0256484039,
0.0554768033,
-0.0050860373,
-0.0999457985,
-0.1046399996,
0.0092519373,
-0.0006085397,
0.0422664545,
0.0061859153,
-0.0354367234,
0.0025444075,
-0.012968868,
0.0455593802,
0.0281320289,
-0.0133024938,
-0.0382792875,
0.0567459837,
-0.0122901024,
-0.026797127,
-0.0248993821,
0.0104361279,
-0.0387788489,
-0.0267378632,
-0.0607732758,
0.0558574684,
0.0794607401,
-0.0119635165,
-0.0086602513,
-0.0231634695,
-0.0632360354,
-0.0254097022,
-0.0005816069,
0.0207936428,
-0.0088112941,
-0.0119860722,
0.0498318747,
-0.0056784609,
-0.0505023263,
0.0313813016,
-0.0522737317,
-0.0108723966,
-0.095875755,
-0.0164670274,
-0.0112202363,
0.0431936905,
0.0075856736,
0.027199164,
0.0782951787,
-0.0568284579,
-0.0013393033,
0.0305514447,
0.0063102297,
-0.0227851849,
-0.005742392,
-0.0671903118,
0.028068101,
-0.0028375352,
-0.0327950455,
-0.0208740868,
-0.0314944722,
-0.0586538948,
0.0072690779,
0.0625053644,
-0.0159849543,
0.0002693852,
0.0249072239,
0.0191593487,
0.0845571905,
0.0213720035,
0.0226173792,
-0.0083363429,
0.0398957133,
-0.0018193021,
-0.0553985313,
0.0192222316,
-0.0033444071,
-0.0224883016,
0.0142588289,
0.0625340864,
0.0598308183,
-0.0290791225,
-0.0166182388,
0.0512763672,
-0.0384207293,
-0.0279055834,
-0.0022899844,
0.0167511459,
0.0052762632,
-0.0311466679,
0.1009212658,
0.0437218808,
-0.0962242857,
-0.0258062445,
0.0264304839,
0.0309662465,
0.0309744235,
0.0086519541,
-0.085990034,
-0.0545534566,
0.0382253714,
0.0225752871,
-0.0353651978,
-0.0283849649,
-0.0346282385,
-0.0583134927,
0.0085560055,
0.0102294739,
-0.0202126782,
-0.0233318172,
-0.0243728328,
0.0058438084,
-0.0051883296,
-0.069866918,
-0.0179923475,
0.0052355709,
-0.0017914171,
0.0317069404,
-0.0373784229,
-0.012731066,
-0.0057377764,
-0.0489146635,
0.0545762293,
0.0682809278,
-0.0064276382,
-0.0211383998,
0.0013405329,
0.0384330116,
-0.0361218899,
-0.0411816947,
-0.0300860982,
0.0315687619,
-0.0322127007,
-0.0323753543,
0.0632876679,
0.0068528848,
-0.0477890447,
-0.007047731,
0.0113822045,
-0.0005611952,
0.007594727,
-0.0151952142,
0.0553763919,
-0.0019316078,
0.0374539904,
0.0445034057,
0.0289509445,
-0.0533895306,
-0.0000144965,
-0.0395404361,
0.0313965492,
-0.0305578467,
-0.0111557283,
0.0074218335,
-0.0204207972,
-0.0722150654,
-0.0695042089,
0.0195445437,
0.0250104498,
0.0310326479,
0.0122169489,
0.0336294733,
0.0132876663,
0.0118107703,
-0.0526869893,
-0.0208899956,
-0.0502476133,
0.0420309678,
-0.0733120516,
-0.0210902691,
0.0423632748,
-0.0127882529,
-0.0032941557,
0.0288044047,
-0.1334987581,
-0.0453031063,
0.0160346441,
-0.0260784216,
0.0145268571,
0.0007339007,
-0.0474202558,
-0.0323787183,
-0.0749432594,
-0.0002346536,
-0.0312366076,
-0.0001411259,
0.0356153622,
0.0039022318,
-0.0223803557,
0.0205152649,
-0.0281250793,
0.0061407201,
0.0593420044,
-0.0057376656,
-0.0746801123,
0.0015194276,
0.0131239695,
0.0275746472,
0.0403044894,
-0.0534817129,
-0.0038475841,
-0.0241249111,
-0.014530546,
0.0449567884,
-0.0268074274,
-0.010119319,
-0.0194916278,
0.0370488763,
-0.0127022797,
-0.020402167,
0.0639908686,
-0.0223105922,
0.0261233989,
0.0161109753,
0.0414874665,
0.045454476,
0.0682823882,
-0.0133889457,
-0.0225655735,
-0.0083339056,
0.045785591,
0.0338119194,
0.0408589728,
-0.027005462,
0.0208270792,
0.0243375301,
-0.0257613994,
0.0103957457,
0.0456218235,
-0.0262298249,
0.0251013916,
0.0165471975,
-0.0131605966,
0.0614300333,
0.0086874431,
0.0934112668,
-0.0031309205,
0.0005713087,
-0.0485576168,
0.031074943,
0.003987032,
-0.0277636293,
-0.0117559405,
-0.0112250149,
-0.0468580425,
0.0064056008,
0.0836592689,
0.0281565748,
0.0119010266,
-0.0020935521,
-0.0394051708,
-0.0075323372,
0.0203092694,
-0.0164622348,
-0.0012266384,
-0.0032148636,
-0.0023389147,
-0.0270346254,
-0.0436384939,
0.0347710624,
-0.0068346411,
0.0737807453,
0.0267517176,
0.0018387639,
0.0856760144,
0.020261446,
0.0182626806,
-0.0544546917,
0.0033213994,
0.0671425909,
-0.0211033095,
-0.0123444917,
-5.101671931e-33,
0.0002042921,
-0.0164953656,
-0.0458894297,
0.024172727,
0.0552775487,
-0.0205195267,
-0.0582224354,
0.0267888829,
-0.0151186613,
-0.0563526712,
0.009068531,
0.0209357254,
0.0332812481,
-0.0173908714,
0.0248698574,
0.0012816403,
0.0172439478,
0.0261397064,
-0.0419405475,
0.0007818483,
0.0372689255,
-0.0027322213,
0.0689619258,
-0.0555472299,
0.0185581017,
-0.0310225748,
-0.0121797016,
-0.0190907307,
0.0470602252,
0.0432110205,
-0.0008206443,
0.0175014436,
0.0361717604,
-0.000988648,
-0.0041021449,
0.0293654744,
-0.0254054144,
0.0105749825,
0.0131453658,
0.0587437451,
0.0339045338,
-0.0629863217,
-0.0060096886,
-0.0317403749,
0.0072279121,
0.0139890192,
0.0215002242,
-0.0219873693,
0.0152381221,
-0.0219254531,
-0.0672338903,
0.0733739883,
-0.0001558055,
0.0088677378,
0.0678309053,
0.065973334,
-0.0149757061,
0.0504560322,
-0.0461969711,
0.0265505407,
-0.0184801109,
0.0559456311,
0.0265273359,
0.046767801,
-0.0307502691,
0.0259982795,
0.0586246029,
-0.0106741413,
0.0249355864,
0.0111738173,
0.0382485278,
-0.0385236964,
0.0622288063,
0.05085719,
0.0292568728,
-0.0061094109,
-0.0511419326,
-0.0095234336,
0.0555900745,
-0.0380596332,
-0.0007815941,
0.0162910484,
-0.030321043,
-0.0248223376,
-0.0213633254,
-0.0814954117,
-0.032711558,
-0.0017327379,
0.0387083888,
-0.0182723086,
-0.0147018097,
0.0038859353,
0.0799052194,
-0.0250976346,
0.0062977155,
-0.0304175057,
0.0242073443,
0.0696671158,
0.0076597207,
0.0624841638,
-0.0603268705,
-0.0352379307,
0.0219110474,
0.0086311242,
0.0598755479,
-0.0110787032,
0.0479029641,
0.0309907515,
-0.0563585795,
-0.0025761619,
0.0008324016,
0.0211589281,
-0.0459722914,
0.0453910343,
0.0032865491,
-0.0053767581,
0.0299355797,
0.0065218075,
0.0305163413,
0.0044927071,
-0.0165895447,
-0.0566556267,
-0.0422208086,
0.0487102754,
-0.0312034693,
-0.014097482,
-0.004478801,
0.0652199313,
0.0097106313,
-0.0177211296,
0.0344207026,
0.0190163963,
2.197e-7,
0.0319590233,
0.0084783947,
0.0071310853,
0.0093362713,
0.0165419839,
0.0132438075,
-0.0234468263,
-0.0014994489,
0.0024451658,
-0.0160933174,
-0.055079896,
-0.0341119021,
0.0914445147,
0.0241922513,
-0.0842666477,
-0.0089417966,
0.0176732801,
0.0357882977,
-0.0215436593,
0.0075397049,
0.0322716758,
0.1099315062,
-0.01003417,
0.0155882863,
-0.0095631946,
-0.0296911504,
-0.0100848358,
-0.0021187735,
0.0137886368,
0.0407305285,
-0.0058365338,
0.01728197,
-0.0118001224,
0.0139385415,
-0.0168399625,
-0.0088974293,
0.0211705826,
0.0294554736,
-0.0058592316,
0.029538827,
-0.0178878643,
-0.0095014926,
-0.0130574061,
-0.0252701398,
0.0484619513,
0.0435007401,
0.0289603975,
-0.0088238101,
0.0029585047,
-0.000303144,
-0.0266404562,
0.0004135225,
-0.0713908151,
0.0700171217,
0.0197734796,
-0.0157630127,
-0.0205598604,
-0.0719494373,
-0.0221203994,
0.0027395769,
-0.0110068899,
-0.0193674713,
0.0221430324,
-0.0271596797,
0.0373210758,
-0.0541488789,
0.036784973,
1.829610351e-34,
0.0012157038,
-0.0187397562,
-0.0328198671,
0.0448432788,
0.027639769,
-0.0197487995,
-0.0681959987,
0.0444257595,
-0.0259801894,
-0.0173126794,
0.0165227465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01495v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01495v1 | A Comparative Analysis of Conversational Large Language Models in Knowledge-Based Text Generation | 2024-02-02T15:26:39 | 2024-02-02T15:26:39 | Phillip Schneider, Manuel Klettner, Elena Simperl, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating natural language text from graph-structured data is essential for
conversational information seeking. Semantic triples derived from knowledge
graphs can serve as a valuable source for grounding responses from
conversational agents by providing a factual basis for the information they
communicate. This is especially relevant in the context of large language
models, which offer great potential for conversational interaction but are
prone to hallucinating, omitting, or producing conflicting information. In this
study, we conduct an empirical analysis of conversational large language models
in generating natural language text from semantic triples. We compare four
large language models of varying sizes with different prompting techniques.
Through a series of benchmark experiments on the WebNLG dataset, we analyze the
models' performance and identify the most common issues in the generated
predictions. Our findings show that the capabilities of large language models
in triple verbalization can be significantly improved through few-shot
prompting, post-processing, and efficient fine-tuning techniques, particularly
for smaller models that exhibit lower zero-shot performance. | [
0.0734867975,
-0.0008997235,
0.0142087331,
0.0380366519,
-0.0426536985,
-0.0089468947,
0.021615861,
0.0020676458,
0.0218633916,
-0.0953990519,
0.0023496165,
-0.0331753008,
0.0093864873,
0.0446684584,
0.0235607326,
-0.0297199506,
0.0175447129,
-0.04169631,
0.0188564546,
-0.0008108949,
0.0181321427,
0.0262212064,
0.0069631319,
0.0369970649,
-0.0173395742,
0.0091873361,
-0.0283274874,
0.0219317265,
-0.0287727956,
-0.0416248739,
-0.0202334411,
0.0433131531,
0.0191450026,
0.0213030223,
0.0000018022,
-0.0548605621,
-0.0032015659,
-0.0070036366,
-0.0009240222,
0.0004899735,
0.0328370966,
-0.0133490302,
0.0200801287,
0.0136779565,
-0.0591129512,
-0.0100476556,
0.0284416378,
0.0603345372,
0.0392330922,
0.0712967962,
-0.0230835415,
-0.0186169315,
-0.0099667972,
-0.0111724921,
0.0428956114,
-0.0217548944,
0.0287016574,
0.0707768425,
0.0283083636,
0.0085368892,
0.0182610061,
0.0167273358,
-0.0218126606,
-0.0356541052,
0.0404288135,
0.042170573,
-0.0274892114,
-0.0384203009,
-0.0092214569,
0.1045573801,
0.0263925325,
0.0035596392,
0.0003134949,
-0.0044745388,
0.0190754198,
-0.0056832712,
-0.0505261309,
0.0632680282,
-0.0161935668,
-0.0135154314,
-0.0234507192,
-0.0055067134,
0.0278556217,
0.0081293238,
-0.0282677524,
0.0656919554,
0.0172522161,
-0.0101014273,
-0.0095500797,
-0.0088164229,
-0.0253600422,
-0.0964879766,
-0.0103908554,
0.0347106233,
-0.0483066514,
0.0257227533,
-0.060016606,
0.0179142226,
0.0127632478,
-0.0120861595,
0.0161828119,
0.0313226469,
0.0255506132,
0.0286399126,
-0.0145341,
0.040840622,
-0.0019231563,
-0.0213940237,
-0.0290728696,
-0.0037857599,
-0.0280097611,
-0.0141016701,
-0.0401496738,
0.0690106228,
-0.0528544746,
-0.0654518679,
-0.0315069556,
0.0457587577,
0.015960671,
0.0395936742,
0.0257631037,
0.0265785623,
-0.0235764496,
-0.0014070559,
-0.0187225901,
0.0226054937,
-0.0223727413,
0.0112006199,
0.050318744,
-0.0690049455,
0.0251833051,
0.0234315228,
0.0451702997,
-0.0099997548,
-0.0156795215,
0.0694947764,
-0.0056049963,
-0.0339628831,
-0.0184299126,
-0.0750777721,
-0.0313932933,
-0.0773610547,
-0.0038667037,
-0.0597140193,
0.0543712825,
0.0267155766,
-0.026221646,
-0.0240348615,
0.0405645557,
0.0141415,
-0.048037149,
0.0392855145,
-0.0634771511,
0.0085108075,
-0.0041787121,
-0.0001425739,
-0.0128512681,
0.0479462296,
0.0467764959,
0.0387606956,
0.055012621,
0.0049240347,
-0.0282269996,
0.023622822,
0.0027716986,
0.0146778505,
-0.0066934424,
0.0084135626,
-0.0049529006,
0.0686796978,
0.0022612605,
0.0856417641,
-0.0513839647,
0.0369434655,
0.0793520957,
0.0266639143,
0.0076690661,
0.0139282942,
0.0873993486,
0.0307973828,
0.000848254,
0.0045627565,
-0.029153334,
0.0028684207,
-0.0312239174,
0.051913809,
0.0285194404,
0.0311738867,
-0.0183316916,
-0.03272333,
0.0094750337,
-0.0040698173,
0.0330047458,
-0.0168451648,
0.0354135968,
0.0272504315,
-0.0735429004,
0.0125541072,
0.045968879,
-0.0682509318,
0.015830351,
-0.0288645551,
0.0333444476,
0.1040529162,
0.0481996238,
0.0456623733,
-0.0351888016,
0.0110444855,
0.0270224866,
0.0368821993,
0.0436468609,
-0.0123630222,
-0.0141438944,
-0.0451344699,
-0.0101532787,
-0.0301885493,
-0.0084570879,
0.0293900929,
0.0201749224,
-0.0024192922,
0.0377023369,
-0.0134487888,
-0.0067864046,
-0.0022161682,
-0.0412979424,
0.0287205875,
0.0072874753,
-0.0194571912,
-0.0166013893,
0.027157424,
-0.0223782267,
0.0289096721,
0.0139367431,
-0.0089644678,
-0.0212326329,
0.021596713,
-0.0292868577,
-0.0655042902,
0.0244400278,
0.0136009334,
0.0274486914,
-0.0451464057,
-0.0102091879,
-0.0533963814,
0.0016437093,
-0.028599022,
0.059306547,
-0.0112911891,
0.0149528282,
0.0578960739,
-0.0092649292,
-0.01442343,
0.0650709197,
0.0206857007,
0.0016104683,
0.0344880149,
0.0201799981,
-0.0137766665,
-0.0494725518,
0.0159375928,
0.0459079258,
0.0045623085,
-0.0046193791,
0.0315983184,
0.0122386441,
-0.0456743874,
-0.0245929398,
-0.1166732535,
0.020484224,
-0.0033064056,
-0.0055194879,
0.016391525,
0.0252918024,
0.0108159129,
0.0202748105,
-0.0839175656,
0.0373959541,
0.0326869376,
0.0197611246,
0.0299901795,
0.0244691037,
-0.035397809,
-0.0189021695,
0.0016009359,
-0.001140464,
0.0838099942,
0.0532104895,
-0.0395430773,
-0.0372027308,
0.0709016621,
-0.0902126655,
0.0164235197,
-0.0111185471,
-0.0134141399,
0.0086341863,
-0.0250033792,
0.0512689315,
0.0345663056,
0.019097751,
0.0374174602,
0.0265512131,
-0.0320355296,
-0.0406018831,
-0.0092052557,
-0.0377656594,
0.0003760048,
-0.0375024974,
-0.0249011964,
-0.0077715018,
0.0149712637,
0.0377608053,
0.0188467167,
-0.0562526844,
0.030883126,
0.023419641,
-0.0262779556,
-0.019978676,
-0.0101754144,
-0.0073197191,
0.0376855619,
-0.0180540066,
-0.0046731587,
0.0380291492,
-0.0601224825,
-0.0085671209,
0.0152915604,
0.0133323418,
-0.0368875004,
0.0465500616,
0.0043696598,
0.0487155393,
-0.0229512062,
-0.0129566621,
-0.0274549276,
-0.0228072628,
0.0331113376,
-0.0311742965,
0.0138477646,
-0.0394041538,
0.0228122249,
0.0139742792,
-0.0367800966,
-0.030281188,
-0.023453366,
-0.042744305,
0.0238673519,
0.044495374,
-0.0478156209,
-0.0143366419,
0.0181227569,
0.026530508,
0.0306799039,
-0.0290381014,
-0.0309760887,
-0.0512025952,
0.0503128879,
0.0626503751,
-0.003857892,
0.0100919977,
-0.0235849079,
0.0576932132,
0.056465704,
0.0066967974,
0.016526578,
-0.0315427072,
-0.0127443857,
-0.0004648599,
-0.0193517301,
-0.0352593474,
0.0344479308,
0.0348461159,
-0.0305100866,
0.0011929534,
0.1303432882,
0.0161953513,
-0.0079296129,
0.0120920334,
0.0154176336,
0.0465222448,
0.0108496035,
0.0077778157,
-0.1047562361,
-0.0304827411,
0.0038077091,
0.0012495309,
-0.0035037049,
-0.0578091517,
-0.0346170627,
-0.1382638812,
0.0272799302,
0.0135296285,
0.0086885467,
-0.0253723152,
-0.0086232144,
-0.0204482879,
0.0245432686,
-0.0143652596,
-0.0022766462,
-0.0265994892,
0.0080554914,
0.0077337297,
-0.0069122692,
-0.0521981269,
0.0241195112,
-0.0184997562,
0.0396213382,
0.0320434086,
0.030777907,
0.020969132,
0.0103160236,
0.0198187195,
0.0422856845,
0.008534722,
-0.0113729956,
0.0147018833,
-0.023634119,
0.0042758812,
-0.0457287319,
0.0274951346,
-0.0066087139,
-0.0100698974,
-0.0052503659,
0.0044402396,
-0.0379959084,
-0.0279295482,
0.0160762854,
0.054179322,
0.0237458479,
0.0769805536,
0.0386872254,
-0.0269472878,
-0.0403426699,
-0.0173858665,
-0.0074722446,
-0.0542052239,
-0.0141664324,
0.0379590318,
0.0077559855,
-0.0091064097,
-0.0723682493,
-0.0532273464,
0.0391415991,
0.0338496193,
0.0081712445,
0.0032543135,
0.0365316235,
0.0012884609,
-0.0003509607,
0.0001167066,
-0.028421808,
0.0086043552,
-0.0332865827,
-0.0005440927,
0.0261288863,
-0.0585052148,
-0.0051608053,
0.0010786103,
-0.0856921598,
-0.086341612,
-0.0368595943,
0.0391225591,
0.0274832342,
0.0577683561,
0.0037868787,
-0.0327316411,
0.004352259,
0.0566019751,
-0.0368997976,
0.0324463211,
-0.0214087144,
0.0524630733,
0.0058233268,
0.0445317999,
-0.0450141095,
0.0070286486,
-0.0319891497,
0.0626767799,
-0.0269150753,
-0.0562905185,
0.0167324562,
0.0681843907,
-0.0299058724,
-0.0092648845,
0.0227123275,
-0.0255884007,
-0.0057291053,
-0.0749125183,
-0.0364008695,
-0.0865108669,
-0.0037707193,
-0.00057041,
-0.0099402592,
0.0127340145,
-0.0252447911,
-0.0171032473,
0.0294404533,
-0.0174606871,
-0.0387879126,
-0.0252959933,
-0.0326835103,
0.0765150264,
-0.0402047783,
-0.0516127199,
0.0512259416,
-0.0144152977,
0.0053205863,
-0.0242857318,
0.0617026798,
0.0180729143,
-0.0516357869,
-0.0264425781,
0.0197194982,
-0.0368465073,
-0.0433436371,
-0.0124176238,
0.0187415145,
0.0417932309,
0.0286964718,
0.0822015703,
-0.0561962053,
0.0106319431,
-0.0250221174,
0.0692312121,
0.0153690251,
-0.0696023777,
0.0530931987,
-0.0094633158,
-0.0282415785,
-0.0011411966,
0.0841256231,
0.0467123948,
0.0356971361,
0.0327967033,
-0.0282551758,
-0.0472541936,
-0.0381454602,
0.0000425079,
0.0230217166,
-0.0007238821,
-0.0064295442,
-0.0687703788,
-0.046573285,
-0.0187975504,
-0.0121244285,
-0.0126382029,
-0.0090529351,
0.044995483,
0.064826183,
0.0115229525,
-0.0134726232,
-0.0557875559,
0.0081188241,
-0.0541577749,
-0.0028192012,
-0.0223795176,
-6.301916316e-33,
-0.0331346318,
-0.0689505115,
0.0407079682,
-0.010521858,
-0.0485149771,
-0.0139183039,
-0.0505243987,
0.0107220076,
-0.0132000493,
0.0106003843,
-0.0050272634,
0.0012771003,
0.0080211796,
0.0405970439,
-0.037076205,
-0.0095271859,
0.0454919189,
-0.0127449865,
-0.0379641913,
0.0558121577,
0.0608424656,
0.017684577,
0.0188777335,
-0.0490535051,
0.0254639052,
-0.0460806452,
-0.0318909474,
0.0162778292,
0.0181762613,
0.038117025,
-0.0174512751,
0.0414498225,
0.0138024734,
-0.0026399179,
-0.0146701047,
0.0174617954,
-0.0363222919,
-0.0114325592,
0.0423755161,
-0.0010515783,
-0.0477085821,
-0.030254133,
0.0089199021,
-0.0239448734,
0.0043818024,
-0.0177895557,
0.0145911332,
-0.0174517464,
-0.0677154809,
-0.0592742823,
-0.0510202348,
0.0285753049,
-0.002820798,
-0.0248687435,
-0.0082082441,
0.0456028283,
0.0012205004,
-0.0068722409,
-0.0318471231,
0.0611172803,
0.0061391364,
0.0030006508,
0.0405838825,
0.0256290697,
0.0126942024,
0.0725568607,
0.0125500858,
0.036057882,
-0.032099016,
0.0015833558,
-0.0144006172,
0.0723120421,
-0.0200511329,
0.0631574765,
-0.0263457727,
0.0112306904,
-0.0649992824,
-0.0233962052,
-0.0194451306,
-0.0061212531,
0.0226414744,
-0.047123678,
-0.0415241718,
-0.037809182,
-0.0539595038,
0.0047146608,
-0.0360660292,
-0.038241718,
0.0332567319,
0.0089938249,
0.0047920342,
-0.006032052,
0.0361607037,
-0.0336008854,
-0.0264608171,
0.0660898536,
-0.0543573685,
0.02955167,
-0.0330610909,
0.0106823985,
-0.051089406,
-0.0424083881,
0.0234266073,
0.0013718726,
-0.0094675738,
0.0526384935,
-0.007201633,
0.003327366,
-0.0473135673,
-0.0030949584,
-0.0412510857,
0.0077566258,
-0.0157371406,
-0.0227516703,
0.0318274572,
0.0025177628,
-0.0398913696,
0.0647084117,
0.0073187998,
-0.0008547967,
-0.0016777246,
-0.0328748748,
0.0183964092,
0.0246505216,
-0.0268320255,
0.0149770919,
-0.0501528978,
-0.0114466352,
0.0608380921,
-0.0228549819,
-0.0149234543,
-0.0078917304,
2.678e-7,
0.0066113616,
0.0606857985,
0.0046586036,
0.0413663387,
0.0125029711,
0.0356215984,
0.0280385967,
0.0214552935,
0.019239733,
-0.0227348004,
0.0088904742,
0.0290494841,
0.012242469,
0.0098495679,
-0.0721526444,
-0.0023333514,
-0.0809831321,
-0.0386804976,
-0.0623718202,
-0.0188119598,
0.074838765,
0.0491955988,
0.0063120308,
0.0058137267,
-0.0066775796,
-0.0755847096,
0.0705564618,
-0.0209248941,
-0.044874832,
0.0488101281,
0.0573620908,
-0.0023095745,
-0.0165884998,
0.0340499878,
0.0059704832,
-0.0098296637,
0.0026638673,
0.0560112819,
0.0129627874,
0.0178324375,
0.0239412673,
-0.0274685808,
-0.0094298581,
-0.0333408751,
0.0654750764,
-0.0702401325,
-0.0161516014,
0.0174764767,
-0.0032075671,
-0.0327099226,
-0.0342680477,
-0.0504242368,
0.0015247543,
0.0153804999,
0.0049546035,
0.01350071,
0.0078501143,
-0.0247151125,
-0.0122270146,
-0.0109825442,
-0.0318026207,
-0.0806317031,
-0.0348438062,
-0.0265002102,
0.0241549052,
-0.0569878928,
0.003042415,
2.615285979e-34,
0.0502677858,
-0.0040923427,
0.0098899053,
-0.0137716373,
0.0586608835,
0.0007053334,
0.0419459306,
0.0049024839,
0.0231058523,
-0.1208257526,
-0.0174738653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01469v1 | AMOR: A Recipe for Building Adaptable Modular Knowledge Agents Through Process Feedback | 2024-02-02T14:56:48 | 2024-02-02T14:56:48 | Jian Guan, Wei Wu, Zujie Wen, Peng Xu, Hongning Wang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The notable success of large language models (LLMs) has sparked an upsurge in
building language agents to complete various complex tasks. We present AMOR, an
agent framework based on open-source LLMs, which reasons with external
knowledge bases and adapts to specific domains through human supervision to the
reasoning process. AMOR builds reasoning logic over a finite state machine
(FSM) that solves problems through autonomous executions and transitions over
disentangled modules. This allows humans to provide direct feedback to the
individual modules, and thus naturally forms process supervision. Based on this
reasoning and feedback framework, we develop AMOR through two-stage
fine-tuning: warm-up and adaptation. The former fine-tunes the LLM with
examples automatically constructed from various public datasets and enables
AMOR to generalize across different knowledge environments, while the latter
tailors AMOR to specific domains using process feedback. Extensive experiments
across multiple domains demonstrate the advantage of AMOR to strong baselines,
thanks to its FSM-based reasoning and process feedback mechanism. | [
0.0343669914,
0.05371112,
-0.0318286568,
0.0240011252,
-0.0384437889,
0.0153870387,
-0.0055585061,
-0.0238520578,
0.0494167991,
-0.0080211423,
0.0056683826,
0.008242514,
-0.0172004513,
0.0557499789,
-0.0051937983,
-0.0446359254,
0.04422668,
-0.069001995,
0.0074227611,
-0.0231654514,
-0.0109778028,
-0.0035035196,
-0.0183506273,
0.0089253308,
0.0198637508,
0.0218881629,
-0.0523302481,
-0.0189348124,
0.0148090897,
-0.011366928,
-0.0230859425,
0.020802578,
0.0476916395,
0.0195765104,
0.0000021943,
-0.0545130186,
0.0201379657,
0.0018912681,
-0.0316426791,
-0.0498817712,
-0.0211938135,
-0.0107889343,
-0.0032247738,
0.0276725776,
-0.0479301438,
-0.0039048903,
0.0273447484,
0.0205247272,
0.0783654153,
0.0784484446,
-0.0050018048,
-0.0370986387,
0.0136059681,
-0.0011350331,
-0.0008227601,
-0.0331705846,
0.0350407623,
0.0158323161,
0.0482581854,
-0.0184716936,
-0.0299019553,
0.0089421645,
0.0403030217,
-0.025463907,
-0.0274116229,
0.0355757475,
0.0043343753,
-0.0431352742,
-0.0065777712,
0.0808674023,
0.048954647,
-0.0123918671,
0.0172422081,
0.0037939828,
-0.005704232,
0.0133081628,
-0.0442045666,
0.0432238132,
0.0064802831,
0.0213321988,
0.0322107151,
-0.0232188255,
0.0129734268,
0.0335970782,
-0.0643759668,
0.114217028,
0.0078951716,
-0.0188291911,
-0.0045800675,
0.0093296943,
0.0136692803,
-0.0629633591,
0.0047755525,
0.0802052394,
-0.0509414002,
0.0498303026,
-0.0364123918,
-0.0261937566,
-0.0251051765,
-0.0424250849,
-0.0061593126,
0.0560786426,
0.0237291325,
0.0730663091,
-0.0364313945,
0.0407511555,
0.0006888647,
0.0549520478,
-0.0144003853,
-0.0447732322,
-0.1152695492,
0.0233047362,
-0.0026785387,
0.0401571244,
-0.0114694508,
0.0026081847,
0.0000681723,
0.0785360038,
-0.0369923003,
0.074746117,
-0.0056209825,
-0.0094798347,
-0.0063551762,
-0.037294548,
-0.091807574,
0.0607616119,
-0.0487729385,
0.0178766642,
0.0119328927,
-0.0052850265,
-0.0031145727,
0.0139394682,
-0.0031830836,
-0.0013802523,
0.0184620675,
0.1006567255,
-0.0070379535,
-0.0090824524,
-0.0165879671,
-0.0445024893,
0.0330881774,
-0.0779570714,
-0.00365612,
-0.0414614752,
0.0598893538,
0.0122050503,
-0.0244246535,
-0.0451799482,
0.0107796211,
-0.0087786857,
-0.0314881504,
0.0630446374,
-0.0361660235,
0.020740794,
-0.0140548991,
0.0206779186,
0.0127574438,
0.0695096701,
0.0322373733,
0.0328627378,
0.0228310209,
0.0175092276,
0.0170880947,
0.0115610119,
0.0055066813,
0.0319550484,
-0.0113417637,
0.0390793607,
-0.0327770449,
0.0339023545,
-0.0001574017,
0.0265815444,
0.0000779531,
0.0305070244,
0.0538335592,
0.0240892339,
-0.0002099376,
0.0236966163,
0.0131049166,
0.0340290666,
-0.0143852504,
-0.0423283949,
-0.0467250608,
0.0697140694,
-0.0248736199,
0.0204225685,
-0.0411700793,
0.0254184809,
-0.0454393886,
-0.0394161381,
0.0087028695,
-0.0011645213,
0.0408921055,
0.0438142307,
0.0805069134,
0.0176728982,
-0.0518256351,
0.0211288407,
0.0293913204,
-0.0303267967,
0.0113880644,
-0.0796913728,
0.0615075007,
0.1090017483,
0.0547795407,
-0.0289405081,
-0.0365881659,
-0.0024123061,
-0.0094928769,
0.0645279214,
0.004239263,
-0.013959527,
0.0041088304,
-0.032881543,
-0.0470803641,
0.0029241161,
-0.0117404936,
0.0265944451,
0.0219375826,
-0.0063430709,
-0.0242467839,
0.0044297255,
0.0121546714,
0.0315818787,
-0.0462036692,
0.0124787595,
-0.0126838954,
0.0067993985,
0.0414299406,
0.0149375414,
0.012012531,
-0.0055163247,
0.0401328355,
-0.0137112243,
-0.0498692393,
0.0262360964,
0.0096865222,
-0.0161417499,
0.0303992555,
-0.0161481835,
0.0002746078,
-0.0310786515,
-0.0537934229,
-0.0684075877,
0.0851315036,
-0.0077105388,
0.0302216224,
-0.0134948585,
-0.0113169998,
-0.0204605032,
-0.0060849423,
-0.0164212901,
0.0405235849,
0.0094553735,
-0.0502691492,
0.0100545241,
-0.0067017232,
0.0019970727,
0.0252155885,
0.006278459,
0.0442670546,
0.018027531,
0.023100514,
0.0272178836,
0.0055370228,
-0.0422693565,
-0.0579734631,
-0.0941186547,
-0.0187258162,
0.0047388151,
-0.0062469062,
0.0166230444,
0.0054583638,
0.0030161068,
-0.0067652022,
0.0050105825,
0.027410401,
0.0158477854,
0.0195934977,
0.0224177502,
0.0256547816,
-0.065220505,
-0.0291829426,
0.0051601534,
-0.0081630582,
-0.0084705725,
-0.0061920797,
0.0232281387,
-0.0942768902,
0.0136962002,
-0.0533211194,
0.0537191778,
-0.0161104761,
-0.0274885669,
0.0353515111,
-0.0311650187,
0.0106014982,
0.0494394302,
-0.0269904528,
0.0268119629,
0.0874773115,
-0.0329536311,
-0.0397569314,
0.0371008702,
-0.0386347771,
0.0108850915,
-0.0561687052,
0.0021593198,
-0.0008146232,
0.0775796995,
-0.0056916946,
0.0043062503,
-0.0719652325,
-0.0083764941,
0.0161847398,
-0.0092864307,
-0.0009857125,
-0.0251942258,
-0.0013095438,
0.04889578,
-0.0041003898,
-0.0082120132,
0.1096252725,
-0.0055952789,
-0.0117757497,
-0.0066058347,
-0.0261111371,
-0.0346399471,
0.0934926122,
-0.0074819773,
-0.0164466258,
-0.0228831097,
0.0112343216,
-0.0463479646,
-0.0329128951,
0.0460543893,
-0.0043336386,
0.0420175679,
-0.0943553969,
0.0110828737,
0.0182050411,
0.0001919042,
-0.0439883582,
0.0234727506,
-0.0605608784,
0.0240228754,
-0.0355465636,
-0.029822655,
-0.0459932722,
-0.0099738399,
0.0488236919,
0.0092371851,
0.0022361812,
-0.0081615085,
-0.0607221946,
-0.0559245162,
0.0239385925,
0.0236903578,
-0.0141084865,
-0.0594403408,
0.0699380189,
0.01576625,
0.0193514712,
-0.0506798439,
-0.0373661295,
-0.0038337777,
0.0224879049,
-0.0221047606,
0.0180476755,
0.0150020309,
0.0522301309,
-0.0669497401,
-0.0088872919,
0.1191092581,
-0.0045468467,
-0.0244465861,
-0.0038715561,
-0.0213737339,
0.0229570065,
0.0434014425,
0.068505764,
-0.0765493959,
-0.0262310319,
0.020039076,
0.0135013731,
0.0128010381,
-0.0469511412,
0.0033164902,
-0.0912004262,
0.0304302368,
0.0042731157,
-0.0114008561,
-0.0643033385,
-0.0398083702,
0.0271705259,
-0.0041312184,
-0.0193715822,
0.0241743568,
0.017229192,
-0.0193205979,
-0.0221975055,
0.0219145566,
-0.0390772447,
0.0307347476,
-0.0178340636,
0.0627412051,
0.0524390638,
0.0038353095,
0.0033960391,
-0.0611092709,
-0.0053417175,
-0.0200250223,
0.000471927,
-0.0122250663,
-0.0059449538,
0.0197421703,
-0.0133799082,
-0.0256844983,
0.0275088828,
-0.0464646257,
-0.0294476226,
0.0147417914,
0.1137043908,
-0.0447422378,
-0.0383262634,
-0.0277955718,
-0.0266158432,
-0.005541028,
0.0606766045,
-0.0159817953,
-0.0429948308,
-0.0397917964,
-0.016103521,
-0.0534791164,
-0.0190275535,
-0.0174970552,
-0.0032463714,
-0.0342441313,
0.0042466503,
-0.0456630848,
-0.0082778847,
0.0698209479,
0.0151398415,
0.04041823,
-0.0199001469,
0.0598922484,
0.0153288655,
-0.0120074758,
0.0020484149,
-0.0400757566,
0.0330781825,
-0.0209587757,
-0.0372723378,
-0.0013104562,
-0.0399259068,
0.0057147839,
-0.0065833693,
-0.0480328165,
-0.0651854649,
0.0023589886,
0.0452119671,
0.0274976268,
0.0563838072,
-0.0253548566,
-0.0359635688,
0.033281371,
-0.0249158014,
-0.063792944,
-0.022732012,
0.0190262031,
0.0167354885,
0.0036053592,
0.0413125679,
-0.0584111847,
0.0020234277,
-0.0076069655,
0.0302011985,
-0.0295248181,
-0.0176977478,
0.0142068285,
-0.0046488564,
-0.0143757667,
-0.0137037458,
-0.0310814548,
-0.0372918472,
0.0252837241,
-0.015227858,
-0.0029521256,
-0.05405844,
0.0087704798,
-0.0114261648,
-0.0323366039,
0.0607763305,
-0.0050277328,
-0.0039459183,
0.0119527085,
0.0483708568,
0.0018541997,
-0.0356878489,
0.0544989593,
0.023369981,
0.0263465568,
0.000170406,
0.04226771,
-0.0011937491,
0.0487171672,
-0.0269520208,
0.0619118959,
0.0358950123,
-0.0023958667,
-0.0403014459,
0.0089995526,
-0.0631908178,
-0.0688282028,
0.0277677309,
0.0469179116,
0.0510132611,
0.0447238944,
0.0397232659,
-0.0771518573,
0.0222087521,
0.0326490365,
0.0747734532,
-0.0143055189,
-0.033056125,
0.0026571578,
0.0405213386,
0.0118905548,
-0.015468277,
0.0479043312,
-0.01127523,
0.0402892381,
-0.01811295,
-0.0011711321,
-0.0479831807,
-0.0436667986,
-0.0126200756,
0.0129250111,
-0.0332297795,
0.0291671157,
-0.0503493249,
-0.0327344276,
-0.0728484988,
0.0102901142,
-0.0375834666,
-0.0170153473,
0.0476412103,
0.0082572354,
0.018967418,
-0.0234910604,
-0.0288249198,
0.0047075739,
0.0042593516,
-0.0159773156,
0.0038601605,
-6.364664939e-33,
-0.0566498935,
0.0021670663,
0.0626992658,
0.0107960384,
-0.0362018459,
-0.0623247772,
-0.0798095837,
0.0025084892,
-0.0004445083,
0.0198615678,
-0.0051092091,
0.0073028728,
0.0018628258,
0.006831679,
0.0323018543,
-0.0154835265,
0.0400915332,
-0.0026317493,
-0.0074611842,
0.0228924938,
0.0425085016,
-0.0074818288,
0.045978114,
-0.0593466014,
0.0193590019,
0.0136310346,
-0.0129579669,
0.0459944792,
-0.0355775654,
0.0275778025,
0.0151848365,
0.0149291195,
0.0096564004,
0.0048800511,
-0.0179140344,
-0.0241876338,
-0.0572078191,
-0.0285555013,
0.0344940536,
0.0169525445,
-0.0497839935,
-0.0191940498,
0.0329560004,
-0.0156870112,
0.0187543631,
0.0177452881,
0.0422117114,
-0.0336532444,
-0.0018028213,
0.0221922286,
-0.0449865237,
-0.0021361846,
-0.0116693527,
-0.0247234832,
0.0147223156,
0.0226032659,
0.0061482484,
-0.0527343974,
-0.0254492108,
0.0365722664,
0.0290479343,
-0.005326659,
0.0636764765,
0.0084826965,
0.0263052955,
0.0276431907,
0.0124933915,
0.0300163422,
-0.040754687,
0.0100522563,
0.0248763636,
0.0813100338,
0.0395779423,
0.0094519379,
-0.0171333626,
0.0001820105,
-0.0550907664,
-0.0126871085,
0.0124524767,
0.107417509,
0.0247688778,
0.0372654051,
-0.0149465185,
-0.0324185081,
-0.0516678207,
0.0197134446,
-0.0122589534,
-0.0380620994,
0.0067000282,
0.0217319466,
-0.0088199629,
-0.0765348002,
0.0154937133,
-0.0518809818,
0.0018596639,
0.0041403631,
-0.0220262501,
0.0187159535,
0.0099170702,
-0.0021686633,
-0.0523755699,
-0.0421307981,
0.0147858337,
-0.048703488,
0.0041813166,
0.0355755016,
-0.0321839042,
0.0540770963,
-0.0229790583,
-0.00981721,
-0.0810001418,
0.0287486035,
-0.0010712253,
0.0040341234,
-0.0233133808,
0.0340677686,
-0.0292214733,
0.0295073856,
-0.0394843891,
-0.0184484683,
-0.0134241367,
0.030569816,
0.0216747746,
0.033680886,
-0.0374395885,
-0.039450299,
-0.0734223723,
-0.0218281448,
0.028435491,
-0.0454192683,
-0.0036394293,
0.0090238443,
3.035e-7,
-0.0246350765,
0.0487336516,
-0.0112316431,
0.0351363532,
0.0437222272,
0.0491544455,
-0.0566702187,
0.0011884219,
-0.0266472865,
-0.0278075449,
0.0123531232,
0.0524003804,
0.0358252041,
0.0327132531,
-0.0594543181,
-0.010882725,
0.0287423767,
-0.0241614021,
-0.0502956137,
-0.009708656,
0.0274534561,
0.0455801003,
0.0805343986,
-0.001449151,
0.0306565482,
-0.037138965,
0.0416223407,
-0.0192660708,
0.0009204696,
0.0108897537,
-0.0094963666,
0.0360709578,
0.0052666827,
0.0375365131,
0.0299455896,
0.0163628794,
-0.0896593928,
0.0631480962,
0.0102360798,
-0.0143870236,
-0.0249257982,
-0.0230886526,
0.0079837637,
-0.0209083594,
0.0554025844,
-0.0614103265,
-0.032830935,
0.009604916,
0.0079592364,
-0.0199630763,
-0.0661018938,
0.0048211333,
-0.0119166756,
-0.0116130281,
0.0071565313,
-0.0236941352,
-0.017992869,
-0.049082119,
0.0038794696,
-0.0217215046,
-0.0507439263,
-0.0393019952,
-0.0189412478,
-0.0155134434,
-0.0026279469,
-0.0348763131,
0.0146943284,
2.945018573e-34,
0.0275996141,
0.0132573573,
-0.0219461061,
0.0373680517,
0.0475635156,
-0.0124240154,
-0.0542208292,
0.0139895445,
0.053776525,
-0.0722673908,
-0.0322038829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01453v1 | The Queen of England is not England's Queen: On the Lack of Factual Coherency in PLMs | 2024-02-02T14:42:09 | 2024-02-02T14:42:09 | Paul Youssef, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert | cs.CL | cs.CL | Factual knowledge encoded in Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) enriches
their representations and justifies their use as knowledge bases. Previous work
has focused on probing PLMs for factual knowledge by measuring how often they
can correctly predict an object entity given a subject and a relation, and
improving fact retrieval by optimizing the prompts used for querying PLMs. In
this work, we consider a complementary aspect, namely the coherency of factual
knowledge in PLMs, i.e., how often can PLMs predict the subject entity given
its initial prediction of the object entity. This goes beyond evaluating how
much PLMs know, and focuses on the internal state of knowledge inside them. Our
results indicate that PLMs have low coherency using manually written, optimized
and paraphrased prompts, but including an evidence paragraph leads to
substantial improvement. This shows that PLMs fail to model inverse relations
and need further enhancements to be able to handle retrieving facts from their
parameters in a coherent manner, and to be considered as knowledge bases. | [
0.0620701313,
-0.0028473448,
-0.0126864165,
0.0431064516,
-0.0483566336,
-0.0224329904,
-0.0258694813,
-0.0127832694,
-0.0012849891,
-0.0451853611,
-0.0151609965,
-0.0352880843,
-0.0089440215,
-0.0034039188,
0.0079634739,
-0.0479517803,
0.0875640735,
-0.0190968178,
0.0516629145,
-0.0086413678,
-0.0173485857,
-0.0004494421,
-0.014686049,
0.0126142828,
-0.0501746088,
-0.0175223444,
-0.0222275686,
-0.0039286758,
-0.0120761711,
-0.0136435395,
-0.0164304804,
0.0385299809,
0.0187027976,
-0.018455267,
0.0000020084,
-0.067888692,
0.0166145843,
-0.0364839435,
-0.0589871593,
0.0231477972,
-0.0005788335,
0.0117030684,
0.0255917627,
-0.0021911061,
-0.0362644456,
-0.0223556217,
0.0059357798,
0.0662366748,
0.059478227,
0.092440106,
0.0036426238,
0.0033013574,
-0.0009524215,
-0.0290601943,
-0.0091058491,
-0.0437103361,
0.0192799866,
0.0074817017,
-0.0150989396,
0.058244694,
-0.0022135391,
0.0621850975,
0.0019594701,
-0.0072661093,
-0.0075840922,
0.0463787615,
-0.0168475378,
-0.0438438766,
0.0031522468,
0.0444670431,
0.0164867137,
-0.0043503786,
0.0022023094,
-0.005790065,
0.0187491346,
0.0341936126,
-0.0037342641,
0.0371524654,
-0.0143449688,
0.0266358517,
0.013738241,
0.0011073755,
0.031485796,
0.0272408891,
-0.0360521562,
0.0616361015,
-0.0032783234,
-0.0333233252,
0.0063212644,
0.0192453153,
-0.014157474,
-0.0461572632,
0.009619859,
0.0244125389,
-0.0132095339,
0.0321187526,
-0.0437359735,
0.0125198364,
0.0182807259,
-0.0817516819,
0.012078397,
0.0295082424,
-0.0820619166,
0.0683569312,
-0.0228193756,
0.0456488132,
0.0123033393,
0.0467972606,
-0.0147667546,
-0.0206148699,
-0.0405812971,
-0.0121739488,
-0.0375886038,
0.0433323644,
0.0014682331,
-0.0118184462,
0.0151238292,
-0.0070003644,
0.0122644808,
0.0264161602,
-0.0224041659,
0.0202989541,
-0.0064763473,
-0.0190145802,
-0.0883413255,
0.0407663286,
-0.0119562456,
0.0043825791,
-0.0269219447,
-0.0702391937,
-0.030559931,
-0.0087692216,
-0.0075818431,
-0.0091103762,
0.0112922397,
0.0082425531,
-0.0058786795,
-0.0566419512,
-0.0740859807,
-0.0414265171,
-0.008503153,
-0.094296284,
-0.0133479908,
-0.0211892724,
0.0253418721,
-0.0041831238,
-0.0086619332,
-0.0433914736,
0.0253382251,
0.0428083725,
-0.0562113971,
0.0359183736,
-0.0277863164,
0.0363913253,
0.0224721693,
0.0300124977,
0.0114130033,
0.0682952404,
0.0062395502,
0.0144556314,
0.0440508537,
0.0114362249,
-0.0037903364,
-0.0023209488,
0.047489237,
-0.0505823344,
0.0156565011,
0.0279027205,
-0.0246074386,
0.0419368334,
0.0597625077,
0.0366954282,
0.0158713739,
-0.0279761832,
0.0843573734,
-0.0031012925,
0.007002336,
0.0113107106,
0.0781200454,
-0.0040638945,
0.0526371263,
0.0599099286,
-0.0874039978,
-0.0132717639,
-0.0207727868,
0.0432513915,
-0.0192589667,
0.0484644882,
-0.0371618494,
-0.0474234261,
-0.0076041259,
-0.0081188241,
-0.0590459406,
0.0298360661,
0.052113343,
0.0077156727,
-0.0470113754,
0.0685905665,
0.0250070989,
-0.051125899,
0.0213500336,
-0.0118193487,
0.0393491276,
0.0722063556,
0.0198750421,
-0.0409643054,
-0.0369949825,
0.0213807169,
0.0337417275,
0.0296831205,
0.0544349886,
0.0025072817,
0.0550183654,
0.004430885,
0.0108549418,
-0.0093950303,
0.0308476239,
-0.0026531911,
0.0059180264,
-0.0010014842,
0.0343686193,
-0.0052282647,
0.0129459687,
0.0521483235,
-0.0304188989,
0.0063968292,
-0.0125560835,
0.0024916355,
-0.0001830573,
0.0448294468,
-0.0103935683,
0.0276599471,
0.0704752728,
-0.0055602449,
0.0009365857,
0.0156420581,
-0.0570225567,
-0.0523734167,
0.0216736812,
-0.0201414842,
-0.0266273171,
-0.0135912811,
0.001143757,
-0.0291849133,
0.0107961642,
-0.0062444415,
0.0750820264,
-0.04609235,
0.0283917729,
-0.0031826913,
-0.0394643061,
-0.0226664152,
0.078378953,
0.0012365261,
-0.0002744771,
0.0415286981,
-0.0033736723,
-0.0026944168,
-0.035931699,
-0.0300700981,
-0.0001521071,
0.0334248915,
-0.0149896331,
0.01778448,
-0.0391814262,
-0.0396972448,
-0.0058000498,
-0.0953892916,
-0.0032611077,
-0.0177478399,
-0.0236646757,
0.0072953072,
-0.0260196906,
-0.0299460869,
-0.0355453864,
-0.0037492306,
-0.0126990704,
-0.0072483323,
0.0151082659,
0.0349927694,
0.0176435336,
0.0106656952,
-0.0356087089,
0.017291341,
-0.0096242586,
0.0256957598,
-0.0026307297,
0.0123056909,
-0.0465145372,
0.0816093236,
-0.0453474782,
-0.0068084262,
-0.0306171011,
-0.0046850895,
-0.0019866005,
-0.009988673,
0.0546905808,
0.0448880382,
0.0432947874,
0.0144116096,
0.0597784109,
-0.0371847823,
-0.0326578878,
0.0299439244,
-0.052508533,
0.0053754733,
-0.0017815065,
-0.000209611,
0.0196626782,
0.0165401716,
0.0256534554,
-0.0187286995,
-0.0522451289,
0.0209371466,
-0.0004120185,
-0.0263102967,
-0.0633130297,
-0.0289738122,
0.0119625907,
0.0548439138,
-0.0213888381,
-0.0511842556,
0.0709903017,
-0.0638492033,
0.0180870462,
0.0018549578,
-0.0138722546,
-0.0040142899,
0.0512728989,
0.0071595432,
0.0258633588,
-0.0026510975,
-0.0135686109,
-0.0374649763,
-0.0062535303,
0.0189358387,
-0.0325288549,
0.0477897935,
-0.0507085472,
0.0108520156,
0.0424562544,
-0.0382079519,
-0.0722730607,
-0.0943006799,
-0.030194629,
-0.0066436566,
-0.0283174478,
0.012888195,
-0.0182340126,
0.0039403173,
0.0358150005,
0.0209772475,
-0.0031258042,
-0.0157999303,
-0.0031622348,
-0.0333830304,
0.0385070704,
0.0490815081,
0.0096567282,
-0.0171183236,
-0.0038990499,
0.0065116575,
-0.0294702575,
-0.0276219118,
0.019937126,
-0.0013036669,
0.0029481223,
-0.0428817458,
-0.0617118664,
0.016939234,
0.0010034951,
-0.0652290508,
-0.0328359939,
0.1483971179,
0.0240068752,
0.0114220865,
-0.0283281468,
-0.0003730323,
-0.0005685253,
0.0210982747,
0.0111461384,
-0.0638672188,
-0.0128474254,
0.0073522739,
-0.0331032649,
-0.0101575106,
-0.0337364785,
-0.0622118227,
-0.1339486539,
0.0162516851,
-0.0359249562,
0.0065210401,
-0.0627393425,
-0.0247639902,
-0.0133072715,
-0.0039679967,
0.0099669788,
0.0364462994,
-0.0280802771,
0.0179837607,
-0.0023987324,
-0.0376808792,
-0.0516056269,
-0.0084461039,
-0.0594125874,
0.0495156758,
0.0658476874,
0.0156073477,
-0.0000460588,
-0.0403805189,
-0.0270674881,
-0.0005693163,
0.0198480897,
-0.003157221,
0.0646825433,
-0.0294810571,
-0.0064732609,
-0.0236097071,
-0.0111374306,
0.0383797176,
-0.0238814279,
0.0224066004,
0.0326143131,
-0.0476205237,
-0.0241720602,
0.0063682292,
0.0472811311,
0.0116828512,
0.1421080232,
0.0383590199,
0.0242031924,
-0.0045253378,
0.0015542427,
0.0560786575,
0.0181297828,
-0.0429210365,
0.0178203378,
-0.0101840431,
0.0232743043,
-0.0678554624,
-0.0393010564,
0.0332473814,
0.0597328022,
0.0226568487,
0.0068546785,
0.0666296706,
-0.0225750189,
-0.0161788445,
0.0173341036,
-0.0351694375,
-0.0347304866,
-0.0805954859,
-0.0093891257,
0.0343825519,
-0.0477119721,
-0.0064507984,
-0.0248019565,
-0.0193568934,
-0.0580618829,
0.0652275831,
0.0604589544,
0.0283175427,
0.0258412901,
-0.0199865028,
-0.0237844605,
0.035276752,
-0.0080331266,
-0.068341732,
0.046947252,
-0.0018998034,
-0.0201371368,
-0.015274263,
0.0467905663,
-0.0122754518,
0.016999023,
-0.0188862272,
0.0246550869,
0.0069065974,
-0.0725751668,
0.0331010856,
0.0183186773,
0.0929179713,
-0.0013797146,
0.0118426867,
-0.0550975837,
0.0063774111,
-0.0522738732,
-0.0204202086,
-0.0174959097,
0.0117433928,
-0.0123194,
-0.0031959994,
-0.0315442607,
-0.0246317536,
-0.0598004907,
0.0438491739,
0.0055747288,
-0.0473273993,
0.0137947537,
-0.0008186274,
0.0091980537,
-0.0195186436,
0.0062529542,
0.0463118441,
-0.017914217,
0.0371812917,
0.0021843654,
0.0475259088,
0.0183292553,
-0.0105113266,
-0.0215195417,
-0.0009706764,
-0.0852388069,
-0.0234026425,
0.0194237512,
0.0447678752,
0.0620597713,
-0.0794691518,
0.0424846448,
-0.0326778069,
0.0086198235,
-0.0015702066,
0.0252118148,
0.0580187626,
-0.0318538658,
0.0408323035,
0.0064847823,
-0.0336736105,
0.0271723196,
0.0960215181,
-0.0137325395,
0.0675609484,
0.0097350627,
-0.041981969,
-0.0221376438,
-0.0321367756,
0.0018659605,
0.0016561527,
-0.0529052354,
0.0166355986,
-0.0932395011,
-0.0411943309,
0.0333451927,
0.002490409,
-0.0155510893,
-0.027142182,
0.0247604493,
0.0899254754,
0.0284732711,
-0.0273297969,
-0.034026444,
0.0305181928,
0.0081581986,
0.0063123247,
-0.0275040362,
-6.876363507e-33,
-0.0884204507,
-0.0124554243,
0.0334408358,
-0.000078508,
-0.0188044123,
0.0298189167,
-0.0374504849,
0.0256220028,
-0.046891585,
0.0359968096,
-0.0179496966,
0.0335940681,
0.0167169981,
0.0019125359,
-0.0161117651,
-0.0417222455,
0.0429259241,
0.0233578496,
-0.0188485552,
-0.0162664372,
0.0600627325,
0.0507215261,
0.0422160178,
-0.0397756621,
0.0392386392,
-0.0023385624,
-0.0029513219,
0.0519870147,
-0.0140675409,
0.0089545595,
0.0020966225,
0.0480242148,
0.0133939805,
-0.0372692496,
-0.0216814019,
0.0331976041,
-0.0897993073,
-0.0708734915,
0.0948225632,
-0.0199159067,
0.014651265,
-0.0103826262,
0.0225965902,
-0.0104924133,
0.0144680198,
0.0152250277,
0.0371626914,
0.0022041171,
0.0210582148,
-0.0065588709,
-0.0601604804,
0.0181840286,
-0.0039857691,
-0.0068923556,
0.0150748501,
-0.0150042735,
0.0180733781,
-0.0190739576,
-0.0702356398,
0.0194523502,
-0.0006511681,
0.0464376397,
0.0291664246,
-0.0030888899,
0.0041582501,
0.0707893595,
-0.0058200504,
0.0159591045,
-0.0882801563,
0.0462374166,
0.0570556298,
0.0315591618,
0.0255650152,
0.0649522692,
0.0111106252,
-0.0000253525,
-0.0682590231,
0.0008381615,
-0.0110137397,
0.0276215635,
0.004658734,
-0.0328036658,
-0.0270177312,
-0.0417340919,
-0.0453038625,
0.0296113491,
-0.0192604754,
-0.038012486,
0.0114223305,
0.0128662959,
0.0087586222,
-0.0193705335,
0.0160846766,
0.0174416769,
-0.0244608521,
0.002778146,
-0.0226614717,
-0.0311509073,
-0.0052802009,
0.0438279621,
-0.0698838457,
-0.0052202661,
0.0255147498,
0.0146904206,
-0.0147551112,
0.026181234,
0.0071015842,
0.0106901592,
-0.0463150591,
-0.0142341517,
-0.0128371706,
0.0145499203,
-0.026209088,
-0.0463145971,
0.0314250104,
0.0423358828,
-0.0322791077,
0.0105017526,
0.0142250098,
-0.0040278411,
-0.0451350212,
-0.019817492,
0.0084611801,
0.0246119797,
0.0094358148,
0.00471177,
-0.0211585574,
-0.0007236036,
0.0202875193,
-0.0463087186,
0.0013354756,
0.0217907373,
2.741e-7,
0.0586167648,
0.0448687449,
0.0316355638,
0.025627736,
-0.0566962026,
0.0238930378,
-0.0422154106,
0.0042545977,
0.0230230298,
-0.0770638958,
-0.0019315322,
0.0516912676,
0.0069097597,
0.0375250541,
-0.1089382991,
-0.0033625404,
-0.0577319488,
-0.0380677395,
-0.0539356321,
-0.0188279394,
0.0392749906,
0.0565259457,
0.0348705724,
-0.0131803313,
-0.0137660457,
-0.0197582636,
0.0439958312,
-0.0442707315,
-0.0459523499,
0.0076911016,
0.083418116,
0.0099661807,
0.0067712991,
0.0433265194,
0.0034658383,
0.0286527779,
-0.0080546336,
0.0457789116,
0.0380845889,
0.008954566,
-0.0258865897,
0.0007517795,
-0.0110063935,
-0.0227615405,
0.0804390833,
-0.0211221594,
-0.0156983044,
-0.0116865262,
-0.0045988257,
0.0050225216,
0.0387956761,
0.0086891856,
-0.0379593745,
0.0209395438,
0.0181820542,
-0.0042928639,
0.0077026309,
-0.0693596303,
-0.0548289865,
0.0079798372,
-0.0275088493,
-0.0249589141,
-0.0146248741,
-0.0144973341,
0.0347344317,
-0.0665552691,
0.0311743617,
2.364925197e-34,
0.0262120888,
-0.003337566,
-0.0017572918,
0.019351311,
0.0526522361,
0.0066712722,
0.0050285608,
0.0050302492,
-0.0129959015,
-0.0658827871,
0.0157296434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01427v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01427v2 | The effect of diversity on group decision-making | 2024-02-02T14:15:01 | 2024-05-20T15:46:42 | Georgi Karadzhov, Andreas Vlachos, Tom Stafford | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore different aspects of cognitive diversity and its effect on the
success of group deliberation. To evaluate this, we use 500 dialogues from
small, online groups discussing the Wason Card Selection task - the DeliData
corpus. Leveraging the corpus, we perform quantitative analysis evaluating
three different measures of cognitive diversity. First, we analyse the effect
of group size as a proxy measure for diversity. Second, we evaluate the effect
of the size of the initial idea pool. Finally, we look into the content of the
discussion by analysing discussed solutions, discussion patterns, and how
conversational probing can improve those characteristics. Despite the
reputation of groups for compounding bias, we show that small groups can,
through dialogue, overcome intuitive biases and improve individual
decision-making. Across a large sample and different operationalisations, we
consistently find that greater cognitive diversity is associated with more
successful group deliberation. Code and data used for the analysis are
available in the repository:
https://github.com/gkaradzhov/cognitive-diversity-groups-cogsci24. | [
0.0339243934,
0.0402754284,
-0.0376387909,
-0.0188319832,
-0.0512840599,
-0.0001997493,
0.0596818216,
-0.0153454496,
0.0025535366,
-0.0111411866,
-0.0293280482,
-0.0280154534,
0.0472488366,
0.002259094,
0.0091813747,
-0.0264288764,
0.0116187399,
-0.01625311,
0.0828635544,
-0.0344617553,
0.0189607423,
-0.0248414632,
-0.0414043367,
0.0554569624,
0.024180714,
-0.0123141678,
-0.0339734592,
-0.0333536305,
0.0534229763,
-0.0056226226,
0.0069260858,
0.0698644891,
-0.0196904987,
0.0090581095,
0.0000022704,
-0.015789954,
-0.0247535706,
-0.0336196311,
0.016181007,
-0.0198083688,
0.0021868872,
0.0937462375,
-0.0061623347,
0.0277823526,
-0.0318320245,
0.0275002234,
0.0163363162,
0.0051261275,
0.0046100141,
-0.0075371824,
0.0074587148,
0.0028824359,
-0.0655368492,
-0.0097438237,
-0.0037315714,
0.0134743061,
-0.0097584464,
-0.0018932581,
0.0016283062,
-0.0000486185,
0.0103115607,
-0.0306271743,
-0.0424703173,
-0.0254554395,
-0.0115849245,
0.0250927117,
-0.0363077633,
-0.0472600758,
0.0250788517,
0.0460876338,
0.0566012971,
0.0475359261,
-0.0112797339,
-0.012889456,
0.0522902571,
0.0242136233,
-0.0313429311,
0.0457565971,
-0.0258137211,
-0.0316830836,
-0.0250833817,
0.0538039915,
-0.0276080482,
0.0104347514,
-0.0041190442,
0.0643423274,
-0.0205566436,
0.0131076137,
-0.0165366922,
0.0066523827,
-0.0210505929,
-0.0497602709,
-0.0180842895,
-0.0080945091,
-0.0563434623,
-0.0091859028,
0.0906673893,
-0.0003465861,
0.0420556776,
-0.0237817168,
0.0316784978,
0.0155526344,
0.0444129035,
0.0267744921,
0.0845451802,
-0.0389410928,
-0.0036473668,
0.0157273356,
0.0039895265,
-0.0044445791,
-0.0603192858,
0.0080112917,
-0.0009156102,
0.0494423136,
-0.0184071735,
-0.0007945021,
-0.0056202831,
-0.0066829864,
-0.0540341251,
-0.0130671309,
-0.0375076979,
0.030429408,
0.0289689321,
0.0004335519,
-0.0601986758,
0.0358306877,
-0.0452421978,
0.0113669736,
0.0037468334,
-0.0470789932,
0.0211257357,
0.0036633078,
-0.0061421795,
-0.0284028333,
0.0026066902,
0.0018984089,
-0.0339625143,
-0.001409746,
0.0189408325,
0.0000397754,
-0.0051599187,
-0.0446213745,
0.0025186108,
-0.0549640246,
0.0067130271,
0.0190711878,
0.0179845877,
0.0020692844,
-0.0045672767,
-0.0195552092,
0.0044616158,
0.0376020744,
-0.0014781826,
0.0222301632,
0.1075904965,
0.0346313305,
-0.0398540236,
0.058936689,
0.0222678129,
-0.0130917346,
0.0016972118,
0.000473473,
0.0103911795,
-0.0027651431,
-0.0395152755,
-0.00867067,
0.0426367261,
0.0224647429,
-0.0581166856,
-0.0196177736,
-0.0284545813,
0.0667736679,
-0.052923318,
0.0391260758,
0.0433717445,
0.0875551924,
0.0315450281,
0.0335864052,
-0.0803233609,
0.036827337,
-0.0160375722,
-0.0412371308,
0.0317960531,
0.0561570674,
0.0417008474,
-0.0199840255,
0.0975240991,
0.0260057226,
-0.0192217007,
-0.0194924958,
-0.0149957258,
0.0323603302,
0.0561769903,
0.0113952104,
-0.0339177437,
-0.0381383896,
0.0237772968,
0.0445216224,
0.000058666,
-0.0174376089,
-0.0839928091,
-0.0278511941,
0.0733138621,
-0.0061186128,
0.0271137841,
-0.008317505,
-0.0340414047,
-0.0481965803,
-0.0219046157,
0.0256994031,
0.1027221158,
-0.0075773355,
-0.0349066891,
-0.0529783666,
-0.0379053243,
0.0348602198,
-0.0027042201,
0.075870581,
0.0312878899,
0.0131972423,
-0.0453765541,
0.0630955622,
0.0106675737,
0.0023594769,
0.0379481539,
0.0546813756,
-0.0337596461,
0.0130729424,
0.0706479251,
0.0180889592,
-0.0353099778,
0.0132587533,
-0.0243704673,
0.0050584106,
-0.0394000039,
0.0341984443,
-0.0473234244,
0.034745086,
0.0156600941,
-0.0849759281,
-0.0112811327,
-0.0222400315,
0.0333893336,
0.0038983163,
0.099789165,
-0.0055760592,
-0.0835071802,
0.0308742225,
-0.0206424408,
-0.0607406311,
-0.0239629652,
-0.0238077585,
0.0586953089,
0.0030033374,
-0.0098418882,
0.0061812918,
-0.0536987446,
0.0488080569,
-0.060635604,
0.012573896,
0.0361736231,
0.0407847762,
0.0012264521,
0.0338868238,
-0.0244162902,
-0.0217935462,
-0.0116835553,
-0.0894799978,
-0.0166512188,
-0.0012388277,
0.0084244721,
-0.0104709463,
-0.0206617378,
0.0047659548,
0.022770226,
-0.0194337796,
0.008746936,
0.0104175303,
0.0451949164,
0.0185188111,
0.0182516482,
0.0186563805,
-0.0026819268,
-0.0037591157,
0.0148672843,
0.0302228387,
0.0584811941,
-0.0753084794,
0.0005687228,
-0.0319606923,
-0.0659637153,
-0.0240631718,
-0.0103848856,
-0.0207995176,
0.0770740211,
0.019740928,
0.0092139738,
-0.0094014276,
0.0498905219,
0.002632881,
0.023925893,
-0.0019205897,
-0.050339371,
0.004138126,
0.0133278565,
0.0730173737,
0.0196242575,
-0.0448817648,
0.0173642393,
0.0500446223,
0.0088604456,
0.0155038638,
-0.0321347825,
0.0478004403,
-0.0354581475,
-0.0333770886,
-0.0527366102,
-0.0931667611,
-0.0040949527,
0.0399099514,
-0.0235583242,
0.0072161979,
0.0239556041,
0.067360796,
0.0103445603,
-0.0612650327,
0.0100162802,
-0.0821235403,
0.0394325592,
-0.0589927658,
-0.0102362353,
0.0338482521,
-0.0175229274,
-0.0620591231,
-0.0456525087,
0.0585756227,
-0.042839963,
0.0838924125,
-0.0178954266,
-0.013188215,
-0.0504809543,
-0.0258783028,
-0.0178714972,
0.0162711106,
-0.020631006,
-0.0033266505,
0.1342478096,
-0.009448288,
-0.0650281608,
0.0053402819,
0.0533275306,
-0.0066210576,
0.034518227,
-0.0120123699,
0.0525918528,
-0.0330050662,
-0.0464655049,
0.0548564419,
0.0961645171,
-0.0599534437,
0.0413877964,
0.0551777631,
0.0051523745,
-0.0607022233,
-0.0161959678,
-0.0567113906,
0.0006745519,
0.0021881314,
-0.0132061718,
-0.0251124296,
0.0545748696,
0.0184272006,
0.0242054667,
0.0338581726,
0.0209780037,
-0.0630850121,
-0.0234522037,
-0.0640809685,
0.037491139,
0.021296367,
-0.0135099422,
-0.0603538752,
0.0146642141,
-0.0084343301,
-0.0091005936,
-0.0545618311,
-0.0633884743,
-0.043601837,
-0.0691044033,
0.0317305066,
0.0049254433,
-0.010478613,
0.0135114715,
0.0368803889,
0.0300281867,
-0.0209008828,
0.0030946257,
0.0094529884,
0.0325271823,
0.0320794433,
0.0315675922,
-0.1095129475,
0.0142956069,
-0.0018429892,
-0.0174066406,
-0.0008484935,
0.029087279,
0.0461207926,
-0.0134416837,
-0.0416421182,
0.0612390079,
-0.0081318058,
-0.0065488764,
0.0121671436,
0.0383706465,
0.0070399167,
0.026606366,
-0.002931793,
-0.0058709318,
0.0155463116,
-0.0298659094,
0.0248819385,
-0.0071147527,
-0.0093387999,
-0.0161143821,
0.0097723631,
-0.0006323317,
0.033929877,
0.0298617911,
0.0204486344,
-0.0199948736,
0.0024874764,
-0.0274507087,
0.0030548971,
-0.0331087969,
-0.0283805281,
-0.0150729213,
0.081498377,
0.0413262025,
-0.0181801319,
-0.0184451323,
0.0162074547,
-0.0050280886,
-0.0271244328,
0.0030527578,
-0.0246420968,
0.0530197546,
0.0206250716,
0.0147270104,
0.0378156193,
-0.0127723431,
-0.0369734615,
-0.0604634024,
-0.0809766129,
0.014633378,
-0.0086349333,
0.0091217505,
-0.0427576676,
-0.0296261907,
0.0244369153,
0.0033835548,
0.0319896154,
-0.0401763879,
0.0168140456,
-0.0376433432,
0.0275900327,
0.0296815522,
0.0266155042,
-0.0127639789,
0.0011189538,
0.0604557879,
0.0026843934,
-0.0102071306,
0.0438017361,
0.0233149044,
0.0246259607,
-0.0138862329,
-0.0295449141,
-0.0246418864,
0.0013921391,
-0.024241142,
-0.0253452528,
-0.0264974684,
0.0015723811,
-0.0294498913,
-0.0286570005,
0.0165203251,
-0.0126721067,
-0.0014853629,
-0.0779565573,
-0.0027642357,
-0.0676117614,
0.0141674215,
0.036808446,
0.0123007037,
0.0344187431,
-0.0371221229,
0.0863561183,
0.0374642648,
-0.0253440756,
0.0035694914,
-0.0038315887,
0.0064692227,
0.0216183551,
-0.04444585,
0.036360871,
0.0214716326,
0.0589799732,
-0.0146092456,
-0.0471241437,
0.030198833,
0.0205997005,
-0.0500809848,
-0.1039339602,
0.0470900498,
0.0297170207,
-0.0324872918,
0.0372744873,
-0.0303861797,
-0.0196848828,
-0.0030331328,
-0.0123846577,
-0.0087751364,
-0.0395980105,
0.0165794306,
0.0014560423,
0.0339796282,
-0.0208317153,
-0.0230225418,
0.0515980683,
-0.0710378811,
-0.0450092293,
-0.050691355,
-0.0048225503,
-0.0590456314,
-0.0091428757,
-0.011291353,
0.0314385928,
-0.0182363912,
0.0083715674,
-0.0975209475,
0.033523947,
0.0125417728,
0.0072905202,
0.0637623519,
-0.0010808065,
0.0015948723,
0.0234742165,
-0.0024333547,
0.0134428507,
-0.0110818269,
0.0264803395,
-0.0422079451,
0.0210104324,
-0.0454897396,
-6.1985382e-33,
-0.0029346277,
-0.0635635853,
-0.0004927047,
-0.0644642487,
0.0190629531,
-0.0541661121,
-0.0061818417,
0.0574360713,
-0.0077157537,
0.0177224614,
-0.0052222335,
0.0152628878,
0.0047078254,
-0.0194050893,
0.0400258265,
0.0039824583,
0.0311395153,
-0.015484537,
-0.0400020368,
-0.0160594173,
0.0313106291,
-0.0196670182,
-0.0223819185,
-0.0002482244,
0.0022846838,
0.0331216268,
0.0200208016,
-0.0455030315,
0.0192660112,
0.0414873213,
-0.0005435943,
-0.01953681,
0.0256069116,
-0.0784073249,
-0.0363135189,
0.0562710054,
-0.0084154643,
-0.0279968344,
-0.0042027337,
-0.0281939525,
0.0155109828,
-0.0074735051,
-0.034970779,
0.0238220599,
-0.0315331966,
-0.0443421267,
-0.0027694502,
0.0017640898,
-0.0015813916,
0.016314324,
-0.0337054059,
0.0324185677,
-0.0400465615,
0.0340592377,
-0.0190240778,
0.0300881732,
-0.0092640528,
-0.0162966084,
-0.0630964041,
0.0634679049,
-0.0068310499,
-0.0332342982,
0.002826225,
0.0059002656,
-0.0083961934,
0.0405957364,
0.0159537196,
0.0721376091,
-0.0511468314,
-0.0407801978,
-0.0484738164,
0.0578168742,
0.0645889342,
0.0604002699,
0.0214504935,
-0.0122713139,
-0.0116715962,
0.0053465492,
-0.0015327459,
-0.0011951731,
0.0557493567,
0.0289096124,
-0.051531855,
-0.0110882185,
0.01694097,
-0.029512452,
-0.0082319081,
0.0002841676,
-0.0095442235,
0.01700994,
-0.0543718897,
-0.0145838633,
0.0560288616,
-0.0254716016,
-0.0102766296,
0.0176353566,
-0.0103113912,
0.0025134541,
0.0051804567,
-0.0575958677,
-0.0929866955,
0.0034274017,
-0.0158537813,
0.0611980259,
0.0418952443,
0.0046496438,
-0.0037118122,
-0.0086239344,
-0.0420087837,
-0.0132000213,
-0.0011116137,
0.0537387542,
0.0126624834,
-0.0083424589,
0.0110119712,
0.0047217566,
0.009793872,
-0.0484998822,
0.0086613512,
-0.0218272097,
0.0078525105,
0.0000687025,
-0.0689766631,
-0.0189595986,
-0.013350443,
-0.023668943,
0.007058966,
-0.0034579546,
0.0427789278,
0.0440281443,
-0.0151483715,
-0.0536437258,
2.847e-7,
0.0122959502,
0.0280951187,
-0.0080322027,
-0.0203488003,
0.0494892783,
0.0310686324,
0.0065499456,
0.0079297237,
0.0135581587,
-0.0383160971,
0.022595806,
0.03867466,
0.0225421172,
0.0710868984,
-0.0219773948,
-0.0732287094,
-0.0318180472,
0.0178473052,
-0.0097366171,
0.0285779946,
-0.0035209171,
-0.0033603495,
-0.0037811429,
0.0110133644,
-0.0605860502,
0.0302783623,
0.0255527887,
-0.0341622867,
-0.0126476837,
0.0455618314,
0.0643319115,
-0.0744788721,
-0.0069127465,
0.0545213595,
0.0340602435,
-0.015152147,
-0.0346216597,
-0.0355689637,
0.0268566124,
0.0048168581,
-0.0006269818,
-0.0040992852,
0.0294545852,
-0.0152150877,
0.022031704,
-0.055607222,
-0.0408166833,
-0.0556944087,
-0.0080689536,
-0.0153144468,
0.0761797056,
0.0316180624,
0.0293949135,
-0.0008662953,
-0.0247983821,
-0.0147534367,
0.0345303677,
-0.0474829525,
-0.0291184895,
-0.0381956771,
-0.055045113,
-0.0874290019,
-0.0002661739,
-0.0234975647,
-0.0068393419,
0.0281662904,
0.0036748706,
1.908186179e-34,
0.0040322486,
0.0097018415,
-0.0300849155,
0.0400009081,
0.0424710102,
-0.0265380125,
-0.0011171496,
-0.0464701094,
0.060505759,
0.0167581327,
-0.0034843497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01423v1 | Different Tastes of Entities: Investigating Human Label Variation in Named Entity Annotations | 2024-02-02T14:08:34 | 2024-02-02T14:08:34 | Siyao Peng, Zihang Sun, Sebastian Loftus, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a key information extraction task with a
long-standing tradition. While recent studies address and aim to correct
annotation errors via re-labeling efforts, little is known about the sources of
human label variation, such as text ambiguity, annotation error, or guideline
divergence. This is especially the case for high-quality datasets and beyond
English CoNLL03. This paper studies disagreements in expert-annotated named
entity datasets for three languages: English, Danish, and Bavarian. We show
that text ambiguity and artificial guideline changes are dominant factors for
diverse annotations among high-quality revisions. We survey student annotations
on a subset of difficult entities and substantiate the feasibility and
necessity of manifold annotations for understanding named entity ambiguities
from a distributional perspective. | [
0.0801259801,
0.0155770266,
-0.0206776224,
0.026355695,
0.0109564522,
0.0468082502,
0.0093537038,
-0.0381201841,
0.0046391832,
-0.0312054362,
-0.009850543,
-0.0179852173,
0.0365535133,
-0.0760436431,
0.0342538804,
-0.0620547161,
0.0344944037,
-0.0059863082,
0.0507192798,
-0.0021480944,
0.0008090118,
-0.0164603833,
-0.0024448764,
0.0206303671,
-0.0101249469,
0.0147701325,
0.0027445257,
-0.0022418234,
0.0313152447,
-0.0281520449,
0.020000888,
0.0837107524,
-0.0357668325,
0.0945529714,
0.0000015977,
-0.0463263616,
-0.0198995844,
0.0059666657,
-0.028333975,
0.0092274938,
0.0056414618,
-0.0063753519,
-0.0243789013,
-0.0624706522,
-0.0034474486,
-0.0430517718,
0.0583762713,
0.0406500809,
0.0245959256,
0.0519094616,
0.0033451421,
-0.0392531157,
-0.0200059656,
-0.01671087,
-0.0008774716,
-0.017550664,
0.0248884931,
0.0076670884,
-0.0259910785,
0.0341180936,
-0.009445996,
0.0439848974,
-0.0219276026,
0.0222448632,
0.0247577801,
0.0418776795,
-0.0193258226,
-0.0230681337,
0.0263739601,
0.0549484715,
0.0318913125,
0.020894954,
0.0312450621,
-0.0192746799,
0.0115086772,
0.0345571972,
0.0144392652,
0.0252636187,
-0.0698748156,
-0.0053630657,
0.0271799676,
-0.031898275,
0.0129688485,
0.0073891361,
-0.0062411185,
0.0633856878,
-0.0051269075,
-0.0472227447,
0.0511306748,
0.0465668589,
-0.0513406843,
-0.0555044077,
0.0231617428,
-0.0274138786,
0.0080349166,
0.0125316307,
-0.0359639041,
-0.0689311624,
0.0164491385,
-0.0503716543,
-0.0158411264,
-0.0069284621,
-0.0352209173,
0.0305247772,
0.0228386968,
0.0120594483,
-0.0016528773,
0.0396211147,
-0.0074291197,
-0.0115865013,
-0.0407996066,
-0.004082378,
-0.0171629116,
0.007292266,
-0.0074650124,
0.0355086885,
-0.0548355244,
-0.0188425146,
-0.0209988076,
0.0316430405,
-0.014009445,
-0.0311512686,
-0.0360695273,
0.0191008803,
-0.0642162412,
-0.0032230394,
-0.034655571,
0.0162931196,
-0.0351223163,
-0.0048513575,
0.0223874748,
-0.0059907157,
-0.0095782671,
-0.0404300094,
0.0015797297,
0.0282114539,
0.0072098146,
-0.0106890714,
-0.0237080175,
-0.0377086177,
-0.0249703173,
-0.0209256895,
0.0157415178,
-0.0515298285,
0.0313551798,
0.0168943275,
-0.0098092621,
-0.098926127,
0.0023782833,
-0.0205749329,
-0.0858578905,
0.0683988333,
-0.0556332767,
0.0009353106,
0.0547195412,
0.002747437,
-0.0152114378,
0.0204277691,
0.009995535,
-0.0288811084,
0.064830102,
0.0125606563,
-0.0011775767,
0.0179336313,
-0.0021023559,
-0.0155483037,
0.0338653438,
-0.012585856,
-0.0124964723,
0.0531732775,
0.0588626526,
0.0464459211,
-0.0268629827,
-0.0519173928,
0.0172952525,
0.0493476987,
-0.0016596678,
-0.0332961231,
-0.0068061301,
-0.0019974634,
0.0414449833,
0.0354277641,
-0.0276072361,
-0.0017356583,
0.0189284123,
0.015618694,
-0.0013108061,
-0.0077195512,
0.0042564077,
-0.0232540295,
-0.0136216944,
0.0249376912,
-0.0107437847,
-0.0191263296,
0.0237322021,
-0.0061587808,
-0.0034035139,
0.0576612055,
0.0245020781,
-0.0356028639,
0.028405562,
0.045185823,
0.0123531101,
0.0543357842,
-0.0074503906,
-0.0146698579,
-0.0251787063,
-0.0102557233,
-0.0046584564,
0.0402184948,
0.0403758585,
-0.0529931858,
0.0174040943,
-0.0136787025,
-0.0156483278,
0.0061215633,
0.0266934521,
0.0118871424,
0.0026734285,
0.0059179184,
0.0023170097,
-0.0761687011,
-0.0676585212,
0.0501575656,
-0.0185030475,
-0.0126371337,
-0.0275374241,
0.0379859619,
-0.0021229261,
0.043479193,
-0.0266455021,
-0.0002928134,
-0.0163129549,
-0.0105006387,
0.0147920977,
-0.0099679232,
0.0449429117,
-0.0060024862,
0.0260591917,
-0.0572098121,
-0.0560808368,
-0.050948862,
-0.0282206349,
-0.0363910422,
-0.0620115921,
-0.0120408824,
0.0098551763,
0.010597284,
0.0095738498,
0.0022376522,
-0.0179330222,
-0.0747389048,
0.0417199396,
-0.0080200974,
0.0462949872,
-0.0011287503,
-0.0125056347,
0.0041682823,
-0.0194972977,
-0.0557984449,
0.0459484458,
0.0408939384,
-0.018833654,
0.0155651858,
-0.0367807485,
-0.0549390279,
-0.0261432324,
-0.0552243553,
-0.0179119557,
-0.0218926463,
0.0551880598,
0.0058626398,
-0.0120642092,
-0.0166195147,
-0.0165978707,
0.0274838824,
-0.0572036654,
-0.0654852912,
0.0423877575,
0.0447939895,
0.0206385814,
0.0054099844,
-0.0181417149,
-0.0073361406,
-0.0334928818,
0.0102530839,
0.0415587202,
-0.0800327212,
-0.081545271,
0.0365948081,
-0.066230841,
-0.0083449045,
0.0151085714,
0.0266855713,
0.0158393811,
0.0580863357,
0.0816704556,
0.0427646004,
-0.0374976173,
0.039223697,
0.024998242,
-0.0342734717,
-0.0401930101,
-0.0016854513,
-0.0132642183,
-0.0073451698,
-0.0260107275,
-0.0717916042,
0.0289042946,
0.0444315225,
-0.0242885333,
0.003286157,
-0.0345410258,
0.0394795202,
-0.0795071423,
-0.00886699,
-0.0196311902,
0.0184414536,
-0.002744674,
0.077599138,
-0.0013683422,
0.0004195692,
0.0845244825,
-0.0034285369,
0.0110308714,
-0.0335268378,
0.0223631132,
-0.0112183047,
0.018294733,
-0.0112749608,
-0.0006308351,
0.0452299602,
-0.0708856061,
-0.0329671279,
0.0637290478,
0.0619994737,
-0.0146426987,
0.0453703888,
-0.0321219042,
0.0049862983,
-0.0184263103,
-0.0080728065,
-0.0062867543,
-0.0219658762,
-0.0505695678,
-0.0024505481,
0.0291506127,
-0.0197075326,
0.0009961778,
0.0164701883,
0.0036379441,
0.0153421946,
0.0037989775,
-0.0084946314,
-0.0202588048,
-0.0172745008,
0.0204412956,
0.0562001914,
0.0343551487,
-0.0303293131,
-0.0387190133,
0.0276304409,
-0.0149895987,
-0.0024813346,
0.0393860824,
-0.026078755,
0.030568514,
-0.0735909343,
-0.0660207793,
-0.0029666347,
0.0480721034,
-0.0489428975,
0.0078829844,
0.0713731647,
0.0202079713,
-0.011442082,
-0.0001622505,
-0.0031399922,
0.0127223972,
0.0054613999,
0.0092013804,
-0.0887294263,
0.0066084363,
0.0015220389,
0.034484148,
-0.0343020819,
-0.0735007077,
0.0074195103,
-0.0785369202,
0.0183622688,
0.0084986612,
-0.1089467928,
0.0223301239,
-0.046256721,
0.0162322298,
-0.0361572057,
0.0134563958,
-0.0157786999,
0.015277219,
0.0506708436,
0.0456815362,
0.0025054535,
-0.079267703,
-0.0101792244,
-0.0545480363,
0.0606352426,
0.0029163952,
0.0225298125,
-0.0372444317,
-0.0480606407,
0.0153955529,
-0.0152477371,
-0.013491381,
-0.0240086485,
0.0865448639,
-0.0164991356,
-0.0106265331,
-0.0347313955,
-0.0057517211,
0.0035835227,
-0.0201116055,
-0.0051766415,
0.0337573476,
0.005668228,
0.0123312389,
0.0078370729,
-0.0086730439,
0.0148426434,
0.0614697672,
0.028138604,
-0.0192034747,
-0.0096368128,
-0.0081810765,
0.0662091151,
0.0098356912,
-0.0079399627,
0.056431327,
-0.0777269006,
-0.086152412,
-0.036729496,
-0.0842195749,
0.0285609718,
0.0280652475,
0.0565942675,
0.0068317563,
0.0516527705,
-0.00568722,
-0.046501372,
0.0689354613,
0.0083192987,
0.0174318217,
-0.0403490923,
-0.0543298163,
-0.0046212086,
0.0407955945,
-0.0364878625,
-0.0082717007,
-0.0403963923,
-0.0700756386,
0.05875092,
-0.0018467017,
0.0210357755,
0.0515645258,
0.0080320844,
-0.0809317753,
-0.0453025959,
0.0441012532,
0.0177954901,
0.0165945906,
0.0177380871,
0.0528456718,
-0.012036493,
0.0180195961,
-0.0307508688,
0.0024131627,
0.0489461124,
0.0171012208,
-0.024319984,
-0.0354628414,
-0.0126719773,
0.0449296497,
0.0527333766,
-0.0301522743,
-0.0019531567,
-0.0462986976,
-0.0072536902,
0.0232722238,
-0.0144698992,
0.0195595566,
-0.0354513377,
-0.0111011378,
-0.0103347423,
-0.0494124889,
0.0823982731,
-0.0054672463,
0.0640615225,
-0.077791892,
-0.0007966549,
0.0519757979,
0.0661657676,
0.0095946519,
-0.0027392828,
0.0114125246,
0.0291858036,
0.0481661707,
0.0768082291,
0.0094751734,
0.0088071683,
0.0334541425,
0.0016993592,
-0.0340555906,
-0.0090325028,
-0.0603590757,
-0.0143609038,
-0.0133960582,
0.0238038395,
0.023890622,
-0.0015190722,
0.0768545344,
-0.0155490916,
-0.0129476339,
-0.0059649395,
0.004686513,
0.0050142491,
0.0133338021,
0.0402294397,
-0.0044288109,
-0.0208562724,
-0.008523874,
0.0444434658,
0.007260222,
0.024777649,
-0.0455009751,
-0.0308690276,
-0.0212433841,
0.0028590614,
-0.0175263137,
-0.0075386399,
-0.011974927,
-0.0129945707,
-0.0900810286,
-0.0283257738,
0.0430068225,
-0.0141926641,
-0.0099752387,
0.015567353,
-0.0049406434,
0.0373811983,
-0.004099384,
-0.0523954816,
-0.0274478793,
0.0151952803,
0.0112106437,
-0.0420354567,
-0.0356843509,
-5.77576284e-33,
-0.0386192985,
-0.0311081056,
-0.0254206005,
-0.0160759725,
-0.0182995182,
0.0202794243,
-0.0029059409,
0.0186990034,
0.0051264307,
0.0083642136,
-0.0046874504,
0.0026329311,
0.0392323397,
-0.0313671753,
0.053713508,
-0.0456880927,
0.0509589389,
0.0388088971,
-0.05206348,
-0.0186483711,
0.0497440882,
0.0097121755,
0.1019576266,
-0.1129738688,
0.1262732446,
0.0162609555,
0.0236697029,
-0.0020379934,
0.0470499918,
0.0319350585,
-0.0026634217,
0.0448644795,
0.0048620086,
-0.0354283266,
-0.0204684362,
-0.0470652431,
-0.1096697375,
-0.0321712829,
0.0061009377,
0.0717678517,
0.009313954,
-0.0543992966,
0.0612809956,
0.0040850569,
-0.0317293741,
0.0363390408,
0.0676893368,
0.0165180489,
-0.0019673016,
-0.0111966012,
-0.023310706,
0.0348876193,
0.0020379373,
0.0693496615,
0.0597856268,
-0.0198187009,
0.0238284189,
-0.0128621086,
-0.0954575613,
0.0138730733,
0.017026253,
-0.0303927623,
0.0123692332,
0.0082935821,
-0.0075070504,
0.0262324214,
0.059273947,
0.0641415641,
-0.0250422582,
-0.027668545,
0.0239604563,
-0.0053094653,
-0.023341747,
0.0499460027,
0.0175585952,
-0.0375119597,
-0.0135947578,
0.0171438828,
-0.0361043625,
-0.0253668725,
-0.0365533866,
-0.0102399606,
-0.0797943771,
-0.0439336039,
-0.0283910614,
-0.0554775633,
-0.0189860575,
0.0239253175,
0.0021597454,
-0.0491528474,
-0.0130191492,
0.0434126966,
-0.0146491583,
-0.0089087691,
-0.0745532811,
-0.0829333812,
0.0224118605,
0.044583451,
-0.009583828,
-0.0013735621,
-0.0615321733,
-0.0109627787,
0.0207029209,
0.0320438854,
0.0495484918,
0.0095636379,
0.0442705676,
-0.0288523529,
-0.0516270064,
-0.0062093986,
0.0051636873,
-0.012436782,
-0.0189590286,
-0.0229598898,
0.0454924405,
0.0054916367,
0.0007246148,
-0.0124756526,
0.0762679502,
0.0238441247,
-0.0181414951,
0.0351438336,
0.0251766015,
0.0125604542,
-0.0031718588,
-0.0008510237,
0.0505097657,
-0.0095229968,
0.0175460577,
-0.0293804891,
0.0046484866,
-0.0218463242,
2.378e-7,
0.0604324639,
0.0603648089,
0.015530142,
-0.0482579917,
-0.0077873305,
0.005288526,
0.0138231162,
0.0062351432,
-0.0107882656,
-0.014929451,
-0.0065475516,
-0.0417711549,
0.0234399252,
0.0608596243,
-0.0479714312,
-0.0523463264,
-0.0014743232,
0.0447655544,
-0.0632004067,
0.0473197997,
0.0493364595,
0.0244047102,
0.0322479755,
0.0070448173,
-0.0475968271,
0.0046435562,
0.02721579,
-0.0072240033,
0.0581779964,
0.0322606303,
0.0748544633,
0.0352289565,
0.0430594645,
0.0914223418,
0.0099174576,
-0.0200752858,
0.0640351027,
0.0308146141,
-0.0031760428,
0.0414779931,
-0.0374066941,
-0.0171480644,
0.0146805765,
-0.0316524692,
0.0034995419,
-0.0415959023,
-0.0468817987,
0.0160814412,
-0.0369371213,
0.0233985763,
0.0425030403,
0.0247842334,
-0.0037983842,
0.0361565128,
0.023597829,
0.0016925038,
-0.0157114677,
-0.033630304,
0.0084677916,
0.0407107137,
0.0088084349,
-0.0494871624,
0.0156044802,
-0.0168715008,
-0.010974464,
-0.0625610948,
0.0034580166,
1.681595638e-34,
-0.0098533472,
0.014191621,
0.00107457,
0.0309463833,
0.0085756723,
-0.0019027777,
0.0117356041,
0.0026087714,
-0.0290187001,
-0.0013640359,
-0.0075878142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01416v1 | Sequence Shortening for Context-Aware Machine Translation | 2024-02-02T13:55:37 | 2024-02-02T13:55:37 | Paweł Mąka, Yusuf Can Semerci, Jan Scholtes, Gerasimos Spanakis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Context-aware Machine Translation aims to improve translations of sentences
by incorporating surrounding sentences as context. Towards this task, two main
architectures have been applied, namely single-encoder (based on concatenation)
and multi-encoder models. In this study, we show that a special case of
multi-encoder architecture, where the latent representation of the source
sentence is cached and reused as the context in the next step, achieves higher
accuracy on the contrastive datasets (where the models have to rank the correct
translation among the provided sentences) and comparable BLEU and COMET scores
as the single- and multi-encoder approaches. Furthermore, we investigate the
application of Sequence Shortening to the cached representations. We test three
pooling-based shortening techniques and introduce two novel methods - Latent
Grouping and Latent Selecting, where the network learns to group tokens or
selects the tokens to be cached as context. Our experiments show that the two
methods achieve competitive BLEU and COMET scores and accuracies on the
contrastive datasets to the other tested methods while potentially allowing for
higher interpretability and reducing the growth of memory requirements with
increased context size. | [
0.0160385538,
0.027410455,
-0.0215498079,
0.0342556089,
-0.0590947084,
0.01624218,
0.0444168374,
-0.0052500018,
-0.0674610734,
-0.0369937085,
-0.0004940851,
-0.0589285269,
0.0580267981,
-0.0153472926,
0.0509284325,
-0.0636066124,
0.0318068638,
0.0101466021,
0.0011009391,
0.0143229784,
-0.0071887625,
0.008657353,
0.0240248721,
0.0335143209,
0.0109527614,
0.0183947179,
-0.0129281739,
0.0185142606,
0.0388651714,
-0.0332110673,
0.0033164932,
0.0511240363,
0.021802457,
0.0082782274,
0.0000023178,
-0.0209551081,
-0.0576348417,
-0.0239227563,
0.0061309282,
0.0042491076,
0.0599631853,
-0.0432152413,
-0.002644365,
0.0318425782,
0.0007157061,
-0.0014344029,
0.038167268,
0.0146124177,
0.0462890267,
0.0717163086,
-0.0258195475,
-0.0680977628,
-0.0188391674,
-0.0463803746,
-0.0143561242,
-0.0590367317,
-0.0051386505,
-0.0395087935,
-0.0386120118,
0.0123795019,
-0.0419914573,
0.0453861207,
0.0536060035,
0.029102046,
-0.010107724,
0.024470875,
-0.0356915854,
-0.0090902876,
-0.0131562846,
0.0608779043,
-0.0322356597,
-0.0177252311,
-0.0235083569,
-0.0036418019,
0.0004349265,
-0.0532202981,
-0.0541614071,
0.0038229206,
0.0163736716,
0.0112959258,
-0.0139752384,
0.0552808866,
0.0312556699,
0.0058231507,
-0.052104529,
-0.0409720913,
0.0358457752,
-0.0175309852,
-0.0703336969,
0.0070349509,
-0.0164704137,
-0.0283405837,
0.0366991684,
0.0114729693,
-0.0181660485,
0.0205072947,
-0.0328174531,
-0.0533640161,
0.0032613711,
-0.0294765402,
-0.0124302004,
0.0629402027,
-0.0165321417,
0.0237001032,
-0.040690206,
0.081804812,
0.0011760166,
-0.027651323,
-0.0846487954,
-0.0391132161,
-0.0342675447,
0.0208243374,
-0.0274776239,
0.0271908082,
-0.0599868409,
-0.0281822309,
-0.0701582208,
0.011290052,
0.0147784567,
-0.0181625057,
-0.0152799515,
0.0190812983,
-0.0451231301,
0.0309129134,
0.000657368,
0.0348777771,
-0.0377301462,
-0.0028094624,
0.0345200412,
-0.0609516129,
-0.0388766602,
0.0139984414,
0.034076035,
-0.0397410356,
-0.0173089616,
0.0745290443,
-0.0102737229,
-0.0476564467,
-0.0122040734,
-0.0304203462,
-0.0387516879,
-0.0393700227,
-0.0006146021,
-0.0763035789,
0.0605420284,
-0.0039945445,
0.0176246595,
-0.0244284403,
-0.0075964425,
0.0075699217,
-0.0000714343,
0.0587845258,
0.0167305544,
-0.0649172589,
0.0041289795,
0.0201600175,
0.0208298042,
0.0432271436,
0.064610593,
0.0543440245,
0.0344877951,
-0.0046804245,
-0.0104035968,
-0.0009581889,
0.0230429787,
0.0036702619,
-0.0022536339,
-0.0175748412,
0.0000968777,
0.0163655188,
0.0209116675,
0.0521317683,
-0.0489389189,
-0.0064633572,
0.027820291,
0.0381030478,
0.0275278948,
0.0392394438,
0.0564644188,
0.0025068955,
-0.0415028557,
0.0402738675,
-0.0101718754,
0.0501215272,
0.0008579459,
0.0036374356,
0.0751247033,
0.0427867062,
-0.025541557,
-0.0204797909,
0.0040655038,
-0.0325045437,
0.0276818685,
-0.0330040678,
0.0276785232,
0.0126114553,
-0.0656437054,
0.0509653352,
-0.0151945157,
-0.0762527883,
-0.0042511919,
0.000183667,
-0.0467317514,
0.0798860341,
0.0302918814,
0.0224103723,
-0.058699619,
-0.019132616,
-0.0399556197,
-0.003734322,
0.018859636,
0.0084724203,
0.0416438989,
-0.0666619539,
-0.0169782918,
-0.0194187425,
-0.0148073724,
0.0282589793,
-0.0028225852,
0.0224875342,
0.061654184,
0.0321510583,
0.0066862204,
0.0317510553,
0.0075164041,
-0.0339713879,
0.029699415,
0.0378319621,
0.0501475558,
0.028038688,
0.0221433975,
0.003435828,
0.0485324711,
-0.0627697408,
-0.0284145623,
0.0304353833,
-0.104826279,
-0.1234709471,
0.001575364,
-0.026337387,
0.013388481,
0.0007102396,
-0.072143428,
-0.0728403851,
-0.0049201786,
-0.038913738,
0.0315711312,
-0.0251771212,
0.0334225185,
0.0025329788,
0.0326310657,
-0.0193275474,
0.07666789,
-0.0412275121,
0.003480636,
0.0220678877,
0.0295518935,
0.0322460346,
-0.0485992283,
-0.0135670016,
0.0082351239,
0.0185601618,
0.0003966705,
0.060053166,
0.010224076,
-0.0381010249,
-0.0073111388,
-0.0879322663,
0.015823165,
-0.0355188176,
0.0121416654,
0.0337038711,
0.0439760052,
0.0296113938,
-0.0073139649,
-0.0202236548,
0.0055045099,
-0.0105582848,
0.0331767648,
0.0342448838,
0.0007702017,
-0.0321858488,
-0.0146301864,
-0.0188265312,
0.0155025851,
0.0770602003,
-0.0241634101,
-0.0424205363,
-0.0339944549,
0.0336740725,
-0.0304049719,
-0.0345037617,
-0.0035757236,
-0.0446449667,
0.0015619076,
-0.0025245463,
0.0402105413,
0.0401567332,
0.0257946681,
0.0498505309,
0.0174942799,
0.0093835965,
-0.0136890067,
-0.0105970744,
-0.0354738422,
-0.0071951295,
-0.0147954952,
-0.0205226857,
0.0018249697,
0.0329934098,
0.0225372277,
0.0205565635,
-0.0687397122,
-0.0129751936,
0.0269966163,
-0.0368224569,
-0.0446106829,
-0.0038402586,
-0.0121615734,
0.0221935175,
-0.0335922986,
-0.0314116329,
0.062417414,
-0.0255433898,
-0.0040062601,
-0.0535197854,
-0.0085964343,
-0.0407826193,
0.0455351844,
0.0021322698,
0.0235315431,
-0.0692794025,
-0.0237438418,
-0.0360624567,
0.0007546219,
-0.007352564,
-0.0167142656,
0.0192798357,
-0.048496183,
-0.0227339379,
-0.0022003718,
-0.0272624679,
-0.0202119015,
0.0143143144,
0.0179552361,
0.0394645222,
0.0592443496,
0.0125934528,
-0.0619040355,
0.0105063831,
0.0163810626,
0.0837835595,
-0.0152083328,
0.0299122315,
-0.0189770013,
0.0598865822,
0.0058952337,
0.0028243545,
0.0510347225,
-0.0525834896,
0.043865595,
0.057643421,
0.0362959318,
-0.0312293023,
-0.0328663401,
-0.0073780469,
0.0106055094,
-0.0023171306,
-0.016956741,
0.0123300757,
0.0504566021,
-0.0653454363,
-0.0220186412,
0.1151085049,
0.0309201647,
-0.0652173087,
0.0168321673,
0.0270474255,
0.0122226188,
0.0077904607,
-0.0101707252,
-0.0661767721,
-0.03745028,
-0.0005625981,
-0.0005983525,
0.0098828664,
0.0161001943,
-0.033977069,
-0.0753337592,
0.0013349972,
0.0352269299,
-0.0842875093,
-0.0319274068,
-0.03100238,
-0.0209687296,
-0.0031937123,
0.0482620448,
0.0134640187,
0.0287400354,
-0.0260194335,
0.0077440105,
0.015535499,
-0.0788892359,
-0.0215310603,
-0.0347278416,
-0.0049761049,
0.0643419996,
0.0313278139,
0.0285895728,
-0.0157079827,
0.0304275919,
-0.0566329956,
0.036309965,
-0.0219223369,
0.0233336203,
-0.0158966519,
0.0130156083,
0.0229343027,
0.0019462047,
-0.0494281873,
-0.0206760094,
0.0108970162,
0.0374823995,
-0.0065714223,
0.0097232312,
0.0051583629,
-0.032431446,
-0.004884962,
0.0453543216,
0.03843854,
-0.0216937475,
0.0033500537,
-0.0226214584,
-0.0294531155,
-0.0690364242,
0.0337631851,
-0.0318302885,
-0.0376581103,
-0.0328881331,
-0.0972708985,
-0.0562284589,
0.0289921891,
0.034716323,
-0.0164549947,
0.0360034928,
0.0013292955,
0.0078436807,
-0.0301482696,
-0.0009556131,
-0.0007951842,
0.007316961,
-0.022498738,
0.0172067117,
0.0294286665,
-0.0112274876,
-0.01033023,
0.021404773,
-0.0987100005,
-0.0473361425,
-0.0166776627,
0.0474364273,
0.0115956413,
0.0566891916,
0.0042112065,
-0.0025825095,
0.0317838937,
0.0117598046,
-0.0533529334,
0.02721815,
-0.0035117832,
0.0007595706,
-0.0109113241,
0.0207196958,
-0.032401897,
0.0282943565,
0.0020955424,
0.0516628996,
-0.0182932522,
-0.0402764939,
0.0220751204,
-0.0141769871,
0.0399865769,
-0.0235475674,
-0.0332850143,
0.004229743,
0.0581127591,
-0.0095062964,
0.0034194156,
-0.0115966545,
0.0003224099,
-0.0043254443,
0.0203700475,
-0.0018142597,
0.0206439439,
0.0169476587,
-0.0531348512,
-0.0056422073,
0.0105873896,
0.0123490058,
0.0319292992,
-0.0181988329,
0.0541859604,
-0.0329411477,
-0.0213886052,
-0.0174340717,
0.0088330209,
-0.0682590306,
0.0103760678,
0.0265934579,
0.0331063345,
-0.0293103158,
0.0666406751,
-0.0674129203,
0.0440740138,
-0.0345445871,
-0.0116906399,
0.0691928789,
-0.014388823,
0.0733098611,
0.027339207,
-0.011137112,
-0.0306825042,
0.0562598296,
-0.0062116878,
-0.0491264164,
-0.0197071265,
0.0056849536,
-0.0138840284,
0.0206004959,
0.0628062114,
-0.0442905277,
-0.0022176548,
-0.0047126324,
-0.0169985052,
-0.0342279486,
-0.005905692,
-0.0166522395,
0.0320317559,
0.0099406987,
-0.0067720464,
-0.0013665153,
-0.0429163799,
0.0308499094,
-0.0080410801,
0.0243370589,
0.0123752654,
0.0675173923,
0.0823448971,
-0.0242341664,
-0.0102820471,
-0.01495241,
0.0071028182,
-0.0170047451,
-0.0197199918,
-0.0372386724,
-6.8149836e-33,
-0.0383662172,
-0.043825537,
0.0073624477,
-0.048881799,
-0.0250852648,
0.012576066,
-0.0689004809,
-0.0498243608,
0.0147419283,
-0.0212115683,
-0.0026133854,
-0.0085538449,
0.022338042,
0.0403800569,
0.0138519099,
-0.0045377049,
0.093306601,
0.0305870678,
-0.0136486692,
0.0260306727,
0.0575842224,
0.0394201092,
0.0526697785,
-0.0402748026,
-0.0094857151,
-0.0036752394,
0.0020427504,
0.0024440328,
0.0225464031,
0.0518237092,
0.0117336968,
0.0259108208,
0.0344406404,
-0.0346298255,
-0.0325929597,
-0.0011096211,
-0.1047616079,
-0.027314283,
0.0143491561,
0.0101384996,
-0.049532529,
-0.106736429,
0.0567368083,
-0.0195629038,
0.0295801368,
0.0113470312,
0.0125845298,
-0.0320963897,
-0.050961148,
-0.0375055969,
-0.0592930876,
0.0038019468,
-0.0115563553,
0.0235135835,
0.0111478632,
0.0561359189,
-0.0230074171,
0.0480242781,
-0.0871967673,
0.0115111033,
-0.0288804453,
0.0630522445,
0.0684003234,
0.0269610416,
-0.000127979,
0.0199041236,
0.0110357795,
-0.0286471546,
-0.0097842626,
-0.0050473665,
0.0035470279,
0.0136826308,
0.0760161132,
0.0350085124,
0.0617264137,
-0.0397203453,
-0.0732907876,
0.0145352622,
-0.0073375711,
0.0166849624,
0.0337253474,
0.0487987287,
-0.0050928276,
-0.0226695985,
-0.0375558287,
-0.0036361855,
-0.0304851066,
-0.0340627059,
0.0200916808,
0.0366197489,
-0.0386290029,
0.0109590543,
0.0643843114,
-0.0017481224,
0.0352499671,
0.011161698,
-0.0137643013,
0.0086741196,
0.0107108094,
0.034038119,
-0.0277317204,
-0.0130809164,
0.0415196195,
-0.0099190623,
0.011242209,
-0.032636717,
0.0639632866,
0.0108910045,
-0.0448713861,
0.0100325504,
-0.0426290743,
-0.0264950804,
-0.0327023678,
-0.015028446,
0.0006681719,
0.0372971669,
-0.017872965,
0.0652853996,
-0.0034700679,
-0.0126434993,
-0.0044288547,
-0.0134589449,
0.0154872462,
0.0552280173,
-0.0545980036,
0.0045697992,
-0.0134215569,
0.0431215577,
0.0851746053,
-0.0349595882,
-0.041616559,
0.0209461395,
3.02e-7,
0.0484123603,
0.0486317053,
0.0338987559,
-0.039028693,
0.0191352293,
0.0109327678,
0.0021405166,
0.0326572992,
-0.0043856525,
0.061480131,
0.0452409312,
0.0294569433,
0.0442731343,
0.028891122,
-0.0745386854,
0.0162374415,
-0.0414014384,
0.0021265987,
-0.0280068126,
0.0131908199,
0.0866266415,
0.1130360663,
0.008672432,
0.0175010413,
-0.0087449243,
0.0011232526,
0.0444387794,
-0.0195621606,
-0.0132813975,
-0.0159330964,
-0.0352880321,
0.0356450938,
-0.0331724994,
-0.0129432762,
-0.0157202817,
0.0242276527,
0.0169334598,
0.0561239831,
-0.0045982073,
-0.0537840761,
0.0269878972,
0.0203262735,
-0.0195103772,
0.0129393106,
0.0659620315,
-0.0566534773,
-0.0168668386,
-0.0061204592,
-0.0029458182,
0.0450346768,
0.0270640925,
0.0205496307,
-0.0297163725,
0.0207938794,
0.0337735638,
0.013338984,
-0.0196964163,
-0.1049117297,
-0.0024657184,
0.001831627,
-0.0162077695,
-0.0042320392,
-0.047055129,
-0.0054408647,
0.0378092639,
-0.0204717182,
0.0017102828,
2.925061342e-34,
0.0234924182,
-0.0212786086,
-0.0134358136,
0.0253641009,
0.0316186175,
-0.0557770245,
-0.0391915962,
0.0010853936,
0.0073608779,
-0.0538207218,
-0.0489013717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01404v1 | On Measuring Context Utilization in Document-Level MT Systems | 2024-02-02T13:37:07 | 2024-02-02T13:37:07 | Wafaa Mohammed, Vlad Niculae | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level translation models are usually evaluated using general metrics
such as BLEU, which are not informative about the benefits of context. Current
work on context-aware evaluation, such as contrastive methods, only measure
translation accuracy on words that need context for disambiguation. Such
measures cannot reveal whether the translation model uses the correct
supporting context. We propose to complement accuracy-based evaluation with
measures of context utilization. We find that perturbation-based analysis
(comparing models' performance when provided with correct versus random
context) is an effective measure of overall context utilization. For a
finer-grained phenomenon-specific evaluation, we propose to measure how much
the supporting context contributes to handling context-dependent discourse
phenomena. We show that automatically-annotated supporting context gives
similar conclusions to human-annotated context and can be used as alternative
for cases where human annotations are not available. Finally, we highlight the
importance of using discourse-rich datasets when assessing context utilization. | [
0.0269591492,
0.0038652054,
-0.0209790505,
0.0462120026,
-0.0454256944,
0.0136889666,
0.0462707318,
-0.0306905098,
-0.0777115002,
-0.0669681802,
-0.0462230332,
-0.0213613566,
0.0459090509,
-0.0468181893,
0.0190440137,
-0.0665060058,
0.0402387306,
-0.0325515866,
-0.023785919,
0.0181244109,
0.0100049255,
0.0041620424,
0.0058281207,
0.0090009989,
-0.0156798735,
-0.0224454645,
0.0200278051,
0.0282286555,
0.0700713322,
-0.0099494588,
-0.0232871585,
0.0597717166,
0.0080722114,
0.0632836074,
0.0000019503,
-0.0546714552,
-0.0421931557,
0.0247136988,
-0.0133932559,
0.0379147828,
0.0823985487,
-0.0416174494,
-0.0086430591,
-0.0039984481,
-0.0305199847,
0.0114444951,
0.0186745506,
-0.0167627316,
0.018254824,
0.0064064017,
-0.0240244567,
-0.0082614953,
-0.053266827,
0.0136699043,
0.0058832299,
-0.0579235405,
-0.0289012715,
0.0357348323,
-0.0141290333,
0.0245068055,
0.002841216,
0.0754285306,
0.0172635335,
-0.0143103991,
-0.013067361,
-0.0002109646,
-0.0214438904,
0.0167191755,
-0.0014070127,
0.0547912531,
0.1086530387,
-0.0068728961,
-0.0006341484,
0.0064274482,
-0.0098943524,
0.0359399579,
-0.0277788788,
-0.0067920643,
-0.0170333888,
0.0107142273,
0.0595826209,
0.0426260829,
0.0022230104,
0.0362229869,
-0.0386438295,
0.0133761438,
0.0293983109,
-0.0000215372,
-0.0192201883,
0.0185181443,
-0.0651555583,
-0.0439654402,
0.0436826572,
-0.0104595134,
-0.0329416022,
0.0345000662,
-0.0233612824,
-0.0813583806,
0.0377373472,
-0.0922393724,
-0.0115527334,
0.0406950489,
-0.0280343294,
0.0460724644,
0.0257520806,
0.0327044725,
-0.0136042954,
-0.0490049347,
-0.0358259492,
-0.022267323,
-0.0230683573,
0.0343699083,
-0.0374472104,
-0.0007399754,
-0.0761639476,
-0.0153440833,
-0.0463097617,
0.0385403521,
0.0254077259,
-0.0155181307,
0.0014003841,
-0.031336911,
-0.0705781877,
0.014170628,
0.0071013588,
0.0344550125,
-0.0324310288,
-0.0152702779,
-0.0186120532,
-0.0320655107,
-0.00016948,
0.0297555663,
-0.0351055115,
-0.0407424867,
-0.0580896288,
0.060511563,
0.0038284655,
-0.0315227285,
-0.0001506272,
-0.0273523238,
-0.0518306382,
-0.0402081944,
-0.0218283255,
-0.0680739358,
-0.0125367735,
0.0291363448,
0.0133900931,
-0.0033972152,
0.0181154609,
-0.0110166911,
-0.0055246102,
0.0925877839,
0.008488615,
-0.005981016,
0.0460755154,
0.0058378414,
-0.0132960146,
0.0784441307,
0.0633356273,
-0.0278284065,
0.0482154228,
0.0269512143,
-0.0396621041,
0.0345037989,
-0.0222259238,
0.0134010604,
-0.018354902,
-0.0016517547,
-0.0286547411,
0.0041973423,
0.0161871556,
0.0706711933,
-0.0378387868,
0.0188982356,
0.0356427655,
0.0305978917,
0.0102665564,
0.0068385727,
0.0553075075,
0.0048210472,
-0.0158471055,
0.0453863516,
0.0093054259,
-0.0147738215,
-0.0178702809,
0.0043384307,
0.0244006328,
-0.001727217,
-0.0189955104,
-0.0525448918,
-0.0199697074,
-0.0073499992,
0.0445393585,
-0.0335726179,
0.0782433748,
0.016866792,
-0.0042354637,
0.0392989367,
-0.0103107421,
-0.0440652333,
0.0110528264,
-0.0185924135,
-0.0426505767,
0.0768323615,
0.0689961165,
-0.038848035,
-0.023296563,
0.0141614731,
0.0219938923,
0.0649498627,
0.0244077891,
-0.0057964739,
0.0265137888,
-0.018741468,
-0.0190301556,
-0.0034695528,
0.0317946561,
0.0105134416,
0.0088413255,
0.0174716283,
0.0308671482,
-0.0583303683,
-0.0132145975,
0.0195263028,
-0.0352857821,
-0.0101667056,
-0.0078162653,
-0.0043231584,
0.0216080677,
0.0462643057,
-0.0310307369,
-0.0062826755,
0.0071932501,
-0.0318675898,
0.0315924548,
0.0800335109,
-0.0556473546,
-0.0510510318,
0.0311429035,
-0.0303322561,
-0.0192055237,
-0.0389339067,
0.0039568041,
-0.0465740375,
0.0098079462,
-0.0533809215,
0.0326828845,
-0.0339814089,
0.0336089022,
-0.0236914959,
-0.0303499009,
-0.0459497161,
0.0528363995,
0.0059545012,
0.0065068286,
0.0599272735,
0.0167989377,
0.0536878482,
0.0011558814,
-0.0257395823,
0.0049849609,
0.0391084775,
-0.0048198686,
0.0529522896,
0.0166787542,
-0.0315006524,
-0.0102602467,
-0.1319394857,
0.0043763644,
-0.0500044413,
0.0442029685,
0.0688196346,
0.0403549597,
0.0017636915,
0.0091081439,
0.0467876755,
-0.0366496108,
-0.0142877651,
0.0148484837,
0.0375294611,
0.020113945,
0.023911994,
-0.0661756918,
0.0032934418,
0.0036196474,
0.0445695184,
0.0399324372,
-0.0591442809,
-0.0449067801,
0.0463031083,
-0.0340689197,
-0.0145831108,
0.0109212268,
-0.0325542651,
0.047348626,
0.0199846197,
0.0550332628,
0.0364829302,
0.0020095622,
0.0549068376,
0.0295801815,
-0.0386533812,
-0.0480124727,
-0.0124718295,
0.0113242352,
-0.0054968442,
-0.02004035,
-0.0367401466,
0.0046317559,
0.0488184318,
0.0227571782,
0.0067928117,
-0.0326155424,
-0.0052096294,
-0.0697501078,
-0.0627507195,
0.0148961199,
0.0230623856,
-0.0156762563,
0.0718976408,
-0.0143641075,
-0.0244627837,
0.0760760978,
-0.0333643295,
-0.0002291195,
-0.0749069899,
0.0144163659,
-0.0258088689,
0.0335935131,
-0.0520312823,
-0.0050590006,
-0.0526329763,
-0.0542119034,
-0.0183274001,
-0.002937983,
0.0473788008,
-0.0331754647,
0.0527307205,
-0.1145504266,
0.0172495916,
-0.0136352666,
-0.0119721126,
-0.0308400001,
-0.0074416562,
-0.0033820665,
0.0242983792,
0.0374532677,
-0.0196936782,
-0.0006467437,
0.0461239889,
0.0490523726,
0.0641799271,
-0.0004389934,
-0.0249526687,
-0.0233141482,
0.0341360681,
0.0024514522,
0.0019732441,
0.0499508306,
-0.02765649,
0.0483129099,
0.0376652852,
0.0035700228,
-0.0410781726,
-0.0283373222,
-0.0394229963,
0.0019537555,
-0.0167567991,
-0.0595215708,
-0.0152588198,
0.0922557414,
-0.0639895275,
-0.0515402406,
0.1365837455,
0.0407215953,
-0.0351269245,
-0.0313869677,
-0.032101512,
0.0258488432,
-0.0224115737,
-0.0137332613,
-0.097849302,
-0.0150631573,
0.0064148786,
0.0167761222,
0.0236925967,
-0.0118037444,
0.0081195049,
-0.0349473618,
0.0213657934,
0.0152720874,
-0.0441554151,
0.0106373588,
-0.0069004376,
0.0443091877,
-0.0084775323,
0.0478974842,
-0.0266325809,
-0.0031989277,
0.0013258981,
-0.0059676748,
0.0201103613,
-0.0646475479,
-0.0092393002,
-0.0401395001,
0.0219395682,
0.0462457538,
0.0204998441,
0.0186785851,
-0.0060723484,
0.0113511849,
-0.0539377779,
0.01562801,
-0.043703109,
0.0090019871,
0.0018039023,
0.0119890729,
-0.0381734744,
0.000663483,
-0.0115841692,
-0.0137850996,
-0.0118395835,
0.0209643785,
-0.0342608131,
0.0389984287,
-0.0235470869,
0.010361827,
0.0265618414,
0.0628697053,
0.0404012054,
-0.05187013,
-0.0285827555,
-0.0098688602,
0.0086644292,
-0.031763833,
0.0320472904,
-0.0489419475,
-0.049464386,
-0.0373827629,
-0.0902816653,
-0.0650808439,
0.005086049,
0.0249947384,
-0.000429163,
0.0485858172,
0.0010239943,
-0.000629984,
-0.0009887627,
0.0040189689,
-0.0159014445,
0.0149515104,
-0.0167270936,
-0.0176168773,
0.0257569663,
0.0127126444,
-0.0004725291,
0.0186550468,
-0.0403537489,
-0.0745586306,
0.0076980712,
-0.01008943,
0.0229579452,
0.0389968678,
-0.0192847755,
-0.0270607006,
0.0160541721,
-0.0144652566,
-0.0077308621,
0.0398011208,
0.0542456433,
0.042543292,
-0.0094901193,
0.0284277033,
-0.0187534876,
0.0124144088,
-0.0166017786,
0.0565206185,
-0.0610346235,
-0.0495105609,
-0.0059985556,
-0.023819318,
0.0463561676,
-0.0473937169,
-0.0138245346,
-0.0104519362,
-0.0081098303,
-0.0664492026,
-0.000956452,
-0.0285841096,
0.0018614614,
0.0031314038,
-0.0091625294,
-0.0325573236,
0.0353532061,
-0.0577533655,
0.0228146985,
-0.0113570234,
0.0173803885,
0.0060078884,
-0.0009077577,
-0.0485095903,
0.0245495569,
-0.000018971,
-0.0247412343,
-0.0109118195,
0.0342204571,
-0.0247465912,
0.0799348056,
0.0094489437,
-0.0178357363,
0.03267226,
0.0579625107,
-0.0478164218,
0.0755263492,
0.0077247708,
0.0094445311,
0.0729138851,
-0.0226864293,
0.1256814003,
-0.0220012944,
0.007967215,
-0.0110709816,
0.0788160488,
0.0143592488,
0.0344270654,
-0.0231624451,
0.0125124436,
0.0107650673,
0.0454345047,
0.0606344305,
-0.0345119722,
-0.0179262385,
-0.0092024272,
-0.0217932407,
-0.0206894986,
0.0003906123,
-0.050868243,
0.0161358379,
-0.0230446663,
-0.0092155682,
-0.0764823407,
-0.0416463353,
0.0283214822,
0.0272006094,
-0.0215980299,
-0.0108304396,
0.0259656943,
0.0710196048,
-0.0173959788,
-0.0221595,
-0.0569053739,
0.0025010791,
-0.0046446929,
-0.0073841335,
-0.0813539177,
-6.08914192e-33,
-0.08068946,
-0.050840266,
-0.005223949,
0.0176511221,
-0.0031450428,
0.0251871273,
-0.0502907932,
0.0014739677,
0.0146890543,
0.0284416676,
-0.0076175896,
0.0261903293,
0.0253098402,
-0.0133142825,
-0.0216966234,
-0.0094907489,
0.0477952883,
0.012195088,
-0.0355585515,
0.0176970996,
0.0507082827,
-0.020178033,
0.0718604103,
-0.0956206992,
0.0702356398,
-0.0089774346,
0.0187250916,
0.0091232406,
0.0309801679,
0.0507203229,
0.0023953789,
0.0278443359,
0.0324547254,
-0.0004211918,
-0.0316684544,
0.0316401087,
-0.0970441103,
-0.0240212865,
0.080882296,
0.0313351452,
-0.0220881235,
-0.0373844951,
0.0248924922,
-0.0077880495,
-0.0292233825,
0.0136638572,
0.0199424401,
-0.0284150541,
-0.018384289,
-0.0278848354,
-0.0740796775,
0.0404104628,
-0.0036833123,
0.0056093638,
0.0377194546,
0.0248383228,
-0.0076140589,
-0.0000084564,
-0.0769194216,
0.004708658,
-0.0100001814,
-0.0009441497,
0.0650215223,
0.0203888863,
0.0158175919,
0.0180696007,
-0.0189439226,
0.0023777012,
0.0268309582,
-0.0394063257,
0.0455620065,
-0.0113503607,
0.0404477753,
0.0578479171,
0.0198651161,
0.0281763412,
-0.0452027135,
0.0239318684,
-0.0260743983,
0.028428033,
0.0299170744,
0.0167529751,
-0.0552196726,
-0.0151996017,
-0.0634855404,
-0.0010612666,
-0.0061567309,
-0.0263439268,
-0.0082705393,
-0.0325051881,
-0.0481837541,
-0.0193003174,
0.0709989518,
-0.0094223218,
-0.0098117646,
-0.0023099103,
-0.0049589733,
0.0395004116,
0.0023014625,
0.0240432415,
-0.0207047109,
-0.0032715148,
0.015896,
0.0520355292,
0.0177371241,
-0.039217785,
0.0125261247,
0.0081091095,
-0.0242608469,
0.022579411,
-0.0178126879,
-0.0013105512,
-0.05101832,
-0.017083155,
0.0235714316,
0.008334537,
0.0038386162,
0.0467679873,
0.0458885506,
0.0026263762,
-0.0482163765,
-0.0004764442,
-0.0212332662,
0.0204361957,
-0.0430672504,
0.017132055,
-0.0033215922,
0.0592314042,
0.0471084006,
-0.0128560718,
-0.0160061624,
0.0271863546,
2.566e-7,
0.0879525095,
0.0654571652,
0.008386665,
-0.0031261337,
0.038545914,
-0.0035421168,
-0.0074266316,
-0.0065416717,
0.0122517142,
-0.0085299378,
0.0273379404,
0.0099184401,
0.0683509558,
0.0464938357,
-0.0282128695,
-0.050995782,
-0.0317824148,
0.0014979007,
-0.0275414456,
0.0165649392,
0.0528387316,
0.0407836512,
-0.0222397633,
0.0239591952,
-0.0494776331,
-0.0478316545,
0.066812031,
-0.0510396771,
-0.0144589692,
0.0220544226,
0.0263516158,
0.0276713911,
-0.0102659389,
-0.0144283371,
-0.012202288,
0.0082203252,
0.0202424806,
0.0593921281,
0.0149528766,
-0.0383389369,
-0.0058802818,
-0.0411050282,
0.0166386161,
-0.0214232244,
0.0241614617,
-0.02725753,
0.0125222746,
-0.0192267578,
0.0033512944,
0.0001723553,
0.0212637391,
0.0048120087,
-0.0515827984,
0.0304854065,
0.0075402977,
-0.0032724054,
-0.0422906354,
-0.0472444482,
-0.0234847739,
0.0080627678,
-0.0188949034,
-0.0388280079,
0.0065106,
-0.0594676994,
-0.0357206725,
-0.026146492,
0.0078195902,
2.277948488e-34,
0.0656321496,
-0.0110753281,
0.006694593,
0.0264645405,
0.0360005647,
-0.012880303,
-0.0244081672,
-0.0069182152,
0.0216967594,
-0.0679692775,
0.0128470836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01812v1 | Distilling LLMs' Decomposition Abilities into Compact Language Models | 2024-02-02T13:23:15 | 2024-02-02T13:23:15 | Denis Tarasov, Kumar Shridhar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated proficiency in their reasoning
abilities, yet their large size presents scalability challenges and limits any
further customization. In contrast, compact models offer customized training
but often fall short in solving complex reasoning tasks. This study focuses on
distilling the LLMs' decomposition skills into compact models using offline
reinforcement learning. We leverage the advancements in the LLM`s capabilities
to provide feedback and generate a specialized task-specific dataset for
training compact models. The development of an AI-generated dataset and the
establishment of baselines constitute the primary contributions of our work,
underscoring the potential of compact models in replicating complex
problem-solving skills. | [
0.0244826078,
0.0607212558,
-0.0301890615,
-0.0063132113,
-0.0495212078,
0.0301803127,
0.0243869033,
0.0178749803,
-0.0340247527,
-0.0035806939,
-0.0024887451,
0.0057175891,
-0.0067040129,
0.029289851,
-0.0170033164,
-0.0165257286,
0.028261045,
-0.0685492307,
0.0026769883,
0.0043182913,
-0.024736248,
0.0353204608,
-0.0260390732,
0.0633001626,
0.0284074303,
-0.0269890316,
-0.0440224893,
-0.0181894228,
-0.0158161223,
0.0105492491,
-0.0087323878,
0.0247303881,
0.0724627599,
0.0311201941,
0.0000018498,
-0.037403021,
-0.0205434076,
-0.0325299911,
-0.0627296492,
-0.0180318244,
0.0143682677,
-0.0164512042,
0.0048736879,
0.0285124946,
-0.0529168099,
-0.0263694115,
0.0137734283,
0.0421084352,
0.0525904819,
0.0908269882,
0.01752753,
-0.0116336783,
0.0182126239,
-0.0262072161,
0.0172215551,
-0.0323606543,
0.0036960107,
0.0603463687,
0.0279144607,
-0.032140892,
-0.0066367309,
-0.0156914294,
0.054970827,
0.023083603,
-0.0390968956,
0.0346098766,
-0.0312647596,
-0.0213059876,
0.0010741749,
0.0368122645,
-0.0611678548,
-0.0178085696,
-0.0056326138,
-0.0286593828,
0.0021830092,
0.0004540591,
-0.0476206467,
0.0596429445,
-0.0011129322,
0.0525001064,
0.0122942422,
-0.0480539389,
0.0215542149,
0.0167586319,
-0.0421422161,
0.0917902738,
-0.0180349573,
-0.0417454429,
-0.0007105881,
-0.0188353229,
-0.055668544,
-0.0344726332,
-0.0093256067,
0.0650480464,
-0.0566216111,
0.0283040591,
-0.0366084762,
-0.0173212234,
0.0003597278,
-0.0023791837,
0.094478704,
0.017104933,
0.0441968516,
0.057082966,
-0.02003593,
0.0744357184,
-0.0023258452,
0.0231590401,
-0.0220648982,
-0.002032626,
-0.0804968104,
-0.0195872504,
-0.03425676,
0.0617405288,
-0.0309974886,
0.007866892,
-0.0148337707,
0.0187115315,
-0.015421005,
0.0495381318,
0.0383005813,
0.0018279027,
-0.0397374183,
-0.0203537736,
-0.0620423034,
0.0147177875,
-0.0387091488,
0.055036217,
0.010665549,
-0.0518823117,
0.0014135044,
-0.013899344,
-0.0083867172,
-0.0287520085,
0.0340605229,
0.0729616955,
-0.0094678048,
-0.0393007211,
-0.0266763661,
-0.0275706984,
0.0255433451,
-0.0812152624,
0.0084712598,
-0.0827366561,
0.0470765382,
-0.0335837044,
-0.0167891178,
-0.045420099,
0.0052679419,
0.022792222,
0.0048435158,
0.0701870769,
0.0413027294,
0.0303170905,
0.0178151485,
-0.0075411974,
-0.0038197224,
0.0879346728,
0.0180303585,
0.0115306424,
0.0113094766,
-0.0101458179,
0.0167610161,
0.0340636373,
0.0268244818,
0.0216834471,
-0.061138425,
0.0119149005,
-0.0111149317,
0.0346965194,
0.0111770891,
0.0274410173,
-0.0382189341,
0.0272204392,
0.0552404299,
0.0613516383,
0.0393857583,
0.0296743382,
0.0272286441,
0.0240423772,
-0.0110654524,
-0.0105562853,
-0.0500972085,
0.019647304,
-0.01790075,
0.0289024841,
-0.0367791131,
0.0272271764,
-0.0311929435,
-0.0545059666,
-0.0059277695,
0.0114058778,
0.0095896441,
0.0282879565,
0.0539271235,
0.0179343782,
-0.0158504769,
0.0414063931,
0.0238328595,
-0.038242124,
0.0023947384,
-0.0847781301,
0.0409171842,
0.0457855836,
0.0734774843,
-0.0241296627,
-0.0342083573,
-0.0165172946,
-0.0372522548,
0.0320334472,
-0.0076795714,
-0.0274417493,
0.0003727879,
-0.0508134365,
-0.0290918853,
-0.0276829544,
0.0250730403,
-0.0010818256,
0.0439992771,
-0.0040698857,
-0.0053100171,
-0.0256407466,
-0.0365988649,
0.0417380743,
-0.0554133616,
-0.0381436236,
0.0069626365,
0.006003134,
0.0232559219,
-0.0172361527,
-0.0014788406,
0.0056888857,
0.033203844,
-0.0296294875,
-0.0057979058,
-0.0204061568,
-0.0204396043,
-0.058837451,
0.043164596,
-0.0339437611,
0.0196235906,
0.0598173849,
-0.0518029518,
-0.0241346247,
-0.0061988626,
-0.0210168194,
0.0189563278,
-0.040148735,
-0.0025729078,
-0.0090889791,
-0.0025942,
-0.0040548551,
0.0765134841,
-0.0554402024,
0.0349822678,
0.0290008038,
-0.0326959379,
-0.0258215591,
-0.0622253045,
0.0149865821,
-0.0022962068,
-0.00815388,
0.020068245,
-0.0026300508,
0.0519084372,
-0.0162833408,
-0.0320711732,
-0.0385317132,
-0.0125244828,
-0.0105502112,
0.0139754377,
0.0454711504,
-0.0093565304,
0.0021650691,
-0.002427798,
-0.0120118475,
-0.0065549063,
0.0526699349,
0.005519378,
0.0343536288,
0.0075827204,
-0.029549947,
-0.0235246848,
-0.0385468863,
-0.0085362112,
0.0268468056,
-0.0558420978,
0.0254007839,
-0.0572846159,
0.026288528,
-0.0245635528,
0.0487359799,
-0.011109137,
-0.0463817269,
0.0190491229,
-0.0519495197,
0.0181107838,
0.1001805961,
0.0030883127,
0.0518709049,
0.1040504873,
0.0065838429,
-0.0629649237,
0.0298229605,
-0.0278421883,
-0.0255195647,
-0.0473766103,
-0.0374884196,
-0.0015153228,
0.0876805112,
-0.0209809095,
0.0146941412,
-0.058153607,
0.0029930945,
0.0069822874,
-0.0365432501,
-0.0379108042,
0.0043529449,
-0.0219288412,
0.0543977618,
-0.0448132344,
-0.0515793078,
0.0864872113,
0.0121047655,
-0.0153423166,
-0.0352613442,
-0.0418028608,
-0.0400832146,
0.0811734945,
-0.0025127588,
-0.0079511469,
-0.0154360989,
-0.0118669411,
-0.0827006102,
-0.0349813327,
0.026125323,
-0.0268784631,
0.0362138078,
-0.0436344109,
-0.0018292014,
0.0009988523,
-0.0336066149,
-0.0474706851,
-0.0143111898,
-0.0290580411,
0.0195589066,
-0.0001365859,
-0.0016723173,
-0.0518058687,
0.0056279167,
0.0307477005,
0.0334876664,
0.007116125,
-0.0014373066,
-0.0283504426,
0.0163449198,
0.0653021708,
0.0581754111,
0.0191773903,
-0.0409195684,
0.0440524407,
0.0370245539,
0.0576420464,
-0.0230621453,
-0.0036731842,
0.0438043922,
0.0239321124,
-0.029780278,
0.0089092916,
0.0421241708,
0.0094653331,
-0.0761024207,
-0.0483661965,
0.1051916555,
0.0410056412,
-0.0368254818,
0.0141227087,
-0.0400238074,
0.0320793241,
0.0248551853,
0.0489410199,
-0.0566198416,
-0.0213032272,
0.0092278998,
0.013182872,
0.0111082839,
-0.0222353656,
-0.0168709494,
-0.1325613856,
0.0146126291,
0.0227948148,
-0.0155692343,
-0.0072583812,
-0.0310560577,
-0.0222010911,
-0.0118826292,
0.0373948216,
0.0330936871,
-0.0090866722,
-0.0333543979,
0.0087270038,
-0.0080441879,
-0.0385705903,
0.0360166095,
-0.0018923195,
0.066060558,
0.0434201173,
0.0222498216,
0.006077033,
-0.0360354483,
0.0333931372,
0.0203212667,
0.0147775887,
-0.0057744468,
0.0042314804,
-0.0069039348,
0.0120652942,
-0.002803453,
0.0541110188,
-0.0375974104,
-0.0256565046,
0.022322733,
0.1119486392,
-0.0350553654,
-0.0124492273,
-0.0076647713,
-0.0290396735,
0.002118035,
0.0633905083,
0.0333850347,
-0.0387542956,
-0.0691515952,
-0.001387521,
-0.0418312363,
-0.0401577801,
-0.0220801234,
-0.0016139685,
-0.0009015096,
0.0226390101,
-0.0275593791,
-0.0323690288,
0.0370335095,
0.0533844829,
-0.0180584025,
-0.0267593339,
0.0151319206,
0.0421961211,
-0.046115078,
0.0207119938,
-0.0373274162,
0.006137413,
-0.0320061073,
0.0144966589,
0.0058438773,
-0.0497798026,
-0.0248717051,
-0.0367000401,
-0.0942754298,
-0.0532083288,
-0.0010901531,
0.0470472164,
0.0342141911,
0.0448615365,
-0.0019668203,
-0.0613704547,
0.0371545181,
-0.0077987253,
-0.0737700835,
0.0230555907,
0.0402877554,
-0.0103462273,
0.0314038172,
0.0535234138,
-0.0311651099,
0.0232843813,
-0.0096219657,
0.0422658734,
-0.0277766678,
0.0199289415,
0.0303224567,
-0.0029059823,
-0.0238952562,
0.0085811773,
-0.0135717271,
-0.0296164025,
0.0608779155,
-0.0158523116,
-0.0111163836,
-0.0269129351,
0.0072094272,
0.0349861123,
0.0102465888,
0.0224513095,
-0.0038535236,
0.0003596468,
0.0407257602,
-0.009870111,
0.0177704729,
0.0442876294,
0.0251273103,
0.0360908471,
0.0060631041,
-0.0113889603,
0.0082996199,
-0.033470884,
0.0131087713,
0.0033275553,
0.0440465212,
0.0238045473,
0.0194023792,
-0.0700236261,
0.0119110718,
-0.0473224483,
-0.0614847168,
0.0177119989,
0.0093963081,
0.0543175712,
0.0202010162,
-0.0006438071,
-0.0232905746,
0.0003181234,
-0.0079394719,
-0.01381901,
-0.0098898336,
-0.0084775751,
0.0320569985,
0.0436895303,
0.0045293476,
-0.0194682125,
0.0932740122,
0.0155555392,
0.0519067794,
-0.0206960887,
0.0510525964,
-0.0405368656,
-0.0144539271,
-0.0323495828,
0.0540539734,
-0.0247199573,
-0.0121797668,
-0.0325635001,
-0.075626947,
-0.0163201559,
0.0414923579,
-0.0096991193,
-0.0081386892,
0.0265568532,
0.0431844033,
0.0091027217,
-0.0103392843,
-0.0066473694,
0.0054536499,
-0.0095690545,
-0.0321727432,
-0.0336485691,
-5.90894084e-33,
-0.0101694977,
-0.0248349961,
0.0628965944,
-0.0453727134,
-0.0245032292,
0.0105753308,
-0.0146275451,
0.0037468027,
-0.0093462802,
-0.0009782856,
-0.0392454714,
0.0392076559,
-0.0048722136,
0.0399914235,
0.0132391183,
-0.0223129448,
0.0177623089,
-0.0341456458,
-0.0369672291,
0.018799562,
0.0339116417,
-0.0126001732,
0.0355682075,
0.0017834534,
-0.0384506471,
0.0021423711,
-0.0328942537,
0.0679775104,
-0.0338207148,
0.0939143077,
-0.0234046746,
-0.0005471873,
0.0413162485,
-0.042969808,
-0.0147664342,
0.024737807,
-0.0795702562,
-0.0496510603,
0.0363010578,
-0.0221937336,
-0.0385954455,
-0.0241297595,
0.0189460237,
0.0042484873,
-0.0068498058,
-0.0014328792,
0.0038558156,
-0.0641498417,
-0.021829864,
0.0005167285,
-0.0141073838,
-0.0244685877,
-0.019319145,
-0.0152929071,
0.0432899892,
0.0200781152,
-0.0396807157,
-0.004429664,
0.0149953347,
0.0302684121,
0.0252969433,
0.0391730107,
0.071048446,
0.0046194512,
0.003465384,
0.0381917208,
-0.0158010889,
0.0069587394,
-0.0504418015,
-0.0233773533,
0.0568409078,
0.0845193267,
0.0152091729,
0.0040740119,
0.0172641929,
0.0003128376,
-0.0540075861,
0.0063492898,
0.0537786707,
0.0751029998,
0.041841656,
0.0071311146,
-0.0240678284,
-0.0024422714,
-0.0460396148,
-0.0095127262,
-0.0351342,
-0.0274484102,
0.0390746184,
0.0426534563,
-0.0243600979,
-0.0690388754,
0.0292889923,
-0.047927808,
0.0078849122,
0.0411643833,
-0.0103223287,
0.0162485167,
0.0089138793,
-0.0126987379,
-0.0644442961,
-0.056808982,
0.0027353808,
-0.015012797,
-0.0021123008,
-0.0016717594,
-0.0044100415,
0.0427049659,
-0.0703146756,
-0.0098708048,
-0.0407389477,
0.0401055589,
0.0051282486,
0.034700077,
0.069010675,
-0.0008258355,
-0.012602522,
0.0134104528,
-0.0132432235,
-0.061433401,
-0.0212017726,
0.0236250479,
0.0028737846,
0.054244332,
-0.0178992525,
-0.0094360597,
-0.0603462495,
-0.0030559688,
0.0456663631,
-0.0209892876,
0.0028952125,
0.0274759885,
2.495e-7,
-0.0189661477,
0.0357949883,
0.0151649211,
0.032022927,
0.0318187103,
0.0160672609,
-0.0314904749,
-0.0251036957,
-0.0100943185,
-0.0157857407,
0.0426916741,
0.0570560247,
0.0443741307,
0.0270408597,
-0.0490212142,
0.0258387048,
-0.0461630262,
-0.016626114,
-0.0704205632,
-0.0268412866,
0.0011287048,
0.1072448641,
0.0330150127,
-0.0305133872,
-0.0233914554,
-0.0047207251,
0.0207190961,
-0.0313692801,
0.0018455784,
-0.0303466115,
0.0157577954,
0.0348138288,
-0.0128359003,
0.0048447317,
0.0095175561,
0.0374511331,
-0.0379315168,
0.0933110565,
0.013652103,
-0.0387419648,
-0.021110611,
-0.0268761311,
-0.0045667049,
-0.033950258,
0.0713009834,
-0.0631075427,
-0.0129450476,
-0.0235855281,
0.0056525627,
-0.0167421158,
-0.0360994264,
-0.0258967225,
0.0205832943,
0.0229587741,
0.0085789701,
-0.0003223989,
0.0198671278,
-0.0901254565,
-0.0054765432,
0.0606004372,
-0.0286571495,
-0.0468778424,
-0.0485272333,
0.0076462533,
0.0408625826,
-0.0618475564,
-0.020204708,
2.501855366e-34,
0.0118929911,
-0.0028347033,
0.0230191555,
0.0696279258,
0.0015655585,
-0.0306787025,
-0.0026919614,
0.0165187065,
0.0424797274,
-0.095824711,
-0.0217546206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01391v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01391v2 | StepCoder: Improve Code Generation with Reinforcement Learning from Compiler Feedback | 2024-02-02T13:14:31 | 2024-02-05T13:28:23 | Shihan Dou, Yan Liu, Haoxiang Jia, Limao Xiong, Enyu Zhou, Wei Shen, Junjie Shan, Caishuang Huang, Xiao Wang, Xiaoran Fan, Zhiheng Xi, Yuhao Zhou, Tao Ji, Rui Zheng, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Tao Gui | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has significantly propelled
the field of code generation. Previous work integrated reinforcement learning
(RL) with compiler feedback for exploring the output space of LLMs to enhance
code generation quality. However, the lengthy code generated by LLMs in
response to complex human requirements makes RL exploration a challenge. Also,
since the unit tests may not cover the complicated code, optimizing LLMs by
using these unexecuted code snippets is ineffective. To tackle these
challenges, we introduce StepCoder, a novel RL framework for code generation,
consisting of two main components: CCCS addresses the exploration challenge by
breaking the long sequences code generation task into a Curriculum of Code
Completion Subtasks, while FGO only optimizes the model by masking the
unexecuted code segments to provide Fine-Grained Optimization. In addition, we
furthermore construct the APPS+ dataset for RL training, which is manually
verified to ensure the correctness of unit tests. Experimental results show
that our method improves the ability to explore the output space and
outperforms state-of-the-art approaches in corresponding benchmarks. Our
dataset APPS+ and StepCoder are available online. | [
0.0000116155,
0.0759380832,
-0.0261997953,
-0.0070111179,
-0.0103936633,
0.0024879405,
-0.0529934913,
0.001200566,
-0.0151469605,
0.0256645549,
0.0047209314,
0.0226513892,
0.001076777,
0.0319670998,
0.0260479841,
-0.0180589762,
-0.0017836532,
-0.0460651629,
-0.0531873927,
0.0075900592,
-0.0236444417,
0.0148723116,
0.0197991543,
0.0567800663,
0.0190886874,
-0.0240718964,
-0.0200387947,
0.0350110382,
-0.0127857253,
-0.0387424342,
0.030523831,
0.0464752652,
0.010646495,
0.0263773724,
0.0000024258,
-0.0384136885,
0.0060524903,
-0.0041611283,
0.0126105649,
0.0275178663,
-0.0053894534,
-0.0011044724,
-0.0062090373,
0.0317425244,
-0.0259366278,
-0.0395001397,
0.0298459921,
-0.0263704509,
0.0535309985,
0.0813153982,
0.032592576,
-0.0077702906,
-0.008522463,
-0.0199936219,
0.0597263314,
0.0015968066,
-0.0088095665,
0.0343350843,
0.0520024858,
-0.032463599,
-0.0217588842,
-0.0166959725,
0.0580709949,
-0.0113483984,
-0.0375579782,
0.0740389153,
-0.0102505377,
-0.0150667699,
0.0021472769,
0.0251717921,
-0.0905212611,
-0.0298913531,
0.0384172052,
-0.0139642982,
-0.027109718,
-0.0363016874,
-0.0063040871,
0.0359985232,
-0.033489082,
0.0025866441,
0.0079168491,
-0.0353123993,
0.002305618,
0.0017419693,
-0.0336656235,
0.0294930097,
-0.0049391473,
-0.0280213617,
-0.0289564859,
0.0052160276,
0.0409879386,
-0.0478910133,
-0.0514682047,
0.0416203104,
-0.068382524,
-0.0007260701,
-0.0578690358,
-0.0047426606,
0.0184245296,
-0.0169581883,
0.0404784046,
0.0284818187,
-0.0038963312,
-0.0062336479,
-0.0745176971,
0.052233085,
-0.0130270915,
-0.0175571982,
-0.0431648791,
0.0451801829,
-0.0350862555,
0.0253957678,
-0.0308031682,
0.0484187268,
-0.0070288903,
0.0265545454,
-0.0626142323,
0.0332359113,
0.0117970547,
0.0970205069,
0.0057687215,
-0.0136119602,
-0.037452396,
0.0209700987,
0.0304764528,
-0.020048121,
-0.0380172916,
-0.0699716806,
0.0193015467,
-0.0607769117,
-0.0050829872,
0.0184831582,
-0.0301634595,
-0.0301171541,
0.0187143534,
0.0673956499,
-0.0025010929,
0.0075558,
-0.0204071682,
-0.0422999635,
0.0189227555,
-0.0620870367,
0.000695273,
-0.1023580357,
-0.0401511565,
0.0034061754,
-0.033403527,
-0.0215393547,
0.0177264921,
0.0011825727,
0.0312230811,
0.0078954529,
-0.0213988516,
0.0107050138,
0.0049108109,
0.0118879909,
-0.0103790425,
0.0662083179,
0.0483315848,
0.0418811403,
-0.0200545788,
-0.0265439954,
0.0419201665,
0.0408872515,
0.012353058,
0.0123829255,
-0.0025241096,
0.0271395817,
0.0066392054,
0.0154709062,
0.0368362963,
0.0153465364,
-0.0179697201,
0.0215751436,
-0.0149626862,
0.0157146603,
0.0112921344,
0.0384265296,
0.0784678534,
0.0311515387,
-0.0143013289,
-0.0034046459,
-0.0193587188,
0.0506109297,
0.0119814891,
0.0389271639,
0.0026010296,
0.066234,
-0.0074792812,
-0.0605801009,
0.0206269808,
-0.0073735323,
0.0113204988,
0.0355680138,
0.0346689783,
0.0013561745,
-0.0778951421,
-0.0200196691,
0.0195841696,
-0.0725245997,
-0.0297732148,
-0.0526592694,
0.0864206105,
0.0376983583,
0.0403468907,
-0.0343833826,
-0.0128327673,
-0.032949321,
-0.005582687,
0.0046217344,
0.0217220634,
0.0020326274,
0.0051817298,
-0.0555616096,
-0.0235984437,
-0.0260059107,
-0.0086161317,
0.0669388324,
0.0685568452,
-0.033076968,
0.0308109969,
0.0141452709,
-0.0912181586,
0.0334068276,
-0.0214610677,
-0.0053608553,
0.0498982742,
-0.0232045501,
0.021095952,
-0.0456549674,
-0.04773679,
0.0034013249,
0.0337256677,
-0.0185705461,
-0.0166277532,
-0.0347485058,
-0.0493842214,
-0.0684528202,
-0.0066034039,
-0.0415563099,
-0.0475991294,
0.0049104132,
-0.0564604104,
-0.0043985806,
0.0301895402,
-0.0199443027,
0.0259616375,
0.0137973502,
0.0127536161,
-0.0138839828,
0.0145673584,
-0.018277403,
0.046629671,
-0.0287322868,
0.0255369712,
-0.0104204062,
0.0635016337,
-0.0009925293,
0.0155787356,
0.0199186783,
0.0109542664,
-0.0357066691,
0.0265978742,
0.0193336066,
0.0778333545,
-0.0159146376,
-0.0529190376,
-0.0588454492,
0.0432346128,
-0.0227292702,
0.0226482283,
0.0046108351,
0.0475923531,
-0.0019304913,
-0.0003536649,
-0.0029825694,
-0.0115406998,
0.0350091755,
0.0010978611,
-0.0034885181,
-0.0226518419,
-0.0421922654,
-0.0211512949,
-0.0132686393,
-0.0113734407,
0.0338648967,
-0.0416524522,
0.0391809605,
-0.0686780512,
0.0497474633,
0.0336227827,
0.0189914778,
-0.0245821793,
-0.0454843678,
0.0151151521,
-0.0582444966,
0.0570609234,
0.051627025,
-0.0049696662,
0.032947816,
0.0252145361,
-0.0012631901,
-0.0641338229,
0.0380281098,
0.0078467671,
-0.0569202416,
-0.0188964326,
-0.0321455598,
0.0557790622,
0.0659198314,
0.0004928453,
-0.0123773748,
-0.0601165742,
0.0339808613,
0.0121894274,
-0.0133432373,
0.0375399739,
0.0040992587,
-0.0236502588,
0.0477185883,
-0.0404736772,
-0.0836899057,
0.0638668761,
-0.0224413257,
-0.0124926511,
-0.0264471062,
-0.0286898371,
-0.0610872656,
0.0091949804,
0.0197851285,
0.0287555289,
-0.019091567,
-0.0278242454,
-0.0075082169,
-0.0008668615,
-0.0169463661,
-0.0328763425,
0.0654814392,
-0.0184602942,
-0.0033991227,
0.0008668259,
-0.0349148624,
-0.0472094677,
0.0365388319,
0.0084989229,
-0.0158891939,
0.0191578325,
-0.0231360123,
0.0442951098,
-0.0086498549,
0.0121513549,
0.0578712225,
-0.0027639233,
-0.0407872349,
0.0005890638,
-0.0256481431,
-0.0054470268,
-0.0527552627,
-0.001209294,
-0.0367435887,
-0.0083820429,
0.0053933798,
0.0670522749,
0.0635696948,
-0.0690141097,
0.0171371512,
0.0355129875,
-0.0176158138,
-0.001108003,
0.081186071,
0.0573655814,
-0.0713677481,
-0.0536492355,
0.0893492401,
0.0204023086,
-0.0457319915,
0.0099830823,
0.000716625,
0.1009443104,
0.0667712688,
0.0682935119,
-0.0708172023,
-0.0109503772,
-0.0025357145,
0.0350713097,
-0.0192597471,
-0.0033858619,
-0.0179154165,
-0.1322353482,
0.0381953791,
0.0145054879,
-0.0195050091,
-0.0322396271,
-0.0206944365,
-0.0344025381,
0.020690918,
-0.0438906141,
0.0574847981,
-0.0108570363,
0.0276445877,
0.0056554652,
-0.0312261898,
-0.0115879858,
0.025017567,
-0.0329991169,
0.0270710252,
0.1405014545,
-0.0016320893,
0.0036812604,
0.0114459135,
0.0170777254,
0.012089109,
0.005849618,
-0.0410577878,
0.0120751783,
0.0152870463,
-0.0091002155,
0.046796158,
0.0359362848,
-0.0366781615,
-0.0140368268,
0.0726320446,
0.0443771109,
0.0144251212,
-0.0400325209,
-0.0150068924,
-0.0090413885,
0.0086638983,
0.0239520445,
0.0302726403,
-0.0397045948,
-0.0556706861,
-0.0666364208,
-0.025728913,
-0.0761718005,
0.0135737304,
-0.0149169695,
-0.0016054407,
0.0175126083,
-0.0262723453,
0.0014730564,
0.0068072192,
0.0242034271,
0.0039515616,
-0.0445231684,
0.0024279186,
-0.0156297218,
-0.0741841421,
-0.0002713087,
-0.0204703975,
0.0180788413,
-0.0331168957,
-0.0073461193,
-0.0176275317,
-0.0354833268,
0.0125640482,
0.0257265605,
-0.0743795931,
-0.0655002072,
-0.0587024093,
0.0938617513,
0.0096772341,
0.0697405413,
-0.0312203094,
-0.0371939056,
0.0085410485,
-0.0189386215,
-0.0216575153,
0.0091654258,
0.022504054,
0.0060817655,
0.0183989685,
-0.0186993685,
-0.0661402792,
0.0044798786,
0.0272298213,
-0.0045870845,
0.0152613977,
0.0121131372,
0.0362039171,
-0.0376253165,
-0.0075473054,
-0.0053801602,
-0.0117987962,
0.0120420642,
-0.0008082123,
0.0066336333,
-0.0209327042,
-0.0351521149,
0.0245832521,
0.0244733114,
-0.0114654554,
0.045913998,
-0.0095653748,
-0.0099545745,
0.072188817,
-0.0151107097,
0.0612306073,
-0.0105422456,
0.0340526663,
0.1169488356,
-0.0053460738,
-0.0053971163,
0.0346031338,
0.009937318,
0.0225984287,
0.0146473804,
0.068432726,
0.0248065367,
0.0549773499,
0.0406205282,
-0.0120403022,
-0.0155306375,
-0.0463366397,
-0.0397546068,
0.0174136665,
0.0389043391,
0.0489174053,
0.0226935353,
-0.0256795213,
0.0278383065,
-0.0113194864,
0.0349843502,
-0.0452004336,
-0.0526078492,
0.0200768411,
0.0270693507,
-0.0077788089,
-0.049432192,
0.1002105027,
0.0198780168,
0.0097828498,
-0.0074096303,
0.0159218907,
-0.0382126905,
-0.0049837423,
0.0402887762,
-0.0072190207,
0.0037290417,
-0.0118932677,
0.0001567887,
-0.0417889953,
-0.0122569278,
0.0639909282,
0.0360861942,
0.0009155485,
0.0371471941,
0.0489509068,
-0.0129107675,
-0.0049158935,
-0.0350193717,
-0.0140931197,
-0.0019418859,
-0.0694803745,
-0.0088031879,
-6.369952459e-33,
-0.0166645832,
-0.0196228288,
0.02377267,
0.0082798852,
-0.0155827375,
-0.0229323059,
-0.0517696701,
-0.0179398078,
0.0456605442,
-0.0371057242,
0.0292691961,
0.0155427726,
-0.0210245699,
0.0180199035,
0.0480461009,
0.0280514881,
0.0683255643,
0.0205383468,
-0.0641482472,
0.0423548482,
-0.0732747391,
0.0356647782,
-0.0255844314,
-0.0249368753,
-0.0654247776,
0.0016023889,
0.0291338507,
0.0002994803,
-0.0071477587,
0.0382894985,
0.0267513897,
-0.0027789089,
-0.0169643555,
-0.0488334969,
-0.0415442586,
0.0009595222,
-0.0437825508,
-0.040157374,
-0.0014221456,
0.0113234865,
-0.0299105085,
-0.0739670992,
0.0532771498,
0.0064720302,
-0.0117172319,
0.000770736,
0.0057650474,
0.0162661597,
-0.0102039622,
-0.0466486923,
-0.0552805439,
0.0298394673,
-0.0278189965,
-0.0248190518,
-0.0065385094,
0.0378265344,
-0.0260318313,
0.012786421,
0.0339324549,
0.0076563456,
0.0308715962,
0.0716604218,
0.0668947548,
0.0403859653,
0.0256266389,
-0.0131612755,
0.0411651582,
0.0055037402,
-0.0277979746,
0.0137513708,
0.0405034125,
0.0320983455,
-0.0108644012,
0.0296711046,
0.0047581424,
-0.0089377444,
-0.0179792177,
-0.0004319305,
0.0102543486,
0.0386494324,
0.0483089946,
0.0081705116,
-0.0214345772,
-0.0163864382,
-0.0600022227,
-0.002457222,
-0.0121671939,
-0.0560485683,
0.0549685173,
0.0271818936,
-0.0248853639,
-0.0265167635,
0.0186914541,
-0.0148683852,
-0.0049077189,
0.0347529948,
-0.076380156,
0.0211828183,
-0.0287446305,
-0.0013645543,
-0.0118002249,
-0.0396590196,
0.0210530497,
-0.0486422405,
0.0585929193,
0.0315501317,
0.0216729585,
0.0087795677,
-0.0678474978,
0.0190332774,
-0.078960672,
0.0327629633,
-0.0120569216,
0.028330192,
0.0108188568,
-0.0129698385,
-0.0046541244,
0.0503179878,
-0.00603814,
-0.0394377261,
-0.0421424061,
-0.0122049432,
0.0153633012,
0.0260481499,
-0.0400679372,
-0.0222943444,
-0.058313679,
0.0408789665,
0.0139758065,
-0.0498803072,
-0.061538551,
0.0356405079,
3.031e-7,
-0.054879304,
0.0451574065,
0.0122596566,
0.0544849597,
-0.0005186836,
0.0362498686,
-0.0091807107,
-0.0014608362,
0.0203963742,
0.0050225486,
-0.0265006423,
0.0047878954,
0.0461248457,
0.0075867479,
-0.0497419089,
0.0263340101,
-0.0187040437,
0.0187435243,
-0.0715497285,
-0.0174831171,
-0.0067266566,
0.0587117001,
-0.0001761583,
0.0155810965,
0.0554418005,
0.0243645888,
0.0091465069,
-0.0104438458,
-0.0050443057,
0.0114642968,
-0.0818830803,
0.0287518036,
-0.0135319727,
-0.0348267481,
-0.0117336567,
-0.0061053624,
-0.0154620213,
0.0540178083,
0.0229659956,
0.0423951596,
0.077919133,
0.0069190608,
-0.0088137146,
-0.0587151051,
0.0358228758,
-0.0561226867,
0.0221877359,
-0.0384180509,
0.0028521419,
-0.0177584179,
-0.0210457109,
-0.0348070934,
0.0361403413,
-0.0146054048,
0.0019963803,
-0.0127873467,
-0.0380791612,
-0.0147603741,
-0.0448877029,
0.0264266618,
-0.0137042757,
-0.0199259166,
-0.070612058,
0.0617707223,
-0.0378631018,
-0.037817359,
-0.0059546405,
3.10930952e-34,
0.009027713,
-0.0437444933,
0.0100041386,
0.007722483,
0.0434860177,
-0.0283067543,
-0.0348850675,
0.054749351,
0.0363583043,
0.0049050902,
-0.0446162932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01383v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01383v2 | LLM-based NLG Evaluation: Current Status and Challenges | 2024-02-02T13:06:35 | 2024-02-26T14:55:48 | Mingqi Gao, Xinyu Hu, Jie Ruan, Xiao Pu, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluating natural language generation (NLG) is a vital but challenging
problem in artificial intelligence. Traditional evaluation metrics mainly
capturing content (e.g. n-gram) overlap between system outputs and references
are far from satisfactory, and large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT
have demonstrated great potential in NLG evaluation in recent years. Various
automatic evaluation methods based on LLMs have been proposed, including
metrics derived from LLMs, prompting LLMs, and fine-tuning LLMs with labeled
evaluation data. In this survey, we first give a taxonomy of LLM-based NLG
evaluation methods, and discuss their pros and cons, respectively. We also
discuss human-LLM collaboration for NLG evaluation. Lastly, we discuss several
open problems in this area and point out future research directions. | [
0.0334375948,
0.0217239819,
0.0070879264,
0.025633933,
-0.0640479922,
-0.0014772054,
-0.0068281339,
0.0027227639,
0.0284797922,
-0.074274987,
-0.0398849584,
-0.0496460162,
0.0152008897,
0.0080925049,
0.0270865466,
-0.0069424487,
0.011204714,
-0.0010469524,
0.0069097052,
0.0293043461,
-0.0096447263,
0.0252453834,
0.0008211501,
0.0600895882,
-0.0023372481,
0.0105707906,
0.0161788687,
0.0160651617,
0.0276760049,
-0.0554202236,
-0.0103031565,
0.0212520398,
-0.0299208425,
0.0187431946,
0.0000018838,
-0.0681776628,
-0.0033172271,
-0.0041874377,
0.0063254749,
0.0397565104,
0.0762783438,
0.0209090095,
0.0034243546,
0.0298511274,
-0.0460533984,
0.0207879134,
0.0005525024,
0.0317730121,
0.0688478425,
0.0651407763,
0.0149162551,
0.0134200146,
-0.007407519,
-0.0168543532,
0.0167752355,
-0.0329098552,
-0.0039016414,
0.0395422801,
0.0199560896,
0.0110386852,
0.0274387375,
0.0254606102,
-0.0001663632,
-0.0172732808,
0.0106118983,
0.0283029489,
-0.048738081,
-0.0210083388,
-0.0162984617,
0.054045964,
-0.0087441299,
-0.0174712725,
0.0284499079,
-0.0173881985,
0.0238524191,
-0.0134949749,
-0.0309597813,
0.0421073847,
-0.0030389675,
0.0301278345,
0.0349740349,
0.0330221727,
0.0278482791,
0.0370499417,
0.0361527503,
0.0566646457,
0.0284680594,
-0.0041296859,
-0.013512996,
0.0160841774,
-0.0028729732,
-0.0591942184,
-0.0039428696,
0.0304805748,
-0.0460333303,
0.0157311875,
-0.039845176,
0.0110571347,
0.0577218235,
-0.0423444584,
0.0439418033,
0.0222023875,
0.0077442736,
0.0055168075,
-0.0354352035,
0.0584963113,
0.013786098,
-0.0163202863,
-0.0605291501,
0.0305625461,
-0.0575348996,
-0.0120549109,
-0.0451047607,
0.0371009074,
-0.0326695293,
-0.0453503802,
-0.0709910467,
0.0143512683,
-0.0029130836,
-0.0192272868,
0.0193462521,
0.008774953,
-0.0296749957,
0.0201558322,
-0.0316713341,
-0.0162974745,
-0.0076490422,
0.0117851766,
0.0353490897,
-0.0408669338,
0.0080053061,
0.0511589535,
-0.006180021,
0.0046785404,
-0.0072191381,
0.1048588157,
0.0023199648,
-0.014404879,
-0.0431670956,
-0.0624903701,
-0.0427456237,
-0.0619296953,
-0.0047311024,
-0.0676030964,
0.010895934,
-0.0023609886,
-0.0201832168,
-0.0170243587,
0.0226187967,
0.0350218192,
0.0011388938,
0.0207262989,
-0.001951253,
0.0140933646,
0.0419520363,
0.0116973966,
0.0098539246,
0.0548722111,
0.0528402962,
0.0420739576,
0.0341599509,
0.018115174,
0.0200866796,
0.0465250202,
-0.0046757101,
-0.0150413597,
0.0199426357,
-0.0352548026,
-0.027520204,
0.0380019769,
0.0248249471,
0.0857042298,
-0.0320394188,
0.0100493757,
0.0282718632,
0.0238091704,
0.0110404221,
0.0119744912,
0.102150403,
0.0365395024,
0.016192168,
0.0339952484,
0.0044740853,
0.014836791,
-0.0488112047,
0.0210607816,
0.055135183,
0.042999018,
0.004169927,
-0.0675279871,
-0.0322393663,
0.0084785055,
0.0089957556,
-0.0447268374,
0.008401881,
0.0209338013,
-0.0636241063,
0.0619534478,
-0.0000812612,
-0.0625014827,
0.0363223366,
-0.0582219064,
0.0090803811,
0.0461916775,
0.0779149979,
0.0307683237,
-0.0350393616,
0.0198717434,
-0.0138229076,
0.0726523027,
0.0225358307,
0.0033975251,
-0.009769652,
-0.0389764123,
-0.0057018599,
-0.0093220007,
0.0216263589,
0.0086831488,
0.0110382289,
-0.0033890484,
0.0548555478,
-0.0278399754,
-0.0650654659,
0.0475542843,
-0.0257035512,
-0.0090977829,
0.0238239281,
-0.0384246781,
0.0460243672,
0.0182558484,
-0.0246806145,
0.0605208054,
0.0210116003,
-0.0255557466,
-0.0299775098,
0.0258491691,
-0.0254856534,
-0.0445551425,
0.0262203123,
-0.0618618689,
0.0278881937,
-0.0172523297,
-0.0391996503,
-0.0422860719,
0.0009791459,
-0.0644792989,
0.0135387303,
-0.0597220622,
0.0382331051,
0.0454567298,
-0.0095927343,
-0.0568152815,
0.0577940345,
-0.0029282854,
0.0234763734,
0.034577366,
0.0313959345,
0.0489451922,
-0.036187578,
-0.031177992,
0.0002013323,
-0.0178281367,
0.0076269116,
0.0400041416,
0.0661005676,
-0.0667279959,
-0.0789269507,
-0.088102974,
0.0201140735,
-0.0085315807,
0.0494468398,
0.0232857745,
-0.02951774,
-0.0097184284,
0.0240560081,
-0.0419530272,
-0.0015699847,
0.0774050727,
-0.0178256501,
0.0501382463,
0.005623321,
-0.0273673981,
-0.038077414,
0.0323883556,
0.0170713644,
0.0308939442,
0.0513136461,
-0.0072699273,
-0.0750407353,
0.0377125628,
-0.0612933673,
-0.0523812398,
0.0111682899,
-0.0647152886,
0.0249941256,
0.0275311358,
0.0314844251,
-0.0030559686,
0.0400943309,
0.0067503103,
0.0249154102,
-0.0071233977,
-0.0347241946,
-0.03064196,
-0.0338383503,
-0.031099705,
0.025527332,
-0.0338745564,
0.0326306112,
0.0519364588,
0.013731733,
0.0032948416,
-0.0398005433,
0.0312509276,
-0.0442337468,
-0.0362268761,
-0.0303609446,
-0.020008821,
-0.0285680108,
0.0333403386,
-0.0182247479,
-0.07261011,
0.0386978388,
-0.0795442462,
0.0146347228,
-0.0432261862,
-0.0044809179,
-0.0513005443,
0.0412448645,
0.0023464733,
0.0253773313,
-0.0112930536,
0.0001597009,
-0.052169688,
0.0242269319,
-0.0057998337,
-0.0512199029,
0.025851246,
-0.0681319386,
-0.0013317434,
0.0156465918,
0.0094655035,
-0.061812453,
-0.0226713475,
-0.008660526,
0.0008545127,
0.0400262289,
0.0153318718,
-0.0119437268,
0.0188043918,
-0.0074007912,
-0.0243619885,
-0.0026466602,
-0.0107709337,
-0.0023767566,
0.0494527854,
0.0617813691,
0.0211568214,
0.0028426868,
0.0098684113,
-0.0022297348,
0.0307927374,
-0.002371609,
0.0514210984,
-0.0062475242,
-0.0005349366,
0.006536162,
-0.0199713465,
-0.0238590389,
0.0348459259,
0.0284634382,
-0.0406317972,
-0.0369087048,
0.1251870841,
0.0427841805,
0.0029060412,
0.0120496033,
-0.0211637672,
0.0593776293,
-0.0139294714,
0.0163656026,
-0.067822732,
-0.0236059688,
-0.0118703665,
0.024351133,
-0.021876948,
-0.0007101082,
-0.027922485,
-0.1272988468,
0.035761103,
0.0388214178,
-0.0290674232,
0.0058508879,
-0.0047722063,
-0.0374724418,
-0.0147602977,
-0.0151893366,
-0.0000232914,
-0.0277670473,
0.0325463191,
0.0277928319,
-0.0689689144,
-0.0588064864,
-0.0105602033,
-0.0268327799,
0.0731085539,
0.0487475805,
0.0352632031,
0.0303521641,
-0.0267028138,
0.0501142032,
-0.0348129943,
0.02137761,
-0.0198965557,
0.0110242255,
-0.0065843128,
0.0096849045,
-0.0316668078,
0.0093671093,
-0.020919783,
-0.0054814126,
0.00603772,
0.0436357111,
-0.0309986062,
-0.0055336459,
-0.0146165984,
0.0661953539,
0.0325549729,
0.1064547002,
0.0461212732,
-0.0333367959,
-0.0277350005,
-0.0244501401,
0.0161699858,
-0.0520633161,
-0.0302292481,
0.0216765236,
-0.0207901001,
0.0122034559,
-0.1218002886,
-0.0388444066,
-0.0220894553,
-0.0151034975,
0.0003382681,
0.0106590092,
-0.015647769,
-0.0082134577,
-0.0124753043,
0.0171472412,
-0.0168442558,
-0.0102004027,
-0.0714792237,
-0.0060621463,
0.0277402848,
-0.0473004468,
-0.0254945569,
0.0909026861,
-0.0804704279,
-0.057084281,
-0.0188380927,
0.0266979784,
0.0260739718,
-0.0129216472,
-0.0088558197,
-0.0194102284,
0.024096759,
0.0832807422,
-0.0145468498,
0.0411577933,
-0.0146383289,
0.0373664312,
-0.0237634964,
0.0107954312,
-0.0483373925,
0.0166902728,
-0.0255881753,
0.0705946311,
0.0032324081,
-0.060076084,
0.0044214176,
0.0563383698,
0.0155572882,
-0.0864391029,
0.0025162385,
-0.0070916503,
-0.0556248017,
-0.0120363692,
-0.0212456249,
-0.064828828,
-0.0072223064,
0.011450706,
-0.000937533,
-0.0255828183,
-0.007585085,
-0.0564080961,
0.0595704503,
0.0005942323,
-0.0127460174,
-0.0113367066,
-0.0027411776,
-0.0253712106,
-0.0144167859,
-0.0130641824,
-0.0078802817,
-0.0376099832,
0.0107737677,
-0.0190554447,
0.0551344417,
0.0093591893,
0.0204461385,
0.0143413274,
0.0597594492,
-0.022708267,
0.0138284918,
-0.0597888716,
0.0436383672,
0.0774872005,
0.0124511151,
0.1054469496,
-0.0453203581,
0.0106595829,
-0.0214221012,
0.0721213743,
0.0097750239,
-0.03745896,
0.0114751244,
-0.0003443149,
-0.0431666672,
-0.0130155263,
0.0753175169,
0.0196138714,
0.0105177555,
-0.0016347659,
-0.0265176222,
-0.0509713553,
-0.0352891013,
-0.0350330919,
-0.0221532956,
0.0054953708,
0.0038269232,
-0.0780382231,
-0.0474412888,
0.0073221899,
0.0519406572,
0.0310459901,
-0.0096366853,
0.0598636717,
0.0373251736,
-0.0300129764,
0.0290936492,
-0.0397633687,
-0.0223893411,
-0.0477539487,
-0.0017248518,
-0.0284588933,
-6.15356599e-33,
-0.0560345724,
-0.0870670676,
0.0319180302,
0.0084489891,
-0.05926954,
0.0072048926,
-0.0353803448,
0.0220530182,
0.0480053611,
-0.0005705437,
0.0260006059,
-0.0430627204,
0.0073268623,
0.0099945869,
-0.0100147817,
-0.0177400913,
0.0240005497,
-0.0156026753,
-0.0585613512,
0.0168658514,
0.0182265919,
0.0009486133,
0.0093763489,
-0.0603500083,
0.0175635107,
-0.0163219683,
-0.0422348715,
-0.0187479202,
0.0232814495,
0.071581848,
-0.0413021334,
0.0256782323,
0.0319961943,
-0.0278556645,
-0.0096594021,
0.0032325624,
-0.0206988733,
-0.0345036536,
0.0116518848,
-0.0262350067,
-0.0179607272,
-0.034115728,
0.0430877246,
-0.0170888547,
-0.0676307678,
0.0255595651,
0.0160356294,
-0.0362768993,
-0.0140385581,
-0.0254710503,
-0.0486587808,
0.0350119062,
0.0058240015,
-0.0247341003,
-0.0213972125,
0.034614075,
-0.03519186,
0.0089100767,
-0.016129829,
0.0306748413,
0.0064494647,
0.0267276708,
0.0812157094,
-0.0015881321,
-0.0258057099,
0.0705571026,
-0.0234478507,
-0.0130419303,
-0.0429122597,
-0.0218836498,
0.0000485164,
0.0452760831,
0.0558717251,
0.0521895662,
0.0161964726,
0.0246461108,
-0.0467827134,
0.0820464939,
0.005574178,
0.0110970242,
0.0086606545,
-0.0253789499,
-0.0120188259,
-0.0079492461,
-0.0418220125,
-0.0093205096,
-0.0137456795,
-0.0382388681,
0.0629659444,
0.0098786205,
-0.0245825704,
-0.041821707,
0.0200239103,
-0.0042335549,
0.0138222873,
0.0213821642,
-0.0447885506,
0.0025214867,
-0.0199082103,
-0.0186396018,
-0.0393568315,
-0.0335441381,
0.0416478552,
0.0423578955,
0.0182714798,
-0.0362424701,
0.0138696441,
-0.0016383993,
-0.0355217606,
0.0523753464,
-0.0350443497,
0.0388119295,
-0.0062758676,
-0.0336411037,
0.0187056307,
-0.0435956419,
-0.03806407,
0.0183116365,
0.0071182591,
0.0130302208,
0.0179353803,
-0.0223787334,
0.0020139297,
0.0065039839,
-0.0466848128,
0.0575069077,
0.0077354205,
0.004656944,
0.0085838912,
-0.0007962142,
-0.0118368231,
0.0069416822,
2.578e-7,
0.0362675786,
0.0469166748,
0.0297914278,
0.039695438,
-0.0028084267,
-0.0033242824,
-0.0072972723,
0.007309691,
0.0054548555,
0.0070410757,
-0.0030903332,
-0.0031337577,
0.0722937584,
-0.0076576681,
-0.0607079677,
-0.0092977714,
-0.0754720718,
0.0015627755,
-0.0274822395,
-0.0212244503,
0.0753926858,
0.0369135439,
-0.0302352011,
-0.0112620806,
-0.031002244,
-0.0767958239,
0.0719431788,
-0.0478463881,
-0.0386886001,
0.0267701596,
0.0973709673,
0.0269867387,
-0.0006661282,
-0.0074713072,
-0.0070506507,
-0.0112783937,
0.0404347032,
0.0518821776,
0.0480115563,
-0.0280247238,
0.0223994777,
0.0131700831,
0.0112271346,
-0.0440936573,
0.042966567,
-0.0476382188,
-0.0061558676,
-0.0305672698,
-0.0129633583,
-0.0145968618,
0.0081467517,
-0.0307828113,
-0.0383309163,
0.032220047,
0.0191134904,
0.0035709075,
-0.0134579195,
-0.0294609517,
-0.0402645469,
-0.0171058774,
-0.0407313854,
-0.0361893885,
-0.0330069996,
0.0394446924,
0.005118324,
-0.0660571977,
-0.0108870547,
2.263830846e-34,
0.042114187,
-0.0385680348,
0.0169543549,
-0.0062147668,
0.0541784689,
0.0420809165,
-0.0211164169,
0.0170847401,
-0.008784703,
-0.0816833675,
0.0145655656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01376v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01376v2 | LoTR: Low Tensor Rank Weight Adaptation | 2024-02-02T13:00:38 | 2024-02-05T12:42:52 | Daniel Bershatsky, Daria Cherniuk, Talgat Daulbaev, Aleksandr Mikhalev, Ivan Oseledets | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper we generalize and extend an idea of low-rank adaptation (LoRA)
of large language models (LLMs) based on Transformer architecture. Widely used
LoRA-like methods of fine-tuning LLMs are based on matrix factorization of
gradient update. We introduce LoTR, a novel approach for parameter-efficient
fine-tuning of LLMs which represents a gradient update to parameters in a form
of tensor decomposition. Low-rank adapter for each layer is constructed as a
product of three matrices, and tensor structure arises from sharing left and
right multipliers of this product among layers. Simultaneous compression of a
sequence of layers with low-rank tensor representation allows LoTR to archive
even better parameter efficiency then LoRA especially for deep models.
Moreover, the core tensor does not depend on original weight dimension and can
be made arbitrary small, which allows for extremely cheap and fast downstream
fine-tuning. | [
0.0135504156,
0.0581069589,
-0.0153174317,
0.0564309284,
0.0266633593,
0.0431350395,
0.0141161662,
0.0223363247,
-0.0212311801,
-0.0297000259,
-0.0579737164,
-0.031276308,
0.0186145082,
-0.0309404712,
0.0139351776,
-0.0361202285,
0.0051834928,
-0.047640644,
-0.0227016304,
-0.0152715305,
-0.0257257521,
0.0240517631,
0.00761976,
-0.0034941768,
0.0644411817,
0.0095924251,
-0.0151361143,
0.0015349049,
0.01849561,
0.0559696741,
0.016441118,
0.036119815,
0.0336481147,
0.0348025486,
0.0000019582,
0.0214574262,
-0.0145187443,
-0.0138126463,
0.0027642306,
0.0247496888,
0.0487671457,
-0.024773987,
-0.0479867868,
0.0006672092,
-0.017529631,
-0.0326873288,
0.050681591,
0.0195256341,
0.0688496158,
0.0702533945,
-0.0273986366,
-0.0430877991,
0.0092325127,
-0.0322567523,
-0.0562093891,
-0.0466691777,
0.0177486595,
-0.0283477865,
-0.0516325347,
-0.0129906125,
-0.038772542,
0.0054510906,
-0.0001197207,
0.0065138694,
-0.0152666047,
-0.0001372241,
-0.0445078909,
-0.0176809952,
0.0013842372,
0.0682266206,
-0.0669308603,
0.0052355975,
0.0082502738,
-0.0180266388,
0.003833493,
-0.0549178459,
-0.0219977349,
0.0027409352,
0.051417388,
0.021521179,
0.0084150303,
-0.0325719267,
0.0173871294,
0.0184064377,
-0.057478562,
-0.0085715717,
0.0528949313,
0.0055733598,
-0.0680723935,
-0.0086676935,
0.0030736583,
0.0066049434,
0.0204013009,
0.0240838453,
-0.0265672412,
-0.0148260053,
-0.0753224269,
-0.0910326615,
-0.0115050962,
-0.053606607,
0.0785702765,
0.0567129813,
-0.0183156058,
0.048856739,
-0.0799067318,
0.0559309721,
-0.0427727401,
-0.0092126289,
-0.0349069014,
-0.0216134004,
0.0307987146,
0.0303190723,
-0.0333572142,
0.0099828439,
-0.057467375,
-0.0132780895,
-0.0226967391,
0.0488257036,
0.0012825284,
-0.027819084,
0.0212850627,
0.0030787624,
-0.0263812933,
-0.0491434261,
0.0050127776,
0.0637765974,
0.0213280823,
0.0226311479,
-0.0463268943,
-0.0238610189,
-0.0099285636,
0.0218294188,
0.0768941119,
-0.0066685905,
0.0591269583,
0.0367143042,
-0.0381706581,
-0.0436668172,
-0.0141283739,
0.053149946,
0.0270501543,
-0.042827934,
0.0117195891,
-0.0208039209,
0.0387586802,
-0.0116632367,
0.0285006836,
-0.0336918905,
-0.018846387,
0.0140076922,
-0.0744656697,
0.0302887838,
0.0224369951,
-0.010150169,
0.0262919627,
-0.0017647307,
0.0201483909,
0.0414519273,
0.0369217284,
0.0320745595,
-0.0110519752,
-0.0513737537,
-0.036804568,
0.0436875373,
0.0014285611,
0.0402591042,
-0.0108435899,
-0.0214986578,
-0.018417513,
0.0129919611,
0.0608979054,
0.0749595389,
-0.0248987321,
-0.0070728511,
0.0541839674,
0.0323213674,
0.0759193599,
0.074972339,
0.0045102262,
-0.0415702872,
-0.0210213307,
0.0084018558,
-0.0129002342,
0.0606927611,
-0.0076984735,
-0.0262148697,
0.0370784476,
0.0831106082,
-0.0439587831,
0.0027996895,
-0.001123426,
-0.001370461,
0.0259568803,
0.0038202421,
0.0342535935,
0.0073839682,
-0.0500156619,
0.0664350837,
0.0182840172,
-0.0429186039,
0.0116033172,
-0.0523471087,
-0.0055939001,
0.0370968431,
0.0209946856,
0.0084717646,
-0.0119844349,
-0.0048073656,
0.0131469416,
0.0031323067,
0.0197837427,
0.0186704285,
0.0524104983,
-0.0744837597,
0.0110995285,
0.0311808381,
-0.0045741005,
0.0061673019,
-0.0268468652,
0.0173765626,
0.0220719054,
0.0088847522,
0.0136728035,
0.0238823537,
-0.0331044458,
-0.0120839579,
0.0566140935,
0.0008743872,
0.0121282386,
0.0022804213,
0.0190787464,
-0.0534321442,
0.028321417,
-0.0525156967,
-0.0037971181,
-0.0525825024,
-0.028589122,
0.0188520253,
0.019234933,
0.0026372273,
0.0202058163,
0.0622665286,
-0.0382094383,
-0.0487747528,
0.0502814576,
-0.0262431949,
0.0200724341,
-0.0246579442,
0.0106796864,
-0.0182998106,
0.0734758973,
-0.0096197547,
0.0142940758,
-0.0133742439,
0.0037320133,
0.0685390159,
-0.0139763476,
-0.0075161792,
-0.0112260059,
-0.0579536855,
0.0300731454,
0.0048675593,
0.0433881283,
0.0181527399,
0.0191468764,
0.0138707189,
-0.0462074354,
-0.08866027,
0.0248998087,
-0.0466108397,
0.0185497422,
0.0453764237,
0.0528791063,
0.0300270077,
-0.0155122569,
-0.0191897899,
0.0305281747,
-0.032026466,
0.0075951442,
0.0042711631,
-0.0054434375,
0.0183473192,
-0.0260339081,
-0.0426992401,
0.0387373455,
0.0415469334,
-0.0396342799,
0.0128756044,
-0.0917528197,
-0.0320759527,
-0.0180259086,
0.0635064766,
-0.0059993849,
-0.0640862659,
-0.0284173116,
-0.0179546028,
0.090788655,
0.0667181239,
0.0243348032,
0.0157409925,
0.0646510571,
0.0440935493,
0.0104925418,
0.0018163454,
-0.0189052057,
-0.0441436209,
-0.0442111716,
-0.0059363507,
-0.0330954865,
0.0408481136,
-0.0216656793,
0.0013543242,
-0.075319007,
-0.0264997836,
-0.0068429247,
0.015677426,
-0.0201318376,
0.0083705084,
-0.0299608558,
-0.0018014931,
0.0186015293,
0.0042045019,
0.0447071418,
-0.0282147005,
-0.0350130536,
-0.041157987,
-0.0491476208,
-0.0463190898,
0.0021841468,
0.0042362935,
0.0401165523,
-0.0635726377,
0.0049809213,
-0.0505604781,
0.0213629249,
0.0250603035,
-0.041953247,
0.0222558416,
-0.017255703,
-0.0103038279,
-0.0620838366,
-0.0395107791,
0.0131618762,
-0.0099004861,
-0.0104455398,
0.0241085961,
0.0348238759,
-0.0500427224,
-0.021551799,
0.011442367,
0.0194479972,
0.0775792599,
-0.0108488277,
0.0131220641,
-0.0381822027,
0.0509478934,
0.0621751547,
0.0467816852,
0.0220981613,
0.0047236294,
0.0270530339,
0.0246279575,
0.0188710988,
0.0092834393,
-0.0735038519,
0.0244734529,
0.0756695196,
0.032323122,
-0.0051371963,
-0.014197194,
0.0002676907,
-0.0074534393,
0.0240041632,
0.0521400757,
-0.0229277704,
-0.0772530362,
0.0011691924,
-0.0037601986,
0.0417934284,
0.0139109492,
0.0264700204,
-0.043057546,
-0.0116025321,
0.0139972614,
0.0088764923,
0.0272688773,
-0.0218080394,
0.0069080326,
-0.0542422682,
0.0237049349,
0.0097045125,
0.0285190716,
-0.0387651995,
-0.0463754758,
0.0252069402,
0.0045932559,
0.0654591471,
0.0229637399,
-0.0043367641,
-0.0590870269,
0.0178791024,
0.0048353537,
-0.0588248782,
-0.0193256773,
0.0051070312,
0.0311328731,
-0.0266716126,
0.0135435862,
-0.0046808547,
-0.049395971,
0.0258835293,
-0.0279741157,
-0.00962024,
-0.004697456,
-0.0272852574,
0.024447551,
-0.0488491282,
0.0049833339,
0.0376370512,
-0.035579998,
0.0173790902,
-0.0571148358,
0.0651031137,
-0.0008335366,
-0.0225457959,
-0.0103887031,
-0.0464066751,
-0.0334447585,
0.0315596759,
0.0157744121,
-0.0593535714,
0.03479385,
0.0293384381,
-0.0073159719,
-0.007672885,
-0.042777963,
-0.0157232601,
-0.0163355786,
0.0037156055,
-0.0160709117,
0.0550455824,
0.0017255393,
0.0186589435,
-0.0243180469,
-0.0182575118,
0.0120833637,
0.0094635375,
-0.0338068344,
0.0085389046,
-0.0234444384,
-0.0182249416,
-0.0309217051,
0.0121893231,
0.0736671612,
-0.0032037566,
-0.0060224715,
0.0049240985,
-0.0919693559,
-0.042936001,
-0.0056954618,
0.0296856798,
0.0080383839,
-0.003218231,
0.0193168316,
-0.0915136635,
0.0610045008,
-0.0045986366,
-0.0163293555,
0.0833278075,
0.0038792917,
-0.0841648281,
-0.0337983891,
0.0332853273,
-0.0756238624,
0.0042727264,
0.0167824402,
0.023635067,
0.0016377706,
-0.0289324783,
-0.0093276566,
-0.0128708025,
0.0164231863,
-0.0065831067,
-0.005783339,
-0.016818542,
0.0608980134,
-0.005521873,
0.0119867986,
-0.0346713737,
-0.0183015596,
0.0205296911,
-0.0007391922,
-0.0206521992,
0.0122372909,
0.0656199753,
0.0230492409,
-0.0139113041,
0.0327740461,
-0.0207439885,
-0.0067518014,
0.0680127963,
0.0174934845,
-0.0276516359,
0.0022827103,
0.0037031178,
0.0200073458,
-0.0542126596,
-0.0141120069,
0.0193412732,
-0.0107633416,
-0.0665752292,
0.0655998513,
-0.0299869571,
-0.1091452688,
-0.0362459011,
-0.0046247048,
0.0498209037,
0.0378956012,
0.056235306,
0.010102503,
-0.0264125112,
-0.0034417626,
-0.0206665229,
-0.0045710802,
0.0021604416,
0.0244710911,
0.0038863546,
0.005966912,
0.0633523166,
0.0286595859,
0.0164839532,
0.0231283065,
-0.0228099748,
0.0083675701,
-0.0253732316,
-0.0207094066,
-0.024346076,
0.0431027189,
-0.0099162273,
-0.0083960062,
0.0369605422,
-0.0436099358,
-0.042070616,
-0.0279489867,
0.0088029746,
-0.0689743683,
0.008325167,
0.0379314274,
-0.0040036268,
0.0225151852,
0.0046605063,
-0.0081750061,
-0.0013001499,
-0.0268696789,
-0.0126634771,
-6.252623429e-33,
-0.02955194,
0.0529185124,
0.002511119,
0.0057882383,
-0.0112111056,
0.0154660866,
-0.0206666179,
0.0104224458,
-0.0193717182,
-0.0060683517,
-0.0268544573,
-0.0130395433,
0.0037935064,
0.0167253222,
-0.0137657896,
0.0184021574,
0.0674165785,
-0.0130445724,
-0.0126568619,
0.0414204411,
0.0048057362,
0.023280533,
0.0569244027,
-0.0171266757,
-0.0630805269,
0.0060475315,
-0.0275630243,
0.0031097375,
0.0230722185,
0.0420026295,
-0.0576152951,
0.0300148167,
0.0198126733,
-0.0379505455,
-0.0219473671,
0.0081967888,
-0.0938856974,
0.004548979,
0.0172767248,
0.0286788214,
-0.0405003093,
-0.0337966383,
0.0595029481,
0.0374838896,
-0.0235318448,
-0.025477916,
0.0131819211,
-0.0145508358,
-0.0317463651,
-0.0328281149,
-0.0292071961,
0.0082884412,
-0.0000833313,
-0.0192513652,
0.0340314843,
0.0212935861,
-0.0194255393,
0.0482629761,
-0.0775324404,
-0.0248550642,
-0.0314553119,
0.079889439,
0.0291836243,
0.0190297868,
-0.0339136124,
0.0223652031,
-0.006223009,
0.0103111872,
0.0086838268,
-0.0437621213,
0.0770225301,
0.0076030358,
0.0601908602,
0.025632672,
0.0076906867,
-0.0380615927,
-0.052892644,
-0.0431913994,
0.0254104491,
0.017965531,
0.0574949794,
0.0553909205,
0.022878807,
-0.0199065097,
-0.0512108915,
-0.0071993275,
-0.049745705,
0.0093615791,
-0.0125015816,
0.0401134603,
-0.0485197864,
-0.0314511992,
0.0518357456,
-0.0463731773,
0.0401551574,
0.0265172683,
-0.0284609962,
0.0272365212,
0.0237459615,
0.014584966,
-0.0112165092,
-0.0535341203,
0.025602201,
-0.0373247117,
0.0009478069,
-0.0136280945,
0.0156857315,
0.0857179239,
-0.0601049364,
-0.0311097801,
0.0002963004,
-0.0032781251,
0.0012412741,
0.0694082826,
-0.023695657,
0.0068267602,
0.0067669787,
0.0477272682,
0.0079058288,
0.0562671721,
-0.0128808348,
-0.0051847878,
0.0494977534,
0.0262728222,
-0.0502232835,
-0.0067156754,
-0.0263728928,
0.0416345038,
0.0729469582,
-0.0648143962,
-0.0233493745,
0.0099249836,
2.717e-7,
-0.0051312642,
0.0341264009,
-0.0126435095,
-0.0479617976,
0.0395861305,
0.031825453,
0.0220994111,
0.0555212945,
0.0475667641,
0.0260632485,
0.0266161263,
0.0108132558,
0.0012266064,
-0.022301292,
-0.0534872897,
-0.0059884791,
-0.0875594914,
0.0252595823,
-0.0218454897,
-0.0394650884,
-0.0133955805,
0.1128410324,
0.0128266932,
-0.0465542004,
-0.0013577866,
0.0047884369,
0.038268093,
-0.0331664048,
0.0197817925,
-0.0053061927,
0.0687194392,
0.0347036943,
-0.0429509431,
-0.0312087853,
-0.0015818302,
0.0619622245,
-0.0462773666,
0.0678392127,
-0.0324658751,
0.0056092967,
0.0455804169,
0.0095285429,
-0.0206112433,
-0.0659565702,
0.0558815598,
-0.0177238025,
-0.009138667,
-0.0905436426,
-0.0169538464,
-0.0110067492,
-0.0123655749,
-0.0355761275,
-0.0018655438,
0.0420947708,
0.0497311056,
0.0004965401,
-0.0247957017,
-0.1097611561,
0.0348204896,
-0.0001988966,
-0.0418871716,
-0.0450674444,
-0.0421873368,
-0.0717286021,
0.0679488108,
-0.0321029723,
0.029828418,
2.114106845e-34,
0.0257299487,
-0.0035483658,
0.023090547,
0.0214638561,
0.0194264334,
-0.0387905501,
0.0009889033,
0.0247988831,
0.0070437402,
-0.1120669022,
-0.0393785238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01375v1 | Dive into the Chasm: Probing the Gap between In- and Cross-Topic Generalization | 2024-02-02T12:59:27 | 2024-02-02T12:59:27 | Andreas Waldis, Yufang Hou, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (LMs) perform well in In-Topic setups, where
training and testing data come from the same topics. However, they face
challenges in Cross-Topic scenarios where testing data is derived from distinct
topics -- such as Gun Control. This study analyzes various LMs with three
probing-based experiments to shed light on the reasons behind the In- vs.
Cross-Topic generalization gap. Thereby, we demonstrate, for the first time,
that generalization gaps and the robustness of the embedding space vary
significantly across LMs. Additionally, we assess larger LMs and underscore the
relevance of our analysis for recent models. Overall, diverse pre-training
objectives, architectural regularization, or data deduplication contribute to
more robust LMs and diminish generalization gaps. Our research contributes to a
deeper understanding and comparison of language models across different
generalization scenarios. | [
0.0240215398,
0.0454439186,
-0.0167212002,
0.0416943692,
-0.0087597491,
0.0242279004,
0.0159617942,
0.0045047635,
-0.0506872907,
-0.0474520512,
-0.0410138033,
-0.020053003,
-0.0225910582,
0.0120781036,
0.0386836492,
-0.0225687325,
0.0478618033,
-0.0120470943,
0.0070854118,
0.0022933483,
0.0058104219,
-0.0001844495,
0.0353523716,
0.0295436047,
0.0087118223,
0.0207593255,
-0.0255302265,
-0.0200002007,
-0.0059196344,
-0.0303567927,
0.017172005,
0.0364680998,
0.0781249776,
0.020437479,
0.0000017338,
-0.0258850753,
-0.0006989695,
-0.014931052,
0.011990197,
0.0389573984,
0.0513927042,
-0.0642522201,
0.0357409008,
0.0195763856,
-0.0168640204,
-0.0868749246,
0.0172888897,
0.0749109536,
0.0343737826,
0.0670365021,
-0.018379638,
-0.0220266934,
0.0367926247,
-0.0575779341,
0.0144050783,
-0.0670403764,
0.0169351865,
0.0112820156,
0.0086118439,
0.0540705211,
-0.0315901674,
0.0091077108,
0.0189670045,
0.0453978665,
-0.0211718287,
0.0351790562,
-0.0311985277,
-0.014242854,
-0.0078907665,
0.090117678,
-0.0649056807,
-0.0268054828,
0.0069707995,
-0.0166146401,
-0.0132331038,
0.0058178613,
-0.0398665257,
-0.0050686933,
0.0405023433,
0.0255359244,
0.0354877971,
-0.0187021364,
0.0538799278,
-0.0096579874,
-0.0337589569,
0.0538115799,
0.0282147564,
-0.0453954898,
-0.0085084466,
0.0199039318,
-0.035921488,
-0.0353756808,
-0.0045213429,
0.0039525689,
-0.0123232584,
0.0288831592,
-0.0645921528,
-0.0238533206,
0.0316588506,
-0.0077155889,
0.0446845554,
0.0147113279,
-0.0421568565,
0.0629561692,
-0.0047442485,
0.0458913036,
-0.0266054422,
0.0476210527,
-0.0368030816,
0.0083648451,
-0.0584460609,
-0.0149817383,
-0.0267641563,
0.0081445463,
0.0387690291,
-0.0474654213,
0.0024967899,
0.0234766752,
-0.0143707097,
-0.0053642029,
-0.0437570661,
-0.024841547,
-0.0365623757,
-0.0138159068,
0.0260856394,
-0.005558413,
-0.0511209741,
0.0610019676,
-0.01238262,
-0.0143002402,
-0.0123165203,
-0.001887479,
-0.0045700641,
-0.0077667274,
0.008514653,
0.0322139524,
-0.0066647893,
-0.0466331951,
-0.0338541456,
0.0112195304,
-0.0107884277,
-0.0374759883,
0.0237090774,
-0.0393747091,
0.0476102307,
0.0004368565,
-0.0013520356,
-0.0231376737,
-0.012212472,
0.0022990524,
-0.0642804056,
0.0770794302,
0.0058930223,
0.0133899869,
0.0507840365,
0.0279196557,
0.0331384167,
0.1019009128,
-0.0133389598,
-0.0043621017,
0.0621176474,
0.0084043061,
0.0025138606,
0.0141558703,
0.0375938639,
0.0226846375,
-0.0307142399,
0.0200036075,
0.0336323529,
0.0239907857,
0.0451895148,
0.0262844469,
-0.0593397766,
-0.0351171978,
0.0374382995,
0.1085559428,
0.0215577055,
0.0142057361,
0.0425772555,
0.0211365465,
-0.0084873959,
0.0338874087,
-0.035280481,
-0.0478628837,
-0.029704893,
-0.0080965562,
0.0382125527,
-0.0185134262,
-0.0624746755,
-0.0024567398,
-0.0340510122,
-0.0472080521,
0.0059927125,
-0.040107958,
0.0622619651,
0.0093187038,
-0.0167582836,
0.0256960392,
0.0369362347,
-0.0252491683,
0.0013467501,
-0.0236698855,
0.0308625847,
0.01914794,
0.0349738672,
-0.028219996,
-0.032257244,
0.0067283376,
0.054291971,
0.0190429501,
0.0667246357,
-0.0322840735,
0.0588487722,
-0.0237186681,
-0.0336885974,
-0.0630128533,
0.0387804732,
0.0038723547,
0.0203312002,
0.006471884,
0.0299546048,
-0.0639239773,
0.0334254429,
0.0599728487,
-0.0522729754,
0.003543495,
-0.0169206597,
-0.0101717254,
0.0166272707,
-0.0177706406,
-0.0281745773,
0.0102782743,
0.0231292937,
-0.0333106704,
0.0013188247,
-0.0241671484,
-0.0383291915,
-0.0320814364,
0.0288114231,
-0.0470875017,
0.0241491795,
0.0233332813,
-0.0472395904,
-0.0096116075,
0.0159326568,
0.0097579509,
0.0631862208,
-0.0378135741,
0.0189010445,
-0.0642498732,
-0.0075927596,
-0.0278732702,
0.0269345976,
-0.0023179101,
0.0115312794,
-0.0241369102,
0.009146384,
0.0495778546,
-0.0003163753,
-0.0537692718,
0.0112762991,
-0.0210685823,
0.013501795,
0.0097830109,
-0.022411637,
-0.0213520024,
-0.0041078473,
-0.1005587429,
0.0142023973,
-0.0325066186,
-0.0213499758,
0.0233180318,
-0.0242549479,
-0.0093376348,
-0.0072038351,
-0.0195633676,
-0.0462136306,
0.0023556533,
0.0498485044,
0.02909513,
-0.006316198,
0.0226000343,
-0.066323474,
-0.0369234867,
-0.0265092161,
0.0670652017,
-0.051483009,
0.0411425941,
-0.0650229082,
0.0559912808,
-0.0329538845,
0.0083696274,
-0.0291248932,
-0.0215644557,
0.0177668165,
-0.0189158358,
0.0254035592,
0.0468726158,
-0.0132388258,
0.0138871279,
0.0793225244,
0.0133592896,
-0.0516864844,
-0.029135935,
0.0003704977,
-0.011860447,
-0.0325320885,
0.008670046,
0.0058356905,
0.1027704552,
-0.015436138,
-0.0042751376,
-0.0405151136,
-0.0056813383,
-0.0512328707,
-0.0014187581,
-0.0584434904,
-0.0243420117,
-0.0121415239,
0.0392054282,
-0.0349862725,
-0.050733123,
0.0606568269,
-0.0229520742,
0.0074687516,
-0.0329573564,
-0.0050198035,
-0.028997926,
0.0648711175,
0.0156239616,
-0.0093735252,
0.0007603084,
-0.0151823852,
-0.0531282499,
0.000678352,
-0.0052101347,
-0.0226935111,
0.0590211153,
0.0032546979,
-0.0073486743,
-0.0074134851,
-0.0273899306,
-0.024961777,
-0.0826337263,
0.0002921571,
0.0014532121,
0.0124651557,
0.0134484256,
-0.0058095115,
0.0155294035,
-0.0163701829,
0.0352109782,
0.0064859707,
-0.0036627315,
-0.0172435958,
0.0331896357,
0.0511362851,
-0.0776821002,
-0.0321844295,
-0.0347179361,
-0.0017329714,
0.0102902465,
0.036980968,
0.0072046495,
-0.0470512621,
0.0272257086,
0.0277795177,
-0.0154898996,
-0.0375912897,
0.0154142268,
0.0427292399,
-0.0171296131,
-0.0025239191,
0.1024953723,
0.0366804078,
-0.0286476128,
0.0184255168,
0.0054979948,
0.0258482769,
0.0335645378,
0.0148076368,
-0.0707523078,
-0.0032736608,
0.0054681003,
-0.0143777356,
0.0218080115,
-0.0034368355,
-0.0067818915,
-0.110935837,
-0.0040751989,
0.0095209945,
-0.0345634334,
-0.0234796815,
-0.0662385821,
0.0096215364,
-0.0025260923,
0.0493333079,
-0.0034913756,
-0.0243718624,
0.0030134378,
0.0050587165,
-0.0450554825,
-0.0746408924,
0.0052045146,
-0.0550326072,
0.040075589,
0.0485926755,
0.0047028153,
0.0119184135,
0.0038983421,
0.0432822257,
0.0268371776,
-0.0120951915,
0.0048864535,
0.0462789834,
-0.0064635868,
-0.0030516901,
0.0273638684,
0.0041551897,
-0.0149510279,
-0.0249696318,
0.0027420849,
0.0681023747,
-0.0071079554,
-0.0334653407,
-0.0262625236,
0.0015803006,
0.0099398615,
0.0868105292,
0.053079959,
-0.0522319227,
-0.0299013667,
-0.0087839114,
0.0079215122,
-0.0028347904,
-0.0286860093,
0.0108677531,
-0.0143558476,
-0.0284478646,
-0.0168207828,
-0.0503997877,
0.0275373943,
0.0130948164,
-0.0005811786,
-0.0109438421,
-0.0158121418,
-0.0341617092,
-0.0290297661,
0.0408926196,
-0.0329342186,
-0.0281604659,
-0.0165944714,
-0.0088689467,
0.0159493871,
0.028119592,
-0.0344571322,
-0.0078362031,
-0.099930197,
-0.0756698623,
0.0298910849,
0.0008046626,
0.0138135115,
0.0236421488,
0.000348903,
-0.0703293458,
0.089340739,
-0.0267591644,
-0.0493992455,
0.019254826,
0.0410093889,
-0.0432961099,
0.0258689765,
0.0160011165,
-0.0464198962,
0.0354548544,
0.0433455743,
0.000770282,
-0.0273412038,
0.022372501,
-0.0155904936,
-0.0299469642,
0.0965766832,
0.0213972051,
-0.0193947162,
-0.0496070087,
-0.0131451059,
-0.0264713299,
0.0088760508,
-0.0302794836,
-0.0204073247,
0.0675872117,
-0.001070718,
-0.0314512253,
-0.0107492339,
-0.0246005077,
0.0972426757,
-0.0299500767,
0.0072116,
0.0252513867,
0.0438156649,
0.0281195585,
0.0160846822,
-0.0186840463,
0.0398782678,
-0.0412192829,
0.0051229079,
-0.0371274017,
0.0133690657,
0.0034691601,
0.0417280123,
-0.0128066428,
0.0131698325,
-0.0830148011,
-0.0317387916,
-0.0041047926,
0.0174760912,
0.0384051837,
-0.0282959845,
0.0239437521,
0.0092577059,
-0.0212484878,
-0.0252457708,
0.0078996578,
-0.0366300866,
-0.0446335822,
0.0442979373,
0.0151600763,
-0.032826189,
0.0468263552,
0.0993613973,
0.0295201987,
0.0471315458,
0.0094327163,
0.0066944468,
-0.0321167894,
0.031524796,
0.0801082551,
0.0340012461,
-0.0423529558,
0.0124843018,
-0.0116520524,
-0.0471254848,
0.0162313059,
-0.0272157788,
-0.0363088176,
0.0464986712,
0.0039299559,
0.0972704515,
-0.0134429056,
0.0311382264,
-0.015763063,
-0.0313106552,
0.0185317304,
-0.0472421199,
-0.0372315273,
-6.197940167e-33,
-0.023283463,
0.0286799725,
0.00110975,
-0.0504727624,
0.0051486851,
0.0172375999,
-0.0236332938,
0.0415919013,
-0.0279633794,
0.0016641917,
-0.023491852,
0.033283852,
-0.0013210385,
0.0174343046,
0.0061871973,
-0.0315930396,
0.036260616,
-0.0054758778,
-0.0050515034,
0.0251452979,
-0.0031737292,
0.0552058183,
0.0451677181,
-0.0465589985,
0.0276114307,
-0.0086966315,
0.0267435275,
-0.0123654585,
0.0550810732,
0.0632949695,
-0.0357036479,
0.0350616314,
0.0478226654,
-0.0354515612,
-0.0389500707,
0.040679846,
-0.0385206491,
-0.0534528457,
0.0076760184,
-0.0272009615,
-0.0064852997,
-0.0175753646,
0.0244287103,
-0.0263517462,
0.0083998991,
-0.0325059183,
0.0357577577,
0.0108243655,
-0.0323745944,
-0.0046246652,
-0.0803816766,
0.0247719511,
-0.0039965496,
0.0182628743,
0.0182702616,
0.0202358346,
0.0181953106,
0.039951764,
-0.0230427869,
0.0368456393,
0.0007061486,
0.036340937,
0.0230934322,
-0.010677143,
-0.0106735928,
0.0690388381,
-0.0143529065,
0.019405501,
0.0134394225,
-0.0350270197,
0.080757454,
0.0408956297,
0.0139406919,
0.0343139209,
0.0581617281,
-0.0124369469,
-0.0765812695,
-0.0092582023,
0.0309746936,
-0.0093929106,
0.0264357813,
0.057072252,
-0.0139208557,
-0.0313806608,
-0.0575380772,
-0.0211777315,
-0.0226863027,
-0.0561854802,
0.0367206596,
0.0344804525,
0.0069121728,
0.0170911252,
0.0407930128,
-0.0524773486,
-0.0170693658,
0.0395694897,
-0.0273873769,
-0.0123619987,
-0.0014514903,
0.0463475436,
-0.0853678808,
-0.0652305633,
0.0168823712,
-0.0166188441,
0.0338182896,
-0.0126276547,
0.02908477,
-0.0123081198,
-0.0807989687,
-0.0260200594,
-0.0058408817,
-0.0518433116,
0.0196356736,
0.0381736197,
0.0489068851,
0.0112656271,
0.0129407449,
0.033726003,
0.0474856496,
-0.0377261452,
-0.0207653958,
-0.038752988,
-0.0198012348,
0.0297273844,
-0.0075770104,
-0.0193118267,
-0.0306524988,
-0.0049582948,
0.0696968287,
-0.0622935668,
-0.0290592667,
-0.0115189757,
2.415e-7,
0.046983894,
0.0398200192,
-0.0183795393,
0.0095962174,
-0.0000819118,
0.0029687458,
-0.0295487177,
0.0516977981,
0.0051271142,
-0.0064141541,
0.0132155176,
0.0375942141,
0.0336613879,
0.0383398943,
-0.0536993295,
0.022692943,
-0.0770237595,
0.0430856645,
-0.04414846,
-0.0007662965,
-0.0181024931,
0.107543081,
0.0278867129,
0.0110363504,
-0.0324787945,
-0.0659090802,
0.0765039772,
-0.0631591454,
-0.0243466049,
0.0376696326,
0.0233431831,
0.075356558,
-0.0001990131,
0.0011250861,
-0.0145223187,
0.0511195846,
0.0096561974,
0.0488958843,
0.0119329309,
-0.0218825731,
-0.0270618293,
-0.0229042899,
-0.0357262529,
-0.0701530501,
0.0945821777,
-0.0684590265,
-0.02879286,
-0.0891002715,
0.013099486,
-0.0090387985,
0.046145536,
-0.0188511219,
0.0074863336,
-0.0094306832,
0.0285343602,
0.0095150014,
-0.002293101,
-0.0822196677,
-0.0194240343,
0.0668006241,
-0.0494388752,
-0.0244651325,
-0.0295052752,
-0.0106093176,
0.0559511371,
-0.0349017866,
0.0309274029,
2.227931892e-34,
0.0451101884,
-0.0139309671,
0.0224911198,
-0.0031675994,
0.0237847362,
-0.027967656,
-0.0229142178,
-0.0068107699,
0.0069488687,
-0.0562447794,
0.0258701853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01364v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01364v2 | Continual Learning for Large Language Models: A Survey | 2024-02-02T12:34:09 | 2024-02-07T07:14:39 | Tongtong Wu, Linhao Luo, Yuan-Fang Li, Shirui Pan, Thuy-Trang Vu, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are not amenable to frequent re-training, due to
high training costs arising from their massive scale. However, updates are
necessary to endow LLMs with new skills and keep them up-to-date with rapidly
evolving human knowledge. This paper surveys recent works on continual learning
for LLMs. Due to the unique nature of LLMs, we catalog continue learning
techniques in a novel multi-staged categorization scheme, involving continual
pretraining, instruction tuning, and alignment. We contrast continual learning
for LLMs with simpler adaptation methods used in smaller models, as well as
with other enhancement strategies like retrieval-augmented generation and model
editing. Moreover, informed by a discussion of benchmarks and evaluation, we
identify several challenges and future work directions for this crucial task. | [
0.0449237376,
0.0818702206,
-0.006669078,
0.0137033127,
-0.0005573769,
0.0370463543,
-0.0032239712,
-0.0421952121,
0.0106979031,
-0.0699620843,
-0.0649378449,
-0.0360750034,
-0.033914078,
-0.0092999637,
0.0262695383,
-0.0321605764,
0.0640042052,
-0.0174481291,
-0.012039124,
-0.0062272912,
-0.0011554949,
0.0140146343,
-0.0134954955,
0.0187534727,
-0.0168750547,
-0.0099176532,
-0.003475803,
-0.0360965095,
-0.0035541037,
-0.0216074008,
0.0328590423,
0.048279576,
0.0445498563,
0.055759225,
0.0000018038,
-0.0532530434,
-0.0378736965,
-0.0223937016,
-0.0439644083,
-0.0105040697,
0.0682971328,
-0.0021482683,
-0.0184082575,
0.0373073928,
-0.0297928471,
-0.0323850363,
0.0860933289,
-0.0031805811,
0.0722865388,
0.0597344153,
0.0026885241,
-0.0497602932,
0.0587987155,
-0.0381720886,
-0.025533855,
-0.0414567068,
0.0228223223,
0.0101128267,
-0.0170380864,
0.0156954117,
0.0049197963,
0.0472159535,
0.0202820357,
-0.0205790829,
0.018551657,
0.0471759848,
0.000401584,
-0.0130406972,
-0.0046879314,
0.0385904945,
-0.0280858595,
-0.0476071797,
-0.0214983914,
0.0219343379,
-0.0100965928,
-0.0088088308,
-0.043629691,
0.0202480219,
0.0270040464,
0.0304359104,
0.0553507805,
-0.0401085541,
0.0214253608,
0.0279110316,
-0.0649385899,
-0.0067910384,
0.0361541733,
-0.0368550979,
-0.0169967413,
0.0169603918,
-0.0348427519,
-0.0270783957,
0.0070329048,
0.0508380719,
-0.0531114712,
0.0240750033,
-0.0727728903,
0.0006731127,
-0.002294688,
-0.0646707118,
0.0513531901,
0.0331790745,
-0.008340586,
0.0562690943,
-0.0263144262,
0.042485252,
0.0086426074,
0.0091819102,
-0.0612086095,
-0.0041612978,
-0.0860045552,
-0.0205668099,
-0.0494267233,
0.0227813162,
0.0088740299,
-0.0082641561,
-0.0284128692,
0.0628426597,
0.0309926029,
0.0118064387,
-0.0067367572,
-0.0378427319,
-0.0732242465,
-0.0109612867,
0.0186018664,
0.0549788028,
0.0142962644,
0.0168354977,
-0.0194725432,
-0.0086018406,
-0.003064651,
0.0326999612,
-0.0140880309,
-0.0382996239,
0.0077724298,
0.0212987978,
-0.0603600927,
-0.0327434391,
-0.0535440557,
0.0216307603,
-0.0101112463,
-0.0359226614,
-0.0110028712,
-0.0236267988,
0.0237660762,
-0.015012959,
0.0069499719,
-0.0558238178,
0.0016671021,
-0.0251991693,
-0.0197209548,
0.0698195323,
0.0042517348,
0.0337201916,
0.0363385081,
-0.0205906723,
0.023816295,
0.0669484213,
0.0234797839,
-0.0293066334,
0.0356354117,
-0.0205494035,
0.0079143653,
0.0368902311,
0.0008048493,
0.0206881873,
-0.0476127863,
0.0123038013,
0.0336954333,
0.0291986819,
0.0394312739,
0.0131012956,
-0.0135399178,
0.0095224837,
0.0444288477,
0.0032135469,
0.0554313175,
0.0551154688,
0.05277301,
0.0009453517,
0.0086173313,
0.0026839017,
-0.0479939431,
-0.0098649282,
-0.0339121968,
0.0120098926,
-0.0123289935,
0.0106959846,
-0.0506054275,
-0.0299203247,
0.0036714647,
0.0090373242,
-0.0190770924,
0.0258449186,
0.0609368533,
-0.0037063968,
-0.0153805455,
0.0625367984,
0.0432689339,
-0.0319965929,
0.0149603654,
-0.0588051192,
0.0072882702,
0.0743729994,
0.0315653719,
-0.0480630733,
-0.0772014782,
0.0113188494,
0.029792469,
0.0064994972,
0.0587372556,
-0.0486815795,
0.0126504702,
-0.0487928614,
-0.0037039383,
0.0079209916,
0.0292742942,
0.0056272615,
0.0281260349,
0.0210050885,
0.0179329719,
-0.0043742722,
-0.037358135,
0.0586445928,
-0.0641388968,
-0.021859562,
0.0005184981,
0.0043556467,
-0.0122274654,
-0.0009257616,
-0.0578466989,
-0.0013043893,
0.0394950956,
-0.0462222658,
0.0340051539,
0.0213812571,
-0.0332384668,
-0.0286665093,
0.0761426538,
0.0736985132,
-0.0292505883,
-0.0058108834,
-0.0374031402,
-0.0094596855,
0.004404258,
-0.0024745732,
0.0549771301,
-0.0557872579,
0.0711531565,
-0.0274106823,
-0.0043717306,
-0.0637283325,
0.0388834327,
0.0121744415,
0.0024181674,
0.0214961581,
-0.0052698301,
-0.0139492182,
-0.0787230879,
-0.0059153182,
0.0342313088,
0.0109178619,
0.0357394144,
-0.0032118976,
0.0289439447,
-0.0304729827,
-0.0615682118,
-0.0983892381,
0.0218484066,
-0.0216642506,
0.0138222305,
0.0187918339,
0.0025932463,
-0.0121499216,
-0.029521998,
-0.0075045242,
-0.0192502085,
-0.0075258808,
0.0290704258,
0.0007096656,
-0.0053205281,
-0.0355687886,
-0.0401951186,
-0.0271547381,
0.0155092096,
0.038021531,
-0.0294003878,
-0.0039690072,
-0.0816365033,
0.0022479268,
-0.0275436919,
0.0336865708,
0.0080969697,
-0.0152974259,
-0.028451886,
-0.0225529131,
0.0181530863,
0.0449817851,
0.0324334055,
0.0452416912,
0.0521902107,
0.0025542912,
-0.0258635636,
0.0144530972,
-0.0309391338,
-0.0669842139,
-0.0390921049,
-0.0077751274,
0.0033371784,
0.0739119947,
-0.0466259643,
-0.0200292561,
-0.0353655592,
-0.0081415316,
-0.0542612635,
-0.0139967268,
-0.0589403324,
0.0047603147,
-0.0117381979,
-0.0211174656,
-0.0300141051,
-0.0575721562,
0.0575149544,
-0.0021119476,
-0.006927364,
-0.0713114291,
-0.0403694063,
-0.0130009642,
0.0438514315,
-0.0332382508,
0.0300864857,
0.0045006052,
-0.0313506089,
-0.0825863928,
-0.0035979568,
0.0245822128,
-0.0170509592,
0.0454591252,
-0.037176922,
0.0403463803,
-0.0180959161,
-0.0323971175,
-0.0650585517,
-0.0710070282,
-0.0052180705,
0.0044871424,
-0.0191121399,
0.0035380519,
-0.0526264682,
0.0385046452,
0.0245308615,
0.0553386584,
-0.0025898661,
-0.0057042809,
-0.013503111,
0.0544699356,
0.0365775265,
0.0452734828,
-0.021798389,
-0.0440346003,
0.0165622365,
0.024401566,
0.0327741876,
-0.0193828903,
-0.0155116189,
0.0187490974,
0.0502403788,
-0.042068027,
0.0106569398,
-0.0222790148,
0.0113960551,
-0.0416245833,
-0.0250176843,
0.1281949729,
0.0415627845,
-0.0526650511,
0.0014560199,
-0.0123629421,
0.0321929604,
0.0182160661,
0.0524399951,
-0.0398289263,
-0.0051225042,
0.0187962651,
0.034155827,
0.0347050317,
0.0013500185,
-0.0172847379,
-0.0952987,
0.0200305656,
0.0547100641,
-0.0366114676,
0.0003352142,
-0.0256988257,
-0.0041392632,
0.004895241,
0.0038084767,
0.0421049334,
-0.0074958503,
-0.0224981606,
0.0254902467,
-0.0025808502,
-0.0427853689,
0.0048780032,
-0.0301889963,
0.0701244697,
0.0501363017,
0.0231809895,
0.0359931104,
-0.0155676715,
0.0993876457,
-0.0329826288,
-0.0134007335,
-0.0170932468,
0.0135031249,
-0.0181866549,
-0.0004714149,
0.0366702452,
-0.0094725722,
-0.005909428,
-0.010240444,
0.0223000944,
0.0667660534,
-0.000634802,
0.0160212163,
0.0000416015,
-0.0524937771,
0.0139990672,
0.0398596413,
0.0032673511,
-0.0523719117,
-0.0069797174,
-0.008782845,
0.0020748526,
-0.0108131347,
-0.0227822457,
0.0165769327,
-0.0770279989,
-0.025986705,
-0.0522323586,
-0.0083846711,
0.0141982492,
0.0328441821,
0.0237191692,
-0.0154958051,
-0.0002538797,
-0.0201879162,
-0.0568932332,
0.021782279,
-0.0547631122,
-0.0037192756,
-0.0830628648,
-0.0440953448,
0.0541310161,
-0.0138486205,
-0.0073071714,
-0.0306415353,
-0.0509146564,
-0.0550099649,
-0.0038031312,
0.0339424573,
0.0169392936,
0.0821097568,
-0.0090526119,
-0.0675046816,
0.0384713896,
0.0025675981,
-0.0371223353,
0.036968708,
0.0143802539,
0.0004577875,
-0.0099884365,
0.0360317789,
-0.0455792993,
0.0208962392,
0.013913109,
0.0644219667,
0.0007951794,
-0.0327747837,
0.0166704003,
-0.02263611,
0.0035423725,
-0.0214425139,
-0.0048311218,
-0.0665289164,
0.0190901998,
0.0073571131,
-0.0323490426,
-0.0242901612,
0.0106362067,
0.0490766428,
-0.000772743,
-0.000573522,
-0.0119101051,
0.0242480487,
0.0439577587,
-0.025315756,
-0.0120896176,
0.0037432867,
0.0101357438,
0.0184855536,
0.0239903796,
-0.0300962999,
0.0157568548,
0.0003768798,
0.0392209701,
-0.0425032899,
0.027523255,
0.0054402952,
-0.003530619,
-0.0620346144,
0.0494406708,
-0.0286959168,
-0.0574455038,
-0.0609490089,
0.0345056765,
0.0942482874,
0.0156877562,
0.057562463,
-0.0003939483,
-0.0336318724,
-0.0325522423,
0.007450256,
-0.0079566268,
-0.0420358442,
-0.0127789564,
0.0238647666,
-0.0210954398,
0.0437824279,
0.0687464476,
0.0231490619,
0.0269905701,
-0.0239257067,
0.0027726041,
-0.0458449833,
-0.0001511163,
-0.0174574684,
-0.00944761,
-0.0272251423,
0.0384249985,
-0.0132979359,
-0.0709937662,
0.0339724123,
-0.0047830408,
-0.0289497953,
0.0001042829,
0.0113184387,
0.0419130661,
-0.0141393347,
0.0196544603,
-0.032118611,
0.0054194913,
0.0416092761,
-0.0343133323,
-0.0225581229,
-6.185482865e-33,
-0.0429001004,
0.0405791737,
0.0510382727,
-0.0636457056,
-0.0743145272,
-0.00705984,
-0.0499558188,
0.0278760102,
0.0146916928,
-0.0164819248,
0.0023955016,
-0.0088573275,
0.0080712121,
0.0198740419,
0.0272505619,
-0.0114350459,
0.0539057776,
0.0036686808,
-0.0093599157,
0.0383179784,
0.0319881029,
0.03272314,
0.0488192961,
-0.0548826866,
-0.0090314737,
0.0446604602,
0.0080651864,
0.0645150691,
0.0483394787,
0.0814874023,
-0.0302792713,
0.01661193,
0.0224324632,
-0.0224428009,
-0.0199687798,
-0.0254824366,
-0.0644788891,
-0.0161463451,
-0.0069325292,
0.0204658099,
-0.0213958826,
-0.0426718444,
0.0198459644,
-0.0101395734,
-0.0016613326,
0.0124221686,
0.0201000366,
-0.0372231193,
-0.0348936357,
0.0086817006,
-0.0734627172,
0.0134989424,
-0.0083024567,
-0.0353213586,
0.0126385484,
0.0043020286,
0.0135624567,
-0.0121295089,
-0.0644020513,
0.0071855523,
0.0213670414,
0.0726702213,
0.0512111075,
0.0444962345,
0.020896554,
0.0195598584,
0.0095881168,
-0.0211379249,
0.0173547994,
-0.0058981096,
0.0560265817,
-0.0075656879,
-0.006952818,
0.0125741148,
0.035174109,
-0.0370372385,
-0.0280316528,
-0.0129365157,
0.022665428,
0.0430875979,
0.0299368761,
0.0239706486,
0.0080567067,
-0.0236000735,
-0.0482816659,
0.0290310271,
-0.0465978161,
0.0109852822,
0.0584772304,
0.0510712117,
-0.0304966681,
-0.0230063088,
0.063073203,
-0.0368172228,
-0.0403687134,
0.0201886911,
-0.007933232,
0.0337161236,
0.0037380368,
0.0407967828,
-0.03300374,
-0.0512073673,
-0.0005219663,
-0.0409701616,
-0.0180831756,
-0.0080509298,
0.0328069702,
0.060548339,
-0.0467371382,
0.0168329235,
0.0027662269,
-0.0024960127,
0.0236559566,
0.0530357212,
0.0181289539,
0.0274971612,
0.0212934967,
0.0457959138,
0.0678957403,
-0.0238940921,
-0.0253214054,
0.0430329926,
0.0320718363,
0.0338906869,
-0.0143446829,
0.0248506684,
-0.0221168119,
0.0122679202,
-0.0135099329,
-0.0956638232,
-0.0052350489,
-0.0196446311,
2.509e-7,
0.0316706151,
0.0290487148,
0.000224399,
-0.0072578681,
0.0447153561,
0.0129153617,
-0.0258581676,
-0.0005187967,
0.0471675582,
0.0554395206,
0.0255838372,
0.0321659371,
0.0641202107,
0.0003848467,
-0.0631163195,
-0.0104543269,
-0.0297389124,
0.0700495169,
-0.0633051693,
-0.0038588315,
0.0249779206,
0.125149861,
0.0098149925,
0.0012838725,
-0.0209756251,
-0.0850375593,
0.0859321803,
0.0140054701,
0.0222772751,
0.0285349451,
-0.0138538554,
0.0595015287,
-0.0213046763,
-0.0183917042,
-0.0170691833,
0.0348027498,
-0.0236845147,
0.0581025109,
-0.0386292525,
-0.0145960683,
0.0281137582,
0.013033174,
-0.0046627265,
-0.0426918902,
0.0577702783,
-0.0846515521,
0.003330267,
-0.0094262222,
-0.0061919116,
-0.0039872071,
-0.0113977026,
-0.0162388291,
-0.0504277684,
0.0284099635,
0.0475230701,
0.0350174159,
-0.0336986594,
-0.0995029658,
-0.0287807547,
0.0173324216,
-0.0534417629,
-0.0400527157,
0.0004211593,
-0.0094344588,
0.0142132696,
-0.0486407951,
0.0392091013,
2.334144465e-34,
0.0211407375,
-0.0046890294,
0.0172776915,
0.0757476836,
0.0081771975,
-0.0387669876,
0.0038888857,
0.0105234198,
0.0055837417,
-0.0919672996,
-0.0122309616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01360v1 | What Makes Medical Claims (Un)Verifiable? Analyzing Entity and Relation Properties for Fact Verification | 2024-02-02T12:27:58 | 2024-02-02T12:27:58 | Amelie Wührl, Yarik Menchaca Resendiz, Lara Grimminger, Roman Klinger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Biomedical claim verification fails if no evidence can be discovered. In
these cases, the fact-checking verdict remains unknown and the claim is
unverifiable. To improve upon this, we have to understand if there are any
claim properties that impact its verifiability. In this work we assume that
entities and relations define the core variables in a biomedical claim's
anatomy and analyze if their properties help us to differentiate verifiable
from unverifiable claims. In a study with trained annotation experts we prompt
them to find evidence for biomedical claims, and observe how they refine search
queries for their evidence search. This leads to the first corpus for
scientific fact verification annotated with subject-relation-object triplets,
evidence documents, and fact-checking verdicts (the BEAR-Fact corpus). We find
(1) that discovering evidence for negated claims (e.g., X-does-not-cause-Y) is
particularly challenging. Further, we see that annotators process queries
mostly by adding constraints to the search and by normalizing entities to
canonical names. (2) We compare our in-house annotations with a small
crowdsourcing setting where we employ medical experts and laypeople. We find
that domain expertise does not have a substantial effect on the reliability of
annotations. Finally, (3), we demonstrate that it is possible to reliably
estimate the success of evidence retrieval purely from the claim text~(.82\F),
whereas identifying unverifiable claims proves more challenging (.27\F). The
dataset is available at http://www.ims.uni-stuttgart.de/data/bioclaim. | [
0.0652240887,
0.0414032117,
0.0207128245,
-0.0156510025,
-0.0084136967,
0.0060188449,
-0.0065547046,
0.0285206139,
0.0071219527,
-0.02197106,
0.0360165983,
0.0100176474,
0.0152560249,
-0.0204764716,
-0.0024239596,
-0.0220310148,
0.0206624027,
0.0456312783,
0.1103167757,
-0.0100061735,
-0.00816496,
0.0017815563,
-0.0508440696,
0.0386710949,
-0.0435431041,
0.0137949316,
0.0465210713,
-0.014595828,
0.0147705674,
-0.084237501,
-0.001609338,
0.051214546,
-0.0332666002,
0.0405405425,
0.0000018551,
-0.0467154793,
-0.0249168184,
0.0622939803,
-0.0644885153,
-0.0091127604,
0.002744491,
0.0164456852,
0.0031654716,
0.0130947139,
-0.0122493738,
-0.0437616967,
0.0489933081,
0.0524027012,
0.025872672,
0.0872368589,
-0.0178969074,
-0.0010687452,
0.012268112,
-0.0131708719,
0.0236580502,
-0.0197977256,
0.0365163237,
0.0145047037,
0.0372398458,
0.0129065998,
0.0476895571,
0.0524875596,
-0.033622019,
-0.0013964619,
-0.0101070609,
0.035136804,
-0.0472558066,
-0.0348197073,
0.0340160541,
0.01245795,
0.0688524023,
-0.0316616371,
0.0272705909,
0.0122067695,
0.0094666714,
0.0809774622,
0.0024795351,
0.0379976146,
-0.0333597511,
-0.0266925693,
0.0168887917,
0.0270888582,
0.045254983,
-0.0000847194,
0.0194892865,
0.0219387729,
-0.0267741624,
-0.0339953154,
0.0171671715,
0.0006332694,
0.0175762028,
-0.0883717164,
0.036363963,
-0.0074198069,
-0.0120035196,
0.0167626198,
0.0195845887,
-0.0307288356,
0.109570846,
-0.0549338982,
-0.0248593334,
-0.0317513496,
-0.0453892015,
0.0547493808,
-0.016604973,
-0.0532478727,
-0.0431116894,
0.0291897301,
0.0096545238,
0.0010010507,
-0.0481062196,
-0.0215340238,
-0.0202684738,
0.0156960115,
-0.0011803247,
0.0430357382,
-0.0441543646,
-0.0593770146,
-0.0235913731,
0.0297622643,
-0.0239410009,
0.0007154589,
-0.021812696,
-0.0030033088,
-0.0556723736,
0.0163688995,
-0.0065932428,
0.0293051675,
-0.0245205332,
-0.0393274873,
0.0231717564,
0.028609233,
0.0263052378,
0.0021731814,
0.0280670151,
0.0053588869,
0.0476122275,
-0.0199264791,
-0.0089870663,
-0.0626993477,
-0.012979337,
-0.0113278301,
0.0126437619,
-0.0298062302,
-0.011371118,
0.0045564556,
-0.0046229865,
-0.0535854809,
-0.0025420417,
0.0163158365,
-0.0430470519,
0.0491905063,
-0.0740988478,
-0.0159446858,
0.0254263766,
0.0158123225,
0.0058862106,
0.0025249219,
0.0281406399,
0.0032929084,
0.0425588936,
0.015018627,
0.0201164894,
-0.033351168,
0.0604816563,
-0.0340754539,
0.0868394747,
0.0228065588,
-0.0023103706,
0.0493382812,
-0.0652842,
0.0447199643,
-0.0426494703,
-0.0389696471,
0.0193483662,
0.0393796861,
-0.0114912027,
-0.0482367836,
-0.011194692,
-0.0432486795,
0.032864131,
-0.0085018743,
-0.0305091571,
-0.0008313691,
-0.0188798085,
-0.0249292105,
0.0057426556,
-0.0199779719,
0.0168529097,
-0.0613101348,
-0.052154772,
0.0238377806,
-0.0585760251,
-0.0300449599,
0.0202120058,
0.0095154885,
-0.000371437,
0.0325742513,
0.026925642,
-0.0331525058,
-0.0207736567,
-0.0311891101,
0.0085980128,
-0.0268093031,
0.0353777148,
-0.0199810956,
-0.0119356997,
-0.0024529926,
-0.0110436706,
0.023605343,
0.0259976685,
-0.0325819962,
-0.0181861185,
0.00836905,
-0.0253932495,
0.0079616839,
0.0305347834,
-0.037151169,
0.0321037285,
0.0252701715,
-0.0130684031,
-0.0446739644,
-0.0347052366,
0.0265286267,
-0.0145742549,
0.0103027774,
-0.0202456638,
0.0026218263,
0.055381678,
0.0367146507,
0.0069390158,
0.0452399403,
0.028520897,
-0.0191315319,
-0.0444646552,
0.0241303835,
0.0807242617,
0.0297555532,
0.0030630336,
-0.0917240381,
-0.0340270102,
-0.0365943462,
0.0083280951,
-0.0073623355,
-0.0712065548,
-0.0546142533,
0.0156058278,
-0.0182508994,
-0.0179208275,
0.0169925485,
-0.0361190736,
-0.0290281437,
0.0424806327,
0.0109942714,
-0.0097506894,
-0.045335371,
-0.0651822239,
0.0509162135,
-0.0407262146,
-0.0376493409,
-0.0006028748,
0.0297641549,
0.0050848215,
0.0332342051,
-0.0719187781,
-0.0262471847,
0.025042437,
-0.0979166478,
-0.0070209857,
0.015407918,
0.0314813219,
-0.0274340846,
-0.0247825459,
0.0176688991,
-0.0261130854,
-0.0163101759,
-0.0507505611,
-0.0040302067,
0.0288225915,
0.0503133796,
0.0252888873,
0.0097718006,
-0.0224805698,
-0.0044339099,
-0.0414437652,
0.0096275378,
0.052639477,
-0.0500371046,
0.0021667632,
0.0066705085,
-0.0276302174,
0.0122453421,
0.0065887454,
0.0303282328,
0.0483888686,
0.0258498602,
-0.0523876734,
0.026381962,
0.0068266736,
0.0187606718,
0.0249267928,
0.0370265096,
-0.0150333615,
0.0014630446,
-0.0308206677,
0.0017361192,
0.0251245461,
-0.0453468226,
0.0582242087,
0.0301447045,
-0.0018387336,
-0.0283938572,
-0.0424051583,
0.013280699,
-0.0343691818,
-0.0023520091,
0.011452849,
0.0112710372,
0.0094872182,
0.0742707998,
0.001403633,
-0.0163878035,
0.0791491121,
-0.022827344,
0.0324426331,
-0.0344123431,
0.0069333497,
0.0152855851,
0.0099002179,
0.0133198546,
0.0138836438,
0.0606810264,
0.0117118331,
0.0458908454,
0.0035541509,
0.0830339491,
-0.0386620723,
-0.0238130372,
0.0044620661,
0.0631214455,
0.0105320942,
-0.0521501489,
-0.013606458,
-0.0356356949,
-0.0239839554,
-0.0118447067,
-0.028413754,
-0.0040999129,
-0.0811826512,
-0.0119037423,
0.0264789201,
0.0491553135,
0.0320758708,
-0.0124111185,
0.0038837125,
-0.0310023874,
-0.0094930269,
0.0268466659,
0.0240778215,
-0.0071845143,
-0.0634853095,
0.0765934959,
-0.0471460707,
0.0110332221,
-0.008695784,
-0.0363030285,
-0.0353370756,
-0.0446244143,
0.0028508294,
-0.025675511,
0.012790448,
-0.0538468398,
0.0184834711,
0.0511519834,
0.0115683842,
0.0276313778,
0.0256186202,
0.0156792887,
-0.0583804697,
0.0060382327,
0.0093909483,
-0.123085171,
0.0106587913,
-0.0258620959,
0.0032654512,
-0.0488895029,
-0.0416880399,
0.0024161199,
-0.0362061746,
0.0701211765,
-0.0248944443,
0.0161239002,
-0.0047215088,
-0.0884546116,
0.0071598273,
-0.0453059413,
-0.0306456927,
-0.0140629625,
0.039846614,
0.013306926,
0.0242486335,
-0.0103923008,
-0.0575421229,
0.0127043305,
-0.0256238542,
0.0301669892,
0.0336463004,
0.0285927225,
-0.0197020546,
-0.0550382026,
-0.0459937751,
0.0487614162,
-0.022977734,
0.0082115699,
0.1056300029,
-0.0022040631,
0.0044534495,
-0.0561120138,
0.0090319561,
-0.030603271,
-0.0309822038,
-0.0083666248,
0.0567852817,
-0.0261478554,
-0.0264195856,
-0.0550048761,
-0.0201946776,
-0.0147315776,
0.070696719,
-0.002574912,
0.0442477167,
-0.0068942066,
0.0092264023,
0.0363410562,
0.0192373041,
-0.0387989953,
0.071860835,
-0.0448013619,
-0.0532555021,
-0.0798690394,
0.0017950685,
0.0143393157,
0.0447036028,
-0.0105020031,
0.0012224995,
0.0527307466,
0.0074932314,
-0.0640164241,
0.0881044567,
-0.0153356846,
0.0121018989,
-0.0233650208,
-0.0097340168,
0.0606363341,
0.0302363671,
-0.0230478141,
0.0054150117,
0.0170483626,
-0.0131007954,
-0.0355956256,
-0.0043980386,
0.0273606125,
-0.0052695293,
-0.0147999516,
-0.0556931421,
-0.0267473981,
0.0798305497,
-0.0274447985,
-0.0248468686,
0.0082207974,
-0.0662715361,
-0.0222483855,
-0.0236818772,
-0.0087912278,
0.0443213694,
-0.0152353207,
0.0194983371,
-0.0433698297,
-0.0073731071,
0.0656130612,
0.085348554,
0.0914491266,
-0.0121450471,
0.0008090719,
-0.010537752,
-0.0129614389,
0.0010091432,
-0.0192791782,
-0.0190260671,
-0.0170403719,
-0.0105201993,
0.0017126885,
-0.0173317604,
0.0083172331,
-0.0501638763,
0.0297801588,
-0.0206830222,
0.0303548649,
0.0106371213,
0.0238813404,
0.0245742425,
-0.035928335,
-0.0005332722,
-0.017742727,
-0.0111028189,
0.0622650571,
0.0004120091,
-0.0143615678,
0.0363596976,
0.0031990062,
0.0201537292,
-0.0235680193,
-0.0592816584,
0.0063409745,
-0.0256970059,
0.0402529314,
-0.0012616344,
0.0098794028,
0.0233070645,
-0.032939937,
-0.0078451363,
-0.0091583505,
-0.0060784193,
0.000183052,
0.0278173331,
0.0433631912,
0.0114575615,
-0.0218746234,
-0.0162380729,
0.0572335869,
0.019919835,
0.0642738342,
-0.0558722094,
-0.0609233864,
-0.0372699089,
-0.0700213909,
-0.0403015278,
0.0072036614,
-0.0291448068,
-0.0173671171,
-0.0875494033,
-0.0283373911,
-0.0003588368,
0.0384975933,
0.0079154335,
0.014635195,
-0.0190816801,
0.0611814559,
0.0276772343,
-0.0654321685,
-0.0146080526,
0.0517586134,
-0.033483278,
0.0126888296,
0.0263649467,
-6.120715698e-33,
-0.0046641519,
-0.0908825696,
-0.0088466778,
0.0081186322,
0.0463070385,
0.0510036349,
-0.0327438526,
-0.0096025076,
-0.0211875215,
0.0757729486,
0.0080775712,
0.0363482684,
0.0195167139,
-0.0263380911,
0.0243704002,
0.0155927939,
0.0470417403,
0.0206163153,
-0.0458840057,
-0.0097945426,
0.0197473243,
-0.0219371524,
0.0257486925,
-0.1437121481,
0.0692746639,
0.016758807,
-0.0069631739,
0.0363397151,
-0.0684435815,
0.0656347051,
0.008504576,
0.004664077,
0.0208847672,
-0.0168677364,
0.0225057881,
-0.0497361831,
-0.0911561921,
0.0163522474,
0.0317929871,
-0.0210589878,
-0.0563693829,
-0.0146046346,
0.0566208549,
-0.002120092,
-0.0456981622,
0.0164616182,
0.0253232978,
-0.0305216238,
-0.0040687895,
-0.067393668,
-0.0122974375,
0.0526871532,
0.0240083858,
0.0187898465,
-0.0021048568,
-0.0073850257,
-0.0068747588,
0.0279329121,
-0.0305558406,
0.0179737397,
-0.0232449565,
-0.0085998354,
-0.0156745706,
-0.0749649778,
-0.032159891,
0.0609749779,
-0.0071118381,
0.0519695878,
-0.01014964,
-0.0013339563,
-0.042047482,
0.0552625842,
0.0627836064,
0.0860850438,
0.0446095876,
0.022519907,
-0.0819440633,
0.0250530224,
-0.0300014205,
0.011939723,
0.0018759267,
-0.0164117105,
-0.0564470626,
0.0039723832,
-0.0266257133,
-0.0111911176,
-0.017981166,
0.0356809199,
-0.0182343274,
0.0165058877,
0.0001084116,
0.0564337149,
-0.026982246,
-0.0156075554,
0.0189763047,
-0.0310623813,
0.0487533212,
-0.0090831574,
-0.0278726052,
-0.0048585692,
-0.0476772003,
0.0264186878,
-0.0074396473,
0.0179356802,
0.0422564857,
0.0258595645,
0.0463590398,
-0.0438494496,
-0.0393746123,
-0.0115282768,
0.0241995081,
0.0157903042,
-0.0213331487,
-0.0542799979,
0.0601719841,
0.0330186225,
0.0221682806,
0.0098932469,
0.0106172832,
0.0394348651,
-0.050405927,
0.0170762409,
-0.0106187612,
-0.0154799949,
0.0018769808,
-0.0245568659,
0.015637828,
0.0145943733,
0.0069030542,
-0.0551131591,
0.0386275798,
-0.0019027494,
2.792e-7,
0.0681876838,
0.0537916906,
0.0349956527,
-0.0131311771,
0.0293670818,
0.0398968942,
0.007953994,
-0.036692325,
0.0136477659,
-0.1007949561,
-0.000791111,
-0.0182593167,
0.0107573755,
0.031052202,
-0.0715068281,
-0.0724117309,
-0.0231225975,
-0.0462866314,
-0.0115516093,
0.009462554,
0.0408239253,
-0.0118164206,
0.0046744687,
-0.0060802428,
-0.0202059466,
-0.0090819709,
0.0403256863,
-0.0078808358,
0.0119641013,
0.0204751957,
0.0835129395,
-0.0129379183,
0.0411260426,
0.0715293437,
-0.0363525376,
0.0127613917,
0.0028223281,
0.0639566779,
-0.0094771907,
0.0309808869,
-0.0173702333,
-0.0451731943,
0.042502597,
-0.002688675,
0.0003056793,
-0.0165932216,
-0.0522420257,
-0.0422582589,
-0.017607972,
0.0113327242,
0.0406851843,
0.0422886014,
-0.0072464151,
-0.0033261308,
-0.0150175644,
0.0347839817,
-0.0165342335,
-0.045881249,
-0.0071992115,
0.029645348,
-0.0266562719,
-0.0534143783,
0.0386457704,
-0.0228158869,
0.0089523531,
-0.0697019398,
-0.0080226939,
1.984250076e-34,
0.0206304565,
0.0110359564,
0.0107734762,
-0.0232329462,
0.047298789,
0.0277537443,
-0.003183994,
-0.0175663009,
0.0259405281,
-0.0122233294,
0.0067179301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01352v1 | Describing Images $\textit{Fast and Slow}$: Quantifying and Predicting the Variation in Human Signals during Visuo-Linguistic Processes | 2024-02-02T12:11:16 | 2024-02-02T12:11:16 | Ece Takmaz, Sandro Pezzelle, Raquel Fernández | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | There is an intricate relation between the properties of an image and how
humans behave while describing the image. This behavior shows ample variation,
as manifested in human signals such as eye movements and when humans start to
describe the image. Despite the value of such signals of visuo-linguistic
variation, they are virtually disregarded in the training of current pretrained
models, which motivates further investigation. Using a corpus of Dutch image
descriptions with concurrently collected eye-tracking data, we explore the
nature of the variation in visuo-linguistic signals, and find that they
correlate with each other. Given this result, we hypothesize that variation
stems partly from the properties of the images, and explore whether image
representations encoded by pretrained vision encoders can capture such
variation. Our results indicate that pretrained models do so to a
weak-to-moderate degree, suggesting that the models lack biases about what
makes a stimulus complex for humans and what leads to variations in human
outputs. | [
0.0097258883,
0.0380448103,
-0.0383378901,
0.0379962251,
0.0076138009,
0.0213009734,
-0.0232177675,
0.0067328806,
-0.0209702365,
-0.0685341731,
-0.0546451919,
-0.071079351,
0.0530773923,
0.0749512538,
0.01270968,
-0.1259235293,
-0.0045931316,
-0.0136929695,
-0.034782663,
-0.003286612,
0.033705283,
-0.0402131304,
0.0143699115,
0.0301806703,
0.0007334829,
0.0094412854,
-0.0436920971,
0.0089812288,
0.0068735126,
0.0040542837,
0.0116164964,
0.06780231,
-0.0075494843,
-0.0398531891,
0.0000019736,
-0.0027293414,
0.0904393643,
-0.0588181429,
0.0276170205,
0.0419902056,
0.0085874544,
-0.0303433519,
-0.0037860945,
-0.04176227,
-0.0218309183,
-0.052040901,
0.0794032663,
0.0044828495,
0.0470255688,
0.0304878466,
-0.0058722799,
-0.0259840358,
-0.0240686275,
-0.0547470674,
0.0393858179,
0.0011342508,
0.0065874951,
-0.0250852015,
0.0081789279,
0.0050416137,
-0.1023389846,
-0.0227200985,
0.0220739432,
0.0796269849,
0.0603126846,
0.0366877504,
-0.0077701346,
-0.0328095816,
-0.0280308947,
0.082989946,
-0.0187232867,
-0.0340880416,
-0.0341297239,
-0.0095055634,
0.0023659409,
0.0154836029,
0.0115646636,
0.0263393205,
-0.0170073975,
-0.0001095462,
-0.0641908795,
0.041637443,
-0.0133749237,
-0.0092832353,
-0.0005622948,
-0.0374558754,
-0.0031288213,
-0.0056457566,
0.0115819825,
0.0301725119,
-0.0072757266,
-0.0486364514,
-0.0062902826,
-0.0256125573,
0.0275883749,
-0.0577226095,
-0.0501290448,
-0.0365068763,
-0.0049233399,
-0.0309478901,
0.0518603735,
-0.0041022399,
-0.0909345746,
0.0144222667,
0.0178064555,
0.1143298075,
-0.0613465197,
0.0121455789,
-0.0742489398,
0.0115706073,
-0.061747916,
-0.0136984922,
-0.0078746825,
-0.0288611799,
0.0124906301,
-0.0322623551,
-0.0525749139,
0.0199683122,
-0.0308339186,
-0.0269275531,
-0.0503298827,
0.054626707,
-0.0268972199,
0.0068885256,
-0.0703221187,
0.0085653411,
-0.025256265,
0.0291365553,
-0.039017994,
-0.0467933156,
-0.0044740457,
0.0581436157,
-0.00304572,
-0.0037735279,
-0.0007389336,
0.0327349603,
-0.0087464359,
0.0107693346,
0.0105947535,
0.0011834162,
0.0007821207,
-0.0270113107,
0.0365448557,
-0.0238788705,
0.027666647,
0.0073189656,
0.0162657425,
-0.0482883006,
-0.023640044,
-0.0184813552,
-0.0089030312,
0.0653493255,
-0.056366384,
0.0024964099,
-0.023878552,
-0.0055813091,
0.020567378,
0.0315835066,
0.0313746482,
0.0180860925,
-0.0168832969,
-0.0409902819,
0.0304775983,
0.026213076,
-0.0167346708,
0.0098276809,
-0.0269255992,
-0.0398375206,
0.0295315627,
0.0229681097,
0.0985054672,
0.0493788384,
-0.0428010225,
-0.0701665804,
0.0699001551,
0.0690446496,
0.005784072,
0.0000823365,
0.0602131858,
0.0054513551,
0.0382201895,
0.0513298847,
-0.0162402112,
0.046786353,
0.0633001104,
0.0177257918,
-0.0500481389,
0.028147826,
-0.058841873,
-0.0350621156,
-0.003446189,
-0.044229053,
0.0443683527,
-0.006830438,
0.017329108,
0.0079277325,
0.0013028622,
0.0293296706,
0.0127557945,
0.0033135107,
-0.0025535135,
-0.0301021319,
-0.0026283646,
0.0883317217,
-0.0324261747,
0.0393654369,
0.0279809665,
-0.0031269991,
0.0120510748,
0.0156361237,
0.0227099732,
0.0233372133,
0.0430601425,
-0.0368980132,
-0.060004767,
-0.0586927943,
0.0086194593,
0.0168010928,
-0.0364209153,
-0.0242748726,
0.0035231477,
0.0193918534,
-0.0249980502,
0.0297415033,
0.0379072838,
0.0152627779,
-0.0023091834,
0.0064961128,
0.0262021273,
-0.0282127876,
-0.0076113683,
0.0241871793,
0.0083682435,
0.0032867426,
0.0773744807,
0.0712502077,
-0.0189393498,
0.008144862,
0.0080857109,
-0.0644987747,
0.0019353179,
0.0219045989,
0.0162529591,
-0.0301733799,
0.0102767833,
-0.0683451444,
-0.0260616299,
-0.0055417856,
0.0156580526,
0.0201667193,
0.0394330211,
0.0259404387,
0.0323072784,
-0.0096653812,
-0.0020972455,
-0.0119736325,
0.0143455109,
0.0337228775,
-0.0317852721,
-0.0077854376,
0.0118803419,
-0.0057470691,
0.0037008785,
0.0000397181,
-0.0182915628,
-0.0439852327,
0.0319414549,
-0.0383875892,
-0.0439614318,
-0.0241392404,
-0.0366867222,
0.0126353325,
-0.0086123375,
-0.0011072017,
-0.0383747518,
-0.0270409137,
0.0756568611,
-0.0226458386,
0.0081260158,
0.0100887325,
0.0076746759,
-0.0049791997,
-0.0211160518,
-0.0003847036,
0.0391896889,
0.0696953163,
0.0105330851,
-0.0223229714,
-0.0575022772,
0.0408696085,
-0.004206344,
0.0330787934,
0.0059627681,
-0.0430295579,
0.0392752253,
0.0096799722,
0.0065930737,
0.0938050374,
0.0477413833,
0.0585746691,
0.0582771562,
-0.0013404523,
-0.0191633198,
-0.0499523766,
-0.0183936805,
-0.0019586321,
-0.020856427,
-0.0377646759,
0.0152409961,
0.0408417471,
0.0373575315,
0.0335387811,
-0.0967360288,
0.0041947868,
0.0138008343,
-0.0619109161,
-0.0239296332,
-0.0013479171,
-0.0199760683,
0.0570236854,
-0.0262528099,
-0.0723542944,
0.0575507991,
0.0106599033,
-0.0210247915,
0.0191535018,
0.0451070219,
0.018517606,
0.0580932237,
0.024183318,
0.0064421459,
0.0025979565,
0.0296450183,
-0.0430705547,
0.0183658563,
0.0418562926,
0.0149853099,
0.0201694444,
-0.034401644,
-0.0337071121,
-0.012356923,
-0.0217016358,
-0.0262784101,
-0.0144804548,
-0.0380805098,
-0.0072460137,
-0.0052820407,
0.0228547435,
-0.0067854729,
0.0366822407,
0.0123400306,
-0.0022323334,
-0.0071226982,
-0.0337464735,
-0.0049091,
0.0175859965,
0.0496016257,
0.0210477393,
-0.0414987877,
-0.0845933259,
-0.0221361872,
0.0571636558,
-0.0148099894,
0.0585268587,
-0.0982146561,
0.0595630147,
-0.0079211742,
0.0072637456,
-0.0285412427,
0.0558869354,
0.0097474484,
-0.0138759725,
-0.0112796025,
0.054282371,
0.0101998383,
-0.0316474847,
0.0367978513,
0.0311423223,
-0.0024457169,
0.0169499125,
0.0115797855,
-0.0673943385,
-0.0206142366,
-0.047680743,
-0.006348331,
0.0234934762,
0.0089194365,
0.0026026033,
-0.0387737155,
0.0306320507,
0.0627303347,
-0.0172077473,
-0.0478401966,
0.0086278133,
0.0040602074,
-0.0006776985,
-0.0072878571,
-0.0305456799,
-0.0000230283,
0.042071905,
0.0356028788,
0.0136050247,
-0.0194570981,
0.0089006843,
-0.0438310057,
-0.0148138516,
0.0589528158,
-0.0420271531,
0.00269454,
-0.0449361354,
-0.019276673,
-0.019433219,
0.0206181072,
0.0080720549,
0.0627399161,
-0.0256967656,
-0.0520052947,
-0.0299922824,
0.0115357162,
-0.0279330425,
-0.0316123813,
-0.0374222174,
-0.0222061966,
-0.0555940866,
-0.0100482861,
-0.035309758,
-0.0092570651,
-0.014421056,
0.0146069368,
0.0070666405,
-0.0775675401,
-0.005905428,
-0.0092281299,
0.0202660915,
-0.0294088181,
-0.0781706646,
0.0267670751,
0.0309565756,
-0.0312470831,
-0.0454634987,
-0.070589833,
-0.0494718775,
0.02037552,
0.0121937748,
-0.0619056672,
0.0599231198,
-0.0289576333,
-0.0682493299,
0.0932697132,
0.0397879854,
-0.0060836039,
-0.0488706194,
-0.0788383558,
0.0347426608,
-0.0080133937,
-0.0110036302,
-0.005965238,
-0.0675223917,
-0.0251144934,
0.0210098177,
0.0360523388,
0.0140430164,
0.0533394255,
0.0214394424,
-0.0558355488,
-0.0153314834,
0.0037344676,
0.0202984102,
0.057209976,
-0.0194323082,
-0.020812856,
-0.014585834,
-0.0172443707,
-0.0323392525,
0.0130122565,
0.0194578711,
-0.0403572395,
-0.0166199394,
-0.0698339343,
0.0173976701,
-0.0243400019,
0.0665469021,
-0.0350664444,
0.0215783529,
-0.0012995305,
-0.019285934,
0.0431256779,
0.0129886512,
-0.0424098633,
-0.0216338597,
0.0508878715,
0.0371323302,
-0.0116460733,
0.0087101124,
-0.0020835153,
-0.0185440518,
-0.0523291901,
-0.0137360096,
0.001994245,
-0.022843549,
-0.0522571541,
0.0477920994,
0.027835831,
0.043232128,
-0.0098117935,
0.0249507651,
0.0276882779,
0.0442224704,
0.0291910116,
0.0331708975,
-0.011121178,
0.0041177669,
-0.0042091398,
-0.0285980869,
-0.0336789414,
-0.0216839127,
0.0091099553,
-0.0506881252,
0.0094878254,
-0.0135655645,
0.0271679275,
-0.0508365706,
0.0351773426,
0.0046372884,
0.0046709049,
0.023766702,
-0.0030540018,
-0.0039064786,
-0.0138472775,
0.0559140667,
-0.0056106457,
0.0102444477,
-0.0097546009,
-0.0141619258,
-0.0582886413,
-0.0016890781,
0.038981054,
-0.0200585406,
-0.0078657418,
0.0425434597,
0.0001693363,
-0.0434349962,
0.0433772653,
-0.005207615,
0.0657099634,
0.0326728746,
0.108490333,
0.0385337584,
-0.0359989069,
0.0150055755,
-0.0071521495,
-0.0539642386,
0.0119981486,
0.0143430578,
-0.0195861831,
-5.633735205e-33,
-0.0038917135,
-0.000632267,
-0.0178170186,
-0.0251724459,
0.0002159637,
-0.0157311019,
-0.0061811162,
0.0199242607,
0.0085514756,
0.0212161839,
0.0609957613,
0.0093956226,
0.0125560975,
0.0071866005,
0.0361764617,
-0.0155244153,
0.0174137354,
-0.0166958626,
-0.0290246569,
-0.026602095,
0.0424060635,
-0.0204949751,
0.0471688434,
-0.0787350088,
0.0076998146,
0.0096983677,
-0.0238970295,
-0.0305778347,
0.0593497269,
0.0641234219,
-0.0494928546,
0.0602396429,
0.0190108102,
0.0210636593,
-0.0281466786,
-0.0031925635,
-0.0254394803,
-0.0138535872,
0.0048426287,
0.0822332054,
-0.0638886541,
-0.0111761475,
0.0756618306,
-0.0153364167,
-0.0423257388,
-0.0194758661,
0.0605161041,
-0.028886456,
0.0146502601,
-0.015754953,
-0.0469157398,
-0.0268627256,
-0.0362144932,
-0.0358921364,
0.0553027578,
0.0283502545,
-0.0333471484,
-0.0090912087,
-0.0338159278,
0.0412190594,
-0.0260124877,
0.0100308321,
0.0234160498,
0.0396314114,
0.0587862581,
0.044492472,
0.0731468648,
0.0199171398,
-0.0166738722,
-0.0148135712,
0.0527161472,
0.00656466,
0.0244871601,
0.0344596729,
0.0520065501,
-0.0044674925,
-0.0152349491,
0.0023103496,
-0.0494889654,
0.0717188865,
-0.0062511382,
0.0229062233,
-0.0296572726,
-0.0191219356,
-0.003657121,
-0.0014209558,
-0.0178322941,
-0.0128158899,
0.0276898351,
-0.0079852333,
0.0472861305,
0.0030224684,
0.0569241941,
-0.0284977891,
0.0208692085,
-0.0562727451,
-0.0471705534,
0.0650868714,
0.0259568598,
-0.0203911345,
-0.0221791845,
-0.0349753685,
0.0550037734,
0.008680271,
0.0426066704,
0.0191296246,
-0.0119075002,
-0.0025837976,
-0.0157575309,
-0.0283637177,
-0.005005267,
-0.0350230224,
0.0258578621,
-0.0292847026,
0.053548459,
0.0133270118,
-0.0506331548,
0.0294156913,
-0.0714773685,
-0.0604404584,
-0.0360259451,
-0.0480343066,
0.015331259,
0.0663792714,
-0.0151434466,
0.0200101342,
-0.0597602427,
-0.0245635286,
0.0025547943,
-0.0247866772,
-0.0167624149,
0.0386427157,
2.704e-7,
0.0143982498,
0.0140963094,
0.0156060299,
0.0083756475,
0.0479696505,
0.0327229947,
-0.0103143649,
0.0208424777,
-0.0176773891,
-0.0752267912,
0.023999745,
0.0573057495,
0.0301967598,
-0.0562123917,
-0.0075435112,
0.0134603912,
-0.0103071034,
0.0319897942,
-0.0244430061,
0.0036887825,
0.0467425548,
0.0348423123,
-0.0339089446,
0.0311279334,
0.0448163748,
-0.0151274297,
0.1138074622,
-0.0273082517,
0.0280057192,
-0.0161229018,
0.0262102857,
-0.0007223372,
-0.0160213802,
0.0771668702,
-0.015863372,
-0.0304614771,
0.0488852262,
-0.0230629481,
-0.0513205118,
-0.016510902,
-0.0170358513,
0.0154847289,
0.0015454814,
-0.0218750574,
0.0452550799,
-0.0432888083,
-0.0318008885,
0.0062601757,
-0.0242280103,
0.0265934765,
0.0545391627,
-0.0166925341,
-0.0242087301,
0.0048369565,
0.0396267325,
0.0149476118,
-0.0446341708,
-0.0581068695,
-0.0238804389,
0.0086760595,
-0.0678987056,
-0.0070204758,
-0.0525755025,
0.0167277791,
0.0824042037,
0.03489599,
-0.0278887562,
1.330251282e-34,
0.0210593846,
0.0316255167,
0.0543597713,
0.0022826528,
-0.0077131446,
-0.0395677239,
-0.0221772976,
0.0142658986,
0.0248169806,
-0.0206148438,
-0.018023232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01349v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01349v2 | Beyond the Answers: Reviewing the Rationality of Multiple Choice Question Answering for the Evaluation of Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T12:07:00 | 2024-05-30T01:57:14 | Haochun Wang, Sendong Zhao, Zewen Qiang, Nuwa Xi, Bing Qin, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the field of natural language processing (NLP), Large Language Models
(LLMs) have precipitated a paradigm shift, markedly enhancing performance in
natural language generation tasks. Despite these advancements, the
comprehensive evaluation of LLMs remains an inevitable challenge for the
community. Recently, the utilization of Multiple Choice Question Answering
(MCQA) as a benchmark for LLMs has gained considerable traction. This study
first investigates the limitations of MCQA as an evaluation method for LLMs and
then analyzes the fundamental reason for the limitations of MCQA, that while
LLMs may select the correct answers, it is possible that they also recognize
other wrong options as correct. Finally, we propose a dataset augmenting method
for Multiple-Choice Questions (MCQs), MCQA+, that can more accurately reflect
the performance of the model, which underscores the need for more robust
evaluation mechanisms in assessing the performance of LLMs. | [
0.0597997829,
0.0576246679,
-0.0123515278,
0.0354833193,
-0.0578242019,
0.0324514061,
0.0238813572,
-0.0044162599,
0.0265263859,
-0.0735643134,
0.003960236,
-0.0402810313,
-0.0156724732,
-0.0185409151,
0.0273778196,
0.0042253006,
0.02942238,
-0.0391742066,
-0.0106345322,
0.0016111113,
0.0107889827,
0.0249736067,
0.0233085658,
0.0357866697,
0.0116393333,
-0.0038321079,
0.0061174063,
-0.0082140928,
0.0059722513,
-0.0341868661,
-0.001498503,
0.0621602498,
0.0120687215,
0.0318133682,
0.0000018384,
-0.0767295361,
0.0132297818,
-0.0090845069,
-0.0569565371,
0.0285359807,
0.0262263827,
0.0423534773,
0.0454493798,
0.0464654043,
-0.0131643582,
-0.0052379039,
0.027481176,
0.0255199596,
0.061284408,
0.0526708737,
0.0275176931,
-0.0321408883,
0.0150962127,
-0.0106910355,
0.0052693081,
-0.0256502759,
0.0431711562,
0.0342002325,
0.0057359785,
0.0008761708,
0.0047612935,
0.0020693734,
0.0090725645,
0.025876347,
-0.0059860004,
0.0239238571,
-0.0339202248,
-0.0269749872,
-0.0069422792,
0.0853827596,
0.0075482032,
-0.0053465734,
-0.0174108613,
-0.0187240634,
-0.0079040891,
0.0330027379,
-0.0436375365,
0.0258576293,
-0.0127021801,
0.012120096,
0.015687624,
-0.0072055049,
0.0072702314,
0.0508491434,
-0.0147443628,
0.0666585639,
0.0217069332,
-0.0209649019,
0.0263249185,
0.0238590743,
-0.0565101206,
-0.0529220365,
0.023017142,
0.0391026288,
-0.0552234277,
0.0243131481,
-0.0349616595,
-0.0017661399,
0.0571286306,
-0.0509409867,
0.0456503779,
0.0137957325,
-0.001722091,
0.0346293747,
-0.0307386182,
0.0707932487,
-0.0169630889,
0.0033457037,
-0.0810055435,
-0.0231385082,
-0.0261313152,
-0.0298959836,
-0.0168248191,
0.0558587871,
-0.0448674634,
-0.0258387625,
-0.0268282648,
0.0137669146,
0.0210974291,
0.0002704383,
0.0134554589,
0.0428453386,
-0.0001909635,
0.0120564578,
-0.0758042559,
0.0487166122,
-0.033822231,
0.0407898836,
0.035793867,
-0.069887042,
-0.0030165035,
0.0107986396,
0.0311133806,
-0.0406800285,
0.0366214924,
0.0731851682,
0.0021727504,
-0.0334960856,
-0.0296909902,
-0.0379532278,
-0.0315739065,
-0.073808901,
-0.007873619,
-0.0836567357,
0.0257796925,
0.0466545336,
-0.0042513525,
-0.004275471,
0.0326865725,
0.0580212176,
-0.0196523312,
0.0340203643,
0.0014583824,
0.0275312848,
0.0529564247,
-0.0051120147,
0.0229319036,
0.0653458089,
0.0349717848,
-0.0000219819,
0.0519503467,
-0.0181545988,
0.0254755281,
0.0380333923,
-0.0067339377,
0.010728918,
-0.0260204822,
0.0621104017,
-0.014303688,
0.0353819616,
0.0075040236,
0.0693334416,
-0.0157675501,
-0.0347006768,
0.0484457538,
0.0579721108,
-0.0141855916,
-0.016782606,
0.0275339279,
-0.0065875007,
0.020904772,
0.0063251536,
0.0091175614,
0.0024957126,
-0.0499653108,
0.0193085819,
0.0464623086,
0.048828233,
-0.0134129394,
-0.0574416779,
-0.0526062101,
0.024248004,
0.0024765211,
0.0667024702,
0.0303805321,
-0.0072956244,
-0.0407999046,
0.029435683,
-0.0071293935,
-0.039880354,
0.0021448038,
-0.0616653971,
0.0672993436,
0.0425562374,
0.0754687637,
0.0122656971,
-0.0576655753,
-0.0156193795,
0.0052111559,
0.0426399671,
0.0466774628,
-0.0261704121,
0.0052197217,
-0.0297499485,
-0.0026849573,
-0.0099743679,
-0.0006792796,
0.0004118218,
0.0202790536,
-0.0088026952,
0.0151968068,
-0.0176214445,
-0.0514419228,
0.0450411662,
-0.0164919719,
-0.0476150289,
0.0115630599,
-0.0260230768,
0.0291179288,
0.0082862992,
-0.0250852909,
0.0356322974,
0.0331302062,
-0.0172644965,
-0.0315654911,
-0.0390252732,
-0.0342662036,
-0.0518536009,
0.0421574973,
-0.0206130203,
-0.0113275843,
0.0502835251,
-0.0431361459,
-0.0449713916,
-0.026921669,
-0.0476544835,
-0.0086851474,
-0.0338069201,
0.0052788393,
0.0122536486,
0.0163554773,
-0.0694019645,
0.0756618902,
-0.0086046867,
0.0753611699,
-0.0002590766,
0.051901333,
0.0210362766,
-0.0165107083,
-0.0224744622,
0.0293393712,
0.0024095916,
0.0090537034,
0.0340423249,
0.0184934456,
-0.0787955374,
-0.01604243,
-0.0756961554,
0.0310576335,
-0.004750818,
0.0109498212,
0.0323377401,
-0.0024682747,
-0.0259799417,
-0.006914604,
-0.0682455972,
-0.0245190579,
0.068561323,
0.0203631595,
0.0314280353,
-0.0222044084,
0.019596966,
-0.0483059809,
-0.0017480901,
0.0043839905,
0.0651754811,
-0.0016076061,
0.0294463001,
-0.0419935249,
0.0182007607,
-0.0513404906,
-0.0268625803,
0.0250068642,
-0.0106868222,
0.008967666,
0.0014170852,
0.0288622845,
0.0210509486,
0.0179912616,
0.0003778253,
0.0525243059,
0.0014870004,
-0.0291829836,
-0.0057812175,
-0.0285732821,
-0.0310928691,
-0.0045817262,
-0.0391279571,
-0.0221072473,
0.0589410365,
0.0263293162,
-0.0175466388,
0.0068197115,
0.0377329439,
-0.0191940255,
-0.0279095229,
-0.0737833232,
-0.0301730651,
-0.0018660112,
0.0619263239,
-0.0170626733,
-0.0451894552,
0.0663978457,
-0.0536270998,
0.0040259822,
-0.0635409281,
-0.0025697637,
-0.0464600809,
0.040740177,
0.0113986442,
0.0049800863,
0.0026465158,
-0.0083314376,
-0.0354602821,
-0.017019432,
-0.0160432868,
-0.0799159929,
0.0505323894,
-0.0623508468,
0.0039399085,
-0.0040492248,
-0.0115072299,
-0.0386293717,
-0.0474216901,
-0.0413090326,
-0.0014483703,
0.03230552,
0.0122433752,
-0.0058518848,
0.0187999383,
0.0230843574,
-0.0039435434,
-0.0354478173,
-0.0103621762,
-0.0156156681,
0.1172963902,
0.0720631704,
0.0629619956,
0.0588525608,
-0.0161280259,
0.0410651118,
0.0416886508,
0.042780865,
0.0246279854,
-0.020782901,
0.0103856372,
0.0228809938,
-0.0244288128,
-0.0037122606,
0.0159522705,
0.0597342104,
-0.0500131659,
-0.0421563201,
0.1088074744,
0.0670872182,
0.0155273303,
0.0026145694,
-0.0015582803,
0.0254935026,
0.0290337261,
0.0255720224,
-0.0603680164,
-0.0380269997,
-0.0107247047,
0.0223584473,
-0.0319087803,
-0.0297250673,
-0.0095238695,
-0.1364308298,
0.0276307259,
-0.0006021071,
-0.0546389632,
0.0068099089,
-0.0594888031,
-0.0154146738,
-0.0125374757,
0.0228839573,
0.0041431254,
-0.0044670571,
0.0130273318,
0.0507457145,
-0.0118054235,
-0.0385788977,
0.0425184406,
-0.0354962796,
0.0404035039,
0.0561928004,
0.0242937654,
-0.0026496053,
0.0044949357,
0.0158433504,
-0.062001422,
-0.0060087843,
-0.0167034026,
0.0191973615,
0.0230025575,
-0.0083596921,
-0.0490888394,
0.0209105425,
-0.034623608,
-0.0050149756,
0.036338415,
0.0622243062,
-0.0173776802,
0.0043402929,
-0.0204541888,
0.0170231014,
-0.0311110131,
0.0774820521,
0.0223294441,
-0.0427990407,
-0.0387642495,
-0.0363251455,
-0.0042634062,
-0.0479692407,
-0.0365264267,
0.0304303151,
0.0072992137,
0.0408789031,
-0.0707687363,
-0.036941804,
0.0636273623,
0.005592478,
-0.0315009058,
0.0308614541,
-0.0007033756,
0.0223388858,
-0.0161478817,
0.0222254191,
-0.0159173273,
0.0128811309,
-0.0261198506,
0.0004444023,
0.0085058538,
-0.0230671149,
-0.0188719463,
0.036094036,
-0.1032984927,
-0.053750921,
-0.0439577028,
0.0084291799,
0.0242545269,
-0.0129346019,
-0.0117735239,
-0.0669973642,
0.0237129852,
0.0218192078,
-0.0165813956,
0.0148990685,
-0.0440942608,
0.0213072337,
-0.0042838198,
0.0073402817,
-0.0212891381,
0.0040883496,
0.0022425051,
0.0670104325,
-0.0037914556,
-0.0338052735,
0.059426114,
0.0439410321,
0.0108950222,
-0.0075233644,
0.0202074554,
-0.0166529417,
-0.0035411504,
-0.022014875,
-0.037487708,
-0.0213647019,
-0.006171464,
0.031140618,
-0.0363099352,
-0.0245229155,
-0.036580231,
-0.0291865151,
0.0610082559,
-0.0395041145,
0.0084096454,
0.0418322533,
-0.0121452976,
0.0037443934,
-0.0154608861,
-0.0463270172,
-0.0156622715,
-0.0265507214,
0.0264803525,
0.0064862771,
0.0743481293,
-0.0260430351,
-0.0013359993,
0.0287679974,
-0.007090997,
-0.0652837083,
-0.0533124134,
-0.045885697,
0.037746463,
0.0367179848,
-0.0099023078,
0.0417216048,
0.0078041898,
-0.0152975982,
-0.050687436,
0.0060424521,
0.0008613019,
-0.0319021158,
0.0706152618,
0.0214615632,
-0.0259824712,
0.0000593407,
0.0896347165,
0.0520088114,
0.0374538675,
0.0141399158,
-0.0395024195,
-0.027541453,
-0.0416914187,
-0.017497398,
0.00639477,
-0.0035969371,
0.0170251969,
-0.0506251529,
-0.0699896514,
-0.0034451068,
0.0216651671,
0.0430850498,
-0.0224130787,
0.0226251278,
0.0630328283,
0.0086597074,
-0.0265231393,
-0.0695323274,
0.021201387,
-0.0655043051,
0.0100924084,
-0.0254049338,
-6.3513532e-33,
-0.0296569038,
-0.0399344489,
0.047297284,
-0.0557835512,
-0.0173082966,
0.0002288423,
-0.0230357964,
-0.0030550852,
-0.0173756946,
-0.0254102238,
-0.013015219,
-0.0044054096,
-0.0089096399,
0.0520402268,
0.0177253336,
-0.050038483,
0.0090582268,
-0.0276049338,
-0.0326467901,
0.0121397004,
0.0343465507,
-0.0000542202,
0.0296502896,
0.0132369408,
-0.010385152,
-0.023479322,
-0.0100936368,
0.0029747842,
-0.0449124277,
0.0891934261,
-0.035408847,
0.059066698,
0.0291800778,
-0.0419578068,
0.0034730139,
0.0474751741,
-0.0361270048,
-0.0341146253,
0.0286376793,
-0.0136164287,
-0.0217904933,
-0.0082275821,
0.0296564158,
0.0011040726,
-0.0085713193,
0.014721578,
0.0128516415,
-0.036507871,
-0.0223559383,
-0.0148218507,
-0.0286630616,
0.0207937714,
-0.022144312,
-0.0106097823,
-0.0451048128,
0.079620406,
-0.0466192029,
0.0486947484,
-0.0292082373,
0.0138873309,
0.0664087087,
0.0143310595,
0.0574770197,
0.0359529071,
-0.0068106884,
0.0390588753,
0.0021271883,
-0.0362645574,
-0.0114150746,
-0.0036101672,
-0.0228957534,
0.0319191366,
0.0676340461,
0.0565863326,
0.0236470811,
0.0078371242,
-0.0839000866,
0.0380449556,
-0.0048227711,
0.009286033,
0.0411130525,
-0.0400205441,
-0.0156540442,
-0.0313729085,
-0.0854212642,
0.0213018544,
-0.0352271087,
-0.0059565222,
0.0629731789,
-0.0100085512,
-0.0102786655,
0.0078656618,
0.0419861861,
-0.0401744805,
-0.0305741988,
0.0093189515,
-0.0378927998,
0.0319483243,
0.0049143643,
0.0400939099,
-0.07478863,
0.0103804329,
0.0241281241,
-0.0302625261,
-0.0212886948,
-0.0082736434,
-0.0019786349,
-0.0049658432,
-0.0677366257,
0.0054700598,
-0.0589967072,
0.0078412937,
-0.0180042516,
-0.0114721283,
0.0340511389,
-0.0033134194,
-0.0198239237,
0.0497621186,
-0.009843017,
-0.0085122362,
-0.0236476213,
-0.0401131846,
-0.0110320747,
0.0288693327,
-0.0228127073,
0.021752663,
-0.0289667696,
-0.0023469413,
0.0099161956,
-0.0311891474,
-0.0078537529,
0.0252157282,
2.5e-7,
0.0771962404,
0.0578108579,
-0.0121584348,
0.027723236,
-0.0050698533,
0.0140149463,
-0.0274516474,
0.0309857614,
0.0323133282,
-0.0046539018,
-0.0080584595,
0.0153913824,
0.0504235551,
0.0400444418,
-0.0276633836,
-0.0170446876,
-0.0815502927,
0.0024400488,
-0.0593174584,
-0.0090986742,
0.0758654922,
0.0956417844,
-0.0111911176,
-0.0239174701,
-0.0340377279,
-0.0304645728,
0.0650116876,
-0.0387094915,
-0.0218518898,
0.0095955506,
0.038727425,
0.037029285,
0.0288644936,
0.0480148979,
0.0093166446,
0.0052483305,
0.0250286423,
0.0444180407,
0.0371293351,
-0.0458421744,
-0.0146744838,
-0.016154144,
0.0115569644,
-0.0803665817,
0.099499397,
-0.0545417815,
-0.0232757498,
-0.0470046736,
-0.0211389381,
-0.0198602062,
0.0374491997,
-0.0407039821,
-0.0064958944,
0.0041003828,
0.0051928405,
-0.0037733358,
-0.0025174702,
-0.0366511159,
0.0090599125,
0.0266085397,
-0.0484173819,
-0.0618805178,
-0.0483270697,
-0.00806008,
-0.0006067973,
-0.0617723987,
-0.0170865301,
2.225575393e-34,
0.0204294734,
-0.0219267979,
0.0023481082,
0.0138382567,
0.0513998643,
-0.0178867988,
0.0009059481,
-0.0029376587,
-0.0229836181,
-0.1160947755,
0.0020211444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01345v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01345v6 | Skip \n: A Simple Method to Reduce Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-02-02T12:02:46 | 2024-05-08T02:15:45 | Zongbo Han, Zechen Bai, Haiyang Mei, Qianli Xu, Changqing Zhang, Mike Zheng Shou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advancements in large vision-language models (LVLMs) have demonstrated
impressive capability in visual information understanding with human language.
Despite these advances, LVLMs still face challenges with multimodal
hallucination, such as generating text descriptions of objects that are not
present in the visual information. However, the underlying fundamental reasons
of multimodal hallucinations remain poorly explored. In this paper, we propose
a new perspective, suggesting that the inherent biases in LVLMs might be a key
factor in hallucinations. Specifically, we systematically identify a semantic
shift bias related to paragraph breaks (\n\n), where the content before and
after '\n\n' in the training data frequently exhibit significant semantic
changes. This pattern leads the model to infer that the contents following
'\n\n' should be obviously different from the preceding contents with less
hallucinatory descriptions, thereby increasing the probability of hallucinatory
descriptions subsequent to the '\n\n'. We have validated this hypothesis on
multiple publicly available LVLMs. Besides, we find that deliberately inserting
'\n\n' at the generated description can induce more hallucinations. A simple
method is proposed to effectively mitigate the hallucination of LVLMs by
skipping the output of '\n'. | [
-0.0104903691,
0.047697302,
0.0109890755,
0.0607862622,
-0.039636001,
0.0202308353,
-0.0218081009,
0.0132702617,
-0.0032703187,
-0.0659730732,
-0.0069694868,
-0.0665973201,
0.0512050614,
0.0250116847,
0.0556056276,
-0.0750311464,
0.0360451452,
-0.0690040439,
-0.0490715653,
0.0118638743,
-0.0144547895,
-0.0301306155,
-0.0079755187,
0.0164677035,
-0.0172206592,
-0.0633868799,
-0.0112623069,
0.0156658851,
0.0125008384,
-0.0246402975,
-0.0659984201,
0.0211196728,
-0.0143063776,
0.0232336372,
0.0000018795,
-0.0347677693,
0.0255433004,
0.0046683592,
0.0312999561,
0.0164958537,
0.0229332112,
-0.0555013977,
-0.0040920032,
-0.0199253485,
-0.0033269292,
-0.0336016715,
0.0656300411,
0.0799825415,
0.0220316518,
0.0628606975,
-0.0155836307,
-0.0410333425,
0.005822666,
0.0122812418,
0.0762810558,
0.018287003,
0.0570402667,
-0.0064622327,
-0.0251793358,
-0.0385497771,
-0.0546419099,
0.0051876944,
0.0228303839,
0.0033924677,
0.0154857552,
0.0543220863,
-0.0580509938,
-0.037089508,
-0.0246329978,
0.0451158136,
-0.0626830161,
-0.0379054733,
0.0110066039,
0.0317584425,
0.0197769124,
-0.0330671594,
-0.0335027054,
0.0761635453,
-0.0321896113,
0.0144273154,
-0.0345920995,
-0.0205761772,
0.026870003,
-0.0156487823,
-0.0553932562,
0.0371748805,
0.009916936,
-0.0144393602,
0.0368007906,
0.0120595489,
-0.0304777641,
-0.0441512279,
-0.010582488,
0.0031655536,
-0.0280360691,
-0.0244126562,
-0.0597293712,
0.0131337298,
0.0001602822,
-0.0779988095,
0.0324560814,
-0.0175145809,
-0.0779633522,
0.0405481495,
-0.0577711836,
0.0397403948,
-0.0259887874,
0.0695304498,
-0.0166779887,
0.0152836516,
-0.0020835095,
-0.0114069944,
-0.0239581186,
-0.0014777387,
-0.0280188881,
-0.0704483166,
-0.0087480014,
0.00375783,
-0.0256509595,
0.0169154275,
-0.0449548997,
0.0176819768,
0.0159981996,
-0.0312741324,
0.0054007089,
0.0026432474,
0.0263015348,
-0.021121813,
-0.0137184327,
-0.0693551973,
-0.0136209829,
0.0726632029,
-0.0165887401,
0.0087367985,
-0.0459268391,
0.0904944614,
-0.0114647383,
-0.004435984,
-0.0323304906,
0.0050593424,
-0.042408783,
-0.0347362794,
0.0361827277,
-0.0380119085,
-0.0070268959,
-0.0136288479,
0.0073216027,
-0.0105279004,
0.0364702716,
0.0299027003,
-0.0445509367,
0.0820460618,
-0.056757737,
-0.0053921994,
0.0148118213,
0.0198177863,
0.020985188,
0.0489572324,
0.0304899234,
0.0424839258,
0.0164952781,
-0.0216983128,
0.042957522,
0.0218846221,
-0.0420399308,
-0.0070121461,
-0.0996156931,
-0.0391871259,
0.0354144238,
0.0322616696,
0.0590549037,
0.0841311142,
-0.0364348032,
-0.0534845255,
0.0667817667,
0.0281230733,
0.0166401323,
-0.0078063845,
0.0542493947,
0.0123397484,
-0.0100557031,
0.0522875786,
-0.0643729866,
0.0159808658,
-0.0017254241,
0.0146973152,
0.0137798013,
0.0152185876,
-0.0090438453,
-0.0225051623,
-0.0097284541,
-0.0027491041,
0.0164612047,
-0.0229140092,
0.0195398834,
0.0243609324,
-0.056807477,
-0.0170164257,
0.0257967226,
0.0009402343,
0.0163229499,
-0.0330126174,
0.0064836298,
0.0759517699,
0.0394567885,
0.0075067594,
0.0287962332,
-0.0368564539,
0.0432328135,
0.0761424974,
0.006775097,
0.016148163,
0.0263120346,
-0.0470979363,
-0.0087345978,
0.0077982089,
0.019843746,
0.0048783049,
-0.0514886007,
-0.0172777418,
0.0014267354,
-0.0216800105,
-0.026837483,
0.0585174114,
0.0336172879,
-0.0031328204,
-0.0444550477,
0.0038868668,
-0.0156293791,
-0.0136077078,
-0.024299331,
0.0368163176,
0.01135635,
-0.0417401046,
-0.0036744715,
0.0149988839,
-0.0421946533,
-0.0175687931,
0.0163103398,
-0.0467224419,
0.0458108187,
-0.0057178745,
0.0217220038,
-0.0134287979,
0.0001136031,
-0.0341539867,
0.0366142616,
-0.0242383666,
0.0444963537,
0.0230624713,
0.0440322869,
-0.0248500258,
0.0569301769,
-0.0299659669,
-0.0023635866,
0.0084523577,
0.0202288181,
-0.0026505655,
-0.0110326512,
-0.0173085127,
0.0488170497,
-0.0027564249,
0.0229322668,
-0.0260216836,
-0.0330371112,
-0.0457375683,
-0.0115975849,
-0.0519164428,
-0.0144582251,
-0.0153046632,
-0.0396451764,
0.0101113794,
-0.0359962508,
-0.0040753963,
-0.0310398955,
-0.0073690838,
0.041728951,
-0.0197903421,
0.0434503183,
0.014838255,
-0.0051132082,
-0.0381187871,
0.0029895294,
-0.0079671554,
-0.0050035855,
0.0907841101,
-0.0055066235,
-0.0765132234,
-0.1069301218,
0.0333213061,
-0.0300234482,
0.0256855506,
-0.008280878,
0.0052441843,
-0.0043962393,
-0.0041652592,
0.0579077229,
0.1153935343,
0.0431277491,
0.0440509133,
0.0714108124,
-0.0124501782,
0.0090763243,
-0.0390525982,
0.0108051933,
-0.0016968771,
-0.0170927923,
-0.0167123005,
0.0057894504,
0.0523750484,
0.0114134727,
0.0393118374,
-0.0669610724,
0.0251070578,
-0.0304771196,
-0.069308348,
-0.0130688427,
-0.0216222387,
-0.0293701347,
0.0187014919,
-0.0396473296,
-0.0662062988,
0.0172852725,
-0.0272061396,
-0.0140779093,
0.0060928427,
0.0320835523,
-0.001166926,
0.0397065245,
0.0659143031,
0.0347863063,
0.0096167447,
-0.0177775603,
-0.0572476238,
-0.009155456,
-0.0535741448,
-0.0006068252,
0.0473225452,
-0.0464126952,
-0.00798597,
-0.0054469095,
-0.0011382408,
-0.0361304618,
-0.0265835989,
-0.0007320418,
-0.0436184257,
-0.0561828651,
0.0161103066,
-0.0383591615,
0.0353128947,
0.0242617056,
0.0172673147,
-0.0417150855,
-0.0180663653,
-0.0126551064,
0.0233887024,
0.0714367777,
-0.0229601134,
0.0377244279,
-0.0696977302,
0.0176274274,
0.0764314309,
0.013094089,
0.0556335114,
-0.0379274972,
-0.0138769858,
-0.0067004277,
0.0068953247,
-0.0433792286,
0.0390092991,
0.0283724051,
-0.0802355781,
-0.00177301,
0.0437144563,
0.027712239,
-0.0564919785,
0.0144363223,
-0.0088647017,
0.0734915361,
-0.0063629989,
-0.0176636335,
-0.0712146014,
-0.0209761653,
-0.034016706,
-0.0295281485,
0.0156932268,
-0.0145696979,
-0.0345318913,
-0.0569699295,
0.0550602004,
0.0460577235,
-0.0077012782,
-0.0341072716,
0.0319196098,
0.0062884651,
0.0301728398,
0.0191367045,
0.000926138,
-0.0255786721,
-0.0183726847,
0.0308028311,
0.0002965034,
0.0097466242,
-0.0363370366,
-0.0392519422,
0.0170505382,
0.077995494,
0.0087970942,
-0.0149532799,
-0.061036896,
0.0507239923,
-0.0277690385,
0.0189725216,
0.0159092043,
0.0676121265,
-0.0163150039,
-0.0126612373,
0.0348379873,
0.0060504596,
-0.0117277661,
-0.0443417579,
-0.0022858442,
-0.0017547406,
-0.0435064062,
-0.0890903622,
-0.0153811276,
0.0489288568,
-0.0299453363,
0.0620634966,
0.039137274,
-0.0517200008,
-0.0650765672,
-0.0229625739,
0.0276431162,
-0.0200967249,
-0.0245164838,
0.0411749482,
0.063353464,
-0.0390159786,
-0.0664998293,
-0.0463782996,
0.0119671812,
0.0471330844,
0.0004636182,
0.0187932122,
-0.0166632812,
-0.023520153,
-0.0252859294,
0.0340380892,
-0.0228076223,
0.0105625866,
-0.0435446389,
0.0117166499,
0.0258294288,
-0.0290397499,
0.0172551461,
0.0029944105,
-0.09871535,
-0.045766633,
0.0263453331,
0.0298493095,
0.0242401492,
0.0780457854,
0.0193848927,
-0.0455977172,
0.0513078496,
0.033674702,
0.0439170972,
0.0637846589,
-0.011899922,
0.0064436151,
0.0045635574,
0.018516086,
0.0152079742,
-0.0310525913,
0.0226916578,
-0.01041325,
0.0178263616,
0.002181771,
0.0285751224,
-0.0402359441,
0.027452426,
-0.0205833577,
0.0512954146,
0.0087924888,
-0.0094643189,
-0.0254713707,
-0.0100981258,
-0.0380626693,
0.0129285529,
0.0308832657,
0.0284316652,
0.0123526035,
-0.0210444555,
-0.0067884871,
-0.0082087032,
-0.0396146029,
-0.0421948954,
0.0007935455,
-0.0420067981,
0.0508184582,
0.0124795083,
-0.0292142015,
0.0232316628,
-0.0297529586,
0.0382654965,
0.0111713978,
0.0787255242,
0.0336501151,
-0.0310324933,
-0.0422088914,
0.0329366662,
-0.0217915215,
-0.0574966781,
-0.0276061017,
0.0365213528,
0.0369029529,
0.0055918563,
0.0605012998,
-0.0263659433,
0.0146333119,
-0.0407039709,
0.0280253049,
0.0503926091,
-0.0502045453,
0.0124806864,
0.0286439713,
-0.0563118383,
-0.0255535543,
0.0740395263,
0.0227493756,
0.0119300215,
0.020549275,
-0.0141924014,
-0.0459152386,
-0.0297971871,
0.0059206085,
-0.0101915123,
-0.0207700171,
-0.0071646315,
-0.0184937883,
-0.0289896969,
-0.000376007,
0.0082836151,
0.0511915945,
0.0143647399,
0.0214983653,
0.0497049838,
-0.0184295885,
-0.0397566035,
0.0016015866,
-0.0442533642,
0.0758698955,
-0.0001646295,
0.0202663727,
-5.436093829e-33,
-0.0105801048,
-0.0030198141,
0.0220860057,
0.0017962893,
-0.0282761399,
-0.0222699698,
0.001519724,
0.0228737351,
0.0294742733,
0.0276865792,
0.0338150747,
0.0158835072,
0.0234614983,
0.0175177827,
0.0007115952,
-0.0282497872,
0.0613057464,
-0.0015001692,
-0.0179299023,
-0.0091975061,
-0.0129849082,
0.0165067427,
0.0345371999,
-0.0303816888,
0.014545247,
0.007972613,
-0.0443813764,
-0.0094440915,
0.028114697,
0.0467857942,
-0.0566946566,
0.0129340542,
0.0374432392,
0.0248623192,
-0.0511419885,
0.0492408872,
0.0048199832,
0.0372808538,
-0.004472937,
0.0548739433,
-0.0810773373,
-0.005091683,
0.0654265732,
-0.0235541761,
0.0143680852,
-0.025595149,
0.0389584675,
-0.0510242507,
-0.0528883673,
0.0580968037,
-0.0647801757,
-0.007934479,
0.019108532,
-0.0146002397,
0.0397888198,
0.0012108155,
-0.0196292456,
-0.0030557858,
-0.0366658866,
0.0147988508,
-0.0054389504,
0.0139169423,
0.0258826967,
0.0589880198,
0.0037830584,
0.0751013085,
0.1215007231,
-0.0146409897,
-0.0212428514,
-0.0308674555,
0.0257621966,
0.0068532713,
0.0095107788,
0.0183355827,
0.0652915686,
0.0182434916,
-0.0268585291,
-0.0328166373,
-0.0890967697,
0.0363221504,
0.0661656559,
0.0154570928,
-0.0310122389,
-0.0344702676,
0.0002461972,
-0.005036484,
-0.0297236107,
-0.0085597187,
0.0527278669,
0.0039817779,
0.0004048813,
0.0306897033,
0.0449471399,
-0.0263673421,
-0.001130187,
0.001689848,
-0.0535181202,
0.0384202786,
-0.0101151858,
-0.0114329988,
-0.013176349,
-0.0049562342,
0.0556004085,
-0.0084499493,
0.0210132618,
0.025412593,
0.0339013264,
-0.0024352742,
-0.0723504275,
-0.0107725384,
-0.0302895065,
-0.0341441184,
0.0403866395,
0.0404080227,
0.0682392865,
-0.0168079734,
-0.0216776039,
0.0482608229,
0.0001332889,
-0.0298966151,
0.0171722434,
0.0223462358,
-0.0209503639,
0.0260244049,
-0.0083450917,
0.0000098929,
-0.0352163725,
-0.0386007726,
0.0514321029,
-0.0636343136,
-0.0173817463,
-0.0012627348,
2.556e-7,
-0.0171658155,
0.0504555516,
0.0261561442,
0.0020311102,
0.0247972012,
0.0225694459,
0.0287705474,
0.0393424071,
0.0006982853,
-0.0521413833,
-0.0294061191,
0.0291469321,
0.0500473045,
-0.011758172,
-0.0480743535,
0.0234634597,
-0.0070395749,
-0.000902927,
-0.0817052796,
-0.0429144241,
0.0444206782,
0.018620681,
-0.0524631292,
-0.0083554443,
0.0592273064,
-0.0713584721,
0.061825335,
-0.0107583394,
-0.0002493303,
0.0289175995,
0.0168917794,
0.0125347422,
-0.0080078645,
0.0774209052,
0.0003265964,
-0.0512781292,
0.0594452918,
0.0067034159,
-0.0446201563,
0.0120806349,
-0.0121883852,
0.013416525,
-0.0132648051,
-0.0512982048,
0.0647194013,
-0.0292182285,
-0.0292999167,
0.0027242824,
-0.0167722162,
-0.0115430951,
0.0474924445,
-0.0308609586,
-0.0177639667,
0.0045446488,
0.0404582769,
0.0229494795,
-0.0313067622,
-0.0536794998,
-0.0169568639,
-0.0002767858,
-0.0248097423,
0.0060314788,
-0.047414761,
0.0061859996,
0.0035550008,
-0.0813832358,
-0.0400957018,
2.49202231e-34,
0.0075274548,
-0.0166074652,
0.0501486771,
-0.0082166167,
0.0003070154,
-0.0205032341,
0.0465510227,
0.0108096832,
-0.0443421565,
-0.0437569022,
-0.0127004404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03469v2 | Rethinking the Role of Proxy Rewards in Language Model Alignment | 2024-02-02T11:58:08 | 2024-04-29T01:09:06 | Sungdong Kim, Minjoon Seo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Learning from human feedback via proxy reward modeling has been studied to
align Large Language Models (LLMs) with human values. However, achieving
reliable training through that proxy reward model (RM) is not a trivial
problem, and its behavior remained as a black-box. In this paper, we study the
role of proxy rewards in the LLM alignment via `reverse reward engineering' by
composing interpretable features as a white-box reward function. We aim to
replicate the ground truth (gold) reward signal by achieving a monotonic
relationship between the proxy and gold reward signals after training the model
using the proxy reward in reinforcement learning (RL). Our findings indicate
that successfully emulating the gold reward requires generating responses that
are relevant with enough length to open-ended questions, while also ensuring
response consistency in closed-ended questions. Furthermore, resulting models
optimizing our devised white-box reward show competitive performances with
strong open-source RMs in alignment benchmarks. We highlight its potential
usage as a simple but strong reward baseline for the LLM alignment, not
requiring explicit human feedback dataset and RM training. Our code is
available at https://github.com/naver-ai/rethinking-proxy-reward. | [
0.0363437943,
0.0770398751,
-0.0090013891,
0.0171792042,
-0.0507728904,
0.0067199501,
-0.0449613221,
-0.0056164972,
-0.0427806601,
-0.0015343003,
-0.0592491589,
-0.0176033881,
0.0055316193,
0.0092774406,
0.0192442182,
-0.0487418659,
0.0781891569,
-0.0300493333,
0.0158944875,
-0.0204158239,
0.0156804826,
0.0068267342,
-0.0000511079,
0.0458954014,
-0.0095924996,
-0.0080664949,
-0.0280966796,
-0.0099295024,
0.0326803662,
0.0041465606,
0.0151361637,
0.0342457741,
0.0190615822,
0.0799817443,
0.0000021041,
-0.0555272959,
-0.0209104326,
-0.0051774536,
-0.0544058457,
-0.0288266446,
0.0124021666,
-0.0049673463,
-0.0101304604,
0.0173649453,
-0.0314512625,
0.0141472323,
0.0570609905,
0.0343418382,
0.0522234254,
0.067722179,
0.0165117122,
-0.033286605,
0.0424619168,
-0.0252589192,
0.0314547196,
-0.0339291096,
-0.0059587723,
0.0223288704,
0.005005355,
-0.0092401905,
-0.0219597667,
0.0254632998,
0.0315172486,
-0.0034931111,
0.0020222641,
0.0395887084,
0.0214490332,
-0.006542142,
-0.00854968,
0.062307056,
-0.0191252902,
-0.0378970876,
-0.022759784,
-0.0154808993,
0.0166866649,
-0.00857752,
-0.0090611586,
0.0148744835,
0.0355123542,
0.0437726825,
0.0701969936,
-0.0087416032,
0.0321218334,
-0.0040955776,
-0.0020861095,
0.0707833245,
0.016638549,
-0.0421162434,
-0.0145037742,
0.021254003,
-0.025350865,
-0.0489004217,
-0.0261758454,
0.0169645231,
-0.0548881255,
0.0417452715,
-0.0527968407,
-0.0267469361,
0.0040874002,
0.0117851626,
0.0415048189,
0.0499515943,
-0.0210260469,
0.0517069995,
-0.0225706715,
0.0821687132,
-0.0505588017,
0.0792804062,
-0.0416452922,
-0.0157711226,
-0.0179966204,
-0.0323357135,
0.0155232856,
0.0230929684,
-0.0002153198,
-0.0053643114,
-0.0483572781,
0.0202593319,
-0.036424242,
0.0557450466,
0.0104976641,
0.0178576224,
-0.0373400301,
-0.0229536165,
-0.0308037382,
0.0417963415,
-0.03765136,
0.023399733,
0.0242276527,
-0.020140633,
-0.0159667637,
-0.0013710825,
-0.0169670209,
-0.0341309011,
-0.0056728679,
0.0851254687,
-0.0147390179,
-0.0112901619,
-0.0077278363,
-0.0270629153,
-0.0012074311,
-0.0480831303,
-0.0157050639,
-0.0641105995,
0.0321080871,
-0.0195261873,
-0.0316543579,
-0.0325978622,
0.012165918,
-0.0029095432,
-0.0073001957,
0.0679182187,
0.0119069545,
0.0056503401,
-0.0018529255,
-0.0370384119,
-0.0198693182,
0.0650336593,
0.0555994138,
0.0192279574,
0.0178313553,
-0.011222465,
-0.0181866158,
0.0276541468,
0.0524612144,
0.0129237473,
-0.029852936,
0.0149549618,
0.0561398976,
0.0539051555,
0.0635192841,
0.0058872509,
0.01019987,
-0.0263995472,
0.0662454143,
0.0527237207,
-0.0131564317,
-0.0227507427,
0.0053372644,
-0.0003965933,
-0.0382546112,
0.0188608784,
-0.0777581483,
0.0337710641,
-0.0320384428,
0.032250531,
-0.0040679392,
-0.0024840175,
-0.0273554809,
-0.0397594348,
-0.0068417513,
-0.0227752328,
0.0251725409,
0.0446855016,
0.058183562,
-0.015768379,
-0.0476205796,
0.0116792433,
0.0562776253,
-0.0210135113,
0.0325543545,
-0.0488186963,
0.0620298758,
0.0562253669,
0.0271107536,
-0.026738748,
0.004250037,
-0.0270524696,
-0.0324398428,
0.0647563189,
0.0443020985,
-0.0082619088,
-0.0109019177,
-0.0225387812,
-0.033218313,
-0.0062826253,
0.0095838122,
0.0277095009,
0.0264879782,
-0.0299240407,
-0.0113771176,
-0.0070189396,
-0.0548429228,
0.0465984829,
-0.0214615483,
-0.0342505872,
-0.0131893801,
0.0255025532,
0.0239461921,
-0.006961171,
0.0049881283,
0.0152138816,
0.0252464507,
-0.025203282,
-0.0061815442,
0.0209079478,
-0.0634966344,
-0.0135446265,
0.0329796448,
-0.0144430809,
-0.0221543927,
0.0946684703,
-0.0276215225,
-0.0419614948,
0.0196209382,
-0.0267969966,
0.0588594787,
-0.0053810473,
0.0494185984,
-0.0359408185,
-0.003983126,
-0.0707324892,
0.0279297382,
0.0011646845,
0.0247433875,
-0.0290299486,
-0.0358126685,
-0.002053221,
-0.0523448177,
-0.0107722161,
0.0200939272,
-0.0049288375,
0.0328275301,
0.0459423326,
0.0028912351,
-0.0506791584,
-0.0219524372,
-0.0168191679,
0.004644766,
-0.029923711,
0.0397887155,
0.0562338084,
0.0002536728,
0.0064970073,
-0.0215857551,
-0.0836933106,
-0.0263692662,
0.0224912874,
-0.0035876355,
0.052168984,
-0.0092064859,
-0.0039070616,
-0.0671877638,
-0.016098598,
-0.0232852586,
0.027329307,
-0.0047096615,
0.0769989341,
-0.0752487034,
-0.003338048,
-0.0260482244,
0.0176541917,
-0.0061060181,
-0.0291271098,
0.0123752598,
0.0205837321,
0.0026825562,
0.0877000093,
0.0264996327,
0.0166506264,
0.0247778688,
0.0453789569,
-0.1066638678,
-0.0080759479,
-0.047443904,
-0.0664336979,
-0.0503957905,
-0.0310943909,
0.0004780857,
0.0936094299,
0.0166273508,
0.0114802038,
-0.0767953172,
0.0171795916,
-0.0030840838,
-0.0441805795,
-0.0500233732,
-0.0083230343,
-0.0479038954,
0.0322922468,
-0.0565692559,
-0.0655821413,
0.0976945832,
-0.0122818742,
-0.0037281234,
-0.0335623436,
-0.0201238524,
-0.0318787061,
0.04836528,
-0.0217397492,
0.0281023439,
0.0034899707,
-0.0361475646,
-0.0808941722,
-0.0297258589,
0.029630214,
-0.0496329963,
0.0337805152,
-0.0244720634,
0.007203633,
-0.0096245417,
-0.0372908264,
-0.0784871578,
-0.0397255644,
-0.01938916,
0.0179891326,
-0.0325675532,
-0.000216984,
-0.0178859383,
-0.0026654203,
0.0460906588,
0.0057356725,
-0.0184978358,
0.0174161904,
-0.0423201323,
0.0163109768,
0.0926940218,
0.0280806348,
0.0278727636,
-0.0397509634,
0.0150242224,
0.022659611,
0.0572450198,
0.0371637233,
0.0093363961,
0.0056488868,
0.055020038,
-0.0601243973,
0.0024344458,
0.0072904201,
0.0269789807,
-0.057871975,
-0.015541004,
0.0961586311,
0.0454604514,
-0.0443692207,
0.0219900571,
-0.0274799634,
0.0614961423,
0.0110323057,
0.0197566748,
-0.0749193057,
-0.0152085163,
0.0183443837,
0.0134856123,
0.003779345,
-0.0023527057,
0.0020151718,
-0.1328915656,
-0.0279813614,
0.0087243309,
-0.0627418086,
-0.0135455579,
-0.012166434,
0.0053080684,
-0.0112790484,
0.0311055426,
0.047389891,
0.0276301336,
-0.0182755459,
0.014179267,
0.0531755313,
-0.0103357481,
0.0320037492,
-0.0490718335,
0.0764404312,
0.1178870574,
0.0078265518,
-0.0100067835,
-0.0398888253,
-0.0148448367,
-0.0102348961,
-0.0331194922,
0.0383855179,
0.0254416317,
-0.0260360781,
-0.029089665,
0.0106769809,
0.0530016124,
-0.0383268148,
0.0144876549,
-0.0089897402,
0.0845531374,
0.0113636712,
-0.0023515399,
-0.002905342,
-0.0191021077,
0.0137546798,
0.083703503,
0.0100756092,
-0.0590093248,
-0.027692344,
-0.0051642084,
-0.0152245937,
-0.0085334601,
-0.0527526401,
0.0226275977,
-0.0024108107,
0.0176582076,
-0.0578839071,
-0.0609873235,
-0.0068380879,
0.0075512668,
0.0075797699,
-0.0124373306,
-0.0310716759,
-0.044000674,
-0.0493122824,
0.0524128005,
-0.0492262356,
0.0451085605,
-0.0604573488,
-0.0027895616,
-0.0194448605,
-0.0449866243,
-0.0366406366,
-0.0431087427,
-0.0542232618,
-0.0595402978,
-0.0119706597,
0.0338364728,
0.0165575352,
0.0738203898,
-0.0210277624,
-0.0012115509,
0.0167788621,
-0.01134694,
-0.0437737927,
0.0154343275,
0.0230176542,
0.0092505515,
-0.0046894727,
0.0382290035,
-0.0605270378,
-0.0006150191,
0.0382084884,
0.0394602716,
0.0063296328,
-0.0053517707,
0.0679611638,
0.0088026728,
0.0388565063,
-0.0139505034,
0.001647791,
-0.0184735954,
0.0041789841,
-0.0212980155,
-0.0318920612,
-0.0038057985,
-0.0297588687,
0.0302703865,
-0.0089813238,
0.0173624735,
-0.043372497,
-0.0209547915,
0.030515749,
-0.0271131229,
-0.0150248995,
-0.0230646785,
0.0279864557,
0.004362145,
0.0319825783,
-0.0132790394,
0.0148105696,
0.0130607588,
0.0700374246,
0.0026798863,
0.0439439118,
0.0450688265,
0.0055512423,
-0.0055904915,
0.0173327532,
-0.0572469644,
-0.0249624923,
-0.008444964,
0.0140230283,
0.053744968,
0.0004548286,
0.0355104841,
0.0018537801,
-0.0156991091,
-0.0060301321,
0.0181301218,
-0.0334428288,
-0.021898536,
0.058180403,
0.0253247917,
-0.013232273,
-0.0153494058,
0.0360778719,
0.000023892,
0.0386154018,
-0.0487605222,
0.0322419554,
-0.0140396636,
-0.0165235996,
0.0249060113,
0.0060844249,
-0.042731721,
0.0061967308,
-0.0594713427,
-0.0823146477,
-0.0529905967,
0.0692795366,
0.0049056625,
-0.0126322201,
0.0411077626,
0.0320076756,
-0.0468503609,
-0.0033747233,
-0.0473376177,
-0.0051141572,
-0.0218643826,
-0.029449204,
-0.0466548502,
-6.671419006e-33,
-0.0387434252,
-0.0153670097,
0.0365609936,
-0.0085958019,
-0.053134609,
0.0072977105,
-0.0212236773,
-0.0028315322,
-0.0228626337,
-0.0122042829,
-0.0041900869,
-0.020409815,
0.0022809166,
0.0125304163,
0.015299377,
-0.0299283992,
0.0190720465,
-0.0053265826,
-0.0418608077,
-0.0125331879,
0.0395624265,
0.0052719372,
0.0826230422,
-0.0448657572,
0.0655865669,
0.0060902555,
-0.0312282257,
0.0384765714,
-0.0088761412,
0.048913449,
-0.0105590466,
0.0258017778,
0.0082954913,
-0.0389955975,
0.0070298305,
0.0174179729,
-0.0671122372,
-0.0130233187,
0.0517698079,
0.0243399087,
-0.0703925937,
-0.0343910903,
0.0519858859,
-0.0393609256,
-0.023488218,
-0.0060137445,
0.0321810469,
-0.0038387286,
-0.0125892079,
0.0542382821,
-0.0855253339,
-0.009673004,
-0.0187345799,
-0.0247261561,
0.010547067,
0.0667619854,
0.0099650593,
0.0452550463,
-0.0267937556,
0.0303035602,
0.0100667011,
0.0361496061,
0.0984295234,
0.0511649512,
0.0279206373,
0.0516265966,
0.0152087333,
-0.0208938867,
0.0061795367,
-0.0010046054,
0.0450289622,
-0.0093289055,
0.0512000248,
0.0406401493,
0.0339615159,
-0.0107156271,
-0.023568105,
0.0028471344,
-0.0169138014,
0.0171625428,
0.0046980893,
0.0325803012,
-0.0475821085,
-0.012733357,
-0.0837780684,
-0.007053331,
-0.0320315436,
-0.059472166,
0.0380645394,
0.0066886526,
-0.0254833959,
-0.0310933962,
0.0081148855,
-0.0489012226,
-0.0098006865,
0.015135305,
-0.003608986,
0.0179129783,
-0.0093861539,
0.0194172282,
-0.0664949045,
-0.0052288221,
-0.012081421,
-0.0110560795,
0.0241063628,
0.0519072264,
0.013406991,
0.0221214201,
-0.0463193953,
0.021722788,
-0.0449351482,
0.0097059542,
-0.0098370733,
-0.0534559079,
0.0601375438,
-0.0029431698,
-0.004511416,
0.0445113964,
0.0281818267,
-0.0071944189,
-0.042681165,
0.0026564377,
-0.025600031,
0.0373986214,
-0.0445744134,
0.0103353076,
-0.0124442307,
0.0221342612,
0.0332002044,
-0.0382813215,
-0.0075529893,
-0.0160453171,
2.771e-7,
0.0220878422,
0.0105651617,
0.0431079455,
0.0365668833,
-0.001363007,
0.0739766881,
-0.0043800925,
0.0260637496,
0.0278815906,
-0.0045221741,
0.007421934,
0.0063070171,
0.0608092248,
-0.0153340921,
-0.0684578493,
0.0268554613,
-0.0932459235,
0.018170584,
-0.022200644,
0.0011844983,
0.0394177176,
0.0913908631,
0.0428947061,
-0.0015660214,
-0.0046319636,
0.0307823997,
0.0552539825,
-0.0610923432,
-0.0337192863,
0.0117183775,
-0.0091080628,
-0.0092087034,
0.0096056238,
-0.0199878365,
0.0104040401,
0.0362604223,
-0.0222712122,
0.0421535373,
-0.0303595029,
-0.0392085798,
-0.0671658739,
-0.0030636322,
0.0113109965,
-0.0742211789,
0.0351131968,
-0.0404275134,
-0.0387975089,
-0.0781566501,
-0.0149372267,
-0.0236952882,
0.0221347604,
-0.0084571317,
-0.0141313793,
0.0112030841,
0.0263874549,
0.0362703837,
-0.0049140318,
-0.0527787581,
-0.0525061674,
0.0354443789,
-0.0117940763,
-0.0222651344,
-0.0169732869,
0.0441737063,
-0.0139518511,
-0.0665806234,
-0.0110010216,
2.421149414e-34,
0.0054955184,
-0.0125841275,
0.0304712951,
0.0472879559,
0.0128578385,
0.011855891,
-0.0026433303,
0.0068854247,
0.0745797381,
-0.0189353917,
-0.0270788912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01300v1 | Two Approaches to Diachronic Normalization of Polish Texts | 2024-02-02T10:42:06 | 2024-02-02T10:42:06 | Kacper Dudzic, Filip Graliński, Krzysztof Jassem, Marek Kubis, Piotr Wierzchoń | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper discusses two approaches to the diachronic normalization of Polish
texts: a rule-based solution that relies on a set of handcrafted patterns, and
a neural normalization model based on the text-to-text transfer transformer
architecture. The training and evaluation data prepared for the task are
discussed in detail, along with experiments conducted to compare the proposed
normalization solutions. A quantitative and qualitative analysis is made. It is
shown that at the current stage of inquiry into the problem, the rule-based
solution outperforms the neural one on 3 out of 4 variants of the prepared
dataset, although in practice both approaches have distinct advantages and
disadvantages. | [
-0.0023805145,
0.04293181,
0.0078459596,
0.0363583155,
-0.0525395498,
0.0136125907,
0.0225911736,
0.0297078993,
-0.044736661,
0.0231336225,
0.0145928096,
0.0040545934,
0.0424991213,
0.0250874497,
-0.0063743507,
-0.0717780218,
0.0306464452,
-0.0004260064,
-0.0617734939,
0.0332514867,
0.0275232699,
-0.0157225449,
0.0077872835,
0.0017922637,
-0.0555142388,
0.0179088321,
0.0065422081,
-0.0084128426,
0.0027770847,
0.0000853172,
-0.0086385058,
0.0128268609,
0.015096548,
0.0411243364,
0.0000017643,
-0.0381557234,
-0.0394446962,
-0.0318165198,
0.0500384867,
-0.007439943,
0.0493489467,
-0.0847220942,
-0.0420937277,
0.0032959443,
-0.0245624986,
-0.0340002775,
0.0764256865,
0.0996235311,
0.03003956,
0.0766055882,
-0.0429100096,
-0.0871225819,
0.0480655096,
0.0092761647,
-0.0588493496,
-0.0065238364,
0.0185634904,
0.0248663742,
-0.0263922922,
-0.0077038072,
0.0034972995,
0.0583382994,
0.0085258093,
-0.0586010553,
0.0224457681,
0.0096691353,
0.053507477,
-0.0012819226,
-0.0285142642,
0.0069047655,
-0.0145535981,
-0.0222740062,
-0.017011242,
0.011581705,
-0.0315980092,
0.0190027654,
-0.0425818898,
-0.0142672677,
-0.0133688869,
0.032217253,
0.0317996293,
0.0412595309,
-0.004251413,
-0.0184118096,
-0.0170752369,
0.0565696619,
0.0082641123,
-0.0513274036,
0.0196652804,
-0.0171003249,
0.076173313,
0.0150996279,
0.1006159484,
0.05128536,
0.0318190567,
0.0039386926,
-0.0277529974,
-0.0311465263,
-0.0343528017,
-0.0284466501,
-0.0007416431,
0.052116517,
-0.0055515305,
-0.0036386952,
-0.0664980784,
0.056981612,
0.0044214851,
-0.0057080579,
-0.086161606,
-0.0322193615,
-0.0587211996,
0.0104582189,
-0.0739737153,
0.0145381615,
-0.0308215115,
0.0114639904,
-0.0417521112,
-0.0357642546,
0.0533776358,
-0.0180225223,
0.0443231538,
-0.0064125988,
-0.0438568369,
-0.0170288682,
-0.0142903719,
0.0643086433,
-0.0670376718,
-0.012769023,
-0.0586096421,
-0.0323326401,
0.0233641602,
0.0208969116,
0.0344110802,
-0.0247342121,
0.0010929573,
0.0224123355,
-0.0638259649,
0.0103867054,
-0.0787619129,
-0.0091505926,
-0.0296249073,
0.0103494292,
-0.0146563509,
-0.0511262976,
0.0038734607,
-0.0019798693,
-0.0024719976,
-0.0167243518,
-0.0235860087,
0.0156522114,
-0.0375126563,
0.0583168454,
-0.0335182659,
0.0190852173,
0.0649244487,
-0.033343073,
0.0144345658,
-0.0017186069,
0.0552747473,
0.0197343845,
0.002237879,
-0.0286655407,
-0.0065864772,
0.0841751471,
-0.0166229401,
-0.0512951352,
-0.0660907775,
-0.0143517293,
-0.0030060052,
0.0050824499,
0.0783100277,
0.0795560777,
0.0099026393,
-0.0322150178,
0.041014377,
0.0581732579,
0.0440121964,
0.0362698436,
0.0457190797,
-0.0459555089,
0.0190925747,
0.0245539285,
0.0141523527,
-0.0142969973,
0.0017444429,
-0.0059441035,
-0.0761845335,
0.0237568393,
-0.0047993385,
-0.0084003545,
0.0385611765,
-0.0179801024,
0.0459518507,
-0.0720063448,
0.0421359688,
0.0159882456,
-0.0201744698,
0.0198571794,
-0.0033146325,
-0.0093011968,
0.0268585905,
0.0405092612,
-0.0252142884,
0.0765028298,
0.0644382313,
-0.0296672266,
0.0054691518,
-0.0125574237,
-0.0179009847,
0.0456361026,
-0.0028901424,
-0.0292070247,
-0.0041995486,
-0.0763361976,
-0.0159488972,
0.0496260375,
-0.0295970961,
0.0287101492,
-0.0378216319,
0.0270402376,
0.0081261378,
0.0185951348,
-0.0533343442,
0.0479182787,
-0.0113518797,
-0.024713764,
-0.0332791992,
0.0185869504,
-0.0129452981,
0.0552801155,
0.0181932207,
-0.0030841692,
0.0295446105,
-0.0854184031,
0.02924354,
0.0423329286,
-0.0938812569,
0.0002138092,
0.0381072462,
-0.0626948699,
-0.0085032694,
0.0108680511,
0.0027995401,
-0.0498973392,
-0.0016883435,
-0.0242582764,
-0.0034401822,
-0.012035667,
0.0419567302,
-0.0181278028,
0.0149070574,
-0.0308477674,
0.0216154978,
-0.001971385,
0.0025983371,
-0.0037388322,
-0.044487711,
0.0318281315,
-0.0291232057,
-0.0042994497,
0.0580480397,
-0.0373049527,
-0.0214314424,
0.0140163172,
0.0058703367,
-0.0371455066,
-0.0117254388,
-0.0231293943,
-0.0158449672,
-0.0050882138,
0.0546100363,
0.0300783105,
0.0261527374,
0.0308602229,
-0.0625780821,
-0.0651654676,
-0.0022869264,
0.0170127172,
-0.0351924188,
0.0981576145,
0.0115359863,
-0.0133431237,
-0.0045219874,
-0.0125763919,
-0.0154995127,
-0.0059298892,
0.0295072868,
-0.0637430251,
-0.0801011845,
0.0445699506,
0.0000955122,
0.0404933505,
-0.0044503906,
-0.0404770225,
0.0118307127,
0.0111805359,
0.0889559314,
0.0228741225,
-0.0010154085,
-0.0546305403,
-0.0012421383,
-0.0407517515,
-0.0184234455,
-0.0167895444,
-0.020837944,
0.0738697946,
-0.0229583494,
-0.0554992296,
0.0025791232,
0.0515729003,
-0.0179972332,
0.0412142985,
-0.0180372521,
-0.0096690934,
-0.0674800947,
0.0130803874,
-0.0252704676,
-0.0122906165,
-0.0053808796,
0.0195512362,
-0.0038122777,
0.0142189153,
0.0367928408,
-0.022450557,
-0.0262256898,
-0.0483806208,
-0.0391396582,
-0.0334504582,
0.0330587067,
0.0078516891,
0.0318152234,
-0.0115519781,
-0.0841608942,
-0.0305324271,
-0.0513624102,
0.005675815,
-0.011013913,
0.048935771,
-0.0190704949,
0.0064923996,
-0.0638739318,
-0.0097787092,
-0.01389091,
-0.0087125497,
0.005475306,
0.0330784991,
0.0011588704,
-0.0274319556,
-0.0398432948,
0.0491227843,
-0.0038820442,
0.0678813756,
0.0038562962,
-0.0032864045,
-0.0165518075,
0.0946943909,
-0.0005772635,
-0.0097170221,
-0.0353363194,
0.0133449808,
-0.0032604381,
0.0050059622,
0.0018486079,
-0.0290426929,
-0.055865068,
-0.0268950537,
-0.0250231232,
-0.0143903047,
-0.0009330041,
-0.0338568389,
-0.0241864212,
-0.0485163555,
0.0033428064,
0.075942114,
0.002062544,
-0.0409844108,
-0.0216962192,
-0.0122743733,
-0.0357228033,
-0.0495610572,
-0.0128083965,
-0.0325238295,
0.0158678666,
-0.0139015205,
0.0156308208,
0.0301380008,
-0.0493295342,
0.0063258293,
-0.0460393056,
-0.0712533593,
0.0278812647,
-0.0622538514,
-0.0707311109,
-0.019612534,
-0.013691823,
-0.0107564153,
0.0307535473,
0.0230743717,
0.0039184904,
-0.0199563168,
0.0238545407,
-0.0594669096,
-0.041122485,
-0.0261843745,
-0.0158560332,
0.0554434136,
0.0333328769,
0.0465669855,
-0.0273796618,
-0.011952199,
-0.0208147224,
0.0193299018,
0.0307551939,
-0.0381964371,
0.0381764434,
0.0709849894,
-0.0155587187,
-0.032409966,
0.015436003,
0.0181135591,
0.0093685398,
0.0104597686,
0.0397398286,
0.0343382508,
-0.0183523931,
0.0152891483,
-0.0191098507,
0.0104026897,
0.0321034007,
-0.0204200856,
0.0140434653,
-0.0325159281,
-0.0232742373,
0.0225011893,
-0.1069793105,
-0.0458789766,
0.0171076469,
-0.0374268927,
-0.041096542,
-0.0884302631,
-0.0516207367,
-0.0074112546,
0.0454301275,
0.0457420051,
-0.0293411054,
0.0510767065,
-0.014886749,
-0.037548773,
-0.0036159088,
-0.0337799303,
0.0010972298,
-0.0784898996,
0.02533512,
-0.0335872136,
-0.0238332804,
0.0205198023,
-0.0150680365,
-0.0067531657,
0.005270259,
0.0492093004,
-0.0182006285,
0.0207443833,
-0.0019467926,
-0.0056866715,
-0.03789258,
0.028425457,
0.0386352316,
-0.0078317383,
-0.0468791761,
-0.0090461709,
0.0126784053,
0.0052222945,
0.0146838566,
-0.0002390774,
0.0691790357,
-0.0024629501,
-0.0027875341,
-0.0023837031,
-0.0255755428,
-0.0084286863,
0.0289162006,
0.0043151514,
0.0091640959,
0.0032035359,
-0.0129908472,
-0.0094937887,
-0.0616774708,
0.0194934439,
0.0154735595,
0.027923787,
0.0375126675,
0.0414988883,
-0.0121323261,
-0.0021235442,
-0.0153713878,
-0.0454680249,
-0.0231938269,
-0.0011428491,
0.0295003671,
0.0634479672,
0.0048194248,
0.0111978864,
0.0144040398,
0.0044911494,
0.0128603717,
0.0255543534,
-0.0112688905,
-0.005631709,
0.0100394422,
0.0110436399,
-0.0436259508,
-0.0071014445,
-0.0238463227,
0.0638765693,
-0.0106828734,
-0.0321969278,
0.073462598,
0.0122207571,
0.0762923509,
-0.0031785446,
0.0135711404,
0.0268037841,
-0.0027105217,
0.0356645212,
0.0521326922,
-0.0190210864,
-0.0094085597,
0.0170782004,
-0.0137585616,
0.0009324474,
-0.0590403415,
0.0112788538,
0.0096378792,
-0.0422614031,
-0.0354038328,
0.0180636253,
-0.0196781643,
-0.0760091394,
-0.0536585338,
-0.0491836816,
-0.0385563262,
-0.0035352844,
0.0070708031,
0.028149398,
-0.0046480424,
-0.0000888289,
0.00561048,
-0.043495018,
0.0248100888,
0.0229135584,
0.0311659593,
0.0878570527,
0.0223979112,
-0.0592452139,
-0.0759644285,
-5.63050884e-33,
-0.0041413647,
-0.0187033508,
0.0260704625,
0.0090712421,
-0.0438049547,
-0.0098148314,
-0.002815584,
-0.0357177891,
-0.005345114,
0.0070107691,
-0.0381929241,
-0.0229244567,
0.0362135135,
-0.0101970164,
0.0463040099,
0.0297478363,
0.0487795882,
-0.020356901,
-0.0058207815,
-0.0012453491,
0.0673290119,
0.0360687859,
0.0940223336,
-0.0654525459,
0.0146133211,
0.0024385105,
-0.0211751889,
0.0194985084,
0.10287451,
0.0044732103,
-0.0126619469,
0.0227508508,
0.0372386612,
-0.0054433043,
-0.0196483098,
0.0428448729,
-0.1034348384,
-0.0353538617,
0.0009557488,
0.0824437216,
0.034296114,
-0.0199668296,
0.0511909463,
-0.0432569534,
-0.0111525254,
0.0566901192,
0.017305756,
-0.0430235825,
0.02225619,
0.0075635859,
-0.06550695,
0.0181544814,
0.0100791939,
0.0020295307,
0.0734344497,
0.0344138145,
-0.0025195528,
-0.0260519609,
-0.0652992427,
0.0038652956,
0.0513771251,
0.055897072,
0.0127255153,
0.0038961775,
-0.0266816393,
-0.022590505,
0.0707300976,
-0.0280711856,
0.0027307365,
0.0357558057,
0.0546457991,
-0.021075977,
0.0774298161,
0.013877213,
0.0725996941,
0.0108354837,
-0.0233763158,
0.0362063237,
0.0845800042,
0.0424428433,
-0.0124470666,
0.0018411698,
-0.0195038859,
0.0006145637,
0.0392795503,
0.010392827,
0.0037991984,
-0.023637142,
0.0177142862,
-0.0084296782,
0.0045467378,
0.026767442,
0.0117267407,
-0.0346459225,
-0.0287120976,
0.0061500673,
0.0045602424,
0.0299269315,
-0.0158471726,
-0.0070954859,
-0.057576146,
-0.085683994,
0.0474206284,
0.0371723436,
0.0100778472,
-0.0107264835,
-0.0051747099,
0.034779489,
-0.0609728433,
0.0106750568,
0.0101420619,
-0.0126575502,
0.0260217357,
0.0314818732,
0.0077857138,
-0.0356869996,
0.0012987207,
-0.0239083935,
0.0650899634,
-0.0176301915,
0.0134251229,
-0.0265465826,
0.088204518,
0.0188430734,
-0.0180730391,
0.0461984873,
-0.0127593577,
0.0292628724,
0.0260948166,
0.0401181579,
0.0024141334,
0.0170471147,
2.467e-7,
0.0576649606,
0.0330558531,
0.085463874,
-0.0035640541,
0.0196838994,
-0.0314529389,
-0.0380856805,
0.0022009416,
-0.013858269,
0.0752429739,
0.039022509,
-0.0483466648,
0.0462864749,
0.0398550779,
-0.0434353836,
-0.0651334897,
-0.0366059728,
-0.0293251593,
-0.0330843367,
0.0572737455,
0.0457700081,
0.0390816107,
0.0020228659,
-0.02934663,
-0.0124226008,
-0.0318493135,
-0.0087242583,
0.0197793208,
0.0101564918,
0.0081423633,
0.0601155683,
-0.0020218787,
-0.0268984102,
0.0352694727,
0.0319876,
0.0396808051,
0.0029755917,
0.0219493806,
-0.0168723632,
0.0546561182,
0.0055520907,
-0.035715811,
-0.0311699267,
-0.0334591381,
0.0103603369,
-0.0143426294,
-0.0051140236,
0.0366760753,
-0.0135870557,
0.0561469682,
-0.010925984,
0.005465751,
-0.0581703335,
0.0081464984,
0.0399669111,
0.0188418347,
-0.0235203132,
-0.0365212895,
-0.0028826001,
-0.001071989,
0.0273814257,
-0.0207767654,
-0.0381785966,
0.0001107838,
-0.0099760508,
0.0222428385,
0.0234341118,
2.013575446e-34,
-0.0012975429,
-0.0188395418,
-0.0061781211,
-0.0044262907,
-0.037583679,
-0.0208895877,
-0.0029555319,
0.0269756559,
-0.024294721,
-0.05594768,
-0.0143813416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01293v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01293v2 | Can MLLMs Perform Text-to-Image In-Context Learning? | 2024-02-02T10:30:05 | 2024-04-15T21:30:10 | Yuchen Zeng, Wonjun Kang, Yicong Chen, Hyung Il Koo, Kangwook Lee | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The evolution from Large Language Models (LLMs) to Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) has spurred research into extending In-Context Learning (ICL) to
its multimodal counterpart. Existing such studies have primarily concentrated
on image-to-text ICL. However, the Text-to-Image ICL (T2I-ICL), with its unique
characteristics and potential applications, remains underexplored. To address
this gap, we formally define the task of T2I-ICL and present CoBSAT, the first
T2I-ICL benchmark dataset, encompassing ten tasks. Utilizing our dataset to
benchmark six state-of-the-art MLLMs, we uncover considerable difficulties
MLLMs encounter in solving T2I-ICL. We identify the primary challenges as the
inherent complexity of multimodality and image generation, and show that
strategies such as fine-tuning and Chain-of-Thought prompting help to mitigate
these difficulties, leading to notable improvements in performance. Our code
and dataset are available at https://github.com/UW-Madison-Lee-Lab/CoBSAT. | [
0.0028312732,
0.0704434738,
0.0264788419,
0.0955645069,
-0.0489239506,
0.0180584658,
0.0455006845,
-0.0130962711,
-0.0016384841,
-0.0694046915,
-0.0709451884,
-0.0393936485,
0.0292502474,
0.0194776673,
0.0528366081,
-0.0531517453,
-0.0135208834,
-0.0537137464,
-0.0402283557,
-0.0040827519,
0.023365818,
0.0356525593,
-0.0134190265,
0.0209374223,
-0.0543086417,
-0.0327410288,
0.0146528035,
0.0536384955,
0.0193395559,
-0.01814791,
-0.0061800489,
0.0240292698,
0.0482752733,
0.003268224,
0.0000018367,
-0.0287729818,
0.0121261338,
-0.0013058207,
0.031647943,
-0.0208087545,
0.070239678,
-0.0568755083,
0.0060391664,
-0.0121687865,
-0.0296966825,
0.0253089648,
0.0620431602,
0.0511101261,
0.0538843647,
0.0752047598,
-0.0277688801,
-0.0207916256,
0.0062676948,
-0.0299502593,
0.0217689406,
-0.034297023,
0.0084280958,
0.002512478,
0.0037768364,
-0.0136940656,
-0.0354949757,
0.0723629445,
0.0348963626,
-0.0143291019,
-0.0415130667,
0.0482303649,
0.0050044414,
-0.0368554145,
-0.0185402539,
0.0933921859,
-0.0356012061,
-0.0153313912,
-0.0410213768,
0.0000808573,
-0.0040991213,
-0.0111082001,
-0.0149647957,
0.0548280962,
-0.0185873695,
0.0300058201,
-0.0287421774,
-0.0087590963,
0.0247906074,
-0.0062002563,
-0.0173622444,
0.0164331663,
0.0263317022,
-0.0002247555,
-0.0236427896,
0.0109496322,
-0.0308503546,
-0.0323671214,
0.0001427057,
0.0326441079,
-0.0306453388,
0.0019472672,
-0.0676495358,
-0.0296257176,
-0.0193143357,
-0.0100154197,
0.0680415183,
-0.0085897306,
-0.031488698,
0.0511560254,
-0.0059357933,
0.006546272,
-0.012086885,
0.0157304537,
-0.0408966579,
-0.0388859846,
0.0026278638,
0.0097952588,
-0.0394481085,
-0.0244306866,
-0.0373328775,
-0.0317260996,
-0.0092640286,
0.0134522282,
-0.0136642326,
0.0048990073,
-0.0320125856,
-0.0015448993,
-0.044831533,
-0.0354888551,
0.0190648139,
0.0211379509,
0.028297551,
0.0289905351,
0.0059204069,
-0.0291022826,
0.0074364184,
0.0398681946,
0.0425133817,
-0.0366760381,
-0.0053634066,
0.0597914495,
-0.0497401468,
-0.0542746633,
-0.0296131689,
-0.0176350698,
-0.0408046357,
-0.0894417614,
0.0180849396,
-0.0651058629,
0.0345995054,
-0.0088386405,
0.0122038629,
-0.0211809445,
-0.0119364606,
0.0016251206,
-0.0017555917,
0.1090829447,
0.0025375925,
-0.0126568619,
0.0379248261,
0.0066094738,
0.004241589,
0.0798057318,
0.0303348005,
0.0491929315,
0.0269897878,
0.0290729105,
0.005129728,
0.0951137245,
0.0120029692,
0.0353411734,
-0.030799767,
-0.0085329181,
0.0117159504,
0.0474285148,
0.0436992608,
0.0699006915,
-0.0283934344,
-0.0049728174,
0.1072335392,
0.0179636478,
0.0440618135,
-0.0050764931,
0.055619888,
0.0035974961,
-0.0008454424,
-0.003489611,
-0.055334013,
0.0293141082,
-0.0022519545,
0.0147203626,
0.0279137343,
0.0557284057,
-0.033505287,
-0.007741625,
0.013981292,
-0.0454239547,
-0.0128163025,
0.0100379074,
0.0393094607,
0.0347341485,
-0.0449562036,
-0.0119508374,
0.0275667068,
-0.0185242239,
0.0028319559,
-0.03278514,
0.0188749768,
0.0494559705,
0.0297406539,
-0.0005813061,
-0.0142952809,
-0.0103102867,
0.054450389,
0.086065717,
-0.0277856365,
-0.0110008586,
0.0539207011,
-0.0572882891,
-0.0439761542,
0.0153404018,
-0.0106522022,
0.0093251299,
0.0020604017,
0.0223654266,
-0.0004663077,
0.0007347435,
0.0223673359,
0.0345406719,
-0.0050690058,
0.0244651698,
-0.013615041,
0.0277057122,
-0.005199777,
-0.0255619194,
-0.0184723977,
-0.0134119848,
-0.0015960885,
-0.0603915155,
-0.0052974839,
0.0172824282,
-0.0598993748,
-0.0613339096,
0.0175706483,
-0.0543038659,
-0.0251868386,
0.0118845915,
-0.0418487154,
-0.0103367278,
-0.0319200568,
-0.0083502857,
0.0029345439,
-0.0269775596,
-0.0265151113,
0.0378011577,
0.0169383213,
-0.0301666129,
0.032356374,
-0.0217339173,
-0.0248927418,
0.0247690771,
0.0179547388,
-0.0254168529,
-0.0070863911,
-0.0219353121,
0.0086738905,
0.0081378594,
0.0297081731,
-0.0042153061,
0.0656157807,
-0.0445578434,
-0.0238499604,
-0.0973005593,
-0.0321941674,
-0.0326999053,
-0.0365272872,
0.0190393757,
0.006445352,
0.003382792,
-0.0232072119,
-0.0329779796,
0.0215079039,
0.0089124748,
0.0244393367,
0.0255165696,
0.0079346374,
0.0261502229,
-0.0274712238,
-0.0067754686,
0.0229192786,
0.0681949556,
-0.0145481937,
-0.034618631,
-0.0407378264,
0.001098274,
-0.0228506085,
0.0208822209,
-0.0210846607,
0.0227134209,
0.0225441027,
-0.0425240211,
0.0757497102,
0.0575090945,
0.0263966359,
0.0033340664,
0.0125980387,
-0.0066898409,
-0.0544064231,
-0.0103403833,
0.0189770255,
-0.0321948528,
-0.0214719735,
-0.0243361127,
-0.0204038192,
0.0425892845,
-0.0014750992,
0.0184898656,
-0.0402791128,
0.0153062288,
-0.0069467854,
-0.0525941327,
-0.0689708814,
0.0303640459,
0.0014376888,
0.0189111494,
-0.0493053645,
-0.0743541867,
0.0182298832,
-0.0494011715,
-0.022081662,
-0.0023626781,
0.0051637497,
-0.0247045029,
0.0523295589,
0.0246391296,
0.0470847599,
-0.0112615265,
0.0164285824,
-0.0593838505,
0.0069814129,
0.0040684063,
0.0090475474,
0.0902163461,
-0.0385294072,
0.0214027558,
-0.0376911834,
-0.0439890213,
-0.0209106766,
-0.0273237657,
-0.0132377874,
-0.0177813843,
-0.0376502387,
-0.0191871226,
-0.013687863,
0.0053291414,
0.0145363398,
0.0280883536,
-0.0050377524,
-0.0330736563,
-0.0119432472,
0.0770390034,
0.0612850636,
0.0119122555,
-0.0202236138,
-0.0343600549,
0.0051421574,
0.0446225181,
0.0239143893,
-0.0046012569,
-0.0624708831,
0.0209131539,
0.0176032409,
0.0787711218,
0.0112296725,
0.0227424279,
0.0638104156,
-0.0234893672,
-0.0287797004,
0.0686377883,
-0.0104823476,
-0.0746398419,
-0.0363443531,
0.023510607,
0.0567447692,
0.0043654079,
-0.0082041519,
-0.0760979652,
-0.0636122674,
-0.0179967284,
-0.0032395115,
0.0333614945,
0.0093877362,
-0.0327066258,
-0.0693493187,
0.0544859618,
0.0047347802,
-0.041326195,
-0.0374535993,
0.0093887849,
-0.0054950221,
0.0259430334,
0.019892294,
-0.0002638831,
-0.0144673437,
-0.0022032049,
-0.0002038081,
0.0236086696,
-0.0649705306,
0.0011897481,
-0.0364006869,
0.0061925417,
0.0441575199,
0.0307133459,
0.0189627819,
-0.0132325748,
0.0799296126,
0.0172699895,
-0.0225416813,
-0.0292063355,
0.0485808887,
-0.0051385066,
-0.0157762822,
0.0085963458,
0.0632238835,
-0.0215257667,
0.0047700205,
-0.0025811649,
0.0300535057,
-0.0011652056,
-0.0122149587,
-0.0308264643,
0.0068516899,
0.0322580002,
0.0481161065,
0.0303082149,
-0.0700046048,
-0.0148087321,
-0.0199897885,
-0.0068384078,
-0.0355441086,
-0.0174673311,
-0.001990004,
-0.0053464198,
0.0385860056,
-0.081875436,
-0.0404217914,
0.0115875602,
0.0616909564,
-0.0108774928,
-0.0058206469,
-0.0401096605,
-0.006725783,
-0.0345991813,
0.0508658215,
-0.0436867662,
0.0429835767,
-0.0534676574,
-0.0044758823,
0.0452700108,
-0.0581468418,
0.0070615928,
0.0447537638,
-0.1130040362,
-0.0273157898,
-0.0369146056,
0.0485262759,
0.0116398865,
0.0721317083,
0.0119585777,
-0.0426729731,
0.04713827,
0.0513831601,
0.0189732816,
0.0239855535,
-0.0031465066,
0.0418790132,
-0.0088421842,
0.0458317772,
-0.042883601,
0.021424545,
0.0266369861,
0.0165396389,
-0.0082222568,
-0.0353906043,
0.00607609,
-0.0065928637,
0.0120837279,
-0.0601767972,
-0.0019699261,
-0.0385651886,
-0.0075133583,
-0.0199582353,
-0.0336905979,
-0.0965633094,
-0.0161190443,
0.0304370094,
0.0197112504,
-0.0071970304,
-0.004748024,
0.0550547987,
0.0530269109,
-0.0389977731,
0.0108931419,
0.0373548232,
0.0167383496,
0.0234159902,
0.0267698411,
-0.0066026459,
0.0414841324,
-0.0292413756,
0.0365350433,
-0.019376358,
0.0781873837,
0.0366536751,
-0.032554023,
-0.0308271907,
0.0474561304,
-0.0091258055,
-0.0043086084,
-0.0632653609,
0.0402298979,
0.0723466352,
0.0252727307,
0.0694139823,
-0.0282103382,
-0.0240315739,
-0.0346044898,
0.06153984,
0.0035043922,
-0.0481620692,
0.0551028252,
-0.0199890416,
0.0209460892,
0.0145869534,
0.0593513399,
0.0010421241,
0.0164949857,
0.0321890004,
0.044469323,
-0.0377746895,
-0.0275465157,
0.0330120511,
-0.0160432346,
0.0117809968,
0.0210592486,
-0.0081242705,
-0.0590864494,
0.0073679294,
0.0265114363,
-0.0228178799,
0.0183612518,
0.0366688929,
0.0573238693,
0.0215954036,
0.0079289572,
-0.0133501161,
-0.0023718853,
0.0344558917,
-0.0312121324,
-0.0283046849,
-5.899515579e-33,
-0.0431568064,
-0.0437102392,
0.0463879891,
0.006437391,
-0.0074467943,
0.0207550786,
-0.0126391184,
0.0263436902,
-0.0140433451,
-0.0000334458,
-0.0061203768,
-0.0317131542,
0.001069379,
0.0727805495,
-0.0285842475,
0.000513223,
0.0162946824,
-0.0299501605,
-0.0118877254,
0.0092379767,
-0.0013803893,
0.0127030527,
0.0303474069,
-0.0440301485,
-0.0168455988,
-0.0163818728,
-0.0459954627,
0.0166369434,
-0.0118777258,
0.0330567881,
-0.0303269364,
0.0230357889,
0.0233221985,
0.0091318963,
-0.0423192643,
0.0225824937,
-0.0838542506,
0.0287018754,
-0.021390982,
0.018315468,
-0.0858466774,
0.0135328555,
0.0467983745,
-0.0144460611,
0.0064470158,
-0.0579763949,
0.0385059789,
-0.0121125011,
-0.0193172637,
-0.0211066082,
-0.0584219433,
0.0065205353,
0.000112687,
-0.0427897386,
0.0300514977,
0.0734912902,
0.00552702,
0.0334992893,
-0.0672777966,
0.0160260368,
-0.0322532579,
0.0110838059,
0.0879273862,
0.0506786443,
-0.0125025967,
0.0425079428,
0.0232806541,
-0.0089016957,
-0.002939834,
0.0078114253,
0.0498272367,
0.0687688142,
0.028664019,
0.0936249569,
-0.0105030285,
0.0462118909,
-0.0382317603,
0.0337387249,
-0.0295048207,
-0.0092541929,
0.035323564,
0.0070656729,
-0.0044504111,
0.0008944282,
-0.0486103147,
-0.0220355988,
-0.0429420657,
0.0075033586,
0.0492979139,
0.0254207104,
-0.0028300821,
-0.0063913283,
0.0836080164,
-0.0175058804,
-0.0488117859,
-0.0100653553,
-0.0263403617,
0.0514076985,
-0.0122230574,
0.0309309289,
-0.0389197692,
-0.0262942556,
0.0268358607,
0.0340760723,
0.0136161894,
0.0104892757,
0.0806481093,
0.0219020154,
-0.0528374687,
-0.0067927572,
-0.0487079546,
0.0433409475,
-0.0173530169,
0.0447559543,
0.0267618839,
-0.0351872481,
-0.053011369,
0.0297987163,
0.0000645587,
-0.0296105407,
-0.0011971595,
-0.0297134314,
-0.0258479957,
-0.003582566,
-0.0227294266,
0.0244209655,
-0.0458858386,
-0.03590912,
0.0513692312,
-0.0544451289,
-0.003279598,
0.0229097996,
2.341e-7,
0.0335323103,
0.0109732812,
0.007061433,
0.0089489371,
0.0375897661,
0.0659548193,
-0.049942635,
0.0219627824,
0.015961444,
0.0005323316,
-0.0026067013,
0.0436778031,
0.0548838973,
-0.0096960645,
-0.0178491194,
0.0207236558,
-0.0319856219,
0.0330647975,
-0.0501632728,
-0.0185824018,
0.035012193,
0.0785977095,
-0.0314985923,
-0.0567907766,
0.046709463,
-0.0578126088,
0.0932859406,
-0.0561838113,
-0.0098024998,
-0.0242141634,
-0.0054312474,
-0.0029959828,
0.0018097567,
0.0042790975,
0.0127884289,
-0.0424494743,
0.0432113484,
0.0434938967,
-0.0075002401,
-0.0496038049,
0.0070729307,
0.0328930318,
-0.0469634384,
-0.0566000342,
0.0702420399,
-0.0526637286,
-0.0154130077,
-0.0396514423,
0.0143433921,
-0.0163617246,
0.0157532003,
-0.0438322276,
-0.0478077047,
0.0298324265,
0.0562964156,
-0.0158901606,
-0.0376543924,
-0.0792436302,
-0.0646727979,
-0.0206716936,
-0.0544903614,
-0.0092469612,
-0.0684615746,
0.0268776827,
0.0226051379,
-0.0370778032,
-0.0407186076,
1.785276191e-34,
-0.0047644684,
-0.0218407903,
0.0182853732,
0.0113053191,
0.0093119405,
-0.0092684608,
-0.0614871345,
-0.0044067586,
-0.0217044223,
-0.0622620322,
-0.0064980723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01806v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01806v1 | HQA-Attack: Toward High Quality Black-Box Hard-Label Adversarial Attack on Text | 2024-02-02T10:06:43 | 2024-02-02T10:06:43 | Han Liu, Zhi Xu, Xiaotong Zhang, Feng Zhang, Fenglong Ma, Hongyang Chen, Hong Yu, Xianchao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Black-box hard-label adversarial attack on text is a practical and
challenging task, as the text data space is inherently discrete and
non-differentiable, and only the predicted label is accessible. Research on
this problem is still in the embryonic stage and only a few methods are
available. Nevertheless, existing methods rely on the complex heuristic
algorithm or unreliable gradient estimation strategy, which probably fall into
the local optimum and inevitably consume numerous queries, thus are difficult
to craft satisfactory adversarial examples with high semantic similarity and
low perturbation rate in a limited query budget. To alleviate above issues, we
propose a simple yet effective framework to generate high quality textual
adversarial examples under the black-box hard-label attack scenarios, named
HQA-Attack. Specifically, after initializing an adversarial example randomly,
HQA-attack first constantly substitutes original words back as many as
possible, thus shrinking the perturbation rate. Then it leverages the synonym
set of the remaining changed words to further optimize the adversarial example
with the direction which can improve the semantic similarity and satisfy the
adversarial condition simultaneously. In addition, during the optimizing
procedure, it searches a transition synonym word for each changed word, thus
avoiding traversing the whole synonym set and reducing the query number to some
extent. Extensive experimental results on five text classification datasets,
three natural language inference datasets and two real-world APIs have shown
that the proposed HQA-Attack method outperforms other strong baselines
significantly. | [
0.0704244375,
0.0672181547,
-0.0124511551,
0.0111602172,
-0.0623154081,
0.0022996003,
0.0017680583,
0.0283385217,
0.0345331877,
-0.0446759984,
0.0036901666,
-0.0308294017,
0.0126310484,
-0.0003530678,
0.0563261546,
-0.005535061,
0.0507679246,
0.0377422199,
-0.0485261045,
-0.0248016175,
-0.0044692871,
0.0104485471,
-0.0069074901,
0.0036018621,
-0.0157106146,
-0.0145437326,
-0.033257246,
0.0253191926,
0.0495433733,
-0.0229206998,
0.0601439364,
0.0398328938,
-0.0110732159,
0.1045621932,
0.0000019485,
-0.0318985358,
-0.0557478815,
0.025112709,
-0.012599512,
0.0116965026,
0.0567972884,
-0.0348217636,
-0.0025706589,
0.0077451053,
-0.0162960012,
-0.0203024354,
0.0153122796,
0.0550470762,
0.0851854533,
0.1125141233,
-0.0179763045,
-0.0621120967,
-0.0051629478,
-0.0649363846,
-0.0061176331,
-0.0813983232,
0.058825627,
-0.0392669477,
-0.0264734272,
0.0125108231,
-0.0052495673,
0.0299933217,
0.0444984622,
0.0204783287,
0.0077614044,
0.0234129764,
-0.0114413863,
-0.0007969289,
0.0268102214,
0.0937823281,
-0.0485277921,
-0.0208875425,
0.0152414432,
0.0005260903,
0.0119372085,
-0.042994678,
0.0098244417,
-0.0304314792,
0.0038577013,
0.0225047823,
0.0140158692,
-0.0040222537,
0.0600021854,
0.017099252,
0.0196507834,
0.0002433319,
0.0342682526,
-0.0354135446,
0.0268521626,
-0.0551346689,
-0.0044151801,
-0.0171963293,
0.0146004129,
0.0267881341,
0.0030536258,
0.0060968697,
-0.0871672854,
-0.0698063746,
0.0337524824,
-0.0701621398,
0.0310579669,
-0.0211876333,
-0.0221672468,
0.040525917,
-0.0330959111,
-0.0093279732,
-0.0166932847,
0.0598850287,
-0.0144603299,
-0.032881245,
-0.0156859159,
-0.011887501,
-0.0576352514,
0.035492219,
-0.0163721759,
-0.0032938016,
-0.0453590117,
-0.0162481088,
-0.0295334272,
0.0352412574,
-0.0262783226,
0.0256825369,
-0.0360367671,
-0.0165772922,
0.0143003697,
-0.0765734389,
-0.0483130962,
0.0051135547,
-0.020925479,
-0.0676447526,
-0.0241311099,
0.0186404809,
-0.0212827306,
-0.0280555226,
0.0024770421,
0.1140647754,
-0.018832596,
-0.0337536074,
-0.0604540259,
-0.0240317043,
0.0032259098,
-0.0185177643,
-0.0137183564,
-0.0239989441,
0.0108059831,
-0.0547262691,
-0.0207063016,
-0.0576313064,
0.0000727748,
0.0215691179,
0.004595519,
0.0836957917,
-0.0237778444,
-0.0519664995,
0.0389122777,
0.0371262953,
-0.0155840544,
0.0752916336,
-0.0379520729,
0.0604718737,
0.0379070938,
0.0208234284,
-0.0075247218,
0.0206701476,
0.0471089073,
0.0289251618,
-0.0408341177,
0.0074629504,
0.0007700166,
0.0379543155,
-0.0370413214,
0.0513708293,
-0.0297607649,
-0.0981426388,
0.0368810482,
-0.0226488542,
0.000365736,
0.054476358,
-0.0042372546,
0.0015688593,
-0.0277220886,
-0.0112884184,
-0.0232953429,
-0.0105639528,
-0.0427993722,
-0.0479112044,
0.0553272665,
0.0119706551,
-0.0181587655,
-0.0380813107,
0.0118646324,
0.0009731454,
0.006370577,
-0.0513021126,
0.0196824074,
0.0762171,
-0.0151955476,
0.0476123951,
0.0353289433,
0.0054817661,
-0.0000204244,
-0.0391567349,
-0.0080225328,
0.0093297372,
0.0689062327,
-0.0303428303,
0.0347989462,
-0.0169177726,
-0.0007987644,
0.0041337586,
0.0266326871,
-0.0097108856,
-0.0065106102,
-0.0662631392,
-0.0127597172,
-0.0375412703,
0.0259097647,
0.0432437733,
0.0220490005,
0.025988644,
0.0466659032,
-0.0047325697,
-0.0324005373,
0.0346752442,
0.0268838424,
-0.0552934855,
0.0410027765,
0.0337919071,
0.0519808233,
-0.0079126004,
-0.0012087881,
0.0072953985,
0.0300111324,
-0.0196704175,
-0.0778326616,
-0.051913105,
0.0462059863,
-0.0340468474,
0.0323854759,
-0.0455635488,
-0.0033548456,
0.0740492344,
-0.0605713166,
0.0030451959,
0.0205889642,
-0.0470298119,
0.0107537638,
-0.0118021872,
-0.032261204,
-0.0079844845,
0.0610119477,
-0.0225885157,
0.057284791,
-0.0136056477,
0.0010258176,
-0.0208696499,
0.0433530994,
0.0088464422,
0.0137127573,
-0.051452484,
0.0023805317,
-0.0170849878,
0.0084386179,
-0.0041582086,
-0.0254913252,
-0.0270729158,
-0.0268450715,
-0.0026179273,
-0.0165632442,
-0.038867157,
-0.0252831504,
0.059104003,
-0.0095365578,
-0.0069688787,
-0.0312009007,
0.0039645648,
0.0334071331,
-0.068015404,
0.0428375341,
0.0494337492,
0.0275706351,
-0.0279972404,
-0.0130967107,
-0.0056405212,
0.0043959455,
0.0774527192,
0.0019230985,
0.0104255527,
-0.0078110299,
0.001761194,
-0.0084920693,
0.0342333578,
-0.035357222,
-0.0341793224,
-0.0009990954,
0.0243722275,
0.0009347837,
0.0542207845,
0.0577202328,
0.0339708738,
0.0272095948,
0.0129905241,
-0.0121049741,
-0.0148529923,
-0.0427051894,
0.0057257949,
-0.0499313548,
-0.0279406589,
0.0292960834,
0.039894212,
0.0334575698,
-0.0020752675,
-0.0164250359,
0.0263825357,
0.0150561621,
-0.0370382108,
-0.0498447083,
0.0427503511,
-0.0383679196,
-0.0349589065,
-0.0162484441,
-0.0323365815,
0.0761261806,
-0.0191811994,
0.034401916,
-0.0297815055,
-0.0528701693,
0.0037151587,
0.041467648,
-0.0184232816,
0.0213722121,
-0.0036001138,
0.0130225709,
-0.0129046999,
-0.0148269227,
0.0538306274,
-0.0029582428,
-0.0210976899,
0.0195460394,
0.0006748146,
-0.0023724311,
-0.0109730111,
-0.041018974,
-0.0667203441,
0.0012255872,
-0.0019603749,
0.0299719479,
-0.0091155544,
-0.0543072745,
-0.0253119525,
-0.0114411581,
0.0481891297,
-0.0259413999,
-0.000958943,
-0.0314549804,
0.0242006741,
0.0935944691,
-0.0610308796,
-0.0165712442,
-0.0010136472,
0.001396666,
0.0712218583,
0.0430174135,
0.0108428365,
-0.0084952386,
-0.0347543173,
-0.0072402623,
-0.0123815825,
0.0044954983,
-0.0045417272,
-0.0583612062,
-0.0057717059,
-0.0100258458,
0.0541013703,
-0.0052705668,
-0.0160005707,
0.034692388,
-0.0296632014,
0.0337664783,
-0.0060515949,
-0.0065882932,
-0.0722385496,
-0.037755385,
-0.0046906383,
0.031229442,
-0.0370046869,
-0.0331689715,
0.0024878085,
-0.107930325,
-0.0227565169,
0.0204060655,
-0.0044514956,
-0.0111506525,
-0.0155633707,
0.0090128072,
-0.0153108165,
-0.0090261055,
-0.0029531349,
0.0628785715,
-0.0095520327,
0.0036422045,
0.0299415942,
-0.0445841365,
0.0147489887,
-0.0002781762,
-0.0077549024,
0.0322460681,
0.0523007624,
-0.0116088046,
-0.01514987,
0.0625595823,
-0.0203205943,
-0.0353710912,
0.0209063962,
0.0632676035,
-0.0309296846,
-0.0258649979,
0.0231870022,
0.039178852,
0.0099268267,
0.0000746248,
0.00311521,
0.0306662004,
0.0080087734,
-0.0134119121,
-0.0228277724,
-0.0044317977,
0.0363998413,
0.0323782004,
0.0200362895,
-0.0613511801,
-0.0288210064,
-0.0003302818,
0.0316083804,
-0.0297992583,
-0.0157483704,
0.0273948833,
-0.0149402404,
-0.0341271646,
-0.0520980172,
-0.0252076797,
-0.0449218974,
0.0551656149,
-0.0109810028,
0.0217732135,
-0.0320004076,
-0.0375241712,
-0.0168414246,
-0.0335539505,
-0.0122222668,
0.0390862413,
-0.0095418356,
-0.0071169022,
0.0559203885,
0.019528674,
-0.0450116396,
0.0268099476,
-0.0276791528,
-0.0728461966,
0.0166302267,
-0.0050245244,
0.0051466604,
0.05499411,
-0.05176064,
-0.0778538957,
0.0221976377,
0.0751959383,
0.0346193463,
0.0014268381,
0.0461505391,
-0.0434683338,
0.0345704108,
0.0756059289,
-0.0363057144,
0.0052349749,
0.0611202605,
0.0078061759,
-0.0162401237,
0.0014627816,
-0.0088960798,
0.0088121369,
0.0491900593,
-0.0171950944,
0.0062888078,
0.031951353,
0.0660321638,
0.0083059035,
-0.0500917993,
0.0125578269,
0.0455105789,
0.0015003225,
-0.0065621892,
-0.0038642201,
0.0027494333,
0.0073725441,
0.0257053692,
0.0096946405,
-0.0105183171,
0.0176103096,
0.0734537765,
0.0367080383,
-0.0022011548,
-0.0073778173,
-0.0127537502,
0.0436591431,
0.04552586,
-0.017728826,
0.0014273827,
0.0580702983,
-0.0118311653,
-0.0048024594,
0.0135130091,
-0.0296732616,
0.0230951197,
-0.0566165671,
-0.0156624336,
0.0255195331,
0.0199417081,
-0.0422073752,
-0.0224854983,
-0.0347644314,
0.005589026,
-0.0167342201,
-0.0387426242,
-0.0602474362,
-0.0110364715,
0.0056593618,
-0.0074206111,
0.0618429109,
0.0446771272,
0.0297681764,
0.0635577664,
0.0210489538,
-0.0169593543,
-0.0370656811,
-0.0034001742,
0.0361929685,
0.004120524,
0.0210445058,
-0.0296632107,
-0.0337667204,
-0.0690826252,
0.0473788753,
-0.0289600212,
-0.0114351166,
0.0577666126,
0.0397062339,
0.0649781302,
0.0181231834,
0.0076522874,
-0.0476136766,
0.0405378193,
0.0055301399,
-0.0609361865,
0.0100865765,
-6.176220705e-33,
0.0017646705,
-0.0321546979,
-0.0351138711,
-0.1045028493,
0.009276079,
-0.0007411495,
0.0042603537,
-0.0675959662,
0.012608747,
0.022431599,
0.0137749771,
0.0041728793,
-0.0091606379,
0.0345283486,
-0.0571854562,
-0.0554673485,
0.041400481,
0.0130667184,
-0.0517641604,
0.0155031364,
0.0396297202,
0.0366627797,
0.0269581284,
-0.0414401442,
-0.0119932313,
-0.0087373126,
-0.0427537933,
-0.0182499532,
-0.0584118254,
0.016224144,
0.0121762529,
0.0432198532,
0.0059171892,
-0.0092825834,
0.0235635471,
0.0016782052,
-0.040595796,
-0.0118956119,
-0.0242244173,
0.0120830098,
-0.0144970063,
-0.0089159962,
0.0412293263,
0.0000638587,
-0.0021603808,
0.0043983869,
0.0004036769,
-0.0310137849,
-0.0232397188,
-0.0162064359,
-0.0207699575,
0.0385352597,
-0.001874809,
0.0255548283,
-0.037266925,
0.0034430914,
0.0557712652,
0.0036715113,
-0.1191231459,
-0.0062308707,
0.0101758111,
0.0105386162,
0.0099037616,
0.0065554869,
0.0334642269,
0.0499876663,
0.0482897498,
-0.0126100276,
-0.0094514778,
0.0131549872,
-0.0031777208,
0.0109861214,
0.0700793639,
0.1033524647,
0.0718811676,
-0.0532876439,
-0.0838102922,
-0.005008013,
-0.0239167772,
0.0010934848,
0.0400397815,
0.0165201314,
-0.0663467199,
0.0061835195,
-0.0273427181,
-0.0339003243,
-0.0191555861,
-0.0282839853,
0.0196962766,
0.0233168006,
-0.0468735881,
0.0329647213,
-0.0536044873,
-0.0213315543,
-0.0153476577,
0.0175751206,
-0.0333387069,
-0.022225963,
0.0124236625,
0.010709567,
-0.0264421739,
-0.0375042446,
0.0324832126,
-0.0212672725,
0.011690055,
-0.0208671764,
0.0334075727,
-0.0069822562,
-0.0839165077,
-0.0193970148,
0.0084874621,
0.0309833791,
-0.004863074,
-0.0529004857,
-0.002427897,
-0.0128231393,
-0.0149218244,
0.0569733344,
0.0412191451,
0.0283590127,
0.0061944756,
0.0441649072,
-0.0225440171,
-0.002409752,
-0.0069120056,
-0.0157482661,
0.0189455543,
0.0072931061,
0.0650901049,
-0.0939998627,
0.0254517086,
-0.0341908894,
2.856e-7,
-0.0156954136,
0.0152242724,
0.0066102925,
-0.0330657512,
0.0209528618,
0.0695534796,
0.0304900445,
0.0645082444,
-0.0523351878,
-0.022942964,
-0.0018575223,
-0.0185495075,
0.0347498879,
0.0171275362,
-0.0500160679,
0.0023842931,
-0.1217537597,
-0.018858945,
-0.0579039864,
-0.0198908523,
0.0529094152,
0.1145720333,
0.0757957771,
-0.0283784922,
-0.0376565531,
-0.042108383,
0.0392273553,
0.0279072803,
0.0091753742,
0.0184742436,
0.0316991545,
0.0053178407,
0.0376693867,
0.0049416739,
-0.0348758548,
0.0017714298,
0.0302243009,
0.0050828224,
-0.0139027154,
-0.0558165722,
-0.0134644629,
-0.0043927995,
-0.0045231408,
-0.0226834361,
0.1009232551,
-0.0308076702,
-0.0220406521,
-0.0192926861,
-0.0285051353,
0.0357614346,
0.0517362356,
-0.0252104718,
-0.017397156,
0.0128047084,
0.009658996,
0.0478247292,
-0.0016716154,
-0.1100782454,
0.0374560654,
-0.0030846028,
-0.0188783407,
0.0202169027,
-0.0355024897,
0.0544104837,
0.0133039588,
-0.019080447,
0.0290141683,
2.225664244e-34,
0.0031229004,
-0.0314358138,
-0.0164808091,
-0.0042891521,
0.0356499441,
0.0094488468,
0.0337449238,
-0.002725146,
0.0133836595,
-0.0166906733,
-0.0223439783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01805v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01805v3 | Can LLMs perform structured graph reasoning? | 2024-02-02T09:45:33 | 2024-04-18T12:04:12 | Palaash Agrawal, Shavak Vasania, Cheston Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pretrained Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated various reasoning
capabilities through language-based prompts alone, particularly in unstructured
task settings (tasks purely based on language semantics). However, LLMs often
struggle with structured tasks, because of the inherent incompatibility of
input representation. Reducing structured tasks to uni-dimensional language
semantics often renders the problem trivial. Keeping the trade-off between LLM
compatibility and structure complexity in mind, we design various graph
reasoning tasks as a proxy to semi-structured tasks in this paper, in order to
test the ability to navigate through representations beyond plain text in
various LLMs. Particularly, we design 10 distinct problems of graph traversal,
each representing increasing levels of complexity, and benchmark 5 different
instruct-finetuned LLMs (GPT-4, GPT-3.5, Claude-2, Llama-2 and Palm-2) on the
aforementioned tasks. Further, we analyse the performance of models across
various settings such as varying sizes of graphs as well as different forms of
k-shot prompting. We highlight various limitations, biases and properties of
LLMs through this benchmarking process, such as an inverse relation to the
average degrees of freedom of traversal per node in graphs, the overall
negative impact of k-shot prompting on graph reasoning tasks, and a positive
response bias which prevents LLMs from identifying the absence of a valid
solution. Finally, we introduce a new prompting technique specially designed
for graph traversal tasks (PathCompare), which demonstrates a notable increase
in the performance of LLMs in comparison to standard prompting techniques such
as Chain-of-Thought (CoT). | [
0.0204608645,
-0.014378137,
-0.0113827297,
0.0299701765,
-0.0605017617,
0.0195846725,
0.0097906748,
-0.0122606577,
0.070958294,
-0.0333542265,
-0.0082594855,
-0.0027182421,
-0.0206102114,
0.0292949732,
0.0066207359,
-0.0451612286,
0.0407061987,
-0.063389115,
0.0034507243,
-0.0288846698,
-0.0286437739,
0.0096780164,
-0.004253055,
0.0121780848,
-0.0021560243,
-0.0329443067,
-0.0516579598,
0.0136271315,
-0.0197307225,
-0.076533623,
-0.03325928,
0.0322912149,
0.0353936814,
0.0279910564,
0.0000021877,
-0.0301378109,
0.0057087936,
-0.0171746984,
-0.0749873593,
-0.0013655778,
-0.0063995663,
-0.0182889886,
0.0244460385,
-0.006910386,
-0.0196576305,
-0.0438351557,
0.0300200488,
0.0351162776,
0.0612078458,
0.077918984,
0.0008292712,
-0.0277824663,
-0.0009466824,
-0.0070052394,
0.0127003808,
-0.0477469936,
0.0300961025,
0.0254670791,
0.0469675027,
0.0233225506,
-0.0290776305,
0.0181931257,
0.0397225283,
-0.0062439507,
0.0192768984,
0.0320981592,
-0.0023522431,
0.0056826002,
-0.0002077948,
0.1115733087,
0.0026153717,
-0.0086934026,
0.0002771143,
-0.0221483149,
-0.0173465163,
0.0107013192,
-0.0502035953,
0.0052362951,
-0.0135364085,
0.002344179,
-0.0114165107,
-0.0175656267,
0.0604639612,
-0.0114577776,
-0.04497917,
0.1178959161,
-0.009862652,
-0.0253744926,
0.059067037,
0.0053909137,
0.006717816,
-0.0670655891,
0.0095817884,
0.0700017437,
-0.0527546629,
0.0275104512,
-0.0080661438,
0.0126981903,
-0.0145030022,
0.0041360068,
0.0487899072,
0.0213451572,
-0.0060946732,
0.0671318248,
-0.0190451015,
0.0452293679,
-0.049340494,
0.0622862428,
-0.0344933905,
-0.0019622499,
-0.0438204147,
-0.0135943852,
-0.0573392324,
0.0330860838,
-0.0216950402,
-0.0446790755,
-0.0059722732,
0.0621695034,
-0.0126516987,
0.0257560797,
0.0225580391,
-0.0007278555,
0.0407069437,
-0.0263970606,
-0.0467551015,
0.0124677699,
-0.0503148884,
-0.0069980733,
-0.0073633925,
0.0073036146,
-0.0113239326,
-0.0015848652,
0.0287505947,
-0.0562146567,
0.0298371706,
0.0826146081,
0.0337360315,
-0.0335657634,
-0.0313082486,
-0.0328851379,
-0.0004942755,
-0.072988078,
0.0504691005,
-0.0817658082,
0.0503341518,
0.0395869799,
-0.0131171998,
0.0006099649,
0.0116874492,
0.002936715,
-0.0572464541,
0.0781711042,
0.0157482438,
0.0383045375,
-0.003565026,
-0.0047993283,
-0.0317818224,
0.0223693531,
0.0085044131,
0.0145736802,
0.0027952669,
0.0103717027,
-0.0071532219,
0.0322803222,
0.0076307557,
-0.0070355851,
0.0093299756,
0.0108549176,
-0.0338807777,
0.0352367088,
-0.0196416061,
0.059141241,
-0.037893638,
-0.0267145596,
0.0011440873,
0.0564632751,
0.0033795247,
-0.048118908,
0.062330313,
0.005696808,
-0.0059541212,
0.0316750519,
-0.0833943188,
0.0208506007,
-0.0356318057,
0.0068560219,
-0.0062168171,
-0.0357569903,
-0.0100370571,
-0.026996972,
-0.015683474,
0.0156797115,
0.054227531,
0.0220670085,
0.0699799731,
0.0160008855,
-0.0373958871,
-0.0011465113,
0.0261188634,
0.0044100513,
-0.0297348369,
-0.0195876919,
-0.0001359089,
0.0827583969,
0.0651394427,
0.0007695969,
-0.0415954925,
0.0271880757,
0.0165163539,
0.0000480187,
0.0245876871,
-0.022508489,
-0.0266574938,
-0.0405106433,
-0.0299150907,
-0.0354100056,
-0.0181909092,
0.0338162854,
0.0075534806,
-0.010690595,
0.0025102373,
-0.0646902174,
-0.0054589109,
0.0106310993,
0.026676923,
-0.0073505933,
-0.0109208599,
0.016765181,
0.0016215052,
0.0205976944,
-0.0011437285,
0.0325930826,
0.0205563921,
-0.0031916655,
-0.0116859032,
-0.0217808727,
-0.059074685,
-0.0812674761,
0.024089573,
0.000063873,
-0.0592630804,
-0.0045336341,
-0.0458023101,
-0.0404366851,
0.0376613848,
-0.023197867,
0.0080624707,
0.002054858,
0.0230079703,
0.0343415402,
-0.0432957858,
-0.015458189,
0.087779507,
0.0265197642,
0.0181988832,
0.0346760303,
0.0258365031,
0.003616126,
-0.0553345308,
-0.0123152547,
0.0422618911,
0.0211827531,
-0.0294929892,
0.0031738677,
-0.0009055376,
-0.0484430641,
0.0247291159,
-0.0894433334,
-0.0046233763,
-0.0023984266,
0.0151340254,
-0.0169414449,
-0.0128429178,
0.0086455606,
-0.038351655,
-0.0626020357,
0.0489438921,
0.0406335816,
0.0471923985,
0.0194047112,
-0.0200817194,
-0.0124049587,
-0.0108968886,
-0.0533804335,
-0.0494392365,
0.053408321,
0.0182979051,
-0.0346226096,
-0.0022514607,
0.0511673987,
-0.0381001569,
0.0324633159,
-0.0170414522,
0.0331553109,
0.0342798568,
-0.0385981835,
0.0566794612,
0.0684801787,
-0.0527559221,
0.0164701194,
0.0545836203,
-0.0470748581,
-0.0355108604,
0.0257688053,
-0.0259582009,
-0.02194448,
-0.0455693789,
-0.010634548,
-0.0164731015,
0.0434353873,
-0.0035511651,
0.0102005359,
-0.047485631,
-0.0202310141,
-0.0048633064,
0.0364809111,
-0.0279227849,
-0.0314589925,
0.022339059,
0.0492053814,
-0.0299518909,
0.0060772207,
0.0997969657,
-0.0239432249,
-0.0167777427,
0.0332329571,
-0.0137435813,
-0.0490632951,
0.1039873213,
0.0532907248,
0.0105154067,
-0.0092065344,
-0.0214211997,
-0.043280784,
-0.0075930054,
0.0275315028,
-0.0010841588,
0.0132761607,
-0.0232023466,
0.0295511838,
0.0076986058,
-0.0331638008,
-0.021693008,
0.003661376,
-0.0491387919,
0.0184395686,
-0.0100095281,
-0.0128588211,
0.0211660899,
0.0017222977,
-0.0005578402,
0.0166833289,
-0.011294526,
0.0042642085,
-0.0478947908,
0.0225428008,
0.0226751268,
-0.0204215478,
0.0208102725,
-0.0445747897,
0.0489612184,
0.0360557958,
0.0146892564,
-0.0332551785,
-0.0245092865,
0.0455057733,
0.0001042228,
-0.0058804229,
-0.0329784118,
-0.0025689332,
0.0408743061,
-0.0866541564,
-0.0060452269,
0.0879168287,
0.0354060978,
-0.0256859157,
-0.0070119519,
-0.0184285175,
0.0109444521,
0.039029669,
0.0363355651,
-0.1061251983,
-0.0288043395,
0.0150825148,
0.000316568,
0.0014348024,
-0.0610429011,
-0.0026589786,
-0.1264254153,
0.0351919346,
0.0139515623,
0.00906255,
-0.0225525871,
-0.0347292721,
-0.0223820135,
0.0499414615,
-0.0215457976,
0.0037731852,
0.0015268612,
-0.0100676846,
0.00014819,
-0.0056615947,
0.0033981453,
0.0678784326,
0.0125121754,
0.0188041832,
0.0068396833,
-0.0004912718,
0.0352363996,
-0.0192116927,
0.0621971227,
0.0117233992,
0.0195553843,
-0.0299526937,
0.0084803952,
0.0073307292,
-0.0119468272,
-0.0376886353,
-0.0113095026,
-0.0243305098,
-0.0406738818,
-0.001764004,
0.1235010475,
-0.0401309058,
-0.0450185835,
-0.0033695216,
-0.0076149045,
-0.0404312275,
0.0404970236,
0.0409718081,
0.0309271198,
-0.0823668763,
-0.0592802949,
-0.0160901453,
-0.0318720751,
-0.0267519411,
0.0465772822,
-0.0144828511,
0.0443338007,
-0.042451527,
-0.0393240601,
0.0699326098,
0.036661353,
-0.0273190495,
-0.0217288099,
0.0349544287,
-0.025127247,
-0.048359409,
0.0247475617,
-0.0564347506,
0.0370451212,
-0.0372163728,
-0.0055240621,
-0.0123785902,
-0.006871358,
-0.0127389664,
-0.0071617668,
-0.0457640775,
-0.0774207264,
-0.050546173,
0.0177995618,
0.0221918132,
0.0544381253,
-0.0205548536,
-0.0152948154,
0.0333871916,
-0.0078103375,
-0.023857221,
-0.0004989827,
0.0274383351,
0.0119533949,
-0.0203289445,
0.0308786221,
-0.0561170764,
0.0310468394,
0.0162146762,
0.0474142022,
-0.0185104758,
-0.0373168401,
0.0217758324,
0.0636679828,
0.0301063173,
0.067084685,
0.009095272,
-0.0183680207,
0.0071177059,
-0.0413699225,
-0.0543639585,
-0.0227439348,
-0.0170804486,
0.0164471827,
-0.0063165817,
0.0214154553,
-0.0542311519,
0.0001057278,
0.0493446216,
-0.0208956841,
-0.0188475605,
0.0189585052,
-0.0191897843,
0.0567604154,
0.0015085129,
-0.0159128662,
0.0283526275,
0.0145061519,
0.0292153228,
-0.0033740178,
0.0682590455,
0.0405132994,
-0.018512981,
-0.0719611421,
-0.0154209659,
-0.0785738528,
-0.0703749508,
0.0498880073,
0.0257413089,
0.0376687795,
0.0162912458,
-0.0044912812,
-0.0330912396,
-0.0077028903,
-0.0059996829,
0.0116146319,
0.0417262092,
-0.0643203631,
0.0697149485,
0.0605520643,
0.0215952303,
-0.001854855,
0.033923503,
0.0431423075,
0.0314821526,
0.0285553001,
-0.0282880906,
-0.0255632047,
-0.0474115945,
-0.0300889406,
0.0394173153,
-0.0017548186,
0.0291978009,
-0.0487628095,
-0.0919459313,
-0.0029033821,
0.010299216,
-0.015851954,
-0.0198315121,
0.0409076586,
0.0297235195,
0.0583561137,
-0.0465060882,
-0.0148539245,
0.0369871445,
-0.0155440755,
-0.0183925852,
-0.0007443405,
-6.528632442e-33,
-0.0312387515,
-0.0701669753,
0.0609974973,
0.0134958411,
-0.0304719284,
0.0022395363,
-0.0781379491,
0.0074362024,
-0.0251820348,
0.0224171951,
-0.0176478904,
0.0060677612,
-0.0022176031,
0.0148255937,
-0.0126629518,
-0.0171919465,
0.0145152239,
0.0238711014,
-0.0110390056,
0.020190699,
0.0316211209,
-0.0060699615,
0.0165192429,
-0.0296767317,
0.0236296151,
-0.0231787283,
0.0201404113,
0.0417729467,
-0.0405883826,
0.0335595571,
-0.0178758185,
0.0284014456,
0.0382373855,
0.0081758555,
-0.0061794971,
0.0455750935,
-0.0795350894,
-0.0496031307,
0.0247119572,
0.0123294992,
-0.0803910419,
-0.021795081,
0.025071986,
-0.0147452531,
0.0168308057,
-0.0228008926,
0.0104044974,
0.0116930893,
-0.0320023671,
0.0213225875,
-0.032912679,
0.0196752958,
-0.0239907969,
-0.0209822785,
0.0371802971,
0.0439873636,
-0.0017047572,
0.0060179899,
-0.0169723183,
0.0260707438,
-0.0135050463,
-0.0166933816,
0.029148709,
0.0200120118,
0.0336589627,
0.0241625849,
0.0072882762,
0.0010437128,
-0.0454670116,
0.0323421322,
-0.0142736956,
0.0713676661,
-0.0048522833,
-0.0049227048,
-0.0165470187,
0.0328442156,
-0.0885346234,
-0.0278147515,
-0.0004637404,
0.0375054926,
-0.0045373756,
0.0166533943,
-0.0335195437,
-0.0667518601,
-0.0434604585,
-0.0171206202,
-0.0405833498,
-0.0317448899,
0.0226063505,
-0.0227582473,
0.0067891828,
-0.0003182991,
0.01192901,
-0.0187467765,
-0.0281311199,
0.0560236424,
-0.0148695167,
0.0447106212,
-0.00781452,
0.0655665025,
-0.02924354,
-0.0396319367,
0.0181928631,
-0.0348897912,
0.0164891426,
0.0357745588,
0.0275376979,
0.0143223433,
-0.0475922488,
-0.0209074225,
-0.0646564215,
-0.0074856058,
-0.0333543792,
-0.0015807502,
0.0778954029,
0.0525655784,
-0.0022162509,
0.0764672309,
0.0005520372,
-0.0144955367,
-0.0218877979,
0.0375506245,
-0.0199857652,
0.0294888467,
-0.0299436804,
-0.0096299136,
-0.0373285189,
0.0224458799,
0.0391973145,
-0.0626231357,
-0.0039119273,
0.0313785523,
3e-7,
0.0281168856,
0.0523444228,
0.0358012915,
0.0660878047,
0.008282654,
0.0234673712,
-0.0279705506,
-0.003163808,
0.0047013676,
-0.0482137538,
0.0371329971,
0.0812377334,
-0.0173708927,
0.0261782277,
-0.0553212874,
0.0495870858,
-0.0407648832,
-0.0399610624,
-0.068501249,
0.0225356258,
0.0724793896,
0.0300088096,
0.0100040818,
0.0045677405,
-0.0069887755,
-0.0731308982,
0.0455456935,
0.0046419143,
-0.0023481445,
-0.0357619226,
-0.0296355188,
-0.0164138321,
-0.010799868,
0.0551048778,
0.030177718,
0.0140297534,
0.0062235789,
0.0495787635,
-0.0017634956,
-0.0156878475,
-0.0005219135,
-0.0507653877,
0.0018104215,
-0.0236529596,
0.1062869728,
-0.0440664217,
-0.0600491799,
0.0074495841,
-0.008297747,
-0.0461005531,
-0.0011155526,
0.0093586976,
-0.0098045636,
0.0019347206,
0.0192569755,
-0.0143030118,
0.026040189,
-0.0787309483,
0.010760719,
0.0077234786,
-0.0039477595,
-0.0315451026,
-0.0346239135,
0.0333741643,
0.0374369062,
-0.0053306576,
-0.0147047369,
2.899614415e-34,
0.0449366644,
-0.003709042,
0.0138852447,
-0.0235430412,
0.0327511095,
-0.0167359691,
-0.0532356054,
0.025755981,
0.0481214933,
-0.1249096468,
-0.0299935024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01267v1 | The Human and the Mechanical: logos, truthfulness, and ChatGPT | 2024-02-02T09:41:51 | 2024-02-02T09:41:51 | Anastasia Giannakidou, Alda Mari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The paper addresses the question of whether it is appropriate to talk about
`mechanical minds' at all, and whether ChatGPT models can indeed be thought of
as realizations of that. Our paper adds a semantic argument to the current
debate. The act of human assertion requires the formation of a veridicality
judgment. Modification of assertions with modals (John must be at home) and the
use of subjective elements (John is obviously at home) indicate that the
speaker is manipulating her judgments and, in a cooperative context, intends
her epistemic state to be transparent to the addressee. Veridicality judgments
are formed on the basis of two components: (i) evidence that relates to reality
(exogenous evidence) and (ii) endogenous evidence, such as preferences and
private beliefs. `Mechanical minds' lack these two components: (i) they do not
relate to reality and (ii) do not have endogenous evidence. Therefore they lack
the ability to form a belief about the world and a veridicality judgments
altogether. They can only mimic that judgment, but the output is not ground in
the very foundations for it. | [
0.0366125703,
0.0164987203,
-0.0488525368,
-0.0149072483,
-0.0570036396,
-0.0043312507,
-0.0610109344,
0.0013963737,
0.001235778,
-0.043931555,
-0.0195621643,
0.0115365256,
-0.0225313008,
-0.0476354212,
0.0803829581,
-0.032794036,
0.0043321135,
0.0153450295,
-0.0038817581,
0.0076222089,
0.0021352668,
0.0111138858,
0.0034738528,
0.0109079126,
-0.0020601952,
0.0203685164,
-0.0176781509,
-0.025843123,
0.0282622203,
-0.007582305,
-0.0428696908,
0.0179498699,
-0.0061311438,
0.0366076306,
0.0000023084,
-0.0006570896,
0.0609555058,
-0.0173972044,
-0.0189753696,
-0.0019715778,
0.0071563628,
0.0405989066,
0.024954116,
-0.0132906474,
-0.0382543504,
-0.0038778908,
0.0003034639,
0.033488214,
-0.0361533128,
0.0274070296,
-0.0000784283,
0.0369336493,
-0.0230405647,
-0.0073315869,
0.0279808436,
0.0415560305,
0.0259427447,
0.0211923774,
-0.010371686,
0.0045511257,
-0.0218619723,
0.0041641043,
0.016641615,
0.0076310756,
-0.0268723462,
-0.0144004021,
-0.0241672099,
-0.0377301313,
0.0165673606,
0.029015813,
0.1383457482,
-0.0358844064,
0.0248842258,
0.0531407148,
0.0502654389,
0.0357592888,
0.0150412284,
0.0768085644,
-0.0221401174,
-0.0125590023,
-0.005145763,
0.0078579364,
-0.0198647939,
0.0050499504,
0.0026058587,
0.0231434088,
-0.0344577767,
0.0098213255,
0.0013555064,
0.0009323362,
-0.0000964117,
-0.0712791681,
-0.0788756907,
0.00536825,
-0.0038578545,
-0.0060727769,
-0.0310421567,
0.05905471,
-0.0108690793,
-0.0813928694,
-0.048456002,
0.0053099222,
0.0016696408,
0.0125074536,
0.0187724605,
-0.0112799611,
-0.0510353446,
0.1087487414,
-0.0576886237,
0.0543258563,
-0.0609563105,
-0.026713619,
-0.0128059536,
0.0051856651,
0.0412088446,
0.0128298774,
-0.0145224826,
-0.0038182919,
-0.0421968624,
-0.0201147925,
-0.1026041731,
0.0065703015,
-0.0199751314,
-0.0343581587,
-0.0413453132,
0.0166707113,
-0.0290679559,
0.0200475194,
-0.0295208525,
-0.0683937818,
0.0199385285,
-0.0110103758,
-0.0150567936,
0.0325202942,
-0.0047166036,
0.0714944154,
0.0060617146,
-0.0009366382,
0.0391191505,
-0.0199819151,
-0.0112945717,
-0.0715329275,
-0.0120794782,
0.0176491048,
-0.0040606763,
-0.0005780747,
0.0122234197,
0.0065124254,
0.0063023763,
-0.003229097,
-0.0000105879,
0.0334077477,
0.0413911566,
-0.0115364017,
-0.0446842536,
0.0185840521,
-0.0329996832,
0.0020352765,
-0.0102755809,
0.0373722464,
-0.0118627194,
0.0172032844,
0.0340331867,
-0.0147682363,
-0.0266536474,
-0.0298745017,
-0.0064317579,
0.0134773105,
0.0262514744,
0.0095972652,
-0.0178576242,
0.0449284799,
-0.0385058336,
0.0463837273,
0.0290464032,
0.0135061406,
-0.0021122261,
-0.0021888786,
0.0093303034,
0.0082396995,
0.0207644273,
0.0707372352,
-0.0373551138,
0.0110003408,
0.0071085435,
-0.0143871848,
-0.0630729795,
0.0064903195,
-0.0260062795,
-0.0190346967,
0.0102296658,
0.0097524254,
0.0208315384,
0.016716294,
0.0115574868,
-0.0284998957,
0.0426113866,
-0.0412446968,
0.0256225877,
0.0073109833,
-0.0309175905,
-0.0805216953,
0.0573018901,
-0.0135522299,
0.0013477699,
0.0577434264,
0.0141635993,
-0.0219761953,
-0.0264810696,
0.0529386066,
0.0501232557,
0.0227203835,
-0.0599648692,
0.005610893,
0.0126940124,
-0.0389514379,
-0.0158767812,
0.0499266312,
-0.1154161543,
0.0322526135,
0.0051231924,
0.0066462583,
0.0846835151,
-0.0031571081,
0.0670010373,
-0.0016513263,
-0.0848506838,
0.0046456605,
0.0161167048,
-0.0321316347,
0.0049950345,
0.0196450613,
0.0167132169,
-0.0207873285,
-0.0301218349,
0.1077811569,
-0.04535475,
0.0948749036,
-0.0116718663,
-0.127938211,
0.0187072679,
-0.0279838908,
0.049895715,
0.0128573803,
-0.0094068302,
-0.021459356,
0.0378185213,
-0.0355195776,
-0.0054279496,
-0.0258332063,
-0.0182064325,
0.000245045,
0.0013770349,
0.0151798539,
-0.0033028738,
-0.0494359955,
-0.0283724926,
0.0819800198,
0.0364537239,
-0.0178104639,
0.0502439067,
-0.0119991573,
0.026458215,
0.0119928513,
-0.0040346589,
-0.0436865427,
-0.0217358265,
-0.0857849568,
-0.0536140203,
0.0201424491,
-0.0343931504,
-0.0113765132,
-0.040734645,
-0.0171466935,
0.0377653912,
0.0104655353,
0.0688745975,
0.033274468,
0.0384226441,
0.0090375682,
-0.0158363041,
0.0062124464,
0.0414827876,
0.0351135805,
-0.0369905382,
-0.020773232,
0.0153083373,
-0.0334214829,
-0.0305020716,
-0.0275697894,
-0.0669113174,
-0.0246613175,
-0.0177807994,
-0.0403671749,
0.0198284835,
0.029773172,
0.0228591636,
0.0086741978,
0.0157333687,
0.0366691202,
0.0033220688,
0.0115113854,
-0.0062221088,
-0.0321580581,
0.013784118,
0.0028584697,
0.0001131443,
-0.0429106131,
0.001093132,
0.033845365,
0.0406740941,
0.0400179066,
-0.0543590039,
0.1171950623,
-0.0247386619,
-0.0316760726,
0.0053219679,
-0.0244693942,
-0.0108830947,
0.0445555225,
0.0079867281,
-0.0258414689,
0.0255468115,
0.0146109462,
0.0000862648,
0.0496497154,
0.0200057589,
0.0091658365,
0.06127657,
0.0444188155,
0.0258305855,
0.1202600747,
-0.0094286259,
-0.0503114648,
-0.0170000345,
0.0296420436,
-0.0094557703,
-0.0303547438,
-0.0178842228,
0.0392448306,
0.0127718411,
-0.0482774489,
-0.0107604209,
0.0098726247,
-0.039127592,
0.0002712661,
0.0404824018,
0.0005847533,
-0.0125413975,
-0.0116186878,
0.0428073257,
-0.0118103921,
0.0236015152,
-0.0064387354,
-0.0334538408,
-0.0644145384,
-0.0103822108,
0.0758830681,
0.0181249976,
0.0299504511,
-0.039246913,
0.0969434381,
0.0120324017,
-0.0007040305,
0.0140976505,
-0.0157175716,
-0.0159398746,
0.0474957153,
-0.0026190446,
-0.0046237838,
0.0140792606,
0.0084479339,
0.0022930778,
0.0066471593,
-0.022412831,
0.0262394287,
0.0068271998,
-0.029938709,
-0.0309541728,
-0.0015554572,
0.0034181182,
-0.116846025,
0.0448560268,
-0.0126579078,
-0.0340689421,
-0.0773279443,
-0.0285252705,
-0.0095508462,
0.006177532,
0.0469785631,
0.0296880696,
0.0176335406,
0.0070702597,
0.0505837835,
-0.0180358049,
-0.0139160147,
-0.0233419631,
0.0085637504,
0.0132533647,
0.0295730885,
0.0121591333,
0.0156371091,
0.0309244227,
-0.0015928724,
0.0129154027,
0.0146885272,
-0.0125740543,
0.0310308356,
-0.0296400376,
-0.082144767,
0.0021342863,
0.0162580721,
0.0123682944,
0.0153401447,
-0.0826081932,
-0.0286119934,
-0.0026982508,
-0.0747207031,
-0.0063137691,
0.0406168476,
0.0090782493,
0.0461896583,
0.0632168502,
-0.0258273762,
-0.0616731048,
0.0150683541,
-0.0113905193,
-0.0435520597,
0.019961996,
0.0044023842,
0.0036057294,
0.018620424,
-0.0288287122,
-0.0348668285,
0.1057378873,
-0.0956507623,
-0.0380628407,
0.0198491774,
-0.0089325132,
-0.0382932536,
-0.0599675514,
-0.0182961728,
0.0646701902,
0.0103263063,
-0.0615186207,
0.0517434366,
0.0015056161,
-0.0185668319,
0.024187997,
-0.0538673624,
-0.0391481072,
0.0238679163,
0.0107082501,
-0.0060264817,
-0.0645688251,
-0.0143168001,
-0.0544502549,
0.0528673306,
-0.0268626846,
0.0286210328,
0.0301700365,
0.0427463353,
0.0072480785,
0.0017750615,
0.0651133657,
-0.0210468136,
0.0091744298,
-0.0495588332,
0.080020383,
0.0011621405,
0.0482578911,
-0.028523406,
-0.0096380245,
0.047725372,
0.0117363827,
-0.0138554741,
-0.0472545438,
0.0059986245,
-0.0282963794,
0.0758240446,
0.0126203764,
-0.0119707696,
0.022268381,
0.0275821295,
-0.0071824542,
-0.0489376821,
0.0310222898,
-0.0235284045,
-0.0276135188,
-0.0027349351,
0.0358014703,
0.005978365,
0.0039321003,
-0.0365300551,
-0.0495995209,
0.012351729,
0.0480276719,
0.0004826688,
0.0041388627,
0.0250431634,
0.0056642862,
0.0100153396,
0.0138641661,
0.056709975,
-0.0132280793,
0.0597295575,
-0.0243983231,
0.0835437104,
0.0351978205,
-0.0383832455,
-0.0073326575,
0.0097902743,
-0.0489924587,
-0.1025175154,
0.0099189859,
0.0174928717,
-0.0337080359,
-0.020044392,
-0.0379695594,
-0.0337735973,
0.0023611011,
0.0039932872,
0.0323206186,
0.0267753731,
0.0050591743,
-0.0192793179,
-0.000694165,
-0.0218932647,
-0.0170847233,
-0.0033761496,
-0.0888531506,
0.015205848,
-0.0149704833,
-0.0001844717,
-0.0512439609,
-0.0403680205,
-0.0327671878,
-0.0399428755,
0.0498615466,
0.0359046422,
-0.0695101544,
-0.0092372056,
-0.023591537,
0.0354237705,
0.0320871323,
-0.0334006026,
-0.0265895296,
0.0726262107,
0.0155578814,
-0.0231401045,
-0.0169938263,
0.0840584412,
0.0094016045,
0.0717491582,
-0.0205761213,
-6.284157535e-33,
-0.028229,
-0.0017418886,
0.0155547904,
-0.0268808901,
-0.0743307993,
-0.0175602455,
0.0150952488,
0.0161940921,
-0.0348759815,
0.0362053476,
-0.0073257186,
-0.0238086451,
0.0110416561,
-0.0493519865,
0.0497450605,
-0.0453480929,
0.0112917172,
-0.0136962188,
0.0041060266,
-0.0372826755,
-0.0104510235,
-0.0400696732,
0.0448386483,
-0.0352311693,
0.0724744573,
-0.0209112577,
-0.039806053,
-0.0208856221,
-0.0316643752,
-0.0387869328,
-0.0126717621,
0.009209414,
0.0200156663,
-0.0122905103,
0.0068592452,
0.0822858959,
0.0272615645,
-0.0155866612,
0.0582251884,
-0.0119804833,
-0.0087355999,
-0.0257513411,
-0.0633848906,
-0.0313237309,
-0.0425865352,
0.0068983249,
0.0306501426,
0.021823924,
0.0167245567,
0.0030133396,
-0.0492936708,
-0.0365788639,
-0.0141555751,
-0.0320696123,
-0.0249136649,
0.0144486288,
-0.030000722,
-0.0413017012,
-0.0664042309,
0.0231749378,
-0.0512997657,
-0.0141246328,
0.0044227145,
-0.0240687355,
0.0386089422,
0.0349991731,
0.0587226897,
0.0603420474,
-0.0513290055,
0.0278728772,
0.006554585,
0.0581210479,
0.0281991977,
0.0340863504,
-0.0314561613,
-0.0029695507,
0.0143553661,
-0.0564610027,
0.0446831733,
0.0286863539,
0.031801261,
0.009367873,
-0.0356785096,
-0.0078465883,
-0.0007758861,
-0.1030556858,
-0.0309257265,
0.0124302506,
-0.0405172408,
0.0031114237,
0.0195860527,
-0.0486585274,
0.0044556307,
-0.0178558528,
0.0321736932,
-0.0392834581,
0.0032433253,
0.0037687842,
-0.0153002311,
-0.0234514251,
0.0097282967,
0.0148120131,
-0.0096721081,
0.0556844324,
0.0200868156,
0.0251250546,
-0.0382857472,
-0.0122297443,
0.0175599102,
-0.0389107093,
-0.0110848714,
-0.0044884658,
-0.0030672736,
-0.0902882591,
0.0713340491,
0.0328208581,
-0.0080903275,
-0.0318630673,
-0.0026669195,
0.0130014187,
-0.0298349112,
0.0223288089,
-0.0176833961,
0.0278184004,
0.0087646274,
0.0291045811,
-0.0271192752,
0.0182163417,
0.0545813888,
-0.0451267138,
-0.006590751,
-0.0386191644,
3.152e-7,
-0.0578103065,
-0.0150768356,
-0.0018093165,
-0.0343799554,
-0.004531282,
0.0750047043,
0.0144253941,
0.0015653439,
0.056753926,
-0.0758504272,
0.0152906906,
-0.0172482803,
0.0236925855,
-0.0135073671,
0.0023294629,
0.0374442674,
-0.0094336169,
-0.0471146815,
0.0338784233,
0.0799761266,
0.0507404618,
-0.0223659165,
0.0303036217,
0.0095920675,
-0.01387267,
0.0257808417,
0.0198422447,
-0.0168639161,
-0.0049100691,
-0.0045169662,
0.0659161955,
0.0022073453,
-0.0030531231,
0.0216303412,
0.0552731343,
-0.0296303369,
0.0021254611,
0.0149739245,
0.0063554905,
0.0196228269,
-0.0201218463,
-0.0467803106,
-0.0086667072,
0.0128641743,
0.0454062968,
-0.121898137,
-0.0135886399,
-0.021093592,
-0.0042347913,
0.0140905716,
0.0216659456,
0.0185015667,
-0.0198839642,
0.0265254062,
0.0326758735,
-0.0045888498,
0.0207711626,
-0.0394154005,
0.0198507328,
0.0055322843,
-0.0379913785,
-0.0245327987,
0.0217356738,
0.0186234899,
0.0391456187,
-0.0555626601,
-0.0329848491,
2.260821856e-34,
0.0049928837,
0.0209494643,
0.0377282836,
-0.0219915099,
0.0521515161,
0.03806483,
0.0415457673,
0.0158636924,
0.0244158618,
-0.0301700514,
-0.0182290655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03370v1 | Detection of tortured phrases in scientific literature | 2024-02-02T08:15:43 | 2024-02-02T08:15:43 | Eléna Martel, Martin Lentschat, Cyril Labbé | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DL | This paper presents various automatic detection methods to extract so called
tortured phrases from scientific papers. These tortured phrases, e.g. flag to
clamor instead of signal to noise, are the results of paraphrasing tools used
to escape plagiarism detection. We built a dataset and evaluated several
strategies to flag previously undocumented tortured phrases. The proposed and
tested methods are based on language models and either on embeddings
similarities or on predictions of masked token. We found that an approach using
token prediction and that propagates the scores to the chunk level gives the
best results. With a recall value of .87 and a precision value of .61, it could
retrieve new tortured phrases to be submitted to domain experts for validation. | [
0.0885094777,
0.0329068154,
-0.0160903353,
0.0398413241,
-0.0887779519,
-0.0066342116,
0.0007789563,
0.0278030392,
-0.0041137054,
-0.0665043518,
-0.0089662997,
0.0579926446,
-0.0082713263,
0.0324087292,
0.0173690766,
-0.0327422358,
0.0476996601,
0.0122708939,
0.0433599465,
0.0135516832,
0.0051153838,
0.0008928154,
0.0374795087,
0.0386474058,
0.0286707561,
-0.0247902516,
0.0476791672,
0.0074673072,
0.026533708,
-0.0395211764,
0.0194576494,
0.009707625,
-0.0179323908,
0.079904981,
0.0000015757,
-0.0571742393,
-0.0477512218,
0.0281034559,
0.0213711727,
0.0498148315,
0.0954557881,
-0.0208187401,
0.0204163231,
-0.0054204017,
-0.0174683966,
-0.0002936002,
0.0099401614,
0.0615482293,
0.0652549788,
0.052115459,
-0.0242627095,
0.0119789587,
0.0294069406,
0.0369623937,
-0.0195326023,
0.0191745609,
0.0777978823,
-0.0340964124,
0.0424096175,
0.0615891889,
0.0241001286,
0.0562365241,
-0.0325807855,
-0.0223718435,
-0.0421787463,
-0.0180285051,
-0.0742744356,
0.0146531276,
0.0237500295,
0.0217530206,
-0.0663923547,
-0.0689819232,
0.0510770679,
-0.0061588371,
0.0111678168,
0.0318639912,
-0.0362017304,
-0.0081036184,
-0.0036514089,
-0.0008936925,
0.0219342913,
0.0084202746,
0.0035003589,
0.0118091004,
0.0181148406,
0.0237827022,
0.0311503541,
-0.0754980594,
-0.023055438,
-0.0623930767,
-0.0234870967,
-0.0148403216,
0.0498539321,
0.0090084868,
0.0550120734,
0.0162241366,
-0.0636932179,
-0.1066947728,
0.0589148737,
-0.0292156618,
-0.0028631468,
-0.0027229579,
-0.0100073898,
0.0356029384,
-0.0614575483,
0.0011572697,
-0.0321772881,
0.0468068458,
-0.0110689877,
0.0131157301,
-0.027150616,
-0.0515772961,
-0.0308567043,
0.0348793454,
0.0117557347,
-0.0182107072,
-0.0192936435,
-0.0220888294,
0.0082967915,
0.032286372,
-0.0696375221,
0.0163787138,
-0.0134627018,
0.0170004442,
0.0255295988,
-0.0298801009,
0.0170968212,
0.0143173337,
-0.0188284293,
-0.0262048934,
-0.0420693941,
0.0424135737,
0.0131811975,
-0.0189717729,
0.0299166422,
0.0026326654,
0.0366942361,
-0.004347411,
0.0158453975,
-0.0545911081,
-0.0083274012,
0.0077421134,
0.018406827,
-0.0230875574,
0.0207941905,
-0.0217559915,
-0.0107166171,
-0.050573267,
-0.0051960987,
0.0456030667,
-0.0962279737,
0.0368772745,
-0.026331339,
-0.0555372201,
0.0144525366,
0.0126086595,
-0.0481114686,
-0.0196731426,
0.0426730886,
0.0413124114,
0.0629676804,
-0.0091892658,
0.0215243567,
-0.0046421816,
0.0225196965,
-0.0039091622,
0.0264285356,
0.0085173184,
0.0103853289,
0.0228355285,
-0.013496994,
0.0627620593,
-0.0145648941,
-0.0475561284,
0.0109911598,
0.0884537026,
-0.0334383212,
0.0313020982,
0.0228080992,
0.0255508795,
0.0451832041,
0.0376752205,
-0.021659987,
-0.0416543558,
-0.0193722565,
0.0199819636,
0.0043977182,
0.0294965692,
0.0492750034,
-0.0229599867,
-0.0282596163,
0.0182679668,
-0.0324185975,
-0.0379156433,
0.0180955641,
0.0172847491,
-0.0383328237,
0.0002322204,
0.0227594636,
-0.0145628927,
0.0064178109,
-0.0234387927,
0.0010130104,
0.0107981693,
0.09556631,
-0.0717011616,
0.0228510145,
-0.0393197201,
-0.0219575129,
0.0178217813,
-0.0364605263,
0.003613567,
-0.0248722974,
-0.0271592233,
-0.0250660107,
-0.0214751922,
0.001027854,
-0.0098502068,
-0.0184500404,
-0.0026068192,
0.0173189398,
-0.0133981518,
-0.0663517416,
0.0704744831,
-0.0008973817,
-0.0238044597,
-0.0030104583,
-0.0257842336,
0.0561089963,
-0.0025754161,
-0.0151243629,
0.0754070505,
0.042249795,
-0.073496595,
-0.034293171,
0.019664377,
0.0030536053,
0.0060690446,
0.034018442,
-0.0649074167,
0.0183778182,
0.0140549568,
-0.0130585078,
0.0029022591,
0.0363823809,
-0.0297832768,
0.0096576381,
-0.0211058687,
0.0142695475,
-0.0446747057,
0.0447532348,
-0.0324237235,
0.0198911596,
0.0146989711,
0.0698346645,
0.0206685457,
-0.0489987768,
0.0317335017,
0.0151874786,
-0.0483237915,
-0.020675946,
0.0032517745,
-0.0295858141,
0.0143267931,
-0.0264697243,
-0.0256513488,
-0.049716197,
-0.0257092882,
0.0111768451,
0.0156621505,
0.016398821,
0.0321522839,
-0.0437527113,
-0.0255622454,
-0.0010010202,
0.0246524028,
-0.0557049476,
0.0049708323,
-0.0005286226,
0.0296910722,
0.0143955657,
-0.0198149905,
-0.0356398895,
0.0152134597,
-0.0623899922,
0.0613211207,
0.0134063885,
-0.0315449126,
-0.0612563156,
0.0322054923,
0.0240484588,
-0.0157914292,
-0.0131062539,
-0.0131101906,
-0.0081963176,
-0.0030989104,
0.0313993357,
0.0856905207,
0.0140671348,
0.0034231397,
0.050176762,
0.0218262952,
-0.0431352332,
-0.0351331271,
-0.0418109186,
0.0181759223,
0.0038744111,
-0.0172461215,
0.1108534113,
-0.0001505301,
0.0111831119,
-0.018076418,
-0.0028600348,
0.0388478003,
-0.0182163827,
-0.0181907043,
0.0471578613,
-0.0422956645,
-0.0320265107,
0.0076204315,
0.0175105724,
-0.0181307122,
0.0633077547,
-0.0369660743,
-0.0008201539,
-0.0755031109,
-0.0029348456,
-0.0101326965,
0.0061253165,
-0.0181972198,
0.031182345,
0.0852360874,
-0.0174568314,
0.0078221634,
-0.003881675,
0.0068746568,
-0.0291291773,
-0.0386175439,
-0.0174777415,
-0.0020864585,
0.0286383964,
0.0211426262,
-0.0249269754,
-0.0615150593,
0.0206621829,
0.0348103717,
0.0297638495,
-0.007943362,
-0.0539005361,
-0.0109947696,
0.026081128,
0.0205585156,
-0.0294384155,
0.0001813075,
-0.0395844318,
0.0063596601,
0.0714098662,
-0.0590753071,
0.0446753576,
0.0032102307,
-0.0040686578,
0.0701620951,
-0.0011524586,
0.0331572108,
-0.0040085241,
-0.0180175882,
0.0036788823,
-0.0532406978,
0.0202585794,
-0.0199384224,
-0.0327129662,
-0.0485103168,
-0.0051998305,
0.0854178518,
0.0245544631,
-0.0162406936,
-0.0059069362,
-0.0599966086,
0.0211455263,
-0.0017318184,
0.0078403503,
-0.0530734025,
0.0262913685,
0.0089377528,
0.0038206177,
-0.0392571166,
-0.0459664837,
-0.0134293707,
-0.0391453095,
0.0249736924,
0.0085866302,
-0.0082162479,
-0.0389547013,
-0.0595928058,
-0.0026098073,
0.0416267067,
-0.0207193177,
-0.0231533162,
-0.0069401585,
-0.0030205091,
-0.0157826487,
-0.0461169221,
-0.0603947304,
-0.0114511475,
-0.0359609574,
0.0138405645,
0.0284717288,
0.0489190519,
-0.0114079183,
-0.0229512677,
-0.0066501172,
-0.0247934237,
-0.0653361976,
-0.0080436515,
0.0420790687,
0.0042004138,
0.0164863393,
0.0226955768,
0.066426903,
-0.0412277542,
-0.0186725166,
0.040378008,
0.0764181167,
-0.0100392476,
-0.0222270396,
-0.0602950454,
0.0128737101,
-0.0075924345,
0.077967979,
0.0372728296,
0.0005860949,
-0.064079456,
-0.0232855026,
0.0023468488,
-0.0347853042,
-0.0341618359,
0.0012864678,
-0.059034612,
0.0323557444,
-0.1152188927,
0.0064694453,
0.0229291338,
0.0351175256,
0.0499624312,
0.0440471321,
0.0124268709,
-0.0166194029,
-0.0520710535,
0.0033281355,
0.0066248775,
0.012965573,
-0.030261226,
0.0324772783,
0.0377709568,
0.0550632738,
-0.0306073315,
-0.0070120017,
-0.039904993,
-0.0749805495,
0.0081029637,
0.0188369434,
0.0145956744,
-0.0017371036,
-0.0054781577,
-0.0098995492,
0.0242176615,
0.0226527173,
-0.0194879752,
-0.0148013132,
0.0255497545,
-0.0403716937,
-0.0102641676,
0.0063953088,
-0.0105633317,
0.0027404334,
0.0324222147,
-0.0002866276,
-0.0688559711,
-0.003371876,
0.0561368987,
0.0330608189,
0.0257268231,
-0.0311257858,
-0.0238338094,
0.0086968075,
-0.0011969735,
-0.0257539246,
-0.0179725662,
-0.0289440304,
0.0379858762,
0.0218743701,
0.0162504371,
0.0022067779,
0.0325347073,
-0.0560338162,
0.026430618,
0.0331487209,
0.0194342677,
-0.0173647851,
0.0422584526,
0.0297255628,
0.0128516024,
-0.0025892023,
-0.0139665669,
-0.0367367044,
0.0290683284,
-0.013104137,
0.0035008213,
0.0447369069,
-0.0056635826,
-0.0112522468,
0.0667377636,
-0.107614316,
-0.0023044762,
-0.0203432608,
-0.0319578126,
-0.0120062772,
-0.0191811007,
0.0435817055,
-0.02837299,
-0.0367044918,
-0.0020383741,
0.0241298135,
-0.0452673025,
0.0446651131,
0.0142888259,
0.0069492366,
-0.0404687859,
0.0255197529,
0.0431665853,
0.020642858,
0.0402158201,
0.0308955237,
-0.0368297584,
-0.0122516062,
-0.0283170938,
0.0374782048,
0.0355739556,
0.0035307729,
-0.0200180002,
-0.0253316946,
-0.0021454219,
0.0455454811,
0.0069388733,
0.0105122374,
-0.0157118756,
-0.0062837522,
0.0365107693,
-0.0099446448,
-0.0071535008,
-0.0571798198,
0.0802076906,
0.0675203428,
-0.0984279811,
-0.033827506,
-5.336455255e-33,
0.0345174074,
-0.0374124534,
-0.0341206416,
0.049812071,
0.0006825758,
0.0105322227,
-0.0284163114,
-0.0593445711,
0.0073220041,
0.0344923213,
-0.0218245853,
-0.037434265,
-0.0105305221,
-0.0242891721,
-0.0129456725,
0.0199953131,
0.0340999253,
0.0036845785,
-0.0194454566,
-0.0193517748,
0.0629214719,
0.0531483442,
0.0297834277,
-0.0932709798,
0.055086311,
-0.0163487811,
-0.0293484479,
-0.0247862358,
0.0155262854,
0.0352967158,
-0.021230815,
-0.0124319624,
0.0085979225,
0.0000354543,
-0.0282550696,
0.0097831702,
-0.0558337085,
0.0260744262,
0.0429099463,
-0.0193301886,
0.0020772589,
-0.0425352082,
0.0506018624,
-0.0292135067,
-0.008515046,
-0.0020184233,
0.055213999,
-0.0362920985,
-0.0324532762,
-0.0706161484,
-0.0597325005,
-0.0025067593,
-0.0068816706,
0.0282228887,
0.0398778766,
0.0271152724,
0.0007028814,
0.1232107431,
-0.0500808097,
0.0122597618,
-0.0314225927,
0.0481616221,
-0.0211035591,
-0.0575132445,
0.0456178337,
0.0448484942,
-0.0146219898,
-0.0245472696,
0.0520725064,
0.0426212549,
0.0295730364,
0.0395765901,
0.0645304173,
0.0207932685,
0.0796747357,
0.0063954075,
-0.005277209,
0.0164149478,
-0.0009430388,
0.0328390002,
0.0017508925,
-0.0008558319,
-0.0143120466,
0.0034931982,
0.00855406,
-0.0168111753,
-0.0087408982,
-0.0382033139,
0.0288237575,
-0.0160250179,
-0.057259798,
0.0163775422,
-0.0088647027,
-0.0401009396,
-0.0116134994,
-0.0413102023,
0.014035292,
0.0379068702,
0.0045177303,
0.0274477173,
-0.0251641572,
-0.0231754221,
0.0238413103,
-0.0279472154,
0.0598238744,
-0.0429223292,
0.0490524322,
-0.0126009919,
-0.0773304328,
0.0137847941,
0.0319645479,
-0.0167653896,
0.0252994038,
0.0045443117,
-0.0278432928,
0.0312372707,
0.0366175994,
-0.0242894758,
0.0350618251,
0.015834596,
-0.0204572584,
0.0553236268,
-0.017235592,
0.0492374785,
-0.0095366687,
-0.0275251493,
-0.004984681,
0.0398279019,
0.0098092537,
-0.0747864768,
0.0217472203,
-0.0153783085,
2.456e-7,
0.0473421104,
0.064927265,
0.0225338358,
-0.0555497892,
0.0117063466,
0.0466440171,
-0.0068982462,
0.0156516042,
-0.000972814,
-0.0069843559,
-0.0134172942,
-0.0686472058,
0.0163451564,
-0.0084304167,
-0.133892864,
0.0175371543,
-0.0646607578,
-0.0902283862,
-0.0503730737,
-0.0014212742,
0.0511530638,
0.0539111421,
-0.0012096735,
-0.0037551308,
-0.029700812,
-0.0783020183,
0.0165581461,
-0.0167668052,
-0.0338094719,
0.059036281,
0.0472911634,
-0.0194764826,
0.0173274409,
0.0016373566,
-0.032281857,
0.0120197032,
0.0257489476,
0.0303680003,
0.0278127957,
-0.0036604446,
-0.0209650453,
-0.0418967344,
0.0243674554,
-0.0446695872,
0.0240849219,
-0.0019355293,
-0.0083580837,
-0.0814183652,
-0.0192852058,
0.0053876387,
0.0273208097,
-0.0290017202,
-0.030629307,
0.0313724503,
-0.0082607213,
0.0410615057,
0.0182559304,
-0.0721661001,
0.0150215775,
-0.0079682646,
-0.0534525923,
-0.0048101232,
-0.0136672966,
0.0083672665,
0.0341101959,
-0.0534026623,
0.0066852313,
2.702307918e-34,
0.0619677752,
-0.050557211,
0.0263631772,
0.0860632136,
-0.0071195425,
0.0060803266,
0.010203464,
0.0393474028,
-0.020598786,
-0.0300861932,
0.0199158639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01801v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01801v3 | Large Language Models for Time Series: A Survey | 2024-02-02T07:24:35 | 2024-05-06T20:48:41 | Xiyuan Zhang, Ranak Roy Chowdhury, Rajesh K. Gupta, Jingbo Shang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have seen significant use in domains such as
natural language processing and computer vision. Going beyond text, image and
graphics, LLMs present a significant potential for analysis of time series
data, benefiting domains such as climate, IoT, healthcare, traffic, audio and
finance. This survey paper provides an in-depth exploration and a detailed
taxonomy of the various methodologies employed to harness the power of LLMs for
time series analysis. We address the inherent challenge of bridging the gap
between LLMs' original text data training and the numerical nature of time
series data, and explore strategies for transferring and distilling knowledge
from LLMs to numerical time series analysis. We detail various methodologies,
including (1) direct prompting of LLMs, (2) time series quantization, (3)
aligning techniques, (4) utilization of the vision modality as a bridging
mechanism, and (5) the combination of LLMs with tools. Additionally, this
survey offers a comprehensive overview of the existing multimodal time series
and text datasets and delves into the challenges and future opportunities of
this emerging field. We maintain an up-to-date Github repository which includes
all the papers and datasets discussed in the survey. | [
-0.0498676859,
0.1181633323,
-0.0008352504,
0.0312301498,
-0.0393963009,
0.0272926837,
0.0188987311,
0.0070026731,
-0.0105505092,
-0.0277933553,
0.0082306825,
-0.064775832,
0.0491421521,
0.0445346683,
0.0152548552,
-0.0922204703,
0.0303406473,
-0.0554608591,
-0.0046970253,
0.0273726154,
0.0205917023,
-0.0142778782,
0.0093440888,
0.0245575197,
-0.0508148633,
-0.0114342859,
-0.0306704156,
-0.0238670707,
0.0366594121,
-0.0483051054,
-0.0604073666,
0.007602287,
0.0674734488,
0.0554634221,
0.0000020055,
-0.0001340606,
-0.0042825867,
-0.0103472816,
0.0227804575,
0.0157625917,
0.0615300946,
-0.0586927459,
0.018167695,
0.000664441,
-0.0667065233,
-0.0111178057,
0.0805677325,
0.0113541912,
0.0670278594,
0.0661489293,
-0.0177661106,
-0.0128453551,
0.0220921654,
-0.0250073448,
-0.0123022776,
-0.0145644518,
0.0209161863,
-0.0011625825,
0.0096192528,
0.0106479637,
-0.0432653502,
0.0521507561,
-0.0117748007,
-0.0026645819,
-0.0010467098,
0.064977482,
-0.0001316175,
0.0074202935,
-0.0374715552,
0.0497291349,
0.0090040751,
-0.016594369,
0.0247940924,
0.0210818648,
-0.0601849668,
0.0319254957,
-0.0661396235,
-0.0042944113,
0.0382452719,
0.0591130555,
-0.0103050442,
-0.0116015719,
0.0353391357,
0.0288306642,
-0.0349751599,
0.0360977873,
-0.0005877427,
-0.0318528526,
-0.0372790135,
-0.0071786111,
-0.0150644314,
-0.0460228808,
-0.0230017174,
0.0393229313,
0.0214598253,
-0.0011511155,
-0.0311390031,
-0.0338217057,
-0.0397810824,
-0.0307426061,
0.0566929393,
0.0231822785,
-0.010384012,
0.047279194,
0.0112521155,
0.0340873711,
-0.0237439126,
-0.0383094177,
-0.0186398458,
-0.0065342085,
-0.0513942167,
-0.0213552956,
-0.0041018762,
-0.0580618307,
-0.011974493,
-0.0039839544,
-0.060089834,
-0.0000938802,
0.0252537131,
-0.0166067444,
0.0158413928,
-0.0061965934,
-0.0046465583,
-0.0193512123,
-0.0098608322,
0.0442019105,
0.0280046407,
0.0310298558,
-0.0120026479,
-0.044883348,
0.0106398696,
0.0390088297,
0.0182647631,
-0.0052137123,
-0.0217763856,
0.0585693642,
0.0298360754,
0.0021004966,
-0.034858264,
-0.0056377393,
-0.0472885258,
-0.023461422,
-0.0354683176,
-0.0557262003,
0.0095008872,
-0.0182370562,
0.0208703261,
0.0044811391,
0.0062572933,
-0.0034266675,
-0.0149231013,
0.0864998102,
-0.0343716927,
0.017848365,
0.0149751175,
-0.0424248986,
0.0823456869,
0.0613762923,
0.087419264,
-0.0073303566,
0.0235868134,
-0.0397090279,
-0.02289024,
0.0557537526,
-0.0083534326,
0.0000873045,
-0.0755586848,
-0.0217208508,
-0.0063493843,
0.0338015035,
0.0392071642,
0.0438356809,
-0.0068671559,
-0.0206012651,
0.0793547109,
0.0583859161,
0.025322007,
-0.0323026292,
0.0204674564,
-0.0057209907,
0.0013002156,
-0.0320924111,
0.0197777208,
0.036149241,
-0.0097794831,
0.0218233131,
0.0057922155,
0.0406314395,
-0.0183128156,
-0.0316905491,
-0.0239315461,
-0.0277084373,
0.0134442504,
-0.0173994843,
0.0723705664,
-0.0669156089,
0.0028805297,
0.0065492452,
0.0239961874,
-0.015281586,
0.0128938807,
0.0014664965,
0.0062406478,
0.0677471831,
-0.0082444493,
-0.0041717552,
0.041157309,
-0.0206408147,
0.0470597185,
0.020173844,
-0.0092394957,
0.0142833143,
-0.0066049253,
-0.0795209929,
-0.0472042747,
0.0369414054,
-0.0064967801,
-0.0026160418,
-0.040436212,
0.0368182622,
0.0192448255,
-0.0195406284,
-0.0058549475,
0.0135655189,
-0.0127618415,
-0.038088318,
-0.01005287,
0.0059290412,
0.0397279263,
0.0114504555,
-0.0191906374,
0.0091654435,
0.0313198417,
-0.0548232496,
0.0143070128,
0.0574200526,
-0.0248700455,
-0.0093847653,
0.0190237686,
-0.0133464411,
0.0098942807,
0.025425937,
-0.0489486158,
-0.0655716583,
0.0417186692,
-0.036326427,
0.0487263352,
-0.0596775264,
-0.013977929,
0.0097621279,
0.0313205309,
-0.030901853,
0.0464000627,
-0.0208898596,
0.0017647014,
0.0018674396,
0.0087562772,
-0.0062571941,
-0.0322082229,
0.0045021581,
0.0192988515,
0.0293743573,
0.0170646384,
0.0046923431,
-0.0201519318,
0.0012275833,
-0.0001907671,
-0.1245724857,
-0.0478956848,
-0.0186543874,
0.0290128738,
-0.0114507023,
-0.0064702127,
-0.021735996,
-0.0046608346,
-0.0027858783,
0.0221461244,
0.0089821555,
0.0010670655,
0.0549540296,
-0.0189111568,
-0.015600618,
-0.0242314916,
-0.0219851322,
-0.041260615,
0.0750580654,
-0.0022125081,
-0.056822978,
-0.0155605646,
-0.0100324266,
-0.0299749132,
0.0189324617,
-0.0117899459,
-0.0054335846,
0.0215638094,
-0.0351645462,
0.0858949497,
-0.0032139414,
0.0472879261,
0.014343461,
0.0121284537,
-0.074073039,
-0.0307493526,
0.016107358,
-0.0182783715,
0.0334922001,
-0.0505186878,
-0.0137782125,
-0.0030495054,
0.0983909592,
0.006646066,
0.0250472557,
-0.0143653248,
0.0281293355,
-0.0598604083,
0.0033869264,
-0.0687327385,
0.0276080016,
-0.0577658452,
0.0254736263,
-0.011408628,
-0.0939506292,
0.01402706,
-0.0479664914,
0.0040216343,
0.0083037466,
-0.0378217772,
-0.0692162737,
0.0658702031,
0.0090141082,
-0.0042638406,
0.0014595796,
-0.0058433982,
-0.0020222294,
-0.0217117649,
-0.0018237265,
-0.0287441257,
0.0126746008,
-0.0501666516,
0.0541694313,
-0.0032643841,
0.0135128917,
-0.0005708997,
-0.0521041639,
-0.0595281608,
-0.0147465682,
-0.0277550463,
-0.0357764289,
-0.0145605654,
0.0665807053,
-0.0074905162,
-0.0051865652,
0.0132942395,
0.0095721763,
-0.0050223228,
0.0691322088,
0.0741690546,
0.0205726698,
-0.015816167,
-0.0409353711,
0.005765059,
-0.0231281146,
0.0490471609,
0.0510684475,
-0.0922309384,
0.0093250284,
-0.0095277382,
-0.0061627035,
-0.0100765079,
0.0110576767,
0.0208606664,
-0.0490797162,
0.0313482471,
0.0886572599,
0.0060858238,
-0.02156852,
0.0070916158,
0.0364189669,
0.0106292423,
-0.0155243529,
-0.0392572805,
-0.0782950819,
-0.0319460034,
0.0019525356,
-0.0090315118,
0.0016072564,
-0.0389710814,
-0.0171264019,
-0.066226624,
0.0317666158,
0.0360686779,
-0.0257538762,
-0.0104253618,
-0.0729790106,
0.0121461228,
-0.0407918915,
0.0087692142,
-0.0251234919,
-0.0293869488,
0.0252985843,
0.0693634152,
-0.0527491793,
-0.0701224208,
-0.0223200805,
-0.0116332509,
0.0153288459,
0.0371710248,
0.0412896574,
-0.0213522371,
-0.0276417956,
-0.0353838541,
0.0256305058,
0.0326588042,
-0.0157374218,
-0.009933671,
0.0007146249,
-0.03595699,
-0.0251219478,
0.0604068674,
-0.0233501904,
0.0109327435,
0.0165387578,
0.0665828139,
-0.0438882373,
0.0047645033,
-0.029599674,
0.0012336816,
0.0290288236,
0.0346300714,
0.0079983603,
-0.0355969928,
-0.0325673223,
0.0055895704,
-0.0062950891,
-0.0403269529,
-0.0794924796,
-0.0243619084,
-0.0060813106,
-0.0100843823,
-0.0392784886,
-0.0115290694,
0.0190538578,
0.0321440585,
-0.0025976198,
0.0473764762,
0.0616334267,
-0.0220479202,
-0.0597272888,
0.0442474149,
-0.0490608402,
0.0537207983,
-0.0306389704,
0.0061763232,
0.0215762332,
-0.0151347052,
-0.0039203824,
0.0334472805,
-0.1596935689,
-0.0580291376,
0.0200998764,
-0.0087996954,
0.0158220101,
0.0087372651,
0.0499081016,
-0.0162837356,
0.0784962177,
0.0762574822,
0.0027254527,
0.0245247837,
-0.0215723291,
0.0365353376,
0.0082038343,
0.0091310088,
-0.0015798096,
0.0279217754,
-0.021238897,
0.024639586,
-0.0480795726,
-0.0172338244,
-0.0029586367,
-0.0104460493,
0.0781889409,
0.0045488649,
-0.0147805028,
-0.0216010194,
-0.0296473522,
-0.0037166001,
-0.0056735976,
-0.0329229534,
-0.000657627,
0.0173376109,
0.0218301266,
-0.0410198122,
0.0262104329,
0.0362827331,
-0.0205603484,
-0.047903277,
0.0689235553,
-0.0026352154,
0.0025536674,
-0.0008649107,
0.0208681803,
0.0339088589,
0.0348243788,
-0.0312921405,
-0.0071696863,
0.0422863178,
0.0235939082,
-0.0076658931,
0.0189453457,
-0.0169377979,
0.008620793,
-0.0479065254,
-0.0098734228,
-0.0009060827,
0.0183447562,
0.0600730181,
-0.0209429115,
0.029295329,
-0.052095335,
0.0203737821,
-0.0380547009,
0.0569884069,
0.0178836863,
0.0248022769,
0.0560072623,
-0.0064767753,
-0.0643050894,
0.0057993196,
0.0645675436,
0.0140228365,
0.011898159,
0.0294169486,
-0.0217837915,
-0.0270121191,
-0.0081370044,
0.0169517882,
-0.0436529145,
-0.0166240335,
-0.0192028619,
-0.0500097312,
-0.0420969687,
0.0157779772,
-0.0331592858,
-0.0137772551,
-0.0103372848,
0.0102508245,
0.0353136249,
-0.0155490702,
0.0564868301,
-0.0230915528,
0.0161551889,
-0.0284405742,
-0.0625165626,
-0.0441479273,
-5.984452393e-33,
-0.0110998563,
-0.0271699578,
0.0290269237,
-0.0252858587,
-0.0443738066,
0.071584411,
0.0013690012,
0.0062945336,
0.0229997169,
-0.0185971409,
0.0249868706,
-0.0146810291,
0.0186241865,
0.0061034909,
0.0385924876,
0.0199354216,
0.0483876467,
-0.0406361222,
0.0260678064,
-0.007370953,
0.0560516566,
0.0321836397,
0.0562450178,
-0.0506368093,
-0.0017174652,
0.0302789565,
-0.0221054796,
-0.0030023046,
0.0608743019,
0.0427795649,
-0.0426600352,
0.0497233011,
0.0365564264,
0.0118525745,
-0.0526728295,
0.0565134585,
-0.0236108005,
0.0118951881,
0.0181801878,
0.0130789978,
-0.0355517641,
-0.0217511375,
0.0100356275,
-0.0162336808,
-0.0367958881,
0.0195524301,
0.0314206332,
-0.0408434123,
-0.0292724315,
-0.0303660147,
-0.0218066946,
0.0665768459,
-0.0302169882,
-0.0089018876,
0.0459376499,
0.0305001028,
-0.0029609045,
0.0482005104,
-0.0569630638,
0.0637164265,
0.0280278362,
0.0286993459,
0.0630851611,
0.0454421006,
0.0525550656,
0.0594016239,
0.0027291165,
-0.0609612763,
-0.0324159972,
0.0468525589,
0.0457354151,
0.0315492339,
0.0119351596,
0.0451144464,
0.0403018259,
-0.0314577632,
-0.0325319096,
0.0184015092,
0.011656573,
0.0309050344,
0.0295259822,
0.0399042256,
-0.0171169564,
0.0105803162,
-0.0197398774,
0.0109799411,
-0.0160609428,
-0.0037555145,
0.0126275048,
0.0142812785,
0.0214299671,
0.022483753,
0.0616762564,
-0.0345768891,
-0.0363357365,
-0.02020224,
0.0165097695,
0.0206953026,
0.0174783524,
0.0107097579,
-0.0738503933,
-0.0675495043,
0.0275987498,
0.0329269469,
0.0184104871,
-0.0642332435,
-0.016396109,
0.0489166416,
-0.0441081971,
-0.0125349071,
0.0006170383,
-0.0279140417,
-0.0037657632,
0.0209182855,
0.0612434186,
-0.0501518026,
-0.0136436336,
0.050396286,
-0.0206989087,
-0.0044758697,
0.0193683263,
-0.0521216057,
-0.0177794974,
0.0253535677,
-0.0053088092,
0.0043429122,
-0.0202815477,
-0.038685482,
0.0456957184,
-0.0387411863,
-0.0126050385,
0.0309118871,
2.679e-7,
0.0250948332,
0.0647972971,
0.0309305303,
0.0105983997,
0.0371093377,
0.0046341806,
-0.0342761911,
0.0216909591,
-0.0360454321,
0.0147380484,
0.0291085187,
0.006430625,
0.0828524455,
0.0266339891,
-0.0237273294,
-0.0244547464,
-0.0918627009,
-0.010841934,
-0.0880741253,
-0.011071994,
0.0519188605,
0.1085922942,
0.0055678273,
0.0097100558,
0.0407613032,
-0.0501170121,
0.0882289633,
-0.0483672768,
-0.0481887721,
-0.0012628452,
0.0172864702,
-0.0024599552,
-0.0209200978,
-0.0406246148,
0.0086885169,
-0.0028660933,
0.0166146662,
0.0145873446,
-0.0021937646,
-0.0079937382,
-0.0122271888,
0.0196114965,
-0.0373733193,
-0.0430725664,
0.0474489443,
-0.0206800196,
-0.0394224375,
-0.0851844102,
-0.0321475342,
0.0317160264,
0.0374598801,
0.0202009417,
-0.0069600758,
0.0312061366,
0.0213278141,
-0.0223436579,
-0.0235368181,
-0.0369547307,
-0.0311496742,
0.0079502258,
-0.0361643843,
-0.0097333938,
-0.0579122342,
-0.0061558485,
0.047390569,
-0.0309181605,
-0.0211432409,
2.249815143e-34,
0.0386019759,
-0.0241588298,
-0.0335236304,
0.0032358009,
-0.0063902941,
-0.0159905106,
-0.0280487053,
0.0388111472,
-0.010762467,
-0.0999144912,
-0.0100591956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01183v1 | LINGO-Space: Language-Conditioned Incremental Grounding for Space | 2024-02-02T06:58:39 | 2024-02-02T06:58:39 | Dohyun Kim, Nayoung Oh, Deokmin Hwang, Daehyung Park | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | We aim to solve the problem of spatially localizing composite instructions
referring to space: space grounding. Compared to current instance grounding,
space grounding is challenging due to the ill-posedness of identifying
locations referred to by discrete expressions and the compositional ambiguity
of referring expressions. Therefore, we propose a novel probabilistic
space-grounding methodology (LINGO-Space) that accurately identifies a
probabilistic distribution of space being referred to and incrementally updates
it, given subsequent referring expressions leveraging configurable polar
distributions. Our evaluations show that the estimation using polar
distributions enables a robot to ground locations successfully through $20$
table-top manipulation benchmark tests. We also show that updating the
distribution helps the grounding method accurately narrow the referring space.
We finally demonstrate the robustness of the space grounding with simulated
manipulation and real quadruped robot navigation tasks. Code and videos are
available at https://lingo-space.github.io. | [
0.0698803961,
0.0287930109,
0.0131395506,
-0.0569205508,
-0.0053932252,
-0.0036781312,
0.0084030777,
-0.0135976328,
-0.0471198633,
-0.0281323809,
-0.0430581085,
0.0061299629,
0.028369287,
-0.0097719617,
0.0124484263,
-0.0448766761,
0.0500333384,
-0.0269424394,
-0.057824973,
-0.0042999485,
-0.0358988903,
-0.0230433047,
-0.0524595678,
0.0343630575,
-0.042936556,
0.0236033611,
-0.0401796065,
0.0010525393,
0.0196965933,
-0.0568372235,
-0.0065696747,
0.0747037008,
0.0383242182,
0.0547459088,
0.0000019712,
-0.0019982278,
-0.0126342494,
0.0039954274,
0.015216223,
-0.0025323245,
0.0058639324,
-0.0055333944,
0.0068804612,
-0.0050546224,
-0.0076750871,
-0.0252499096,
0.0828058273,
0.0257521588,
0.0329384767,
0.0099738529,
0.0120111192,
-0.007778008,
-0.0412320718,
0.0166624989,
0.0570723712,
-0.0246465281,
0.0084097153,
0.0692182779,
0.0164336469,
0.026805263,
-0.0502383225,
0.0345026478,
0.0289574005,
-0.0340093821,
0.0207243506,
0.0665885136,
-0.0413326919,
0.0106391674,
-0.0426744111,
0.022397738,
-0.0368295535,
-0.0551871844,
-0.0012977208,
0.0080355806,
0.0144752385,
-0.0054294756,
-0.0309608728,
0.0393270105,
-0.025236262,
-0.0215881746,
-0.0681005716,
-0.0253115036,
-0.0111432467,
-0.0176111516,
-0.0487153567,
0.1607434005,
0.0267863646,
0.0074892039,
0.0083355037,
-0.0083261263,
0.0020215586,
-0.0616848581,
0.0485535637,
0.0028105185,
-0.0416441038,
0.0270282924,
-0.0473130308,
0.0337043814,
-0.0148093952,
-0.0870150179,
-0.0032102214,
0.0541293398,
-0.0020693191,
0.0284983553,
-0.0104136486,
0.0374341756,
-0.0323730297,
0.0520767532,
-0.0039003876,
0.0361740477,
-0.0129138837,
0.024969561,
-0.0496823266,
0.0301366057,
-0.0388784371,
-0.0611490905,
0.0201781839,
0.0332306288,
-0.0266576353,
-0.0182476714,
-0.0555955917,
0.0390727706,
-0.0328124277,
0.0205645021,
0.0198475309,
-0.0336388871,
-0.0295128208,
0.0381233878,
-0.0058659292,
-0.0003452665,
-0.0279273484,
0.0440292992,
-0.0213927589,
-0.0224284548,
-0.0067454372,
0.0681444854,
0.0355026945,
-0.0182282049,
0.0046513309,
-0.012875326,
-0.0233168583,
-0.0313479751,
0.0607589036,
-0.0550611019,
-0.0320082009,
0.0072359638,
-0.020387575,
-0.0257443096,
0.0351770632,
0.0296943132,
-0.0045637311,
0.1260709018,
0.0253113341,
0.0095119225,
0.0252152123,
-0.0036538038,
-0.0279222988,
0.0493526682,
0.0236313548,
0.0345388465,
0.0107405158,
0.0141955568,
0.0132743707,
0.009268214,
-0.021975575,
0.0165963955,
-0.0209708475,
-0.0327231251,
0.0207961146,
0.0145458216,
-0.0034575653,
0.0201393515,
-0.012119594,
0.0226209555,
0.0076674172,
0.0409461074,
-0.0712812543,
-0.0321743563,
0.0423859395,
-0.0204610936,
-0.0551092848,
0.015810363,
-0.0858112723,
0.0498279221,
-0.0595945939,
-0.0045027635,
-0.0006675896,
0.0299581401,
-0.0129676983,
-0.0081364298,
-0.0143779973,
0.014994896,
0.0587191731,
-0.031094702,
0.0390937552,
0.0072406931,
-0.0397126675,
0.0808729082,
0.0385661051,
-0.0492537878,
-0.0264203791,
0.0089245746,
-0.0358120203,
-0.0076572178,
0.0006401959,
-0.0293976795,
-0.0630866364,
0.0020233386,
0.0429791287,
0.0378475115,
-0.0263060536,
0.0244738627,
0.0216870327,
0.0195795633,
-0.0507496819,
0.0377741419,
0.0076472964,
0.0667393506,
0.0685558543,
0.0230057277,
-0.003748043,
-0.0795395821,
0.0411736444,
0.0666450337,
0.0815568641,
0.0033552283,
0.0083958032,
0.0182424784,
0.0108129345,
0.02047286,
-0.0223316662,
0.0019606277,
0.0381086059,
0.0221479125,
0.0062686056,
0.0162028018,
-0.0155358715,
0.0163594168,
0.0521480106,
-0.0668806881,
-0.0203077346,
-0.019794818,
-0.003747727,
-0.0069160853,
0.0239749271,
-0.0099473661,
0.022603564,
0.0439841188,
0.0235784668,
-0.0093369465,
-0.0005679568,
0.005267276,
0.0028754501,
-0.0452260226,
0.0334243476,
0.0117416615,
0.0754486099,
0.0471560098,
-0.0274623074,
-0.0072293966,
-0.0281474963,
0.0121042011,
-0.0327517278,
0.0572165549,
0.0501397438,
-0.012113072,
-0.0483913496,
-0.0362139829,
-0.0368745402,
-0.010970992,
-0.0211440064,
0.0324779972,
-0.0350230187,
-0.019066494,
-0.022495836,
0.0654509366,
-0.0154215824,
-0.0255585574,
0.0003570253,
0.0074834386,
-0.0005841339,
-0.0688267201,
-0.0247354601,
-0.00307708,
-0.0196055993,
-0.0330949165,
0.0381386429,
-0.0501201786,
-0.0763667002,
0.0196353011,
-0.0197145138,
0.0442140214,
0.0095105683,
-0.0271258652,
0.0323971994,
-0.0268748775,
0.0124593461,
0.0836258605,
-0.0554147996,
-0.0165463071,
0.0914396197,
-0.0148625169,
-0.0054496094,
-0.0103119528,
-0.0181288682,
-0.0259920154,
0.0126469051,
-0.0031277242,
-0.0035997191,
-0.0046778088,
-0.0266066398,
-0.0115946382,
-0.0469175875,
-0.0053291381,
-0.0502209589,
-0.0476684533,
-0.0154505717,
0.0176202357,
-0.0475730635,
0.0203681383,
-0.0347983874,
-0.0466813482,
0.0197515152,
-0.0287091844,
0.0083114095,
0.0082832202,
-0.012046054,
0.0376339294,
0.0481943376,
0.0049529881,
-0.0087501053,
-0.0013405296,
-0.0539866947,
0.0055132257,
0.0010483363,
-0.0283146929,
0.0337289572,
0.0318864286,
-0.0882643387,
0.0412202887,
0.0240180641,
-0.0246235691,
-0.0446481816,
0.0378638208,
0.0058666067,
0.01782001,
-0.0256829783,
-0.0872431621,
-0.0219333675,
0.0181754176,
0.0569490604,
0.046458941,
-0.0363434218,
-0.0027555802,
-0.0328113474,
-0.0492272452,
0.002464145,
0.0297074318,
-0.0434396043,
0.0239091963,
-0.1043470725,
0.0177485514,
0.0579346605,
-0.0260895137,
-0.0089247702,
0.0057165669,
0.0103775468,
0.0241480619,
0.0050249971,
0.0337320715,
0.0420443639,
0.0032320176,
-0.0776164606,
0.0714774132,
0.0415917747,
-0.0057163863,
0.0079870857,
-0.0128099043,
-0.0175539162,
0.0462179743,
-0.0016125422,
-0.0285413619,
-0.0099541312,
0.0217270404,
-0.0253803972,
0.0537412353,
0.0045782877,
0.0028630593,
-0.0981872901,
0.0098987939,
0.006714303,
-0.1089919582,
-0.167891115,
-0.0004600307,
0.0073155886,
0.0060195108,
-0.0366948582,
0.041543588,
0.0135748284,
0.0301959403,
0.0148355253,
-0.0201806072,
-0.0045114211,
-0.0178301688,
-0.0304702297,
-0.0130340587,
0.027466828,
0.0055155144,
-0.0348533876,
-0.0421133004,
-0.0161465984,
0.0251068547,
-0.0051007597,
-0.035263449,
-0.0209275838,
0.0323165506,
0.0152238533,
0.0515945256,
0.0204295013,
-0.0242945161,
-0.0216940939,
-0.0150195779,
0.023497723,
-0.0459212922,
0.0585878789,
-0.0161995385,
0.0288346037,
0.053300146,
0.0311305132,
0.026027903,
-0.0111376652,
-0.0574095361,
-0.0441546366,
0.0357678831,
-0.0003357658,
0.0088156853,
-0.0201967675,
-0.0313734561,
-0.0566139556,
-0.0593791604,
0.0107148737,
0.0581712946,
0.0732526705,
0.0251268279,
-0.0287042875,
-0.0168929026,
0.0195496026,
-0.0421344489,
-0.0069435402,
0.0088767437,
0.0171614811,
-0.0175509509,
0.0042378008,
0.0046286858,
-0.0066994266,
-0.0294691753,
0.0530062467,
0.0211263616,
-0.0495215841,
0.0645142272,
0.0671064258,
0.0233747605,
-0.0030561371,
-0.0080942893,
0.0411673859,
-0.0068144281,
0.0215369966,
-0.007508032,
0.0922817364,
0.0404663347,
0.0508672297,
0.0330087133,
0.0176665653,
-0.0626006648,
-0.0150463944,
-0.0107561126,
0.0256344322,
-0.0698574558,
-0.0168163292,
-0.0048032026,
-0.0403078683,
0.0746214613,
-0.0206793882,
0.0235468168,
-0.0230082273,
-0.0022675681,
-0.0311421845,
-0.009660163,
-0.0351592042,
0.0432653204,
-0.0227741674,
0.0101453541,
0.0433849059,
0.0070672338,
-0.0035710395,
0.039652843,
0.0603445396,
-0.0408922732,
0.0425259955,
-0.0146381836,
0.0137785543,
0.0052989074,
0.006460147,
-0.014859071,
0.0125544742,
0.0449647941,
-0.0134959519,
0.0105907666,
0.050176546,
-0.041257035,
-0.0497419201,
-0.0006645563,
-0.055555623,
-0.0517466851,
0.0228579696,
0.0386529528,
0.0868171602,
0.0225582495,
0.0058861477,
-0.0729752406,
-0.0248404834,
0.0103315292,
-0.0027071959,
0.0620145239,
0.0005346672,
0.005934461,
0.0172672328,
0.0006287643,
0.0044665826,
0.0120090041,
-0.020002855,
0.0597283505,
-0.0132341776,
-0.0116817383,
-0.0335280001,
-0.018321665,
-0.0210685767,
0.0522761457,
0.0021049764,
0.0389321037,
-0.0418026969,
-0.0435371436,
-0.0427528881,
0.0335527472,
-0.0307973512,
-0.0244645383,
0.0733216852,
0.0169238392,
-0.0008746344,
-0.0432431772,
-0.0043693525,
-0.0252438225,
0.0359497033,
-0.0035419366,
-0.0744493082,
-5.721940627e-33,
-0.0634809807,
-0.0845481008,
-0.0069893482,
-0.0057044718,
-0.0247481912,
-0.0013046574,
-0.0027483567,
0.0407377072,
-0.017393833,
0.0227895137,
0.0102127828,
0.0109293638,
0.020604426,
-0.0125237331,
0.0264721103,
0.0457333513,
0.0145284003,
0.0228904355,
-0.0432091504,
-0.0165762194,
0.0658843443,
0.0317521207,
0.0399748795,
-0.086568132,
0.0012008686,
0.0392956957,
-0.015160881,
0.0043166676,
-0.0332452841,
-0.0024245272,
-0.0101065375,
-0.0150160855,
-0.0502161384,
-0.0173151083,
-0.0173387304,
-0.0025524257,
-0.0754531696,
-0.0651987791,
-0.0132100238,
0.0431455374,
0.0121600749,
0.0033359379,
0.0501878969,
-0.0072794766,
-0.0439553894,
0.016215127,
0.0119481422,
-0.0100618294,
-0.0143644717,
0.0361045301,
-0.0332821161,
0.0079169553,
0.0327572189,
-0.0556223728,
-0.0106122326,
-0.0430172309,
0.030734539,
-0.037936043,
-0.0388898365,
0.0185660813,
0.0154266246,
0.0271216836,
0.0303895269,
0.0150977001,
0.0729400143,
0.0810236558,
0.0241453238,
-0.0558278188,
0.0313356519,
-0.0531292893,
0.0103723966,
-0.0283198878,
-0.0128704524,
-0.0350035764,
0.0420946889,
0.0028333301,
-0.0317435786,
-0.0182594564,
-0.0017620658,
0.0657770634,
0.0010895141,
0.0106161349,
-0.0533441007,
0.0037669765,
0.0165638868,
-0.0339667015,
0.0482122116,
-0.0471976399,
0.0203833524,
0.018311074,
-0.0071881628,
-0.0032072235,
0.0225305147,
0.0170345176,
-0.0187767968,
0.0253416486,
0.0188237969,
0.0342099369,
-0.0047021993,
-0.0181729123,
-0.0045539453,
-0.0326863863,
-0.0008300254,
-0.0091759562,
0.0068442784,
0.0093449596,
-0.0519912057,
0.0542426296,
-0.0534039885,
0.0058941431,
-0.0008163319,
-0.0448648445,
0.0198746361,
0.0170103386,
0.0785518438,
0.0086557139,
0.008084802,
0.0674866065,
0.0298538394,
-0.0259067267,
0.0175175797,
-0.0369368121,
-0.0465128906,
0.0388034843,
-0.0659032613,
-0.01754006,
-0.0402304418,
0.0094596539,
0.0067625935,
-0.05485861,
-0.0390444137,
0.0140619734,
2.767e-7,
0.0497186594,
0.0280352049,
0.0493421517,
0.0010803692,
-0.0306267869,
0.0032313308,
0.0141278803,
0.0013105943,
-0.0240866281,
-0.0400208794,
-0.0327571817,
0.0138188992,
-0.0547348596,
-0.0244670901,
-0.0669240654,
0.0330957137,
-0.0035026937,
-0.0164140277,
-0.0199750196,
0.0001393224,
0.022515364,
0.0651883036,
0.025410844,
0.0134321311,
0.005572815,
-0.0541022494,
-0.0280772708,
-0.0078908131,
0.0716951415,
-0.0090553388,
-0.0229688138,
0.0159128141,
-0.046697706,
-0.001805942,
-0.026126314,
0.0001563055,
0.0071895281,
0.0293386485,
-0.0523774996,
0.0015387184,
-0.0063053006,
0.0044371248,
-0.0115391696,
-0.0245140567,
0.0489649735,
-0.0515158698,
0.037097428,
0.0083497167,
0.0353201441,
0.0141213806,
-0.0200893786,
0.0302446727,
-0.0042826147,
-0.057286527,
-0.0212046467,
0.053091608,
-0.0098344367,
-0.0629244894,
-0.0042367526,
0.0441578478,
-0.0181974787,
-0.0338090844,
0.0534771569,
-0.039418757,
-0.0157303009,
0.0237675998,
-0.0546086058,
2.524428531e-34,
0.0172721334,
-0.0231958125,
0.0075501031,
0.0384515934,
0.01483142,
0.024390921,
-0.0364220329,
0.0089448234,
0.0438092798,
0.0176333431,
-0.0330987349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01182v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01182v1 | In-Context Learning for Few-Shot Nested Named Entity Recognition | 2024-02-02T06:57:53 | 2024-02-02T06:57:53 | Meishan Zhang, Bin Wang, Hao Fei, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In nested Named entity recognition (NER), entities are nested with each
other, and thus requiring more data annotations to address. This leads to the
development of few-shot nested NER, where the prevalence of pretrained language
models with in-context learning (ICL) offers promising solutions. In this work,
we introduce an effective and innovative ICL framework for the setting of
few-shot nested NER. We improve the ICL prompt by devising a novel example
demonstration selection mechanism, EnDe retriever. In EnDe retriever, we employ
contrastive learning to perform three types of representation learning, in
terms of semantic similarity, boundary similarity, and label similarity, to
generate high-quality demonstration examples. Extensive experiments over three
nested NER and four flat NER datasets demonstrate the efficacy of our system. | [
-0.0190640986,
0.0303453859,
0.0104272962,
0.0518747382,
-0.0288334228,
0.064153038,
0.0602674671,
0.0116277793,
0.0228712708,
-0.0765184015,
-0.052636113,
-0.0200808663,
-0.0175625607,
-0.0157706738,
0.0332001597,
-0.0547071919,
0.015959885,
-0.0206658933,
0.017773604,
0.0195399765,
-0.0094149597,
0.0082698166,
-0.0227721687,
0.0107712131,
0.0028940956,
-0.0331018865,
-0.0074813752,
0.0217304491,
0.043554537,
-0.1012383476,
0.0436155647,
0.0416628756,
0.0347269811,
0.0266357604,
0.0000019527,
-0.0504270345,
-0.0338839442,
0.0401220433,
-0.0383317135,
-0.0213729106,
0.0646977872,
-0.017835103,
0.0108116101,
-0.012865914,
-0.0055758883,
-0.0731885061,
0.0171436109,
0.0626278818,
0.0026896698,
0.0628615245,
-0.0180695206,
-0.0608303137,
0.0149440961,
0.0005116772,
-0.0140275881,
-0.0148016475,
0.0227223281,
-0.0195031706,
0.0271967705,
0.0142260073,
-0.0043297536,
0.0002867775,
0.0133949211,
0.0357302427,
-0.0198019855,
0.05162929,
-0.0399941839,
0.0162243955,
-0.0105901947,
0.089334704,
-0.0339188464,
-0.0144181876,
0.0113308365,
-0.0549682826,
-0.0321010798,
-0.0556975007,
-0.0310893245,
-0.0147652896,
-0.0297249611,
0.0315505564,
0.0399361178,
0.0476363488,
0.0000699819,
-0.0224469453,
-0.0112328995,
-0.0236055069,
0.0216484591,
-0.0351426005,
-0.0035069028,
0.0285255909,
0.0056261783,
-0.0401157327,
-0.0003789759,
-0.0105998321,
-0.0147773987,
0.0351439491,
-0.058204677,
-0.0588853359,
0.0064003463,
0.0086417049,
0.0434334502,
0.0209206957,
-0.0294469949,
0.0659687221,
-0.0562404171,
-0.0106159346,
-0.0163471475,
0.0190754309,
0.0170354601,
-0.0028173069,
-0.0554076545,
0.0302222297,
-0.0476623513,
0.0390079804,
-0.017481124,
-0.0149218375,
0.0055451752,
0.0086045237,
-0.0278195795,
0.0233955588,
-0.0241997316,
-0.0178574976,
-0.0213478934,
-0.0193341505,
0.0026886924,
0.0079196775,
-0.0390762128,
-0.0009798405,
-0.0006204863,
-0.0538354218,
-0.0216792412,
-0.0120705841,
0.0477612317,
-0.0536489934,
0.0176575519,
0.0661727488,
0.0341080539,
-0.1172795072,
-0.0733184144,
0.0208048932,
0.0038544694,
-0.0346247219,
0.0050532115,
-0.0419799201,
0.0479218103,
0.0045330576,
0.0015020882,
-0.0558990575,
0.00485761,
0.0144389244,
-0.0303724818,
0.0905830041,
-0.0542794466,
-0.0549876727,
-0.0219243243,
-0.0082416469,
0.0177644081,
0.0822683871,
0.020021623,
-0.025136143,
0.0271498896,
0.0351553336,
-0.011812414,
0.0185141917,
0.0537986904,
0.0095023653,
-0.0265004579,
0.0333950594,
-0.012045919,
0.0195157528,
0.0334794223,
0.0165136382,
-0.010730288,
0.0145798754,
0.0299080331,
0.0454164408,
0.0145389205,
-0.0193481706,
0.0413299017,
0.0094804727,
-0.0158316344,
0.0188224204,
-0.0203530565,
0.0316598192,
-0.0311784763,
0.0238006301,
0.0405437164,
0.0519991741,
-0.031677749,
0.0142182857,
0.011168154,
-0.0036196471,
-0.0319022834,
0.0065067057,
0.0538653992,
0.0474670194,
-0.0838645399,
0.0379079692,
0.0619858429,
-0.0008872746,
-0.0021173444,
-0.0031588813,
0.0167765301,
0.0355733335,
0.0394693464,
-0.0397043116,
-0.0342855342,
-0.0326192677,
-0.003277407,
0.0469676591,
0.0224964302,
-0.0169295892,
0.0369672552,
-0.0279613528,
-0.0307897776,
-0.0308639687,
0.018509021,
0.0050053862,
0.0070714033,
0.0314138606,
0.0092813224,
-0.0408375524,
-0.0076811244,
0.0382515304,
-0.0173501335,
-0.0279064216,
0.0260552149,
0.0408028476,
0.0208792482,
0.0360649154,
-0.0200186633,
-0.020250015,
0.0169199985,
-0.0272385832,
0.0260288361,
-0.0270854533,
-0.0310325176,
-0.1312832385,
-0.0244985297,
-0.0129417898,
-0.0314873531,
-0.0312680565,
-0.0412719548,
-0.0207623281,
-0.0622066483,
0.0296270382,
0.0781870633,
-0.03165273,
0.0108481878,
0.0211071782,
0.0045924149,
-0.0269823875,
0.0971427709,
0.0029820497,
0.0184115954,
0.022925077,
-0.0039430973,
-0.0183863621,
-0.0177580696,
-0.0195326544,
-0.0197314769,
0.0047849379,
-0.0332942642,
-0.0187726542,
0.0355673879,
-0.0779494494,
0.0120869577,
-0.0565971136,
0.0042794715,
-0.0305750482,
0.0339973718,
-0.0038930005,
0.0178658925,
-0.0252666548,
-0.0395177938,
-0.0157798231,
-0.0124883978,
-0.0492355637,
0.0183283705,
0.0395165086,
0.0124212988,
-0.0090974811,
-0.0061334218,
0.0149291521,
-0.0338429026,
0.0604994036,
-0.0135504259,
-0.0167615227,
-0.0508295931,
0.0566049069,
0.0163024887,
0.0034457431,
0.0251119565,
0.0618445911,
0.0019021707,
0.0384952873,
0.0087256785,
0.0572381094,
-0.0118013946,
0.0505155921,
-0.0234747082,
-0.0132117085,
-0.0725468397,
0.0264074337,
-0.009969241,
0.0481891111,
0.0131953359,
0.0256679803,
0.0244943779,
0.0461077578,
-0.0167730842,
0.0240713432,
-0.0294171628,
0.0510076731,
-0.000883307,
-0.0075186165,
-0.0182468444,
0.0231095627,
0.0007043044,
0.0157563165,
-0.0192879736,
-0.0113899531,
0.0819803551,
-0.0424732156,
-0.0222015083,
-0.023223374,
0.0198360328,
-0.0448282771,
0.0411481112,
-0.0105170598,
-0.0032474198,
0.0405083448,
-0.057606332,
0.0015955557,
0.0315063708,
-0.0212312341,
-0.0067420639,
0.0214263815,
0.0111596864,
0.0169263352,
-0.014517149,
-0.0473356284,
-0.0252048932,
-0.0248162467,
-0.0445371121,
0.0259053893,
-0.0392427854,
0.0338638276,
-0.0009931944,
0.0252164174,
0.0059069009,
0.0580530316,
0.0128297349,
-0.0195073374,
-0.0300653242,
0.0575210378,
0.0353997238,
-0.0180131644,
0.0209078602,
-0.0119902184,
0.0315159932,
0.0098460056,
0.0243215375,
0.0122630866,
-0.0046201623,
0.0077513354,
0.0062974724,
-0.0456799939,
0.0025130424,
-0.0013752427,
0.0425227731,
-0.0453344509,
-0.0150666619,
0.0846270472,
0.0012814691,
-0.0426849723,
-0.0076039787,
0.0178622957,
0.0131291021,
0.0223162901,
0.0231469218,
-0.1040340886,
-0.0403872803,
0.0057142577,
0.00093019,
0.033170972,
-0.0601780899,
0.0010796485,
-0.1487845778,
0.0417354852,
-0.0017925359,
-0.0709454045,
-0.005908051,
-0.0384769291,
0.0333741568,
-0.0004406334,
0.0285306461,
-0.0138214417,
-0.0414133891,
-0.003609444,
-0.0034310934,
0.034794271,
-0.0840424001,
0.0487610884,
-0.0637955815,
0.0330236815,
0.0121623967,
0.007913989,
0.017129682,
-0.0034643747,
-0.0246592872,
-0.0522286966,
-0.0144685032,
-0.024689218,
0.0302567333,
-0.0578915402,
-0.0300410595,
-0.0151261436,
0.0135669131,
-0.0220667683,
-0.032671012,
-0.0013358019,
0.0580774248,
0.0107950494,
0.0052229972,
-0.0243558828,
-0.0381088443,
0.0746401921,
0.0821264833,
0.0484861583,
-0.0323078893,
-0.0118841501,
0.0304863099,
0.0004192067,
-0.0312659964,
0.0102402596,
0.0210563168,
-0.0358699597,
0.0127304699,
-0.0361061841,
-0.0554357953,
0.0712749735,
0.062614046,
-0.0161965229,
-0.0014085027,
-0.0074177543,
-0.0030328957,
-0.0320783071,
0.0224835649,
-0.0352495685,
0.0229132827,
-0.0425554663,
-0.0109484289,
0.038520176,
-0.012928986,
-0.0613698922,
-0.0214490946,
-0.0534045473,
-0.0358786657,
-0.016780993,
0.035187427,
-0.0016607523,
0.0574842058,
-0.0076789982,
-0.0098820087,
0.0642550513,
0.0412254855,
-0.0321156606,
-0.0364740863,
0.0236874111,
0.0204359144,
-0.004498912,
0.0307189506,
-0.048079256,
0.0406922661,
0.0365588814,
0.0498679318,
-0.0179375838,
-0.0119845895,
0.0101819169,
-0.0259751007,
0.073996976,
-0.0130908946,
-0.0235616155,
-0.0473113358,
0.0501164235,
-0.0137451589,
-0.0142233428,
-0.0267266352,
-0.0139308618,
-0.0374733359,
-0.0111323744,
-0.0359549858,
0.0269613992,
-0.0150449052,
0.0459283814,
-0.0286885742,
0.023801649,
0.0440892167,
0.0204155259,
-0.0027015042,
-0.0217910595,
-0.0333666988,
0.0379027016,
0.0067146225,
0.0481717065,
-0.05567424,
0.0425559282,
0.0129089439,
0.0015601192,
-0.0432349108,
0.0183508601,
0.0013809946,
0.0281304251,
-0.0563558117,
0.0173828583,
0.049936235,
-0.0264649931,
0.0200425368,
0.0042087878,
-0.0056025507,
0.0024950481,
0.0154479519,
-0.0258526821,
-0.0579261892,
0.0202539638,
0.0262530521,
-0.0088114608,
0.0052726837,
0.0543950126,
0.0019885704,
0.0429672152,
0.0314220265,
0.0494627282,
-0.040754661,
0.0167769901,
0.0656461567,
0.0379348285,
0.0053155799,
0.0056670145,
-0.0503829792,
-0.047691606,
0.0319432169,
-0.0109008178,
-0.0532130487,
0.0424528942,
0.0253556129,
0.018097423,
0.0090416241,
-0.0498530902,
-0.0161707047,
-0.0100642145,
0.0327494591,
-0.0529727861,
-0.027504541,
-6.485017193e-33,
-0.0468952507,
-0.0194732063,
0.0116768451,
-0.0291477814,
0.0232010689,
0.0202916227,
-0.0349047184,
-0.0389556773,
-0.0108547704,
-0.0144836791,
-0.0141307376,
-0.0353435166,
0.0267381184,
0.0314509496,
-0.0103776194,
-0.031220153,
0.051544413,
0.0197297204,
-0.0127328765,
0.0153683163,
0.0019025638,
0.0612968244,
0.0873284563,
-0.090800032,
0.0175118614,
0.004183623,
0.0104136802,
0.0053897984,
0.0549809076,
0.0620838106,
-0.0330297314,
-0.0074510463,
0.0196671784,
-0.0308168735,
-0.008913178,
-0.0036288311,
-0.1353770941,
-0.010019918,
-0.0365138687,
0.0102033596,
-0.0400978215,
-0.0105382083,
0.0152903022,
-0.0247815922,
0.0455629118,
-0.0228332411,
0.0163670778,
-0.0096052289,
0.0008486961,
-0.0330494642,
-0.086272873,
0.0468597449,
0.0215502176,
0.0204193927,
0.0372803845,
-0.0070786816,
0.0362692662,
0.0317573175,
-0.0911489427,
-0.0187093541,
0.0129269026,
-0.0487533584,
0.0393667854,
0.012324227,
0.007288747,
0.0865294859,
0.0270071216,
0.0024318183,
0.0047945757,
-0.0341763087,
0.040611431,
0.0440629385,
-0.0267784614,
0.0628469884,
0.0606752895,
0.0047254618,
-0.0573199764,
0.0121769346,
0.0093272859,
-0.0152817238,
-0.005564149,
0.001406483,
-0.0651795939,
-0.006612041,
-0.0052466388,
-0.0580569282,
-0.0460742712,
-0.0290806424,
0.0480248481,
0.0081389472,
-0.0559378639,
0.0418205298,
0.0525407568,
-0.0014293733,
-0.0651540086,
0.0106387641,
0.0487254336,
0.0091007845,
-0.0109370016,
0.0033148164,
-0.04280046,
-0.0618089214,
0.0098790079,
0.0032948817,
0.0184897892,
-0.0021834881,
0.092047669,
0.0003526297,
-0.0888873488,
0.0036227165,
0.0029748359,
-0.0056239106,
-0.0006649346,
-0.0149176596,
0.0410242267,
0.0156458654,
0.0001596856,
0.0450873151,
0.0738903955,
-0.064253293,
-0.0339942984,
0.0172996707,
-0.025050506,
0.0372049101,
0.0234299488,
-0.0155804418,
0.0058662249,
0.0031383929,
0.0289078094,
-0.0402821004,
0.0035631692,
0.0025055835,
2.658e-7,
0.0257658549,
0.0216445997,
0.0069045327,
-0.0078078029,
0.013283778,
0.0206268597,
0.0213253014,
0.055116903,
-0.0241882931,
-0.0011707043,
0.0155558381,
-0.0363578722,
0.027012825,
0.0492161997,
-0.0899691731,
0.0088706072,
-0.0285144597,
0.0001058926,
-0.0755728707,
-0.0206905641,
0.0824981183,
0.0627949461,
0.0279124379,
-0.0069618518,
-0.0140346261,
-0.027794946,
0.0577767938,
0.000703699,
0.0352249816,
0.0020307803,
-0.0585551113,
0.0647472218,
0.0014661454,
0.0318330452,
-0.0162064023,
0.05244115,
0.0046554604,
0.035283573,
0.0089887828,
-0.0141498437,
-0.0058735316,
-0.0251728762,
-0.0023308643,
-0.0452764295,
0.0833753794,
-0.1121659949,
0.0103046969,
-0.0285250191,
-0.0318017043,
-0.0254406501,
0.005679924,
0.0168662183,
-0.0201520436,
0.0432038158,
0.0236245804,
-0.0103999963,
-0.0268253498,
-0.0784669518,
0.0272067916,
0.0390548445,
0.0028851859,
0.0268396586,
-0.0162230935,
-0.0174595583,
0.0320190974,
-0.0394352004,
0.0021233957,
2.452947913e-34,
0.0010149585,
0.0004443503,
0.000377843,
0.0674170926,
0.0090494957,
-0.0227231681,
-0.0177602991,
-0.0205582157,
0.0078537911,
-0.0633058622,
0.020281937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01176v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01176v2 | CorpusLM: Towards a Unified Language Model on Corpus for Knowledge-Intensive Tasks | 2024-02-02T06:44:22 | 2024-04-21T08:33:32 | Xiaoxi Li, Zhicheng Dou, Yujia Zhou, Fangchao Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Large language models (LLMs) have gained significant attention in various
fields but prone to hallucination, especially in knowledge-intensive (KI)
tasks. To address this, retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has emerged as a
popular solution to enhance factual accuracy. However, traditional retrieval
modules often rely on large document index and disconnect with generative
tasks. With the advent of generative retrieval (GR), language models can
retrieve by directly generating document identifiers (DocIDs), offering
superior performance in retrieval tasks. However, the potential relationship
between GR and downstream tasks remains unexplored. In this paper, we propose
\textbf{CorpusLM}, a unified language model that leverages external corpus to
tackle various knowledge-intensive tasks by integrating generative retrieval,
closed-book generation, and RAG through a unified greedy decoding process. We
design the following mechanisms to facilitate effective retrieval and
generation, and improve the end-to-end effectiveness of KI tasks: (1) We
develop a ranking-oriented DocID list generation strategy, which refines GR by
directly learning from a DocID ranking list, to improve retrieval quality. (2)
We design a continuous DocIDs-References-Answer generation strategy, which
facilitates effective and efficient RAG. (3) We employ well-designed
unsupervised DocID understanding tasks, to comprehend DocID semantics and their
relevance to downstream tasks. We evaluate our approach on the widely used KILT
benchmark with two variants of backbone models, i.e., T5 and Llama2.
Experimental results demonstrate the superior performance of our models in both
retrieval and downstream tasks. | [
0.0832369849,
0.0287314169,
0.0099623743,
0.0070998864,
-0.0169845074,
0.0087513234,
-0.004740512,
-0.0023284175,
0.0285688359,
-0.0499259345,
-0.0134418756,
0.0002044763,
-0.0291637667,
-0.0272604413,
0.0093090227,
-0.0167779103,
0.0522771701,
-0.0177600421,
0.0222034398,
-0.0260012355,
-0.0066399351,
0.0235464238,
0.0140826423,
0.0141170602,
-0.0081554074,
-0.0259170402,
0.0097709112,
-0.0052378955,
-0.0091046831,
0.0036543256,
0.0339288153,
0.0382553004,
0.0181595217,
0.0396873169,
0.0000020514,
-0.0482896492,
-0.0320031792,
0.0158264879,
-0.0087655224,
0.0035805614,
0.0354529172,
0.0030938319,
0.0261165276,
0.0116716651,
-0.0232973173,
0.0059219855,
0.0142508484,
0.0577982366,
0.0422428325,
0.0596704967,
0.0102023678,
-0.0474618897,
0.0512764007,
-0.0043532732,
0.0530113466,
-0.0174373984,
0.0091013545,
0.0417515412,
0.0373956263,
0.0588918813,
0.0078203818,
0.0549435541,
-0.00389532,
-0.0339851379,
0.0670279115,
0.0362322927,
-0.0541898087,
-0.0072612911,
0.0273295157,
0.0417767242,
0.0102359876,
-0.0586232133,
0.028466532,
0.0255662724,
0.0051157353,
0.023931941,
-0.0717121065,
0.0373197682,
-0.0291309226,
0.0050742929,
0.0538165271,
0.0114744874,
0.0270013548,
0.0171121489,
0.0014932046,
0.0423857123,
0.0317193344,
-0.026960602,
-0.0360170715,
0.015573333,
-0.0218738168,
-0.0244849995,
0.0018778386,
0.0282129105,
-0.0292444006,
0.0232831687,
-0.0015183325,
-0.0645920634,
0.0572486259,
-0.0471762344,
-0.0094966246,
-0.0032652477,
-0.0041323951,
0.0567507111,
-0.0388827287,
0.024587201,
-0.0075951158,
-0.0071581095,
-0.0683892518,
-0.0258822497,
-0.0420666412,
-0.0362359919,
-0.042987261,
0.0427405126,
-0.0463036299,
-0.0210745726,
0.0101068178,
0.0241271574,
0.0226085447,
-0.0130087296,
0.0176979937,
0.0284951795,
-0.0611374304,
-0.0174661744,
-0.035807576,
0.0085493699,
-0.0158684384,
-0.0194287244,
0.0176849086,
-0.0369949341,
-0.0003857796,
0.0065002367,
0.0097540421,
-0.0373244286,
-0.0066251578,
-0.0009382579,
-0.0248267204,
-0.0141782835,
-0.0189515911,
-0.0418826491,
-0.0109725343,
-0.0530813932,
0.0250221416,
-0.0839571953,
0.0373951793,
0.0368693136,
-0.0214133803,
-0.022024354,
0.0223532356,
0.0375307985,
-0.0355268493,
0.0225239601,
0.0164302383,
0.0022976401,
0.0520907789,
0.0117390165,
0.0241238754,
0.0398542732,
-0.0040947227,
0.0225047618,
0.0674899146,
0.0370833352,
0.0009424299,
-0.0071256775,
0.0227263775,
-0.0015645119,
0.023424793,
0.0275676027,
0.0042842184,
0.0234573893,
0.0345255584,
0.0416897833,
-0.0464191847,
-0.0073812609,
0.0548204705,
-0.003172688,
0.0029128832,
0.0175853744,
0.0085880468,
0.0240319073,
0.0124568464,
0.0247606691,
0.0102791796,
0.017192198,
-0.0064226943,
0.0065202536,
0.0426147021,
0.0127934106,
-0.0272706021,
-0.0307913907,
-0.0084495507,
0.0007481633,
-0.0371534936,
0.0098170405,
0.0388802812,
0.0224305969,
-0.0350061208,
0.0719088688,
0.0143346125,
-0.0867974311,
0.0302788299,
-0.0314188637,
0.0294080358,
0.0587411672,
0.1020041257,
-0.015143442,
-0.0339319855,
0.0086015286,
-0.0160034746,
0.0568974689,
0.0310177952,
-0.034973409,
-0.0403983966,
-0.0567353219,
-0.0148897367,
-0.0167220347,
0.0064899735,
0.0136176106,
0.0039671175,
-0.0085735247,
0.0295649525,
-0.1104023606,
-0.0442440286,
0.0213933438,
-0.0533201508,
-0.0437658131,
0.013874731,
-0.0331466012,
-0.0236126538,
-0.001439015,
-0.0186051168,
0.0347574167,
0.0228111316,
-0.0440474488,
-0.0234873295,
-0.0066792415,
-0.0330178924,
-0.0380254015,
0.0346399136,
-0.0105469674,
0.019906722,
0.0450045764,
-0.0115334932,
-0.0375862531,
-0.0043117562,
-0.0279417802,
0.0228769518,
-0.0819906592,
-0.0182164218,
0.0383961387,
0.0003014028,
-0.0702835917,
0.0867819265,
-0.0013787727,
0.0401204005,
0.023309119,
-0.003097235,
0.0223330539,
-0.0529178455,
-0.008384373,
0.0258877818,
-0.0136874849,
0.0196779948,
0.0600832812,
-0.0024676418,
-0.0242529362,
-0.0406861044,
-0.1060617045,
0.002509654,
-0.0180373527,
-0.0244046394,
0.0205375291,
0.0190714709,
0.0022308263,
0.003852613,
-0.0489868075,
0.0035045466,
0.0348880701,
0.0072626481,
0.0102858469,
0.0091395378,
0.0269564781,
-0.0234352835,
-0.0096625639,
0.0171781089,
0.0394811742,
0.0137193818,
-0.0093522491,
-0.0352048539,
0.0174340066,
-0.042174153,
0.0182560366,
-0.0132284034,
0.0196872652,
0.0156915896,
-0.0260749068,
0.0779297128,
0.0184753872,
0.0533849634,
0.0160003565,
0.0135986665,
-0.0266162064,
-0.0995713845,
0.024385104,
-0.0472573228,
-0.0202572867,
0.0045953775,
-0.0087721199,
0.0226306971,
0.0423886329,
0.0173555035,
-0.0315841995,
-0.0496864729,
0.005191416,
0.0023209741,
-0.0427294411,
-0.0682331026,
0.0081250742,
0.0061126053,
0.0390754938,
-0.0350639224,
-0.033743646,
0.0387681685,
-0.0310978685,
0.011564048,
-0.0783160478,
0.0379075296,
-0.0409235321,
0.0289357919,
0.0179382339,
0.0227963775,
-0.0007246361,
-0.0044415365,
-0.0261065755,
0.0606724657,
0.0302080829,
-0.0702036023,
-0.0040238812,
-0.0266967509,
0.0190717652,
-0.014642247,
-0.0462518372,
-0.0666325241,
-0.0046179504,
0.0340760984,
0.0081979251,
0.020480793,
-0.0002303002,
-0.0237635672,
-0.0116213476,
0.0425247848,
0.0212775618,
-0.0385981426,
-0.0237626042,
-0.0111293662,
0.0642902851,
0.0886804238,
-0.0076660234,
0.0214955378,
0.0007361626,
-0.0036352328,
0.0661364943,
0.0270600617,
-0.0017228364,
0.0097332234,
-0.029597817,
0.0501680113,
-0.0591632575,
-0.0218594894,
-0.0100907087,
0.0024898578,
-0.0304283518,
-0.0619722269,
0.1029082537,
0.0603654757,
-0.0418597572,
-0.0317161344,
-0.0555794723,
0.0431301706,
-0.0021664577,
0.0509641841,
-0.0772621706,
0.0070055062,
0.0156806465,
0.0515856929,
0.0093924757,
-0.0242537968,
0.0042971517,
-0.1326654404,
0.0756923631,
-0.0010528998,
0.0432192087,
0.0030772351,
-0.0365624055,
-0.0296694171,
0.0386122316,
-0.0384664536,
0.0670203641,
0.0049264394,
0.0429152474,
0.0220098924,
0.0164289828,
-0.0340389609,
0.002496944,
-0.0333609357,
-0.0041362685,
0.0728941038,
0.0396075137,
0.0269270502,
-0.0428333133,
0.0094096754,
-0.0447808765,
-0.0181263257,
-0.0057850378,
0.0331873856,
-0.0178807322,
0.0164922718,
-0.0309331045,
0.0282146391,
-0.0233290307,
-0.0092893671,
-0.0085445102,
0.0506077111,
-0.0333488584,
-0.0078878039,
-0.0680341423,
-0.0117807128,
0.0073263329,
0.1052099019,
0.005918276,
-0.0219345987,
-0.0231172815,
-0.0204985961,
0.0590377264,
-0.0543145165,
-0.0285538733,
0.0167620219,
0.0256251879,
-0.010942677,
-0.1257412136,
-0.0515878312,
-0.0174013004,
0.0046660337,
-0.0165540278,
0.0294543114,
-0.0270305425,
-0.0323989615,
-0.0519905314,
0.0124382842,
-0.0318042561,
-0.0376407579,
-0.0585827492,
-0.0221555214,
0.0646998137,
-0.0676459447,
-0.0229780115,
0.0282079261,
-0.0071648913,
-0.0383595824,
-0.001881292,
0.0355204493,
0.0187212154,
0.0538999885,
-0.0335732214,
-0.0193415787,
0.0287751071,
0.0744125247,
-0.0676625669,
0.0228770506,
-0.0110161919,
-0.015106665,
-0.0208171122,
0.0375033803,
-0.0962411091,
0.0301385988,
-0.0312441606,
0.074372299,
0.0164496731,
-0.0523535535,
0.0418653712,
0.0271904077,
0.0317295305,
-0.0199540276,
0.0178312752,
-0.0509778745,
0.0054847924,
-0.0281282738,
-0.0362320803,
-0.0400511324,
0.0157435313,
0.0401839688,
-0.003403092,
-0.0065275342,
0.0597488917,
0.0115645016,
0.0889585987,
-0.0190139674,
-0.0405975729,
-0.0088773826,
0.0093021868,
-0.013770734,
-0.0207605083,
-0.0399472453,
-0.0028509765,
-0.0213263333,
0.0626595393,
-0.0293726623,
0.0332504995,
0.0102263456,
-0.0190841146,
0.0019098063,
0.0057307663,
-0.0698972791,
-0.0197293889,
-0.0465476662,
-0.0068832347,
0.0225274209,
-0.0063533164,
0.0565539449,
-0.0438273512,
-0.0216492917,
-0.0460003912,
0.0003503662,
0.0418062657,
-0.0212086942,
-0.0008723199,
0.0249455627,
-0.0124528706,
-0.0134863043,
0.0904721022,
0.0009946554,
0.0094847521,
-0.0082226358,
-0.0257942304,
-0.0429742374,
-0.0466493927,
-0.0311698113,
0.0107203089,
0.0023537732,
0.0085119056,
-0.0379090756,
-0.0318573974,
0.0176695567,
0.0172627307,
0.0064839097,
-0.0188062433,
0.0441621579,
0.0866043866,
-0.0224456768,
-0.0181115158,
-0.0831497833,
0.057674922,
-0.0535074249,
-0.0194269679,
-0.0205173567,
-6.532434431e-33,
-0.0277786031,
-0.0046630157,
0.0290493127,
-0.0053872392,
0.0047784871,
-0.0162352398,
-0.0401365906,
-0.0134899169,
0.0129397521,
0.0007971451,
-0.0156928841,
-0.007507707,
0.002606306,
0.0466551483,
-0.0071303928,
0.0217610914,
0.0318424143,
-0.0083647585,
-0.0287951697,
0.0490818657,
0.0792638883,
0.0332098082,
0.0065776054,
-0.055116754,
0.0213827491,
-0.0481717214,
0.020933358,
0.0005534498,
0.0055886195,
0.0586722866,
-0.0350761339,
0.0432168469,
0.0361563191,
-0.0309277456,
-0.0100049134,
0.00531223,
-0.130822584,
-0.0187357031,
-0.0006579025,
-0.0127877546,
-0.0426908731,
-0.0527798496,
0.0340091772,
-0.0025061916,
0.022463141,
-0.0184011795,
0.0444423743,
-0.0261722002,
-0.033917658,
-0.0785268918,
-0.0470334329,
0.0211614016,
0.0180426408,
0.0056025824,
-0.0169274453,
0.0452516563,
0.0154349972,
0.0525372066,
-0.056724824,
0.0124253342,
-0.0072697881,
0.0711926073,
0.0301132184,
-0.0041501443,
-0.0072615473,
0.0451978929,
-0.0160907097,
-0.0252903532,
-0.0239623729,
-0.0009794924,
0.0191162322,
0.0356844403,
0.0338874795,
0.0682349727,
0.0312526189,
0.0018360778,
-0.0557932109,
0.0873010531,
0.007357819,
0.0260567367,
0.0217870288,
0.0011191698,
-0.0106712785,
-0.0185848698,
-0.0310035925,
0.0091151595,
-0.031375926,
-0.0107791061,
0.0617808551,
0.0263713952,
-0.032099802,
-0.0355429575,
0.0481658131,
-0.0166977029,
-0.0210662894,
0.0690134019,
-0.0210095961,
0.0253824349,
-0.0089905681,
0.0294780955,
-0.0446891598,
0.0068053454,
0.037795607,
-0.0030014864,
-0.0514540486,
0.0316989012,
0.0062342016,
0.0073268334,
-0.0252732784,
0.0144014014,
-0.0273860041,
0.0304617379,
-0.0226677097,
0.0076981043,
0.0064560371,
0.0158266537,
0.003818786,
0.0320993811,
0.0087043764,
0.0132396221,
-0.0282501727,
-0.0372092985,
0.0112633519,
0.0001892324,
-0.011120338,
0.035460934,
-0.0246602409,
0.0418455377,
0.0298055839,
-0.0540078804,
0.0071013183,
0.0391989686,
2.827e-7,
0.0531837828,
0.0207569301,
0.0406907313,
0.0237118136,
0.0101610925,
0.0146279261,
0.0262365118,
0.039016977,
0.0482716784,
-0.0304093882,
-0.0303372089,
0.0164869055,
0.0191372801,
0.0205682442,
-0.1049508452,
-0.0071141305,
-0.0388900153,
-0.000131837,
-0.0292606819,
-0.0353147425,
0.0254741143,
0.0534506328,
-0.0273356754,
-0.014296066,
-0.0071911034,
-0.0481639095,
0.095619306,
0.0008470428,
-0.0328965411,
0.0299410261,
0.087702252,
0.0199793316,
0.026649002,
-0.0287262406,
-0.0134977065,
0.0140557662,
0.02058254,
0.0303953364,
0.0139769427,
-0.0501637161,
0.0184670724,
-0.0325734615,
0.015436017,
-0.0633393973,
0.0673951209,
-0.0293170847,
0.0301104058,
0.012949788,
-0.0588193871,
0.0123376157,
-0.0429026559,
-0.0184670184,
-0.037169043,
0.045643121,
0.0114381332,
0.0139780063,
0.0048278351,
-0.0721715093,
-0.0318721235,
-0.0087852534,
-0.0638906956,
-0.0297544487,
-0.020696748,
0.0116604557,
-0.0274952352,
-0.0510190539,
0.0166422017,
2.80990514e-34,
0.032581877,
0.0152151752,
-0.0321163759,
0.0044819433,
0.0279653985,
-0.0263361093,
-0.038812194,
0.0480888374,
0.0099847978,
-0.0878242031,
-0.0220097508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01173v1 | Efficient Prompt Caching via Embedding Similarity | 2024-02-02T06:34:11 | 2024-02-02T06:34:11 | Hanlin Zhu, Banghua Zhu, Jiantao Jiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved huge success in numerous natural
language process (NLP) tasks. However, it faces the challenge of significant
resource consumption during inference. In this paper, we aim to improve the
inference efficiency of LLMs by prompt caching, i.e., if the current prompt can
be answered by the same response of a previous prompt, one can directly utilize
that previous response without calling the LLM. Specifically, we focus on the
prediction accuracy of prompt caching for single-round question-answering tasks
via embedding similarity. The existing embeddings of prompts mostly focus on
whether two prompts are semantically similar, which is not necessarily
equivalent to whether the same response can answer them. Therefore, we propose
a distillation-based method to fine-tune the existing embeddings for better
caching prediction. Theoretically, we provide finite-sample guarantees for the
convergence of our method under different types of loss functions. Empirically,
we carefully construct a hard dataset based on Kwiatkowski et al. (2019) where
the existing embedding model (Wang et al., 2022) only achieves an AUC of 0.51.
We then fine-tune the above embedding model, which significantly improves the
AUC of caching prediction from 0.51 to 0.81. We also conduct simulations
demonstrating that our trained models achieve better caching efficiency than
the previous embedding model. | [
0.0172155499,
0.036869444,
-0.0022952317,
0.0343423113,
-0.0221224278,
0.0272919983,
0.0136131225,
-0.0168806668,
0.02203192,
-0.011725097,
-0.0155243948,
-0.0413093418,
-0.00259243,
-0.0006440905,
0.0120349266,
-0.0095052039,
0.0505703986,
-0.0357262269,
0.0132881505,
-0.0151310591,
-0.007671128,
-0.0043118224,
0.0120417224,
0.0407937169,
0.033198379,
-0.0167784933,
-0.0172397252,
-0.0134074399,
0.015557413,
-0.0301166195,
0.0297793206,
0.0549947619,
0.0249039885,
0.0371465907,
0.0000020865,
-0.0503876358,
0.0266226549,
-0.0113144852,
-0.0830171183,
0.0186074618,
-0.0037693421,
0.0554483086,
0.0529333502,
0.0387570038,
0.0018418502,
-0.0403634198,
0.0349944532,
0.0277395584,
0.0679069012,
0.0328962766,
0.0208949316,
-0.0237314235,
0.023408087,
-0.0343357325,
0.0101634786,
-0.0443736985,
0.0115389246,
-0.0522642247,
-0.012650121,
0.023722643,
-0.0251825117,
0.0418019779,
0.0494830832,
0.0185926501,
-0.0316461697,
0.0562581569,
0.0051473416,
0.0069939056,
0.0055030063,
0.0598832294,
-0.0041437247,
-0.0238723624,
-0.0121411467,
-0.0040835277,
0.0273939781,
0.017191764,
-0.0585105419,
-0.0061807223,
0.0112691028,
0.0006234717,
0.0017907367,
0.0249760039,
-0.0013696313,
-0.0003545223,
-0.0139250867,
0.0311270989,
0.0317238979,
-0.0339614637,
0.0038287723,
-0.0038160502,
-0.0136616305,
-0.0465484969,
-0.0109817479,
0.0253933184,
-0.040717531,
0.0007092461,
-0.0312775746,
0.0254741367,
0.0256497562,
0.0064403876,
0.0603985898,
0.0308466777,
-0.0083399508,
0.0631859824,
-0.0400907472,
0.0638933182,
-0.0073115821,
0.0088842306,
-0.0470751338,
-0.000023591,
-0.0707169846,
-0.0220324602,
-0.0349894986,
0.0386071168,
0.0146872252,
-0.0137814879,
-0.0226488449,
0.0221828613,
-0.0116074104,
0.0384559892,
0.0319326818,
0.0317957811,
-0.0094362963,
0.011389018,
-0.0419600308,
0.0525120832,
-0.0852925479,
0.0164894722,
0.0130607793,
-0.0605161227,
-0.0546173602,
-0.0180328954,
0.0357087068,
-0.0396604761,
0.0038377938,
0.0319854803,
-0.0090092476,
-0.0472570322,
-0.027039187,
-0.0325441994,
0.0077719875,
-0.0675727502,
-0.0166958887,
-0.0534629561,
0.0700591654,
-0.01797859,
0.0141178919,
-0.0016670213,
-0.0145106427,
0.0515831783,
-0.0105905943,
0.0736753121,
0.0423100218,
0.0103150522,
0.0090146,
0.0078494251,
-0.0002021833,
0.027386589,
-0.0106180822,
0.0053272289,
0.0395119712,
-0.0322490558,
-0.0153205302,
0.0053053978,
0.0232536625,
0.0002630411,
0.0509621724,
0.0352200419,
0.04004962,
0.0337346718,
0.034294039,
0.022831317,
-0.0290027838,
-0.0665050149,
0.0646436438,
0.0568679124,
-0.0228305738,
-0.0332487002,
0.0380448997,
0.0314272977,
-0.0139468675,
0.0390229188,
-0.0725664571,
0.0316327661,
-0.0006352116,
-0.0026471349,
0.0481728427,
-0.0008763651,
-0.0794829279,
-0.023019284,
0.0252145343,
-0.0127651328,
-0.0179747269,
0.0321720578,
-0.0156398248,
0.010551461,
-0.0482713692,
0.0566590913,
-0.0026093242,
-0.0240522418,
0.0044417977,
-0.0288513452,
0.0397407673,
0.0355585702,
0.0232635625,
-0.016480092,
-0.0042423862,
-0.0451400056,
0.0258382149,
-0.0194103159,
0.0533553548,
-0.0333875194,
0.0385921709,
-0.043411091,
-0.0202539973,
-0.022050662,
-0.0074879779,
0.0022782655,
0.0142040448,
0.0244421344,
0.0272354037,
-0.0017883546,
0.0170888454,
0.0079035321,
-0.0462775305,
-0.1012004018,
0.0278164167,
0.0161905009,
0.0160936061,
-0.0005313042,
-0.0022261969,
0.034055952,
0.017433282,
-0.0594336055,
-0.0354613997,
-0.0063723596,
-0.0798815265,
-0.0829750821,
0.002188812,
0.0091246059,
-0.000853097,
0.0382631533,
-0.0649340749,
-0.057280656,
-0.0437491313,
-0.0259878188,
0.0410904437,
-0.0268039368,
0.0298654456,
0.0113095371,
0.0123061286,
-0.0381015874,
0.0570815057,
-0.0483400896,
0.061224144,
0.0063452846,
0.038168475,
0.0206711441,
-0.0282746702,
-0.0605651215,
0.0061202408,
-0.0137942107,
-0.0153550021,
0.0506934822,
-0.0060966834,
-0.0417905524,
0.0049794675,
-0.0752974078,
0.0213806909,
-0.0065948907,
0.0067306519,
0.0015706834,
0.0180602595,
0.0111253699,
-0.0404699408,
-0.0372737832,
-0.0298239235,
-0.0020606986,
0.0778674707,
0.0227576122,
0.0077700466,
-0.0164217707,
-0.032327503,
-0.0330411084,
0.017247431,
0.0467702411,
-0.0522351861,
0.0361976065,
-0.0454003215,
0.0439376943,
-0.0005041427,
0.0166601595,
0.0096949814,
0.0063116313,
-0.0064967046,
0.0010815584,
0.024380656,
0.0703787729,
0.0083580678,
-0.0257154889,
0.0153690102,
-0.0020473914,
-0.0599980466,
0.0115384059,
-0.0363942198,
-0.0551193394,
0.004751347,
-0.0299812481,
0.0141922738,
0.0885418355,
0.0349803418,
0.0038600992,
-0.0401274115,
-0.0076528443,
-0.0178798325,
-0.0090978006,
-0.076388143,
0.0014025725,
-0.0241356529,
-0.002771822,
-0.022494534,
-0.0558722839,
0.09438508,
-0.0325376354,
0.0077126864,
-0.0235758293,
-0.024977902,
-0.0186579358,
0.0658524781,
0.0217163377,
-0.0012689825,
0.0065856944,
-0.0210079402,
-0.0716203675,
0.0040546702,
0.0255601052,
-0.0424284786,
0.0205949973,
0.0049912441,
-0.0100630391,
-0.0191911291,
-0.0727242827,
-0.0722502545,
-0.0445021428,
-0.0042611808,
0.0174568314,
-0.0337307118,
0.0028586993,
-0.0015407548,
-0.0065436135,
0.0005083843,
0.0301583055,
-0.0265098438,
-0.0110865822,
-0.0429918393,
0.0805483609,
0.0809081495,
0.0112529229,
0.0009100293,
0.0039796513,
0.0643605068,
0.0539756604,
0.0817344114,
0.032665886,
-0.0038113603,
-0.0086956518,
0.0387270972,
-0.0362998471,
-0.017857885,
0.0368539393,
0.0412019528,
-0.0481815413,
-0.019564433,
0.1248283386,
0.0415781699,
-0.0378579907,
0.0003409422,
0.0055658175,
0.0499744825,
0.0446763635,
-0.0074209766,
-0.0499103032,
-0.0457498915,
0.0211472064,
0.018709721,
-0.0006238231,
-0.0407842323,
0.0004852191,
-0.1415765136,
-0.0066755116,
-0.0157276969,
0.0171324853,
-0.0449468642,
-0.047806181,
-0.0037677069,
0.0101719173,
0.0202327594,
0.0045899702,
-0.007084135,
-0.0147387311,
0.0160765853,
-0.0182766914,
-0.0223507322,
0.0542800836,
-0.0399895497,
0.0287572443,
0.0325428583,
0.0199760962,
0.0240540858,
-0.0432784483,
0.0169547051,
-0.0698985681,
-0.000874523,
0.0053454689,
0.0417002179,
0.010854519,
0.0074087167,
-0.020648919,
0.0421701707,
-0.0350257792,
-0.0136093237,
0.0232272837,
0.0807838589,
-0.0197199453,
-0.0357682779,
0.0064134235,
-0.024680661,
-0.0008253756,
0.1055488586,
0.0304151885,
-0.0302682742,
-0.0469479635,
0.0006845249,
0.0264364034,
-0.0031871386,
-0.0071015912,
0.0091701401,
0.0317371227,
0.0366545841,
-0.030788539,
-0.0362783037,
0.0124073233,
0.0112596257,
-0.0321314223,
0.0218065977,
-0.0143485675,
-0.0081523145,
-0.0387872681,
0.0315182544,
-0.068075873,
0.0508179814,
-0.0297408123,
0.0126299039,
0.0366313308,
0.0361963362,
-0.0394728146,
0.0046812738,
-0.1291229278,
-0.043291539,
-0.0279894657,
0.0491612852,
0.0080531007,
0.0400938503,
-0.009005121,
-0.0615642518,
0.0607246049,
-0.0266465563,
-0.0510173663,
0.0162374154,
-0.0066159554,
0.0298076943,
-0.0127796112,
0.0407546572,
-0.0343005732,
-0.0133201666,
0.0106645571,
0.0423455387,
-0.0169940311,
-0.0539062694,
0.0250477325,
0.0112805776,
0.0205945037,
0.0304118507,
0.0045291311,
-0.030708313,
0.0477117971,
0.0441990905,
-0.0087240115,
-0.0060526291,
0.0044032843,
0.0409722589,
-0.0412918814,
0.006284731,
-0.0189529564,
0.0229036175,
0.0430699103,
-0.0584142283,
-0.0327242911,
0.023637183,
0.0040484555,
0.0248166602,
0.0143315047,
-0.0511482581,
0.004144243,
0.0053589297,
0.031161245,
-0.029071629,
0.0574400909,
0.0040572155,
0.0308386404,
-0.0110051297,
0.0132017862,
-0.0776121616,
-0.0616346747,
0.0004237387,
0.0141736614,
0.0250290819,
-0.0325678103,
-0.0289769378,
-0.0005080877,
0.001012516,
-0.0315903015,
-0.006272065,
0.0144851934,
-0.023850942,
0.0588000678,
0.0419512503,
-0.0125026992,
-0.0017108107,
0.0848380923,
-0.0110113891,
0.0539425649,
-0.0245023575,
0.000297954,
-0.0503979437,
-0.0388982445,
-0.0145817669,
0.0560268052,
0.0053615365,
0.0181075986,
-0.0453663468,
-0.0708843991,
-0.0244942363,
-0.0133763328,
-0.0188704934,
-0.009199827,
0.037219312,
0.0159097053,
-0.0033224816,
-0.0385420658,
-0.0161866844,
0.0235002618,
-0.0066061579,
-0.0454260707,
-0.0358015224,
-6.340223472e-33,
-0.017111659,
-0.0055130296,
0.0177613981,
-0.0293720476,
-0.0151114017,
0.0106389839,
-0.0188419819,
-0.0304227937,
-0.0450117439,
-0.008985837,
-0.0381318964,
-0.0031551917,
0.0180762894,
0.0337088667,
-0.0058369944,
-0.0553182475,
0.0770043731,
-0.0133267194,
-0.0252240431,
0.0534363687,
0.0506405979,
0.0133082988,
-0.0051767007,
0.0116000539,
0.0032085439,
-0.0109992139,
0.0342924036,
0.0357345045,
-0.0169838984,
0.0315200724,
-0.0299812574,
0.0663694516,
0.0408540182,
-0.0403892361,
-0.0143545447,
0.0615283959,
-0.0963136926,
-0.0750620216,
-0.0076962528,
-0.0300797094,
-0.037103273,
-0.0151612414,
-0.0143051762,
-0.0184189957,
0.016714802,
-0.0015804607,
-0.0028417397,
0.0160744861,
-0.0302680973,
0.0152892517,
-0.0141870473,
-0.0030539422,
-0.0117396722,
-0.0356516168,
-0.0081243822,
0.0738933831,
0.0354321487,
0.020817617,
-0.076325044,
-0.0096301371,
-0.0422010832,
0.0778197646,
0.0288436357,
0.0085244421,
0.0135731474,
0.0444869287,
0.0067141857,
-0.018388167,
-0.00431104,
0.001794934,
0.0055725793,
0.0281941947,
0.0272422601,
-0.0022402999,
0.0503786206,
-0.026384037,
-0.0139457639,
0.0309892371,
0.0315102749,
0.0743990391,
0.0476978272,
-0.003901236,
-0.0179789793,
-0.0546497069,
-0.0975402817,
0.0359605737,
-0.0297837257,
0.0220612399,
0.0686289668,
0.0475163795,
-0.0108611146,
-0.0299088974,
0.0620932952,
-0.0283534154,
0.0054208343,
0.0404006913,
0.0091868294,
0.0002698609,
0.0131532783,
0.036630787,
-0.044617027,
-0.0015669237,
0.0009753382,
-0.0423289202,
-0.0035486314,
0.0127984891,
0.0157065634,
0.0091513582,
-0.0948714614,
0.0018887935,
-0.0495006181,
0.0258237682,
-0.0102883372,
-0.0071588201,
0.0420528539,
0.0200633015,
-0.0029698042,
0.038347967,
-0.0022716012,
-0.0275333505,
-0.0037084997,
-0.0126603199,
0.0037679807,
0.0126836812,
0.0021381858,
0.0091469111,
-0.0402550586,
0.0360087156,
0.0106717953,
-0.0419514477,
0.0051628831,
0.0237337239,
2.656e-7,
0.0040526334,
-0.0272446554,
0.0146832587,
0.0385600664,
0.0117359469,
0.0366340056,
0.0202928334,
0.0459378622,
0.0071130274,
-0.0408630446,
-0.0163935535,
0.0239311215,
0.0361832678,
0.0234406851,
-0.0982639715,
0.0069033075,
-0.1007932276,
0.0182032064,
-0.0513524376,
-0.0414005257,
0.0422090739,
0.1126480624,
0.0178654585,
-0.0191671047,
0.0108142244,
-0.0230847746,
0.0409211144,
-0.0169834178,
-0.0057178759,
0.0102427062,
0.0178010929,
-0.0107587529,
0.031790249,
0.0243813861,
-0.0256747007,
0.0171346776,
-0.0011921406,
0.0459440649,
0.0417870469,
-0.0533226281,
-0.0333150849,
-0.0270197093,
-0.005780037,
-0.049455341,
0.1024660617,
-0.0506956466,
-0.0166284591,
-0.0644318163,
0.0177806132,
-0.0086906692,
0.0649349615,
0.0049348515,
-0.0289403647,
0.0235310569,
0.0178397652,
0.0119470563,
0.0026307632,
-0.0846844465,
-0.0111547736,
-0.0110695446,
-0.0571469627,
-0.0492949486,
-0.055889897,
-0.0288849231,
0.01551707,
-0.0463888012,
-0.0089557627,
2.605781694e-34,
0.0238228869,
0.0005962002,
0.0575034134,
0.0353951454,
0.0351914279,
-0.0222073402,
-0.0003335511,
0.0183634628,
0.0454795025,
-0.1004774272,
-0.0266227927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01172v1 | Streaming Sequence Transduction through Dynamic Compression | 2024-02-02T06:31:50 | 2024-02-02T06:31:50 | Weiting Tan, Yunmo Chen, Tongfei Chen, Guanghui Qin, Haoran Xu, Heidi C. Zhang, Benjamin Van Durme, Philipp Koehn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | We introduce STAR (Stream Transduction with Anchor Representations), a novel
Transformer-based model designed for efficient sequence-to-sequence
transduction over streams. STAR dynamically segments input streams to create
compressed anchor representations, achieving nearly lossless compression (12x)
in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) and outperforming existing methods.
Moreover, STAR demonstrates superior segmentation and latency-quality
trade-offs in simultaneous speech-to-text tasks, optimizing latency, memory
footprint, and quality. | [
-0.0478401221,
0.025387045,
-0.0005783201,
-0.027182905,
-0.0218982957,
-0.0109531833,
0.0155308098,
-0.007688296,
-0.0562527068,
0.0033001818,
-0.0024900455,
-0.0439474806,
0.0448593237,
0.0666727424,
0.0200954173,
-0.0726905093,
0.0460399725,
-0.0240586605,
-0.0154757295,
0.0158290081,
0.0247474276,
0.0080030989,
0.0002915933,
0.0259819422,
0.0179129168,
0.018871583,
-0.0375298262,
-0.0271862596,
0.0259678848,
-0.0268317964,
-0.046869345,
0.0107777473,
0.0591411777,
0.0157166775,
0.000001879,
0.0224521067,
-0.0360045098,
-0.0008008296,
-0.0605967566,
0.01650545,
-0.015037721,
-0.0725311637,
-0.0311288647,
0.0412277244,
0.0219014212,
-0.0373962484,
0.0451430157,
0.0066199531,
0.0441248678,
0.038056083,
-0.0213952251,
-0.0534414873,
0.0703569129,
-0.0243619215,
-0.0267236717,
0.0093973447,
-0.0214346573,
-0.0140939038,
-0.0294968151,
0.0057482426,
-0.054875575,
0.039424058,
0.0309172217,
-0.0180770885,
0.0314364582,
-0.0011062284,
-0.064706549,
-0.0408646353,
-0.0339565314,
0.0331600383,
-0.0603360757,
-0.0383880511,
0.0087888846,
-0.0027055107,
-0.0094638048,
-0.067893438,
-0.0312182512,
0.0411663353,
0.0011490592,
0.0159885809,
0.0094917296,
0.0086447494,
0.0198631193,
-0.0485787131,
-0.0128090242,
-0.0426908731,
-0.0012258809,
-0.0168061126,
-0.0454559103,
0.002157849,
-0.0175668988,
0.0002214734,
0.0617950112,
-0.0084616654,
-0.022387879,
0.0072747758,
-0.0544956066,
-0.0465553626,
-0.0278356038,
-0.0133094657,
0.0895596221,
0.0629659519,
0.0154540455,
-0.0070449645,
-0.0299826227,
0.0570043549,
-0.0071352869,
-0.0264921505,
-0.0235649701,
0.0013790469,
-0.0182334166,
-0.0114984363,
-0.0340238512,
0.0394067727,
-0.041640684,
-0.0397335961,
-0.0215543564,
0.0206694398,
0.0271460507,
-0.0330658369,
0.0128227193,
-0.0132710375,
-0.0409784652,
-0.0038655126,
0.0747697279,
0.0929790735,
-0.0047892844,
0.0151675958,
0.033852607,
-0.0282478463,
-0.0266180076,
0.021709092,
0.0239953194,
0.0003180231,
-0.0103425318,
-0.0229517538,
-0.0086934352,
-0.0415445976,
0.0000820335,
0.0019191882,
0.0130080795,
-0.0166984424,
0.0179230571,
-0.037515413,
0.0398349501,
0.0101147722,
-0.0101272352,
-0.0404812023,
0.0052811564,
0.0320003293,
0.0041689221,
0.0273843035,
0.0234663766,
-0.0130686751,
0.0191182271,
0.0004645252,
0.0318001471,
0.0411515646,
0.0523920953,
-0.0075660339,
-0.0160550941,
-0.041686099,
-0.0432533287,
0.0370580852,
0.0139614595,
-0.0240207929,
-0.0546455309,
-0.0164046027,
-0.003173243,
0.0205591526,
0.0597224683,
0.0662939548,
-0.0314487554,
-0.0391134918,
0.0445604511,
0.0932439342,
0.0525253154,
0.0690973699,
0.034282364,
0.0368173942,
-0.0218797866,
-0.0147406198,
0.0467960313,
0.0586286895,
0.0466421992,
0.0304616503,
0.0233365167,
0.0547056161,
-0.0179996733,
0.0100335125,
-0.0278008208,
-0.015995875,
-0.0196596012,
-0.0115162684,
-0.0090140495,
0.0230166391,
-0.0670281798,
0.0831074193,
-0.062719658,
-0.0778056756,
0.0020592012,
-0.0242835842,
-0.0438914932,
0.0185655076,
0.0090191448,
0.0068158349,
-0.0207567941,
-0.0495860018,
0.0157661624,
-0.0060469625,
0.0068967622,
0.0179391149,
0.0274026357,
-0.0452497154,
0.0095665976,
0.0611301251,
0.0076649389,
0.0712891966,
0.0007769279,
0.0212833751,
0.0306412634,
0.0045085046,
0.0256924611,
-0.0103997821,
-0.0088037811,
-0.0208939575,
0.0324124247,
-0.0162495356,
0.0361863486,
0.0084780902,
-0.0041794707,
0.0176952705,
0.0601768158,
-0.0388874486,
0.0134864077,
0.055777926,
-0.0820115209,
-0.0132934796,
-0.0063941763,
-0.0396944061,
0.0284175035,
0.073732093,
0.0277145002,
-0.0826202482,
0.0289931782,
-0.0442477539,
0.0336646363,
-0.032485541,
0.0302985199,
0.0473516285,
0.0377970785,
0.0410898775,
-0.0282777995,
-0.0072744056,
0.0067535122,
0.0011150541,
-0.0197703578,
-0.0465299375,
-0.0614238679,
0.0094139036,
0.0120230801,
-0.019348165,
-0.0164005235,
0.0085811559,
-0.0507931821,
0.0040650992,
-0.0050899838,
-0.0050387578,
0.0021883482,
-0.0063890382,
0.0569581278,
-0.0205309987,
0.0575001761,
0.0260701533,
0.0315198228,
-0.0379387364,
-0.0394964367,
0.0184603333,
0.0119334087,
-0.0215769373,
-0.0101718176,
-0.0368018821,
0.0096916892,
-0.0371832214,
0.0102357371,
0.0443752632,
-0.0224807691,
-0.0344321579,
-0.0823976845,
-0.0502478257,
0.0801916122,
0.0074745994,
-0.0010575306,
-0.013676933,
-0.0279575363,
0.0008621514,
0.0317963772,
0.0290307906,
0.0010304152,
-0.0129988724,
-0.0008953342,
-0.0064231274,
-0.0144391023,
-0.0082432935,
-0.0078662029,
0.0729972944,
0.0090546701,
0.022176601,
-0.0058510108,
0.0476079993,
-0.0058044209,
0.0118965795,
-0.0407496504,
-0.0679533333,
0.0251871683,
-0.0104632918,
-0.0125135826,
-0.082829915,
-0.0436710231,
0.0023170223,
-0.0057797218,
-0.0352724344,
0.0213751756,
-0.054362718,
-0.0535901152,
-0.0069077564,
-0.0164759085,
-0.0433255844,
0.0378084369,
-0.0012368056,
-0.0069681033,
-0.0043965746,
-0.0413252339,
-0.0093901092,
0.0778449178,
-0.0305924471,
-0.0472396538,
0.0299557503,
-0.0052886307,
-0.0395990759,
-0.0269774534,
-0.0195137821,
-0.0136002144,
0.011658336,
0.0063720155,
0.0427802652,
0.0710439011,
-0.0373353623,
-0.0633414611,
0.0584873408,
-0.002062273,
0.0427598879,
0.0145262647,
0.0130066322,
-0.0233013891,
0.0456265323,
-0.0244355183,
0.0198261589,
0.0245127715,
0.0505840629,
0.0368420519,
0.0239729788,
0.1028484181,
-0.0009681038,
-0.009267563,
0.0211590212,
0.050343778,
0.0025699507,
-0.0318986401,
0.0184009355,
0.0260176435,
-0.0785806999,
-0.0088046733,
0.0704864636,
0.0350988396,
-0.0102357343,
-0.0131691638,
0.0092843464,
0.0468874611,
-0.0097175008,
0.0130752558,
-0.0465499274,
-0.0214397833,
0.0264543854,
0.0205529612,
0.0500004217,
0.0124608008,
-0.0187463444,
-0.0638626218,
0.0196586456,
0.0369144045,
0.004101587,
-0.0330952033,
-0.0626922771,
-0.0405752137,
0.0026233275,
0.0071042562,
0.0198586397,
-0.0160335284,
-0.021025721,
0.0257148892,
-0.0636924878,
-0.0239330363,
-0.0006733712,
-0.0000173631,
0.068529956,
0.0685697794,
0.0129478471,
0.0304402858,
-0.0188104548,
0.0202876143,
-0.0320933461,
-0.0083546881,
0.0051446604,
-0.0329612941,
-0.0009725204,
0.004082513,
0.0418785438,
0.0324766636,
-0.0258935001,
0.0135910641,
-0.0451261774,
0.0725457072,
0.02012893,
0.0131425234,
-0.0089957416,
-0.0066270945,
-0.0340224244,
0.0509229042,
-0.0119983396,
0.0118831312,
-0.0320390798,
-0.0129991276,
0.0335206985,
-0.0160593241,
-0.0635852665,
-0.003259684,
0.0344814099,
-0.1062252671,
-0.0338302217,
0.0258490834,
0.0012334475,
0.0170530342,
-0.0001327662,
0.0169678368,
0.0432317741,
0.0147256125,
-0.0586118922,
-0.0153228417,
-0.0035728046,
0.0170517769,
-0.0736116767,
0.0004175215,
0.040518634,
-0.0225263853,
-0.0161898192,
0.0539245047,
-0.0941253155,
-0.0276627615,
0.0247718859,
-0.0083027855,
0.0138840815,
0.0370898172,
-0.0059676603,
0.0338785313,
-0.0041124327,
0.0366957672,
-0.0354418941,
0.013120031,
0.0454522148,
-0.0563827455,
-0.0002359688,
0.0184971839,
-0.021540679,
-0.0005131093,
-0.0614315234,
0.0224382244,
-0.0224376507,
-0.0010009027,
0.0033550526,
0.0228333045,
0.0495435633,
0.0099482806,
0.0155194774,
0.0471615605,
0.0585125014,
-0.0017644393,
0.0808907747,
-0.0368466228,
0.0227786414,
0.013013945,
0.0150100403,
0.0041988837,
0.0355013721,
0.0213954132,
-0.0749062449,
-0.0126979817,
0.045895841,
0.0222639274,
-0.0404676013,
0.0036122182,
-0.0060601821,
-0.0141504034,
-0.0178436972,
0.0369831063,
0.0278213322,
-0.0673275441,
0.0019426292,
-0.0051956493,
0.0519570298,
0.0207032543,
0.0272416156,
-0.0435546003,
0.0416044481,
-0.0434826165,
0.0379678607,
0.0135639487,
0.0117595512,
0.0343842842,
-0.0263532046,
0.0368099399,
-0.0298122279,
0.0336385705,
-0.0546867773,
-0.0486295372,
-0.0151301604,
0.0127901342,
-0.0114498409,
0.0027433119,
0.0361984745,
0.007867991,
0.0185899902,
-0.0025482927,
-0.013169976,
-0.0171979088,
-0.0341096148,
-0.0728647709,
-0.0170592647,
-0.0096521238,
-0.0346881375,
-0.0118507147,
-0.0447472222,
0.0478337891,
-0.0336227119,
0.0668779761,
-0.052000396,
-0.0013555099,
0.0107029919,
-0.0217018258,
0.0024927796,
0.0144078778,
-0.0308940839,
-0.0208370257,
-0.0240058303,
0.0165669397,
-6.001196943e-33,
0.0024845661,
0.044422444,
-0.0014537874,
-0.0116190249,
-0.0385985859,
0.0354053639,
-0.0168850403,
-0.0033294491,
0.0200798884,
-0.0510812514,
-0.0279876329,
0.0260820631,
0.0305103566,
0.0355663821,
0.0007611688,
-0.006386946,
0.0902596489,
-0.0344565324,
0.0026719531,
0.0330887698,
0.0032902043,
0.0224633589,
-0.0005593849,
0.0130889723,
-0.0597760826,
0.0040578637,
0.0200721268,
-0.0604816899,
0.0542445406,
0.0228927303,
0.0205410495,
0.0202527735,
-0.0243446361,
-0.0881847665,
-0.0376848094,
0.0601837151,
-0.1133116111,
0.0226661414,
-0.0045043766,
0.0144112026,
0.005330048,
-0.0198896695,
0.0078991838,
0.0059102131,
0.0047743954,
-0.0509243496,
-0.0340475701,
-0.0142362043,
-0.0532857589,
-0.0758663118,
-0.007098658,
0.0292941015,
-0.0388979837,
-0.0049868035,
0.0653336644,
0.0685288087,
-0.0305723567,
-0.071787335,
-0.0532293543,
0.0570301563,
0.0286906995,
0.075203903,
0.024265781,
-0.0203783363,
0.0168105438,
-0.0298179891,
0.029140003,
-0.0814409107,
0.0051996117,
0.0813983083,
0.0227883831,
-0.0180026032,
0.0469928011,
-0.0297673866,
0.0684539974,
-0.0614883304,
-0.0200344045,
-0.0103326039,
0.0385401882,
0.0027479313,
0.041493196,
0.0505255908,
-0.0130371833,
0.0061852024,
-0.0174702518,
-0.0143257985,
-0.007502378,
-0.0111092236,
0.0454290695,
0.0389787294,
-0.0009275612,
0.0549953021,
0.0908964872,
0.0028065683,
0.0333735794,
0.0057821916,
-0.0045173927,
0.024583729,
-0.0076769502,
0.0119805029,
-0.0354825221,
-0.0109821949,
0.0647702813,
0.0234919377,
-0.0024190955,
-0.0130994534,
0.0150888423,
0.0721991807,
-0.0545818247,
-0.0254508462,
-0.0019475952,
0.0366606154,
-0.0190990884,
-0.0076597533,
0.0515345261,
-0.0132205244,
0.0096558239,
0.0267259199,
-0.0486839116,
0.0231543798,
-0.0112857204,
0.0112502892,
-0.015028446,
0.060378436,
-0.040387217,
0.0056467764,
-0.0339442492,
0.0213183071,
0.0550402328,
-0.0420997962,
-0.0330309682,
0.0385125019,
2.653e-7,
-0.0375946276,
0.0483827926,
0.0362013839,
-0.0432093143,
0.0173902735,
-0.0250692591,
0.0150512327,
0.0334262773,
0.0310677867,
0.0333633721,
-0.0099620027,
-0.0306719597,
0.0547389723,
0.0234598368,
-0.1337790638,
-0.0487635359,
-0.0651750043,
0.0343586989,
-0.0061989226,
-0.0014523369,
-0.0031150924,
0.0894756094,
-0.0573858358,
-0.0216644146,
0.0531512834,
-0.0071279011,
0.0075073475,
0.0297202803,
0.0557858795,
-0.0591920018,
-0.0185416527,
-0.0152447782,
-0.0397219919,
-0.0202526078,
-0.0389060862,
0.0056633353,
0.011336254,
0.0545368418,
0.0080915997,
-0.0696612746,
0.0074761817,
0.0358169563,
-0.0363849364,
0.0472420529,
0.0443470106,
-0.0110636242,
-0.0036520765,
-0.0080628684,
-0.0516630523,
0.0273145624,
-0.0427737124,
0.0160225052,
0.0297693834,
0.0201786719,
0.0119063538,
-0.0055848625,
-0.0061125224,
-0.0413760841,
-0.0093795415,
-0.0232896879,
-0.0372025967,
0.0024843793,
-0.0697621778,
0.0058389041,
0.0219896175,
0.004020731,
-0.0693869814,
2.716830324e-34,
0.0047295652,
-0.0234664399,
0.0070351139,
0.0269341506,
0.0030355982,
-0.0404161178,
0.0122689931,
0.0413994864,
-0.0203359816,
-0.0556383133,
-0.0793223605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01799v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01799v2 | Faster and Lighter LLMs: A Survey on Current Challenges and Way Forward | 2024-02-02T06:29:34 | 2024-04-24T04:58:46 | Arnav Chavan, Raghav Magazine, Shubham Kushwaha, Mérouane Debbah, Deepak Gupta | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite the impressive performance of LLMs, their widespread adoption faces
challenges due to substantial computational and memory requirements during
inference. Recent advancements in model compression and system-level
optimization methods aim to enhance LLM inference. This survey offers an
overview of these methods, emphasizing recent developments. Through experiments
on LLaMA(/2)-7B, we evaluate various compression techniques, providing
practical insights for efficient LLM deployment in a unified setting. The
empirical analysis on LLaMA(/2)-7B highlights the effectiveness of these
methods. Drawing from survey insights, we identify current limitations and
discuss potential future directions to improve LLM inference efficiency. We
release the codebase to reproduce the results presented in this paper at
https://github.com/nyunAI/Faster-LLM-Survey | [
-0.0542043522,
0.048993703,
-0.0052427361,
0.0578835681,
-0.0345442481,
-0.0229819994,
-0.0072523057,
0.0285520274,
-0.0062798085,
0.0197637118,
-0.0008340947,
0.0168181136,
0.0136247808,
-0.027496364,
0.0318554975,
0.0358672626,
0.02218429,
-0.0220442954,
-0.0516859144,
-0.0363561437,
-0.0424506478,
-0.0320152044,
0.0373889022,
-0.0031467492,
0.0288559534,
0.0155246509,
-0.03078923,
0.0568311997,
0.0152553162,
-0.0186467879,
-0.0305472594,
0.0281191878,
0.0331589729,
0.0077420617,
0.0000021155,
-0.0127179176,
0.0179084521,
0.0392142013,
-0.0364161283,
0.0741017833,
0.0279385578,
0.0166642983,
-0.0079066698,
0.0194317456,
0.047442995,
0.0090460964,
0.0599519499,
-0.0131782787,
-0.0222916584,
0.017005071,
0.0326240435,
0.0067319684,
0.0191398319,
-0.0286934748,
0.0077082613,
-0.0185567234,
0.0109835993,
-0.0121260453,
0.0185861029,
-0.0108506056,
0.0022908284,
0.0022489806,
0.0295564961,
-0.002922941,
-0.0197333153,
0.0098924758,
0.0274744835,
0.0001031644,
-0.0170910545,
0.0317278318,
0.0082561169,
-0.045688618,
-0.0046263863,
-0.0142206419,
-0.0449518599,
-0.0027419701,
-0.0405476205,
0.0320594274,
-0.0011940498,
0.0275052469,
0.0161309186,
0.0007682329,
0.0579231977,
-0.012648927,
-0.0254937559,
0.0780450851,
0.0496010073,
0.0284116566,
-0.0153617701,
0.0043766727,
-0.0007501332,
-0.0549507774,
-0.0156779569,
0.0024526231,
0.0176139753,
-0.0187119357,
-0.0379364975,
0.0126159815,
0.0194710176,
-0.0272517931,
0.0945440382,
0.058317095,
0.0056611304,
-0.0037877285,
-0.0556439459,
-0.0223752782,
-0.0567470379,
0.0033614843,
-0.0218461752,
0.0164619032,
0.0483136475,
0.0213776026,
0.0188571382,
0.0504817292,
-0.043427147,
0.0251545366,
-0.0421354994,
0.0132898381,
0.0178507268,
-0.0256496947,
0.0033196756,
-0.0058154082,
0.0020530701,
0.0087459851,
-0.0219978485,
-0.0070625227,
-0.0401829816,
0.0246194154,
-0.0057939338,
-0.0397905074,
-0.0499960706,
0.0282872263,
-0.0306657869,
-0.0098109273,
0.0550952144,
0.0703357682,
0.0148763293,
-0.0563470162,
-0.055281613,
-0.0121868672,
0.0276273713,
-0.0553501919,
0.0425472148,
-0.0697080195,
0.0470818244,
-0.036773622,
-0.0002690019,
-0.0106337788,
0.0150330951,
-0.0149591835,
-0.0081476988,
0.0434221476,
-0.008223502,
-0.0138702011,
-0.0068728072,
0.0381816253,
0.0064805308,
0.0969707668,
0.0164206363,
0.0539956801,
-0.0103659704,
0.0036702924,
-0.0178891439,
0.03959902,
0.0662455633,
0.013398597,
-0.041768115,
-0.0217691716,
-0.0326943845,
0.0106892968,
0.0502101369,
0.0048134616,
-0.0236745365,
-0.0407407843,
-0.0053251153,
0.0471360162,
0.0262957513,
0.026731275,
0.0002235732,
-0.0233591069,
0.0369227678,
-0.0090862373,
-0.053088855,
0.0735879615,
-0.0742444173,
0.0117440624,
0.0511474647,
0.06520316,
-0.0209126156,
-0.0473085865,
-0.061470069,
-0.0231668483,
-0.035310857,
0.0051060347,
0.0111075323,
-0.0324954912,
-0.016051583,
0.1068072543,
0.0535188168,
-0.0833115205,
-0.1040823087,
-0.1042086333,
0.0513569936,
-0.0102720428,
0.023743717,
-0.0187972859,
-0.0500059538,
0.0562078916,
-0.0052914615,
-0.0051895794,
-0.0174899008,
0.0297204442,
0.044424355,
-0.0156699643,
-0.0072089434,
-0.0059283786,
0.0263865888,
0.0224387869,
0.0481431335,
-0.0325156413,
0.0134893488,
-0.0566525273,
-0.0072060265,
0.0075843348,
-0.0146363154,
0.0094054528,
0.0544442087,
-0.0046726358,
0.0442277938,
-0.0224357452,
-0.0102121076,
-0.0345657878,
0.077617839,
-0.0536445901,
0.0015179836,
-0.047731936,
0.000137142,
-0.0447895601,
0.0404598117,
-0.0278105102,
0.0337362215,
0.0142254885,
-0.0642637014,
-0.0208242703,
0.0096138837,
-0.0298372079,
0.0117481677,
-0.0462393202,
-0.0029302267,
-0.0023439035,
0.0335537344,
0.0085282903,
0.0359108336,
-0.0640390739,
-0.0247177277,
0.0577327274,
0.0007760896,
0.0167212225,
0.0080932034,
0.0089641027,
-0.0071304357,
0.0152939651,
-0.0332262889,
-0.0363273285,
0.0045564957,
0.0422823429,
-0.014325751,
-0.027603481,
0.0470412225,
-0.0087944921,
0.0403505154,
0.0222132765,
0.0184980892,
-0.0037125673,
0.0426852591,
0.0298655163,
0.0358803831,
-0.0196734983,
-0.0137584219,
0.01099962,
-0.0295395367,
-0.0698065013,
-0.0180939995,
-0.0386756435,
0.0042161737,
0.0448331386,
-0.0664877966,
-0.0393730476,
-0.0307580829,
0.0612568557,
-0.0109162154,
0.0005735853,
-0.0327734314,
-0.017184779,
-0.0188127384,
-0.0239872206,
0.0028237246,
0.0706618056,
-0.0480808169,
0.0283758305,
0.0715819523,
0.0179739483,
-0.0399752408,
0.0205242895,
0.0124160638,
-0.0210330337,
0.0032480054,
-0.0542082749,
-0.0497520231,
0.0729731768,
-0.0483610146,
-0.0211329684,
-0.0001285162,
-0.0388040207,
0.0511873811,
-0.0664801598,
0.028400708,
0.0279914103,
-0.0114430115,
0.0291846637,
0.0236909054,
-0.0610844716,
0.0265545193,
-0.0707841665,
0.0179190412,
0.03504939,
-0.0540000945,
-0.0477306508,
0.0172488466,
0.0030075971,
0.0353810154,
-0.0377012491,
0.0360270217,
0.0178431645,
0.0154473474,
0.0058595836,
-0.0198377147,
0.0236697998,
-0.0110438485,
0.0117115481,
-0.0249880329,
-0.0289008431,
0.0332113057,
0.0476082191,
-0.0088381357,
0.0100938734,
-0.0202532411,
-0.0307674445,
0.0077714473,
-0.0008408331,
0.0003338411,
-0.0279248804,
-0.0242173523,
-0.0090373997,
-0.0288326796,
-0.0042646518,
-0.023372164,
0.0100087253,
0.0848317146,
-0.0182851031,
0.0098476755,
0.0339192413,
0.001360032,
0.0345787071,
-0.0706197545,
-0.0277092233,
0.0626920089,
0.0140465815,
-0.0426003002,
0.0692508444,
0.0369360112,
-0.0462265611,
0.0021362179,
0.0280691832,
0.0084048137,
-0.0473522395,
0.0073914826,
-0.0255314894,
0.0691617131,
0.0227196626,
0.0596345961,
-0.0789372623,
-0.0464500301,
0.0510002449,
0.0297452305,
-0.0226942953,
0.012715036,
0.0032609473,
-0.0630432889,
0.0439831875,
0.0144937653,
0.044833824,
-0.0132863531,
-0.0860729218,
-0.0081600724,
0.009358908,
-0.019397188,
0.028023662,
-0.0072357929,
-0.0104598161,
-0.0118299276,
-0.0401430652,
-0.0063688974,
-0.0000872693,
0.0220182575,
0.0102078095,
0.0089974348,
-0.0134665538,
-0.0263486467,
-0.0360628366,
0.0500882939,
0.034134116,
0.0079156533,
-0.0753993616,
-0.0091034574,
0.0496318005,
0.0172235724,
-0.012828825,
0.0274389368,
0.0240028836,
-0.0100660222,
-0.0362046286,
0.0587012656,
-0.0333608575,
-0.0231646281,
-0.0176728088,
-0.0168502796,
-0.0232189,
0.0661028177,
0.0258138701,
0.0287607405,
-0.0614679605,
-0.0354500823,
-0.0504537672,
-0.0069624102,
0.0008261361,
-0.0135896401,
0.0041676559,
-0.0199976135,
0.0399784893,
0.0669018254,
-0.0300056804,
0.0115241427,
-0.015992092,
-0.0343340449,
-0.0251203608,
-0.0395488702,
-0.0856460631,
-0.0091414992,
-0.038179718,
0.0303313378,
-0.0338331126,
0.0339109935,
0.0410788842,
-0.0148925679,
0.0050528566,
0.0642895401,
-0.1389870942,
-0.0611313656,
-0.0506812669,
0.0713888183,
0.0228594672,
0.0573550984,
0.0330723077,
-0.0081731016,
0.046096243,
0.0614908338,
0.0024236457,
0.0864930376,
0.0055480367,
-0.0073678815,
0.0182334501,
0.008556135,
0.0054758224,
0.0091794133,
0.0166587085,
0.0218617301,
0.0087253572,
-0.0759266317,
-0.0553538278,
0.0683033764,
0.0165130198,
-0.0043944269,
-0.0365463719,
0.0303956997,
0.0723367631,
-0.0155505054,
0.0331019983,
-0.0341180749,
0.0090920124,
-0.0076837889,
-0.0330315754,
0.0069826399,
-0.0005097426,
0.0730878636,
0.0081698969,
0.0038057263,
0.0235917401,
-0.0253604893,
-0.0420670733,
0.0275668055,
-0.0115435598,
0.0041099726,
-0.0017654905,
0.0236689728,
0.0686169863,
-0.0314151831,
-0.0102064274,
-0.0179162659,
0.0487679429,
-0.0734723285,
0.0256680101,
-0.0094935279,
-0.057521712,
-0.0339447409,
0.0595591925,
0.0578873344,
0.0601194687,
0.0447545648,
-0.0238154829,
0.0023046411,
-0.0035373014,
0.0463757738,
-0.0059030238,
0.0417613797,
0.0542530306,
-0.0095538907,
-0.0174633451,
-0.0338173956,
0.0213728864,
0.0346477963,
0.0457238629,
-0.0323346071,
0.0239458792,
-0.0011324612,
-0.0619005486,
0.0044942992,
0.0050890199,
0.0248997174,
-0.0710151792,
-0.0460114665,
-0.0151675642,
0.0414901711,
0.0237659495,
-0.0142533807,
-0.031514518,
0.0051470078,
0.0416689999,
0.042684976,
-0.0374736935,
0.040490862,
-0.05934982,
0.005230905,
-0.016161127,
0.0549440272,
-6.446826851e-33,
-0.0434297211,
0.0044671046,
0.0197833516,
0.0169127584,
-0.0234272648,
-0.0297231823,
-0.02360834,
-0.0206929352,
0.0211313833,
-0.0218652375,
-0.0102497507,
0.0034369989,
0.0136349071,
-0.0271079484,
-0.0329305343,
-0.002459103,
0.0233706161,
0.0098240413,
-0.0323039405,
0.0015361762,
-0.0132200373,
0.0148315551,
0.0065062293,
-0.0069783325,
-0.0624464303,
0.0332837142,
0.0123713398,
-0.0139809679,
-0.0621274263,
0.0144032296,
-0.0269414019,
-0.0111522051,
-0.040194232,
-0.0126026766,
0.0003836256,
-0.0280573908,
-0.0457623713,
-0.019886801,
0.050638929,
-0.033767052,
0.0005579144,
-0.0960073769,
0.028112838,
0.0901624262,
-0.0490408465,
-0.0648455918,
-0.0199798681,
-0.0152168125,
-0.0125729609,
-0.0554176122,
-0.0146928905,
0.0077353185,
0.0288620703,
0.0418155752,
0.0289976969,
-0.0212522838,
-0.0456209481,
0.0230658371,
-0.0082571795,
-0.0003941711,
0.0492313094,
0.0434930846,
0.1050013602,
0.0111695314,
0.016401777,
0.0141246747,
0.0004423477,
-0.0311202426,
-0.0543969646,
0.0090579875,
0.0132947387,
0.0624237359,
0.0123483129,
0.0204529092,
0.0343001783,
0.0141938962,
-0.108773388,
0.0379815921,
0.0435468405,
0.0379652269,
0.0056638294,
0.0063987202,
0.0147956703,
-0.0209666267,
-0.0054729092,
0.0124987271,
-0.0120780086,
-0.0272832382,
-0.0207959395,
0.0027896271,
-0.0531040058,
-0.0364660844,
0.0273607522,
-0.0412917249,
0.0252600275,
-0.0017141309,
0.011739905,
-0.0139470482,
0.0380611457,
0.0272489469,
-0.0209381115,
-0.0298140757,
-0.033442799,
-0.0411158763,
0.0504364185,
-0.0175541341,
-0.009509298,
0.043295186,
-0.0506377146,
0.0056650871,
-0.0409560688,
-0.038030874,
0.0202995073,
-0.0119020287,
0.0310184024,
-0.0096555604,
0.0178444572,
0.0030539015,
-0.0136436112,
0.0202919692,
0.0014040377,
0.0108239893,
0.0315302312,
0.0551229008,
-0.0269905962,
0.0071919248,
-0.0428283848,
0.001524722,
0.0046931482,
-0.0477206483,
-0.0555170439,
0.0543060414,
2.806e-7,
0.0283714775,
0.01306675,
0.0044504022,
0.0620245896,
-0.0065875067,
-0.0042096414,
0.0002676515,
-0.0152298659,
0.0034271611,
-0.0408377275,
0.0231380463,
0.0334092267,
0.0467832275,
-0.0207582768,
0.0085494155,
0.0101715801,
0.0021527286,
0.0072577507,
-0.0197169054,
-0.0746593997,
-0.0066724415,
0.0641626567,
0.0015771559,
-0.0321400575,
0.0266160984,
-0.0008870416,
0.0273095947,
-0.0360223129,
0.0087354351,
0.0122002466,
-0.0009570579,
-0.0280050151,
-0.0409188345,
-0.0128652751,
0.006892255,
0.0050587943,
-0.06788674,
0.078820914,
0.0394212566,
-0.036376927,
0.031873215,
-0.023728257,
-0.0168273617,
0.0135298157,
0.0719128102,
0.047362525,
-0.0124084139,
-0.0481884517,
0.0044731409,
-0.0477776304,
-0.005261343,
-0.0183708239,
0.0949575305,
0.0164971221,
-0.0305803493,
-0.0184247214,
-0.0128042568,
-0.0328712948,
-0.0539165847,
0.0014874297,
-0.0332881995,
-0.059680786,
-0.0387367494,
0.0352389105,
-0.0023968539,
-0.0558343679,
-0.0456791744,
3.223409385e-34,
0.0167511348,
-0.0156091694,
-0.0020806163,
0.1048395336,
-0.0194181968,
-0.0337367766,
-0.051441595,
-0.0054677683,
-0.0442681126,
-0.0748832226,
-0.0137019223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01158v1 | LLM-Detector: Improving AI-Generated Chinese Text Detection with Open-Source LLM Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-02T05:54:12 | 2024-02-02T05:54:12 | Rongsheng Wang, Haoming Chen, Ruizhe Zhou, Han Ma, Yaofei Duan, Yanlan Kang, Songhua Yang, Baoyu Fan, Tao Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT and other general large language models (LLMs) have achieved
remarkable success, but they have also raised concerns about the misuse of
AI-generated texts. Existing AI-generated text detection models, such as based
on BERT and RoBERTa, are prone to in-domain over-fitting, leading to poor
out-of-domain (OOD) detection performance. In this paper, we first collected
Chinese text responses generated by human experts and 9 types of LLMs, for
which to multiple domains questions, and further created a dataset that mixed
human-written sentences and sentences polished by LLMs. We then proposed
LLM-Detector, a novel method for both document-level and sentence-level text
detection through Instruction Tuning of LLMs. Our method leverages the wealth
of knowledge LLMs acquire during pre-training, enabling them to detect the text
they generate. Instruction tuning aligns the model's responses with the user's
expected text detection tasks. Experimental results show that previous methods
struggle with sentence-level AI-generated text detection and OOD detection. In
contrast, our proposed method not only significantly outperforms baseline
methods in both sentence-level and document-level text detection but also
demonstrates strong generalization capabilities. Furthermore, since
LLM-Detector is trained based on open-source LLMs, it is easy to customize for
deployment. | [
0.0227789246,
0.0111030517,
0.0159936193,
0.0717961341,
-0.0207956191,
0.0105359629,
-0.0193896554,
0.0405045599,
0.0549752228,
-0.0301934667,
-0.0553553477,
-0.0254987795,
-0.0286315773,
0.0191211607,
-0.0075589949,
0.0095054926,
0.0236635413,
0.0000921749,
-0.0116840405,
0.039193999,
0.0517133586,
-0.0006728663,
0.0114646889,
0.0231179725,
0.0053316341,
-0.047107093,
-0.0024360844,
0.0541284233,
0.053298153,
-0.0393994972,
0.0478715301,
0.024500614,
0.0117325885,
0.0488463379,
0.0000018303,
-0.0412080698,
-0.0393988006,
-0.0100319441,
-0.0149603998,
0.0382857881,
0.0523031913,
0.0001812425,
-0.0284945313,
0.048586823,
-0.032578703,
0.0194131732,
0.0017590349,
0.0973031074,
0.0298245214,
0.1071598604,
-0.0189724527,
0.0290575176,
0.0504535809,
0.003488061,
0.0023881192,
-0.0482858494,
0.0353732891,
-0.0025129924,
-0.00701256,
-0.0013391008,
0.0021604756,
-0.0002583041,
0.0034477343,
-0.0139849419,
-0.0235236287,
0.0195117127,
-0.0280944519,
0.0067694997,
-0.0508535542,
0.0772878975,
-0.0380583145,
-0.0253879409,
0.025316231,
-0.0145384446,
0.0228201002,
-0.0100822747,
-0.0087365108,
0.0267168134,
-0.0450083986,
0.0192594714,
-0.0069105946,
-0.030905094,
0.0043616402,
0.057716351,
-0.0221547671,
0.0255852379,
0.0116041442,
-0.0583871715,
-0.0050164214,
0.0017040338,
-0.0496104434,
-0.0249136128,
0.090572156,
0.0328258835,
-0.0037110737,
-0.0039015466,
-0.0601495393,
-0.0380923301,
0.006376022,
-0.0422956087,
0.0280499738,
0.0216729399,
-0.0576764606,
0.0318036824,
-0.0636815876,
0.0582822338,
-0.0544980168,
0.0148453824,
-0.0535107553,
0.0032337152,
-0.0020823388,
-0.0188996363,
-0.0490454882,
0.0131029775,
-0.0460759588,
-0.055125203,
-0.0216236543,
0.0250195283,
0.0328786224,
-0.0250538196,
-0.0034809061,
-0.0133907981,
-0.023211021,
-0.0375377499,
0.0233849864,
0.0202983562,
-0.0098611349,
0.0285427477,
-0.0039633517,
-0.0492693745,
-0.0259354431,
0.0760331452,
0.0431221686,
0.0002633941,
0.025488684,
0.0563899428,
-0.0200925097,
-0.0659988672,
-0.0312451832,
-0.0032325839,
-0.0194252227,
-0.0266126432,
0.0247073174,
-0.0472603776,
-0.0342073105,
-0.0182000753,
0.0347689725,
-0.0000128957,
0.0185649488,
0.0384664834,
0.0058413465,
0.0271511823,
-0.0175795984,
-0.0046943221,
0.0183953345,
-0.0011962993,
0.0036641702,
0.0630978718,
0.0316140465,
0.061163649,
0.055458568,
0.0281417929,
0.036022149,
0.0775490031,
-0.0265597254,
0.0141582098,
0.0159875229,
0.0124263633,
-0.0147869522,
0.0025379627,
0.0400021411,
0.0184965469,
-0.0074167168,
0.0070026955,
0.0702777281,
0.0287046693,
-0.0040933285,
-0.0024594578,
0.0154439546,
0.0705981553,
0.0040999972,
0.0472144596,
-0.007460569,
-0.0158362091,
-0.038959723,
-0.0004055249,
-0.0025140622,
0.0323234573,
-0.010281885,
-0.0394524597,
-0.0283783432,
-0.0126213981,
-0.0253871921,
0.0095664375,
0.0499148294,
0.0107547715,
-0.0604379699,
-0.0101339035,
0.0060543492,
-0.0352766328,
-0.0000592013,
-0.0510794222,
0.0327240489,
0.0602486804,
0.0500973202,
-0.031021215,
0.0120458351,
-0.0052024606,
0.0328426659,
0.1049672142,
0.0148512637,
0.0204116385,
-0.0158684254,
-0.0652711615,
-0.0305909384,
0.0156085379,
0.0085402373,
0.0245652236,
0.0538169257,
0.0095417378,
0.0215415247,
-0.0511428304,
-0.042641744,
0.0762572661,
-0.0321449414,
-0.0263703857,
-0.0062771658,
0.0008998619,
0.0005365232,
0.0090421122,
-0.0349756628,
0.0070833685,
0.0206169542,
-0.046155747,
-0.0273881461,
-0.0285385828,
-0.0256654005,
-0.05418244,
0.0134974243,
-0.0410308689,
-0.0318703689,
0.0328394473,
-0.0385551415,
-0.0134832915,
-0.0481566079,
-0.0237639379,
0.0000727883,
-0.078793861,
0.0324809477,
-0.0034010399,
0.0359494947,
-0.015640052,
0.0519272126,
-0.0065224185,
-0.0181072745,
0.0283926334,
0.0082597788,
0.0440146774,
-0.0242705401,
-0.0263786744,
-0.0231313333,
-0.0331059098,
0.0311191585,
0.028521115,
0.0620705821,
-0.0348113626,
-0.0278165601,
-0.0982368663,
0.0483932346,
-0.0467883386,
0.0139766475,
0.0428925082,
-0.0011866761,
-0.045555491,
-0.0205892418,
-0.0174044017,
-0.0212276671,
0.0024756372,
-0.0187738072,
0.0305523016,
-0.0566252097,
0.0164516866,
-0.024283994,
0.0214437097,
-0.025477523,
-0.0031064698,
0.0117360931,
-0.0583242066,
-0.0697666928,
0.0290890783,
0.0361230746,
0.0213396717,
0.0026722145,
-0.0687871873,
-0.0183496885,
-0.0132063162,
0.0494399779,
0.1012550816,
0.0142807877,
-0.0124163684,
0.0213772617,
0.0448102541,
-0.0313823894,
0.042211514,
0.022184303,
-0.0051153665,
-0.0084443744,
-0.0215002596,
0.0531757772,
0.062678054,
0.0079163332,
0.0086667053,
-0.0151655897,
-0.0457912013,
-0.0293558259,
-0.0406931825,
-0.0232338365,
-0.0065776799,
-0.058595188,
0.0081664026,
-0.0379360244,
-0.0479335599,
0.0364347212,
-0.0293648411,
-0.0133583536,
-0.0833453387,
-0.0100834416,
-0.0450938791,
0.0026290908,
0.007704251,
0.0150822327,
0.0067852894,
-0.0225041583,
-0.0374184772,
0.016170932,
-0.0249807779,
-0.0241549797,
0.0382401347,
-0.0128033468,
0.0015430734,
-0.0228312425,
-0.0234730057,
-0.0553957708,
-0.0436651669,
-0.0343135782,
-0.0114537785,
0.0111732334,
-0.0304003078,
-0.0026990909,
0.0105446065,
-0.0019157898,
0.0795152113,
-0.0348328277,
0.0108569423,
-0.0377223641,
0.0748234466,
0.05341883,
-0.0065025105,
0.0012420577,
-0.0474888086,
0.047444813,
0.0547953323,
0.0117284907,
-0.0060127005,
0.0143509889,
-0.0135881836,
0.0189655274,
-0.0087104309,
0.0023430239,
0.0183033738,
0.0634754747,
-0.062765047,
-0.0081790555,
0.1140012741,
0.0204322618,
-0.0267358813,
-0.0295208972,
-0.0125491759,
0.009133636,
0.0063118571,
-0.0026958429,
-0.075784795,
-0.0733459145,
0.0175184142,
-0.0223987326,
0.0037840419,
0.0274426565,
0.0017680967,
-0.1141003221,
0.0256892666,
0.0085677924,
0.0052845906,
-0.0225110948,
0.0236222483,
0.0307998657,
0.024445083,
0.0056846715,
-0.0184192397,
-0.0367812328,
-0.0185742751,
0.0006837146,
-0.016520815,
-0.0193624645,
-0.0007229003,
-0.0529669598,
-0.0073479456,
0.0981509238,
0.066225253,
0.0019192745,
-0.0072742468,
0.0638439059,
-0.0222286582,
0.0031331719,
0.0058495384,
0.049331475,
-0.0163817406,
0.0004934549,
-0.0144928042,
0.0375417583,
-0.0397522599,
0.014207989,
0.0798932984,
0.0202531032,
0.0079802265,
-0.0496638529,
-0.0388393737,
0.0146434316,
-0.0098928325,
0.108455494,
0.0227578133,
-0.0657275096,
-0.0580866374,
-0.0221474804,
-0.0160371363,
-0.0836663246,
-0.0047607799,
0.033329308,
-0.0492384396,
-0.0015746241,
-0.0887826681,
-0.0152621679,
0.0087980069,
-0.0120610446,
0.01108771,
-0.0030250691,
-0.0126450788,
0.0423701219,
-0.0256217178,
0.0061378167,
-0.0398624763,
0.0154034188,
-0.0833875388,
0.0204855055,
0.0180961583,
-0.0584613308,
-0.0105003156,
0.0457161069,
-0.0697949976,
-0.0318605416,
-0.0042880517,
-0.0213151313,
0.0091867317,
0.0124034034,
-0.0343499072,
-0.0144050559,
0.0628509521,
0.0366460532,
-0.0323686786,
0.0026010599,
0.0240588691,
0.0039261631,
-0.0300872289,
0.0173624512,
-0.0272065531,
0.0336902067,
0.0283878054,
0.0019020338,
-0.0209468603,
-0.0127551798,
0.0162952077,
0.0029104676,
0.0302925892,
0.0025046603,
-0.0016838118,
-0.0531200804,
0.012338588,
0.0173879545,
-0.0202053897,
-0.0544191711,
0.0195360389,
0.055130396,
-0.0098568751,
-0.0212440174,
0.0630675629,
-0.0088360477,
0.0192202237,
-0.0263872854,
0.0314026847,
0.0067287716,
0.051887814,
0.0185490698,
-0.0241256915,
0.0017765583,
0.0336352289,
0.0001793245,
0.016103385,
0.0207764041,
0.0814941302,
0.0037553546,
-0.0336380787,
0.0259686504,
0.0177599229,
-0.0427866206,
-0.0051831505,
-0.0565231554,
0.0648162812,
0.0694498122,
-0.0074071349,
0.0504305288,
-0.0403882787,
-0.0064145289,
-0.0401152298,
0.0082612429,
0.0024275817,
-0.0097139115,
-0.0041960636,
-6.177e-7,
-0.0381727926,
-0.0578930601,
0.0841281712,
0.042249497,
0.0526786856,
0.0328617394,
-0.0305515397,
-0.0534724481,
-0.0128925173,
0.0517067052,
0.0129688289,
-0.0118711498,
0.0494264662,
-0.0167770609,
-0.0299245864,
-0.0080870651,
-0.0275920518,
-0.019322155,
-0.0114570362,
-0.0010035385,
0.0455298983,
-0.0188409202,
-0.0180172753,
-0.0183378775,
-0.003772585,
-0.0289251655,
-0.016637899,
-0.0182901658,
-5.935414809e-33,
-0.0091119464,
-0.0496554449,
-0.0121704172,
-0.0126262698,
0.0087258741,
0.0251480397,
-0.0187098179,
-0.0325485915,
-0.0226648562,
0.0096210707,
-0.025427537,
0.0427950434,
0.0314553827,
0.031191973,
-0.0426783152,
-0.0160766114,
0.0610208809,
-0.0268034283,
-0.0242994726,
-0.0046190205,
0.0044909497,
0.0440789498,
0.0431369171,
-0.0394764431,
-0.0135527905,
-0.0288899578,
-0.0293035842,
0.0296424348,
0.0078820586,
0.0705476403,
-0.0286306813,
0.041301813,
0.0513821766,
0.0169437118,
-0.0123209571,
0.084234558,
-0.0824334025,
-0.0005151151,
-0.0166024845,
0.0198228993,
-0.0031880937,
-0.0448799767,
0.0157467388,
-0.022157507,
0.0208407119,
0.0064905495,
0.0684868768,
-0.0523802638,
0.0145820258,
-0.0241646133,
-0.0576021522,
0.0404502898,
0.0128153842,
-0.0310403816,
0.0005115276,
0.0567932874,
-0.0022062778,
0.023626728,
-0.0274272598,
0.005124507,
0.0326803848,
0.0397141539,
0.0002532449,
0.0382746533,
-0.0045167021,
0.0302981362,
0.0013565276,
0.0190185457,
-0.0053814175,
-0.0562047027,
0.0199410431,
0.0137236547,
0.0249718651,
0.0612588823,
0.0378388576,
-0.001596329,
-0.0632795915,
0.0367303528,
0.0262924079,
0.0045056427,
0.038842082,
0.0074690809,
-0.0747550055,
0.0067914431,
0.0188201517,
-0.0242354181,
-0.0434615128,
-0.0040957155,
0.0465526171,
0.0513571799,
-0.0386041477,
-0.0261450894,
0.0308692269,
-0.042392157,
0.0189043544,
0.0150024649,
-0.0125591066,
-0.0079202717,
-0.0056649116,
0.0307210218,
-0.0561121628,
-0.0469625145,
0.0156583488,
0.0092538288,
-0.0200857148,
-0.010521004,
0.0478363186,
-0.0151300766,
-0.079275772,
0.0227761399,
-0.030560296,
-0.0113761779,
0.0291191153,
0.0566320978,
0.0114767579,
-0.0271262955,
-0.0070735132,
0.0452929102,
0.0267087147,
0.0092754848,
-0.0592648871,
-0.042710159,
-0.04685954,
0.0159440022,
-0.0368290283,
0.0320396647,
-0.0182976127,
0.0051303571,
0.0233824067,
-0.0659419224,
0.0025940321,
-0.0093792425,
2.372e-7,
0.0389716811,
0.0126971081,
0.0389003828,
0.0371815227,
0.0010161611,
0.0505676568,
-0.0085439263,
0.0433076657,
0.0020794312,
0.0148126706,
0.022770904,
0.0174289774,
0.0867712945,
-0.0313263014,
-0.1183006465,
0.0097506382,
-0.0213125721,
0.0029477356,
-0.0552032776,
-0.0191272795,
0.0240805633,
0.0713851228,
-0.0276588071,
-0.011726669,
0.0092454301,
-0.1026429385,
0.0469418541,
-0.0200680066,
0.0190414563,
0.0410443395,
0.0311947055,
0.0448042713,
-0.0240097176,
0.0054299003,
-0.0079183094,
0.0352055319,
0.0589626804,
0.0847561806,
0.0242140573,
0.007562214,
0.007288767,
-0.0039934237,
0.0101152118,
-0.0293760542,
0.0623833388,
-0.0208010189,
0.0005893372,
-0.0281204693,
0.0203915965,
-0.0721394047,
-0.0099847969,
-0.0362571552,
-0.0223179068,
0.0333052985,
0.0271466523,
-0.0212582685,
-0.0226757582,
-0.0616948642,
-0.0559495501,
-0.0335930511,
-0.0529691838,
-0.0272423308,
-0.0713246688,
0.0196778513,
0.013372384,
-0.0757245123,
0.0209363867,
2.102926103e-34,
0.0183536001,
-0.0302751008,
-0.0286182184,
0.0491431803,
0.0435485393,
-0.0108613707,
-0.0003943018,
-0.0238290876,
-0.0082042469,
-0.0648832917,
0.013012832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01155v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01155v3 | CABINET: Content Relevance based Noise Reduction for Table Question Answering | 2024-02-02T05:48:39 | 2024-02-13T09:11:01 | Sohan Patnaik, Heril Changwal, Milan Aggarwal, Sumit Bhatia, Yaman Kumar, Balaji Krishnamurthy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table understanding capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) has been
extensively studied through the task of question-answering (QA) over tables.
Typically, only a small part of the whole table is relevant to derive the
answer for a given question. The irrelevant parts act as noise and are
distracting information, resulting in sub-optimal performance due to the
vulnerability of LLMs to noise. To mitigate this, we propose CABINET (Content
RelevAnce-Based NoIse ReductioN for TablE QuesTion-Answering) - a framework to
enable LLMs to focus on relevant tabular data by suppressing extraneous
information. CABINET comprises an Unsupervised Relevance Scorer (URS), trained
differentially with the QA LLM, that weighs the table content based on its
relevance to the input question before feeding it to the question-answering LLM
(QA LLM). To further aid the relevance scorer, CABINET employs a weakly
supervised module that generates a parsing statement describing the criteria of
rows and columns relevant to the question and highlights the content of
corresponding table cells. CABINET significantly outperforms various tabular
LLM baselines, as well as GPT3-based in-context learning methods, is more
robust to noise, maintains outperformance on tables of varying sizes, and
establishes new SoTA performance on WikiTQ, FeTaQA, and WikiSQL datasets. We
release our code and datasets at https://github.com/Sohanpatnaik106/CABINET_QA. | [
0.0335045978,
0.0733161569,
0.0127885481,
0.0324277654,
-0.0126621481,
0.0370534211,
-0.0386130661,
0.01413792,
-0.0133369127,
-0.0083941184,
-0.0565246828,
-0.0002562847,
-0.0274597034,
-0.0054872138,
0.0415666401,
0.0348047875,
0.0633894131,
0.0055669383,
-0.0305981264,
0.0088453097,
-0.0021330209,
-0.0168790091,
-0.0095172189,
0.0176937655,
-0.0149254492,
-0.0145234307,
-0.0184064731,
-0.0022782851,
-0.0434934907,
0.0125644635,
0.0369695835,
0.0926543176,
0.0105233239,
0.0323047042,
0.0000019599,
0.0062667923,
-0.0361059606,
-0.0114656268,
-0.0368273184,
-0.0057154498,
0.0130427433,
-0.0152663523,
0.0198291931,
-0.0040752562,
-0.0526197664,
-0.0072085648,
0.010970545,
0.0442338921,
0.0494148917,
0.0327752531,
0.027688494,
-0.0199719053,
0.0025523149,
-0.0069784434,
0.0811423063,
-0.0917041525,
0.0163818784,
0.0254068263,
-0.0015570971,
-0.0028800841,
-0.0103066526,
0.0547713675,
0.0300911516,
-0.019582713,
-0.0037526099,
0.0331615135,
-0.0443119034,
0.047779426,
0.024485616,
0.118739903,
0.0367342979,
-0.0312195793,
0.0011303463,
0.0251938794,
0.0407500565,
-0.0437146202,
-0.0556815155,
-0.0181433689,
0.0124202054,
-0.0112083163,
-0.0015112621,
-0.0128077324,
0.0050171362,
0.0073361928,
-0.014697643,
0.0737869963,
-0.017662039,
-0.045237612,
0.01304112,
-0.0099304626,
-0.0218882617,
-0.0183347557,
0.0045061046,
0.0676338375,
-0.0509938076,
0.0260162447,
0.0138220536,
-0.0325576551,
0.0185012724,
-0.0641025826,
-0.0194054469,
0.0370705165,
-0.0035247912,
0.0418198928,
-0.0206477735,
0.0092961546,
-0.0210504383,
0.0218156539,
-0.0596565567,
-0.0510596782,
-0.0273116175,
-0.0112699773,
-0.0540390015,
0.0430381969,
-0.0777910575,
-0.0251294058,
0.0081393067,
-0.0030286273,
-0.0007701258,
0.013327131,
0.0212702695,
0.0506124608,
-0.0206728522,
0.0074961972,
-0.0119333491,
0.0221311357,
-0.0292974133,
0.0044312999,
-0.0322025903,
-0.063864395,
-0.0339271016,
-0.0188980438,
0.0138601298,
-0.0318721272,
0.0542454757,
0.0565688051,
-0.0337567627,
-0.0209788941,
-0.0208098385,
-0.0048083249,
-0.0222245902,
-0.0598304421,
-0.0248422511,
-0.0337683558,
0.036720328,
0.0136109358,
0.017204674,
-0.0598400757,
0.0116614485,
0.0648999438,
-0.0091109425,
0.0613196343,
0.0174057893,
0.0278571323,
0.0282471534,
0.0046251286,
-0.0209255461,
0.0851047784,
0.0097642988,
-0.007308952,
-0.0205793176,
-0.0311778542,
-0.0335497223,
0.0306668952,
0.059962038,
0.0002014996,
-0.0013412578,
0.0806246549,
0.0284134708,
0.0229802039,
0.0163976029,
0.0117635438,
-0.0055724224,
0.0159962215,
0.0325508006,
0.0351947844,
-0.0050140172,
0.07084959,
0.00258883,
0.0157039203,
0.0245664399,
0.0299617145,
-0.031623181,
0.0354152098,
-0.0121606756,
-0.0044757663,
0.0544203855,
-0.0164850671,
-0.0266303476,
-0.0482852198,
0.0169680398,
0.0025049609,
-0.0276089739,
0.0417000577,
0.0283772424,
0.027607182,
-0.0570355915,
0.0274396446,
0.0005164141,
-0.0433072336,
-0.0088642975,
-0.0294564385,
0.0541504361,
0.04725793,
0.0431795083,
-0.0711218491,
-0.0087627927,
0.0004736214,
0.0420936905,
0.0009778554,
-0.0094428966,
-0.0285298061,
0.0299517289,
0.0048118867,
-0.0268723369,
0.024657879,
0.0283577479,
-0.043293573,
0.0306019075,
-0.0044036251,
0.0018847649,
-0.0723581761,
-0.009662359,
0.0183303747,
0.0601014979,
-0.0450106375,
0.0035543242,
0.0032367557,
0.0189917088,
0.0215452556,
0.0161049869,
0.0154217994,
0.0366890356,
-0.0101291863,
0.044593364,
-0.0232051555,
-0.0273571722,
-0.0080342805,
0.0205160994,
0.0459836721,
-0.0666444302,
0.0017914667,
-0.0415647998,
-0.0273764133,
0.024424769,
-0.04633734,
-0.037317697,
-0.0431166217,
-0.0263736118,
0.0271683633,
0.0410819724,
-0.0227337312,
0.0790506601,
-0.0118279587,
0.0407198407,
0.0295003243,
-0.0607898124,
0.0226652008,
-0.0385518596,
0.026039999,
-0.0454323292,
-0.0365526639,
0.0368398838,
0.0054594856,
0.0382487215,
-0.0639878511,
-0.0154811451,
-0.0874894336,
0.0300780907,
-0.0518103167,
0.0258821473,
0.0375952125,
0.0261781737,
-0.0119661754,
-0.0417117067,
-0.044698406,
-0.0006924077,
0.0139454491,
-0.0008823997,
0.0483721271,
0.0087056756,
0.0102323564,
-0.0494753011,
-0.0309924427,
-0.0095180608,
0.032739073,
-0.0347975977,
-0.0266713332,
-0.0088561904,
-0.02403263,
-0.0029546532,
0.0295109469,
0.0236081649,
-0.0160372108,
-0.0204276592,
-0.0306571163,
0.0322034247,
0.0415081978,
-0.041559644,
0.0175902173,
0.0091408715,
-0.0209331345,
-0.0553433411,
0.0403070487,
-0.0179358833,
0.0050541428,
-0.0108300624,
-0.0470172651,
0.0530331694,
0.0250218902,
-0.0041485387,
-0.008366189,
-0.0374965928,
0.0166006684,
0.0166824218,
-0.0084877862,
-0.1075479016,
0.0650621653,
-0.001460374,
-0.0049309898,
-0.0235292148,
0.0020477676,
0.0108222757,
-0.0255970154,
0.0068781921,
-0.0420105048,
0.0091068996,
-0.0556524582,
0.0578178093,
-0.0001298947,
-0.0053659417,
-0.0470272265,
-0.0429260544,
-0.0432437249,
-0.0389954187,
-0.0213740412,
-0.0491512939,
0.0834744647,
-0.0477492921,
0.0320020653,
-0.0014860781,
-0.0125707835,
-0.0133347819,
-0.0414513722,
-0.0107359048,
0.0233849753,
0.0092036799,
0.0122951912,
-0.0289902687,
-0.019501958,
0.0407775342,
0.0434606336,
-0.0143296467,
-0.0174649525,
-0.0277624372,
0.0756025985,
0.0502604768,
0.0501267463,
-0.0298878904,
0.0188861359,
0.0381797664,
0.0492105968,
-0.0036919499,
-0.0424393564,
0.0021063611,
0.0271664876,
0.0423295759,
-0.0203639474,
-0.0059841219,
0.033743538,
0.0019239885,
-0.054516159,
-0.0386002921,
0.0810045227,
0.0196965449,
0.0062647909,
-0.0145188253,
-0.0127055524,
0.0180552024,
0.0136647234,
0.0646906942,
-0.0594646782,
-0.0415299647,
-0.002431693,
0.0092414515,
0.0319739245,
-0.0429502875,
-0.0289615039,
-0.0967212021,
0.0350915454,
-0.0519100614,
-0.0724935681,
-0.0915471166,
-0.0133673931,
0.0115876375,
-0.0336791836,
0.0488813743,
0.064693138,
-0.0206031092,
0.0296487231,
0.0289260279,
-0.025908323,
-0.0472613983,
-0.0240566619,
-0.0404923335,
0.02219899,
0.0613454022,
0.0072568227,
-0.0242810491,
-0.008690699,
0.0070870239,
-0.0301023182,
-0.0028368908,
-0.014469862,
0.0521731526,
0.0050930697,
-0.0102896029,
-0.0308992099,
0.0030234782,
-0.0250996947,
0.0133531559,
0.0489355251,
0.0608691573,
-0.0368037485,
0.0100201322,
0.0276214723,
-0.002434222,
0.0064111105,
0.0895714462,
0.065711081,
-0.0012677051,
-0.0330986865,
-0.0126657328,
-0.0554645248,
-0.0446488969,
0.0246220324,
0.0378811322,
0.0167137329,
0.0093840603,
-0.0506946445,
-0.0311468672,
0.0612370111,
-0.0046831141,
-0.0143695474,
0.0950025842,
-0.0839529186,
0.007903371,
-0.0441164449,
-0.0102042574,
-0.0843200982,
-0.0101394635,
-0.0289053824,
-0.0201358721,
0.018325692,
-0.0566057302,
-0.0309974235,
0.0264490955,
-0.0592423789,
0.0057328213,
-0.0152286263,
0.0191460997,
0.0144044813,
0.0092558488,
-0.0062642233,
-0.0275882985,
-0.0187952369,
0.0117538441,
-0.0695435926,
-0.0076848273,
0.0048897308,
-0.0479572527,
0.0028565747,
0.0495667942,
-0.044622153,
-0.0041065291,
0.0155198406,
0.0515046306,
-0.0040569114,
-0.0007306509,
0.0492628179,
-0.0049169483,
-0.0076754466,
0.0562082417,
-0.0538570881,
-0.0071509681,
0.0429842845,
-0.0167841502,
-0.0269458629,
-0.0033738809,
0.0002369272,
0.0246251561,
-0.0244994834,
-0.0331899598,
0.0043956474,
0.011157521,
0.04369184,
-0.0376059376,
-0.0023514701,
0.0288887061,
-0.0437686257,
-0.0019334853,
-0.0343591273,
-0.0097372439,
-0.0160793513,
0.0330249332,
0.0192357376,
-0.0112435063,
-0.0222166032,
0.0115641719,
-0.0537897684,
-0.0209239516,
0.0425574966,
-0.0634751692,
-0.0404226333,
-0.0299903732,
0.028418513,
0.0251296293,
-0.0031406772,
0.0026582966,
-0.0101921335,
-0.0191841368,
0.0054195207,
0.0001639457,
0.0359285958,
0.0119226426,
0.0531616956,
0.0119038671,
-0.0016564574,
-0.0109272366,
0.0860134363,
0.0536390617,
0.0388288945,
0.0096885329,
-0.0194979273,
-0.0636560395,
-0.015205591,
-0.0120047824,
0.018747801,
-0.0510733873,
0.0263198335,
0.0092805214,
-0.0320619196,
0.0125434799,
0.0224343929,
-0.0566860661,
-0.0112472316,
0.0417252071,
0.05502275,
0.0499186404,
-0.0343010612,
-0.0295558199,
0.0273257419,
-0.0074690795,
-0.0395801701,
-0.0167584028,
-6.524030381e-33,
-0.0398600996,
-0.0212589484,
0.0142018311,
-0.0312389657,
0.0184630174,
-0.0052897809,
-0.0561563186,
-0.0366127752,
-0.0288049784,
-0.0180405714,
-0.0422579311,
0.0695654973,
0.0161046553,
0.0113921929,
0.0002651879,
-0.0815051273,
0.024316363,
-0.0084963925,
0.0180441272,
0.0329613201,
-0.0235647932,
0.0443820879,
0.0374044143,
-0.0090578012,
0.0414669663,
-0.0164356455,
-0.0191959236,
-0.0047912928,
-0.0131142456,
0.0411266088,
-0.0491746254,
0.0437107198,
0.0385446623,
-0.0416927263,
-0.0394466408,
0.0149276946,
-0.1657097787,
-0.013873063,
0.015333523,
0.0166254546,
-0.0213009603,
-0.044092387,
0.0312910415,
-0.0016065118,
-0.0160280429,
-0.0084441891,
0.0278973505,
-0.0366459005,
0.005709745,
0.0101299053,
-0.0136202183,
0.0058920151,
-0.028185131,
0.0006433654,
0.0254226532,
0.0417504571,
0.0095321201,
-0.0023403871,
-0.0481639616,
0.0027621102,
-0.0112153785,
0.0585704222,
0.0297161508,
-0.0349433236,
0.0024603594,
-0.0109831123,
0.0104209129,
-0.0316809751,
-0.0201022904,
-0.0585211553,
-0.0530874133,
0.0378742404,
0.085768804,
0.037917383,
0.0579679161,
0.0185136646,
-0.0907522216,
0.0738360435,
-0.0244585276,
0.0369761102,
-0.0086053088,
-0.0314637907,
-0.0232326221,
0.0030301909,
-0.0304307397,
0.0347612165,
-0.0421981141,
-0.0041204095,
0.0398264974,
-0.0204412676,
0.0179170575,
-0.0284318551,
0.0169833228,
-0.0182213504,
-0.004433746,
0.0835803598,
0.0074669672,
-0.0184833184,
0.035471715,
0.0116399871,
-0.0096655861,
-0.0034780449,
0.0273377113,
-0.0376920253,
0.0160450209,
0.016894117,
0.0314888433,
0.0172100123,
-0.0488646552,
-0.0097137829,
-0.0295654293,
0.0729927719,
-0.0203599371,
0.0266342387,
0.016442515,
-0.002147696,
0.0078188609,
0.0379829668,
0.0217757225,
0.0269537009,
-0.0016656048,
-0.0255604666,
-0.0086549576,
0.0021173174,
-0.0057943952,
0.0361645035,
-0.0227533132,
0.0394303948,
-0.0207824036,
-0.0230380036,
0.0050189458,
0.0285536647,
2.509e-7,
0.0998430178,
0.0075006606,
0.0446682498,
0.035560064,
-0.0127213616,
-0.0110244118,
-0.0113918874,
0.007759924,
-0.0152133564,
-0.0188413896,
0.0526575781,
0.0145906666,
0.0699245036,
0.0086917272,
-0.0359631255,
-0.0222353898,
-0.0801192224,
0.0060621491,
-0.0313970745,
0.0025298533,
0.0385390632,
0.1037571728,
-0.0661692247,
-0.0096473033,
-0.0270977262,
-0.0519289188,
0.0323467851,
-0.0658598915,
0.0547967553,
0.0149696898,
0.0437021516,
-0.0334933959,
0.0316606201,
0.0299081523,
-0.0245727729,
0.0048822789,
0.0220382512,
0.0446816422,
0.0277687982,
0.0136027243,
-0.0097370446,
-0.0493819229,
0.0526349731,
-0.0751856193,
0.1276053041,
-0.0430095047,
-0.0046431078,
0.0663257092,
0.0048480695,
-0.0163353514,
0.0144935194,
0.0015460473,
-0.0134410728,
-0.0080150357,
0.036838375,
-0.0052988045,
0.011692551,
-0.050675571,
-0.0144487293,
0.0074454029,
-0.0361219384,
-0.0140874749,
-0.0172586422,
-0.0478030108,
-0.0284002963,
-0.0366747975,
-0.0116001954,
2.118011231e-34,
0.0401614532,
-0.000095247,
0.0457888544,
0.0497093685,
0.0368635468,
-0.0103108063,
0.0031637826,
-0.0234536063,
0.0258310568,
-0.1044400409,
-0.0103017129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01152v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01152v2 | AccentFold: A Journey through African Accents for Zero-Shot ASR Adaptation to Target Accents | 2024-02-02T05:38:59 | 2024-02-05T05:45:59 | Abraham Toluwase Owodunni, Aditya Yadavalli, Chris Chinenye Emezue, Tobi Olatunji, Clinton C Mbataku | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Despite advancements in speech recognition, accented speech remains
challenging. While previous approaches have focused on modeling techniques or
creating accented speech datasets, gathering sufficient data for the multitude
of accents, particularly in the African context, remains impractical due to
their sheer diversity and associated budget constraints. To address these
challenges, we propose AccentFold, a method that exploits spatial relationships
between learned accent embeddings to improve downstream Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR). Our exploratory analysis of speech embeddings representing
100+ African accents reveals interesting spatial accent relationships
highlighting geographic and genealogical similarities, capturing consistent
phonological, and morphological regularities, all learned empirically from
speech. Furthermore, we discover accent relationships previously
uncharacterized by the Ethnologue. Through empirical evaluation, we demonstrate
the effectiveness of AccentFold by showing that, for out-of-distribution (OOD)
accents, sampling accent subsets for training based on AccentFold information
outperforms strong baselines a relative WER improvement of 4.6%. AccentFold
presents a promising approach for improving ASR performance on accented speech,
particularly in the context of African accents, where data scarcity and budget
constraints pose significant challenges. Our findings emphasize the potential
of leveraging linguistic relationships to improve zero-shot ASR adaptation to
target accents. | [
-0.0269521866,
0.1150068268,
0.0126382671,
0.0136564607,
0.0165043231,
0.017363837,
0.0561581701,
-0.0048921751,
-0.0383093208,
0.0132552488,
-0.0570255183,
-0.057798218,
0.0690147802,
-0.0231400598,
0.0520672984,
-0.048673775,
-0.0158640891,
-0.0399316624,
-0.0351368301,
-0.0330995843,
0.0197539199,
0.0371311605,
-0.0135324495,
0.0542457737,
-0.0137226628,
0.0453173667,
-0.0259488653,
0.0391634069,
0.0337410085,
0.0131815001,
-0.0506159253,
0.0049794144,
0.0069603547,
0.0060735564,
0.0000019382,
-0.0161961857,
-0.0215586629,
-0.0039416188,
-0.0895922333,
0.0505890772,
0.0302873887,
0.016014453,
-0.0411011875,
0.0352448374,
0.0019476536,
-0.0316625312,
0.0956539661,
-0.0165865533,
-0.0353977047,
0.03376415,
-0.0124117881,
-0.018883327,
0.0045417007,
-0.0393531471,
-0.0161043052,
0.0126352757,
-0.0091343215,
-0.078639783,
-0.0223353207,
-0.0030991503,
-0.0241546445,
-0.00901224,
-0.0007884086,
0.0244055726,
0.0024244881,
0.0303691234,
-0.0139223626,
-0.0104576778,
-0.0068867374,
0.035723187,
-0.0421624407,
-0.0133760003,
-0.0054299938,
0.0144206164,
-0.0189221129,
-0.01967871,
-0.0216507036,
-0.0153426584,
0.0007338962,
0.0219341591,
-0.0217776559,
0.0580759682,
0.0386764146,
-0.0247377064,
-0.0505990312,
0.0198426861,
0.012495161,
-0.0205591638,
-0.0071399971,
-0.0302077495,
0.0015747907,
0.009237201,
0.024532333,
-0.0167380776,
0.0375113897,
-0.0182142798,
0.0313979499,
0.0376941264,
0.0306731705,
0.0416740663,
0.0716208369,
0.0394368283,
-0.0697175413,
-0.0267346743,
-0.0283857379,
0.0315336362,
-0.0196580887,
-0.0131521448,
-0.0139979161,
-0.0010661741,
-0.041076865,
-0.0159401689,
-0.021665331,
-0.0180609189,
-0.0022637907,
0.0164713506,
-0.003289524,
-0.0304233078,
-0.0363125652,
0.0131479399,
0.0142593943,
0.0052577634,
-0.0345731266,
-0.060146708,
0.0792530701,
0.0527089462,
-0.0047431295,
0.0357600339,
-0.0548194423,
-0.0751106665,
-0.0179639403,
-0.0022511645,
0.0536786839,
0.0489160493,
0.0199506357,
-0.0140065625,
0.0485580005,
-0.0328997634,
-0.0389054678,
0.0247373488,
-0.0611360185,
0.0112042483,
-0.0264185369,
-0.0496127941,
0.0051523852,
-0.0300435908,
0.0238343719,
-0.0308723021,
-0.0320383497,
-0.0346708409,
0.0404673852,
0.0563931875,
0.0339235291,
-0.0136688612,
0.0674709529,
-0.0213806387,
0.0323515758,
0.0347685926,
-0.0006773911,
-0.0207620822,
-0.019738229,
-0.0007502821,
-0.0334708169,
0.0570578277,
0.0449382775,
0.017991744,
-0.0069500627,
-0.01598447,
-0.0066322442,
0.009189426,
0.0568967387,
0.0072323065,
-0.0263174269,
-0.0469426364,
0.0043417448,
0.0696300417,
0.0209831502,
-0.0206129458,
0.0414733589,
-0.0037497601,
-0.0460607745,
-0.0241941791,
0.0170874652,
-0.0165736191,
0.0222067069,
-0.0284580067,
0.0093112811,
0.0889052227,
-0.0685470328,
0.0012756553,
0.0049785743,
-0.0433208756,
-0.0215818044,
0.0165371392,
0.0171094313,
-0.0094617084,
-0.0133092506,
-0.0184811428,
0.0258900281,
-0.0238281209,
0.0066988315,
-0.0297715366,
-0.0178069547,
0.0042040297,
-0.0171136484,
0.0043559764,
-0.0266422015,
-0.02322492,
0.0216051694,
-0.009559691,
-0.0194096416,
-0.0165035967,
0.0808544829,
-0.084005706,
0.0172953364,
0.0370222591,
0.0141259683,
0.0727583542,
-0.0317395031,
0.054197643,
0.0047690449,
-0.034654133,
0.0403565913,
-0.0151721658,
-0.0294804946,
-0.0126247173,
0.0416646302,
0.0410469919,
0.0328535475,
0.0381874032,
-0.0323646516,
-0.0146016302,
-0.0033418767,
-0.061966978,
0.0251406468,
0.074978739,
-0.0635866821,
-0.0105507923,
0.0327619053,
-0.0406544097,
0.0511287749,
-0.0159544982,
0.0318977199,
-0.072028406,
0.0668550432,
-0.0341223069,
0.0698721036,
-0.0254519098,
0.0232894253,
0.0098590842,
0.028910365,
0.001032892,
-0.0081327027,
0.0404382795,
-0.0389156267,
0.0016730273,
0.0397709049,
0.0481900088,
-0.0227660742,
0.0238053352,
0.0006070968,
-0.002794777,
-0.0037582463,
-0.0261768457,
-0.0318453275,
0.0110107409,
-0.0146418456,
-0.0881248266,
-0.0036510567,
-0.0186552145,
0.0291804597,
-0.0216446482,
0.0463600866,
-0.0067146951,
-0.0219416674,
-0.0118763596,
-0.0406787731,
-0.034514159,
-0.014076571,
-0.0378543437,
-0.0563566536,
-0.0352202505,
0.000895619,
-0.0112672914,
0.0116323382,
0.036640048,
-0.0351020247,
0.0122628715,
-0.0352970697,
-0.0836422518,
0.0250192583,
-0.0030439736,
0.0026871115,
-0.0242867582,
-0.0388149656,
-0.0029391251,
-0.0120676132,
0.0033428508,
-0.0560076386,
-0.0159553438,
0.0063795438,
-0.0145387994,
-0.0294332802,
-0.0328177623,
0.0135108456,
0.0601179898,
-0.0000393103,
0.0086621279,
-0.0508322753,
0.014383697,
0.0210097637,
0.0175289139,
-0.0741570964,
-0.0121170245,
0.0193611719,
0.0059293238,
-0.0098259607,
-0.0243211407,
-0.0134991687,
-0.0066543645,
-0.0601142719,
-0.041784212,
0.0399800912,
-0.059984155,
-0.0395722203,
-0.0389807671,
-0.0239799321,
-0.0146759069,
-0.0193984192,
-0.0064288895,
0.0170519371,
0.023646716,
-0.0359973125,
0.0234682374,
0.0327802598,
0.0113554504,
-0.010068275,
0.0321258605,
0.0216988623,
-0.0260602869,
0.0008353226,
-0.0521862358,
0.0244483799,
-0.0242839009,
-0.0563995652,
0.0260593873,
0.0246824473,
-0.0396324955,
0.0425478742,
0.022248419,
0.0288417861,
0.0680095032,
0.0135535579,
0.015201509,
0.0107578961,
0.0096988026,
0.0117754228,
0.0522844084,
-0.0484615974,
0.0115852738,
0.0492679439,
-0.0481416993,
0.0474376827,
0.0062265154,
-0.0578004122,
0.0226002373,
0.0333014391,
0.004606653,
-0.019320678,
-0.0059326068,
0.0317453593,
0.0235909969,
0.0056016957,
0.0310780276,
0.0400412492,
0.0010880104,
0.0278448891,
-0.0575685166,
0.0765291452,
-0.0007371351,
-0.0216854122,
-0.0720119104,
-0.0278213974,
0.0443474315,
0.0028841267,
0.0156297926,
0.0114243934,
0.0082530389,
-0.1169831678,
0.0462193526,
0.0458400585,
-0.0477259643,
-0.0154500268,
-0.0639244393,
-0.0337915309,
-0.0214888118,
0.0142487502,
0.0053304723,
0.0173614398,
-0.0587559603,
0.079994835,
-0.0751962662,
-0.0762037635,
0.0098929768,
-0.0597666912,
0.0932495818,
-0.0039916397,
-0.0223161485,
0.0059692231,
-0.0312498678,
-0.0521724224,
-0.0245562326,
0.0180235896,
-0.059962377,
0.0374168903,
0.0633705333,
-0.0179820694,
0.0426974855,
0.0228662007,
-0.0220403727,
0.0022899832,
-0.0003985884,
0.0609926693,
-0.0315029509,
0.0484127812,
-0.0013123865,
-0.0181047413,
-0.0020142118,
0.0260524862,
0.0284389425,
-0.0219321605,
-0.0082135191,
0.0044098119,
0.0428659245,
-0.0148108182,
0.0195252895,
0.0494190231,
0.0336869545,
-0.0432270467,
-0.0489909574,
-0.003777296,
0.0146886166,
0.0513916574,
0.0255274773,
-0.0312009957,
-0.0252521932,
0.0008493924,
-0.0204251818,
0.0125818765,
-0.0333247371,
0.0528190173,
0.0280998964,
0.0280415248,
0.0426659994,
-0.0585500374,
0.0262575392,
-0.0335595943,
-0.0192957874,
-0.0507932752,
0.0316187292,
-0.0039707711,
0.0196456574,
0.0646717921,
-0.0120744677,
-0.0578294136,
0.0826905891,
-0.035460569,
0.0426134616,
-0.0025238416,
0.0839836225,
-0.0112633426,
0.0253035706,
0.0130119827,
0.0070831757,
0.0610289536,
-0.0159971993,
-0.0372727849,
-0.0652219877,
-0.0077826483,
-0.0368036479,
-0.0136694545,
0.0280270819,
-0.0603545383,
-0.0353662968,
-0.0309833735,
0.0304299667,
0.0118124848,
0.0901309848,
-0.0188029669,
-0.047817342,
0.0527797788,
0.0300746746,
-0.0177480038,
0.0006874959,
-0.0171835348,
-0.01775706,
0.0082310382,
0.06612093,
0.0366807431,
0.0273170937,
-0.0038318881,
0.0493558198,
-0.0122806998,
0.0453114435,
-0.0097604804,
0.029761631,
-0.0425030403,
-0.0315285102,
-0.0146446545,
-0.0014330196,
-0.0263308827,
0.0385538898,
0.0009735891,
0.0699602738,
-0.0134913158,
0.0124824326,
0.0723372996,
-0.0280347243,
0.0629884154,
0.025040552,
0.0236285385,
-0.0020929261,
-0.0198687166,
-0.0577591844,
-0.0081876749,
0.0442627594,
0.0110374866,
-0.0063690427,
0.0811851546,
0.0301679466,
-0.0044766613,
0.0397489294,
-0.0438717231,
0.0552594438,
-0.0121010821,
0.0006314406,
0.0254057199,
-0.0087996433,
-0.0501507185,
-0.0142632276,
-0.0090212375,
-0.0775388181,
0.0340543315,
-0.0051467298,
0.0285487361,
-0.0062777721,
-0.0015401486,
-0.0513158999,
-0.032949701,
0.0129673565,
0.0203999113,
-0.0580089428,
-0.0024475781,
-0.0235756654,
0.0497345328,
-6.161274294e-33,
0.0281640831,
0.0412137061,
-0.0026730443,
0.0273038931,
-0.0258761719,
0.0335201211,
-0.0102150701,
0.0168737508,
-0.0490364805,
-0.028944524,
-0.0211355463,
-0.0203573629,
0.0212380588,
0.0294552092,
0.0087320572,
0.0309906416,
0.0431357436,
-0.0015888652,
0.0090389224,
-0.0196691714,
0.0270230472,
0.0374294631,
0.0314775147,
-0.0414285809,
-0.0530080609,
0.008255139,
-0.0431425013,
-0.0040239827,
0.0171549208,
0.0541784838,
-0.0076014376,
0.0475791059,
-0.0061755953,
-0.0318151861,
-0.0065751099,
0.0044223648,
-0.0927930325,
-0.0115762679,
-0.0291320682,
0.0359135084,
0.0076397583,
-0.0345978476,
0.018799521,
0.0034179327,
-0.0097030457,
0.008764199,
-0.0223854575,
-0.0494583733,
-0.0285205245,
0.0403284468,
-0.0367750637,
0.0765298381,
-0.0103062391,
0.0130814407,
0.0810040832,
0.026940031,
-0.02770718,
-0.0257060919,
-0.0539860502,
-0.0124868369,
0.034897089,
0.03821427,
0.0078179166,
0.0242489148,
-0.0331728235,
-0.009399523,
0.0874310955,
-0.0975260809,
0.0036534041,
-0.0356288478,
0.0805228055,
-0.016339805,
-0.0051792907,
0.039061971,
0.068815656,
-0.0572132841,
-0.0481530502,
0.006576872,
0.0504545085,
-0.0040372568,
-0.0273692235,
0.0250604898,
-0.0068123024,
-0.0170787461,
-0.0203578994,
-0.0396945104,
-0.0221958887,
-0.0188505501,
0.0405989252,
-0.0092153018,
0.0156469159,
0.0833953097,
0.0484847799,
0.0134853767,
-0.0275158528,
-0.0145864999,
0.0116228061,
0.0182594322,
0.0258146971,
0.0309246741,
-0.045291841,
0.0048150485,
0.0081230216,
0.0638008639,
0.0093753971,
-0.0176215935,
0.0709796995,
0.06021991,
-0.0729377046,
0.0004726244,
-0.0053796638,
-0.0208372921,
-0.0039913491,
0.0036624458,
0.0149234487,
-0.0167633407,
0.0341574103,
-0.0025479207,
0.0542945564,
-0.0029900956,
0.0293315258,
-0.0004458265,
-0.0045981868,
0.0119132865,
-0.0217202045,
0.0083721466,
0.0435135439,
-0.04590597,
-0.0056466409,
-0.0367279463,
-0.0173861533,
0.0064195413,
2.669e-7,
-0.0422219224,
0.0154942563,
0.0512173623,
-0.0618827678,
0.0306039788,
-0.0093938401,
-0.0322521403,
-0.0325393267,
-0.0147084901,
0.0171447881,
0.0384810418,
0.0059969528,
0.1093566269,
0.0339155011,
-0.063524425,
0.0251767449,
-0.0326368064,
0.0138543081,
-0.0279694367,
-0.025579568,
-0.0143694347,
0.1032727808,
-0.0261818357,
-0.0562420376,
-0.0125984829,
-0.0035631182,
0.0175607968,
-0.0173329599,
0.0622394271,
-0.0568991117,
0.0287989061,
-0.025661679,
-0.0157043282,
0.0237747189,
-0.0214786362,
0.0463744588,
-0.0149734588,
0.0054614022,
-0.0624213032,
-0.0261578839,
0.0122572742,
0.0205082241,
-0.0711380914,
-0.0506401248,
0.0633386075,
0.0297648571,
-0.026153056,
-0.0503198169,
-0.0734095424,
0.0268824063,
0.0165182427,
-0.0133932214,
0.01887298,
0.003011643,
0.0187093187,
-0.0402699672,
-0.0332340933,
-0.0368014723,
-0.0006632116,
0.0523427725,
-0.0350681916,
0.0402687304,
0.0054267589,
0.0212778486,
0.009200383,
-0.0134395119,
0.0220735092,
2.266092984e-34,
0.0118983025,
-0.0411779732,
0.0547180101,
0.0165068619,
-0.02471512,
-0.0384585522,
-0.000149187,
0.0213721897,
0.0279246792,
-0.0325206891,
-0.0463522375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01796v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01796v2 | Speech foundation models in healthcare: Effect of layer selection on pathological speech feature prediction | 2024-02-02T05:09:42 | 2024-06-21T13:49:56 | Daniela A. Wiepert, Rene L. Utianski, Joseph R. Duffy, John L. Stricker, Leland R. Barnard, David T. Jones, Hugo Botha | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG | Accurately extracting clinical information from speech is critical to the
diagnosis and treatment of many neurological conditions. As such, there is
interest in leveraging AI for automatic, objective assessments of clinical
speech to facilitate diagnosis and treatment of speech disorders. We explore
transfer learning using foundation models, focusing on the impact of layer
selection for the downstream task of predicting pathological speech features.
We find that selecting an optimal layer can greatly improve performance (~15.8%
increase in balanced accuracy per feature as compared to worst layer, ~13.6%
increase as compared to final layer), though the best layer varies by predicted
feature and does not always generalize well to unseen data. A learned weighted
sum offers comparable performance to the average best layer in-distribution
(only ~1.2% lower) and had strong generalization for out-of-distribution data
(only 1.5% lower than the average best layer). | [
-0.0161921997,
0.0810476243,
-0.0085060783,
-0.0190528184,
-0.0129700936,
-0.0028995965,
0.0193530805,
-0.0111929039,
-0.0566780306,
0.0353685617,
-0.0220707189,
-0.0518573001,
0.0364105143,
0.0495727807,
-0.0262564644,
-0.0450132452,
0.0268788394,
-0.0262686163,
-0.0044912817,
-0.0162495505,
0.0108409161,
0.0152318152,
-0.049489364,
0.0595944412,
-0.0132432207,
0.0354443043,
0.039058242,
-0.0155645814,
-0.0004226786,
-0.0210124031,
-0.0050565717,
0.0261299908,
-0.0060888487,
-0.0413079225,
0.0000019314,
-0.0429074839,
-0.0244815983,
0.025342891,
-0.0372869596,
-0.0180688687,
0.004575321,
0.0045745615,
-0.01044886,
0.0393549688,
-0.0466087349,
-0.0390624814,
0.0219315048,
0.0465785637,
0.0560559444,
0.0422717333,
-0.0144143431,
-0.0015085273,
0.0403341837,
-0.017347876,
-0.0504736416,
-0.044605203,
0.0358224101,
-0.0327931121,
-0.0466621295,
-0.1036376357,
-0.0015008356,
0.0195405409,
-0.0112345591,
0.030834958,
0.0554129072,
0.0260542631,
-0.0274701379,
-0.049668055,
-0.0304379109,
0.0872251764,
-0.0136951637,
0.0118254451,
0.0188173633,
0.0011109001,
-0.0149314664,
0.002655314,
-0.0646654069,
0.0000602415,
0.007041201,
0.0127922194,
0.025741946,
0.0089583499,
0.0356298387,
-0.0127509311,
-0.0265067667,
0.0327486098,
-0.0085889464,
0.0151048265,
0.0514784195,
0.0164613444,
0.0090660481,
-0.0326806381,
0.0068620276,
0.0250220485,
-0.0417855009,
-0.0020945244,
-0.0187814254,
-0.0279305149,
0.0068873558,
-0.014677559,
0.0078587355,
0.0050153062,
-0.0612855889,
0.0254393499,
-0.0399621427,
-0.0088916626,
-0.0160693545,
0.0444953442,
-0.0156175913,
-0.0213969275,
-0.03524746,
0.0266185757,
-0.0080075329,
0.0759289265,
0.0473937765,
-0.0207710266,
-0.059822578,
-0.0358219594,
-0.0501686335,
-0.0290379096,
0.0494728126,
0.0319124572,
0.0014328848,
0.0271493122,
0.0158086922,
0.0386094153,
0.0116968323,
0.0687180683,
-0.0025223382,
-0.0831590816,
-0.0060853981,
0.0211652461,
-0.0107182236,
0.0049892738,
0.0618150719,
0.053978309,
0.0227653161,
0.0010347939,
-0.006269,
0.0182329901,
-0.0082110297,
-0.0271655452,
0.0026839187,
-0.0511617698,
-0.0048984853,
0.0115023805,
0.0425974838,
-0.0573668256,
-0.0021805919,
-0.0215267222,
-0.0062968074,
0.0045119217,
-0.0099873962,
0.0357546583,
0.0617344826,
-0.0031115846,
-0.0650968179,
0.0114638954,
0.0487488657,
-0.0288578141,
-0.0173556134,
-0.0603982769,
-0.0103533156,
0.0543943718,
0.0589657687,
-0.0194191262,
-0.0281003844,
-0.0255677365,
-0.0634280369,
0.0158658195,
0.005472932,
0.0251845662,
0.0146755558,
-0.030683402,
0.0176939648,
0.0767306611,
0.0593502223,
0.0430989675,
-0.0117625669,
-0.0327238999,
0.0088533638,
-0.015267591,
-0.0058876998,
0.0129966736,
-0.0216014795,
-0.0297273863,
-0.063781485,
0.0230430663,
-0.033386793,
-0.0275586713,
0.0110470774,
-0.0369797088,
-0.0050244816,
0.0240718741,
0.0507909022,
0.0194262899,
-0.0236821491,
0.0560374148,
0.0462585166,
0.0058709336,
-0.0019027104,
-0.0656996444,
-0.0155801652,
0.000689377,
-0.0245417375,
-0.0191614442,
-0.0338781327,
-0.028427843,
-0.0036701409,
-0.0190251824,
-0.0252933409,
0.0160377845,
0.0770637691,
-0.0264119897,
0.0149331884,
0.0739283487,
0.0222029984,
0.0160779878,
-0.0402302817,
0.0135228811,
-0.0206308886,
-0.0261516906,
-0.0202206932,
0.0428862646,
-0.0500329807,
-0.0000468688,
0.0228671767,
0.0066382745,
0.0479017235,
-0.0056325174,
-0.0339684226,
0.0033644957,
-0.0075588175,
-0.0398755893,
-0.0667722821,
0.0161481518,
-0.0727004781,
0.0184290595,
0.0061442866,
-0.0070407856,
0.0799733475,
0.0241302252,
-0.0066493643,
-0.0420462675,
0.0313073061,
-0.052765131,
0.0170449559,
-0.0245927274,
0.0103006968,
-0.0151921688,
0.0282748062,
0.0039683301,
-0.0122897532,
0.0017460209,
-0.0813645422,
0.0106498962,
-0.0664388984,
-0.0022690687,
-0.058715187,
-0.0059964452,
0.0116512077,
-0.0371880643,
0.0057580052,
-0.0281238332,
-0.0238855183,
0.0051725795,
0.0153314145,
-0.0767840594,
0.0055800462,
-0.0007416956,
-0.0101322699,
0.014577481,
0.033251971,
0.0023892496,
-0.0150823053,
-0.050885722,
-0.0014534382,
0.0444928147,
-0.0170498602,
-0.0023126996,
0.0315474607,
-0.0318825468,
-0.0475355834,
0.0010280913,
-0.0257934835,
0.0112508452,
-0.0214961432,
-0.0735520646,
0.0284757707,
-0.0005071321,
-0.0024176834,
0.0021801409,
0.0212744232,
0.002885005,
-0.0430472419,
-0.0382236354,
-0.1197324991,
0.0496850908,
-0.0109445378,
0.040796902,
0.0189510658,
0.0029327164,
-0.0041440371,
0.0055957427,
-0.0173460785,
0.041680675,
-0.0049606948,
-0.0059286538,
0.0045124907,
0.076849319,
0.06799227,
0.0327418819,
-0.0581511259,
-0.0032617506,
-0.017371811,
0.026428543,
-0.0121549862,
-0.0196401104,
-0.0167329926,
0.0385588184,
-0.0132275922,
-0.0344588347,
0.0495051332,
-0.0433368944,
0.0239705425,
-0.03675621,
-0.0613563731,
-0.0608990192,
-0.0342116766,
-0.0508009493,
0.0037502944,
-0.0129767377,
-0.0279214792,
-0.0200746208,
0.0023105885,
0.0279974155,
-0.0532292053,
0.0313489772,
-0.0343527906,
0.0115252677,
0.0198448524,
-0.0417101234,
-0.039095629,
0.0094884187,
-0.0173858181,
0.0294092372,
-0.0488892384,
0.0206292048,
-0.0213335734,
-0.0109288879,
-0.0192219764,
0.0934213325,
0.0168941449,
0.0339156464,
0.0204370581,
0.0305645037,
0.0132041741,
0.0554270148,
-0.0112324003,
-0.0139626106,
0.0719032884,
-0.0033675269,
0.0173657648,
0.0737704411,
-0.0342156254,
0.0177266523,
-0.0087167928,
0.0017163869,
-0.0252103992,
0.0460999608,
0.0171290673,
-0.0276374239,
0.0121704247,
0.0802966282,
-0.0183256734,
-0.0158667397,
0.0146660879,
0.01507538,
0.0013198109,
-0.0329240598,
-0.0107990159,
-0.0185407382,
-0.0328922085,
0.0447659753,
0.052503705,
-0.0015424953,
-0.0305195991,
0.0261397269,
-0.0550382137,
0.0389870331,
-0.000961909,
-0.0230280515,
0.0252637062,
-0.0508393981,
0.045787394,
-0.0488522798,
0.0004679947,
-0.0492692441,
0.0036502078,
-0.0298487544,
0.0593371876,
-0.1104155779,
-0.0710063726,
0.0366039425,
-0.0107438844,
0.0370785259,
0.0760887936,
-0.0226676222,
-0.0293241777,
-0.0147417895,
0.0190571528,
0.0214933045,
0.0096933292,
-0.0240766443,
0.0764138997,
0.0508746766,
-0.0003785278,
-0.0122202253,
0.0722281039,
-0.044962164,
0.0018504929,
0.0258805808,
0.0776666105,
-0.0068939971,
-0.0309075136,
-0.0292034931,
0.0406269506,
0.031937357,
0.054560367,
0.0011570057,
-0.038909886,
-0.0071556899,
0.0326186456,
0.0298385993,
0.0247542541,
-0.0275733788,
0.0590822361,
0.0227804855,
-0.0489273295,
-0.0610424727,
0.0324372984,
0.011046051,
0.0403384194,
0.052745495,
0.0307203792,
0.0188413132,
0.0354192741,
-0.0067339726,
0.0339663513,
0.0638456196,
0.043369744,
-0.0426187105,
-0.0039929044,
0.0436133221,
-0.0489686653,
-0.0524252765,
-0.0097673815,
-0.0161587857,
-0.0070791896,
0.0206112973,
0.0205321796,
0.0246656667,
0.0050505572,
-0.0516439565,
-0.0001262628,
0.0689823925,
-0.0017294261,
-0.0615640916,
0.0319729485,
0.0571251698,
-0.1079805791,
-0.0072247335,
0.0405022278,
-0.0191697311,
0.0720664859,
0.0082220109,
0.0152750919,
-0.0066592679,
-0.0175265018,
0.0082210358,
0.0447313897,
0.0680648834,
0.0319459103,
-0.0071982103,
-0.0193010587,
0.0556782484,
0.0271881111,
0.0511836894,
-0.0361653194,
-0.0121368319,
0.045761086,
0.0287281908,
0.0018009553,
-0.0090139257,
-0.0246564727,
-0.0085205249,
-0.0000034317,
0.0608116537,
0.0135713639,
0.02127905,
0.0223033652,
-0.0013112732,
0.0057714055,
0.0031537367,
0.0515332259,
0.0162374843,
-0.0017076174,
0.0061764778,
0.0097361328,
0.0260788891,
0.015801318,
-0.009605838,
-0.0363875739,
-0.098699972,
-0.0528629869,
-0.0413498431,
-0.0061939107,
-0.0215167701,
0.0541380756,
0.0102686211,
0.0320567153,
-0.0359126404,
0.0086839106,
-0.0642292574,
0.0526226461,
0.0185067914,
0.0008542299,
0.0123436786,
-0.0033760285,
0.0415273272,
0.0449890681,
0.053402368,
-0.048135642,
0.021760691,
-0.0249614362,
-0.0211338717,
0.0233973507,
0.0012719801,
-0.0301191565,
0.0415668488,
-0.0553011782,
-0.0427299291,
0.0789334625,
-0.0647343025,
0.0307773128,
-0.038497407,
0.0406368002,
-0.0050139651,
-0.022694055,
0.0103536639,
0.0094858687,
-0.0524627194,
-0.0341587849,
-0.0118210297,
0.0155795822,
-5.697574099e-33,
-0.0121632228,
0.0325691737,
0.0216531157,
0.0241635274,
-0.0150990626,
0.0460390784,
-0.0299463701,
0.0243816171,
-0.024388181,
0.0168733317,
-0.0360335968,
-0.0062616174,
0.0235658903,
0.0494658686,
-0.0074430378,
-0.0402512774,
0.0526423194,
0.0100448253,
-0.0215706676,
0.0107668471,
-0.0086010704,
0.0627191514,
0.048650194,
-0.0788891464,
-0.1064933315,
0.0359741636,
-0.0277408175,
-0.0133266766,
-0.0062300903,
0.0266801771,
0.0124182291,
0.0406513885,
0.0251473095,
-0.0441032797,
0.0033489701,
-0.0033423596,
-0.0689693391,
-0.0046417671,
0.0210416261,
0.0034875479,
0.0013033319,
0.0206920393,
0.0568524003,
-0.0092018601,
-0.020817155,
-0.031477727,
0.0373158753,
-0.0790573657,
0.0013937829,
-0.0656373054,
-0.015154249,
0.0266732927,
-0.0163648482,
-0.0063073258,
0.0111500528,
-0.007201999,
-0.0747451708,
-0.0061343117,
-0.0099357367,
-0.018224271,
0.0186768398,
0.016942095,
0.0206258371,
0.0046796734,
-0.0461091399,
0.0496969856,
0.0652797073,
-0.0388204567,
-0.0147812041,
-0.0316925794,
-0.0120741669,
0.0973422006,
0.0443845987,
0.0130196521,
0.0168695766,
-0.0396764949,
-0.103362821,
0.0071730567,
-0.0009601867,
0.0360031463,
0.000353,
-0.0282957591,
-0.0339131169,
-0.0120475385,
-0.0772600845,
0.0071318392,
0.007366138,
0.0057367645,
0.0502454713,
0.0026767578,
0.0151714729,
0.0009618004,
0.0231463555,
-0.024746811,
0.0205031317,
0.0166649409,
-0.0016011454,
-0.0163907334,
-0.0024904704,
-0.0034380055,
-0.0737277791,
-0.0348199718,
-0.0024271449,
0.0252616238,
0.057177294,
-0.005635967,
0.0218921117,
0.0219509285,
-0.0163122248,
-0.0190501269,
-0.0009488318,
0.0264322069,
0.0057227211,
0.0913152471,
0.0216678027,
0.0126184719,
-0.0204994958,
0.0343334638,
-0.075242579,
0.0474200472,
-0.0498596393,
-0.0130181415,
0.0334261246,
0.0303660668,
-0.0793640837,
-0.0305831693,
-0.0136093348,
-0.0370471366,
0.0338323414,
-0.0666012317,
-0.0357013047,
-0.0004823362,
2.777e-7,
0.0185248312,
0.0164825954,
-0.0064744782,
-0.0431636684,
0.0187684279,
0.0096613448,
-0.0497511141,
0.0196774211,
0.0099386415,
-0.0100229988,
0.0189440977,
0.0343950316,
0.0829952136,
0.0255502127,
-0.0486450866,
-0.0338747837,
-0.097384803,
0.0007538594,
0.0085200677,
-0.0160569698,
-0.0300748982,
0.0578067861,
-0.0126352618,
-0.1019594967,
0.0496520624,
-0.0028580003,
0.0236256756,
-0.0268395636,
0.0351795815,
-0.0027656285,
0.0053046416,
0.0022484758,
0.0108166737,
0.0504001565,
-0.0304521639,
0.057022009,
0.0067981491,
0.056376826,
-0.0533773974,
-0.0561705343,
0.0189655218,
0.0501698516,
0.0425734259,
0.013090888,
0.0598858856,
-0.011265886,
-0.0268614814,
-0.050868962,
-0.0515215471,
0.001852634,
0.0278543085,
-0.0264297631,
0.0232534371,
-0.0015036863,
0.0117828939,
0.0250317045,
-0.0480907857,
-0.015433209,
-0.0226096828,
0.0499005504,
-0.0526933186,
-0.0384910069,
0.0106807649,
-0.0206615068,
-0.01860171,
-0.0622913241,
0.035897959,
2.288032714e-34,
-0.0060986937,
-0.0038700572,
0.0199975446,
0.0170029625,
-0.0189932175,
-0.0055309669,
0.0482167713,
0.0291538648,
-0.001343163,
-0.0308716819,
-0.031343244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01135v1 | A Multi-Agent Conversational Recommender System | 2024-02-02T04:20:13 | 2024-02-02T04:20:13 | Jiabao Fang, Shen Gao, Pengjie Ren, Xiuying Chen, Suzan Verberne, Zhaochun Ren | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Due to strong capabilities in conducting fluent, multi-turn conversations
with users, Large Language Models (LLMs) have the potential to further improve
the performance of Conversational Recommender System (CRS). Unlike the aimless
chit-chat that LLM excels at, CRS has a clear target. So it is imperative to
control the dialogue flow in the LLM to successfully recommend appropriate
items to the users. Furthermore, user feedback in CRS can assist the system in
better modeling user preferences, which has been ignored by existing studies.
However, simply prompting LLM to conduct conversational recommendation cannot
address the above two key challenges.
In this paper, we propose Multi-Agent Conversational Recommender System
(MACRS) which contains two essential modules. First, we design a multi-agent
act planning framework, which can control the dialogue flow based on four
LLM-based agents. This cooperative multi-agent framework will generate various
candidate responses based on different dialogue acts and then choose the most
appropriate response as the system response, which can help MACRS plan suitable
dialogue acts. Second, we propose a user feedback-aware reflection mechanism
which leverages user feedback to reason errors made in previous turns to adjust
the dialogue act planning, and higher-level user information from implicit
semantics. We conduct extensive experiments based on user simulator to
demonstrate the effectiveness of MACRS in recommendation and user preferences
collection. Experimental results illustrate that MACRS demonstrates an
improvement in user interaction experience compared to directly using LLMs. | [
0.0688124523,
0.0095862988,
-0.0181080233,
0.0203109942,
-0.0408610813,
-0.0318181999,
0.0402569994,
-0.0247140136,
0.0529830195,
-0.0329716392,
-0.0314012617,
0.0091004772,
-0.0220258404,
0.0401002839,
-0.047675252,
-0.0489362963,
0.0075062048,
-0.0577552728,
0.008352411,
-0.02622566,
0.0301907677,
0.004565774,
0.0026561024,
0.0389431044,
0.0042406828,
-0.0134096369,
-0.0375674926,
-0.0212691929,
-0.0312632844,
-0.0059636105,
0.0329527743,
0.022512259,
0.0232669227,
0.0008934328,
0.0000024117,
-0.0584805757,
-0.0085018035,
-0.0384530127,
-0.0038803087,
0.0015080892,
0.0451652668,
0.0972809643,
0.0056799175,
0.0065208832,
-0.0359608494,
0.0364704952,
0.0194884557,
0.0572871044,
0.062549226,
0.0204588771,
-0.0174022056,
0.0055150329,
-0.0196372326,
0.009062157,
0.0256707408,
-0.0278116632,
0.0030544333,
0.0132752964,
0.047377266,
0.0204233229,
0.0072916243,
-0.0000120579,
-0.0196192712,
-0.0590014011,
-0.0143921608,
0.0195509903,
-0.0226471331,
-0.0519582443,
-0.0081838388,
0.0741931647,
0.040711049,
-0.0045370599,
-0.0139083201,
0.009162507,
0.0072381292,
0.0140967779,
-0.0381398536,
-0.0163419899,
-0.030104097,
-0.011967143,
-0.034263432,
-0.0026340699,
0.0216428023,
0.0139425443,
-0.0192583613,
0.0796324387,
0.0006074355,
-0.0297315791,
-0.0038816696,
-0.0079321843,
0.0426013172,
-0.0655190125,
0.0433979332,
0.0240987968,
-0.1275705248,
0.0030703035,
-0.0036173579,
0.0616398118,
0.0071304692,
-0.0560627952,
0.0384845771,
0.029123975,
0.004791711,
0.0406179763,
0.0208707172,
0.0197963715,
0.0113642747,
-0.0208496638,
-0.0429410301,
-0.0344134048,
-0.0133302603,
-0.001634142,
-0.0206380468,
0.0476113856,
-0.0625416636,
-0.0290484075,
-0.0202687122,
0.069814682,
-0.0189117938,
0.0500172302,
0.0063844761,
0.0454688594,
0.0163432956,
0.0009204921,
-0.1064055115,
0.017700851,
-0.0348847993,
0.0098196631,
0.0249508228,
-0.0336941928,
0.046904996,
0.0197924934,
0.0130172512,
-0.0110942721,
-0.0190705154,
0.0435523614,
0.0121765016,
-0.0150321834,
0.0261789467,
-0.020243559,
-0.0012028139,
-0.0581579171,
-0.0699440762,
-0.0474991687,
0.0436092615,
0.0465573594,
-0.0008010232,
-0.0087116724,
0.0390751027,
0.0320590585,
-0.010743903,
0.0718927234,
0.0088169239,
0.0193746481,
0.0280478541,
0.0193902273,
-0.0602506101,
0.0065840799,
0.0249984711,
0.0724980682,
0.0537072122,
0.0177264288,
0.0339119472,
-0.0034970725,
-0.0293367077,
0.0066479538,
0.0196916573,
0.0380823612,
-0.0511459038,
0.0430353507,
-0.0048897695,
0.0690989047,
-0.0552124046,
-0.0088815605,
0.0818502009,
0.0362123474,
0.0052151028,
0.0573711284,
0.0553881116,
0.039406009,
-0.0272638891,
-0.0149844224,
-0.0007233372,
0.0578994192,
-0.0320202596,
-0.0404919721,
0.0379557274,
0.0112244971,
-0.0360338949,
-0.0388640687,
0.0473282076,
-0.0337433219,
0.0643523261,
0.0474950857,
0.0097837169,
-0.0409713499,
-0.0666832626,
0.0149362599,
0.0340534858,
-0.0477448776,
-0.0246240292,
-0.0355607159,
0.0827258676,
0.1583820581,
0.0417576209,
0.0265998542,
-0.022997994,
-0.005372426,
-0.0047314386,
-0.0139734764,
0.063772738,
-0.0441394299,
-0.0078583863,
-0.0388673022,
-0.0262762066,
0.0406735763,
-0.0497833118,
0.0533012338,
-0.0279302839,
-0.0206287354,
-0.007299304,
0.0542344525,
-0.0088503184,
-0.0382814109,
-0.0115079274,
0.0339929685,
0.0203462597,
0.014917274,
0.0641761869,
-0.0012309292,
0.0263181329,
-0.0139271086,
0.0172836129,
0.0048358585,
-0.0416095145,
0.0333195254,
-0.0327392109,
-0.0399828441,
0.004403613,
0.0167191681,
-0.0052775964,
0.0025103751,
0.0225714408,
-0.0358493887,
0.0149206063,
0.0029686417,
0.0348085128,
-0.0281589832,
0.0262822229,
0.0218687691,
0.0022696077,
-0.0158396028,
0.0343242325,
0.0247580893,
-0.0061630816,
0.0322536267,
0.0200905688,
-0.0059137805,
-0.0463971384,
-0.0095244972,
0.0266515743,
0.0369821861,
0.0306656808,
0.0335800648,
-0.0011417146,
-0.0155443335,
-0.0315605365,
-0.1022418141,
-0.004920037,
0.0114458734,
-0.0306509994,
-0.0418883786,
0.0632655844,
0.0155767333,
-0.0354364999,
-0.04273789,
0.0434912778,
0.0167971179,
0.0204531141,
-0.0129828341,
0.0227030478,
-0.0502444878,
-0.0467711613,
0.0317043439,
-0.0093808062,
-0.0033659944,
0.0035181178,
0.0185821652,
-0.0497302338,
-0.0255777333,
-0.0433036312,
0.0060023856,
-0.0320006087,
-0.0074663721,
0.0122184223,
-0.026069684,
0.0237679537,
0.0134198749,
0.0182758253,
0.0594778545,
0.0216754153,
-0.0457971022,
-0.0972234011,
0.0382518508,
-0.0277000181,
-0.0082090618,
-0.0556848757,
-0.0081083998,
0.0300429109,
-0.0055954722,
0.0010127529,
0.0235152543,
-0.0485889204,
0.0082148798,
0.0520868115,
0.0021603433,
-0.0131270159,
-0.0337773897,
-0.0367569439,
0.0638563037,
0.0111177219,
0.0000523425,
0.0794710293,
-0.0204368476,
-0.0366658382,
-0.0382254981,
-0.0340550616,
-0.0411477871,
0.0030911153,
0.0052371342,
0.0296071693,
-0.0335169919,
-0.0048116157,
-0.0041632554,
-0.0323643498,
0.0444638953,
-0.0350917466,
0.0518903248,
-0.0388974957,
0.0094643747,
0.0132412314,
-0.0492846519,
-0.0220900252,
-0.0576812774,
-0.0110606281,
-0.0123714861,
0.0036115369,
-0.0145191662,
-0.0573277324,
-0.006902101,
0.0302518066,
0.0299421065,
0.0064921491,
-0.0314772092,
0.008678969,
-0.0229939427,
0.0447787307,
-0.0022236821,
-0.0195596498,
0.0018985746,
0.0849590376,
0.0255323183,
0.0064401086,
-0.0299289264,
-0.0334414691,
-0.0160435662,
0.0537014715,
0.0114316661,
0.0026765519,
0.036575608,
0.0286492407,
0.0127491131,
0.0087309554,
0.1042610854,
0.0433886684,
-0.1098913625,
0.0084692147,
-0.0367995799,
0.0061200559,
0.019471826,
0.0389741212,
-0.0192995314,
-0.007140635,
0.0009978295,
0.0109406048,
-0.0047208918,
-0.0332521424,
0.0075574326,
-0.0846617371,
0.0389204882,
-0.0281472281,
0.0024981122,
0.0306115802,
-0.0377519093,
0.0010131549,
-0.0012533851,
0.0450266562,
-0.0130558442,
0.0088540595,
-0.0283294823,
-0.018062409,
0.0012485678,
-0.0033790595,
0.062644206,
-0.0273344126,
0.0478243418,
0.071714595,
0.045494508,
0.0237104893,
-0.0068064919,
-0.0028984775,
0.0245126579,
0.0019658096,
-0.0118803075,
0.0016593382,
-0.0087487949,
0.0169034079,
-0.0410236605,
-0.00091746,
-0.018992044,
-0.0163739212,
0.0276447255,
0.0313020982,
-0.0663875192,
0.0121805482,
-0.0117594516,
0.0482305996,
0.0497682542,
0.0479264222,
-0.0005714197,
-0.0886489451,
-0.0112373549,
-0.0709017664,
-0.0493327864,
-0.0272858776,
-0.0258615762,
-0.0116466423,
0.0143256178,
0.0337868445,
-0.0510281622,
-0.0540346801,
0.0086138751,
-0.0139864609,
0.0045349477,
0.0286683477,
0.0120566022,
0.0061048972,
0.0795649961,
-0.0110296588,
0.0102207083,
0.0366855077,
-0.0278269183,
-0.0124359885,
0.0543220863,
-0.0591492392,
0.0217020027,
-0.0245287195,
-0.0130823627,
-0.0362793766,
-0.0459037498,
0.093347922,
0.0137121817,
0.0434406213,
-0.0411799997,
-0.0688927397,
-0.0181205496,
0.0051956628,
-0.055300612,
-0.0336356536,
0.0086152414,
0.0902466625,
0.0056158686,
0.0439441204,
-0.0474017225,
-0.0123186642,
-0.0414761305,
0.0112643,
-0.0587737337,
-0.0859008282,
0.0145917991,
-0.002098657,
-0.0029052291,
0.0225374047,
0.0439827144,
0.0303036589,
0.0320799947,
-0.0463827662,
-0.0506098196,
-0.0365023017,
-0.0024180349,
0.0008092949,
-0.0546681099,
0.0236097574,
-0.0254369061,
-0.0335798003,
0.0123363333,
0.0080493465,
0.0656248331,
0.0048872386,
-0.028887067,
0.0594878085,
0.03399048,
-0.0099775428,
-0.0116779199,
0.0377994031,
0.0353379734,
-0.0061084544,
0.0922510028,
-0.0072506722,
-0.0610759072,
0.0064415783,
0.0207236223,
-0.0268828385,
-0.0545988269,
0.0449365899,
0.0406740494,
0.0117988819,
0.0037386888,
0.0276323464,
-0.0397729538,
0.02825642,
-0.046371948,
0.0123309456,
0.0050282707,
-0.0369641893,
0.0319803916,
0.0298176203,
-0.0051696929,
0.0198858306,
0.0467582829,
-0.0403658077,
-0.0221279897,
-0.0034867094,
-0.0606843531,
-0.0533236563,
-0.015092412,
-0.0089639816,
0.0300601982,
-0.0448189005,
-0.0145896664,
-0.0291141011,
-0.0150620723,
-0.0160071142,
-0.0187808871,
0.008737701,
-0.0655035153,
0.0148209147,
0.0611071065,
0.0152392136,
-0.0019040415,
-0.0951236188,
0.0114142485,
-0.054363817,
-0.0060670716,
-0.0497256666,
-6.448183812e-33,
-0.0037283993,
-0.0241046138,
0.0516761541,
0.0549612492,
0.0097126523,
-0.0777822584,
-0.0386696123,
0.0148158213,
0.0197776314,
0.0020480298,
-0.0315979458,
-0.0097430125,
0.0050793593,
0.0161123872,
0.0202323943,
-0.0029115649,
0.0603153817,
0.0277230199,
-0.0250746049,
0.0156146996,
0.0414102785,
0.0043600462,
-0.0288373139,
-0.0782022774,
-0.0011084887,
-0.0279571917,
-0.0063296766,
0.007319021,
-0.0253273826,
0.0639217868,
-0.0032168375,
0.0443892553,
-0.0019162396,
0.0017504136,
-0.0000602315,
-0.0102126868,
-0.0324235111,
0.0062543782,
0.0538606122,
0.0323226117,
0.0152851017,
-0.0164992437,
-0.0285440031,
-0.0008829467,
-0.0027585775,
0.0468526855,
0.0135358265,
-0.0120925205,
-0.0766412988,
0.0215421207,
-0.0143995713,
-0.0078403158,
-0.0208329167,
-0.0438994132,
0.0087250173,
0.0506854877,
-0.0204633307,
0.0077594202,
-0.0393462516,
0.0380660295,
-0.0295512658,
-0.0126846973,
-0.0262777284,
0.0004483099,
-0.0196832158,
0.0377888791,
0.0286661815,
0.0280947071,
0.0058574853,
0.0010102732,
-0.0568875037,
0.0697257668,
-0.0152755696,
0.072786063,
-0.0428868234,
-0.0081554353,
0.0091059813,
0.0480751805,
0.0450833403,
0.0246729571,
0.0616082512,
0.0445718989,
-0.034563899,
-0.0198294669,
-0.0259382483,
0.016685199,
-0.0527097024,
-0.0784848556,
0.0292515401,
0.0434260219,
0.0253430791,
-0.0108270617,
0.0243256167,
-0.0373106748,
-0.0473443381,
-0.0057502599,
-0.0256023593,
-0.0084830932,
-0.0109300725,
0.0021702929,
-0.0550356396,
-0.0166547559,
-0.0034921004,
-0.0274412315,
-0.0289202239,
0.0402099453,
-0.0044382312,
0.0235738792,
-0.0168839898,
-0.0059048315,
-0.0151908901,
-0.0366035737,
-0.0391446836,
0.021340508,
0.0204622839,
0.0090417657,
-0.0521021821,
0.051857017,
-0.0315911919,
-0.0203519631,
-0.0319234766,
-0.0973127857,
0.0112282652,
-0.0067342166,
-0.0416124985,
-0.0451790206,
-0.0463887155,
-0.0064919461,
0.0605154745,
-0.0236876812,
-0.010510291,
-0.0223000292,
3.093e-7,
-0.0465949066,
0.049218744,
-0.0447689146,
-0.0013256101,
0.0173094645,
0.0610717684,
0.0000541983,
0.028272314,
0.0464722775,
0.0282808524,
0.0322776362,
0.0050778091,
0.0348118059,
0.0397542343,
-0.0844679698,
-0.0021345003,
-0.0232052952,
-0.0229343362,
-0.0533598512,
-0.0111974282,
0.0282149818,
0.0487905107,
0.0401237831,
0.0156269483,
0.00601761,
0.0112876724,
0.0459293127,
-0.0785299018,
-0.0696633756,
-0.0025417299,
0.0214662924,
-0.0330250748,
-0.0069467793,
0.0031497472,
0.0093414402,
0.0074855811,
-0.0142950518,
0.054804597,
-0.0130459769,
-0.0540829003,
-0.0122638484,
-0.0066944938,
0.0190790892,
-0.0186295137,
0.0381420255,
0.0073781139,
-0.0142594958,
-0.002430635,
-0.0179483406,
-0.0085711563,
-0.005494989,
-0.0377069004,
-0.0377432257,
0.0062008421,
-0.0166169982,
0.0044937576,
-0.0080372738,
-0.0410387889,
0.0363115333,
-0.0195831489,
-0.0377397127,
-0.050758265,
-0.04383187,
0.0103273578,
0.0037301295,
-0.0272868741,
0.0495510884,
2.412659222e-34,
0.0373680517,
0.023031259,
-0.0030777252,
0.0274276715,
0.0614791363,
0.0230039638,
0.0066947332,
0.0222328808,
0.0615192167,
-0.0605893023,
-0.0368839838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01118v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01118v3 | PokeLLMon: A Human-Parity Agent for Pokemon Battles with Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T03:22:12 | 2024-04-02T15:46:35 | Sihao Hu, Tiansheng Huang, Ling Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce PokeLLMon, the first LLM-embodied agent that achieves
human-parity performance in tactical battle games, as demonstrated in Pokemon
battles. The design of PokeLLMon incorporates three key strategies: (i)
In-context reinforcement learning that instantly consumes text-based feedback
derived from battles to iteratively refine the policy; (ii) Knowledge-augmented
generation that retrieves external knowledge to counteract hallucination and
enables the agent to act timely and properly; (iii) Consistent action
generation to mitigate the panic switching phenomenon when the agent faces a
powerful opponent and wants to elude the battle. We show that online battles
against human demonstrates PokeLLMon's human-like battle strategies and
just-in-time decision making, achieving 49% of win rate in the Ladder
competitions and 56% of win rate in the invited battles. Our implementation and
playable battle logs are available at: https://github.com/git-disl/PokeLLMon. | [
0.023931602,
0.0038126502,
-0.0096147554,
0.0440611877,
0.0260722619,
0.0070600035,
-0.045185931,
0.0081634261,
-0.0470336974,
-0.018483771,
-0.0531133451,
-0.0131124686,
-0.038535051,
0.0334790647,
0.0302092694,
-0.0537775792,
0.0069715925,
-0.0324862078,
0.0522140786,
-0.0142514864,
-0.0027951556,
-0.046767164,
-0.0352746174,
0.0360358134,
0.0049732681,
-0.0049230959,
-0.0751736537,
0.017181918,
0.0345334038,
-0.1070015728,
0.0224250313,
-0.0513494909,
0.0329048298,
0.0040099607,
0.0000018319,
-0.0306525566,
0.0243290532,
-0.035496328,
-0.014460844,
-0.0398319513,
0.0087302839,
0.005019967,
-0.0092205852,
0.009178645,
-0.072190173,
0.0119934753,
0.0513010621,
0.0587205328,
0.0885351896,
0.070555076,
0.0187599026,
-0.017362535,
0.0270549152,
-0.0009354551,
0.0081617245,
-0.0270992946,
-0.022227617,
-0.0464162491,
0.0211849157,
-0.0136871161,
0.0017017042,
-0.0332999229,
0.0401170552,
0.0012403933,
-0.0340599306,
0.0463934802,
-0.002184334,
0.0267165396,
-0.0225101896,
0.0313177444,
-0.0241014287,
-0.0129933031,
0.025766246,
0.0098578315,
0.0340546966,
-0.0168775078,
-0.0037853145,
0.0374320969,
-0.0191348158,
0.0254926179,
0.0148122022,
0.0119062029,
0.0234854668,
-0.00262521,
-0.0318178423,
0.0794029385,
-0.0136692468,
-0.0541917533,
-0.00399868,
0.0151636321,
0.0128919603,
-0.0288844183,
-0.0008057705,
0.0381208584,
-0.0539271422,
0.0001107464,
-0.0488908961,
-0.032613799,
-0.0020587123,
-0.093543455,
0.0102169076,
0.0014263784,
-0.0135465497,
0.0108900992,
0.0023609141,
0.0446317531,
0.0121357422,
0.0409753993,
0.0058567934,
0.0278946161,
-0.0186591949,
0.0179298557,
-0.0520080477,
0.0359873697,
-0.0103091625,
-0.0256100129,
-0.0440928712,
0.0210055113,
-0.0375719406,
0.039374277,
-0.0281915441,
0.0180578399,
0.0195156392,
0.009685264,
-0.0496924371,
-0.0522410534,
-0.0351334251,
-0.0069586299,
0.0203124546,
-0.0344472863,
-0.0029251149,
-0.005021947,
-0.0459857322,
-0.0200160723,
0.0261330772,
0.0826094672,
0.0039559752,
-0.0165202338,
-0.0013172628,
0.022915775,
0.0303660668,
-0.0584792644,
-0.0110304961,
-0.0485222414,
0.0229937732,
-0.0448004641,
-0.0090461699,
-0.0213341787,
0.0296089556,
0.001519102,
0.0477899611,
0.077852644,
-0.0085148523,
0.0125537608,
0.0027923486,
-0.0071818437,
-0.057043869,
0.0486814752,
0.0804260373,
0.0001530846,
-0.0170129575,
-0.0062811337,
0.0414105579,
0.0507219881,
-0.0041554966,
-0.0097995596,
0.0022347132,
-0.0272464212,
-0.0124396319,
0.073972553,
0.0244038831,
0.0136134,
-0.0529616326,
-0.0194129646,
0.0869603381,
0.0582122058,
-0.0051504741,
0.0285344776,
0.0217679515,
0.0020140882,
0.0198473427,
-0.0121803991,
-0.0199431013,
0.0539731793,
-0.0107345702,
0.0017112956,
-0.0467374548,
0.0117638633,
-0.001645339,
-0.0578644872,
0.0110636326,
0.0144549897,
0.0006200548,
0.0200669821,
0.0417212583,
0.0113463448,
-0.0484670773,
0.055043906,
0.0108680381,
-0.0370266587,
-0.0110893259,
-0.0572649501,
0.035729453,
0.0984710902,
0.0102816839,
-0.0500155389,
-0.0291908104,
-0.0051820679,
-0.0230165515,
0.0991289988,
-0.0258337427,
0.0017331674,
0.0062648975,
-0.0234591644,
-0.0259732585,
-0.0185385793,
-0.0050107343,
0.044079829,
-0.0148706324,
0.0297612138,
-0.043948859,
0.0532977805,
-0.0143337948,
0.0478000306,
0.0035622814,
-0.0297964737,
-0.0073984927,
-0.006323887,
0.045224119,
0.0327484235,
-0.0302665699,
-0.0076008099,
0.0387853272,
-0.004347051,
-0.0150569333,
0.0515558496,
0.02226099,
0.0187953897,
0.0631675869,
-0.0242404807,
0.0039113299,
0.0172780026,
0.0182778202,
0.01307273,
-0.001296508,
-0.0346374959,
0.063921608,
-0.0137325982,
0.0251610801,
-0.0058683367,
-0.0153689999,
0.0182047263,
0.0158546511,
-0.0047948183,
-0.0468415916,
0.0184483323,
0.0071332697,
0.0293155275,
-0.0808937401,
-0.0190607943,
0.0536756963,
0.0202181116,
0.0121473707,
0.0135932276,
0.0204582196,
-0.0281933416,
-0.007817965,
-0.0717547759,
-0.009317481,
-0.0094720144,
0.0052030007,
0.0121662132,
-0.0504306704,
-0.0225125868,
-0.0153398542,
-0.0282652061,
0.0372103974,
-0.0019937416,
-0.011475536,
0.0357253551,
0.0225918926,
0.0043726731,
-0.0314614885,
0.037369851,
0.0076415003,
0.0152682075,
-0.0286072362,
0.0149607649,
-0.0345145948,
0.0412845761,
-0.0414308645,
0.0608329475,
-0.0232120343,
-0.0924354121,
0.0841789618,
-0.0438439623,
-0.0091368575,
0.0319618657,
0.0312063359,
0.020114664,
0.0941120982,
-0.0056919022,
-0.048639264,
0.0450330339,
0.0144582018,
-0.0211941637,
-0.046496775,
-0.0125672733,
0.035446506,
0.0906785801,
-0.0445087887,
0.0369878784,
-0.0497026742,
0.0067547327,
0.0208398271,
-0.0727125332,
-0.0471974723,
0.0157183651,
-0.0418763719,
-0.0227274913,
-0.0476394333,
-0.0140826115,
0.083642073,
0.0038464963,
0.0002942545,
-0.0152617767,
-0.0278624389,
-0.0019180301,
0.0610796548,
-0.0129373325,
0.0213181376,
-0.051176846,
-0.0017145183,
-0.0115083661,
-0.0381404459,
0.0180788003,
-0.0404231623,
0.0166970082,
-0.0479779653,
-0.0102098202,
0.0353704467,
-0.0373221971,
-0.0216479935,
0.0057362611,
-0.0491834581,
-0.0182641111,
-0.0394823439,
-0.0616137572,
-0.0439613797,
-0.0354182981,
0.0314064696,
0.0104357712,
-0.0133595066,
-0.0253601801,
-0.0109681077,
-0.0457545593,
0.0703829527,
0.0786401629,
0.0261205398,
-0.0400972031,
0.0482494533,
0.0766128972,
0.0736976936,
-0.0650183186,
-0.0317363627,
0.0141398711,
-0.0078769187,
-0.0363447927,
-0.0141243516,
0.0227552019,
0.0211401302,
-0.0836866796,
0.0067326082,
0.0787540451,
0.0149814915,
0.0107214889,
0.0036934244,
-0.0669237599,
-0.0016820901,
-0.0082770856,
0.0110755153,
-0.037097577,
-0.007215017,
-0.0217466056,
0.0606048442,
0.016782945,
-0.0253197383,
0.0232476145,
-0.095645532,
-0.00523121,
0.0231857654,
0.0169319641,
-0.026341714,
0.0201579742,
-0.0188553277,
-0.0056347079,
-0.0083735902,
0.0280594621,
0.0198294148,
-0.0182437208,
0.0046695848,
-0.0049552368,
0.0749257728,
0.001056258,
-0.0749960318,
0.0187580679,
0.0587522089,
0.0688850433,
-0.0352863334,
-0.0787249655,
-0.0489548072,
0.0382360965,
0.0346259922,
0.0018439596,
-0.0075560231,
-0.0168107543,
-0.0133165186,
0.0026868442,
0.0002294862,
-0.0075514331,
-0.0305414721,
0.061036326,
0.0488709062,
-0.0223924369,
-0.0185015574,
-0.0225019027,
-0.0184956547,
0.0158331338,
0.0378113799,
-0.0333960615,
-0.0632654503,
-0.0685073584,
-0.027004119,
0.0075684781,
-0.0360588245,
-0.0340209194,
-0.0010474037,
0.0153818214,
0.0097291498,
-0.0891716778,
-0.0699212626,
0.0191806648,
0.0568417497,
0.012318518,
0.0082788402,
-0.0567124784,
0.0011371569,
-0.0058590304,
-0.0167158991,
0.0137280365,
0.019434521,
-0.0327499807,
-0.0429236442,
0.0005573218,
-0.046628654,
0.0312815197,
0.0418370515,
0.0329403989,
-0.0145281218,
0.0236993097,
0.075179331,
0.0175025463,
0.0165007096,
0.0342041664,
-0.0222364515,
0.0778652728,
0.0174370743,
-0.0060762982,
0.0342082195,
0.0320227109,
0.0149681401,
0.0226427,
0.019889297,
-0.057003893,
-0.0504329689,
0.014222417,
0.0362120979,
-0.0557133928,
-0.0301779527,
0.00445526,
-0.0155576542,
0.0459061638,
-0.0386225991,
-0.0366577506,
0.010371156,
-0.0005716889,
-0.0230262298,
0.0178885814,
-0.0506480709,
-0.0090237577,
0.0075070844,
0.0278003737,
0.0292862374,
0.0125497961,
-0.0052737645,
-0.0442614034,
-0.0150236925,
0.0541887172,
0.0597519875,
0.0263453182,
0.0078179101,
0.0279529784,
0.0366814025,
0.0428506248,
0.0114713535,
0.0077460143,
0.0424007252,
0.0569560193,
0.0140921883,
-0.0339110345,
-0.0120285088,
0.0225934424,
-0.0407577083,
-0.0146376323,
0.0546474494,
0.0220943857,
0.0712127537,
0.0694809109,
0.0274472106,
-0.0437239073,
0.0065041953,
0.0063699046,
0.0072010625,
-0.0148671521,
-0.039665889,
0.0148409558,
0.0476017259,
-0.022946585,
-0.0055624028,
0.0374632254,
0.030496126,
0.0935752168,
-0.0126043689,
-0.0072409352,
-0.024139002,
-0.0121696163,
0.0001105095,
0.051081378,
-0.005608961,
-0.0275789425,
-0.0656119585,
-0.0320479944,
0.0075380593,
0.1180754602,
0.0080569396,
-0.0513036586,
0.019550506,
-0.0040205489,
-0.0043372982,
-0.0117823835,
-0.0370697491,
0.0163111873,
0.0038000741,
-0.0043012868,
-0.0112103252,
-4.740370518e-33,
-0.0286703706,
-0.0606192611,
0.0634022504,
-0.0088413004,
-0.0603085272,
-0.0163204893,
-0.0552265458,
0.0108589474,
0.0129747866,
0.0109517919,
-0.0111267101,
0.0116065443,
-0.0121905245,
-0.0310204122,
0.0403971486,
-0.0345520563,
0.0238939226,
0.0002961143,
-0.0193062983,
-0.0308866184,
0.0133172497,
0.022896098,
-0.0062165507,
-0.0208360609,
0.0164093543,
0.0188799258,
-0.0190156866,
0.0248083007,
-0.0468014441,
0.0441989861,
0.0003639864,
-0.0105335237,
0.0024429581,
-0.0043719918,
-0.016627796,
0.0040819542,
-0.0383317955,
-0.0354225934,
-0.0363531038,
-0.0006798782,
-0.0111722751,
-0.0068289516,
0.0311003495,
0.0242014788,
-0.0428609923,
0.0168331955,
0.0045317444,
-0.0328470878,
0.0142062781,
-0.0074517238,
-0.0144600794,
0.0081264004,
0.0116799809,
-0.0293798614,
0.0386264063,
-0.019653298,
-0.0321404822,
-0.0412828885,
-0.0525245219,
0.0448492765,
-0.0002897758,
-0.0754305869,
0.0326162353,
0.074004136,
0.0577196479,
0.0693931878,
0.0510174744,
-0.0117062554,
-0.0571889691,
-0.0222385898,
0.0322766341,
0.057665173,
0.0591638051,
0.0407184027,
0.0260561183,
-0.0202658456,
-0.0239840578,
0.0542474203,
0.0647777393,
0.0432961285,
0.0138148135,
0.0616799854,
-0.0511508994,
0.0063067325,
0.027747713,
0.0030570359,
0.0032857461,
-0.0879123509,
-0.00192523,
-0.0208070427,
0.0050529172,
-0.0596099943,
0.0266925879,
0.0090273684,
0.0075790691,
0.0152517911,
-0.0295747593,
0.019989375,
-0.017531842,
-0.0431989431,
-0.0116660642,
-0.0297648069,
0.0007093895,
-0.005871152,
0.0390906781,
0.0455012508,
-0.0076920618,
0.0357992612,
-0.0204654522,
-0.0040733651,
-0.0163662154,
0.02099034,
0.0580827184,
-0.0141662452,
0.0582686253,
-0.0610530637,
-0.0050905864,
-0.0030910438,
-0.035525091,
-0.0761675239,
-0.0315470845,
0.0518533178,
-0.0210694671,
-0.005738222,
-0.0274695344,
0.0429314785,
-0.0439981744,
0.0810342282,
-0.0376803726,
-0.0578712709,
-0.0327069126,
-0.010396949,
2.651e-7,
-0.0357546769,
0.0153339375,
-0.0017556937,
-0.0088197412,
-0.0051117949,
0.0822333246,
-0.06397181,
0.0352743343,
-0.0137487724,
-0.035668321,
0.0364083387,
0.0617785566,
0.0288922265,
0.001266586,
-0.0855847225,
-0.0611341894,
-0.055190213,
-0.002969336,
-0.0191051085,
0.0005596101,
0.035237167,
0.0035352283,
0.0401200987,
-0.0068468023,
0.0394593701,
-0.0038501457,
0.0002672648,
-0.029000273,
0.007050483,
-0.0482643768,
-0.0366855636,
0.0190723855,
-0.0568988994,
-0.041067265,
-0.0024398174,
0.0315656774,
0.0208126716,
0.0283977259,
-0.027391972,
-0.0132653639,
-0.0089877825,
0.0118144099,
-0.0206300281,
-0.0121984594,
0.0176063012,
0.034615688,
-0.004608707,
-0.0471985042,
-0.0240811408,
-0.0418745615,
-0.0733187795,
-0.051246237,
-0.0333808698,
-0.0210678149,
-0.0343736373,
-0.018813828,
0.0179315954,
-0.0566735789,
-0.0023353884,
0.0238014422,
-0.026657192,
-0.0543838963,
-0.0753532127,
0.0693280622,
0.0096379211,
0.0067966105,
0.0071245157,
1.770558405e-34,
-0.0292028412,
-0.0115249269,
-0.0146348132,
0.0138477506,
0.0310496911,
0.0458240658,
0.0297284685,
0.0027416376,
0.073632881,
0.0191666577,
-0.0058858478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01117v1 | DTS-SQL: Decomposed Text-to-SQL with Small Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T03:21:00 | 2024-02-02T03:21:00 | Mohammadreza Pourreza, Davood Rafiei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.HC | Leading models for the text-to-SQL task heavily rely on proprietary Large
Language Models (LLMs), posing concerns over data privacy. Closing the
performance gap between small open-source models and large proprietary models
is crucial to mitigate this reliance. To this end, we introduce a novel
two-stage fine-tuning approach that decomposes the task into two simpler tasks.
Through comprehensive evaluation on two large cross-domain datasets and two
small LLMs, we show that this approach improves execution accuracy by 3 to 7
percent, effectively aligning the performance of open-source models with their
proprietary counterparts. | [
-0.0062632756,
0.0937620848,
-0.0151367523,
0.0430443175,
-0.0253399108,
0.0013681938,
0.057239417,
0.0004264865,
0.0136666857,
-0.0324183144,
-0.022103684,
0.0040457458,
0.0023994313,
0.0477209166,
0.0293501057,
0.0046333959,
0.0210985746,
-0.0219952054,
-0.055997543,
-0.000556886,
-0.045689784,
0.0213780496,
0.0518258177,
-0.0280446503,
0.0257235076,
-0.0209165923,
-0.0011807302,
0.0034395875,
-0.0105807194,
0.0129861552,
-0.0109641058,
0.0455862172,
0.0350778252,
0.0544238612,
0.0000020354,
-0.0398980826,
-0.0530165248,
0.0567920916,
-0.0216943063,
0.0284039192,
0.0482796617,
-0.0411179587,
0.0490944535,
0.0367324948,
-0.0336260125,
-0.0121032735,
0.0101189306,
0.0250216145,
0.0632482395,
0.0793086737,
-0.0109456424,
-0.042635154,
-0.037750531,
-0.0205178913,
0.0004598171,
-0.0394725688,
0.0170380771,
0.0107758306,
-0.0069455919,
0.0122192269,
0.0058340239,
0.0135960886,
-0.0448170677,
0.0212735236,
-0.021921834,
-0.0467910096,
-0.0024368076,
0.0186312497,
0.028909117,
0.0103608957,
0.0282458421,
-0.0180222895,
0.0194358211,
0.0233358871,
0.0240684673,
-0.0157153476,
0.0104199033,
0.0075279064,
0.005657861,
0.0146430479,
-0.0135146128,
-0.023137128,
-0.0022644075,
-0.0020886117,
-0.0460483916,
0.0154628158,
-0.0103534255,
0.0007918663,
-0.0213893615,
-0.0328816697,
0.0071353819,
-0.049837362,
0.0485600755,
-0.0209288057,
-0.0344202928,
-0.0184325576,
-0.0619493797,
-0.0294155627,
0.0088515915,
-0.0441463441,
0.0292511918,
0.0310587026,
0.0425274596,
0.044032,
0.0141426474,
0.0123048089,
0.0199157875,
0.000025791,
-0.0163426287,
-0.0359458514,
-0.0122583937,
0.0412805453,
0.0009245269,
0.049516838,
-0.1265345216,
0.0292090196,
-0.0185901374,
0.0388575122,
0.0087210173,
0.0373122767,
0.0376218446,
0.0022740266,
-0.0157342423,
-0.0312587097,
0.0022726103,
-0.0358990133,
0.0107200211,
0.0402132422,
0.0119611705,
-0.0563894995,
-0.0057126177,
-0.0397150107,
0.0200708471,
-0.0393917933,
0.0173266809,
0.0327064097,
0.0021410997,
-0.0052673607,
-0.0871729404,
-0.069958441,
-0.0125426408,
-0.0212187059,
-0.0296773929,
-0.0290458687,
0.0523659252,
0.0039934833,
-0.0179746635,
-0.1010143161,
-0.0458023958,
0.0156904832,
-0.0343921706,
0.0557142459,
-0.0269714072,
0.0225018542,
0.0091304351,
-0.0136282202,
0.045949731,
0.0670452192,
0.0192541536,
0.0565487258,
0.0210716147,
-0.0162043311,
-0.03456036,
0.0135178035,
0.0197296459,
0.0491030701,
-0.0672593191,
0.0849670991,
-0.0082601272,
-0.0138684427,
0.0211783815,
0.0539530665,
0.0121906828,
-0.0255051274,
0.0744396448,
0.0268905386,
0.0281585772,
0.0315040872,
-0.0386125706,
0.0668706149,
-0.0140517438,
-0.0444222167,
-0.0348431505,
-0.029318545,
-0.0272548851,
-0.0105679715,
0.0202233605,
0.0325852297,
-0.0151743386,
-0.0183471665,
-0.0068020006,
-0.0490185283,
0.0202715974,
0.0424821749,
0.022998983,
0.0207813773,
0.0279006548,
0.0349583365,
-0.0141026424,
-0.0188521855,
-0.0073586302,
-0.0211266167,
-0.0400090441,
0.0713164806,
-0.0049683983,
-0.0223293267,
0.0186997987,
-0.0358423553,
0.0431751795,
0.0018528471,
0.0061530634,
-0.0024347613,
0.0341956243,
-0.0058077895,
-0.0485657565,
0.0424431004,
0.0435766913,
-0.01021918,
0.0204657968,
0.0127011184,
0.0234371852,
-0.0388128981,
-0.0144651858,
0.0212430377,
-0.018286474,
-0.0320833325,
0.0473178662,
0.0076138591,
0.0201843753,
0.03551713,
-0.0167865697,
0.0014424182,
0.0013906318,
0.0289505254,
-0.0220692493,
-0.0614963584,
0.0659100041,
0.011130318,
0.0010479062,
-0.0011955515,
0.0205253921,
0.0395852663,
-0.0497481152,
-0.0095626563,
0.0020609866,
0.0009699871,
-0.0014082422,
-0.0194917526,
0.0152272107,
-0.0164468735,
0.0007948543,
-0.0417608507,
0.0112844445,
-0.0323691703,
0.0167849865,
-0.0287057161,
-0.0748462752,
0.0299103241,
-0.0322832651,
0.043054726,
-0.0445650667,
-0.0166158415,
0.0508787595,
-0.0156552531,
-0.0048221531,
-0.0240296591,
-0.0314571895,
-0.0164185949,
0.0306308959,
0.0085205426,
0.0748629123,
-0.0065600537,
0.0394207239,
-0.026877176,
0.0040656086,
-0.0531679392,
-0.0323018096,
-0.017920034,
0.0052486444,
0.0315774232,
-0.0120959496,
-0.0250408147,
0.0169568136,
-0.0288783293,
-0.0059551871,
0.043791052,
-0.0690057874,
-0.0321224332,
-0.0345637649,
0.0585488603,
-0.0161349718,
0.0428138487,
0.0110218562,
-0.0238923542,
-0.0495926253,
0.004669535,
-0.0264240727,
0.0473144799,
-0.012569448,
-0.0683667436,
-0.0135235321,
-0.010506873,
-0.0473232158,
-0.0096352529,
-0.0220893193,
-0.0074511147,
-0.020908311,
-0.0388789028,
0.0493168943,
0.0119987698,
0.0209461264,
-0.0389676727,
-0.0109061105,
0.0178147741,
0.0235646404,
0.0116336746,
-0.0172716118,
0.032128185,
0.0075737541,
0.0315104164,
0.009750627,
-0.0193149094,
0.0624645501,
-0.0403959118,
0.0353847146,
-0.0251704846,
-0.0107652443,
-0.0433548056,
0.0252438858,
-0.0125059392,
0.0472983643,
0.0148925614,
-0.0365414023,
-0.0257238094,
-0.0015491813,
0.0450372808,
-0.0614011697,
0.0912271664,
0.0243945941,
-0.020377025,
-0.0117074912,
-0.0373982377,
-0.0070723128,
-0.051461447,
-0.0306692719,
0.0213890374,
0.0779274181,
-0.0405040309,
-0.0379318967,
-0.0204123948,
0.0045559006,
0.0345630981,
0.0108273514,
-0.014367315,
-0.0071962643,
-0.0368459597,
-0.0089632021,
-0.0329164453,
0.0079624541,
-0.0123023419,
-0.0003374805,
0.0518451482,
0.0254063997,
-0.0280638281,
0.0049593765,
-0.0294924807,
0.0079113087,
-0.0047248555,
-0.0178349968,
0.0294670649,
-0.0025003555,
-0.0379727259,
0.0127588445,
0.0749082863,
0.0051256013,
0.0115227066,
-0.0103708301,
0.0495454557,
0.0189090557,
0.0322063491,
0.0269581098,
-0.1450498104,
-0.0317805223,
0.0032563731,
0.0709948316,
0.0420127772,
-0.050566338,
-0.0095868558,
-0.1068244949,
0.0301893558,
0.0032624716,
-0.0081583625,
-0.0106943781,
-0.0361872651,
-0.0158061534,
-0.0406805426,
-0.000274216,
0.0101692574,
-0.0303128567,
-0.0126605565,
-0.0025470578,
-0.00354498,
-0.0691746399,
-0.0203160457,
-0.0500739105,
0.0157063324,
0.0199130289,
0.0202594902,
0.0393970758,
-0.0067971931,
0.0027164589,
-0.0028657869,
-0.0334799476,
-0.0075165639,
0.0592311174,
-0.0073646833,
0.0135030327,
0.0045273933,
0.0592290126,
-0.0362329483,
0.0355562903,
-0.0005940846,
0.0735697001,
-0.0197417606,
0.0246313885,
0.0236535463,
-0.0453418009,
0.0149832694,
0.0712184235,
-0.0131067485,
-0.0350440443,
-0.014246433,
-0.0022966124,
-0.0150579726,
-0.0265391134,
-0.0022466618,
0.0498023927,
-0.0504858941,
-0.07407666,
-0.0362555757,
0.0062375069,
0.0200490355,
0.0022267522,
-0.0034960932,
0.0626145676,
0.0025093816,
-0.0390008353,
-0.0606628433,
0.0107707139,
-0.0608404838,
0.0098754354,
-0.034664344,
0.050736662,
0.0078729577,
-0.0193382036,
-0.0397590362,
-0.0222664922,
-0.0748057961,
-0.0607616417,
0.0183564089,
-0.0003870264,
0.0118568763,
-0.0012550534,
0.0016822494,
-0.0913443416,
0.0027081391,
0.0734023675,
-0.0365190729,
-0.0451489314,
0.0173729695,
-0.0162407272,
-0.01763561,
0.0485071503,
-0.0323838666,
-0.0064326432,
0.0331353433,
-0.0849825814,
0.0143189803,
-0.0065658488,
0.0098402333,
0.0821415782,
0.0627735928,
0.0397877656,
0.0055125961,
-0.0256250985,
0.0569739155,
-0.0533357896,
-0.0420300663,
-0.0415713377,
0.0096220709,
0.0371089615,
0.004341071,
0.0063163736,
0.010631524,
0.0321502686,
0.026576804,
-0.0817394629,
0.0348972157,
0.0142422849,
0.0092936847,
0.059267994,
-0.0522611216,
-0.0119538577,
0.0673066825,
0.0364181437,
0.0529376641,
-0.0295908246,
0.0203840155,
0.0084511293,
0.0468980893,
-0.028746048,
0.031108629,
0.0052936221,
-0.0352693275,
-0.032776583,
-0.0333042741,
0.0169365797,
0.0243792757,
0.0477953218,
-0.0092446906,
-0.0094691049,
-0.0269976743,
0.0208132882,
0.0247964505,
0.0175662115,
-0.0248096548,
-0.0248324182,
-0.035739217,
0.0040744683,
0.0961486772,
0.0257437751,
0.0030218058,
-0.0305391848,
-0.0732006654,
-0.0393695123,
-0.0480242893,
-0.001353627,
0.0034996397,
-0.030558452,
-0.0535949133,
-0.0383039936,
-0.0250457767,
-0.0077229128,
-0.0009779482,
-0.0336248726,
-0.0123071885,
0.0226208773,
0.039145384,
0.0306046624,
-0.0396595374,
-0.0604372472,
-0.0190934092,
0.0103289243,
-0.0681243017,
0.0111160418,
-6.308017866e-33,
0.0091777835,
0.0100610154,
-0.0100824526,
0.0122317811,
0.019044701,
-0.0136977099,
0.0233808663,
-0.0086031929,
-0.0235916656,
0.007691748,
-0.0526449233,
0.0257656071,
0.0374491997,
0.0462696441,
0.0137592098,
0.0107430005,
0.0472001359,
-0.0463043675,
-0.0253649112,
0.0165917687,
0.0645201206,
0.0198714398,
0.0187610034,
-0.0534032099,
0.0072379876,
-0.0089135263,
-0.0533724837,
0.0236769021,
0.0106001524,
0.0099546462,
0.0154765798,
-0.0168260206,
0.0137122646,
-0.0252907332,
-0.0277020596,
-0.0115257418,
-0.0577396788,
0.0289423969,
-0.0019286007,
0.0038254913,
0.0430283509,
-0.0374820232,
0.0628066659,
-0.0283815414,
-0.0425675549,
-0.0429528281,
-0.0476100966,
-0.0616812296,
-0.0159648973,
-0.0681041107,
0.0081344023,
0.0389670208,
0.02340414,
0.0146547286,
0.0836252719,
0.0216335189,
-0.0085046692,
-0.0133257601,
-0.0239608735,
0.0172615703,
0.0604189523,
0.0411314778,
0.0454925373,
0.0137437023,
0.0069424892,
-0.0101762423,
0.0327169076,
0.0134219825,
0.0221793372,
0.0376627743,
-0.0264748093,
0.0696224049,
0.0101579372,
0.0676869377,
-0.0232155547,
-0.051848501,
-0.1023299769,
0.0472606905,
-0.090756394,
-0.0310327895,
0.0502827764,
-0.0066511966,
-0.0885738656,
-0.0423793122,
-0.0442220047,
0.0401109867,
-0.0241006073,
0.01402908,
0.004051913,
0.0056907898,
-0.0204519574,
-0.0008310251,
0.0477059893,
-0.0439219736,
-0.0312884822,
0.0145874647,
0.0010217087,
-0.0434485935,
-0.0178808887,
-0.0147735896,
-0.0487027839,
-0.0425725356,
-0.0171663109,
-0.0031105946,
0.015070565,
0.016745789,
0.0378304422,
-0.0098749492,
-0.0838805735,
0.0214904193,
0.0014646886,
0.0491377972,
-0.0084862448,
0.0538732894,
0.027437577,
-0.0284056198,
0.0388503037,
0.0495835207,
0.0251340009,
-0.0099081397,
-0.0002029674,
0.0166234951,
0.040267244,
0.0029568011,
0.0535728484,
0.0136008421,
0.0186958276,
-0.0517303757,
0.0987300426,
0.0255006924,
-0.0108052175,
-0.000392887,
2.735e-7,
0.0483002029,
0.0397449434,
-0.0294965431,
0.0426315404,
0.0120983403,
0.0678953603,
0.0209879335,
0.0437624715,
0.0093658529,
0.0278123319,
0.0069347387,
-0.0292941201,
0.0773031339,
0.0343217775,
-0.0577469207,
-0.0184374414,
0.0237597506,
0.0108015835,
-0.0654943213,
-0.0097413892,
0.020467896,
0.0746378526,
-0.0111834314,
-0.0121440301,
0.0196485687,
-0.0405452512,
0.018683102,
-0.0654773116,
-0.0330334567,
0.048939839,
0.0392810255,
0.0153048057,
-0.0000713651,
0.0086415038,
-0.029660577,
0.049408216,
-0.0461120903,
0.1188706532,
0.0185769517,
0.0452326275,
0.0269741509,
-0.1091963649,
-0.0306273811,
-0.0106761931,
0.0738709718,
-0.0395710878,
-0.0284732152,
0.0342562012,
0.0127031514,
-0.0512491204,
0.0125850616,
0.0054283454,
0.0317314416,
-0.0342772529,
0.0354489759,
0.0336953662,
-0.0045918743,
-0.03669025,
-0.0396393687,
0.0145120267,
-0.0337588266,
-0.0137635963,
0.0317645818,
0.0354188122,
-0.0134448623,
-0.0048865327,
0.0335959196,
2.781608557e-34,
0.0098123923,
0.0047988193,
-0.0027398516,
-0.0289012957,
0.0582203865,
-0.0159423985,
0.0436638258,
-0.016882401,
-0.001984467,
-0.0841608346,
-0.0083093243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01115v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01115v3 | Interpretation of Intracardiac Electrograms Through Textual Representations | 2024-02-02T03:15:13 | 2024-04-12T01:32:32 | William Jongwon Han, Diana Gomez, Avi Alok, Chaojing Duan, Michael A. Rosenberg, Douglas Weber, Emerson Liu, Ding Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.SP, I.2.7; J.3 | Understanding the irregular electrical activity of atrial fibrillation (AFib)
has been a key challenge in electrocardiography. For serious cases of AFib,
catheter ablations are performed to collect intracardiac electrograms (EGMs).
EGMs offer intricately detailed and localized electrical activity of the heart
and are an ideal modality for interpretable cardiac studies. Recent
advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) has allowed some works to utilize
deep learning frameworks to interpret EGMs during AFib. Additionally, language
models (LMs) have shown exceptional performance in being able to generalize to
unseen domains, especially in healthcare. In this study, we are the first to
leverage pretrained LMs for finetuning of EGM interpolation and AFib
classification via masked language modeling. We formulate the EGM as a textual
sequence and present competitive performances on AFib classification compared
against other representations. Lastly, we provide a comprehensive
interpretability study to provide a multi-perspective intuition of the model's
behavior, which could greatly benefit the clinical use. | [
-0.0077070519,
0.0099004088,
0.0096711786,
0.0436520539,
0.0104637928,
0.0306841861,
0.0235228557,
0.0213874783,
-0.025634747,
0.0043135989,
-0.0044090031,
-0.0838872567,
0.0253288858,
0.0895420685,
-0.0135241402,
-0.0618016124,
0.0151862176,
0.0030576261,
0.030241752,
0.0017177283,
0.0143198157,
0.0113313273,
-0.0119860573,
0.0579727143,
0.0177282542,
-0.0181705728,
-0.0101665575,
-0.0172448382,
0.0389768928,
-0.0405147038,
-0.0209296551,
0.0217355229,
-0.0067763412,
0.0351386704,
0.0000021785,
-0.0196505096,
-0.0247485396,
0.0153315933,
-0.0570378937,
-0.0194209106,
0.028358886,
-0.0537442863,
0.0349725783,
-0.014113633,
-0.0726785362,
-0.0017197176,
0.0450767316,
0.0368880257,
0.0745316669,
0.0373215526,
-0.0278652683,
-0.0296019558,
-0.0071839439,
-0.0335556604,
0.0236956608,
-0.0538752638,
0.0125718703,
-0.0397991762,
0.0158886444,
0.0259853732,
-0.0312907696,
0.0406690612,
0.0421942137,
0.0617107861,
0.0513905548,
0.0321817398,
-0.0269989166,
-0.0303569157,
-0.013928948,
0.0895137265,
-0.0425501987,
0.005722513,
-0.0123743592,
-0.0029806795,
-0.0090038953,
0.0023386884,
-0.0414851345,
0.0064793718,
-0.0076968279,
0.0235907547,
0.0464107469,
0.0082818838,
0.0229254831,
-0.0033475251,
-0.0852534026,
-0.0079948921,
-0.0086019021,
0.0172981713,
0.0126367901,
0.006752477,
-0.0607713871,
-0.0245382506,
0.0574865453,
0.0100065526,
0.0113507248,
0.01138754,
-0.0628280342,
-0.0534819327,
0.0084333001,
-0.0312785469,
0.0109089511,
0.0254371036,
0.0034685754,
0.0417349897,
-0.014322402,
-0.0149792414,
-0.0537598431,
0.0685286745,
-0.0151892006,
0.0302094966,
-0.0465610996,
-0.0279933903,
-0.0235687904,
0.0294792503,
-0.0238670576,
-0.0129802218,
-0.05146778,
-0.035458155,
-0.0267029759,
0.0001654528,
-0.0619593449,
0.03500963,
-0.0180550404,
-0.006257657,
-0.0074674259,
-0.0093403906,
-0.0054699332,
0.0024888837,
-0.0194846205,
-0.0237696432,
-0.0101131406,
0.0009376271,
0.0235622674,
-0.0282649305,
0.018525647,
0.0626284704,
0.0286328811,
-0.0076572197,
-0.0233735424,
-0.0546658151,
-0.0151351225,
0.006511467,
0.0195308868,
-0.0493798479,
0.0349248089,
0.0010731675,
0.0191160403,
-0.0551611595,
0.0170390755,
0.0209755134,
0.0034127745,
0.1009197012,
-0.0614824891,
-0.0332732834,
0.0119442604,
0.0400601141,
0.0416267775,
0.019223744,
0.0484380163,
-0.0116569018,
0.0081153996,
-0.0198587421,
0.0217124075,
0.0236145183,
0.0200006887,
-0.0541840419,
-0.0247336589,
-0.0347533822,
0.000078263,
0.0421480313,
0.040147081,
0.0352825001,
0.0143926749,
-0.0519837886,
0.0204564314,
0.043795798,
0.0044177175,
0.0672612861,
0.0487573929,
-0.0211739838,
-0.004837017,
-0.0046783532,
0.005981653,
0.003623202,
0.0123139648,
-0.0089848107,
-0.0499689318,
-0.0495882444,
-0.0102416715,
-0.0547470823,
-0.0315554105,
-0.0215003584,
0.0069419965,
0.0022129864,
0.0619499721,
-0.0221759547,
-0.0562805608,
0.0367529728,
0.0150756622,
0.0102533279,
-0.0231415797,
-0.0277800392,
-0.0094139827,
0.0668656528,
0.0174557734,
-0.0468572639,
0.0216341931,
-0.0594170578,
0.0268350095,
0.0390554518,
0.0188916847,
0.0117460163,
0.047341153,
-0.0577522255,
-0.020638708,
0.0122967092,
-0.012144722,
0.0141708888,
-0.0932045802,
0.0187396742,
-0.0079327337,
-0.0218435582,
-0.0439658575,
0.0415659919,
-0.0297745317,
-0.0557975918,
0.005522402,
0.0493249074,
0.0426589586,
0.0077006849,
-0.019227609,
0.0064800968,
0.0163881984,
-0.0698636919,
-0.035820663,
-0.0164663624,
-0.058494512,
-0.0120098144,
0.0258373469,
-0.0337670296,
-0.0117295831,
-0.0000164199,
-0.0454972163,
-0.0081100641,
-0.0286083817,
-0.0371889398,
0.0135009773,
0.0006884314,
0.0176768117,
0.0090807043,
0.0526937917,
-0.0342495181,
0.0000353557,
0.0092156613,
0.0090122223,
0.0273035429,
-0.0183530953,
0.0367998257,
-0.0161894057,
-0.042672839,
0.0179646257,
0.0098193642,
-0.0148694301,
-0.0127723422,
0.0230721459,
-0.0146689666,
0.0294157639,
-0.0667886809,
-0.0055357446,
0.0147547331,
0.018106373,
0.0219189841,
0.0105516044,
0.0067118285,
-0.0017801082,
-0.0082069831,
-0.0482062139,
0.0174226835,
0.0006350862,
0.0436100028,
0.0656422675,
0.0007111601,
-0.0127048651,
-0.0110340305,
-0.0528831072,
0.0966040045,
0.0089952014,
-0.0274416879,
-0.0251208041,
-0.0066764569,
0.0091524245,
0.0245547853,
0.0028577496,
-0.0534423105,
-0.003607712,
-0.0342975929,
-0.0209829472,
0.0578948669,
0.0034999012,
0.0808212608,
0.0093283942,
0.0042814156,
-0.005095405,
0.0135500953,
-0.0084746554,
0.0247958433,
-0.0163712502,
-0.0385087952,
0.0002733473,
0.1236135736,
0.0395452939,
0.0005262971,
-0.0294168089,
0.0104269795,
-0.0081275087,
-0.0247591697,
-0.0757554695,
-0.0186724775,
-0.0095487451,
0.067955263,
0.0009419945,
-0.0218463968,
0.1027028039,
0.0001061184,
-0.0025443735,
-0.0563919619,
-0.0360602178,
-0.0440814309,
0.0435228944,
-0.0281484984,
0.032303229,
-0.0015948209,
-0.0331120752,
-0.0106396349,
0.0300995335,
-0.0449252836,
-0.0505291969,
0.0640647784,
-0.0468658246,
-0.0132153053,
0.0157269165,
-0.0001505202,
-0.0466552749,
-0.0399234518,
-0.015703233,
0.0010979109,
0.0245122723,
0.0371297598,
-0.0405182615,
0.0727779642,
-0.0237420667,
0.0266244933,
0.0036188881,
-0.0152003439,
-0.0180215016,
0.0469791032,
0.002728014,
-0.0091031957,
0.0204515718,
-0.0362452753,
0.0316390581,
0.0410437062,
-0.0216764398,
0.0325905569,
-0.0660933554,
0.0140372263,
-0.0283772834,
-0.0423893854,
-0.0307711698,
-0.0014289652,
-0.0002152671,
-0.0665817782,
-0.0092427274,
0.1353976578,
0.0264846291,
-0.0677688271,
0.0230740625,
0.0047569503,
0.0041418779,
-0.0151444208,
-0.0209659562,
-0.1160874963,
-0.03010731,
-0.0016642001,
0.0077560628,
0.0091659138,
-0.0119619276,
0.0156610925,
-0.0239087585,
0.0075728758,
0.0304182488,
-0.028635513,
-0.0699656755,
-0.0579590313,
-0.0111506563,
-0.0144058922,
0.0018002524,
-0.0484712236,
-0.0196203757,
0.0112965144,
0.0053656818,
-0.0609087795,
-0.0626907572,
0.0161984544,
-0.007279831,
0.0040042005,
0.0542892553,
0.0161184091,
-0.0511755534,
0.02134813,
0.0034535411,
-0.0049413145,
-0.0235965494,
-0.0038905886,
0.0552489795,
0.0230993535,
-0.0286296979,
0.0286029074,
0.0542349145,
-0.0648462921,
-0.0255405828,
-0.0138096334,
0.0570942424,
-0.0719591528,
-0.0308035072,
-0.0435796641,
0.0281334575,
0.0400124006,
0.0503637157,
0.027706312,
-0.0359955765,
-0.0183786564,
-0.0394658595,
0.0515604168,
-0.0059901047,
-0.043579977,
0.0354652256,
-0.0135217989,
-0.0274975449,
-0.0186713785,
-0.0645819008,
0.0303067062,
0.0103822984,
0.0473016873,
0.0105429906,
0.0693531483,
-0.0297985729,
-0.0433645919,
0.0714100972,
0.0219622161,
0.0599280745,
-0.0131837241,
-0.0440197513,
-0.0114087425,
-0.0070087463,
-0.065071173,
0.0647479817,
-0.0413559489,
0.0150345769,
0.0276576336,
0.0318326019,
0.0293205604,
0.024718022,
-0.0442217812,
-0.0256561302,
0.0176042654,
-0.0040383693,
-0.0071763559,
-0.0054137041,
0.039443735,
0.0157022234,
-0.0303871538,
0.0063365167,
0.0113270264,
0.0143945403,
-0.0111869667,
0.0201807097,
-0.0196922924,
-0.017770296,
0.0157948416,
0.0084455283,
0.0218361225,
-0.0052444628,
-0.0276436135,
-0.0181813743,
0.0259326994,
0.012958318,
0.0195541047,
-0.0297468826,
-0.0054007005,
0.0120598506,
-0.0246574767,
-0.0243976545,
-0.0447562449,
-0.0361844078,
-0.0744230598,
-0.0314215086,
0.0920030624,
-0.0131198112,
0.0135607645,
0.0312416479,
0.0095329238,
-0.0023080606,
0.0098590851,
0.001701885,
0.0015560746,
-0.0003553339,
0.0307455622,
0.0158771481,
0.0455862358,
-0.029533511,
0.0540804863,
-0.0239586793,
0.0332316123,
0.0012515732,
0.0034173378,
0.0265379976,
-0.0505112037,
-0.0056304759,
-0.0045012711,
0.0017757628,
-0.0048506316,
0.0405514017,
-0.0307809487,
0.0246762019,
0.0614372306,
0.0088596661,
0.0087432126,
0.0082746791,
0.0875573084,
0.0175997522,
0.0431621931,
0.0179898292,
-0.0737804919,
-0.0541585945,
-0.0044000712,
0.032308083,
0.0313914753,
-0.0316164345,
0.0064930776,
-0.0204278249,
-0.05698549,
0.0798701718,
-0.0197441205,
-0.0145599404,
-0.0185300168,
0.0752528682,
0.0605091713,
-0.0264318995,
0.0230376851,
0.026085658,
0.0297289118,
-0.0217963271,
-0.0383581631,
-0.0474201813,
-5.813596493e-33,
-0.0126910172,
-0.0182686653,
0.0136465719,
-0.0116067603,
-0.0185525846,
0.0349204652,
-0.0485273749,
-0.0038854061,
0.0150702288,
0.0435222164,
-0.0298602991,
0.0033789717,
0.0295846257,
0.0399622656,
-0.0184477698,
-0.0707884058,
0.0479712337,
0.0230035912,
0.0183526594,
0.0139776431,
-0.0226454716,
0.085882768,
0.0734379292,
-0.0907439068,
0.0169892572,
0.0317250788,
-0.0007124992,
-0.0348796956,
0.0186719745,
0.0475723036,
-0.0631399825,
0.0602668449,
0.0334187783,
-0.0114158485,
-0.0201151054,
0.0198773257,
-0.0726579577,
0.0014906653,
0.0119557381,
0.0352732502,
-0.0244134236,
-0.0590187944,
0.0536294729,
-0.0068882643,
0.0333288386,
-0.0058680456,
0.0634999797,
-0.0619267635,
-0.0030375733,
-0.0398948304,
-0.0035246774,
0.0354529433,
-0.0481060147,
-0.0056259469,
0.0451737233,
-0.0247062352,
-0.0449149311,
0.0391686596,
-0.0608546101,
-0.0377067327,
0.0571710095,
0.0196600389,
0.0090154214,
-0.0203242451,
-0.0202418994,
0.0450518839,
0.0271760914,
-0.0193584375,
-0.0384591222,
0.0682091042,
0.0038450088,
0.0655133724,
0.0496181138,
-0.0039694034,
0.0243793484,
-0.014809588,
-0.1025366634,
0.0291421581,
-0.0629278645,
0.0368914902,
0.0003856197,
-0.0140288007,
-0.0484696925,
-0.0126250973,
-0.0159470979,
-0.025818238,
-0.016664844,
-0.015042034,
0.0249605495,
-0.0438488014,
0.0238300301,
0.047298193,
0.0295658484,
-0.0498131253,
0.0173755568,
-0.0189372022,
0.0512328893,
-0.0003782975,
0.018865196,
-0.0181290805,
0.0376415886,
-0.0371156819,
0.0239780936,
-0.0033190413,
0.0865473822,
-0.0259842686,
0.0129461391,
0.01357882,
-0.0358616821,
-0.011971443,
-0.0013329261,
-0.0338076688,
0.0005623568,
0.0516227335,
0.0218416397,
-0.0128031205,
0.0004648186,
0.0784197748,
-0.0414143354,
0.0267153848,
-0.0035762533,
-0.0278565418,
-0.0021644824,
0.0441619791,
-0.068487227,
-0.0592251495,
-0.0235534217,
0.0271635465,
0.0206550993,
-0.0830132365,
-0.0341100954,
-0.0073469761,
2.813e-7,
0.0711969882,
0.0237552673,
0.0285923444,
0.004327205,
-0.0091844201,
0.0209068526,
-0.0130958771,
0.0106033972,
-0.0320629142,
-0.0102701727,
0.0291867107,
0.0330372676,
0.0351183005,
0.0138942515,
-0.0586703792,
-0.025814781,
-0.0638631657,
0.0332720019,
-0.0232097153,
-0.0111914314,
0.0652280003,
0.0901620537,
-0.022725489,
-0.0328651071,
0.0458009802,
-0.0043511833,
0.0404569581,
-0.0263526496,
0.0042772274,
0.0218543895,
-0.0240750648,
0.0214963593,
0.0173153114,
0.031909205,
0.003060099,
-0.0047093551,
0.0454416871,
0.0580982938,
-0.0588492155,
0.0017056033,
0.0038182419,
0.0184921883,
0.0313638933,
-0.0302738808,
0.0795778632,
-0.0547283031,
-0.0554473586,
0.0011646587,
-0.0301149972,
-0.045682475,
0.0551161803,
-0.0301584154,
-0.0215618182,
0.0198827665,
0.035660591,
-0.0268834848,
-0.0334318541,
-0.0471199341,
-0.0001723381,
0.025210645,
-0.0303499531,
0.0053797523,
-0.0049853576,
0.0028211945,
0.050790634,
-0.0491117164,
-0.0171111897,
2.66545617e-34,
0.0100365849,
0.007299745,
-0.0011271819,
0.0753110573,
0.0285635088,
-0.0212099142,
0.0086496416,
-0.0029694727,
-0.0044849091,
-0.0852259845,
-0.0199071653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03369v1 | Evaluation of Google's Voice Recognition and Sentence Classification for Health Care Applications | 2024-02-02T03:13:09 | 2024-02-02T03:13:09 | Majbah Uddin, Nathan Huynh, Jose M Vidal, Kevin M Taaffe, Lawrence D Fredendall, Joel S Greenstein | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | This study examined the use of voice recognition technology in perioperative
services (Periop) to enable Periop staff to record workflow milestones using
mobile technology. The use of mobile technology to improve patient flow and
quality of care could be facilitated if such voice recognition technology could
be made robust. The goal of this experiment was to allow the Periop staff to
provide care without being interrupted with data entry and querying tasks.
However, the results are generalizable to other situations where an engineering
manager attempts to improve communication performance using mobile technology.
This study enhanced Google's voice recognition capability by using
post-processing classifiers (i.e., bag-of-sentences, support vector machine,
and maximum entropy). The experiments investigated three factors (original
phrasing, reduced phrasing, and personalized phrasing) at three levels (zero
training repetition, 5 training repetitions, and 10 training repetitions).
Results indicated that personal phrasing yielded the highest correctness and
that training the device to recognize an individual's voice improved
correctness as well. Although simplistic, the bag-of-sentences classifier
significantly improved voice recognition correctness. The classification
efficiency of the maximum entropy and support vector machine algorithms was
found to be nearly identical. These results suggest that engineering managers
could significantly enhance Google's voice recognition technology by using
post-processing techniques, which would facilitate its use in health care and
other applications. | [
0.0648657903,
0.0055177375,
-0.0490134098,
-0.0355505086,
-0.0246757045,
0.0007251208,
0.0457351059,
-0.0008694648,
0.0058876793,
-0.082229577,
0.0358194001,
-0.0296366587,
0.0322691835,
-0.0010536963,
0.0151878484,
-0.0656060055,
0.0207175761,
0.0222080965,
0.0274573769,
0.0241271555,
-0.0077576237,
0.0262546632,
-0.0237870645,
0.0546651706,
-0.0063672033,
0.019416105,
0.0208327193,
0.0059916098,
0.0321696103,
-0.0661137998,
-0.0117768822,
0.0054001985,
-0.0316100121,
0.0082288506,
0.0000018365,
-0.036853224,
-0.0105139101,
0.0347711444,
-0.0659164488,
-0.05449659,
0.040147908,
0.0160194337,
-0.0304578766,
0.0534238629,
-0.0122929318,
-0.019889174,
0.0623293705,
0.0745170861,
0.0086831227,
0.0562138818,
-0.0401193574,
-0.0270109829,
0.0129513387,
0.0177487936,
0.0057246359,
-0.0456039049,
0.0031118807,
-0.0193201825,
0.0341835693,
-0.0455191918,
0.0559612773,
0.023671627,
-0.0177050103,
0.0331671536,
0.0105681643,
0.0450996608,
-0.025893677,
0.0007212228,
-0.029431982,
0.0068143932,
-0.0067622494,
0.0099749919,
-0.0097106462,
-0.004691103,
-0.0221229959,
-0.0206548255,
0.008120006,
-0.0413829871,
-0.0301563721,
-0.0140034342,
-0.0456439927,
0.0324171707,
-0.0017111868,
-0.0299072713,
0.0023293628,
-0.0457736403,
-0.0151671274,
-0.0735352263,
0.0333544239,
0.0234473664,
-0.0057383906,
0.031517569,
0.031070767,
0.02116373,
-0.0177195948,
0.0159062017,
-0.0143463537,
-0.0546384193,
0.0357791856,
-0.0877824649,
0.0212077163,
0.0086561693,
0.0060278382,
0.0039884779,
0.0021486711,
0.0123529164,
0.0033740452,
0.0139223086,
-0.0406998135,
0.0465870686,
-0.0787023157,
-0.009493826,
-0.0076601547,
0.0411984734,
0.0344095007,
-0.0278459843,
-0.0814646259,
-0.0135612199,
0.0251261033,
0.004255312,
-0.0033469014,
0.014428027,
-0.0003267146,
0.0371180512,
-0.0079309847,
-0.0194435976,
0.0105780605,
0.0724498034,
-0.031226011,
-0.0528861918,
0.0594284758,
-0.0041831043,
0.0471711196,
0.033470232,
0.0236573033,
-0.0067197816,
-0.0223755799,
-0.0383447632,
-0.0782124922,
-0.0256146695,
-0.01979612,
-0.0162683539,
-0.0086891018,
-0.0125264833,
-0.0062984317,
0.0201789234,
-0.0157883409,
0.0102679851,
0.034193866,
0.0021315066,
-0.0235086791,
0.0242431946,
-0.0343845524,
0.0179459117,
0.0675200745,
0.0099387737,
0.0300747026,
0.0124458056,
0.0209364891,
-0.0383000858,
0.0161760394,
-0.0609835573,
0.0010707118,
0.0242512133,
-0.0592608079,
-0.0783450156,
0.0236645713,
-0.0120159034,
-0.0088028545,
-0.0045384779,
-0.0243701432,
0.0727083459,
0.0206855461,
0.0879048258,
0.0507447124,
0.0635237992,
0.0453483611,
0.0055067558,
-0.0241180789,
0.0179061033,
0.0037137507,
-0.0319777392,
0.0247170236,
-0.0623228066,
0.0028848427,
-0.0048595248,
-0.0046825027,
0.00441609,
-0.0425016806,
-0.0366358235,
-0.0484803356,
-0.0368864387,
-0.0384409316,
0.0316792689,
0.0380052924,
-0.0256080758,
-0.0383117832,
0.0196070038,
-0.0138891842,
-0.039345175,
-0.0486484654,
-0.0319779702,
-0.0207056776,
0.1184506118,
0.0417352021,
-0.055239372,
0.0142226536,
-0.0711658671,
-0.0549166054,
-0.0016653436,
0.0058981362,
0.0061485516,
-0.0056753824,
-0.0365382247,
0.0079684649,
0.0581569299,
0.0057729864,
-0.0252422318,
-0.0155682554,
0.0648003668,
0.0241606813,
0.0265539754,
-0.0387391932,
0.0241499729,
0.0505753867,
-0.0555217862,
0.0190669652,
0.0096413214,
0.0413085893,
0.0697509572,
-0.0305537246,
-0.0074347602,
0.0264215712,
-0.0260773804,
-0.0095649716,
0.0471525602,
-0.0173101574,
0.038305413,
-0.005931362,
0.0144485962,
-0.0015296172,
0.0194234718,
-0.0047147684,
-0.0392542854,
-0.0423169695,
-0.0672668666,
0.037106473,
-0.0354913026,
0.0637052804,
0.0093474379,
0.0068540541,
-0.0415784642,
-0.0004454608,
0.0256725457,
0.0045630089,
-0.0469560251,
-0.0211250689,
0.0385858752,
-0.0437166765,
-0.0081116343,
0.04639633,
-0.0346924141,
0.0736426935,
-0.0096085193,
0.0100794593,
-0.0125504602,
-0.0033650657,
-0.1187609285,
-0.0437909514,
0.0012777136,
0.0066969986,
0.0213391948,
0.0148120606,
0.0226334762,
-0.0392716751,
-0.0245160181,
-0.0235440601,
0.0041265925,
-0.0175714716,
0.0187286343,
-0.0068049151,
-0.0043132552,
0.0011509925,
-0.0042697815,
-0.0330919586,
0.0299366917,
0.034468729,
-0.0241273753,
-0.0428542942,
-0.0069845971,
0.0185268931,
-0.0152385514,
0.0108488901,
-0.0125173023,
-0.0044156718,
0.0083967568,
0.0164013971,
0.0284420531,
0.0320436172,
-0.0153504983,
-0.0068438649,
0.0494832732,
0.0341236368,
-0.002793431,
-0.0103340065,
0.006398648,
-0.0201332141,
-0.0333361775,
0.0014787507,
-0.0114004947,
0.0160911791,
0.0687234402,
0.0058937492,
-0.0250220038,
-0.0258326344,
-0.01059255,
-0.0324322507,
0.0028556911,
-0.0610174686,
0.0450399257,
0.0293936674,
-0.0289158523,
0.0298438147,
-0.0014794902,
0.0127956001,
-0.0989149585,
-0.0600356236,
0.0072099152,
0.0449286215,
-0.0869383514,
0.0322136208,
0.0343507715,
-0.0587711297,
0.012835783,
-0.0036168708,
-0.0273596607,
-0.0628606975,
-0.0155122131,
0.0085401004,
0.010674757,
0.0003767588,
-0.0514752194,
-0.05114647,
-0.0219224859,
-0.0497315377,
0.0079337647,
0.0469677262,
-0.0050429543,
-0.0306350105,
0.078293629,
0.0044055926,
0.0584040098,
0.0381975248,
-0.0050113909,
0.0212300811,
0.0132671529,
-0.0006487262,
0.0474753827,
-0.0345081575,
0.0483999811,
0.0544849075,
0.0058420007,
0.0575599,
-0.0081788274,
-0.0137588838,
-0.0393157192,
0.0023661456,
-0.049647674,
-0.0324526019,
0.0444009751,
0.0432167128,
-0.0335733034,
0.0362576097,
0.0632224679,
0.0175045151,
-0.0614879504,
-0.0067100427,
0.0141626801,
-0.088371329,
0.003906677,
0.035903994,
-0.0163060427,
0.0005842957,
-0.0029484725,
0.0527176112,
-0.012988084,
0.0370292328,
0.0077980747,
-0.0480144173,
0.0482146107,
0.0043735383,
-0.0367212407,
-0.030513946,
-0.0267987773,
-0.0062410757,
0.0136366272,
-0.0025425877,
-0.0408319645,
-0.0401639938,
-0.0347447284,
0.015804084,
-0.1150290743,
-0.081398949,
0.0171343759,
0.0015905192,
-0.0000897393,
0.135465771,
0.0242103934,
-0.0250118207,
-0.0482570231,
0.0130393077,
-0.0100746918,
0.0571199581,
-0.0089506097,
0.0620542504,
0.0012887521,
0.0146619203,
0.0241817571,
-0.0028406156,
-0.0322159305,
0.0149447909,
0.048820693,
0.0635377243,
-0.0406570211,
-0.0212583169,
-0.020902846,
0.0450114049,
0.0230382532,
0.0044638165,
-0.0181783643,
-0.0260317866,
-0.069623217,
0.0268325899,
0.0335092396,
0.0425310545,
0.020422155,
0.029369846,
-0.0082358019,
-0.0847274959,
-0.0278441571,
-0.0267792419,
0.0076559302,
0.0511457846,
0.0442158431,
0.0475483015,
0.0301633161,
0.0908466354,
-0.0502586439,
-0.0530041531,
0.0428555608,
0.0565933213,
-0.0512778424,
-0.0253450777,
0.0114289708,
0.0127821825,
-0.0076121283,
-0.055215653,
0.0365774184,
-0.0327199399,
0.0368616655,
0.0249889921,
0.0255865343,
-0.0041433293,
-0.0200414546,
-0.0590541475,
0.0279153455,
0.0475572236,
-0.0631193221,
0.0158147532,
0.023256598,
0.0104806833,
-0.0207179151,
-0.0278479997,
0.0000790285,
0.0327297673,
-0.0094419718,
-0.0246872213,
-0.0474231616,
-0.058097899,
-0.0009017282,
0.0312179532,
0.0237978678,
-0.0033583445,
-0.0319304429,
-0.0053390735,
0.0396830216,
0.0298382193,
0.0304023027,
0.0003754144,
-0.0301698893,
-0.0235106628,
0.0262794755,
0.02170505,
0.0131412074,
-0.0846400112,
-0.0527148321,
-0.0040633213,
0.0443817638,
0.0100885537,
0.0553514883,
-0.0146268001,
0.0137064634,
-0.0239171479,
-0.0166126043,
0.0459582545,
0.019652009,
0.027947871,
0.0441090651,
-0.0305968337,
0.0231095776,
-0.0277418457,
0.060284622,
-0.055935964,
-0.0510980338,
-0.0065039643,
-0.0168711189,
0.0416343696,
0.0034765322,
-0.0335447527,
-0.021190621,
0.0110102855,
-0.0477329046,
0.0247277748,
-0.010562703,
0.0397035331,
0.0035485872,
0.0047097304,
-0.0439794026,
-0.0100741973,
0.0456507616,
-0.0079538012,
-0.0070845867,
-0.0453808904,
-0.0273583233,
-0.0579467826,
-0.0122423535,
0.0399704054,
0.0676788539,
-0.0490970165,
-0.0224968605,
-0.0439566784,
-0.0129658757,
0.0501561016,
-0.068794772,
0.0468470529,
-0.068980664,
0.0429403633,
0.0494071282,
0.0116459206,
-0.0020436505,
-0.0250291303,
-0.0283583999,
-0.0345177464,
0.0438367799,
-0.009286481,
-5.539709248e-33,
0.0244927667,
-0.0386984311,
-0.0163535587,
0.043523252,
-0.0040617255,
0.0203548893,
0.0212430451,
0.0460782461,
0.0113936858,
-0.035296265,
-0.0395007208,
-0.002062662,
0.0245446861,
-0.0069547221,
0.0163713768,
-0.0170607027,
0.0976672471,
-0.0116541935,
0.0035981154,
0.021380391,
0.0112084467,
0.0749553218,
0.0459502079,
-0.1071044281,
-0.0017764639,
0.0282093417,
-0.0185505878,
-0.0499224029,
0.0643157884,
-0.0137192281,
0.01111353,
0.0352747031,
0.0371916071,
-0.0230882987,
0.0182862189,
0.0818527117,
-0.0289680008,
0.0039811605,
0.0024282329,
0.0392397232,
-0.0104186321,
-0.0286765564,
0.0459652953,
-0.0293885283,
-0.0635691583,
0.0168073028,
0.0573245548,
-0.0152329039,
-0.0404456109,
-0.0598808639,
-0.0118519906,
0.0116543984,
-0.0003924717,
0.0018616872,
0.005158307,
0.0462552011,
-0.0634548441,
-0.0028994908,
-0.0303802211,
0.0178601295,
0.0006619312,
-0.0187968351,
-0.0140729407,
0.0390406176,
-0.0121040624,
0.0283704437,
0.0457960963,
-0.0219336078,
-0.0327650122,
-0.0147310896,
-0.0184428934,
0.0368039683,
0.0516188405,
0.0011596209,
0.0504089929,
-0.0730771497,
-0.0251238123,
0.0241423715,
-0.0126203988,
-0.0198983438,
0.0307878982,
-0.0039972393,
-0.0698726326,
-0.0156772211,
0.0035433895,
-0.0069385329,
-0.0107292989,
-0.0253944267,
0.033032462,
-0.0019948033,
-0.0105900001,
0.0321650356,
0.0078879213,
-0.0194283314,
0.0496775992,
-0.0652342513,
0.0090852426,
0.0169093888,
-0.0258552786,
-0.055848863,
-0.0833122134,
-0.0185075365,
0.0223116763,
0.0594189167,
0.0476161838,
-0.0186598673,
0.0230333451,
-0.0055689788,
-0.0573772043,
-0.0040548705,
0.0637029707,
0.014863967,
-0.0097002611,
-0.0081987754,
0.0273005906,
-0.0045210342,
0.0165907368,
0.0433184206,
-0.0152591467,
0.0108649526,
-0.0374123603,
-0.0418693982,
-0.0062282723,
0.008678766,
-0.0302769747,
-0.0010598185,
-0.0537272654,
0.0238199718,
-0.0005570784,
0.0003487428,
-0.0001194655,
-0.0112406267,
2.646e-7,
0.037983004,
0.0337970778,
-0.0165684987,
-0.0170375761,
0.0410008244,
0.015826337,
0.0452070087,
-0.0225768909,
-0.0091662239,
0.0478347875,
0.0605654083,
-0.04360383,
0.0636042356,
0.0118849492,
-0.0730933398,
-0.0662576333,
-0.0475147031,
0.0233968273,
-0.0562012345,
0.0618275926,
0.094129622,
0.0642408654,
-0.0224066004,
-0.0470894352,
-0.0076213176,
-0.0171569902,
0.0123309772,
-0.0201032069,
0.0662899688,
-0.0283045266,
0.0466419198,
0.037026763,
-0.0174920913,
0.0515634194,
-0.0194263812,
-0.0149296345,
0.0049058408,
0.0382229909,
-0.0610962845,
-0.0014190826,
0.0104947174,
0.0226369072,
0.0231768712,
-0.0171718374,
0.0313790292,
-0.0080915028,
-0.0451859981,
-0.0122054555,
-0.0161038395,
-0.0415566005,
0.0537901185,
0.0113446498,
-0.0069122999,
-0.0021351811,
-0.008145215,
-0.02234447,
-0.0378162526,
-0.0255222898,
0.0218435992,
0.0262116957,
-0.0043410957,
-0.047679361,
0.0201873723,
-0.0080594942,
0.0226394888,
-0.0016284811,
0.0369325541,
1.892876283e-34,
0.0188224558,
-0.0047496394,
-0.0042797565,
0.0484727472,
0.0051425598,
0.0039608642,
0.059544079,
0.0145423692,
0.0109321987,
-0.0303328577,
0.0001139217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01109v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01109v3 | Vaccine: Perturbation-aware Alignment for Large Language Model | 2024-02-02T02:56:50 | 2024-02-29T07:15:13 | Tiansheng Huang, Sihao Hu, Ling Liu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The new paradigm of finetuning-as-a-service introduces a new attack surface
for Large Language Models (LLMs): a few harmful data uploaded by users can
easily trick the finetuning to produce an alignment-broken model. We conduct an
empirical analysis and uncover a \textit{harmful embedding drift} phenomenon,
showing a probable cause of the alignment-broken effect. Inspired by our
findings, we propose Vaccine, a perturbation-aware alignment technique to
mitigate the security risk of users finetuning. The core idea of Vaccine is to
produce invariant hidden embeddings by progressively adding crafted
perturbation to them in the alignment phase. This enables the embeddings to
withstand harmful perturbation from un-sanitized user data in the finetuning
phase. Our results on open source mainstream LLMs (e.g., Llama2, Opt, Vicuna)
demonstrate that Vaccine can boost the robustness of alignment against harmful
prompts induced embedding drift while reserving reasoning ability towards
benign prompts. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/git-disl/Vaccine}. | [
0.0011265583,
0.0646190345,
-0.0178641155,
0.0625250265,
-0.019424323,
0.0062500681,
0.0235148072,
-0.0323814712,
0.0097585116,
0.0117627187,
0.0026130816,
-0.0085100215,
0.0016050546,
0.0091028772,
0.0591496304,
0.0220018849,
0.0806744844,
-0.0247444548,
-0.0188969448,
-0.0163118336,
0.0216266997,
-0.0301653352,
0.0204282384,
-0.0065057683,
0.0203192439,
-0.0292446427,
-0.0347424634,
0.0281082131,
0.0385368988,
-0.0044852407,
-0.0103562921,
0.0503280796,
-0.0133366324,
0.1202104762,
0.0000019503,
-0.0392177962,
-0.060619209,
0.0544584133,
-0.050404802,
0.0386775918,
0.01712377,
-0.0248688366,
-0.0601089038,
0.0262663383,
-0.0268660579,
0.0241085812,
0.0856067911,
-0.0242412295,
0.1092037782,
0.0787356794,
-0.0023974923,
-0.0212939456,
0.0006899743,
-0.0173660498,
-0.0357589386,
-0.0370365195,
0.0202044975,
-0.025020143,
-0.0310867485,
0.0173238367,
-0.029637076,
0.0261718147,
-0.0133198639,
-0.0476578847,
-0.0140456622,
-0.0006847398,
-0.0560593009,
-0.0371921025,
0.0121603422,
0.0582491197,
-0.0275359955,
-0.0086947605,
0.0092799813,
-0.0030006294,
0.0207881629,
0.0166690014,
-0.0121497586,
0.0002559766,
0.0444276333,
0.0214634873,
0.0242270809,
-0.0477291644,
0.0457024798,
-0.0224067103,
-0.0028179071,
0.0397736542,
0.0398006216,
-0.0367090367,
-0.0563366823,
-0.055123087,
-0.0159831718,
-0.0715800002,
-0.0111471396,
0.0095970035,
-0.0195316356,
0.0225666463,
-0.088842608,
-0.0658630505,
0.0452452786,
-0.0391458534,
0.0352375545,
0.05944876,
-0.0113253202,
0.0310150478,
-0.0176963974,
0.049808614,
-0.0291401409,
0.059704002,
0.0226140972,
0.0490443036,
0.0323281065,
0.014965984,
-0.0098465094,
0.0178911686,
-0.0144495694,
0.0100263702,
-0.0294259042,
0.0669891983,
0.0057294625,
0.1012527794,
-0.0462616943,
-0.0273693334,
-0.022780614,
0.0030726413,
0.0264546704,
-0.006941922,
0.0015302225,
-0.0393657535,
-0.0019921081,
-0.049057506,
-0.0371921621,
0.0037442122,
-0.0159324408,
-0.0309105199,
-0.0109452382,
0.0614500046,
0.0305798687,
-0.0023207481,
-0.0076498315,
-0.0756419227,
-0.017738767,
-0.0348875634,
-0.0171370599,
-0.0690045282,
-0.0034373046,
0.0041215853,
-0.0261047073,
-0.1121000648,
-0.0075826612,
0.0064800456,
-0.0481283329,
0.0646852925,
-0.0552524291,
-0.0005203357,
-0.0309800375,
-0.0083733676,
0.0165673047,
0.0600301661,
0.034059532,
0.0096077966,
0.0643343106,
-0.0272810701,
-0.00272521,
0.0656122193,
0.0103864344,
0.0466050804,
-0.0189298708,
0.0119568948,
0.0700223967,
0.0347295366,
0.0000426028,
0.0496954843,
0.0283466615,
-0.0434742607,
0.0688916445,
0.0618236139,
-0.0261449162,
0.0155242328,
-0.0234882552,
0.0051906905,
-0.0192806441,
0.0418958031,
-0.0813371688,
-0.002684369,
-0.0480993539,
0.0155266523,
0.0281582568,
0.0690317973,
0.0167144965,
0.0212521534,
-0.0137782004,
-0.0315941982,
-0.0058224285,
-0.0056015709,
0.0037555255,
-0.0117535787,
-0.0021506383,
0.0643591061,
0.0249035396,
-0.0510455184,
-0.0071466137,
-0.0370768644,
-0.0054601119,
0.0430169813,
0.0670955256,
-0.0210601483,
-0.0737920105,
-0.0207900517,
-0.0043305377,
0.0142223267,
0.0432524867,
0.0118982308,
-0.0006861618,
-0.0224345475,
-0.0236432478,
-0.0009384844,
0.0072554308,
-0.0197337009,
0.0077484073,
0.0050979634,
0.0100012738,
-0.0077454718,
-0.0164696593,
0.026497256,
-0.0260641295,
-0.0321140178,
-0.041654218,
0.039599102,
0.0137981437,
0.0061533717,
-0.027285805,
0.0170041993,
0.0500440001,
0.0234228894,
0.0546394177,
-0.0015918313,
0.0105448123,
0.0036081092,
0.0760557577,
0.0098464377,
-0.0099627245,
0.0100795785,
-0.0602255501,
-0.015897803,
0.0277699362,
-0.0098566748,
0.0075827423,
0.0105359564,
0.049595654,
-0.0318825878,
0.0412779264,
-0.0410561599,
-0.0039671371,
-0.0120237395,
0.038843058,
-0.0059508421,
0.0063916217,
0.0240209848,
-0.0084191086,
-0.0766296759,
0.0248356462,
0.0034289067,
0.0173330568,
-0.0130917886,
-0.0045101508,
-0.0184348319,
-0.0330893695,
-0.0301316157,
0.0008699434,
0.0020429231,
0.0599507578,
0.0213884711,
0.0341914855,
-0.0303015169,
-0.0108982483,
-0.0096614268,
-0.0163573623,
-0.0067179613,
0.0336276367,
0.0408150069,
-0.0217613596,
-0.0625482649,
-0.0386051051,
-0.008564353,
-0.0211490449,
0.0328644514,
-0.0181980915,
-0.0053276899,
-0.0862469226,
-0.0237198528,
-0.0498658568,
0.0350587964,
0.0100089181,
-0.0710178167,
-0.0191116761,
0.0065286737,
0.0109772906,
0.087060146,
-0.0201980285,
-0.0041144192,
0.0513324514,
0.0067448588,
-0.0163282566,
-0.0207586382,
0.0156117352,
-0.0480519049,
-0.0571776927,
0.0288355947,
-0.0105375107,
0.0339997113,
-0.025138868,
-0.0309391841,
-0.0404837802,
0.057909295,
0.0129948845,
0.0191031862,
0.0396940373,
-0.0083303377,
-0.0547211692,
0.0395135432,
-0.0049158004,
-0.0780744106,
0.0707507282,
-0.0525268055,
-0.0043024598,
-0.0067595402,
-0.0083708391,
-0.0157758668,
0.0114234993,
-0.0061614546,
0.0380250812,
0.0227330308,
-0.0291992873,
-0.0625665486,
0.0032152361,
0.0613773689,
-0.0540747829,
0.0254845247,
0.0056787478,
-0.0104209604,
-0.0412728004,
-0.0424697772,
-0.0184190888,
-0.0720831752,
-0.0294132382,
-0.0320997164,
0.0256896559,
-0.0331271626,
0.0119268224,
-0.0104246931,
0.0166413505,
-0.0005178894,
-0.0088624544,
0.0366024598,
-0.0495691188,
0.0019310998,
0.0209943168,
-0.0247896332,
0.0157944448,
-0.0288949031,
0.0127330068,
0.0573189445,
0.0205811337,
-0.0128219072,
-0.0258025862,
-0.0141055407,
0.0509594902,
-0.0274097845,
-0.0152649442,
0.0197760481,
0.0338351466,
-0.0218906421,
-0.0024255074,
0.0680448487,
0.0142976269,
-0.0131432442,
0.0282288212,
-0.0311578028,
0.074699834,
0.022051055,
0.0414980166,
-0.1016279012,
-0.0090935696,
0.0524056852,
0.042547714,
0.0077847638,
-0.0226360857,
-0.0313758701,
-0.097634986,
0.0364499018,
0.0472233556,
0.0067014336,
-0.0334476046,
-0.0231622569,
0.0132454056,
0.0179610327,
0.0366769098,
0.0206312165,
-0.0045146011,
0.0054317419,
0.0106497984,
0.0073729954,
-0.0560492463,
-0.0359531194,
-0.0658430159,
0.0758221224,
0.08586061,
-0.0089248242,
0.0054864981,
-0.0593076348,
0.0440522395,
0.0333973244,
-0.0277893171,
0.0150582753,
0.0232754331,
0.0161048379,
-0.0345675386,
0.0221898668,
0.0154475858,
0.0117600411,
0.0011200778,
-0.0171255525,
0.0689943358,
0.0009526229,
0.0386276469,
-0.0016813858,
-0.0456157997,
0.0004024621,
0.0409890637,
0.025250569,
-0.0299175959,
-0.0122331213,
-0.0588021614,
0.0100755487,
0.0305802599,
-0.0144490441,
0.0056239939,
-0.0236715376,
-0.0398066565,
-0.0337053686,
-0.0023557993,
-0.0093250629,
0.0506163016,
0.0555017218,
0.0130567588,
0.0208734199,
-0.0205785967,
-0.036592409,
-0.0032788131,
-0.0592265874,
0.0487370081,
-0.0523970872,
0.0348097906,
-0.0041438513,
0.0172414649,
-0.0157325063,
-0.0297657587,
-0.0977639481,
-0.119316265,
0.0351888612,
0.0453936681,
0.0342696048,
0.0502561554,
-0.0248391759,
-0.0553040057,
0.0540523566,
0.0437506363,
-0.0521357022,
0.0119673945,
0.0286320522,
-0.0486857779,
0.0149674024,
0.0485899076,
-0.0287111867,
-0.0827987045,
0.0344418846,
-0.0195409413,
-0.004355757,
-0.0249165986,
-0.0267991386,
0.0682088956,
0.0328869261,
-0.0296555795,
0.014599503,
-0.0080429353,
0.0481523797,
-0.0116212526,
-0.029769225,
-0.0144540761,
-0.0100679835,
-0.0149135459,
-0.0286812503,
0.0418461747,
0.0278790388,
0.0088093057,
0.0276701842,
-0.0112123322,
0.027105052,
-0.016723223,
0.0021372123,
0.0860557407,
0.0205575675,
-0.0010474912,
0.0610010326,
-0.005161914,
0.0433931947,
-0.0391771607,
0.0037988254,
0.0293621421,
0.015438118,
-0.0310257878,
0.0587550588,
-0.0204320066,
-0.0509744324,
-0.0188772604,
0.0055373302,
0.0293381885,
0.0179579146,
0.0565323606,
0.0198609438,
-0.0148331327,
-0.0294313449,
0.0115073947,
-0.0177740399,
-0.0371811204,
0.023636939,
-0.0243970118,
-0.0216275994,
0.039345488,
0.0671388879,
-0.029601723,
0.031690795,
-0.0201312155,
-0.0329700746,
-0.0452457778,
0.0036327355,
0.0009659404,
0.0148889599,
-0.0496630818,
-0.0512538441,
-0.0567154959,
-0.0983873233,
-0.0325965807,
0.0172197539,
-0.0161164757,
0.010183475,
-0.0279733464,
0.0529161617,
0.0019856626,
0.0079598725,
-0.038353797,
0.0094714817,
0.0091940835,
-0.0581153482,
0.0256210305,
-6.220005665e-33,
0.0041504297,
0.0008533039,
-0.0390707031,
0.0041173617,
-0.0129440166,
-0.0121904593,
-0.0367515534,
0.0025603205,
-0.0074624857,
-0.0231868736,
-0.0301994998,
-0.0085270656,
0.0131414542,
0.0044228751,
0.0025273117,
-0.0316239707,
0.0120152291,
0.0088683227,
-0.0476764515,
0.0062536062,
0.0150148328,
-0.0054640151,
0.0371056497,
-0.0566457398,
0.0322087258,
-0.0266303644,
-0.0156176137,
0.0233009271,
-0.0385359526,
0.0559666045,
0.0191819835,
-0.0313778743,
-0.0276311468,
0.0131894518,
-0.022595467,
0.0097947828,
-0.0118752066,
-0.0139666153,
0.0223379266,
0.0345587134,
0.0095934961,
-0.0655671656,
0.0537397377,
-0.0294844452,
-0.0109369485,
0.008808854,
-0.006206267,
-0.0061429352,
-0.0314257517,
0.0059563145,
-0.0353643224,
0.0192246679,
-0.0181665793,
0.0018013082,
0.0448156446,
-0.0374797545,
0.0516668558,
0.0188186392,
-0.0361216441,
0.0164549798,
0.0391348042,
0.0362754129,
0.0796438605,
0.0048455922,
-0.0023434705,
0.0438988172,
0.0038057365,
-0.0206961427,
0.0414746962,
0.0021262069,
0.0014838418,
0.0006897734,
-0.0025877925,
0.0533919223,
0.0298907608,
-0.0189851522,
-0.0230748709,
0.0148031209,
-0.012804918,
0.0190879628,
0.0243300814,
0.0179935805,
-0.0395588577,
-0.0034934434,
-0.0470831916,
-0.0419618674,
-0.0314492546,
-0.0299960673,
-0.0122320205,
-0.0183058083,
-0.0364957005,
-0.0030540528,
0.0249132719,
-0.0440589078,
-0.0281259306,
-0.0026635462,
-0.017417632,
-0.0118633909,
-0.0147712976,
0.0244887862,
0.0161841288,
-0.0169094317,
-0.0259683579,
-0.0651192218,
0.0503775291,
0.0067367377,
0.052198261,
0.0430208743,
-0.0922838151,
0.0208787825,
-0.0337840728,
0.0264949761,
0.0121354507,
-0.0030997491,
0.0603291467,
-0.0343967304,
0.0192143526,
0.0189441219,
0.0748471767,
0.0474944748,
-0.0293549057,
0.0343598239,
0.0121121062,
0.0115143713,
-0.0056642257,
0.0185645241,
0.0248678327,
0.0770435557,
0.0386806726,
-0.046342086,
-0.0030764386,
-0.0349580757,
2.819e-7,
0.0386231951,
0.0634986758,
0.0425251797,
-0.0032560837,
0.0251081362,
0.074705556,
-0.0458025187,
0.0429944471,
-0.006584812,
0.015000172,
-0.0278745722,
-0.0201219097,
0.0526240952,
0.0230103023,
-0.0619167797,
0.0252059177,
-0.0612735227,
0.0410425887,
-0.055705972,
-0.0234063659,
0.0217757914,
0.1100754589,
0.0336536244,
-0.0128790122,
-0.005419055,
-0.0579110049,
0.0001814267,
0.0221853871,
0.0001344294,
-0.0013450285,
0.0175844952,
0.0190506056,
-0.0013126587,
-0.017060481,
-0.0540618934,
0.0131386798,
-0.0544479191,
0.0460650958,
-0.0047595035,
0.0244121719,
-0.0136158029,
-0.067416437,
-0.0219519585,
-0.055979114,
0.0473187417,
0.0039629666,
-0.0409998298,
-0.0579880364,
-0.040109925,
-0.0354511067,
0.0279381685,
-0.0098556215,
-0.0085577406,
0.0376418605,
0.0162495021,
-0.0240480043,
-0.018189095,
-0.0639568865,
-0.0650078803,
-0.0138364164,
-0.0188335255,
-0.0447064936,
0.0159963965,
0.0176668037,
0.0293008853,
-0.0302433353,
0.0183285978,
3.086569445e-34,
0.0159196798,
-0.051016897,
0.0399669483,
0.0377045833,
0.0253127776,
-0.0364505202,
0.0410497561,
0.0200919751,
0.0159378145,
-0.0400621071,
-0.0429454781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01108v1 | Reasoning Capacity in Multi-Agent Systems: Limitations, Challenges and Human-Centered Solutions | 2024-02-02T02:53:11 | 2024-02-02T02:53:11 | Pouya Pezeshkpour, Eser Kandogan, Nikita Bhutani, Sajjadur Rahman, Tom Mitchell, Estevam Hruschka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Remarkable performance of large language models (LLMs) in a variety of tasks
brings forth many opportunities as well as challenges of utilizing them in
production settings. Towards practical adoption of LLMs, multi-agent systems
hold great promise to augment, integrate, and orchestrate LLMs in the larger
context of enterprise platforms that use existing proprietary data and models
to tackle complex real-world tasks. Despite the tremendous success of these
systems, current approaches rely on narrow, single-focus objectives for
optimization and evaluation, often overlooking potential constraints in
real-world scenarios, including restricted budgets, resources and time.
Furthermore, interpreting, analyzing, and debugging these systems requires
different components to be evaluated in relation to one another. This demand is
currently not feasible with existing methodologies. In this postion paper, we
introduce the concept of reasoning capacity as a unifying criterion to enable
integration of constraints during optimization and establish connections among
different components within the system, which also enable a more holistic and
comprehensive approach to evaluation. We present a formal definition of
reasoning capacity and illustrate its utility in identifying limitations within
each component of the system. We then argue how these limitations can be
addressed with a self-reflective process wherein human-feedback is used to
alleviate shortcomings in reasoning and enhance overall consistency of the
system. | [
0.0469950326,
0.0153058553,
-0.0248940922,
0.0359101556,
-0.0497494973,
0.0059179217,
0.0018523696,
-0.0102212336,
0.0338141285,
-0.0326309875,
-0.0217686091,
0.0006390418,
-0.006111939,
0.0234751459,
0.0081225326,
-0.0101512233,
0.0034343647,
-0.0402021967,
0.0053762188,
-0.0084145609,
0.0048928247,
0.0019655852,
0.0117772575,
0.045696646,
-0.0132881757,
-0.0078258505,
0.0038514372,
-0.0221173447,
0.0229903031,
0.0015643181,
-0.0552281365,
0.017197974,
0.0276117604,
-0.0010801381,
0.0000023756,
-0.0870426446,
-0.0305596869,
0.0183669459,
-0.0919441208,
0.0081991525,
0.0494430028,
0.0134499688,
-0.0165223889,
0.025210375,
-0.0401414968,
0.0395910665,
0.0050676079,
-0.020913884,
0.0633947998,
0.0443030261,
-0.0119528789,
0.0145370839,
-0.0376292877,
0.0252172146,
-0.038363874,
-0.0884988159,
0.0165534895,
0.0574059375,
0.0839031935,
-0.0278494712,
0.0226120204,
0.0307121743,
0.0382250957,
-0.0427383371,
-0.0294767916,
0.0198045261,
0.0162643064,
-0.0266775712,
-0.0212070309,
0.0200500209,
0.0672702342,
0.016039677,
-0.0066172853,
-0.006035842,
-0.0036161919,
-0.0176223125,
-0.0136203459,
0.0334851593,
-0.0287303887,
-0.0031954465,
-0.0289118458,
-0.008406546,
0.014769976,
0.0155266663,
-0.0592057295,
0.1201673672,
-0.0309525654,
-0.0120447427,
-0.0047610765,
-0.0025107232,
0.0069632619,
-0.0481239185,
0.0023215422,
0.0880982503,
-0.0786634311,
0.0195817295,
0.0197841749,
0.0051410487,
0.0167626441,
-0.0682688132,
0.0191663485,
0.0098442119,
0.0391984135,
0.0548591726,
0.0111901239,
0.0831122249,
-0.0237013698,
0.0318986028,
-0.0308545586,
-0.0287727751,
-0.1024119034,
-0.0270082839,
-0.0474267155,
0.0210891832,
0.0109649794,
-0.0130740516,
-0.0074244724,
0.0506867841,
-0.0265527349,
0.0514990129,
-0.0107407412,
-0.0326369666,
0.0023872016,
-0.0609046258,
-0.0661686063,
0.0143314488,
-0.0223186985,
0.0296838451,
-0.0076802759,
-0.0573850386,
0.0267740674,
0.0195727479,
-0.0500595197,
-0.0027363901,
-0.0113911526,
0.0733797103,
0.0235636979,
0.0157041978,
-0.0248096474,
-0.0608085282,
-0.0209740307,
-0.0957262143,
-0.0681848526,
-0.043244049,
-0.020608535,
0.0290525164,
-0.0217214208,
-0.0348367132,
-0.0041449745,
-0.045239009,
-0.0204692073,
0.0567743741,
-0.0209851339,
0.0492531061,
0.0272433944,
0.0287362952,
-0.0075934334,
0.0868227705,
0.0615706965,
0.0332743078,
0.0345015377,
0.0430262908,
0.026319867,
0.0140392585,
-0.0245678797,
0.0056857653,
-0.0230423398,
0.0490825027,
-0.0444371216,
0.013639899,
-0.0332737416,
0.0455169193,
-0.0070774765,
0.0009032133,
0.0286541767,
0.0347883627,
-0.0046320101,
-0.0148527194,
0.0429356024,
0.0348318852,
-0.0153218815,
-0.0408528633,
0.0096996604,
0.0167634115,
0.0178622846,
-0.01064956,
0.0027510335,
-0.0099247452,
-0.0233582333,
-0.0715496913,
-0.0358257294,
0.0074151908,
0.0134095969,
0.0112328604,
0.0601776354,
-0.0255366303,
-0.0164390709,
0.0131271286,
-0.0266964976,
-0.0244871806,
0.0044660461,
-0.0809571818,
0.0090739336,
0.1196614131,
0.0595598519,
-0.0304045621,
-0.0061855614,
0.0066120611,
0.0085692657,
0.035178192,
0.0464537032,
-0.0148621434,
-0.0204389393,
-0.024528088,
-0.0516366959,
0.0280945078,
-0.0011381961,
0.0262980126,
-0.0527527742,
-0.0013630379,
-0.0088875173,
0.0056410981,
-0.030967366,
0.0087809507,
-0.0305216201,
0.0128828557,
-0.0617541075,
0.0482652783,
0.0452139005,
0.04606032,
-0.0238510296,
0.0371806063,
-0.0004725874,
-0.0238574147,
-0.0643984005,
0.0400384925,
0.0284110624,
0.0593531691,
0.002348305,
0.0118937762,
-0.00483796,
0.0122786872,
0.0190916285,
-0.044766672,
0.0605908297,
-0.0564350896,
0.0052506602,
-0.0217591971,
0.0307103861,
-0.0610683747,
-0.0343579203,
-0.0221857782,
0.0291937646,
0.0059823031,
-0.0407507084,
0.0039568432,
0.0321759693,
0.046521008,
-0.0482572541,
0.0033457137,
0.0573850125,
0.0365440547,
0.0229438134,
0.0366418213,
-0.0218640883,
-0.0159482155,
-0.0179006588,
-0.074022755,
-0.0268845055,
-0.0052532968,
0.0187335964,
-0.0081082601,
-0.0279152822,
0.005920358,
0.0137621751,
0.0109467804,
0.0371693522,
0.0303869005,
0.0238564145,
0.0160894115,
0.053633891,
-0.0591536164,
0.0086734258,
0.0277934857,
-0.0212466028,
0.0258765202,
0.0460413434,
0.0046324776,
-0.0733825564,
0.0305571016,
-0.0413972028,
-0.0046987459,
0.0122006154,
-0.0299281925,
0.0509755425,
-0.0089953393,
-0.0088915313,
0.0282884557,
-0.042324461,
0.042664364,
-0.0012576598,
-0.0417321697,
-0.0568246245,
0.0020617065,
-0.0105579691,
-0.0029049234,
-0.0495405719,
-0.0005817719,
-0.0076334919,
0.0313419029,
0.0061554415,
-0.0174569264,
-0.0516117737,
0.0478489101,
-0.0541451462,
-0.0292392038,
-0.0363888964,
-0.047615435,
0.0011750521,
0.0781852305,
-0.0037048191,
-0.0361936539,
0.058449626,
-0.0036292393,
-0.0028737662,
-0.0369445458,
-0.0388359874,
-0.067261599,
0.0712439045,
-0.0340709016,
0.0069017378,
-0.0218729656,
-0.0071012536,
-0.0304209869,
-0.0433093272,
0.0373202823,
0.0010228951,
0.0318326727,
-0.0604104772,
0.0407310538,
-0.0007595862,
-0.0350568816,
0.0019402769,
0.0324624032,
-0.0774538815,
0.0358219221,
-0.0054537887,
-0.0023385431,
-0.0434882417,
0.0345396921,
0.0425861403,
-0.0013784117,
0.0283685587,
-0.0428395048,
-0.0042112633,
-0.0833962262,
-0.0178195331,
0.041907452,
0.0589482896,
-0.025357822,
0.0730495825,
0.021111317,
0.0518263727,
-0.0357517228,
-0.0253038332,
-0.0128114764,
-0.0225587934,
0.0002344106,
0.0241394415,
0.015596237,
0.0308749359,
-0.0632119626,
-0.0033491068,
0.0559067354,
0.0149975484,
-0.0199493449,
0.0212666634,
-0.044660408,
-0.0314398371,
0.0385052375,
0.0585054047,
-0.0244316217,
-0.016261356,
0.0008927552,
0.0192325506,
-0.0070187901,
-0.0435084067,
-0.0232188329,
-0.0610367507,
0.0571156554,
-0.0180847142,
-0.0022882803,
-0.044795543,
-0.0126211848,
-0.0185232908,
-0.0369601324,
0.0166662093,
0.0265599433,
0.0439809747,
-0.0393600501,
0.0277315192,
-0.0390102826,
-0.0331809893,
0.0359780788,
-0.0241117645,
0.0556928776,
0.056031324,
0.0170129146,
0.019241415,
-0.0495378301,
0.0078400429,
0.0322461538,
0.0380005576,
0.0013699556,
-0.0146410521,
0.0268229917,
0.0014460024,
-0.0034818605,
-0.029937081,
-0.0315288864,
-0.0250938199,
0.0352448449,
0.093912527,
-0.0155757219,
0.0065920809,
0.0002049983,
0.005908146,
0.0048707984,
0.0592033342,
-0.0064147916,
-0.0343598314,
-0.0653080121,
0.0004923203,
-0.0426264443,
-0.0534410328,
-0.0304765794,
0.0755762532,
0.0047290977,
-0.0095194131,
-0.0255988128,
-0.0697686449,
0.0166734587,
0.0331286415,
-0.0075843683,
-0.0034505606,
0.0314635299,
0.0156782866,
0.0114017371,
-0.0362249017,
-0.0267001186,
0.0484718755,
-0.0163181424,
0.0265932605,
-0.0178541038,
-0.0211469606,
0.0075059575,
-0.0414875969,
-0.0409266241,
-0.0534578823,
0.004234869,
0.0311760642,
0.0372479334,
-0.005545794,
-0.0180189628,
-0.0841048956,
0.0292091388,
-0.0427622944,
-0.0620456375,
-0.00603728,
0.0183657184,
0.0281282887,
0.00413991,
0.0525527112,
-0.0570896193,
0.0353911184,
-0.0036872628,
0.0287232827,
-0.0378382206,
-0.0467493609,
0.0040607899,
0.0268808175,
-0.0619185753,
0.0090091145,
-0.019121943,
-0.0185831636,
0.0148302196,
-0.0293787178,
-0.0171171222,
-0.0445529558,
0.0046751639,
-0.0265454873,
-0.0279428307,
0.0544268414,
-0.0230483674,
-0.0099901184,
-0.023883583,
0.0463227555,
0.0377167985,
-0.0076749735,
0.011657374,
0.0123601099,
0.0011025831,
-0.005890348,
0.0083698099,
-0.0248945169,
0.0340200663,
0.0287553612,
0.0810995921,
0.0275473334,
-0.0312872157,
-0.0089281313,
0.0075394427,
-0.0403657332,
-0.0606244132,
0.0475361757,
0.0093990294,
0.0376536958,
0.0541922674,
0.0046293545,
-0.0542862229,
0.0288328025,
-0.0173181184,
0.0093337595,
0.023542909,
-0.0260385331,
-0.0173091888,
0.048024565,
-0.0324889943,
0.0000562016,
0.0632013679,
-0.0088337455,
0.0207329988,
-0.0606769547,
-0.0574504621,
-0.0610202812,
-0.0478927717,
-0.0287643597,
-0.0250627697,
-0.0308225956,
0.0197681803,
-0.1064544097,
-0.0399053507,
0.001670379,
0.0806082711,
0.0047209584,
-0.0101305591,
-0.0061232881,
0.0556636341,
0.0308697205,
-0.0227075834,
-0.0380435139,
-0.0284820907,
-0.0640698075,
0.0579551607,
0.0352717191,
-6.206688784e-33,
-0.0188766401,
-0.0569341592,
0.0920233428,
-0.0035795136,
-0.0070423726,
-0.0118472455,
-0.0405176282,
0.0101932706,
0.0030800011,
0.0324220434,
-0.0097810365,
0.0000237663,
0.0188689027,
-0.0310225766,
0.0268839207,
0.021653885,
0.0060761925,
0.0199700352,
-0.0273252837,
-0.0044896244,
0.0656411797,
-0.0166736934,
0.0204822011,
-0.0406999998,
0.0330425538,
-0.0009769063,
-0.0262750536,
0.0646748245,
-0.0174911655,
0.0759017393,
0.0030139398,
0.0234356523,
0.0281024612,
-0.0673649162,
-0.0290850997,
0.0161460005,
0.0081952941,
-0.0212759227,
0.0033197638,
0.0313868746,
-0.0046355659,
0.0002400618,
0.00271984,
0.0046360251,
-0.022764178,
0.0359138958,
0.0243060999,
-0.0365233608,
0.0135528995,
0.0219669286,
-0.0607223772,
0.0298798308,
-0.0408655256,
0.0192556009,
0.0380529724,
0.0350632332,
-0.0397689044,
-0.0255809352,
-0.0634921789,
0.0227665436,
-0.0168891586,
-0.045201432,
0.0731867328,
0.0268085506,
-0.0026037474,
0.040083237,
0.0066297064,
0.03379317,
-0.0308809187,
-0.0248874091,
0.0022982187,
0.062343955,
0.040242184,
0.0656822026,
-0.067895852,
0.0003551252,
-0.0563339368,
0.0281332806,
0.0053251316,
0.0630860999,
0.0776127651,
0.027352063,
-0.066250585,
-0.031692978,
-0.0273064207,
0.0460760929,
-0.0426959209,
-0.0265108943,
0.0332797766,
0.013663155,
-0.0523441844,
0.0150693236,
0.0501636378,
-0.0416222923,
-0.0260237493,
-0.0086050984,
0.0205122642,
-0.0048102587,
0.0160721969,
0.0172414184,
-0.0527091697,
-0.0055585438,
-0.0188535117,
0.0571945161,
0.0398272946,
-0.0086810701,
-0.0063684215,
0.023573352,
-0.0008785762,
-0.0051089856,
-0.0491476581,
0.0262648035,
0.0076093059,
-0.0258279201,
0.0285653416,
-0.00347822,
-0.0087286169,
0.0331258401,
-0.0022738026,
-0.0438114144,
0.010617245,
0.0389125496,
0.0158557277,
-0.0209331345,
-0.0367096812,
-0.0076290527,
-0.0313347839,
0.0212749839,
0.0475116111,
0.0005068186,
-0.0067956373,
0.0202136263,
3.086e-7,
0.0173372552,
0.0271473397,
0.0008309608,
-0.006236515,
0.0207691006,
0.0701552182,
-0.0311366282,
-0.0221357066,
-0.0242116228,
-0.0229063723,
0.046439603,
0.0520958006,
0.0496545807,
0.0480750352,
-0.0131452102,
-0.0237152744,
-0.0103857061,
0.0016926499,
-0.0512334257,
-0.0018576419,
0.0801392645,
0.0041096243,
0.0289662518,
-0.0031978246,
-0.0139150005,
-0.0745212063,
0.0094812382,
-0.0372007452,
0.0307556745,
0.0324288048,
0.0448687971,
0.0034584901,
0.0168722402,
0.0483669043,
0.0225498974,
0.0330562033,
-0.0281372219,
0.0702149123,
-0.0251480602,
-0.0209584944,
0.0018402755,
-0.0669989735,
0.0145592941,
-0.0392512456,
0.0207681749,
-0.0649966374,
-0.050592754,
-0.0135045331,
0.0413074605,
-0.039398659,
-0.0173341986,
0.0042535164,
-0.0236449614,
0.008991369,
-0.0055479007,
-0.038471885,
0.0324437618,
-0.0726025626,
0.038439475,
-0.0171330757,
-0.0578160547,
-0.0389596038,
-0.0262777228,
0.0006081365,
0.0265294556,
-0.0332569778,
0.0208678823,
2.527160867e-34,
0.0172687024,
0.0018337942,
0.0126761524,
0.0217838902,
0.0453445427,
0.0369267166,
-0.0465878062,
0.0209785495,
0.0320238844,
-0.0683243796,
-0.0163400564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01789v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01789v2 | The Political Preferences of LLMs | 2024-02-02T02:43:10 | 2024-06-02T04:48:36 | David Rozado | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | I report here a comprehensive analysis about the political preferences
embedded in Large Language Models (LLMs). Namely, I administer 11 political
orientation tests, designed to identify the political preferences of the test
taker, to 24 state-of-the-art conversational LLMs, both closed and open source.
When probed with questions/statements with political connotations, most
conversational LLMs tend to generate responses that are diagnosed by most
political test instruments as manifesting preferences for left-of-center
viewpoints. This does not appear to be the case for five additional base (i.e.
foundation) models upon which LLMs optimized for conversation with humans are
built. However, the weak performance of the base models at coherently answering
the tests' questions makes this subset of results inconclusive. Finally, I
demonstrate that LLMs can be steered towards specific locations in the
political spectrum through Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) with only modest
amounts of politically aligned data, suggesting SFT's potential to embed
political orientation in LLMs. With LLMs beginning to partially displace
traditional information sources like search engines and Wikipedia, the societal
implications of political biases embedded in LLMs are substantial. | [
0.0589404963,
0.0679728165,
-0.0252177343,
0.0174819939,
-0.0273496099,
0.0163027067,
0.0098989327,
-0.0102726519,
0.0188235231,
-0.0681791827,
-0.0187653266,
-0.0405806303,
-0.0182526745,
-0.0045779077,
-0.0000065972,
-0.0748710781,
0.0508921705,
0.0259438828,
0.060600426,
-0.0702388734,
0.0054570273,
0.0324598476,
-0.0123964204,
0.0328768119,
-0.0010685368,
0.0062164678,
-0.0173642896,
0.0029030456,
0.0383198112,
0.0258674491,
0.0271505173,
0.0595677979,
-0.0002284849,
-0.0108581064,
0.0000018738,
-0.0417793058,
0.0097401692,
-0.0597086772,
0.0297576599,
-0.0186668467,
0.0745474771,
0.019280633,
-0.0085056294,
0.0238493979,
-0.0453039035,
0.016128106,
0.0323609672,
0.0269058924,
0.0110058459,
0.0408420041,
0.0222339816,
-0.0343079902,
-0.0146701913,
0.0051821922,
-0.007830237,
-0.0318529345,
0.0511059687,
-0.0147932367,
-0.0417134576,
0.0349981077,
-0.044257082,
-0.0000245379,
0.0091387015,
0.0070770318,
-0.023095537,
-0.0039775022,
-0.0140392063,
-0.0186553188,
0.0091350954,
0.0614275821,
0.0070013027,
-0.0150245735,
0.0186898541,
-0.0171999037,
0.0115079023,
0.0399338454,
-0.0444022715,
0.0444659479,
-0.0112098251,
0.0167930853,
0.0342694297,
-0.0412650183,
-0.0006537519,
0.0736822262,
-0.0387175642,
0.1065404043,
-0.0268878452,
-0.015480197,
0.0183886494,
-0.0016322737,
0.0270700101,
-0.0423170701,
0.0215960722,
-0.0273999609,
-0.0023250736,
0.0269073732,
-0.0241927486,
0.0637667999,
0.0375440009,
-0.0432925113,
-0.0006477402,
0.0429833643,
-0.013133402,
0.0664483011,
0.0724622086,
-0.0180869568,
-0.0161391068,
0.0115563637,
0.0016700458,
-0.0261405855,
-0.0136143835,
0.0011899149,
0.0335123204,
0.0022248412,
-0.0187087674,
0.0103618726,
-0.0162791777,
-0.0021972971,
-0.0161238834,
0.0127622141,
-0.0366963856,
0.0068221334,
-0.0048356657,
-0.01349374,
-0.0811032355,
0.0559443347,
-0.0614227988,
0.0466380604,
-0.0148736751,
-0.042136807,
0.0412962809,
0.0474054702,
-0.0275725871,
-0.0316335447,
0.0099552004,
-0.0033462041,
0.0129514197,
-0.0075493688,
0.0203741174,
0.0039661401,
-0.0166578945,
-0.0510768183,
0.0314776115,
-0.0464811027,
0.0441210717,
0.0281368289,
-0.0051953192,
-0.0521415062,
0.0092160599,
0.0387278013,
-0.0573493764,
0.0518672764,
0.0353125259,
0.0372328945,
0.0316837914,
0.0193276368,
0.012171953,
0.0965889469,
-0.0013968907,
0.0149981501,
0.037544392,
-0.0609506629,
0.0063321656,
0.0287785903,
-0.0403654873,
0.0249953382,
-0.0445836261,
0.0423201509,
-0.0299554877,
-0.0180177353,
0.064150624,
0.0473276824,
0.0136507815,
-0.0463824049,
0.0796149448,
0.0676470399,
-0.0125947101,
0.0246168487,
-0.003838595,
0.0506875515,
0.0097929882,
0.0446915701,
-0.0401906632,
0.0169892572,
-0.0607586242,
-0.0398899727,
0.0088433651,
0.0578676201,
-0.0290201586,
-0.0301887076,
-0.0173823964,
0.0084910858,
0.0516360551,
0.0444284901,
0.0428567491,
-0.0586385466,
-0.005785706,
0.0228451043,
0.0412472896,
-0.0349421762,
-0.0152230309,
-0.0686074421,
0.0423967391,
0.0443234704,
-0.0086486051,
-0.0080460142,
-0.0088951513,
-0.0323427916,
0.0288456231,
0.1003027111,
0.1171760559,
-0.0318636447,
-0.0231910367,
-0.0272914823,
-0.0120416358,
0.0030842538,
0.0108047854,
0.0488176644,
0.0271001458,
0.0174745303,
-0.0056964206,
-0.0153307952,
-0.0066872765,
0.0131838806,
-0.0169177242,
0.0061235903,
-0.0079937261,
0.0302217286,
0.0354643352,
0.0084293308,
0.0030446858,
-0.0260904171,
0.0187478419,
0.0148344133,
-0.0003904371,
-0.0109752063,
-0.0649412423,
0.0297460388,
0.00832533,
-0.0185692534,
-0.016374968,
0.0432052985,
-0.012679711,
0.004467031,
0.0461150743,
-0.0027869472,
0.0224969573,
-0.014412974,
-0.0056343162,
-0.0615302213,
0.0013181961,
-0.0751090348,
0.0448427461,
-0.0082944194,
0.0149962725,
0.0224238504,
-0.0368463621,
0.0210583024,
-0.0149347335,
-0.0280293468,
0.0220607575,
0.0122033944,
0.025034396,
0.05769936,
-0.0380928107,
-0.0563852564,
-0.0657165498,
-0.0434953086,
-0.0011609069,
-0.0258576237,
0.0258379616,
0.0178317241,
-0.0265364405,
-0.0247529857,
0.0232145861,
-0.0470290631,
-0.0017936248,
-0.0175448265,
0.0281906836,
0.0169633813,
-0.0070298705,
-0.0264316127,
-0.0301852468,
0.0172383711,
-0.0246741716,
-0.0215938017,
-0.0000585313,
-0.0043507069,
-0.0109797241,
0.0278635416,
-0.0664329976,
-0.0186411235,
-0.0389740504,
-0.0435435027,
0.0195014086,
0.0260714646,
0.0287653767,
0.0997112468,
0.0594771951,
0.0129207671,
0.0417845249,
0.0119668739,
-0.0828136429,
-0.0222488679,
-0.0309793297,
-0.0006334302,
-0.0594710745,
-0.0476749055,
0.0036445146,
0.0669634789,
0.0124412514,
0.0088820066,
-0.0454023182,
0.0636869743,
-0.0065105343,
-0.0320031159,
-0.0078276349,
0.0095952395,
-0.0147694601,
0.0499704331,
0.0094849775,
-0.034128584,
0.0472202711,
0.0227385238,
0.0405656733,
-0.0204858817,
-0.0148207303,
-0.0127222287,
0.0317260213,
-0.0136379255,
0.0007610096,
-0.0224280115,
-0.0048260754,
-0.0675578415,
-0.0417488702,
0.0318542421,
-0.0603589155,
0.0390583239,
-0.0524639636,
-0.0123961698,
0.0054061483,
-0.0291754473,
-0.0552409329,
-0.0540242456,
-0.0267153643,
0.0068909582,
0.0518897362,
-0.0325601548,
-0.0017565986,
0.0077142534,
0.0431096777,
-0.0550538488,
-0.0079906359,
0.0160210282,
0.0130802477,
0.0012324456,
0.028310813,
0.028842913,
0.0354535617,
0.0059254658,
0.0124419918,
0.0103467051,
-0.0026689819,
0.0322849862,
0.0085092839,
-0.0483874679,
0.054332424,
-0.0149412593,
-0.0358466394,
0.0009609795,
0.0456100143,
-0.0199191496,
0.0240809526,
0.0958572403,
0.0336466096,
-0.0622719824,
-0.0221986659,
-0.0259556528,
-0.0150018502,
0.0435622782,
0.0133442972,
-0.0809868649,
0.0228191298,
0.0100076068,
-0.0035902059,
-0.0494023003,
-0.0105232866,
-0.0235074591,
-0.1251732558,
-0.0068822294,
-0.0118698049,
-0.0298958477,
-0.0157344006,
-0.0359927677,
0.0465307273,
-0.0038854543,
0.0161776058,
0.0076240436,
0.0085915215,
0.0018444721,
-0.007539317,
-0.0572928116,
-0.0690582767,
0.0388518758,
0.0131951161,
0.0427664146,
0.0322427787,
0.0513665192,
-0.0037909455,
-0.0350488201,
0.0669988021,
-0.0138553837,
-0.0198435131,
-0.0249555577,
0.0052554524,
-0.0295281503,
0.0123426775,
-0.0209874921,
0.043974258,
0.0236439034,
0.0001446179,
0.0032732275,
0.0294231232,
-0.0394249931,
-0.0349712633,
0.0103197293,
0.040301878,
0.0512236245,
0.0745512843,
0.0607521757,
-0.0765917897,
0.0257883258,
-0.0614522025,
-0.0062700459,
-0.0123234848,
-0.0493607372,
-0.0156013984,
-0.0174761247,
0.0081301685,
-0.0127631547,
-0.0658482313,
0.0177446734,
-0.0216417182,
-0.010404787,
-0.0208465923,
0.0322491787,
-0.0079561612,
0.0070874034,
0.0486809909,
-0.0252123419,
0.0069003473,
-0.0289287362,
-0.0747060329,
0.0228232257,
-0.0474233665,
-0.0210467931,
-0.0157243889,
0.0019858417,
-0.0587140545,
0.0547157563,
0.0118691865,
0.0174193457,
0.0122588575,
-0.0037930564,
-0.0550535806,
-0.0049273102,
0.0564863235,
-0.0376609303,
0.0124966595,
0.0043530478,
0.0577207655,
0.0078129619,
0.0259482022,
-0.0069571347,
0.0416132882,
0.0537653938,
-0.0306664612,
-0.0628992394,
-0.086486578,
0.0095166508,
0.0095144827,
0.0672419593,
0.0230658185,
-0.0499293171,
-0.024485033,
-0.0276813786,
-0.0078680972,
-0.0469289497,
0.0304730367,
-0.0443147458,
0.0327483639,
-0.063107729,
-0.0204159729,
0.0190033913,
-0.0575582907,
0.0347366482,
-0.0232474748,
0.0365440845,
-0.0212604385,
0.019188894,
0.0175658595,
0.0195776317,
-0.0164119825,
0.0462373905,
0.0152078206,
0.054345578,
0.024904009,
0.0778009668,
0.0105005307,
-0.017374428,
0.0451482199,
-0.0269774534,
-0.0299779363,
-0.0764101073,
0.0118391942,
0.0423591658,
0.0172858853,
-0.0146284672,
0.0197802186,
-0.0059745912,
-0.0223608613,
-0.024224842,
0.0151923643,
0.0196580235,
-0.0361702852,
0.0698798522,
-0.0057584238,
-0.0556626208,
-0.0077814315,
0.040782392,
-0.0077965404,
0.0215240046,
0.0260365717,
0.0022289718,
-0.0283639617,
-0.0099713281,
0.0046049682,
-0.0046648951,
-0.0405556411,
-0.0091694398,
-0.0707140341,
-0.0365143083,
0.009216344,
0.0123401629,
-0.0105671398,
-0.0129918782,
0.0242927764,
0.0755270272,
-0.0392133929,
0.0197430924,
-0.0556733645,
0.0645065755,
-0.0584091544,
-0.0146380998,
-0.0239463318,
-6.238360275e-33,
-0.0162882935,
-0.0263994951,
0.0119111761,
-0.0213824734,
0.0060184593,
-0.0349566899,
-0.0083600152,
0.0692622662,
-0.0588278398,
0.0041287625,
-0.0030003204,
0.026187418,
0.0217183232,
0.001775694,
-0.0164904576,
-0.0309669636,
0.0106243985,
-0.0065046572,
-0.0381716974,
0.0061520711,
0.0158137623,
-0.0029473009,
0.0452218726,
-0.0729172826,
0.0027743015,
0.0074460055,
0.0166132376,
-0.0042208009,
-0.030603556,
0.017452592,
-0.0213785321,
0.0353667773,
0.0299664363,
-0.0002862545,
-0.0033350016,
0.0745416805,
-0.0032887403,
-0.0183084644,
0.037110962,
0.0118314801,
0.0153309936,
-0.053518109,
0.0147022763,
-0.0087117618,
-0.0594061986,
0.006257602,
0.0400085673,
-0.0330782458,
0.0116462149,
0.0114508169,
-0.0230250191,
0.0124840541,
-0.0086114667,
-0.0232930593,
-0.0502867997,
0.0635150075,
0.0393784121,
0.0554536469,
-0.0314101987,
0.068227388,
-0.0324748233,
-0.0009903796,
0.0705033392,
-0.0202187598,
0.0261160843,
0.0724349767,
0.0331008919,
0.0523519926,
-0.0472639389,
-0.0709247515,
0.0574561208,
-0.0106780063,
0.0287411194,
0.0589044616,
-0.008517745,
-0.0637052208,
-0.046962481,
-0.0172197931,
0.0668379664,
-0.0000264292,
0.0158748906,
-0.0191389062,
-0.0207433999,
-0.0370888487,
-0.0652816147,
-0.0471143872,
-0.0243030787,
-0.0175472796,
0.0111170486,
0.0138618117,
-0.0317967162,
-0.0206382871,
0.0503291674,
-0.0354473069,
-0.0128456922,
0.0306397118,
-0.0406583324,
-0.013103948,
-0.0024422642,
0.013861767,
-0.0721749589,
-0.0137095191,
-0.0422202833,
-0.0227315556,
0.0028011801,
0.0009835965,
-0.0099807549,
-0.0015704393,
-0.0595145971,
-0.013548281,
-0.0172612481,
-0.0101065924,
0.0037919115,
0.0295155756,
0.0318361335,
0.0515242144,
0.0160305928,
0.0478541404,
0.030370554,
-0.0080537088,
-0.0155879427,
-0.0695463195,
-0.0619813018,
0.0355616175,
-0.0426393375,
-0.028125681,
-0.0335426368,
0.0439489409,
0.0045436937,
-0.0085891569,
-0.0231567789,
-0.027175637,
2.458e-7,
0.0421903245,
0.100348793,
-0.0391583443,
0.0201680195,
-0.0186533313,
0.0093255965,
0.0252230689,
0.0080251545,
-0.0020203888,
-0.0459690057,
-0.043418996,
0.0062119788,
0.0610299483,
0.0182009321,
-0.0874487534,
0.0128479414,
-0.018695971,
0.040176779,
-0.0458372198,
0.0324602611,
-0.0311870407,
0.0293021128,
0.0209616013,
0.0241512097,
-0.0343153179,
0.0175994933,
0.0571074523,
-0.0747406557,
-0.0514096096,
0.033188615,
0.0129495272,
-0.0019664648,
0.0302429441,
0.0487874895,
0.0167708639,
0.0185797643,
-0.041011814,
0.0955823362,
0.011204794,
-0.0344136618,
-0.0252652299,
-0.0208038725,
0.0038427815,
-0.0401735306,
0.064402394,
-0.0458720699,
-0.0021829894,
-0.0367568694,
-0.0070542293,
-0.0082137715,
0.0478839092,
-0.042473264,
-0.0278369244,
-0.0103449067,
0.0078785941,
-0.0053801648,
0.0067673922,
-0.0314477868,
-0.0097393477,
-0.0285951514,
-0.0487152115,
-0.092130281,
0.0087488899,
0.0023447576,
0.0251746457,
0.0038478491,
0.0064560878,
1.771327986e-34,
0.0295924526,
0.014521814,
-0.0084415302,
-0.049958434,
0.0538383313,
0.0160390865,
0.0117428796,
0.0027274708,
0.0292364303,
-0.0959713459,
0.0177149121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01788v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01788v1 | LitLLM: A Toolkit for Scientific Literature Review | 2024-02-02T02:41:28 | 2024-02-02T02:41:28 | Shubham Agarwal, Issam H. Laradji, Laurent Charlin, Christopher Pal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Conducting literature reviews for scientific papers is essential for
understanding research, its limitations, and building on existing work. It is a
tedious task which makes an automatic literature review generator appealing.
Unfortunately, many existing works that generate such reviews using Large
Language Models (LLMs) have significant limitations. They tend to
hallucinate-generate non-actual information-and ignore the latest research they
have not been trained on. To address these limitations, we propose a toolkit
that operates on Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) principles, specialized
prompting and instructing techniques with the help of LLMs. Our system first
initiates a web search to retrieve relevant papers by summarizing user-provided
abstracts into keywords using an off-the-shelf LLM. Authors can enhance the
search by supplementing it with relevant papers or keywords, contributing to a
tailored retrieval process. Second, the system re-ranks the retrieved papers
based on the user-provided abstract. Finally, the related work section is
generated based on the re-ranked results and the abstract. There is a
substantial reduction in time and effort for literature review compared to
traditional methods, establishing our toolkit as an efficient alternative. Our
open-source toolkit is accessible at https://github.com/shubhamagarwal92/LitLLM
and Huggingface space (https://huggingface.co/spaces/shubhamagarwal92/LitLLM)
with the video demo at https://youtu.be/E2ggOZBAFw0. | [
0.074197486,
-0.0101970742,
-0.002726106,
-0.0238522235,
-0.0053264038,
-0.0261853803,
0.0263785552,
0.001391007,
0.0020490617,
-0.0621657558,
-0.0563550331,
-0.0101877572,
-0.0061802599,
0.039138969,
0.0396462604,
-0.0449734926,
0.0214512311,
-0.0086460952,
0.0230675582,
-0.0054163355,
-0.0106985448,
-0.0083372239,
0.006022539,
0.0268014092,
0.0794493333,
-0.0096763531,
-0.0033856295,
-0.0102080265,
0.0269308332,
-0.0541723855,
0.0351397395,
0.0419179611,
0.0064890985,
0.0712846816,
0.0000021894,
-0.0693989471,
-0.0223471466,
0.0210228506,
0.0500864536,
0.0261746608,
0.1148176938,
0.0077247634,
0.0013056585,
0.0020968949,
-0.0145375617,
-0.0211377963,
0.0146116586,
0.0274470747,
0.0142426742,
0.0259241275,
0.0052450639,
-0.0265236907,
0.009224765,
-0.0205613393,
0.0252911355,
0.0244774967,
0.0068760337,
0.0346923545,
0.0914851427,
0.0903194845,
0.0477278829,
0.0426219255,
-0.0285686031,
-0.0681811124,
0.0693900436,
0.0246018823,
-0.0515966378,
-0.028663246,
0.0140725998,
0.0546652749,
0.022325309,
-0.0407413542,
0.0336716585,
-0.0186193958,
-0.0254097357,
0.081216298,
-0.0921851546,
0.029687617,
0.0171879735,
-0.0294867903,
0.0060555674,
-0.0061687161,
0.029117452,
0.0201042052,
0.0364580676,
0.0425615273,
0.0210364964,
-0.0309877116,
-0.0142315431,
-0.0097934026,
0.0337855145,
-0.029721465,
-0.0078119216,
0.0444352254,
-0.0148209427,
-0.0144770974,
0.0537263788,
-0.0656715631,
0.1056594774,
-0.0356129669,
0.0148234414,
-0.0302177016,
0.00985434,
0.0193118472,
-0.0163397789,
-0.0422229841,
-0.0209050961,
-0.0518670902,
-0.0263609476,
0.0307793077,
-0.0243215896,
-0.0607702993,
0.0001075313,
0.0047597066,
-0.0359965228,
-0.0112337284,
-0.0426586457,
0.0025895359,
-0.018554965,
0.0007000658,
0.0051781111,
0.02978977,
-0.0346046388,
0.0089430176,
-0.0144157978,
0.0329044014,
0.0183770359,
0.0238751955,
0.0008099783,
0.0090383356,
-0.0080202166,
0.0195754394,
0.0067615849,
-0.001299499,
0.0341607295,
0.0011525919,
0.0211111736,
-0.0428102873,
0.0165825542,
-0.053403426,
0.0003752739,
-0.0264076218,
0.0182758756,
-0.10064096,
0.0217317082,
0.0131685324,
-0.0140944514,
0.0126960659,
0.0182931796,
0.0473105982,
-0.0197383221,
-0.0010386247,
-0.071520783,
0.0092463307,
0.0486760437,
0.023147732,
0.0355544649,
0.0171699952,
-0.0279941745,
0.018457571,
0.035734579,
-0.0073287943,
0.021781737,
0.005213744,
-0.0025629676,
0.0078195063,
0.0154431751,
0.0022227112,
-0.038696222,
0.0265659075,
0.0101915915,
0.024280617,
-0.0422938764,
0.0420654267,
0.0126749324,
0.0674270391,
0.0239732526,
0.0327849798,
0.008272741,
0.0226222221,
0.0335531123,
-0.0174752027,
0.0082834549,
0.0403549336,
-0.0266695451,
0.0155933788,
0.0282446537,
0.0417283997,
0.0062663215,
-0.0294644013,
-0.0111874873,
0.0224819612,
-0.006644031,
-0.0246666893,
0.0849565268,
0.0252443105,
-0.0139379455,
0.0072331964,
0.0297587495,
-0.0569037832,
0.0362948887,
-0.0140543338,
0.0435712375,
0.0593808778,
0.1121317595,
-0.0499910712,
-0.0046342607,
0.0099851843,
-0.0305290148,
0.0552022234,
0.0154799614,
-0.0089856088,
-0.051831454,
-0.0261580143,
-0.0362694189,
-0.0352384634,
-0.0238617845,
-0.0003039031,
0.0138847223,
-0.0069002281,
0.0289582368,
-0.0338488854,
-0.0787376463,
0.0136352908,
-0.0412068479,
-0.0188159309,
0.0016552184,
-0.0641823262,
0.0279798601,
0.0283100512,
-0.0282498281,
0.0634199008,
0.067392081,
-0.019753335,
-0.0444357954,
0.0035886657,
0.0450097956,
0.0421057865,
0.0178659726,
-0.0553242266,
0.0466583222,
0.0114355721,
-0.0024430361,
-0.046734836,
0.0423403047,
0.0147552304,
0.040124625,
-0.0120955417,
0.0125444913,
-0.0153176365,
-0.0193760283,
-0.047095418,
0.0557318553,
0.0314105488,
0.061859902,
0.0414799936,
-0.0270349868,
-0.001646339,
-0.0226195995,
-0.022261139,
0.01748682,
0.0048984922,
0.0064305384,
0.0737819821,
0.0173602384,
-0.0261813235,
-0.0235628746,
-0.0917915702,
-0.0022477743,
0.0269478839,
-0.0057068826,
0.0269746203,
0.0123578226,
-0.0075174868,
-0.0027080178,
0.0030589488,
-0.0044042836,
0.0391322151,
-0.008572801,
0.030377144,
0.0064473925,
0.0237760898,
-0.080139935,
-0.0320842043,
-0.0014002002,
0.0279584732,
0.0551983416,
0.0029260847,
-0.0606363378,
0.0572119951,
-0.0161778014,
-0.0137205524,
-0.0280760862,
0.0149174863,
0.0133473799,
-0.0217743851,
0.0235636756,
0.0336335935,
0.0208946411,
0.0028059091,
0.0884450153,
-0.0145843728,
-0.0669468418,
-0.0266130809,
-0.0271375217,
-0.0148978187,
0.0347343795,
-0.0345823355,
0.0537959486,
-0.0063444627,
-0.0071175541,
-0.015261109,
0.0162149575,
-0.013477305,
-0.0128836045,
-0.0134460153,
-0.030154163,
-0.0321424678,
0.0038947316,
0.030508846,
0.02745305,
-0.0467541963,
0.0373711176,
-0.0401119478,
-0.006051139,
-0.0877685174,
0.0163228791,
-0.0466021113,
0.0392978713,
0.007558601,
0.0116745243,
-0.0429700688,
0.0217741691,
-0.0147998026,
0.000356912,
0.0016212189,
-0.0456978045,
0.007534558,
-0.0398362726,
0.011869764,
-0.0208732244,
0.0156364981,
-0.0044775978,
-0.0185033195,
-0.0085332505,
0.011317079,
0.0287767928,
-0.0327198356,
-0.0227331836,
0.0175892096,
0.089121528,
0.0180695355,
-0.0419944078,
-0.0280202534,
-0.0072053466,
0.0136484234,
0.0736809447,
-0.0609685071,
0.0116849467,
0.004509062,
0.0103265401,
0.0582803898,
0.0085587958,
0.0091546979,
-0.0219591353,
-0.0444032475,
0.0456571355,
-0.050929375,
-0.0134507623,
-0.016580034,
0.0060732444,
-0.0435093343,
0.0018242577,
0.0920033976,
0.0437706374,
-0.0830836296,
-0.0307104532,
-0.0854364634,
0.0178073384,
0.0155010736,
0.0466898903,
-0.0471423455,
0.038810391,
0.0012749704,
0.0625883341,
-0.0070643607,
0.0085357251,
0.0167220123,
-0.0725634545,
0.0596113019,
0.0239712056,
0.0123301418,
-0.0042335112,
-0.0705510899,
0.0131918043,
0.0106985299,
-0.0421716124,
0.07242845,
-0.0575490147,
0.0086829653,
0.0092014773,
-0.0158268232,
-0.045781374,
0.0071325782,
-0.0454123281,
0.0167391561,
0.0335253216,
0.0092943273,
-0.0217801556,
-0.000760252,
0.0134598101,
-0.0393877551,
-0.0097078253,
-0.0281048454,
0.0112017635,
0.0294210631,
0.0302043576,
-0.0507445857,
0.0336836018,
-0.0095763691,
-0.0274726991,
0.0437715203,
0.0479522943,
-0.0436628498,
0.0081435507,
-0.0921440423,
0.0189805236,
-0.0109457131,
0.0546489097,
0.0034934317,
-0.023658989,
-0.0226092096,
0.0051930323,
0.0159421284,
0.0302117839,
-0.0531324521,
-0.002221561,
-0.0376694277,
-0.0086568296,
-0.0469764881,
-0.0093645845,
0.0004970523,
0.0137888985,
0.036182221,
0.0541531742,
0.0162117388,
-0.0304254144,
-0.0431173369,
0.0278276,
0.019799348,
-0.0074155335,
-0.006989148,
-0.0336028263,
0.1089427471,
-0.0449417867,
0.0012412567,
0.0040095598,
0.0159966797,
-0.0410231985,
-0.0382163972,
0.0423080102,
0.0288002249,
-0.0002229729,
-0.0200798307,
-0.0276275203,
0.0558997653,
0.0309271421,
-0.0116485665,
-0.0082253469,
-0.0345238671,
0.0090027191,
-0.017949421,
-0.0503572822,
-0.08342354,
0.0101234652,
-0.0318958834,
0.0109686889,
-0.0192223936,
-0.0415072329,
0.019628793,
0.0351342596,
0.0075546009,
-0.0596610457,
0.0265311562,
-0.0235942919,
-0.0010250255,
-0.0402693748,
-0.0186458696,
-0.0242675468,
0.0542480536,
-0.0031055866,
-0.0198198147,
0.0237512439,
0.036270801,
-0.0379720293,
0.0757602081,
-0.0403030328,
0.0667268112,
-0.0363380499,
0.0119913705,
0.0358421504,
-0.0192508493,
-0.0342240222,
-0.0264033619,
-0.0805639401,
0.0251577329,
-0.0187251065,
0.0100855092,
0.0142424246,
-0.0261501819,
-0.0205186233,
0.0443167761,
-0.1005320325,
-0.045455467,
-0.0449472554,
-0.0208215471,
0.0240224563,
0.0157181546,
0.0796134919,
-0.0508661084,
-0.0127540901,
-0.028238222,
0.0240672454,
0.001571862,
0.0084695583,
-0.0012879276,
0.0302249454,
-0.017027365,
-0.0272356272,
0.0723262206,
-0.0068123005,
-0.0301389471,
0.012099131,
-0.0460434631,
-0.0175424479,
-0.0501450375,
0.0088628437,
0.0330002606,
-0.0252267495,
-0.0542497076,
-0.0295282304,
-0.0074816337,
0.0059940619,
0.0209146589,
-0.0188432634,
-0.0424158536,
0.0199469998,
0.0823736191,
0.0042220643,
-0.0158901606,
-0.0446244739,
0.0573929995,
-0.0321877711,
-0.0505938083,
-0.0253050923,
-6.492626315e-33,
-0.0083858538,
-0.0578067899,
0.0261322036,
-0.0109530836,
-0.0279184766,
0.0115839597,
-0.0574031994,
-0.0218390562,
0.0341250747,
0.0018032001,
-0.019047467,
0.0058213146,
-0.0098881014,
0.0040066056,
0.061725378,
0.0489464216,
0.0225253422,
0.0082184719,
-0.0124253696,
0.0602212809,
0.0235267673,
0.0016635422,
-0.0057821893,
-0.0424658507,
0.0563550144,
-0.0164001174,
0.0026024806,
-0.0244232602,
0.0007929818,
0.0532671064,
-0.0323068611,
0.0313408785,
0.0107130064,
-0.0003307517,
-0.0112252897,
0.0073446459,
-0.0547565818,
0.0114087742,
0.0161848627,
-0.0353469476,
-0.0225641951,
-0.0111707542,
0.0511676036,
-0.0183839481,
-0.0353733674,
0.0370106548,
0.0629484504,
-0.0400970206,
-0.0529706702,
-0.0821938366,
-0.0490267314,
0.004378444,
-0.0006643865,
0.0346511006,
-0.0101578599,
0.086321719,
-0.0175493229,
0.0705304071,
-0.0420263931,
0.0538322143,
0.0036791395,
0.0497753322,
0.0357455239,
-0.0044729477,
0.0294561032,
0.0443751849,
-0.0519612841,
-0.0113654379,
0.0321079679,
-0.0336558893,
0.0162504148,
0.016179258,
0.0207201876,
0.0121601392,
0.0196532905,
-0.0187463798,
-0.0432021022,
0.0612967983,
0.012127962,
0.0423928909,
0.0710784793,
-0.0055896882,
0.0449287705,
-0.0221989993,
0.0084503777,
-0.014403847,
-0.0077516376,
-0.0426537879,
-0.005392292,
0.0082938867,
-0.0459276065,
-0.0587957762,
-0.0018907015,
-0.0142045375,
-0.0073296591,
0.0481998622,
-0.0061807721,
0.0353872925,
-0.013790153,
-0.017181715,
-0.0388795473,
-0.0210037995,
-0.000728262,
0.0118579119,
-0.0231044982,
-0.0011341311,
-0.003694497,
0.0136437342,
-0.0421520844,
0.0059056263,
0.0036244851,
0.0136817833,
-0.0069941911,
0.0030085079,
-0.0250011701,
0.0167331621,
0.02556381,
0.0166159216,
0.0199218933,
0.0339242555,
-0.0062205694,
-0.0150283296,
-0.0118200099,
0.0305491332,
0.0134084951,
0.0439072773,
-0.0284038819,
0.0395546705,
0.043524351,
-0.0422205739,
-0.0038210286,
-0.0071888058,
3.078e-7,
0.0522400215,
0.053134758,
-0.0178402252,
0.0012169363,
0.0562108792,
-0.0111224428,
0.0066009737,
0.0047645154,
0.0370982029,
0.0349324606,
0.0177514087,
-0.0147134317,
-0.0035988821,
0.0181200989,
-0.1001512557,
-0.0266806819,
-0.090973787,
-0.0854946077,
-0.048723802,
-0.018685529,
0.0158864707,
0.0049115201,
-0.029650569,
-0.0041569108,
-0.0451845117,
-0.0577161275,
0.040094763,
-0.0257849824,
-0.0053166454,
0.0411123745,
0.0574890226,
-0.0066928454,
0.0114957653,
-0.058876656,
-0.0245526135,
0.0089922808,
-0.0211656056,
-0.0096183894,
0.0131563321,
-0.003494584,
0.0564087257,
-0.0306129791,
0.0492443107,
-0.0642151386,
0.0290698539,
-0.0338993184,
-0.0060607884,
-0.0420758128,
-0.0633864924,
-0.0219967049,
0.0188318808,
-0.0463835821,
-0.0350223705,
0.0516798645,
-0.032508377,
-0.0125196166,
-0.0277367961,
-0.0345795415,
-0.0143712685,
0.0580158755,
-0.0398650765,
-0.0672366023,
-0.0095346533,
-0.0414051488,
-0.0431679413,
-0.0512679815,
0.011672915,
3.095872839e-34,
0.0956117734,
-0.0114957709,
-0.0164204445,
0.0146288453,
0.0252274666,
0.005721685,
-0.0661886632,
0.0508514121,
0.0152353169,
-0.0913028419,
-0.0186719615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01097v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01097v1 | Let's Negotiate! A Survey of Negotiation Dialogue Systems | 2024-02-02T02:12:46 | 2024-02-02T02:12:46 | Haolan Zhan, Yufei Wang, Tao Feng, Yuncheng Hua, Suraj Sharma, Zhuang Li, Lizhen Qu, Zhaleh Semnani Azad, Ingrid Zukerman, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Negotiation is a crucial ability in human communication. Recently, there has
been a resurgent research interest in negotiation dialogue systems, whose goal
is to create intelligent agents that can assist people in resolving conflicts
or reaching agreements. Although there have been many explorations into
negotiation dialogue systems, a systematic review of this task has not been
performed to date. We aim to fill this gap by investigating recent studies in
the field of negotiation dialogue systems, and covering benchmarks, evaluations
and methodologies within the literature. We also discuss potential future
directions, including multi-modal, multi-party and cross-cultural negotiation
scenarios. Our goal is to provide the community with a systematic overview of
negotiation dialogue systems and to inspire future research. | [
0.0893710107,
0.0298150815,
-0.0300944988,
-0.0017689767,
-0.0412676521,
-0.0183040723,
0.0561509952,
0.0182240754,
0.0096797859,
-0.0354786813,
-0.0269345939,
-0.014891142,
0.0058863666,
0.027343085,
0.0004389825,
-0.0568104349,
0.0401588678,
-0.0042124349,
0.0686253011,
-0.0157783087,
0.0310659949,
-0.0012941913,
-0.04218252,
0.0635636896,
-0.0740353614,
-0.0072159511,
-0.0762923807,
-0.0038168696,
0.0496472903,
-0.000524445,
-0.0343716517,
0.0477720685,
-0.0126475608,
0.037574444,
0.0000016829,
-0.0706954598,
-0.0011651611,
-0.0222250968,
-0.0257546585,
-0.0267678238,
0.0717607215,
-0.0225346088,
-0.0148716727,
0.0372627415,
-0.0623643249,
-0.010333037,
0.0359689035,
0.0831659958,
0.0664801821,
0.0633407012,
-0.0041155485,
0.01888193,
-0.0128650405,
-0.0187924709,
-0.0385876819,
-0.0706719682,
-0.0035403597,
-0.0234569144,
-0.0035367196,
-0.0022730641,
0.0048092003,
-0.0058593359,
0.0089117577,
-0.0619099215,
-0.0981224775,
0.0231693294,
-0.0672956407,
-0.0292153973,
-0.0120307803,
0.075772129,
0.0504730828,
0.019250825,
0.0017287005,
-0.0019465478,
0.0153638506,
-0.0199875049,
-0.0244595725,
0.0264122244,
-0.0125896512,
-0.0164368115,
-0.0113878511,
0.0037397705,
-0.0288560931,
-0.012297756,
-0.0184287094,
0.0596300289,
-0.0170819089,
-0.0157496836,
0.0100004012,
-0.024254689,
0.0416756645,
-0.1103130877,
0.0009721569,
0.0325778313,
-0.0900494605,
0.0088961776,
-0.0100694103,
0.0061998256,
0.028766552,
-0.0284694992,
-0.0016820084,
0.0257350616,
0.0151074259,
0.0422383361,
0.0755276754,
-0.015094867,
0.0129021499,
0.0173223782,
0.0043081604,
-0.0174666308,
-0.0587916262,
-0.0150471516,
-0.0599135756,
0.0026301434,
-0.0385535657,
-0.0188764799,
-0.0119533828,
0.0121613322,
-0.0474257693,
0.0350085348,
-0.011399311,
0.0282492656,
-0.003661199,
0.0173833128,
-0.0549660623,
-0.0101793204,
-0.0665121824,
0.0168650188,
0.020557873,
-0.0349859595,
0.0087608602,
0.0298884362,
-0.0140028689,
0.0274490342,
-0.0166367944,
0.0589080155,
-0.0219715163,
0.0145524014,
0.0316523425,
-0.0233322475,
0.0139810545,
-0.0794101581,
-0.0354819112,
-0.0350081027,
0.0741877705,
-0.0198363177,
-0.0620303228,
-0.0418087244,
0.0321472138,
0.0180157032,
0.0043870299,
0.0476404019,
0.0156344157,
0.0173411444,
0.0501780175,
0.0305368043,
-0.0609034486,
0.0251198411,
0.0747990161,
0.0116791753,
0.0450596772,
0.027618112,
0.0310523398,
0.0250154678,
-0.0119624687,
-0.0031065168,
0.0571820922,
0.0232124794,
-0.0054730675,
0.039053645,
-0.060078267,
0.0565382242,
-0.0669239238,
-0.0683944076,
0.0702485219,
0.0837135315,
-0.0328310467,
0.0442808419,
0.0043344302,
0.0571776815,
0.0334419534,
-0.0509116314,
-0.0279735513,
0.032837566,
-0.0030940815,
-0.0379236452,
0.0014942627,
0.0206864513,
-0.0377137624,
-0.0428170301,
0.0261086579,
-0.0064213471,
0.0724982694,
0.0284777768,
0.0122638065,
-0.0180338379,
-0.0333016776,
-0.024165066,
-0.0170369018,
-0.0126204593,
-0.0447061211,
-0.0226968881,
-0.0076688398,
0.0227505211,
0.046083767,
-0.0246973,
-0.0246669985,
-0.0334529206,
-0.02284142,
0.0589302108,
0.0720538646,
-0.0278403908,
0.0123063577,
-0.0546411462,
-0.0345709063,
0.0156275574,
-0.0214981511,
0.0282832328,
-0.0045546507,
-0.0004219946,
-0.0190972034,
0.0364736654,
0.056921795,
-0.0082263881,
0.0463994332,
0.0339031108,
0.018110903,
0.0191912241,
0.0511991642,
0.0316985399,
-0.0075833919,
-0.0141580105,
0.0246481318,
0.0163755734,
-0.0341483764,
0.0713118911,
-0.0061981622,
-0.0330413915,
0.0170478355,
-0.0264976881,
-0.0328999124,
-0.0110370852,
-0.0097979037,
-0.041307427,
0.0405259617,
-0.0062505966,
-0.0080629112,
-0.0358440131,
0.0115255788,
0.0164278131,
-0.0109262867,
-0.0022478104,
0.0095453318,
0.031195296,
-0.0558541529,
0.02294356,
-0.0257950313,
0.0397198424,
-0.0546812974,
0.0194871612,
0.0425343774,
0.0075705051,
-0.0060650436,
0.0165718943,
0.0169251617,
-0.0366232246,
-0.0360239185,
-0.0952105373,
-0.0147749893,
0.0075968988,
-0.013266555,
-0.0271990653,
-0.0197475031,
0.0145733617,
0.0028226785,
-0.0578603484,
0.0520209372,
0.065840818,
-0.0165810566,
0.0377898738,
0.0087262802,
-0.0439977013,
-0.0080952924,
0.0160860885,
-0.010301806,
0.0274023861,
-0.0149491755,
-0.0097969072,
-0.0215251651,
-0.0067069493,
-0.063186273,
0.0438961759,
-0.0115766609,
-0.0635867119,
0.0636908859,
0.0321516842,
-0.0082169045,
0.0515674651,
0.0525678061,
0.0731152073,
-0.0146025727,
-0.0420141034,
-0.0646525845,
0.0416845195,
-0.0097713647,
0.0367943086,
-0.0700074807,
-0.0270930491,
-0.0144941779,
0.0080021834,
0.0066319969,
0.0442956686,
-0.022496948,
0.0528664291,
0.0749612376,
-0.0520496964,
0.0153099224,
-0.0124807162,
-0.0245675929,
0.0861821026,
-0.0016804406,
0.0036006726,
0.0622359477,
-0.0066990908,
-0.0035268967,
0.008750814,
-0.0008134915,
-0.0465099402,
0.05295543,
-0.0475013256,
0.010181536,
0.0420637727,
-0.0213593282,
-0.0243971702,
-0.0449494682,
0.0482047051,
-0.0376056582,
0.005897067,
-0.0342382826,
-0.0216433574,
-0.0072401646,
-0.0291175004,
-0.0450181775,
-0.0187671706,
-0.0099892523,
0.0382918641,
0.0203471556,
0.002391242,
-0.0719237924,
0.0177159831,
0.0073158336,
-0.0017769701,
0.0772496238,
-0.0069533763,
-0.0193478614,
-0.0506078266,
0.0276005678,
0.0559156276,
0.0101416921,
0.0109270075,
0.0409204364,
0.042786099,
0.0051690117,
-0.0089968434,
0.0080178408,
-0.0207799505,
0.0163775161,
-0.0017813734,
0.0080878222,
-0.0181326885,
-0.0015868887,
-0.0200376119,
0.0285730157,
0.0438223109,
0.0360827856,
-0.0023334736,
0.0065069394,
-0.0440245084,
-0.000164394,
-0.0094023701,
0.0218451433,
-0.0986567885,
0.0025441593,
-0.0201824009,
0.0002085804,
-0.0609977767,
-0.0517447777,
0.0000920377,
-0.0644886419,
0.0276109912,
-0.0103366654,
-0.0128023662,
0.0273733996,
0.0328140147,
0.0056670634,
0.0008338461,
-0.0044175549,
-0.0271641649,
0.0716844946,
-0.0380888917,
-0.0328646675,
0.0045026382,
0.0212920532,
0.016115183,
-0.0320347138,
0.0490399748,
0.0323738307,
0.0475491621,
0.0500490032,
0.0104345679,
0.0014189642,
0.0579131022,
-0.0332793146,
-0.0013563427,
0.0007755702,
-0.0266250074,
0.0082180202,
-0.0240059551,
0.0299058761,
-0.0052174912,
-0.0431384295,
0.0579511747,
0.0268542673,
-0.0554520711,
0.0131561989,
0.0081996648,
0.0322506651,
0.036300499,
0.0369638428,
0.0049676015,
-0.036216367,
-0.0787449405,
-0.0251914822,
-0.0397825986,
-0.0172896683,
-0.0317430645,
0.0144608188,
0.0258411877,
0.0136515377,
-0.0188739821,
-0.1150345132,
0.0284779724,
0.0328213982,
-0.0024722151,
-0.0192886665,
0.0507362336,
0.0259448178,
0.0385070257,
-0.0068411445,
-0.0003843623,
-0.0077270963,
-0.0087135192,
-0.0173808243,
-0.0222792383,
-0.0453144088,
-0.0011265287,
0.0064835902,
-0.0121062612,
-0.0272639263,
-0.0409027487,
0.0565925129,
0.0281434096,
-0.001110114,
0.0039304188,
-0.0162982624,
-0.0517757833,
0.0011247237,
0.0198143143,
-0.0297804847,
0.039484676,
0.0512484834,
-0.0006555319,
0.0381818116,
-0.0156985167,
0.0297619849,
0.0090981452,
0.0250102095,
-0.0420225225,
-0.0733114406,
0.0177403428,
-0.0288899001,
-0.0544218384,
0.0303207133,
-0.0542834774,
-0.0120625235,
0.0350463912,
-0.0547752269,
-0.0197269898,
-0.0387490131,
-0.0246751662,
-0.0501267277,
-0.0200459529,
0.0428851992,
-0.0136116985,
-0.0441104732,
0.0260249879,
0.0373255648,
0.0403469689,
0.0028081224,
-0.0071281972,
-0.0066137654,
-0.0183302071,
0.0237669013,
0.0360973328,
-0.0068971827,
0.0188949555,
0.0233701132,
0.0873906463,
0.0315661207,
-0.0566664711,
0.0068921903,
0.0300949141,
-0.0455712825,
-0.0634429455,
0.0688084215,
0.0500541292,
0.0267671328,
0.0440706946,
0.0057322453,
-0.0411210172,
0.0205729436,
0.0104012573,
0.0396252126,
0.0140934391,
-0.0468487591,
0.0174606368,
0.026764676,
-0.0190043878,
0.0229111519,
-0.0086390665,
-0.0671232641,
-0.0053365161,
-0.0147940712,
-0.0378724076,
-0.058787439,
-0.0273025446,
-0.0391974673,
-0.0012988733,
-0.0150331315,
0.0087097669,
-0.0709963441,
0.0051976917,
-0.0036098105,
0.0203176551,
0.0049826079,
-0.0052787592,
0.0173023958,
0.0292175747,
0.0256061126,
-0.0160560645,
-0.0296360049,
0.012547235,
-0.0537541509,
-0.0297225639,
-0.0369737558,
-4.987550164e-33,
0.0004216957,
-0.0499346554,
0.0394460671,
0.0536032617,
-0.0374659821,
-0.0758107826,
-0.0270476565,
-0.0010186117,
-0.0165888425,
0.0380106233,
-0.0541132502,
0.0062488536,
0.0310282204,
-0.0364272259,
-0.0021473556,
-0.0030343796,
0.0217414554,
-0.0216221567,
-0.0459147878,
-0.0034201031,
0.0223614071,
-0.0417902246,
0.0092888772,
-0.0940997973,
-0.0050252639,
-0.0182785243,
-0.028032843,
0.0365612768,
-0.017072333,
0.0689877942,
-0.0036200411,
0.0042465115,
0.0034706905,
-0.0105365282,
0.0201743226,
0.037087705,
-0.0469339229,
0.0185191613,
0.0043427823,
-0.0132965669,
-0.0238989461,
-0.0102527384,
-0.0155186616,
0.0027582045,
-0.0166502874,
0.0115300221,
-0.0125754559,
-0.0112034585,
0.0005894912,
0.0178564955,
-0.0544800274,
0.0202103797,
-0.0607461557,
-0.0373599976,
-0.0047161244,
0.0481804833,
0.0064379531,
-0.0539320745,
-0.0457367375,
0.0373523124,
-0.0153109413,
-0.041929245,
0.0349406265,
-0.0358219072,
0.0193705596,
0.0401285216,
0.0566873252,
0.0686837509,
-0.0032312623,
-0.0729729831,
-0.0232401453,
0.0775177255,
0.0289152432,
0.0876122341,
-0.0621792041,
-0.0232437737,
-0.0360646881,
0.0029808201,
0.0778532401,
0.0535570942,
0.0096189007,
0.0071883374,
0.0240596905,
-0.0057666237,
-0.0391288437,
-0.0357822776,
-0.0196204782,
-0.0525519252,
0.0443530492,
0.044563666,
0.0313653573,
0.0053587826,
0.042664852,
-0.0345217772,
0.0180782415,
0.0206485186,
0.03274462,
0.0421373956,
-0.0147305019,
-0.0292448457,
-0.0273661166,
-0.0171976369,
0.0204113685,
-0.0202216674,
0.0443547629,
0.0071605407,
-0.0030453042,
-0.0170190223,
-0.0079346448,
0.0094076972,
0.0050151655,
0.0811859816,
-0.0551250838,
-0.0158342607,
0.0047824215,
0.0073598637,
-0.0154393828,
-0.0103819007,
-0.0097835865,
-0.0304968879,
-0.0609139875,
0.0047444445,
0.0236215964,
0.0123892231,
-0.0243565813,
0.0177174639,
-0.0043243705,
-0.0237466674,
0.0024467809,
0.0251331292,
-0.0096144062,
-0.027107697,
2.28e-7,
-0.0335954055,
0.0253226608,
0.0223644171,
0.0580819584,
0.023079427,
0.0669875145,
0.0052609262,
0.047788512,
0.0143954931,
-0.0225918889,
0.03423886,
0.0177886803,
0.0539886765,
0.0600562021,
-0.0539936386,
-0.0129310293,
0.0001813041,
-0.0874563977,
-0.0477873683,
0.007771221,
0.1064219102,
0.0116121909,
0.0106007801,
0.0261877514,
-0.0345561653,
0.018009318,
0.0316650644,
-0.059659604,
-0.0200870391,
0.0430944227,
0.0266895965,
-0.0963216871,
0.019272171,
0.0142305894,
0.0222251359,
0.028997032,
-0.0487271063,
0.0343355797,
-0.016717663,
-0.061548546,
0.0025956675,
-0.0045329854,
0.0106577128,
-0.0305354316,
0.0007973546,
-0.0445009209,
-0.0393355265,
-0.0016938808,
0.0042934804,
-0.0256441906,
0.0141650941,
0.00365389,
0.0130363591,
-0.0041140378,
0.008139451,
0.0078581087,
0.0668921843,
-0.0592987128,
0.0078095635,
0.0109935254,
-0.0257453639,
-0.01570509,
0.0248712078,
-0.0005308116,
0.0147973178,
-0.0014149438,
-0.0259556882,
1.190468128e-34,
0.0238456391,
-0.0110854544,
-0.0061073541,
0.0920787826,
0.0551125444,
0.0188361127,
0.0077985213,
0.0068983636,
0.0396200866,
-0.0556406826,
-0.0184292309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01093v1 | Specialized Language Models with Cheap Inference from Limited Domain Data | 2024-02-02T01:45:18 | 2024-02-02T01:45:18 | David Grangier, Angelos Katharopoulos, Pierre Ablin, Awni Hannun | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models have emerged as a versatile tool but are challenging to
apply to tasks lacking large inference budgets and large in-domain training
sets. This work formalizes these constraints and distinguishes four important
variables: the pretraining budget (for training before the target domain is
known), the specialization budget (for training after the target domain is
known), the inference budget, and the in-domain training set size. Across these
settings, we compare different approaches from the machine learning literature.
Limited by inference cost, we find better alternatives to the standard practice
of training very large vanilla transformer models. In particular, we show that
hyper-networks and mixture of experts have better perplexity for large
pretraining budgets, while small models trained on importance sampled datasets
are attractive for large specialization budgets. | [
0.0311551262,
0.0680647418,
0.0044500832,
0.024187034,
-0.0194940809,
0.0086687412,
0.0122571476,
-0.0076081413,
-0.0429445393,
-0.0188867114,
-0.0450566337,
-0.0241079517,
-0.0084973061,
-0.00496495,
0.0075599863,
-0.0532793999,
0.0015296446,
-0.0213460326,
-0.0242276601,
-0.0117519367,
-0.0135173295,
0.0312511884,
-0.0085012466,
0.0356137529,
-0.000026206,
0.0154729579,
-0.0222087018,
0.0144325811,
0.0002899787,
0.004294883,
-0.0053684935,
0.0615360104,
0.0446925834,
0.0288059525,
0.0000018459,
-0.0334963053,
-0.0483529903,
-0.0211710352,
-0.0320434533,
-0.0156031102,
0.0343140401,
-0.0634348914,
0.0203181766,
0.0168075468,
-0.021951111,
-0.0674657747,
0.0809777975,
0.0573439188,
0.0312111005,
0.0844595432,
-0.012424753,
-0.0272199828,
0.0148243504,
-0.073040545,
-0.0329544805,
-0.0657140836,
-0.0001834424,
-0.004283349,
-0.0294240378,
0.0039525279,
-0.0165481195,
0.0145563046,
0.0420433544,
0.0386080407,
-0.0294723753,
0.0248346161,
-0.0368280672,
-0.0120201632,
0.0021071497,
0.0544885695,
-0.0671390221,
-0.0188926589,
0.0024791874,
-0.007523004,
-0.0058387411,
0.0305279139,
-0.0072919447,
0.0400638357,
0.0107474402,
0.0091534508,
0.0149507504,
0.0144732846,
0.043382071,
0.0104554957,
-0.0793006569,
0.0162312053,
0.015804546,
0.0168270059,
-0.0143637164,
-0.0057928907,
-0.0840996876,
-0.0321584456,
-0.0328992158,
0.0208154526,
0.0146845197,
0.0052669523,
-0.0561432764,
-0.0538456179,
-0.0256536044,
0.0357765295,
0.0144987255,
0.0088431789,
0.0021694589,
0.0617356077,
-0.0004476957,
0.0113031343,
-0.0485193804,
0.0093320245,
-0.0260934941,
-0.0313566029,
-0.0269864909,
-0.0065589584,
-0.0758325085,
0.0209794212,
-0.016355399,
-0.0091101229,
-0.01287302,
-0.0080821533,
0.0021687562,
-0.0081469445,
0.0188937485,
-0.0014276574,
-0.0766641647,
-0.0569429211,
0.0373627692,
0.0575210154,
-0.0015442779,
0.050099954,
-0.0071453457,
-0.0395330749,
-0.0219835751,
0.0492859446,
0.0198172983,
-0.0218203943,
0.0276184753,
0.0967281461,
-0.0121927802,
-0.0538946092,
-0.0258481074,
0.0210395772,
-0.0022761922,
-0.0778991729,
0.0102255307,
-0.0814772025,
0.0223385505,
0.010555068,
0.0134697231,
-0.0411964431,
0.0062328279,
-0.0173168276,
-0.0162110925,
0.081697762,
-0.0020703119,
0.0247163307,
0.0065642851,
-0.0185100622,
-0.0265760813,
0.0763707384,
0.0113210417,
-0.0253721662,
0.0202195588,
-0.0203443188,
0.0249253064,
0.0430579744,
0.0104744509,
0.0126727596,
-0.0247273855,
-0.0170138516,
-0.0404366627,
-0.0111751435,
0.0182021037,
0.0369747803,
-0.036796242,
0.0039490662,
0.0495296903,
0.044685185,
-0.0014283689,
0.0094439443,
0.0500269681,
0.0272054933,
-0.0111623975,
-0.0141494693,
-0.0574480481,
-0.0119352192,
0.0048231725,
-0.0052616475,
-0.0139155043,
0.0216525737,
-0.0651282594,
-0.0358483829,
0.0261399802,
-0.0429714806,
0.0020164112,
0.0204109661,
0.1136653721,
0.0464915559,
-0.0193313099,
0.0963243842,
0.0344457515,
-0.0200797152,
0.0029862663,
-0.0400788784,
-0.0087562166,
0.0205278695,
0.0061329799,
-0.04549665,
-0.0091357958,
-0.0245019346,
0.0327641927,
0.007761505,
0.0183908157,
0.0114516774,
0.0408705696,
-0.0558927283,
0.0120067056,
-0.0050535919,
0.0607766584,
0.0192709193,
0.0247621834,
-0.0075042564,
0.0367510542,
-0.0741210878,
0.0071455431,
0.0072350083,
-0.0366721042,
0.0105412062,
0.0090312231,
0.0380938984,
0.0242201928,
0.000115651,
-0.0366430134,
0.0034289898,
0.005544289,
-0.0448965505,
-0.018279016,
-0.0075759017,
-0.0027201157,
-0.048470512,
0.0213874411,
-0.0738145784,
0.0056397775,
0.0525421761,
-0.0489825755,
-0.0346059315,
0.0175788216,
-0.0325667076,
0.0632667169,
-0.0426373519,
0.0212362912,
-0.0015757503,
0.0243178271,
-0.0507021621,
0.0457413308,
-0.0048273588,
0.0293769278,
-0.0088343052,
-0.0190709475,
0.0220618285,
-0.0309780817,
-0.0542330444,
-0.0090511525,
-0.0141018741,
0.0284226369,
-0.015617393,
-0.0013151224,
0.0199702401,
-0.0402387977,
-0.0637064502,
-0.0328755267,
-0.064883478,
-0.0062744278,
0.0102213128,
0.0409051739,
0.0078948103,
-0.0137227522,
-0.0134530459,
-0.0074143303,
0.0065934518,
0.003993846,
0.0061278967,
0.0070780208,
-0.0265008509,
-0.0132692773,
-0.0415492244,
0.010844456,
0.0815636367,
-0.0033825091,
0.0023595693,
-0.0433735214,
0.0140345283,
-0.0055282903,
0.0555698052,
-0.0251817591,
-0.0449560918,
-0.018879123,
-0.0421062373,
0.0241299979,
0.0441025272,
-0.0079364283,
-0.0154659143,
0.0114960968,
0.0327359997,
-0.0458873399,
-0.0008395372,
-0.05371603,
-0.0335562825,
-0.0396764986,
0.0052751857,
-0.0003305466,
0.0647343919,
-0.0238336977,
-0.0314458609,
-0.0370533317,
0.0281440951,
0.0083973212,
-0.0087768054,
0.0334867202,
0.0282592699,
0.0352133662,
0.0551054738,
-0.0182253681,
-0.037562456,
0.0749103129,
-0.0060773725,
0.0078748139,
-0.0593501814,
-0.0334963314,
-0.0531084724,
0.0457668118,
0.0079118498,
0.0179761797,
0.0325756967,
-0.0395831168,
-0.0596455708,
0.0080500226,
0.0105646681,
-0.001970456,
0.1019373685,
-0.0150105171,
0.0323060006,
-0.0152738858,
-0.0489269122,
-0.0375247933,
-0.0628104582,
-0.0453896858,
0.0018556922,
0.0202933904,
-0.0254478864,
-0.0495950803,
0.0470048375,
-0.0121518457,
0.0891453326,
0.0023348697,
0.0177783631,
-0.0222005304,
0.0423879735,
0.0216385573,
-0.0023774584,
0.00411567,
-0.0382909104,
0.0173249096,
0.0148548372,
0.0111241704,
-0.0031881616,
-0.0421699062,
-0.0054650404,
0.0257975627,
-0.0043439376,
-0.014946932,
0.0011346331,
0.0398839377,
-0.0235997289,
-0.0180749092,
0.1160195619,
-0.0002456206,
-0.0576505549,
0.008685071,
0.0335663706,
0.0194214396,
0.0172812846,
0.0265844632,
-0.0801796541,
-0.0173694752,
0.0147917205,
0.005047732,
0.0175090786,
-0.0154831456,
0.0045040557,
-0.1237997711,
0.0236419588,
-0.002137155,
-0.0423434712,
-0.045493532,
-0.0244332477,
0.0053931703,
-0.0261937864,
0.0018214715,
-0.0291482043,
0.0097555164,
-0.0414914526,
0.0205311254,
0.012317555,
-0.0783236623,
0.0122178523,
-0.044427909,
0.0065238178,
0.008973239,
-0.0173717961,
-0.0180320814,
-0.0249871369,
0.0367033891,
0.0255418848,
-0.0185235664,
0.0078062173,
0.0659371018,
0.0188961346,
-0.0412059613,
0.0380707309,
0.054611735,
-0.0389484093,
0.0095876763,
-0.0023557839,
0.0523771904,
-0.0369224101,
-0.0036692307,
0.0211437475,
-0.023528859,
0.0166518763,
0.056464117,
0.0072324187,
-0.0632525906,
0.0166648217,
-0.0001831594,
-0.0005172545,
-0.0316628292,
-0.0047504893,
0.0204093941,
0.0278577507,
-0.0876871496,
-0.0367779173,
0.0060724011,
0.0210045651,
0.0573341995,
0.0114247426,
-0.0186422616,
0.0386568233,
0.0308966022,
-0.0645852908,
0.0704038218,
-0.0460149758,
0.0059964573,
-0.0591985807,
0.0026202877,
0.067030564,
-0.0159769747,
-0.0269115027,
-0.0172441173,
-0.0610338748,
-0.0578065105,
-0.0310735591,
0.0406470746,
0.0294514541,
0.0406246856,
-0.024029078,
-0.0433010273,
-0.0105426013,
0.0246485677,
-0.0455673672,
-0.0110017853,
0.0659784153,
-0.0385055318,
-0.0043831267,
0.0579022877,
-0.023371581,
0.0670973063,
0.0542863607,
-0.0037358066,
-0.0257166959,
-0.012514038,
0.0170480125,
-0.0301526468,
0.063620232,
0.0016933571,
0.0412445739,
-0.0194906965,
0.0163161326,
-0.0056764358,
-0.0250653345,
-0.0615944415,
-0.0184476692,
0.0482553132,
0.0379495546,
-0.0170770809,
-0.0173358247,
0.0107958056,
0.0500538349,
-0.0016317886,
0.0152645372,
-0.0094037745,
-0.0268591475,
0.0499471873,
-0.0062665222,
-0.0212605335,
-0.0128264949,
0.0204063021,
0.0008381919,
-0.0091421409,
0.0277439393,
0.0179817602,
-0.0064288406,
-0.0770489201,
-0.0007344135,
-0.0525215752,
-0.0612231866,
-0.0063622319,
0.0004692163,
0.0640029684,
-0.0427677631,
0.0072496831,
-0.003492089,
-0.0053696888,
-0.032308057,
0.0348194279,
0.0171928313,
-0.0101452461,
0.0178701263,
0.034053199,
-0.0146406004,
0.0500896759,
0.1039423421,
0.0287126843,
0.0400210842,
0.0137417559,
0.0109581407,
-0.045315288,
-0.0032064239,
0.0048492514,
0.0400910564,
-0.0191016737,
0.0319552235,
-0.03036277,
-0.0957635045,
0.0125625981,
-0.0347663686,
-0.0201327316,
0.0065194545,
0.0314786769,
0.0498037264,
-0.0456739292,
-0.0112696169,
-0.0334896222,
0.0171280373,
0.0469591059,
-0.0141411731,
-0.0283042584,
-6.148501813e-33,
0.0300832242,
0.0084445151,
-0.013671156,
-0.017624883,
0.0141766053,
0.0101241982,
-0.0207564756,
0.0237959884,
-0.0355004407,
0.0111922408,
-0.0188830923,
0.016365001,
0.0121316239,
0.0574254431,
-0.0164078139,
0.0020795215,
0.057086248,
0.0160348937,
-0.0098876674,
0.0020981724,
0.0040309527,
0.018469261,
0.0834413767,
-0.0777383223,
-0.053237129,
-0.0046292781,
-0.0127413617,
0.0525715128,
0.0183699485,
0.0245442931,
0.0208880138,
0.0341634192,
0.0257509667,
-0.0930782333,
-0.0058120177,
0.0053300089,
-0.0740179718,
-0.0031417382,
-0.0039925664,
0.0053987242,
0.0187058728,
-0.0244388264,
0.0608436763,
0.0022865892,
0.0236582849,
-0.0174136143,
0.0237823781,
-0.0203898903,
0.0007401673,
-0.0111703873,
-0.0315767601,
0.0472865738,
0.0062562744,
-0.0165944938,
0.0118622696,
0.0423796028,
-0.0149609363,
0.0116443867,
-0.0207389574,
0.0159694236,
0.0403148383,
0.0318664648,
0.0320657939,
0.0424271822,
-0.011114602,
0.0232300386,
0.0284849275,
0.0171915572,
0.0094530638,
0.0144725144,
0.0524360053,
0.0630119666,
0.0309077278,
0.026854191,
0.0218449086,
-0.0010590247,
-0.0796160623,
-0.0355104282,
-0.0192106273,
0.016192669,
0.0443358608,
-0.0072184191,
-0.0448563658,
-0.019664159,
-0.0449792556,
-0.0029866651,
-0.0195201281,
-0.0077149398,
-0.0072977371,
0.0512553267,
-0.0332547501,
0.0140969101,
0.042672269,
-0.0718989447,
-0.0269996691,
0.0281639155,
0.0174930114,
0.0353786908,
-0.0258058086,
0.0079759378,
-0.0282215159,
-0.0352965854,
-0.0090480782,
0.0092325639,
-0.0088273101,
-0.0218544565,
0.0556018315,
0.006903254,
-0.0735001639,
-0.0325379968,
-0.0055154809,
0.017690286,
0.0018365033,
0.1119985804,
0.0447250269,
0.025184691,
-0.0207799505,
0.0184400566,
0.0088499272,
-0.0435482264,
0.0040433076,
0.0521602295,
0.0270712264,
0.0264793169,
-0.0190025941,
-0.0266360436,
-0.0417133942,
-0.0395026356,
0.035356164,
-0.0604713261,
-0.018301608,
0.0109611293,
2.6e-7,
0.0318769552,
0.0069779619,
0.0099682529,
-0.012983242,
0.0318530537,
0.0134098753,
0.0249742512,
-0.0146987131,
-0.0185146928,
-0.0105855959,
0.0317969024,
0.0384984761,
0.0419256017,
0.0005273949,
-0.1146412417,
-0.0362123586,
0.0002837369,
0.017477978,
-0.0190480575,
-0.0148016689,
0.0102584362,
0.1665715575,
0.0316053145,
-0.0055342549,
0.0001876518,
-0.0427894704,
0.0458563305,
-0.013717101,
0.0193052907,
0.0532008484,
0.0167577676,
0.071911931,
-0.0026285653,
0.0394444428,
0.0079886178,
0.0501618125,
0.0393030494,
0.0787679851,
-0.0103484103,
-0.0114741502,
0.0113502787,
-0.0007684162,
-0.0323071741,
-0.0342268459,
0.0592869073,
-0.1359159499,
-0.0259815771,
-0.0223662369,
-0.025178425,
-0.0036230895,
-0.0122068692,
0.0010858561,
-0.0021608854,
0.0395017527,
0.0381464958,
-0.0148683973,
0.0101495329,
-0.0683672726,
0.0068823411,
0.0207792725,
-0.0755773261,
-0.0215797555,
0.0031666176,
-0.0348058119,
0.0549951531,
-0.0190746468,
0.040121153,
2.425169053e-34,
0.0610244125,
-0.0217285417,
-0.0118205287,
0.0161138736,
0.004363847,
-0.0267084949,
-0.0260888748,
-0.0166577026,
0.0139080491,
-0.1035872176,
0.0075218724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01091v1 | Reading Between the Tweets: Deciphering Ideological Stances of Interconnected Mixed-Ideology Communities | 2024-02-02T01:39:00 | 2024-02-02T01:39:00 | Zihao He, Ashwin Rao, Siyi Guo, Negar Mokhberian, Kristina Lerman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | Recent advances in NLP have improved our ability to understand the nuanced
worldviews of online communities. Existing research focused on probing
ideological stances treats liberals and conservatives as separate groups.
However, this fails to account for the nuanced views of the organically formed
online communities and the connections between them. In this paper, we study
discussions of the 2020 U.S. election on Twitter to identify complex
interacting communities. Capitalizing on this interconnectedness, we introduce
a novel approach that harnesses message passing when finetuning language models
(LMs) to probe the nuanced ideologies of these communities. By comparing the
responses generated by LMs and real-world survey results, our method shows
higher alignment than existing baselines, highlighting the potential of using
LMs in revealing complex ideologies within and across interconnected
mixed-ideology communities. | [
0.0272499211,
0.0502380915,
-0.0080501884,
0.0533032343,
-0.0472297892,
0.0089585464,
-0.036645107,
-0.0087474901,
0.0068073194,
-0.0422234572,
0.0235186294,
-0.0174020957,
-0.0083269496,
-0.0023341966,
-0.0103198998,
-0.0571155958,
0.0325362608,
0.0302261859,
0.0441427156,
-0.0413766652,
0.0634705573,
0.0407793969,
0.0096511496,
0.0274269879,
-0.0028823579,
-0.0283083804,
0.0076614758,
0.0205509458,
0.0588494726,
0.033134643,
0.0439519025,
0.0336643495,
-0.0288265664,
0.0618715063,
0.000001738,
-0.0024811877,
-0.0422227457,
-0.0431699231,
0.0443662144,
0.0000269104,
0.1022434756,
-0.0037702359,
0.0213127509,
0.0182825234,
-0.0456998162,
0.0391368754,
0.0490483269,
0.03995803,
0.0604273304,
0.0421242937,
-0.0123727974,
-0.0337070227,
-0.0163203012,
-0.0097420178,
-0.0468035378,
-0.0365092419,
0.0636424869,
-0.0355073176,
-0.055525627,
0.0380486064,
-0.0154537102,
0.0448012576,
-0.0063105174,
0.0061373264,
-0.0268970635,
-0.0054839696,
0.0100137899,
-0.0108923521,
0.0206826013,
0.0639907718,
0.0008866102,
-0.0119400388,
0.0578966662,
-0.0291704461,
-0.0468147658,
0.0471688174,
-0.0677024946,
-0.0239131432,
-0.0324295722,
0.0443896726,
0.0496185012,
-0.0009653161,
0.0239761826,
0.0490363687,
-0.0523395501,
0.0921018571,
-0.0149279963,
0.0051610307,
-0.0268511269,
0.0288671665,
-0.0091633722,
0.0059949281,
0.0259797107,
-0.0255187638,
0.0296747964,
0.0132886153,
-0.0394050963,
0.0211022105,
0.0074209813,
-0.0364316925,
-0.0048901616,
-0.0165342521,
0.0098400088,
0.0653228387,
0.0340105183,
-0.0607346967,
-0.0300588142,
0.0044152136,
0.0195674207,
-0.0277604666,
-0.0333064422,
-0.0165677927,
0.0067150095,
0.0121499933,
-0.0170100015,
-0.0063008834,
-0.0076180501,
-0.0139691103,
-0.0583896711,
-0.0280155949,
-0.0380367562,
-0.0197343323,
0.0314685591,
-0.0317726806,
-0.0181931946,
0.0660719872,
-0.0640770197,
0.0209479611,
-0.0309916046,
-0.0300901234,
0.0190088134,
0.0409177169,
0.017907992,
-0.043010015,
-0.0286977738,
0.0085203405,
0.0169442333,
-0.004014696,
0.0213394705,
-0.0366732441,
-0.0189845972,
-0.0257811863,
0.0230254345,
-0.0804748684,
0.0676853508,
0.0158904027,
0.0149232093,
-0.0537391007,
0.0018538788,
0.0420077704,
-0.0785055682,
0.0448252074,
0.0242934581,
0.0305435359,
0.022221949,
0.0127986586,
0.0471751615,
0.0947448909,
-0.0054214834,
0.0176743641,
0.0437875018,
0.0060515408,
-0.0167756416,
0.0416538157,
-0.0000889187,
0.0165939927,
-0.0274006817,
0.0082292892,
-0.0323448479,
-0.0258886274,
-0.0034368585,
0.0843227133,
0.0130250715,
-0.0284892078,
0.0352401286,
0.0537009053,
-0.0097191911,
-0.0166814867,
0.0288290549,
0.0391606502,
-0.0067919637,
0.0326494277,
0.0134105021,
-0.0069904211,
-0.0107571725,
-0.0508416928,
0.0730394945,
0.0444417968,
-0.0177093334,
-0.0107320659,
-0.0037988853,
0.0055788914,
0.0365133137,
-0.0366355106,
0.0228773486,
-0.0514696352,
-0.0085344901,
0.0237569548,
0.0497763604,
-0.0074500134,
0.0019178115,
-0.0374247767,
-0.0175422579,
0.0430246368,
0.0008747629,
0.0004130247,
0.0012775782,
-0.0194268953,
0.0888360217,
0.0477947071,
0.0541648604,
-0.0219459794,
-0.0464679524,
-0.0183723029,
0.0301316269,
0.0357352272,
0.0051699225,
0.0366287529,
0.0204796605,
0.004868682,
-0.0166743137,
0.0266709588,
0.0199057106,
0.0100433994,
0.0111311674,
0.0302209873,
0.0005060809,
0.0126463352,
0.0094511295,
0.0353496,
-0.0123076774,
-0.0273878332,
0.0181063283,
-0.0166013893,
-0.0530685149,
-0.0000067689,
-0.0416997783,
0.0230606534,
0.0196673963,
-0.0421500131,
-0.0264130179,
0.0268912949,
-0.0050554541,
0.0061512985,
0.0779756904,
0.0054347883,
-0.0114379646,
-0.001519167,
-0.014762463,
-0.0461617112,
-0.0153414337,
-0.0554401502,
0.0567562096,
-0.0190040786,
0.0272210613,
-0.0067074113,
-0.0863184929,
0.0135308905,
0.0225716159,
-0.0140571333,
0.0139508741,
0.0018457508,
0.0089523932,
0.0386239439,
-0.0469925217,
-0.020757122,
-0.0587593392,
-0.0293406919,
-0.0157850571,
-0.0167834926,
0.0213565566,
0.0363476798,
-0.0117495665,
0.0192691721,
0.0579115786,
-0.0063589457,
-0.0069205649,
-0.0090771923,
0.0129422331,
0.0330704674,
0.0003666411,
-0.0043941117,
-0.0402990766,
-0.0258714277,
-0.0406621881,
0.0340224728,
0.0033659586,
-0.077070199,
0.0032406359,
-0.040126048,
-0.0450013541,
-0.0181501973,
-0.0524633676,
-0.0343517289,
0.0200009458,
-0.0216213744,
0.0480525941,
0.0368758328,
0.0403935686,
0.0530217886,
-0.0012343775,
0.002561888,
-0.0340357237,
-0.0251490567,
-0.0490801595,
0.0155614736,
-0.0416200496,
-0.0334544256,
0.0018537357,
0.1082172692,
0.0112815835,
-0.0074352776,
-0.063223362,
0.0562098883,
-0.0599962659,
-0.0102835223,
0.0219106358,
-0.0016328826,
0.0067696678,
0.0063522202,
-0.0086068213,
-0.0031783199,
0.0251685921,
0.0131423967,
0.0482394882,
-0.0001429299,
-0.0462019555,
-0.0128168771,
0.0111074746,
0.0003017811,
0.0053021745,
0.0126372501,
-0.0045010094,
-0.0158076137,
-0.0265655555,
0.0460753776,
-0.0441966988,
0.0450523905,
-0.0186187904,
0.0413292088,
0.015730286,
0.0106308041,
-0.0006189604,
-0.0799624398,
-0.0467280261,
-0.0095847277,
0.0535220578,
-0.0246837754,
0.0043051536,
0.0428387821,
0.0126926918,
-0.0778614432,
-0.0064813634,
0.0091220876,
0.0030966259,
0.0405905209,
0.0166664459,
-0.031977836,
0.0381482765,
-0.0129511086,
-0.014462118,
0.0564155616,
0.0158963259,
0.0343582407,
-0.0061588902,
-0.0757210255,
0.0081315329,
-0.0200832561,
-0.0076987059,
-0.037838757,
0.0804727226,
-0.0111685228,
0.0236656908,
0.077633135,
0.0538664013,
-0.0113746831,
-0.0153826075,
0.016967874,
0.0105053997,
0.0084865959,
-0.0031073284,
-0.0947353616,
0.0088606942,
0.0118852714,
0.0129285734,
-0.0410134457,
-0.0614565425,
-0.0008470644,
-0.0716396794,
-0.0275468659,
0.011605639,
0.0189560298,
-0.0355277918,
-0.0472451113,
0.051555831,
0.002073962,
-0.0521601997,
-0.0277601369,
0.0066365968,
0.0223587193,
0.0009128906,
-0.0769698173,
-0.0489117429,
0.0185668673,
-0.0162011515,
0.0382858627,
-0.0084035173,
0.048873309,
0.0172360949,
0.0088504627,
0.071625568,
-0.0765776038,
-0.0248218365,
-0.0465431772,
0.0351804905,
-0.0297879186,
-0.0103013003,
-0.0043103285,
0.0338454135,
-0.0053091752,
-0.0065772645,
-0.0353267267,
0.0461128466,
-0.0059214756,
-0.0597452931,
-0.003116736,
0.0600562021,
0.0458624065,
0.0449146517,
0.0414106771,
-0.0245878659,
0.0049305111,
-0.0606392361,
0.0278599896,
-0.0173272677,
-0.0665506646,
-0.0498713739,
0.0051346207,
-0.0051766224,
-0.0450982116,
-0.058560662,
0.0217214227,
-0.0013271563,
-0.022999648,
-0.0075495397,
0.0445420779,
-0.0284434836,
-0.0205664095,
0.017313512,
-0.0473010056,
0.0453601666,
0.0036435151,
-0.0400145128,
-0.0015903981,
0.0277408995,
-0.045140598,
0.0192086101,
-0.0861674696,
-0.0852855146,
0.036549449,
-0.0166814309,
0.0231262576,
-0.0014320405,
-0.0568604544,
-0.0370516069,
-0.0176580697,
0.0669508204,
-0.0341218486,
-0.0040416182,
0.0369252041,
0.0546051785,
0.0371696725,
0.0495632216,
0.0101169311,
0.0064490121,
0.0212501623,
-0.0248452574,
-0.0908293724,
-0.0624707416,
-0.014756294,
-0.0050072568,
0.0471664257,
0.0584608689,
-0.0793817788,
-0.0441255085,
-0.0534102581,
-0.0486554429,
-0.045200076,
0.0002356209,
-0.0220470522,
0.0267192908,
0.0058980454,
-0.0714090466,
0.0361140519,
-0.0132785393,
0.0492194742,
-0.0524171367,
0.0334365964,
-0.0287524611,
0.0190633517,
0.0188580099,
-0.0029078657,
0.0089429179,
0.0181936249,
-0.0283577852,
0.0278740264,
-0.0051612323,
0.0259705242,
0.011936863,
-0.0149044562,
0.0270690024,
-0.0197294913,
-0.0471236445,
-0.0681613237,
-0.0047462555,
0.0437816232,
-0.007483596,
0.0088292845,
0.0557801984,
0.0222052243,
-0.0261774641,
-0.027619807,
0.0399337038,
0.0078200577,
-0.0273381025,
0.013313558,
0.0231812615,
-0.042327825,
0.0056447946,
0.0571636185,
-0.0504653379,
0.016981734,
0.0616366826,
-0.0002852946,
-0.0152821559,
-0.0117123099,
-0.0097571826,
0.0220211875,
0.0020689024,
0.0134381317,
-0.0396535508,
-0.0459558703,
0.0685417652,
-0.0331791937,
0.0075206049,
0.0220975652,
-0.0187705122,
0.0716715753,
0.0127392877,
0.0588818826,
-0.0657296926,
0.0157107823,
-0.0353805944,
-0.0427032225,
-0.0015707713,
-6.709952445e-33,
0.0004660066,
-0.0350155756,
-0.0229486171,
-0.0089191115,
-0.0272269771,
-0.0099513941,
-0.0165592451,
0.053052552,
-0.0241720639,
0.0222670473,
0.0153952669,
0.0476213656,
0.0169103034,
0.0299165417,
-0.0099733286,
-0.019881025,
-0.0110570891,
0.0074121794,
0.0154504087,
0.0306752548,
0.0208521727,
0.0049052825,
0.0151776765,
-0.0846979171,
0.0444413237,
-0.0117997285,
0.0074296496,
0.0098944856,
0.0256947968,
-0.0054508597,
-0.0394869484,
0.0131775523,
0.0526118428,
-0.0162795391,
0.0190868378,
0.0796160027,
-0.0273846779,
-0.0268416107,
0.0210988615,
-0.0199817307,
0.0016754837,
-0.0270831585,
0.0358758569,
0.0022474574,
0.0051051648,
-0.0106269615,
0.0496908054,
0.010081796,
0.0404086038,
-0.0333807096,
-0.0453197286,
0.0558565035,
-0.0339373462,
-0.0008062012,
-0.0144294575,
0.0185230337,
0.0632001609,
0.0888655633,
-0.0461433306,
0.0229691882,
-0.0566240288,
0.0115775736,
-0.0022567892,
-0.0388960354,
-0.0058584409,
0.0640913472,
-0.0346872397,
0.038348645,
-0.0418728068,
0.0103828516,
0.0302168131,
-0.0172897819,
0.0570956245,
0.0613885522,
-0.0218594726,
-0.0496936068,
-0.0472468287,
-0.0152180437,
0.0569905713,
-0.0189747419,
0.0405338481,
-0.012331279,
-0.0132844606,
-0.0155721027,
-0.0163461007,
-0.0760186389,
-0.0295582041,
-0.0114331124,
-0.0460682362,
-0.0030909334,
-0.0605517849,
0.0197653696,
0.0365879051,
-0.0341226459,
-0.0619518012,
0.0326099582,
-0.0211794786,
0.0203299671,
0.0021182392,
0.0584034286,
-0.0471872427,
-0.0130551243,
-0.0169155207,
-0.0070429151,
0.0202635955,
-0.0397567116,
0.0165560171,
-0.0003901909,
-0.0816664249,
-0.0266498812,
-0.0191655364,
-0.0022581143,
-0.0401136316,
0.016364608,
0.0541947372,
0.0598839261,
0.0161211789,
0.0302271619,
0.044888664,
0.0061083618,
0.0210726857,
-0.0048203329,
-0.0701173916,
0.002436314,
-0.0313827433,
-0.0448544621,
-0.0349500589,
0.0276958589,
0.0040742382,
-0.0428885296,
-0.0172739774,
-0.0177385639,
2.519e-7,
0.0721696541,
0.0764874369,
-0.0054062996,
0.0227102153,
0.0022512893,
0.0093431184,
0.0533202402,
0.0003953,
-0.0445797071,
-0.0675586686,
-0.0345575698,
0.0650793687,
0.0430326276,
0.0034747715,
-0.0457052439,
0.0194344725,
-0.0158826858,
0.0157414712,
-0.0288798902,
-0.0011906663,
0.0065233824,
0.0356189869,
0.0476499163,
0.0383703262,
-0.0246669576,
-0.0132808695,
0.0655878037,
-0.0393159389,
-0.0425193943,
0.0349632017,
0.0142570632,
-0.0793550834,
0.0188036673,
0.0334888659,
0.0245071817,
-0.0034181585,
0.0110206269,
0.0586227179,
0.0329653285,
-0.0139460685,
-0.0136508718,
-0.0228959117,
0.0016068403,
-0.0403860584,
0.0737866834,
-0.0989233032,
-0.0308466014,
-0.0830567107,
-0.0265895259,
-0.0040894044,
0.0208171308,
0.0018693055,
-0.0418366231,
0.0339367092,
-0.0149967633,
0.0027450989,
-0.0076277251,
-0.0748787299,
0.0214406122,
-0.0080812238,
-0.0525324941,
-0.0387657061,
0.0025472683,
-0.016622236,
0.0568995923,
0.016543692,
0.0204704236,
1.859235448e-34,
0.0372104794,
-0.0175963547,
-0.026381338,
-0.0098899882,
0.0524273217,
0.0101688253,
-0.0495293662,
0.0184705686,
0.0093231462,
-0.0596558601,
0.000502653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01065v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01065v1 | Evaluation Methodology for Large Language Models for Multilingual Document Question and Answer | 2024-02-01T23:46:05 | 2024-02-01T23:46:05 | Adar Kahana, Jaya Susan Mathew, Said Bleik, Jeremy Reynolds, Oren Elisha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the widespread adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs), in this paper
we investigate the multilingual capability of these models. Our preliminary
results show that, translating the native language context, question and answer
into a high resource language produced the best results. | [
0.0494857505,
0.0018480574,
-0.0039560152,
0.0650831461,
-0.0469229519,
0.0264483616,
0.0355422199,
0.0006605113,
-0.001037155,
-0.0584950075,
-0.0591947995,
-0.0472965613,
-0.0362977833,
-0.0113794971,
0.0147299608,
-0.0333665982,
0.008347284,
-0.0606536679,
-0.0032178157,
-0.0225877389,
0.0258316342,
0.0320938565,
0.0329475589,
0.003341014,
0.0079011861,
-0.0278478097,
0.0244542789,
0.006217354,
-0.0005837486,
-0.0364860408,
-0.0091242306,
0.0277203303,
-0.001086109,
0.0270338077,
0.0000015601,
-0.0511039831,
-0.0028231291,
0.0333289206,
-0.0090024443,
0.003911606,
0.0330819637,
0.0062560826,
0.0164213255,
0.0271610636,
-0.029846821,
0.0074626752,
0.0132905301,
0.0318339095,
0.0741782486,
0.0349812657,
-0.0100804055,
-0.058090806,
0.0317339748,
-0.0008045883,
0.023665376,
-0.0595858395,
0.0010601348,
0.0752419978,
0.0520150922,
0.0134828975,
0.0236726049,
0.0393037349,
0.0341619179,
-0.0474514365,
-0.0391276367,
-0.0257349126,
-0.008385702,
0.0110764606,
0.0111858202,
0.0631533489,
0.0151157938,
0.0126429014,
-0.0396529473,
0.0231606271,
0.0100078853,
0.0370544456,
-0.0656237379,
0.007091641,
0.0009514781,
-0.0204199143,
0.0625097156,
0.0073118,
0.0155376457,
0.012926803,
-0.0238730665,
0.0653088465,
0.0341565683,
-0.0112858973,
-0.0051771593,
0.0040808339,
0.0169154536,
-0.0529455654,
0.0154466229,
0.0602755733,
-0.0351694562,
0.0191334151,
0.001323721,
-0.0379370637,
0.0539806746,
-0.0920733288,
0.0046112859,
-0.0007240907,
-0.0070553934,
0.1008951664,
-0.0316121913,
0.049494151,
-0.0398785174,
-0.0198303014,
-0.0779484287,
-0.0727017447,
-0.034595076,
-0.006235078,
-0.0200243499,
0.0417594202,
-0.0477204658,
-0.0064152568,
-0.0148237832,
0.0391102247,
0.0440678112,
0.0092538903,
0.0214681868,
-0.0344561189,
-0.0104405517,
-0.04587752,
-0.0244609378,
0.0547828265,
-0.0382234044,
-0.0067272978,
-0.0151648177,
-0.0688308179,
0.0626200363,
0.0354365632,
-0.0038615756,
-0.0450485162,
-0.0016170833,
0.0742903277,
0.0104155792,
0.0225934368,
-0.0195156895,
-0.0069634304,
0.0238601919,
-0.0404704139,
-0.0224440563,
-0.1027987078,
0.0213201437,
0.0230650418,
0.018144438,
0.0251721889,
0.0235762913,
0.0213140603,
-0.0140006151,
0.0125481244,
0.0122438828,
0.0252602473,
0.0851860866,
-0.0114397975,
0.0356517695,
0.0819811597,
-0.014528445,
-0.0114478497,
0.064016819,
-0.0003911154,
-0.0054121311,
0.0576936491,
-0.0202946775,
0.0283309035,
-0.000784645,
0.094355084,
0.0167751946,
0.0011841845,
-0.0271469317,
0.0567559898,
-0.0104135908,
0.0032728205,
0.0243380163,
0.0463634543,
0.0115067512,
0.0099052284,
0.0394019373,
-0.0125075104,
0.0092848605,
-0.0103928177,
0.0164146535,
0.0334295109,
-0.020405069,
-0.0188354496,
0.0245512016,
0.0401382074,
-0.0493644439,
-0.0160083808,
-0.0308299977,
-0.018218182,
-0.0234826822,
0.0135342637,
0.0352909267,
-0.0051741353,
0.0105835479,
0.0427771062,
-0.0104408171,
-0.0127501944,
0.0213855673,
-0.0434162207,
0.0186444782,
0.0231669992,
0.0369986072,
-0.0248511862,
-0.0326992944,
-0.0198954102,
0.0054737357,
0.0311482232,
0.0706561655,
-0.0204954576,
-0.0148283374,
-0.0239085313,
-0.0024562967,
-0.0110905236,
-0.021897614,
0.0271125492,
-0.007010282,
0.0385068841,
0.008910534,
-0.0571637563,
-0.0495270118,
-0.0074764467,
-0.0308221523,
-0.0115662962,
0.012071671,
0.004059942,
0.0002800983,
0.0491922945,
-0.0020501669,
0.0234899484,
0.0144061642,
-0.0629132688,
-0.0107228495,
-0.0007566186,
-0.0427020863,
-0.0289663803,
0.0421093926,
-0.0340981744,
-0.010135795,
-0.0000099018,
-0.0035547293,
-0.0577021837,
-0.0418881401,
-0.0308202785,
0.0125438077,
-0.0539226755,
-0.006616022,
-0.008994204,
-0.0080542471,
-0.0644963086,
0.0390575267,
0.0017120773,
0.0624554567,
0.0272030197,
-0.0002793179,
0.053294383,
-0.030635206,
-0.0415540785,
0.0804129094,
-0.001301494,
0.008438603,
0.0318132415,
0.0335216671,
-0.0378110707,
-0.041106794,
-0.0696685761,
-0.0167239886,
-0.0295339581,
0.0375956483,
0.0355521142,
0.0211565029,
0.0138961216,
-0.0235202555,
-0.1019836441,
-0.0264207032,
0.0602262244,
0.0362122208,
0.0151278358,
0.0197677761,
0.0397869088,
-0.0271739177,
-0.018526081,
0.0419589728,
0.0587484911,
0.0199296903,
-0.0035607291,
-0.0488346666,
0.0049661403,
-0.0469429754,
-0.0242955666,
0.026781179,
-0.0356588922,
-0.0245980732,
-0.0395513289,
0.0426695347,
0.0222682897,
-0.0188254882,
-0.0089455303,
0.0106182517,
0.0104465885,
-0.0317299478,
-0.0055703591,
0.0187555291,
-0.0437742844,
-0.0502687246,
-0.0402130187,
0.0122906435,
0.0231747851,
-0.0107084895,
-0.0081271734,
-0.0209003855,
-0.0029292314,
-0.0638106987,
-0.0121778827,
-0.0768750608,
-0.0010662067,
0.0063023795,
0.0538643003,
0.0059385565,
0.0007852731,
0.055426728,
-0.0334762856,
-0.0109633952,
-0.0764783993,
-0.0165572502,
-0.0670158416,
0.0453302898,
-0.03500342,
0.0508175977,
-0.0790699869,
-0.0257568415,
-0.0238482002,
-0.0044257557,
0.0231976584,
-0.0307884626,
0.0262389276,
-0.0213709101,
-0.001623816,
-0.0365587994,
-0.0240992196,
-0.0136723053,
-0.0268393829,
-0.0122900978,
0.0194770694,
-0.0051168017,
0.0047077066,
-0.0124560399,
0.0378985107,
0.055784937,
0.0017401548,
-0.0378717743,
0.000664031,
0.0202315524,
0.1174942777,
0.0437612422,
0.0340064093,
0.0084988577,
-0.0246557873,
0.0614192635,
0.033275865,
0.026261434,
-0.0133819403,
0.0183469169,
-0.0260021333,
0.0484388359,
-0.0224053431,
-0.0480886251,
-0.0221108552,
0.0490233563,
-0.0588466935,
-0.0034194877,
0.0984610468,
0.0560915247,
-0.0545073822,
-0.0439212285,
-0.102548711,
-0.0147450296,
0.0301985443,
0.0738477856,
-0.0673378631,
0.0164233409,
-0.0299558826,
-0.0303075742,
0.0253661629,
0.0123841399,
0.0237749387,
-0.0971464217,
0.0114968875,
-0.0299036223,
-0.0635951012,
-0.0138892764,
-0.0293075051,
-0.0286938846,
0.019247409,
0.0046527479,
0.0151470387,
0.0074681961,
-0.0095728152,
0.0008165202,
-0.0134569407,
-0.0142663028,
0.030606227,
-0.0234908573,
-0.0028331636,
0.0759057254,
0.0438310578,
-0.0352269225,
-0.0138146589,
0.0282991994,
-0.0525729619,
0.0036771491,
0.0038084709,
-0.0195270944,
0.0205699988,
-0.0043709748,
-0.01838273,
-0.0085095512,
-0.0241832845,
0.0366002508,
0.0512803197,
0.0896545202,
-0.0198808108,
0.020562483,
-0.0150639964,
-0.0187646113,
0.0077414415,
0.0611867271,
0.0072224331,
-0.0405634157,
-0.0199697409,
-0.0327834114,
-0.0438843705,
-0.0251258481,
0.0016335995,
0.0252816901,
0.0021051108,
0.0206081718,
-0.0817748755,
-0.0498199537,
0.0060064155,
0.0065704561,
0.0023920634,
0.0335572958,
-0.0264104512,
-0.014847693,
0.033236105,
-0.0072486186,
-0.0377218947,
0.0479432307,
-0.0675467029,
0.0178140774,
0.0753269941,
-0.0081963493,
-0.004634514,
-0.0193425547,
-0.0302040279,
-0.0431376025,
-0.045332931,
0.0274590515,
0.0174817163,
-0.0149496738,
-0.058146555,
-0.0560375005,
0.0169724282,
-0.0342528,
-0.0368623659,
-0.0067754807,
0.0099636531,
0.0450492278,
-0.0194711946,
0.05273569,
-0.0685640648,
0.0187791456,
-0.0003776786,
0.0397118367,
-0.0154524036,
-0.0697840378,
0.0033312228,
0.0715378597,
-0.0564680547,
0.0215123314,
-0.0021116426,
-0.01163017,
0.0424088538,
-0.0544853099,
-0.0248073153,
-0.0248918999,
0.0300448462,
0.0495377555,
-0.0385024138,
0.0144780148,
0.0230526421,
0.0067303646,
0.0017238882,
-0.0154669508,
0.0473792665,
0.0449228175,
0.0017824956,
0.0008318486,
0.0314456709,
-0.0472647324,
-0.0180631075,
-0.010430675,
0.0196906794,
-0.0166596398,
0.0809755102,
-0.0161517784,
-0.0354852788,
0.0253447872,
0.017680984,
-0.0391208716,
-0.0745712966,
0.0008571195,
0.0100616086,
0.0675579086,
0.0169982035,
0.0465878509,
0.0061044069,
-0.0307206586,
-0.0255151223,
0.029503841,
0.0527080558,
-0.0460337102,
0.0723536313,
0.0180300791,
-0.0077794748,
0.0085309679,
0.0667664707,
-0.010609081,
-0.0261502899,
0.0164653175,
-0.0017343373,
-0.0434987731,
0.0025980934,
0.0045279763,
-0.0014267128,
-0.027808791,
0.0295010693,
-0.0269095246,
-0.0535454042,
-0.0088608135,
0.0200785752,
-0.0156162344,
0.0050408365,
0.0214133691,
0.0925712213,
0.0406935737,
0.0158577133,
-0.0829312727,
0.0393137373,
-0.0565444157,
-0.0055781333,
0.0091037275,
-5.567314998e-33,
-0.015582432,
-0.0193026476,
0.023290405,
-0.0310565121,
0.0101910057,
0.0003750043,
-0.019018488,
-0.0018026909,
-0.0364273228,
0.0044871909,
-0.0328695513,
-0.0046933712,
0.0082583511,
0.022976853,
-0.0107087158,
-0.020797234,
0.0012454048,
-0.000907905,
0.0084969932,
0.0356020592,
0.0138540678,
0.0091650002,
0.0625665113,
-0.0458116904,
0.0554876588,
-0.0502688363,
0.0096088126,
0.0325725898,
0.0043889536,
0.0863468051,
-0.0208263751,
0.0182294566,
0.0527365394,
-0.0579808578,
-0.0051799277,
0.003236915,
-0.0312398653,
-0.0217502378,
0.0427370369,
0.0106818294,
-0.041264195,
-0.033638414,
-0.009423702,
-0.0082137808,
0.033845067,
0.011952254,
0.0327501446,
-0.0383755676,
-0.0093114544,
-0.0116398698,
-0.0587606132,
0.028600784,
0.0238879919,
0.0432348922,
-0.0101814084,
0.0671883523,
-0.0399442092,
0.0069295559,
-0.0237273127,
0.0010287135,
0.0067661847,
0.0298807509,
0.0494155809,
-0.0035065152,
-0.0153806498,
0.0034987319,
-0.0319694132,
0.0179937631,
0.0260945205,
0.0059356964,
-0.0284265485,
0.0209698305,
0.0754719526,
0.0807021484,
-0.0345546193,
0.0278135203,
-0.0745967999,
0.0619733445,
0.0112764873,
0.0381800383,
0.0190789327,
-0.0057169492,
0.0184385031,
0.0078678988,
-0.060761556,
0.0304557402,
-0.0528900065,
-0.0376785956,
0.0239241272,
-0.0406093672,
-0.0013753825,
0.003439548,
0.0822196081,
-0.0304029062,
-0.0311912112,
0.0496384315,
0.0068153213,
0.0246082321,
0.0055209151,
0.0727562383,
-0.036912065,
0.0141669037,
-0.0377356485,
-0.0298437588,
-0.0224843882,
0.0014804148,
0.0050483928,
-0.0224219672,
-0.0635079667,
0.0025012121,
-0.0235957317,
-0.0080662621,
-0.0249841809,
0.0417886451,
-0.0122142574,
-0.0338894166,
0.0003013934,
0.0828406215,
0.0018792081,
-0.0228448622,
-0.0374138914,
-0.0451555699,
0.0195114277,
0.0104501136,
-0.0513494425,
0.0319300406,
-0.0356210209,
0.0329268612,
0.0153833646,
-0.0162035115,
-0.0049498528,
0.0063374466,
2.247e-7,
0.0644853115,
0.0067247115,
-0.0222029798,
0.0187003482,
0.0422209129,
-0.0021719027,
-0.0157620963,
0.0235774759,
0.0388109349,
0.0319512412,
-0.0200297982,
0.0052408185,
0.053268332,
0.0507654585,
-0.0874197483,
-0.0154802622,
-0.0636145622,
-0.0001484841,
-0.0336719267,
0.0059806891,
0.0216545854,
0.0794349015,
-0.0401791222,
0.0067928163,
-0.0605656728,
-0.0665814951,
0.0503025874,
-0.0291416198,
-0.0493676029,
0.0327462032,
0.0379451141,
0.0214336552,
0.0245017037,
-0.0090974327,
-0.0073038084,
-0.0003496121,
0.0622897223,
0.0539359935,
0.0035612888,
-0.0227716342,
0.0202598404,
-0.0339177139,
0.003623222,
-0.0858132094,
0.0715584457,
0.0042894795,
-0.0322010554,
-0.015994614,
-0.0046873498,
-0.0329791345,
0.0421087146,
-0.0584904999,
-0.0263936967,
0.0248045251,
0.0211359207,
-0.0259826891,
0.0020665398,
-0.0154095292,
-0.0278189071,
0.0133543266,
-0.0137910824,
-0.0620968081,
-0.0175297204,
-0.0209052451,
-0.0275844373,
-0.0201132763,
0.0231815502,
1.456514757e-34,
0.0359169245,
-0.004095057,
0.0180598665,
0.0400874764,
0.0238388386,
-0.0181362964,
-0.0173402112,
0.009846366,
-0.0008890315,
-0.1134813428,
0.001672497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01053v1 | Plan-Grounded Large Language Models for Dual Goal Conversational Settings | 2024-02-01T22:56:39 | 2024-02-01T22:56:39 | Diogo Glória-Silva, Rafael Ferreira, Diogo Tavares, David Semedo, João Magalhães | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Training Large Language Models (LLMs) to follow user instructions has been
shown to supply the LLM with ample capacity to converse fluently while being
aligned with humans. Yet, it is not completely clear how an LLM can lead a
plan-grounded conversation in mixed-initiative settings where instructions flow
in both directions of the conversation, i.e. both the LLM and the user provide
instructions to one another. In this paper, we tackle a dual goal
mixed-initiative conversational setting where the LLM not only grounds the
conversation on an arbitrary plan but also seeks to satisfy both a procedural
plan and user instructions. The LLM is then responsible for guiding the user
through the plan and, at the same time, adapting to new circumstances,
answering questions, and activating safety guardrails when needed. We propose a
novel LLM that grounds the dialogue on a procedural plan, can take the dialogue
initiative, and enforces guardrails on the system's behavior, while also
improving the LLM's responses to unexpected user behavior. Experiments in
controlled settings and with real users show that the best-performing model,
which we call PlanLLM, achieves a 2.1x improvement over a strong baseline.
Moreover, experiments also show good generalization to unseen domains. | [
0.0551729351,
0.0331221484,
-0.0187419765,
0.03303032,
-0.008079973,
0.0084108347,
-0.008004643,
-0.0310915131,
0.004799495,
-0.0316726342,
-0.021270562,
-0.0385831445,
-0.0426787026,
0.0483022928,
0.0161951762,
-0.0422321968,
0.0363179855,
-0.0708286986,
0.0167211704,
-0.0067276084,
0.009083204,
0.0057392106,
-0.0117546981,
0.0612849779,
0.0025890162,
-0.0014159821,
-0.0418826118,
0.0156809445,
0.0001042397,
-0.0417774022,
0.025051754,
0.0206775628,
0.0664085224,
0.0243226942,
0.0000020467,
-0.0593031049,
0.0140498383,
-0.0439293161,
-0.0170361176,
-0.0440026261,
-0.0378769301,
-0.0186367184,
-0.0132486327,
0.0291854478,
-0.0514228232,
0.0188937597,
0.0089843087,
0.102280423,
0.0649917051,
0.0791352019,
-0.0009001725,
-0.0535914749,
0.0079900734,
-0.0191127118,
-0.0259294752,
-0.0800786167,
0.0057494631,
0.0301889535,
-0.0070327916,
0.0284503624,
0.0132366447,
0.0018494313,
0.0144671788,
-0.0464792885,
-0.0244529676,
0.0367242508,
-0.0402626321,
-0.034024857,
-0.02294649,
0.1068523228,
-0.0046498831,
0.0045094225,
0.0354841352,
-0.0040600784,
-0.0054917838,
-0.020902697,
-0.0469951406,
0.0124668507,
0.0078691812,
0.0075828684,
-0.0094294325,
0.0130568212,
0.0235737916,
0.016396042,
-0.0487227216,
0.0769014508,
-0.0226907376,
-0.037994612,
0.0201485287,
0.0034206896,
0.0078812828,
-0.0686775818,
0.0105118118,
0.06493067,
-0.0946189389,
0.0438474491,
-0.0205994025,
0.0138801299,
0.0048346622,
-0.0282741375,
0.0207006447,
0.0393129513,
0.0130898161,
0.0535706617,
0.0127912881,
0.0494123287,
-0.0048311166,
0.0163968299,
-0.0083174976,
0.0192506872,
-0.0369088426,
0.0084902449,
-0.0553800538,
0.027051283,
-0.0579111278,
-0.0340538993,
-0.0018580875,
0.0756410286,
-0.0174377672,
0.052572649,
0.0145839863,
-0.0130984727,
-0.0427492186,
-0.0477763824,
-0.0498771146,
0.0140637662,
-0.0385752842,
0.0407206938,
0.0210309159,
-0.0307987314,
-0.0028926088,
0.0176443942,
0.0000052519,
0.0062696491,
-0.0294412058,
0.0705935955,
-0.0063730166,
-0.0064413454,
-0.0345992073,
-0.0404907241,
-0.0142165059,
-0.0729085654,
-0.0053377254,
-0.0206913836,
0.0290480573,
0.0010303094,
-0.009085441,
-0.0092531936,
0.0295069665,
0.016354315,
-0.0090444749,
0.042815078,
0.0185445752,
0.0213865787,
0.010628053,
0.022595739,
-0.0289381593,
0.0922281817,
0.0310424082,
0.0129439756,
-0.0026315639,
-0.0041718381,
0.0091059506,
0.039910648,
0.0025103886,
0.0156983584,
0.0197946001,
0.0303455126,
0.0386642516,
0.0377302989,
0.0220526382,
0.0616915077,
-0.0215451401,
0.0261712037,
0.0706641451,
0.0630270988,
-0.0352555588,
0.0133663686,
0.0427860767,
0.0218348391,
-0.0273001771,
0.0190083347,
-0.0693433955,
0.0121312113,
-0.0232364703,
0.0015453729,
0.0022752574,
-0.0006643567,
-0.0429002754,
-0.0247865263,
0.0266071577,
-0.0132053671,
0.025112804,
-0.0005784802,
0.0273375474,
0.007875965,
-0.0889544934,
-0.0052028075,
-0.0038119392,
-0.0079792039,
-0.0114184534,
-0.0162354913,
0.0231769271,
0.0922539011,
0.0228500608,
-0.0195370968,
-0.0342938863,
-0.0371006764,
0.0439715721,
0.0421120599,
0.024583606,
-0.0232814904,
0.0096787373,
-0.0609674565,
-0.0185211021,
-0.0194939505,
-0.020835612,
0.0085983714,
0.0107014775,
-0.0051658624,
-0.0111655137,
0.0248493962,
-0.0205618571,
0.008975856,
-0.0364886895,
0.0065718321,
-0.0060581579,
-0.0059893169,
0.0404915437,
0.0063236775,
0.0095461532,
-0.0107285865,
0.0427063219,
-0.0240565911,
-0.0237050261,
0.0123862503,
-0.0815720111,
-0.0205147527,
0.0251484122,
0.0080210157,
-0.0327861793,
-0.0186704919,
-0.0258154366,
-0.0500477627,
-0.0151138483,
-0.009999007,
0.0333063118,
-0.0358993672,
0.034975715,
0.0404431932,
-0.035501577,
-0.0467080027,
0.0322803669,
0.0069501535,
-0.0243726783,
0.0383032747,
-0.0239787865,
-0.0186960455,
-0.0684563592,
0.0045702998,
0.0374842137,
-0.0074217091,
-0.0019468649,
0.0206565186,
0.0322496071,
-0.0529678464,
-0.0573512092,
-0.1148409843,
-0.0135874832,
-0.0424668677,
-0.0120026777,
-0.001202291,
0.0188888051,
-0.0016022022,
-0.0296082199,
-0.0354408957,
0.0216223784,
0.0404582806,
-0.0181213897,
0.028441608,
0.0456848964,
-0.0303857271,
-0.0402051099,
0.049766507,
-0.0067452337,
-0.0113643976,
0.0044976845,
-0.0319422372,
-0.0737753958,
0.0723096505,
-0.0030133119,
0.0496305078,
-0.0300985482,
-0.0202047005,
0.0041460381,
0.0032766107,
0.056820076,
0.069675602,
0.0065519186,
0.030921964,
0.0268084574,
-0.025286207,
-0.0831123888,
0.0524539165,
-0.0102889845,
-0.021966856,
-0.0747511908,
0.0179576892,
0.0300921034,
0.0492992066,
-0.0078683598,
0.0468701944,
-0.0552088507,
0.0127683431,
0.0120110605,
-0.0559916049,
-0.0156707168,
-0.0229934193,
-0.0414206274,
0.0429940559,
-0.0092404354,
-0.0206532907,
0.0601499937,
-0.0093632303,
-0.0271787196,
-0.0131537747,
-0.0221813787,
-0.0216570385,
0.0266580377,
-0.0138280895,
0.0206670035,
0.0126787825,
-0.0317519419,
-0.0287921205,
-0.0113702016,
-0.0167096239,
-0.0236740001,
0.0743637383,
-0.0862979889,
0.020126462,
0.0082411831,
-0.0653274804,
-0.0683245808,
-0.0370185003,
-0.0539826825,
-0.0011505893,
-0.0024278632,
-0.016199423,
-0.0266669933,
-0.0017604323,
0.0265001524,
0.0456190519,
0.0031441876,
-0.0053759916,
-0.0315997005,
-0.0393261909,
0.063902393,
0.042760253,
-0.0250061583,
-0.0200722981,
0.0863449648,
0.0139111802,
0.0368203931,
-0.0119932592,
-0.0242157299,
-0.0215906277,
0.0277805571,
0.0198475178,
-0.0211611949,
0.0456917509,
0.0892196298,
-0.015224155,
-0.0268974751,
0.1251457036,
0.0079182414,
-0.0297481231,
-0.0015840763,
-0.0519915037,
0.0476551987,
0.012076431,
0.0355179943,
-0.048827488,
-0.0278829001,
0.0058797374,
-0.0129729547,
0.002285829,
-0.0279828403,
-0.0140324188,
-0.1123363525,
0.0110912649,
0.0056842356,
-0.028520355,
0.0116665335,
-0.002683168,
0.0095362458,
0.0189442951,
0.0587539747,
-0.0189541541,
-0.001287932,
-0.0254805367,
0.0031909363,
-0.0162381008,
-0.0350820906,
0.0098742945,
-0.026707815,
0.0818547085,
0.101012744,
0.0364822522,
0.0175492801,
0.0118464632,
0.0570313931,
0.0394989513,
0.0200258531,
-0.0066899341,
-0.0136391986,
-0.029344853,
0.0007383046,
-0.0031736144,
0.0637629181,
-0.0352204479,
-0.0192144178,
0.0526561514,
0.0604050159,
-0.0566566847,
0.0089602564,
0.0057697976,
0.0363751277,
0.0459399112,
0.0595686771,
0.0156894121,
-0.06243461,
-0.018581979,
-0.0227214601,
-0.0176203828,
-0.0616346374,
-0.0320647992,
-0.0117517849,
-0.0073783379,
0.053435903,
-0.0487452149,
-0.0601530075,
0.0453347303,
0.0413031168,
0.0363164283,
-0.0207653791,
0.0408588648,
0.0028430773,
0.0456814766,
-0.0006726354,
-0.0408983901,
0.0420530736,
-0.0893581957,
0.0005282566,
0.0225291792,
-0.0174217224,
0.0069942996,
0.0370071456,
-0.0326887891,
-0.0655081049,
-0.0282693077,
0.0635837689,
0.0183185153,
0.0507497899,
-0.0037824018,
-0.0627744198,
-0.0028135001,
-0.0222614594,
-0.0352800488,
0.0127213662,
0.0237812214,
0.0698554069,
-0.0122142565,
0.0554369949,
-0.0514178649,
-0.0079090204,
0.0011488702,
0.0517887548,
-0.0715041086,
-0.0628717691,
0.0176738873,
-0.0055947416,
0.0316930376,
0.0016940151,
-0.0038359861,
0.0023860892,
0.0378888659,
-0.0211379938,
-0.0258229822,
-0.0587514117,
0.0223606639,
0.0105414446,
-0.0325048529,
0.0353221707,
-0.0253141094,
-0.0205642693,
0.0183295272,
0.0009059412,
-0.0291625913,
-0.0082447659,
0.0063102753,
0.0295731425,
0.0208096169,
-0.0184081737,
0.0476138964,
0.0511176027,
0.0354709364,
0.0287926961,
0.1027894616,
0.0306414608,
-0.0110301469,
-0.0105916336,
0.0088831102,
-0.0440129451,
-0.0704030618,
0.0408120342,
0.0357723087,
0.0416778028,
0.0301278885,
0.0423209369,
-0.0382759646,
0.0256228689,
-0.0391789302,
0.0253999587,
0.0165193379,
-0.0457576551,
0.0580724478,
0.015590352,
-0.0268530697,
0.0110853575,
0.0653088242,
0.0055818204,
0.0340940692,
-0.0302922782,
0.0410946645,
-0.052000165,
-0.025708735,
0.0050019585,
0.0482472405,
-0.0139820576,
0.0061195577,
-0.0426819846,
-0.0209334213,
-0.0323784947,
0.0062847063,
-0.0336816832,
-0.0461234674,
0.0333986171,
0.0305934157,
-0.018419126,
-0.0349631459,
-0.0173667129,
-0.0254452452,
0.0043684365,
-0.0243328363,
-0.0744669065,
-5.767508298e-33,
-0.0452075303,
-0.0309451856,
0.0506397113,
-0.0032740748,
-0.0286836978,
-0.0220926832,
-0.0316980854,
0.012290122,
-0.0220385063,
0.0161877107,
-0.027531201,
0.0215872657,
0.0169581622,
0.0110053122,
-0.0106541794,
-0.0202024113,
0.0479212888,
0.0040486353,
-0.0247304402,
0.0384581387,
0.038907811,
0.0163575355,
-0.0161764845,
-0.0940017924,
0.0137041779,
-0.0012665138,
-0.0171822272,
0.0581495129,
-0.0010736398,
0.045260597,
-0.0167695396,
0.0055363011,
0.0075224214,
-0.0219378825,
-0.0333556235,
0.0724420249,
-0.019108152,
-0.0144929327,
0.0587304309,
0.0000107077,
-0.0290280562,
-0.0548497587,
0.0083669117,
-0.0311608128,
-0.0196003765,
0.0083782235,
0.0138988886,
0.0042909607,
-0.0183492322,
0.0184241049,
-0.0721944794,
-0.0079615172,
-0.0228048433,
-0.0503312834,
-0.0073306556,
0.025826076,
0.0032556797,
-0.0299374815,
0.0012966353,
0.0423528813,
-0.0484126918,
-0.0159877911,
0.053044226,
0.018618932,
-0.0033736054,
0.071058467,
-0.0004806748,
0.0343034044,
-0.0263095926,
-0.0619988218,
-0.0173237845,
0.0423587151,
-0.0255023483,
0.0094393641,
-0.0610668436,
0.0247082841,
-0.0493763909,
0.0151780657,
0.0180520862,
0.0516148917,
0.0214625318,
0.0338402987,
-0.0301135816,
-0.0168638807,
-0.0327375643,
0.0268691946,
-0.0046269028,
-0.0260001756,
0.0513681322,
0.0326028168,
0.0299579035,
-0.0154597806,
0.0498686172,
-0.0409487337,
-0.0204595793,
0.0347065404,
-0.0094748456,
-0.001166669,
-0.0118610384,
0.034811575,
-0.0709383339,
-0.0361584611,
0.03623138,
0.0054212683,
0.0154425902,
0.0267034471,
0.0057924022,
0.0109491115,
-0.0469429791,
-0.0072288536,
-0.0411524028,
0.0207449012,
-0.0245288219,
0.0037995081,
0.0311683193,
-0.0074221799,
-0.0228204448,
0.0795802772,
0.000165937,
-0.0758721456,
-0.0282181241,
-0.0713963658,
-0.0016418865,
0.0232988279,
-0.0401835479,
-0.0003673407,
-0.0052505727,
-0.0072876937,
0.0183097925,
-0.0291690044,
-0.011138536,
0.0073991008,
2.733e-7,
-0.0235927328,
0.0442311838,
0.0065827379,
0.0254180413,
0.0074565336,
0.0492286868,
-0.031686645,
0.0396540724,
0.0067954673,
-0.0190053172,
0.0153776994,
0.0392296277,
0.0158417057,
-0.0088857813,
-0.0940041468,
-0.0118857436,
-0.0456506722,
-0.0223246682,
-0.0638975501,
-0.0172172599,
0.0605208389,
0.0511274412,
-0.0233685914,
0.0164143853,
0.0185220428,
-0.0391403586,
0.0646115392,
-0.0463986434,
-0.0285052452,
0.0100370878,
-0.0057477229,
0.0057164803,
-0.0093479445,
0.0177489929,
0.0051324186,
0.0459171869,
-0.0275438987,
0.1089503095,
-0.0044396846,
-0.0073112571,
-0.0048277248,
-0.0164603591,
0.0020770552,
-0.0293066688,
0.0350677893,
-0.0657558516,
-0.0208053086,
0.0259824079,
0.0242350958,
-0.0501638539,
-0.0292283799,
-0.0037044499,
-0.0135289077,
0.0059521524,
0.0245427247,
0.0046265931,
0.0063305446,
-0.0700745136,
0.0360101089,
-0.0011761347,
-0.0401859432,
-0.0615291931,
-0.0285743941,
0.0319790468,
-0.0005563734,
-0.0363152772,
0.0071264869,
2.360509058e-34,
0.0122991549,
-0.0019290854,
0.017475618,
0.0402913019,
0.0378131755,
0.005724384,
-0.0040533929,
0.0270324256,
0.0581659861,
-0.0925803483,
-0.0069885869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01051v1 | Generation, Distillation and Evaluation of Motivational Interviewing-Style Reflections with a Foundational Language Model | 2024-02-01T22:54:31 | 2024-02-01T22:54:31 | Andrew Brown, Jiading Zhu, Mohamed Abdelwahab, Alec Dong, Cindy Wang, Jonathan Rose | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Foundational Language Models are capable of performing many tasks at a
high level but are difficult to deploy in many applications because of their
size and proprietary ownership. Many will be motivated to distill specific
capabilities of foundational models into smaller models that can be owned and
controlled. In the development of a therapeutic chatbot, we wish to distill a
capability known as reflective listening, in which a therapist produces
reflections of client speech. These reflections either restate what a client
has said, or connect what was said to a relevant observation, idea or guess
that encourages and guides the client to continue contemplation. In this paper,
we present a method for distilling the generation of reflections from a
Foundational Language Model (GPT-4) into smaller models. We first show that
GPT-4, using zero-shot prompting, can generate reflections at near 100% success
rate, superior to all previous methods. Using reflections generated by GPT-4,
we fine-tune different sizes of the GPT-2 family. The GPT-2-small model
achieves 83% success on a hold-out test set and the GPT-2 XL achieves 90%
success. We also show that GPT-4 can help in the labor-intensive task of
evaluating the quality of the distilled models, using it as a zero-shot
classifier. Using triple-human review as a guide, the classifier achieves a
Cohen-Kappa of 0.66, a substantial inter-rater reliability figure. | [
0.1002195477,
0.0361247249,
-0.0246075112,
-0.0298449583,
-0.0641693771,
-0.0107831815,
0.0187935531,
-0.014001729,
-0.0109659201,
-0.0314320177,
-0.0210455004,
-0.0077205957,
0.0055990247,
0.0550892465,
-0.0303535108,
-0.0927999243,
0.0250275768,
0.0002273613,
0.0375213809,
-0.0014039094,
0.0180841573,
0.0303183068,
-0.0352297612,
0.0815206319,
0.0042824321,
-0.0243585054,
-0.018353248,
0.0141836097,
-0.0153904958,
-0.0537322164,
-0.0283457581,
0.0469370745,
0.0073857242,
0.0025770795,
0.0000024265,
-0.0039021571,
0.0036149009,
-0.0051033674,
0.0027398798,
-0.0622045025,
0.0982244536,
-0.0098082721,
-0.0224230085,
0.0258833878,
-0.0224066637,
-0.0005346482,
0.0132385083,
0.0544789135,
0.0914622694,
0.0524855405,
-0.008757337,
0.0141378725,
-0.014936869,
0.017674638,
0.0102385907,
0.0050095231,
-0.028368976,
0.0222742278,
0.0392151996,
0.0250653662,
-0.0243143719,
0.0015386619,
0.0064785965,
-0.0035553302,
0.0100669954,
0.034206558,
-0.0311849862,
-0.0549697913,
-0.0337329246,
0.0549738519,
0.0624975413,
0.0012277198,
-0.0110507337,
0.0037671451,
0.0408162773,
-0.033449769,
-0.0349853113,
0.0112942597,
0.0121750413,
0.0107123516,
-0.0224943366,
0.0150196627,
-0.0323681831,
-0.0200349893,
0.0550211556,
-0.0176580921,
0.0054117967,
-0.0122139817,
0.0159248486,
0.0158858076,
0.0503848568,
-0.0669168532,
-0.0278426744,
0.0378237553,
-0.0417140536,
0.01583918,
-0.0446798876,
0.0047397763,
-0.0048936186,
0.0291916616,
0.034480691,
0.043376565,
-0.0403002314,
-0.0082381628,
0.0086984318,
0.030903561,
0.0591974594,
0.0128735341,
-0.0398432836,
0.0085712709,
-0.0724645555,
-0.0047497358,
-0.0423448533,
0.0258480087,
0.0016863084,
-0.0515135787,
-0.0647912174,
0.022022156,
-0.0154763814,
0.0019691586,
-0.0323783457,
-0.0040889224,
-0.0123027368,
0.0294392221,
-0.0108652981,
0.0245076977,
-0.0169609301,
0.0055766366,
0.0527384654,
-0.1182408929,
0.0288013462,
-0.0065621953,
-0.0098108025,
0.0227050018,
0.0132197943,
0.0444203131,
0.0019690529,
-0.0549733862,
0.0322216153,
-0.0043446398,
-0.0434632674,
-0.0587859415,
0.0075187134,
-0.0391875692,
-0.0087787351,
-0.001777802,
0.0000880049,
-0.0309539959,
0.0358715802,
0.0034103929,
-0.0269835163,
0.0730467066,
-0.0196139906,
0.0258813482,
0.0027876336,
0.0284097064,
-0.0284951124,
0.0393967144,
0.010702813,
0.0115114916,
-0.0047880933,
-0.0596830957,
0.0373556204,
-0.0401628315,
-0.0083332043,
-0.0323179178,
-0.0159738045,
-0.0209440459,
-0.031788554,
0.0508047342,
-0.0422454737,
0.0427443013,
-0.0253920704,
0.0465773456,
0.0699274242,
0.0572031364,
0.0037800679,
0.0611016192,
0.0250788163,
0.0417317115,
0.0055821976,
-0.0181952175,
-0.0360470302,
0.0281738769,
-0.0019381127,
-0.02265279,
-0.0086423,
-0.016984567,
-0.0308359619,
-0.0418937169,
0.0054658037,
-0.0113561638,
0.0018204597,
0.0233742204,
0.0133277941,
-0.0018260129,
-0.0344581343,
-0.0162552632,
0.026459381,
-0.0663818344,
-0.0428787768,
-0.076445736,
0.0222722683,
0.1043867469,
0.0537861511,
0.0154024167,
-0.0107521378,
-0.0145938108,
-0.0034004385,
0.0490503386,
0.0380376838,
0.0250582155,
-0.015417235,
-0.0151985204,
-0.003662887,
-0.0069380109,
0.0067466055,
0.0113525614,
-0.0515737198,
0.0274067298,
-0.023021955,
0.0411108285,
-0.0191879198,
0.0391186103,
0.0216293484,
-0.0054691541,
0.0087189041,
-0.0302986614,
0.0249179322,
0.0462353043,
-0.0131805707,
0.0217242632,
0.0349997543,
0.001436557,
-0.0237425212,
0.0715272129,
-0.0294909999,
-0.0436967649,
0.0094936686,
-0.0429049432,
0.0159064606,
0.0422522724,
0.0282279383,
-0.0353391282,
0.0381805003,
-0.0708026215,
0.08133623,
-0.0217118897,
0.0282918587,
-0.0252620615,
0.0135525633,
-0.0048060501,
0.0008476744,
0.0139034949,
0.016423367,
0.0035170463,
-0.0653727055,
-0.0221269093,
-0.0609247498,
-0.0162065011,
-0.0026832214,
-0.0256191194,
0.00985354,
-0.003719769,
0.0223543718,
-0.0605162904,
-0.047006648,
-0.106121026,
-0.0286296736,
-0.0006973461,
-0.041906707,
0.0079504354,
-0.0286709704,
-0.0062164445,
-0.0230854172,
-0.0617204569,
0.0161813702,
0.036117658,
0.0244927593,
-0.0110628,
0.007536286,
-0.0372732878,
-0.021360565,
0.0160380229,
-0.0023026967,
0.0121690789,
0.0103331422,
0.0437503457,
-0.0638618544,
0.047107514,
-0.0201461297,
-0.0200527348,
-0.0026916345,
-0.061911609,
0.0679660812,
0.0050914343,
0.0261276029,
0.0307155065,
0.0316305533,
0.0333110057,
0.02106997,
0.003691548,
-0.0560133457,
-0.0124501605,
0.0104369959,
-0.0227075126,
0.0079381615,
-0.0697974339,
0.0013372354,
0.0207073241,
0.0419463739,
0.0377255753,
-0.0790587291,
0.0230105035,
0.0017950694,
-0.0253373273,
0.0019514769,
-0.0184704419,
-0.0195759386,
0.016321471,
0.0092635183,
-0.0294037424,
0.0596684143,
-0.0164737161,
-0.017779531,
-0.0320998356,
-0.021662809,
0.0050930837,
0.0343833007,
-0.0424201228,
0.0100948876,
0.0405715853,
-0.0013543027,
0.006158663,
-0.0389995091,
0.0000259635,
-0.0521323718,
-0.0053947149,
-0.0387782939,
0.0054366868,
0.0201380774,
-0.0126851946,
-0.0702149868,
-0.0627873987,
-0.0451387651,
0.00422552,
-0.0169852655,
0.0315882862,
-0.0177753083,
0.0050059832,
0.0320765935,
0.0523194149,
0.0124230944,
-0.026121581,
-0.0008946937,
-0.0544884652,
0.0433792025,
-0.0112702455,
0.041360233,
0.0044754343,
0.1071883217,
0.0280057974,
0.0638685375,
0.0511735231,
-0.0262491722,
-0.0259153508,
-0.0103146713,
0.0234502815,
0.0088450406,
0.0246435925,
0.0608002171,
-0.0131606702,
-0.0421151109,
0.1093927994,
0.0049536768,
-0.0867598206,
0.0127939237,
-0.0580474138,
-0.0127152046,
0.0195416566,
-0.0007757923,
-0.0637521744,
-0.0324099101,
0.0198866501,
0.0480516739,
-0.0419265404,
-0.0166438576,
-0.0080549894,
-0.0875189602,
0.0404469594,
-0.0097210519,
-0.0127932671,
-0.0056833574,
-0.0020038499,
-0.0032021436,
0.006440171,
-0.0064247195,
-0.0106063774,
-0.0153950024,
0.0148113482,
-0.0105401743,
-0.0427849405,
-0.030297434,
0.0743621588,
0.0107250642,
0.0998408869,
0.0578917675,
0.0566119775,
0.026122259,
0.0078128465,
-0.001988204,
0.0171624329,
0.031244291,
0.0242535342,
0.0335991941,
-0.0062866309,
0.0074208523,
-0.0389943793,
0.0603627935,
-0.0507078618,
0.0034945949,
0.0375111252,
0.0418954566,
-0.0633948669,
0.0047440631,
-0.0141272731,
0.061037045,
0.0321714245,
0.072656624,
0.06076058,
-0.0566144176,
0.0025826863,
0.0199802052,
0.0352439657,
0.0055582253,
-0.0863218904,
0.0077664913,
-0.0073122052,
0.0469355769,
-0.0925378278,
-0.0683175102,
0.0205519348,
0.0049843392,
-0.0150747392,
-0.0178104043,
-0.0450296625,
0.0443300791,
0.0102668041,
0.0249355175,
-0.0053207367,
0.0127141643,
-0.0617822446,
-0.0164132547,
0.0426513404,
-0.0718296394,
0.0048330827,
-0.0048462097,
-0.0087180603,
-0.0156071233,
0.0322466977,
0.0407256633,
0.0233202707,
-0.0047049467,
0.0012518365,
0.0217524078,
-0.0192176532,
-0.0129834516,
-0.044039499,
0.0075651542,
0.023896262,
0.0537167862,
0.0045342036,
0.0172339212,
-0.0196880884,
0.0463174693,
0.0185928978,
0.0207177196,
0.0093658576,
-0.050559409,
0.0461800992,
0.0233585909,
0.036666058,
-0.0212142691,
0.0179506671,
0.0202575736,
-0.0131898634,
-0.0555960424,
0.0012434612,
-0.0755795985,
-0.0050215456,
-0.0013065228,
0.0022321583,
0.004992127,
-0.0323425122,
-0.1121441275,
0.0263111349,
-0.0442022718,
0.0113039706,
0.0071424791,
-0.0105774561,
-0.0287356507,
-0.0065224059,
-0.0128720263,
0.0086229397,
-0.0206306167,
0.0186166465,
0.0027652236,
0.113619566,
0.007217837,
-0.0360211991,
0.0188662931,
0.0492908321,
-0.0593213886,
-0.044606708,
0.0038226475,
0.0562245697,
0.0263579078,
0.0735412017,
0.022268692,
-0.0362994522,
0.0380113795,
0.0009436152,
0.0428503491,
-0.0158989932,
-0.0370765477,
-0.0200933442,
0.016134657,
-0.0057870597,
-0.0348136835,
0.0215474069,
-0.0467693955,
0.0261621587,
-0.0050956765,
0.0058616679,
-0.06208691,
0.0081243515,
-0.0029716145,
-0.0093085142,
-0.0110594053,
0.0187780801,
-0.0794395953,
-0.0364320539,
-0.0323910601,
-0.0106509989,
0.0058485675,
-0.0736990049,
0.0367389768,
0.0337213576,
-0.0172174089,
-0.02678244,
-0.0584364608,
0.0201528575,
-0.0150461299,
0.0111063272,
-0.0230634827,
-6.225391633e-33,
-0.009578404,
0.0101932781,
0.0138794929,
0.0298534203,
-0.0607525483,
0.0053221127,
-0.0400233231,
0.0291663203,
-0.0144765023,
0.0082862861,
-0.018519925,
0.029130578,
0.009404622,
0.0023426446,
0.0332496949,
0.032632608,
0.0391856618,
-0.0280006826,
-0.0517152883,
0.0166654401,
0.0035263777,
0.035172224,
0.0432971232,
-0.0591867082,
0.0153476354,
0.0165352821,
-0.0173339359,
0.0012598085,
0.0103181414,
0.0267026573,
-0.0141371042,
0.0392611921,
0.0313238502,
-0.0472560637,
-0.0085259378,
0.0101213884,
-0.0227566771,
-0.0342190936,
0.0154391062,
0.0070450618,
-0.0602635033,
-0.0068317042,
-0.0022554705,
-0.0519229993,
-0.0368967056,
0.0224229991,
-0.0086127091,
-0.0370218381,
0.0044128983,
0.0554792061,
-0.0432584807,
-0.0244229976,
-0.0106476974,
-0.0995228067,
-0.0181077681,
0.0767557621,
-0.0515330546,
-0.0109837661,
-0.0189564507,
0.0473941639,
0.0252372939,
0.0050017745,
0.0172442943,
-0.0061800457,
-0.0022369809,
0.0605344772,
0.0367806777,
0.0188247394,
-0.0125737758,
-0.0180315766,
0.0191327576,
0.0238091927,
0.0789939165,
0.0475945249,
0.0024789339,
-0.0057359082,
0.0041411016,
0.0002417111,
0.0484487899,
0.0045755729,
0.0620411597,
0.0067009353,
-0.0180822872,
0.009201712,
-0.0583036952,
-0.0205454398,
-0.0087914765,
-0.067581825,
0.049857527,
0.0239971895,
-0.0403690264,
-0.0409038998,
0.0218119863,
-0.031196421,
0.0406100005,
0.0011739484,
-0.0451614037,
0.0387280509,
-0.0276909415,
-0.0353347622,
-0.0518401749,
0.0182512999,
0.0624820217,
0.0252905414,
0.0417688489,
-0.0007514209,
-0.0054665096,
0.0194253158,
-0.0270034522,
-0.0180595815,
-0.0330089293,
0.0672235638,
-0.0108754868,
-0.0019441681,
-0.0240099486,
0.0388350412,
-0.0389645956,
0.048283793,
0.0001608782,
0.0076555233,
-0.0595160127,
0.0091587128,
-0.0117284954,
-0.005895861,
-0.0542257279,
-0.0177258607,
-0.0435233936,
-0.0144505221,
0.0457413122,
0.0140536828,
-0.019566115,
-0.0068029994,
3.165e-7,
-0.0453716293,
0.0272093508,
0.0000449049,
0.0010590472,
0.0412561148,
0.0590273328,
0.0070978003,
0.0399813727,
0.0295038708,
-0.0613293499,
0.0015854285,
0.0218419507,
0.0819087401,
0.0145419762,
-0.0629127473,
-0.0200145878,
-0.0560345724,
-0.0521638133,
-0.0343427621,
0.0077047581,
0.0862712041,
0.0537994467,
0.0076064812,
-0.0266556069,
0.0010754172,
0.0430589728,
0.0425478742,
-0.0474845283,
-0.0313794538,
0.0083637377,
-0.0062700184,
-0.0220114514,
0.0014699062,
0.0031008713,
0.030728057,
0.0013739155,
-0.0253608897,
0.0530197099,
-0.0498628318,
-0.0508492291,
0.0334027298,
0.0581938513,
-0.0201229379,
-0.009490354,
0.0311195981,
-0.0783298984,
-0.0377983488,
-0.0495605208,
-0.0335851796,
-0.0341341197,
0.0515392609,
-0.0274472479,
-0.0386882536,
0.0344577953,
-0.0133432513,
0.0028773928,
0.0017679575,
-0.0239079539,
0.0243030135,
-0.0304273684,
-0.050999403,
-0.0178861879,
-0.0137564624,
-0.0424932688,
-0.0411670692,
-0.1019119173,
0.0069310502,
2.463572132e-34,
0.0125971129,
0.0325557142,
0.0353843458,
0.0575882234,
0.0269768424,
0.0507841296,
0.0071441904,
0.0242824759,
0.0397916101,
-0.0342769139,
-0.0279064234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01786v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01786v2 | COA-GPT: Generative Pre-trained Transformers for Accelerated Course of Action Development in Military Operations | 2024-02-01T21:51:09 | 2024-03-28T15:22:42 | Vinicius G. Goecks, Nicholas Waytowich | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, I.2.6; I.2.7; J.7 | The development of Courses of Action (COAs) in military operations is
traditionally a time-consuming and intricate process. Addressing this
challenge, this study introduces COA-GPT, a novel algorithm employing Large
Language Models (LLMs) for rapid and efficient generation of valid COAs.
COA-GPT incorporates military doctrine and domain expertise to LLMs through
in-context learning, allowing commanders to input mission information - in both
text and image formats - and receive strategically aligned COAs for review and
approval. Uniquely, COA-GPT not only accelerates COA development, producing
initial COAs within seconds, but also facilitates real-time refinement based on
commander feedback. This work evaluates COA-GPT in a military-relevant scenario
within a militarized version of the StarCraft II game, comparing its
performance against state-of-the-art reinforcement learning algorithms. Our
results demonstrate COA-GPT's superiority in generating strategically sound
COAs more swiftly, with added benefits of enhanced adaptability and alignment
with commander intentions. COA-GPT's capability to rapidly adapt and update
COAs during missions presents a transformative potential for military planning,
particularly in addressing planning discrepancies and capitalizing on emergent
windows of opportunities. | [
0.0467906483,
0.0203075092,
0.0054622181,
-0.0527883396,
-0.0170096457,
-0.0206342731,
-0.0315369219,
-0.0322076119,
-0.0545500033,
-0.0372944735,
-0.0169287622,
-0.0506405868,
-0.0255891606,
0.0595880635,
-0.0003272572,
0.0000405752,
0.0505113676,
-0.0521441363,
-0.0057694702,
0.0299811698,
-0.0372745208,
-0.0104388781,
-0.0275410321,
0.0347351506,
0.0204246156,
-0.0077984584,
-0.0641540959,
-0.0120505011,
0.035691224,
-0.0709051415,
0.0007963584,
0.0186249949,
0.0554429255,
0.0032897254,
0.0000020111,
-0.0393921956,
-0.0239385329,
-0.0475361049,
-0.0168965664,
0.0224951189,
0.0354954116,
-0.0146674784,
-0.0411262661,
0.0395896398,
-0.0619435012,
0.0046251398,
0.0553479642,
0.0698279068,
0.0675800815,
0.0884934664,
0.004733671,
-0.0298310854,
-0.0508124493,
-0.0361005291,
-0.0428506397,
-0.0391952358,
0.0071388287,
0.0040598996,
-0.0082956357,
0.0281425156,
-0.0025559396,
-0.0184790716,
-0.0118247746,
0.0123753538,
-0.0250083152,
0.0705424547,
0.0164583623,
0.0185649693,
-0.0035446105,
0.0198987033,
-0.0077641411,
-0.005533339,
0.011175503,
-0.0118546495,
-0.015909249,
0.0068995114,
-0.0249455329,
-0.0054088184,
-0.0062239016,
0.0079338513,
0.0216197744,
-0.0035980952,
0.0061321119,
-0.0068150526,
-0.0381373651,
0.0521056615,
-0.0151140057,
-0.0369886123,
-0.0069446457,
0.0098809162,
-0.0296528898,
-0.060398221,
-0.0336342417,
0.0677504316,
-0.1265224218,
0.0037848973,
-0.0181928445,
0.0183791332,
0.0231306218,
-0.0028638295,
0.0906620324,
0.0214689877,
-0.003538643,
0.0481275022,
-0.0166271701,
0.1027941331,
-0.0227932502,
0.0288335253,
-0.0356738009,
0.0350168496,
-0.0836421251,
-0.0306384396,
-0.0362668484,
0.0425651856,
0.003727119,
-0.0618129298,
-0.091961734,
0.0094831577,
-0.0316878855,
0.0442690477,
0.023308821,
0.0245266184,
-0.0499837957,
0.0108988211,
-0.0762559697,
-0.0211270582,
0.0139587745,
0.0305541847,
0.0077222544,
0.0251268316,
0.028160736,
-0.0100023178,
-0.0380604155,
0.0005834021,
0.0010580688,
0.098831892,
-0.0401183069,
-0.0094428863,
-0.025337182,
0.0100573488,
0.0055973278,
-0.0442106389,
0.019078441,
-0.0761963353,
-0.0079740118,
-0.0156223159,
0.0011911372,
0.0061259293,
-0.0117248697,
0.0067839012,
0.0127349487,
0.0515808985,
0.0543795042,
0.0342864878,
-0.0006324541,
0.0086461622,
0.0075811893,
0.0602438189,
0.0464581884,
0.0622820929,
-0.0016194024,
0.0136035252,
0.0632343963,
0.0552097559,
-0.0441041179,
0.0271496009,
-0.0067583672,
-0.0048037153,
-0.0096064731,
0.0560315028,
0.023055464,
-0.0076035038,
-0.0162746795,
0.0121713597,
0.06614317,
0.0113307433,
0.0160279516,
0.0135354698,
0.1027511358,
0.0525181852,
-0.0106625389,
-0.041570574,
-0.0213842597,
0.0266917888,
0.0165077895,
0.0014525999,
-0.0348007008,
0.0446385182,
-0.0171934851,
-0.0142043512,
0.0294126216,
-0.0137986317,
-0.0062730201,
-0.0322595648,
0.0200330336,
-0.0043530618,
-0.0642891005,
-0.0099755805,
0.0301340334,
-0.016594056,
-0.0036888442,
-0.0286449138,
-0.0087802093,
0.0842259452,
0.0471809357,
-0.0582389645,
-0.0956757888,
-0.0441889651,
-0.0252208654,
0.035908334,
0.0309722871,
-0.0201872438,
0.026229525,
-0.0169471949,
-0.040950153,
-0.0214061886,
-0.0053620473,
0.0482431687,
-0.0033743575,
0.0244320706,
-0.0077376179,
0.0482077785,
-0.0220769811,
0.0343112499,
0.0484584384,
-0.0605962612,
0.026426781,
0.0112514161,
0.0567087717,
0.0206459668,
-0.0248950701,
0.0140134972,
-0.0101150544,
0.0011193554,
-0.0114986254,
-0.0122231282,
-0.0393217616,
0.054082185,
0.0090505118,
-0.0266092196,
-0.0035170428,
0.0073048966,
-0.036037799,
-0.0223384146,
0.0013302615,
-0.0311370231,
0.0209565423,
0.0066974377,
0.0115452064,
0.0032595387,
-0.0036860157,
-0.0559151769,
0.0336427465,
-0.0004435474,
-0.0617857426,
0.0314799547,
0.0049758791,
0.0076690475,
0.0078463024,
0.0191103127,
0.0491978601,
0.0143361595,
-0.0186136812,
0.0522965379,
0.0652724355,
-0.0074445442,
-0.0708889812,
-0.0487234071,
-0.0105222547,
-0.0090295207,
0.0009042822,
0.0163629092,
-0.0440350771,
-0.0127032455,
0.0390277952,
-0.0030793475,
0.0124560846,
0.0076370835,
-0.0126491189,
0.0244824532,
0.0371829458,
-0.0025552546,
-0.0147487679,
-0.0074575441,
0.0084091295,
0.0250865445,
0.0029780674,
0.0365742855,
-0.0655869469,
0.0383866504,
-0.028327981,
0.0393912084,
-0.0247214437,
-0.1043505296,
0.0659373552,
-0.054168649,
0.0515592471,
0.0098986216,
0.0284406617,
0.0375227481,
0.0842647702,
-0.0078539206,
-0.0153363757,
0.0060758535,
-0.0786970332,
-0.0913542435,
-0.0957227051,
0.0115215657,
0.0355272107,
0.046257969,
0.0002597653,
0.0274507757,
-0.0669020563,
-0.0358612873,
-0.0164449345,
-0.0158693455,
-0.0073497817,
-0.0146961603,
-0.0285656881,
0.0408981107,
-0.0214368906,
0.0109351408,
0.0553494617,
0.0238939561,
-0.0119463056,
-0.0311197378,
0.0036494385,
-0.0179905277,
0.0365593284,
0.0227008779,
0.0020324728,
0.0296677258,
-0.0381590724,
-0.0685105622,
-0.0261112861,
0.0150723439,
-0.0484430157,
0.0276328418,
-0.0203926619,
-0.0184350442,
0.0094816945,
-0.0120084202,
-0.01979791,
0.009643754,
-0.0134184873,
0.0233499631,
-0.0021511782,
-0.048799701,
-0.047684636,
-0.0236119628,
0.0768261477,
0.0441562347,
-0.0071055172,
-0.0465187319,
-0.0449645333,
-0.0165633485,
0.0622901991,
-0.0219272673,
-0.0016571026,
-0.031433437,
-0.0190966837,
0.0240710471,
0.0061083166,
-0.0358595327,
-0.0652511343,
0.0222789608,
0.0174482018,
-0.0266932789,
0.0003545834,
0.0413259156,
0.0276343953,
-0.045455467,
0.0066255131,
0.0781751424,
0.0277506132,
-0.0689317584,
0.0063921544,
0.0144489724,
0.01517299,
0.0291920286,
0.0369525179,
-0.0579483882,
0.0097604925,
-0.0322237536,
0.004970686,
-0.0346565843,
-0.031609714,
0.0080802515,
-0.1248607263,
0.0176409893,
-0.0135684703,
-0.0550771542,
-0.0351189263,
-0.0395018309,
0.0194526073,
-0.0127904639,
-0.0515043959,
0.0189587623,
0.0071421256,
-0.0014480633,
0.0305837225,
-0.0351899862,
-0.0335782059,
0.0210194513,
-0.0514541231,
0.0309315734,
0.069719024,
0.0100447023,
-0.011785211,
0.0031773211,
0.0220547393,
0.0249919128,
0.0152738811,
0.004177297,
-0.0094773769,
-0.0087576387,
-0.010957391,
0.0178230293,
0.0116641652,
0.0252341926,
-0.0416198857,
0.0034413959,
0.0695608258,
-0.0417073406,
0.0084948987,
0.0014279347,
0.012190856,
0.0758133456,
-0.0080814539,
-0.0310284607,
-0.0638401136,
-0.0480552576,
0.0127003072,
0.0192122739,
-0.0720939487,
-0.0798643157,
0.0032886278,
0.0395910218,
-0.0137998937,
-0.052576445,
-0.0349549539,
0.0102940928,
0.0309143327,
0.0484180041,
-0.0123313116,
-0.0011584589,
0.0238627642,
-0.0119428132,
-0.0111513697,
0.0003610157,
-0.0087742694,
-0.0814090297,
-0.0577003807,
-0.0043525868,
-0.0464626215,
-0.0245633349,
0.0028811307,
-0.0186525006,
-0.0373712815,
0.0482548997,
0.0688382611,
0.0167905707,
-0.0221249815,
0.0203602351,
-0.0126575539,
0.0460651405,
0.0347054116,
-0.0186555982,
0.0052106748,
0.0346552208,
0.0418118052,
0.018513279,
0.0051551065,
-0.0367347859,
0.036030896,
0.0150074726,
-0.0142030874,
-0.0112699317,
-0.0156195061,
0.0290710665,
-0.0701624826,
0.0389127173,
-0.0738741681,
-0.0069805947,
0.0021429565,
0.0009772067,
-0.0185479727,
-0.0061112558,
0.0115969749,
0.0203768406,
0.0284758843,
0.0007422577,
0.0389364772,
-0.0029637415,
-0.0075915097,
-0.0100459317,
0.004536822,
-0.0008249465,
0.0401646346,
0.0285428874,
0.0530349761,
0.0030978145,
0.0249843635,
0.0095805209,
-0.0121511966,
0.0057899053,
0.0210855175,
0.0687984675,
0.0448242724,
-0.0003472075,
-0.0237161797,
0.0007393687,
-0.0454624072,
-0.0595657118,
0.0092374412,
0.0372303873,
0.0749137402,
0.0233342592,
0.0101975789,
-0.0827868134,
0.0165513922,
0.0154820653,
-0.0051817168,
-0.0324928463,
-0.009127927,
0.0265604258,
0.0387130268,
0.0164853688,
0.0602745749,
0.0554332361,
0.0001721238,
0.0428549014,
-0.006945604,
-0.0335842296,
-0.0284009222,
-0.0254543051,
-0.0191449076,
0.036865849,
-0.0281731952,
0.0313506387,
-0.0671965629,
0.003909322,
-0.005286477,
0.0749235377,
0.0016178179,
-0.0356457718,
0.007724674,
0.044750981,
-0.0269779004,
0.0190756191,
-0.0556212813,
-0.0117460312,
0.0033569916,
-0.0198731143,
-0.0295663327,
-5.632930726e-33,
0.0000491356,
-0.0166794285,
0.0997576565,
-0.0172439441,
-0.0739063844,
0.0070432969,
-0.0395083725,
0.0155395279,
0.0354213603,
0.0179886408,
-0.0127947852,
-0.010366424,
-0.003158438,
0.0309905261,
0.0378196426,
-0.0126874056,
0.0336987451,
-0.0069523733,
-0.0417630263,
0.0466098152,
0.0469486713,
-0.0261204168,
0.0223025456,
-0.0858758986,
-0.0482972786,
0.0524227656,
-0.0264724102,
0.0005963024,
-0.0057869176,
0.0780958086,
-0.0066741086,
-0.0074853376,
-0.009869541,
-0.0517630875,
0.0029975935,
0.0129751973,
-0.0151033448,
0.0022780846,
-0.0174369048,
-0.0092269611,
-0.0164658427,
-0.0310565252,
-0.0350700878,
0.0185227487,
-0.0214632563,
0.009803867,
0.0217317715,
0.0198761839,
0.0181360487,
-0.0207252521,
-0.0884063542,
0.0222708173,
-0.0215220489,
-0.0227754675,
-0.0076895664,
0.0446143672,
-0.0026932424,
-0.0023958064,
-0.0100447834,
0.0621205159,
0.0364891887,
0.036283087,
0.0246973559,
0.0549569055,
0.0123872906,
0.051385235,
-0.0405230746,
0.0305614211,
-0.0381560698,
-0.026969796,
0.0015301501,
0.0657647699,
0.0152550256,
0.047763709,
0.0229901802,
0.0025280551,
-0.0484468341,
-0.0026550379,
-0.0188302305,
0.0729372352,
0.0623899177,
0.0076717804,
-0.0002599499,
0.016068479,
0.0020734498,
0.0056826472,
0.0059339413,
-0.034018904,
0.0233977735,
0.0183522403,
-0.0164365675,
0.0255751908,
0.0558614768,
0.0136089548,
0.0448636599,
0.0207148772,
-0.0547802672,
0.0625371113,
-0.046979811,
-0.0351061784,
-0.0645176321,
-0.0519592091,
0.0597075149,
-0.0478524007,
0.009944832,
0.0181211885,
-0.0139630595,
0.0375977308,
-0.0273506604,
0.0003000075,
-0.0134085184,
0.0275120698,
0.0059813601,
-0.0591704547,
0.0423259735,
-0.0291408431,
-0.016483428,
-0.0214651134,
0.0121525275,
-0.1188081428,
0.0177335087,
-0.013590144,
0.0171042979,
0.0212962274,
-0.0258785039,
0.0488511734,
-0.061677441,
0.0573281348,
-0.0122238928,
-0.0445550233,
-0.0114063574,
0.0454602391,
2.786e-7,
0.0163156912,
0.0484691449,
0.0083259651,
-0.001574585,
-0.0080097895,
0.0426201373,
-0.0110027883,
0.0137149449,
0.0036533352,
-0.0147367641,
0.0651782006,
0.0612525754,
-0.0061682807,
-0.0023813925,
-0.0343875438,
-0.0250478238,
-0.0259550065,
-0.0246852376,
-0.1007302776,
0.0028067401,
0.0710971281,
0.0395167582,
0.0201080386,
-0.0435535945,
0.011708024,
0.0351070389,
0.0324589536,
0.0135520594,
0.0233373661,
0.0067179031,
0.0050384328,
-0.0024626825,
-0.0621927381,
0.0075724637,
-0.0155314356,
-0.0172922369,
-0.0135014709,
0.0417505912,
0.010486885,
-0.0106497714,
-0.0256177783,
-0.00369519,
-0.0240625329,
-0.053888239,
0.0506103449,
-0.1048455462,
-0.0116573032,
-0.0245854631,
-0.0310553722,
-0.0074581364,
-0.0287703834,
-0.0058927955,
-0.0074515208,
-0.0053698863,
-0.0167715549,
0.0347000062,
0.0106443921,
-0.0563212782,
0.0417260192,
0.0638484657,
-0.024354903,
-0.0183005314,
0.0063091726,
0.0038037964,
0.0233890396,
0.0273526497,
0.0067625935,
2.334961112e-34,
-0.0039944979,
-0.0122796902,
0.0066865664,
-0.0230047461,
-0.0002084107,
0.0258684624,
-0.0400015824,
0.028134536,
0.0256179851,
-0.031838458,
-0.0250799302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01035v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01035v2 | Getting the most out of your tokenizer for pre-training and domain adaptation | 2024-02-01T21:49:34 | 2024-02-07T10:51:11 | Gautier Dagan, Gabriel Synnaeve, Baptiste Rozière | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tokenization is an understudied and often neglected component of modern LLMs.
Most published works use a single tokenizer for all experiments, often borrowed
from another model, without performing ablations or analysis to optimize
tokenization. Moreover, the tokenizer is generally kept unchanged when
fine-tuning a base model. In this paper, we show that the size,
pre-tokenization regular expression, and training data of a tokenizer can
significantly impact the model's generation speed, effective context size,
memory usage, and downstream performance. We train specialized Byte-Pair
Encoding code tokenizers, and conduct extensive ablations on the impact of
tokenizer design on the performance of LLMs for code generation tasks such as
HumanEval and MBPP, and provide recommendations for tokenizer hyper-parameters
selection and switching the tokenizer in a pre-trained LLM. We perform our
experiments on models trained from scratch and from pre-trained models,
verifying their applicability to a wide range of use-cases. We find that when
fine-tuning on more than 50 billion tokens, we can specialize the tokenizer of
a pre-trained LLM to obtain large gains in generation speed and effective
context size. | [
0.0161132421,
0.074629508,
0.0062264656,
-0.0015635424,
0.0112856338,
0.0109303026,
0.0114559913,
0.0242660735,
-0.0623396561,
-0.0701432079,
-0.0212147459,
-0.0019974492,
-0.0654144138,
0.0377111211,
0.0648325235,
0.0084513668,
0.0758742094,
-0.0153272627,
0.0046186591,
0.0116075156,
-0.0123993941,
-0.0034526752,
0.0244972631,
0.0734612867,
-0.0304258037,
0.0168375652,
-0.0205651708,
0.0584119484,
-0.0339706875,
-0.0416267924,
-0.0011681992,
0.0116525311,
0.0099156881,
-0.0033846153,
0.0000018633,
-0.0508915558,
-0.0401828401,
0.0145188067,
-0.0100978734,
0.0520666577,
0.0352218263,
-0.0134409452,
-0.0282888245,
0.0426045433,
-0.0237838533,
-0.0086485343,
0.0622989275,
0.0228258912,
0.0502549671,
0.0883511677,
-0.0002489922,
0.004689524,
0.0335783102,
0.0160332918,
0.0136946365,
-0.0223258771,
0.0146643464,
-0.0233369842,
-0.0142050711,
-0.0243525896,
-0.0263836775,
-0.0301022008,
0.0043992894,
0.001280739,
0.0031128405,
0.0138385687,
-0.039423421,
0.0069467984,
-0.0330388024,
0.0059278714,
-0.0454650894,
-0.0254130941,
0.0183411483,
0.0102692712,
-0.0063350005,
-0.0534229502,
-0.0090762377,
0.0400491841,
0.013087648,
0.0361721963,
0.0146531835,
-0.0244821124,
0.0257212035,
-0.0097397808,
-0.0498513505,
0.0605649576,
0.0318771079,
-0.0065396489,
-0.0209814273,
-0.0089780716,
-0.0175484791,
-0.083863005,
0.0109647298,
0.0373634808,
-0.0073035718,
0.0056734094,
-0.0852912888,
-0.0344957039,
0.0285327341,
-0.0007787736,
0.0273864623,
0.0657968894,
-0.0290597286,
-0.0327716619,
-0.0967018008,
0.0276844949,
-0.0122532705,
0.0415965021,
-0.0177241657,
-0.0005342673,
-0.0403098501,
-0.0023481532,
-0.0596253462,
0.0816335082,
-0.0239224974,
0.0318490081,
-0.038072262,
0.053615775,
0.0293818377,
0.0080749579,
-0.0160110313,
-0.024634216,
-0.023128828,
0.0181132145,
-0.0097957002,
-0.0314235426,
-0.0399500579,
-0.0129150199,
0.0162246805,
-0.088421911,
-0.0222556815,
0.0151090315,
-0.0166192353,
-0.0409848839,
0.0258919615,
0.1108825877,
-0.0003384361,
-0.0214298125,
-0.0758763999,
-0.0433127619,
0.032304883,
-0.0042044739,
0.0000188355,
-0.0568783134,
-0.0275110956,
-0.0041761678,
-0.0166338943,
-0.0509652421,
-0.0021578586,
-0.0232066941,
-0.0033071842,
0.0387478061,
-0.0457800217,
-0.0340254754,
-0.0151457377,
-0.0157344211,
-0.0140034938,
0.0682974979,
0.0209545065,
0.03567148,
0.0251787603,
-0.0244402699,
0.0077629667,
0.043944858,
0.0086194789,
-0.005435816,
-0.0141843408,
0.0105730742,
0.0475669131,
0.0057283631,
0.097814396,
0.0494817309,
-0.0514992476,
0.0044343732,
-0.0160737019,
0.0675515682,
0.0278491508,
0.0371403657,
0.0811927542,
-0.0056579714,
-0.014611084,
-0.024177881,
-0.0397165418,
0.0030669603,
-0.0015901992,
0.005892491,
0.0167581309,
0.0721757784,
-0.0134419529,
-0.0518985167,
-0.0144647406,
-0.0178085659,
-0.0238403119,
-0.0575641543,
0.0178377833,
0.0062313909,
-0.065717712,
0.0914234519,
0.0128499139,
-0.0857359245,
-0.0212761238,
-0.0815800503,
-0.0028559121,
0.0600273684,
0.0552910082,
-0.0374462418,
-0.0414679497,
0.0020597877,
-0.0033823326,
-0.0090160118,
0.0418006666,
0.0107326871,
0.0291779414,
-0.0664876252,
-0.0238262992,
-0.0514757186,
0.0192974489,
0.0416853987,
0.0258175209,
-0.0084853182,
0.0285744984,
-0.0393315889,
-0.0040961416,
0.0726047605,
0.0221515466,
-0.0309847891,
0.0402354933,
-0.0053267921,
0.0354926512,
-0.0068099489,
-0.0363949649,
0.0252111144,
0.040541552,
-0.0180646367,
0.0054940539,
0.0016756356,
-0.0342015512,
0.0026449289,
0.0624273233,
-0.0114013245,
0.0167962611,
0.0024034954,
-0.0269120932,
-0.0391087383,
0.0246127211,
-0.0326028876,
0.0822510496,
-0.0059467312,
0.0584440194,
-0.0143245412,
0.0105658006,
-0.0557698607,
-0.0043500401,
0.0114114583,
-0.0430869497,
-0.0319389738,
0.0447793044,
0.0383491889,
-0.0049751624,
-0.017607484,
-0.0324900746,
-0.0350124016,
0.0073609268,
0.0081729796,
0.0423394851,
-0.0330954045,
-0.0345958918,
-0.0811710656,
0.0389577821,
-0.028466804,
0.0431609675,
0.0091427024,
0.0338116772,
-0.0106162373,
-0.0037300216,
-0.0344158933,
-0.0116888015,
-0.0253847931,
0.0076366281,
0.0225151405,
-0.0001690902,
-0.0599221289,
-0.0180676393,
-0.0066619758,
-0.0202436261,
0.045331005,
-0.0345407464,
-0.0157789718,
-0.0530526042,
0.058880996,
-0.0056734802,
0.038446378,
0.004234741,
-0.0471075214,
0.0336331427,
-0.0326365009,
0.0311361458,
0.0266219843,
0.0075381687,
0.0174991172,
0.050932847,
0.0241435003,
-0.0793642625,
0.01144257,
0.0315445438,
-0.0518193766,
-0.0515403599,
-0.0046542874,
0.0692214444,
0.0554654188,
-0.0342307985,
-0.0206488948,
-0.0227281153,
0.0073654484,
0.0331222676,
-0.0534345172,
0.0138190519,
-0.0229511131,
0.000730255,
0.0527254231,
0.0037029667,
-0.0736688524,
0.0350237601,
-0.0394194387,
0.0071618352,
-0.0245344676,
0.012686206,
-0.0533991754,
0.0190460533,
-0.0212717894,
0.0197484344,
0.0068148738,
-0.0640469342,
-0.0211743806,
0.003763305,
-0.0191329066,
-0.010789454,
0.0345454216,
-0.0279180836,
0.0042135664,
-0.0261543244,
-0.0476811044,
-0.0596211143,
0.0146656688,
-0.0133777969,
0.0036875773,
0.0604248755,
-0.0098726433,
-0.0201669838,
0.0196269583,
-0.0254221261,
0.0160028953,
0.0046091587,
-0.0330264829,
-0.0125304684,
-0.0054235361,
-0.0068699028,
-0.0039080679,
0.0217677839,
0.0145028569,
-0.0111046666,
0.0511354543,
0.0384237915,
-0.0250569396,
-0.0527162068,
0.0317412391,
0.0506525934,
-0.0681494027,
-0.0063805445,
0.0370923765,
0.0873884559,
-0.0404864773,
-0.0271922201,
0.0972128958,
0.0333919898,
-0.0343177952,
0.0281482805,
-0.0140631534,
0.0249229148,
0.0358040705,
0.0393913463,
-0.0875260383,
-0.0236978605,
0.027982479,
0.0247500874,
-0.0215806235,
-0.0112875244,
-0.0177852288,
-0.0904125497,
0.0137962569,
0.0305893607,
-0.0275601298,
0.0176522154,
-0.0330569968,
-0.041499,
0.0055264421,
0.0399433523,
0.0277691912,
0.0040527876,
0.0124635994,
0.027092753,
-0.0007505763,
-0.0044894102,
-0.0135301659,
-0.0573417693,
0.0448962077,
0.09128315,
-0.0295747481,
0.0054880166,
-0.0226355288,
0.0781416669,
0.0484315418,
0.0370709896,
-0.0446769707,
0.0103694331,
-0.0157205332,
-0.0098206494,
0.0372088403,
0.0061080679,
-0.0272946116,
-0.0264557488,
0.0244341139,
0.0126159359,
-0.0110708848,
0.0112866163,
-0.038536787,
-0.0352468528,
-0.036556676,
0.0428780317,
0.0492263287,
-0.020406466,
-0.0584962368,
-0.0757856369,
-0.0379068293,
-0.0962398723,
0.0218351912,
-0.0320598446,
-0.0210816432,
-0.013342903,
-0.0539358445,
0.0375408642,
0.0291142687,
0.0663134903,
0.0031496023,
-0.0165890716,
-0.0320804045,
-0.0024600034,
-0.0757458881,
0.0255738162,
-0.0330490209,
0.0008028708,
-0.084310703,
-0.0119977854,
0.0133863054,
-0.0115732532,
0.0004587139,
0.0021483107,
-0.0500100479,
-0.071744293,
-0.0284346081,
0.0829629749,
0.0169938169,
0.0526434742,
-0.0121505605,
-0.0487226434,
0.0118949544,
0.0481136516,
-0.0451676846,
0.0242083669,
0.0577115528,
0.0000955455,
0.0090099405,
-0.0226952527,
-0.0489073284,
0.0066217314,
0.0504100546,
0.0002435343,
0.0258774608,
0.011539612,
0.0241567735,
0.0687036291,
0.0016800073,
-0.0267771836,
0.0084408,
0.0395547599,
0.0215175021,
-0.0184542723,
0.0150372181,
-0.040709924,
0.0130347507,
-0.0062692328,
0.0039420556,
0.0106601547,
-0.0250888318,
-0.0377085842,
0.060343869,
0.0224508159,
0.0373021513,
-0.0422750451,
0.050783217,
0.0544546507,
-0.0093815429,
0.0009257841,
-0.0115122292,
0.0244042259,
0.0196013544,
-0.0479060262,
-0.0164949521,
0.0003599264,
0.0736563429,
-0.0462690257,
0.0483753197,
-0.0205536839,
-0.0308550075,
-0.0273243245,
0.0145444721,
0.0467129759,
0.0294110812,
0.0166769233,
-0.0015935012,
0.0072606946,
-0.0058384174,
0.0220013242,
-0.0095260842,
-0.0069937673,
0.0277250428,
-0.0105068963,
-0.0426160619,
-0.0487489179,
0.0684349164,
0.0184327345,
0.0552621819,
-0.0119686937,
0.005955291,
-0.0399428904,
0.0223194212,
0.0415466055,
0.032191921,
-0.0091251945,
-0.0437637568,
-0.0197365172,
-0.0546333268,
0.0201938506,
0.0046707382,
0.0240859203,
0.0301195495,
0.0302667096,
0.0704172254,
0.0069978395,
-0.0218475889,
-0.0127987778,
-0.0041949367,
0.041730728,
-0.0400097258,
0.0132693322,
-5.455918541e-33,
-0.0111627234,
-0.0052931607,
0.0376845635,
-0.0149265453,
-0.0237879623,
-0.0169411339,
-0.0072474885,
-0.0165966507,
0.0208606366,
-0.057738632,
-0.0016155662,
-0.0034652385,
0.0148271238,
0.0042029927,
0.0092099141,
0.0139858816,
0.0591024011,
-0.0045679323,
-0.0468428694,
-0.0150677096,
-0.0127830077,
0.032833267,
0.0149053996,
-0.0360571779,
-0.0564162657,
0.027122099,
-0.0120251318,
-0.0275761671,
0.0282557346,
0.0590186827,
0.0085388208,
0.0170689151,
-0.0013141857,
-0.0170838647,
-0.0414468981,
-0.0100212535,
-0.0610945933,
-0.0236612763,
0.0239214767,
0.0135008059,
0.0289586633,
-0.130496338,
0.0674511716,
0.0234304052,
-0.0460387617,
0.0239520669,
-0.0233652256,
-0.0036221128,
-0.0155787673,
-0.0614239052,
-0.0521252342,
0.0111993225,
-0.0213380568,
0.0346898884,
0.0194517709,
-0.0410346277,
-0.0012717517,
0.0408854485,
0.0079619838,
0.0271812156,
0.0249732286,
0.0278143231,
0.0684846267,
0.0168362074,
0.0176161733,
0.0385973118,
0.0461949818,
0.0139352893,
0.0128905224,
0.0281297863,
0.052130457,
0.042678386,
0.0010975752,
0.0155247431,
0.0563609973,
-0.0422982611,
-0.0620769486,
0.0335680246,
0.0149367433,
0.0104974788,
0.0072693177,
0.0739404112,
0.0142894983,
0.0087682595,
-0.0276650228,
0.0190629233,
-0.0144561101,
-0.0645487756,
0.046487242,
-0.002950957,
-0.0209188685,
-0.0086312899,
0.0344516635,
-0.0335308686,
0.0125852227,
-0.0112077203,
-0.0110428892,
0.0021595873,
-0.0163863134,
-0.0057239179,
0.0006300173,
-0.0640061721,
0.0436821058,
-0.0525133088,
0.0501091592,
-0.0217379741,
0.0259938724,
0.0012572961,
-0.0831869915,
-0.0004435467,
-0.0324233249,
0.0232593212,
0.0436465926,
0.0386045799,
-0.0057979091,
-0.0132637145,
0.0094761718,
-0.0194520801,
-0.0169507153,
-0.0583536252,
-0.0328658596,
0.0219475497,
0.0336971879,
0.0517966226,
-0.0425340384,
0.0050491318,
-0.036697261,
0.0428317487,
0.0303240661,
-0.0571903735,
-0.0600978807,
0.0115460875,
2.638e-7,
0.0500532426,
0.0422791839,
0.0420850329,
-0.012841342,
0.0021725306,
0.0087057259,
0.0017690198,
0.0048596738,
-0.0107520148,
0.034040302,
-0.020406248,
0.0194141082,
0.016391417,
0.008719353,
-0.0535896607,
0.0137532493,
0.0069148322,
0.0173047204,
-0.0528531112,
0.0086902939,
0.0187684298,
0.0989536494,
-0.0294138398,
-0.0164654292,
0.0364270397,
-0.0301745851,
0.0125849731,
-0.0255940668,
-0.0016804743,
0.0296758264,
-0.0336387791,
0.0117395585,
0.0064721103,
-0.0068952725,
-0.0183707792,
0.0049515096,
-0.017772628,
0.0630452931,
-0.001744007,
-0.017872192,
0.0399239585,
-0.023044413,
0.0157259274,
-0.0159220509,
0.054136496,
0.0148603674,
-0.0002436123,
-0.0436910875,
-0.0377188176,
-0.0137410956,
-0.0473239459,
-0.029804064,
0.0223161951,
0.0573927313,
0.023578383,
-0.0078828987,
-0.0205276515,
-0.0706942379,
-0.0258721076,
-0.0158329345,
-0.0263215397,
-0.0668802261,
-0.0563430712,
0.0590485893,
0.0520762093,
-0.0316537321,
-0.0114738783,
2.887649398e-34,
0.0375298709,
-0.0604304895,
0.0256962422,
0.0850253999,
0.0313375443,
-0.0090392511,
-0.0144260116,
0.0398232117,
-0.0007013622,
-0.0215294678,
-0.0121217882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01032v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01032v2 | Repeat After Me: Transformers are Better than State Space Models at Copying | 2024-02-01T21:44:11 | 2024-06-03T22:22:15 | Samy Jelassi, David Brandfonbrener, Sham M. Kakade, Eran Malach | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Transformers are the dominant architecture for sequence modeling, but there
is growing interest in models that use a fixed-size latent state that does not
depend on the sequence length, which we refer to as "generalized state space
models" (GSSMs). In this paper we show that while GSSMs are promising in terms
of inference-time efficiency, they are limited compared to transformer models
on tasks that require copying from the input context. We start with a
theoretical analysis of the simple task of string copying and prove that a two
layer transformer can copy strings of exponential length while GSSMs are
fundamentally limited by their fixed-size latent state. Empirically, we find
that transformers outperform GSSMs in terms of efficiency and generalization on
synthetic tasks that require copying the context. Finally, we evaluate
pretrained large language models and find that transformer models dramatically
outperform state space models at copying and retrieving information from
context. Taken together, these results suggest a fundamental gap between
transformers and GSSMs on tasks of practical interest. | [
0.0228232518,
0.0804753378,
-0.0093130236,
0.0174628422,
-0.0670725852,
0.0028901435,
0.0167699829,
-0.0000413071,
-0.0589296967,
-0.0365950912,
-0.0034674332,
-0.0764996409,
0.0277413409,
0.0224725455,
0.0362640284,
-0.0649293363,
0.0461344533,
-0.0344700478,
-0.040235389,
0.0106461458,
-0.0124877319,
-0.0519452505,
0.0071099354,
0.0604416914,
0.0181838982,
0.013699865,
-0.0410012528,
-0.0248544794,
0.0154989101,
-0.0051018321,
-0.0157871544,
0.0357289799,
0.0402696617,
0.028729992,
0.0000017343,
-0.0045051747,
0.0147103667,
-0.000269015,
-0.0096214758,
0.0117421262,
0.0075114295,
-0.0089118546,
-0.003715158,
0.0310646053,
-0.0257674344,
-0.0462736823,
0.0602030754,
0.0391387641,
0.0482833497,
0.0989551395,
-0.0249096919,
-0.0306255594,
0.0228440631,
-0.0617200173,
0.016652301,
-0.0265295208,
0.0405574851,
-0.0129853934,
0.0194118656,
0.0060536205,
-0.0478992611,
0.0469755195,
0.0201971475,
0.0176840667,
-0.0325662978,
0.0461639278,
0.0070374492,
-0.028701853,
-0.0043086843,
0.0690007508,
-0.0489406958,
-0.0167486984,
0.0188317746,
-0.0017730448,
0.0049170395,
0.02932241,
-0.0230265465,
0.0492439717,
-0.0061443998,
0.0289061721,
-0.0092990929,
-0.0095329545,
0.0426170528,
-0.025808977,
-0.0579823479,
0.0229068771,
0.0225418285,
-0.0314713754,
-0.0494942255,
-0.0142053766,
0.0175924841,
-0.0856930017,
0.0328432843,
0.0638398528,
-0.0082004061,
0.0157630797,
-0.0548089035,
-0.0528850034,
-0.0298805796,
-0.000228291,
0.0395638421,
0.0438735448,
-0.0159713626,
0.02768136,
-0.0328858383,
0.0704500973,
-0.0588591322,
0.04856335,
-0.0406875759,
-0.0013871234,
-0.040523883,
0.004228611,
-0.0377605371,
0.0452660173,
-0.0035882236,
-0.0516970679,
-0.0301802736,
0.0246600881,
0.013528374,
-0.0263885111,
0.0139120426,
0.0109944548,
-0.0331192575,
0.0069848523,
0.0013684169,
0.0248749387,
0.025385594,
0.0343289711,
0.0392868742,
-0.0297905579,
-0.0407645516,
0.0097032273,
0.0469594672,
-0.0146068223,
-0.0082871085,
0.0707083046,
-0.0039080339,
-0.0786744431,
-0.0125649348,
0.0307898931,
0.0029427053,
-0.049458243,
0.0227604229,
-0.0332272202,
0.0189018659,
0.0161066968,
-0.001214986,
-0.024630405,
0.015431934,
0.0307572465,
-0.0078401631,
0.0635050535,
0.0380547009,
-0.0029648675,
-0.0148306899,
0.0082110995,
-0.0013489432,
-0.0206788369,
0.0427165665,
0.0422064848,
-0.0073064459,
-0.0149271823,
0.0433850922,
0.0484859683,
0.0076830895,
0.0057390765,
-0.0081200972,
-0.0477163084,
-0.0161300655,
0.0145557616,
0.0309610702,
0.080168739,
-0.0463467538,
0.0120757958,
0.0828043744,
0.0506847054,
0.0553340465,
0.0346105397,
0.0941092744,
0.0320363268,
-0.0045174621,
0.0017748725,
-0.0276520364,
0.0421384871,
0.0219246112,
0.0222217292,
0.0034265607,
0.0261103176,
-0.0336519331,
-0.00358214,
-0.0124740573,
-0.0492770858,
-0.0063743629,
-0.0210059397,
0.0670235455,
0.0264045503,
-0.092230849,
0.0813498646,
-0.0211195275,
-0.0570866242,
0.0049480577,
-0.0534263961,
0.0036603026,
0.0146116959,
0.0236570612,
-0.0175606068,
-0.0349997915,
-0.011474628,
-0.0184020307,
0.0185176432,
0.0085225534,
0.0132010151,
0.012575754,
-0.0330140181,
-0.0449998602,
0.0188899674,
-0.0065470296,
0.007997103,
0.0400853418,
0.0241473578,
0.0480650179,
-0.0113818366,
0.0072338646,
0.0301169958,
-0.0302866511,
-0.0307516772,
-0.0124419155,
-0.0079439413,
0.0463506728,
-0.0175897945,
-0.0163580421,
0.0445071496,
0.028862007,
-0.0389749072,
-0.0605602637,
0.0272124391,
-0.117847532,
-0.040141236,
-0.0076154377,
-0.0201907828,
0.0525537208,
0.0776953474,
-0.0527773649,
-0.0580221415,
0.0113108801,
-0.0601290613,
0.0314947255,
-0.0295211393,
0.0156932119,
0.0426830277,
0.0393378921,
-0.0106488839,
0.0406859778,
-0.0394132771,
-0.0181682818,
0.0309807435,
0.0272376854,
-0.0079080276,
-0.0024889845,
-0.0313756093,
-0.0100013679,
-0.0267927423,
-0.0046199155,
0.0177262202,
-0.0250457004,
0.0033675553,
-0.0188266989,
-0.0418412723,
-0.0171495117,
-0.0368591957,
0.0358823501,
0.0111781862,
0.0482233316,
0.0159714706,
0.0045018764,
-0.0399573967,
0.0071148961,
0.0098611051,
0.0120183742,
0.0327679329,
0.0203075316,
-0.0388020054,
-0.051447317,
-0.0201591328,
0.0010932059,
0.066900447,
-0.0479171053,
-0.0298770443,
-0.0651331469,
0.0065465923,
0.0116042439,
0.0381900482,
-0.0333016962,
-0.0176812019,
0.0045194901,
-0.0310080182,
0.0625597239,
0.0251236223,
0.0346491374,
0.0232617557,
0.0082613099,
0.0073553561,
-0.0128335198,
0.0089197671,
-0.0706516281,
0.0120679103,
-0.0700605959,
-0.0006291394,
0.0407695621,
0.1027667969,
-0.0131809693,
-0.0040779966,
-0.0785656124,
-0.0341135301,
0.000871132,
-0.0032904746,
0.0091828592,
-0.0300878044,
-0.0661782548,
0.0060586645,
-0.0315610878,
-0.0208030511,
0.0417866744,
-0.051258605,
-0.0018897328,
0.0198222976,
-0.0096224137,
-0.0339791104,
0.0760240704,
0.0380350389,
-0.0017940385,
-0.0214621462,
-0.0178696401,
-0.0328893177,
0.0268237572,
0.027098801,
-0.0169383734,
0.0295137241,
-0.0475853086,
0.0277481619,
-0.0170082003,
-0.047196988,
-0.0341954567,
-0.0027352194,
-0.0158500373,
0.0059110513,
0.0355374739,
-0.034411069,
-0.0476472005,
0.0349735506,
0.0279729292,
0.1104861349,
-0.0062083807,
0.0053098607,
-0.0204290301,
0.0640324578,
0.0336828381,
0.0011607881,
0.0115173487,
-0.0355892964,
0.0015239546,
0.0460878722,
0.0372984409,
0.0318800732,
-0.0365593359,
-0.0007602123,
0.0405997857,
-0.0353798158,
-0.0363765322,
0.0380357094,
0.0390233882,
-0.04048758,
-0.0477380753,
0.0926681086,
0.00753813,
-0.0423723534,
0.0253460836,
0.0158336386,
-0.0092060352,
0.0124211079,
0.003389172,
-0.0639640018,
-0.0347450711,
0.0116213299,
-0.0252744202,
-0.0009299216,
-0.0236862302,
-0.0146199921,
-0.0707385838,
-0.0196586214,
-0.0189049672,
-0.0732208267,
-0.0467765927,
-0.0430169366,
0.0083591053,
0.0041409777,
-0.0124976449,
0.0253760815,
-0.0247217119,
-0.0008538709,
0.0429721996,
-0.0141821317,
-0.0523665994,
0.0134114847,
-0.005888103,
0.023631731,
0.0703005418,
0.0040256255,
0.005475997,
-0.0786117166,
0.0397704095,
0.0034837243,
0.0217251405,
0.0215994939,
0.0215383247,
-0.0192465279,
-0.0158907585,
-0.0153525043,
0.0376927182,
-0.0347152911,
-0.0176315028,
-0.0249750149,
0.0348743275,
-0.0022667884,
-0.0482918583,
-0.0040756627,
-0.0377002396,
0.0056339507,
0.0628454462,
0.0449659824,
-0.0291730147,
-0.0501086637,
0.0098944642,
-0.019209221,
-0.0521012284,
-0.0355970934,
-0.0160742775,
0.0444029868,
-0.0509824753,
-0.0737496838,
-0.0363693647,
0.0169676673,
0.0281642191,
0.0051433016,
-0.0121514015,
0.0544199049,
0.0013354323,
-0.0432845131,
-0.0146618141,
-0.028880503,
0.0272431839,
-0.0274428967,
-0.0059652859,
0.0260678846,
0.0070595182,
-0.0615854412,
-0.0407156087,
-0.1350759417,
-0.0339656025,
0.0406056792,
0.0574786961,
0.0191684719,
0.0071307435,
0.0146742547,
-0.0005446327,
0.0572496839,
0.0088394154,
-0.0095483279,
-0.0069537838,
0.042050153,
-0.0655498132,
0.0116376709,
0.0327423066,
-0.0345724337,
0.0224856324,
0.0246418398,
0.0378885008,
-0.0116119115,
-0.0308469459,
0.0024754021,
-0.0218329486,
0.0506616794,
0.0085855937,
0.0218169689,
0.0176748633,
0.0255849268,
0.0078800637,
0.0377955288,
-0.0616540685,
-0.0144827804,
0.0277021043,
0.0470326953,
0.0060063079,
0.0110225035,
0.0300176889,
0.00846125,
0.0094175506,
0.0000722013,
0.0044961381,
0.009493975,
0.0546016507,
0.0031553451,
-0.0129385376,
0.0018430724,
0.0197951756,
0.0274131689,
-0.0375352129,
0.0439077355,
0.034645386,
0.0381032228,
-0.0105728665,
0.0251673199,
-0.1030033454,
-0.022279812,
-0.0347878262,
-0.0003873022,
0.0666977763,
-0.0097499471,
0.026436232,
-0.037041612,
0.019803673,
-0.0095158061,
0.0669573247,
-0.0170363411,
-0.0293571185,
0.0256801862,
0.0138937822,
0.0137148174,
0.015008783,
0.0948972031,
0.0323336758,
0.0590255521,
-0.0285160132,
0.0082353977,
-0.0347492211,
-0.0308761522,
-0.0079741031,
-0.0060411575,
-0.0087839859,
-0.0190287866,
-0.0386471264,
-0.0782465786,
0.0283168238,
0.0054634977,
0.0239213537,
-0.031979315,
0.0517930426,
0.0563129894,
0.0009049848,
-0.0128969643,
-0.0240689255,
-0.0135672921,
0.0303306896,
-0.0249573309,
-0.0064152908,
-5.65977167e-33,
-0.0062479801,
-0.0005176153,
0.0470396131,
0.0044659185,
-0.0636824444,
0.000757176,
-0.0741673261,
-0.007859285,
0.0151515976,
-0.0131896725,
-0.0236012507,
0.0113084828,
0.015533464,
0.0614623316,
-0.0066980468,
-0.0225265175,
0.0646685809,
0.0148310186,
-0.0119098583,
0.0067297132,
0.0028383976,
0.0418679342,
0.0626455396,
-0.0002852387,
-0.0157302655,
-0.0133834137,
0.030853264,
-0.0230201073,
-0.0230800156,
0.0089955823,
-0.023853546,
0.0112916222,
0.0229154453,
-0.0748609975,
-0.0278032478,
0.0316381752,
-0.0502179377,
-0.0168944634,
-0.0053189211,
-0.0174235646,
-0.0454131402,
-0.0174346976,
0.0332605243,
0.0175836813,
0.0096607599,
0.0067139985,
0.0288117863,
0.0006752549,
-0.0410329662,
-0.0538479574,
-0.0611794367,
0.0077660284,
0.0254626218,
0.0000103256,
0.0261181016,
0.0664604306,
-0.0367360376,
0.0132087432,
-0.0363254026,
0.0122151664,
-0.0018824013,
0.06496685,
0.0493490882,
0.0461753421,
0.0135154054,
0.0120714121,
-0.0063374038,
-0.0462324284,
-0.0668388978,
-0.0170567017,
0.0305714514,
0.0238479748,
0.0239412095,
-0.0119394436,
0.020845551,
-0.0211019162,
-0.0322041027,
0.0017376501,
-0.0059659658,
0.0564039797,
0.0151283378,
0.0079190452,
0.0041531953,
-0.0060076299,
-0.0412647538,
0.0234697498,
0.0001017062,
-0.0143309524,
0.0359689258,
0.0488499738,
0.0041334508,
0.0244079214,
0.0575275049,
-0.02182726,
-0.0146412747,
-0.0214935783,
-0.0056828265,
0.0174296051,
-0.0215508863,
-0.0159854442,
-0.0944697037,
-0.0395403765,
0.0168971997,
0.043845538,
0.0139548788,
-0.0044519086,
0.0174210072,
0.0591708422,
-0.0678892806,
-0.0274585802,
-0.0563421957,
0.020629419,
-0.0218443815,
0.0412921347,
0.0671225339,
0.0144021008,
-0.0226114634,
0.0190117192,
-0.03507616,
-0.0342719853,
-0.0133592105,
0.018568892,
0.0208379608,
0.0238596387,
-0.0378893204,
-0.0218863618,
-0.0852570832,
0.0651768073,
0.016970424,
-0.0681360364,
-0.0263912212,
0.0326630995,
2.467e-7,
0.0285137277,
-0.0027796899,
0.0604795739,
0.0079099881,
0.019156646,
0.0251353756,
-0.0034467236,
0.0259177797,
-0.0014274749,
0.0374003947,
0.0312498882,
0.0268794242,
0.0330220647,
-0.0369883701,
-0.105390273,
-0.0311675072,
-0.0875376388,
0.0088848555,
-0.0216647759,
-0.0026228246,
0.0346502811,
0.0916839167,
0.0194942541,
-0.0110081648,
0.02084524,
-0.0099356491,
0.0668120831,
0.0088855466,
0.0483975224,
-0.0068829753,
0.0153162135,
0.0157111324,
-0.0049767783,
0.003280194,
-0.011576145,
-0.0109479921,
-0.0017648173,
0.0633430481,
0.0030254952,
-0.0367652364,
-0.0283091962,
0.0161758512,
-0.0198193397,
-0.0203034058,
0.0552321747,
-0.091383256,
-0.0066726138,
-0.0212229192,
-0.0464483388,
0.0331221782,
-0.0613887236,
0.0390950553,
0.0018553357,
0.0084202616,
0.0127172191,
0.020585468,
0.0101729743,
-0.1027270406,
0.0075894953,
-0.0148385391,
-0.0505643412,
-0.0115244305,
-0.0988917351,
-0.0088389358,
0.0530912764,
-0.0045357626,
-0.0503925793,
2.275657651e-34,
-0.0099787768,
-0.0213128477,
0.0183858201,
0.0258426238,
-0.034724135,
-0.013004777,
0.021624662,
0.0189876426,
-0.0190062393,
-0.0464868508,
-0.0636354163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01030v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01030v4 | Executable Code Actions Elicit Better LLM Agents | 2024-02-01T21:38:58 | 2024-06-07T01:53:07 | Xingyao Wang, Yangyi Chen, Lifan Yuan, Yizhe Zhang, Yunzhu Li, Hao Peng, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Model (LLM) agents, capable of performing a broad range of
actions, such as invoking tools and controlling robots, show great potential in
tackling real-world challenges. LLM agents are typically prompted to produce
actions by generating JSON or text in a pre-defined format, which is usually
limited by constrained action space (e.g., the scope of pre-defined tools) and
restricted flexibility (e.g., inability to compose multiple tools). This work
proposes to use executable Python code to consolidate LLM agents' actions into
a unified action space (CodeAct). Integrated with a Python interpreter, CodeAct
can execute code actions and dynamically revise prior actions or emit new
actions upon new observations through multi-turn interactions. Our extensive
analysis of 17 LLMs on API-Bank and a newly curated benchmark shows that
CodeAct outperforms widely used alternatives (up to 20% higher success rate).
The encouraging performance of CodeAct motivates us to build an open-source LLM
agent that interacts with environments by executing interpretable code and
collaborates with users using natural language. To this end, we collect an
instruction-tuning dataset CodeActInstruct that consists of 7k multi-turn
interactions using CodeAct. We show that it can be used with existing data to
improve models in agent-oriented tasks without compromising their general
capability. CodeActAgent, finetuned from Llama2 and Mistral, is integrated with
Python interpreter and uniquely tailored to perform sophisticated tasks (e.g.,
model training) using existing libraries and autonomously self-debug. | [
0.014943718,
0.0604493991,
-0.017324781,
0.0293272864,
-0.0170146171,
0.0256824754,
-0.0116490247,
-0.0222226493,
0.042853009,
-0.0406153277,
-0.0311527736,
0.0353065357,
-0.0316151306,
0.0720818788,
0.0225038715,
-0.0387798548,
0.054419782,
-0.0474654548,
0.007947579,
0.0141019449,
-0.0187169798,
0.0069512194,
-0.0383805074,
0.0809039921,
0.0222121105,
-0.013660864,
-0.0437251106,
0.011778377,
0.0070844153,
-0.0136360303,
0.0030146076,
0.0280205719,
0.0652401373,
0.0389130823,
0.0000020971,
-0.0508190803,
0.0139601277,
-0.0151906209,
-0.0345746092,
-0.0193389021,
0.0408809148,
-0.0136836497,
-0.0051008011,
0.0260758214,
-0.0698453411,
-0.0006730399,
0.043811433,
-0.021034006,
0.076343596,
0.0705966502,
0.0137643414,
0.0322094634,
-0.0022687416,
0.0040359427,
-0.0209799968,
-0.018231472,
-0.0013778993,
0.0061971005,
0.0397107489,
0.0031249914,
-0.0195381548,
0.0097194919,
0.0330701694,
-0.0274470411,
-0.0044286004,
0.046949435,
-0.0403636135,
-0.0554407164,
-0.0451192446,
0.0641682968,
-0.0146475295,
-0.0159317851,
0.0178635772,
-0.0107381651,
0.0060891276,
-0.0182493422,
-0.0304250922,
0.0315572582,
0.0099828327,
0.0070909234,
0.000177624,
-0.0489984974,
0.0226432215,
0.000990768,
-0.0289109405,
0.0900358111,
-0.0093531543,
0.0103183091,
-0.0342592336,
-0.0205708425,
0.0325940065,
-0.0856060609,
-0.0221715569,
0.0597118028,
-0.074098818,
0.0235899407,
-0.039803572,
0.004472272,
0.0043107388,
0.0019035339,
0.036042206,
0.0426117331,
-0.0037066084,
0.0291925464,
-0.0025327767,
0.0553204902,
0.0013723942,
0.050191585,
-0.0121313529,
0.0072338767,
-0.0569702089,
-0.0005898481,
-0.0157076512,
0.0262410399,
-0.0203516297,
-0.0173634402,
-0.0001640612,
0.0680713654,
-0.0205254368,
0.0337702595,
-0.0139783686,
-0.0074144206,
-0.0253626965,
0.013174166,
-0.0307762325,
0.0132074254,
-0.0270466115,
0.0138938418,
0.0375231951,
-0.0703263432,
-0.0086437967,
0.0149165317,
0.0014603663,
-0.0126928575,
0.0230287388,
0.1092332751,
0.0121604921,
-0.0262196958,
-0.0064816778,
-0.0294786133,
0.0472009517,
-0.0585953183,
-0.0145428898,
-0.0869977102,
0.0317795537,
0.010487766,
-0.0219015423,
-0.0663590729,
0.0202463251,
-0.0087911403,
-0.0099965893,
0.0760086328,
-0.0182986483,
0.0220748689,
0.0161183123,
0.0024348793,
-0.0315026678,
0.0587245226,
0.0524666384,
0.042320203,
0.0238397606,
0.0027489404,
0.0377455018,
0.0400164239,
-0.0227530412,
0.017215522,
0.0362673849,
0.0094264904,
0.0003869077,
0.0294011477,
0.0421488695,
0.0004187434,
-0.0235519819,
0.0080987709,
0.0488962792,
0.0501796231,
-0.0226152912,
-0.0340965763,
0.0571758598,
0.0269603208,
-0.0041783862,
-0.0373793654,
-0.0609221496,
0.0538897328,
-0.0002060862,
-0.0009035898,
-0.0212423876,
0.0384197012,
-0.0153948795,
-0.0569410957,
0.0046186671,
-0.0257829037,
0.0417532884,
0.0234962739,
0.0389972962,
0.0030987647,
-0.0564998947,
0.0192660782,
0.0321803056,
-0.0700670779,
-0.0241248384,
-0.0923518986,
0.0435301475,
0.0744037181,
0.0495131277,
-0.042921178,
-0.0614721961,
-0.0145439031,
-0.0136608165,
0.0353248902,
0.0071850671,
-0.0174260568,
0.0232113544,
-0.0193684474,
-0.0454737023,
-0.0538292453,
-0.0010520235,
0.0436319411,
0.0273389407,
-0.0261839349,
-0.0227912124,
0.001117256,
-0.020320436,
0.0513842702,
-0.0223034006,
-0.0286664572,
-0.022105705,
0.0000669336,
0.0568153411,
-0.0014925001,
-0.0171321221,
-0.0151477298,
0.0527145937,
-0.0049199127,
-0.0268896576,
0.0053810393,
0.0002503222,
-0.0094213476,
0.0376080982,
0.0046318579,
-0.0288125966,
0.0546368398,
-0.0415777564,
-0.0302936379,
0.0318741091,
-0.0075636972,
0.0494918413,
0.0169603471,
0.0139399869,
-0.0180646665,
0.0112987142,
-0.0009425239,
0.019574808,
0.0082880929,
-0.0365001671,
0.0240819082,
0.053505443,
0.000240157,
-0.0010070887,
0.0027210156,
0.0211664476,
0.0153759001,
0.0237911046,
0.0422416776,
0.0321524478,
-0.0304683838,
-0.0337802246,
-0.0836229473,
0.0067534233,
-0.0338962674,
-0.0093349349,
0.0260669719,
0.0207280125,
-0.0100230584,
-0.0018119223,
0.0078709116,
0.0139621077,
0.0054823663,
0.0299226157,
0.0197702684,
0.0065092575,
-0.0720215216,
-0.0576901026,
0.0069554993,
-0.0081110932,
0.011951359,
0.0213752892,
0.0065114964,
-0.072449334,
0.0328110717,
-0.0184757151,
0.024199577,
-0.0406579897,
-0.0774081722,
0.062972188,
-0.0326685533,
0.0033065975,
0.0969642848,
-0.0352167338,
0.0388396233,
0.0971195996,
-0.0001188774,
-0.0820560381,
0.016277153,
-0.0072994316,
-0.0321423002,
-0.0519061722,
-0.0079885982,
0.0218103714,
0.0816160962,
-0.0024859207,
0.0177208073,
-0.0341058038,
-0.0097996453,
0.0183742475,
-0.0583833531,
0.011628883,
-0.0084433407,
-0.0436831228,
0.0636727586,
-0.0205428377,
-0.0906231478,
0.071898289,
-0.0090236356,
-0.039170783,
-0.0161960591,
-0.0501434356,
-0.0315344334,
0.0923818052,
0.036540769,
0.0068636006,
-0.0149797304,
-0.035825368,
-0.0311802737,
-0.0012317606,
-0.0078473231,
-0.0066214483,
0.0442967638,
-0.0718432367,
-0.0028251177,
0.0066298037,
-0.0295762327,
-0.0313287228,
0.0087817609,
-0.0442745984,
0.0157312341,
0.0066393064,
-0.0664075613,
-0.0216052178,
-0.0301681329,
0.0553368814,
0.0405861214,
0.0068069557,
-0.0275163762,
-0.0513578765,
-0.0532503352,
0.0232280884,
0.0220003948,
-0.0132787842,
-0.0081508625,
0.032425005,
0.0387406461,
0.0237702895,
-0.022051705,
-0.0637180582,
0.0122559313,
0.0242895223,
-0.0226807464,
0.0210198704,
0.0435429551,
0.0741504803,
-0.0697085857,
-0.0178818312,
0.1024900898,
0.0194399953,
-0.0253878944,
0.0209804233,
-0.0460570492,
0.0202265047,
0.0509857684,
0.0477579087,
-0.0496286787,
-0.0393103436,
0.0010642871,
0.0464017279,
0.005258339,
-0.0222335532,
0.002604411,
-0.1011879146,
0.0506750904,
-0.0084959194,
-0.0139971701,
-0.0293507595,
-0.058214549,
0.0285689011,
-0.0306934807,
0.0079052961,
0.038776055,
0.0027272711,
-0.0000062294,
-0.0108454283,
-0.0110310279,
-0.0198676456,
0.0320339613,
-0.0385049023,
0.0582425222,
0.101807639,
0.0130559998,
0.0081118774,
0.0028287689,
0.0026443158,
0.0274692941,
0.0282192845,
-0.0187632032,
0.0354369618,
0.0057605444,
-0.0244273804,
0.0181567613,
0.0541450009,
-0.0749083832,
-0.0265387092,
0.0068445341,
0.0576689504,
-0.0311882757,
0.0055750627,
-0.0144989556,
-0.0242059641,
0.0160023235,
0.0254419725,
0.0247934237,
-0.0241683181,
-0.0588843301,
-0.0578746386,
-0.0558885857,
-0.0283270106,
-0.0366583206,
-0.0134470267,
0.0021149442,
-0.0255220272,
-0.0571535192,
-0.0651914328,
0.0493640862,
-0.0021424198,
0.0250861086,
-0.0184816569,
0.0384776182,
0.0230168663,
-0.0177821293,
0.0073440699,
-0.0314720236,
0.0341208465,
-0.0442568511,
-0.0669618174,
0.0394758172,
-0.035975758,
-0.008312678,
0.0164796058,
-0.0634781867,
-0.0760596618,
0.0099116936,
0.0796781033,
0.0262727458,
0.045917362,
0.0032797956,
-0.0210805777,
-0.021693293,
0.0340055488,
-0.055969853,
0.0292532071,
0.0322131403,
0.0486594178,
0.0056420071,
0.0279319566,
-0.0779440328,
-0.0088502429,
-0.0061696153,
0.0208208803,
-0.0745111257,
-0.0511501133,
0.0094308248,
-0.0028708051,
-0.0044594724,
-0.0112460526,
-0.0091066277,
-0.0267617088,
-0.000315057,
-0.0065260665,
0.0135484217,
-0.0718724951,
0.0041168388,
-0.0206327066,
-0.0288754907,
0.0476777703,
0.0259652063,
-0.0230323132,
0.0176644046,
-0.0044837701,
0.063067466,
0.0160291716,
0.0428311229,
0.0479656942,
0.0154226674,
-0.0138228834,
0.0160932839,
-0.010063245,
0.0274442136,
0.001197416,
0.0532843657,
0.0086810878,
0.0064752325,
-0.012996776,
0.0382011533,
-0.0822324306,
-0.0892763212,
0.0319545791,
0.0046127741,
0.0466181189,
0.0272834413,
0.064694427,
-0.0671216697,
0.0159091018,
-0.004759016,
0.0400897749,
0.0005644372,
-0.0340757705,
0.0278060623,
0.0312447995,
-0.0073467791,
-0.0130557381,
0.0821064785,
-0.0338290893,
0.0850791782,
-0.0032781283,
-0.0011006091,
-0.0472471379,
-0.0486923754,
0.0428083055,
-0.0097342608,
-0.0069712801,
-0.0121414093,
-0.0081177885,
-0.0394794233,
-0.0412513055,
0.0386223271,
-0.0257407185,
-0.0481027476,
0.0429243669,
0.0329916105,
0.0128678596,
-0.0125890365,
-0.042662628,
-0.0000335575,
-0.0038450295,
-0.0364891738,
-0.0335426703,
-5.826059672e-33,
-0.0321664847,
-0.0430832617,
0.0536244139,
0.0201065391,
-0.0020293542,
-0.0194293261,
-0.0679577217,
0.0001590423,
-0.0272752736,
-0.0131701892,
0.0127487257,
0.0224021599,
0.002235482,
-0.0179311261,
0.0425124802,
0.0021657366,
0.0252317805,
-0.0187481213,
-0.0328287371,
0.0402370021,
0.0286238901,
0.0038681927,
0.0176488273,
-0.0882537067,
0.007167601,
0.0065300101,
-0.0047850767,
0.0088769766,
-0.0408380963,
0.0528933108,
0.004241304,
0.0253990106,
0.0076777581,
-0.0234430693,
-0.0306782573,
0.0024398456,
-0.0260235481,
-0.028405102,
0.0008019623,
0.0162920821,
-0.0419189446,
-0.0553965159,
0.0416398086,
-0.0091501065,
-0.0319264866,
0.0042386828,
0.036376182,
-0.0085282968,
-0.0142276976,
-0.0014601222,
-0.0719949305,
0.0086537795,
-0.0255662631,
-0.057928808,
0.002901024,
0.013895439,
-0.0023750961,
0.0204447787,
-0.034921065,
0.0222338755,
0.0188893862,
0.0101939524,
0.0821858197,
0.01274822,
0.0295838155,
0.0488740243,
0.038301561,
-0.0005478926,
-0.0011220301,
0.0223975535,
0.0226175245,
0.0667725056,
-0.0031732987,
0.0335273147,
-0.0315137878,
0.0038611819,
-0.0260204896,
0.0184441283,
0.0238387603,
0.0549893491,
0.0048142471,
0.0391904935,
-0.0236957818,
0.0047573852,
-0.0251633767,
0.0003495521,
-0.0123660369,
-0.0438445471,
0.0258601308,
0.0075181886,
0.0036053858,
-0.0582740605,
0.025782112,
-0.0305706579,
-0.011005884,
0.0290365685,
-0.037141934,
0.0375934653,
0.0069983331,
0.0044705709,
-0.0306944884,
-0.0160404146,
0.0143557722,
-0.0117877042,
0.0582338236,
0.0164599232,
-0.014420012,
0.0649985,
-0.0416767821,
0.0048580109,
-0.0768062025,
0.0035897833,
0.0086726667,
-0.0019218363,
0.0102237351,
-0.0146432398,
-0.01204303,
0.0581023321,
-0.0304715559,
-0.0560601912,
-0.0424029417,
-0.0030413677,
-0.0046565863,
-0.0065925694,
-0.0723559558,
-0.0216460265,
-0.0855377764,
0.051699277,
0.0196656492,
-0.0173544772,
-0.019333167,
0.0015900674,
2.785e-7,
0.0073367748,
0.0357195027,
0.0003544523,
0.0618399605,
0.0232365672,
0.0592908151,
-0.0376303196,
0.0270526893,
0.0080267107,
-0.0319417268,
-0.0039187516,
0.0410884805,
0.0367242098,
0.0227810629,
-0.0599895827,
0.0156415123,
-0.0098559922,
-0.0141984047,
-0.0725527033,
-0.0087069646,
0.0526565872,
0.0824083686,
0.0242839195,
0.0021129756,
0.0262696929,
-0.0290495083,
0.0033657469,
-0.0425784439,
0.0283301864,
0.0176113211,
-0.0541737378,
0.0269889627,
-0.0083681839,
-0.0108657721,
-0.007695369,
-0.0063338089,
-0.0584917702,
0.0932579935,
-0.0145502379,
-0.0235325638,
0.0238595754,
-0.0184419118,
0.0053090304,
-0.0555658564,
0.0396023318,
-0.0420318693,
-0.0178001523,
-0.0122015849,
0.018089503,
0.0047649643,
-0.0330201276,
-0.0260410625,
0.0064004231,
0.0223909337,
-0.0180919431,
-0.0286052953,
-0.0211276058,
-0.06562756,
-0.0136254672,
-0.0273864008,
-0.0470844693,
-0.0492350571,
-0.0430854484,
-0.0034983109,
-0.0002338064,
-0.0354751348,
-0.000641493,
2.669465019e-34,
-0.0087938458,
-0.0199528541,
0.0160187632,
0.0717890486,
0.0492796265,
0.0087258993,
-0.0171539076,
0.0311688744,
0.0525043495,
-0.0531184673,
-0.025625227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01025v1 | Graph-based Clustering for Detecting Semantic Change Across Time and Languages | 2024-02-01T21:27:19 | 2024-02-01T21:27:19 | Xianghe Ma, Michael Strube, Wei Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the predominance of contextualized embeddings in NLP, approaches to
detect semantic change relying on these embeddings and clustering methods
underperform simpler counterparts based on static word embeddings. This stems
from the poor quality of the clustering methods to produce sense clusters --
which struggle to capture word senses, especially those with low frequency.
This issue hinders the next step in examining how changes in word senses in one
language influence another. To address this issue, we propose a graph-based
clustering approach to capture nuanced changes in both high- and low-frequency
word senses across time and languages, including the acquisition and loss of
these senses over time. Our experimental results show that our approach
substantially surpasses previous approaches in the SemEval2020 binary
classification task across four languages. Moreover, we showcase the ability of
our approach as a versatile visualization tool to detect semantic changes in
both intra-language and inter-language setups. We make our code and data
publicly available. | [
-0.0366795734,
0.0331198424,
-0.0418889821,
0.0341885574,
-0.0176151469,
-0.0120718479,
-0.0337103978,
0.0456399955,
0.0250134021,
-0.0059569934,
0.0161850452,
-0.0024123329,
0.0350418054,
0.0225571208,
0.0285681989,
-0.0270882733,
0.0999894589,
0.0249376148,
-0.0459812433,
0.0264070481,
0.0190557968,
-0.0113828434,
-0.0103593199,
0.007751402,
-0.0337620303,
-0.0262257904,
-0.0271275491,
-0.0535823554,
0.0135107962,
-0.0181759335,
-0.0541975573,
0.0591398068,
0.0644520819,
0.0789552927,
0.0000016677,
-0.0495197289,
-0.0230473354,
-0.0447964594,
0.0009481799,
0.033474531,
0.0766673833,
-0.0379432216,
0.0009633922,
-0.0399498232,
-0.0428360477,
-0.0512610041,
0.031898845,
-0.040028479,
0.0058300784,
0.0141848316,
-0.0111291995,
-0.0000938155,
0.0014593041,
-0.0073831985,
0.0081627388,
0.0167567674,
-0.0094473101,
0.0173671152,
-0.0263748281,
-0.0075120372,
-0.0910631418,
0.0060419748,
-0.0260896739,
-0.0162837841,
0.036639981,
0.0453459211,
0.0072010052,
0.0199163463,
0.0065890197,
0.0373756215,
-0.0091120452,
-0.0256329942,
-0.0183675271,
0.0239181928,
-0.018126199,
-0.009533789,
-0.0099451477,
-0.0442788266,
0.0256338064,
0.0281726662,
0.040015921,
-0.0221206807,
0.0515821129,
0.0233551096,
-0.0075336513,
0.067161791,
0.0296842325,
-0.0199157894,
0.0008939609,
0.0160226729,
0.0119927013,
0.0039682025,
0.0081433672,
0.005417366,
-0.0102210483,
0.0428722613,
0.0092453584,
0.0024009252,
0.01008897,
-0.0379777886,
-0.0182270873,
-0.0141789718,
-0.0408474654,
0.0478007048,
-0.036210034,
0.0113126971,
0.0208170097,
-0.0146952095,
-0.0307870079,
0.0061619803,
-0.0653563291,
0.021008186,
-0.031500563,
0.0013583803,
-0.0304394048,
-0.02073857,
-0.0393266417,
0.035870973,
-0.0109711047,
-0.0155041171,
-0.0224485472,
0.0134656169,
-0.009063419,
0.0569433756,
-0.0176313668,
0.031110324,
-0.0508291498,
0.0129705369,
-0.0484639034,
-0.0168492608,
0.0136367278,
0.0117500238,
0.0144475084,
-0.0062596318,
-0.040443372,
0.0427464582,
-0.0087135388,
-0.0006463096,
-0.061551109,
-0.0375178494,
-0.0425390005,
0.0111372694,
-0.0310076363,
-0.0640706718,
0.0205735415,
-0.0094190389,
0.0221165791,
-0.0471613184,
-0.0138548743,
-0.04011764,
-0.0444492176,
0.0779232383,
-0.0504136235,
-0.015430158,
-0.0121735148,
-0.0357042924,
0.0050127227,
0.0660752356,
0.0279514827,
-0.0478724502,
0.0828658864,
-0.0051345308,
-0.0898545235,
0.0062804967,
-0.0032296984,
0.0558103584,
-0.0040078615,
-0.0711044371,
0.0120871291,
0.0488145687,
0.0240181331,
0.0067996667,
-0.0486405045,
-0.0566903874,
0.0048937672,
0.0585195757,
0.0395657271,
-0.020184774,
0.0067837224,
-0.0075390092,
-0.0419683829,
0.0015448885,
0.0121572642,
-0.0322272144,
-0.0173823424,
-0.0505397506,
-0.0022093437,
-0.0105245952,
-0.0160830952,
0.001898392,
0.0080179833,
0.0151451696,
0.0936374515,
-0.0524508692,
0.0570916124,
0.0281690881,
0.0281248931,
0.0282033719,
0.074541539,
-0.0407973267,
0.0512313992,
0.0126924785,
0.0206313748,
0.052660495,
0.0272745248,
-0.0215998869,
0.038185671,
0.0384307131,
-0.0016708678,
-0.0138757639,
0.0115450546,
-0.0416432135,
0.0320252329,
-0.0383241326,
-0.0006195091,
-0.0047591464,
0.0021371415,
0.0161296781,
-0.0016581591,
0.0353286602,
-0.0120981568,
-0.1001866311,
0.0075722355,
0.0321655869,
0.0204240363,
0.0283346064,
0.006348493,
0.0220171344,
-0.0036398333,
0.03026562,
0.0240655579,
-0.0101252841,
0.0196175426,
-0.0145422639,
0.0282361247,
0.0665589944,
-0.0116284294,
-0.0419164859,
0.0516988486,
0.0046962188,
-0.0127334082,
-0.0351269729,
-0.0478624441,
-0.0053832163,
0.0997163951,
-0.0502111837,
0.0821271613,
-0.0396161899,
0.0049137222,
-0.0423905253,
0.0201160312,
-0.0466923863,
0.062281251,
-0.0109413043,
0.0113011049,
-0.0428166762,
0.0464746431,
0.0221715905,
-0.0088436715,
-0.0153198438,
0.0425288193,
0.0415378474,
-0.0136229945,
0.0128200362,
-0.0266304445,
-0.0613298155,
0.0658681616,
-0.1043039858,
-0.029884683,
-0.0241412129,
0.0013675285,
0.0469630212,
0.0056615658,
0.0199575257,
-0.0346917585,
-0.010241461,
0.0649182796,
-0.005955114,
0.0524716564,
0.0582267717,
-0.0329756141,
0.0181113351,
-0.037340682,
-0.0268066116,
-0.0369123183,
0.0680574402,
0.0208936818,
-0.0106155174,
-0.031646613,
-0.0134658124,
-0.0597890615,
0.0200155415,
0.0159836411,
0.0307793524,
0.0141276997,
-0.0271348897,
0.0475737005,
0.0163923372,
0.001233052,
0.0889093876,
0.0787237734,
-0.0538193136,
-0.05690258,
-0.0373649783,
-0.0386543907,
0.0368543342,
-0.0414918624,
-0.0070903846,
0.0196714438,
0.0144751118,
0.0522714518,
-0.0096319951,
-0.0366041064,
-0.0144373858,
-0.0773982108,
0.0124351028,
-0.0415654592,
0.0103594912,
-0.0223179515,
0.0197997,
-0.0297263749,
-0.0293283612,
0.0503940992,
0.0222110581,
0.0421524234,
-0.0383539051,
-0.0517513603,
-0.0369471274,
0.0710940659,
-0.0033867038,
0.0206590686,
-0.0323576182,
-0.0370519161,
-0.0623221211,
0.0116001703,
0.0639101192,
-0.001716935,
0.0427234434,
-0.0729772151,
-0.0026392161,
0.0268838257,
0.0312434658,
0.0099272458,
0.0190723725,
-0.0077957497,
0.0193752293,
0.0404276773,
-0.0100599863,
0.0238019582,
0.0197725222,
-0.0140360296,
0.0036572174,
0.019837454,
-0.0186988208,
0.0038414227,
0.0378030278,
-0.0138844186,
-0.0136160739,
-0.0257125925,
-0.019332923,
-0.0224351194,
0.0459708683,
-0.0038170456,
-0.0536123253,
-0.0908896327,
0.0328067616,
0.0037365579,
-0.0294910669,
0.009163064,
-0.0582776815,
0.0216295104,
-0.0099844551,
-0.010359141,
0.040475741,
0.0405045189,
-0.0776138902,
0.0545481592,
-0.0057899756,
0.0014927151,
0.0162759628,
-0.0391885005,
-0.0600975007,
-0.0330820195,
-0.0338296928,
0.0001192495,
0.0196915772,
-0.0696146786,
0.0194678064,
-0.0782954991,
-0.0166181717,
0.0228717383,
-0.0699039251,
0.0060205408,
-0.0654460862,
0.0439001694,
-0.003140352,
-0.0246752072,
-0.0301526394,
0.0203337632,
0.0033257843,
0.0180186462,
-0.0450078845,
-0.0095931301,
0.0212855879,
-0.0300359763,
0.0155052599,
0.0200594272,
0.0657585338,
-0.0044999486,
-0.0431207456,
0.0401758738,
-0.012548876,
-0.0178570747,
-0.0461641029,
0.0411009751,
0.0398799218,
0.0096088452,
0.0204634964,
-0.0326838084,
0.0217492562,
-0.0246387143,
0.0268497914,
0.070053637,
-0.0197324529,
-0.0420508645,
-0.0170802493,
0.0040322593,
-0.0186301954,
-0.0174742974,
0.0185347628,
-0.0071047586,
0.0055936226,
0.0052474518,
0.059082251,
0.0189836659,
-0.0227792617,
-0.0516116247,
-0.0505462736,
0.0097587481,
-0.087129809,
-0.0076053669,
0.0190043654,
-0.0097498698,
0.0316830948,
-0.001118516,
0.016381152,
-0.0448483601,
-0.1208460256,
-0.002488981,
-0.0315137766,
0.0281315669,
0.0002625728,
-0.0239908956,
0.0262040496,
0.0459986106,
0.0051656347,
-0.0007269299,
-0.0657769069,
-0.0451592058,
0.0073538851,
-0.067506142,
0.0034231166,
0.0584497228,
-0.0314787328,
0.0035705485,
0.055003304,
-0.0177339837,
0.0096731251,
0.0222287029,
-0.0427879877,
-0.0004662288,
-0.0068247076,
0.0213566851,
-0.026105674,
-0.009648649,
-0.0179468095,
0.0316718258,
-0.0578095801,
-0.0042082132,
0.0093902117,
-0.0082710292,
0.0668367743,
0.0097760269,
-0.0438175835,
-0.0481376685,
-0.0526076965,
-0.002913581,
-0.0235538781,
0.0560031943,
-0.0442813486,
0.0120062018,
0.0044392892,
-0.0331607163,
0.0411339216,
-0.0068807998,
0.016383294,
0.0007160626,
-0.0047983131,
0.0723782852,
0.0213948525,
-0.0029892898,
0.0599191003,
0.0090389038,
-0.0081852721,
-0.0452541597,
-0.0009003678,
-0.0216035452,
0.0140115377,
0.0265833791,
-0.0331994072,
-0.0524642691,
0.0280321985,
-0.0273562986,
0.0348719619,
0.037495289,
-0.0296994299,
0.0329755545,
-0.0139414081,
0.0652880594,
-0.0233153943,
-0.0116174603,
-0.0322825909,
0.0207709409,
0.0004127421,
-0.0416256003,
0.042700395,
0.0084052635,
0.0095000006,
0.056516476,
0.0157392249,
-0.063920036,
0.0405772738,
-0.0201495122,
-0.048206564,
0.0002211913,
0.0098507246,
0.0010587474,
0.040739987,
-0.0016178899,
0.0215781908,
-0.054521881,
-0.0461076461,
0.0300785489,
-0.0109257819,
0.009067595,
0.0631825328,
0.0404276624,
0.025907563,
0.0446752943,
0.0416369513,
-0.0567946583,
0.0278808512,
-0.0021265701,
-0.046220772,
-0.0298651382,
-5.83285807e-33,
-0.0018484086,
-0.0414509736,
-0.0257230271,
-0.0081377476,
-0.0565217733,
0.0244726148,
-0.0272176024,
0.0282358825,
-0.0354749821,
0.0400994271,
0.0451605581,
0.0308656469,
-0.0009380733,
-0.0321949311,
0.0335199162,
-0.0018934456,
0.0414663702,
0.0134794768,
-0.0006673104,
0.0146876303,
0.0914016441,
-0.0249401238,
0.083060801,
-0.0151534965,
0.0555434376,
0.0823122784,
0.0222869478,
0.0447005145,
0.0304564424,
0.014286276,
-0.0023138647,
0.1099020839,
0.0141296824,
0.0288387723,
-0.0229703188,
-0.0502566062,
-0.0775843486,
-0.0804986209,
0.0147241298,
0.0303934999,
-0.0398307107,
-0.0252667125,
0.0129449712,
0.0024689687,
-0.0008009764,
0.0089300117,
0.0614734367,
0.0107970964,
-0.0642753914,
0.0069412929,
-0.034279231,
0.0501224883,
-0.0236801784,
0.0365259871,
0.0004831718,
0.003054162,
0.0292197093,
-0.0353089347,
-0.094345592,
0.0736615062,
-0.0431546643,
-0.0139840776,
0.0195168685,
0.0019145001,
0.0033269974,
0.051466994,
0.0228028428,
-0.0369685628,
0.0117989266,
0.0452075042,
0.0857133418,
-0.0091998708,
0.0034608359,
0.0337223485,
0.0116297128,
-0.0543653071,
-0.0106468117,
-0.0051317927,
0.053694617,
0.0492233895,
-0.007005027,
0.0407723673,
-0.0067894505,
-0.0347948559,
-0.0236366112,
-0.0396467037,
-0.0473456159,
-0.0410108231,
-0.0044920738,
-0.040310327,
-0.0008834798,
-0.0030996429,
-0.0161657706,
-0.0290504545,
-0.029096486,
0.0159047283,
-0.0164468382,
0.0257218294,
0.0316012688,
0.0104669267,
0.0203699004,
-0.0296761934,
0.0321826153,
-0.0045361086,
0.0313141905,
-0.0174325202,
0.0170748867,
-0.0408724919,
-0.0073254006,
0.0068968106,
0.0029730604,
-0.0880036727,
-0.039460443,
-0.0452283435,
-0.0024460009,
-0.0001691037,
-0.0112858517,
0.0220156945,
0.1004014835,
0.0174603313,
-0.0058066924,
-0.0001045612,
-0.0085991332,
0.0337727852,
-0.0302638393,
-0.0180269778,
0.0006571906,
0.0454687551,
0.0448656082,
-0.0427800491,
-0.0270759445,
-0.0177897811,
2.57e-7,
0.0747570172,
0.0683428794,
0.0237749442,
0.0040804902,
0.0281642172,
-0.0121807428,
-0.0378827266,
0.0289793499,
-0.0231829807,
0.0236735325,
-0.0024815318,
0.032550633,
0.0129485838,
0.0627931356,
-0.0012702208,
0.017942654,
-0.0035863982,
-0.0069420482,
-0.0605027638,
0.0102527598,
0.0492464229,
0.0361128114,
0.0309152361,
-0.0012824576,
-0.0268424973,
-0.0276498422,
0.0321069919,
-0.0059968033,
0.0106669068,
-0.0459618978,
-0.0381405577,
0.0030035626,
0.0337636508,
0.0213372055,
-0.027270345,
-0.0155621795,
0.0004654133,
-0.0444053635,
-0.0542218089,
0.0068716505,
-0.0131206103,
0.0193682946,
0.0262636226,
-0.0142115327,
0.0499820374,
-0.0081422273,
0.001398059,
-0.0197150595,
-0.0259088073,
0.0409103185,
0.0541542135,
-0.0020868068,
-0.0915404558,
0.0350282229,
0.0130901635,
0.0370754153,
-0.0591382831,
-0.057763882,
-0.0023688423,
0.0369309112,
0.0170974657,
-0.0508904792,
0.0309322029,
-0.0164358877,
-0.0089857131,
0.0110023674,
0.0344164334,
1.618525544e-34,
0.0105614532,
0.045413889,
0.0117609445,
-0.0154087711,
0.0180489793,
-0.0576959141,
0.0282186177,
-0.008599868,
0.0283994693,
-0.0309529155,
-0.0120589808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01019v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01019v1 | Domain-Independent Deception: A New Taxonomy and Linguistic Analysis | 2024-02-01T21:13:04 | 2024-02-01T21:13:04 | Rakesh M. Verma, Nachum Dershowitz, Victor Zeng, Dainis Boumber, Xuting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CY | Internet-based economies and societies are drowning in deceptive attacks.
These attacks take many forms, such as fake news, phishing, and job scams,
which we call ``domains of deception.'' Machine-learning and
natural-language-processing researchers have been attempting to ameliorate this
precarious situation by designing domain-specific detectors. Only a few recent
works have considered domain-independent deception. We collect these disparate
threads of research and investigate domain-independent deception. First, we
provide a new computational definition of deception and break down deception
into a new taxonomy. Then, we analyze the debate on linguistic cues for
deception and supply guidelines for systematic reviews. Finally, we investigate
common linguistic features and give evidence for knowledge transfer across
different forms of deception. | [
0.0710611418,
0.039401073,
-0.0696734414,
0.060608916,
-0.0732681379,
0.004124824,
0.04572808,
0.0335257426,
0.0140959881,
-0.0367668755,
-0.0245578699,
-0.017427979,
0.0601101816,
0.0477230512,
0.0560732782,
-0.0202920064,
0.0317091718,
0.0113411536,
0.0402120538,
-0.0053487243,
0.0223513395,
0.0236662384,
-0.0041211275,
0.0364160761,
-0.0233385302,
-0.029653132,
0.0245822314,
-0.028158091,
0.0257198252,
-0.0078650108,
0.0361925699,
0.0427789092,
0.0071534757,
0.065051578,
0.0000019847,
-0.0612356178,
-0.0000087039,
-0.0190486051,
-0.070848085,
0.0283263549,
0.0707672909,
-0.0398256145,
-0.0027605942,
0.0079792002,
-0.0248567704,
0.0005046251,
0.0366449021,
0.0877583027,
0.067878142,
0.0889112651,
-0.007741394,
-0.0041125645,
0.0087316455,
-0.0051566013,
-0.0167588796,
-0.0003933932,
0.0620403104,
-0.0640635341,
-0.057287395,
0.0069715749,
-0.0092235142,
-0.0329029374,
-0.0457342528,
-0.0057938448,
-0.046891246,
0.0185369439,
-0.0305818561,
-0.0281258356,
-0.0044063521,
0.009660108,
-0.0039295545,
-0.0135748517,
0.0076283324,
0.0098086996,
0.0233755913,
0.0474002808,
0.0297649968,
0.0456690937,
-0.0306508858,
-0.0344774239,
-0.0136785572,
0.0166603085,
0.0432361066,
0.0361124575,
0.0255301408,
0.0280461535,
-0.0165557228,
-0.0314962454,
0.0195278227,
-0.0304625053,
0.0089697428,
-0.0686358139,
-0.018077936,
-0.0025670589,
-0.019346498,
0.005323444,
-0.0467401147,
-0.0034773475,
0.0460957736,
-0.0692504421,
0.0149037912,
-0.0103269592,
-0.0058755884,
0.0028838981,
0.02568659,
0.0383370295,
-0.0241197757,
0.0085524255,
-0.0397305153,
0.0144041628,
0.003954601,
-0.0140932845,
0.0157117341,
0.0212884098,
0.0406617634,
0.0069370647,
-0.0998671278,
-0.0064315945,
-0.0810611695,
0.0028323121,
-0.0364887938,
0.0166481659,
-0.0297674611,
-0.0198436771,
-0.0298276041,
0.0261833984,
0.0089205606,
0.0415548161,
-0.0260838866,
-0.0624519996,
0.0008637255,
0.0292903706,
-0.0343520381,
0.0043174457,
-0.0121399201,
0.0397662334,
0.0388199352,
-0.0233611669,
-0.0522054955,
-0.0406308733,
-0.0768090934,
-0.0415674448,
-0.0079728588,
-0.0391894691,
-0.0171591118,
-0.0232112147,
-0.0145810675,
-0.0554130971,
-0.0056942529,
0.0208201464,
-0.0607023239,
0.0445547253,
-0.0359159447,
0.0013820747,
0.0547181144,
0.0045815296,
-0.0440848693,
0.0338056199,
-0.0181216039,
0.0992264524,
0.0686637387,
0.0117366398,
0.0465096459,
-0.0007970337,
0.0203881692,
-0.0005285201,
0.0549431518,
-0.0076070321,
0.0134979095,
-0.0244050175,
-0.0113858106,
-0.0063480469,
-0.0249568503,
-0.0221899785,
0.0797297657,
0.0178404935,
-0.0214289371,
0.0076568024,
0.0405078195,
0.0457544401,
-0.0069224727,
0.0087988395,
-0.0442500003,
-0.0323404521,
-0.0787293389,
-0.0166074242,
-0.0426044837,
0.0182742011,
0.0251951478,
-0.0477718562,
-0.0282325614,
-0.0236438308,
-0.0012381233,
-0.0036889224,
0.0015296799,
0.0304647069,
-0.0144451279,
0.0014320619,
0.0415436402,
0.0175421126,
-0.0093214354,
-0.0422458053,
-0.0111145228,
0.0312101021,
-0.002575509,
0.0480958521,
0.0133364284,
-0.0566001832,
0.002531861,
0.0354611687,
0.0048449379,
0.0082625523,
-0.015849039,
0.0153083969,
-0.0215260126,
-0.0326602608,
-0.0034646438,
0.0104210423,
-0.0163098108,
0.0290431939,
0.0259529073,
-0.0166632514,
0.0428586341,
0.0264775623,
0.0186068099,
-0.0078427112,
-0.0074790125,
0.0452443957,
0.0515361726,
-0.0091648698,
0.0083351769,
-0.0072755101,
0.0339157395,
-0.011117531,
-0.0496132001,
-0.0268204622,
0.0409196056,
0.0188812874,
-0.0035862958,
-0.0697308704,
-0.0163307656,
0.0139996335,
0.003599768,
0.0331787951,
0.0640801787,
-0.040745236,
-0.0100762164,
-0.0230039824,
-0.0002045038,
-0.0333523639,
0.0532444045,
-0.0006397569,
0.0943672508,
-0.0308853518,
0.0048335423,
-0.0395250581,
-0.0481606498,
-0.0074332347,
0.00826135,
0.0468890183,
-0.0401247554,
-0.0135425832,
-0.0111398818,
0.0450050272,
0.0060071209,
-0.0232213233,
-0.0148620224,
-0.0471622385,
-0.0642429739,
-0.0018624836,
-0.0093689449,
0.0097422944,
-0.016794296,
-0.0056951265,
0.0355036519,
-0.0077226958,
-0.0034009602,
-0.0075522186,
-0.0011561643,
0.0262484383,
-0.0318211056,
-0.033180967,
0.0275334809,
0.027718341,
-0.0273581818,
0.0398823358,
0.0109757669,
-0.0551885217,
-0.0581537113,
-0.0217636451,
-0.0441344082,
0.0174988005,
-0.0140103446,
-0.0229176991,
-0.0281712115,
0.0308732428,
-0.0544977896,
0.0002454031,
0.0791611075,
0.0546800829,
-0.0000832193,
0.0397900604,
-0.0198111944,
-0.0304429196,
-0.0292787924,
0.0399758108,
-0.0207721051,
-0.0611456595,
0.0599956363,
0.0491974093,
0.0586712062,
0.0038912056,
-0.0028470017,
0.059423048,
-0.0398722887,
-0.0577682629,
0.0236346852,
-0.0655692071,
-0.0128697427,
0.0452805683,
0.0161262415,
-0.0514249206,
0.1025349796,
-0.0253808144,
0.0281534921,
-0.013667074,
-0.0067252112,
0.0259855855,
-0.0130257029,
-0.0144254062,
0.036444433,
0.1332313865,
-0.0263960715,
0.0171118435,
-0.0120975832,
0.0601487905,
-0.0075812601,
0.004836672,
-0.0151494611,
0.0195422508,
0.0425254218,
-0.0424664915,
-0.072064288,
-0.0811225697,
0.0069268993,
-0.0442291163,
-0.0041787662,
-0.0127940755,
-0.0772241503,
-0.0759966224,
-0.0211788937,
-0.0429329723,
-0.001497944,
-0.0242751651,
-0.0081674354,
0.0059651146,
0.019785393,
-0.012755407,
0.0492543243,
-0.0181572326,
-0.0444083326,
0.0380622298,
-0.0462182947,
0.0074908361,
0.0309899077,
-0.001286617,
0.0279357266,
-0.0206557009,
0.0231355503,
0.009397706,
-0.0549032465,
0.0051364088,
0.007765186,
0.0581427142,
0.0083249388,
0.0049395943,
0.0160873197,
0.0034838053,
0.0017501917,
0.0122626806,
-0.0289994441,
-0.0845704749,
-0.0059850579,
0.0035346872,
0.0077793747,
-0.0689768791,
-0.0039281435,
-0.0228563659,
-0.0822639093,
0.0461033434,
0.0113034016,
-0.0371330939,
-0.0376055464,
-0.0275607351,
-0.0359445922,
0.0352390371,
0.0369468369,
-0.0408474915,
-0.0114952661,
-0.0266653728,
-0.0122538926,
-0.0362124182,
-0.0455685258,
-0.0177228246,
0.0028231135,
0.0435004421,
0.0365347937,
0.0474240705,
-0.0109088263,
-0.0567151159,
-0.0198912919,
0.0052609937,
-0.0272094645,
-0.0108556263,
0.095895417,
-0.026941197,
-0.003505562,
-0.0044865212,
0.0147436634,
-0.030197436,
-0.0081769228,
0.009742137,
0.0534832366,
0.0042265099,
-0.0836688802,
0.0040300158,
-0.0126797324,
0.0568801835,
0.0361253768,
-0.039101541,
0.0237918682,
-0.016085187,
-0.0351378769,
0.0114422096,
0.0751478523,
-0.0578535236,
0.0683465153,
0.0207199659,
-0.0371587127,
-0.0524546169,
-0.0131346481,
-0.0237941798,
-0.0222953036,
0.0436184332,
-0.0186524447,
0.0401768796,
0.0064323279,
-0.0703752339,
-0.0015093164,
-0.0426295847,
0.0666525438,
-0.0310222078,
0.022042878,
0.0023655966,
-0.0601713918,
0.0354502574,
0.0107029211,
-0.0256875064,
-0.0036629769,
0.025466416,
0.0140697481,
0.0152603677,
0.0381976739,
-0.0337751508,
0.0016825999,
0.0307302345,
0.0044871168,
-0.0602192171,
0.0093418844,
0.0720702559,
-0.0070332214,
0.0066294195,
0.0169369821,
0.0007718407,
0.05172747,
0.0283890516,
-0.0359723195,
-0.0195082091,
0.0052416199,
0.0728538707,
0.0007900533,
0.0683114082,
-0.0074490514,
0.0565532707,
0.008191485,
-0.0199937951,
0.0021032679,
-0.0305319298,
-0.0104174176,
-0.0478893071,
0.0386936925,
0.0524645299,
0.0212131683,
0.013092149,
-0.0735060722,
-0.0330438986,
-0.006701129,
-0.0090443324,
0.0379021913,
0.0554834269,
0.0060470086,
0.0000145392,
0.0171847902,
0.0412329212,
0.0103990985,
0.0430809036,
0.0158829857,
0.0092236418,
0.0164463595,
-0.0225361139,
-0.0341045558,
-0.0182214435,
0.0046570236,
-0.0008189249,
0.0057020271,
0.0048233857,
0.0097713023,
-0.0052653654,
0.0075915214,
0.0082164099,
0.0018769308,
0.0175774153,
-0.0156114027,
-0.0280247498,
-0.0569218174,
0.0083724027,
-0.0100028245,
-0.0388315991,
0.0252816677,
0.0610874481,
-0.0145811206,
0.0174644832,
-0.034968026,
-0.0600226745,
-0.0131161325,
-0.0481502004,
0.0118633127,
0.0368152931,
0.0009220737,
-0.0178476069,
-0.1033626869,
-0.0728473216,
0.0139620444,
-0.0519068837,
0.0517960489,
-0.0101545546,
-0.0109160217,
0.0865505636,
0.008842729,
0.020352168,
-0.0790240765,
0.0303195268,
0.0072583817,
-0.004398128,
-0.0132962633,
-6.139837318e-33,
0.0409571081,
-0.0767935738,
-0.033487618,
0.0282407887,
0.0120630842,
0.0381394513,
0.0258541368,
-0.0163652115,
-0.00378506,
0.0626183823,
-0.0116744759,
0.0235708021,
-0.0030976171,
0.0088559026,
-0.0463282093,
0.0132540213,
0.0235137455,
-0.0066619138,
-0.0324213542,
-0.0169001315,
0.0399283692,
-0.0074600922,
0.0577036701,
-0.085374862,
0.0859833211,
0.009806525,
-0.0598282516,
0.0290980712,
-0.0009253903,
0.0212479606,
-0.0105083138,
0.0531653501,
0.0275558364,
-0.0349507183,
0.0139362756,
0.0317297317,
-0.0006709053,
-0.0295207854,
0.0617894828,
0.0053119138,
0.0162665248,
-0.0154884076,
0.0306051727,
-0.0345218293,
-0.0556661412,
0.0237022638,
0.0280877519,
-0.0090210773,
0.0058486583,
-0.0294332728,
-0.0662350655,
-0.0227582082,
-0.009355668,
0.011036911,
0.0037652324,
0.094972901,
0.0066402378,
-0.0112041784,
-0.0916035175,
0.0529962368,
-0.0221348424,
-0.0194468964,
0.025306629,
-0.0291504003,
-0.0304060243,
0.0752010718,
0.0298645068,
0.0172539763,
-0.0106178354,
0.0342216045,
-0.0017772662,
0.0463177338,
0.0522417426,
0.0681048036,
-0.0101137068,
-0.0575994551,
-0.0405033343,
-0.0151037918,
0.0270988792,
-0.0194377024,
0.0175445434,
-0.0404250212,
-0.0436173007,
-0.0295272507,
-0.0118970452,
0.0175564084,
-0.0487430729,
0.0175016671,
0.0246012211,
0.0019978583,
-0.0319519639,
0.0140484767,
-0.0064923842,
-0.0888383687,
-0.0105373506,
-0.0000474635,
0.0315624215,
-0.0152024757,
0.0360704325,
0.0014537128,
-0.0102177439,
-0.0339391008,
-0.0007858313,
0.0053315661,
0.0479263328,
-0.0544331968,
0.03474731,
-0.0153702917,
-0.0195313171,
-0.0213562734,
0.0067429096,
0.0365404263,
0.0131765064,
-0.0032195661,
0.0376051143,
0.0119990809,
-0.0254097879,
-0.0352901332,
0.0410701148,
-0.0072585884,
-0.0326716937,
0.0687072277,
-0.0301195625,
0.0446081236,
-0.0565454178,
-0.0388402715,
-0.0277103614,
0.022064643,
0.0294437781,
-0.0566167459,
-0.0327601619,
-0.0503972881,
2.815e-7,
-0.0262960549,
0.0498203561,
-0.0640909821,
0.0290241949,
0.0216886066,
0.0941316858,
0.0353340991,
0.0247498937,
0.0255062617,
-0.0521428883,
-0.036391072,
-0.0174369439,
0.0203862861,
0.0030716991,
-0.0669302866,
0.0232885256,
0.022645602,
-0.018762609,
-0.0257091392,
0.0083158202,
0.0203962289,
0.0619424544,
0.0497043431,
-0.0641150922,
-0.0234878957,
0.0176596325,
-0.0073024957,
0.0090150358,
-0.0063126553,
0.0270544328,
0.0101454267,
-0.0379328281,
-0.0015159509,
0.0548076779,
-0.026272729,
0.0137919663,
-0.0305741485,
0.0273095518,
0.0067740236,
0.0278536826,
-0.0463386998,
-0.049602855,
0.039034985,
-0.0477020368,
0.0245710742,
-0.0392873697,
-0.0462993458,
-0.0627442375,
-0.0295832474,
-0.0228703059,
0.0380865447,
0.0104030482,
-0.0436347127,
0.0546707697,
0.0266447328,
0.0392465331,
0.0198774971,
-0.0127549116,
0.0305788163,
0.0108884582,
0.0019885639,
-0.0045578629,
0.0296220575,
0.0359616764,
0.0654218197,
-0.033296112,
0.0396544114,
2.424240137e-34,
0.0056974539,
-0.0197788458,
0.0163688883,
-0.0063897716,
0.043981038,
0.0109763425,
0.0184406042,
0.0186720919,
-0.0071417615,
0.0209334865,
0.0098544192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01018v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01018v1 | HR-MultiWOZ: A Task Oriented Dialogue (TOD) Dataset for HR LLM Agent | 2024-02-01T21:10:44 | 2024-02-01T21:10:44 | Weijie Xu, Zicheng Huang, Wenxiang Hu, Xi Fang, Rajesh Kumar Cherukuri, Naumaan Nayyar, Lorenzo Malandri, Srinivasan H. Sengamedu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have been reshaping
Natural Language Processing (NLP) task in several domains. Their use in the
field of Human Resources (HR) has still room for expansions and could be
beneficial for several time consuming tasks. Examples such as time-off
submissions, medical claims filing, and access requests are noteworthy, but
they are by no means the sole instances. However, the aforementioned
developments must grapple with the pivotal challenge of constructing a
high-quality training dataset. On one hand, most conversation datasets are
solving problems for customers not employees. On the other hand, gathering
conversations with HR could raise privacy concerns. To solve it, we introduce
HR-Multiwoz, a fully-labeled dataset of 550 conversations spanning 10 HR
domains to evaluate LLM Agent. Our work has the following contributions: (1) It
is the first labeled open-sourced conversation dataset in the HR domain for NLP
research. (2) It provides a detailed recipe for the data generation procedure
along with data analysis and human evaluations. The data generation pipeline is
transferable and can be easily adapted for labeled conversation data generation
in other domains. (3) The proposed data-collection pipeline is mostly based on
LLMs with minimal human involvement for annotation, which is time and
cost-efficient. | [
0.0857568309,
0.0444417633,
-0.0121942069,
0.0079494556,
-0.0520698428,
0.0192118138,
0.0243607331,
-0.0191121977,
0.0483095832,
-0.0570917167,
-0.0464066975,
-0.0304775108,
-0.0124583896,
0.003939108,
0.0125527969,
-0.0386088341,
0.0192349218,
0.0209591631,
0.0272957571,
0.0248051994,
0.0049397759,
0.0391468294,
-0.0234328397,
0.0600360073,
-0.0084437951,
-0.019392645,
-0.0050068717,
0.0036935969,
0.0299596116,
-0.0000671689,
0.0339739397,
0.0550963692,
0.0374789312,
-0.0107933618,
0.0000017491,
-0.0719710216,
0.0056033335,
0.0027001831,
-0.0522199273,
-0.0549566485,
0.0477235913,
-0.0285585616,
-0.0042852079,
0.0368420146,
-0.0410093516,
0.0089537017,
-0.0142646078,
0.0943050385,
0.0769114271,
0.0882036462,
-0.013844559,
-0.0008358792,
-0.0084320744,
-0.0420124158,
0.0112048723,
-0.0725152344,
0.0357869491,
-0.0036528672,
-0.0118914712,
0.0163582526,
0.0512129366,
-0.0176417511,
-0.0134998271,
-0.0365830474,
0.0144386431,
-0.0028045408,
-0.0259613059,
-0.0233871415,
-0.0188450981,
0.0929462835,
0.0365490727,
0.03244856,
0.0084552681,
-0.0004740073,
0.0384897441,
-0.0181992408,
-0.0268447176,
0.0468912125,
-0.0235005617,
-0.0086148372,
-0.0183977131,
0.009713457,
-0.019358566,
0.0098270783,
0.0361659192,
0.0325451605,
-0.0215417631,
-0.0354525447,
0.0305622146,
0.0108499993,
0.0433570184,
-0.0510583185,
0.0100070164,
0.0154313641,
-0.0358013064,
0.0308390688,
-0.0444657318,
0.0182227939,
0.0525362641,
-0.0912118033,
0.0055063688,
0.0067996029,
0.0085305804,
0.0362216905,
0.0161838699,
0.0115938662,
0.0022708981,
-0.0102696,
-0.0115063768,
-0.0362856835,
-0.0758523867,
0.0054895235,
-0.0339535363,
0.0281623695,
-0.0467741042,
-0.0042334553,
-0.0637172982,
0.0350773409,
-0.0269926954,
0.0172781497,
0.0123304389,
0.0059307902,
-0.0144448532,
0.0209454093,
-0.0696484447,
-0.0252778474,
-0.0096165584,
0.0401553661,
0.006982984,
-0.068446584,
-0.00273192,
0.0188655984,
0.0163534917,
-0.0073206993,
-0.0154667925,
0.0651981384,
0.0142300753,
-0.042744644,
-0.0360598005,
-0.0400663577,
0.0013331214,
-0.0419092327,
-0.0106291119,
-0.0315106548,
0.0704356581,
-0.0370479263,
-0.0211215187,
-0.0404141806,
0.0409776084,
0.0666667297,
-0.0263698604,
0.0471534915,
-0.0303606205,
0.0155659923,
0.0388757288,
0.0192322265,
0.0017208379,
0.0597863644,
0.03208616,
0.0162370801,
0.0720098987,
-0.0092262272,
0.0074532344,
0.0303423461,
0.0119199175,
-0.0081778653,
0.0583268739,
0.0641651005,
-0.0039173407,
0.0566470027,
0.013185,
0.0429561436,
-0.0440123528,
-0.0065532858,
0.0219130814,
0.0575619042,
-0.0124530932,
0.0188020635,
0.0270012226,
0.0700361356,
-0.0132761374,
-0.0241679102,
-0.0348317474,
-0.0162433982,
-0.0226318911,
-0.0433581397,
0.0107222814,
-0.0120058749,
-0.0556671135,
-0.0380233303,
-0.0023753203,
-0.0117379008,
0.0034857956,
-0.0025868525,
0.0225597396,
0.0427865013,
-0.0635202006,
0.0614376776,
0.0261223596,
-0.0446786769,
-0.0398292094,
-0.0395585038,
0.0063810539,
0.0793527812,
0.0469849743,
-0.0325896554,
-0.0214984417,
-0.080369845,
0.0206603948,
0.0682050958,
0.0564292148,
-0.0181008447,
0.0156172849,
-0.0512167811,
-0.0238432158,
-0.0140146613,
-0.0030210186,
-0.0190870147,
0.0179627836,
-0.0222376343,
0.028666351,
0.0037638636,
-0.0623105913,
0.0346143432,
-0.015838122,
-0.0088042887,
0.0547423288,
0.0096264547,
0.0308547951,
0.0589220636,
0.0062895701,
0.003841209,
0.0173797719,
-0.0213936102,
-0.039860934,
0.0050532925,
-0.0064583565,
-0.0461975746,
0.0290769525,
-0.0047292784,
-0.0314019993,
0.0408218428,
-0.0356371365,
-0.0210596509,
-0.0305848755,
-0.0254086517,
0.0045290105,
-0.0458675437,
0.0070189554,
0.0154204033,
0.0291520525,
-0.0257786047,
0.0595712252,
-0.0184057299,
0.0012260001,
-0.0147855598,
-0.0176407434,
0.0177945271,
-0.0736440942,
0.0105335265,
0.0073851659,
0.0107044606,
0.0054146433,
0.0197193325,
0.0091206403,
-0.0767805502,
-0.0282421988,
-0.0992061719,
0.0085799508,
-0.0028748491,
0.0197300408,
-0.0075500091,
-0.0179480221,
-0.0020922504,
-0.0289481431,
-0.0453010239,
-0.0183932763,
0.0506945997,
0.0058326269,
0.0769331679,
0.0044530579,
-0.0219751783,
-0.022403175,
-0.0116213076,
-0.0091016619,
0.012137902,
0.0124943312,
-0.0127548128,
-0.042573899,
0.0693077222,
-0.0343156382,
0.0202259682,
-0.0151542015,
-0.0022906167,
0.0157193244,
0.0340267196,
0.0217914917,
0.0304488838,
0.0332981944,
0.0314798877,
-0.0295092613,
-0.0013553598,
-0.0247555468,
0.0182967689,
-0.0291648787,
0.005087622,
-0.0608152412,
-0.0413164496,
0.0350194834,
0.016706828,
0.0084553044,
0.0111592617,
-0.0321404189,
-0.0031159017,
0.0069247531,
-0.0137821157,
-0.0250113048,
-0.0049651088,
-0.0214495007,
0.0335000679,
0.002608306,
-0.028033115,
0.0465060584,
-0.0094036069,
0.0196952783,
-0.052674979,
-0.0347949043,
-0.068212986,
0.078186281,
-0.0360299423,
0.003318944,
0.0180911031,
-0.0426713154,
0.0125020836,
-0.021237338,
0.01450531,
-0.0411968566,
0.0120994989,
-0.0201765653,
0.0062926058,
-0.0129325073,
-0.0503074639,
-0.0616547652,
-0.0486470759,
-0.0224441849,
0.0097207688,
-0.0127742225,
0.0159785617,
-0.072054252,
-0.0329601429,
-0.0139087737,
0.017162757,
0.0266668238,
-0.0114342505,
-0.0165200513,
0.0262249596,
0.0435247682,
0.03988529,
-0.0008374816,
0.0000929505,
0.058461424,
0.0505346544,
0.0533398204,
-0.0063340878,
0.0318918787,
-0.0457876623,
0.0060772165,
-0.0430058278,
0.0150923664,
-0.0240670238,
0.0387825184,
-0.0374986157,
0.0123939905,
0.1003046036,
0.0140345963,
-0.0407453403,
-0.008084639,
-0.0218652226,
-0.0149640599,
0.0136719896,
0.0193098169,
-0.0627295598,
-0.0371460654,
-0.0235192981,
0.0106602013,
-0.0549545586,
-0.082524322,
0.0015499711,
-0.1190874204,
0.0366888493,
-0.0393884256,
0.0229794383,
-0.0119610289,
-0.0285911765,
-0.0068755252,
-0.0120141655,
0.0284284931,
-0.0326521248,
-0.0141402241,
-0.0404647328,
0.0214273985,
-0.0222093742,
-0.0476404242,
0.0692313462,
-0.0339140408,
0.0407549776,
0.0417593904,
0.0610086322,
0.0206340794,
-0.0076153744,
0.0387087837,
0.0214445386,
-0.0017330024,
0.0141337942,
0.0709470883,
-0.0420588925,
-0.0057034148,
-0.05172465,
0.0570261329,
-0.0614780933,
-0.0001194168,
0.0338433608,
0.0521295629,
-0.0493598022,
0.0330557004,
-0.0025839081,
0.028756028,
0.0286230426,
0.0768168569,
-0.0039449316,
-0.0510049611,
0.0011566718,
0.0047849012,
-0.0098058013,
-0.0232313499,
-0.0070886831,
0.0132503537,
-0.017804902,
0.0278076958,
-0.0481503494,
-0.0662322864,
0.0438718498,
-0.0044703819,
0.0094431564,
-0.0062919697,
0.0141394651,
0.0143276602,
-0.0412637219,
0.0282501578,
-0.0411892384,
0.0462646894,
-0.0413019285,
-0.0292647667,
0.0400629863,
-0.006268796,
-0.0161254462,
0.051867675,
-0.0839529261,
-0.0379172601,
-0.0550678,
0.0200560018,
0.017068753,
0.0491692871,
0.0114547592,
-0.0192923676,
-0.0173726212,
0.0231377538,
-0.088790603,
-0.0062057325,
0.0148225259,
0.0698472708,
-0.0131951664,
0.0593116283,
-0.0381671675,
0.010817348,
-0.0045939684,
0.0207808446,
-0.0172437392,
-0.0669883564,
-0.0064121508,
-0.0069217989,
0.0117336493,
0.043220561,
-0.0025979583,
-0.0700638071,
0.023454655,
-0.0324445888,
-0.0375043973,
-0.0498056076,
0.0227116626,
0.0013816881,
-0.0329835042,
0.0148970289,
0.0125913313,
-0.0739473924,
0.0278878305,
-0.0420162119,
0.0288726725,
0.0093200784,
-0.0106386049,
-0.0220568031,
-0.0243055988,
-0.0307951793,
0.0180618744,
-0.0038612618,
0.0235269237,
0.0345151238,
0.065240033,
0.016116811,
0.0149639575,
0.0286363084,
0.0213219523,
-0.0316203423,
-0.0416885018,
0.0045936229,
-0.0021027902,
0.010449362,
0.024741916,
0.0559539981,
-0.0223988164,
0.0055875606,
0.0022497342,
0.0547521673,
-0.0298116673,
-0.0096136443,
0.0597390123,
0.0092000682,
-0.0456045307,
-0.005090754,
0.0630422607,
0.0191202071,
0.0276174787,
-0.023686422,
-0.0214947164,
-0.0745795071,
-0.046770148,
0.0470781215,
0.0220806729,
0.000286167,
-0.0133555969,
-0.0580896884,
-0.0332394205,
-0.005415244,
-0.0220706593,
-0.0125849834,
-0.0097529208,
0.041800458,
0.0454661474,
0.007233914,
-0.0300437026,
-0.0769834295,
-0.0049844221,
-0.006330546,
-0.0054043503,
-0.0069605582,
-5.25107359e-33,
-0.0124746449,
-0.0244416613,
0.0282699242,
0.0292733442,
-0.0239914339,
-0.0049509825,
0.0222229473,
-0.0139194233,
-0.0418486521,
-0.0082562771,
-0.0163680594,
0.0383498445,
0.0135157052,
0.0401512608,
-0.0000846515,
-0.0049476475,
0.0488112755,
-0.0341413096,
-0.0027952844,
0.0437998138,
0.0242802575,
0.0384884961,
0.0607501119,
-0.0588238724,
0.0464656502,
-0.0135424407,
-0.0192778073,
0.063214004,
0.0273942016,
0.0553308874,
-0.0428382158,
0.0633738339,
0.0272990782,
-0.0358733609,
0.0235554874,
0.0631322861,
-0.0574571975,
-0.0227566212,
0.0341428891,
0.0112175923,
-0.0169511884,
-0.0356279686,
0.0116177993,
-0.0047487277,
0.0116088493,
0.0053029344,
0.0307071228,
-0.036125049,
-0.0083561921,
-0.0028099131,
-0.0468955338,
0.0424595997,
-0.0125564542,
-0.045982182,
-0.0210572314,
0.0422168225,
-0.0206749551,
-0.0094835768,
-0.0826871917,
0.0209267195,
-0.0042498577,
-0.0424365029,
-0.0032429469,
-0.0095909741,
0.0159369502,
0.0702439919,
0.0441859439,
0.0673292726,
-0.0195138194,
0.0052505084,
-0.0452813804,
0.0659143552,
-0.0340752937,
0.0220951159,
-0.0432373844,
-0.0185968876,
-0.0526581034,
0.0230428465,
0.0235650465,
0.0167822335,
0.0336179137,
-0.0215775426,
-0.0415189043,
-0.0060367323,
-0.0056499834,
0.0089606792,
-0.0007684465,
-0.0055466173,
0.0211469494,
0.0353512652,
0.0142715769,
0.0164175443,
-0.0069454173,
-0.044954285,
0.0071154614,
0.0238363035,
-0.0236527659,
-0.032845445,
-0.0065863216,
-0.0487015769,
-0.0933841094,
-0.0317858197,
0.0119263818,
0.0106042204,
0.0260102432,
0.0050523672,
0.0230222121,
-0.0299111344,
-0.0537144393,
-0.0018053557,
-0.024066478,
0.076704137,
-0.0532791428,
0.0563608557,
-0.0049683214,
0.0118410951,
-0.0210150648,
0.1195071265,
0.0051476676,
-0.0057821372,
-0.0307254773,
0.0156132365,
0.0371533781,
0.0155887296,
-0.005284756,
-0.0130607933,
0.0132603506,
0.0203098636,
0.0503048375,
-0.006919676,
0.0137325618,
-0.0156623051,
2.454e-7,
0.0012021252,
0.0154885342,
0.0179281272,
0.0194876529,
0.0332814977,
0.0531939417,
0.0057263188,
0.0563492514,
-0.0067905015,
-0.0072411434,
0.0149670839,
-0.0090451287,
0.0625593364,
0.0176390801,
-0.0801085681,
-0.0867239237,
0.0013565598,
-0.0611171946,
-0.0565207042,
0.0021670668,
0.0959580541,
0.0925351083,
0.0390033089,
-0.0235755965,
-0.0457119048,
-0.0223749783,
0.0791913494,
-0.0350217074,
-0.0633214414,
0.0377083234,
0.038011793,
0.0164704807,
-0.0125178946,
0.0229901467,
-0.0170056131,
0.0490412116,
0.0142580215,
0.0887969285,
-0.0098300483,
-0.0442648642,
0.0083225043,
-0.0356893018,
-0.0261397399,
-0.0024159488,
0.0368956067,
-0.0507913977,
-0.0789966881,
-0.0026663973,
0.0312420372,
-0.0188162271,
0.0336907431,
-0.0124228448,
0.0037368126,
0.0013732309,
0.0261981338,
-0.0105565749,
-0.0056455419,
-0.0651986301,
0.0354698151,
-0.0093119452,
-0.0790442228,
-0.0643471032,
0.0063635763,
-0.0140987001,
-0.0051075886,
-0.0204301085,
0.0339772888,
1.652826102e-34,
0.0295082014,
0.0130882422,
-0.0243139304,
0.0480055362,
0.0404853374,
0.0036172045,
0.0097009372,
-0.0163668413,
0.0160846431,
-0.0698432028,
0.0137143806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01783v1 | Hierarchical Multi-Label Classification of Online Vaccine Concerns | 2024-02-01T20:56:07 | 2024-02-01T20:56:07 | Chloe Qinyu Zhu, Rickard Stureborg, Bhuwan Dhingra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Vaccine concerns are an ever-evolving target, and can shift quickly as seen
during the COVID-19 pandemic. Identifying longitudinal trends in vaccine
concerns and misinformation might inform the healthcare space by helping public
health efforts strategically allocate resources or information campaigns. We
explore the task of detecting vaccine concerns in online discourse using large
language models (LLMs) in a zero-shot setting without the need for expensive
training datasets. Since real-time monitoring of online sources requires
large-scale inference, we explore cost-accuracy trade-offs of different
prompting strategies and offer concrete takeaways that may inform choices in
system designs for current applications. An analysis of different prompting
strategies reveals that classifying the concerns over multiple passes through
the LLM, each consisting a boolean question whether the text mentions a vaccine
concern or not, works the best. Our results indicate that GPT-4 can strongly
outperform crowdworker accuracy when compared to ground truth annotations
provided by experts on the recently introduced VaxConcerns dataset, achieving
an overall F1 score of 78.7%. | [
0.0547864027,
0.0868248045,
-0.0015373382,
-0.0100571336,
-0.028386984,
0.0130225997,
0.0323434174,
-0.0108851939,
0.0164755099,
-0.0804096311,
0.0165654812,
-0.0268066153,
-0.001993878,
0.0013527554,
-0.013841928,
-0.0461528897,
0.0382807255,
0.0156432074,
0.0829092115,
0.0167112462,
0.0296857022,
0.0186558384,
-0.0495956577,
0.0583392866,
-0.0021606153,
-0.0100322627,
0.0055924007,
-0.0156295039,
0.0509944595,
-0.1289876103,
0.0659511834,
0.0440945514,
0.0312112812,
0.0541787632,
0.0000017274,
-0.0261856616,
-0.0234809089,
0.0100745242,
-0.0155871399,
-0.008342064,
0.0591686592,
-0.0247814301,
0.0352825336,
0.05431832,
-0.0378979445,
-0.0327266119,
0.053961318,
0.0464820676,
0.042222444,
0.0466833226,
-0.0178766903,
-0.0160373803,
0.0354946628,
0.0033941674,
-0.0002886298,
-0.0753738657,
0.0570963845,
-0.0431335978,
0.0038862331,
0.0628286675,
0.0367761403,
0.0367096439,
-0.0416290313,
-0.0088012405,
0.0194985196,
0.0309514254,
-0.0385798588,
-0.0202225894,
-0.0220507141,
0.0676305145,
0.028829081,
-0.007866771,
0.0196826719,
-0.0251156893,
0.006306286,
0.0070540346,
-0.0249993764,
-0.0048678061,
-0.0157192294,
0.0238472335,
0.0223232582,
0.0108664799,
0.0429113954,
0.0304277372,
0.0422172435,
0.0607685186,
-0.0267404746,
-0.0389359668,
0.006290569,
0.0110981977,
0.0151550053,
-0.0506586507,
0.0294635631,
0.0230598692,
-0.0376588181,
0.0250529759,
0.0034589469,
-0.0418674238,
0.0460996516,
-0.0921530649,
-0.0303071626,
-0.0210929699,
0.002947286,
0.0366278961,
0.0468298458,
-0.014107828,
-0.0203961339,
-0.0090112742,
0.0462731756,
0.0048953951,
-0.0831008255,
-0.0030452935,
-0.0505375788,
0.0314331427,
0.016190134,
0.0325700492,
-0.0676945075,
-0.0141690122,
-0.0325100869,
-0.0206417665,
-0.0442037098,
0.0018267321,
0.0033001066,
-0.0002294181,
-0.0035757225,
0.0805387273,
-0.0406014919,
0.043683514,
-0.0079495711,
-0.0431841053,
0.0147081204,
-0.0014991082,
0.0154425418,
-0.0159454532,
-0.0122786975,
0.0157591272,
0.0186731797,
-0.0182886235,
-0.0239899233,
-0.032976687,
-0.0504565537,
-0.0195043907,
-0.0342269987,
-0.039901495,
0.0100665558,
0.0004693957,
0.0018196893,
-0.005207655,
0.0026341614,
0.006397401,
-0.067873165,
0.0701642185,
-0.0182127394,
-0.0028906062,
0.0705338344,
0.0149092097,
0.0171853863,
0.0369327441,
0.0161983967,
0.0045161997,
0.0326729827,
-0.0031278336,
0.037824925,
0.0051391334,
0.0248250067,
0.012201298,
0.0404935144,
-0.0008415451,
0.0161557496,
0.0234829299,
-0.0541676022,
0.0506100506,
-0.0129948752,
-0.0229602177,
0.0642241165,
0.0507000685,
-0.0892425478,
-0.0844906345,
-0.0082888156,
0.0677584261,
-0.0197146274,
-0.0373896956,
-0.0022068124,
-0.0209671576,
-0.0490151905,
-0.0653036609,
0.0136516355,
-0.0190457907,
-0.0229843035,
-0.0262674168,
-0.0488382503,
0.0032139164,
0.0031791404,
-0.0029255573,
0.0352372974,
-0.0290816091,
-0.0407456346,
0.0268344507,
0.0478614494,
-0.0003609073,
-0.0055874744,
-0.0696488321,
0.0192566011,
0.0273577329,
0.0211843941,
-0.0193520281,
-0.0728986934,
-0.0579450168,
0.0569484122,
0.0205997694,
0.0267703794,
-0.028996788,
-0.0148093682,
-0.0233626068,
-0.0191084854,
0.0349384621,
0.0333850347,
0.008328327,
0.0303617548,
-0.0040533571,
-0.0141138081,
0.0171398818,
-0.0171802323,
0.0425575562,
0.0171150342,
-0.0262707174,
0.0131124677,
0.0274690185,
0.0840141848,
0.0096018119,
0.0341935195,
0.009858666,
0.0246572196,
-0.0348215289,
-0.0216298252,
-0.0409225374,
0.0057710051,
0.0047982619,
0.0247867685,
-0.0123025533,
-0.022229977,
0.0049098786,
-0.0567663088,
0.0320166238,
-0.0023189499,
-0.0060417615,
0.0093637686,
-0.0176347345,
-0.0067726802,
-0.015728103,
-0.0006598301,
-0.0333067514,
0.0325381532,
-0.0198924635,
-0.001729546,
0.0045183175,
-0.0483606532,
-0.0177317783,
-0.032461293,
0.0138878953,
-0.00202379,
0.0150495786,
-0.0015413869,
0.018157674,
-0.0276678354,
-0.0290952772,
-0.0139334705,
-0.0989724994,
-0.0008943322,
0.0030843804,
0.0362281092,
0.017942749,
-0.01675223,
0.025939092,
-0.0078744227,
-0.0324096866,
0.0054874527,
0.0067950105,
0.0603539757,
0.059970554,
0.0116506573,
0.0204828829,
-0.0274505131,
0.0022782302,
-0.0660452619,
0.0072652437,
0.0548822023,
-0.0572860651,
-0.0228172485,
-0.0668392256,
-0.0405318029,
0.0092480173,
-0.0096602486,
-0.0156608913,
0.0250621811,
0.004431081,
-0.0105731841,
0.0164580662,
0.0349880569,
0.0364016294,
0.0522283018,
0.024355568,
-0.0187890828,
0.0188330561,
-0.0450710058,
-0.0294253472,
-0.0233302172,
0.0060412842,
0.0182514861,
0.1128047109,
0.0186725575,
0.0069309804,
-0.0636230037,
0.0196738672,
-0.0511116944,
-0.0036059937,
-0.0877162442,
-0.0186791439,
-0.0284545012,
0.0345206819,
-0.0252539683,
-0.0272786058,
0.052459009,
0.0283699352,
0.0204482973,
-0.0498262048,
-0.0302750841,
-0.025851367,
0.0012822089,
0.0028557407,
0.0066359038,
0.0583671592,
-0.0095036644,
0.00819558,
-0.0297248885,
0.0064426619,
-0.0476212315,
-0.0569937527,
-0.0380119979,
0.0384156853,
-0.0077473447,
-0.0559290834,
-0.0518217571,
-0.0948256403,
-0.0724918693,
-0.0306324437,
0.0099178348,
-0.0072574341,
-0.0558275767,
0.0195658952,
-0.0045463797,
0.0429012515,
0.0095666526,
-0.0351779684,
0.0243316274,
0.0510528013,
0.0297322385,
-0.0338560268,
0.0090358788,
-0.0301022623,
-0.0063793608,
0.0560232103,
0.0169895776,
0.0192915332,
-0.0054853437,
-0.0188330021,
0.00648217,
-0.012960704,
-0.0212898534,
0.0319337249,
0.040460594,
-0.0600361675,
0.0281926282,
0.095458135,
0.0333792046,
-0.0148964254,
0.0036494613,
0.0048629069,
0.0135152973,
-0.0070377872,
-0.0045356047,
-0.063567616,
-0.0271428358,
-0.0042512398,
0.0419614837,
-0.0423671715,
-0.0547290035,
-0.0081960149,
-0.063586399,
0.0467963517,
-0.0114599504,
-0.0279498287,
0.0418643504,
-0.0579759777,
0.0119716106,
0.0048073274,
-0.0107630668,
-0.0219779145,
0.0396055467,
-0.0116642341,
0.0046490398,
-0.0710559785,
-0.0215713307,
0.0405058824,
0.0165123474,
0.0499084741,
0.0256706905,
0.0708715618,
-0.0004581876,
-0.0687905923,
0.0382861942,
-0.0036010204,
-0.058137022,
-0.0197973363,
0.0888717175,
-0.0303055476,
0.0036756657,
-0.0554240458,
0.0311478823,
-0.0401525572,
-0.015051947,
0.0154285589,
0.0910366476,
0.0018422629,
-0.0464612246,
-0.0351431817,
0.0299717952,
0.0229136758,
0.0566816442,
0.0092433542,
-0.0523402169,
-0.008393174,
0.0053338571,
0.0314131454,
-0.0316159576,
-0.0099548921,
0.0028266443,
-0.010425359,
-0.0576435365,
-0.0540345311,
-0.002317552,
0.0424768291,
-0.026856916,
-0.0255399905,
-0.0228748601,
0.0522469692,
0.0310767014,
-0.027936589,
0.0233775806,
-0.0169744436,
0.008369145,
-0.0548243783,
-0.0166745,
0.0410623588,
0.0233451705,
-0.0300104283,
0.0602521114,
-0.0679894015,
-0.0726281404,
-0.0158588607,
-0.0066821505,
0.0195258167,
0.0072623761,
0.0032015499,
0.0091022868,
0.0499600545,
0.0595347956,
-0.0055265119,
-0.0395685397,
0.0180208255,
0.0275201332,
-0.0037171529,
0.0268572289,
0.0101128677,
0.0138488924,
-0.0098753227,
-0.0151902102,
-0.0768500194,
-0.0172151476,
-0.0018081,
0.0051522446,
0.0767290071,
-0.00818587,
-0.0250288527,
-0.0486534834,
-0.0232331008,
0.0227651447,
-0.0339452513,
0.0026427449,
-0.015350135,
0.0122057814,
-0.0415235944,
-0.0503821075,
0.031729579,
-0.0156341083,
0.02695987,
-0.0190100931,
0.0025134734,
0.0142542049,
0.0622517727,
0.0439142808,
-0.0304326005,
-0.0026949083,
0.0321480371,
0.030001821,
0.012479132,
-0.0062307753,
0.0133911343,
-0.0083082067,
0.0222875755,
0.0272474755,
-0.0041106977,
-0.0462071151,
-0.0422100574,
-0.0208937842,
0.0199904069,
-0.0042001088,
0.0245555099,
0.0412188545,
-0.0069381041,
-0.054439038,
-0.0237023942,
0.0556750782,
-0.0217223894,
-0.0267806109,
0.0334498622,
0.0038824694,
-0.0570413321,
0.0104119275,
0.0544695891,
0.0229737479,
0.0878052562,
0.0370636582,
-0.0560230464,
-0.0445532873,
-0.0049263486,
-0.0150433993,
0.053277608,
-0.0088918908,
0.0629952773,
-0.0676797181,
-0.0129256025,
0.0306440573,
-0.0396207012,
-0.0108342431,
0.0026148432,
0.0183233228,
-0.0057491083,
0.0070162993,
-0.0125247939,
-0.0549495891,
0.0158769768,
0.006465748,
-0.0348588526,
-0.0453267992,
-6.23942924e-33,
0.0090434114,
-0.0576709025,
-0.0191039499,
-0.0319140106,
0.0017231185,
0.0500342622,
-0.0175566971,
0.023037063,
-0.0090686083,
0.0347955786,
0.0375304408,
0.0025012721,
-0.0078462055,
0.0304669347,
0.0181304645,
-0.0279483404,
0.0503453836,
-0.0278313514,
-0.0000336756,
0.0494424328,
0.0314024687,
0.0111419503,
0.0306786243,
-0.0766331553,
0.0642205998,
-0.0141431503,
0.004062844,
0.0481306985,
0.0018212852,
0.0437618196,
-0.0154205449,
0.0487915464,
0.0560557097,
-0.0020016953,
0.0371273123,
0.0626374185,
-0.0534506068,
-0.0154963927,
-0.0420768298,
-0.0238182731,
-0.0495793223,
-0.0379186831,
0.0419550948,
0.0355070308,
-0.0099734487,
-0.0027923104,
0.0402489305,
-0.0133252786,
0.0097529925,
-0.0367590263,
-0.0506924316,
0.0222463124,
-0.0267267209,
0.0017770918,
-0.0078797089,
0.0633481368,
-0.0239449311,
0.1195316538,
-0.0282117147,
0.0336280204,
0.0161120575,
-0.0154956887,
-0.0016172782,
0.0026792337,
0.0096389484,
0.0267319456,
0.0032853493,
0.0059602093,
-0.0405251421,
-0.0099375956,
-0.0133116562,
-0.0016174515,
0.0417900309,
0.0479952842,
0.0576566607,
0.0077001858,
-0.0979785547,
0.0032255149,
-0.0277155414,
0.0234276485,
0.0203748886,
-0.0033998659,
-0.0307420157,
-0.0158415269,
-0.0170142259,
-0.0252000727,
-0.0204269215,
0.022351345,
0.019879451,
0.0052984785,
-0.0215508882,
-0.0014795058,
-0.0104580354,
0.0113568828,
-0.0573382415,
0.0152833825,
0.0409557074,
0.0004431134,
0.0125506409,
0.0375719741,
-0.0621938594,
0.0133930063,
-0.0016834913,
-0.016054986,
0.0285746269,
-0.0103125377,
0.0405189544,
-0.0363792628,
-0.089589633,
-0.0221866276,
0.0126568219,
0.0480178073,
-0.0336714908,
0.0716881901,
0.0367682427,
0.0016294247,
0.0219814256,
0.0739164203,
0.0075915237,
0.0014300218,
0.0116058579,
-0.0207052249,
-0.0555038229,
-0.0044730864,
-0.0240792427,
-0.0152580673,
0.0016183241,
0.0423694029,
0.0025108622,
-0.0821852088,
-0.0063047367,
-0.0447240844,
2.531e-7,
0.0847447589,
0.0940364078,
-0.014402736,
-0.029480366,
0.0349513367,
0.0487983041,
-0.0157017633,
0.0052124974,
-0.0123555223,
-0.0455246717,
0.0207633823,
0.010032204,
0.0344118625,
0.0548424572,
-0.0609630421,
-0.0482845753,
-0.0736671463,
0.0338727683,
-0.0458586402,
0.0132085243,
0.0823522136,
0.0517282821,
0.0280908979,
-0.0086788693,
-0.0119137801,
0.0299738832,
0.0572737567,
0.0060902899,
-0.0148834772,
0.0244069807,
-0.0082134325,
0.0175401289,
-0.0049288943,
0.0396974273,
-0.0365294069,
-0.0468981713,
-0.0379799418,
0.0605268814,
-0.0224180594,
-0.0129254786,
0.0081957961,
-0.004655798,
-0.0254666228,
-0.0123628881,
0.0427887328,
-0.0712756291,
-0.051268138,
-0.0277464464,
-0.0097478125,
-0.0054106396,
0.0387655832,
-0.0142233251,
-0.0326874405,
0.0022802397,
-0.0001881008,
-0.0010872143,
-0.0053866371,
-0.0584221929,
0.0272384789,
0.006688036,
-0.0498672314,
-0.0665880814,
0.0220248122,
0.00479184,
0.0124744112,
-0.0271237139,
0.0675627589,
1.897682035e-34,
0.0327537805,
-0.0039847428,
-0.0146078812,
-0.004858199,
0.0127076441,
0.0385576561,
-0.0350827388,
-0.0226185545,
0.0391963497,
-0.0307809468,
0.0338427313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00978v1 | An Information-Theoretic Approach to Analyze NLP Classification Tasks | 2024-02-01T19:49:44 | 2024-02-01T19:49:44 | Luran Wang, Mark Gales, Vatsal Raina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, math.IT | Understanding the importance of the inputs on the output is useful across
many tasks. This work provides an information-theoretic framework to analyse
the influence of inputs for text classification tasks. Natural language
processing (NLP) tasks take either a single element input or multiple element
inputs to predict an output variable, where an element is a block of text. Each
text element has two components: an associated semantic meaning and a
linguistic realization. Multiple-choice reading comprehension (MCRC) and
sentiment classification (SC) are selected to showcase the framework. For MCRC,
it is found that the context influence on the output compared to the question
influence reduces on more challenging datasets. In particular, more challenging
contexts allow a greater variation in complexity of questions. Hence, test
creators need to carefully consider the choice of the context when designing
multiple-choice questions for assessment. For SC, it is found the semantic
meaning of the input text dominates (above 80\% for all datasets considered)
compared to its linguistic realisation when determining the sentiment. The
framework is made available at:
https://github.com/WangLuran/nlp-element-influence | [
0.021397382,
-0.0468060412,
-0.0237324871,
0.0243144818,
-0.0729020312,
0.0480123498,
0.0146430666,
0.0303570721,
0.0429078303,
-0.0944327042,
0.0180308279,
0.0031798163,
0.002599624,
-0.0413689502,
-0.0015266038,
-0.0505567007,
0.0354053937,
0.0080795577,
0.000563034,
-0.0074768085,
0.0060922792,
-0.0050646481,
0.0006560688,
-0.0192482956,
0.0087488517,
-0.0155516947,
-0.0037091675,
-0.0269050226,
0.011796454,
-0.0330634713,
0.0003195251,
0.0576972142,
-0.011423544,
0.0136302011,
0.0000021454,
-0.055939354,
-0.0306798872,
-0.0035563156,
-0.0188981388,
-0.0089840572,
0.0719170198,
0.0093276445,
0.0376492515,
0.0174812861,
-0.0094363838,
-0.0104846824,
0.0255138781,
0.0810695142,
0.0477023311,
0.0719216019,
0.0066874488,
-0.0215393044,
-0.0042853551,
0.0560608692,
0.0711555481,
-0.0073825913,
0.0193113089,
0.0234950874,
-0.0089805042,
0.0330673829,
0.0022687374,
0.0226865541,
0.0107110105,
0.0449573919,
0.0157482214,
0.0034726791,
0.0229669251,
-0.0160961766,
-0.015763022,
0.0303340629,
0.0471522547,
-0.0324861743,
-0.0609855503,
-0.0268088542,
-0.0079382434,
0.0507797524,
-0.0088875582,
-0.0025764569,
-0.0221453309,
0.0068356819,
0.0351514295,
0.0216085389,
-0.0015351827,
0.0422277711,
-0.0082700606,
0.0601792596,
-0.0189788472,
-0.0587861128,
0.041249387,
0.0430925749,
-0.004833295,
0.0048898049,
0.0194360632,
0.0150143187,
0.0102644665,
0.019733157,
0.0087892553,
-0.0610492453,
0.0523340516,
-0.0838349834,
-0.0032681718,
0.0268082023,
0.0162667129,
0.0183948111,
0.0008402768,
0.0470484421,
0.023222141,
0.0008762511,
-0.0676610395,
0.0180113371,
-0.0710786805,
-0.013113373,
0.0159716513,
0.0527337007,
-0.0180890225,
-0.0047820634,
-0.0249955561,
0.005836654,
-0.0095558334,
-0.0147085646,
-0.0343672968,
0.0004113688,
-0.0163828637,
0.0731988177,
-0.0572813861,
0.0198387206,
-0.0504640117,
0.0219898205,
-0.0350379162,
0.0049497606,
0.0359784886,
0.0313739032,
0.0100235455,
-0.0312371012,
0.0102172457,
0.0509455912,
0.0005682987,
-0.0391553827,
-0.0283947624,
-0.0494425781,
-0.0059419684,
-0.0380135663,
-0.0016203063,
-0.0125082796,
-0.0108861448,
0.0254374184,
-0.0036601364,
-0.0004270767,
-0.0137137128,
0.04957157,
0.008355028,
0.0871106535,
0.02285349,
-0.0337503329,
0.0303809848,
0.0166173782,
0.0387489945,
0.0528599173,
-0.0206559505,
-0.0080705993,
0.0554112606,
-0.0335060023,
-0.0006580388,
-0.0138845723,
-0.0174795594,
-0.0097610811,
0.0071940804,
0.0287161805,
-0.0154397776,
0.0016713131,
-0.0251853559,
0.0362531468,
-0.0101616355,
-0.0112433117,
0.0300167575,
0.0216832142,
0.043100331,
-0.0171764754,
0.0150343981,
0.0299598575,
0.0106299082,
0.0574987456,
-0.0038695927,
-0.0107966876,
-0.0614886805,
0.0077316677,
0.0014741324,
-0.0377291776,
0.0057017179,
-0.0789294839,
-0.0231188089,
0.0274969302,
0.0648203641,
0.0203224905,
0.0580466241,
0.0019692071,
-0.0475477092,
-0.0376617126,
0.0169260018,
-0.0542849414,
0.0053897868,
-0.0264220815,
0.0481894277,
0.0349002741,
0.0252731871,
-0.0476715602,
-0.0083652688,
-0.001850797,
-0.0309449453,
0.0082744481,
0.031398274,
-0.029808538,
-0.0104216402,
-0.0319349095,
-0.0003437836,
0.0223470628,
-0.0137343835,
0.0060614441,
-0.0089175031,
-0.0057012551,
-0.0003599069,
0.0145976683,
-0.0424965434,
0.0450025685,
0.0360263139,
-0.0748606324,
-0.0032698461,
0.0306677856,
0.0657917038,
0.0330883227,
-0.0024335284,
-0.017163137,
0.010963412,
-0.0224380456,
-0.0257819891,
-0.0149098281,
-0.0151695088,
-0.0559228174,
0.0046206438,
-0.0546646789,
0.005072,
0.0287742056,
-0.0119347172,
-0.0260465741,
-0.0053083627,
-0.0528751276,
-0.0027072192,
-0.0235861093,
-0.0217044074,
-0.0523433201,
-0.0300969724,
-0.1067644656,
0.0578007996,
0.0103622396,
0.0893788934,
-0.0158662125,
0.0383602045,
0.0557725318,
0.0236287173,
-0.0479608439,
0.0088922987,
0.013695132,
0.0034065871,
0.0640765354,
0.0206119549,
-0.0504447259,
-0.0123248957,
-0.0848994404,
-0.0032928903,
0.0096520865,
0.0268125236,
0.0304430183,
-0.0116069466,
0.0082099959,
0.0147078112,
-0.0123431692,
-0.0020973131,
-0.0268464237,
0.0285977833,
0.0390418656,
0.0123302527,
0.0341807567,
-0.012182124,
-0.0054033445,
-0.0535906963,
0.0341194905,
0.0767918974,
-0.0172883309,
-0.0477638803,
0.0399337634,
-0.0086948322,
-0.023391135,
0.002874508,
-0.0158923771,
0.0275915358,
-0.0063942797,
0.0178090166,
0.0335264876,
0.0074069644,
0.0394846946,
0.0074958242,
0.0102175679,
-0.043543756,
0.0220081564,
-0.0393160097,
0.0424852483,
-0.0164778493,
-0.0460408367,
0.0116239497,
0.0637906715,
0.0381276123,
-0.0490838028,
-0.0216157567,
0.021810459,
-0.0911206976,
-0.0180087611,
-0.0833609104,
-0.0014642477,
-0.0063677928,
0.0575414896,
0.0022359171,
-0.0162997581,
0.0701393858,
-0.0201191474,
0.0107170353,
-0.1644206345,
-0.0028996442,
-0.0415858217,
0.0642628372,
0.0216055699,
-0.0028210466,
0.0295200925,
-0.0144099435,
-0.0238613226,
-0.033627674,
0.0166197754,
-0.0255495347,
0.0414073952,
-0.0284690969,
-0.0225506257,
-0.0075273537,
-0.0185603574,
0.0163610429,
-0.0095362654,
0.006274438,
-0.0405487753,
0.0440989956,
0.0155801103,
0.0100767864,
-0.0232525337,
0.0193042438,
-0.0257584602,
-0.026725797,
-0.032018546,
-0.0022548591,
0.0613719374,
-0.0112277251,
0.0321692899,
0.0308503527,
-0.0150058344,
0.001120374,
0.0409553871,
-0.0002314344,
0.0323889665,
-0.0022173361,
0.0090617919,
0.0320124812,
-0.0617717281,
-0.0009952937,
-0.0170655362,
0.0448112674,
-0.0692595765,
-0.0131698074,
0.0839286,
0.0542037822,
-0.0294557437,
-0.0065475977,
-0.0089638438,
-0.0062883752,
0.036547482,
0.0037716841,
-0.0327991396,
-0.0408367291,
-0.015399958,
-0.0033620642,
-0.0666923523,
0.0038511599,
-0.009563012,
-0.0668486357,
-0.0088141449,
-0.0267708097,
-0.0596309453,
-0.0425556526,
-0.0806768015,
-0.0115140602,
-0.0019913707,
0.0140047586,
-0.0205201693,
0.0068066092,
0.0271141604,
0.0279550105,
-0.0209310874,
0.0168389417,
0.0234939493,
0.0355627239,
0.0068361722,
0.0430575535,
0.0424533151,
-0.0479510687,
0.019811634,
0.0344757773,
-0.1090750545,
-0.0001574364,
-0.0470441505,
0.0667325109,
0.0251691919,
0.0187389813,
-0.060389556,
0.0082850615,
-0.0193007905,
-0.0021438194,
0.0226753335,
0.0483470708,
-0.00767523,
-0.0500915758,
-0.046011094,
0.0244611092,
0.0157333259,
0.0861415341,
0.0328611359,
-0.0891553834,
-0.0143002374,
-0.0402157642,
0.0234494731,
-0.0737768412,
-0.0356575586,
0.0304161813,
-0.0031595661,
-0.0199224669,
-0.0398518145,
-0.0895134136,
0.0345270038,
0.010722056,
0.0019126699,
0.0320591517,
0.0204173494,
-0.0175729785,
-0.0264541879,
0.0010144664,
0.0314333476,
0.0103531396,
0.0257655941,
-0.0270673521,
0.0345756896,
-0.0211737249,
-0.0352677144,
0.0022616368,
-0.0339075588,
-0.0049524973,
-0.0027379768,
-0.0055880104,
0.0153203942,
0.0237157624,
0.0138676604,
-0.0495445095,
0.0709467307,
-0.0262638498,
-0.0251914188,
0.0040299539,
0.013463893,
0.044910688,
0.0270791613,
-0.0027613884,
0.0074812351,
0.0337347798,
0.0154426917,
-0.0209848154,
-0.0163601805,
-0.0136602446,
0.0233917907,
0.0349625684,
0.0286443997,
0.015756961,
-0.0190336406,
-0.0223193243,
-0.0145240622,
0.010925903,
-0.0529704429,
0.0038275393,
-0.0192202069,
0.0121553633,
-0.0219622198,
-0.0716801286,
-0.0043756263,
-0.0276802201,
0.0272451099,
-0.023725044,
0.0509248488,
0.0579716675,
0.0580016933,
-0.0079781506,
0.0117263841,
-0.0492541082,
-0.0261154417,
-0.030825058,
0.0077146366,
0.0275059007,
0.0741091743,
0.0349948332,
-0.0068001645,
0.0011122178,
-0.01085955,
-0.0573578142,
0.0830857381,
0.0141209224,
-0.014034017,
-0.0453374088,
-0.01411762,
-0.0050635198,
-0.0253781453,
0.002654481,
-0.0183972158,
0.0306075364,
0.0101349745,
-0.0078875897,
0.0492558703,
0.0098621733,
-0.0027994278,
-0.00273773,
0.0529022254,
-0.0341613442,
0.0023885451,
0.0214081965,
-0.01583267,
-0.0649934784,
0.0002886839,
-0.0069959848,
0.0694340467,
0.0092567988,
0.0320477113,
-0.0572415292,
-0.0480746701,
0.0319610424,
0.011808103,
0.0527841412,
-0.0045757745,
0.0276038479,
0.069432199,
-0.0082826475,
-0.0103482753,
-0.0460728258,
-0.0002384254,
-0.0656011328,
-0.0279741846,
-0.0235329289,
-6.225641426e-33,
-0.0160910785,
-0.0311027635,
-0.004966775,
0.0180526767,
0.0177566092,
0.0220249407,
0.0058539649,
-0.0055193058,
-0.0138335107,
0.0152857127,
-0.0004733422,
0.0105448207,
-0.0189676955,
0.0560645349,
0.0028768934,
-0.0208311845,
0.0170865823,
-0.0062121172,
-0.0188610125,
0.0205569323,
0.047243055,
-0.0125181489,
0.0299325045,
-0.0841812491,
0.0730015188,
-0.0119700544,
0.0006042686,
-0.0163409691,
-0.0102583393,
0.0155412387,
-0.036356315,
0.0939600766,
0.0695953965,
-0.0711899102,
0.0247923527,
0.0785735771,
-0.0402268246,
-0.1004986167,
0.0197654795,
0.0462889299,
-0.0281045679,
-0.0178026035,
0.0434724092,
-0.0205679983,
-0.0017297326,
-0.0275664646,
0.0702788904,
0.0151988175,
-0.0130845336,
-0.0370545574,
-0.0739103779,
0.0174434651,
-0.0382624492,
0.0158595182,
0.020173328,
0.0865320414,
-0.0175693519,
0.0302234292,
-0.0654897019,
0.0049966453,
-0.0106415981,
0.0110449903,
-0.0239532832,
0.0103804953,
-0.0018367863,
0.0482557677,
-0.0055827689,
-0.0312894732,
-0.0161078237,
-0.004825769,
0.0121365543,
-0.0338887945,
0.0365090258,
0.0719045699,
0.054913722,
-0.0409656651,
-0.07175266,
0.0509800911,
0.0610779561,
-0.0073255207,
0.0226562712,
-0.0264612138,
-0.0787851065,
-0.0377688594,
-0.0546765216,
-0.0229146518,
-0.0385201238,
-0.0275598802,
0.0198028293,
-0.0577885434,
-0.027322514,
-0.0073430417,
0.0034841625,
-0.0411404148,
-0.0048249681,
0.0009445639,
-0.0346495844,
0.0579977445,
-0.0004203698,
0.0039748782,
0.001041881,
-0.0218003001,
-0.0315146409,
0.0074991342,
0.0398162864,
-0.0147401206,
0.0401008613,
0.0156914592,
-0.0496193394,
-0.061325945,
-0.014310888,
-0.019915102,
0.0282285064,
0.0433365442,
-0.0070707211,
0.0467930362,
0.0003302964,
0.0241826549,
0.0412270986,
0.0233901106,
-0.001698793,
-0.059310507,
-0.0267968215,
-0.0117681641,
-0.0315650776,
-0.0613870993,
0.0066094869,
-0.0121577717,
0.0052562854,
-0.0542223416,
0.015787486,
0.0340396389,
2.83e-7,
0.0672280863,
0.0906108692,
-0.0415863059,
0.0147062084,
0.0095042298,
0.0503669754,
0.0401252583,
0.0046922332,
0.0200242698,
-0.0162299629,
0.0032534879,
-0.0067506121,
-0.0139426962,
0.0178368613,
-0.1017615423,
-0.0481497981,
0.0337225273,
0.0368205942,
-0.005125978,
0.0868249685,
0.1124305353,
0.0571519881,
0.0154631995,
-0.0041535422,
-0.041525539,
-0.0088592796,
-0.01040213,
-0.050812576,
0.0223633535,
0.0476266928,
0.0015978484,
-0.0138071533,
0.050706882,
0.0849142522,
-0.0067402455,
-0.0079343785,
0.007549305,
-0.0000802925,
0.0233733896,
-0.0428856872,
-0.0000915489,
-0.0164340436,
0.0143880434,
-0.0404517278,
0.0789732859,
-0.0428855047,
-0.0613686666,
-0.0281015933,
-0.0053964579,
-0.0250748191,
0.0336876214,
0.0328145027,
-0.0234616604,
0.0103705889,
-0.0205428544,
-0.0334792919,
-0.0094229346,
-0.0504062288,
0.0026294689,
0.0198211391,
-0.0110796839,
-0.0244415328,
-0.0326736383,
-0.0070566498,
0.0651904568,
-0.08380799,
-0.0068221693,
2.43071982e-34,
0.0100398958,
-0.0070965583,
0.0122257536,
-0.0014844274,
0.0206655022,
0.0004363056,
-0.0233984478,
-0.0005293851,
0.0394648723,
-0.0784594789,
0.0231719092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00969v1 | SPARQL Generation with Entity Pre-trained GPT for KG Question Answering | 2024-02-01T19:38:32 | 2024-02-01T19:38:32 | Diego Bustamante, Hideaki Takeda | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, 68P20, 68T50, H.2.3; H.3.3; I.2.7 | Knowledge Graphs popularity has been rapidly growing in last years. All that
knowledge is available for people to query it through the many online databases
on the internet. Though, it would be a great achievement if non-programmer
users could access whatever information they want to know. There has been a lot
of effort oriented to solve this task using natural language processing tools
and creativity encouragement by way of many challenges. Our approach focuses on
assuming a correct entity linking on the natural language questions and
training a GPT model to create SPARQL queries from them. We managed to isolate
which property of the task can be the most difficult to solve at few or
zero-shot and we proposed pre-training on all entities (under CWA) to improve
the performance. We obtained a 62.703% accuracy of exact SPARQL matches on
testing at 3-shots, a F1 of 0.809 on the entity linking challenge and a F1 of
0.009 on the question answering challenge. | [
0.0738215894,
0.0352768786,
0.0144542139,
0.0107837608,
-0.0103955884,
0.0302895773,
-0.0439535752,
-0.0036051637,
0.0431983359,
-0.0473703369,
0.008543889,
0.0182876103,
-0.0534593128,
0.0289198719,
0.0233764201,
-0.0308523811,
0.0156399272,
0.0337392539,
-0.0118258437,
-0.0049874973,
0.010016771,
0.072850287,
-0.0367439613,
0.0037243108,
-0.0410288647,
-0.0110176839,
-0.0301624276,
0.0206237342,
-0.0108306771,
-0.0269492734,
0.0027791995,
0.0607978888,
0.0158537608,
0.0176408179,
0.0000018847,
-0.0677138343,
-0.0378251486,
0.0223679245,
-0.0553842373,
-0.0462078564,
-0.0492694192,
0.0042446605,
0.0405003838,
0.0348746739,
-0.062891759,
-0.0483803302,
0.0293559842,
0.0660328567,
0.0498487167,
0.0685541034,
-0.0108705182,
-0.0497160703,
0.0078736069,
-0.0045525031,
0.0531832241,
-0.0654457584,
-0.0017598538,
0.0068777259,
0.019982053,
-0.0025609755,
-0.0090768626,
-0.0055233017,
0.0134664401,
0.0402175896,
0.0051984098,
0.0052898405,
-0.0543026552,
0.0327066854,
0.0002931621,
0.0853620619,
0.0164668914,
-0.0150321601,
0.0196523387,
0.0157113224,
-0.0251778476,
0.007349378,
-0.0028228769,
-0.0271849502,
-0.0161548667,
-0.0017848427,
-0.0267322697,
-0.0135706905,
-0.009505704,
-0.0071827793,
-0.0286814068,
0.0745908841,
0.0325205922,
-0.0289884135,
0.0201815795,
0.0294963811,
-0.026302848,
-0.034347754,
0.0017204747,
0.0263570901,
-0.0185124446,
0.0387370624,
-0.0534488745,
0.0072824233,
0.0167255662,
0.0067147319,
-0.0213962849,
0.0281412527,
0.0631755069,
0.046547737,
-0.0372318141,
0.0306823384,
-0.0013975981,
0.0106923375,
-0.0236454848,
-0.0502239317,
-0.0984785259,
-0.0059857271,
-0.0910121724,
0.0517317913,
-0.0286085121,
-0.0347530469,
-0.0299601257,
0.0366670154,
0.0366957337,
-0.0005351447,
0.0505033955,
0.0365938917,
-0.0143262194,
-0.0149301374,
-0.072271876,
0.0173812453,
-0.0461655408,
-0.0197049864,
-0.0356142223,
-0.0499897487,
-0.0065529835,
-0.0075534526,
0.0340495557,
-0.0675562918,
0.0094657484,
0.0360118635,
0.0102690943,
-0.0241127685,
-0.078844972,
-0.0672138631,
0.0401464924,
-0.0444021933,
-0.0167769901,
-0.0349165723,
0.0519906469,
0.0020539728,
-0.001404581,
-0.0456398353,
0.0176508855,
0.0290293489,
-0.0503564365,
0.0671598613,
-0.0768091604,
0.0078121182,
0.0064323363,
-0.0040956531,
0.0237569679,
0.079155609,
0.000532178,
-0.0255929716,
0.0390489101,
0.0091170762,
-0.0418658592,
0.0081646387,
0.0551052205,
-0.0115210824,
0.044402238,
0.0522993766,
-0.0349006988,
0.0283547137,
0.0097315032,
0.0476457104,
-0.0142889749,
-0.0107589168,
0.0052320883,
0.0490797497,
0.0081784185,
0.0320039503,
0.0390908793,
0.0320984311,
0.0033902414,
0.0068881135,
-0.0411228687,
0.0271061957,
-0.0305206161,
0.0173848365,
0.004872581,
0.0389113761,
-0.034615498,
0.0079239225,
0.0085794618,
0.0351670757,
-0.0212762356,
0.0322353542,
0.0369737372,
0.0340771899,
-0.0582244135,
0.084533684,
-0.0014810539,
-0.0282920524,
0.0069070426,
-0.0213703588,
0.0008273656,
0.0321041942,
0.0476719812,
0.006614327,
-0.0727476999,
0.0040700207,
-0.0250799954,
0.0330922306,
0.0104220267,
-0.0036874444,
0.0001058206,
-0.0195637755,
-0.0457434841,
0.0141249532,
0.0051494851,
-0.0026377395,
0.0605157577,
0.063281469,
0.0547357015,
-0.0327669419,
0.051040981,
0.030024562,
0.0001918696,
-0.0393726528,
-0.0045283167,
0.008774871,
0.0119596105,
0.0440521576,
0.0007686139,
0.0194892772,
0.0064988378,
0.0026757831,
-0.0346602984,
-0.0008933868,
0.0344043784,
-0.0639209673,
0.0340932123,
-0.0430649109,
-0.007776062,
0.005257695,
-0.0442725047,
-0.0484571047,
0.0043630055,
-0.0154595971,
0.0427959077,
-0.0437897556,
-0.035451293,
0.061980322,
-0.0465578027,
-0.0281248763,
0.0460834987,
0.028179599,
0.0306108203,
-0.0379087478,
0.0045737769,
0.0419411175,
-0.0700589269,
-0.0254206173,
-0.0192672443,
-0.003160455,
0.0152154397,
0.0010864318,
0.014154885,
-0.1057891473,
0.0137531022,
-0.0937892795,
0.0376164392,
-0.0101126302,
0.0382001661,
0.0267462339,
0.0077844658,
-0.0313399844,
-0.0244466234,
-0.0795128867,
0.0057159332,
0.0197743401,
0.019918751,
0.021028826,
0.0169485435,
0.0218787249,
-0.0085221892,
-0.0017374166,
-0.0287415348,
0.0157206301,
0.0323588289,
0.0196149573,
0.0028647392,
0.0389943346,
-0.0645583197,
0.0139484992,
0.0380391106,
-0.0023595013,
0.0050876462,
-0.0251876377,
0.0038227513,
0.0117573049,
-0.0084943306,
-0.0003316363,
-0.0448933542,
-0.0265729781,
-0.0412637442,
0.037083853,
-0.0301849674,
-0.0023111065,
-0.0011298938,
0.0068320772,
0.0731820539,
0.0140604153,
0.0068486431,
-0.0380474553,
-0.0678721145,
0.0623154044,
0.000830674,
0.0218182914,
-0.0470465496,
0.0317698903,
0.0417204536,
0.0106552439,
-0.0127326287,
0.0114263566,
0.0571741872,
-0.0035871333,
0.0204611607,
-0.044244092,
0.0190493781,
-0.0320170373,
0.0397654101,
0.0119061088,
0.0350524783,
-0.0213752184,
-0.0369846746,
-0.0381107032,
0.0120063843,
0.0254136175,
-0.0066785295,
0.0011744878,
-0.0010285841,
0.0421715491,
0.0197818018,
-0.0038880885,
-0.0258413311,
0.0050850459,
-0.0204112865,
0.0081638806,
0.0244284756,
0.0165012833,
0.0165002495,
0.0205955803,
-0.0302608218,
-0.0172410849,
-0.0074027041,
-0.0356692448,
-0.0068965699,
0.0614906102,
0.0997832268,
-0.0062426208,
-0.0309316833,
0.0330334641,
-0.0398109518,
0.0565084629,
0.0605260357,
-0.050199423,
0.0222696178,
0.032953348,
0.0103021385,
-0.0957645103,
0.0012275712,
-0.0131068388,
0.0091826115,
-0.0238819066,
0.0086403992,
0.1077614054,
0.0498047769,
0.0206205565,
-0.0287230499,
0.0293705259,
0.0282457788,
0.0208014771,
0.0576337799,
-0.12831752,
-0.0461161025,
-0.0391490571,
0.0257906113,
-0.0070993928,
-0.0831908658,
-0.014346065,
-0.1371567398,
0.0013448399,
-0.0303521082,
-0.0507664979,
-0.0331913903,
-0.0317101963,
-0.0373060256,
-0.0421090685,
-0.0319608748,
0.0243494883,
-0.0160413794,
0.0424462706,
0.0190165043,
0.0208980553,
-0.0222257208,
0.0367904752,
-0.0706024468,
0.0203113705,
0.0352528393,
0.0282061249,
0.0057165888,
-0.012765578,
-0.068581149,
-0.023162771,
-0.0089208288,
-0.0179231353,
0.0646826327,
-0.0429744497,
-0.0185662229,
-0.0349387489,
-0.0011473862,
-0.0550782643,
0.0246680379,
0.0041264123,
0.0689934492,
0.0058253678,
0.0087796776,
-0.012101898,
-0.0202741437,
-0.0056274133,
0.0606573522,
-0.0052219662,
0.0132053792,
-0.0760817453,
-0.0147047434,
0.0253869612,
-0.041809503,
-0.0326430202,
0.0325404145,
-0.0172422547,
-0.0070770518,
-0.0579661094,
-0.0614421777,
0.0772115737,
0.0738488063,
-0.0227245819,
0.0089383032,
-0.0330136791,
0.0451777205,
-0.0528886728,
0.0344948657,
-0.0342958346,
-0.006397686,
-0.0600314252,
-0.0101406481,
0.0329015777,
-0.005071213,
-0.0378101058,
0.0054066363,
-0.0596657768,
-0.0419206321,
-0.0455134511,
0.0482924841,
0.0210358724,
0.0033259396,
-0.0307747815,
-0.0119561069,
0.0232499279,
0.0296383593,
-0.0668331087,
-0.0215759352,
-0.0095133632,
-0.0022788909,
-0.0104934908,
0.0361992568,
-0.0568953939,
-0.0069067408,
-0.02341621,
0.084127821,
-0.0220251512,
-0.0535615832,
0.065493159,
0.0711469054,
-0.0062444657,
0.0267345048,
0.027847914,
-0.0251703709,
0.0117252385,
0.0035894001,
-0.0037565723,
-0.0461448096,
0.0029310917,
0.015827015,
-0.0086017698,
-0.0132732112,
-0.0289061554,
-0.0256066993,
0.0402877852,
-0.0187949687,
-0.0523060225,
0.0430209823,
-0.0214352813,
0.036306303,
-0.0179609396,
-0.0147695299,
0.006240428,
0.0320717022,
0.0285096206,
-0.0217594933,
0.0493653864,
0.0120538296,
0.0003421365,
-0.0139488569,
0.000980504,
-0.0246430431,
-0.0596380346,
-0.0407091081,
-0.0022729305,
0.0604816005,
-0.005739253,
0.0215503685,
-0.01215884,
-0.0101917246,
0.0095028877,
0.010626697,
0.0031063296,
0.0143071953,
0.0563075021,
0.0266783647,
-0.0053676488,
-0.027185794,
0.0876996964,
0.0437476523,
0.066611439,
0.0331318378,
-0.065437533,
-0.0264485124,
-0.036682561,
0.0300821401,
-0.0123921521,
0.0027190037,
0.020874979,
-0.0382237546,
-0.0880544186,
0.0007653576,
0.0001799367,
-0.0116628679,
0.0173279773,
0.0853418484,
0.0548739396,
0.0303822327,
-0.0405377671,
-0.0162987262,
-0.0197005942,
-0.0320715122,
-0.0239252336,
0.0038693638,
-6.282753554e-33,
-0.0339605026,
-0.0357375853,
0.0380517766,
-0.00950698,
-0.0111638717,
-0.0436318144,
0.0106460005,
-0.013558872,
-0.0398792177,
0.0026665279,
-0.0065902718,
0.0085517531,
0.0045703063,
0.0156359691,
-0.0213945732,
-0.0283332169,
0.0098492587,
-0.0125305131,
0.0349895544,
0.0187700447,
0.0398070998,
0.0448499583,
0.0345146395,
0.0060376949,
-0.0048260717,
-0.0122440867,
0.0008870183,
0.0258980058,
0.0149427829,
0.0500258319,
-0.0137684494,
0.0210445505,
0.0212343223,
-0.0192756616,
0.0162733737,
-0.0513096526,
-0.101344876,
-0.0724575073,
0.0036948447,
0.0127853425,
-0.007533784,
-0.0007154475,
0.029116001,
-0.0280570369,
0.0413210876,
-0.0197548755,
0.0349702314,
0.0265568271,
-0.0005414812,
-0.0867578015,
-0.0355019905,
0.019308988,
-0.0070241755,
0.0163313411,
-0.0229243748,
-0.0211385489,
0.0073934058,
-0.0131088691,
-0.0427209064,
-0.0064034783,
0.0242748838,
0.0089930454,
0.0020966858,
-0.0392526537,
0.0196639374,
-0.0019727163,
-0.0180715024,
-0.0320746563,
-0.019754177,
0.0455905721,
-0.0111854011,
0.0291194692,
0.014248129,
0.045659475,
0.0679160804,
0.0014971355,
-0.0704929307,
0.0405574329,
-0.024802763,
0.0331357606,
-0.0413814373,
-0.0221682228,
-0.0389876366,
-0.0198456105,
-0.0397094972,
0.0248003136,
-0.0458001532,
-0.0639102012,
0.047876589,
-0.0136825442,
0.002709771,
0.0140722878,
-0.0024051499,
-0.0234510601,
-0.0031152943,
0.0451729335,
0.0048381449,
-0.0313768759,
-0.0105203204,
0.0394958071,
-0.0624569207,
0.0062639611,
0.0243740678,
-0.0304567385,
-0.0196484737,
0.0089645749,
-0.0280855987,
-0.0014464979,
-0.0620559044,
0.0011033234,
-0.0069016456,
0.038362544,
-0.015631279,
0.0033595089,
0.0112350145,
0.0223776922,
0.0086278468,
0.019494487,
0.029241683,
-0.0222388934,
-0.017547965,
0.0172870941,
0.039093405,
0.001848179,
0.0048827063,
0.0077765197,
-0.0171984527,
-0.0210610516,
-0.0250046756,
-0.0537516996,
-0.0198097564,
0.0010812123,
2.632e-7,
0.0427389592,
0.0044805259,
0.0331413671,
0.0700039193,
-0.033886455,
-0.0083658257,
0.0295856185,
0.0627396628,
0.0193939134,
-0.0000204484,
0.0156314149,
0.021082852,
-0.0182222519,
0.0641092211,
-0.1046151072,
0.0072867619,
-0.0042015836,
-0.039363008,
-0.0529579371,
-0.0171716809,
0.0805310607,
0.032154873,
0.0162658263,
0.0066528944,
-0.0131920213,
-0.0523170307,
0.0472514555,
0.0311847683,
-0.0035146158,
0.0386244729,
0.0430567414,
0.0050763669,
-0.0079174656,
0.0490502603,
-0.0185137317,
0.016416382,
0.0201690234,
0.0259374585,
-0.0260216799,
-0.0330278836,
0.0172938537,
-0.0587281436,
0.0182635505,
-0.0308925286,
0.1025783494,
-0.0445017442,
0.0064561339,
0.1019520611,
-0.0452060662,
-0.0446795486,
0.0052231504,
-0.04401711,
-0.0160657428,
0.0102374507,
0.0480988808,
0.0093714055,
0.0197603498,
-0.0613437742,
0.0412585884,
0.0315566622,
-0.0079345051,
-0.025149148,
0.009886235,
-0.0215413831,
0.0127245691,
0.0012978248,
-0.0038870615,
2.340367927e-34,
0.0104088178,
0.0401314013,
0.0261848699,
0.0251795966,
0.058838442,
-0.0064891661,
0.010951235,
-0.0107610496,
0.0341078788,
-0.0743324012,
-0.0066905045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00956v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00956v2 | Exploring Spatial Schema Intuitions in Large Language and Vision Models | 2024-02-01T19:25:50 | 2024-05-27T14:29:31 | Philipp Wicke, Lennart Wachowiak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the ubiquity of large language models (LLMs) in AI research, the
question of embodiment in LLMs remains underexplored, distinguishing them from
embodied systems in robotics where sensory perception directly informs physical
action. Our investigation navigates the intriguing terrain of whether LLMs,
despite their non-embodied nature, effectively capture implicit human
intuitions about fundamental, spatial building blocks of language. We employ
insights from spatial cognitive foundations developed through early
sensorimotor experiences, guiding our exploration through the reproduction of
three psycholinguistic experiments. Surprisingly, correlations between model
outputs and human responses emerge, revealing adaptability without a tangible
connection to embodied experiences. Notable distinctions include polarized
language model responses and reduced correlations in vision language models.
This research contributes to a nuanced understanding of the interplay between
language, spatial experiences, and the computations made by large language
models. More at https://cisnlp.github.io/Spatial_Schemas/ | [
0.0233351309,
0.0329130962,
-0.056943588,
0.0255271215,
-0.0405640937,
0.0174511354,
-0.0155261206,
0.0030488647,
0.011330354,
-0.0666136593,
-0.0665311515,
-0.022763066,
0.0595853701,
0.019325491,
0.0380322896,
-0.0713060796,
-0.0061620935,
-0.0565654933,
-0.0359436348,
0.0052871439,
-0.0445400104,
-0.0094108572,
-0.0152518107,
0.041345235,
-0.0100521864,
0.0341749936,
-0.0240932424,
-0.0176264681,
-0.0278773848,
-0.0253660511,
-0.0563965775,
-0.0284709111,
0.0597619973,
0.010610099,
0.0000017585,
-0.0219038334,
0.0449659824,
0.0030432947,
0.037650723,
-0.0004858965,
0.0282591153,
-0.0543667153,
0.0099843377,
-0.0291312635,
-0.0403364338,
-0.0356905237,
0.0819657296,
-0.0042904592,
-0.034497086,
0.0106523037,
-0.0209770445,
-0.0433128588,
0.0030442423,
0.0050989096,
-0.006972082,
0.069734104,
0.0136307282,
0.0121243307,
0.0286895819,
0.0383199304,
-0.0847392306,
0.0042971065,
0.0326932669,
0.0404607058,
-0.0314832143,
0.0613178052,
0.001153898,
-0.0329516008,
0.0092327204,
0.042196624,
0.0020339533,
-0.0392694883,
0.0131441187,
0.008776539,
-0.0072585139,
0.0077343625,
-0.0376518667,
0.0493922345,
0.023501087,
0.0428406037,
-0.0506524593,
-0.0209549628,
-0.002886896,
-0.0079878811,
-0.0306328963,
0.0961674899,
0.014427647,
0.013142596,
-0.0309828892,
0.0064263474,
0.0001596299,
-0.0586469024,
-0.0157586467,
0.0394636914,
0.0077311229,
0.0132208839,
0.0016439871,
0.0522713028,
-0.0164273903,
-0.0458987504,
0.0888454467,
0.0299805701,
-0.0117764315,
0.0210417863,
-0.0315134786,
0.0927577913,
-0.0300430376,
0.0779578164,
-0.0396582745,
0.0234679151,
-0.0108230598,
-0.0132184383,
-0.0092235785,
0.0297146011,
-0.0310661886,
-0.0463948101,
0.01694954,
0.0502658859,
0.0037560768,
0.0012625586,
-0.0532825738,
0.0300464462,
0.0216967333,
0.0009505749,
-0.0255963877,
-0.0084915562,
0.0109081669,
0.0593896136,
-0.0643692836,
-0.0601942576,
0.0016280562,
0.0568594113,
-0.0238232184,
-0.0282913763,
-0.0392379537,
0.056353461,
0.0605172031,
-0.028823249,
0.0284368377,
0.0104050776,
-0.0221777707,
0.0008563236,
0.0472760908,
-0.0243220665,
-0.0157097876,
0.0248268042,
-0.0158862695,
-0.0730612203,
-0.0084088547,
-0.0156716853,
-0.0168594941,
0.0602761172,
0.0143881654,
0.0277751945,
0.0197954532,
-0.0071749482,
0.0277456064,
0.0344735757,
0.072582379,
0.0445795134,
-0.0148967467,
-0.0017501853,
0.029132301,
0.00849286,
-0.0215331875,
0.0184256714,
-0.0816590935,
-0.0112592224,
0.0209078006,
0.0385123082,
0.0268914159,
0.0628597364,
-0.0043708608,
-0.0022195417,
0.0677538887,
0.1067554876,
-0.0423573777,
-0.0205898844,
0.0419097878,
-0.0157815721,
-0.0118415328,
-0.0132868076,
-0.0440001935,
0.0218565837,
0.0345419459,
-0.0043406244,
-0.0307055674,
0.0163702779,
-0.0284753088,
-0.0152420728,
-0.0358034968,
0.0050441762,
0.0212414805,
0.0056052888,
0.0311623309,
0.0110424943,
0.0090665985,
-0.0020055878,
0.0003773351,
-0.0254936926,
-0.0204211827,
-0.0240411889,
0.0086104916,
-0.0052750139,
-0.0097537423,
-0.0043624463,
0.0149724279,
0.0177490711,
0.029474495,
0.0642778203,
0.054576952,
0.01482624,
0.0012696175,
0.0173473023,
-0.003679188,
0.0031212969,
0.0297905151,
0.0229452271,
-0.0126775829,
0.0053796028,
0.0020343682,
-0.0458680727,
-0.0292845611,
0.0427782647,
-0.0287366975,
0.004307372,
-0.0604247339,
0.0082411701,
-0.0144722015,
-0.0370459706,
-0.0311903078,
0.0519540161,
0.0237320792,
-0.0305822548,
0.0197331589,
0.093023777,
-0.0246811509,
0.0310898963,
0.026506003,
-0.0192098562,
0.0507471003,
0.0046910839,
0.0205940139,
-0.0087058498,
0.0533987619,
-0.0619706623,
0.0700755268,
0.0004279281,
0.0027811348,
-0.0264524724,
0.001504369,
-0.0483526997,
0.0204552952,
-0.0028176112,
-0.0039398409,
-0.0101644797,
0.0072699022,
0.0413542949,
0.0007890488,
0.0077886092,
0.0328953303,
0.0161126703,
0.0126531115,
-0.0021006428,
-0.0360159911,
-0.0551772267,
-0.0257427823,
-0.0588972531,
-0.0393719189,
0.0163121819,
-0.0058849878,
0.0089483587,
-0.0691498667,
-0.0239436217,
-0.019767927,
0.005373572,
0.001607148,
-0.0085511403,
0.0428489894,
0.0371408276,
-0.0269775987,
-0.0381458029,
-0.0281270146,
0.0003086939,
-0.027252689,
0.0454951152,
0.0177611373,
-0.0079157762,
-0.0509335771,
0.0241205059,
-0.0249917377,
0.0140355527,
0.0062192511,
-0.0162708759,
0.0660139471,
-0.0293763354,
-0.0088243997,
0.066871658,
-0.0312081128,
0.0775793269,
0.0854857489,
-0.0369121321,
-0.021134736,
-0.0527428053,
-0.0268497411,
0.012139624,
-0.0169698149,
-0.038582854,
-0.0134210773,
0.0689744651,
0.0110379932,
-0.0040734494,
-0.0479782447,
0.0634450391,
-0.058024738,
-0.0556214415,
-0.0143398978,
0.0010069327,
-0.0306095891,
0.0579077117,
-0.0526567288,
-0.0538405031,
-0.0024279477,
-0.0462457649,
0.0157408826,
0.0244153403,
0.0472566672,
-0.0020668961,
0.140071854,
0.0474878028,
0.0038831134,
0.002469545,
-0.0048986818,
-0.0241763592,
-0.0324200727,
-0.0300655756,
-0.0163027588,
-0.0193463508,
-0.1002574041,
0.0057959943,
-0.0050192084,
-0.0218840614,
-0.0160830244,
0.0298748836,
-0.0475523323,
0.0234880932,
-0.0218940396,
-0.0410917215,
0.0166581832,
0.0451811738,
0.067224741,
0.0334292836,
-0.0132066617,
-0.0084938481,
-0.0328029022,
-0.0084732715,
0.0597263612,
0.0863460973,
-0.0058759172,
-0.0024842606,
-0.0296979751,
0.0149620352,
-0.0140399346,
0.0483406037,
-0.056660004,
0.0487524308,
0.0457302853,
0.0306991823,
-0.0382566974,
0.0145002753,
0.0708246008,
-0.0276496895,
-0.0519597866,
0.0463781357,
0.0434273072,
0.0010844342,
0.0304917879,
-0.0349217132,
0.0149390036,
0.0554664731,
-0.0039136661,
-0.0102942465,
0.0183167979,
0.0126475999,
-0.0593647286,
0.0056118346,
-0.0463898741,
0.0006502036,
-0.1196158975,
0.0274448935,
0.0016207118,
-0.108164005,
-0.0649331361,
-0.0206782054,
0.0282559562,
0.0532136783,
-0.0268250983,
-0.0003923778,
-0.0125789214,
0.0338420793,
0.0152682289,
-0.0002731358,
0.0233442299,
-0.0185961332,
-0.0230614208,
0.0240157843,
0.0252970979,
0.0516477041,
-0.0181481317,
-0.0465118438,
0.0092377178,
0.0030769564,
0.0365569517,
0.005872095,
-0.0105750626,
0.0466088392,
-0.0102348542,
0.0098016243,
-0.0003572523,
-0.0539979003,
-0.0291588847,
-0.033540681,
0.0361926071,
-0.073596105,
-0.004621807,
-0.0119326077,
0.0286677461,
-0.0263714567,
0.0227871295,
0.0560122654,
-0.0411488898,
-0.045637697,
-0.0149283977,
-0.0038326308,
0.0549367927,
-0.0896700993,
0.0303446539,
0.0506171845,
0.008636781,
-0.0563682355,
-0.0237938706,
0.0238406062,
0.0423252024,
0.049983874,
-0.032799121,
-0.0158985965,
-0.0474571399,
-0.0430947132,
0.0471190475,
-0.0221784171,
0.0038194763,
0.0201517008,
0.0248902254,
0.0271192323,
-0.0778097287,
-0.0049829618,
-0.0016437094,
-0.0248378441,
-0.0586489439,
0.0281600785,
0.0353966653,
0.0258789584,
0.0107266037,
0.0201978404,
-0.0047125178,
0.0321646929,
0.0178773496,
0.0112957107,
0.1064170599,
-0.0165219288,
0.0247167293,
0.0230503473,
0.0213683043,
0.0021547324,
-0.0049048415,
0.0346307009,
-0.0050501199,
0.0032471123,
-0.0055416017,
0.0104176896,
-0.0150497127,
0.0659483597,
-0.0029364761,
-0.0125842076,
-0.0051994147,
-0.048457399,
-0.0306289885,
0.0121410666,
-0.0293458011,
-0.0180691145,
0.0294185411,
0.0443010554,
-0.0132636176,
-0.0065536886,
-0.0021420547,
0.0556049496,
0.0486696549,
-0.0210348032,
0.0138902077,
-0.0084789386,
0.0015676717,
0.0532656163,
0.0021617657,
0.0538460054,
-0.0919344053,
0.0438757651,
0.0235227067,
-0.0211863723,
0.0335557945,
-0.0367029049,
-0.0451659076,
0.0297138952,
-0.0257922821,
-0.1053482294,
0.0189612694,
0.019765377,
0.0459954888,
-0.0585889518,
0.0309219174,
-0.0681521297,
0.0188269969,
-0.0025632787,
0.0022068985,
0.0301808733,
-0.0188515466,
0.0301116798,
0.0137540083,
-0.0283375103,
0.0022594086,
0.017645238,
-0.0193269029,
0.0371761471,
0.0208209977,
-0.011255933,
-0.0017823795,
-0.0034683426,
0.0315370709,
-0.0161980018,
-0.0117695862,
0.0246268064,
-0.0540144965,
-0.0562712513,
0.0042613018,
0.0287718605,
-0.0046103494,
-0.0078321807,
0.0601194911,
0.0248890463,
0.0009942487,
0.0009511365,
-0.0188230667,
0.0060722949,
0.0039491961,
-0.01814886,
0.0075506158,
-5.25150889e-33,
-0.0245106593,
-0.0554997325,
0.0293471795,
-0.009635753,
-0.0209480245,
0.0037324643,
-0.0511930659,
0.0325935818,
-0.0400305502,
0.010143551,
0.0226233359,
-0.0100371009,
-0.003558977,
0.0115328077,
0.0495742224,
0.0298985448,
-0.01910799,
-0.0296838097,
-0.0140572097,
-0.041986607,
0.0417783037,
-0.0338062383,
0.0215578116,
-0.0669103414,
0.0003929252,
0.0609094612,
-0.0042614383,
0.014445032,
-0.0209136475,
0.0201319326,
-0.063473627,
0.0244242512,
0.0341632292,
0.0164783671,
-0.0131174754,
0.0308748242,
-0.0052618044,
-0.0454390496,
0.0198019315,
0.0453253016,
-0.0532633103,
-0.0191623289,
0.0566363893,
-0.0432148799,
-0.0484382398,
0.028044099,
0.0173872523,
-0.0385772102,
-0.0298502408,
0.0515120886,
-0.0520079769,
-0.0188909359,
0.0187924132,
-0.036258053,
0.0340110287,
-0.0268806368,
0.0065876977,
0.0430081449,
-0.0312171057,
0.0388661362,
-0.0381477624,
0.0168166142,
0.0419047996,
0.028286675,
0.0655207932,
0.0878014863,
0.0845995843,
0.0129321627,
-0.0353030413,
-0.0373116583,
0.0904398933,
0.0030989007,
-0.0106260767,
0.0259294771,
-0.0319597721,
-0.0115867732,
-0.0046568369,
-0.032170102,
-0.0476393178,
0.0263480581,
0.0330926329,
0.0023706197,
-0.0256738812,
-0.0121172052,
-0.0321492292,
-0.0640035793,
-0.0173822939,
0.0179393254,
0.0030620338,
-0.0320767872,
0.0597049147,
0.0019274415,
0.0245519727,
-0.0520082191,
-0.0402880795,
-0.0401495919,
-0.0501383804,
0.0332811996,
0.0078764539,
0.0251178928,
0.003306376,
-0.0301239286,
-0.0123459911,
0.0485357456,
-0.0029524614,
0.0298195146,
-0.0139317177,
0.0404250771,
-0.0104188444,
-0.0311505198,
-0.0284913778,
-0.0844713151,
0.0389201604,
-0.0252051987,
0.0411529467,
0.0205290634,
-0.0289152153,
0.0039311405,
-0.0063731694,
-0.0058771209,
-0.0096370876,
0.0061676558,
-0.082769312,
0.0223161653,
-0.0290076286,
-0.0271294918,
-0.0469047651,
0.0101777771,
0.0659256577,
-0.0419376865,
-0.0314366184,
-0.0419350639,
2.679e-7,
0.0357631519,
0.0569957346,
0.0257210582,
-0.0166233629,
0.0490931608,
0.0132015292,
-0.0043474077,
0.0273528863,
-0.0292356238,
-0.0242851134,
-0.0011800895,
0.047150176,
0.0184425898,
-0.0287226662,
-0.0536833555,
0.0679832399,
-0.0090691363,
-0.0069946558,
-0.0416536033,
0.038899038,
0.0087313317,
0.0205515753,
-0.0063370522,
-0.0087202871,
-0.0275795478,
-0.0019784544,
0.0306793414,
-0.089186281,
0.0700242445,
-0.0406677425,
-0.0109939631,
-0.0328208171,
-0.0059463484,
-0.0001372635,
0.0284344964,
-0.0238013882,
0.0107814306,
0.0108890384,
-0.0298128203,
-0.0008462479,
-0.0013771987,
-0.015074715,
-0.0316534489,
-0.0905707553,
0.0502693243,
-0.1017524078,
-0.0218620319,
0.0074775466,
0.0251308847,
0.001267793,
0.0224337559,
0.0136471372,
-0.0010843255,
-0.022529982,
0.0113596786,
-0.008730635,
-0.0218416434,
-0.029242292,
-0.0266062152,
0.015967017,
-0.0529209226,
-0.026673466,
-0.0322218761,
-0.0159809534,
0.0120251663,
-0.048172038,
-0.0398999788,
1.978580153e-34,
-0.0013936857,
0.0289354585,
0.0191587787,
-0.0164310131,
0.0086464882,
-0.0193090569,
0.0323165841,
0.0206929427,
0.0272323992,
-0.0462610722,
-0.0176386535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01781v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01781v2 | When Benchmarks are Targets: Revealing the Sensitivity of Large Language Model Leaderboards | 2024-02-01T19:12:25 | 2024-07-03T11:20:43 | Norah Alzahrani, Hisham Abdullah Alyahya, Yazeed Alnumay, Sultan Alrashed, Shaykhah Alsubaie, Yusef Almushaykeh, Faisal Mirza, Nouf Alotaibi, Nora Altwairesh, Areeb Alowisheq, M Saiful Bari, Haidar Khan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Model (LLM) leaderboards based on benchmark rankings are
regularly used to guide practitioners in model selection. Often, the published
leaderboard rankings are taken at face value - we show this is a (potentially
costly) mistake. Under existing leaderboards, the relative performance of LLMs
is highly sensitive to (often minute) details. We show that for popular
multiple-choice question benchmarks (e.g., MMLU), minor perturbations to the
benchmark, such as changing the order of choices or the method of answer
selection, result in changes in rankings up to 8 positions. We explain this
phenomenon by conducting systematic experiments over three broad categories of
benchmark perturbations and identifying the sources of this behavior. Our
analysis results in several best-practice recommendations, including the
advantage of a hybrid scoring method for answer selection. Our study highlights
the dangers of relying on simple benchmark evaluations and charts the path for
more robust evaluation schemes on the existing benchmarks. The code for this
paper is available at
https://github.com/National-Center-for-AI-Saudi-Arabia/lm-evaluation-harness. | [
0.0169463214,
0.077660501,
-0.0172421616,
0.0556237809,
-0.03351276,
0.0085482523,
0.0129249291,
0.0150855863,
0.0189844873,
-0.0439954139,
-0.0261818971,
-0.0266867634,
0.0078961505,
-0.0192707703,
0.0469734445,
-0.0095312344,
0.042260997,
-0.0465841107,
0.0005373777,
-0.0301504619,
-0.038846232,
-0.0191290416,
0.0013428337,
0.012473735,
0.0483494513,
0.0061456435,
0.0197746493,
-0.013961901,
0.0094144335,
-0.0478296205,
-0.0296183657,
0.0584047064,
-0.0199561846,
0.0198546294,
0.0000020952,
-0.0622913502,
-0.0108202361,
-0.0132217128,
-0.0281580295,
0.0605701432,
-0.0232106037,
0.0527178086,
0.0009112495,
0.0073363185,
-0.0399363376,
0.0177855324,
0.0061908108,
-0.0273849182,
0.0432463959,
0.0325283632,
0.0201426949,
0.0071481005,
0.0192932189,
-0.0252436064,
-0.0000599909,
-0.0496543758,
0.0213298053,
0.028586667,
0.0225583576,
0.0160658676,
-0.0494929999,
0.0116579868,
-0.0015678167,
0.0082500642,
0.016203111,
0.0411213338,
-0.0550292805,
0.0107370391,
0.0251838937,
0.0877155066,
-0.046870444,
-0.0031291116,
-0.000803059,
-0.0163621642,
0.0079106474,
0.0112330057,
-0.0744591355,
0.0087724691,
0.0245774332,
-0.0144219007,
0.0468063504,
0.0031167446,
0.0314922407,
0.0205246806,
-0.05190764,
0.096416004,
0.0326294936,
-0.0420405678,
0.0378066339,
-0.0011929274,
-0.0402067192,
-0.059853524,
0.0100370226,
0.0023349749,
-0.0525872521,
0.0258053653,
0.014166397,
0.0155498534,
0.0277254339,
-0.0418661907,
0.0600089245,
0.0220644586,
0.0117500918,
0.0502853021,
-0.0249161497,
0.1111063957,
0.0099805128,
0.0419950783,
-0.0630315617,
0.0268604588,
0.0004071121,
-0.0023498351,
0.0472272448,
0.0282847099,
0.0003261775,
0.0066570831,
-0.0613067076,
-0.0033745,
-0.0239539407,
0.0222959183,
0.0014962679,
-0.0093908394,
0.0185868479,
0.0381822363,
-0.030331051,
0.0290469788,
-0.037837714,
-0.0000246505,
0.0064426796,
-0.0606673211,
0.009409395,
0.0026884628,
-0.0198940262,
-0.0286952816,
0.0394191444,
0.0572808608,
-0.0147480415,
-0.0071720127,
0.0626245588,
0.0001055812,
-0.0175995938,
-0.0514526591,
0.0169647634,
-0.0923570246,
0.0319580659,
0.0373355821,
0.0180154666,
-0.0076016402,
0.0192912873,
0.0362410881,
-0.005623702,
0.0138958581,
0.0293886084,
-0.0030870284,
0.0165152568,
0.0122933732,
-0.0090096677,
0.0575866029,
0.0231935922,
0.0207861047,
0.0486280471,
-0.0548027717,
-0.0021671741,
0.0578063428,
0.0057656141,
0.0115145342,
-0.0102002528,
0.0652123988,
0.0123351896,
0.0425971188,
-0.0269002188,
0.0406932868,
-0.0112453746,
-0.0262969676,
0.071455054,
0.0743975565,
-0.0065794447,
-0.0136514958,
-0.0211403444,
-0.0396929011,
0.0289846193,
0.0127721671,
-0.0263726506,
0.0027667969,
-0.0183879714,
-0.0064931023,
0.00935598,
0.0377765223,
-0.0006972831,
-0.0635760725,
-0.0137618938,
0.0280109588,
-0.0314658657,
0.0515170321,
0.0410564505,
-0.0385754332,
-0.0168583281,
0.0474107116,
-0.0122110406,
-0.0392265245,
0.0055429731,
-0.0581391491,
-0.0130236307,
0.0016703663,
0.0518328212,
-0.0238872338,
-0.0408208109,
0.0022944841,
-0.0084682032,
0.0123049589,
0.059532214,
-0.0285999514,
-0.0112540182,
-0.0191513412,
0.0033701945,
-0.0024093639,
0.0042447369,
0.0018111372,
-0.000504201,
-0.0020821702,
-0.0243958998,
-0.0550081842,
-0.0441767946,
0.0231523775,
-0.0099499598,
-0.0443397351,
0.001234009,
-0.0391614288,
0.0417268872,
0.0023268394,
-0.0096045835,
0.0133355819,
0.0429507904,
-0.0091332663,
-0.0149715133,
-0.0273203403,
-0.0445269495,
-0.0204075091,
0.0442913882,
-0.0182024278,
-0.016138725,
0.0982472748,
-0.0433535427,
-0.0306711402,
-0.0106328307,
0.0011928878,
0.0024634914,
0.0191543419,
0.0531076081,
-0.0353489295,
-0.0065357927,
-0.0774694905,
0.0745421797,
-0.0143355187,
0.0621946827,
0.036963664,
0.0364812687,
0.0159303341,
-0.018124776,
-0.0270128697,
0.0794355497,
-0.0243549608,
0.0180667173,
0.0269724354,
-0.0048986389,
-0.0795926377,
-0.0281746704,
-0.088606149,
0.0042378176,
-0.0125653846,
0.0005932037,
0.017754063,
-0.0175538752,
-0.0042816103,
-0.01200464,
-0.0370328426,
-0.0299748201,
0.0294046551,
0.0426765755,
0.0147695355,
-0.0029562917,
0.0028227114,
-0.0636340603,
-0.0486115627,
-0.0140570477,
0.067938894,
-0.0043200827,
0.0381176695,
-0.0066524283,
0.0383102074,
-0.0789038762,
-0.0221728291,
-0.0188630279,
-0.0128936935,
0.0221235156,
-0.0213535056,
0.0161127634,
0.0745180473,
0.011172263,
0.0186471585,
0.0713354722,
-0.0050319894,
-0.0706162751,
-0.0133006983,
0.0128347622,
-0.0219295491,
-0.0451454669,
-0.0556636415,
0.0181307532,
0.0439725854,
0.0037200595,
-0.0087797958,
0.0035436871,
0.0526032448,
-0.0804562271,
-0.02624093,
-0.0847328454,
0.0266646426,
-0.0274728369,
0.0632428601,
-0.0061949557,
-0.0555297621,
0.035963539,
-0.019930141,
0.0050601182,
-0.0595061257,
0.0084391925,
-0.0410257205,
0.0194628984,
0.0292840824,
0.0062560509,
-0.0545370393,
-0.0008511522,
-0.0644215643,
-0.0300900824,
0.0118949143,
-0.0602554418,
0.0515666194,
-0.0359191187,
0.0024989676,
-0.016633112,
-0.0604413711,
-0.0269186981,
-0.031859301,
-0.033730235,
0.0167699009,
0.0375555716,
-0.0114359353,
0.0095626656,
-0.0293163676,
0.0297375396,
0.013539697,
-0.0409960747,
-0.0039891889,
-0.0019807068,
0.0623534918,
0.0532140993,
-0.0005220472,
0.0591448769,
-0.0496566147,
0.0490475222,
0.0567150787,
0.0897626355,
0.0169123542,
0.007893838,
0.0160019398,
0.0478682443,
-0.0575160943,
-0.0398449115,
0.0496713407,
0.0365408622,
-0.024424402,
-0.0014907811,
0.1048815921,
0.0412650965,
0.0035005715,
0.0236864313,
0.0060274783,
0.0323225707,
0.0203147847,
0.04065549,
-0.0426497571,
0.0145433126,
0.0036473947,
0.0226732269,
-0.0274708942,
-0.030011816,
0.0141450856,
-0.1242933571,
0.0229592659,
-0.0076399548,
-0.0526068285,
0.042035941,
-0.0572952703,
0.0009542303,
-0.0142497914,
0.0103285238,
0.040152546,
-0.0176956076,
0.0156785361,
0.0202615578,
-0.0617716648,
-0.0451606438,
0.0503141619,
-0.0167125091,
0.039284002,
0.0176251233,
0.0497804396,
-0.052212745,
-0.0069503109,
0.0437475294,
-0.0394993909,
-0.0174413975,
-0.0402298234,
0.0329753645,
0.0307935923,
0.0036277447,
-0.0273538921,
-0.0184734277,
-0.0021801982,
0.0336071476,
0.0304732975,
0.0689330772,
0.0161024444,
-0.0394941755,
0.0039014644,
-0.00605861,
-0.0427612402,
0.0535126999,
0.0172979645,
-0.0386085026,
-0.0189726911,
-0.0656332374,
-0.0068231593,
-0.0130951852,
-0.0672025084,
0.0010788428,
0.0116364993,
0.0224730559,
-0.0302694645,
-0.0461076051,
0.0210229792,
0.0078743361,
-0.0066048484,
0.0492478982,
-0.0202698801,
-0.0002937147,
0.0013324852,
0.0094832359,
0.0077104904,
0.0156696439,
-0.0482566319,
0.0205761027,
0.0511923432,
0.0153511818,
-0.0398094766,
-0.0212359205,
-0.0654637367,
-0.0358384177,
0.0009435915,
0.0556993373,
0.0207105596,
-0.0176454186,
0.0260336287,
-0.0537619777,
-0.0006550931,
-0.0150039298,
0.0209397376,
0.0395992324,
-0.0079903966,
-0.0401167758,
-0.0175913051,
0.0027500899,
-0.0367614292,
0.0123287076,
0.0647051111,
0.045813363,
-0.0181789193,
-0.0183483213,
0.0244615693,
0.0580949299,
0.0135537712,
0.0002453818,
-0.0198078249,
0.0153313437,
0.0292787217,
-0.032913927,
-0.0202286206,
0.0063266749,
-0.0358587392,
0.0310096312,
0.0078084883,
-0.0206151623,
0.0200227369,
0.0009559558,
0.0336932577,
-0.0809534118,
0.0323182568,
0.0197997354,
0.0095078666,
0.0285081379,
-0.0036532122,
-0.0508755408,
-0.0004732258,
0.0101866135,
0.0901608616,
-0.0055508749,
0.0266194623,
-0.0073722438,
-0.0264766123,
0.0324435905,
0.0409915969,
-0.0935454145,
-0.0633129627,
-0.0208844151,
0.0141838705,
0.0678238422,
0.0021813412,
0.0564528368,
0.0208882447,
-0.0166920219,
-0.0405102596,
-0.0500959083,
0.0160570405,
-0.0307516418,
0.0049276198,
0.0308168437,
0.0070809531,
0.0454833694,
0.0597341545,
0.0448399223,
-0.0030663153,
0.0354071967,
0.011791151,
-0.0294638798,
-0.0115122683,
-0.0106005473,
0.0154076349,
-0.0119321849,
-0.0208243467,
-0.0770645738,
-0.0765419751,
0.0086758966,
0.0285184756,
0.0306499489,
-0.0220485609,
0.0112153199,
0.0619713478,
-0.0124862008,
-0.0161862839,
-0.0599910058,
-0.0025857727,
-0.0652645528,
-0.02505612,
-0.0142404605,
-6.178663529e-33,
-0.0268286392,
-0.0244306959,
0.0166083444,
-0.0412949733,
0.0070556472,
0.0054229186,
-0.0073774979,
0.0211990178,
-0.0401995704,
-0.0174124073,
-0.0564241223,
-0.0163299423,
0.0000317152,
0.0145268077,
0.0249005444,
-0.0374253057,
0.0127628045,
-0.0015172398,
-0.0559791401,
-0.0008118158,
-0.0013471501,
-0.0013968941,
0.0375969633,
-0.0433426015,
0.0135161281,
0.0009915193,
0.0106403986,
-0.0099721942,
-0.056085486,
0.0651244,
0.0090955468,
0.0569379628,
0.0280820355,
-0.0473601148,
-0.0089192213,
-0.0212576333,
-0.0161903296,
-0.0509026572,
0.0182831772,
0.0094939554,
-0.0029297881,
-0.0109252911,
0.0244216807,
0.0149604883,
-0.0635715872,
-0.0333291329,
0.0241658986,
-0.0317290612,
-0.0479715355,
-0.0039179693,
-0.020819243,
0.0269836374,
-0.0287014693,
0.0476111583,
-0.0304973461,
0.0593070537,
-0.0145315072,
0.0164159592,
-0.017724257,
0.0205746274,
0.057841029,
0.0538121909,
0.0872511044,
0.0298884735,
-0.0216381941,
0.0561624132,
0.0339285657,
0.0329783782,
0.0554415919,
-0.0446831957,
0.015707802,
0.0212341547,
0.0886816457,
0.029512573,
0.0429521091,
0.0273424778,
-0.0930018798,
0.0311625581,
0.037839625,
-0.0186343081,
0.0108749038,
0.00219366,
-0.0518853366,
-0.031340491,
-0.0782149434,
0.0316585079,
-0.0383538119,
-0.0264722705,
0.0637444556,
-0.0377216898,
-0.0224515423,
-0.0120196315,
0.0394936949,
-0.0306118261,
-0.0490779355,
0.0029243918,
-0.0002299824,
0.0427716896,
0.0086147534,
0.0390995108,
-0.0458271578,
0.0219034217,
-0.0185255334,
0.006669159,
0.0264211334,
0.0048496122,
-0.0363455229,
-0.0138013707,
-0.0369669497,
-0.0091929073,
-0.0271649081,
-0.0436775722,
0.0085101184,
-0.009462988,
0.0205698404,
-0.0146436468,
0.008797707,
0.0499329641,
0.0181451216,
-0.0092551643,
-0.0464420989,
0.0058995881,
-0.0058837086,
-0.0047762082,
-0.0089359311,
-0.0115695223,
-0.0394767299,
0.0555613525,
0.0196358245,
-0.0415724963,
-0.0198376086,
-0.0020947198,
2.696e-7,
0.0547091104,
0.0848532096,
-0.0380197614,
0.0226936955,
0.0137316734,
0.0111126825,
-0.038343735,
0.0098045813,
0.0702078119,
0.0396918654,
-0.0086843893,
-0.0041160248,
0.0384488888,
0.0494889244,
-0.0441123992,
-0.0393048003,
-0.0637901872,
0.0051437202,
-0.0706575811,
-0.0020060155,
0.0339758657,
0.0524931476,
-0.0187744033,
-0.006278344,
-0.0492516905,
-0.0210434888,
0.0407273546,
-0.0670941547,
-0.0052206721,
0.0259592198,
0.0163582247,
0.0012749543,
0.0128742699,
0.0287978407,
-0.0120838592,
-0.0079588108,
0.0538529381,
0.0481135137,
0.009327461,
-0.0133380853,
-0.0066782543,
-0.006415756,
0.0124184918,
-0.0981271416,
0.0942500234,
-0.0348162651,
-0.0314629227,
-0.0427484289,
-0.044934608,
-0.0332538448,
0.0421819761,
-0.0174175128,
-0.0147185307,
0.0081368312,
-0.003041517,
0.0057244455,
-0.0036575769,
-0.0139418179,
-0.0346420929,
0.0104165198,
-0.0258659981,
-0.1007634923,
-0.0368613563,
-0.0053491811,
-0.0353780352,
-0.0266479384,
-0.0238057282,
2.777598101e-34,
0.0056930766,
-0.0002215671,
0.0544382595,
0.0019937414,
0.0284940824,
-0.0039804848,
-0.0027156249,
0.0135237556,
0.0059914272,
-0.1006490588,
-0.0095428256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00861v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00861v2 | Evaluating Large Language Models for Generalization and Robustness via Data Compression | 2024-02-01T18:56:18 | 2024-02-04T01:16:25 | Yucheng Li, Yunhao Guo, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing methods for evaluating large language models face challenges such as
data contamination, sensitivity to prompts, and the high cost of benchmark
creation. To address this, we propose a lossless data compression based
evaluation approach that tests how models' predictive abilities generalize
after their training cutoff. Specifically, we collect comprehensive test data
spanning 83 months from 2017 to 2023 and split the data into training and
testing periods according to models' training data cutoff. We measure: 1) the
compression performance on the testing period as a measure of generalization on
unseen data; and 2) the performance gap between the training and testing period
as a measure of robustness. Our experiments test 14 representative large
language models with various sizes on sources including Wikipedia, news
articles, code, arXiv papers, and multi-modal data. We find that the
compression rate of many models reduces significantly after their cutoff date,
but models such as Mistral and Llama-2 demonstrate a good balance between
performance and robustness. Results also suggest that models struggle to
generalize on news and code data, but work especially well on arXiv papers. We
also find the context size and tokenization implementation have a big impact of
on the overall compression performance. | [
0.0198734384,
0.1124004126,
-0.0000662044,
0.0124112619,
-0.0212875716,
0.0022573164,
0.0105025787,
0.0643051863,
-0.014702742,
-0.0218789764,
-0.0069479453,
-0.0279417094,
0.0064250496,
0.0352106355,
0.0247125421,
-0.0368986987,
0.0376625657,
-0.0348347276,
0.0145265739,
-0.0101647098,
0.0161660854,
-0.0261413474,
0.0674390271,
0.0491754189,
0.0294566695,
0.0061817956,
-0.0071606268,
-0.0092976019,
-0.0427215956,
-0.0175405052,
-0.0126684373,
0.0732739717,
0.0392637961,
0.0617379583,
0.0000017352,
-0.0682694465,
-0.0089013577,
0.0310011897,
-0.0351925455,
0.0408525355,
0.0568961576,
-0.0650866181,
0.0056773913,
0.0025081146,
0.0003492592,
-0.047399085,
0.0445249826,
0.0346200131,
0.0404429398,
0.0452207178,
0.0017989498,
-0.0113052903,
0.0573207214,
-0.0337325893,
-0.0091227703,
-0.0254444946,
0.0235895813,
0.0044829682,
-0.0105206454,
0.0262684692,
-0.037668325,
0.0282918364,
0.0237267017,
0.0018218467,
-0.0186785012,
0.0302401148,
-0.0667852834,
-0.0342248641,
0.0035806168,
0.0416652635,
0.0039644083,
-0.0510556698,
0.0047203461,
0.009999943,
-0.006104196,
0.011490128,
-0.070328787,
0.0192202739,
0.0181512646,
0.0003361717,
0.0160820317,
-0.0031994751,
0.0525697991,
0.0097450605,
-0.018565055,
0.0538318008,
0.0174431168,
-0.0381993204,
0.0244459491,
-0.0044180835,
-0.0315783583,
-0.0472845137,
-0.0199476983,
0.0131382365,
0.001426475,
0.0119704427,
-0.0590801723,
-0.0449358374,
0.0592450872,
-0.0595232248,
0.0100098057,
0.0168749783,
-0.0033450662,
0.055367101,
-0.0441247784,
0.0408610627,
-0.016028421,
0.0171086378,
0.0033523692,
-0.0228374004,
-0.0347635597,
-0.0022903269,
-0.0094491541,
0.0521216094,
0.0066261902,
0.0001219732,
-0.0353382193,
0.015902454,
0.0143261254,
0.0278537702,
0.0387993678,
-0.0209326819,
-0.0352330878,
-0.0090028029,
0.002732747,
0.0039487504,
-0.0398376696,
0.0167995859,
0.004135387,
-0.0445430316,
-0.0046707359,
0.018856572,
0.010880365,
-0.029745454,
0.0213391315,
0.063245751,
0.0257749986,
-0.0342206955,
-0.0257893037,
-0.0210731998,
-0.0022937297,
-0.0499655753,
-0.0163736548,
-0.0692873597,
0.0121643422,
0.023569854,
0.0070281541,
-0.0442640036,
-0.0238970388,
-0.0010093878,
-0.0575288981,
0.0358071662,
-0.0133855147,
0.0028666845,
0.0111182854,
0.0021377238,
0.0135324979,
0.0917838886,
0.0252254661,
0.007713886,
0.0587809347,
-0.0258636605,
-0.0078411754,
0.0339829773,
0.0690804496,
0.032728754,
-0.0313470364,
0.0282078404,
0.0157068893,
0.0195271447,
0.0301485825,
0.0756059512,
-0.0400933176,
-0.0387647524,
0.0438868403,
0.0449632406,
0.0331370868,
0.0322135985,
0.0312755592,
-0.0209862031,
0.0165059995,
-0.0054919682,
-0.0421535969,
-0.0179312043,
-0.0399046093,
0.0142704798,
0.0397721902,
0.011400396,
-0.0264390968,
-0.0314353481,
-0.0342398137,
-0.0214866325,
0.0456935801,
-0.0293249376,
0.0630051792,
-0.0156318638,
-0.0256198291,
0.0517720096,
0.0323372409,
-0.0483861156,
0.0062180334,
-0.0593079776,
0.0297579356,
0.0170978419,
0.0628200248,
-0.006339265,
0.0289824679,
-0.0270218924,
0.0231352784,
-0.0166466795,
0.0305794217,
-0.0231460985,
0.0135698989,
-0.0427027978,
-0.030655155,
0.0241301935,
0.0274277925,
-0.0108435862,
0.0483959615,
0.0262321942,
0.0126192439,
-0.0808249488,
-0.0495390669,
0.0401124246,
-0.0482984446,
-0.0082402546,
-0.0116610974,
-0.0167240016,
0.0373570025,
-0.0146315414,
-0.0191772133,
-0.0042805495,
0.0609517321,
-0.0248312782,
-0.0059113926,
-0.0205031782,
-0.0135074677,
-0.0118882461,
0.0344868153,
-0.0223732423,
0.0358923264,
0.0520595498,
-0.0254632924,
-0.0326489136,
0.0228042286,
-0.0248289816,
0.0557081029,
-0.0304596014,
0.0035290858,
-0.0591198392,
0.0508380644,
-0.0149267139,
0.0358920246,
-0.0384449922,
0.0497415997,
0.012505034,
-0.0131849675,
0.016660288,
-0.0200456809,
-0.0752294809,
0.0358703099,
-0.0291658808,
0.0230673421,
0.0494269319,
-0.0062791719,
-0.0105724521,
-0.0116092255,
-0.1033418924,
-0.0073532965,
-0.039099209,
0.012562735,
0.0156219574,
-0.0035434952,
0.0012332712,
-0.0001739249,
-0.0186604075,
-0.0125401253,
0.0105560599,
0.0312771685,
0.0277282856,
0.013652456,
-0.0202910826,
-0.0515567362,
-0.0604422316,
-0.012105084,
0.1102372855,
-0.0222135149,
-0.0136082573,
-0.0279668048,
0.051609125,
-0.0257906858,
0.0046789902,
-0.0189575441,
-0.0344012119,
-0.0076295338,
-0.0272624306,
-0.0011705358,
0.0520341881,
0.0008722847,
0.0217177346,
0.0694099069,
0.0255029574,
-0.0577869788,
-0.0108298874,
-0.0091591431,
-0.0232501309,
-0.0433092117,
-0.0471057631,
0.0036964123,
0.0750898346,
-0.0102904849,
-0.0049295323,
-0.0579728261,
-0.0294211153,
-0.0363349468,
-0.0130858729,
-0.0314932093,
-0.0125514381,
0.0090621486,
0.063161239,
0.0148266088,
-0.0751260817,
0.0680867583,
-0.0279337931,
0.0148447556,
0.0034759257,
-0.021543229,
-0.0521826036,
0.0626890585,
-0.0059737652,
0.0155511824,
0.009868959,
0.0001414012,
-0.0449684858,
0.0041658892,
0.003438774,
-0.0351509862,
0.0306073297,
-0.0253193825,
0.0212358814,
-0.0133788623,
-0.0172445998,
0.0004199769,
-0.0314903371,
0.0023761331,
0.0288267974,
0.0453665704,
-0.0245972015,
-0.0217056498,
0.0318497755,
0.0017562492,
0.0611606799,
-0.0001884092,
-0.0237819664,
0.0228486005,
0.0190537889,
0.0406463072,
-0.0063953688,
0.0281435922,
-0.0229786262,
0.0194880571,
0.0270726718,
0.0469116382,
0.0328951329,
-0.0473937951,
-0.018782841,
0.0273048002,
-0.0257905982,
-0.0292370636,
0.0324691534,
0.0444326811,
-0.0544820242,
-0.0199184492,
0.1012912393,
0.0214017164,
-0.0397611968,
-0.0009765843,
0.0004762609,
0.0756635889,
0.0117806867,
0.0155658191,
-0.0696974546,
-0.0061747534,
0.0135057848,
0.0266134962,
0.0067383745,
-0.0461369455,
0.0044837138,
-0.0860825405,
0.0173182376,
-0.0055252039,
-0.0219099056,
-0.015720617,
-0.0895397663,
0.0101530757,
-0.04630512,
0.0332071744,
0.0098144868,
-0.0152165405,
0.0005336464,
0.0242084879,
-0.0567410663,
-0.0830150247,
0.0212833956,
0.002707514,
0.0391090922,
0.0322117656,
0.0147586018,
-0.022527447,
0.0056387479,
0.0322749056,
0.022736216,
-0.0301125981,
-0.0128655611,
0.0605640635,
0.0252200775,
0.016049616,
0.0259764548,
0.0381774306,
-0.0141592836,
0.0122144502,
-0.0005683731,
0.0762537941,
0.008609226,
-0.0447101071,
-0.0399631374,
-0.0456745923,
-0.0345935263,
0.0881221369,
0.0403912514,
-0.0253742896,
-0.0355165415,
-0.0294410344,
-0.0033050282,
-0.0066158846,
-0.0242855251,
-0.0184381008,
-0.0016195052,
-0.0253941901,
-0.0708658993,
-0.0287371129,
0.0016153309,
0.0250070468,
-0.0050369911,
0.0105597069,
-0.0136863254,
0.0140313292,
-0.0671040118,
-0.0033616198,
-0.0120538622,
-0.0073467577,
-0.0779358521,
0.0371501558,
0.0140478443,
0.0090531101,
-0.0422384553,
0.0190163366,
-0.1284223944,
-0.0675307438,
-0.0043961811,
0.0364913829,
0.0317641497,
0.0341489315,
-0.0026819722,
-0.0834198445,
0.0545391813,
0.0480733812,
-0.022812061,
0.0221939087,
0.0473196059,
-0.0387447327,
0.0021458748,
0.0412606075,
-0.0590845272,
0.0080150915,
-0.0245881863,
-0.0039204895,
-0.0235865302,
-0.0042314539,
0.0042823628,
0.0386540145,
0.0247654691,
-0.0182526857,
-0.0201508347,
0.0097244587,
-0.0014569822,
-0.0100142928,
0.0157237388,
-0.0290782452,
0.0380394794,
0.0420218557,
0.0037505901,
0.0011740434,
0.0335422456,
0.0161732174,
0.0224513672,
-0.062873058,
0.018208297,
-0.0064937104,
0.0189035982,
0.0597323515,
0.0078325551,
-0.0204098504,
-0.0405439921,
-0.0153138544,
0.0237825308,
-0.0433714241,
0.0046288655,
0.0084401416,
0.0380138122,
0.0154438792,
0.0211331397,
-0.0942095295,
-0.0271894168,
-0.0288554933,
0.0355058424,
0.0143521531,
0.003498876,
0.0329313017,
-0.0382603109,
-0.0075242557,
-0.0331971869,
0.0078761941,
0.0246860888,
-0.008634205,
0.0404256098,
0.0085701635,
-0.0431904867,
0.0181018654,
0.1153417453,
0.0367735326,
0.0375102721,
-0.0251365602,
-0.0050997152,
-0.0427100435,
-0.0044892896,
-0.0078979563,
0.0238743071,
-0.0306083616,
-0.0247280784,
-0.020172907,
-0.0594393611,
-0.003898429,
-0.0081849284,
0.006240441,
-0.0175124425,
0.002223284,
0.0865469947,
0.0115747442,
0.0423686467,
-0.0257621258,
-0.0129356431,
0.0171040688,
-0.0269368384,
-0.0222177748,
-6.074432445e-33,
0.0160073955,
0.0269189049,
-0.0109772375,
-0.0552144609,
0.0076747779,
0.0368713662,
-0.0376023985,
-0.015823042,
-0.0463191792,
-0.0127302501,
-0.0263460726,
0.0122980392,
-0.0060182954,
0.0124379024,
0.020754952,
-0.0134016154,
0.0525159501,
-0.0049624988,
-0.0369716138,
0.033239238,
0.0425830968,
0.0178173613,
0.0485367514,
-0.0628732964,
0.0506097265,
0.0082536293,
-0.0214125514,
-0.024404997,
0.0401357599,
0.0682820901,
-0.0325229131,
0.025366189,
0.0107883243,
-0.0593629181,
-0.0226692427,
0.0022331886,
-0.067060709,
-0.0125005133,
0.0157963019,
-0.024220001,
-0.0037376052,
-0.0326193608,
0.0595849529,
-0.0050209863,
-0.0151717588,
-0.0216867495,
0.0212635584,
-0.0110530118,
-0.0543528125,
-0.0455376096,
-0.0205229204,
0.0211071912,
-0.0274527408,
0.0295852255,
0.029358644,
0.0535341427,
0.0013626007,
0.1000327691,
-0.0248208307,
0.0188963003,
0.0134051703,
0.052473668,
0.0565279387,
-0.0369140394,
0.0010016346,
0.0441737324,
-0.0067641959,
0.0188828465,
0.0101989107,
0.0184562095,
0.0707045123,
0.0043520322,
0.0351722613,
0.0739951283,
0.0667224303,
-0.0310885664,
-0.0873146281,
0.0162427649,
0.0333880819,
0.0283925273,
0.0308120009,
0.0371762998,
-0.0435056128,
-0.0193407536,
-0.0503594354,
-0.037129771,
-0.007198764,
-0.0468536615,
0.0112088053,
0.0194395315,
-0.0325784869,
0.0026432429,
0.0294694547,
-0.08198338,
-0.0794324428,
0.0639828816,
-0.0349693783,
0.0338593125,
0.0180293471,
0.0225012992,
-0.0575150587,
-0.0191954132,
0.0154220033,
-0.0006201987,
0.029932417,
-0.0305545758,
0.0408931524,
0.0367180854,
-0.0783630982,
-0.0097100576,
-0.0196528062,
-0.0139760999,
0.0055591227,
0.0004720848,
0.0491338298,
0.0142590059,
0.0166214574,
0.0169851016,
0.0349702016,
0.0257101208,
-0.0398847796,
-0.0277734231,
0.0137805501,
0.0309206527,
-0.003942613,
-0.0560646504,
-0.0413233638,
0.0210979469,
0.0511381663,
-0.0420265459,
-0.0119097298,
0.0226650424,
2.524e-7,
0.0428657681,
0.0566112511,
-0.0086110495,
-0.0048187501,
0.0043371008,
0.0035485246,
-0.0189294517,
0.0328549668,
-0.0192910209,
-0.0176215284,
-0.0105690937,
-0.0166406874,
0.0388612226,
0.0342852958,
-0.0935908705,
-0.0395518281,
-0.1168600023,
-0.0143109234,
-0.0643321127,
0.0111736003,
0.0271171983,
0.1460368186,
0.0084305936,
-0.0093766032,
0.004940704,
-0.0305575002,
0.0457517616,
-0.0467798188,
-0.0050543887,
0.0318028666,
0.0189866647,
0.0324064195,
0.0031050104,
-0.0072859335,
-0.0358472094,
0.0111011472,
-0.0034274235,
0.0692875385,
0.0244465414,
0.0226764567,
0.0258510709,
-0.0442115329,
-0.0137850391,
-0.0649673715,
0.0816282108,
0.0017077032,
-0.0262541976,
-0.042757079,
-0.0065618171,
-0.0188119039,
0.0569574721,
-0.0291448925,
0.0139425043,
0.0243627224,
-0.0228274353,
-0.0045828004,
0.0037392229,
-0.0674018189,
-0.0296575092,
0.0052422131,
-0.0209658127,
-0.0575924367,
-0.0509043522,
-0.0208781958,
0.0310349278,
-0.0652338639,
0.0319534354,
2.583413781e-34,
0.0657483414,
-0.0127659477,
-0.0121084396,
0.0120015051,
0.0129187452,
-0.0500331223,
0.0092177158,
0.0121344626,
-0.0131982341,
-0.079766497,
0.0051442119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00858v1 | Can Large Language Models Understand Context? | 2024-02-01T18:55:29 | 2024-02-01T18:55:29 | Yilun Zhu, Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Shruti Bhargava, Jiarui Lu, Dhivya Piraviperumal, Site Li, Yuan Zhang, Hong Yu, Bo-Hsiang Tseng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding context is key to understanding human language, an ability
which Large Language Models (LLMs) have been increasingly seen to demonstrate
to an impressive extent. However, though the evaluation of LLMs encompasses
various domains within the realm of Natural Language Processing, limited
attention has been paid to probing their linguistic capability of understanding
contextual features. This paper introduces a context understanding benchmark by
adapting existing datasets to suit the evaluation of generative models. This
benchmark comprises of four distinct tasks and nine datasets, all featuring
prompts designed to assess the models' ability to understand context. First, we
evaluate the performance of LLMs under the in-context learning pretraining
scenario. Experimental results indicate that pre-trained dense models struggle
with understanding more nuanced contextual features when compared to
state-of-the-art fine-tuned models. Second, as LLM compression holds growing
significance in both research and real-world applications, we assess the
context understanding of quantized models under in-context-learning settings.
We find that 3-bit post-training quantization leads to varying degrees of
performance reduction on our benchmark. We conduct an extensive analysis of
these scenarios to substantiate our experimental results. | [
-0.009442728,
0.0601473041,
0.0007511226,
0.066660881,
-0.0078893714,
0.0288496949,
0.0398650877,
0.0026274528,
-0.0607965998,
-0.0626093894,
-0.0317621045,
-0.0577952377,
-0.0003458648,
0.0320737772,
0.0233575441,
-0.0286931936,
0.0381608345,
-0.0108830584,
0.0029685011,
0.0041347132,
-0.022504596,
-0.0013148005,
0.0179334059,
0.0319016799,
-0.0152222235,
-0.0191765875,
-0.0092372103,
0.0373063385,
0.0217312369,
-0.0298252702,
0.0007772964,
0.0643685758,
0.072141014,
0.0285020433,
0.0000019758,
-0.0408355445,
0.0008597077,
-0.0202673301,
-0.080047451,
0.0160233378,
0.0274262112,
-0.027595818,
-0.0340482481,
-0.0138587868,
-0.0446681008,
-0.0114749735,
0.0302928053,
0.0192380734,
0.0122720618,
0.0520697944,
-0.0123443697,
-0.0287990626,
0.0070604836,
-0.0426235311,
0.0199540108,
-0.0552979819,
0.0139776841,
0.0320167691,
-0.0082803499,
0.0089121684,
-0.042463284,
0.0234065596,
0.0389515422,
0.0429621711,
-0.010559448,
0.0455458611,
-0.0406354554,
0.0051796339,
-0.0244645253,
0.073765412,
-0.0524371676,
-0.0126634678,
-0.0071209422,
-0.0095810071,
-0.0145236356,
-0.0757456794,
-0.0252749547,
0.0286898911,
0.0130022233,
0.0409414917,
-0.0155578023,
0.028488623,
0.0427405685,
0.0240724385,
-0.0531570092,
0.0320986286,
-0.0015337685,
-0.011830762,
-0.0104582943,
-0.0033541694,
-0.0712268949,
-0.0430241264,
-0.0152784474,
0.0262286235,
-0.0218706727,
0.0195003133,
-0.0518318675,
0.0029580547,
0.0161261074,
-0.0158660561,
-0.0055384343,
0.0401136652,
-0.0346177183,
0.0554660223,
-0.0082188668,
0.0513310991,
-0.0151226372,
0.0099191433,
-0.0309826117,
0.0140680261,
-0.0226917546,
0.0053567737,
-0.0432487689,
-0.0000056433,
-0.0732036009,
-0.0352919847,
-0.0300308112,
0.0274236742,
0.0020394067,
0.0001168421,
0.0083602834,
0.0230957996,
-0.0420896411,
-0.0018291447,
0.0164337363,
-0.008322373,
-0.0274225101,
0.0308414586,
0.0185721386,
-0.0738855824,
-0.0077921711,
0.0091139842,
0.0212075226,
-0.0388062224,
0.0069726561,
0.0195943862,
0.0129530141,
-0.0646260902,
-0.0092833592,
-0.0142146777,
-0.0262430869,
-0.0816681758,
-0.0451638438,
-0.0492787547,
-0.0009348842,
-0.0056214491,
0.0166394953,
-0.0342570543,
-0.0060214777,
-0.0115702515,
0.0093045132,
0.097796835,
-0.0068110484,
-0.0088337297,
0.0063101728,
0.0328362361,
0.0745250881,
0.0748776123,
0.0141921584,
0.0374478027,
0.0072832573,
0.0129644154,
-0.0195657909,
0.0353124551,
0.0408947803,
-0.0042111985,
-0.0286966618,
0.0046451529,
-0.0069633117,
0.058710169,
0.0720770136,
0.0544290803,
-0.0533893928,
-0.0356357917,
0.0364702865,
0.06136702,
0.0554701835,
0.0150180617,
0.0464221723,
0.0188724287,
-0.0159196947,
-0.0050038118,
-0.0660414994,
-0.0062767318,
-0.0078083621,
0.0122338766,
0.0286288206,
0.0086953733,
-0.0281245075,
-0.0243374296,
-0.0155513901,
-0.0073081437,
0.002308839,
0.0260308292,
0.028256353,
0.0131466957,
-0.0346798524,
0.0356570072,
0.0278860368,
-0.0469441749,
-0.0183412526,
-0.0595267601,
0.026138613,
0.073029995,
0.0412967093,
-0.0000620202,
0.0155168474,
-0.0091514327,
0.0160333607,
0.0091449181,
0.0031173609,
-0.0131222997,
0.0567713454,
-0.0352550521,
-0.0495438688,
-0.0317753777,
0.0120518431,
0.0363449566,
0.0280113779,
0.0041410197,
0.0213585068,
-0.0301646534,
0.0350111462,
0.0306618717,
-0.0202137884,
-0.0598612316,
0.0067979023,
0.0156655852,
0.0414157659,
0.0170962028,
-0.0235153697,
-0.017161807,
0.0398207493,
-0.0497107506,
0.0373993181,
0.0072394842,
-0.1102536172,
-0.0798798129,
0.0078642284,
0.0176539477,
-0.0076802326,
-0.0143836001,
-0.0668817163,
-0.022684522,
0.0031251784,
-0.0099211484,
0.0694114715,
-0.0614607818,
-0.0042946618,
0.0062168567,
0.0568564236,
-0.0432994924,
0.0824359432,
-0.0177881494,
0.0008969944,
0.0439565815,
0.0603744574,
0.0171730369,
-0.0381958075,
-0.0245002862,
-0.0043938118,
-0.014746679,
0.0039499677,
-0.008885473,
0.0058301874,
-0.0381751209,
0.0128898751,
-0.1243169308,
-0.0094081145,
-0.0527346283,
0.0116639016,
0.0377305411,
0.0160545856,
-0.0182006173,
-0.0231680479,
-0.0384394936,
-0.0079195928,
0.0005733883,
0.0090432735,
0.0084807081,
0.0234801993,
-0.0088969683,
-0.0429921336,
-0.0147422682,
0.0106815137,
0.0527577922,
-0.0192839,
0.0003730883,
-0.0471040756,
0.0436437242,
0.0153475814,
0.0227642916,
-0.0210530553,
-0.0049631428,
0.0198496245,
-0.0379519351,
0.0455257557,
0.0917986259,
0.0148270885,
0.0631324202,
0.0496064089,
-0.0040533408,
-0.0581608191,
0.0059565436,
-0.0073520029,
-0.0322372094,
-0.0517970808,
-0.0327019319,
-0.0110631501,
0.0753416196,
0.0109654348,
0.0113018854,
-0.0421166457,
0.0085285325,
-0.0110344272,
-0.0429138243,
-0.0846626982,
0.0010472006,
-0.0149286203,
0.084086962,
-0.0296509117,
-0.0466006696,
0.0353320241,
-0.0398483723,
-0.0060895835,
-0.0078229206,
-0.0222816393,
-0.0348588489,
0.0907458737,
0.003051603,
0.0215852298,
-0.0022784513,
-0.0309562627,
-0.0495684557,
-0.0055218842,
-0.0171636324,
-0.0175201949,
0.0246831588,
-0.0451411791,
0.0214584656,
-0.0239613075,
-0.0354532935,
-0.0511147007,
-0.048805587,
-0.0201802272,
0.026686741,
0.0242943224,
0.0047236583,
0.0285808444,
0.0277174469,
-0.0255302917,
0.0512567796,
0.0155494083,
-0.0259255264,
-0.0152050499,
0.0551713519,
0.0377222411,
0.0129592121,
0.026284704,
-0.005732228,
0.0115788179,
0.0402081832,
0.0248849634,
0.014781246,
-0.0708047524,
0.0338621177,
0.0181471296,
0.0021067413,
-0.0105035855,
0.0397877209,
0.05644181,
-0.0691840127,
-0.0348515734,
0.1172018349,
0.0239471495,
-0.0411552303,
0.0132647241,
0.0096290009,
0.0049572061,
0.0131918909,
-0.0058347844,
-0.1247162372,
-0.0471959338,
0.0048474199,
-0.0208246,
0.004670342,
-0.0093976799,
-0.0220494289,
-0.0802967995,
0.0239851363,
-0.0030033856,
-0.0311524812,
-0.0168198459,
0.0046465537,
-0.0046519851,
-0.0150274094,
0.0676487312,
0.0000038376,
-0.0155938501,
-0.0131928036,
0.0142971883,
0.0374749526,
-0.085767962,
0.059934929,
0.0012323133,
0.0637716949,
0.082657896,
0.0239324551,
0.0354849845,
0.0076178275,
0.0149564408,
-0.0079361834,
0.0222268384,
-0.0064314278,
0.0265407171,
-0.0071210908,
0.0045324443,
0.0312815383,
0.009305398,
-0.031151684,
-0.0387006961,
0.0049212938,
-0.0011831631,
-0.0134766083,
-0.0035313701,
-0.0142801357,
-0.0219057016,
0.0224917643,
0.0935643911,
0.0625888482,
-0.0097233029,
-0.0479113087,
-0.0219197404,
0.0227475446,
-0.0353608243,
-0.01239077,
-0.0194097143,
0.0102027878,
-0.0241064169,
-0.0412985198,
-0.0200961567,
0.0188293047,
0.0298310816,
-0.0096842237,
-0.0029448862,
-0.0160149951,
0.016743131,
-0.0736338794,
0.0272892565,
-0.0210381597,
0.0269329585,
-0.0612696297,
0.0108774751,
0.0178382173,
-0.033805389,
-0.0279413462,
0.0087928586,
-0.1218090579,
-0.0415764563,
0.0160435624,
0.0019321284,
0.0193159543,
0.0818485692,
-0.002629553,
-0.0624341741,
0.0610643364,
0.0272990912,
-0.0042611565,
0.0409475788,
0.0226908438,
0.0286172871,
0.0014680154,
0.0408509485,
-0.0373905636,
0.0604656003,
0.0185670294,
0.0282104015,
-0.0749430433,
-0.037772622,
0.0103074033,
-0.0361466631,
0.0544860922,
-0.0300171077,
-0.0104305679,
0.0059482832,
0.0092371004,
-0.0164657887,
0.0288007911,
-0.0437815599,
-0.0444013886,
0.0409087762,
-0.0054296856,
-0.0105301263,
0.0184166003,
-0.0040925667,
0.0298204646,
-0.0273442604,
0.0154189467,
-0.0006817618,
0.0175790768,
0.0365583822,
0.016380772,
-0.0239060856,
0.0230770297,
-0.0024503693,
0.0512204133,
-0.024096895,
0.0496001765,
-0.0076114982,
0.0062455004,
-0.0168317612,
0.0445989445,
-0.0764959157,
0.0011601226,
-0.0339869335,
0.0254119616,
0.0489385165,
-0.0207752343,
0.0255805328,
-0.0143006751,
-0.0004179451,
-0.0145902047,
0.0174290035,
0.0110760015,
-0.043676924,
0.0558713414,
0.0311828125,
-0.0231491216,
0.0170078762,
0.0776102096,
0.0364805199,
0.0255803987,
0.0030490663,
0.0152669912,
-0.035863068,
-0.006881136,
-0.0228913408,
0.0252227075,
0.0018372074,
0.0483550094,
-0.0243027639,
-0.056805253,
-0.0140376324,
0.0105873318,
0.0218663905,
-0.0119597549,
0.0369874537,
0.0371942371,
-0.0107874051,
-0.0266717765,
-0.0091535971,
-0.0000770645,
-0.0099159004,
-0.0049291286,
-0.0457295775,
-6.372238796e-33,
-0.0294567328,
-0.0125874914,
0.0259287059,
-0.0594956651,
-0.001958464,
0.0334322974,
-0.0442008115,
-0.000146918,
-0.0302144587,
-0.0215379689,
-0.0262268316,
0.0285336338,
0.0213949103,
0.0507806242,
-0.0401216857,
-0.0090696122,
0.0818664357,
-0.0109587647,
-0.0004409692,
0.0189195145,
0.0087870536,
0.0184783377,
0.0285090115,
-0.020226799,
0.0000863435,
-0.0120300744,
-0.0231514201,
0.00763408,
0.0045344494,
0.0384948365,
-0.0551052094,
0.0127433203,
0.0291326679,
-0.0111677684,
-0.0458389558,
0.0413022973,
-0.105063729,
0.0028986356,
0.0186623633,
0.0191803854,
-0.024912063,
-0.0353622027,
0.0440032929,
-0.0201248676,
-0.0117874723,
-0.0167143773,
0.001166252,
-0.0341471843,
-0.0426297672,
-0.0955659375,
-0.0477942526,
0.0228230301,
-0.0139990952,
0.0014508405,
0.0625662282,
0.007010201,
-0.0233341213,
0.0185763314,
-0.0490251444,
0.0118220178,
0.0137793152,
0.045710776,
0.0652733296,
0.0385950021,
0.0095317261,
0.0453385934,
-0.0011904842,
-0.0321309231,
-0.0385969169,
0.0001819739,
0.0361661687,
0.0473827757,
-0.0060333228,
0.0720534325,
0.0785521716,
-0.0073831128,
-0.0682747439,
-0.0004588446,
-0.0045123035,
0.0113267042,
0.0387048982,
0.032744363,
-0.0289532728,
-0.0136423316,
-0.0494115278,
-0.0270955022,
-0.0337056853,
-0.028377302,
0.0411738306,
0.0143204816,
-0.0052089724,
-0.0235774275,
0.0368661657,
-0.0715015531,
-0.0096681826,
0.036582049,
-0.0024924348,
-0.0092566973,
0.020990178,
0.0451448075,
-0.0447705612,
-0.0201425944,
0.0400429331,
0.0381243862,
0.013556744,
-0.0242821649,
0.0494844802,
0.0065815574,
-0.0556257926,
-0.0157683101,
-0.0341964327,
0.0299935322,
-0.0317047313,
0.0295331348,
0.0461008698,
0.0199500956,
-0.0075252904,
0.0342723876,
-0.0115246335,
-0.018593194,
-0.007255001,
-0.003426933,
0.0032243871,
0.0447898805,
-0.0455017127,
-0.0250079725,
-0.0288699064,
0.0098505029,
0.1078256741,
-0.0282542985,
-0.0219742768,
0.0444768853,
2.533e-7,
0.0399343669,
0.0159531124,
0.0085976403,
-0.0329380035,
0.0237670857,
0.0143023329,
-0.0033583811,
0.0087059792,
-0.0062869117,
-0.0161496885,
0.0304162186,
0.0505624227,
0.0312490016,
-0.0080364225,
-0.0608007386,
0.0338660926,
-0.0505237319,
0.0107010892,
-0.0432140827,
0.001021095,
0.0538724847,
0.1229483634,
-0.0309255328,
-0.0132985059,
0.045944076,
-0.0164484568,
0.0469068699,
-0.058076527,
0.0436703227,
0.0124116968,
-0.0170995686,
0.0478249192,
0.002124907,
-0.0038930071,
0.0074517047,
-0.0005824438,
-0.0367452241,
0.0990871936,
0.0046483502,
-0.0536743104,
-0.0188416671,
-0.0004710027,
-0.0029743914,
-0.0521044582,
0.0764086097,
-0.0683861375,
-0.0077146012,
-0.0657914802,
0.004458731,
-0.0100577809,
0.0108127957,
0.0048737684,
0.0077125719,
-0.0004250326,
0.0147357704,
-0.0367442742,
-0.0253044236,
-0.1280643195,
-0.031449642,
0.0085026128,
-0.0373683386,
-0.0226356983,
-0.0479872599,
-0.0079362001,
0.0551512353,
-0.0137764029,
0.0028773034,
2.121941331e-34,
0.026515305,
0.0090819756,
0.023183085,
0.0091946432,
-0.009044962,
0.0024653743,
-0.0234572329,
0.0051238174,
0.0061219288,
-0.0734737888,
0.0069742985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00856v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00856v4 | Towards Efficient Exact Optimization of Language Model Alignment | 2024-02-01T18:51:54 | 2024-06-05T08:15:12 | Haozhe Ji, Cheng Lu, Yilin Niu, Pei Ke, Hongning Wang, Jun Zhu, Jie Tang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The alignment of language models with human preferences is vital for their
application in real-world tasks. The problem is formulated as optimizing the
model's policy to maximize the expected reward that reflects human preferences
with minimal deviation from the initial policy. While considered as a
straightforward solution, reinforcement learning (RL) suffers from high
variance in policy updates, which impedes efficient policy improvement.
Recently, direct preference optimization (DPO) was proposed to directly
optimize the policy from preference data. However, we show that DPO derived
based on the optimal solution of the problem leads to a compromised
mean-seeking approximation of the optimal solution in practice. In this paper,
we propose efficient exact optimization (EXO) of the alignment objective. EXO
is guaranteed to optimize in the same direction as RL algorithms asymptotically
for arbitrary policy parametrization. This leads to the same mode-seeking
solution, while enables efficient optimization by circumventing the
complexities of RL. We also compare our method to DPO with both theoretical and
empirical analyses, and further demonstrate the advantages of our method over
existing approaches on realistic human preference data. Code is available at
https://github.com/haozheji/exact-optimization. | [
0.0341313183,
0.0663005486,
0.0020699287,
0.0309819933,
-0.0356167443,
0.0038347428,
-0.0634626746,
-0.016757939,
-0.042590607,
0.0076314933,
-0.0276715383,
-0.038871713,
0.0202860609,
0.0040715248,
-0.009069385,
-0.0503824092,
0.0608992465,
-0.0295747519,
0.0200321525,
-0.0133302072,
0.0483486652,
-0.0085942214,
-0.0150886541,
0.0235644337,
0.0336303823,
0.007664022,
-0.0178502165,
0.0023090537,
0.0677432939,
0.0124744065,
0.037249919,
0.0226824097,
0.0077321199,
0.0497957282,
0.0000022349,
-0.03489016,
-0.0368931033,
-0.0338080935,
0.0111416942,
-0.0428467654,
0.0584859401,
0.0252443124,
-0.0389843881,
0.0309524704,
-0.0205220655,
0.0288466718,
0.1001721546,
0.010299081,
0.0371144414,
0.0653492361,
0.0070577357,
0.0003198083,
-0.0367926583,
-0.0309846159,
-0.0001750512,
-0.025311837,
0.0237255078,
-0.0316565037,
0.0027011011,
0.0009127573,
-0.0201966241,
0.0226918943,
-0.0290316921,
0.0099148657,
-0.0333255827,
0.0329881683,
0.0090636089,
-0.0176368263,
-0.0062604314,
0.0653022453,
-0.0363703035,
-0.0639567971,
0.0213720538,
-0.0301796068,
0.0003207909,
0.0303223822,
0.0183090027,
-0.0173832402,
-0.0024669338,
0.0523367636,
0.0295408461,
-0.0290685631,
0.0296034347,
0.0158842895,
-0.0151904849,
0.0767324343,
0.0093740029,
-0.0333382897,
0.0116870021,
0.0019279374,
-0.0181336869,
-0.0445603207,
0.0144069139,
-0.0067812004,
-0.0691016242,
0.0328542553,
-0.0481891148,
-0.02069881,
-0.0093984175,
-0.0510749184,
0.0417986847,
0.0699264035,
0.0208208375,
0.0122854272,
0.0370333381,
0.0719867423,
-0.0286595412,
-0.0363615341,
-0.0642974675,
0.0277751312,
-0.0220940057,
0.0056475862,
-0.0018930706,
-0.0020734998,
-0.0248087663,
-0.0173492301,
-0.0604866371,
0.040459387,
-0.0128487628,
0.0255708117,
-0.0022015383,
0.0054809055,
-0.0664876252,
-0.0154867359,
-0.0420609005,
0.023651408,
-0.0201090518,
0.0032964246,
0.0082797259,
0.0313568972,
0.0273994952,
0.0074886391,
-0.0275215376,
-0.0224025585,
-0.0110561205,
0.0918641463,
-0.024372166,
0.020622367,
0.0044546705,
-0.0025733635,
-0.0282924902,
-0.026505582,
-0.0512554944,
-0.0741792768,
0.0058930949,
-0.0206308849,
-0.0339437388,
-0.0598484986,
-0.0119715631,
-0.0049995976,
-0.0308529008,
0.0641137213,
0.0071579213,
0.011091331,
0.0320433117,
-0.0363082848,
-0.0050260653,
0.0742742866,
0.0353560895,
0.0306316838,
0.009539851,
-0.0127046099,
-0.0118501391,
0.0699308142,
0.0087060267,
0.0139776533,
-0.0253542811,
0.0068216934,
0.0128872078,
0.0563743412,
0.0694830194,
0.0168683045,
-0.0086938823,
-0.0277981721,
0.0643685833,
0.0288297255,
0.0285993945,
-0.0438026264,
-0.0085440977,
0.041577369,
-0.0500969328,
-0.0138196694,
-0.0525360331,
0.0285794158,
-0.0302581061,
0.0265692007,
0.0079218075,
0.0388510823,
0.0003315628,
-0.0350801051,
0.0124055892,
-0.0165137574,
0.0203591976,
0.045066677,
0.0146800792,
-0.0357321575,
-0.0494803861,
-0.0062787547,
0.0464285165,
-0.0036819431,
0.0020655824,
-0.018472109,
0.0184301585,
0.0605951883,
0.0070289262,
-0.0184215754,
-0.0550267845,
-0.0032747851,
-0.0495464914,
0.0555643998,
0.0364717059,
-0.0289317444,
-0.0196585357,
-0.0601418093,
-0.0609065443,
0.0597995445,
-0.0129611362,
0.0289537534,
0.0318255574,
0.0062931147,
-0.0191765614,
-0.0125960903,
-0.0592686608,
0.0238022096,
-0.0100933462,
-0.0417620577,
0.0031392965,
0.0406094044,
0.0449454598,
-0.0088313678,
0.0054700226,
0.0022800604,
-0.0136805316,
0.0167955905,
0.013251395,
0.0105090849,
-0.0483295582,
-0.0017514072,
0.0661040246,
-0.0288875997,
-0.0384199843,
0.0558767058,
-0.0329018049,
-0.0474339798,
-0.0241122283,
-0.0215110537,
0.0384637006,
0.0084850229,
0.0415809341,
-0.0294731725,
-0.0220510177,
-0.0787299573,
0.0444992334,
-0.0095744208,
0.0124290632,
0.0107369507,
-0.0244653057,
-0.0108094132,
-0.0673743635,
-0.0375511684,
0.0399038643,
0.0015342783,
0.0558576658,
0.0829351842,
0.0288347173,
-0.0228922442,
-0.0268539563,
-0.0402039476,
0.0002977431,
-0.0108298734,
0.0277530588,
0.0449800342,
0.0239083748,
-0.0369073041,
-0.0297625121,
-0.0427140146,
0.0096988119,
-0.0374458805,
-0.0043571242,
0.0289419256,
0.0052647837,
-0.0263120793,
-0.0779178217,
-0.0020718067,
-0.0030941316,
-0.0301012285,
-0.022462206,
0.04557826,
-0.0473713912,
0.0350291282,
-0.0289173685,
0.0464406759,
-0.0121454075,
-0.0450249054,
0.0001311885,
-0.0112474961,
0.0320544057,
0.0950123146,
0.054919336,
0.0167988054,
0.0607542954,
0.0392262302,
-0.0940320268,
0.0125533119,
-0.0796031654,
-0.0457585528,
-0.0475446954,
-0.0302384701,
0.0338927805,
0.1009573415,
-0.0089884792,
0.0063880375,
-0.0656369105,
-0.0130469399,
-0.0000605382,
-0.0182549581,
-0.0128224473,
0.0462793,
-0.0561482161,
0.0417179018,
-0.0521326736,
-0.0816898644,
0.0984641686,
-0.0076938793,
0.0253241491,
-0.081480369,
-0.0326256864,
-0.0004749022,
-0.0307716858,
-0.0049701519,
0.0457812175,
-0.0245194584,
-0.0161575861,
-0.0765948743,
-0.0330086127,
0.0664099976,
-0.0398731716,
0.066590555,
-0.0158148613,
0.0307859201,
-0.0115901465,
-0.0707922429,
-0.0519792214,
-0.0253601093,
-0.0164768491,
-0.0289975125,
0.0040150173,
-0.0569038913,
-0.018753605,
-0.0015622133,
0.0520941056,
0.0309425611,
0.0034891737,
-0.0117687816,
-0.0190464389,
-0.0124724284,
0.1006203741,
-0.0115901111,
-0.0403128341,
-0.0023504347,
-0.0155104129,
0.0056987884,
0.0585680418,
0.0157834142,
-0.0353687592,
0.0166711323,
0.0677055046,
-0.0628921017,
-0.0050429748,
0.0596684888,
0.0186252017,
-0.0086702397,
-0.0033761475,
0.0856532902,
0.0322258882,
-0.0657529607,
0.0111565143,
-0.0157305617,
0.0592779219,
0.0044078361,
0.0435264967,
-0.0059229168,
-0.0147278085,
0.01331254,
0.0757208765,
0.0135279149,
-0.0026121375,
0.0075436439,
-0.1143104807,
-0.0470897071,
0.0173676275,
-0.0776137263,
-0.0307625458,
-0.0176299233,
0.0328500718,
-0.0374334268,
0.0523585901,
0.0209205486,
0.0171304289,
0.0094766235,
0.023721097,
0.0413404852,
-0.0186797138,
0.004899099,
-0.0382364541,
0.0543953627,
0.1106931865,
0.0260445885,
0.0091417516,
-0.005170681,
0.0073996293,
0.0456152968,
-0.0486177504,
-0.0011868532,
-0.0415830202,
-0.0252826679,
-0.0098395804,
-0.0090041216,
0.0743646845,
-0.0167454313,
0.0189510528,
0.009736035,
0.0406710617,
0.0055591222,
0.0241415445,
-0.0013355688,
-0.0104030175,
0.0484983176,
0.0387958363,
-0.0104355654,
-0.0797977597,
-0.0066959425,
-0.0581060462,
-0.0279594548,
-0.0430018343,
-0.0480443686,
-0.0231866948,
-0.0054013897,
-0.0012513639,
-0.0602979884,
-0.0208167844,
-0.0242791418,
0.0532482825,
0.0174173806,
0.0141795129,
0.0278071649,
-0.0328500085,
-0.016307177,
-0.0007391449,
-0.0182775464,
0.0131691024,
-0.0899353847,
-0.0137486476,
-0.0074478863,
-0.0394484699,
-0.0332482755,
-0.0162833873,
-0.0059842402,
-0.1087083593,
-0.0002416254,
0.0432627052,
0.0122553222,
0.0904125199,
-0.0014508523,
-0.0377659388,
0.0324463136,
0.0281130373,
0.0020866101,
0.0110320235,
0.0199031346,
0.0264103618,
-0.0070592379,
0.0316139609,
-0.0458632894,
-0.0132580893,
0.0216098055,
0.0282971039,
-0.027673861,
-0.0403745174,
0.0424178764,
0.0037030948,
0.0287895408,
-0.0447609127,
-0.0274520814,
-0.0310830493,
-0.0170257334,
0.0270891227,
-0.0405720621,
0.006038161,
-0.0164621491,
0.0335237011,
-0.0049694548,
0.0289456956,
-0.0060473196,
0.0162255578,
-0.0029206616,
-0.0007806533,
-0.0002121665,
0.0122234523,
0.0489482321,
0.0694139823,
0.0358097926,
0.0156702623,
0.0393272825,
0.0100866314,
0.0664678365,
-0.0061361636,
0.0263524223,
0.0661581382,
0.0228134729,
-0.0105088372,
-0.002790171,
-0.0109208981,
-0.0646860003,
-0.0291291922,
-0.0116991112,
0.0615819655,
-0.0388953201,
0.0580341592,
-0.0466128625,
0.0000631394,
-0.0307178162,
0.0185770933,
-0.02780829,
-0.0046118964,
0.0241911802,
0.0225787126,
0.0043627438,
0.0126375444,
0.0651442036,
0.0110726878,
0.0311251618,
-0.0364860483,
0.0108689209,
-0.0361092798,
0.0047010588,
0.0128517663,
0.0132326102,
-0.0629383251,
-0.0260040853,
-0.0251050442,
-0.0633488297,
-0.0157563016,
0.0475361869,
0.00248712,
0.0048461431,
0.0613703169,
0.027700508,
-0.0410214365,
0.0390663184,
-0.0566154234,
-0.0249284878,
-0.0115624368,
-0.0219995882,
-0.045301646,
-6.401568114e-33,
-0.0254162773,
-0.0149747496,
0.0060879546,
-0.004596455,
-0.0076755141,
-0.0478554741,
0.0114965625,
0.0241145473,
-0.0134520084,
-0.0265752245,
0.0028265384,
-0.0239910651,
0.0168795623,
-0.0132174883,
0.0260697678,
0.0263305716,
0.0022729081,
-0.0230291449,
-0.0676562116,
-0.0208060779,
0.0449908413,
0.0004303442,
0.0218141079,
-0.0565777048,
0.0269133616,
0.0320597775,
-0.0139783276,
0.0329030529,
0.0105801336,
0.0845888555,
0.0043185321,
0.0038796235,
-0.013902802,
-0.0242585633,
-0.0310251284,
-0.0065325531,
-0.0214900654,
-0.0318820998,
0.0249899235,
0.0364165343,
-0.0186974443,
-0.0224570092,
0.0435223952,
-0.0029090068,
-0.0596835501,
0.0192783996,
0.0213042684,
-0.0044153831,
-0.0249655247,
0.0424821451,
-0.0543632209,
-0.0011801983,
-0.0066531193,
-0.0114104692,
0.0604878552,
-0.0140180346,
0.0078588361,
0.0173707418,
-0.0233251564,
0.0412433855,
-0.022294566,
0.0632287264,
0.1183242425,
0.0715746135,
0.0123907486,
0.0299008954,
0.0304722097,
-0.0542728789,
0.043659389,
-0.0127698537,
0.0443198606,
-0.0145005826,
-0.0156043619,
0.0460940003,
0.0246013347,
-0.005016672,
0.0013061918,
0.0355290212,
0.0099436594,
0.0085752038,
0.0318469293,
0.0481104031,
-0.07799422,
-0.0117452368,
-0.0723545402,
0.0024503791,
-0.0394129902,
-0.0366231725,
0.0306461714,
0.0088855848,
-0.013954143,
-0.058886718,
0.0138788782,
-0.0346325338,
-0.007844625,
0.0020633265,
-0.0509616882,
-0.0104775662,
-0.001216081,
0.0272034034,
-0.0558295101,
-0.0488514528,
-0.0516418405,
-0.015784502,
-0.0108592585,
0.0294395238,
-0.0039149644,
0.0108042425,
-0.0429319106,
0.0361260772,
-0.0194238573,
-0.0190037768,
0.0109028984,
0.0123883318,
0.0678552687,
-0.0390350856,
0.0020064812,
0.0446195081,
0.02836488,
-0.0362629406,
-0.0192432124,
-0.0184244104,
-0.0331824161,
0.0234988239,
-0.0209101979,
0.0364870057,
-0.0247369613,
0.0207616482,
-0.011590451,
-0.0228449833,
-0.0169729181,
0.0000946708,
2.819e-7,
0.0213107616,
0.0497289412,
0.0377962776,
0.0419831164,
-0.0459238328,
0.0678767562,
-0.0150734838,
0.0184085071,
-0.0007058748,
0.014986692,
0.0320737027,
0.0068136463,
0.0172562692,
-0.0123548349,
-0.0838626996,
0.0116714463,
-0.0500292443,
0.0604233071,
-0.0237106774,
0.0107301688,
-0.0076202084,
0.0639088973,
0.0193320569,
0.0154003911,
0.0070237219,
0.0245705582,
0.0488921776,
-0.0605461188,
0.0201399941,
0.011120881,
-0.0049004848,
-0.003536524,
-0.0420967042,
-0.0444741361,
-0.0001399772,
0.0296039749,
-0.0212714132,
0.0612295717,
0.0087052239,
-0.0276879016,
-0.0258037765,
0.0167270526,
-0.0049869446,
-0.0514168926,
0.0096810954,
-0.0368801318,
0.0022618133,
-0.0195596926,
-0.012106197,
-0.0027121413,
-0.0015548011,
-0.033449553,
-0.0145530002,
0.0119057149,
0.0148787154,
0.0249032304,
-0.0124610057,
-0.0269587394,
-0.0163662285,
0.03136402,
-0.0412021689,
-0.0281014349,
-0.0195627585,
0.0780293643,
0.0213368274,
-0.0184372123,
-0.0095914304,
2.531534073e-34,
0.0016430469,
-0.0123880915,
0.0303128865,
0.006164406,
-0.0132329799,
0.0177919455,
-0.0038775126,
0.0398520976,
0.0480142385,
-0.0522372685,
-0.0455564372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00841v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00841v2 | Tiny Titans: Can Smaller Large Language Models Punch Above Their Weight in the Real World for Meeting Summarization? | 2024-02-01T18:31:34 | 2024-04-15T17:56:58 | Xue-Yong Fu, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Elena Khasanova, Cheng Chen, Shashi Bhushan TN | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities to
solve a wide range of tasks without being explicitly fine-tuned on
task-specific datasets. However, deploying LLMs in the real world is not
trivial, as it requires substantial computing resources. In this paper, we
investigate whether smaller, compact LLMs are a good alternative to the
comparatively Larger LLMs2 to address significant costs associated with
utilizing LLMs in the real world. In this regard, we study the meeting
summarization task in a real-world industrial environment and conduct extensive
experiments by comparing the performance of fine-tuned compact LLMs (e.g.,
FLAN-T5, TinyLLaMA, LiteLLaMA) with zero-shot larger LLMs (e.g., LLaMA-2,
GPT-3.5, PaLM-2). We observe that most smaller LLMs, even after fine-tuning,
fail to outperform larger zero-shot LLMs in meeting summarization datasets.
However, a notable exception is FLAN-T5 (780M parameters), which performs on
par or even better than many zero-shot Larger LLMs (from 7B to above 70B
parameters), while being significantly smaller. This makes compact LLMs like
FLAN-T5 a suitable cost-efficient solution for real-world industrial
deployment. | [
0.0317330994,
-0.0179038923,
0.0206128284,
0.0521008186,
-0.0181147177,
-0.0118932445,
0.025228221,
-0.0079310089,
-0.0316879675,
-0.042040851,
-0.0444614477,
-0.046628736,
0.0336721465,
0.031432081,
0.0138277588,
-0.0908507854,
0.0152801359,
-0.0404906087,
-0.0326511376,
-0.0153756719,
0.0172879603,
-0.0053503676,
0.0247558299,
0.0434258655,
0.0085791843,
0.0079536121,
-0.0119546149,
-0.0001618692,
0.01839686,
0.0124575235,
-0.0210681017,
0.0070459321,
0.038751252,
0.042141322,
0.0000019719,
-0.0284519102,
0.0022518551,
-0.0187357329,
-0.0121659068,
0.0528654121,
0.0744850859,
-0.0195367988,
-0.005801178,
0.0463978499,
-0.0109727662,
-0.005337486,
0.0214181263,
0.0412178263,
0.0383138731,
0.0561138652,
-0.0052494616,
-0.0360376798,
-0.0045467145,
-0.0387406535,
-0.0349185877,
-0.0503026433,
0.013412416,
0.008458267,
0.0118666701,
-0.0147302356,
0.0247817282,
0.0520311445,
-0.0245917477,
-0.025104152,
-0.0162034016,
0.0488492027,
-0.08077804,
0.0001522569,
-0.0093307849,
0.0635003075,
0.0036185549,
0.0062366365,
0.025986081,
-0.0004161004,
-0.0174051821,
-0.0453028828,
-0.0893363208,
0.0194493961,
0.0066164993,
0.0278277993,
-0.0074406737,
0.0211193971,
-0.0098549668,
0.0034705084,
-0.0210489538,
0.0357463472,
-0.0036435516,
-0.0100833802,
-0.0567037202,
-0.0035089958,
-0.0074881581,
-0.0620315634,
0.0308403112,
0.044572711,
-0.0028969217,
0.023363905,
-0.0498085916,
-0.0213257112,
0.0109901158,
-0.0505000167,
0.0413475893,
0.0263798255,
0.0400487445,
0.0626349971,
-0.0087447176,
0.0366513804,
0.0083588427,
0.0095440829,
-0.0741165131,
-0.0158734154,
0.0041002431,
0.0230825339,
-0.0283359811,
0.0306484289,
-0.0718022361,
-0.052002307,
-0.0213788394,
0.0336806737,
0.0425579175,
0.0140441759,
0.0082776267,
0.000111852,
-0.0063857995,
-0.0195779651,
0.013564527,
0.0470595025,
-0.0094367322,
-0.009719966,
0.0159606878,
-0.057076592,
0.0040515638,
0.0198924448,
0.0161626767,
0.0290142819,
-0.013708855,
0.0681374669,
-0.0172045417,
-0.0400202684,
-0.0092690438,
-0.0102431308,
-0.0112229176,
-0.0640286207,
-0.0368959866,
-0.0703086331,
0.0188838709,
0.0173578635,
-0.0072633163,
0.007864085,
0.0014869341,
0.0040920754,
-0.0470250174,
0.0239272639,
-0.0223742295,
0.0535813272,
0.0452418551,
-0.0124057876,
0.0129710166,
0.0682604834,
0.0686247349,
0.077844508,
0.0495158397,
0.0245132633,
-0.0003163362,
0.0631230995,
-0.0121170897,
0.0239117928,
-0.0042576278,
-0.0134457229,
-0.0248830225,
0.0096754348,
0.0200941917,
0.0791446045,
-0.0230541918,
0.0244801641,
0.0895513743,
0.0775581375,
0.0302007496,
-0.0068799756,
-0.0110998247,
0.0353695601,
0.0092270225,
0.0114149274,
0.0005269657,
0.0233171657,
-0.030281378,
0.0437047109,
0.1115079373,
0.0159402471,
-0.0411583893,
-0.0272989795,
-0.0279182196,
-0.0020066414,
-0.0523510575,
-0.0056410665,
0.0302848704,
-0.0493078493,
-0.0694796816,
0.0737945661,
0.0237726457,
-0.0547387302,
-0.0250404961,
-0.0419797972,
0.0003435808,
0.0775860623,
0.0481275953,
-0.0353772826,
-0.0239949226,
-0.0085074641,
-0.0030126886,
0.0551589616,
0.0857318863,
-0.0142127918,
0.0046141623,
-0.0640766174,
-0.0097183157,
0.0355055407,
-0.0103571201,
-0.0049336911,
0.0021131213,
-0.0019986304,
0.0375645496,
-0.0001443523,
-0.0599905327,
0.0122932214,
0.0067724064,
-0.0043590055,
-0.019849699,
-0.0081827249,
0.0282848813,
0.038718693,
-0.0077048489,
-0.0046834159,
0.0435689762,
-0.0339602828,
0.0422296561,
-0.014148172,
-0.0381125771,
-0.0256129727,
0.0521276407,
-0.0018373356,
0.0342779905,
0.032347735,
-0.0627994612,
-0.0767738298,
0.0121058151,
-0.047234349,
0.0117477058,
-0.0227102861,
0.038350787,
-0.0034445415,
0.002091896,
-0.0206493717,
0.0269466639,
-0.0062340633,
-0.0166736599,
0.0383080617,
-0.0043654423,
0.0054575023,
-0.0666956976,
-0.0315581039,
0.0288521964,
0.0287545361,
0.0199281126,
0.0186762959,
0.0184161421,
-0.0192958489,
-0.0268234927,
-0.1029174924,
0.0080188531,
-0.0175673477,
0.0043217028,
0.0273543764,
0.0232330412,
-0.0035113192,
0.0108827362,
-0.0435435995,
0.0025212332,
0.0403641462,
0.013917095,
0.025763141,
0.0312809497,
-0.01802627,
-0.0875602961,
-0.0236869268,
0.0365930349,
0.0292714033,
-0.0040920833,
-0.0583326146,
-0.055741448,
0.0400067493,
-0.0245888215,
-0.0018370448,
0.0031728193,
-0.0347875133,
-0.0268238112,
-0.0234338585,
0.0508717038,
0.0434771106,
0.0174249336,
-0.0010673938,
0.0352840573,
0.0031064267,
-0.0472126305,
-0.0055988068,
-0.0144979116,
-0.0000959076,
-0.0106263254,
-0.0229681805,
0.0060301456,
0.0264923628,
-0.0084432494,
0.0305675436,
-0.0500181317,
0.0244744234,
0.0015835697,
-0.0013366719,
-0.0264380854,
-0.009933386,
-0.0505778529,
0.0625176132,
-0.0110163903,
-0.033731889,
-0.0025683686,
-0.0548664443,
0.0016648895,
-0.0153419385,
-0.0252654701,
-0.0606711209,
0.0212152041,
-0.0071018273,
0.0275426731,
-0.0552308224,
-0.0259100609,
-0.027271837,
-0.0088432878,
-0.0082545979,
-0.0461999215,
0.0815769061,
-0.0370490812,
0.035169173,
-0.0565596446,
-0.0279170331,
-0.0108657945,
-0.0010632172,
-0.0648716837,
0.0243197381,
0.0090876464,
0.0064246664,
-0.1092842966,
0.077953957,
0.0263631474,
0.0668762848,
-0.0158282835,
0.0065386998,
-0.0189502183,
0.0516482815,
0.0367771462,
0.0337995179,
0.0490912907,
-0.0352516696,
0.0171517562,
0.0293155648,
0.0849029347,
-0.0203316342,
-0.0013799898,
-0.0488277301,
0.0304163806,
-0.0243233405,
-0.0099613899,
-0.0103992578,
0.0577880628,
-0.036814291,
0.0213597789,
0.1019013003,
-0.0072262199,
-0.041937381,
-0.0230345093,
0.0026277981,
0.0541319624,
-0.003589974,
0.0182514396,
-0.0689558238,
-0.0233257543,
0.0251895301,
0.0441939868,
0.0034830719,
-0.0052985875,
-0.0402665362,
-0.1147160828,
0.0361535251,
0.023329379,
-0.0131892478,
-0.0271530598,
-0.0205095503,
0.0114103872,
-0.0257030297,
0.0443706885,
0.0371640697,
-0.0349009633,
-0.0387593023,
0.0274380408,
-0.0749913529,
-0.0398462862,
-0.0130021777,
-0.009474894,
0.0417736545,
0.0161320493,
0.024159411,
0.0124216042,
0.0055935737,
0.0374789163,
-0.0064850277,
0.0193650071,
-0.0153036797,
0.0485942438,
-0.0051964335,
-0.0071817315,
0.0109725958,
0.0073833996,
-0.0089784414,
0.0212464333,
0.0080549857,
0.0155669823,
-0.0028029447,
0.001177407,
-0.0158392061,
0.0461410061,
-0.0486663058,
0.0750129744,
0.0354383774,
0.0072381403,
-0.0443670601,
-0.0225536507,
-0.0219242275,
-0.0265059453,
-0.017220512,
-0.0237505287,
-0.0276992675,
-0.0329360366,
-0.0546941571,
-0.0463085882,
0.0551355965,
0.0153455846,
-0.0139355259,
0.0085053788,
-0.0311337542,
0.0392174385,
-0.0350498892,
-0.0148351509,
-0.0649258718,
-0.0126748346,
-0.0940628573,
0.0111038787,
0.0417141728,
-0.001686349,
-0.0110325571,
0.0295853838,
-0.1135374829,
-0.0777354166,
-0.0164153557,
0.044272624,
0.0343246199,
0.042583067,
0.0308039449,
-0.0419449732,
0.0589085557,
0.0150313554,
0.0024981287,
0.0493359156,
-0.0057200678,
0.0005464799,
-0.0325288847,
0.0322515741,
-0.0636424273,
0.0313935466,
-0.0329677053,
0.0283067618,
-0.0343755707,
-0.0843187645,
-0.0357288383,
0.0657549724,
-0.0152006987,
-0.0064996439,
-0.0210423935,
-0.0142454011,
0.0140155694,
-0.0222146623,
0.0006446342,
-0.0372950397,
0.0031136521,
-0.0481873602,
-0.0048668715,
-0.0006814649,
0.0206795167,
-0.0108224144,
0.0163528025,
-0.0348852985,
0.0084398016,
-0.0405470766,
-0.0593811981,
0.0117752971,
-0.0105722323,
-0.0651611015,
-0.0002809532,
-0.019606078,
0.0058877929,
-0.0181421153,
-0.0113599598,
0.0137714716,
-0.001615531,
-0.029626783,
0.0742563009,
-0.0671432391,
-0.0466102697,
-0.0479121581,
0.0575675108,
0.0554075167,
-0.0023657326,
0.0862885341,
-0.023931358,
0.0184848364,
-0.0615930073,
0.0119217569,
0.0154665802,
-0.0086103389,
-0.0068097757,
0.0234158933,
0.0032757593,
0.0389057845,
0.0930252597,
-0.0186793022,
0.0025687397,
0.0212513097,
-0.0016468834,
-0.0454944521,
-0.0090925666,
-0.0176257771,
0.0437223949,
0.0095655583,
-0.041394759,
-0.060583733,
-0.0011481016,
0.0485767312,
-0.0173846353,
-0.0107012335,
-0.0746518224,
0.0425862037,
0.0260078628,
0.0558837093,
0.0311378762,
-0.0237096343,
-0.0408945978,
-0.0007356261,
0.0159009062,
0.0183914248,
-6.5043673e-33,
-0.0483125225,
-0.0199456178,
0.009817048,
0.0399222001,
-0.0429005697,
0.0176124182,
-0.0505370945,
-0.0106990822,
-0.0099628409,
-0.0365811251,
-0.0386765972,
0.0087886062,
0.0338296518,
0.0197673272,
-0.0147595983,
0.0194086153,
0.066521354,
-0.0155825317,
-0.0270496178,
0.0471048877,
0.0322138406,
0.0177635681,
0.0092685735,
-0.0327624418,
-0.0285300612,
-0.0317671783,
0.0020501788,
-0.012600882,
0.0558631606,
0.0282146391,
-0.0366226994,
0.0529782362,
0.0253175683,
-0.0051724454,
-0.0475840457,
0.0216997769,
-0.0294482075,
0.0001263287,
0.0337983705,
0.010188573,
0.0180587787,
-0.0220008176,
0.0280627999,
0.0090116635,
-0.019470362,
-0.0354598835,
0.0168823283,
-0.0428456552,
-0.0650564879,
-0.0156941339,
-0.0064511062,
0.0374897495,
0.0160272103,
-0.0344017148,
0.0670309141,
0.0228628125,
0.000746871,
-0.0027799704,
-0.0393840484,
0.072388269,
0.0605444871,
0.0426008478,
0.0709915683,
0.0446820594,
0.0064081037,
0.0696512684,
0.0099252034,
0.0110298907,
0.0073051928,
-0.0289470963,
0.0019144213,
0.0349306874,
0.0144920507,
0.0173019841,
0.0127254268,
0.0104816156,
-0.0205873027,
0.0380968936,
0.0106575387,
-0.0026760446,
0.0585869439,
0.0186960157,
-0.0118623283,
-0.0174899213,
-0.0109150531,
0.0451261029,
-0.0294198915,
-0.0102815609,
0.003025959,
0.0328353494,
-0.0311682019,
-0.0164331961,
0.0526810884,
-0.0247772131,
0.0083781974,
0.0200124029,
-0.0092110783,
0.021235045,
-0.0176777747,
-0.0129960151,
-0.0673689395,
-0.0033690981,
0.0087012015,
0.0148026841,
-0.0170937236,
0.0003947492,
-0.005443078,
0.0150378617,
-0.0410755463,
0.017434923,
-0.0078484071,
0.0249215141,
-0.0413475707,
-0.0095828883,
0.0276579615,
-0.035441447,
0.0014313663,
0.0543395467,
-0.0266858004,
-0.0303993374,
0.0131676039,
-0.0119401589,
0.00556358,
0.0369189382,
-0.0693180785,
0.0421437919,
-0.0489753336,
0.0281159747,
0.0735053569,
-0.0063104481,
-0.0298705082,
-0.0172247477,
2.648e-7,
0.0264070276,
0.0482562333,
0.0586102158,
0.015302795,
0.0069999313,
0.02323246,
-0.0075964029,
0.0183471926,
0.028309701,
0.0334492847,
0.0315402113,
0.0215758812,
0.0653847903,
0.0158712864,
-0.0757591873,
0.0225900896,
-0.1062797382,
-0.013884048,
-0.0399067886,
-0.0080964454,
0.0121491039,
0.1120698825,
-0.0106551796,
-0.0199724343,
-0.0262841154,
-0.0489329696,
0.0451439805,
-0.0488171764,
-0.0367734507,
0.0062119146,
0.0300248079,
0.0465191938,
-0.0441936441,
-0.0166795161,
0.0202504285,
-0.0110643031,
0.0309822168,
0.0758037269,
-0.0029088533,
-0.0091826078,
0.0497264303,
-0.0198944211,
-0.0204362441,
-0.0000857848,
0.0492926389,
-0.0426893532,
0.0015847539,
-0.002388936,
-0.0074160015,
-0.0171758942,
-0.0464802533,
0.0002826783,
-0.0252314173,
0.0280259158,
-0.0201744922,
-0.0352032855,
0.0046775644,
-0.0787133127,
-0.0133518353,
0.0350213759,
-0.0266763233,
-0.0716269389,
-0.0325386561,
-0.0383866355,
-0.002554015,
-0.022999594,
-0.0185157787,
2.459415658e-34,
0.0530916154,
-0.0110342791,
-0.0396071598,
0.0552716926,
-0.0015563647,
-0.0233283341,
0.0041417987,
-0.0060210815,
0.0150330542,
-0.1134791002,
-0.0051506166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00838v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00838v4 | OLMo: Accelerating the Science of Language Models | 2024-02-01T18:28:55 | 2024-06-07T21:59:52 | Dirk Groeneveld, Iz Beltagy, Pete Walsh, Akshita Bhagia, Rodney Kinney, Oyvind Tafjord, Ananya Harsh Jha, Hamish Ivison, Ian Magnusson, Yizhong Wang, Shane Arora, David Atkinson, Russell Authur, Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, Arman Cohan, Jennifer Dumas, Yanai Elazar, Yuling Gu, Jack Hessel, Tushar Khot, William Merrill, Jacob Morrison, Niklas Muennighoff, Aakanksha Naik, Crystal Nam, Matthew E. Peters, Valentina Pyatkin, Abhilasha Ravichander, Dustin Schwenk, Saurabh Shah, Will Smith, Emma Strubell, Nishant Subramani, Mitchell Wortsman, Pradeep Dasigi, Nathan Lambert, Kyle Richardson, Luke Zettlemoyer, Jesse Dodge, Kyle Lo, Luca Soldaini, Noah A. Smith, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) have become ubiquitous in both NLP research and in
commercial product offerings. As their commercial importance has surged, the
most powerful models have become closed off, gated behind proprietary
interfaces, with important details of their training data, architectures, and
development undisclosed. Given the importance of these details in
scientifically studying these models, including their biases and potential
risks, we believe it is essential for the research community to have access to
powerful, truly open LMs. To this end, we have built OLMo, a competitive, truly
Open Language Model, to enable the scientific study of language models. Unlike
most prior efforts that have only released model weights and inference code, we
release OLMo alongside open training data and training and evaluation code. We
hope this release will empower the open research community and inspire a new
wave of innovation. | [
0.0362867564,
0.1059186831,
-0.0129534295,
0.0552931204,
-0.0228223316,
-0.0065288325,
0.0054404517,
0.0170986019,
-0.0138259716,
-0.037968576,
-0.0576814227,
-0.0289226081,
0.0014089412,
0.0576569587,
0.0192444939,
-0.0202745087,
0.0347660556,
-0.0276184417,
0.0010852732,
0.0002001132,
0.0203756336,
0.022496229,
0.0161427297,
0.0380040854,
0.0439382046,
-0.0184789393,
0.020712886,
-0.0011127797,
-0.0344034545,
-0.0279075988,
0.0150310472,
0.0742097124,
0.0042267703,
0.0549656637,
0.0000018969,
-0.0525051393,
-0.0181246437,
-0.001696788,
-0.0398790352,
0.0296898838,
0.0719039738,
-0.0318085849,
0.0077424538,
0.017332688,
-0.0247257333,
-0.0377316289,
0.0762937441,
0.0098527623,
0.0291983895,
0.0687943622,
-0.0014340761,
-0.0272201225,
0.0306166448,
-0.0528754964,
-0.0277572274,
-0.0042358842,
0.0321825445,
-0.017199263,
-0.0214363895,
0.0366941653,
-0.0162084941,
0.029284779,
-0.000561717,
0.0250292569,
0.0037191757,
0.038874235,
-0.0301086698,
-0.0517595932,
-0.0127617149,
0.0803925395,
0.0057314197,
-0.0478004478,
0.0062766843,
0.0066289306,
-0.0457550697,
-0.0054330472,
-0.0638393238,
0.0734839961,
0.0421679057,
0.0514481254,
0.0405567549,
-0.0000844133,
0.0470606573,
0.0318076834,
0.0066415984,
0.0784801766,
0.038399145,
-0.0068572946,
0.003234206,
-0.020353429,
-0.0256221872,
-0.0557973534,
-0.0121543361,
-0.0035218732,
0.0262893252,
0.0247925576,
-0.0271741785,
-0.026464222,
0.04815704,
-0.0548444577,
0.0745345205,
0.0192051902,
-0.0132131185,
0.0260973275,
0.001405944,
0.0181470364,
-0.0184127297,
0.0195959173,
-0.0138532175,
-0.0057600592,
-0.0258942619,
-0.0167684276,
-0.0063888035,
0.0189374872,
-0.0551416613,
-0.0325133018,
-0.023464445,
0.004277532,
0.0036000467,
-0.0297158323,
0.0366560072,
0.0147925336,
-0.0147509063,
-0.0099637089,
-0.0361819863,
0.0170558784,
-0.0029907804,
0.0143994763,
-0.0168589987,
-0.0755529925,
-0.0174731221,
0.0303729624,
-0.0175966322,
-0.0264187641,
0.0050846776,
0.0677018166,
0.0460855924,
-0.0326753445,
-0.008616887,
-0.0071958117,
-0.023483498,
-0.0632959604,
-0.0083892513,
-0.0781233534,
0.0179171171,
0.0184656754,
0.0232175123,
-0.0567372218,
0.0205974951,
0.0188285988,
-0.0570156649,
0.0655862093,
-0.06206448,
-0.0169372,
-0.0122814402,
-0.0077703991,
0.0473242477,
0.0574845448,
0.0113825845,
-0.0314606018,
0.0654137507,
0.0042841444,
-0.0011452761,
0.0643365458,
0.0094193714,
-0.0147587676,
-0.0195189193,
0.0282635465,
0.0391045734,
0.0361654051,
0.0317707248,
0.0655710772,
-0.0147249959,
-0.0376473293,
0.0755772963,
0.0507767387,
0.0280467104,
0.0221791118,
0.0128702577,
-0.0071349223,
0.000866346,
-0.0420869552,
-0.0314571895,
-0.0080331853,
-0.0298165586,
0.0091453595,
0.0288484432,
0.0407284796,
-0.0188167226,
-0.0205595642,
-0.0645526424,
-0.0312905833,
-0.004079673,
-0.0219860282,
0.0582868271,
0.0025987527,
0.0167599153,
0.0683100447,
0.0774586499,
-0.045034308,
0.0103393216,
-0.0574986711,
0.0476505198,
0.0244659055,
0.0621867105,
-0.001606168,
0.0166136846,
-0.0147051299,
-0.0034867688,
0.0695086196,
0.0640145093,
-0.0080719208,
0.0244992785,
-0.0373415649,
0.0067787278,
-0.0189093649,
0.0408911034,
0.0028556718,
0.0456186235,
-0.0153875332,
0.0150457071,
-0.0324465558,
-0.0524076149,
0.0551057421,
-0.0550006106,
-0.0221902542,
-0.006856129,
-0.0459402092,
0.0302048624,
0.0105618723,
-0.0020157301,
0.0274874698,
0.0385248736,
-0.0281793233,
-0.0043209619,
-0.002201735,
0.0048450809,
-0.0194057673,
0.0456479415,
-0.0129860519,
0.0336254798,
0.0473271385,
-0.0248757228,
-0.0226801317,
0.0515260994,
0.0122967921,
0.0608381964,
-0.06990318,
0.0211833511,
-0.0139884837,
0.0306230746,
-0.0165305808,
0.0580337197,
-0.0213872567,
0.0503330119,
0.0260382518,
-0.0212867651,
0.0196162667,
-0.041144304,
-0.0330500863,
0.0094765294,
-0.0149453403,
0.0102314791,
0.0044056857,
-0.0056549581,
-0.0335587077,
-0.0174354855,
-0.0768203065,
0.0326311216,
-0.0207384974,
0.0181031469,
0.0252208635,
0.0120298984,
-0.0131174019,
0.0080419248,
0.0034155443,
-0.0173638649,
0.0105719352,
0.008975694,
0.0378815569,
-0.0143384431,
-0.017265806,
-0.0606169738,
-0.0508442968,
-0.0092933811,
0.0590024963,
-0.0274243746,
0.0160758123,
-0.0276152287,
0.0048820521,
-0.0455990992,
0.0566605963,
-0.0120832818,
-0.0148145314,
0.0081879161,
-0.038346719,
0.0219225697,
0.0461446047,
-0.0061454158,
0.0274981372,
0.0637793094,
-0.0108162984,
-0.0320261605,
-0.0268696509,
-0.033700861,
-0.0235450864,
-0.0237375237,
-0.0243287925,
-0.0027767336,
0.0973172188,
-0.0080517512,
-0.0266230814,
-0.0203020312,
0.0026233583,
-0.0277887862,
-0.0074271644,
-0.0009144618,
0.0093082525,
-0.0325327367,
0.0358785391,
-0.0433314443,
-0.0743656456,
0.0469780006,
-0.066584304,
0.0083129043,
-0.0324148014,
-0.0068379473,
-0.0735322908,
0.0626691058,
-0.0032166338,
0.0058781686,
0.0401897244,
0.0004094323,
0.0000922922,
0.0181015264,
0.0023094367,
-0.0417690799,
0.0162714645,
-0.0507548787,
0.0193043072,
0.0050415508,
-0.0248978604,
0.0000631927,
-0.0325899459,
-0.0466232225,
0.031893108,
0.015906835,
-0.0169174857,
-0.0381675363,
0.0187958628,
-0.0039968719,
0.0301107373,
-0.0176932532,
0.0230099261,
-0.0191026665,
0.0238816235,
0.0782113746,
-0.0095472317,
0.0152113354,
-0.0626316145,
-0.0109862741,
0.0417664573,
0.0426221378,
0.0380506292,
-0.0372047722,
0.0047694361,
0.050953418,
-0.0257200208,
-0.0330895856,
-0.000858853,
0.0222725999,
-0.025928095,
-0.0092549445,
0.1276543587,
0.0219028033,
-0.0596260689,
0.0077963611,
-0.0140901636,
0.0454362594,
0.031070888,
0.0037519769,
-0.0783985481,
-0.0459344275,
0.0055575646,
0.014865079,
0.0031735529,
-0.0194435921,
-0.015007182,
-0.105953373,
-0.004711132,
-0.0046621836,
-0.0346756093,
-0.006279489,
-0.0574279763,
-0.0014106031,
-0.0639792681,
0.0146124912,
0.0157902446,
-0.0213712342,
0.0165597983,
0.0141881471,
-0.0213519651,
-0.0525552034,
0.0314375646,
-0.064629823,
0.066911757,
0.0637016222,
-0.0057350197,
-0.0084154019,
-0.038739305,
0.0383688211,
-0.013340096,
-0.0173557904,
-0.0474699549,
0.0470290333,
-0.0261018202,
-0.0065764445,
-0.0337017514,
0.0374632627,
-0.0529871248,
-0.0063365418,
-0.033461228,
0.0700860247,
0.0341700949,
-0.0240363162,
-0.0249487087,
-0.0165968072,
-0.0176413842,
0.0801797882,
0.006410602,
-0.0436414629,
-0.0278614517,
-0.0199370496,
0.0018085157,
0.0005786001,
-0.0349780023,
0.0106090205,
0.0229585245,
-0.0471514873,
-0.0408627912,
-0.0054574194,
0.0170946643,
-0.0029324663,
0.0183648318,
0.0086917067,
-0.0308772251,
-0.0340245441,
-0.0435374528,
0.058147531,
-0.0490020216,
0.0193598345,
-0.0613628663,
0.0043658791,
0.0592394844,
0.0003489478,
-0.0209951214,
0.0294095017,
-0.0925985724,
-0.0839944184,
-0.0090307016,
0.0607803576,
0.0320506319,
-0.0045127715,
0.0004218399,
-0.0751992911,
0.0115426676,
-0.002889941,
-0.0256097186,
0.0282778647,
0.0168650635,
-0.0271622483,
0.0335319601,
0.0448689796,
-0.0208603516,
-0.0033350964,
0.0164940003,
0.0406126231,
-0.0066484758,
-0.042466905,
0.0251448322,
-0.0189913511,
0.0617352352,
-0.0024658523,
-0.0203596391,
-0.0637977123,
-0.0004659725,
-0.0175368823,
-0.0079754805,
-0.0566275306,
0.0127103487,
0.0545022748,
0.0220656749,
-0.0126640964,
0.0172179658,
-0.0272869524,
0.0644060373,
-0.0525824726,
0.0232224111,
0.0377761647,
-0.0040678577,
-0.002595413,
0.0020817749,
-0.0258379821,
0.0284247678,
-0.0768195167,
0.0310459267,
-0.0348666944,
0.0275004748,
-0.0037012012,
0.0032102223,
0.0200201198,
0.0237727389,
-0.0497532226,
-0.0052436301,
-0.0271089431,
0.0323590301,
0.0344957821,
0.004782219,
0.0758932307,
-0.0217577647,
-0.0104495231,
-0.0305300727,
0.0404725745,
-0.0083241276,
-0.0473840013,
0.0491885245,
0.015712684,
-0.0325881056,
-0.0103708655,
0.0950510204,
0.0515172631,
0.0263437033,
-0.0208237097,
0.0052462476,
-0.0148368785,
0.0042196661,
0.0402136818,
0.0318069644,
-0.0446880534,
0.0163237303,
-0.0391093194,
-0.0673129559,
-0.0004163177,
0.0214925874,
0.0108068315,
-0.0100388452,
0.0185980573,
0.0788405389,
0.0131462626,
-0.0469945818,
-0.0488416702,
-0.0223569218,
-0.0233369824,
-0.0238108709,
-0.0173451658,
-6.706834446e-33,
-0.0183796566,
0.0119758826,
-0.009089306,
-0.0110368766,
-0.0325256027,
0.0076217856,
-0.0185395889,
0.0385939218,
-0.0451144762,
-0.0290595852,
0.001904582,
0.0295864381,
-0.0031268105,
0.0427101888,
0.0199196953,
0.0238411669,
0.0199018084,
-0.0376095586,
-0.0077439807,
-0.014985132,
0.0239142776,
0.0338152274,
0.0476977006,
-0.0152849965,
0.0652718097,
-0.0362147689,
-0.0134350033,
0.032579571,
-0.011454653,
0.064106673,
-0.0501083583,
0.0241651349,
0.0287859123,
-0.0323883034,
-0.0082607949,
-0.0180194601,
-0.0684889778,
0.0093528777,
0.0380058028,
-0.0215503611,
-0.0275706481,
-0.0084754312,
0.0335086584,
-0.0161398835,
-0.0074260235,
-0.0231165551,
0.017783029,
-0.0227834806,
-0.0309701506,
0.034560062,
-0.0352764577,
0.0330301896,
0.0178110525,
0.0091529572,
0.0316071995,
-0.0073920861,
-0.0206964109,
0.0226104856,
-0.0186439045,
0.0167927537,
0.0315102525,
0.0566668957,
0.0571055189,
0.0505042151,
0.0175622981,
0.0535898246,
0.0060715061,
-0.034210939,
-0.0325059667,
0.0150135802,
0.0516260229,
0.0612600073,
0.0536791608,
0.0140141994,
0.0178991482,
0.0000994256,
-0.0685757473,
-0.019776471,
0.0369168855,
0.0200069696,
0.0291085988,
0.0160752386,
-0.0091790091,
-0.027856607,
-0.0515907481,
-0.0795653462,
-0.0405473709,
-0.0137491943,
0.0170186423,
0.0262705795,
-0.0209720042,
-0.0140371034,
0.020966379,
-0.063193351,
-0.0169474389,
-0.0056349253,
0.026630193,
0.0204812344,
-0.0056620943,
0.0303630158,
-0.1055314168,
-0.0363459177,
-0.0172469728,
-0.0223308541,
-0.0028727858,
0.0047852891,
0.0066968268,
0.0063987649,
-0.0507160388,
0.0017136878,
-0.0374502167,
-0.0003891331,
0.0054609468,
0.0555681251,
0.0249781441,
0.0003663711,
-0.0006615464,
0.0468020104,
0.0392311551,
0.0335128009,
-0.0521084629,
-0.0078331605,
0.0050368668,
0.014785124,
-0.0218209866,
0.0017496498,
-0.031767413,
0.0132174818,
0.0265327394,
-0.0298771225,
-0.0133808879,
0.0083413702,
2.503e-7,
0.0731566101,
0.0193859041,
0.0063534472,
0.04171196,
0.0205051582,
0.014431824,
-0.0264567323,
0.0544075444,
0.0048024687,
-0.0162374321,
-0.0404197015,
0.0175404362,
0.0665570945,
-0.0093202442,
-0.0738014206,
-0.0105581023,
-0.0619829074,
-0.0034621847,
-0.0528963283,
-0.0314083658,
0.0008918574,
0.1281647235,
0.0110764951,
0.0057062847,
-0.030975882,
-0.0366100781,
0.0872514993,
-0.0478596389,
-0.0040649464,
0.0307099074,
0.0154057611,
0.038473282,
-0.0154378572,
-0.0310251676,
-0.0145206675,
0.0392539725,
-0.0056864177,
0.0646379888,
0.004345607,
-0.0503100678,
0.0458716191,
-0.0422255546,
-0.0373422429,
-0.0681260601,
0.0902065262,
-0.0181331914,
-0.0413790084,
-0.0475614555,
0.0056435503,
0.0045796321,
0.012745277,
-0.0547468849,
-0.0153316893,
0.0027938983,
0.0132151069,
-0.032122504,
-0.0295973979,
-0.0651678443,
-0.0646880865,
-0.0508959927,
-0.0364098996,
-0.0495038107,
-0.0132371234,
-0.0152943628,
-0.0022084939,
-0.0336811505,
0.0137841227,
2.608489693e-34,
0.0584463999,
-0.0112634925,
-0.015804816,
0.0394023471,
0.0296026878,
-0.0364489257,
0.0337164477,
0.0163774807,
-0.0147487121,
-0.1251100451,
-0.0143562257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00835v1 | ALISON: Fast and Effective Stylometric Authorship Obfuscation | 2024-02-01T18:22:32 | 2024-02-01T18:22:32 | Eric Xing, Saranya Venkatraman, Thai Le, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.0 | Authorship Attribution (AA) and Authorship Obfuscation (AO) are two competing
tasks of increasing importance in privacy research. Modern AA leverages an
author's consistent writing style to match a text to its author using an AA
classifier. AO is the corresponding adversarial task, aiming to modify a text
in such a way that its semantics are preserved, yet an AA model cannot
correctly infer its authorship. To address privacy concerns raised by
state-of-the-art (SOTA) AA methods, new AO methods have been proposed but
remain largely impractical to use due to their prohibitively slow training and
obfuscation speed, often taking hours. To this challenge, we propose a
practical AO method, ALISON, that (1) dramatically reduces training/obfuscation
time, demonstrating more than 10x faster obfuscation than SOTA AO methods, (2)
achieves better obfuscation success through attacking three transformer-based
AA methods on two benchmark datasets, typically performing 15% better than
competing methods, (3) does not require direct signals from a target AA
classifier during obfuscation, and (4) utilizes unique stylometric features,
allowing sound model interpretation for explainable obfuscation. We also
demonstrate that ALISON can effectively prevent four SOTA AA methods from
accurately determining the authorship of ChatGPT-generated texts, all while
minimally changing the original text semantics. To ensure the reproducibility
of our findings, our code and data are available at:
https://github.com/EricX003/ALISON. | [
0.010600403,
0.1068911552,
-0.0321827829,
0.0633746386,
-0.0680332705,
-0.0002673264,
0.0890969634,
0.0059057181,
-0.0002610993,
0.0287859403,
-0.0207475852,
-0.0249851719,
0.0430014357,
0.0230260864,
0.0217398722,
0.0591879673,
-0.0351215638,
0.0413170755,
0.01130147,
-0.0066798199,
-0.0195582286,
0.0214523226,
0.0267891157,
0.0313385427,
0.0339593925,
-0.043608997,
0.0191319361,
-0.0033505682,
0.035941612,
0.0323518701,
0.0056269527,
0.0401070006,
-0.0218127053,
0.1121439338,
0.0000019416,
-0.0239089448,
-0.0262721144,
0.0558773987,
-0.0182637963,
0.0086228298,
0.0696787164,
0.0136172334,
-0.0133657735,
0.0156427789,
-0.0240104925,
0.0202863961,
0.023957748,
0.043163497,
0.0390173271,
0.099360384,
-0.025708558,
-0.0592808351,
0.0296171401,
-0.034080606,
0.0153775234,
-0.0084914044,
0.0083906306,
-0.0805582255,
-0.041330941,
0.0446612686,
-0.0007415831,
0.0777708367,
0.0040125083,
-0.0067273038,
-0.025981307,
0.0172567405,
0.0052754437,
0.0226835255,
0.0425655618,
0.0070124851,
-0.0028681855,
-0.0458154306,
0.0335730873,
0.0403754339,
0.0143870087,
0.0442433655,
0.0148827462,
0.0334827192,
-0.0535407849,
-0.036485482,
-0.0223976653,
0.0044214218,
0.029851187,
0.0084570916,
0.0237292182,
-0.0011604739,
0.0057164324,
-0.0039734789,
-0.0553132147,
-0.0500072911,
-0.0207009055,
-0.0542285331,
0.0742888898,
-0.0133863166,
0.0598117486,
-0.0072851204,
-0.0582068935,
-0.0773271322,
0.0024118577,
-0.0274557807,
0.0171406046,
-0.0111836214,
0.0078736087,
0.030456949,
-0.0322782397,
0.0570880696,
-0.0321031548,
0.0276890695,
-0.0033650494,
-0.005371612,
-0.0286186878,
-0.0334285796,
-0.0381567106,
0.0030949495,
-0.018897118,
0.0023754651,
-0.0316037275,
0.0030282354,
0.0156663992,
0.0092145475,
-0.0415378511,
0.0103171095,
-0.0535043702,
0.0119557772,
0.0526910163,
-0.0227898937,
0.012747054,
-0.0059136027,
-0.004781045,
0.0062421169,
-0.0216736458,
0.0189331546,
0.0139630903,
-0.013814996,
0.0242559444,
0.0493347608,
-0.0036064985,
-0.0110593243,
0.0210151616,
-0.0359921455,
-0.028093012,
-0.0223382451,
-0.0303972326,
-0.0065159299,
-0.0070445137,
0.0010156024,
-0.0192042869,
-0.0966187567,
-0.0303130429,
0.0203058012,
-0.0402259566,
0.0667288601,
0.021779228,
-0.0357816778,
0.0546669811,
0.02747982,
0.00554953,
-0.0279470254,
0.0551628545,
0.0910322145,
0.0370237306,
-0.0236960389,
0.0487097651,
0.0035279819,
0.0458525755,
0.0076457476,
0.041379109,
-0.0106488708,
-0.0053117657,
-0.0216833688,
0.0032871261,
0.0175217185,
0.0152758555,
-0.0823354796,
0.0554919653,
0.0161398072,
-0.0023736686,
0.0671308786,
-0.0125655532,
0.0318388753,
-0.0012897028,
-0.0227997601,
-0.018990906,
0.0101927919,
-0.098516129,
-0.0401569642,
-0.0527338237,
0.0243007429,
-0.0042714109,
-0.0078992061,
0.0253923293,
-0.0207099691,
0.0415464453,
0.016137505,
0.007656069,
0.0395010933,
-0.0373981111,
-0.0242265202,
-0.0207694396,
-0.0515688807,
-0.025598336,
-0.0593218766,
0.0030320187,
0.0139043005,
0.0775873587,
-0.0293801725,
0.0214927197,
-0.0594082326,
-0.0000604394,
0.0054474398,
-0.0251283273,
0.0181568675,
0.0683315322,
-0.0430616364,
-0.0255209915,
-0.0434085056,
-0.0056744772,
0.0746379271,
0.033828862,
0.0029638337,
0.0383239202,
-0.0345359854,
0.0041235308,
0.0196584966,
-0.02648261,
-0.0571825765,
0.0516652055,
0.0092038158,
0.031595666,
-0.0044103414,
-0.0165298358,
0.0077467868,
-0.0042787152,
-0.037928842,
-0.03114767,
-0.0021657983,
0.0233841334,
-0.0331874825,
-0.0063444781,
-0.0082367687,
-0.0082138404,
0.0372196436,
-0.0277741905,
-0.0095102759,
0.0128822969,
0.0019775853,
0.007607637,
-0.0241888836,
0.0064078798,
-0.0120176775,
0.0559615865,
-0.0445657596,
0.0355846025,
0.0072484175,
0.0124006206,
-0.0582578368,
-0.0299302079,
0.0432220176,
-0.0036981965,
-0.0100525217,
-0.0353156775,
-0.0434511565,
0.0124160862,
0.0182549264,
0.0060295188,
0.030216502,
-0.0869686082,
-0.0141905639,
0.0065038507,
-0.0023006247,
0.0246183481,
-0.0089032585,
-0.003041771,
0.0012826291,
-0.0099991728,
-0.0439812206,
-0.0559842251,
-0.0687458441,
-0.0044562197,
0.0347220413,
0.0135859381,
-0.0426363274,
0.0099684512,
-0.0031329663,
-0.0137876561,
0.0237229764,
0.0248698257,
-0.016490154,
-0.0298962686,
0.0203125738,
-0.0079120137,
-0.0032275531,
-0.042791415,
-0.0274238382,
-0.0091136377,
0.0211842861,
-0.0241923854,
0.059699554,
0.0115694795,
0.0211153533,
-0.0165986717,
0.0231019948,
0.0138227642,
0.0079543777,
-0.0151721872,
0.0263346843,
-0.0082005365,
-0.056722492,
0.0333484337,
-0.0061973436,
0.0177766737,
-0.0383099504,
-0.0409539156,
0.0154543938,
0.027879145,
-0.030295413,
0.0211563706,
-0.0180781353,
0.0301723704,
-0.0403372757,
-0.0491680279,
-0.0308624096,
0.0494372621,
-0.0626377538,
-0.0101530077,
-0.024235297,
-0.0110999784,
-0.0303623453,
0.0725103542,
0.0174919385,
0.041248735,
0.0631103814,
-0.0339180492,
-0.0050354721,
0.0304287765,
0.0821328312,
0.0015605444,
-0.0231764093,
0.0235972442,
-0.0065699825,
0.0298358481,
-0.0376125984,
-0.0121088391,
-0.118399024,
0.0238854233,
-0.0146302702,
0.0090221958,
-0.0722802505,
-0.0510675982,
-0.0531810969,
0.0515642986,
0.0170717444,
-0.0163547378,
-0.0157415606,
-0.0201000087,
0.0211057365,
-0.0207714718,
-0.0504206307,
-0.0286722835,
-0.0116028534,
-0.0180678777,
0.0510046929,
0.003586781,
0.0129359076,
0.0326397419,
-0.039709691,
-0.0072323419,
-0.014046506,
-0.0687106848,
0.004438919,
0.0416499972,
-0.0393779613,
-0.0029991276,
0.1028324664,
0.0014692721,
-0.0072485921,
-0.0201144386,
0.0228065588,
0.0231818277,
-0.0154378442,
0.0012381437,
-0.0946442187,
-0.0037838891,
0.0061762752,
0.035644792,
-0.0266951006,
-0.0202824194,
-0.0404505506,
-0.0365720429,
0.0077542537,
0.0016119849,
-0.0640715286,
0.0140471691,
-0.0333706662,
-0.0558558404,
-0.0103524979,
-0.0406802632,
-0.0440355204,
0.0162683204,
-0.0141875986,
-0.0392516367,
0.0035937463,
0.0384934805,
0.0052018301,
-0.0206199437,
-0.0022039795,
0.0609211028,
0.0838569775,
-0.0269980803,
-0.0284057837,
-0.0291697308,
0.0253746323,
-0.022386672,
-0.0135639906,
0.0957462862,
-0.0071045379,
0.0042462661,
-0.0226473585,
0.0883293599,
-0.0036742445,
-0.0141148092,
0.0251042694,
-0.0108342702,
-0.0061019519,
-0.0333317891,
0.0338170454,
-0.0230778269,
0.0243854783,
0.0519119911,
-0.0299392845,
-0.0318139605,
-0.0532218851,
-0.0397205651,
0.0426905826,
-0.0137364082,
-0.0106614176,
0.0084007671,
-0.002770707,
-0.0946708918,
-0.0312361736,
0.0193312615,
-0.0330576114,
-0.0117486725,
0.0307560749,
0.0279647261,
-0.0020513553,
-0.0157087985,
-0.0572439879,
-0.0268461909,
-0.0483590662,
0.0577068068,
-0.0015892154,
0.0102088703,
-0.0028530236,
-0.0140630091,
0.0080797663,
0.0285883341,
-0.0641651824,
-0.0370378904,
0.0383259691,
-0.0181140974,
0.0082710395,
0.0536287017,
-0.062589176,
-0.080175668,
0.0309894346,
0.0521400198,
-0.0173497032,
0.0166339707,
0.0588722154,
-0.0479378439,
-0.012715661,
0.0191376507,
0.0045620003,
0.0218463689,
0.0721519738,
-0.0787709579,
-0.0414385051,
0.017101286,
-0.0080584092,
0.036478892,
0.0355390981,
-0.0338488631,
0.0185825825,
0.0048644086,
0.003062686,
-0.0137865106,
0.011476608,
-0.0082026729,
-0.0198014658,
0.0431464091,
-0.0039193756,
0.0113812704,
0.0417619571,
0.0214612633,
0.0247208923,
-0.0276722778,
0.0468676835,
-0.0180311557,
0.0707089603,
-0.0052348734,
0.0205952115,
0.0158341844,
0.0420403145,
0.0417453684,
0.057047572,
-0.0109361326,
0.0096107638,
0.0257986411,
0.0366667844,
-0.0269401707,
0.0562365875,
-0.0807250664,
0.0131827425,
-0.043459788,
0.0578945875,
-0.0265353378,
0.0101970248,
0.0178739,
-0.0303804148,
0.0050218981,
-0.0127197318,
0.0510645844,
-0.0016184634,
-0.0138244424,
-0.0468002521,
-0.0270123612,
-0.0307337437,
0.0229901373,
0.0750234351,
0.0421218015,
0.0268069189,
0.0283182133,
-0.060878519,
-0.0435060076,
-0.0459821709,
0.0222396292,
0.0094913319,
0.0305390265,
-0.0044491589,
-0.0444049686,
-0.0313476697,
0.0461301133,
-0.0149704888,
0.0376414284,
-0.0145173883,
-0.0279756058,
0.0432007499,
-0.0159887336,
-0.0317385271,
-0.0675891563,
0.0354337171,
0.0264054723,
-0.0620828122,
0.0425611027,
-4.97940509e-33,
0.0289269537,
-0.0181383099,
-0.0280258823,
0.0375018716,
0.0262739938,
0.0212742407,
-0.0038692397,
-0.0354190022,
-0.017984096,
-0.011170364,
-0.0415098295,
0.0169319175,
-0.015823897,
0.0321897566,
-0.0287613701,
0.0089394711,
0.0501779616,
0.0309338029,
-0.0325900577,
0.0445300676,
0.0609934367,
-0.0017915997,
0.0353792198,
-0.082295835,
0.0449375771,
-0.0361506753,
-0.0785522982,
-0.020826038,
-0.0557429902,
0.0259563606,
-0.0014408416,
-0.0047211922,
0.0058863452,
0.0041357954,
-0.0023629335,
0.0205578804,
-0.081321463,
-0.0174160916,
-0.008820123,
0.0186996125,
0.030976316,
-0.066810824,
0.0543378592,
-0.0379351974,
0.010182363,
-0.0249787718,
0.034303993,
0.0052625597,
-0.0184608828,
-0.0573634841,
-0.031415008,
0.0163467769,
-0.0387653485,
-0.0239787567,
0.0401522703,
-0.0012406156,
0.0091044428,
-0.0273251105,
-0.0690944195,
-0.0234901104,
-0.008923783,
-0.0236409847,
-0.0108517241,
0.0305407811,
0.0296619777,
-0.0073611066,
0.0330342613,
0.0298312753,
-0.0228363387,
0.0326416232,
0.0353541896,
0.0341564752,
0.0754258037,
0.0804221779,
0.0370579101,
-0.0593471229,
-0.052877441,
0.0254733097,
0.0036432436,
-0.0304718465,
0.032414414,
0.0131140035,
-0.0818032324,
-0.0320219956,
-0.0330824777,
-0.0553497523,
-0.0086068967,
0.0118138893,
-0.0180498809,
-0.0229824148,
-0.0453829542,
0.0080821905,
0.0009513411,
-0.0665235445,
-0.017833136,
0.0212894678,
-0.0183530748,
0.0492429882,
0.0048979106,
0.0133682406,
-0.008277717,
-0.0091045182,
0.0313870013,
0.0015248763,
0.0244769771,
-0.0163445231,
0.1222280785,
0.017935466,
-0.0720966756,
-0.0317850858,
0.0052441582,
0.0636498481,
0.0524621382,
0.0067113247,
-0.0025920609,
0.0182419997,
0.010961392,
-0.015468589,
0.0243553296,
0.0177209899,
-0.0459463,
0.0376178548,
0.0132152112,
-0.0259909183,
0.0037981181,
-0.028163923,
0.0502772704,
-0.0378330648,
0.0485585369,
-0.0429495387,
-0.0067829872,
-0.0359958373,
2.596e-7,
0.0653103217,
-0.0094405422,
0.034251444,
-0.0165880062,
0.0145278256,
0.0610742345,
0.0480561368,
0.042612087,
-0.023835605,
0.016334895,
-0.0019608049,
-0.0001269366,
0.0839018598,
0.0082492512,
-0.0581681952,
0.0055281171,
-0.0033044347,
0.0015374761,
-0.0547339655,
0.0298730694,
0.0118325669,
0.0487435721,
0.0664475635,
-0.0382991768,
-0.0167676099,
-0.0537854843,
0.0510547161,
-0.0134380246,
0.0191807337,
0.0354679748,
0.0083511062,
-0.0048242654,
0.0328612402,
-0.0326253176,
-0.0271699466,
-0.005444251,
-0.0351511128,
0.0807559565,
-0.0019623435,
0.0063328794,
0.010511959,
-0.0402703844,
-0.0082863597,
-0.0320423283,
0.0366805121,
0.0457185805,
-0.0499267839,
0.0033790551,
0.0143530546,
-0.0244573876,
0.0309617277,
0.0090410206,
-0.0245139971,
0.0182519611,
0.02163109,
-0.0365666933,
-0.0031914585,
-0.0654211566,
-0.0277493522,
-0.0203187913,
-0.0352880843,
0.032305792,
0.0114813615,
0.0079427017,
0.0659819245,
-0.0523146614,
0.0432345346,
2.729922392e-34,
-0.0011320174,
0.0008979065,
-0.0269841794,
0.0099602332,
0.0447222255,
-0.0017194703,
0.0652450696,
0.0276405755,
0.0029422941,
-0.0466781892,
-0.0018194671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01778v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01778v1 | Introduction to speech recognition | 2024-02-01T17:54:15 | 2024-02-01T17:54:15 | Gabriel Dauphin | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | This document contains lectures and practical experimentations using Matlab
and implementing a system which is actually correctly classifying three words
(one, two and three) with the help of a very small database. To achieve this
performance, it uses speech modeling specificities, powerful computer
algorithms (dynamic time warping and Dijktra's algorithm) and machine learning
(nearest neighbor). This document introduces also some machine learning
evaluation metrics. | [
0.0292417444,
-0.0229307972,
0.0035267256,
0.0085105542,
-0.0453116037,
0.0208096337,
0.0236227922,
0.0136552854,
-0.0065445928,
-0.0543686002,
-0.012446899,
0.0237116721,
0.0914454758,
0.0049860291,
0.0002267197,
-0.0840997547,
0.0568361729,
-0.0269914065,
0.0305753592,
-0.0094281277,
0.0166256782,
0.0162720885,
-0.0520659871,
0.0595769212,
-0.0360814258,
0.0439229645,
-0.0178873315,
-0.0493860357,
0.0003347363,
-0.0219946522,
-0.0116057377,
0.0229285937,
0.0044462546,
0.0134395836,
0.0000017283,
-0.046362143,
0.0051092142,
-0.0296866614,
-0.0175228715,
-0.0482703298,
0.0275409799,
0.0207194071,
0.0028686977,
0.0299541652,
-0.0484035686,
-0.0180229452,
0.0580838025,
0.0136931315,
0.0355953649,
0.0859728307,
-0.0110542132,
-0.0466401204,
-0.0176960472,
0.0264594611,
0.0112083452,
-0.0162773337,
-0.0025353257,
0.0154445758,
0.028206015,
-0.0534158498,
0.0089633819,
0.0230587889,
-0.068726331,
0.0148194581,
0.0506813414,
0.018141672,
-0.0502550416,
-0.0571375526,
-0.0442521758,
0.0524165556,
-0.0183944087,
-0.0363078676,
0.0180463027,
0.0035980144,
-0.0410667583,
-0.0193541031,
0.0174302384,
-0.0625778735,
-0.0147069013,
-0.0276866872,
0.0213720389,
0.0517046414,
-0.0055631092,
0.0158142429,
-0.0097112013,
0.0190708805,
-0.0125758052,
-0.0234642625,
0.0018585447,
-0.0567479581,
0.0551281422,
-0.0221479964,
0.0515740775,
0.0272381622,
0.0255884286,
-0.018742891,
-0.0101829777,
-0.0529749244,
0.0102930581,
-0.0948384926,
-0.0026609756,
-0.0024117981,
-0.0113595743,
0.0375275426,
-0.018944988,
0.0419297516,
0.0176272187,
-0.0198414624,
-0.0340670273,
0.022797469,
-0.0425467677,
0.0327017084,
-0.0342604816,
0.0322104134,
0.0208510961,
-0.0173664149,
-0.0792777166,
-0.0156027954,
0.019332841,
-0.0093091978,
0.0390336439,
0.0086418232,
0.0072252853,
0.005413949,
0.0021031054,
-0.0200517979,
-0.0067938347,
0.044830475,
-0.0485884808,
-0.0847712979,
0.032046508,
0.0171105769,
0.0199861806,
0.0170796774,
0.0350403301,
0.0752868727,
-0.0044445992,
-0.0330445692,
-0.0350016356,
0.0141880047,
-0.0151392482,
-0.0402181856,
-0.0540676415,
-0.0589774437,
-0.0068537514,
0.0027816729,
0.0129211992,
0.0260777269,
0.0081669809,
-0.0300267823,
0.0186062753,
0.0702485442,
0.0203338005,
0.023200918,
0.092626892,
-0.0100693526,
0.051851619,
0.0005437873,
0.0732899606,
-0.0298784226,
0.0105425613,
-0.0491045974,
0.0099437041,
0.0280048456,
-0.0487046354,
-0.0712535083,
-0.0322077833,
-0.0045450064,
-0.0025782571,
0.0139977345,
-0.002572454,
0.0391252786,
0.004761178,
0.0298838969,
0.0369773358,
0.0872190669,
0.0343721732,
0.0072403452,
0.0179485027,
0.0135210995,
-0.0081104087,
-0.0750291049,
0.0221122243,
0.0040458669,
-0.0084137842,
-0.005759282,
0.0180434082,
0.0504306294,
-0.018855134,
-0.0203714669,
0.0067027933,
-0.0494497716,
0.0007019279,
-0.0218280852,
0.0661777481,
-0.033479806,
-0.0384018905,
0.0054178461,
-0.0037667574,
0.0128678707,
-0.0197638385,
-0.0411362201,
0.0381907895,
0.0259115677,
0.0025644107,
-0.0219118465,
0.016459547,
-0.0278179403,
-0.0060415925,
-0.0233038142,
0.0402536467,
-0.0060205748,
0.00630516,
-0.070233494,
-0.0003972368,
0.1206736937,
-0.0049423538,
0.0504447892,
-0.0298750512,
0.0452600829,
0.0415078141,
0.0075854822,
0.033674255,
-0.0152800959,
0.0536085181,
-0.0278949272,
0.0072753942,
0.0383233577,
0.0902728662,
0.0417360365,
0.008457046,
0.0053315042,
0.0164539609,
0.0024815104,
0.0527211688,
0.0385490023,
0.0048257955,
-0.0194119997,
0.0498343557,
-0.0010110693,
0.0094202003,
0.0375132337,
0.0155109568,
-0.0932243764,
0.0438775495,
-0.0474661589,
0.0353470854,
-0.0380817726,
0.0645243376,
-0.01814734,
0.0358701497,
-0.007779113,
0.0187488329,
0.0059922165,
0.0179649815,
-0.0264975056,
-0.0339690857,
0.0294351578,
-0.0483814254,
-0.0205334388,
0.0315797552,
-0.0458650589,
-0.0098139709,
-0.0347564705,
-0.0016270638,
-0.0252240486,
0.005145546,
-0.0070370664,
-0.0414145589,
0.021290062,
0.025564095,
-0.0559430905,
-0.007496472,
-0.0095355557,
-0.0628189594,
-0.0103489039,
0.0269905012,
0.0209103432,
-0.0666810796,
-0.0094034597,
-0.0197457485,
-0.0801901072,
-0.0146089243,
0.0048967949,
-0.0196913034,
-0.0005650754,
0.0232344605,
-0.1039176732,
0.0017951283,
-0.0536155589,
-0.0136213489,
0.0251452774,
0.0404544622,
-0.0279666297,
-0.0125114592,
0.0068925065,
0.0323829576,
-0.021462217,
-0.0092366664,
-0.0096211256,
0.0155834416,
-0.0134641519,
-0.0415242277,
-0.0035630732,
-0.014872021,
0.0566967055,
-0.0103553878,
-0.0085037723,
-0.0586912557,
0.0055914982,
0.0716294795,
0.0347061902,
-0.0054171104,
-0.0045647556,
-0.0114179533,
-0.0113551086,
-0.0262776129,
0.0001206523,
-0.0371445566,
0.0228210073,
0.0150211724,
-0.035071671,
0.0559946448,
-0.055314824,
-0.0211372804,
-0.0496397465,
-0.0846486464,
0.0199207738,
0.0164168701,
-0.0664103627,
0.0093872165,
-0.0203814078,
-0.0692098513,
0.034570042,
-0.0194901526,
0.0457882583,
-0.050659202,
-0.0270622578,
-0.0166059695,
0.0121882139,
-0.0073877298,
0.0103554353,
-0.0066297622,
-0.0142113753,
-0.0607739985,
-0.0246785302,
-0.0461676121,
0.0072534564,
-0.0162400175,
0.0606889874,
-0.0457215942,
0.0435163006,
0.0039408202,
0.014165719,
-0.0232047029,
0.0621223003,
0.0027070038,
0.0372234993,
-0.0222472064,
0.0452282205,
0.0583862737,
-0.0162724964,
0.066996567,
0.0086390059,
-0.0637385398,
0.0232266113,
0.0218435321,
-0.0250059702,
-0.0024971697,
0.0330802575,
-0.0093441568,
-0.0261685643,
-0.0004360647,
0.0778707042,
0.006791702,
-0.0174107403,
0.0027487059,
0.0214761253,
-0.0625157207,
-0.0130897388,
0.0114531321,
-0.0043474627,
-0.0034158654,
0.0155088929,
0.0386472978,
-0.0299985353,
0.0250417031,
0.0048748259,
-0.0640285835,
0.015951328,
0.0306712259,
0.0010012605,
-0.0871203169,
-0.0523097217,
-0.0361916944,
-0.0081791058,
-0.0102798697,
-0.0141360443,
0.0308142267,
-0.0308125429,
0.0397669785,
-0.0426739641,
-0.0443707742,
0.0518674143,
0.0397068299,
0.0800597966,
0.0193068963,
0.0183032453,
-0.0495012291,
-0.0580717362,
0.0132898232,
0.0178896729,
0.0105255544,
-0.0436018221,
-0.0366906524,
0.0133247869,
-0.0141683379,
-0.0148831755,
0.0194273032,
-0.0089804213,
0.0282754283,
0.0261079986,
0.0525383912,
-0.0545716695,
-0.0029626843,
-0.0036170399,
0.0351401232,
0.0309792925,
0.0220498051,
0.0056267749,
-0.0189203694,
0.0036093583,
0.0496131703,
0.0166958775,
0.0103196492,
0.0077020293,
-0.0065876236,
-0.0286634993,
-0.052380383,
-0.0489067286,
0.00533053,
-0.0181460958,
0.0371803865,
0.0512663126,
0.0383386128,
-0.00457305,
0.0676028058,
-0.061818026,
0.0044709751,
0.0692087784,
0.0420535766,
-0.0604618751,
0.0008887708,
0.0676447079,
-0.0036599045,
-0.0510410592,
-0.0648749545,
-0.0621473156,
-0.0379335284,
0.0254440326,
0.0188710876,
0.0244917236,
0.0204580873,
-0.0508005284,
-0.0254095756,
0.0339388661,
-0.0215617996,
-0.0160391033,
-0.026840603,
0.0372864641,
0.0123321377,
-0.0246639494,
-0.008850853,
-0.0170097463,
0.0464216657,
-0.0153198084,
-0.0697357133,
-0.0513312891,
-0.0299782977,
-0.0172228087,
0.0245710351,
0.0861068666,
0.0019175913,
0.0047839172,
-0.0439396538,
0.0095842937,
0.0649380162,
0.0379836746,
0.0022299213,
-0.0138145862,
0.0190042872,
0.0313414112,
-0.0301847346,
-0.0528534837,
-0.0175783671,
-0.1162519902,
0.0484960824,
0.0830019712,
0.0616947263,
0.0631117597,
-0.0377140865,
-0.0137066338,
-0.0089784833,
0.0590823852,
0.0268245712,
-0.0133241862,
-0.0024149176,
-0.0033333467,
-0.0251003094,
0.0042197304,
0.0000548453,
0.0216355138,
0.0135685764,
0.0294790268,
-0.0387852639,
0.0177970715,
0.0219147746,
-0.0034880822,
0.0033403938,
-0.0158703439,
0.0283648074,
-0.0136797735,
0.0452581942,
-0.0402596183,
0.0216402207,
0.0075965528,
-0.003224747,
-0.027170863,
0.0349745937,
0.0138462028,
-0.0231602639,
0.0076380009,
0.0451442115,
-0.0208461396,
-0.0597078539,
0.0220485944,
-0.004255455,
0.0106095606,
-0.0325415879,
0.0237815082,
-0.0146979326,
-0.0300492682,
0.0287283603,
0.0222829618,
0.0164460596,
0.0132971192,
0.0096532078,
-0.0142649896,
-0.0024487779,
0.0389538296,
0.0009446966,
-0.0481131226,
-0.0081637502,
-0.0021377252,
-0.0080184508,
-5.72718774e-33,
-0.0138357757,
-0.0549898036,
-0.0185914468,
-0.0196570605,
-0.0260641221,
-0.012249927,
-0.0028975934,
0.0167149473,
-0.0230548084,
-0.0407706015,
0.0091387834,
0.03329188,
0.0335403048,
-0.0379646085,
0.0270475317,
0.0053204601,
0.0142342364,
0.0005477591,
0.0100659039,
-0.0129422983,
0.0425793603,
0.0446435623,
0.0630333275,
-0.0768485218,
-0.0213251431,
0.024598958,
-0.0633620769,
-0.0046940958,
0.0234478172,
0.0096804984,
-0.0168526042,
0.0424286276,
-0.0066311955,
-0.0102442857,
-0.0022417619,
0.0236086193,
-0.0719093233,
-0.0297633931,
-0.0071866466,
0.1004947871,
0.0727965981,
-0.004092067,
0.012738985,
0.0081696957,
-0.07213597,
0.0463797711,
0.0418064408,
-0.0481201895,
-0.0231566317,
-0.0337740816,
-0.0153286662,
0.0526009016,
-0.0450993367,
-0.0329381824,
0.0874015465,
0.0289469119,
-0.0299781319,
-0.0781709254,
-0.0016241278,
0.0603324771,
0.0299356617,
0.0119794337,
0.0359127671,
0.0127603589,
-0.010598423,
0.0118994769,
0.0744785666,
-0.0844381079,
0.059365008,
0.0063042496,
0.0215747096,
0.0466348715,
0.0240977798,
0.0096578896,
0.0484998524,
-0.0774469748,
-0.0262200832,
0.0105994735,
0.0903766155,
0.0048183883,
-0.0157306399,
-0.024412144,
-0.0539068058,
0.0328473412,
0.0081274174,
-0.0143282795,
-0.0157277305,
-0.016603956,
0.0482173152,
-0.0087841945,
-0.014590431,
0.0030972776,
-0.0001317799,
0.0027139115,
0.0394430012,
-0.0267844405,
0.0534980707,
-0.0128328409,
-0.0097782165,
-0.0058603249,
-0.0142140267,
-0.0633994192,
-0.0011875469,
0.0238924865,
0.0636124313,
-0.032217335,
-0.0353004038,
0.0380383506,
-0.0562529452,
-0.0004724323,
0.0480332226,
-0.0350922421,
0.0006710506,
0.0267352015,
0.0409095921,
-0.0363851935,
0.000006035,
-0.0065148226,
0.0143904584,
0.0069917915,
0.0241278913,
0.0079970015,
-0.001918226,
0.0438812152,
-0.0449982397,
-0.0038066024,
-0.0343865752,
-0.0109648369,
0.0024384705,
0.0238075815,
0.0003084365,
0.0154310474,
2.581e-7,
-0.0110463668,
0.0692689717,
0.0155177033,
-0.021063989,
-0.0162025467,
-0.0152198896,
-0.0391500182,
0.0096355006,
-0.046523951,
0.0428445786,
0.0706775486,
-0.0611683689,
0.0671930015,
0.011427613,
-0.0655234382,
-0.0316153802,
-0.0581624284,
0.0139660593,
-0.0670102164,
0.0684883073,
0.0065306076,
0.0879681706,
0.0200476609,
-0.0080819819,
-0.0263917614,
-0.0379717723,
-0.0363516435,
-0.0056841364,
0.0448425636,
-0.0169236548,
0.0801729113,
0.0005637839,
-0.0016925832,
0.0150178075,
-0.0254825186,
0.0642963797,
0.0297797211,
0.0453826301,
-0.044176612,
-0.0332259089,
0.0036713094,
0.041356761,
-0.0316665284,
0.024158271,
0.0357222408,
0.0308339819,
-0.0226065144,
-0.0179379247,
-0.0019508166,
-0.0136397956,
0.037469238,
0.0079990523,
-0.0023887309,
-0.0141455065,
0.0076028425,
-0.0379137844,
-0.0172232874,
-0.05793266,
0.0117871156,
0.0280527901,
-0.049806729,
-0.0334982127,
0.0303101465,
0.0058157952,
0.0683682263,
0.0029581303,
-0.0134977205,
1.700439363e-34,
-0.0073751924,
-0.0516257435,
-0.0353999734,
0.0451120064,
-0.029712731,
-0.0260915887,
0.0321650095,
0.0076633943,
0.0301254094,
-0.0464187972,
-0.0369572155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00798v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00798v3 | Formal-LLM: Integrating Formal Language and Natural Language for Controllable LLM-based Agents | 2024-02-01T17:30:50 | 2024-06-18T05:44:03 | Zelong Li, Wenyue Hua, Hao Wang, He Zhu, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.FL | Recent advancements on Large Language Models (LLMs) enable AI Agents to
automatically generate and execute multi-step plans to solve complex tasks.
However, since LLM's content generation process is hardly controllable, current
LLM-based agents frequently generate invalid or non-executable plans, which
jeopardizes the performance of the generated plans and corrupts users' trust in
LLM-based agents. In response, this paper proposes a novel ``Formal-LLM''
framework for LLM-based agents by integrating the expressiveness of natural
language and the precision of formal language. Specifically, the framework
allows human users to express their requirements or constraints for the
planning process as an automaton. A stack-based LLM plan generation process is
then conducted under the supervision of the automaton to ensure that the
generated plan satisfies the constraints, making the planning process
controllable. We conduct experiments on both benchmark tasks and practical
real-life tasks, and our framework achieves over 50% overall performance
increase, which validates the feasibility and effectiveness of employing
Formal-LLM to guide the plan generation of agents, preventing the agents from
generating invalid and unsuccessful plans. Further, more controllable LLM-based
agents can facilitate the broader utilization of LLM in application scenarios
where high validity of planning is essential. The work is open-sourced at
https://github.com/agiresearch/Formal-LLM. | [
0.0474032909,
0.0528956167,
-0.0150533253,
0.0394999757,
-0.0472952835,
-0.0412444398,
-0.0330485404,
-0.0229622629,
0.035946846,
-0.0576245598,
0.0205888115,
0.0179896057,
-0.026281314,
0.0927781165,
0.0071417433,
-0.058362145,
0.0235981923,
-0.0434222706,
0.0425542779,
0.0188060962,
0.0093214177,
0.0002796584,
-0.0009194664,
0.026481716,
-0.0040818253,
0.0179918502,
-0.0589637905,
-0.0045711561,
-0.0057592471,
-0.0448489562,
-0.0194541868,
0.0334684923,
0.013518149,
-0.0001064572,
0.0000022804,
-0.0859565213,
-0.0030951332,
-0.0004148041,
-0.0436424427,
0.0036287804,
-0.0079525225,
-0.0031719655,
-0.0224601645,
0.0192940533,
-0.0520505868,
0.0533644333,
0.010943735,
0.0524691455,
0.0871664658,
0.063728027,
-0.0118827736,
0.0028122573,
0.0248898193,
0.0192412697,
-0.0035436025,
-0.0624913462,
0.0145374965,
0.0093486821,
0.0675650015,
0.0338470675,
0.016132798,
0.0005896537,
0.0132562881,
-0.0265124179,
-0.0373418592,
-0.0016090138,
-0.0089392988,
-0.0554972701,
-0.0510808229,
0.0653714612,
0.0079902848,
-0.0154921738,
0.0677115694,
-0.0281560905,
0.0000392379,
0.0086627994,
-0.0406314731,
0.051025331,
-0.0141964285,
0.0043596495,
-0.0216678083,
-0.0150835402,
0.0297247954,
0.0189394169,
-0.0057411334,
0.0968083814,
-0.0009913032,
-0.0208182484,
0.0092095425,
-0.026146315,
0.0336901695,
-0.1045112088,
0.045337934,
0.0820105374,
-0.0714239329,
0.0331644826,
-0.0379188024,
-0.0047734301,
0.0378294028,
-0.0421749949,
0.0243647397,
0.043097239,
0.0148878451,
0.0229796525,
-0.0059357318,
0.0738093257,
-0.0220412221,
0.0099853901,
-0.0278913826,
0.0090078861,
-0.0389320105,
-0.0082843024,
-0.0427163765,
0.0334420912,
-0.04422969,
-0.0124652628,
-0.0360082611,
0.0613085888,
-0.0487996265,
0.0758713931,
-8.688e-7,
-0.0048379544,
-0.0178540163,
-0.0183530115,
-0.0826621726,
-0.0562499873,
-0.0554489754,
0.003331698,
-0.0005320182,
-0.0168304797,
0.0303440206,
0.0316121802,
0.0069089946,
0.0423924588,
-0.0102298604,
0.0838809982,
0.0041366112,
0.0116016828,
-0.0364454128,
-0.0706504062,
0.0161315482,
-0.0557629466,
-0.0103209233,
-0.077586107,
0.0161820091,
-0.0075976029,
-0.051475767,
-0.0301330369,
0.026485879,
0.0371647812,
-0.0054719695,
0.057687182,
-0.034860909,
0.0063104336,
0.00825899,
0.0160342194,
-0.0207649544,
0.0299729593,
0.0682027191,
0.0607247613,
0.0246324949,
0.0508335195,
0.0388557315,
0.0628992766,
-0.0288302787,
-0.0196817741,
-0.0043244152,
0.0129324896,
-0.0202518068,
0.0316821411,
-0.0270135514,
0.0708905607,
0.0056041507,
0.0153148035,
0.0202354547,
0.0470584296,
0.0023367824,
-0.0031287021,
0.0675110593,
0.0590145104,
-0.0018959692,
-0.033875972,
-0.0386945382,
0.0260584485,
-0.0578204244,
0.0026917409,
-0.0265542064,
-0.0024723122,
0.00410472,
-0.0699773431,
-0.0168591496,
-0.0221014749,
0.0486336946,
0.0051231598,
0.0294381063,
0.01602,
-0.0593681298,
-0.0016135036,
-0.0230223406,
-0.0327739902,
-0.0210642722,
-0.0535478257,
0.0438046008,
0.0818950161,
0.032035809,
-0.0310671702,
-0.0369795747,
0.0033151614,
-0.0306823645,
0.0532432012,
0.0252400842,
-0.0191351362,
-0.0289671086,
-0.0265191812,
-0.0274728574,
-0.0054503162,
-0.0010148605,
0.0089304708,
0.0220878702,
-0.0073213228,
-0.0003906734,
0.0130543308,
-0.025771711,
0.0486226007,
-0.0065586357,
-0.0300757661,
-0.0163162686,
-0.0195105262,
0.0508228131,
0.0172820278,
0.0105042206,
0.0295755919,
0.052768331,
-0.0027825353,
-0.0684365481,
-0.0128500778,
-0.032777667,
0.0389231406,
0.0469004177,
-0.0131363319,
-0.0221892204,
-0.0067063347,
-0.0248767883,
-0.0523046218,
0.0079033244,
-0.0220664032,
-0.0015333821,
-0.0128712272,
0.0062720375,
0.036093168,
-0.0434988849,
-0.0289785098,
0.0532570817,
0.0173828974,
-0.0656683147,
0.0316427797,
0.0116462409,
0.01170047,
-0.0143767465,
-0.0146453865,
0.0220801085,
0.0296121687,
0.0157572608,
0.0526378937,
0.0529492944,
-0.020355545,
-0.0233945101,
-0.0488482788,
0.0180366114,
-0.0190322511,
0.000872347,
-0.0130798547,
-0.0119962543,
-0.0134419613,
-0.0078671928,
-0.0262061991,
0.0299548414,
0.029435996,
-0.0240954794,
0.039007809,
0.0317164548,
-0.0676649138,
-0.0499876961,
0.0159070548,
-0.0262127109,
-0.0384266376,
0.0379513018,
-0.0399464667,
-0.0609316975,
0.0471950024,
-0.0203405377,
0.0252320264,
-0.0230474733,
-0.0046840562,
0.0269332603,
-0.0307279825,
-0.0210930407,
0.0105579374,
-0.0275992136,
0.020305384,
0.068729341,
-0.0267862417,
-0.0618287995,
0.0252032541,
-0.0041913129,
-0.0071670138,
-0.0225259028,
-0.0209313594,
0.0442892164,
0.0405426994,
0.0002778587,
0.0345447846,
-0.027273003,
-0.0087062465,
0.0204372369,
-0.0018223178,
0.0085046096,
-0.0695522577,
-0.0396768823,
0.0865750983,
0.0124314092,
-0.0435816571,
0.0576764159,
-0.0304150078,
-0.0060343412,
0.0161564182,
-0.0220559184,
-0.0459798276,
0.0777660161,
0.0169448461,
0.0084905671,
0.0152891409,
0.0202653371,
-0.0099638849,
-0.0427672751,
0.0091851475,
-0.0076773795,
0.047982119,
-0.0880831704,
0.0205032062,
0.0099512795,
-0.0296195764,
-0.0528069809,
-0.0133591359,
-0.0502665602,
0.0332950726,
-0.008002894,
-0.0340445749,
-0.0136068221,
-0.0403385758,
0.0196733382,
0.043505758,
0.0156119559,
-0.0187624153,
-0.0432582609,
-0.0529804789,
0.0274071824,
0.0368448645,
-0.0144200958,
0.0240455009,
0.027597731,
0.0422417969,
0.0155149652,
0.014463746,
-0.0461576432,
0.0048905872,
0.0135572217,
-0.0209902748,
-0.006961233,
0.0739623159,
0.032424897,
-0.0469741859,
-0.0109884171,
0.1016148999,
0.0382020548,
0.0151456138,
0.0229206085,
-0.0440562069,
0.0050568143,
0.0317440964,
0.0602684543,
-0.06290856,
-0.0149895614,
0.0090481415,
0.0024645959,
-0.0108840456,
-0.0276212264,
-0.033129666,
-0.1045869812,
0.0299152993,
-0.0072728763,
-0.0018559422,
0.0284299646,
-0.049686987,
-0.0190779418,
0.0223254021,
0.0022657434,
-0.0024625196,
0.0263296869,
-0.0345665403,
-0.0030195292,
-0.0523593351,
-0.0004919044,
0.0173071939,
-0.0326300524,
0.0541004352,
0.0806120783,
0.0410315283,
-0.0053253947,
-0.0251460727,
0.0467010401,
0.0704885647,
0.0336722173,
-0.0281598568,
-0.0291593205,
0.006951951,
0.0073901122,
-0.025496006,
0.0481496938,
-0.0613941662,
-0.0561817251,
0.0415567383,
0.101864554,
-0.0176829454,
-0.0164044444,
-0.0547500141,
0.0035361401,
0.0318242162,
0.0524393879,
-0.0225584824,
-0.0182395261,
-0.0672691762,
-0.0593665168,
-0.0440437235,
-0.0384884402,
-0.0321036391,
0.0057768687,
-0.0127706146,
0.0279199183,
-0.0709479377,
-0.0424088687,
0.0487266295,
0.0112716602,
0.0319768861,
-0.0365896374,
0.0698035508,
-0.0093651302,
0.0012235154,
-0.0010356646,
-0.028024381,
0.0394962095,
-0.0309302732,
-0.0183591209,
0.0018124194,
-0.0186818857,
0.0016244327,
0.0309021641,
-0.0312069356,
-0.0608123429,
-0.0102684097,
0.0702680647,
0.0237868521,
-0.0215527378,
0.0058059497,
-0.0388233922,
0.0167711452,
0.0115081966,
-0.049348779,
0.0004907533,
0.0236942321,
0.0501652956,
0.0178941395,
0.0314275846,
-0.0744573623,
0.0150170103,
-0.0238452423,
0.0585673936,
-0.044588536,
-0.0251527987,
0.0261791218,
0.0548810326,
-0.0271303002,
-0.0279617328,
0.0008663774,
-0.0044052894,
-0.0114206085,
-0.0545552038,
-0.0441641547,
-0.05271817,
0.0353603363,
-0.0393249355,
-0.0306178983,
0.0497696325,
-0.0304585639,
-0.044616282,
-0.0195573959,
0.0256423857,
0.0137663642,
0.0073302989,
0.0188524202,
0.0284963902,
-0.0088340826,
0.0055894917,
0.057308767,
-0.0122537911,
0.0307649616,
0.0216939021,
0.0267408453,
0.0170970652,
0.0143137854,
-0.0639582053,
-0.0212887879,
-0.0022029865,
-0.076189965,
0.0470543467,
0.0525826104,
0.042751044,
0.0318241492,
0.0178515855,
-0.0925532505,
0.0298183784,
-0.0000385261,
-0.0103492215,
0.0104686292,
-0.0605541766,
0.0421436764,
0.0236132164,
-0.0132448683,
-0.0194305368,
0.0431214869,
0.0158001035,
0.0243958086,
-0.0196011923,
-0.0210905075,
-0.0793627203,
-0.0335418917,
-0.0066489088,
0.0197969116,
-0.03470039,
-0.0319102816,
-0.0618458651,
-0.0466104485,
0.0197166596,
0.043304462,
0.0119176935,
-0.033574041,
0.0386703163,
0.0032113576,
0.0228120722,
-0.0219191201,
-0.029845288,
-0.0175712928,
0.0159404203,
-0.0162316058,
-0.027661249,
-5.939648426e-33,
-0.0201413818,
-0.0844367966,
0.0624421574,
0.0147160087,
0.0287908707,
-0.0294381995,
-0.0540098473,
0.0248476136,
0.0516623259,
0.0216514617,
-0.0215656571,
-0.0076428209,
0.0165652893,
-0.0084566437,
0.0171736032,
-0.004476151,
0.0208195783,
-0.0188628007,
-0.027070256,
-0.0319397971,
0.0329747535,
-0.026474528,
-0.0050801374,
-0.0655183643,
0.0515365563,
0.0035877437,
-0.0349071808,
0.0312558971,
-0.0176767297,
0.0459385924,
-0.0161594283,
0.0173579268,
0.0011213869,
0.0047126249,
-0.0503021441,
0.0638660342,
-0.0097409375,
-0.0577737689,
0.0271449164,
-0.0003215031,
-0.0537414849,
-0.0162614156,
0.056474328,
-0.0143409157,
-0.0626475215,
0.0697556958,
0.0122273043,
0.0090324422,
0.009283836,
-0.0057375757,
-0.0851978809,
0.0188052543,
-0.0105857346,
-0.0117802527,
0.0133495601,
-0.0216759425,
-0.0076070311,
-0.0256373454,
-0.0136689404,
0.0004712107,
-0.0089703221,
-0.0326937065,
0.0728241578,
-0.0234266017,
-0.0042646131,
0.0573926754,
-0.0040417584,
0.0199377332,
-0.0327916816,
-0.0062934728,
-0.0151715437,
0.0801604241,
0.0083406586,
0.0372858159,
0.005981727,
0.0203473121,
-0.0359429419,
0.0425410271,
-0.0116166407,
0.0772828832,
0.0409209169,
0.0307654217,
-0.0367281362,
-0.0029968533,
-0.0350176282,
0.042426493,
-0.0200878549,
0.0055322349,
0.0333708115,
0.0209301934,
0.0172685776,
-0.0151374778,
-0.0116635021,
-0.023182882,
-0.0043829577,
-0.0004732964,
-0.0231717266,
0.0111579346,
-0.0159292016,
0.030775087,
-0.034339793,
-0.0195585564,
-0.0136042694,
-0.0308600646,
0.034552101,
0.0438282713,
-0.0389737301,
0.038686756,
-0.0406346843,
0.0104638599,
-0.044861041,
-0.0056071789,
0.0079715801,
-0.0237577539,
0.0370947607,
-0.0192999355,
-0.0207556672,
0.0261241402,
-0.0236586556,
-0.0839930102,
-0.0200151168,
0.0324475989,
0.0226653647,
-0.0014098578,
-0.0340879597,
-0.022538865,
-0.038616199,
0.0038935849,
0.0373083353,
-0.0337496437,
0.0145846028,
0.0243445951,
2.997e-7,
-0.0177824758,
0.0659464598,
0.0142019782,
0.068736583,
0.0109229926,
0.0421364829,
0.0032430131,
0.0080163181,
-0.0566982329,
-0.0298896283,
0.0231610574,
0.0240711402,
0.0130055929,
0.0458698645,
-0.0580748133,
0.0219911281,
0.0020317307,
-0.0112986453,
-0.0829241425,
0.0202145223,
0.0770389438,
0.0290160235,
0.033988826,
0.0141473347,
-0.0089769587,
-0.0492360294,
0.0202888399,
-0.038224142,
0.0140933068,
0.0352802649,
0.0149633279,
0.0225285944,
-0.0033832325,
0.025803728,
0.021533791,
0.0111793904,
-0.0309037343,
0.1110531613,
0.0011551965,
-0.0106104668,
-0.0149638448,
-0.0693098679,
0.0128785567,
-0.0067931539,
0.0118632372,
-0.0101718567,
-0.0230677817,
-0.0214698147,
0.0186875109,
-0.0287701264,
-0.0445351601,
-0.0084666852,
0.0250598881,
0.009483939,
-0.0081099095,
-0.0097824475,
-0.0048747621,
-0.058662381,
0.0051230877,
-0.0114414506,
-0.0436971746,
-0.0015203378,
-0.0511527024,
0.0322079249,
-0.0070594228,
-0.0173599049,
0.0146402931,
2.883220172e-34,
-0.0195969921,
-0.0049675144,
-0.0069217039,
0.0364696905,
0.0499895886,
0.0584216453,
-0.038767729,
0.0563222691,
0.0503910817,
-0.0612153225,
-0.0445186049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00794v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00794v2 | ReAGent: A Model-agnostic Feature Attribution Method for Generative Language Models | 2024-02-01T17:25:51 | 2024-02-07T21:01:16 | Zhixue Zhao, Boxuan Shan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Feature attribution methods (FAs), such as gradients and attention, are
widely employed approaches to derive the importance of all input features to
the model predictions. Existing work in natural language processing has mostly
focused on developing and testing FAs for encoder-only language models (LMs) in
classification tasks. However, it is unknown if it is faithful to use these FAs
for decoder-only models on text generation, due to the inherent differences
between model architectures and task settings respectively. Moreover, previous
work has demonstrated that there is no `one-wins-all' FA across models and
tasks. This makes the selection of a FA computationally expensive for large LMs
since input importance derivation often requires multiple forward and backward
passes including gradient computations that might be prohibitive even with
access to large compute. To address these issues, we present a model-agnostic
FA for generative LMs called Recursive Attribution Generator (ReAGent). Our
method updates the token importance distribution in a recursive manner. For
each update, we compute the difference in the probability distribution over the
vocabulary for predicting the next token between using the original input and
using a modified version where a part of the input is replaced with RoBERTa
predictions. Our intuition is that replacing an important token in the context
should have resulted in a larger change in the model's confidence in predicting
the token than replacing an unimportant token. Our method can be universally
applied to any generative LM without accessing internal model weights or
additional training and fine-tuning, as most other FAs require. We extensively
compare the faithfulness of ReAGent with seven popular FAs across six
decoder-only LMs of various sizes. The results show that our method
consistently provides more faithful token importance distributions. | [
0.0355986878,
0.0746422336,
-0.0076412759,
0.0122499475,
-0.030392807,
0.0131142568,
0.0229892116,
-0.0425209552,
-0.0423683152,
-0.0325537138,
0.0202494822,
-0.040733099,
0.0398222134,
0.0501931459,
0.0445228592,
-0.0260247048,
-0.0134521499,
0.0015983362,
0.0277100019,
0.0066157836,
-0.0192893613,
-0.0032756275,
0.0272257552,
0.0686363429,
-0.0122032845,
0.006399258,
0.010391729,
0.0207040887,
0.0444944315,
-0.0024656637,
0.0197363831,
0.041795522,
0.008805315,
0.013341113,
0.0000021023,
-0.0194991268,
-0.0078982087,
-0.0061888802,
0.0121890418,
-0.0009371201,
0.0423010364,
-0.0170770418,
-0.0108871805,
0.0267253853,
-0.0280296654,
-0.0186978504,
0.0698896721,
0.019880712,
0.0062705004,
0.0590034574,
-0.0035540632,
-0.0233938973,
0.0236356724,
-0.0466150939,
0.0429447778,
-0.0169581268,
0.000579435,
-0.0374683887,
-0.0692247152,
-0.004734965,
-0.0450864621,
0.056052763,
0.0443723686,
-0.0224141348,
0.0622674488,
0.0505462289,
0.0117056528,
0.0064809667,
-0.0143008158,
0.0620327331,
-0.0537922718,
-0.0369474068,
-0.0088964505,
-0.0064920299,
-0.0125229862,
-0.0045497776,
-0.0351440459,
0.0243771281,
0.0099607762,
0.0210435241,
0.0474207103,
-0.0149399098,
0.0345609859,
0.0110763619,
0.0046186,
0.0253941678,
0.036816597,
0.0122543145,
-0.0467310399,
0.02905499,
-0.0536706634,
-0.0841933489,
-0.0023166751,
0.0175612066,
0.0202280413,
0.0164807513,
-0.0554435104,
-0.030700434,
-0.0037044617,
-0.0116892895,
0.03973772,
0.0438116528,
-0.0014143005,
-0.0089345751,
-0.0580334067,
0.0690414384,
0.0257820003,
0.0053090644,
-0.0263384059,
0.0056133042,
-0.026832236,
-0.024402203,
-0.0238382518,
0.0225045905,
-0.01448943,
-0.0246680398,
-0.0482753851,
0.004153477,
-0.015799189,
-0.0592969246,
0.0425461344,
0.0666333288,
-0.0660279989,
0.0017058561,
0.0031269584,
0.035372477,
-0.0328797251,
0.0306191929,
0.0292226635,
-0.0668989047,
-0.0461571589,
0.0362046771,
0.0266194306,
-0.0181647707,
0.000931292,
0.0638056695,
-0.0199002866,
-0.0397553742,
-0.023084525,
-0.0381464362,
-0.0232957341,
-0.0565474108,
-0.0128076132,
-0.0560109802,
-0.0066941949,
0.0027434216,
-0.0117008332,
-0.067340605,
-0.006205156,
0.0133262705,
0.0013271898,
0.0437472761,
0.0578942895,
0.013853156,
0.0521809123,
-0.0230332389,
0.0111262267,
0.018980749,
0.0536124222,
0.089484781,
-0.0182203222,
0.0191732179,
0.0166939031,
0.0106837116,
0.0119434558,
0.0057731168,
-0.0262524281,
-0.0387934893,
-0.0113829132,
-0.0015995322,
0.0846038014,
0.0205623433,
-0.0378292911,
0.0000777875,
0.0829822868,
0.0028930095,
0.0111183636,
0.0422513895,
0.0796874762,
-0.0122883366,
-0.0268651731,
-0.0073507451,
-0.039099928,
0.0714503154,
0.002882276,
-0.0029302209,
0.0419543386,
0.0179957263,
-0.0177754629,
-0.0454396792,
0.0342717692,
-0.0079117175,
0.0000562466,
0.0048747836,
0.0464223623,
0.0446577258,
-0.0731709599,
0.0242699441,
-0.0079260403,
-0.0647664145,
0.0434574969,
-0.0585998893,
0.0030661244,
0.0905198529,
0.0606430322,
0.017301714,
-0.0054446347,
0.0043916004,
0.0103929155,
0.0240615401,
0.0070743035,
0.000046949,
0.0065823705,
-0.0523732714,
-0.0364834294,
-0.0242699068,
0.0354283676,
0.0707539171,
-0.0054080575,
0.0161490943,
0.052099742,
-0.0447233655,
-0.0277410652,
0.0172529779,
-0.0038348204,
-0.061108768,
0.0474663079,
-0.018972788,
0.020212194,
-0.0160326585,
-0.0051069031,
0.032746736,
0.0022304275,
-0.0498566888,
0.0007812316,
0.0228482299,
-0.0633809865,
-0.0700101852,
-0.0044245147,
-0.0388796814,
0.0474018417,
0.038837716,
-0.0426881537,
-0.057006795,
0.0866888538,
-0.0663445964,
0.0370664932,
-0.0450391769,
0.0356671065,
0.014675389,
0.0331908576,
-0.0085584698,
0.054088559,
-0.0386261828,
-0.004800654,
0.0179633927,
0.0118088806,
-0.0143811563,
-0.0373201519,
0.0072466629,
-0.0367084891,
-0.0091817891,
0.0013332365,
0.0168936551,
0.0082826503,
0.0157536604,
-0.0345257446,
-0.0646267906,
0.0000658714,
-0.0454984829,
0.0431862548,
0.0228332505,
0.0345362946,
0.0208288189,
-0.0201530531,
-0.0414324403,
-0.02143698,
-0.0121891964,
-0.0032225722,
-0.0019847469,
-0.0196964499,
-0.0018925403,
-0.0237199925,
-0.0154071338,
0.0206652805,
0.0521208718,
0.0118153188,
0.0115529643,
-0.0495206751,
0.0048158993,
-0.0235992409,
-0.0170425158,
-0.0049802843,
-0.0487199239,
-0.0019534349,
0.0253288671,
0.0705651715,
0.0468897596,
0.0164159965,
0.0488290563,
0.0214308463,
0.0025660251,
-0.0539638065,
-0.0055285944,
-0.0408630557,
0.0057121981,
-0.014036024,
-0.0727354288,
-0.0047393288,
0.0796301439,
0.0225973818,
-0.0204910897,
-0.0722846016,
0.0369423516,
0.0065397257,
-0.057042513,
-0.0057609621,
-0.0093106814,
-0.029834643,
-0.0162006151,
-0.0411640368,
-0.09476576,
0.0573552884,
-0.0548547246,
0.0192500707,
-0.0274550449,
0.0246710461,
-0.0468387082,
0.0310457889,
0.022293428,
0.0081598796,
0.0139160184,
-0.0368302576,
-0.0163631458,
0.0461716242,
0.0373050384,
-0.0421668403,
0.0316938013,
-0.0600506291,
0.0051110685,
0.0275577176,
0.0081851846,
-0.0369163193,
-0.0066212756,
0.008144211,
0.0306661408,
0.0068574795,
-0.0256986003,
-0.0150213763,
-0.0208370909,
0.0271959007,
0.0425435603,
-0.0150689455,
0.0144775938,
0.000137374,
0.0273788963,
0.0519681685,
-0.0004483334,
0.0081544491,
-0.0323540084,
-0.0327442884,
0.023741914,
0.0274978336,
0.0131914597,
-0.0186692551,
0.0221796241,
0.0072200904,
-0.0130376592,
-0.0125997663,
0.0368943475,
0.0647543967,
-0.0657229349,
-0.0392719172,
0.0976773798,
0.0142070688,
-0.0679814219,
0.0269843824,
0.0200534705,
0.0713378266,
0.0201542135,
-0.0007185829,
-0.0377948955,
-0.0559367128,
0.0137244528,
0.0377986133,
-0.0232534166,
-0.0250641536,
-0.0182919893,
-0.0982820392,
0.0414380729,
0.002877498,
-0.0606180429,
-0.0331351459,
-0.0353486538,
-0.0229146536,
-0.0131781241,
-0.022262305,
0.0063848654,
-0.0041211289,
0.0348337255,
0.0228894446,
-0.0155218216,
-0.0563369505,
-0.012677771,
-0.0132633392,
0.0253507178,
0.1148013473,
0.0024408,
0.0105651375,
-0.0100815278,
0.0060699964,
-0.0126370145,
0.0227986239,
-0.0184988696,
0.0452267863,
-0.0300585702,
0.0128389867,
-0.0255829282,
0.0400779359,
-0.0448177457,
0.0005952975,
0.0066894945,
0.0433927923,
0.0104480479,
-0.0470662676,
-0.0150973499,
-0.0405576378,
0.0493932664,
0.0666490272,
0.0648655519,
-0.0314984843,
-0.0719854757,
-0.0549795851,
0.0228418019,
-0.0507094823,
-0.0078495657,
-0.0175757352,
0.0271999054,
-0.0842707753,
-0.1062628031,
-0.0236478727,
0.0165461972,
-0.004274636,
-0.0062671388,
-0.0073580467,
-0.0348104984,
-0.0496162884,
-0.0559023768,
0.0067489748,
-0.0171153396,
0.0074086511,
-0.0311342198,
-0.0198683813,
0.020445969,
-0.0578922704,
-0.0156315174,
0.0040675746,
-0.0864503533,
-0.0390788689,
-0.0117254676,
0.0643807873,
0.0159154162,
0.0580174923,
0.0015898888,
-0.0686703175,
0.0958569646,
0.0077722366,
-0.0201862659,
0.0387800857,
0.0099110138,
-0.0377633125,
-0.0122308489,
0.0349482335,
-0.0313099027,
0.017918082,
0.0415242314,
0.0685980469,
0.0321765915,
-0.0255064815,
0.0051333327,
-0.022996299,
0.0137049789,
-0.0365768783,
-0.0279132612,
-0.0315391794,
0.0188043248,
0.0125656649,
0.0020511446,
-0.0640994534,
0.0274652019,
0.0298790671,
0.0444527902,
-0.0199401472,
-0.0066848043,
-0.0056976313,
0.0225402862,
0.0027568506,
0.0130680026,
-0.0330728814,
0.0192899387,
0.0158685874,
0.0060992013,
0.0003070371,
-0.0073865093,
-0.0058328453,
0.0305669475,
-0.0113812229,
-0.0009748938,
0.0070256186,
0.0105206566,
-0.0282661244,
0.0106845563,
-0.0688038617,
0.013133104,
-0.0938982293,
0.0095109195,
0.0322986878,
0.0212322325,
0.0927238241,
-0.0196806192,
0.0175384823,
-0.0337077528,
0.0416883193,
0.0079369489,
-0.0288912579,
-0.0009561187,
0.0017933914,
-0.0175575875,
0.0000241437,
0.1029496491,
0.052928552,
0.0325837322,
-0.0470264293,
-0.0163231045,
-0.0118107721,
-0.0397836603,
-0.0042782938,
0.006253466,
-0.0033595618,
0.0217242949,
-0.025541747,
-0.0775059536,
0.0098353783,
-0.0321715474,
0.0177996587,
-0.0214394443,
0.0427976362,
0.0278696921,
-0.0434076637,
-0.0164094698,
-0.0651137009,
-0.0082738837,
-0.0279074199,
-0.0292868223,
-0.0163805597,
-6.584300181e-33,
-0.0056483871,
-0.0299146194,
0.0016110369,
-0.01444868,
-0.0246490017,
0.0060731261,
-0.0756403729,
-0.0287815183,
0.0338072032,
0.0343535915,
0.0068870429,
0.0079882061,
0.0108865928,
0.0515771396,
0.0145605328,
-0.0027698905,
0.0660705641,
0.0253008511,
-0.0451380983,
0.0639909804,
0.0294923279,
0.0246791989,
0.0675264075,
0.0133404694,
0.0144184064,
-0.0119735086,
-0.007532598,
0.0048683155,
0.0014024833,
0.04155102,
-0.0236722752,
0.0347711146,
0.0288999937,
-0.0797077268,
-0.0572114028,
-0.0016541505,
-0.0597353913,
-0.0189895816,
-0.0227194708,
-0.0101875085,
-0.0456065312,
-0.0761357993,
0.0588989146,
0.025954403,
-0.0100689698,
-0.0303295497,
0.0499541126,
-0.014580735,
-0.0352061093,
-0.0413492434,
-0.0624044798,
0.0325466096,
-0.0084861731,
-0.0297812149,
0.0101428889,
0.016804209,
-0.0084121926,
-0.0149342036,
-0.0291473791,
0.0203376766,
0.0196866151,
0.0293611325,
0.0642806739,
0.035155151,
0.0115131326,
0.0404383466,
0.0243444182,
-0.0125121288,
-0.0477927774,
-0.0110917827,
0.0024697492,
0.0222801119,
0.0254563186,
0.0243689176,
0.0619673654,
0.0043095388,
-0.0657610297,
0.0354747735,
-0.0099035865,
0.0408880599,
0.0667211786,
-0.0021507542,
-0.0025970258,
-0.0358485729,
-0.0412547626,
-0.0196518339,
-0.0270083863,
-0.0464423113,
0.0421113297,
0.041725006,
-0.034794692,
-0.0361447521,
0.0376696885,
-0.0480908565,
0.0123986155,
0.0492810644,
-0.014248495,
0.0352465957,
0.0163221154,
0.0203096326,
-0.0346191972,
0.0112386066,
0.060404744,
0.0078404788,
0.0077750618,
0.0005557979,
0.0303836726,
0.0359861217,
-0.043357797,
0.0047734603,
-0.052631963,
0.0197174046,
-0.003655772,
0.0523675941,
0.0029686347,
0.001501104,
-0.0346205272,
0.0193487331,
-0.0156382658,
0.0312825739,
-0.0369141698,
0.0052750618,
0.0162383728,
0.0266393907,
-0.0764159784,
0.0035166575,
-0.0369112939,
0.0115853902,
0.0320225582,
-0.0079518193,
-0.041500017,
0.0240696948,
2.834e-7,
0.0394586101,
0.0050725113,
0.0367360041,
0.0000373746,
0.0281127337,
0.0277353954,
0.0396062657,
0.0594842285,
0.0377291217,
-0.0034445957,
0.0210000332,
0.0334067829,
0.0782050863,
-0.0224748682,
-0.0854592249,
0.0346817337,
-0.0638854876,
0.0218711197,
0.0101316348,
-0.0500881337,
0.0013132485,
0.0714810342,
-0.0042703473,
-0.02574623,
0.009912801,
0.02286583,
0.0652209818,
-0.0019656024,
-0.000194645,
0.0176954661,
0.0482828543,
0.0125020081,
-0.0186121035,
-0.0058387942,
-0.0394398607,
-0.028876856,
-0.004092718,
0.0528775752,
-0.017963089,
-0.0749029443,
-0.0088770492,
0.0255206097,
0.0362028033,
-0.0233492944,
0.0437560789,
-0.0449976474,
-0.0099595329,
-0.0085090753,
-0.0221838858,
0.0069899466,
0.0085511692,
-0.0391643867,
-0.0092614563,
0.0470148437,
0.0140352892,
0.0185144562,
-0.0356442146,
-0.0687587038,
-0.0356691591,
-0.0238039326,
-0.0585633852,
-0.0321136788,
-0.0655612126,
-0.0125132725,
0.0301039126,
-0.0512032211,
0.0066629881,
2.458310418e-34,
0.0415030681,
0.010727481,
0.0130941309,
0.0309328754,
0.0198172871,
-0.0047927643,
0.0132335257,
0.0162466466,
0.0352899097,
-0.0805566609,
-0.0586769283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00786v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00786v4 | CroissantLLM: A Truly Bilingual French-English Language Model | 2024-02-01T17:17:55 | 2024-03-29T14:56:42 | Manuel Faysse, Patrick Fernandes, Nuno M. Guerreiro, António Loison, Duarte M. Alves, Caio Corro, Nicolas Boizard, João Alves, Ricardo Rei, Pedro H. Martins, Antoni Bigata Casademunt, François Yvon, André F. T. Martins, Gautier Viaud, Céline Hudelot, Pierre Colombo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce CroissantLLM, a 1.3B language model pretrained on a set of 3T
English and French tokens, to bring to the research and industrial community a
high-performance, fully open-sourced bilingual model that runs swiftly on
consumer-grade local hardware. To that end, we pioneer the approach of training
an intrinsically bilingual model with a 1:1 English-to-French pretraining data
ratio, a custom tokenizer, and bilingual finetuning datasets. We release the
training dataset, notably containing a French split with manually curated,
high-quality, and varied data sources. To assess performance outside of
English, we craft a novel benchmark, FrenchBench, consisting of an array of
classification and generation tasks, covering various orthogonal aspects of
model performance in the French Language. Additionally, rooted in transparency
and to foster further Large Language Model research, we release codebases, and
dozens of checkpoints across various model sizes, training data distributions,
and training steps, as well as fine-tuned Chat models, and strong translation
models. We evaluate our model through the FMTI framework, and validate 81 % of
the transparency criteria, far beyond the scores of even most open initiatives.
This work enriches the NLP landscape, breaking away from previous
English-centric work in order to strengthen our understanding of
multilinguality in language models. | [
-0.0261002779,
0.0991822332,
0.0023649198,
0.0733932406,
-0.0356368683,
-0.0040317494,
0.02592122,
-0.0375749916,
-0.0159642436,
-0.0426732861,
-0.0573209375,
-0.0427905358,
-0.0315163881,
0.0201337263,
0.0362592861,
-0.0188136995,
0.0657696947,
-0.024180185,
-0.0188171826,
-0.0148191303,
0.0189591516,
0.0337256789,
0.0197237451,
0.0600099899,
0.0061432999,
-0.0139293829,
0.0037614105,
0.0301854704,
-0.0150859514,
0.0016886911,
0.0257236864,
0.0672843829,
0.0083080828,
0.0741143152,
0.0000020547,
-0.0282514077,
-0.0106077837,
0.0031871058,
0.0089680171,
-0.000200845,
0.0270157773,
-0.0402256288,
-0.0065806778,
0.0298568867,
-0.0358151868,
-0.0231602043,
0.0300621465,
0.0147765307,
0.031746164,
0.07646323,
-0.010536789,
-0.0169417486,
-0.0123245418,
-0.0570324771,
-0.0275607221,
-0.0133218141,
-0.0139561174,
-0.022041874,
-0.025725197,
-0.0086084707,
-0.036689043,
0.0431388803,
0.0430535302,
0.0199865364,
-0.0143816015,
0.0200580787,
-0.054292839,
-0.0234247241,
-0.0099441577,
0.0833148211,
-0.0499408431,
-0.0382524431,
-0.0070534279,
0.0244364589,
-0.0120283049,
-0.0781851336,
-0.027893411,
-0.0052951067,
0.02371669,
0.0310856327,
0.0304072779,
-0.0147669269,
0.0491889492,
-0.0121522481,
-0.0512573943,
0.0223660544,
0.029160697,
-0.0089017544,
0.0122584701,
0.0287567973,
0.003208922,
-0.045076929,
-0.0023012145,
-0.0108361244,
-0.0341682807,
-0.0068872645,
-0.0314961337,
-0.0006227185,
0.0252802875,
-0.0507661924,
-0.0228231288,
0.0333894566,
-0.0284328144,
0.0491517112,
-0.0143629545,
0.0163916107,
-0.0386923291,
0.030548064,
-0.0499732867,
-0.0236272831,
-0.0255881585,
0.0124869216,
-0.0407513008,
-0.0176573172,
-0.0492306091,
-0.0239006914,
-0.0132947993,
-0.0225833263,
0.0095299585,
0.0013584589,
0.0706114918,
-0.0054413229,
-0.03516417,
-0.0053498633,
0.0131702442,
0.0670890436,
-0.0442563705,
0.0011902476,
0.0134603502,
-0.1135945246,
-0.0157695897,
0.0065049483,
-0.0437036641,
-0.0516465977,
0.0084918328,
0.0900554955,
-0.0269667935,
-0.0269206408,
-0.0077640535,
-0.0248130709,
0.0038758265,
-0.0920024812,
-0.0147673478,
-0.1046811342,
0.0576018244,
0.0070618023,
0.0576810651,
-0.0353795327,
0.0120319221,
-0.0146287149,
-0.0174091458,
0.0676257089,
-0.0279500429,
-0.0154677304,
0.0109943515,
-0.0036622637,
0.0017573986,
0.1166533083,
0.0259163175,
-0.025697913,
0.053249862,
-0.0112600317,
-0.0299347173,
0.0796143264,
0.0429084562,
0.0073126224,
-0.0222590212,
-0.0031820908,
0.0262758713,
0.0383754447,
0.057462424,
0.0594768897,
-0.0244107973,
-0.0106349709,
0.0375207327,
-0.0064282622,
0.0142999562,
0.0535776652,
0.045463562,
0.0145076895,
0.0055111507,
-0.0184584036,
-0.0275075901,
0.0090884427,
0.0021586032,
-0.0127274962,
0.0363942608,
0.0493949503,
-0.0448105522,
-0.0158359315,
0.0038068215,
-0.0165768564,
0.0390513465,
0.0031323354,
0.044267185,
0.0240561999,
-0.0221867058,
0.0624520294,
0.0403869413,
-0.0333732851,
0.0222674347,
-0.0276132822,
-0.014997365,
0.0729556158,
0.0212161336,
0.0102394298,
-0.0180282872,
-0.0324663967,
0.0129237631,
0.0316042341,
0.0664658621,
-0.0088829026,
0.0533199199,
-0.0585147552,
0.002080485,
-0.0281574856,
0.0188466907,
0.0490514524,
0.0085513452,
0.0328283869,
-0.010337838,
-0.0282941293,
-0.0333056599,
0.0322801694,
-0.0591337681,
0.0030145475,
0.0022656375,
0.0007663987,
-0.0099474313,
0.0099255769,
-0.0234527662,
0.0013866011,
0.0272536129,
-0.0370639339,
0.0196355358,
0.0384318121,
-0.0211970322,
-0.0411402211,
0.0394863114,
-0.0170770772,
-0.0119836824,
0.0228306912,
-0.0571798459,
-0.0277928915,
0.0348343104,
0.0117681073,
0.0403235592,
-0.0366865359,
0.0169586521,
0.0231397059,
0.016968105,
0.0079915812,
0.0249114931,
-0.0152719617,
0.0382447541,
0.0116320373,
-0.0157877523,
0.0401661918,
-0.0350210182,
-0.0340131223,
0.041322358,
-0.013129604,
0.035539452,
0.0277069621,
0.06194368,
-0.011853368,
-0.0332012288,
-0.0803149417,
0.0018509068,
-0.0450009964,
0.0109514995,
0.0128983269,
0.0178291034,
-0.0128932027,
-0.0452168137,
-0.0362152904,
-0.0243228544,
-0.0009172817,
0.018261103,
0.0024591868,
0.0035375138,
-0.0095695667,
-0.0233280286,
-0.0156629197,
0.0323126204,
0.0505698025,
-0.0344424695,
0.0084752133,
-0.0187500641,
0.0022703274,
-0.0229696296,
0.0421833433,
-0.0159574114,
-0.0460369661,
-0.0061176238,
-0.0370859541,
0.0168825909,
0.0404813923,
-0.0002999428,
0.0143951671,
0.0163736455,
-0.0102782594,
-0.061469581,
0.0313245505,
-0.0098841758,
-0.0453266613,
-0.0565217808,
-0.0281613953,
-0.0048058825,
0.077392064,
-0.0277952384,
-0.0211397856,
-0.0531224161,
-0.0003004292,
-0.0228051189,
-0.0391019508,
-0.0360250436,
0.0712239221,
0.0064724502,
0.0304444991,
-0.0301791541,
-0.0205819011,
0.0676015839,
-0.0472832657,
0.0020730551,
-0.0318827517,
-0.0073345546,
-0.0200726483,
0.0448035188,
-0.0039230087,
0.0244253557,
0.0044593983,
-0.0168883484,
-0.0379809327,
0.0123352706,
0.0127952322,
-0.0177102126,
0.0599750765,
-0.0202046204,
-0.0111160716,
0.0003698934,
-0.0729415119,
-0.0138386935,
-0.0268466584,
-0.0296724346,
0.0104071405,
0.0249308851,
-0.0184045546,
-0.0285670348,
0.001943005,
0.0012207187,
0.0812831298,
-0.0140876472,
0.0159645732,
0.0001945662,
0.0080544641,
0.0309601072,
-0.0016706558,
0.0024314851,
-0.0691847354,
0.0126323616,
0.0249974523,
0.0318083018,
0.0070280293,
-0.0270244069,
-0.0155715756,
0.0373441316,
0.0037862505,
-0.0495813489,
-0.033088997,
0.0592552051,
-0.0476635583,
-0.0619093627,
0.1001603752,
-0.0098346872,
-0.055285681,
-0.0037615066,
0.0128239542,
0.0471121706,
0.0404656939,
0.0107465554,
-0.0807151198,
-0.0234248806,
0.01515646,
0.0031056569,
0.0439444967,
0.0238980725,
-0.006003351,
-0.0891234726,
0.0047398913,
-0.0085545564,
-0.0827068239,
-0.0013383115,
-0.0231202673,
-0.0568575822,
-0.0534132011,
0.0548052639,
-0.0243932717,
0.0174642429,
-0.0034699375,
0.0053166342,
0.002960135,
-0.0708770454,
0.0096709551,
-0.0680473149,
0.0410340913,
0.0457100682,
0.0230315458,
-0.0155180208,
-0.0289527103,
0.0496887416,
-0.0003666417,
-0.0056936634,
-0.0187373366,
0.0176364351,
-0.0080281328,
-0.0312691443,
0.0255144499,
-0.0228344966,
-0.0113403592,
0.0203905515,
0.0216844883,
0.0387037545,
0.009270886,
0.0116712684,
-0.0030278706,
-0.0125938999,
0.0025430941,
0.0620420165,
0.0236947015,
-0.0399141125,
-0.0378407054,
-0.0461727828,
-0.0205890052,
-0.0857151821,
-0.0236423276,
0.0074723088,
-0.0165367573,
-0.0486043915,
-0.0429532267,
-0.0458555855,
0.0141699696,
0.0295772068,
0.0151957208,
0.0104131773,
-0.0215282105,
-0.0066118324,
-0.0382555462,
0.0702976957,
-0.0242842827,
0.0053293034,
-0.0775364563,
-0.0047761621,
0.0179272369,
-0.02466329,
-0.0272380468,
0.0243472289,
-0.0833858028,
-0.0722407848,
-0.0311171412,
0.0771755055,
0.0201797467,
0.0596135966,
-0.0321173258,
-0.0469068028,
-0.0124267768,
0.0291334409,
-0.0263367891,
-0.0133643355,
0.0575261302,
-0.0373157933,
-0.0114296032,
0.0542068593,
-0.0271230005,
0.0210994165,
-0.0009859788,
0.0677901208,
0.0194842312,
-0.0174058303,
0.0082494803,
-0.0098520936,
0.0572680756,
-0.0401351899,
0.0024974241,
-0.0514985509,
0.0127487555,
-0.0320054889,
-0.0050966409,
-0.029433066,
0.0150680728,
0.0494544096,
0.0045448812,
-0.0055152071,
-0.0181509294,
0.044044178,
0.0185692944,
-0.0210995097,
-0.0282653272,
0.009775864,
0.0139794899,
0.0407100394,
0.0192114003,
-0.0129022254,
0.0347594731,
-0.0041542011,
0.0285986792,
-0.0857487172,
0.0414651595,
0.0403933264,
0.0195884313,
-0.0121137444,
0.029976476,
-0.0192009695,
-0.0388444252,
-0.0137998071,
0.0214354694,
0.083915174,
0.0069613266,
0.1003278866,
-0.0084623909,
-0.0417895801,
-0.0372514538,
0.0571034923,
-0.0026573581,
-0.0467386059,
0.00139729,
-0.0083911549,
-0.0401891246,
-0.0271431766,
0.0817220286,
-0.0071645454,
0.0114367865,
0.0225327332,
0.0266529154,
-0.0224667825,
-0.000088051,
0.0217836853,
0.007259849,
-0.0277227014,
-0.0173657387,
-0.0170570426,
-0.0599143356,
-0.0058227223,
0.0333993509,
-0.0068456503,
0.0098157823,
0.0210492685,
0.0892427862,
0.0016268392,
-0.0050233621,
-0.0510366149,
0.0164086316,
0.0107604358,
-0.0216476377,
-0.0034578436,
-6.416529954e-33,
0.0021684566,
0.0419697538,
-0.0008592464,
-0.0137570119,
-0.0177474301,
0.0105140051,
-0.0264666025,
0.0033560784,
-0.0431390777,
0.0033268253,
-0.001424633,
0.0128160845,
0.0173099507,
0.0553486273,
0.0110237049,
-0.0019664525,
0.0599776544,
0.0082324082,
-0.0120124649,
0.0284308698,
0.0248377267,
0.0553434528,
0.0814985707,
-0.0244945381,
0.0066178339,
-0.0332670212,
-0.0219741873,
0.0247798003,
-0.0263724718,
0.0733283609,
-0.0372107886,
0.0481605604,
0.0027879728,
-0.022872217,
-0.0209548734,
-0.0350547321,
-0.1090833172,
-0.0161149148,
0.0060552293,
0.0542990118,
-0.0269037951,
-0.0120274359,
0.0362608656,
-0.0048427931,
-0.0249522366,
0.01261569,
0.0099749351,
-0.0042729797,
-0.0023378057,
-0.0038413329,
-0.0667476952,
0.0109691974,
0.0318159126,
0.0029215491,
0.0408383943,
0.0692748427,
-0.0005631713,
-0.0296869222,
-0.0689871386,
-0.001804192,
-0.0252835564,
0.0430114269,
0.0764561445,
0.0338981375,
0.0088689374,
0.0564172007,
0.0536175556,
0.0066613294,
0.0031072721,
0.034297321,
0.0795321465,
0.0184754021,
0.0561631396,
0.075419113,
0.0225157589,
-0.0076452587,
-0.0730483159,
-0.0018499179,
0.0244946815,
-0.013127449,
0.0128087783,
0.0098443795,
-0.0083645154,
-0.0225178786,
-0.0577708371,
-0.0362557322,
-0.0206335112,
-0.0186508242,
0.0327863656,
0.0274920724,
0.0225406252,
-0.0277574733,
0.0645514652,
-0.0102413483,
-0.0365476124,
0.0161442272,
0.0118766706,
-0.0089791836,
-0.0209582839,
0.0903746039,
-0.0501809642,
-0.0510875359,
-0.0130710173,
-0.0013167217,
0.0165931247,
0.0040187915,
0.0546516664,
0.0117373057,
-0.0477019027,
0.0075376434,
-0.0558577552,
0.041875232,
-0.0100798886,
0.0530969314,
0.0516974181,
-0.0120493546,
-0.0075214077,
0.0672068298,
0.019157365,
-0.0056765988,
-0.0403827578,
-0.0295831226,
0.018535791,
0.0484759696,
-0.0236420464,
0.0127990162,
-0.0608547032,
-0.0275095627,
0.0252467804,
-0.0686915219,
-0.0400079153,
0.0159269366,
2.651e-7,
0.0482415073,
-0.0037920724,
0.0278116371,
0.0248884521,
-0.0058361846,
0.0185762011,
-0.0559797809,
0.0380419269,
-0.0098447772,
0.0105439769,
-0.0413270257,
0.0333632305,
0.0796591863,
0.0358993746,
-0.0846233219,
0.0022787142,
-0.0498171411,
0.0226925537,
-0.0391381159,
-0.0128395623,
-0.0147506036,
0.1266647428,
0.00244457,
0.0153831523,
-0.0007949579,
-0.0241593793,
0.0620249696,
-0.0360035561,
-0.0138090085,
0.0118072135,
0.0075167585,
0.0542629212,
-0.0172774829,
-0.0220678896,
-0.0169415157,
-0.0187930614,
0.0191703048,
0.0584048033,
-0.0013202343,
-0.0083596557,
0.0309244394,
-0.0428286716,
-0.0382366814,
-0.0710602254,
0.0321372785,
-0.0243098978,
0.0106573058,
-0.0383752137,
-0.0110174948,
0.0007818057,
0.0676272213,
-0.0548847429,
-0.0222911239,
0.0389360599,
0.0431137905,
0.0022672594,
-0.0290496685,
-0.0679805055,
-0.0558552593,
-0.0133551452,
-0.0348813757,
-0.0161741972,
0.0056015127,
0.0245750807,
-0.0168456063,
-0.0341919437,
0.0238398854,
2.571491238e-34,
0.0480796285,
-0.0013111553,
0.0051471726,
0.0172208492,
0.0489906073,
-0.0456663631,
-0.0115176989,
-0.0149225378,
-0.035960719,
-0.0330592431,
-0.0202147029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00746v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00746v6 | Health-LLM: Personalized Retrieval-Augmented Disease Prediction System | 2024-02-01T16:40:32 | 2024-03-19T22:12:19 | Mingyu Jin, Qinkai Yu, Dong Shu, Chong Zhang, Lizhou Fan, Wenyue Hua, Suiyuan Zhu, Yanda Meng, Zhenting Wang, Mengnan Du, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in artificial intelligence (AI), especially large
language models (LLMs), have significantly advanced healthcare applications and
demonstrated potentials in intelligent medical treatment. However, there are
conspicuous challenges such as vast data volumes and inconsistent symptom
characterization standards, preventing full integration of healthcare AI
systems with individual patients' needs. To promote professional and
personalized healthcare, we propose an innovative framework, Heath-LLM, which
combines large-scale feature extraction and medical knowledge trade-off
scoring. Compared to traditional health management applications, our system has
three main advantages: (1) It integrates health reports and medical knowledge
into a large model to ask relevant questions to large language model for
disease prediction; (2) It leverages a retrieval augmented generation (RAG)
mechanism to enhance feature extraction; (3) It incorporates a semi-automated
feature updating framework that can merge and delete features to improve
accuracy of disease prediction. We experiment on a large number of health
reports to assess the effectiveness of Health-LLM system. The results indicate
that the proposed system surpasses the existing ones and has the potential to
significantly advance disease prediction and personalized health management.
The code is available at https://github.com/jmyissb/HealthLLM. | [
0.0622438528,
0.0600578859,
-0.0179050285,
-0.0307288375,
0.011773291,
-0.0014737336,
-0.0003429001,
0.0415937938,
0.0875336677,
-0.0027975298,
0.0047548562,
-0.0192329083,
-0.0190132726,
0.0792957768,
-0.0259897225,
-0.0425623022,
0.03697161,
0.0352208652,
0.0378150381,
0.0174262132,
-0.0113038896,
0.0091621531,
-0.0024944367,
0.0651992634,
0.009209373,
0.0078793596,
0.0281475019,
-0.0325851217,
0.0263274759,
-0.0609420761,
0.0016436086,
-0.0013823394,
-0.0338431075,
-0.0187483318,
0.0000020023,
-0.0575643107,
-0.0327304266,
0.0181305762,
0.0060846265,
-0.0744574517,
0.0410960354,
-0.0330892019,
0.0061988579,
0.0121474834,
-0.0519937016,
-0.0300505701,
0.0255467054,
0.0548076779,
0.0548572019,
0.0602974147,
-0.0138010355,
-0.0161499623,
0.0112511544,
-0.0051726573,
0.0599486642,
-0.0351560302,
0.0501974039,
-0.0011482988,
0.0429615118,
-0.0436149873,
0.0262177605,
0.0548350476,
-0.032492023,
0.0347455665,
0.0331865922,
0.0563789383,
-0.0103584547,
-0.0346276835,
-0.0149960192,
0.0344690755,
-0.0073602423,
0.0004306932,
0.0255450699,
0.0128891952,
0.0102836499,
0.0103507899,
-0.0235781651,
-0.0473571457,
-0.0298375897,
0.0169639215,
0.0173779465,
-0.0099596912,
0.0303056333,
0.0005637765,
-0.0159772914,
0.0358589329,
-0.0113648521,
-0.0220546946,
-0.0035539125,
-0.0249371715,
-0.0036540206,
-0.0311632231,
0.0349220298,
0.0623931549,
-0.0517640039,
-0.011626753,
0.0128526744,
-0.0585615486,
0.0959270149,
-0.0521165542,
0.0115932841,
-0.000883088,
-0.0160472244,
0.0202770885,
0.0186717361,
0.0008467499,
-0.009499928,
-0.016499307,
-0.048160892,
0.009198348,
-0.0802899003,
-0.0210101772,
-0.0102001885,
0.0498600565,
0.0315274186,
0.0136701744,
-0.0800685808,
-0.023895612,
-0.0377740115,
0.020494163,
0.0406322479,
0.0749057382,
-0.0205505267,
0.0167102925,
-0.0336395055,
0.0201950967,
-0.0155181158,
0.0009986069,
-0.0060839034,
-0.0191926491,
0.0436802059,
-0.017370183,
0.0182662494,
-0.0014501483,
0.0540938862,
0.0386863835,
0.0255538281,
-0.0377124771,
0.0097918548,
-0.06167778,
-0.0230135657,
-0.0149579812,
-0.0302136112,
-0.071588479,
0.0352752134,
-0.0050653145,
-0.0000253684,
-0.0477306396,
0.0186191127,
0.013288199,
-0.0483680293,
0.022291733,
-0.0377609245,
0.0140585173,
0.059092816,
0.0115756709,
0.0158080328,
-0.0029606123,
0.007301209,
0.0208558775,
0.0132232057,
-0.0047067474,
0.0272989888,
0.0119947651,
0.0196103267,
-0.0367678739,
0.0321341306,
0.0160512514,
-0.0018362626,
0.0488865227,
-0.069637455,
0.059699364,
0.0328929834,
0.0005409032,
0.0243918821,
0.04913776,
0.0645866171,
0.0227404218,
0.0075549264,
-0.0078972066,
-0.006860076,
-0.0472061783,
0.0240231603,
-0.0051707104,
-0.0629032776,
0.0013175722,
-0.0097531602,
0.0317629911,
-0.0251435265,
-0.0563011132,
-0.0375281163,
-0.0246356018,
-0.005160192,
0.0034069384,
0.0427654684,
-0.027396407,
0.0036628409,
0.049296312,
0.0448677465,
-0.0288528334,
-0.0245873798,
-0.0675170273,
0.0111279143,
0.0986723974,
0.0483851694,
-0.0589177161,
-0.008905489,
0.0111290365,
-0.0431039259,
-0.0501688384,
0.022269601,
-0.0206987839,
0.0036875936,
-0.0240655132,
0.0053833225,
0.0744137019,
0.0045175082,
-0.0351241641,
-0.0114156799,
0.0389119945,
-0.0101645291,
0.0052097789,
-0.0343262553,
0.0200097729,
-0.0521965884,
-0.0171699896,
0.0115029607,
0.009797045,
0.033796493,
0.0195930153,
0.0138924094,
0.0386339091,
0.0445256457,
-0.0642927289,
-0.0522687621,
0.0034239863,
-0.002260779,
-0.0136281522,
-0.000117593,
0.0252118427,
0.0504208282,
-0.0243110638,
-0.0268797372,
-0.0238691401,
-0.0283824727,
-0.0472979844,
0.018729616,
-0.0252108425,
0.0043658419,
0.0267546047,
-0.0015161055,
-0.0464030206,
0.0369419269,
-0.0153375398,
-0.028986318,
-0.0251126327,
-0.0792953074,
-0.0096949777,
-0.0440306589,
-0.0167576913,
0.0208773538,
-0.0002637366,
0.0155792208,
0.0165702142,
0.0021788846,
-0.0238794051,
-0.0084857,
-0.1385587901,
0.012486035,
0.0199513938,
-0.0143586844,
0.0019155045,
0.0368030593,
-0.0112369368,
-0.0338042602,
-0.0640685558,
-0.0150265768,
0.0545537844,
0.0062286453,
0.0370879136,
0.0707579404,
0.0008131072,
-0.0399221629,
0.0083200373,
-0.0375787169,
0.0287508927,
0.0076322672,
-0.0170261506,
-0.0058201849,
0.0069587189,
-0.0782666802,
0.0126813687,
0.027520068,
-0.0121345641,
-0.0273035616,
-0.0608331859,
-0.0133781768,
0.0265365802,
-0.0019628652,
0.0171465296,
0.0683059692,
0.0117386803,
-0.0502248369,
0.0318707973,
-0.063053228,
-0.0086197648,
0.0128606521,
-0.0520362779,
0.0153078148,
0.0302337538,
0.0392638966,
0.0088452967,
-0.0646556392,
0.0383784734,
-0.0039932365,
0.0321819149,
-0.0644483119,
0.035556782,
-0.0246688519,
0.0345333368,
-0.0109366402,
-0.0512273982,
0.1016636342,
0.0015216883,
0.0516932569,
-0.0884979591,
-0.0181219392,
-0.0425683595,
0.0206637681,
-0.0064071589,
0.0391372629,
-0.0020637105,
0.0102010453,
0.014168052,
0.0204074606,
-0.0110480441,
-0.1033623442,
0.0249154773,
0.0000168715,
0.027333511,
0.0473306924,
-0.0303029567,
-0.0380268395,
-0.0304410458,
-0.0330191366,
-0.0112690525,
-0.018238917,
0.0249967631,
-0.058912266,
0.0165848881,
-0.0012801915,
0.0375748351,
0.0267477129,
-0.0152365221,
0.0415099934,
-0.0066809999,
0.0519882441,
0.0124652814,
-0.0335786864,
0.006203427,
0.0173441544,
0.0562198572,
0.0093355943,
0.0168813169,
0.0347443745,
0.0192386582,
0.0203864705,
-0.0418068133,
-0.0057121473,
0.0193282273,
-0.0047755274,
-0.0551969223,
0.0003132517,
0.0990534052,
0.0671603307,
-0.0614023171,
0.0175012518,
-0.0360243954,
-0.0143578118,
-0.0163283311,
0.04593537,
-0.0566909239,
-0.026583042,
-0.0111928713,
0.045546107,
-0.0339439176,
-0.0258412659,
0.0198847223,
-0.0299297199,
0.0045969971,
-0.0015654364,
-0.0281855725,
-0.0616023727,
-0.0347106159,
0.0047741644,
0.0019092421,
-0.0485379733,
-0.0116993738,
-0.0156871397,
-0.0050067492,
-0.0004471366,
-0.0594431758,
-0.0677271411,
0.0414880328,
-0.0125965625,
0.0073891515,
0.1274106801,
0.051114399,
0.0144625949,
-0.0408698358,
-0.0577660985,
0.0585859604,
0.0382118262,
-0.042491883,
0.0835851133,
0.026211977,
0.0033728208,
-0.0635114834,
0.0116407219,
-0.0204728097,
-0.0174070112,
0.0177293755,
0.0966319889,
-0.0411656648,
-0.0287475847,
-0.0568780899,
0.0084659671,
0.0220123176,
0.0561554991,
-0.0231735334,
-0.01635799,
-0.0126770865,
0.0242692512,
0.0211506914,
0.0342188217,
-0.0449991859,
0.0490739085,
-0.0527332053,
-0.020322755,
-0.08658804,
-0.0253672693,
0.0348887891,
-0.0341294482,
0.011962831,
0.0134887379,
-0.0005986752,
0.0119224247,
-0.0613046475,
0.0297160596,
0.0465020165,
0.0028542667,
-0.0418531373,
-0.0265835188,
0.06917198,
-0.0315283053,
-0.0126813026,
0.0078692967,
-0.0249500051,
-0.0058351024,
0.0190962236,
0.0384847596,
0.0176917315,
0.0052090702,
-0.004926363,
-0.0139819132,
0.0804530531,
0.0576356687,
-0.0553107187,
-0.025994746,
-0.0250397511,
-0.0305624846,
0.002858123,
0.0293119755,
-0.0390996523,
0.0186550952,
-0.0154745691,
0.0274251979,
-0.0133560523,
-0.0209479351,
0.0155515317,
0.0596094877,
0.0415762812,
0.0082149869,
-0.0400563665,
-0.0281781312,
0.018288197,
-0.0106314663,
-0.0044590444,
-0.0224061571,
0.0088160243,
0.0083457073,
-0.0182700958,
0.0049480363,
0.0490502119,
-0.0359631516,
-0.0269062389,
-0.0418873169,
0.0410208739,
-0.0200525708,
0.0167910997,
0.0656239018,
-0.003189038,
0.0162694007,
0.0254709516,
0.0078801764,
0.0172693562,
-0.0259598494,
0.0363689773,
-0.0259046536,
0.0148494868,
-0.0299202073,
0.0524628013,
-0.0373170152,
-0.0544265471,
-0.0204463173,
0.018440092,
0.0351378433,
-0.0022896596,
0.0421890467,
-0.0256104674,
-0.0139373103,
-0.0301199742,
-0.0168577358,
-0.0141426884,
0.0076282555,
0.0188428722,
-0.0043646386,
-0.0360271223,
-0.0378650427,
0.074353531,
-0.0175380968,
0.0143048102,
-0.0101855984,
-0.0754086524,
-0.0404477492,
0.0032581924,
0.041761443,
0.0251249429,
-0.081381999,
-0.0165665597,
-0.05435206,
-0.029948093,
0.0587028787,
-0.0233961567,
-0.037219651,
-0.0071390867,
0.0534685589,
0.0541328117,
0.0015188905,
-0.0145785986,
-0.0410850309,
0.0336239934,
-0.0869332924,
-0.0274783652,
0.012624166,
-5.892638937e-33,
-0.0003005132,
-0.0267615262,
0.0372588448,
-0.0226581637,
0.0326032974,
0.0016693352,
-0.0034441086,
-0.0119746393,
0.0166341569,
0.0131017966,
-0.0031418761,
-0.0164470263,
-0.0044557019,
0.0132705132,
0.0102649108,
-0.0230731517,
0.0397569351,
0.0181887913,
-0.0072591458,
0.0220886189,
0.0251746643,
0.0851214454,
0.0082679028,
-0.0785016492,
-0.0045852582,
-0.0126777953,
0.0211024303,
0.0282194763,
-0.0056669028,
0.057640098,
-0.0382675268,
0.0667531416,
0.0371602066,
0.0026918675,
0.0099174874,
-0.0117748752,
-0.0357228406,
-0.0276218746,
-0.0310970247,
-0.0552211031,
-0.0151503207,
-0.0294054691,
0.0537854768,
-0.013887533,
-0.0454096347,
0.013351582,
0.0501058847,
-0.0563660413,
-0.0144376215,
-0.0567592271,
0.0019239482,
0.0242757238,
0.0211582687,
0.0198331326,
-0.0193859786,
0.0242930818,
-0.0174970888,
0.056928467,
-0.0145496624,
-0.0069948812,
0.0063330554,
0.0404891409,
0.0182705503,
-0.018269388,
-0.0165269449,
0.0546307229,
0.0268353168,
-0.0184152536,
-0.0522066243,
0.0220275018,
-0.0380988531,
0.0378356166,
0.0319002643,
0.0182169545,
0.019367462,
-0.0424732119,
-0.0759868026,
0.0876339674,
-0.0602350421,
0.0329084136,
0.0087477043,
-0.0073714089,
-0.0297311209,
0.0107913539,
-0.0230483711,
0.047538761,
-0.0498222485,
-0.0475314371,
0.0289981384,
0.0150716519,
0.0158495158,
0.015498165,
-0.0287672989,
-0.0202605706,
0.009398994,
0.0100035798,
0.0114048868,
-0.0207619108,
-0.0384363867,
0.0021576013,
-0.028025521,
0.0091512417,
-0.0018223746,
-0.0378917083,
0.0166857541,
0.0231090114,
0.0218712017,
-0.0491550043,
-0.0386325829,
-0.0106474785,
0.0479435474,
0.0009639686,
-0.0228778385,
0.0145710362,
0.0127401678,
0.0386876427,
-0.0053270431,
0.0789413229,
0.0329626352,
0.0344704166,
-0.0823512822,
-0.0419416986,
0.0367060266,
-0.0229584277,
-0.0304633062,
0.0048704948,
-0.0598220043,
0.0470247865,
0.0425846279,
-0.0343405791,
0.0025664193,
0.0070926729,
2.82e-7,
0.0771459341,
0.0475998521,
-0.0182072818,
-0.0312822722,
0.008900444,
0.0225960985,
0.0026203657,
-0.0002484794,
0.0142875882,
0.0414770953,
0.0454426035,
0.0225006714,
0.0187639184,
0.0696741194,
-0.0661269575,
-0.0145180756,
-0.0699985549,
-0.0495902263,
-0.0534622036,
-0.0165722221,
0.0586061776,
0.0617455877,
-0.0216858368,
-0.0410177447,
0.0591423027,
-0.0090347538,
0.0270419233,
-0.0216368847,
-0.0360120796,
0.0254455674,
0.0246765576,
0.0147914542,
0.0183410831,
-0.0131172501,
-0.0303596277,
-0.0155754983,
-0.0063547031,
0.0586025231,
-0.0523902737,
-0.0155443801,
0.0153775793,
0.0272774026,
0.0264744461,
-0.0016452468,
0.0746822804,
-0.013630054,
-0.0336745605,
-0.0146512277,
0.007981698,
-0.0123490328,
0.0372867025,
-0.0369668081,
-0.0434964523,
0.0362148099,
0.0067137531,
0.0250310842,
-0.0029385637,
-0.0612642951,
-0.0321221165,
0.0367755853,
-0.042435348,
-0.0484898128,
0.020985065,
-0.0089379875,
-0.039044451,
-0.0883210897,
0.0322851017,
2.542490966e-34,
0.0136642363,
0.0412374996,
-0.0055952119,
-0.0118153859,
0.040017575,
-0.0051993364,
-0.0030843201,
0.0253869612,
0.010774306,
-0.0750783905,
-0.0197054539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00745v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00745v1 | Enhancing Ethical Explanations of Large Language Models through Iterative Symbolic Refinement | 2024-02-01T16:39:51 | 2024-02-01T16:39:51 | Xin Quan, Marco Valentino, Louise A. Dennis, André Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | An increasing amount of research in Natural Language Inference (NLI) focuses
on the application and evaluation of Large Language Models (LLMs) and their
reasoning capabilities. Despite their success, however, LLMs are still prone to
factual errors and inconsistencies in their explanations, offering limited
control and interpretability for inference in complex domains. In this paper,
we focus on ethical NLI, investigating how hybrid neuro-symbolic techniques can
enhance the logical validity and alignment of ethical explanations produced by
LLMs. Specifically, we present an abductive-deductive framework named
Logic-Explainer, which integrates LLMs with an external backward-chaining
solver to refine step-wise natural language explanations and jointly verify
their correctness, reduce incompleteness and minimise redundancy. An extensive
empirical analysis demonstrates that Logic-Explainer can improve explanations
generated via in-context learning methods and Chain-of-Thought (CoT) on
challenging ethical NLI tasks, while, at the same time, producing formal proofs
describing and supporting models' reasoning. As ethical NLI requires
commonsense reasoning to identify underlying moral violations, our results
suggest the effectiveness of neuro-symbolic methods for multi-step NLI more
broadly, opening new opportunities to enhance the logical consistency,
reliability, and alignment of LLMs. | [
0.0486272648,
0.0966747627,
-0.0355758779,
0.0595077164,
-0.0737259239,
0.0105691301,
0.0391711295,
-0.0279151034,
-0.0012345702,
-0.0212659445,
0.020804137,
0.020163497,
0.0206624605,
0.0043954211,
0.0289122872,
-0.0165866558,
0.0318811797,
-0.0014651626,
0.0376887284,
-0.0060281535,
-0.0011932959,
0.0694180727,
0.0373608135,
0.0120526059,
0.002804491,
0.0053648944,
-0.0180825219,
-0.0038903656,
0.0184680913,
-0.0006181006,
-0.0229967181,
0.0155068366,
0.0721672922,
0.0482119881,
0.0000020208,
-0.0499677733,
0.005778905,
0.0466520227,
-0.0419670753,
0.0211530216,
0.0446550511,
-0.0335634351,
0.0240890626,
0.0008557925,
0.010491468,
0.0503056012,
0.0413007326,
0.0640155822,
0.0482552089,
0.0437819585,
0.012125724,
-0.0256901141,
0.0327705592,
-0.0124787604,
-0.0485714599,
-0.0112213623,
0.0426446199,
0.0036022514,
-0.0209145807,
-0.0012875193,
-0.0043545868,
0.0280901324,
0.0813508555,
-0.0129866181,
-0.0592987016,
-0.0161287151,
-0.0082386527,
-0.0209166072,
-0.008069816,
0.0300977565,
-0.0025065038,
-0.0459585078,
0.0110394666,
0.0253537465,
0.0041752639,
0.0018676765,
-0.0219829809,
0.0799623653,
-0.0391067266,
0.0104069375,
0.054360237,
-0.0061284578,
0.0626781136,
0.0721947476,
0.0219649412,
0.0242652074,
-0.0188711882,
-0.0215984546,
0.0010751765,
-0.0131188035,
-0.0247658622,
-0.0288024154,
0.02999264,
0.0419160575,
-0.0343273282,
0.0533407666,
0.0152403917,
0.0111924866,
0.0345856249,
-0.0283101406,
0.0321650207,
0.0431724414,
0.0251368117,
0.0167803243,
-0.0194073431,
0.0061729262,
-0.0427189283,
0.0536193252,
-0.0245841555,
-0.0123950969,
-0.0263733938,
-0.0423583835,
-0.0102140727,
0.0181297231,
-0.0363295749,
0.0282147527,
0.0245565474,
-0.0173787884,
-0.0451797061,
-0.0051850844,
-0.0198391899,
0.0364699513,
-0.000998666,
-0.026289314,
-0.0335992947,
0.0129084876,
-0.049853202,
0.0425426736,
0.0291534327,
-0.0104143806,
-0.0228291713,
-0.0404924154,
-0.0412772782,
-0.0052145785,
0.0139918095,
0.0895113721,
0.0166535005,
0.0265689306,
-0.0513773225,
-0.0450092293,
-0.0151467696,
-0.068317242,
-0.0224266332,
-0.0518652797,
0.0313267559,
-0.0255118664,
-0.0405971296,
-0.0564641953,
0.0283972416,
0.0030778057,
-0.0333924294,
0.0697653368,
-0.0172535032,
-0.0049674078,
0.0203757901,
0.035308037,
-0.010848091,
0.0362465233,
0.0407636575,
0.0172602143,
0.0025559687,
0.0076867845,
-0.0030337099,
-0.0130612645,
0.031826064,
0.0144215394,
-0.0462595783,
-0.0118186688,
-0.0448996089,
0.043953605,
0.0286507104,
0.0391464792,
-0.0163279995,
-0.0250583161,
0.0358267426,
0.0717788935,
-0.0020640481,
0.0144266132,
0.0515691116,
-0.0185027644,
-0.0116067873,
-0.0138624785,
-0.0878277645,
0.0308736786,
-0.0136118867,
-0.0203438271,
-0.0814392865,
0.067950584,
0.0063693398,
-0.063140884,
0.0273103919,
-0.0009193853,
0.0534666069,
0.0186524484,
0.0284887664,
0.0181442965,
0.0020768736,
0.0207330957,
0.0575676151,
-0.0545143895,
-0.0027745483,
-0.0472115465,
0.044971548,
0.0582449064,
0.0487507842,
0.0102780275,
-0.007580637,
-0.0655179247,
-0.0183382183,
0.0382755585,
-0.0301594455,
-0.0108533483,
0.0235342551,
-0.0266273711,
-0.033528477,
-0.0464367792,
0.0231863186,
0.0098562017,
0.019145852,
-0.0283693522,
0.0288642514,
-0.0396122411,
-0.0296060294,
0.0495977029,
-0.0331825055,
0.0180705562,
-0.0311889127,
0.0241563711,
0.0170198679,
0.0001454149,
0.0161924455,
-0.0178373046,
0.0052076168,
-0.004970253,
-0.0173036419,
0.0214836337,
-0.0382628925,
-0.0309845451,
0.0374619067,
-0.0530042388,
-0.020821372,
0.0386736877,
-0.0676319599,
0.0159059372,
0.0110221626,
-0.0511235148,
-0.0103485258,
-0.0670997724,
-0.0252610631,
-0.0613341033,
-0.0367713161,
-0.0109285796,
0.0737173483,
-0.0192019083,
-0.0222239792,
0.0031251011,
-0.0000844159,
0.0190189052,
-0.014945711,
0.0207084604,
0.0139523782,
-0.031797938,
-0.0042793103,
0.0046088169,
0.0204213224,
-0.01521987,
-0.0048577376,
-0.0473265089,
0.0065648961,
0.0009244044,
-0.0162556786,
-0.0136725744,
-0.0175529197,
0.0176291019,
0.0077334736,
0.0139854169,
-0.0102762859,
-0.0072399015,
0.0027086351,
0.0203872509,
-0.0256044548,
-0.0647776574,
0.0111474814,
-0.0091779791,
-0.054315988,
0.0571981743,
0.0284542032,
0.0074603716,
-0.0405469425,
-0.0146878175,
-0.0652920306,
0.0088638486,
0.0033760204,
-0.0162160322,
0.0178739987,
0.0657766014,
-0.0454979315,
0.0726652071,
0.0187278856,
0.0420734324,
0.0386990644,
0.0367509425,
-0.0488288738,
0.0021191866,
-0.0012750875,
0.0178071149,
-0.0272208918,
-0.0450676456,
-0.0138697326,
0.0618988127,
-0.0057826522,
-0.0080893617,
-0.0286121927,
0.0405988395,
-0.0395571291,
-0.0646708682,
-0.0213934314,
-0.0916337445,
0.0095664049,
0.0463085584,
-0.0432124399,
-0.0642780364,
0.1139770597,
0.019952694,
0.0317511223,
-0.0206099432,
-0.0223677922,
-0.0406978168,
0.0783746168,
-0.0285941344,
0.0491450839,
0.0310294218,
-0.0078201555,
-0.0136940507,
-0.0296675321,
0.0515095294,
-0.0110749211,
0.058785066,
-0.0714612678,
-0.0053484421,
0.0307843108,
-0.053454034,
-0.0340377949,
-0.0485029221,
-0.0353020839,
-0.0153506259,
-0.0206105206,
0.0097375931,
0.0086226612,
0.0011470122,
0.0369099267,
-0.0190193709,
0.0180488173,
0.0080223223,
-0.0287364833,
-0.0408725031,
0.0130939232,
-0.0107819894,
0.0637703687,
0.0224235654,
0.0244707875,
0.033687301,
-0.0044492837,
0.0155342948,
-0.0248789974,
0.0557542592,
-0.0203988794,
-0.019331798,
0.0263108276,
0.0151653606,
0.0098986188,
-0.0656380951,
-0.0099701276,
0.0904853642,
0.008285596,
-0.0256780721,
0.0355536379,
-0.0300758295,
-0.0307573266,
0.0015734865,
0.0149514666,
-0.0970302075,
-0.0220604297,
0.0145559572,
-0.0105805602,
-0.0436913334,
-0.0446219072,
-0.0145823313,
-0.0973766148,
0.0252408925,
0.0218932964,
-0.0455319509,
0.0125351921,
-0.0684267655,
-0.0039967187,
-0.0161170959,
0.0180189256,
0.0144222248,
0.0087326681,
-0.0218157284,
-0.0032396442,
0.0226516295,
0.0098907975,
0.0519913174,
-0.0474530421,
0.0378338769,
0.0302908905,
0.0335922278,
-0.0141827939,
-0.0271938983,
0.0201952737,
-0.0005000381,
0.0071076346,
-0.005479815,
0.0066289357,
-0.010461038,
0.0077292225,
-0.0626039132,
0.0406793095,
-0.0106040398,
-0.0722346306,
-0.0076785153,
0.0847143531,
0.0133860791,
-0.0175340325,
-0.0041965009,
0.0046954714,
-0.0033423356,
0.0717501193,
0.0225318652,
-0.0106907571,
-0.0232341196,
-0.0350403897,
-0.0617952161,
0.0118497405,
-0.014164147,
-0.0040685241,
0.0151029117,
-0.0032715646,
-0.0162512008,
-0.0200099144,
0.0025717246,
0.0043581389,
0.0357153267,
-0.0207524039,
0.0271386839,
-0.0191031843,
-0.0150750121,
0.0319830664,
-0.0431907065,
0.0188590903,
0.0460643321,
0.0661732033,
-0.0326438546,
-0.0229480546,
-0.0057002851,
0.0401957221,
0.0062210057,
-0.0322828554,
-0.0098710591,
0.0393097624,
0.0187506713,
0.0695685521,
-0.030767912,
-0.0041203354,
-0.0172819868,
0.0526982024,
-0.0240311082,
0.0039619938,
0.0409903303,
0.0058336882,
0.0208222065,
0.031548921,
-0.0246587712,
-0.0142557016,
0.0167200398,
0.0487166047,
-0.0423979573,
0.0008242152,
0.0606290027,
0.0262822937,
-0.0272315778,
-0.0357818976,
-0.0225231107,
-0.0387865119,
-0.0139871798,
-0.0223850776,
-0.0472180173,
-0.0243197288,
0.0396574326,
0.0478544272,
-0.002896341,
-0.0261795297,
-0.0211116113,
-0.000413867,
-0.0133659663,
-0.0010102226,
-0.0212835427,
0.0230504088,
0.0221376065,
-0.0263609122,
0.0074427878,
-0.0366624966,
0.0076171048,
-0.0247023609,
0.0563951693,
-0.0240822509,
0.070240289,
0.0624127723,
-0.0060955943,
-0.0539490841,
-0.0065159448,
-0.0467270203,
-0.0202373378,
0.0258561783,
-0.0278739072,
-0.0074887034,
0.006395678,
0.0223814771,
0.0032983352,
-0.0065519493,
0.0396386981,
0.0402846299,
-0.0073893978,
-0.0618238077,
0.0206771623,
0.0116361752,
-0.018457735,
-0.0017874816,
0.0242433604,
-0.0111309076,
0.0469396226,
0.0149791567,
-0.0269416217,
0.0040245075,
-0.0659072176,
0.0014046463,
-0.0252049398,
-0.014433085,
-0.0231074765,
-0.0723341405,
-0.0799066201,
-0.0566279665,
0.0188209917,
0.0121391751,
-0.0229240097,
-0.0051341332,
0.0656720921,
0.0248515233,
-0.0739913061,
-0.0030326801,
0.0165253375,
-0.0084271235,
-0.0172638968,
-0.0499921404,
-5.44350826e-33,
-0.0158573221,
-0.0459448025,
0.0061584571,
-0.0079333894,
-0.0291804392,
-0.0168187078,
-0.0454818308,
-0.031889271,
-0.0250580665,
0.0703429505,
0.0031794633,
0.0283634216,
0.0059543969,
-0.0068110875,
-0.0081776911,
-0.0463914908,
-0.001501917,
0.0389978513,
-0.0222859308,
0.0037414276,
0.0000646125,
-0.0055072554,
0.0370469615,
-0.0797507688,
0.0552909188,
0.0285796952,
-0.0154511053,
0.052831728,
-0.0737137794,
0.0022359651,
0.0110427178,
0.0411769152,
0.0216783136,
-0.03208239,
0.0394245498,
0.0274879057,
-0.0484900698,
0.0099622272,
0.0935990289,
-0.0387331508,
-0.0549048856,
-0.062756218,
0.0522093102,
0.0116877286,
0.0006989968,
-0.0121798106,
0.0293183494,
-0.0298351217,
0.0101337507,
-0.022974018,
-0.0863720402,
-0.0245297737,
-0.0469496883,
-0.0201802421,
-0.0634004697,
0.0204155147,
-0.0393144377,
-0.0060635945,
-0.0198970661,
-0.0305222552,
0.03123652,
-0.0751957148,
0.0819810927,
-0.0321875066,
0.0070666377,
0.0535018072,
-0.0174666066,
0.0088579813,
-0.0924474299,
-0.0014902991,
-0.0041742725,
0.0688321367,
0.0864730626,
0.0222523492,
0.0058642044,
0.0272402987,
-0.0666210726,
-0.0223548226,
-0.0076300711,
0.0782535151,
0.026496565,
-0.0086687217,
-0.0234520026,
-0.0332636088,
-0.0665284768,
-0.0342990384,
-0.0263993349,
-0.033656422,
0.0200239662,
-0.0081450883,
-0.0492145196,
-0.0056677447,
-0.0123258308,
-0.0823208839,
0.0277442578,
0.0329656601,
0.055199448,
-0.0327802449,
0.0138177508,
0.0393346362,
-0.0227678884,
0.010450582,
-0.0008036647,
0.0107552381,
0.0546861105,
-0.0293875095,
0.0641255379,
0.0142332874,
0.0227474142,
0.0278522205,
-0.0687663481,
-0.0003342771,
0.0084364796,
-0.0136227245,
0.0318146795,
0.043643143,
-0.0273173787,
-0.0182319563,
0.0401329175,
0.0129999947,
-0.0265804287,
0.040195059,
-0.0266751759,
0.0159636363,
-0.0118818376,
-0.0012484763,
-0.0326329358,
0.018295655,
0.0524709225,
-0.0676861629,
-0.0148543054,
0.0365071371,
2.658e-7,
0.027692914,
0.0133486502,
0.0359361805,
-0.0046437699,
-0.0113774324,
0.0372723937,
0.0219738502,
0.0089476556,
0.0086982138,
-0.0727614686,
-0.0001643379,
0.09057872,
0.0548259132,
0.016048396,
0.0311668608,
-0.0127852578,
-0.0655361563,
-0.0347435735,
-0.0659417808,
0.0361650884,
0.0255697742,
0.0418911949,
0.0650300458,
-0.0216900911,
-0.0011815528,
-0.0340977758,
0.0606085211,
-0.0427353047,
0.0071008881,
-0.0141496891,
0.0091150682,
-0.0357466787,
0.0481244661,
-0.0089791575,
0.0531934015,
-0.0030525338,
-0.0117477374,
0.0469196923,
-0.0357363187,
0.0052945712,
-0.0717428923,
-0.0740448236,
0.0093705747,
-0.0775866434,
0.0593127199,
-0.0499025583,
-0.0273456238,
-0.0240109283,
0.0119728232,
-0.0362432376,
0.0093135387,
0.0212743934,
0.0168187227,
0.0106633483,
-0.0036173267,
0.0074603544,
0.0136899007,
-0.0630611926,
-0.0575815067,
0.0043328353,
-0.0047074519,
0.0159881134,
0.0214877389,
0.0270467568,
0.0678631067,
-0.0810246393,
0.0224422812,
2.337048762e-34,
-0.0174764618,
-0.0232100002,
0.0348873883,
0.036252968,
0.0697210357,
0.0537501052,
-0.054207433,
0.0040452764,
0.017056549,
-0.0260877199,
-0.003036055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00744v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00744v1 | BATON: Aligning Text-to-Audio Model with Human Preference Feedback | 2024-02-01T16:39:47 | 2024-02-01T16:39:47 | Huan Liao, Haonan Han, Kai Yang, Tianjiao Du, Rui Yang, Zunnan Xu, Qinmei Xu, Jingquan Liu, Jiasheng Lu, Xiu Li | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | With the development of AI-Generated Content (AIGC), text-to-audio models are
gaining widespread attention. However, it is challenging for these models to
generate audio aligned with human preference due to the inherent information
density of natural language and limited model understanding ability. To
alleviate this issue, we formulate the BATON, a framework designed to enhance
the alignment between generated audio and text prompt using human preference
feedback. Our BATON comprises three key stages: Firstly, we curated a dataset
containing both prompts and the corresponding generated audio, which was then
annotated based on human feedback. Secondly, we introduced a reward model using
the constructed dataset, which can mimic human preference by assigning rewards
to input text-audio pairs. Finally, we employed the reward model to fine-tune
an off-the-shelf text-to-audio model. The experiment results demonstrate that
our BATON can significantly improve the generation quality of the original
text-to-audio models, concerning audio integrity, temporal relationship, and
alignment with human preference. | [
0.0157685913,
-0.0056440895,
-0.0053438456,
-0.0143731693,
-0.0208605174,
-0.0237833764,
-0.004997272,
-0.0278071091,
-0.0480917804,
0.018287234,
-0.0677660853,
0.0129910177,
0.0214358848,
0.0402945839,
0.0027230084,
-0.117536217,
0.0042964919,
-0.0468778089,
0.0178685859,
0.0204317514,
0.0141128264,
0.0309060831,
-0.0322696455,
0.0262941308,
-0.0390728377,
-0.0300927348,
-0.0161361042,
0.0460698158,
0.0253886376,
-0.0245567355,
-0.0461641997,
0.0509611741,
-0.0038513946,
0.0111888908,
0.000001592,
-0.0415720083,
0.0169246662,
0.0171985365,
-0.0132998647,
-0.0100941593,
0.0284379255,
0.0629008636,
-0.0605764948,
0.0269784294,
-0.0043558292,
0.055082608,
0.057534188,
0.028095711,
0.0491925254,
0.0419542491,
-0.0118699055,
-0.008830539,
-0.0012707558,
-0.0248982329,
0.0303216539,
0.0223732702,
-0.0350397006,
-0.0169275552,
0.0697663501,
0.0235671625,
0.035673257,
0.0345482193,
0.0215369314,
-0.0105521576,
0.050731536,
0.0530143343,
-0.0180649851,
-0.021305861,
-0.0374806635,
0.0754664615,
0.026816627,
-0.0153369913,
-0.0173127893,
-0.0171405915,
0.0470371135,
-0.0123836687,
-0.0266047921,
-0.0114897434,
-0.0188890006,
0.0064112525,
-0.0514767133,
0.0337088518,
0.0336637273,
-0.0385740921,
0.0552033707,
-0.003038448,
0.0311444141,
-0.0350604169,
-0.0013088697,
-0.0058130231,
-0.0151073523,
-0.0526138283,
0.0564152487,
0.0101505686,
-0.0287860837,
-0.0302399322,
-0.0621703081,
-0.0054264087,
-0.0281603318,
-0.007744221,
0.0608825795,
0.0401230827,
-0.0472411923,
0.0517592765,
-0.0053900727,
0.0318432935,
-0.0184013676,
-0.0029476727,
-0.0237675421,
0.0201031044,
-0.0053052157,
-0.0235741995,
-0.0163332578,
-0.0089277513,
-0.0421700701,
-0.0409449972,
-0.0239987038,
-0.0134295449,
-0.0446954481,
0.0603924841,
0.0270715766,
0.0482296534,
-0.0410912782,
0.0068417159,
-0.0275512673,
-0.0109192021,
-0.0324145555,
0.067538999,
0.0567916036,
0.0110442555,
0.0042002583,
-0.002570241,
0.0175564773,
-0.006626674,
0.0161150228,
0.0618220419,
-0.0172879416,
0.0091933217,
-0.0042731115,
-0.0310409907,
-0.0391658656,
0.016574055,
-0.0678476244,
-0.0668566599,
0.0471878462,
-0.0190730467,
-0.0360145196,
-0.0196207147,
-0.010859211,
0.0236862171,
0.0005350258,
0.0638270229,
-0.011911476,
0.0552981906,
0.0448759347,
-0.0079542389,
-0.025130786,
-0.0039320216,
0.0920167491,
0.0554346368,
0.0207856335,
-0.0010525483,
-0.0089100916,
0.0588534102,
-0.0027716162,
-0.0191585422,
-0.0302034654,
-0.0111080771,
-0.0098232571,
0.0720258206,
0.0403512493,
0.0539655872,
0.0016449074,
-0.0068063075,
0.1033103094,
0.0300389435,
0.016045941,
-0.0344334468,
0.0432335436,
0.0130630229,
-0.01283444,
0.0258000232,
0.0184398219,
0.0495590717,
0.010035865,
0.044795543,
0.0521757118,
0.0159396417,
-0.0152192879,
-0.0395089388,
-0.0018485488,
-0.0164870229,
-0.0055661597,
-0.0027216717,
-0.0057669985,
0.0341941789,
-0.05986109,
-0.0193685852,
-0.0143320924,
-0.0645405203,
0.0371647179,
-0.0148629909,
0.0809118524,
0.1286528111,
0.0430937298,
-0.0271679014,
0.0529688671,
-0.0349664874,
-0.0158096459,
0.070200406,
0.0076070931,
-0.042139288,
-0.0188584402,
-0.027209064,
-0.0281106401,
-0.0045753466,
-0.0340556353,
0.0272706579,
-0.0192956664,
0.0183516946,
0.0111075789,
0.0207312796,
0.0000305263,
0.0082122069,
-0.0028163872,
-0.048103597,
0.001654072,
0.0278587025,
0.0438350998,
0.0557230748,
-0.0297835525,
0.0268833153,
0.0209869891,
0.0134331351,
0.0177786648,
0.046591673,
-0.0680672303,
0.028394226,
0.0336788297,
-0.0478985123,
0.032697279,
0.0173728205,
0.0234946571,
-0.0525357127,
-0.0185006019,
-0.0076042321,
0.0305454303,
-0.01459953,
0.0376868919,
0.0204415768,
-0.0253786705,
-0.0037646289,
-0.002861063,
0.0274410415,
-0.031892851,
0.0206636935,
0.0308608972,
-0.0047379406,
-0.0603374355,
-0.0015224955,
0.0484680831,
-0.0110984463,
0.0054182801,
0.0321413502,
-0.0246145315,
-0.0617585629,
-0.0454012193,
-0.0462856069,
-0.0102044698,
0.0163086876,
-0.0138042308,
0.0095315501,
-0.0006763039,
-0.026026221,
-0.013911319,
-0.0393515863,
-0.0658616126,
0.0173616204,
-0.0114371562,
-0.0218829475,
-0.0098973727,
0.0115163708,
-0.0564808287,
0.0242677927,
0.0133592496,
-0.0330218822,
0.0093386415,
0.0103880949,
-0.035603188,
0.0007254312,
-0.0134569947,
-0.007919848,
0.0318904258,
0.0150569817,
0.0390187316,
0.0267073605,
0.0999782532,
0.0595812239,
0.0115782674,
0.021767363,
0.0342345536,
0.0058811968,
-0.0660849139,
0.0188684259,
-0.0096312296,
0.0308695156,
-0.0021971685,
0.0089867935,
0.0093689123,
0.0292406566,
0.0751020387,
0.0507115349,
-0.0482709929,
0.0103724599,
-0.01260175,
-0.016389396,
-0.024357181,
-0.069565095,
-0.0522142015,
0.0478392392,
-0.0390079618,
-0.0526297577,
0.0630755574,
-0.0684546307,
-0.0080111707,
-0.0204364583,
-0.0197826345,
-0.006746965,
0.0378656164,
-0.0515451096,
0.0129670613,
0.0265750643,
-0.0020534135,
-0.0510466881,
0.0020480356,
0.0541192368,
-0.058433719,
-0.0081141312,
-0.0099162487,
-0.018158868,
0.0109308762,
-0.0350750238,
-0.0278583616,
-0.0208126567,
-0.0127228461,
-0.0018817721,
0.0046294206,
-0.0183615014,
0.0060057235,
0.017604718,
0.026237553,
0.029659152,
-0.0159897208,
-0.0037987253,
-0.0336452983,
0.0543582775,
0.0503216311,
-0.008178968,
-0.0459876657,
-0.0300615523,
0.0164062735,
-0.0226491541,
0.0300047919,
-0.0032995699,
-0.0350424424,
-0.0053946399,
0.0254091714,
0.0049220477,
-0.0111600207,
0.0514924116,
0.0241949111,
-0.0320539065,
0.0136161037,
0.0972068682,
0.0426529087,
-0.0088646011,
0.0059210155,
0.00619683,
0.046075426,
0.0035491961,
0.0075831623,
-0.0583937876,
-0.0170800686,
0.0431817248,
0.065512076,
0.0362351462,
0.0423921533,
0.0096102972,
-0.0880117714,
0.0420761444,
0.0164219644,
-0.0065548238,
-0.0129872551,
-0.0213621892,
-0.0100942375,
0.0141489124,
-0.0038283474,
0.0115373582,
-0.0078007802,
0.0112520037,
0.0448107272,
0.0092963595,
-0.0313055553,
-0.008216803,
-0.029411925,
0.0952469707,
0.1301376224,
0.0589488298,
-0.0047287336,
-0.0398933999,
-0.0606607571,
0.032163959,
0.0080655711,
0.029178787,
0.0218851361,
0.0148971751,
0.0036296125,
-0.0028022849,
0.0644362941,
0.0227437131,
-0.017989574,
0.0383115895,
0.0298270844,
-0.0083474806,
0.0109323747,
-0.0690360293,
0.0341094732,
0.0298470091,
0.0587047003,
0.0266233571,
-0.0564846396,
0.0083047757,
-0.027358735,
0.0051492187,
-0.0932426751,
-0.0127306916,
-0.0031236911,
-0.0020209167,
-0.0357915349,
-0.0739390105,
-0.0231418163,
-0.0227493495,
0.0194827598,
0.0423217006,
0.0001978711,
-0.0268702116,
-0.0047895312,
-0.0574131943,
0.0280676633,
0.0135296676,
0.0579886809,
-0.0601399019,
-0.0487177372,
0.0042741797,
-0.0919749588,
-0.0074535701,
0.03297925,
-0.0227272399,
-0.0439531058,
-0.0191856511,
0.0281831045,
0.0251743998,
0.0708936751,
-0.0085583208,
-0.0201037638,
0.0262177289,
0.0431777425,
-0.0563771017,
0.0063838684,
0.0127284834,
0.034469679,
0.0039898413,
-0.0201680362,
-0.0620468296,
0.020109633,
0.0140227303,
0.0247556716,
0.048507873,
-0.0681109577,
0.0224526897,
-0.008022693,
-0.0053971936,
-0.0473832786,
0.0212063324,
-0.0497658774,
-0.0102850795,
-0.0106646745,
-0.0063074613,
-0.0409015603,
-0.0018999557,
0.0221088659,
0.0083118305,
-0.0340174176,
-0.0352090709,
-0.0242908951,
0.0069214138,
-0.068464525,
-0.0052212696,
0.013150827,
0.0040767733,
0.0270748362,
-0.0086811753,
0.036394801,
0.0196662936,
-0.009447515,
0.0284805652,
0.0327882543,
0.0362922847,
0.0164648071,
-0.0118521629,
0.0189015456,
0.0530286841,
-0.0272809248,
0.027861964,
-0.0472289957,
-0.0097705787,
0.0369598567,
-0.0287412032,
0.0299791303,
0.0042827553,
0.0083266217,
-0.0047487835,
0.0266220272,
-0.0145404926,
-0.0386527851,
-0.0158682764,
0.003667322,
-0.0011730589,
-0.0180242117,
0.0239917524,
-0.0675971806,
-0.0073890053,
-0.0549965538,
-0.0109875025,
-0.0259437598,
-0.0103064608,
-0.0182701591,
0.0160024017,
-0.0252928026,
-0.0169306789,
-0.0421655141,
-0.0622035451,
0.0223387908,
0.0359133184,
0.0187535752,
-0.0030390045,
0.0624189191,
0.0113770384,
-0.0443837494,
0.0297567639,
0.0200984478,
-0.0551224984,
-0.0502704233,
-0.0485011302,
-0.0441553034,
-4.638447076e-33,
-0.0519117564,
-0.0266638696,
-0.0094700726,
0.0288943425,
-0.0203641299,
-0.0294386186,
-0.0432927646,
-0.0050069215,
0.0413603522,
-0.0109031647,
-0.0104657514,
-0.0278622732,
0.0155160837,
0.0168029945,
0.0172267258,
0.0100268461,
0.0721216276,
-0.0279390849,
-0.0645770282,
0.0319622494,
0.0410676412,
0.0064491434,
-0.0222652704,
-0.0897001252,
0.0115077645,
0.0007093008,
-0.0560504533,
-0.0323676318,
0.0071915258,
0.0715402216,
0.01381307,
0.025769325,
-0.035132505,
-0.0184212867,
0.0060666408,
0.0606356226,
-0.0469405353,
-0.009414156,
0.009919228,
0.0057817749,
-0.0171783026,
-0.045107659,
0.0121856509,
-0.0112486202,
-0.0415014513,
0.0192305204,
0.0631852224,
-0.0237259828,
0.0097895227,
-0.0500659347,
-0.0676552653,
-0.0052269343,
-0.0619096197,
-0.0733063444,
0.0208797753,
0.0648080334,
0.0012675902,
0.0149895027,
-0.0589802861,
0.0713394284,
0.0189955197,
0.0092936149,
0.0667297617,
0.0129495356,
-0.0202279873,
0.0569713637,
0.01979509,
-0.0576223284,
-0.0275566373,
0.0396808684,
-0.0189697985,
0.0361705199,
0.0312248394,
0.0140737984,
-0.0105128121,
-0.0338727571,
0.0367261767,
0.0775670335,
-0.0167130604,
-0.0358647965,
0.0128198881,
0.0462992825,
-0.0556442142,
0.0240297802,
-0.0582113042,
-0.0367169082,
-0.034275718,
-0.0601080172,
0.049061127,
-0.0210291855,
0.0082940171,
-0.0372184291,
-0.0052496586,
0.0093219299,
0.0209635366,
-0.0226517543,
-0.0681816563,
0.0452957228,
-0.0076500634,
-0.0314869098,
-0.0111596715,
0.0103773512,
0.1083453298,
0.0160042439,
0.025073288,
0.0214898065,
-0.0001751308,
0.0638932884,
-0.0568686165,
0.0149467066,
0.011890009,
0.0297499355,
0.0074117454,
-0.0250507817,
0.0188249741,
-0.0007078808,
-0.048678048,
0.0215448644,
-0.0176651869,
-0.001432433,
-0.0366250351,
-0.0642817765,
-0.0372838527,
-0.0186657235,
-0.0256604459,
0.0137943253,
-0.0013459905,
-0.0157606434,
0.0100963544,
-0.0130087463,
-0.0315320119,
0.0120700467,
2.357e-7,
-0.0292773675,
-0.0037534898,
0.0277677681,
0.0137296943,
0.0300034452,
0.0290071256,
-0.0290876292,
0.0060612084,
0.0182978828,
-0.0006346905,
0.0286890175,
-0.0221579205,
0.083422333,
0.0008690698,
-0.1024439558,
0.0103602456,
-0.101891309,
0.0326124318,
-0.0283284765,
0.0116748577,
0.0780562162,
0.0426751636,
0.0359568521,
-0.014746014,
0.0155250989,
0.0351651274,
0.0092879049,
-0.0313483998,
0.0304769501,
-0.0558383241,
0.0173794311,
-0.0548320226,
-0.0532965437,
-0.0191586372,
-0.0431375317,
0.0078241061,
0.0578064211,
0.0388314165,
-0.0042119683,
-0.0515138321,
-0.0466398858,
0.0396928303,
0.0140493568,
-0.0350375846,
0.0340389758,
0.0120928157,
-0.0036453286,
-0.0348410942,
-0.061837934,
-0.0125546195,
-0.0249066316,
-0.0340816155,
-0.0129685467,
-0.0407148637,
0.0201025084,
0.0472741127,
-0.0089390213,
-0.0163063463,
-0.022808427,
0.0056474684,
-0.0342243351,
-0.021848524,
-0.0613212623,
0.0285577849,
-0.0238935314,
-0.0794889182,
-0.0065102265,
1.660955265e-34,
0.0080262804,
-0.0409523025,
0.0289111603,
-0.0270645805,
0.0266480334,
0.0283209663,
0.057364963,
0.0163758285,
0.0295999106,
-0.0274805799,
-0.0593850128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00743v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00743v2 | Theoretical Understanding of In-Context Learning in Shallow Transformers with Unstructured Data | 2024-02-01T16:39:45 | 2024-06-18T13:11:32 | Yue Xing, Xiaofeng Lin, Chenheng Xu, Namjoon Suh, Qifan Song, Guang Cheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Large language models (LLMs) are powerful models that can learn concepts at
the inference stage via in-context learning (ICL). While theoretical studies,
e.g., \cite{zhang2023trained}, attempt to explain the mechanism of ICL, they
assume the input $x_i$ and the output $y_i$ of each demonstration example are
in the same token (i.e., structured data). However, in real practice, the
examples are usually text input, and all words, regardless of their logic
relationship, are stored in different tokens (i.e., unstructured data
\cite{wibisono2023role}). To understand how LLMs learn from the unstructured
data in ICL, this paper studies the role of each component in the transformer
architecture and provides a theoretical understanding to explain the success of
the architecture. In particular, we consider a simple transformer with one/two
attention layers and linear regression tasks for the ICL prediction. We observe
that (1) a transformer with two layers of (self-)attentions with a look-ahead
attention mask can learn from the prompt in the unstructured data, and (2)
positional encoding can match the $x_i$ and $y_i$ tokens to achieve a better
ICL performance. | [
0.0126974676,
0.030269511,
-0.0094697904,
0.0434493385,
-0.0260805096,
0.0123852603,
0.0185880121,
-0.008231963,
-0.0288999435,
-0.0637990162,
-0.0694711357,
-0.0228743516,
0.0342610478,
0.0113156084,
0.0434300266,
-0.0243242178,
0.0382754467,
-0.0486330576,
-0.006555168,
0.0052705426,
-0.0219437871,
-0.0349337906,
0.0359612219,
0.0257010497,
-0.012400751,
-0.0178156104,
-0.0248173904,
0.0026614026,
-0.0451773778,
-0.0160903968,
0.0065666987,
0.0252283812,
0.0241886619,
0.0506239757,
0.0000019704,
-0.0288833138,
-0.0233686157,
-0.0137941614,
-0.0295099095,
-0.0458195731,
0.0002963843,
-0.0640803352,
-0.0091114007,
-0.0043990659,
-0.0348200202,
-0.0337690637,
0.0640259683,
0.0938731283,
0.0541092418,
0.0909900516,
-0.0269100182,
-0.0428245813,
0.0273599382,
-0.0401745066,
0.0019139257,
-0.0199547037,
0.0362966694,
-0.0653823763,
-0.0307926349,
0.0367625318,
-0.0485124066,
0.0475737937,
0.0269197617,
0.0353166014,
-0.0049185115,
0.0572247021,
-0.0558106489,
-0.0280285683,
-0.0295700487,
0.0322909877,
-0.0614865869,
-0.0309900809,
-0.0264784209,
0.0041750302,
0.0157755539,
-0.0315704122,
-0.0353227407,
0.0456187911,
-0.0129589783,
0.0302632507,
0.0250560455,
0.0120234322,
0.0270710178,
-0.0162826292,
-0.0632800832,
0.0870967507,
-0.0038803769,
-0.0701671615,
-0.0079329526,
-0.0019371544,
-0.007013632,
-0.0541089699,
-0.0029352473,
0.044720903,
-0.0421026312,
0.0406627171,
-0.0466975495,
-0.0378971808,
-0.0212543756,
-0.0318364091,
0.0321319737,
0.0329745784,
-0.0203475859,
0.0435768068,
-0.0470659658,
0.0809574351,
-0.0419587009,
0.0575788729,
-0.025032239,
-0.0201111771,
0.0065346174,
-0.0224822517,
-0.0618948936,
0.0324892849,
-0.0447526388,
-0.0128171286,
0.008140157,
0.0508662835,
-0.0216762871,
0.000656304,
0.0106557151,
-0.0044717514,
-0.0724365041,
-0.0025691758,
-0.0235547945,
0.0306991637,
0.0162153747,
0.0228025373,
0.011250902,
-0.065213941,
-0.0235000718,
0.0186836664,
0.0397107825,
-0.0327015147,
0.0023795348,
0.0774075016,
-0.0278672203,
-0.0482588746,
-0.0427921116,
-0.0009526067,
-0.0113778729,
-0.0542562343,
0.0421126634,
-0.0600152425,
0.0188475456,
0.0349629931,
-0.0028317019,
-0.0382345095,
-0.0055017434,
0.0556276366,
-0.0398139954,
0.0746311545,
0.0349769592,
-0.0129882479,
-0.012946506,
-0.0082458723,
-0.0068209493,
0.0471356139,
-0.0053803558,
0.0248267446,
0.0021191903,
-0.0202695727,
0.0007061952,
0.0376332551,
0.0307160392,
-0.0018375994,
-0.0321016014,
0.0210842639,
-0.0046520098,
0.0263542887,
0.0293617453,
0.074789241,
-0.0094369473,
0.0007005841,
0.0688854158,
0.0545448922,
0.0442353524,
0.0488851033,
0.0202945732,
0.0008772155,
-0.0096150255,
0.047309801,
-0.0691591427,
0.0136095136,
0.0007947277,
0.0037112068,
-0.0022265171,
-0.0086903507,
-0.0527288727,
-0.0377998576,
-0.005047638,
-0.0146599114,
-0.001943237,
-0.0078809466,
0.0543220118,
0.0590478852,
-0.0754835904,
0.0889130905,
0.0136840213,
0.0007968391,
-0.0063621104,
-0.0470847338,
0.0076047918,
-0.01341628,
0.0051735137,
-0.0214148797,
-0.0281247627,
-0.0058004321,
-0.0018165864,
0.0428289734,
-0.0136382608,
-0.0018868825,
-0.0194938034,
-0.0124667864,
-0.0194304455,
-0.0030932019,
-0.0086677894,
0.0019543921,
0.0046301642,
-0.0311755612,
-0.0070273359,
-0.0079307603,
0.0149821322,
0.0405970961,
-0.020948397,
-0.0433214828,
-0.0107292123,
0.0210100152,
0.045698408,
-0.0196997467,
0.0239577498,
0.0238206834,
0.0526453666,
-0.0279403087,
-0.0072993827,
0.0028974314,
-0.1035549343,
-0.0397831425,
0.0095513761,
-0.0407319479,
-0.0128688328,
0.0365970507,
-0.0071538854,
-0.0402336828,
0.0045832852,
-0.0527837388,
0.0711211711,
-0.005940475,
0.0142496666,
0.0138534717,
0.0329377353,
-0.0475181788,
0.0797711238,
-0.0085841632,
0.0159695875,
0.0278054122,
0.0252850242,
-0.0125541138,
-0.0096415197,
-0.0243521053,
-0.014743709,
-0.0370948687,
-0.0094782133,
-0.0142606953,
-0.0262146536,
-0.0367504917,
-0.035790313,
-0.0495995246,
-0.0286570564,
-0.0359717757,
-0.0039866096,
0.0176541228,
0.0040455172,
0.0152470451,
-0.0263363291,
-0.0339624099,
0.0040165726,
0.0220379923,
0.0249063801,
0.035787832,
0.0138872396,
-0.003538223,
-0.0082511511,
-0.0218371022,
-0.0223591551,
0.0660025775,
-0.0014166578,
-0.0416273624,
-0.0867690668,
0.029030636,
0.0433662757,
0.0569975227,
-0.0341326408,
-0.0172598343,
0.010502398,
0.0008133592,
0.0764741972,
0.089005217,
0.008715841,
0.0345450342,
0.0259106569,
-0.0103712576,
-0.0399981961,
0.0255036969,
-0.0374046713,
-0.0024893552,
-0.078985393,
0.0210922882,
0.037727844,
0.0879219323,
-0.0037698965,
-0.0022159319,
-0.0393580459,
0.0110034551,
0.0115827145,
-0.0257144403,
-0.0118950494,
-0.0251302682,
-0.028670093,
0.0255425889,
-0.0109478841,
-0.0481273159,
0.0370967127,
-0.0422850214,
-0.0323171355,
-0.0412154645,
0.0068629063,
-0.0391209163,
0.0281136353,
0.0177039374,
0.0066713449,
-0.002454367,
-0.0363660194,
-0.0852917507,
0.026561439,
-0.0299203098,
0.0044939029,
0.0847995654,
0.0142570212,
-0.0071166619,
-0.0209558364,
-0.0256343018,
-0.0703076348,
-0.0305668432,
-0.0252433512,
0.0232665464,
0.037163198,
-0.0017078572,
-0.0452355593,
0.0218138881,
0.0293253791,
0.0502407886,
-0.0136190355,
-0.0248841662,
-0.0379634611,
0.0271779187,
0.0225946419,
0.0262459107,
0.0379221477,
-0.0189889949,
0.0042619524,
0.0573701933,
0.0408017151,
-0.0043051224,
-0.0203721523,
0.0122843944,
0.0549152158,
-0.0127780717,
-0.0064529581,
0.0273372345,
0.0320381485,
-0.0490774624,
-0.0540779904,
0.1091117263,
-0.0070696827,
-0.0707618669,
0.0020379764,
-0.0034782966,
-0.0001526579,
0.0330330171,
0.0209313855,
-0.0311211068,
-0.0188261326,
0.0121446457,
-0.0046400712,
0.0067765904,
-0.0046681701,
-0.0004407165,
-0.1087072864,
0.0157561656,
-0.0158924125,
-0.0624198392,
-0.0704604685,
-0.0372244194,
0.0055663511,
0.0226753596,
0.0411025435,
0.018487094,
-0.0448120013,
-0.0417256542,
0.0116358111,
-0.0003657398,
-0.0298237056,
0.0213442985,
-0.0229925904,
0.0122677144,
0.0576929636,
0.0150537062,
-0.030087566,
-0.0664223284,
0.0364952944,
0.0029534327,
0.0114162872,
-0.0062210704,
0.0297274273,
-0.0256063547,
-0.0075311554,
0.0017425783,
0.0349126197,
-0.0383731648,
-0.0029553559,
-0.040850997,
0.0882367641,
-0.012133278,
-0.0303122997,
-0.0033678017,
-0.0298800636,
-0.0071639447,
0.0723718554,
0.0271018352,
-0.0282995459,
-0.0432815403,
-0.0061508729,
0.02733404,
0.0069747539,
-0.0231491886,
0.0386645049,
-0.0030096038,
-0.0275634248,
-0.0519831069,
-0.0221631397,
0.0142119518,
0.0455421172,
0.003120515,
-0.0097917207,
0.0337558463,
-0.0006780667,
-0.0281244833,
0.0277330372,
-0.0188312531,
0.0085916705,
-0.0626046807,
-0.0006654466,
0.0279171485,
-0.0435190387,
-0.0255521592,
-0.0080088424,
-0.0855184942,
-0.0251880735,
0.0387866274,
0.0352323763,
0.0183482412,
0.0935161635,
-0.0104550235,
-0.0163298268,
0.0885515735,
0.020946512,
-0.0224059299,
0.0178930797,
0.0494649261,
-0.0093232514,
0.0052063284,
0.0428523198,
-0.038453754,
0.0194594972,
0.0503378808,
0.0118105588,
-0.0044658622,
-0.009147889,
0.0529019162,
-0.0212099887,
0.09570124,
0.009818946,
0.0432413891,
-0.0028122903,
0.0371144451,
0.0163758695,
-0.01298746,
-0.0428399295,
-0.0414785482,
0.0118542714,
0.0232641418,
0.0063396157,
0.0122239003,
0.0090861265,
0.0187437683,
-0.0043872101,
0.0183675606,
0.0346925631,
-0.0046997857,
0.0267801546,
0.0304006599,
-0.0189982634,
-0.0083207022,
0.0187450815,
0.0428478532,
-0.006485262,
0.0464938693,
0.0387171432,
0.0009659137,
-0.0527071692,
0.0161618963,
-0.088986896,
0.0106902039,
-0.0134177571,
-0.0195031371,
0.015515646,
-0.0618390664,
-0.0025262937,
-0.0150119392,
-0.0079720812,
-0.0099969944,
0.0100417556,
-0.0121757966,
-0.0289038885,
0.0535809398,
0.009098826,
-0.0052113892,
-0.0195793249,
0.0767105967,
0.0124344314,
0.0075079668,
0.0093452856,
0.0094086621,
-0.0298143886,
-0.0035630935,
0.0326257832,
0.0133827459,
-0.007556879,
-0.0058531263,
-0.0222512409,
-0.057969138,
0.030111663,
-0.0119800251,
0.0124315284,
-0.0481733195,
0.0349407755,
0.0750638619,
0.0296013337,
-0.0020493444,
-0.0000469381,
0.0184681602,
0.0466528833,
-0.0080835493,
-0.0384003408,
-6.324038385e-33,
-0.0281213522,
-0.0233593304,
0.0191643946,
0.0181086343,
0.0003595885,
0.023782935,
-0.0367139615,
-0.0184336975,
-0.0237744972,
-0.0047772289,
-0.049975872,
0.0056439256,
0.0112267109,
0.0520462543,
-0.0000466252,
-0.029836731,
0.0304230452,
0.0035609633,
-0.0100359889,
0.0045334497,
0.0226353891,
0.0126586109,
0.0760124773,
-0.0367446616,
-0.0045572692,
-0.0273257028,
0.0141802719,
0.0422861315,
-0.0199062396,
0.0609420761,
-0.0201700199,
0.0290975887,
0.0386160016,
-0.0666089505,
-0.0329963267,
0.0871571749,
-0.1030635685,
-0.018987963,
0.0024684726,
0.049121283,
-0.0469104759,
-0.0096594328,
0.0882169977,
0.0012895277,
-0.002549795,
-0.0347955748,
0.0256996993,
0.0008669423,
-0.0345247127,
-0.0165684447,
-0.0683008283,
-0.0014637058,
0.0351497307,
-0.0121409437,
0.0288889874,
0.0610170625,
0.010654984,
0.0414523482,
-0.0836061686,
0.0048583038,
-0.0233589597,
0.0562063567,
0.043182198,
0.0434114859,
-0.0051798723,
0.0462137908,
0.0348252021,
0.0116816051,
-0.0239878949,
-0.0514821671,
0.0492704771,
0.0440101735,
0.0127709517,
0.000149359,
0.0513268821,
0.0105045345,
-0.0495548956,
-0.0235560276,
-0.0249449238,
0.0651972368,
0.0395969711,
-0.0011556412,
-0.0186804067,
-0.0368775055,
-0.0198108274,
-0.0145719517,
-0.0289705899,
-0.0004279532,
0.0254991204,
0.0287498683,
0.0057015326,
0.0081649106,
0.0440464132,
-0.0446643904,
-0.0062293927,
0.0105674947,
0.0125654554,
0.0117369164,
-0.0022893746,
0.0281914752,
-0.0743364543,
-0.0384924598,
-0.0082621314,
0.0155777829,
0.0092304302,
0.0309369974,
0.0748859495,
0.0452433862,
-0.0582530759,
-0.0486618616,
-0.0467685945,
-0.0066816774,
-0.0209051054,
0.0179256424,
0.0542225316,
0.0279925689,
-0.026767388,
0.0149951354,
0.0092414059,
-0.0100314701,
-0.0313836299,
0.0291509498,
-0.0139266374,
0.0065342076,
-0.0109505728,
-0.0337273479,
-0.0636911541,
0.0254096575,
0.0469111949,
-0.0654332489,
-0.005507255,
0.0265198816,
2.758e-7,
0.0351094827,
0.0380545557,
0.042965062,
0.0075263064,
0.0501409359,
0.029783586,
-0.0207395591,
0.0429097936,
0.0325805061,
0.003286469,
0.0061813211,
-0.0032867424,
-0.0035601389,
0.0219151042,
-0.0969531983,
-0.0184125323,
-0.0567942038,
0.0283343978,
-0.0070795757,
0.0213190522,
0.0193321873,
0.1260453165,
-0.0171839613,
-0.0203698594,
-0.0154565237,
-0.0118340002,
0.0529533923,
-0.005076509,
0.0495671332,
0.0165812578,
-0.0164480582,
0.0032633576,
0.0148909725,
0.0364851169,
0.010374533,
0.0317646489,
-0.0056190416,
0.0334001668,
-0.0020382639,
-0.0466255359,
0.0045395936,
0.0007182297,
-0.0226255283,
-0.071334362,
0.0512022413,
-0.1312265843,
-0.0425269566,
-0.0300650652,
-0.0124494908,
0.0189552922,
-0.0498593748,
0.0337713994,
-0.0149286669,
0.0015261429,
0.0223951023,
-0.0064471383,
-0.0033572582,
-0.0813732669,
-0.0341122001,
0.0065807314,
-0.0598810092,
-0.03016489,
-0.0646177903,
-0.0006918107,
0.0648861229,
-0.0137432143,
-0.0068699946,
2.621272276e-34,
-0.009577536,
-0.00061341,
0.0197911914,
0.0388992317,
-0.0143435718,
-0.0520108119,
0.0162719004,
0.0421288908,
0.0354607962,
-0.0687978342,
-0.0148974704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00742v1 | Transforming and Combining Rewards for Aligning Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T16:39:28 | 2024-02-01T16:39:28 | Zihao Wang, Chirag Nagpal, Jonathan Berant, Jacob Eisenstein, Alex D'Amour, Sanmi Koyejo, Victor Veitch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2 | A common approach for aligning language models to human preferences is to
first learn a reward model from preference data, and then use this reward model
to update the language model. We study two closely related problems that arise
in this approach. First, any monotone transformation of the reward model
preserves preference ranking; is there a choice that is ``better'' than others?
Second, we often wish to align language models to multiple properties: how
should we combine multiple reward models? Using a probabilistic interpretation
of the alignment procedure, we identify a natural choice for transformation for
(the common case of) rewards learned from Bradley-Terry preference models. This
derived transformation has two important properties. First, it emphasizes
improving poorly-performing outputs, rather than outputs that already score
well. This mitigates both underfitting (where some prompts are not improved)
and reward hacking (where the model learns to exploit misspecification of the
reward model). Second, it enables principled aggregation of rewards by linking
summation to logical conjunction: the sum of transformed rewards corresponds to
the probability that the output is ``good'' in all measured properties, in a
sense we make precise. Experiments aligning language models to be both helpful
and harmless using RLHF show substantial improvements over the baseline
(non-transformed) approach. | [
0.0451663658,
0.0755148008,
0.0009661348,
-0.0080217924,
-0.0514567904,
0.0113261063,
-0.032021109,
-0.0093151135,
-0.0649641007,
-0.0183343664,
-0.0598041788,
-0.0078734187,
0.0251433328,
0.001350551,
-0.0050270399,
-0.0953491405,
0.0545339733,
-0.0354372151,
0.0082278596,
-0.0256153438,
-0.0052092844,
-0.028836688,
0.0044088867,
0.0261799712,
0.0519717485,
0.0047267433,
0.0301109292,
-0.0250748768,
0.0556785651,
-0.0013505126,
-0.0144997211,
0.0438702106,
0.0036074629,
0.0243038293,
0.0000019599,
-0.0762152523,
-0.0191036947,
-0.0210284255,
-0.0090321302,
0.0054541309,
0.0539129339,
0.041037742,
-0.0119906543,
0.0218910612,
-0.0161559358,
0.0140316328,
0.0423634276,
0.0126925735,
0.0062001999,
0.0290682074,
0.0193035118,
-0.0097326487,
-0.0092197377,
-0.0483560301,
0.0257005822,
-0.0108399978,
0.005810143,
-0.0207346231,
0.0144756939,
0.0031764787,
-0.0152320489,
-0.0011362473,
-0.007738661,
-0.0003672912,
0.0582447946,
0.048143588,
0.0020211085,
0.0054238997,
-0.0078745568,
0.0172372032,
-0.0201062858,
0.0095455647,
-0.021325402,
-0.0114587834,
0.03666462,
0.0080096163,
-0.0161971841,
0.0038027752,
0.0283888262,
0.0284475461,
0.0607349351,
0.0214539971,
0.0276689436,
0.0241042525,
-0.0084855137,
0.1099936441,
0.0180516597,
-0.0546975099,
0.0037336641,
0.0318102278,
-0.0241219159,
-0.040882811,
-0.0200330988,
-0.0115534393,
-0.0272834674,
0.0256288536,
0.0130774202,
0.0588929728,
-0.0000951674,
-0.0172574967,
0.0532556213,
0.0382525399,
-0.0110972058,
0.0317742489,
-0.0223841146,
0.0815740973,
-0.0150235649,
0.0373753496,
-0.0602360629,
0.0482070446,
-0.0082126819,
-0.0133692846,
0.0282451008,
0.0365104787,
0.0019848249,
-0.0018735427,
-0.0939688683,
0.0186399855,
-0.0382692739,
0.0371728539,
0.0201565865,
0.0220154114,
-0.0571804233,
0.0091579491,
-0.0755235702,
0.0394246653,
-0.0113368984,
0.0229793582,
0.0361485779,
0.0348116606,
0.0223797243,
-0.0147925103,
-0.020295864,
-0.037519604,
0.0013579233,
0.0775827616,
0.0063630901,
-0.0092096636,
0.0256837513,
0.0060084364,
-0.0418255627,
-0.0096001085,
-0.012709002,
-0.0798319653,
0.0135178417,
-0.0110396836,
-0.0009245874,
-0.0181933213,
-0.0052228896,
-0.0319957882,
-0.0461162105,
0.051180318,
0.0402521007,
0.0150843309,
-0.0019821059,
-0.0158412326,
-0.0305163916,
0.0362916589,
0.0386909358,
0.0601751804,
0.0292916503,
-0.0339900516,
-0.0088722296,
0.0381007865,
-0.0098446375,
0.0281423591,
-0.0195087865,
-0.0078868456,
0.038164258,
0.0341447294,
0.0588693321,
0.0261220429,
-0.0178128742,
0.0178505648,
0.0858631507,
0.0224519819,
0.0297223423,
-0.0489104539,
-0.0275641177,
-0.0378644876,
-0.031584233,
0.0447992682,
-0.0514436588,
0.0237821247,
-0.0310301185,
0.0152202277,
0.0278945975,
0.0097093042,
-0.003023772,
-0.0388235636,
0.005167657,
-0.0185950268,
0.0555890054,
0.0452634394,
0.0730800778,
-0.0189916957,
-0.0271945596,
-0.0279902127,
0.0643805042,
-0.0444035493,
0.0329731591,
-0.0739562362,
0.0385086909,
0.0758681968,
0.028538717,
-0.020817576,
0.026235817,
-0.0275000054,
-0.0829773769,
0.0363057181,
0.054017406,
-0.0268102102,
-0.0164609626,
-0.0023696006,
-0.0363251194,
0.0175408274,
0.016058702,
0.0346438177,
-0.0088997781,
-0.0523489602,
-0.0287349112,
0.0399844274,
-0.0379778929,
0.0142580345,
0.0280062556,
0.0047884923,
0.0199029706,
0.0155679537,
0.0518988185,
-0.0160352029,
0.0103408052,
0.0270135738,
-0.0006092601,
-0.0101994723,
-0.0107982336,
0.0345822945,
-0.0272198748,
-0.0050793304,
0.0199021008,
0.0071663209,
0.0194984376,
0.060245242,
0.0016249969,
-0.0114339124,
0.0061920062,
-0.0217929035,
0.0539306216,
0.0355913565,
0.0630758032,
-0.0313444994,
-0.0608326048,
-0.0802766085,
0.0638046265,
-0.0151530188,
0.0391743481,
-0.048170168,
-0.0544898808,
-0.0162787698,
-0.0790712163,
-0.0220722053,
0.0193237681,
0.0035593684,
0.0382543094,
0.0718067512,
0.0000689056,
-0.033961907,
-0.0476713814,
-0.0158346128,
-0.0010342005,
0.0100224083,
0.0118468795,
0.0312484875,
-0.0058672712,
0.0148022696,
0.0049536233,
-0.0604430325,
-0.0163767375,
0.0415257923,
0.0433581509,
0.0283931438,
0.0168621801,
-0.024611026,
-0.0618481264,
-0.0398363844,
-0.0277178846,
0.0034132537,
0.0037897341,
0.0406370237,
-0.052913256,
0.0435148031,
-0.04690383,
-0.0107163182,
-0.0118212737,
-0.0177779682,
0.0243790355,
0.0161924809,
0.0315591767,
0.101496987,
0.0366199538,
0.0291318763,
0.0752918795,
0.0106837293,
-0.0813051686,
-0.0227612704,
-0.0593864657,
-0.0490813144,
-0.0193764791,
-0.0710714906,
-0.0035067953,
0.0588699654,
0.0200300552,
-0.0042936783,
-0.0569467619,
0.0188704282,
-0.0399863459,
-0.0459704734,
-0.0593835413,
-0.029749155,
-0.0317725539,
0.0580854341,
-0.0367765389,
-0.0733292848,
0.0579028055,
0.0056166835,
0.0357841812,
-0.0523349606,
-0.0059154257,
-0.0129217552,
0.0002115145,
0.0214457586,
0.0383286811,
-0.0163211524,
-0.0247994084,
-0.0757692978,
-0.0402907468,
0.067873098,
-0.0407867953,
0.054493174,
-0.0147808399,
-0.0103053702,
-0.0236126147,
-0.0854958892,
-0.0408289693,
-0.0521742664,
0.0181125868,
-0.0044689472,
0.0206339508,
-0.0146314092,
-0.0343185738,
-0.0223051719,
0.067617178,
-0.0195385665,
-0.0146319419,
-0.0096597811,
-0.0003592303,
-0.0018834599,
0.0757453889,
0.002974466,
0.0233111773,
-0.046747718,
-0.0389967598,
0.0212095864,
0.0319170579,
0.0283118505,
0.0189483818,
0.0236306228,
0.0665802509,
-0.0485869907,
-0.0302220471,
0.0292629562,
0.0092348643,
0.0021297401,
-0.0035797318,
0.0740024894,
0.0289113279,
-0.0428128354,
0.0259199888,
-0.0203097612,
0.0313198529,
-0.0059255115,
0.0242829565,
-0.065926753,
0.0203072745,
0.0077052927,
0.0356020927,
-0.0274777319,
-0.005873241,
0.0445725359,
-0.1245661154,
-0.0225997455,
0.0146206552,
-0.0425167456,
0.0054213381,
-0.0344228745,
-0.0010792667,
-0.0353973024,
-0.0122614615,
0.0240528304,
0.008440732,
0.0075123073,
0.0224621911,
0.0533851534,
-0.0126418769,
0.0059983376,
-0.0381474085,
0.0579553619,
0.12385346,
0.001837038,
-0.0379588008,
-0.0526438206,
-0.0378706791,
0.042681843,
-0.0341431759,
0.0222825836,
0.0009375314,
0.0018102373,
-0.0009867392,
-0.0346529484,
0.0219608452,
0.0248856861,
-0.0102311382,
-0.0131413629,
0.0352648832,
0.0281995833,
-0.0136730522,
-0.0157111268,
-0.0061266553,
-0.0004400463,
0.0757143721,
-0.0127802445,
-0.0786292851,
0.0396615043,
-0.039816767,
-0.0446372107,
-0.0013052381,
-0.0347425304,
0.0147553589,
-0.0006011242,
-0.0350542627,
-0.0812923759,
-0.0353603438,
-0.0226950087,
0.0253894087,
0.0247835964,
-0.0104701845,
-0.0235872958,
-0.0023320271,
-0.006551119,
0.0344205946,
-0.0017312767,
0.0128510324,
-0.0868799835,
-0.0042958069,
0.0065168147,
-0.0513620488,
-0.0441093557,
-0.0644725487,
0.0056987521,
-0.0683981106,
0.0129728373,
0.0697012916,
0.0343322679,
0.0222740564,
0.0127701666,
-0.0201073699,
-0.0100860586,
0.0258745458,
-0.0158755649,
0.0204680376,
0.0178746693,
0.0147200599,
-0.0084202383,
0.0005759745,
-0.0639762133,
0.0130458223,
0.0425807275,
0.0343216099,
-0.0003196171,
-0.0538241267,
0.0638775229,
0.0211632587,
0.0375816599,
-0.0350064524,
0.0009427935,
-0.0170258675,
-0.0194993485,
-0.0027868371,
-0.0453842133,
0.0072524142,
-0.041903235,
0.0668458641,
0.0211232603,
0.0099492501,
-0.0130056012,
0.0026608368,
0.0147106294,
-0.0463389009,
-0.0119280843,
0.0154840294,
0.0144844335,
0.0277738404,
0.0330740176,
-0.0232708324,
-0.0114786979,
0.0130347461,
0.0539410189,
0.0158571228,
0.0422954001,
0.0287354123,
0.0071597388,
-0.0027003256,
0.0392749794,
-0.0460488573,
-0.0292495023,
-0.0221332535,
-0.0316260904,
0.0354667678,
-0.0153697487,
0.0667020604,
-0.0140596787,
-0.0197599307,
-0.031010652,
-0.0079963561,
-0.0188011806,
-0.0176878814,
0.0372712798,
0.024097437,
0.0091217821,
-0.0498117022,
0.0376544148,
-0.0316309929,
0.0095773339,
-0.0410914272,
-0.0063222502,
-0.0095609147,
-0.0173456538,
0.0072417511,
0.0345784687,
-0.0467363372,
-0.005667191,
-0.0661784708,
-0.0435749739,
-0.046964433,
0.0709224865,
0.0404577777,
-0.0207267962,
0.0172005221,
0.0297798887,
-0.0413296819,
0.0081764301,
-0.0578347929,
0.0011438688,
-0.0165266357,
-0.0049138074,
-0.0467821136,
-5.792526492e-33,
-0.039095439,
0.0142652281,
0.011229896,
0.006432489,
-0.0068077035,
-0.0367445275,
0.0159713998,
0.0536288209,
-0.0171902012,
-0.0084692566,
-0.0058697583,
-0.0629588291,
0.003749931,
-0.0180654656,
0.0371027589,
-0.0006725919,
0.0366663672,
0.0115543446,
-0.0922333971,
-0.0179177523,
0.0464419201,
-0.0249814037,
0.068059139,
-0.0456783436,
0.0430313163,
0.0537505001,
-0.0388501063,
0.0222997908,
-0.0251079407,
0.0592333749,
0.0179324988,
0.031889841,
0.0042517548,
-0.0530569777,
0.0032235929,
0.0229443479,
-0.0277101584,
-0.0054160934,
0.0683400556,
-0.0057818787,
-0.0112085203,
-0.0414596647,
0.0361264572,
0.0034835977,
-0.0663935393,
0.0056911651,
0.0268245935,
-0.0328934938,
-0.03545231,
0.0273264535,
-0.0661808699,
-0.0123307835,
0.0018654163,
-0.0178990569,
-0.0060298438,
0.0362763777,
-0.0200501904,
0.049052123,
-0.0342307724,
0.091245994,
0.0275883134,
0.0443951711,
0.0776368007,
0.0186472032,
0.0013587663,
0.0391924903,
0.0197487827,
0.0077131577,
0.0240151752,
-0.0196792521,
0.0384036079,
0.0059703523,
0.0548680462,
0.0267869569,
0.0476150028,
-0.0233755037,
-0.0135661969,
0.0421799198,
0.020896703,
-0.0195353143,
0.0313445255,
0.0527848527,
-0.0522332489,
-0.0390011929,
-0.0528208576,
-0.0081225066,
-0.0344568454,
-0.0582875237,
0.0429249667,
0.01009434,
-0.0175811164,
-0.0219424833,
0.0221719798,
-0.0359641202,
-0.0577007905,
0.0061454321,
-0.0300990269,
0.0375028141,
-0.0256970488,
-0.0257400591,
-0.0732476711,
0.0011893085,
-0.0443604365,
0.0121183163,
-0.0159968119,
0.0523357764,
0.0297117718,
-0.0063308491,
-0.0372580178,
0.0197512321,
-0.0197825171,
-0.0118181948,
0.0277659856,
-0.0194908418,
0.038951803,
-0.0260243937,
0.0035299924,
0.0061520245,
0.0008549868,
-0.0549903475,
-0.0670092329,
0.0087898485,
-0.0021921152,
0.0189636163,
-0.0058098412,
-0.0117068952,
-0.0110223079,
0.040519312,
0.0216946863,
0.0007990022,
-0.0252245944,
-0.0320576765,
2.644e-7,
0.0304977354,
0.0287775081,
-0.0281298123,
0.0183084905,
-0.0251811482,
0.0655823424,
-0.0151628749,
0.0271816291,
0.080478631,
0.0317130461,
-0.0060145389,
-0.0081166783,
-0.0055513349,
-0.0044025714,
-0.0157523174,
-0.0435951613,
-0.0535375141,
0.0077252355,
0.0055441679,
-0.0004074507,
0.0364598259,
0.049617961,
0.0466386229,
0.0024396733,
-0.019553164,
0.0177463256,
0.0532533117,
-0.0832898095,
-0.0178643558,
0.0152579695,
-0.0153992688,
-0.0241036732,
-0.0197951421,
-0.0030251369,
0.0226914622,
-0.0025512334,
0.0182844866,
0.0432961769,
-0.0236451272,
-0.0226121098,
-0.0377109833,
0.0006087999,
0.0114376908,
-0.0744990557,
0.0330734439,
-0.0614103936,
-0.0323965698,
-0.0244714152,
-0.0211409945,
-0.00041757,
0.0189486165,
-0.0238127615,
-0.0259343125,
-0.0169623028,
0.0130096665,
0.0598683804,
-0.0005134276,
-0.0413940027,
-0.0364801325,
0.0489129238,
-0.0205879323,
-0.0924902707,
-0.0123141799,
0.0771050304,
-0.0380133577,
-0.0883255899,
-0.0156189837,
2.415360104e-34,
0.0097704316,
0.0259205531,
0.041405309,
-0.0220410805,
0.0214126501,
0.009475572,
-0.0091585768,
0.0044421293,
0.0573339611,
-0.0454139374,
-0.0279115718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00723v1 | Improving Semantic Control in Discrete Latent Spaces with Transformer Quantized Variational Autoencoders | 2024-02-01T16:14:35 | 2024-02-01T16:14:35 | Yingji Zhang, Danilo S. Carvalho, Marco Valentino, Ian Pratt-Hartmann, Andre Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Achieving precise semantic control over the latent spaces of Variational
AutoEncoders (VAEs) holds significant value for downstream tasks in NLP as the
underlying generative mechanisms could be better localised, explained and
improved upon. Recent research, however, has struggled to achieve consistent
results, primarily due to the inevitable loss of semantic information in the
variational bottleneck and limited control over the decoding mechanism. To
overcome these challenges, we investigate discrete latent spaces in Vector
Quantized Variational AutoEncoders (VQVAEs) to improve semantic control and
generation in Transformer-based VAEs. In particular, We propose T5VQVAE, a
novel model that leverages the controllability of VQVAEs to guide the
self-attention mechanism in T5 at the token-level, exploiting its full
generalization capabilities. Experimental results indicate that T5VQVAE
outperforms existing state-of-the-art VAE models, including Optimus, in terms
of controllability and preservation of semantic information across different
tasks such as auto-encoding of sentences and mathematical expressions, text
transfer, and inference. Moreover, T5VQVAE exhibits improved inference
capabilities, suggesting potential applications for downstream natural language
and symbolic reasoning tasks. | [
0.0218481049,
0.1191178337,
-0.0336612277,
0.024455864,
-0.0151450047,
0.0055524544,
0.0348345488,
-0.0370917916,
-0.0483623073,
-0.0026466874,
0.0039884164,
-0.0187495761,
-0.0465337709,
0.0577908717,
0.062660329,
-0.04843219,
0.0500127263,
-0.0113457842,
-0.0165567566,
-0.0534899831,
-0.0054912888,
-0.0416673981,
0.0084214192,
0.0202640221,
-0.0230379216,
-0.005381417,
-0.0073733516,
-0.0432921313,
0.0130108027,
0.0241602194,
-0.0024317224,
0.0500382408,
0.0526116788,
-0.0220011733,
0.0000021123,
0.004640284,
-0.0201396011,
-0.0255420748,
-0.0455729626,
-0.0281654634,
0.0178880543,
-0.0571403168,
-0.00789838,
-0.0305623598,
-0.0036708808,
-0.0761160478,
0.0721860006,
0.0434754267,
0.0557062216,
0.0330822654,
-0.0127848238,
-0.0281134024,
0.0287561398,
-0.0420486219,
0.0424278788,
-0.0729860365,
0.0259046741,
-0.0090587214,
0.0000808455,
0.0339423865,
-0.0901969746,
0.0416075066,
0.0645012632,
-0.0217477083,
0.0111719277,
0.0376364142,
0.0083834156,
-0.0415187813,
-0.0411075465,
0.031512443,
-0.0241983775,
-0.0439017229,
-0.0277415216,
-0.0120640164,
-0.0295702145,
0.0174183454,
-0.026059987,
0.0533904582,
0.0287798811,
-0.0042994218,
0.0224122759,
0.0427445695,
0.0188337546,
0.0072980388,
-0.0394939221,
0.0111588426,
0.0375911035,
-0.0239076037,
-0.0036917883,
0.0097197508,
-0.1076287255,
-0.0036585785,
0.0141098956,
0.003726148,
-0.0308551881,
-0.0060918857,
-0.0326858982,
-0.0678492486,
-0.0501099601,
0.0260879155,
0.0286261011,
0.0818757713,
0.0137626957,
0.0085942801,
-0.0270618815,
0.0836821422,
-0.0717022344,
0.0377281494,
-0.0416496806,
-0.034747839,
0.0184685588,
-0.0184806958,
-0.0443006121,
0.013093113,
-0.0288467743,
-0.0266284607,
-0.0122308554,
0.0418215059,
-0.031200368,
-0.0130694201,
-0.0004964737,
0.0691303909,
-0.0552360751,
0.0097743487,
0.0221315566,
0.0161734391,
-0.0548446961,
0.0083652902,
0.0007461312,
-0.0245936997,
-0.0367213823,
0.0166968051,
0.0598861463,
-0.0621798374,
-0.0129469885,
0.0424611792,
-0.0059509892,
0.0049365074,
0.0020506091,
0.0127374465,
-0.0194323082,
-0.0306820627,
0.0323947109,
-0.0193655416,
0.0312307607,
0.0153957633,
-0.0092958398,
-0.0141880335,
-0.0056161042,
-0.0059764492,
0.0054745376,
0.0771794692,
0.0542817898,
-0.0259318464,
0.0240281411,
-0.0038687075,
0.0281714536,
0.033065699,
0.0061287163,
0.0402523018,
-0.0157879721,
0.0134029714,
-0.0114454813,
0.0203496516,
0.0515293926,
-0.046037633,
-0.0385703556,
-0.0285867434,
-0.020603437,
0.039062459,
0.0877021849,
0.050564833,
-0.0589865148,
-0.0371318869,
0.0200314447,
0.0342540517,
0.0576642491,
0.0181732774,
0.0456232727,
-0.0034577085,
-0.0283196941,
-0.0195554085,
-0.028245056,
0.0980246738,
0.0495350771,
0.0048406217,
0.0009646799,
-0.0006821797,
-0.0103922822,
-0.0382965431,
0.0116056688,
0.0141546559,
-0.0025781477,
-0.012433623,
0.0343314484,
0.0550427027,
-0.0210167915,
0.0786293745,
0.0136927338,
-0.011736189,
0.0252245665,
-0.0091867223,
0.0333953016,
0.0077792173,
0.0207022242,
0.0154452249,
0.0220185183,
-0.0083104428,
-0.0316066965,
0.0505750217,
0.0121851889,
-0.0045056948,
-0.0328763723,
-0.0203536414,
-0.0708408281,
-0.0739057958,
0.0095534744,
-0.004860518,
0.0192543287,
-0.0184782781,
-0.0177444872,
-0.0167838149,
0.0641226918,
0.0309013128,
-0.0137311053,
-0.0124051478,
0.0303408355,
0.0125223873,
0.0306042321,
-0.0063938303,
0.0073920675,
0.0255948436,
0.0064993352,
-0.0563923903,
-0.0340213291,
-0.0078515038,
-0.0640407503,
-0.0783439279,
0.0078497538,
-0.0367924683,
-0.0054402524,
0.0304504521,
-0.0238514841,
-0.0139897326,
0.0753771067,
-0.0531932153,
-0.0188637357,
-0.0338714384,
-0.0478960946,
0.0355849639,
0.0397803001,
0.0011349987,
0.066862911,
-0.0398011953,
0.023441365,
0.0333006233,
0.0787939429,
-0.0099305622,
0.0078712655,
0.0162114184,
-0.0176849775,
0.0181907564,
0.0038267542,
0.0293501504,
-0.0049305819,
-0.0041291397,
-0.0290146898,
-0.0601860918,
-0.0102539696,
-0.0489212014,
-0.0149600906,
0.0186338462,
0.0521829873,
0.0219518766,
0.0206702314,
-0.0000308136,
0.0062162634,
-0.0064248084,
0.0111792712,
0.0202138685,
-0.0244671702,
0.0417858921,
-0.0165666789,
-0.0385595076,
-0.0108704148,
0.0558362827,
-0.0075566121,
0.0085185068,
0.0126418993,
-0.028156234,
-0.0003815585,
-0.0053095748,
-0.0209521074,
-0.0159745198,
-0.0035477439,
-0.0302913897,
0.0714719743,
0.025755519,
0.0188066922,
0.0618398935,
0.0365574136,
0.0092372121,
-0.0360407345,
0.0345172249,
-0.1009173915,
-0.0096398136,
-0.0055568512,
0.0354164056,
-0.002378287,
0.0596818887,
0.0285880882,
-0.0012992135,
-0.068815887,
0.0673840195,
-0.0040908037,
-0.0324227698,
0.0154943271,
0.022573011,
-0.0362686962,
0.0456203669,
-0.0612809211,
0.0216796771,
0.0656642467,
0.0433363281,
-0.0005805493,
-0.0193791073,
0.0453586429,
-0.025569031,
0.0274022855,
0.0570382513,
0.0177619532,
-0.0221445262,
-0.0354580432,
-0.02953084,
0.0367454104,
0.0056705326,
0.0230874699,
0.0297413599,
0.0078439619,
0.01100084,
0.0254152752,
-0.0290751811,
-0.0494066887,
-0.0034466842,
0.0317781344,
0.045476377,
0.0593730472,
0.0058959229,
-0.0119548589,
-0.0213372689,
0.0210703015,
0.0447588712,
-0.033163663,
-0.0186858345,
-0.0319132656,
0.055918891,
0.0528945886,
0.0430769734,
0.0275676865,
-0.0246865358,
-0.0668522194,
0.036689505,
-0.0052405745,
-0.0001588832,
-0.003583255,
0.0686158836,
0.0218740758,
-0.01470323,
0.0446774699,
-0.0178691093,
0.028089691,
-0.0286110137,
-0.059127491,
0.0521415807,
-0.0161206573,
-0.0035450391,
0.0174832176,
-0.0555516519,
0.0114501398,
0.0105249276,
0.0116701936,
-0.0745894164,
-0.0237719361,
-0.0283940677,
-0.0009389918,
0.0275678281,
0.0004307278,
-0.0087175937,
-0.0393807143,
0.0248757619,
-0.0062862923,
-0.0119330911,
0.003319531,
-0.0015188607,
0.0050645513,
-0.0426430404,
0.0545489751,
-0.009591287,
0.0087871104,
0.0046524988,
0.0163491759,
0.0670866743,
-0.0481769778,
-0.002918293,
-0.0218313038,
0.015928803,
0.080541499,
0.0076873042,
-0.0132054193,
-0.0391754508,
-0.0034991286,
-0.0536196642,
-0.0021704168,
-0.0089878431,
0.0415330194,
-0.0428195298,
-0.0183832105,
0.0161850043,
0.0340603217,
-0.0115567995,
-0.0330221727,
-0.0350959972,
0.0491657034,
0.0019469213,
-0.0490712412,
-0.0244445819,
-0.0173627771,
-0.0621210635,
0.0378563106,
0.0387015268,
-0.0223570094,
-0.0608257353,
-0.0148210507,
0.028312102,
-0.0475263037,
-0.0587995574,
-0.036659535,
0.0564100146,
-0.1235490292,
-0.0327164046,
-0.0238775052,
0.0052994583,
0.0107523724,
-0.0308778435,
-0.0345336422,
0.0421225876,
-0.0493930914,
-0.0606204681,
-0.0177748334,
0.0126626901,
0.0013312881,
0.0160875153,
-0.0037552561,
0.0030106667,
-0.0634463429,
-0.0299876127,
-0.0315692537,
-0.0989972949,
-0.0427267477,
0.0280566756,
0.0472833067,
0.0004139841,
0.0758747682,
-0.0103009259,
-0.0288441256,
0.0798719153,
0.0153730912,
-0.0211219788,
0.0248458143,
0.005858182,
0.0171921812,
0.0021662144,
0.0392712802,
-0.0215115137,
0.0132337306,
0.0305301752,
0.0763262585,
-0.0112319728,
0.0022885979,
0.0281585604,
-0.0846560821,
0.01836849,
-0.0004554075,
0.0082947053,
-0.0293756574,
-0.0046873349,
-0.015696276,
-0.0165939312,
-0.0564602353,
0.0205885544,
0.0239528995,
0.040107552,
-0.0256241411,
-0.0078195361,
0.0487740748,
-0.0124735758,
-0.0016650878,
0.0117186978,
0.0183089916,
0.0152814863,
-0.0170745663,
0.0278203227,
-0.005665814,
-0.0119918948,
0.0043220632,
0.0398978852,
-0.019883994,
0.0477803536,
0.0599817708,
-0.0133578982,
-0.0160890762,
0.0039530629,
-0.0709012672,
-0.0335830078,
-0.0301995855,
-0.0308203548,
0.0037184937,
0.0202080682,
0.0199288502,
-0.0336833447,
-0.0242901985,
0.0167198628,
-0.0089078369,
-0.0049675428,
-0.0500740558,
0.0442517959,
0.0023836778,
0.0338285938,
-0.043838948,
0.0120261209,
-0.0052349679,
-0.0018278677,
-0.047098849,
0.0186008159,
-0.0435476899,
-0.0105308453,
-0.0297233779,
0.0068148565,
0.0091039361,
0.0218123011,
-0.0085804695,
-0.0368407667,
0.0250722021,
0.010108687,
-0.0310164969,
-0.0038110644,
0.0326912925,
0.0499366857,
0.0002336498,
-0.0929984823,
-0.0181639604,
0.0266992915,
0.0344504043,
-0.0126095302,
-0.0538901985,
-7.071060636e-33,
-0.039571736,
-0.0393737331,
0.0132577755,
-0.0215994287,
-0.0307194684,
0.0038449191,
-0.0750369206,
-0.0424620323,
0.0091660693,
0.0295358151,
0.0109767662,
0.0238494966,
-0.0088908682,
0.0414621383,
0.0364426896,
-0.0527862236,
0.0566567294,
-0.0017976855,
-0.0074179326,
0.0270078611,
-0.0067718774,
0.0309920572,
0.0473106615,
-0.0240939576,
0.0239680856,
0.0379279591,
0.0362035893,
0.0054803444,
0.0059368992,
0.0461656675,
-0.0411902517,
0.006928158,
0.0145803494,
-0.038718868,
-0.0271165352,
-0.0294211637,
-0.0949943438,
-0.0527681038,
-0.0238878969,
0.0171098597,
-0.0319822766,
-0.0388987437,
0.0866490453,
-0.0141606424,
0.0025835531,
-0.0587844029,
0.0119936336,
0.0128030824,
0.0035715606,
-0.1061892733,
-0.0514261462,
-0.0029604123,
0.0050040586,
0.0237274785,
0.0278856605,
-0.0393562205,
0.0028681871,
0.0472717658,
-0.0447137468,
-0.0033219568,
-0.0213539954,
0.0218584761,
0.0581938215,
0.0003008563,
0.023654623,
0.0004241531,
0.0462242737,
-0.0635448173,
-0.0646096021,
0.0108580329,
0.0265205763,
0.0065162089,
0.0391873494,
-0.0050140424,
0.0559303686,
0.0249852855,
0.0005821614,
-0.033483468,
-0.0657688603,
0.0817623064,
0.0180521943,
0.0367441475,
0.004289364,
-0.0209852997,
-0.0094426656,
-0.033649046,
-0.053698495,
-0.0175899379,
0.0143901091,
-0.0038496521,
-0.0313133411,
-0.0045130514,
0.0151433349,
-0.0480153337,
-0.0180450138,
0.0377998874,
0.0063399165,
0.033599589,
0.0056143338,
0.0285049118,
-0.0675787404,
0.0373757072,
0.0337384902,
-0.0039076088,
-0.0148865329,
0.0158161111,
-0.0149089973,
0.060351368,
-0.0302514303,
-0.0304685123,
-0.0573498793,
-0.0288164802,
-0.0259372387,
0.0306647364,
0.0301272701,
0.051724337,
-0.0172539279,
0.0270298682,
0.0213586278,
0.0221259892,
-0.0243141484,
0.0217875447,
0.0303991549,
0.0657646209,
-0.0441536792,
-0.0263169892,
-0.0459498912,
0.0619361401,
0.0287716202,
-0.0781419948,
-0.0031486407,
0.0437638201,
2.821e-7,
0.0665443465,
0.017338641,
0.0262336507,
0.0061123078,
-0.0007578229,
0.0289810468,
0.0366698503,
0.0309728365,
0.0080893291,
-0.0082122721,
0.0235668141,
0.0480658449,
-0.0204063542,
-0.0019006769,
-0.0080854222,
0.0372460485,
-0.0061480142,
-0.0044047209,
-0.0001993716,
-0.0241649915,
0.0830580369,
0.1043609828,
-0.0006551447,
0.0122563588,
0.0276899766,
0.0416977741,
0.0639217794,
0.0376238897,
-0.0120832501,
0.019691525,
0.0081877243,
-0.0394396782,
0.0186089128,
-0.0290644504,
-0.0079652462,
0.0259691104,
-0.0040040724,
0.0383763202,
0.0090778293,
-0.0631688163,
-0.0576984547,
-0.0126997214,
-0.0046501476,
-0.0063769533,
0.0391881093,
-0.1265438795,
-0.0217799805,
0.010329728,
-0.0344210453,
0.0525765084,
0.007992968,
0.0081676506,
-0.0290027522,
-0.005779108,
0.0416909568,
0.0527640507,
-0.0204338338,
-0.0867554098,
0.0105774347,
0.0014062105,
-0.0456440598,
0.0315045156,
-0.0444799289,
0.0032417972,
0.0338492468,
0.0044494257,
-0.0520743839,
2.534546277e-34,
-0.0037106303,
0.0169167556,
-0.0173573811,
0.0116629014,
0.0046365643,
-0.0418592691,
0.0089856526,
0.0080495412,
0.0020287987,
-0.0120043699,
-0.0527141243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00711v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00711v2 | Explaining Text Classifiers with Counterfactual Representations | 2024-02-01T16:06:35 | 2024-04-29T16:04:38 | Pirmin Lemberger, Antoine Saillenfest | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, 62Fxx | One well motivated explanation method for classifiers leverages
counterfactuals which are hypothetical events identical to real observations in
all aspects except for one categorical feature. Constructing such
counterfactual poses specific challenges for texts, however, as some attribute
values may not necessarily align with plausible real-world events. In this
paper we propose a simple method for generating counterfactuals by intervening
in the space of text representations which bypasses this limitation. We argue
that our interventions are minimally disruptive and that they are theoretically
sound as they align with counterfactuals as defined in Pearl's causal inference
framework. To validate our method, we conducted experiments first on a
synthetic dataset and then on a realistic dataset of counterfactuals. This
allows for a direct comparison between classifier predictions based on ground
truth counterfactuals - obtained through explicit text interventions - and our
counterfactuals, derived through interventions in the representation space.
Eventually, we study a real world scenario where our counterfactuals can be
leveraged both for explaining a classifier and for bias mitigation. | [
0.0246691946,
0.0596515872,
-0.0229620691,
0.0080101155,
-0.0452306978,
0.045399949,
0.04553115,
0.0016111238,
0.0175568033,
-0.0487518013,
0.0753780305,
0.0335880481,
-0.0176360421,
0.0301381629,
0.0205058958,
-0.0281206593,
0.0193596836,
-0.0002065863,
0.0252460223,
-0.024615027,
-0.0007828919,
0.0210648552,
-0.0038002825,
0.0276706591,
-0.0074580228,
-0.0164015777,
-0.0156821534,
-0.0021946456,
0.0149532678,
-0.0050849239,
0.0103884591,
-0.0035473718,
0.0097154975,
0.0255316626,
0.0000021265,
-0.0226965006,
-0.0261839163,
0.0307559241,
-0.0494509302,
-0.0143497968,
-0.0106355613,
-0.0330997407,
0.021322839,
-0.0027667743,
-0.0192803517,
0.0508630238,
0.0453946181,
0.0633772761,
-0.0032853882,
0.069419235,
-0.02252662,
-0.0515096262,
-0.0056106467,
0.0145666096,
0.039034646,
-0.0054959883,
0.0100509059,
-0.0183900613,
-0.0372011364,
-0.0009366819,
-0.0124199735,
0.0054566502,
0.0353192911,
0.0103338808,
0.0285979304,
0.0402040966,
0.0193594322,
0.0071819038,
0.018522298,
0.0020271025,
0.0494247749,
-0.0682948306,
0.0193921421,
-0.0403034091,
0.0532609075,
0.0520626232,
-0.006025949,
-0.0198912825,
-0.0125310989,
0.0088490928,
0.0428532474,
0.0493472554,
0.0637407154,
0.0455699079,
-0.0038934425,
0.0433846638,
-0.0054722345,
-0.0020810722,
-0.048755534,
0.0231741257,
0.0041243741,
-0.0289957169,
0.0076781181,
0.003454057,
-0.0211408157,
-0.0036175386,
0.0065934248,
-0.0318413153,
0.0130685093,
-0.1004355401,
0.0140331564,
0.0299663804,
-0.0155714154,
0.0220110752,
-0.0096750343,
0.025115598,
-0.0226955339,
0.0200035851,
-0.0083766049,
-0.0027112218,
-0.0440244749,
-0.0428905897,
0.0020591153,
-0.004177534,
-0.0357042849,
0.0562875047,
0.007441842,
0.0059027649,
-0.0477481075,
0.0102941534,
-0.0313206837,
0.0498299561,
-0.0313941538,
-0.0202718042,
-0.0390937105,
0.0084801875,
-0.0444655158,
0.0302993972,
-0.0228792503,
-0.0252364837,
-0.0028482969,
0.0098498967,
0.0059064762,
-0.0334671997,
0.0046785511,
0.0786533579,
0.0357859321,
0.0216647219,
-0.0258654505,
-0.0540290065,
-0.0275502577,
-0.0483447649,
-0.0236066487,
-0.0247819275,
-0.0463570915,
0.0331570208,
0.0038519842,
-0.0293922257,
-0.0217554402,
-0.0283119064,
-0.033201389,
0.0804623216,
-0.0053461362,
-0.0209713932,
0.0269048698,
-0.0013700925,
-0.0246415362,
0.049538672,
0.0342174694,
0.0008933697,
0.0411330648,
-0.0384234153,
0.023993304,
-0.0348279476,
0.0439458974,
-0.0229090396,
-0.0504306704,
0.0051154695,
-0.0231104847,
-0.0172739215,
0.0023926946,
-0.0504666753,
-0.0103785694,
-0.0220020451,
0.0491958596,
-0.0329127014,
-0.0121774282,
0.0331357345,
0.0185607988,
-0.0096250288,
-0.055174619,
0.0599043258,
-0.0530208759,
0.0263715349,
-0.0822436213,
-0.0046212645,
-0.028323872,
-0.0153328683,
-0.0359294973,
-0.0798197836,
-0.0069155763,
0.0002467172,
0.0196098685,
0.024218427,
0.0552662835,
0.0146629084,
-0.0125051634,
-0.0225648545,
0.0273978449,
-0.0218469389,
0.0139494147,
-0.0361718945,
0.0062108366,
0.0977146551,
0.0371127278,
-0.0807987005,
0.0254935529,
-0.0177635811,
-0.0018094422,
-0.017043652,
0.0513573252,
-0.0185595192,
-0.005258888,
-0.0187994093,
-0.0055518402,
-0.0398929007,
0.0557027012,
0.0080595231,
-0.0039824899,
-0.0190979298,
-0.0035419858,
0.0069026877,
-0.0279935803,
0.0500395373,
0.0097854733,
-0.0288574751,
0.0129846893,
0.0226519648,
-0.0007062571,
0.0294001289,
0.004969683,
-0.0067987102,
0.0207140706,
0.011342084,
-0.0385445394,
0.0332474783,
0.0014186612,
-0.0448537841,
-0.008062169,
-0.0414375365,
-0.0450870767,
0.0422447659,
-0.0372235924,
-0.0099044852,
0.0295119602,
-0.0261787716,
0.0721923709,
-0.022358004,
0.0012704945,
-0.0089104958,
-0.0023982681,
-0.0149993505,
0.0607845522,
0.0093783597,
-0.0112228673,
-0.035985183,
-0.0340935513,
0.0251359828,
-0.0256248545,
0.0411864966,
-0.000889707,
-0.0059404811,
-0.0121645443,
0.0304440409,
-0.0439067967,
-0.0093142977,
0.0126629081,
-0.0258521196,
-0.0275864862,
-0.0366091356,
-0.0209118109,
0.0077009019,
-0.0185500961,
0.0105026746,
-0.0328355655,
-0.016314432,
-0.0292474329,
-0.0041909893,
0.0281414539,
0.0458389744,
-0.0256931987,
0.0096495748,
0.00365154,
0.0039325152,
-0.0546715409,
0.0942267403,
0.0534194559,
-0.0131301805,
-0.0533057638,
-0.0463097133,
-0.0016886326,
-0.0230585691,
-0.0225822087,
-0.0057332818,
-0.0020337205,
0.017465163,
-0.0315953158,
0.0382223837,
0.0020275,
0.0562600829,
0.0395994894,
0.0300484393,
-0.0461140834,
-0.017320158,
-0.0447372757,
0.0371222161,
-0.0335550681,
-0.0611782297,
-0.0447337478,
0.0462986305,
-0.0070480551,
-0.0381005369,
-0.0779963136,
0.0291299075,
0.00755119,
-0.0374882706,
-0.0213122163,
-0.059208829,
0.0069532814,
0.0571842864,
-0.0084037632,
-0.0654038563,
0.0840124786,
0.0083785094,
0.0228901692,
-0.0417832956,
-0.0176226553,
-0.0030619903,
0.0557816811,
-0.0107552931,
-0.0036382393,
0.0476930253,
0.0280193742,
0.0063411631,
-0.0019961027,
0.03958432,
0.0264401305,
-0.0117952647,
-0.0703056976,
0.0075446442,
0.0241999663,
-0.0322505347,
-0.0543487221,
-0.0975491479,
-0.003640689,
-0.0041188067,
-0.0368405953,
-0.0115922093,
-0.0493101478,
0.0074607152,
-0.0009143282,
0.0299390946,
-0.015204615,
-0.0233887769,
0.004077327,
-0.0226004161,
0.003394369,
-0.0081634242,
0.027945077,
-0.0301408712,
0.0152462199,
0.014980481,
-0.0077629006,
-0.0309364554,
-0.0151067087,
0.0180826392,
-0.0335503407,
-0.0220864639,
-0.015576561,
0.0006538044,
0.0022584936,
-0.0387360901,
-0.0034582175,
0.0691557154,
0.0467857271,
-0.0035566702,
0.0433656462,
0.0160137173,
0.0131264618,
0.0012684566,
-0.0325186327,
-0.0517220199,
-0.0106139984,
-0.0009817187,
-0.0012418632,
-0.0420230404,
-0.0090486854,
0.0123350956,
-0.0477758087,
0.0465508103,
0.0100850975,
-0.0064565553,
-0.0321393013,
-0.0416010134,
-0.0478577912,
-0.0471298322,
-0.0614424273,
-0.0269083139,
0.0422931463,
0.0368000828,
0.0057384791,
-0.0124661764,
-0.0240956098,
-0.0166894253,
0.0172106959,
0.0017181352,
0.0458164513,
0.0342704318,
0.0135540403,
0.0255230274,
-0.0207544193,
-0.01340965,
0.0380091183,
0.0016527504,
0.1124841571,
0.0090163685,
0.0008453222,
-0.0283698142,
0.0489528365,
-0.0061678179,
-0.0556522049,
0.0001214005,
0.0530673228,
-0.0327159166,
-0.0190427229,
-0.0115483161,
-0.0083076749,
0.0121596903,
0.0795105323,
0.0075404588,
-0.0355459414,
-0.0441157594,
-0.0542658791,
-0.0031499455,
-0.0134568205,
-0.0108475648,
-0.0349007957,
0.0636144504,
-0.0544017702,
-0.010029085,
-0.0613339096,
-0.031321194,
-0.0050511281,
-0.0121479565,
-0.0119010108,
-0.0573175997,
-0.0087907827,
-0.0493543781,
0.0312942602,
0.0021619594,
0.0339953527,
0.0719733611,
-0.0495044217,
0.0208573937,
-0.0498969518,
-0.0310696755,
-0.0051320605,
-0.0083624432,
-0.0620201118,
0.0212455075,
0.0073124385,
0.0303736161,
0.0789297745,
-0.0099106571,
-0.0745971799,
0.0358023532,
0.0690330416,
-0.0626722872,
0.0098219868,
0.0691176653,
-0.0123728821,
0.0117984563,
0.025492087,
0.0046104402,
0.0090423068,
0.0188252348,
-0.0140162203,
-0.0524575561,
0.0138096679,
0.0238557924,
-0.0327413119,
0.0553741865,
-0.027593093,
-0.0289150719,
-0.0159757305,
0.0290833972,
-0.0472842902,
-0.0311220232,
0.010510982,
-0.0001313528,
0.0236661509,
0.0099357907,
-0.0318785906,
0.0153064616,
-0.0492508113,
0.0039275051,
-0.0222160257,
0.0566281229,
0.0603989325,
0.0541291162,
-0.0014282201,
0.0007881068,
-0.0094521204,
-0.008905435,
0.0367853865,
0.0406696759,
-0.0107731791,
0.0264387578,
0.0297168884,
0.0231734198,
-0.0327336751,
-0.0501956753,
-0.1349329799,
0.0487014577,
-0.0164102316,
0.0411802791,
-0.0123192407,
-0.0385823101,
0.0138780242,
-0.0151309418,
-0.029897131,
0.0193023086,
0.0420133546,
0.0658895746,
-0.0312587693,
-0.0067251101,
0.0044834721,
-0.0532665849,
0.00544221,
0.0388014354,
0.0169769898,
0.0633177757,
-0.0288664997,
-0.0204457082,
-0.0181369577,
-0.0865184739,
0.019050464,
0.05535689,
0.0051388745,
-0.0137620829,
-0.1085461974,
-0.0411799699,
0.0283565186,
-0.0112639843,
0.0386112668,
-0.029566383,
-0.0329118557,
0.0250484049,
-0.0047450964,
-0.0292845275,
-0.0112750093,
0.0408590212,
-0.0024644225,
0.0304033421,
-0.0586523972,
-6.005070197e-33,
-0.0085039102,
-0.08831276,
-0.0107865455,
-0.0270559676,
0.0456157103,
0.0072491607,
-0.0085494919,
-0.0472138412,
-0.0034475569,
0.0504525155,
0.016448468,
0.0450907461,
0.0188655239,
0.0109556857,
-0.0086310636,
-0.0306758676,
0.0421981998,
0.0147760846,
-0.0308101103,
0.028716553,
0.0221361201,
0.0054577659,
0.0420956574,
-0.1182096228,
0.0967542157,
-0.0204655845,
-0.0359214842,
-0.0092989122,
-0.0651525855,
0.0308813695,
-0.0207859743,
0.0457558967,
0.0363643691,
-0.012234197,
0.0146754421,
-0.0086387545,
-0.0334076434,
-0.0237176958,
0.0333342329,
0.0292322319,
0.0301968399,
-0.0505221859,
0.0199558772,
0.0156817045,
-0.0273540802,
-0.0079090213,
0.0669274479,
-0.0320247039,
0.0239117332,
0.0318807811,
-0.085790813,
0.0414818414,
-0.061197184,
0.0127160195,
0.0358669721,
0.0584925637,
0.0475879833,
0.0250227246,
-0.0183967371,
0.0395668,
0.0364210494,
-0.0522600748,
0.0301896688,
0.0062831137,
-0.0093383426,
0.053072542,
0.0483809374,
0.0182793345,
-0.0613252856,
-0.0122751798,
-0.0029287366,
0.0112517085,
0.0970454887,
0.1517470479,
0.0706856325,
-0.0184463393,
-0.085068956,
0.0171603113,
-0.0164397806,
-0.0704414397,
0.0308967009,
-0.0038910692,
-0.0734779462,
-0.0361273624,
-0.0297534131,
-0.0532597192,
-0.018103851,
0.0234552249,
-0.0039963275,
-0.0098929061,
-0.03695843,
0.0640317798,
-0.0098596923,
-0.0614669174,
-0.0033656561,
0.0384028442,
-0.0001875931,
-0.0123972148,
0.0094788941,
-0.0272246208,
-0.0045210258,
0.0030625667,
0.0296519287,
0.0349339359,
0.0535200723,
0.0133522851,
0.0831175297,
0.0113492403,
-0.0332527757,
-0.0001695548,
-0.021899363,
-0.0232233033,
-0.0015511365,
-0.0193181559,
0.032311596,
0.0384644642,
-0.0092139784,
0.0222253483,
0.017931683,
0.0314805582,
-0.0101239989,
0.0008780621,
-0.0448585227,
0.0114423651,
0.0022795477,
-0.024387151,
0.0302547123,
-0.025786534,
0.0284944661,
-0.0560071878,
-0.0241407286,
-0.023071073,
2.596e-7,
0.0596667491,
0.0215754937,
0.0516456366,
-0.0137281669,
0.03533132,
0.0674663708,
-0.0011730196,
0.0064378628,
0.0062559978,
0.0050727804,
0.0597917773,
0.0166556407,
0.0334460549,
0.0154562648,
-0.0061968844,
0.0337916166,
-0.0493476465,
-0.0365203321,
-0.0358774662,
0.0339408778,
0.093929179,
0.0435972773,
0.0574124046,
-0.0011088782,
0.0160164665,
0.0159411319,
0.0467951186,
-0.0491499864,
0.0295748338,
-0.0147798713,
-0.0216882788,
-0.0153770642,
-0.0149265062,
0.0611493774,
-0.0300147682,
-0.0022730788,
-0.0509781018,
0.0235938281,
-0.0475891642,
-0.0166552067,
-0.0554357842,
-0.0419897363,
0.0089813555,
-0.0504502766,
0.0672044307,
0.0140249394,
-0.0295124184,
-0.0035459073,
-0.03350861,
0.0159438588,
0.0096187629,
0.026417993,
-0.0235225204,
0.0137672834,
-0.0189098697,
0.0114991423,
0.0015404741,
-0.072936967,
-0.0529067442,
0.0067302356,
-0.0159453079,
-0.0164689422,
-0.0092066862,
0.0464508422,
0.0756079108,
-0.0754186362,
0.0278380159,
2.467952456e-34,
0.0414322689,
0.0559896119,
-0.027041534,
-0.0129190702,
0.0488135964,
0.0085558938,
0.035394799,
0.0207446404,
0.0840807706,
-0.0247692447,
-0.0038358674
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.