id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03620v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03620v1 | Self-Discover: Large Language Models Self-Compose Reasoning Structures | 2024-02-06T01:13:53 | 2024-02-06T01:13:53 | Pei Zhou, Jay Pujara, Xiang Ren, Xinyun Chen, Heng-Tze Cheng, Quoc V. Le, Ed H. Chi, Denny Zhou, Swaroop Mishra, Huaixiu Steven Zheng | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce SELF-DISCOVER, a general framework for LLMs to self-discover the
task-intrinsic reasoning structures to tackle complex reasoning problems that
are challenging for typical prompting methods. Core to the framework is a
self-discovery process where LLMs select multiple atomic reasoning modules such
as critical thinking and step-by-step thinking, and compose them into an
explicit reasoning structure for LLMs to follow during decoding. SELF-DISCOVER
substantially improves GPT-4 and PaLM 2's performance on challenging reasoning
benchmarks such as BigBench-Hard, grounded agent reasoning, and MATH, by as
much as 32% compared to Chain of Thought (CoT). Furthermore, SELF-DISCOVER
outperforms inference-intensive methods such as CoT-Self-Consistency by more
than 20%, while requiring 10-40x fewer inference compute. Finally, we show that
the self-discovered reasoning structures are universally applicable across
model families: from PaLM 2-L to GPT-4, and from GPT-4 to Llama2, and share
commonalities with human reasoning patterns. | [
0.0044992836,
-0.0028212576,
-0.012064782,
0.0400977731,
-0.0543440282,
0.0305538028,
-0.021780625,
-0.0229699947,
0.0295169856,
-0.0037455591,
-0.0272948891,
0.0355288908,
-0.0244433042,
0.0158010703,
0.0054586036,
0.0179831665,
0.0438673086,
-0.0558157973,
0.0242170189,
-0.0278324895,
-0.0334833525,
0.0045803832,
-0.0247265734,
0.0007552818,
0.0162572451,
-0.036237821,
-0.0442796759,
-0.0097666681,
0.005282376,
-0.047048457,
-0.0425754078,
0.0243277308,
0.0225330349,
0.0289114174,
0.0000020258,
-0.0547394119,
-0.0222283732,
-0.0113585852,
-0.077012971,
-0.0268465988,
-0.0336740874,
0.0099423165,
0.0011442846,
0.0281996913,
-0.0497354269,
0.0130375819,
0.0170539171,
0.0531768724,
0.0645302609,
0.0414915346,
0.0170147009,
-0.0335547328,
-0.0092044175,
0.005161189,
0.0048099416,
-0.031367708,
0.0032252627,
0.0334988534,
0.0373992771,
0.0282534361,
-0.0134203881,
0.0183375888,
0.0654266626,
0.0015545654,
-0.0267894194,
0.0435835868,
-0.026384199,
-0.0344485193,
-0.0103127444,
0.056027595,
0.0584052615,
-0.0252250452,
-0.0281424839,
0.021985257,
0.0075086346,
-0.0145515082,
-0.031952776,
0.056061022,
-0.0281560142,
0.0366167836,
0.0771563947,
0.0069850017,
0.0325343721,
-0.0067237811,
-0.0620401353,
0.1273079365,
-0.0082515385,
-0.0280250311,
0.035135787,
0.0097705601,
0.0264176484,
-0.0441886596,
0.0009954171,
0.0704153106,
-0.0254512224,
0.0141404225,
0.0081704948,
0.0523653589,
-0.0095751248,
0.0046229558,
0.0378771722,
0.0753556788,
-0.0063199284,
0.0575268008,
-0.0478572361,
0.0333498828,
-0.0332755148,
0.0462902859,
-0.0518849194,
-0.0021518937,
-0.0440475605,
-0.010550186,
-0.0260927416,
0.0680627674,
-0.020622246,
-0.0137164639,
-0.0192463081,
0.0434152111,
0.0134714497,
0.0196333751,
0.0318542421,
-0.0122202309,
0.0161138959,
-0.0374901481,
-0.0511199385,
0.0179852545,
-0.0525184497,
0.0141984979,
0.0368003398,
-0.0557553843,
-0.0275529008,
-0.0155068189,
-0.0313183106,
-0.0236120131,
0.0193319842,
0.0691453815,
-0.0283519626,
-0.0164375696,
-0.0543701872,
-0.0200346708,
0.0113473581,
-0.1054413095,
0.0384481288,
-0.0413941927,
0.0215719603,
0.0037017348,
-0.0030221355,
-0.0127386283,
0.0118943276,
-0.0149925975,
-0.0049065012,
0.088410683,
0.0112195797,
0.0028866958,
0.0233175438,
0.0139769502,
-0.0248886645,
0.0685082823,
0.0274742506,
0.0122542856,
-0.008545354,
0.0102591375,
0.0000885626,
0.0123865167,
0.007644258,
-0.0251878835,
0.0032568986,
0.034382116,
-0.0348850228,
0.0335189104,
-0.0113782575,
0.0329804868,
-0.0254247729,
0.0037217517,
0.046775829,
0.0771826878,
0.008476452,
-0.0013865859,
0.0313769318,
-0.0214447584,
0.0176561475,
0.0110563831,
-0.0689062625,
0.0701128915,
-0.0467864238,
-0.0001058908,
-0.0024711243,
0.0133215692,
-0.0460819565,
-0.0391749628,
-0.0113457683,
0.0321755558,
0.015140227,
0.0247951746,
0.0414547846,
-0.0026381938,
-0.0246009547,
0.0268564261,
-0.0260472186,
-0.0256063715,
-0.0394482985,
-0.0743492395,
0.0737072974,
0.0484244078,
0.0503072776,
0.0111259501,
-0.047397092,
0.0169890579,
0.0066685006,
0.0380280353,
0.0009250393,
-0.0133760562,
-0.0203853585,
-0.0585022494,
-0.0229228437,
-0.0110581676,
0.0039773574,
0.0040375441,
0.0014885392,
-0.0164195374,
-0.0173801761,
-0.0305802617,
0.0317083001,
0.021121772,
-0.0146034053,
-0.0338147432,
-0.0081544397,
0.0196179058,
0.0294738691,
0.019119516,
0.0391030833,
0.0249113515,
0.0377663299,
-0.0184470061,
-0.0462902747,
0.028013248,
-0.0724849775,
-0.0619571432,
0.0377999879,
-0.0241676401,
-0.0315906815,
-0.0054163155,
-0.019087851,
-0.0728312433,
0.0359514691,
-0.0271501653,
-0.0051404471,
-0.0480986089,
0.0304277707,
0.0244458765,
-0.0174812246,
-0.0098029105,
0.090009518,
-0.0222867262,
-0.0476507656,
0.0116708642,
0.0458992943,
0.0006359069,
-0.0497653969,
0.0084281256,
0.0343461856,
0.0043241344,
0.000032067,
-0.0244878065,
0.0177392121,
-0.0597475655,
-0.0336739197,
-0.0423617475,
0.0024042714,
-0.0033588789,
0.0359815843,
-0.001597942,
-0.0103916265,
0.0023901898,
-0.0039630556,
-0.0347650871,
0.0207621679,
0.0169977155,
0.0187387615,
0.0199528411,
-0.0112321535,
-0.0072397692,
0.0061249542,
-0.0203110892,
-0.0349083729,
0.0106201665,
-0.008826171,
0.0201163348,
-0.058389008,
0.0153506147,
-0.0188520681,
0.0038526182,
-0.0149340667,
-0.0262025893,
0.0751943141,
-0.0386698693,
0.0275576785,
0.0949456915,
-0.0407579914,
0.0325468555,
0.0592314415,
-0.0349864401,
-0.0346272029,
0.0486036763,
-0.015949836,
-0.0159424413,
-0.0174352136,
-0.0001417097,
-0.019656213,
0.0818923712,
0.0019624881,
0.0056931865,
-0.0786015317,
0.0022083963,
0.0249160584,
-0.020883346,
0.0001408712,
-0.0098917624,
-0.0061303428,
0.0538140163,
-0.0003101073,
-0.0222758017,
0.0852720886,
-0.0231181365,
0.0020663808,
-0.0507806689,
0.0131213106,
-0.0410188735,
0.0899930894,
-0.043299932,
-0.0137292463,
0.0226678345,
-0.0147848437,
-0.0358213969,
-0.013970159,
0.0370821767,
-0.0155386766,
0.0418752059,
-0.0497318469,
0.010530428,
-0.0094385389,
-0.0687244013,
-0.0510291159,
0.0596038699,
-0.0869837478,
0.0067531937,
-0.0347652324,
-0.0159393344,
0.0012626755,
-0.0164114833,
0.0133379549,
0.0194555689,
-0.0186372325,
-0.0131637445,
-0.0460819378,
0.0011163785,
0.0127427988,
0.0336882994,
0.068572931,
-0.0333277062,
0.0949174389,
0.0591816939,
0.0375640765,
-0.0262712389,
-0.0279407781,
0.0510501266,
0.0215033405,
0.0078788996,
0.0041111982,
0.02578656,
0.049789127,
-0.0763736218,
-0.0185422488,
0.1236510351,
0.0328471027,
-0.0281512048,
-0.0057951906,
-0.073270686,
0.0054080882,
0.0396013223,
0.0300410558,
-0.0407135151,
-0.06962955,
0.0537723973,
-0.0075708358,
-0.0097884014,
-0.0587137453,
-0.0158119965,
-0.0818708614,
0.0554682091,
0.0115707954,
0.008686671,
0.003275787,
-0.0144308703,
-0.0130944941,
0.0035108568,
-0.0345095918,
0.0545180179,
0.0319158807,
0.0113722542,
-0.0125903236,
0.006163938,
-0.0045957896,
0.0541409999,
-0.0084977839,
0.0394841023,
0.0313847624,
0.0137337958,
0.013719907,
-0.0686235055,
0.0582416169,
-0.0158346724,
0.0208614636,
-0.0468698144,
-0.016958151,
-0.0009404891,
0.0034463506,
-0.0300403498,
0.0722953081,
-0.0579613671,
-0.0008033312,
0.0173031706,
0.1201824471,
-0.0617255494,
-0.0349782109,
-0.0083095813,
0.0051644519,
-0.043460995,
0.0800746456,
0.0198315401,
-0.0047727861,
-0.0451808386,
-0.0445915386,
-0.0294970404,
-0.0208273698,
-0.0025560518,
0.0336982608,
0.0419507809,
0.0196896512,
-0.0519840494,
-0.0513045117,
0.0442781635,
0.0406980999,
-0.0046650157,
0.0004854705,
0.0114288116,
-0.0013661727,
-0.046634905,
-0.0062020305,
-0.0578737855,
-0.0104156993,
-0.0290645063,
0.0433314592,
0.0316357426,
-0.0605992302,
0.0015858833,
0.0221778844,
-0.0687335208,
-0.0516804866,
-0.0281138644,
0.0391634665,
0.0300839338,
0.0297716167,
-0.0162370112,
-0.0200215988,
0.008247816,
-0.0124624185,
-0.0382393934,
0.0136608202,
0.0251123458,
-0.0008204777,
0.0162571482,
0.0612760037,
-0.0104464181,
0.0263923965,
-0.0084873643,
0.0698010921,
-0.0255304519,
-0.0128324907,
0.0571249165,
0.0343738124,
-0.006519815,
0.0079045463,
0.0271601416,
-0.0285413545,
0.0416992642,
-0.0201485921,
-0.0108764423,
-0.0601743162,
0.0250369105,
0.008398423,
-0.0092715155,
0.030814141,
-0.0436469764,
0.0196200535,
0.0224757586,
0.0481770746,
-0.0025915513,
0.0052681444,
0.05511811,
0.0052123396,
-0.0253521949,
-0.0177632105,
0.0215608142,
-0.0129788313,
0.0433651544,
-0.0037814996,
0.1054056287,
0.0484575443,
-0.0077909091,
-0.0336614586,
0.018847188,
-0.0605992228,
-0.0758871511,
0.0538542941,
0.0092821978,
0.0260595959,
0.0436323658,
0.0034325193,
-0.0600749031,
-0.0032442147,
0.0189828519,
0.0220184028,
0.0217544921,
-0.0109193753,
0.0405340008,
0.0388840586,
0.0026746572,
-0.0430976227,
0.0079137264,
-0.026883442,
0.0426179208,
0.004434919,
0.0058116461,
-0.0488911867,
-0.0452217758,
-0.0688474923,
0.0042392788,
-0.0050208531,
0.0129498085,
-0.0649620742,
-0.0625316128,
-0.0086630341,
0.0406758077,
-0.0280444548,
-0.0293714181,
0.040861167,
0.0619538948,
0.0081981085,
-0.0456808768,
0.0242303517,
-0.0160474088,
-0.0297854133,
0.0014836722,
-0.0021593547,
-6.288738289e-33,
-0.0198574048,
-0.0275630374,
0.0869325995,
-0.014366731,
0.0008783947,
-0.0189180262,
-0.0507140085,
0.0035095611,
-0.0288968384,
0.0188682415,
-0.0301770475,
0.0264672469,
0.0070847864,
0.0079882564,
0.0083447797,
-0.013005143,
0.0122225387,
-0.0199188441,
-0.044670783,
-0.0074735712,
0.0266151242,
0.0012559092,
0.0285338927,
-0.0214536227,
-0.0156617016,
0.0030422797,
-0.0215463955,
0.0621887408,
-0.0809863731,
0.0430333652,
-0.0422465019,
-0.0197337586,
0.022382861,
-0.0199837852,
-0.0018869984,
-0.0057891323,
-0.0963261947,
-0.0508888364,
0.0414253809,
-0.0230309237,
-0.0740947202,
-0.0418048203,
-0.0145486267,
0.0117495107,
-0.0197621305,
-0.0463219732,
-0.0232839193,
-0.0340824276,
0.0276581384,
0.0347880311,
-0.0072639105,
-0.0022352396,
-0.0050554443,
-0.0190117266,
0.0328709185,
-0.0024497013,
-0.0417506956,
0.0221983697,
-0.0312646404,
0.0210178029,
-0.0076617068,
-0.0233195368,
0.094782494,
-0.0032227987,
-0.0041688783,
0.0354275554,
0.0211801939,
-0.0233007222,
-0.0635190383,
-0.0059891604,
-0.0227840431,
0.0812836215,
0.0339636691,
0.0317137912,
0.0014660122,
0.0335158743,
-0.0675472468,
0.0097479969,
0.0456986837,
0.04237964,
0.0325048678,
0.0066861957,
-0.0469785109,
-0.0136266099,
-0.0366623551,
0.0206151772,
-0.0497579947,
-0.0243340619,
0.0363120437,
-0.0059092706,
-0.0102309287,
-0.0460716188,
0.0240204036,
-0.0223667882,
0.0386448652,
0.0011023033,
-0.0141092166,
0.006512776,
0.0001877823,
0.0421715602,
-0.0264378991,
-0.0106278853,
-0.0049372967,
0.0043579005,
-0.0039892104,
0.0174488798,
0.0017581927,
0.0316949561,
-0.0138280094,
-0.0169225801,
-0.0634987876,
0.0022298347,
-0.0097809117,
-0.0034983326,
0.0298737641,
0.0196828246,
-0.0118045118,
0.0175541136,
-0.030198887,
-0.0081161195,
-0.0401459411,
0.0485909246,
0.0141941188,
0.0323276296,
0.0130641237,
0.0023741005,
-0.0417939201,
0.0168815069,
0.0145715997,
-0.0690600723,
0.0031509709,
0.0763691664,
2.809e-7,
-0.0125647923,
0.0209879614,
0.0276233405,
-0.0036469961,
0.0361952484,
0.0591368414,
-0.0224624854,
-0.0162322018,
0.0092453463,
-0.0542515405,
0.0048163659,
0.0880955011,
0.0451426245,
0.0332171507,
-0.0613899939,
0.0101525579,
0.001638589,
-0.0208233893,
-0.0239728261,
-0.0163017027,
0.0548384227,
0.0483764894,
0.0165998321,
-0.0303037073,
0.0305912048,
-0.0162289422,
0.0518645607,
-0.0064460058,
0.0202787519,
-0.0022278777,
-0.0275682956,
0.0120400162,
-0.0142780747,
0.0289708935,
0.0280264821,
0.0085639879,
-0.0199871585,
0.0524926409,
0.0214734674,
-0.0427233689,
-0.0186157711,
-0.0262369458,
0.0064314748,
-0.0428643525,
0.084145382,
-0.0589356944,
-0.0757803991,
0.0207327474,
0.0180714559,
-0.0324226506,
-0.0476087369,
0.0014731169,
0.0096051907,
0.0130000245,
-0.0097519197,
-0.0134623153,
0.0060773995,
-0.0855217576,
0.0045341575,
-0.028372759,
-0.0422669612,
-0.0391127691,
-0.053673584,
0.0106312064,
0.0425769538,
-0.0508800931,
-0.0258429367,
2.662225627e-34,
0.0094866492,
-0.0235623736,
0.0450891778,
0.0438805521,
0.0109458528,
-0.013372506,
-0.0195573252,
0.007175127,
0.0359214917,
-0.0875718966,
-0.0392554514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03618v1 | Comparing Abstraction in Humans and Large Language Models Using Multimodal Serial Reproduction | 2024-02-06T01:07:56 | 2024-02-06T01:07:56 | Sreejan Kumar, Raja Marjieh, Byron Zhang, Declan Campbell, Michael Y. Hu, Umang Bhatt, Brenden Lake, Thomas L. Griffiths | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Humans extract useful abstractions of the world from noisy sensory data.
Serial reproduction allows us to study how people construe the world through a
paradigm similar to the game of telephone, where one person observes a stimulus
and reproduces it for the next to form a chain of reproductions. Past serial
reproduction experiments typically employ a single sensory modality, but humans
often communicate abstractions of the world to each other through language. To
investigate the effect language on the formation of abstractions, we implement
a novel multimodal serial reproduction framework by asking people who receive a
visual stimulus to reproduce it in a linguistic format, and vice versa. We ran
unimodal and multimodal chains with both humans and GPT-4 and find that adding
language as a modality has a larger effect on human reproductions than GPT-4's.
This suggests human visual and linguistic representations are more dissociable
than those of GPT-4. | [
0.0179957785,
0.0815455839,
-0.0652047768,
0.0120464796,
-0.0535887927,
-0.0044196243,
0.0296208095,
0.0144055113,
-0.0176012162,
-0.0315467566,
-0.0355512425,
-0.055924356,
0.0250615273,
0.0564624108,
0.0593989789,
-0.0629504099,
-0.0169722401,
-0.0215052683,
-0.0194995981,
-0.011301023,
-0.04866229,
-0.0068203541,
0.0095865177,
0.0048857052,
0.0161747634,
0.0074987784,
-0.0439496413,
-0.0332949348,
-0.00082878,
-0.0479553863,
-0.0455247425,
0.0149977878,
0.0883573219,
0.0038936713,
0.0000018355,
-0.0477983616,
0.0821357518,
-0.0189411268,
0.0375747234,
0.0129504008,
0.0381003208,
-0.0136364652,
0.0376409441,
-0.0396964997,
0.0014225314,
0.0030744919,
0.0582506657,
0.0295851715,
0.0262717456,
-0.0363505855,
-0.0005993883,
-0.0285851452,
0.0246902127,
0.0084912051,
0.0158925112,
0.056959372,
-0.0031724302,
0.0280745905,
0.0430437066,
0.0363648124,
-0.0525415428,
0.0109450547,
0.0607471205,
0.0542299971,
-0.0199286398,
0.0522545204,
0.052267231,
-0.0619257241,
0.0131573062,
0.049627997,
0.0442302562,
-0.0328513272,
0.0013471735,
0.0473039523,
-0.0045035724,
-0.0207513459,
-0.0401748233,
0.0491462089,
0.0053844918,
0.036852356,
-0.0440800637,
-0.032654956,
-0.0057597072,
-0.0281692334,
0.0339983478,
-0.0132462177,
0.0123578124,
0.0159674026,
0.0212009754,
-0.0068625505,
-0.0276682824,
-0.0367793031,
-0.0138049433,
-0.0272848941,
-0.0059868367,
-0.0155037614,
-0.0119783292,
-0.0330521204,
0.0033449586,
0.0061808992,
0.0547152348,
0.0326611549,
-0.0342100561,
-0.0152384583,
0.002640303,
0.0190424062,
-0.0535721928,
-0.0012983019,
-0.0293199196,
0.036573533,
-0.0589332357,
-0.0333774239,
-0.0054001026,
0.0225780495,
-0.0489810705,
-0.0250134617,
-0.0120909056,
0.0152549669,
-0.0088357506,
-0.0414533913,
-0.1132979989,
-0.0139933405,
0.0080807963,
-0.0047821794,
-0.0317790732,
-0.0185875557,
-0.0521307215,
0.0148167936,
-0.0026388306,
-0.049359832,
-0.0081432723,
-0.0084054219,
0.0058283689,
0.0209446382,
-0.0652637407,
0.0640657097,
-0.0034827325,
-0.012383854,
0.0222381167,
-0.0189044848,
0.0592918769,
-0.0328732133,
0.0325790234,
-0.010171595,
0.0236719251,
0.0089019658,
-0.0078381514,
-0.0242681634,
0.0213878769,
-0.0490333289,
0.0102146585,
0.070240438,
-0.017001396,
0.0209742505,
0.0275486745,
0.0204057619,
0.0174704455,
0.0313759595,
0.0076545812,
-0.0062100296,
-0.0282791145,
-0.0150339678,
0.0480474383,
0.0098166429,
-0.0119887246,
0.0282729119,
-0.0100913122,
-0.0343523026,
-0.0363774747,
0.0444283225,
0.0821195543,
0.0366811939,
-0.0484940372,
-0.0127140703,
0.0632452667,
0.0476061031,
-0.0472625345,
0.0309749171,
0.0740634874,
0.0283281263,
-0.0227502007,
0.0353689156,
-0.0317537114,
0.0195705127,
0.0322000496,
0.0141436607,
0.0353617221,
-0.0294907168,
-0.0445658974,
0.0047426573,
-0.0225747135,
0.0134324897,
0.0292672571,
-0.0105314488,
0.0233261678,
0.0057768901,
-0.0022525752,
0.0007478927,
0.0307257473,
-0.0183639526,
-0.0011307257,
-0.0404447876,
0.0389193594,
0.0146811642,
-0.0398236662,
0.0305610579,
0.0487096831,
-0.0063372091,
0.0242016651,
0.0741763785,
0.028525902,
0.0270385332,
0.023200633,
0.020977987,
-0.0284684841,
-0.0041506244,
0.0032355557,
0.0098996116,
-0.0452974215,
-0.0090938779,
-0.0074070371,
0.0038772,
0.0305127334,
0.0342828855,
0.0059476001,
-0.0103535699,
-0.064082332,
-0.0209464952,
0.0174739398,
-0.0425533503,
-0.0245904736,
0.0383217633,
0.003771462,
-0.0192143135,
0.0001610478,
0.0696298331,
-0.0339221172,
0.0113364356,
-0.0065184324,
-0.0725912005,
-0.036658857,
0.0318498164,
0.0354870595,
0.024267327,
0.0784724951,
-0.0771747082,
0.0918813869,
-0.0220416188,
-0.0028008353,
-0.0005099966,
0.013780931,
0.0318112597,
0.0484618619,
-0.012890785,
-0.0034759406,
-0.0326463282,
-0.008322442,
0.0120342532,
-0.0225050393,
0.0095317503,
-0.0104912715,
-0.005092869,
0.0145045789,
-0.0088703642,
-0.0110602612,
-0.122392565,
0.0063932426,
-0.0758222565,
-0.044564452,
0.0326196179,
0.0103928624,
0.028001897,
-0.0418768786,
-0.0032297981,
0.0005192287,
-0.0166639742,
0.0510546081,
-0.0147698391,
0.0523210987,
-0.0228770822,
-0.0394547991,
-0.0387261249,
-0.0086670313,
0.0100020887,
-0.0248551704,
0.0262664948,
-0.0049374518,
0.0034271709,
-0.0407085009,
-0.0419320054,
-0.0382368118,
-0.0000921474,
-0.0114628756,
-0.0097707808,
0.0548524968,
0.0088153975,
0.0560162999,
0.0191359054,
-0.008688082,
0.0832826868,
0.0535409003,
-0.0184837673,
-0.0211882778,
-0.0282721575,
-0.0107485307,
-0.0212398395,
0.012188741,
-0.0453478619,
-0.0087648714,
0.0765309334,
0.0199004766,
0.0145151,
-0.0328783356,
0.0422766432,
-0.0026633702,
-0.0728665665,
-0.0293480288,
-0.0703961179,
-0.0314457454,
0.0471144058,
-0.0440148674,
-0.0270885136,
0.0381852426,
0.0513625257,
-0.0206554625,
0.000769156,
0.0366888382,
0.0533004701,
0.0869388357,
0.0447426178,
0.0093517983,
0.037237756,
-0.0278818738,
-0.0672182217,
0.0149189867,
-0.0053906241,
-0.0063136043,
0.0080300281,
-0.1007902995,
-0.0185309928,
-0.001727722,
-0.0447685532,
-0.0213117562,
0.0241411198,
-0.0297348332,
0.0108075449,
-0.028355103,
0.0468897112,
-0.0439164415,
-0.0112488074,
0.0772936344,
-0.0301442873,
0.0297263619,
-0.0225002561,
-0.0020937631,
0.0065895258,
0.0494477786,
0.0298609622,
-0.0011319484,
-0.0949489176,
0.0061519449,
0.0275864769,
-0.0183472652,
0.0606739447,
-0.0338133499,
0.0653753728,
0.0200530011,
0.0241462402,
-0.0363086276,
0.0312388167,
0.0532761775,
-0.0420896858,
-0.0124856886,
0.0107073085,
0.0144493412,
-0.043188829,
0.0502051488,
-0.022134386,
0.0131282592,
0.028832823,
0.0221483111,
-0.0565824807,
0.0063838931,
0.0167586803,
-0.0614328869,
0.0129606277,
-0.0205150135,
0.0111869453,
-0.0703127086,
0.0210758988,
0.0104940832,
-0.103668645,
-0.0408166349,
-0.0143946232,
0.0376709998,
0.0767559335,
-0.0167593844,
0.0274289679,
-0.0097600156,
-0.0026170011,
-0.0188725293,
0.0433147885,
0.0042877304,
-0.0271072593,
-0.0106257526,
0.0318480283,
-0.0135185253,
0.0200447123,
-0.0266571678,
-0.0563264713,
0.0706820339,
-0.0121908439,
-0.0059158038,
0.0077987523,
-0.0001124826,
0.0562782772,
0.0124634542,
-0.0538691469,
0.0211559795,
0.0141650951,
-0.052568417,
0.002496477,
0.0189147033,
-0.0087507097,
-0.0504392572,
-0.011281128,
0.026956249,
-0.0268640276,
0.0011981721,
0.0615552478,
-0.0857134014,
-0.0149298962,
-0.0098166298,
0.0305620357,
0.0221379846,
-0.0422570817,
-0.0043023159,
-0.0003958262,
-0.0277456213,
-0.0839709863,
-0.0258798711,
-0.0232961979,
0.0123492954,
0.0486543141,
-0.0332720615,
0.0132204508,
-0.0418084413,
-0.0232538879,
0.0200396031,
0.0183005966,
-0.039295692,
-0.0023777308,
-0.0235776175,
-0.0383010246,
-0.0822404623,
0.0122700287,
0.0314090587,
-0.0064761881,
-0.0671360865,
0.0131485313,
0.0040733176,
0.0248335619,
0.0269067064,
0.0486359634,
-0.0339532457,
0.0265175346,
0.0190151781,
0.0435402282,
0.0532417819,
-0.0581668876,
0.052773308,
0.0130732385,
0.0185657497,
-0.0025945839,
0.0053414865,
0.0017163751,
0.0069473227,
-0.0083000772,
0.0660174266,
0.0089807417,
0.0058935345,
0.0320436694,
-0.0488460623,
0.030241346,
-0.0100347633,
-0.0634297878,
-0.0067367223,
0.0092305066,
-0.0130443163,
-0.0076665771,
0.0097677615,
0.0439384766,
0.0123332068,
-0.0520531945,
0.0541584305,
0.0256643835,
0.0530924648,
-0.0392778255,
-0.0212459471,
-0.0097871898,
-0.0275969412,
0.0580885224,
-0.0034955298,
0.0093310168,
-0.0349796601,
0.0319732688,
0.0072333813,
0.0589837283,
0.0263721067,
-0.0164626073,
-0.0039444813,
0.0161365252,
0.0106968191,
-0.0418866873,
0.0324065872,
-0.0442937016,
0.0129008591,
-0.0129994852,
0.0340610705,
-0.0679322258,
0.0053117326,
-0.0060562762,
0.0278917588,
-0.0231744032,
-0.0121118492,
-0.0231631547,
0.0368174501,
-0.0086817574,
-0.0319016129,
0.0135727348,
-0.0377554782,
-0.0094261384,
-0.0123098567,
-0.0126776574,
-0.0241107848,
0.0449847281,
0.0164396018,
0.0329698175,
0.0029894749,
0.0389241166,
-0.020621011,
-0.0593294613,
-0.0365958661,
0.037922468,
0.0108713396,
0.0103255343,
0.0723958686,
0.0000956131,
0.006954886,
-0.0647458211,
-0.0167961475,
0.0004055404,
0.0576158613,
0.0029366615,
0.0048758634,
-5.833493204e-33,
-0.023820037,
-0.0111638354,
0.0101454165,
0.0245225914,
-0.0735007748,
-0.0183459409,
-0.0621932372,
0.0701358393,
0.0185655691,
0.0229060613,
0.0496195368,
-0.0323962569,
0.0010996956,
-0.0113186548,
0.0635994077,
0.0395727567,
-0.0052537918,
-0.0247376021,
-0.0214149449,
-0.0295636393,
0.0291405413,
0.0013333748,
0.0499638058,
-0.0605067164,
0.0070285322,
0.0142448479,
0.0078172879,
-0.0112180589,
-0.0294764545,
0.0033798353,
-0.0607148036,
0.0451562963,
0.0406199135,
0.0254068617,
-0.0028540418,
0.0499002188,
-0.0068221558,
-0.0629267991,
0.0364161581,
-0.0219633039,
-0.1136791706,
0.0094571877,
0.0601306781,
-0.031452287,
-0.0185298622,
-0.0014893751,
0.0333348326,
0.0025927909,
0.0115536889,
0.0550685599,
-0.0770253912,
-0.0516676717,
-0.0128225917,
-0.0034928797,
0.0432932526,
-0.0015247407,
-0.0612497404,
0.0089944927,
-0.0396262594,
0.0528338514,
-0.0176799111,
-0.0190685783,
0.0115888938,
0.0194931868,
0.0854374841,
0.0357996821,
0.0719084218,
-0.0025896304,
-0.0354656056,
-0.0068422435,
0.0567201227,
0.0236912481,
-0.0077797049,
0.0171177275,
0.0423104838,
-0.0227507669,
0.019811349,
-0.0272389352,
-0.0422288999,
0.020245051,
0.035191413,
0.0015785035,
0.0457033291,
0.0165386572,
-0.0160461962,
-0.0196814314,
-0.0308868866,
-0.0347486325,
0.0092488574,
-0.030992154,
0.0402164608,
-0.0467862785,
0.0371278338,
-0.0227097347,
-0.0437152311,
-0.1189766154,
-0.0230116472,
0.0245595872,
0.0246124696,
-0.0298362579,
-0.004347058,
-0.0289018936,
-0.014450823,
0.029342493,
0.0358136147,
-0.0155224027,
-0.0160901025,
-0.021338148,
-0.0361308344,
-0.0102690486,
-0.042035941,
-0.0207542181,
0.0656784847,
-0.0425102264,
0.0252418965,
0.0068553351,
-0.0373160057,
-0.0866810679,
0.0257039722,
-0.0177438185,
-0.0365864076,
0.0706231594,
-0.0797504187,
0.0341592282,
-0.0135679776,
0.0077168476,
-0.070442982,
0.0601783618,
0.0834299624,
-0.0310846455,
-0.0397009961,
0.0184878465,
2.802e-7,
-0.0123658925,
0.0533603467,
-0.0278818533,
0.006634837,
0.0703498051,
0.0167493764,
0.0109571526,
0.0318930298,
0.0202888045,
-0.0515885875,
-0.0045235641,
0.0142422635,
0.0459570996,
-0.003863656,
-0.0603773482,
0.0317909531,
-0.0035658225,
0.0281397831,
-0.0145393545,
0.0482257269,
0.0570509955,
-0.0160231479,
0.0142597491,
-0.0014054429,
0.009991304,
0.0359739847,
0.0571051873,
-0.0595048368,
0.017124366,
-0.0313062109,
-0.0653190464,
0.0055474928,
0.0121316751,
0.0334489793,
0.0211265441,
-0.0598353706,
0.0212485492,
-0.0396011211,
-0.0335927606,
-0.0055647986,
0.0273710098,
0.0493339151,
-0.0076383487,
-0.0212269612,
0.0220606998,
-0.0500944927,
-0.0262482986,
0.0668897852,
-0.01899774,
-0.0386487246,
0.0083342446,
-0.0245831087,
-0.0534106344,
0.0255240835,
-0.0139965797,
0.0088805063,
0.0011719512,
-0.0254909974,
0.0119520482,
0.0364012606,
-0.0532201044,
-0.0357333981,
-0.0140748564,
-0.0045090462,
-0.0038901754,
-0.0408106148,
-0.0396340825,
1.709039068e-34,
0.0048573385,
-0.009437901,
0.0795898288,
0.005192942,
0.0077640424,
-0.0122709889,
-0.0118130548,
0.0190351587,
0.0309660472,
-0.0121254362,
-0.0043583848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03616v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03616v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Hybrid Workplace Decision Support | 2024-02-06T01:05:14 | 2024-02-06T01:05:14 | Yujin Kim, Chin-Chia Hsu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.IR | Large Language Models (LLMs) hold the potential to perform a variety of text
processing tasks and provide textual explanations for proposed actions or
decisions. In the era of hybrid work, LLMs can provide intelligent decision
support for workers who are designing their hybrid work plans. In particular,
they can offer suggestions and explanations to workers balancing numerous
decision factors, thereby enhancing their work experience. In this paper, we
present a decision support model for workspaces in hybrid work environments,
leveraging the reasoning skill of LLMs. We first examine LLM's capability of
making suitable workspace suggestions. We find that its reasoning extends
beyond the guidelines in the prompt and the LLM can manage the trade-off among
the available resources in the workspaces. We conduct an extensive user study
to understand workers' decision process for workspace choices and evaluate the
effectiveness of the system. We observe that a worker's decision could be
influenced by the LLM's suggestions and explanations. The participants in our
study find the system to be convenient, regardless of whether reasons are
provided or not. Our results show that employees can benefit from the
LLM-empowered system for their workspace selection in hybrid workplace. | [
0.0521275178,
-0.0204270147,
-0.0223257542,
-0.0156322923,
-0.0411877856,
0.0054999315,
0.0720926225,
0.0477237254,
0.0324783362,
-0.0132154794,
0.0038573225,
-0.0138968378,
-0.0206753388,
0.0127557153,
0.0066741379,
-0.0724916384,
0.008705142,
-0.0227137394,
0.0213359259,
0.0251530707,
0.005239489,
0.0142089939,
-0.027443951,
0.0700305179,
0.0025192541,
-0.0167492218,
0.0117435902,
-0.0032162538,
0.0048859101,
0.0297498647,
0.0059698615,
0.0291239806,
0.0406135879,
-0.0037590687,
0.0000022304,
-0.0340056419,
-0.0049643517,
-0.0218680538,
-0.0492427833,
-0.0403052494,
0.0084020374,
0.0201825947,
-0.0085355844,
0.011455263,
-0.0248618815,
0.0065193484,
0.0200697184,
0.0297503155,
0.0036068389,
0.0184799191,
-0.0134340515,
0.0117862793,
-0.0739167482,
0.0081585459,
0.0212391075,
-0.034684591,
0.009223355,
-0.0030779738,
0.0316287093,
-0.0173599757,
0.0689912066,
-0.0171230454,
0.0003068714,
-0.0451417603,
0.0061576562,
0.027876595,
0.0069793426,
-0.0475164726,
0.0155276507,
0.0505075678,
-0.0134962499,
-0.0107772034,
0.0227766782,
-0.0422377847,
0.0170703717,
0.0359872915,
-0.0235390514,
0.0093839969,
-0.0265728123,
-0.0515870936,
-0.0104105715,
0.0523502119,
0.0082339384,
0.0122052096,
-0.0115669249,
0.0636319742,
-0.012594589,
-0.024678275,
0.0340451635,
0.0191281103,
0.0378648192,
-0.0638370737,
0.041017931,
0.0610825792,
-0.0873311907,
0.0082040187,
-0.0007340064,
0.0255338922,
-0.0162676461,
-0.0565625019,
0.0039114212,
0.017006604,
0.026080979,
0.0471743234,
0.0276526455,
-0.0118627539,
-0.0737170503,
-0.0467163436,
-0.0355760567,
-0.0076839682,
-0.0306164417,
-0.0143323205,
-0.0219972357,
-0.0316672809,
-0.0664160475,
-0.0385058932,
-0.0080261705,
0.0719641969,
-0.0118920133,
0.0399064086,
0.0423813909,
0.0411826335,
0.0236921888,
-0.0280435365,
-0.0670467243,
0.0000671,
-0.0305306893,
0.0263704732,
-0.0005932185,
-0.0160029065,
0.0610854365,
0.0585070178,
-0.0059311497,
-0.0162508767,
-0.0119368974,
0.0545231849,
0.012346494,
0.0278264862,
-0.0324322321,
-0.0820375606,
-0.0037104627,
-0.0292018689,
-0.0557816923,
-0.0648945272,
0.0200262573,
0.0373830236,
-0.0394961126,
-0.0171075705,
0.0006627315,
0.0250006877,
0.0508194976,
0.0136554064,
-0.0293865167,
0.0296365209,
0.051546637,
0.0206066053,
-0.0435332246,
0.0171596762,
0.0390528888,
0.0945291892,
0.020585699,
-0.0049036657,
0.0332122818,
0.0239936467,
-0.0870021731,
-0.0315007791,
-0.0130605157,
0.0302303117,
-0.0390267,
-0.0008977007,
-0.0573599786,
0.0062430683,
-0.0417146794,
0.0696565732,
0.0447401665,
0.079375878,
0.0372873656,
0.0420217142,
-0.0236774161,
0.0174849275,
-0.0352202542,
-0.0441891998,
0.0443711765,
0.0633222759,
-0.0142432842,
-0.0010433967,
0.0229134466,
0.0187063552,
-0.0097277304,
-0.0612510592,
-0.0119510852,
0.0024537493,
0.026573183,
0.0183598306,
0.0499071963,
-0.0808830932,
-0.0397457853,
0.0474554598,
0.002185002,
-0.0475766882,
-0.0290708113,
-0.0369426869,
0.0478636399,
0.1453092694,
0.0330859944,
-0.0506174602,
0.0102259675,
-0.0193566233,
0.0042775874,
0.034137208,
0.0864079297,
0.0144410646,
-0.0437343717,
-0.0514876135,
-0.0323309302,
0.0278702658,
-0.0178612918,
0.0281515755,
-0.0053488309,
0.0115830703,
-0.0031195546,
-0.0164265037,
-0.0101225236,
-0.0229748096,
0.0069440175,
-0.0117294416,
-0.0337006673,
0.0748332143,
-0.0066692103,
0.0494599454,
-0.0008867656,
0.0095934086,
-0.0138487089,
-0.0216645673,
-0.0280645732,
0.0551454499,
-0.0739637315,
0.0483092107,
0.0192051567,
0.0074187978,
0.0029519917,
-0.0205688812,
0.0107275257,
-0.0069512012,
0.0005003277,
-0.0111890147,
0.0128628518,
-0.0091066463,
-0.010709893,
-0.0484474823,
-0.0367973782,
-0.0469624512,
0.0804218948,
0.0265918467,
0.0050324406,
0.0038107424,
-0.035274718,
0.0433452241,
-0.0554925613,
0.0134044923,
0.0252226982,
0.0470368601,
0.0298700687,
0.0068928367,
-0.0026771044,
-0.0272400454,
-0.0295124985,
-0.0921457186,
-0.0228982102,
-0.0080791581,
0.0024927177,
0.0140412971,
0.0057611829,
-0.0112627503,
-0.0054736841,
-0.0407747254,
0.0261280946,
0.032125067,
0.0272372328,
0.0350197963,
-0.0008257469,
0.0067525408,
-0.0194714535,
-0.0035011119,
-0.0287230425,
0.0040744655,
0.0425083227,
-0.0447683819,
-0.0701422691,
0.0277650449,
0.0041158525,
-0.0092204232,
0.0187526848,
0.021895539,
0.0329700895,
-0.0411138646,
0.0362335704,
0.0328090526,
-0.0465796776,
0.0367595144,
0.0504623204,
0.0091374349,
-0.0547145903,
-0.0177560914,
0.0054276283,
0.0439100191,
-0.0069690724,
-0.0347885638,
-0.0059344545,
-0.0011747414,
-0.0008251498,
0.0161457211,
-0.0357363671,
0.0619547293,
-0.0218805913,
0.0161999613,
-0.037456844,
-0.0157184303,
-0.0411112309,
0.1194457561,
0.022864053,
-0.0227415543,
0.0284203198,
-0.0049354401,
0.0060466705,
-0.0201104153,
-0.0746597648,
-0.0401518904,
0.0562275648,
-0.0723614842,
-0.005443811,
-0.0150606567,
-0.0322171338,
-0.0014741429,
-0.010400028,
0.0003755583,
-0.0180343892,
0.019279357,
-0.0407030173,
-0.0072841118,
0.0133936414,
-0.0258925427,
-0.0091003664,
-0.0351066552,
-0.0843699872,
-0.013711283,
0.0318972357,
-0.0214516222,
-0.0366858356,
0.0087875687,
0.0551820919,
0.0604048669,
0.01258488,
-0.0259216763,
-0.0201198757,
-0.0179274995,
0.0205719881,
0.0715360641,
-0.0137444576,
-0.0149598345,
-0.0012312644,
0.0474129878,
-0.0168775246,
-0.0074295369,
-0.0409324951,
-0.032194484,
0.0374080092,
-0.0113527235,
0.0056475559,
0.0215504598,
0.0378671698,
-0.0357380882,
0.0464741401,
0.0886996016,
0.0332900248,
-0.0862876251,
-0.0144253233,
-0.0763096213,
-0.0187547784,
0.0339925103,
0.066462718,
-0.0337015949,
-0.0152199734,
-0.0066875909,
0.0041699619,
0.0155413635,
-0.0360395834,
0.0214350633,
-0.0438910984,
0.0417945758,
-0.0055702981,
-0.011368542,
0.009050386,
0.0079276497,
0.0035542429,
-0.0011781318,
-0.0048571378,
0.0090023922,
0.0121444194,
-0.015827043,
0.0514581874,
-0.0254670326,
-0.0287614986,
0.0147986067,
-0.0213245675,
-0.0113278609,
0.0518454388,
0.0421894416,
0.0258388706,
-0.0761403218,
0.0173579697,
0.0707517788,
0.056479983,
-0.0129891634,
-0.0132290134,
0.0221737549,
0.0202198662,
-0.049236685,
-0.0041599423,
-0.0219226088,
0.0001041999,
0.0752959177,
0.1025328487,
-0.0318833999,
0.0106324311,
0.0044226376,
0.0191096235,
0.0379565991,
0.0322071351,
0.0177499931,
-0.0804157779,
-0.0448546,
-0.0454658754,
-0.0561444163,
0.0054407176,
-0.023939617,
-0.0148064056,
-0.0088953543,
-0.0158059224,
-0.0322688557,
-0.0266382191,
0.0639399737,
0.0615154058,
-0.0035138752,
-0.0222663749,
-0.0217540413,
0.0028076132,
0.005854045,
-0.0058440752,
-0.0043539493,
0.0762496144,
-0.0182802733,
0.0290114414,
-0.0419739783,
-0.0415751301,
0.0222513471,
-0.0465507433,
0.0059972377,
-0.0424593315,
-0.0597256571,
0.0392037667,
0.0390105695,
-0.0418448038,
0.0191328395,
-0.071211502,
-0.0098938989,
0.0284016114,
-0.0629298389,
-0.0046734568,
0.0124353673,
0.0428372025,
0.0067336075,
0.0037804442,
-0.052943632,
-0.0544715412,
-0.0082595544,
-0.0042309193,
-0.0496269166,
-0.0329574309,
-0.0120841963,
0.0009673904,
-0.0725766271,
-0.0148297166,
-0.0174950417,
-0.0116685722,
0.0280562285,
-0.0030493725,
-0.0344932415,
-0.0025247922,
0.0102967899,
0.0008202035,
-0.0601340756,
0.0702417046,
0.0266646575,
-0.0295145866,
0.0110810911,
-0.0108018676,
0.0399436913,
-0.0009582766,
0.0259829443,
0.0300140753,
0.0319908261,
-0.0339862593,
-0.0193848405,
0.0024199744,
0.0359906815,
0.0134278573,
0.0960485861,
-0.0043798275,
-0.0329964422,
-0.0619865879,
0.0304250699,
-0.0089658126,
-0.1232147589,
0.0773876905,
0.0189929102,
0.004682824,
-0.0316856503,
0.0147564178,
-0.0448231623,
-0.0089604901,
-0.0110996068,
0.0292344764,
0.0228560213,
0.0105009219,
-0.0075761434,
0.0172896218,
-0.03156773,
-0.038975697,
0.0571349561,
-0.0129754376,
-0.0390445702,
-0.0192001145,
-0.0783119574,
-0.0537258312,
-0.0019259092,
-0.0059230719,
0.0607673079,
-0.0421588682,
-0.0174664445,
-0.0994562879,
-0.0171717368,
-0.0335629471,
0.0093822954,
-0.0228037126,
-0.0425981916,
0.0149814682,
0.0716272965,
0.0363702066,
-0.0157002117,
-0.0254100822,
0.0284062196,
-0.0075019891,
0.0612562895,
-0.0609596968,
-5.861528745e-33,
0.030515708,
-0.0484077856,
0.0485670306,
-0.0357991159,
0.0377561152,
-0.0469423756,
0.0167534929,
0.0219099391,
0.0206684824,
-0.0304940976,
-0.0251835547,
-0.0120962663,
0.0245868154,
-0.0278997757,
0.0058546341,
0.0123535888,
0.0146025419,
0.0472671911,
-0.0366586559,
0.0149300741,
0.0313692912,
-0.0026902414,
0.0132266814,
-0.0949108079,
0.0277799293,
0.0084290076,
0.034159936,
0.0006423045,
-0.028952131,
0.0259101279,
-0.0108040618,
0.0254130624,
0.009186035,
-0.0285226684,
-0.0097544612,
0.1272608042,
-0.004154664,
-0.0124907466,
0.0481730737,
0.0190470386,
-0.0032889587,
-0.0301522054,
-0.0188937951,
0.0257460009,
-0.0131562389,
0.04201914,
0.0181620345,
-0.0327746049,
-0.0331857428,
0.0246059746,
-0.0281429589,
-0.0120201651,
-0.0230151713,
0.0172353853,
0.0120538166,
0.0326167233,
-0.0358263142,
-0.0154473791,
-0.0857041255,
0.0387134738,
0.0185020268,
-0.0180686787,
0.0539422669,
-0.01380393,
0.0009639693,
0.042785123,
-0.0205818489,
0.0341561511,
-0.0424972251,
-0.0115062352,
-0.0216636937,
0.0768522173,
0.0190206282,
-0.0180744026,
-0.0129717635,
-0.0223230589,
-0.0269427579,
0.0306207873,
0.0512133278,
0.0013963812,
0.0686177313,
0.046566125,
-0.0285325833,
-0.0434256941,
0.0088174734,
0.0180220958,
-0.0490978472,
-0.0662821084,
0.0129587809,
0.0004341947,
0.0092990808,
0.0071649384,
0.0044173775,
0.0002065694,
0.001499487,
0.0128171453,
0.0051989853,
0.0035054376,
0.0232484005,
-0.0187677145,
-0.0599336848,
0.00223064,
-0.060973525,
0.0384193473,
0.0194336902,
0.030262718,
-0.0302954949,
-0.0171825159,
-0.033283323,
-0.0042798226,
-0.058587499,
-0.0125769489,
0.0081219738,
-0.0203923695,
0.0343588963,
0.0073846332,
-0.0055120923,
0.0625299588,
-0.0084219826,
-0.0523469597,
-0.0018725195,
-0.0444461294,
-0.0186049398,
0.0050289454,
-0.0014608715,
-0.0345090926,
-0.0372158773,
0.0192937013,
0.0714476332,
-0.0196992047,
-0.0023358867,
-0.0135804461,
2.776e-7,
0.0052693649,
0.0434241854,
-0.039776817,
-0.0114487102,
0.0020837055,
0.0414326303,
0.0138806449,
-0.0184047669,
0.0120701678,
0.0278307293,
0.025104221,
0.0070821322,
0.0460254923,
0.0349529386,
-0.0542549342,
-0.0414673313,
-0.0098404214,
-0.0269090571,
-0.066136755,
0.0446510576,
0.0805718005,
0.0110193649,
0.0386821255,
-0.0041664997,
-0.0082634371,
-0.0215118695,
0.0063320077,
-0.0615358464,
0.021805793,
-0.0295840688,
0.0783934742,
-0.0221251231,
-0.0224764496,
0.0200080555,
0.0119995456,
-0.0087448414,
-0.0086815618,
0.0527311862,
-0.0186145045,
0.0251502525,
0.0123425163,
-0.0729998648,
-0.0023010604,
-0.0394825935,
0.0302716456,
-0.0133300126,
-0.006616672,
0.01878828,
0.0192156956,
-0.0661595762,
-0.0092188837,
-0.0082040643,
0.010791596,
-0.0111943968,
-0.0267856568,
-0.0128352446,
-0.0037406008,
-0.0262978692,
-0.0071363542,
0.0414499752,
-0.0476214141,
-0.0414595976,
-0.0114545291,
0.0269935708,
0.0241124947,
-0.0221814811,
0.0075044516,
2.099285515e-34,
-0.0017169764,
0.0956815183,
0.0035294816,
0.0386608578,
0.0353476182,
0.0466788262,
0.0078275381,
0.0299065672,
0.0591753572,
-0.0227182321,
-0.0195946116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03610v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03610v1 | RAP: Retrieval-Augmented Planning with Contextual Memory for Multimodal LLM Agents | 2024-02-06T00:53:27 | 2024-02-06T00:53:27 | Tomoyuki Kagaya, Thong Jing Yuan, Yuxuan Lou, Jayashree Karlekar, Sugiri Pranata, Akira Kinose, Koki Oguri, Felix Wick, Yang You | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Owing to recent advancements, Large Language Models (LLMs) can now be
deployed as agents for increasingly complex decision-making applications in
areas including robotics, gaming, and API integration. However, reflecting past
experiences in current decision-making processes, an innate human behavior,
continues to pose significant challenges. Addressing this, we propose
Retrieval-Augmented Planning (RAP) framework, designed to dynamically leverage
past experiences corresponding to the current situation and context, thereby
enhancing agents' planning capabilities. RAP distinguishes itself by being
versatile: it excels in both text-only and multimodal environments, making it
suitable for a wide range of tasks. Empirical evaluations demonstrate RAP's
effectiveness, where it achieves SOTA performance in textual scenarios and
notably enhances multimodal LLM agents' performance for embodied tasks. These
results highlight RAP's potential in advancing the functionality and
applicability of LLM agents in complex, real-world applications. | [
0.0592785217,
0.0161825232,
-0.0254463814,
0.0104567008,
-0.0458566248,
-0.0209083073,
-0.0323921219,
-0.0003539557,
0.0227057729,
-0.0716682002,
-0.0600042716,
-0.0080148913,
-0.0135278236,
0.0268520545,
-0.0018432713,
-0.0388666205,
0.0393687189,
-0.012798436,
0.0241043698,
0.0098472927,
-0.0071856305,
-0.0115472954,
-0.0324542038,
0.0627531409,
-0.0279225279,
0.0146056833,
-0.0348786488,
0.0077083092,
0.0025400734,
-0.0723649934,
-0.0080638668,
-0.001277258,
0.0756330639,
-0.0054802205,
0.000001965,
-0.0466267616,
-0.0247531757,
-0.0465058759,
-0.0021864187,
-0.0531835407,
0.0487820096,
0.0342378691,
0.0054337597,
-0.0088286633,
-0.0783872455,
-0.0157504268,
0.0236700512,
0.0254477523,
0.0333233252,
0.0494966544,
-0.0113395685,
0.0116992528,
-0.001764748,
0.021116877,
0.0078732353,
-0.0334417708,
-0.0144479815,
-0.0189589113,
0.0404853374,
0.0253901277,
-0.009331366,
0.0246673636,
0.0223104637,
0.004257632,
-0.0484943762,
0.0509866923,
-0.0147459721,
-0.012296238,
-0.0294625349,
0.0449225307,
0.0367382765,
-0.0219254885,
0.0369950086,
0.0039916714,
-0.0008387559,
-0.0010354186,
-0.0404015817,
0.0203111079,
-0.0185066648,
0.0047122743,
-0.0613945127,
0.0048175869,
0.0263462421,
0.0152432499,
-0.0020341026,
0.0857586712,
-0.0114292046,
-0.028741505,
0.0092995921,
-0.027116105,
0.0371013321,
-0.0289173331,
0.0184999369,
0.0677442253,
-0.0622728989,
0.0340594538,
-0.0125849349,
0.0168298669,
0.0078566046,
-0.0250662118,
0.0430735052,
0.0527769253,
-0.0328556374,
0.0287422799,
-0.0469785929,
0.0590810478,
0.0067890082,
0.0246136226,
-0.0323095098,
0.0130172716,
-0.0539103374,
-0.0214098226,
-0.0280861333,
0.0398806371,
-0.049777586,
-0.0487691052,
0.002151412,
0.0565471612,
-0.0104414066,
0.0217545927,
-0.0497205816,
0.0403946899,
-0.0035752575,
-0.0024235221,
-0.0956735238,
-0.0302395429,
-0.0273811817,
0.023822559,
0.0265854504,
-0.0211065039,
0.0150921633,
0.0091362214,
0.00226816,
-0.0203960929,
-0.0014900687,
0.1028473303,
-0.0083377445,
-0.0470138825,
-0.0390622094,
-0.0393906906,
-0.0009094972,
-0.0467758588,
0.0362142473,
-0.0351564214,
0.0286142193,
-0.0213250592,
-0.0198774841,
-0.0240873806,
0.0237220097,
0.0283572003,
0.023993222,
0.0584633872,
0.0528357141,
0.0178809594,
0.0390053913,
-0.0006871482,
0.0007112616,
0.0533340946,
0.0550480708,
0.0768557936,
0.0195872542,
0.0467518307,
0.0041543595,
0.0236218087,
-0.0093067782,
-0.0163189191,
-0.0131977797,
-0.0080803316,
-0.011219047,
0.0419558845,
0.0055186902,
0.0318010449,
-0.0293550566,
-0.0123462165,
0.0603358001,
0.0697761029,
0.0046015396,
-0.0311018061,
0.0421722531,
-0.0049706511,
-0.018394433,
-0.0290848669,
-0.0504876748,
0.0725115687,
-0.0090305973,
-0.0109900283,
-0.0031978001,
0.0264016055,
-0.0058654747,
-0.0177394915,
0.0104572186,
0.0110813659,
0.0322030149,
0.0160413925,
0.0095525933,
-0.0017419265,
-0.0730270296,
0.0154917333,
-0.0195899196,
-0.0524539724,
-0.0246626008,
-0.0578654967,
0.0407962501,
0.0686152354,
0.0467075333,
-0.0466691256,
-0.0297603291,
0.0314438902,
-0.0182921588,
0.0472589061,
0.0035627033,
-0.0083441129,
0.0253248736,
-0.0287895799,
-0.0464162193,
-0.0044216956,
0.0040383176,
0.0472149812,
0.0410843678,
0.0301565249,
-0.0019100445,
0.0176974181,
0.0555673614,
0.0384149104,
-0.013341601,
-0.0094988579,
-0.0416877307,
0.0025557559,
0.0181893203,
-0.0079220394,
-0.0103086075,
0.0176315363,
0.0403709821,
-0.0209259968,
-0.0409556888,
0.033244852,
-0.0524427481,
-0.019649731,
0.0302476119,
0.0040059215,
0.0265024994,
0.0079791173,
0.0065745767,
-0.0389806516,
0.0062566511,
-0.0173539985,
0.070404835,
-0.0344229899,
-0.0064769951,
0.0146558322,
-0.0137980459,
-0.022098897,
0.0392260626,
-0.0263450239,
-0.0312243197,
0.0249237716,
0.0431002118,
0.0078287506,
-0.047362525,
0.0110647175,
0.0233943108,
0.0230520722,
0.027873693,
0.0548153333,
0.0110661387,
-0.0397682227,
-0.0437373929,
-0.1018771008,
-0.0180673972,
-0.008819514,
-0.0260646567,
-0.0222247224,
-0.0393079184,
-0.014164879,
-0.018052239,
-0.0104619954,
0.0530339591,
0.0148930401,
0.0437405333,
0.0070209689,
0.0138411652,
0.0036502946,
-0.0665890649,
0.0196274575,
-0.0167355482,
0.0103795705,
-0.0204804167,
-0.0165181123,
-0.0254433583,
0.0267872233,
-0.0665773526,
0.0366025716,
-0.0467011482,
-0.0413202122,
0.0654137805,
-0.0515876636,
0.032178551,
0.0457207784,
0.0026458194,
0.0183852687,
0.0909358561,
-0.0613222495,
-0.0690470338,
0.049528107,
-0.0305972379,
-0.0146452403,
-0.0329620242,
0.0101095792,
0.0329967216,
0.0276845843,
0.006084682,
0.0392688923,
-0.0481522977,
-0.0240198728,
0.0038461876,
-0.0730134845,
-0.0155719053,
0.0112886224,
-0.0502150618,
0.0531567745,
-0.0294663571,
-0.0362925567,
0.0550151505,
-0.0019174,
-0.0129642449,
0.0244955365,
-0.0062415791,
-0.0347624868,
0.1188505441,
-0.0047884323,
0.0125255715,
-0.0144358948,
-0.0011017617,
-0.0385885984,
-0.034847945,
-0.0042219949,
-0.040772669,
0.0491722599,
-0.0687486082,
0.0132134045,
0.0176010784,
-0.0384551026,
-0.0398238041,
0.0058878763,
-0.0311216079,
-0.0050962693,
-0.064749144,
-0.0208531208,
-0.0639423132,
-0.0136867641,
0.0661847517,
0.0464175157,
0.0137171261,
-0.0371254236,
-0.0219788961,
-0.0196745563,
0.0500051789,
0.0570258349,
-0.0182704311,
-0.0076326667,
0.0147161456,
0.0360022746,
0.0239579771,
-0.0525148287,
-0.0373406447,
0.0110079339,
0.0305894371,
0.0095076375,
0.0096323062,
0.064534232,
0.0142605146,
-0.0444669537,
-0.0117756277,
0.057427384,
0.0275421645,
-0.0361361839,
-0.0034220342,
-0.0659516528,
0.0441462025,
0.032400094,
0.0258258693,
-0.0211104248,
-0.0481579192,
0.012663777,
-0.0027124612,
-0.0103359185,
-0.0437376089,
-0.0094602583,
-0.1137765497,
0.0097649097,
-0.0096553955,
-0.0440410934,
0.0068482817,
-0.025539225,
0.0050893552,
0.0236694608,
0.0013906147,
0.0275559016,
0.0057959924,
-0.008366785,
-0.0127121592,
-0.0370607637,
0.009199664,
0.0119771613,
-0.0011368644,
0.0210563038,
0.0753071159,
0.0460051745,
0.0052330601,
-0.0245768987,
0.0012214194,
0.0374873839,
0.0605172329,
-0.0205486938,
0.0095577957,
-0.0299666133,
0.028170798,
-0.0078763552,
-0.004534489,
-0.0115985498,
-0.0637836233,
0.0062089488,
0.0674260706,
-0.0582944863,
0.016145708,
-0.0339630842,
0.0022849811,
0.0115099829,
0.0420728289,
-0.0215075873,
-0.029192172,
-0.0517777056,
-0.0255395491,
-0.0176999047,
-0.0242024437,
-0.0527155846,
-0.0126594957,
-0.0065589533,
0.0344303325,
-0.0840608254,
-0.052892942,
0.0052371053,
0.0217296537,
0.0180558749,
-0.0014506078,
-0.0169104431,
0.011741247,
-0.0279678535,
-0.0073861107,
-0.0293747075,
0.0029807575,
-0.0192426424,
0.0115393512,
0.0566412695,
-0.0620233603,
0.0144727491,
0.0379894264,
-0.0383385569,
-0.037076924,
-0.0029424378,
0.0711417422,
0.0198142361,
0.0021659464,
0.0420207419,
-0.0215383507,
0.0735731125,
0.0465164781,
-0.0276451763,
0.0558355041,
0.0206908677,
0.0702868551,
0.0119216964,
0.0373369828,
-0.082983546,
-0.0099157859,
-0.0332508199,
0.0632014722,
-0.0047940528,
-0.0247096736,
0.0200227145,
-0.0216625724,
0.0286371615,
-0.0231517423,
-0.0179046132,
-0.0126801571,
0.0198210962,
-0.022996245,
0.0016719878,
-0.0423009023,
0.0124416128,
-0.0112828854,
-0.0112672346,
0.0448382348,
-0.0214275606,
0.0124048777,
0.0334257148,
0.016038442,
0.0034285181,
0.0446289405,
-0.014640972,
0.003887011,
0.0499251746,
-0.0217737146,
0.0144994278,
-0.0471264347,
0.0563008375,
-0.0033725433,
0.0859646425,
0.0137403272,
-0.0695261583,
-0.036318779,
0.0195605215,
-0.0683768615,
-0.0582007729,
0.0664474443,
0.002787069,
0.0486732572,
0.0006278932,
0.0409046821,
-0.0713956505,
0.0342586711,
-0.0139318937,
-0.0049343281,
0.0289864354,
-0.0630712137,
0.0211131666,
0.0239103194,
-0.0123187928,
0.0077877203,
0.028286064,
-0.0506663881,
0.0718442649,
-0.0300804805,
-0.0146683566,
-0.0376445018,
-0.0534426384,
0.0207678284,
0.0478054658,
-0.0187902413,
-0.0411005579,
-0.0734788328,
-0.0252773613,
0.0218200237,
0.0542818196,
-0.0491168685,
-0.0464837775,
0.0304451305,
0.0191465169,
0.0216303077,
-0.0503093451,
-0.0545140058,
-0.0169147048,
-0.0373472385,
0.0037553769,
-0.0385712869,
-5.238251518e-33,
-0.0308836158,
-0.0380550362,
0.0840969607,
-0.043637123,
-0.0211634282,
-0.0068314625,
-0.0599265918,
0.0127748474,
-0.0011623397,
-0.0141571723,
-0.0345579349,
-0.0178750101,
0.0108011775,
0.0190973375,
0.0138506731,
-0.003889556,
0.0058749183,
-0.0004185663,
-0.0287037045,
-0.0175598878,
0.0627954379,
0.0298367254,
0.0091616241,
-0.0608374514,
0.0035194922,
0.0329156294,
-0.014042316,
0.0337952487,
-0.0214075577,
0.0669086277,
-0.0388734713,
0.0110206185,
0.0210365467,
0.0055708922,
-0.0314692222,
0.0283648204,
-0.0223155841,
-0.0494686924,
0.0172272008,
-0.0143607743,
-0.0452608615,
-0.0029001732,
0.0033269669,
-0.0130169494,
-0.0358397327,
0.0339640789,
0.0153620113,
-0.01168657,
-0.0447150916,
0.0288021713,
-0.0407381542,
0.0070582689,
0.0168003999,
-0.0098449429,
0.0330750532,
0.0571311601,
0.0196029507,
0.0257648844,
-0.0528015122,
0.026069805,
-0.0874058306,
-0.0148216663,
0.0412997156,
0.0414802916,
0.0262922104,
0.0979995131,
0.0462823659,
0.0033831077,
-0.0395629071,
-0.0190530196,
0.0503139384,
0.058931753,
-0.0316836685,
0.0874208137,
-0.0212406293,
0.0044428441,
0.0126497466,
0.0445258394,
0.0120944111,
0.05519953,
0.0567804649,
0.0544353463,
-0.0212214906,
0.0188188348,
-0.035077326,
0.0563539192,
-0.0154733583,
-0.0245675035,
0.0364466421,
0.0346047953,
0.0415052399,
-0.0413357317,
0.056832619,
-0.0060501941,
-0.0054312944,
0.0145966923,
-0.0425732546,
0.0356793106,
-0.0241979901,
0.0272034295,
-0.0234882049,
-0.0171295945,
0.0274460018,
-0.019302668,
0.0077875676,
0.0239415914,
-0.0397439599,
0.0814913511,
-0.0379069485,
-0.003563677,
-0.0370752104,
-0.0142619414,
0.0214263909,
-0.0468999632,
0.0431500413,
-0.0165890865,
-0.034373261,
0.0260076355,
-0.005528592,
-0.0435413159,
-0.0211016703,
-0.066560477,
-0.0023905435,
0.0033630102,
-0.0185406525,
0.020804381,
-0.0488929562,
0.0488187633,
0.0069375583,
-0.0324041173,
0.0276507158,
0.0357056931,
2.705e-7,
-0.0159440301,
0.022760991,
0.0104453079,
-0.0001508533,
0.0167138465,
0.0480551124,
-0.0261831693,
0.0372293033,
-0.0218338892,
-0.0504171252,
0.0384106599,
0.0521617644,
0.0392621197,
0.012147435,
-0.0667221174,
-0.0025003029,
0.0004623607,
-0.0528980941,
-0.0513604879,
0.004924247,
0.0669211447,
0.0389562137,
0.0300076697,
-0.0120425997,
-0.0055187708,
-0.0427506752,
0.0623930618,
-0.0735654533,
0.02085476,
-0.0239503626,
0.0056722057,
0.0070461337,
-0.0167348478,
-0.0344200432,
0.0069523789,
-0.0010962089,
-0.0206897464,
0.05947515,
-0.0083444957,
-0.1002212539,
0.0008946906,
0.0143524464,
-0.0190731864,
-0.0190983601,
0.0482533127,
0.0014738629,
0.0105688768,
-0.007361189,
0.0069279494,
-0.0019958776,
-0.037374109,
-0.013763763,
-0.0262834113,
-0.0000382221,
-0.0317199975,
0.0228224117,
-0.0060915411,
-0.1245739162,
-0.0143331913,
0.0188983325,
-0.0486557819,
-0.0175474938,
-0.0607907474,
0.0184289571,
-0.0015914346,
-0.0817597285,
-0.0086910566,
2.289566367e-34,
-0.0070388438,
0.014552705,
-0.0143947443,
0.0486301407,
0.0364333503,
0.0376942903,
0.0189924352,
0.0289088544,
0.0413618423,
-0.0473735519,
-0.0373387188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03607v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03607v1 | Improving Contextual Congruence Across Modalities for Effective Multimodal Marketing using Knowledge-infused Learning | 2024-02-06T00:51:27 | 2024-02-06T00:51:27 | Trilok Padhi, Ugur Kursuncu, Yaman Kumar, Valerie L. Shalin, Lane Peterson Fronczek | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY, cs.HC, I.2.7; I.2.10; I.2.4; I.2.1 | The prevalence of smart devices with the ability to capture moments in
multiple modalities has enabled users to experience multimodal information
online. However, large Language (LLMs) and Vision models (LVMs) are still
limited in capturing holistic meaning with cross-modal semantic relationships.
Without explicit, common sense knowledge (e.g., as a knowledge graph), Visual
Language Models (VLMs) only learn implicit representations by capturing
high-level patterns in vast corpora, missing essential contextual cross-modal
cues. In this work, we design a framework to couple explicit commonsense
knowledge in the form of knowledge graphs with large VLMs to improve the
performance of a downstream task, predicting the effectiveness of multi-modal
marketing campaigns. While the marketing application provides a compelling
metric for assessing our methods, our approach enables the early detection of
likely persuasive multi-modal campaigns and the assessment and augmentation of
marketing theory. | [
0.0309629422,
0.0160427745,
-0.0170405935,
0.0300914831,
-0.0178405885,
-0.018102454,
-0.0144597339,
-0.0034249383,
0.0480050109,
-0.1159304753,
-0.024008099,
-0.0084126173,
0.0131645752,
0.0714358836,
0.0305368174,
-0.0363589302,
-0.0006140108,
0.0125782844,
0.0076383054,
0.0222507454,
0.0510758795,
0.0310787484,
-0.0054323785,
0.0329328813,
-0.0557046607,
-0.038115561,
0.0208532643,
0.0176391639,
0.0330307558,
-0.06293872,
-0.0232667215,
-0.0036693171,
0.0726299211,
-0.0080335476,
0.0000019028,
-0.0303800143,
0.0336512215,
-0.0186786447,
-0.014038871,
-0.0027071503,
0.0578037016,
-0.0300164744,
0.0474205799,
-0.0119074984,
-0.0423065722,
0.0305573177,
0.0613552742,
0.0464707725,
-0.0049738195,
0.009953198,
-0.0427036509,
-0.0107051535,
0.015573306,
0.0178117584,
0.0418647267,
-0.040512342,
-0.0201088358,
0.0175728239,
-0.0096910112,
-0.0175937098,
-0.0318431444,
0.0367827713,
-0.0009601418,
-0.0046458817,
0.0190602895,
0.050098747,
0.0337829664,
0.011151108,
-0.0519164205,
0.0909058154,
-0.0082076034,
0.0202043001,
-0.006428286,
-0.0045834631,
0.0048622917,
0.0260061398,
-0.0555810146,
0.0036514113,
0.0027169441,
0.0247385707,
-0.0604521297,
-0.0177407432,
0.0342087038,
0.0103283003,
0.0301984884,
0.0373099558,
0.0082545765,
0.0192212369,
0.0176707972,
0.0150570842,
-0.025684664,
-0.0192866754,
-0.0506518818,
-0.0082116993,
0.0161309615,
0.0153297894,
0.0341787152,
0.0261288863,
-0.0022104268,
-0.0636518002,
0.0595306754,
-0.0215288363,
-0.046995379,
0.0355710164,
-0.026092615,
0.005464708,
-0.0205708127,
0.0322001502,
-0.0275681335,
0.0182983298,
-0.0809986517,
-0.0217074733,
0.0037017395,
0.001154831,
-0.0764626861,
-0.0764896572,
-0.0637669563,
0.0192984361,
-0.0409827866,
0.0029627893,
-0.0297699254,
0.0610285923,
0.0104593532,
-0.0130165741,
-0.0399287194,
0.0789188668,
-0.0041152867,
0.0502254367,
-0.0412153862,
-0.0211934503,
0.0620276108,
0.0533247106,
0.0232967343,
-0.0278643891,
-0.011378495,
0.0618594214,
-0.0428373702,
-0.0241786819,
-0.0804032534,
-0.0674735308,
-0.0602393597,
-0.0114864893,
0.0257089697,
-0.0351076163,
0.0006722897,
0.0058455858,
0.0207165536,
0.0061346833,
-0.0018717962,
-0.0255444106,
-0.0311393961,
0.0791176111,
0.0439251587,
-0.0046543651,
-0.0039341799,
0.0129746487,
0.0230610278,
0.0418029316,
0.0155867711,
0.0507048331,
0.0381881148,
0.0128365653,
-0.0102021545,
0.0176945627,
-0.0063703414,
-0.0144979693,
-0.0309108533,
-0.0121033862,
-0.0222302731,
0.0057153786,
0.0237300657,
-0.0013973125,
-0.006643055,
0.0181823187,
0.132983163,
-0.0015284375,
0.0333084948,
-0.0197913386,
0.0226097219,
-0.0023638569,
-0.0381426066,
-0.0249240734,
-0.0191145949,
0.0429180898,
-0.045506727,
0.0032186003,
0.000639234,
0.0025239028,
-0.0326247923,
0.005577249,
0.0215842556,
-0.0159972347,
0.0561740436,
0.0333636478,
0.0284930225,
-0.0306953974,
-0.0200851075,
0.0045379926,
0.0216438565,
-0.0194577556,
0.0095718484,
-0.0023900855,
0.0337439552,
0.0622046515,
-0.0102264388,
0.0108253453,
0.017187614,
0.0025552453,
0.0171413925,
0.0206239223,
0.0075904783,
-0.0276271105,
0.0269874949,
-0.0267621409,
-0.0584772825,
-0.0508723557,
0.0014158987,
0.0225802269,
-0.0379010066,
0.0204829015,
0.0221193638,
-0.0628371388,
0.0619440526,
-0.0193939339,
0.0627941936,
0.0073959273,
-0.0323596187,
0.0499176681,
0.0115836505,
0.019428907,
0.015870193,
0.0044006556,
0.0206561927,
-0.071087487,
-0.0122052794,
0.0619965382,
-0.0066576852,
0.0086300783,
0.0493549518,
-0.0709212869,
-0.0044390238,
-0.007603507,
0.0144840609,
-0.0026787831,
0.0554975644,
-0.0158593133,
0.0684342608,
-0.0109253777,
-0.0565696433,
0.024271464,
0.0130682914,
0.0285028387,
0.0520846248,
0.0081299245,
-0.0242718495,
0.0019983198,
-0.0433075167,
0.0151727861,
0.047039561,
0.0142827723,
-0.0074725663,
0.0312039107,
0.0379186906,
0.0145678092,
-0.0072779856,
-0.0342962481,
0.0111353742,
-0.1416154355,
-0.048868943,
0.0210800394,
-0.0077028102,
-0.0179367419,
0.0115998136,
0.0246153753,
-0.0318396613,
-0.0355838127,
0.062242873,
-0.0066508073,
0.0379850082,
0.022104755,
0.0370298289,
-0.005876991,
0.0208747499,
0.0180395246,
-0.0049822531,
0.0937052742,
0.0527945571,
0.0231236015,
-0.01211375,
-0.0479382314,
-0.0559609495,
-0.0019655793,
-0.0162355825,
0.0001514265,
0.0043217004,
0.0083090179,
0.0568313301,
0.0034200384,
0.0151451062,
0.0134357093,
0.0106211295,
-0.0497515611,
-0.0533334315,
-0.0254444405,
-0.013433096,
-0.0161678251,
-0.0662037134,
-0.0012627485,
-0.016919598,
0.0061755329,
0.0160171166,
-0.0064564082,
-0.0409982949,
0.0057164449,
0.0399462804,
-0.0772043914,
-0.0779369846,
0.0124051729,
-0.0094180796,
0.0324315876,
-0.0270207562,
-0.0532422513,
0.0246613529,
-0.0113987802,
0.000153153,
0.0637087747,
-0.0033239245,
-0.0198663827,
0.0914274901,
-0.0164044332,
0.029170407,
-0.0303206909,
-0.0320197195,
-0.0306944083,
-0.0381325595,
0.0381203108,
0.0088635311,
0.0668680742,
-0.0671243966,
0.0071914163,
0.0065948912,
-0.0414726697,
-0.0228982549,
-0.0713211969,
-0.0292304065,
-0.0207157135,
-0.004109446,
0.015542645,
-0.0305018779,
0.0260906164,
0.0131015992,
-0.0401429497,
0.0268050749,
-0.035829179,
0.0150825707,
0.0532824025,
0.0313944481,
0.0408212468,
-0.0457639582,
-0.0295596663,
-0.0322892815,
0.0325277299,
0.0018578484,
-0.0218058135,
-0.0656434447,
0.0430055782,
0.0046730018,
0.0514006466,
-0.0059327022,
0.0451481454,
0.0283435192,
0.0020042525,
0.0529690534,
0.0629162937,
-0.0340647697,
-0.0457940921,
0.0004678748,
0.0164058376,
-0.0097393245,
0.0272611249,
0.0139000174,
-0.0883996114,
-0.0636636317,
-0.0571044683,
-0.0365841277,
0.0261635091,
-0.0001201982,
-0.0070978738,
-0.0923792124,
0.0183430873,
0.0084200976,
0.0041562933,
-0.0416002162,
0.005333194,
-0.017079819,
-0.0080256872,
-0.0094174137,
-0.0489383899,
-0.0481010377,
-0.0085965879,
-0.0137577541,
0.0368117616,
-0.0425982587,
0.0242599826,
-0.0538170449,
-0.0068849768,
0.0236469992,
0.0457793958,
0.0061890837,
-0.0834460706,
-0.0237652753,
-0.0066156816,
0.0285132378,
-0.015923949,
0.017736217,
-0.0379725918,
-0.0065352391,
-0.0036275,
0.0134512251,
-0.020031793,
-0.0321279913,
-0.0115822777,
0.0622396097,
0.017586913,
-0.0291199386,
-0.0075301779,
0.0024124489,
0.0208284389,
0.0313031077,
-0.0085164998,
-0.0250732526,
0.0142055964,
-0.0216604955,
0.0033102238,
0.0023226708,
-0.0338703655,
0.0204686541,
0.0078318315,
0.0014872553,
-0.0455130786,
0.0204236154,
0.0294884872,
0.0408462696,
0.0328804888,
0.010095546,
-0.0160031319,
0.0417769514,
-0.064605087,
0.0447429828,
-0.025928136,
0.0310821887,
-0.0218621045,
0.02591989,
0.0073773451,
-0.0857595727,
-0.0130013637,
0.0015118715,
-0.0271989144,
-0.051686313,
-0.0767075345,
0.0413008668,
0.0100127198,
0.0611727275,
0.0383985974,
-0.026895754,
0.0508473441,
0.0805034339,
-0.0314701758,
0.0010902522,
0.0194289461,
0.0176273249,
0.0096724732,
0.0129034556,
-0.0318660252,
-0.0059825401,
0.0394967832,
0.0352971256,
-0.0073323804,
-0.0134494193,
0.0184456166,
-0.007872548,
0.0401672237,
-0.0522930212,
0.0328730531,
-0.0407247655,
-0.0299727265,
0.0276376195,
-0.0080633936,
-0.066716522,
-0.0195768606,
0.0110744741,
0.0249963775,
-0.0147499721,
0.0412793756,
0.0060243616,
0.0045012743,
-0.0350270383,
0.0104494188,
0.0276799686,
0.0065253507,
-0.0223863516,
0.0118435491,
0.0271078423,
0.0288289115,
-0.0469980948,
-0.0096129142,
-0.010966138,
0.0641280636,
0.005275174,
-0.0533164479,
-0.0534182079,
0.0581726618,
0.0204239842,
0.0016247118,
-0.0062484071,
0.042747546,
0.0658914894,
-0.0366275571,
0.0279017873,
-0.054492984,
0.0031880906,
-0.0221482497,
0.0610588975,
-0.0433155596,
-0.0291337818,
0.0428970046,
0.0258500203,
-0.0028134356,
0.0074430993,
0.0412998796,
-0.0621236339,
0.0126061374,
-0.0113245845,
-0.0529438592,
-0.0487636477,
-0.0140310032,
0.1172385663,
0.0550832525,
-0.0105845714,
0.0428120121,
-0.0732820183,
-0.072167553,
0.0273438748,
0.0134461056,
0.0038746898,
0.0345493406,
0.0363303013,
0.0648296922,
0.01867388,
-0.0242589526,
-0.0471137837,
0.0016675143,
-0.0327828005,
0.0406982489,
-0.0227636229,
-6.027247367e-33,
0.0145277102,
-0.0531526282,
0.0090917442,
-0.0177304838,
-0.0206241515,
0.0249881092,
0.007577132,
0.0119821718,
0.0350297168,
0.0356838927,
0.0297143832,
-0.0435251743,
-0.0082373228,
0.0088267857,
0.0391850211,
-0.0190806165,
0.0486433543,
0.0264175367,
-0.0243877638,
0.0199349206,
0.053338442,
0.0181875676,
0.0517100692,
-0.0489839949,
0.015837824,
0.0313947164,
-0.018901119,
0.0132818595,
0.0325834788,
0.0681505948,
-0.0260868985,
0.051780615,
0.0456193052,
0.013592355,
0.0098945098,
0.0545597672,
-0.0554154925,
0.00540826,
0.076757744,
-0.0056754784,
-0.0652079955,
0.0205108989,
0.0428138673,
-0.046874769,
-0.0099995425,
-0.0015672292,
0.0664688274,
-0.0290013496,
-0.0083945896,
0.0170359574,
-0.0278315973,
-0.0108364578,
-0.0220024996,
-0.0316805206,
0.0308643915,
-0.004144663,
0.0289955717,
0.0324777588,
-0.0368977524,
0.0768787935,
-0.0915602297,
-0.0488044098,
0.0803595781,
0.0077070636,
0.0121823335,
0.0830871686,
0.0009514344,
-0.0398800932,
-0.0083333757,
0.0253407303,
-0.0015159934,
0.078996554,
-0.0099802427,
0.0987519249,
0.024452826,
-0.0101132682,
-0.024943646,
0.0242355429,
-0.0024886958,
-0.0003126627,
-0.0048685782,
0.0137290377,
0.001996815,
-0.0016322437,
-0.0287819225,
-0.0131503884,
-0.0475026481,
-0.0168379918,
0.0305960402,
0.0116440635,
0.0002090594,
0.0566622801,
0.0459186248,
-0.0383900777,
-0.0475108139,
0.0073342407,
0.021966707,
0.0406228937,
0.020924136,
-0.038304355,
-0.0180892106,
-0.0206545331,
0.0133826621,
-0.0244602878,
-0.0164046567,
-0.0163067561,
0.0361387208,
0.0145458067,
-0.0175607447,
-0.0039182813,
-0.0197385997,
-0.040061824,
-0.0029123724,
-0.0184413306,
0.0484353118,
0.0158613864,
-0.0513741225,
-0.002667685,
-0.0388469063,
-0.0044244481,
0.0241281949,
-0.0767892376,
-0.0072204219,
0.0361785069,
-0.030520441,
-0.0116275363,
-0.0449337922,
-0.0885249972,
0.0310052261,
-0.0705714896,
-0.0261629224,
0.0216774922,
2.778e-7,
0.0224094912,
0.0272269752,
-0.0551276542,
-0.0090828137,
0.0363774635,
0.0759761631,
-0.027201023,
0.0353747457,
-0.009409491,
-0.0653852522,
0.0104929395,
0.028743146,
-0.003578082,
-0.0293186158,
-0.019841034,
0.0352343768,
0.0113301929,
-0.0231590327,
-0.0379876085,
0.0505666211,
0.0276001152,
0.0348031297,
0.0246266611,
-0.0257169977,
0.037144281,
-0.0689536259,
0.0723231509,
-0.0379069,
-0.0088758161,
-0.052164752,
-0.0076041901,
-0.0291942246,
-0.0320360363,
0.0157485213,
-0.0030425976,
-0.0085859783,
0.0137744425,
0.0130713675,
0.0108738523,
-0.0157425757,
-0.0583060347,
0.0167714003,
-0.0339181647,
0.0065769264,
0.0560600013,
-0.0712032095,
-0.036181882,
-0.0568380766,
0.0029000398,
-0.0184207838,
-0.0096698375,
-0.0143201118,
-0.0250800475,
0.0076331315,
0.0035072137,
-0.037987791,
-0.0146069787,
-0.0522381067,
0.0150896786,
0.0211786665,
-0.0187435374,
-0.0494506359,
-0.0308300424,
-0.0014117083,
0.0497918837,
-0.0602790825,
-0.0198624376,
1.806838247e-34,
0.0233702101,
-0.0105484547,
0.0083626332,
-0.0348494165,
0.0196787659,
-0.0214494821,
-0.0223037209,
-0.0276026819,
0.0332269184,
-0.0642590225,
-0.0031249952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05969v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05969v2 | Breaking Symmetry When Training Transformers | 2024-02-06T00:32:28 | 2024-06-16T22:18:36 | Chunsheng Zuo, Michael Guerzhoy | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | As we show in this paper, the prediction for output token $n+1$ of
Transformer architectures without one of the mechanisms of positional encodings
and causal attention is invariant to permutations of input tokens $1, 2, ...,
n-1$. Usually, both mechanisms are employed and the symmetry with respect to
the input tokens is broken. Recently, it has been shown that one can train
Transformers without positional encodings. This must be enabled by the causal
attention mechanism. In this paper, we elaborate on the argument that the
causal connection mechanism must be responsible for the fact that Transformers
are able to model input sequences where the order is important. Vertical
"slices" of Transformers are all encouraged to represent the same location $k$
in the input sequence. We hypothesize that residual connections contribute to
this phenomenon, and demonstrate evidence for this. | [
0.0115995361,
0.0386812426,
-0.0205033757,
0.0228111073,
-0.0136879571,
0.0012933596,
0.0259487834,
-0.0230194293,
-0.067702122,
-0.0407797061,
-0.0161675047,
-0.0313469581,
0.0276079401,
-0.0051185293,
0.0504855774,
-0.0580976456,
0.0530117191,
0.0351183638,
-0.0464756675,
-0.016006114,
-0.045506116,
-0.0615395755,
-0.0137666622,
0.0282924529,
-0.0276992805,
0.0071094814,
-0.0326622911,
-0.0135042276,
0.0001194263,
-0.0302580502,
-0.0157563053,
0.0175397713,
-0.020135412,
0.0169466846,
0.0000017879,
0.0109721515,
0.0032398193,
0.006129662,
-0.0358527526,
-0.013168674,
-0.0482236072,
-0.0092649888,
-0.0388282239,
-0.0189755205,
-0.0100352969,
0.0155521147,
0.1091963872,
0.0925660804,
0.0514230542,
0.0594670437,
-0.0239104908,
-0.0827716812,
0.0327723697,
-0.0541140325,
-0.0073197503,
0.0350251012,
-0.0032622663,
-0.0872651413,
-0.0417829938,
0.0045938459,
-0.066918008,
-0.0088007674,
0.0403910503,
0.0357724167,
-0.0204815436,
0.0181129649,
-0.0181021485,
-0.0319485255,
-0.0334079713,
0.0134912105,
-0.0499718487,
-0.0154385492,
0.0086454339,
0.0111159934,
0.0259383842,
-0.0151163535,
-0.0420953222,
0.0327835754,
-0.0063483142,
0.000940315,
-0.0163141917,
0.0280344822,
0.0111729354,
-0.061173331,
-0.0439261496,
0.0413578749,
0.0225160662,
-0.0292215832,
-0.0678342879,
-0.0042531793,
0.0095394719,
-0.0189568978,
-0.0230124053,
0.0404523276,
-0.007769546,
-0.0022262249,
-0.0073682046,
-0.0367126428,
-0.0140335094,
-0.0226823669,
0.0164528228,
0.0470465459,
-0.0269594025,
-0.0229969732,
-0.0545414463,
0.0902966484,
-0.0702611208,
0.112640515,
-0.0520952679,
0.0417722352,
0.0360631756,
-0.0301394537,
-0.0221961942,
0.0260794163,
-0.0020191253,
-0.0179671273,
-0.0399613865,
0.0552736372,
0.0099179884,
-0.0270236637,
0.0141211608,
0.0196078774,
-0.0701380745,
0.0144542418,
0.0011215482,
0.0432927907,
0.0116029205,
-0.0179335084,
-0.0018708872,
-0.0295687914,
-0.0452738367,
0.0157906543,
0.0071992832,
0.0021386056,
-0.0138655845,
0.1110374108,
-0.004606226,
-0.0288693234,
-0.0166710559,
0.0395660736,
0.0048510274,
0.0062630624,
0.0766930804,
-0.0127790309,
-0.0296608731,
0.0431272462,
0.0014713178,
0.0008894859,
0.0148020163,
0.0210366547,
-0.0122182779,
0.0422142111,
0.0590210035,
-0.0401015356,
-0.0102854148,
-0.0197969973,
-0.0152660329,
0.0254387166,
0.0322086141,
0.0424667411,
-0.0205459204,
-0.0298984535,
0.0417249165,
0.0163288694,
-0.0001544277,
-0.0225555319,
-0.0138039012,
-0.0524728186,
-0.0004933801,
-0.0160554796,
0.0313591808,
0.0298235565,
-0.0247793812,
-0.040296495,
0.0255610365,
0.0446571335,
0.0499671064,
0.0707930103,
0.0088899061,
-0.0559694953,
-0.038336847,
0.0826280415,
-0.0781777054,
0.0714688078,
0.0498518087,
0.0149715142,
-0.0468102321,
0.0241686311,
-0.0253751706,
-0.0201501958,
-0.0159832407,
-0.0036998261,
-0.0259345528,
-0.0516526215,
0.0438243076,
0.0371305086,
-0.0753595307,
0.1117052585,
-0.0231301021,
-0.0491860285,
-0.0404667147,
-0.0449966155,
-0.0226195678,
-0.0200662781,
0.0187118016,
-0.0187024754,
-0.0404880494,
0.0116450312,
-0.0237014554,
0.0174199361,
0.0038435583,
0.0229334105,
-0.019418627,
-0.0061931633,
-0.0365125798,
0.0400097258,
0.0005188097,
0.0485375151,
-0.0239427313,
-0.0261000451,
0.0099528357,
0.0247279555,
0.0253711287,
0.0098959878,
0.0160123929,
-0.0088058393,
-0.0058479756,
0.0396132991,
0.0187952705,
-0.0103172353,
-0.0116787916,
0.0240027327,
0.0828006193,
-0.0235764273,
-0.003764384,
0.0686328709,
-0.0878478736,
0.0183789134,
0.0222851932,
-0.0438651107,
0.0210586973,
0.0840145051,
-0.0116744414,
-0.0686998889,
0.0523674563,
-0.0777461678,
0.0440088212,
0.0005934229,
0.0279783867,
0.0240673181,
0.0400824547,
-0.0230623651,
0.0541680492,
-0.0149842417,
0.0266273133,
-0.0076164058,
-0.002569834,
0.0062472187,
-0.0115566403,
-0.0198226944,
0.016531555,
-0.0416865312,
-0.010534252,
0.0257502291,
-0.066111058,
0.0044292798,
-0.049385976,
-0.0012350648,
-0.0209452733,
-0.0317298397,
0.0499492921,
0.0054047774,
0.0082579423,
0.0404159501,
-0.0411131531,
-0.0344799124,
0.0192297865,
0.0135158952,
0.008403142,
0.0663926452,
-0.0223074611,
-0.0616950169,
0.0151805002,
-0.0382384881,
-0.0146178687,
0.053058777,
-0.0017838784,
-0.0028382121,
-0.0574462339,
-0.0585989952,
0.0380700789,
0.0354790539,
-0.0313971862,
-0.0505231917,
-0.0043445942,
0.013503097,
0.0076929927,
0.0999920815,
0.0530290045,
0.0342014357,
-0.0216012243,
0.0525786094,
0.0130443089,
0.0010747762,
-0.0518912263,
0.0066455388,
-0.0395156853,
0.0031692365,
-0.0169542357,
0.0779799372,
-0.0250665192,
8.226e-7,
-0.0554662682,
-0.0380258746,
0.0365799442,
0.0039688614,
0.020407645,
-0.0550219044,
-0.0574067831,
0.0019365005,
-0.0315118432,
-0.0187750123,
0.0248359591,
-0.0183338579,
-0.0146178911,
-0.0052788015,
0.037043646,
-0.0192330014,
0.0561602339,
0.0552037507,
0.0325562358,
-0.0068705934,
-0.0413093641,
-0.0677965432,
0.0254585072,
0.0081810113,
-0.0107668843,
0.0330677964,
0.0230771303,
-0.0161524657,
-0.0448219851,
-0.051465217,
-0.0667981058,
-0.0124806808,
0.0231614523,
0.0109433066,
0.0484035425,
-0.0558656529,
-0.0705403164,
0.0446097031,
0.0330207609,
0.0526526459,
-0.0247497652,
-0.0011237535,
-0.0224882271,
0.0219611134,
0.0163272042,
0.0332549624,
0.0619634427,
-0.0207283348,
-0.0090973685,
0.0333732106,
0.0226590075,
0.0261098202,
-0.0291947126,
0.0106832767,
0.0250680204,
-0.0399897397,
-0.0150178745,
0.0006390102,
-0.0226271823,
-0.0048467317,
-0.0152956378,
0.0291315224,
0.0034274883,
-0.0546922982,
0.0335928798,
0.023283843,
-0.0201871991,
0.0464923047,
0.0121916775,
-0.0489443839,
0.0159711465,
-0.016648028,
-0.0022269657,
-0.0106059462,
0.0144556835,
-0.001717249,
-0.0703639239,
0.0085560419,
-0.0136706699,
-0.0471549891,
-0.059897691,
-0.0025559834,
-0.0102092829,
-0.0189638846,
0.0277832411,
0.028646199,
-0.0282227471,
-0.042396687,
0.0645042583,
0.0264449809,
-0.0036468497,
-0.0546865612,
-0.0057966993,
-0.0159268714,
0.0609478392,
-0.0132835051,
-0.0201848131,
-0.0637435839,
0.0160313305,
0.0319387652,
0.0573334806,
0.0410347804,
0.0237053521,
0.016824225,
-0.0479613282,
-0.0151385777,
-0.0023583856,
-0.0347524621,
0.0019586461,
-0.076277025,
0.0325648636,
-0.003143691,
-0.0066793459,
-0.0194435753,
-0.0329013057,
-0.0599290654,
-0.0165458284,
0.0075019416,
-0.0074061044,
-0.035670802,
-0.0279614404,
0.0421629176,
-0.0141143128,
-0.0216514729,
0.0087976558,
0.0217410177,
-0.1192004234,
-0.0525608435,
0.0051312707,
-0.0561780259,
0.0777922645,
0.0441935807,
-0.0679597184,
0.0179494713,
-0.0038672376,
-0.0407405719,
-0.0101706963,
0.0405063666,
0.0080053397,
-0.0858264118,
0.0322293602,
0.0473929755,
-0.0531089641,
-0.0340028368,
-0.0373634025,
-0.0643671677,
-0.0408765413,
0.060934715,
0.0703915358,
0.0151056014,
0.0229707249,
0.0127076153,
0.0046606427,
0.0317190774,
0.0664450452,
0.0096849361,
0.0308230557,
0.0515031591,
-0.0679328293,
-0.0178136136,
-0.0017670216,
-0.0193041116,
0.0260221437,
0.0333670788,
0.00560949,
-0.0120862918,
0.0208849162,
0.0338215679,
-0.0025755637,
0.0849634707,
-0.0042894511,
0.0505564101,
0.0396775901,
0.085095197,
-0.0016995972,
0.0030006801,
-0.0185931902,
-0.010510765,
-0.007759342,
0.0314369015,
0.0119895805,
-0.0185821652,
0.045335941,
0.0044536931,
0.0228805784,
0.023509739,
-0.0344974473,
-0.0007442243,
-0.0157162137,
0.0278722886,
0.0101628201,
-0.0062499736,
0.038698867,
0.0483304374,
-0.0091339964,
0.0219765119,
0.0538528711,
0.0502536222,
-0.0624786951,
0.0341915041,
-0.0892164037,
-0.0022454215,
-0.0313252509,
-0.03159054,
0.0567058548,
-0.0139010865,
-0.0001987646,
-0.003346975,
0.0218489245,
0.0019201081,
0.0024731727,
-0.0005123171,
-0.0004456914,
0.0007082274,
0.0146769211,
0.0267424155,
-0.0415171981,
0.0522978306,
-0.0543780699,
0.0271984357,
-0.0602626354,
0.0007927745,
-0.0097449068,
-0.027361542,
0.0126909958,
-0.0248657279,
0.0222924408,
-0.0392719097,
-0.0213987399,
-0.0457341708,
0.0223688614,
-0.0180541035,
0.0760116801,
-0.0432319939,
0.03378243,
0.0362319611,
0.0065334039,
-0.0167284366,
0.0180735309,
-0.0147481663,
0.0404589251,
0.0130237415,
-0.0022103144,
-5.551577333e-33,
-0.0067974953,
-0.0140762692,
0.0081066014,
0.0260888431,
-0.0210074428,
-0.0050343391,
-0.024297053,
-0.0200472064,
-0.0028142333,
-0.0250993464,
-0.0309398007,
0.0000641539,
0.0146657666,
0.0299760494,
0.0316145383,
-0.0334305838,
0.0477688424,
0.0132841617,
-0.0260553621,
-0.0012061376,
0.0433501676,
0.0249015167,
0.0826042891,
0.0234065577,
-0.0427169986,
-0.0058651459,
0.0246167742,
-0.0058704554,
-0.0382974111,
0.038494613,
0.0028281168,
-0.0156391542,
0.0263005961,
-0.0933247879,
-0.008433247,
0.0228806958,
-0.0339624882,
-0.0193030834,
-0.0316937864,
0.0692005679,
0.0119928392,
-0.031081846,
0.0601730756,
0.0076591154,
-0.0302500371,
-0.0098422635,
0.0246374793,
0.0233180448,
-0.043085847,
0.0161189735,
-0.0107752848,
-0.0058640791,
-0.0221790299,
-0.0342589095,
0.0108025633,
0.041278787,
0.0067599793,
0.0026784597,
-0.0225220378,
0.0460899659,
0.0160913989,
0.0579641908,
0.0253957771,
0.0575204268,
0.0121290004,
0.016843576,
0.0629110709,
-0.0085768709,
-0.0450556129,
-0.0354288854,
-0.0120287836,
-0.0012626742,
0.0343751423,
-0.0372536927,
0.0529435128,
-0.024192661,
-0.022257695,
0.0140284486,
-0.0412179604,
0.0619845502,
0.022068277,
0.0082841469,
-0.0172664803,
-0.0085814726,
0.0133251771,
-0.0127171697,
-0.0080913343,
-0.0081887068,
-0.000121063,
0.011804481,
-0.0127536273,
0.0490346588,
0.0311150551,
-0.0376784839,
0.0184502602,
0.039017234,
-0.0034249942,
0.0606004857,
-0.0103346156,
-0.0154789584,
-0.0129026072,
-0.0163995344,
0.0087642316,
0.020387765,
-0.0001661351,
0.0130955381,
0.0446313769,
0.0570095368,
-0.0410192013,
-0.0313783549,
-0.0147366161,
-0.0211737156,
0.0012870157,
0.0105930045,
0.0415272415,
0.0224727653,
-0.0095831649,
0.0220506266,
-0.0210864358,
0.0158793181,
-0.0189873874,
0.0676004216,
-0.0003116274,
0.0248493906,
-0.0045974352,
-0.0067705298,
-0.0436651111,
0.0544272959,
-0.0042593703,
-0.0965405479,
-0.0383982472,
0.0291414075,
2.679e-7,
0.0264270194,
-0.0039484608,
0.0565675311,
0.0173585676,
0.0378577113,
-0.0030000061,
0.0140640177,
0.0588824637,
0.0213163793,
0.0511927269,
0.0114618298,
-0.0154513912,
-0.0239665229,
-0.0224906765,
-0.0665032864,
-0.0021549899,
-0.0851689428,
0.0452409647,
0.0187213682,
0.0200730879,
0.0254882108,
0.070032306,
-0.0363015756,
-0.0008939462,
-0.0162620004,
0.0352132171,
0.0124740414,
0.0443129875,
0.0581284128,
-0.0190812219,
-0.0054687019,
-0.0421740189,
-0.026952751,
0.0317560546,
-0.0132778846,
0.0126584573,
-0.026421193,
-0.036687281,
-0.0290253628,
-0.0609206781,
0.0083053624,
0.0165096931,
0.0024588325,
-0.0044319928,
0.0036092312,
-0.0614044629,
-0.0279640257,
0.0010280149,
-0.0516999178,
0.0394784957,
-0.0254787747,
0.0167301428,
0.0205658954,
0.0183611475,
0.0142006343,
-0.0176894795,
0.0268366076,
-0.0646102428,
-0.0085272063,
-0.0221669879,
-0.0455196984,
-0.0276003424,
-0.0331390835,
-0.0248364955,
0.0604055561,
0.0267489776,
-0.0740102977,
2.168692487e-34,
-0.0149296168,
-0.0267985146,
0.0213911161,
0.0555583276,
-0.0053319163,
-0.0517836623,
0.0545739345,
0.0269245561,
0.0070987269,
-0.0296201725,
-0.0603239462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03597v1 | Identifying Reasons for Contraceptive Switching from Real-World Data Using Large Language Models | 2024-02-06T00:14:53 | 2024-02-06T00:14:53 | Brenda Y. Miao, Christopher YK Williams, Ebenezer Chinedu-Eneh, Travis Zack, Emily Alsentzer, Atul J. Butte, Irene Y. Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Prescription contraceptives play a critical role in supporting women's
reproductive health. With nearly 50 million women in the United States using
contraceptives, understanding the factors that drive contraceptives selection
and switching is of significant interest. However, many factors related to
medication switching are often only captured in unstructured clinical notes and
can be difficult to extract. Here, we evaluate the zero-shot abilities of a
recently developed large language model, GPT-4 (via HIPAA-compliant Microsoft
Azure API), to identify reasons for switching between classes of contraceptives
from the UCSF Information Commons clinical notes dataset. We demonstrate that
GPT-4 can accurately extract reasons for contraceptive switching, outperforming
baseline BERT-based models with microF1 scores of 0.849 and 0.881 for
contraceptive start and stop extraction, respectively. Human evaluation of
GPT-4-extracted reasons for switching showed 91.4% accuracy, with minimal
hallucinations. Using extracted reasons, we identified patient preference,
adverse events, and insurance as key reasons for switching using unsupervised
topic modeling approaches. Notably, we also showed using our approach that
"weight gain/mood change" and "insurance coverage" are disproportionately found
as reasons for contraceptive switching in specific demographic populations. Our
code and supplemental data are available at
https://github.com/BMiao10/contraceptive-switching. | [
0.0271068085,
0.1019311473,
0.0056636375,
-0.0392666161,
-0.0033214856,
0.041458901,
0.0168844797,
-0.0301579535,
0.0208835043,
-0.0222173594,
0.0602504462,
-0.0086972378,
-0.0394339412,
0.0300945044,
-0.0317943208,
-0.0371626914,
0.0023159892,
0.0209405944,
0.0502879843,
0.001397077,
0.0087358523,
0.0148203289,
-0.013140671,
0.0225383323,
0.028431749,
-0.0425992683,
0.0320290737,
0.0036582972,
0.034905456,
-0.070801802,
0.0293776095,
0.0785028487,
0.0135163711,
-0.011796263,
0.0000017721,
-0.0641750693,
-0.04019247,
0.0357671082,
-0.0410975628,
-0.0136825377,
0.0614177175,
-0.0523062162,
-0.000951514,
-0.0174891055,
0.0129674617,
-0.0113217309,
0.027959533,
0.0493266657,
0.0069340053,
0.0533026271,
-0.0267225578,
0.000426007,
-0.0106853452,
-0.0200865921,
0.0567932129,
-0.0508997589,
0.0543789826,
-0.0225658789,
0.0255137198,
0.0057871141,
0.0145587092,
-0.02325093,
-0.0358581655,
0.0040772739,
-0.0189826023,
0.0332855619,
-0.0649769083,
-0.0143566942,
0.0096341176,
0.0557082556,
-0.0002600275,
0.0111784553,
0.0535743348,
-0.001926217,
-0.0281535108,
0.0615202375,
-0.0524286479,
-0.0056148712,
-0.037970297,
0.0327419341,
0.0314770341,
-0.0378649384,
0.0376955606,
0.0044195419,
-0.0048213648,
0.0566258319,
0.0357141905,
-0.0121475076,
0.0305929706,
-0.0162412338,
0.0028940404,
-0.0371955223,
0.0384032466,
-0.0572218858,
0.0071354914,
0.0258166119,
0.0071245395,
-0.0454553217,
0.0580302365,
-0.0674369335,
0.0293401033,
0.0288536102,
-0.0047348998,
0.0013527691,
0.0515626371,
0.0088648899,
0.0000652468,
-0.0203735474,
-0.0242490377,
0.0357930399,
-0.0764647126,
0.0211717617,
-0.0207513329,
-0.0097511774,
-0.0046756347,
-0.0004181047,
-0.0554540977,
0.015080221,
-0.0553080328,
-0.0320137665,
-0.0513376109,
0.0185359772,
0.0095563447,
0.0054312106,
0.0274747722,
0.0330649763,
-0.0060300026,
0.020158479,
0.018633768,
-0.005147737,
0.0488984585,
-0.0108101526,
0.0389846936,
0.0100606661,
0.0019706597,
0.0577294901,
0.0272776876,
-0.0167011973,
-0.052582819,
0.0054678507,
-0.0274236221,
-0.0283948537,
-0.0093462998,
-0.0687497556,
0.0342129357,
0.0066403979,
-0.0268680342,
-0.0303002968,
0.0317358635,
0.0006605641,
-0.0594027899,
0.056111671,
-0.0036775512,
-0.0316078253,
0.032504715,
0.0098454747,
0.0296049137,
0.0818719491,
0.0222597197,
-0.0059928326,
0.0244694445,
-0.0505714156,
-0.01361656,
0.0042177858,
0.0062023089,
0.00626464,
0.0105614671,
0.0064764842,
0.0182265323,
0.0307800565,
-0.01583983,
0.0010634058,
-0.0342017896,
-0.0094818631,
0.0313088708,
0.0592933856,
-0.0114809144,
0.0436895415,
0.0124505898,
0.0075991061,
-0.051964093,
-0.0124409143,
0.0118632372,
-0.0181802846,
0.0129421111,
-0.0223423745,
0.0280900653,
-0.0414513685,
-0.0238452554,
-0.0177324302,
-0.0357710794,
-0.0266629122,
-0.0592758693,
-0.0317635089,
0.0358690545,
-0.0236509591,
0.0135982204,
0.0980493426,
0.0509724356,
-0.0219625924,
-0.0449138507,
-0.0225654021,
0.025566319,
0.0831910521,
0.0062075332,
-0.0434892178,
-0.0479356125,
-0.0113011319,
-0.0094562108,
-0.0050045,
0.0190762319,
-0.0323635451,
-0.0116028013,
-0.0343846567,
0.0105486987,
0.0291496608,
0.0463077649,
0.0080346223,
-0.0290139616,
0.0185483098,
-0.0209945645,
-0.0472702533,
-0.0158809535,
0.0267575625,
-0.0024153292,
-0.0564137995,
0.0341044478,
-0.017396763,
0.0611165203,
0.0169373397,
-0.0006211274,
0.0360273533,
0.0228791963,
-0.0403115638,
0.0243976284,
0.0051471749,
0.0510826036,
-0.0355597064,
-0.0158210043,
-0.057812687,
-0.001563644,
-0.0033410424,
-0.0552691706,
-0.0327917933,
0.0239172,
-0.079038389,
0.0247715972,
0.0043093809,
-0.0105751613,
0.0160432551,
0.0205668453,
-0.0347196236,
-0.0019621416,
-0.020658059,
0.0323519558,
0.0203390699,
-0.0863279551,
0.0076177162,
-0.0337342843,
0.0376251787,
0.0358207636,
0.0370918959,
0.0121195186,
0.0202327017,
-0.0178960264,
-0.031294439,
-0.0489598885,
-0.0848456249,
-0.0089509143,
0.0017606346,
0.0146447392,
0.0119248508,
-0.0084786862,
0.0039804354,
-0.0022917027,
-0.0182350967,
0.0026210551,
-0.02234089,
0.0563697554,
0.0042410512,
0.0150791323,
0.0059130774,
-0.0320630372,
-0.0302158277,
-0.0510452725,
0.0552438833,
-0.00213526,
0.0129201878,
-0.0194289368,
-0.0408103243,
-0.0131700775,
-0.0187334027,
-0.000651107,
0.0073201666,
-0.0007431495,
-0.0141724488,
0.0761498287,
0.036800459,
-0.0237489808,
0.04543126,
0.0327209495,
-0.0277921185,
-0.0408163965,
-0.0142151546,
-0.0305263698,
0.0014328915,
0.0132001946,
-0.055694133,
-0.0036430883,
0.0608919971,
0.004994052,
-0.0062814206,
0.0152400257,
-0.015218514,
-0.0255396646,
0.0124608651,
-0.029849181,
0.0515078194,
0.0010573248,
0.0631713495,
0.0182172358,
-0.024406651,
0.043083325,
0.0160857923,
0.029846862,
-0.0722969919,
-0.0187038723,
-0.022415353,
-0.0650132596,
0.0110566439,
0.0064190081,
0.023954425,
-0.0039728582,
0.0410925001,
-0.0359117091,
-0.0183666963,
-0.027231073,
0.0814376622,
-0.0672527701,
0.0571196005,
0.0535098054,
-0.0392964855,
-0.017956974,
-0.0940039605,
-0.0169234388,
-0.0128456056,
0.0170938019,
-0.0138113275,
-0.0618534423,
0.0283370949,
-0.0251315776,
0.0628395379,
0.0165964738,
-0.0220852494,
0.0375527479,
-0.010539378,
0.0697408095,
-0.0749191716,
-0.019520361,
-0.0269447137,
0.0136530725,
0.0379852541,
0.0530270115,
0.0277241934,
-0.0312683843,
0.0345530547,
0.0025875187,
-0.0601844527,
-0.0254519992,
0.0041424977,
-0.0255884584,
-0.0739892498,
-0.0005482152,
0.0913559943,
0.0070582703,
-0.0454148315,
0.0200103056,
-0.0162218772,
-0.0117617166,
-0.0051789987,
0.0065676346,
-0.0601082817,
-0.0186331682,
-0.006406399,
0.0323583297,
-0.0216052998,
-0.0299046803,
-0.0072326274,
-0.0437803604,
-0.0010387306,
0.0183791071,
-0.0212032925,
-0.0127965054,
-0.0504905619,
0.0267818421,
-0.0453890972,
-0.0457374938,
-0.0322017558,
0.0206997991,
0.0008594362,
0.0065921149,
-0.090197064,
-0.0459613353,
0.0654659495,
0.0056143119,
0.0398535728,
0.0528499112,
0.0448329635,
-0.0197686907,
-0.0403986536,
0.0323675387,
-0.0204315335,
-0.0903745294,
0.0170005485,
0.0809761584,
0.0034795492,
-0.0055740802,
-0.0681914762,
0.0681411102,
-0.0474021174,
-0.0459975898,
-0.0307134185,
0.0471105836,
-0.0366516262,
-0.0582196638,
-0.0419813357,
0.0590967499,
0.0286431033,
0.0247431528,
0.0074930517,
-0.0406107605,
0.0108139366,
-0.0128619224,
-0.0112277437,
0.0081577627,
0.0218257792,
-0.0023428637,
0.002414234,
-0.063742049,
-0.0183732305,
-0.0082335938,
0.0308276545,
-0.0353458598,
-0.0016928965,
-0.0205984805,
0.076122582,
-0.0140297925,
-0.0467316881,
0.0459463783,
0.038666036,
-0.0172175225,
0.0096178893,
-0.0676314011,
0.0118508376,
0.0385069996,
-0.0084259622,
0.0133194169,
-0.0414626785,
-0.0282134395,
0.0069050291,
0.0057155634,
0.0240071248,
0.0006308163,
-0.0142507777,
0.010312004,
-0.0028819144,
0.0659532025,
0.0343966559,
-0.0485344678,
0.0182294063,
0.0705576837,
0.0035765402,
0.0122509794,
-0.0036163067,
0.00274069,
-0.0252793971,
-0.0202962216,
-0.0444144607,
0.0277975313,
0.0038782042,
0.0043596285,
0.0199550111,
0.0031295009,
0.0322928913,
-0.0577583872,
-0.0055516926,
-0.0144041302,
-0.008912337,
-0.0201732218,
-0.0334345177,
-0.0044319248,
-0.0219331328,
-0.0603170209,
-0.0073505822,
-0.0812167004,
-0.046413172,
-0.0320376009,
0.0393184125,
-0.0064080064,
0.0431666411,
0.0241694413,
-0.0353578366,
-0.0108597334,
0.0227407143,
-0.0045474814,
0.0455295891,
-0.0489168204,
0.1066236496,
0.0005198825,
0.0071387417,
0.0168143865,
0.0313113257,
-0.0279076751,
-0.0723396018,
0.0040398543,
0.0152752688,
0.0164184719,
-0.070880495,
0.0774963424,
-0.0104255229,
-0.0246920995,
-0.0501347072,
0.0153805995,
0.0207723901,
0.0207558274,
0.0555290207,
0.029627014,
-0.0413310006,
-0.0420021117,
0.076560609,
0.0376249254,
0.0482713059,
0.013180282,
-0.0097033242,
-0.0473526418,
0.005694936,
0.0025191566,
0.020776486,
-0.0598080717,
0.0248671863,
-0.0784775093,
-0.0084617287,
0.0287393481,
-0.0378484614,
0.0184810795,
0.0036039564,
0.0284312908,
0.0557309873,
-0.0203126725,
-0.0251059271,
-0.0353551246,
0.026347369,
-0.0223034676,
-0.0294864401,
-0.0147730783,
-5.094214522e-33,
0.001698334,
-0.0169068985,
-0.0234264657,
-0.0057219644,
0.0396415852,
-0.014642288,
-0.0473523438,
0.0005649659,
0.0458719432,
0.0654798672,
0.0274896175,
0.0347539112,
0.0120391715,
0.028918203,
0.032030873,
-0.0182119198,
0.01661692,
0.0059763337,
0.0031475928,
0.0538715683,
0.019762557,
0.0745170265,
0.0022642759,
-0.0852961913,
0.078124471,
-0.0047500706,
0.0459945984,
-0.0145361479,
-0.0161503665,
0.0506018996,
-0.0326102711,
0.0518414825,
0.0223714206,
-0.0334203243,
0.0069883908,
0.0332147218,
-0.0287798624,
-0.0623757243,
0.0077082301,
-0.0490189493,
0.0042723757,
-0.0591602959,
0.0170997698,
0.0054976097,
-0.0166199841,
-0.0187220313,
0.0460676439,
-0.0377782248,
-0.0147376154,
-0.0006791903,
-0.0354483612,
0.0340674892,
-0.0483858734,
0.0110635897,
-0.0206482001,
0.0563478582,
-0.0663020834,
0.0653452426,
0.0041985912,
0.0134672169,
0.0242822878,
0.0203135181,
-0.0071758321,
-0.0632225201,
0.0337020233,
0.0624147281,
-0.0072634942,
0.0036643213,
0.0098508094,
-0.0018623011,
-0.0413864888,
0.05124126,
0.0259448104,
-0.0251878556,
0.0578177087,
0.0123867281,
-0.0919649899,
-0.0161717273,
-0.0647062585,
-0.009482977,
0.0513316467,
0.0048271422,
-0.030555455,
-0.0174061935,
-0.0300858095,
-0.045566909,
-0.0294428468,
0.0156200733,
0.0038015458,
-0.0194052961,
0.0080576874,
0.0386156105,
-0.019144997,
-0.0213411991,
-0.0344058275,
-0.0324242711,
0.0247500557,
-0.0272600185,
0.0149914511,
0.0216693971,
-0.0669259503,
-0.0055853245,
-0.0189185385,
0.0050473181,
0.0351790451,
0.0507018976,
0.0154784517,
-0.0320458673,
-0.051335413,
-0.0560169592,
-0.0080670919,
-0.0029170704,
-0.0073637618,
0.02494663,
-0.0068907482,
0.0147761041,
0.0256622136,
0.0951561853,
0.0602044873,
0.0215984918,
-0.0116085429,
-0.0506900847,
-0.0134142097,
0.0231612734,
-0.0268072616,
0.0013545186,
-0.0122993505,
0.0416543856,
0.0359391533,
-0.0276775043,
0.0180544201,
-0.0275232717,
2.48e-7,
0.0940496027,
0.0718420073,
0.0011361999,
-0.0268707406,
0.0457586311,
0.0291645788,
-0.0240725148,
-0.0005948554,
0.015810905,
0.0103827631,
0.0287577398,
-0.0190901402,
0.0313445367,
0.0342464,
-0.0288643725,
0.0124670379,
-0.0297228396,
-0.0571661666,
-0.0674778074,
-0.0070384373,
0.0413921699,
0.0891841426,
0.0149369827,
-0.0172384456,
0.0350087732,
0.0381995998,
0.0446876176,
-0.0394897051,
-0.0050823879,
0.0295195542,
0.0064442088,
-0.0074029285,
-0.0298536904,
0.0232167207,
-0.0236686543,
-0.038567014,
-0.0114967963,
0.1036500707,
-0.0455708764,
-0.0038757855,
0.0156724788,
-0.037713632,
0.0078465389,
-0.0229629166,
0.0742363557,
-0.0481913723,
-0.0760433078,
-0.0350782312,
-0.0236261897,
-0.0340447761,
0.0643013716,
-0.0244126376,
-0.0281483885,
0.0465758294,
0.0183253214,
0.0362078771,
-0.004426525,
-0.0433721133,
-0.0063202647,
0.08297012,
-0.0455600172,
-0.0317917131,
0.014663212,
-0.009166169,
0.001438671,
-0.0431491956,
0.0210558753,
1.871363359e-34,
0.0432728641,
0.0585141219,
-0.0190227255,
-0.0113208229,
0.0219440218,
0.020593958,
0.0229839291,
0.0143250106,
0.0046935799,
-0.0618050359,
0.0162547845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05132v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05132v2 | TexShape: Information Theoretic Sentence Embedding for Language Models | 2024-02-05T22:48:28 | 2024-05-11T20:03:26 | Kaan Kale, Homa Esfahanizadeh, Noel Elias, Oguzhan Baser, Muriel Medard, Sriram Vishwanath | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT | With the exponential growth in data volume and the emergence of
data-intensive applications, particularly in the field of machine learning,
concerns related to resource utilization, privacy, and fairness have become
paramount. This paper focuses on the textual domain of data and addresses
challenges regarding encoding sentences to their optimized representations
through the lens of information-theory. In particular, we use empirical
estimates of mutual information, using the Donsker-Varadhan definition of
Kullback-Leibler divergence. Our approach leverages this estimation to train an
information-theoretic sentence embedding, called TexShape, for (task-based)
data compression or for filtering out sensitive information, enhancing privacy
and fairness. In this study, we employ a benchmark language model for initial
text representation, complemented by neural networks for information-theoretic
compression and mutual information estimations. Our experiments demonstrate
significant advancements in preserving maximal targeted information and minimal
sensitive information over adverse compression ratios, in terms of predictive
accuracy of downstream models that are trained using the compressed data. | [
0.0118091824,
0.0879480764,
-0.0229290109,
0.0444112942,
-0.0893006101,
0.0145425871,
-0.0050164093,
0.0117612183,
-0.0413464271,
-0.0528648868,
0.0005661387,
-0.0136490697,
0.0029372515,
-0.0343584567,
0.0392458513,
0.0095781647,
0.0230961181,
0.011293727,
0.0383761413,
-0.0230222363,
-0.0149733154,
-0.0234795548,
0.0482665673,
0.043694973,
-0.0275790002,
-0.0241308492,
0.0056677423,
0.0030708245,
-0.0070303162,
0.0175562724,
0.0127714798,
0.0358498059,
0.0459432416,
0.0438720621,
0.0000019416,
-0.0202979967,
-0.0272135977,
0.0337555259,
-0.0446807854,
0.0332507715,
0.0164623521,
-0.0694278181,
0.0254454929,
0.0022031711,
-0.0275998469,
-0.0009808688,
0.0295793638,
0.06469246,
0.0682461709,
0.0865721703,
-0.0253507383,
-0.0213292036,
0.0098885726,
-0.0505059958,
0.0231752209,
-0.0014447488,
0.0265603662,
-0.0213120766,
-0.0592219718,
0.0255734008,
-0.0214423928,
0.0516740978,
0.0374442339,
0.0153478319,
0.0187057406,
0.0021445297,
0.0129914964,
-0.0203347653,
-0.0104147363,
0.0484986342,
0.0126127424,
-0.0266375076,
-0.0254010055,
-0.0269115232,
0.0266826469,
-0.0094369911,
-0.030260399,
0.0199195929,
0.0283259079,
0.0265369602,
0.0236058589,
0.0296988487,
0.0427239537,
-0.0083735809,
0.0129850991,
0.0152986934,
-0.0090979272,
-0.046442762,
-0.0167372674,
-0.0082124658,
-0.0366003104,
0.0075659668,
0.0289504416,
-0.0109862965,
0.0564732477,
-0.0109176021,
-0.0756999254,
-0.0999289006,
0.0335125066,
-0.0730676353,
0.0279815067,
-0.0033859406,
0.0541190878,
0.0353572108,
0.0017481672,
0.0881732106,
0.0117461421,
0.0089764539,
-0.0200739373,
0.0062941373,
-0.0265872385,
-0.0152862584,
0.0081568938,
0.0696307495,
-0.0441060178,
-0.018474333,
-0.0131915109,
0.036600586,
-0.0240481477,
0.0464681387,
0.004363039,
0.0012625277,
-0.0236525796,
0.034261588,
-0.0067851096,
-0.050936196,
-0.0243438762,
0.0213013142,
0.0014908698,
-0.0436443053,
-0.0277039595,
0.0102173667,
0.0120700235,
-0.0117194001,
-0.0123810936,
0.0308900177,
0.0146310935,
-0.0280932933,
-0.0030924177,
-0.0630734786,
0.011788737,
-0.0366838388,
0.021956455,
-0.0444083586,
0.0568192713,
-0.0295551904,
-0.0058707767,
-0.0616123714,
-0.030680716,
0.0189275425,
-0.0646148622,
0.0727074072,
0.0032999734,
-0.0266818758,
-0.011137207,
0.0129795233,
0.0612415224,
0.0671313107,
0.0400842316,
0.0192063972,
0.0559817404,
0.0008338626,
-0.0043854853,
-0.0036666724,
0.0414917916,
-0.0076959017,
-0.0187315717,
0.0110911326,
-0.002557345,
0.0003352935,
0.0023148276,
0.0701795965,
-0.0216269325,
-0.04180694,
0.0637694746,
0.0691718683,
0.0305105038,
0.0020121404,
0.0016712063,
0.04443077,
-0.0241564158,
0.0285320729,
-0.0235506352,
-0.0122451922,
-0.0238894764,
-0.01082006,
0.0327749774,
-0.0057506496,
-0.0248649586,
-0.0491812006,
-0.0001627226,
-0.0705441386,
0.0326229818,
-0.0157098342,
0.0067003709,
-0.0093761608,
-0.0128582567,
0.0282392446,
0.0045936112,
-0.0334984697,
-0.0102788005,
-0.0094218617,
-0.015543255,
0.0499541461,
0.0489150435,
-0.0422922485,
0.0288971122,
-0.049999211,
-0.0274508428,
0.0029124697,
0.0241091289,
-0.0000325731,
0.0607413426,
-0.0547556654,
-0.0421781838,
-0.0319047719,
0.0351596102,
-0.0282852445,
-0.0206979383,
0.0006647682,
0.0428859405,
-0.0582293533,
0.0015224055,
0.0554592088,
-0.0156898685,
-0.0503574722,
0.0212742146,
0.0197259337,
0.0468950383,
0.0246092156,
-0.0516957864,
0.0244371947,
0.050234545,
-0.0528802834,
-0.0211561527,
-0.0208121613,
-0.0373693556,
-0.060444884,
0.0008231773,
-0.0602589361,
0.0520981997,
0.08693932,
-0.0189643726,
-0.0344301052,
0.003404811,
-0.0589953549,
0.0350603126,
-0.0452464856,
-0.0048445761,
-0.0072593899,
0.0275464728,
-0.0541445985,
0.0263469946,
-0.0543811694,
0.0187982284,
-0.0538041294,
-0.0470234491,
0.0184210595,
-0.0219714716,
-0.0099760909,
-0.0081177978,
-0.0232158862,
0.0188960433,
0.0465497524,
-0.006942031,
0.0558525473,
-0.0185477473,
-0.0363195203,
-0.0113646667,
-0.0096466038,
0.033284694,
0.0097169345,
0.0072051184,
0.0264543276,
-0.0111678168,
-0.0444956161,
0.0017429745,
-0.0112683158,
0.018992668,
0.0452977195,
0.010673983,
-0.0126890326,
-0.021856375,
-0.0557842515,
-0.0215896908,
0.0803297237,
-0.0213139188,
-0.0488480069,
-0.0097328695,
0.0122499149,
-0.0087894779,
0.0189012662,
-0.0166062713,
-0.0362033807,
-0.034693107,
-0.0007448525,
0.0071968283,
0.0502459183,
0.0173971076,
0.0503028519,
0.0574001297,
0.0368367657,
-0.0412408225,
0.0188061818,
-0.0251767207,
0.0411177278,
-0.0371988751,
-0.0592002645,
0.0576958321,
0.0560065918,
0.0173480809,
-0.0271342695,
-0.0620257072,
0.0060637686,
-0.0106188338,
-0.0521678068,
-0.0332970135,
-0.0482806414,
0.0251370613,
0.010774157,
-0.0203871708,
-0.0446671098,
0.0651793554,
-0.0489081815,
0.0396329612,
-0.0281051695,
-0.0281258915,
-0.0086641023,
0.0332423821,
0.0485364646,
0.0434588455,
0.0653487071,
-0.0031415338,
-0.0217824429,
0.0345677026,
0.0640428364,
-0.0299784075,
-0.0166440345,
0.0050665722,
-0.0146895796,
-0.0147338919,
-0.0489693582,
-0.0101136472,
-0.1246022359,
0.0272476617,
0.0115611227,
0.0577353798,
-0.0271042492,
-0.0261977091,
-0.0227822475,
0.036798276,
0.0067330902,
0.0189214014,
-0.005303768,
-0.0251192059,
0.0223425757,
0.0314032286,
-0.0125887757,
0.0273571182,
-0.0130547443,
0.0232177004,
0.0522044972,
0.0168484133,
0.0713872612,
0.040853925,
0.0056590759,
0.0236809999,
-0.0124659389,
-0.0711998716,
0.0266895052,
0.0411428213,
-0.0030814412,
0.0114411274,
0.0967816487,
0.0190774389,
-0.0577688143,
-0.0031152507,
0.0239618681,
0.0089259977,
0.002462863,
-0.0178983249,
-0.1057643145,
-0.0108383577,
0.0277952999,
0.0088709947,
-0.0344063826,
-0.0414074361,
-0.0107158348,
-0.0575600229,
-0.0241335705,
0.0126742674,
0.0288260467,
-0.0668231621,
-0.0582065433,
-0.0132222939,
0.0142615568,
0.0023308916,
-0.0539251715,
0.0013496268,
-0.021543581,
0.0183150489,
-0.0212448481,
-0.0545347445,
-0.0313555747,
-0.0368019864,
0.0278268047,
0.0533837713,
0.0399476886,
-0.0040809326,
-0.0255118161,
-0.0361863114,
-0.0168281011,
-0.0263202991,
0.0214997008,
0.0654330254,
-0.017345788,
0.015629122,
-0.0162104033,
0.0298823267,
-0.0090480158,
0.001738559,
-0.0134215439,
0.0473042987,
-0.0232113749,
-0.0217597671,
-0.0089319516,
-0.0399601124,
0.0045407936,
0.0961513519,
0.0339769274,
-0.0209822394,
-0.0146185802,
-0.0287248828,
0.0734650642,
-0.0169094428,
0.0331005827,
0.0224091634,
0.0316252038,
-0.0665007234,
-0.0790982321,
-0.0196467508,
-0.0279762819,
0.014586607,
0.0037631551,
0.0047977804,
0.0228017606,
-0.0199877843,
-0.0775252953,
-0.0350277945,
-0.0204283912,
-0.0130069098,
-0.0147524662,
0.0362712182,
-0.0222118031,
0.0057251793,
-0.0326201692,
0.0160693917,
-0.0810007304,
-0.0804954395,
-0.0214937888,
0.0457836874,
0.0095833242,
0.0413246192,
-0.0375386849,
-0.0653530657,
0.0950235799,
0.0642584115,
-0.0754686892,
0.0385499522,
0.0777349249,
-0.0608267337,
0.0256870836,
0.0561743565,
-0.0467367209,
-0.0184662174,
0.0089318296,
-0.0128624178,
-0.0129178008,
-0.0636137128,
0.0057306373,
0.0439029299,
-0.0003852519,
-0.0052692336,
-0.0124625508,
-0.0057807933,
-0.0021959054,
-0.0324916728,
-0.0013047009,
-0.0478960387,
-0.0107360305,
0.0366169512,
0.029538516,
0.0024742051,
0.0582020581,
0.0730682239,
-0.0007396807,
-0.0755244642,
0.0007850492,
0.0119092828,
0.0014282058,
0.007533323,
0.0248261392,
-0.0288385656,
-0.0015907667,
-0.0139003014,
-0.0111364704,
-0.030520035,
-0.0010693772,
0.0065993099,
0.0253458321,
-0.0494705103,
0.0490400232,
-0.0702024996,
-0.0009279065,
-0.0140607366,
-0.0034584771,
0.0307642426,
-0.001788752,
0.0125425523,
-0.0398492254,
-0.0072566476,
-0.0112907076,
0.0400230363,
0.0147874001,
-0.0074310638,
0.0240949672,
0.0159659926,
-0.0426879078,
0.0074798572,
0.1073684171,
0.0347886235,
0.022585243,
-0.0279227383,
-0.0371918306,
-0.067169629,
0.0081492737,
0.0148011884,
0.099669084,
-0.0051995786,
-0.0038391654,
-0.0157002956,
-0.0642853156,
0.0036089672,
0.0122610796,
0.0135575952,
0.0050452435,
0.0119804172,
0.0216396786,
0.007152738,
-0.0325666629,
-0.042972751,
-0.0124421781,
-0.012836528,
-0.0225388333,
-0.0004203891,
-6.030684586e-33,
0.0035411513,
0.0497857854,
-0.0593480878,
0.0214652903,
0.0064441534,
0.0522024482,
0.0075682481,
-0.0370040946,
-0.0408024117,
0.0124118775,
-0.0285891518,
0.0256782547,
-0.0051429421,
0.0233481061,
-0.0246457625,
-0.0096473955,
0.0606205054,
-0.0359433666,
0.0038525374,
0.0076674097,
0.0040712496,
0.0255590193,
0.0563168861,
-0.0526667796,
0.0287983157,
-0.0034498102,
-0.0063823825,
0.0217174422,
-0.0067952112,
0.0402607806,
-0.0491555892,
0.0279888771,
0.0300918464,
-0.0471588075,
-0.0096302917,
0.0518379211,
-0.0613343194,
-0.0432222746,
-0.0015017559,
-0.0040115663,
-0.0098185437,
-0.0662467107,
0.0524454825,
-0.0180631895,
0.0116829099,
-0.0044880472,
0.0268534534,
0.0103083635,
-0.0098696714,
-0.0387357101,
-0.009697983,
0.0011811535,
-0.0353240296,
0.004708136,
0.086041294,
0.0430084951,
0.0147816725,
0.0094817206,
-0.0516377278,
-0.0010703136,
-0.0017733002,
0.032089591,
0.0129355406,
-0.022083113,
0.0429726429,
0.0704129562,
0.0269362368,
0.0088715851,
-0.024491176,
-0.0054748012,
0.0240730718,
-0.0082545616,
0.0113322549,
0.0574793257,
0.0231476203,
-0.0448476076,
-0.092472434,
0.0111660408,
0.0428540967,
-0.008415442,
0.044090569,
0.0204079635,
-0.0803930685,
-0.0360004753,
-0.0435450673,
-0.0129495542,
-0.0060670851,
0.0097772796,
-0.00229103,
0.0329577364,
-0.0105887828,
-0.0132211633,
0.0238378234,
-0.0571292304,
-0.006985106,
0.0679124668,
0.0171594396,
0.0036502359,
0.0193544459,
0.0108080739,
-0.0610032566,
0.0035547132,
0.0054563181,
-0.0073291091,
0.0319168977,
-0.0043538748,
0.0647108629,
0.0147267841,
-0.0419399664,
-0.0416058749,
-0.0292813256,
-0.0166145768,
0.0341144353,
-0.0252521299,
0.0505127981,
0.0347790159,
-0.0120457495,
-0.0018080994,
0.032710731,
0.0183760822,
0.0151838195,
-0.0415642932,
0.0114164213,
0.0104111247,
0.0175132435,
-0.0534533709,
-0.0446821749,
0.0078863893,
0.0646167547,
-0.0364624225,
-0.004177744,
-0.005557619,
2.716e-7,
0.0202673022,
0.0060009258,
-0.0023709973,
0.009177682,
0.016813172,
0.0542821512,
0.0226200316,
0.0551970936,
-0.0308164377,
-0.0203288496,
0.0047646491,
0.0104502104,
0.0322242826,
0.0079811858,
-0.0879774988,
-0.0153009575,
-0.042513866,
-0.0136960279,
-0.0220479425,
0.0173128024,
0.0482750088,
0.1281342357,
0.0417089351,
0.0195294768,
0.0098285992,
-0.0321112424,
0.0239648167,
-0.0841213539,
-0.0251816828,
0.00539312,
0.0751317516,
0.0167219229,
0.0124428971,
0.0402008593,
-0.0245051607,
0.0305955857,
-0.0325850472,
0.0507760458,
0.0128766187,
0.0025753495,
-0.0038483401,
-0.0216754191,
-0.0406896733,
-0.0124371769,
0.0774439126,
0.0212743562,
-0.0468162,
0.0047853594,
0.0065908101,
-0.0315122604,
0.0460284352,
0.0074979188,
-0.0021758282,
-0.0112549635,
0.0136434203,
0.0077061029,
0.0279882103,
-0.0650331005,
-0.0223407857,
0.011834681,
-0.0345549509,
0.0105843004,
-0.0307448003,
0.0047778995,
0.0598415695,
-0.0511030592,
0.0449837334,
2.798567589e-34,
-0.0179862436,
-0.0047698701,
0.0190534145,
0.0248568393,
0.0096406741,
-0.0211930517,
-0.0144254407,
0.0037289592,
0.0292083286,
-0.0961886868,
0.0006938523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05131v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05131v3 | Financial Report Chunking for Effective Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-02-05T22:35:42 | 2024-03-16T09:08:26 | Antonio Jimeno Yepes, Yao You, Jan Milczek, Sebastian Laverde, Renyu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chunking information is a key step in Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG).
Current research primarily centers on paragraph-level chunking. This approach
treats all texts as equal and neglects the information contained in the
structure of documents. We propose an expanded approach to chunk documents by
moving beyond mere paragraph-level chunking to chunk primary by structural
element components of documents. Dissecting documents into these constituent
elements creates a new way to chunk documents that yields the best chunk size
without tuning. We introduce a novel framework that evaluates how chunking
based on element types annotated by document understanding models contributes
to the overall context and accuracy of the information retrieved. We also
demonstrate how this approach impacts RAG assisted Question & Answer task
performance. Our research includes a comprehensive analysis of various element
types, their role in effective information retrieval, and the impact they have
on the quality of RAG outputs. Findings support that element type based
chunking largely improve RAG results on financial reporting. Through this
research, we are also able to answer how to uncover highly accurate RAG. | [
0.0235929172,
-0.0001773039,
0.0028216008,
0.0055563417,
0.0218859613,
0.0060444637,
-0.0049903113,
0.0380296409,
-0.0079142982,
-0.0479443818,
-0.0254210662,
-0.0353691578,
-0.0130876582,
0.0277833287,
0.0299922153,
-0.058359541,
0.0365593806,
0.0191411953,
0.0240458865,
0.0418742374,
0.079599306,
-0.0047183232,
0.0091500189,
0.0030651318,
0.0037308275,
-0.0138314674,
-0.0262819156,
0.0094097937,
-0.0058974614,
-0.0167034045,
-0.0052062823,
0.0219347887,
0.0315062702,
0.0262908489,
0.0000017349,
-0.0351558439,
-0.0580106936,
0.0285628978,
-0.0318957642,
0.0041071516,
0.0352310799,
-0.0107374433,
0.0440495349,
0.024110483,
-0.0320619009,
-0.0047695818,
0.0034471226,
0.0728134289,
0.0590437613,
0.0684197396,
-0.0071722809,
-0.0148176551,
0.0163678471,
-0.0247088987,
0.0833172053,
-0.0542540923,
-0.0250518527,
0.0322442167,
0.0336572491,
0.0277411342,
0.012914204,
0.0191173293,
0.0052949074,
-0.031679552,
0.0542976074,
0.0113956239,
-0.077722542,
-0.0139235463,
0.0039163749,
0.0470766537,
0.0682394579,
0.0183192994,
0.0201982129,
-0.0163517632,
0.0396870263,
0.0211429261,
-0.0710115433,
0.0256669242,
-0.0396905616,
-0.0250333659,
0.0123723773,
0.0272788033,
-0.0124897175,
0.0106005548,
-0.0236776061,
0.0085369488,
-0.0330460072,
-0.0394896939,
-0.006870144,
0.0259533897,
-0.0073085278,
-0.0233816709,
0.0240475107,
0.0409277864,
0.0146769928,
0.0208342578,
-0.0369001739,
-0.0676244944,
0.0340232477,
-0.0251855105,
-0.0037633826,
0.0303710196,
-0.012407585,
0.0336110406,
-0.0426262207,
0.0279324371,
0.0085925441,
-0.0553301983,
-0.0402279384,
0.0302359797,
-0.0470849462,
-0.0357686877,
-0.0549413748,
0.0738428831,
-0.0649212003,
-0.0373708084,
0.0075171278,
0.0358729474,
0.0020245595,
0.0149154412,
0.0116088791,
0.0056875441,
-0.0376139991,
-0.0106276805,
-0.0192540661,
0.0140135391,
-0.0576900318,
-0.0021811835,
0.0493862815,
-0.0494804047,
0.0192758217,
0.0238950346,
0.0156311449,
-0.0155037502,
-0.021231845,
0.0147450073,
-0.0120394835,
-0.0143954707,
-0.0360066034,
-0.0918315277,
0.0204257071,
-0.0066505102,
0.0023891316,
-0.0320928544,
0.0360411517,
0.0169069543,
-0.0484273098,
0.0426716432,
0.0122059975,
0.0344209746,
-0.0215535145,
0.0381914452,
-0.0050337445,
-0.0058043865,
0.0253366176,
0.0060349302,
0.0347878896,
0.059496332,
0.0236114878,
0.0330523401,
0.0463881604,
0.0252230782,
0.0027432905,
0.0102174059,
0.0186644383,
-0.0434247777,
0.0269029923,
0.0518584922,
-0.0102766184,
0.0008312927,
0.0148333386,
0.0295395777,
-0.0469292589,
0.0228198916,
0.0290126838,
0.013085302,
0.0664000288,
0.0230256915,
0.0180508252,
0.0405050479,
0.0312383864,
0.0513176657,
0.017596405,
0.0192944836,
-0.0056512454,
0.0650930628,
0.0463676006,
-0.0052695666,
-0.024451809,
-0.0378699191,
-0.0292377267,
0.0430441648,
-0.0376604758,
-0.0073062414,
0.0084713958,
0.0373575836,
-0.0578673072,
0.0349695086,
-0.0128989639,
-0.0800836906,
0.0389107801,
-0.0052657542,
0.0621144362,
0.0575235821,
0.0917844176,
-0.0538484342,
-0.0106190443,
0.0010641823,
0.0141615868,
0.0195220578,
0.0457093939,
-0.0247389153,
-0.0323691182,
-0.0846822411,
-0.0156008303,
-0.0137183061,
-0.0088801784,
0.000095754,
0.0128456522,
-0.0087740729,
0.0424919091,
-0.0553071983,
-0.0255553685,
0.0308140256,
-0.0115437564,
-0.052192539,
0.0003555826,
-0.0011729976,
-0.0392869264,
0.0229207054,
-0.0131761376,
0.0453097969,
-0.0005106006,
0.0049703042,
0.008410533,
0.0038631917,
-0.0313239768,
-0.0231229886,
-0.0557948723,
-0.0207008924,
0.0340269022,
-0.0391759314,
-0.0287663415,
-0.0412391536,
-0.0313500278,
-0.0526768528,
-0.0027207602,
-0.0477370918,
0.0016439689,
0.0274781454,
-0.0011221665,
-0.0439113379,
0.072475031,
0.0068244967,
0.0212358031,
0.0080245584,
0.0128106959,
0.0127138626,
-0.0771632865,
0.0082728136,
0.0257941801,
-0.0303207189,
0.0048084315,
0.0702778399,
-0.0094268052,
-0.0625406355,
-0.009992281,
-0.0789828002,
-0.0078511406,
-0.0113199493,
0.0541381575,
0.0110399406,
0.0200238749,
-0.0239948276,
-0.0340404473,
-0.0536081046,
-0.0468087159,
0.0035247772,
0.0325870588,
0.0499972887,
0.036386352,
0.0427383259,
-0.0397029184,
-0.0374087915,
0.0166827478,
0.0142938932,
0.0556288026,
-0.0430566892,
-0.0663681328,
0.0172758289,
-0.0160625856,
-0.0126187056,
0.00697122,
0.0216268376,
0.0125233196,
-0.0461998954,
0.0551661588,
0.062265534,
0.0486133136,
0.0595983006,
-0.0395982601,
-0.0210225806,
-0.0447835103,
0.0155847576,
-0.018482035,
0.0739491954,
0.0397533551,
-0.0503692813,
0.0637730435,
0.011363769,
-0.0236305725,
0.0023781322,
-0.0391588062,
-0.0002173503,
-0.0110449567,
-0.0148701742,
-0.0430239737,
-0.0161079932,
-0.0003329713,
0.0398009457,
-0.0120485518,
-0.0203900412,
0.0453032702,
-0.0242220685,
-0.010840374,
-0.0335418694,
0.030166572,
-0.0687272847,
0.0632958859,
0.0078715924,
-0.0059857485,
-0.0228837077,
-0.0528348461,
-0.0360321477,
0.0108817974,
0.0527819507,
-0.0572367832,
0.0367192104,
-0.0031010993,
0.0113440501,
-0.0391617268,
-0.0416168571,
-0.0352152735,
-0.0357821696,
0.0532956459,
0.0036805726,
0.0298935995,
-0.0216924138,
-0.0736164823,
0.0279852375,
0.0417969525,
0.0319494158,
-0.056503199,
-0.0310484655,
0.0002497878,
0.0920224264,
0.0576194525,
-0.0019599723,
0.0364329219,
-0.0437831618,
0.0303295553,
0.0416857414,
0.0675951093,
-0.0112122083,
0.03584655,
-0.0348816179,
-0.0021458918,
-0.0604093932,
-0.0229636021,
0.0002014603,
0.0150339557,
-0.0911897123,
-0.0412079319,
0.0698351711,
0.0483642705,
0.015012431,
-0.0441329367,
-0.0327602401,
0.025627749,
-0.004524786,
0.0663841069,
-0.0890227333,
-0.0195633452,
0.009612889,
0.0411312021,
-0.0043161791,
-0.0338191316,
-0.00985297,
-0.1037722975,
0.0362716615,
-0.0187723208,
-0.0103888148,
-0.0173861478,
-0.0398104116,
-0.0209306758,
0.0000430799,
-0.032055743,
0.0588657856,
-0.0580244921,
0.0194556378,
0.042186223,
-0.0582770109,
0.0060800374,
-0.0640006661,
-0.0154377241,
-0.0499304906,
0.069355458,
0.0046254611,
-0.0016314388,
-0.0349681489,
-0.0105980216,
-0.0351963341,
0.0056362501,
-0.0028556818,
0.0521484725,
-0.0251049586,
0.0169498567,
-0.0214232467,
0.0095855957,
0.0284755062,
0.0095049096,
-0.0072985701,
-0.0006950285,
-0.0280702878,
0.0028641124,
-0.0531741194,
0.0246202517,
-0.021802403,
0.0784296244,
0.0182325449,
0.0016164012,
-0.0398470312,
-0.029811291,
0.0210362375,
-0.0851702243,
0.0610453449,
0.0095218876,
-0.0340898931,
0.0042827236,
-0.1052483767,
-0.0876466781,
0.0182224307,
0.0508257523,
-0.0163378753,
0.0015931255,
-0.0249234866,
-0.0125626158,
-0.0511475727,
0.0131619722,
-0.0296090841,
0.0034272084,
-0.0288883243,
-0.0009710661,
-0.0083863204,
-0.051965367,
-0.0140257711,
0.0159751456,
-0.0562421456,
-0.0209227316,
-0.0103978794,
-0.0119778765,
0.0250171833,
0.019240113,
-0.0140687218,
-0.0175543968,
0.0409405492,
0.057088986,
-0.0739044771,
-0.0237815753,
-0.0020095862,
0.0147857647,
-0.0132010952,
0.0004887052,
-0.0831743106,
-0.0014863921,
-0.0281052478,
0.0508315526,
0.0081479652,
0.0405361243,
0.0110973231,
0.0324349552,
-0.0360607095,
0.0216828771,
0.029520737,
-0.050024882,
0.0001968133,
-0.0223549157,
-0.0178779662,
-0.0290926155,
0.0348717906,
-0.0043616001,
-0.0037099507,
0.0056201871,
0.0944167599,
-0.019752495,
0.0769154355,
-0.054102011,
-0.0103605324,
-0.0106817996,
0.0125873871,
-0.0239581522,
-0.0285195634,
-0.029031409,
-0.019680243,
-0.0100310305,
0.0320276581,
-0.0136432629,
0.0562175512,
0.0293093808,
0.0065542529,
0.0109244073,
0.0170421861,
-0.0617483482,
0.0105374418,
-0.0338533334,
-0.0146297868,
-0.0488612093,
-0.0362976603,
0.0064328392,
-0.009664203,
-0.0005019385,
-0.0012225412,
0.010502887,
0.0576659627,
-0.0434120893,
0.0260711908,
0.0394289233,
-0.0179890096,
-0.0410323106,
0.0854894221,
-0.0044613937,
-0.0147851994,
-0.0608149059,
-0.0521779358,
-0.0513443761,
-0.0320996642,
0.0319935232,
0.0367383249,
0.0033564039,
-0.0292615499,
-0.0700670779,
-0.0103495587,
-0.0167804249,
0.0337656438,
0.0081336852,
0.0024786955,
0.0385203958,
0.0891121179,
0.0376027562,
-0.0063080704,
-0.0482340455,
0.0313650109,
-0.0787101611,
0.003154557,
-0.0067297672,
-5.340250265e-33,
-0.0381334759,
-0.0302141346,
0.0249906499,
-0.0176307298,
-0.02455182,
0.0169355143,
-0.0207824074,
-0.0438921489,
0.0268534925,
-0.0065084095,
-0.015305764,
0.0184321422,
0.0344827138,
0.0129510295,
-0.008416676,
-0.0055497801,
0.059314318,
-0.0080993176,
-0.0625221953,
0.0168800075,
0.0684670061,
0.0230462868,
0.0214247052,
0.0235803816,
0.0322314426,
-0.0274331756,
-0.0192054454,
-0.0164368823,
0.0628794283,
0.0619666539,
0.0136064244,
-0.01724598,
0.0551323108,
-0.0529162548,
-0.0389909409,
0.0684567019,
-0.094456993,
-0.0300634522,
0.0179258138,
0.0026009711,
-0.0625403076,
0.0081858542,
0.0425010547,
-0.0432804003,
0.0375536494,
-0.0119508021,
0.0357070602,
-0.0131055731,
0.0003747229,
-0.0672867224,
-0.0675120056,
0.0440823026,
0.0187856462,
0.026101524,
0.0159486849,
0.1115538701,
0.00427819,
0.0211600959,
-0.0277769584,
0.0077088536,
0.0205016602,
0.0561007559,
0.0372060612,
0.0369039774,
-0.0007976548,
0.0409017764,
0.0170766003,
0.0279994756,
-0.0285228789,
0.0128813414,
0.0238931831,
0.023597341,
0.0263320766,
0.0254781991,
0.0592465885,
-0.0026140343,
-0.0248380415,
0.0766539872,
0.0208849497,
0.041370526,
-0.0023620827,
-0.0024686451,
-0.0351543911,
-0.0036796669,
-0.0139900884,
0.0135492701,
-0.0470477566,
-0.0045024171,
0.023822818,
0.0468679033,
-0.0294039566,
0.0496731624,
0.0494515859,
0.0218225326,
0.0000789545,
0.0174463727,
-0.0352742076,
0.0321384259,
-0.0139265759,
-0.0264906026,
-0.0337665938,
-0.0128464717,
0.0348529965,
0.0026140136,
-0.0452148169,
0.0169205721,
0.0526096299,
-0.0103647998,
-0.0387774371,
-0.0004026609,
-0.0183842313,
0.0357419327,
-0.0207264833,
-0.0116884634,
0.0299694501,
0.0145997405,
-0.0316436812,
0.0205872301,
0.0141573744,
0.0104352804,
-0.0249340143,
-0.0420964807,
-0.0014116184,
0.0434375443,
0.0075212903,
0.0071197436,
-0.0129497768,
0.0206961893,
0.0240104236,
-0.0228499584,
-0.0008116804,
0.0644390136,
2.356e-7,
0.0185734313,
0.011700429,
0.0675776824,
-0.0033000344,
0.023081122,
0.0058111507,
0.0323342793,
0.0226090793,
-0.0119265001,
-0.0067856326,
0.0047694342,
-0.00509544,
0.0544295982,
0.0171876736,
-0.0841350481,
-0.0419940911,
-0.0606293827,
-0.0273939855,
-0.0506197624,
-0.0165098011,
0.0307266135,
0.0180434342,
-0.0426830687,
-0.0181114525,
-0.0041926075,
-0.0438304953,
0.0544598699,
0.0375453085,
-0.0283195153,
0.0334225483,
0.0500940941,
-0.0022243101,
-0.0092486665,
-0.0193360411,
-0.0233796332,
0.0226818565,
0.059490487,
-0.0029085362,
0.0452498272,
0.0147051876,
-0.0014065135,
-0.0389341973,
0.0204092283,
-0.026831653,
0.0551931895,
0.0120940926,
-0.0125890169,
0.0040123919,
-0.040205773,
0.0020334374,
-0.0195730738,
0.0054027732,
-0.0141658289,
0.0430679508,
0.004357887,
-0.0202212688,
0.004308125,
-0.027124051,
-0.0172036625,
0.0058854222,
-0.0389725305,
-0.011930462,
-0.0616709627,
0.0010996063,
-0.0280765072,
-0.0818270147,
-0.0335902832,
2.328979636e-34,
0.0294215307,
-0.003763434,
-0.0338230692,
0.0176899824,
0.0812449679,
-0.0150370598,
-0.0175115485,
0.0451499783,
0.0087690875,
-0.0903263837,
-0.01985153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03563v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03563v2 | Distinguishing the Knowable from the Unknowable with Language Models | 2024-02-05T22:22:49 | 2024-02-27T07:37:08 | Gustaf Ahdritz, Tian Qin, Nikhil Vyas, Boaz Barak, Benjamin L. Edelman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We study the feasibility of identifying epistemic uncertainty (reflecting a
lack of knowledge), as opposed to aleatoric uncertainty (reflecting entropy in
the underlying distribution), in the outputs of large language models (LLMs)
over free-form text. In the absence of ground-truth probabilities, we explore a
setting where, in order to (approximately) disentangle a given LLM's
uncertainty, a significantly larger model stands in as a proxy for the ground
truth. We show that small linear probes trained on the embeddings of frozen,
pretrained models accurately predict when larger models will be more confident
at the token level and that probes trained on one text domain generalize to
others. Going further, we propose a fully unsupervised method that achieves
non-trivial accuracy on the same task. Taken together, we interpret these
results as evidence that LLMs naturally contain internal representations of
different types of uncertainty that could potentially be leveraged to devise
more informative indicators of model confidence in diverse practical settings. | [
0.0448764749,
0.1230076104,
-0.0100154374,
0.0513359345,
-0.0235885698,
0.0170961227,
-0.0081103314,
0.0081581054,
0.0002155169,
-0.0570586771,
-0.0179282129,
-0.0650591105,
0.0132348342,
0.0304635409,
0.0412811153,
-0.0377113707,
0.0070960475,
-0.0478948988,
0.0395324826,
-0.0145388516,
-0.015225214,
-0.025155874,
0.0245788749,
0.0354897529,
-0.0081571303,
0.0141926855,
-0.0052925348,
0.0020415296,
-0.0118509633,
0.0057573747,
-0.0361924842,
0.053477332,
0.0428757221,
0.0857137218,
0.0000019603,
-0.0269378871,
-0.007851908,
-0.0139471563,
-0.0229336508,
0.0329760499,
0.0184359942,
-0.0310757831,
-0.0163939986,
-0.0233959705,
-0.0083041005,
-0.0216444898,
0.0532682464,
0.0218579099,
-0.0192143787,
0.0358042307,
0.0086305989,
-0.0135545181,
0.0000278818,
-0.030285608,
0.0066164061,
-0.0542504601,
0.0371465012,
-0.0142213982,
-0.0521372557,
0.0522792637,
-0.0260678791,
0.040558178,
0.0202048998,
-0.016597731,
-0.0285798144,
0.0567966066,
0.03252469,
-0.036885947,
0.0069661592,
0.0414894931,
-0.0214174837,
-0.0476401225,
-0.0106551703,
-0.0172163118,
0.0127511118,
0.039708145,
-0.0081317024,
0.0303114932,
0.0314631015,
0.0279043764,
-0.0050415159,
0.0294297468,
0.0723544061,
0.0102733308,
-0.0361923538,
0.0842124224,
-0.0097088395,
-0.0145963943,
0.0116776498,
0.021325767,
-0.0505239628,
-0.0655851886,
-0.0336674675,
0.0181857403,
0.0145558938,
0.0476141386,
-0.0263076946,
-0.0017936549,
0.0070228186,
0.0028281366,
0.022116486,
0.0174024962,
-0.0129983118,
0.0400350243,
-0.0065285079,
0.0276174471,
-0.0224675443,
0.0438258313,
-0.016415976,
-0.0105395345,
-0.0261264145,
-0.0089335591,
-0.0061805663,
-0.0047468706,
-0.0159378089,
-0.018358523,
-0.0219827592,
-0.0096064499,
-0.0138030071,
0.0531131513,
-0.0185847357,
0.0159665681,
0.0163521264,
-0.0293807108,
-0.0317406952,
-0.001890075,
-0.0069194236,
0.0381062627,
-0.0070383791,
-0.0534945615,
-0.0095910039,
0.0084145181,
-0.0191816129,
0.0034995875,
-0.0021226644,
0.0373090915,
0.00795615,
-0.0090643577,
-0.0230450686,
-0.0039453111,
-0.0472757295,
-0.0783800557,
-0.0026369281,
-0.0708703771,
-0.0286755599,
0.0025121977,
0.0230960175,
-0.0807935819,
0.0187966041,
-0.0349910296,
-0.0581831038,
0.1196610332,
-0.0064654937,
-0.0011091625,
-0.0013677193,
0.0203946084,
0.0153884459,
0.0696787685,
0.0430958606,
0.0208872035,
0.0613952875,
-0.0028526396,
0.0063753454,
-0.0038504533,
0.0392977335,
0.032100752,
-0.0431228466,
-0.0189354382,
-0.0194173455,
0.0099806394,
0.0048751277,
0.0769099072,
0.0035927366,
-0.0374391712,
0.0880065262,
0.0657643527,
-0.029586738,
-0.0070879231,
0.039044857,
-0.0219335649,
0.0304087661,
0.0488345399,
-0.034958154,
-0.0068627708,
-0.0038905276,
0.0128703397,
0.069615528,
-0.0225699544,
-0.0246396642,
-0.0567513704,
-0.0526598692,
-0.0151624847,
-0.0140396003,
-0.005204977,
0.060978815,
-0.0282253698,
-0.0133346384,
0.0096094431,
0.0066463044,
-0.0155592943,
0.01229202,
-0.0398844071,
0.0573423356,
0.0417495668,
0.0031666877,
-0.0321400501,
0.0357610807,
-0.0137804905,
-0.004162346,
0.037761163,
0.0309564844,
0.0100662922,
0.0286651235,
-0.0296201091,
0.0005400077,
-0.0159296878,
0.0739893541,
0.0111271618,
-0.0104690203,
0.0119067384,
-0.0049444959,
-0.0821517855,
-0.0018192648,
0.0331702232,
-0.037519034,
-0.0061899377,
0.0059317118,
-0.0023918331,
0.0319385752,
-0.0112849511,
-0.0355113074,
0.0343198515,
0.0290305745,
-0.0172632951,
-0.0657344311,
0.0139993839,
-0.001554286,
0.0123374825,
0.0342707932,
-0.0114444373,
-0.0090884166,
-0.0235031545,
-0.0338019133,
-0.0484034084,
0.038984295,
-0.015819557,
0.0662792251,
-0.0413438864,
0.0051536392,
-0.0274113882,
0.0064676753,
-0.0527643897,
0.0507262014,
-0.0550451875,
0.0348751657,
-0.0087742833,
0.000367493,
0.019327715,
0.0070606144,
-0.0370859839,
0.0152680185,
0.0100646401,
0.014382598,
0.026741365,
-0.0284041837,
-0.0039741383,
-0.0423933081,
-0.0346853174,
-0.015958786,
-0.0114111919,
-0.0039984337,
0.0128397038,
-0.0380548202,
0.0036445367,
-0.00084205,
-0.0001367404,
-0.0068549081,
0.0082382103,
0.0113740731,
0.0542136841,
0.0092353337,
0.01435808,
-0.0394850597,
-0.001085593,
-0.0169272684,
0.0869642422,
0.0016491584,
-0.0007832411,
-0.0806867033,
0.0715843365,
-0.0367846303,
0.0270247012,
-0.011163081,
-0.0634109825,
0.0125700412,
-0.0282878298,
-0.0272263903,
0.0598258413,
0.0032416761,
0.0349367894,
0.094110541,
-0.0095913839,
-0.0190026443,
-0.0318339281,
-0.0367290266,
-0.0133149102,
-0.0468096621,
-0.0272281971,
-0.0239000153,
0.0705796406,
0.0445709005,
-0.0433179438,
-0.0525212102,
0.0600993671,
-0.0226690173,
-0.03380448,
-0.0649816468,
-0.0107289655,
0.0012641866,
0.0830978379,
-0.0122981826,
-0.0768059418,
0.0727908537,
-0.0495669208,
0.03627019,
0.0225823224,
-0.0275414269,
-0.0001861725,
0.055486951,
0.0128429523,
0.0072550857,
0.0198518056,
-0.0118915513,
-0.0408030078,
-0.0175198559,
0.0026137088,
-0.024285974,
0.0481356382,
-0.0576067045,
-0.0060649151,
0.020497622,
-0.0175694451,
-0.0498559549,
-0.0430032313,
-0.0552690625,
-0.0125900824,
0.0465829335,
-0.0735871494,
-0.0005379679,
0.0173466038,
0.0130807152,
0.0363286845,
-0.0102109937,
-0.018790856,
-0.0301126819,
0.0214493051,
0.0336530246,
-0.0213353839,
0.0893191844,
-0.0501518063,
0.0236449968,
0.0426250696,
0.0187461451,
0.0181185734,
-0.0478595272,
-0.0268186145,
0.0168785118,
0.008702579,
-0.028400775,
0.0287162103,
0.0487665534,
-0.0270502791,
-0.0331469364,
0.1463102549,
0.0176293124,
-0.0114738885,
0.0030869753,
0.00017059,
0.0306429453,
0.0156557802,
-0.0036828914,
-0.0774027407,
-0.0237991344,
0.0230723452,
-0.0082228919,
-0.0282497481,
-0.0281924251,
-0.0220769718,
-0.0785107985,
0.0239853207,
0.0037594999,
-0.0106484639,
-0.0348530225,
-0.0470226221,
-0.0061389902,
-0.009609051,
0.0223885644,
-0.0302839614,
0.0011856774,
0.0146876909,
0.014355829,
-0.0296385773,
-0.0692084804,
-0.0092944149,
-0.0131746214,
0.0641092658,
0.0163670965,
0.0445009694,
-0.0311912019,
-0.0324577577,
-0.0164627638,
-0.0378393158,
-0.0223604348,
0.0126444278,
0.0658081844,
0.0184562486,
-0.0056000906,
0.0102855843,
0.0202431325,
-0.0359510332,
-0.0045846957,
-0.0209945794,
0.0448748916,
-0.0229668692,
-0.0519875288,
0.0124480054,
-0.0215890054,
0.0056311754,
0.0863949209,
0.0197887197,
0.000112476,
-0.0171751194,
-0.0420955904,
0.0490367636,
0.0239640344,
-0.0363930091,
0.0336377583,
0.0486434065,
-0.0174653251,
-0.0415382534,
-0.0023271677,
-0.0117917703,
0.0389332846,
0.0150368446,
0.0011469184,
0.0301117506,
-0.0192470532,
-0.0402836017,
0.0070044352,
-0.0349835306,
0.0096519515,
-0.0353161991,
0.0134107573,
0.0245945416,
0.005992604,
-0.0391553603,
0.0235038251,
-0.0828261897,
-0.1082627699,
-0.0092182746,
0.0139525821,
0.034322761,
0.0211794544,
-0.0320818201,
-0.0555265881,
0.0968494788,
0.0103154909,
-0.0275657661,
0.0136652952,
0.0380414724,
0.0055755642,
0.0156787466,
0.0619162023,
-0.0278598778,
0.0032231265,
0.0287055559,
-0.0111459419,
-0.0418101437,
-0.1031930372,
0.015428639,
0.0068374989,
0.061365474,
-0.0044552088,
-0.0232612379,
-0.0253023915,
-0.0109577496,
-0.0065593622,
-0.0159450192,
-0.0334898159,
-0.0221563429,
0.0683271214,
-0.0159833208,
-0.0283624195,
0.0086515434,
0.0082697393,
0.055134587,
0.0057145753,
-0.0385131761,
0.0000663897,
0.0299550407,
0.0167196207,
-0.0040925401,
0.0033836863,
0.0507861786,
-0.0469776876,
0.0321308784,
0.0237107687,
0.0090168985,
0.0197875742,
-0.0283603631,
-0.0255561024,
0.0084430287,
-0.1267692894,
-0.0588317327,
0.0012660435,
0.037743561,
0.0474802777,
-0.0099460073,
0.0386438966,
-0.0649255738,
0.0000246165,
-0.0257569626,
0.0239720214,
0.0383210406,
-0.0042507858,
0.0607964285,
0.0019032221,
-0.0472270027,
0.0376692973,
0.0692154691,
0.0281541217,
0.0665560365,
-0.0024831549,
-0.0547857247,
-0.0236996878,
-0.0185032934,
-0.0090959771,
0.0236494113,
-0.0245203134,
0.0462359041,
-0.0600667372,
-0.0784088671,
-0.0233828705,
0.0384181514,
-0.0214608591,
-0.0114725251,
-0.0409821011,
0.0598767698,
0.024885267,
0.0171659198,
-0.0422795936,
0.0013018483,
0.0177478753,
0.0007359532,
-0.0300837588,
-6.747726222e-33,
-0.0071339416,
-0.0587219559,
-0.0537150726,
-0.0424992964,
0.0209540203,
0.0318407901,
-0.007951566,
0.0247850642,
-0.02832257,
0.0630844533,
-0.0023559455,
0.0240141824,
0.0118596209,
0.0064993277,
0.0141550982,
-0.0116766738,
0.0546534397,
-0.0063770111,
-0.012581666,
-0.0117052672,
0.0868156999,
0.0032388403,
0.0605637319,
-0.0410577729,
0.0597380698,
-0.0029369637,
-0.0171834193,
0.0740972012,
-0.0104409242,
0.0187658295,
-0.0458772294,
0.0162554253,
-0.0156660974,
-0.0284731146,
-0.0355020985,
-0.022363361,
-0.0326018892,
-0.0312170908,
0.0242996644,
0.014689913,
-0.0151367877,
-0.0361200757,
0.0157912113,
-0.0232458003,
-0.0113065746,
0.0180457029,
0.0317250304,
-0.0024633405,
0.0164591745,
-0.0090654725,
-0.0030828591,
0.0274929199,
-0.0120291933,
-0.0142369578,
0.0302138552,
0.0020981622,
0.0166650563,
-0.0311982688,
-0.0531989001,
0.005567567,
0.012022228,
0.040598277,
0.0418225825,
-0.0032916334,
0.0097951349,
0.0727124214,
-0.0215143785,
-0.0118045425,
-0.0616759509,
-0.0304513387,
0.0453562215,
0.024335213,
0.0254818182,
0.0511234999,
0.031873621,
-0.0170562193,
-0.0762927905,
-0.0084928162,
0.0279739313,
0.0111794416,
0.0582444184,
0.0106660593,
-0.0419223532,
-0.0402161255,
-0.0673856735,
-0.0539569966,
-0.0194707047,
-0.0095223878,
0.0146158263,
0.0079135196,
0.0010000891,
-0.0451452434,
0.0124445129,
-0.0542866476,
-0.02925428,
0.0349385105,
0.0239643585,
0.0265955031,
0.025163658,
0.0417993963,
-0.0523158684,
-0.0089303879,
-0.0081502609,
0.0297674201,
-0.0077471305,
0.0157965161,
0.0308536906,
0.0094010085,
-0.0612624362,
0.0123382881,
-0.0341872945,
-0.0073127537,
-0.0112853721,
-0.0559840649,
0.0411089137,
-0.0042989524,
-0.0267305505,
0.018858904,
-0.0053352504,
0.0236434042,
0.0212078299,
0.0473240502,
0.0002539298,
0.0403515585,
-0.0351449847,
-0.0592912622,
-0.0287910346,
-0.0346927941,
0.0609910786,
-0.0224884767,
0.0099011585,
0.0032320935,
2.745e-7,
0.0285826288,
0.0397472978,
0.0103098368,
0.0044164681,
0.049070552,
0.0605885126,
-0.0350826494,
-0.0217526201,
-0.0277744494,
-0.0818247423,
-0.0161887091,
0.0139378831,
0.0497478396,
0.0517086685,
-0.0244320631,
-0.02515308,
-0.043531321,
0.0047292369,
0.0114010265,
-0.002057805,
0.034201514,
0.1115812808,
0.0589777641,
0.0279785339,
0.0103827808,
-0.0412148573,
0.0727240592,
-0.0460918508,
0.006891808,
0.0170897655,
0.0422898233,
0.0306397155,
0.0258900207,
0.0119052734,
0.0099836411,
-0.0020593016,
-0.0172493123,
0.0511521064,
0.0232606903,
0.0313955098,
-0.0321651958,
-0.0318001658,
0.0162566938,
-0.0732975677,
0.0654898807,
-0.0477331355,
-0.0566227101,
-0.03702664,
0.0400985144,
-0.0427862033,
0.0509624593,
0.0067236321,
-0.0221051294,
0.0084990393,
-0.0050405632,
0.0102791227,
0.0111417817,
-0.0702047646,
-0.0468988679,
0.0023105172,
-0.0381483473,
-0.0376931429,
-0.0060103922,
-0.0310509354,
0.0305683184,
-0.0905430093,
0.0185042284,
2.718836011e-34,
0.0610849708,
0.0133727863,
-0.0159633178,
-0.0095438147,
0.0366658382,
-0.0190831795,
0.0169814769,
-0.0082749855,
0.0495211072,
-0.0582510233,
0.0083299428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03561v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03561v2 | VLN-Video: Utilizing Driving Videos for Outdoor Vision-and-Language Navigation | 2024-02-05T22:20:19 | 2024-02-07T18:02:51 | Jialu Li, Aishwarya Padmakumar, Gaurav Sukhatme, Mohit Bansal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Outdoor Vision-and-Language Navigation (VLN) requires an agent to navigate
through realistic 3D outdoor environments based on natural language
instructions. The performance of existing VLN methods is limited by
insufficient diversity in navigation environments and limited training data. To
address these issues, we propose VLN-Video, which utilizes the diverse outdoor
environments present in driving videos in multiple cities in the U.S. augmented
with automatically generated navigation instructions and actions to improve
outdoor VLN performance. VLN-Video combines the best of intuitive classical
approaches and modern deep learning techniques, using template infilling to
generate grounded navigation instructions, combined with an image rotation
similarity-based navigation action predictor to obtain VLN style data from
driving videos for pretraining deep learning VLN models. We pre-train the model
on the Touchdown dataset and our video-augmented dataset created from driving
videos with three proxy tasks: Masked Language Modeling, Instruction and
Trajectory Matching, and Next Action Prediction, so as to learn
temporally-aware and visually-aligned instruction representations. The learned
instruction representation is adapted to the state-of-the-art navigator when
fine-tuning on the Touchdown dataset. Empirical results demonstrate that
VLN-Video significantly outperforms previous state-of-the-art models by 2.1% in
task completion rate, achieving a new state-of-the-art on the Touchdown
dataset. | [
-0.007684283,
0.0109499358,
0.0249718688,
0.0098155979,
0.0203621816,
0.0131255696,
-0.0096229827,
-0.0560077243,
-0.0220002308,
-0.0464788824,
-0.0300128181,
0.0177159514,
0.0052936398,
0.0361199975,
0.020175131,
-0.0734045282,
0.0119222822,
-0.0709585696,
-0.0469816253,
0.0361834131,
0.0006452558,
0.030659236,
-0.0272686575,
0.0160627123,
-0.02459969,
0.0015426017,
-0.021448791,
0.0344736129,
0.0676622316,
-0.061917983,
0.0210931543,
0.0034624096,
0.1207199544,
-0.0364038646,
0.000001933,
0.0118208705,
0.0472690165,
-0.0512119718,
-0.0068166782,
-0.0097085666,
0.0294460803,
0.0125578111,
0.0161765013,
0.0517507903,
-0.0281644799,
-0.0298015364,
0.0239899438,
0.0429765098,
0.0682500079,
0.0477812253,
-0.0151489498,
-0.0197656397,
-0.0253686644,
0.0277173501,
0.0236271266,
0.0151483854,
-0.0173504744,
0.013802872,
-0.0121071758,
0.0161408391,
-0.0303164721,
0.0067172442,
0.0648375228,
0.0035636055,
0.0085462425,
0.0614898726,
-0.0156528857,
-0.0303577986,
-0.0340991691,
0.0932647958,
-0.0694155619,
-0.0478147343,
-0.0259719994,
-0.0079318751,
-0.0120168561,
-0.0368592143,
-0.0183687471,
0.0079240119,
0.0174165964,
0.0342507251,
-0.0158716328,
0.0377468579,
0.0296066031,
-0.0007299078,
0.0021806434,
0.0237897374,
0.0215640385,
0.0200174674,
-0.0251922719,
-0.0026675316,
0.0123383766,
-0.043930281,
-0.0091408156,
0.0127907349,
-0.0398064293,
0.0095774205,
-0.0546379499,
0.0795114934,
-0.0524811484,
-0.020011561,
0.0835365653,
0.0227503572,
-0.0401291251,
0.0574673936,
-0.0279610883,
0.0513590164,
-0.0093910713,
0.0287298188,
-0.019544987,
-0.0138928443,
-0.0259669404,
0.0344544314,
-0.0467634834,
0.0019893115,
-0.0427468829,
-0.0089156954,
0.029242754,
0.0279268604,
-0.0053951903,
0.0050225835,
-0.0573191009,
0.0896036997,
-0.024257727,
-0.0072336891,
0.009508214,
-0.0111003686,
-0.0086693009,
0.0306947269,
-0.0004804849,
-0.0644038543,
0.0217343438,
0.0320223719,
0.0052829934,
-0.0274113528,
0.0219237711,
0.0497693159,
-0.0332491323,
-0.0215796288,
-0.0480060577,
0.0354447663,
0.0102442577,
-0.026716968,
0.0199683737,
-0.0792787224,
0.047269322,
-0.0307574701,
-0.0452678874,
-0.0359523147,
0.0255386941,
0.0076284106,
0.0193603262,
0.058842577,
0.0202041492,
-0.0215688907,
0.0295064822,
-0.0104231844,
0.0418470316,
0.0208614487,
0.0236861818,
0.0430717692,
-0.0119711757,
0.0139587782,
0.0232612696,
0.0477380231,
-0.0049226978,
0.0514609925,
-0.0415896252,
0.0000044711,
0.0218003578,
0.0496404134,
0.0238933656,
0.037795037,
-0.0337031111,
-0.0219848659,
0.0655494481,
-0.0019236727,
-0.0478272922,
-0.0347882807,
0.0697011501,
0.052177716,
-0.0036449821,
-0.0323372111,
-0.0693277493,
0.0673547462,
-0.0128291072,
-0.0183939189,
-0.0169149581,
0.0368518457,
-0.0845701173,
-0.0433926545,
0.0097660143,
-0.0166325551,
0.0673404858,
0.0089655956,
0.0068817399,
-0.0131761869,
-0.0593270585,
0.0222331509,
-0.0081178974,
0.0276368931,
0.0305398218,
0.0192346908,
-0.0183307193,
0.0627294779,
-0.0165060069,
0.0494359881,
-0.0659631565,
-0.0405463912,
0.0477687232,
-0.0048120571,
-0.0128893731,
-0.0156805012,
0.067841813,
-0.0674624816,
-0.0528348312,
0.0195918996,
0.002909862,
0.0114487754,
0.0338469669,
0.0432755202,
0.0432633609,
-0.0314129293,
-0.0245385598,
0.0503939763,
0.0268792585,
-0.0474352166,
-0.0123720672,
0.0148366187,
0.0180601273,
-0.0032748713,
-0.0029067271,
-0.0300308373,
0.044901181,
-0.0078790803,
0.0252236407,
0.0378711484,
-0.0460607074,
-0.036992766,
0.0353723392,
-0.0843608081,
-0.0212589242,
0.071305491,
-0.0471682996,
-0.0321953632,
-0.0283862893,
-0.0224919934,
-0.0154012181,
0.0095316721,
-0.0114994738,
0.0764219761,
-0.0014458889,
-0.0180070251,
0.0107842973,
-0.0035581319,
-0.0031172184,
0.0101107229,
0.0039377464,
0.0186868608,
-0.0161008332,
0.0103428317,
-0.0453101657,
-0.0133180786,
-0.0281982329,
0.0332190096,
0.0563680418,
-0.0505236164,
0.0173926242,
-0.0291140303,
-0.0031997238,
-0.0556006841,
0.0014796561,
0.0126685211,
-0.0284040831,
0.0042382483,
-0.0230322834,
-0.0235979576,
-0.0237639397,
0.0132788057,
-0.0294326413,
0.0009120777,
-0.0119906468,
-0.0322750211,
-0.0197078288,
-0.007771601,
-0.0012281213,
0.0198839009,
0.0133772176,
-0.0195994768,
-0.0303407069,
-0.0412252024,
-0.0387089252,
0.0565800667,
-0.0364138559,
-0.0326481238,
0.0119048255,
-0.0054261247,
0.0191289037,
0.0349432975,
0.0175413862,
-0.0171403084,
0.0061722682,
-0.0199765861,
-0.0604536496,
0.0239260141,
-0.0373423137,
-0.0178219881,
-0.0855772942,
-0.0063775079,
-0.01252288,
-0.0397776291,
-0.0382422619,
0.0502485149,
-0.0533540249,
-0.0349375792,
0.0007536936,
-0.0627344176,
-0.0337667204,
0.0396158025,
-0.0132378507,
-0.0039867484,
-0.0360490158,
-0.0430001207,
-0.0145824309,
-0.0118935462,
-0.0579063371,
-0.0303828288,
0.0111128325,
0.0141969807,
0.0583317056,
0.0410653874,
0.0163551476,
0.0025336449,
-0.0155487973,
-0.0231568329,
-0.0278721303,
-0.0153440712,
0.0343485437,
0.0552035645,
-0.0746126175,
0.0133675551,
0.0169441383,
-0.0062453179,
-0.0437649898,
-0.0307104029,
-0.0076207151,
0.0099576795,
-0.0329155214,
-0.0221462306,
-0.0218412075,
-0.0109870331,
0.0204429999,
0.0543231927,
0.0081704352,
0.0081129363,
-0.0234898888,
-0.0355462581,
0.0928669348,
0.0144040463,
-0.0049731648,
-0.0299320761,
0.0107041365,
0.016598098,
0.0461326838,
-0.022613138,
-0.0487289093,
0.0528600365,
0.0463776141,
0.0231031794,
-0.0252527967,
0.109790124,
0.0366297439,
-0.0504754558,
-0.0222801026,
0.0883278325,
0.0283545833,
-0.006354575,
0.0186741035,
-0.0005165618,
0.025633594,
0.0460402891,
0.0173123423,
-0.0355762281,
-0.0383147448,
-0.0236139148,
-0.0230403952,
0.0711426735,
0.027063081,
0.0147437435,
-0.0554050244,
0.054194279,
0.0194743965,
-0.0414905027,
-0.0346564539,
-0.0288615879,
-0.0290382747,
-0.0209893063,
0.0040495433,
-0.03718156,
-0.0138318976,
-0.0176801253,
0.025956681,
-0.0024211186,
-0.0586354472,
0.0082870508,
-0.0639357194,
0.0147129903,
0.0428451747,
0.0114264674,
-0.0329723023,
-0.0878439844,
-0.0012719497,
0.0090536177,
0.0341087095,
-0.0384034701,
0.0171495341,
-0.0478439406,
-0.0216253456,
0.0263199061,
0.0653264597,
-0.0322007276,
-0.0121783987,
-0.0133853685,
0.0351391099,
-0.0629764572,
0.0398699977,
-0.0286523718,
0.0032100743,
0.0601123646,
0.018123161,
-0.0385733023,
0.0044316747,
-0.0210668538,
-0.022403026,
-0.0305859055,
-0.0278937481,
-0.0447211638,
-0.0110668503,
0.0007266324,
-0.0268440098,
-0.0481470227,
-0.0458301678,
0.0796900764,
0.0578511991,
-0.0164612643,
-0.051454965,
0.0171135031,
0.0014398342,
-0.0479376279,
0.0526716225,
-0.0326742642,
0.0381755084,
-0.004047465,
0.0132492641,
0.0216859709,
-0.0354952477,
-0.0180672184,
0.0140166748,
-0.0494691283,
-0.0458982214,
0.0427723676,
0.0631391183,
0.0025160469,
0.0964226574,
0.0046675312,
0.022327181,
0.0499531403,
-0.0101692267,
0.025850201,
0.0061987177,
0.0012644853,
-0.0139070321,
0.0114735169,
0.0029064575,
-0.0626452565,
0.0232867524,
-0.0046048248,
-0.0176937189,
-0.0235522613,
0.0110276984,
0.0366200171,
-0.049578201,
0.0603758693,
0.0087389331,
0.0450259149,
-0.0144469095,
0.0119174914,
0.024106171,
-0.0021471868,
-0.0644250885,
0.0260576848,
0.02606727,
0.0390126258,
-0.0097853485,
0.0538361892,
0.0300326664,
-0.0127516137,
-0.0207479913,
-0.0155715002,
0.0276074782,
0.0050098891,
-0.0223185942,
0.0174683947,
0.0185790788,
0.048931893,
-0.0136331161,
0.0138389533,
0.0149844131,
0.0040714713,
0.0468962826,
0.0414162613,
-0.0552295372,
0.0255432259,
0.0032923985,
-0.063499108,
-0.0624967478,
0.0112335291,
0.0481800772,
-0.0299196132,
0.0053670257,
-0.0485574007,
0.0087854397,
-0.0146385878,
-0.0106380414,
0.011898444,
-0.0643563494,
0.0737781003,
0.0037099065,
-0.0094723366,
-0.0231850911,
0.0333221257,
0.0479839742,
0.070345059,
0.0307222232,
0.0177500565,
-0.0418535583,
0.0143929068,
0.0232265126,
0.0411127992,
0.0092248693,
0.0187753085,
0.024779344,
-0.0257413071,
-0.0261827391,
0.0324490517,
-0.0208107606,
-0.0273597892,
0.0678910911,
-0.0032458289,
-0.011854534,
-0.0501023419,
0.0039337408,
-0.0675771981,
-0.0018789057,
-0.0445056036,
-0.0552113168,
-5.770235445e-33,
-0.0197898429,
-0.0102359485,
0.0596892126,
-0.0100943949,
-0.0195177831,
-0.0227968283,
-0.0179741587,
0.0038270832,
-0.0289731994,
0.0372200757,
0.0176400486,
0.0352077521,
0.0228463616,
0.0500005819,
0.0138188554,
-0.0310479309,
0.0590964183,
-0.0168136321,
-0.0226957593,
0.0167645626,
-0.0026097484,
-0.0185437873,
0.0511856303,
-0.0904615074,
-0.0362588204,
-0.0196975842,
-0.0637831911,
0.033721827,
-0.0110186199,
0.046523422,
0.0300900098,
-0.0281684659,
-0.0193275996,
-0.0734605715,
-0.0541436598,
-0.0357581899,
-0.0335277356,
-0.0167992376,
-0.00856084,
0.0569279827,
-0.0863868669,
-0.0237704497,
0.0223493129,
-0.0141474446,
0.0023043361,
-0.000552027,
0.0564525537,
0.0085498113,
0.0003549826,
-0.0024925307,
-0.0436462052,
0.0073200427,
-0.0071648485,
-0.0737691,
0.0154039366,
0.0585091449,
0.0008302875,
-0.0223528054,
-0.0569134839,
-0.0052464027,
-0.0194303356,
0.0470689386,
0.0719993487,
0.0556138083,
0.0338077694,
0.0534870476,
0.0175275356,
-0.0378549695,
-0.0492494293,
-0.0172713809,
0.0467506275,
0.0829181224,
0.0046553323,
0.0285614319,
0.025030449,
0.0130979512,
-0.0159987062,
0.0391523987,
-0.0646744668,
0.0485709719,
-0.0100916009,
0.0059938389,
-0.0348679423,
-0.014430536,
-0.0441403575,
0.0030982639,
0.0112154931,
-0.0242251102,
0.0650004148,
0.0468500964,
-0.0230913293,
-0.005685844,
0.0793605894,
-0.0154797435,
-0.002814967,
0.0361105166,
-0.0001050797,
0.0083552152,
0.0169930402,
0.0265345648,
-0.1107400656,
-0.0451556966,
0.0215728581,
-0.0171636492,
0.0017705348,
0.0001729903,
0.0058876583,
0.0767173916,
-0.0223051012,
0.0052677272,
-0.0320642367,
-0.0030370958,
0.0089336382,
0.0223646164,
0.0690046698,
-0.0005940148,
-0.046532277,
0.0358606391,
-0.0222827345,
-0.0703124404,
0.0090090856,
-0.0567506477,
-0.0001671597,
0.0375847816,
-0.0208630059,
0.0237882491,
-0.0667032301,
-0.051908318,
-0.0090002082,
-0.0312840082,
-0.0040917164,
0.0381862782,
2.571e-7,
-0.018317271,
0.0341871306,
0.0244825613,
0.0130919553,
0.0125404662,
0.0566734448,
0.0181706939,
0.0248338617,
-0.0175088048,
-0.0142931491,
0.0442807712,
0.0655626059,
-0.0045057889,
0.0039669275,
-0.0294224117,
0.0359357223,
-0.0324375108,
-0.0000219252,
-0.037083827,
-0.0131487129,
0.0486542881,
0.1140648276,
0.0122464048,
0.0014174565,
0.0682307631,
0.0270936526,
0.0184053052,
-0.02613502,
-0.0113279102,
-0.0185374767,
0.0011659983,
0.078975521,
-0.0521674268,
-0.0097777341,
-0.0277607385,
-0.0083782235,
0.0133836009,
0.0225501154,
-0.0375516154,
-0.0417606495,
-0.018407993,
0.0081183026,
-0.0272371601,
-0.0499879085,
0.0440288149,
-0.0466021933,
0.0343456678,
-0.0122858277,
-0.0669587404,
0.0272374526,
-0.0185204931,
0.0269106142,
-0.0084863827,
-0.0213172343,
0.0353666209,
-0.0146010639,
-0.0238212403,
-0.0689740553,
-0.0160645172,
0.0230291337,
-0.0060275081,
0.0346697271,
-0.0494845659,
0.0265005007,
0.0104613779,
0.0066385395,
-0.0555742122,
1.809145614e-34,
0.0005877665,
0.0060437443,
0.0059463368,
-0.0310472548,
-0.0127717042,
0.0261534173,
-0.0255455151,
0.0065865386,
-0.0193461962,
-0.0144894533,
-0.0302900877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03519v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03519v1 | Resolving Transcription Ambiguity in Spanish: A Hybrid Acoustic-Lexical System for Punctuation Restoration | 2024-02-05T21:05:35 | 2024-02-05T21:05:35 | Xiliang Zhu, Chia-Tien Chang, Shayna Gardiner, David Rossouw, Jonas Robertson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Punctuation restoration is a crucial step after Automatic Speech Recognition
(ASR) systems to enhance transcript readability and facilitate subsequent NLP
tasks. Nevertheless, conventional lexical-based approaches are inadequate for
solving the punctuation restoration task in Spanish, where ambiguity can be
often found between unpunctuated declaratives and questions. In this study, we
propose a novel hybrid acoustic-lexical punctuation restoration system for
Spanish transcription, which consolidates acoustic and lexical signals through
a modular process. Our experiment results show that the proposed system can
effectively improve F1 score of question marks and overall punctuation
restoration on both public and internal Spanish conversational datasets.
Additionally, benchmark comparison against LLMs (Large Language Model)
indicates the superiority of our approach in accuracy, reliability and latency.
Furthermore, we demonstrate that the Word Error Rate (WER) of the ASR module
also benefits from our proposed system. | [
-0.0026414518,
0.0620380715,
-0.0192653593,
0.0061021568,
-0.0407984778,
-0.0130182309,
0.0188459791,
0.0151985269,
0.0088955285,
-0.0020931377,
-0.0110714221,
0.0201476645,
0.0688801035,
-0.0266648699,
0.028122155,
-0.0114878807,
0.037429437,
-0.0419771895,
-0.0155303935,
-0.0193090308,
0.0551205166,
-0.0173363443,
-0.0324385725,
0.0311527271,
-0.0021289324,
0.0000092289,
0.0153415762,
0.0250591896,
0.0283176582,
0.0140121104,
-0.0082944576,
0.0280233622,
-0.0924145207,
0.0597376712,
0.0000014173,
-0.0556816459,
-0.0733333156,
0.0275582857,
0.012143611,
-0.0045607635,
-0.0062217033,
0.0173012782,
-0.0371366069,
0.0823167488,
0.0053556273,
-0.0181675535,
0.0495668985,
-0.0081467358,
0.0084062908,
0.0133988997,
-0.0228700973,
-0.0348156244,
0.0197617393,
0.0179834925,
-0.0461164601,
0.0179418605,
0.0103967879,
-0.0154800676,
-0.0054350533,
-0.0359683745,
0.0310979579,
0.0893222988,
-0.0269444138,
-0.0486878976,
-0.0316867009,
-0.038786903,
-0.0665026978,
-0.0299362,
-0.0374493338,
-0.0004878492,
-0.0076422421,
-0.0232815258,
0.016484132,
0.0137299085,
0.0228157099,
-0.030057339,
-0.0295357239,
-0.0432320796,
-0.0054067718,
-0.0015461172,
0.0270254649,
-0.0147558115,
-0.0000975775,
-0.0198388286,
-0.010951817,
0.0242278501,
0.0241168272,
-0.0226352643,
-0.0097372727,
-0.0032976377,
0.0005211258,
0.0105931638,
0.120541051,
-0.0209755674,
0.0114042331,
0.0023576138,
-0.0028542795,
-0.0770515949,
0.0331582762,
-0.0368326083,
-0.0267494228,
0.0360930823,
-0.0618094802,
-0.0093150306,
0.0070978249,
0.0456615314,
0.0193067268,
-0.0182254184,
-0.033154048,
-0.0326405019,
-0.0131078279,
0.0139780762,
-0.0530606918,
0.0384087861,
-0.002888876,
0.0046459236,
-0.0310017988,
-0.0314045511,
0.0268760826,
-0.0018298632,
0.0478760153,
-0.0282249264,
0.006182529,
0.0110703176,
0.0348074809,
0.0313024633,
-0.0024059946,
0.0491995029,
-0.0027452665,
-0.0574434325,
-0.0078060455,
0.0301318225,
0.0610651672,
0.0064594555,
0.0082205543,
0.0127701284,
-0.0441233218,
-0.0321457908,
0.0124326684,
-0.0262032952,
-0.0693414658,
-0.0364116617,
-0.0717261061,
-0.0561568402,
0.0348160192,
0.0118822949,
0.0013101067,
0.0246990547,
0.0125452988,
0.0031644052,
0.0261636283,
0.1139892861,
-0.032491561,
-0.0075804191,
0.0378722213,
-0.0402199104,
-0.0031354239,
0.0063331672,
0.057088729,
-0.0327724405,
0.0306953322,
0.0161876567,
-0.0113560613,
0.077259697,
-0.0195949487,
-0.0288687497,
-0.0168583449,
-0.0297251865,
-0.0242027137,
0.0355587527,
0.0063257269,
0.0898067877,
-0.0083747189,
0.0405489914,
0.0319046117,
0.0152275497,
0.0147854537,
0.0159224737,
-0.0176058132,
0.0123686409,
0.0277220365,
0.0228703935,
0.0088363178,
-0.0908877999,
-0.03666858,
0.0497201458,
0.0556807704,
-0.0034090653,
0.0043531493,
-0.0264814682,
-0.0137585942,
-0.0165532734,
0.0327898003,
0.0243183039,
0.0251922607,
0.01492819,
-0.0617049113,
0.0296024103,
-0.0363204964,
-0.0593306236,
-0.0169899091,
-0.0213031359,
0.0012878607,
0.0407525338,
0.0657814965,
-0.0435210168,
-0.0190491565,
-0.0275351331,
-0.0737169161,
0.0353771858,
-0.0340905376,
-0.0018117125,
0.0605562031,
-0.0560529381,
0.03091879,
0.1206582859,
0.0019425483,
0.0282772146,
-0.0182068031,
0.0160756391,
0.0045343069,
-0.0287417118,
0.0078587122,
0.0055947616,
0.0175662525,
-0.0116620259,
0.0015422644,
-0.0117795765,
0.0543339513,
0.057554882,
-0.0193796046,
0.0020792694,
0.0531954169,
-0.0612942055,
0.0169346891,
0.0202849433,
-0.0653835386,
-0.0759508237,
0.0342943519,
-0.0159396827,
0.0069639166,
0.0359134823,
0.0519682802,
-0.0821202248,
-0.053804595,
-0.0332316682,
0.0278700031,
-0.0661406443,
0.0859982669,
-0.0051216944,
0.040927615,
-0.0337135531,
-0.0631815791,
0.0017542589,
0.017145671,
-0.0376515351,
-0.0283327345,
0.0323080197,
-0.0409714021,
-0.0185529068,
0.0307535958,
-0.0526874252,
0.030394787,
0.0165905356,
0.0104971537,
-0.0063048904,
-0.0358868204,
-0.1002820134,
0.0194666944,
-0.0168444347,
0.0125700906,
-0.0068533313,
0.0171657894,
-0.0106125707,
-0.0225324389,
0.0184784923,
0.0001392414,
0.0249055065,
-0.0159283541,
0.0118247634,
0.0052790749,
-0.0391549058,
-0.0586453639,
0.0136982733,
0.0081749912,
0.0088430736,
0.0103893494,
-0.076790899,
-0.07347361,
0.0446231924,
0.0175675061,
0.0307116453,
0.0459779277,
-0.0756102651,
0.0152495904,
0.0185318161,
0.0533205383,
0.0257400442,
-0.0463183299,
-0.0564895086,
-0.0199030209,
-0.0227846168,
-0.0217246097,
-0.0008315559,
0.0536983758,
0.021993069,
-0.0356000774,
0.0154891731,
-0.0012464462,
0.0349215753,
0.0344164297,
0.0108466242,
-0.0010381876,
-0.0125895711,
0.000811022,
-0.024138527,
0.0117995273,
-0.0478450246,
-0.0655903146,
0.0306344572,
0.005798338,
0.0032751197,
0.0034605891,
-0.0812049508,
-0.0393335335,
-0.0678367689,
-0.0090646036,
-0.0222556628,
-0.003243125,
0.0001524572,
-0.02252803,
0.0447331071,
-0.1327067912,
-0.0155864824,
0.0017402561,
0.0084644537,
-0.0645200983,
0.0302402209,
-0.0309168305,
0.0179740172,
0.016037479,
-0.055051934,
-0.0017893679,
0.0356295928,
-0.0229811072,
0.0231281463,
0.0378634445,
-0.02581889,
-0.0254361331,
-0.0004130958,
0.004548565,
0.1008345932,
-0.0167409461,
0.0237186514,
-0.0376933999,
0.0807181448,
-0.03685873,
0.0246000271,
0.0308448356,
-0.0396622419,
0.0055477149,
-0.0296855979,
0.0271832161,
-0.0024996502,
0.0069266376,
-0.0219593626,
0.053014338,
-0.0101049002,
-0.0368967205,
-0.0120770549,
0.0625851601,
-0.0249235164,
-0.0154030342,
0.090205729,
0.0163896307,
-0.0050280076,
-0.0604908578,
-0.0050046192,
0.0280702021,
0.0163062699,
-0.004746859,
-0.0600246973,
-0.0286171492,
0.0739800036,
0.0474779755,
0.0214573108,
0.0309619363,
0.0016997387,
-0.0770055726,
0.024398474,
0.0226142351,
-0.0746827722,
-0.0093227997,
0.0039127832,
-0.0061158706,
-0.0367563814,
0.017103659,
0.0255062543,
0.0152416881,
-0.0154884662,
0.0145831713,
-0.0609074049,
-0.0167739317,
-0.0338799059,
-0.0207145941,
0.0175657719,
0.0591294728,
0.0269865748,
-0.0068972013,
0.0052556801,
0.0263213478,
-0.0118320882,
-0.0263705477,
-0.0350788347,
0.0421149433,
0.0554690845,
-0.0193954092,
-0.008122609,
0.0090955114,
-0.0077829352,
0.0220472775,
0.0375542007,
0.0168882124,
-0.011489463,
0.0590130612,
0.0088296225,
-0.0062285466,
-0.0169091616,
0.0359375961,
0.0152599299,
-0.055413451,
-0.0182588436,
-0.0055154236,
0.0196089949,
-0.0650943518,
0.0342554711,
-0.0000960754,
-0.0492507443,
-0.0465854108,
-0.0707651153,
-0.0382841118,
0.0296976808,
-0.0096245036,
0.0320025273,
0.0283735059,
0.0110317366,
0.0402095318,
-0.017375635,
-0.0336787216,
0.0153424507,
-0.0049878089,
-0.0611126386,
0.0290328208,
-0.038481053,
-0.0276470724,
-0.0038603586,
0.0309197567,
-0.0697520599,
-0.0591803789,
0.0711212233,
0.0036268816,
0.0216808841,
0.019210007,
-0.0442311838,
-0.0359783247,
0.0025391506,
0.0706220865,
-0.0129342778,
0.0152840391,
0.0176021643,
0.0054289363,
-0.0164565276,
0.0247210637,
-0.0030775066,
-0.0178049654,
-0.0561258048,
0.0535534881,
-0.063487269,
-0.0679873452,
0.0095222145,
0.0400425196,
0.0887412354,
-0.0309404153,
-0.0156555567,
-0.0364491194,
0.0129386671,
-0.0153483385,
0.0313425064,
-0.0221453886,
0.0082936287,
-0.0063887392,
0.0084796194,
-0.0493600741,
-0.0388548002,
-0.0529188551,
0.0121142492,
-0.0004390905,
0.0412755646,
0.032071162,
-0.0120437462,
0.0095590213,
-0.0045308694,
0.0370207503,
0.0738907531,
0.015763009,
0.0202809013,
0.0040616221,
-0.0049301782,
-0.0726519376,
0.0086922813,
-0.0242220592,
0.0178635865,
-0.0077454797,
0.0010450772,
-0.002784607,
0.0662278756,
0.0565501936,
0.0049647563,
0.0913153142,
0.0217699446,
0.0156590566,
-0.0211952813,
-0.0021242993,
-0.0098784463,
0.0390058085,
0.0175805409,
-0.0062796352,
-0.0068864017,
0.015301791,
0.0127013642,
-0.0208693501,
-0.0268874932,
-0.0311653428,
-0.0096008312,
-0.042822741,
-0.0218132883,
0.0038604888,
-0.0005848869,
-0.0467334129,
-0.0362625867,
0.0087467516,
-0.0176180433,
0.0453865305,
-0.0002812146,
0.0258332919,
-0.0168499574,
0.0027086937,
0.0324953347,
-0.0240653791,
-0.0365879424,
-0.004809971,
-0.0224637017,
0.0232346747,
-0.0358911566,
0.0091227358,
-5.413636744e-33,
-0.00914081,
-0.0170963593,
-0.0297402348,
0.0047575207,
-0.0278243572,
0.0313295349,
-0.0253662039,
0.007349405,
0.0198404063,
-0.0204141345,
-0.0378779285,
0.0180488676,
0.0460074842,
-0.0165068805,
0.0424132794,
0.0211475547,
0.0806519091,
-0.021364633,
0.0510945171,
-0.0536794439,
0.0114328945,
0.076038897,
0.0394123793,
-0.0492609777,
0.011541469,
-0.0028188974,
-0.0226821527,
0.0103344554,
0.0383595154,
0.0344496332,
0.0330041796,
0.0289607961,
-0.0238955822,
0.0097040925,
-0.0342986882,
0.0345852524,
-0.0974128097,
-0.0055695577,
0.0519042164,
0.0797179863,
0.0016410915,
-0.0172603521,
0.061234206,
-0.0467760116,
-0.0126287956,
0.0155908391,
0.0231412593,
-0.0398652554,
0.0089404564,
-0.0279156063,
0.0030883681,
0.0232311487,
-0.0037228137,
-0.006263047,
0.0834868699,
0.0715679675,
-0.0150291901,
-0.0182212032,
-0.0419238284,
0.0058241519,
0.0236489139,
0.0587967336,
0.0020580501,
0.0380482562,
-0.0290227514,
-0.0108657917,
0.0469909236,
-0.0525430366,
0.0431422666,
-0.0349753052,
0.0416173451,
-0.0069616996,
0.0414988734,
0.041264493,
0.0572069921,
-0.0057399282,
-0.0190431774,
-0.0257289428,
0.0071441229,
-0.0269760229,
-0.0064838585,
0.0628111959,
-0.0658779591,
0.0169987772,
-0.0545400754,
-0.0111192884,
-0.0239115637,
0.0125842709,
0.0259046443,
-0.0207518153,
0.0014350883,
0.0000089814,
0.0738104954,
0.0035310849,
0.0039541367,
-0.0379931852,
0.0056845117,
0.0296299178,
-0.0418501161,
0.0497224703,
-0.0597074367,
0.0108027002,
0.021569116,
0.0485483892,
0.0170260407,
-0.0196615532,
-0.0007894848,
0.0167872105,
-0.0618880056,
0.020096777,
0.028254196,
0.0369801074,
-0.0096793864,
0.0031850252,
0.0182749182,
0.0339519829,
0.03976807,
0.0276157688,
0.0335298181,
0.029952459,
-0.0181657672,
-0.0377839655,
-0.0119222198,
0.0211300235,
-0.0536639988,
-0.0246734098,
0.0124111399,
-0.0169657841,
-0.0441660397,
-0.0260573756,
-0.0136064263,
-0.0002154219,
2.235e-7,
0.0331263579,
0.0609833747,
0.0280620381,
0.0247537494,
0.0033395474,
-0.0135457115,
0.0000624278,
0.0012973995,
0.0230269283,
0.0573758222,
0.0036267117,
-0.0669107363,
0.0906477943,
0.0099569373,
-0.1140396073,
-0.0486217365,
0.0041584563,
0.011728785,
-0.0396690778,
0.0296125449,
0.0653987452,
0.051155746,
-0.0279616173,
-0.0208504815,
-0.026782345,
-0.0278102029,
0.0005445253,
0.0262757,
-0.0355645157,
0.0012259682,
0.0562155508,
0.0197903253,
0.0042204154,
0.0408678018,
-0.0054654316,
0.0076487921,
0.0303495284,
0.0204864591,
0.0007275927,
-0.0234173313,
0.074248068,
0.0187725481,
-0.0308475047,
-0.0426931977,
0.0440332443,
0.025302425,
0.0334571153,
-0.0084239841,
-0.0165758878,
-0.0413199179,
0.0464907512,
-0.0319364183,
-0.0235071592,
0.0206568353,
0.0265874509,
-0.0054489374,
-0.0375315212,
0.0061041582,
-0.0643773451,
0.0229815617,
-0.018575836,
0.0116239004,
-0.0059391502,
-0.0106613273,
-0.0203724783,
-0.0683876649,
0.0163396783,
1.885714951e-34,
0.0293779112,
-0.0550529771,
0.0214540735,
0.0392884575,
0.0386160575,
-0.036863178,
-0.0002847993,
0.053589765,
-0.0094165085,
-0.0413782932,
-0.020945685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03509v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03509v1 | Evaluating the Factuality of Zero-shot Summarizers Across Varied Domains | 2024-02-05T20:51:11 | 2024-02-05T20:51:11 | Sanjana Ramprasad, Kundan Krishna, Zachary C Lipton, Byron C Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent work has shown that large language models (LLMs) are capable of
generating summaries zero-shot (i.e., without explicit supervision) that, under
human assessment, are often comparable or even preferred to manually composed
reference summaries. However, this prior work has focussed almost exclusively
on evaluating news article summarization. How do zero-shot summarizers perform
in other (potentially more specialized) domains? In this work we evaluate
zero-shot generated summaries across specialized domains including biomedical
articles, and legal bills (in addition to standard news benchmarks for
reference). We focus especially on the factuality of outputs. We acquire
annotations from domain experts to identify inconsistencies in summaries and
systematically categorize these errors. We analyze whether the prevalence of a
given domain in the pretraining corpus affects extractiveness and faithfulness
of generated summaries of articles in this domain. We release all collected
annotations to facilitate additional research toward measuring and realizing
factually accurate summarization, beyond news articles. The dataset can be
downloaded from https://github.com/sanjanaramprasad/zero_shot_faceval_domains | [
0.0281203408,
0.0064721806,
0.042629458,
-0.0039046162,
-0.0249943715,
0.0217858255,
0.0164064709,
-0.0193694923,
-0.0425169319,
-0.0815897882,
-0.0213376917,
-0.0154732708,
0.0166096874,
-0.0072696344,
0.0109651452,
-0.0554233193,
0.0340516493,
-0.0030730611,
0.0008193608,
0.0062863803,
0.0240240805,
-0.0018753494,
-0.009613133,
0.0367027186,
-0.0006776117,
0.0075360173,
0.0185312312,
-0.0068780622,
0.0446212105,
-0.0266849939,
-0.0059490767,
0.031597726,
0.0022765023,
0.0527345538,
0.0000016176,
-0.0511956178,
-0.0083955489,
0.0161308646,
-0.0080343848,
0.0253232643,
0.0440633111,
-0.0869765133,
-0.0011204483,
-0.0048204632,
-0.0064477008,
-0.0466568656,
0.0098820785,
0.0365288891,
0.07454025,
0.0937657133,
-0.00776558,
-0.030507192,
0.0160010587,
-0.0365311913,
-0.0231759865,
-0.0214551333,
0.0158411935,
0.0179429539,
-0.0085631497,
-0.0100536421,
-0.0005464884,
0.0125969164,
0.0096205631,
-0.0190037508,
-0.0057140524,
0.0346526504,
-0.0873870775,
-0.015687447,
0.0418046117,
0.0643336773,
0.0249169953,
-0.0071177497,
0.0402598456,
0.0086612469,
-0.0087795723,
0.0121968668,
-0.0678725243,
0.078123942,
0.0041988646,
0.014363057,
-0.0210725572,
0.0494192205,
-0.0076939515,
0.0213067327,
-0.0160217173,
0.0317778662,
-0.0009321322,
-0.0121326083,
-0.0148485359,
0.0405588001,
-0.0055569145,
-0.080094941,
-0.0257023443,
0.0343099795,
0.0100006228,
-0.0010148142,
-0.0689906999,
-0.0569508858,
0.0531264096,
-0.0343041122,
0.00250402,
-0.0042532524,
-0.0164391212,
0.0575746559,
-0.0159597397,
0.0093758963,
0.0279796757,
0.0172979161,
-0.0316498056,
-0.0102247298,
-0.0301111657,
0.0297344681,
0.0007463808,
0.0485214107,
-0.0231138375,
-0.0041129449,
-0.0565945506,
-0.009605973,
0.0016201149,
0.0118996231,
-0.0346255451,
0.0034382292,
-0.0127696143,
-0.0256612953,
-0.0140493279,
0.05025585,
-0.0279541425,
-0.0062641632,
0.0167926308,
-0.0221148971,
-0.0310006719,
0.0234558433,
-0.003229714,
-0.0030297642,
-0.0028688021,
0.0488983989,
-0.0192832947,
-0.0421913341,
-0.0080097495,
-0.0577918924,
-0.0184813924,
-0.0756826252,
0.0227416921,
-0.0717177987,
-0.0228991173,
-0.0167972799,
-0.0097627686,
-0.0406427421,
-0.004498282,
0.0234400183,
-0.0437440239,
0.0022504935,
-0.017278038,
-0.0156053556,
0.0056567257,
0.0104992883,
0.0147467051,
0.0712753087,
0.0424426794,
0.0240669455,
0.0252652001,
0.0426686481,
0.0123918941,
-0.0010562829,
0.0382376127,
0.0258222912,
0.0215033721,
-0.0253395308,
-0.0309515838,
-0.0035453343,
0.0575225204,
0.0317412317,
-0.0596091561,
0.0163205508,
0.0579218008,
0.0482186899,
0.0171746612,
-0.0151743721,
0.0519357547,
-0.0062355422,
0.0589695051,
0.0693994239,
-0.0331297778,
0.0260417163,
-0.0324463136,
0.0667606965,
0.0642076507,
0.015206988,
-0.0264673997,
-0.0408892073,
0.0060145529,
-0.0124197658,
-0.0230298862,
-0.0277301315,
0.0528759621,
0.0142948469,
-0.0413123146,
0.0233934987,
0.0049055549,
-0.0587348342,
0.0194891244,
-0.0022650096,
0.0194612406,
-0.0062387218,
0.0524301305,
-0.0417953543,
-0.0324530937,
-0.0168176014,
0.020991195,
0.0527625345,
0.0259767007,
-0.023631731,
-0.0092641348,
-0.0303323362,
-0.0290851872,
-0.0309431069,
0.0547924563,
-0.009798659,
-0.0079339975,
-0.007053738,
0.0450073965,
-0.0298268888,
-0.0156269148,
0.0332110301,
-0.0414406545,
-0.0237643011,
0.0002314885,
-0.0307319537,
0.0061714686,
0.040445976,
-0.0401417352,
0.0214065686,
0.0009069495,
-0.0075878073,
-0.0025710023,
0.0074870451,
-0.0185476039,
-0.0113707976,
0.0384364016,
-0.0859964639,
-0.0073614502,
0.0005319031,
-0.051335033,
-0.0345890298,
0.0229863636,
-0.0102503747,
-0.0370953642,
-0.039146658,
0.008836329,
0.028255675,
0.0008709522,
-0.0087666363,
0.0486554168,
0.0253079273,
-0.0155064072,
0.0429590158,
-0.0677822754,
0.0092014913,
-0.0260951258,
-0.0038005945,
-0.0059691272,
0.0077447481,
0.0189921726,
0.042641174,
-0.0057683163,
-0.0336855091,
0.0041188532,
-0.0920139179,
0.0298104826,
-0.0269937646,
0.0083456179,
0.0531290732,
0.0053000227,
0.0036342847,
0.0018411314,
-0.0100946538,
-0.052075237,
0.0170252956,
0.011690136,
0.0362047255,
0.0195126049,
0.0633779392,
-0.0574553832,
-0.0106749898,
-0.0266910139,
0.0619760677,
0.0069964728,
-0.0170525387,
0.0047383993,
0.0409936868,
-0.0270194132,
-0.0285843648,
0.0076778089,
0.0076889619,
0.0023003521,
0.0238856729,
-0.0003111422,
0.0450317673,
0.0297795068,
0.0153315514,
0.0367242321,
0.0210081153,
-0.0313828066,
-0.0230599549,
-0.0320577137,
0.0116500407,
0.0269121137,
-0.0005191489,
0.0442263894,
0.0596895702,
0.0016439086,
0.0004731454,
-0.0190604609,
0.0555921644,
-0.0423114859,
-0.0151373055,
-0.0292681605,
0.0116914827,
0.0079000387,
0.0665103421,
-0.0246982202,
0.0043406086,
0.0630397871,
-0.0230708029,
0.0439941697,
-0.0385577343,
0.01414405,
-0.0669611841,
-0.000528262,
0.0044869962,
-0.0002435404,
0.0451248959,
0.0034060604,
-0.0227644145,
-0.0253268238,
0.0534148514,
-0.0116902133,
0.1086700782,
-0.0444703698,
0.0339433998,
-0.0511277318,
-0.0049757562,
-0.0149037624,
-0.0517291687,
-0.0271787439,
0.050029818,
-0.0298521668,
0.0119105456,
-0.0782852322,
-0.0040950333,
0.0514977612,
0.0764928609,
-0.0339682437,
-0.0128983129,
-0.0014963099,
0.061951261,
0.0657486692,
0.0052678613,
0.0193374641,
-0.0278727617,
0.0150359431,
0.0514031798,
0.0000382953,
0.0491613932,
0.0041530775,
-0.0190964621,
-0.0250419918,
-0.0823423564,
0.0074310522,
-0.0104516177,
0.0442433059,
-0.034239199,
0.0101818638,
0.1151817441,
0.0174001474,
-0.016651487,
-0.0033533666,
0.0156967565,
-0.0145741776,
0.0083378367,
-0.0143786659,
-0.1202370077,
-0.0164342001,
-0.0125340223,
0.0277878605,
-0.0061372006,
-0.0397332162,
-0.0232338682,
-0.1135052368,
0.0257918537,
0.0308874212,
-0.0674235597,
-0.0123264669,
-0.0259632785,
0.0229572207,
-0.0396162048,
0.014004956,
0.0168435145,
-0.0387257636,
0.0236633141,
0.0238896813,
-0.0444197208,
-0.0471673049,
-0.0049331184,
-0.0270861778,
0.022706138,
0.0652946457,
0.0176393725,
-0.0062561813,
0.0677507371,
0.0179830715,
-0.0246130526,
-0.0332603976,
0.0132135293,
0.0941832736,
-0.0288085453,
0.0223724693,
-0.0061951256,
0.0397787578,
0.0228691138,
-0.0205848925,
0.007101927,
0.0092355683,
0.0130926613,
-0.0286716856,
-0.0712005273,
0.0439652205,
-0.0585471019,
0.0661230683,
0.0542849191,
0.0228839852,
-0.0286879949,
-0.0306783803,
-0.0149398632,
-0.0899337158,
-0.0655540302,
0.0052386131,
-0.0520608462,
-0.0359596573,
-0.0706192926,
-0.0754629076,
0.022472484,
-0.0097481078,
-0.0167492274,
-0.0354242325,
0.0249393955,
0.0006176664,
-0.0130367894,
-0.0052671842,
-0.0309694838,
-0.0187815409,
-0.0374299735,
0.000889642,
0.06084425,
-0.0075774197,
-0.0216659363,
-0.0069030449,
-0.0310051553,
-0.0404088721,
-0.0201736428,
0.0476639122,
0.0267102905,
0.0356536321,
0.0085266624,
-0.0192809142,
0.0705050603,
0.0768422484,
0.008870542,
0.0463208444,
0.026660461,
-0.0059932782,
-0.0139798382,
-0.0028019892,
-0.0462670438,
0.0566415228,
-0.0186197199,
0.020286506,
-0.0238090269,
-0.0274993163,
0.0118111111,
0.0319400877,
0.0386417545,
-0.0214626193,
0.0283602327,
-0.0149511602,
-0.0396161899,
-0.0502899811,
-0.0107208658,
-0.0238678996,
0.005991864,
-0.0041389996,
0.0103911133,
-0.0176562332,
0.0699847937,
-0.0748227239,
0.0499803387,
-0.0501975492,
-0.0067912908,
0.000723583,
-0.0123232976,
-0.0641724616,
-0.0263132118,
-0.0489603728,
-0.0291764867,
-0.0365904272,
0.02199037,
-0.0171816479,
-0.0113723837,
0.0228640251,
0.0388801694,
0.0070839361,
0.0248040836,
-0.0906748995,
0.0674786046,
-0.0558363274,
0.0279303025,
0.0664162561,
-0.0468566529,
0.0759197772,
-0.0149540128,
-0.0047486057,
-0.0304294992,
0.0286694188,
0.0230421219,
0.0259145815,
-0.029276276,
0.0291050244,
0.0042540976,
0.0136659853,
0.1138586625,
0.0172419548,
0.0266949628,
0.0285319593,
-0.0128969196,
-0.0237819348,
-0.0415295735,
-0.0353882201,
0.0025264858,
0.0046244147,
-0.0528097488,
-0.1162703633,
-0.0220575705,
0.0501493588,
0.0203406177,
0.0202183798,
-0.0220347587,
0.0033432834,
-0.0006646789,
0.0064986995,
0.0128390789,
-0.0608130693,
0.000178972,
-0.0131588997,
-0.0031121131,
-0.0032323869,
-5.520025963e-33,
-0.0481008366,
-0.0117581477,
-0.0120595042,
-0.015977243,
-0.0335365459,
0.0252060853,
-0.0646626353,
0.0011887433,
-0.0089726476,
0.0204349328,
-0.0180057082,
0.006120807,
0.0181931872,
0.0128614688,
0.005051712,
0.0036892295,
0.0442656279,
-0.0127261067,
-0.0596622229,
0.0110686608,
0.0085686985,
-0.0125007452,
0.0418098383,
-0.0475683957,
0.0571824387,
-0.0142912073,
-0.0276762247,
-0.0473957434,
0.04379154,
0.045709122,
-0.0010227198,
0.0292538721,
0.0456855781,
-0.0615232587,
-0.0480856299,
-0.0220809858,
-0.0909064114,
-0.0219712965,
0.0476450436,
-0.0541746579,
-0.0201228615,
-0.0442557223,
0.048269812,
-0.0100677414,
0.0010747692,
-0.0827077478,
0.0523902215,
-0.0460469276,
-0.0390137658,
-0.0780692548,
-0.0534178726,
0.0299087707,
-0.0196644142,
-0.0153685408,
0.0259622131,
0.0451342873,
0.003812595,
0.0443763882,
-0.0353300497,
0.0396951512,
0.0205067229,
0.0525081754,
0.0366653055,
-0.0345675237,
-0.0076037841,
0.0765170306,
-0.0068812966,
0.0025985097,
-0.0426353812,
0.015718665,
0.0109632527,
0.0053616711,
0.0042596878,
0.0789691359,
0.0732238367,
0.0400156267,
-0.0597768277,
0.0819596723,
-0.0221171714,
0.011502102,
-0.0030861073,
-0.0226638857,
0.0286217798,
0.0118013937,
-0.0177790355,
-0.0059112823,
0.0007033987,
-0.0170586519,
-0.0250532441,
0.0059253238,
-0.0426744893,
0.0215005744,
0.0209054202,
-0.0380915403,
0.0385040678,
0.0176497586,
-0.037501283,
0.0399233922,
0.0026618852,
-0.0211681724,
-0.0436519682,
0.0211387612,
0.0258235447,
0.0451031215,
0.0179024041,
-0.0035874639,
0.0854208097,
-0.0188379548,
-0.0197019018,
-0.0075233667,
0.0053488826,
0.0218914319,
-0.0254894979,
0.0433802605,
-0.0146118393,
0.0423162878,
0.005802426,
0.02110775,
-0.0214297194,
-0.0240620058,
0.0068253465,
0.0398972593,
0.0227673929,
0.0255306344,
-0.0191381574,
0.0098632919,
-0.0051288856,
0.0292378422,
0.0429627337,
-0.0315606259,
-0.0109854555,
-0.0031777115,
2.233e-7,
0.0555352941,
0.0315914191,
0.0545947291,
-0.0034342916,
-0.0115126604,
0.0513772182,
-0.0182029512,
0.0452945232,
0.0247332323,
-0.0170843862,
0.0235139392,
0.0223641489,
0.0421531983,
0.0312764011,
-0.0904278532,
-0.0327754281,
-0.0607929267,
-0.0417617634,
-0.0205457676,
-0.0269789863,
0.0321541689,
0.0353743173,
-0.0199119225,
-0.0001873595,
0.0001354762,
-0.0038931631,
0.0509828664,
0.0228097271,
-0.0538127124,
0.0172387678,
0.043562755,
0.0093749966,
0.0028314486,
-0.0203382205,
-0.0169201773,
-0.0184383653,
0.0335707292,
0.0623448156,
0.0091998773,
-0.0052921395,
-0.0024852725,
-0.015715966,
0.0300797559,
0.0494803265,
0.0596967377,
-0.0662554875,
-0.0224918853,
-0.044172693,
-0.0806688368,
0.0294045135,
0.0133795934,
0.0103460653,
-0.0324532017,
0.0602381304,
0.0130090462,
0.0106833596,
-0.0109334085,
-0.0339878164,
-0.0475979894,
0.0195197463,
-0.001568596,
-0.0269039143,
0.0273964889,
-0.0064500854,
0.0004491388,
-0.0917121843,
-0.0099207228,
1.885037205e-34,
0.104453288,
-0.0072623012,
-0.0217375346,
-0.014539144,
-0.0035918707,
-0.0115499413,
-0.0403809734,
-0.0188336503,
-0.0017119166,
-0.0432945788,
0.0088275308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03507v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03507v1 | Neural networks for abstraction and reasoning: Towards broad generalization in machines | 2024-02-05T20:48:57 | 2024-02-05T20:48:57 | Mikel Bober-Irizar, Soumya Banerjee | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | For half a century, artificial intelligence research has attempted to
reproduce the human qualities of abstraction and reasoning - creating computer
systems that can learn new concepts from a minimal set of examples, in settings
where humans find this easy. While specific neural networks are able to solve
an impressive range of problems, broad generalisation to situations outside
their training data has proved elusive.In this work, we look at several novel
approaches for solving the Abstraction & Reasoning Corpus (ARC), a dataset of
abstract visual reasoning tasks introduced to test algorithms on broad
generalization. Despite three international competitions with $100,000 in
prizes, the best algorithms still fail to solve a majority of ARC tasks and
rely on complex hand-crafted rules, without using machine learning at all. We
revisit whether recent advances in neural networks allow progress on this task.
First, we adapt the DreamCoder neurosymbolic reasoning solver to ARC.
DreamCoder automatically writes programs in a bespoke domain-specific language
to perform reasoning, using a neural network to mimic human intuition. We
present the Perceptual Abstraction and Reasoning Language (PeARL) language,
which allows DreamCoder to solve ARC tasks, and propose a new recognition model
that allows us to significantly improve on the previous best implementation.We
also propose a new encoding and augmentation scheme that allows large language
models (LLMs) to solve ARC tasks, and find that the largest models can solve
some ARC tasks. LLMs are able to solve a different group of problems to
state-of-the-art solvers, and provide an interesting way to complement other
approaches. We perform an ensemble analysis, combining models to achieve better
results than any system alone. Finally, we publish the arckit Python library to
make future research on ARC easier. | [
0.0178083796,
0.0779087245,
-0.0232705865,
0.0392820835,
-0.0322921984,
0.0309864879,
0.030405825,
0.0080547892,
-0.0187597014,
-0.0022086289,
0.0312652104,
-0.0205093417,
-0.0067158812,
0.0852833986,
0.0389134698,
-0.0696192458,
-0.0148257082,
-0.01823131,
0.0207597725,
-0.0025149577,
-0.0256441869,
0.0117259659,
-0.0169629753,
0.0479606614,
-0.0368000753,
-0.0061971047,
-0.0388181917,
-0.0260196514,
0.022332361,
-0.0076196166,
-0.025350919,
0.0038172845,
0.0730329677,
0.0023923172,
0.0000024298,
-0.0386954397,
0.03549603,
-0.0113303252,
-0.0154927466,
-0.034522932,
-0.0350881703,
-0.0360507891,
0.0281264205,
-0.0072972886,
-0.0435365811,
-0.0097795129,
0.0678273141,
0.0478910767,
0.0779047981,
0.0407341234,
-0.0142876552,
-0.0390237793,
-0.0091432072,
0.010436058,
0.0187353827,
0.009465497,
0.0058255685,
0.040959347,
0.0029811903,
-0.0601874515,
-0.0274121799,
0.0183266196,
0.0796899945,
-0.0035200587,
0.0103088329,
0.0362857245,
-0.06600485,
-0.0477843694,
-0.0189520624,
0.0516787022,
-0.0492276512,
-0.0174815934,
-0.0045290291,
0.0125080636,
0.0084140915,
0.0023344154,
-0.0367984846,
0.0462594815,
-0.0084994948,
0.016192643,
-0.0399932638,
-0.0017959906,
0.0218212903,
0.0039443057,
-0.0653708056,
0.0441353694,
-0.0187962595,
0.0178150497,
0.0678059459,
0.0168393105,
-0.0274928622,
-0.0518207587,
0.0441618897,
0.0509864651,
-0.003672576,
-0.0033801622,
-0.0015870787,
-0.0430165492,
-0.0561546013,
-0.0217138976,
0.0486012101,
0.0565073416,
0.0049698032,
0.0402261615,
-0.0649650097,
0.0663025677,
-0.0351748243,
0.0377097577,
-0.0271321479,
-0.0254727453,
-0.048349306,
-0.0167962499,
-0.0299821775,
0.0511242114,
-0.0521002896,
-0.0210213009,
-0.0163182821,
0.0040806117,
-0.041822914,
0.0231890287,
-0.0057437243,
0.0648089945,
0.0311152227,
-0.051871825,
-0.0377110206,
-0.020225063,
-0.0537995026,
0.0160340182,
0.0048757219,
0.0036048742,
0.0052233962,
0.0098939454,
0.0006938629,
0.0032845594,
0.0239931438,
0.0837244615,
-0.0249575302,
0.0258848611,
-0.0325057432,
-0.0294934642,
0.0396234617,
-0.0572362505,
0.0601773746,
-0.0760690942,
0.036718633,
-0.008894504,
-0.0157338735,
-0.0570377037,
0.0156181911,
-0.0022739409,
-0.0019823948,
0.0812271312,
-0.0163178034,
-0.0046169842,
0.0379207097,
0.0106801828,
-0.0411218219,
0.0339074731,
0.0406441018,
0.0483438,
-0.0177627727,
-0.0013124379,
0.0645790845,
0.0166283939,
-0.0075609321,
-0.0498394892,
-0.0043139746,
-0.0368451625,
-0.0674199387,
0.0353600197,
-0.0062663094,
0.0443812236,
-0.0423858613,
-0.0593220331,
0.0351822488,
0.0723234341,
-0.0367882624,
0.0332222208,
0.0622413568,
-0.0375575051,
0.0165558029,
-0.0302688982,
-0.0372268297,
0.0782308578,
0.0105116637,
-0.02226853,
-0.0626342595,
0.0199272726,
-0.0364491902,
-0.0625971928,
0.0011727152,
-0.0075849025,
0.0132315615,
0.0254070871,
0.0698780641,
-0.0060617132,
-0.0156097952,
0.0377410464,
-0.0177114271,
-0.0180230085,
-0.009968915,
-0.0454794951,
0.0110644838,
0.0367516093,
0.0194364544,
-0.0245121252,
-0.0056312047,
-0.0174685866,
0.0232888982,
0.0426551178,
0.0017677289,
0.0071958182,
0.0219023302,
-0.0653725117,
-0.0147990938,
-0.0295149516,
0.0023555206,
0.0336386673,
0.01885565,
-0.0018068991,
-0.0076403562,
-0.0383936837,
-0.0308532342,
0.0418763943,
-0.0093171839,
0.011284709,
0.008222783,
0.0467499644,
0.0043415413,
-0.0054126051,
0.0002088265,
-0.0049880282,
0.0023770065,
-0.0759482309,
-0.0335254595,
0.0020735285,
-0.0495409742,
-0.0039440766,
0.0271633342,
-0.0932883993,
-0.0421791747,
0.0564535335,
-0.0553916693,
-0.0031675247,
0.0572879724,
-0.005592986,
0.0124549111,
-0.0289554931,
-0.0086515769,
0.0136672016,
-0.0222687535,
0.0083349356,
0.0665701926,
-0.0146371052,
-0.0332703702,
-0.02264731,
-0.0148867918,
0.0499993488,
-0.0196160506,
-0.0158958714,
-0.005510442,
-0.0350303985,
-0.0123465071,
-0.0070427461,
0.0108201988,
-0.0460497662,
0.0251641404,
-0.0557816513,
-0.0109714679,
0.0109183714,
-0.042974174,
0.0165188853,
-0.0325133614,
0.0236565024,
-0.0216981042,
-0.0405607522,
0.0323836505,
-0.0183596946,
-0.015716834,
0.029943971,
-0.0124688577,
-0.0251838863,
0.0134113645,
-0.0293935686,
-0.018533079,
0.0684583187,
0.0226674583,
-0.0245759021,
-0.0349005498,
-0.0038363284,
-0.0308573674,
0.0409048647,
-0.008296364,
-0.0315865315,
0.032209333,
-0.0297289751,
-0.0466258302,
0.0883410424,
-0.0157966483,
0.018389415,
0.0316011161,
0.002985297,
-0.0267014541,
0.0106158014,
-0.0041466039,
0.0171462055,
0.0172680803,
-0.0255844761,
-0.0236617215,
0.0434257947,
-0.0041619735,
-0.0065012025,
-0.0661958009,
0.0520884581,
0.0223525837,
-0.0477021448,
-0.0725142434,
-0.0530098975,
0.0185853373,
0.0609234348,
-0.0408377051,
-0.0385931805,
0.0879927874,
0.0190850832,
0.0030476134,
0.0060555516,
-0.0106492238,
-0.0245147217,
0.0975302756,
0.0091014551,
0.026925765,
0.0325641558,
-0.0348730609,
-0.0507190786,
-0.0123293782,
-0.0219191872,
0.003578726,
0.0587666146,
-0.0754794702,
0.0020125238,
0.0080397706,
-0.0441381074,
-0.054454226,
0.0164114144,
-0.0392847508,
0.0144547829,
-0.0315823592,
-0.0251110233,
-0.02870759,
0.0162632167,
0.0115542412,
0.0140420748,
0.0047394419,
-0.0040375441,
-0.0187681802,
0.0180489123,
0.0219462477,
0.0206129979,
0.0037768392,
-0.0330641307,
0.0270388033,
0.0391740501,
-0.0048590046,
0.0097681442,
-0.1100115255,
0.0773499981,
-0.0389243849,
0.0171674471,
0.026837904,
0.0010721468,
0.0400754437,
-0.0718129799,
-0.0021001813,
0.0746124312,
0.0289724413,
-0.0042143976,
-0.0026736648,
-0.0314158201,
-0.0070718867,
0.0400348455,
0.0651051328,
-0.0726294667,
-0.0367901102,
0.0194854494,
-0.015203164,
0.0184672661,
-0.0576871447,
-0.0076834345,
-0.0758317187,
0.0487709083,
0.0224753004,
-0.0495572649,
-0.06751284,
0.0290815216,
0.0027900485,
0.0067243441,
-0.0520734899,
-0.0041996408,
0.0462677628,
-0.0050447918,
-0.0028354707,
0.010422647,
-0.0000136194,
0.0383918174,
-0.0478743389,
-0.0178390257,
0.0494117774,
0.0235888921,
-0.0072689326,
-0.0393939614,
0.0538778864,
0.0015264426,
0.0075609921,
0.0032901336,
0.0232498851,
0.0388309918,
-0.0423260294,
0.0230901167,
0.0521716848,
-0.0344505943,
-0.03766701,
-0.0037804591,
0.0723652318,
-0.0344394408,
-0.030761376,
-0.0314305574,
-0.0045540831,
-0.0291374028,
0.0421495438,
0.053787794,
-0.0133617427,
-0.0520492755,
-0.0384397171,
-0.0382438488,
-0.0503730848,
-0.009458757,
0.0071384716,
0.047011219,
-0.012315345,
-0.0673723221,
0.0007314778,
0.0738907456,
0.0395963043,
0.0198397096,
-0.0778968036,
0.0438979305,
-0.0138693787,
-0.0713052675,
0.0489121154,
-0.0099993851,
0.0049742525,
0.0146835623,
-0.0190497562,
-0.0158891864,
-0.0488055609,
-0.0220661797,
0.0300729815,
-0.0174893867,
-0.038853135,
-0.0172665399,
0.0576514676,
0.0285659023,
0.0234330427,
0.002783865,
-0.0284768865,
0.0583412573,
0.0640986785,
0.0626103058,
0.0072339512,
-0.0074277851,
0.0036291895,
0.0036694743,
0.006443067,
-0.013299007,
0.034539897,
0.0255176108,
-0.0001257603,
-0.0164603163,
0.081957832,
0.0191509183,
0.0078905011,
-0.012842414,
0.0169527996,
-0.0204641856,
-0.0421972685,
-0.0038432237,
0.006951761,
-0.0078711882,
-0.0607093088,
-0.0120493127,
0.0005592232,
0.0175509453,
0.0185119007,
-0.0146400668,
0.0640235022,
-0.0059895325,
0.0074743624,
-0.0192225873,
0.0094138645,
0.0264315177,
-0.0064390739,
-0.0001324031,
-0.0176833291,
0.0213208068,
-0.0337827243,
0.0526538193,
-0.0143518364,
0.0592029355,
0.0385676138,
-0.0025462066,
-0.0599618405,
0.0286225975,
-0.0542321876,
-0.102867566,
0.0191641003,
0.0226793326,
0.0463515744,
-0.0096130939,
-0.0504286662,
-0.0465859659,
0.0021613911,
0.029780468,
0.0081848195,
0.0141761871,
-0.0158080179,
0.0434910059,
0.0393793099,
0.0197227038,
-0.0378874131,
0.0176274199,
-0.0752704516,
0.0384101532,
-0.0240903571,
-0.007898882,
-0.0373725854,
0.0046112509,
0.0126044862,
-0.013333437,
0.0279502105,
0.008433735,
-0.0277087893,
-0.0769366995,
0.0095127402,
0.0503014587,
0.0130896643,
0.0455121174,
0.045007892,
0.0155773396,
0.0182258077,
-0.0331366062,
0.0329101831,
-0.0165258702,
-0.0202059783,
-0.0141941169,
-0.0353285596,
-6.422228162e-33,
-0.0061874548,
-0.0159072559,
0.0233429763,
-0.0233476665,
0.0005707581,
-0.0047562611,
-0.0659937784,
-0.02803245,
-0.0246308111,
0.0184173342,
0.0060637435,
0.0054018814,
-0.0039600646,
0.0237258337,
0.0433411933,
-0.0082812356,
-0.015764961,
-0.0058779176,
-0.0249060839,
-0.0211636163,
0.0293720849,
-0.0009856621,
0.0190598052,
-0.0752622783,
-0.0462419949,
0.04904975,
-0.0092988862,
0.0378510728,
-0.0313030705,
0.0273444261,
-0.0177466143,
-0.0054378873,
0.0386244766,
0.0029221668,
-0.0134596536,
0.0097179404,
-0.0466393344,
-0.0373488292,
0.0030347358,
0.0033983639,
-0.0939850509,
-0.0129432138,
0.0894505903,
-0.0107204933,
0.0045080935,
-0.0272100326,
0.0396774299,
-0.0532154292,
0.0526962951,
-0.0187027175,
-0.004669847,
-0.0314804465,
-0.0379086956,
-0.0145648178,
0.0253393874,
0.0090378607,
-0.0339174792,
0.0148350997,
-0.0638371408,
0.027599683,
0.0108719002,
-0.0323974453,
0.0646208003,
0.0146338046,
0.030375082,
0.0654131696,
0.0562794469,
-0.0477404185,
-0.0508199111,
0.0491287932,
0.0157697648,
0.0839825869,
0.0779519081,
-0.0081202732,
0.0359882414,
0.0161841661,
-0.0536795743,
-0.0028631571,
-0.0533543117,
0.0799660236,
0.0332094319,
0.0220242888,
0.0073964582,
-0.0107548125,
-0.0241374709,
-0.020537667,
-0.0484327897,
-0.0156018324,
0.020664528,
-0.0154537177,
-0.0132728461,
0.0296172518,
0.0290462673,
-0.0519883372,
0.0315818898,
0.0014044677,
0.0258547254,
0.0345194079,
0.0295772497,
0.0041265381,
-0.0009493511,
-0.0091803847,
0.0182404779,
-0.0035081832,
0.0585944951,
0.0220264364,
0.0420582294,
0.0366598777,
0.0027871118,
-0.0142325396,
-0.0650797933,
-0.0053993585,
0.0501077138,
0.0463209264,
0.0144391321,
0.0358919874,
-0.0381139629,
-0.0266651232,
-0.0394129641,
-0.0200208183,
-0.006888797,
0.0538144596,
0.0019510855,
0.0398648717,
-0.0258209128,
-0.0188833978,
-0.0502064601,
-0.0384720005,
0.0372221172,
-0.0541059077,
-0.0105738165,
0.0173573475,
3.086e-7,
-0.0117268292,
0.0120550506,
0.0212865882,
0.0383392945,
0.0314019248,
0.0423316397,
-0.009320532,
-0.0159337148,
0.0045642788,
-0.0867680386,
-0.0138508445,
0.0851927027,
0.035389252,
0.0048494814,
-0.0460902676,
0.0294090901,
0.0469434485,
-0.0447702669,
-0.0501073673,
0.0333486795,
0.0731017813,
0.0568385199,
0.046471227,
-0.0178138446,
0.0674217194,
-0.0464195609,
0.0367984958,
-0.0280970428,
0.0516324379,
-0.0223068316,
-0.0437102132,
0.0380869173,
-0.0165530108,
0.0552736893,
-0.0069387308,
-0.0116882194,
0.0122566223,
0.0143422419,
-0.0166632123,
0.0054233707,
-0.019466931,
0.0136542525,
-0.0009649905,
-0.0353631675,
0.0602307506,
-0.0677332878,
-0.0345153026,
0.000613136,
-0.0072066509,
-0.0235993788,
-0.0003959571,
0.0033557785,
0.0247556213,
0.0032846525,
-0.0005498967,
-0.0152198989,
0.0025999446,
-0.0987844542,
-0.0023126721,
0.0046972604,
-0.0372415893,
0.0322757885,
-0.0225880835,
0.0161832701,
0.0372521728,
-0.0474271923,
-0.0551746152,
2.648884914e-34,
-0.0127961254,
0.00081265,
0.00819775,
0.0468028523,
0.0541734286,
-0.0167339258,
-0.0369328298,
0.0004748095,
-0.0032360395,
-0.0457304753,
-0.0321374238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03501v1 | An Inpainting-Infused Pipeline for Attire and Background Replacement | 2024-02-05T20:34:32 | 2024-02-05T20:34:32 | Felipe Rodrigues Perche-Mahlow, André Felipe-Zanella, William Alberto Cruz-Castañeda, Marcellus Amadeus | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | In recent years, groundbreaking advancements in Generative Artificial
Intelligence (GenAI) have triggered a transformative paradigm shift,
significantly influencing various domains. In this work, we specifically
explore an integrated approach, leveraging advanced techniques in GenAI and
computer vision emphasizing image manipulation. The methodology unfolds through
several stages, including depth estimation, the creation of inpaint masks based
on depth information, the generation and replacement of backgrounds utilizing
Stable Diffusion in conjunction with Latent Consistency Models (LCMs), and the
subsequent replacement of clothes and application of aesthetic changes through
an inpainting pipeline. Experiments conducted in this study underscore the
methodology's efficacy, highlighting its potential to produce visually
captivating content. The convergence of these advanced techniques allows users
to input photographs of individuals and manipulate them to modify clothing and
background based on specific prompts without manually input inpainting masks,
effectively placing the subjects within the vast landscape of creative
imagination. | [
0.0132051632,
0.0756141394,
-0.0066033583,
0.0082635302,
-0.0390979834,
-0.0138643226,
-0.0087263528,
-0.0297883712,
-0.0403294489,
0.030854404,
0.0474076755,
-0.0474310145,
0.0263766572,
0.0408065505,
0.0118593173,
-0.0796493068,
-0.0681319311,
-0.0307680126,
-0.0655647442,
-0.0054222476,
-0.0060530216,
-0.0198950823,
-0.0086021181,
-0.0185034033,
-0.0163694676,
-0.026172515,
-0.017009886,
0.0395392068,
0.0116645535,
0.0151117127,
0.0015500602,
0.0249316767,
0.0318545103,
-0.0443333946,
0.0000020772,
-0.0121644624,
0.0574817508,
0.0017377343,
0.0602695607,
0.029712474,
-0.0002110254,
0.0089802481,
-0.0386858359,
-0.0528160594,
-0.0180811081,
0.0637327209,
0.0776981339,
0.049399592,
0.0936696827,
-0.0461116582,
-0.0234264489,
-0.0560840927,
0.0063277227,
0.0062791505,
0.045542933,
0.0367859229,
0.0338341556,
-0.0096943807,
0.0522105657,
-0.0612490997,
-0.034867011,
0.0487237982,
0.0114958771,
0.01281395,
0.0462595783,
0.0070886109,
0.0671220794,
-0.0621380806,
0.0108534517,
0.0013587661,
-0.0672346503,
0.042573005,
-0.01153717,
-0.0026098988,
-0.0218011588,
0.042983707,
-0.0124922739,
-0.0215208996,
-0.0256328452,
0.0170399174,
-0.0923920572,
-0.0396556146,
0.0203224849,
0.0044793379,
-0.0204149988,
-0.0099444157,
0.0624774173,
-0.0203749463,
-0.05429966,
-0.0134760225,
-0.0383345857,
-0.0486683585,
0.0118547566,
-0.0026825191,
-0.0042307591,
0.019524999,
-0.0156868696,
0.0071983268,
-0.02222028,
-0.0040073842,
0.048720669,
0.037218146,
-0.0340140238,
0.0419039689,
0.0494874567,
0.0293190219,
-0.0451804437,
-0.0323024727,
-0.0401021652,
-0.0161424261,
0.0576887801,
-0.0293584261,
-0.0376024432,
-0.0492533483,
-0.0636582375,
-0.0221227799,
-0.0415438488,
-0.0035927473,
-0.0410341546,
0.0068541695,
0.0053064432,
0.059931118,
-0.0451820381,
0.025522735,
-0.0323259272,
-0.0422693677,
0.0087402631,
0.0710989311,
-0.0167420488,
0.0117175151,
-0.003399018,
-0.027027566,
0.0181118585,
-0.0033684894,
-0.017216526,
0.0066597979,
-0.0421327874,
0.0798472986,
-0.0474019013,
0.0300806351,
0.0415860228,
-0.0478132926,
0.0434379689,
-0.0230523702,
-0.0081818579,
-0.0767816082,
0.0149960499,
-0.0238156673,
-0.0040826243,
0.01697978,
-0.0255320389,
0.09150929,
0.0136981057,
0.0357647277,
0.0257756505,
0.0037618128,
-0.0257560369,
-0.0112000704,
0.0042834026,
0.0418489985,
-0.0128004486,
-0.0367850363,
0.0371345729,
0.0074503957,
0.0041569485,
0.0028959764,
-0.0312713422,
-0.0442596972,
0.0281293318,
0.046020437,
0.0462451577,
0.0269466601,
-0.0512610935,
0.0336738564,
0.0899472907,
-0.0255157724,
0.0268459916,
0.0262484364,
0.0735702142,
0.0048503466,
-0.0090405541,
0.0145592364,
0.0507071838,
0.0508374497,
0.0435405709,
0.0053729699,
-0.0221301168,
-0.0000081465,
-0.058441177,
-0.0162656549,
0.0430443808,
-0.0311305076,
0.0742609426,
-0.0089875394,
0.0175455511,
0.0471217334,
-0.0131666204,
-0.0619560815,
-0.0211383328,
-0.0517177768,
-0.0015718421,
-0.0221415162,
-0.0059738755,
0.1366216838,
-0.0157098137,
0.0543381833,
0.0604905561,
0.0229628813,
0.0334749967,
0.0161183663,
-0.0591531582,
-0.0212911572,
0.047687754,
-0.0082327081,
-0.0080907084,
-0.0316227339,
0.0052086473,
0.0035850669,
-0.018352231,
0.0134690823,
-0.0002364078,
0.0556485765,
0.0507074855,
0.0110852383,
-0.0832167193,
0.0120018134,
0.0101544149,
0.0184940062,
-0.0090459371,
0.0164124686,
0.0016523576,
-0.0075324709,
0.0037634356,
-0.0161575023,
-0.011707576,
0.0414493121,
0.0239144079,
0.0415913165,
-0.0019717691,
-0.0867971182,
-0.0370192714,
-0.003469147,
0.0206952803,
-0.0168140009,
0.0217169914,
-0.0282927752,
-0.0079575432,
-0.0511560105,
-0.0581861064,
0.0099608554,
0.0081791347,
-0.0015700241,
0.0481976271,
-0.020838581,
-0.0199984349,
0.0327008963,
0.0287063885,
-0.0242583789,
-0.0100461422,
-0.0047765989,
-0.0398995243,
0.0282956287,
0.0272518378,
-0.0393516868,
-0.0116620064,
-0.0426967293,
0.012492137,
-0.0368181765,
-0.0431186743,
0.0194255505,
-0.0520553924,
-0.0399780162,
0.0173926596,
0.0056251432,
0.0127046844,
-0.0057170191,
0.028757818,
-0.0232259501,
-0.0041766721,
0.0196024124,
0.0617539026,
-0.0237946138,
-0.0370162576,
0.0339512751,
0.0575691126,
0.0113586197,
0.0539261214,
-0.0523323938,
-0.0463988483,
-0.0274511557,
-0.0343228765,
0.045231849,
0.0046428945,
-0.0175066832,
-0.007508425,
-0.021613393,
0.0518129654,
0.0645130277,
0.0375395194,
-0.0190461054,
-0.0063249934,
-0.0298185069,
0.0169226676,
0.0096216109,
0.0010766512,
0.0027809239,
0.0551658385,
-0.0150602153,
0.0280387588,
-0.0278260671,
0.0104274293,
0.0006235943,
-0.0413533561,
0.0557246581,
0.0245115608,
-0.0584095828,
0.0202147122,
-0.0067767114,
-0.0400646701,
0.0370461792,
-0.0769429952,
-0.0415972993,
0.0324523374,
0.024200011,
-0.0330361053,
0.0616870411,
0.005070549,
0.0351670757,
-0.0062914458,
0.0127133029,
0.0232681055,
-0.0287036207,
0.010224442,
0.0032472673,
0.0125945406,
0.0430560783,
-0.0290018991,
-0.0259083714,
-0.1052681133,
-0.0176496617,
0.0204163678,
-0.0399850048,
-0.034658961,
-0.0255166534,
0.0144178579,
-0.0098053832,
-0.0195581857,
-0.0011997267,
0.02239158,
0.012987854,
-0.0339614749,
0.0569926277,
0.0164745748,
0.0153852087,
0.0027602743,
0.0150581682,
0.0384947769,
0.0153152701,
-0.0670002401,
-0.0167687964,
-0.0224449206,
0.0315968432,
-0.0521912761,
0.0007345131,
-0.0613618754,
0.064993456,
0.0018606941,
0.0514840484,
-0.0017700559,
0.018055547,
0.0445670485,
0.0002254826,
-0.0168766119,
0.0354548953,
-0.0145698264,
-0.0344276652,
0.0206404142,
0.0197797138,
-0.0218495522,
0.0248629339,
0.0067533851,
-0.0214216486,
0.028100837,
0.007640277,
0.0153789604,
-0.014306468,
-0.0271046069,
0.0012745766,
-0.0265689902,
0.1152390167,
0.014515263,
-0.0105822226,
0.0063666869,
-0.0434926823,
0.0710206181,
0.0367076099,
-0.0037391318,
0.0090735573,
0.0180933103,
-0.0098602483,
-0.005581785,
0.0518340543,
-0.0742530599,
0.0064390763,
-0.0329897255,
-0.0112900529,
0.0662731752,
0.036208082,
-0.0112787904,
-0.0904811472,
0.0238384437,
0.0127833486,
0.0070067467,
-0.0178924873,
0.0541129075,
0.0156136537,
0.0135297608,
-0.0474812947,
0.0654077083,
0.030412687,
-0.0115066143,
0.0108937491,
-0.0018092627,
0.0125086028,
0.0231450833,
-0.0442530848,
-0.0722633675,
0.0661504045,
-0.0046214135,
0.0326581039,
-0.0635196567,
-0.0121231163,
-0.0706616119,
0.0431533866,
-0.0141161289,
-0.0085813003,
-0.0079099433,
-0.0234544855,
-0.0379952714,
-0.0279485472,
0.0195124522,
0.0238499865,
0.0308783408,
-0.001642654,
-0.0420806594,
-0.0559727773,
0.0157949608,
-0.0682416111,
-0.0454655886,
-0.0033279923,
0.0273391362,
0.0414310694,
-0.0038006057,
-0.0332547277,
-0.0402911566,
-0.013998149,
0.0224495325,
-0.0585191585,
-0.0247646086,
0.0171176977,
0.0686521232,
0.018932052,
-0.0008631241,
0.0084544187,
-0.0781317875,
0.0180849452,
-0.0167734269,
0.0944196582,
-0.0013907953,
-0.0161396936,
0.0023689666,
0.0232978463,
-0.0065215919,
-0.0386832394,
0.0215184856,
-0.0085264891,
0.0130898748,
0.0346144028,
-0.0079304669,
0.0235030781,
-0.0231169835,
-0.0004685465,
-0.0091618383,
0.0884516761,
-0.0158642996,
0.0278330445,
-0.0205561277,
0.002123249,
-0.0449316911,
-0.053473372,
0.016902864,
0.0687980801,
-0.0117471898,
0.0210941732,
0.0020146563,
0.0347859338,
-0.0641172975,
-0.0298292339,
0.0443383493,
0.0361775681,
0.0219883211,
0.0008458951,
0.0366382487,
0.0219326336,
-0.0474644117,
0.0144756148,
0.0474361926,
-0.0189261679,
0.0242136326,
-0.0133235706,
-0.0462214611,
0.0260408595,
-0.0134415952,
-0.0496880189,
-0.0472967066,
0.0544475541,
0.0533866286,
0.0085820993,
0.0183352046,
0.0007213349,
-0.0290493742,
-0.0311466213,
0.067445375,
0.0197986048,
-0.0483027808,
-0.0016754954,
-0.0007692681,
0.0150729958,
0.0033719277,
0.0038612387,
-0.0408107713,
0.0117948391,
-0.0616124459,
-0.0504321232,
-0.0136228865,
0.0133286668,
-0.0081164669,
0.0097575719,
0.0127569949,
0.0319891162,
0.0124889556,
-0.0059214579,
-0.0170757845,
0.0324639753,
-0.0342696756,
-0.0057947123,
0.0196419768,
0.0513227619,
-0.0498267487,
-0.0069398982,
0.0133127309,
-0.0107337283,
-0.0462348722,
-0.0143716289,
0.001541885,
-5.825903552e-33,
-0.0281711351,
0.0034454288,
0.0089947805,
-0.0158150271,
-0.0485060848,
-0.0426019244,
-0.0475931428,
-0.0293667596,
0.0345784724,
0.0113510713,
-0.0137885828,
-0.0290184952,
-0.0188163687,
0.0327407271,
0.0583571494,
0.0339869149,
0.0584409758,
0.0806196854,
-0.0092125619,
-0.0158564467,
-0.0259029362,
0.0183569733,
0.0158731099,
-0.049631577,
-0.0532005765,
-0.0433505811,
-0.0530745462,
-0.0006637122,
-0.0031368693,
0.0130155422,
-0.0120963231,
-0.0378632843,
-0.0005514953,
0.0128601603,
0.0034625882,
0.0125932936,
-0.0726828352,
-0.0198768545,
-0.0167792663,
-0.0107781515,
-0.0703382418,
-0.0264505278,
0.0194349159,
-0.01483713,
-0.0187170599,
-0.005928841,
0.0585069843,
-0.0529514141,
0.0321953595,
-0.0036466818,
-0.0344569944,
-0.0324552618,
-0.005418838,
-0.0313573442,
0.0006432042,
-0.0085172364,
-0.0080931308,
0.019227,
-0.0864709616,
0.0642358214,
0.0019333357,
-0.0751903728,
0.0143018179,
0.0681771114,
0.0706540421,
0.0040900605,
0.0239847358,
0.0087769395,
-0.0270237103,
-0.0045642606,
-0.017344268,
0.037427444,
-0.0232323688,
0.0284155942,
0.06579151,
0.0113623133,
-0.0366044901,
0.0193244573,
-0.0551784709,
0.0598151647,
-0.0058768154,
0.1066627875,
0.0278840996,
0.0142282955,
-0.0177921616,
-0.0877402425,
-0.0218769275,
-0.0484321825,
0.0128054023,
-0.0051537049,
-0.0273201503,
0.0007977913,
0.0016274153,
-0.0094585512,
0.0084086377,
-0.0723180249,
-0.0296969227,
0.00769629,
-0.0028178759,
-0.0263135564,
0.0036394421,
-0.0015673314,
0.0461299233,
0.0756433383,
0.0029878782,
0.016201118,
-0.0306534711,
0.0449476019,
0.045952905,
-0.0075958678,
-0.0066698934,
0.0164485481,
0.0202127788,
0.0047844299,
0.0063815508,
0.0079825046,
-0.0353450105,
-0.0444709137,
-0.0006454033,
0.0582190752,
-0.027166348,
-0.0102908881,
-0.0030126716,
-0.03577004,
-0.034506917,
0.0161386076,
-0.0254080333,
-0.0049979337,
0.0463026464,
-0.0582743473,
-0.0353483371,
0.0279954672,
2.86e-7,
-0.0328063332,
-0.0183346979,
-0.000047967,
0.0102042025,
0.0318707637,
-0.012835362,
-0.0488801673,
0.01558482,
0.0293188561,
-0.0632895529,
0.0646079257,
0.0269126426,
0.0148139847,
-0.0233090147,
-0.0413577929,
-0.0385608822,
0.0509505942,
0.0079008033,
-0.0169734675,
0.0408822075,
-0.0007045274,
0.0069689238,
0.0426090062,
-0.0384464338,
0.0832502544,
0.0053948448,
0.0634288192,
-0.0339232124,
0.0158347543,
-0.0790792331,
0.0065925135,
0.0275339019,
0.0110745952,
-0.0285751708,
-0.0132389246,
-0.0022132026,
0.0700759962,
0.0273748357,
-0.0431039371,
0.014082144,
-0.0240191258,
0.0810842887,
-0.0010043774,
-0.0497836098,
0.0296572372,
-0.0248075128,
-0.006766452,
-0.0590463877,
-0.0654639006,
0.0410504714,
0.0406388305,
-0.0163392909,
-0.0324186385,
-0.0406849124,
0.0214919988,
0.0386573859,
-0.0082011018,
-0.0274651069,
-0.0094653107,
-0.0381202437,
-0.0748898238,
-0.0191493053,
-0.0140406964,
0.0015058854,
0.0309046246,
0.0224234629,
0.0004343166,
1.546233101e-34,
0.0162107106,
0.0213902369,
0.0514104813,
-0.0116202449,
0.014668717,
0.0643981993,
-0.0275903773,
0.0304199401,
0.0127276918,
-0.0383799002,
-0.0211875197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03485v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03485v2 | Attention Meets Post-hoc Interpretability: A Mathematical Perspective | 2024-02-05T19:56:56 | 2024-06-17T13:18:30 | Gianluigi Lopardo, Frederic Precioso, Damien Garreau | stat.ML | stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG | Attention-based architectures, in particular transformers, are at the heart
of a technological revolution. Interestingly, in addition to helping obtain
state-of-the-art results on a wide range of applications, the attention
mechanism intrinsically provides meaningful insights on the internal behavior
of the model. Can these insights be used as explanations? Debate rages on. In
this paper, we mathematically study a simple attention-based architecture and
pinpoint the differences between post-hoc and attention-based explanations. We
show that they provide quite different results, and that, despite their
limitations, post-hoc methods are capable of capturing more useful insights
than merely examining the attention weights. | [
-0.0179740861,
0.0120720416,
-0.0275715478,
0.0338157415,
-0.007670172,
-0.0208241809,
0.0112289488,
-0.0158737842,
-0.0520351753,
0.0051309909,
-0.0123854894,
-0.0450542159,
0.00651877,
0.0193081759,
0.0547158383,
-0.0269032326,
0.0291440915,
-0.0090047615,
-0.0383048467,
-0.0000867002,
-0.027632745,
-0.0479311235,
0.0241210684,
0.040887367,
0.040239878,
-0.0042144358,
-0.0263334978,
0.0029127563,
0.0254669096,
-0.0047667692,
-0.0406202972,
0.0130639868,
-0.0007340954,
0.0312309377,
0.0000022843,
0.0165803004,
0.0050830776,
0.0247736685,
-0.0459037162,
0.0344525687,
0.0161392037,
0.0129358163,
0.0122881094,
-0.0178102329,
0.0274925213,
0.0400903597,
0.0900128856,
0.052457016,
0.0210307259,
0.0434397534,
0.0053613544,
-0.032139428,
0.0310491789,
-0.0337615646,
0.0233006645,
-0.0197908524,
-0.0189454257,
-0.0645100102,
0.0218310412,
-0.0050791893,
-0.0541902259,
-0.0013483473,
0.0596142411,
-0.0084653469,
0.0811358616,
0.0087081147,
-0.0049289209,
0.0054712119,
-0.021746397,
0.036432527,
-0.0404638611,
-0.006987277,
-0.0036657527,
0.0132609559,
-0.0235638339,
-0.0070991227,
-0.0491160229,
-0.043768201,
0.0074977628,
-0.0158310477,
0.0181185454,
0.0435029268,
0.0499949455,
-0.0383779183,
-0.0312935002,
0.0185560286,
0.0047471821,
-0.01354778,
-0.0580523722,
0.0008566583,
0.0311315358,
-0.0134741915,
0.0044485833,
0.0582114011,
0.0245583933,
-0.0044043171,
0.0006807155,
0.0103874216,
-0.0430152342,
-0.027291704,
0.0873751566,
0.0131777665,
-0.0399973392,
0.0142841665,
0.0149137098,
0.0444550291,
-0.0920999497,
0.0340965465,
-0.0153990323,
0.0620213859,
-0.0312509835,
0.0039969245,
0.0001879141,
0.0377154723,
-0.0142877903,
-0.0267662816,
-0.0058376342,
0.030467838,
-0.0083701843,
-0.0425138324,
0.0074256808,
-0.0059756245,
-0.0240878854,
-0.0076065478,
-0.0023605309,
0.0431155227,
-0.013014405,
-0.0201287773,
0.0078465836,
-0.028561445,
-0.0614098832,
-0.0185545683,
-0.0237731766,
-0.003068703,
-0.035258349,
0.1046924144,
0.0251370519,
-0.0265737642,
-0.016127592,
-0.0052176067,
-0.0290706269,
-0.0255192146,
0.0384803526,
0.0018105514,
0.0051019243,
0.0158971995,
0.0098197032,
0.0368803442,
0.00286881,
-0.0168706086,
-0.0451420397,
0.0555202253,
0.0134759564,
-0.0043752436,
-0.0681498498,
-0.0028218424,
-0.0226613767,
0.0471229181,
0.0222873241,
0.010461051,
-0.0106292535,
-0.0276314206,
0.0553185232,
-0.0001063098,
0.0389422923,
-0.0146521563,
0.0160094388,
-0.0260163937,
-0.0720908269,
-0.0191887189,
0.0025296649,
0.0185385682,
-0.02236058,
0.0124334628,
0.0240766928,
0.0170684941,
0.0382266678,
0.0737353042,
0.0023006313,
-0.0156043945,
-0.028484378,
0.0502075031,
-0.0966388881,
0.0940461829,
-0.0298907869,
0.0019161894,
0.0056325104,
-0.0192312058,
-0.0360196047,
-0.0766985714,
-0.0087377988,
0.0004486408,
-0.034949407,
-0.0019652171,
0.0670369044,
0.026300801,
-0.0208590757,
0.0551864691,
0.0046207947,
-0.0235119872,
-0.0063058236,
-0.0811519027,
0.0066422843,
0.0393602513,
0.0267631803,
-0.0516056977,
0.0292016268,
-0.002586097,
0.0011121387,
0.0257223137,
0.0071823313,
0.0532071069,
0.0047915401,
0.0065484834,
0.0011463056,
-0.0750169456,
0.0192172937,
0.0020155723,
-0.0674906448,
-0.065558672,
-0.0142344097,
0.0148094976,
-0.0443988442,
-0.0091280332,
0.0481545962,
-0.0029354629,
-0.0077620023,
0.0169281214,
0.044845622,
0.0184062757,
-0.0236328449,
0.0289684553,
0.0386536643,
-0.0150825065,
0.0397821665,
0.0487177521,
-0.0068114819,
0.0113784419,
-0.0303023811,
-0.0708648115,
-0.0080748694,
0.0444810018,
-0.0114869745,
-0.0350311063,
0.1030049548,
-0.0703778937,
0.0745310336,
0.0157275144,
0.0086235413,
-0.0007156881,
0.0391455628,
-0.0110478615,
0.0409568772,
-0.0262916237,
0.028482182,
-0.0070766648,
-0.0160056576,
-0.0059125442,
0.0045536775,
-0.0180534627,
0.0003270245,
-0.0342738293,
-0.0279805101,
0.0049359137,
-0.060104657,
0.0057583977,
0.0259990804,
0.002483834,
-0.0154173728,
-0.0403402895,
0.0224018041,
0.0367214568,
-0.0037293914,
0.0499630906,
0.0098534217,
0.0435540602,
0.0247936156,
-0.0255444124,
0.0051394165,
0.0458989628,
-0.0612074845,
-0.0607519709,
-0.0272532646,
-0.0460976698,
-0.0135293296,
0.0711406097,
0.0484767295,
0.0353049412,
-0.0511041321,
-0.0142538054,
0.0360425226,
0.0068719657,
-0.0281898696,
-0.0523569509,
0.0287397671,
-0.0232252777,
0.0051067155,
0.0930786803,
-0.0140978852,
0.1074249893,
0.0116060283,
0.0130452234,
0.0141108641,
0.0103103723,
-0.0318102203,
-0.002326942,
-0.0320151113,
-0.0255664065,
0.0159183592,
0.1031080186,
-0.0294124223,
-0.0268793143,
-0.0477827005,
-0.0062890598,
0.0039597317,
-0.0359962359,
0.0119036082,
-0.0212135874,
-0.0292492118,
0.0343703292,
-0.0317546204,
-0.05423785,
0.072671771,
0.0138818333,
-0.005151825,
0.0084371688,
0.0278339088,
-0.0175296329,
0.0485059358,
0.0001666596,
0.0172760263,
0.01321474,
-0.0143531011,
-0.0112206433,
-0.006771849,
-0.0044551571,
0.0023648706,
0.0604717843,
-0.0006945529,
-0.0311621316,
0.0147386137,
0.0095730126,
-0.0041538836,
0.0336131789,
-0.0284306873,
0.0166124199,
0.0343968347,
-0.0326542333,
-0.0603508092,
0.0330586918,
0.062087398,
-0.01799489,
-0.0160935912,
-0.0326368175,
-0.0121967699,
-0.0334019512,
-0.024414897,
0.0479145087,
0.0721880421,
-0.080697611,
0.0091549214,
0.0253308844,
0.0222168602,
0.0063925744,
-0.0769449621,
0.0053360229,
-0.0091216099,
-0.0220011398,
-0.0138005223,
0.0161293317,
0.0361908935,
-0.063712649,
-0.0243333168,
0.0183381736,
-0.0124763381,
-0.0523455739,
0.0517894924,
-0.0149124647,
-0.0424226113,
0.0304282047,
0.0338344201,
-0.0117253438,
-0.0182118453,
-0.0146715734,
0.0167146325,
-0.0079807127,
0.0010185615,
0.0175293181,
-0.0297823809,
0.0478162952,
-0.009849227,
-0.0314077437,
-0.0302415397,
-0.0330208912,
0.004001501,
-0.0304352622,
-0.0390639342,
0.0184470955,
0.0217825081,
0.0089686029,
-0.0031922648,
-0.0006802118,
0.0018452462,
0.0040548188,
0.012223158,
0.0187061839,
0.0671756566,
-0.0038513783,
-0.0282303821,
-0.0683516338,
-0.0069961771,
0.0262039863,
0.038596794,
-0.0045984457,
0.0536411777,
0.029294692,
-0.0428539217,
-0.0575662069,
0.0004852089,
-0.0392323621,
0.0204109922,
-0.0483857766,
0.0623963848,
0.0068521155,
-0.0237386897,
-0.0228948388,
-0.0093734832,
-0.0130279912,
0.0406152494,
0.0666929781,
-0.0095748343,
-0.0640507564,
-0.0481155924,
-0.0242529847,
-0.0680636987,
-0.0941033885,
0.0189580601,
0.0350059681,
-0.0636473,
-0.0027689855,
-0.018219661,
-0.045927912,
0.0228054132,
0.0195096731,
-0.0687849969,
0.0206510834,
-0.0152617935,
-0.0318445154,
0.0555658676,
0.0121682091,
-0.0024013515,
-0.054998111,
-0.0192407575,
0.0147174187,
-0.0631157681,
-0.0211733282,
0.0073264875,
-0.0080201048,
-0.0220270008,
0.0514626876,
0.0660154596,
0.027443314,
0.0115855373,
-0.0279670414,
-0.0444930866,
-0.0097496724,
-0.0130068939,
-0.0302999951,
0.0176488329,
0.0633813441,
-0.0263842065,
0.004668403,
0.0136849927,
-0.0042318427,
0.0275973771,
0.062815398,
0.0123566948,
-0.0049469271,
0.0208778847,
0.022160342,
0.017464485,
0.0906851143,
0.0282778963,
-0.0150528094,
0.0256009102,
0.0160331782,
0.0036508671,
0.0142268967,
-0.0757472292,
-0.0205653217,
-0.0110828709,
-0.0101740276,
-0.0042095287,
-0.0076361592,
-0.0004417999,
-0.0629588217,
-0.0110223927,
0.0314786248,
-0.0244070645,
0.0188893247,
-0.0071675978,
0.0420124158,
-0.0084626116,
0.0106381476,
-0.016794702,
0.0533646755,
0.0469754338,
0.0207570884,
0.0009349924,
0.0140927024,
-0.0538112894,
0.0198895968,
-0.1242592186,
-0.0437261537,
0.0421324335,
0.000661216,
-0.0010513426,
0.0099480776,
0.0419316962,
0.0299115982,
0.007301983,
-0.0216672607,
0.0675116405,
0.0009557498,
-0.020543864,
-0.0247465763,
0.01919223,
0.0126868002,
-0.0553698651,
0.0386475548,
-0.0723380446,
-0.0337517634,
-0.0584009625,
0.0109716598,
-0.0050310367,
-0.0275178589,
-0.0320135206,
0.0229442939,
0.0110705495,
-0.0024547291,
-0.0927847326,
-0.0613509752,
0.0052069621,
-0.0134581765,
0.0420996659,
-0.0298321359,
0.0128472401,
0.0450315215,
0.0118263885,
-0.0445474461,
0.020015534,
-0.0072762799,
-0.0305788703,
0.011660221,
0.0020402153,
-6.524268419e-33,
-0.0002526486,
-0.0109895002,
0.0002101674,
-0.0066043362,
-0.0263302345,
0.017386565,
-0.0708890855,
-0.0183258913,
-0.0237059742,
0.0095779374,
-0.0128084291,
0.0238367096,
-0.0051622414,
0.0203403402,
0.0260645766,
-0.0274585392,
0.0190846715,
0.0251278747,
-0.0212099981,
0.0539288223,
0.037712764,
0.0082275271,
0.0498273075,
0.0102647739,
0.0157651827,
0.0288038962,
0.0163817387,
0.0083601288,
-0.0548456684,
0.046142336,
-0.0328315981,
0.0050114268,
0.0061911279,
-0.0517111234,
-0.0209969152,
-0.0079904478,
-0.0122757154,
-0.0171259157,
0.0253617857,
-0.0036276665,
-0.0468008071,
-0.056656152,
0.0685917661,
0.0299209617,
-0.0005779848,
-0.074674204,
0.0285519082,
-0.0103286942,
-0.0194589403,
0.0296377074,
-0.0506443121,
0.0032340968,
-0.0466535166,
-0.0109999534,
0.0149120009,
0.0457986481,
-0.0394347832,
0.0212459546,
-0.0568550527,
0.0158160198,
0.0530451424,
-0.0004557716,
0.0630871058,
0.0426596515,
0.024367189,
0.0083028339,
0.0676470026,
0.0364895612,
-0.0831602067,
-0.0279962402,
0.0092843287,
0.0706698149,
0.0891922936,
-0.0403500721,
0.0482096337,
0.0274315141,
-0.0487562455,
-0.0251741111,
-0.0436655842,
0.0764234513,
0.0899470225,
0.0074285888,
-0.0474199057,
-0.0072903857,
0.0246532038,
-0.018941205,
-0.0363719612,
-0.0263908375,
-0.0103350133,
-0.0249493159,
-0.0457595177,
0.0373691693,
0.0289985146,
-0.0537894182,
0.0842299312,
-0.0288251601,
0.0509180836,
0.0388228707,
0.0275735371,
-0.0124407783,
-0.0287304036,
0.00596159,
-0.0307879336,
0.0552833751,
0.0271415114,
-0.0212938469,
-0.0034238212,
0.039906811,
0.0390945189,
-0.0282554869,
-0.0616856888,
-0.0448227786,
0.0137729803,
-0.0065355902,
0.0369374491,
0.0207872223,
-0.0251010787,
0.0383471996,
-0.0236162655,
0.0286885016,
-0.0090518463,
0.0812203512,
-0.0227531586,
0.0429878458,
-0.0201523192,
-0.0382491276,
-0.0661066622,
0.0272612311,
0.031726528,
-0.0924611315,
-0.070549503,
0.0161434561,
3.057e-7,
0.0394108295,
-0.0014033727,
0.0288005285,
0.0039911396,
0.0448902994,
-0.0077027776,
0.0155531028,
0.0284316,
0.0166790485,
0.0014471146,
0.0146579007,
0.0383766741,
0.0206054635,
-0.0227222033,
-0.0112821339,
-0.0604837053,
-0.0527764,
0.0239410698,
0.0293989554,
0.0102593331,
0.0436397791,
0.0495699719,
0.0147166187,
0.0337843932,
0.0200409349,
0.0139549151,
0.0387888663,
0.0149307624,
0.0562929027,
0.0082801282,
0.0015538529,
-0.0250606518,
-0.0507281981,
0.0147020239,
-0.0009019875,
-0.0024024635,
-0.0474722385,
0.0219625309,
-0.0103206839,
-0.0445124432,
-0.0294420868,
-0.0092598461,
0.0173919834,
-0.04372482,
0.0506976433,
-0.0986662209,
-0.0629422963,
0.0205581561,
0.0096748648,
0.0002314091,
-0.0309184212,
0.0227589738,
0.0395116173,
-0.0219058227,
-0.0318718962,
-0.0498731248,
0.0080958297,
-0.0672310889,
-0.0092985798,
0.0053084185,
-0.0508291386,
-0.0151372412,
-0.0513137095,
-0.0699647591,
0.0706115589,
0.0114441449,
-0.0630260184,
2.749648427e-34,
0.0355332755,
-0.0211431943,
0.0301327016,
0.0373875089,
0.0337472595,
-0.0348762013,
0.0290140118,
-0.0179427881,
0.0684880689,
-0.0546079129,
-0.0535905808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03484v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03484v1 | Harnessing PubMed User Query Logs for Post Hoc Explanations of Recommended Similar Articles | 2024-02-05T19:56:27 | 2024-02-05T19:56:27 | Ashley Shin, Qiao Jin, James Anibal, Zhiyong Lu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Searching for a related article based on a reference article is an integral
part of scientific research. PubMed, like many academic search engines, has a
"similar articles" feature that recommends articles relevant to the current
article viewed by a user. Explaining recommended items can be of great utility
to users, particularly in the literature search process. With more than a
million biomedical papers being published each year, explaining the recommended
similar articles would facilitate researchers and clinicians in searching for
related articles. Nonetheless, the majority of current literature
recommendation systems lack explanations for their suggestions. We employ a
post hoc approach to explaining recommendations by identifying relevant tokens
in the titles of similar articles. Our major contribution is building PubCLogs
by repurposing 5.6 million pairs of coclicked articles from PubMed's user query
logs. Using our PubCLogs dataset, we train the Highlight Similar Article Title
(HSAT), a transformer-based model designed to select the most relevant parts of
the title of a similar article, based on the title and abstract of a seed
article. HSAT demonstrates strong performance in our empirical evaluations,
achieving an F1 score of 91.72 percent on the PubCLogs test set, considerably
outperforming several baselines including BM25 (70.62), MPNet (67.11), MedCPT
(62.22), GPT-3.5 (46.00), and GPT-4 (64.89). Additional evaluations on a
separate, manually annotated test set further verifies HSAT's performance.
Moreover, participants of our user study indicate a preference for HSAT, due to
its superior balance between conciseness and comprehensiveness. Our study
suggests that repurposing user query logs of academic search engines can be a
promising way to train state-of-the-art models for explaining literature
recommendation. | [
0.0759386197,
0.0268019456,
0.0038183269,
-0.0335715637,
0.0084996736,
0.0016642464,
0.0262393188,
0.0347501263,
0.0085140811,
-0.0243216753,
-0.0327340513,
0.0241425224,
-0.0329639502,
0.0283475854,
0.0205679797,
-0.065830566,
0.003071866,
0.0437605754,
0.002646311,
0.0230165608,
0.0304982588,
0.0244480874,
-0.0034030569,
0.0491188616,
0.0877249092,
-0.0244231541,
0.0049505518,
0.0152517185,
0.0375267453,
-0.032493934,
0.0010645899,
0.0347826593,
0.0003532791,
0.016249774,
0.0000017254,
-0.0279001296,
-0.0244088266,
0.0156510491,
-0.0033482087,
0.0271047149,
0.0673512965,
0.0052608219,
0.0685046762,
-0.0026042708,
0.0089205671,
-0.0169621352,
0.0310779326,
0.0613530464,
0.0012506689,
0.0224963836,
-0.0012841164,
0.0067800833,
0.016775772,
-0.0226085987,
0.0767732635,
-0.0038047526,
0.0185578018,
-0.0203200169,
0.058027599,
0.0606256314,
0.0293451827,
0.0119814109,
-0.0168176293,
-0.0491569974,
0.0499532223,
0.0535732768,
-0.0161794573,
0.0014830719,
0.0241855849,
0.0824286193,
-0.0170714054,
-0.0534841195,
0.0537699796,
0.0184597317,
-0.03849978,
0.0858681649,
-0.0800639316,
-0.0641936064,
-0.0158701222,
-0.0104394509,
0.0117882015,
0.0007648825,
0.0474657044,
0.0407356173,
0.0269326176,
0.0140554421,
0.017755419,
-0.0165690761,
-0.0073341015,
-0.0126925539,
0.0286754463,
-0.0431752726,
0.0660200641,
0.0290144235,
-0.0414386764,
-0.0013690525,
0.0417789146,
-0.0100007523,
0.0631561652,
-0.0111359712,
0.0060403836,
-0.0064120414,
-0.0055804458,
0.0433625095,
-0.0085722068,
-0.0249792039,
-0.0310651567,
0.0239276905,
-0.0407369658,
0.0051951823,
-0.0750804916,
-0.0309740826,
-0.0073838872,
0.0169639736,
0.0150909731,
-0.020474799,
-0.0402111448,
-0.0047768666,
0.0115099875,
-0.0122931516,
0.0071486081,
0.0591558553,
-0.0480168276,
-0.0173971765,
-0.0256242938,
0.0214703027,
-0.0291565601,
0.0146636683,
0.0230348893,
0.0121844336,
-0.0068479953,
0.0114065586,
0.0290210564,
-0.0315524079,
0.0113461418,
-0.0129805142,
0.0121790636,
-0.0211458746,
0.0257994812,
-0.0682754964,
0.0138564166,
-0.0129803214,
-0.0101163629,
-0.0543399528,
0.049906373,
0.0184270255,
-0.0076687797,
-0.0049950718,
-0.0115678255,
0.0225750394,
-0.035519138,
0.0613219403,
-0.0506409556,
-0.0091680642,
-0.0088245235,
0.0376292877,
-0.0004401228,
0.0017218103,
-0.0195039976,
0.0236738902,
0.0389006697,
-0.0270444602,
0.0223910864,
-0.0447806604,
0.0289536845,
-0.0230102371,
0.0508046933,
0.0186797418,
-0.0402676761,
0.0846955404,
0.0115515925,
0.0299951285,
-0.0526448153,
-0.0228600092,
0.0272764768,
0.0935510471,
0.0375444591,
0.0320271701,
0.0316563249,
0.0036202467,
-0.0017569067,
-0.0134605234,
-0.0184558742,
0.0355274044,
0.002397974,
0.0003305432,
0.0201890692,
0.0245524384,
-0.0347348712,
-0.0088836709,
-0.0038885202,
0.0105662961,
-0.0511596277,
0.0173776336,
0.0459598899,
0.0128596453,
-0.0072931242,
0.0483995862,
0.0522844419,
-0.0030119745,
0.0283741727,
-0.0244731363,
0.020478325,
0.0509093367,
0.0711516887,
-0.0301939603,
-0.0129599981,
-0.0327147469,
-0.0110260695,
-0.0209017675,
0.0289244205,
-0.0264477562,
-0.0061131734,
-0.0309396498,
-0.0188310277,
0.0041997572,
0.0015541659,
-0.0165188946,
-0.0051557943,
-0.0004397021,
0.0000041715,
-0.0640960485,
-0.0333300717,
0.0035349922,
-0.039951317,
0.0106577957,
-0.0018799989,
-0.0442594104,
0.0325876698,
0.0219091438,
0.0266974308,
0.0475657173,
0.0472509824,
-0.010547136,
-0.0489659309,
0.0251765829,
0.0172231179,
-0.0018281846,
-0.0019905095,
-0.0873964354,
0.034175273,
0.0286700577,
-0.0156706944,
-0.0261967145,
0.01134538,
-0.0138077475,
0.0277648773,
-0.0011203603,
-0.0192666054,
-0.0082872538,
-0.0223882124,
-0.0386341177,
0.0248180311,
0.0000729389,
0.0485428907,
0.0111569725,
-0.07398507,
-0.0172531176,
-0.0531532355,
0.0195485465,
-0.0001317926,
-0.0011162566,
-0.032396365,
0.0211410336,
-0.0362560451,
-0.0446230881,
0.0161079355,
-0.0809791312,
0.0075959484,
0.0208233055,
0.0137389265,
0.0331655517,
0.0090213344,
0.018551616,
-0.029247364,
-0.0456223264,
-0.019850431,
-0.0075786253,
0.0017470433,
0.0496542677,
0.0418607481,
-0.0027910783,
-0.0794927478,
-0.0285498016,
-0.0525689684,
0.0476026759,
0.0301595721,
0.0546860583,
-0.0368012972,
-0.0131709259,
-0.0273783281,
-0.0485723428,
-0.0279007554,
0.0298792478,
0.0060781054,
0.0027608655,
-0.0141764134,
0.029174652,
0.0099265724,
0.0208892599,
0.0474146344,
0.0364753567,
-0.0789626464,
-0.0355792642,
-0.066366069,
0.0183407329,
-0.0005128769,
-0.0416431352,
0.0642006323,
0.0365479626,
0.0001355571,
0.0046322863,
-0.0208574235,
-0.0064414898,
0.0286381431,
0.002840769,
-0.0528729223,
-0.0096560456,
0.0042730225,
0.0485515222,
0.0059648105,
-0.0279898904,
0.1196031123,
-0.0218105819,
0.0163699109,
-0.0468412787,
-0.0075894734,
-0.0420552976,
-0.0118882526,
-0.0015129234,
0.0133248782,
-0.005308236,
-0.0142558841,
0.0221784748,
0.0198461954,
0.0188753773,
-0.036459472,
0.0233442541,
-0.0036107302,
-0.0044515408,
0.0420629047,
-0.0377294011,
0.0105279125,
-0.0649036244,
-0.0379576944,
-0.0006070121,
0.0258002393,
-0.0314359739,
-0.0993501171,
0.0212272946,
0.0147866514,
0.0374876149,
-0.0228404198,
-0.0461720712,
0.0142093049,
0.0072645722,
0.0821653008,
-0.0412083901,
0.0054310281,
-0.0051039597,
0.0358500518,
0.0582297072,
0.0247233137,
-0.0201803036,
-0.019330129,
-0.0301937182,
-0.0029997483,
-0.070466809,
-0.0020330099,
-0.0179870855,
0.0070880088,
-0.0146274092,
-0.0051179607,
0.0664426461,
0.0354807302,
-0.1064944118,
0.0076382332,
-0.0379616916,
0.0205039773,
0.0189176425,
0.0408729501,
-0.0585274138,
-0.0160504542,
-0.0030111107,
0.0601456761,
-0.001748575,
-0.0317283906,
0.015579856,
-0.02688835,
0.0232329331,
-0.0161164403,
-0.0139829498,
-0.0145675866,
-0.1118223295,
0.0007306112,
-0.0333727263,
-0.0284030717,
0.0120043634,
-0.0218746681,
0.0165752079,
0.0207917783,
-0.0164201465,
-0.0585848466,
0.0199622028,
-0.0463017151,
0.0060267267,
0.0254374575,
0.0181339085,
0.02458141,
-0.0081560258,
-0.0417074561,
0.005261655,
0.006841606,
-0.0194758493,
0.0856953189,
-0.0175699331,
0.0244237892,
-0.0787439495,
0.0664924383,
-0.0301149804,
-0.0434558466,
0.003656331,
0.0818815231,
-0.0348436013,
-0.0221702438,
-0.0710084513,
0.0188642293,
-0.011435613,
0.0799224228,
0.0392187648,
0.0069418703,
-0.0023411612,
0.0123423925,
0.0269863494,
0.003672827,
-0.0489515699,
-0.0304432977,
-0.0317201652,
0.0394805484,
-0.0581529588,
-0.0334243551,
0.0286047496,
-0.0094682146,
0.0037019816,
0.0212629475,
0.0071662478,
-0.0378271043,
-0.0263726134,
0.0587886423,
0.036284849,
-0.0095221708,
-0.0172132719,
-0.0137164854,
0.0937996581,
-0.0285479762,
-0.0105035761,
0.0003379495,
0.0118306959,
-0.0054712608,
-0.0491522215,
0.0037534451,
0.0309493002,
0.0522063933,
-0.0200671591,
-0.0885071978,
-0.0138027864,
0.0292841941,
0.0094914641,
-0.0855442882,
-0.0347357392,
-0.0243533812,
-0.0053030611,
0.0031809972,
-0.0496857017,
0.0041444162,
-0.0266711731,
-0.0045692311,
-0.0216466282,
-0.0100805517,
0.0612825826,
0.0080497023,
0.0671068579,
-0.0205784235,
0.0457139127,
-0.0231706705,
-0.0042438274,
-0.0260399934,
0.027215207,
-0.0150781088,
0.022132732,
0.0252369028,
-0.0107839806,
-0.0129915774,
0.0153698502,
-0.0769739524,
0.0219101645,
-0.1043284535,
0.0125072338,
-0.0231248382,
0.0012544829,
0.0155028561,
-0.0036321688,
-0.0078414492,
-0.0144329118,
0.0068140915,
0.0312736481,
-0.0245576054,
0.0316294916,
0.0300645567,
0.0077141025,
-0.0030614473,
0.0213006809,
-0.1409920305,
-0.0349918418,
-0.010503876,
-0.0233813636,
-0.0034626203,
-0.028209677,
0.0543469749,
-0.020364996,
-0.0293737967,
-0.0180214271,
0.0509157181,
-0.012689949,
0.030983327,
0.0487071574,
0.0447242036,
-0.0040065278,
-0.0273189154,
0.0872701034,
-0.0034996097,
0.0270969383,
0.006337882,
-0.0964843109,
-0.00518408,
-0.0142417094,
0.0138642797,
0.0641251355,
-0.0612358339,
-0.0410205573,
-0.0408916734,
-0.0024674097,
-0.0014094352,
-0.0216257777,
-0.0011522963,
-0.009421085,
0.0437809937,
0.0665015578,
0.0073529882,
-0.038200859,
-0.0264887735,
0.0531929247,
-0.0464378446,
-0.0555434711,
-0.0095894681,
-6.086468405e-33,
0.0489923246,
-0.0159829035,
-0.0178351458,
0.0163182393,
-0.0068719722,
-0.0031320155,
-0.0633389726,
-0.0296085142,
0.0267597158,
0.0705403984,
-0.0133527545,
0.0244021043,
-0.0070186518,
-0.007888359,
0.01916744,
-0.006225856,
0.0352716856,
0.0293905661,
-0.0194237195,
0.0667927638,
0.0232866239,
0.0364318863,
0.0107507221,
-0.055709172,
0.0274839606,
0.0098026805,
0.0102282381,
0.0055348049,
-0.0035730596,
0.0857423693,
-0.0158027224,
0.0280666333,
0.0293112136,
-0.0177990068,
0.0088726571,
-0.0052357684,
-0.0952343792,
0.0106910178,
0.0373813622,
-0.046745237,
-0.0456274711,
-0.0243690498,
0.0707286671,
-0.0351513736,
-0.0050017559,
-0.0355900414,
0.0493646823,
0.0063249911,
-0.0442206375,
-0.0621031523,
-0.0129836099,
0.0187773854,
-0.030703973,
0.0199935716,
-0.023880545,
0.0687229931,
-0.0140500702,
0.0948757008,
-0.0051676529,
0.0196124595,
-0.0052478961,
0.0383786932,
0.0260141175,
-0.0299853627,
-0.0084948428,
0.0496658161,
0.0288215503,
-0.0433726832,
-0.0024642993,
0.0231588874,
-0.022302065,
0.0176063497,
0.0630060136,
0.0227069631,
0.0534941666,
0.0104184523,
-0.0535945743,
0.075160943,
-0.0281670596,
0.0269810595,
0.0340240188,
0.0225396827,
0.0077949925,
-0.0086772498,
-0.0148512339,
-0.0271868557,
-0.0423651524,
-0.0577406548,
-0.0015914213,
0.0078516342,
-0.0329359993,
0.0282789469,
-0.0067199571,
-0.0203185659,
-0.0210624803,
0.0146760233,
0.0189942457,
-0.010241528,
0.0007654722,
-0.0288169663,
-0.0397418961,
0.0089002196,
0.0156309213,
-0.0004407834,
0.0269382391,
-0.0067454483,
0.0395871103,
-0.0288658552,
-0.005437627,
-0.0202195533,
-0.0060827769,
-0.0406511314,
-0.0390733033,
-0.0299027115,
0.0076469029,
0.0457979068,
-0.0100083062,
0.0446032919,
0.0399820171,
0.029104406,
-0.0283290651,
-0.0099584293,
0.0037202565,
0.0161178727,
-0.0044495799,
-0.0126268473,
-0.0400458984,
-0.032731846,
0.0382769667,
-0.0644363686,
-0.0235192385,
-0.017325893,
2.613e-7,
0.0776065513,
0.0517674834,
0.0199231394,
-0.0707863644,
0.0494850948,
-0.0028591412,
0.0066725053,
0.0118496669,
0.0416498892,
0.0222992096,
0.0433278345,
-0.0100024696,
0.0087418389,
0.0096606975,
-0.0595349707,
-0.0671746358,
-0.1016064808,
-0.0878611282,
-0.0582306273,
-0.0269119926,
0.0301500838,
0.0418494381,
0.0038151452,
-0.0039310539,
0.0256931409,
-0.0231623575,
0.0437992364,
-0.0540868342,
-0.003857214,
0.0316164419,
0.0500956848,
-0.0125381202,
0.0153396036,
-0.024703525,
-0.0188739169,
-0.0133670466,
0.0133466944,
0.0203704312,
-0.0152660748,
0.0038882261,
0.0184879173,
-0.0369161032,
0.0641516894,
-0.0929167867,
0.0477936305,
-0.0561969876,
-0.0399548858,
-0.0112456996,
-0.0463741682,
-0.0077593448,
0.0339593776,
-0.0395339914,
-0.0283926912,
0.0541204587,
-0.0230084881,
0.0300355814,
-0.0125377569,
-0.0721152872,
-0.0112754973,
0.0570155755,
-0.0354635082,
-0.0073373979,
-0.023993792,
-0.0225313511,
-0.0253033563,
-0.0526238456,
-0.0110972412,
2.341712398e-34,
0.0301846769,
0.0513775721,
-0.0132436221,
-0.0082901716,
0.0518243909,
0.0097200591,
-0.0223024525,
0.0100998338,
0.0536294058,
-0.0827468261,
-0.024938846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03483v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03483v1 | SWAG: Storytelling With Action Guidance | 2024-02-05T19:55:06 | 2024-02-05T19:55:06 | Zeeshan Patel, Karim El-Refai, Jonathan Pei, Tianle Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automated long-form story generation typically employs long-context large
language models (LLMs) for one-shot creation, which can produce cohesive but
not necessarily engaging content. We introduce Storytelling With Action
Guidance (SWAG), a novel approach to storytelling with LLMs. Our approach
reduces story writing to a search problem through a two-model feedback loop:
one LLM generates story content, and another auxiliary LLM is used to choose
the next best "action" to steer the story's future direction. Our results show
that SWAG can substantially outperform previous end-to-end story generation
techniques when evaluated by GPT-4 and through human evaluation, and our SWAG
pipeline using only open-source models surpasses GPT-3.5-Turbo. | [
0.0239593908,
0.0259116143,
-0.0141621102,
0.0073430375,
-0.0378393829,
-0.0151062822,
-0.0326687768,
-0.0189938042,
-0.0060531404,
-0.0459821187,
0.0225199219,
-0.0223982446,
-0.0115721514,
0.1052463204,
-0.008241754,
-0.0376287028,
-0.014492224,
-0.0327845626,
0.0366615392,
0.0288029015,
0.0063772565,
0.0370954536,
0.0261567216,
0.0608995818,
-0.012218521,
-0.0176742803,
-0.0351102874,
0.0094163883,
0.0183181595,
-0.039835643,
-0.0047248024,
0.0020606772,
0.0694937184,
0.0071696779,
0.0000019553,
-0.0611290373,
-0.0106496615,
-0.025486663,
0.0239923857,
-0.0045634517,
0.0098622888,
0.0174651481,
-0.0151851512,
0.0010564505,
-0.0030684103,
0.0110235214,
0.0338910036,
0.0667386875,
0.0474726558,
0.0702602118,
-0.0179199912,
-0.0656388998,
-0.0140410587,
-0.0214364678,
0.0296356045,
-0.0073193233,
-0.0249909032,
0.0150370803,
0.0887437537,
-0.0082393689,
0.0001256576,
0.0111099929,
0.0191703904,
-0.024430342,
-0.0208255239,
0.0872122496,
0.0067113796,
-0.0007156352,
0.0034910063,
0.0559039339,
-0.0301297195,
-0.0225502905,
-0.0106915263,
-0.0369169153,
0.0091359792,
-0.0246841814,
-0.0704013258,
0.0755347237,
-0.0038529178,
0.018532427,
0.0238512103,
-0.0178083591,
0.0174736604,
-0.0134953028,
0.0280735809,
0.0351483487,
0.0385412015,
0.0012991641,
-0.0649581254,
0.0042886408,
0.0047930637,
-0.0776726231,
0.0106594479,
0.0610407218,
-0.0246464536,
0.0127764074,
-0.0485671125,
0.0499587208,
-0.009361852,
-0.0340777747,
0.0299706198,
0.0337025858,
0.0193150081,
0.0301226322,
-0.0011042462,
0.0412778892,
-0.0014754551,
-0.0584531799,
-0.0333064124,
0.0444063582,
-0.046161592,
0.0019246519,
-0.0621272065,
0.0223014671,
-0.0682644248,
-0.0683964938,
-0.0341932774,
0.0369832925,
0.0430506207,
0.0082183164,
-0.0135805644,
0.0238481965,
-0.0186005495,
0.0072861589,
-0.0002653066,
0.0456094034,
-0.0229815915,
-0.013080487,
0.0368123986,
0.0124215493,
-0.0110165747,
0.0070271934,
0.0045483191,
-0.020282086,
0.0161389336,
0.0604994297,
-0.0254873261,
0.0037962673,
-0.0752471387,
-0.0527586229,
-0.008282871,
-0.0678881556,
-0.0463469028,
-0.0613309368,
0.0291425418,
0.0189984161,
0.0157703999,
-0.020306699,
0.0057102228,
0.0116009573,
-0.01301031,
-0.0021381283,
0.0179543197,
0.0169451609,
0.0262533911,
0.0261262748,
0.0277722124,
0.0505195819,
0.0715199411,
0.0688919872,
0.0267640371,
0.016814094,
0.0535935871,
0.0375344902,
-0.0262183398,
0.0139322402,
-0.0138859889,
0.0069592972,
0.030236382,
0.0948798805,
0.0175940897,
0.0445657261,
-0.0264515951,
0.0477573834,
0.0850716531,
0.0525181144,
0.0427162461,
0.0011489374,
0.0906676948,
0.0040251967,
-0.0330412388,
-0.0053672595,
-0.0023214044,
0.0411263593,
0.0000644152,
0.0091506094,
-0.0072926283,
0.0288139675,
-0.0150260217,
0.0130476989,
-0.0050843642,
-0.0067716944,
-0.0223235693,
-0.0349333435,
-0.0105762947,
-0.0065681539,
-0.0897861719,
-0.0048037726,
-0.0106761558,
-0.0799054578,
0.0444332287,
-0.0107011078,
0.0777523145,
0.0814778656,
0.0811133012,
0.0204562061,
-0.0392221659,
-0.0407175347,
0.0048684338,
0.025192298,
0.0065765698,
-0.0173209589,
0.0081614563,
-0.0214119423,
0.0016812142,
-0.0449287109,
-0.0031930848,
0.0030085002,
-0.0159205813,
0.013307116,
0.0188771989,
0.0127508976,
-0.0534369461,
0.0223520063,
-0.0591897964,
-0.0129015939,
-0.0135198906,
-0.0323239937,
-0.0136246374,
-0.0151521591,
-0.0297581218,
-0.0001798147,
0.0116224345,
-0.0242299065,
-0.0357392095,
0.0487223417,
-0.0112260962,
-0.0261305198,
0.0044350922,
-0.0280638896,
0.0035317084,
-0.0370265245,
0.0081988517,
-0.0535618588,
0.0148687772,
-0.0304352529,
0.0147133358,
-0.0208473317,
0.0374745429,
0.008510231,
-0.0313034244,
-0.0315505825,
0.0619468354,
0.0395876057,
-0.0068085873,
0.0197297838,
0.0263970196,
-0.0158482492,
-0.0261279903,
0.0268611442,
0.0668421388,
0.0416333675,
-0.0213447716,
0.0523391888,
0.0099084228,
-0.0288076457,
-0.0598791055,
-0.0756952912,
0.035696812,
0.0168125834,
0.0008163507,
0.0230815038,
0.0407453254,
-0.0402013622,
0.0362875871,
-0.0680465996,
-0.022750631,
0.0500012338,
-0.0205204915,
-0.0037803964,
0.0512716398,
-0.0268864594,
-0.0297870263,
0.0384020358,
0.0114689283,
0.0508450009,
0.0708834007,
0.004730097,
-0.0818143412,
0.0535549074,
-0.0171924531,
-0.0036941846,
-0.0309232008,
-0.028782431,
0.030321721,
-0.0350760631,
0.0851970613,
0.0405928157,
0.0127389794,
0.0183366742,
0.0524903648,
-0.060915228,
-0.018802274,
0.0253119376,
-0.0182015169,
-0.007621828,
-0.0272215214,
-0.0200662278,
0.0314394496,
0.0691634864,
0.0238311663,
0.0173512455,
-0.0433576033,
0.0163587444,
-0.0145143997,
0.0143930539,
0.0018908411,
-0.0399536751,
-0.0254007429,
0.0242847521,
0.0043085609,
-0.0302052572,
0.0727245063,
-0.0429263674,
-0.0096494518,
-0.0019119572,
0.0020439399,
-0.0768050402,
0.0835330412,
-0.0043343049,
0.0438278727,
-0.0283724088,
0.0089426665,
-0.0119808884,
-0.0096764658,
0.0126512442,
-0.0155746397,
0.0313229151,
-0.049022425,
-0.0108542144,
-0.0121515561,
-0.0286913756,
-0.0188665055,
-0.0203522332,
-0.0329320319,
0.0011295178,
0.0549768284,
-0.0432128571,
-0.0267064385,
0.0464501493,
0.0378508866,
0.0604933724,
-0.0315322056,
-0.0313798264,
-0.0099273566,
0.0141962962,
0.0731526017,
-0.0447363891,
-0.0184678938,
-0.0476177186,
0.0548479073,
0.0329807028,
0.0159548689,
0.0091563351,
0.0113154817,
0.0064988048,
0.0454280302,
-0.0207666811,
-0.0485453419,
0.0191008337,
0.0492614433,
-0.067367658,
-0.0228671916,
0.1271173507,
0.0282614175,
-0.0264033731,
0.0157791339,
-0.0027593398,
0.0496145152,
0.0018769319,
0.0182094947,
-0.040897835,
-0.0357204229,
0.0215857141,
0.0193180516,
-0.0066815722,
-0.0318537094,
-0.0397046544,
-0.0812512636,
0.0783812329,
0.0314570069,
-0.0284336172,
0.0056320606,
-0.0154625745,
-0.0061501334,
0.0202293284,
-0.0259442851,
0.0421537869,
-0.0439834967,
0.0027908671,
-0.0468878746,
0.0035131811,
-0.0129743535,
0.0135806045,
-0.0519666746,
0.0348184332,
0.0626994297,
0.045716323,
0.0240476299,
0.0534222908,
0.0123957498,
0.0055604517,
0.0183405522,
-0.010695301,
-0.0046281745,
-0.0366590209,
-0.0026595683,
-0.0346242823,
0.0575097278,
-0.0051403698,
-0.0582212359,
0.0204909742,
0.0681107938,
-0.0239246543,
-0.0474961437,
-0.0176052302,
0.0188692827,
0.0187160019,
0.0791643783,
0.0210179947,
-0.0615504906,
-0.0533365943,
-0.0288290698,
0.000875906,
-0.0405937172,
-0.0430557393,
-0.0324734114,
-0.0031444407,
0.030282367,
-0.0335538872,
-0.0768536329,
0.0474562906,
0.0511265136,
0.0375894979,
0.0155767733,
-0.0379182473,
-0.0086259944,
-0.0294985827,
0.0004924557,
-0.0264571533,
0.016629925,
-0.0500995889,
0.0222406946,
0.0287383702,
-0.0590336621,
0.0134590119,
0.064396672,
-0.0788394585,
-0.0557111278,
-0.0480237603,
-0.0174145363,
0.0203323606,
0.0286987554,
0.0163393002,
-0.053817939,
0.0251686275,
-0.0070003765,
-0.0325776041,
0.0595752709,
-0.0352288857,
0.0514733158,
0.0052368292,
-0.0100372611,
-0.0395554937,
-0.0118029946,
-0.0186054483,
0.0827787444,
0.0138160167,
-0.0098035326,
0.0191883314,
0.0022829631,
-0.0325635448,
-0.0636308417,
-0.0215529297,
-0.0689530596,
-0.0241729617,
-0.0410109982,
-0.0159619823,
-0.0644037798,
0.0363806672,
0.0259369481,
0.0056461128,
-0.0013833025,
0.0178912096,
-0.0548411757,
0.0167416446,
-0.0436939448,
-0.0147113269,
0.0089868028,
-0.0321871154,
0.0685782433,
-0.0167175643,
-0.011483945,
0.0100636072,
-0.0384775177,
0.0291608498,
-0.025675606,
0.0640208796,
0.019797286,
-0.0011468297,
0.0401067957,
0.0215295572,
-0.033591371,
-0.0361072458,
-0.0297746621,
0.0044773328,
0.0617883392,
-0.0038968602,
0.0705941767,
-0.0507990718,
0.0226212405,
-0.0196625125,
0.037938986,
-0.0041246382,
-0.0604301058,
-0.0369504765,
0.0290405955,
-0.0272743888,
0.0277002137,
0.0692254975,
0.0116898343,
0.0571466833,
0.0010747935,
-0.0296545569,
-0.0186671503,
-0.0497297309,
0.01874917,
0.013185909,
0.017636735,
-0.0179460458,
-0.0496824048,
-0.0080862464,
-0.0239539966,
-0.0118448334,
-0.0195903406,
-0.0230468083,
0.0397435799,
0.0302835237,
-0.0163826626,
-0.0045393244,
-0.0481434613,
-0.0139543675,
-0.0096514029,
-0.0252212267,
-0.0147463745,
-6.023456398e-33,
-0.0323759057,
-0.0446542688,
0.0374717228,
-0.0224914625,
-0.0679349527,
-0.0062308884,
-0.0378790908,
0.0062448904,
0.0499444753,
0.0314966328,
0.0183965359,
0.0004000869,
-0.0203008596,
0.0032577319,
0.0064986791,
0.0224719867,
0.0432909802,
0.0267575383,
-0.0876124129,
0.0437255502,
0.041190885,
0.0245246142,
-0.0174397379,
0.0052880291,
-0.0183740184,
-0.0483299606,
-0.0504109934,
0.0278413128,
0.0420891307,
0.0433040075,
-0.007165214,
0.0024826284,
0.0179648902,
-0.0275453385,
-0.0093594221,
-0.0030866475,
-0.0021885191,
0.0060021863,
0.0248334948,
-0.0303295292,
-0.0038635689,
-0.0443924703,
0.0051509398,
-0.01793034,
-0.0184986945,
-0.0054415921,
0.0171363596,
-0.0090886978,
0.0132154431,
-0.0142768174,
-0.0867667198,
0.0006284292,
-0.0144227762,
-0.0558282882,
-0.0293748789,
0.0409736708,
0.0168496836,
0.0078394813,
0.012554138,
0.0502700917,
0.0043668933,
0.034444578,
0.0283632148,
0.0211131535,
-0.0122870468,
0.0716393813,
-0.0211788006,
-0.0174029395,
-0.078455627,
0.032333497,
-0.0309546404,
0.0264065657,
0.0208612476,
0.0147464238,
-0.0214285646,
0.0132448813,
-0.044588536,
0.0563517325,
-0.0210054666,
0.0233218465,
0.0439159125,
0.0241213199,
-0.0164462682,
-0.040252097,
-0.0406271927,
0.0030953221,
-0.0252725892,
-0.0436774753,
0.0441290513,
0.0177561678,
0.0148061439,
-0.0249951556,
0.043326851,
-0.0045636683,
0.017754592,
0.0636413991,
-0.0902347416,
0.0358411521,
-0.0061822585,
0.0195088293,
-0.0236124266,
-0.0059715225,
0.0558625199,
0.0145482933,
0.0121484585,
0.0214088354,
-0.0220728796,
0.0684047416,
-0.030736072,
0.0121949334,
-0.0393103622,
0.0168619994,
-0.0092646526,
-0.0633061826,
0.0112409862,
-0.0487390123,
-0.0092581548,
0.0393468402,
0.0168247316,
-0.0120940255,
-0.0199534241,
-0.0508901142,
-0.0090544568,
0.012788876,
-0.0313226096,
0.044132214,
-0.0090741972,
0.0232418384,
0.036227528,
-0.0682160556,
-0.0211780053,
0.0190066323,
2.743e-7,
-0.0342665277,
0.0164830387,
-0.0077413144,
0.0533078872,
0.0036201722,
0.0409092568,
-0.0054945853,
0.006343991,
0.0358808115,
0.0052714506,
0.0183514636,
0.0236718785,
0.0307216626,
0.0124822827,
-0.0845559984,
0.0194290429,
-0.0594589002,
-0.0028561952,
-0.0842483193,
-0.0467285514,
0.0554538853,
0.0181020219,
0.0351180471,
-0.0087657142,
0.0263575166,
-0.0641431287,
0.0823781192,
-0.0141196931,
-0.0475427136,
0.0486057773,
-0.0552695319,
-0.0066533368,
-0.040456254,
-0.0756367147,
0.0060243807,
0.0048759431,
0.0117939515,
0.067340076,
-0.0122262379,
-0.0027701617,
0.0407634191,
-0.0023857541,
-0.0088727502,
-0.0538890101,
0.0383384489,
-0.0504127182,
-0.0168324262,
-0.0143702794,
0.0159571562,
-0.0319596753,
-0.0186034925,
-0.0375207216,
-0.0176017154,
0.0107975556,
0.0018491781,
0.0257859118,
-0.0024368824,
-0.0349915586,
-0.0225962922,
0.0098567959,
-0.0425357521,
-0.0166647863,
-0.0340687074,
-0.0116763897,
-0.0184515249,
-0.0500719547,
0.0087815039,
2.715071674e-34,
0.0133739365,
-0.0289384704,
-0.0069631133,
0.0150272604,
0.0475795045,
0.0347291343,
0.0319287032,
-0.0038532068,
0.0448376797,
-0.0564977378,
-0.0562908985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07927v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07927v1 | A Systematic Survey of Prompt Engineering in Large Language Models: Techniques and Applications | 2024-02-05T19:49:13 | 2024-02-05T19:49:13 | Pranab Sahoo, Ayush Kumar Singh, Sriparna Saha, Vinija Jain, Samrat Mondal, Aman Chadha | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Prompt engineering has emerged as an indispensable technique for extending
the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) and vision-language models
(VLMs). This approach leverages task-specific instructions, known as prompts,
to enhance model efficacy without modifying the core model parameters. Rather
than updating the model parameters, prompts allow seamless integration of
pre-trained models into downstream tasks by eliciting desired model behaviors
solely based on the given prompt. Prompts can be natural language instructions
that provide context to guide the model or learned vector representations that
activate relevant knowledge. This burgeoning field has enabled success across
various applications, from question-answering to commonsense reasoning.
However, there remains a lack of systematic organization and understanding of
the diverse prompt engineering methods and techniques. This survey paper
addresses the gap by providing a structured overview of recent advancements in
prompt engineering, categorized by application area. For each prompting
approach, we provide a summary detailing the prompting methodology, its
applications, the models involved, and the datasets utilized. We also delve
into the strengths and limitations of each approach and include a taxonomy
diagram and table summarizing datasets, models, and critical points of each
prompting technique. This systematic analysis enables a better understanding of
this rapidly developing field and facilitates future research by illuminating
open challenges and opportunities for prompt engineering. | [
0.0702835917,
0.0294967722,
-0.0082644382,
0.0193171278,
-0.0371426456,
0.0043883324,
0.0069040759,
-0.014294181,
0.0369091593,
-0.0696901232,
-0.0352918692,
-0.0181556325,
-0.0139050176,
0.0395887122,
0.0192170292,
-0.0575679354,
0.0736743361,
-0.0528616235,
0.0053219637,
0.0053892406,
-0.0097656995,
0.0118990811,
0.009624715,
0.0510596856,
-0.0002390462,
-0.0452608801,
-0.0194590446,
0.0220316481,
0.0147619164,
-0.0128982384,
0.0036959453,
0.063594833,
0.0362104364,
0.0277349837,
0.0000019896,
-0.0790629238,
0.0334809572,
-0.0208085086,
-0.0631334782,
-0.0098901708,
0.0142652765,
-0.0261673089,
0.0061422377,
-0.0078963824,
-0.0289413221,
-0.0070725256,
0.0360603444,
0.0409545042,
0.0612210929,
0.0367586166,
0.0030113615,
-0.0077708564,
0.0016864995,
-0.0262735095,
0.0169431884,
-0.0329837352,
0.0315759741,
-0.0214899108,
0.0289244149,
0.0595125258,
-0.0389563367,
0.0505125225,
0.0446953103,
-0.0328611434,
0.0197222382,
0.031438373,
0.0131452493,
-0.0444834121,
-0.068215929,
0.0925783142,
0.0081606014,
-0.0012936032,
-0.0098252036,
-0.0245730896,
0.0347351059,
0.0021434822,
-0.0483371317,
0.0309306327,
0.024554031,
-0.0034500891,
0.0037184961,
0.0163322724,
0.0053326483,
0.040386606,
0.0213297922,
0.0198676903,
0.0210015289,
-0.0255102422,
0.0235654917,
-0.0072539556,
-0.0214956049,
-0.0792930722,
-0.0176600292,
0.0531513318,
-0.0738588721,
0.0249598809,
-0.0393963978,
-0.0056068446,
0.0429137573,
-0.0037579886,
0.0646367073,
0.0239185523,
-0.0509232767,
0.0723022819,
-0.0288373604,
0.063795045,
-0.0169162583,
0.0274615977,
-0.009581075,
0.0104908319,
-0.038045112,
-0.0154439723,
-0.0563187115,
-0.0170554332,
-0.0347180702,
-0.0277179834,
-0.0290439595,
0.0611270256,
0.003216153,
0.0240211505,
0.0097814566,
0.0077630426,
-0.0180037878,
-0.0198815931,
-0.0302673541,
0.0046425662,
-0.0446080193,
0.02133606,
0.0138587533,
-0.0620646514,
-0.0245411545,
0.0122576589,
0.0046952008,
-0.0362779312,
-0.0261781774,
0.0202137511,
0.0068069221,
-0.0466527939,
-0.0234497078,
-0.0222944412,
-0.0078912117,
-0.0418159328,
-0.0303170513,
-0.0563770384,
0.030443484,
-0.0244710483,
0.0044251606,
-0.0018931984,
0.0021281133,
0.0294259917,
-0.0093071554,
0.090075627,
-0.0127186077,
0.0127750086,
0.011105841,
0.0217408184,
0.0094025303,
0.0510091409,
-0.0197169632,
0.0083899405,
0.0305010099,
0.0016551422,
0.011809418,
0.0257546306,
0.0082044676,
-0.0104165385,
-0.0111679379,
0.0445559472,
0.0352275558,
0.0222333912,
0.0100700157,
0.0409554876,
-0.0154971229,
-0.0091612991,
0.0633330569,
0.0494641922,
-0.0216673855,
-0.0313838758,
0.0819405019,
0.0246283449,
-0.0042630001,
-0.0168949217,
-0.069450736,
0.0058664354,
-0.0418066867,
0.0009819762,
-0.019084014,
0.0283116773,
-0.0536680855,
-0.0383265465,
0.00860414,
-0.0142210601,
0.0149634052,
0.0368098393,
0.0408641621,
0.0334868394,
-0.0306590702,
-0.0007760173,
0.0005103524,
-0.0293716546,
0.0134656532,
-0.0766067505,
0.0629277602,
0.0512115173,
0.042446766,
-0.0190833006,
-0.0135935219,
-0.0006046792,
0.0466852337,
0.0381829292,
0.0383097492,
-0.03640531,
0.0038296103,
-0.0415425226,
-0.0419817418,
-0.0013207437,
-0.0123170624,
-0.0136090871,
0.0154239647,
-0.0130037423,
0.0147683918,
-0.0031163765,
-0.011874293,
0.0436664112,
-0.0140068354,
-0.0228594355,
-0.0123150079,
0.0155709209,
-0.0083051082,
0.0157389697,
0.0271556526,
0.0050092298,
0.0354868285,
-0.0035728228,
0.0105867917,
-0.0028513151,
-0.0518858731,
-0.0518733151,
0.0056228661,
0.0113786785,
-0.036606174,
0.0202681236,
-0.041185692,
-0.0342123844,
-0.0420006365,
-0.0290999804,
-0.001155581,
-0.070709683,
0.0053435788,
0.0053316508,
-0.0086479336,
-0.0568456315,
0.0663830936,
0.0056330604,
0.0016042864,
0.082242094,
0.023255948,
-0.000189535,
-0.0452417806,
-0.0186059084,
-0.0062178131,
-0.0071560489,
-0.0082739173,
0.035761442,
0.0427590907,
-0.0671374574,
-0.0134355929,
-0.0914354399,
-0.0276365671,
-0.0392270498,
-0.0146615226,
-0.0067525948,
0.013190669,
-0.0237925816,
-0.0596479475,
-0.0489894338,
-0.0078654271,
0.0286593754,
0.0323478132,
0.0374332927,
0.0103368517,
-0.0321249813,
-0.0026626077,
-0.0165773109,
0.0099153901,
0.0432364382,
0.0370597728,
-0.0074910475,
-0.0993858278,
0.0184212979,
-0.0125874635,
0.0349715166,
-0.0192055982,
0.0047618272,
0.0194226932,
-0.0064924606,
0.0787980482,
0.0706000626,
-0.0069920747,
0.0239479728,
0.0484369285,
-0.0066978834,
-0.0553011894,
0.0209230445,
-0.0475883894,
-0.0209527556,
-0.0219109599,
-0.0121221496,
0.0162892006,
0.035228204,
-0.0087713972,
-0.0141494181,
-0.0775872767,
0.0157630853,
-0.0037126387,
-0.0526376814,
-0.0650902167,
-0.0345435552,
-0.017018605,
0.0610870682,
-0.013154529,
-0.0710888132,
0.0828016773,
-0.0186144412,
-0.0106198825,
-0.0267635938,
0.0134089971,
-0.0326059684,
0.0705384612,
0.0025557308,
-0.0087156314,
0.0335732214,
-0.0320701487,
-0.0483454019,
-0.003335723,
-0.0287214164,
-0.0060821446,
0.0342549868,
-0.0387894996,
-0.001357396,
-0.0006328706,
-0.023583265,
-0.0699586347,
-0.0776098743,
-0.0190566108,
0.0163309202,
-0.0469949841,
0.0110151758,
0.0024666393,
0.0006297794,
0.0120518859,
0.0175475162,
-0.0124739436,
-0.0184916351,
-0.0470925868,
0.0342375375,
0.0776634961,
0.0525471307,
-0.0048381109,
-0.0128508117,
0.0451171175,
0.042525325,
0.0257214308,
-0.0042835367,
-0.0255344715,
0.0190931931,
0.0648077205,
-0.0295828972,
0.0049131662,
0.0619186461,
0.0710775033,
-0.0448193736,
-0.0155769233,
0.1191666424,
0.0516035371,
-0.0309458766,
-0.0149512906,
-0.0252827145,
0.0327475853,
0.0178755,
0.0314307585,
-0.0695949495,
-0.0341253057,
0.0132143768,
0.0058083818,
-0.0230886601,
0.0015204733,
-0.0252761114,
-0.0960406363,
0.0586244278,
-0.0245607831,
0.0055936133,
-0.0332007818,
-0.0209235698,
0.023120204,
0.0092392415,
0.0072267889,
0.0052507976,
-0.0253024735,
-0.0205061156,
0.0050656898,
0.0020000832,
-0.0590223446,
0.0451239944,
-0.0458557568,
0.0457859747,
0.0736934692,
-0.0054514436,
0.0188691895,
-0.0629178137,
0.0031725094,
-0.0220869109,
0.033618778,
-0.0233287066,
0.0250993483,
-0.0211410746,
-0.0057860436,
-0.0321471393,
0.0515395813,
-0.0047379211,
-0.0554389171,
0.0149758104,
0.0922113582,
-0.0551532805,
0.0093968809,
-0.0308551826,
0.0183745697,
0.0429939218,
0.0952110887,
0.0522409789,
-0.0636315718,
-0.0151963867,
0.002466344,
-0.019148251,
-0.0201350916,
-0.0433410369,
0.0035775441,
0.0168554056,
0.0035946935,
-0.0432886966,
-0.0550732687,
0.0487610288,
0.0111408718,
0.0187120624,
-0.0148194907,
-0.0053475564,
0.0062832925,
-0.0137189254,
0.0773159638,
-0.060011033,
0.0274541657,
-0.0759197176,
-0.0016373667,
0.0151446285,
-0.0591675825,
-0.0134056304,
0.0023631372,
-0.061270941,
-0.0600401051,
-0.0156274065,
0.0720457137,
0.0181588177,
0.0448492616,
-0.0341802761,
-0.0618210435,
0.0449168161,
0.0034202773,
-0.0032245682,
0.0047519989,
0.0223346092,
0.0008249479,
-0.0174357295,
0.0527457595,
-0.0210025646,
0.0125600817,
0.036431171,
0.027645424,
-0.0158708766,
-0.0645678416,
0.0166978035,
-0.0070755491,
0.0591496788,
-0.0128167607,
-0.0079526445,
-0.0574881546,
0.0048710648,
-0.0017934892,
-0.0329958349,
-0.0468224026,
0.0102686547,
0.0149537269,
-0.0146789523,
-0.0063649053,
-0.0142448535,
-0.0621971972,
0.0246854294,
-0.0737624317,
0.0115751,
0.0212970451,
0.0071670753,
0.0277414676,
0.0094036488,
-0.0255353823,
0.0317292213,
-0.0243710522,
0.0233195405,
0.0190948062,
0.1042013839,
0.0324153863,
-0.0161082298,
-0.0122342799,
0.0476310924,
-0.0542029068,
-0.043250028,
0.0290652923,
0.0438983142,
0.0096712634,
0.0096518658,
-0.0168349072,
-0.0192420408,
-0.0124046309,
-0.0043019895,
0.0420569032,
0.0521047711,
-0.0433187895,
0.0806203783,
0.0232254602,
-0.0208092816,
-0.0045922701,
0.0361454114,
-0.0282366127,
0.0148737878,
0.004753923,
0.0182187166,
-0.038999524,
-0.0173086803,
0.0398986675,
-0.0141280601,
-0.0467978604,
0.0441834666,
-0.0559655242,
-0.0386576876,
0.0080170073,
0.0140357642,
-0.0387919769,
0.0102726556,
0.059439268,
0.0580520667,
0.0093671223,
-0.0230492689,
-0.0229998566,
0.0058752401,
-0.0382101089,
-0.0437278487,
-0.0195450671,
-6.042341449e-33,
-0.0208452102,
-0.0199428797,
0.0298315175,
-0.0155784274,
-0.0273937099,
0.0171768181,
-0.0322073251,
-0.0018855617,
-0.0246286858,
0.0009237181,
-0.0111017646,
-0.006831245,
0.0190016665,
0.029979622,
-0.0104123708,
-0.0239527933,
0.0372492373,
-0.0094642872,
-0.0191688202,
0.0145063968,
0.0026927951,
0.011219373,
0.0154565498,
-0.0091825724,
0.0854208767,
-0.0051329229,
-0.0212958306,
0.0450168699,
-0.0426233672,
0.0820946097,
-0.0455243327,
0.0483596921,
0.0230375323,
-0.0262769051,
-0.0289107244,
0.1195852086,
-0.0688323006,
-0.0391060971,
0.0553710572,
0.002617632,
-0.0947516114,
-0.0217989776,
-0.0311962068,
-0.0434030481,
0.0042272909,
0.0141315125,
0.0311447214,
-0.0159453917,
-0.0110394089,
0.0022524006,
-0.0497914553,
-0.0044786553,
0.0133352214,
-0.0548764504,
0.0195640158,
0.0745865554,
0.00186944,
0.0461058803,
-0.0217081849,
0.01864958,
0.0439255908,
-0.0016954931,
0.0555006154,
0.0419834964,
-0.0150158601,
0.0481287651,
-0.0002266912,
-0.0228989571,
-0.0253067352,
-0.0062998468,
0.0143775735,
0.0175993647,
0.0403709076,
0.0286447983,
-0.0156062068,
0.0350420736,
-0.0451148115,
-0.0017217355,
-0.0049959696,
0.0400190912,
0.0342523605,
-0.0307135526,
-0.0278375093,
-0.0101899588,
-0.0556270443,
-0.0141533576,
-0.0419473499,
0.0037557003,
0.049668517,
0.0191873144,
-0.0268691238,
0.0136256209,
0.046584107,
-0.0251261219,
0.0058155344,
0.0375502519,
0.0242208745,
0.024022026,
0.0092150792,
0.0358691029,
-0.0311610624,
-0.0118948305,
0.0543409139,
-0.0414615907,
-0.011807139,
0.0063971207,
0.0217204411,
0.0270453393,
-0.0409260243,
0.0093613369,
-0.0139599983,
0.0497621782,
-0.0247253887,
0.0186636765,
0.0437785909,
0.0395433009,
-0.0407317914,
0.059636306,
0.0102959005,
-0.0559994541,
-0.0220572595,
0.0046295743,
-0.0085928151,
0.0327027515,
-0.0182412043,
0.0073727737,
-0.0195477996,
0.0255549327,
0.0113937389,
-0.0130514754,
0.0015122234,
0.0426971801,
2.532e-7,
0.0237268247,
0.0055299615,
0.0259974021,
0.0432685129,
-0.0014963449,
0.0247449223,
0.0058886376,
0.0282458756,
0.0245452933,
-0.0195943657,
0.0215729475,
0.0391403064,
0.0452628359,
-0.0288674757,
-0.0925523043,
0.0167942196,
-0.0481447726,
0.0048131999,
-0.0694657266,
0.0024156107,
0.0815977082,
0.0751956105,
-0.0248314049,
-0.0158568025,
0.0037308263,
-0.024764182,
0.0452614538,
-0.0583089739,
-0.0070905513,
0.0056428257,
0.0152891492,
-0.0177384466,
0.0198379848,
0.0385334305,
0.0027345987,
0.0052428148,
-0.0063457498,
0.0644861534,
0.0113933524,
-0.0053191115,
-0.029634174,
0.0123229278,
0.0131674092,
-0.0710820854,
0.0896464065,
-0.0840044171,
-0.014584247,
-0.0279322341,
0.0046926551,
-0.0225355346,
0.0385287404,
-0.0325410664,
-0.0223126467,
0.0090041263,
0.0480565801,
-0.0055430261,
-0.0138247665,
-0.0806802735,
0.0042225085,
-0.0347582586,
-0.029247649,
-0.0447379388,
-0.0475778207,
-0.0115384944,
0.0080078682,
-0.0726440176,
-0.0216132049,
2.364919228e-34,
0.0237226617,
-0.0135536371,
0.0304042175,
0.0301867612,
-0.0005695018,
0.0192722026,
-0.0079711434,
0.0149650034,
0.0577923842,
-0.1118136942,
-0.0343226865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03477v1 | Arabic Synonym BERT-based Adversarial Examples for Text Classification | 2024-02-05T19:39:07 | 2024-02-05T19:39:07 | Norah Alshahrani, Saied Alshahrani, Esma Wali, Jeanna Matthews | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text classification systems have been proven vulnerable to adversarial text
examples, modified versions of the original text examples that are often
unnoticed by human eyes, yet can force text classification models to alter
their classification. Often, research works quantifying the impact of
adversarial text attacks have been applied only to models trained in English.
In this paper, we introduce the first word-level study of adversarial attacks
in Arabic. Specifically, we use a synonym (word-level) attack using a Masked
Language Modeling (MLM) task with a BERT model in a black-box setting to assess
the robustness of the state-of-the-art text classification models to
adversarial attacks in Arabic. To evaluate the grammatical and semantic
similarities of the newly produced adversarial examples using our synonym
BERT-based attack, we invite four human evaluators to assess and compare the
produced adversarial examples with their original examples. We also study the
transferability of these newly produced Arabic adversarial examples to various
models and investigate the effectiveness of defense mechanisms against these
adversarial examples on the BERT models. We find that fine-tuned BERT models
were more susceptible to our synonym attacks than the other Deep Neural
Networks (DNN) models like WordCNN and WordLSTM we trained. We also find that
fine-tuned BERT models were more susceptible to transferred attacks. We,
lastly, find that fine-tuned BERT models successfully regain at least 2% in
accuracy after applying adversarial training as an initial defense mechanism. | [
0.0498440303,
0.0472619906,
-0.0286343321,
0.0389182083,
-0.0442587137,
0.0272668637,
0.0369208381,
0.0176157169,
-0.0152744409,
-0.0724137947,
-0.0272722244,
-0.0146328993,
0.0504304953,
-0.0128668528,
0.0814611688,
-0.0245386064,
0.0527073406,
-0.0192229785,
-0.0366006754,
-0.0314926878,
0.0130167967,
-0.0128576634,
0.024598429,
0.0316127688,
0.0015561418,
-0.0098316809,
0.0121774534,
-0.0061878841,
0.027939802,
0.024212312,
0.0610809363,
0.0780668929,
-0.004859556,
0.0885617658,
0.000001651,
-0.0573377199,
-0.0164855234,
0.0150506776,
-0.0148204258,
0.044348672,
0.023239322,
-0.0343242437,
-0.0371441282,
-0.0033543154,
-0.0258933324,
-0.0097440798,
0.0105483597,
0.0491375029,
0.0748961791,
0.0928659812,
0.0006907461,
-0.0558314845,
0.0176797751,
-0.052055411,
-0.0257325247,
-0.0341558792,
0.0509736128,
-0.0332476161,
-0.0511274077,
-0.0077064945,
-0.0207139701,
0.0172986407,
0.0127216745,
-0.0040001022,
-0.0060236044,
-0.0026360189,
-0.0381365307,
0.0042027095,
0.0455439016,
0.041351568,
-0.0748377591,
-0.038893383,
-0.0339668021,
0.0189789534,
0.0207846109,
0.0084468592,
0.0147152562,
-0.0066704596,
0.0228234883,
0.0165346265,
0.0193754863,
-0.0222459845,
0.0575092286,
0.025649393,
-0.0297169201,
-0.005606072,
0.0399278328,
-0.0351767167,
0.0103252428,
-0.0255087689,
-0.0101027563,
-0.0633376092,
0.0227763467,
-0.0049285223,
0.0304795764,
0.003011825,
-0.0986461937,
-0.0954185128,
0.0394510888,
-0.0971282497,
0.0237797853,
0.0308721885,
-0.0428810604,
0.0135307461,
-0.0847844034,
0.0366919637,
-0.0080034267,
0.0708462521,
-0.0072775246,
-0.0128794434,
-0.0298160482,
-0.0044686184,
-0.0273062419,
0.0492864661,
-0.0339297429,
0.033517126,
-0.0632319748,
0.0232984107,
-0.0416854993,
0.0408550911,
-0.0562316924,
-0.0099801598,
-0.0188754871,
-0.0137524633,
0.0019212792,
-0.0670550019,
0.0056412234,
0.0107502304,
-0.0483755283,
-0.1018651798,
-0.0137084611,
0.011014998,
-0.0413494967,
-0.027124377,
0.014564476,
0.0638419166,
-0.0258328151,
-0.0578548908,
-0.017009791,
0.0096618924,
-0.0138449473,
0.004720123,
-0.001034998,
-0.0343791246,
-0.0041664909,
-0.022204889,
-0.0278568957,
-0.0313151069,
0.0064657885,
0.0335662477,
-0.0018722137,
0.1006395891,
0.0175310429,
-0.0311050266,
0.0597006343,
0.0418547466,
-0.0095483307,
0.0253884029,
-0.0122826984,
0.0278728977,
0.0208154228,
0.0059974873,
0.0061686095,
0.0367702022,
0.0238502733,
0.0183583628,
-0.0524532758,
-0.0096943574,
-0.0057642478,
0.018696053,
-0.0305178538,
0.0594585575,
-0.0252462644,
-0.0862550288,
0.081715554,
0.0119838528,
-0.0352208056,
0.0936367735,
-0.010031349,
0.0087741893,
0.0231304727,
0.0199035481,
-0.0418401286,
-0.038617596,
-0.0315363146,
-0.0239981022,
0.016541753,
0.0310464893,
-0.0077185696,
-0.0304934904,
-0.0124063836,
-0.0117552178,
0.0545837767,
-0.0421597473,
0.0563720986,
0.0471340939,
-0.0369597785,
0.0196059197,
-0.0114200963,
0.0097185234,
-0.014129458,
-0.092970252,
-0.0300430842,
0.0121073341,
0.0582456216,
-0.0331751704,
-0.0029105598,
-0.0369351767,
-0.024182478,
0.0240411237,
0.0353585631,
-0.0021265834,
-0.0026560638,
-0.023708947,
-0.0122792413,
-0.0608268715,
0.0070222183,
0.0238519441,
0.0218824856,
0.0335324295,
0.0043576718,
-0.025364181,
-0.0354421623,
0.0514909402,
0.0341826044,
-0.0446273647,
0.0052766879,
0.0293448251,
0.0301486552,
0.0051641325,
-0.0514045097,
0.0207698084,
0.0257329904,
-0.0469948798,
-0.0505458526,
-0.0258585792,
0.0187000539,
-0.0274589732,
0.0108964508,
-0.0347288065,
-0.0186020248,
0.0892590359,
-0.0392417125,
0.0156145263,
0.0419144332,
-0.0616499856,
0.0554297939,
-0.0408081301,
0.0294944681,
-0.0275158137,
0.0645044222,
-0.0093808146,
0.0641920418,
-0.0403285362,
0.0007710536,
0.0065701529,
0.0191822071,
0.0537914932,
0.0254775509,
-0.0406390503,
0.01053314,
-0.0242828932,
-0.0008347482,
0.0128313368,
-0.0240496751,
0.0035238718,
-0.0264707543,
-0.0426244773,
-0.0326522924,
-0.0305333808,
0.0210412871,
-0.0024681517,
-0.0303902514,
-0.0197254475,
-0.0042714248,
0.000205608,
-0.0052710767,
-0.0504077896,
0.0226066876,
0.0317943096,
-0.0257761236,
-0.0048356676,
-0.0287159886,
-0.02000314,
0.0055627446,
0.0875071883,
-0.0127098272,
-0.0554677062,
0.0121867005,
-0.0316079743,
-0.0043453467,
0.0574453473,
-0.0109796962,
-0.0657384619,
0.0273398422,
0.0314251035,
0.0065958146,
0.0629362166,
0.0545681193,
0.0514512397,
0.0236207135,
0.0369846448,
-0.0253300685,
-0.0000034505,
0.0284376517,
-0.0210642759,
-0.0467679836,
-0.039633356,
-0.0040494357,
0.0194945745,
0.01249744,
-0.0281650685,
-0.0086907083,
0.0310749151,
-0.0038789075,
-0.0325275287,
-0.0313367099,
-0.0305464771,
-0.0286606811,
-0.0235805642,
-0.0115223657,
-0.0493057258,
0.0690935031,
-0.0160107389,
0.0363343209,
-0.0408575162,
-0.021260215,
0.0215001479,
0.0252287555,
-0.0200860277,
0.0186230019,
-0.0248877145,
-0.0161612239,
-0.0316148736,
-0.0434115417,
0.0251470599,
-0.0133113572,
0.0143555412,
-0.0121337315,
-0.0096259173,
-0.0199946295,
-0.0299250558,
-0.0741158277,
-0.0491399728,
-0.0160156246,
0.029968895,
0.050506629,
-0.0137140984,
-0.0435368493,
-0.0312009137,
0.0138011184,
0.0243605375,
-0.0081109433,
-0.0020838038,
-0.033286646,
0.0326635651,
0.0149907339,
-0.0480190963,
0.012788658,
-0.0271795858,
0.0046706921,
0.0520738922,
-0.0158449579,
0.020501921,
-0.05387678,
-0.0159354042,
0.0278610773,
-0.0280480459,
-0.0160646718,
-0.0291832145,
-0.0316153429,
-0.0424382426,
0.0141437165,
0.0656677485,
0.0025426217,
0.0176613126,
0.012943794,
-0.0341817513,
0.003051257,
-0.012766744,
-0.0278423447,
-0.0808303803,
-0.0123311281,
0.0446526371,
-0.0012968446,
-0.0006235737,
0.0184464026,
0.0244498011,
-0.0838619471,
-0.0248480607,
-0.0138877761,
-0.0155594693,
-0.0333093964,
-0.0195294451,
-0.0080617229,
0.0237034149,
0.0202053003,
-0.0362010971,
0.0380496122,
-0.0088695977,
0.0137780961,
0.0079268878,
-0.0595309027,
0.0137538342,
-0.0296181459,
0.0158164017,
0.06137909,
0.0381979272,
-0.060724739,
-0.0556249917,
0.0547281578,
-0.0203067344,
-0.0254323762,
0.0196010508,
0.0508955978,
-0.0224151183,
-0.0180377308,
0.0169039089,
0.0161736347,
0.0109715005,
-0.0204432569,
-0.0189567544,
0.0060520968,
0.0077216779,
-0.0169416964,
-0.0298093408,
0.0004457807,
-0.0061822636,
0.0610641018,
0.019836098,
-0.0593161434,
-0.0301798563,
-0.0231562071,
0.0043860548,
-0.0576793961,
0.0119066751,
0.0337640345,
0.0021657818,
-0.0434878245,
-0.0639296472,
-0.0268567558,
-0.0303816292,
0.0041753612,
0.0203202348,
0.0262934789,
-0.0370973833,
-0.0121534802,
-0.0362373255,
-0.0081484513,
0.0398628302,
0.0494183637,
-0.0152636794,
-0.0032330882,
0.0132658612,
-0.033806324,
-0.0247355197,
-0.0166758858,
-0.0610068925,
-0.0680772215,
0.0454154834,
0.0323204845,
0.011401088,
0.0214438215,
-0.0342924409,
-0.0977360234,
0.0583179146,
0.0516524464,
0.0292967334,
0.0077074063,
0.0690607503,
-0.0356504843,
0.0135658002,
0.0568590835,
-0.0174525045,
-0.0044609807,
0.0656505376,
-0.0553555377,
-0.0214263052,
-0.0031220953,
-0.0329541266,
-0.0155056054,
0.0575185046,
-0.0065696528,
-0.0250362828,
-0.0033989656,
0.0424917638,
0.0025549605,
-0.0073410249,
0.0235762261,
0.0088241268,
0.0159640629,
0.0380256809,
0.0016263931,
0.0341228768,
-0.0183465574,
0.0220431779,
0.0040792525,
0.0215324163,
-0.0129047604,
0.0525993295,
-0.0031631903,
0.0351386666,
-0.0298496094,
-0.0154524641,
0.0047044754,
0.0147490641,
-0.0275543518,
0.0148051074,
0.0032396328,
0.0132645685,
0.0159683581,
0.037051782,
-0.0083817421,
0.0044881864,
-0.0296054985,
0.0261365063,
0.0255880002,
-0.0112438044,
-0.0148826176,
-0.0183045976,
-0.0248885639,
-0.0002492143,
-0.0262714699,
-0.0361653082,
-0.0166111477,
-0.0015741361,
-0.0148909502,
-0.0077957455,
0.0518808067,
0.0576275699,
-0.0049194586,
0.0386167206,
0.0314965472,
-0.0439225882,
-0.0295397975,
0.001037506,
0.0824890509,
0.0149539039,
-0.0155597599,
0.0049044746,
-0.0385263264,
-0.1056782231,
0.0388184786,
0.0157153513,
0.0370616131,
0.0249052178,
0.0104398895,
0.0773541257,
0.015485906,
0.0149881253,
-0.0546475351,
0.0735072792,
0.0387859009,
-0.0472864918,
0.0045680236,
-5.32110036e-33,
0.021395091,
-0.0028339794,
-0.0311748907,
-0.0496695489,
0.0213643666,
0.009103057,
-0.0195994973,
-0.0233221482,
-0.0344042368,
0.0457518846,
-0.0062658312,
0.0237585139,
-0.0138979889,
0.0275144055,
-0.0427331328,
-0.0588756688,
0.038702406,
0.0131134214,
-0.0131186983,
-0.0146836452,
0.039194528,
0.0440565422,
0.058454562,
-0.0489916727,
0.0473632887,
-0.0014732016,
-0.0342293493,
-0.0061867069,
-0.0241535436,
0.0611448959,
-0.0241303239,
0.0351142175,
0.0111903232,
0.0086373482,
0.0096371807,
0.0354879573,
-0.027798811,
-0.0152603183,
0.0111785801,
0.0286017619,
-0.0286906809,
-0.0206011664,
0.0385785773,
0.0174449161,
-0.0495359115,
0.0191963799,
0.0179631468,
-0.0300386362,
-0.0218892153,
-0.0044593601,
-0.0676818043,
0.031130258,
0.0019920985,
-0.0177900344,
0.0170300677,
0.0102318581,
0.0444850028,
-0.0048359041,
-0.1010299101,
-0.030531317,
0.0307330322,
0.0153063498,
0.0323268138,
0.0003650967,
-0.0096741365,
0.0745065585,
0.0374049507,
-0.0069658458,
0.0177243724,
-0.0074116001,
0.043847695,
0.0081918342,
0.0987231731,
0.100016363,
0.0559454039,
-0.0269504935,
-0.0891137421,
0.0206263773,
-0.0207492094,
0.0019124952,
0.0360553786,
-0.0016601086,
-0.0527960248,
0.0253043026,
-0.0176147725,
-0.0550139919,
-0.0318710394,
0.0175616182,
-0.0037467282,
-0.0277970936,
-0.0233631618,
0.0514048003,
-0.0243624933,
-0.0262297988,
0.02502946,
0.0024335375,
-0.0208768807,
-0.0256731343,
0.0276303962,
0.0358230136,
-0.0069221179,
-0.0277002379,
0.0306458846,
0.0174866281,
0.0432076193,
0.0112717729,
0.0730209202,
0.0337449424,
-0.0801839009,
0.0098267496,
-0.0020244322,
0.0252526198,
0.0287011676,
0.0432110317,
0.0093270335,
0.002131162,
0.0107401395,
0.0056508686,
0.0405560099,
-0.0011012533,
-0.0051668966,
0.0387161188,
-0.0287462696,
-0.0039846813,
0.0246161334,
-0.0089109596,
-0.0128006376,
0.0470327698,
0.0510741882,
-0.099152483,
0.0150049115,
-0.0259130932,
2.554e-7,
0.0159175359,
0.0339468271,
0.0225964058,
-0.0285185669,
0.0306474622,
0.0721683726,
0.0121807158,
0.0861731768,
-0.0028062363,
0.0335234106,
-0.0198534969,
-0.0314274617,
0.0373500697,
0.0028901109,
-0.0468074083,
0.0073261727,
-0.0975889266,
0.0197271537,
-0.0265884884,
-0.0081456341,
0.025799552,
0.1226467714,
0.0200653486,
-0.0162287522,
-0.0194324683,
-0.0807198882,
0.0340335071,
-0.0191907827,
-0.0036746403,
0.0050936975,
0.0609613061,
0.0117268451,
0.0524215288,
0.0251667686,
-0.0625766292,
0.0185425319,
0.0470436774,
0.0329521038,
-0.0145829711,
-0.0037744858,
-0.0218685716,
-0.0460812636,
-0.020944722,
-0.0803496838,
0.0641019717,
-0.0285878275,
-0.0016613433,
0.0122731561,
-0.0281485599,
0.0231353063,
0.0767482519,
-0.0451734699,
-0.0359135047,
0.0134965964,
0.0405871049,
0.0362045355,
-0.0009653327,
-0.0742444396,
0.0197179969,
-0.0300261024,
-0.0347924791,
0.0154852858,
-0.0219126958,
0.005345175,
0.0337686129,
-0.0078610079,
0.0261990353,
1.945720953e-34,
0.0216029156,
-0.014608643,
-0.0237005483,
-0.0032513128,
0.053396102,
0.0014457032,
0.0029797519,
-0.0006028428,
0.0152356019,
-0.0056643966,
-0.0182278566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03435v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03435v1 | Psychological Assessments with Large Language Models: A Privacy-Focused and Cost-Effective Approach | 2024-02-05T19:00:02 | 2024-02-05T19:00:02 | Sergi Blanco-Cuaresma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | This study explores the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) to analyze text
comments from Reddit users, aiming to achieve two primary objectives: firstly,
to pinpoint critical excerpts that support a predefined psychological
assessment of suicidal risk; and secondly, to summarize the material to
substantiate the preassigned suicidal risk level. The work is circumscribed to
the use of "open-source" LLMs that can be run locally, thereby enhancing data
privacy. Furthermore, it prioritizes models with low computational
requirements, making it accessible to both individuals and institutions
operating on limited computing budgets. The implemented strategy only relies on
a carefully crafted prompt and a grammar to guide the LLM's text completion.
Despite its simplicity, the evaluation metrics show outstanding results, making
it a valuable privacy-focused and cost-effective approach. This work is part of
the Computational Linguistics and Clinical Psychology (CLPsych) 2024 shared
task. | [
0.0639221743,
0.0958750322,
-0.0324735269,
0.0116884839,
-0.0687476695,
0.0130831851,
0.0608582906,
0.0080089001,
0.0831412897,
-0.0286386125,
-0.007089321,
-0.0359642766,
-0.031927444,
0.0098429741,
-0.0166276637,
-0.0237597991,
0.0033950997,
-0.0015990204,
0.0491733402,
-0.012911452,
0.0155736152,
0.0250563566,
-0.0092612766,
0.033666525,
0.0286020879,
-0.0100902664,
0.0289177857,
-0.0380399302,
0.0056559476,
-0.0466707312,
-0.0189756099,
0.0778893307,
-0.0334238037,
0.0459877849,
0.000002053,
-0.0519861095,
-0.0211515911,
0.0185614116,
-0.0028630893,
-0.0145138595,
0.0822368115,
-0.0196889732,
0.0203513,
0.0229796618,
-0.0267492998,
-0.0226600226,
0.0527613796,
0.0306346156,
0.0673655495,
0.0707700178,
-0.0321041122,
-0.0580642745,
0.0107646184,
-0.0113569628,
0.0081153139,
0.0046567731,
0.0724198893,
-0.0245106295,
0.0138040837,
0.0083270874,
0.0226250943,
0.0285438448,
-0.0182938855,
-0.0046199425,
-0.0171090327,
0.002452458,
-0.0165080149,
-0.0644119233,
0.0066570523,
0.0273218099,
0.0575452335,
0.0028239083,
0.0611837506,
0.011343969,
0.0063819499,
0.0138610108,
-0.0461574793,
0.0532402173,
-0.0457625911,
-0.0032224203,
0.036325343,
0.0087883919,
0.0326648243,
0.0142840501,
0.0430375449,
0.0403836742,
0.0042535281,
-0.0162028652,
0.0017780452,
-0.0206201281,
-0.0469950177,
-0.0803518295,
0.0749128833,
0.0001577106,
0.0018740142,
0.0240417663,
-0.0422024429,
-0.0851474181,
0.0627196059,
-0.0745141953,
0.0423284434,
-0.0104046836,
0.0403704606,
0.0439563021,
0.0053480295,
-0.0047505726,
0.0000080635,
-0.0082198624,
-0.0033023222,
0.0377107263,
-0.0361885279,
0.0069544772,
-0.0229899995,
0.032799542,
0.0053088944,
0.017181363,
-0.053296946,
0.0464354269,
-0.0274955668,
-0.0056600622,
-0.0104006566,
-0.0530183502,
0.0099939536,
0.0160584096,
0.0124248732,
-0.0444488749,
-0.0312843062,
0.0016521201,
-0.0135284467,
-0.0223407689,
0.0339339823,
-0.0099856183,
0.0034533376,
-0.0276612677,
0.0012789716,
0.0624615736,
0.0535411052,
-0.0120304329,
-0.0163287167,
-0.0708329454,
-0.0391621888,
-0.0122434143,
-0.0272988044,
-0.0627757981,
0.0097671105,
0.0082193241,
-0.0184355192,
-0.0397543535,
0.0162144117,
0.0308483746,
-0.0511589684,
0.0481670983,
-0.0308558196,
0.0131606329,
0.0149054155,
0.0305275843,
0.0246848892,
0.0308042467,
-0.0013307671,
0.0351005755,
0.0511042811,
-0.0224422161,
0.0274203457,
0.016676832,
0.0031297926,
-0.0121973362,
-0.0363884605,
0.0088684484,
-0.0351334177,
-0.0295029413,
-0.0516311601,
0.0593318157,
0.0057985894,
-0.0030119489,
0.0661614835,
0.1082303748,
-0.002461883,
0.0430974923,
-0.043724291,
0.0383793227,
-0.0145785986,
-0.0380835421,
-0.0350167528,
-0.0170701295,
-0.0396115556,
-0.0375454724,
0.027862357,
-0.0179846454,
0.0157875642,
-0.0215845965,
-0.0301445667,
-0.0406809337,
0.0039835609,
0.0231928714,
-0.0077118445,
-0.0264680702,
0.0275286343,
0.0075784065,
0.0483150221,
-0.030877484,
-0.0017856109,
-0.0273748301,
0.0393894687,
0.0552336872,
0.0256580673,
-0.0152966846,
0.0361572094,
-0.0487959571,
0.0388286225,
0.025909815,
-0.0176341739,
0.0199447218,
-0.0030283933,
-0.0201349016,
-0.0220178086,
0.016928792,
0.0178647544,
-0.0213394482,
-0.006696301,
-0.00411626,
-0.0172913559,
-0.0061254138,
-0.0080228345,
0.0168640204,
0.0256509092,
-0.0338829346,
-0.0076765954,
-0.0001640282,
0.0621271804,
0.0212798994,
-0.003181285,
0.0161869954,
-0.006188706,
0.0091556292,
-0.0294684619,
-0.0383493006,
0.0083109299,
0.0298146121,
-0.0185253657,
-0.0498410389,
0.0235133395,
0.0562319532,
0.0043040337,
-0.0091299564,
0.0040519885,
-0.0514852442,
0.0545718707,
0.0051778699,
-0.0145056108,
-0.0362294912,
0.0058850618,
-0.0414138325,
0.0297608972,
-0.0331308134,
0.0538057424,
-0.0457870737,
-0.0632807016,
-0.0090285586,
-0.0185484886,
-0.0599097311,
-0.0382608883,
-0.0080513591,
0.026718298,
0.0322012082,
0.0002214673,
-0.0236794073,
-0.0482580476,
-0.0985957012,
0.0392456017,
-0.001070692,
0.0427642912,
0.0289714914,
-0.0059030061,
-0.0302982386,
-0.0059906379,
-0.0320350155,
-0.0158485211,
0.0037754155,
0.0593236163,
0.0105949417,
0.0059582619,
-0.0090254685,
-0.0101137068,
-0.0511148646,
-0.0364548042,
0.0229784455,
0.0265995581,
-0.065026015,
-0.0114498688,
0.0694157109,
-0.0335397236,
-0.0009290077,
-0.0006459868,
-0.0295161828,
0.0030016664,
-0.0097330408,
0.018013034,
0.0371109322,
0.0236020405,
0.0178474896,
0.0497027785,
0.0152196316,
-0.0162278898,
-0.0364280343,
-0.0422751941,
-0.0416255854,
-0.0360171013,
-0.0651416779,
0.0052145687,
0.0299056228,
0.0519795083,
-0.0310499966,
-0.0180278663,
0.0312670209,
-0.0524797179,
-0.024986377,
0.0144181447,
-0.0225562677,
0.0066716201,
0.032847207,
0.0038373666,
-0.0495060869,
0.0704185069,
0.0055100508,
0.0413519815,
-0.00793509,
-0.0474668667,
-0.0202719513,
0.0525922216,
0.0228148531,
0.0376184732,
0.026569657,
-0.0337655693,
0.0610220022,
-0.0037816537,
0.0172861218,
-0.0357611105,
0.0150913997,
-0.0063233282,
-0.0118820947,
0.019334171,
-0.0253441632,
-0.0175939687,
-0.1323473006,
-0.049102623,
-0.0385522023,
0.0210851002,
0.0005180227,
-0.0105604567,
0.0165140256,
0.0323787183,
-0.0146282697,
-0.008446102,
-0.0105869733,
-0.0101614129,
-0.022224525,
0.024947226,
-0.0781656802,
0.035214819,
-0.0235217586,
0.0170804393,
0.1065090001,
-0.0085396571,
0.0458697975,
0.0282973815,
-0.0249054153,
0.0018929568,
-0.0374771766,
-0.0237874649,
0.0127491169,
0.0251075067,
-0.0277163237,
0.0083154636,
0.1086152643,
0.0316382945,
-0.0686973557,
-0.0010795171,
-0.0077240118,
-0.0187400803,
0.0093951477,
-0.0160432998,
-0.0700273141,
0.0048452388,
-0.0036295257,
0.0603564233,
-0.0786644667,
-0.0675711632,
-0.0084835086,
-0.0624383278,
0.0286725778,
-0.0151360026,
0.0057749827,
0.0484326221,
-0.0710952431,
0.0361301787,
-0.0133864479,
-0.0533785671,
-0.030583676,
0.0062189125,
-0.0025578286,
-0.0038020262,
-0.0885430723,
-0.0120978709,
0.0040063052,
-0.0312443022,
0.0605416819,
0.0090397736,
0.0187577568,
-0.0179411732,
-0.0258519165,
0.0315494575,
0.0210270267,
-0.0538614467,
0.0006961229,
0.058170639,
0.0363455862,
0.0031309314,
-0.1087650508,
0.084549576,
-0.0265961178,
-0.0120583698,
0.0264214072,
0.0636840165,
-0.0381072089,
-0.0309891477,
-0.0173400789,
0.0265229773,
0.0115726879,
0.0672303215,
0.0056615011,
-0.0455550067,
0.008621118,
-0.0012714103,
-0.0052550063,
-0.0007075565,
-0.051995337,
-0.0120940227,
-0.004392277,
-0.0414748043,
-0.0431038961,
0.0044101374,
0.0099380286,
-0.0160235185,
0.0102315629,
0.0030064292,
0.0433838293,
-0.0020806561,
-0.0538907275,
0.035381075,
-0.0308422726,
-0.0063636536,
-0.042101413,
0.0305162314,
0.0314304121,
0.0342094339,
-0.0140156215,
0.022874115,
-0.0695878044,
-0.0292442441,
0.0418453217,
0.0083665615,
0.0157977715,
-0.0312516354,
-0.0310688876,
-0.0801428556,
0.0533534922,
0.0013021408,
-0.010436818,
0.0082768686,
0.0099451458,
0.0013343261,
0.0105315084,
0.0129696652,
0.001133906,
0.0289277192,
0.0509408675,
-0.0328547247,
-0.07029365,
-0.026585957,
0.0010875864,
0.0614100322,
0.0289525073,
0.009111451,
0.0338847116,
-0.0103441617,
-0.0213264376,
-0.0498536937,
-0.00806648,
-0.0098129325,
-0.0412752554,
0.0502341241,
0.0105373356,
-0.0157047212,
-0.0310037173,
-0.0343085676,
-0.0191922132,
-0.0480435304,
0.0565878153,
0.0232027248,
-0.0060414635,
0.0425077938,
0.0067473021,
-0.0394226238,
0.0535424873,
-0.0101098837,
0.0207200851,
-0.0214749165,
0.0269545689,
-0.0241248272,
-0.0179017708,
0.049754642,
0.0435939133,
-0.051722765,
-0.0607357994,
-0.0078276712,
-0.0030355367,
-0.0189551972,
0.0104795974,
0.0317028277,
-0.0399240889,
0.0074387179,
-0.0410422608,
0.0423941426,
-0.001627064,
-0.0560708418,
0.0192925483,
0.0105197895,
-0.0264273025,
0.0024890972,
0.0503287576,
-0.0023437103,
-0.0148119451,
0.026281679,
-0.0754716247,
-0.0180820692,
-0.0307667088,
-0.0254872832,
0.0400350839,
-0.0330518447,
-0.0242315121,
-0.0504657589,
-0.0672140568,
0.0092540793,
-0.0170645565,
0.0061458289,
-0.0040694424,
-0.0031568385,
0.007729867,
0.0166762602,
-0.0303489286,
-0.076792635,
0.0495313257,
-0.0101728439,
-0.042487599,
-0.0154534001,
-5.805582193e-33,
0.0205355696,
-0.0384136662,
-0.0316079631,
0.0432256497,
0.0145124691,
0.0168023761,
0.0079111625,
0.0460299179,
0.0205824506,
0.0014835648,
-0.0189786665,
0.0330226794,
0.0087720621,
0.0270940587,
0.021336101,
0.0050992346,
0.0075701275,
-0.0203775615,
0.0097631011,
0.0203059521,
0.004992153,
0.0163178332,
0.0168399885,
-0.0892595053,
0.0977586955,
-0.0062227375,
-0.019382624,
0.0315501392,
0.0046240417,
0.0387300327,
-0.0234181732,
0.0401841663,
0.0361131467,
-0.0029067253,
-0.0087618241,
0.0667480975,
-0.0286463052,
-0.0177421439,
0.0252590608,
-0.0288546551,
-0.0163457189,
-0.0506928824,
0.0511495732,
-0.0255939513,
-0.0259242784,
-0.0248066168,
0.0165001974,
-0.0358369127,
0.036436934,
-0.0059682475,
0.0315431952,
0.0179014392,
-0.0096361544,
0.0273768101,
0.0343770124,
0.0154274544,
-0.02100976,
0.012119907,
-0.0165604353,
0.0203385074,
0.0130763883,
0.0007614109,
0.0210360568,
-0.0330442078,
0.0177926347,
0.0452084132,
0.0096268347,
0.0167831462,
-0.0453789122,
-0.0055414527,
-0.0153398877,
0.0202485044,
0.0630196184,
0.0711174235,
0.0034020639,
-0.0295799877,
-0.0663186982,
-0.0246431697,
0.0275448505,
-0.0006573542,
0.0927619487,
-0.0271165874,
-0.0440285243,
-0.0235781725,
-0.031304352,
-0.0160984173,
-0.0264989082,
0.0018592286,
-0.0242956225,
-0.0368633829,
-0.0336349308,
-0.0183417089,
0.003041259,
-0.0489885993,
-0.0221908465,
-0.0042281649,
0.0573277622,
0.0386175774,
-0.0035784158,
0.0106025459,
-0.03488129,
0.0307802595,
-0.0095266262,
-0.0335768759,
0.0555454232,
0.0088206334,
0.0229821242,
-0.0391496122,
-0.0743884817,
-0.0364379995,
-0.0023297635,
0.0504029095,
0.021097485,
0.041040685,
0.0492004938,
0.0074491999,
0.0154628241,
0.0425920375,
0.0509636551,
0.0346492007,
-0.0368338041,
-0.0020748544,
-0.0284550171,
-0.0222442765,
0.0218136888,
-0.0375854671,
0.0185862314,
0.0407229662,
0.0814795643,
-0.0219129864,
0.0085521853,
-0.0424144194,
2.798e-7,
0.0460026413,
0.0598188825,
-0.0422614813,
0.0016034411,
0.0312328804,
0.0360380486,
0.0264846124,
0.046284277,
0.0281193033,
0.0092037506,
-0.0150412461,
0.0061070342,
0.06084444,
0.0637193695,
-0.041783195,
-0.0414640419,
-0.0401057079,
0.0006602559,
-0.0659696311,
0.0319571272,
0.0895627141,
0.0588218644,
0.0360025018,
-0.010547719,
-0.0471090302,
-0.0487772711,
0.0219800025,
-0.0592959002,
-0.0346115641,
0.0233755708,
0.040974386,
0.0398747176,
0.0228988826,
0.0147223203,
0.0089500062,
-0.0477284528,
-0.0200497303,
0.1074843332,
0.0219386481,
0.0356150977,
0.0319773294,
-0.0463347621,
0.0061879982,
-0.0275050271,
0.0631107092,
-0.0310589299,
-0.0514840558,
-0.061833702,
0.0080830473,
-0.0972445309,
0.0524375625,
-0.0158629995,
-0.0119097782,
0.0114070959,
0.0091957655,
-0.005636123,
0.0123777157,
-0.0444518998,
-0.0328187458,
-0.0047365222,
-0.0269587748,
-0.0506276824,
0.0028344786,
0.0399272926,
0.0016029961,
-0.044784449,
0.0777643919,
2.476538156e-34,
-0.0209023412,
0.0270767789,
-0.000857048,
-0.0311681312,
0.0328871198,
0.0201899111,
0.0067221327,
0.0231352523,
0.007693511,
-0.1111285612,
0.0015092733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03303v1 | Nevermind: Instruction Override and Moderation in Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T18:58:19 | 2024-02-05T18:58:19 | Edward Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Given the impressive capabilities of recent Large Language Models (LLMs), we
investigate and benchmark the most popular proprietary and different sized open
source models on the task of explicit instruction following in conflicting
situations, e.g. overrides. These include the ability of the model to override
the knowledge within the weights of the model, the ability to override (or
moderate) extracted knowledge in the prompt, and lastly the ability to perform
a full jailbreak. Experimentation performed suggest several key findings to
improve instruction following - larger models perform the best in following
instructions that override internal and contextual instructions, and are
obedient, even to a fault. When scaling to longer contexts via rope scaling, a
significant buffer needs to be maintained from the edge of the perplexity cliff
in order to maintain instruction following capabilities. Finally, we observe
improving instruction following, and subsequently instruction
overrides/jailbreaks, is fundamentally at odds with the ability of a language
model to follow given safety filters or guidelines. Thus, we postulate the most
effective approach for safe, trustworthy AI should be dealt external to the LLM
itself. | [
0.0354157276,
0.0607383735,
-0.0211084858,
0.0153477769,
-0.0305941217,
0.0040118131,
-0.0153325815,
-0.0113839908,
0.0306900647,
-0.0053330967,
-0.0312741324,
-0.023256164,
-0.0238817669,
0.0163154453,
0.004638724,
-0.0147522269,
0.0747243389,
-0.1005009338,
-0.0191197097,
-0.0026795289,
-0.0146934101,
-0.0062840502,
0.0211445112,
0.0302653518,
0.0177200045,
-0.0106188459,
-0.0238628034,
0.0287300032,
-0.0066196378,
-0.0094369594,
-0.0069228127,
0.0141254487,
0.0050697112,
0.0418853462,
0.0000024331,
-0.0403155014,
-0.001732719,
-0.0045820433,
-0.0245046485,
0.0443359315,
0.0208004732,
-0.0466343462,
-0.0372466855,
0.0151526025,
-0.0297198649,
0.0333158597,
0.0501515791,
0.0275786575,
0.0767989904,
0.0799293146,
0.0171790104,
-0.0050784689,
0.0474172905,
-0.0128407869,
-0.0077448306,
-0.0771495402,
0.0336061418,
0.0035670591,
0.0270480793,
0.0355164632,
-0.0367907099,
0.0132911317,
0.0452846587,
-0.0489293225,
-0.0395274088,
-0.0082429983,
-0.0135455616,
-0.0303559527,
-0.0326500051,
0.0615920611,
-0.031987112,
-0.0108228372,
-0.0017303966,
-0.0080760624,
0.018072838,
-0.0008841094,
-0.0201059021,
0.0605853572,
-0.0062371194,
-0.0096632196,
0.0272171348,
-0.0302577,
0.0383117273,
0.019845577,
-0.0136370938,
0.0799130499,
0.0094222454,
-0.0456038974,
0.0103450343,
-0.0193162952,
-0.0336499922,
-0.0706927702,
0.0056471946,
0.0417505465,
-0.0423932485,
0.0351582319,
-0.0540141053,
0.0403441675,
0.0364387818,
-0.0313886404,
0.0512133278,
0.0493441336,
-0.0102877216,
0.0389471613,
-0.0096063698,
0.0485372692,
-0.0130921779,
0.039821554,
-0.0203842875,
0.0306956377,
-0.0192703474,
0.0123270806,
-0.0423100144,
0.0330783911,
-0.0334913097,
0.0104796775,
-0.0117400168,
0.0359728672,
-0.0331593528,
0.0494964123,
-0.0038104802,
-0.0393969156,
-0.0228946935,
-0.022839779,
0.0239906106,
0.0051614963,
-0.0400947556,
0.0124934213,
0.0097941468,
-0.0450167917,
-0.0120507358,
-0.0027217946,
-0.0523106158,
-0.0226631314,
0.0082438961,
0.0966180637,
0.0103440089,
0.0035428542,
-0.0492733978,
-0.0603661835,
-0.0142381219,
-0.0595722869,
-0.0361900106,
-0.0515559763,
0.0052900705,
-0.0267244093,
-0.0063476139,
-0.0467870533,
0.013726471,
0.0110730678,
-0.0306689739,
0.032190375,
0.0320819281,
0.0019267816,
-0.0078409854,
0.053191077,
-0.0055529466,
0.0507719889,
0.0011039295,
0.0354268588,
0.0428208709,
-0.0022338969,
0.0146678677,
0.0324452408,
0.0193226319,
0.045986414,
-0.0207033083,
0.0045271888,
0.013567022,
-0.012575062,
0.0061558373,
0.0779080614,
-0.0120859519,
-0.0114146434,
0.0740821585,
0.0015859433,
-0.0480512865,
-0.0030791445,
0.0596678555,
0.0102279587,
0.0027650397,
0.0339457616,
-0.0903985053,
0.0010046053,
-0.0404019989,
0.0000225009,
-0.0371756405,
0.0378718488,
-0.0236271434,
-0.0372831486,
0.0071245399,
-0.0057871258,
-0.0079446193,
0.0271424707,
0.0248186551,
-0.0013641277,
-0.0502102375,
0.0153407948,
0.0487171598,
-0.0369827151,
-0.0210624263,
-0.0805612132,
0.0115557527,
0.0768996701,
0.0368203707,
-0.0244333893,
-0.0370806716,
-0.0001496018,
0.0330750011,
0.017322557,
0.0273085441,
-0.0171247125,
0.0437613204,
-0.0451718159,
-0.0045542531,
-0.0075342152,
0.0289528947,
0.0466128029,
0.0296646953,
-0.000108603,
-0.0140690785,
0.025750896,
-0.0567448772,
0.0331987403,
-0.0241053253,
-0.0637867525,
-0.0319936499,
-0.001135951,
0.0059395884,
-0.0008898879,
-0.0240487512,
-0.0049765101,
0.037488468,
0.0109054102,
0.01142802,
-0.030353263,
-0.1041317284,
0.0048423503,
0.0349959731,
-0.0003213119,
-0.0109412903,
0.0216226727,
-0.0305564068,
-0.0111897113,
0.0315140001,
-0.0222169701,
0.0451836623,
0.0179762412,
0.0623666011,
-0.023514457,
-0.0351067483,
-0.0389108695,
0.0102199884,
-0.0472563319,
-0.0316643454,
0.0456503443,
0.0001912767,
-0.0036003573,
-0.0042121531,
-0.0443844795,
0.0147860032,
-0.0104237106,
0.037668895,
0.0077001923,
0.0217067525,
-0.0145016564,
-0.0659532398,
-0.0451245867,
-0.0045871753,
-0.0276660994,
0.010832848,
0.0200387724,
0.001704097,
-0.0161658209,
-0.0143902721,
0.0104645165,
-0.0127182147,
-0.008465956,
0.029076606,
-0.0121578276,
0.0386110134,
-0.0497741476,
-0.0225340985,
-0.0131432395,
-0.0083377771,
-0.0004774418,
-0.0139416074,
-0.0078320084,
-0.0811385885,
0.0462466441,
-0.0246105343,
0.046841193,
-0.0253589507,
-0.0427307673,
0.0243773758,
-0.0074339341,
0.0443719141,
0.1013967097,
-0.035431046,
0.0219614152,
0.105915308,
0.0084968647,
-0.0528384149,
0.0122747086,
0.0212213136,
-0.0891044512,
-0.0448766537,
-0.0355406515,
-0.0078488532,
0.068838872,
-0.0140876742,
-0.0128954127,
-0.0475707911,
0.0154527836,
-0.0373748243,
-0.0632787421,
0.0088006901,
-0.0673289895,
-0.0233666413,
0.0344348364,
-0.0334527977,
-0.0809569657,
0.0933872238,
-0.0028301096,
0.0115847113,
-0.0206440352,
-0.013712639,
-0.0207659621,
0.064149864,
-0.0019741708,
0.0361392088,
0.0125538837,
-0.02450292,
-0.0476085097,
-0.0251635555,
0.0337437615,
-0.012556212,
0.0348274745,
-0.0893838182,
-0.0079551116,
0.0099570341,
-0.0463812687,
-0.0435751677,
-0.03299639,
-0.0012941597,
-0.0083203921,
0.0428340808,
-0.0546494499,
-0.0097836554,
-0.0338805728,
0.0492547676,
0.0211122278,
-0.0156190051,
-0.0040491652,
-0.026427947,
-0.0431290045,
0.047543373,
-0.0402523614,
0.0342034437,
-0.0624994785,
0.0725342184,
0.0848805383,
0.0334677137,
-0.0406016633,
0.0005090461,
0.0271549895,
0.0482397676,
-0.0139674842,
-0.0349938832,
0.0592133589,
0.1019395515,
-0.0655118749,
-0.0262386408,
0.0787148923,
0.027532639,
-0.0413847193,
0.0394752994,
-0.0422167629,
0.0363865197,
0.0146714654,
0.0591964833,
-0.0685277507,
-0.0101488102,
0.0294530131,
0.0387181416,
-0.0033638023,
-0.0405388772,
-0.014109307,
-0.096076481,
0.0380010493,
0.0379338264,
-0.0095237326,
-0.0245508496,
-0.0326731466,
-0.0188088398,
0.0024799351,
0.0403513312,
0.008534003,
-0.0370343477,
-0.0366941877,
-0.0018809007,
0.032150697,
-0.0179724284,
0.0447546728,
-0.0401485413,
0.0826758966,
0.0617430136,
-0.0276812501,
0.009698919,
-0.0063559618,
0.0510826074,
0.0086606601,
0.0255909692,
-0.0128298895,
0.0170407016,
0.0034025193,
-0.0034590431,
-0.0042715198,
0.0259038843,
0.0098801767,
-0.0066199019,
0.0436057821,
0.064474903,
-0.0177369863,
-0.0366418846,
-0.0043159416,
-0.0053754975,
0.0107360454,
0.0671791509,
0.0188857559,
-0.049670551,
-0.0315750018,
-0.0507009141,
-0.0466300063,
-0.0312537029,
-0.0229492802,
0.011755622,
-0.0199606046,
-0.0341465697,
-0.0426280536,
-0.0443435945,
0.0066711595,
0.0420393348,
0.0478712954,
-0.0335184522,
0.0245431177,
-0.0061432961,
0.0217006691,
-0.0019105008,
-0.0558490567,
0.0269365292,
-0.0865099132,
0.0047733714,
-0.0040977909,
0.0005642948,
0.0043488238,
0.021317916,
-0.0368372984,
-0.0983137935,
0.0373730958,
0.09348993,
0.0308589898,
0.0466417745,
-0.0162023362,
-0.0446781293,
0.02736637,
0.0214410946,
-0.0447430313,
0.0382244326,
0.0640249923,
-0.0250483118,
0.0191979799,
0.0474496521,
-0.0366309546,
0.0301072951,
0.061369136,
0.0214176197,
-0.0637600794,
-0.02214019,
0.0240846463,
0.0473011769,
-0.0544051677,
-0.0157007016,
0.035870336,
-0.0053576808,
0.0373757072,
-0.0269362126,
-0.0209175628,
-0.0271838363,
0.0357616208,
0.0448640771,
-0.0272269491,
0.021668721,
-0.0033687742,
-0.0029645413,
0.0229027569,
-0.0371449552,
0.0421480425,
-0.0154783837,
0.0632120669,
0.0663124099,
0.0331750661,
-0.0337352492,
0.0491781719,
0.0118390117,
0.0475754663,
0.0075596939,
0.0628290698,
0.0094414977,
0.0014567174,
-0.0423597917,
0.0642781481,
-0.0856519565,
-0.0581573732,
0.0047355904,
0.0392999202,
0.0258801579,
-0.0025735735,
0.0387596078,
-0.0343935825,
0.0018589058,
-0.0341270342,
0.0056591639,
0.0490623377,
-0.0659045205,
0.0073404852,
0.0319318362,
0.0113884117,
0.033078447,
0.0672569573,
0.006743568,
0.0806022733,
0.0331137665,
0.0212628692,
-0.0361663774,
-0.0336002819,
0.0353069268,
0.0244032126,
-0.0533381328,
0.0090577807,
-0.0621639006,
-0.0645260066,
-0.0527795218,
0.0141643574,
0.0030215669,
-0.0399860665,
0.0014972894,
0.0098135024,
0.0197952688,
-0.0287987925,
-0.0367743075,
-0.0174295176,
0.015180937,
-0.0111356769,
-0.021324303,
-6.65863477e-33,
-0.0216640886,
0.0002719521,
0.0088497177,
-0.0173643027,
0.0136495745,
0.0034957333,
-0.0261223223,
0.0049679107,
-0.0513752252,
0.0024026833,
-0.0233923458,
0.0136078661,
0.0080680996,
-0.0090495348,
0.0116866659,
0.0120362947,
0.0385393165,
0.0084740724,
-0.0398281366,
0.0518710576,
0.009345524,
-0.0115440711,
0.0180863906,
-0.0791124701,
0.0395058841,
-0.0038508773,
-0.0297327638,
0.0298328437,
-0.0726496801,
0.053735476,
0.014671701,
0.0242142752,
-0.0075350613,
-0.0435594842,
-0.0316479653,
0.0062130876,
-0.0148278726,
-0.0401420593,
0.0208266396,
-0.0119639607,
-0.0096333567,
-0.0660453141,
0.0264020916,
-0.0104000261,
-0.036501728,
-0.0172222536,
-0.0163008384,
-0.0016233217,
-0.0175819211,
0.0281433724,
-0.0736123472,
0.0121381385,
-0.0064661149,
-0.0557779372,
0.0012814477,
0.0288171172,
-0.0013360486,
-0.0206703357,
-0.0163320154,
0.0472185761,
0.05362349,
0.0121608255,
0.0684987307,
-0.0122015551,
-0.0179047771,
0.0233813729,
0.0101653505,
0.0378746167,
-0.0096064871,
-0.0436537489,
-0.0099976258,
0.0731000826,
0.0211229622,
-0.006850299,
0.0210128203,
-0.0180067439,
-0.0525162518,
-0.0086823078,
0.0128371157,
0.0635567084,
-0.0014448675,
0.004162177,
-0.089013733,
-0.0219529774,
-0.0266812555,
-0.0127639044,
-0.0212890934,
-0.0252048373,
0.041520372,
0.0192106124,
-0.0295814276,
-0.0180808362,
0.0134156542,
-0.0351144932,
-0.0017245391,
0.0017201048,
-0.0060674427,
0.007651113,
-0.0047499896,
0.0404224657,
-0.0681671128,
-0.0275121108,
0.0031301938,
-0.0445412211,
0.0188343991,
0.0259683747,
0.0349228717,
0.044591628,
-0.0648981556,
-0.0014881031,
-0.042564448,
0.0449795164,
0.0458441786,
-0.0068775578,
0.036666505,
-0.0162761491,
0.011161916,
0.0530893207,
0.0307914671,
-0.0268850923,
-0.0256179553,
0.0189998616,
-0.0020416894,
0.029366564,
-0.0264166072,
-0.0082830871,
-0.0280951392,
0.0218970235,
0.0000580792,
-0.0610047989,
-0.024021348,
0.0011083155,
3.183e-7,
-0.0124137085,
0.0418499187,
0.0315594599,
0.0193369314,
-0.003527205,
0.0267417561,
-0.0180411693,
0.0314654894,
-0.0174349695,
-0.0004442244,
0.0008549556,
0.0503385626,
0.0197536908,
0.0241017584,
-0.0476080738,
0.0036053809,
-0.0318635665,
0.0068575917,
-0.0653229058,
-0.0039435551,
0.021822108,
0.0803010166,
-0.0080528306,
-0.010249258,
0.0082676932,
-0.0552363396,
0.0143356528,
-0.009769612,
0.0182573125,
0.0331879295,
0.0048497221,
0.0288193952,
-0.0039091096,
0.0331198387,
-0.0115702692,
-0.0081212828,
-0.0625027567,
0.1189561039,
-0.0205188692,
0.0167828053,
0.0064379717,
-0.0116657801,
-0.0181772094,
-0.0493460596,
0.0513439178,
-0.0125805046,
-0.0238245353,
-0.0239443164,
0.0058016288,
-0.0283058863,
-0.016191544,
-0.0197462495,
-0.0073435898,
0.016040286,
0.0138686216,
-0.0076206303,
-0.0014975485,
-0.0324884132,
-0.0128947124,
0.0001695885,
0.00856556,
-0.1012639701,
-0.0385319144,
0.0312852263,
0.001038178,
-0.0708132014,
0.0088709341,
3.177273068e-34,
0.0264208019,
-0.0634398237,
0.0496024005,
0.0066526956,
0.0375105441,
0.0084589012,
-0.032251481,
0.0244730636,
0.0434265509,
-0.0496872626,
-0.0356092937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03300v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03300v3 | DeepSeekMath: Pushing the Limits of Mathematical Reasoning in Open Language Models | 2024-02-05T18:55:32 | 2024-04-27T15:25:53 | Zhihong Shao, Peiyi Wang, Qihao Zhu, Runxin Xu, Junxiao Song, Xiao Bi, Haowei Zhang, Mingchuan Zhang, Y. K. Li, Y. Wu, Daya Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Mathematical reasoning poses a significant challenge for language models due
to its complex and structured nature. In this paper, we introduce DeepSeekMath
7B, which continues pre-training DeepSeek-Coder-Base-v1.5 7B with 120B
math-related tokens sourced from Common Crawl, together with natural language
and code data. DeepSeekMath 7B has achieved an impressive score of 51.7% on the
competition-level MATH benchmark without relying on external toolkits and
voting techniques, approaching the performance level of Gemini-Ultra and GPT-4.
Self-consistency over 64 samples from DeepSeekMath 7B achieves 60.9% on MATH.
The mathematical reasoning capability of DeepSeekMath is attributed to two key
factors: First, we harness the significant potential of publicly available web
data through a meticulously engineered data selection pipeline. Second, we
introduce Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO), a variant of Proximal
Policy Optimization (PPO), that enhances mathematical reasoning abilities while
concurrently optimizing the memory usage of PPO. | [
-0.0112817297,
0.1450212598,
0.013947445,
0.0479209162,
-0.0347568057,
0.0210600328,
-0.0002952548,
-0.0003129126,
-0.0301508084,
-0.0127182556,
-0.0162905473,
-0.0265469998,
-0.0342066027,
0.0704294592,
0.0314954072,
-0.0463217013,
0.0129406145,
-0.0449058115,
0.0423012041,
-0.0399690084,
-0.0075168875,
-0.0154081294,
-0.0211295523,
0.0256604832,
-0.0139696766,
-0.0454102978,
0.0187325887,
-0.0501109213,
0.0171990842,
-0.0393082909,
-0.0061337557,
0.014310929,
0.0316176787,
0.0282484721,
0.0000023451,
-0.0524574257,
-0.0335023515,
0.0213837773,
-0.0249922089,
-0.0189444404,
-0.0311839096,
-0.0103282537,
0.0153688071,
0.0249541644,
-0.0690924078,
0.011957177,
0.048826769,
0.0131789967,
0.0878928974,
0.0744581744,
0.0047712545,
-0.0692659691,
0.0231548939,
-0.0165018681,
0.0391175076,
-0.0692753792,
0.0073760399,
-0.0054681185,
0.0123382295,
-0.0043315757,
-0.0361162648,
0.0099484306,
0.0724261701,
-0.0179594755,
-0.0315756798,
0.0291038435,
-0.0370565243,
-0.0192436483,
0.0038314089,
0.0831399933,
0.0024911789,
-0.0288847759,
0.0234544184,
-0.0138008688,
-0.033164762,
-0.016474722,
-0.0534816235,
0.0470994972,
0.0051279184,
0.0197216533,
-0.0010523763,
-0.0008259045,
0.0430728309,
0.0432272926,
-0.0603965595,
0.1091536134,
0.0050234608,
-0.0288811233,
0.0089895222,
-0.0262454636,
-0.0707630217,
-0.0405978225,
0.0278372988,
0.0484829955,
-0.0103202034,
0.0158530083,
-0.0277744327,
-0.0250452179,
-0.0329506993,
0.0136059476,
0.0500154682,
0.0843872949,
-0.0150221782,
0.0377352647,
0.0087367836,
0.0805960968,
-0.0263010841,
0.0358304866,
0.0195707902,
0.0229286868,
-0.0347529389,
-0.0047563752,
-0.0083118724,
0.063649945,
-0.0168692544,
-0.005891575,
0.0051514483,
0.010588211,
-0.0616740733,
0.027115494,
0.0181894805,
0.0049434495,
-0.0121549331,
-0.0264981538,
-0.0358660333,
0.0014959034,
-0.0615882538,
-0.0070456713,
-0.0105669433,
-0.0431177244,
-0.0359919183,
0.0283975583,
-0.021796992,
-0.0241220612,
0.0176827945,
0.0858411044,
0.0272399746,
0.0137529727,
0.0035945456,
-0.0332240388,
0.0127137769,
-0.0769171417,
0.004599032,
-0.0921538696,
0.038136106,
-0.0006628881,
-0.0243285596,
-0.0633255169,
-0.0049275858,
0.0236398727,
0.0085744252,
0.0693782046,
-0.004998921,
-0.0291708391,
-0.0106727658,
-0.0073342719,
-0.008997554,
0.0435814299,
0.031126501,
-0.0227440726,
0.023698844,
0.0227832384,
-0.020426983,
0.0131561887,
0.036991559,
-0.0134294415,
0.018364476,
0.0435231775,
0.005370745,
0.0505783185,
0.0217273682,
0.041401092,
-0.0461463258,
-0.0437660776,
0.0026959346,
0.0732336268,
-0.0280715059,
0.0151314847,
0.0260754805,
0.0183547419,
0.0500295199,
-0.0301394034,
-0.0851227567,
0.0393743217,
0.0059246165,
0.0106819635,
0.008787835,
0.0174515415,
-0.0077222674,
-0.0557821169,
-0.0082296384,
-0.0048474097,
-0.0354378559,
0.0152171673,
0.078791067,
-0.0146575654,
-0.0195529964,
0.0563910492,
0.0212263316,
-0.0025120499,
-0.0089164814,
-0.0260084979,
0.0239333156,
-0.022461595,
0.0405211933,
-0.0665085614,
-0.0315296538,
-0.023859635,
0.0098280581,
0.0134758977,
0.0493022464,
-0.0126136784,
-0.0127595915,
-0.0418548696,
-0.0286881197,
-0.0168461911,
-0.002751044,
-0.0022102452,
0.0442257784,
0.0070225052,
0.0301002618,
0.0042529176,
0.0156455617,
0.0297333635,
-0.0272698496,
-0.0305706561,
-0.0053975293,
-0.0190233644,
0.0293033943,
0.0028813444,
-0.0040470413,
0.0345903561,
0.0142409531,
-0.0206938069,
0.0030985293,
-0.0443569385,
-0.041344624,
-0.0213537049,
0.0862044543,
-0.0539506413,
-0.0258883443,
0.0447227918,
-0.060713388,
-0.0241503567,
0.0697915256,
-0.024951892,
0.0182932317,
-0.0392244644,
-0.0039445334,
-0.0074634668,
-0.0183523875,
-0.0000282404,
0.0533435047,
-0.0022599779,
0.0013918427,
0.0438996442,
0.0092636505,
0.0188892391,
-0.0336330533,
0.0244021434,
0.0087914681,
-0.0435324982,
0.0239673629,
0.0163759086,
0.0304827113,
-0.0372929573,
-0.0184994191,
0.0051495712,
0.019924609,
-0.0262990166,
0.0593328848,
0.008819133,
-0.0303366818,
-0.0011755442,
-0.0191731565,
0.0016865389,
-0.0087945107,
-0.0194025394,
-0.017740801,
0.0308448691,
-0.0087166103,
0.0063009895,
-0.0212825742,
-0.0370285958,
-0.0405228883,
0.0048118695,
-0.0011290777,
0.0786732286,
0.0285049304,
0.0048181987,
-0.069024615,
-0.009980822,
-0.0139640402,
0.0066660242,
0.0327239521,
-0.0467641912,
-0.0026329821,
0.0515940636,
-0.0317713805,
0.0416476168,
0.0162185859,
-0.0048984368,
-0.0604849383,
0.0153071973,
-0.0211882424,
-0.0088190362,
-0.0253617987,
0.0463858247,
-0.0154323485,
0.0711379275,
-0.0271063298,
-0.0156688113,
-0.0450331829,
0.0557188094,
-0.0275566801,
-0.0075697419,
-0.031188786,
0.0440575778,
-0.0237727202,
0.0125723146,
-0.0151221938,
-0.0539242662,
0.0789327621,
0.0178226288,
-0.0059555825,
-0.0742806867,
0.0204674285,
-0.0395932086,
0.041109439,
0.01435709,
-0.0188493431,
-0.0405736491,
-0.0045458288,
-0.0268575884,
0.0054326369,
0.0348459706,
-0.0245342311,
0.0429249033,
-0.030022338,
0.0309737287,
0.0085089132,
-0.064060308,
-0.0247051697,
-0.0256888755,
-0.0354346447,
0.04544596,
-0.0083699832,
-0.0756186023,
0.0015447491,
-0.0377468169,
0.0104923956,
0.0305930041,
-0.0315317251,
-0.0230114162,
-0.0268318802,
-0.0296191815,
0.0284116548,
0.0138744321,
0.0410001986,
-0.0425524041,
-0.0145208118,
0.03249548,
0.0774928629,
-0.0354698896,
-0.0213292297,
0.0474065728,
-0.0096815219,
-0.0377208553,
-0.0265283529,
0.0348660871,
-0.0062899487,
-0.0917949826,
-0.0022640219,
0.0978065655,
0.0301065166,
-0.0133865969,
0.0019590489,
-0.0450340211,
0.0380319022,
0.045141425,
0.0163692106,
-0.0599068217,
-0.0295391195,
0.0312222112,
0.0400258489,
0.0194597431,
-0.0471862704,
-0.0080781495,
-0.1011813655,
-0.0002135197,
-0.0125525957,
-0.0192097463,
0.0042076926,
-0.0547232106,
0.0099354228,
-0.0386692174,
-0.0219548959,
0.0327880681,
-0.0116330562,
0.0305717476,
-0.0042144181,
-0.0284124371,
-0.0242773425,
0.0344393849,
-0.0252488982,
-0.0312703326,
0.0206297338,
0.026575515,
-0.0193640031,
-0.0632469952,
0.0340398848,
0.012239527,
-0.0586691909,
-0.033453092,
0.0230594557,
-0.0041869543,
-0.0284838583,
-0.0094817411,
0.0807414502,
-0.0758774504,
-0.0189029202,
-0.0084352046,
0.1146120355,
-0.0292604342,
-0.022193566,
-0.0113516143,
-0.02413816,
-0.0361953378,
0.0481233783,
-0.0152171496,
0.0156473629,
-0.0688640624,
-0.0486336164,
-0.0286520459,
-0.0419258885,
-0.0157503337,
-0.0354039557,
0.0638512,
-0.0087831328,
-0.0253905114,
-0.0112164132,
0.0253073219,
0.0681813806,
-0.0236661974,
-0.0500430539,
0.0370786674,
-0.0140939178,
-0.0489435084,
0.0290947575,
-0.0387575999,
0.0275591649,
-0.0192613192,
0.0219447259,
-0.0093209082,
0.0058293166,
-0.0639470741,
0.0150882713,
-0.0903142095,
-0.0479891859,
-0.0175591018,
0.0465363301,
0.0238213744,
0.0148628401,
-0.0210323669,
-0.017198978,
0.0257180016,
0.0144940764,
-0.0584121533,
0.0004506129,
0.0556274131,
-0.0371367745,
0.0240988042,
0.0373658873,
-0.0194051266,
-0.0236217286,
0.0096930834,
0.0418481492,
0.0178439226,
0.0239359625,
0.0197045244,
0.028124731,
0.0003656507,
0.0334043279,
0.0053766393,
-0.0248660278,
0.0076243025,
0.0055128904,
0.0160407908,
-0.0323648937,
0.0348924249,
0.0133617921,
-0.0268623922,
0.0058467211,
0.0257658269,
0.0610954762,
0.0020884802,
0.0366172679,
0.0540884137,
0.0419263244,
0.0516095608,
0.041813463,
-0.0436613411,
0.0202013496,
-0.0026525815,
-0.0262134448,
0.0397324339,
-0.0292995907,
0.0154805286,
0.0538537242,
0.0259086099,
0.003546817,
-0.0336130224,
-0.0580063947,
-0.1110150516,
-0.0010639512,
-0.0021054333,
0.0228722133,
0.0135683054,
-0.003738709,
-0.0543096587,
-0.0096393824,
-0.0067140036,
0.0147827705,
0.0117633371,
-0.0093939221,
0.0317268893,
0.0192195531,
-0.0045854948,
-0.0203647837,
0.0729612559,
-0.0010492125,
0.0498140678,
-0.000043442,
0.0411086828,
-0.033276245,
-0.0339640416,
-0.0008673366,
0.0440669283,
0.0084236618,
-0.0135810375,
-0.0318901241,
-0.0811292455,
-0.0066189705,
0.0271745306,
-0.0309825782,
0.0242963843,
0.0534760058,
0.0602058806,
-0.0335715078,
-0.0201847572,
0.0255849548,
0.0285993386,
0.0012129308,
-0.0337688886,
-0.0129492264,
-6.482059355e-33,
0.0165970717,
-0.0298205167,
0.0322752409,
0.01848449,
-0.0358326547,
-0.0227759145,
-0.0440372899,
-0.0264697503,
-0.0201337878,
0.0195389409,
-0.0003736119,
0.0653098896,
0.0093092769,
0.0394690819,
0.027021192,
-0.0350768156,
0.0294270664,
-0.0208686106,
-0.032698527,
0.0099504013,
0.014892689,
0.0260747932,
0.0562632941,
-0.0435847677,
0.0355796218,
0.0252218693,
-0.0093860188,
0.0262520108,
-0.0097130304,
0.0897398815,
-0.0078275101,
0.0134504605,
0.0015883127,
-0.0278832577,
-0.0509932525,
-0.0158095621,
-0.0710126832,
-0.0810384452,
-0.0187460594,
0.00201341,
-0.0529452376,
-0.0327938199,
0.0280518048,
0.0187405609,
-0.027231399,
-0.0530036204,
0.0217303801,
0.0015217925,
0.0149142323,
0.0097713275,
-0.0310036801,
0.0421583615,
-0.034694843,
0.0328034721,
0.0554805882,
-0.0135401217,
-0.0144266738,
-0.0003751564,
-0.0055049835,
0.0117368083,
-0.0359613523,
0.0301030688,
0.0734547079,
-0.0102649666,
0.0334596746,
0.0382347889,
0.0031713508,
-0.0614226311,
-0.0193675123,
-0.0175067075,
0.0682713911,
0.0519302674,
0.0425659977,
0.0068274899,
0.0587240718,
0.0221228991,
-0.0584738068,
-0.0129517019,
-0.0162481703,
0.0491742902,
-0.0114497198,
0.013910668,
-0.0297424868,
-0.0015086783,
-0.0420830362,
-0.0165384132,
-0.0422002152,
-0.024155613,
0.0210692752,
-0.0006647041,
-0.0133411838,
0.0377283059,
0.0064528394,
-0.0729007944,
-0.0107676992,
0.0475536771,
0.0112986788,
-0.000222248,
0.0083739292,
0.0390948392,
-0.08158952,
-0.0191858131,
-0.048870042,
-0.003583312,
0.0337136947,
0.0163349565,
0.0036597312,
0.0428304076,
-0.0332691334,
-0.0290749818,
-0.0351087488,
-0.0057550385,
0.0485028215,
0.0556824245,
0.0404816121,
0.0373933949,
0.0224524811,
0.0577052608,
0.0052936394,
-0.0011886983,
-0.0221082717,
0.0442605093,
0.0102519402,
0.0247794334,
-0.0073132771,
-0.0223005712,
-0.0462374277,
0.0223128404,
-0.0091190692,
-0.0834167898,
-0.0084846364,
0.0336270146,
2.91e-7,
0.0559842698,
0.0466218479,
0.0369938649,
0.0270295925,
0.0012479513,
0.0205638204,
-0.0237338115,
-0.0001956048,
-0.0278236978,
-0.0465307347,
0.0073752794,
0.047422003,
0.0323572643,
0.029205475,
-0.0744796023,
0.0660965219,
-0.0527071692,
-0.0269823801,
-0.0562106371,
0.010784246,
0.0623627082,
0.106311515,
0.0448968932,
-0.0132866707,
0.0197496843,
-0.0355424993,
0.0392200835,
0.0312444065,
0.0179892108,
0.0026379202,
-0.0091666589,
0.0059795207,
0.0171163082,
-0.0125132473,
-0.0213831123,
0.034194503,
-0.0082448851,
0.0763461888,
0.0286166687,
0.0089131482,
-0.030455878,
-0.0576313399,
0.0035552406,
-0.0564782433,
0.0846443176,
-0.0170236994,
-0.0274746083,
0.0023670332,
0.0053351452,
-0.0395285189,
0.0213051066,
-0.0144169377,
0.0251080859,
0.0240933355,
0.0099780876,
-0.0167679098,
0.0010920438,
-0.0550375693,
-0.0321312584,
-0.0190766882,
-0.0439693928,
-0.0420952812,
-0.0526090525,
0.0251419321,
0.0456414707,
0.0054354952,
-0.0206299499,
3.148786616e-34,
0.0558432266,
-0.0322349295,
0.0012448702,
-0.0042541167,
0.0252293348,
-0.0004789197,
-0.0183228664,
0.0224628039,
0.0218001269,
-0.0695086345,
-0.0302253682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03299v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03299v4 | GUARD: Role-playing to Generate Natural-language Jailbreakings to Test Guideline Adherence of Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T18:54:43 | 2024-05-30T21:14:26 | Haibo Jin, Ruoxi Chen, Andy Zhou, Yang Zhang, Haohan Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | The discovery of "jailbreaks" to bypass safety filters of Large Language
Models (LLMs) and harmful responses have encouraged the community to implement
safety measures. One major safety measure is to proactively test the LLMs with
jailbreaks prior to the release. Therefore, such testing will require a method
that can generate jailbreaks massively and efficiently. In this paper, we
follow a novel yet intuitive strategy to generate jailbreaks in the style of
the human generation. We propose a role-playing system that assigns four
different roles to the user LLMs to collaborate on new jailbreaks. Furthermore,
we collect existing jailbreaks and split them into different independent
characteristics using clustering frequency and semantic patterns sentence by
sentence. We organize these characteristics into a knowledge graph, making them
more accessible and easier to retrieve. Our system of different roles will
leverage this knowledge graph to generate new jailbreaks, which have proved
effective in inducing LLMs to generate unethical or guideline-violating
responses. In addition, we also pioneer a setting in our system that will
automatically follow the government-issued guidelines to generate jailbreaks to
test whether LLMs follow the guidelines accordingly. We refer to our system as
GUARD (Guideline Upholding through Adaptive Role-play Diagnostics). We have
empirically validated the effectiveness of GUARD on three cutting-edge
open-sourced LLMs (Vicuna-13B, LongChat-7B, and Llama-2-7B), as well as a
widely-utilized commercial LLM (ChatGPT). Moreover, our work extends to the
realm of vision language models (MiniGPT-v2 and Gemini Vision Pro), showcasing
GUARD's versatility and contributing valuable insights for the development of
safer, more reliable LLM-based applications across diverse modalities. | [
0.0753969252,
0.0826735273,
-0.0454286002,
0.0419142395,
-0.0492454283,
-0.0422591604,
-0.0205411445,
0.004139577,
0.0852272362,
-0.0281978659,
0.0186171569,
-0.0052500106,
-0.0160235967,
0.0655099154,
-0.0015362559,
-0.0334914066,
0.0328164548,
-0.0499595553,
0.0362984054,
0.0281555932,
0.0285736416,
0.0296664387,
0.0137822693,
0.0575022809,
-0.0115515329,
-0.0074830912,
0.011571113,
-0.0022300773,
0.0254613776,
-0.0441719294,
0.0034809748,
0.0475297756,
-0.0083872778,
0.0503257625,
0.0000022872,
-0.0531869642,
-0.0195272062,
0.0097135818,
0.0201705936,
-0.0206450578,
0.0351518132,
-0.0419695415,
-0.0347729288,
0.0191103891,
-0.0655130073,
-0.0033821515,
0.0686875656,
-0.0060158013,
0.1051087603,
0.0568328537,
-0.0096888365,
0.00931386,
0.0181600079,
0.0081140948,
0.0246179365,
-0.0312063545,
0.0062462511,
0.0247741286,
0.0526706092,
0.0143288504,
0.0130426502,
0.0143284826,
0.0345678441,
-0.0418146141,
-0.0267269593,
-0.0095076282,
-0.0565319099,
-0.05903209,
0.0086807143,
0.0556710027,
-0.0235362146,
-0.0422036909,
0.0276244562,
0.0183787011,
0.0158857964,
0.0667068288,
-0.0100212069,
0.0579148196,
-0.0180424266,
-0.0110313315,
0.0126616415,
0.0130121494,
0.0481885448,
-0.0111919884,
0.0236329976,
0.0565240346,
-0.0104190102,
-0.0234848969,
-0.0375100411,
-0.036081221,
-0.0132256411,
-0.0507096946,
0.0042262259,
-0.0097080804,
-0.03133028,
0.0333140418,
-0.0661484823,
0.0162192918,
0.0713111684,
-0.0603711456,
-0.0227125008,
0.0146099059,
-0.0052918578,
0.0439623967,
0.0088734915,
-0.0177091993,
0.0198135469,
0.0263583418,
-0.0150970053,
0.0169425271,
-0.0230945665,
-0.0391340852,
-0.0379470736,
0.0156623907,
-0.0242106747,
0.0091748014,
-0.0086251292,
0.0403972082,
-0.0441632196,
0.0372028016,
-0.0071569835,
0.0204193462,
0.0018451671,
0.01017759,
0.0121743605,
-0.048442889,
-0.0238777865,
-0.0093131028,
0.0013560484,
-0.0520952605,
0.0130292885,
-0.027530523,
-0.0513041653,
0.0277606137,
-0.0090775182,
0.1165216193,
0.0367312208,
0.0041564223,
-0.0557879768,
-0.0947902873,
-0.0335923955,
-0.0289134402,
-0.0247957408,
-0.097424008,
-0.0108210342,
-0.0156149715,
0.0026962857,
-0.057559967,
0.0210810453,
0.0195695702,
-0.0327501483,
0.0779915527,
-0.0356143825,
-0.0055413712,
-0.0145945307,
0.0710814372,
0.0351019129,
0.0830016881,
0.0154969571,
0.0171842687,
0.0608459637,
-0.0019754213,
0.0449742004,
0.0464721546,
-0.0332341082,
0.0372413807,
-0.0151615888,
-0.0243721306,
0.0260366555,
0.0127437441,
-0.0457690321,
0.0354735181,
-0.0195582174,
-0.0135794412,
0.0528831556,
0.0697168708,
-0.0277201422,
0.0191312432,
0.0198196489,
-0.0050154892,
-0.0110281231,
-0.0214767009,
-0.0210877247,
0.0026813936,
-0.050178498,
-0.0333307944,
-0.0752039552,
0.026672719,
0.0080242259,
-0.0136606907,
0.0072360849,
-0.0080226371,
0.0333048329,
-0.003487227,
-0.0106623014,
0.0236498527,
-0.0062289988,
0.0359910429,
0.0297603644,
-0.062168397,
-0.0144218961,
-0.058088921,
0.0214579273,
0.1044042632,
0.0778542683,
-0.0131999068,
-0.03036258,
0.0007473016,
-0.0037944724,
0.0150313312,
-0.0139493207,
-0.0064951102,
-0.0093300547,
-0.0123802694,
-0.008680678,
0.0062415744,
0.0313381106,
0.0161156114,
-0.0020544904,
0.0016632653,
-0.0031795811,
-0.0300596245,
-0.0538652427,
0.0168753881,
0.0202798583,
0.0101101249,
-0.0315962732,
0.0117106261,
0.0101650748,
-0.0065086405,
-0.0118876742,
0.0090260701,
0.0661880672,
-0.0283214245,
0.0198227521,
0.0221060347,
-0.0474783257,
-0.0121019464,
0.0486746803,
-0.0771286786,
0.0016063965,
0.0621585846,
-0.0208122116,
-0.0016440561,
0.0520273484,
-0.0253392365,
0.0302058756,
-0.0047085816,
0.012007311,
-0.0006388794,
-0.0310060624,
-0.0273729954,
-0.0003633091,
-0.0148128867,
-0.0078737233,
-0.0181216933,
-0.0130460449,
0.0162282474,
0.0083269784,
-0.0246999077,
0.0432877764,
-0.040879216,
0.0399728902,
0.0480610467,
0.0426940694,
-0.0268114172,
-0.0520113595,
-0.0605255999,
-0.0189225618,
-0.0220891032,
0.0168893542,
0.0373451822,
0.0358178839,
-0.0303735882,
-0.0281172432,
-0.0198260099,
-0.0263711531,
0.029539194,
0.0042716307,
-0.0009306922,
-0.0057877335,
-0.0616076551,
0.0047386461,
-0.0144864023,
-0.0204018075,
0.0412205793,
0.0012861051,
-0.006141915,
-0.031934239,
-0.0172613468,
-0.0194381122,
0.0083385743,
-0.0102587584,
-0.0502980873,
0.0421313867,
0.0037843839,
-0.0045283828,
0.0257383902,
0.0066399863,
0.040099062,
0.0539955534,
-0.0229218677,
-0.0341296494,
-0.0232623275,
0.0617087781,
-0.0468198545,
-0.0209236965,
-0.0669744983,
0.0501322858,
0.031686049,
-0.0043677967,
-0.0035374532,
-0.0552253798,
0.0576719828,
-0.0387469046,
-0.033582747,
0.0041304389,
-0.0537296534,
-0.0322825126,
-0.0110938996,
-0.0153311118,
-0.0437224843,
0.0716200098,
-0.0242033359,
0.011948145,
-0.0267724916,
-0.028521454,
-0.0406613313,
0.1012653187,
0.024930317,
0.0434663668,
0.0654214844,
-0.0148075102,
-0.0140502546,
-0.032907445,
0.0571989641,
-0.0261910744,
0.0307054203,
-0.0972361043,
-0.0046570469,
-0.0026091426,
-0.0363568328,
-0.0348047204,
-0.0579015464,
-0.0225102529,
-0.0112785082,
0.0790756196,
-0.0147574758,
0.0029106175,
0.0040900088,
0.0029982547,
0.0238138493,
0.043068137,
-0.0243078377,
-0.0120317359,
0.0003063827,
0.0305065997,
-0.0516769476,
-0.028764803,
0.0101771606,
0.0180295873,
0.1000541002,
0.0139386849,
-0.0074239583,
-0.0170347616,
0.0432442576,
0.0287764817,
-0.0038143708,
-0.0145200519,
0.0414917804,
0.0286453832,
-0.0665381625,
-0.0001098432,
0.0459629148,
0.0475677662,
-0.0263066813,
0.0349664316,
0.0051964372,
0.0389441513,
0.0307684503,
0.0352782048,
-0.0912939012,
-0.0194238238,
-0.0169355217,
0.0438692272,
-0.046138674,
-0.0475491546,
-0.03050391,
-0.0850218311,
0.0428306386,
0.0372121222,
-0.0313199647,
0.048224207,
-0.0274402611,
-0.0339701399,
-0.009338174,
-0.0173164587,
-0.0112587651,
-0.0251154453,
-0.0088972133,
-0.0070934137,
-0.0803764537,
0.0022123244,
0.0273856372,
-0.0443272702,
0.0886422843,
0.0913246945,
0.0041654534,
-0.0132709881,
0.0037066673,
0.0073660426,
0.0142247947,
0.0027747545,
-0.0114477202,
0.0020587074,
0.0072965473,
-0.0167274624,
-0.0110366158,
0.0404480956,
-0.0184026379,
-0.0663173273,
0.0155588659,
0.0725814402,
0.0069445274,
-0.0495566316,
-0.0349437781,
-0.0009199799,
0.0247036517,
0.0348739773,
0.0067557329,
-0.0160498749,
-0.0247334484,
-0.0511847921,
-0.0263135247,
-0.0563080274,
-0.0672566593,
-0.0360926054,
0.0287703034,
-0.0024077573,
-0.0665581897,
0.0032225568,
0.0106322896,
0.034130048,
0.0264434051,
-0.0121649895,
0.0153192598,
0.0052186418,
-0.0005968923,
-0.0053310725,
-0.0237677433,
0.0245384052,
-0.0358966738,
0.0098465839,
-0.0288795363,
0.0082979295,
0.0099860458,
0.0515766256,
-0.0140948799,
-0.0725531504,
0.0366966948,
0.0707326829,
0.0296078697,
-0.0168491229,
-0.0433001071,
-0.0508408844,
0.0314479545,
0.1141864955,
-0.0847722217,
0.0030453352,
0.0395939164,
-0.0254887342,
0.0107468469,
0.0223955419,
-0.0378604829,
-0.0339238271,
0.0038149857,
0.0302828904,
-0.0652465895,
-0.0001411866,
0.0446488298,
0.0387544818,
-0.0264690928,
-0.0280809328,
0.0472736992,
0.0142332586,
-0.0011438066,
-0.0160937719,
-0.0495455563,
-0.0049676555,
0.0474536642,
0.0108284801,
-0.0660964027,
0.0214477368,
0.0435896292,
-0.0374114215,
0.0078503257,
-0.0108868247,
0.0193766411,
0.0537549593,
0.00941863,
0.0564162508,
-0.0010575936,
-0.0077758683,
0.029270051,
-0.0397551619,
0.044210799,
-0.0078812167,
0.0267470852,
-0.0025617033,
-0.0305190422,
-0.0112469811,
0.0702310652,
-0.043372225,
-0.0589836873,
0.0082999496,
0.0734131411,
0.0204172824,
0.0212873351,
0.0167541374,
-0.0618015751,
0.0109757176,
-0.0247492604,
-0.0107271979,
-0.0054885484,
-0.0747336149,
0.010826109,
0.0218251105,
-0.0346255377,
-0.0257487278,
0.0872766748,
0.0299680326,
0.0385131761,
0.0218940843,
-0.0110852243,
-0.0516253263,
-0.0180325005,
0.0651932433,
0.0213660561,
-0.0568025783,
-0.0304623321,
-0.0977241695,
-0.0449737534,
-0.038063366,
0.0263336953,
0.0279916376,
0.0070830151,
-0.0106817456,
0.0378654748,
0.0408799909,
0.0013792153,
-0.0442258418,
-0.0147117497,
-0.0362490453,
-0.0075153685,
0.0121029569,
-6.425130899e-33,
0.0114136776,
-0.0596266165,
-0.0147982882,
-0.0196101293,
-0.0005127905,
-0.0187640563,
-0.0291201621,
0.0272057839,
0.036579404,
0.0025449398,
0.007195815,
-0.0145814195,
0.003541267,
-0.0228483137,
0.0084847109,
-0.0154486187,
0.0277381539,
0.0455219895,
-0.029972693,
0.0315762796,
0.0313488655,
0.0000953116,
-0.0033112473,
-0.0539233349,
0.046742972,
-0.0056589046,
-0.037072286,
0.0456703566,
-0.0430559665,
0.0685006604,
0.0284588803,
0.0479067937,
0.0001817543,
-0.0195387434,
-0.0226227734,
0.0364691131,
-0.004655357,
-0.0163645726,
0.0474614501,
-0.0087257819,
-0.0319348909,
-0.0448501185,
0.0461744778,
-0.0055753617,
0.0103367576,
0.0222326517,
0.0109247463,
-0.0238653962,
-0.019589968,
0.002831894,
-0.0383271761,
0.0016944727,
-0.0406979993,
-0.0192260146,
-0.032695327,
0.002327956,
0.0062822425,
-0.0393026769,
-0.0278362148,
0.0419565886,
0.0150487348,
-0.0006129434,
0.0565004274,
-0.0045802025,
-0.005170559,
0.0776278749,
-0.0670646876,
0.0054709101,
-0.0090232641,
-0.0303519871,
0.0117006376,
0.1149159893,
0.0455564968,
0.0728961453,
0.0280165877,
-0.01878177,
-0.0515408441,
0.0140115712,
-0.017417429,
0.0533340909,
0.0255459603,
0.0090916995,
-0.0578381903,
-0.0355651565,
-0.0211689491,
0.0022753098,
-0.0096335514,
-0.0495194755,
0.0100481827,
-0.0003019618,
-0.052137807,
-0.017503988,
-0.0076660682,
-0.0764347836,
0.0158008579,
0.0115760537,
-0.0277458448,
-0.0156496316,
-0.0191253107,
0.0341411829,
-0.0369643643,
0.0143989045,
0.0218736101,
-0.0296265911,
0.0406525582,
0.0167660303,
0.0136242574,
0.0386654399,
-0.0584065057,
0.004555387,
-0.017960947,
0.0461122952,
-0.0025847417,
-0.0272655804,
0.0205940641,
-0.0197264273,
-0.0011210107,
-0.0224588513,
0.0460619703,
-0.0237273257,
-0.0506421365,
0.0510723777,
-0.0388073139,
0.0048242076,
-0.0020854587,
-0.0068577006,
-0.0451059453,
0.0290269591,
0.064999029,
-0.0445659272,
-0.0275169481,
-0.0041745692,
3.047e-7,
-0.0163154639,
0.004565645,
-0.0052094087,
0.0124154091,
0.0133486185,
0.0620699972,
-0.0042998493,
0.0550791249,
-0.0000193529,
-0.0387100242,
-0.0260925796,
0.0031831556,
0.0347899161,
0.0775996521,
-0.0748557076,
0.0296783764,
-0.0424283482,
-0.0129238553,
-0.0612732843,
-0.0019199221,
0.0452816933,
0.0267438982,
0.0182227269,
-0.0239103138,
0.0199807454,
-0.0791588351,
0.0057497821,
-0.0259084422,
-0.0205026474,
0.020808937,
0.0504430048,
0.0272752866,
0.0086574014,
0.019192392,
-0.011581202,
-0.0409787185,
-0.0579509959,
0.022508163,
0.0024540143,
0.0320585109,
-0.0241443645,
-0.0645212531,
-0.0090872785,
-0.053438168,
0.0594484694,
-0.004713282,
-0.0098516438,
-0.0054430878,
0.0217876099,
-0.0462420098,
-0.0185608324,
-0.0256941207,
-0.0182648636,
0.0084213689,
0.0171488672,
-0.000025677,
-0.0038411713,
-0.0390558988,
-0.0202521197,
0.0181586612,
0.0068140286,
-0.0538966022,
-0.005961007,
0.0321956947,
-0.0006443869,
-0.0475325324,
0.0387872867,
2.963755999e-34,
0.0006128825,
0.0023749573,
0.0058250399,
-0.0201414209,
0.048641637,
0.0134703135,
0.010207179,
0.0337402746,
0.0074292328,
-0.0145193767,
-0.006908942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03284v1 | Deal, or no deal (or who knows)? Forecasting Uncertainty in Conversations using Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T18:39:47 | 2024-02-05T18:39:47 | Anthony Sicilia, Hyunwoo Kim, Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, Malihe Alikhani, Jack Hessel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Effective interlocutors account for the uncertain goals, beliefs, and
emotions of others. But even the best human conversationalist cannot perfectly
anticipate the trajectory of a dialogue. How well can language models represent
inherent uncertainty in conversations? We propose FortUne Dial, an expansion of
the long-standing "conversation forecasting" task: instead of just accuracy,
evaluation is conducted with uncertainty-aware metrics, effectively enabling
abstention on individual instances. We study two ways in which language models
potentially represent outcome uncertainty (internally, using scores and
directly, using tokens) and propose fine-tuning strategies to improve
calibration of both representations. Experiments on eight difficult negotiation
corpora demonstrate that our proposed fine-tuning strategies (a traditional
supervision strategy and an off-policy reinforcement learning strategy) can
calibrate smaller open-source models to compete with pre-trained models 10x
their size. | [
0.0720775053,
0.1306843311,
-0.0304325987,
0.0003563896,
-0.0388035178,
-0.0023805271,
0.0047318018,
-0.0035863644,
-0.0113425963,
-0.045797769,
-0.0499716252,
-0.0672771335,
-0.0029251806,
0.0593158454,
-0.0305319056,
-0.0876874253,
0.0440199114,
-0.0212084204,
0.1007442549,
-0.0162467025,
-0.0004714133,
-0.0002097019,
-0.0194625314,
0.0685219914,
-0.0447275154,
-0.0092302226,
-0.0272330139,
0.0116477143,
0.0092591699,
-0.0084933117,
0.0317285098,
0.0743838549,
-0.0051668892,
0.0388569273,
0.0000018505,
-0.056930799,
0.0077739353,
-0.0526005551,
-0.0140115358,
-0.0332556292,
0.0546986908,
-0.0000789167,
-0.0022591159,
0.0305937622,
-0.0525794812,
0.0012089614,
0.0295452476,
0.0572665408,
0.0369227193,
0.0666339174,
0.0165058132,
-0.0013549026,
-0.0012250699,
-0.0338830799,
-0.0040364396,
-0.0992193669,
-0.0082737999,
-0.0182624869,
-0.0390397906,
-0.0068934327,
-0.0230943095,
-0.0088124061,
0.0009922562,
-0.0214802045,
-0.042145703,
0.0289479569,
-0.0344710201,
-0.0446054898,
-0.0497119837,
0.0413394645,
0.0061239237,
0.0117875161,
-0.006079712,
-0.0345688388,
0.0158020165,
-0.025388319,
-0.0347082205,
0.017400533,
0.028221257,
0.0084458608,
-0.026400324,
0.0445427448,
0.0156003814,
0.0124245323,
0.0018778967,
0.0902728736,
-0.0266917367,
-0.021344969,
0.0055759796,
0.0079561537,
-0.0127449334,
-0.0884926617,
-0.0113789653,
0.0192216504,
-0.1083058193,
0.0376069397,
-0.0350187346,
0.0329309888,
0.0194708407,
-0.0267682504,
-0.0106130391,
0.0432985015,
0.0246516243,
0.0316755399,
0.0549305826,
0.0354915485,
0.0305285454,
-0.0104292119,
-0.0160162114,
-0.0096871825,
-0.038538646,
0.0081554949,
-0.0476232618,
0.01033941,
-0.0430953056,
-0.0491382144,
-0.0590184964,
0.0017931805,
-0.0410203859,
0.0477462783,
-0.0017241245,
0.0314772725,
-0.0337134711,
-0.0239829347,
-0.0878471583,
0.030048877,
-0.0301314667,
0.0311039053,
0.0418701321,
-0.0603464767,
-0.0074018333,
-0.0036589364,
-0.0105959615,
-0.0025137833,
-0.0024409329,
0.1087110937,
-0.0071349707,
0.0057291179,
0.0376080163,
-0.0351315811,
-0.0423804075,
-0.0943331048,
-0.0312751755,
-0.0155659663,
0.0054161092,
0.0007825447,
-0.0052784602,
-0.044486098,
0.0383498855,
0.0041635241,
-0.0213720612,
0.0670283735,
0.0338661,
-0.0071385643,
-0.0032576856,
0.0109014576,
-0.0434607081,
0.079869993,
0.0430704169,
0.0424613208,
0.0409703963,
-0.0043475176,
0.0287238806,
0.0159722995,
0.0176371951,
-0.0066463016,
-0.0132350475,
0.0104176225,
0.0190375615,
0.0391136482,
-0.001709981,
0.0565841831,
-0.0270868167,
-0.0058220504,
0.0842012465,
0.0529099293,
-0.0240357369,
0.0112001747,
-0.0009984242,
0.0296039786,
0.0076392461,
-0.0071802717,
-0.0529326759,
0.0388435759,
-0.0028695159,
-0.012900657,
0.0323930159,
-0.0043765674,
-0.0002401417,
-0.0646747127,
-0.002920677,
-0.0039795768,
0.0393874533,
0.028699372,
0.0091664279,
-0.024637036,
-0.0516728051,
0.0201970395,
0.0118014514,
-0.0008631576,
-0.0220718551,
-0.0344561413,
0.012449949,
0.0630474761,
0.040320266,
-0.0088674491,
-0.053542342,
-0.0490504131,
-0.019937057,
0.0391913019,
0.0773521438,
-0.0211462714,
0.0298235547,
-0.0587691888,
-0.0177492909,
0.0107868556,
0.0265217796,
0.0255756322,
0.0232699569,
0.0059835184,
-0.0070277466,
0.0065549435,
-0.0039290041,
-0.0071914271,
0.0265635457,
-0.0119180372,
0.0324641801,
-0.0183873456,
0.0559365936,
-0.0224619303,
0.0022770707,
0.006246597,
0.0062619378,
0.0271119736,
-0.0349976942,
0.0230412297,
-0.0597074479,
0.0019172579,
0.0445411205,
0.0196464974,
-0.0292806476,
-0.0519906692,
-0.0391121954,
-0.0357490256,
0.0381584391,
-0.0097841658,
0.0215401612,
-0.0108472472,
0.0163099803,
-0.0051761377,
0.0015922149,
-0.0147806928,
0.0165712219,
-0.0020144966,
0.0146229155,
-0.019177774,
0.0036400117,
0.0107897893,
-0.0357405767,
-0.0013206156,
0.0022922542,
-0.0065318248,
0.0261463225,
0.0488821752,
0.0147711728,
-0.045942232,
-0.0905583873,
-0.0973605365,
-0.0025716817,
-0.0125313988,
-0.0053630508,
0.0009673024,
-0.008476398,
-0.000691376,
-0.0248222444,
-0.0155443149,
-0.0144651802,
0.0264189132,
-0.010645343,
0.0245619845,
0.0238443688,
-0.00816203,
-0.0549066104,
0.0223777741,
-0.0137216523,
0.01770024,
0.0024547733,
0.0316414796,
-0.0381069854,
-0.0020017668,
-0.042943269,
0.0199620482,
-0.0213759374,
-0.0652699545,
0.0212361906,
0.0150735704,
0.0056822333,
0.0478260256,
0.037234135,
0.0565046109,
0.016041005,
-0.061926581,
-0.0487113185,
0.0484646633,
-0.0388299972,
-0.0165829659,
-0.079468675,
-0.0116789322,
-0.0184724368,
0.0553332344,
0.0175643992,
0.0283753928,
-0.0877454951,
0.0499166101,
0.0136113726,
-0.0654854029,
-0.0160441343,
0.010559313,
-0.0233475491,
0.061286483,
0.0004254865,
-0.0401667804,
0.1117815375,
-0.0016488277,
-0.006328709,
-0.0195326768,
-0.0090897642,
-0.025330184,
0.0554672331,
-0.0397625603,
-0.0179490559,
0.0292961057,
-0.0128685385,
-0.0593347698,
-0.0534251146,
0.0108994655,
-0.0496103503,
0.0104060741,
-0.0582380518,
-0.0251823217,
0.0272962227,
-0.0276755448,
-0.0537553392,
-0.0550827421,
-0.0634592548,
0.0244280584,
0.0552270934,
-0.0395902991,
-0.0399456806,
0.0082202358,
-0.017180549,
-0.0083264429,
-0.0120845744,
-0.0077157184,
0.0011706782,
-0.0198072772,
0.0497346409,
0.0287663974,
0.0438564122,
-0.0261986218,
0.0344171152,
0.0121877324,
0.0238871109,
0.0024295815,
-0.0045162085,
0.023761455,
0.0099066738,
-0.0000384721,
-0.0090989117,
0.0550485998,
0.0637695342,
-0.0291568153,
-0.0282459762,
0.1333573908,
0.0316512957,
-0.0014836497,
-0.0055074897,
-0.0309732854,
0.0650774837,
0.0242675506,
0.0247046687,
-0.0674310401,
-0.0253274515,
0.0223131664,
0.0020765294,
-0.029282935,
-0.0505157448,
-0.0042440812,
-0.1088823527,
0.0289444067,
-0.0092975125,
-0.0049934397,
0.0263954923,
0.0020689447,
0.0105104372,
-0.0259981081,
0.0402261242,
-0.0207301918,
0.0128100477,
-0.0099234795,
0.0075382907,
-0.022400789,
-0.009258532,
0.0240063556,
-0.0053322962,
0.0811008289,
0.0485016443,
0.0616708696,
0.014893434,
0.0259329602,
-0.000446454,
0.0062079318,
-0.0257422049,
-0.0035950274,
0.0388870202,
0.0091866413,
-0.0117178569,
-0.0279076099,
0.0235368088,
0.0181095693,
-0.0387200825,
0.0039651478,
0.0066624884,
-0.0497772172,
-0.0097505674,
0.0213856604,
0.0412395895,
0.0711301714,
0.0627076775,
0.007298064,
-0.0598298013,
-0.0502014197,
-0.0344557241,
0.0220781267,
-0.0220138188,
-0.0022864107,
-0.0103897052,
0.0208694246,
0.0074216085,
-0.0404597819,
-0.063205421,
-0.0017907091,
0.0182080902,
0.0007857366,
-0.0338856988,
0.0351180807,
0.0322265849,
0.0181962848,
0.0008279486,
-0.0135533279,
0.0272030588,
-0.0552463494,
0.026103735,
0.0121993301,
-0.0014110561,
-0.016086353,
0.0303389207,
-0.0790072754,
-0.0573359244,
-0.0042429562,
0.0735091642,
0.0314546674,
0.0193628743,
-0.0168062318,
-0.0333037265,
0.0246041603,
0.0155230043,
-0.0396241955,
0.0112310993,
0.0585010499,
0.0725626126,
-0.0033184222,
0.0500615649,
-0.0156209422,
0.0310273692,
0.0085420804,
0.0385371409,
-0.0542661361,
-0.0987116694,
-0.0034034583,
-0.0484581217,
0.0488899797,
-0.0045843143,
-0.0247664154,
-0.0087692449,
0.0238904674,
-0.0255345069,
-0.0220929738,
-0.0278142225,
-0.0524408817,
0.036165759,
-0.027194567,
-0.0152022513,
0.0083664311,
-0.018376423,
0.0291086566,
0.0095151532,
-0.0292290226,
0.0229057167,
-0.0137210414,
0.0156113841,
-0.0078949509,
0.0075947973,
0.0213795379,
-0.0055864095,
0.0406469032,
0.0246353131,
0.0622661002,
0.0291804336,
-0.0331035294,
0.0162641369,
-0.0179610457,
-0.0700062439,
-0.078712821,
0.0118051162,
0.0620622598,
-0.0013067633,
0.0051223454,
0.0088656563,
-0.0514695756,
0.0155017693,
-0.0004327064,
0.0220192857,
-0.0234165136,
-0.0104147922,
0.0601304881,
0.0100763366,
-0.036542628,
0.0096396049,
0.0388247781,
-0.0188325066,
0.0421052538,
-0.0074116439,
-0.0248809494,
-0.0373962,
-0.031444937,
0.0027438032,
0.0344569609,
0.0017396908,
0.0342440978,
-0.0779011175,
-0.0335125513,
0.0225118455,
0.0403419994,
0.0015619972,
-0.0427601226,
0.0287452713,
0.0337618366,
-0.028224308,
0.0201838892,
-0.0399750955,
-0.0053922902,
-0.0033492222,
-0.0164709333,
-0.0636627302,
-6.271678193e-33,
-0.0305691995,
-0.0399846621,
0.0049148365,
0.0035694721,
-0.0234598257,
-0.0173147582,
-0.0014806908,
0.0165724773,
-0.0121211857,
0.0393323638,
-0.0414521918,
0.0153716961,
0.0191790741,
0.0141848978,
0.0353069603,
-0.0320697129,
0.0553180315,
-0.0102897556,
-0.0379408337,
-0.0088483384,
0.0371412635,
0.0113643799,
0.0326945037,
-0.0664253607,
0.0303385518,
0.0233070571,
-0.0583235063,
0.0548921786,
0.0138212871,
0.0379948504,
-0.0064616748,
0.0129974168,
-0.0213556327,
-0.046338059,
-0.0139475493,
0.0090261633,
-0.0263679177,
-0.0503521673,
0.0394146256,
0.0277986005,
0.0218771547,
-0.0022077318,
0.0068993033,
-0.004104313,
-0.0561313033,
0.0136371944,
-0.0062679686,
-0.0095175663,
-0.0144906295,
0.0055202451,
-0.0293286629,
0.0082034785,
-0.0285270456,
-0.0691977516,
0.0110452417,
0.0245874338,
0.0083585856,
-0.0229916126,
-0.0091925478,
0.0162570495,
-0.0302800313,
0.0228607785,
0.0218519364,
0.0120903784,
0.0044102352,
0.0867116898,
0.0207787678,
0.0272911098,
0.0057932655,
-0.0370737016,
0.0173742026,
0.0590664633,
-0.0028541994,
0.0680429637,
-0.0176818185,
-0.0273262318,
-0.0290995501,
0.013283019,
0.0507078469,
0.0604723729,
0.0246767327,
0.0279673506,
-0.0180278532,
-0.0425793789,
-0.0543279573,
-0.0374668948,
-0.0205770079,
-0.0203902684,
0.0150708435,
0.0200313423,
0.0164072774,
-0.0123368101,
0.034287788,
-0.0357122049,
-0.0255457815,
0.0322684273,
-0.0011417862,
0.0184860136,
-0.0038025333,
0.0306058098,
-0.048306182,
-0.0272333063,
0.0404512919,
0.0107193142,
0.0240621213,
0.0062337886,
0.0034197115,
0.0148736043,
-0.0579514913,
0.0130294021,
-0.0150236823,
0.0811991915,
-0.0390945077,
-0.0127087934,
0.02130845,
0.0093972711,
-0.0186590143,
0.0279043075,
-0.0176082123,
0.0099635599,
-0.0091611352,
-0.016860744,
0.0167604666,
0.0259537157,
-0.0520851165,
-0.0158458799,
-0.0121812187,
-0.0436498709,
-0.0160793308,
-0.0028809248,
-0.016263986,
0.0097309193,
2.67e-7,
-0.0017913086,
0.0807596892,
0.0171896201,
0.0372871943,
0.0272753425,
0.0878425092,
-0.0264991242,
0.0240578055,
0.0376584046,
-0.0243440736,
0.0289647393,
0.0111544998,
0.073003836,
0.0453999043,
-0.0742811263,
-0.0341187045,
-0.0810154155,
-0.0233216342,
-0.0004084052,
-0.0254004002,
0.0660115853,
0.0897903219,
0.0592764281,
0.0107912198,
-0.0095721614,
0.021617962,
0.0627729818,
-0.0666790307,
-0.0509936996,
0.0567963235,
0.0121176383,
-0.003069449,
-0.0030246773,
0.0087656109,
0.0015236845,
0.0328142717,
-0.0373080596,
0.0531186461,
0.0169361942,
-0.0403201878,
-0.0267598927,
0.0050517954,
0.0025016866,
-0.0456084684,
0.019468192,
-0.0772362277,
-0.0352140814,
-0.0409709662,
0.0210337024,
-0.0297134593,
0.0461028405,
-0.0244372264,
-0.0315849148,
0.0100787859,
0.0050815158,
0.0379430354,
0.0175939817,
-0.0582117587,
-0.0308134723,
0.0227693375,
-0.0249909982,
-0.0490397885,
-0.0183765329,
-0.0113921296,
0.0019853739,
-0.0699929446,
0.016333513,
2.071132654e-34,
0.0696057975,
0.0143463975,
-0.0335844085,
0.0332460813,
0.0701865777,
0.016116973,
0.028838871,
0.0252153557,
0.0625268295,
-0.0405074693,
-0.0069265985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03271v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03271v2 | Uncertainty of Thoughts: Uncertainty-Aware Planning Enhances Information Seeking in Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T18:28:44 | 2024-05-30T14:03:35 | Zhiyuan Hu, Chumin Liu, Xidong Feng, Yilun Zhao, See-Kiong Ng, Anh Tuan Luu, Junxian He, Pang Wei Koh, Bryan Hooi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In the face of uncertainty, the ability to *seek information* is of
fundamental importance. In many practical applications, such as medical
diagnosis and troubleshooting, the information needed to solve the task is not
initially given and has to be actively sought by asking follow-up questions
(for example, a doctor asking a patient for more details about their symptoms).
In this work, we introduce Uncertainty of Thoughts (UoT), an algorithm to
augment large language models with the ability to actively seek information by
asking effective questions. UoT combines 1) an *uncertainty-aware simulation
approach* which enables the model to simulate possible future scenarios and how
likely they are to occur, 2) *uncertainty-based rewards* motivated by
information gain which incentivizes the model to seek information, and 3) a
*reward propagation scheme* to select the optimal question to ask in a way that
maximizes the expected reward. In experiments on medical diagnosis,
troubleshooting, and the `20 Questions` game, UoT achieves an average
performance improvement of 38.1% in the rate of successful task completion
across multiple LLMs compared with direct prompting and also improves
efficiency (i.e., the number of questions needed to complete the task). Our
code has been released [here](https://github.com/zhiyuanhubj/UoT) | [
0.0703422874,
0.0294660442,
-0.0204309803,
0.0164516959,
-0.0449430607,
-0.018018337,
-0.0414409004,
0.0215914473,
-0.0042419443,
0.0286618005,
0.0147135854,
-0.0569109693,
-0.0084411725,
0.0074315676,
-0.0006928471,
-0.08213301,
0.0330585763,
-0.0501698628,
0.069385685,
-0.02048406,
-0.0171963833,
-0.0510191433,
-0.0648661256,
0.0271316562,
-0.0132682715,
0.0140317064,
-0.0447940528,
0.014317832,
0.0247080773,
-0.0917837992,
-0.0189063009,
0.0190599579,
0.0076515381,
0.0076483041,
0.0000023161,
-0.0496761166,
-0.0160093084,
-0.0348516554,
-0.0316031091,
-0.055882629,
0.0137461238,
0.0281931926,
0.0082643284,
0.0254547913,
-0.0462018326,
0.0276730675,
0.0445567593,
0.0376464315,
0.0309813116,
0.0514986478,
0.0090343319,
0.0307459645,
0.0081662545,
0.0067892917,
0.0946925282,
-0.0799326226,
0.0082558487,
0.0123444004,
0.0818661153,
0.0304676034,
-0.0038123876,
0.0276551079,
0.0076681999,
0.001080794,
-0.028875513,
0.0744642541,
0.0503511727,
-0.0502084494,
-0.0284471437,
0.0272552688,
-0.0087365313,
0.0207026973,
0.0205397289,
-0.0190994162,
0.0131636085,
0.0082410341,
-0.0402644575,
0.0235555153,
-0.0241745114,
-0.0081783533,
0.0155754453,
0.0361726508,
0.0463504083,
-0.0004450989,
0.0153172454,
0.0569823459,
-0.0238041393,
-0.0536204055,
0.0157340001,
-0.0245191567,
-0.005481157,
-0.0522217192,
0.0084321713,
0.0843132064,
-0.0904466584,
0.0288734902,
-0.0021021219,
-0.0089304447,
0.020042887,
0.0124537898,
0.0164581202,
0.0409794226,
0.0116393035,
0.0489573032,
0.0318864137,
-0.009953375,
-0.0152744539,
-0.0058373394,
-0.0450404137,
0.0291297007,
-0.0250770897,
0.0123907244,
-0.0527035184,
0.0372115672,
-0.0028994905,
-0.0367080718,
-0.0321680531,
0.0319379829,
0.0011980943,
0.0236894619,
-0.0039084004,
0.0243245307,
0.0075958893,
-0.0084746908,
-0.0631244928,
-0.0184787959,
-0.053457737,
-0.0022839152,
0.0392382033,
-0.0229106843,
-0.0184047557,
-0.0218825005,
-0.0034475599,
-0.0089683011,
0.0259917919,
0.0709293708,
-0.0032282334,
-0.0196127184,
-0.0218186565,
-0.0273919832,
-0.0060924236,
-0.039614208,
0.0062689278,
-0.0463874191,
-0.0071190638,
-0.0005385211,
0.0000948365,
0.0039911843,
0.0501645431,
-0.0022010421,
-0.0236202683,
0.0737802386,
-0.0299133509,
0.0282236431,
0.0369027294,
0.0247496367,
-0.0253796931,
0.0589840561,
0.0681234747,
0.0136155207,
0.0014927624,
0.0217762459,
0.0500106476,
0.0347365029,
0.0057908325,
-0.0106920637,
0.0426605679,
-0.0088914791,
-0.0051786476,
0.0877285749,
-0.0406679139,
0.0536242127,
-0.0211690478,
0.0403048694,
0.0540492199,
0.0512569174,
-0.0270414408,
-0.0398923717,
0.012311928,
-0.0009620271,
-0.0144176073,
-0.0312515199,
-0.0334488414,
0.0821892768,
-0.0184844676,
0.0094073573,
-0.0134405093,
-0.0187679026,
-0.0236571059,
-0.0530757122,
-0.0371518619,
0.0160333961,
0.0159260482,
0.0300100185,
0.0138703957,
-0.0323668011,
-0.0568233393,
0.0099574458,
-0.001713338,
-0.0035731785,
-0.0368693247,
-0.0864168108,
0.0640944988,
0.07771983,
0.0527430736,
-0.0582668371,
-0.0710877702,
0.0055679488,
-0.025181191,
0.0105597032,
0.0351693407,
-0.0159331411,
0.0098435748,
-0.0342251323,
-0.0257887691,
0.010763933,
-0.0011646389,
-0.0015973318,
0.0229500495,
0.0141048664,
-0.0438473374,
0.0145902578,
-0.0026745512,
0.0135932174,
0.0010956657,
-0.0318666585,
-0.0140944235,
-0.0185750015,
0.0068564806,
-0.0056858514,
-0.0088318884,
0.0378508866,
0.0319602974,
-0.0004188851,
-0.0297694169,
0.0330379792,
-0.0244874749,
0.0020304727,
0.0224798564,
0.0181269608,
-0.0168937128,
-0.0248748902,
-0.0158472508,
-0.0369061567,
-0.0216315649,
-0.0529928058,
0.0139171313,
0.0242802426,
0.0474869981,
0.0175061263,
-0.0477557778,
-0.0469497703,
0.0566519722,
-0.0311640445,
0.0140338838,
0.0443877056,
0.000988291,
0.0018248581,
-0.0552075431,
-0.0127962036,
-0.0070200725,
-0.009070294,
-0.0012266262,
0.0359359831,
0.0466296226,
-0.0710159913,
-0.0498331487,
-0.1088915244,
-0.02871277,
-0.0077625606,
-0.0222149044,
0.00288394,
0.0303843673,
-0.0170146916,
-0.0213616136,
-0.0170400906,
0.0519795008,
0.0149142062,
0.0156918988,
0.0358467214,
0.0455931649,
-0.010055732,
-0.0530890599,
0.0177010261,
-0.0235828329,
-0.0364373364,
0.0071470672,
-0.0144850872,
-0.076798439,
0.0694785193,
-0.0384729169,
0.023881834,
-0.0088263778,
-0.0170331076,
0.0417994186,
-0.0594323277,
0.0389238559,
0.0562219992,
-0.0005810646,
-0.0111818388,
0.0751917884,
-0.0277213156,
-0.0537627228,
0.0670842305,
-0.0219308361,
-0.0216471031,
-0.0204116181,
-0.0603618063,
0.0108367158,
0.0761296973,
0.0013367441,
0.0176721402,
-0.0456385016,
0.0247178804,
-0.0302525628,
-0.0328432545,
-0.0257081036,
0.0106202401,
-0.0147254374,
0.0748208538,
-0.0172042754,
-0.0283709429,
0.1136862487,
0.0031220333,
-0.0039471183,
-0.0376743004,
-0.0034965554,
0.0116956541,
0.0701762289,
-0.0091949757,
-0.0003955545,
0.0402320586,
-0.0096276263,
-0.0373551175,
0.0040058359,
-0.0040893327,
-0.0446010865,
0.0202498063,
-0.0547512472,
-0.0089069735,
0.0045046341,
-0.0582222082,
-0.0505703203,
-0.0247441102,
-0.0394493751,
-0.017029928,
0.0414877385,
-0.0148151191,
-0.0167553816,
-0.0121275363,
0.0642626733,
0.0473014079,
-0.010223913,
-0.0357950814,
-0.0090236077,
0.0001104235,
0.0493192561,
0.0347269699,
0.0618789792,
-0.0190699901,
0.0388421528,
0.0308019277,
0.0378194004,
0.0022293013,
0.0191506892,
-0.0056451662,
0.0194978863,
0.0016204466,
-0.0044811075,
0.0958933085,
0.0943867341,
-0.0188413579,
-0.0700522587,
0.1263182312,
0.0584528111,
-0.0225557648,
0.0037127486,
-0.0976272523,
0.037245281,
0.028221067,
0.0279954467,
-0.0559723526,
-0.0343249328,
0.0274903271,
0.0020665606,
-0.0198460277,
-0.0459362641,
0.0247555152,
-0.0738650933,
0.0045922943,
-0.0302299447,
-0.000171177,
0.0093678534,
-0.0125335166,
-0.0153228287,
0.037279278,
-0.0168583225,
0.0147895431,
0.0280987862,
0.0035985233,
-0.0119021041,
-0.0450345613,
-0.0296002422,
0.0215918161,
-0.0101943547,
0.0813243613,
0.0751737952,
-0.0000811526,
-0.005608906,
-0.045491077,
-0.0188922547,
0.0346839912,
0.0201673992,
-0.032310605,
0.0340934172,
0.0225804131,
0.0017806097,
-0.0180207491,
-0.0022923285,
-0.0262285918,
-0.0006290431,
0.0412055738,
0.0751835555,
-0.0520858169,
-0.0204508491,
-0.0495042242,
0.0103185726,
0.0486308224,
0.0467241481,
-0.022144353,
-0.0407572389,
-0.0024466543,
-0.0213600714,
0.0102075236,
-0.0568155237,
-0.0116891395,
-0.0174441449,
0.0186208375,
0.0428929701,
-0.0502591468,
-0.0600461252,
0.0386841223,
-0.0032612637,
0.0150664654,
-0.0062528299,
0.0298185758,
0.0327867046,
-0.0472583584,
-0.0270319879,
0.015923705,
0.0164977871,
-0.0371229984,
-0.018720096,
0.0193933118,
-0.0129879592,
0.0310287662,
0.0393048711,
-0.0983868465,
-0.0496673323,
-0.0194052812,
0.0891524106,
0.0245694779,
-0.0051258449,
-0.0266840383,
-0.0299870018,
0.0193277951,
-0.0086327614,
-0.0435096994,
0.0054208422,
0.0121752573,
0.0454342775,
0.0216755588,
0.0187466368,
-0.0405506939,
-0.0134846382,
-0.0006533869,
0.0620905347,
-0.0526335128,
-0.0367766172,
0.0179501586,
0.020279333,
0.0346639678,
-0.0379714295,
0.0074316454,
-0.0013306752,
0.0188703258,
-0.0272249356,
-0.0238763615,
-0.0332846902,
0.0096228477,
0.0246368349,
-0.025976222,
0.0332783312,
-0.0052262084,
-0.0056142798,
-0.0382593051,
-0.0012620777,
-0.0087001203,
0.0148825115,
0.0013581716,
0.0672415048,
-0.007589167,
0.003468008,
0.0265862364,
0.0039106929,
0.0377468579,
0.0388523228,
0.0754374266,
0.0041751959,
-0.0367889777,
0.0024873372,
0.0030039484,
-0.0547424331,
-0.1345841885,
0.0387170352,
0.0374764539,
0.0510861687,
0.0518536791,
0.0022581229,
-0.0559630729,
0.0308706202,
0.0093660988,
-0.0359268636,
0.0082440879,
-0.0262415987,
0.0828612223,
0.0359213725,
0.0145938406,
-0.0231286325,
0.0415082723,
-0.058729846,
0.0554956719,
-0.005908703,
-0.0251886211,
-0.044439666,
0.006838399,
-0.0205212142,
0.0676449761,
-0.0394568555,
0.0311133601,
-0.0504399091,
-0.0287412703,
0.0038406481,
0.0532628894,
-0.0145797804,
-0.0655760393,
0.0638120025,
0.0203234982,
-0.0004607186,
-0.0296334382,
-0.0012310169,
0.0102956733,
-0.0208493453,
-0.029885333,
-0.045009125,
-6.253245707e-33,
-0.001748469,
-0.0442782603,
0.0624797828,
-0.0435717665,
-0.0322153084,
0.0020519646,
-0.0567935929,
0.0621503368,
-0.0203539953,
0.0113145085,
-0.038592495,
0.0167182125,
0.004281078,
0.0134557663,
0.0439829342,
-0.0377340019,
0.0251375102,
0.0066506821,
-0.053369306,
-0.0117473751,
-0.0006837496,
0.0133618191,
0.0048407624,
-0.0249867328,
0.0242503118,
0.0058837389,
-0.0345889591,
0.064572446,
-0.0014581913,
0.010822719,
-0.0262718443,
0.0131865907,
0.0158417933,
-0.0187403746,
-0.0057140812,
-0.0114923725,
-0.0166707002,
-0.0636259541,
0.0174992569,
-0.0171984807,
-0.0919507369,
-0.0142638627,
0.0027200538,
0.0166861508,
-0.0463298336,
0.0265603382,
0.0068048052,
-0.0096534388,
-0.0063368753,
0.0155223301,
-0.0058425725,
-0.0067758942,
0.0066339117,
-0.0611556172,
0.0296890642,
0.0217439849,
-0.0300441403,
-0.0197090246,
-0.0098637119,
0.0359955989,
0.0116589917,
0.0622505844,
0.0132303182,
-0.0057185506,
-0.0024365066,
0.0253069736,
0.0112801697,
-0.0186367035,
-0.0431099534,
-0.0037104147,
-0.0307428613,
0.0267484635,
0.0315500461,
0.0294521023,
0.0258513764,
0.0098162191,
-0.0391096137,
0.0407637246,
0.0210262723,
0.0458348766,
0.0360953622,
0.0335250907,
-0.0434886999,
-0.0150819076,
-0.0308841933,
0.0320888497,
-0.0316890925,
-0.0317486599,
0.0169519149,
0.0170925707,
0.0193974432,
-0.0426564105,
0.0021352964,
0.0130671887,
-0.001560459,
-0.0206824392,
0.0022822942,
0.0467152335,
-0.0189024042,
0.0070094275,
-0.0511600412,
-0.001455807,
0.0011707019,
-0.0008364494,
0.0051155291,
0.0605346449,
-0.0235705767,
0.0292743742,
-0.0684901327,
-0.0071190982,
-0.0215113368,
0.041757457,
-0.0007773967,
-0.033567436,
0.013695946,
-0.0146174449,
-0.024791928,
0.008930333,
0.0184513144,
-0.0533954427,
-0.0530824177,
-0.0078313528,
-0.0050048325,
-0.0012519725,
-0.0315127485,
-0.0085065914,
-0.0710807517,
0.0269650314,
-0.0206241198,
-0.0557820275,
-0.0233616009,
0.0158677101,
3.069e-7,
-0.0152737275,
0.0610360466,
-0.0067053637,
0.0614597946,
0.0151010742,
0.0476411171,
-0.0158406273,
-0.0068450193,
0.0126407156,
-0.0606697984,
0.0311767794,
0.0476602837,
-0.0042368914,
0.0264559165,
-0.0933850631,
-0.0563558601,
-0.0236205515,
0.0099079236,
0.0007892693,
-0.0246054791,
0.0786476284,
0.0354106463,
0.0008392335,
0.0209846795,
0.0153970513,
0.0064315591,
0.0314401053,
-0.0518012717,
-0.005243165,
0.0211856104,
-0.0001410391,
0.001559162,
-0.006259975,
0.0104958769,
0.0128978994,
-0.0382266901,
-0.0375910327,
0.0384433568,
-0.0088869212,
-0.0322176851,
-0.0136550907,
-0.0140147572,
0.0226182025,
-0.0529746488,
0.0326259434,
-0.0252201967,
-0.0305856653,
0.0152591188,
0.072723113,
-0.0225653201,
0.0336958729,
-0.0431238674,
-0.0583972819,
-0.0353426598,
0.0045579285,
0.0518652461,
-0.0120651657,
-0.0458205938,
-0.0123391626,
0.0147804217,
-0.0189850833,
-0.068460077,
-0.0411763638,
-0.0063941316,
-0.0150781432,
-0.1063355356,
-0.019991532,
2.595243112e-34,
0.0368044078,
0.0345640779,
0.0142064402,
0.0371474288,
0.0341959037,
0.016659813,
-0.0023009034,
0.0153112812,
0.0530664138,
-0.0311069265,
-0.0510659032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03269v1 | ISPA: Inter-Species Phonetic Alphabet for Transcribing Animal Sounds | 2024-02-05T18:27:27 | 2024-02-05T18:27:27 | Masato Hagiwara, Marius Miron, Jen-Yu Liu | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Traditionally, bioacoustics has relied on spectrograms and continuous,
per-frame audio representations for the analysis of animal sounds, also serving
as input to machine learning models. Meanwhile, the International Phonetic
Alphabet (IPA) system has provided an interpretable, language-independent
method for transcribing human speech sounds. In this paper, we introduce ISPA
(Inter-Species Phonetic Alphabet), a precise, concise, and interpretable system
designed for transcribing animal sounds into text. We compare acoustics-based
and feature-based methods for transcribing and classifying animal sounds,
demonstrating their comparable performance with baseline methods utilizing
continuous, dense audio representations. By representing animal sounds with
text, we effectively treat them as a "foreign language," and we show that
established human language ML paradigms and models, such as language models,
can be successfully applied to improve performance. | [
0.0226153061,
0.0712191314,
-0.0063044755,
-0.0147377551,
-0.0082939276,
0.0144400559,
0.0447194129,
0.0079206266,
-0.0670121536,
-0.0324136689,
-0.0718316659,
0.0004237274,
0.1032334343,
0.022900695,
0.0188650526,
-0.0906713977,
0.0021337662,
-0.0655101538,
0.0737922341,
-0.0132088466,
0.0041160458,
0.0337594524,
-0.059654519,
0.0715685934,
-0.0275995005,
-0.0084071783,
-0.0272368696,
-0.0001560317,
0.0438212939,
-0.010350992,
-0.0261240173,
-0.0258143768,
0.0251178797,
0.015834827,
0.000001366,
-0.0302230921,
0.016826814,
0.0282533206,
-0.0019829036,
-0.0014218307,
0.0204737727,
-0.0236561503,
-0.0193872154,
0.0227484833,
0.0135855051,
-0.0355556868,
0.0828478634,
0.0113600949,
-0.0024550403,
0.0327316746,
-0.0290995482,
-0.098676376,
0.0270529613,
0.0078918505,
0.0206516422,
0.0023452535,
-0.0053885048,
-0.0137054194,
0.0066153314,
-0.0314422622,
0.0021683041,
0.0583386607,
-0.0311527662,
-0.0056820717,
0.0382921472,
0.0196597278,
-0.0073261983,
-0.0944455937,
-0.0001350888,
0.0404079556,
0.0045700781,
-0.0334189646,
-0.0281699095,
0.0461605154,
-0.033510983,
-0.0457995273,
-0.0100100134,
0.0041280244,
0.0090210866,
0.0229773838,
0.032356184,
0.06927149,
0.0105106626,
-0.0173529405,
-0.0040401998,
-0.0183862206,
0.0329309478,
-0.0083107213,
0.0046625743,
-0.0053832098,
0.0483594313,
0.0520099588,
0.096547842,
0.0454077534,
-0.017439153,
-0.0225225203,
0.0075386437,
-0.0456123874,
0.0160738472,
-0.0031284739,
0.0114761377,
-0.0209796429,
-0.0723532587,
0.0155193629,
0.0021773793,
0.0056693559,
0.0014012376,
-0.0319977216,
-0.0127738966,
-0.0116267027,
-0.03623024,
-0.0306797512,
0.0152344964,
-0.0316094384,
0.0100538088,
0.0002793406,
-0.0227470789,
-0.0511587895,
-0.0086761191,
0.0071282936,
-0.0168767925,
-0.0217109267,
-0.0352021568,
0.0203492492,
0.0439673029,
0.0239669364,
0.009131223,
0.0672405213,
-0.0534521714,
-0.0439901911,
0.0180127509,
0.0174930841,
0.017659137,
0.0184338931,
0.0311102718,
0.0794021711,
0.0080817454,
-0.0229439642,
0.0358469896,
0.0360422656,
-0.0387529917,
-0.0314726159,
-0.0700444505,
-0.0629381388,
0.0417989641,
0.0000711239,
-0.0055915243,
-0.0186323002,
-0.0175574962,
-0.0036178436,
0.026455937,
0.097676903,
-0.0459145829,
0.0441942737,
0.0488251224,
-0.0071857977,
0.0185108539,
0.0058976104,
0.0820327774,
-0.0272846501,
0.0255193673,
-0.0683360398,
-0.021046171,
0.032939218,
-0.033350233,
-0.0362156853,
-0.0417657197,
-0.0378088579,
0.0130132511,
0.0295821354,
0.0424338952,
0.0886992589,
0.0159321688,
-0.0372135527,
0.0450456329,
0.0824815258,
0.0201866254,
0.0047682323,
0.063186653,
0.0172414929,
0.0349817723,
-0.0151663022,
0.011961964,
-0.0320632495,
-0.0034758076,
-0.0134240324,
0.0192919225,
0.021111533,
-0.0168360006,
0.0111372974,
0.00604987,
-0.0296393335,
-0.0205727443,
0.031227855,
0.0531748533,
-0.0212462712,
-0.0283616576,
0.0136324391,
0.0033760038,
-0.0234781392,
-0.004017958,
-0.0069654412,
0.0741881803,
0.0590054356,
0.0096286042,
-0.0587768443,
0.0397514924,
-0.0275509581,
-0.0398047864,
0.0437513217,
0.0150020206,
-0.0320114605,
0.0440233015,
-0.0301698092,
0.0049221651,
0.0734376907,
0.0276840609,
0.0286949668,
-0.0185101107,
0.0735109895,
0.0187722147,
-0.0287625417,
-0.0336441733,
0.0422703512,
-0.0133216213,
-0.0260434244,
-0.0007808814,
0.0115316762,
0.0373161547,
0.0375044309,
-0.0147862444,
0.0311480332,
0.0334791504,
-0.0442915186,
0.0493288152,
0.0462684557,
-0.0011763303,
0.0122523382,
0.0553938039,
-0.0507059507,
-0.0153607279,
0.0393924341,
0.03817752,
-0.0496186912,
-0.0033431114,
-0.0567515157,
0.042916052,
0.0038491944,
0.0215683617,
-0.0183770061,
0.0267678834,
0.0210131723,
-0.0607326999,
0.0648551285,
-0.019041054,
-0.0207830295,
-0.0462981984,
0.0136468615,
-0.0792660937,
-0.0105800722,
0.0628249198,
0.0005472449,
-0.0267504398,
-0.015442024,
0.0021982135,
-0.0311049335,
0.0046299612,
-0.0940298811,
-0.0446016304,
0.0176778827,
0.0370754711,
-0.0337294228,
-0.0165353026,
0.0355929211,
0.0071978634,
-0.0460541211,
-0.046660576,
-0.0523526669,
-0.0104265595,
-0.0225904454,
-0.0212298892,
-0.0486181676,
-0.0043102079,
-0.0159334838,
0.0054847081,
0.0372076482,
-0.0111937383,
-0.0811718777,
-0.050014399,
-0.0149062052,
0.0023696311,
-0.034587536,
0.0051400652,
-0.0010293501,
0.0460606888,
0.0156337563,
0.0005514352,
-0.0030000396,
0.0051585166,
-0.0027262697,
0.0237103645,
0.0173845049,
-0.0334013961,
-0.0266458504,
0.0300338417,
0.0556706041,
-0.0380756371,
0.0021065341,
-0.0520368367,
0.0426355228,
0.0042989724,
0.0035777809,
-0.026773788,
0.0250306688,
0.0145337312,
-0.0499294177,
-0.0835938901,
-0.0361080356,
-0.0202953797,
0.0085405819,
-0.001862393,
-0.0396510437,
0.0415999144,
-0.0312474165,
-0.0642427355,
0.0022411759,
-0.0520761311,
-0.0201378446,
0.0760788843,
-0.0484684147,
-0.002615449,
0.0020651747,
-0.0220921841,
0.0181820411,
0.0322210565,
0.0046194876,
-0.0689493492,
-0.0101523036,
-0.0322297923,
0.0134626431,
-0.0251821745,
0.0146673424,
-0.0384028703,
0.0129595399,
-0.0626144186,
0.0267597809,
-0.0230204165,
-0.0629266426,
-0.0344267078,
0.06296359,
0.0391973965,
-0.0016031981,
0.0167526267,
0.0277578868,
0.0018935979,
0.0314878933,
0.0025618649,
0.0245979223,
-0.0009865146,
-0.0357505456,
0.0551987402,
-0.0142243244,
0.0150318919,
0.0169714261,
-0.0184069313,
0.0274526905,
0.0228894614,
0.0157891978,
-0.0415082611,
-0.0050519151,
0.0203396846,
-0.0329460464,
0.0321166888,
0.0844189078,
0.0220775604,
-0.0187602099,
0.0372170731,
0.0160215199,
0.0426918082,
-0.037065722,
0.0369829014,
0.0080491733,
-0.0246146545,
0.0365968533,
0.0370883942,
0.0332464799,
0.0414053462,
-0.0050192615,
-0.0101347426,
0.0225702412,
0.0506492816,
-0.0803518295,
-0.0460235365,
-0.0189748071,
-0.0432571284,
-0.0428073667,
-0.0039180559,
0.0239339694,
0.0094675673,
-0.0109388595,
0.0207195096,
-0.0425574854,
-0.0234251637,
0.0071988693,
0.0123252487,
0.0527633913,
0.0440512933,
0.0285601839,
-0.0258249473,
-0.0443904884,
-0.0158692487,
-0.0108635044,
-0.0314286351,
0.0058662468,
0.0041350448,
0.0196151771,
-0.0461349189,
0.026089048,
0.0209569819,
-0.0313656181,
0.0086652189,
0.0052081277,
0.0571201816,
-0.0089297201,
-0.0011478979,
0.0147700123,
0.0150398677,
0.0089460053,
0.0695347711,
0.0383427739,
-0.0732528791,
-0.0535952933,
-0.0180306323,
-0.0499294475,
-0.040859919,
-0.0261504818,
0.0062647937,
0.0090043303,
-0.0740045607,
-0.0814402997,
0.0282317288,
0.0265783574,
-0.0008256969,
0.0437779799,
0.0078423191,
0.0269021112,
0.0185705069,
-0.049907133,
0.0334120356,
0.0277843848,
0.0517012067,
-0.0285198465,
-0.0625745058,
0.0500882044,
-0.018182721,
-0.0064790277,
0.0291506983,
0.0182681438,
-0.0641640797,
0.0368947275,
-0.0136696398,
0.0200028494,
0.0011328281,
-0.0050400714,
-0.0347691439,
0.0461774729,
0.0315333083,
-0.0387647562,
0.0319775119,
0.0572770499,
-0.0051018568,
0.0107463626,
0.0092557026,
-0.0416540951,
0.0328994095,
-0.0388058238,
0.0179344043,
0.0007057854,
-0.0700203255,
-0.003274254,
0.0131388046,
0.0188865978,
-0.0291137639,
-0.0629531145,
-0.0278573483,
0.0005735336,
0.0194579102,
0.0594664402,
-0.054482881,
-0.0066523342,
0.0414925814,
0.0715941265,
-0.0151901385,
-0.0237607248,
-0.0119954972,
-0.0393939801,
0.0303758662,
0.0868908167,
0.0301966388,
0.0017930521,
-0.0148765696,
0.0056312326,
-0.0269423239,
0.0564652532,
-0.0555044636,
0.0212107599,
-0.0022249192,
-0.0441038497,
-0.0217046291,
0.0139502268,
0.0265509617,
0.0301855057,
0.0146108512,
0.0180662833,
0.0233642664,
0.0242161825,
0.0342892073,
-0.0080340803,
0.0487836264,
-0.002973946,
0.0106552728,
-0.0237751119,
0.0256026983,
-0.0601675399,
0.0122299315,
-0.0173705127,
0.0165656451,
-0.0433805846,
0.0138767939,
0.050726369,
-0.0025194816,
0.0257546566,
-0.042479489,
0.0266910009,
-0.006493805,
-0.0143868523,
-0.0020405683,
0.0016270356,
-0.0370324515,
0.0033852227,
-0.0077917925,
-0.0789804757,
0.049653586,
-0.0324110314,
0.0078197056,
-0.0083531048,
-0.0064827539,
-0.0191877652,
0.0052667335,
0.0453820787,
0.0147155654,
-0.0472972058,
-0.0118191699,
-0.0232172944,
-0.0244063437,
-4.134152653e-33,
-0.0325316973,
-0.0369785205,
-0.0292705782,
0.0291239433,
-0.013247489,
0.0151047539,
0.0012721439,
0.0071577742,
0.0188247375,
0.0200143866,
0.0300290268,
-0.0338018872,
0.0155151729,
-0.0238138027,
0.0198113564,
0.0375449248,
0.0201266371,
-0.0261366758,
0.044735983,
-0.029365059,
0.0596039295,
0.0989733115,
0.035537567,
-0.0935597494,
-0.0338389836,
0.0150018735,
-0.007494126,
-0.0453414246,
-0.0051271496,
0.0277654976,
-0.0678355172,
0.0384180024,
-0.0148330918,
0.0125353495,
-0.0166482683,
0.0121050039,
-0.094706133,
0.0177595597,
0.0248522945,
0.0533456355,
0.0112852156,
0.0069881412,
0.0551576018,
-0.0347116105,
0.0035349689,
0.0177905317,
0.0302948579,
-0.1100615337,
0.0085725971,
-0.0476694368,
-0.0901739597,
0.0061155679,
-0.0067819557,
-0.0014301887,
0.0669430494,
0.0745000467,
-0.0532574393,
-0.0060333028,
-0.0275072232,
0.05288174,
0.0158353485,
0.0275531393,
0.0107734073,
0.021129461,
-0.0145973088,
0.0086651295,
0.0825554058,
-0.0906257331,
0.010044612,
0.0161969159,
0.009631482,
0.023506863,
0.0508398004,
-0.0095981164,
0.0083106821,
-0.0087770186,
-0.0201909021,
-0.0058472734,
0.03421662,
-0.0227480382,
-0.0054466543,
0.0507755876,
-0.0119090015,
0.0172803886,
-0.0249452181,
0.0035940434,
0.007668308,
0.0039029212,
0.0388575159,
-0.0291335694,
-0.0019580668,
0.027059529,
0.0448117852,
-0.0029839096,
0.0090176901,
-0.0455319472,
-0.0016104489,
-0.0078812474,
0.0156987887,
-0.0310441125,
-0.0387740396,
-0.0608591959,
0.0793099552,
0.0061361417,
0.0701344684,
-0.0571427904,
0.0057737222,
0.0411239676,
-0.0352033265,
-0.0117429225,
0.0142197777,
-0.0277519356,
0.0170888156,
0.0571799241,
0.0275718216,
-0.0352787673,
0.0001980254,
-0.0159591902,
-0.0277740173,
0.0031825714,
-0.035965357,
-0.0069772145,
-0.0597250313,
0.026890792,
-0.0440108776,
0.0078510866,
0.0232978445,
-0.0210832097,
-0.0100023281,
-0.0033042619,
-0.0054370584,
0.0020706342,
2.232e-7,
-0.004092244,
-0.0018608874,
0.0578456409,
-0.0125851091,
0.0690066144,
0.0318023264,
-0.0338282846,
-0.0258238018,
-0.008588586,
-0.0268809665,
0.0010001673,
-0.0032851896,
0.1312320679,
0.0011303597,
-0.0819821581,
-0.0551479869,
-0.0345706232,
-0.0036486823,
-0.031846121,
-0.0005260766,
0.0014672902,
0.0763746053,
-0.0156372599,
-0.0737885386,
0.0396578796,
-0.0142940516,
0.0492414497,
-0.0513578765,
0.0128625259,
-0.08004307,
0.0298957899,
-0.0303704776,
0.0049596,
0.0324434713,
-0.0009806952,
-0.0026495974,
0.0405365936,
0.0326134302,
-0.0238452498,
-0.0218782984,
-0.0047646975,
0.0795520321,
-0.0594692528,
-0.0305979922,
0.0484263673,
0.0188159365,
-0.028740216,
-0.0456465185,
0.0183914378,
-0.0068209367,
-0.0019797403,
-0.0151031213,
0.0504376851,
0.0246386882,
0.0024929079,
-0.0228510033,
-0.0276708324,
-0.0342861786,
-0.0332733504,
-0.017780304,
-0.0535910837,
-0.0217582118,
-0.0213107616,
0.002578849,
0.0253973883,
-0.0372921601,
-0.02072943,
1.34051872e-34,
0.0131851053,
-0.0276625734,
0.0186341163,
0.0456323214,
-0.0555927008,
-0.0113213845,
0.0359854326,
0.0063394648,
0.0167994499,
-0.0117915915,
-0.021220861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03268v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03268v3 | Understanding Reasoning Ability of Language Models From the Perspective of Reasoning Paths Aggregation | 2024-02-05T18:25:51 | 2024-06-20T18:46:06 | Xinyi Wang, Alfonso Amayuelas, Kexun Zhang, Liangming Pan, Wenhu Chen, William Yang Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (LMs) are able to perform complex reasoning
without explicit fine-tuning. To understand how pre-training with a next-token
prediction objective contributes to the emergence of such reasoning capability,
we propose that we can view an LM as deriving new conclusions by aggregating
indirect reasoning paths seen at pre-training time. We found this perspective
effective in two important cases of reasoning: logic reasoning with knowledge
graphs (KGs) and chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. More specifically, we
formalize the reasoning paths as random walk paths on the knowledge/reasoning
graphs. Analyses of learned LM distributions suggest that a weighted sum of
relevant random walk path probabilities is a reasonable way to explain how LMs
reason. Experiments and analysis on multiple KG and CoT datasets reveal the
effect of training on random walk paths and suggest that augmenting unlabeled
random walk reasoning paths can improve real-world multi-step reasoning
performance. code: https://github.com/WANGXinyiLinda/LM_random_walk | [
0.0471856073,
0.0272704028,
-0.0037936156,
0.0250611268,
-0.0522722863,
0.0328803621,
-0.006672916,
-0.0347048454,
0.028744502,
-0.0497659668,
0.0055371365,
0.0052306545,
0.0010554569,
0.0219667684,
0.0464596413,
-0.0448602587,
0.0330817215,
-0.0700561181,
0.0272808708,
-0.0140130511,
-0.0278985854,
0.0181966871,
-0.029985033,
0.0443722494,
0.0047197756,
-0.0064706318,
-0.0410007946,
-0.0187510904,
0.0068333806,
-0.0314982869,
-0.0346603394,
0.0432276875,
0.0153814368,
0.0433190241,
0.0000018396,
-0.0752777085,
-0.0206735581,
-0.0189675651,
-0.0601346642,
-0.020527022,
-0.0428169742,
0.0185105763,
0.0107160136,
0.0335395746,
-0.0337859094,
-0.0211295821,
0.0147312479,
0.0519128852,
0.0388810597,
0.0673349872,
0.014037149,
-0.0504670702,
-0.0060001663,
-0.0260758009,
0.018205015,
-0.0618324578,
0.0284571741,
0.0558352917,
-0.0338014178,
-0.0216933545,
-0.0069740317,
-0.0122045279,
0.0205137897,
0.007283458,
-0.0102460897,
0.0603684112,
-0.024885077,
-0.004863407,
-0.0043352027,
0.0761576295,
-0.046472393,
-0.050463751,
-0.0195622854,
-0.0252004694,
-0.0062638666,
0.0041812807,
-0.0374092087,
0.0371276625,
-0.0083493711,
0.0386150666,
-0.0024505008,
-0.020215895,
0.0561618693,
0.0074197915,
-0.0772895589,
0.1437447071,
-0.0208982434,
-0.0183653366,
0.0561115928,
0.0125592472,
0.0065442706,
-0.082582213,
-0.0274036881,
0.0695819259,
0.0201233774,
0.0503699817,
0.0169810615,
0.0419265516,
0.0147836199,
-0.005569966,
0.0217783973,
0.0333084241,
0.0126660196,
0.0683198571,
-0.060701713,
0.0058823274,
-0.0161133613,
0.0770867467,
-0.0264190733,
-0.0020175506,
-0.0499434285,
-0.0086811548,
-0.0172623154,
0.0530635975,
-0.0143500799,
-0.0115178246,
-0.0225268863,
0.0281710159,
-0.0042172885,
-0.0002628762,
0.0265491866,
-0.0115190381,
0.0557543226,
-0.0221603215,
-0.0641119629,
-0.0093271183,
-0.0319777355,
0.0613734797,
0.0172963627,
-0.0012411494,
-0.0263311062,
-0.0108361561,
0.011731361,
-0.0141693531,
0.0172453858,
0.063403368,
0.0104118725,
-0.0116355782,
-0.0567551404,
-0.0671967268,
0.0100114224,
-0.053795699,
0.0411391109,
-0.0797559246,
0.0296360068,
0.0316868126,
-0.0060380325,
-0.0110990079,
-0.0050034323,
0.0057520354,
-0.0620159246,
0.0677396283,
0.0071589435,
0.0143642221,
-0.0278264284,
-0.0030565979,
-0.0211228728,
0.0423126742,
0.0124599962,
0.0139721278,
0.0122894961,
0.0273471009,
-0.0163535345,
0.0040005012,
0.032418415,
-0.0240133125,
0.0316643193,
0.002987216,
-0.0316591896,
-0.0079185748,
0.004829823,
0.0273580216,
-0.0447425582,
0.0074019367,
-0.0092725083,
0.0609446019,
0.0283445567,
-0.0295632537,
0.0553534962,
-0.032260906,
0.0307505839,
0.0280389376,
-0.0627305135,
-0.0021247333,
-0.0570861846,
0.0210038181,
0.0188988168,
0.0033104443,
-0.0363450982,
-0.039070487,
-0.0153976521,
-0.0096571967,
0.0476446338,
0.0199622121,
0.0675488412,
0.0256671458,
-0.0347063355,
0.0479768403,
0.0539303795,
-0.0561955646,
-0.0310160648,
-0.0517155305,
-0.0004446307,
0.0270226113,
0.0348642655,
0.0024978078,
-0.038610924,
0.0291378256,
-0.0126700755,
-0.0168543942,
0.0263549592,
-0.0072503779,
-0.0016554456,
-0.0358320735,
-0.0607800521,
-0.0149965519,
0.0144482143,
0.0212599263,
-0.0074731912,
-0.0168676171,
0.0159583483,
-0.0453931466,
0.0040753395,
0.0332477167,
-0.0032891766,
0.0215695854,
-0.0278108362,
0.0217810273,
0.0228601675,
0.0089495964,
0.0001694609,
0.0335085168,
0.039449133,
-0.0000173504,
-0.0433342867,
0.0459976494,
-0.0319752917,
-0.0623905472,
0.0499012582,
-0.0040850127,
-0.0311383046,
-0.0194586888,
-0.0556898229,
-0.0503679514,
0.0284642782,
-0.0007386674,
0.0673912093,
-0.0198547617,
0.0229687095,
0.0170221329,
-0.0231909789,
-0.0109605109,
0.0999596789,
-0.0168209989,
0.0240131672,
-0.0252400991,
0.036287453,
0.0213178843,
-0.0088000586,
0.0199425258,
-0.0028954479,
-0.0055343583,
-0.0085368995,
0.013377768,
-0.0147315012,
-0.0531848855,
0.0047004414,
-0.0661466792,
-0.0208318755,
0.0128120091,
0.0175962001,
-0.0053026234,
-0.0262120422,
0.0138441436,
-0.0132696228,
-0.0263006091,
-0.0047169905,
0.0273860078,
0.0085206144,
0.0249913856,
-0.0162424669,
-0.013342876,
-0.0316317789,
-0.0222910009,
-0.0590800531,
0.0561675318,
0.0024648176,
-0.0038004394,
-0.0091671431,
0.0348954983,
-0.0735540986,
0.0248793699,
-0.0409045629,
-0.0232182983,
0.0327182263,
-0.0302359778,
0.0256443694,
0.0587102808,
-0.021389192,
0.0197500233,
0.0871016905,
-0.0101888375,
-0.0177969933,
0.0203946382,
-0.0361189395,
-0.0118604722,
-0.050768666,
0.0145173846,
-0.0323187895,
0.0589920208,
-0.006337916,
-0.0250913482,
-0.043525096,
-0.0027707007,
0.0012923133,
0.0126144364,
-0.0165508464,
-0.032691583,
0.006198518,
0.0913951769,
-0.0120771145,
-0.0193011332,
0.0788891837,
-0.0191684105,
0.0081044417,
-0.0400499217,
-0.0086016254,
-0.0409844369,
0.0896244049,
0.0338114873,
-0.0047029746,
-0.0130773271,
0.0035277647,
-0.0409025513,
-0.0464770421,
0.0264032558,
-0.0288283303,
0.0401817113,
-0.0332104154,
0.0136021366,
0.0186790228,
-0.0080429045,
-0.0426114239,
-0.004169683,
-0.078143999,
0.0075314534,
-0.0223963223,
-0.008350471,
0.0031275621,
-0.0114315236,
0.0106451036,
0.0288907047,
0.011229502,
-0.0139348321,
-0.0063633271,
-0.00131609,
0.0135445297,
-0.0259198863,
0.0470395461,
-0.0283205826,
0.0400794521,
0.0447172299,
0.0644618273,
-0.0123152072,
-0.0311356355,
0.0219998676,
-0.0123890555,
-0.0082032215,
-0.0244254079,
0.0160672721,
0.0241757035,
-0.0499226153,
0.0145988213,
0.12924321,
0.0314823501,
-0.0009903529,
0.0106452806,
-0.0012661065,
0.034763068,
0.0283348262,
0.0163625814,
-0.0659081116,
-0.0327848457,
0.0264533833,
0.0055917655,
-0.0107317409,
-0.0568961427,
-0.0085069779,
-0.1151673719,
-0.0036331848,
0.0102579743,
-0.0109495902,
-0.0206341743,
-0.0449906252,
-0.0048611737,
0.0019694797,
-0.0301574543,
0.0107878251,
0.0089768469,
0.0195264369,
0.0258276369,
-0.0398978703,
-0.0101433937,
0.0497249104,
-0.0219286773,
0.0172807071,
0.0088839028,
0.0138754472,
0.0110607808,
-0.0403395928,
0.0584467798,
-0.0117685758,
0.0156743061,
-0.0052870489,
0.0156913213,
-0.0013610016,
0.0077927154,
-0.0211983267,
0.0254719146,
-0.0446364805,
-0.0378402695,
-0.0047013271,
0.1021400243,
-0.0334658101,
-0.0609206073,
-0.0074728299,
0.0194992311,
-0.0449498184,
0.0695916191,
0.0141868433,
0.0273211915,
-0.0320904925,
-0.0415136963,
-0.0092891641,
-0.0025642449,
-0.0440149605,
0.0459572151,
0.0187174156,
-0.0067425924,
-0.0474791564,
-0.0604972728,
0.0283088163,
0.0672255084,
-0.0362507217,
0.0381993912,
0.0411596633,
-0.0021015706,
-0.0330830067,
0.0529400222,
-0.044688113,
0.0056033656,
0.0109830471,
0.003750172,
-0.006998138,
-0.0102366935,
-0.0604954548,
-0.0141012603,
-0.0627367944,
-0.092319876,
-0.0393585116,
0.0379026569,
0.0345770717,
0.064227283,
-0.0260805376,
-0.0085899802,
0.0321783908,
-0.0204174835,
-0.0035930206,
0.0108181275,
0.0621356927,
-0.0181029756,
0.0129257096,
0.0296429731,
-0.0583647564,
0.0239956677,
0.0239908546,
0.0453781672,
-0.0402239375,
-0.0569886081,
0.012744518,
0.0081353635,
0.061596252,
0.0360255875,
0.012673297,
-0.0198438205,
0.0401768424,
-0.013726376,
-0.0331619419,
-0.0123975063,
0.0033949453,
0.0042117937,
-0.0110868588,
0.0057535642,
-0.0571700819,
0.0000760857,
0.0173220206,
0.0187138692,
-0.0329414308,
0.0361951441,
0.0245234855,
0.02564786,
-0.0405109897,
-0.0072242171,
-0.0066098524,
-0.03421738,
-0.0001760418,
0.0056841751,
0.0236598328,
0.0360110886,
0.0005262079,
-0.041647017,
-0.0273933969,
-0.1061782241,
-0.0824001357,
0.0344860889,
-0.0047163097,
0.0772214606,
-0.034441974,
0.0274933148,
-0.0261611305,
0.0022622792,
0.0126632061,
0.0211344678,
0.0153460233,
-0.0403238982,
0.042147439,
0.0337095484,
-0.0132923769,
0.0006306877,
0.0675561503,
0.0002909974,
0.0603113584,
-0.0095584095,
-0.0355499797,
-0.0209674556,
-0.041734878,
-0.0328932777,
0.0390064679,
-0.0135509791,
0.0395090617,
-0.0519243293,
-0.1177580357,
-0.0137653314,
0.0387839936,
0.0073679355,
0.0076723108,
0.042572815,
0.0743101463,
0.017474262,
-0.0234129149,
-0.0172836222,
-0.0060984134,
-0.0045045293,
0.0082815038,
-0.0038544275,
-6.11786292e-33,
0.0059723631,
-0.0224337857,
0.0408165082,
0.023287192,
-0.0053242529,
-0.0314100645,
-0.0554366931,
0.0088242805,
-0.0563640893,
0.0457644165,
-0.0058070887,
0.0109592564,
0.0007076832,
0.0287747663,
-0.0126961125,
0.0132565778,
-0.0032834534,
0.0177056342,
-0.0144031895,
0.0071719335,
0.0481659323,
0.0047958018,
0.0426940657,
-0.0513670817,
0.0095212646,
-0.0152617283,
0.0012042295,
0.0579494499,
-0.0522764325,
0.0474857874,
0.0128513323,
-0.0143207274,
0.0369644016,
-0.0053357068,
-0.0094920415,
-0.0047972105,
-0.0719127059,
-0.0571435131,
0.0442830548,
0.0029997407,
-0.052888874,
-0.0032522529,
0.0382720307,
-0.0030659169,
0.0241910387,
-0.0242571272,
0.0267524589,
0.0138978437,
-0.038949322,
-0.0041819564,
-0.0257356688,
0.0290530492,
-0.0208731871,
-0.0172917228,
-0.0023220936,
-0.011196265,
0.0003144905,
-0.0282430314,
-0.033576645,
0.002710802,
0.0001581949,
-0.0156260543,
0.0475849211,
0.0269996524,
0.0205495805,
0.0576064959,
-0.0168519635,
-0.0255091432,
-0.0657698736,
0.0372974426,
0.0178161822,
0.0485019758,
0.0202119201,
-0.0392495878,
0.0064500538,
0.0274281017,
-0.1195630431,
-0.0036208089,
0.0154547151,
0.0596202947,
0.0115843564,
0.0129172048,
-0.0068897544,
-0.0184032712,
-0.0821376741,
-0.0099709695,
-0.0262819715,
-0.0296489298,
0.0004959776,
0.0089418124,
-0.0180837549,
-0.0282992944,
-0.0048477664,
-0.0337826796,
-0.0342928767,
0.066521205,
-0.007980858,
-0.0077130441,
-0.0270433389,
0.0480782613,
-0.0430899262,
-0.0259912554,
0.0123720039,
-0.0256668832,
-0.0077435947,
0.0214735381,
0.0622430667,
0.0015665968,
-0.0425957292,
-0.013606281,
-0.0431804247,
-0.015303608,
0.0098922057,
0.0088712405,
0.0827454254,
0.0602700971,
-0.0046662064,
0.029226603,
0.0046444978,
0.0111500258,
-0.0280834939,
0.0537444241,
-0.0069382014,
0.02411828,
-0.0263512917,
-0.0441899113,
-0.0317267701,
0.0113861728,
0.0324395038,
-0.0443704873,
-0.0253749695,
0.0508133173,
2.671e-7,
0.0667971224,
0.0142786745,
-0.0002985527,
0.0745939687,
0.0182484668,
0.0313861258,
-0.0317437463,
-0.0417655818,
0.0451935679,
-0.0638299733,
-0.0077065066,
0.0744669214,
0.0000462932,
0.0194966309,
-0.0286497064,
-0.007179922,
-0.0412026942,
-0.0156096527,
-0.012029808,
0.0011427503,
0.0546065345,
0.1021005213,
0.050816562,
-0.0196711719,
-0.0194239765,
-0.0566001087,
0.0427619778,
0.0328279063,
0.0284811202,
-0.0174883306,
0.0135278683,
0.0075535453,
0.0087665003,
0.0672639683,
0.0061734836,
0.0302206185,
-0.0278221834,
0.0401586518,
-0.0265601706,
-0.02453826,
-0.018283302,
-0.0365954861,
0.0293543544,
-0.0523785464,
0.1216009036,
-0.0490783155,
-0.0261975452,
-0.0107510136,
0.0154930139,
-0.0183741339,
-0.0001379932,
0.0342389308,
-0.0092383856,
0.0175382271,
0.007165466,
-0.0105305063,
0.0392866544,
-0.125447467,
-0.0313569643,
0.0267581679,
-0.0072571426,
-0.02704373,
0.0078970967,
-0.006084376,
0.052999381,
-0.0527128242,
-0.0066252248,
2.579703168e-34,
0.0360097885,
-0.028997099,
0.022670934,
-0.0192392003,
0.0504464991,
-0.0392432325,
0.0032207635,
0.0152675519,
0.025783116,
-0.1038979143,
-0.0263389964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03244v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03244v2 | Skill Set Optimization: Reinforcing Language Model Behavior via Transferable Skills | 2024-02-05T17:59:00 | 2024-06-22T18:58:09 | Kolby Nottingham, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Sameer Singh, Peter Clark, Roy Fox | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have recently been used for sequential decision
making in interactive environments. However, leveraging environment reward
signals for continual LLM actor improvement is not straightforward. We propose
Skill Set Optimization (SSO) for improving LLM actor performance through
constructing and refining sets of transferable skills. SSO constructs skills by
extracting common subtrajectories with high rewards and generating subgoals and
instructions to represent each skill. These skills are provided to the LLM
actor in-context to reinforce behaviors with high rewards. Then, SSO further
refines the skill set by pruning skills that do not continue to result in high
rewards. We evaluate our method in the classic videogame NetHack and the text
environment ScienceWorld to demonstrate SSO's ability to optimize a set of
skills and perform in-context policy improvement. SSO outperforms baselines by
40% in our custom NetHack task and outperforms the previous state-of-the-art in
ScienceWorld by 35%. | [
0.0424816273,
0.0613333695,
-0.0177422762,
0.0151298549,
-0.0107884733,
0.0173554067,
-0.02350761,
0.0187221412,
-0.0011778732,
0.0015257003,
-0.07677643,
-0.0078882007,
-0.0176020712,
0.0410677232,
0.0185449198,
-0.0748270974,
0.0510006063,
-0.0735819787,
0.0177849568,
-0.0008174988,
-0.0310101155,
-0.0164866708,
-0.0182460137,
0.0442542545,
0.0199152678,
-0.0237861909,
0.0389690921,
-0.0235853139,
0.0506560728,
-0.0447549038,
0.0226476789,
-0.0078861266,
0.0506632254,
-0.0467672236,
0.0000021895,
-0.0270825997,
0.0146789448,
-0.0502029993,
-0.0071649686,
0.0054408899,
0.0574483648,
0.0058566104,
-0.0245495979,
0.027267931,
-0.0490593724,
-0.0075979852,
0.0540338419,
-0.017903585,
0.0694806427,
0.0638298169,
0.0014129096,
0.0227330197,
-0.0169909745,
-0.0115387607,
-0.0105346581,
-0.0429166816,
0.016709609,
0.0371411927,
0.0346238911,
-0.0019404353,
-0.0365646146,
0.0148633262,
0.0366522893,
-0.0698217452,
0.0228529572,
0.0405833386,
0.0196397007,
0.032672137,
-0.0050608316,
0.0430867933,
-0.0397846922,
-0.0011021736,
-0.0017937784,
-0.0165603254,
0.031265147,
0.024937924,
-0.0486493446,
0.0321324021,
0.0194131695,
-0.0027206175,
0.0160994101,
0.0069419099,
0.0248012617,
0.0155185983,
0.010670092,
0.0594004877,
0.0041756583,
-0.0243476462,
-0.0091816057,
-0.0091916313,
-0.009935976,
-0.0665985942,
-0.0061801565,
0.0552300699,
-0.1050754413,
0.0401933677,
-0.0244535338,
0.0419849828,
-0.0541801453,
-0.0115235727,
0.0818386525,
0.0447302349,
0.017554827,
0.0424978547,
-0.0113157071,
0.0453036949,
0.0389642939,
0.0128053837,
-0.0170210209,
0.0158685874,
-0.0681215078,
-0.0292293802,
-0.0343932137,
0.0102891764,
-0.0047808243,
-0.027577661,
-0.0044896156,
0.0263052247,
-0.0264183246,
0.0242977422,
0.0032462131,
0.0020074074,
-0.0390956849,
0.0063854125,
-0.0441060737,
0.0364973396,
-0.0111685367,
0.0332245231,
0.0463965386,
-0.0065379366,
-0.0259842984,
0.0007173238,
-0.0189079866,
-0.0174382441,
0.0410194844,
0.1092536673,
-0.0247199293,
-0.0268352125,
-0.0035202091,
0.0034957172,
0.0130260577,
-0.023691874,
-0.021544477,
-0.04347739,
-0.0057164691,
-0.0528921261,
-0.0063378727,
-0.0426487178,
0.0025088538,
-0.0079483315,
0.0126993516,
0.0521404259,
0.0079565793,
0.0265670028,
0.0351049565,
0.0105708763,
0.0047719777,
0.0503041483,
0.0707365423,
0.0266737845,
-0.0135053089,
-0.0270811971,
0.0143362572,
0.0539129674,
-0.0096238889,
0.0296792295,
-0.0484782383,
-0.0258392412,
0.021856837,
0.0555331595,
0.0496626236,
0.0049639074,
-0.0574151464,
0.0511888638,
0.0647040978,
0.0524118654,
0.0083773341,
-0.0395336896,
0.0545249134,
0.0067165713,
0.0148284771,
-0.033057373,
-0.0373204462,
0.0576386899,
0.0532798581,
-0.0183828678,
-0.049863562,
0.0317154974,
-0.0128175886,
-0.0573307648,
0.0233811606,
0.007080181,
0.0345993079,
0.0461251624,
0.0374666676,
0.0097502703,
-0.0585257635,
0.019484356,
0.0443012081,
-0.0535154417,
0.0456329621,
-0.0646577775,
0.0392471924,
0.1078812405,
0.038223654,
-0.044315774,
-0.0506793261,
-0.014100506,
0.008676134,
0.0395343229,
0.0166606363,
-0.045696415,
0.0296655744,
-0.032453727,
-0.0469228923,
-0.0063580251,
0.0036975835,
0.0618975982,
0.0269766897,
-0.0048593255,
-0.0368441567,
0.0362007134,
-0.0335982628,
0.0272808652,
-0.0511333942,
-0.0477375351,
-0.0060568787,
-0.0289609674,
0.0472551323,
-0.0223102849,
-0.0078094215,
-0.0106731225,
0.0041725552,
-0.0304397717,
-0.0267289393,
0.0345535204,
-0.0534891672,
-0.0025299811,
0.0463875346,
-0.0095640533,
0.024820067,
0.0476166084,
0.0038885174,
-0.0039574802,
0.0048786867,
-0.003935033,
0.016205566,
0.0160622727,
0.0221191179,
-0.0331551135,
-0.0037094885,
-0.0395941027,
0.0399131589,
-0.0082372362,
-0.0339016244,
-0.0252678655,
0.0213209204,
-0.0162047204,
-0.0855363086,
0.0624650083,
0.0027470693,
0.0091334609,
0.0082013104,
0.0441425294,
0.0412893705,
-0.0427668765,
-0.0485683195,
-0.0030971104,
-0.0077441931,
0.0068348492,
0.0141062336,
0.0207686685,
-0.0405528694,
-0.0315778032,
0.0105323708,
-0.0056321644,
-0.0054817242,
0.0412081331,
0.0013554327,
0.0166048724,
0.0025906663,
-0.0123050129,
-0.0107189566,
-0.0035595512,
0.0131527018,
-0.0019044478,
-0.0187331028,
0.0431392267,
-0.0890398771,
0.0667067468,
-0.005254305,
0.0054305089,
-0.042741172,
-0.0434020981,
0.04009616,
-0.0048686988,
-0.0108886836,
0.0706565678,
-0.0155410701,
0.0440318361,
0.0764181241,
-0.0303950515,
-0.0395834185,
0.0168584473,
-0.0062304493,
-0.0205495544,
-0.0636299253,
-0.0041634766,
0.0344202034,
0.0471006595,
-0.0049967426,
0.0223266073,
-0.0607967265,
0.0171528608,
-0.0186968446,
-0.0555644594,
-0.0305765755,
-0.0441406518,
-0.0439379774,
0.003435717,
-0.0257613733,
-0.0274339635,
0.0396753177,
-0.0115349712,
-0.0026965404,
-0.0557036772,
-0.0102711692,
0.0010449003,
0.0430544503,
-0.0253013615,
-0.0025998931,
-0.0328360237,
-0.0345293507,
-0.0537589118,
-0.0382445455,
0.0476055518,
-0.0157300923,
0.0070109228,
-0.0523536019,
-0.0247589275,
0.0123590855,
-0.0235988963,
-0.0476642884,
0.0304730069,
-0.0058161733,
-0.0011153436,
0.0298526287,
-0.0426479839,
-0.0472252071,
-0.0055372445,
0.0671130717,
0.0035401576,
-0.0158584584,
-0.0092563638,
-0.0154792145,
-0.0239852425,
0.0931439251,
0.0564628914,
-0.0015383471,
-0.0598973818,
0.0113431914,
0.0364219993,
0.0184256453,
-0.0292780567,
-0.0038553958,
0.0411134511,
0.0466975197,
-0.0360954218,
0.0009184916,
0.0368922763,
0.0596853346,
-0.0884418339,
-0.024854634,
0.0716411844,
0.0057791341,
-0.0226442777,
0.0305260811,
-0.0283201542,
0.0199119654,
0.0238399729,
0.0608949326,
-0.0498422943,
-0.0022118015,
-0.0124714011,
0.0084391572,
0.0046570385,
-0.0299343932,
-0.0125774778,
-0.1254490316,
0.0738948807,
0.03968703,
-0.0791254267,
0.0052522165,
-0.0286842026,
0.008298547,
-0.0212762374,
0.0210269745,
-0.0015954577,
0.0002815932,
-0.0093422197,
0.0313392803,
0.01318321,
-0.0602409169,
0.0297298767,
-0.0018899096,
0.0940193981,
0.0636780709,
0.0157567225,
-0.0068416293,
-0.0339642167,
0.047167033,
0.0014027531,
0.0081728529,
-0.0080089374,
0.0429073572,
-0.0243367162,
-0.0290234704,
0.0107301334,
0.0304847211,
0.0135796247,
-0.0449603684,
0.0034469357,
0.0825374648,
-0.005908085,
0.0040897736,
-0.0007636214,
-0.0244399216,
0.0514865816,
0.0595938414,
-0.0140765859,
-0.0659416467,
-0.0115967626,
-0.021674931,
-0.0676174983,
-0.026517218,
-0.0643604025,
-0.0248363987,
-0.0113096917,
-0.0156427082,
-0.0562526658,
-0.0441771522,
0.0293682758,
0.0315368921,
0.0018432282,
0.0074607553,
0.0004417386,
0.0075511984,
-0.0035990828,
0.0063108671,
-0.0616623797,
0.0164698884,
-0.0602578446,
-0.0369964652,
-0.0264360905,
-0.0733568892,
-0.0001466736,
-0.0232072342,
-0.0071720285,
-0.0544637106,
-0.0152524458,
0.0865398422,
0.0205819756,
0.0404447392,
0.0239407364,
-0.0742549598,
0.0519187525,
0.0172220916,
-0.0527572408,
0.0214324314,
0.0290723182,
0.0070958934,
0.0190474149,
0.0141789997,
-0.0318315886,
0.0343824551,
0.0300090406,
0.0669449717,
0.0058135744,
0.0014873855,
0.0004129808,
-0.002081051,
-0.01555942,
-0.0345862694,
-0.0139279999,
-0.0354573093,
-0.0137511529,
-0.0210948251,
0.0006484112,
-0.0440066829,
0.026596915,
0.0469641797,
0.0106788399,
0.0454304367,
-0.0063240007,
-0.0240775347,
-0.0159551259,
-0.0299531035,
0.0302319378,
0.0111883869,
0.0381507091,
0.0227825493,
0.0364948586,
0.0277502462,
-0.0080684945,
-0.0086478535,
0.0217970647,
0.016712375,
0.0238457117,
0.0476374589,
-0.0379816182,
-0.0419382304,
0.0269857384,
-0.0381370895,
-0.0506323166,
0.0190213788,
0.0314173251,
0.0565200113,
-0.0109298099,
0.0489010289,
-0.0488678925,
-0.0020672374,
0.00582649,
-0.0049274615,
0.0315801762,
-0.0493548922,
0.0240307972,
0.0470938832,
-0.0053076711,
-0.0290526524,
0.0545445718,
0.0083145089,
0.0578550249,
-0.0271966271,
0.0118969101,
-0.0492276847,
-0.0250909347,
0.0369141437,
0.0161018819,
-0.0331525765,
0.0133117884,
-0.0415997952,
-0.0342314653,
-0.0520112067,
0.0477299727,
-0.0194512755,
-0.0320287272,
0.0221698377,
0.0351851061,
-0.0236396566,
-0.0149593595,
-0.0269433632,
-0.0362972096,
-0.0118600689,
-0.0229208916,
-0.0185765978,
-5.96949386e-33,
-0.047050897,
-0.0121391229,
0.0810849145,
0.0419461541,
-0.0293100253,
-0.0166269634,
-0.0507821254,
-0.0133100022,
0.0083978791,
0.0130324466,
-0.0045714094,
-0.0025571347,
0.0020530196,
-0.0169008784,
0.035301134,
-0.0060401517,
0.0448134765,
0.0081285173,
-0.1023559496,
0.0400075838,
0.0305481851,
0.0075587309,
0.1048521399,
-0.0902875215,
-0.001630393,
0.0462406464,
-0.0250685215,
0.0206673741,
0.001620853,
0.0429081172,
0.0050910544,
0.0222806502,
-0.0022378163,
-0.0845400095,
-0.0212633628,
0.0004179811,
-0.0480751432,
-0.03696163,
0.034995582,
-0.024672322,
-0.0201193728,
-0.0601124354,
0.0064116488,
0.0172719192,
-0.0453948379,
-0.0060568629,
0.0374264084,
-0.0475327931,
-0.016982073,
0.0355319642,
-0.077844426,
0.0052071493,
-0.0058888579,
-0.0463183708,
-0.0091092279,
0.0108069545,
-0.0362455286,
-0.0284752697,
-0.0502500348,
0.0728022829,
0.032318823,
0.0304644126,
0.0620018728,
0.0451512411,
0.0333860181,
0.0404496193,
0.0388916247,
-0.0014112248,
0.017241437,
-0.012463253,
0.0558072999,
0.020953266,
0.0061761201,
0.0269478317,
0.0164656565,
-0.0473766513,
-0.041715838,
0.0321922563,
0.008778506,
0.0693000257,
0.0138262762,
0.0321064405,
-0.0223629288,
-0.0292824991,
-0.0074957199,
0.0249026883,
0.0183418151,
-0.0417841896,
0.0571795404,
-0.0003977931,
-0.0041280938,
-0.0509357639,
0.0317702144,
-0.0224914327,
-0.0165430438,
0.0498716272,
-0.0552098937,
0.018772671,
0.0042565758,
-0.0262452271,
-0.0947584361,
-0.0403480344,
0.0248887595,
0.0100520952,
0.0068914983,
0.0353635438,
0.004909338,
0.0910895616,
-0.0323509723,
0.0013969786,
-0.0311909914,
0.0216266904,
0.0347478762,
0.0199562237,
0.0152283106,
-0.0410341918,
-0.0047739968,
0.0221199598,
-0.0006392719,
-0.0955062583,
-0.0083196284,
0.0477108397,
-0.0129731363,
0.0149423238,
-0.0280615222,
0.0194693841,
-0.0620485581,
0.0205114037,
-0.0009120497,
-0.0497804396,
-0.0177942757,
-0.0296359304,
2.959e-7,
-0.0146779623,
0.0478787571,
-0.0224257801,
0.0201051999,
-0.0056525851,
0.0372930057,
-0.0545285866,
0.0108620254,
0.0362000875,
0.0091295233,
0.0250317287,
0.0619497597,
0.0251900684,
-0.0158777498,
-0.0545783937,
-0.0257912856,
-0.039265655,
-0.0172170456,
-0.0253368318,
-0.0100750653,
0.0331847072,
0.021166889,
0.0352288894,
-0.025649406,
0.0277379118,
-0.0349090174,
0.0502488054,
-0.0492661819,
-0.0079001905,
0.0182720814,
-0.0328683071,
0.0159160942,
-0.0270277169,
0.0057851775,
-0.0101044662,
0.0262189377,
-0.0199121684,
0.0796875283,
-0.0307100099,
0.0115358969,
-0.0293961894,
0.0427040197,
-0.0091325669,
-0.0252269395,
0.0438639373,
-0.0485235788,
-0.023106074,
-0.0320678316,
-0.0123271355,
-0.0319002569,
-0.052602578,
-0.0321932882,
-0.0325359739,
-0.0087014139,
0.0068204608,
0.0429848395,
-0.033713907,
-0.0561558343,
-0.0212249495,
0.0192181654,
-0.0277079474,
-0.0687771812,
-0.0419734381,
0.0164182894,
-0.0115295677,
-0.058669515,
-0.0203121025,
2.873541629e-34,
-0.0065450929,
-0.0033211161,
0.0344056524,
0.0055143838,
0.0135877049,
0.0232849121,
0.0123415627,
0.0502330363,
0.0627037659,
-0.0279178917,
-0.0186208691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03242v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03242v1 | JOBSKAPE: A Framework for Generating Synthetic Job Postings to Enhance Skill Matching | 2024-02-05T17:57:26 | 2024-02-05T17:57:26 | Antoine Magron, Anna Dai, Mike Zhang, Syrielle Montariol, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent approaches in skill matching, employing synthetic training data for
classification or similarity model training, have shown promising results,
reducing the need for time-consuming and expensive annotations. However,
previous synthetic datasets have limitations, such as featuring only one skill
per sentence and generally comprising short sentences. In this paper, we
introduce JobSkape, a framework to generate synthetic data that tackles these
limitations, specifically designed to enhance skill-to-taxonomy matching.
Within this framework, we create SkillSkape, a comprehensive open-source
synthetic dataset of job postings tailored for skill-matching tasks. We
introduce several offline metrics that show that our dataset resembles
real-world data. Additionally, we present a multi-step pipeline for skill
extraction and matching tasks using large language models (LLMs), benchmarking
against known supervised methodologies. We outline that the downstream
evaluation results on real-world data can beat baselines, underscoring its
efficacy and adaptability. | [
0.0410896279,
0.0572763942,
-0.0105133094,
-0.0250224844,
-0.0118666524,
-0.0138066225,
0.0001410436,
0.0124593917,
0.0073848092,
-0.0324957408,
-0.0086731957,
0.0018610951,
-0.0120434556,
0.0003067238,
0.0276935063,
-0.0194172282,
-0.0006382148,
0.0327738225,
-0.056577377,
0.0405363292,
0.0067139138,
0.0952140614,
-0.0041020401,
0.0805867165,
-0.0059046955,
-0.0385765843,
0.0559355989,
-0.0201423615,
0.0456027128,
0.0251926277,
0.0387667604,
0.0032510012,
0.0146582602,
0.0024328991,
0.000001756,
-0.0017543888,
-0.0123101743,
0.0114095118,
-0.0106234858,
-0.0657795444,
0.0442375205,
-0.0179019645,
0.0204667188,
0.0585485771,
-0.0345590264,
-0.0437775254,
0.0350847282,
-0.0168104433,
0.0295125265,
0.050425604,
0.0071805208,
-0.0127138197,
-0.0162293073,
-0.029640073,
0.0207070485,
-0.0096704038,
0.0228956286,
-0.0170709193,
0.0237958077,
0.0179763027,
0.02796386,
-0.0029770408,
-0.0258538071,
-0.0675017312,
0.0492113791,
0.0150265805,
-0.0077826409,
0.0289317463,
0.0403793529,
0.0483368002,
-0.0470729508,
-0.0699523389,
-0.0151682338,
-0.0243616682,
0.0321249701,
0.0718520507,
-0.0205124822,
0.0151335485,
-0.0199223049,
0.0005870399,
-0.0215465538,
0.0114952214,
0.0005244172,
-0.0211475138,
0.058764413,
0.0461173356,
-0.0054581305,
-0.0452730209,
0.0228493754,
0.000972141,
0.0259878244,
-0.0539636537,
0.0225335695,
0.0242348071,
-0.0351461992,
-0.015694743,
-0.0487477444,
0.0126606207,
-0.0019411638,
-0.0406887904,
0.0043055722,
0.0248567555,
-0.0023587188,
0.0429622382,
-0.0208308659,
-0.0069767344,
0.0271432437,
0.0132658966,
-0.0724160522,
-0.0456623696,
-0.1046475992,
-0.0203983542,
-0.0307856407,
-0.0238640551,
-0.0000449432,
0.0256820172,
-0.0268122125,
-0.0091106575,
-0.0560281873,
0.0142083867,
0.0452197865,
0.0331059918,
-0.0328551643,
0.0431750938,
-0.0621872656,
-0.0250294991,
0.0172840338,
0.0251527876,
-0.0273406748,
0.0054140091,
0.0188570041,
0.020497594,
0.0165540725,
-0.0398922861,
0.0573046356,
0.0146281887,
0.0212379899,
0.0371203683,
-0.0001060083,
-0.0279245488,
0.020861052,
-0.0081918854,
-0.0293117687,
-0.0328812599,
0.0579231903,
-0.0337422937,
-0.0173360165,
-0.0389061272,
0.0198747478,
0.0600604229,
-0.0338506661,
0.0609260537,
-0.0101872282,
0.043530345,
0.0276229344,
-0.0253563132,
-0.0208481494,
0.0052135661,
0.0076750536,
0.0058937767,
0.0116629507,
-0.0342571437,
0.0726728961,
0.0461383611,
-0.0274652913,
-0.0409651846,
0.0058064428,
0.049713511,
0.0495558716,
0.0606042705,
0.098862201,
-0.0570518449,
-0.0029739123,
0.0247056596,
0.0200056694,
0.0738506243,
0.0419666618,
-0.0029695951,
0.0888606831,
0.0775973052,
-0.0156168044,
-0.0465000495,
-0.0239163935,
0.0278599281,
0.0242193993,
-0.0127752759,
-0.0345978104,
0.0335317813,
-0.0469156392,
0.0284961313,
0.004973514,
-0.0007148499,
-0.0420701727,
0.037843734,
0.0018466009,
0.0187068544,
-0.023649957,
0.0394234397,
0.0246003848,
-0.0198958293,
0.0144518074,
-0.0334630683,
-0.0471405163,
0.1109132841,
0.0474403203,
-0.0175740253,
-0.0351296254,
-0.0473108031,
-0.0039267889,
0.0297022313,
0.0260198079,
-0.0499587022,
-0.018691767,
-0.0290194862,
-0.0251407307,
-0.0025349609,
-0.0100210486,
-0.0032864804,
0.0229016077,
0.0227280874,
0.0291907433,
-0.0160145834,
-0.0548331626,
0.0520792156,
-0.0036812217,
-0.0325984657,
0.0437249616,
0.0151292607,
-0.0140856681,
0.0034347374,
-0.0061438507,
0.0146506382,
-0.0011723663,
-0.0236189887,
-0.0060026837,
0.0365491845,
-0.0008080642,
0.0063816467,
0.0145852929,
-0.0383501314,
-0.0535200164,
0.0385288186,
-0.0463300832,
0.0098057017,
-0.0321440212,
0.0214313995,
-0.0056069246,
-0.0204348564,
0.0033447875,
-0.0249246787,
-0.0140593378,
-0.0155312475,
0.0564448498,
0.0766170099,
0.0293489881,
-0.0562126078,
-0.0150070088,
0.0016591358,
-0.0926932693,
0.0117830336,
-0.0649279729,
0.0006089281,
0.0632277206,
0.0173927061,
0.0154308965,
-0.0135344127,
-0.0209788829,
-0.0580965988,
0.0476320423,
0.0313164815,
-0.0028450235,
0.0438609049,
-0.0335539505,
-0.012901702,
-0.0225597341,
-0.0792161524,
-0.0332911983,
0.0301973913,
-0.0322931036,
0.0272161625,
-0.0211134516,
-0.0179665908,
-0.0232697763,
0.0036124433,
-0.0326832198,
0.0231468659,
0.0287807751,
0.0353919528,
-0.061375428,
0.0408905745,
-0.0115187941,
0.0213832315,
0.0281485412,
-0.0157906543,
-0.0277352687,
0.0174102206,
-0.0285922922,
0.0166738182,
-0.0039489847,
-0.042850472,
0.0582915917,
0.03461143,
-0.011362223,
0.0031047263,
-0.0230063796,
-0.0001953511,
-0.0234574787,
-0.0478497408,
-0.0037266684,
0.0065069455,
0.0125438785,
-0.0316876434,
-0.0377927162,
0.0174034908,
0.0095879603,
0.0299745016,
-0.0596173815,
0.0225650128,
0.0131422617,
0.0028994046,
-0.0351944529,
-0.0076599284,
0.022108769,
-0.0160096418,
0.0315379202,
-0.0229239333,
-0.0742986426,
-0.056924805,
0.0365454592,
-0.0255268011,
0.0073870043,
-0.0344356522,
0.0120492829,
-0.025895685,
0.022454353,
0.0225359201,
-0.0256407522,
-0.0550910123,
-0.0181207713,
0.0197638236,
0.022783896,
-0.0265473444,
-0.047539331,
-0.0203996506,
0.0077109258,
0.0319136865,
0.0374975912,
0.0029962356,
-0.0478898957,
-0.0213205311,
-0.0342242457,
0.0622678213,
0.0230239108,
-0.0190695841,
-0.0120792044,
0.0330838077,
0.069030866,
0.0420734063,
-0.0793933421,
0.0001133123,
-0.042527806,
0.0023684453,
0.0140851187,
0.0283205789,
-0.0084968479,
-0.0230444241,
0.047672946,
-0.0812403932,
0.0242219828,
0.0071824756,
-0.0250267275,
-0.0383143201,
0.0055920365,
0.0838544443,
0.0161667336,
-0.0391022116,
0.0066434811,
0.0174421184,
-0.0624995194,
0.0428124517,
0.0886528194,
-0.0481033623,
0.0093295807,
-0.0204652343,
0.0452252887,
0.0024811986,
-0.0185656548,
-0.0193828698,
-0.1283364445,
0.0606296211,
-0.0203394406,
-0.04612137,
-0.0358150601,
-0.0530438535,
-0.0127444249,
-0.0434313081,
-0.029105885,
-0.0286995657,
-0.0377788022,
0.0096731847,
0.0464051478,
-0.002682711,
-0.0905952826,
0.0782050863,
-0.0657635033,
0.0644269809,
0.0316562466,
0.0519750193,
0.0101286909,
-0.0168947522,
0.0106815565,
0.0361474492,
-0.0059421682,
0.0407119282,
0.0509739444,
-0.0620478094,
-0.0232581496,
0.0042289798,
0.0079007139,
-0.028314447,
0.0119071463,
0.0423808768,
0.0627695769,
-0.0027933943,
0.013102212,
-0.0233566966,
-0.0192188043,
0.0254008844,
0.109352693,
-0.0197713226,
-0.0649465322,
-0.0042443923,
-0.0032480857,
0.0054462575,
-0.0025145968,
-0.0543654971,
0.0378564522,
-0.0296367891,
0.0127696069,
-0.0314882398,
-0.0464310758,
0.0623387918,
-0.0049460446,
0.024077259,
0.0089376951,
-0.0227013025,
-0.0211916212,
-0.0931289643,
0.0529926904,
-0.0234214868,
0.0695844814,
-0.045766253,
-0.0362360775,
-0.0162099395,
-0.0568876266,
-0.0605942458,
-0.0454215221,
-0.0851783231,
0.0182116814,
-0.0489254147,
-0.0162329618,
0.0093565639,
0.0624242276,
-0.0259969886,
-0.0448475964,
-0.0166527666,
0.0766169131,
-0.0645475239,
-0.0157884508,
-0.0373840407,
-0.0074581234,
0.0034701519,
0.0085090073,
-0.057634078,
0.0226792544,
0.0293358229,
-0.0174045954,
0.0242418032,
-0.0160966776,
0.0145921195,
-0.0030343069,
0.0005751686,
0.0299104489,
-0.0051109591,
-0.0933104903,
-0.0123427194,
0.0114351856,
-0.045508597,
-0.0325827934,
0.0016975959,
0.0893158317,
0.0142532503,
0.0487490706,
0.0307751372,
-0.0146034732,
0.0294015761,
-0.0716344938,
-0.0059073414,
-0.0417506769,
0.031836994,
-0.0173557959,
0.0005205022,
-0.02095972,
-0.0264380556,
0.0030924147,
0.0464891717,
-0.0001217772,
-0.0228033345,
-0.0044891699,
0.018026676,
0.0051074605,
0.0229820292,
-0.0161478259,
-0.0680198073,
-0.039959345,
0.0419513993,
0.0673320368,
-0.0945493579,
0.003585035,
-0.0096344985,
-0.0158065911,
-0.007024216,
-0.0051533459,
0.0256295968,
0.0056932378,
0.0030329956,
0.0044469698,
-0.0203197449,
-0.0224238895,
0.0509147979,
0.0173252635,
0.0513540916,
-0.0330915377,
-0.0646980032,
-0.0208908301,
0.0106630865,
0.0491950549,
0.0291766394,
-0.0247851349,
0.0027523427,
-0.0342563316,
-0.0367704928,
-0.0101183737,
0.0005551132,
-0.0467918776,
0.0213148948,
0.0310879257,
0.0560607389,
-0.0176635757,
0.0060286517,
-0.0403430536,
-0.0505688749,
0.015790401,
0.0080191158,
-0.0513046421,
-5.198799356e-33,
-0.0118284216,
-0.0351755358,
0.0412186235,
0.0209428929,
0.0261797234,
0.0141659509,
0.0738465339,
-0.0486510582,
-0.0025808441,
0.0039817798,
-0.0005046156,
0.0031964078,
0.0026727312,
-0.0097978106,
0.0518064648,
0.0293419976,
0.055033002,
0.0056316615,
0.0153642651,
0.0146655822,
0.0139470426,
0.0075538149,
0.0504947156,
-0.055127874,
-0.000792996,
-0.0185134802,
-0.0123192314,
0.0401809625,
0.0100501329,
0.0663061514,
-0.0182000957,
0.0143534411,
0.028431816,
-0.0103614815,
0.015373704,
0.0054794182,
-0.0227022991,
0.0055592139,
0.0095485123,
0.0027729734,
0.03347224,
-0.0326530933,
0.0076894388,
-0.006657097,
-0.0215925034,
-0.0215114951,
0.1033025607,
-0.0393132418,
0.0484998338,
0.0026634678,
-0.0161688142,
0.0051134974,
-0.0228773206,
-0.0366242304,
-0.0040953923,
0.0293799974,
-0.0070381332,
0.000948864,
-0.1056151018,
0.0261317771,
-0.0317082293,
0.0571701862,
0.0381528847,
-0.0074048508,
0.0013614506,
0.039704863,
0.0426064134,
0.007004003,
0.0416401923,
0.0080895498,
-0.0083820922,
0.0346952751,
0.0043686312,
0.0310332887,
0.0806107968,
-0.0196763184,
-0.0105811143,
0.0601825602,
-0.0078245997,
0.006047586,
-0.0065811491,
-0.003748633,
-0.0453685708,
-0.0237183776,
-0.0253711101,
0.0013614717,
-0.0289315954,
0.015927447,
0.0601304658,
0.0181554221,
0.0238219183,
0.0354829058,
-0.03803977,
-0.0346222483,
0.0301682334,
-0.0149158696,
-0.0581955351,
-0.023385888,
0.0205940586,
-0.0234417655,
-0.0660241544,
-0.058175981,
0.0228464548,
-0.0140592046,
0.0429648384,
0.0650028512,
0.0322932303,
0.0177394152,
-0.060262125,
0.0096957972,
-0.0159598347,
-0.0083555672,
-0.0561165139,
-0.0004040777,
0.0333622433,
0.0172613114,
0.017538432,
-0.0044606109,
0.0198049471,
-0.0232854262,
0.0195377506,
-0.0113541437,
0.0261078775,
0.0070087803,
0.0328818373,
0.0191667303,
-0.0339875557,
-0.0387707427,
-0.0057543078,
-0.0375459343,
-0.0153194768,
-0.0205282383,
2.304e-7,
0.0382747538,
-0.001933432,
-0.0415233225,
0.0428508595,
0.007490206,
-0.0224244837,
-0.0289702099,
0.0461371876,
-0.0004863318,
0.0469274335,
-0.0029496548,
0.0043472974,
0.0449968278,
-0.002207164,
-0.0672394037,
-0.008027724,
-0.0408040844,
-0.0243157838,
-0.0761452764,
-0.010317157,
0.0487924404,
0.0491702072,
0.0584714971,
-0.0266568549,
0.0018767046,
-0.0425285324,
0.0343343392,
-0.0106891207,
0.0029767139,
0.0589337572,
0.0035475614,
0.0253041741,
-0.0304727722,
0.0587256327,
-0.0318195485,
0.0395224057,
0.0823496208,
0.0322904028,
-0.0500743426,
0.0677634776,
-0.0151223307,
-0.0063537718,
-0.0282523185,
-0.0415972322,
0.0341132283,
-0.0541859716,
0.0113563202,
-0.0464933999,
-0.0499879494,
0.0179895032,
-0.0141154593,
0.0214073416,
-0.0160287339,
-0.0209063478,
0.0440693125,
-0.0132153137,
-0.0887437463,
-0.0243639182,
0.0125130787,
0.0320329033,
-0.025883263,
-0.0574680679,
0.0156169729,
-0.0031034772,
0.0415327512,
-0.0312696286,
0.0033010191,
1.908413471e-34,
-0.0034714309,
0.073740527,
0.0073275859,
-0.0163761377,
0.0083165755,
-0.0008864671,
0.0212387871,
0.0188395958,
-0.0115255434,
-0.007853969,
-0.0127902878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03223v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03223v4 | English Prompts are Better for NLI-based Zero-Shot Emotion Classification than Target-Language Prompts | 2024-02-05T17:36:19 | 2024-03-07T17:18:18 | Patrick Bareiß, Roman Klinger, Jeremy Barnes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion classification in text is a challenging task due to the processes
involved when interpreting a textual description of a potential emotion
stimulus. In addition, the set of emotion categories is highly domain-specific.
For instance, literature analysis might require the use of aesthetic emotions
(e.g., finding something beautiful), and social media analysis could benefit
from fine-grained sets (e.g., separating anger from annoyance) than only those
that represent basic categories as they have been proposed by Paul Ekman
(anger, disgust, fear, joy, surprise, sadness). This renders the task an
interesting field for zero-shot classifications, in which the label set is not
known at model development time. Unfortunately, most resources for emotion
analysis are English, and therefore, most studies on emotion analysis have been
performed in English, including those that involve prompting language models
for text labels. This leaves us with a research gap that we address in this
paper: In which language should we prompt for emotion labels on non-English
texts? This is particularly of interest when we have access to a multilingual
large language model, because we could request labels with English prompts even
for non-English data. Our experiments with natural language inference-based
language models show that it is consistently better to use English prompts even
if the data is in a different language. | [
0.01932556,
0.0428874083,
0.0013678597,
0.0481359623,
-0.0331619941,
0.0441665314,
0.0699879229,
-0.0066750906,
0.045581691,
-0.0830114931,
-0.065958634,
-0.0301184505,
-0.0215543844,
-0.0238705706,
-0.0155146206,
-0.0557275414,
0.022283908,
0.0294731613,
0.0358913094,
-0.02499073,
0.0082117729,
0.0301448386,
-0.0112457601,
0.0101195546,
-0.0315529145,
-0.0252329297,
-0.0273553729,
0.0065494534,
0.0175104234,
-0.0404240564,
0.0237015188,
0.0699830502,
0.0006038153,
0.0232205689,
0.0000017779,
-0.0464385003,
0.0312408134,
-0.0124007305,
-0.0162510276,
-0.0626948476,
0.1110490337,
-0.0403605029,
-0.0149495909,
-0.0189020429,
0.0031012464,
-0.0607615151,
0.0767697394,
0.0584043674,
0.0192492362,
0.0754696056,
-0.0495807603,
-0.0276077576,
-0.0355377756,
-0.0017532647,
0.0350880027,
-0.0011488327,
0.0238917992,
-0.0460383072,
0.030631559,
0.0081755798,
-0.0266057868,
0.0050709462,
0.0073579634,
0.0237209983,
-0.0215052422,
0.0108813317,
-0.02963016,
-0.0435943417,
-0.010787298,
0.0395818576,
-0.0150540937,
-0.0102625182,
-0.0292586107,
-0.0018254562,
-0.0091464445,
-0.0214286353,
-0.0154668037,
0.0531453751,
-0.0073306798,
0.0247957781,
0.05620832,
0.0247652438,
-0.0087459339,
0.0365577266,
-0.0052982294,
0.0599195324,
-0.010691518,
-0.0091185104,
0.0683384016,
0.0314431787,
-0.0209856611,
-0.0479009748,
-0.0353330597,
-0.0114902509,
0.0209111013,
0.0178802479,
-0.0496097542,
-0.0178350974,
-0.0110959904,
-0.0279885605,
-0.0099931424,
0.0203707963,
-0.0325478688,
0.0313533954,
0.0371345654,
0.020262586,
0.0405676141,
-0.005549646,
-0.0374969356,
-0.0278567132,
-0.0550568439,
0.0333433412,
0.0084088733,
0.0367345959,
-0.0125417151,
-0.0135226259,
-0.0840934068,
-0.0099272523,
-0.0238528978,
0.0144333197,
-0.0061182673,
-0.0371182226,
0.0104049919,
0.0087946756,
-0.0031478191,
0.0640794262,
-0.0407569744,
0.0183794368,
-0.0160416365,
-0.0784862936,
0.0137593178,
0.0270600338,
-0.0116078472,
-0.0414094478,
0.0157210529,
0.0391186774,
0.0060762996,
-0.0354276113,
-0.0551502667,
-0.0098722652,
-0.031500686,
-0.0529038645,
0.0162047986,
-0.0344938636,
0.0238603503,
0.0060254526,
0.0241896156,
-0.037286289,
0.0131774601,
-0.0062867105,
-0.0306026004,
0.0797656626,
-0.0241276231,
-0.0272639357,
-0.0291397683,
-0.0021154033,
-0.0087195234,
0.0646976829,
-0.0307957046,
0.0404361337,
0.0677708909,
0.0085579082,
0.031826064,
0.0315162987,
-0.0182550009,
-0.0118328324,
-0.0537801124,
-0.0511161946,
0.0100390986,
-0.0120409727,
0.0299259257,
-0.0118056992,
-0.0322516598,
0.0080526285,
0.0144137954,
0.0753450766,
-0.029145265,
-0.0079462212,
0.0106590912,
0.0099928621,
-0.0103157684,
-0.020027725,
-0.0148773305,
0.015731493,
-0.0560927279,
-0.0055734608,
-0.0138432868,
-0.012292875,
-0.0593373775,
-0.0404598899,
-0.0307112224,
-0.0502564535,
-0.0047971541,
0.0112314671,
0.0627854466,
-0.0109223966,
-0.0060133659,
-0.0293724798,
0.0399844721,
-0.0751774982,
-0.0202725735,
-0.0196244307,
0.0252344105,
0.0380313359,
-0.0020364588,
-0.0352346972,
-0.0190901887,
-0.0207188632,
0.0167762041,
0.0540679619,
0.0196804442,
-0.010170768,
0.0184844099,
-0.0439094305,
0.0059231655,
0.002585114,
0.0200043935,
0.01350246,
-0.0477659665,
0.0654560253,
-0.0239370782,
0.0040917881,
-0.0274693631,
-0.0008724798,
-0.0164377671,
-0.0461455174,
0.0220585521,
0.0323136263,
0.0122038396,
0.0239594299,
-0.0185244903,
-0.0365862921,
0.0119564403,
-0.0261014607,
-0.0014496841,
0.0047247442,
0.026047688,
-0.0715543702,
0.0216148514,
-0.0033178064,
-0.0012719349,
0.0005828935,
-0.0507320873,
-0.0225669779,
0.0288486406,
0.0303766858,
-0.0184643753,
-0.0208012369,
0.0183949992,
-0.0309579503,
0.0255251992,
-0.0097337281,
0.0452329069,
0.0166109167,
0.0485314578,
0.0076241465,
-0.0266089104,
0.0271589253,
-0.0163721759,
-0.0843280181,
0.0514207557,
0.0219605751,
-0.0053329444,
0.0285545122,
-0.0010483211,
-0.0393713862,
-0.0186281744,
-0.0695783868,
0.0087806704,
0.0016864458,
0.0185578521,
-0.0211785454,
0.0076764799,
-0.0416657627,
0.0153340958,
-0.0469097905,
0.0073939604,
0.0062805358,
0.0402963087,
0.0020724924,
-0.0296078287,
0.0228725504,
-0.0198433306,
0.0126765333,
-0.0231898036,
0.057885021,
-0.007531275,
-0.0312067736,
-0.0082393,
0.0412454791,
-0.0610231645,
0.0233861227,
0.006288196,
-0.0532070957,
0.0159045272,
0.0072811185,
0.0065086875,
0.0452670418,
-0.0446671769,
0.0727846175,
0.0284015629,
-0.0007264371,
-0.0367329381,
0.0189638883,
-0.013550831,
-0.0177376643,
0.0053744158,
-0.0254695248,
-0.0141275469,
0.078352347,
-0.0032780077,
-0.0088278083,
-0.0427717045,
0.0404071435,
-0.0321043991,
-0.0311486088,
-0.0463394448,
0.0157205723,
0.0283654034,
0.0480361208,
0.0098377932,
-0.0162333641,
0.0395660661,
0.0310219564,
-0.0226895064,
-0.0883130059,
0.0016072511,
-0.0234756023,
0.0502654016,
-0.032006409,
0.0237050075,
0.0534842424,
0.0313215442,
-0.0054992116,
-0.0306759868,
-0.0239400081,
-0.0139742289,
0.002875072,
-0.01422635,
-0.028940117,
-0.0117487162,
-0.0237239376,
-0.0303239319,
-0.0442272946,
-0.0631070808,
0.0038644026,
-0.0348515622,
0.0011049091,
-0.0078865364,
-0.012688118,
0.0395326316,
-0.0414450876,
-0.0274253078,
-0.0199002363,
0.02758459,
0.0376419127,
0.0547184423,
-0.0350589789,
-0.0099915424,
-0.0023552629,
0.0381913297,
0.0398898385,
0.0212986935,
0.0419141464,
0.0079629635,
0.0320855007,
0.0541615635,
0.0045108474,
-0.0571278855,
-0.0156241357,
0.0045963535,
0.0030645812,
0.0239158589,
0.1385422796,
0.049217537,
-0.0735986233,
-0.0023830328,
-0.0624742769,
0.02010368,
0.0341428556,
0.0206260849,
-0.0818181038,
-0.0403765254,
-0.024877755,
0.0031922862,
-0.033243563,
-0.0102441357,
-0.0037969027,
-0.1299764812,
0.0340873413,
0.0024574439,
-0.0263760593,
0.0154183973,
-0.0291060228,
0.0315715559,
-0.0057883882,
-0.0313985646,
-0.0703614876,
0.0353041962,
-0.0093674725,
0.0254578628,
0.0292031746,
-0.0948940739,
0.0091364812,
-0.0187395997,
0.052475445,
-0.006906298,
0.0682481453,
-0.0128936712,
-0.0384072065,
0.0412317477,
-0.0239883382,
-0.0073915734,
-0.0459532999,
0.0566005781,
-0.0092437901,
-0.0143775195,
-0.0266914237,
0.0223534517,
-0.0342513248,
-0.0070799734,
-0.0216728654,
0.0703673586,
-0.0110574979,
-0.0130501352,
-0.0332040414,
-0.0034108534,
0.0249829479,
0.0682484582,
0.0188701991,
-0.0802866444,
-0.0304759648,
-0.0341800936,
0.0041256952,
0.0031902476,
-0.0475733019,
0.0305095166,
-0.0406120606,
-0.1057776585,
-0.0352026634,
-0.0722404495,
0.0354676954,
0.036618378,
0.0079280809,
-0.042165406,
-0.0252523348,
-0.013354985,
-0.0049772677,
0.014652092,
-0.000457141,
0.0103280526,
-0.0235067345,
0.0108262394,
0.0614406317,
-0.009719152,
0.0072868834,
-0.0344110131,
0.0112293391,
-0.0603555329,
-0.0082075326,
0.0316875353,
0.0154847195,
0.011791233,
-0.0054121776,
-0.0534634255,
0.0280506555,
0.063230902,
0.0473231077,
-0.0055850758,
0.0463048667,
0.068358399,
-0.0129653672,
0.0184952635,
-0.0204781126,
0.0871205181,
0.0278825834,
-0.0153312758,
-0.0098983413,
-0.0596633554,
-0.0098279137,
0.0259455405,
0.0531239733,
-0.0040854933,
-0.0403210297,
-0.0133886589,
-0.037824057,
-0.0239438079,
-0.0390012562,
-0.0180162452,
-0.0587739274,
0.0042209974,
-0.0035712172,
-0.0620122291,
-0.0220531896,
-0.0486494042,
0.0155159924,
-0.0258352775,
0.0144183934,
0.0829450414,
0.0336843394,
-0.0522263199,
0.0434896201,
-0.0221279636,
-0.0095622661,
0.0189800952,
0.0152915623,
-0.0386331119,
0.080844596,
0.0173519459,
-0.0040814555,
-0.0006669158,
0.0393676572,
0.0155508909,
0.0424129665,
0.0360872336,
-0.0033380741,
0.047036998,
-0.0618444309,
0.0460782275,
-0.0376904681,
0.0109322825,
-0.0044489289,
0.0252030827,
0.0011222042,
-0.0896253288,
0.0394876599,
0.0067024282,
-0.0106692631,
-0.0227929838,
0.0526210032,
-0.0326387994,
0.0290598962,
0.034332525,
-0.001300494,
-0.0359287858,
0.0479433723,
0.0585653447,
-0.0441373587,
0.0219304655,
0.0564655364,
-0.092129685,
-0.0722544268,
0.042179171,
-0.057092946,
-0.0088584209,
-0.0136330035,
0.0179852843,
0.0394678004,
-0.0085067395,
0.0424832515,
-0.0424632505,
0.0270343032,
-0.0600075014,
-0.0480676405,
-0.0476235077,
-5.453505472e-33,
0.0037400646,
0.0061088135,
-0.0407677703,
0.0012819801,
-0.012724991,
0.0204809513,
-0.0176507663,
0.027306417,
-0.0096433228,
0.0529794395,
-0.0195151549,
-0.0097977947,
0.0068505323,
0.0059131146,
0.0234084558,
-0.0354510397,
0.002921629,
-0.0125806807,
-0.0147055816,
-0.001845565,
0.0420194417,
-0.0038893782,
0.0835761502,
-0.0470018983,
0.0610799417,
-0.0028485279,
-0.0028808049,
0.0099143004,
0.1024568304,
0.0483555309,
-0.0059124217,
0.1049404442,
0.0370429009,
-0.0153609375,
0.033522591,
0.0302607659,
0.0002920319,
-0.0591688715,
-0.0068768086,
0.0292596165,
0.0020619838,
-0.0408882685,
-0.0252141543,
0.0226019137,
-0.0508944318,
0.0036700978,
0.0264038667,
-0.0217886381,
0.0176117495,
-0.0447661653,
-0.0511362813,
-0.0011663324,
0.0063906712,
-0.024509646,
0.0763686597,
0.1048334017,
0.0004471191,
0.0291951094,
-0.0378393419,
0.0374133363,
0.0061124349,
0.0067956415,
0.042371694,
-0.0102940109,
0.0071792756,
0.0676304474,
0.0386814848,
0.0435333662,
-0.024389714,
0.0453749821,
0.0477463901,
-0.009219368,
0.0232298858,
0.0801878124,
0.0220424421,
0.0088876691,
-0.0358347706,
0.0503374077,
0.0345357507,
0.006662596,
0.0322618261,
0.0024448654,
-0.0189296789,
-0.0352677666,
0.0030413449,
-0.0490728319,
-0.0490929559,
-0.0155178299,
0.0262601227,
-0.0579411387,
0.0114511745,
-0.0151833929,
0.0258718319,
-0.0090873353,
-0.0390631631,
0.0545374192,
-0.017365614,
0.0966497138,
0.0046710367,
0.0177024789,
-0.0287129097,
-0.0302122217,
0.0089244228,
0.0303467475,
0.0600567795,
0.026454743,
0.0267613549,
0.0329341926,
-0.0383190401,
-0.0296938121,
-0.0347802006,
0.0416715369,
-0.0075798412,
0.0420229845,
-0.0335684158,
0.0292387083,
-0.0093841078,
0.0331934951,
0.0423342995,
-0.0128670605,
0.0140268365,
-0.0067161149,
-0.0211647041,
0.0109273111,
-0.0629035532,
-0.0001527419,
0.0120644746,
-0.0073304134,
0.0089179762,
-0.0363954529,
-0.0150193041,
-0.022458585,
2.533e-7,
-0.005899461,
0.0291033238,
-0.0174911674,
-0.0091464296,
0.0198067669,
0.0739987046,
-0.0219284426,
0.027310051,
0.0356573723,
-0.0144369481,
-0.000135545,
-0.0096124206,
0.0414680243,
0.0144080631,
-0.1003419012,
0.0091771018,
0.0214649644,
0.0549605712,
-0.0365328416,
0.0704621077,
0.0918822214,
0.078608714,
0.0279362835,
0.0073676603,
-0.0207014214,
0.0332031175,
0.0308776908,
-0.0315046757,
-0.0035113539,
0.0108682672,
0.0241400301,
-0.0212678276,
0.0038193963,
0.0210672691,
0.0136571145,
-0.0221344493,
0.0194730721,
0.0064351615,
-0.0241098851,
-0.0181231573,
0.0178439673,
0.0187912825,
-0.0401080586,
-0.0203180909,
0.0573063083,
-0.0476591401,
-0.0475596413,
-0.0215162598,
-0.0196431801,
0.0034338536,
0.0576860681,
-0.0342155695,
-0.0550433621,
0.0297485292,
0.0430495627,
-0.0138315577,
-0.0374145098,
-0.0278875548,
-0.0074600177,
0.0080867773,
0.0008646837,
0.0178883094,
0.0045127128,
0.0458505787,
0.0087564373,
-0.0595159978,
0.0188768804,
1.930991228e-34,
-0.0019102676,
-0.0103856334,
-0.0139782354,
0.0379116796,
0.0093694096,
0.0130703282,
-0.0398013219,
-0.0075798091,
0.0408892184,
-0.0577049255,
0.0138242226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03221v1 | "Define Your Terms" : Enhancing Efficient Offensive Speech Classification with Definition | 2024-02-05T17:33:22 | 2024-02-05T17:33:22 | Huy Nghiem, Umang Gupta, Fred Morstatter | cs.CL | cs.CL | The propagation of offensive content through social media channels has
garnered attention of the research community. Multiple works have proposed
various semantically related yet subtle distinct categories of offensive
speech. In this work, we explore meta-earning approaches to leverage the
diversity of offensive speech corpora to enhance their reliable and efficient
detection. We propose a joint embedding architecture that incorporates the
input's label and definition for classification via Prototypical Network. Our
model achieves at least 75% of the maximal F1-score while using less than 10%
of the available training data across 4 datasets. Our experimental findings
also provide a case study of training strategies valuable to combat resource
scarcity. | [
0.0385249853,
0.0385740474,
-0.0047485591,
0.041149132,
0.0053280238,
0.0084798513,
0.0278680176,
-0.0149801513,
-0.0533800274,
-0.0579779558,
-0.029662326,
0.0160137564,
-0.0308408234,
0.0619910136,
0.0008565446,
-0.0421746597,
0.0309639685,
0.0418720245,
0.0085970592,
-0.0190379545,
0.0347139873,
-0.012565772,
0.0061612912,
0.0309834089,
-0.0519804135,
0.0023994187,
0.0367058329,
0.0052020825,
0.0451305807,
0.0078825587,
0.0444494858,
0.0318058357,
0.0148623772,
0.1065409556,
0.0000019233,
-0.0260988288,
0.0213447083,
0.0013484427,
-0.0472375974,
-0.0413296781,
0.065758273,
0.0202065259,
-0.0313753076,
0.0416048616,
-0.0115458686,
-0.0280039832,
0.0890302882,
0.047249265,
0.0497535616,
0.0308190789,
-0.0023553947,
-0.0587823279,
0.0123882852,
-0.0197103359,
-0.0067827781,
0.010610465,
0.0092145279,
-0.0726623237,
-0.0771513432,
-0.0087682297,
-0.0287254378,
0.0206144135,
0.0634216219,
0.0192885865,
0.0261944868,
0.0212993864,
-0.0308979247,
-0.0098789819,
0.0020106758,
0.058908727,
-0.0547450259,
0.0133420676,
-0.0299177021,
0.0018566041,
0.0191772282,
-0.0100522209,
-0.0167913139,
0.0064345901,
-0.0055112112,
0.0134436181,
-0.0474202111,
0.0500810966,
0.054222364,
0.0821496099,
0.0178487208,
-0.0134976078,
-0.0344507098,
-0.0387507007,
0.0309867319,
-0.0373243541,
-0.0289836936,
0.0386218429,
0.0254040752,
-0.0159199331,
-0.0070417062,
0.0158752892,
-0.0329279415,
-0.0540661812,
0.0123368138,
-0.0753107294,
0.0346010216,
0.0088823996,
-0.0548611656,
0.0190889724,
0.012737561,
-0.0066565322,
-0.0069589945,
0.0251058489,
-0.0176660288,
0.0081210183,
-0.0597922392,
-0.0190242175,
-0.0331680886,
0.0142889954,
0.0432282723,
0.0174982902,
-0.0626325682,
-0.0069579063,
-0.0623094216,
-0.0139633352,
0.0066063497,
0.0326064155,
-0.0217698794,
0.0140333818,
0.0055817757,
-0.0251837969,
-0.0484885946,
0.0169219766,
0.0106385695,
-0.0363534577,
0.0049572107,
0.0128237829,
-0.0375935063,
-0.0186531674,
0.0341211408,
0.0514918081,
0.0382165387,
-0.0565528385,
-0.0236432031,
-0.0270774662,
-0.0237971451,
-0.0305057261,
-0.004480368,
-0.0793858394,
0.0043399162,
-0.0623462573,
-0.0310841128,
-0.0265249927,
-0.0186294671,
-0.0015303673,
-0.0357112959,
0.0778747052,
-0.0147123253,
-0.0276941806,
0.0363996737,
0.0412481502,
-0.0208897591,
0.085989885,
0.0513373315,
0.0439123139,
0.0689833835,
-0.0115272822,
-0.008382583,
0.0429293513,
0.0393718332,
-0.012837518,
-0.0243597049,
-0.0253752284,
-0.0259429868,
0.0044314936,
0.0115247658,
0.003578851,
-0.023553187,
-0.0749841332,
0.0404821374,
0.0786860287,
-0.0257001445,
0.0284133703,
0.0637197196,
0.0197923519,
-0.0226337742,
-0.0669298172,
-0.0487065613,
0.012530447,
0.0027302653,
-0.0491782911,
0.0369931273,
0.0734881982,
-0.0512803271,
-0.0554548353,
0.0179487299,
-0.0473286919,
-0.0008161959,
-0.0241657291,
0.0228728727,
0.0260925721,
0.0057535488,
-0.0054045538,
0.0391299054,
-0.0194027089,
0.0215445347,
-0.0436831564,
-0.0283170417,
0.0830174536,
0.0411985293,
-0.0317544788,
-0.0047840779,
-0.0921794623,
0.0193199106,
0.0578368381,
-0.003268155,
-0.03720925,
0.0297893565,
-0.050285764,
-0.0213063341,
0.0446454436,
0.012858022,
0.0251834169,
0.0259831641,
-0.0053202654,
0.0232676696,
-0.0203340296,
-0.0242152065,
0.0162998289,
0.0152386669,
-0.038446825,
0.0333467647,
0.0468794033,
0.0566422381,
0.0288581327,
-0.0299674701,
-0.0425171852,
0.0292072576,
-0.0369744077,
-0.0342349708,
0.0120280059,
-0.0198538844,
0.0038114013,
0.0382772908,
-0.0326923281,
-0.0063541899,
0.0585858338,
-0.0448552109,
0.0014348654,
0.0433083773,
-0.0070450734,
0.0047733653,
-0.0642997026,
-0.0463825464,
-0.0470739864,
0.0335760675,
-0.005844919,
0.0694118515,
-0.0323525369,
-0.0134941414,
0.0056673158,
-0.0509768464,
0.0249977298,
0.0119639924,
-0.0485388152,
0.0109822843,
-0.031008143,
0.0588439405,
-0.0187531337,
0.0017075764,
-0.0265000109,
-0.0252652243,
-0.0296607818,
0.0023749296,
-0.0144076617,
-0.0162167102,
0.0128837982,
-0.0043177172,
0.0126181105,
0.001025616,
0.0049794344,
-0.0181527194,
0.0241687037,
0.0470777862,
-0.0053713955,
-0.0372750424,
-0.0405088812,
-0.0082315309,
-0.0325153321,
-0.0020339442,
0.0444904007,
-0.0321257003,
0.0069868909,
0.0706104338,
-0.0587971061,
-0.0095865568,
0.0174671747,
-0.0059243017,
-0.0568167083,
0.0093251225,
0.0353903174,
-0.0433612876,
0.04472683,
0.0621833019,
0.0587231182,
0.0124451462,
0.0405966081,
-0.0481819175,
-0.0076849158,
-0.0166981723,
0.0188937336,
-0.0133785419,
0.0032147774,
-0.0487622321,
0.0583764352,
0.0177421682,
0.0151251061,
-0.0525127575,
0.0544166826,
-0.0106233703,
-0.0674176663,
-0.0589701235,
-0.0204497781,
-0.0347410701,
-0.040630389,
-0.0515607819,
-0.0719764903,
0.0826045945,
0.0310596135,
0.0136896838,
0.0147767197,
-0.0262688324,
0.0155813005,
0.0295054745,
-0.0127531402,
0.0445722826,
0.0082322834,
-0.0065793707,
-0.022294946,
-0.0342466459,
0.0287741162,
-0.0576320067,
0.0087369578,
0.0414816439,
-0.0047560204,
0.0160256755,
-0.0490217693,
-0.0701483414,
-0.0380678736,
0.0017695817,
0.0024958353,
-0.0495240837,
0.0140923997,
-0.0288859624,
0.0071277297,
0.0162263326,
-0.0091247121,
-0.0002046524,
0.0025886414,
0.0174853113,
-0.0060842121,
0.011394253,
0.0120348036,
0.0032468333,
0.0332199521,
0.0223510973,
0.0401249565,
0.0005906541,
-0.0075762984,
-0.0230254158,
0.02004073,
-0.0066535026,
-0.0168600623,
0.0111614801,
-0.0137431026,
-0.0396532789,
-0.0160793681,
-0.0085461205,
0.0767892599,
0.0250511747,
-0.0180149712,
0.0030099116,
0.0112258736,
0.0256988425,
0.0363971442,
0.0061704414,
-0.0498430878,
-0.0257344022,
-0.0249612518,
0.0405962281,
-0.0581884533,
-0.0237904936,
0.0000624222,
-0.0548711754,
0.0137695475,
0.0097982418,
-0.0366004296,
-0.0396018624,
0.0179959089,
0.0046325945,
-0.002753003,
0.0342848785,
-0.0296696741,
0.0546532571,
-0.0133486874,
0.0359298959,
-0.0263796616,
-0.0667437762,
0.0283887312,
-0.0352478996,
0.0536672026,
0.0411201231,
0.0221563764,
-0.0630586743,
-0.0125575121,
0.0653767735,
-0.0135573996,
-0.0464909188,
-0.0249180123,
0.1032880396,
-0.0423717946,
-0.0130075561,
0.0074338736,
0.0132108154,
-0.0148479557,
-0.0186122712,
0.0126591204,
0.0898229182,
0.0482158102,
0.0045586713,
-0.0600672811,
0.0062522497,
0.0215029679,
0.0541413873,
0.0272937529,
-0.0648832396,
0.0424911901,
-0.0459460095,
-0.0189736802,
-0.0273739696,
-0.0504559241,
0.0165580045,
0.0159987826,
-0.0675251037,
-0.012695279,
-0.0370927714,
0.0040556635,
0.0330630429,
0.0121948225,
-0.0024836829,
-0.0627563745,
0.0050017498,
-0.0647168234,
-0.0147279855,
0.0112742241,
0.0243808441,
-0.0463581607,
0.0047152513,
0.0186706744,
-0.0303216428,
-0.0513254851,
0.0164585002,
-0.011914745,
-0.0342882425,
0.0476762243,
0.0679290742,
0.0171776861,
0.0103917979,
-0.0258115176,
-0.0386620834,
0.1078542024,
0.1257579178,
0.0015156058,
-0.0293171592,
0.1209262684,
-0.0335564502,
0.0055658459,
0.0281153638,
-0.0352937318,
0.07385315,
0.0192111768,
-0.0449259505,
-0.0392655134,
0.0109011084,
0.0011706081,
-0.0317242928,
0.0486298501,
-0.0228077751,
-0.0596697405,
-0.048889976,
-0.0133689353,
0.0431477353,
-0.0349261351,
-0.0100515429,
0.0145573514,
0.0301329624,
-0.0101174461,
-0.0202543568,
-0.0115756402,
-0.001537655,
0.0162946023,
0.0142630078,
0.0103864456,
-0.0208532903,
0.042621199,
-0.006787187,
0.0347614884,
-0.0300231613,
0.0019585001,
0.0185155924,
-0.0341371968,
-0.0223622154,
0.0112099973,
0.0141551858,
0.0228667594,
-0.0094867377,
0.0257783011,
-0.0026774108,
0.0238397084,
-0.0297450032,
-0.0061054765,
0.0116947936,
0.013702618,
-0.0097311893,
0.0121530276,
-0.0084492322,
-0.0179618225,
-0.0199028086,
-0.0383404382,
-0.076201804,
0.0461700596,
0.0243208688,
-0.0258482825,
-0.0018309996,
0.0322399773,
-0.048861362,
0.0393344052,
0.0279831663,
-0.0161093008,
-0.0273352209,
-0.000780268,
-0.0110058906,
0.0514682345,
-0.0030649637,
0.0478764512,
-0.0674289688,
-0.0475932173,
0.0216247849,
-0.0135410437,
0.041348502,
0.0217068214,
0.0183689427,
0.0462652184,
-0.0026905553,
0.025035264,
0.0256974641,
-0.0003290157,
0.0007347236,
-0.0352541581,
0.0204268787,
-5.940930817e-33,
-0.0185999107,
-0.0039504818,
-0.0116378199,
0.0253353808,
-0.0123728383,
0.0114397733,
0.0391159132,
-0.0129312994,
-0.0288715828,
-0.0017375522,
-0.0094957678,
0.0019276566,
0.0066808476,
0.0127121489,
-0.0204725787,
-0.0517584756,
0.0355138369,
-0.0281856656,
-0.0240283813,
0.0027761508,
0.0687090755,
0.0131616909,
0.0305342767,
-0.0569499731,
-0.0153586371,
0.0214896891,
-0.0281740353,
0.0337134562,
0.0183646958,
0.0974962264,
-0.0041669956,
0.1087543294,
0.04316682,
-0.003266179,
-0.0035833155,
0.0416120104,
-0.0644783229,
-0.0209423788,
-0.0087845307,
0.0073452927,
-0.001080074,
-0.0317688473,
0.0485652424,
0.0096185133,
-0.0304419287,
-0.0483547039,
0.0414941423,
-0.0325482301,
-0.0227029137,
-0.0067906408,
-0.0397050977,
0.0201023277,
-0.0131798657,
-0.0209788792,
0.0256409533,
0.0089307893,
0.0398301072,
-0.0076624169,
-0.0604326539,
0.0187339652,
-0.0385564603,
0.0142728416,
-0.0057976902,
0.0289028008,
0.0156493001,
0.0776398331,
0.0186040495,
0.0170030463,
0.0311449002,
-0.0167404134,
0.0405000411,
0.0210945979,
0.040003702,
0.0581677854,
0.0802356973,
-0.0883814543,
-0.0403284058,
-0.0253414325,
0.056516353,
0.0036638011,
0.0232330374,
-0.0306838285,
-0.0390274413,
-0.0215449687,
-0.0414974615,
-0.0477254391,
-0.0256543253,
-0.0493914858,
0.0548615269,
0.0056943097,
-0.0050058188,
-0.0347660966,
0.0064122551,
-0.0550514795,
0.027986316,
0.0555910245,
-0.0035515989,
0.0153816938,
0.0265571065,
0.0393524133,
-0.0737229139,
-0.007387354,
0.0111486437,
-0.0204431042,
0.0146814976,
0.0092161205,
0.0876979828,
0.0436152443,
-0.0589309074,
0.0044762492,
-0.0158307496,
0.0298286919,
-0.0226830337,
-0.0065087858,
-0.0008177278,
0.0456843898,
-0.016074406,
-0.0277214255,
0.0292457528,
-0.0268108137,
-0.0265946891,
-0.0023551283,
-0.0366230719,
0.0211038701,
0.0013485599,
0.0263456423,
-0.0145101659,
0.001129764,
0.0462725908,
-0.0969170257,
0.0156143671,
-0.0539559387,
2.72e-7,
-0.0092963008,
0.0213270094,
-0.0001403167,
0.0000415129,
0.0380951799,
0.0391382352,
0.0090820733,
0.0257637333,
0.0063399314,
-0.0077953669,
0.0048237229,
0.0520586818,
0.0097745592,
0.0550749563,
-0.0188011955,
0.0049160928,
-0.0802813098,
0.0449176431,
-0.0213123616,
-0.006215102,
-0.0004237931,
0.093108803,
0.0863406137,
-0.0382857434,
-0.0128054377,
-0.0260885153,
0.0130643686,
-0.0399025828,
0.0312865525,
-0.050391186,
0.0037262964,
0.0402630493,
0.0001725028,
0.0161056519,
-0.0183820669,
0.0269951187,
0.0193977058,
0.0293070339,
0.0064729066,
0.0159853939,
-0.0230337847,
-0.0287471954,
-0.0049690036,
0.0311643872,
0.0352918766,
-0.0345709994,
-0.0245039612,
-0.0549600795,
-0.0317686424,
-0.0001105863,
0.0432854407,
-0.0438909791,
-0.0361733884,
-0.0274527539,
0.0243492499,
-0.0213290527,
0.0182441324,
-0.1014979109,
0.001730987,
0.0115951141,
-0.0380521566,
-0.0522590429,
-0.0153612839,
-0.0127934162,
0.0559833385,
-0.0033987164,
0.034029942,
2.133471508e-34,
0.0362000205,
-0.0317612924,
0.0386726819,
-0.049146276,
-0.0126812113,
-0.0005591768,
0.0073370934,
-0.0246400852,
0.0582281016,
-0.0056058727,
-0.0058669797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03216v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03216v4 | BGE M3-Embedding: Multi-Lingual, Multi-Functionality, Multi-Granularity Text Embeddings Through Self-Knowledge Distillation | 2024-02-05T17:26:49 | 2024-06-28T09:55:49 | Jianlv Chen, Shitao Xiao, Peitian Zhang, Kun Luo, Defu Lian, Zheng Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we present a new embedding model, called M3-Embedding, which
is distinguished for its versatility in Multi-Linguality, Multi-Functionality,
and Multi-Granularity. It can support more than 100 working languages, leading
to new state-of-the-art performances on multi-lingual and cross-lingual
retrieval tasks. It can simultaneously perform the three common retrieval
functionalities of embedding model: dense retrieval, multi-vector retrieval,
and sparse retrieval, which provides a unified model foundation for real-world
IR applications. It is able to process inputs of different granularities,
spanning from short sentences to long documents of up to 8192 tokens. The
effective training of M3-Embedding involves the following technical
contributions. We propose a novel self-knowledge distillation approach, where
the relevance scores from different retrieval functionalities can be integrated
as the teacher signal to enhance the training quality. We also optimize the
batching strategy, enabling a large batch size and high training throughput to
ensure the discriminativeness of embeddings. To the best of our knowledge,
M3-Embedding is the first embedding model which realizes such a strong
versatility. The model and code will be publicly available at
https://github.com/FlagOpen/FlagEmbedding. | [
0.0052510211,
-0.0274957288,
0.0182036143,
0.0657808632,
-0.0180599689,
0.0080336556,
-0.0004279374,
-0.0005102744,
0.0318758152,
-0.0454125516,
-0.02622848,
-0.0084360735,
-0.0538468286,
0.0256829113,
0.0249288417,
-0.0012010422,
0.0551634207,
0.0138012972,
0.0039877794,
-0.0119712856,
0.0332906581,
0.0121843889,
0.0333144851,
0.0282923225,
-0.0324679501,
0.0022895148,
-0.0040654978,
0.0059104874,
0.013693681,
-0.0018126067,
-0.0115668178,
0.0210683085,
0.0867477804,
0.0326207653,
0.0000017987,
-0.0236979853,
-0.0405535437,
0.0014093556,
0.0129244439,
-0.0203384236,
0.0443487912,
-0.0217466187,
0.0359499119,
-0.00366168,
-0.0172048733,
-0.0228029191,
0.0262895934,
0.0566537045,
0.0241822526,
0.0492357649,
-0.0153607922,
-0.0146860303,
0.0133343982,
-0.0347392708,
0.0005409365,
-0.0101423478,
0.0165761095,
0.0155012831,
-0.0242671352,
0.0668584928,
-0.0414916277,
0.045106288,
0.0063786781,
0.0122139845,
0.0062199179,
0.0136557622,
-0.0343386307,
0.0144242588,
0.0190121811,
0.0615954772,
-0.0345511399,
-0.0091162445,
-0.0194670185,
0.0264034476,
-0.0040663211,
-0.0288555063,
-0.0493285581,
-0.0226995721,
0.026652256,
0.0341632925,
-0.0246429015,
0.029796809,
0.0214118976,
0.0119630527,
-0.0141155934,
-0.0005981944,
-0.0104539245,
-0.0393102802,
-0.0146926409,
-0.0020961682,
-0.0073469616,
0.0300908163,
0.008700178,
0.0102434205,
0.0391808897,
-0.0025798238,
-0.0125487735,
-0.0220361911,
0.0591896102,
-0.0478407331,
-0.040434178,
0.0378275849,
-0.0380337127,
0.087879926,
-0.0605532937,
0.0313906074,
-0.0004696598,
0.0280191265,
-0.0458680876,
-0.0423756242,
-0.05312296,
-0.0078224782,
-0.0361629426,
0.0481997207,
-0.0004844987,
-0.0530558489,
-0.0132653844,
0.0150134508,
-0.0059779719,
0.0173169058,
-0.0123834433,
0.0031116451,
-0.0389177874,
0.0041815201,
0.0043748119,
0.0385964401,
-0.0483645871,
-0.0330678523,
-0.0196479969,
-0.0125273606,
-0.0120326802,
0.0332318991,
0.0171689298,
-0.007048639,
0.0006819731,
-0.0177949108,
-0.031184325,
-0.0508735888,
-0.014405,
-0.0084399348,
-0.0175262578,
-0.0635795668,
-0.0020790566,
-0.0828880593,
0.0531626642,
-0.0098081091,
0.0045502568,
-0.0277636759,
0.0082079517,
0.0001040527,
-0.0036191617,
0.0883546397,
0.01608642,
-0.0292183794,
0.0145507567,
0.0394141339,
0.0079939878,
0.0958699062,
-0.0325212255,
0.0209978502,
0.0955008939,
-0.003896442,
-0.0118928198,
-0.0027137098,
0.0026435347,
0.0213902034,
0.014217495,
0.0169101506,
-0.0153900459,
0.0275792629,
0.0517536104,
0.0342491455,
-0.0385558866,
-0.0280173887,
0.0014903521,
0.0577798076,
0.0348753594,
0.0071527851,
0.0529497862,
0.0336837359,
-0.0233227089,
0.0227251966,
-0.0147667117,
0.0105616348,
0.0099751018,
-0.0147028873,
0.022623999,
0.0576685406,
-0.0631238893,
-0.0314471722,
0.0204941202,
-0.0214373171,
0.0165941305,
-0.0094843237,
0.0636657849,
-0.0309089739,
0.0069508976,
0.0354700685,
0.0422521308,
-0.0432101078,
0.0309306849,
-0.0261067469,
0.0223178659,
0.0464050472,
0.0494963415,
-0.0711799264,
0.0107681127,
-0.0088335453,
0.0226706527,
0.0113028046,
0.0322918743,
-0.0146216331,
0.0331758559,
-0.0666243061,
-0.0577729233,
-0.0335060284,
-0.0008598538,
0.0405821539,
-0.0219066385,
0.0348116793,
0.0415495373,
-0.0435156152,
0.0268427618,
0.0265932139,
-0.0115476428,
-0.0380094498,
0.0111611625,
0.0284113996,
-0.0085424045,
0.0191562902,
-0.0054457886,
-0.0218076129,
0.0667021126,
-0.049372118,
-0.0174833722,
-0.0331075229,
-0.050727509,
-0.0846750587,
0.0237796996,
-0.0225160643,
0.028745411,
0.0272703115,
-0.0349613689,
-0.0418734029,
-0.0074799578,
0.0188804697,
0.033315856,
-0.0734289289,
-0.0044015376,
-0.0041298866,
0.0290992856,
-0.0356400125,
0.0431929193,
-0.0097312853,
0.0201188698,
-0.0519433208,
-0.0435516052,
0.0531766266,
-0.0305775907,
-0.0860027969,
0.0385631323,
-0.0143527091,
0.0394123308,
0.0265011415,
-0.0084146997,
-0.0157768279,
-0.0042252908,
-0.0994252115,
-0.0059439801,
-0.0405330993,
-0.0083996393,
-0.0083570052,
0.0103363972,
0.0335014351,
-0.0320635289,
-0.0566001274,
-0.0181451757,
-0.016407609,
0.0395641327,
0.0072421487,
0.0058888267,
0.0365954563,
-0.0193507895,
-0.0275653768,
0.0006445275,
0.0566700511,
-0.054435201,
-0.0040154764,
-0.0384399295,
-0.0471772365,
-0.0413336866,
0.0301315282,
-0.0277817138,
-0.0221022069,
-0.012363486,
-0.0216118041,
0.0479728617,
0.0472296886,
-0.015571449,
0.0114756096,
0.0403255671,
0.001528387,
-0.0768393353,
0.0409447066,
-0.0351438932,
0.0522865653,
-0.023995718,
0.0137980366,
-0.0252052434,
-0.0261005424,
-0.0156925749,
-0.0157771092,
-0.0461205468,
-0.0253013019,
0.0035032094,
-0.0224626455,
-0.0553750135,
0.0099585019,
-0.0005179735,
-0.0107265133,
-0.0250016358,
-0.0279493574,
0.0498837084,
-0.0316787735,
-0.0233435258,
-0.0247708857,
-0.0319754928,
-0.0448173396,
0.0664855763,
-0.0173609033,
0.0405328237,
-0.006966169,
-0.0019012751,
-0.0359105133,
0.0165202599,
0.008047753,
-0.0310067516,
0.0494467653,
0.0434868634,
-0.0094643496,
-0.0174232088,
-0.0622228421,
-0.0046931594,
-0.0654204488,
0.0385007896,
0.0288358945,
0.0184670836,
0.0102925701,
-0.0447717793,
0.0210035108,
0.0319334492,
0.0146497767,
-0.0134012392,
-0.0212801415,
-0.0135568371,
0.0613144077,
0.0319248699,
-0.0148328971,
-0.014974352,
0.0358704478,
0.0231302362,
0.0362075306,
0.0017927651,
-0.0491724983,
-0.016972648,
0.004883776,
0.031441804,
-0.0035892001,
-0.0397739485,
-0.0589436591,
0.0454963781,
-0.0284970626,
0.0023418542,
0.0711162835,
0.0022253466,
-0.0412951,
-0.0196029227,
-0.040648032,
0.0364847183,
0.0301127788,
0.0485988557,
-0.0709250793,
-0.0246391259,
-0.0066154217,
0.0002850717,
0.0516187698,
0.0083191069,
-0.006761129,
-0.0656507015,
0.0261685196,
0.0096705416,
0.0166065749,
-0.0473130085,
-0.0300924815,
-0.0146118309,
-0.0044667856,
-0.007504493,
-0.0135397688,
-0.0032785779,
-0.0266257953,
-0.0033731987,
-0.0244160928,
-0.0624904409,
0.0161062777,
-0.0346999764,
-0.0199531484,
-0.0047495104,
0.0589821152,
0.0186425783,
-0.0312841497,
-0.0356400833,
-0.0406770855,
-0.0392125361,
-0.0280753225,
0.0729579404,
-0.0368545353,
-0.0040364051,
0.0068216017,
-0.0185540523,
-0.006027427,
0.0089294761,
-0.0292314328,
0.0875524059,
0.0050543575,
0.0281327143,
-0.0392728597,
-0.0432967097,
0.0050657433,
0.0800212696,
-0.0074958629,
-0.0044049979,
-0.0327790156,
-0.0246471688,
0.0243752766,
-0.002040593,
-0.0359353758,
-0.0274024513,
-0.0130625265,
-0.0209305231,
-0.0600073077,
-0.0519371033,
0.0365207531,
0.0461231247,
-0.0317825638,
0.028889399,
-0.0566436574,
-0.0027253018,
-0.0353262648,
0.0061239162,
-0.028385818,
-0.0033140031,
-0.0252901539,
0.0314227417,
0.0408458561,
-0.0300125498,
-0.0236303862,
-0.0210097935,
-0.0314112008,
-0.0397084989,
-0.0180508643,
0.0352579504,
0.0000634753,
0.0555575229,
-0.0317339264,
-0.0339478143,
0.0970486179,
0.0165330749,
-0.0461894535,
-0.0243026353,
0.0512072742,
0.0147773027,
-0.0250504892,
0.063793093,
-0.0467556156,
0.026499711,
-0.0301731937,
0.0371352695,
-0.0381708331,
-0.0021770999,
0.0069509218,
-0.0213819072,
0.0339865983,
-0.0014042447,
0.0319428407,
-0.062308833,
0.0025810741,
-0.0221628733,
-0.0243324749,
-0.0563512295,
0.0279033501,
0.0498656295,
-0.0592826605,
-0.0006595296,
0.0483884439,
0.0257665552,
0.0229794476,
-0.0096464036,
0.0084211268,
0.0046747993,
-0.0024759166,
-0.0156230414,
0.0361312404,
-0.0344133973,
0.013242797,
-0.0207722671,
-0.0140326247,
-0.0755632967,
0.017222736,
-0.0040410329,
-0.0147178955,
-0.0261295736,
0.0413471758,
-0.0308230277,
0.0098633859,
-0.0151126748,
-0.0079679815,
0.0750682205,
-0.0273185093,
0.0343233123,
0.0140273375,
-0.03455716,
-0.0272683203,
-0.0027375275,
-0.0131810103,
-0.017375255,
0.0437861905,
0.0299199503,
-0.0438772663,
0.0353042968,
0.0753167048,
-0.009028797,
0.0143211707,
0.0001526839,
-0.0281169042,
-0.0466297418,
-0.0149428202,
0.0947734192,
0.0781523734,
-0.028280694,
-0.0063138856,
-0.0090572722,
-0.0262026899,
0.0080642486,
-0.0080560539,
-0.0819419995,
0.0173215512,
0.0209884904,
0.0840564519,
0.0114173228,
-0.022940293,
-0.0463383198,
-0.0203700252,
-0.013523384,
-0.0233988129,
0.0156090921,
-5.880598202e-33,
0.0125513766,
0.0311761573,
0.0007745423,
-0.0052615688,
-0.0043029236,
0.0362963565,
0.024801014,
-0.0009847779,
-0.0540982187,
0.0140922945,
-0.0100795086,
-0.0146002211,
0.0222834982,
0.0212171748,
-0.0169395283,
0.0176064521,
0.0660365373,
0.0056608994,
0.0047060424,
0.0579343401,
0.0789959952,
0.067410633,
0.0631571189,
-0.0709132627,
-0.0146153197,
-0.011676454,
-0.0063488996,
0.0254266411,
0.0435564034,
0.0831692368,
-0.0480628945,
0.053306479,
0.0240167528,
-0.0039289631,
-0.0181173403,
0.0248918198,
-0.1095344871,
-0.0367948376,
-0.0263071582,
0.0060666157,
-0.0537056699,
-0.0041058403,
0.033664003,
-0.0522435345,
0.0346392319,
-0.0065068048,
0.042211201,
0.0048410506,
-0.031798631,
-0.0400298759,
-0.0347661898,
0.0369982757,
0.0033077032,
-0.0067085815,
0.0779986009,
0.0349284187,
0.0606389418,
0.0637839735,
-0.0865074545,
-0.008622543,
-0.1003102511,
0.0509131812,
0.0289903656,
-0.0183337238,
-0.0127797546,
0.0624676012,
-0.0125492942,
-0.013152794,
0.0242031068,
-0.0469004996,
0.0526766032,
0.0580317229,
0.0148206148,
0.0913997889,
0.0503808036,
-0.0001398826,
-0.0557233244,
0.0239532609,
0.014775604,
0.0580417141,
0.0125218416,
0.0365838371,
-0.0463837385,
-0.0045576729,
-0.025625648,
-0.0118331974,
-0.0183825213,
-0.0576828942,
0.0377972759,
0.0442113057,
-0.020682143,
0.0162522402,
0.0853554681,
-0.0338766649,
-0.0169508569,
0.0583973117,
-0.0164230317,
0.0162877589,
0.0180043541,
0.014439404,
-0.0366914123,
-0.0325537175,
0.0149132861,
-0.0430732407,
-0.0333017744,
-0.0157839675,
0.0835800841,
0.0177292265,
-0.0681959093,
0.0034322836,
-0.0065915249,
-0.0566657446,
-0.0114512136,
0.036218334,
0.0028418042,
0.0099497,
-0.0032389178,
0.0337235294,
0.0515537113,
-0.0101115126,
-0.0012700228,
-0.0923274904,
0.019090483,
0.0232510343,
0.004729385,
0.0231747068,
-0.04746731,
0.0165384132,
0.0414679684,
-0.0343585499,
0.0050615272,
0.0523773953,
2.446e-7,
0.0437020138,
0.0225311182,
-0.0124145821,
-0.0289469101,
-0.0069225943,
0.0388095416,
-0.0161029603,
0.043583028,
-0.0156920049,
0.005183368,
0.025688637,
0.0454547927,
0.0338920727,
0.0237553529,
-0.0906302109,
0.0361430049,
-0.0179832336,
-0.0247018337,
-0.0330970176,
-0.0344965607,
0.0594861656,
0.1281525344,
0.0325135514,
0.0205799788,
-0.0243045446,
-0.0757145956,
0.0845060199,
-0.0128226476,
0.0085632997,
0.0172013678,
0.0313083604,
0.0510587953,
-0.0062006488,
-0.0257874969,
-0.0114734964,
0.0509237349,
0.0495098867,
0.0726320669,
-0.0105289621,
-0.0322015658,
0.009215584,
-0.0085878922,
-0.0140320733,
-0.0608947314,
0.070069328,
-0.0182069466,
0.0116264513,
0.008291536,
-0.001918403,
0.0180937685,
0.070647411,
-0.0024253228,
-0.0537301898,
0.0338670388,
0.0231349021,
-0.0260096639,
-0.0192656685,
-0.0994234458,
0.0155810062,
-0.0037578314,
-0.0546997488,
0.0138400076,
-0.0225748345,
-0.0125729861,
0.0278826673,
-0.0516894124,
0.0186996367,
2.332363085e-34,
0.0273023043,
-0.014775916,
-0.0050238296,
0.0121635078,
0.0180380605,
-0.0344900973,
-0.042009037,
-0.0014302873,
0.0007350167,
-0.0578343347,
-0.0171615984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03191v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03191v3 | Isotropy, Clusters, and Classifiers | 2024-02-05T16:57:24 | 2024-05-27T10:21:08 | Timothee Mickus, Stig-Arne Grönroos, Joseph Attieh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Whether embedding spaces use all their dimensions equally, i.e., whether they
are isotropic, has been a recent subject of discussion. Evidence has been
accrued both for and against enforcing isotropy in embedding spaces. In the
present paper, we stress that isotropy imposes requirements on the embedding
space that are not compatible with the presence of clusters -- which also
negatively impacts linear classification objectives. We demonstrate this fact
both mathematically and empirically and use it to shed light on previous
results from the literature. | [
-0.0405705646,
0.0222307611,
-0.0349217951,
0.0161833465,
-0.0319941528,
0.0212068912,
0.0605724491,
0.036931511,
0.0595548153,
0.0116620902,
0.0290488098,
-0.0322100185,
-0.0147292353,
-0.0068559456,
0.0316978358,
-0.0536237769,
0.0056619658,
0.0222903714,
-0.0220458694,
-0.0300198887,
-0.038505692,
-0.0433672741,
0.0115911933,
0.0068795877,
-0.0296508949,
0.024645146,
0.0005321397,
-0.08005853,
-0.0267064869,
-0.0060342159,
-0.0515452437,
-0.022854818,
0.0427721627,
0.0127528692,
0.0000015284,
0.0043129055,
-0.0150922751,
0.0103064151,
0.0146948202,
0.0144804632,
0.0053236987,
-0.0140115703,
0.029092554,
-0.0242374148,
-0.021891376,
-0.0748405457,
0.0489646755,
0.0557508804,
0.0019801813,
0.0082678935,
-0.0491875298,
-0.0152455997,
0.0186582934,
-0.0263489876,
-0.0079144435,
0.0800455809,
0.0183125772,
0.0113553498,
-0.0612477921,
0.0106887845,
-0.052493915,
0.0333323032,
0.0378455259,
0.053862676,
0.0490326807,
0.0820592344,
-0.0371701717,
0.0128560513,
0.0005998848,
0.0209165663,
0.0120267011,
0.0160692316,
-0.0267868768,
0.0189399868,
0.0148212351,
0.0385858007,
-0.0076217242,
-0.0358152762,
0.0334837884,
0.0258831009,
-0.0251092762,
0.0576009341,
0.0454116724,
-0.0343252793,
-0.0025142441,
0.0219909977,
0.029284697,
-0.0581898764,
0.004194194,
0.0344639122,
-0.0162489116,
0.0492103659,
0.0074133361,
-0.0093589835,
0.0733098835,
-0.0250911079,
0.0449767895,
0.0707997382,
0.0071371472,
-0.018902367,
0.0586626604,
-0.0080678277,
0.0079626041,
0.0083738836,
-0.0334068462,
0.013102999,
-0.0200251359,
0.0364625566,
-0.022309389,
0.057928104,
-0.0344959833,
0.0006833396,
0.0024921247,
0.0608097799,
0.0066029159,
-0.0054732827,
-0.0296725053,
0.0750935748,
-0.0010556871,
0.0370444134,
-0.0363499001,
-0.0091268066,
0.0499518663,
0.0719382539,
0.0191847812,
-0.0059928475,
-0.025830619,
0.0348990858,
-0.0403341092,
0.0172781851,
0.0071166637,
0.0172317084,
0.007804269,
0.0165643338,
0.0204825159,
0.0424456708,
0.0268972665,
-0.0083700521,
-0.0207612216,
0.0579040162,
-0.0594924465,
0.0060419058,
0.0025724743,
-0.0243013073,
0.0103788339,
0.0080217635,
-0.0048120758,
-0.0218459964,
-0.0383228101,
-0.0539401956,
-0.0233607683,
0.1066353247,
0.0024274809,
-0.0042761243,
0.0516810194,
-0.0296957735,
-0.0142680686,
0.0194111615,
0.0022718005,
0.0116471583,
0.0589857064,
-0.0539077818,
-0.0174784791,
-0.0079096444,
-0.0001712803,
-0.0309462734,
-0.0457928441,
0.0179291647,
-0.0053652697,
-0.0289762598,
-0.0036655434,
0.0136809833,
-0.032810647,
-0.0236151759,
0.0213974044,
0.0817785114,
0.0347662531,
0.0360295847,
-0.0138111319,
-0.0014229605,
-0.0750620738,
0.048163157,
0.0003769959,
-0.034871351,
0.0105377669,
-0.0031491257,
0.0760194734,
-0.0158421621,
-0.0629197061,
-0.0707559213,
-0.00460009,
-0.0096724117,
0.0442504957,
-0.02324952,
0.057619337,
-0.049665954,
0.016805524,
0.0227269549,
0.0281795599,
-0.0505784526,
-0.0101483194,
0.016838057,
0.0266911425,
-0.0353428908,
-0.0095813051,
-0.0356819518,
0.009814675,
0.0148834111,
-0.0130302114,
-0.0299502816,
0.0358496867,
-0.0395812243,
0.0115126837,
-0.0686825365,
-0.0141866496,
0.0614526831,
0.0322064795,
-0.0308690555,
0.0040755449,
-0.0029540733,
-0.0135680474,
-0.0366032124,
0.012736897,
0.0377111621,
0.0382907018,
-0.0211271029,
0.009395455,
0.0872067288,
0.0512112901,
-0.0032429816,
-0.0025274262,
-0.0544593595,
0.0508635789,
-0.0344136432,
-0.0550577864,
-0.004349248,
-0.0114417337,
-0.0333254598,
0.0290920623,
-0.0105416756,
0.0254001841,
-0.0206402112,
0.0224134121,
-0.0236614961,
0.0358986817,
-0.0348942392,
0.0419099443,
-0.0563792624,
-0.0044012507,
-0.0539370701,
0.0182528403,
-0.0468873233,
0.0481574386,
-0.0125973448,
0.0488549434,
-0.0290458929,
-0.0001142266,
0.0719382688,
0.0167571474,
0.0055404711,
0.0037538272,
-0.0038000478,
0.0515108109,
-0.0104054576,
-0.048419185,
0.0375678279,
-0.0692451224,
0.0161234923,
-0.0609375611,
-0.0045094816,
-0.0175998826,
-0.0409486555,
-0.0085432148,
0.0132675162,
-0.0148634696,
-0.0045672767,
0.0327941775,
0.0078863185,
0.0047022011,
0.0562648363,
0.0039345236,
-0.0307233352,
0.0533260889,
-0.0323254019,
0.0000330839,
0.0257133879,
-0.0425232276,
0.0272361543,
-0.0223825611,
0.0407961532,
0.0024579247,
0.0110739619,
-0.0065784906,
-0.018871069,
0.0070174108,
-0.0024296935,
-0.0599658564,
0.0907925814,
-0.0171949845,
0.0256829895,
0.0498392694,
0.0199974608,
-0.013154556,
-0.010320955,
-0.0333658457,
0.0631433651,
0.0046695112,
-0.0096702082,
-0.0122052841,
0.0190419685,
0.0128891626,
-0.0330801271,
-0.0552976578,
-0.0219698343,
-0.0345085077,
0.0078990171,
-0.0050719646,
-0.0076984363,
-0.0175123755,
-0.0252787732,
0.003065868,
-0.0713429749,
0.0555779971,
-0.0109470626,
-0.0008193204,
-0.0105371913,
-0.0579622909,
-0.0525721796,
-0.0146792252,
0.019842945,
0.0049043498,
-0.0107890125,
-0.0214061961,
-0.0076729036,
-0.023373371,
-0.0243264567,
0.0030419528,
0.0195769276,
0.0319052376,
-0.0414295755,
0.0091886045,
-0.0474736616,
-0.0026751063,
-0.0517923199,
0.0434071645,
0.0111055905,
-0.0576316379,
-0.0117204161,
-0.0162319932,
0.070129618,
-0.0207292922,
0.0046558958,
-0.0067676445,
-0.0210373867,
0.0030517303,
0.032081075,
-0.0234205872,
-0.0456105694,
-0.0455851331,
-0.0521942489,
-0.0203000847,
0.0072436561,
-0.003334583,
0.0408426747,
-0.0347533897,
0.0505357832,
0.0229005441,
0.0238399748,
-0.0783235133,
-0.0298779346,
-0.003067479,
0.0606786311,
0.0173694137,
0.0662688687,
0.0026279457,
-0.0515635237,
-0.0211672727,
-0.0069473879,
0.0428195,
0.025278559,
-0.0097782426,
0.1033164114,
0.0373371467,
-0.0534058437,
0.0222978182,
0.035702996,
0.0213235132,
0.0484455787,
-0.0158970598,
0.0392976925,
0.0600424074,
-0.062794745,
-0.0300781466,
-0.0306524802,
-0.0097346567,
-0.0524195321,
-0.0007733951,
-0.0571221523,
-0.0233556945,
-0.0053424621,
0.0509869121,
-0.0991369188,
0.0117491931,
-0.0595075898,
-0.0423655659,
-0.030904429,
0.0046800259,
0.0279730316,
-0.0187322423,
-0.0235566366,
-0.0313307904,
-0.0209894739,
-0.018273199,
-0.0105363149,
0.0424881056,
0.0473373421,
-0.0018872136,
-0.0063850898,
-0.0031904734,
-0.0004431865,
0.0187016595,
0.0002373263,
0.1046388,
-0.0086748013,
-0.0062249191,
-0.0114484206,
-0.0157535449,
-0.0120375967,
0.0163414609,
0.0102136927,
-0.033995118,
-0.0064688288,
0.0221961327,
0.0451200828,
0.0805703774,
-0.0030473624,
0.0277783554,
-0.0163150039,
-0.0091109984,
-0.0335017033,
-0.0073838546,
0.0020418901,
0.1113620326,
0.0118782949,
-0.0185590051,
-0.0286550559,
-0.0311226733,
-0.0454541072,
0.0036644572,
0.0155540183,
-0.0444182195,
0.0321047269,
0.0063336412,
0.0342723653,
-0.0067081647,
-0.0182369929,
-0.08637207,
0.0653071105,
-0.066757299,
-0.0052827452,
-0.0205916036,
0.0064037708,
0.0416631326,
-0.0063031395,
-0.0346165225,
0.1369800568,
-0.0157104768,
0.050475508,
0.0278436933,
0.0312545896,
-0.0706906542,
0.004064308,
0.0058595655,
0.0092475116,
0.0265931804,
-0.0119953724,
-0.0697483942,
-0.114061892,
-0.0084124729,
-0.0155911045,
0.0064936955,
0.0719873831,
-0.0020388386,
-0.011662757,
0.004782639,
0.013142867,
0.0201053806,
0.0352502689,
0.0177224241,
-0.0479528978,
0.0826026201,
0.0448851101,
-0.0496072397,
0.0226476304,
0.0131962132,
0.0266719926,
-0.0247480534,
0.0077503938,
0.0302106589,
0.0264333785,
-0.0322396494,
0.0635697916,
-0.0458416864,
-0.0447075702,
-0.0155340293,
0.0118563063,
0.0027329703,
-0.0107812881,
0.0008362044,
0.0696261451,
-0.0449269749,
0.0367694236,
-0.0563468114,
0.0696906596,
-0.0218834151,
-0.0683106482,
-0.0099316733,
-0.0732708722,
-0.0177759752,
-0.0246585999,
-0.0544498041,
-0.0080937762,
-0.0300354045,
0.0028932458,
-0.0300429389,
0.0529116429,
0.0245893337,
-0.0446033515,
0.0368705913,
0.009890303,
-0.0332343578,
-0.0133578526,
-0.0314081647,
-0.0029623574,
-0.0736905262,
0.0590547174,
0.0718389004,
0.0242475178,
0.0029545911,
0.0076856692,
-0.02031173,
-0.0127067361,
-0.0005900135,
-0.019258691,
0.017413564,
0.0192530882,
-0.0159988701,
0.0430339351,
0.0250205025,
-0.0197283085,
-0.0144265201,
-0.0261162911,
-0.0000670497,
0.0016175358,
0.0124986526,
-4.885121627e-33,
0.0094227418,
-0.0142917037,
-0.0536540411,
-0.0029342452,
-0.0437405519,
0.0375415124,
0.0624239929,
0.0001837844,
-0.0096690562,
-0.0111337518,
-0.0277555995,
-0.0043505863,
0.0001408031,
-0.0066228593,
0.0428343304,
0.0235998165,
0.0057935528,
-0.0190869775,
-0.0270906854,
0.0166809447,
0.0245962851,
-0.018143151,
-0.0246664081,
-0.0841951594,
-0.0450968072,
0.0429576263,
-0.011141723,
0.0321744271,
0.0321819335,
0.0196239501,
-0.048672732,
0.0275940839,
0.0081814509,
0.0225055516,
-0.006986029,
0.0179900099,
-0.001649066,
-0.0317335278,
-0.0546668433,
0.0168197621,
-0.0034573823,
-0.0345966332,
0.0453556627,
-0.0508816801,
0.0033071097,
-0.0346592404,
0.0304134395,
-0.0296718162,
-0.0349714458,
0.1030803546,
0.0043480676,
0.0243867151,
-0.0057219681,
0.0076148175,
0.0634057298,
0.0223324019,
0.0388432071,
-0.013879369,
-0.0022438422,
0.0734139308,
-0.0327009037,
0.000847138,
-0.0164088141,
0.0112379333,
0.024320418,
0.0432827547,
0.0559692979,
-0.0396589525,
-0.0126443086,
-0.0472931266,
0.0088517712,
0.0410641022,
0.0246959887,
0.0105018774,
0.0059864828,
-0.0363413841,
-0.0534026623,
0.0117936051,
-0.0219972339,
-0.05732641,
0.0179855414,
0.0251444578,
-0.1075142547,
-0.0545582287,
0.014784676,
-0.0767750517,
0.0039350386,
-0.0431104042,
-0.0127800005,
0.0119961109,
-0.005174919,
0.0009208128,
-0.0403442197,
-0.0300799627,
0.0203471519,
-0.0366477706,
-0.0062620975,
0.0622585714,
0.029584486,
-0.0366788805,
0.0146927321,
-0.0651389435,
-0.0276338626,
0.0191888977,
0.010652286,
0.0232941583,
0.0231161136,
0.0178828835,
-0.0257185027,
-0.0420389175,
0.0518657304,
-0.0975176618,
0.0173254702,
0.0101900091,
0.0280732363,
-0.0206088275,
0.0337064117,
0.0444230363,
0.0245865919,
0.0427371524,
0.0269609541,
-0.0132430084,
0.0112240352,
0.0519734211,
0.0119607942,
-0.0131566459,
0.0203135926,
0.0141518898,
0.028572239,
-0.0492570288,
-0.016234789,
-0.0499258228,
2.229e-7,
0.0009281174,
0.0310388412,
-0.0112215597,
-0.0471162274,
0.0041295127,
0.0482181981,
-0.0537752248,
0.0066439318,
-0.0585292317,
0.0194340926,
0.0499131344,
-0.0149266059,
0.0281959176,
0.0307235885,
-0.0152426567,
0.0018904743,
0.0030826384,
0.0458370857,
-0.0171596184,
0.0544842854,
0.0083557805,
0.07412415,
0.0052879835,
-0.0192415789,
-0.0165998638,
-0.0400579162,
0.008008102,
-0.0348337926,
0.0360741913,
-0.0044933972,
-0.0004636636,
-0.0149127701,
0.0182205327,
0.0413008705,
-0.0090114735,
0.0590971634,
0.0022984622,
-0.0346896425,
-0.0059600226,
-0.023054624,
0.0006325545,
0.0071521886,
0.0015578441,
-0.041333735,
0.0401686132,
-0.0378438085,
-0.0352211446,
-0.0055172052,
-0.0438562073,
0.0175374374,
0.0864063948,
0.0292264391,
0.017713543,
0.0084400699,
-0.0277456883,
-0.0537643917,
0.0406296849,
-0.0405318104,
0.0141574703,
0.0098187113,
-0.0464192592,
-0.0285769291,
0.0462574512,
0.0465731211,
0.0893012509,
0.0341638103,
-0.0135500729,
1.798671775e-34,
0.0106439581,
0.012238198,
0.0673237219,
-0.017362386,
-0.0589305684,
-0.0479655266,
-0.0247403104,
-0.0383567363,
0.0385904796,
-0.054467123,
0.0243603643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03190v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03190v4 | Unified Hallucination Detection for Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T16:56:11 | 2024-05-27T11:52:56 | Xiang Chen, Chenxi Wang, Yida Xue, Ningyu Zhang, Xiaoyan Yang, Qiang Li, Yue Shen, Lei Liang, Jinjie Gu, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.MM | Despite significant strides in multimodal tasks, Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) are plagued by the critical issue of hallucination. The reliable
detection of such hallucinations in MLLMs has, therefore, become a vital aspect
of model evaluation and the safeguarding of practical application deployment.
Prior research in this domain has been constrained by a narrow focus on
singular tasks, an inadequate range of hallucination categories addressed, and
a lack of detailed granularity. In response to these challenges, our work
expands the investigative horizons of hallucination detection. We present a
novel meta-evaluation benchmark, MHaluBench, meticulously crafted to facilitate
the evaluation of advancements in hallucination detection methods.
Additionally, we unveil a novel unified multimodal hallucination detection
framework, UNIHD, which leverages a suite of auxiliary tools to validate the
occurrence of hallucinations robustly. We demonstrate the effectiveness of
UNIHD through meticulous evaluation and comprehensive analysis. We also provide
strategic insights on the application of specific tools for addressing various
categories of hallucinations. | [
-0.0039143264,
0.0429497175,
-0.0020508301,
0.0607759021,
-0.0198747441,
0.0255992748,
0.0207348466,
0.0288151968,
-0.0055516553,
-0.0589517206,
-0.0378809273,
-0.0694485903,
0.0076236874,
-0.0118527794,
0.0393719263,
-0.057836514,
0.0436449684,
-0.0695676655,
-0.0477272049,
-0.0025374426,
0.0216363594,
-0.0131709706,
-0.038434241,
0.0619616248,
-0.038380485,
-0.042398721,
-0.0080411406,
0.0148213217,
-0.001934659,
0.0004676986,
-0.018942887,
0.0761842877,
-0.0058288495,
0.0759134367,
0.0000020433,
-0.0472123474,
-0.0065159164,
-0.0110250702,
0.0389995724,
-0.0022265767,
0.0643209517,
-0.0138321528,
-0.0022455929,
-0.0194496866,
-0.0095406668,
-0.0077077858,
0.062828362,
0.0602216609,
0.0446338989,
0.0234706011,
-0.0127403988,
-0.0178585649,
0.0203502271,
0.0228701159,
0.0425430387,
0.0155286258,
0.0282021463,
0.0281302724,
-0.0182627887,
-0.0757771432,
-0.0349068381,
0.0321991742,
0.0084312595,
-0.0026071428,
-0.0290484894,
0.0053966683,
-0.0675596818,
-0.0263731126,
-0.0236756261,
0.0601771995,
-0.0560156628,
-0.0276877042,
0.0228366703,
0.0259973966,
-0.0057031615,
0.0137577783,
-0.0351883657,
0.0290860739,
-0.0057345643,
-0.0070024882,
-0.0072221383,
0.0050142128,
0.0312476028,
-0.0109231919,
-0.0327266119,
0.0451920182,
0.0368838236,
-0.0201195292,
0.0288919266,
0.0053372891,
-0.0276472364,
-0.0520623773,
0.0225279927,
-0.0126431677,
-0.0645883381,
-0.0418370031,
-0.0618288293,
-0.0283262022,
0.0386825427,
-0.0637062192,
0.044576373,
-0.0199419595,
-0.0791256353,
0.0549801476,
-0.0131155727,
0.0265409183,
-0.040440388,
0.050264515,
0.0062846448,
0.010614248,
-0.0114389444,
0.0174458064,
-0.0179678947,
-0.0426557846,
-0.0041734977,
-0.0600196235,
0.0085801138,
-0.0096353358,
-0.0248531848,
0.0207617767,
-0.0498921424,
0.002067378,
0.0119395629,
-0.0251925401,
0.0458004028,
0.0281187762,
0.00651117,
-0.0254681837,
0.0064088977,
-0.0678325593,
-0.0011308776,
0.0630218759,
-0.0212741308,
-0.0124150822,
-0.0140786953,
0.0624866411,
0.0346808545,
-0.0073064584,
-0.0034418837,
-0.0318836309,
-0.0444626957,
-0.0543725342,
0.0406985804,
-0.0512009747,
0.0149604985,
-0.0169976093,
0.0157357659,
-0.0010330724,
0.0149743268,
-0.0111468658,
0.0150554162,
0.0895624086,
-0.0422450304,
-0.0009842133,
0.0146067552,
0.0340067782,
-0.0260454211,
0.0903155431,
-0.0007911805,
0.0404617563,
0.0428529195,
-0.0278366636,
0.0636568367,
0.0484910458,
-0.0500538833,
0.0220880285,
-0.0418873243,
-0.0436358005,
0.0357767642,
0.0193304401,
0.0005404729,
0.0674224496,
-0.0263769887,
-0.0399825424,
0.0806432888,
0.0255738981,
-0.012665242,
-0.0338691436,
0.0084402347,
0.0043915641,
-0.0054879924,
0.0385993347,
-0.0456443094,
0.0247914139,
-0.0376291238,
-0.0143066235,
0.0705668777,
0.0224478561,
-0.0071332678,
-0.0071547716,
-0.0324133672,
-0.003431695,
0.0027651994,
0.0114864977,
0.0417016707,
0.0117136389,
-0.0472530909,
0.0184533522,
0.0241425019,
-0.0422218032,
0.0175472368,
-0.0268690474,
-0.0146833155,
0.0804779381,
0.0559820607,
-0.0237289462,
0.016931152,
-0.045830097,
0.0655900836,
0.0699569955,
0.0037170409,
0.0062639019,
0.0504540764,
-0.0596400388,
-0.0006341481,
0.0221386105,
0.0506841019,
-0.0216518529,
-0.033300899,
-0.0035924455,
-0.0210427959,
-0.046809487,
-0.0136049548,
0.0387303121,
0.0125312554,
0.0237254221,
-0.0530316308,
-0.0003388898,
-0.0053289221,
-0.0021539219,
-0.0380423442,
0.0014610237,
-0.0056661414,
-0.0427126549,
-0.0088506909,
0.0255277064,
-0.0246881135,
-0.0052282936,
0.0407390185,
-0.0321683995,
-0.0019818125,
0.0305906087,
-0.001519121,
-0.0098999739,
0.0176659878,
-0.0559345931,
0.0220238008,
-0.0539532639,
0.0315069556,
-0.0001925725,
0.0648115203,
-0.0035027023,
0.053224273,
-0.0362116173,
0.0158742853,
0.0169550814,
-0.0214792099,
-0.0056098378,
-0.0114319371,
-0.0742225051,
0.0531257764,
-0.016141504,
0.0326558389,
-0.049911689,
-0.0494510867,
-0.0579102933,
-0.0078380276,
-0.1055667624,
-0.0132747432,
-0.0462979823,
-0.0117614912,
0.0256666541,
-0.019536484,
-0.0026135484,
-0.0183236133,
0.0159340706,
0.0115942284,
0.0200310349,
0.048674494,
-0.0245386902,
-0.0172469616,
-0.0376125947,
-0.0202547181,
-0.0120351911,
0.0014736981,
0.0703470781,
-0.021303447,
-0.0623821467,
-0.0693279207,
-0.0089079868,
-0.0272150114,
0.0291425362,
-0.0054127118,
-0.0110824518,
0.0183605254,
-0.0243724044,
0.0658620298,
0.0705642179,
0.0286103003,
0.0147758862,
0.0678340942,
-0.0546432212,
0.0103233941,
-0.0329378247,
0.0141214421,
0.0180634726,
-0.0060913349,
-0.0314573646,
0.005336524,
0.0506874211,
0.0111869294,
0.0375055857,
-0.0384795442,
-0.0119896811,
-0.0555229113,
-0.0866891593,
-0.0242821202,
0.0022453319,
-0.030074589,
0.0265096594,
-0.0263963751,
-0.0343071893,
0.0331919156,
-0.0574076623,
-0.0268464647,
0.0273186192,
0.0082795015,
0.0211382676,
0.0380347073,
0.0221393388,
0.0270412527,
-0.0220048726,
-0.0182587896,
-0.0141857611,
0.0106153898,
-0.0232956149,
-0.0404211059,
0.0299849957,
-0.040186394,
-0.0068640332,
0.0181656536,
0.0012922275,
-0.0243373141,
-0.0188704506,
-0.0149732539,
-0.0516022071,
-0.0463163704,
0.0011516729,
-0.0238272641,
0.0437337384,
-0.0131464796,
0.0187876597,
-0.019364452,
-0.0040233131,
-0.0041167769,
0.0292751305,
0.0658599064,
0.0121542159,
0.0336673744,
-0.0806848705,
0.0020372409,
0.0809124112,
0.0371078141,
0.0561994165,
-0.0474106483,
0.0081590759,
0.0241696518,
0.0072554364,
-0.0245942958,
0.0126907527,
0.0378926396,
-0.0626812354,
0.0100882351,
0.0699189976,
0.0085732192,
-0.0835356042,
-0.012447862,
-0.0464347228,
0.058502689,
-0.0043453374,
-0.0462332703,
-0.0593070425,
-0.0460660234,
0.0054418533,
-0.0147238784,
0.0013720572,
-0.0026228377,
0.0154691832,
-0.0390412547,
0.0425999798,
0.0155068012,
-0.0292917378,
-0.0108767077,
0.0030851618,
0.0389285609,
0.0200787485,
0.0557069369,
-0.0022405484,
0.0078028189,
-0.0361317173,
0.0114388848,
-0.0243053138,
-0.0332474336,
0.0081481803,
-0.0483015589,
0.0670634955,
0.0701610595,
0.0238780789,
-0.0097858142,
-0.0789628923,
0.0535139516,
-0.0084217945,
-0.0133651681,
0.0284969099,
0.0588114746,
0.0012700228,
-0.0016520338,
0.002317704,
-0.0060909996,
-0.0262845475,
-0.0073838173,
0.0042430097,
0.045282986,
-0.0360192247,
-0.0392324142,
-0.0286849178,
0.041216176,
0.0179771949,
0.06748382,
0.0618524626,
-0.055364918,
-0.0507241637,
-0.0025196965,
0.0470969416,
-0.0400685333,
-0.0474542528,
0.0336583704,
0.0597691648,
-0.0370563827,
-0.0668708831,
-0.0063566198,
0.019350918,
0.0118615003,
0.0021633653,
0.0491370745,
-0.0554292612,
-0.0029940424,
-0.0296955127,
0.0245324858,
-0.0327777453,
0.0298048891,
-0.0452354699,
0.0344141498,
-0.0034709941,
-0.0005587804,
0.0211169608,
0.060004048,
-0.1054966748,
-0.0408921316,
0.0382686146,
0.0352077372,
0.0229880176,
0.012674517,
-0.0330595188,
-0.0660146698,
0.020061424,
0.0211912449,
0.0260859318,
0.0369158052,
0.0252957251,
-0.0287159327,
-0.0029927422,
0.0243394393,
-0.0010382774,
-0.0029113588,
-0.0064728577,
0.0157175716,
0.021105295,
0.0202464685,
-0.0073938952,
-0.0258184485,
0.02211258,
-0.0410271175,
-0.005360093,
-0.0028312337,
-0.022821201,
-0.0099397162,
-0.0193465222,
-0.0350277759,
0.0191123746,
0.0291535128,
0.0017612682,
0.0275984928,
0.0022050885,
-0.0135284886,
-0.0226869714,
-0.0561615527,
0.0017414738,
0.0102395089,
-0.0291899871,
0.0372041278,
0.00063955,
-0.0109269237,
0.0269736703,
-0.0049125776,
0.0249847211,
0.008476262,
0.0800252929,
0.0016505356,
-0.0545382053,
-0.0058839037,
0.0643182546,
-0.0011648888,
-0.0432258509,
-0.0343174897,
0.0295841433,
0.0600907356,
0.0280073062,
0.0946334526,
-0.0105546312,
0.0142778251,
-0.0282565616,
0.0341758318,
0.0394176766,
-0.0364335068,
-0.0278661977,
0.0147341453,
-0.0208670124,
0.0043865573,
0.0495173931,
-0.0138580417,
0.0176552404,
0.0130763808,
-0.0063888268,
-0.0182317663,
-0.0579281896,
-0.0299161356,
0.0076160068,
-0.0430777296,
-0.0388568603,
-0.0329616405,
-0.0398327596,
-0.0273620673,
0.0186208226,
0.0180121493,
0.0309689175,
0.008259397,
0.0543482937,
-0.0255768858,
-0.0115279919,
-0.0100236135,
-0.0319312885,
0.068956174,
-0.0093962075,
0.0340504237,
-6.246232413e-33,
0.0106865978,
-0.0230101012,
-0.0032911515,
-0.0700403154,
-0.0197019111,
-0.00817848,
-0.0202616714,
0.0489424579,
0.0485149883,
0.0005979042,
0.0277647972,
0.0067998944,
0.0189833455,
0.0135675557,
0.0038650888,
-0.0095757712,
0.0311725475,
0.0084011666,
-0.0319258682,
0.0186011847,
0.0178139489,
-0.0058977692,
0.0463087931,
-0.0487435199,
0.022129273,
-0.0162729174,
-0.0511538386,
0.0012014234,
-0.0266249832,
0.0542864203,
-0.0580671802,
0.058230333,
0.0217866115,
-0.020638803,
-0.0451470166,
0.0250206552,
-0.0012985322,
0.0233363174,
-0.0005492487,
0.0537036583,
-0.0779335499,
0.007761478,
0.055068288,
-0.0220184959,
0.0152721833,
-0.0009098613,
0.0347251147,
-0.0355125666,
-0.0157445818,
0.050964497,
-0.0527554192,
-0.001020082,
0.0093000038,
-0.013369062,
0.061204534,
0.0545492172,
0.0034894552,
-0.0314556137,
-0.0513404869,
0.0253260601,
-0.035884954,
-0.0031487173,
0.0641776994,
0.0256245416,
-0.0012420578,
0.106255427,
0.0785859898,
0.0017109051,
-0.0000849985,
-0.0064257365,
0.0419528633,
0.0498310514,
0.031847585,
0.0264457576,
0.0316461362,
0.0095135057,
0.0327457972,
0.0032345227,
-0.0643749684,
-0.00781966,
0.1061847061,
0.0066914735,
-0.0457041264,
-0.0319373086,
0.003896228,
0.0073841037,
-0.0331840403,
-0.0140933413,
0.061125312,
-0.0047388505,
-0.0340167396,
0.0053001842,
0.09096542,
-0.0273740906,
-0.0057801767,
-0.0086699743,
-0.0174604096,
0.056654688,
0.0125152618,
-0.0032736324,
0.0420950018,
-0.0111999121,
0.0626330599,
-0.0179696232,
0.0402944498,
-0.0307915267,
-0.0071421452,
-0.0065239356,
-0.0505989343,
0.028211575,
-0.0250125714,
0.0193249788,
0.022437783,
0.0360283218,
0.0519198589,
-0.0368017554,
-0.029178869,
-0.0031741045,
0.0279239956,
0.0106478808,
-0.0257116146,
0.0059939953,
-0.0547416173,
-0.0126087582,
-0.0340485685,
0.0085931215,
-0.0585249662,
-0.0712789074,
0.0396050587,
-0.0614428483,
-0.0130111808,
-0.0229086634,
2.672e-7,
-0.0104474733,
0.0492828116,
0.0082789753,
-0.0224616285,
0.0339396745,
0.0201277528,
0.0055066268,
0.0264855307,
0.0177272037,
-0.0703400671,
-0.0419396497,
0.0248817988,
0.0798099339,
0.0427412689,
-0.0379402041,
-0.0442567281,
-0.0027220531,
0.0308746845,
-0.0764204413,
-0.0301760547,
0.0330337659,
0.0340696461,
0.0074394015,
-0.047959663,
0.0387082174,
-0.0590509735,
0.0298484862,
-0.0376986004,
-0.0039167837,
0.0100229261,
0.0421559364,
0.0118648494,
0.0161917005,
0.0332312882,
0.0208513662,
-0.0624948926,
0.0534584671,
0.0004726251,
-0.0282802619,
-0.0352934599,
-0.0145075796,
0.0135628656,
-0.0133294621,
-0.0512845106,
0.0713360086,
0.0174113661,
-0.0105804838,
-0.0175446849,
-0.0348025411,
-0.0510230362,
0.0684533864,
-0.0191977527,
-0.0247811545,
0.0349615254,
0.0287586525,
0.0298906416,
-0.0391665287,
-0.0462872759,
-0.0103105148,
0.0024263782,
-0.0348921902,
-0.0219825692,
-0.0068230485,
-0.0285065509,
-0.0407257117,
-0.1021612957,
-0.0314314812,
2.511389727e-34,
0.0232741926,
0.0057196235,
0.0570034645,
0.0034551802,
0.0319446959,
-0.0136454515,
0.0019016297,
-0.0172339715,
-0.0475953072,
-0.0507799648,
-0.0114615634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05130v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05130v2 | LB-KBQA: Large-language-model and BERT based Knowledge-Based Question and Answering System | 2024-02-05T16:47:17 | 2024-02-09T02:45:51 | Yan Zhao, Zhongyun Li, Yushan Pan, Jiaxing Wang, Yihong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI), because of its emergent abilities,
has empowered various fields, one typical of which is large language models
(LLMs). One of the typical application fields of Generative AI is large
language models (LLMs), and the natural language understanding capability of
LLM is dramatically improved when compared with conventional AI-based methods.
The natural language understanding capability has always been a barrier to the
intent recognition performance of the Knowledge-Based-Question-and-Answer
(KBQA) system, which arises from linguistic diversity and the newly appeared
intent. Conventional AI-based methods for intent recognition can be divided
into semantic parsing-based and model-based approaches. However, both of the
methods suffer from limited resources in intent recognition. To address this
issue, we propose a novel KBQA system based on a Large Language Model(LLM) and
BERT (LB-KBQA). With the help of generative AI, our proposed method could
detect newly appeared intent and acquire new knowledge. In experiments on
financial domain question answering, our model has demonstrated superior
effectiveness. | [
0.0609977134,
0.036613211,
-0.0136002861,
0.0348088518,
-0.0190194901,
0.0058330512,
0.004273579,
0.0422104038,
0.0410821959,
-0.0539513268,
-0.0063418751,
-0.0345908515,
-0.0500634573,
0.0502768196,
0.0270053502,
-0.0191735588,
0.0478242598,
-0.0181110855,
0.0576355904,
-0.0085672112,
0.0267923195,
0.0147846323,
-0.0040821945,
0.0228979718,
-0.0050713615,
-0.0334688164,
-0.025554562,
-0.0232710801,
0.0031399147,
0.0024378793,
-0.005590809,
0.0273211095,
0.0171522889,
0.0142833227,
0.0000016951,
-0.1084103882,
-0.0403715074,
-0.0207933132,
-0.0756391212,
-0.0108262431,
-0.0158416759,
0.0343540236,
0.0448551103,
0.0314701498,
-0.0614657365,
0.0497590527,
0.0160070211,
0.0599487871,
0.059636686,
0.0416172296,
0.000118758,
-0.0823810101,
0.0186530985,
-0.0067086192,
0.0303204414,
-0.0803806186,
0.0693261325,
0.0434847139,
0.0150710559,
0.019362133,
-0.0198553745,
0.0258417111,
-0.018812526,
-0.0170789082,
0.0178876314,
0.0100639798,
0.004401092,
-0.0081493333,
-0.0240532793,
0.0658738986,
0.0042936741,
0.0068392977,
0.0257271063,
-0.0202884935,
0.0108564608,
0.0264885798,
-0.0138658546,
0.0442130342,
-0.0277620498,
-0.0393897854,
0.0528645404,
-0.0057070618,
-0.0089143487,
0.0396767445,
-0.0624854639,
0.0299696289,
0.0253959876,
-0.0454749167,
-0.0103206467,
0.0072968481,
-0.0283372439,
-0.0736009851,
0.0079607544,
0.0773471221,
0.017874077,
0.0322832167,
-0.0056627695,
-0.0285469647,
0.0315462798,
-0.058097817,
-0.0435441621,
0.0363631546,
-0.0001029832,
0.0741789192,
-0.0056822808,
0.0417642854,
-0.0069576567,
-0.0318050757,
-0.0525435619,
-0.0165985189,
-0.0772567689,
-0.0373231955,
-0.062330097,
0.0843541995,
-0.0595687963,
-0.0497632213,
-0.0140715139,
0.0574891753,
0.0431474596,
-0.0020173371,
0.0283561852,
-0.0130686723,
0.0062056771,
-0.0109625366,
-0.0346633084,
0.0094621535,
-0.0659979656,
0.0198023468,
-0.0117311068,
-0.0210687034,
-0.0002705422,
0.0399398357,
0.0331291743,
-0.0237119067,
0.0102474261,
0.0098519875,
0.0164024606,
-0.0497105755,
-0.0409178771,
-0.0374464393,
-0.0388399772,
0.0046579018,
-0.0259690657,
-0.015493976,
0.0344683118,
0.0115488833,
-0.0348372199,
-0.0026979074,
0.0133698406,
0.0179874822,
0.0069964407,
0.0658979118,
-0.0005879507,
0.0022466297,
0.0526412725,
-0.0154008511,
0.010469947,
0.036481034,
-0.0039562173,
-0.0056634299,
0.0484309644,
0.0283973422,
-0.0118290894,
0.0435851067,
0.0064635756,
-0.0396209583,
0.0581293888,
0.0550647713,
-0.0236043781,
0.0346080661,
0.0116622411,
0.0572485849,
-0.0308540966,
0.0093775764,
0.044964429,
0.0313273072,
0.0085902354,
0.0402648598,
0.0200848412,
0.0701629668,
0.0219189432,
-0.0358657427,
0.02904501,
0.0009898988,
-0.0616885982,
0.0357402116,
-0.0104529941,
-0.0018386925,
-0.0398649387,
-0.0282155294,
-0.0165849738,
-0.0101383366,
-0.0098388726,
0.0127867861,
0.0353030749,
0.0054569603,
-0.0292904153,
0.0565441363,
-0.0125314174,
0.0003041361,
0.0105903279,
-0.0817845911,
0.0871840119,
0.0473257899,
0.0376916975,
-0.0279230233,
-0.032900624,
-0.022814678,
-0.0576268062,
0.057956174,
0.004865495,
-0.0245808568,
-0.0546058789,
-0.0408468507,
-0.0120623661,
0.0013634698,
-0.0193924215,
-0.0041261381,
-0.0041474239,
0.0328783095,
-0.0076105404,
-0.0447574072,
0.0516607948,
0.0272587314,
-0.0009465308,
-0.0249279663,
0.0030370725,
0.0018969437,
0.0074321479,
0.0529536642,
0.0137515739,
0.0171376839,
0.0050430764,
-0.0200332738,
-0.05900269,
0.010721989,
-0.0274661388,
-0.0752368644,
0.0298019014,
0.0275771432,
-0.014307037,
-0.0060877618,
-0.0064941351,
-0.04169273,
-0.0411861464,
-0.0495346114,
0.0204434842,
-0.0930632204,
-0.0302315596,
0.0229452699,
0.0034464253,
-0.0524922051,
0.116484344,
0.0217513777,
-0.0123258168,
0.0073218914,
0.0230816063,
0.023245113,
-0.0373132862,
-0.0120542701,
-0.0155465212,
-0.0256228037,
0.0133266626,
0.0391392894,
0.0229417905,
-0.030579621,
-0.0064131059,
-0.0862923563,
-0.0047091227,
-0.0153115671,
0.0234976169,
0.0167426653,
0.0277747065,
0.0051144054,
0.0018568983,
-0.0559401773,
0.0026249897,
-0.0047642258,
-0.0133652622,
0.0588364974,
0.0117155015,
-0.0236017276,
-0.0250038337,
0.0248073116,
-0.0140013946,
0.03463348,
0.0455162078,
-0.0105791278,
-0.0715780184,
-0.0092868777,
-0.0201229509,
0.0224351306,
0.0276534688,
-0.0100843273,
-0.0120087583,
-0.0246931072,
0.0287473258,
0.0411095321,
0.0300713927,
0.0315993838,
-0.0201298799,
0.0292332284,
-0.0600090362,
0.0399591029,
-0.0181542281,
0.0060198093,
-0.0234452281,
-0.0138054574,
0.0373399816,
0.04439722,
0.0154483225,
-0.0213992316,
-0.0722165257,
0.0065503865,
-0.0205990374,
-0.0294568501,
-0.0587616339,
-0.0006527818,
-0.0316538736,
0.0185905602,
0.0238108374,
0.004694703,
0.0712437853,
0.0177777279,
-0.0240379199,
-0.0737174153,
0.0107985558,
-0.0518780686,
0.0469749048,
-0.0468178689,
0.0375589691,
0.010852783,
-0.0361715145,
-0.0111758942,
-0.0212951824,
-0.0162983052,
-0.0253575966,
0.0374444984,
-0.0496901013,
0.0525927618,
0.0164105855,
-0.0184782166,
-0.0611598976,
-0.0679670051,
-0.0275905617,
0.0272245351,
0.0450918563,
-0.0048931269,
0.0178030115,
0.0345098153,
0.0225940179,
-0.0189206079,
-0.0101667931,
-0.0096387072,
-0.0270974077,
0.0888076574,
0.080078572,
0.0242350735,
0.0082580596,
0.0018948553,
0.0505046658,
0.0087580904,
-0.0206400398,
-0.0161855388,
0.0042708465,
-0.0184309166,
0.0167838316,
-0.0696859509,
-0.0001856652,
0.0110045113,
0.0230803471,
-0.00293999,
-0.0297975298,
0.1228421256,
0.0451122932,
0.0273075476,
-0.0271957107,
-0.0486346707,
-0.0095546423,
-0.0130727412,
0.0697347224,
-0.0655348599,
-0.0494974516,
-0.0357643701,
0.0137624331,
-0.0012014166,
-0.0109718628,
0.0034234426,
-0.1167206988,
0.0290332772,
-0.0648844019,
-0.007806879,
-0.0308322255,
-0.0044276887,
-0.0253413059,
-0.0005577272,
-0.0160374027,
0.0194847938,
-0.0120655112,
0.0162145048,
0.0272524916,
-0.0361223295,
-0.0036810355,
0.0207156632,
-0.0163177159,
0.0251820628,
0.0750030205,
0.0409646481,
-0.023981696,
-0.0251961593,
-0.0614591278,
-0.0568148755,
-0.0011711341,
-0.0095992582,
-0.0052510193,
-0.018918043,
-0.0087241791,
-0.0184060335,
0.0096005909,
-0.0465450659,
0.0101173511,
0.0289980918,
0.0414196886,
-0.0568086766,
-0.0073881904,
-0.0060670082,
0.00977284,
0.0190942455,
0.1167540476,
0.0049885134,
-0.0587981343,
-0.0082672546,
-0.0145432856,
-0.0239650961,
-0.050176546,
0.0145028848,
-0.0027911947,
0.015258274,
0.0221416391,
-0.1099122763,
-0.0392939672,
0.0362825766,
0.0212069135,
0.0078133484,
0.0237962082,
0.0544454493,
0.0330547988,
-0.0022254745,
-0.0277692229,
-0.0293583442,
0.0242705625,
-0.0383682325,
-0.0082709603,
0.050316833,
-0.0629920736,
-0.0638609007,
0.0118055437,
-0.0477313586,
-0.0121527137,
0.0106685422,
0.0202740971,
0.0107126581,
0.0009511342,
-0.0558177903,
0.0108030112,
0.0245977826,
-0.0061641736,
0.0026592084,
0.0261885002,
0.0173665471,
0.0649100989,
-0.0225789491,
0.0216385815,
-0.0622716323,
-0.0073922533,
0.0003855769,
0.0754898712,
-0.0864290446,
-0.049348034,
0.0184649862,
0.0325197838,
-0.0468979478,
0.0166330729,
-0.0179828666,
-0.0264376663,
-0.0098316157,
0.0062014344,
-0.0050165178,
-0.0365320258,
-0.0110667357,
0.0350688472,
-0.0326535739,
-0.0115270242,
0.0202544071,
-0.0467528254,
-0.0142825944,
-0.0041281255,
0.0251847636,
0.0192799065,
0.0285345595,
-0.0076393387,
-0.0527505912,
-0.0182535425,
-0.0056680227,
0.0096897203,
0.0248879679,
0.0038331777,
0.0670226067,
0.0273318607,
-0.0526625291,
0.0042973557,
0.0109510152,
-0.0297697354,
-0.0737254843,
0.0372156836,
0.0579085574,
0.0390488654,
0.0120315077,
0.0000453713,
-0.0196991246,
0.0062606591,
-0.001278594,
0.0111457407,
0.0323324017,
-0.0537221171,
0.0685448572,
-0.0000346539,
-0.0084870886,
-0.056275446,
0.0693598911,
-0.0206500478,
0.0314676799,
-0.0338949822,
-0.0062145111,
-0.0558529198,
-0.0102224359,
0.0408781543,
0.003408476,
-0.0187954474,
0.0476994403,
-0.0461099111,
-0.0073411702,
0.0212803558,
-0.0065617128,
-0.0021392317,
-0.0072269677,
0.0877642259,
0.0470588394,
0.0184909236,
-0.0493813381,
-0.0552594326,
0.055676423,
-0.0482695475,
-0.0135827297,
-0.0436896496,
-5.711839825e-33,
-0.0064497883,
0.0040254132,
0.0425688811,
-0.0598862693,
0.0075774151,
0.0033411202,
-0.0257421192,
-0.0319916904,
-0.0342613533,
0.0011442822,
-0.0100548333,
0.0239135921,
-0.0009249381,
0.0251162574,
-0.0151319215,
-0.0394575559,
0.0105791911,
-0.0256754849,
0.0314800516,
0.0053535006,
0.0336163975,
0.0418829694,
0.0073431726,
0.0046603871,
0.0091132428,
-0.0308340155,
-0.0260120779,
0.0488371365,
0.018354807,
0.0682817325,
-0.026816424,
0.0121684037,
0.02832295,
-0.0687709302,
0.0145758986,
0.0452906303,
-0.0587055944,
-0.0505754016,
0.0424583256,
0.0045545814,
-0.0461129993,
-0.0076738293,
-0.000313175,
-0.013760224,
0.0094397953,
0.0293836407,
0.0331877954,
-0.0068628425,
0.0160959028,
-0.0393881276,
-0.0554612651,
0.0130103696,
-0.01520631,
-0.0059093805,
-0.0143586854,
0.0509660617,
0.0053417361,
-0.0063424408,
-0.0197998416,
-0.0072510624,
0.0147582944,
-0.0142877288,
0.0119474204,
0.0348602645,
-0.0160096008,
0.0249534249,
-0.0479528569,
-0.0355152339,
-0.0181951523,
0.0046034614,
-0.0276414454,
0.0213490333,
0.0314398333,
0.02552085,
-0.0242135767,
0.0201559905,
-0.0524239391,
0.0292115789,
0.0231369529,
0.0290603004,
0.034423463,
-0.0155620743,
-0.0485381447,
0.0217270963,
-0.02541898,
0.0391477682,
-0.0464821421,
0.0128782904,
0.0429756194,
0.0089635663,
-0.0207853541,
0.0145013416,
0.0299609601,
-0.0422187448,
0.0085975304,
0.0413549617,
0.0126661863,
0.0136579247,
-0.0038110057,
0.0481991395,
-0.0489477888,
-0.0103600752,
0.0205275621,
-0.0123882992,
-0.0281466972,
0.0263977461,
-0.0152846789,
-0.0381295569,
-0.0077425167,
-0.0009671723,
-0.0045549613,
0.0096681211,
-0.058387503,
0.0019143666,
0.0084237223,
0.0574249066,
-0.0021484832,
0.0182751417,
0.0135719972,
0.0183437094,
-0.0302240904,
-0.0470968857,
0.0137881022,
0.0503537729,
-0.0437048301,
0.0212194566,
0.0213408023,
0.0498830937,
-0.032042522,
-0.0506221913,
0.0016433153,
0.0446165651,
2.499e-7,
0.0612794682,
0.0432218648,
0.0061500422,
0.0838619322,
-0.0005209188,
0.0372219607,
0.0376262851,
0.0337084383,
0.0000624596,
0.0066184867,
0.015028174,
0.029769633,
-0.0090205632,
-0.0546039902,
-0.1036114246,
-0.00908064,
-0.0027473946,
-0.0164118633,
-0.0622037686,
0.0419386402,
0.1064800397,
0.0672672763,
-0.007898259,
-0.0079277027,
0.006297579,
-0.0704984218,
0.0389265195,
0.0364360698,
0.0022882721,
0.0242751632,
0.0551571138,
-0.0191606339,
0.0201208536,
0.0475469269,
-0.0064094672,
0.0132898483,
0.0102555119,
0.03685892,
-0.0240212604,
-0.0203104652,
-0.015389855,
-0.0114515033,
0.0157107525,
-0.0681164786,
0.0776582062,
-0.013818616,
0.0066156783,
-0.0052611614,
-0.0252908859,
-0.018201787,
-0.0340645723,
-0.0132094547,
-0.0157426521,
-0.0160498824,
0.021210568,
-0.0211565588,
0.029538421,
-0.0558137223,
0.0324344486,
-0.0104272766,
-0.0410915166,
-0.0053513339,
-0.050100062,
-0.012456418,
0.043495737,
-0.0883627459,
-0.0041492828,
1.944678161e-34,
0.038303297,
-0.002144275,
-0.0159494765,
0.0671759993,
0.0505566709,
0.0289425608,
-0.0293012112,
0.0213306192,
0.0349493586,
-0.1216781288,
-0.0100447871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03181v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03181v4 | C-RAG: Certified Generation Risks for Retrieval-Augmented Language Models | 2024-02-05T16:46:16 | 2024-06-04T04:51:08 | Mintong Kang, Nezihe Merve Gürel, Ning Yu, Dawn Song, Bo Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | Despite the impressive capabilities of large language models (LLMs) across
diverse applications, they still suffer from trustworthiness issues, such as
hallucinations and misalignments. Retrieval-augmented language models (RAG)
have been proposed to enhance the credibility of generations by grounding
external knowledge, but the theoretical understandings of their generation
risks remains unexplored. In this paper, we answer: 1) whether RAG can indeed
lead to low generation risks, 2) how to provide provable guarantees on the
generation risks of RAG and vanilla LLMs, and 3) what sufficient conditions
enable RAG models to reduce generation risks. We propose C-RAG, the first
framework to certify generation risks for RAG models. Specifically, we provide
conformal risk analysis for RAG models and certify an upper confidence bound of
generation risks, which we refer to as conformal generation risk. We also
provide theoretical guarantees on conformal generation risks for general
bounded risk functions under test distribution shifts. We prove that RAG
achieves a lower conformal generation risk than that of a single LLM when the
quality of the retrieval model and transformer is non-trivial. Our intensive
empirical results demonstrate the soundness and tightness of our conformal
generation risk guarantees across four widely-used NLP datasets on four
state-of-the-art retrieval models. | [
0.0453021638,
0.0872656852,
-0.0007251919,
0.0122482684,
-0.0273931511,
-0.0001982843,
-0.0446386933,
0.0105691943,
-0.0166374967,
-0.0402286127,
-0.0158944465,
-0.0715529546,
-0.007401546,
-0.0201661531,
0.0177962761,
-0.0124880066,
0.086124599,
-0.0171960592,
-0.0147547815,
-0.000351016,
-0.0139932819,
-0.0218934435,
0.0190878287,
0.0344485193,
-0.0326955691,
0.0058764019,
0.0359091163,
0.0168935768,
0.0035539686,
-0.0023964529,
0.0210851077,
0.0484457985,
0.0019956632,
0.0599211529,
0.0000018877,
-0.0463964827,
-0.0507774688,
0.0242145155,
-0.0277477503,
-0.0096131302,
0.0374325402,
0.0098241763,
-0.0261016302,
0.0176467113,
-0.0200758018,
0.0069055166,
0.0464568548,
0.0519303717,
0.0482767634,
0.0580731258,
-0.0016991991,
-0.0178947356,
0.060043104,
-0.0423051342,
0.0444893651,
-0.0436514802,
0.0309360977,
0.0236863475,
-0.0263287835,
0.0305155721,
0.0127003845,
0.0768134072,
-0.0026322475,
0.0254492853,
0.0057357317,
0.0083843451,
-0.0610851124,
-0.010183109,
0.0012893737,
-0.0000149164,
0.0420776419,
-0.054931026,
-0.0284525957,
0.0253950469,
0.0230218768,
0.0928694978,
-0.0404124893,
0.0431630649,
-0.0033891269,
0.0425072797,
0.0146290204,
0.0061960951,
0.0499240421,
0.0019842037,
-0.0203307569,
0.0880273581,
0.0326021165,
-0.0497084223,
-0.0114260567,
0.0325542837,
-0.0185463056,
0.0104521979,
-0.0130141219,
-0.014258936,
0.0025414319,
0.0476295725,
-0.0219629817,
-0.0252596047,
0.0443410389,
-0.0399703421,
0.0223214272,
-0.005440786,
-0.028834397,
0.0252922401,
-0.0140801352,
0.0473496728,
-0.0302042626,
0.0079696327,
-0.0206161719,
-0.0055688727,
-0.0175409373,
-0.0438878685,
-0.0160197653,
0.0145235816,
-0.0381373093,
-0.0055923234,
-0.03755261,
0.0245969668,
-0.0189598799,
-0.0083786659,
-0.0081538139,
0.0209951326,
-0.0621651337,
-0.002220666,
-0.0311435964,
0.0156753622,
0.0204368979,
-0.0174287744,
0.0162503459,
-0.1035429686,
-0.0199883822,
0.0118771344,
-0.0175761692,
-0.0341562927,
-0.017754551,
0.046993766,
0.0246501528,
-0.0348137245,
-0.0228100605,
-0.0446301363,
-0.0576408915,
-0.0365183279,
0.00961811,
-0.0674905255,
-0.006379893,
0.0102572795,
-0.007300253,
-0.0552555844,
0.0033089544,
0.0416227616,
-0.0681261793,
0.05494247,
0.0151232211,
0.0157284494,
-0.0169809479,
-0.0018949161,
0.0115001407,
0.0478431955,
0.0238317903,
-0.0165931508,
0.0920991302,
0.0186560508,
0.0508113541,
0.0423204564,
0.020601809,
0.0493872091,
-0.0364440605,
0.0083546238,
0.0361293629,
-0.0347115025,
-0.0176054742,
0.0910324454,
-0.0211857166,
-0.0464592874,
0.0469031185,
0.0206200574,
0.0389087871,
-0.0113335,
-0.0012472572,
-0.0095013371,
-0.0068422696,
0.0429604836,
-0.0506404899,
-0.0218384173,
-0.0738899559,
0.0014621563,
0.0442444794,
-0.0124329543,
-0.0299650244,
-0.0249070413,
-0.0441232435,
0.0124177244,
0.019234864,
-0.0254027154,
0.0139915431,
0.0159519892,
-0.0139871156,
0.0833976567,
0.020374136,
-0.0789258331,
0.0101058315,
-0.0651263818,
0.0173802711,
0.0412652083,
0.0718340129,
-0.0123901404,
0.0262643415,
0.0108418949,
-0.0081093824,
0.0157317426,
0.0391807817,
0.0076529011,
0.0133260712,
-0.0226779468,
-0.0057885037,
0.0384421013,
0.0300289132,
-0.0139723662,
0.0564776696,
-0.0139226653,
0.0221466161,
-0.0570575371,
-0.0426408798,
0.0304756425,
-0.0283050444,
-0.0282142013,
-0.0326402374,
-0.0111723989,
0.011090843,
-0.0052786311,
-0.0267361552,
0.0420693047,
0.0493381023,
0.0126703391,
-0.0414686091,
0.0156826563,
-0.0302554686,
0.0168940928,
0.0068274057,
0.0049382886,
0.0572065935,
0.0113271466,
0.010258629,
-0.046213828,
0.0140263028,
-0.0393745266,
0.0631422028,
-0.0377236381,
0.0459924228,
-0.0033000568,
0.0417812616,
-0.0491112769,
0.0680430159,
-0.0238433983,
0.0383284949,
-0.0033375614,
0.0095568979,
0.00006684,
-0.0314068943,
-0.0673117042,
0.0185732227,
-0.0206949059,
0.0444206111,
0.0671076849,
-0.0346149877,
-0.0276931133,
-0.0258429926,
-0.0282352585,
0.0185683537,
-0.039755404,
0.0118603567,
-0.0041794479,
-0.010697078,
-0.0154174119,
-0.0020146626,
-0.0167338699,
-0.0164102633,
0.0294160992,
0.0738423541,
0.0135896839,
0.0016162677,
0.025239503,
-0.0221018512,
-0.0500123203,
0.0107021425,
0.0814595222,
-0.0002634166,
0.0058016307,
-0.0760293379,
0.0787103772,
-0.0455655716,
0.0356412455,
-0.0055179303,
0.0085784029,
0.0185056664,
-0.0225786325,
0.0513964593,
0.0295235738,
0.0331753828,
0.014895956,
0.0125568891,
-0.0390242152,
-0.0691362172,
-0.0141441617,
-0.0420249179,
-0.0964246243,
0.0045484807,
-0.0338650532,
0.0357011557,
0.0117073236,
-0.0053153252,
-0.0476484895,
-0.0697818026,
-0.0009650265,
-0.0260535087,
-0.0006474196,
0.0204092152,
-0.01378401,
-0.0352319032,
0.0321421176,
-0.0237919409,
-0.0953554362,
0.0314341784,
-0.046728231,
0.0225216448,
-0.0268645566,
-0.0049073813,
-0.0088006109,
0.0480920859,
-0.0118548134,
-0.000300419,
0.0224696919,
-0.002352095,
-0.0409605764,
-0.0054141087,
0.0157581232,
-0.0606367439,
0.0634208471,
-0.0237810016,
0.0353083946,
0.0068444028,
-0.0257654116,
-0.0570164546,
-0.0456715003,
0.0295761693,
0.0044723167,
0.0022409461,
-0.0140712168,
-0.0379363522,
0.0176350866,
0.0229862481,
0.0124570495,
-0.0263142306,
-0.0241459627,
-0.0120551595,
0.0289027225,
0.0510369577,
-0.0368439294,
0.0399681479,
-0.035812173,
-0.038223166,
0.0551805645,
0.05625806,
0.0061639422,
-0.0145655889,
-0.041346617,
0.0536481962,
-0.0015421675,
-0.0445339158,
0.0309489053,
0.0299591161,
-0.0350826196,
-0.0187725015,
0.0684605911,
0.0254348908,
-0.0299980175,
-0.0178740639,
-0.0070729414,
0.0476115234,
0.0223888326,
-0.0045402744,
-0.0663954318,
0.0042151348,
0.026635265,
0.0505004115,
0.0016379005,
-0.0238063298,
-0.0008350375,
-0.1155138686,
0.0388824865,
0.0055987462,
0.0176246092,
-0.0103627983,
-0.0448079035,
0.002682921,
-0.0287210699,
0.0429373123,
0.0282384586,
-0.0258317273,
-0.0112399729,
0.0224144291,
0.0157857202,
-0.0503178462,
0.014773543,
-0.0500523262,
0.0299628228,
0.0712131485,
-0.0032105567,
-0.0141308634,
-0.0838265121,
0.0073800106,
-0.0578536987,
0.0009370152,
0.0157330912,
0.0439061895,
-0.0062393527,
0.0050232238,
-0.0197851565,
-0.0179676283,
-0.0115112904,
-0.0101723624,
-0.0463101789,
0.0188698135,
-0.027909996,
-0.0218666736,
-0.0384080075,
-0.0014362923,
0.0075403033,
0.0815858245,
-0.0153111937,
-0.0090471972,
-0.0143653266,
-0.0318993852,
0.0549464338,
0.0164684411,
-0.0075986004,
0.0261844322,
0.0034630192,
-0.0322415382,
-0.0862927586,
-0.0045986613,
-0.0698315576,
0.0511805117,
0.0026469526,
0.0090215812,
-0.0355334282,
-0.0212233346,
-0.037518166,
0.0485203862,
-0.0702620372,
-0.0014555044,
-0.0508606657,
0.0508195572,
0.0334262401,
-0.003080697,
-0.0273682401,
0.022207763,
-0.0544937178,
-0.0946287662,
0.0181144215,
0.038881138,
0.0381759554,
0.0427785441,
-0.0021567682,
-0.0450275317,
0.0331051722,
0.0435780212,
-0.0207200944,
0.028987851,
0.0307276547,
-0.0342828855,
-0.0099406745,
0.0292607844,
-0.0588954762,
-0.005455012,
-0.0153291924,
0.066793412,
0.0029030973,
-0.0422881804,
0.0171208251,
0.0216970984,
0.0497518964,
-0.0035576108,
-0.0111756083,
-0.0198734179,
-0.0050605247,
-0.0225438885,
-0.0155200846,
-0.0204843059,
0.0292816646,
0.0166900232,
-0.0302708987,
-0.0157751273,
0.0226048976,
-0.0017814218,
0.0705377385,
-0.0308134314,
-0.0293992218,
-0.0082011763,
-0.0171953049,
0.0392353684,
0.0108306026,
-0.0099526839,
0.0221095625,
-0.0184486602,
0.0396136008,
0.0038316499,
0.0311248768,
0.0054515516,
-0.0135632819,
-0.002570197,
-0.002632245,
-0.0923199281,
-0.0226906613,
-0.0147635322,
-0.0049104029,
0.01259067,
-0.0004817305,
0.0798512697,
-0.0338039957,
0.0003277537,
-0.0386765823,
-0.0082738623,
0.0398631953,
-0.0543677062,
0.0191386677,
0.0127891311,
-0.0294023324,
0.0500875786,
0.0564521067,
-0.0071107317,
0.0228818227,
-0.0834598169,
-0.0526852831,
-0.0138887009,
-0.0404404253,
0.0011239002,
-0.007041838,
-0.0046302229,
-0.0074557555,
-0.0763443485,
-0.077630043,
0.0406244658,
-0.0007521131,
0.0242629815,
-0.0075777424,
-0.0076164035,
0.0938667133,
0.0097851586,
0.0108149936,
-0.0522340611,
-0.0137738548,
-0.0218285937,
0.0270901676,
-0.0259985924,
-6.798018278e-33,
0.0033824362,
-0.0045883101,
-0.0160444584,
-0.0642180368,
0.006301004,
0.0057365606,
0.0049042976,
0.0084273675,
-0.0170908272,
-0.0384699889,
-0.0297157504,
0.038786836,
0.0241459813,
0.0305089597,
-0.0115159396,
-0.0115925763,
0.039420981,
0.0074578924,
-0.0396381617,
0.007936419,
0.0899986178,
0.0048734001,
0.0542246066,
-0.0376128182,
0.0713429973,
-0.0217069089,
-0.0037787291,
0.0189059582,
0.0039018616,
0.0716087446,
-0.0151014524,
0.0536743477,
0.0099547459,
-0.0514138266,
0.0140203023,
-0.0084655257,
-0.0640539899,
0.0038950015,
0.0085933357,
-0.0045062155,
-0.0020046372,
-0.0219298489,
0.050785467,
-0.0268471986,
-0.0323302709,
0.0164433811,
0.0251915026,
-0.0336504877,
-0.0472440608,
-0.0214693248,
-0.014599124,
0.0304870624,
0.0382509083,
-0.0012315992,
-0.003060244,
0.0657762736,
0.0185025241,
0.0113949915,
-0.0722904131,
0.0143947834,
0.0039630174,
0.0605079457,
0.052421879,
0.0027084476,
0.0073173116,
0.0625709221,
-0.0116902944,
-0.0143496785,
-0.0145106744,
-0.0712131411,
0.0451179892,
0.0367636681,
0.0120944092,
0.039554026,
0.0341172256,
-0.0289367046,
-0.0317145921,
0.0370349139,
-0.0057702018,
0.0589215085,
0.0580883473,
0.0199934635,
-0.0973122939,
-0.0308971554,
-0.0563428812,
-0.0225037038,
-0.0287546888,
-0.0175481569,
0.0426823944,
0.0411296226,
-0.035903722,
0.0064074192,
0.0504631735,
-0.0472973026,
-0.0278759692,
0.0367921963,
-0.029496843,
-0.0275626462,
-0.0476938784,
0.0541113131,
0.0277439505,
-0.0156248892,
0.0237951465,
-0.003559435,
-0.0250995345,
0.0214569923,
0.0365389101,
0.0301471855,
-0.0764403194,
0.0040479116,
-0.022198163,
0.0306069162,
-0.0004463368,
-0.0173511729,
0.0602726005,
0.0164336171,
0.0096195797,
0.0410869569,
0.0430859067,
0.0401863419,
-0.0085595855,
0.0207572524,
0.0085154288,
-0.0012065276,
0.0107433675,
0.0333331302,
-0.0099697066,
0.0551678836,
0.0376174748,
-0.0334219933,
-0.0048220148,
0.0365395248,
2.749e-7,
0.0606343299,
0.0200822428,
0.036936719,
0.0046019601,
0.0096994946,
0.0128273508,
0.0065198489,
0.0127925044,
0.0111687547,
0.0029172827,
-0.0475149006,
0.0030751689,
0.0449797809,
0.0298227463,
-0.0533555672,
-0.035494104,
-0.0733374134,
0.026511535,
-0.0228001829,
-0.0151824495,
0.046200484,
0.0788250938,
-0.0139460508,
-0.0164903272,
-0.0396603346,
-0.0641644672,
0.0826684609,
-0.0099757956,
-0.0142814759,
0.0121947937,
0.0571193993,
0.0769706368,
0.0336457007,
-0.0086101992,
-0.0160077196,
0.0182842296,
0.0101446072,
0.040390972,
0.0158036686,
-0.0590074211,
-0.0069449316,
-0.0380065478,
-0.0246718377,
-0.0343602188,
0.0582632683,
-0.0286719054,
-0.0066130036,
-0.0330566578,
-0.0524287969,
0.0220899004,
0.0202477798,
-0.0097755725,
-0.0297186393,
0.009004036,
-0.0103340894,
0.0631511062,
-0.0211866833,
-0.0825335085,
-0.0243045762,
-0.0089648226,
-0.0161853414,
-0.0480751321,
-0.0089058103,
-0.0114547461,
-0.0453155935,
-0.0798580423,
0.0192763656,
2.969861682e-34,
0.0386429429,
-0.0024999771,
0.0148159182,
-0.0290192775,
0.0366466157,
-0.0225916021,
0.015501881,
0.0335729495,
-0.0063246903,
-0.0899908245,
-0.0264955331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03177v1 | CIDAR: Culturally Relevant Instruction Dataset For Arabic | 2024-02-05T16:44:17 | 2024-02-05T16:44:17 | Zaid Alyafeai, Khalid Almubarak, Ahmed Ashraf, Deema Alnuhait, Saied Alshahrani, Gubran A. Q. Abdulrahman, Gamil Ahmed, Qais Gawah, Zead Saleh, Mustafa Ghaleb, Yousef Ali, Maged S. Al-Shaibani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Instruction tuning has emerged as a prominent methodology for teaching Large
Language Models (LLMs) to follow instructions. However, current instruction
datasets predominantly cater to English or are derived from English-dominated
LLMs, resulting in inherent biases toward Western culture. This bias
significantly impacts the linguistic structures of non-English languages such
as Arabic, which has a distinct grammar reflective of the diverse cultures
across the Arab region. This paper addresses this limitation by introducing
CIDAR: https://hf.co/datasets/arbml/CIDAR, the first open Arabic
instruction-tuning dataset culturally-aligned by human reviewers. CIDAR
contains 10,000 instruction and output pairs that represent the Arab region. We
discuss the cultural relevance of CIDAR via the analysis and comparison to
other models fine-tuned on other datasets. Our experiments show that CIDAR can
help enrich research efforts in aligning LLMs with the Arabic culture. All the
code is available at https://github.com/ARBML/CIDAR. | [
0.0173233021,
0.0518249348,
-0.0350287147,
0.016300898,
-0.0467048623,
0.0483283438,
0.0583537519,
-0.0422421061,
-0.0342093073,
-0.0082020452,
-0.0680139437,
-0.0840216354,
0.0497425385,
-0.0287353192,
0.0474615358,
-0.0419846885,
0.0237126909,
-0.054217279,
-0.0210500322,
0.0187499989,
0.0483091921,
0.0617255829,
-0.0204092916,
0.0405325033,
0.0021362377,
-0.0496076867,
-0.0123326117,
0.0041750809,
0.0207643472,
-0.0054345769,
0.0174487568,
0.0610790066,
0.0016458404,
-0.0070954813,
0.0000021587,
-0.0499905571,
-0.0006652465,
-0.0643668994,
-0.0077335853,
0.0586022735,
0.0646302179,
-0.0458002053,
-0.0444040298,
0.0002158079,
-0.0257004537,
0.000504679,
0.0533760861,
0.0270361602,
0.0414867662,
0.0598969162,
0.0317012407,
-0.0346214622,
-0.0270297229,
-0.006904671,
-0.0233284142,
0.0186263453,
0.0118957153,
0.0343160927,
0.0177395623,
0.0164516233,
-0.0617284179,
0.012975649,
0.0179261435,
-0.0389161557,
-0.0398212299,
-0.039535962,
-0.0566105843,
-0.0231448803,
0.0207781121,
0.0536873527,
0.0379424915,
-0.0160045177,
-0.0025499575,
-0.0034371957,
-0.0095928032,
-0.0061057559,
-0.0314134806,
0.0666887313,
-0.012937665,
0.0339252688,
0.0611732937,
-0.037756566,
-0.0060797147,
-0.0009502541,
0.0179001745,
0.0429358855,
0.0066784881,
-0.0227808766,
-0.0206034966,
0.0121993171,
0.0054254257,
-0.036378067,
0.0070909974,
-0.0057278932,
-0.0292043798,
0.0010222483,
-0.0488044694,
0.0091614239,
0.0254690982,
-0.0476185232,
0.0815800056,
0.097802937,
-0.0032013173,
-0.0039350628,
-0.0003415551,
0.0463386886,
0.0396292061,
0.0419188924,
-0.0712365434,
0.0480208397,
-0.045791585,
0.0056118141,
-0.0038720593,
-0.0072008795,
-0.0524536707,
0.0372150801,
-0.0773585066,
0.0159984101,
-0.0466514677,
0.0102134896,
0.0151527822,
-0.0479859039,
-0.0258315392,
0.0066856914,
0.0049862154,
0.015658699,
-0.029390661,
0.0156715773,
-0.0502117872,
-0.0768963024,
0.0128369574,
0.008810889,
-0.002342381,
0.0227813292,
-0.0050176634,
0.0244793408,
-0.0055356296,
-0.0305438824,
-0.0688992217,
0.0379614606,
0.0161070917,
-0.0234478805,
-0.0125958938,
-0.0588564761,
0.0411842726,
0.0065242895,
-0.0166194383,
-0.0349783599,
-0.0210212395,
0.0335770212,
0.0498246588,
0.0086404886,
0.0499891229,
0.0231914334,
0.0577992611,
0.0064357645,
0.0209157504,
0.0844594017,
0.0388200805,
-0.0469310023,
0.0296349023,
-0.0380401462,
-0.0127446447,
0.0334697329,
-0.0018665268,
0.0363088772,
-0.0270649511,
-0.0106082186,
0.0307157356,
0.0488807932,
0.009692125,
0.0204906166,
-0.0058995485,
-0.0062338095,
0.0399112739,
-0.0020829409,
-0.0408189557,
0.0200467166,
0.0746585876,
0.0408265702,
0.0363253951,
0.0217321571,
-0.0249983966,
0.0145990876,
0.0223575775,
0.0083768424,
-0.0101477755,
0.0910553932,
-0.0468265265,
-0.0542549677,
0.0010075716,
0.008246976,
0.0315932035,
-0.0021325522,
0.0619182624,
0.0064120698,
-0.0115975291,
0.006872782,
0.060023509,
-0.0134244775,
0.0090275705,
-0.0216577984,
0.0184770823,
0.0445312001,
0.0028636197,
-0.0064984527,
-0.0509303585,
0.0024665901,
0.088552542,
0.02710253,
0.0357845537,
-0.028371416,
-0.0035221688,
-0.0703473836,
-0.0370659605,
-0.0037537334,
0.0080616716,
-0.0162400603,
0.035826318,
0.0196937844,
-0.0193070285,
0.004309718,
-0.0649467334,
0.0378556363,
-0.0625899807,
0.0082460307,
-0.0115735,
-0.0067629418,
0.0000098502,
0.0465454273,
-0.0144391209,
-0.0072099012,
0.0125760343,
-0.016100714,
0.0407860205,
-0.0203314275,
-0.0784152895,
-0.0042339312,
0.0236958675,
-0.0177089814,
-0.0265057683,
0.0037288894,
-0.0423295498,
-0.031172147,
0.0750830472,
-0.0080457721,
0.0321410298,
0.0100505603,
0.0438124649,
-0.0062428061,
-0.0021057231,
-0.0180115681,
0.0112566948,
-0.0360937677,
0.0010545657,
0.0099936258,
0.0174752139,
0.0165758263,
0.0019365789,
0.0217931215,
0.0036504925,
-0.0155991204,
-0.002470938,
0.0514511392,
0.0544911139,
-0.030690942,
-0.0409621447,
-0.039789401,
-0.0204079784,
-0.0158534963,
0.0508785881,
-0.0013878831,
-0.0022013527,
-0.0318926722,
-0.0134263961,
-0.047631342,
-0.0661855787,
-0.0034276114,
0.0162336398,
0.0386506468,
-0.0243634768,
-0.0372825712,
-0.0357574597,
-0.03964049,
0.0177560076,
0.0284319464,
0.0036672889,
0.0081256144,
-0.0048386054,
-0.019749729,
-0.0192809645,
0.0025479002,
-0.0017397621,
-0.0534000583,
0.0364447162,
0.0340363346,
0.0545404702,
0.0613088459,
-0.023382077,
0.0042950576,
0.0358719826,
-0.0080693252,
-0.0636664182,
-0.0118136415,
0.0090610469,
-0.0216165297,
-0.0340949036,
-0.0911872387,
-0.0463953838,
0.0426332876,
-0.0046981541,
-0.0142124072,
-0.0456032977,
0.0301553011,
-0.036408525,
0.0009395914,
0.0065172855,
-0.0138093773,
0.0010697297,
0.0485884249,
-0.0476098247,
-0.064205654,
0.0407849066,
0.0037881513,
-0.0056490805,
-0.0295229368,
0.028971523,
-0.0567801185,
-0.0285438467,
-0.0261839591,
0.0161673576,
-0.003170199,
-0.0244096071,
-0.0558656976,
0.0129606212,
0.0380560793,
-0.0034551795,
0.0147741605,
-0.0842685699,
-0.0282986052,
-0.0060254964,
-0.0312499609,
-0.0125895096,
0.0355285667,
-0.0068751071,
-0.0086275768,
0.0429978184,
-0.0169005524,
-0.0446794704,
-0.02117116,
0.0409590453,
0.0191872772,
-0.0143026747,
0.0345884226,
0.0002339471,
-0.088646248,
0.0491454005,
-0.0149080371,
-0.0098798666,
-0.0316120535,
0.0215971712,
0.0336412117,
0.0132774105,
-0.0409326367,
-0.0360965431,
0.032901682,
0.0619289391,
-0.0035735178,
-0.0272952933,
-0.0212812256,
0.0475763753,
-0.0479886457,
0.0179160032,
0.0890519395,
0.0251264181,
-0.0474300794,
0.0223956667,
-0.0208048951,
0.0036787351,
0.0037591921,
0.0027965445,
-0.1247339472,
0.0106055681,
0.0154292472,
0.0225620363,
0.0035876441,
0.0152761042,
0.0117705688,
-0.0913334563,
-0.0073557869,
0.0260851812,
-0.0545548499,
-0.0633919761,
-0.0408581607,
-0.0155412508,
-0.030728342,
0.0211452786,
-0.0184088871,
-0.0317456201,
0.0320524722,
0.0564383119,
-0.0225996021,
-0.0905934349,
0.039059706,
-0.0231302828,
0.063985385,
0.03672342,
-0.018570926,
0.015893111,
-0.0481251255,
0.0022005131,
-0.0166157801,
-0.0550540052,
0.002901274,
-0.0234168954,
0.0078755245,
-0.0243137293,
-0.01547857,
0.0265242942,
-0.0655598789,
0.0098468922,
0.0036708154,
0.0375796258,
0.0010104985,
0.0390434824,
0.0018206799,
0.0219074991,
-0.0197207332,
0.0384722911,
0.015418916,
-0.0638431385,
-0.0018299875,
-0.0480429642,
-0.0495883524,
-0.0514325351,
-0.0360237323,
0.0154157002,
-0.0556388088,
0.0237777736,
-0.0480052456,
-0.0557612479,
0.0419547781,
-0.0069693932,
0.040495906,
-0.0093278242,
0.0275615826,
0.0020146831,
0.0065695415,
0.0278987549,
0.003988402,
0.0151463021,
-0.0900672823,
-0.0833172128,
0.0012080522,
-0.0575824268,
0.037684679,
0.0006872904,
-0.0510464124,
-0.0487282723,
0.0392153189,
0.0395917632,
-0.0021726196,
0.0245319102,
0.0613001361,
-0.0368894786,
-0.0296869129,
-0.0309806354,
0.0073974212,
0.0204557925,
0.0185968634,
-0.01250643,
-0.0102532739,
0.0326616168,
0.0083078528,
0.0397607647,
0.0412607566,
0.0203789044,
-0.0391026139,
0.0175494365,
0.0151024247,
-0.0214398652,
-0.0007161068,
-0.0502919629,
-0.0328407362,
-0.0770533085,
0.0108298967,
-0.056310948,
0.0120901354,
-0.0361274108,
0.0086661382,
-0.001918537,
0.0201527756,
-0.0076625138,
-0.0096051553,
0.0135270543,
-0.0103297066,
-0.0226274692,
0.0819353685,
0.0089116041,
0.0277603697,
-0.0194146968,
0.0505357459,
-0.008131762,
-0.0189528223,
-0.0368556939,
0.0406789184,
0.0032110403,
0.0717740878,
-0.0039156205,
0.0492093042,
0.0541413687,
0.0526225306,
0.0278004482,
0.0194160081,
-0.0073529081,
0.0366669558,
0.0307856407,
-0.0475670882,
0.0547556207,
0.0226311125,
0.0118968775,
-0.0284596384,
0.0572892092,
-0.0053349845,
-0.0366020165,
0.0138559435,
0.0151704662,
-0.0046410258,
-0.0192550998,
0.0612877086,
-0.0002617733,
0.0160613265,
0.0110347234,
0.0131196352,
0.0012344618,
-0.0222786069,
0.0498977005,
-0.0287028532,
-0.0263066515,
0.0208821073,
-0.0427958257,
-0.0622958988,
-0.068795152,
0.0423239246,
0.0030444241,
-0.0150009133,
0.0376095399,
0.0616298094,
-0.0326857269,
-0.0234956071,
-0.0731257871,
-0.0248095691,
-0.0226232801,
-0.0555475689,
0.0004523421,
-6.411512062e-33,
-0.0095707262,
0.0089950617,
0.034966711,
0.0129452934,
0.0208592974,
-0.0256858356,
-0.0232258439,
0.0059154225,
-0.003830069,
0.0082185995,
-0.0147469696,
0.0095481649,
0.00464836,
0.0233904049,
0.0806651115,
0.0152744493,
0.0214717928,
-0.0287713353,
-0.0135975908,
0.0441094376,
0.0170796681,
-0.0003888885,
0.1117166206,
-0.0340459123,
0.0386086814,
-0.0239301082,
-0.0086611025,
0.0110382624,
-0.0209321026,
0.1049159989,
-0.0030885579,
0.0401796289,
0.0107931653,
-0.0314088389,
-0.0212352257,
-0.0242575817,
-0.0562679917,
-0.029530894,
0.0183850788,
0.0529738851,
-0.0005142299,
-0.0712367445,
-0.0225423705,
-0.0217350386,
-0.0720051527,
0.032278385,
0.0127725294,
-0.0168202873,
0.0173675977,
0.0290782675,
-0.0767212361,
0.0389742628,
-0.0235271566,
-0.0097368509,
0.0257595275,
0.0684804022,
-0.0116924411,
-0.0435068198,
-0.0364348106,
0.0495782569,
0.0476394333,
0.0655511841,
0.1096307114,
0.0195695478,
-0.0264128186,
0.0284534693,
0.0163643658,
-0.0039435891,
0.0686730891,
0.023082396,
0.0313024223,
-0.0362656154,
-0.0141627938,
0.066005066,
0.0018670462,
0.0003751162,
-0.0430133753,
0.0057218936,
0.0034288706,
0.0288427677,
0.0059270933,
-0.0267255679,
-0.0723289102,
-0.035885077,
0.0169679485,
0.0044723619,
0.003512068,
-0.0000462316,
0.0193704255,
0.0056559136,
-0.0280545,
0.0116998656,
0.0024706379,
0.0120872436,
0.033083111,
-0.0072184294,
-0.0043854048,
-0.039869234,
0.0076028151,
0.0036830916,
-0.0845184028,
-0.0672278628,
0.0020827239,
-0.0124421837,
0.0324751697,
0.0299266744,
0.0416660868,
0.0495043062,
-0.0653244928,
0.0213320646,
-0.0325963497,
0.0543121658,
0.0071826512,
0.0035392528,
0.0218293387,
-0.0068496964,
-0.0346709006,
0.0538709611,
0.0353806727,
-0.0260477345,
-0.0164146218,
-0.0632820353,
-0.0358638205,
0.0103896586,
-0.0060302475,
0.0159514565,
-0.0753314793,
0.0018185768,
0.0074368105,
-0.038186606,
-0.0104782069,
0.0086477799,
2.854e-7,
0.0273872036,
0.0435548387,
0.0088911317,
0.0307194293,
0.0026610466,
-0.0033586416,
-0.0081151305,
-0.0040036286,
0.0407554768,
0.03708883,
0.0072886185,
0.0047368961,
0.0621995963,
-0.0259850472,
-0.0776586831,
-0.0048443559,
-0.0363705792,
0.0544514433,
-0.0531973653,
-0.0065551242,
-0.0120547507,
0.1175741255,
-0.0377844647,
0.0101666227,
-0.0756313428,
-0.000532935,
0.0274711624,
-0.0325443782,
-0.0040023304,
0.0287511405,
0.0241932496,
-0.073078014,
0.0111728776,
-0.0100985663,
-0.043429859,
-0.00213861,
-0.0019743638,
0.0963194221,
0.0282040499,
0.0169713981,
0.0399472266,
0.0228210911,
-0.0563849993,
-0.0499893613,
0.0282146819,
0.0200441275,
-0.0208940022,
0.0269343853,
-0.0030003011,
0.0212340876,
0.0261846203,
-0.0205496214,
0.0115903039,
0.025770545,
0.0360971801,
-0.0425427519,
0.0168997739,
0.0052837841,
0.0178807657,
0.010972756,
0.0213705711,
-0.0328821391,
0.0172060542,
-0.0148286344,
-0.0521606915,
0.027034007,
-0.0028930216,
2.410229255e-34,
0.0159392767,
-0.0307304412,
0.0372074582,
0.0001368248,
0.0285377521,
-0.0208753254,
-0.0319365524,
0.0217152536,
0.0198217053,
-0.0389810205,
-0.0219586845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03173v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03173v2 | MULTI: Multimodal Understanding Leaderboard with Text and Images | 2024-02-05T16:41:02 | 2024-02-20T07:55:52 | Zichen Zhu, Yang Xu, Lu Chen, Jingkai Yang, Yichuan Ma, Yiming Sun, Hailin Wen, Jiaqi Liu, Jinyu Cai, Yingzi Ma, Situo Zhang, Zihan Zhao, Liangtai Sun, Kai Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Rapid progress in multimodal large language models (MLLMs) highlights the
need to introduce challenging yet realistic benchmarks to the academic
community, while existing benchmarks primarily focus on understanding simple
natural images and short context. In this paper, we present MULTI as a
cutting-edge benchmark for evaluating MLLMs on understanding complex tables and
images, and reasoning with long context. MULTI provides multimodal inputs and
requires responses that are either precise or open-ended, reflecting real-life
examination styles. MULTI includes over 18,000 questions and challenges MLLMs
with a variety of tasks, ranging from formula derivation to image detail
analysis and cross-modality reasoning. We also introduce MULTI-Elite, a
500-question selected hard subset, and MULTI-Extend, with more than 4,500
external knowledge context pieces. Our evaluation indicates significant
potential for MLLM advancement, with GPT-4V achieving a 63.7% accuracy rate on
MULTI, in contrast to other MLLMs scoring between 28.5% and 55.3%. MULTI serves
not only as a robust evaluation platform but also paves the way for the
development of expert-level AI. | [
-0.0066257706,
0.0658739358,
-0.0053129257,
0.0825280547,
-0.0435130484,
0.0266301688,
0.0345305018,
-0.0066703833,
0.0008617963,
-0.0590788759,
-0.0473195985,
-0.0155858584,
-0.0202055927,
0.0380306505,
0.0502044708,
-0.0390887782,
0.0302360449,
-0.060030058,
-0.0143049061,
0.0023142709,
0.0126340119,
-0.0029162171,
-0.0462557375,
0.0274011046,
-0.0222006496,
-0.0502535403,
-0.0163360555,
-0.0025136215,
0.0060925833,
-0.0121695129,
-0.0250927322,
0.0591835789,
0.0695445985,
0.0286741462,
0.0000019461,
-0.04001268,
-0.0154212425,
-0.0078548593,
-0.0230631009,
0.0101071103,
0.0248543397,
-0.0300952308,
0.0271084569,
-0.0456460454,
-0.0457838885,
-0.0092667937,
0.0240410753,
0.0549834743,
0.0757054016,
0.0420969389,
-0.0130745955,
-0.0447828546,
0.0170599073,
-0.0100294994,
0.0460328199,
-0.0824361816,
0.0151755307,
0.0557244159,
0.0074127442,
-0.0176930614,
-0.0625397861,
0.053891845,
0.0478552058,
-0.0067080958,
-0.0146832196,
0.0477736816,
-0.0021414708,
-0.0229096003,
-0.0126753571,
0.1251591891,
-0.0065542865,
0.0086378567,
-0.0219937284,
0.013047873,
0.0014078814,
-0.004380798,
-0.0642744228,
0.0512856655,
-0.0097540971,
-0.0188735239,
-0.0214766432,
-0.0152551075,
0.0231866911,
0.0113406368,
-0.0271271002,
0.0312577374,
0.0138821127,
-0.019523114,
0.0278542005,
-0.0075391447,
-0.0641815737,
-0.0288249347,
0.0095414044,
0.0318482518,
-0.0189410485,
0.0250360444,
-0.0086701615,
-0.0557527691,
-0.0015642501,
-0.0317220613,
0.0168593973,
0.0237422176,
-0.0417304747,
0.0868074819,
-0.0355319045,
0.0622134134,
-0.0278057102,
0.0142950807,
-0.0220121741,
-0.012335103,
-0.0406672843,
0.0060416991,
-0.0093364911,
0.0017153564,
-0.0702972859,
-0.0456879884,
-0.0098922523,
0.0093310652,
-0.0199921113,
0.0465714782,
-0.0005312642,
0.0136509286,
-0.0158376861,
-0.0317100435,
-0.0046732142,
0.040678516,
-0.0451651961,
-0.0045594829,
-0.0100794481,
-0.041666612,
0.0113122771,
0.0249482021,
-0.0046785288,
-0.0424930379,
0.0121797146,
0.0945373103,
-0.0412829481,
-0.0241535045,
0.0271275286,
-0.0305236913,
-0.0128522227,
-0.0966030285,
0.0362081863,
-0.0390000865,
0.0587745085,
0.0084458524,
0.0021194818,
-0.0131157786,
0.001834012,
0.0059474963,
0.0037916622,
0.1020146459,
0.0378315002,
-0.0126210721,
0.0286754537,
0.0240503475,
-0.0257679988,
0.0763528571,
0.0212618355,
0.0223287735,
0.0319540501,
-0.0302306991,
-0.0063661025,
0.0656187907,
0.0012291335,
-0.0188411213,
-0.0311369002,
0.0444208123,
0.034637399,
0.0512751192,
0.0015733719,
0.0197691787,
-0.0277664587,
-0.0196571033,
0.0731524825,
0.0257571619,
0.0078126965,
-0.002047356,
0.0136957923,
-0.025211649,
0.0269400347,
0.0061893701,
-0.0715760142,
0.0629722327,
-0.0109607419,
0.0177053809,
0.0210561641,
0.0239639077,
0.0125437016,
-0.0220748186,
0.0012833474,
0.0142768677,
-0.0282239784,
0.0434995443,
0.0597692952,
-0.0135919293,
-0.0564391278,
0.0081025138,
-0.0007476514,
-0.025834268,
0.0016108368,
-0.0089049125,
0.0258986168,
0.0398616455,
0.053101033,
-0.0344754532,
-0.0258530211,
-0.0068152007,
0.0281567369,
0.0273947939,
0.0075468319,
-0.0094185472,
0.0322390348,
-0.0562117361,
-0.0136912158,
-0.0150588807,
0.0071967533,
0.0028747222,
0.0054779048,
-0.0287755784,
-0.003927141,
-0.0628625602,
0.031165937,
0.0170412846,
0.0013018502,
-0.0117025943,
-0.0437540002,
0.0136553328,
0.0170329548,
0.0020791772,
-0.0091974176,
-0.0040380079,
0.019581452,
-0.0407914855,
0.030725332,
0.0012606318,
-0.0532991178,
-0.0214515179,
0.0385906249,
-0.0589719415,
-0.0637949556,
0.0297022332,
-0.0421205163,
-0.0098661631,
0.0113222254,
-0.0041324366,
-0.0088042058,
-0.0597815774,
-0.0228469316,
0.0262968242,
0.0287393015,
-0.0307639111,
0.085205622,
-0.0117220525,
0.005237693,
0.022392666,
-0.0282470845,
0.0125493631,
-0.0186585113,
-0.0097724721,
0.0205202736,
-0.0011305737,
0.0230191294,
-0.0226129405,
0.0137006622,
-0.0693037808,
-0.0073661641,
-0.1057500318,
0.0090574995,
-0.0220590625,
-0.0094393315,
0.022828592,
-0.0114185186,
-0.0075064912,
-0.0219892748,
-0.022810556,
0.0260609761,
0.00217476,
-0.0071077938,
0.0244330503,
0.0124905501,
0.0248807091,
-0.0226273183,
-0.0244331043,
-0.0303585362,
0.0862732381,
-0.0055173496,
0.0299341157,
0.0122390343,
-0.0095192343,
-0.0212119222,
0.0340912752,
-0.0350563526,
0.0039981231,
0.0247331019,
-0.0675326958,
0.053331282,
0.07978715,
-0.0015011086,
0.0365866087,
0.0110065127,
-0.0445687287,
-0.0437284596,
0.0268591736,
0.0300700702,
-0.0050821709,
-0.0208931472,
-0.0190143697,
-0.0325692147,
0.0540316366,
0.0022702173,
-0.0030210339,
-0.0294542778,
0.0157165062,
-0.004391321,
-0.0466678441,
-0.087965928,
0.0514837727,
0.0309416577,
0.0242274366,
-0.0532507598,
-0.0143589033,
0.0534230955,
-0.044768367,
-0.0130775217,
-0.0059240796,
0.0112808282,
-0.0425166823,
0.0985426977,
0.0284967329,
0.0181599632,
-0.0402245596,
-0.0037114052,
-0.0506679825,
0.0022994301,
0.0226012617,
-0.024658097,
0.0862891078,
-0.0752527043,
-0.0002838595,
-0.031535957,
-0.0292579141,
-0.0050805435,
-0.0245796703,
-0.03274424,
-0.0010871035,
-0.0107677411,
0.0028443481,
-0.0317409411,
0.0184091516,
0.0435770862,
0.0151734399,
-0.0088369865,
-0.0029944871,
-0.0333726108,
0.0565287136,
0.0568798445,
0.0330624282,
-0.0119120823,
-0.0921944603,
0.0297074821,
0.0197953638,
0.0356778987,
-0.0137179689,
-0.0456939451,
0.0480961092,
-0.0050685164,
0.0088925762,
0.0120682986,
0.0339200757,
0.0369670093,
-0.0577507764,
0.0316751152,
0.0977291018,
-0.010142318,
-0.0319102854,
-0.0313237123,
-0.0110787507,
0.0229284856,
0.0292512849,
0.0165438205,
-0.085263826,
-0.0524696447,
-0.0055414708,
-0.0348385349,
0.0525403433,
-0.0455431417,
0.0017522492,
-0.0829684287,
0.0450182222,
-0.0206424464,
-0.0863451362,
-0.0511002652,
-0.0039638965,
0.0032875028,
-0.0053074788,
0.0238859877,
0.0220195577,
-0.00187783,
0.0061159148,
0.0068439427,
0.0147994123,
-0.0332994945,
0.04231539,
-0.0521220788,
0.012134077,
0.0243639778,
0.0191580281,
-0.0234988239,
-0.0248335581,
0.0300551299,
-0.0014254471,
-0.0009235358,
0.0048081609,
0.0377015471,
-0.0174198095,
-0.0296547096,
-0.0171981566,
0.0184227247,
-0.0269006789,
-0.0016798516,
0.0239405837,
0.0916089192,
-0.0007201228,
-0.0153013319,
-0.0119432425,
0.0090118712,
-0.0194626395,
0.0716508552,
0.0254235193,
-0.0333238654,
-0.0541785397,
-0.0108450893,
0.0124021312,
-0.0518967286,
0.0068811453,
0.0400118791,
0.0117712235,
0.0123721529,
-0.0390432104,
-0.0306868739,
0.0547238737,
0.0634905472,
0.0050583053,
0.0106193013,
-0.0384609066,
0.0079669105,
-0.047310099,
0.0517921671,
-0.0279181134,
0.0203492809,
-0.015565794,
0.0264111292,
0.0011838081,
-0.0416867472,
-0.0308023114,
0.0515536554,
-0.0808929354,
-0.0221159365,
-0.0241678916,
0.0379200652,
0.0218205266,
0.0193959046,
0.0343755595,
-0.0453039706,
-0.0246716179,
-0.0117442049,
-0.0247751027,
0.0056586508,
-0.0008837977,
-0.0229659807,
0.0009886225,
0.022855375,
-0.0432391651,
0.0060038608,
0.0075284294,
0.0563737899,
0.004736132,
-0.0081002992,
0.0120449271,
0.0190672074,
-0.0092123402,
-0.000993337,
-0.0314948857,
-0.0260762274,
0.0207184404,
-0.0303348117,
-0.030925639,
-0.0234529842,
-0.0085544977,
0.0202506222,
0.0021063008,
0.0060633034,
0.0147690009,
0.0539701842,
0.0317043811,
-0.0511552505,
0.0166473556,
0.0367905572,
-0.0312498752,
0.0183711499,
-0.0156092839,
-0.0130461296,
0.0061219158,
-0.0100471489,
0.0399810784,
-0.0133639975,
0.09574534,
0.0310395565,
-0.0416406542,
-0.0141111305,
0.0225933641,
-0.0206096191,
-0.0333705358,
0.0096646668,
0.0474109314,
0.0784240961,
0.0131881181,
0.0066669234,
-0.0141353598,
-0.0105829798,
-0.0027600941,
0.0363517292,
0.0024789046,
-0.0260932911,
0.0621644668,
0.0342280045,
0.0555250682,
0.0027516086,
0.0602538176,
0.0117892977,
0.0307753067,
0.0218620375,
0.0311301071,
-0.0675619692,
-0.0245957654,
0.0134757394,
0.0184801333,
0.0007216478,
0.018195305,
-0.0381744131,
-0.0854944438,
0.0073664887,
0.0515013002,
-0.0276931617,
0.0257492624,
0.0291546844,
0.0871060863,
-0.0007989397,
-0.0516176745,
-0.0221136995,
0.0391646214,
-0.0150296213,
-0.004007563,
-0.0141626466,
-6.11222716e-33,
-0.0255313106,
-0.026699461,
0.0486684181,
-0.057174664,
-0.0168131161,
0.0187686402,
-0.0428448804,
-0.013858038,
-0.0034594908,
0.0084334323,
0.0044009876,
-0.0075874086,
-0.0062430156,
0.0249609984,
-0.0080576884,
-0.0360259674,
-0.0102979196,
-0.0083180927,
-0.0140170418,
0.0020689496,
-0.0078224568,
0.0326267406,
0.0391458273,
-0.0283298641,
0.027693741,
0.0211616214,
-0.0203489233,
0.0298252571,
-0.0316517875,
0.0585708134,
-0.0597105697,
0.0195891559,
0.0419263393,
-0.0381462537,
-0.0204263777,
0.0172252767,
-0.1025411934,
0.0038450281,
0.030418342,
0.0191174727,
-0.0851818025,
-0.00713313,
0.0586852394,
-0.0184599832,
0.0010600076,
-0.0526863113,
0.0456482917,
-0.0101972297,
0.0023633307,
0.0186088905,
-0.0350807272,
0.0041970978,
-0.0504617356,
0.0079253996,
0.0357965864,
0.0538856164,
0.0127299,
0.0313931182,
-0.0441505946,
0.0080097392,
-0.0189665277,
-0.0081223603,
0.1021365076,
0.0073767151,
0.0141464146,
0.0522763655,
0.0393538475,
-0.0202225372,
-0.0393375978,
-0.0297700129,
0.0238339342,
0.0916104317,
0.0538055822,
0.0709888041,
0.0107017793,
0.0449149422,
-0.0558416694,
0.011537388,
-0.0200895108,
0.043930307,
0.0125303334,
0.0049882545,
0.0003643993,
0.0219383035,
-0.0585960895,
0.0348603912,
-0.0521001816,
0.0044761533,
0.0511949249,
-0.0386736952,
0.0254898872,
0.0097046895,
0.0732078254,
-0.0318550952,
-0.015467315,
0.0044322885,
0.0365446322,
0.0490865819,
0.0116635384,
0.0475503094,
-0.018083116,
-0.0196271017,
0.0293526389,
-0.0123113254,
0.0346526578,
0.0019303999,
0.0098377327,
-0.0037886701,
-0.0089573637,
-0.035196919,
-0.0637820736,
-0.0067888354,
-0.0029578069,
0.0423172712,
0.0350558944,
0.013491679,
-0.0373633467,
0.0287557747,
-0.0001553464,
-0.0023570457,
-0.008192488,
-0.0170182008,
-0.0086566405,
-0.0008133186,
-0.0213783123,
0.0028478729,
-0.0291766208,
-0.0484489687,
0.0219492689,
-0.0634746104,
0.0263373405,
0.064424172,
2.555e-7,
0.0642602146,
0.0515920967,
0.0122438334,
0.0105190091,
0.0246884059,
0.037485145,
-0.0436083116,
0.007936676,
-0.0180052072,
-0.0548353344,
-0.0059909676,
0.0520428866,
0.0302572362,
0.0184408445,
-0.0211605038,
-0.0383093357,
-0.0223302115,
-0.0264294874,
-0.0676459968,
0.0411968157,
0.0714324415,
0.0520615131,
-0.0433914699,
-0.0279140361,
0.0096798064,
-0.0461006239,
0.0645816326,
-0.0588264391,
-0.0141712045,
-0.0185797624,
0.0158121251,
-0.0140159847,
-0.0065858089,
0.0586225837,
0.0170396995,
-0.0274166204,
0.0585185774,
0.0520702787,
-0.0030800079,
-0.0137178749,
-0.0235075895,
-0.0183855034,
-0.0295812916,
-0.0854417011,
0.0778999403,
-0.0298865624,
-0.0323674567,
-0.0130731687,
-0.05638697,
-0.0393297747,
-0.0128488783,
0.006128503,
-0.0082288049,
0.0265416913,
0.0130178807,
-0.0285263974,
-0.021875659,
-0.0638887435,
-0.0067282035,
0.0202901214,
-0.0708134174,
-0.0048010023,
-0.0473448075,
-0.0579035208,
0.0405876003,
-0.0566159822,
-0.0577378087,
2.073317651e-34,
0.0375006013,
-0.0173022114,
0.0251335967,
0.0184861869,
0.0575885139,
-0.0360538475,
-0.0610645413,
-0.0149699021,
-0.0179704614,
-0.1190121472,
-0.0096610757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03172v1 | Accurate and Well-Calibrated ICD Code Assignment Through Attention Over Diverse Label Embeddings | 2024-02-05T16:40:23 | 2024-02-05T16:40:23 | Gonçalo Gomes, Isabel Coutinho, Bruno Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) has been adopted
worldwide, manually assigning ICD codes to clinical text is time-consuming,
error-prone, and expensive, motivating the development of automated approaches.
This paper describes a novel approach for automated ICD coding, combining
several ideas from previous related work. We specifically employ a strong
Transformer-based model as a text encoder and, to handle lengthy clinical
narratives, we explored either (a) adapting the base encoder model into a
Longformer, or (b) dividing the text into chunks and processing each chunk
independently. The representations produced by the encoder are combined with a
label embedding mechanism that explores diverse ICD code synonyms. Experiments
with different splits of the MIMIC-III dataset show that the proposed approach
outperforms the current state-of-the-art models in ICD coding, with the label
embeddings significantly contributing to the good performance. Our approach
also leads to properly calibrated classification results, which can effectively
inform downstream tasks such as quantification. | [
0.0048105479,
0.0390955061,
0.0161180161,
0.0008321311,
-0.0119918101,
0.0474197492,
0.0164974704,
0.0252638124,
0.0131764142,
-0.0274819303,
0.0009153166,
-0.0616092645,
0.0138636827,
0.0647862852,
-0.0117072295,
-0.0386666283,
0.0317201167,
0.0175796002,
0.0301900245,
0.0176426787,
-0.0450520664,
0.0003574583,
0.0064726248,
0.0602605268,
-0.0123528102,
-0.0006022368,
0.0419759341,
-0.0115373023,
0.033739645,
-0.0661306009,
-0.0030463275,
0.0407896005,
0.0047860355,
-0.0085708648,
0.0000019611,
-0.0255637635,
-0.0226164032,
0.0127025722,
-0.0115430048,
-0.0599850416,
0.0206744149,
-0.1008838937,
0.0245751608,
-0.0070834048,
-0.0054360963,
-0.0357011817,
0.0694550499,
0.0858062804,
0.0333307795,
0.0623203851,
-0.0175536256,
-0.0168539248,
0.029979175,
-0.0250089876,
0.01177934,
-0.0279955324,
0.0472380966,
0.0217117667,
0.0036791582,
0.0085323108,
-0.0394259579,
0.0766978115,
0.0371576883,
0.0091841836,
0.0433914475,
0.0667414069,
0.0105315624,
0.0096954359,
0.0063469452,
0.0542374365,
-0.0500482097,
-0.0044162939,
0.0022572109,
0.0058737593,
0.0026638668,
-0.0507506952,
-0.0341514871,
-0.0162011869,
-0.0101695415,
0.0140006989,
0.0164332297,
0.063304387,
0.0069918428,
-0.0504574217,
-0.0318705626,
-0.0319874436,
-0.0109080849,
-0.028096756,
-0.0177373346,
-0.0261216667,
-0.0032377201,
-0.0527519844,
0.0336761437,
0.0428371839,
-0.0005459346,
-0.0008884997,
-0.0698137656,
-0.0075388835,
0.0436835587,
-0.0650506541,
-0.0036863803,
0.0166319739,
-0.0042546145,
0.0292248316,
-0.0118489508,
0.0377768949,
-0.020743154,
0.0823781341,
-0.0476745889,
-0.005466809,
-0.0685431734,
0.0034799543,
-0.0496546812,
0.0114720175,
0.0355158672,
-0.0195558071,
-0.0609578677,
-0.0137609895,
0.0013423247,
-0.0025895759,
0.0321886018,
0.0306879301,
-0.0404689871,
0.0198388472,
0.0159223862,
0.0284341872,
0.0047476022,
-0.0260606762,
-0.0050025503,
-0.012916401,
0.0037422096,
0.0244297069,
0.0095635774,
-0.0077626696,
0.0187962539,
0.0245933253,
-0.0019755184,
-0.0450615287,
0.0264864564,
-0.0214246623,
-0.0483457707,
0.0263628736,
-0.0029776113,
-0.0415798426,
0.0460855477,
0.0181561504,
0.0337756276,
-0.0822890326,
0.0090325987,
-0.0136357537,
-0.0494704917,
0.0759854391,
-0.0345020927,
-0.0143070938,
0.0038687012,
0.0195838287,
0.0141238663,
0.013418939,
0.0645934269,
-0.0299082603,
0.0143925762,
-0.0493553504,
0.0636814013,
0.0079195518,
0.0005875226,
-0.0242473111,
-0.0086681014,
0.0050203688,
0.0097996015,
0.0499275625,
-0.0003635136,
0.0491418578,
0.0053929556,
-0.0505278409,
0.0370414257,
0.0405824631,
0.0348080099,
0.0232615229,
0.0214073639,
-0.0137652624,
-0.0434087142,
-0.0294097979,
0.000742046,
0.0324483775,
0.0750476271,
0.0042847912,
-0.000151933,
0.0000259542,
-0.0195543617,
-0.0388259888,
-0.0184547231,
-0.0136219794,
0.0018331974,
-0.0099414643,
0.012738606,
0.0077619497,
-0.0058974894,
0.057405483,
0.0032496229,
-0.0144611346,
-0.0083792126,
-0.0552737303,
-0.0519296676,
0.0541393906,
0.0391512364,
-0.004539967,
-0.0429816991,
-0.0451881178,
0.0262204614,
0.0078715198,
-0.0024184119,
0.0006518624,
-0.0053908899,
-0.0541515201,
-0.0100316368,
0.0355740674,
0.0007280877,
-0.0261762496,
-0.0227680653,
0.0044376566,
-0.0277681034,
-0.015027089,
-0.0351623259,
0.0400507748,
-0.0510117747,
-0.0490869321,
0.0029624002,
0.001268191,
0.0113461139,
-0.0021760187,
-0.0086607914,
0.0345390402,
0.0261580292,
-0.0423549004,
-0.0606826432,
-0.0121656386,
-0.0209544469,
-0.0314972177,
0.0061052791,
-0.050951682,
-0.025224708,
-0.0204550829,
-0.0341838077,
-0.0031854045,
-0.0557659939,
-0.0575314686,
0.0280019287,
0.027236212,
0.0242075399,
0.0395318605,
-0.0043835407,
-0.0360084996,
0.0177871827,
-0.0522497296,
0.0182489287,
-0.0003981818,
-0.0215264577,
0.0116640218,
0.0027124833,
-0.0019456083,
0.0288939346,
-0.0467204377,
-0.0018180987,
-0.0271823481,
-0.0110956319,
0.0274269059,
-0.051310908,
-0.0879427791,
-0.0186832566,
0.0077231135,
-0.0186282173,
0.0307660233,
0.0131879505,
0.0031010027,
-0.0243859459,
-0.0460761972,
-0.0508205853,
0.0121549135,
0.0188832972,
0.0223663151,
0.0163052864,
-0.0359161198,
0.0109676635,
0.0017460994,
-0.0367262512,
0.0402877964,
0.0285729691,
-0.0308168456,
-0.0632800907,
-0.0108041232,
-0.0212257076,
-0.0166545156,
-0.018912863,
-0.0385750718,
0.00826889,
0.0317306779,
0.0058608311,
0.0284389835,
0.0267040692,
0.0340449885,
0.0361221656,
0.0058572679,
-0.0114670927,
0.008396334,
-0.0562610887,
-0.0193745848,
-0.0240128748,
-0.0739014447,
0.0185199268,
0.0990561917,
0.0277493242,
0.0103716459,
-0.053174343,
-0.0486638434,
0.0071716569,
0.0229783393,
-0.0418348573,
-0.0099084387,
-0.0339054465,
0.0252246279,
0.0064811534,
-0.0475254431,
0.0932591558,
-0.022332387,
0.0131292529,
-0.0674899593,
-0.0297821183,
-0.0461907759,
0.0257669222,
-0.0279826391,
0.0337424353,
0.0331676789,
-0.019474322,
0.0265776105,
0.039700333,
-0.026751481,
-0.0590091832,
0.063632831,
0.0231991131,
0.0004158322,
0.0139600104,
-0.0315434858,
-0.0375745967,
-0.0035937754,
0.0010833029,
0.0061723166,
0.0389104262,
-0.0024817416,
-0.0714392662,
0.0679921284,
-0.0096786255,
0.066258885,
0.004852308,
-0.0037144155,
-0.0135104191,
0.0343404301,
0.0148449093,
-0.0002557309,
-0.0138337519,
-0.0158183556,
0.0181468278,
0.0631014928,
-0.010924858,
0.0525551699,
0.0112205297,
0.0004430152,
-0.0005164688,
-0.0205835924,
0.0224497877,
0.0193335712,
0.0100358538,
-0.0511124283,
-0.0334220715,
0.101147227,
0.0309359618,
-0.1006720141,
0.0153564643,
-0.0211708825,
-0.0202207733,
0.000630955,
0.0035640742,
-0.0464155488,
-0.0181960166,
0.0111525906,
0.004196899,
-0.0168628581,
-0.0291058607,
0.03708243,
-0.0116695026,
0.0256018136,
0.0298825819,
-0.0245404597,
-0.1084738299,
-0.0408259034,
-0.0225339271,
0.0221770462,
-0.0300175492,
-0.0155528383,
0.0110397814,
-0.0237507001,
0.0006848652,
-0.055086039,
-0.0801701546,
0.0164618399,
-0.0104734004,
0.0357733592,
0.0685349405,
0.0235856418,
0.0078406716,
-0.0440438688,
0.0114621669,
-0.0140051264,
-0.0262701251,
0.0077188765,
0.100638777,
-0.0337754264,
-0.0123167858,
-0.0398788936,
0.0163471904,
-0.0418079942,
-0.0260189846,
-0.0170972608,
0.0941896588,
-0.036137145,
-0.0352009311,
-0.0449327715,
-0.0083157178,
0.022590233,
0.0590690523,
0.0313926227,
-0.0088561317,
0.0107737053,
-0.009516879,
0.0548211075,
-0.0170597136,
-0.0392292999,
0.0723777264,
-0.0612801313,
-0.0757061094,
-0.0530493632,
-0.0217485148,
0.0523381159,
-0.004252716,
0.0173406396,
-0.0332838185,
0.0366968475,
-0.0266053863,
-0.0794834569,
0.0554899871,
0.0070564654,
0.0084952945,
-0.0635078177,
-0.0301621407,
0.0526147187,
0.0372951515,
-0.0222142991,
0.0246778131,
-0.0175956041,
0.0192946233,
0.0007103074,
0.0224449337,
0.0124804685,
0.0147685958,
-0.0059568072,
-0.0058428319,
0.0460738912,
0.0276421085,
0.0120558171,
-0.0226543956,
-0.0162048936,
-0.0489710644,
-0.0022034543,
0.0101736588,
-0.0245834216,
0.0511553101,
0.0027149408,
0.0354911573,
-0.0253330208,
-0.0232357346,
0.0215039589,
-0.0139423097,
0.0488787778,
-0.0229471456,
-0.0376978442,
0.012328173,
0.0299427565,
-0.0000107783,
0.0074026668,
-0.0166306142,
-0.0148884626,
0.0557021461,
-0.0006072636,
-0.0258851089,
0.0391917154,
-0.0338134877,
-0.0671928898,
-0.0400511175,
0.0437787287,
-0.0293836985,
0.0200448409,
0.0322492979,
-0.0013378792,
-0.0295545273,
0.0150780873,
0.0076015745,
0.021986099,
-0.0182006061,
0.0314540453,
0.0205604378,
0.0445101224,
-0.0157088079,
0.0526805893,
-0.0341662094,
-0.0109060025,
-0.0638385415,
-0.0291773956,
0.0116723692,
0.0154267503,
-0.00202001,
-0.0135523416,
0.0129698776,
-0.008873539,
0.0194501933,
-0.0377028957,
-0.0090451287,
0.0368233435,
-0.0008381805,
-0.0199672021,
-0.0382960066,
0.0570320413,
-0.0048724734,
0.0351247154,
-0.013143451,
-0.0542621948,
-0.0389114954,
0.0128317997,
0.0391540751,
-0.0046411492,
-0.023826763,
-0.0066573936,
-0.0632671192,
-0.0505863875,
0.0946492255,
-0.0327879898,
-0.0099528311,
0.0022898384,
0.0306057092,
0.0033758446,
-0.0028099548,
-0.0318069756,
0.0001704342,
0.0398224965,
0.0067431391,
-0.0553923473,
-0.0154226739,
-5.664568789e-33,
-0.0147436652,
-0.0260790233,
0.0171255115,
-0.0139903296,
-0.0190726761,
0.0402250998,
-0.0280411467,
-0.0305164978,
0.0357291624,
0.0361134857,
-0.0081011383,
-0.0116749704,
0.0023693559,
0.0521968417,
0.0091129029,
-0.0430651531,
0.0275410768,
0.0171569195,
-0.0337437503,
0.0357617475,
-0.0083213625,
0.0568687208,
0.0529681928,
-0.087663874,
0.003816535,
0.0171713922,
0.0451694466,
0.0079386039,
0.0512696393,
0.0705137551,
-0.0396869071,
0.0195695646,
0.0587183349,
-0.0204357933,
-0.0078492016,
0.0335575566,
-0.0667151138,
-0.0011523518,
-0.0403314158,
-0.0329321101,
0.0062888209,
-0.0588327385,
0.0603674129,
-0.0009241954,
-0.0141383521,
-0.0293201394,
0.0337828957,
-0.0309317634,
-0.0009323906,
-0.0406944081,
-0.0415864363,
0.0441636927,
0.0083697941,
-0.0272285454,
0.0146210445,
0.0168291926,
-0.0073009231,
0.0784862638,
-0.0522216856,
-0.0053787627,
0.0078240586,
0.0547316447,
0.0112957982,
-0.0287000239,
-0.0278278142,
0.0594131798,
0.0211803559,
-0.0169473719,
-0.0590423346,
-0.0050734696,
-0.036704462,
0.0261764731,
0.0913221315,
0.023747908,
0.0307129417,
-0.0231608003,
-0.046180021,
0.0415809341,
-0.0849881694,
0.0224412475,
0.0357454903,
-0.0104717463,
-0.0449634381,
-0.0003999676,
-0.0155033013,
0.0295592081,
-0.0093595795,
-0.017481409,
0.0502042435,
-0.0077366964,
-0.0207407437,
0.0502023138,
0.0473781899,
-0.0341514386,
-0.0105244964,
-0.0368554592,
0.0883083194,
0.0937035605,
-0.0317785144,
0.0154365646,
0.0139851114,
-0.004057352,
0.0671467111,
-0.0138643049,
0.0441638082,
0.0127065256,
0.0555997863,
-0.0252416953,
-0.0678240135,
-0.0270109605,
0.0257109832,
-0.0312073547,
-0.017481504,
0.0432520732,
0.0066158678,
0.0477415435,
-0.0012298409,
0.039895121,
-0.0113795912,
-0.0117835272,
-0.0165474322,
-0.0343172662,
0.0036136105,
0.0222880859,
-0.0151260458,
-0.0094619552,
-0.0734316707,
0.0543882065,
0.0107550705,
-0.0677117854,
-0.0028602043,
0.0167646687,
2.72e-7,
0.0937046781,
0.0503450781,
0.0388736092,
-0.0544178821,
0.0286956951,
0.0063245143,
0.013174518,
0.0286582243,
-0.0038674714,
-0.0143421981,
0.0305891428,
0.0067056729,
0.0344867036,
0.0281596221,
-0.0673040003,
-0.0236612856,
-0.0621590801,
0.0007046073,
-0.0107126096,
-0.0182839204,
0.0768389553,
0.1093331426,
-0.0351878032,
0.006188646,
0.0325839818,
-0.0321021974,
0.0347916745,
-0.0322275832,
0.0169918966,
0.0470063202,
-0.0177824069,
-0.0040570153,
0.0188964531,
0.0453056246,
-0.01994518,
-0.0126300137,
-0.008814441,
0.0933768824,
-0.0625451654,
0.0164213683,
-0.016875999,
0.0249055028,
0.0123967705,
-0.0577983409,
0.0520095788,
-0.1188509613,
-0.0137691749,
-0.014785815,
-0.0153091885,
0.0217529107,
0.050325647,
-0.0057830755,
-0.0399839245,
0.066634275,
0.0514053777,
0.0281432942,
-0.0249626487,
-0.0969764218,
-0.0050529777,
0.0177085735,
-0.0505791083,
0.0077335536,
-0.0122518335,
-0.0178791825,
0.0310401358,
-0.0580831654,
0.0042004352,
2.812422351e-34,
0.0347275026,
0.0051790369,
-0.0014219459,
0.0609109811,
0.0398282148,
-0.0431247987,
0.0294475518,
0.0172119457,
0.0013706248,
-0.0832735822,
-0.0030051186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03171v1 | Homograph Attacks on Maghreb Sentiment Analyzers | 2024-02-05T16:39:15 | 2024-02-05T16:39:15 | Fatima Zahra Qachfar, Rakesh M. Verma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | We examine the impact of homograph attacks on the Sentiment Analysis (SA)
task of different Arabic dialects from the Maghreb North-African countries.
Homograph attacks result in a 65.3% decrease in transformer classification from
an F1-score of 0.95 to 0.33 when data is written in "Arabizi". The goal of this
study is to highlight LLMs weaknesses' and to prioritize ethical and
responsible Machine Learning. | [
0.0248278901,
0.0415130444,
-0.0206548516,
0.0479928926,
-0.0514473468,
0.0529250801,
0.0602472574,
0.0007723168,
0.0420932174,
-0.0628998876,
-0.0176593065,
-0.0417979807,
0.0368863121,
-0.0130434353,
0.034879975,
0.0299379472,
0.0104492204,
-0.0069820634,
0.0118906852,
-0.0400285348,
0.0161560103,
0.0199373122,
0.0259502139,
0.0187640972,
-0.0076238131,
0.0379147865,
-0.0166310742,
-0.0215730015,
0.037977282,
0.0396917723,
0.0102341622,
0.0292823836,
-0.0350035988,
0.0330694951,
0.0000015751,
-0.0470964387,
-0.0461663231,
0.0106064379,
0.0341893882,
-0.0586133599,
0.0900179595,
-0.0797284096,
-0.0202532299,
0.0264974087,
-0.0301896185,
0.0078797573,
0.0145226512,
0.0625800192,
0.0760451332,
0.1058562249,
0.0049790787,
-0.0562504753,
0.0257188771,
0.001934485,
-0.0178062096,
0.0357327051,
0.0136744138,
-0.0453215651,
-0.084233433,
-0.0052991202,
-0.0125489859,
0.0189678818,
-0.0325706378,
0.0142681981,
-0.0424702764,
-0.0286522042,
-0.0270138234,
-0.0105656227,
0.0295665115,
0.0053634164,
-0.0457795225,
0.0096253157,
-0.0108132539,
0.0105285188,
-0.0152664287,
0.0294107236,
0.0035143595,
0.0555017814,
-0.0337246209,
0.0183302239,
0.032057777,
0.0033167633,
0.0234554093,
0.0108238161,
-0.0447747372,
0.0411271341,
-0.015915934,
-0.0303785913,
0.0704448819,
0.0522831976,
0.007137958,
0.012211442,
-0.0002355738,
0.0213392265,
0.0288108736,
0.0043848245,
0.0070713456,
0.0052616876,
0.0459671095,
-0.0939506069,
0.007106577,
0.0421632715,
0.0012088763,
-0.0093292724,
-0.0098068016,
0.0065932861,
0.0007401321,
0.0447572581,
0.0028313145,
0.0014364531,
-0.0294393487,
0.0171861444,
0.0318610296,
0.0342765376,
-0.0189311709,
0.0613678768,
-0.0760417581,
0.0176349133,
-0.0497560427,
0.0057646362,
-0.0109026562,
-0.041804038,
0.0245938804,
0.011183151,
-0.0238969605,
0.0111188134,
0.0319973007,
0.0113818916,
-0.0909088254,
-0.0773883685,
0.0189721975,
0.0276865158,
-0.0149616962,
0.0118134385,
0.0150772547,
0.0414982438,
0.018958101,
-0.0526524,
-0.0330697671,
-0.0328596532,
-0.0220359862,
-0.0270359423,
0.0338100195,
-0.0492884144,
0.0277650915,
-0.0027980162,
-0.0388203897,
-0.0001260868,
-0.0137980198,
-0.0241566468,
-0.0245871507,
0.0641394034,
-0.0237794425,
-0.0194560103,
0.0374754965,
0.0249621309,
-0.0004660288,
0.0578501821,
-0.0075856834,
0.0358035751,
0.0298939478,
0.0141859967,
0.0489645451,
0.0321639664,
0.0042302483,
0.0304776467,
-0.0253021456,
-0.0366860591,
-0.0450248457,
-0.0094315233,
-0.0003359702,
0.0732461736,
-0.0071681305,
-0.0750233829,
0.0482879616,
0.0491673015,
-0.0015016951,
0.0399788469,
-0.0393330716,
0.0157031845,
0.0056198826,
0.0369656682,
-0.0179930851,
-0.0321497433,
-0.0364714153,
-0.0330472775,
-0.0258663874,
0.0404783115,
-0.011372772,
-0.0468653701,
-0.007481101,
-0.046148181,
0.0282396264,
-0.0085039707,
0.0717221424,
-0.0002018211,
-0.0107055856,
0.0029554861,
0.0259668753,
-0.0443979166,
0.0112369265,
-0.0445221104,
-0.0058476366,
0.0497345291,
0.0128190825,
0.0278479867,
0.0134177413,
-0.0596928373,
-0.0489711463,
-0.0016831323,
-0.0276280381,
-0.0043701804,
0.0091132801,
-0.047335837,
-0.0305358637,
0.0074082226,
0.0064276378,
-0.0275349151,
-0.0342539512,
0.0642130598,
-0.0190428589,
0.0051580654,
0.0076677939,
-0.0174798276,
0.0289914384,
0.0272928532,
-0.0246866047,
0.0586059093,
0.0001957973,
0.0301366542,
-0.0243734736,
-0.0077759125,
0.0350573398,
-0.0239395443,
-0.0593367033,
0.037276566,
0.0100517944,
0.0034579553,
0.0227318741,
-0.0590157732,
0.0132632386,
0.0385278799,
-0.0064089983,
0.029917717,
0.0573785082,
-0.0619832464,
0.0477827899,
-0.0070508611,
0.0275550839,
-0.041403763,
0.0177799705,
-0.0329979584,
0.0440204367,
-0.0469022803,
0.0073275827,
-0.0603537522,
-0.0236216709,
0.0357043371,
0.0164135825,
-0.032734476,
0.0401176885,
0.0282084141,
0.0048735971,
0.0147413407,
-0.0375452749,
0.0019284516,
-0.0520655587,
-0.0389346294,
-0.059540987,
-0.0315599181,
0.0522621758,
-0.0149294985,
-0.0088551911,
-0.0136198914,
0.0141486768,
-0.0164717324,
0.0156425331,
0.0053898632,
0.0307666883,
0.0475488715,
-0.0476739183,
-0.0196140502,
0.0218972489,
-0.0107544558,
-0.0173427649,
0.0780594647,
0.048135642,
-0.0358743556,
-0.0115998602,
-0.0162838697,
-0.033364974,
0.0327830166,
-0.0109734442,
-0.0484737083,
0.0224889815,
0.0132081183,
-0.0215745345,
0.0237605833,
0.0302656349,
0.0731548071,
0.0253099445,
0.0401095673,
-0.0036585913,
-0.0393119417,
-0.0322531387,
-0.0233619232,
-0.0688358918,
-0.0501387678,
0.0108475089,
0.0062649385,
0.0198850334,
-0.0146481171,
-0.0036399262,
0.0228693206,
-0.0158631224,
0.012407341,
0.0134500163,
-0.0227972511,
0.0066518402,
0.041203022,
0.0446047746,
-0.060074605,
0.0393618159,
0.0115556633,
0.0509148352,
-0.0212957878,
-0.0354297385,
-0.0398456939,
0.0091010788,
-0.0091934958,
0.0240998417,
0.0103927404,
-0.0376024358,
-0.0017372327,
-0.0280698109,
0.037710771,
-0.0257652868,
0.0811778978,
0.0259272326,
-0.0038882724,
-0.0405878983,
-0.0366107672,
-0.006472521,
-0.0287063699,
-0.0598741807,
-0.0331711881,
0.0759372786,
-0.0134531343,
-0.0198075045,
-0.007528895,
-0.0067536496,
-0.0518119633,
-0.0133846886,
-0.0239712372,
0.0340916291,
0.0260115433,
-0.0002948015,
-0.0227051917,
0.0560268089,
-0.006462581,
-0.0395875201,
0.0833461061,
-0.0569553003,
-0.0335396156,
-0.0399184674,
0.0044589071,
0.0409580208,
-0.0072102873,
-0.0178029351,
-0.0859591961,
-0.0066841035,
-0.030880224,
0.0601931922,
0.0927073509,
0.0064078341,
-0.0440417752,
0.0006233446,
0.0162420645,
-0.0226386208,
-0.0085172746,
-0.0242453441,
-0.1361972392,
0.0135137103,
0.0066924775,
0.0628179163,
-0.0346338786,
-0.0208366178,
0.0505780987,
-0.0851522535,
0.0200685319,
0.0066131828,
-0.0396629684,
-0.0782024711,
-0.0237978939,
-0.0251254141,
-0.0311581008,
0.0089909872,
-0.0660464391,
-0.0037249422,
0.0060886024,
0.0304231513,
-0.0582639351,
-0.0178063978,
-0.0239752308,
-0.0251106378,
0.0002398664,
-0.0328305662,
0.0078080059,
-0.0687805563,
-0.0600509048,
-0.007273146,
0.0259766057,
-0.0016205728,
-0.0349956527,
0.0587400906,
-0.0041663619,
-0.0453001633,
-0.0294494573,
-0.0443740971,
-0.043029774,
0.0340386108,
-0.0255409013,
0.0364156738,
-0.0450699665,
-0.0182916187,
-0.0184547566,
0.0424760953,
0.0139281573,
0.0179357547,
-0.0306094848,
-0.0188675486,
-0.0369208828,
-0.0511175096,
0.0082287649,
-0.0135336844,
-0.0583012216,
0.0222775489,
0.0161350351,
-0.0393235162,
-0.0480497591,
-0.057167843,
-0.0270534214,
0.0196513142,
0.0016280895,
-0.0110725807,
0.0296004266,
0.0227485951,
-0.0653175116,
-0.0362228565,
0.0312043559,
0.0023979305,
-0.028251946,
0.0012897426,
0.0392431505,
-0.0134453997,
0.0362031236,
-0.0399201922,
-0.0482888296,
-0.0552489311,
0.0527077466,
0.0094245169,
0.0182760861,
0.0005704662,
0.0134748304,
-0.0525913425,
0.0155384699,
0.0227832049,
-0.0083536822,
0.0234723389,
0.0716171712,
0.0076037636,
-0.0352179185,
0.0285569429,
0.0118178474,
0.013952842,
0.0531095862,
-0.075707376,
-0.0351717137,
-0.0687807202,
-0.0423766449,
0.0057266434,
0.0288237501,
-0.0106692594,
-0.0199845117,
0.007888413,
0.0258772131,
0.0243393183,
0.0236011166,
0.0149400663,
-0.0195844714,
-0.015980361,
0.0400099009,
-0.0415022485,
-0.0022933409,
-0.0286374111,
-0.0150793782,
-0.0321055986,
0.0795798525,
0.0150097217,
0.0106419139,
0.0201218724,
0.032058116,
-0.0092201829,
-0.0145879304,
0.0451329723,
0.0189967807,
-0.0066059344,
-0.0099861892,
-0.0062094233,
0.0277477764,
0.0009393327,
0.0082758442,
-0.023621561,
0.0214531869,
-0.0096025215,
0.0014251244,
0.0018051678,
-0.0175776277,
0.0157136265,
0.018381292,
-0.0017506341,
0.0068451096,
-0.0115389759,
-0.0599129535,
-0.0004452635,
0.0406605974,
-0.0160116013,
-0.0320218317,
0.0572882891,
0.0241865423,
-0.0180147886,
0.0244452227,
0.0553052425,
-0.0517661795,
-0.0108311865,
-0.0415185466,
0.0655748993,
-0.07450784,
-0.0243145023,
-0.0408654064,
-0.0712713674,
-0.0676454008,
0.0753095374,
-0.0424544886,
0.0308354776,
0.0220445991,
-0.0004959808,
0.0419140495,
0.0382621959,
0.0466386266,
-0.0661810189,
0.0464577302,
-0.0323412344,
-0.0163510069,
0.0491872765,
-5.584781742e-33,
0.0485995635,
-0.0587695539,
-0.0222714804,
0.009119384,
-0.0039565321,
-0.0125782304,
0.0174478348,
0.0269016121,
-0.0265211537,
0.0330131017,
0.0037398674,
0.0100592254,
0.0122111216,
0.0063879052,
0.0101579027,
-0.0534454212,
0.0075395694,
-0.0010981538,
-0.0183571875,
0.0026761773,
0.0610253625,
0.0171431061,
0.066464819,
-0.0916926339,
0.0242896229,
-0.0235063527,
-0.0624831952,
0.0084260963,
0.0013407319,
0.047932256,
0.0178728942,
0.0754880384,
0.034372393,
-0.0129729193,
0.0352222398,
0.0128881549,
0.003647801,
-0.0078576356,
-0.0212982614,
0.061730776,
0.0433312319,
-0.0267331637,
0.0190776419,
0.0150761055,
-0.0765287429,
-0.0047947606,
0.0070903637,
-0.004360592,
-0.0110197924,
-0.0677449852,
-0.0311934091,
0.0360685959,
0.0000530732,
0.0648191646,
0.0249516238,
0.028738685,
0.0382996947,
0.0184914954,
-0.0676433221,
0.0488655604,
0.0290978085,
-0.0399605036,
0.0068325819,
-0.0312231593,
-0.0338009,
0.0477466956,
0.0380295515,
-0.0105691561,
-0.0017705718,
0.0386103243,
0.0227175765,
-0.021351289,
0.0270304456,
0.0817460194,
-0.0124966903,
-0.0606663972,
-0.0687217936,
0.0341264009,
0.0562781207,
0.0030337439,
0.006626247,
-0.0288501382,
-0.0516180471,
-0.0313893929,
0.0515267737,
0.0145542854,
-0.0162666682,
-0.0067079081,
-0.0438550413,
-0.0275737774,
0.0061672297,
0.074379921,
-0.0138310548,
-0.0389471799,
0.0373897888,
0.0381478816,
-0.020371113,
0.0265088733,
0.0049854862,
-0.0088897804,
0.0204821639,
-0.0225865636,
-0.0079245539,
0.0140492469,
0.0355380625,
-0.0154569577,
0.0590056516,
0.0477379039,
-0.101382114,
-0.0037015758,
0.0020582529,
0.0589703247,
0.032451354,
0.0819227099,
0.0006177415,
-0.0365422033,
0.0029983106,
0.0222292449,
0.0047511635,
0.0552056916,
-0.0096805524,
0.0752096176,
-0.030773161,
-0.0122450162,
-0.0070833308,
-0.0013837034,
0.0244783759,
0.0347531512,
0.009861717,
-0.0903115124,
-0.0110432245,
-0.0488529727,
2.525e-7,
0.0433968939,
0.0338031426,
-0.003867581,
-0.0514826775,
0.0109029347,
0.0470211096,
-0.0051157814,
0.037494354,
0.0246305168,
0.056669157,
-0.0017595901,
-0.031122433,
0.0166880172,
0.0396682695,
-0.0752024502,
0.0120306648,
0.0051881718,
-0.006145909,
-0.0015648273,
0.0559315346,
0.0537125729,
0.0966044664,
-0.0287682917,
-0.0352197215,
-0.0580302924,
-0.0036045294,
0.0383385941,
-0.0203305334,
-0.0480535887,
-0.0233654622,
0.0307939872,
-0.0167801399,
0.0150612639,
0.0196143873,
-0.029202912,
0.0098381918,
-0.0080668908,
0.0334243663,
0.054604046,
-0.0444125533,
0.0067550652,
-0.06124321,
0.0063407626,
-0.0139701981,
0.0399184041,
-0.0026516188,
-0.0602955818,
-0.048308339,
-0.0084307827,
0.0068194871,
0.047074616,
-0.0449049175,
0.0085460143,
0.0183611885,
0.0279281866,
-0.023363078,
0.0274116769,
-0.0380674042,
0.0536362305,
-0.0138960006,
0.0211483929,
-0.0427257642,
0.0667264685,
0.0375623628,
0.0179999452,
0.0270821918,
0.0215775985,
2.231897578e-34,
0.0143918851,
-0.0306974016,
-0.0048023276,
0.0154298134,
0.0216462966,
0.0065475455,
0.0057620844,
0.0155358352,
0.0131390551,
-0.0029140615,
-0.0152202602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03163v1 | Linguistic features for sentence difficulty prediction in ABSA | 2024-02-05T16:31:03 | 2024-02-05T16:31:03 | Adrian-Gabriel Chifu, Sébastien Fournier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | One of the challenges of natural language understanding is to deal with the
subjectivity of sentences, which may express opinions and emotions that add
layers of complexity and nuance. Sentiment analysis is a field that aims to
extract and analyze these subjective elements from text, and it can be applied
at different levels of granularity, such as document, paragraph, sentence, or
aspect. Aspect-based sentiment analysis is a well-studied topic with many
available data sets and models. However, there is no clear definition of what
makes a sentence difficult for aspect-based sentiment analysis. In this paper,
we explore this question by conducting an experiment with three data sets:
"Laptops", "Restaurants", and "MTSC" (Multi-Target-dependent Sentiment
Classification), and a merged version of these three datasets. We study the
impact of domain diversity and syntactic diversity on difficulty. We use a
combination of classifiers to identify the most difficult sentences and analyze
their characteristics. We employ two ways of defining sentence difficulty. The
first one is binary and labels a sentence as difficult if the classifiers fail
to correctly predict the sentiment polarity. The second one is a six-level
scale based on how many of the top five best-performing classifiers can
correctly predict the sentiment polarity. We also define 9 linguistic features
that, combined, aim at estimating the difficulty at sentence level. | [
0.0565943681,
0.0099262809,
-0.0213062204,
0.0014838579,
-0.0603838265,
0.0301117748,
-0.0087715676,
-0.0290261805,
0.0009905851,
-0.0674101338,
-0.0028373809,
-0.0297901873,
0.0019474989,
0.0158803053,
-0.0502839088,
-0.0164317284,
0.0087871812,
0.0378186554,
0.0409238189,
-0.0250298623,
0.018656427,
0.0282590147,
0.0161546227,
0.0192200281,
-0.0276446398,
-0.0092888521,
0.0181069188,
-0.0003091711,
-0.0007447536,
-0.017825665,
0.0818000436,
0.0405030921,
-0.0307602473,
-0.0249864794,
0.0000018537,
-0.0373355709,
-0.033798635,
-0.02143679,
0.0240895692,
-0.0057949121,
0.0950479358,
-0.0047713229,
0.0159501955,
0.0269632451,
-0.0222843625,
-0.0143954484,
0.0500200242,
0.0836158395,
0.0443194211,
0.0644606054,
-0.0144934785,
-0.021957418,
-0.0509436615,
0.0169930309,
-0.0366356708,
-0.0416929685,
-0.0118927341,
-0.0252635535,
-0.024887342,
0.0093949093,
-0.0148058692,
-0.0118147321,
0.0073726797,
0.0663934052,
-0.0404053852,
-0.004969995,
-0.0062625348,
-0.0070397607,
-0.0002187132,
0.0301713105,
0.015442403,
-0.0122174975,
-0.0140319951,
-0.0106708659,
0.0196365938,
0.0221702363,
0.0180896055,
0.0044589746,
-0.003369581,
0.0500571206,
0.0141692897,
0.0610095672,
-0.0318462998,
0.0116619337,
0.0261586215,
0.030156102,
-0.0269524232,
-0.0687145218,
0.0493286662,
0.0396075472,
-0.0097526917,
0.011687981,
0.0245921984,
-0.0168504193,
-0.0319525935,
0.0326732136,
-0.0315493084,
-0.0317203589,
0.0327149704,
-0.0767694488,
0.0201645922,
-0.0270697083,
-0.0447202809,
0.0203819927,
0.0117915077,
-0.0078829639,
0.0496540628,
-0.0441310108,
-0.0317720249,
0.020011548,
-0.0624924675,
0.0121690398,
-0.006645862,
0.0511433221,
-0.0171924159,
0.0010318088,
-0.0467964597,
-0.0670370236,
-0.0432616249,
-0.0106587932,
0.0195729751,
0.011112635,
-0.004619265,
0.0170043297,
-0.0365661196,
0.033097744,
-0.0655879304,
0.040473707,
-0.048263371,
0.0090783974,
0.0397497602,
0.0212085042,
0.0191388261,
-0.0142636765,
0.0204539597,
0.0098154591,
0.0135361739,
-0.025929654,
-0.0455346331,
-0.0144000296,
-0.0331468768,
-0.0636029169,
0.005764883,
-0.0263884142,
0.0018288816,
0.0190413762,
-0.0064533288,
-0.0259678941,
0.0148414997,
0.0102270013,
0.0036732319,
0.0556023903,
0.0423563607,
-0.028319804,
-0.0065574925,
-0.0034491557,
0.0364935659,
0.0498434715,
-0.0345167182,
0.0416512564,
0.0628403276,
0.0203206055,
0.0331184193,
-0.0326369479,
-0.0166742094,
-0.0057252855,
0.0258349236,
-0.0005338205,
-0.0607183836,
-0.0503828339,
-0.0448310897,
0.0550268218,
0.0291605759,
-0.0113697182,
0.022414932,
-0.0342614166,
0.0043280921,
0.0432521701,
-0.0110718934,
0.0497069471,
0.0037197764,
0.0270508695,
-0.0068999445,
0.0135666169,
-0.0236984976,
-0.0131444931,
-0.0057068081,
0.0231489353,
-0.0096509038,
-0.1237674206,
-0.0425857119,
-0.0171697717,
0.0359930433,
-0.0273239929,
0.0559641905,
-0.0112562282,
-0.0445543043,
0.0076271226,
0.0244334526,
-0.0731152743,
-0.0565173142,
0.0106535135,
0.0002218977,
0.0254762266,
-0.0275169369,
-0.0635977238,
-0.0077445782,
-0.0131970942,
-0.0027350786,
0.0171194281,
0.0376161747,
0.0261524208,
-0.0133982012,
-0.0531906746,
-0.0187164955,
0.0031645193,
0.0481279716,
0.0055179847,
0.0000269097,
0.0277982298,
-0.0004520629,
-0.0048524733,
-0.0354938656,
0.0151637103,
0.0313299596,
-0.0223780628,
0.0208094995,
0.0382214226,
0.0339889079,
0.0353316106,
0.0156586561,
-0.0092062196,
-0.0004501179,
-0.049273286,
-0.067989476,
0.0184931476,
-0.004188437,
-0.0143540502,
0.0128703536,
-0.0388923474,
-0.0287893098,
0.0199546013,
-0.0351309367,
-0.015435244,
0.0317742564,
-0.0613636486,
-0.014740211,
-0.0091994628,
0.016444847,
-0.0069877263,
0.0216121357,
-0.0382549725,
0.0954350755,
-0.0173105355,
0.0750847906,
-0.0720722228,
-0.0718927458,
0.0355866849,
0.021523688,
-0.0182173848,
-0.0513980277,
-0.0109624341,
0.0409386344,
0.0481757857,
0.0090296483,
-0.0260574371,
-0.0544039868,
-0.0810594633,
-0.0127146477,
-0.0238360669,
0.0116596147,
-0.0090140859,
-0.0325484462,
-0.0099074002,
0.020602664,
-0.0406929478,
-0.0189766213,
-0.0561069399,
0.0381693691,
0.0381966345,
0.0278578736,
-0.0077666277,
-0.037212044,
-0.0015891327,
-0.0074154623,
0.0292553734,
0.0073148948,
-0.0073072682,
-0.0201115888,
0.0438967124,
0.0092784381,
-0.0225726999,
0.0173482392,
-0.0653301701,
-0.0222184155,
0.0374510922,
0.0062714862,
0.0495334119,
-0.0032835479,
0.0830063075,
0.048234988,
-0.0120364986,
0.0184463561,
0.0433349758,
-0.0508531928,
0.0427835472,
0.0064614164,
-0.0574132949,
0.0344574153,
0.0542612486,
0.0190069452,
-0.0216583405,
-0.0389383808,
0.0302929971,
-0.0692924783,
0.0126378229,
0.0034792649,
0.0281623956,
0.0080690747,
0.0252967272,
-0.0157435741,
-0.00514577,
0.0594801642,
0.0086411675,
0.0223398115,
-0.1042535752,
-0.0310956575,
-0.0415521264,
0.0531744175,
0.0020509427,
0.0144005874,
0.0440318994,
0.0175195299,
-0.0144667905,
-0.0262689497,
0.0172392149,
-0.0155366529,
0.0530480221,
-0.0152766313,
-0.0241845474,
0.0054548127,
-0.0810736045,
0.0247509442,
-0.0377965458,
-0.012076566,
-0.0176757593,
0.0281969979,
-0.0221720114,
-0.0134213651,
-0.0504694805,
-0.0059483619,
-0.0376238599,
-0.0331196599,
-0.0262068473,
0.026624009,
0.0314604826,
0.0407515913,
0.0008470634,
0.0081879189,
-0.0005293092,
-0.0122387884,
0.0165783204,
-0.0373580754,
0.0219204053,
-0.0084049245,
-0.0096486062,
0.0182034057,
-0.0407712348,
-0.0560270622,
-0.0256696623,
0.0555214174,
-0.0401648879,
0.000160055,
0.0929396227,
0.0700013041,
-0.0104465326,
0.0308630224,
-0.0131635685,
0.0170009825,
0.0240018275,
0.0313802026,
-0.0159780532,
-0.0291744154,
-0.0155931143,
0.0219041761,
-0.0550099611,
0.016592307,
-0.0050390763,
-0.0837390646,
0.0307983924,
-0.0260019042,
-0.0422468223,
-0.054200381,
-0.0190487877,
-0.0017448082,
-0.031003641,
0.0175054632,
-0.0480032451,
-0.0031373338,
0.0151041541,
0.0314427838,
-0.0540087558,
-0.0189603604,
0.010589174,
0.0165201146,
0.0194360856,
0.0210041888,
0.0576359443,
-0.0199625157,
-0.0025541177,
0.0388315059,
-0.0324334688,
0.0151877925,
-0.0281684846,
0.0857833251,
0.0236767232,
-0.0271087736,
-0.052628547,
0.011207452,
-0.0339028463,
0.0170608945,
-0.0116261858,
0.0468928814,
0.0223852135,
0.0190127566,
-0.0216170363,
0.0033355295,
0.0251096617,
0.0839842036,
0.0060527292,
-0.0809944794,
-0.0286226552,
-0.0560970455,
0.0158403236,
-0.0508901589,
-0.0437311456,
0.0075318981,
-0.0349891111,
-0.0312094465,
-0.059686143,
-0.0778921992,
0.0081280591,
0.0254371259,
-0.0258172918,
-0.009014722,
0.0096749924,
0.0220164992,
-0.0334857889,
-0.0021370917,
0.0221853964,
0.0215717684,
-0.0233313348,
-0.0305737387,
0.0684645399,
-0.0111155435,
-0.0356693566,
-0.0216837134,
0.0055715512,
-0.0348224007,
0.0221918523,
0.0041058003,
0.0094368858,
-0.024476748,
0.00677572,
-0.0398983546,
0.0264559016,
0.0682944506,
-0.021559516,
0.0260804743,
0.0851334259,
0.0411239862,
0.0141296526,
0.0472812504,
-0.02019573,
0.0411608405,
0.0010785615,
-0.0015046443,
-0.0289539043,
-0.0191491526,
0.0267642792,
-0.0057347151,
0.0501811095,
0.0264083818,
-0.0521276146,
-0.0114290481,
0.0038190146,
-0.0151743097,
-0.0486444682,
-0.0272062775,
-0.0264455434,
-0.0152486069,
-0.0089498386,
-0.0630966723,
0.0341555811,
0.0021061171,
0.0286218561,
-0.0121408692,
0.073360391,
0.0231845621,
0.0304677375,
-0.0342463516,
0.0057250229,
-0.0422461741,
-0.026417518,
0.0111842286,
0.0130331749,
0.0191239789,
0.034890458,
-0.0104657523,
0.0253437087,
-0.0215613041,
0.0053238831,
0.0088417716,
0.0649588406,
-0.0168625861,
0.0012517811,
-0.0080786142,
-0.0706857666,
0.0556561314,
-0.0522175059,
0.0097595481,
-0.0186634921,
0.0014793812,
0.0269294903,
-0.0121838972,
0.0640489832,
0.0118788946,
-0.0237670932,
-0.0044198572,
0.0990272611,
-0.058574032,
0.0238724388,
0.0394049026,
-0.0341563076,
-0.0552957207,
-0.0103297802,
0.0437814891,
-0.0009758305,
0.0297777671,
0.0285611749,
-0.0881126896,
-0.0138972253,
0.0634214357,
-0.0258905832,
0.0282943621,
-0.0115458965,
0.0153815113,
0.0537637398,
-0.017195344,
0.0095532127,
-0.0598226599,
-0.0234205797,
-0.0447789207,
0.0106459474,
-0.011070041,
-6.094306748e-33,
-0.0132328225,
-0.0436745808,
-0.0521482863,
0.0260544494,
0.0146672269,
0.0401262715,
0.0133152846,
0.0512718521,
-0.0043254956,
0.0555642322,
0.0195724517,
0.0155377435,
0.0138777895,
0.0403265171,
0.0009309726,
-0.0266513228,
0.0458705053,
-0.0107211564,
-0.0003113352,
-0.012016112,
0.0570269302,
-0.0135286842,
0.013869307,
-0.1317382455,
0.0398051292,
-0.0075060753,
-0.0529308729,
-0.0100761978,
0.0317116231,
0.0613434426,
0.0044294121,
0.0950055495,
0.0243365895,
-0.0592552647,
0.0340781696,
0.0021753449,
-0.002815441,
-0.0708892867,
0.0140126711,
0.026641842,
0.0234522205,
-0.0608571507,
0.0059938217,
0.0225676969,
-0.0045584855,
-0.0206912141,
0.0377871655,
-0.0416631699,
0.0368774943,
-0.0861313418,
-0.0492663719,
0.0310086366,
-0.0070177191,
-0.0119740404,
0.0119401859,
0.0584399365,
0.008954945,
0.0011799618,
-0.0361574665,
0.0223421864,
-0.0242879,
0.0740307048,
-0.0066853394,
-0.0428033434,
-0.0128452508,
0.0452210568,
-0.0003268684,
-0.0004367763,
-0.005638496,
0.032239724,
-0.0147655699,
0.0360163189,
0.045199614,
0.0732437223,
0.0291515179,
0.0031126991,
-0.0350301787,
0.0298665836,
0.0345366225,
-0.0166352261,
0.042704422,
0.0013660914,
-0.1215888709,
-0.0395193994,
0.0181181543,
0.0174187087,
-0.0225379523,
-0.0127394227,
0.0128151746,
0.0091658374,
-0.0282235406,
0.0030685856,
-0.0405735746,
-0.025403019,
-0.0265719406,
0.0109889172,
-0.0327438675,
0.0501570776,
0.0029505561,
-0.0071496465,
-0.0339568593,
-0.0037999314,
-0.051379323,
0.0165994,
0.0251014717,
0.0050869724,
0.0792607591,
0.0071407412,
-0.0918983892,
0.0051990724,
0.0350039378,
0.0272429027,
-0.0282635316,
0.0471284986,
-0.0255610757,
-0.0004044332,
-0.0238037501,
0.0819636807,
0.0270918086,
0.0464831069,
-0.0310172718,
-0.0163729694,
-0.0330761559,
0.0262463596,
-0.0306067318,
-0.0328241251,
0.0096625537,
-0.0351811387,
-0.0115674995,
-0.0371157005,
-0.0273268893,
-0.0369562246,
2.556e-7,
0.0405560732,
0.0857166871,
-0.006323216,
0.0253151562,
0.003969728,
0.088369742,
0.020252265,
-0.0047539971,
-0.0344247818,
-0.0050600325,
0.0203209594,
0.0068678916,
0.0287220459,
0.0482961386,
-0.0702413023,
0.0460625961,
0.0248915665,
0.0007982163,
-0.0221049823,
0.0324102379,
0.1182066575,
0.0902444422,
0.0282690693,
0.0323188789,
-0.0431844704,
-0.0004364215,
0.0281266104,
-0.0489907525,
-0.0177769084,
0.0104573322,
0.009462296,
-0.0051650787,
-0.0082292529,
-0.0070612114,
-0.0324684605,
-0.0001580122,
0.0086693121,
0.0330775827,
0.0273745935,
-0.0704045445,
0.0542013831,
0.0048841191,
-0.0192109179,
0.0161157995,
0.0560427457,
-0.0579922013,
-0.054535538,
-0.0472703241,
0.003464119,
0.0368329659,
0.0494900793,
0.0037009744,
-0.0329719596,
0.0076731872,
-0.0197787825,
-0.0606424697,
-0.0287417229,
-0.0535421073,
-0.0299940016,
0.0331637152,
0.0325954817,
-0.0108743226,
-0.0037450958,
0.0703902245,
0.0336794592,
-0.0676632151,
0.0122067295,
2.404737951e-34,
0.0782452896,
-0.0096388431,
0.0047531063,
0.0084333168,
0.0219533984,
0.0011104562,
-0.0514559485,
0.0034904755,
0.0131458836,
-0.018834535,
0.0315192156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03161v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03161v3 | Video-LaVIT: Unified Video-Language Pre-training with Decoupled Visual-Motional Tokenization | 2024-02-05T16:30:49 | 2024-06-03T08:09:09 | Yang Jin, Zhicheng Sun, Kun Xu, Kun Xu, Liwei Chen, Hao Jiang, Quzhe Huang, Chengru Song, Yuliang Liu, Di Zhang, Yang Song, Kun Gai, Yadong Mu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In light of recent advances in multimodal Large Language Models (LLMs), there
is increasing attention to scaling them from image-text data to more
informative real-world videos. Compared to static images, video poses unique
challenges for effective large-scale pre-training due to the modeling of its
spatiotemporal dynamics. In this paper, we address such limitations in
video-language pre-training with an efficient video decomposition that
represents each video as keyframes and temporal motions. These are then adapted
to an LLM using well-designed tokenizers that discretize visual and temporal
information as a few tokens, thus enabling unified generative pre-training of
videos, images, and text. At inference, the generated tokens from the LLM are
carefully recovered to the original continuous pixel space to create various
video content. Our proposed framework is both capable of comprehending and
generating image and video content, as demonstrated by its competitive
performance across 13 multimodal benchmarks in image and video understanding
and generation. Our code and models are available at
https://video-lavit.github.io. | [
-0.0045140772,
0.0667828545,
0.0132942228,
0.0485626571,
0.0085668564,
0.0146320881,
0.0249906387,
0.0150917275,
-0.0519661456,
-0.0874631405,
-0.0257047191,
-0.0518338792,
-0.025568679,
0.0414040796,
0.0273647457,
-0.0859895423,
0.0226576645,
-0.0345379412,
0.0009671227,
0.0114235943,
0.0451562181,
0.0191087723,
-0.0188485179,
0.018703213,
-0.0688543096,
-0.0145605663,
-0.0188072808,
-0.0010534617,
0.0482405089,
-0.0239419453,
-0.0284397267,
0.0372922719,
0.079858087,
-0.0001376175,
0.0000018704,
-0.0075445203,
0.0241191462,
-0.0176573321,
0.0211745426,
0.026310971,
0.0374589562,
-0.0438885875,
0.0136397872,
-0.0058584996,
-0.0411037356,
-0.0603450201,
0.029822886,
-0.008929343,
0.0842961892,
0.0531332642,
-0.0464161411,
-0.0680888742,
-0.0014214545,
-0.0236222949,
0.0170329604,
-0.0167446155,
-0.0037741701,
0.0026701605,
-0.0000311753,
-0.007526665,
-0.069715701,
0.0198892765,
0.0293469802,
-0.0056209243,
0.0053573903,
0.0495850146,
-0.0335140228,
-0.0439520665,
-0.0308767669,
0.0796192214,
-0.026794631,
0.0048334249,
-0.0000518515,
0.0088764401,
-0.0010735139,
-0.0108018182,
-0.0712096021,
0.0528316535,
0.0530290194,
0.0347297229,
-0.0208297912,
0.0152828619,
0.0076498827,
-0.0230805557,
-0.0093522454,
-0.0363944247,
0.0469125211,
0.0290933885,
-0.0488654077,
-0.0130064711,
-0.023285076,
-0.0818743333,
0.0162517298,
0.0338478871,
0.0007426053,
-0.010005,
-0.0454601981,
-0.0020665668,
-0.031436801,
-0.0405472964,
0.02616073,
0.0090988036,
-0.0479523912,
0.0437427498,
-0.0395772979,
0.0505422391,
-0.0320559032,
0.026441386,
-0.0268956218,
-0.0062566791,
-0.0241881553,
-0.0114103602,
-0.0301748887,
0.0121518308,
-0.0515928045,
-0.0289268941,
-0.0136569953,
0.0095399246,
-0.0216917321,
-0.0063054725,
-0.0441910997,
0.0206675828,
0.0079292478,
-0.0447364114,
0.003479769,
0.03730933,
-0.0339348763,
0.0512401462,
-0.0114741288,
-0.0628244355,
-0.019804813,
0.0636237189,
0.001315677,
-0.0222849119,
0.0119179338,
0.0476681665,
-0.0631253198,
-0.0355707183,
-0.0157879014,
0.0025094352,
-0.0244784076,
-0.0344385877,
0.0379346721,
-0.0707225725,
0.0293810572,
-0.0109884394,
0.0167418998,
-0.0049597477,
-0.0034718704,
-0.018375244,
-0.0096516069,
0.0585555881,
-0.0082410034,
0.0209557936,
-0.0044243434,
0.0185034312,
0.0371653028,
0.0673851296,
0.0342026763,
0.0586484522,
0.0115810344,
0.0166141707,
0.0070068394,
0.0590977557,
-0.0187462065,
0.0306775011,
-0.0684763044,
-0.0052045509,
0.0319521874,
0.0281906687,
0.0848580226,
0.0570577383,
-0.0594175272,
-0.0085933302,
0.0469278581,
0.030249007,
-0.0476352759,
-0.0034534012,
0.0872827992,
-0.0006121573,
0.0097371154,
0.00396309,
-0.034917675,
0.0435815416,
0.0238370989,
-0.0010386452,
0.009863006,
0.066490978,
-0.0824517906,
-0.026320722,
-0.0034980788,
-0.0396511368,
0.0089992508,
0.0056467359,
0.0550389364,
0.0191491526,
-0.0488835052,
0.0587469079,
-0.0045906734,
-0.0216311775,
0.064241156,
-0.0078837154,
0.000283791,
0.0579057783,
0.0085756956,
0.0050435863,
-0.033049278,
0.0040359595,
0.0828765035,
0.0425004773,
-0.0226704348,
-0.0229632165,
0.0425732732,
-0.0802173018,
-0.0343766958,
-0.0277219694,
0.0088778706,
0.030847339,
-0.0164743364,
0.0344590023,
0.0164807569,
-0.0110651273,
0.0051232511,
0.0601481535,
0.0409137234,
-0.003806154,
-0.0164997019,
0.001256323,
0.0138412369,
0.0031804598,
-0.0216181651,
-0.0175155643,
0.0228769779,
-0.0468215942,
0.049545683,
0.0525756739,
-0.0528199151,
-0.0356623381,
0.0379957706,
-0.0095037501,
-0.0019292139,
0.0178258941,
-0.0641534254,
-0.0417012535,
0.0299314931,
0.0435308442,
0.0262503084,
-0.054365702,
-0.0140622575,
0.0544179231,
0.0026551459,
-0.0086400956,
0.0077450876,
-0.0050690696,
-0.0279742349,
0.01904146,
0.039926704,
0.0154943569,
-0.0159105118,
-0.0447915941,
-0.0065785605,
-0.0100168986,
-0.0109014027,
0.0032259871,
-0.0008393746,
-0.0547933057,
-0.0163010936,
-0.0889585689,
-0.0067696394,
-0.021730056,
0.0071571236,
0.008198183,
0.0093246838,
-0.0064207837,
-0.0291976184,
-0.0028016993,
0.02854448,
0.0297479015,
0.0167710055,
-0.0008414167,
0.0134281497,
0.0081475433,
-0.0095394263,
-0.0030795049,
0.0460926034,
0.0706345737,
-0.0157235507,
0.004457396,
0.0061233542,
-0.0077581159,
0.0111544374,
0.0279932022,
-0.0316361152,
-0.0376995131,
0.015616457,
-0.0356525593,
0.049843017,
0.032374505,
0.0302572697,
0.0271709207,
-0.0051260949,
-0.044863265,
-0.0164368767,
0.0036768725,
-0.0152693298,
-0.0237779338,
-0.0617576241,
0.0105226114,
-0.0260487609,
0.0181843229,
-0.0145116998,
0.0284792595,
-0.0872490853,
-0.0251630414,
0.0051798485,
-0.0293188412,
-0.0381029807,
0.0234183352,
-0.0020020606,
-0.0039457832,
-0.0382003561,
-0.0614817366,
-0.0022665539,
-0.0530458316,
-0.0454673804,
0.0344517976,
0.0124738161,
-0.009462486,
0.0941279978,
0.0402833372,
0.0093434742,
-0.0626433417,
-0.0156287812,
-0.0703295916,
-0.0008038079,
-0.0108489562,
0.0173404664,
0.0224545207,
-0.047671698,
-0.0005070638,
-0.005209994,
0.0068288664,
-0.0466184579,
-0.0257133134,
-0.0225715972,
-0.021114083,
-0.0522979312,
-0.0011889847,
0.0252478775,
0.010926662,
0.0006470865,
0.0223280005,
-0.0087009091,
0.0290577151,
-0.0144090801,
0.0668797046,
0.0641820282,
0.002523435,
-0.067206338,
-0.0617078803,
0.0243148971,
0.0657625943,
0.0354404226,
-0.0415420085,
-0.0776383728,
0.0530841872,
0.0294847321,
0.0112969987,
-0.0151867531,
0.0325222649,
0.0454823636,
-0.0371306799,
0.001247669,
0.0787679404,
0.0055108364,
-0.0403321721,
0.0117304288,
0.0408016928,
0.0338306651,
0.0227052774,
-0.00252848,
-0.0973451212,
-0.0439313278,
-0.0211244337,
-0.0381454527,
0.0778110102,
0.0183174107,
-0.035536021,
-0.0578212552,
0.0630065426,
0.0436548293,
-0.0140663804,
-0.0072816415,
0.0128556732,
-0.0136444811,
-0.0193188302,
0.003746208,
0.0124328872,
-0.0042515961,
0.049252212,
0.0293858349,
-0.0093608387,
-0.0610114001,
0.0078368848,
-0.0354794487,
0.0086726602,
0.0214805026,
0.0028696768,
-0.0101468265,
-0.0352400765,
0.0317205749,
-0.0044440082,
0.0022387384,
-0.0131407585,
0.0142819136,
-0.0323576294,
-0.0252789538,
0.0280491319,
0.0332539976,
-0.00121964,
-0.0694996044,
0.0095034055,
0.058704298,
-0.0207716599,
-0.0036159628,
-0.0256321225,
-0.0090095969,
0.0078928852,
0.049429182,
0.0052632908,
-0.0283415914,
-0.0085098334,
0.0415193699,
-0.0250495672,
-0.0317175612,
-0.0276782215,
-0.0357615389,
0.0007518391,
-0.0088454485,
-0.034073472,
-0.0075584683,
0.0689733922,
0.0719788,
-0.0535420813,
0.0079620862,
-0.0019233552,
0.0199111458,
-0.0740182251,
0.0790256262,
-0.0162876379,
-0.0047685178,
-0.0478669852,
-0.0441040136,
0.0610324442,
-0.0264684334,
-0.0055303089,
0.0194250476,
-0.0629899874,
-0.0333355293,
-0.0249831155,
0.0769263729,
0.0110185668,
0.0948681086,
0.0097301565,
-0.0061291745,
0.0439915024,
0.0193095747,
-0.0035317175,
0.0356768146,
-0.0201497003,
-0.0340463445,
-0.0151555557,
0.0197562501,
-0.0260196514,
0.0264813695,
0.0005405024,
0.0174992569,
-0.0258077104,
0.0111944443,
0.0008202445,
-0.0292732138,
0.07021413,
-0.0619024001,
-0.0036079681,
-0.0366080925,
-0.0366021655,
-0.0111284805,
0.0324901119,
-0.1019032598,
0.004892502,
0.0425748676,
0.0165754743,
-0.0125999227,
0.003759305,
0.0120536005,
-0.0111716315,
0.0006458927,
-0.0139537193,
-0.0309035499,
0.007812418,
0.0285192337,
0.0299631152,
0.06770356,
0.0110777132,
-0.0338782445,
0.0009877466,
-0.0205947924,
0.0308495518,
0.0308106821,
0.0049495599,
-0.0034308201,
0.0319711566,
-0.0030436567,
-0.0249897521,
-0.0584662929,
0.0349825919,
0.0613560826,
-0.0305363107,
0.03057459,
-0.0068809516,
-0.0189522039,
-0.0085319411,
0.0807088912,
-0.0009710063,
-0.0766105726,
0.0514933169,
-0.0211573336,
-0.0281287618,
-0.0012986236,
0.1008859128,
0.0188703369,
0.0384406373,
0.0189864766,
0.0281000528,
-0.0166362058,
-0.0416515693,
0.0069802906,
-0.0072572324,
-0.0170368589,
0.0278397389,
-0.0017758751,
-0.055309549,
-0.0222604033,
0.0043813325,
-0.0264288485,
0.0400336608,
0.0632336885,
0.0338522308,
-0.0144752646,
-0.0085894419,
-0.0076435301,
-0.0063060932,
0.0250474941,
-0.0543449037,
-0.0110635562,
-5.705253383e-33,
-0.0391953774,
-0.0207245257,
0.0692403018,
-0.0079861544,
-0.0423256271,
0.0102094859,
-0.003378662,
0.027943857,
0.0142658111,
0.0295623336,
0.0372582003,
0.0112959929,
0.0067909467,
0.0482208543,
0.018737549,
-0.0140371919,
0.0310887694,
-0.0723447204,
0.0093799448,
0.0210971441,
0.0213898607,
0.0263471715,
0.0569824576,
-0.0286449958,
-0.0622184761,
-0.0052278135,
-0.0399814695,
0.0298259463,
0.0316155329,
0.0275133234,
-0.022716172,
-0.0313071869,
0.0164366048,
0.0080339815,
-0.0460282825,
-0.0002232799,
-0.0508356765,
-0.0045810509,
0.032588046,
0.055667866,
-0.0879525989,
-0.0076829493,
0.0469881259,
-0.0188943036,
0.0043532732,
-0.0016190981,
0.0328144617,
-0.0171001088,
0.0182160418,
-0.0160859935,
-0.0327378251,
0.0048202039,
-0.042894993,
-0.0380429626,
0.0521205179,
-0.0054875608,
0.0122266719,
-0.0215949193,
-0.0354697816,
0.0140604796,
-0.0409724042,
0.0424766429,
0.0919358879,
0.0343810506,
0.0235431232,
0.0595372729,
0.0336474031,
-0.0767032206,
-0.0409521461,
0.0617440157,
0.0419518873,
0.0705720708,
-0.0041670604,
0.0398935936,
0.0109804524,
0.0023140651,
-0.0573742464,
0.0129742753,
-0.0607896671,
0.0373081304,
-0.0232553706,
0.0302921422,
0.0782169625,
-0.0021548965,
-0.0161079708,
0.0001756954,
-0.0007569323,
-0.0174937062,
0.0271209441,
0.0278069228,
0.0381288417,
-0.0216511022,
0.1001464054,
-0.0156594012,
0.0025461977,
0.0411258824,
-0.0447981097,
0.0525863022,
0.0205583759,
0.0298345666,
-0.0405847616,
-0.0391950347,
0.0482618324,
-0.0132819312,
-0.0057227812,
0.0172450952,
-0.008563959,
0.0431988649,
-0.0109626139,
0.0004046497,
-0.005283819,
0.013075917,
0.0198806003,
0.0112074679,
0.0297296494,
0.0016179696,
-0.0462227017,
0.0578173324,
-0.0318077281,
-0.0074164714,
-0.0042974991,
-0.0185602847,
0.0079740006,
0.0428413153,
-0.0351722836,
0.0358427726,
-0.0555503033,
-0.0360412598,
0.025534654,
-0.0483558513,
-0.0146337794,
0.0315636806,
2.552e-7,
0.0296343695,
-0.0034626552,
0.0123147126,
-0.0121489624,
0.0118299341,
0.0247942228,
-0.0148602296,
0.027339898,
0.0128662251,
-0.0155691365,
0.0339241251,
0.0780323893,
0.0257645641,
-0.016128622,
-0.0202991683,
0.0192663353,
-0.0463061631,
-0.0130832139,
-0.0575161353,
-0.0223817751,
0.0201642141,
0.0796475038,
0.0015433398,
0.0050876616,
0.0466643088,
-0.0269673839,
0.0787010863,
-0.0181834009,
-0.0473643132,
0.0102361264,
-0.0026125391,
-0.0065543423,
-0.0411520153,
-0.0179149155,
-0.0244351905,
-0.0238138624,
0.0335798077,
0.0516079031,
-0.0412678421,
-0.0238281786,
-0.0164752025,
0.0057630762,
-0.0509697646,
-0.0155986855,
0.0597091019,
-0.0284581613,
-0.0020341682,
-0.0498657487,
-0.0545169897,
0.0052459151,
-0.0174860936,
0.0022915471,
-0.0410726741,
0.0374792106,
0.0546704717,
-0.0220853854,
-0.0501683913,
-0.1162874699,
-0.0069326819,
-0.0019946813,
-0.0746399909,
0.0209617317,
-0.0500591323,
-0.0042493516,
0.055811625,
0.0099953422,
-0.0749998391,
1.759162193e-34,
0.029931156,
-0.0085228067,
-0.008170235,
-0.0204821546,
0.0025835147,
-0.004296124,
-0.0333363935,
0.0191272534,
-0.0257321708,
-0.0508883931,
-0.0252993517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03142v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03142v2 | Less is KEN: a Universal and Simple Non-Parametric Pruning Algorithm for Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T16:11:43 | 2024-06-09T10:32:03 | Michele Mastromattei, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Neural network pruning has become increasingly crucial due to the complexity
of these models and their widespread use in various fields. Existing pruning
algorithms often suffer from limitations such as architecture specificity,
excessive complexity and reliance on demanding calculations, rendering them
impractical for real-world applications. This paper introduces KEN: a
straightforward, universal and unstructured pruning algorithm based on Kernel
Density Estimation (KDE). KEN aims to construct optimized transformers by
selectively preserving the most significant parameters while restoring others
to their pre-training state. This strategy preserves model performance while
enabling storage of only the optimized subnetwork, leading to substantial
memory savings. Extensive evaluations across seven different LLMs demonstrate
that KEN achieves equal or better performance than their original unpruned
versions, with a minimum parameter reduction of 25%. Furthermore, in-depth
comparisons with established pruning and PEFT algorithms confirm KEN
effectiveness. We further introduce KEN$_{viz}$, an explainable tool that
visualizes the optimized model composition achieved by KEN from different
points of view. | [
-0.0036454792,
0.0651392788,
-0.0104350913,
0.0535727516,
-0.0192025043,
-0.0268880203,
-0.0118231243,
0.0323234573,
-0.0889281407,
0.0247147176,
-0.0754187554,
0.002066754,
0.0143744564,
-0.0036842355,
0.0127060711,
-0.0355811827,
0.0318081118,
-0.0246311855,
-0.0318999328,
-0.0123301474,
0.0037605038,
0.0009195051,
0.0037123272,
0.0493093804,
-0.0175789129,
-0.0205083769,
-0.0033270654,
-0.0081059085,
-0.007220149,
0.0294353981,
0.0162689369,
0.0386070237,
-0.0204219986,
0.0116826603,
0.000002227,
0.0035339107,
0.0315777287,
-0.0093309218,
-0.056246493,
0.087226145,
0.0221211147,
-0.0073964065,
0.0000481499,
-0.0210434701,
-0.0083128316,
-0.0309877973,
0.0501019917,
0.0822587609,
0.0518658385,
0.0810725316,
0.0164296422,
-0.0548178516,
-0.0114584407,
-0.0359948911,
-0.0464859977,
-0.0091590025,
0.0238943994,
-0.0305436887,
-0.0436720625,
-0.0136845307,
-0.0067534456,
0.0301294364,
0.0317347273,
0.0074182712,
0.0088088196,
0.034624435,
-0.0561765581,
-0.0213035792,
0.0406324416,
0.0651080832,
-0.029685948,
-0.0276994053,
0.0269586258,
-0.0051015336,
-0.0076124649,
-0.0392205529,
-0.0273881089,
-0.0010555061,
0.0494500138,
0.023529714,
-0.0625109151,
-0.0181707758,
0.0594947934,
-0.0043903319,
-0.0257475711,
0.0614884607,
0.0302513745,
0.0074901059,
-0.009982951,
-0.0225999914,
-0.0497792959,
-0.0360913128,
-0.0050704847,
0.023191832,
0.0383208394,
-0.0018253817,
-0.0331654437,
-0.0100968899,
-0.0058558066,
-0.0572060496,
0.026340194,
0.0293570329,
0.0242657568,
-0.0098767122,
-0.0185662583,
0.0256879106,
0.0257453229,
0.0150968209,
-0.0366280861,
0.0222456511,
-0.038380526,
-0.0145577881,
-0.0400007404,
0.0181486532,
-0.0220919121,
-0.0055569489,
-0.0517534018,
-0.0049297838,
-0.0004540899,
-0.0239330865,
0.0726353303,
0.0249627866,
0.0103808753,
0.0207412709,
0.0074349521,
0.040379405,
-0.0489413738,
-0.0058139469,
-0.0280718524,
-0.0337556973,
-0.0184652302,
0.04453253,
0.0010889046,
-0.0159166027,
-0.0061806059,
0.0286419727,
0.0181518141,
-0.0420210138,
-0.0509855449,
-0.0103432033,
-0.0456287116,
-0.0646760091,
0.0278526358,
-0.0651017427,
0.0197908804,
-0.0579759404,
-0.0004613845,
-0.0741797462,
-0.0072898651,
0.0168534536,
-0.0309690144,
0.0280720163,
0.0061488929,
0.0239674635,
0.0489590131,
0.0070889494,
0.0381975695,
0.0738345385,
0.0214264207,
0.0094843013,
0.0040631271,
-0.0244793184,
-0.0486609079,
0.0413410626,
0.0374655165,
-0.016323898,
-0.0674647391,
-0.0323100388,
-0.0242855642,
-0.0004454542,
0.0357350782,
0.0375729091,
-0.0428234711,
-0.0574513115,
0.0636422187,
0.0183790121,
0.047129184,
0.0453112237,
0.0310738832,
0.019107027,
0.0399097204,
-0.0154502625,
-0.0323738344,
-0.0045125736,
-0.021776244,
-0.01879628,
-0.0512178056,
0.0248780623,
-0.0532830656,
-0.0437038541,
-0.0179820284,
-0.013157296,
-0.0415165946,
0.0144284423,
0.0303280093,
0.0199987963,
-0.0115975458,
0.1308507621,
-0.006291714,
-0.0367058106,
0.0013083301,
-0.0414703079,
-0.0351434387,
0.02277443,
0.0210379604,
-0.0200318918,
-0.0279086195,
0.0424806848,
0.0007167333,
-0.0143868877,
0.0261276439,
0.0013939789,
0.0360896513,
-0.0606176704,
-0.0040508304,
-0.0171742849,
0.0465308055,
-0.019005334,
0.0415327512,
0.027956631,
0.0403720886,
-0.073227793,
0.012462127,
0.0555289611,
-0.0093242992,
-0.0012151214,
0.0263598189,
0.0054640197,
0.0136040226,
-0.0031160754,
-0.0279790945,
0.0091870176,
0.0586211421,
-0.0166170578,
0.0105991205,
0.0024969582,
-0.0397453681,
-0.0602101609,
0.039446786,
0.0322894491,
0.0424534604,
0.061259754,
-0.0490063876,
-0.0486033186,
0.0098301191,
-0.0452437326,
0.0587782525,
-0.0463127904,
0.0262609515,
-0.0087128533,
0.0535812527,
0.0086467844,
0.0316389278,
-0.0480434261,
-0.0011581529,
0.0135748805,
-0.0240109507,
-0.009036026,
-0.0493531264,
-0.0520736538,
0.0058196443,
-0.047117155,
0.0257878974,
-0.0151615674,
-0.0150077883,
0.00688256,
0.0052711149,
-0.0691272244,
0.0217968691,
-0.0253084321,
0.0179760121,
-0.0006452634,
0.0225127786,
0.0046428824,
-0.0079521714,
0.0326582976,
0.0512595847,
0.0040098564,
0.0137702534,
-0.0025070426,
-0.0150963059,
-0.0161176119,
-0.0085408781,
-0.0595831238,
0.0308931544,
0.0859730914,
-0.0818009973,
-0.0238517839,
-0.0356711186,
0.0874468461,
-0.044041656,
0.0281120446,
-0.008686794,
-0.0595699102,
-0.03797701,
-0.005424975,
0.0132845985,
0.0321828164,
0.0053744814,
0.0320966505,
0.0549778342,
0.0136164725,
-0.026184069,
0.0204813927,
-0.0087054363,
0.0092616389,
-0.0160699375,
-0.0370321497,
-0.0019616999,
0.0742987767,
-0.00338284,
-0.0078723766,
-0.0565937795,
-0.0317651108,
-0.0144676417,
-0.0376137681,
-0.0374240689,
0.0003803155,
-0.0231121425,
-0.0069734002,
-0.0151456269,
0.0038512258,
0.0244378243,
-0.0431231596,
0.0013412321,
0.0180652216,
-0.0212464426,
-0.0034747724,
0.0517160036,
0.0426799282,
0.0020543002,
-0.0042251828,
0.0218433626,
-0.0355149359,
-0.0258175898,
-0.0101720383,
0.0066241203,
0.0530193895,
-0.0319508687,
-0.0048331078,
-0.0023825034,
-0.0017838911,
-0.0312182158,
-0.009861663,
-0.0302707683,
0.028651014,
-0.0099961413,
-0.0317571834,
-0.0268239304,
0.0227880031,
-0.0015396931,
0.0583189428,
0.0206555631,
0.032351505,
0.0030404185,
0.0342932194,
0.0380284898,
0.0300218742,
0.0322686732,
-0.0318619423,
0.0593889877,
0.0466713607,
0.0200618301,
0.042920284,
-0.0760970488,
-0.0265423898,
-0.0235600788,
-0.0302492548,
-0.0399666242,
0.0046331086,
0.0482254103,
-0.0610516109,
0.0233920403,
0.0730770081,
0.0030561271,
-0.0400505848,
0.030279886,
0.0393952541,
0.059127491,
0.0174522959,
0.0471488163,
-0.0429109596,
-0.0417545512,
0.025235245,
0.0154622812,
0.0227626543,
-0.0228695851,
-0.0121413581,
-0.0977080688,
0.0222147629,
-0.0021715066,
-0.034740109,
0.0072420784,
-0.0624230281,
-0.0031331247,
-0.0347448215,
-0.0237321574,
0.0001928586,
-0.0069113187,
-0.0309436824,
0.0050568972,
-0.0494022891,
-0.0479806401,
0.0159169454,
-0.0075867199,
0.0287113041,
0.0192059893,
0.0379768088,
-0.0028065403,
-0.0256625898,
0.0333256684,
-0.0271400511,
-0.0044451579,
0.0018982977,
0.0671264157,
0.0333033949,
-0.0220750626,
0.0124198487,
0.0049679889,
-0.0221249163,
-0.0113445064,
-0.0236398093,
0.062440455,
-0.0143947452,
-0.0536022522,
-0.0051879631,
-0.0034514603,
-0.0333125517,
0.0601118021,
0.0531406924,
-0.0095997183,
-0.0368889049,
0.0261259973,
-0.0068098037,
-0.0193390381,
-0.01101718,
0.0122798355,
-0.0006674995,
-0.0719678029,
-0.050576508,
0.0126131428,
-0.0090256836,
-0.0049794749,
-0.010637112,
-0.027667962,
-0.006244841,
0.0437110066,
-0.0932053104,
0.0399861597,
-0.0252622962,
0.0052102078,
-0.0465194248,
0.0351349227,
0.051205866,
-0.0120635414,
-0.0243101679,
0.0001319936,
-0.0829038993,
-0.0440710746,
-0.0114623168,
0.0721552521,
0.0142602213,
0.0551702417,
0.0005196773,
-0.0437042154,
0.0424400829,
0.0567526892,
-0.0042390744,
0.0577156395,
0.0263249446,
-0.0678984448,
-0.006453977,
0.0696602836,
-0.0163477454,
0.0437319279,
0.0147653567,
0.0008119605,
-0.006203759,
-0.0143491467,
-0.05103717,
0.0254018623,
0.0144609548,
0.0161107555,
0.0033219829,
-0.0266584139,
0.0217750128,
0.0113252066,
0.0188150518,
-0.0492027067,
0.0082099428,
0.0289015919,
0.0634128675,
-0.002492585,
0.0529006645,
0.0523311049,
-0.0036339215,
0.0074148728,
0.0210786778,
0.0452107526,
0.0113443611,
0.0503136329,
0.0294597,
-0.0284501351,
0.0157843363,
0.0065954369,
-0.0006924293,
-0.0531918928,
-0.0074553518,
-0.0101254033,
0.0030844877,
-0.091831401,
0.0317755006,
-0.0508853123,
-0.0643335804,
-0.0361245349,
0.0519652702,
0.0291887745,
-0.0250482596,
0.0184478741,
-0.0338613205,
-0.0148000848,
-0.0421798639,
0.0364095233,
0.0188824944,
0.0174143426,
0.019824205,
0.0130387871,
-0.0136905629,
-0.014452449,
0.0445253477,
0.0270061828,
0.0813990757,
-0.0261302907,
0.0008772933,
-0.0409577638,
-0.0297756959,
-0.0333812796,
0.0096546467,
-0.0395902619,
-0.0328941718,
-0.0230795164,
-0.0870755687,
0.0214704685,
-0.0273682605,
0.0010475259,
-0.0119871395,
0.073358424,
0.0216949396,
0.0224189814,
-0.0011164868,
-0.0080497582,
-0.0454781577,
-0.0078219492,
-0.0307218246,
0.0193351898,
-6.333686989e-33,
0.0150217591,
-0.0022903783,
0.0103803976,
0.0083252406,
-0.0554299429,
0.0181450062,
-0.0377105512,
-0.0191855878,
-0.0280635282,
0.0195120331,
-0.0337688625,
0.0294747241,
0.0053907949,
0.017555695,
-0.0361251086,
-0.0036770522,
0.0951740518,
-0.0398573801,
-0.0067448844,
0.0229400545,
0.0083123092,
0.0542536378,
0.0682059377,
0.0226047095,
-0.0395772606,
0.0397306047,
0.0009711697,
0.0207214318,
-0.025042193,
0.0257541519,
-0.0554889441,
0.0675283745,
0.0173250865,
-0.0248503927,
-0.0101684397,
0.0047737961,
-0.0746841803,
-0.0335736759,
0.016652694,
0.0258333255,
-0.0197206177,
-0.013995043,
0.0842684433,
0.0214037821,
-0.0242544264,
0.0108644869,
0.0224224664,
-0.0081970589,
-0.0624506697,
0.012454208,
-0.0262469351,
0.0297654625,
0.0036461423,
-0.0535328463,
0.0488606021,
0.0351939052,
-0.0195372831,
-0.0187787451,
-0.0477091968,
-0.0174122453,
0.0034181941,
0.0629050136,
0.0572251007,
0.0519196317,
0.0200366322,
0.0652713031,
0.0281073134,
0.0146854268,
-0.0586487725,
-0.0191954114,
0.0802359432,
0.0854245722,
0.0410614088,
-0.0034717401,
0.005926874,
-0.0694609806,
-0.0846914798,
-0.0206223018,
0.0032230294,
0.0426163711,
-0.0148958508,
0.0020027615,
0.0238807276,
-0.0127210366,
-0.0335579179,
-0.0644589812,
-0.029579578,
0.0075475513,
0.0286230706,
0.0195033327,
-0.0802615583,
-0.0014393929,
0.0130609917,
-0.0644487441,
0.046686884,
0.058794152,
0.0052780961,
0.0429132804,
0.0214378666,
0.0129909366,
-0.0481831878,
-0.012365317,
-0.0039498126,
-0.0035412123,
0.0252918471,
-0.0130829467,
0.0356686413,
0.0350875929,
-0.0150923654,
-0.0131743951,
-0.0307128299,
0.0127586043,
0.0043076687,
0.1104525626,
0.0385340936,
0.0209756158,
0.0180377513,
0.0114894547,
0.0267316587,
0.0002735952,
-0.0097155627,
-0.0130081102,
0.0686191097,
0.0346134789,
0.0004814283,
-0.0194748174,
-0.0391224883,
0.0186742395,
0.0102620982,
-0.0670638084,
-0.0209155232,
0.0230315328,
2.849e-7,
0.0348297171,
-0.0235642437,
0.002745836,
-0.0242857728,
0.0330039747,
-0.0012736918,
-0.0063901707,
-0.0105331466,
-0.0335646346,
-0.0229028407,
0.0194795597,
0.0268463735,
0.0873661339,
-0.0063495529,
-0.1156152114,
-0.0132228406,
-0.0651399195,
-0.0162765514,
-0.0266066529,
-0.0466062166,
-0.0279990807,
0.1017548516,
0.0213757232,
-0.0350722708,
-0.0038942653,
-0.0111411624,
0.0320113674,
-0.0189387165,
0.044513613,
0.0216790568,
0.0261587631,
-0.0022774925,
-0.009052759,
-0.0086564487,
-0.025809342,
0.0123771252,
-0.001469741,
0.1152473018,
-0.0164161045,
-0.0408857204,
0.018278135,
0.0325344354,
-0.0218251795,
-0.0292774141,
0.0671791807,
0.0044153132,
0.0079400027,
-0.0246995073,
0.0198245943,
-0.0405124389,
0.0312840529,
-0.0258933622,
0.0018568912,
0.0370592065,
0.008430711,
-0.0479943156,
-0.0362632573,
-0.0829621628,
-0.0376995094,
-0.0244081374,
-0.0790199712,
-0.0160639472,
-0.0702343434,
-0.0424561799,
0.0568113253,
-0.0148629937,
-0.0222560875,
2.506321785e-34,
0.0337124318,
-0.0018990942,
-0.0163601413,
0.0283940751,
0.0123897167,
-0.0156492926,
-0.0116369277,
0.016516719,
-0.0480467416,
-0.0675987974,
-0.0246900488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03137v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03137v1 | Sociolinguistically Informed Interpretability: A Case Study on Hinglish Emotion Classification | 2024-02-05T16:05:32 | 2024-02-05T16:05:32 | Kushal Tatariya, Heather Lent, Johannes Bjerva, Miryam de Lhoneux | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Emotion classification is a challenging task in NLP due to the inherent
idiosyncratic and subjective nature of linguistic expression, especially with
code-mixed data. Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have achieved high
performance for many tasks and languages, but it remains to be seen whether
these models learn and are robust to the differences in emotional expression
across languages. Sociolinguistic studies have shown that Hinglish speakers
switch to Hindi when expressing negative emotions and to English when
expressing positive emotions. To understand if language models can learn these
associations, we study the effect of language on emotion prediction across 3
PLMs on a Hinglish emotion classification dataset. Using LIME and token level
language ID, we find that models do learn these associations between language
choice and emotional expression. Moreover, having code-mixed data present in
the pre-training can augment that learning when task-specific data is scarce.
We also conclude from the misclassifications that the models may overgeneralise
this heuristic to other infrequent examples where this sociolinguistic
phenomenon does not apply. | [
0.029083211,
0.0581680909,
-0.0267368052,
0.0411619991,
0.0203788821,
0.0354379676,
0.0064058076,
0.0098093878,
0.0451341756,
-0.0380475931,
-0.0961235017,
-0.0152505236,
-0.0120473597,
0.0233803857,
0.0064649605,
-0.039780505,
0.023079291,
0.0417178012,
0.0413385741,
-0.0231603179,
0.024042977,
0.0369962864,
0.0228691623,
0.0255698711,
-0.022796398,
-0.0164130963,
-0.0245251041,
0.0149686439,
0.0025966379,
0.000687382,
0.0309043434,
0.0707055703,
-0.0084615108,
-0.0076224976,
0.0000019872,
-0.0341024585,
-0.0023515739,
-0.035593994,
-0.0264578499,
0.0367401242,
0.1040649638,
-0.0071879695,
-0.0256596468,
0.0048635816,
-0.0306318309,
-0.0334744565,
0.0644473508,
0.0300855562,
0.0592527576,
0.0482148193,
-0.0273627564,
-0.0050475169,
-0.0382559337,
-0.0131926751,
-0.0143719101,
0.0103140371,
0.0366464406,
0.0191527512,
-0.0260684863,
-0.029875759,
-0.0577233769,
0.0041055148,
-0.0054699881,
0.0085543906,
-0.0290031172,
-0.0337641798,
-0.0470604524,
-0.0329443663,
0.0240391418,
0.0279426295,
-0.0279829446,
-0.0515396073,
-0.0118545089,
-0.0123327263,
-0.0214698054,
-0.0259400625,
0.0202084128,
-0.0038890047,
0.0141637307,
0.0576309972,
0.059369985,
0.0329075716,
0.030839825,
0.0448699221,
-0.0064687412,
0.0656855032,
-0.0480425432,
0.0202317592,
0.0228643529,
0.0038666415,
0.0212223902,
-0.014780879,
0.0136689423,
-0.0263589993,
0.0010858012,
0.045426812,
-0.0149137853,
-0.0005392017,
-0.0119472183,
-0.0986484513,
-0.0144245848,
0.0255948231,
-0.0430329032,
0.0061533763,
0.0311168805,
-0.0008612434,
0.0135388738,
0.0170944091,
-0.0116843693,
-0.0325986482,
-0.0548249334,
-0.0173279252,
0.0117330691,
0.0240545198,
-0.0334784687,
0.0328091271,
-0.0959872454,
-0.0120385606,
-0.0752260685,
-0.0164003912,
-0.0185486153,
-0.0378367901,
-0.0193562731,
-0.0067863655,
-0.0307635516,
0.0115925204,
-0.0240842793,
0.0329615064,
-0.0582020916,
-0.0655913204,
0.0665675104,
0.0090047559,
-0.0286228284,
-0.0141398963,
0.0151531622,
0.0096875932,
-0.0041980585,
-0.0065124407,
-0.0802882239,
-0.0065314444,
-0.016070649,
-0.05014937,
-0.0238649733,
-0.0270923115,
0.0182165299,
0.0395067818,
0.0206819829,
-0.0718296915,
-0.0103783859,
-0.0396658853,
-0.0274270698,
0.0674420148,
0.0058641671,
-0.0142980702,
-0.0025433553,
0.0105709964,
0.0056743245,
0.0767978802,
0.0120692858,
0.0234057773,
0.0639679879,
-0.0427904427,
0.0318526514,
0.0395864584,
-0.0061034956,
-0.0097842067,
-0.00695374,
-0.0437374115,
-0.0172442626,
-0.040485613,
0.0466861762,
0.0142703429,
0.0026605513,
-0.0185720176,
-0.0039741844,
0.035511177,
0.0097458223,
0.0523364395,
-0.0051424252,
0.0240207464,
0.0102845049,
0.0079024043,
-0.023457747,
-0.007760054,
-0.0465716049,
-0.0463254526,
-0.0219891798,
0.0085572544,
-0.044182878,
-0.0675652027,
-0.0216349661,
-0.0336827524,
0.0274735298,
0.0262563173,
0.0491058864,
-0.0075256745,
0.011680508,
0.0334536843,
0.0745967925,
-0.0763438717,
0.0177583508,
-0.041389659,
0.0059228549,
0.0490546376,
-0.0263523702,
-0.0369565375,
0.0291565415,
-0.0073461938,
-0.0250369683,
0.0083896434,
0.0456282906,
-0.0212581195,
0.0394484513,
-0.032355275,
0.0311697219,
0.0250822995,
0.0079964474,
0.0227438807,
-0.0320274271,
0.0315325484,
-0.0095694959,
-0.0158920139,
-0.0642688125,
0.0040865531,
-0.050201457,
-0.0129283099,
-0.0058267685,
0.0132423388,
0.063031666,
0.0182134211,
-0.0005692327,
-0.0308028776,
-0.0107396273,
-0.000599407,
0.0121381423,
0.0655006096,
-0.0026683279,
-0.0633862987,
0.008410193,
-0.0081777321,
-0.012175166,
0.0361081809,
-0.0285119582,
-0.0237264391,
0.0677721426,
0.0019385302,
0.0730459765,
-0.0395501591,
0.0192788076,
-0.053887412,
0.0136180362,
-0.0221024472,
0.0271396171,
0.0075853444,
0.0043632197,
-0.0349697731,
-0.0058176192,
0.0364280976,
0.002089075,
-0.0651957393,
0.0463601388,
0.0049851653,
-0.0186423212,
-0.0087351557,
-0.0233277306,
-0.048484955,
-0.0220070016,
-0.1103375852,
-0.0295167491,
-0.0092630666,
0.0028482133,
-0.0130699966,
-0.0084339166,
-0.0116000334,
0.0106583228,
-0.037804842,
0.0057869214,
0.0174022391,
0.0176746175,
-0.0071869721,
-0.0196970869,
0.0315527469,
-0.0647077709,
-0.0234464742,
-0.0316559337,
0.0635557026,
-0.0026117105,
-0.0070612212,
-0.0296940636,
0.0286761411,
-0.0469368249,
0.0077627865,
-0.0313159414,
-0.0846971348,
-0.0251587722,
0.0205252375,
0.0026332051,
0.0181295834,
-0.0346523114,
0.0776963979,
0.0193897896,
0.0096835792,
-0.049703259,
-0.0024692838,
0.0024614823,
0.0247963984,
-0.0414155312,
-0.0661576316,
-0.0343290195,
0.0665657371,
0.0173318442,
-0.0177664999,
-0.0606129766,
-0.0107029313,
-0.033294633,
-0.0375913605,
0.0028100684,
-0.0353043005,
0.0107112983,
0.05785577,
0.007086758,
-0.0601222068,
0.050134141,
0.0325244442,
-0.0408963747,
-0.0769151896,
-0.0190866962,
-0.0380788073,
0.0686091483,
-0.0406986885,
-0.0010844088,
-0.0048520095,
-0.0108158179,
-0.0275818314,
-0.045134604,
-0.0395000093,
-0.0411144793,
0.0358874612,
-0.0319434814,
-0.0549995899,
0.020045964,
-0.0556175336,
-0.0142803015,
-0.0578897893,
-0.0528929383,
-0.0215143394,
0.0652076378,
0.0056443671,
0.0729193613,
-0.0045605432,
-0.0030036068,
-0.0764473528,
-0.0089900987,
-0.0065098158,
0.0239110589,
-0.0090974281,
0.0293013081,
-0.0076952139,
0.0168664269,
0.0014436628,
0.0030545492,
-0.0049386593,
0.0491935089,
-0.0194110759,
-0.027120769,
0.0651991591,
0.0380193777,
0.0378763489,
-0.0686465725,
-0.0139079327,
0.0292754695,
-0.0075398572,
0.04151465,
0.1001178771,
0.0375428647,
-0.0332970358,
0.026072247,
-0.0489478,
0.020452844,
0.0214158278,
0.041751653,
0.0022113498,
0.0007131832,
-0.0142941251,
-0.0023399782,
-0.0141985426,
-0.0028157223,
-0.0077978778,
-0.0870693251,
0.0183909945,
0.0210388377,
-0.0094192661,
-0.0319157057,
-0.0117701394,
-0.0088581871,
-0.0203086734,
-0.0226602294,
-0.0312809907,
0.0067795203,
0.0019047927,
0.054734353,
-0.0502771139,
-0.0494424254,
0.0686386153,
-0.0019088791,
0.0604089499,
0.0219452027,
0.0534957796,
-0.0610875711,
-0.0297672451,
0.0486148372,
0.0153578361,
-0.0208247341,
-0.03831397,
0.052365046,
0.0084106913,
-0.0293079205,
-0.0112966336,
0.0190160554,
-0.0374171287,
0.0031940059,
-0.0226681624,
0.058474578,
-0.0094678327,
-0.0405842736,
0.007465987,
0.0058929492,
0.005474891,
0.0562036037,
0.0098968158,
-0.0617409796,
-0.0141882338,
-0.0431960337,
0.0417649075,
0.013822102,
-0.0274495557,
0.028497912,
-0.0098892143,
-0.062623471,
-0.0275841448,
-0.0976264477,
0.0001249927,
0.0467181504,
0.0128215598,
-0.0223765019,
0.0237108488,
-0.026402276,
-0.0221596714,
0.0508230887,
0.0134805758,
0.0081006372,
-0.016020149,
-0.0395839475,
0.0536677539,
-0.0437501334,
-0.0146129346,
-0.0614824295,
0.0190141555,
-0.0486940183,
0.0567303896,
0.0414747968,
0.0260280166,
0.0207065344,
0.0204839408,
-0.0813933462,
-0.0079437355,
-0.0023641989,
-0.0000454007,
0.0027597933,
0.0806879327,
0.0404489636,
-0.0007102066,
0.0197515767,
-0.0168276615,
0.0567820035,
0.0619231388,
-0.0251473915,
-0.0239601526,
-0.0249415468,
-0.0129919229,
-0.0000520424,
0.0383311175,
-0.0272496287,
-0.0694529042,
-0.0482280031,
-0.0325957686,
-0.0013594086,
-0.0136697516,
-0.0264446121,
-0.0608719997,
0.0075521227,
-0.0019344869,
-0.0599279664,
-0.0486588068,
-0.0398364961,
-0.0126356017,
0.018619692,
0.054711584,
0.0539458878,
0.033299759,
-0.0163561944,
0.0613197386,
-0.0163140874,
0.0003168333,
0.0023735731,
0.0131777842,
0.0060135145,
0.0579522625,
0.0051769051,
-0.0054879668,
0.0175219849,
0.0091498056,
0.0090343086,
0.0313675888,
0.0108930133,
-0.0363120846,
0.0441338494,
-0.0686562806,
0.0387344211,
-0.0380879752,
0.0404425748,
-0.0466039181,
0.0357339494,
0.0039634574,
-0.0765356943,
0.0411732234,
-0.0249679163,
-0.0479597971,
0.0061112028,
0.0625830442,
-0.0173770133,
0.0336226113,
0.0030690967,
-0.0148960119,
-0.0279261172,
0.0075231255,
0.0856569409,
-0.0040032784,
-0.0129695488,
0.0331824087,
-0.098199524,
-0.0972166061,
0.0383176953,
-0.0574053563,
0.0148444343,
-0.0261270106,
0.0263319891,
0.0887994841,
-0.0105115836,
0.0341805257,
-0.0512675568,
0.0133980997,
-0.0335314386,
0.0156495199,
-0.0015088391,
-5.995158208e-33,
0.0017651287,
-0.0086170891,
-0.0396755971,
0.00473765,
0.0162152071,
0.0206301324,
-0.0371041298,
0.0350630656,
-0.0267265998,
0.0575119331,
-0.008847178,
0.0262335446,
0.0102184461,
0.0175012965,
0.0402056091,
-0.0269228127,
0.0253725611,
0.0296573825,
0.0208948441,
-0.0075373719,
0.031673491,
0.0430405363,
0.0693107098,
-0.1041350365,
0.0659949109,
0.0251649152,
-0.0051641599,
-0.0252770577,
0.0404818393,
0.0392228849,
-0.0314026661,
0.081798248,
0.0276497472,
0.0226161759,
0.0098176431,
-0.0026992345,
-0.0200998336,
-0.0379328243,
0.0206816103,
0.0505006947,
-0.0195599236,
-0.0133232009,
0.0139790056,
-0.0080408081,
-0.0521405824,
0.0144522274,
0.0234791916,
-0.0118074864,
0.0187424459,
-0.0472042188,
-0.0255649611,
0.0241167545,
-0.0013373641,
0.0036472774,
0.0484494977,
0.0394424684,
-0.0116288243,
0.0321047045,
-0.0489953347,
0.0004997331,
-0.0027546785,
0.0013965087,
0.0547928996,
0.0037574845,
-0.0038565393,
0.0637793317,
0.0475930572,
0.019893961,
0.0135048497,
0.0349250361,
0.0636979416,
0.0141094765,
0.0123924389,
0.0365647972,
-0.0194770135,
-0.0335206762,
-0.0144084767,
0.0084954137,
0.0481903255,
-0.0149611048,
0.0365219265,
0.0231288988,
-0.0605492555,
-0.0580667369,
0.013301271,
-0.0301488489,
-0.0084859002,
-0.0378519148,
0.0063424953,
-0.0762669146,
0.0032460999,
0.0095114503,
0.0210522842,
-0.0442042872,
-0.0486084968,
0.0611135513,
-0.0351250619,
0.0487571359,
0.0218734741,
0.0391839221,
-0.0130701838,
-0.0200004,
-0.0306154899,
0.0022433021,
0.0457975008,
0.0123146633,
0.0156336278,
0.029531192,
-0.0448961407,
0.0089116581,
-0.0121435691,
-0.0066811545,
0.011331616,
0.0137664452,
-0.0165551156,
0.0404672064,
-0.0255396813,
-0.0204517879,
0.0509528443,
0.0391938873,
-0.0070984024,
-0.0065417653,
-0.0530062765,
0.0500498414,
-0.0432438478,
-0.03793405,
0.0128241554,
0.0011194637,
0.0217940081,
-0.0181694776,
0.0012386751,
-0.0188004859,
2.731e-7,
0.0346785672,
0.0582433641,
-0.0177251659,
-0.0251088087,
0.0219058041,
0.0516781881,
-0.0253260285,
0.0170724485,
0.0366569646,
0.0038254408,
0.0086346269,
-0.0156119,
0.0762033686,
0.0312008057,
-0.0489363968,
0.0137976147,
0.004290679,
0.0309886876,
-0.0158488005,
0.0510247685,
0.0819517598,
0.124072291,
0.0467096679,
0.0120252576,
-0.024788063,
0.0268831365,
0.0248189792,
-0.0585116707,
0.0051539908,
0.0463292114,
-0.030404985,
-0.0236888379,
0.0306262374,
0.0288028382,
-0.0247097574,
-0.0028787632,
0.0179602448,
0.041558329,
-0.0165692605,
-0.0166703705,
0.0022831503,
0.0328871459,
-0.0391466618,
-0.0515839718,
0.0503200628,
-0.0096181957,
-0.0541259982,
-0.0087844264,
0.0264739972,
-0.0177486241,
0.0335869379,
-0.0066929162,
-0.0330420136,
0.0320278928,
0.0082872091,
-0.0611559972,
-0.0193885285,
-0.0507118478,
-0.0186956692,
0.0104241092,
-0.0288391672,
-0.0041742036,
0.0081670228,
0.071122624,
0.0416169912,
-0.0287282448,
0.0415766202,
2.164146859e-34,
0.0364135988,
0.0122384131,
0.0061294027,
0.0217396691,
0.0497835912,
0.0201044641,
-0.0204199497,
0.0372793376,
0.0590180792,
-0.0062669409,
0.0187224764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03131v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03131v1 | Constrained Decoding for Cross-lingual Label Projection | 2024-02-05T15:57:32 | 2024-02-05T15:57:32 | Duong Minh Le, Yang Chen, Alan Ritter, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Zero-shot cross-lingual transfer utilizing multilingual LLMs has become a
popular learning paradigm for low-resource languages with no labeled training
data. However, for NLP tasks that involve fine-grained predictions on words and
phrases, the performance of zero-shot cross-lingual transfer learning lags far
behind supervised fine-tuning methods. Therefore, it is common to exploit
translation and label projection to further improve the performance by (1)
translating training data that is available in a high-resource language (e.g.,
English) together with the gold labels into low-resource languages, and/or (2)
translating test data in low-resource languages to a high-source language to
run inference on, then projecting the predicted span-level labels back onto the
original test data. However, state-of-the-art marker-based label projection
methods suffer from translation quality degradation due to the extra label
markers injected in the input to the translation model. In this work, we
explore a new direction that leverages constrained decoding for label
projection to overcome the aforementioned issues. Our new method not only can
preserve the quality of translated texts but also has the versatility of being
applicable to both translating training and translating test data strategies.
This versatility is crucial as our experiments reveal that translating test
data can lead to a considerable boost in performance compared to translating
only training data. We evaluate on two cross-lingual transfer tasks, namely
Named Entity Recognition and Event Argument Extraction, spanning 20 languages.
The results demonstrate that our approach outperforms the state-of-the-art
marker-based method by a large margin and also shows better performance than
other label projection methods that rely on external word alignment. | [
-0.0169810969,
0.0320718363,
0.0264625642,
0.0806169808,
0.0075695869,
0.0223302376,
-0.0014626817,
0.0133106057,
0.025076909,
-0.0296158753,
-0.0479423702,
0.0120630888,
-0.0264143888,
-0.0580042861,
0.0386880636,
-0.0352130383,
0.0203038137,
-0.0138782701,
0.0031522023,
0.0003572115,
0.0072025233,
0.0154147223,
-0.0159234442,
0.0064382846,
-0.0230231825,
0.0137756113,
0.0251762923,
0.0003084338,
0.0414980985,
-0.0411372557,
-0.0018237837,
0.0163035933,
0.0007567115,
0.0248099212,
0.0000018803,
-0.0560989566,
-0.0570624582,
0.0120139159,
0.0099764727,
0.018308429,
0.012332378,
-0.0630148724,
-0.0070439642,
-0.0108659491,
-0.0123161701,
-0.0781294554,
0.0601029471,
0.0646981522,
0.0093786633,
0.078141354,
-0.0307958331,
-0.0068642823,
0.0005314106,
-0.0243392512,
0.0086780274,
-0.0805131793,
0.0062703048,
-0.0043621706,
-0.0338836759,
0.0256496668,
-0.0051061744,
0.0561769009,
-0.0234872475,
0.0396710709,
-0.018958142,
0.0156158013,
-0.0258761551,
-0.0178417731,
0.0033255615,
0.0541859753,
-0.0112007074,
-0.0088987583,
0.0096888086,
-0.009821726,
-0.019239055,
-0.0503008701,
-0.0392073393,
0.0294883568,
-0.0105247414,
0.051154267,
0.0699974149,
0.0351036713,
0.0396936908,
-0.0311185475,
-0.0126173748,
0.0376066752,
0.0218581874,
-0.0121306414,
0.0101949312,
0.0461639389,
0.0057050227,
-0.0156762749,
0.0063653965,
0.0159757547,
0.0055482178,
0.0351240113,
-0.0266439635,
-0.0102350842,
-0.0080481842,
-0.0169212315,
0.0020613458,
0.0494747683,
-0.0342371799,
0.0545702688,
-0.0768413395,
0.0483717769,
-0.0292404406,
0.0319741368,
-0.0443697087,
-0.0546233989,
-0.045108173,
0.033648923,
-0.0280146487,
0.015315515,
-0.0231932234,
0.0153229982,
-0.0107303904,
-0.0099688442,
0.0264637787,
0.0042524878,
0.0249817818,
-0.0301817507,
-0.0317269415,
-0.0195264518,
0.0121186655,
0.0749849156,
-0.021000525,
-0.0225421023,
-0.0473730899,
-0.0463770553,
-0.0441307761,
0.0246480554,
-0.0012744535,
-0.0286842957,
-0.0104015768,
0.1122815162,
-0.0293427035,
-0.0422382727,
-0.0558522344,
-0.0040939231,
-0.037549112,
-0.0366514139,
0.0388261788,
-0.0455455258,
0.0473792441,
0.0171186551,
0.034191303,
-0.0567469597,
0.0466446131,
-0.026803473,
-0.0724320561,
0.0727725178,
0.0191605054,
-0.0122433323,
-0.0066895606,
-0.0144529073,
-0.0329331011,
0.0972058252,
0.0479342826,
0.0126114879,
0.0549557284,
0.016688399,
-0.0393757299,
0.0769997612,
0.03559931,
0.0383717194,
0.0042924164,
-0.0218539741,
0.0787404403,
-0.0083469767,
0.0130780339,
-0.0274859071,
0.0048665004,
0.0126232291,
0.0469269305,
0.0002350436,
-0.0254579838,
-0.0009395835,
0.013908782,
-0.0369689725,
-0.0355409756,
0.0046269963,
-0.0166007336,
0.0051280819,
0.0128416037,
-0.0188716166,
0.0327626616,
0.0023127471,
-0.0189223439,
-0.0010789064,
-0.0038762772,
-0.0216154512,
-0.0111804521,
0.0062707639,
0.0549275577,
0.0433691554,
-0.0669911057,
0.0836693943,
0.0531855002,
-0.0346667245,
0.0272826664,
0.0236994158,
-0.0142708626,
0.0059296843,
0.0094661843,
-0.0331324078,
-0.0199382436,
0.0165841337,
0.0476050526,
0.035205543,
0.0621405616,
-0.0093911728,
0.0666169524,
-0.0256496463,
-0.0117968619,
0.0041333628,
0.0211206246,
0.0321333855,
0.0032922847,
0.0489420295,
0.0123453448,
-0.0622994639,
-0.0427484922,
0.0409664623,
-0.0475861803,
-0.0720730796,
0.0380056202,
0.0283785947,
-0.0221193694,
0.022793347,
0.0250225216,
-0.0160695873,
0.0189182777,
-0.0846487209,
0.0297993682,
-0.005403148,
0.002972689,
-0.0719244108,
0.0249821208,
-0.0506978892,
-0.0262272358,
-0.0095790438,
-0.0441455804,
-0.0506320111,
-0.0232809316,
0.0200010948,
0.0218036305,
-0.0045428541,
0.0169656686,
0.0072953594,
0.0211964268,
-0.0411564708,
0.0228869934,
0.0366443135,
0.036380399,
0.0174445398,
-0.0398254208,
0.0532664172,
-0.0050094603,
-0.0430789851,
0.057078585,
-0.0011026266,
-0.0214573704,
0.0208916161,
0.0217999015,
-0.0308069084,
0.0012872145,
-0.0678624958,
0.059235312,
0.0010221833,
0.0676027909,
0.0236908644,
0.0127263786,
0.0003852745,
-0.0191202406,
-0.0375924185,
-0.0242001787,
-0.027348388,
-0.0105957929,
0.0482659638,
0.0261224192,
0.0187849514,
-0.0157568175,
0.0386566222,
-0.0149607342,
0.0217300393,
-0.0240776669,
-0.0564628541,
-0.0645131022,
0.0641347542,
-0.0182243846,
0.0277180523,
0.0163273644,
-0.0156647675,
-0.0057729529,
-0.0014926885,
0.0223974939,
0.0252483245,
-0.0509793907,
-0.0156031242,
0.0190966744,
-0.0376280621,
-0.0641844198,
0.0026926042,
-0.006337231,
-0.025803335,
-0.0459349379,
-0.0271617472,
0.001076856,
0.062896505,
0.0045095505,
0.0162276886,
-0.0957566351,
-0.03890628,
-0.0230889544,
-0.0125000719,
-0.0141924927,
0.0795769319,
0.0141276093,
0.0262184981,
-0.028921945,
-0.0021243102,
0.0559328236,
-0.0688033924,
-0.018858742,
0.0053720218,
0.0004441213,
-0.0511878692,
0.0282384884,
-0.0158194769,
0.0170151144,
0.0013652775,
-0.0393563285,
-0.0267542601,
0.0302715432,
0.0171429832,
-0.036325831,
0.0045250198,
-0.0361370742,
-0.0092159668,
-0.0526831076,
-0.0249625221,
-0.0252500698,
-0.0062110717,
-0.0132590765,
-0.0001596449,
-0.0477854982,
0.0114555713,
-0.023642242,
0.0125476457,
0.0203900989,
0.0190490838,
-0.0121815195,
0.0063462518,
-0.0267079379,
0.032366138,
-0.0059337076,
-0.013293609,
-0.0186810605,
-0.0149627328,
-0.0033764925,
0.0281089135,
-0.0023200298,
0.0170492623,
-0.0060594454,
0.0041679032,
0.0514858216,
0.0225472692,
-0.0202973653,
-0.0308279004,
0.0783775523,
-0.0366712511,
0.0115080746,
0.0761980787,
0.0078374185,
-0.030558072,
-0.0197108444,
-0.0092368061,
0.0127423331,
0.0128436238,
0.0232203659,
-0.0883106515,
-0.0428826101,
0.012445217,
0.022435125,
0.0110851787,
-0.0281100404,
-0.0173562635,
-0.1258666366,
0.0004236989,
0.023764655,
-0.0596566014,
-0.018339688,
-0.0529909804,
0.0043578711,
-0.0200070031,
-0.0042686719,
-0.0472773276,
0.0188956168,
-0.00386389,
-0.0017628573,
0.0007818395,
-0.0655248314,
0.0026639092,
-0.0456700437,
0.0344694704,
0.0136501472,
0.0672849342,
0.0105429478,
-0.0039192825,
0.0062281876,
-0.0384456702,
-0.0326568075,
-0.0276051536,
0.0174535625,
-0.0025353034,
-0.0461443588,
0.0473476499,
0.0072802985,
-0.0502837263,
-0.0190280322,
0.0075714253,
0.1127451658,
0.0300748926,
0.009577007,
0.0349818468,
-0.0405694619,
0.0478090011,
0.0819039643,
0.0141669316,
-0.0135392789,
-0.0072582792,
-0.0123877805,
0.0071889781,
-0.05163702,
-0.0245147049,
0.0525563248,
-0.0901197493,
-0.0372589417,
-0.0871979594,
-0.0688224584,
0.0495787002,
0.0213887058,
0.0111943139,
0.0340033583,
-0.0272736195,
-0.013159005,
-0.0041438988,
0.0177036673,
-0.0535224713,
-0.0026140905,
-0.0095498618,
0.0297660921,
0.0040288232,
-0.0142778745,
0.0127173867,
0.0294121318,
-0.042721834,
-0.0690449029,
-0.0629365593,
0.0239735935,
-0.0026717223,
0.0515743531,
-0.0287270658,
-0.0294652879,
-0.0321920365,
0.0389353521,
0.0210443884,
-0.0024288355,
0.0430646501,
0.0115198158,
-0.0106768822,
0.0570086688,
-0.0423212834,
0.0167601556,
0.0121713933,
0.0685700625,
-0.0465417132,
-0.0538136326,
0.0138354879,
0.0450298153,
0.0648598969,
-0.045542717,
-0.0640658885,
-0.0116611673,
0.0228888318,
-0.0301385354,
-0.0146698654,
-0.0135905594,
-0.0078308107,
0.0216684565,
-0.0314605944,
0.0016530839,
0.0423307046,
-0.018742878,
0.0183450393,
-0.0408479571,
0.0177635271,
0.0155627457,
0.0251445752,
-0.0065254834,
0.0355614945,
-0.0056175408,
0.0369360819,
0.0408711433,
0.0314548016,
-0.0779360384,
-0.0124695264,
0.0279724151,
0.0238825865,
0.0083860289,
-0.0246505868,
-0.0077354512,
0.0033113435,
-0.0011845941,
-0.0016066654,
0.0785632059,
-0.0363810398,
0.1136328354,
0.0048760842,
-0.0319949463,
0.007007482,
0.0241533611,
-0.0280281603,
0.0173425786,
0.0231023114,
0.0082658539,
0.0123370467,
0.0207055062,
0.0604228824,
0.0295200087,
0.0562347323,
-0.0040698242,
0.0254227016,
-0.0250056591,
-0.012216487,
0.0412296951,
-0.0439212844,
-0.0003732772,
-0.0180731434,
-0.0195299145,
-0.039572008,
0.0113275861,
-0.0359281935,
-0.0340133347,
-0.0070909262,
-0.0346046351,
0.0400009267,
-0.0078070671,
-0.0037479552,
-0.0409986749,
-0.0088712201,
0.0572408624,
-0.0219447967,
-0.0191441812,
-6.005844553e-33,
-0.0116136335,
0.0017948329,
0.0159967858,
0.0205492601,
-0.0054340851,
0.012384126,
-0.0342287421,
-0.0179042071,
-0.0091548618,
0.0178091805,
-0.0083535779,
-0.048225183,
0.0298898742,
0.0013929728,
-0.0196851641,
-0.0181803722,
0.0183963384,
0.0055718734,
-0.0192617681,
0.0113567524,
0.0465676114,
0.0576129407,
0.1169664487,
-0.0822875351,
0.0621380098,
-0.0161622949,
0.001963909,
0.0044053593,
0.1092010587,
0.0292027351,
-0.0139242262,
0.0393042639,
0.0270738732,
-0.0707433075,
0.0155311981,
0.0117655937,
-0.126435414,
-0.0127241816,
0.0050626826,
0.0291719381,
0.0066367695,
-0.0506764054,
-0.0154396333,
0.0062218327,
0.0267867185,
-0.0161990393,
0.0075063459,
-0.0570512488,
-0.0097278515,
-0.0359039977,
-0.0642382279,
0.025654057,
0.0057363687,
0.0185365211,
0.0696986765,
0.0579423346,
0.0170084015,
0.0502561554,
-0.055579707,
-0.0014828049,
-0.0611383878,
0.0322034098,
0.0554642454,
0.0058127237,
-0.0551023409,
0.0113092838,
-0.0185627583,
-0.0040367604,
0.0244021825,
-0.0010954925,
0.0394071415,
0.0416882969,
0.0206110645,
0.0916020274,
0.0363024771,
-0.0096995616,
-0.0764293969,
0.0437182263,
-0.0240127742,
-0.0270836446,
-0.0098241856,
0.0213606972,
-0.0231846347,
-0.0025349665,
-0.0514454767,
-0.0363461152,
-0.0255665686,
-0.0021530276,
0.0153888799,
0.0258198343,
-0.0467246585,
0.0399596058,
0.0631916896,
-0.0176955983,
-0.0486179329,
-0.0082378639,
0.0019453628,
0.0073755821,
-0.020935379,
0.0406061336,
-0.0607518852,
-0.059262421,
0.0173111074,
-0.0128281759,
0.0508865714,
-0.0132859051,
0.0627015457,
-0.0353579633,
-0.0475469492,
0.0061308392,
-0.0522923134,
0.0127334073,
-0.0153632136,
0.0369509049,
-0.0021402729,
-0.0126343491,
-0.0026160635,
0.0509342775,
0.0494970754,
0.0092049642,
0.0272322353,
-0.0196337644,
0.0068039233,
0.0088438634,
-0.016895121,
0.0060244212,
0.0068290988,
0.042139966,
0.0175525844,
-0.0569864996,
-0.0298830383,
0.0029771794,
2.627e-7,
0.0668726563,
0.0324010998,
-0.0037318685,
0.0129808737,
-0.0143019576,
0.0284388363,
-0.0413702019,
0.0603114851,
-0.0075814486,
-0.0674683303,
-0.0293082371,
0.0175888389,
0.07006374,
0.0628435016,
-0.0800961405,
-0.0500768237,
0.023867568,
0.0012427003,
-0.0396518856,
0.037625894,
0.067712374,
0.0729144812,
-0.0035104188,
0.0000858779,
-0.0014527933,
-0.0091119586,
0.0638685003,
-0.0191802867,
-0.0262679141,
0.0036137747,
0.0089393519,
0.0342387669,
-0.0325302966,
0.0292893276,
-0.041088637,
0.0156896077,
0.0076232976,
0.0524618216,
0.0141238505,
-0.0424587987,
-0.0018497899,
-0.0204161834,
-0.0151291089,
-0.03034552,
0.0638132468,
-0.0450155884,
-0.0063094064,
0.0086511504,
-0.0034416092,
0.0441017039,
-0.0037317716,
-0.0059185969,
-0.0191460606,
0.0375424847,
0.0362752415,
0.0059080571,
-0.0615509115,
-0.0457647145,
-0.0129823871,
-0.0123384213,
-0.0012304098,
-0.0122680133,
0.0171281695,
-0.0176627487,
-0.0330388844,
-0.0717113763,
0.0158909671,
2.392513728e-34,
-0.0394780152,
-0.0311192386,
-0.0110997735,
0.0186893772,
0.0310463328,
-0.0304291602,
-0.0378603712,
0.0184254386,
-0.0116561512,
-0.0160401519,
0.0140248407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05129v1 | Best Practices for Text Annotation with Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T15:43:50 | 2024-02-05T15:43:50 | Petter Törnberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have ushered in a new era of text annotation, as
their ease-of-use, high accuracy, and relatively low costs have meant that
their use has exploded in recent months. However, the rapid growth of the field
has meant that LLM-based annotation has become something of an academic Wild
West: the lack of established practices and standards has led to concerns about
the quality and validity of research. Researchers have warned that the
ostensible simplicity of LLMs can be misleading, as they are prone to bias,
misunderstandings, and unreliable results. Recognizing the transformative
potential of LLMs, this paper proposes a comprehensive set of standards and
best practices for their reliable, reproducible, and ethical use. These
guidelines span critical areas such as model selection, prompt engineering,
structured prompting, prompt stability analysis, rigorous model validation, and
the consideration of ethical and legal implications. The paper emphasizes the
need for a structured, directed, and formalized approach to using LLMs, aiming
to ensure the integrity and robustness of text annotation practices, and
advocates for a nuanced and critical engagement with LLMs in social scientific
research. | [
0.0466620736,
0.0394218527,
-0.0262059886,
0.0141276568,
-0.0161352511,
0.0224264599,
0.0339576639,
-0.0400001295,
0.0439086258,
-0.0717271715,
0.0212869197,
-0.0410359278,
0.0159063265,
-0.0220506843,
0.0163922515,
-0.0181944352,
0.0187209286,
0.0004137269,
0.0240150075,
0.0178780798,
0.0302667301,
0.0403924063,
0.0553559996,
0.0572007373,
-0.0196748544,
0.0045847087,
0.0290615149,
0.0024389685,
-0.0017832227,
-0.0355896987,
-0.022055544,
0.0700505227,
0.001075068,
0.0830552801,
0.000002157,
-0.0634195134,
-0.0107127158,
0.0368568562,
-0.0244371612,
0.0645441487,
0.0354215577,
-0.0002675943,
-0.020110976,
-0.0076818219,
-0.0104206949,
0.0140432501,
0.0682842061,
-0.0111435093,
0.0539255142,
0.0142711308,
0.0023749741,
-0.035318546,
0.0100618815,
-0.0109957932,
-0.0702238828,
0.0142487884,
0.0665357187,
0.0423425138,
0.0176203735,
0.0655204281,
0.0232954919,
0.0666480362,
0.0011532068,
-0.0823939443,
-0.0194712225,
-0.0259861853,
-0.0210225694,
-0.0535153188,
0.015523158,
0.015625339,
0.0828642175,
-0.0040412098,
0.0265574232,
-0.0123664737,
-0.0152099459,
0.03701929,
-0.0454500951,
0.0615385659,
-0.0168084819,
0.0370244645,
0.032431297,
-0.0081244344,
0.0301234182,
0.0261387993,
0.0207591318,
0.0607361086,
-0.0009241299,
-0.0096696783,
0.0042792442,
0.007089742,
-0.0376456715,
-0.0530956462,
0.0046876348,
0.0152378669,
0.018444458,
0.0308706239,
0.0248178449,
-0.0220537949,
0.0675726682,
-0.0864254087,
0.0206768177,
0.0172636304,
-0.0313844085,
0.0330784172,
0.0312788561,
-0.0035800107,
-0.0104795666,
-0.0147566767,
0.0087019932,
0.0299145915,
-0.0036639755,
0.0013422989,
-0.0163613707,
-0.0221303254,
-0.0231231842,
0.0133165251,
-0.0418840945,
0.0234765746,
0.0036101288,
0.0571419261,
-0.0089076217,
-0.059763398,
0.0123337545,
0.0122020794,
0.0064655705,
0.0211659689,
0.0021674333,
0.0372517519,
-0.0345443971,
-0.0435552746,
0.0483088568,
0.0402003638,
-0.0415878855,
-0.017769618,
-0.0282336548,
0.0187548585,
0.0332500152,
0.0297964774,
-0.0430180728,
-0.0453482606,
-0.0520232394,
-0.0318678133,
-0.0175116826,
-0.0734610334,
-0.0139602935,
0.0335660577,
0.0088307066,
-0.0690746531,
0.0247422997,
0.0142110577,
-0.0264405422,
-0.0038090448,
-0.0632167533,
-0.0119453883,
0.0318988524,
0.0192967504,
0.0013952727,
0.0581742637,
0.0628363937,
0.0043759127,
0.0460012481,
-0.0149104958,
-0.0097335996,
0.0661758631,
-0.0291176569,
0.0512555726,
-0.0201563518,
0.0031238343,
0.0205891356,
-0.0022421759,
-0.0017434993,
0.0712897107,
-0.0111856535,
0.0290028807,
0.0630468726,
0.07595478,
-0.0366237164,
0.0221036375,
0.0250699054,
0.025759792,
0.0345325395,
-0.031935893,
-0.0197695065,
-0.0147667825,
-0.0081141982,
-0.020937793,
-0.0128098289,
0.0106968805,
0.0058859433,
-0.0484912284,
-0.0627397522,
-0.00177627,
0.0210915618,
0.0299639311,
0.0251243096,
-0.0358125232,
0.0229247138,
0.0145049598,
0.0274348743,
-0.0332941189,
-0.0015646854,
-0.0104791503,
0.0338930748,
0.0597885288,
0.0040503736,
-0.0144740632,
0.0078087226,
-0.0555837341,
0.0559206828,
0.0776415467,
0.012277009,
-0.0233537909,
-0.0325969718,
-0.0094565907,
-0.0149033535,
0.0103528798,
0.0107333651,
-0.0031159329,
-0.0308589246,
-0.0144371605,
0.0102330092,
-0.0065580178,
-0.103285782,
0.0381148383,
-0.0641132221,
-0.0048466735,
-0.0536159351,
-0.0181518886,
0.002746857,
0.0470478758,
-0.0114372652,
0.0026520602,
-0.0120676495,
0.00777116,
0.0269941594,
0.0200722087,
0.0077664354,
0.0675421953,
0.0391544327,
-0.0102738701,
-0.0057876478,
-0.0189326964,
-0.0041956902,
-0.0061031254,
-0.0220657848,
0.0010692008,
0.0451950096,
-0.0230602734,
0.0004115178,
-0.0817802399,
-0.0150636844,
-0.0507531427,
0.0030203119,
-0.0166550316,
0.0192368943,
0.0183346495,
-0.0440330543,
0.0544335358,
0.0119187944,
-0.0761182234,
0.014609714,
0.0338174403,
0.0236669332,
0.0268434975,
-0.0041232668,
-0.0061567025,
-0.0104464963,
-0.0812428668,
0.000316779,
-0.0232858174,
0.0117990943,
-0.0172321536,
-0.0267514754,
-0.0254746377,
0.0125935879,
0.0023538049,
-0.0380258746,
-0.0151129635,
0.0238231681,
0.0078863166,
-0.0073143966,
-0.0132587356,
-0.0230087526,
0.0049100374,
-0.0087035717,
0.0512794405,
0.0632910728,
-0.0540237948,
-0.062777549,
0.0364700556,
-0.0409058332,
-0.0087690018,
-0.016564399,
0.0140553685,
0.0214193221,
0.0572144315,
0.0027288315,
-0.0201616902,
-0.0237274449,
0.0069045797,
0.0394632407,
0.0074000917,
-0.0351956524,
-0.0474290065,
0.0385695323,
-0.0093807867,
-0.0335311107,
-0.0620874874,
-0.0115147559,
0.0400769971,
-0.0177058727,
-0.0098681943,
-0.0165628754,
-0.0048002913,
-0.0870516673,
-0.0067951581,
-0.0018781365,
-0.0664822757,
-0.0277152136,
0.0491918288,
0.0059185163,
-0.0355325639,
0.0264767408,
-0.0336710885,
0.0239835419,
-0.0330182165,
-0.0111491149,
-0.0325139873,
0.0259301234,
-0.0133066559,
0.0038613025,
0.0021233251,
-0.002179615,
0.016110383,
-0.0137565611,
0.049504526,
-0.0335975997,
0.0598788857,
-0.0308099706,
0.0536814705,
-0.0131026749,
-0.0008839636,
-0.0244396459,
-0.0687074512,
-0.0728088915,
0.0396744572,
0.0336762257,
0.0243511535,
0.0077738315,
0.0364890285,
0.0382836536,
0.0225135088,
0.0154326484,
0.0255294759,
-0.0072838641,
-0.0340904221,
0.0041556424,
-0.0235393327,
0.0434832722,
-0.0248029754,
0.0170204416,
0.0214563403,
-0.0430646576,
0.0019501783,
-0.0086410111,
-0.0323195606,
0.0555351153,
-0.0351920165,
-0.0538395792,
0.0151080154,
0.0369457901,
-0.0735770315,
0.0079686809,
0.1133909374,
0.02243842,
-0.0383129455,
0.0072178207,
-0.0432169102,
-0.001042339,
0.0270554293,
0.0083311405,
-0.1095899716,
0.0351919793,
-0.0016874433,
0.0180774033,
-0.0360115245,
-0.025908038,
-0.0131230811,
-0.0523018353,
0.034514416,
0.0096891262,
-0.0416444615,
0.0414861962,
-0.0365970172,
0.0039220112,
-0.0222460516,
0.032528244,
-0.0051985271,
0.0001965611,
-0.0227966178,
0.0673727393,
-0.0719429553,
-0.0569421686,
-0.0111642191,
-0.0613810644,
0.0781513825,
0.0296721365,
0.0008628774,
-0.0232866071,
-0.0026662908,
0.0520106032,
0.0320645645,
-0.0561419837,
-0.0044332091,
0.0011915687,
-0.0074107135,
-0.0077270991,
-0.0418307111,
-0.00513617,
0.0090828482,
-0.038368687,
0.036476586,
0.0598229989,
-0.0142967291,
0.0262894202,
0.0008502125,
0.0207409784,
0.0115202209,
0.0612068176,
0.0181406904,
-0.0481903367,
0.0061506652,
-0.0637439638,
-0.0061391513,
-0.0043564006,
-0.0434850976,
0.0398371331,
-0.044797089,
-0.0000089716,
-0.0138923042,
-0.0710215494,
0.014503249,
-0.0065230462,
0.078692615,
0.0267814752,
0.0374762341,
-0.0380310267,
0.0264804196,
0.0272870902,
-0.0567097142,
0.0004312092,
-0.006436748,
0.0027971128,
0.0211417489,
-0.0177994054,
0.0090923179,
-0.0082494784,
-0.0492704287,
-0.0457402505,
0.0493354797,
-0.0039123241,
0.0170837734,
0.0075975503,
0.0271394141,
-0.08455991,
0.0016700204,
0.006637081,
0.0165718868,
-0.0039157728,
0.0069678365,
0.0522692576,
-0.0111105591,
0.0033310968,
-0.0258997642,
0.0047568693,
0.010709485,
0.0137170404,
-0.0458602868,
-0.0320491195,
-0.0074063526,
0.0279793292,
-0.0059644701,
-0.0679929182,
-0.0141811054,
-0.0718087852,
-0.0294094272,
-0.0555520058,
-0.0412517004,
-0.0254231095,
0.0286957454,
0.014259696,
-0.0092634708,
-0.0418832414,
0.0253959782,
-0.0464343019,
0.0592683218,
-0.0675158426,
0.0758578628,
-0.0095776534,
0.0212897547,
-0.0136853568,
0.0015311522,
-0.0250985324,
0.0306713972,
-0.0138163902,
0.0481715165,
0.0342710242,
0.0381238237,
0.0085937688,
-0.0262831599,
0.0293213576,
0.0139836408,
-0.000326603,
-0.0405949913,
-0.0237804577,
0.0295429062,
0.0266828965,
-0.0177506916,
0.1050003916,
-0.0324622877,
-0.0077432632,
-0.033983849,
0.0089598252,
0.0106018391,
-0.0794876665,
-0.0021844772,
-0.0190810971,
-0.0609128289,
0.0132059045,
0.0148157934,
0.0100774132,
0.0043019247,
0.0024261686,
-0.0315683745,
-0.0035366572,
-0.0334659927,
0.0217467211,
-0.0084518138,
-0.0463206656,
-0.052630417,
-0.115448378,
-0.0426343307,
0.0039857789,
-0.0152435908,
-0.0492919385,
-0.0203378052,
-0.0219552014,
0.0179579388,
0.017434895,
-0.0048616338,
-0.0592073277,
0.0164475627,
-0.0262221694,
-0.0143207181,
0.0077406708,
-5.954496021e-33,
-0.003004245,
-0.027111439,
0.0459343605,
-0.03601937,
-0.0456341766,
0.0122579057,
-0.0185276959,
-0.0038744973,
-0.0146448594,
0.0144346664,
-0.0138827171,
-0.0261010453,
0.0146620134,
0.0021994058,
0.0554064065,
-0.0169561356,
0.0175979827,
0.0174612924,
-0.022419719,
-0.0172671974,
0.0341020525,
-0.0445123129,
0.0602162145,
-0.0851383135,
0.1241545305,
-0.0123343868,
-0.0366558656,
0.011170839,
0.0195329487,
0.0480625071,
-0.0277424343,
0.0239090882,
0.0113653671,
-0.0404293798,
0.0035092768,
0.0233479869,
-0.002438545,
0.0081600733,
0.0554590262,
0.0303075593,
0.0188267902,
-0.0420402512,
0.0542440265,
-0.0163422842,
-0.0407755673,
0.0406719148,
0.0419428647,
-0.0553680137,
-0.0242572371,
-0.0084343581,
-0.0795317218,
0.0541269779,
-0.0159500316,
0.0445315354,
0.014105048,
0.060201522,
0.0131409224,
0.0336189568,
-0.0544196852,
-0.0082268724,
0.0158540029,
-0.0061195944,
0.0522846058,
0.016646849,
0.0167953521,
0.0663615689,
-0.0190227982,
0.0436759964,
-0.0053791408,
-0.0262149367,
0.0479435064,
-0.0390255786,
0.0349014215,
0.0778862089,
-0.0494252406,
-0.0316665284,
-0.0631973147,
-0.0067919474,
0.0110633736,
-0.0085465396,
0.0301201046,
-0.0225844532,
-0.055738993,
-0.0722804219,
-0.0709875599,
-0.0329891481,
0.0114040971,
-0.0012821431,
0.005289847,
-0.0396778919,
-0.0331057496,
0.0572658293,
0.0418033302,
-0.0364165083,
-0.0495824665,
-0.0014755906,
-0.0092893327,
0.0192797389,
-0.0089294724,
0.0508690886,
-0.0644567981,
-0.0045038518,
-0.0045407359,
-0.0064423899,
0.0203044415,
0.0124968803,
0.0422700495,
0.0009540216,
-0.0427840874,
-0.0038909365,
-0.0021822532,
0.0056858389,
0.0114054205,
-0.0270237997,
0.0458662845,
0.0128009329,
0.0299003124,
0.0252490826,
0.0773776174,
0.0037673994,
0.0311298408,
-0.0105160829,
-0.0142646972,
-0.0314015783,
-0.0177070741,
0.0286227614,
0.0398875475,
0.0743269324,
0.0165026765,
-0.0362349302,
0.0107492758,
-0.0048838682,
2.753e-7,
0.0916155875,
0.0676771626,
-0.0055879601,
-0.0397470184,
-0.0042688232,
-0.0034757596,
0.0067799324,
0.0021482143,
0.0104194926,
-0.0279962998,
0.0052658864,
-0.0165888537,
0.0540858507,
0.0451707467,
-0.0749756396,
-0.0471960753,
-0.0702387914,
0.0163777284,
-0.0721800327,
0.0180698801,
-0.0191711858,
0.0388755649,
0.0103604235,
0.0130136171,
-0.0560696833,
-0.0371571928,
0.045421537,
-0.0607624464,
-0.0249874815,
0.0515089557,
0.0535473377,
0.0201034918,
0.0378385074,
-0.0102313692,
0.0099693164,
0.0194128752,
0.0306503903,
0.0666494146,
0.023357939,
0.0340780616,
-0.0137493378,
-0.0459379479,
0.0318876691,
-0.0710536242,
0.0535801947,
0.0089346552,
-0.0371905863,
-0.0666567162,
-0.0302004851,
-0.0361206867,
0.0496382266,
-0.0154651199,
-0.0074815559,
0.0394196026,
0.0003487917,
-0.0090536717,
-0.0015217764,
-0.0061437469,
-0.0437737741,
-0.0042913025,
-0.02096924,
-0.0729412958,
0.0074427417,
0.0140497182,
-0.0270604268,
-0.053782396,
0.0665075183,
2.551300286e-34,
0.0296931714,
-0.0591311678,
0.0185763836,
0.0419961885,
0.0146634607,
0.0544116013,
0.0026760458,
0.0165319405,
-0.0025353758,
-0.0277685225,
-0.0011492453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03099v1 | Intent-based Prompt Calibration: Enhancing prompt optimization with synthetic boundary cases | 2024-02-05T15:28:43 | 2024-02-05T15:28:43 | Elad Levi, Eli Brosh, Matan Friedmann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Prompt engineering is a challenging and important task due to the high
sensitivity of Large Language Models (LLMs) to the given prompt and the
inherent ambiguity of a textual task instruction. Automatic prompt engineering
is essential to achieve optimized performance from LLMs. Recent studies have
demonstrated the capabilities of LLMs to automatically conduct prompt
engineering by employing a meta-prompt that incorporates the outcomes of the
last trials and proposes an improved prompt. However, this requires a
high-quality benchmark to compare different prompts, which is difficult and
expensive to acquire in many real-world use cases. In this work, we introduce a
new method for automatic prompt engineering, using a calibration process that
iteratively refines the prompt to the user intent. During the optimization
process, the system jointly generates synthetic data of boundary use cases and
optimizes the prompt according to the generated dataset. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method with respect to strong proprietary models on
real-world tasks such as moderation and generation. Our method outperforms
state-of-the-art methods with a limited number of annotated samples.
Furthermore, we validate the advantages of each one of the system's key
components. Our system is built in a modular way, facilitating easy adaptation
to other tasks. The code is available
$\href{https://github.com/Eladlev/AutoPrompt}{here}$. | [
0.0606880151,
-0.0075707119,
-0.0347329825,
0.0127663082,
-0.0330666155,
-0.0274213981,
0.0325263739,
-0.0324232057,
0.0179895088,
-0.0406753011,
-0.0133836269,
-0.0371529385,
-0.0141558116,
0.0550986305,
-0.0122900102,
-0.0425524972,
0.0501008742,
-0.0251502525,
0.0187939126,
0.0245801229,
0.0056895674,
0.0088518318,
-0.0108540058,
0.067326352,
-0.0252253395,
-0.0331847891,
-0.0220381711,
0.0396019034,
0.0080686724,
-0.0329134613,
0.0342471749,
0.0709865466,
-0.0209028274,
0.0242135674,
0.0000022555,
-0.0870755389,
-0.0138017572,
-0.033544343,
-0.0606911443,
-0.0079532508,
0.0581002384,
0.0462995395,
-0.0268843509,
0.0410471596,
-0.0281830151,
0.0437749103,
0.0252667591,
-0.0167926475,
0.0613884069,
0.0453379899,
-0.0058098044,
0.0288646258,
-0.0266579185,
-0.0091528073,
0.0267253723,
-0.0237567108,
-0.0096436432,
-0.0474968962,
0.022710586,
0.0193090755,
0.022127036,
0.0155904368,
0.0118202204,
-0.0417934023,
-0.0104417661,
0.0037608785,
0.0055512837,
-0.0344650298,
-0.0615810081,
0.0731585696,
0.0099472217,
-0.0126407351,
-0.0026237036,
-0.0546293259,
0.0554639511,
0.002430862,
-0.001378188,
0.0121262334,
-0.0276376028,
-0.0301943589,
-0.0046577826,
0.0395711027,
-0.0136928111,
0.0085116802,
0.0164111536,
0.0726960227,
0.0213128198,
-0.0193000734,
0.0015481719,
-0.0213939752,
0.0076841363,
-0.0692389011,
0.0444422737,
0.0306720734,
-0.0904523805,
0.0227458179,
-0.0448799841,
-0.0386771187,
0.0391977876,
0.0160410088,
0.0428535938,
0.0675339773,
-0.0276576579,
0.02135689,
-0.0008389709,
0.0512929298,
0.027785344,
-0.0177155212,
-0.0473735742,
0.0352607779,
-0.0274673142,
0.0064811287,
-0.0661556423,
-0.0145410467,
-0.0487579964,
0.0034872182,
-0.0359193757,
0.0557082556,
-0.0118381139,
0.0191641413,
0.0320453495,
0.0019401729,
-0.0542579256,
-0.0157673955,
-0.0249143895,
-0.0065262066,
-0.0540049523,
0.0259796549,
0.0367924422,
-0.0451665595,
0.0162154771,
0.0135355182,
-0.0063773845,
-0.0093575064,
-0.0088519286,
0.0249192938,
-0.0130661791,
-0.0184539147,
-0.0353241749,
-0.0758541226,
-0.0325302109,
-0.021734383,
-0.053349264,
-0.0604024902,
0.0236916728,
0.008055849,
-0.0209379327,
-0.0231828224,
-0.0046526515,
0.0316066742,
0.0245993715,
0.0754147321,
-0.0333426893,
0.0188445933,
0.0313437842,
0.0110948058,
-0.0278914981,
0.0555977747,
0.0008651103,
0.0740512386,
0.0376050174,
-0.0069452939,
0.0205737464,
0.0569165684,
-0.012177363,
-0.0021237882,
0.0244235583,
-0.0003845942,
0.0116402395,
0.0285524987,
0.0191795211,
0.0371834897,
0.0044378666,
0.0346713848,
0.0425444916,
0.0280968584,
-0.0249413308,
-0.0407767817,
0.0595863089,
0.0272308681,
-0.0200033132,
-0.0102155767,
-0.0411078185,
-0.0119255818,
-0.0470566154,
0.0189508256,
-0.0007907557,
0.0220868289,
-0.0217594523,
-0.0472142845,
0.0268119816,
0.0025961821,
-0.013478253,
0.0199389532,
0.0026930543,
0.0205610972,
-0.0642745718,
0.0375878699,
-0.0000033264,
-0.0382730328,
0.0014802088,
-0.0503017344,
0.0529726036,
0.0726334974,
0.0388328172,
-0.0475221276,
-0.0275706835,
-0.0245704371,
0.0351242386,
0.0337042697,
0.0564649887,
-0.0297235698,
-0.0231073163,
-0.0492106192,
-0.039420113,
-0.0032435975,
-0.006804721,
0.0403721444,
-0.0057999962,
-0.0271742567,
0.034120962,
0.0016371991,
-0.0013443163,
0.0350081846,
0.0011455381,
-0.0435264818,
0.0184293892,
0.0248663537,
0.0235873796,
0.0382190123,
0.0228834897,
0.0107724993,
0.0269019511,
-0.0013223338,
0.0276939683,
-0.0067102271,
-0.0595520996,
-0.0154838627,
0.0308247562,
-0.0145678986,
-0.042852588,
-0.0061095017,
-0.0254786462,
-0.0514782779,
-0.0520723574,
-0.0109092183,
-0.0016407031,
-0.0452914871,
0.0451690555,
-0.0186707377,
-0.0165105518,
-0.0553536527,
0.0300774071,
0.0205522627,
0.0082802307,
0.0773026571,
0.0052807336,
0.0188452061,
-0.0382799469,
-0.0353756137,
-0.0296204668,
-0.0495751426,
0.0011622377,
0.0447430573,
0.0323249772,
-0.044815708,
-0.0264615975,
-0.0982506871,
0.0085283881,
-0.0343851745,
-0.0142245097,
0.0277165473,
0.0357687175,
-0.0415158607,
-0.0058611785,
-0.0227148216,
-0.0207109526,
0.0153314872,
0.0212506186,
0.0260173455,
0.002350467,
-0.0300779585,
-0.0251742844,
0.0147583634,
-0.0390150249,
-0.0002059722,
0.0139284246,
-0.0125209186,
-0.084558025,
0.0563913025,
0.0364914499,
-0.0026220968,
-0.0014378864,
-0.0089147519,
0.0235417951,
0.0077375052,
0.0805602223,
0.0510718152,
0.0196407586,
-0.0010085253,
0.0558105633,
0.0031804298,
-0.0807425082,
0.020621812,
-0.0065859687,
-0.0297904927,
-0.0015557992,
-0.0610621497,
0.0617318004,
0.0383282229,
0.0269195307,
0.0088565107,
-0.0528076291,
0.0100184549,
-0.0132657066,
-0.0208568778,
-0.0546664596,
-0.037067648,
-0.0596015304,
0.0638481304,
-0.0045973104,
-0.0666969344,
0.0737199038,
-0.0372351445,
0.007340658,
-0.0348318182,
0.021489393,
-0.0035860895,
0.0510049611,
-0.0311082229,
0.0080633732,
0.0543721057,
-0.0386246294,
-0.0183693692,
0.0079322886,
0.0241823886,
-0.0241949856,
0.0304503739,
-0.0494130887,
-0.0093691051,
-0.016842626,
-0.0346335582,
-0.0657111183,
-0.0724462867,
-0.0063897329,
-0.0222533047,
0.0288607776,
0.0207145456,
0.0157526433,
-0.0000637719,
-0.0023281546,
0.0629588142,
-0.0165729616,
-0.0130125033,
-0.0291474834,
-0.0078398241,
0.0596746542,
0.0112171136,
-0.0172833484,
-0.005715406,
0.0426619612,
0.0063357526,
0.0235659834,
0.0053973286,
-0.0084248595,
-0.005196936,
0.0524782278,
-0.0430158302,
-0.0080147963,
0.1036624089,
0.092495881,
-0.037952181,
-0.0111679323,
0.1284051687,
0.059343446,
-0.0543253273,
-0.0080820732,
-0.0316161998,
0.0157834981,
0.0422255546,
0.0230154824,
-0.0625893101,
-0.0425549969,
0.026954798,
0.0369318686,
-0.0378833115,
-0.0079832384,
-0.0203302484,
-0.1229248121,
0.0379062109,
-0.0214830376,
-0.0017601745,
-0.0029251347,
-0.0113397716,
0.0041130283,
0.0224854723,
0.0293415617,
0.0136805866,
0.0001586184,
-0.0131665459,
0.0307682585,
-0.0168900583,
-0.0362685099,
0.0168469325,
-0.0239354558,
0.0614187382,
0.0568639785,
0.0088041797,
0.0281838533,
-0.0306163225,
0.0519822426,
0.0065917745,
0.011817324,
0.0053251446,
-0.0014845873,
0.0166873224,
0.0213058852,
-0.0204562154,
0.047534015,
-0.034379214,
-0.0468500257,
0.0552068241,
0.0599823482,
-0.0274968334,
0.0335867368,
-0.0342198648,
0.0032715641,
0.0708042383,
0.0751307979,
0.0382461697,
-0.0716817826,
-0.0072023897,
-0.0444474444,
0.0000235307,
-0.0386058874,
0.0020134493,
0.004274643,
-0.0122438176,
-0.0007822808,
-0.0392769575,
-0.031878531,
0.0362763591,
0.0572781786,
0.0449563004,
-0.0111719817,
-0.0151355136,
-0.0054449169,
-0.0034305803,
0.0480638817,
-0.0433309823,
0.0610769093,
-0.0873191431,
0.0174639523,
-0.0007384007,
-0.0478605069,
-0.003263568,
0.0416588522,
-0.0182018559,
-0.0726560205,
-0.0021590916,
0.0635594577,
0.0260126907,
0.0211129896,
-0.0360249393,
-0.0455540568,
-0.0024910534,
0.0449078195,
-0.0183552653,
-0.0411150455,
0.0152752474,
0.0481892303,
-0.042604737,
-0.0019082283,
-0.0313003026,
0.0047063194,
0.0174579043,
0.0305856429,
-0.0113850301,
-0.0785092935,
0.0467966236,
0.0599230938,
0.0421586633,
-0.0490462035,
-0.0312217902,
-0.045365192,
0.0075772349,
-0.0070170225,
-0.0459773876,
-0.0062948219,
0.0206251536,
0.0079585891,
-0.0628537685,
0.026123073,
-0.0255954321,
-0.0758179054,
0.029464718,
-0.044303041,
0.0116752693,
-0.0152009968,
0.0803724527,
0.0483958833,
-0.0315186419,
-0.0189223271,
0.0440710448,
0.0161195695,
0.0346601419,
0.0021672922,
0.090360336,
0.0121457381,
-0.0026329679,
-0.0204649176,
0.0572935045,
-0.0310698841,
-0.0102389138,
-0.0230559148,
0.0404934771,
0.0353270955,
-0.0155459587,
-0.0109525565,
-0.014905666,
0.0007855666,
-0.0270018578,
0.032555107,
0.0464680605,
-0.0532556809,
0.0208740793,
0.0115890158,
-0.0154410983,
-0.0230471417,
0.0292329378,
-0.069837898,
0.0189110637,
-0.0012480837,
-0.0147015406,
-0.0611673556,
0.0020815548,
0.0113386093,
0.0211826079,
-0.0573822856,
-0.0371827595,
-0.0795543939,
-0.0199532211,
0.0059934584,
0.0316935629,
0.018336108,
0.0133384112,
0.0537230633,
0.0508078896,
-0.0273892414,
-0.0155228693,
-0.0300764516,
0.0109479669,
-0.017941257,
-0.0259525757,
-0.0792401731,
-5.689064254e-33,
-0.0317090601,
-0.0270119105,
0.0143042225,
-0.0028788266,
0.0135499574,
-0.0092338081,
-0.0379510634,
0.0218941178,
0.0241263434,
-0.0127586676,
-0.0475255027,
-0.0326798148,
0.0331567936,
0.0003803375,
-0.0059569851,
0.0002904278,
0.0531135239,
0.006296658,
-0.0842344239,
0.0179815926,
0.0138184382,
-0.0014901507,
-0.022667177,
-0.0412879959,
0.0375525877,
0.0018317718,
-0.032688424,
0.0239176676,
-0.0101808328,
0.0545505881,
0.0026532011,
0.0575628467,
0.0129293827,
-0.0545651391,
-0.0172538571,
0.0917424783,
-0.0205213092,
-0.0391533673,
0.0308325104,
-0.0120676411,
-0.0219211299,
-0.0642171875,
-0.0163053405,
-0.0256530568,
-0.0570158735,
0.0540199503,
0.023140518,
-0.0070587983,
-0.0050673801,
-0.0552021861,
-0.0721675903,
-0.0131798303,
-0.0196646377,
-0.0629905686,
-0.0072914795,
0.080427587,
0.0116172954,
-0.0055242898,
-0.0240473226,
0.0411767177,
0.0051133111,
0.0216798224,
0.0750699714,
0.0252702329,
-0.027908694,
0.0282403473,
-0.0008048422,
0.03576364,
0.0104263425,
-0.0023893667,
0.010591465,
0.012532237,
0.022294702,
0.0454049222,
0.0002569169,
-0.0647637993,
-0.0026638608,
0.0736916885,
0.052141156,
-0.0219907351,
0.0290701929,
-0.0181097444,
-0.0234680492,
-0.0093998732,
-0.0594556443,
-0.0014739388,
-0.0260857716,
0.006188082,
0.0575389713,
0.0021793593,
-0.0290674362,
-0.0525382757,
0.0322163738,
0.0044259643,
0.0282748975,
-0.0228414815,
-0.0012300466,
0.0249404926,
-0.0029439603,
0.0321025774,
-0.0030824293,
-0.0363439731,
0.0348143466,
-0.014778534,
0.031328924,
0.0165265184,
-0.011270009,
0.0128236907,
-0.0460771695,
0.0294116866,
-0.0288419034,
0.0527926944,
-0.015913805,
-0.0101670381,
0.0300804172,
-0.0038753597,
-0.0266972501,
0.0273527801,
0.0024256911,
-0.0541652814,
-0.0493535772,
-0.0310122762,
-0.0027201977,
0.0155192669,
-0.0272066202,
0.0040241033,
0.001561307,
0.0160976425,
0.0240584482,
-0.0093872678,
-0.0210298412,
0.0062689791,
2.783e-7,
0.0325833596,
0.0208198894,
0.0085725831,
0.0477131158,
-0.0129526863,
0.03604443,
0.0025997465,
0.0297575016,
0.0380584933,
-0.0354718193,
0.0179044697,
-0.0301638097,
0.0371606573,
-0.0068677026,
-0.1033888906,
-0.0058319741,
-0.0146069434,
0.0315173455,
-0.0800985843,
0.0484142601,
0.0800622702,
0.0540997908,
-0.0191611443,
-0.0090099704,
0.0124458829,
0.0025684922,
-0.0034842293,
-0.040766973,
0.0049750139,
0.0572633669,
0.063659355,
-0.0640003011,
-0.0024371331,
0.0324350931,
-0.0045562843,
0.0036438787,
-0.0167693235,
0.0611752681,
0.0320580341,
-0.0110382568,
-0.0074877469,
-0.0223634988,
0.0254581496,
-0.0445745699,
0.0490353256,
-0.0108131804,
0.0213825889,
-0.0512109473,
-0.011051639,
-0.0212464463,
0.0144396126,
-0.0262344126,
0.0009373935,
0.0105315913,
0.0010910594,
0.006098853,
-0.0144534167,
-0.0455225222,
-0.0203040168,
-0.0017989838,
-0.0339124054,
-0.0400266871,
-0.0391346775,
0.0117935119,
0.0257055685,
-0.1029645056,
0.0241671093,
2.767908768e-34,
0.0237090588,
-0.025123287,
0.0480522737,
-0.0020700099,
0.0362107083,
0.0221337117,
-0.0000796097,
0.0313806422,
0.0462502912,
-0.0599488057,
-0.0455650724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03407v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03407v1 | Enhancing the Stability of LLM-based Speech Generation Systems through Self-Supervised Representations | 2024-02-05T15:08:19 | 2024-02-05T15:08:19 | Álvaro Martín-Cortinas, Daniel Sáez-Trigueros, Iván Vallés-Pérez, Biel Tura-Vecino, Piotr Biliński, Mateusz Lajszczak, Grzegorz Beringer, Roberto Barra-Chicote, Jaime Lorenzo-Trueba | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are one of the most promising technologies for
the next era of speech generation systems, due to their scalability and
in-context learning capabilities. Nevertheless, they suffer from multiple
stability issues at inference time, such as hallucinations, content skipping or
speech repetitions. In this work, we introduce a new self-supervised Voice
Conversion (VC) architecture which can be used to learn to encode transitory
features, such as content, separately from stationary ones, such as speaker ID
or recording conditions, creating speaker-disentangled representations. Using
speaker-disentangled codes to train LLMs for text-to-speech (TTS) allows the
LLM to generate the content and the style of the speech only from the text,
similarly to humans, while the speaker identity is provided by the decoder of
the VC model. Results show that LLMs trained over speaker-disentangled
self-supervised representations provide an improvement of 4.7pp in speaker
similarity over SOTA entangled representations, and a word error rate (WER)
5.4pp lower. Furthermore, they achieve higher naturalness than human recordings
of the LibriTTS test-other dataset. Finally, we show that using explicit
reference embedding negatively impacts intelligibility (stability), with WER
increasing by 14pp compared to the model that only uses text to infer the
style. | [
-0.0494922847,
0.0570771582,
0.0095243817,
0.0106844967,
-0.0092043867,
-0.0120290732,
0.0211398993,
-0.0024788226,
0.0083333915,
-0.0153938131,
-0.0905436426,
-0.0323696136,
-0.0088690277,
0.022389384,
0.0394998267,
-0.0325155668,
0.0352610685,
-0.0344517007,
-0.025139546,
-0.0362670086,
-0.0086298445,
-0.0068939063,
-0.0316630453,
0.0117113963,
-0.0068403259,
-0.0090904702,
-0.0098860608,
0.0098409951,
-0.0037331383,
-0.0158033501,
-0.0106999204,
0.0348813944,
0.0832096189,
0.0027905973,
0.0000021906,
-0.0197798517,
-0.0045827217,
-0.0261433814,
-0.033579208,
0.0190471001,
0.0009579129,
0.0069332966,
-0.0296676196,
0.0416365862,
-0.0087879151,
-0.0226083156,
0.009619086,
0.030493807,
0.0754162967,
0.0687260479,
0.0000288227,
-0.0668849275,
0.0373979621,
-0.0395857506,
0.0060056848,
0.0156792682,
-0.0320343971,
0.0022910028,
-0.0613334924,
0.0032874665,
-0.0331463367,
0.0308984816,
0.0152355889,
-0.0035485569,
0.0109444084,
0.0176152848,
-0.0091303438,
-0.0425040722,
0.0121997539,
0.0581612214,
0.0099421022,
-0.0309784096,
0.0301918797,
0.0375658609,
-0.0262661893,
-0.01518883,
0.0322597027,
0.0282338969,
0.0321054645,
0.0675310269,
0.0187587738,
0.0589217693,
0.0137178637,
-0.0175378267,
-0.0099960398,
-0.0321431831,
0.0184332449,
-0.0327606536,
-0.0003173061,
-0.0068367547,
0.013102876,
0.0048032547,
0.0438672528,
0.0063396152,
0.0005728282,
-0.0114758676,
-0.0664196983,
-0.0188970007,
-0.0428395271,
-0.0385094732,
0.003439771,
0.0427110642,
-0.0248496737,
-0.0289928969,
-0.0604220554,
0.0311021246,
-0.0016643159,
0.0358635299,
-0.0036930025,
0.0071897502,
-0.0219164062,
0.0076856222,
-0.0614397712,
0.0594855063,
-0.0369066186,
-0.0358055457,
-0.025915131,
0.0150487572,
-0.0396848656,
0.0225180238,
-0.0351724736,
0.0174425989,
-0.0210188236,
-0.0254676305,
0.004571117,
0.0372300334,
0.0425388888,
-0.0036749349,
0.011991716,
-0.0167809594,
-0.0030751198,
0.0441932492,
0.0119006997,
0.0038399836,
0.0250185151,
0.0454890393,
-0.0090055401,
-0.0414236709,
-0.0541491136,
-0.0055350587,
-0.0129687721,
-0.0310369078,
0.0293449927,
-0.0554753318,
-0.0023562687,
-0.0060054716,
-0.0133402813,
-0.0794167891,
0.0292999428,
-0.0148867751,
0.0224255845,
0.0435261875,
-0.0485173948,
0.0215060413,
0.073290512,
0.0218853559,
0.0471397378,
0.032937713,
0.0513325073,
0.0103681106,
-0.0148297371,
-0.0587397702,
0.0354759917,
0.0322807431,
0.0480681174,
0.0304139834,
-0.0613194518,
-0.034810476,
0.0002845306,
0.0225180946,
0.0774762332,
0.0764688402,
-0.037934646,
-0.0332964025,
0.0911956728,
0.033670757,
0.0485517792,
0.0332175195,
-0.0018631549,
0.0351438299,
-0.0141995642,
0.0180613305,
-0.0067009404,
0.0513850711,
0.0078915935,
0.0020328052,
0.0990251973,
0.0034783054,
-0.0661718547,
-0.0064676767,
0.0302350298,
-0.0317860804,
-0.0123304687,
-0.0074117822,
-0.0043428694,
0.0424150638,
-0.0338552706,
0.0788261294,
-0.0121657755,
-0.0881844461,
0.0590520613,
-0.0492133759,
0.0118986936,
0.0574765764,
0.009501758,
0.0460606664,
0.0288932752,
-0.0537903793,
-0.0206914395,
0.0852121934,
-0.0113328844,
0.0233765505,
0.0520056523,
-0.0585224554,
0.0064018136,
0.0008361163,
-0.0185429212,
0.0111397468,
-0.038173873,
0.0360119157,
0.0337366685,
0.0124688838,
0.0647204965,
-0.0065195542,
-0.0607088953,
-0.0381080806,
0.0412190408,
-0.0117578348,
0.0351109542,
0.0055147246,
-0.0493957587,
0.0210649967,
0.0042537907,
-0.0725764036,
-0.0393166989,
0.0159300175,
-0.0759532824,
-0.0478296392,
0.005527881,
-0.0430655032,
0.0617371313,
0.017129913,
0.0369666144,
-0.086884968,
0.072671786,
-0.0559015833,
0.030036822,
-0.0222801846,
-0.007150243,
0.046255812,
0.0455200039,
0.0040264009,
-0.0042903549,
0.0061377413,
-0.0251974519,
0.0046462617,
0.0968275145,
0.004796539,
-0.0436274968,
-0.0160190389,
0.0171507746,
-0.0071637882,
0.0296351369,
-0.0088581517,
-0.0024709883,
-0.0088040773,
-0.040428523,
-0.055822432,
-0.0127630737,
-0.0144160148,
0.0101074213,
0.0152966417,
-0.01028575,
-0.0052558989,
-0.0262972079,
-0.06995897,
-0.0343995094,
0.0283135138,
-0.0200796314,
-0.0024431734,
-0.0339536481,
-0.0362519138,
-0.0307304524,
0.0066447118,
0.0477492623,
0.0002522399,
-0.062389072,
-0.0068520582,
-0.0694592595,
0.0377918184,
-0.0015736036,
0.0283243842,
0.0325871296,
-0.0374405757,
0.0229586363,
0.0020946267,
0.0776858553,
0.0221333932,
0.0339515768,
-0.0155826956,
0.0633420497,
-0.0121812988,
-0.0446916707,
0.0040987488,
-0.0023722327,
0.044866804,
-0.0053288387,
0.0153610837,
0.0120858094,
0.0008067935,
0.0642985553,
0.0037105386,
-0.0433972813,
-0.011049442,
0.0305974558,
-0.041110076,
0.0160617847,
0.0096383374,
-0.0085025011,
0.021352835,
0.0090505164,
-0.046567712,
0.0160611738,
-0.055742085,
-0.0161807686,
0.0031130207,
-0.0578569509,
-0.0276205689,
0.0433927588,
0.0038877898,
0.0185625236,
-0.0530171916,
0.0102040647,
-0.022683071,
0.0353976898,
-0.000818065,
-0.0460941233,
0.0177551936,
-0.0015475322,
0.0028652307,
-0.0001087664,
-0.0264962222,
-0.0559594519,
-0.0206449814,
0.0062977956,
-0.002275022,
0.0326760039,
-0.0130846202,
0.0349874981,
0.0319158249,
0.0042275079,
0.0303476136,
-0.0023204903,
-0.0047637168,
-0.034992341,
0.059807431,
0.0468134657,
0.0168063976,
-0.0032184811,
-0.0173326787,
0.056377098,
0.026220968,
-0.0027775739,
0.043787688,
-0.0577834994,
0.025081709,
0.022492161,
0.023996016,
-0.0187365022,
0.0173627306,
0.056711819,
-0.0273584072,
-0.0322449356,
0.1153496876,
-0.0286435112,
-0.0398087129,
-0.0106320735,
-0.0047957874,
0.0347306579,
-0.007799631,
0.0056263157,
-0.0512833409,
-0.0322503224,
0.0228504278,
0.0277157631,
0.0268992297,
0.0241769105,
-0.0206170436,
-0.0739235282,
0.0228452366,
0.066170752,
-0.0146331368,
-0.0790752098,
-0.0328351483,
-0.0362017043,
-0.009406724,
0.0576498583,
0.0260586981,
-0.0028475153,
-0.0059128823,
0.0118830269,
-0.0568652414,
-0.0140512893,
-0.0345104858,
-0.0173429772,
0.1237515658,
0.0629737601,
0.0101451743,
0.0092425458,
-0.0540072918,
-0.0345525406,
-0.0484917909,
-0.0283091441,
0.003216834,
0.0567891076,
0.0189360417,
-0.0179664996,
-0.008058371,
0.0750826746,
-0.0246800315,
-0.0055252244,
-0.0160482023,
0.0052513089,
-0.0444400869,
-0.0450406559,
-0.021224048,
0.0448556431,
-0.0022072641,
0.0586262979,
0.0250354894,
-0.049658224,
-0.0332217813,
0.0104950573,
0.0940499306,
-0.0408464596,
-0.0374722965,
0.0069750077,
0.0111399191,
-0.0089580482,
-0.0631844774,
0.0226023514,
-0.0547706373,
0.0336391591,
-0.0084273256,
-0.0013784806,
0.0154640628,
-0.0123068094,
-0.0063552591,
-0.0322869234,
-0.0200019889,
-0.0120834429,
-0.0330731198,
-0.0187708978,
0.0573576912,
-0.0409299061,
0.0189623795,
0.0075293141,
-0.0626136512,
-0.0577791445,
-0.0105256001,
0.0036820984,
0.0094229802,
0.0442810729,
0.0134737734,
0.001493854,
0.0803889185,
0.0333143808,
-0.0672695115,
0.0281746015,
0.0358032137,
0.0589903258,
0.0005331901,
0.0183722954,
-0.0024627419,
0.032642968,
-0.0356429182,
-0.0015932742,
-0.014679959,
-0.078666456,
0.0063961167,
0.0016500308,
0.0033230227,
-0.0149157206,
0.1006340384,
0.0009764055,
-0.0042833644,
-0.0347427353,
0.0621814542,
-0.0533375405,
0.0001298281,
0.0390641466,
0.0170648191,
0.0249318015,
-0.0181424301,
0.0074368278,
0.0326976553,
0.0111310044,
-0.0260446128,
-0.0625217408,
0.0165314917,
-0.0419105366,
0.0022552274,
-0.0087863365,
0.0446368977,
0.0151680382,
-0.0072404165,
-0.0172431394,
0.0254930835,
-0.0014679633,
-0.0012196741,
0.0199530888,
0.0189696681,
-0.0431947671,
-0.0187797751,
-0.0393310897,
0.0079278257,
0.0409793966,
0.053413149,
0.0945238322,
-0.0190225691,
0.0344923958,
-0.005297265,
0.0510263555,
-0.0509953201,
0.0340870358,
-0.0199831016,
-0.0105397077,
-0.0279884338,
-0.0116318148,
0.0388660878,
0.0444266126,
0.0007678481,
-0.0114437165,
0.0471978672,
-0.0278559867,
-0.0493104942,
-0.0419946425,
0.0129642868,
0.0196455754,
0.0026028105,
0.0086682457,
-0.0524362959,
-0.0074575655,
-0.007254723,
0.013126893,
-0.0289693866,
0.0431850515,
-0.0335526466,
-0.0163615346,
-0.0048597078,
0.003408622,
-0.0096622696,
0.0312993005,
-0.0215391554,
0.0049072034,
-6.484377283e-33,
-0.0472042821,
0.0090861926,
0.0297469851,
0.0142379533,
-0.0461657159,
-0.051816415,
-0.0389293469,
0.0141841909,
0.0292412955,
-0.0270817876,
-0.0046527162,
0.0016507467,
-0.0026409463,
0.0685642138,
-0.0306688715,
0.0085459314,
0.104630284,
-0.0282906517,
0.0064987247,
0.048587244,
0.0570931509,
0.0234910548,
0.0120266387,
-0.0830637887,
-0.0639410764,
-0.0232421439,
-0.016473718,
-0.0329545811,
0.0031966937,
-0.0229678284,
-0.020094689,
0.0182140116,
-0.033796344,
-0.0220432561,
-0.0444440693,
-0.0157492869,
-0.0633274764,
-0.0279977024,
-0.0524472073,
-0.0048355367,
-0.0235149283,
-0.0154851498,
0.0701478347,
0.0115942629,
-0.043759197,
-0.024071686,
-0.0128350835,
-0.0110090114,
-0.0313987695,
-0.0470448174,
-0.0142192058,
0.0152547862,
-0.0064563979,
-0.0367811695,
0.0546608232,
0.0491640233,
-0.0500751957,
-0.0617194399,
-0.0867048278,
0.0393340662,
-0.0186697561,
0.0404279269,
0.0411549173,
-0.0025146587,
0.0083027594,
0.0365473591,
0.0735001639,
-0.0518145859,
-0.0362742208,
-0.0258835889,
0.0303934645,
0.0631950796,
0.0311480444,
0.0221818052,
0.0338878892,
-0.0385484323,
-0.0361043774,
0.0039987904,
-0.0014763839,
-0.0105004897,
0.0472889058,
0.0390064158,
-0.0059995214,
-0.0362025723,
-0.0541155934,
-0.0302750077,
-0.0005555855,
-0.0534509234,
0.0415342003,
0.0239844956,
0.0147449374,
-0.0398395769,
0.0380221196,
-0.0236906093,
-0.0010240846,
0.0304322746,
-0.0786386207,
0.004727344,
0.0015049179,
-0.007415269,
-0.0276635848,
-0.0609253831,
0.0680222884,
0.0177373756,
-0.0032922407,
-0.0087139411,
-0.0359642655,
0.0394975618,
-0.0610759258,
-0.0243724845,
-0.0221281648,
0.0376875326,
0.0257776752,
-0.0270333756,
0.0117464568,
-0.0244168136,
-0.0123992227,
0.0511866324,
-0.0541674979,
0.0337148383,
-0.0085567776,
-0.0265424363,
0.018215321,
0.0516905785,
-0.0111983307,
0.0305436198,
-0.0121523095,
-0.0164853316,
0.0481075309,
-0.0616282597,
-0.0071030748,
-0.0364415534,
2.97e-7,
-0.0517273284,
0.0251031984,
0.018434912,
-0.0287858546,
0.0555478074,
0.0491270497,
0.0057778396,
0.0431849323,
-0.0138911353,
-0.0186874885,
-0.0172416624,
0.0220715068,
0.089837566,
0.0373052321,
-0.0255929828,
-0.0097735142,
-0.0891707018,
0.0301331785,
-0.0196964946,
-0.0261225775,
0.0408778042,
0.0364487432,
0.017530553,
-0.0502362102,
0.060529802,
0.0035345424,
0.0638193637,
-0.0135588422,
-0.0108779864,
-0.0378006808,
0.0029019569,
0.0087478338,
-0.0058740042,
-0.0017862666,
-0.008379967,
0.0321528316,
-0.0104335509,
0.0519879609,
0.0428793058,
-0.0703287497,
0.0031430328,
0.0735438839,
-0.025304582,
0.0294031892,
0.0663638115,
-0.0466807894,
-0.0170952212,
0.000462163,
-0.016962707,
0.0263908599,
0.0115695028,
-0.0248524994,
-0.0249865111,
-0.0119321998,
0.0168742649,
0.0124674821,
-0.0092324801,
-0.0371743143,
-0.0136689683,
0.0364168137,
-0.066863142,
-0.023763977,
-0.0535252541,
0.0265484136,
0.0153980758,
0.0129053174,
-0.0016198409,
2.344638277e-34,
-0.0163947362,
-0.0320126079,
0.0385536999,
-0.0079956017,
-0.0088496255,
-0.0429708585,
0.0140331704,
0.009360468,
0.0235580783,
-0.0299286917,
-0.0279846955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03067v1 | Multilingual transformer and BERTopic for short text topic modeling: The case of Serbian | 2024-02-05T14:59:29 | 2024-02-05T14:59:29 | Darija Medvecki, Bojana Bašaragin, Adela Ljajić, Nikola Milošević | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents the results of the first application of BERTopic, a
state-of-the-art topic modeling technique, to short text written in a
morphologi-cally rich language. We applied BERTopic with three multilingual
embed-ding models on two levels of text preprocessing (partial and full) to
evalu-ate its performance on partially preprocessed short text in Serbian. We
also compared it to LDA and NMF on fully preprocessed text. The experiments
were conducted on a dataset of tweets expressing hesitancy toward COVID-19
vaccination. Our results show that with adequate parameter setting, BERTopic
can yield informative topics even when applied to partially pre-processed short
text. When the same parameters are applied in both prepro-cessing scenarios,
the performance drop on partially preprocessed text is minimal. Compared to LDA
and NMF, judging by the keywords, BERTopic offers more informative topics and
gives novel insights when the number of topics is not limited. The findings of
this paper can be significant for re-searchers working with other
morphologically rich low-resource languages and short text. | [
0.0307051949,
-0.0070479359,
-0.0195039399,
-0.0036320058,
-0.025123518,
-0.0151971104,
-0.0112149119,
0.0153854266,
-0.0671569631,
-0.0257593784,
0.0205386579,
-0.0274053793,
-0.0204443969,
0.0042211828,
-0.0200316869,
-0.0468813628,
0.023401957,
-0.0058087572,
-0.0082694078,
0.006654738,
0.0299793966,
0.0212013628,
0.02426406,
0.0274555162,
-0.0038467254,
0.0474918969,
-0.013190127,
-0.001069479,
0.0222961828,
-0.0169539098,
0.0064437157,
0.0476791561,
-0.006032146,
0.0235986821,
0.0000018781,
-0.0416829214,
-0.0703416914,
-0.0011309105,
0.0684510097,
-0.0024838676,
0.070397079,
-0.0617387816,
-0.0025045872,
0.0350295492,
-0.0010247262,
0.0168762282,
0.0199164078,
0.0642804429,
0.0331194885,
0.0695410296,
-0.031200178,
-0.0297899041,
0.0544139743,
0.0033753598,
0.0004454414,
0.0099755488,
0.0168745592,
-0.0481741503,
0.0131330742,
0.0450196452,
0.0285880063,
0.0471607,
-0.0403794348,
-0.0254398137,
0.0034211578,
0.0113357315,
-0.0514682569,
-0.0626519993,
0.0304094218,
0.0148375835,
-0.0369932614,
-0.0190936048,
0.0590457581,
0.0152785704,
0.0143621992,
0.0310512856,
-0.0507275276,
0.0018163347,
-0.0230492689,
0.0306560919,
0.0525995679,
-0.0023799567,
-0.0098594818,
-0.0006393077,
-0.0130675109,
0.0462203659,
0.0502337776,
-0.0529554449,
-0.0425687283,
-0.0305317119,
0.0271068048,
-0.0514520444,
0.0598295443,
0.018816324,
0.0185831133,
0.0189270563,
-0.0228425413,
-0.0942490101,
0.0417612046,
-0.1087547019,
-0.0528157204,
0.0117618423,
-0.0061812312,
0.0034195289,
-0.0270450935,
-0.0175460875,
-0.0172160286,
-0.0177679732,
-0.0252320245,
-0.0480206199,
-0.0390642695,
-0.0027330725,
-0.0740761459,
0.0105953068,
0.0029132501,
0.0155440941,
-0.0388953835,
0.0528258085,
0.0354980491,
-0.0496197455,
-0.0143403476,
-0.035877835,
-0.0393369757,
0.0035706635,
0.005946327,
0.0662573501,
-0.032317102,
-0.0205658618,
-0.0420349576,
-0.0012874355,
0.0448458754,
0.0346967094,
0.0563038178,
0.0053966418,
0.0090606408,
0.0062491819,
-0.0193107091,
-0.0449939147,
-0.0251347665,
0.0031875642,
-0.0270874612,
0.0116710113,
0.010151946,
-0.0992004126,
-0.0187916383,
0.0398313515,
-0.0149972243,
0.0500008129,
0.0031006571,
0.0250188038,
-0.088881202,
0.051964771,
-0.0280632842,
0.0290978588,
0.0505295917,
0.0104670301,
0.0675385743,
0.0671311617,
0.0064675375,
0.0495283753,
0.0585034713,
-0.01095514,
-0.0042525972,
0.0188165829,
0.0110948412,
0.036011979,
0.0084037688,
0.0211780909,
-0.033394482,
0.0032497514,
0.0054493374,
0.0612669289,
-0.0037581332,
0.0121005569,
0.0290122703,
0.0776732862,
0.0384687632,
0.0186626203,
0.0289484337,
0.0568528473,
-0.0100500742,
0.0167546663,
0.0356912762,
-0.0172556508,
-0.0332425013,
-0.0047598071,
0.0064267428,
0.0492774285,
-0.0297773313,
0.0039568548,
-0.0070721926,
-0.0317221694,
0.0319768935,
-0.0660803765,
0.0719615594,
-0.0134811727,
-0.0273280498,
0.061602246,
0.0435678959,
-0.0514212288,
0.0144494558,
-0.0302090887,
-0.0092304135,
0.0520436615,
0.0227313656,
-0.0356745571,
-0.065331839,
-0.0097685922,
0.0187743008,
0.0420564674,
-0.0093974043,
0.006673018,
-0.03318749,
-0.0426784344,
0.0031236589,
-0.0040335078,
0.0183721352,
0.0392583497,
-0.0301413108,
0.056459602,
0.0140921306,
0.0051498408,
0.046460811,
0.0015893918,
0.0047607836,
0.0519623421,
-0.0119961556,
-0.0111282244,
0.0135827959,
0.0213637911,
0.0190450475,
0.0155466991,
0.0345222875,
-0.0330180936,
-0.0301135834,
0.0098719783,
0.0421564877,
-0.0161051601,
0.0146039054,
-0.0589356832,
0.0260666087,
-0.0323308595,
0.0284563601,
-0.0242487807,
0.022295149,
-0.040313594,
0.03895358,
-0.0127934115,
0.0464740209,
-0.0733484775,
-0.0063135996,
-0.0196386799,
0.0265289824,
-0.003797628,
0.0493709482,
0.0326153487,
-0.0662897751,
0.0293765422,
-0.0115118865,
0.0077603371,
0.0482170396,
-0.0023639051,
-0.0026347255,
0.0509241372,
-0.004257787,
0.0240470022,
-0.0473524593,
-0.1430954486,
0.0121459244,
-0.0127118453,
0.0231067613,
0.0353465341,
0.0542263687,
-0.0156751852,
0.0073957113,
-0.0300570354,
0.0073703676,
0.0202503484,
0.0317070782,
0.0208143424,
-0.006097341,
0.0106665809,
-0.0127545781,
-0.0152725866,
-0.0156946238,
0.0169648267,
0.0026663239,
-0.0442435257,
-0.0242164247,
-0.0053518577,
-0.0220224503,
-0.0303461608,
-0.0133201722,
-0.0668007508,
0.0020762563,
-0.0215127692,
0.1182821095,
-0.041318316,
0.0197028238,
0.0233186446,
0.044120919,
-0.0420567282,
-0.0116323894,
-0.0244720858,
-0.0312595777,
0.0177054685,
-0.0155412778,
-0.0656291544,
0.0378720351,
0.0519647822,
-0.0069358842,
0.0039046614,
-0.0441520028,
-0.0337123871,
-0.0573940091,
0.024311142,
-0.03550414,
0.0035526312,
-0.0048184646,
0.0373624414,
0.0199923832,
-0.0246985629,
0.0572934188,
-0.0117561938,
0.0195448622,
-0.0822690353,
-0.0287955515,
-0.0311221946,
-0.0343441851,
-0.024181392,
0.0185900871,
-0.0301728453,
-0.0206334423,
-0.0171727259,
0.0146688372,
-0.0042245211,
-0.0327473357,
0.0462847389,
0.0182742104,
-0.0130965095,
-0.0136090918,
-0.0135290343,
0.0028587107,
-0.0974208191,
0.026852008,
0.0023106658,
0.0804209188,
-0.0221741516,
-0.0336021483,
0.0527397431,
0.0426137894,
0.0188927371,
-0.0213665795,
-0.011861491,
0.019130731,
0.0503197685,
-0.0022927851,
-0.1105803773,
-0.0261013787,
0.0071023619,
0.0130864782,
-0.0015230995,
0.0140645541,
-0.0444699302,
-0.0226633288,
-0.0323070996,
0.0062238812,
-0.0479728915,
-0.0794655159,
-0.0413630083,
0.0433548689,
-0.0082966899,
0.029888304,
0.0984050781,
0.0374014489,
-0.006751786,
-0.0201824233,
-0.0433160439,
-0.002387776,
-0.014134096,
0.0493562296,
-0.0388542823,
0.0235604141,
0.0150394412,
0.0137741836,
-0.0131743383,
-0.009919134,
0.0212858059,
-0.0258849319,
0.0147992894,
-0.0299059749,
0.0059233177,
0.0025685807,
-0.0931361839,
-0.0140089728,
0.0048238179,
-0.0393550098,
-0.000013746,
-0.0476589724,
0.0246923398,
0.0068038958,
-0.0567998104,
-0.0416673943,
-0.0385354087,
-0.0342993997,
-0.0115617961,
0.0276598372,
0.0559922419,
-0.0386225991,
-0.0045008152,
-0.0035030621,
-0.0031823991,
-0.029901633,
-0.0103559345,
0.0295630675,
0.0141620236,
-0.0099639511,
-0.0415175594,
-0.0211207066,
-0.0080018705,
-0.008272158,
-0.0225976463,
0.0616166778,
-0.0131234713,
-0.0027014785,
-0.0365171619,
0.0072130021,
-0.0140967341,
0.0524326749,
0.0133290337,
-0.0323613472,
0.023552265,
-0.0073366547,
0.0166672524,
-0.0020650064,
-0.0298828427,
-0.0147536509,
-0.0737128556,
-0.0742322579,
-0.0607606359,
-0.0571436919,
0.043702811,
0.0090490067,
-0.0269894935,
-0.0060912031,
-0.0130945193,
-0.0150164384,
-0.0591880083,
0.0186359473,
0.029356936,
-0.0054413634,
-0.060459815,
-0.0139894607,
0.0639744177,
0.0082674958,
0.0094481241,
-0.0323130079,
-0.0321236588,
-0.0361098908,
-0.0115700597,
-0.0184668023,
0.0165401772,
-0.0063597574,
-0.0247029997,
-0.0352768004,
0.0563152023,
0.0471632294,
-0.0029168359,
-0.0281608999,
0.0005498739,
0.0193951577,
0.0050439998,
0.0210093651,
-0.0409842283,
0.038423378,
-0.0364294946,
0.0078858826,
-0.0180726331,
-0.0547695234,
-0.0092126429,
0.0222064406,
0.0564320758,
-0.0387221277,
-0.0356101245,
-0.0577975735,
-0.0284442399,
-0.0331997313,
0.0083937068,
0.0000801193,
0.0332101956,
0.0234965347,
-0.0192021355,
-0.019282192,
0.0533883981,
-0.0618745238,
-0.0188433044,
-0.0485302433,
0.0781319961,
-0.013690331,
0.0260622799,
0.0435448922,
0.0141867362,
0.015302253,
0.0182347409,
-0.0066561149,
-0.0309846476,
-0.0594701134,
-0.0113916481,
-0.0244149826,
-0.0135989673,
0.0009079533,
0.0412107669,
-0.0390492603,
0.007008818,
-0.025121972,
0.0435286015,
0.0494047776,
-0.0144782839,
0.0514888391,
-0.0242445953,
-0.017589746,
-0.0088271573,
0.043570336,
-0.0082897171,
0.0001998571,
0.011417171,
-0.0069083464,
-0.0399735607,
-0.000162916,
0.0750283897,
0.0037105707,
0.0237276573,
0.0371729136,
-0.0383844338,
-0.0173586048,
0.0214527454,
0.0600594431,
0.030988859,
-0.0558664501,
0.006693095,
-0.0350516848,
0.0193449631,
0.0244283825,
-0.0717059746,
-0.0294306539,
0.0001892101,
0.019335011,
0.0717107281,
0.0022115968,
0.0262907203,
-0.0497743562,
0.0297739021,
-0.0012762367,
-0.0462037846,
0.0416554548,
-6.39108197e-33,
0.011798284,
-0.0099278195,
-0.0013909943,
-0.0040278248,
0.0341960117,
0.0297606289,
-0.0022103868,
-0.0005365408,
0.0066752741,
0.0184050575,
-0.0176439323,
0.0076722368,
0.0141354101,
-0.0169819761,
0.0179339424,
0.0153417634,
0.0323454812,
0.0042495672,
0.0027681871,
0.0450172573,
0.0462627448,
0.0646697059,
0.0690236911,
-0.0550147556,
0.0064900811,
-0.0265915412,
0.0141922161,
-0.0021347501,
0.1051322967,
0.0484428369,
0.0061308742,
0.0230204798,
0.0413502939,
-0.0427176766,
-0.001720803,
0.0451462194,
-0.0022924691,
-0.027682269,
0.0139228841,
-0.0180197041,
-0.0189405736,
-0.0488395132,
0.0314785317,
-0.0197134539,
0.0143712712,
0.0586321428,
0.0475288145,
-0.0088225491,
0.0016532937,
-0.059186019,
-0.0720263422,
0.0566811375,
0.0088208048,
-0.027820034,
0.0350196436,
0.0254724994,
0.0143148471,
0.0375210159,
0.0198234748,
0.0369895883,
0.0094914455,
0.0545775406,
0.0229422897,
-0.0360779725,
-0.0164268296,
0.0071763298,
-0.0184563436,
0.0229894239,
0.0302232895,
-0.0106789954,
0.025638964,
0.0373696089,
0.0433457717,
0.041768983,
0.013358199,
-0.0071466775,
-0.0370282829,
0.0608159751,
0.0010633009,
0.0132046631,
-0.0052097328,
0.0181908198,
-0.0051515908,
-0.0268627647,
-0.0007770648,
-0.0045106756,
-0.0153148696,
-0.037639007,
-0.011648125,
0.0033869331,
-0.0211220365,
0.0493540615,
0.0384275317,
0.0067128432,
-0.00203745,
0.0309942625,
-0.0332679413,
0.0564468801,
-0.026042873,
0.06445124,
-0.0504672378,
-0.0297790933,
0.0318475887,
-0.0165138785,
-0.0237091556,
0.0335137509,
-0.0167386942,
-0.0123760644,
-0.0579709113,
-0.0000724518,
0.023796862,
-0.0190562159,
-0.0366032682,
0.0603613816,
-0.0005083943,
-0.0165230408,
0.0260856058,
0.0195132438,
0.0937725976,
0.0322906263,
0.0096105961,
-0.0765586644,
-0.0012155648,
0.0139738042,
-0.0018845773,
0.0464837253,
-0.0472570769,
0.0750347674,
0.0287745669,
-0.04819097,
-0.0209695548,
-0.0339499526,
2.811e-7,
0.0688125193,
0.1080944538,
-0.0086388197,
-0.0547652729,
0.0226717573,
0.0116513418,
-0.0366213657,
0.032933753,
-0.026353132,
0.0256147925,
0.0057045943,
-0.0382344835,
-0.0057888385,
0.0527138747,
-0.0866280049,
-0.0228072423,
-0.0660897642,
-0.0161242001,
-0.0671989694,
0.0144823454,
0.0035620974,
0.0739009306,
0.0045982264,
0.017369071,
-0.0457441285,
-0.0306205265,
0.0523015223,
-0.0265977606,
-0.0602768734,
0.04933073,
0.0867116973,
0.0109733567,
0.0090396516,
-0.0264114439,
-0.0416714996,
-0.0048471028,
0.0223667696,
0.0302471239,
-0.0188490488,
0.0261875018,
0.0762085766,
-0.08187747,
-0.0496205166,
-0.0560958534,
0.0470760129,
-0.0297060646,
-0.0471903235,
-0.0099318596,
-0.0169598721,
0.0389208272,
0.0109487781,
-0.0439715944,
-0.0496324338,
0.0396025926,
-0.0158658829,
-0.0097652897,
-0.030228449,
-0.0523522422,
0.0258357506,
0.0040879408,
-0.0201247782,
-0.0418593585,
-0.0537472405,
-0.0137723312,
0.048814483,
-0.047530286,
0.0583609939,
2.510996212e-34,
0.0468083099,
0.0030368429,
-0.0566783026,
-0.001247144,
-0.0302392095,
-0.0100276303,
0.0056633721,
0.0450729206,
-0.0199779514,
-0.0426081829,
-0.0047658975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03053v1 | Multi-Lingual Malaysian Embedding: Leveraging Large Language Models for Semantic Representations | 2024-02-05T14:36:51 | 2024-02-05T14:36:51 | Husein Zolkepli, Aisyah Razak, Kamarul Adha, Ariff Nazhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this work, we present a comprehensive exploration of finetuning Malaysian
language models, specifically Llama2 and Mistral, on embedding tasks involving
negative and positive pairs. We release two distinct models tailored for
Semantic Similarity and Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG).
For Semantic Similarity, our 600 million parameter Llama2 model outperforms
OpenAI text-embedding-ada-002 across all recall@k metrics for b.cari.com.my,
c.cari.com.my, Malay news, and Malaysian Twitter test sets.
In the realm of RAG models, our approach proves competitive with OpenAI
text-embedding-ada-002 in the Malaysian context. Notably, our 2 billion
parameter Llama2 model achieves superior Recall@5, Recall@10 for the "Melayu"
keyword research papers dataset and excels in Recall@3, Recall@5, and Recall@10
for the lom.agc.gov.my dataset.
These findings underscore the effectiveness of our finetuning strategy and
highlight the performance gains in both Semantic Similarity and RAG tasks.
All models released at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mesolitica/malaysian-embedding-6523612bfe5881ad35f81b99 | [
0.0186948087,
0.0063841571,
0.0058366931,
0.0508663096,
-0.0203436818,
0.0137138339,
-0.0111363614,
-0.0147690503,
0.0012985351,
-0.0444142073,
-0.0546467565,
-0.0547839701,
-0.0181816667,
0.0040800478,
0.0515164584,
-0.0396823548,
0.0494653136,
0.010856865,
0.0161887053,
-0.0143123632,
0.0273219813,
0.0093366867,
0.0360761657,
0.0242413599,
0.0081437128,
0.0118066901,
0.0231512394,
0.0008300001,
0.023463456,
-0.062773414,
-0.0062080873,
-0.0021200511,
0.0330653004,
0.0765101016,
0.0000017092,
-0.0524886474,
0.0003687175,
-0.0143238138,
0.0177351832,
0.0423738919,
0.0566749536,
-0.0003008667,
0.0195854772,
0.0304103363,
-0.037514288,
-0.0198959876,
0.0180844497,
0.0545415357,
0.0616045445,
0.0668869466,
-0.0188728869,
-0.0240105875,
0.0287085492,
-0.0657017827,
0.0217890311,
-0.0101042092,
0.0115360646,
-0.0197669901,
0.0009264905,
0.0064367289,
-0.0111822281,
0.041617427,
-0.0051362989,
0.0321138501,
0.0170355644,
0.033378534,
-0.0439743102,
-0.0104730129,
0.0404616781,
0.0773842484,
-0.0046011675,
-0.0492121205,
-0.0285944063,
0.0227154922,
-0.0249295477,
0.0368615016,
-0.0575776957,
0.0057173646,
-0.0075343908,
0.0848314837,
0.0400748104,
0.0061523356,
0.0612870678,
0.042483788,
-0.0203287993,
0.0000054059,
0.0283438601,
-0.0553704724,
-0.003347306,
0.0004230447,
-0.035517808,
0.0280034412,
0.0198217779,
0.0140227471,
0.0192591008,
0.0198026337,
-0.0277205743,
-0.0369628258,
0.0719046667,
-0.0793162808,
0.0226509366,
0.0800544694,
-0.0224942062,
0.0487629026,
-0.1055399999,
0.0100755226,
-0.0479041673,
0.0328966938,
-0.0511094071,
-0.0646169484,
-0.013779779,
-0.0221838225,
-0.0188327357,
0.029781336,
-0.01270964,
-0.0260120053,
-0.0275234077,
0.0396258533,
-0.0359240919,
0.0095828362,
-0.0106149446,
0.0047401623,
-0.0347744636,
0.0045057153,
-0.0270245392,
-0.0010054179,
-0.0505098887,
-0.0023980122,
0.0195856113,
-0.0181011818,
0.004179256,
0.0455806106,
-0.0015360116,
-0.0265281722,
-0.0072577917,
0.024775764,
-0.0362388827,
-0.0336458571,
-0.0403234884,
-0.0058999653,
0.0231497493,
-0.0198974796,
0.0107038487,
-0.0637820885,
0.0442638621,
0.0034537499,
-0.0091726212,
-0.0413301103,
0.036047712,
0.0367109179,
-0.0289152302,
0.0479041077,
0.0182900485,
-0.0163835529,
0.0470146947,
0.0363339931,
0.0218539909,
0.0597695261,
0.0077877836,
0.0168001559,
0.052461803,
0.0274076145,
-0.0478381328,
0.0046202978,
0.0586568639,
0.0397861637,
-0.0116271283,
0.0007942464,
0.0082125207,
0.059763059,
0.0324324965,
0.0713315904,
-0.0398534201,
-0.0133283846,
0.0006905975,
0.020237172,
0.025307836,
0.0083512999,
0.0613053814,
-0.0217380635,
-0.0438225679,
-0.0054387366,
0.0011829948,
0.0198537465,
-0.0310522802,
0.0302957613,
0.0754091963,
0.0397328213,
-0.0702819601,
0.0066545447,
0.0104043735,
-0.046784386,
0.0089543173,
-0.0264612772,
0.0363457389,
-0.0002611103,
-0.0614760555,
0.0707351416,
0.031331785,
-0.0567518175,
0.0340368077,
-0.0450574756,
0.0243178923,
0.0432062671,
0.0502920598,
-0.0056465468,
-0.0322013199,
0.0068321447,
-0.0483108684,
0.0559277199,
0.0257687569,
-0.0187357143,
-0.0333884843,
-0.0862923414,
0.0173282288,
0.0050409548,
0.01781803,
0.0355415158,
0.0252462588,
0.0395822525,
0.0687069222,
-0.0318430699,
0.0053271661,
0.031470526,
-0.0783150792,
-0.0174924526,
-0.0084398026,
0.0157164074,
-0.0011733001,
0.0188560151,
0.0241218396,
0.0203622337,
0.0419814102,
-0.0732637942,
-0.0358933099,
-0.0036767144,
-0.0545919836,
-0.0355321951,
0.0268683303,
-0.027281085,
0.0495042093,
0.061677102,
-0.0347896591,
-0.0384609513,
0.0070446064,
0.0250936821,
0.0406541973,
-0.0975124389,
0.0074084564,
-0.0158543456,
0.0299461167,
-0.0268175863,
0.0639191642,
-0.0622102208,
0.0209202506,
0.0170191508,
0.0383178256,
0.0467402302,
-0.0428486876,
-0.0690425411,
0.0054954207,
0.0348817408,
0.0171389356,
-0.0282286815,
-0.0220616441,
-0.0295394454,
-0.0375243835,
-0.0971159786,
0.0155268814,
-0.0223967154,
0.0054151225,
0.0236970447,
-0.0005728353,
0.0041390047,
0.0028498978,
-0.0078646149,
-0.0238364916,
0.0227002278,
0.0560484976,
0.0093660485,
-0.006257466,
0.0133422222,
-0.0444346331,
-0.0070029264,
0.0016507134,
0.0373333655,
-0.0489913858,
-0.0475422144,
-0.0286108535,
0.0127120838,
-0.0610369556,
-0.0312110987,
-0.0287295282,
-0.013327959,
0.0036445933,
-0.0089523969,
0.0493152738,
0.0213484634,
0.0058321059,
0.0075312727,
0.0457600877,
0.0261123721,
-0.0418328941,
-0.0138545567,
-0.0165787283,
0.0210442469,
0.0126466891,
-0.0221341513,
-0.0038468267,
0.0380804837,
-0.0296620354,
-0.0127500826,
-0.0456403531,
-0.0243085138,
-0.0140378345,
0.0012982729,
-0.0054172529,
-0.0022844728,
-0.0274057835,
0.0160454493,
-0.0064440877,
-0.0319031402,
0.0732673109,
-0.0325318985,
0.0268746261,
-0.0319121294,
0.0079735937,
-0.0462914445,
0.0140865212,
-0.0459385626,
0.0130419927,
-0.0733157396,
0.0137444902,
-0.0237611718,
-0.0080652367,
0.0075942813,
-0.0416969694,
0.0395291559,
0.0065404084,
-0.0166571103,
-0.0302408058,
-0.0244569071,
-0.0409833826,
-0.0580905117,
-0.0013118156,
0.033263471,
-0.0081515359,
0.0288590956,
-0.0279154144,
0.017377181,
-0.0129693467,
-0.027199354,
-0.0036700908,
0.0000513068,
-0.0153314359,
0.0469901673,
0.05437598,
-0.0095729409,
0.0233554933,
-0.0002604899,
0.029852381,
0.0197701082,
0.0196512248,
-0.005398381,
0.0115326783,
-0.0332607776,
0.0264192689,
-0.0113704875,
-0.0142024066,
-0.0406153686,
0.0160396136,
0.0090793036,
-0.0167139713,
0.086317353,
0.0346521512,
-0.0461676419,
-0.0178559665,
-0.0689286366,
0.0585922375,
0.0250542574,
-0.0043781893,
-0.0666988567,
0.0021120056,
0.0058039916,
0.0001866449,
0.0133185992,
0.004557082,
-0.0009978095,
-0.1210374758,
-0.0203872882,
0.0258102771,
-0.0296836291,
-0.035176497,
-0.040252164,
-0.0173580628,
0.0205058716,
0.0395053029,
0.027416788,
0.0061380025,
-0.0095917452,
0.016420465,
0.0197959933,
-0.078816615,
0.0196102932,
-0.051182732,
0.0228657555,
0.039982643,
0.0316535383,
0.0020949915,
-0.044959683,
-0.0085436217,
-0.0698607415,
-0.0308197252,
-0.0154543938,
0.009274181,
0.0071649784,
-0.000770164,
-0.029588351,
0.0074861776,
-0.0380644388,
0.0202904008,
-0.018699117,
0.1013642624,
-0.0266741291,
0.0085200956,
-0.0233262014,
-0.0072310958,
-0.0055922293,
0.0655082464,
0.0247824956,
-0.019838715,
0.0088177938,
0.0054632481,
0.026233824,
-0.0152607234,
0.0078404481,
0.019769758,
-0.0322130807,
-0.0184383877,
-0.0922680497,
-0.063580215,
0.0054802969,
0.0322550721,
-0.0213443115,
0.0294132121,
-0.017700091,
-0.0352065191,
-0.0387550332,
-0.0078558233,
-0.0420208797,
-0.0057886979,
-0.0389548205,
0.0145372897,
0.0521912277,
-0.0129282121,
-0.0078617753,
-0.0325267576,
-0.0677651539,
-0.0513744354,
-0.0160460677,
0.0142052127,
0.0144347232,
0.0093504759,
0.0073069786,
-0.0413906313,
0.0241886228,
0.0438191891,
-0.0115221096,
0.0010989718,
0.0221749675,
0.027318554,
0.0077997018,
0.0615148246,
-0.0482196957,
0.0020105266,
-0.0194481481,
0.0450806804,
0.0022456709,
0.0137029262,
0.0134126209,
0.0018873567,
0.0525385812,
-0.0387179404,
-0.0019805608,
-0.0505907424,
0.0101347473,
-0.0062682745,
-0.0004690445,
-0.0172094498,
0.0114963884,
0.0584594719,
-0.0361810066,
-0.0072609908,
-0.0085165333,
0.0040157116,
0.050201688,
-0.0282882303,
0.0077085122,
-0.0031137217,
0.0500797331,
-0.0168335419,
0.0227941424,
-0.0496317074,
-0.0285191648,
-0.0335926116,
0.0119270924,
-0.0646320507,
0.0537387431,
-0.0095381588,
0.0133393202,
-0.0012368244,
0.0425839648,
0.0132462205,
-0.0339518636,
-0.0088535612,
0.0167212114,
0.0835464001,
-0.0136978235,
0.0386037007,
-0.0122257508,
-0.0194420796,
-0.0300996192,
-0.0008690101,
-0.0263306405,
-0.0169523973,
0.048901096,
0.0036704342,
-0.0083261123,
0.0335608535,
0.0844512135,
-0.0289455485,
0.0281095505,
0.0006900297,
0.0078534419,
-0.0016042099,
-0.0235596076,
0.0411843434,
0.0828318372,
-0.0301057156,
-0.0034413117,
-0.044371888,
-0.0585655086,
0.0140122306,
-0.0205504354,
-0.0597473793,
0.0003171955,
0.0227345116,
0.0669213682,
-0.0059917504,
0.0496721789,
-0.0419357233,
0.0141265588,
-0.0240743235,
-0.0340305343,
-0.0147340382,
-6.177895784e-33,
-0.0301167667,
0.0165608022,
0.0172011144,
-0.0384820215,
-0.0225538127,
-0.0296010505,
-0.0256260484,
-0.0131864147,
-0.0601336025,
0.0037242463,
-0.0058882274,
-0.0027913409,
0.0067054559,
0.0240656622,
-0.0249084663,
-0.0337115638,
0.0120362602,
0.054079771,
0.0099786855,
0.0531096868,
0.0826762095,
0.0314048789,
0.0403904021,
-0.0484576188,
0.0132079553,
-0.0412143543,
0.0212195683,
-0.0068721515,
0.0143552972,
0.070086807,
-0.0703643635,
0.0514176115,
0.0246983357,
0.0274718385,
-0.0317672491,
-0.0303820111,
-0.0731094331,
-0.0325506628,
0.0093735773,
-0.035002023,
-0.028043557,
-0.0241052508,
0.0566222109,
-0.0152234202,
-0.0084271366,
0.0328710526,
0.0219303425,
-0.0057058739,
-0.0540520214,
-0.0054800576,
-0.0685979724,
0.0208101254,
0.0586739369,
-0.0139400149,
0.0324461646,
0.0418723188,
0.0174229294,
0.0945376381,
-0.098459661,
-0.0150903035,
-0.0522788092,
0.0401527286,
0.0412492752,
-0.0183514059,
-0.0159171261,
0.0442175642,
-0.0023505646,
-0.0159596484,
0.0377322137,
-0.0049791639,
0.0512932651,
0.0109827835,
0.0287620872,
0.065009743,
0.0312745087,
-0.0665569082,
-0.0605950654,
0.0421491265,
0.0207612421,
0.0121994875,
0.0464505702,
0.0249374136,
-0.0420694239,
-0.0228537079,
-0.0100529548,
0.0005323477,
-0.0480817072,
-0.0442702696,
0.0306574013,
0.0247051772,
-0.0127429143,
0.0124129625,
0.0389631875,
-0.0308688302,
0.0123435063,
0.0283170957,
-0.0238942336,
-0.0087468633,
-0.0184934847,
0.0196462441,
-0.0391621366,
-0.0607072376,
0.0059967665,
-0.0147180771,
-0.0412065536,
-0.0048901071,
0.0293005276,
-0.0231652372,
-0.076206319,
0.0239733532,
-0.0379333906,
-0.0511625931,
0.0015651234,
-0.0218453165,
-0.0194944944,
0.0252324212,
0.0029524341,
0.0535979569,
0.0589878447,
-0.0143857198,
-0.0240981448,
-0.0428705961,
-0.0041185669,
0.0032799987,
-0.0188434627,
0.0439099036,
-0.04064456,
0.0464352034,
0.0253272429,
-0.0639376715,
-0.0142632416,
0.0211987924,
2.496e-7,
0.052814275,
0.0077254763,
0.016553795,
-0.0140306689,
-0.0059315292,
0.0239201747,
-0.0140887061,
0.0375556722,
0.00701052,
0.0189463012,
0.013733943,
-0.0012546257,
0.0075987843,
0.0372507945,
-0.0831130147,
0.0753241703,
-0.1106611937,
-0.0262851659,
-0.0346917547,
-0.0358022563,
0.0492382459,
0.1228680238,
0.0193238929,
0.0088164676,
-0.0092873266,
-0.0462245718,
0.1231860295,
-0.011832186,
-0.0386708416,
0.0139552215,
0.03395487,
0.0439973734,
0.0017662989,
-0.0415556021,
-0.0228350926,
0.0379351862,
0.0304880328,
0.0491349921,
0.0296089351,
-0.0451433361,
0.0098904511,
-0.0281200185,
-0.0013320199,
-0.0751525909,
0.0733755603,
-0.010610274,
-0.0224374533,
-0.0106827896,
-0.0064196936,
0.0609515682,
0.0599571727,
-0.0155069102,
-0.056194637,
0.0395412669,
0.01714224,
0.0149330404,
-0.0154489251,
-0.0574037805,
-0.0148193724,
0.0092989681,
-0.0391566344,
-0.0128722638,
-0.0352148786,
0.0106151272,
0.0270161461,
-0.0278367233,
0.0408919342,
2.034142694e-34,
0.0488439351,
0.0097202333,
-0.011241952,
0.0289367121,
0.0328032896,
-0.0383933559,
-0.0346855558,
0.0178090688,
0.024957126,
-0.0656663626,
0.0063054455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03050v1 | A Comprehensive Study of the Current State-of-the-Art in Nepali Automatic Speech Recognition Systems | 2024-02-05T14:34:14 | 2024-02-05T14:34:14 | Rupak Raj Ghimire, Bal Krishna Bal, Prakash Poudyal | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | In this paper, we examine the research conducted in the field of Nepali
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR). The primary objective of this survey is to
conduct a comprehensive review of the works on Nepali Automatic Speech
Recognition Systems completed to date, explore the different datasets used,
examine the technology utilized, and take account of the obstacles encountered
in implementing the Nepali ASR system. In tandem with the global trends of
ever-increasing research on speech recognition based research, the number of
Nepalese ASR-related projects are also growing. Nevertheless, the investigation
of language and acoustic models of the Nepali language has not received
adequate attention compared to languages that possess ample resources. In this
context, we provide a framework as well as directions for future
investigations. | [
0.0327559523,
-0.0020635722,
-0.0170374066,
0.035982471,
-0.0631360039,
0.0055037178,
-0.0277179312,
0.0146552976,
0.0111629833,
-0.00395616,
-0.0158626363,
-0.0076033613,
0.0564042665,
0.0022684487,
0.0093336441,
-0.0927128419,
0.0136239575,
-0.0777894258,
0.0210205093,
0.0142081426,
-0.0049603297,
-0.0153173553,
-0.0404129997,
0.035096202,
0.0216417126,
0.0263990406,
-0.0144751985,
-0.0059936536,
0.010375916,
-0.0238141026,
-0.0470315553,
0.0103793582,
-0.0322701558,
0.0072492925,
0.0000014027,
-0.0500162132,
-0.0027618613,
-0.0044751042,
-0.0412260816,
-0.014174236,
0.0197748672,
-0.0075629014,
0.0039494643,
0.0383826941,
0.0067777596,
0.0066649588,
0.0747889876,
0.0016590158,
-0.009158846,
0.0016484145,
-0.0229435824,
-0.0649059489,
0.0244725812,
0.0324325599,
-0.0551488735,
-0.0074960282,
0.0423367843,
0.002160528,
-0.0030246503,
-0.0411610045,
0.0177048463,
0.0582850352,
-0.0138404546,
-0.0144811794,
0.0217857845,
-0.0398058929,
-0.0581345223,
-0.0672953725,
-0.0259437114,
0.0248293094,
-0.0218013003,
-0.049459774,
0.0410167314,
0.0087022316,
-0.0468462855,
0.0169864595,
0.0201085918,
0.0023455792,
-0.0317661949,
-0.0178300198,
0.0429752134,
0.0395491943,
-0.0241858903,
-0.0055425223,
0.0819101259,
-0.0610928871,
-0.0122259483,
-0.0262568872,
0.0070774769,
-0.0596371479,
-0.0164861344,
0.0411815345,
0.0643581152,
0.0087796329,
0.0252961516,
-0.006957151,
0.0215079859,
-0.0160385426,
0.0174341407,
-0.0519059636,
0.0287029184,
0.0185702164,
-0.0345680751,
-0.0107428282,
0.019216489,
0.0405273177,
-0.0102939764,
-0.0239811316,
-0.0240806136,
0.0183267966,
0.0275181234,
-0.0399318524,
-0.0169800352,
-0.0156659484,
-0.0164951943,
-0.008071118,
-0.0403660163,
0.014444151,
0.0399711654,
-0.0431328043,
0.0313101411,
-0.0352279469,
-0.0250783917,
-0.0252404734,
0.023164602,
0.0126204733,
0.0250424352,
0.0607719049,
-0.0420772359,
-0.1029510275,
0.0096599683,
0.0230289325,
0.0092013823,
0.0352786854,
-0.0266793855,
0.0247703101,
0.0131627107,
-0.0364218019,
-0.0603880808,
0.0547054335,
-0.0026078597,
-0.0515459999,
-0.0431023017,
-0.0189604033,
0.0616720617,
0.0729472786,
-0.0109086437,
0.0256570149,
0.0003621728,
-0.0400552861,
0.0217447188,
0.0822954848,
0.0048163366,
0.034345109,
0.0799232274,
0.0054304553,
0.0404255427,
0.0277355593,
0.0011434093,
-0.0001300497,
0.0008055839,
-0.0674379393,
0.0416995287,
0.0390027948,
-0.0668888092,
0.0041486705,
-0.0277348161,
-0.0057883421,
0.0073099681,
-0.0110648489,
-0.0246242937,
0.0712569803,
0.0071975365,
0.0193831641,
0.0264584012,
0.0461460017,
0.0415301397,
0.035841167,
0.0273467135,
-0.0137670757,
0.0522499904,
0.0106660826,
0.0512678362,
-0.0383066237,
-0.0330488048,
0.0024148384,
-0.0072108521,
0.0204706155,
-0.0015274197,
0.0076318895,
-0.030216068,
-0.0241840519,
-0.0483192839,
0.0208468158,
0.0693595931,
-0.0088803163,
-0.0286195278,
-0.0227542706,
0.0444085784,
-0.0211314168,
0.0350355431,
-0.0659526512,
0.0077829156,
0.0133355707,
0.0473282896,
-0.0420468822,
0.0315547772,
-0.0094548604,
-0.0455503948,
0.0144502632,
0.0128660286,
0.0110967821,
0.0171297546,
-0.0573116392,
0.0420559682,
0.0971880779,
-0.0315670669,
0.0419329889,
-0.0444615446,
0.0237465147,
0.0050200811,
0.0325015411,
-0.018189352,
0.0061010635,
-0.0136061898,
0.0076311268,
0.007192113,
0.032506071,
0.0777697861,
0.0356194749,
-0.010404421,
-0.0302241705,
0.0449798591,
0.0078250933,
0.0447947308,
0.0480889827,
0.0047571724,
-0.0085780909,
0.0273996107,
-0.026482556,
0.046005182,
-0.0122585753,
0.0721272156,
-0.0823088959,
0.0613661334,
-0.0085737845,
0.0272623096,
-0.0429529995,
0.0978340432,
0.0066343076,
0.0356388055,
0.0127064763,
0.0161316879,
-0.011708471,
-0.0231130663,
0.0085122008,
0.00311779,
0.0165995788,
-0.0803840533,
-0.0184157956,
0.0517513342,
-0.0039211004,
0.0114996517,
0.0084807994,
-0.0480799228,
-0.0208379868,
-0.0413178243,
-0.0411482118,
-0.0619011298,
-0.0025918679,
0.0025810853,
-0.0513934754,
0.0436003953,
-0.0139755569,
-0.0447982401,
0.0197643563,
-0.0132548017,
0.023510322,
-0.0433864333,
-0.0459386297,
-0.0006759826,
-0.0319429301,
-0.0087622236,
-0.0157335177,
0.0170089416,
-0.0022154059,
-0.0125699788,
-0.0856091231,
-0.0562253259,
-0.0030547839,
0.0291833226,
0.0360070616,
-0.0172834881,
-0.0448817834,
-0.0538397692,
-0.0138917379,
0.0180114359,
0.0339096151,
-0.0041614524,
-0.0146307684,
-0.002875465,
-0.001537344,
-0.0002236662,
-0.0176622514,
-0.0148556754,
0.0492990017,
0.0127347251,
0.0160684083,
-0.0466001146,
0.0105560459,
0.0257713012,
0.0443582721,
-0.0040318393,
-0.0560382381,
-0.0425515659,
-0.0191323161,
-0.0105057927,
0.0036907096,
-0.0583740734,
0.0399907082,
0.0152991703,
-0.0318426825,
0.0328046978,
-0.0695502833,
-0.0203922335,
-0.0514431782,
-0.0198452417,
-0.0313857943,
0.0066453912,
0.0109204641,
-0.0368905738,
-0.0007075346,
-0.0536850467,
0.0414556228,
0.0058207405,
0.012176686,
-0.0486888587,
-0.0126844337,
-0.0254527926,
0.0369879305,
-0.0453157239,
0.0079169692,
0.0052595185,
-0.0053776768,
-0.0231367629,
0.0024351685,
-0.0115609756,
0.0143196275,
0.0086815413,
0.1315314621,
0.0067443787,
-0.0034383538,
-0.0160984378,
0.0665320158,
-0.0506970435,
0.0609718338,
0.0390605144,
-0.0059330547,
-0.0067170309,
0.0168262944,
0.0448887646,
-0.096703589,
0.071470581,
0.0042178859,
-0.0198352989,
-0.0081598116,
0.043299716,
0.0185902566,
0.015004809,
0.0043253344,
0.0089845099,
0.0020126768,
0.0539568812,
0.0157863349,
0.0110832583,
-0.0052171652,
-0.0450298302,
-0.0466055684,
-0.0285251979,
-0.0172590706,
0.0023877067,
-0.0112660481,
0.0116060069,
0.0605198257,
0.0122561203,
0.0038706823,
0.0248037148,
-0.0205388367,
-0.0549777411,
0.0099269608,
0.0051901387,
-0.0123103112,
-0.0319455825,
-0.0246744752,
-0.0290248226,
-0.0222700294,
0.0376251638,
0.0421881415,
-0.02444553,
-0.0672505423,
0.079164356,
-0.0746208802,
-0.0805715248,
0.0070356545,
-0.0187248122,
0.0565436445,
0.0065191742,
-0.016757369,
-0.0309662949,
-0.0291735996,
-0.0197679587,
-0.0297523085,
0.0143354926,
-0.000674588,
-0.0369567052,
0.0305610429,
-0.0166542996,
0.018337002,
0.0184714384,
0.0210743267,
0.0277242344,
-0.0011614896,
0.0444389097,
-0.0290708859,
0.0040666508,
0.0258253422,
0.0058866679,
0.0165710263,
-0.0020858569,
0.0126259914,
0.0007966184,
-0.0272473227,
0.0223129243,
0.0423496254,
0.0344359018,
-0.0007700917,
-0.0010430391,
-0.0279791746,
-0.0740175545,
0.008407128,
0.0009412483,
0.0235321838,
0.0378460363,
0.0752324462,
0.062074963,
0.0276930239,
0.08937677,
-0.0093886089,
-0.0081060948,
-0.0144052785,
0.0010542396,
-0.0725762397,
-0.0188537072,
0.0242502764,
-0.0424338765,
-0.0051976983,
-0.0014872912,
0.0151993493,
-0.0427029543,
0.0651272088,
0.0078997025,
0.0329695381,
0.0049206228,
-0.0497020781,
-0.0824146122,
0.0087835975,
0.0186236668,
-0.0769592747,
-0.0188762546,
0.0075848326,
-0.0008862356,
-0.0153325154,
-0.0014238177,
-0.0160252936,
0.0244325008,
-0.0589905269,
-0.0365125462,
-0.0168170817,
-0.0370198265,
-0.0091951583,
0.0130941579,
0.0424405709,
-0.0447632745,
-0.0102679031,
-0.0108133825,
0.0123303663,
0.0195362885,
0.0549210422,
-0.0051151332,
-0.0068287328,
0.0132363616,
0.0705436245,
-0.0289092883,
-0.0165140573,
-0.068249315,
-0.0231517795,
0.0580998734,
0.1122345924,
0.0416341498,
0.0616287328,
0.0198364668,
-0.0147004984,
-0.0092768073,
0.0190872345,
0.0329284854,
-0.0042462107,
0.0067053125,
0.0267853551,
-0.0214733519,
0.0242802072,
0.0234599393,
0.0261451993,
0.034361247,
0.0151545331,
0.0082110679,
-0.0201809946,
0.0277511049,
0.0232461523,
0.025444977,
-0.0030186654,
0.0215370264,
-0.0528380759,
0.0031758146,
-0.0230566375,
0.0166961662,
0.0163082983,
-0.0047250977,
-0.0462745912,
0.0588301383,
-0.0027745212,
-0.0014050598,
-0.0067430809,
-0.0052236295,
0.0007866679,
-0.029892141,
-0.0681628883,
-0.0463898778,
-0.0325420722,
-0.0405264273,
0.006984375,
-0.0248482972,
-0.0534563139,
-0.0253524426,
-0.0097901868,
0.06897939,
-0.0301060807,
-0.0302044768,
-0.0080258762,
0.0038306133,
0.010993287,
-0.0182248913,
-0.034906663,
-0.0362480655,
0.0149989501,
0.0368954092,
-4.82378323e-33,
-0.0087828729,
0.0465655923,
-0.0307954326,
0.0203790162,
-0.0112886103,
0.004397009,
-0.0093543651,
0.0179827493,
-0.0127635943,
-0.069275409,
-0.0428581834,
-0.0428247489,
0.0517323613,
-0.0522198118,
0.0337173119,
-0.0037444094,
0.0185534284,
-0.0010867264,
0.0265816301,
-0.0291714296,
-0.0040752427,
0.0296847541,
0.0287495553,
-0.0199367218,
0.0005622594,
-0.0238130763,
-0.0095439199,
-0.0151332328,
0.0219775587,
0.0242714845,
-0.0377121568,
0.0363326371,
-0.0146689499,
-0.0110956579,
0.0135253863,
0.0213768929,
-0.07869149,
0.0701253265,
0.020494977,
0.115928635,
-0.0183943044,
0.0058942782,
0.0184697136,
0.0205441732,
-0.102303341,
0.0843643472,
-0.0164526682,
-0.0321711749,
-0.017290635,
0.0110405246,
0.008116181,
0.0306305569,
-0.0083258767,
-0.0123587633,
0.0781005546,
0.0157213435,
-0.0370545387,
-0.0626202077,
-0.0382749513,
0.0370018519,
0.0635850728,
0.0338981003,
0.0365240015,
0.0663656592,
-0.0077667795,
-0.0299720392,
0.053633444,
-0.134847939,
0.0160205811,
-0.0308198314,
0.0457484499,
0.0099416012,
0.0028835502,
-0.0143789854,
0.0510692894,
-0.0829841793,
-0.0040466292,
-0.0419659391,
0.0791767836,
0.0452900864,
0.0292851478,
0.0042684139,
-0.0546775684,
-0.0142413964,
0.0107127568,
-0.0551252291,
-0.0470157638,
-0.0296144057,
0.0745381042,
-0.0180747677,
0.0089432895,
0.0306776203,
0.0655164272,
-0.0182671063,
0.0179893337,
0.0324695036,
-0.0156972557,
0.0363539681,
-0.0147356428,
0.0242836867,
-0.0751713887,
-0.0607542619,
0.0161075741,
0.0333096944,
0.0023106325,
-0.0460292995,
-0.0310144573,
0.0382841825,
-0.0261093583,
0.0242826901,
0.0187773015,
0.0367443338,
0.0045797322,
0.020388715,
0.0089464895,
-0.0389859006,
0.0050412496,
0.0116725927,
0.0117791248,
0.0320460424,
0.0032111569,
0.052107729,
0.0245257765,
0.0304764435,
-0.0338410437,
0.0417625792,
-0.0077544493,
-0.0333321504,
-0.0084510026,
0.0467315502,
0.0255455039,
0.0185199231,
2.261e-7,
-0.0707166642,
0.0129472613,
0.0889817253,
-0.0744121522,
-0.011831169,
-0.0224215612,
-0.0225288421,
-0.0171240475,
0.0121792015,
0.055591356,
0.0056683086,
-0.0226093512,
0.0819077268,
-0.0080684964,
-0.0979433879,
-0.0015746176,
-0.0662205815,
0.0063232062,
-0.0503421389,
0.0178106539,
-0.0565814935,
0.0359233208,
-0.0099759474,
-0.0140101649,
-0.0478015244,
-0.0123413866,
0.007422491,
0.0114721367,
0.0092873806,
0.0202751625,
0.0281454977,
0.0017694731,
-0.0135980295,
0.0128811821,
-0.0142466705,
0.0481065586,
0.0391773432,
0.0193147324,
-0.0356088951,
-0.0288604442,
0.0385556258,
0.0337997377,
-0.0049723252,
-0.0317314938,
0.0479751043,
0.0787902549,
-0.0278205108,
0.008886544,
-0.0045518256,
0.0040310007,
-0.0077023781,
-0.0031132509,
0.0373592302,
0.0084777074,
0.0201046839,
-0.0777780563,
-0.0476602092,
0.0132769141,
-0.0108649777,
0.0088669565,
-0.0326912552,
-0.0027445843,
0.0082646953,
0.0177714471,
0.0320433713,
-0.0050841579,
0.0061928197,
1.075013805e-34,
0.0324761309,
-0.0196195096,
-0.0034876938,
-0.0069262427,
0.0036688319,
-0.0441144146,
-0.0021591152,
0.0671950355,
0.0118959825,
-0.0485879071,
-0.0349510573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03049v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03049v4 | EasyInstruct: An Easy-to-use Instruction Processing Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T14:33:56 | 2024-06-24T02:10:23 | Yixin Ou, Ningyu Zhang, Honghao Gui, Ziwen Xu, Shuofei Qiao, Yida Xue, Runnan Fang, Kangwei Liu, Lei Li, Zhen Bi, Guozhou Zheng, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG | In recent years, instruction tuning has gained increasing attention and
emerged as a crucial technique to enhance the capabilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs). To construct high-quality instruction datasets, many instruction
processing approaches have been proposed, aiming to achieve a delicate balance
between data quantity and data quality. Nevertheless, due to inconsistencies
that persist among various instruction processing methods, there is no standard
open-source instruction processing implementation framework available for the
community, which hinders practitioners from further developing and advancing.
To facilitate instruction processing research and development, we present
EasyInstruct, an easy-to-use instruction processing framework for LLMs, which
modularizes instruction generation, selection, and prompting, while also
considering their combination and interaction. EasyInstruct is publicly
released and actively maintained at https://github.com/zjunlp/EasyInstruct,
along with an online demo app and a demo video for quick-start, calling for
broader research centered on instruction data and synthetic data. | [
0.0369367041,
0.0393390879,
-0.0390856974,
0.0308256559,
-0.0286197625,
0.0064994805,
0.0201698281,
-0.015687868,
0.0046460223,
-0.0434351414,
-0.0410396755,
-0.0416459106,
0.0118564088,
-0.0111393416,
0.0249825213,
-0.0524215288,
0.0531319566,
-0.0566391721,
-0.0338560976,
0.015690919,
0.0165219307,
0.0366065949,
-0.0248650704,
0.0425374359,
0.0332073048,
-0.0386123434,
-0.0285764262,
0.0027930299,
-0.0189492069,
-0.0251919813,
0.0217337254,
0.0719311908,
0.0236840602,
0.0078222333,
0.0000021093,
-0.0415421464,
-0.0074480604,
-0.0343766585,
-0.0185430851,
0.0567327142,
0.0564583503,
0.0071710735,
-0.0355680697,
0.0380012468,
-0.0015552312,
0.0084682405,
0.0359772556,
-0.0144265927,
0.066773437,
0.0567865893,
0.0221690834,
-0.0140837813,
0.0005218204,
0.0117403753,
0.0158612262,
0.0170437898,
0.0154953413,
-0.0051410771,
0.0462963469,
0.0348919928,
-0.0378925428,
0.020194605,
0.0338696353,
-0.0295750983,
-0.0120289056,
0.0118540609,
-0.016396828,
-0.0333652012,
-0.0454525724,
0.0628773049,
0.0316473693,
-0.0143574737,
-0.01788662,
-0.0107107637,
0.0032067825,
-0.000149169,
-0.059089236,
0.0451353863,
0.0206997972,
0.0173853058,
0.0503055938,
-0.0438520052,
-0.010599372,
-0.0069466373,
0.0230670422,
0.0486898273,
0.0316180065,
-0.0270024501,
-0.0382029526,
0.0233005434,
-0.0182862114,
-0.0621545576,
-0.0039882129,
0.0412953384,
-0.0399246216,
0.0351127163,
-0.0737574324,
-0.0046372255,
0.0321539827,
-0.0095699579,
0.1083704606,
0.0552806742,
-0.0159591567,
0.0127134332,
0.005205065,
0.0585807711,
0.0293091554,
0.0222102776,
-0.0300020315,
0.0321438424,
-0.0430453271,
0.0203057751,
-0.0386695489,
-0.0097617144,
-0.0431265309,
0.0159149226,
-0.0262872763,
0.0446096361,
-0.0164211765,
-0.0059636342,
0.0356822982,
-0.0320085175,
-0.0219356287,
0.0229934007,
-0.0170067064,
0.0189490356,
-0.0356544293,
0.0107109174,
-0.0083252685,
-0.0777366161,
0.0166868269,
0.0181890354,
0.0016366327,
-0.0065551754,
0.0185570344,
0.0283411909,
-0.0137759438,
-0.0180850793,
-0.0615314581,
-0.0233064964,
0.0154260518,
-0.0733768642,
0.0175536871,
-0.0878457129,
0.0113583971,
0.0225195028,
0.0066622687,
-0.0155002689,
0.004590638,
0.0310573354,
0.0047129276,
0.0014356098,
0.0057876576,
0.0299461819,
-0.0015462872,
0.0005457233,
0.0259314049,
0.0675703809,
0.0255374592,
-0.0138553716,
0.0383981429,
-0.0369479209,
-0.0041303192,
0.0624197088,
0.0075119021,
0.0218352936,
-0.0118652806,
0.0093489233,
-0.0001967424,
0.0033256984,
0.0256498642,
0.0344470926,
-0.0016528118,
0.0153647838,
0.0436738096,
0.0206760783,
-0.0030307404,
-0.0004307754,
0.0923951715,
0.0575025231,
0.0340676978,
0.0089391768,
-0.0528688431,
0.0327414386,
-0.0093770046,
0.014079202,
-0.0212001652,
0.0502502099,
-0.019038165,
-0.0433544107,
-0.0042553577,
0.0082850158,
-0.0080316784,
0.018448567,
0.0291017722,
-0.0002326223,
-0.0436898433,
0.0152908899,
0.0521055833,
-0.0504360683,
0.0118061006,
-0.0402783379,
0.0408012457,
0.0863840654,
0.0442564823,
-0.0013040891,
-0.0389162786,
-0.0000920633,
0.0598675013,
0.0094898166,
0.0406805165,
-0.041608844,
0.0056121559,
-0.0713823959,
-0.01692071,
-0.0173437204,
0.0114249298,
-0.0059882062,
0.0550469682,
-0.0253851358,
-0.0176373422,
0.0037998888,
-0.0574449971,
0.0445508249,
-0.0409790576,
-0.0550966151,
-0.0592838079,
0.004917813,
0.0095742093,
0.0347875133,
-0.009948615,
-0.0062929345,
0.0435017906,
0.0186995007,
0.0613765605,
-0.0253613591,
-0.0587249361,
-0.0256741587,
0.029186694,
0.0177212004,
-0.0533484705,
0.0201030467,
-0.0232524779,
-0.0194166154,
0.0028479761,
-0.0393937491,
0.0351301953,
-0.0186435096,
0.0409681238,
-0.0344336182,
-0.0132928798,
-0.0317766517,
0.0087326718,
-0.0193319563,
0.0232531559,
0.0791169107,
0.0254521165,
-0.0214635953,
-0.0182903036,
-0.0223854762,
-0.0115757771,
-0.0258575585,
0.0203606598,
-0.027676899,
0.0694323033,
-0.0612084605,
-0.0201855619,
-0.0764444098,
0.0179767963,
-0.0319063179,
0.0155716268,
0.0245660227,
0.0036774962,
-0.0310487878,
0.0089418739,
-0.0089835143,
-0.0236176345,
0.0069307727,
0.0173003394,
-0.0122884242,
-0.0120195607,
-0.0591414571,
-0.0267676041,
-0.0228912346,
-0.0122126658,
-0.0097888885,
-0.000901379,
0.0225500204,
-0.0691907704,
0.0328892469,
-0.0079121273,
0.0242753047,
0.0209315065,
-0.0683585703,
0.0286838487,
-0.011304521,
0.0731914788,
0.0503433123,
-0.0385587998,
0.0352835506,
0.0584984273,
-0.0436629616,
-0.0776470155,
0.0072751776,
-0.0218350291,
-0.0306802429,
-0.0518831983,
-0.0658876747,
-0.040396791,
0.0832121894,
0.0153833162,
-0.0073355888,
-0.0414643399,
-0.0314198919,
-0.048494231,
-0.0272972379,
-0.0016248449,
0.0161093585,
-0.0323215649,
-0.0039795684,
-0.0192709249,
-0.0766247511,
0.0825814009,
-0.0490987189,
-0.0249664262,
-0.0687644929,
-0.0157875754,
-0.0158687159,
0.0175469965,
-0.0002709446,
0.0076553226,
-0.0079482906,
-0.0160650369,
-0.0425699353,
0.0429833643,
0.0143444957,
-0.0150739234,
0.0280452482,
-0.0867785439,
-0.0275086053,
0.0100042922,
0.0212432425,
-0.0389865339,
0.0164625011,
0.0050143753,
0.006666935,
0.0555386469,
-0.0406614728,
-0.0033983297,
-0.0229085963,
0.0371923223,
0.0360309407,
-0.0225993562,
0.0134653207,
-0.0432053506,
-0.031189939,
0.0490424521,
-0.021617027,
-0.021789141,
-0.0669592172,
0.0249444135,
0.0400236696,
0.0528405234,
-0.0210568979,
0.0079814279,
0.0265617333,
0.0785134733,
-0.0342445113,
0.0092048207,
0.0725340098,
0.1018686742,
-0.0895258635,
-0.012787641,
0.1175452843,
0.0456687212,
-0.0516163334,
0.0179525912,
-0.0246021394,
0.0349960215,
0.0288565047,
0.0301546995,
-0.066376403,
-0.0175209716,
0.0054173223,
0.0368688814,
-0.0112265134,
-0.0022223815,
-0.0108354446,
-0.0972355008,
0.0587321334,
0.0215194207,
-0.0353027508,
-0.02622246,
-0.0529438853,
0.0124717569,
0.027230395,
0.0262245834,
0.0235195663,
-0.0600821301,
-0.0017036337,
0.0219381899,
-0.016279541,
-0.0729100928,
0.0361893959,
-0.0389233194,
0.1037692279,
0.0337088332,
-0.0051970351,
0.0176563505,
-0.0110208029,
0.0204765499,
-0.0141571527,
-0.01584992,
-0.0348969102,
0.0244431514,
0.0076260851,
-0.0033170076,
-0.0259396378,
0.051193662,
-0.0219658315,
-0.0022345395,
0.0099474946,
0.0998457968,
-0.0104458733,
0.0173739828,
-0.0309062283,
-0.0044937823,
0.0301819947,
0.0581111833,
0.0497936532,
-0.0658918098,
-0.0028771448,
-0.0558996536,
-0.0442413799,
-0.0594383739,
-0.0200594869,
0.0481239818,
-0.0657745451,
-0.0042465739,
-0.0369321108,
-0.0567623377,
0.0950989872,
-0.0197961126,
0.0210328717,
-0.0048146299,
0.0248629581,
-0.0314626023,
-0.0376421399,
0.0391626433,
-0.0320809446,
0.0403490998,
-0.1189005673,
-0.0987332091,
-0.0064688548,
-0.0091534285,
0.005450238,
0.0276927855,
-0.0444815308,
-0.0757100359,
0.025504563,
0.0577579848,
0.0111748278,
0.0374482907,
0.0212801304,
-0.0387124941,
-0.001365418,
-0.0185129475,
-0.0411972366,
0.0077906149,
0.0199527033,
-0.0220838655,
0.006680429,
0.017465163,
-0.0160977244,
0.0286530033,
0.0046996456,
0.0407019928,
-0.0155821992,
-0.0019416701,
0.0139417397,
0.0141961267,
-0.001683665,
-0.0230333526,
0.0047995341,
-0.0738310516,
0.0208995789,
-0.034902446,
-0.0000050008,
-0.0419438072,
0.0010296211,
0.0076372805,
-0.0102984067,
-0.0005827009,
-0.0133554777,
-0.020409843,
0.0366519056,
-0.0182062443,
0.0802363679,
-0.0006938606,
0.0270686969,
0.0572250001,
0.02386236,
-0.0197373778,
0.0057279286,
-0.0139027163,
0.0282816216,
0.0231982172,
0.0807085708,
-0.0241678152,
-0.0037931569,
-0.0119026843,
0.0092974268,
-0.0022198737,
-0.0194237791,
-0.0348510556,
0.0164851155,
0.042294275,
-0.0229393281,
0.060440354,
-0.0253782887,
0.0070841964,
-0.0185221676,
0.0479655378,
-0.0234577823,
-0.041350849,
0.0019349208,
0.0364596844,
0.0090008331,
-0.0192974191,
0.0534683131,
0.0109893074,
0.0525119714,
-0.0076723662,
0.0121581284,
-0.0260649584,
-0.0227718502,
0.0396794789,
0.0141320778,
-0.0423645712,
0.0175516289,
-0.0263377335,
-0.0510220528,
-0.0610564053,
0.035899926,
-0.0216929298,
-0.0314015783,
0.044320073,
0.0262624417,
-0.0340959132,
-0.0203382485,
-0.0567236245,
0.0134364525,
-0.0163669493,
-0.0592367351,
-0.0175746307,
-6.326238028e-33,
-0.0311332755,
-0.0136776138,
0.0477293096,
-0.0177469049,
0.0081773167,
-0.0073598358,
-0.038979996,
0.004841147,
0.004664355,
0.0001858655,
0.0127186952,
-0.0096853664,
0.0142250201,
0.0362038836,
0.0409447588,
0.0183876231,
0.045257546,
-0.0142095275,
-0.0102893384,
0.0466231816,
0.0164501481,
-0.0009730929,
0.0741013736,
-0.030036021,
0.0315008871,
-0.0203125719,
0.0189191699,
0.0039723516,
-0.043677818,
0.0712150335,
0.0115103656,
0.0437801965,
0.0092602251,
-0.0242289323,
-0.0343995392,
0.0160157736,
-0.0426651277,
-0.052962184,
0.0434740745,
0.0179304853,
-0.0534951463,
-0.0609454364,
-0.012728882,
-0.0217775758,
-0.0268105455,
-0.0124505507,
0.0199918114,
0.0027487117,
0.0221841726,
0.0482709371,
-0.0882371739,
0.0120553458,
-0.0033984713,
-0.0416356102,
0.0034199636,
0.0523647927,
0.0118673909,
-0.0279470794,
-0.0349190794,
0.0573627166,
0.054036852,
0.0746480003,
0.0884835199,
0.0018781071,
0.0021886982,
0.0257425401,
0.0222278889,
-0.0111677321,
0.0255707875,
0.0388780907,
0.0418132134,
0.0450325534,
0.0190915279,
-0.0126036592,
-0.0024794845,
0.0025453852,
-0.0146310776,
0.0048639523,
0.0436459482,
0.0113776233,
0.009898752,
-0.0094689075,
-0.0487820841,
-0.0223705787,
-0.0158366822,
-0.0018846655,
-0.0122078825,
-0.0358344615,
0.0507580452,
-0.0082373926,
-0.0362064503,
-0.0180464908,
0.0502237603,
-0.0118664047,
-0.036537461,
-0.0035493493,
-0.0189743116,
0.0437857956,
-0.006392959,
0.0333061144,
-0.08455275,
-0.0538303293,
0.0212339982,
-0.0763487592,
0.019519601,
0.0310257506,
0.0049366443,
0.0396888889,
-0.0313864909,
0.0118637094,
-0.050142888,
0.0483763739,
0.0038188633,
0.0036484448,
0.0126490584,
0.0067465375,
-0.0178220179,
0.0591219142,
0.0212717075,
-0.0153431427,
-0.0439592227,
-0.0323628448,
-0.011891461,
0.025766911,
-0.0212829467,
0.0101590157,
-0.0894808993,
0.0128495246,
0.0123468069,
-0.0320416354,
0.0002285733,
-0.006206491,
2.731e-7,
0.0152767589,
0.0669861734,
0.0085900091,
0.0506436229,
0.0019128767,
-0.0105625819,
-0.0233052261,
-0.0107194083,
0.0343770273,
0.0101904925,
-0.0227894038,
0.0307185091,
0.0349136405,
0.0281696618,
-0.0654332265,
-0.0047801286,
-0.0099089695,
0.0145369796,
-0.0739289597,
0.0263310112,
0.0166669842,
0.0662901774,
0.0050951364,
0.006651991,
-0.0109338025,
0.0227774438,
-0.020004876,
-0.0247919522,
-0.0055320901,
0.0687450096,
-0.0055057174,
-0.0139522338,
0.013557151,
-0.0045597055,
-0.0326012745,
0.0016336729,
-0.0537301935,
0.0808204189,
-0.0008553452,
0.0007617312,
0.0475588441,
-0.0346750841,
-0.0379417576,
-0.0478047878,
0.0417802818,
-0.0359670334,
0.0129676973,
0.0152732944,
-0.0041547702,
-0.004000131,
-0.0228412822,
-0.0279869139,
-0.0007833029,
0.0239591599,
0.0149477972,
-0.047052756,
-0.0202010013,
-0.0072941957,
-0.0098614004,
0.0137820942,
-0.0172881261,
-0.0882791132,
-0.0472635999,
-0.0161630381,
-0.0283919796,
-0.0538533628,
-0.0018899698,
2.816936525e-34,
0.0212487821,
-0.014016903,
0.0570166372,
0.0445019081,
0.0160940439,
-0.0234028269,
-0.0310426001,
0.0405254923,
0.0061230976,
-0.0720733255,
-0.0474318378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03043v1 | SIDU-TXT: An XAI Algorithm for NLP with a Holistic Assessment Approach | 2024-02-05T14:29:54 | 2024-02-05T14:29:54 | Mohammad N. S. Jahromi, Satya. M. Muddamsetty, Asta Sofie Stage Jarlner, Anna Murphy Høgenhaug, Thomas Gammeltoft-Hansen, Thomas B. Moeslund | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Explainable AI (XAI) aids in deciphering 'black-box' models. While several
methods have been proposed and evaluated primarily in the image domain, the
exploration of explainability in the text domain remains a growing research
area. In this paper, we delve into the applicability of XAI methods for the
text domain. In this context, the 'Similarity Difference and Uniqueness' (SIDU)
XAI method, recognized for its superior capability in localizing entire salient
regions in image-based classification is extended to textual data. The extended
method, SIDU-TXT, utilizes feature activation maps from 'black-box' models to
generate heatmaps at a granular, word-based level, thereby providing
explanations that highlight contextually significant textual elements crucial
for model predictions. Given the absence of a unified standard for assessing
XAI methods, this study applies a holistic three-tiered comprehensive
evaluation framework: Functionally-Grounded, Human-Grounded and
Application-Grounded, to assess the effectiveness of the proposed SIDU-TXT
across various experiments. We find that, in sentiment analysis task of a movie
review dataset, SIDU-TXT excels in both functionally and human-grounded
evaluations, demonstrating superior performance through quantitative and
qualitative analyses compared to benchmarks like Grad-CAM and LIME. In the
application-grounded evaluation within the sensitive and complex legal domain
of asylum decision-making, SIDU-TXT and Grad-CAM demonstrate comparable
performances, each with its own set of strengths and weaknesses. However, both
methods fall short of entirely fulfilling the sophisticated criteria of expert
expectations, highlighting the imperative need for additional research in XAI
methods suitable for such domains. | [
0.0417221449,
0.0210126769,
-0.0051442618,
0.0282501522,
-0.022580266,
0.0338951349,
0.0216167048,
0.0081954878,
0.0238579325,
-0.0404630639,
-0.0401726104,
-0.0037836258,
0.0197177436,
0.0295933131,
-0.046103619,
-0.0416213796,
-0.0183936413,
0.0223135706,
0.0206207428,
0.0255233292,
0.0075242175,
0.0054521523,
0.0271382164,
0.0479717888,
-0.0144050634,
-0.0068274662,
-0.0179986656,
-0.0396556519,
0.0283067729,
-0.0130000226,
-0.028452199,
0.0438193195,
0.0232598763,
-0.0206158105,
0.0000023232,
-0.0064591435,
-0.0138601027,
-0.0045728846,
0.0089736069,
0.0164728872,
0.0212398041,
-0.0364193767,
0.047706753,
0.0209133271,
-0.0121165542,
0.0027858606,
0.0523221493,
0.1041071936,
0.0597617663,
0.0220410656,
-0.0434258133,
-0.0488137752,
-0.0133325607,
-0.0045442665,
-0.0103367018,
-0.0454021059,
-0.0309310704,
-0.0020318509,
-0.0127393901,
0.003939481,
-0.0062653823,
0.043202363,
0.0327321887,
-0.0253337827,
0.03052436,
0.0245856084,
-0.0059477189,
0.0039056207,
-0.0117193004,
0.0737627596,
-0.0017949158,
-0.0235406309,
-0.0344036445,
-0.0214132238,
-0.0171675961,
0.0147684719,
-0.0402997844,
-0.0117633529,
0.03069501,
0.0636311546,
-0.0019262134,
0.0470152572,
0.0302436408,
0.0419346541,
0.012260667,
0.0750037581,
-0.033837568,
-0.0447065607,
0.0090951398,
0.0460563749,
-0.0036862942,
-0.0147294197,
0.0136392862,
0.0552983731,
0.0164144821,
0.032841742,
0.0358812846,
-0.0005283849,
0.0030790947,
-0.0859678164,
0.0727409646,
0.0024490226,
-0.0497755781,
0.0567879267,
-0.0136417169,
0.0506954156,
0.0253256038,
0.0008138555,
0.0078089577,
0.0008794345,
-0.1094537005,
-0.0242441129,
0.0168344956,
0.0087530632,
-0.0251625367,
-0.0184053797,
-0.0279104598,
-0.0260048527,
-0.0617295168,
0.0075001414,
0.0100634908,
0.046688959,
0.0078059477,
0.0220507476,
-0.0406752788,
-0.0110177882,
-0.0719347745,
0.0506710336,
-0.0312474854,
-0.0124137383,
0.0092108632,
0.0432226323,
0.0114126299,
-0.0025026184,
0.0036551396,
0.0380157754,
-0.0009387677,
-0.0437733456,
-0.0437780991,
-0.0585192181,
-0.0277662612,
-0.0493959188,
0.0186571404,
-0.0279116482,
-0.0074788453,
-0.0273953453,
-0.0071858037,
-0.0207681116,
-0.0030187112,
-0.0085334433,
-0.0399340838,
0.1226252392,
0.0061062397,
-0.0182627644,
-0.0064666397,
0.0232119784,
-0.0047671963,
0.030170653,
-0.0012452315,
0.0540058501,
0.047585655,
-0.0106960591,
0.0756343529,
-0.0492361747,
0.0167486258,
0.0176080093,
-0.0363308601,
0.0085872542,
-0.0985396206,
0.006842881,
0.0004861519,
-0.0162483379,
0.0095465658,
0.0162008144,
0.0164037868,
0.0876655802,
-0.0238421597,
0.0236292817,
0.02879728,
-0.0075180242,
-0.0206735507,
0.0251004696,
-0.0199181493,
0.04924291,
0.0189710464,
-0.0101907086,
-0.0062590423,
-0.0205525625,
-0.0359176584,
-0.0694409758,
-0.0276872367,
-0.0289712436,
0.0210420545,
-0.028684916,
0.0324028432,
0.0162729863,
-0.032002151,
0.01339876,
0.0236798916,
-0.0407332852,
-0.0297957137,
-0.0615083687,
0.0246638637,
0.0939283818,
0.0290321987,
-0.0192884877,
0.0030495024,
-0.0069833775,
0.0115321353,
0.0373300426,
-0.0144930128,
0.0264358297,
0.0105681354,
-0.0493329056,
-0.0450172871,
-0.0447772481,
0.0196818896,
0.0198730994,
-0.015389015,
-0.020797886,
0.0140634989,
-0.0280424189,
-0.0455204621,
0.0342819206,
0.008806698,
-0.0344794765,
-0.0000265185,
0.0280703288,
0.0432783253,
0.0234754644,
0.0019041019,
-0.0186767559,
0.0055110953,
-0.0102608548,
-0.038464915,
0.0637976974,
0.0082279034,
0.0096601434,
-0.0174375009,
-0.0720049962,
-0.0034933318,
0.0708165243,
-0.0494556464,
-0.0255337134,
0.0237193517,
0.0093266331,
0.0103243319,
-0.051516857,
-0.0087195663,
-0.0200361293,
0.0119326757,
-0.0220439639,
0.0815696046,
-0.0128032435,
-0.0155570572,
-0.0154952984,
-0.00106908,
0.0364033841,
0.0195704084,
0.0082728676,
-0.0107918913,
0.0160625707,
0.0068399333,
-0.0279555228,
0.0073230993,
0.0089219492,
-0.0115479873,
-0.1027446464,
-0.0201113578,
-0.0210003573,
-0.0034240915,
0.0450012758,
-0.0506228656,
0.0243317224,
-0.0055818907,
-0.0216898881,
-0.0256461073,
-0.0094468612,
-0.0183594935,
0.0615434945,
0.0025739709,
0.0135547761,
-0.0442465916,
0.0078023523,
-0.0325389616,
0.0693575218,
0.0339597091,
-0.0077310721,
-0.0215679109,
0.0706653595,
-0.0141691798,
0.0000526954,
0.0054691043,
-0.0369535089,
0.0036203137,
0.0589565262,
-0.0537252761,
0.0126107233,
-0.0106581189,
0.0939316154,
0.0123395287,
0.0365244597,
-0.0075829793,
-0.0183059182,
-0.0314438939,
0.0317275338,
0.0098210862,
-0.045301199,
0.0059405682,
0.0431433134,
0.0007980638,
0.0009994425,
-0.0656385347,
0.0071950494,
-0.0211780537,
-0.0204638056,
-0.0510531887,
-0.0363838561,
0.0073278379,
0.0440876074,
-0.0463886373,
-0.0682014227,
0.0470266119,
-0.0418549664,
0.0654830635,
-0.0524082929,
-0.029990064,
-0.0616154708,
0.0882247314,
-0.0310396962,
0.001317264,
-0.0195023809,
-0.0054718642,
0.0250916928,
-0.0562345162,
-0.006240143,
0.0234867819,
0.0244558062,
-0.0013586464,
0.0116493395,
0.0332063548,
-0.0156377014,
0.0106663052,
-0.0362102427,
-0.0214035064,
0.0093678189,
0.032062497,
-0.0148697915,
0.0101719173,
0.0423660241,
-0.0028810333,
-0.0050227614,
-0.0039257552,
-0.022102043,
-0.0055246148,
0.0219208039,
0.034378171,
-0.0013506435,
0.0327568352,
-0.0110433893,
0.0168020241,
0.0198733155,
-0.0035509639,
0.0075366856,
-0.0409623496,
0.0319876932,
-0.0231581908,
-0.015972184,
-0.0097910753,
-0.0377011709,
0.0590057634,
-0.0576109439,
-0.0300273113,
0.0906812027,
0.0457560159,
-0.0547914766,
0.0139698982,
0.0076474608,
-0.0085909059,
0.0118456082,
-0.0113017065,
-0.0027817995,
-0.036430914,
-0.0259166397,
0.0362797156,
-0.0429075919,
0.0085114948,
0.0201582871,
-0.0761730671,
0.0621550567,
-0.0385122709,
-0.0614243932,
-0.0448522829,
-0.0466487743,
0.0010344603,
-0.0124390824,
-0.0133343404,
-0.0648374036,
0.0282897409,
0.0097889025,
0.0005345037,
-0.0183198862,
-0.033626046,
0.0536012836,
-0.0379922763,
0.0080632214,
0.0535419248,
0.0627046973,
-0.0082380986,
-0.0278419107,
-0.0073800799,
0.0183230266,
0.0681793094,
0.0105775362,
0.0708787963,
0.0034073342,
-0.0190741196,
-0.0438090973,
0.0377939828,
-0.0528391115,
-0.0236321967,
-0.0260864384,
0.0924848914,
-0.0621625707,
-0.0053779627,
-0.0228291992,
0.0191341192,
0.0025972496,
0.0665056556,
0.0519202799,
-0.0428268835,
-0.0616653636,
-0.0050882488,
0.0189831294,
-0.0714715049,
-0.0420062318,
0.0062596281,
-0.009733866,
-0.0325240977,
-0.0344563685,
-0.0730089322,
-0.0135079632,
0.0437323079,
0.0075846184,
0.0053935624,
-0.0097637679,
-0.0257196911,
-0.0111084189,
0.0583678707,
0.0230654459,
-0.0050067622,
0.0218996629,
-0.0072605726,
0.029911086,
-0.0223025307,
-0.0328036025,
-0.010211952,
-0.0106905317,
0.0024078467,
-0.0299496651,
0.01799988,
0.0201566555,
0.0128800487,
0.0138875674,
-0.0610925406,
0.0306837931,
0.0244182032,
0.0132512562,
-0.0207715295,
0.0261987727,
0.0064632683,
0.0251736734,
0.0324602947,
0.0161998831,
0.0494942144,
0.0279103499,
-0.0355169401,
-0.0095963273,
0.0148228211,
-0.0028765434,
-0.035573706,
0.0371078104,
-0.0077726943,
-0.0523968488,
-0.047081247,
-0.0259472243,
0.0159684233,
-0.0023453201,
-0.0419101678,
0.0010447433,
0.0210279245,
0.0181533843,
-0.0482007265,
-0.0137513382,
-0.0395265855,
0.0068147294,
-0.0448255241,
0.0507592633,
0.0397610217,
0.0085691549,
-0.0953330696,
0.0337383971,
-0.0077318121,
0.0138523113,
-0.0302280057,
0.0215343926,
0.0278846305,
0.0797099397,
0.0152269499,
0.0277421325,
-0.0316357575,
0.0402740426,
-0.045811329,
-0.0071658026,
-0.0262565855,
-0.0042363205,
0.0233334433,
-0.0432530381,
-0.0034190277,
-0.022211995,
-0.0163706876,
0.0507679209,
0.0406944677,
0.0131299617,
-0.0281985775,
-0.0089723766,
0.0156533048,
-0.0302880425,
0.025788499,
0.0413134061,
-0.0342357941,
0.0212133992,
0.0023731485,
-0.0666930601,
-0.0142037552,
-0.0041888654,
0.038874425,
0.0090863463,
0.0013965351,
0.0240946542,
-0.045972757,
-0.0584865473,
0.0203453191,
-0.0275159106,
-0.0183561426,
0.0138226524,
0.033974681,
0.0683790967,
0.0240905881,
0.0093821269,
-0.0536343418,
-0.0306413397,
-0.0030873753,
0.0109208487,
-0.0314218961,
-6.848098011e-33,
0.0093113035,
-0.0792158097,
-0.039959155,
-0.0247342903,
0.0250340495,
0.0304250997,
-0.0291786809,
0.0071879486,
-0.0154383453,
0.0571573563,
0.017034879,
0.0246229619,
0.0031309649,
0.0147400619,
0.0042617004,
-0.0441042297,
0.0063273665,
0.0166951064,
-0.0307134874,
0.0304021444,
0.0708853453,
0.0138113573,
0.059724763,
-0.1174273938,
0.0592452176,
0.0174381379,
-0.0260758568,
0.0019566235,
-0.0000571323,
0.0638829023,
-0.0302872211,
0.0424435921,
0.0535626598,
-0.0666979849,
0.0183529854,
0.0140219443,
-0.022159161,
-0.0171311051,
0.0211483892,
0.0221380945,
-0.0416659378,
-0.0139605673,
0.0299463328,
-0.0083057247,
-0.0246201325,
-0.0403046012,
0.051958181,
-0.014515819,
0.0367026664,
0.0032810525,
-0.0658203438,
0.0262124669,
-0.0418270119,
-0.0123637756,
0.0164464135,
0.0243959501,
-0.0260837786,
0.0735153779,
-0.0711058676,
-0.0306760184,
0.021984322,
-0.0216117539,
0.0621259324,
-0.0484744571,
-0.0008735454,
0.0624051206,
0.0304272268,
0.0157506745,
-0.0825365856,
-0.0264331494,
-0.0163954999,
0.0606317371,
0.0921294019,
0.032803461,
0.0395730622,
-0.0137466993,
-0.0546982363,
-0.0006713493,
-0.0377423167,
0.0119487289,
0.0715143308,
0.013336082,
-0.0641453639,
-0.0089658042,
-0.017181538,
-0.0337974392,
-0.0251782127,
-0.0322784595,
0.0229910742,
-0.0136617199,
-0.0404046737,
0.008767332,
0.0047303005,
-0.0586492643,
0.0553741008,
0.0046222378,
-0.0154014342,
0.0547351241,
0.0311797634,
-0.0292042159,
-0.0188526809,
-0.0228936113,
-0.0120550189,
0.0226011686,
0.0652624518,
-0.0170240924,
0.0688836202,
0.0178960394,
-0.0151216043,
-0.0064447415,
-0.0326068625,
-0.0116276182,
-0.0081053367,
0.0609196723,
-0.0138356369,
0.0312025845,
-0.0374889709,
0.0486106686,
0.034467455,
0.0623570643,
0.0273012333,
-0.048546724,
-0.0625977293,
-0.0361080542,
-0.018923562,
-0.0360082425,
-0.0105870422,
-0.0491036661,
0.021955438,
-0.0880104974,
-0.0104453322,
0.0446437262,
2.996e-7,
0.052927684,
0.031553749,
-0.0055239638,
-0.040697515,
0.0112440167,
0.0526609644,
0.0100602722,
0.0001427709,
-0.0265069474,
-0.0348576978,
0.0376654975,
0.0260097645,
0.0495794751,
0.0133310249,
-0.0365052782,
-0.0162483379,
-0.0691024885,
-0.0248687118,
-0.0446773432,
0.0229861941,
0.0668203384,
0.1035868973,
0.0194599032,
-0.0177283399,
0.0130406637,
-0.0216558184,
0.0313205309,
-0.0432467721,
0.0178282857,
-0.0005679289,
0.0424957611,
-0.0036814478,
-0.0264009312,
-0.0100620966,
-0.0096819317,
0.0172755048,
0.0293056928,
0.0170613825,
-0.0128099229,
-0.0604154319,
-0.0049692658,
0.0119984122,
0.0259918813,
-0.0740539655,
0.0754226446,
-0.0295618791,
-0.0779766515,
-0.0814167708,
-0.003155723,
0.0096222367,
0.0613464527,
0.0243239142,
0.0289233625,
0.0298247747,
-0.0197078381,
-0.0347911529,
-0.027259443,
-0.0930597708,
-0.025439227,
0.0072836145,
-0.002677833,
0.0683417544,
-0.0340589136,
-0.0109571191,
0.0578039028,
-0.0511115193,
-0.0039549251,
2.778960481e-34,
0.0143748,
-0.0166709162,
0.0115237152,
0.0082506714,
0.0513464138,
0.0481811762,
-0.0478837788,
-0.0194412805,
0.0310501754,
-0.0151043134,
0.0346452221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03038v1 | Automatic Combination of Sample Selection Strategies for Few-Shot Learning | 2024-02-05T14:23:43 | 2024-02-05T14:23:43 | Branislav Pecher, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova, Joaquin Vanschoren | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In few-shot learning, such as meta-learning, few-shot fine-tuning or
in-context learning, the limited number of samples used to train a model have a
significant impact on the overall success. Although a large number of sample
selection strategies exist, their impact on the performance of few-shot
learning is not extensively known, as most of them have been so far evaluated
in typical supervised settings only. In this paper, we thoroughly investigate
the impact of 20 sample selection strategies on the performance of 5 few-shot
learning approaches over 8 image and 6 text datasets. In addition, we propose a
new method for automatic combination of sample selection strategies (ACSESS)
that leverages the strengths and complementary information of the individual
strategies. The experimental results show that our method consistently
outperforms the individual selection strategies, as well as the recently
proposed method for selecting support examples for in-context learning. We also
show a strong modality, dataset and approach dependence for the majority of
strategies as well as their dependence on the number of shots - demonstrating
that the sample selection strategies play a significant role for lower number
of shots, but regresses to random selection at higher number of shots. | [
0.0110366577,
0.0025905494,
-0.0122807072,
-0.0130863218,
-0.024585465,
0.027759688,
0.0592714883,
0.0295042079,
-0.0714130923,
-0.0638025776,
-0.0337368213,
0.0432701297,
0.0042373645,
-0.0475744866,
0.0115711624,
-0.0529609695,
0.0179271698,
0.024209613,
-0.0014826352,
0.0147055052,
-0.0145690758,
0.0088558272,
0.0226066392,
0.0148092369,
0.04296913,
0.0167055503,
0.0046910094,
0.0263734106,
0.0481253564,
-0.037527658,
0.0156042296,
0.0326704085,
0.0060329679,
0.0021068533,
0.0000021536,
-0.0384887755,
-0.0070257308,
0.0058867857,
-0.0372040905,
-0.034000475,
0.0231054537,
-0.0265564118,
0.0240825266,
-0.0266945325,
-0.0141157657,
-0.0464446023,
0.0358612016,
0.0130757513,
0.0044183834,
0.0327490754,
-0.034365844,
-0.0219911505,
-0.0589682125,
-0.0343703032,
0.0405349806,
-0.0410036445,
0.0451779626,
-0.0571058579,
0.0012585453,
0.0166643523,
-0.0184632875,
0.0016543922,
-0.0400665663,
0.0339899175,
0.0093275104,
0.0297209453,
-0.0922236368,
0.0001608691,
-0.0042113983,
0.0771918446,
-0.0473161489,
-0.0132808043,
-0.0021533601,
-0.0535803363,
-0.0135394596,
0.0266947411,
-0.0495244414,
-0.0392680503,
-0.0209232755,
0.0449488834,
-0.0612544566,
0.0205058884,
0.0085118376,
0.0150366081,
-0.0227547884,
-0.0589768887,
-0.010907365,
-0.0329174995,
0.0352698565,
0.0118651725,
-0.0320479311,
-0.0046152431,
-0.0363376178,
0.0015204587,
-0.0177979469,
-0.0127516342,
-0.0275835767,
-0.0543972552,
0.0164782424,
0.0060867947,
0.1074953079,
0.0082696965,
-0.0113880876,
0.0879063159,
0.0040649991,
-0.0476735607,
0.047058858,
0.034411855,
-0.0040929248,
0.0136393839,
-0.061704386,
0.0563387871,
-0.0252528302,
0.0456413031,
-0.0115726413,
0.0017828598,
-0.0543417409,
-0.0113999443,
0.0297639389,
0.005269228,
-0.0109656397,
-0.0308308788,
-0.0153503092,
0.0160231162,
0.0512000844,
0.0320264064,
-0.0598770678,
0.0261175297,
-0.0147056077,
-0.0367645994,
-0.0163110346,
0.005504597,
0.0361932106,
-0.054764796,
0.0374425426,
0.0381799005,
0.033620026,
-0.0697580278,
-0.0345678069,
0.0150945596,
-0.0264754109,
-0.0520912558,
0.0020838806,
-0.0226388723,
0.0114443721,
-0.0175980758,
0.0098164435,
0.031748645,
-0.0304933526,
0.0203061309,
-0.0451693833,
0.0704080537,
-0.0398445055,
-0.0062259971,
-0.0063308226,
-0.0092823906,
-0.0130818756,
0.0987835154,
0.0080996957,
0.0191189125,
0.0131816342,
0.002257121,
0.0460866727,
-0.0071956394,
0.0401242562,
0.0170697812,
-0.02211334,
-0.0172708426,
-0.0022990734,
-0.0058540767,
-0.0239467714,
-0.0422851481,
-0.0559464842,
-0.0158886611,
0.0158098005,
0.021655554,
0.0307351351,
-0.0260527655,
0.0047901636,
-0.0172452684,
0.0506283753,
-0.0203536563,
-0.0228706375,
0.0648335814,
-0.0374676324,
-0.0179142319,
-0.0095117632,
0.0289280303,
-0.0590515248,
-0.0157563183,
0.014724805,
-0.0059522982,
-0.0619939044,
0.0284258313,
0.0658171624,
0.0173273794,
0.0006264165,
-0.0178060587,
0.0634604692,
0.0017410781,
-0.0424865372,
-0.008317573,
0.000655016,
0.0510173999,
0.0264767483,
-0.0478228256,
-0.0134307249,
-0.0648584142,
0.0727894083,
-0.0166964475,
0.0163788069,
-0.0062688543,
0.0630173758,
-0.0475509167,
-0.0540976822,
-0.014457576,
-0.0026031837,
0.0009461957,
-0.0115350708,
0.024243176,
-0.0198004413,
-0.0347570069,
0.0484178625,
0.0453335755,
0.005719135,
-0.0195902381,
0.0341191813,
0.0408793502,
0.0093015591,
-0.0354766436,
-0.0225326158,
-0.0332190804,
0.0088572232,
-0.0166147631,
0.0452261418,
0.0172666218,
-0.0117606716,
-0.0886722654,
-0.0098761721,
-0.0105535295,
-0.0124323554,
-0.0307456888,
-0.0751016662,
-0.0053383778,
-0.0158842653,
0.0158583242,
-0.0136190774,
-0.0323228836,
-0.0142608257,
-0.0384823754,
0.0146396356,
-0.0544046499,
0.0510392487,
0.0155197838,
-0.0008284864,
0.0473327562,
-0.037936382,
0.0478649735,
-0.0080727376,
-0.016107779,
0.0013061971,
-0.0091335298,
0.0171537045,
0.0138890063,
0.0196088105,
-0.036258027,
0.0145005444,
-0.0563525185,
-0.0221665464,
-0.0214830097,
-0.0021715423,
-0.0145631451,
0.0045568813,
-0.0272610672,
-0.0243248604,
0.0285005439,
0.0480614603,
-0.0634607896,
0.0198427513,
0.0248082951,
0.0168273989,
0.0449747816,
-0.0193471368,
-0.012802558,
0.0354119055,
0.0816445798,
-0.0050911191,
-0.01026667,
0.0165101141,
0.0052803052,
-0.0106707076,
-0.0339399241,
-0.0164401624,
-0.0168312043,
-0.0251605809,
-0.0321053229,
-0.0662008375,
0.042660404,
-0.0141757783,
-0.0035628323,
0.0080394074,
0.0287735723,
-0.0341466516,
0.0006384909,
-0.0134922536,
0.019953277,
-0.0200339798,
0.022081323,
-0.0135555798,
0.0257802196,
0.0015224002,
0.0169419721,
-0.0258688033,
0.0730976686,
0.0264063478,
-0.01053767,
-0.0455471128,
0.0561835915,
0.0035340502,
0.0079946015,
-0.032383386,
-0.018442817,
0.0602009222,
0.0605841652,
0.0009650979,
-0.0316431299,
0.0089820456,
-0.0015260646,
-0.0085400864,
-0.0236587189,
0.0168157518,
0.0395193808,
0.0237283092,
-0.0472489037,
-0.0925970823,
0.0529790036,
0.0091183661,
0.0073132138,
0.0045316606,
0.0167379845,
-0.0368097685,
-0.0439003147,
-0.0220686402,
-0.0425267816,
-0.0250779986,
0.0140381912,
-0.0863102227,
0.0281992815,
-0.048866801,
-0.0232668538,
0.0324559696,
0.0400395878,
-0.0166437831,
-0.0415252857,
0.0131225102,
0.0351436548,
0.0319469757,
-0.0502824187,
-0.0343567841,
-0.0142562259,
0.0678686425,
0.0255741272,
0.0177942626,
0.0664700493,
-0.0336306877,
0.0190079994,
-0.008344057,
-0.0039423737,
-0.0152129354,
0.0373848714,
0.0097491704,
-0.0304881856,
-0.001086972,
0.0750057027,
0.0239036772,
-0.0489402004,
-0.0393058583,
0.022197485,
-0.0179890078,
0.0391350873,
0.0320095196,
-0.0436525904,
-0.0529255308,
-0.0058063129,
0.0309040602,
-0.0065150745,
-0.0073521123,
0.007224076,
-0.0699561909,
0.0730504915,
0.0168678984,
-0.0802151784,
0.0080520967,
-0.037021447,
0.0485606864,
-0.0261894464,
-0.0060322173,
-0.0085586766,
-0.0316847675,
-0.0171834026,
0.0179075077,
0.0291989855,
-0.1006235108,
0.0342989787,
-0.0256143436,
-0.023058923,
0.0516358316,
0.0425668806,
-0.002573827,
0.0198016502,
0.0290485304,
-0.0370509252,
0.0264400505,
-0.0463117212,
0.1091181114,
-0.0182465445,
0.0049127871,
0.0157964379,
0.0197653081,
0.0019896957,
-0.0309318081,
0.013328718,
0.0389120802,
-0.0144377463,
-0.0254992284,
-0.0106715225,
-0.0276862383,
0.0489154123,
0.015962135,
0.0467406996,
-0.0648004636,
-0.0214965418,
0.0232811738,
-0.0315353014,
-0.0664381906,
0.0222880356,
0.0380668901,
-0.0006251884,
-0.0209183972,
-0.0455896445,
-0.0158324838,
0.0535029732,
0.0693426132,
-0.0265164971,
0.0415619127,
-0.0412379988,
0.0258230194,
-0.0310146194,
-0.0244009439,
-0.0356903449,
0.0069123991,
0.020188842,
-0.0040549636,
0.0722143203,
-0.0350850783,
-0.0122870263,
-0.0325776003,
-0.0441822931,
-0.0233716667,
-0.0023863707,
0.0679664388,
0.0088173337,
0.0333114043,
0.0227149948,
-0.0594955906,
0.104826726,
0.0926736221,
0.0320355929,
0.0130860554,
0.045371715,
-0.0158611406,
-0.0378957763,
0.0220225789,
-0.0260929409,
0.0442555659,
0.0786572918,
-0.0383547321,
-0.0716824532,
0.0641918108,
0.0185618084,
-0.0334550254,
0.0518407077,
-0.0409443863,
-0.0405209027,
0.008521622,
0.0139953829,
0.0412957482,
-0.0100307781,
-0.0245940574,
-0.018780496,
-0.0226400234,
-0.0355304331,
-0.0169270821,
0.0001365329,
-0.0164055582,
0.0310768317,
-0.0271915905,
0.0325482823,
0.0072358912,
0.0530875251,
0.0058608055,
0.0476611592,
-0.0086931875,
0.0183335729,
0.0368578136,
0.0092051197,
-0.0340976566,
0.04519381,
0.0404816307,
0.0202420149,
-0.0594800971,
0.0147954645,
-0.0395379066,
0.0472021922,
-0.0295161307,
0.0155248893,
0.0381034203,
-0.0338800922,
-0.0146544417,
0.0309358221,
-0.0288391802,
-0.0310189296,
0.0308884326,
-0.0057675154,
0.0147833331,
-0.0202149544,
0.0274389721,
0.0025295659,
0.0149001945,
0.0785026997,
-0.0069445702,
0.028345244,
0.0289351922,
0.0229478404,
-0.0462112874,
0.0402936414,
0.0156819467,
0.0509373099,
0.0178181604,
0.0178358052,
-0.0617529601,
-0.0065629669,
0.0572576486,
-0.074464567,
-0.0102101946,
0.0362618566,
0.0441464074,
0.0162172187,
0.0246187001,
0.0138321379,
-0.0069279955,
-0.0149235129,
-0.0082376488,
0.0036640912,
0.0111917295,
-6.128018089e-33,
-0.0013727698,
-0.0100813732,
-0.0103061777,
-0.0125292912,
0.0281122979,
-0.0447752811,
-0.0558609106,
-0.0469955169,
-0.0415195227,
-0.0046773036,
-0.0208162554,
-0.0387938768,
0.0150758428,
0.0271770786,
0.019410789,
-0.0143942414,
0.0433824658,
-0.0141491788,
-0.0201691408,
-0.0084139397,
0.010870304,
0.049615562,
0.0333189778,
-0.0279461741,
-0.0664802939,
0.0352092572,
-0.033571735,
-0.0340534076,
0.0017345428,
0.0603654459,
0.0533836149,
0.0043645101,
0.0155913243,
-0.0073745381,
-0.0274507757,
-0.0052308086,
-0.0480610728,
-0.0754177421,
-0.0312445629,
0.0004242825,
0.0127831344,
-0.0113719124,
0.0108817769,
-0.0414357297,
0.0376144834,
-0.0542325601,
0.0468976684,
-0.0569315329,
-0.0704087764,
-0.0310736243,
-0.0381714962,
0.0247733723,
-0.016809037,
-0.010543758,
0.0436663739,
0.0280419197,
0.0001346466,
0.0435113199,
0.0030761051,
0.016776707,
0.0233466644,
0.00606034,
-0.0243351609,
0.0368400104,
0.0196580142,
0.0537485555,
0.0072425017,
0.0086258054,
0.0555143468,
-0.0131959375,
0.0335607491,
0.0460382737,
0.0140291937,
0.1174699664,
0.0771784708,
-0.0129206898,
-0.1103498936,
-0.00370771,
0.0046553961,
0.0240894221,
0.005170458,
0.0040785042,
-0.0331741571,
-0.0022395251,
-0.0265849717,
-0.0431653783,
-0.0302153509,
-0.0131568378,
0.030769242,
0.0607991517,
-0.0610508434,
0.0185438264,
0.0518371612,
-0.0194383133,
-0.0163906366,
0.037202511,
-0.0315298252,
0.0365671441,
0.0224870145,
-0.0842335522,
-0.0485933572,
-0.0389540233,
0.0457528234,
0.0406003334,
0.0388182439,
-0.011322354,
0.0965670794,
0.0238657743,
-0.0526844412,
-0.0124568045,
0.015895335,
-0.0065653552,
0.0316843055,
-0.0276172161,
-0.0114918584,
0.0289965589,
-0.0267385188,
0.0259694029,
-0.0005107244,
-0.0708732903,
0.0280286018,
0.010103506,
-0.0012836362,
0.0193853527,
0.015939571,
0.0075609908,
-0.0105434963,
-0.0419113412,
0.0547930859,
-0.0231174566,
0.0025507046,
0.027861746,
2.805e-7,
0.0032324647,
0.0424667597,
-0.0284565389,
-0.0527984761,
0.0257849675,
0.0222964305,
-0.0269274767,
-0.0171949677,
0.0090314886,
0.0135036865,
0.0463747978,
0.0138154421,
0.0528177172,
0.0357027054,
-0.0638265386,
0.0826274753,
0.0044634156,
0.0107008535,
-0.0208018254,
-0.0368168578,
0.0128157465,
0.0710847154,
0.0452158637,
-0.0191138051,
0.0261846147,
-0.0287966337,
0.0616138577,
-0.0349416174,
0.0411646441,
-0.0056362734,
-0.0799188539,
0.0326295011,
-0.0382880606,
0.0175153017,
-0.0343169682,
0.0099586053,
-0.0040990673,
0.0401291773,
-0.0240425244,
-0.0060389061,
-0.0081768846,
0.029963823,
0.0341980681,
0.0239842925,
0.0704470873,
-0.1259364933,
0.016874481,
-0.0424275883,
-0.0121038789,
-0.0225069299,
0.0357395858,
-0.0343858004,
0.0065353834,
0.0289987586,
0.0060335379,
0.0099784648,
-0.0429749414,
-0.0812271386,
-0.0084875338,
0.0372337997,
0.0110009378,
-0.0162265319,
-0.0076468154,
-0.0287780594,
0.0512221865,
-0.0520227216,
-0.0149768898,
1.98217666e-34,
0.0102602886,
-0.0373536013,
0.02030297,
0.0008590178,
-0.0809031352,
-0.0044199596,
-0.0453823581,
-0.0215758588,
0.0478591733,
-0.0162172262,
-0.0047506006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03009v1 | UniMem: Towards a Unified View of Long-Context Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T13:47:53 | 2024-02-05T13:47:53 | Junjie Fang, Likai Tang, Hongzhe Bi, Yujia Qin, Si Sun, Zhenyu Li, Haolun Li, Yongjian Li, Xin Cong, Yukun Yan, Xiaodong Shi, Sen Song, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Long-context processing is a critical ability that constrains the
applicability of large language models. Although there exist various methods
devoted to enhancing the long-context processing ability of large language
models (LLMs), they are developed in an isolated manner and lack systematic
analysis and integration of their strengths, hindering further developments. In
this paper, we introduce UniMem, a unified framework that reformulates existing
long-context methods from the view of memory augmentation of LLMs. UniMem is
characterized by four key dimensions: Memory Management, Memory Writing, Memory
Reading, and Memory Injection, providing a systematic theory for understanding
various long-context methods. We reformulate 16 existing methods based on
UniMem and analyze four representative methods: Transformer-XL, Memorizing
Transformer, RMT, and Longformer into equivalent UniMem forms to reveal their
design principles and strengths. Based on these analyses, we propose UniMix, an
innovative approach that integrates the strengths of these algorithms.
Experimental results show that UniMix achieves superior performance in handling
long contexts with significantly lower perplexity than baselines. | [
0.0243877862,
0.0560652316,
-0.0072641405,
0.0729473084,
-0.0512018017,
0.0168699268,
0.0056076446,
-0.0336013548,
-0.0296137575,
-0.0592147522,
-0.0287772492,
-0.0920859277,
0.0205098838,
-0.0071801119,
0.0131729636,
-0.029249642,
0.0256848093,
-0.0736549571,
-0.036852017,
-0.0040457929,
-0.0259524733,
-0.0179560557,
0.0189859122,
0.0148246633,
0.0042611877,
-0.0387552492,
-0.0193538815,
0.0011922783,
-0.0058869072,
-0.04130245,
-0.0154036032,
0.0293415636,
0.0159846358,
0.0366626084,
0.0000021211,
-0.0528819934,
-0.0317785181,
-0.0086815245,
-0.00420271,
0.057046786,
0.0556065477,
-0.0190146994,
-0.0392840207,
0.0262466576,
-0.0112834396,
-0.0034610953,
0.0525357611,
0.0225114487,
0.0239866991,
0.0606155135,
-0.0178346355,
-0.0665002912,
0.0283258855,
-0.030730322,
0.0089393137,
-0.060428381,
0.0598193035,
0.0102846678,
0.0058685127,
-0.0003671971,
-0.0526151992,
0.0326338857,
0.0221728459,
0.0181227196,
-0.0162484851,
0.0416198634,
0.0009834649,
0.0221232548,
-0.0065228594,
0.0422278121,
-0.0094572129,
-0.0056970632,
-0.0010948539,
0.0309007876,
-0.022939451,
-0.0238521434,
-0.0596043244,
0.0268710349,
0.0043906728,
0.0121170161,
0.0375050269,
-0.0037664173,
0.035853494,
0.0104080802,
-0.0976570174,
0.051732216,
0.0536238514,
-0.0329466462,
-0.0501308404,
-0.0286821909,
-0.0306598973,
-0.0535676852,
0.0146170044,
0.0652681813,
-0.0103068259,
0.0429089256,
-0.0239497591,
-0.0526850857,
0.0139710521,
-0.0358707421,
0.0142711839,
0.0414648503,
-0.0296969563,
0.080357641,
-0.0440120921,
0.0452440865,
-0.0514640249,
-0.0345138609,
-0.0385693759,
-0.0062471032,
-0.0263816025,
0.0027884205,
-0.0427809916,
0.0169972442,
-0.0230593309,
-0.0421080478,
-0.0200112667,
0.0369007178,
0.0347759463,
-0.0246288627,
0.0113251209,
-0.0241851024,
-0.0239163246,
-0.0028153982,
0.0149399536,
0.0582349151,
-0.0092624677,
-0.018005142,
-0.0436098948,
-0.0391879715,
-0.0190821029,
0.0232693963,
0.0179800019,
-0.0621302873,
0.0000100146,
0.0512948707,
0.007771546,
-0.0491215102,
-0.0366703458,
0.0063234749,
-0.0475930013,
-0.0779844746,
0.0063768872,
-0.0835808739,
0.0151366796,
0.0177564975,
0.0181470867,
-0.0133867105,
0.0119209932,
0.0018907954,
-0.0238206424,
0.0664744526,
0.0335513018,
0.0250971839,
0.0082615055,
0.0087254839,
0.0429316089,
0.068862915,
0.0105036832,
0.0035670481,
0.018482279,
-0.0240553096,
-0.0013448591,
0.0519691221,
0.0104943886,
0.0122256856,
-0.0542133525,
0.0110208951,
0.0568538606,
0.0053756628,
0.0193088315,
0.0617629029,
-0.0257828105,
0.0045077708,
0.0170297623,
0.0211857315,
0.047449138,
0.0165755507,
0.0275946986,
-0.0160729568,
-0.0302145872,
0.0098475805,
-0.0430261418,
0.0114352126,
-0.0104064373,
0.0350776948,
0.0311981663,
0.0569175854,
-0.0215658415,
0.0105508864,
-0.0220644008,
-0.0180255771,
0.0238865465,
0.0071696499,
0.0712250322,
-0.0073541165,
-0.0497774221,
0.0732490495,
0.0220209956,
-0.029197935,
0.0054497747,
-0.0406417884,
0.0159796067,
0.0741580725,
0.0279831998,
-0.0216410607,
-0.0196828786,
0.0177458078,
0.0232203957,
0.0196104087,
-0.0165973436,
0.0194262918,
0.0184310395,
-0.0515692309,
-0.0031749669,
0.0106963618,
-0.0013596218,
0.0316776782,
0.0563628525,
0.0200713873,
0.0344952866,
-0.0248596333,
0.0373914167,
0.0157794133,
-0.0508331358,
-0.0237826593,
-0.0139709674,
0.0129857631,
0.0142884618,
0.0124188783,
-0.0071167736,
0.0286776908,
0.0423641093,
-0.0612940975,
0.0088631967,
-0.0048094681,
-0.1036121398,
-0.0320374779,
0.0639662147,
0.0392330252,
0.0102922991,
0.0003364029,
0.0027864308,
-0.0557839982,
0.0249469765,
-0.0224921871,
0.107552126,
-0.0374506228,
0.071010083,
-0.0100962603,
0.0132785384,
-0.0525989719,
0.0684133247,
0.0002741244,
0.0109451059,
0.0431534052,
0.0378165357,
-0.0114947716,
-0.0328536183,
-0.0490716994,
0.0194946527,
-0.0057558324,
-0.0030461787,
-0.0261221714,
-0.0163218323,
-0.0371123962,
-0.0479547568,
-0.0935084671,
0.0052468376,
-0.0369257815,
0.0191470217,
-0.0054635876,
0.0334170349,
0.0021400726,
0.0161159653,
-0.020412622,
-0.016967617,
-0.0026926366,
0.0419705659,
-0.0203224868,
0.016899623,
-0.0581270196,
-0.0129769957,
-0.0362086929,
0.0022626997,
0.0576765798,
-0.0333141014,
-0.0357594192,
-0.0748574734,
0.0543822646,
-0.008522233,
0.0239464398,
-0.0339190252,
-0.0096922182,
-0.0154634574,
-0.0418481566,
0.0928214565,
0.0355583765,
0.0027507381,
-0.0013135084,
0.0288504642,
-0.0454897285,
-0.0013536421,
0.0025860528,
-0.0145931821,
-0.0574357361,
-0.0355908982,
0.0128525794,
-0.0362776145,
0.0617537498,
-0.0233230162,
-0.002868305,
-0.0188253075,
-0.025328856,
-0.025376955,
0.0051783053,
-0.0164155997,
-0.0232766848,
-0.0357584991,
0.0076691229,
-0.029118076,
-0.0281283744,
0.0384377576,
-0.0713926628,
0.0095042568,
-0.0463097282,
0.0023084925,
-0.0654221624,
0.0829339623,
-0.0137686003,
0.0272464771,
-0.0376658216,
-0.0487207547,
-0.0092477323,
-0.0002679417,
-0.0500592664,
-0.0305376034,
0.0704103112,
-0.0213124901,
0.0265090782,
-0.0142243225,
-0.0202773567,
-0.0415269285,
-0.0053010401,
-0.0419535115,
0.0125136543,
0.0531661883,
-0.0110696862,
-0.0160355773,
0.0673516318,
0.0242669713,
0.0385925844,
-0.0015685753,
0.0267621614,
-0.0158680473,
0.0297482982,
0.0443697348,
-0.0025380745,
0.0262079276,
-0.0103378817,
0.0398125015,
0.0448044874,
0.044571586,
-0.0121993991,
-0.0263805911,
-0.00472371,
0.010886712,
-0.0101994388,
-0.0136067597,
0.0123561267,
0.027496133,
-0.0784082264,
-0.0153900664,
0.1036729068,
0.0294867605,
-0.0598599017,
0.0097005814,
-0.0259704776,
0.0175997801,
0.014180949,
-0.003607162,
-0.0682036728,
-0.0296370033,
0.0203537252,
-0.024144331,
0.0242247339,
-0.0157808773,
-0.0015099782,
-0.124652043,
0.0007581601,
0.04470139,
-0.0596126057,
-0.0224032775,
-0.0391956344,
0.0027343368,
0.0324453972,
0.0371148176,
0.0574594103,
-0.0243018288,
-0.0330202281,
-0.0031392784,
0.0002436819,
-0.0289305262,
0.0302367397,
-0.0397353657,
0.0445588417,
0.0369860046,
0.0111482423,
0.03107531,
-0.0076433877,
0.0594268031,
-0.027652422,
0.0299224276,
-0.0202672724,
-0.0168657135,
-0.0137053933,
-0.0324607044,
0.002948445,
0.0203393158,
-0.0410407856,
-0.0311694238,
0.012457923,
0.0671772957,
-0.0068246955,
0.026019806,
0.004520339,
-0.0287189353,
0.0006738474,
0.0852383003,
0.0266260151,
-0.0167994704,
-0.0248458162,
0.0090710158,
-0.0114757475,
-0.0124202156,
0.0181141589,
0.0010437453,
-0.007661283,
-0.0192270596,
-0.0306898169,
0.009123669,
0.0469165109,
0.0393943787,
0.0129711414,
0.0416282192,
0.0148374345,
-0.0038772228,
-0.0875130817,
0.00946943,
-0.0761897862,
0.0556874797,
-0.0595823415,
0.008166017,
0.0210429784,
-0.0005034809,
0.0123868454,
0.0380194895,
-0.099204205,
-0.0644971877,
0.0120748458,
0.0001249016,
0.019151777,
0.042518422,
0.0055643972,
-0.0337823406,
0.0267844256,
-0.0138994101,
-0.0196963344,
0.0527115278,
0.0120201809,
0.0285715535,
0.0093652662,
0.0324947461,
-0.0394993722,
0.0033616207,
0.0296488963,
0.0672130138,
-0.0209458414,
-0.0122165326,
-0.0077859974,
-0.0081753703,
0.0196703319,
0.0005185269,
0.0359407365,
0.014937466,
0.0520252548,
-0.0480306707,
0.0045698904,
-0.0105641074,
-0.0015709481,
0.0440224968,
0.0084080966,
-0.0004859515,
-0.0252209175,
0.008798494,
0.0042320439,
-0.0032305464,
0.0168445203,
-0.0207038708,
-0.0401531048,
0.0589604415,
0.0188307669,
-0.0237467811,
0.0034537504,
0.0129890461,
0.0110251252,
-0.0315577574,
0.0533880033,
-0.0012559424,
-0.0152479867,
-0.0707915276,
0.0238231607,
-0.0360522568,
-0.019016115,
-0.006332689,
0.0231964812,
0.0650619194,
-0.0184491109,
0.0330994204,
-0.0046858224,
-0.0118674496,
-0.0275192577,
0.0097583588,
0.0104882792,
-0.0331080481,
0.0098049566,
0.0395178124,
-0.0203554612,
0.0320304334,
0.0786248744,
0.017439371,
0.0301605444,
0.04428114,
0.0106291594,
-0.0149592115,
-0.0201050788,
0.0023572447,
0.0370777398,
-0.0352717526,
-0.0079977997,
-0.043302644,
-0.0748929232,
0.0283392388,
-0.0365359858,
-0.0175422449,
-0.0272837784,
-0.0037336827,
0.0517688245,
0.0040463787,
0.0000980405,
-0.0090695294,
0.0262452997,
0.0021621326,
-0.0241818707,
0.0076127588,
-6.699096755e-33,
-0.0169558153,
-0.0338069871,
0.0268307999,
-0.0356392562,
-0.0489882901,
0.0137672387,
-0.041064959,
0.0221878253,
0.0206032787,
-0.0315804556,
-0.0223982818,
0.0071341838,
0.0104117934,
0.0301385932,
-0.0302864183,
-0.0131068593,
0.0494892187,
0.0427498668,
0.013971461,
0.0212553795,
0.0148031916,
0.0549190044,
0.0232436955,
-0.0513660312,
-0.0253671184,
-0.0133457473,
0.031004684,
0.0355788842,
0.0102203721,
0.0649404973,
-0.0419336148,
0.0234931968,
0.0366992317,
-0.0704383254,
-0.0222339053,
0.0621531308,
-0.0811284184,
0.0402720012,
0.0534416139,
-0.0104524661,
0.0059839361,
-0.0599321462,
0.0199238881,
0.0140913222,
0.0099370098,
-0.0082556177,
-0.0021733064,
-0.0486644395,
-0.0520621911,
-0.0045124032,
-0.0668248832,
0.0248796232,
0.0118272025,
-0.0134007176,
0.0349126793,
-0.0468286611,
-0.0114085982,
0.0496697947,
-0.0601207949,
0.0044693067,
0.0175639484,
0.0635794923,
0.0790330321,
0.0600986071,
0.0439113006,
0.0404347517,
0.0151865529,
0.0094830953,
-0.0183056425,
-0.0507385172,
0.0302587096,
0.0295772068,
0.0045896186,
0.0163673479,
0.0477204323,
-0.0198625643,
-0.0497342087,
-0.0501458123,
0.0000777943,
0.039060045,
0.0561424121,
0.035694208,
-0.0268678777,
-0.0354617648,
-0.0331927948,
0.0237755366,
-0.0593751818,
-0.01149562,
0.0351451822,
0.0226146299,
-0.0483770967,
-0.0076213898,
0.0725331157,
-0.0472987518,
-0.0166997667,
0.0400818251,
0.0114753954,
0.0174922422,
-0.0349163748,
0.0358221121,
-0.0327385142,
-0.0328747258,
0.0242244676,
0.0016998897,
-0.0168953128,
-0.0228238627,
0.0177709833,
0.0143752815,
-0.0774681941,
-0.0256074872,
-0.0437450558,
-0.0033063316,
-0.0203592721,
0.0217334367,
0.0330632888,
0.0210993122,
0.0214582607,
0.0780062824,
0.0437201932,
-0.011951129,
-0.0013690251,
-0.0218932256,
0.008658411,
0.0136583857,
-0.0215742961,
0.0009739366,
-0.0261558443,
0.0174163152,
0.0667146966,
-0.0528963841,
-0.0187821221,
0.0116172154,
2.796e-7,
0.0283566713,
0.0315319151,
0.0432042815,
-0.0191826597,
0.0481555946,
-0.0112501634,
-0.0008758442,
-0.0075295991,
0.0164444484,
0.0002886153,
0.0023568845,
0.0496416576,
0.0325627886,
-0.0240333043,
-0.0772511289,
0.0136644049,
-0.0571893305,
0.0036358188,
-0.074615933,
-0.0015328382,
0.0219283253,
0.1250742376,
-0.0258008149,
-0.0155650666,
-0.0069021476,
-0.0478285216,
0.0485564806,
-0.0376351103,
-0.0132331336,
0.0107259843,
-0.02568084,
0.0304425433,
0.0057412819,
-0.0190435778,
0.0287173018,
0.0338869356,
0.0063972226,
0.0872220546,
0.0012492299,
-0.0332545452,
0.0210418701,
-0.0003112973,
-0.0377838835,
-0.0481132604,
0.0680960417,
-0.0751315579,
-0.0244215075,
-0.05079538,
-0.0026362068,
-0.0098183174,
-0.0223608222,
0.0179769509,
-0.0007781352,
0.0259771254,
0.03470755,
-0.0053414144,
-0.003330695,
-0.0998590887,
-0.0356749445,
0.0022517717,
-0.0593793169,
-0.0449494533,
-0.0347392336,
-0.0407888182,
0.0346486345,
-0.0421548821,
0.0148671223,
2.875306248e-34,
0.0461632833,
-0.0169377774,
0.0045109661,
0.0284396913,
0.0351933502,
-0.0319524929,
-0.0191936679,
0.0427691042,
-0.0046841344,
-0.128977865,
-0.0207481105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02992v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02992v2 | Decoding-time Realignment of Language Models | 2024-02-05T13:31:28 | 2024-05-24T08:39:07 | Tianlin Liu, Shangmin Guo, Leonardo Bianco, Daniele Calandriello, Quentin Berthet, Felipe Llinares, Jessica Hoffmann, Lucas Dixon, Michal Valko, Mathieu Blondel | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Aligning language models with human preferences is crucial for reducing
errors and biases in these models. Alignment techniques, such as reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF), are typically cast as optimizing a
tradeoff between human preference rewards and a proximity regularization term
that encourages staying close to the unaligned model. Selecting an appropriate
level of regularization is critical: insufficient regularization can lead to
reduced model capabilities due to reward hacking, whereas excessive
regularization hinders alignment. Traditional methods for finding the optimal
regularization level require retraining multiple models with varying
regularization strengths. This process, however, is resource-intensive,
especially for large models. To address this challenge, we propose
decoding-time realignment (DeRa), a simple method to explore and evaluate
different regularization strengths in aligned models without retraining. DeRa
enables control over the degree of alignment, allowing users to smoothly
transition between unaligned and aligned models. It also enhances the
efficiency of hyperparameter tuning by enabling the identification of effective
regularization strengths using a validation dataset. | [
0.0244310852,
0.0864015073,
-0.0043135099,
0.0360919833,
-0.025128752,
0.0252254084,
-0.0059203398,
-0.0101213166,
-0.0765495971,
-0.0010070223,
-0.0664139614,
-0.0262477174,
0.0384271592,
-0.0334092863,
0.0038962183,
-0.088419795,
0.0549525581,
-0.0270231664,
0.0146656316,
0.0041531236,
0.0248005297,
-0.0144567229,
-0.001778356,
0.0655135885,
0.0314582363,
-0.0164228957,
-0.0181520283,
0.0400237218,
0.0547681637,
-0.0281562768,
0.0145244682,
0.0775832236,
0.0197537672,
0.0559264123,
0.0000019822,
-0.0324840173,
-0.0148662403,
-0.0091198822,
-0.0162159987,
0.0290934891,
0.0285161491,
-0.0341593102,
-0.000282718,
0.0197477397,
-0.0271806624,
-0.0240418911,
0.0909291878,
0.0061386507,
0.0267835259,
0.0801299736,
0.0097083189,
0.0037347111,
-0.0094669908,
-0.0391518399,
-0.0089422949,
-0.0463744029,
0.0157205816,
-0.0323658139,
-0.0074414555,
-0.0142985936,
-0.0263814591,
-0.0043436233,
-0.014171768,
0.0239973664,
0.0336204879,
0.0128606092,
-0.0081450297,
-0.0162484683,
-0.0453411974,
0.0551604182,
-0.0142253339,
-0.0355949327,
-0.0100765405,
-0.0061215837,
-0.0087302737,
0.0136495214,
-0.0195391309,
-0.017525984,
0.0206344705,
0.0262063444,
0.0271461736,
-0.0097744269,
0.0412389114,
0.0110523161,
-0.0072061955,
0.076105468,
0.0288603213,
-0.035336595,
-0.0189292934,
0.0280656833,
0.0167026892,
-0.0494422056,
0.0060483394,
0.0115335053,
-0.0433278494,
0.0249507725,
-0.078513138,
-0.038780544,
-0.0054870038,
-0.0222496614,
0.0260392353,
0.038333226,
0.022710694,
0.0122129219,
0.0162517447,
0.061543636,
-0.0243381169,
0.0425282903,
-0.0527950898,
0.0376846716,
-0.0082557518,
-0.0273674112,
-0.0009144712,
-0.0261002127,
-0.0039038619,
-0.0014777939,
-0.0625724494,
0.0242946111,
-0.0003086174,
-0.0004511477,
0.0195582211,
0.0272144098,
-0.0610701181,
-0.0103506269,
0.0060056755,
0.0735421851,
-0.0292290989,
0.0079845851,
0.0222064704,
-0.0341261216,
-0.0214648247,
0.006258633,
-0.0129414499,
-0.0485602692,
-0.039098829,
0.0575619265,
-0.0238376353,
-0.0079478631,
-0.0000639082,
0.0076680332,
-0.0373213813,
-0.040217232,
-0.0226977281,
-0.0547451116,
0.0247255117,
-0.0057993708,
-0.0052511026,
-0.0720360875,
-0.012308808,
-0.0150773581,
-0.0297938697,
0.0665465966,
-0.020614896,
0.0063473149,
0.0112561453,
-0.0297498126,
0.0052808477,
0.0789278895,
0.0477146655,
0.0240510497,
0.0147720128,
-0.0265454501,
-0.026441101,
0.0645009726,
-0.0057986919,
0.0162152965,
-0.0630881041,
-0.0351118743,
0.0323057026,
0.0561064743,
0.0840185657,
0.0372952595,
-0.0356049724,
-0.0061648255,
0.0759405345,
0.0628612414,
0.0347178616,
-0.0270455759,
0.0235228408,
0.0107960729,
-0.015724048,
0.025310982,
-0.0449998602,
0.0058066431,
-0.0290336665,
0.0016811789,
0.0279688034,
0.0356679782,
0.0027353365,
-0.0407364108,
-0.0075601125,
-0.0207137354,
0.0343383923,
0.0173973385,
0.0744886324,
-0.0256097764,
-0.0247090068,
0.0119904755,
0.0522882715,
-0.0339692384,
0.0091101499,
-0.0178273134,
0.0255455114,
0.0841177553,
0.0170737132,
-0.0160617344,
-0.02554591,
0.0064758584,
-0.0296855066,
0.0538928472,
0.0824481547,
-0.0055607189,
-0.0001984908,
-0.0364456698,
-0.038803909,
0.0391764604,
0.0156104397,
0.041392494,
0.0117538376,
-0.0106945448,
-0.0064377259,
-0.0026993449,
-0.056067761,
0.0351905189,
-0.0069163889,
-0.0314675719,
-0.0099471873,
0.0222998951,
0.0042599607,
0.0054919519,
-0.0134586114,
0.0123125026,
0.0203436762,
-0.0265659913,
0.0298652221,
0.0200785231,
-0.0549607165,
-0.018406814,
0.0469845794,
-0.0022117114,
0.0030082888,
0.0776282921,
-0.0163548086,
-0.0274471175,
0.0471423641,
0.0017534187,
0.0559541173,
0.0059468122,
0.0475786775,
-0.020246055,
-0.001274228,
-0.0759419501,
0.0367230959,
-0.001338864,
0.0305915531,
-0.0029699833,
-0.0478038676,
-0.0014900196,
-0.0579667278,
-0.0173546132,
0.0373126194,
-0.009732103,
0.0185570326,
0.0424869657,
0.0077420482,
-0.0225246139,
0.0024075329,
-0.059446983,
-0.0103150578,
-0.0317261741,
0.0359397717,
0.0235648919,
0.0076123457,
0.0092874961,
-0.0212277696,
-0.0366675407,
-0.0264884923,
-0.0240156706,
0.0104390383,
0.0210907068,
0.0112610152,
-0.041476462,
-0.0714684352,
-0.0175490472,
-0.0110889794,
0.0317799672,
-0.0079097506,
0.0153859584,
-0.0797206759,
0.0208739191,
-0.0151633304,
0.0128669692,
-0.0075759296,
-0.0398824699,
0.0316769481,
0.0141984541,
0.0106388982,
0.1059597731,
0.0007987889,
0.0433600061,
0.0593712926,
0.0420682319,
-0.072130926,
0.0071214135,
-0.0160484314,
-0.0546802096,
-0.0732307732,
-0.0310441498,
0.001711457,
0.1174937189,
0.0105490144,
0.0132832099,
-0.0801849589,
0.0135540823,
-0.041046232,
-0.0542371087,
-0.0221490469,
-0.0072367615,
-0.0477427915,
0.0493365116,
-0.0486578345,
-0.0944271088,
0.0786748007,
-0.0265640542,
0.0133039923,
-0.0214758813,
-0.0271325279,
-0.0122458935,
0.018091023,
-0.0226156935,
0.0376600809,
-0.0230764095,
-0.0422664918,
-0.0666061342,
-0.0347330049,
0.0443647839,
-0.028879907,
0.0560957529,
-0.0373554081,
-0.0122309327,
-0.0265065543,
-0.0696501583,
-0.0339552052,
-0.0345476903,
-0.0292840321,
-0.0272547957,
0.0317131244,
-0.056277018,
-0.037995711,
-0.0047035962,
0.0242838543,
0.0241238158,
-0.0370715372,
0.0139998365,
-0.0054653655,
0.0099691711,
0.0895955488,
0.0238164365,
-0.0181556568,
-0.0385708436,
0.0049100234,
0.0270341039,
0.0514950082,
0.0190311782,
-0.0568831041,
0.0098417467,
0.049245812,
-0.026737364,
-0.0075326054,
0.0157769285,
0.0532035269,
-0.0186615586,
-0.0067633581,
0.0975460336,
0.0323574282,
-0.0878321528,
0.0305763632,
-0.0404411852,
0.0796488747,
0.0201069415,
0.0212543309,
-0.0435365215,
-0.0309473742,
0.0116258869,
0.0484569781,
0.0237442721,
0.0081435395,
0.0027142335,
-0.0998938829,
-0.0250738245,
0.0454317406,
-0.054806564,
-0.0064016297,
-0.019396333,
0.016399594,
-0.0251916889,
0.0519176982,
0.025809614,
0.014122095,
-0.0060809008,
0.0403619185,
0.0112756575,
-0.0500522666,
-0.0103640109,
-0.0298885778,
0.0708263367,
0.0799916163,
0.0081424164,
-0.001390909,
-0.0571172982,
-0.016387945,
0.0641586855,
-0.0044958522,
0.0101007866,
0.0039689983,
-0.0222193208,
-0.0183553658,
0.0081662564,
0.0418350995,
-0.0136052445,
0.0002962685,
-0.015303771,
0.0713799745,
0.014874544,
0.0116749667,
0.0082461061,
-0.0179575309,
0.0314364918,
0.0541065186,
0.020669423,
-0.0709777251,
-0.0254746806,
-0.0351103097,
-0.0179786868,
-0.0667749867,
-0.023497751,
0.0081983674,
0.0142824296,
-0.0497374535,
-0.0616954826,
-0.016679205,
-0.0165819656,
0.0365399271,
0.0146418884,
0.0102019059,
0.0149227893,
-0.009272119,
-0.0360204466,
0.0595338643,
-0.0105116433,
0.0349761844,
-0.0694417879,
-0.0355829,
-0.0231039394,
-0.0204038452,
0.0005692304,
0.0076572923,
-0.0895304382,
-0.0997215956,
-0.006369283,
0.0198331326,
0.0196635928,
0.0629981682,
0.0112305526,
-0.0767384171,
-0.003948166,
0.0000943833,
-0.0261886697,
0.0234803539,
0.0254519079,
-0.0189359579,
-0.0228748154,
0.023072768,
-0.0484820902,
-0.0118254367,
0.0338323489,
0.0279167295,
-0.0148349572,
-0.0204210356,
0.0243849512,
0.0012236,
0.0677275807,
-0.0272881649,
-0.0326862819,
-0.0229807086,
-0.0099152364,
-0.0292981081,
-0.0178655237,
-0.0194886103,
-0.0408734642,
0.0663860142,
-0.0017961778,
-0.0042836582,
-0.0480243117,
-0.0024914669,
-0.0210225862,
-0.0643942505,
0.0238584634,
0.0010094583,
0.0326183215,
0.0375502147,
0.0511420034,
-0.004519287,
0.0319449231,
-0.0303126276,
0.0371164121,
-0.004216108,
0.0088471072,
0.03058354,
0.0249875933,
-0.0203367081,
0.0178362615,
-0.0460078269,
-0.0242432375,
-0.0183115546,
-0.0525950938,
0.0590479262,
-0.007720584,
0.0903797001,
0.0134172207,
-0.0043688035,
-0.0116271283,
0.0261895265,
-0.0309911091,
-0.0149480104,
0.0241472051,
0.0080893738,
-0.0259500463,
0.0276178364,
0.0836308673,
0.0038561674,
0.0181082003,
-0.0395975076,
-0.0118321544,
-0.0183602422,
-0.0021579345,
0.0491939969,
0.0222046431,
-0.0547710471,
-0.0267047416,
-0.0151722608,
-0.0614889897,
-0.0063074725,
0.0297634285,
0.0062411092,
0.0021253831,
0.033350233,
0.0460730009,
-0.070052512,
-0.023933664,
-0.022456212,
-0.026358204,
0.0139507949,
-0.0389904715,
-0.0446694754,
-6.740051713e-33,
-0.0281743724,
0.0059721963,
0.0025798576,
-0.0554985404,
-0.0466389395,
-0.0134516312,
-0.0079612508,
0.0517883413,
-0.0046298718,
-0.0074173026,
-0.023581801,
-0.0171259884,
0.0139547456,
0.0145871527,
0.0234579761,
-0.0002766518,
0.0238084979,
-0.0303785577,
-0.054462377,
-0.0141579267,
0.0230332743,
0.0232267696,
0.0832980797,
-0.0537035055,
0.021838652,
0.0370152257,
-0.0333300494,
0.0074607059,
-0.0024876941,
0.0524662696,
-0.0100657819,
0.0228337273,
-0.0010710158,
-0.03884634,
-0.0098871235,
0.0090882443,
-0.0489235595,
-0.0221468862,
0.0386002101,
0.0423626341,
-0.045590587,
-0.0496730022,
0.0410443991,
-0.004325035,
-0.0487096421,
-0.0090395035,
0.0140493298,
-0.0140622519,
-0.0407437086,
0.0314097814,
-0.0646427348,
0.0179254785,
-0.0360669158,
0.0019137339,
0.0166514274,
0.0340349115,
-0.0330039002,
0.0112226503,
-0.0341094881,
0.0387023464,
0.0508064628,
0.0365428403,
0.1215208918,
0.0789324418,
0.0097644441,
0.052427806,
0.0075686066,
-0.018733751,
0.0201398507,
0.0104874438,
0.0637959987,
0.0028308886,
0.0133306282,
0.0364435241,
0.0421634912,
-0.0369032547,
-0.0022467677,
0.015138926,
-0.0051761479,
0.0071987063,
0.0512527861,
0.0623060502,
-0.0654870197,
-0.0318590626,
-0.0366828032,
-0.0285990108,
-0.0271633323,
-0.0562990047,
0.0308016334,
0.0147317881,
-0.0292644259,
-0.0190824475,
0.0367378592,
-0.0344473384,
0.0134850862,
0.0284714103,
-0.014950742,
0.0366280526,
-0.0147310477,
0.000462634,
-0.0575825199,
-0.0047367197,
0.0214653593,
-0.0027123566,
0.0437033959,
0.0039901151,
0.0312774964,
-0.0026728243,
-0.0500927307,
0.0095661394,
-0.0258719679,
-0.004583267,
0.0237705186,
0.0371700153,
0.0845104381,
-0.013617021,
-0.0197536983,
0.052335266,
0.0076033557,
-0.0276804157,
-0.050250642,
-0.016807925,
0.014342729,
0.0115683638,
-0.0074577671,
0.0113864997,
0.002830191,
-0.0034569851,
0.0425563306,
-0.0238852501,
-0.0298596825,
0.0002347763,
2.739e-7,
0.026977811,
0.0430043228,
0.0362568237,
0.0083350595,
-0.0172966067,
0.0217357818,
-0.0092735104,
0.0289019477,
-0.0287154093,
0.0188483987,
0.033186771,
0.0310872383,
0.0619193912,
-0.007906625,
-0.0474836342,
-0.0255745575,
-0.0713000968,
0.0398599021,
-0.0423173644,
-0.0284727272,
0.0163956117,
0.1022488028,
0.0156125501,
0.0016638276,
0.010214882,
-0.0075475732,
0.0320713595,
-0.0540811457,
-0.0014473604,
0.0094665419,
0.0318598412,
-0.0074870144,
-0.0206169672,
-0.0414005816,
0.0075487946,
0.0198583063,
-0.005238317,
0.045263201,
-0.0640659407,
-0.0405435972,
-0.043580357,
0.0248234123,
-0.0167066306,
-0.0535990112,
0.0107368864,
-0.0178795736,
-0.0127728088,
-0.0219228901,
0.0216747895,
-0.0079646194,
0.0240612365,
-0.0539446212,
0.0186658185,
0.0177324153,
0.0382786691,
0.0299044047,
-0.0318527631,
-0.0499689728,
-0.0299154073,
0.0544957295,
-0.043630857,
-0.0223581716,
-0.026782915,
0.0193553269,
0.0135164298,
-0.0343875624,
0.0185791142,
2.528355417e-34,
0.0073653613,
-0.0135225467,
0.0225859676,
0.0140196737,
0.0428338684,
-0.0229359139,
0.0113022579,
0.0188954473,
0.0438518412,
-0.0925072581,
-0.0079613626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02987v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02987v1 | Conversation Reconstruction Attack Against GPT Models | 2024-02-05T13:18:42 | 2024-02-05T13:18:42 | Junjie Chu, Zeyang Sha, Michael Backes, Yang Zhang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In recent times, significant advancements have been made in the field of
large language models (LLMs), represented by GPT series models. To optimize
task execution, users often engage in multi-round conversations with GPT models
hosted in cloud environments. These multi-round conversations, potentially
replete with private information, require transmission and storage within the
cloud. However, this operational paradigm introduces additional attack
surfaces. In this paper, we first introduce a specific Conversation
Reconstruction Attack targeting GPT models. Our introduced Conversation
Reconstruction Attack is composed of two steps: hijacking a session and
reconstructing the conversations. Subsequently, we offer an exhaustive
evaluation of the privacy risks inherent in conversations when GPT models are
subjected to the proposed attack. However, GPT-4 demonstrates certain
robustness to the proposed attacks. We then introduce two advanced attacks
aimed at better reconstructing previous conversations, specifically the UNR
attack and the PBU attack. Our experimental findings indicate that the PBU
attack yields substantial performance across all models, achieving semantic
similarity scores exceeding 0.60, while the UNR attack is effective solely on
GPT-3.5. Our results reveal the concern about privacy risks associated with
conversations involving GPT models and aim to draw the community's attention to
prevent the potential misuse of these models' remarkable capabilities. We will
responsibly disclose our findings to the suppliers of related large language
models. | [
0.0425280668,
0.0964942202,
-0.0187936202,
0.0777401403,
-0.0830824003,
-0.0160983242,
0.0199033655,
-0.0100386217,
-0.0009346656,
-0.0326524004,
-0.0269779805,
-0.0516298227,
0.0201608017,
0.0300246049,
0.0362485386,
-0.0159301646,
0.0230504926,
-0.0193710197,
-0.0325884633,
-0.045816604,
0.0086576184,
0.0092615653,
0.0226298515,
0.0216342602,
0.0156381205,
-0.0200976003,
-0.0372301042,
0.0010490889,
-0.000501004,
0.0105035482,
-0.0117091089,
0.0451547205,
0.036296811,
0.079756096,
0.0000022175,
-0.0082172016,
-0.0710161105,
0.0224764906,
-0.0668770745,
0.0503630973,
0.0264051873,
0.0333197787,
-0.0230636764,
0.0187101196,
-0.0419586413,
0.0401516221,
0.0291418359,
0.0561638214,
0.0692709982,
0.0772057325,
-0.021544084,
-0.0039669592,
0.0286349412,
-0.0195630658,
0.0000892318,
-0.0619907342,
-0.0010565637,
-0.0201546792,
-0.0126301395,
0.0445064604,
0.043163307,
0.0010626555,
-0.0286671408,
0.0215662755,
-0.0585171804,
0.0343711935,
-0.0047571938,
0.0022709933,
-0.008423537,
0.0067409119,
0.0062134927,
-0.0000495155,
0.0297140367,
0.0399702489,
-0.0088200318,
0.0098029869,
-0.0515400916,
0.0194374919,
-0.0157662164,
0.0139288828,
0.0030257851,
-0.0317393504,
0.0488351732,
-0.0152511504,
0.0124319047,
0.0436485559,
0.0489063784,
-0.0133118667,
-0.0618641339,
-0.0463944003,
-0.0219561905,
-0.0589565746,
0.0280267857,
-0.0265967119,
0.0276856776,
0.022131158,
-0.0604733676,
0.006510145,
0.0187341552,
-0.0125756375,
0.0208901446,
0.0359911509,
0.054988727,
0.0200692415,
0.0169129763,
0.0435634553,
-0.0568185784,
0.0002855006,
0.0245928913,
-0.0175036378,
-0.0451340005,
-0.037526127,
-0.0167207289,
0.0795146599,
-0.0294996891,
-0.0021970663,
-0.0282363854,
0.0484788194,
0.0064606457,
0.0332977287,
-0.0170298535,
0.0059430306,
-0.0358545519,
-0.0157796014,
0.012864043,
-0.0452980809,
0.0097908545,
0.0023335575,
0.0060485601,
-0.1081197932,
-0.0305726249,
-0.0329888053,
-0.0255038403,
-0.0035732298,
-0.0330394022,
0.066924639,
0.0067482605,
-0.0397688895,
-0.0049247453,
-0.1095399931,
0.0079326006,
-0.0363652036,
-0.0485886857,
-0.0456270054,
0.0107313814,
-0.0104738791,
-0.005226058,
-0.0198176038,
-0.0026930994,
0.0036496024,
-0.0475815348,
0.0408757776,
0.005261214,
0.0115769142,
0.0007198081,
0.0467521735,
-0.0278662294,
0.0043517859,
0.0070682289,
0.0206557941,
0.0342722572,
-0.0186925307,
0.0495599918,
0.0376126468,
0.0322824009,
0.0210539438,
0.0233144909,
0.0263382327,
0.0495180525,
-0.0255095512,
-0.0443398431,
0.0736732483,
-0.0203314181,
-0.0586493947,
0.1141015589,
0.0835088938,
-0.0840484425,
0.0718137175,
-0.034450721,
0.0345397741,
-0.0280347094,
0.0251550339,
-0.0508160107,
-0.0316478498,
-0.0732983872,
-0.0437999442,
0.0395774953,
0.0003845948,
-0.0165960304,
0.0386631526,
0.046847973,
-0.0342474133,
0.0261014737,
0.0059070513,
0.0060103117,
0.020162385,
-0.0065806182,
0.06982743,
-0.0163856484,
-0.050930988,
-0.0594807193,
-0.0542510822,
-0.0065448713,
0.0266646855,
0.0779586211,
0.0132090328,
-0.0207979698,
-0.0271151438,
-0.0452526249,
0.0132365394,
0.0259229634,
0.0346055739,
0.0419637114,
-0.0190659314,
0.0066328645,
0.0024453085,
0.0249779355,
0.0085054189,
0.0201685149,
0.0057526897,
0.0330425985,
-0.0137013365,
0.0254172869,
-0.0319401324,
-0.0038881919,
-0.0013588328,
0.0245955717,
-0.0201419573,
0.0499405526,
0.0196215045,
0.0003527534,
0.0108548841,
0.0365124419,
0.0331239067,
-0.0025839838,
0.0029201473,
-0.0303808637,
0.0428198986,
-0.0202699676,
0.0002391206,
0.0326131247,
0.0702864304,
-0.0157228205,
-0.0284244344,
0.0324997939,
-0.034961883,
0.0667728484,
-0.0196631718,
0.0264177844,
-0.0079715597,
0.0037495862,
-0.0086456435,
0.0008565843,
-0.0068657896,
-0.0015747133,
-0.0319355205,
-0.0059227431,
0.0321733244,
-0.0758230239,
-0.0227551069,
0.0193641186,
-0.0372843072,
0.0118555641,
0.034003213,
-0.0329263508,
-0.0251632854,
-0.0105135972,
-0.1087620854,
0.0269036349,
-0.0071293609,
0.0772038698,
0.0310372915,
0.0536043048,
-0.0532137379,
-0.0457178652,
-0.0489055477,
-0.0106913988,
-0.0026047111,
0.0427949764,
0.0316268168,
-0.0051815831,
-0.0361153185,
-0.0126680508,
-0.0097878147,
-0.0243115742,
0.041255828,
-0.0332859121,
-0.035051737,
-0.0112224035,
0.0513844378,
-0.0273275543,
0.0203701779,
-0.0199306551,
-0.0216352828,
0.0267865304,
-0.0133437831,
0.0233785268,
0.0356222875,
0.0420375466,
0.0489050634,
-0.0380101018,
-0.0395843834,
-0.0253342725,
-0.0174797177,
-0.0177226774,
-0.0552699305,
-0.0709046349,
-0.0163667202,
0.0317225158,
0.0337918885,
0.044680085,
-0.0286471471,
-0.0245791394,
0.027345052,
0.0185771026,
0.0179101769,
-0.0217057373,
-0.0172581449,
-0.0166711435,
0.0062780287,
0.0134958271,
-0.0842060074,
0.0208461825,
-0.056495823,
0.0300810728,
-0.0295761824,
-0.0606631525,
0.0394239686,
0.0738022178,
0.0202287529,
0.0320986323,
0.0088040605,
-0.0491540805,
-0.0279650372,
-0.0148435505,
0.0586738475,
-0.0606325343,
-0.0076517467,
-0.0365218334,
-0.0180481933,
0.0129019888,
-0.0425051674,
-0.0259064101,
-0.0457431115,
-0.029197108,
-0.0303149428,
-0.0017528697,
-0.0418822803,
-0.0414149128,
-0.0151080592,
0.0309822988,
0.0158514045,
-0.029317541,
0.0140212718,
-0.0299795419,
0.0120983971,
0.0283662975,
-0.037318226,
-0.039702829,
-0.0247226786,
-0.0021622286,
0.12061584,
0.0705333501,
0.0125998184,
0.0230691694,
-0.042757351,
-0.0067932354,
-0.0096988473,
-0.0510491394,
0.0258565191,
0.0286117569,
-0.0458351746,
-0.019246446,
0.0635669902,
0.0056522852,
-0.0744693652,
-0.0229690876,
0.019471122,
-0.0025479398,
-0.0295756217,
-0.0106490022,
-0.1071205363,
-0.0107706878,
0.0321670435,
0.0280320961,
-0.0398982242,
-0.015461673,
-0.013938196,
-0.0787824169,
-0.0018703381,
0.0245422646,
0.0025938007,
-0.0074153496,
-0.055531282,
0.002408046,
0.0280518103,
0.0214912649,
-0.0420352928,
0.0393592417,
0.0179151241,
-0.0356560834,
-0.0169353578,
-0.0097362772,
0.0330078155,
-0.0163029954,
0.045184914,
0.0579408891,
0.0172940399,
-0.0136483256,
0.0170971602,
0.0451873131,
0.0322001763,
-0.0456729159,
0.0413960554,
0.0327752717,
0.0116127217,
0.0052064098,
-0.0003562974,
0.0354927704,
-0.008835827,
-0.0083227493,
0.0185636897,
0.0365137197,
-0.042447526,
-0.0028479137,
0.0177113228,
-0.027828576,
0.04619487,
0.0605682395,
-0.0124198748,
0.0015266667,
-0.0278043691,
-0.0532295331,
0.0573463067,
0.0043102102,
-0.0134691224,
0.0032731404,
0.0667394474,
-0.0109762289,
-0.0303106047,
0.0042349515,
-0.0268129557,
-0.0130045004,
0.0096817445,
0.0290369317,
0.0444884188,
0.0028450745,
-0.0166423209,
-0.0324766785,
-0.0939368233,
0.0323755778,
-0.0679722652,
0.0429232195,
0.01336117,
0.0002058743,
-0.0119946534,
0.0249051917,
-0.0972140506,
-0.0647376329,
0.0074188914,
0.0344813727,
0.0275624413,
0.04599078,
-0.0160948746,
-0.0270218924,
0.0234475192,
-0.0029219072,
-0.0427280739,
0.0177902337,
0.0430777222,
-0.0025094613,
-0.0020141448,
0.034167178,
-0.0294926707,
-0.016351629,
0.0061611864,
-0.0296316445,
-0.0314362273,
-0.055598978,
0.0029468262,
0.0504591726,
0.0503354967,
0.064585939,
0.0457330309,
0.0062185754,
0.0388934687,
-0.0346068442,
0.0207171869,
-0.0301395934,
0.0106073404,
0.0056171045,
-0.021854667,
0.0427021347,
-0.0395335481,
0.0029754881,
0.0074357986,
-0.0257260501,
-0.0242956895,
0.0114417765,
-0.026769409,
0.0373326205,
-0.0225889888,
-0.0232155733,
0.0348313488,
0.018212717,
0.062028829,
-0.0452069789,
0.0468521528,
-0.0140154287,
-0.0327954702,
0.0252272543,
0.0589697845,
-0.0806813464,
-0.0529061779,
0.0133937486,
0.0171163995,
0.0020802259,
0.0175988749,
0.0125609599,
-0.0440256596,
0.0127748419,
-0.0640355945,
0.0041401382,
-0.0099682445,
-0.0223752148,
-0.016295258,
-0.01122043,
-0.0098204194,
0.0799023136,
0.0766629726,
0.0006601778,
0.048714038,
0.0259169601,
-0.0621048026,
-0.0432642661,
-0.0286781397,
-0.00474717,
0.0363954976,
-0.003484305,
-0.0431602113,
0.0005710113,
-0.0374986641,
-0.0090310043,
-0.0396547168,
0.0085267834,
-0.0281953271,
0.0099686347,
0.0470273457,
-0.0135181602,
0.0053891581,
-0.0798017606,
0.0367750004,
-0.0169494152,
-0.0324289277,
0.0218611229,
-6.163088229e-33,
0.0257659648,
-0.021639144,
-0.0331652202,
0.0427033305,
-0.0019198869,
-0.0106837787,
-0.0182476901,
0.0054974058,
-0.0272662677,
-0.0215390325,
-0.0351421349,
0.0465442427,
0.0282231309,
0.0599260852,
-0.0314621106,
-0.0029353835,
0.0341739953,
0.0009684922,
0.0021975129,
0.0892226622,
0.0870936364,
0.0116717536,
0.0612866394,
-0.0851391107,
-0.0049266717,
-0.0412508696,
-0.023269197,
-0.0040998966,
-0.0490704812,
0.0328901298,
-0.0270910785,
0.0040021958,
-0.0008891364,
-0.0280101337,
-0.0109693939,
0.0169995781,
0.026226433,
-0.0032634919,
0.0055718208,
-0.0345073529,
0.0188866742,
-0.0712101832,
-0.028918324,
-0.0216725674,
0.0138933081,
-0.0081517426,
-0.0435602926,
0.0097126961,
-0.0168415364,
0.0123761464,
0.0013666684,
-0.0008480179,
-0.0258874334,
0.0153779155,
0.0490902662,
0.0005086885,
0.0372785069,
-0.0228314586,
-0.0214682184,
0.0477348007,
0.022766633,
0.013803279,
0.0287121627,
-0.0288648959,
0.0282391366,
0.0086285938,
0.0240674075,
0.0006554865,
-0.0253221504,
-0.0038663894,
-0.0555422865,
0.0399271213,
0.0157197863,
0.0431288034,
0.0113828573,
-0.0287747327,
-0.0045761792,
0.0199660603,
0.0148200812,
0.0064519439,
0.0782515928,
-0.0030089016,
-0.0841050968,
-0.0122915497,
-0.0247605219,
-0.0231233854,
-0.0334656052,
-0.0055826162,
0.0086826682,
0.0127173113,
-0.0058842204,
0.0064972239,
0.0274117757,
-0.0591296293,
-0.0160747152,
0.0225271098,
-0.0085777463,
-0.0432727709,
-0.0115997279,
0.0295202155,
0.0282370225,
0.0000795446,
0.0004678803,
-0.0376201123,
0.0110877175,
0.0123941973,
-0.0049985107,
0.0106276497,
-0.0642438158,
-0.0134477802,
-0.0124874385,
0.0481421687,
-0.018594861,
0.0023568473,
0.0324725509,
-0.0061422042,
0.0189498626,
0.0352192298,
0.0310612582,
0.0330074877,
-0.0508530885,
-0.0039778026,
-0.0285897702,
-0.0063582035,
0.0133117251,
0.0141728371,
-0.0115577653,
0.0226914771,
0.0722444206,
0.0164484289,
0.0024924888,
-0.0345721655,
3.071e-7,
-0.0121502839,
0.0109215239,
0.0267665517,
-0.0002690061,
0.0389263257,
0.0826406106,
0.0231721103,
0.0913788974,
0.0146284755,
-0.0267732162,
-0.0137465075,
-0.0045986394,
0.0637151673,
0.0400246419,
-0.0735087395,
0.0069122235,
-0.0863335952,
-0.0526193865,
-0.0671469569,
0.0004374273,
0.060330525,
0.1055559665,
0.0281909406,
-0.0220598113,
-0.0232523084,
-0.0249724723,
0.039577961,
-0.0573402904,
-0.0503909811,
-0.0292735342,
0.0452855416,
0.0661328882,
0.0101302806,
0.0095668631,
-0.0214558449,
0.0184909217,
-0.0410527363,
0.0512733534,
0.017195601,
-0.0270924158,
-0.0217301901,
-0.043621406,
0.0077137281,
-0.0461787656,
0.0361037701,
-0.0216066707,
-0.0351357982,
0.0018731324,
0.0034251919,
-0.0610660203,
0.0286383983,
-0.0063189073,
-0.0134505508,
0.0185502637,
-0.0162842534,
0.0226255618,
0.0256040748,
-0.0665137395,
0.0023484542,
-0.0249898545,
-0.055354774,
-0.0152791068,
-0.0189067833,
0.0058164173,
-0.0016636178,
0.0120983282,
0.0467136204,
2.696117057e-34,
-0.020521624,
0.0078289686,
0.0123029798,
0.0398213528,
0.0431826077,
0.0180495623,
0.0266765282,
0.0180519558,
0.0010099462,
-0.0764639825,
-0.0409307703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02975v1 | Putting Context in Context: the Impact of Discussion Structure on Text Classification | 2024-02-05T12:56:22 | 2024-02-05T12:56:22 | Nicolò Penzo, Antonio Longa, Bruno Lepri, Sara Tonelli, Marco Guerini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current text classification approaches usually focus on the content to be
classified. Contextual aspects (both linguistic and extra-linguistic) are
usually neglected, even in tasks based on online discussions. Still in many
cases the multi-party and multi-turn nature of the context from which these
elements are selected can be fruitfully exploited. In this work, we propose a
series of experiments on a large dataset for stance detection in English, in
which we evaluate the contribution of different types of contextual
information, i.e. linguistic, structural and temporal, by feeding them as
natural language input into a transformer-based model. We also experiment with
different amounts of training data and analyse the topology of local discussion
networks in a privacy-compliant way. Results show that structural information
can be highly beneficial to text classification but only under certain
circumstances (e.g. depending on the amount of training data and on discussion
chain complexity). Indeed, we show that contextual information on smaller
datasets from other classification tasks does not yield significant
improvements. Our framework, based on local discussion networks, allows the
integration of structural information, while minimising user profiling, thus
preserving their privacy. | [
0.0283114035,
0.0570143275,
0.0219899602,
0.0520255156,
-0.047492601,
-0.0125745134,
0.0585372299,
-0.0125136869,
-0.0047505447,
-0.0653822348,
-0.0377278626,
-0.0034227686,
-0.0016704736,
-0.0122701302,
-0.0114518665,
0.0090374313,
0.0136593264,
0.0204787795,
0.0084259771,
-0.0012134457,
0.0401935987,
0.0385172591,
-0.0233533196,
0.0099136466,
-0.0084044319,
-0.0122517189,
-0.0083353277,
-0.0403819904,
0.0710649639,
0.0037994073,
0.0147963325,
0.0670161843,
0.0157399997,
0.0481951796,
0.0000017058,
-0.022311395,
-0.0401481055,
-0.016140325,
-0.000162809,
-0.0305732451,
0.0471034497,
-0.0419323631,
0.0102754841,
0.0249666888,
-0.0743137747,
0.0064002941,
0.0323758945,
0.0651977286,
0.0682402775,
0.0777878612,
-0.0150467632,
-0.049062714,
-0.0008054913,
-0.0260015875,
-0.0114274677,
-0.0457666032,
0.023599878,
-0.0201289188,
-0.065369077,
0.080699414,
-0.013852369,
0.0060514347,
0.0184090957,
-0.0385794826,
-0.0212447625,
0.0028614372,
-0.0107472567,
-0.0198951978,
0.0015542173,
0.0509364009,
0.0590754412,
-0.0369099937,
0.0134680364,
-0.0120564392,
0.0097852899,
0.060034398,
0.001369415,
0.0464177318,
-0.0442445539,
0.0237756167,
0.0252781026,
0.0451944321,
0.0146411229,
0.0302940104,
0.0052865641,
0.0495296121,
-0.055068858,
-0.001823753,
-0.0126342019,
0.0328273401,
0.02441906,
-0.0425109304,
0.0680085272,
-0.004158109,
-0.0017195751,
0.0323339105,
-0.017546013,
0.0051731714,
0.0207416713,
-0.088743709,
-0.0507540219,
-0.0167086311,
0.0317102633,
0.0486590564,
-0.0009797161,
-0.0175424237,
-0.0493507646,
-0.0242613479,
-0.0062786913,
0.0018385554,
-0.0714978427,
0.0005195089,
-0.0206794534,
0.0358892381,
-0.0769926459,
-0.0142912287,
-0.0385535918,
0.0182170793,
-0.0392822549,
-0.0247636139,
-0.0002225966,
0.0203454942,
0.0008197732,
0.0277444161,
0.002296485,
0.0272633415,
0.0060865963,
0.0273068883,
-0.0205270909,
0.0012410638,
0.0132320393,
0.0106144901,
0.0148586333,
-0.0162357911,
-0.0251810886,
0.0205150675,
0.0126013793,
-0.0087076919,
0.024572067,
-0.0227172077,
-0.0080274474,
-0.0211035181,
-0.0310579743,
-0.0558812097,
0.0357351825,
-0.0017096165,
-0.0011007489,
-0.0096373893,
0.0108865593,
0.0506527349,
0.0140028819,
0.0891798958,
0.0416652523,
-0.0329546779,
0.0443857834,
0.0510788448,
0.0271484032,
0.0356650464,
-0.001314793,
0.0000428606,
0.0470681973,
0.008408796,
-0.0204623267,
-0.0016219454,
0.0455413647,
-0.0248354673,
0.0182916671,
0.0395928323,
-0.0680834204,
-0.037116006,
-0.0458737165,
0.0272049848,
-0.0147282965,
-0.0510745831,
0.0354461856,
0.0534101054,
-0.0041357968,
0.0562200099,
-0.0101411445,
0.0538372435,
-0.0137348445,
-0.0150501812,
-0.0100173512,
0.008687878,
-0.0427488834,
-0.0537665747,
-0.0274464171,
0.0094762836,
-0.0203941744,
-0.0333243906,
0.0124131953,
-0.0212909039,
0.0564065315,
0.0169399716,
0.0211598072,
0.0132202432,
-0.0185799841,
0.0664140135,
0.0240731928,
-0.0411448218,
-0.0197485518,
-0.038280651,
0.0398480073,
-0.0005581876,
-0.0010287621,
-0.0124684013,
-0.0202097706,
-0.048485674,
0.0276995171,
0.0344023108,
0.0346344225,
-0.0425204672,
-0.0053068018,
-0.0169547256,
-0.0233354233,
0.0172468908,
0.0096635846,
0.0254645403,
0.0163624473,
-0.0240184851,
0.0193605237,
0.0323373005,
0.0528277718,
0.000322654,
0.0102235461,
0.0110216485,
0.0145151103,
0.0146980071,
0.0630064234,
0.057267569,
-0.0002711706,
-0.0453540981,
0.0305144712,
-0.0000864676,
-0.0525721051,
0.0137273017,
-0.033553239,
-0.0608344451,
-0.0062685837,
-0.0390202999,
-0.0100409454,
0.0112139834,
-0.0122827217,
-0.016147472,
0.0020998199,
-0.0200694501,
0.0000661692,
-0.040406689,
-0.0400139466,
-0.0229246076,
0.0024749138,
-0.0689227432,
0.0549814403,
-0.0213496592,
0.0153124193,
-0.0088140257,
-0.0358734839,
0.0339033455,
-0.013078996,
-0.0097715305,
-0.0361486673,
0.0035927761,
0.0037365719,
0.0676171035,
-0.0028315941,
-0.0198090672,
-0.0263220295,
-0.1346237063,
-0.0023578652,
-0.0233094972,
0.0594174601,
0.0644092113,
-0.0150430417,
0.0392685011,
0.0056365426,
-0.0611165091,
-0.0235494245,
-0.0436443686,
0.0152522419,
0.0448656231,
0.0195452664,
-0.0122496663,
-0.015316058,
-0.0165078379,
-0.0129622594,
0.0552146062,
0.0208740998,
-0.0723190308,
-0.0191375297,
0.0029890593,
-0.0267870091,
0.0058868793,
-0.0335899293,
-0.0265410282,
0.0153673869,
0.0074718683,
-0.0099290255,
0.0205997489,
0.0301814005,
0.0534590632,
-0.0053725014,
0.0469489731,
-0.0438601039,
-0.0299425106,
-0.0488509126,
0.0572004318,
-0.038057074,
0.0020951901,
0.0411374345,
0.0554981008,
0.0222602729,
-0.0295808613,
-0.0402211808,
0.0340529308,
-0.0252731927,
-0.0232481193,
-0.0088520665,
-0.0287875216,
-0.005517012,
0.0009807352,
-0.0156899001,
-0.0165382493,
0.0643664673,
0.0031869323,
0.014298398,
-0.0459092408,
-0.0569993481,
-0.0467976928,
0.0566099957,
0.0496488139,
0.0249385852,
0.0301924665,
-0.0032137113,
0.0211445745,
-0.0293754134,
0.0407494903,
-0.0210961271,
0.0368031263,
0.00228104,
0.0464549884,
-0.0146384034,
-0.065488331,
-0.0096849501,
-0.0882176831,
-0.0197718963,
-0.0104606245,
0.0091770068,
-0.0402961895,
0.0305813029,
0.0100751612,
-0.0131431716,
0.0336468369,
0.0006058413,
-0.0218504649,
0.0208962355,
0.0515814498,
-0.0485315509,
-0.0158430822,
0.0062414892,
-0.0096504353,
-0.0057004807,
0.0761084333,
0.0044952296,
0.0066953036,
0.0013896017,
-0.0666450709,
-0.0017299791,
-0.0172495395,
-0.0286544394,
-0.0413148813,
0.061584346,
-0.0515001304,
-0.0074318582,
0.0881122127,
0.0476113744,
-0.0629498437,
-0.024304051,
0.0549860932,
-0.0188996103,
0.015404718,
-0.014842472,
-0.0855737701,
-0.006492754,
-0.0376723856,
-0.0031998181,
-0.0364545286,
-0.025143696,
-0.0061546378,
-0.0427579172,
-0.0404755212,
-0.0370400287,
-0.0745467246,
0.0162088647,
-0.0604351163,
0.0098299291,
-0.0528823212,
-0.0157565437,
-0.0415595211,
0.0165148005,
-0.0146341762,
0.0216454621,
-0.0314025506,
-0.0118806474,
0.0026717414,
-0.0080893375,
0.0397199355,
0.0017166915,
0.0239960272,
-0.0176470168,
-0.0252436232,
0.0941820517,
0.0029150306,
0.0165975746,
-0.0130923232,
0.062011864,
-0.0031326707,
0.0192539543,
-0.0534301847,
0.0295137335,
-0.0290541686,
-0.027872989,
-0.0147401998,
0.0321831331,
-0.0129565159,
-0.0077655092,
0.0081330566,
0.0378311314,
0.0275734104,
0.0429424495,
-0.0079733962,
-0.0517640412,
-0.0027644322,
-0.0373702124,
0.0151601993,
-0.0498507991,
-0.0388886631,
-0.0353602394,
-0.0017666542,
0.0300215315,
-0.038767878,
0.0176226441,
-0.0309571214,
0.0242872089,
-0.0121298069,
0.0047474727,
0.065630883,
0.0016104132,
-0.0437553823,
0.0289237946,
-0.0096877962,
0.0332178511,
0.0119442381,
-0.0086230887,
0.0917271897,
0.0094618704,
-0.0317107104,
-0.0363584422,
-0.0781920999,
-0.0577193908,
-0.0147882663,
0.0149633465,
0.0155409593,
0.0465727001,
-0.0192547254,
-0.0298567731,
0.0528834052,
0.0640437901,
-0.0129751367,
0.0004386826,
0.0522970892,
0.0250548795,
-0.0081051337,
0.0190219413,
0.017335942,
0.003589429,
0.0134494314,
-0.0483164601,
-0.0956459939,
-0.0113082714,
-0.0102066137,
-0.0349364914,
0.0454060547,
0.0351007022,
-0.0098745525,
-0.0355543084,
0.0012312182,
-0.0292048194,
-0.0260204729,
-0.0066514979,
-0.0112294825,
0.0301745795,
-0.0443422608,
-0.0254724827,
0.0547461137,
-0.0077045695,
0.075503476,
-0.049954135,
0.0750209093,
0.0955111533,
-0.023140274,
-0.0051058084,
0.0050187008,
-0.0329574235,
-0.0041707498,
0.047979977,
0.0255373232,
0.0054337345,
0.0570777878,
0.0109088887,
-0.0140290847,
0.0156487245,
0.0315584503,
-0.0902839527,
0.0435485952,
-0.0261853132,
-0.0013827053,
-0.0074186451,
-0.0124952821,
0.0200649612,
0.0004575911,
-0.0203365982,
-0.0047354754,
0.0498367958,
-0.0273699891,
-0.0391843319,
0.0295734275,
0.0223340895,
-0.011060508,
0.0348836146,
0.0269331634,
-0.0254978966,
0.0094231181,
0.0460620597,
-0.0429176837,
-0.0470957309,
-0.018004328,
-0.0365372784,
0.0209655352,
-0.0096779186,
0.0114319613,
-0.033402577,
-0.0393789001,
-0.0046943324,
-0.0086740451,
0.0547593795,
0.0128439013,
0.0092110857,
0.0447417088,
0.0100162104,
0.0272127464,
-0.0717209056,
0.0190817378,
0.0065778471,
-0.0017046597,
-0.0438205115,
-5.559444696e-33,
-0.0082046092,
-0.0693569034,
-0.0443680324,
0.037800625,
0.007367244,
0.0338713527,
-0.0046697757,
0.0151269259,
-0.0181052089,
0.0386259407,
0.0026597024,
0.0598051287,
-0.0088052787,
0.0459058881,
-0.0373824164,
-0.018168211,
0.0336513557,
-0.0239282195,
-0.0126465149,
0.0306332391,
0.070395574,
-0.0189181734,
0.0344886258,
-0.1199369654,
0.0689006001,
0.0219131149,
-0.0414631628,
0.0501069799,
-0.0126720648,
0.0792847574,
0.0143987369,
0.0427757725,
0.0584992245,
-0.0332041942,
0.0193300266,
0.0866654888,
-0.0776217952,
-0.0093416534,
-0.0069905631,
0.00182458,
0.0284532495,
-0.0102940528,
0.0314874128,
-0.022564536,
-0.0046624932,
-0.021159675,
0.0234333631,
0.018977236,
0.0070772818,
-0.0894874558,
-0.0088008931,
0.0429397859,
-0.0298583619,
-0.0026943071,
-0.0043527493,
0.0042286958,
0.0171711072,
-0.0181499217,
-0.0589477718,
-0.0027409818,
-0.0475759208,
-0.0191706717,
-0.0063591693,
0.0023895826,
-0.0031554694,
0.034205649,
0.0037130539,
0.047667969,
-0.065421477,
-0.0177192576,
-0.0525967181,
0.0045195133,
0.067942746,
0.0489780866,
-0.0074313036,
-0.0061773974,
-0.0882407203,
-0.001680578,
0.0663161799,
-0.034237612,
0.0472514443,
0.0138891647,
-0.0365864672,
-0.0275555756,
-0.026542265,
-0.0346683152,
-0.0193208344,
0.0146933598,
-0.0458283797,
0.0078931637,
-0.0411441661,
0.0112075387,
0.0077315336,
-0.0747607201,
-0.0294075031,
0.0835625082,
0.0198602285,
0.0127347894,
0.0070454623,
-0.0044323714,
-0.0463599041,
-0.0043587638,
-0.0089482777,
0.0124565288,
0.0306287184,
-0.0214362629,
0.0833291709,
0.0025058012,
-0.0601730868,
-0.038592279,
-0.0137509052,
0.0293972716,
-0.0275454111,
0.1161760017,
0.045144897,
0.0104365228,
-0.0247063711,
0.0752456784,
0.0116008865,
0.0409217998,
0.0043299426,
0.0273183063,
-0.0394870453,
-0.0030150414,
-0.0125049604,
-0.0371391848,
0.0193268955,
0.0499528907,
0.0514686257,
-0.0382033102,
-0.0000580349,
-0.0000267223,
2.449e-7,
0.0303204712,
0.0406891145,
0.0177952629,
-0.0418959931,
0.0714050382,
0.0508378819,
0.0335443355,
0.0337740034,
-0.0159028135,
-0.0120614152,
-0.0099668279,
0.0216572713,
0.0350998975,
0.0473667532,
-0.0900142491,
-0.053351514,
-0.0351666734,
0.0013546142,
0.0031153199,
0.0381969139,
0.0258315504,
0.0693478361,
0.0334004648,
-0.0021424079,
-0.0172522925,
-0.0100177322,
0.0456838645,
-0.0285388641,
-0.016920222,
0.0098725352,
0.0142826298,
-0.0547335967,
-0.0011392775,
-0.0006758718,
-0.0274278801,
0.0247352142,
-0.0382878631,
0.0945326835,
0.0225577503,
-0.0297496654,
-0.0000706449,
-0.0461910069,
0.0117895408,
0.0038486444,
0.0425388813,
-0.0808883384,
-0.0317796096,
-0.059014637,
0.007898937,
-0.030290544,
0.0470467843,
0.0204583947,
0.0088767828,
0.0236608703,
-0.0179256499,
-0.0294388365,
0.0138035174,
-0.0970801935,
-0.0270769,
-0.0265621878,
-0.0393818654,
-0.0303358492,
0.0409674942,
-0.019685898,
0.0185323562,
-0.0006438277,
0.0242938753,
1.827712226e-34,
0.011021588,
-0.0026206197,
-0.0117638903,
0.0070232726,
0.0227962602,
0.013931416,
0.0042410954,
-0.0310163926,
0.0473582745,
-0.046475973,
0.0045183445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02969v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02969v2 | Towards Understanding the Word Sensitivity of Attention Layers: A Study via Random Features | 2024-02-05T12:47:19 | 2024-05-17T15:31:34 | Simone Bombari, Marco Mondelli | stat.ML | stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG | Understanding the reasons behind the exceptional success of transformers
requires a better analysis of why attention layers are suitable for NLP tasks.
In particular, such tasks require predictive models to capture contextual
meaning which often depends on one or few words, even if the sentence is long.
Our work studies this key property, dubbed word sensitivity (WS), in the
prototypical setting of random features. We show that attention layers enjoy
high WS, namely, there exists a vector in the space of embeddings that largely
perturbs the random attention features map. The argument critically exploits
the role of the softmax in the attention layer, highlighting its benefit
compared to other activations (e.g., ReLU). In contrast, the WS of standard
random features is of order $1/\sqrt{n}$, $n$ being the number of words in the
textual sample, and thus it decays with the length of the context. We then
translate these results on the word sensitivity into generalization bounds: due
to their low WS, random features provably cannot learn to distinguish between
two sentences that differ only in a single word; in contrast, due to their high
WS, random attention features have higher generalization capabilities. We
validate our theoretical results with experimental evidence over the BERT-Base
word embeddings of the imdb review dataset. | [
0.0398166105,
0.000717213,
-0.0036885878,
0.0265751705,
0.0114382459,
-0.0011607014,
-0.0138636678,
0.0186217446,
-0.0443657897,
-0.0490113609,
-0.009133121,
-0.0631891489,
0.0164083354,
0.0228302032,
0.0188161358,
-0.0420203097,
0.027843168,
0.0244543441,
0.0331060514,
0.0012173161,
0.0124673825,
-0.0092391996,
0.0282309577,
0.0515594333,
-0.0078682378,
0.0080532664,
0.0307884775,
0.000162578,
0.028774919,
-0.005718024,
0.0068128486,
0.0795081928,
0.0312862955,
0.0378327109,
0.0000014951,
-0.0571243279,
0.0081308996,
-0.0156831257,
0.0321349017,
0.0122555699,
0.0118754385,
-0.0174982175,
0.0002095323,
0.0074684322,
-0.011863023,
0.0095463516,
0.0654690936,
0.0837702751,
-0.021322364,
0.069452174,
-0.0150308758,
-0.025095135,
-0.0053850375,
-0.0450163856,
0.0333406143,
-0.0573705807,
0.0052252235,
-0.062772207,
0.000882284,
-0.0107218623,
-0.0719502941,
0.0020473991,
0.0013793452,
0.009634763,
0.0632475987,
0.0578473359,
-0.0813260004,
0.0019400164,
-0.0005112744,
0.1081722602,
-0.0504020751,
-0.0088953171,
-0.0386714935,
0.0068282266,
0.0056451424,
0.0054565533,
-0.0350481384,
0.0093288152,
0.0211716834,
0.0111091174,
-0.0224655215,
0.0363400578,
0.0291696582,
-0.0022116248,
-0.0071583297,
0.0339541398,
0.033892788,
-0.0211504381,
-0.0029786089,
0.041367095,
-0.007550396,
-0.0239574946,
0.0010127227,
0.033226423,
0.017016869,
0.0050068442,
-0.0670390278,
-0.0299056582,
0.0170865841,
-0.0853256136,
0.0571053922,
-0.0076401602,
-0.0543499216,
0.0566404201,
-0.0171038099,
0.0508630127,
-0.0396057181,
0.0367218591,
0.003541172,
0.0220480785,
-0.014242867,
0.0021491491,
-0.0219010115,
0.009068816,
-0.0158299096,
-0.0350242369,
-0.0233440269,
0.0189789124,
-0.0224158335,
-0.012783831,
-0.0058931578,
0.0304759853,
-0.0550217256,
-0.021994235,
-0.0080470843,
0.0369183719,
-0.0432213023,
0.0265837759,
-0.0295984857,
-0.0183074791,
-0.035898678,
0.01331593,
0.0496919565,
-0.0205184687,
0.0064260978,
0.0816578194,
-0.008833237,
-0.0751859546,
-0.0159485862,
0.0036088112,
-0.0536003448,
-0.0141368834,
0.0207629725,
-0.0405855067,
0.0205491111,
0.0241767764,
-0.0135976793,
0.0062126643,
0.0153307766,
0.0180462915,
-0.0480508208,
0.0514942221,
0.0466271341,
-0.0073019704,
-0.0060648713,
0.0030713505,
0.0070378808,
0.0653485656,
0.0111558968,
-0.0011795355,
0.0478071757,
-0.0106673185,
0.0335616469,
0.0199782867,
-0.0056412276,
0.0208147373,
-0.0096003795,
0.0098000607,
-0.0249258634,
0.0211508572,
0.0497977659,
0.0302028172,
-0.0065479907,
-0.0478113517,
0.0691457689,
0.0676089823,
-0.0085943593,
0.0525929779,
-0.0051949155,
0.0371842124,
-0.0174359661,
0.0308878217,
-0.0522899739,
0.0706791729,
0.0123712979,
-0.0044422178,
0.0055575636,
-0.001502858,
-0.0385607257,
0.0141411955,
-0.028883988,
-0.0036785386,
0.0300981645,
-0.053779535,
0.0609088689,
0.0478006117,
-0.0298210308,
0.077939406,
0.0336634405,
-0.0354997888,
0.0227252878,
-0.0333246328,
0.0094247824,
0.0209672991,
0.022184385,
-0.0355052873,
0.0172139779,
-0.0149291893,
-0.0147123532,
0.0613489933,
0.0530028231,
0.0076500531,
0.0219247788,
-0.0211058762,
-0.003853257,
-0.0563778616,
0.0348973945,
0.0272647813,
-0.0056725028,
0.0173703432,
0.0070875864,
-0.0507832132,
-0.0098233838,
0.0240162518,
0.0126023004,
-0.0662500337,
-0.0223652069,
0.0286187977,
0.0151825128,
0.0370758064,
-0.0265358929,
0.0288398601,
0.0060701729,
-0.0261952262,
-0.0325071402,
-0.0028998067,
0.0084451335,
0.0046578245,
-0.0083607379,
-0.0894009247,
0.0119337654,
0.0942059979,
-0.0179883782,
-0.017768532,
0.0262872409,
-0.0307750814,
0.0575766936,
-0.0104089938,
-0.0038821069,
-0.0167003386,
0.0955562964,
-0.0264813639,
0.0526746772,
0.0085417982,
0.0482115373,
-0.0214567278,
-0.0142881339,
0.0239597894,
-0.0353889614,
-0.0471821465,
0.0109699713,
-0.022358058,
0.0111713158,
0.027032556,
-0.0313879699,
-0.028748747,
-0.0010703232,
-0.0538701527,
-0.0416362248,
-0.0351401828,
0.0177768208,
0.0352667868,
0.0128905037,
0.0057231453,
-0.0351560488,
-0.0196812097,
-0.0111774066,
-0.0405667536,
0.0565785803,
0.062778689,
-0.0081099933,
-0.0166407954,
-0.0371005945,
-0.0341821909,
-0.0036892814,
0.0649002492,
0.0105903614,
-0.0059418203,
-0.0327522457,
-0.00626306,
-0.0028495956,
0.0221248176,
0.0060306378,
-0.0474426001,
-0.0060658823,
-0.0078982292,
0.0062663886,
0.0902708471,
0.0322914347,
0.0386402383,
0.0314865038,
0.0054450156,
-0.0141764004,
0.0216366332,
-0.0289284084,
0.0039233714,
-0.0562850088,
-0.014999155,
0.0095318528,
0.0715553015,
-0.0150261084,
-0.0248994492,
-0.06669797,
-0.0027786179,
-0.0026411274,
-0.0150599936,
0.0026115174,
0.023695685,
-0.0314676911,
0.0142765446,
-0.0363811925,
-0.0198474173,
0.0476082712,
0.0000458589,
0.0047744699,
-0.0501408577,
0.0104882345,
-0.0323631354,
0.0627299994,
0.0061253789,
0.0181386415,
-0.0323529132,
-0.0474796146,
-0.0499569587,
0.0150417816,
0.0093325311,
-0.0193195026,
0.0674550459,
0.0401307531,
-0.0160193425,
-0.0419168696,
-0.0203432571,
-0.0119224312,
-0.0692172945,
-0.0270501319,
-0.0104915947,
0.0399198644,
-0.0538438261,
-0.0101433415,
0.0028305689,
0.006994714,
0.0310477819,
-0.0065558036,
-0.0106757004,
0.0030932389,
0.0571182966,
0.0591167659,
0.0205564015,
0.0276403464,
0.0017180599,
0.0022142883,
0.0301907621,
0.0271518119,
0.0161233451,
-0.033592429,
-0.018746322,
0.0375796929,
-0.050292246,
-0.0053450256,
-0.0047883415,
0.0746560991,
-0.0417304002,
-0.0162805654,
0.0566305369,
-0.0059575224,
-0.075263828,
0.0194076411,
-0.0139673483,
-0.0035808175,
0.0460668616,
0.0212752316,
-0.0333818607,
-0.0422719046,
-0.0256259795,
-0.0081489226,
0.0187094714,
-0.0120679224,
-0.0193386171,
-0.0947378427,
0.0078250403,
-0.0328673236,
-0.0390904732,
-0.0798495784,
-0.016944021,
0.0456511863,
0.0120389862,
0.0247409344,
-0.0330465063,
-0.0067553567,
-0.0030327074,
0.0048875446,
0.0045543136,
-0.0501164086,
0.0487250015,
-0.0315294974,
0.029997725,
0.0746756271,
0.0213572551,
-0.0574476272,
-0.0339562297,
0.0063174078,
0.0082821213,
-0.0117705148,
0.0466671735,
0.0641983896,
-0.0042775474,
-0.0022244966,
-0.0050245994,
-0.0080176098,
-0.0043917098,
-0.0149379848,
-0.0492694676,
0.0557000786,
0.0198823027,
-0.0627697185,
-0.0581729636,
0.0031706013,
-0.00799728,
0.0652262419,
0.0387053415,
-0.0695859939,
-0.0332505703,
-0.0000653184,
0.0128271012,
-0.0575168692,
-0.0403457172,
0.0184963476,
-0.0109820897,
-0.050152868,
-0.0505490266,
-0.0450215042,
-0.0324031524,
0.0125764133,
0.0079911249,
-0.0340618677,
-0.0221147221,
0.010586123,
-0.0076210857,
0.0455477275,
0.0170696508,
0.0201598816,
-0.0140337748,
0.0041922187,
0.0100103859,
-0.0214167498,
-0.0495116785,
-0.0110840937,
-0.0985917971,
-0.0432671085,
0.0415150784,
-0.0268586464,
0.0183042847,
0.0092811203,
-0.0339825563,
-0.0769837499,
0.0622479692,
0.0156881306,
-0.0183200222,
0.043575827,
0.0310496297,
-0.0218907315,
-0.0100529846,
0.0527957529,
-0.076412648,
0.0242135152,
0.0275150631,
0.0367892236,
0.0191504806,
-0.0370604098,
-0.0253243074,
-0.0349065252,
0.0618003532,
0.0158007164,
0.0321926326,
-0.0208886303,
0.006870131,
0.058414977,
0.0180006083,
-0.0409648716,
-0.045294866,
0.0316100791,
-0.016563192,
-0.0332206972,
0.0231296998,
-0.0092879636,
0.0161746796,
-0.0288800001,
0.0223656595,
0.0316344984,
-0.0409539081,
0.0268021226,
0.030776538,
-0.0494117476,
0.0117940456,
-0.013165215,
0.0066983975,
0.0286242068,
0.0225402713,
0.0105730714,
-0.0114705171,
-0.0468787327,
-0.0180010684,
-0.0879957601,
-0.0063072233,
-0.007259375,
0.0230083279,
0.013277798,
-0.0673928112,
-0.0026720024,
0.0040939418,
-0.0223954059,
-0.0081559764,
-0.0044051781,
-0.0187503844,
-0.0118515305,
0.0543932207,
0.0080374731,
-0.0015615468,
0.0192595348,
0.0943130404,
-0.0061450577,
-0.0113897016,
0.0077198478,
-0.0382877551,
-0.0190097988,
0.0137073984,
0.0449608415,
0.0298495851,
0.0015521804,
0.044318445,
-0.048015669,
-0.0634440705,
0.0551642627,
-0.0412700064,
0.0266905632,
-0.0019903353,
0.0195144322,
0.0720263571,
0.0246482659,
-0.0142973252,
-0.0036928048,
0.0013514963,
0.00719736,
0.0084301895,
-0.0209757071,
-5.982721478e-33,
0.0113221202,
-0.0029943599,
-0.0774433613,
0.0044374382,
-0.0171980094,
0.0182820149,
-0.0062498879,
0.010277275,
-0.0532538146,
0.0468216687,
-0.032858368,
0.0538209006,
0.0068020606,
0.0279718675,
-0.0040694876,
-0.0772631615,
0.0406012014,
0.0073651588,
-0.0213772766,
0.0151565019,
0.0455104038,
0.025273364,
0.0982383937,
0.0011077761,
0.0326659642,
-0.0156948082,
-0.0005478911,
0.0030299379,
0.0359546281,
0.0641161576,
-0.0187097732,
0.0738971755,
0.0391930006,
-0.0579698458,
-0.0211972054,
0.0647402108,
-0.0799471661,
-0.0503953993,
-0.0059648608,
0.0208553988,
-0.028006101,
-0.0168091785,
0.069247067,
-0.0024873603,
0.0112211108,
-0.0876952484,
0.063065052,
-0.0020872185,
-0.0351244323,
-0.0438268296,
-0.0631776452,
0.0240562148,
0.0022740103,
0.0128620015,
-0.0288836714,
0.0077702804,
0.0211941451,
0.0465037413,
-0.0484368354,
-0.0090929717,
-0.0072258026,
0.0713979304,
0.0058941282,
0.0179389231,
-0.0570811071,
0.0335018486,
0.007879436,
0.0098543847,
-0.017998036,
-0.0593014359,
-0.0092251105,
0.0001520707,
0.0223531611,
0.0403931066,
0.0633503869,
-0.0110582793,
-0.0764779523,
-0.0448540337,
-0.0299218502,
0.0222995635,
0.0937917382,
-0.0063380636,
-0.0357602313,
0.0233260859,
-0.0387537293,
-0.006787607,
-0.0569572672,
-0.0081964098,
0.0149487313,
0.0312946178,
0.0224220324,
0.0231023487,
0.021031443,
-0.0461126342,
0.0205316134,
0.0270440746,
-0.0048588272,
0.0061627077,
0.0240941364,
-0.0219331104,
-0.0184141695,
0.0230778493,
-0.0074452171,
0.0121782934,
-0.0011087161,
-0.0089661302,
0.0621004067,
0.030217072,
-0.0670403019,
-0.0242885631,
-0.0312558077,
-0.0248840805,
-0.0138014518,
0.0749592111,
0.0342346504,
-0.0096186791,
-0.0383334272,
0.0611068532,
0.0139106363,
0.066727519,
0.0007824868,
-0.0069172177,
-0.0150503321,
0.013353412,
-0.0329591334,
-0.0352798104,
-0.0342681818,
0.0302033033,
0.0075943139,
-0.0730440244,
-0.0214335993,
0.0209895112,
2.407e-7,
0.041988723,
0.0150273591,
-0.0054109786,
-0.0015869373,
0.0207982678,
0.0328500979,
0.0251687821,
0.1041772366,
-0.008185708,
0.008572909,
-0.0182420257,
-0.0077853762,
-0.0084515,
-0.034927588,
-0.0751551762,
-0.0196434483,
-0.0669865012,
0.0660897791,
-0.0054902388,
-0.0281953383,
-0.0001859794,
0.116823405,
0.0226492863,
0.0027972022,
0.0061705303,
-0.0631665811,
0.043958962,
-0.0342498012,
0.0198698081,
0.0000240889,
0.0685838461,
-0.0133890957,
-0.0065673729,
0.009871495,
-0.0515806079,
0.0539819635,
0.0272364877,
0.036916431,
-0.0465921536,
-0.053792119,
-0.0003059201,
-0.0194214564,
0.014616739,
-0.0437295958,
0.055840414,
-0.0614955723,
-0.0461200625,
-0.0391405374,
-0.00967017,
0.005518984,
0.0225350019,
-0.0216278452,
0.0195376482,
-0.0270255767,
0.0103929918,
-0.0006991678,
-0.0213063844,
-0.1247794628,
-0.0224043205,
0.0325862505,
-0.0435162075,
-0.0259959698,
-0.043091327,
-0.032136593,
0.0697219595,
-0.018558301,
-0.011493383,
1.823931703e-34,
0.0631363094,
0.0040296214,
-0.0227367468,
-0.0169491451,
-0.009128144,
-0.0309550371,
-0.0044248989,
-0.037086986,
0.0471722409,
-0.0544722266,
-0.0101293763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05964v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05964v2 | A Survey on Transformer Compression | 2024-02-05T12:16:28 | 2024-04-07T13:03:58 | Yehui Tang, Yunhe Wang, Jianyuan Guo, Zhijun Tu, Kai Han, Hailin Hu, Dacheng Tao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Transformer plays a vital role in the realms of natural language processing
(NLP) and computer vision (CV), specially for constructing large language
models (LLM) and large vision models (LVM). Model compression methods reduce
the memory and computational cost of Transformer, which is a necessary step to
implement large language/vision models on practical devices. Given the unique
architecture of Transformer, featuring alternative attention and feedforward
neural network (FFN) modules, specific compression techniques are usually
required. The efficiency of these compression methods is also paramount, as
retraining large models on the entire training dataset is usually impractical.
This survey provides a comprehensive review of recent compression methods, with
a specific focus on their application to Transformer-based models. The
compression methods are primarily categorized into pruning, quantization,
knowledge distillation, and efficient architecture design (Mamba, RetNet, RWKV,
etc.). In each category, we discuss compression methods for both language and
vision tasks, highlighting common underlying principles. Finally, we delve into
the relation between various compression methods, and discuss further
directions in this domain. | [
-0.0059693763,
0.0617915504,
-0.0106184538,
0.0529135838,
-0.0399047583,
-0.0023352657,
-0.0055797882,
0.0349424817,
-0.0325840488,
0.0008116351,
-0.032917399,
-0.0075392937,
0.0524115264,
-0.0001344703,
-0.0041539557,
-0.0438391231,
0.0168982726,
0.0107481694,
-0.038385056,
0.0114131328,
-0.0170863569,
-0.0038877553,
0.0481070727,
0.0565081649,
-0.0221634377,
-0.0153197702,
-0.0342453495,
0.0056680338,
0.0074733878,
0.0135261463,
-0.0095981378,
0.039898105,
0.0155122308,
0.0126290508,
0.0000020115,
0.0150565747,
0.0144445077,
-0.0022574924,
-0.0452254973,
0.0075452705,
0.0355219133,
-0.0730525628,
0.0010340887,
0.0193106905,
-0.0181393195,
-0.0743983537,
0.0643969327,
0.0742382556,
0.0386846401,
0.0604176782,
0.0002842693,
-0.0729350597,
0.043043144,
-0.0352380015,
-0.0392511562,
0.0140925366,
0.0050544147,
-0.0103761181,
-0.0555722006,
0.026543241,
-0.0492807925,
0.0372413732,
0.055405993,
0.0343036391,
0.0058548595,
0.0156305935,
-0.054865066,
-0.0431042723,
-0.0050336276,
0.0333981514,
-0.0741712824,
-0.0497856289,
-0.0143990684,
0.0216115266,
-0.006723946,
-0.0172958355,
-0.0432857871,
0.0414748825,
0.0265870281,
0.0398170501,
-0.0397856273,
-0.007717038,
0.0300497729,
-0.0247647706,
-0.0267580319,
-0.005223501,
0.0091604581,
0.0172222946,
-0.0203893911,
-0.0056738551,
-0.0238293819,
-0.0623955168,
-0.0145315472,
0.0370732956,
0.03771016,
-0.0285495259,
-0.0711152703,
-0.0420598052,
-0.0145590678,
-0.0273743402,
0.0497779772,
0.0430607013,
0.0004743073,
0.0210649054,
-0.0467397571,
0.0761516318,
-0.0324084796,
0.0305671021,
-0.0347213671,
-0.0180888604,
-0.025128372,
-0.0153792696,
-0.0625857338,
0.0231331419,
-0.0328037031,
-0.0164794978,
-0.038715478,
-0.0095593026,
0.0107903881,
-0.023573542,
0.0405376516,
0.0133105107,
-0.0356614701,
-0.0040923115,
0.0186395328,
0.0596138388,
0.0179433823,
-0.0018675532,
-0.0040409043,
-0.0632698536,
-0.0293673109,
0.0343324579,
0.0014072009,
-0.0117028048,
0.002846889,
0.0290953964,
0.0083892997,
-0.0667214394,
-0.0240096655,
0.0103248311,
-0.0116279079,
-0.044666294,
0.0402280316,
-0.0680526271,
0.0431813449,
-0.0518956073,
0.0110080419,
-0.0207186807,
0.0190139171,
0.0370036364,
-0.0355524793,
0.044825051,
0.0327433906,
0.0043432182,
0.0151438806,
0.0078800507,
0.0336757861,
0.0524540432,
0.058263842,
0.0285624228,
-0.0223330911,
-0.0393718667,
-0.002689674,
0.0305326451,
0.0431198254,
-0.0186635181,
-0.034314502,
-0.022234384,
-0.0339652821,
-0.0076857717,
0.0346309543,
0.0738093108,
-0.0536948591,
-0.0514652766,
0.0571908765,
0.0344862081,
0.0744792819,
0.0627899915,
0.0314127505,
0.0085153133,
0.019998217,
-0.0045186528,
-0.0408078209,
0.0411713235,
-0.00521413,
-0.0076763635,
-0.0512255207,
0.0668615177,
-0.0531898998,
-0.0433152691,
-0.0112635773,
-0.0353290774,
0.0380016863,
0.0115993731,
0.0269314684,
0.0405866839,
-0.0156414304,
0.1140878573,
-0.0058319191,
-0.0408160128,
-0.0374450311,
-0.0764997825,
-0.0419773236,
0.000247055,
0.0244324394,
0.0163884554,
-0.0078803599,
0.0045747529,
-0.0090407757,
-0.0044740546,
0.003687202,
0.0248945057,
0.0338817202,
-0.0528726093,
-0.0065887836,
0.0062321844,
0.0005765636,
-0.0055510295,
0.0411238372,
-0.0034752013,
0.0243539177,
-0.017538676,
-0.0112069845,
0.0390402041,
0.0200101677,
-0.0286684353,
0.032199353,
0.0155473324,
0.014967015,
-0.0289040357,
0.0063183666,
-0.0105217714,
0.068904832,
-0.0446476638,
0.0184537545,
0.0097093713,
-0.0343240164,
-0.0539995544,
0.036361821,
-0.0432705954,
0.0678802133,
0.0882592946,
-0.0378183164,
-0.0251762755,
-0.0027932343,
-0.0626639575,
0.0379304066,
-0.0267338641,
0.0244130958,
-0.0014518691,
0.0625990704,
0.0160916597,
0.0338882543,
-0.0442438684,
-0.0227206368,
0.0080647282,
-0.0475517958,
-0.0142258098,
-0.0171551798,
-0.038955383,
0.0176289249,
-0.0315750539,
0.0031589665,
0.0113359224,
-0.0100899106,
0.0067199818,
-0.0289263856,
-0.0660352334,
-0.005996658,
-0.0343137048,
0.0017887182,
-0.0044636917,
0.0388219319,
0.0392434485,
0.0062776753,
-0.006500626,
0.0352729894,
0.0147508131,
0.0010020402,
-0.0024038379,
-0.0257348269,
-0.0301096831,
0.0093230475,
-0.0678534955,
0.0305780973,
0.0904316753,
-0.0515585616,
-0.0202757102,
-0.0450772047,
0.0268844943,
0.0095409565,
0.0240461156,
-0.0211727712,
-0.0576201491,
-0.0276251137,
0.0123343375,
0.0246125516,
0.0788197741,
0.0132853277,
0.0580445603,
0.0614754856,
0.0134429894,
-0.0124311363,
0.017843442,
-0.0501981564,
-0.0401812755,
-0.0204563346,
-0.0442078784,
-0.0148101263,
0.0764133036,
-0.038876541,
-0.0047138678,
-0.0658336207,
-0.0406550653,
-0.0004347787,
-0.041896414,
0.0119130127,
-0.0130361877,
-0.0148739675,
0.0147034153,
-0.0209365245,
-0.0368259773,
0.0097760689,
-0.047589004,
0.0031747641,
-0.0038079561,
-0.0157924592,
-0.0159040298,
0.0595630445,
0.043358624,
0.0389856771,
-0.0034164132,
0.0187736172,
-0.0388590097,
-0.009648229,
0.0030728164,
-0.0327136256,
0.0484461077,
-0.0068696085,
-0.014318279,
-0.0336678103,
-0.0218381584,
-0.0131068742,
0.0018818146,
0.0036376242,
0.0334723704,
0.0186011493,
-0.0035023305,
-0.0590256564,
0.0508236848,
0.0114816781,
0.0460987352,
0.0142798778,
-0.012779301,
0.0038856578,
0.0499744192,
0.023863988,
0.042241361,
0.043223504,
0.0056858882,
0.0059610647,
0.0706481636,
0.0158452317,
0.0324331224,
-0.0753010958,
-0.0118277865,
0.029340148,
0.0041001546,
-0.0288148578,
0.0194606632,
0.0408453122,
-0.0916491523,
0.0028141353,
0.0623451546,
0.0064482815,
-0.0209291913,
0.0107817268,
0.0321214944,
0.0259676911,
-0.0109773949,
0.038754493,
-0.0527983047,
-0.0182510708,
0.019648144,
-0.0076410221,
0.0116358744,
-0.0062196204,
-0.0075156777,
-0.0708618462,
0.0293764863,
0.0271110516,
0.0090851383,
-0.0565604977,
-0.012414081,
-0.0278675407,
-0.0281613898,
-0.0170551892,
-0.0074950512,
-0.0231084339,
-0.0263919327,
0.0039287573,
-0.0238173269,
-0.0321908481,
-0.0107985968,
0.0055673136,
-0.016828388,
0.0339342579,
0.0065275128,
0.0010806198,
-0.0487781987,
-0.0221988745,
0.0168716721,
0.035303589,
-0.0121618286,
0.0396213494,
-0.0040518646,
-0.0226664525,
0.01092395,
0.0199027751,
-0.0140697891,
-0.0376578681,
-0.0599320456,
0.0533112474,
0.0050501646,
-0.0379293226,
-0.0132393334,
-0.0226360895,
-0.0470175967,
0.0637475848,
0.0271739028,
-0.003922306,
-0.0351924151,
0.0168667194,
0.0016934382,
-0.0232227594,
-0.0538545176,
0.0229337029,
0.030952774,
-0.0831144899,
-0.0435730666,
-0.0174294561,
0.0031205264,
0.0136774797,
-0.011461311,
-0.0740374625,
0.0538860522,
0.018093884,
-0.1068804041,
0.0244104024,
-0.0408884622,
-0.0025867024,
-0.0379586071,
0.0301695112,
0.0046930443,
-0.0283429381,
-0.016170606,
-0.0044954116,
-0.1506760716,
-0.0270988066,
0.0136739584,
0.0733540133,
0.0208271593,
0.0472392179,
0.0183253847,
-0.0315700732,
0.0255726092,
0.0439785942,
-0.0296095908,
0.0654417574,
0.0315986238,
-0.0572086424,
0.0122938119,
0.0393278338,
-0.00496038,
0.0364989229,
0.0159803014,
0.0146783926,
-0.035001345,
-0.0488054976,
0.0154011631,
-0.0114781791,
0.0546063855,
0.0092423866,
0.0392609388,
0.0315318108,
0.0403303616,
0.0380398892,
0.0346871428,
-0.0633618683,
0.0122122671,
0.0214703754,
0.0348557904,
0.0224788915,
0.0214564782,
0.0589259639,
-0.0534099191,
0.0057467641,
0.0045326701,
-0.0071605276,
-0.0398777798,
0.0186904166,
0.0496056974,
-0.0254848283,
-0.017554136,
0.0062226322,
0.0189157929,
-0.0180417225,
0.019481374,
0.0167326182,
0.0279221907,
-0.0711167753,
0.04632961,
-0.0396000594,
-0.049174957,
-0.0307723749,
0.0257907677,
0.0229984727,
-0.0317769162,
0.0029866947,
-0.0363247618,
-0.0104464376,
-0.0366529487,
0.0343495198,
0.0101455711,
-0.0018272543,
0.0128008928,
0.0047677178,
-0.0129492572,
-0.0401366055,
0.0749343708,
-0.0058857398,
0.0318329185,
0.0016113137,
-0.0053252443,
-0.0409657098,
-0.0308922827,
-0.0243060105,
-0.0187295675,
0.0237849243,
-0.0117806001,
-0.0343957469,
-0.0495357774,
0.0336685702,
-0.0171131529,
0.0173943471,
-0.0230207909,
0.0476876311,
0.0082018627,
0.0362847261,
-0.0171348155,
0.0050094733,
-0.0326232724,
-0.024024738,
-0.0088792583,
0.0216348805,
-5.86454352e-33,
-0.0137399388,
0.0103140082,
0.020209251,
-0.0103096245,
-0.0589041039,
0.0375081487,
-0.0083585847,
-0.0152081717,
-0.0499791317,
0.0114481477,
-0.0299999267,
0.0168630145,
0.0114797913,
0.0521924384,
-0.0335828513,
-0.0089367917,
0.080062747,
-0.008658384,
-0.0302187074,
0.0130208135,
0.0033031078,
0.0126118585,
0.04386333,
-0.0037058792,
-0.0719989687,
0.0119262366,
0.0199242141,
0.0018149981,
0.0031117469,
0.0517643131,
-0.0366506949,
0.0114842113,
0.0233513657,
-0.0472877994,
-0.0233670436,
0.0487379991,
-0.0937447026,
0.0019287884,
-0.0076376558,
0.0418157429,
-0.0527677163,
-0.0336585306,
0.0782453418,
0.0195266157,
-0.0001462615,
-0.0609596297,
-0.0043514944,
-0.0290353093,
-0.0517469831,
-0.044233311,
-0.0211435724,
-0.0046213847,
-0.0010597943,
-0.0432954617,
0.0714826584,
0.033911895,
-0.0425397418,
0.0242526457,
-0.0842964947,
0.0005714526,
0.0153086577,
0.0767623261,
0.0545280352,
0.0176357366,
0.0300853346,
0.017715795,
0.0271182917,
-0.0445319526,
-0.0505317897,
0.0274139456,
0.0371995978,
0.0498409234,
0.0664402544,
0.0195876993,
0.060853105,
-0.0376517065,
-0.0644258261,
-0.0114653809,
-0.0300954413,
0.1067584455,
-0.0002756589,
0.0112402691,
0.0180833749,
-0.0179968439,
-0.0213747229,
-0.0064611039,
-0.0117101474,
-0.0028328546,
0.0225723591,
0.0453582592,
-0.0467220768,
0.0264703464,
0.0427361839,
-0.0665938556,
0.033925347,
0.029039083,
0.015432056,
0.0547202677,
0.0163532794,
0.0201485194,
-0.0397700742,
0.0059695323,
0.0273735598,
0.0075682928,
0.0170366745,
-0.0001678528,
0.0434208103,
0.0738488063,
-0.0576837212,
-0.0157052688,
-0.0282420795,
0.009011534,
0.0116549674,
0.067863591,
0.051668942,
0.0271532945,
0.0029407351,
0.0091391271,
-0.020915281,
-0.0061538895,
-0.0169321522,
0.036876604,
0.0651743636,
0.0452066027,
-0.015151266,
-0.0014023617,
-0.06407585,
0.0263505485,
0.0365119651,
-0.058367271,
-0.0382887349,
0.0677590296,
2.66e-7,
0.0135142365,
0.0230581965,
0.0067594498,
-0.0209697988,
0.0252337363,
0.0218184274,
0.0478003919,
0.0256713871,
-0.0113837812,
-0.0051999073,
0.0192126036,
0.0520993471,
0.0515125729,
-0.0138593502,
-0.0593748055,
-0.0129965935,
-0.0358974934,
-0.0194592457,
0.0018997696,
-0.0154625457,
0.0219944809,
0.1185385883,
-0.0087433979,
-0.0134547083,
0.0260897782,
0.0086883539,
0.0516000651,
-0.0191978235,
0.0462859049,
-0.0003466183,
0.0258142296,
0.0182150863,
-0.0481786728,
-0.0011293206,
0.0018046873,
-0.0082089137,
-0.0091349222,
0.0713242739,
-0.020299444,
-0.0133282291,
0.0025871356,
0.0231428128,
-0.0674093589,
-0.0429073982,
0.061900638,
-0.0703051835,
-0.0154960454,
-0.0476414002,
-0.008638341,
-0.0073388186,
-0.0036464592,
0.0035049093,
0.0301875602,
0.0067976932,
0.0256108027,
-0.0137229739,
-0.0252018292,
-0.0707724243,
-0.014430901,
-0.0071202689,
-0.0363745727,
-0.0054939194,
-0.0648092553,
-0.0340862423,
0.0567525923,
0.0026948804,
-0.0581708886,
2.435608683e-34,
-0.0006205206,
-0.0170779433,
0.0142779555,
0.0243487153,
-0.0386533923,
-0.0396361165,
0.004633863,
0.0074684899,
-0.0482774526,
-0.1027073786,
-0.0340003781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05128v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05128v2 | Enhancing Textbook Question Answering Task with Large Language Models and Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-02-05T11:58:56 | 2024-02-14T10:06:54 | Hessa Abdulrahman Alawwad, Areej Alhothali, Usman Naseem, Ali Alkhathlan, Amani Jamal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Textbook question answering (TQA) is a challenging task in artificial
intelligence due to the complex nature of context and multimodal data. Although
previous research has significantly improved the task, there are still some
limitations including the models' weak reasoning and inability to capture
contextual information in the lengthy context. The introduction of large
language models (LLMs) has revolutionized the field of AI, however, directly
applying LLMs often leads to inaccurate answers. This paper proposes a
methodology that handle the out-of-domain scenario in TQA where concepts are
spread across different lessons by incorporating the retrieval augmented
generation (RAG) technique and utilize transfer learning to handle the long
context and enhance reasoning abilities. Through supervised fine-tuning of the
LLM model Llama-2 and the incorporation of RAG, our architecture outperforms
the baseline, achieving a 4.12% accuracy improvement on validation set and
9.84% on test set for non-diagram multiple-choice questions. | [
0.0423925221,
-0.0134431198,
-0.0272219367,
0.0464404933,
-0.0272090677,
-0.0064657084,
0.009351436,
-0.0301368106,
-0.0034528947,
-0.0875041261,
-0.0507477224,
-0.0175315514,
-0.0412199274,
0.0036413812,
0.0285528619,
-0.0334314257,
0.0394582674,
-0.0253456403,
-0.0329665989,
0.0069454098,
-0.0092849713,
0.0152823115,
-0.0107290465,
-0.0148420092,
0.0164288152,
-0.0396182612,
-0.0087686395,
-0.0087821027,
0.0197428074,
-0.0120968828,
0.0244262721,
0.0033477135,
0.0190653503,
-0.0290377215,
0.0000019206,
-0.068452999,
-0.0401973687,
-0.0003202911,
-0.0265095644,
0.0205475651,
0.0358345136,
0.0523161255,
0.0291039441,
0.0069553251,
-0.0419993028,
0.0443819277,
0.0016878062,
0.0523707569,
0.0678744912,
0.0569455102,
0.0091802217,
-0.0103548653,
0.0376017205,
0.0257313456,
0.042360574,
-0.0777779743,
0.0421100222,
0.055738993,
0.0541603789,
0.0424536094,
-0.0429918133,
0.0473729037,
0.019976465,
0.0083513577,
0.0017473161,
0.0089412685,
-0.0163840037,
0.046591565,
0.0112881185,
0.1124370098,
0.0271876212,
-0.0008029323,
-0.0357662924,
0.0291350111,
0.0187283829,
0.041484084,
-0.0851520747,
0.0158614703,
-0.0269273538,
-0.0037715014,
-0.0071521355,
-0.0234185699,
0.0104496172,
0.0252186321,
-0.0466156714,
0.0290615559,
0.0154940905,
-0.0304561835,
0.0121155893,
0.0071344501,
-0.0564626046,
0.0059071588,
0.0148140676,
0.0929022357,
-0.0161113329,
0.035633292,
-0.0019632494,
-0.0386625007,
0.0141611705,
0.0023183522,
0.0064316746,
0.0302817915,
-0.0465641171,
0.0478634499,
-0.0555351414,
0.0600837991,
-0.0097741438,
0.0263489485,
-0.0793288648,
-0.0415761918,
-0.0571320914,
-0.0312814973,
-0.0332321003,
0.0648157299,
-0.0335353091,
-0.0442243516,
-0.0416995324,
0.026599085,
0.0095427744,
-0.0136896092,
0.0036816874,
0.0437649488,
-0.0343579203,
-0.0096899215,
-0.0573509112,
0.0470940061,
-0.0375660397,
0.0226320289,
-0.0009504224,
-0.0342848413,
-0.0009868672,
0.0116982991,
0.0184737984,
-0.0265174247,
0.0254978761,
0.0910877362,
-0.029135501,
-0.0379531644,
-0.036998637,
-0.0246713869,
-0.0089215711,
-0.0551707745,
0.0298094563,
-0.0532258488,
0.0176125169,
0.0088772634,
-0.0187983662,
-0.0015318394,
0.0043201819,
0.0523444824,
-0.0013251543,
0.0365133882,
0.0038194705,
0.003339374,
0.0746310949,
0.0254336353,
-0.0196016468,
0.0310745314,
0.0310502946,
0.0087224077,
0.0560529418,
-0.0083930111,
0.0131720873,
0.0260446332,
0.02204974,
0.0097236866,
-0.0283744708,
0.0452695824,
-0.0017986076,
0.0213555954,
-0.0050293286,
0.0376058742,
-0.0101134405,
-0.0138618061,
0.0174375866,
0.057889428,
-0.0005309607,
0.025165746,
0.0244019181,
0.0081465365,
0.0235594548,
0.0226049051,
-0.0180565324,
0.0274411142,
-0.0478532054,
0.0150077101,
0.0341566354,
0.0330661908,
-0.0199214797,
-0.036085587,
0.0090949209,
0.0120749492,
-0.0129238255,
0.0661453083,
0.0576597415,
0.0304461662,
-0.026686037,
0.0375055149,
0.0161748789,
-0.0044420729,
0.0272963438,
-0.0386557952,
0.0762488544,
0.0408687405,
0.0601914562,
-0.0538552888,
-0.0634360686,
0.007547609,
0.0315733403,
0.0158230327,
0.0021772764,
-0.0293990411,
-0.0331949107,
-0.0692868531,
-0.0104047842,
-0.037197873,
-0.0196228679,
0.0095401686,
0.0289564226,
0.0334630869,
0.0329357535,
-0.0530624092,
-0.0155035965,
0.0308658984,
-0.0434874482,
-0.0624144115,
-0.028904466,
0.0145224817,
-0.0099263014,
-0.0069547468,
0.0089801466,
0.0078088911,
0.0264406539,
-0.0564878397,
-0.0057991506,
-0.0437125862,
-0.0583026819,
-0.0388080142,
0.0604209453,
-0.0101685598,
-0.0014333323,
0.0252020899,
-0.0358736254,
-0.044474531,
0.0089594936,
-0.0254696328,
0.0084675364,
-0.0384561606,
-0.0131517416,
0.0253444277,
0.0235916264,
-0.0625426099,
0.0636045337,
0.0425142758,
0.0106158592,
0.046094086,
0.0282603018,
0.0255645551,
0.0004918823,
-0.0056363996,
-0.0074357125,
-0.0139938556,
0.0187724382,
-0.0052185836,
-0.0004780476,
-0.0628479198,
-0.0089129079,
-0.0558305308,
0.0340759233,
0.0107796416,
0.0236972384,
0.0118976142,
0.0080080247,
-0.0069106361,
-0.0117039466,
-0.0636625886,
0.0226415098,
0.0212487858,
0.0158386137,
0.0187028013,
0.0254988894,
-0.01161745,
-0.0345565192,
-0.0074024643,
-0.0236747768,
0.0481689647,
-0.0119775552,
0.0164143369,
-0.0514458679,
0.0428079367,
-0.0436040424,
0.0219229031,
-0.0029439372,
-0.0214171037,
-0.0137040019,
-0.0444641672,
0.0358567834,
0.0758093819,
-0.0093723107,
0.0051370114,
0.0514707305,
-0.0385804959,
-0.0711814985,
0.0500418097,
-0.0134559218,
-0.0620178916,
0.0052921581,
-0.0150423376,
0.0002067849,
-0.0006848113,
0.000853336,
-0.0393398032,
-0.0215154532,
0.0241284743,
0.0005113498,
0.0064585228,
-0.0662249774,
-0.0095540015,
-0.0032825484,
0.038479276,
-0.0055713938,
0.0179066043,
0.0479377396,
-0.0052185012,
0.0106442664,
-0.092669189,
0.0245177057,
-0.065867871,
0.0353750251,
-0.0306986943,
0.0135195423,
-0.0412049629,
-0.0076138866,
-0.0704063624,
-0.0125397677,
-0.0124854902,
-0.0430659428,
0.035341993,
-0.0538052283,
0.001351301,
-0.0067783385,
-0.006221693,
-0.0584647469,
-0.0014864691,
-0.0169275142,
0.0088256169,
-0.0439957306,
0.0097015481,
-0.0273311958,
-0.0076760831,
0.0519313887,
-0.0173702333,
-0.0283359326,
-0.0256192628,
-0.0062714061,
0.0851574391,
0.0942473114,
0.0476939492,
0.00751126,
-0.0328020267,
0.0210295897,
0.0504579879,
0.0148144867,
-0.0068291184,
-0.0053179418,
-0.0074351113,
0.0259246323,
-0.0387284197,
0.0023256561,
0.0380708277,
0.0183054544,
-0.0875513107,
-0.0269989725,
0.0761292279,
0.0152862286,
0.0115632173,
-0.0238312017,
-0.0649832338,
-0.0003102843,
0.0088449381,
0.0752677694,
-0.0642827451,
-0.0494730324,
-0.0282721706,
0.0139017748,
0.0153666651,
-0.0060893903,
0.0022409004,
-0.1442516148,
0.0060419575,
-0.0115109812,
-0.0500322357,
-0.0379532203,
-0.0146297375,
0.010214678,
0.0442994349,
0.0383794159,
0.0067575914,
-0.0219805334,
0.0168369431,
0.0307237189,
0.0397928506,
-0.0185599662,
0.0583346337,
-0.0077886577,
-0.0132104363,
0.043690782,
0.0285280664,
-0.0203733966,
-0.0281592179,
0.0270806365,
-0.0490341783,
0.0120015778,
0.0221079923,
0.0412063077,
-0.0098565742,
-0.0019706402,
-0.0302452538,
0.0370875411,
-0.0234923828,
-0.0114156185,
0.0512235649,
0.1034569293,
0.0042868354,
-0.0133432932,
-0.0531864353,
0.014165068,
-0.0316131189,
0.0723677725,
0.0140422331,
-0.0482352078,
-0.0383424982,
0.0019998311,
-0.0287598427,
-0.0561089404,
-0.0002087833,
0.0514666811,
-0.0300260484,
0.0436774492,
-0.0932316408,
-0.0309817269,
0.0357168242,
0.0373675115,
0.0322535485,
0.0292969197,
0.0085910251,
-0.0024547747,
-0.0207757596,
0.0142649645,
-0.0595126562,
-0.0051389607,
-0.0286138523,
0.0438146926,
0.0376076102,
-0.0624889694,
-0.0069602611,
0.0004062424,
-0.0197188891,
-0.0423042551,
-0.0070641655,
0.0400040485,
0.0099928565,
0.0212849025,
0.0070208232,
-0.0254202429,
0.0481774695,
0.0038741268,
-0.0434378199,
0.0115137473,
-0.0142621379,
0.016283581,
-0.019560663,
0.0268079266,
-0.070227325,
0.0097520789,
0.0094821053,
0.0309869219,
-0.0163418241,
-0.0383232869,
0.0142941019,
0.0166479517,
-0.0106278211,
0.0331944525,
-0.0238218233,
-0.010078623,
0.046858184,
-0.0171355456,
-0.023995623,
-0.0020081962,
0.0154173439,
0.0205972139,
-0.0430923067,
0.0026015793,
-0.0051741805,
0.0184897445,
0.0674983487,
0.0098101692,
0.0322682746,
0.0114928102,
0.0130247697,
0.0033645651,
-0.0047129821,
-0.0200506821,
-0.033673726,
0.0193191748,
0.0810750425,
-0.008233943,
0.0768837705,
0.038693279,
-0.0307578743,
-0.0475573838,
-0.0151349278,
-0.0540262945,
-0.0177381486,
-0.0178695116,
0.0212568138,
0.0098933205,
-0.0091769276,
0.0143802008,
0.0090541737,
-0.0297614392,
-0.0097351121,
0.0085205734,
-0.0121396892,
-0.0110846423,
0.0463272557,
0.0287146978,
0.0347015336,
0.0184730832,
0.0362618677,
-0.0080215987,
0.047542911,
0.0025573769,
-0.016299203,
-0.0375662707,
-0.0019931952,
0.0233951919,
0.0254183579,
0.0276740156,
0.0344686769,
-0.0225836542,
-0.0570186935,
0.0405298285,
-0.0111004598,
-0.0257605091,
-0.0267072227,
0.036310222,
0.0689458176,
0.0120474724,
-0.0309542548,
-0.024712624,
0.0494316965,
-0.0626656264,
-0.0179882925,
-0.0066553485,
-6.106550991e-33,
-0.0289250165,
-0.0448894463,
0.066638276,
-0.0278308149,
-0.0247889142,
-0.0135435844,
-0.028122846,
-0.0281647984,
-0.038987916,
-0.0092384089,
-0.0142375482,
-0.0122512085,
-0.0060113044,
0.0520150214,
-0.0134438509,
-0.0116537986,
-0.0021850506,
0.0166644249,
-0.0064781131,
0.0310728364,
0.0504903644,
0.0552526191,
0.0367715918,
-0.0311242156,
-0.0242924336,
-0.0297184791,
0.0282940753,
0.0109812338,
-0.0359950699,
0.0752988756,
-0.0415539369,
0.0501783416,
0.0451932363,
-0.037175145,
0.0310457777,
0.0546228215,
-0.0781132355,
-0.0570163839,
0.0235826652,
-0.005988651,
-0.0453497767,
-0.0562102981,
0.0202071127,
0.0014801993,
0.0286073163,
-0.0186023731,
0.0549309067,
-0.0515983142,
-0.0132373776,
0.015910197,
-0.0845261365,
-0.0107145905,
-0.0187756103,
-0.0211257376,
-0.0168677419,
0.0806566998,
-0.0115221497,
0.0273369942,
-0.0123338196,
-0.0224367678,
0.0242010076,
0.0403393321,
0.0455701426,
0.0459730215,
-0.0371830277,
0.0381574593,
0.0158980004,
-0.0294995718,
-0.0337159857,
-0.0646432117,
0.0067574312,
0.0415248312,
0.0422567055,
0.0943286568,
0.0036579235,
0.01740003,
-0.0957496315,
0.0382787362,
-0.0088357851,
0.0575800315,
0.0215822123,
-0.0368672386,
-0.0338476188,
-0.007758603,
-0.04917676,
0.0836254731,
-0.0488646477,
-0.0215166062,
0.0701333359,
-0.0319334343,
-0.022315355,
0.0100832283,
0.0462693833,
-0.0475148037,
-0.0158301145,
0.0054836604,
-0.0333225243,
0.0135061238,
-0.0229398478,
0.0261574853,
-0.0406854227,
-0.017172683,
0.0098303081,
-0.0410757735,
-0.0110230874,
0.0183638074,
0.0268217362,
0.0050132656,
-0.0294080619,
-0.0078153443,
-0.04241037,
-0.0146878995,
-0.0018860055,
0.0208353251,
-0.002887435,
0.0589753129,
-0.0132500613,
0.0707675815,
0.0003021549,
-0.0068251234,
-0.0126670673,
-0.0495309904,
0.0055487072,
-0.0152114611,
-0.0467495471,
0.0323492102,
-0.0105161527,
0.0534637347,
-0.0376654416,
-0.0615396611,
-0.0060016117,
0.0577776432,
2.621e-7,
0.0810668766,
0.0349138714,
0.0121508129,
0.0009058948,
-0.0248989537,
0.022121245,
0.0050358768,
0.0171392821,
0.0695028156,
-0.0008150596,
-0.0053386781,
0.0466412716,
0.0103407456,
0.0025858085,
-0.0873600766,
-0.0280618872,
-0.0077818464,
-0.0332239866,
-0.0453042053,
-0.0144763179,
0.0936838463,
0.0489527583,
-0.0147921564,
-0.0454885326,
-0.0373625234,
-0.0443943068,
0.0535318889,
-0.0257295668,
-0.0221234411,
0.0448699668,
0.0063551753,
0.0279386975,
0.0055365879,
0.0131383566,
0.0088323532,
0.02930573,
0.0243433788,
0.0149176884,
0.0222652946,
-0.0725342333,
0.0017799182,
0.0078099929,
0.0128704915,
-0.0576469898,
0.0723355412,
-0.0415258817,
-0.0097442325,
-0.0002669067,
-0.056569472,
-0.0111752609,
-0.0262835268,
-0.0140154529,
0.0061853235,
0.0008421807,
0.0020595423,
-0.0137181049,
-0.0161432363,
-0.0920419618,
0.0192149188,
0.0283955615,
-0.0338164829,
-0.0066386615,
-0.0354438871,
-0.0107904989,
-0.0031110446,
-0.0849838555,
0.029633224,
2.106462688e-34,
0.0159034878,
-0.0333359614,
0.038069576,
0.0243060775,
0.0140653718,
-0.0026077402,
0.0098436363,
0.0098998258,
0.0328192562,
-0.1105883345,
-0.0175209735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02926v1 | Automated Cognate Detection as a Supervised Link Prediction Task with Cognate Transformer | 2024-02-05T11:47:36 | 2024-02-05T11:47:36 | V. S. D. S. Mahesh Akavarapu, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI, I.2.7 | Identification of cognates across related languages is one of the primary
problems in historical linguistics. Automated cognate identification is helpful
for several downstream tasks including identifying sound correspondences,
proto-language reconstruction, phylogenetic classification, etc. Previous
state-of-the-art methods for cognate identification are mostly based on
distributions of phonemes computed across multilingual wordlists and make
little use of the cognacy labels that define links among cognate clusters. In
this paper, we present a transformer-based architecture inspired by
computational biology for the task of automated cognate detection. Beyond a
certain amount of supervision, this method performs better than the existing
methods, and shows steady improvement with further increase in supervision,
thereby proving the efficacy of utilizing the labeled information. We also
demonstrate that accepting multiple sequence alignments as input and having an
end-to-end architecture with link prediction head saves much computation time
while simultaneously yielding superior performance. | [
0.0015896995,
0.0495486259,
-0.047852505,
0.0357437171,
-0.0475807823,
0.0177797005,
-0.0025417514,
-0.0045440122,
0.0086588496,
-0.0116778705,
-0.0356484875,
-0.0377251059,
0.051198557,
-0.0261072014,
0.0246755984,
0.0160694234,
0.0394866504,
-0.015623413,
-0.0006984917,
0.0080592083,
-0.0556667559,
-0.0011805666,
0.0017742586,
-0.0038281758,
-0.0318913758,
-0.0032839903,
-0.0046838284,
0.034632355,
-0.0074519594,
-0.0300625935,
-0.0171062313,
0.0100849299,
-0.0463524014,
0.0908110067,
0.0000017386,
-0.0511885174,
-0.0024646821,
-0.0054810648,
-0.0570500903,
-0.0174812526,
0.0019793198,
0.0154839857,
-0.0072886138,
-0.0204348769,
0.0297778845,
0.0368928164,
0.0793424025,
-0.0024512766,
-0.0111925974,
0.0677884892,
0.0008089372,
-0.0853424817,
0.0495621562,
-0.0167913493,
0.0478077084,
0.0077150851,
0.0020084379,
0.0250151251,
-0.0022207496,
-0.0106712468,
-0.0447089858,
0.0554891974,
-0.0489364937,
0.0239518061,
-0.0608950853,
0.0005323456,
-0.047724314,
-0.0544475093,
-0.0096230656,
-0.0134373959,
-0.0008722778,
-0.0450030155,
0.0247799829,
0.046050556,
-0.0024610152,
0.0368221849,
0.0208776072,
0.0055031977,
-0.0437847748,
0.0201974902,
0.0777181834,
-0.0411214866,
0.0241580885,
-0.0158505403,
0.0041134064,
0.0847828612,
0.0391358994,
-0.0183764733,
0.0138310678,
0.0321123265,
0.0251908917,
0.0037696972,
0.0398854651,
0.0165693723,
-0.0624924339,
0.0006780846,
0.0115748392,
0.0009634798,
0.022638645,
-0.0182396006,
-0.0074617011,
0.0136179691,
-0.0145517327,
0.0412132144,
-0.0975339711,
-0.009499426,
-0.0123956269,
-0.0887671635,
0.0091646137,
-0.042707745,
-0.0464214124,
-0.0056173122,
-0.0218403209,
0.0013526103,
-0.0261385385,
0.0314290933,
-0.0417883769,
-0.0325020254,
0.0140359588,
-0.0260385014,
0.0241944417,
-0.0237638857,
-0.024695972,
0.0340178721,
-0.0206886362,
0.0029440071,
0.0016767762,
-0.0220214985,
-0.0747740716,
-0.0575643368,
-0.028850507,
0.0392461345,
0.0373798721,
-0.0151720317,
0.0555148534,
0.0784087703,
-0.0025904165,
-0.0576320812,
0.0076295482,
-0.0488467626,
-0.0564801209,
-0.003655653,
-0.0212188419,
-0.063862592,
0.0566190034,
-0.012462588,
-0.0013126942,
-0.0033893473,
-0.0105482517,
-0.0027844466,
-0.0821073204,
0.0306981187,
0.0204246137,
0.0192364696,
0.011708416,
-0.0160336178,
-0.0093628801,
-0.0157493744,
0.0464157537,
-0.0118422695,
0.0468496904,
-0.000861812,
-0.0368588828,
0.0207608771,
-0.0226453673,
-0.0541817397,
0.0422428288,
-0.0434821621,
0.0199869294,
0.026056692,
0.0481162295,
0.0311102122,
0.0284785405,
-0.0401176475,
0.0190804303,
0.0712228194,
0.1213695705,
0.042253416,
0.0846460164,
-0.0107855517,
-0.0145819373,
-0.0008611158,
-0.0103531014,
-0.0358667448,
-0.0369050726,
-0.0106796753,
-0.0333098881,
0.0512540378,
0.0299249385,
0.041085612,
-0.0071895076,
-0.0269426927,
-0.0606935695,
0.0094269179,
0.0283149052,
-0.0128628174,
-0.0336609669,
-0.005128012,
0.0313883349,
-0.0281018652,
0.0088416031,
0.0094419243,
0.0462448597,
0.0236805119,
0.0335824117,
-0.0261925198,
-0.0132163027,
0.0558067188,
-0.0174708609,
0.0088622933,
-0.0258453097,
-0.027302105,
0.0212221649,
-0.0172310676,
0.0194350667,
0.0653958991,
0.0095928311,
0.0477022938,
-0.0108093591,
0.0772444829,
0.017694246,
-0.0175379831,
0.0527811684,
0.0433272906,
-0.0680255219,
-0.0294980761,
-0.0110335629,
0.0063072736,
0.0330883153,
0.0354960859,
0.0115215536,
0.0253727715,
0.0438258201,
-0.0355819687,
0.0226488765,
0.0329803452,
-0.0263563637,
-0.025835827,
0.0464027412,
-0.042230051,
-0.0142237386,
-0.0528322458,
0.0324966349,
-0.0332315341,
0.0836425424,
-0.0751700699,
0.0716439486,
-0.0125718359,
0.0356600173,
-0.0349921025,
0.0192950182,
-0.0087866737,
0.0725434646,
0.1061157808,
0.0447443277,
0.0280679688,
-0.0453845039,
-0.0088011893,
-0.0076938574,
-0.011416479,
-0.0381906554,
-0.0152151817,
-0.0722663775,
0.008038057,
-0.0236960985,
-0.0231227763,
-0.0313929394,
-0.0409504026,
0.0280009303,
0.0079207905,
0.0934553742,
-0.017770879,
-0.0031437732,
-0.0161833819,
-0.0132157654,
0.0091982875,
0.0505389608,
-0.0288994983,
-0.0118487449,
0.0150516154,
-0.0720585063,
-0.0387430824,
-0.0296493508,
-0.0092072682,
-0.0321252383,
0.0808109492,
0.0339367352,
-0.055583287,
-0.0471044965,
-0.0529489219,
-0.0709180459,
-0.0057120314,
-0.0079586878,
0.0342729203,
-0.0267160218,
-0.0017379026,
0.0697011724,
-0.0128566232,
-0.0244024433,
-0.0632387996,
0.0199216325,
-0.0252914503,
-0.0049591018,
-0.0251413826,
-0.0231899787,
0.0106717655,
0.0124831162,
0.0123280147,
-0.0232621934,
0.0666134953,
-0.0237498991,
-0.0085858982,
0.0158443432,
-0.0282899346,
0.022126263,
0.0028725187,
0.0229537375,
-0.0641979203,
-0.0127322664,
0.0011109271,
-0.0023709806,
-0.0259731319,
0.0333446786,
-0.0308467895,
-0.0227613878,
-0.0131030399,
-0.0347805098,
-0.0558151491,
0.0814541504,
0.0192999933,
0.0200060941,
0.0116497818,
-0.0372638181,
-0.010462367,
0.0454280265,
0.0494615808,
-0.0452467389,
0.0016862155,
-0.0163104963,
-0.0176607147,
0.0100464933,
0.0075426591,
-0.0185646396,
0.0488083512,
-0.0783305913,
0.0288675614,
0.0073996033,
-0.033869803,
-0.0039809383,
0.010893031,
0.014999669,
-0.0001502197,
0.0326053575,
-0.0034298489,
0.0014344612,
0.0735568404,
-0.0238024443,
0.0166158509,
0.0112719731,
0.0461463518,
0.0198432002,
0.0189215634,
-0.0083074998,
0.0109109962,
0.0106342155,
-0.0140284533,
0.0377906859,
-0.0403631292,
-0.0426804684,
-0.0265116729,
0.0054207146,
-0.0164590068,
-0.0015083201,
0.0732999519,
0.0433600172,
0.0045503397,
0.0323744938,
-0.0455296636,
0.0115767131,
0.0089382278,
0.0071484987,
-0.0607798062,
-0.0616442971,
0.0180065539,
-0.0207187794,
0.0168373697,
-0.0615144446,
0.0282516852,
-0.0892765597,
-0.0040171989,
-0.0037931721,
0.0152221201,
-0.0132992323,
-0.0887379274,
0.0023978166,
-0.0224591512,
-0.1014876887,
0.0384859778,
0.0112226848,
0.0125835761,
-0.0119332317,
-0.026485309,
-0.0088481661,
0.0017048977,
-0.0878935009,
0.0061848164,
0.0384879969,
0.0829125419,
-0.0131203383,
-0.0341896787,
0.0205272026,
-0.0597351566,
0.020070821,
-0.0270942971,
0.0365910903,
0.0242481437,
0.0256935768,
-0.0136867277,
0.0071821939,
-0.0324213542,
-0.0331624895,
0.03871499,
0.0758863464,
0.0123054581,
-0.0858415738,
0.0250507332,
0.0362524018,
-0.0332960077,
0.0767131969,
-0.0079613337,
-0.0105982348,
-0.0235413332,
0.0206158087,
0.0582102463,
0.0184332356,
-0.0580011383,
-0.0172792654,
-0.0205386989,
-0.072455667,
-0.0872271508,
0.0241484679,
-0.0037656387,
0.0345459431,
0.059445288,
0.0011699916,
0.0145058166,
-0.0030853357,
-0.0811188221,
0.007979502,
-0.0378811695,
0.0260740425,
-0.0846960992,
0.0012499846,
0.0873418003,
-0.032231383,
0.0237412062,
0.0541109741,
-0.0183231756,
-0.0531343743,
-0.0095464857,
0.0147708952,
0.0193691067,
0.0249918848,
-0.0057989238,
0.0105965594,
0.0385971107,
0.0321802273,
-0.004410964,
0.0436615758,
-0.0149480989,
-0.0693377703,
-0.0160464253,
0.0173125416,
-0.0356686711,
0.0131326159,
0.0107024005,
0.0270738136,
0.0072728205,
-0.0420546941,
0.0160602462,
-0.0144150117,
0.0593534745,
-0.0794857591,
0.0108789206,
0.0165949073,
-0.0097945826,
0.0099392403,
0.0189022981,
0.0128845628,
0.0192812234,
0.0077253343,
0.0224844869,
0.0095756408,
-0.0063632149,
-0.0172270145,
0.0083209826,
-0.0200814661,
0.0475745052,
0.028563939,
0.0238480456,
-0.036694631,
-0.0043326551,
0.0539109856,
0.0002363875,
-0.0217591003,
0.0868593827,
-0.0333989002,
-0.0527936406,
-0.0240078252,
0.0263100769,
-0.0168345254,
0.0001497533,
-0.0162243303,
0.0317704901,
0.0155656384,
0.0074577318,
0.0806906596,
-0.0465854183,
0.0561652966,
-0.0238802247,
-0.0217717942,
0.0111256251,
0.0226731841,
-0.0615950748,
-0.0152610783,
-0.0050828666,
0.0092404792,
-0.026451746,
0.0133099789,
0.0172966123,
-0.0795162246,
0.0596627928,
-0.006775687,
-0.0686615035,
0.034262538,
-0.0313969664,
-0.0176705774,
-0.0804119706,
-0.0326663479,
-0.0529189333,
-0.0429986455,
-0.0457672887,
0.0372982062,
0.0065306486,
0.0488764197,
0.0014315111,
0.0214247257,
0.0203167796,
0.0526989698,
0.0045394492,
-0.0265118219,
0.0385143943,
0.0130268084,
-0.0029575645,
-0.026457401,
-5.642700553e-33,
-0.0110085113,
-0.0265903361,
0.0032267666,
0.0293830242,
0.0009947628,
0.0299810134,
-0.02925843,
0.028848011,
-0.0338560715,
-0.0289477836,
0.0307144541,
-0.0203406028,
-0.0077443505,
-0.032906808,
0.0393298455,
0.0260230377,
0.0112571698,
-0.0071572186,
0.0181206781,
-0.0260223653,
0.0349633619,
-0.0021806853,
0.0478439368,
-0.0575336926,
-0.0120627331,
0.0220565554,
0.0184622388,
0.0028345999,
-0.0088838059,
0.011371647,
0.0010167436,
-0.0039227675,
-0.0008343596,
-0.0025733917,
0.0410606898,
0.0374453291,
-0.1055982634,
-0.0243280418,
-0.0078797992,
-0.0113327689,
0.0410834029,
-0.0066333376,
0.0164711494,
0.0422026403,
-0.0228152219,
0.0124713136,
0.0217624921,
0.0046950975,
-0.0296131875,
-0.0516229607,
-0.0927258283,
0.0424305834,
-0.0078333504,
-0.0064206924,
0.0660519376,
0.0803484693,
0.0125408974,
-0.0008171679,
-0.017431695,
0.0306937825,
-0.0317911319,
0.007810032,
0.038923014,
0.0168505516,
-0.051719375,
0.0460566953,
0.0635714009,
-0.0644856617,
-0.0111346124,
0.0633310825,
-0.0032271303,
-0.0260760449,
0.0050619724,
0.0103185,
0.0642422959,
-0.0248582233,
0.0024405378,
0.0119985174,
0.0277753808,
-0.0130526358,
-0.0191548709,
0.01655313,
-0.0025837296,
0.0011513671,
-0.0017106581,
-0.0431249961,
-0.0157497264,
-0.0312776826,
-0.0470755436,
-0.0254894588,
-0.0009248574,
0.0884527713,
-0.0098380139,
0.0177796427,
-0.0043899119,
-0.0534113757,
-0.004783567,
0.0078073125,
-0.0054863812,
0.0312145427,
0.0195377376,
-0.0660395473,
0.0421004817,
0.0005390733,
0.0397134982,
-0.0075604473,
0.0318197422,
0.030109901,
-0.0678480342,
-0.0029768918,
-0.0018506933,
-0.0305136777,
-0.0046270932,
-0.0211291965,
0.0334403701,
0.0307102147,
0.0327452533,
-0.0541812778,
0.0628735572,
-0.0012480583,
-0.0078177741,
0.0463743247,
-0.0251797773,
-0.0178174488,
-0.0174853764,
0.0188993849,
0.0171941258,
0.0425875075,
-0.00795139,
-0.0566279888,
-0.0311593581,
0.0002470628,
2.775e-7,
0.0392555222,
0.0309747439,
0.0344539322,
-0.0167308822,
0.0115406709,
-0.0151876649,
0.0117086722,
0.0267216358,
0.0026915804,
-0.0207573231,
0.0032898493,
-0.0110133504,
0.0231813807,
0.0503485352,
-0.0627553537,
-0.0081043392,
-0.044739943,
-0.0015843647,
-0.0434150882,
-0.0181998573,
-0.0225569662,
0.0957740173,
-0.0070452103,
-0.0565142222,
-0.0045272764,
0.0091698729,
0.0071298741,
-0.0388491638,
0.0153213991,
-0.0040034116,
-0.0524945185,
-0.0559562966,
0.0016183313,
0.0268160757,
-0.049796436,
0.0296693258,
0.0234483182,
-0.0163786411,
-0.0019485923,
0.0561427735,
0.0485365801,
-0.0010841903,
-0.0115804076,
0.0370200202,
0.0417720973,
0.0685435608,
-0.0275440291,
-0.004658388,
-0.0130720511,
0.0670454279,
-0.005796351,
0.0000748808,
0.026641449,
0.0250205565,
0.0364850052,
-0.0004370574,
-0.0371806994,
-0.0119770365,
-0.0043243514,
0.0343484916,
-0.0425869226,
-0.0117112538,
0.032165885,
-0.0166527964,
-0.0140006244,
-0.0134776933,
0.0009256252,
2.139239466e-34,
-0.0352300294,
-0.0304636024,
0.0150446817,
0.0011555445,
0.0205789246,
-0.0469135046,
0.0002754295,
0.0416037068,
0.0011125676,
0.0028121003,
-0.0223047026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02915v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02915v1 | A Computational Model for the Assessment of Mutual Intelligibility Among Closely Related Languages | 2024-02-05T11:32:13 | 2024-02-05T11:32:13 | Jessica Nieder, Johann-Mattis List | cs.CL | cs.CL | Closely related languages show linguistic similarities that allow speakers of
one language to understand speakers of another language without having actively
learned it. Mutual intelligibility varies in degree and is typically tested in
psycholinguistic experiments. To study mutual intelligibility computationally,
we propose a computer-assisted method using the Linear Discriminative Learner,
a computational model developed to approximate the cognitive processes by which
humans learn languages, which we expand with multilingual semantic vectors and
multilingual sound classes. We test the model on cognate data from German,
Dutch, and English, three closely related Germanic languages. We find that our
model's comprehension accuracy depends on 1) the automatic trimming of
inflections and 2) the language pair for which comprehension is tested. Our
multilingual modelling approach does not only offer new methodological findings
for automatic testing of mutual intelligibility across languages but also
extends the use of Linear Discriminative Learning to multilingual settings. | [
-0.0359624475,
0.0312927663,
-0.0377510972,
0.0917860717,
-0.0784548596,
0.0237303283,
0.0142911132,
-0.0327963158,
0.0145302452,
0.0115804542,
-0.0636644512,
-0.0136758452,
0.0137813985,
-0.076152198,
0.0413434282,
-0.0242191032,
0.0516449995,
-0.0474726036,
0.0165267605,
-0.05259775,
0.0116098989,
-0.018695021,
-0.0130772106,
0.0182752497,
-0.0098750908,
-0.0064128935,
0.0058083176,
-0.0226267539,
-0.0168954004,
0.0160810221,
-0.0224258322,
0.0057831611,
-0.0006543326,
0.0188703667,
0.0000016941,
-0.0501867794,
-0.0020445823,
-0.0529891811,
-0.0061245561,
0.012217883,
0.007907928,
0.008489633,
0.0125927664,
-0.0526947118,
-0.0048193182,
0.040101558,
0.0189730916,
-0.036085058,
-0.0016123502,
-0.0091399364,
-0.0056643928,
-0.0425070412,
0.0131357666,
-0.0015402528,
0.0099248709,
-0.0019131296,
-0.0054889652,
0.0204755608,
-0.0500036851,
-0.0501266755,
-0.0651210546,
0.0735809952,
-0.0344199538,
0.0413014516,
-0.0104985181,
0.0100827729,
0.0670144185,
-0.0356488749,
-0.0109901316,
0.0091346093,
0.009850909,
-0.0609188341,
0.0022665067,
0.0297562741,
-0.0042017894,
0.0368502848,
-0.0312976725,
-0.0321398042,
-0.0228947829,
0.0186434072,
0.0688622594,
-0.0123469001,
-0.0098962951,
-0.0108262291,
0.0411830656,
0.1178731322,
0.0244078729,
-0.0637695938,
0.0211558603,
0.0097919498,
-0.0212012418,
0.0280036312,
0.0029474904,
-0.0144085493,
-0.0408833995,
0.0339991637,
0.0150756426,
-0.0304441489,
0.0244875513,
-0.0040779095,
0.0243291315,
0.000072235,
-0.0297474097,
0.0514997616,
-0.0377719402,
0.0426486097,
0.0360693,
-0.0011673053,
-0.022109,
-0.0210743584,
-0.044547949,
0.0027392246,
-0.0221835654,
0.0221999642,
0.0110291094,
0.0214143693,
-0.0470614508,
-0.0251705851,
-0.0339047238,
0.0078747235,
-0.0341952108,
-0.0659029931,
-0.0469851047,
0.0054201605,
0.0008186396,
0.0366028808,
-0.0585467257,
0.0232908372,
-0.0577542484,
-0.0674733967,
0.0169457477,
0.0286351591,
-0.0018235721,
-0.017708024,
0.0194872301,
0.0289437324,
-0.0427803621,
-0.0208049025,
-0.0195897222,
-0.0266698413,
-0.0282995272,
-0.037074402,
0.0004842162,
-0.0646725893,
0.0407069772,
0.0071257805,
0.0093499413,
-0.0974387899,
-0.0392772518,
-0.0484182574,
-0.0212338325,
0.0673820153,
-0.0124132503,
0.0279914159,
0.0244535282,
-0.014335556,
-0.018343119,
0.0106789973,
0.0171698723,
-0.0962076932,
0.0691559687,
-0.0373148061,
-0.0421826355,
0.0409531593,
0.0143092684,
-0.0442749001,
0.0104524307,
-0.0361857377,
0.0090675754,
0.0027383429,
0.046774812,
0.0484188795,
-0.0261323042,
-0.0627247021,
0.0278813131,
0.0875678733,
0.0490839221,
0.020628687,
0.0573856197,
0.0235568471,
0.0089688292,
0.0488071591,
0.035471268,
-0.0424898453,
-0.0293977819,
0.0229465719,
0.0005202105,
0.0321529023,
-0.023504056,
-0.0052127168,
0.0244722217,
-0.0437309891,
0.050329119,
0.0205798205,
0.0318157785,
-0.0147449132,
-0.0156457704,
0.0374167971,
0.0535836108,
-0.0538792796,
0.0055540144,
0.0166511498,
0.0637341291,
0.0007935207,
-0.0388984606,
-0.0364971906,
0.0326677188,
0.0232574418,
0.0002096835,
-0.0114700934,
0.0340900496,
-0.0296113119,
0.0546485856,
-0.042893894,
0.0531969182,
0.000588936,
0.0019256627,
0.0446721651,
-0.056631282,
0.0226894319,
-0.0142358989,
-0.0427538604,
0.0461591855,
-0.0038031673,
-0.0720017925,
0.0126284864,
-0.0104172658,
0.006448633,
0.0434584208,
0.0441157259,
-0.0086054476,
0.0176952053,
0.0157249328,
-0.0151658403,
0.0579521507,
0.0968402028,
0.0002168528,
-0.0043649874,
0.0479980782,
-0.0511571206,
-0.0195025336,
-0.0267562978,
0.0464519076,
-0.0301811788,
0.0870398507,
-0.073130168,
0.0222472437,
-0.0343017392,
0.0276242793,
-0.0404297486,
-0.0021622295,
-0.0122536812,
0.0371034741,
0.0371194929,
0.0621984191,
-0.0233134069,
-0.0236971285,
0.0607134476,
-0.0462246425,
-0.0221900158,
0.0148453349,
-0.0295987278,
-0.014277732,
-0.0133611718,
-0.0505744405,
-0.0370746739,
-0.0032839372,
-0.0808001608,
-0.0328442156,
-0.0086659798,
0.0650777966,
-0.031403847,
-0.0191266723,
-0.0093451692,
-0.0209522434,
-0.0113652442,
0.0372152627,
0.0158073865,
0.0180047844,
-0.0159543287,
-0.0317633525,
-0.0458391421,
-0.010275092,
-0.0177130774,
0.0153852478,
0.0427238494,
0.03082899,
-0.0470561683,
-0.0439697504,
-0.0130368499,
-0.0669880509,
-0.0000431488,
-0.0051252041,
-0.0184505042,
-0.0130862985,
0.0399551354,
0.0390971266,
0.0311273336,
-0.0314961225,
-0.0213855319,
0.0258149877,
-0.0354007557,
-0.0580902547,
-0.0034161038,
0.0003073267,
0.0178020075,
-0.0511441194,
-0.0222991444,
-0.0091794934,
0.0740750656,
0.0181268286,
-0.006146369,
-0.0012103664,
0.0029615259,
-0.0303374752,
-0.0365349725,
-0.0157394391,
-0.0510396399,
-0.0119965319,
0.0464550108,
-0.0073800934,
-0.0272404868,
0.0952643752,
-0.0531956032,
-0.0453191772,
-0.040731661,
-0.0316618048,
-0.0062538153,
0.0079288594,
-0.0109645976,
0.0123973573,
-0.0318315998,
-0.0303153042,
-0.0036184848,
0.0341560617,
0.0942783654,
0.002164128,
0.0843842924,
-0.0608857386,
0.0003163868,
0.0372828245,
-0.0258983839,
0.0090185972,
0.0195471011,
-0.0641867071,
0.0288242344,
0.0195712317,
0.0119976578,
0.0424661264,
0.0015515311,
0.058544416,
-0.0197083894,
0.052938439,
0.0142001221,
-0.0140941571,
0.0086544985,
-0.0326786526,
0.0216680001,
-0.0375814289,
-0.0356546268,
0.0137757817,
-0.0070631243,
0.057284303,
0.0043741977,
0.0176290758,
0.0440078937,
0.0471371897,
-0.0166726876,
-0.0411560312,
0.0122356173,
0.0472481288,
0.0359142907,
0.0163921081,
0.0739265606,
0.0077092154,
-0.0185070019,
0.0523300767,
-0.0572397932,
0.0165853687,
0.0195881259,
-0.0006390781,
-0.0560217164,
-0.0184664894,
0.0176907722,
-0.0071520777,
0.0071246196,
-0.0374088213,
-0.0047718636,
-0.0821916312,
0.0002777717,
0.0066188658,
-0.0171676241,
-0.0249980856,
-0.0521178506,
0.0088140136,
0.0033582165,
-0.0166124869,
0.0280058738,
0.0024789071,
-0.0082740271,
0.0251906347,
-0.037100222,
-0.0330899134,
0.0286511797,
-0.0342913866,
0.0299292095,
-0.0298022795,
0.0504787229,
-0.0368586034,
-0.0676635802,
0.0194732826,
-0.0657903329,
-0.0050529134,
-0.0193168763,
0.0351472013,
0.040459726,
0.0051987073,
-0.0013377945,
0.0304640308,
0.0223607291,
-0.0217891131,
0.0636822656,
0.0592332482,
0.0269472413,
-0.0388095975,
0.065950051,
0.0507348999,
-0.0087792389,
0.0665720999,
0.0568330362,
-0.041960191,
0.0129381958,
-0.0040648812,
0.0396693386,
0.0083262865,
-0.0387072526,
0.0061085634,
-0.0061676367,
-0.0146547072,
-0.0554091595,
-0.0256682169,
-0.0150571344,
0.0033147533,
0.0397835597,
0.0353374556,
0.0167367719,
-0.0092381854,
-0.0343318917,
-0.0059204418,
-0.0177154839,
0.0516812541,
-0.05166829,
0.0106928498,
0.0289479401,
-0.0358711146,
-0.0507201813,
-0.0230180118,
-0.0247600097,
-0.0730132759,
-0.0189399999,
-0.0081330305,
0.0204153936,
0.0744082704,
-0.0016708326,
-0.056304507,
-0.0254013874,
-0.0229413249,
-0.0449617654,
0.0348668508,
0.0259476546,
-0.0085798623,
0.0156348441,
0.0321384631,
-0.0224093944,
0.0330551565,
0.0141260484,
-0.0275696907,
-0.0283838566,
-0.0729309395,
0.0091200545,
0.0579145588,
0.0054536578,
-0.014868604,
0.0187310912,
-0.0458137803,
-0.0088080885,
0.033819586,
0.0205401629,
-0.022327248,
-0.0197134763,
0.0104154553,
-0.0292249676,
-0.0084712105,
-0.0496069454,
-0.0009073705,
-0.0024401606,
0.0031795246,
0.0481141396,
0.0226031542,
0.0210184883,
-0.0341751575,
0.0102142198,
0.021148378,
0.0321489647,
-0.0227735024,
0.061938677,
0.0184936952,
0.0336853229,
-0.0032561074,
0.0042533935,
0.0177811012,
-0.0404489003,
0.0089109177,
0.0008936354,
0.0257119574,
0.0128058065,
0.0711904019,
-0.0155003555,
0.0838294998,
-0.0354584642,
0.0298635326,
-0.033178784,
0.0378602445,
-0.0389200598,
-0.0256243665,
0.0452966578,
0.0028724079,
-0.0072111036,
0.016708903,
0.0755903497,
-0.0624446198,
0.0016512518,
-0.0428887792,
-0.0060055684,
-0.0307896081,
-0.0272100773,
-0.0180538893,
0.0261742324,
-0.0401504375,
0.0179147106,
-0.0209506825,
-0.0723862126,
0.0082921926,
0.0304470062,
0.0473672003,
-0.0144479787,
0.0011019256,
0.0766007826,
-0.0182572976,
0.0140659399,
-0.0176612549,
-0.0046074186,
-0.0246930923,
-0.0194923636,
-0.0266004112,
-5.301851272e-33,
-0.0179883447,
0.0039448957,
-0.035083551,
0.04667335,
0.0213306956,
-0.0015484997,
-0.0339822285,
0.047959201,
-0.0576959886,
0.0247339718,
0.0320761949,
-0.0381593257,
0.0029689588,
-0.0294957887,
0.0228362754,
-0.0236981101,
0.0014540413,
-0.0061076945,
0.0192599408,
-0.0067966771,
0.0132835237,
-0.0014820033,
0.0517277643,
-0.0645679981,
0.0444429889,
0.0286834389,
0.0204496235,
0.0198487323,
-0.0115867686,
0.0327676162,
-0.0028355699,
0.0586343445,
0.0059732441,
0.0042746733,
-0.0157385673,
-0.0097612394,
-0.0776718184,
-0.0182437897,
0.0702848881,
0.0330624059,
-0.0339269862,
-0.0100741526,
0.0367183015,
-0.0053514624,
-0.0529809333,
0.0002604879,
0.0424217284,
0.0097842123,
0.0229493976,
-0.0059342561,
-0.0616678335,
0.0110284304,
-0.0672972947,
-0.003322453,
0.1080258712,
0.0556830019,
-0.0032512818,
-0.0359142199,
-0.0370000042,
0.0588691458,
-0.0662781224,
0.011178799,
0.0722359121,
-0.0683887377,
0.0304114949,
0.0333219506,
0.061671596,
-0.0375096947,
0.0739113092,
0.0122044915,
0.0595771186,
0.0025933646,
0.0389408283,
0.0672759265,
0.0287443567,
-0.0089544365,
-0.0067811427,
-0.0567641407,
0.09276063,
-0.0376302116,
-0.0438617207,
0.0234196149,
-0.0056996006,
-0.0130807599,
-0.0328939632,
-0.0420439318,
-0.0181164443,
-0.0370105505,
0.0201465134,
-0.0452268571,
0.0249298215,
0.0035625938,
0.0525939576,
-0.018777797,
-0.0179417375,
-0.0066683642,
0.0089431992,
0.0276943576,
-0.0005985209,
0.0275179092,
-0.0391938053,
-0.024615312,
-0.0517299138,
0.0129681043,
0.0584698841,
0.0085102366,
0.0207152851,
-0.0444320403,
-0.0089001432,
0.002597583,
-0.0258963965,
-0.0376408882,
-0.0096902186,
-0.0199363194,
0.0388870239,
0.02478409,
-0.0114438096,
-0.0501805954,
0.0385029502,
-0.0609327629,
-0.0311948843,
-0.0261679534,
-0.0716869608,
0.0497615151,
-0.0408140607,
-0.0261685643,
0.0284174141,
-0.0636249632,
0.014184027,
-0.0095587894,
0.002715508,
0.00303257,
2.724e-7,
-0.0069910348,
0.0256457385,
0.0083516119,
-0.0098232543,
0.0611911342,
0.0065326421,
-0.0350356586,
-0.0117543675,
0.0540248975,
-0.0037586601,
-0.0098084966,
-0.0168147441,
0.074605681,
0.0380927697,
-0.0623759739,
-0.0162114445,
-0.0342832915,
0.0277636405,
-0.0288238041,
0.0092730094,
-0.0064404039,
0.0050412039,
0.0043204436,
-0.0140597653,
-0.0341714472,
-0.0279822033,
0.013274176,
-0.0567758344,
-0.0023213676,
0.0460651293,
0.0531881973,
-0.0556016974,
0.0336784385,
0.1150663197,
-0.0248806477,
0.040844135,
0.0444653705,
-0.0084856097,
-0.00730245,
0.0160475858,
0.0001685207,
0.0170230679,
-0.0384752974,
-0.0081919404,
0.025015261,
0.031259533,
-0.0263254568,
0.0594750009,
-0.0277907345,
-0.0133159403,
0.0437082462,
0.0161682013,
0.0013733525,
0.0159719121,
0.041316092,
-0.0147522073,
0.0086500682,
0.0505667627,
-0.0204366837,
0.0530507527,
-0.0640284047,
-0.0287788641,
0.0343140289,
-0.0121683152,
0.0039652498,
-0.0569302477,
-0.001730475,
1.307818854e-34,
-0.0075771357,
0.0064516529,
0.0765085965,
0.0158612952,
0.0302537605,
-0.0478445292,
0.0027001807,
0.0376953818,
0.0280733686,
0.0096438918,
-0.0004482878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02896v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02896v1 | LLM Agents in Interaction: Measuring Personality Consistency and Linguistic Alignment in Interacting Populations of Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T11:05:20 | 2024-02-05T11:05:20 | Ivar Frisch, Mario Giulianelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.MA | While both agent interaction and personalisation are vibrant topics in
research on large language models (LLMs), there has been limited focus on the
effect of language interaction on the behaviour of persona-conditioned LLM
agents. Such an endeavour is important to ensure that agents remain consistent
to their assigned traits yet are able to engage in open, naturalistic
dialogues. In our experiments, we condition GPT-3.5 on personality profiles
through prompting and create a two-group population of LLM agents using a
simple variability-inducing sampling algorithm. We then administer personality
tests and submit the agents to a collaborative writing task, finding that
different profiles exhibit different degrees of personality consistency and
linguistic alignment to their conversational partners. Our study seeks to lay
the groundwork for better understanding of dialogue-based interaction between
LLMs and highlights the need for new approaches to crafting robust, more
human-like LLM personas for interactive environments. | [
0.0474710092,
0.0230776705,
-0.0628021359,
0.0199398734,
-0.0436469465,
-0.0193526782,
0.0338212959,
-0.0256306473,
0.0124020204,
0.0245545674,
-0.054775089,
-0.0443303995,
0.0063652308,
0.0161719713,
0.0257991645,
-0.0515853725,
0.0485425256,
-0.0189690441,
0.0213471334,
-0.0195715651,
0.0207729917,
0.0392873101,
-0.0040745758,
0.0271541607,
-0.0014569875,
-0.0327848904,
-0.0257488899,
-0.0135579761,
0.0396338589,
0.0163644534,
0.0142817721,
0.0531642437,
0.04561444,
0.0182150807,
0.0000018003,
-0.0558724627,
0.0129832057,
-0.0214958973,
0.0145317027,
-0.0137528786,
0.06137532,
0.0627137795,
-0.0074360147,
0.0268567409,
-0.0563943684,
-0.013683388,
0.0213068593,
0.0331363529,
0.0519168973,
0.0399312451,
0.007517132,
0.0034880352,
-0.0136314686,
-0.0099494485,
-0.0018634616,
-0.018001413,
-0.01007427,
-0.0292763617,
0.0197303575,
-0.0056956313,
-0.0014161186,
-0.0133169908,
-0.0034952082,
-0.0171494707,
0.0038653095,
0.0069519174,
-0.0329111628,
-0.0445808321,
0.0079008397,
0.06687776,
0.100467667,
0.0041835746,
-0.022927532,
-0.0093541043,
0.048100736,
0.030971203,
0.0077808825,
0.0225102641,
-0.0023939256,
-0.0229671281,
0.0060521769,
-0.0075844633,
-0.0214200485,
-0.0049125659,
-0.0197377298,
0.0710560307,
0.0232780799,
-0.0093954355,
-0.0197930112,
0.0023349542,
0.0059177778,
-0.0609803908,
-0.0087292148,
0.0105485981,
-0.0613799915,
0.0288220532,
-0.0679953843,
0.0387704186,
0.0284044109,
-0.0081782611,
0.0203390643,
0.0402589813,
0.0130624305,
-0.0066739148,
0.0603273921,
0.0671943054,
0.0028738598,
0.0183727164,
0.0059038084,
-0.0124457078,
-0.0428011268,
-0.0163803212,
-0.0009910975,
0.0087639736,
0.0259665307,
-0.0169793293,
-0.0388502963,
0.0609754547,
-0.012136952,
0.0338848084,
-0.0154943867,
-0.0114240116,
-0.0332147889,
0.0113428868,
-0.0652101189,
0.0213505197,
-0.0548851527,
-0.0172052812,
-0.001250433,
-0.0562203228,
0.0213905573,
-0.0059990431,
0.020739194,
-0.0418982655,
-0.0069812867,
0.043674022,
0.0092993835,
-0.0476457588,
-0.00144287,
-0.0207334645,
-0.00546706,
-0.0929756984,
-0.0298413467,
-0.0318945237,
0.044812303,
-0.0066480511,
-0.0088660596,
-0.0697515085,
0.0008880959,
0.0201955251,
0.0195520986,
0.0527871996,
-0.01467505,
0.0284540448,
0.0268869288,
0.0074615353,
0.0069038491,
0.0307156742,
0.026321454,
-0.0307419989,
0.0278717317,
-0.0445539244,
0.039832443,
0.0430862531,
-0.030153757,
0.0153503027,
0.0164874475,
-0.0063261837,
0.0380392373,
0.035801217,
0.0678161308,
0.0512271374,
-0.016429754,
-0.0296797194,
0.1100689173,
0.0698220804,
-0.0013966304,
0.0290819779,
0.0246512908,
0.0650237277,
0.0101378653,
0.0538190082,
-0.0396755151,
0.0320013538,
0.0057681897,
0.0114165219,
-0.0111926515,
0.0468527824,
-0.0093970438,
-0.0251318309,
-0.0021415341,
0.022554148,
0.0369347893,
-0.0005028619,
-0.0277959798,
-0.0184506793,
0.000574791,
0.0152864149,
0.0324682631,
-0.0659178197,
-0.00461405,
-0.0219509713,
0.0242258348,
0.116291441,
0.017271366,
0.0093673561,
-0.0434085317,
-0.0058987746,
-0.0359406695,
0.0785960853,
0.0477768257,
-0.0085113086,
0.0145870792,
-0.0290374029,
0.0205022879,
-0.0273480155,
-0.0253143739,
0.0246398393,
0.0141259879,
0.0223277546,
-0.0198821649,
0.028811438,
0.000809446,
-0.0012556183,
-0.1062389165,
-0.0123824384,
-0.0250227693,
0.0173848551,
0.0271842591,
0.0105186328,
-0.0327601992,
-0.0340038091,
-0.0096189352,
0.010176599,
-0.0058340896,
0.0543841682,
-0.0001645475,
-0.0104230503,
0.029181404,
0.0051658908,
-0.0306401942,
-0.0040954668,
0.0195487533,
-0.0105010932,
0.0059968242,
-0.0254432037,
0.0319552049,
-0.0181476679,
0.0165709276,
-0.0340130888,
0.0507119782,
-0.0028205954,
0.0037351213,
0.0108686378,
-0.0080174329,
0.0290519539,
0.0479538329,
-0.0177781973,
-0.0918038636,
-0.0033514549,
0.0137597946,
0.0401956849,
0.0033065276,
0.0241222698,
0.0028054889,
-0.059187796,
-0.0625610501,
-0.0856632218,
0.0136069311,
0.017294772,
0.0061590415,
0.023530433,
0.0147387581,
-0.047876671,
0.0222769175,
-0.0854888037,
0.0013476092,
0.0389642566,
0.0184478164,
0.0664018467,
-0.0202673934,
-0.0459851213,
-0.0574471466,
0.0271423589,
-0.0179057848,
-0.007708116,
-0.0132208029,
0.0432850569,
-0.0434973352,
0.0112435333,
-0.0874386132,
-0.0081300968,
-0.0195237566,
-0.0576574579,
0.0527070984,
0.0068768393,
0.0622866303,
0.0630968139,
0.0337496214,
0.0223605409,
0.0154260295,
-0.0131677166,
-0.0458706878,
0.0167187341,
0.0017789874,
0.0098694498,
-0.0349585228,
-0.0696595088,
0.0020649098,
0.0278214421,
0.003567222,
0.0117233498,
-0.0741937533,
0.0491328761,
0.0319509394,
-0.0355729759,
0.0769298673,
0.0186781324,
-0.0421731547,
0.0373674929,
0.0010130809,
-0.0228910465,
0.0889653265,
-0.0307773296,
-0.0298394989,
-0.01908754,
-0.0318410322,
-0.0237817429,
0.0603272878,
0.004280983,
-0.0073022698,
0.0146740545,
-0.0103156185,
-0.0586978458,
-0.0295205526,
0.0341938064,
-0.0259384532,
0.0451747254,
-0.0329670943,
-0.0273133572,
0.0198075455,
-0.0213752687,
-0.0216017794,
-0.0191114172,
-0.0241915472,
-0.0001933763,
0.0326617062,
-0.0352801643,
-0.017261399,
-0.0180844106,
0.0339169465,
-0.0057085501,
-0.0397263095,
0.006169979,
-0.0446748137,
-0.0259429049,
0.0525077395,
0.0519245416,
0.0040061837,
-0.0792894289,
0.0333996154,
-0.0075313854,
-0.0463828854,
0.0020161131,
0.0043614735,
0.0005622795,
0.0159573723,
-0.0105543053,
-0.0227699466,
0.0106845759,
0.0629409999,
-0.0126080858,
-0.0025785624,
0.1156955883,
0.0023366648,
-0.0265644398,
0.000838862,
-0.0217996445,
0.0500424057,
0.0155376401,
0.0430757627,
-0.0149638522,
0.0123923533,
-0.0050282041,
0.014978189,
-0.0426666103,
-0.0309609044,
-0.0437034406,
-0.0965989083,
0.040507365,
0.0136956405,
-0.0200987626,
0.0335336067,
-0.0064964499,
0.0348365828,
-0.0145150572,
0.0696201473,
-0.0263095014,
-0.0010103984,
-0.0149872331,
-0.0302192364,
-0.0397443213,
-0.0307186954,
0.0429576784,
-0.0658812001,
0.0824626833,
0.0364832059,
0.0572024249,
-0.0126257008,
-0.0376711152,
-0.052255597,
0.0530750714,
0.0222666599,
0.0261824969,
0.034022551,
-0.0120223453,
0.0129511738,
-0.0844396129,
-0.0025880206,
-0.0040758457,
0.0133433202,
0.0258848816,
0.0276588164,
-0.0310565121,
-0.0444034152,
-0.0005866663,
0.036827866,
0.014397434,
0.0447296798,
0.0034242859,
-0.1023105681,
-0.0020408873,
-0.0020996472,
-0.0046430849,
-0.0109967208,
-0.0595023297,
-0.0017381771,
-0.0125018442,
-0.0091477837,
-0.0483734757,
-0.1096410006,
0.0274153035,
0.0220014378,
0.009352698,
-0.0036531074,
0.0061885188,
0.0081500318,
0.0178853627,
0.0128424093,
-0.026612876,
0.0308328271,
-0.0487420373,
-0.0394119397,
0.0404342972,
-0.0788449273,
0.0244776718,
0.0009147396,
-0.0611537397,
-0.0796732828,
0.0281966142,
-0.0027325063,
0.0243885368,
0.0680316016,
0.0313362069,
-0.0517642982,
-0.0238231998,
-0.0281821042,
-0.0003413207,
0.0687439963,
-0.0356596224,
0.0518534668,
-0.0163058471,
0.0268110111,
0.0040268847,
-0.0052645849,
-0.0203562938,
0.0175723936,
-0.018464867,
-0.128237173,
0.0053624483,
0.0247481652,
-0.039569106,
0.0091299014,
0.0114947567,
-0.0349003673,
-0.0217794571,
-0.0481815077,
-0.0086030988,
-0.0198897403,
-0.0764084458,
-0.0029375602,
0.0110302772,
0.012089083,
-0.0164745916,
-0.0580659695,
0.039186094,
-0.0212404151,
-0.0223788116,
-0.0039530373,
0.0101152034,
0.0008924095,
0.0131486878,
-0.0069957087,
0.0331748053,
-0.0161665305,
0.0627781376,
0.0243920684,
0.0895674825,
-0.0132164778,
-0.0146686118,
0.011292927,
0.0302961078,
-0.0500003844,
-0.0347926058,
0.0398766398,
0.0192615166,
0.0015870233,
0.0234686434,
0.0483356752,
-0.0541154109,
0.0327777825,
-0.0205064174,
0.027630711,
0.0204523206,
-0.0209295917,
0.0112500414,
0.0016063181,
-0.0316917486,
-0.0294360705,
0.0247081611,
0.0325153358,
-0.0008969932,
-0.0401579402,
-0.0078921085,
-0.0265404508,
-0.0033550344,
0.0036411064,
0.0120379133,
-0.0123684937,
-0.0398867056,
-0.0792096555,
-0.0538696907,
0.0416865349,
0.0172225423,
-0.0330346413,
-0.0625609234,
-0.0003427996,
0.0365104564,
-0.0171923507,
-0.0435839668,
-0.0403191,
0.00208512,
-0.038100116,
0.0002888868,
-0.016661942,
-5.763098725e-33,
-0.0610043854,
-0.0357807577,
0.0345292501,
0.0161678381,
-0.0658063293,
-0.0597713776,
-0.0457058623,
0.0269281361,
-0.0080728279,
-0.0093640927,
-0.0369452499,
0.0085162632,
0.0148927262,
-0.0319872163,
-0.0051536425,
0.0145221604,
0.0573783182,
0.0132150492,
-0.0270853881,
0.0105334818,
0.0101286657,
0.0013492886,
0.0235700998,
-0.0455477126,
0.0263712853,
-0.0568450093,
-0.0036796804,
-0.0123090846,
-0.022220606,
0.0521147698,
-0.000022597,
0.0272496752,
0.0190496109,
0.0269928686,
-0.010486288,
0.0338986479,
-0.0059431838,
-0.0569874905,
0.0374667905,
0.023416331,
-0.0006113895,
-0.0562167503,
0.0086141797,
-0.0410250276,
-0.0559170619,
-0.0005750318,
0.0399221815,
0.0074790521,
0.0325849019,
0.0521075651,
-0.0691576451,
-0.0088008223,
0.0026427361,
0.0012347181,
-0.0216125529,
-0.0414602943,
-0.0040412243,
-0.0232834741,
-0.0482864529,
0.0484942608,
-0.0293035079,
-0.0250029732,
0.0262472965,
0.0455713719,
0.0250098743,
0.0445170254,
0.0441063493,
0.090713948,
0.0014348549,
-0.0288994666,
0.0427823886,
0.0224233083,
-0.0147475637,
0.1287361383,
-0.0598080531,
-0.017762186,
0.0350042433,
0.0274214819,
0.0963047966,
-0.0483320169,
0.0248843692,
0.0124062402,
-0.0305122714,
-0.0373598896,
-0.0221060272,
0.0288527813,
-0.0101112816,
-0.0576443672,
0.0096013974,
-0.0208439864,
0.0054326383,
-0.0627239645,
0.0425797813,
-0.0204315707,
-0.0473641083,
0.0063890573,
-0.0813966319,
0.0286195911,
-0.0091101294,
-0.0011203025,
-0.0284355506,
-0.0159058236,
0.0065784617,
0.0101328082,
0.02981738,
0.0520514026,
-0.031652879,
0.0241507124,
-0.048697263,
-0.0029777945,
-0.0034563462,
0.0319780521,
-0.0196249261,
0.0366297625,
0.0224275552,
-0.0049923183,
-0.0168474447,
0.0220010988,
0.0155541301,
-0.0058394563,
-0.0711101219,
0.0054582171,
0.000782197,
-0.0072127366,
-0.0226997361,
0.0123452442,
-0.0646458939,
0.0194862001,
0.0358240008,
-0.0227961559,
0.0034580689,
-0.0187933967,
2.614e-7,
-0.0387126319,
0.0450793095,
-0.0123696933,
0.0537297055,
0.0352834836,
0.0414089523,
-0.0093695438,
0.0302621555,
0.0349137336,
-0.0299953781,
0.0184978973,
0.0396912135,
0.048936151,
0.048642166,
-0.0617941208,
0.0319105759,
0.0022584819,
0.0050996677,
-0.0449063703,
0.0130750947,
0.0546620265,
0.0260195248,
0.0354707129,
-0.0078148879,
0.0109714763,
-0.0015960307,
0.0428913087,
-0.0160525292,
-0.0317148529,
0.0464420468,
-0.0364558659,
-0.0339464061,
0.013296362,
0.0527823754,
0.0373405069,
0.0235714503,
-0.0521527305,
0.0836442634,
-0.0305240434,
-0.0133158723,
0.018740315,
0.0271808952,
-0.0299267471,
-0.03019429,
0.0238745809,
-0.0035336451,
-0.0390774608,
0.0100599416,
0.0027845514,
-0.0627395436,
0.0199855492,
-0.0271524899,
-0.0348143838,
0.041932486,
0.0024115443,
-0.0127505781,
-0.0053156125,
-0.0208086539,
0.0379169956,
-0.0288809575,
-0.0527334511,
-0.0959146917,
-0.0198635217,
0.008554955,
0.0002773218,
-0.0407498181,
0.0355200022,
2.099157404e-34,
-0.0077226479,
0.0475183316,
0.0180435013,
0.0110721178,
0.0656153113,
0.0121523449,
0.0178474337,
0.023472555,
0.0698799789,
-0.0675202608,
-0.0095047355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02883v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02883v1 | Approximate Attributions for Off-the-Shelf Siamese Transformers | 2024-02-05T10:49:05 | 2024-02-05T10:49:05 | Lucas Möller, Dmitry Nikolaev, Sebastian Padó | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Siamese encoders such as sentence transformers are among the least understood
deep models. Established attribution methods cannot tackle this model class
since it compares two inputs rather than processing a single one. To address
this gap, we have recently proposed an attribution method specifically for
Siamese encoders (M\"oller et al., 2023). However, it requires models to be
adjusted and fine-tuned and therefore cannot be directly applied to
off-the-shelf models. In this work, we reassess these restrictions and propose
(i) a model with exact attribution ability that retains the original model's
predictive performance and (ii) a way to compute approximate attributions for
off-the-shelf models. We extensively compare approximate and exact attributions
and use them to analyze the models' attendance to different linguistic aspects.
We gain insights into which syntactic roles Siamese transformers attend to,
confirm that they mostly ignore negation, explore how they judge semantically
opposite adjectives, and find that they exhibit lexical bias. | [
0.0452637188,
0.0696784556,
-0.0123699326,
0.0495378152,
-0.0431936719,
0.0277122986,
0.011935181,
-0.0441898108,
-0.0530651025,
-0.0494396016,
-0.0604365766,
-0.0505150855,
-0.0119193774,
0.0347656831,
0.0172540098,
-0.0286208224,
-0.0008748118,
0.0423274301,
-0.0212330054,
0.0047472343,
-0.003911016,
-0.0095709898,
0.0063718725,
0.0440019667,
-0.0185305625,
-0.0139476405,
0.0289370753,
0.0097659044,
0.0119507853,
-0.0080175512,
0.0514150113,
0.0518923849,
-0.023732055,
0.0031190151,
0.000001923,
-0.0319628641,
0.0199480522,
-0.003120553,
0.0036725567,
0.011161318,
0.0223653968,
-0.0291212946,
0.0235166065,
0.007732796,
-0.0319077075,
-0.0159821808,
0.0610023215,
0.0476856641,
0.0567564294,
0.0527228713,
-0.018390093,
-0.0392485633,
0.0133488784,
-0.0485354699,
-0.016275635,
0.0017542848,
0.0282735284,
-0.0509325415,
-0.0719519034,
0.0091507426,
-0.0259365663,
0.0433899537,
0.0484905057,
0.0117809577,
0.0396171473,
0.0108737582,
-0.0178804174,
-0.0241397731,
-0.0097039966,
0.0598845445,
-0.0131318849,
-0.0184806976,
0.003453874,
-0.0107959518,
-0.0232617892,
-0.0180069711,
-0.0315971076,
0.0109257065,
0.0380803235,
0.0209062286,
0.023276154,
0.0341457501,
0.0095195519,
0.0146208992,
0.0086752726,
0.0374747813,
0.0202592947,
-0.0320072435,
0.0036283284,
0.0414579771,
-0.0387588739,
-0.0272529684,
0.0118647907,
-0.0225769319,
0.0308413021,
0.0042385631,
0.0006696332,
-0.0399047285,
-0.0051782997,
-0.0556655414,
0.020728834,
0.0038690015,
-0.0409766585,
0.0305842068,
-0.052231051,
0.0482376851,
-0.0430292264,
0.0824748874,
-0.0479240306,
-0.0317941532,
-0.0532685518,
-0.0244098902,
-0.0454029441,
0.0393482633,
-0.0062343432,
-0.0241268538,
-0.0327449664,
-0.0243703462,
-0.0491601266,
-0.0385263599,
0.0235745702,
0.0581102185,
-0.0565805286,
-0.0084671192,
-0.0335762575,
0.0476189591,
-0.0321219489,
0.0361687317,
-0.0148064932,
-0.0627912879,
-0.0385961048,
0.0550924949,
0.0104327379,
-0.0551930629,
0.0312824845,
0.0314157754,
-0.0170572568,
-0.0364642069,
0.0092503801,
-0.0022396208,
-0.0480388403,
-0.0581670254,
0.0020380754,
-0.0464960113,
0.0172058139,
0.0310969651,
0.0097123319,
-0.0740597174,
-0.0010988396,
0.0078102462,
-0.0319850706,
0.0656712204,
0.0676841959,
-0.019870216,
-0.0449915454,
-0.0243695844,
-0.0182460472,
0.0245261714,
0.03840141,
0.0509566031,
-0.0177719556,
0.0176176112,
0.0224424563,
-0.0072817435,
0.0072722645,
0.0150901824,
-0.0213513002,
-0.0102045909,
-0.0114371795,
-0.0110647073,
0.0183650274,
0.062970005,
0.0006543542,
-0.0025824734,
0.04995206,
-0.0054081455,
-0.0002772073,
0.0795928165,
0.061236646,
-0.0068367515,
-0.0314258784,
-0.0105195707,
-0.0674011409,
0.0727500916,
0.0275635328,
-0.0254561659,
-0.0343646593,
0.0047625587,
-0.034515541,
-0.036780782,
0.0139989303,
-0.0151957078,
0.0018584268,
-0.0212098714,
0.0429651067,
0.0200057253,
-0.0373928472,
0.0992835984,
-0.0102866245,
-0.0447607413,
0.0267276466,
-0.0369071327,
-0.0598963238,
0.0205193739,
-0.002046512,
-0.0145516414,
-0.0327034704,
-0.0196509212,
-0.0210354868,
0.0465459488,
0.0423199758,
0.0202623941,
0.0153329177,
-0.0392395817,
-0.0412527584,
-0.0702788681,
0.0463608019,
0.0165798739,
0.005476106,
0.0346051939,
0.0487944111,
-0.0224526618,
0.0185443442,
0.0258122254,
-0.0110110277,
-0.0250427015,
0.025986623,
0.0234592799,
0.0405026488,
-0.0028642865,
0.010222544,
0.0113301044,
0.0056996802,
-0.0525936149,
-0.0728277117,
0.0449355915,
-0.0533323474,
-0.0368697867,
-0.0008341382,
-0.0916902348,
0.0118315024,
0.0986467525,
-0.0424078293,
-0.0456999801,
0.0296312999,
-0.0462049805,
-0.0124826906,
-0.0343607925,
0.0280475505,
-0.0077928975,
0.0318290964,
0.0050038006,
0.0600285754,
-0.028027961,
0.0186758116,
0.0032356351,
-0.0037781922,
0.0309167802,
0.0031877197,
-0.0387073085,
-0.0216205325,
-0.0238642655,
0.0235849433,
0.0320879295,
-0.0146987354,
-0.0088074822,
-0.0783462897,
-0.0049014236,
0.0260441396,
-0.0357355326,
0.0421625376,
0.0360738188,
-0.0087099839,
0.0320475176,
-0.0165547226,
-0.0497810133,
0.0104032895,
-0.0095798085,
0.0022903858,
0.0226492379,
0.0041282559,
-0.014340966,
-0.016231792,
-0.0077654831,
-0.0352753215,
0.017270945,
-0.0277848039,
-0.0034941437,
-0.0328102782,
0.0187096763,
-0.0168897808,
0.0018045005,
0.0098691927,
-0.0689557865,
-0.0113683511,
0.0030742092,
-0.0172132403,
0.0551673099,
0.001439304,
0.0351726487,
0.0299029611,
0.041235283,
-0.0336219631,
0.0214290339,
-0.0521606281,
-0.0068973061,
-0.0374972709,
-0.0396367386,
-0.0193078984,
0.1044583917,
-0.0179555304,
0.0012710277,
-0.0779626518,
0.0232569166,
0.0038964644,
-0.033333797,
0.0183203071,
0.0075263074,
0.0029205128,
0.0007148589,
-0.0408052206,
-0.0191060752,
0.0687645301,
0.0206080507,
-0.009660447,
-0.0237970278,
-0.0010352434,
-0.0505462363,
0.0790036097,
0.0120633915,
-0.01125562,
0.0300607607,
-0.0189623423,
-0.0707464516,
-0.0070998902,
0.0588627867,
0.0122434441,
0.0364856012,
0.0045185373,
0.0009972831,
-0.0067861383,
-0.0580042861,
-0.0312085226,
-0.0518022589,
-0.026144173,
0.0295504425,
0.0156142348,
0.0103231361,
-0.08079575,
-0.0196209475,
-0.0121715711,
-0.0053156968,
0.0037124567,
0.0037238144,
-0.0439797118,
0.0219942853,
0.0468756743,
0.0027826023,
0.0400035456,
-0.0281057823,
0.0067516612,
0.037181858,
-0.0076093855,
0.0484003723,
-0.0417718366,
0.0068175308,
0.0248720683,
-0.0027807609,
-0.0339381509,
-0.0156420115,
0.021513788,
-0.0204874612,
-0.013013551,
0.1050259843,
0.0144875767,
-0.0229606926,
0.0172986425,
0.0064919344,
0.0182160195,
0.0332740992,
-0.0227730833,
-0.0678336173,
-0.043714758,
-0.0124292234,
-0.0169931054,
0.0329802744,
-0.0158052798,
0.0036237729,
-0.0886062235,
0.0086474102,
-0.0156421047,
-0.0011070401,
-0.0078465063,
0.0051258625,
0.0111264531,
-0.0715490803,
-0.0268473327,
-0.0300162658,
0.0117866145,
-0.005671978,
0.0146286367,
0.0123078777,
-0.0075060898,
0.0504239239,
-0.0457018316,
0.0212716553,
0.0173425097,
0.0492416471,
-0.0170181971,
-0.0190060548,
-0.0135078393,
-0.0767039508,
-0.0170244463,
0.0008170917,
0.0767926425,
-0.03147934,
-0.0302223917,
0.0002271935,
0.0244760308,
-0.0676354542,
-0.0001557888,
-0.0442626886,
0.0479734689,
-0.0097463643,
-0.0713295266,
-0.0171059109,
-0.0108792372,
-0.0104375351,
0.091935575,
0.003890038,
-0.0093109859,
-0.0689048544,
-0.0171290971,
0.0022075926,
-0.0269079097,
-0.0247166678,
0.0196934398,
0.0429271087,
-0.0726807863,
-0.0711835399,
-0.0467100516,
-0.0196249839,
-0.0375236161,
-0.0093911272,
-0.0490336977,
0.0331268273,
-0.0299849752,
-0.0124839703,
0.0324564055,
-0.0183824934,
0.0251611415,
-0.0088980868,
0.0112272529,
0.0772734135,
0.0147661893,
-0.0471479446,
-0.013700014,
-0.0779369622,
-0.0134537006,
-0.0066566831,
0.0477989502,
0.0159203969,
0.0295407251,
-0.0264603365,
-0.0218108092,
0.011185566,
0.0656512603,
0.0080774473,
0.0139195658,
0.0579625443,
-0.0332574695,
0.000529432,
0.0560014807,
-0.0299861021,
0.0556302592,
0.0383339599,
0.0363451093,
0.008446808,
-0.0585842989,
0.0130704697,
-0.0117634786,
0.0819059014,
0.013764618,
-0.0159706175,
0.0021004356,
0.0154268797,
0.009548516,
-0.0142307701,
-0.060842067,
-0.011139214,
0.0401422419,
0.0457918867,
-0.0394113809,
0.0185546055,
0.0072731939,
0.0268293079,
-0.0221733227,
0.0105863521,
0.0003757614,
-0.0344512202,
-0.0191516839,
0.0367678143,
-0.0140236188,
-0.0183150917,
0.0331399515,
0.0293576587,
0.0035955207,
0.0043176715,
0.0343934111,
0.0250955038,
-0.0330463499,
0.0173060708,
-0.0838967487,
0.0346835144,
-0.056143932,
-0.0232489742,
0.0238747727,
-0.0176484268,
0.0618883409,
-0.0424356088,
0.0179259479,
-0.0053944965,
0.0486105494,
0.0085588302,
-0.0146569405,
0.0145826014,
-0.0114933345,
0.0057257237,
-0.0040290891,
0.0625674352,
-0.0143240513,
0.0475293994,
-0.0018525092,
-0.0158860553,
-0.022381274,
-0.0515981056,
-0.0112775611,
-0.006312022,
0.0196662191,
0.0309980121,
-0.0358640403,
-0.0709672943,
0.0317440256,
-0.0417537577,
0.0187524837,
-0.0468201451,
0.0373444259,
0.0393996425,
-0.0139120035,
-0.0480011031,
-0.0055125905,
-0.0158427246,
0.0199574511,
0.0024850122,
-0.0536159761,
-6.260276632e-33,
-0.0033009665,
0.0240847934,
-0.0270491317,
0.0532981753,
-0.0094549479,
-0.0130713843,
-0.027365027,
-0.0176020637,
-0.0294821449,
0.0402955711,
0.0240912605,
0.0303586759,
0.0094774691,
0.0337700993,
0.0353641361,
-0.0607345998,
0.0570403859,
0.003635139,
-0.0064369449,
0.0124168731,
0.0268568285,
0.0279419012,
0.0915149897,
-0.0611178093,
0.0077110445,
0.0107695628,
-0.0329779387,
0.0331004485,
-0.015627604,
0.0602196082,
-0.0033675935,
0.0621005856,
0.0407075658,
-0.0563242696,
0.0076652216,
0.0106799854,
-0.0769482628,
-0.0378558151,
-0.0172297508,
0.0079267807,
0.0054121031,
-0.0618692227,
0.0674396902,
0.0329548605,
-0.0146891633,
-0.0573688708,
0.0665732101,
-0.01137893,
0.0484281965,
-0.0427600965,
-0.0517514572,
-0.0145754786,
-0.0089016184,
-0.0451853573,
0.0001616249,
0.0389116257,
-0.0080153383,
0.016626155,
-0.0529822558,
-0.0140711796,
-0.0215568207,
0.0416417085,
0.0385768339,
-0.0026603697,
-0.0040127113,
0.0520507731,
0.0285817999,
0.0104602911,
-0.0122082233,
-0.0503467917,
0.041271966,
0.0501161516,
0.1053082421,
0.0608332157,
0.0558990464,
0.0376193635,
-0.067437239,
-0.0016337318,
0.005154714,
0.0824051425,
0.0461065881,
-0.0099161882,
-0.0355910696,
-0.0317722708,
-0.058184322,
-0.0112259807,
-0.0524835251,
-0.030447986,
0.0412490927,
0.0183715634,
-0.0295010768,
0.0432526097,
0.0290194731,
-0.0758611038,
-0.0048283567,
0.0308715031,
-0.0222943313,
0.044880759,
0.0112988334,
0.0348356329,
-0.0404344201,
-0.0482205898,
0.0225991029,
0.0741178989,
0.0239401143,
0.0092536276,
0.0696090609,
0.0089702476,
-0.0630421489,
-0.0036531079,
-0.0291561633,
-0.0065529821,
-0.0282871779,
0.0072381948,
-0.0076972684,
0.0535917319,
-0.0228013098,
0.0447961912,
0.0155932354,
0.0127592888,
-0.0387552045,
0.0049970946,
0.0298966635,
0.0208799671,
-0.0275240391,
0.0053945007,
-0.0565789714,
-0.0484193265,
0.0233203992,
-0.0376259014,
-0.0229129158,
-0.0135896197,
2.686e-7,
0.0610907152,
0.0125448611,
0.0325571485,
0.0191671606,
0.0209580846,
0.0584666878,
0.0174366068,
0.05062389,
0.0095335478,
-0.023208132,
0.0230806805,
0.0452360325,
0.0537431203,
-0.0050469586,
-0.0608140379,
0.0682586208,
-0.1070109531,
-0.0091436561,
0.0018047699,
0.0156097868,
0.0574430153,
0.1047081947,
0.0100623574,
-0.0085509298,
-0.0315976776,
-0.0224813744,
0.0628049076,
-0.0124628879,
0.0086141098,
0.0314073339,
0.0320245884,
0.0123020746,
0.0189761426,
0.0363220125,
-0.0186410248,
0.0243825931,
0.0292981192,
0.0650866702,
-0.0186564866,
-0.0329229869,
-0.0254207533,
-0.0003263223,
0.0115842503,
-0.0470232964,
0.0545390472,
-0.0952268839,
-0.0031330206,
-0.0110512124,
-0.0515939966,
0.0137168877,
0.0231791381,
-0.0020959079,
0.0011534449,
0.0186901018,
0.0329249501,
0.0036022535,
-0.0192896258,
-0.0529311933,
-0.0369763188,
-0.022596227,
-0.0188035574,
-0.0475692824,
-0.0279026758,
0.0107028736,
0.0366920941,
-0.0395172387,
0.0216173381,
2.110136108e-34,
0.0462134555,
0.0353537351,
0.0319410004,
0.0040268912,
0.0168681722,
-0.0018408614,
-0.0148231387,
-0.0044148779,
0.0125660533,
-0.0622464493,
-0.0199586339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02872v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02872v2 | How do Large Language Models Learn In-Context? Query and Key Matrices of In-Context Heads are Two Towers for Metric Learning | 2024-02-05T10:39:32 | 2024-06-11T12:58:51 | Zeping Yu, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We investigate the mechanism of in-context learning (ICL) on sentence
classification tasks with semantically-unrelated labels ("foo"/"bar"). We find
intervening in only 1\% heads (named "in-context heads") significantly affects
ICL accuracy from 87.6\% to 24.4\%. To understand this phenomenon, we analyze
the value-output vectors in these heads and discover that the vectors at each
label position contain substantial information about the corresponding labels.
Furthermore, we observe that the prediction shift from "foo" to "bar" is due to
the respective reduction and increase in these heads' attention scores at "foo"
and "bar" positions. Therefore, we propose a hypothesis for ICL: in in-context
heads, the value-output matrices extract label features, while the query-key
matrices compute the similarity between the features at the last position and
those at each label position. The query and key matrices can be considered as
two towers that learn the similarity metric between the last position's
features and each demonstration at label positions. Using this hypothesis, we
explain the majority label bias and recency bias in ICL and propose two methods
to reduce these biases by 22\% and 17\%, respectively. | [
0.0188105013,
-0.0177695751,
-0.0105795171,
0.0466356091,
-0.0311053377,
0.0605352633,
-0.0101270666,
-0.0148195522,
0.0058884406,
-0.0589098372,
-0.0545692816,
-0.0427053161,
0.0222252235,
-0.0062592863,
0.0306659862,
-0.0591178313,
0.0355469994,
-0.0207182672,
0.0021974398,
0.0034330264,
0.0050574937,
-0.0192455538,
-0.0020887284,
0.0213513151,
-0.0425506681,
-0.0338069834,
-0.0094601931,
0.0187257715,
-0.0108738923,
-0.0149852782,
0.0388354957,
0.0445377752,
0.0071912557,
0.0309469104,
0.0000018187,
-0.0513022095,
0.0134778395,
-0.0216127858,
-0.003932117,
0.0001551685,
0.0285441261,
0.0156835187,
-0.0063623972,
0.0121521233,
-0.0138053363,
-0.0273301527,
0.0408509746,
0.0486084968,
0.0033220504,
0.0596427135,
-0.0053331563,
-0.0298976079,
-0.0045885313,
-0.029248286,
0.060920056,
-0.0845072865,
0.0259391759,
-0.0307609513,
-0.046955917,
0.0178967752,
-0.0284434967,
0.0332401991,
0.0229368713,
0.0305465627,
0.0334877335,
0.0818197504,
0.0031921307,
-0.0104384031,
-0.0144766187,
0.0549258031,
-0.0274249669,
-0.0385590568,
0.0060705016,
-0.0087942611,
0.0518973656,
-0.05520235,
-0.0725355148,
0.0270150881,
0.0256665275,
0.0152219813,
0.0332829878,
0.0308977533,
0.0164012276,
-0.0247013345,
-0.0225782227,
0.0473986045,
0.010038631,
-0.0591856912,
0.0282111671,
0.0297408793,
-0.0139033459,
-0.0565333478,
-0.0307187438,
0.0063822204,
-0.0226437096,
0.0397991389,
-0.0394878536,
-0.0201254878,
0.0120623251,
-0.0901392102,
-0.0053294268,
0.011801823,
-0.0432803072,
0.0526689142,
-0.0262563564,
0.0626731589,
-0.0140738068,
0.0301868301,
-0.0385775119,
-0.0226155426,
-0.0372019969,
-0.0129498001,
-0.015664408,
0.0262417123,
-0.000776294,
-0.0112232398,
-0.0227441024,
0.034419246,
-0.0173583999,
-0.0042501371,
-0.0014894141,
0.0043710335,
-0.0462499037,
-0.0108939176,
-0.0155662317,
0.0466083661,
-0.0154861398,
0.0198788848,
-0.0100677833,
-0.020520458,
-0.033004418,
0.0370180197,
0.0386214592,
-0.027880244,
-0.0040664119,
0.0263803992,
-0.0319148153,
-0.0617103986,
0.0045341831,
-0.0015767138,
-0.045336701,
-0.0710491091,
-0.0066599413,
-0.0434458479,
-0.0088238446,
0.0441142097,
0.0020309454,
-0.0315381736,
-0.0117470222,
0.0518584363,
-0.0358695053,
0.0297848564,
0.0868431926,
0.00718066,
0.0223423094,
-0.0052691344,
0.0108066183,
0.0734368861,
-0.0250957888,
0.0394278094,
0.0065845395,
0.0163586345,
-0.00749441,
0.0352920368,
0.0430919901,
0.0101419594,
-0.0632631257,
0.018454222,
0.0783363655,
0.0198528841,
0.0251509584,
0.0089655556,
-0.0147712668,
0.0110104568,
0.0772319138,
0.0289534535,
0.0099108834,
-0.0365152322,
-0.0031237439,
-0.0231092181,
-0.0336334258,
0.0230040997,
-0.0889602005,
0.0315898471,
0.000365701,
-0.0010149002,
0.0110405572,
-0.0178545248,
-0.039518822,
-0.0440321714,
-0.0070594498,
0.00423293,
-0.0391742997,
0.0050788582,
0.0465286821,
0.0419662222,
-0.0495920293,
0.0295166206,
0.0223148521,
-0.0103525473,
-0.0040027509,
-0.0174969435,
-0.0000837229,
-0.0048048524,
0.0029553361,
-0.0342275351,
-0.0056118108,
0.0094266897,
0.0295099579,
0.0129878558,
0.0258638784,
-0.0301867332,
0.0071017719,
-0.0046260841,
-0.016835371,
-0.0108755715,
0.0311998185,
-0.0182877034,
0.0070949784,
-0.0002507169,
0.0160411485,
-0.0641909465,
-0.0190705657,
0.0487381853,
0.0169243962,
-0.0566154309,
0.0012186031,
0.0363080241,
0.0286009219,
-0.0316135213,
0.0167502016,
0.0130281709,
0.0452459008,
-0.0332823172,
0.0047966619,
-0.0122857429,
-0.0914281309,
-0.0743768141,
0.0426633134,
0.0036341678,
-0.0233575888,
-0.0100811915,
-0.0158676915,
-0.033507362,
0.0089384858,
-0.025166221,
0.0389100425,
-0.0191946514,
0.0200603921,
-0.0195061211,
0.0104852915,
-0.0676361248,
0.1042692363,
-0.0079260888,
0.0025078193,
-0.0176366866,
0.0024321387,
0.0035136314,
0.0111065684,
0.0125765158,
0.0214068722,
0.0080685345,
-0.0023601388,
-0.0105309039,
-0.0272897147,
-0.0534142964,
-0.0100293765,
-0.1153631881,
0.0037426818,
-0.036201939,
0.0017410851,
0.053115271,
0.0003449679,
0.015686132,
-0.0410719849,
-0.0461866446,
-0.0249525309,
-0.0222336631,
0.0424783193,
0.0223913398,
0.0282319449,
-0.0231964029,
-0.0123385228,
-0.0145896822,
-0.0260045715,
0.0803684369,
-0.0174278673,
-0.0313617624,
-0.0480943583,
0.0436201356,
0.0163022317,
-0.0010082836,
-0.0107300971,
0.0204821788,
0.0134728719,
-0.0241410024,
0.0620360561,
0.1089099199,
0.0102675613,
0.0569969341,
0.0588650629,
-0.0028743676,
-0.0494041145,
-0.0023974441,
-0.0405656099,
-0.004846029,
-0.0564515181,
-0.0067023397,
0.0104764272,
0.0664723441,
0.0282465443,
0.0137678143,
-0.0439540371,
0.0021015187,
-0.0164194386,
-0.0167341959,
-0.0910575092,
0.0070432774,
-0.0486158095,
0.0590015762,
-0.0151263792,
-0.0368250422,
0.0463678651,
-0.0022628133,
-0.0187852103,
-0.0648203418,
0.0037387575,
-0.0382157266,
0.0579966046,
0.0279289465,
0.0178710297,
-0.0009110096,
-0.0426410474,
-0.0784378648,
-0.0090616904,
-0.0001580815,
0.0016687117,
0.0190405827,
0.0095768953,
-0.0019393583,
-0.0077027581,
-0.0214187186,
-0.0522677675,
-0.0222517606,
-0.0165679287,
0.0049546985,
-0.0506993569,
0.0023335901,
-0.0158404689,
-0.0121500669,
0.0612661093,
0.0315624103,
-0.0298489891,
-0.0014491155,
-0.0073256572,
0.0638188645,
0.0349273086,
0.0013776933,
0.0031465308,
-0.0596150793,
0.0022010901,
0.0586265847,
0.0511112101,
0.0059495317,
0.0045948005,
-0.0176210944,
0.042152632,
-0.0256097205,
-0.0299557317,
0.0670011491,
0.023413552,
-0.0591632016,
-0.0294316243,
0.0801041424,
0.0237521324,
-0.0830184892,
-0.0036134701,
0.0151334759,
0.0526923425,
0.057104066,
0.011158796,
-0.0408316776,
-0.0342248753,
0.0341832824,
0.0028238599,
0.003931317,
0.0101944292,
-0.006869066,
-0.1319103837,
0.0504554212,
-0.0156594999,
-0.0860636756,
-0.0422905646,
-0.0250381958,
0.0221672133,
0.014908893,
0.0270660724,
0.0195210725,
-0.016513681,
-0.0069108717,
0.0440561473,
0.0297089573,
-0.0507798493,
0.0202442184,
-0.0073777186,
0.0242112856,
0.0487186722,
0.0371767357,
-0.0042760721,
-0.006210817,
0.0658827871,
-0.0784021243,
0.0042886096,
-0.0152764376,
0.0460248291,
-0.0124404477,
-0.0036412182,
-0.0124369403,
0.0252439957,
-0.0455579422,
-0.0031667913,
-0.0033318398,
0.0847311169,
0.0010484129,
-0.0269070696,
-0.003966819,
-0.0284767523,
0.002812939,
0.0737185031,
0.0647835061,
-0.0485448204,
-0.0512265079,
0.0026329411,
0.0286455043,
0.0140157714,
0.001401521,
0.0100516947,
-0.0002746374,
-0.0316611528,
-0.0629365295,
-0.0248012636,
0.0115894796,
0.031211786,
-0.010268773,
0.0238279346,
-0.0377877913,
0.0019056094,
-0.0200875197,
0.0169497225,
-0.0239731912,
0.0068488447,
-0.0591539852,
0.0101565905,
0.0178731717,
-0.0382604599,
-0.0456157476,
0.0116249109,
-0.0674856752,
-0.039177727,
0.0188116003,
0.00203625,
0.0140068494,
0.0722461492,
0.0010704,
-0.0432926677,
0.0251798313,
0.0478060134,
-0.0038605186,
0.0493480898,
0.0171164405,
-0.0268380754,
0.0022728047,
0.0566573665,
-0.0514550209,
0.0198739786,
0.0490677282,
0.0180983432,
-0.0305799134,
-0.0141282547,
0.0312720314,
-0.0253188238,
0.069097206,
0.0058341315,
-0.0096093584,
-0.0233824309,
0.0423095264,
0.0292584021,
-0.048485972,
0.0022884745,
-0.0220002104,
0.0134069901,
0.0467612222,
-0.0086215334,
0.0499842912,
0.0243570432,
0.0249006618,
-0.0067663868,
-0.0364451408,
0.0038161175,
0.0303945206,
0.0205268413,
0.0373570919,
-0.0284954254,
0.001852002,
0.0229546353,
0.0721949115,
-0.0021754261,
0.0063530691,
0.0492806211,
-0.0196733512,
-0.0510333478,
0.0086714895,
-0.1066569611,
0.0104665533,
-0.0206973981,
-0.0251420252,
0.0393155701,
-0.0375992842,
0.0253283326,
-0.0097587137,
-0.015075068,
-0.010791501,
-0.0036372752,
-0.0035464328,
-0.024865713,
0.0169191472,
0.0056045996,
0.0007346294,
0.0304398108,
0.0738131851,
0.0481045432,
0.029275341,
0.0087224254,
-0.0195035972,
-0.0132348705,
0.0071758763,
0.0155261373,
0.0441041589,
0.0028322535,
0.0196249746,
-0.0363550223,
-0.0555849411,
0.0283650551,
-0.0395535417,
-0.0070790276,
-0.0512324125,
0.0410406776,
0.0560780279,
0.0141164633,
-0.0473143756,
-0.0198916718,
0.0000415641,
0.0341035984,
-0.0204104539,
-0.0224106163,
-6.346974483e-33,
-0.0190197118,
-0.0313478447,
-0.0273140632,
0.0182816163,
0.0017374324,
-0.004887043,
-0.0409914777,
-0.0014289285,
-0.0147993341,
0.0226278678,
-0.0011296098,
0.0177730918,
0.0089740427,
0.011748095,
0.0137266386,
-0.0364396349,
0.0332391709,
-0.014522926,
-0.0115951421,
0.0597328544,
0.0370210633,
0.0334370285,
0.0737914965,
-0.0732550919,
0.0127290841,
-0.0360977873,
0.0039577857,
0.0128926113,
-0.0172719136,
0.0348078236,
-0.0128725171,
0.0615983643,
0.0519320965,
-0.0693583488,
-0.0193622522,
0.0414391868,
-0.0953221843,
-0.0330395885,
-0.0066601331,
0.0185797717,
0.0087066917,
-0.0088402219,
0.065372698,
0.018381875,
-0.018329965,
-0.051959414,
0.0703945458,
0.0049967254,
-0.0747803748,
-0.0029972305,
-0.0646608844,
-0.0129720662,
0.0092060352,
-0.002185965,
0.0101425033,
0.031286072,
0.0107398126,
0.0595432296,
-0.0526270047,
0.0008015205,
-0.0161730144,
0.0598352849,
0.0075601926,
0.0605558269,
0.0002975731,
0.0562965609,
0.0658434704,
0.0208189301,
0.0116435289,
-0.0600985587,
0.0381566584,
0.0134146502,
0.004885505,
0.0183579847,
0.0690078661,
0.018958278,
-0.0946316198,
-0.0253309552,
-0.0108023481,
0.0306652021,
0.033093702,
0.0084314924,
-0.063412115,
-0.0608735085,
-0.0507415533,
-0.0368658304,
-0.0472914316,
0.0026305648,
0.0587257259,
0.0274416376,
0.033924982,
0.0297788475,
0.0123755531,
-0.0227962304,
-0.0376182608,
0.026482692,
-0.0180347171,
0.0121040121,
0.027333891,
0.0181189701,
-0.0809272826,
-0.0058513065,
-0.0165418684,
0.0215342958,
-0.0045475587,
0.0011276148,
0.0753311962,
0.0069792168,
-0.0666843131,
-0.0234894715,
-0.0377735011,
-0.0086364141,
-0.0201424379,
0.0241083056,
0.0285954531,
0.0147473915,
-0.0078566708,
0.0930357575,
0.0463945195,
0.0004080321,
-0.039040003,
-0.0393559448,
-0.0189489946,
0.0148645444,
-0.031825792,
-0.0396667235,
-0.0244092532,
0.0247626211,
0.0445713177,
-0.0468892008,
-0.0123447953,
0.0045429748,
2.689e-7,
0.0171699338,
0.0416792966,
-0.024298925,
-0.014325045,
0.0605349801,
0.0677444488,
-0.0255234316,
0.029457828,
0.0399137624,
-0.0344978198,
-0.0036410051,
0.013745307,
0.0151259908,
0.0005386854,
-0.0753981844,
0.0295073353,
-0.0738609731,
0.0323352627,
-0.0255046226,
0.0098667555,
0.0139279822,
0.086154066,
0.0116889765,
-0.0205912087,
0.0091099991,
-0.0112458672,
0.0676512197,
-0.00910425,
0.0378321074,
-0.0059215715,
-0.0247641671,
0.0278179627,
0.0289002117,
0.0444199629,
0.0080749942,
0.0468456745,
-0.009049071,
0.0279988367,
-0.0197306201,
-0.0369302072,
0.0112955924,
0.0380336232,
0.0034916776,
-0.094817318,
0.0849214345,
-0.0624287799,
-0.0195690244,
-0.0415823311,
-0.007398461,
0.0048190164,
-0.0002038221,
0.0421797447,
-0.0097193429,
-0.0225412864,
0.0188591573,
-0.0061409972,
-0.0209852252,
-0.1038681939,
-0.0549212806,
0.0459805317,
-0.0322273374,
-0.0382993892,
-0.0404060371,
0.0438040569,
0.0349367112,
-0.0261691306,
-0.0112503264,
2.487715914e-34,
-0.0056586564,
-0.0032448838,
0.028219467,
0.0412447862,
-0.0124885021,
-0.0371863171,
-0.0206847545,
-0.0078082881,
0.0480047464,
-0.063388966,
0.0064852522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02864v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02864v1 | EEVEE: An Easy Annotation Tool for Natural Language Processing | 2024-02-05T10:24:40 | 2024-02-05T10:24:40 | Axel Sorensen, Siyao Peng, Barbara Plank, Rob van der Goot | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Annotation tools are the starting point for creating Natural Language
Processing (NLP) datasets. There is a wide variety of tools available; setting
up these tools is however a hindrance. We propose EEVEE, an annotation tool
focused on simplicity, efficiency, and ease of use. It can run directly in the
browser (no setup required) and uses tab-separated files (as opposed to
character offsets or task-specific formats) for annotation. It allows for
annotation of multiple tasks on a single dataset and supports four task-types:
sequence labeling, span labeling, text classification and seq2seq. | [
0.0433187261,
-0.0235614609,
-0.0193181001,
-0.0043416866,
-0.0109528694,
0.0360659137,
0.0378004052,
-0.018212961,
0.0460797474,
-0.0972326696,
-0.0034094115,
0.0371463038,
-0.0245926641,
0.0635803863,
0.0449202619,
-0.0758544728,
0.0620182119,
0.0197720323,
0.048424121,
0.058838401,
0.0539416261,
0.0330470726,
-0.0237841569,
0.0525323004,
-0.0310570151,
-0.0117248548,
-0.0119433478,
-0.0332297347,
0.0428499877,
-0.0617617108,
0.0130581195,
0.0871537402,
0.0191842038,
0.0174152665,
0.0000019097,
-0.0446534567,
-0.0110782906,
0.0152010601,
-0.0331377089,
0.0039592055,
0.0054444247,
0.0090586189,
-0.0063624578,
0.0250933543,
-0.0104819881,
-0.0380388834,
0.0661970079,
0.0465090722,
0.1029765978,
0.0699369609,
-0.0203385875,
-0.0332893282,
-0.013066479,
-0.0073049199,
0.0302030314,
0.0014317663,
0.0173752271,
-0.0290052295,
-0.0074713863,
-0.0030046955,
0.0351889171,
0.013785149,
-0.0188006274,
-0.051479511,
0.0514853857,
0.0215176716,
-0.0390023142,
-0.0608824119,
-0.0280865617,
0.0565271787,
0.0279361699,
0.0049298233,
0.0187175814,
-0.0002818251,
-0.0279271882,
-0.0249999966,
-0.0361918062,
0.0199360177,
-0.0036159668,
-0.0208661519,
0.0253647063,
-0.005379112,
-0.0034935032,
-0.0055330107,
0.0331106037,
0.0243643578,
0.0137155596,
-0.0116059305,
0.0057845837,
0.0272061992,
-0.0236178152,
-0.0695095956,
0.0637961775,
-0.0063545038,
-0.0195710864,
0.012940377,
-0.0313861854,
-0.081242457,
0.0454136804,
-0.0423451364,
0.0121906875,
-0.0068356483,
-0.0075293407,
0.0404881574,
-0.0107953893,
-0.0158609636,
0.0385790505,
-0.0029604603,
0.024153458,
0.0063803904,
-0.0606621429,
-0.0042730863,
-0.0664899275,
0.0124600409,
-0.0338874198,
-0.0141662983,
-0.0437181555,
0.0103018004,
-0.0201917756,
0.0121319955,
0.0212158989,
-0.0039679715,
-0.0146208787,
0.0487121977,
-0.0070604943,
-0.0176967252,
-0.0571594052,
0.0320299752,
-0.0028514271,
-0.0297459736,
-0.0007980107,
0.0309302583,
0.0482881032,
-0.0365679897,
-0.0283662658,
0.028249789,
0.0260082837,
-0.045947738,
-0.056600064,
-0.0103695523,
-0.0091538467,
-0.0010271689,
-0.0412780009,
-0.0735150725,
0.0290966425,
0.0217483733,
-0.0101014553,
-0.0176651776,
0.0203368999,
0.0269215591,
-0.0105744395,
0.0622045696,
-0.079445295,
-0.0474990644,
0.0227763709,
-0.0157635491,
0.0231474228,
0.0251784455,
0.0457375757,
-0.0120413126,
0.0413108766,
-0.015217185,
0.0058487551,
0.0374625809,
-0.0427450761,
-0.0461092666,
0.0028333659,
-0.0299372245,
-0.0039711329,
0.0077665448,
-0.020480087,
0.0239591505,
-0.0075772721,
0.0335379988,
0.0019990834,
0.0862446949,
0.0004237013,
0.0213125497,
0.0256217103,
0.0660937428,
0.0208230298,
-0.0382653549,
-0.0324046239,
0.0321934111,
0.0197580438,
-0.0099423751,
-0.0018985928,
-0.0261689927,
0.0209822711,
-0.0249203518,
-0.0569712073,
-0.0076314211,
0.0222062934,
-0.0343117267,
0.030899968,
0.0109598888,
-0.0164740365,
0.0173697807,
0.0244214144,
-0.0688649043,
0.0002972068,
-0.0018064341,
0.03067098,
0.0697604865,
0.0198075827,
-0.0403381214,
-0.032505855,
-0.0540493913,
-0.0040649539,
0.0372385271,
0.0486418456,
-0.0440855622,
-0.0267112143,
-0.0396402068,
-0.0251095705,
-0.0351920798,
0.0183330718,
-0.0130563797,
0.0255801827,
-0.0213987585,
0.0022654305,
-0.008292662,
-0.0545634553,
0.0542172156,
0.0330552794,
-0.0145652033,
-0.0013304987,
-0.0077703255,
0.0095969625,
0.0452090912,
-0.0226721466,
0.0254610106,
0.026881827,
0.0100717638,
-0.0108163003,
0.0275525935,
0.043792095,
-0.019655535,
0.0095436135,
-0.054364346,
-0.034452036,
-0.0143459002,
-0.0252928045,
-0.0441784784,
-0.0419249125,
-0.0604447462,
-0.004185345,
-0.0223246124,
-0.0191643722,
0.0002804244,
-0.0011102412,
-0.0248695463,
0.0614587069,
0.0595271699,
-0.0108408863,
-0.0022179151,
0.0001906165,
0.0074931039,
-0.0087228632,
-0.0483495668,
-0.019618541,
0.0241278093,
-0.0310009643,
0.033818718,
-0.0086730523,
-0.0741852596,
0.0317965671,
-0.1041530445,
0.0325294435,
-0.0227292627,
0.0424411111,
0.0234259292,
0.0023778181,
-0.0164931566,
-0.0414974727,
-0.0144229094,
0.0104527278,
-0.0126171643,
0.0009664787,
0.0577363186,
0.0045396257,
-0.0029021206,
-0.0309651587,
0.0162395425,
-0.0483286455,
0.0225593783,
0.042451039,
-0.0865740553,
-0.0377079286,
0.031793274,
0.0078105163,
0.0131625291,
0.0561109148,
0.0059501724,
0.0054155104,
0.0170224719,
0.0186773967,
0.0198392831,
0.0205784906,
0.054606013,
0.0489857681,
0.0039837505,
-0.0105080698,
-0.0051162746,
-0.0078552952,
0.058846835,
-0.0132841952,
-0.0249422714,
0.0081820609,
0.0894855559,
-0.0067144111,
0.0110132406,
-0.0165029988,
0.0266818404,
-0.0096270377,
0.0043083564,
-0.0190192796,
-0.0182710178,
-0.0342067033,
0.0300623365,
-0.0246209558,
-0.0402095877,
0.0648570508,
-0.009729404,
-0.026172949,
-0.0845196396,
-0.0254356321,
-0.0294144414,
0.0850352496,
-0.0250742082,
0.0021601056,
0.0013221317,
-0.0522972271,
0.0395222679,
0.0251964964,
0.0476174988,
-0.0031229586,
0.0050140936,
-0.0472826101,
0.0178693123,
-0.0424745418,
0.0018922959,
-0.0235463139,
-0.0047963662,
-0.0534954965,
0.0037325332,
0.0450021252,
-0.0036956081,
-0.0551442429,
0.0078439526,
0.0294218324,
0.0676800981,
-0.0094449865,
0.01329662,
-0.0194742046,
0.0299386866,
0.0301444679,
0.0146500953,
-0.0224286858,
0.0053707571,
0.016231643,
0.0509889312,
-0.0526568741,
0.0097738551,
-0.0090036886,
0.0119234659,
0.0339210369,
-0.0953116715,
-0.0351445638,
-0.0033635423,
0.0535335392,
-0.0755620077,
0.0030183122,
0.1271526515,
0.0514877848,
-0.035785798,
-0.0094527202,
-0.0101119047,
0.0088699386,
0.0641707927,
0.0318175778,
-0.0889612362,
-0.0477094874,
-0.0046615284,
0.0243638791,
0.0014772329,
-0.022231834,
-0.0060684648,
-0.0511681885,
0.0276282802,
-0.0203588903,
-0.0418772511,
0.0245276615,
-0.0715908706,
-0.0034584298,
-0.0352957435,
-0.0329716057,
-0.0470872633,
0.0004540722,
0.033152774,
0.0461448394,
-0.0320227742,
-0.0335844494,
-0.0094392877,
-0.0492534973,
0.0753050148,
0.0572788715,
0.0444349833,
-0.0035671908,
-0.0090267248,
-0.0010672469,
0.0039931568,
-0.0205322374,
-0.0273216143,
0.0722330809,
-0.0102437194,
-0.0119784959,
-0.04494901,
0.0139524769,
0.0210377853,
-0.0493842699,
0.0443261452,
0.0399141982,
-0.0444579832,
0.0256950948,
0.0022538663,
-0.0165880062,
0.0039994577,
0.0449422337,
0.0144856274,
-0.0211369675,
-0.0375440456,
-0.0385251008,
-0.0065150242,
-0.0846098587,
-0.0482627787,
-0.0000264981,
-0.0518993959,
-0.0489976257,
-0.0675774217,
-0.0493288785,
0.1029823869,
0.0192194078,
0.0651536211,
0.0133082205,
0.0185954235,
0.0162807517,
-0.0469778739,
0.0203383677,
0.0351800136,
0.0102482559,
-0.0014488905,
-0.067292735,
0.0424516387,
0.0208039861,
-0.0151617909,
0.0442689508,
-0.0502347834,
-0.0310586859,
-0.0030574545,
0.01097719,
0.014160159,
0.0033463323,
-0.008513175,
-0.0379010253,
-0.0206345804,
0.0397455022,
-0.067084603,
-0.056755133,
-0.0077426,
0.0100393221,
-0.0039047177,
0.0095162857,
-0.0179550312,
0.0152896857,
-0.054922875,
0.0346727483,
-0.0112468218,
-0.0540096126,
0.0099820569,
0.0019674585,
0.0737325698,
-0.034097638,
-0.0130592166,
-0.0726278871,
0.0012485191,
-0.0121682351,
-0.0333583318,
-0.0273508634,
0.0475092009,
-0.0067158956,
-0.0180384535,
-0.0158756711,
0.0669784322,
-0.0229713749,
-0.0284518301,
-0.0834598541,
0.0712781623,
0.0302450396,
-0.0118634589,
-0.03409978,
0.0051845592,
-0.0290007144,
0.0012261218,
0.0088473773,
0.0263473094,
-0.015299907,
0.0258629117,
0.0021553217,
-0.0412088186,
0.0213629156,
0.0299536046,
-0.0289094821,
0.0454444699,
-0.0095881913,
0.046534624,
0.0551904812,
-0.0311820116,
0.1009326875,
-0.021992892,
-0.0143806245,
-0.0082240086,
0.0683860332,
-0.0057567297,
-0.0309139993,
0.0195378624,
-0.0119703989,
-0.0504169911,
-0.0525326394,
0.0402997844,
-0.0109257093,
0.0414865389,
0.017606508,
-0.0519303977,
-0.0414998196,
-0.0018648012,
0.0093068685,
0.0275856461,
-0.0372369438,
-0.0115300836,
-0.0145869376,
-0.0140955141,
0.009907796,
-0.0098951738,
-0.0101390062,
0.0244050045,
0.0557832643,
0.0172971152,
0.0082721747,
-0.0523358919,
-0.048938904,
0.0338834189,
-0.0068115015,
-0.0293070935,
-0.0205025356,
-5.725719474e-33,
-0.0294504277,
-0.0664855763,
-0.0119102849,
0.0753300786,
0.0334715769,
0.0052499957,
-0.0393014699,
0.0186066963,
0.02982031,
-0.0038716539,
0.0338744707,
-0.0147893941,
0.0331269912,
-0.0063413726,
0.0372897014,
-0.0196624883,
0.0585214347,
0.0152417822,
-0.0300599858,
0.0053787208,
0.0289571621,
0.0420617722,
0.1028119847,
-0.0916473791,
0.0600009747,
0.0181586333,
-0.0006554766,
-0.0027176826,
0.0133363921,
0.0505151264,
-0.0117527694,
0.0393616222,
-0.0106100375,
-0.0465892404,
-0.0266380962,
0.0273745693,
-0.0762970895,
-0.0229501352,
0.0249030106,
0.0329762287,
-0.0457869992,
-0.0328231342,
-0.0045885998,
-0.0105527407,
0.0002886886,
0.0533446372,
0.0777236819,
0.0043791612,
0.009999739,
-0.0069570229,
-0.0671360046,
0.0516419336,
-0.0396330692,
-0.0022237608,
0.033087641,
0.0500723682,
0.0335602574,
-0.0352679603,
-0.0777419806,
0.0035940025,
-0.0316082351,
0.0266087949,
0.0468490459,
-0.0147210229,
-0.0281519387,
0.070358336,
0.0185187738,
-0.0339649804,
0.0074071288,
0.0424280129,
-0.0177355465,
0.0324262716,
0.0295335781,
-0.0006590829,
0.0259166453,
0.0053073438,
-0.0519639924,
0.0454529338,
0.0324135236,
0.0218047705,
0.0005160564,
0.0089897849,
0.0109481681,
-0.0045053083,
-0.040112704,
-0.0056696674,
-0.0231168792,
-0.0167756975,
0.0232126191,
-0.0064173709,
-0.0352906808,
0.0759681016,
-0.0105685862,
0.0141787268,
-0.0096795978,
-0.010936141,
0.0035315177,
0.0304408967,
-0.0209504515,
-0.0214384012,
-0.012628275,
-0.0161685701,
0.0216275193,
-0.0126095172,
0.0459447876,
-0.0261446834,
0.058067631,
-0.0212522727,
-0.0589892939,
0.0125900842,
-0.002969376,
0.0292993113,
-0.0205627345,
0.0139541281,
0.0078604864,
-0.0180487428,
-0.0232354328,
0.0264581591,
0.0291288793,
0.0183190387,
-0.0431926511,
-0.0462532751,
0.0149923265,
0.0087457551,
-0.0092887552,
0.0159792881,
-0.0212270282,
0.0514043719,
-0.0212476254,
-0.0380420648,
0.0143218385,
0.0128845209,
2.472e-7,
0.0618440881,
0.0764156431,
0.0726839304,
-0.0228312202,
0.0162087046,
0.0167274419,
-0.0093615679,
0.0383126959,
-0.0182083156,
0.0125010349,
-0.0417802073,
0.0003702513,
0.0261327159,
0.0490058251,
-0.0811477378,
-0.068365261,
-0.0363066867,
0.0171327852,
-0.0718265697,
0.0603885427,
0.0935911983,
0.0623748973,
0.0269517731,
0.0217886101,
-0.010435489,
-0.0175817516,
0.0018705714,
-0.0050957776,
0.024481222,
0.0246357489,
0.0029971637,
0.0466210321,
-0.0083738659,
0.0573170595,
-0.0690271184,
-0.0070913499,
0.0221873261,
0.0546089187,
-0.0229754038,
0.0240937155,
0.0038477373,
0.0010373122,
0.014793505,
-0.0217732191,
0.0653568506,
-0.0078164889,
-0.0459163859,
-0.0255611185,
0.0108190365,
-0.0003338893,
0.0092881666,
-0.0130972816,
0.004306362,
-0.0085284337,
0.0172379613,
-0.0329341888,
-0.073612608,
-0.0629345626,
-0.0618907586,
0.0164426602,
0.0041769939,
-0.0204525795,
-0.0446377955,
-0.0005245372,
0.0220718812,
-0.0390443243,
0.0047111777,
2.220182124e-34,
-0.0110774999,
0.0136451442,
-0.0097743571,
0.0612027794,
0.0334247537,
-0.0054742349,
-0.0004422083,
0.0119277015,
-0.0131656108,
-0.0418769382,
-0.0394834913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02844v1 | Comparing Knowledge Sources for Open-Domain Scientific Claim Verification | 2024-02-05T09:57:15 | 2024-02-05T09:57:15 | Juraj Vladika, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The increasing rate at which scientific knowledge is discovered and health
claims shared online has highlighted the importance of developing efficient
fact-checking systems for scientific claims. The usual setting for this task in
the literature assumes that the documents containing the evidence for claims
are already provided and annotated or contained in a limited corpus. This
renders the systems unrealistic for real-world settings where knowledge sources
with potentially millions of documents need to be queried to find relevant
evidence. In this paper, we perform an array of experiments to test the
performance of open-domain claim verification systems. We test the final
verdict prediction of systems on four datasets of biomedical and health claims
in different settings. While keeping the pipeline's evidence selection and
verdict prediction parts constant, document retrieval is performed over three
common knowledge sources (PubMed, Wikipedia, Google) and using two different
information retrieval techniques. We show that PubMed works better with
specialized biomedical claims, while Wikipedia is more suited for everyday
health concerns. Likewise, BM25 excels in retrieval precision, while semantic
search in recall of relevant evidence. We discuss the results, outline frequent
retrieval patterns and challenges, and provide promising future directions. | [
0.0295865666,
0.0255784821,
0.006144336,
-0.00850398,
-0.0542655885,
-0.0135878902,
-0.0057110754,
0.0590088367,
0.033531297,
-0.0171012562,
0.0228180028,
-0.0170453768,
0.0226600375,
0.021394439,
-0.0224450435,
0.0124954982,
0.0226205774,
0.0375498012,
0.0878482163,
-0.0128078489,
-0.0363758542,
0.0026921534,
-0.0495194085,
0.0363490619,
-0.0011372084,
0.0158510301,
0.0600774474,
-0.0251806378,
0.0242666341,
-0.0795372725,
0.0182667468,
0.0171175674,
-0.019063225,
0.0656412318,
0.0000016832,
-0.0648300275,
-0.0132465344,
0.0586554557,
-0.0352506265,
0.0189953148,
0.0174055602,
0.0186421275,
0.0137225138,
0.0315244198,
-0.0043537286,
-0.0357787013,
0.0385901332,
0.033338856,
0.0113995662,
0.0615825206,
-0.0068633044,
-0.0164164156,
0.0303331837,
0.0025476236,
0.0258947797,
-0.0040898845,
0.0664649829,
-0.00158285,
0.0358258598,
-0.0109137036,
0.0525171198,
0.04130698,
-0.0553104132,
-0.0093162479,
-0.0150103569,
0.0571271181,
-0.0433980636,
-0.0231939945,
0.017408859,
0.0355864465,
0.0639880151,
-0.0443791486,
0.0292564891,
-0.0094160466,
-0.0081040831,
0.0656827912,
-0.0298286825,
0.0570251569,
-0.0372216627,
-0.007336189,
-0.0079155145,
0.032003995,
0.0402337275,
0.0323164128,
-0.0008491504,
0.0622200333,
-0.0098728659,
-0.0773831904,
0.0472886413,
-0.0041402993,
0.0526915863,
-0.0671763942,
0.0445282049,
-0.0180827826,
0.0167234652,
0.0089654215,
0.0369154327,
-0.0097124791,
0.1207766086,
-0.080926545,
0.0005048135,
-0.0001351093,
-0.0450299159,
0.0492553711,
-0.0200649966,
-0.0284860395,
-0.02979967,
0.0167638157,
0.0319566615,
0.009764744,
-0.0426549502,
-0.0058851088,
0.0162101034,
0.0372089259,
-0.0047963676,
0.0186799895,
-0.0570094399,
-0.029601194,
-0.0151156168,
0.0200277679,
0.0203752462,
0.0064779865,
-0.0022524146,
0.015443583,
-0.0848231688,
0.0229518246,
0.0185969621,
0.0279879943,
-0.016734533,
-0.0212113913,
0.0089543443,
0.0175723396,
0.0355844237,
0.0111889122,
0.0195051506,
0.0116491122,
0.0432825349,
-0.015254396,
-0.0220994782,
-0.0643903017,
-0.0095160352,
-0.0412931703,
0.0042006862,
-0.0372279063,
-0.0065340875,
0.0237467531,
-0.0111733768,
-0.0238272753,
-0.0102251554,
0.0298892967,
-0.044107534,
0.003295287,
-0.0370191298,
-0.0315078162,
0.0263492242,
0.005690115,
-0.0054455246,
0.0101239448,
-0.0018716268,
-0.0071494668,
0.0475540347,
0.0264779534,
-0.0074088112,
-0.0506712347,
0.0640533119,
-0.009003303,
0.1050726771,
0.0409866087,
0.0091365762,
0.0559971482,
-0.0688849092,
0.0270089079,
-0.0322766043,
-0.0272705145,
0.0380639434,
0.0317960493,
0.0026381724,
-0.0730544105,
-0.0174863432,
-0.0208230708,
0.0308498666,
-0.0251906067,
-0.0352907255,
-0.0038617132,
-0.047406733,
-0.0201831814,
0.0397888124,
0.0077424548,
0.014603232,
-0.0323316641,
-0.0656854212,
0.0300052557,
-0.0499834865,
-0.0253332239,
0.0312406067,
-0.0071211364,
-0.02336834,
0.0448292904,
0.0429188982,
-0.0214599948,
-0.036486201,
-0.042393066,
0.0310850833,
-0.0070355143,
0.0377683267,
-0.03375322,
0.0043259156,
-0.0016379004,
-0.0070084967,
0.0138163501,
0.0164773278,
-0.0081207892,
-0.0069510923,
0.0045012906,
-0.0097082648,
-0.0236737002,
0.0312356465,
-0.0356768258,
0.0488318764,
0.0505171679,
-0.0148449829,
-0.0545674749,
-0.0213013589,
0.0189875346,
-0.0116009163,
0.0182280634,
0.0025452517,
-0.0151865678,
0.0495186821,
0.0044739144,
-0.002334364,
0.0264753513,
0.0542479604,
0.0031883048,
-0.0736492872,
0.0085336585,
0.0769177377,
0.0179802924,
-0.0068624006,
-0.0521128736,
0.0022898351,
-0.0139117613,
-0.0216445867,
0.0111301914,
-0.0393150598,
-0.0013450368,
-0.0038728409,
-0.0249679144,
-0.0227354243,
-0.0209276807,
-0.0142114144,
-0.0134042446,
0.0493652523,
-0.006729607,
0.0134764509,
-0.0229540486,
-0.0652906224,
0.027613949,
-0.0313021094,
-0.0132586211,
-0.0132515617,
-0.0063256505,
0.0027259588,
0.0170355644,
-0.0802271441,
-0.0229545943,
0.0388875343,
-0.0613767952,
0.0224475563,
0.0105089759,
0.0078541972,
-0.0301517192,
-0.0365257896,
0.0031979475,
-0.001918196,
-0.004152067,
-0.0058291364,
0.045531489,
0.0277036093,
0.0315883011,
0.0410445519,
0.012672049,
-0.0187496804,
-0.0157618243,
-0.0156371426,
0.0580362827,
0.0346502028,
-0.0185765959,
-0.0354383215,
0.0113980798,
-0.0541151688,
-0.009590378,
-0.019116614,
0.0569421388,
0.0232720505,
0.012600664,
-0.0527355745,
0.0131837064,
0.0109623987,
-0.0225668903,
0.0508599542,
0.0405646302,
-0.0373807885,
-0.0051902276,
-0.0283740517,
0.0119031034,
0.026281748,
-0.0036824183,
0.0574844852,
-0.0064768414,
0.0203405265,
0.0011662877,
-0.0139510911,
0.0204802677,
-0.0028529696,
-0.0211904738,
0.0040005483,
0.0100973481,
0.0228701159,
0.0535535291,
0.0105960881,
-0.0507499427,
0.0999588966,
-0.0216573179,
0.0530607253,
-0.0355345421,
0.006073412,
0.011627919,
-0.0080769956,
0.0038656525,
0.0097741205,
0.0478203148,
0.0378428288,
0.0585767366,
-0.0066451239,
0.0646961033,
-0.0245219488,
0.0024557658,
0.0025338077,
0.0513354316,
0.0114719514,
-0.0705058873,
-0.0249849968,
-0.0420512557,
-0.0113858907,
-0.0025142045,
-0.0317892469,
-0.006369859,
-0.1077475846,
-0.0085769221,
0.0328521244,
0.0334648304,
0.0099618388,
-0.0094888946,
0.0230513029,
-0.027560791,
-0.0084872236,
-0.0214941036,
0.0424090438,
0.0110052843,
-0.0528071597,
0.0737772956,
-0.0188842788,
0.0071044383,
0.0006691131,
-0.0602912642,
-0.0250332616,
-0.0685935467,
0.0066311061,
-0.0012889459,
-0.0250447653,
-0.0379502364,
0.0136834905,
0.0226466414,
0.005094029,
0.0189832151,
0.0012533315,
-0.0112638744,
-0.0555678681,
0.0064910972,
0.0124020912,
-0.1008975431,
0.01050968,
-0.0201467853,
-0.0049239639,
-0.0473507643,
-0.0320019834,
-0.0093392683,
-0.0561162718,
0.0803309307,
-0.0293924958,
0.0176536031,
-0.0340218805,
-0.1056705788,
0.0193140171,
-0.0157934614,
-0.0559983701,
0.0183172803,
0.0301575195,
-0.032165654,
-0.0120998425,
-0.013740411,
-0.0587824546,
0.0474489629,
-0.0248281751,
-0.0033908857,
-0.0111246007,
0.0180036295,
-0.0117677078,
-0.0895489529,
-0.0299941748,
0.017865371,
-0.0185270105,
-0.0049315901,
0.0897048712,
-0.0013039439,
0.0348306373,
-0.0590482689,
0.0018823469,
-0.0032647166,
-0.0160087384,
0.0060078832,
0.0835283622,
-0.0384697132,
-0.0489647873,
-0.0580868758,
-0.0034598985,
0.0200705398,
0.0622128993,
-0.0512401871,
0.0570542775,
-0.0412965268,
0.0222114585,
-0.0190431103,
-0.0042688721,
-0.0004010763,
0.0560662411,
-0.0265516825,
-0.0180158336,
-0.0620189533,
0.0500693992,
-0.0114963893,
0.023749331,
-0.0332738943,
-0.0315020122,
0.0402838998,
0.0319855958,
-0.0473789349,
0.0606750175,
-0.0136244707,
0.0474857353,
-0.0239162296,
0.006028044,
0.0873751789,
0.0120214196,
-0.0171037205,
0.0228013024,
0.0122547839,
-0.0366737917,
-0.0524659529,
0.001448868,
0.0195156615,
0.0212838873,
-0.0113651911,
-0.0124771707,
0.0670290589,
0.0533985719,
-0.0213423613,
-0.0133933472,
-0.0145918876,
-0.05427875,
-0.0227541775,
-0.0312175415,
-0.0311319046,
0.0233877152,
-0.0114324773,
0.0004476575,
0.0001235815,
-0.0018595272,
0.0523661152,
0.0741690248,
0.0958362445,
-0.0002587042,
-0.0279100426,
-0.0189741123,
0.0267175231,
-0.0107540824,
-0.0137732644,
0.0163254756,
0.0076471828,
-0.0110169323,
-0.0108978376,
-0.0079075135,
0.0426490828,
-0.0460352898,
0.0408774205,
-0.0574857555,
0.000994921,
0.0160845071,
0.0504970886,
0.0554324389,
-0.0285718497,
-0.0346607976,
-0.0342618451,
-0.0374342389,
0.0447097756,
-0.0173272416,
-0.006193846,
0.0056118197,
0.0158668105,
-0.0007726103,
-0.029623853,
-0.1027023047,
-0.0078268284,
-0.0227704961,
0.0043199961,
0.0051632426,
0.0286601298,
0.0060883937,
-0.0463915654,
-0.0305225253,
-0.0251100343,
-0.0043989574,
-0.0051760403,
0.013829208,
0.0444355197,
0.0091847265,
-0.0357073508,
0.0007375252,
0.0410575196,
0.0067644431,
0.051016815,
-0.0410822891,
-0.0819565728,
0.0007972796,
-0.0794584528,
-0.0492933616,
0.0456158295,
-0.0348185897,
-0.0734031275,
-0.0654415935,
-0.0120289847,
0.0298952796,
0.0321814232,
0.0135223726,
0.0153136877,
-0.0035841244,
0.0718813092,
0.0585406423,
-0.0525667071,
-0.0008734482,
0.0206636582,
-0.0613774247,
-0.0046193367,
0.002037229,
-6.022684979e-33,
0.0349033922,
-0.0400435738,
-0.0158582162,
0.016944671,
0.0329367295,
0.039356079,
-0.0274424441,
-0.0396727808,
-0.0035919228,
0.0536689758,
0.0103247426,
0.0386350751,
0.0135376565,
-0.0364786014,
0.0091524944,
0.0025183046,
0.0533772223,
0.0084456801,
-0.0476008914,
-0.0073866351,
0.074030973,
-0.0052794688,
0.0145904478,
-0.0846310481,
0.0485901125,
0.0363776051,
0.0230095796,
0.0131455697,
-0.0721182674,
0.0684532002,
0.0092581147,
0.0673493445,
0.0220032036,
-0.0223658197,
0.0218245033,
-0.0281069688,
-0.0608610921,
0.0440552495,
0.0167283323,
-0.0551890321,
-0.0219625961,
0.032325983,
0.0338439494,
0.0118705966,
-0.0517523736,
-0.0126084583,
0.0143234516,
-0.0309843086,
-0.0129056731,
-0.0870092511,
-0.0102921687,
0.0316210128,
0.0198959876,
0.0463492312,
-0.0522259474,
0.0301753487,
0.0042799795,
0.0714683905,
-0.0437102355,
0.0454156063,
-0.0450206921,
-0.0177012775,
-0.0092650419,
-0.0647462383,
-0.0268383864,
0.0702754781,
-0.0155371064,
0.0159596354,
-0.0230000317,
-0.0128914835,
-0.0254948847,
0.058016032,
0.0437525697,
0.0892690867,
0.0533336811,
-0.03633577,
-0.1103991494,
0.0353664942,
-0.0016238528,
0.0092965802,
0.0241059437,
-0.0226220619,
-0.015319135,
0.0034061046,
-0.0221199524,
0.0261286628,
-0.043927189,
0.0369087942,
-0.0000400671,
0.0305723082,
0.018105844,
0.0278826132,
-0.0045705205,
-0.0191385876,
0.0253843628,
0.0407664143,
0.0260653459,
-0.0121284677,
-0.0240074266,
-0.0104286913,
-0.0587697811,
0.0107362662,
-0.0130871562,
0.0206350591,
0.0028871666,
-0.0048952638,
0.028386835,
-0.0370501876,
-0.050444182,
0.0185255464,
0.0053235348,
0.0046492578,
0.0015051983,
-0.0495110154,
0.0280274488,
0.0306373145,
0.0343966596,
0.0180771947,
-0.0036504378,
0.0364305265,
-0.0415951051,
-0.027509626,
-0.0090513369,
-0.0116162589,
-0.0052379086,
-0.0082426611,
0.0054758978,
0.013618852,
-0.0145790698,
-0.0683566406,
0.0343151838,
0.0335063376,
2.652e-7,
0.0442244895,
0.039507959,
-0.0192844663,
-0.0064853798,
0.0353149697,
0.0066566793,
-0.0076898173,
-0.0169946626,
0.0044954177,
-0.072412312,
-0.0203681607,
-0.0147554511,
0.0004468117,
0.0343323871,
-0.058410354,
-0.0720153004,
-0.0327201337,
-0.0622037202,
-0.0586910881,
-0.0197112001,
0.0114863943,
-0.007330128,
-0.0053224242,
-0.0041009104,
0.0001210235,
-0.0303657912,
0.0585652329,
0.0215089116,
0.010206853,
-0.0121799009,
0.074663125,
-0.0196395684,
0.0359631889,
0.0563755222,
-0.0347472988,
0.0016623307,
-0.0374264643,
0.0423992313,
0.0201389994,
0.0171867758,
-0.0120204734,
-0.0280001797,
0.0451531298,
-0.0079317736,
0.0127128959,
-0.0238037556,
-0.0391829722,
-0.0372837372,
-0.003627355,
-0.0299234409,
0.0486904904,
0.0062713106,
-0.0197569914,
0.0147718033,
-0.0412529409,
0.0451328866,
0.0132341916,
-0.0598476008,
0.0224605035,
0.051934205,
-0.028287733,
-0.0635079667,
0.0508450978,
-0.0305221956,
0.0281920172,
-0.0832886919,
0.0127792191,
2.012279647e-34,
0.0442411937,
0.0167881865,
-0.025506191,
-0.0620478876,
0.0373757407,
0.0173491668,
0.008795985,
-0.0214648861,
-0.0088583203,
-0.0503748916,
0.016259972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02837v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02837v1 | With a Little Help from my (Linguistic) Friends: Topic Segmentation of Multi-party Casual Conversations | 2024-02-05T09:48:07 | 2024-02-05T09:48:07 | Amandine Decker, Maxime Amblard | cs.CL | cs.CL | Topics play an important role in the global organisation of a conversation as
what is currently discussed constrains the possible contributions of the
participant. Understanding the way topics are organised in interaction would
provide insight on the structure of dialogue beyond the sequence of utterances.
However, studying this high-level structure is a complex task that we try to
approach by first segmenting dialogues into smaller topically coherent sets of
utterances. Understanding the interactions between these segments would then
enable us to propose a model of topic organisation at a dialogue level. In this
paper we work with open-domain conversations and try to reach a comparable
level of accuracy as recent machine learning based topic segmentation models
but with a formal approach. The features we identify as meaningful for this
task help us understand better the topical structure of a conversation. | [
0.0303266402,
-0.0083982507,
-0.0004472371,
0.0308698472,
-0.0576990433,
-0.0052711377,
-0.0057547563,
-0.0128521724,
-0.0468919091,
-0.0372867063,
0.0213939901,
-0.0312442556,
0.0094438624,
0.0575185344,
-0.0475266427,
-0.1013285145,
0.0243954547,
-0.0032081378,
0.0387407541,
0.025181096,
0.0193142612,
-0.0195494425,
-0.0277805701,
0.0162802469,
0.0048031551,
-0.0139664859,
-0.0784762204,
-0.0167865995,
-0.0093267187,
0.0496226847,
0.0169927757,
0.0468095429,
-0.0150929764,
-0.0276030041,
0.0000017278,
-0.0272135735,
-0.0321111828,
-0.0649077147,
0.0274731554,
-0.0039742962,
0.0237518158,
0.0079239961,
0.0121241668,
0.0310370419,
-0.0330986306,
0.031041462,
0.0000551849,
0.1077913418,
0.0598960891,
0.0539047532,
-0.0321312994,
-0.0188781638,
0.0107239224,
-0.0040666051,
-0.0079463925,
-0.0890272558,
0.0127355969,
0.013952258,
-0.0722684115,
0.0252083428,
0.0137470374,
-0.0237182807,
-0.0115293888,
-0.0181891769,
0.0335132219,
0.0135832112,
-0.0488674156,
-0.0451915115,
-0.0263855159,
0.0781058297,
0.0472713932,
0.0408237688,
0.0516185239,
-0.0076927682,
-0.0121001843,
-0.0098878676,
-0.0508301519,
0.0034621155,
-0.0204266161,
0.0098764896,
0.0276283082,
0.0293669999,
-0.0133928536,
0.0122293215,
-0.0348135717,
0.0851003751,
-0.0129086217,
-0.0113207297,
-0.0091968272,
0.0052795708,
0.0492041185,
-0.056450963,
0.0262663644,
0.0007854705,
0.0038543707,
0.0340455957,
0.0011963191,
0.022654064,
-0.011392843,
-0.035606645,
-0.0549382642,
-0.040762268,
-0.0155302454,
0.0491937064,
0.0833573192,
-0.0451526605,
-0.0326999053,
-0.0043985578,
-0.0068600108,
-0.0392499343,
-0.0562244207,
0.0066022896,
-0.0334777199,
0.0294278283,
-0.0731961876,
-0.0349544846,
-0.0227042995,
0.0230058022,
0.0055529922,
-0.0383620262,
-0.0000073735,
-0.0023617528,
0.005443519,
0.0105008855,
0.0053595435,
0.0280444995,
-0.0757467225,
0.0195902605,
0.0125435889,
-0.0111826835,
0.0461738221,
0.0317409486,
-0.0073891948,
0.0070643858,
-0.0929187462,
0.0105984807,
-0.0295199268,
-0.0102984207,
0.0052428902,
-0.0463151112,
-0.0417210683,
-0.0400669836,
0.024273891,
-0.0330019817,
0.0269137733,
-0.0208577979,
-0.0058380626,
0.001092846,
-0.0000855251,
-0.0358553715,
-0.0144444946,
0.0052519715,
0.0081154071,
0.0452123135,
0.0971258208,
0.0612695627,
0.0379859842,
0.0512288623,
0.0259504914,
-0.0082230028,
0.0922749713,
-0.0020413995,
-0.017593883,
0.0299479906,
-0.0123241972,
-0.0119664213,
0.0253506284,
0.0090451082,
0.0005198373,
-0.015632363,
-0.0118032349,
0.0464815646,
-0.0367898643,
-0.0478333198,
-0.0051458357,
0.0591234267,
-0.0139432978,
0.0681122243,
-0.0259224176,
0.0671450421,
0.005395689,
0.0750466734,
0.0274371933,
-0.0271957684,
0.0210101996,
-0.0409466326,
0.0707114413,
-0.0256646927,
-0.0302820131,
-0.0420267209,
0.0144761493,
-0.0060543921,
0.020085752,
-0.0255664978,
0.0555455163,
-0.0031417336,
-0.0083390251,
0.0468859114,
-0.0057147783,
-0.0257319268,
-0.0301104821,
-0.0177445952,
0.0280469246,
0.0161691215,
-0.007495136,
-0.0292386282,
-0.0442520939,
-0.0030372662,
0.0520355776,
0.0066820593,
0.0434935763,
-0.0369935967,
0.026161911,
-0.0274628047,
0.012796931,
-0.0150335478,
0.0126551297,
-0.0035082272,
0.0063798865,
-0.0292781275,
0.005716953,
0.0168119427,
0.085265778,
0.0086421631,
0.0084983641,
0.0446911044,
0.0221182052,
-0.006240089,
0.0522178784,
0.0372188203,
-0.0009863891,
-0.0305542368,
0.0309198834,
-0.0109531246,
0.0362277925,
0.0248431545,
-0.0365695395,
0.0153916422,
0.0227470566,
-0.0176202673,
-0.0410704836,
-0.0334121361,
-0.0325787216,
-0.0411102585,
0.0550500266,
0.0117459279,
-0.0049740672,
-0.0212998595,
-0.002006063,
0.0214212034,
-0.0097171739,
0.0173259135,
0.0377402939,
-0.0196294673,
-0.0237689056,
0.0133294249,
-0.055805169,
0.0154597731,
-0.0832657814,
0.075395368,
0.0196810439,
-0.0128402775,
-0.0167094506,
0.014183389,
-0.0144278873,
-0.0425440818,
-0.0160573628,
-0.1106271595,
-0.0109240115,
-0.0371389203,
0.0103034079,
0.0235319715,
0.0231213644,
0.007211973,
0.0083064074,
-0.0250026286,
0.0127586778,
-0.0106403111,
-0.0082868952,
0.0527539887,
-0.0025987094,
-0.0173030235,
-0.0450067297,
-0.0096339639,
-0.0289280396,
0.0596659705,
0.0014925858,
-0.0684990883,
-0.0485090427,
-0.0147650661,
-0.0234511681,
-0.0083805164,
-0.0291059539,
0.0081772134,
0.007987367,
-0.0086955354,
0.0794102326,
0.027966829,
0.0800115913,
0.0806659386,
-0.0123315323,
-0.0413725004,
0.0247866325,
-0.0173438247,
-0.0264960807,
0.0450417474,
-0.0220700242,
-0.0306231119,
0.0633615553,
0.073015213,
-0.0062581776,
0.0540288687,
-0.0137152728,
-0.021828251,
-0.0036092375,
-0.0346951485,
-0.0303025302,
-0.0165931843,
-0.0356605239,
0.0489424653,
-0.0134644499,
-0.0050038295,
0.0271389727,
0.003041856,
-0.0006693359,
-0.0324485265,
-0.0602487363,
-0.0421771966,
0.0396065228,
-0.0277644116,
-0.0133436089,
0.0326455086,
-0.0396410674,
-0.0267763454,
-0.0176899973,
0.0069554891,
0.012928633,
0.0642419755,
-0.0535433553,
0.0003948091,
0.034944389,
-0.000926825,
-0.0214773249,
-0.0511248223,
-0.0126192588,
0.0171792675,
0.017094003,
-0.0182064828,
-0.0099126557,
0.0290154759,
-0.0251723398,
0.0170321837,
0.024500262,
0.0198129937,
0.0061579654,
0.0942795426,
0.0182933956,
-0.0130525958,
-0.0365306586,
-0.0361878872,
0.0322321393,
0.0392053425,
0.0391013585,
-0.0430660732,
-0.0183851421,
-0.0240681432,
-0.0227305442,
-0.0332001522,
-0.0410597585,
0.0203920063,
0.0621061884,
-0.0176789816,
-0.0066658948,
0.1202700213,
0.058858756,
-0.0099475831,
-0.022036206,
-0.0276053213,
-0.0058700987,
-0.0207529273,
-0.0101569463,
-0.0576187298,
-0.0139970658,
-0.0217088256,
-0.0089474702,
-0.0285921525,
-0.0387302227,
-0.0108861877,
-0.0453739464,
0.0182516668,
-0.0115385056,
-0.0218907259,
0.0283372961,
-0.0358600244,
0.0111599471,
-0.0134247653,
-0.0253992788,
-0.0316980705,
0.0241102371,
-0.0319737047,
0.0265006516,
-0.0866549462,
0.0064733899,
0.0020426076,
-0.0045543103,
0.0253204387,
-0.0058873389,
0.0521893278,
0.0267260931,
0.047173474,
0.0709590614,
-0.0214700811,
-0.0094584292,
0.018525552,
0.0399151705,
-0.0173790473,
0.0469828062,
-0.0390222222,
0.0222002473,
0.0026030107,
-0.0248362422,
0.0434183069,
0.0386855528,
-0.0549899377,
-0.0232237149,
0.0051819296,
0.0704269186,
-0.0003148918,
0.0404253528,
0.0406001732,
-0.0113419322,
-0.0087643303,
-0.0314692147,
0.0512735471,
0.0338165164,
-0.00692887,
-0.0500280112,
-0.0122369686,
-0.0437325276,
-0.0564054735,
-0.0344958417,
0.0317698084,
-0.0063797631,
-0.0515021794,
-0.0043290253,
0.0283349808,
0.0198450852,
-0.0017514463,
0.0170347616,
-0.0192176551,
-0.0357716642,
-0.0493255369,
-0.0572435409,
0.035958387,
0.0065099038,
-0.0281870998,
0.0061040916,
-0.0718519539,
-0.0626804605,
-0.0061313678,
-0.0062549175,
0.0173631553,
0.0171142388,
-0.0367225371,
-0.0262551475,
-0.0413599499,
-0.0035639589,
-0.0547410846,
-0.0076473942,
0.0353350937,
0.0416693389,
0.010774768,
0.0337195471,
-0.0202077553,
0.0420796014,
-0.0458387285,
-0.0283290017,
-0.1130661294,
-0.0743759871,
-0.0366221219,
-0.0387033485,
0.0795812532,
0.0475211814,
-0.0616290458,
-0.0333656445,
-0.0028929017,
-0.0049907225,
-0.0232848302,
-0.0289430693,
0.0004318351,
0.0026822845,
-0.0039545787,
-0.0110749919,
0.0044948002,
-0.0553463325,
0.0365569331,
0.000611035,
0.002956596,
0.0450221896,
0.0070021083,
-0.0057194154,
-0.015754018,
0.0197001193,
0.0147626335,
-0.0018899471,
0.0040044505,
0.025151195,
0.0891048312,
-0.0058077048,
-0.0083425222,
0.0106700202,
0.003223866,
-0.0594956949,
0.0012045357,
0.0183770079,
0.1014879197,
0.0010064938,
0.0079209926,
0.0266242363,
0.008688488,
0.0073026824,
-0.0260275491,
0.1044928879,
-0.0417101905,
-0.0375540927,
-0.0081419898,
0.0210783686,
-0.0447104797,
0.0326891541,
0.0492039062,
0.0044772099,
-0.0369071029,
0.0626639947,
-0.0012036789,
-0.0431265123,
0.0081690419,
-0.0031980823,
0.0418327898,
-0.0141195636,
0.0386601686,
-0.0443269499,
0.0246000718,
0.0219354965,
-0.0514049381,
0.0383756012,
0.0104416069,
0.0336525217,
0.0910280123,
-0.0382075086,
0.0117830923,
-0.049389109,
-0.0037185783,
-0.0076825372,
-0.0260265246,
-0.0378904492,
-5.725107115e-33,
-0.0229265168,
-0.0432162024,
0.0035554732,
0.052861277,
-0.0007594659,
-0.0052062869,
-0.0394985378,
0.0378421172,
0.0251471829,
0.0092511931,
-0.0105042588,
0.0761311427,
0.0425611027,
-0.018796755,
-0.0231995042,
-0.0547729507,
0.0509656705,
-0.0185054168,
-0.0190578792,
0.0537237041,
0.0235896911,
0.0129120843,
0.0096794786,
-0.0826162547,
0.0258221831,
-0.0016000951,
0.0228221975,
0.0338164754,
0.076906018,
0.0136828925,
-0.0041910917,
-0.010923937,
0.0366558768,
-0.0262219068,
0.0067809131,
0.0657435507,
-0.0584959798,
-0.0298623014,
-0.0007701265,
-0.0036512138,
-0.0268370938,
-0.0082408413,
0.0259934422,
0.0397847258,
0.0413569584,
-0.0371885225,
0.0701674819,
0.0094558243,
-0.0123275891,
-0.0119851297,
-0.0264187437,
0.057969451,
-0.0583937354,
-0.0351451784,
0.027520936,
-0.0020304171,
0.0272326544,
-0.0664047822,
0.0208752807,
0.0608196594,
-0.008551822,
-0.0099346312,
0.0023387808,
-0.0298535917,
0.0024508312,
0.06101574,
0.0270615779,
0.0459818803,
-0.0047310567,
-0.0356592722,
-0.0443692952,
0.0620000251,
-0.012629441,
-0.0111126732,
-0.0174495447,
0.0390577056,
-0.0430408157,
0.0166172497,
0.0639609993,
-0.0179273114,
-0.0249636658,
0.0104505904,
-0.0040490548,
-0.012321908,
0.0275129918,
0.0035198065,
0.021375943,
-0.0063463477,
-0.0072274162,
-0.0034622457,
-0.0205466673,
-0.015855927,
0.0391645096,
-0.0481344946,
0.018883042,
0.0318517238,
-0.0095394673,
0.0339013599,
-0.0086241132,
-0.0119780796,
-0.0836617276,
-0.0367410071,
0.0065246043,
-0.006621961,
0.0162174422,
-0.0015445276,
-0.0514418408,
-0.0738017038,
-0.017661931,
-0.0260243285,
0.0274121705,
-0.0002692479,
-0.0625417009,
0.0928106606,
0.0401753597,
0.0255555101,
-0.0298282094,
0.0868692398,
-0.0004369082,
0.0263016708,
-0.0084132869,
-0.0434414446,
-0.0158253741,
0.0144624319,
-0.0360818431,
-0.0373599082,
0.0110348864,
-0.0444029272,
0.0547608696,
0.0162368938,
-0.0306546986,
-0.0597236678,
2.388e-7,
-0.0000675383,
0.0634793565,
0.0561334752,
-0.0074595511,
0.0089762611,
0.0291103274,
0.0267897714,
0.005812542,
-0.0221209321,
-0.0592470393,
0.0354806557,
0.0239945501,
0.0407828391,
0.0449192785,
-0.0934097171,
-0.0123859076,
-0.0602093674,
-0.0308111962,
-0.016245516,
-0.0116710877,
-0.023998687,
0.0477050692,
0.0424556099,
0.0222503301,
-0.0509756915,
-0.0072356714,
0.0299915671,
-0.0557929464,
-0.0455656052,
0.0386989452,
0.0400270298,
-0.0202528778,
-0.0064743767,
0.0082490444,
0.0232978072,
0.0050610364,
0.0364025347,
0.0752714872,
0.0222333726,
-0.0103687802,
-0.0264079142,
0.0004370647,
-0.0143739302,
0.0461003855,
-0.0045526451,
-0.0565787256,
-0.0302075613,
0.0033244283,
0.0046841344,
-0.0043716761,
0.0055700233,
0.0184813645,
0.0281214826,
0.0293952916,
-0.0291238315,
-0.046059344,
0.0408137403,
-0.0399136022,
-0.0000568341,
0.0173313934,
-0.0378039964,
-0.0391516984,
0.0069483472,
-0.0355234519,
0.0051061306,
-0.0135022784,
0.0134717729,
1.709568271e-34,
0.0404876433,
0.015281192,
-0.063816376,
0.0678671673,
0.0340823904,
-0.0436187834,
-0.0434699729,
-0.0030873767,
0.0306371991,
-0.0055481978,
0.0514859371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02834v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02834v2 | Shortened LLaMA: Depth Pruning for Large Language Models with Comparison of Retraining Methods | 2024-02-05T09:44:49 | 2024-06-23T08:45:33 | Bo-Kyeong Kim, Geonmin Kim, Tae-Ho Kim, Thibault Castells, Shinkook Choi, Junho Shin, Hyoung-Kyu Song | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Structured pruning of modern large language models (LLMs) has emerged as a
way of decreasing their high computational needs. Width pruning reduces the
size of projection weight matrices (e.g., by removing attention heads) while
maintaining the number of layers. Depth pruning, in contrast, removes entire
layers or blocks, while keeping the size of the remaining weights unchanged.
Most current research focuses on either width-only or a blend of width and
depth pruning, with little comparative analysis between the two units (width
vs. depth) concerning their impact on LLM inference efficiency. In this work,
we show that simple depth pruning can effectively compress LLMs while achieving
comparable or superior performance to recent width pruning studies. Our pruning
method boosts inference speeds, especially under memory-constrained conditions
that require limited batch sizes for running LLMs, where width pruning is
ineffective. In retraining pruned models for quality recovery, continued
pretraining on a large corpus markedly outperforms LoRA-based tuning,
particularly at severe pruning ratios. We hope this work can help build compact
yet capable LLMs. Code and models can be found at:
https://github.com/Nota-NetsPresso/shortened-llm | [
0.0083774226,
0.0692608878,
-0.0108637279,
0.0781691,
-0.0129612358,
-0.0042116768,
-0.0031473103,
0.0112947887,
-0.0412188172,
0.0094378376,
-0.0543681197,
-0.0520212203,
0.0346179605,
-0.0126771405,
0.0293593779,
-0.0430106111,
0.0309045464,
-0.0595353916,
-0.0267175585,
-0.0105822505,
0.0213277042,
0.0034459392,
0.0120842727,
0.0293869451,
0.0261035338,
-0.0203650706,
-0.0193956103,
0.0148583325,
-0.0113137104,
-0.0055413037,
-0.0024102801,
0.0330532454,
0.0250884518,
0.0302445292,
0.0000020721,
-0.0170274116,
0.012480055,
-0.0109647019,
-0.0330364443,
0.0829277262,
0.014115205,
-0.020348914,
0.0037791906,
0.0189549271,
0.0137480069,
-0.0411030576,
0.0368791819,
0.0230028462,
0.0287879445,
0.0867031813,
0.0059727533,
-0.0422463529,
0.0023496388,
-0.0708852783,
-0.0483834445,
-0.0514096618,
0.0169399641,
-0.0355252922,
-0.0246466603,
-0.0058434452,
-0.0304107331,
0.0227308199,
0.0362024903,
0.0181569383,
-0.037547268,
0.0221646838,
-0.0213989727,
-0.0331235044,
0.0210470557,
0.058021713,
-0.0219207853,
-0.0158764329,
0.0088120755,
-0.0160885062,
-0.0173034798,
-0.0568046495,
-0.0385948271,
0.0466286689,
0.0222996864,
0.0357877724,
-0.010830747,
-0.019338632,
0.0471507385,
-0.0082514193,
-0.0139270313,
0.0402360857,
0.0357554369,
-0.0177918822,
0.0052735186,
0.0102409013,
0.0228864625,
-0.0381767452,
-0.01064575,
0.0022522642,
0.0073234709,
0.0165614653,
-0.0240689069,
0.0048526223,
0.0327945538,
-0.0362173617,
0.0368332639,
0.0495205969,
-0.0336514935,
0.023083305,
-0.0016683688,
0.025690468,
-0.0157339144,
0.0039958484,
-0.0457334705,
-0.0060724164,
0.0429991297,
0.0085477876,
-0.0364859924,
-0.0003215942,
-0.0398485288,
0.0127027687,
-0.0524373949,
-0.010806893,
0.0032714794,
-0.0325064436,
0.0156119643,
-0.0056502377,
-0.0520238318,
-0.0132779898,
-0.0013621168,
0.070081301,
-0.0205121767,
0.0429785252,
-0.0185015816,
-0.066970408,
-0.0633639395,
0.0458898544,
0.0043727295,
-0.0368301794,
0.026530711,
0.0547095127,
-0.0004349287,
-0.0797132179,
-0.0609418415,
-0.002808081,
-0.0367190428,
-0.0972958803,
0.0105047747,
-0.0539173484,
0.0332842134,
-0.0595908947,
0.0143872146,
-0.034463264,
0.0011573596,
0.0328312479,
-0.0238156971,
0.0212738197,
0.0056434986,
0.0078097223,
0.0031409084,
0.0069624851,
0.0244761985,
0.0888013095,
0.0455011353,
0.0463151112,
0.0093632862,
-0.01871497,
-0.0618112087,
0.0482865795,
0.0433128774,
0.0146519449,
-0.0552101806,
-0.023973057,
-0.0143211838,
0.0111870328,
0.0885825977,
0.0539807416,
-0.0450271964,
-0.0262861028,
0.0699421987,
0.0368532278,
0.0511997156,
0.0336714946,
0.0590373464,
-0.0424452983,
0.0228894521,
0.0325176641,
-0.0477322154,
0.0155128641,
0.0143287545,
0.0099255852,
0.052742701,
0.0570710301,
-0.0413726121,
-0.0325858369,
-0.0208490491,
-0.0134174637,
-0.0198464822,
0.0280892663,
0.0397057571,
0.0196287353,
-0.0266176984,
0.084694691,
0.0606523529,
-0.0572024956,
-0.0061238175,
-0.0560691617,
0.0382646173,
0.0336784497,
0.0241059214,
-0.0052462965,
-0.0022826886,
0.0420150757,
0.01666045,
0.0449608378,
0.0157610867,
0.0130767487,
0.0592601188,
-0.0589873269,
0.0304399282,
-0.0172437932,
0.0410610624,
-0.001860965,
0.0355391391,
0.0039924006,
0.0215889532,
-0.0527982861,
-0.0096840356,
0.0477223583,
-0.0334039629,
0.0041055037,
-0.003700953,
-0.0037236128,
0.0319020003,
-0.0010364322,
-0.0091573866,
-0.0010763691,
0.0446838625,
-0.0476104356,
0.0266894065,
-0.0249817874,
-0.0451444499,
-0.0617432706,
0.0402886681,
0.0008386261,
0.0183332562,
0.0716742352,
-0.0425754264,
-0.019924907,
0.0308535509,
-0.0360620692,
0.0287221204,
-0.0512258224,
0.0150961867,
-0.0044048345,
0.0742052794,
-0.0157623608,
0.0287663005,
-0.0181422457,
0.0124514513,
0.0215699319,
-0.0550115816,
-0.006197731,
-0.0898394287,
-0.0344144553,
0.0230588689,
-0.0197039396,
0.0026415738,
-0.0370481908,
0.0084832832,
-0.0189042743,
0.0004683777,
-0.0614737384,
0.0265701506,
-0.0361123085,
0.0307800435,
0.0087007293,
0.036406517,
-0.0056106849,
-0.0180020239,
0.0144475978,
0.0029472462,
-0.0084526641,
0.020932598,
-0.0022895557,
-0.0246536527,
-0.0288351942,
-0.0542057194,
-0.0385300592,
0.0254256241,
0.0421432629,
-0.0399143174,
-0.055529125,
-0.0493631177,
0.0520303212,
-0.039404884,
0.0272294581,
-0.0192206074,
-0.0476230122,
-0.0138749955,
0.0074489643,
0.0263523851,
0.0659943894,
-0.0260374546,
0.0282943975,
0.0737148821,
0.0141982613,
-0.020557452,
0.0279347394,
-0.0168070253,
0.000290455,
-0.0325599574,
-0.0385216996,
0.0065744617,
0.0924266949,
0.0011313853,
0.009337889,
-0.0267060455,
-0.0444212407,
-0.0148625607,
-0.0147260819,
0.0273149647,
-0.0224079434,
-0.0298731476,
0.0127320783,
-0.0206639133,
-0.054638844,
0.0505415276,
-0.0788753033,
-0.0237526577,
-0.007679916,
-0.0318520293,
-0.0700320303,
0.0486714467,
0.0168623123,
0.006421064,
-0.0440138765,
-0.0158113632,
-0.0390424244,
0.025620956,
0.0140186949,
0.0021754524,
0.0535674021,
-0.0404977016,
0.0222146157,
-0.0506565049,
-0.0267430581,
-0.0074177184,
-0.004252729,
-0.0567591526,
-0.0017731198,
0.000353042,
-0.0024191702,
-0.0088495947,
0.0112019731,
0.0147360507,
0.0478189215,
0.0079789851,
0.053651832,
-0.0114112254,
0.018871583,
0.0378051735,
0.0350176468,
0.0347155705,
-0.0596396178,
0.0236875769,
0.0507494546,
-0.0191734973,
0.0398008935,
-0.0455975421,
0.000420198,
0.0349661633,
0.0038461785,
-0.0160403606,
0.011393535,
0.0743769631,
-0.069808349,
-0.0113281794,
0.0568139814,
-0.0129463663,
-0.0506242886,
0.0203478709,
-0.0002172881,
0.052145604,
0.0041323924,
0.0183542296,
-0.0580194369,
-0.0521217398,
0.0335872509,
0.0193110388,
0.0309147201,
0.0060105398,
-0.014593049,
-0.1243408769,
0.0395919494,
-0.0041694185,
-0.0327602513,
0.0021338072,
-0.0567059144,
0.0106781134,
-0.0108400136,
0.0125709372,
0.0365364552,
-0.0300838295,
-0.010633504,
0.0190202314,
-0.0284597278,
-0.0330956616,
0.0398440398,
0.0045202272,
0.0427431613,
0.0363532417,
0.0070410655,
0.0185281113,
-0.042844519,
0.0660979226,
-0.0442732163,
-0.0204241015,
-0.01340474,
0.0603722185,
0.0031174854,
-0.0107563501,
0.0067728935,
0.0165372845,
-0.0026126679,
-0.0112229381,
-0.0181425251,
0.0449093506,
0.005616595,
-0.0393795893,
-0.0066743074,
0.0190639347,
-0.0457439013,
0.0667527169,
0.0771270618,
-0.0008224057,
-0.029117547,
0.0177098531,
-0.0153982956,
-0.0416148826,
-0.0182008948,
0.0304189473,
-0.0129454909,
-0.0309145208,
-0.0219806638,
-0.0005406521,
0.0261961985,
0.0101276981,
-0.0314363018,
-0.009987182,
-0.0082955165,
0.0154578649,
-0.0257589966,
0.0404466614,
-0.0489315577,
0.0180129949,
-0.0485172644,
0.0305018481,
0.0127024082,
0.0182373282,
-0.0023280673,
0.0294149723,
-0.1329724789,
-0.0527192689,
-0.0063067283,
0.0466371775,
0.0244210195,
0.0343036912,
0.0086956564,
-0.0681251287,
0.0107106427,
-0.0105537195,
-0.0097937798,
0.0938851461,
0.0198891722,
-0.0343358926,
-0.000803047,
0.0854923278,
-0.0325859524,
0.0335107185,
0.02227295,
0.0490150973,
0.0187254306,
-0.0338544548,
-0.0226610843,
0.0259147175,
0.0206247214,
0.001879058,
-0.0155960815,
-0.0430991948,
0.0648923293,
-0.0262896549,
0.0234310944,
-0.0427168943,
0.0070977537,
0.0056660557,
0.0080862744,
-0.0013710811,
-0.0062976326,
0.0074352003,
0.0140789775,
-0.0175019931,
0.0292304829,
0.0375300124,
-0.0156509206,
0.0232918765,
0.0134777091,
-0.0332284346,
0.0035668521,
-0.0329321548,
0.0270607229,
-0.0170470681,
-0.0285716373,
-0.0070428113,
0.00236931,
-0.0976776257,
0.0130973486,
-0.0304414183,
-0.04977303,
-0.023172237,
0.0357862227,
0.0542682111,
-0.0225659348,
0.0514759198,
0.0358525738,
-0.009431811,
-0.0234442726,
0.0292707235,
-0.0124546839,
-0.0103974752,
0.0410834961,
0.0105794687,
-0.0256825238,
-0.0084575247,
0.0874171853,
0.0389091372,
0.0515477434,
-0.0015484499,
0.0253998507,
-0.0132445293,
-0.0643796027,
-0.0191004649,
0.0279167462,
-0.0281986874,
-0.0341457464,
-0.0485940762,
-0.0940079018,
0.0111930249,
-0.0079908203,
0.0116685694,
-0.0260318127,
0.0239340756,
0.0433652326,
0.0286354665,
-0.0083144419,
0.0087057129,
-0.0262227301,
0.0066727288,
-0.0337125175,
-0.001910027,
-6.640814276e-33,
-0.0110981269,
0.0287159476,
0.0290100425,
-0.0385913737,
-0.0727960095,
0.0393620208,
-0.0384666063,
-0.0158835538,
-0.0244485233,
0.0194427483,
-0.0103535708,
0.0274338238,
0.0075721941,
0.0183535796,
-0.0219053477,
-0.0004833461,
0.0564643741,
-0.0075777289,
-0.0237831324,
0.0120011792,
0.0046300665,
0.0271242317,
0.073115699,
0.0626930892,
-0.0325844549,
0.0205756016,
-0.0127215786,
0.0190504082,
-0.0291456506,
0.0381006598,
-0.0399857014,
0.0369957201,
0.0391928032,
-0.032352481,
-0.0157326069,
0.0297198128,
-0.0779727623,
-0.0138282478,
0.0511334799,
-0.0062021436,
-0.0456024744,
-0.015593404,
0.0554835573,
0.0372539349,
0.0076136375,
-0.0385313183,
0.0057820813,
-0.0230473969,
-0.0550414994,
0.002135586,
-0.0369909182,
0.0340951011,
-0.0017253651,
-0.0293653999,
0.0276484229,
0.0043597538,
-0.0174385998,
0.0477077775,
-0.0455455333,
-0.0166152101,
0.0181447361,
0.0809959248,
0.0299687721,
0.0080037182,
-0.0090843029,
0.047422979,
-0.0025076284,
0.0067598694,
-0.0215125382,
-0.0021482466,
0.0524787158,
0.0340643786,
0.0296633076,
0.023875244,
0.0257581491,
-0.0145226568,
-0.1352825314,
-0.0292457528,
0.0003766921,
0.0867762417,
-0.0139353378,
0.0284768026,
0.0052888873,
-0.0205240399,
-0.0174473338,
-0.0492320061,
-0.0302059818,
0.0101491874,
0.0196179338,
0.0379966646,
-0.0341443084,
-0.0304158591,
0.0319623388,
-0.0231390502,
0.0160291754,
0.0018724871,
-0.0230735075,
0.0095887072,
0.0202883668,
0.0238927081,
-0.0477843285,
0.0007654188,
-0.0040444219,
-0.0073064007,
0.0246094689,
-0.0166294929,
0.0453734808,
0.0298359524,
-0.0575696714,
-0.0083079021,
-0.0547775738,
0.0133446697,
-0.000585254,
0.0870906562,
0.0360378996,
0.0044927225,
-0.0003904165,
0.0481988154,
0.0136301592,
0.0130043458,
-0.0362776779,
0.0010207997,
0.0301488154,
0.0475274213,
-0.053757403,
-0.0053113317,
-0.0124374256,
0.0127430381,
0.0569333397,
-0.0813355893,
-0.0355059803,
0.0148018552,
2.675e-7,
0.0171076618,
-0.0153814247,
0.0321192145,
0.0139974225,
0.0043870294,
-0.0080060204,
0.0025915198,
0.0152531071,
0.000056371,
0.0022321527,
-0.0122476593,
0.0269635469,
0.0693810657,
0.0106918607,
-0.0961510763,
0.0435648523,
-0.0746729895,
-0.0113777518,
-0.0356176645,
-0.0737262443,
-0.0343878642,
0.1175620779,
0.0145078823,
-0.0337215438,
-0.0015374974,
-0.0241727568,
0.0436579287,
0.0175048281,
-0.0100006787,
0.0082951188,
0.0645528212,
-0.0073913969,
-0.0098569775,
-0.0364519432,
-0.0017132309,
0.0291920137,
-0.0276043061,
0.0850602388,
-0.0040820213,
-0.0139349317,
0.021614803,
0.0112119671,
-0.0219521634,
-0.0376396216,
0.0589983985,
-0.0240576863,
-0.0216665566,
-0.0525461324,
-0.0068161683,
-0.0113283312,
0.0063027577,
-0.0066992543,
0.0017794882,
0.0279690325,
0.0156135801,
-0.0373239629,
-0.0312750787,
-0.0845059305,
-0.0364169851,
-0.041231256,
-0.0560905449,
-0.0407766029,
-0.0473733135,
-0.0438521765,
0.0231001303,
-0.0684825778,
0.0064646876,
2.571308256e-34,
0.036948882,
-0.0354632288,
-0.003527612,
0.0474889539,
0.017555574,
-0.0427291691,
0.0150157511,
0.0015822491,
-0.0359051824,
-0.0900521651,
-0.0160924308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02823v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02823v2 | Evading Data Contamination Detection for Language Models is (too) Easy | 2024-02-05T09:10:32 | 2024-02-12T17:50:07 | Jasper Dekoninck, Mark Niklas Müller, Maximilian Baader, Marc Fischer, Martin Vechev | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | Large language models are widespread, with their performance on benchmarks
frequently guiding user preferences for one model over another. However, the
vast amount of data these models are trained on can inadvertently lead to
contamination with public benchmarks, thus compromising performance
measurements. While recently developed contamination detection methods try to
address this issue, they overlook the possibility of deliberate contamination
by malicious model providers aiming to evade detection. We argue that this
setting is of crucial importance as it casts doubt on the reliability of public
benchmarks. To more rigorously study this issue, we propose a categorization of
both model providers and contamination detection methods. This reveals
vulnerabilities in existing methods that we exploit with EAL, a simple yet
effective contamination technique that significantly inflates benchmark
performance while completely evading current detection methods. | [
0.0105056018,
0.1344744563,
-0.0296050776,
0.0806310549,
-0.0190120451,
-0.0113226185,
0.0112226103,
0.0145057552,
-0.0028183179,
-0.0247886013,
-0.0161571521,
-0.0180400517,
0.0425804667,
0.0388220549,
0.0422572009,
-0.0006178483,
0.062736772,
-0.0149212433,
-0.0255474187,
-0.0224962998,
-0.0119084921,
-0.0162855089,
0.0596101545,
0.0223112218,
0.0086235227,
-0.0081308698,
0.0134027144,
-0.0162063241,
-0.0171463937,
-0.0049190135,
0.0102985473,
0.0402701609,
-0.041959662,
0.0910946131,
0.000001916,
-0.0239616502,
-0.0405505598,
0.037009716,
-0.0333822519,
0.0603369661,
0.0167426337,
0.0053181606,
-0.0287524387,
0.0359956138,
-0.0037126667,
0.0096081849,
0.0449374728,
-0.0128513202,
0.0546464175,
0.0631339625,
0.0011248101,
0.0622599125,
0.0070863049,
-0.0155927427,
-0.0203279722,
-0.0049433908,
0.0311332289,
-0.0428461023,
-0.0085419798,
0.0089769363,
-0.0311972741,
0.0476510748,
0.0068641342,
0.0093148556,
-0.0461429022,
0.0184938014,
-0.0342636444,
-0.026664149,
0.0281902887,
0.051014442,
-0.0391059071,
-0.0139757553,
0.0185112953,
-0.0045385817,
-0.0112240538,
0.0151043562,
0.0218263529,
0.0293248985,
-0.0095525458,
-0.0063457508,
-0.018238388,
-0.0158053637,
0.0766492113,
-0.0029481745,
-0.0175963677,
0.0851411149,
0.0426754989,
-0.0176056661,
-0.0145716928,
-0.012764045,
0.0040650563,
-0.0706498995,
-0.0022663488,
-0.0425868593,
-0.0130262123,
0.0370757915,
-0.0546984971,
-0.0371279716,
0.0394788086,
-0.0373063982,
0.0338558927,
0.0293955896,
-0.0375827514,
0.0209219996,
-0.0071707964,
0.0381114818,
-0.0230327807,
0.0272627585,
-0.0027246613,
0.0272359867,
0.0456096567,
-0.002201746,
-0.0122526763,
-0.0026313649,
-0.010957039,
0.008107218,
-0.0345889255,
0.0363583267,
-0.045010604,
0.0344970934,
-0.0266407337,
-0.0156016396,
-0.0080906535,
0.0153558971,
0.0090842815,
-0.0197264738,
-0.0232155342,
0.0064650965,
-0.0197413135,
-0.0923012272,
-0.0193799101,
-0.0003650209,
-0.0301370118,
-0.0339000151,
0.003596341,
0.0682897642,
0.0552174859,
-0.0154445069,
-0.0161944982,
-0.0569329746,
-0.0311606452,
-0.0348225757,
-0.0273835212,
-0.0634305179,
-0.0267195292,
0.0119157955,
-0.0015279126,
-0.0831970572,
-0.0335124806,
0.0218556505,
-0.0538682863,
0.0397372507,
-0.0421874225,
-0.0127311023,
-0.011933038,
0.0211568009,
-0.0360470712,
0.0847947672,
0.0019612915,
0.017913105,
0.0577959605,
-0.0170989987,
0.0362538099,
0.0517946854,
0.0228881538,
0.0471877381,
-0.0258405712,
-0.0095806718,
0.0268852897,
-0.0222807638,
-0.0058741313,
0.0757337213,
-0.0097292736,
-0.0634860843,
0.0741712749,
0.018485494,
-0.0502381064,
-0.0210617203,
-0.0265237,
-0.014133119,
0.0023051598,
0.0388814658,
-0.0543256104,
-0.0585579537,
-0.04908574,
-0.0141481627,
0.0366731398,
0.0429699607,
-0.0008706346,
-0.0273814797,
-0.0380212106,
-0.0299241282,
0.0182657316,
0.0211715028,
0.0482684672,
0.0007459533,
-0.0109608406,
0.0303651635,
0.0182894524,
-0.0405929312,
0.0077684675,
-0.0656678379,
0.0006033897,
0.047271423,
0.0429766476,
0.0064169979,
0.0132845426,
-0.0160871688,
-0.0094330981,
0.002783396,
0.0207817368,
-0.0147773093,
0.0439432226,
-0.0055448832,
-0.0314106718,
-0.0092275599,
0.0314789154,
0.0307963379,
0.031940423,
0.024557963,
0.0166804418,
-0.0464674719,
-0.0449946113,
0.0322811343,
-0.0282189958,
-0.0004990081,
0.0170143172,
0.0078811562,
-0.0017924854,
-0.0131208133,
-0.0247822665,
-0.0001748662,
0.0224746503,
0.0453807637,
0.0093866121,
0.0001632968,
0.0031932367,
0.0399098508,
0.043942824,
-0.0056241662,
-0.0210399572,
0.0698621497,
-0.0023062199,
-0.0186416358,
0.0268617477,
-0.0146736968,
0.0413633958,
0.0016775423,
0.0513769239,
-0.0412694216,
0.0425597429,
-0.027277777,
0.034751229,
-0.0070015006,
0.0363703892,
0.0179251991,
0.017752761,
0.0387933068,
-0.0209314823,
-0.0862413347,
0.0353057645,
-0.02039239,
0.0328983925,
0.0276523232,
-0.029267218,
-0.0356301479,
0.0036079071,
-0.0600959659,
0.0001989998,
-0.0207717828,
0.0248784982,
0.0210088901,
0.016278388,
-0.0219597481,
-0.0231549609,
-0.0043289247,
-0.0573213324,
0.0096000452,
0.0636193082,
-0.0015102508,
-0.0074817552,
-0.0262407232,
-0.0169428736,
-0.023308007,
-0.0129010212,
0.0707827434,
-0.0310305338,
-0.0121561829,
-0.0559098721,
0.0160251241,
-0.0337278359,
0.0351682305,
-0.0064305076,
-0.0263662469,
0.0172203574,
-0.0064210626,
-0.0352061167,
0.0676308498,
0.0003247838,
0.0052222079,
0.0753700882,
0.0112799471,
-0.0609343871,
-0.0351638421,
0.0256848466,
-0.0234673712,
-0.0101078805,
-0.0349395722,
0.0109562194,
0.0499192327,
-0.013709127,
-0.0500559956,
-0.0180674084,
0.0383232571,
-0.0414589979,
-0.017553661,
-0.0238132458,
-0.0233902,
-0.0343676098,
0.0343799889,
-0.004373109,
-0.0797406062,
0.0402239636,
-0.0429098234,
0.0232194178,
-0.0173922554,
-0.020916,
0.0122738918,
-0.0070814262,
0.006210383,
0.035845492,
0.0223953035,
-0.0308437329,
-0.0166710205,
0.0072266595,
0.0612243079,
-0.0440087058,
0.0187794287,
-0.0289730672,
0.0055856253,
0.0034971978,
-0.0482752845,
-0.0559242181,
-0.0440222844,
-0.0041157585,
-0.0247351695,
0.0293952823,
-0.0384394787,
0.00306976,
-0.0237370208,
-0.0144071458,
0.0346649475,
-0.0076029683,
-0.0102386866,
-0.011039054,
0.0096135465,
0.0438922346,
-0.0733321607,
0.0551295951,
-0.0615787432,
-0.017376557,
0.0741599798,
0.0518688746,
0.0212560557,
-0.0341184251,
-0.010326907,
0.0475136563,
0.0050640656,
-0.0100644287,
0.0480773933,
0.0110789305,
-0.0512714759,
-0.0050190049,
0.0614855587,
0.0128776701,
-0.0114286859,
0.0071849148,
0.0109298602,
0.0635408089,
0.0271825697,
0.0058188625,
-0.1113608778,
0.0166716147,
0.0448574945,
0.0411588363,
-0.0229374599,
-0.028885914,
-0.0167158302,
-0.0932641253,
0.003584648,
0.0170680042,
-0.0731428862,
0.0293685365,
-0.0658010393,
-0.0053682714,
-0.0246751904,
0.057682585,
-0.0326984152,
0.0031801143,
0.0089228172,
0.0048437444,
-0.0177776869,
-0.0843378603,
0.0057998491,
-0.0445761457,
0.0623161681,
0.0427410044,
-0.0033063304,
-0.0423309691,
-0.0049437042,
0.0429799519,
0.0118645541,
-0.038684126,
0.008845564,
0.0635445118,
0.0125037739,
-0.0397365801,
0.0418060534,
-0.0159292091,
-0.0013130457,
0.0219129957,
-0.0007239705,
0.0222033262,
0.0061283624,
-0.0348866582,
0.0226737782,
-0.050001733,
0.0274346638,
0.0675408244,
-0.009889598,
-0.032090161,
-0.0048334999,
-0.0574609451,
0.0092651602,
0.002024156,
-0.0040728436,
0.0544076711,
-0.0142769013,
-0.0655778199,
-0.0530265756,
-0.0377825275,
-0.004923414,
0.0272949152,
0.0387930907,
0.0359380171,
-0.0117338579,
-0.0152648212,
-0.0262854062,
0.0420328639,
-0.0316156037,
0.0552893318,
-0.0760411918,
0.0353787094,
-0.0278773997,
0.0456356183,
-0.0139358165,
0.0162768066,
-0.0893978551,
-0.1141345575,
0.0271378644,
0.0470634662,
0.02903069,
0.0282359812,
-0.027215112,
-0.0734928623,
0.0156788249,
0.0026950396,
-0.032452751,
0.0241222512,
0.050374452,
-0.1075941101,
0.0068455366,
0.0257330406,
-0.0424805842,
-0.0186466929,
0.0521962419,
-0.0338455364,
-0.0424631648,
0.0055425875,
0.0142716747,
0.0519430824,
0.0658053458,
-0.0518410392,
-0.0141768316,
-0.0011839389,
-0.000891717,
-0.0275901631,
-0.0239841715,
-0.0175586212,
0.0083208093,
0.0168674961,
0.0227372069,
-0.007469757,
0.0203644186,
0.0041397195,
0.0408287458,
-0.0374423526,
0.0040100017,
0.0173517838,
0.0035629603,
0.0783800855,
0.0212830417,
0.013157269,
0.0454991497,
0.0262811948,
0.0866187289,
-0.0130227031,
-0.0068138782,
0.0112845683,
0.0049221292,
0.0178385992,
0.0392052867,
-0.0627363697,
-0.0445641391,
-0.0187327396,
0.0198390279,
0.0214747414,
-0.0091840178,
0.030790301,
0.0017987044,
-0.0080311997,
-0.0469199643,
-0.0428395271,
-0.0064755525,
-0.0446954556,
-0.0018588167,
-0.0242244489,
-0.0296830777,
0.0511176549,
0.0785044953,
0.0217352118,
0.0528543666,
-0.0419769101,
-0.0199560374,
-0.0080144554,
0.0028940525,
0.0262004863,
0.0095079895,
-0.0444908142,
-0.0587021746,
-0.0468467921,
-0.1104124412,
-0.019354796,
0.0057658381,
0.0258006454,
0.0179768428,
-0.0212052073,
0.0696281269,
0.015496253,
0.0275502801,
-0.0752035156,
-0.0169962831,
0.0129292328,
-0.018568147,
0.0088004796,
-6.021112388e-33,
0.0291776881,
-0.0341900922,
-0.0265015326,
-0.0248076189,
0.0580150411,
0.0576043203,
-0.0043745334,
0.0089758374,
-0.0447486565,
-0.0194147322,
-0.0166726429,
0.0236884672,
0.009835585,
-0.0023030862,
-0.009259209,
0.0016798167,
0.0325823948,
0.0167180263,
-0.0802478343,
-0.0093780877,
0.0461144261,
-0.0134906732,
0.0284553301,
-0.0735185966,
0.018256899,
-0.0155267073,
-0.0320469141,
0.0148238949,
-0.0429162048,
0.066867061,
0.0230566207,
0.0260470118,
-0.0069363569,
-0.014014204,
-0.0454765446,
-0.0208564345,
-0.0093851658,
-0.0115865069,
0.0066666882,
0.0247221608,
-0.0059763524,
-0.0308995359,
0.0656405091,
-0.016249273,
-0.0031704758,
0.0142001295,
0.0066502583,
-0.0198447499,
-0.045273032,
0.0081047444,
0.0050372193,
0.0290504191,
-0.0135983489,
0.0513899364,
0.0676212758,
0.042538818,
0.0294257998,
0.0033423512,
-0.0324073099,
0.0245133024,
0.0541276596,
0.0232237335,
0.0891750604,
0.0412897728,
-0.0094075846,
0.0707425401,
0.0279055908,
0.0423905328,
0.0792621002,
-0.018947741,
0.0478409268,
0.0342631713,
0.0340980031,
0.0372794829,
0.0401427895,
-0.0351820625,
-0.0177186765,
0.0402354486,
0.0024303645,
-0.0220315121,
0.0043548294,
-0.0145584373,
-0.066070728,
-0.0395981967,
-0.0659434572,
-0.0135369962,
-0.0501031838,
-0.0152657181,
0.0359747186,
0.0044734105,
-0.0280348491,
0.0006844661,
0.0115144784,
-0.0535130799,
-0.0558652095,
0.027955072,
-0.0178460311,
-0.0102419136,
0.0059574032,
0.0595122427,
0.0045520212,
-0.0003706331,
-0.0119304908,
-0.004678804,
0.0383015908,
-0.0059739612,
0.0294298455,
0.025136767,
-0.0737398714,
0.0306510385,
-0.0364962667,
0.0260362942,
0.0182623472,
-0.0083940132,
0.0558139011,
-0.0275051985,
0.0182183292,
0.0151363565,
0.0554390363,
0.0299338512,
-0.0655526742,
0.0209129602,
0.0024276958,
0.0053805425,
0.0055584125,
-0.0494845323,
-0.0097281532,
0.0682953969,
0.0841620862,
-0.0484812371,
-0.0049298005,
-0.0332447961,
2.645e-7,
0.0216872562,
0.0288385209,
0.0093603507,
0.0049508964,
0.0008342364,
0.0418016501,
-0.0513659678,
0.0349184424,
-0.0032142117,
-0.0027979952,
-0.0389116965,
-0.0279858243,
0.0442799553,
0.042421706,
-0.0526926033,
0.0031475814,
-0.0676278695,
0.0132789873,
-0.075952515,
-0.0225148909,
-0.0052666725,
0.0768018737,
0.0208874382,
-0.0408631265,
0.0103286859,
-0.0614747293,
0.0139004085,
-0.0319708809,
-0.0129012205,
0.0172541961,
0.0446971916,
0.0291973744,
0.0332948975,
0.0015395483,
-0.0480464287,
-0.0011811976,
-0.0149152959,
0.0387754776,
-0.0035140745,
0.01144055,
-0.0297168251,
-0.0618547723,
-0.0287096221,
-0.0410883017,
0.0694756582,
0.0467120819,
0.0014263856,
-0.0647031665,
-0.0271950122,
-0.0642744005,
0.0583464056,
-0.0147427674,
-0.0208670571,
0.025022056,
-0.005906946,
-0.0292185619,
-0.0004669917,
-0.0444315672,
-0.0490730256,
-0.0217345525,
-0.0193219837,
-0.0652216077,
-0.0021463693,
0.0142128384,
0.0073840716,
-0.0266401581,
0.0209808294,
2.618464406e-34,
0.0330543779,
-0.0501474105,
0.0214473996,
-0.0054344186,
0.0434953347,
-0.0267653596,
-0.0071365386,
0.0097586615,
-0.0197505299,
-0.0199241154,
-0.0010171576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02807v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02807v3 | Are Sounds Sound for Phylogenetic Reconstruction? | 2024-02-05T08:35:33 | 2024-05-14T07:38:26 | Luise Häuser, Gerhard Jäger, Taraka Rama, Johann-Mattis List, Alexandros Stamatakis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In traditional studies on language evolution, scholars often emphasize the
importance of sound laws and sound correspondences for phylogenetic inference
of language family trees. However, to date, computational approaches have
typically not taken this potential into account. Most computational studies
still rely on lexical cognates as major data source for phylogenetic
reconstruction in linguistics, although there do exist a few studies in which
authors praise the benefits of comparing words at the level of sound sequences.
Building on (a) ten diverse datasets from different language families, and (b)
state-of-the-art methods for automated cognate and sound correspondence
detection, we test, for the first time, the performance of sound-based versus
cognate-based approaches to phylogenetic reconstruction. Our results show that
phylogenies reconstructed from lexical cognates are topologically closer, by
approximately one third with respect to the generalized quartet distance on
average, to the gold standard phylogenies than phylogenies reconstructed from
sound correspondences. | [
-0.0294766277,
0.0993325785,
-0.0386358127,
0.0076203654,
-0.0666635185,
0.0005389185,
-0.0235865563,
0.0048481151,
-0.1062749922,
-0.0127953077,
-0.0557778776,
-0.0383148678,
0.0892244279,
-0.032254234,
0.0406745449,
-0.0059248772,
-0.0027532219,
-0.039597474,
0.0175223742,
0.0110276081,
-0.0218616799,
0.0078933565,
-0.0130470246,
0.033248242,
-0.0119987438,
-0.0107579483,
-0.0098947184,
0.0190900601,
0.0316191874,
-0.0211078655,
-0.0307128672,
-0.0194678437,
-0.005797056,
0.076714173,
0.0000014325,
-0.0182249509,
0.0343036205,
0.0058641504,
-0.0232986584,
0.0216793027,
0.0069038915,
0.0279608648,
0.001041343,
-0.0306688491,
0.0280505735,
0.0134109501,
0.0979992971,
-0.094528079,
-0.0596252605,
0.0252346843,
0.0066790045,
-0.0689048916,
0.0150877023,
-0.0125484839,
0.0415887199,
0.0377984531,
0.0352070704,
-0.0244239289,
0.0038415149,
-0.0284625348,
-0.0211650953,
0.0450103469,
-0.0512593947,
0.0284490995,
-0.0651535317,
-0.0085957348,
0.0038316695,
-0.0657024011,
0.0288472027,
-0.0093479594,
0.0270981062,
-0.0583777353,
-0.0259920824,
0.0192287844,
-0.0395294093,
0.0094934842,
0.016264908,
0.0084055765,
-0.0178481136,
0.0364537016,
0.0430150479,
-0.0630986094,
0.015716549,
-0.0116004003,
0.0322983004,
0.0653922632,
0.0628066137,
-0.026359247,
-0.0168101937,
-0.0304658189,
0.0021115213,
0.0146301026,
0.0067630471,
-0.0079503767,
-0.013936121,
0.0025386305,
0.0641965345,
0.0299610887,
0.0440330692,
0.0263686366,
0.0202627126,
0.0192489326,
-0.0209655017,
-0.0176260099,
-0.0436485037,
-0.0112959929,
-0.0012627547,
-0.0717576817,
0.0107602123,
-0.0163527131,
-0.0487734415,
-0.0231206995,
0.0368106104,
-0.035941653,
-0.0397074446,
0.0414476953,
0.0099323038,
-0.0172494967,
0.0019705847,
-0.0387946069,
-0.0242932066,
-0.0398052111,
-0.0313498639,
0.0548417196,
-0.0217429083,
-0.0195910465,
0.0084064649,
0.0691506714,
-0.0341744646,
-0.0417494625,
0.0006932894,
0.0084386356,
0.0348802544,
0.0349263735,
0.045221027,
0.0304851905,
0.0088837193,
-0.025637893,
0.0298893992,
0.0036589762,
-0.1061184779,
0.0296965558,
-0.0343509391,
-0.0301119816,
0.0422746539,
-0.001433757,
-0.0427428521,
-0.0104092285,
-0.0258389227,
-0.0364714488,
-0.0536381193,
0.0370207503,
-0.0540353172,
0.0454773791,
-0.026032785,
-0.0218096711,
0.014091393,
-0.0456507243,
0.0282131024,
-0.0466173589,
0.0402663574,
-0.0340846479,
-0.0623974949,
0.0024185129,
-0.0294875372,
-0.0239730142,
-0.0029312354,
-0.0226648636,
-0.0060916487,
0.0091046747,
0.0280964598,
0.0287577119,
-0.0189404786,
-0.0521340333,
0.0138545251,
0.0844290853,
0.0342752151,
0.0271292794,
0.0361796133,
-0.0230893586,
-0.041610904,
0.0167814232,
0.0128076095,
-0.0558808073,
-0.041344475,
-0.0075885723,
0.0065010297,
-0.005876027,
0.0201008227,
0.0253581256,
-0.0204385556,
-0.0098292893,
-0.0216497779,
0.0290876962,
0.0378332175,
0.007104917,
0.0001781206,
-0.0180496834,
0.0355702676,
-0.02396865,
-0.0186112598,
-0.0041371007,
0.1097219437,
-0.0044295774,
0.0031481467,
-0.0528128445,
0.0091381185,
0.0678587034,
-0.0225129705,
0.0332545079,
-0.0157222133,
-0.015957633,
0.0070366175,
0.0144431945,
-0.0182439927,
0.0313272737,
0.038216196,
0.0710816309,
-0.0357554033,
0.0478671528,
0.0173160005,
-0.0308793951,
0.0101792319,
0.0081557725,
-0.0173248276,
-0.0120738195,
0.0089679314,
0.0045305775,
0.0643652081,
0.042981077,
-0.0215955134,
0.041735217,
0.0315934308,
0.0237211641,
0.0449874476,
0.0234388504,
-0.0316561386,
0.0111962743,
0.0774935186,
-0.0087381285,
0.0257935319,
-0.0182133019,
0.038754411,
-0.0034434623,
0.0353456512,
-0.0765651539,
0.0431884676,
-0.0181012694,
0.0386846624,
-0.0802979097,
0.0035605496,
0.0110877408,
0.0269938204,
0.0739337653,
0.0692224428,
-0.0224297345,
-0.0207203068,
-0.0147309164,
-0.0565964654,
-0.0014079537,
-0.0044806669,
-0.0219835024,
-0.0484197624,
0.0140748834,
-0.0247851331,
-0.0067731538,
0.0279255752,
-0.0505059734,
-0.0074541401,
0.0182879325,
0.0983538106,
-0.0084563261,
-0.0290852021,
-0.0183449928,
0.0223704036,
-0.001988729,
0.0328455381,
-0.0271436498,
0.0360512808,
0.0077390084,
-0.0671199188,
-0.0417683981,
-0.0442295037,
-0.0246494524,
-0.0168020949,
0.0421114266,
-0.0256369337,
-0.0645856038,
-0.0330876857,
-0.0209470205,
-0.1065367088,
-0.0103133367,
0.0058328863,
0.0115471231,
0.0159070361,
0.0048555122,
0.0375439636,
-0.0802070573,
-0.0365249366,
-0.0772564858,
0.0253403597,
-0.0265470482,
-0.0142837446,
-0.0230157766,
-0.0243262183,
0.0142997317,
-0.0071276529,
-0.0091343159,
-0.0312289912,
0.0656395033,
-0.0156590454,
-0.0398439653,
0.0196068939,
-0.0124388654,
0.0324567929,
0.0141870286,
0.0029046445,
-0.1022544205,
-0.0258032475,
0.052260302,
-0.0270704962,
-0.0318453647,
0.0224813968,
-0.0455503985,
-0.0078371605,
-0.0010790857,
-0.0338164233,
-0.0329213031,
0.102412194,
0.0369037539,
-0.0184863042,
0.0625869334,
-0.0368268453,
-0.0079887528,
0.006750762,
0.0962080285,
-0.0241733547,
-0.0156222591,
-0.0613383166,
0.0231520962,
-0.0297882278,
0.0040292996,
0.0205189623,
0.0483591184,
-0.0392089188,
0.0482908078,
-0.005246792,
-0.0421607047,
-0.0060421773,
0.0169461966,
0.0368565135,
-0.0113715809,
0.0247732587,
0.0337297581,
0.0099124052,
0.055384092,
-0.015661614,
0.03391435,
-0.0042891158,
0.013828381,
0.0199850164,
0.0078433556,
0.0219009556,
0.0593854673,
-0.0131799374,
0.0067454446,
0.0320269987,
-0.0012422815,
-0.0276826192,
-0.0092746783,
0.0066838311,
0.0478921011,
-0.0076321564,
0.0263443757,
0.0407249257,
0.0141354371,
0.0545737296,
-0.0084885005,
0.0138442777,
0.0230637267,
-0.0542212613,
-0.0348835923,
-0.0237934738,
0.0448963195,
0.0022201452,
0.0397183411,
-0.0450597294,
0.0062717143,
-0.0670164376,
-0.0018439908,
0.0174702667,
-0.0646293908,
-0.0274725389,
-0.0745041817,
0.0246489309,
0.0226923302,
-0.0169579536,
0.0711961761,
0.0280800518,
-0.0074352869,
0.0013627276,
-0.0081034601,
0.0106229894,
0.0133337062,
-0.0425240286,
0.0135679124,
0.0146753397,
0.0584423393,
-0.024245305,
-0.0341435857,
0.0485729985,
-0.0103763305,
-0.0265134573,
0.0200260282,
-0.0200288817,
0.1023437008,
0.0496954173,
0.0216018781,
0.0028209104,
-0.0444237739,
-0.0376109742,
0.0127212116,
0.0586577095,
0.0127494456,
-0.0652488917,
0.0072586946,
0.0320131592,
-0.0545007735,
0.0274944622,
0.0208646674,
-0.0067879613,
-0.0123342145,
0.0213264823,
-0.0115977107,
0.0465362333,
-0.0198823884,
-0.0070140916,
-0.0117631461,
-0.0455981605,
-0.0871399194,
0.0321357995,
0.0015945267,
0.0342200398,
0.0247445516,
-0.0290958229,
-0.0306991413,
-0.0339469276,
-0.0557010137,
0.003679794,
-0.0229677055,
0.0276673343,
-0.0076611713,
0.0188480187,
0.0545454994,
-0.006321901,
0.0056150202,
0.0240748655,
0.0085821478,
-0.0619722381,
-0.0306816846,
-0.0299469214,
0.0098255891,
0.0076810108,
0.0341459401,
-0.0038543374,
0.0291105192,
0.055933129,
-0.0152598545,
0.0473230444,
-0.0100923469,
-0.0507597066,
0.0002340824,
0.0261039194,
-0.0593578778,
0.0040753214,
0.0161974914,
0.048282329,
0.0387183614,
-0.0633482784,
0.0001828633,
-0.0019477252,
0.0372940041,
-0.0500559323,
-0.081027098,
0.0164369028,
-0.0360985026,
0.0230557434,
-0.0013211325,
0.0018690686,
0.0004432148,
0.014523373,
0.0486073978,
0.0222268403,
-0.0206373669,
0.0027554629,
0.0491763614,
-0.0086896531,
0.0316001847,
0.0752949044,
0.0453357697,
-0.0270447824,
-0.0021492634,
0.0054469509,
0.0248862561,
-0.0998010114,
0.0511061847,
-0.0174224004,
-0.0442411937,
-0.0345774442,
0.0001752834,
-0.0009814983,
-0.035108082,
-0.0130229639,
0.0100092152,
-0.0102173304,
0.0058609466,
0.0487830192,
-0.007459431,
0.0548279919,
-0.0255163945,
-0.0294132922,
-0.0190359559,
0.0230426602,
-0.0457432345,
-0.0310768206,
-0.0202048551,
0.0264721643,
-0.0361868031,
0.0370018892,
0.0111676343,
-0.0346719399,
0.0309333894,
-0.0385676473,
-0.0371704698,
0.0543954335,
-0.0508794151,
-0.0487215109,
-0.0134755224,
-0.0384427197,
-0.0687831938,
-0.0102804946,
-0.0470327027,
0.0211075321,
0.0295148864,
0.0244750194,
0.0232470371,
0.010714923,
0.0353095531,
0.031603381,
0.0195508096,
-0.0137072047,
0.0210847203,
-0.023699468,
0.0097316941,
-0.0147976913,
-4.148671478e-33,
0.0210360941,
-0.0203786194,
-0.0396706723,
0.0196327809,
-0.0036046784,
0.0133859394,
-0.0252517425,
0.0282545686,
-0.0048089451,
0.0005344495,
0.0822286308,
-0.0036057492,
-0.0268571917,
-0.010138561,
0.0318008289,
0.0457804762,
-0.0137102902,
-0.0299091637,
0.0095700491,
-0.0418909565,
0.0414387658,
-0.0245389715,
0.0681955591,
-0.0144391404,
0.0248463675,
0.0628938973,
0.0064949645,
-0.0010661813,
-0.045594316,
0.003249659,
-0.029403327,
0.0157260802,
0.0073879189,
0.0509964265,
0.0313536003,
-0.034612637,
-0.0445854217,
0.0104770195,
0.0187819861,
-0.0323408172,
-0.002614774,
0.0394417569,
0.0371442102,
0.0416667238,
-0.0223442558,
0.000132981,
0.0139828399,
-0.0525740273,
-0.024792511,
-0.028016597,
-0.0628468394,
0.0277914647,
-0.0342990644,
-0.0065335543,
0.0285233017,
0.0633019656,
0.0044439081,
0.0084369853,
-0.0158858355,
0.092738077,
-0.0140027385,
0.0034373065,
0.0468455888,
-0.0217397083,
-0.051789172,
0.0451801047,
0.113035202,
-0.0780981407,
0.0155573357,
0.0426093526,
0.0071875327,
0.0301992763,
0.0138862859,
0.0239587706,
0.0450846069,
-0.0290875658,
0.024492668,
-0.0271293819,
0.0085658431,
-0.0490516946,
0.0056548854,
0.0505771078,
0.0036056149,
0.0137306331,
-0.0476200022,
-0.0385726988,
-0.0237627178,
0.0148024522,
-0.0284847505,
-0.0413087979,
0.0169078335,
0.0230246261,
0.0114511112,
0.0306056403,
-0.0315124802,
-0.0374086797,
-0.0144778155,
-0.0148065817,
-0.0173150152,
0.0351599641,
0.0277500656,
-0.0382483602,
0.0411957763,
0.0156582408,
0.0063263532,
-0.0279775281,
0.0019167807,
0.0517768674,
-0.0284560528,
-0.0035004688,
-0.0056040981,
-0.0819133297,
0.0141133321,
0.0063495361,
0.0442952812,
0.009703692,
0.0283332039,
-0.0474240966,
0.0819054246,
0.0010098205,
-0.0120785711,
0.0167227238,
-0.1108187512,
-0.0274677146,
-0.0153872306,
0.0189880598,
0.0574930608,
0.0281618889,
-0.0082038566,
0.0156324599,
-0.0079600504,
0.0044471947,
2.363e-7,
0.0417748429,
-0.0269277543,
0.0548615083,
-0.0119344648,
0.028081242,
-0.0227191616,
-0.0238204114,
-0.0388848856,
0.0093204742,
0.0051000691,
0.0090162205,
-0.0244427081,
0.0790161714,
0.0615917221,
-0.0296511855,
0.0166903287,
-0.0825574473,
-0.0174532142,
-0.0294698589,
-0.0048796721,
-0.0078542586,
0.0618438497,
-0.0271377768,
-0.0655626804,
-0.0199610516,
0.0024212531,
0.0266269371,
-0.0636274517,
0.0188461859,
-0.0363722369,
-0.0424372256,
-0.0818225816,
0.0453463532,
-0.0227846187,
-0.057538785,
0.0273671988,
0.0083781341,
-0.0499978587,
-0.0055737863,
0.0133605711,
0.0279973019,
0.0288814027,
-0.0028244634,
0.0027731624,
0.0148438951,
0.0698404908,
-0.0115183182,
-0.0039120344,
-0.0328554809,
0.0333950631,
0.0115485098,
0.0132667636,
0.0352275558,
0.0109974481,
0.0182560775,
0.0117320335,
-0.057605762,
-0.0128960963,
-0.0168149583,
0.0362552963,
-0.0787522942,
-0.0144615062,
0.0375385769,
0.0047467984,
0.0136162816,
-0.0094590904,
-0.0011438526,
1.460860987e-34,
0.0058351913,
-0.0222690925,
0.0199504718,
0.0146326311,
-0.0186884645,
-0.0137554221,
0.0457435288,
0.0498305038,
0.0048370007,
0.0148233967,
-0.0280499682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02805v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02805v2 | Graph-enhanced Large Language Models in Asynchronous Plan Reasoning | 2024-02-05T08:26:33 | 2024-06-03T13:07:06 | Fangru Lin, Emanuele La Malfa, Valentin Hofmann, Elle Michelle Yang, Anthony Cohn, Janet B. Pierrehumbert | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Planning is a fundamental property of human intelligence. Reasoning about
asynchronous plans is challenging since it requires sequential and parallel
planning to optimize time costs. Can large language models (LLMs) succeed at
this task? Here, we present the first large-scale study investigating this
question. We find that a representative set of closed and open-source LLMs,
including GPT-4 and LLaMA-2, behave poorly when not supplied with illustrations
about the task-solving process in our benchmark AsyncHow. We propose a novel
technique called Plan Like a Graph (PLaG) that combines graphs with natural
language prompts and achieves state-of-the-art results. We show that although
PLaG can boost model performance, LLMs still suffer from drastic degradation
when task complexity increases, highlighting the limits of utilizing LLMs for
simulating digital devices. We see our study as an exciting step towards using
LLMs as efficient autonomous agents. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/fangru-lin/graph-llm-asynchow-plan. | [
0.0156474505,
0.0268550552,
-0.0163743161,
0.0302654412,
-0.0630397275,
-0.0193633921,
0.024023775,
-0.0237917081,
0.0654081181,
-0.0119632706,
0.0061424347,
0.0083936285,
-0.0021723078,
0.0331589058,
-0.001291036,
-0.0244326107,
0.0150882006,
-0.0652926639,
0.0253168158,
-0.0323261805,
-0.0135066081,
0.0149526382,
-0.0351097696,
0.0445663482,
-0.0040523396,
-0.0308836475,
-0.0585730895,
0.0055055888,
0.0101096192,
-0.075013876,
-0.0468107164,
0.0190616846,
0.0131346723,
0.0238413401,
0.0000020957,
-0.0648032501,
0.0074251471,
-0.0154630831,
-0.0533285812,
0.0051125344,
-0.0013611622,
-0.0138220014,
0.013926534,
0.0160519779,
-0.035803806,
0.0201605372,
0.0268245749,
0.0496267863,
0.0515405126,
0.0560436472,
-0.0028984454,
-0.012388411,
0.0031048863,
-0.0203194432,
-0.0171476454,
-0.0468438491,
0.0099737896,
0.0092067048,
0.0883006155,
0.0016630018,
-0.0196084213,
0.0067175468,
0.0416368432,
-0.0106747448,
-0.0325051509,
0.037810199,
0.0018267423,
-0.0360600576,
-0.0201877896,
0.0814183876,
-0.0155920452,
-0.0018162555,
0.0367191881,
-0.0199207589,
-0.0152047826,
0.0265668239,
-0.0538903996,
0.0307464786,
-0.032858178,
0.0001664748,
-0.0111706257,
-0.0348204561,
0.054214865,
-0.0107971085,
0.0079179164,
0.0992725939,
-0.0084591731,
-0.0083844839,
0.0299327616,
-0.0129675381,
-0.0073008928,
-0.0871280059,
0.0361421257,
0.0639443845,
-0.082927905,
0.0095316367,
-0.0043811351,
0.0130361747,
-0.0061489362,
0.0053733964,
0.0497843102,
0.036539074,
0.0120148389,
0.0451284796,
-0.0007868289,
0.0859744772,
-0.0129566398,
0.0239198692,
-0.0415074937,
0.048521731,
-0.0520409457,
-0.0009556767,
-0.0623983517,
0.0408593118,
-0.0465515777,
-0.0728199482,
-0.0054385317,
0.0644508451,
-0.0271824002,
0.0265494306,
0.0456496403,
0.0099992836,
0.0141365584,
-0.0347248651,
-0.0661182776,
0.0055260225,
-0.0300179012,
0.0172033608,
-0.0117319953,
-0.0191911366,
-0.0117825652,
-0.0031603002,
0.0097883651,
0.0027805301,
-0.0102068512,
0.0998644605,
-0.0022978536,
-0.0225519799,
-0.0221172478,
-0.0415050723,
0.0003085503,
-0.0796446651,
0.0527050085,
-0.0637329519,
0.040642865,
-0.0007472883,
-0.007478883,
-0.0095224585,
0.0276892651,
0.0088532465,
0.0015922327,
0.0781019926,
0.0121793244,
0.047819674,
-0.0241672508,
0.0007122239,
-0.0335434712,
0.0572144687,
0.0583280101,
0.0406464264,
-0.0056252233,
0.0290770996,
-0.0173350014,
0.080082491,
-0.0155049404,
-0.0274513811,
0.031060271,
-0.0167122614,
-0.0085715456,
0.0464830138,
-0.0143731767,
0.0530374348,
-0.0259720571,
-0.0067140055,
0.0531834587,
0.0493858755,
-0.0235394593,
-0.0258375816,
0.0319401249,
0.0455535538,
-0.019141376,
-0.0176444128,
-0.0875040591,
0.0379845463,
0.0027535995,
0.0273382943,
-0.0066380231,
0.0054273955,
-0.0061621028,
-0.0260499902,
-0.0093444549,
-0.0092620431,
0.0477873012,
0.0048042564,
0.018305989,
0.0124702388,
-0.0772533491,
-0.00061408,
-0.0282725208,
0.0093825795,
-0.0532188341,
-0.0450294241,
0.029536834,
0.0954685137,
0.0529161878,
-0.018616844,
-0.0723850876,
0.0268310439,
0.0069081928,
0.0266537704,
0.025398735,
-0.0089108236,
-0.0240749456,
-0.039181862,
-0.030358322,
-0.0471022651,
-0.0084788911,
0.0258807596,
0.0358513892,
-0.0228686314,
-0.0116270371,
-0.0267304219,
-0.0093834037,
0.0020191628,
-0.0106732454,
-0.0050026984,
-0.0194061417,
-0.0045052483,
0.033027567,
0.0008499537,
-0.0086744931,
0.0169502553,
0.0461252518,
-0.0110179372,
-0.0111035639,
0.0260199849,
-0.0375547335,
-0.0272522848,
0.0514347069,
-0.0199018661,
-0.0242250133,
0.0323179998,
-0.0478606299,
-0.051280167,
0.0137483217,
-0.0416784585,
0.0347958542,
0.016268868,
0.0291369017,
0.0451382883,
-0.0354717337,
0.0134096928,
0.0531216599,
0.0118945856,
-0.0174066667,
0.0207017232,
0.0287630875,
-0.0050337245,
-0.0667637438,
0.0132451942,
0.0548185185,
0.016971007,
-0.0229550563,
-0.0019820072,
0.0364429168,
-0.0476513356,
-0.0102858301,
-0.1262150109,
-0.0028296863,
-0.0073733134,
0.0024872557,
-0.0158828497,
-0.0033180439,
-0.0010713855,
-0.0273984559,
-0.0176534336,
0.049293939,
0.0261039063,
0.0102813384,
-0.0120532587,
0.0035164899,
-0.0624075532,
-0.0052574426,
-0.01790566,
-0.0332290046,
-0.0034110777,
0.0396718271,
-0.0162626132,
-0.0356543809,
0.0300751571,
-0.0176390074,
0.0337577984,
-0.0181878321,
0.020541776,
0.0509327315,
-0.0177680627,
0.0437969007,
0.0723623782,
-0.045695208,
0.0151289683,
0.0543498546,
-0.0424725972,
-0.0374019183,
0.0617754459,
-0.0194213167,
-0.0088558812,
-0.0393957496,
-0.0296837296,
-0.0366010256,
0.045897007,
-0.017589232,
0.0131683461,
-0.0419417135,
-0.0084979879,
0.0232363231,
0.0010673093,
0.0088871764,
-0.0316795185,
-0.0162586793,
0.0162291713,
-0.0458262376,
-0.0329108983,
0.0686953068,
-0.0397471562,
-0.0041382904,
0.0158929229,
-0.0050110533,
-0.0380961448,
0.0963276476,
0.0605929121,
-0.005112126,
-0.0073770205,
-0.0058046989,
-0.0284858886,
0.0241291076,
-0.0162014402,
-0.0046486496,
0.0303766038,
-0.0843326524,
0.018669581,
0.0077758669,
-0.0435545333,
-0.0303696115,
-0.012070843,
-0.0883653909,
0.0461100116,
-0.0083581004,
-0.0673247352,
-0.0188063215,
-0.0299244374,
-0.0077293008,
0.027420219,
-0.0223394167,
0.0064387284,
-0.0453805402,
-0.0182269923,
0.0595319606,
0.0342377611,
0.0024927454,
-0.0156125585,
0.044661399,
0.0306324326,
0.0395810381,
-0.0224610865,
-0.0462710746,
0.0185243282,
-0.0036529431,
0.0007697542,
-0.0178960189,
0.039093975,
0.0345181748,
-0.0402015671,
-0.0062475093,
0.1016286388,
0.0123521686,
0.0050255801,
0.0127235288,
-0.0315427706,
0.0328041241,
0.0300573744,
0.0243910439,
-0.061987374,
-0.0505233519,
0.0189935137,
-0.0013191919,
0.0240615103,
-0.0496686026,
-0.0127490526,
-0.1152450591,
0.0286597759,
-0.0047297897,
-0.0036836092,
0.0215770919,
-0.0538983718,
-0.0205251575,
0.0288852844,
-0.0160295423,
-0.0076426524,
0.0142344227,
-0.0072006891,
-0.0206769947,
-0.0526402146,
0.0246764943,
0.0630369261,
0.0346428193,
0.0270715039,
0.0496521108,
0.0160648413,
-0.0036024146,
-0.0356218591,
0.0473140888,
0.0702062547,
0.0074143214,
-0.0314423069,
-0.0154114086,
0.0259213056,
-0.001231346,
-0.0152175454,
0.0297311638,
-0.0400721878,
-0.0534388162,
0.0154208997,
0.1101989523,
-0.0267155599,
-0.0459565707,
-0.0246330816,
0.0053973505,
-0.0080076875,
0.042828694,
-0.0177855119,
-0.0076172338,
-0.0832737684,
-0.0383380949,
-0.017078096,
-0.0641050935,
-0.0330032781,
0.0193068925,
0.0004130448,
0.0361093991,
-0.0219293237,
-0.0354196131,
0.0537888668,
0.0242528282,
0.0293061733,
-0.020067459,
0.0420230813,
0.0090007586,
-0.0302096903,
0.0121059138,
-0.0385386012,
0.0369810946,
-0.029031679,
-0.0151527561,
-0.0057773376,
-0.0284283962,
0.0072854883,
0.0638427138,
-0.083437711,
-0.0611298233,
-0.015726462,
0.0312289596,
0.0210941099,
0.0056269816,
-0.0074993172,
-0.0287303198,
0.023260301,
0.012376233,
-0.0245298166,
0.0296106637,
-0.0011380882,
0.0364083871,
0.0102667697,
0.0342668146,
-0.0592334867,
0.0195680652,
-0.0184239466,
0.0704829171,
-0.0317788199,
-0.0162226241,
0.001200457,
0.067237258,
0.0059014731,
0.0108614182,
-0.0088806041,
-0.0198297109,
0.0150154335,
-0.0319098122,
-0.0132781137,
-0.0472939275,
-0.0034424386,
0.0020554089,
-0.0097551402,
0.0498351045,
-0.0269770399,
0.0146590089,
-0.0025758531,
0.0147533985,
-0.0195348859,
0.0118329693,
-0.0352723859,
0.0495517999,
0.0139770275,
0.0064454465,
0.0241225921,
0.0132103181,
0.0150318146,
0.0233089328,
0.049169898,
0.0370610841,
-0.0196893644,
-0.0475795753,
-0.0118553685,
-0.0527058356,
-0.1137572229,
0.0714787617,
0.0506634004,
0.0397481546,
0.0165445432,
0.011918433,
-0.0637192652,
0.0240325499,
-0.0286133494,
0.0255611204,
0.0160315316,
-0.0655013248,
0.0871733874,
0.0438848659,
0.0090834592,
0.000618281,
0.0428252034,
0.0177607406,
0.0651545897,
0.0195305552,
-0.0267953984,
-0.0592140593,
-0.0789076462,
-0.0330110863,
0.0294227041,
-0.0018057869,
-0.0320153311,
-0.0376683846,
-0.0704640076,
0.0184164327,
0.0412825458,
-0.0129837431,
-0.0398908891,
0.0466663204,
0.0119183706,
0.0104285562,
-0.0684114844,
0.0015644922,
0.0112349512,
-0.0335386507,
-0.0343427584,
-0.0139451968,
-5.900902663e-33,
-0.0257925577,
-0.0778121203,
0.0858497098,
0.0044436096,
-0.0293528028,
-0.0069071748,
-0.0579051711,
0.0246811174,
0.00179407,
0.0259939097,
-0.0245450716,
0.0216953866,
0.0121016977,
0.0011929485,
-0.0031276806,
-0.0137354592,
0.0297131818,
-0.0061166394,
-0.0348600708,
-0.0012785695,
0.0050985054,
-0.0226626825,
-0.0175028834,
-0.0225711633,
0.0044174031,
0.0006496659,
-0.0094419401,
0.030682696,
-0.0481783152,
0.0403274782,
-0.0270791985,
0.0262836851,
0.0291371364,
0.0167642049,
-0.0176262893,
0.0710796267,
-0.0325915106,
-0.0441989079,
0.0540620536,
0.0222672075,
-0.0721562579,
-0.0348168984,
0.0192671642,
0.0270297956,
-0.0400488749,
-0.009521368,
0.0128714172,
0.0029006335,
-0.0193121936,
0.0594730414,
-0.0189989489,
-0.0057143969,
-0.0259491447,
-0.0185007732,
0.0554638319,
0.0114394929,
-0.0010686719,
-0.0241075456,
-0.0028720554,
0.0358528718,
-0.0170739107,
-0.0064780824,
0.0565672629,
-0.0142222699,
0.0373823494,
0.059039548,
0.0156471897,
0.010910322,
-0.0395565405,
0.0135221286,
-0.0115555814,
0.1075495034,
-0.0165874548,
-0.0123494845,
-0.035737671,
0.0276908539,
-0.0650794506,
0.0069172694,
-0.0039170412,
0.0744437501,
0.0458898097,
0.0226608794,
-0.0146640372,
-0.0140808988,
-0.0384869315,
0.0188305043,
-0.0151305795,
-0.0002252787,
0.0253485739,
0.027555041,
0.0288434327,
-0.0124570951,
0.0031293293,
-0.0230829809,
0.0034420062,
0.0504190102,
-0.0168725122,
0.0416616388,
-0.0161791611,
0.0396838933,
-0.0578389354,
-0.0298526026,
-0.0133941034,
0.0077721365,
0.0367626771,
0.0260664318,
-0.0052878102,
0.039300479,
-0.0369663537,
-0.001130374,
-0.0673833191,
0.0193836391,
0.0045159757,
-0.0616058446,
0.0715356842,
-0.0076549766,
-0.0210123379,
0.0283155944,
-0.0026651251,
-0.0766630322,
-0.0150864823,
0.0177897606,
-0.002770321,
-0.0106935007,
-0.0209178813,
0.002991772,
-0.0270207506,
0.0148878098,
-0.0074521205,
-0.0465965942,
-0.0181376934,
0.0207996815,
2.84e-7,
-0.0245163273,
0.0333874375,
0.0273422431,
0.0826007575,
0.0390444547,
0.0220058747,
-0.0075477422,
-0.0115507701,
0.0003537376,
-0.0107246479,
0.0242348928,
0.0836496204,
0.0003686061,
0.0145914648,
-0.0749838352,
0.0383483171,
-0.0219557825,
-0.0039339974,
-0.0658928975,
-0.014802753,
0.0540810451,
0.0144149633,
0.0142193027,
0.012522297,
-0.0155590791,
-0.0603713654,
0.0364450775,
-0.0341583453,
-0.0023801764,
-0.0212031584,
-0.012418393,
-0.0220532473,
-0.0303675998,
0.0396189392,
0.0283427481,
0.0015103678,
-0.0205235612,
0.0541198961,
0.0044060629,
-0.0429475717,
-0.0161904078,
-0.0546929762,
-0.0172879584,
-0.0133662308,
0.0813689679,
-0.0020469332,
-0.0395747647,
-0.013750555,
0.0180056766,
-0.0360714868,
-0.0288601182,
0.0119533865,
0.0242355093,
-0.0029361891,
-0.0058656177,
-0.0321755223,
0.0074572363,
-0.0581835806,
0.0006367251,
0.0226635821,
-0.0563517958,
-0.0364432558,
-0.0532431379,
0.0521093048,
-0.007000267,
0.0090372907,
-0.0142572075,
2.416640979e-34,
0.0176663473,
0.0002497481,
0.0203497224,
0.0393629372,
0.0494136401,
-0.0112237111,
0.0069768578,
0.0454652272,
0.0289368685,
-0.1193624139,
-0.0511962809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02801v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02801v2 | KS-Lottery: Finding Certified Lottery Tickets for Multilingual Language Models | 2024-02-05T08:19:56 | 2024-06-03T07:35:25 | Fei Yuan, Chang Ma, Shuai Yuan, Qiushi Sun, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The lottery ticket hypothesis posits the existence of ``winning tickets''
within a randomly initialized neural network. Do winning tickets exist for LLMs
in fine-tuning scenarios? How can we find such winning tickets? In this paper,
we propose KS-Lottery, a method to identify a small subset of LLM parameters
highly effective in multilingual fine-tuning. Our key idea is to use
Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test to analyze the distribution shift of parameters before
and after fine-tuning. We further theoretically prove that KS-Lottery can find
the certified winning tickets in the embedding layer, fine-tuning on the found
parameters is guaranteed to perform as well as full fine-tuning. Comparing
KS-Lottery with other parameter-efficient tuning algorithms on translation
tasks, the experimental results show that KS-Lottery finds a much smaller set
of parameters for fine-tuning while achieving the comparable performance as
full fine-tuning LLM. Surprisingly, we find that fine-tuning 18 tokens'
embedding of LLaMA suffices to reach the fine-tuning translation
performance~\footnote{https://github.com/CONE-MT/KS-Lottery.}. | [
0.0226081386,
0.0376386568,
-0.024127854,
0.0623635501,
-0.0295858309,
0.0116494615,
-0.0213232264,
0.020194903,
-0.0572493672,
0.0134623591,
-0.0548395328,
-0.0649858639,
0.0328633077,
-0.0028918111,
0.0663499907,
0.0090024099,
0.0133832479,
-0.0314073563,
-0.0266638696,
-0.0336090401,
-0.0446093976,
-0.0224890765,
0.0162323061,
0.0412611961,
0.0304969959,
0.005702558,
0.0121032717,
0.0296369996,
-0.0031933228,
-0.0240134355,
-0.0244685207,
0.05424162,
-0.0231417697,
0.0349743627,
0.0000020608,
-0.057852827,
-0.0003959774,
-0.0126641979,
-0.0073796152,
0.0468183421,
0.0019420744,
-0.0161793157,
-0.0360260084,
0.0205747727,
-0.0119592985,
0.0285098534,
0.0636861324,
0.0329572074,
0.0005915877,
0.0828009546,
0.0128234653,
-0.030104477,
0.0131741092,
-0.0540761203,
-0.021021992,
-0.0510610491,
0.0080083832,
-0.05094295,
-0.0446130298,
-0.0105471732,
-0.0072369259,
0.0418598056,
0.0247650612,
0.0121110566,
-0.0058069634,
-0.0016751206,
-0.0631392896,
-0.015966516,
0.0049290638,
0.0499416888,
-0.0853864849,
-0.0303053856,
0.0019572487,
-0.0145132169,
0.0099705802,
-0.0381567664,
-0.022134088,
0.0328440443,
0.0552104823,
0.0349799395,
0.0376767665,
0.0119527169,
0.0753554702,
-0.0119377999,
-0.0186101627,
0.0431857668,
0.0281314794,
-0.0296696369,
-0.00622764,
0.0208582766,
-0.00535957,
-0.0536790378,
0.0037475617,
-0.0113151446,
0.0200356506,
0.0135868564,
-0.0268965214,
-0.006706275,
0.0242362767,
-0.0443882234,
0.1014015153,
0.0255104043,
-0.0154054025,
0.0353395753,
-0.0413397215,
0.0265551433,
-0.0146599123,
0.0661350936,
-0.0613392182,
-0.0071743079,
0.023512315,
0.0179372448,
-0.0021042156,
-0.0228671003,
-0.0219391081,
0.0136343846,
-0.0687657669,
0.0351383761,
0.0251128487,
0.0185945109,
-0.001665852,
-0.0393737964,
-0.0126168253,
0.0164718125,
-0.0137175955,
-0.0070883571,
-0.0783109218,
-0.0078247674,
0.0191526916,
-0.0531383343,
-0.0421449915,
0.0282601845,
0.0079188999,
-0.0242392775,
0.0095359078,
0.0605410188,
-0.0120857852,
-0.0148432273,
-0.0661007836,
-0.0188148078,
-0.0151684899,
-0.0491600931,
0.0559396483,
-0.0621727742,
0.0140127651,
-0.014441737,
0.0148333963,
-0.0250658169,
-0.0067808847,
-0.0197016243,
-0.0154049657,
0.0425291322,
0.0077285804,
-0.0063146055,
-0.0032588397,
-0.0044644265,
0.0157956909,
0.0934902206,
0.018118253,
0.0407349616,
0.0904785991,
-0.0268485639,
-0.0224399045,
0.0706423,
0.0333480798,
0.0521459915,
-0.0216213875,
-0.0353453718,
0.0420253426,
0.0319301412,
-0.0165734477,
-0.0103751346,
-0.0264357794,
-0.0051577552,
0.0535640456,
0.0732224733,
0.0475941487,
0.0189001244,
0.0122803701,
-0.0510514975,
-0.0064228983,
0.0377418324,
-0.0435269251,
0.0274534989,
-0.0276658684,
0.0092863673,
0.0385199077,
0.0315870233,
-0.0191732682,
-0.04685691,
-0.0263733603,
-0.01278181,
-0.0227077641,
-0.0306975134,
0.0369226187,
0.000953416,
-0.006525117,
0.0269303694,
0.0089967595,
0.0029512332,
0.0077075684,
-0.0603079982,
-0.0327320583,
0.045405332,
0.0260132812,
0.0049954485,
-0.0116939694,
-0.0070067411,
-0.0123658013,
0.0423172973,
0.0663047731,
0.0265524965,
0.0339664854,
-0.0547543205,
-0.0218743272,
0.0014604157,
0.037606962,
0.0363433398,
0.0182251316,
0.0558889173,
0.0169371925,
-0.0543284044,
0.0085299453,
0.0367312841,
-0.0237678811,
-0.0367424674,
0.031445004,
0.0433907583,
0.0248582438,
-0.0068462114,
-0.0097342171,
0.0012887674,
0.0019662823,
-0.0257410854,
0.0029498495,
-0.0190973524,
-0.0070531252,
-0.0060604294,
0.0297115967,
0.0081936736,
0.0401374809,
0.0296225157,
-0.0315809436,
-0.0366508178,
0.0126375426,
0.038792938,
0.0010378434,
-0.0519816875,
0.0307518914,
-0.0128401965,
0.0450506769,
-0.0387028493,
0.0018504381,
0.0054441015,
0.0340624414,
-0.0149574541,
-0.016768625,
0.0530353934,
-0.0843110234,
-0.0572942682,
0.0382993855,
-0.0120922141,
0.0540774763,
-0.0074624354,
0.0129618105,
0.0048900605,
-0.0530290715,
-0.0349646546,
0.000272903,
-0.0418543741,
0.011223481,
0.0047320458,
-0.0142801125,
-0.0131213721,
0.0096720848,
-0.0431931615,
-0.0039945589,
-0.0034326017,
0.0345928483,
0.0416020341,
-0.0420393087,
-0.014473767,
-0.0264697373,
-0.0391132757,
0.0324629024,
0.0545432083,
-0.0305458959,
0.0234812461,
-0.0727705806,
0.0300040785,
-0.0292692818,
-0.0119504035,
-0.0036800089,
-0.0836676955,
-0.0046270532,
-0.0004179582,
-0.0405100249,
0.0736585706,
-0.018967431,
-0.0224744249,
0.0265154,
0.0005390081,
-0.0561435632,
-0.0237136465,
0.0237613134,
-0.0127624897,
-0.0568303801,
-0.0028463064,
0.0218169391,
0.071002759,
-0.0039993576,
-0.0289047603,
-0.0417871363,
0.0008837146,
-0.0117366947,
-0.0302624479,
-0.0357794277,
0.0560093895,
-0.0029024975,
0.0596006066,
0.0037985502,
-0.0405505449,
0.0490782745,
-0.064412944,
0.0106988447,
-0.0155622177,
-0.0302565861,
-0.0179827586,
0.0190016758,
-0.0157032106,
0.0321509652,
-0.0103430767,
0.0186932813,
-0.0553602651,
-0.027854234,
0.0052643786,
-0.0261822678,
0.0505639575,
0.0012922821,
-0.0251936577,
-0.0319840312,
-0.0337477103,
-0.0246518757,
-0.0500261933,
-0.0210620742,
-0.0037614848,
0.0410459153,
-0.0136867715,
-0.0312034767,
0.0040594256,
-0.0140379574,
0.0620208532,
-0.0323884152,
0.0242958125,
-0.0183733199,
0.0192641187,
0.0428144298,
0.0096781552,
0.0754914433,
-0.0465519577,
0.0027575034,
-0.0118469307,
-0.0166139212,
0.0131247751,
-0.0087306639,
0.0059824684,
0.0536408387,
-0.0400685407,
-0.0264204945,
0.0061091767,
0.0329889059,
-0.0286480784,
0.0312237181,
0.0769540146,
-0.0061408728,
-0.0154414056,
0.0041951179,
0.0013007112,
0.0425178818,
0.0078993514,
0.042783916,
-0.0902768672,
-0.0115865618,
0.0223834068,
0.0207525603,
0.0047335974,
0.0237681419,
-0.0161641762,
-0.0970475748,
0.0377044976,
0.0352601185,
-0.0563698076,
-0.0393480994,
0.0186538491,
-0.0264020357,
-0.022044858,
0.0482921079,
0.0051502618,
0.0283744354,
-0.0190060288,
-0.0287313163,
0.044778008,
-0.0917390883,
0.0077120881,
-0.0677181557,
0.0670476407,
0.0561762378,
0.0180196203,
-0.0283722393,
-0.0590037256,
0.030433977,
-0.0252975617,
-0.0250821449,
0.0236669313,
-0.0165571012,
0.0294219833,
-0.0370591506,
0.0362275504,
-0.0099532092,
-0.0288039837,
0.0258048438,
-0.0088215191,
0.04865098,
0.0026904738,
-0.0492362864,
0.0290050786,
-0.0247495342,
-0.0154550383,
0.0436737873,
0.0459239259,
-0.0493862182,
0.0249189194,
-0.0560544096,
0.0126719158,
-0.0664610565,
-0.0075997892,
0.0090186363,
0.0059394496,
-0.0263972916,
-0.0866309404,
-0.0113278795,
-0.0278712418,
0.0546617359,
0.0079170298,
0.0405801237,
-0.0215278473,
-0.0256653391,
0.004842266,
0.0276713651,
-0.0749723688,
0.0054187695,
-0.0795872882,
0.0126092397,
0.0201799329,
-0.0582778007,
-0.0274814554,
-0.0200630818,
-0.0835521892,
-0.0748939514,
-0.0257224645,
0.0435057394,
0.0132084414,
0.0160599817,
-0.0340492167,
-0.0749411583,
0.0601205677,
0.0035667999,
0.0105984788,
0.0344235711,
0.0310218576,
-0.0335746482,
-0.0176246986,
0.0500096232,
-0.01091005,
0.0198624171,
0.018330114,
0.0306639317,
0.0109642949,
-0.0412509926,
-0.0421570204,
0.0296075735,
0.0463750102,
-0.0240523033,
-0.0310420208,
-0.0346620902,
0.0537833124,
0.0395629108,
0.0019172095,
-0.0224772077,
-0.0373200551,
0.0265850034,
-0.0022097584,
-0.006258083,
-0.0436172858,
0.0272670686,
0.017633507,
0.0004515407,
-0.0143045364,
0.0046062078,
-0.0065414659,
0.0241438858,
0.0390408076,
0.0052725449,
0.0799837857,
0.0026753743,
0.036131151,
-0.051603727,
-0.0124999704,
0.0018647406,
0.0169110298,
-0.0276970491,
0.0517482832,
-0.005882021,
-0.025935147,
-0.0061490308,
0.0308330506,
0.1121766344,
-0.0207476653,
0.0279283635,
0.0079025012,
-0.0109626129,
0.0079812286,
-0.0129568744,
0.0028288404,
0.01330938,
0.0272074509,
-0.0031919056,
-0.0249349996,
-0.0226669684,
0.0349597409,
0.0142092938,
0.0114077004,
-0.0385668464,
0.0297294445,
0.0017876914,
0.0090290206,
-0.0047291652,
0.0220196974,
-0.0216812529,
-0.0090149017,
-0.0177241042,
-0.0748672187,
0.0223303717,
0.0266139489,
-0.0160844382,
0.0161205046,
-0.0077871447,
0.0830768496,
-0.0061063245,
0.0528964177,
-0.0306219459,
-0.0605201423,
0.0493775755,
-0.0142725641,
0.0210277643,
-6.835395325e-33,
-0.0114043066,
0.0013684685,
-0.0017025826,
-0.0017859524,
0.0277404357,
-0.0425185971,
-0.025993878,
-0.0128716016,
-0.0408341289,
-0.0092603471,
-0.0445868038,
-0.0239758641,
0.033846546,
0.0019793361,
0.0024361734,
-0.0188063756,
0.0300972573,
0.0016771472,
-0.0375053883,
-0.0454917811,
0.0146364737,
0.0190208647,
0.101639092,
0.021179067,
-0.0029080086,
0.0092290398,
-0.0082580512,
0.0239234436,
-0.0193950646,
0.0503292531,
0.0075285127,
0.0283421166,
0.0133517133,
-0.0480396785,
0.0006516932,
-0.0492887311,
-0.0206952672,
-0.0582877398,
0.0386662334,
0.035465654,
0.0117877992,
-0.0584933832,
0.0857639089,
-0.0472517647,
-0.0233766772,
0.0071077282,
0.0218809023,
-0.0137466332,
-0.0503477566,
-0.0156401917,
-0.0345280617,
0.0165499765,
0.0408368334,
-0.0048403181,
0.0451794863,
-0.0385973938,
-0.0082998089,
0.0048051653,
-0.054159835,
0.0353172421,
0.0023754013,
0.0778393,
0.057547491,
0.0262353197,
-0.0219404753,
0.0212795213,
0.0020848168,
0.0249431077,
0.0151514364,
-0.0084934868,
0.0866647437,
-0.0177149307,
0.0600012802,
0.0556523949,
0.0286936034,
-0.0407881103,
-0.0710421801,
0.0127330497,
0.0091810143,
-0.0345340222,
0.0329324789,
0.0023899069,
-0.0429734588,
-0.017576674,
-0.0895372704,
-0.0725379512,
-0.0484675914,
-0.009034886,
0.0294169504,
0.0323016644,
-0.005553599,
-0.0208545588,
0.0385276489,
-0.0310537927,
-0.0032010153,
0.0267883576,
0.0161631275,
0.0228023715,
-0.0196645427,
0.0084650684,
-0.0223337412,
-0.0386041515,
-0.0279648881,
-0.0231979433,
0.0092160497,
0.0130416295,
0.0424145013,
0.025200231,
-0.0609244779,
0.0292987749,
-0.0242365841,
0.0000664064,
0.0432978906,
0.0375737809,
0.022467358,
-0.0246583652,
0.0142411012,
0.0243140627,
0.0367057063,
0.0264292471,
0.0080730682,
0.0112767592,
0.0181027818,
0.0587625094,
-0.0277736653,
0.0341421627,
-0.0414576046,
0.0337631516,
0.0329652503,
-0.0268705171,
0.0019042682,
-0.0195834972,
2.901e-7,
0.0227502529,
0.0534804724,
-0.0430884026,
0.0184534825,
-0.0028317082,
0.0418327972,
-0.0619141646,
0.0053539709,
-0.0131835639,
0.0122835422,
-0.0092972582,
0.0029345939,
0.0564679727,
0.0327796042,
-0.1088713557,
0.0228171851,
-0.0379581042,
0.0998822525,
-0.0138502456,
-0.0364528038,
-0.0221463572,
0.1450027674,
0.0230288599,
-0.0043187663,
-0.0081886817,
-0.0682596192,
0.036631424,
-0.0410220586,
-0.027564358,
0.0348569192,
0.0437621437,
0.0397054553,
-0.023408521,
-0.0050378297,
-0.0587191917,
0.07814686,
0.0194689892,
0.071204111,
0.0293783583,
-0.0161907412,
0.0021147702,
-0.0380351804,
-0.0192649607,
-0.0651925579,
0.0675831139,
-0.009979805,
-0.022868067,
-0.0288142003,
0.025819486,
-0.046415478,
0.0759543926,
-0.0792843848,
-0.013196189,
0.0221589394,
0.0317200571,
-0.0064846077,
0.0018375228,
-0.0680966079,
-0.0352406204,
-0.0027166149,
0.0029125013,
-0.0258742142,
-0.040979322,
-0.0526168272,
0.0314256512,
-0.0372773334,
-0.0101349363,
2.797580128e-34,
0.0715398714,
-0.0264261179,
0.0285977945,
-0.0432763509,
0.0310808904,
-0.0033508884,
0.0272410996,
0.007720727,
-0.0109670535,
-0.038601689,
-0.0075153559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02791v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02791v2 | Rethinking Optimization and Architecture for Tiny Language Models | 2024-02-05T07:59:38 | 2024-02-06T05:38:26 | Yehui Tang, Fangcheng Liu, Yunsheng Ni, Yuchuan Tian, Zheyuan Bai, Yi-Qi Hu, Sichao Liu, Shangling Jui, Kai Han, Yunhe Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The power of large language models (LLMs) has been demonstrated through
numerous data and computing resources. However, the application of language
models on mobile devices is facing huge challenge on the computation and memory
costs, that is, tiny language models with high performance are urgently
required. Limited by the highly complex training process, there are many
details for optimizing language models that are seldom studied carefully. In
this study, based on a tiny language model with 1B parameters, we carefully
design a series of empirical study to analyze the effect of each component.
Three perspectives are mainly discussed, \ie, neural architecture, parameter
initialization, and optimization strategy. Several design formulas are
empirically proved especially effective for tiny language models, including
tokenizer compression, architecture tweaking, parameter inheritance and
multiple-round training. Then we train PanGu-$\pi$-1B Pro and PanGu-$\pi$-1.5B
Pro on 1.6T multilingual corpora, following the established formulas.
Experimental results demonstrate the improved optimization and architecture
yield a notable average improvement of 8.87 on benchmark evaluation sets for
PanGu-$\pi$-1B Pro. Besides, PanGu-$\pi$-1.5B Pro surpasses a range of SOTA
models with larger model sizes, validating its superior performance. The code
is available at https://github.com/YuchuanTian/RethinkTinyLM. | [
0.0210102461,
0.0230079126,
-0.0005786064,
0.0368290171,
0.016986981,
-0.0210831128,
0.0623863153,
0.0177859496,
-0.0702917874,
-0.0402513705,
-0.0300181825,
-0.0718835965,
0.0222235993,
-0.011673836,
0.035773214,
-0.019930359,
0.0439797118,
-0.0319871157,
-0.0158055015,
-0.0130469268,
0.0194249228,
-0.0100201508,
0.0468592979,
0.0559313931,
0.0023539173,
-0.0092798024,
-0.0131473755,
0.0370857082,
-0.0591231212,
-0.067831479,
0.0009819438,
0.0393587947,
0.0163949132,
0.0412839502,
0.0000020971,
0.0032351909,
-0.0014095375,
0.0008030189,
-0.0062436508,
0.0488220155,
0.1050720662,
-0.0005953269,
-0.0306515153,
0.0526828952,
-0.0174897742,
-0.0482767522,
0.0255394857,
0.0578851849,
0.0156961475,
0.0710313395,
-0.0067980122,
-0.0355615504,
0.0144256083,
-0.0319675058,
-0.0496167839,
-0.0140260132,
-0.0104787936,
-0.0500603169,
0.0067181042,
0.0054342858,
-0.0034660101,
0.0021453504,
0.0252013803,
0.0528874137,
-0.03024357,
0.0076132445,
-0.0203024838,
-0.0254198164,
-0.0190436263,
0.0220939051,
-0.0419448577,
-0.0389206633,
-0.0143493982,
0.0086805718,
-0.0273292474,
-0.0725459978,
-0.0405907817,
0.0120787174,
0.0038790617,
0.0131356213,
0.0076160892,
-0.012776643,
0.0605865493,
-0.0090766819,
-0.0285819303,
0.0241383892,
0.0314735435,
-0.0120785413,
-0.037558414,
-0.0324244611,
-0.0159207527,
-0.025667768,
0.014983437,
0.0141654825,
0.0130452085,
0.0039492417,
-0.0304175299,
-0.030811714,
-0.0007231538,
-0.075887464,
0.0457727909,
0.0286642145,
0.0137298871,
0.0048135035,
-0.042809166,
0.0276563987,
-0.0045252526,
0.0190184209,
-0.0494484454,
0.0188618507,
-0.0086547751,
0.0098772133,
-0.0403552875,
0.0611654706,
-0.0367856734,
-0.0132253366,
-0.0118040619,
-0.0014261458,
0.0640155151,
-0.0315269381,
0.023636831,
0.000710193,
-0.0136747574,
-0.0086926837,
0.0115208365,
0.0373201668,
-0.036537908,
0.0417193882,
-0.0069688652,
-0.0895899087,
0.0017185115,
0.0018208057,
0.0092807552,
-0.0047264537,
0.0115650455,
0.0522538573,
0.0083780279,
-0.0665848404,
-0.0661436096,
0.0388082825,
-0.0133047933,
-0.0357562825,
-0.0229067821,
-0.073178798,
0.0161914229,
-0.0274813343,
0.0253013428,
-0.0247402452,
0.0244410802,
0.037566077,
-0.0242209993,
0.0350905024,
-0.0431721061,
0.0004870298,
0.0265734531,
-0.0035120447,
0.0125984009,
0.0866088271,
0.0687217563,
0.0567792766,
0.0432330891,
-0.0281026345,
-0.0459855795,
0.0323993228,
0.0367057994,
0.0072762035,
-0.0059634559,
-0.0392872691,
-0.0193570815,
0.0180172175,
0.0125379236,
0.0896896496,
-0.0291920938,
0.0081392173,
0.0564497039,
0.090959534,
0.0391681902,
0.0773374662,
-0.0031681799,
-0.0104226684,
0.0151519803,
-0.065834634,
-0.0214149896,
-0.0114839422,
-0.0063429889,
0.009898426,
0.033917807,
0.0452032015,
-0.0443614163,
-0.0413309298,
-0.0483931825,
-0.0305359606,
-0.0221819729,
-0.0235758573,
0.0300163534,
0.0032286199,
-0.026858354,
0.0603949837,
0.0367556699,
-0.0703106001,
-0.0234429985,
-0.0622106716,
0.0448456295,
0.0286663827,
0.0221347623,
0.0165269449,
-0.0037965151,
-0.0034153829,
-0.0219871122,
0.0418834202,
0.0499516726,
0.0051563517,
0.0431684181,
-0.0682415292,
0.0372450128,
0.0192506351,
0.0206447821,
0.0121891201,
0.0064472375,
0.0301923435,
0.0345357619,
-0.0253467113,
-0.0543660261,
0.0344337896,
0.0050267796,
-0.018460799,
0.0264518242,
0.0172731318,
0.0212524403,
0.0247733518,
0.0117155751,
-0.0085364217,
0.024945071,
-0.0537017211,
0.0479607396,
-0.0140239,
-0.0422752351,
-0.034157373,
0.0443678685,
0.030472599,
0.0780305341,
0.0232062321,
-0.0140394727,
-0.0560990609,
0.0426937044,
-0.0330294184,
0.0623278692,
-0.0339077227,
0.0659081042,
-0.0282516666,
0.0425975919,
-0.0105324881,
0.0223477222,
0.0022927069,
0.0306918062,
-0.0089531615,
0.0390591994,
0.0507353656,
-0.0313391834,
-0.0550366491,
-0.0055578793,
-0.0388618074,
0.0320635736,
0.0225934386,
0.0105229588,
0.0132379606,
-0.0380187966,
-0.0940737352,
0.0114919413,
-0.031335447,
0.039356079,
0.004256953,
0.0502993315,
-0.0038174351,
-0.0184092,
-0.0061745318,
0.0263854265,
-0.0570015498,
0.0325988829,
0.0091338344,
-0.0119294878,
-0.045510672,
-0.0425102413,
-0.0151319262,
0.004286279,
0.0493870303,
-0.0326435342,
-0.0220254585,
-0.0354711413,
0.0013764685,
-0.0029728326,
0.0351045765,
0.011745546,
-0.0909868553,
0.0236677881,
-0.0077112163,
0.0492477827,
0.0606829859,
-0.0025729085,
0.00540089,
0.0340769254,
0.0428425595,
-0.0351922773,
0.0179594681,
0.0055071036,
-0.0135555118,
-0.0278812554,
-0.0314001106,
-0.0252759568,
0.120043546,
-0.0464913249,
0.0101582306,
-0.0531746894,
-0.0261087194,
-0.0291030202,
-0.0149007887,
0.0163211301,
0.0437711328,
-0.0160829909,
0.0166795701,
-0.0276656225,
-0.0369068831,
-0.0097616827,
-0.0702180043,
-0.0004980907,
-0.0523715131,
0.0000883641,
-0.0404815711,
0.0662705675,
0.0224175882,
0.0303280689,
-0.0196357332,
-0.0114512863,
-0.0371004604,
0.0437253676,
-0.0135435825,
-0.0170415919,
0.0229428895,
-0.0110544665,
0.0133062797,
-0.0318946391,
-0.0626163557,
0.0184229221,
-0.0108009847,
-0.0521416478,
0.0019201256,
0.0464914851,
-0.0024687746,
-0.0029127067,
0.0709114298,
0.0074798367,
0.0621873103,
-0.0185739435,
0.0354034603,
-0.0220570788,
0.0176865198,
0.0208141934,
0.0007419839,
0.0222943146,
-0.0277815834,
0.0506619923,
0.0019197153,
0.0756412074,
0.0088629518,
-0.0583768375,
-0.0044338754,
0.0399741121,
0.0004186979,
-0.0363894999,
0.0450033136,
0.063844949,
-0.0612503439,
-0.0190553777,
0.0856598318,
0.0069997399,
-0.046427466,
0.023121627,
0.0072185383,
0.0408682227,
-0.0119231213,
0.0176598858,
-0.0311094057,
-0.0296250395,
-0.0045860428,
0.0008225612,
0.0131357983,
0.0318073817,
-0.0416425727,
-0.0856989622,
-0.0423235334,
0.0331621431,
-0.0331252031,
-0.0189255942,
-0.0439846925,
-0.0422128476,
-0.0068458905,
0.0315751359,
0.046159938,
-0.0061582183,
-0.0086049,
0.0239173211,
-0.0619473308,
-0.0507076457,
0.0147924982,
-0.0350552201,
0.0265427567,
0.035819903,
-0.0096410885,
0.0062241219,
-0.0255781598,
0.0419178084,
0.025911754,
0.0057967636,
-0.0181854442,
-0.0142976567,
0.0154593457,
-0.0105049321,
0.0109133972,
0.0036559713,
-0.0342450179,
0.0072500594,
-0.017141372,
0.0271930601,
0.030606959,
-0.0170425102,
0.0102051003,
-0.0544101261,
-0.0480785072,
0.0395419076,
0.0355621018,
-0.0534016378,
-0.0482315794,
-0.0121926283,
-0.040622469,
-0.0666924939,
0.0144619234,
0.012941163,
0.0087105362,
-0.0443857685,
-0.0438921563,
-0.0022349255,
-0.0300540086,
0.039788004,
-0.0015965424,
0.0173987709,
0.0396329463,
0.0318599157,
-0.0362922512,
-0.0013992367,
0.004377469,
-0.005019214,
-0.0922575817,
0.0182255916,
0.041465085,
0.002928223,
0.0120330947,
-0.0122738639,
-0.1446927339,
-0.0384516716,
-0.0105101299,
0.0326387137,
0.0134531436,
0.0212660767,
-0.0215738602,
-0.0762217268,
0.0419188701,
0.0321677662,
-0.0351351015,
0.0200703535,
-0.0010571674,
-0.0268073659,
0.0105660884,
0.0546093509,
-0.0112141911,
0.0381463431,
-0.0101427445,
0.0427717902,
-0.0184164513,
0.0280311313,
-0.0054057948,
0.0293362774,
0.0406770706,
-0.0260751657,
-0.040839117,
-0.0144822281,
0.0630612522,
-0.0263992827,
0.03932954,
-0.0270228609,
-0.0047290749,
-0.0028913831,
0.0263569523,
-0.0231844895,
-0.0730873719,
0.0550392233,
0.006883787,
0.0430373922,
0.012339795,
-0.0120451255,
0.0460725501,
0.0083872816,
0.0158576928,
-0.0383008532,
0.0099118045,
-0.0197877567,
0.0140040861,
-0.077481918,
0.0062626461,
-0.0107525,
-0.0066128965,
-0.0524041094,
0.0584733114,
-0.0044816607,
-0.0245219097,
-0.0678614229,
0.0148326345,
0.032916382,
0.0004767299,
0.0267041773,
-0.00104656,
-0.0118965283,
-0.0267353095,
0.0068708737,
-0.0295143872,
-0.0117385499,
0.0300486833,
0.0119570484,
-0.0329776816,
-0.025256237,
0.0785565004,
0.0415702127,
-0.0108122081,
0.0101671154,
0.0395436808,
-0.0253484584,
0.0216066465,
-0.0234195534,
0.044279702,
-0.0451501235,
0.0227571204,
-0.0434039459,
-0.0340698026,
-0.0146127008,
-0.0196824856,
0.0367705971,
0.0102494201,
0.0179593675,
0.0447303057,
-0.0021898337,
0.0037032603,
-0.0115254866,
-0.0457334369,
0.0110531338,
0.004469913,
0.0099126659,
-6.433522459e-33,
-0.0151608363,
0.0548044145,
0.0414540619,
-0.0461723581,
-0.009065032,
0.0030351337,
-0.0196765829,
-0.0000833556,
-0.0496721454,
-0.0529871546,
-0.0398878604,
-0.0065459656,
0.0108639468,
0.0598895811,
-0.0181667693,
0.03400819,
0.062940456,
-0.0321404189,
-0.0138678076,
0.0069580842,
0.0154250329,
0.0358733349,
0.0201228131,
0.0112874899,
-0.0682694614,
0.0055817445,
-0.0021027948,
-0.003239237,
0.0076003852,
0.0420321971,
-0.0373368487,
0.012257183,
0.0207208972,
0.0139942607,
0.0022217387,
-0.0002512931,
-0.0494101718,
-0.0546681434,
0.0069497507,
0.0501297414,
0.0037876861,
-0.0416059755,
0.0516040474,
0.0141157098,
-0.0484013371,
0.0255754944,
-0.0114523768,
-0.0101260971,
-0.0643556789,
0.0199763868,
-0.0438389853,
0.0200502127,
0.0579187162,
0.0078161461,
0.046215713,
-0.0191274714,
-0.0836889297,
-0.0096483063,
-0.0586820617,
0.0100736916,
0.006411165,
0.0832446665,
0.0485314429,
0.0195393637,
0.0141141871,
0.0157108586,
0.0686489046,
0.0184377264,
-0.0431999154,
0.0079356628,
0.0612150282,
0.0081988517,
0.0552991256,
0.0111315399,
0.0569952205,
-0.0591260865,
-0.0702808052,
-0.0386445969,
0.0498259291,
0.0581172444,
0.0269001648,
0.0273445863,
-0.0331104472,
-0.0389191136,
-0.0437607542,
-0.0624394938,
-0.038424056,
-0.0442101769,
0.0177616812,
0.0220913365,
-0.0113212308,
-0.021100454,
0.0203836337,
-0.0233095624,
0.0182031449,
-0.0406657308,
0.0177164711,
0.0160313789,
-0.0036687071,
0.0297701806,
-0.0761954188,
-0.0607007481,
-0.027290035,
0.0038647696,
0.0159140769,
0.0051232404,
0.0193937309,
0.0165622756,
-0.0803033262,
-0.0302349739,
-0.0301143173,
-0.0183693115,
0.053299129,
0.032962881,
0.0498695672,
0.0062029464,
0.0001254302,
0.0596549958,
-0.0057044313,
-0.0022425344,
-0.0027023705,
-0.0372628383,
0.0305858217,
0.0334447958,
-0.0315053239,
0.0097723519,
-0.0669165179,
0.047814142,
0.0329239629,
-0.0410989188,
-0.0439614467,
0.0383525826,
2.794e-7,
-0.0044950033,
0.0191256441,
-0.0044480655,
-0.0270453561,
0.0238873363,
0.0080676163,
0.0132442191,
0.0116439452,
-0.0376116894,
0.0332604237,
-0.0074241664,
0.0013723038,
0.0511845835,
0.0108617274,
-0.0784903243,
0.04003907,
-0.0583380982,
0.0466767102,
-0.028410919,
-0.0157179069,
-0.0055320337,
0.1517216861,
0.0091716517,
-0.0123648718,
-0.023490537,
-0.0221680999,
0.0326443985,
-0.0075009004,
0.0107689146,
0.0178922582,
0.0006540534,
0.0449753851,
-0.044671081,
-0.0115559213,
0.0047167037,
0.0205357131,
-0.0091462834,
0.0239722002,
-0.0360666886,
0.0132208876,
0.050556384,
-0.0276198108,
-0.0402391776,
-0.0510855764,
0.0432770327,
-0.0046888883,
-0.0157221872,
-0.0187798385,
0.0279558972,
0.0149781462,
-0.024429908,
-0.0316312462,
-0.0166274253,
0.0094057024,
0.005138115,
-0.0142812449,
-0.0031284627,
-0.0496452563,
0.0023829038,
0.0117380321,
0.0327698998,
-0.0595744215,
-0.0903659686,
0.0236658137,
0.043437276,
-0.0299988948,
0.0223158151,
2.64961822e-34,
0.0238949805,
-0.0737246573,
0.0143050402,
0.0451920293,
-0.0026417619,
-0.0364934914,
0.0560598485,
-0.0065583675,
0.0076534152,
-0.070049651,
-0.0200947318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02782v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02782v1 | From Partial to Strictly Incremental Constituent Parsing | 2024-02-05T07:33:25 | 2024-02-05T07:33:25 | Ana Ezquerro, Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, David Vilares | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study incremental constituent parsers to assess their capacity to output
trees based on prefix representations alone. Guided by strictly left-to-right
generative language models and tree-decoding modules, we build parsers that
adhere to a strong definition of incrementality across languages. This builds
upon work that asserted incrementality, but that mostly only enforced it on
either the encoder or the decoder. Finally, we conduct an analysis against
non-incremental and partially incremental models. | [
0.0087149926,
0.0752705112,
-0.0369223654,
0.0042730444,
-0.0197573528,
0.0136473654,
-0.0573723055,
-0.0196957607,
-0.1068020537,
-0.0346535444,
0.0411657281,
-0.0034651861,
-0.0099221468,
0.0282530896,
0.0063628526,
-0.0699228272,
0.0843802541,
-0.0324848965,
0.0092550898,
0.0264376998,
-0.0058576688,
0.0016406855,
0.0111369686,
0.0284237042,
-0.0147288619,
-0.0412098207,
-0.0310306326,
-0.0088691982,
-0.0323486254,
-0.0176493898,
-0.050440371,
-0.0230348445,
-0.0136076175,
-0.0242695585,
0.0000016564,
-0.0330487415,
-0.0626933277,
0.0159163531,
-0.0529205315,
-0.011072794,
0.0180337671,
-0.0413971879,
-0.0444068052,
-0.0068294089,
-0.0244503021,
-0.0083630485,
0.0480278172,
-0.0483931452,
0.0673931092,
0.0764235035,
-0.0136128142,
-0.0778678581,
0.0470732749,
-0.0039549372,
0.0142322639,
0.0175241772,
-0.0212379284,
0.000505463,
-0.0065513267,
0.0057270043,
-0.0259356927,
-0.020916231,
0.0301696677,
-0.0186478179,
0.020860659,
0.0401675142,
0.0247615259,
-0.0115491366,
0.0071643433,
-0.0241435561,
-0.0393608883,
-0.0085086999,
-0.0172445513,
-0.0072021876,
-0.0164306797,
-0.0647591203,
-0.0613723733,
0.0903369933,
-0.0241804551,
0.0436210521,
0.06684836,
-0.0069775232,
0.0184705574,
-0.0299914852,
-0.0312964916,
0.1059728712,
0.0195231475,
-0.0480827577,
-0.0437563658,
0.0290910974,
-0.0064432174,
-0.0453956015,
-0.0029075239,
0.0214640275,
0.0132893575,
0.0247160178,
-0.0287728682,
-0.0160403978,
0.005784391,
-0.0052728639,
-0.0113509027,
0.0703426227,
-0.0133286016,
0.0177061558,
0.0231336858,
0.0538567156,
0.0203608889,
-0.0126285749,
-0.053381592,
0.0043801344,
-0.011614833,
-0.0466809236,
-0.0600456372,
0.049821455,
-0.0477256514,
0.0125133013,
-0.0003443429,
0.0468714759,
0.0290065147,
0.0106469467,
0.0472519435,
-0.0428211875,
-0.0642258301,
0.047349602,
0.0158795435,
0.024066709,
-0.030944882,
-0.0348016843,
0.0233491659,
-0.0677534342,
-0.034005668,
0.0314978138,
-0.0137841199,
-0.0323714539,
-0.046033062,
0.0177478176,
-0.00495358,
-0.0101517634,
-0.0150203919,
-0.03073751,
0.0072188769,
0.0130508877,
0.0077835619,
-0.0476031378,
-0.0050309231,
0.0134938126,
0.0361453593,
-0.0404513031,
-0.0262879673,
0.0183355622,
0.0246127099,
0.0006764592,
-0.0278254319,
0.0154663213,
-0.0402966402,
-0.0287622046,
0.0114682578,
0.0401150621,
0.0106146978,
-0.0291178115,
0.0356229655,
0.0013264319,
-0.0308398437,
0.0265713837,
-0.0361094624,
-0.0543236919,
-0.0281240698,
0.0166331548,
0.0072010425,
-0.0064192195,
0.0213315934,
0.0257268045,
-0.0243238714,
-0.0303781964,
-0.0255295504,
0.0185188036,
-0.0197778083,
-0.0027188065,
0.0815858245,
-0.0026377772,
-0.0186500512,
0.0257082339,
-0.0023691501,
-0.0402902253,
-0.0032336698,
0.0238600112,
-0.0719113722,
0.0120297074,
0.0117800115,
-0.0234125871,
-0.0288665742,
0.0028267577,
0.0054945424,
-0.0556818619,
0.0498392917,
0.0327257775,
0.0040050568,
-0.0009948426,
-0.0194041245,
-0.0728764683,
-0.003248034,
-0.0028254618,
-0.0238450747,
0.0338325724,
0.0179408155,
-0.012284996,
-0.0222603902,
0.0349981859,
-0.0384036675,
0.0080142096,
0.0049432153,
-0.0409074835,
0.0412625745,
0.0066272598,
-0.0010610922,
-0.0027489664,
0.0277586635,
0.0170004833,
-0.0524529889,
-0.0276011694,
-0.0043440219,
0.0033163964,
0.0467742309,
0.0409769155,
-0.0108933691,
0.0293015651,
-0.0143822646,
-0.0033855243,
0.0237980913,
0.0267271772,
-0.0243762992,
0.0506890304,
0.0600282103,
-0.0175694581,
0.0122318175,
0.0673941523,
-0.0327306762,
-0.071865879,
0.0383610725,
0.0300784335,
-0.0126434574,
-0.0490837172,
-0.0087234229,
-0.0349802934,
0.0233156532,
-0.0443447456,
0.0409033783,
-0.00225945,
0.080580458,
0.0161036011,
-0.0462227017,
-0.0205986258,
0.0885148719,
-0.045742847,
0.0241298825,
0.0186664853,
0.0001837489,
0.0004229518,
-0.0550085716,
-0.02782562,
0.0566918962,
0.0122186374,
-0.0736366436,
0.0254238304,
-0.0263587683,
-0.0015839564,
0.0042657042,
-0.0274176206,
0.012680267,
-0.0331769846,
0.0748851597,
0.0302080587,
0.0406284742,
0.0277637169,
0.0094143059,
0.0098905126,
-0.0358366743,
0.016085403,
0.0309980959,
0.013407615,
0.0150759891,
-0.0424146913,
-0.0209375564,
-0.0372222103,
-0.0375980251,
0.0312560163,
-0.0305288974,
-0.0576462299,
-0.0466986261,
-0.0537157059,
-0.0052108429,
0.0191660598,
-0.0038143301,
0.0025352652,
0.0229387581,
-0.0475716256,
0.0441385396,
-0.0065249437,
-0.0105219949,
0.0481218584,
-0.0104549956,
-0.0411542356,
0.0026337104,
-0.0084571857,
0.0054431567,
-0.0212183613,
-0.0319929793,
-0.0362764001,
0.0231609847,
0.1055651531,
-0.0220139995,
-0.0067371051,
-0.0329533182,
0.0072735585,
-0.0564600788,
-0.0091036595,
-0.0208856259,
-0.0740352571,
-0.0148209538,
0.0275222231,
-0.0270467699,
-0.0376879759,
0.0451224558,
-0.0359272845,
-0.0247879159,
-0.0070644147,
0.0106171286,
-0.0422951542,
0.0941805989,
0.0457668379,
0.0037804879,
0.0296675544,
-0.0548318364,
0.0049356171,
0.0650305897,
0.038285546,
0.0100667616,
0.021625068,
-0.051346153,
0.0375653356,
-0.0206233077,
-0.0304175802,
-0.0214734618,
-0.0378009677,
0.0523593985,
0.0361828059,
0.0202254374,
0.0492556505,
0.0219703969,
0.0382499248,
-0.0467478484,
0.0196215864,
0.0207947455,
0.006503772,
-0.0207162276,
0.0023745811,
-0.0240736827,
-0.0021638435,
0.001528949,
0.0098377429,
0.0274829324,
0.0366219804,
0.0444913469,
-0.0131079257,
-0.0173565242,
0.0414439999,
0.0052362345,
-0.0397848487,
-0.0680747554,
-0.0096422834,
0.018627502,
-0.0453082472,
-0.0317929573,
0.0700959116,
0.037480738,
0.001954563,
0.05341864,
-0.0536545888,
0.0047997548,
0.018287994,
-0.0075554969,
-0.1088754684,
0.0107200611,
0.0262989085,
0.0057858042,
-0.0181853361,
-0.0373804644,
0.0161777604,
-0.1038966402,
0.0182960369,
0.025263764,
0.0083710775,
0.0235555917,
-0.0008717414,
-0.0410976894,
0.0073883859,
-0.0257629361,
0.0808914229,
-0.0288578235,
0.035757944,
0.0196032468,
-0.0241505392,
-0.0199732166,
-0.053994514,
-0.0135289375,
-0.0365833491,
0.0787504762,
-0.0241430812,
0.0066183582,
0.0039360183,
0.0555876084,
-0.0561450124,
0.0295095369,
-0.0215702914,
-0.0508170947,
-0.0054321657,
0.001811269,
0.0263910107,
-0.0068089217,
-0.0042756051,
-0.0235374402,
0.0044842372,
0.0613873303,
-0.0264254808,
0.0249865316,
-0.0089364136,
-0.0512600392,
-0.0175451245,
0.0175498407,
0.0156989396,
0.0341675244,
-0.0624298155,
-0.0665752068,
0.0262967572,
0.0470207185,
0.009866884,
0.0128923506,
-0.004053147,
-0.0489649698,
-0.0590273626,
-0.0547719635,
0.0080719618,
-0.0059256498,
-0.0426793098,
-0.0006797448,
0.0002806777,
-0.0284607168,
-0.0168166906,
-0.0066003082,
0.0048768129,
0.0128359487,
-0.0362547487,
-0.0218013059,
0.0444056615,
0.0439340435,
-0.0326713137,
-0.062662594,
-0.0116390502,
-0.0212102067,
0.0235760007,
0.0759914145,
0.0220640451,
0.0343901664,
-0.0292175189,
-0.0131723713,
-0.0936790928,
0.020867845,
-0.0247108359,
0.0421743169,
0.0165303852,
-0.0230946895,
0.0217905063,
0.0234508738,
-0.0008679862,
0.0232887045,
-0.0425846316,
0.0672473758,
-0.0187541004,
0.0358068272,
0.0734022409,
0.0240989532,
0.0511322357,
0.0305167753,
0.0481157564,
0.0237914752,
0.0265316945,
-0.077755183,
-0.0200304091,
-0.036776945,
0.0207383428,
0.0022704597,
0.0269472655,
-0.0056155785,
0.0054244334,
-0.0193085,
0.0503466874,
-0.0498330556,
0.037839368,
-0.0014258176,
0.0146798743,
-0.0266168267,
0.0162921753,
-0.0270470101,
0.0086772982,
-0.0203185678,
0.0001878774,
-0.0165393595,
-0.0277600456,
0.0139729548,
0.0292428322,
-0.0314167067,
-0.0260784142,
0.0039050614,
0.0036757097,
-0.0070397761,
-0.0023298445,
0.0384659767,
0.0484275892,
0.0698436275,
0.012012762,
0.0202953443,
-0.0156964753,
0.0013101139,
0.0362470113,
-0.0824154392,
-0.0084277894,
0.0172871444,
-0.0200435203,
-0.039321892,
0.0789173469,
-0.0317122787,
0.0334047303,
-0.0292195398,
0.0032565016,
-0.0216089319,
-0.044011943,
-0.0283679329,
0.0211158264,
0.0180225018,
0.0220837686,
-0.0279620439,
0.0026447205,
-0.0390379354,
0.0625554845,
0.044222232,
-0.0182218645,
0.0389116853,
0.0472659692,
-0.0168839619,
-0.0770187229,
-0.0132073117,
0.0239558723,
-0.0320623219,
-0.0094771655,
-0.0090269409,
-4.927207631e-33,
-0.0848119706,
0.0674345791,
0.0165429898,
0.0163063779,
-0.0502604805,
-0.0276120342,
-0.0527679808,
0.0197232962,
0.0334542319,
-0.0222065896,
-0.0105242934,
0.0123422388,
0.0098004937,
0.0223182775,
0.0531209111,
-0.0207144897,
0.0664755851,
-0.0010662093,
-0.020969931,
-0.0201008134,
0.0698604658,
0.003118505,
0.0786663741,
-0.0077559701,
0.0216251612,
-0.0322438329,
-0.0119930757,
0.038977541,
0.0117681287,
0.0452726074,
0.036811702,
-0.0382350907,
0.0172135159,
-0.0209578052,
-0.0703022256,
-0.0287837461,
-0.0954166874,
-0.0051884409,
0.0209755413,
0.0272440743,
-0.0485850722,
-0.0305793975,
0.0345331021,
-0.0124646164,
-0.0173170902,
0.0454457887,
-0.0211629029,
-0.0316180736,
-0.0167938489,
-0.004612253,
-0.0363566987,
0.0426294915,
-0.0089419167,
0.056402985,
0.0198076349,
0.0268443841,
0.0144341551,
-0.0040392634,
0.0071324282,
0.0025298796,
0.0247324035,
0.0528859347,
0.0137586836,
-0.0329629555,
0.0429625995,
0.0157514475,
0.0458761342,
-0.0424762852,
0.0132805184,
0.0626221672,
-0.0433992893,
0.0326978192,
0.0008345212,
-0.0527622849,
0.0734307766,
0.0252603572,
0.0037836372,
0.0144411279,
0.0901311263,
0.0608765706,
-0.0235750563,
0.034645848,
0.0077394778,
-0.0167744588,
-0.0118221631,
-0.042207092,
0.0152060557,
-0.0422528051,
0.0250410251,
-0.0116197225,
-0.0020880308,
0.0657426193,
0.0592119209,
-0.0003950257,
-0.027226327,
0.0197465271,
-0.0210728049,
0.0722701475,
-0.0219368711,
0.0215412583,
-0.0093769822,
-0.0384417661,
-0.0057295547,
-0.0254486948,
0.0291268714,
0.0198472533,
0.0043205461,
0.0370419547,
-0.0077133276,
-0.0110348659,
-0.013989144,
0.001015028,
-0.0758781657,
0.0549597666,
0.058575362,
0.0347163901,
0.0093748989,
0.0501652509,
0.0078996196,
-0.013651981,
-0.0315740667,
0.016658688,
0.0206767134,
0.0204690918,
0.0051258407,
-0.0192649774,
0.0145089095,
0.0031738023,
0.0372130275,
-0.0332529768,
-0.0077758776,
0.0631792024,
2.365e-7,
0.0561104119,
-0.0185301974,
0.0811104923,
-0.0080186715,
0.0474426411,
-0.0425907783,
-0.0164498854,
0.0320272334,
-0.0235833935,
0.0118601723,
-0.0182189681,
-0.0435579307,
-0.0471928455,
0.0228708107,
-0.046516344,
0.0284164734,
-0.0727324709,
-0.0169290937,
-0.0310383532,
0.0121210376,
0.0522213243,
0.0531922095,
-0.0219779462,
0.0310063064,
-0.0310851932,
0.0187356304,
0.0513974763,
0.017447859,
0.0209392831,
0.0150145302,
-0.0122057777,
-0.0042966851,
0.0269329399,
-0.0468648747,
0.0091049392,
0.0527679175,
0.0149085578,
0.0515382141,
-0.0387455709,
0.045559898,
0.0482882708,
-0.0083293561,
-0.0166110117,
0.0185239315,
0.0670166388,
-0.0380802639,
-0.0120662544,
0.002399584,
-0.0884284601,
0.0587665364,
-0.0730304644,
0.0417054072,
-0.0306859929,
0.0335056335,
0.0420157351,
-0.0049578859,
-0.056104809,
-0.0320474878,
-0.0236488953,
-0.0174261183,
-0.0393842719,
-0.0400292911,
-0.0245873798,
0.075472109,
-0.0121104615,
-0.0016306411,
-0.0967183262,
2.127676688e-34,
0.0318647511,
-0.00053939,
0.0239724014,
0.047470957,
-0.0018033476,
-0.0276594497,
0.0148222353,
0.0681294724,
-0.0174565986,
-0.055022791,
-0.0296331793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02781v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02781v1 | Dual Knowledge Distillation for Efficient Sound Event Detection | 2024-02-05T07:30:32 | 2024-02-05T07:30:32 | Yang Xiao, Rohan Kumar Das | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Sound event detection (SED) is essential for recognizing specific sounds and
their temporal locations within acoustic signals. This becomes challenging
particularly for on-device applications, where computational resources are
limited. To address this issue, we introduce a novel framework referred to as
dual knowledge distillation for developing efficient SED systems in this work.
Our proposed dual knowledge distillation commences with temporal-averaging
knowledge distillation (TAKD), utilizing a mean student model derived from the
temporal averaging of the student model's parameters. This allows the student
model to indirectly learn from a pre-trained teacher model, ensuring a stable
knowledge distillation. Subsequently, we introduce embedding-enhanced feature
distillation (EEFD), which involves incorporating an embedding distillation
layer within the student model to bolster contextual learning. On DCASE 2023
Task 4A public evaluation dataset, our proposed SED system with dual knowledge
distillation having merely one-third of the baseline model's parameters,
demonstrates superior performance in terms of PSDS1 and PSDS2. This highlights
the importance of proposed dual knowledge distillation for compact SED systems,
which can be ideal for edge devices. | [
-0.054458905,
0.0313276239,
-0.003455282,
0.0588111393,
0.0115021495,
-0.0150379185,
0.0617901944,
-0.0562785976,
-0.0400102809,
0.0052750525,
0.0010077413,
0.0057776175,
-0.0274379533,
0.0523227006,
-0.0047453251,
-0.0307615511,
0.0357928239,
-0.0047101569,
0.0226767063,
-0.0018039208,
0.0056702802,
-0.0329494216,
-0.0330078416,
0.0457929336,
-0.0043305228,
0.0013636278,
-0.0479534455,
0.0185587183,
0.0366980471,
-0.0200786404,
0.0258721113,
0.0196611844,
0.0645496622,
0.0328859501,
0.0000021054,
-0.0129353711,
0.0214021318,
0.0087719057,
-0.0426999107,
0.0129659045,
-0.0237887446,
0.0057469211,
-0.028228268,
-0.0116618825,
-0.0015042407,
-0.0357712246,
0.0174046848,
0.0232854914,
0.0284678042,
0.0168904513,
-0.0017058417,
-0.0567082986,
0.0162778217,
-0.016291989,
0.0277897436,
-0.027000431,
-0.0123655461,
-0.0428112559,
-0.006768032,
-0.0047751302,
-0.0177299418,
0.0319631174,
0.0181355271,
0.0212573484,
0.0677339956,
0.036977943,
-0.0126644662,
0.0092504658,
-0.0309515093,
0.048719313,
0.0155729009,
-0.0143475961,
0.0510362126,
0.0033374219,
-0.0338895097,
-0.0569164231,
-0.0535848401,
-0.0590267628,
-0.0017115858,
0.0225709174,
-0.0532800145,
0.0203290414,
0.0423565358,
-0.0336191803,
0.0170980375,
0.0142446663,
-0.0196380988,
-0.0228810105,
-0.038781628,
-0.043113362,
-0.0067801331,
-0.0118758474,
0.0536799282,
0.0306846611,
0.0291149467,
-0.0378267691,
-0.0173197929,
-0.0477397479,
-0.0275612846,
0.0036801193,
0.0038709841,
0.0414273404,
-0.0488637239,
0.0608949959,
-0.0253933202,
0.0316844173,
-0.0033184313,
-0.0039324053,
-0.0327862054,
0.03158997,
-0.0369057804,
0.0131128412,
0.0001289122,
0.0349320918,
0.0052227611,
-0.060522493,
0.009839233,
-0.0294759665,
-0.0594657734,
-0.0051746326,
-0.0003981185,
0.019780999,
-0.0328750871,
0.0095219919,
0.0384339578,
0.04736479,
-0.0174842719,
0.0554298833,
-0.0324552916,
-0.0060355486,
-0.0293707252,
-0.0129745156,
0.044913169,
0.0254441407,
-0.0113893766,
-0.0008972636,
-0.0363854021,
-0.0335092023,
-0.0365172513,
-0.028248081,
-0.0133254752,
0.0245126653,
-0.0138937384,
-0.0727342442,
0.0746317208,
-0.0439463742,
0.008265472,
-0.0471975841,
0.004044333,
-0.049874533,
0.0357564017,
0.0741473287,
-0.0007768488,
0.0097714085,
0.0324171558,
0.0371872596,
-0.0247533526,
0.0624356717,
0.0610274598,
-0.0086306604,
0.0102336695,
0.0094812568,
-0.0506147183,
0.0223060325,
0.0442382321,
-0.02197944,
-0.0002846741,
-0.0289657246,
-0.0221371502,
0.0243789256,
0.0475294702,
-0.0197128039,
-0.0334232561,
-0.0172363706,
0.0375664532,
0.0173901524,
0.0298472792,
-0.0227777958,
0.0116520552,
-0.012553839,
-0.0334336795,
-0.0036534155,
-0.0092878891,
0.0298806578,
0.0269686319,
0.0062570935,
0.0572437532,
0.0333144516,
-0.0272206273,
-0.0410882235,
0.0115658259,
-0.0264926851,
-0.0380880013,
0.0494980365,
0.029149631,
-0.027762644,
0.0364000537,
0.0654646084,
0.0171790738,
-0.0392446779,
-0.0033484539,
-0.0287436619,
0.0629404858,
0.052732978,
-0.0059122327,
-0.0669955611,
-0.0383681245,
-0.0240447856,
0.0331032872,
-0.0264602229,
-0.0030613036,
-0.0434016474,
0.083756499,
-0.0179681405,
-0.0748830885,
-0.0151680242,
0.0346114747,
0.0191343334,
0.0114735998,
0.0189848728,
0.040404506,
-0.0257568788,
0.0388958156,
-0.0071096281,
0.0032872907,
-0.0516885333,
-0.0245909002,
0.0231701769,
0.0460193604,
-0.0014911029,
-0.0268082265,
-0.0229504369,
0.0356533155,
-0.0760418624,
0.0361021422,
0.018651098,
-0.0666145533,
-0.0731430277,
0.0547334477,
-0.0020977175,
0.0317333713,
0.0493677445,
-0.0338094011,
-0.0435193144,
0.0163616594,
0.0301089156,
0.0395562947,
-0.008518354,
-0.0016353133,
0.0054387646,
-0.0110694058,
0.0234273933,
0.0159374122,
-0.0002941472,
-0.0268139448,
-0.0480625853,
0.0057441518,
0.0420927741,
-0.0310549438,
-0.0284505542,
0.0175675359,
-0.0268639866,
-0.0043815766,
-0.0255072992,
-0.0265824627,
-0.0157156996,
-0.0021334011,
-0.0637092069,
0.0077270186,
-0.0414953418,
-0.0006718695,
-0.0220419373,
0.003164382,
0.0239344463,
-0.0352049023,
-0.0110176597,
-0.0256770067,
-0.0494196825,
0.0099990228,
-0.0640395507,
0.0122470073,
-0.0141596748,
0.0071934578,
0.015175228,
0.013025526,
0.0006269271,
-0.02377351,
-0.0013074385,
0.0152001483,
0.021880284,
0.0055933846,
0.0148868905,
0.0111629749,
0.0353482477,
0.0206560567,
0.0043070051,
0.0363500081,
0.0600171015,
-0.0385855027,
0.0442005806,
0.032845296,
-0.0148115391,
-0.0491741262,
0.0457138829,
0.0182166137,
0.0520103201,
-0.0461469442,
0.0244235676,
-0.0445334092,
0.0458853357,
0.0130038187,
-0.0101860929,
-0.0192630626,
-0.0238144919,
-0.014645976,
-0.0550130829,
-0.069058463,
-0.0395387076,
-0.0200919323,
0.0006017042,
-0.0377777778,
-0.0430583544,
0.0328149647,
-0.0048036613,
-0.0172415636,
-0.0521724224,
-0.0715935305,
-0.0120735047,
0.0606674254,
-0.0413828045,
-0.0028495996,
-0.0138133178,
-0.0222320482,
-0.0011365095,
-0.0125738028,
0.0445201658,
-0.0611446798,
0.0292520821,
-0.0494531803,
-0.0100390464,
-0.003675421,
-0.0360994637,
-0.0424937531,
0.0047424408,
-0.0104965391,
0.0104472497,
-0.0212679934,
-0.0147934528,
-0.0078159301,
0.0083744638,
0.0149892848,
0.0662706345,
0.0512648709,
0.003699085,
-0.0234415866,
0.0662317201,
0.008577914,
0.0194024127,
-0.0526322126,
0.0094984248,
0.0400530398,
0.0524957813,
0.1314239651,
-0.0357685797,
-0.0849317089,
0.0575931631,
0.0310993586,
0.0112965843,
-0.0330609083,
0.0463727005,
0.0341279358,
-0.0908455178,
-0.0022556377,
0.0772060156,
0.0071506142,
-0.0217348002,
0.0025604959,
0.0540726706,
0.0044508968,
0.0147592239,
-0.0486704931,
-0.0249530319,
-0.0342596732,
0.0457649119,
0.0185102839,
0.0536333583,
0.0396969728,
-0.0200389344,
-0.0298297144,
0.0398135036,
0.043686416,
-0.0173695907,
-0.0566486977,
-0.0096653514,
0.005222219,
-0.0270194579,
0.0066796779,
-0.0264550932,
0.0203554034,
0.0000473782,
0.0070426306,
-0.0557210445,
-0.0954699665,
0.017768817,
-0.0278409813,
0.0058144238,
0.0409937464,
0.0277992915,
0.0054152128,
-0.0460932218,
-0.0240388978,
-0.0152793061,
0.0029966542,
-0.0001349887,
0.0118534202,
0.0045359712,
0.0023787078,
0.0466561802,
0.0608432814,
0.0007393486,
-0.0281437412,
0.0515724793,
0.11497695,
0.0159106329,
0.0025075465,
-0.034985844,
-0.0209654048,
0.0362606086,
0.031489484,
0.0227152482,
0.0261044111,
0.0009316706,
0.0499882773,
-0.033747267,
-0.02515487,
0.0225422177,
-0.0092003653,
0.0054143127,
-0.0321472995,
-0.0279410928,
-0.0079665929,
0.0182032604,
0.0310976785,
0.0100751203,
0.0233073309,
-0.0208348036,
0.0329359174,
-0.0740016848,
0.0135023324,
0.0205234978,
0.0545129664,
0.0051651457,
0.0005073613,
0.0140885627,
-0.0097154528,
-0.0409214236,
0.0426936746,
-0.0756644085,
-0.0673548877,
0.0003847961,
-0.0543948635,
0.0158760212,
0.0879441798,
-0.0214508548,
0.001844593,
0.1059213504,
0.0203217026,
-0.0289280247,
0.0271567516,
0.075505726,
-0.0515707731,
-0.0022433721,
0.0270314813,
-0.040937826,
0.0497569256,
-0.0134424334,
0.0150809335,
-0.02456671,
-0.0168967508,
0.0040729735,
-0.0251292475,
0.0723241866,
0.0155391693,
0.0029500911,
-0.053866975,
0.0418761745,
0.035749726,
0.0422981083,
-0.0609907955,
0.0120057529,
-0.0112089654,
0.0188884363,
-0.0274536163,
0.0610957518,
0.0692024082,
-0.0246054567,
-0.0624896772,
0.0605190992,
0.0247447416,
-0.0255949758,
0.032401666,
-0.0053838929,
0.0025236327,
0.0296033155,
-0.0057695401,
-0.0143876942,
0.0001948794,
-0.0141293686,
0.0118121607,
0.0013681948,
-0.0071123773,
-0.0083914595,
-0.0505700856,
-0.0000179365,
-0.0185701028,
-0.0094664115,
0.0573930778,
-0.0198999923,
-0.0056784502,
0.0019872771,
-0.017019216,
-0.0131732142,
0.0411222279,
-0.0425274223,
0.0137615902,
0.0256610122,
0.0394279063,
0.0081979288,
0.0030099358,
0.0610798523,
-0.0411150828,
0.0472529419,
-0.0256089084,
0.0417438373,
-0.0392098129,
-0.0386319868,
0.0542089865,
0.072317183,
-0.0160315093,
0.0080464492,
-0.0018831268,
-0.0361710675,
0.0271043666,
-0.0425258055,
0.0154781118,
-0.0081082638,
0.0251387283,
0.0398305655,
-0.025005281,
-0.0159809981,
0.0557603352,
-0.0392767563,
-0.0266816821,
-0.0201009028,
0.0031559977,
-5.866370679e-33,
0.0225841794,
0.0252064075,
0.0014012955,
0.0059222304,
-0.0238250922,
0.0307935923,
0.0056063682,
-0.0331011564,
0.0186774991,
0.0273849275,
-0.0006157993,
0.0320353806,
0.038432952,
0.0030789392,
0.0163945947,
-0.0244887341,
0.1221880764,
-0.0312162675,
0.0307706837,
0.0227333494,
0.0592062175,
0.0596756339,
0.0194655806,
-0.0519765466,
-0.0393467881,
0.0308985822,
0.0175211988,
-0.0512071662,
-0.0123334778,
0.0007134257,
-0.0175410695,
0.0242522359,
-0.0250640437,
-0.0448443107,
-0.0411829613,
0.0004580445,
-0.1216220483,
-0.0286723319,
-0.0349264033,
0.0043135178,
-0.0037388222,
-0.0416994467,
0.0480734147,
0.0164809618,
-0.0366920047,
-0.0513338633,
0.0295027327,
-0.0225098003,
-0.048466783,
-0.1008671895,
-0.006909627,
0.033227507,
-0.0024671415,
-0.0474800393,
0.0696691126,
-0.0275786407,
-0.0031134086,
-0.0064237318,
-0.1079866141,
0.056409128,
-0.004533743,
0.0139922639,
0.0228766855,
-0.002269062,
-0.021800708,
0.0649258122,
0.017652113,
-0.0615533851,
0.0020091243,
0.0005147258,
0.008162871,
0.0674217045,
-0.0015056038,
0.0026497543,
0.0835524872,
-0.0457394347,
-0.0569864884,
0.0316502489,
0.0227687061,
-0.0066768378,
-0.0129948352,
0.0586266108,
-0.0583491735,
-0.0203871336,
-0.0543635115,
0.0295222122,
-0.0171469878,
-0.0033671332,
0.0563006029,
0.0399208926,
-0.0131247537,
0.0155949388,
0.0341617167,
-0.0422597602,
0.0529443733,
0.0391109176,
0.0337650925,
0.004220326,
0.0334115326,
-0.0249432158,
-0.038857948,
-0.0004973458,
0.0644570813,
0.0076939114,
0.0147881974,
-0.0400561616,
0.0177275632,
0.0872827768,
-0.0436340794,
-0.0116826566,
-0.0290064588,
-0.0183584522,
0.0344330706,
0.0112947877,
0.0400233716,
-0.0139639238,
-0.0228962637,
-0.0040493021,
-0.0327242017,
0.0288423859,
-0.0213510264,
0.0029808453,
-0.037352629,
0.0435512811,
0.0104442174,
0.0089934692,
-0.0331748649,
-0.0466520451,
0.0211119857,
-0.0137453433,
-0.0219870154,
0.0022139121,
2.914e-7,
-0.0667288899,
-0.0599794537,
-0.0022724988,
-0.0358336195,
0.0514033325,
0.0153055806,
-0.0444538407,
0.0267523825,
-0.023393292,
-0.0156554151,
0.0201542675,
0.0333438739,
0.0684430078,
0.0460217707,
-0.0836911723,
-0.0134176789,
-0.0025699781,
0.0328640863,
-0.0206343271,
-0.0393128954,
0.0350634456,
0.0380278192,
0.0383423604,
-0.0142401503,
0.0518758893,
-0.0251400135,
0.0113153551,
0.0238673054,
0.0662975535,
-0.0383419804,
0.0352593064,
-0.0399924107,
-0.0209440924,
0.0519754663,
-0.0362007283,
0.010185509,
-0.0143115027,
0.0564071126,
0.0187408905,
-0.0147699732,
-0.0472731777,
0.0553134792,
-0.0067943451,
-0.0214862153,
0.0930224136,
-0.0152709596,
-0.0199089944,
-0.005091635,
-0.0378624238,
-0.0234468523,
-0.0128850946,
0.0333671309,
0.0530527756,
-0.0385445617,
-0.0282462686,
-0.0152443461,
-0.0213939939,
-0.0715004206,
-0.0227121636,
0.0471063368,
-0.0449013375,
-0.0535398014,
-0.0405544937,
-0.0504310764,
0.0255854446,
-0.0424067751,
-0.0304637104,
2.249627109e-34,
0.0156298,
-0.0251868963,
0.0052410513,
0.0033202961,
-0.0558003448,
-0.0518404134,
-0.0254968982,
-0.0320289247,
0.0414688475,
0.0167959053,
-0.027575057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02764v1 | List-aware Reranking-Truncation Joint Model for Search and Retrieval-augmented Generation | 2024-02-05T06:52:53 | 2024-02-05T06:52:53 | Shicheng Xu, Liang Pang, Jun Xu, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | The results of information retrieval (IR) are usually presented in the form
of a ranked list of candidate documents, such as web search for humans and
retrieval-augmented generation for large language models (LLMs). List-aware
retrieval aims to capture the list-level contextual features to return a better
list, mainly including reranking and truncation. Reranking finely re-scores the
documents in the list. Truncation dynamically determines the cut-off point of
the ranked list to achieve the trade-off between overall relevance and avoiding
misinformation from irrelevant documents. Previous studies treat them as two
separate tasks and model them separately. However, the separation is not
optimal. First, it is hard to share the contextual information of the ranking
list between the two tasks. Second, the separate pipeline usually meets the
error accumulation problem, where the small error from the reranking stage can
largely affect the truncation stage. To solve these problems, we propose a
Reranking-Truncation joint model (GenRT) that can perform the two tasks
concurrently. GenRT integrates reranking and truncation via generative paradigm
based on encoder-decoder architecture. We also design the novel loss functions
for joint optimization to make the model learn both tasks. Sharing parameters
by the joint model is conducive to making full use of the common modeling
information of the two tasks. Besides, the two tasks are performed concurrently
and co-optimized to solve the error accumulation problem between separate
stages. Experiments on public learning-to-rank benchmarks and open-domain Q\&A
tasks show that our method achieves SOTA performance on both reranking and
truncation tasks for web search and retrieval-augmented LLMs. | [
0.0335975178,
0.0100358557,
0.0098467544,
0.0308780111,
0.0370549895,
0.0014255249,
-0.0296384636,
0.0035741914,
0.0079329005,
-0.0502521135,
-0.0396475047,
-0.0404616445,
-0.0348202065,
-0.0206422079,
0.0069241724,
-0.0341485776,
0.0311108511,
0.0144994017,
-0.0017760074,
-0.0215745438,
-0.0172904525,
0.0079121795,
0.0493425094,
0.0129804062,
0.058363568,
0.0046339622,
0.0031919898,
0.0405513793,
0.0195471533,
-0.0346683003,
0.0101962043,
0.0238248482,
0.0375194587,
0.019542696,
0.0000019255,
-0.0464312434,
-0.0462870747,
-0.0041151429,
-0.0135230431,
-0.0096174208,
0.012044508,
-0.0006970675,
0.0085485056,
0.0344981365,
-0.0091134431,
0.007861481,
0.010807354,
0.0040195384,
0.0678278804,
0.0758077353,
0.0309616178,
-0.0160573609,
0.0165271703,
-0.0841086507,
0.0182587728,
-0.0531871021,
0.0147012938,
-0.0263622068,
-0.0111345379,
0.0480182394,
0.0008183122,
0.0168288965,
0.0041093705,
-0.0182172861,
0.0412335694,
0.0083903531,
-0.056095928,
-0.0084140673,
0.0191594735,
0.0651184693,
-0.0403769538,
-0.0261357017,
0.0317412727,
0.0142082851,
0.0254814532,
-0.0084216315,
-0.0459084362,
0.0316875577,
-0.0079900874,
0.0317694321,
-0.0165922139,
0.0181626361,
0.0230791178,
0.0039829607,
-0.0035430214,
0.0528607406,
0.018591186,
-0.0340534113,
-0.0457841903,
0.0233909432,
-0.0134009188,
0.0090295728,
0.0367557183,
0.0286083072,
-0.034060888,
0.0095008872,
-0.0300731137,
-0.0478446633,
0.0180834886,
-0.0380254276,
-0.003513963,
0.0081265112,
0.0190578606,
0.0361647122,
-0.0313771926,
0.050147742,
0.0260151327,
-0.0167034976,
-0.0695988014,
-0.0193275902,
-0.0025684487,
-0.0469901003,
-0.002562853,
0.0430353358,
-0.0402906314,
-0.0064841229,
-0.0608419143,
0.0132935904,
-0.0288891848,
-0.0009790703,
0.0283777285,
0.0212890469,
-0.070326373,
-0.00692013,
-0.0329865478,
0.0212608036,
0.0031055214,
-0.0036217575,
0.0297163259,
0.00413692,
0.0018839393,
0.0023271868,
0.0192952696,
-0.0138035892,
-0.0158029962,
0.0311830714,
-0.0281725265,
-0.011548778,
-0.0168649219,
-0.0400607698,
0.0193827618,
-0.0340506099,
0.0148835862,
-0.044254344,
0.0467183478,
-0.0232063476,
-0.005158518,
-0.0493678078,
-0.0002262964,
0.0411131606,
0.0011895788,
0.0346181504,
0.0381113589,
-0.0129635418,
0.0645219013,
0.0216456633,
0.0491227694,
0.0545990951,
0.0135420412,
0.0576690324,
0.0445628464,
0.0240527801,
0.0001211771,
-0.0029940347,
0.0490323752,
-0.0041895527,
-0.0027820542,
-0.0101924855,
-0.0248471107,
0.0424170792,
0.0778435469,
0.0633286908,
-0.0674088374,
-0.0109443674,
0.02855625,
-0.0192227308,
0.0718836561,
0.0423929542,
0.0357349887,
0.0063386741,
-0.0323418714,
0.0341370516,
-0.0130887572,
0.0250295997,
-0.023197826,
0.0008506126,
0.051592961,
0.0338105001,
-0.0469088629,
-0.0330110714,
0.0129911536,
-0.0003118326,
-0.0254120063,
0.0003642323,
0.0432031378,
0.0352494381,
-0.0485213548,
0.0512513146,
-0.0004220171,
-0.0563839078,
0.0608796291,
-0.0535258539,
-0.0043135192,
0.0876494199,
0.0719810575,
-0.0518790707,
-0.0026513045,
0.0179994404,
-0.0558674484,
0.0035642942,
0.0101366183,
-0.0298730098,
-0.0304855015,
-0.0475313365,
-0.0495283119,
-0.0142106963,
-0.0002089972,
0.0277113952,
0.0108346185,
0.0300284699,
0.07423345,
-0.0591110885,
0.0084184716,
0.0036593827,
-0.036084976,
-0.0162226968,
0.0153185306,
-0.0070496849,
-0.0097810188,
0.0109660663,
0.0162439812,
0.021347031,
0.0425345972,
-0.0060778842,
-0.0360428542,
-0.0514809862,
-0.0260466598,
-0.0554217771,
0.0179101769,
-0.0468528345,
0.0688535795,
0.0976690128,
-0.0513739586,
-0.0407280326,
-0.0037842155,
-0.0278978553,
0.0069166799,
-0.0619826056,
0.0231737103,
0.0280657485,
0.0017393935,
-0.0424103141,
0.0835219398,
-0.0210027732,
0.0239193309,
0.0369986072,
-0.0404494964,
-0.0544578545,
-0.1014561281,
-0.0536666177,
0.0261873174,
-0.004853039,
0.012274812,
0.0615733042,
0.0020859505,
-0.0270865187,
-0.0094835171,
-0.0883677974,
0.007147572,
-0.0125063686,
0.0173370242,
0.0106791537,
0.0088574588,
0.0216168724,
-0.0266900379,
-0.0329808183,
-0.0141952448,
-0.0021827254,
0.0207609553,
0.0142428111,
0.0125842346,
0.0097173201,
-0.0169290882,
-0.0478575081,
0.0371608585,
0.0335466526,
-0.0208953824,
-0.0007544946,
-0.0664984062,
0.0563756563,
-0.0662346333,
0.0200816579,
-0.0181202088,
0.0246451199,
-0.0259853117,
0.0056078229,
0.0260179304,
0.0441650338,
0.0346836671,
0.0561730824,
0.0450503454,
0.0176595189,
-0.0657990053,
0.0063660098,
-0.052827917,
-0.0043030446,
0.0062374873,
-0.0171167385,
-0.0057809739,
0.0082984185,
-0.0209644102,
0.0050616642,
-0.0330874063,
-0.0020668621,
0.0122870849,
-0.0440734811,
-0.0732685849,
-0.0228576306,
-0.0114439242,
-0.0034654506,
-0.0134879658,
-0.0259816069,
0.0380602814,
-0.0066739805,
0.0291341878,
-0.0290350579,
0.0256519616,
-0.0352140218,
0.0224899389,
0.0234555937,
0.0297995564,
-0.0177031197,
-0.0269187968,
-0.0609029979,
0.0689744353,
0.0498913191,
-0.080841288,
0.0046728016,
-0.0335718989,
0.0136733735,
-0.011152057,
-0.0643268898,
-0.0281731803,
0.0130392257,
0.0461503267,
0.0198300388,
0.0204228833,
-0.009533382,
-0.0168369245,
-0.0015938825,
0.0275170952,
0.0679153204,
-0.0113935359,
-0.0092949858,
-0.0036619257,
0.0754821599,
0.0581420772,
-0.0178181492,
0.0116675906,
-0.0139296651,
0.0078575034,
0.0515765063,
0.0480170324,
-0.0381542854,
0.0395761952,
-0.0297399648,
0.0660575032,
-0.0271313135,
-0.0642592385,
0.0110654449,
-0.0005775774,
-0.0267593786,
-0.0388479643,
0.068053551,
0.0300348476,
-0.0621888265,
-0.0169189889,
-0.0087970588,
0.0428602472,
0.0174827091,
0.0519181676,
-0.0463521443,
0.0172641613,
0.0339531898,
0.0674415678,
-0.0014622409,
0.0009291842,
-0.0134677179,
-0.1465355605,
0.0601977333,
-0.0021240173,
0.0190250389,
-0.0045729498,
-0.0477413759,
-0.0074409307,
-0.0126843043,
-0.0030341307,
0.0608153082,
-0.0275795236,
0.0195480529,
0.0349195227,
-0.00475968,
-0.0738048851,
-0.0310647376,
-0.0040727765,
0.0210648198,
0.0601681434,
0.0381937772,
0.0339381732,
-0.0157797672,
0.0090592327,
-0.0380200148,
-0.0020003568,
-0.0161300004,
0.0245253518,
-0.0266193412,
0.0408149213,
-0.0234404095,
0.0182816051,
0.0048466837,
0.0094273128,
-0.0387583822,
0.041175779,
-0.0315814279,
0.0040851389,
-0.0139013315,
-0.0445651524,
-0.0102352742,
0.0626839921,
-0.0054873307,
0.0157226659,
-0.0169420298,
-0.0277986564,
0.0434903689,
-0.039670255,
-0.0103884721,
-0.0009114055,
-0.024644658,
-0.0183316246,
-0.0977765471,
-0.0273357425,
-0.0399874933,
0.0117424512,
-0.0407177508,
0.0226349104,
-0.029614469,
0.0035678288,
-0.029875407,
-0.0306350887,
-0.0139985653,
-0.0256756395,
-0.0300253704,
0.0223932713,
0.0258225147,
-0.0542890579,
-0.0392185673,
-0.00531646,
-0.0324688368,
-0.0403665826,
-0.0441983379,
0.0701453537,
0.0221355949,
0.0560903065,
-0.009136416,
-0.0673109293,
0.0515733436,
0.0655498803,
-0.0221604221,
0.0213937778,
0.002203051,
-0.0085880235,
-0.0326642841,
0.029686965,
-0.0880786553,
0.0093117002,
-0.0398920104,
0.057349775,
0.0004820329,
-0.0184881613,
0.0221407767,
0.0307496861,
0.0209480394,
-0.0503234938,
-0.0037936205,
-0.0485015102,
0.0395932458,
-0.0479720011,
-0.0199633073,
-0.0424380787,
0.0485074259,
0.0397011973,
0.0013515602,
0.0075028851,
0.0358678624,
0.0273810402,
0.0314057358,
-0.1064287871,
-0.0219243411,
-0.0049500656,
-0.0151813002,
0.0034956902,
0.0091442494,
-0.0123934755,
-0.0072046802,
0.0303545222,
0.0534486473,
-0.0454267226,
-0.0057107951,
0.0219451338,
0.011696714,
-0.0213213544,
0.0453861468,
-0.0552123897,
-0.0359965451,
-0.1126832291,
0.0059997276,
0.0425243266,
0.0456378721,
0.0528843254,
0.0218856782,
-0.0146739893,
-0.0323691331,
-0.0135118915,
0.0226317067,
-0.0535482019,
0.0036795796,
0.0201828592,
0.0076967496,
-0.0000626662,
0.1219941378,
0.011959061,
0.0058467626,
-0.061158821,
-0.046672605,
-0.0340990126,
-0.0396252126,
-0.0086867819,
0.0337817222,
-0.0183921698,
-0.0256944876,
-0.0014846681,
-0.0390072241,
0.0248798821,
-0.0065386142,
0.0243768208,
-0.0322239548,
0.0668096244,
0.0615937226,
-0.0478690267,
0.0004975172,
-0.0566843227,
-0.0215359461,
-0.025153771,
-0.0099107334,
0.0042818044,
-6.212697764e-33,
-0.0376389921,
-0.0079587717,
0.0253536217,
-0.0365721844,
-0.0490771942,
0.0178262312,
-0.0199493002,
-0.0391452163,
0.0181837697,
-0.0205907319,
0.0095304297,
0.0203385018,
0.0124952057,
0.0351935551,
-0.0201926883,
-0.0049209748,
0.063131392,
-0.0078138774,
-0.0440201573,
0.0443206392,
0.0665299669,
0.0455137528,
0.0033793387,
-0.0103930086,
-0.00779601,
-0.0260744169,
-0.0231303815,
0.0045902389,
0.0233273394,
0.0495643988,
-0.0035110784,
0.0577842966,
0.0291250572,
-0.0912728086,
0.0087126084,
0.0169494711,
-0.0870857984,
-0.017510049,
-0.0315757655,
-0.0359547585,
-0.032676857,
-0.0003376795,
0.017728366,
0.0268979762,
-0.0076367608,
-0.0124270422,
0.0359732024,
-0.0193668678,
-0.0447965413,
-0.0846845508,
-0.0282654185,
0.0177967492,
0.0084574036,
-0.0294873696,
0.0141337356,
0.0991644338,
0.0075135282,
0.0505235977,
-0.0618305355,
0.0299412459,
-0.029569855,
0.0874250457,
0.0605633669,
0.0014997262,
-0.0357857943,
0.0444833934,
-0.0126519725,
-0.0035910881,
-0.0012053364,
-0.0362344086,
-0.0147444261,
0.0196437631,
0.005114432,
0.0459471345,
0.0182257853,
0.0100632478,
-0.062689811,
0.0752837136,
-0.0174113829,
0.0351421423,
0.0224751811,
0.0533467606,
-0.0015868971,
-0.0298237149,
-0.0172598045,
0.0055019329,
-0.0298863072,
-0.0106617538,
0.0305097625,
0.0804659426,
-0.0433482714,
-0.018966781,
0.0276937801,
-0.011784873,
-0.020712126,
0.0458393395,
-0.0135078235,
-0.0069957739,
-0.0015601272,
0.0108889015,
-0.0271702223,
-0.0053662099,
0.0491673425,
-0.0197657328,
-0.0489153862,
-0.0011455381,
0.0171546154,
0.0202669203,
-0.0230790153,
0.022460619,
-0.0366971232,
0.012806478,
-0.0150183113,
0.0238008033,
0.0011079848,
0.0041421656,
-0.0145251658,
0.0404276922,
0.0489226542,
0.0413705818,
-0.0321059301,
-0.0311929993,
0.0236612558,
0.0000600114,
-0.0055313283,
0.0424468778,
-0.0051250271,
0.0512578599,
0.0155870728,
-0.0593406372,
-0.0284227282,
0.0215397794,
2.733e-7,
0.0343117751,
-0.0077266069,
0.0163936187,
-0.0075379093,
0.0231303945,
-0.0008641095,
0.0382744446,
0.0735063851,
0.0537923835,
0.0069421311,
0.0344565995,
-0.0092318412,
0.0203545392,
0.0055482103,
-0.06923794,
0.0121418238,
-0.0748904347,
-0.0158822313,
0.0045455825,
-0.0641008765,
0.0163807459,
0.053818021,
-0.0132515533,
-0.0052300706,
-0.0110989213,
-0.0069747935,
0.0855199769,
0.0080559328,
0.0090096602,
-0.0020274865,
0.0663937181,
0.0080871973,
-0.0028604078,
-0.0161220208,
-0.045313295,
0.0190851428,
0.0609172955,
0.0132300369,
-0.005715338,
-0.0325597636,
0.0413284861,
0.0132811051,
-0.0090221716,
-0.0522262827,
0.063348718,
-0.0254580062,
0.0307796504,
0.0294834673,
-0.0608881824,
-0.0063019972,
-0.0291381776,
-0.0341154858,
-0.0180472415,
0.0113900704,
0.0101221353,
0.0601726882,
-0.0001389852,
-0.0762552023,
-0.0067757866,
-0.0257220212,
-0.0629414991,
-0.0478720143,
-0.0386040211,
-0.0211351179,
-0.021506222,
-0.0583456308,
-0.0072041107,
2.448272568e-34,
0.0457961522,
0.0187390298,
-0.0296693314,
0.0032830352,
0.0154722109,
0.0102271074,
-0.0508543402,
0.0397838466,
0.0037029143,
-0.0519854128,
-0.0536319278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06147v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06147v2 | DeAL: Decoding-time Alignment for Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T06:12:29 | 2024-02-21T02:25:32 | James Y. Huang, Sailik Sengupta, Daniele Bonadiman, Yi-an Lai, Arshit Gupta, Nikolaos Pappas, Saab Mansour, Katrin Kirchhoff, Dan Roth | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are nowadays expected to generate content
aligned with human preferences. Current work focuses on alignment at model
training time, through techniques such as Reinforcement Learning with Human
Feedback (RLHF). However, it is unclear if such methods are an effective choice
to teach alignment objectives to the model. First, the inability to incorporate
multiple, custom rewards and reliance on a model developer's view of universal
and static principles are key limitations. Second, the residual gaps in model
training and the reliability of such approaches are also questionable (e.g.
susceptibility to jail-breaking even after safety training). To address these,
we propose DeAL, a framework that allows the user to customize reward functions
and enables Decoding-time Alignment of LLMs (DeAL). At its core, we view
decoding as a heuristic-guided search process and facilitate the use of a wide
variety of alignment objectives. Our experiments with programmatic constraints
such as keyword and length constraints (studied widely in the pre-LLM era) and
abstract objectives such as harmlessness and helpfulness (proposed in the
post-LLM era) show that we can DeAL with fine-grained trade-offs, improve
adherence to alignment objectives, and address residual gaps in LLMs. Lastly,
while DeAL can be effectively paired with RLHF and prompting techniques, its
generality makes decoding slower, an optimization we leave for future work. | [
0.0404649228,
0.0946116224,
-0.0015985032,
0.0174719431,
-0.0253046416,
0.0059521468,
-0.0628418699,
-0.0110078631,
-0.0347200707,
0.0114895273,
-0.0321835764,
-0.0266519785,
0.0128051164,
-0.0061699897,
-0.0064323409,
-0.0687887892,
0.0628130361,
-0.0405870341,
0.0056399717,
0.0017120587,
0.029993359,
0.0092487643,
-0.0072726607,
0.0443149097,
0.0145183513,
-0.0242630579,
-0.0319717005,
0.0135397781,
0.0182626229,
-0.0362274013,
0.0135587724,
0.0457693636,
0.01175455,
0.0580096208,
0.0000020499,
-0.0522882789,
-0.0179007333,
-0.0045465953,
-0.036375545,
0.0326892585,
0.0361652188,
-0.0403364487,
-0.0408861525,
0.0103049027,
-0.0364951789,
0.0098296814,
0.0878283232,
0.016518645,
0.052756235,
0.0609971173,
0.0071188984,
0.0068195737,
0.0088950414,
-0.012933542,
0.0011803234,
-0.0509812348,
-0.0069357688,
-0.0012702683,
0.0299592335,
0.0015281579,
-0.0364125669,
0.0421919152,
0.0059765936,
0.0005785355,
0.0184187572,
0.0349994488,
-0.0088437935,
-0.0397043303,
-0.0385635011,
0.0455082916,
0.0043466249,
-0.0436291434,
-0.0136776734,
-0.0164815579,
0.0031078127,
-0.0098500559,
-0.0096546439,
0.0213649124,
-0.0007926569,
0.0379131176,
0.0463197939,
-0.0126322005,
0.0459568873,
0.0095321154,
-0.0058554965,
0.0570579208,
0.0239420161,
-0.0590018965,
0.0089069046,
0.0237905998,
0.0004364375,
-0.0577227473,
-0.0158862919,
0.0223379284,
-0.0567841493,
0.0312177595,
-0.066540055,
-0.0022380236,
0.0201693457,
-0.0441019274,
0.0134623386,
0.0678395629,
0.0239826441,
0.0153773008,
0.0216476675,
0.0461328402,
-0.0300496705,
0.0224057678,
-0.0445875302,
0.0267078374,
-0.0094005903,
-0.0278952233,
-0.0288978256,
-0.0062299883,
0.0032147435,
-0.0138533749,
-0.041908972,
0.0572106615,
0.0127141485,
0.0490299053,
0.0195048042,
-0.0064328425,
-0.0565537512,
-0.0002583255,
-0.0129052531,
0.0337060802,
-0.0481675342,
-0.0116321286,
0.0103650037,
-0.0120517164,
-0.0203285832,
-0.0043622106,
-0.0254570693,
-0.0379330441,
-0.0146193635,
0.0629346445,
-0.0299785994,
-0.0038978255,
-0.016184438,
-0.0134271448,
-0.0268772598,
-0.0302416515,
-0.0313490331,
-0.0690653175,
-0.0055289436,
0.0042446372,
-0.015450893,
-0.0727516562,
0.0068956162,
-0.0017158745,
-0.0190472323,
0.0747520179,
-0.0092206923,
0.0245917402,
0.0022469284,
-0.0093664071,
0.00718696,
0.0871954411,
0.0354445726,
0.0472651385,
0.0300756823,
-0.0131206168,
0.0011817222,
0.0757216662,
0.0190429725,
0.0329314061,
-0.0140846977,
-0.0147946579,
0.0492737591,
0.0604954325,
0.0508668609,
0.0332495533,
-0.0136751337,
0.0199331269,
0.0687318966,
0.0484267734,
0.0196167938,
0.001632282,
0.0089658238,
0.0201774314,
-0.0291291047,
0.0132817291,
-0.0528795607,
0.0104613211,
-0.0439390764,
0.0379883721,
0.0028928977,
0.0288665388,
0.0000648107,
-0.0276370142,
-0.017272979,
0.0075580147,
0.044859264,
0.0313707814,
0.0452461466,
0.0128836343,
-0.042050954,
0.0452137925,
0.0416145213,
-0.033868853,
0.0195665564,
-0.01896061,
0.0387514569,
0.0854817852,
0.0676059201,
0.0039825854,
-0.0236705039,
0.0132122198,
-0.0260992758,
0.0658195838,
0.0662682354,
-0.0130468514,
-0.0075788116,
-0.0499514304,
-0.041377537,
0.0140883019,
-0.0084109176,
0.0112723755,
0.0523480251,
-0.0073188455,
-0.0270330273,
0.0079945717,
-0.0672547296,
0.0398764648,
-0.0224828124,
-0.0535111837,
-0.0377747416,
0.021786835,
0.0088991113,
0.0075438889,
-0.006316144,
0.0012968739,
0.0349382348,
0.0045555132,
0.0343983695,
0.0215385426,
-0.0552176982,
0.0024601989,
0.0494186543,
-0.0058427225,
-0.0226748269,
0.0382244736,
-0.0136002181,
-0.0060139652,
0.0146868434,
-0.0356517993,
0.0521722995,
0.0032262017,
0.050664451,
-0.0154801803,
-0.0329812765,
-0.0645292923,
0.036405161,
0.0033524435,
-0.0045351502,
0.0044801664,
-0.0239513665,
-0.0078404313,
-0.0329144746,
-0.0223187581,
0.0471905731,
-0.0060194423,
0.03692884,
0.0600704215,
0.0452165455,
-0.020194469,
-0.0337596312,
-0.0564099625,
0.0110751558,
-0.0199825745,
0.0285785478,
0.0263883751,
0.0216796082,
-0.022631973,
-0.0123070339,
-0.0397470258,
-0.0255375616,
0.0011917485,
-0.0020475297,
0.0277983658,
0.01456495,
-0.0422716998,
-0.0514061414,
-0.0007760654,
-0.0102347024,
-0.0025654938,
0.0016852346,
-0.0112011991,
-0.0846385434,
0.0414165705,
-0.0060370471,
0.0268931314,
0.0007096705,
-0.053098429,
0.034121111,
0.0002709782,
0.0263997279,
0.0758789927,
0.0088130813,
0.0510887727,
0.0577570535,
0.0070128883,
-0.1010227725,
0.012608706,
-0.0361548439,
-0.0810308382,
-0.0509705395,
-0.0437518246,
0.0154245012,
0.1081624478,
-0.0118533364,
0.0263393484,
-0.0966892019,
0.0017912736,
-0.0266619604,
-0.0488284193,
-0.0240153614,
-0.0269330274,
-0.0388352834,
0.029143773,
-0.030848857,
-0.0812081844,
0.0916084573,
-0.0317035206,
0.0017609788,
-0.0340235122,
-0.0107459929,
-0.0286369417,
0.0571136586,
-0.0321720056,
0.0389143489,
0.0167175252,
-0.0500157885,
-0.0487145856,
-0.0094043957,
0.0456985794,
-0.0315003693,
0.0460493639,
-0.0548576526,
-0.0075678774,
-0.0209163204,
-0.0651342422,
-0.0520426594,
-0.036893446,
-0.0211240239,
-0.0378518477,
0.0397918895,
-0.0415668041,
-0.008709575,
-0.0170266107,
0.0256302673,
0.0058035394,
-0.0090609062,
0.0010389239,
-0.0212055389,
-0.021028867,
0.0801372528,
0.0061476026,
-0.0020814263,
-0.0574356578,
-0.0002003318,
0.0302305948,
0.0343780965,
-0.0013728163,
-0.0056408211,
0.0167247914,
0.0919517204,
-0.0286248755,
0.0069205356,
0.0456430465,
0.058088012,
-0.0387484729,
-0.0294136554,
0.092554532,
0.0533199161,
-0.0503818318,
0.0303125046,
-0.0500383154,
0.0859195068,
0.0121363718,
0.0450985543,
-0.0738469586,
-0.0305537377,
0.0162216295,
0.0530379936,
0.0022436529,
0.021590909,
-0.0164327305,
-0.1181139499,
-0.006713287,
0.0491567552,
-0.0513551682,
-0.0202783141,
0.0015900368,
-0.0270888042,
-0.0162141807,
0.0354241654,
0.0310648382,
-0.0137384292,
-0.0132857952,
0.0287106391,
0.0142773995,
-0.0480565205,
-0.0151338903,
-0.0583805479,
0.1015887707,
0.0930733308,
-0.0056079081,
0.0058813281,
-0.038063556,
-0.0177524276,
0.0480600111,
-0.0106183011,
-0.0010777103,
-0.0098800585,
-0.0325419754,
-0.0051028109,
-0.0161407962,
0.0376914777,
-0.0014323273,
-0.018942738,
0.0091480445,
0.0738500655,
-0.0020741615,
0.0181774609,
-0.0165221002,
-0.0092519568,
0.0246899314,
0.0699708685,
0.0101393256,
-0.063578248,
-0.0122038983,
-0.0421591848,
-0.0285242219,
-0.0457637422,
-0.0480002314,
0.0128462482,
-0.017808795,
-0.0160803404,
-0.0641711876,
-0.0620413721,
0.0063784011,
0.0241365992,
0.0454579815,
-0.0077892668,
-0.0088668605,
-0.0084202951,
-0.0474694222,
0.0283309277,
-0.030819146,
0.0167743973,
-0.0926107839,
-0.0095813619,
-0.0345558785,
-0.0652578995,
0.0229814555,
0.0150710633,
-0.0515245236,
-0.0917947665,
0.0008919962,
0.0355973467,
0.0239551384,
0.0891680047,
-0.0128890751,
-0.0732055977,
0.0001021592,
0.031834092,
-0.0402233154,
0.0032468487,
0.0256267805,
-0.0161433574,
0.0137987472,
0.0222365726,
-0.0564534105,
-0.0280124992,
0.0209285729,
0.0495372228,
-0.0185355712,
-0.0116408858,
0.0613003485,
0.018418096,
0.0065894024,
-0.0547003001,
-0.0221918412,
-0.0228837989,
0.0010191061,
-0.0165278167,
-0.03648993,
-0.0066608945,
-0.0068769259,
0.0489901043,
-0.0125825228,
0.0160294306,
0.0034020082,
-0.0078494465,
0.0277062431,
-0.0253530331,
0.0059888512,
-0.0062798103,
0.0174780414,
0.0561935455,
0.031202713,
-0.0143736023,
0.0372431055,
-0.0139621906,
0.0499434732,
0.0039732829,
0.0676416606,
0.0369332433,
-0.0014164629,
-0.013341927,
0.015465457,
-0.0210718699,
-0.0286281202,
-0.0326013826,
-0.0107589848,
0.055921495,
0.0009379416,
0.0669689178,
-0.0430279337,
0.0006258109,
0.0024721839,
0.0109257093,
-0.025678385,
-0.0438143052,
0.0156185245,
0.0314493589,
-0.0234995056,
-0.0324425884,
0.0555777214,
-0.010139537,
0.0287043732,
-0.0330292024,
-0.0007996021,
-0.0285899714,
-0.0278591383,
0.0457846485,
0.004780388,
-0.065756917,
-0.0090371734,
-0.0673781335,
-0.0508904308,
-0.0464482084,
0.0558099486,
-0.0267428216,
-0.0116000343,
0.0299459733,
0.02947166,
-0.0423873328,
-0.0214539748,
-0.0367919244,
-0.0099346228,
-0.0081474502,
-0.0268846713,
-0.0415728651,
-6.224668704e-33,
-0.0306496881,
-0.0020796647,
0.0352843255,
-0.0117905252,
-0.0389977619,
-0.0304374732,
-0.0168186016,
0.0250077099,
0.0149669005,
-0.0102025177,
-0.0232422072,
-0.024574643,
0.0110392617,
-0.0085761873,
0.0314824693,
-0.0029804136,
0.0327638239,
0.0041491357,
-0.0789299384,
-0.0101188524,
0.0069886697,
-0.0023602434,
0.0548828468,
-0.0212618895,
0.0513472818,
0.0131949,
-0.0387341306,
0.0277331322,
-0.0108867045,
0.0691570044,
-0.0146349594,
0.0122508183,
-0.0176578555,
-0.0264799148,
-0.0284030084,
0.0287345611,
-0.0520264842,
-0.0094882073,
0.0587830655,
0.0326942317,
-0.0404230431,
-0.0605427772,
0.0267235599,
-0.0200217385,
-0.0561373979,
0.0193466395,
0.0129007632,
-0.0108935675,
-0.0348389819,
-0.0011501277,
-0.0801190883,
0.0111833569,
-0.0194309037,
-0.0249521025,
0.032251738,
0.0085343895,
-0.0053880764,
0.0069681555,
-0.0208124705,
0.0483999178,
0.0529918075,
0.0313396379,
0.1213657036,
0.0360782817,
-0.002909614,
0.0521254689,
-0.0277640279,
-0.0244071893,
0.0001123855,
-0.0112213027,
0.045184318,
-0.0049341195,
0.0174661484,
0.052549988,
0.0447207689,
-0.0074098436,
0.0056964834,
0.0230141189,
-0.0099815754,
0.0364246815,
0.0253659729,
0.0492241234,
-0.0870286077,
-0.0229917299,
-0.045903407,
0.0257547908,
-0.0208681654,
-0.0500735752,
0.0491546765,
0.0214502122,
-0.0365529396,
-0.0265616216,
0.0129170148,
-0.0358617716,
0.0048934598,
0.0246977285,
-0.0181759056,
0.0145770749,
-0.0261544995,
0.0090491697,
-0.0559150577,
0.0021470839,
0.0097957859,
-0.0306901056,
0.0252114497,
0.043871209,
0.0125006046,
0.0475755148,
-0.0580189303,
0.0212238673,
-0.0385676064,
0.0216620564,
0.0077872057,
-0.0402833,
0.0788362324,
-0.0124976123,
-0.0225510914,
0.0270434991,
0.0363981277,
-0.0086033177,
-0.0541253053,
-0.006324592,
-0.0007768257,
0.0065380824,
-0.0043441956,
0.0072110575,
-0.0162797235,
0.027233243,
0.0402685031,
-0.0426949412,
-0.0130796777,
0.0088996822,
2.758e-7,
0.0172926504,
0.0567139536,
0.0487633049,
0.0417834185,
-0.0199395977,
0.0404783562,
-0.0194198918,
0.0366318636,
-0.0046531181,
0.0081854761,
0.0273416061,
0.0229854062,
0.0562486947,
0.0223115608,
-0.0644300729,
0.0108080544,
-0.0615109168,
0.0348974206,
-0.0538314134,
-0.0203469936,
0.0435340703,
0.07871788,
0.0161393005,
0.0146388523,
0.0209013838,
-0.0019505065,
0.0402485207,
-0.053740155,
-0.0112689808,
0.0216837637,
-0.0225525293,
-0.0042039235,
-0.0216500498,
-0.0267909542,
-0.0080976328,
0.0097424416,
-0.0205050856,
0.0618180074,
-0.022265194,
-0.0266847815,
-0.0362616777,
-0.0062275864,
-0.0110659618,
-0.0601577424,
0.0078491112,
-0.0263512675,
-0.0124589242,
-0.0267409943,
0.0023218549,
-0.0162844397,
-0.0216166396,
-0.0404574797,
-0.00152367,
0.0134148076,
0.0278716385,
0.0269942954,
-0.031945698,
-0.0455643684,
-0.0447469354,
0.0237308796,
-0.0005337142,
-0.0380157046,
-0.0348933004,
0.0298172981,
-0.0135480789,
-0.0904374644,
0.0096850917,
2.632248454e-34,
0.0152488807,
-0.0341693982,
0.0377349518,
0.0365828276,
0.028343223,
0.0070311441,
0.0114083262,
0.0301312562,
0.0614326298,
-0.0477429554,
-0.0218159985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05127v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05127v1 | Illuminate: A novel approach for depression detection with explainable analysis and proactive therapy using prompt engineering | 2024-02-05T06:08:06 | 2024-02-05T06:08:06 | Aryan Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper introduces a novel paradigm for depression detection and treatment
using advanced Large Language Models (LLMs): Generative Pre-trained Transformer
4 (GPT-4), Llama 2 chat, and Gemini. These LLMs are fine-tuned with specialized
prompts to diagnose, explain, and suggest therapeutic interventions for
depression. A unique few-shot prompting method enhances the models' ability to
analyze and explain depressive symptoms based on the DSM-5 criteria. In the
interaction phase, the models engage in empathetic dialogue management, drawing
from resources like PsychDB and a Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) Guide,
fostering supportive interactions with individuals experiencing major
depressive disorders. Additionally, the research introduces the Illuminate
Database, enriched with various CBT modules, aiding in personalized therapy
recommendations. The study evaluates LLM performance using metrics such as F1
scores, Precision, Recall, Cosine similarity, and Recall-Oriented Understudy
for Gisting Evaluation (ROUGE) across different test sets, demonstrating their
effectiveness. This comprehensive approach blends cutting-edge AI with
established psychological methods, offering new possibilities in mental health
care and showcasing the potential of LLMs in revolutionizing depression
diagnosis and treatment strategies. | [
0.0512456335,
0.022214897,
-0.0336206593,
-0.0033353504,
0.011946775,
0.027951153,
0.0301018003,
0.0058511905,
0.0660738572,
-0.0161729474,
-0.0166408345,
-0.0173171852,
-0.0274347663,
0.0583824329,
-0.0139439348,
-0.0794052705,
-0.0019577616,
0.0339497738,
0.0345894955,
0.0128184715,
0.0036019336,
0.0105703669,
-0.0424036011,
0.0449134484,
-0.0045534545,
-0.0331411622,
0.0040058508,
-0.0052196439,
0.0184877627,
-0.0788478106,
-0.0050995946,
0.0728907436,
-0.0101472195,
0.0020713715,
0.0000024376,
-0.0430849344,
-0.0269738752,
-0.0194814242,
-0.0115246801,
-0.055065807,
0.0116241639,
-0.0292789768,
0.0287306868,
0.0334246494,
-0.0277792253,
-0.0387271866,
0.0258979928,
0.0861447826,
0.0942356363,
0.0716140941,
-0.0326503851,
-0.0247219317,
0.0329458527,
-0.0253650956,
-0.0066324743,
-0.0070845424,
0.050158307,
0.0276203863,
0.0294862986,
0.0000934129,
-0.0207915623,
0.0050027776,
-0.0250715576,
-0.0001450618,
0.0076167905,
-0.0077920365,
0.0200849157,
-0.045322828,
-0.0113282818,
0.0775212869,
0.0571934171,
0.0137239099,
0.0142239733,
-0.0162826329,
0.0098799048,
-0.0262300689,
-0.0326001942,
0.0022196311,
0.0032668218,
0.0173505843,
0.0207878426,
0.0182871744,
0.0052838475,
-0.0367088243,
0.0059859278,
0.0260040294,
-0.0028283361,
-0.0224350467,
-0.0054977313,
-0.0209967662,
-0.04939612,
-0.0592708439,
0.0158538446,
0.057196714,
-0.0798022896,
-0.0015042943,
-0.0077155605,
-0.0505928397,
0.0105487676,
0.0382839851,
-0.0089310035,
0.0730176941,
-0.0572721623,
-0.008008589,
0.0313729271,
0.0722607225,
0.0403216481,
-0.0165189207,
-0.0445987247,
0.0066776616,
-0.0662684515,
0.0007506122,
-0.0523277968,
0.0142665347,
-0.0142316017,
-0.0441537648,
-0.0773521364,
0.0314193405,
-0.0126788467,
-0.0094273547,
0.0269313436,
-0.0026693635,
0.0194747057,
0.0256063361,
-0.0110744545,
0.0377882682,
-0.0468856283,
-0.0147957699,
0.0356673859,
-0.0687413961,
0.020598216,
-0.0068230396,
-0.0263578687,
-0.030911712,
0.0153121101,
0.0340962186,
0.0160541479,
-0.0415638797,
-0.0410299897,
-0.025584653,
-0.0204671491,
-0.0404397026,
-0.0023541118,
-0.0168678537,
0.0023763946,
0.0089755598,
0.0465624705,
-0.048362609,
0.0226028319,
-0.0242388044,
-0.0090135289,
0.0754460916,
-0.060287904,
0.0126823895,
0.0445281677,
0.0439408273,
-0.0027473222,
0.043395333,
-0.0122355428,
0.0422854237,
0.0129117696,
-0.0586741492,
0.0549255162,
-0.0119493036,
-0.0073507112,
-0.0484173819,
0.0346686505,
-0.0330286175,
-0.0390589982,
0.0691312775,
-0.012850157,
0.0327815823,
-0.0140262069,
0.0324362442,
0.0715428889,
0.0751700848,
0.0308099985,
0.0855138451,
0.0164000466,
0.0155198295,
0.0030524083,
-0.0267806705,
-0.035868369,
0.0311166514,
-0.0434228629,
-0.0333321244,
0.0135011766,
0.0055557247,
-0.0280671604,
-0.0641597137,
-0.0160058215,
-0.0383694097,
-0.018292781,
0.0197720919,
-0.007533059,
-0.0319202319,
-0.0223289896,
0.0413024686,
0.0334794298,
0.0096040452,
-0.0816695541,
-0.0770534053,
0.0390408598,
0.1024525538,
0.0140541876,
-0.0481590033,
-0.030877823,
-0.0003026839,
0.0078666452,
0.0074397824,
0.0117743118,
0.0052116578,
0.0099016139,
-0.0231615119,
-0.0040896311,
0.0019351572,
0.0135276783,
0.0008878256,
-0.0227434691,
0.0188073087,
-0.021640908,
0.0326808244,
-0.0029797179,
0.0422250703,
-0.0137417112,
-0.0337662585,
0.0143090012,
-0.0130513264,
0.0405517444,
0.0195377171,
0.0101895062,
0.0079023559,
0.0260842498,
-0.0167179946,
-0.0485327505,
0.0237039141,
-0.0247816797,
-0.029874647,
0.0004460213,
0.007766705,
0.0137522873,
0.0348165259,
-0.0276982859,
-0.0440519191,
0.0259857327,
-0.0521689169,
0.0412524864,
-0.0304482244,
0.0251121093,
-0.0108057326,
0.0501250438,
-0.0282050073,
0.0336074755,
-0.0031425289,
0.0118436087,
0.0111550689,
-0.0329422578,
-0.0235434137,
-0.0316680185,
-0.0398566984,
-0.0081971837,
0.0002204217,
-0.0077165589,
-0.044538226,
0.0167752728,
-0.033180628,
-0.0116374698,
-0.1380699426,
0.0367150791,
-0.0065103988,
-0.015873732,
0.0084463209,
0.0088200225,
-0.0300226565,
-0.0178319626,
-0.0347927026,
0.0424607471,
0.0676157996,
0.0027468307,
0.0311646461,
0.0447309576,
-0.0295281913,
-0.042891115,
-0.0033447689,
-0.0197621882,
0.035672605,
-0.0177493002,
-0.0145626785,
-0.0453016609,
0.0060558752,
-0.0272262078,
0.0094654458,
-0.0244139098,
-0.0451684631,
-0.0000192535,
-0.0021077055,
0.0581020378,
0.0422473811,
0.0024902711,
0.0565423258,
0.0020608692,
0.0188201889,
-0.0334671289,
0.0141498391,
-0.0198517591,
-0.0474505052,
-0.0341760293,
-0.0474792719,
0.0001474385,
0.072943978,
0.0139547437,
0.0069306805,
-0.0527604967,
-0.0239355471,
0.0238748975,
0.0340286829,
-0.00515807,
-0.0022448187,
0.0022838484,
0.0236366335,
0.0072684437,
-0.0603472367,
0.0728167742,
-0.0129801342,
-0.0341861136,
-0.0415120386,
-0.0468530506,
-0.0247604139,
0.0193717089,
0.0033716082,
0.0129633592,
0.0423520692,
-0.0290318076,
0.0200406816,
-0.0186739974,
-0.0119077461,
-0.0214106813,
0.0332792141,
-0.0456037261,
-0.0153881107,
0.042644944,
-0.0219722297,
-0.0496273562,
-0.0441274457,
-0.0495468304,
0.0011941402,
0.044557713,
0.0172267668,
-0.02305994,
0.0029186714,
0.0177780725,
0.0333529897,
-0.0098737031,
-0.0428232215,
0.0098959869,
-0.0112587772,
0.0364420451,
0.0032152645,
0.050641641,
-0.0199387409,
0.0774253756,
0.0154724196,
-0.0603307486,
0.0126520041,
-0.0195571594,
0.0296413749,
-0.0190694239,
-0.0026546442,
-0.0176002234,
0.0246870108,
0.0045036776,
-0.0006439163,
-0.0204865243,
0.149498269,
0.0194317196,
-0.0621237345,
0.0247875303,
-0.0425845645,
-0.0373656116,
0.0040885909,
-0.0059340685,
-0.0677743256,
-0.0317994989,
-0.0485197976,
0.0458903089,
-0.0240907855,
-0.0160570424,
0.0197091233,
-0.0455717817,
0.037026763,
-0.0375998989,
0.0327587537,
0.011259377,
-0.0297789667,
0.0041373945,
-0.0039100647,
-0.0142799616,
-0.0213410016,
-0.0008831017,
-0.0074719004,
0.0099467272,
-0.0548013076,
-0.0452155024,
0.0538950451,
0.0042333142,
0.0687377006,
0.0440737754,
0.053344056,
0.0132747944,
-0.0217662286,
-0.0316591524,
0.0453192703,
0.0152608603,
-0.0005691873,
0.0611495636,
0.014423918,
0.0027001216,
-0.0395784713,
0.0547162108,
-0.0495194383,
-0.0143190511,
0.0131080681,
0.0870680511,
-0.0447966717,
-0.0146972379,
-0.0018536858,
0.0377457775,
0.0401075371,
0.0563604869,
0.0358634368,
-0.0344621502,
-0.0053535048,
0.0314340554,
0.025835393,
0.0211781487,
-0.0232675951,
-0.0008827485,
-0.0208401512,
-0.0226279963,
-0.0853130147,
-0.0455097109,
0.0500893258,
-0.0112596164,
-0.0198144708,
-0.0374965928,
-0.0447698757,
0.0476504155,
-0.0240804311,
0.053457059,
0.0318566337,
0.0103949923,
-0.0599926487,
-0.0081052575,
0.0348811746,
-0.0635114685,
-0.0190143399,
0.0161878932,
-0.0445417538,
0.0018322215,
0.0316934846,
0.036242485,
0.0200961195,
-0.0149114216,
0.0196636189,
-0.0550559796,
0.0034694462,
0.012519056,
-0.0015127009,
0.0006930172,
0.0062851449,
0.0486360416,
-0.0005477879,
0.032332994,
-0.0016525687,
0.0832843184,
0.0258084722,
-0.0152241215,
-0.006053722,
-0.0318675674,
0.0179402232,
0.0359465405,
0.0422231629,
-0.0077098953,
-0.0514927842,
-0.0110664926,
-0.0346522406,
-0.0228891298,
0.0042827362,
-0.0504305139,
-0.0058251838,
0.0246211812,
-0.0080861747,
-0.0058752806,
-0.053781651,
-0.0508330911,
-0.0400010459,
-0.058298219,
0.0163166411,
-0.0138264643,
-0.0047881212,
0.0013185317,
0.02147948,
-0.006321657,
0.0090560196,
0.0052933032,
0.0268395077,
-0.0159911048,
0.1390785724,
0.0041948585,
0.0070385169,
0.0270274077,
0.0678312853,
-0.0307346676,
-0.0948624164,
-0.0242675021,
0.0331330337,
0.0548878945,
0.0506130233,
0.0551291592,
-0.0260875635,
0.0244798064,
-0.0068730656,
0.0251444783,
-0.0085693784,
-0.0355673917,
-0.0029162851,
-0.0078250449,
-0.0177272893,
-0.0315038003,
0.0611556806,
-0.048673667,
0.0164935887,
0.02393841,
-0.0163043775,
-0.0388693735,
0.0142775513,
0.0330384485,
0.0323926359,
-0.0389108136,
-0.0254369751,
-0.0321073197,
-0.0428545251,
0.0197473131,
-0.0295989737,
-0.0444923565,
-0.0340738669,
0.0386481732,
0.0363083482,
0.008826335,
-0.0180709697,
-0.0379913226,
0.0310597681,
-0.0470280051,
0.0022773207,
-0.051692225,
-6.272630343e-33,
-0.0183357503,
-0.0075823432,
0.0129296985,
-0.018976219,
-0.0153071666,
0.002804274,
-0.0528142713,
0.030551834,
0.0088716382,
0.036445085,
0.0168175865,
0.0720367953,
-0.0046137418,
0.028648762,
0.0020682293,
0.0049342806,
0.0173331965,
-0.0022960817,
-0.0327992626,
0.0494403988,
0.0012583745,
0.0817041174,
0.0399111845,
-0.0488480665,
0.0037133882,
0.011078082,
-0.0255497843,
0.0293844491,
0.0157394595,
0.0398938321,
-0.0575309843,
0.0472543873,
0.0523748361,
-0.0225556884,
0.0189323165,
0.0047723195,
-0.0483032614,
-0.0357206091,
0.0217968449,
-0.024139706,
-0.0203890223,
0.004248606,
0.0064428994,
-0.0369827747,
0.0027556887,
-0.0002598805,
0.0340880118,
-0.0522775091,
0.0413742065,
-0.02872812,
-0.0270204414,
-0.0107866507,
-0.03922607,
-0.0270793959,
-0.0367079154,
0.0368202366,
-0.0358313546,
0.0644235089,
-0.0095645702,
0.0135263316,
0.0119953835,
-0.0129187386,
0.0126389079,
-0.0360511206,
-0.0109150251,
0.0403244123,
0.015928911,
-0.0228290427,
-0.0306261089,
0.012099891,
-0.0204251949,
0.0445707105,
0.0718341395,
0.0243557468,
0.0129685234,
-0.0123118339,
-0.0554160029,
0.0301069114,
0.0000405298,
-0.0119634802,
0.0205105301,
0.0106676947,
-0.0297182258,
-0.0238576066,
-0.0204293765,
0.0195113905,
-0.0293250941,
-0.0578217432,
0.0174330845,
-0.0008519998,
-0.0106394589,
-0.0151814288,
0.008674142,
-0.0481156148,
0.033380717,
-0.0053887297,
-0.0068114297,
0.0417651609,
-0.020055823,
-0.0100224009,
-0.0093045868,
-0.0264788587,
0.0261976011,
0.0051675588,
0.0707345232,
0.0107891019,
0.0150492871,
-0.0274428297,
-0.027190065,
-0.0033183976,
0.0022851338,
0.0406774916,
-0.0092353765,
0.0180349927,
-0.061956685,
0.0222316515,
-0.0273110233,
0.042916134,
0.0273031425,
0.0218343213,
-0.0827312842,
-0.0313756503,
0.0090977075,
-0.0016416569,
-0.0170936659,
-0.0340395458,
-0.0304303914,
0.006004903,
0.0582926609,
-0.0555025339,
-0.0100696394,
-0.0030427426,
3.141e-7,
0.0287954435,
0.0609673746,
-0.0183808636,
-0.0054592732,
0.0329092741,
0.0152164362,
0.0109131662,
0.0314604752,
0.0637459755,
-0.0106615657,
0.0452592149,
0.027568927,
0.0389338098,
0.0441982225,
-0.0225257128,
-0.0333447009,
-0.0295866895,
-0.0789581761,
-0.0705621541,
0.0209109113,
0.0915629864,
0.0755070969,
0.0119478432,
-0.0177428965,
0.0448988676,
0.005780492,
0.0407914557,
-0.0579242669,
0.023251012,
0.0738279,
0.0654392913,
-0.0090165026,
0.0121503342,
0.0023449464,
0.0038370988,
-0.0026811825,
-0.0259392131,
0.0619752668,
-0.0387993529,
-0.0166847631,
0.0054966039,
0.0371758603,
0.0005990092,
-0.0453694351,
0.0485542603,
-0.1159409434,
-0.0566205308,
-0.0071297949,
-0.0280993562,
-0.0973680988,
0.0372519828,
-0.0461753942,
-0.0083504822,
0.0461622812,
-0.0014286434,
0.0073402259,
0.0328432433,
-0.0599854402,
-0.003346394,
0.0305561367,
-0.0760559589,
-0.0229742806,
-0.0322300047,
-0.0550064631,
-0.0001377049,
-0.0618179254,
0.0426606722,
2.865084957e-34,
0.0198256895,
0.0485871956,
0.0331812799,
0.0361882895,
0.0481919609,
0.0355498046,
0.006876572,
0.0246275272,
0.0174713135,
-0.1139945537,
-0.0187879354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02750v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02750v1 | KIVI: A Tuning-Free Asymmetric 2bit Quantization for KV Cache | 2024-02-05T06:06:47 | 2024-02-05T06:06:47 | Zirui Liu, Jiayi Yuan, Hongye Jin, Shaochen Zhong, Zhaozhuo Xu, Vladimir Braverman, Beidi Chen, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PF | Efficiently serving large language models (LLMs) requires batching many
requests together to reduce the cost per request. Yet, the key-value (KV)
cache, which stores attention keys and values to avoid re-computations,
significantly increases memory demands and becomes the new bottleneck in speed
and memory usage. This memory demand increases with larger batch sizes and
longer context lengths. Additionally, the inference speed is limited by the
size of KV cache, as the GPU's SRAM must load the entire KV cache from the main
GPU memory for each token generated, causing the computational core to be idle
during this process. A straightforward and effective solution to reduce KV
cache size is quantization, which decreases the total bytes taken by KV cache.
However, there is a lack of in-depth studies that explore the element
distribution of KV cache to understand the hardness and limitation of KV cache
quantization. To fill the gap, we conducted a comprehensive study on the
element distribution in KV cache of popular LLMs. Our findings indicate that
the key cache should be quantized per-channel, i.e., group elements along the
channel dimension and quantize them together. In contrast, the value cache
should be quantized per-token. From this analysis, we developed a tuning-free
2bit KV cache quantization algorithm, named KIVI. With the hardware-friendly
implementation, KIVI can enable Llama (Llama-2), Falcon, and Mistral models to
maintain almost the same quality while using $\mathbf{2.6\times}$ less peak
memory usage (including the model weight). This reduction in memory usage
enables up to $\mathbf{4\times}$ larger batch size, bringing
$\mathbf{2.35\times \sim 3.47\times}$ throughput on real LLM inference
workload. The source code is available at https://github.com/jy-yuan/KIVI. | [
0.0178663805,
0.0158020686,
-0.0135455513,
0.0527969971,
-0.0226341337,
0.0095841046,
0.0048622373,
0.0021214851,
0.0203568488,
-0.0481772088,
-0.0237258431,
-0.0578372069,
0.0132641103,
0.0148044359,
0.0139289219,
-0.0186076984,
0.0706813633,
-0.0522788949,
0.0282985941,
-0.0284033604,
-0.0187408868,
-0.0005078813,
0.02365884,
-0.000664249,
-0.0013432698,
-0.02041509,
-0.0292898826,
0.006124496,
0.0094312225,
-0.0052258507,
0.0016067483,
0.0373952202,
-0.0097649405,
0.0051090312,
0.0000024156,
-0.0161334425,
-0.0053939079,
0.0019186817,
-0.0356663913,
0.0814570189,
0.0460536331,
0.0093554575,
-0.0583765134,
0.00891372,
0.0097316988,
0.0131364083,
0.0736497417,
-0.060096439,
0.0340772681,
0.0241336115,
-0.0066270377,
-0.0251393039,
0.0138575202,
-0.0072516962,
0.0140456446,
-0.0601982884,
0.0102269901,
-0.0241574328,
-0.034017168,
-0.0110490955,
-0.0243905,
0.0567387342,
0.0191150215,
-0.0011857955,
0.0235492382,
0.0331998356,
-0.1055814996,
-0.0031654683,
-0.0126335062,
0.0137324594,
-0.0456371717,
-0.0572921894,
0.0148689654,
0.0068471986,
-0.0638365597,
-0.0521443412,
-0.0170303956,
0.0356615372,
-0.0293579157,
-0.0094988868,
0.036034666,
-0.0231453236,
0.0326127969,
-0.0089423545,
-0.0332927369,
0.0157620143,
0.0510701574,
-0.0017363005,
-0.0539886169,
-0.0219014119,
-0.0350543447,
-0.075946711,
0.002768538,
0.0203570537,
0.0058528981,
0.017206125,
-0.0399459526,
-0.0197187811,
0.0047734343,
-0.0914760828,
0.0351906195,
0.07414563,
0.0048711738,
0.0200546905,
-0.0262010768,
0.0553796589,
-0.0166632477,
0.0233442672,
-0.05441048,
0.0013636489,
0.0162451603,
-0.0244499333,
-0.0339468382,
0.0046116444,
-0.0035304136,
-0.0036882288,
-0.0226323623,
0.0043081772,
0.0163085721,
-0.0172903519,
0.0267641973,
0.0201330706,
0.0027894892,
0.044267036,
0.0074673565,
0.0343419127,
-0.0191693623,
-0.0421359092,
-0.0191791635,
-0.081439741,
-0.0110824704,
0.0138696413,
0.0159906503,
-0.034326043,
0.0166611802,
0.0291176382,
0.0050260015,
-0.0486889444,
-0.0190179162,
0.0111967856,
0.0038473818,
-0.0718916282,
0.0100243762,
-0.0486956276,
0.0107575664,
0.0217875149,
-0.0097892974,
0.0341828875,
-0.0003864227,
0.0301419999,
-0.0295442864,
0.0095360791,
0.0143350037,
-0.0036446168,
0.0184291825,
0.0000451279,
0.0534930006,
0.0727816224,
0.0456541516,
0.0324873663,
0.0173992552,
-0.0287063234,
-0.0407908335,
0.0226685312,
0.0315920822,
0.0103265531,
-0.0393136293,
-0.0074602058,
0.0314486101,
0.0354375429,
0.0494950302,
0.076848954,
-0.0477188379,
-0.0449008793,
0.0155616356,
0.0406435765,
0.0144577734,
0.0021134398,
-0.0136301666,
0.0040291869,
0.0410549305,
-0.0312268157,
-0.0259644613,
0.0846765712,
0.028195044,
0.0105950972,
0.0827384964,
0.0433168374,
-0.0272644311,
-0.0270851087,
-0.0476249009,
0.0036731169,
0.0008458613,
-0.0072348299,
0.0403569825,
-0.015782902,
-0.0337758586,
0.0863923356,
0.034194462,
-0.0652802587,
-0.0395801291,
-0.0552363992,
0.0181332547,
0.0855819732,
0.05364535,
0.0520054437,
-0.0356882922,
0.0714270771,
-0.0442324914,
-0.0132355187,
0.0079781255,
0.0163863301,
0.0027107939,
-0.0676420555,
-0.0194251239,
-0.0277174767,
-0.0073378189,
0.026192043,
0.0409480557,
0.0260247309,
0.0020393482,
-0.0225964673,
0.0137481922,
-0.0212688129,
0.0171288606,
-0.0153981419,
0.0132446121,
-0.0078324135,
0.0006154731,
-0.0007141378,
0.0048421132,
0.0081689432,
0.0384311192,
-0.0305168685,
0.0632639304,
-0.0263223685,
-0.029256681,
-0.0057645375,
0.0456293374,
0.0526843853,
0.0697835088,
0.0078594554,
-0.0386006534,
-0.0420744866,
0.0579666384,
0.0030955437,
0.0599187501,
-0.0121669648,
0.016688386,
0.0007789135,
0.0458862446,
0.0050308765,
0.0313587338,
-0.0364783667,
0.0170603171,
-0.0324816741,
0.0363713875,
0.0049595339,
-0.0181968082,
-0.0138668632,
0.0147316922,
0.0106851002,
0.0482723974,
-0.0147584071,
-0.0268612169,
-0.0066492204,
0.0198655836,
-0.1116969585,
0.0014696041,
-0.0211341456,
0.0444450676,
0.0098433876,
0.0175455939,
0.0009811661,
0.0018702142,
-0.0057829162,
-0.0174075887,
-0.0108162537,
0.0274055284,
-0.0321487524,
-0.0274339896,
-0.0385269113,
-0.0284330547,
-0.0551092625,
0.0014863083,
0.0533977672,
-0.0588352717,
-0.0691482872,
-0.0251726918,
0.0494077951,
-0.026173478,
0.0214225519,
-0.0268584006,
-0.0437593795,
0.012331469,
-0.0190779604,
0.0317434743,
0.0509589277,
0.0127738137,
-0.0183323771,
0.0407788567,
-0.0422968306,
-0.0394600742,
0.003928957,
0.0268090926,
-0.0610136352,
0.0241611917,
-0.0040848241,
-0.0110103702,
0.0895546153,
-0.0387494154,
-0.0283974595,
-0.0166262742,
-0.0117156571,
0.0033151007,
-0.0090539735,
-0.039195884,
0.0165337529,
-0.0189014412,
0.0413884781,
-0.0133786155,
-0.0462882631,
0.0054087993,
-0.0593012795,
-0.0019041506,
-0.0296155196,
0.0051652766,
-0.0228201561,
0.0132091418,
-0.0071466696,
0.0405082814,
-0.0508732274,
0.0084256316,
-0.0085348887,
-0.0247576814,
-0.0177290272,
-0.0530352406,
0.0217314996,
-0.0065079033,
0.0197045021,
-0.0413462706,
0.011260842,
-0.0233638156,
0.0733013526,
0.0009400106,
-0.0197282676,
0.0305397213,
-0.0398721397,
0.0421987809,
0.0740067512,
-0.0234676357,
0.0491868705,
-0.0242793523,
0.0018893732,
-0.0118316086,
0.0090093482,
0.0143783707,
0.0059000142,
0.0212028157,
0.0036169644,
-0.0078456784,
0.0896133035,
0.0541333817,
0.0346162319,
-0.0357631706,
0.0149990711,
0.0535540581,
0.0107573848,
-0.0161995403,
0.0071397577,
0.0300703384,
-0.0639638528,
-0.0183748323,
0.0372349769,
0.0298973136,
-0.054489892,
0.0008123424,
-0.0134790316,
0.0265427828,
0.0139274998,
0.044223763,
-0.1231186911,
-0.0001167717,
0.0365862697,
0.0312684588,
0.0026323958,
0.0153815141,
-0.0174822621,
-0.078470692,
0.0288972557,
0.028885141,
-0.0212384071,
-0.0071066846,
-0.0420980304,
-0.0479507446,
-0.0034159212,
0.0451936834,
0.0516945608,
0.0079584438,
-0.0115381507,
0.0075197271,
0.0295151807,
-0.031379614,
0.0511152484,
-0.020070402,
0.0170756597,
0.045544643,
0.0187493414,
0.0227338951,
-0.0342577919,
-0.0064822645,
-0.0190013424,
-0.0027399277,
-0.0207095668,
-0.037459664,
0.001619086,
-0.0235422608,
-0.0207525138,
-0.0245525483,
-0.003175657,
-0.0154812299,
-0.0258307625,
0.0090583758,
-0.0041667204,
-0.0379223228,
0.0000561933,
-0.0594392233,
-0.0311846025,
0.0304287188,
0.0113175288,
0.0206770077,
-0.0582411774,
-0.0387922116,
-0.0021760196,
-0.0350521728,
-0.0404063277,
-0.0116006713,
-0.0032701776,
-0.0558053516,
-0.0213852525,
0.0420092046,
-0.0228395499,
0.028992366,
-0.0272085313,
-0.001593417,
0.0257361904,
-0.0218174364,
-0.1089796275,
0.0241632815,
-0.0694322363,
0.0264048595,
-0.0605199188,
-0.0424266942,
-0.0088243475,
-0.0111716026,
-0.0293751284,
0.0253389478,
-0.1217878163,
-0.0614110269,
0.0163432136,
0.0738848448,
0.0183879547,
0.0574393384,
0.0149997147,
-0.0314962864,
0.0289880093,
0.0548504479,
-0.0575585961,
0.0743550286,
-0.0122652054,
-0.0059448597,
-0.0084525403,
-0.0008889213,
-0.0258476753,
0.00504399,
0.0115271416,
0.0352515653,
0.0008414345,
-0.0116253262,
-0.0468619503,
0.0095743081,
0.0325457193,
0.0058679264,
0.0132110417,
0.0247348491,
0.0631603822,
0.0044226679,
0.0333002172,
-0.0112350164,
-0.0053250445,
-0.0050469637,
-0.0043079439,
-0.0201255232,
-0.0455043949,
0.0620588958,
-0.0461968109,
0.01767065,
-0.0002704253,
-0.0238407627,
0.0243368074,
0.0556935668,
-0.0137071256,
-0.0138953412,
0.0231829621,
-0.0003344835,
0.0543980896,
-0.0510358438,
-0.0217608903,
-0.0123578105,
0.0101654315,
-0.0189379957,
0.0506141596,
-0.021386724,
-0.0463338941,
-0.0286356527,
-0.0166093595,
0.0635338426,
0.0033387232,
0.0216781497,
-0.0012153424,
-0.0074596917,
-0.0297711771,
0.0111802071,
0.0065240166,
-0.0175916627,
0.017980963,
0.028073499,
-0.0045084944,
0.0025058761,
0.0253015533,
0.0051775374,
0.0428741984,
-0.0284032244,
0.0131000523,
-0.0068724761,
-0.0127433483,
-0.0659599379,
0.0287737362,
0.0119443489,
-0.0663720742,
-0.0417388007,
-0.0534540899,
0.0095464345,
0.0081349937,
-0.0147543652,
-0.0284621585,
0.0236976128,
0.0530002452,
0.0285586882,
-0.0257223509,
-0.0176179036,
-0.0103594791,
-0.0368151441,
-0.0120732365,
0.043446172,
-7.225489003e-33,
-0.0265879314,
0.0039707446,
0.0310441256,
-0.0128037585,
-0.0175056811,
0.0259164236,
-0.0440074652,
-0.0547743738,
-0.0217337664,
-0.047508873,
-0.0257873032,
0.011011241,
0.0400850363,
-0.0325488523,
-0.0024947263,
0.0061098756,
0.0383032039,
0.027392989,
-0.0094239553,
0.055259075,
0.0433106422,
0.0203836709,
0.0648302361,
0.0174570046,
-0.041614905,
-0.0251352284,
0.049951829,
-0.0260614548,
-0.036773473,
0.0354036614,
-0.0424229726,
0.0351639874,
-0.0093665896,
-0.025824517,
-0.0131942667,
-0.039934352,
-0.0711831748,
-0.0052610715,
0.0452332571,
0.0411351062,
0.0281786025,
-0.0693075731,
-0.0002625011,
0.0678220615,
-0.0150433006,
-0.0011978262,
-0.0202055909,
0.0049902373,
-0.0666155219,
-0.0416045934,
0.0065395054,
0.0311782975,
0.0351905711,
0.0517800488,
0.0700916424,
-0.0431788042,
-0.0226142816,
0.0142719243,
-0.1096736342,
0.0173649229,
0.034240786,
0.1353051364,
0.0961380377,
0.0442773364,
0.0249026716,
0.0258611869,
0.0785851181,
-0.0086447038,
-0.0193947051,
0.1076912209,
0.0754007772,
-0.0020030721,
-0.0149451988,
-0.0036337033,
0.0921866968,
-0.0456837639,
-0.05180135,
-0.0366289802,
-0.0056987628,
0.0398391262,
0.0212068558,
0.0145761939,
-0.0227479767,
-0.0596382879,
-0.0367672592,
-0.0045377463,
-0.060715694,
-0.0133971665,
0.0302906893,
0.023868233,
-0.0369738415,
-0.0212227665,
0.0343932547,
-0.013563347,
0.0123193003,
0.0296251345,
0.0195523873,
0.0545394793,
-0.0085334126,
0.0497454107,
-0.0306278821,
-0.0514096804,
0.0139500424,
-0.0243093856,
0.0221402217,
0.0076396558,
-0.0255423486,
0.0567477569,
-0.0559028499,
0.0048238412,
-0.0497275442,
-0.0026714215,
0.0030220971,
0.0522476137,
0.0215800367,
0.0182276499,
0.0306750871,
0.0633739233,
-0.0285193771,
0.0138637768,
-0.0070135803,
-0.0074640173,
0.0093677035,
0.0468199328,
-0.0193141811,
0.0266423523,
-0.0687571689,
0.0257419553,
0.02990105,
-0.0449604876,
-0.0385212079,
0.0370422006,
3.18e-7,
0.0201390479,
0.0521746278,
0.0496909879,
0.0054425597,
-0.0151643297,
0.0055395896,
0.021786768,
-0.0066298936,
0.0285492428,
-0.0074370503,
-0.0255826581,
0.0441059843,
0.0131565817,
0.0058461446,
-0.0655990466,
0.0492304564,
-0.067289561,
0.0142855914,
-0.0328619406,
-0.0261257943,
-0.010035946,
0.0924640968,
0.0007050239,
-0.0167225413,
0.0346802883,
0.0307966713,
0.0168825798,
0.0165480096,
-0.0032321282,
0.0310798343,
0.0140698012,
0.0088169239,
-0.0238237251,
-0.0217842963,
0.0008814771,
-0.0167743526,
-0.0699386299,
0.0593572743,
-0.0182192307,
-0.0433030017,
0.0498231351,
-0.0146848736,
-0.0354134962,
-0.0436855964,
0.0760607272,
0.0222470928,
-0.0060282466,
-0.0950723886,
-0.0000299827,
-0.0001622548,
-0.0138385436,
0.0093729673,
0.033691857,
0.0537769981,
0.0024770522,
-0.029196294,
0.0104562948,
-0.0724210069,
-0.0619993135,
-0.0027565663,
-0.0189942289,
-0.0555158705,
-0.0671886057,
0.0089935362,
0.0159119666,
-0.0183100644,
-0.0100947125,
3.166350843e-34,
0.0488250442,
-0.0002965144,
0.0173136853,
0.048354622,
0.010188452,
-0.018352164,
-0.0128111774,
0.0177005026,
-0.0240656789,
-0.0517646112,
-0.0455663055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02716v1 | Understanding the planning of LLM agents: A survey | 2024-02-05T04:25:24 | 2024-02-05T04:25:24 | Xu Huang, Weiwen Liu, Xiaolong Chen, Xingmei Wang, Hao Wang, Defu Lian, Yasheng Wang, Ruiming Tang, Enhong Chen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | As Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown significant intelligence, the
progress to leverage LLMs as planning modules of autonomous agents has
attracted more attention. This survey provides the first systematic view of
LLM-based agents planning, covering recent works aiming to improve planning
ability. We provide a taxonomy of existing works on LLM-Agent planning, which
can be categorized into Task Decomposition, Plan Selection, External Module,
Reflection and Memory. Comprehensive analyses are conducted for each direction,
and further challenges for the field of research are discussed. | [
0.0657249391,
-0.0022231725,
-0.0429051779,
0.0310970005,
-0.063202478,
-0.0200033318,
-0.0063065588,
-0.0009877983,
0.0428767391,
-0.0429677777,
-0.0085328324,
0.0002514706,
-0.025347596,
0.0166639816,
0.0028491835,
-0.0345341377,
0.0198619049,
-0.081276007,
0.0014060307,
0.0011206054,
-0.0250259582,
-0.0237031709,
0.0158364978,
0.0298884492,
0.0150447777,
0.0324999467,
-0.0588293262,
-0.0008704404,
-0.0270645376,
-0.0198053457,
-0.0570120886,
-0.007447022,
0.0097954879,
0.030557489,
0.0000019729,
-0.0503294952,
-0.022903759,
-0.0329281352,
-0.0318223312,
0.0071732048,
0.0428677164,
-0.0004266504,
-0.0096354131,
0.0194912013,
-0.0442891344,
0.0307821203,
0.0009198801,
0.0224229693,
0.0463569462,
0.0761683211,
0.0031644516,
-0.0219955053,
0.0028004611,
0.0271042455,
0.0076728938,
-0.04067396,
0.0069176019,
0.0044066822,
0.0503746569,
0.0383143984,
-0.0120773455,
0.0097660916,
0.0089669116,
-0.0242150705,
-0.0483126119,
0.0275125485,
-0.0158796608,
-0.0232539047,
-0.0202526376,
0.034347102,
0.0118997218,
-0.0178828109,
0.0448746756,
-0.0013916948,
-0.0075760526,
0.0011842427,
-0.0472282954,
0.0530443117,
0.0035107911,
0.0206629205,
0.0337367021,
-0.0295897257,
0.0112547893,
-0.0036783875,
-0.0643398464,
0.0880344063,
0.0199251678,
-0.0238086358,
-0.0263495836,
-0.0348379835,
0.0253447555,
-0.0801638067,
0.0162174087,
0.0933510885,
-0.0477718934,
0.0422578193,
-0.0127833374,
0.0000152013,
-0.0057013412,
-0.0309769176,
0.0437365212,
0.0355770774,
0.0269748662,
0.037210837,
-0.0091119185,
0.0743609816,
-0.0134019796,
0.0393338762,
-0.0323453397,
0.0048238789,
-0.0483595841,
0.0046158424,
-0.0461451896,
0.0529253185,
-0.0310859513,
-0.0093688387,
0.0009538421,
0.0846697986,
0.0318956226,
0.0437967181,
0.020636443,
-0.0339538306,
0.0008533929,
-0.0359945185,
-0.0858208984,
-0.0250799041,
-0.0216167327,
-0.0093637211,
-0.0346742198,
-0.0186857842,
0.0275800005,
0.0309761148,
-0.0093415808,
0.0069732331,
-0.0128677767,
0.1199992448,
0.0192410462,
-0.0415496193,
-0.0355330147,
-0.0319117233,
0.0050941943,
-0.0535236672,
0.0184800345,
-0.0517279841,
0.0198595747,
-0.0153791746,
-0.0243667476,
-0.0157125816,
0.0102882804,
0.0007679461,
-0.0038677568,
0.0371409766,
0.0249878969,
0.0581399798,
0.0153552862,
-0.0053021801,
0.0002474817,
0.0631861687,
0.0552367866,
0.0437464267,
0.01104639,
0.0495227724,
0.026763685,
0.0648698509,
-0.0319615863,
-0.0037046408,
-0.0016416572,
0.0077473726,
0.000664029,
0.0177356843,
-0.0252502244,
0.0631771311,
0.0003956757,
-0.01432232,
0.0329387002,
0.0664049163,
0.0045753149,
-0.0059858179,
0.062537998,
0.0351053588,
-0.0198380034,
0.0066889329,
-0.0227100439,
0.0254983548,
-0.009940899,
0.0038151171,
-0.0370705687,
0.0250471588,
-0.0285129249,
-0.0525132827,
-0.0305427164,
-0.0184029229,
0.0426896103,
-0.0132358642,
0.0475118458,
-0.0104926713,
-0.0669191107,
0.0257815868,
-0.0187196173,
-0.0274297446,
-0.0028933058,
-0.0935431197,
0.0080985595,
0.0669497177,
0.0542918704,
-0.0202935655,
-0.0426088497,
0.0351001658,
-0.0130011328,
0.0532728732,
-0.0059366236,
-0.0293209348,
-0.0242844131,
-0.0499442033,
-0.0227969084,
-0.0001703937,
-0.0192578845,
0.016794363,
-0.0007112603,
-0.0221924074,
-0.0101874098,
0.018049987,
-0.0259003136,
0.0458935462,
-0.0500424914,
-0.0153221553,
-0.0330370069,
-0.0005276544,
0.055046618,
0.0085345237,
-0.0003187091,
0.0263222195,
0.0647488609,
-0.0274387188,
-0.0026179869,
0.0096167335,
-0.0017189167,
-0.0294551812,
0.059212856,
-0.0096316151,
0.028206585,
0.0135406712,
-0.0044197738,
-0.053135477,
0.0477211662,
-0.0418765172,
0.0475258641,
-0.0294810478,
0.0550776757,
-0.0007616153,
-0.0405027829,
-0.027888393,
0.0537863038,
-0.0097551551,
-0.0436581969,
0.0635544956,
0.028956851,
0.0223854166,
-0.0311338324,
-0.0193562806,
0.0392731242,
0.0314832218,
0.0158808921,
0.0239360556,
0.0134596443,
-0.0173875075,
-0.0650323033,
-0.0753913894,
-0.0145109231,
-0.0239622928,
-0.0053142793,
-0.0048086131,
-0.0019794044,
0.0063089491,
0.0033176211,
-0.0083576106,
0.0439345837,
0.031465672,
-0.0132243251,
0.004034692,
0.0059676999,
-0.0745684057,
-0.0360333584,
0.0079463599,
-0.0128272232,
-0.0252389684,
0.0081908349,
-0.0358656608,
-0.071058847,
0.0602284074,
-0.0265954304,
0.0352711342,
-0.0315302424,
-0.0571937822,
0.0107703386,
-0.0604604371,
0.001990264,
0.0405271798,
-0.020557221,
0.0086285956,
0.0835227743,
-0.0434968658,
-0.0476472676,
0.0443726704,
-0.0413155816,
-0.0191413183,
-0.0883649215,
-0.0325810313,
0.0279586092,
0.0629833341,
-0.0250977483,
0.0227481406,
-0.0404217727,
-0.0355131812,
-0.0051654913,
-0.0369168408,
0.0241697021,
-0.0237915292,
-0.0340925381,
0.0790608749,
-0.019795401,
-0.0391263962,
0.0496834069,
-0.0393685065,
-0.0112864543,
-0.0202947147,
-0.0208173543,
-0.071780026,
0.0796869621,
0.010973095,
0.027670607,
-0.0351486057,
0.0120340809,
-0.0228098333,
-0.0216938425,
-0.027467642,
0.0065060752,
0.0609699003,
-0.0647964552,
0.0352352522,
0.006993331,
-0.0276346486,
-0.0355968401,
-0.0139881717,
-0.0370764434,
0.027619062,
-0.0026303076,
-0.024006946,
-0.0411593914,
0.0202310197,
0.0288786665,
0.0271161962,
0.0244564414,
-0.0089323577,
-0.0415964462,
-0.0433301069,
0.0105095394,
0.0413516946,
-0.0111707468,
-0.0086229974,
0.0594804548,
0.0203993339,
0.0606275201,
-0.0138025172,
-0.0001432272,
0.0003557284,
0.0327878855,
-0.0189365596,
-0.0057217316,
0.0354063921,
0.0268380158,
-0.0268440153,
-0.0230674185,
0.1027986258,
0.0431618206,
-0.0224833898,
0.0183005836,
-0.0599946119,
0.0034481932,
0.022853937,
0.0511336923,
-0.0128605226,
-0.0007983613,
0.0068516312,
-0.0302401129,
-0.0270534288,
-0.0367328078,
-0.0211732425,
-0.1058796421,
0.0413902849,
-0.0022564402,
0.0009431539,
0.0178832486,
-0.0350767747,
-0.0095305191,
0.0238840804,
0.0060306815,
0.0031139271,
-0.0022563103,
-0.0428853817,
0.0015878265,
-0.0590276271,
0.0087010525,
-0.0055722771,
-0.0126186665,
0.0644813627,
0.0723307803,
0.0373171829,
0.0100005083,
0.0019470457,
0.0009059654,
0.025976751,
0.0423872024,
-0.019689573,
-0.0091130352,
-0.0008661058,
0.0113599859,
0.0069705304,
-0.0064598955,
-0.0461407304,
-0.0188403949,
0.0384580195,
0.0880799443,
-0.0659783185,
0.0052314913,
-0.0223335382,
0.0151468059,
-0.0244571324,
0.0676843673,
-0.0009057337,
-0.0258914884,
-0.0490035117,
-0.033662755,
-0.0527639091,
-0.0481316522,
-0.0511469319,
0.0171706825,
-0.0296987649,
0.0266084187,
-0.0373309888,
-0.0700053275,
0.0706583336,
0.014018652,
0.0285972822,
0.0153782815,
0.0408675522,
-0.0086685894,
0.0071844263,
-0.0638052747,
-0.0338724442,
0.004756812,
-0.036118675,
-0.0219206493,
0.0370172188,
-0.0568095967,
0.0164262131,
0.0122808767,
-0.0594449192,
-0.0670122579,
0.0353783965,
0.0657095164,
0.0204421803,
0.0216958225,
-0.0146576911,
-0.0341340937,
0.0473103374,
-0.0184546281,
-0.0522764325,
0.0712536201,
-0.0057192957,
0.0536998361,
0.0211685449,
0.0641220063,
-0.058953803,
0.0358190723,
-0.0014320676,
0.0344294384,
-0.0408686772,
-0.0285008028,
0.0012371928,
0.0416753404,
-0.029169336,
-0.0010267545,
-0.0050467262,
0.0089753037,
0.0413115919,
-0.053825222,
-0.0217230227,
-0.0611806959,
0.0203690883,
-0.0119827306,
0.0005720995,
0.0264568627,
0.0033150311,
-0.0288007874,
0.0037398979,
0.0526556745,
0.0197258312,
-0.0155166164,
-0.0242032483,
0.0145611065,
0.0361258015,
0.0037873681,
0.0329322591,
-0.0161390603,
0.0121200848,
0.030321477,
0.0420589224,
0.0059665442,
-0.0185429789,
-0.0549797527,
-0.0151782138,
-0.0680644289,
-0.0946999416,
0.0723068491,
0.0738549158,
0.0422051735,
0.0190789197,
0.043843925,
-0.0753691792,
0.0265789162,
-0.0080658821,
-0.0161896739,
0.0190474037,
-0.0382129662,
0.0225327928,
0.0278630275,
-0.0247115903,
-0.0264453609,
0.0540272519,
0.0196747538,
0.0656243637,
0.0106278658,
-0.013976898,
-0.0577119999,
-0.0321458168,
-0.0073017827,
-0.0031489662,
-0.0163142886,
-0.0116388304,
-0.0760917366,
-0.04595856,
0.004991869,
0.0220731739,
0.002608822,
-0.0512751155,
0.0360844731,
0.0213460866,
0.0246438887,
-0.0225617867,
-0.0444615409,
-0.0234055892,
-0.0340731479,
-0.0350893587,
0.0230209306,
-5.868843626e-33,
-0.0451897904,
-0.0494305082,
0.1005888805,
-0.0270467382,
0.0095379883,
-0.0046770233,
-0.042582307,
-0.004949206,
0.0019659493,
-0.0139364228,
-0.033607129,
0.0135082556,
0.0241216272,
0.0046442896,
0.0198722091,
0.0078879241,
0.0279362649,
-0.0295876265,
-0.0094123771,
-0.0092318943,
0.0282717515,
0.0022358093,
0.006028261,
-0.0146162724,
-0.0202319697,
-0.00288986,
0.0056362227,
0.0452148579,
0.0152651472,
0.0837489814,
-0.0344807208,
0.003073114,
0.0214668363,
0.0102937166,
-0.0456567593,
0.0083874939,
-0.0068323766,
-0.0520817898,
0.0374865718,
0.0098728379,
-0.0301760715,
-0.0443781205,
0.0055576744,
-0.0112268003,
-0.0385690108,
0.0464950986,
0.010075273,
0.0094822561,
-0.0086168256,
0.0583987683,
-0.062497057,
0.015827205,
0.0152417189,
0.007402957,
0.0746528059,
-0.0344432443,
0.0024734824,
-0.0312513784,
0.0044305129,
0.0352519937,
-0.0097518247,
0.0119537264,
0.0443901569,
0.0248518288,
0.0187132657,
0.0640994534,
0.0439138375,
0.0455623679,
-0.0301788654,
-0.0106421448,
0.0068442798,
0.069405131,
-0.0138991857,
0.0190660954,
-0.0563655607,
0.0375732183,
-0.0118482113,
0.0142759532,
0.0505069122,
0.034892004,
0.0645467564,
0.0229201317,
-0.0209351126,
-0.0160816871,
-0.0246741343,
0.031022666,
-0.0080256332,
-0.0421570204,
0.0258453097,
0.0353018641,
0.0210713018,
-0.0394148752,
0.0402125046,
-0.0469826199,
-0.0031247074,
0.0170280002,
-0.0288688913,
0.0461449809,
-0.003467794,
0.0379860923,
-0.0538275167,
-0.0217974707,
-0.0131171029,
-0.0281585753,
-0.0154390829,
0.0226685088,
-0.0677157417,
0.0591845103,
-0.0142129203,
-0.0082399473,
-0.0564748943,
-0.0172122549,
0.0200219378,
-0.0108231213,
0.0305356346,
-0.0012628069,
-0.0183505863,
0.0090946639,
0.0200419538,
-0.0979405865,
0.0145476991,
0.0088647576,
0.0231059268,
0.0201919749,
-0.0287897754,
0.0020105869,
-0.0471200123,
0.0243774205,
0.0266196746,
-0.0331623331,
0.0030211883,
0.0122352615,
2.8e-7,
-0.0010313707,
0.0374278761,
0.0228533503,
0.0447814018,
-0.0002945363,
0.0136553785,
-0.0173078813,
0.0069829407,
-0.0438661985,
0.011414554,
0.0394427925,
0.0609331354,
0.0121426396,
0.0037636375,
-0.0818346888,
0.0269726664,
0.0097338958,
-0.0472949222,
-0.0656457916,
-0.0084443148,
0.0270316359,
0.0763262212,
0.0088314526,
-0.0098879663,
-0.0469583087,
-0.0601904541,
0.0303896423,
-0.0583695024,
-0.0120866103,
0.0324964039,
0.011175802,
0.017060481,
-0.0304557551,
-0.015743779,
0.0441161431,
0.0312569141,
-0.036160402,
0.0899230614,
-0.0013390931,
-0.0365697332,
0.0186687969,
-0.0384547599,
-0.0093125449,
-0.002021913,
0.0370718092,
-0.0002778488,
-0.0298735611,
0.0085277753,
0.0391551852,
0.006216723,
-0.0739061683,
-0.0151331993,
0.0202502534,
0.0339479037,
-0.0101544457,
-0.0401713289,
0.0296699125,
-0.0829840153,
0.0199786406,
-0.0203145165,
-0.0465017706,
-0.0429395996,
-0.038854409,
0.0235916562,
0.0122141317,
-0.0539210029,
-0.0059240744,
2.716044901e-34,
0.0004913828,
0.0124967117,
-0.0201528296,
0.0731967464,
0.0296255462,
0.0186505802,
-0.0370408967,
0.0399932452,
0.0308123063,
-0.1114561483,
-0.0420604721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02695v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02695v2 | Exploiting Class Probabilities for Black-box Sentence-level Attacks | 2024-02-05T03:15:26 | 2024-02-21T00:09:00 | Raha Moraffah, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Sentence-level attacks craft adversarial sentences that are synonymous with
correctly-classified sentences but are misclassified by the text classifiers.
Under the black-box setting, classifiers are only accessible through their
feedback to queried inputs, which is predominately available in the form of
class probabilities. Even though utilizing class probabilities results in
stronger attacks, due to the challenges of using them for sentence-level
attacks, existing attacks use either no feedback or only the class labels.
Overcoming the challenges, we develop a novel algorithm that uses class
probabilities for black-box sentence-level attacks, investigate the
effectiveness of using class probabilities on the attack's success, and examine
the question if it is worthy or practical to use class probabilities by
black-box sentence-level attacks. We conduct extensive evaluations of our
attack comparing with the baselines across various classifiers and benchmark
datasets. | [
0.0413305089,
0.0791409835,
-0.0206213761,
0.0479135327,
-0.0620684735,
0.0218948033,
0.0161186773,
-0.0003799749,
-0.0159097072,
-0.0948949158,
0.0140239559,
-0.0011870983,
0.0359986722,
0.0274009313,
0.0380776115,
-0.0286003631,
0.0164415687,
0.0176064018,
-0.0140021136,
-0.0053295917,
0.0204478484,
-0.0098139066,
0.0019596226,
0.04673554,
-0.0030291108,
-0.0038313773,
0.0016065622,
0.0160461348,
0.031601198,
-0.0129674794,
0.0631967783,
0.0452631786,
-0.0142096058,
0.0761301666,
0.0000014964,
-0.0162845161,
-0.046239242,
0.0007828034,
0.0037717235,
0.0325976945,
-0.0132661005,
-0.0168552417,
0.0178867411,
0.0171634816,
-0.0375082381,
0.0235484783,
0.0158572905,
0.0674998835,
-0.0043640542,
0.1135764495,
-0.0059575811,
-0.0171886012,
0.0219245665,
-0.0324114077,
0.0214420166,
-0.0532064177,
0.0225794446,
-0.0479101166,
-0.0372390375,
0.0258449893,
0.001487445,
0.0317643695,
0.0328307599,
0.0033379786,
-0.0029268388,
0.0238225218,
-0.0393573567,
0.0159615278,
0.0184489191,
0.0349969231,
-0.0254688971,
-0.0009294428,
-0.0265693422,
0.0027968271,
0.0310701132,
-0.0467658006,
0.0008007382,
0.0215389654,
0.0051714336,
0.0363305509,
-0.0207901634,
0.0202425104,
0.0398459993,
0.0172178317,
0.0420985706,
0.0548031107,
0.0189254154,
-0.0405766852,
0.0095165288,
-0.0009154673,
-0.0117359161,
-0.0352856591,
0.0184245538,
0.0035869698,
0.0189296715,
0.0061141509,
-0.0727850795,
-0.0596370585,
0.0457516462,
-0.040221151,
0.0359636098,
-0.0352639817,
-0.0119840717,
0.0306045786,
-0.0028255668,
0.0174441971,
-0.0079233544,
0.0372579098,
-0.0042027142,
0.0291193705,
-0.0388614573,
-0.0293450747,
0.0093603581,
0.0392271355,
-0.0165301524,
0.0026800274,
-0.0630212203,
-0.0154956998,
-0.0280073602,
0.0229098517,
-0.065418005,
0.0319366194,
-0.031970866,
-0.0090061417,
0.0074690301,
-0.0128963105,
0.0224043261,
0.0031866571,
-0.0081407009,
-0.0685033798,
-0.0343283787,
0.0186988451,
-0.0197874717,
-0.0203800797,
0.0015579585,
0.0506635122,
-0.0013288677,
-0.0448949337,
-0.0307540949,
-0.0821152925,
-0.0644721836,
-0.011355117,
-0.0320819318,
-0.0510432348,
-0.0621006899,
-0.0132299112,
-0.0044916035,
-0.0135460952,
0.0130548356,
0.0099367741,
-0.0009765637,
0.0917354822,
0.0467135124,
-0.0758734494,
-0.002588443,
0.0272528287,
0.0387694947,
0.0593422391,
0.0147967422,
0.0261459835,
0.0454839878,
0.0250070486,
0.0558112375,
0.0008188427,
0.0147876386,
0.0052709971,
-0.0184904132,
0.001184481,
0.0285643078,
-0.0026062261,
-0.0324862599,
0.0083633466,
0.001896496,
-0.0324750021,
0.0861941352,
-0.0056294156,
-0.0348615423,
0.002253436,
0.0028915559,
-0.0225925855,
-0.0214148406,
0.0216566436,
-0.0302723236,
-0.0231721494,
-0.0631271601,
-0.0253521111,
0.0148737105,
0.0046769031,
0.0038317714,
-0.0735162795,
0.0023454779,
-0.0023537977,
-0.0011394192,
-0.0062547494,
0.0251161307,
0.0556771643,
-0.0054397862,
0.0313009694,
0.0259647761,
-0.0219777264,
-0.0154461069,
-0.0349924639,
-0.0139671126,
-0.0033263201,
0.0621062219,
-0.0602171607,
0.0492662154,
-0.0305643249,
-0.0150992842,
0.0496750623,
0.0243741143,
0.013933613,
0.0353466682,
-0.018048048,
-0.034254469,
-0.0508968011,
0.0303771757,
0.0436336994,
0.0197823048,
0.0146827307,
0.0185476486,
-0.0255683344,
-0.0224956926,
0.0313526876,
0.083277151,
-0.0552612133,
0.0593804345,
0.0342330448,
0.0290024225,
-0.0196892489,
-0.0468350425,
0.0257895719,
0.018589396,
-0.039580889,
-0.0803861022,
-0.049660299,
0.0242382511,
-0.0624048971,
-0.0009416521,
-0.0401908681,
-0.0184012391,
0.0599852614,
-0.0408628285,
0.0001917654,
0.0085068978,
-0.0458432846,
0.0353612043,
0.0047347452,
-0.0023959621,
-0.0232819598,
0.0641574636,
-0.0636724457,
0.0517169945,
-0.0056433943,
0.0146420132,
-0.0445424803,
-0.0276354644,
0.0138820522,
-0.0319904238,
-0.0234277993,
-0.0239997506,
-0.0361756347,
0.0069435234,
0.0454659909,
-0.0082551297,
-0.0123336222,
-0.0150276078,
-0.0198175143,
-0.0224413686,
-0.0211706776,
0.0233490188,
0.0069824443,
-0.0121969003,
-0.0015621516,
-0.035742797,
-0.0199694261,
-0.011269981,
-0.055547189,
0.0195758864,
0.0428736694,
0.0005945223,
-0.0019555381,
-0.0056837373,
-0.0077327546,
-0.0063925418,
0.0709481761,
0.0003271768,
0.0085701123,
-0.0295213237,
0.0379749797,
-0.0001646559,
0.0281620007,
-0.0065290094,
-0.049015183,
0.0329346359,
0.0156000638,
-0.0242788829,
0.0930810645,
0.0489217751,
0.0312612131,
0.0443018749,
0.0453458466,
-0.0094554406,
0.0041809622,
0.0053505306,
0.0025207414,
-0.0869431347,
-0.0550979152,
0.0284678619,
0.0506298989,
0.0235013627,
-0.0153226405,
-0.0143309496,
0.0082083922,
0.0105536189,
-0.0366253927,
-0.0331286602,
0.0069602998,
-0.0231219642,
-0.0228413548,
-0.0190603435,
-0.0656989664,
0.0762048438,
-0.0280053299,
0.0191371497,
-0.0219467524,
-0.0518648848,
0.0143203791,
0.0587386563,
0.033294525,
-0.0031194494,
0.0222153049,
0.0099879233,
-0.0255843587,
-0.0300069135,
0.0497291163,
0.0076362202,
-0.0000071112,
-0.0043111686,
-0.0133683449,
-0.0204941891,
-0.074180454,
-0.0478389077,
-0.0720689222,
-0.0442618951,
0.0057299132,
-0.0578330271,
-0.0180894732,
-0.0574208237,
-0.0524240099,
0.0015815462,
-0.0147914179,
-0.0716044083,
-0.0285970401,
-0.020818444,
0.0686357021,
0.0609080307,
-0.0610654689,
0.0166818537,
-0.0029683267,
0.0077667204,
0.0936022773,
0.0211285595,
0.0916067958,
-0.0178915076,
-0.0520932861,
0.004070072,
0.0033380408,
-0.0326551013,
0.0019860219,
0.0059882705,
-0.0559593998,
-0.0307565965,
0.0558515228,
0.0029711414,
0.0036856863,
0.0181630887,
0.0412304699,
0.0469314232,
0.0000710332,
-0.0004157962,
-0.0547652207,
-0.0532680862,
0.0101143848,
0.0353096165,
-0.063361451,
-0.0028955732,
-0.0119760688,
-0.1246800423,
-0.008736752,
0.0142197218,
-0.000123964,
-0.040685039,
0.0093341004,
-0.0139039392,
-0.0005144434,
0.002842336,
-0.0158067346,
0.0356871076,
0.0124410074,
0.0169571601,
-0.0223292112,
-0.0246320404,
0.009178618,
0.0050847991,
-0.0079051703,
0.0599254705,
0.0287329238,
-0.0377262272,
0.0091142757,
0.0355463475,
-0.0510350354,
-0.030960964,
0.037403848,
0.0919557586,
-0.0206518304,
-0.0315099508,
0.0105392449,
0.0408171974,
-0.0435190275,
-0.0102320872,
0.0165520739,
0.0051932381,
-0.0186101571,
-0.0447891243,
-0.0386161543,
0.0104357908,
0.0520318858,
0.0573277697,
0.0195704196,
-0.0566198602,
-0.0626640916,
-0.0900021419,
0.0166694429,
-0.0640347227,
-0.0040953471,
0.0316810608,
0.0270507764,
-0.0429566763,
-0.0342237018,
-0.0163582806,
-0.0464186817,
0.0139032761,
-0.0223337207,
0.0091159549,
-0.0393944904,
0.0038997345,
-0.0317115635,
-0.0139160035,
-0.0020379669,
0.0416456945,
-0.0073889527,
-0.0201502386,
0.0106592923,
-0.0233645849,
-0.0186193436,
-0.045665957,
-0.0956392959,
-0.0638723224,
0.0002290261,
0.0256072599,
0.0045070243,
0.0287533961,
-0.0074149566,
-0.0824494213,
0.0911517069,
0.0919020846,
0.0286510661,
0.0179337002,
0.0651634336,
-0.0043217912,
0.0164137874,
0.0629907176,
-0.037923038,
-0.0079950858,
0.0807798281,
-0.0101425201,
-0.0590410121,
0.0168537106,
-0.000735343,
-0.0207284857,
0.0696450099,
0.0034092315,
-0.0016778458,
0.035943456,
0.0483030565,
-0.0097010685,
-0.0434121825,
-0.0020973012,
0.0082002673,
-0.0010506262,
0.0150328744,
-0.011756531,
0.0212344285,
-0.0176494196,
0.0197048616,
-0.0233409442,
-0.0030504183,
0.0845877156,
-0.0052238116,
0.0287991986,
-0.0137634436,
-0.0147261852,
0.0511660241,
0.0298938714,
0.0484736338,
0.0325555727,
0.0130926482,
0.0179827362,
-0.0107438592,
-0.0209544096,
-0.0160150118,
-0.1046632826,
0.0478591546,
0.0022248868,
0.0254851356,
0.003234697,
-0.0043583424,
-0.0219605695,
-0.0407322943,
-0.0345690846,
-0.0074182884,
0.020236548,
0.0137541024,
-0.023685541,
0.0325454175,
0.002762438,
-0.0151244979,
0.0592444018,
0.0580879785,
0.0198014732,
0.0511549935,
0.035386879,
-0.0561805479,
-0.0233629532,
-0.008302995,
0.0529033355,
0.0178757459,
0.0200850386,
-0.0020390658,
-0.0332774445,
-0.0438905396,
0.0451145545,
0.0109099131,
0.0465981327,
-0.0032615012,
-0.0187925007,
0.0472402871,
0.0084599433,
-0.004749523,
-0.0573397167,
0.048253417,
0.0057243141,
-0.0334242471,
-0.0138618434,
-5.244361517e-33,
0.0245484971,
-0.0426920056,
-0.0840730593,
0.0107332869,
0.0471088327,
0.0300534852,
0.0116039068,
-0.0122156451,
0.0079807239,
0.0551481247,
0.0087727187,
0.0365299918,
-0.0144861815,
0.0685983673,
0.0070671127,
-0.0512382649,
0.0138044106,
-0.0160622299,
-0.0363650918,
-0.0004251232,
0.0678556189,
0.0432188772,
0.0346364081,
-0.0316270776,
0.0354379565,
-0.0059849215,
-0.0558728799,
0.0137539143,
-0.0422002114,
0.0481979623,
0.0039570113,
0.0777900517,
0.0197335575,
0.0013461541,
0.0299204346,
0.0458381772,
0.0111404536,
0.0007487889,
-0.080422543,
0.0301356595,
-0.0201915242,
-0.04170724,
0.0446250066,
0.0101318639,
0.0033585248,
-0.0446555875,
0.0280376188,
-0.0295480173,
0.0022280475,
-0.0259178318,
-0.0321999006,
0.0221768413,
-0.0223304015,
-0.0058808704,
-0.0304334331,
-0.0010328034,
0.0331391729,
-0.0027083387,
-0.0107262824,
0.0077402159,
0.0423955098,
0.0223547053,
-0.0018903511,
0.0226883944,
-0.0119215352,
0.0607559234,
0.0458085947,
0.0055747642,
-0.0072726472,
0.0062028659,
-0.0155188264,
-0.0349359699,
0.0735006779,
0.0986488163,
0.0542635992,
0.0027006762,
-0.1038560793,
-0.0037671437,
0.0350432955,
-0.0485651866,
0.0331539474,
-0.0026399989,
-0.0499731451,
-0.0020968525,
-0.0097185988,
-0.068806313,
-0.0030485692,
0.0326157436,
0.0073591871,
0.0209575687,
0.0071385237,
-0.0043921801,
-0.0353215002,
-0.0466329046,
-0.0140534397,
0.0069912216,
-0.0247530825,
-0.0365657099,
0.0198114607,
-0.0045695202,
0.0035985783,
0.0207460243,
0.0360803008,
-0.0346482992,
0.0108866859,
-0.0021107334,
0.0893062577,
0.0040102759,
-0.0837775543,
-0.0165343639,
0.003898886,
0.0216499679,
0.0061633317,
0.0306416955,
0.011447723,
-0.0151795326,
-0.0142280348,
0.0223380234,
0.0152079081,
0.0209274925,
-0.0092613846,
0.0334662609,
-0.036794398,
-0.0034514107,
-0.0201889873,
-0.0300294328,
-0.0039189961,
0.0146247447,
0.030289704,
-0.0653333217,
0.0135281906,
-0.0364861302,
2.295e-7,
0.053027954,
-0.0088169659,
-0.0234377533,
0.0040555759,
0.0524313897,
0.0968034938,
0.0073462105,
0.0717908889,
0.0013963426,
-0.0185665116,
-0.0078782672,
-0.0177833587,
0.0686166137,
0.0008680453,
-0.0699091628,
0.001623848,
-0.0557665341,
-0.0027603779,
-0.0583360158,
-0.0029148292,
0.064022474,
0.1006845087,
0.0579638369,
-0.0288781282,
0.0160103366,
-0.0568974279,
0.0387094729,
0.00593495,
0.0092745069,
0.0181030687,
0.0051342687,
0.0112713259,
0.0103433328,
0.0296487808,
-0.0422164947,
-0.010893086,
-0.0128651466,
0.0273882151,
-0.0071491431,
-0.018142039,
-0.0549468957,
0.0211886559,
0.0017239128,
-0.0256127995,
0.0732003599,
-0.0159855727,
-0.0177404135,
-0.0342645943,
0.0132512851,
-0.0213813875,
0.0663633719,
-0.010865666,
-0.0570386872,
-0.010294647,
-0.0085277259,
0.0093118297,
0.0043596653,
-0.0705505461,
-0.0258767139,
-0.0238643344,
-0.0215062629,
-0.0240014941,
-0.0155823203,
0.0165977478,
0.0261811558,
-0.0412006304,
-0.0174393579,
2.146994744e-34,
0.0025491545,
-0.0256771632,
-0.0174111184,
-0.0118722711,
0.0350281112,
0.0033788832,
0.0147943925,
-0.0261180121,
0.0186802335,
-0.0442853197,
-0.0116986968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05126v1 | Graph Neural Network and NER-Based Text Summarization | 2024-02-05T03:00:44 | 2024-02-05T03:00:44 | Imaad Zaffar Khan, Amaan Aijaz Sheikh, Utkarsh Sinha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | With the abundance of data and information in todays time, it is nearly
impossible for man, or, even machine, to go through all of the data line by
line. What one usually does is to try to skim through the lines and retain the
absolutely important information, that in a more formal term is called
summarization. Text summarization is an important task that aims to compress
lengthy documents or articles into shorter, coherent representations while
preserving the core information and meaning. This project introduces an
innovative approach to text summarization, leveraging the capabilities of Graph
Neural Networks (GNNs) and Named Entity Recognition (NER) systems. GNNs, with
their exceptional ability to capture and process the relational data inherent
in textual information, are adept at understanding the complex structures
within large documents. Meanwhile, NER systems contribute by identifying and
emphasizing key entities, ensuring that the summarization process maintains a
focus on the most critical aspects of the text. By integrating these two
technologies, our method aims to enhances the efficiency of summarization and
also tries to ensures a high degree relevance in the condensed content. This
project, therefore, offers a promising direction for handling the ever
increasing volume of textual data in an information-saturated world. | [
0.0431991369,
-0.0004502081,
0.0287635159,
0.0018403083,
0.0025026461,
0.0144975809,
-0.0580803864,
-0.0157584473,
0.0516722836,
-0.0195800848,
0.0247356165,
0.0317607969,
0.0245566536,
0.0178549346,
0.018311467,
-0.0676251873,
0.0003423825,
0.0322992727,
0.0218396392,
0.0123722749,
0.0168598294,
0.0365362875,
0.039365381,
0.0089391936,
0.0193386581,
0.0262309425,
0.0079065375,
0.0407147259,
0.0273310505,
-0.0431497544,
-0.0323689692,
-0.0149024017,
0.0231755804,
0.0098040216,
0.0000019482,
-0.0434107445,
-0.0537439995,
-0.004699558,
-0.016132243,
-0.0116309207,
0.0612417832,
-0.0442522913,
0.025580449,
-0.0085860556,
-0.012550286,
-0.0160359554,
0.0003914313,
0.0702000856,
0.0673706159,
0.0617820621,
-0.0195286069,
-0.0355045572,
0.0303783007,
-0.0047368179,
-0.0311420914,
-0.02636973,
0.0178775676,
0.0086650671,
0.0166433938,
-0.0247537103,
-0.0274462588,
0.0321893618,
0.00845752,
-0.0241750218,
0.0379643962,
0.0316653512,
-0.0347852781,
0.0511249453,
0.0205097813,
0.0745231733,
-0.0094954232,
-0.0027844645,
0.0639147237,
-0.0049798884,
-0.0197277479,
-0.0027973256,
-0.0565732904,
0.0063047851,
-0.0315538011,
0.0401893891,
-0.0155578637,
-0.0268114153,
0.0081443368,
0.0072754398,
-0.0178714581,
0.0220233258,
-0.019876942,
-0.0065819551,
0.0086631691,
-0.0134321135,
-0.0240331907,
-0.0404442474,
0.0520163625,
0.073386386,
0.0202981904,
-0.0178098548,
-0.0116514992,
-0.0426322035,
0.0008856541,
-0.0526413769,
-0.001686783,
-0.0369436331,
0.0732824653,
0.0447244272,
-0.0349662565,
0.0172415059,
0.0172544494,
0.0151777016,
-0.0265007839,
-0.0068717189,
-0.0391488932,
0.0073248944,
-0.0478671566,
0.0821828619,
-0.0089632561,
-0.0495242551,
-0.0290871859,
0.0138427522,
0.0291712955,
0.0232153833,
0.0209551957,
0.067913413,
0.037120413,
-0.0208707731,
0.0098594595,
0.0218512081,
-0.0093998211,
-0.02114667,
-0.0293397419,
0.0438664742,
0.0199592356,
0.0099775493,
0.0922052786,
0.0256251786,
0.0244017355,
0.04097718,
0.0350251533,
-0.0562505834,
-0.0595417432,
-0.0258989669,
0.0226810146,
-0.0221200399,
-0.0117879612,
-0.0570375957,
-0.0049377033,
-0.0047752173,
-0.0254410207,
-0.0305899978,
0.0227307025,
0.0002430774,
-0.0940423682,
0.0146685597,
-0.063092038,
-0.0064017335,
0.0634411871,
-0.0098351324,
0.0388764255,
0.0036732929,
0.0872968733,
0.0591575019,
0.0560670905,
0.0235841237,
-0.0318057612,
-0.011800142,
0.0258413069,
-0.0181996226,
0.0281659849,
-0.0415275246,
-0.0894139558,
-0.0279404018,
0.0050185649,
0.062095508,
-0.0247469582,
0.0077221254,
0.0569613799,
0.0805452541,
-0.0142315226,
0.0155289769,
0.015606259,
0.041872263,
0.0203952286,
0.0461978354,
-0.0197343212,
0.0091717392,
-0.0350349806,
0.0509435497,
0.0403399952,
0.0030480602,
-0.0144235669,
-0.0230081752,
0.0307595618,
-0.0042669596,
0.0920230895,
-0.0104358383,
0.0405177251,
0.0069817384,
-0.0552072302,
0.0190738533,
0.0060614641,
-0.0412806086,
0.0312544517,
0.0006956197,
-0.0279653259,
0.0494653545,
0.035800755,
-0.0184051022,
-0.0445545726,
-0.0150057161,
-0.037720561,
0.0020347065,
-0.011747648,
-0.0287700072,
-0.0086048227,
-0.0602807961,
-0.020950349,
-0.0215764623,
-0.0113089243,
0.0024063652,
-0.0247878116,
0.0318444297,
0.0400679223,
-0.0226442944,
-0.0771990195,
0.0160107315,
0.0188429467,
-0.0115363095,
0.0025073856,
0.0049053901,
-0.0188060384,
0.0687886998,
0.0033619639,
0.0182218906,
0.0255545974,
-0.0114742862,
-0.0316401273,
-0.0234061833,
-0.0041099028,
-0.0247834828,
0.0086830342,
-0.0581915826,
-0.0109909493,
-0.0046165558,
-0.0232060887,
-0.064375557,
0.0457264259,
-0.0649663359,
0.0041036326,
0.011702056,
0.0039887992,
0.014061721,
0.0207553077,
-0.0028750664,
0.0528648123,
0.004061745,
0.0066178553,
0.0342714414,
-0.026891645,
-0.0192326494,
-0.0500926822,
0.0056873672,
-0.0136213312,
0.0229402781,
-0.0095259193,
0.0560952798,
-0.0020519129,
-0.0329245776,
-0.0006130013,
-0.1133724153,
0.0250833575,
0.0012504295,
0.0411585309,
0.031658601,
0.0194144156,
-0.006312964,
-0.0284971669,
-0.0318246931,
0.0184088126,
0.0159896966,
-0.0315528512,
0.0200116746,
0.0059953141,
-0.0051541678,
-0.0277347863,
-0.0289507639,
-0.0330897421,
0.0561155044,
0.0545222349,
-0.0736308992,
0.0031104928,
0.038118083,
-0.0308872052,
-0.0167635735,
0.0166872274,
0.0319160409,
-0.0276489165,
0.0158582125,
0.0155602153,
0.0588242635,
-0.004146859,
0.0254029948,
0.0084427027,
-0.0181446653,
0.0057539665,
-0.0087949615,
-0.0643677339,
0.077987127,
-0.014961361,
-0.0556092896,
0.0195206385,
-0.0015802172,
0.0501613989,
-0.0034531166,
0.0022280717,
0.008700096,
-0.0321918353,
0.0130708106,
-0.0106931143,
-0.0266043991,
0.0081735607,
-0.0457438752,
-0.0356293768,
0.0285820477,
0.0437226929,
0.0059868055,
0.0272580758,
-0.0196320508,
-0.0352343284,
-0.0898896605,
0.0492776558,
0.0590613857,
0.0218211897,
0.0116866091,
-0.0654760748,
0.0014513927,
-0.0178438965,
0.048256319,
-0.0121775446,
0.0353143252,
-0.0015994787,
0.0286745876,
-0.0149216512,
0.0218526796,
0.0181479417,
0.0165362358,
-0.027966883,
0.0366751961,
0.029806653,
-0.0054382565,
-0.0035799581,
0.0103357444,
0.0174129028,
0.0498611592,
-0.0362465568,
-0.0123808384,
-0.0278759766,
0.0898744538,
0.0443885066,
-0.0134105403,
0.0318473615,
-0.0183639247,
0.0114646731,
0.0495907255,
-0.0097863451,
-0.0134388544,
-0.0084845293,
-0.0040858905,
-0.0373428427,
-0.0962724313,
0.0239949785,
-0.0426977016,
0.0198688097,
-0.0402195416,
0.0297457781,
0.0879991353,
0.0119503438,
-0.0433282964,
-0.0236851163,
0.034524478,
-0.0258764587,
0.0032287012,
-0.0088022528,
-0.0541830137,
0.0022731768,
-0.0063689202,
0.019480532,
0.0161377415,
-0.0774788409,
-0.0170466602,
-0.0517226309,
-0.0178764127,
0.0091428254,
-0.0447052866,
-0.0155841475,
-0.0714604035,
-0.0031518782,
-0.0110764094,
-0.024149213,
-0.0264389832,
-0.0440085083,
-0.0208014231,
0.0023101782,
-0.0374655426,
0.0436221957,
-0.0333696157,
-0.013010609,
-0.0303586069,
0.0046260022,
0.0732398555,
-0.006302855,
0.0514580011,
0.0487321354,
-0.0061768726,
-0.0372268856,
-0.0024319305,
0.0973511636,
-0.0276994016,
0.0449919216,
-0.0569506027,
0.0349869505,
0.0117711276,
-0.0109002581,
0.0011874499,
0.0232731905,
0.03047801,
-0.0516425036,
-0.026773395,
0.0081944978,
-0.0265847184,
-0.0002139015,
0.0451656915,
0.0099044945,
-0.0467424244,
-0.0327022895,
0.020075731,
-0.0716246217,
-0.0247312356,
0.0107000973,
-0.0701631531,
-0.0117906081,
-0.0527083464,
-0.0339377262,
0.0124802152,
-0.0188929588,
0.0101051005,
0.0068840031,
0.0665457696,
0.0059883362,
-0.0622490086,
-0.017707549,
0.0040184692,
-0.016351169,
-0.0270763673,
-0.0004962182,
0.0146428971,
0.0181776974,
-0.0310974754,
-0.0020537812,
-0.0415366925,
-0.0632668287,
-0.0318918377,
-0.0119988183,
0.0096651707,
0.0507512428,
0.0023606762,
-0.0094964281,
0.0572885014,
0.0256956201,
-0.0167595875,
-0.0129509727,
-0.0113155507,
0.0251938254,
-0.0454111323,
0.0152611891,
-0.066953741,
0.0541862957,
-0.0213818401,
0.0258480627,
-0.0274962541,
-0.0764203668,
-0.013645323,
0.0553903468,
-0.0117206685,
0.0083352048,
0.0084249703,
-0.0698147044,
-0.0277296305,
-0.0089051556,
0.0218107607,
0.0052685579,
0.0260437615,
-0.0256391615,
0.0213524178,
-0.0068013589,
0.028826179,
0.0354112573,
-0.0007019108,
-0.0463315621,
0.0022066694,
-0.0217859317,
-0.0198766105,
-0.0452710353,
-0.003528421,
-0.0306440555,
0.0134017766,
0.0051084994,
-0.0017377092,
-0.0171678476,
-0.0206327774,
0.0299128871,
-0.0190275144,
-0.0590549037,
0.0300967712,
-0.0824787617,
0.0378439613,
-0.0725544691,
0.0326182358,
0.0485936925,
0.0133383786,
0.0504208989,
0.0117516313,
-0.0123900454,
-0.0149174156,
0.0590546541,
0.0260764007,
-0.0142444791,
-0.049850449,
0.0324686877,
0.0205363594,
0.0316468626,
0.0253660567,
0.0121282041,
-0.0120108351,
0.0441576205,
-0.06310983,
-0.0338798873,
-0.0144848414,
-0.0036854614,
0.0291066337,
-0.0011457247,
-0.0067478116,
-0.021865515,
-0.0424381196,
0.0573433042,
0.0162650477,
0.0274822339,
0.0037501508,
0.0268277805,
-0.0519235395,
0.0427973419,
-0.0173531678,
-0.057385616,
0.0348977819,
-0.0240180194,
0.00467538,
0.0264702402,
-5.856154899e-33,
-0.0202755276,
-0.0599358752,
-0.0243696496,
0.0658381358,
-0.0723427162,
0.0397238135,
-0.0682832003,
-0.0506142788,
0.0000309385,
0.0090515073,
-0.0158157796,
0.0150139108,
0.0052429922,
0.0090354821,
-0.0354152136,
0.006095394,
0.0274984594,
0.0342569128,
-0.010734926,
0.0734743178,
0.0490833484,
0.0564783998,
0.0608851276,
-0.0615840964,
0.0304803234,
-0.0190863051,
0.0075933635,
-0.0279222019,
0.1003623083,
0.0101984218,
-0.0065424871,
0.009480685,
0.036264088,
-0.0330871418,
-0.0015687012,
0.0100725256,
-0.1341209859,
-0.0535005666,
-0.0275723021,
-0.0182745662,
-0.0373992547,
-0.0248649828,
0.0568505861,
-0.0110578705,
0.0403180197,
-0.0227231719,
0.0936754495,
0.0090214182,
-0.0284683742,
-0.0493788235,
-0.0285400692,
0.0601941012,
-0.0307055768,
0.0268279705,
0.0242163502,
-0.0260193087,
0.0123217907,
-0.0296933446,
-0.0690732002,
0.0168599803,
-0.0067943214,
-0.0230346229,
-0.0242430996,
0.0365725495,
0.0203764122,
0.0338784903,
-0.0156746451,
-0.0252095219,
-0.05235314,
0.0225371756,
0.0046996428,
0.013885159,
-0.0241206549,
-0.0074603669,
0.0211482905,
-0.0295392554,
-0.0795648918,
0.0688325316,
0.014320015,
0.041265104,
-0.0017829483,
-0.0127395112,
-0.0073697371,
-0.0346408077,
0.0089652566,
-0.0282756463,
-0.0123008164,
-0.0210195724,
-0.046133738,
0.010501273,
-0.077633962,
0.0044575953,
-0.0235096309,
-0.0660407096,
-0.0207295362,
0.0659999922,
0.0260065086,
0.0283858962,
-0.0134612955,
-0.0250541139,
-0.0335086808,
-0.0027624622,
-0.0010717728,
-0.0152879776,
0.0203603506,
-0.0356523655,
0.0448062457,
0.0036513701,
-0.0081554111,
0.0062280344,
0.0222821906,
-0.0199909639,
-0.0364935733,
-0.0006213158,
-0.0007666532,
0.0194557346,
0.0056358143,
0.0171767268,
0.0338549465,
0.0393585004,
0.000152438,
0.0558248647,
0.0761390626,
0.056900762,
-0.0440795496,
0.00044095,
0.0116810026,
0.0532534756,
0.0247456357,
-0.0543741807,
-0.0243115425,
-0.0100201806,
2.648e-7,
0.0472221412,
0.0214055181,
0.087989375,
-0.0191114899,
-0.0298149232,
0.0063167494,
-0.0048849271,
0.0588425174,
0.0078250663,
0.0040543,
0.0674374327,
0.0420497321,
-0.052766107,
0.0425373316,
-0.1129108667,
-0.0105304364,
-0.040553838,
-0.0680772811,
-0.0226327293,
0.0386748128,
0.0339942575,
0.0137830842,
0.0342071578,
-0.0100380583,
-0.0424407758,
-0.0439837649,
0.0070889448,
0.0265182778,
0.0133031299,
0.0237649083,
0.0138450414,
0.0125484373,
-0.0742585585,
-0.013046707,
0.0033398683,
0.0360849947,
0.0566175245,
0.035050448,
-0.0233678594,
0.0075796084,
0.0176328085,
-0.0456489362,
0.0314520076,
0.0269855242,
0.0575369112,
-0.0560345016,
-0.0394426696,
-0.019671116,
-0.0242707767,
0.0026243124,
-0.0103551075,
0.0196105447,
-0.0329749584,
0.0336784385,
0.003840267,
-0.0234009977,
0.0264773332,
-0.0966556147,
0.033244554,
0.0592531599,
0.0376014747,
-0.0124174478,
0.0185961351,
0.0094742412,
0.0181880984,
-0.0431427062,
0.0164733566,
2.283744915e-34,
0.0429034792,
0.0084792515,
-0.0601069815,
-0.0178206135,
0.0155932102,
-0.046236854,
-0.0709021688,
0.0010966896,
0.0223254245,
-0.0971569046,
-0.0092426967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06655v1 | Adversarial Text Purification: A Large Language Model Approach for Defense | 2024-02-05T02:36:41 | 2024-02-05T02:36:41 | Raha Moraffah, Shubh Khandelwal, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Huan Liu | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Adversarial purification is a defense mechanism for safeguarding classifiers
against adversarial attacks without knowing the type of attacks or training of
the classifier. These techniques characterize and eliminate adversarial
perturbations from the attacked inputs, aiming to restore purified samples that
retain similarity to the initially attacked ones and are correctly classified
by the classifier. Due to the inherent challenges associated with
characterizing noise perturbations for discrete inputs, adversarial text
purification has been relatively unexplored. In this paper, we investigate the
effectiveness of adversarial purification methods in defending text
classifiers. We propose a novel adversarial text purification that harnesses
the generative capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to purify
adversarial text without the need to explicitly characterize the discrete noise
perturbations. We utilize prompt engineering to exploit LLMs for recovering the
purified examples for given adversarial examples such that they are
semantically similar and correctly classified. Our proposed method demonstrates
remarkable performance over various classifiers, improving their accuracy under
the attack by over 65% on average. | [
0.0289469045,
0.1008607224,
0.0014042453,
0.0464862101,
-0.0347915962,
0.0001494945,
0.0137846982,
0.0368084162,
0.0081897844,
-0.0796248093,
-0.0250781178,
-0.0172297824,
-0.0010769762,
-0.0058590667,
0.0542743132,
-0.018394025,
0.0189634264,
-0.0012686946,
-0.0050247437,
-0.0221645683,
-0.0013151946,
-0.0142921396,
0.0177919846,
0.0156093622,
0.01744752,
-0.0326755531,
0.0283380486,
-0.0074249581,
0.0207314827,
-0.0026390608,
0.026176339,
0.005660993,
-0.0026713465,
0.1049054712,
0.0000019941,
-0.0095818974,
-0.0265622418,
0.0295783747,
-0.006540441,
0.0692560747,
0.0432643592,
-0.0333778709,
-0.0026345772,
0.018348204,
-0.0197175071,
-0.0280555114,
0.0126877492,
0.0880663842,
0.1001694947,
0.1097221896,
-0.0160015561,
-0.0374935083,
0.04707155,
-0.0350478701,
-0.0263451003,
-0.0524862371,
0.0532362312,
-0.0346486084,
-0.0204423927,
0.0357156955,
0.020136673,
0.0565790236,
0.01159753,
0.0216938872,
-0.0286688413,
0.0307133012,
0.0088655185,
0.0090169357,
0.0099734506,
0.0533334911,
-0.0576475039,
-0.0368334055,
0.0150806569,
-0.0030969044,
0.0221219342,
0.0098689962,
-0.0111841466,
0.0171353016,
0.0083967317,
0.0402589999,
-0.0330512822,
-0.0254551657,
0.0735933408,
0.014591923,
-0.025730934,
-0.0024521851,
0.0290210322,
-0.0384744741,
-0.0291310661,
-0.0411761813,
-0.0435410738,
-0.0264905561,
0.0343836918,
0.015372294,
0.0292700659,
-0.0016272707,
-0.0850775465,
-0.0766036958,
0.0164093506,
-0.0246943161,
0.0310185663,
-0.0285633653,
0.0008940178,
0.0327877142,
-0.0391350538,
0.0256107505,
-0.0194669217,
0.0386859365,
-0.0187563915,
-0.0054066298,
-0.0199274682,
-0.0130692497,
0.0037035469,
0.0460313894,
-0.0219679996,
0.0016710242,
-0.0046615899,
0.0214961395,
-0.0545029789,
0.0459915064,
-0.0343108699,
0.0221463069,
-0.0066695358,
-0.0075113699,
0.0360187218,
-0.0393792018,
0.0088657914,
-0.0019048119,
-0.0259456988,
-0.038554132,
-0.0342001468,
0.0308990143,
-0.0251484849,
-0.0213236976,
-0.0071395519,
0.0897267833,
0.0122885685,
-0.02079398,
-0.0173924882,
-0.0218813904,
-0.0254349671,
-0.0238476731,
0.0082143201,
0.0041332552,
-0.0215598345,
-0.0442217924,
-0.0094966805,
-0.1057122275,
-0.001680553,
0.0141158756,
-0.0586254895,
0.0893003568,
0.0381302871,
-0.0368057676,
0.0337326936,
0.0356395878,
0.028069444,
0.0216654968,
0.0146692386,
0.0426035896,
0.045339033,
-0.0057188296,
0.018083496,
0.0504774339,
0.0338112861,
-0.0021445639,
-0.0688508451,
-0.0207916517,
0.0228930172,
-0.0362125412,
-0.0055450709,
0.0756825283,
-0.0183647033,
-0.0652755946,
0.0804198682,
0.0151904821,
-0.0162856635,
0.0503608882,
0.0032631571,
0.0091843745,
0.0150824701,
0.0249921698,
-0.0530154184,
-0.0375368558,
-0.0752481446,
-0.0516676381,
0.0329773016,
0.0215354636,
-0.0425724424,
-0.0445202589,
0.0066890079,
-0.0144559788,
0.0187753048,
-0.0198564343,
0.0399601087,
0.0181149673,
-0.0207415465,
0.0174656585,
0.0168731995,
-0.0356281623,
-0.002702225,
-0.0702676252,
0.0271859635,
0.0043862928,
0.0679740235,
-0.0535363853,
0.0673144683,
-0.0251811035,
-0.0107743563,
-0.009316978,
0.014168621,
-0.0042980998,
0.0135332141,
-0.0471738242,
-0.0149455369,
-0.0540371165,
0.0157643873,
0.0097158793,
0.0231421646,
0.0006208378,
0.018418856,
0.0178609844,
-0.0587094091,
0.0608423874,
0.0163699277,
-0.1002720445,
0.0520983599,
0.0062603634,
0.0342823043,
0.010172612,
-0.0405137613,
0.0280405153,
0.0580107123,
-0.0347466916,
-0.0213858541,
-0.0599724725,
0.0180532113,
-0.0433178656,
0.0204919707,
0.0059901774,
-0.039168179,
0.0632763132,
-0.0449188165,
0.0279796533,
0.0166700408,
-0.031245539,
-0.0168392602,
-0.027769899,
0.0067002266,
-0.0144819058,
0.0424244925,
-0.0518012233,
0.0634134784,
-0.0081970543,
-0.0211629719,
-0.0200299416,
-0.0033361157,
0.0142071545,
-0.0024910751,
-0.0431004949,
0.0106444089,
-0.0331646428,
0.0408602618,
0.0075935591,
-0.0147785563,
0.0133379092,
-0.0365274511,
-0.0136897974,
-0.0230102073,
-0.0275673382,
-0.0067712595,
0.0287509821,
-0.014135858,
0.0213724822,
-0.013393092,
-0.0043481183,
-0.0177695137,
0.0116486261,
0.0107257012,
0.0060319062,
-0.0340594798,
0.0038951884,
-0.0111624096,
-0.0135062682,
0.0006195202,
0.1081816256,
-0.0390897729,
-0.0164507776,
-0.0368385911,
0.0407905579,
0.0062760301,
0.0668353811,
-0.0070590042,
-0.0394668691,
0.018424781,
0.0030334711,
-0.0095242849,
0.0726728663,
0.0441208705,
0.0476024561,
0.0597668663,
0.0417656861,
-0.0079865102,
-0.0179061387,
-0.0088827414,
0.0178552736,
-0.0217356049,
0.0009672507,
0.0432715341,
0.0457809083,
0.0164552853,
-0.0374114588,
-0.0121302046,
0.0643624067,
-0.0053198738,
-0.028700754,
-0.0257111546,
-0.0294429231,
-0.0268606413,
-0.0325649641,
-0.0443640836,
-0.0406345204,
0.0730196238,
-0.0386937261,
0.0449127071,
-0.0469326377,
-0.0683075413,
0.0325967222,
0.0434499681,
-0.0136969434,
0.0177820157,
0.0019081633,
0.0059372759,
-0.0380188338,
-0.0414414443,
0.0473446958,
-0.0036387437,
0.0357371941,
-0.0111840013,
0.0056116404,
0.0185130909,
-0.0194671024,
-0.0810916126,
-0.069697991,
0.0197670776,
0.0245894864,
0.0037585327,
0.0061366376,
-0.0609379523,
-0.0157325156,
0.0109673748,
0.0072523369,
-0.0092238002,
-0.0001415235,
-0.0199743323,
0.0780879706,
0.0352531672,
-0.0493206792,
0.0020370844,
-0.0341170877,
0.0380719975,
0.0818443671,
0.0012105558,
0.0245809145,
-0.0351889729,
-0.0364623219,
0.0148959178,
-0.0067836763,
0.0119551681,
0.0138505604,
0.0082828933,
-0.0279603619,
-0.009638872,
0.0658199787,
0.0050815204,
-0.0084388955,
0.0242591351,
0.0413862914,
0.0154173858,
-0.0223015826,
-0.0257339403,
-0.0318573415,
-0.0115118064,
0.0227498002,
0.0006241539,
0.0173788052,
-0.000082443,
-0.0145078367,
-0.0710806847,
0.002224399,
0.0229274742,
-0.0414337516,
-0.0536995046,
0.0030779024,
0.0038879914,
0.0056110569,
0.0318801627,
-0.0016759413,
0.0151672633,
-0.0093260771,
-0.000165087,
-0.0086932024,
-0.0475511812,
-0.0036897867,
-0.0266707707,
0.0183158219,
0.0762024224,
0.0461837053,
0.0005980103,
-0.0347617567,
0.0551795624,
-0.0230292752,
-0.0322055109,
0.0321750008,
0.0772487298,
0.0005253035,
-0.0090092067,
0.0291475914,
0.0657840967,
-0.0038796288,
-0.0265365001,
0.0358823203,
0.016105203,
-0.0153519809,
-0.0378983542,
-0.0193417091,
-0.0082476381,
0.0063623763,
0.0773166046,
0.021206053,
-0.0648169965,
-0.0300801676,
-0.0544170775,
0.0097053759,
-0.0261400677,
-0.0558053367,
0.0374236144,
-0.0179979708,
-0.0492156222,
-0.0440702215,
-0.0276366752,
-0.0389395133,
0.0176761616,
0.001205227,
0.0018111402,
-0.0321072638,
-0.014549071,
-0.0310394503,
0.0046030274,
-0.0333686583,
0.0401050188,
0.0020353161,
-0.0101486519,
-0.0121136326,
-0.0103135305,
-0.034511935,
0.0229374617,
-0.0856302753,
-0.0796835348,
0.0235148333,
0.0011719214,
0.011692618,
0.0252100173,
-0.0419975445,
-0.0956453979,
0.1053730026,
0.0492924601,
-0.0186723676,
0.0090409331,
0.0528118648,
-0.0370714292,
0.0383160412,
0.0507542975,
-0.0258985609,
0.0188565943,
0.0694806278,
-0.038236402,
-0.0395812914,
-0.0233574081,
-0.0070097991,
0.0396528058,
0.0600820445,
0.0076354854,
-0.012408684,
0.0157206152,
0.0038384739,
-0.0065333787,
-0.0370245464,
-0.0091020055,
0.0219003409,
0.038973026,
-0.0185983907,
-0.0267139729,
0.0219895691,
0.0204527862,
0.0578741655,
-0.0317036808,
-0.0131575158,
-0.0063253972,
0.0436775275,
0.0478213727,
0.0169573743,
-0.0042705941,
0.0366746783,
0.0201603714,
0.0014858888,
-0.019653175,
0.0187709946,
0.0209002681,
0.0286919326,
-0.0521975532,
0.0211975314,
-0.0849294886,
-0.0233226232,
-0.0261384081,
0.0104453778,
0.0213002507,
0.0174516384,
-0.0203388222,
0.0003960794,
-0.024610946,
-0.0258672833,
-0.034558706,
0.0126663037,
0.0039874995,
0.0290265009,
-0.0057561221,
-0.0118285138,
0.0101268105,
0.0880669206,
0.0048170993,
0.061635755,
0.0007339511,
-0.0396502167,
-0.0485707596,
-0.0366073847,
0.0261013769,
0.0005031241,
-0.0238227379,
-0.0233210176,
-0.0122950403,
-0.0798074529,
-0.0123859933,
-0.003226622,
0.02078267,
0.0074596414,
-0.0406597517,
0.0474942103,
-0.0016808569,
0.0433755405,
-0.043365024,
0.0461571813,
0.0305854119,
-0.0806218162,
-0.0008202552,
-5.677874283e-33,
0.0327362791,
-0.0272725262,
-0.0242866054,
-0.0303121991,
0.0240644701,
0.0116149206,
-0.0040430985,
-0.0589832105,
0.0007339697,
0.0055771722,
0.0029246775,
0.0175316762,
-0.0296888761,
0.0401962101,
-0.0595321693,
-0.0370196328,
0.0770950839,
-0.034819819,
-0.0339969248,
0.0237269215,
0.050543353,
0.0128724799,
-0.0166908223,
-0.0837771595,
0.0390740074,
0.0043517533,
-0.0459963307,
-0.0158732273,
-0.0290740672,
0.0535615198,
-0.0241336618,
0.0252172705,
0.0165223945,
0.007912037,
0.006175973,
0.0216464754,
-0.0160819814,
0.001136436,
-0.0135751106,
-0.0096188672,
-0.0282098111,
-0.0640603974,
0.0676390305,
-0.0311316475,
0.0079654949,
-0.007131509,
-0.0035479057,
-0.0126937628,
-0.0158032998,
-0.0389717892,
-0.0317745917,
0.02361474,
-0.0270299502,
-0.0056447349,
0.0569362491,
-0.0107981209,
0.0315769054,
0.0389692262,
-0.0648480058,
0.0134320892,
0.0166044571,
0.0393671207,
0.0065194261,
-0.0065765246,
-0.0027622073,
0.0638734922,
0.0129721565,
-0.0009599655,
-0.0239013005,
-0.0227699727,
0.0435588136,
0.0330294855,
0.0768471062,
0.0791099444,
0.060978964,
-0.0670555979,
-0.0899363458,
0.0249721352,
-0.0176200867,
0.0038682683,
0.0080766454,
0.0181328394,
0.0060631093,
0.0042509511,
-0.040687453,
-0.0572928227,
-0.0388750136,
0.0134902308,
0.0046345633,
0.0164482389,
-0.0797436982,
-0.0181309432,
-0.0137713449,
-0.0648036748,
-0.0138516026,
0.0517075211,
-0.0534148514,
-0.034846779,
0.0084558241,
-0.0037861329,
0.0003213758,
-0.0081196493,
0.043043036,
-0.0508411117,
0.0202815142,
-0.0051282123,
0.0571351908,
0.0190799758,
-0.0659349486,
-0.0057526594,
-0.0249236561,
0.0454506837,
0.0363815613,
0.0366319343,
0.0180284213,
0.0203829054,
0.0203878172,
-0.0400315151,
0.0274942871,
-0.0140590491,
0.0033748755,
0.0629277751,
0.0089148153,
0.0006888072,
-0.0065063532,
-0.027963683,
0.0047809603,
0.0387229361,
0.0731768385,
-0.082775414,
0.0306753479,
-0.0382545777,
2.644e-7,
-0.0070330105,
0.0357327238,
-0.0181398522,
-0.0168522485,
0.0519252159,
0.0620104857,
-0.0056286803,
0.0389113314,
-0.0291230939,
-0.011362656,
-0.0262146574,
0.02169968,
0.0467335396,
0.0232227985,
-0.0514136925,
0.0063813427,
-0.0714752004,
-0.0288934335,
-0.0347519927,
0.0078080511,
0.0338662341,
0.1173945144,
0.0400444604,
-0.0314609148,
-0.0116337417,
-0.0749438331,
0.0387180932,
-0.0210702457,
0.0143515328,
0.0333633535,
0.0486738086,
-0.0210306887,
0.0376646854,
0.0067866733,
-0.0597326495,
-0.0119607737,
0.0237428993,
0.0696410537,
-0.0155249238,
-0.0093090804,
-0.0332835503,
-0.0101239346,
0.0071458318,
-0.0196350105,
0.0675762221,
0.0079452684,
-0.0035581707,
-0.0467213169,
-0.0272679906,
-0.0335856974,
0.0353127159,
-0.0225394294,
-0.0029648773,
0.0236166343,
-0.017545253,
0.0274349786,
0.0148063032,
-0.0872596949,
-0.0104601672,
-0.0384451561,
-0.0385615863,
-0.0104326941,
-0.0053141857,
0.0114769805,
0.0577825755,
-0.0343808755,
0.0138191953,
2.504622829e-34,
0.0073070847,
-0.0277160052,
-0.0184205063,
-0.008008413,
0.0174103286,
-0.0096673649,
0.0070273434,
0.0142031033,
-0.0100765973,
-0.0505126119,
-0.0065729953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02680v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02680v1 | Large Language Models are Geographically Biased | 2024-02-05T02:32:09 | 2024-02-05T02:32:09 | Rohin Manvi, Samar Khanna, Marshall Burke, David Lobell, Stefano Ermon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) inherently carry the biases contained in their
training corpora, which can lead to the perpetuation of societal harm. As the
impact of these foundation models grows, understanding and evaluating their
biases becomes crucial to achieving fairness and accuracy. We propose to study
what LLMs know about the world we live in through the lens of geography. This
approach is particularly powerful as there is ground truth for the numerous
aspects of human life that are meaningfully projected onto geographic space
such as culture, race, language, politics, and religion. We show various
problematic geographic biases, which we define as systemic errors in geospatial
predictions. Initially, we demonstrate that LLMs are capable of making accurate
zero-shot geospatial predictions in the form of ratings that show strong
monotonic correlation with ground truth (Spearman's $\rho$ of up to 0.89). We
then show that LLMs exhibit common biases across a range of objective and
subjective topics. In particular, LLMs are clearly biased against locations
with lower socioeconomic conditions (e.g. most of Africa) on a variety of
sensitive subjective topics such as attractiveness, morality, and intelligence
(Spearman's $\rho$ of up to 0.70). Finally, we introduce a bias score to
quantify this and find that there is significant variation in the magnitude of
bias across existing LLMs. | [
0.0461203791,
0.1153925732,
-0.0208788682,
-0.0132784648,
-0.0192504916,
0.0447413549,
0.0668410137,
-0.0269822776,
0.0399400853,
-0.0350911282,
-0.0131317535,
-0.050115332,
0.0448140539,
-0.0252186749,
0.0181433707,
-0.0690007135,
0.0153734284,
-0.0000747992,
0.024620574,
-0.0402236991,
-0.0254020095,
0.0283237901,
0.0306466352,
0.0441449918,
-0.0067198281,
0.0157894827,
0.0381329395,
-0.0394742675,
-0.0209116209,
-0.0096087931,
0.0038268627,
0.0471447632,
-0.0381680876,
-0.0000393444,
0.0000020494,
-0.0399866998,
0.0091891615,
-0.0168039501,
0.0384607688,
0.0312294532,
0.0653693303,
-0.0168034453,
-0.0013141154,
0.0227053724,
-0.0356022641,
-0.0048135277,
0.0214484558,
-0.0061446126,
-0.0074709835,
0.0202685855,
0.0061024353,
-0.0229349453,
-0.0161080789,
-0.0148294233,
-0.0243043154,
0.030647302,
0.0683262795,
-0.0020417895,
-0.0496667065,
0.0366655178,
-0.052716732,
0.0061165616,
0.0092790937,
0.029015189,
-0.0290048383,
0.0153245311,
-0.0500775017,
-0.0239609182,
0.0057834582,
0.0090239011,
0.0098907584,
-0.0123436321,
0.0149267372,
0.0243711174,
-0.0158213712,
-0.0146204466,
-0.0348882563,
0.0474957749,
-0.002708998,
0.0317139924,
0.0102372775,
0.0013828698,
0.0246600807,
0.0601741634,
-0.0224602651,
0.1152116209,
0.0187175032,
-0.0305550732,
-0.0303768888,
0.0524374172,
0.011537455,
-0.0471657217,
0.004744926,
-0.0262970421,
-0.0048278053,
0.0013517408,
0.0074117579,
0.0682504028,
0.0217880774,
-0.0568684079,
0.033450596,
0.0103425151,
-0.0394775569,
0.0002559255,
0.0451695137,
0.0424771085,
0.0104176234,
0.0432898737,
-0.0104278512,
-0.0291688554,
0.0267040823,
0.022978209,
0.0776299238,
-0.0483210087,
-0.0086209029,
0.0737552717,
-0.0645591766,
-0.0166559666,
-0.0363305286,
0.0031215374,
-0.052800905,
0.0053169471,
0.0001987827,
-0.0315576233,
-0.0448654927,
0.0153484764,
-0.018530868,
0.029226331,
-0.0487980507,
-0.0430892818,
0.0464573987,
0.0066149039,
-0.025355801,
-0.0086669968,
0.0031992702,
0.047526896,
0.0523375496,
-0.0006169839,
-0.0246008467,
0.0213428363,
-0.0635480806,
-0.0330626555,
0.006366068,
-0.0640391484,
-0.0081242817,
0.0286297053,
-0.0141151277,
-0.0585364588,
-0.0041557099,
0.0072367862,
-0.0577267595,
-0.0089966236,
0.0036193929,
0.0317748152,
0.0772367939,
0.0153796775,
0.0020495115,
0.0882429481,
0.0048556412,
0.0446296893,
0.0444435626,
-0.0063547785,
-0.0154645285,
0.0088106254,
0.0120292129,
0.0604506955,
-0.0563853681,
-0.0037974373,
-0.0072558401,
-0.0127508566,
0.0557328947,
0.0395548977,
0.0098226219,
0.0018933293,
0.0813685358,
0.0844108239,
-0.0069744391,
0.0307678357,
0.0069707343,
0.0467836596,
-0.0388200246,
-0.0105504459,
-0.0949348733,
-0.0448136739,
-0.0197584089,
-0.0333593078,
0.0337586701,
0.0917409211,
-0.0234333239,
-0.0127705988,
-0.0113730934,
0.0073009632,
0.0289758779,
0.0197894406,
0.0358518101,
-0.0479162224,
0.0230189804,
0.0279926006,
0.091994673,
0.0012621211,
-0.0082872007,
-0.0110888509,
0.0309434105,
0.0099801701,
-0.0363679752,
0.0315396115,
0.0066102515,
-0.0021903305,
0.0472088046,
0.0245308876,
0.0536859818,
0.0254060458,
-0.0010140808,
-0.0245689042,
-0.0290813819,
0.0251110103,
0.030825058,
0.0057917852,
0.0550700352,
0.0565334745,
0.0381040908,
-0.0436282605,
-0.0285335258,
0.0025616051,
-0.0151318768,
0.0183578245,
-0.0376916304,
0.0154314684,
0.0179304387,
-0.0194006879,
-0.0311297961,
-0.0190971494,
-0.0495433621,
-0.0056159561,
0.0100036571,
0.0171290729,
-0.0599923469,
0.041995652,
0.0181674547,
-0.0521097556,
0.0066675204,
0.0220903661,
-0.0049542701,
0.0273334514,
0.0391916893,
0.0036039099,
0.0448950008,
0.0151734632,
0.0137024438,
-0.0522777699,
0.0334708802,
-0.0102254255,
0.0390522331,
-0.041438587,
0.0207883604,
-0.028330313,
-0.0300429836,
0.0480833724,
-0.0024641189,
-0.0122339381,
-0.0468546413,
-0.0094445245,
0.0039792121,
0.0169838704,
0.0124735963,
-0.0084912609,
-0.0336071998,
-0.0929689184,
0.0032425055,
-0.0183680095,
-0.0242046434,
0.0057117408,
-0.0153100686,
-0.0321406648,
0.0102499491,
-0.0370197967,
-0.0218015909,
0.0278321654,
0.0493290313,
-0.0229978058,
-0.0669960231,
0.0050184042,
-0.0153540531,
-0.0219232235,
-0.0315844864,
0.0551418401,
-0.0050465553,
0.0172130261,
-0.0288106743,
0.016793238,
-0.0622156374,
0.0101027386,
-0.026921967,
-0.0313160308,
-0.0070353006,
0.0233850311,
-0.0284568202,
0.0270621311,
0.0243859515,
0.005108892,
0.0717021674,
0.0010271444,
-0.0346894003,
-0.0595464297,
-0.016489638,
0.0127805313,
-0.0189170409,
-0.1014271602,
-0.0571529716,
0.0883153006,
0.0330187865,
-0.0047706002,
-0.0041584764,
0.060037706,
-0.08579427,
-0.049575869,
-0.0274881795,
-0.0038486756,
0.0037272514,
0.0710001364,
-0.0560634546,
-0.0827690512,
0.016516313,
0.0184609406,
0.0648713186,
-0.000944067,
-0.0016976672,
-0.0339413024,
0.0142720006,
0.0217156205,
0.0223928485,
-0.0023604252,
-0.0253120381,
-0.0443169661,
-0.0472753942,
0.0004162952,
-0.0128385611,
0.0137741407,
-0.0419157855,
-0.0144491503,
0.0088028396,
-0.0731437802,
-0.027261585,
-0.0618712641,
-0.0393519253,
-0.0085077817,
0.0360846594,
-0.0200428218,
0.0033839927,
0.0173677225,
0.037093088,
-0.0034962518,
-0.017096566,
0.0246772449,
0.016151743,
-0.0628214777,
0.0650720373,
0.0177186038,
0.040656589,
-0.0362338088,
-0.034394633,
0.0131882587,
-0.0242174547,
0.049372904,
0.0250536855,
0.0448214412,
0.0444565229,
0.0079239644,
-0.0567363612,
0.0183306709,
0.0646003112,
-0.0144737065,
0.0025814909,
0.1080029085,
0.0255405307,
-0.0351887196,
0.0342749394,
-0.0059064548,
-0.0138685424,
0.0360835083,
0.0083886394,
-0.0857606605,
0.029025685,
-0.0060744351,
-0.0098701147,
-0.0598333254,
-0.0311991945,
0.0257548746,
-0.112864159,
0.0340019949,
0.0435536876,
-0.0169012286,
-0.0222335774,
-0.0273396987,
-0.0136497719,
-0.0034847059,
0.02065208,
-0.0216370672,
0.0098357033,
-0.0080501214,
0.0054816878,
-0.0736788958,
-0.048669979,
0.0252969097,
-0.0544520766,
0.0430319048,
0.002178276,
0.0494279079,
-0.027403377,
-0.012380559,
-0.0040813806,
0.0331482217,
-0.0101475613,
0.0092524774,
0.0276164711,
0.0046066795,
-0.0268164445,
-0.0457696281,
-0.0058118352,
0.0147709735,
0.0098360712,
0.0167625882,
0.0355054215,
0.0016441785,
-0.0141769974,
-0.0051737349,
0.0334656164,
-0.0067908955,
0.0427802801,
0.001962563,
-0.0490757674,
0.0110419672,
-0.0637123287,
-0.0262275599,
0.0169060845,
-0.0595579706,
0.0612366833,
-0.0035543647,
-0.0470991693,
-0.0123449462,
-0.0447197706,
0.0094593847,
-0.0026564288,
0.0401991345,
-0.0602519922,
0.0268748384,
-0.0364202112,
-0.0208987668,
0.0440382846,
-0.0267183091,
-0.0056055733,
0.0056058504,
0.0112642758,
0.0103569254,
-0.0216722153,
0.0034732847,
-0.0094740214,
-0.0436733179,
-0.0428247638,
0.0786781162,
0.0263204686,
0.0158460997,
0.0175856743,
-0.0008782438,
-0.0402807035,
0.0729624256,
0.014719218,
-0.0313658975,
0.0435116887,
-0.0184601787,
0.0215259343,
0.0250719581,
0.0100843245,
-0.0139190853,
0.0580236353,
0.0465605669,
-0.0451296642,
-0.0547803603,
-0.004496309,
-0.0178495087,
-0.0350274518,
0.0844845399,
-0.0337815247,
-0.0091480324,
-0.0344993509,
-0.0394762345,
-0.0334145837,
-0.0115781305,
0.0081991283,
-0.0115021355,
0.0474233255,
0.0368843041,
-0.0227392446,
-0.0004692877,
-0.0219194964,
-0.0120143369,
-0.0472938828,
0.0217058193,
0.0053792819,
0.0260178708,
0.0174991004,
0.0194839388,
-0.0230829157,
0.0293765441,
-0.02458754,
0.0433904082,
0.0080013592,
0.0244778432,
-0.0023731056,
0.0134037519,
-0.0192349739,
0.0037325707,
-0.0370476432,
-0.0644459575,
-0.0162362568,
0.0168092493,
0.0426938348,
-0.0411112569,
0.0224500299,
0.0114000747,
-0.0216328949,
-0.0120902015,
-0.0051701209,
-0.0015443431,
-0.0759940296,
0.0108421221,
-0.0309864767,
-0.0342346318,
0.0619251467,
0.0417958423,
0.0324004851,
0.0165577233,
0.0286404043,
-0.0685245246,
0.0057705273,
-0.0165389962,
0.0363015048,
-0.019447187,
-0.0377647914,
0.0001472033,
-0.0946565419,
-0.0599581078,
-0.0072154612,
0.0024478042,
-0.0133714844,
-0.039282918,
-0.0156047232,
0.0357576162,
-0.0535830967,
-0.0171333645,
-0.051817067,
0.0065031182,
-0.0433466285,
-0.0347074494,
-0.0006442915,
-6.220021094e-33,
-0.0093856817,
-0.0281970929,
0.0131836627,
-0.0363245346,
-0.0170048233,
-0.0180244856,
0.0004499362,
0.0447897166,
-0.0516668484,
0.0229219552,
0.0094551193,
-0.0004368625,
0.0052298903,
0.0163783655,
0.0404796861,
0.010074974,
-0.0172819272,
0.0183085762,
-0.0093483524,
-0.0107428636,
0.0483059585,
0.0067148739,
0.066624172,
-0.0897358134,
0.0172416531,
0.0147973346,
-0.0100910384,
-0.0100937402,
-0.0010365386,
0.0206869747,
-0.0177192464,
0.0672132671,
0.0220276956,
-0.0341348685,
-0.0026001558,
-0.0111486847,
0.0019087916,
-0.0206620321,
0.0278099552,
0.0123218028,
0.0463664606,
-0.0183273405,
0.0116164712,
0.0085414555,
-0.0570091195,
0.0043063224,
0.0409008376,
-0.0076101325,
-0.0190122202,
0.0251952354,
-0.0354838111,
0.0218303278,
-0.0176339243,
0.039747227,
-0.0623850785,
0.0281187501,
0.0020562659,
0.0371248797,
-0.0053461883,
0.0262869392,
0.0777337328,
0.0310754329,
0.0389846526,
-0.0148939677,
0.026811311,
0.0923507661,
0.0599736348,
0.0310430806,
-0.0268847346,
-0.0748880804,
0.0797676891,
-0.0382660292,
-0.0050841356,
0.0887154043,
-0.0040928773,
-0.0523012131,
-0.0315781906,
-0.035266269,
0.0134192063,
-0.000395954,
0.0073237717,
-0.0303330775,
-0.043984592,
-0.0727020577,
-0.0375343338,
-0.070013538,
-0.0056889364,
-0.0131344674,
0.03786112,
-0.0174235832,
0.0313601159,
0.0491532199,
0.0295826793,
-0.0419897065,
-0.0205545593,
0.0086349854,
-0.0318268053,
-0.0339679979,
0.003630528,
0.0255298875,
-0.0843483806,
-0.0166008249,
-0.0562880486,
0.0262198299,
0.0147170853,
0.0377983041,
0.0056736977,
-0.0134546086,
-0.055579368,
0.0039761164,
-0.0265930388,
-0.0116597991,
0.0328360684,
-0.002042826,
0.0449791588,
-0.0229509696,
0.0232451633,
-0.0171742626,
0.0491508357,
0.0282745101,
0.0035869898,
-0.0147111369,
-0.0141890617,
0.0503429957,
-0.0210079961,
-0.0240087677,
-0.0247500688,
0.0241396725,
0.0383615047,
-0.0430353209,
-0.0192580968,
-0.0360878631,
2.54e-7,
0.0196579043,
0.0996619612,
-0.0339822508,
-0.0255537461,
0.0106230062,
0.0384746753,
0.0412547514,
0.0063331733,
0.0423817709,
0.0099060414,
-0.0270681363,
0.0175558422,
0.0546287447,
0.0389777049,
-0.0797537267,
0.0571718924,
-0.0615477413,
-0.0009149793,
-0.0635247529,
0.0124949673,
-0.0283172242,
0.0790476575,
0.0326121785,
-0.0169032048,
-0.021810716,
-0.0171529576,
0.0400402546,
-0.074376598,
-0.0302394778,
0.0020058297,
0.0191822853,
-0.0114341006,
0.0053141257,
0.0051200134,
0.0096433312,
0.0200897641,
-0.00912097,
0.0476367995,
0.002048244,
0.0161089245,
-0.0250653476,
-0.0171679836,
-0.0377429426,
-0.111459367,
0.0747192651,
-0.0033316722,
-0.0500496328,
-0.0465576202,
-0.0073447684,
-0.0014305083,
0.0463965014,
-0.0045962902,
-0.0075634215,
-0.0311797354,
0.0368531346,
-0.0044278651,
0.0280412864,
-0.0312421825,
-0.0250433069,
0.0119376127,
0.0046230564,
-0.0580407605,
0.0054296949,
0.0571430102,
0.0033120462,
-0.0327458642,
0.0300691873,
2.464580486e-34,
0.0194754675,
0.013305991,
0.0206758995,
-0.0746384859,
0.0398888588,
0.0351739675,
0.0239007678,
-0.0043172883,
0.0087916944,
-0.0121091148,
0.0207234155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02662v1 | Image-Caption Encoding for Improving Zero-Shot Generalization | 2024-02-05T01:14:07 | 2024-02-05T01:14:07 | Eric Yang Yu, Christopher Liao, Sathvik Ravi, Theodoros Tsiligkaridis, Brian Kulis | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in vision-language models have combined contrastive
approaches with generative methods to achieve state-of-the-art (SOTA) on
downstream inference tasks like zero-shot image classification. However, a
persistent issue of these models for image classification is their
out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization capabilities. We first show that when
an OOD data point is misclassified, the correct class can be typically found in
the Top-K predicted classes. In order to steer the model prediction toward the
correct class within the top predicted classes, we propose the Image-Caption
Encoding (ICE) method, a straightforward approach that directly enforces
consistency between the image-conditioned and caption-conditioned predictions
at evaluation time only. Intuitively, we take advantage of unique properties of
the generated captions to guide our local search for the correct class label
within the Top-K predicted classes. We show that our method can be easily
combined with other SOTA methods to enhance Top-1 OOD accuracies by 0.5% on
average and up to 3% on challenging datasets. Our code:
https://github.com/Chris210634/ice | [
0.0212564599,
0.0989925489,
0.0213737041,
0.0529860184,
-0.0037449026,
0.0416576564,
0.0055665323,
0.0263675228,
-0.0079871593,
-0.0815638006,
-0.0064478558,
-0.0220163316,
0.0023516449,
0.0267120618,
0.0170351043,
-0.0444156453,
0.0090663144,
-0.0240174551,
-0.0242084619,
-0.0018763364,
-0.0032187582,
0.0024943233,
0.0133323595,
0.0235263146,
0.0257852282,
-0.0067356089,
0.0122898584,
0.0242717247,
0.0267923363,
-0.0212464966,
-0.0115255145,
0.0878278837,
0.0426677763,
0.0125094075,
0.0000019385,
-0.0277387705,
0.0199559778,
0.0105628744,
-0.011444428,
-0.0218498372,
0.018732639,
-0.0736502111,
0.0145810349,
-0.0218858756,
-0.00238933,
-0.0648987964,
0.0847466365,
0.0154571235,
0.0043101483,
0.0661851317,
-0.0253889319,
-0.0238451175,
0.012026038,
-0.0341868736,
0.0318152681,
-0.0160249397,
0.0137324166,
0.0139365196,
-0.053694848,
-0.003139619,
-0.0608090274,
0.0237587802,
0.0036814762,
0.0138117243,
0.003031783,
0.0702946484,
-0.0600814559,
-0.0413478985,
-0.0086723268,
0.0793847963,
-0.0306257829,
-0.0171436351,
-0.0218874793,
-0.0095717814,
-0.0020741071,
-0.0212042984,
-0.038162455,
0.0640112609,
0.0117957983,
0.048810266,
-0.0247516204,
0.0598003268,
-0.0098762894,
-0.0099225696,
-0.0241007321,
-0.0282353293,
0.0179970227,
0.0291627552,
-0.0414177254,
0.0183320213,
-0.1008903682,
-0.0436299555,
-0.0412522852,
-0.0091746477,
0.0253005363,
-0.0082556829,
-0.0586554371,
-0.0332647003,
0.00558769,
-0.0163923074,
0.0680708885,
0.0111689139,
-0.046414461,
0.0628453195,
-0.0028131355,
0.0358112752,
0.0033777659,
0.0588487014,
-0.0244738348,
-0.0192832053,
-0.0487329289,
0.0183236487,
-0.0086680455,
0.021800926,
-0.00581977,
-0.0166361947,
-0.0414697602,
-0.021106068,
-0.0185098574,
0.0177642889,
0.009259792,
0.0427104868,
-0.036879573,
-0.0172324646,
-0.0100312214,
0.0358072855,
0.0196436699,
0.0042861439,
-0.0427713096,
-0.0577280596,
-0.025885677,
0.0673135445,
0.0261633657,
0.0149124172,
0.0012930699,
0.0687985346,
-0.0220208541,
-0.063891843,
-0.0327561721,
-0.0127778416,
-0.0396667756,
-0.0345767103,
0.0123650255,
-0.0592368729,
-0.0328222886,
0.0035598739,
0.0037914738,
-0.047234375,
0.0292509496,
0.0150868846,
-0.024425678,
0.0773516595,
-0.0353397839,
-0.0344787762,
0.0056853979,
0.0028587957,
0.0028144992,
0.1031283066,
0.0004012565,
-0.0106089469,
-0.009774372,
0.0173927899,
0.0779384449,
0.0502299257,
0.0082593057,
0.0160767585,
-0.0583418496,
-0.0108274957,
0.0306975394,
-0.0156218996,
0.0659351349,
-0.0173292607,
-0.013839242,
-0.0210391432,
0.0380158164,
0.0086210556,
-0.0207112674,
-0.0038762584,
0.0171237718,
-0.0104588419,
-0.0411681943,
0.0053639272,
-0.0387067944,
0.0436461493,
0.0090221753,
0.0165126007,
-0.0128492387,
0.0220173057,
-0.0513741076,
-0.0414533652,
-0.019956382,
-0.0329883657,
-0.0165241826,
0.006465435,
0.0886614695,
0.0352216586,
-0.0236710608,
0.0411843434,
0.0548917167,
0.0017755853,
-0.0215869285,
-0.0491475239,
0.0187512711,
0.0410145298,
0.0403652899,
-0.0078520821,
-0.0191797316,
0.0046116877,
0.0201801974,
0.0698971525,
-0.0239382554,
0.0244511161,
0.0374199711,
-0.0615668595,
-0.0551824421,
0.0104537634,
0.0273778103,
0.0224325508,
-0.0076243766,
0.009535172,
0.0387202054,
-0.036327783,
-0.0404831283,
0.0343624242,
0.0526689179,
-0.0569543429,
0.0004587598,
0.0080594439,
-0.0083389478,
-0.0190485399,
-0.0330395065,
-0.0169737246,
-0.0056358026,
-0.0297423508,
-0.0187447965,
0.0065401644,
-0.044777602,
-0.0790830404,
0.013416009,
-0.0424642749,
0.0009914481,
-0.0171180461,
-0.0674216449,
-0.0179487169,
0.0582040846,
0.0025171041,
0.0265907031,
-0.0632215515,
-0.0253780559,
-0.0131968763,
0.0069789244,
0.0057525793,
0.0638340116,
-0.0237497631,
-0.0268571265,
0.0422310978,
-0.0384729244,
0.0203286372,
-0.0281808171,
-0.0171289667,
0.0148864286,
-0.0191621184,
0.0190801527,
0.0026707768,
0.0443776511,
-0.0508356616,
0.0193335786,
-0.0818449706,
-0.0326412283,
-0.0347575843,
-0.0220210683,
0.0054801586,
-0.0190166943,
-0.0024878331,
-0.0461335778,
-0.0132300323,
-0.0107403938,
-0.002965014,
-0.0144190686,
0.0275939479,
0.0111790886,
-0.0257961601,
0.0004668591,
0.0071139168,
0.016714517,
0.092275694,
-0.0323083512,
-0.0024092784,
-0.0459533334,
0.0679528341,
-0.0405816026,
0.0397294201,
-0.0098228781,
-0.0062486548,
-0.0120911514,
-0.0285824239,
-0.026285924,
0.034618482,
-0.0158188287,
-0.0190947279,
0.0120446058,
-0.0123386765,
-0.0111192139,
-0.0328881331,
0.0065569663,
-0.0796897188,
0.0273672435,
-0.0180253498,
-0.0398063101,
0.0614728555,
-0.0074902955,
-0.0063569923,
-0.0846716911,
0.0089438753,
-0.0046115103,
-0.0221291948,
-0.0460438207,
0.052566845,
0.0259080995,
0.0125797708,
-0.042772688,
-0.0464545228,
0.0407844149,
-0.0377606414,
-0.0258805174,
-0.0083673764,
0.0118927583,
-0.0284199901,
0.0504389703,
0.0195527039,
0.0147021608,
0.0511901118,
-0.0092981514,
-0.0252061225,
-0.0546903238,
-0.0121667525,
0.0134074343,
0.0596763566,
-0.047043927,
0.0262816995,
-0.0228844341,
-0.0133257154,
-0.0269268677,
-0.0310364161,
-0.0338518284,
0.0138907433,
-0.0976872891,
-0.0243310109,
-0.0294962358,
0.0066434662,
-0.0075727189,
0.0780184343,
-0.0054563498,
-0.0073053571,
-0.0067117154,
0.0528842919,
0.0518062413,
-0.0035995077,
-0.0668956488,
-0.0038464169,
-0.0058292304,
0.0561728254,
0.0097879134,
0.0356893726,
-0.0284979194,
0.0038682416,
0.0342323855,
0.0430696048,
-0.002534535,
0.049819883,
0.0240527522,
-0.0317692645,
-0.0132615482,
0.0713493451,
0.0109542524,
-0.0375884064,
-0.0317790732,
0.0129757179,
0.0490669385,
0.0509421043,
-0.0138943335,
-0.0770016387,
-0.0789300278,
-0.042848967,
0.0044256668,
0.0099819452,
0.0101508861,
-0.0245114136,
-0.0945209861,
0.0675487593,
0.0377672352,
-0.0512273461,
-0.0438065939,
0.013638515,
-0.0027956136,
-0.0171535071,
-0.0626992807,
-0.0047390345,
0.0314768851,
0.0323820151,
0.0148772243,
0.0177870486,
-0.0527804717,
0.0228297524,
-0.0390683562,
0.0031453911,
0.0759200305,
-0.0158327986,
0.0073001324,
-0.034509182,
-0.0158123579,
-0.0700570196,
0.0105120325,
-0.0110611124,
0.0887525231,
-0.0220343769,
-0.0215597432,
0.0334316194,
0.0405124426,
-0.0418153815,
-0.018981332,
-0.0258865878,
0.0305973571,
0.0206785128,
-0.0221515503,
-0.0499017239,
-0.0065063182,
0.0201465636,
0.0286744405,
0.0181780998,
-0.002901254,
-0.0191094317,
-0.0415719263,
-0.0161960535,
-0.0535595156,
0.0259819012,
0.0117406305,
0.0324839875,
-0.0658570826,
-0.0463362113,
0.0060884603,
0.027329823,
0.0265282393,
-0.0270274468,
-0.0336455218,
-0.0408879034,
0.0074196914,
-0.0619204231,
0.0122761391,
-0.0610570908,
-0.0093544852,
-0.0133355567,
-0.0203755591,
0.0841018632,
-0.0422974937,
-0.0259664375,
0.0462680869,
-0.046066612,
-0.0285582114,
-0.0421291143,
0.0670512617,
0.015105309,
0.0299921259,
0.0311233588,
-0.0257548057,
0.0798034295,
0.0801997781,
0.069990553,
0.0328972116,
0.0324822217,
-0.0122007644,
0.017302582,
0.0418378115,
-0.0221337173,
0.0377784707,
0.0191483442,
-0.0184526835,
-0.0121807763,
0.03440791,
0.0024950495,
-0.0260386858,
0.0685101449,
-0.0533703677,
-0.0063436497,
-0.0085098427,
0.0183912795,
-0.003430346,
-0.0028160776,
-0.0652066171,
0.0225752182,
0.0342425779,
0.0313616395,
-0.0013020297,
0.0310989544,
-0.0486872569,
0.0343807079,
-0.0122705363,
-0.0140695628,
0.0631555691,
-0.0248176288,
0.0055156592,
0.010782551,
0.0098694395,
0.0167897549,
-0.0017550098,
0.0449607745,
-0.0212297384,
0.0596838295,
0.0233776718,
0.0191580299,
-0.0516810007,
0.005411583,
-0.0180663802,
0.0369600803,
-0.0767785087,
0.0722160265,
0.0384329185,
-0.0044097514,
-0.0085240789,
-0.0078423638,
-0.0173121188,
-0.0144497789,
0.0310463663,
-0.0236280188,
-0.0634791031,
0.032271307,
0.0063542384,
-0.0061226683,
-0.0107000051,
0.1019546688,
0.0549401268,
0.0207808763,
-0.0146922823,
0.0092826756,
-0.0189841539,
0.024886366,
0.0316679962,
-0.0172708835,
0.0134936478,
0.0497801118,
-0.0209891647,
-0.0579759367,
0.012332554,
0.0115748411,
0.0174208656,
0.0297417603,
0.0451581068,
0.0290158205,
0.0245022606,
-0.0285700448,
-0.0081873927,
-0.0349707715,
0.0103745591,
0.0169097949,
-0.0216350723,
-5.995354001e-33,
-0.0096622519,
-0.0331396982,
0.019546926,
0.0015989169,
0.0266157016,
0.0146124028,
-0.0184362605,
0.0126149757,
-0.0254144035,
-0.0001324018,
0.0198772456,
-0.0079542631,
0.0172981787,
0.0587934479,
0.0251301005,
-0.0283982288,
0.01458898,
-0.0208607111,
-0.015421574,
0.0145275528,
0.0083336504,
0.0045493878,
0.0635582656,
-0.0128745008,
-0.0015783199,
-0.017699223,
-0.0384899229,
-0.0020262022,
0.0342547633,
0.0405450277,
0.0014722367,
0.0489041358,
0.017020883,
-0.0209745038,
-0.0263745598,
-0.0238932669,
-0.0295747202,
-0.0197337568,
0.004499075,
0.0172680244,
-0.0076179029,
0.0168775078,
0.016928019,
-0.0176400468,
-0.0162918512,
-0.0621188171,
0.0456010662,
-0.0359375849,
0.0136740431,
-0.0179755427,
-0.0462875925,
0.0270733833,
-0.0124764666,
-0.0388321988,
0.0471177399,
0.0288756918,
0.0401107743,
0.0482457951,
-0.0387758985,
0.0233054031,
0.0259005092,
0.0358439609,
0.0909871981,
0.0610552728,
-0.004668361,
0.045355808,
-0.00530747,
-0.0219296254,
-0.0402036235,
-0.0422507264,
0.0273780636,
0.0369355865,
0.0265944395,
0.058740586,
0.0738283992,
0.018145822,
-0.0569383539,
0.0200936515,
-0.0815520659,
-0.0050863102,
-0.0026815608,
0.0406148583,
-0.0240009893,
-0.0378342047,
-0.033315666,
-0.071393393,
-0.0397397019,
0.0079616401,
0.0233259425,
0.0371022522,
-0.0230155196,
0.013452176,
0.0549269579,
-0.0291778035,
-0.0151609499,
0.007705417,
-0.0317402855,
0.0646468401,
-0.0067722672,
-0.0198531896,
-0.0610355437,
-0.0312011428,
0.0654059798,
0.0289115664,
0.0021239137,
0.0125250015,
0.1091161147,
0.0348042473,
-0.0433928706,
-0.0082800006,
-0.0384445675,
0.0022852009,
-0.0121067427,
0.0459156781,
-0.0091924202,
0.0258896258,
-0.0433227979,
0.034675274,
-0.0088463034,
0.0137222251,
-0.024217993,
0.0165125877,
-0.0056291954,
0.0200314038,
-0.0298871435,
0.0171571728,
-0.0018095631,
-0.0388522744,
0.0283043589,
-0.0333696753,
-0.0268285293,
0.0398794748,
2.546e-7,
0.0502541363,
0.0066439705,
-0.0009100849,
-0.0075928131,
0.0030239681,
0.086158596,
-0.0304461475,
0.0320846885,
0.022791706,
-0.0626753941,
0.0246844776,
0.0327092037,
0.0287813749,
-0.0183325652,
-0.048618108,
0.0592719987,
-0.0116115408,
-0.0231592767,
-0.0382421389,
-0.0265750624,
0.0405967049,
0.1224014014,
-0.0081702489,
-0.0125472937,
0.0526816212,
-0.0551845171,
0.0878280327,
-0.0015999326,
0.0305804666,
-0.0449006781,
-0.0252121761,
0.0370223522,
-0.0176049229,
0.0447332002,
-0.007818005,
-0.0081606219,
0.0352377333,
0.0140579958,
-0.0444002189,
-0.0112286098,
-0.0195631571,
0.0711483136,
-0.0256503243,
-0.0464714468,
0.0722991973,
-0.0629184321,
-0.0153996963,
-0.0335624404,
-0.0166750774,
0.0150965061,
0.0355135724,
-0.0335876271,
-0.0190232433,
0.0270433873,
0.0397005007,
0.0056105927,
-0.0560349636,
-0.05080688,
-0.0328983553,
-0.0112192361,
-0.0402669571,
-0.0272984821,
-0.0326544568,
-0.0267328806,
0.0267306212,
-0.0287240837,
-0.0235819668,
1.984166736e-34,
0.0470556021,
0.0080943014,
-0.0095356405,
-0.0172531605,
0.0052994541,
-0.0021058489,
-0.0261097327,
0.0097459201,
-0.0059896102,
-0.0622183718,
-0.0139422091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02658v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02658v1 | Multi-step Problem Solving Through a Verifier: An Empirical Analysis on Model-induced Process Supervision | 2024-02-05T00:57:51 | 2024-02-05T00:57:51 | Zihan Wang, Yunxuan Li, Yuexin Wu, Liangchen Luo, Le Hou, Hongkun Yu, Jingbo Shang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Process supervision, using a trained verifier to evaluate the intermediate
steps generated by reasoner, has demonstrated significant improvements in
multi-step problem solving. In this paper, to avoid expensive human annotation
effort on the verifier training data, we introduce Model-induced Process
Supervision (MiPS), a novel method for automating data curation. MiPS annotates
an intermediate step by sampling completions of this solution through the
reasoning model, and obtaining an accuracy defined as the proportion of correct
completions. Errors in the reasoner would cause MiPS to underestimate the
accuracy of intermediate steps, therefore, we suggest and empirically show that
verification focusing on high predicted scores of the verifier shall be
preferred over that of low predicted scores, contrary to prior work. Our
approach significantly improves the performance of PaLM 2 on math and coding
tasks (accuracy +0.67% on GSM8K, +4.16% on MATH, +0.92% on MBPP compared with
an output supervision trained verifier). Additionally, our study demonstrates
that the verifier exhibits strong generalization ability across different
reasoning models. | [
-0.0296018887,
0.012286487,
-0.0109276827,
-0.029457327,
0.0000296417,
0.0077459086,
0.0371657871,
-0.000718064,
-0.0174454767,
-0.0182177238,
0.0263333097,
0.04180241,
0.0164161101,
0.0095144259,
0.0027849085,
-0.0529647879,
0.0658915192,
-0.0503040515,
0.0341481715,
0.0000494039,
-0.0407503583,
-0.0199912116,
-0.0337533318,
0.0470656306,
-0.0666488335,
-0.0479564779,
-0.0198945869,
-0.0495671146,
0.0064415131,
-0.0371824875,
0.0078083463,
0.0547420718,
0.0178605001,
0.0271981638,
0.0000023783,
-0.0322628506,
0.0160651989,
0.0144408774,
-0.0609203093,
-0.0228510741,
-0.0616965108,
0.0308593698,
-0.0257627647,
0.045401711,
-0.0361241996,
-0.0086829923,
0.009175865,
0.0659261793,
0.0657827556,
0.0262386501,
-0.0045183939,
-0.0155156944,
0.0264505204,
0.0334894732,
0.0030874861,
-0.019022163,
0.0194887891,
0.085581474,
0.0487747788,
-0.0245894659,
0.017562177,
0.0120057976,
0.0622376986,
-0.0346421078,
-0.0023578748,
0.0254432522,
0.0610635392,
-0.0218968689,
-0.012348826,
0.0057139429,
-0.005355007,
-0.0287894607,
-0.0289914552,
-0.0084949639,
-0.0048167268,
0.0391286574,
-0.0302301925,
0.0195263028,
-0.0472016297,
-0.0123497546,
-0.0153957615,
-0.0401306339,
0.0173372477,
-0.034498632,
-0.0189125147,
0.0576535277,
-0.0183370523,
-0.0487124994,
0.0535072759,
0.0518777966,
0.013620656,
-0.0662153959,
0.0480719805,
0.0588957332,
-0.0490954071,
-0.0069753649,
-0.0068937638,
-0.0484442115,
-0.0312607959,
-0.0402350351,
0.0386297517,
0.0453214459,
0.0192637295,
0.0121089155,
-0.0247673392,
0.0323545299,
-0.0351644419,
0.054755453,
-0.0257518385,
0.037698593,
-0.0806744769,
-0.0203372464,
-0.0345657282,
0.0368840657,
-0.0083999485,
0.0183892995,
-0.054170493,
0.0086761937,
-0.0386265554,
0.0462021716,
-0.0002417793,
0.009529667,
0.033397764,
0.0170408711,
-0.0447824821,
0.0214830302,
-0.0646143183,
0.0339312963,
0.0174941402,
-0.0056913346,
0.0059726555,
-0.0342374966,
-0.0299787223,
0.0074684834,
0.0365435444,
0.0616698377,
-0.0202854387,
0.0030061991,
-0.0523203239,
-0.0429975204,
0.0588886179,
-0.0871604607,
0.028314231,
-0.042538967,
0.0237348974,
-0.0157156326,
-0.0210744329,
0.0222941898,
0.001053871,
0.045169197,
0.0412224568,
0.0606935397,
-0.0080426922,
0.01021636,
0.0608997568,
0.0075054863,
-0.087778002,
0.0447568744,
0.0384991802,
-0.0376715958,
-0.0195556376,
-0.035968665,
0.051885929,
0.0033377577,
-0.0020482522,
-0.065005675,
0.0173686817,
-0.0238457154,
0.0357161686,
-0.0097029032,
-0.0200307965,
0.0223857593,
-0.0456335656,
0.0415450409,
0.0285025705,
0.0678416491,
-0.0165993348,
0.0032474736,
0.0594665743,
-0.0543476194,
0.0582254045,
0.0182118285,
-0.0818549916,
0.040858943,
-0.0426287651,
0.0042457124,
-0.0761733875,
-0.0129541252,
-0.0222804099,
-0.0940711871,
-0.0204861462,
0.0229721498,
-0.0127933053,
0.0305202492,
0.0692853853,
-0.0081228223,
-0.0241113752,
-0.0058239582,
-0.0032514145,
-0.0147368191,
-0.0335949026,
-0.0573712587,
0.0669585913,
0.0469252989,
0.0304930136,
-0.0367632546,
-0.0079403156,
-0.0431365445,
0.0193732269,
-0.076309897,
0.0266134609,
-0.0240740515,
0.0030195073,
-0.0334296934,
-0.0660426766,
-0.0229949579,
-0.0041822814,
0.0081405248,
0.0789247006,
-0.0243769735,
-0.0043720538,
0.0306058154,
-0.0326956846,
0.03536468,
-0.0209676474,
-0.032489676,
-0.0033900517,
0.0012887969,
0.018814873,
0.0000798834,
0.0118348887,
0.0057348516,
0.0314034373,
0.0143304886,
-0.000452596,
0.0036805186,
-0.0639744475,
0.009679025,
0.0434397385,
-0.053362038,
-0.0595323257,
-0.0105585912,
0.0163629036,
-0.0581844822,
-0.0098181227,
-0.0291900132,
-0.0397796705,
0.0005799732,
0.0553942174,
-0.0044607092,
-0.0671273544,
0.0189802144,
0.0581605919,
0.0361169502,
-0.0222215932,
0.0000786111,
-0.014778411,
0.0267282724,
-0.0272681359,
0.0081886593,
0.00473784,
-0.0236750823,
0.0298439171,
0.0086797662,
0.0120977089,
-0.0464861728,
0.0058245012,
-0.0714801475,
-0.0047081951,
0.008517867,
0.0180891231,
0.01332606,
-0.0220723953,
0.0129516674,
-0.0242454354,
-0.0226484612,
-0.026321305,
0.0378171317,
0.0132574392,
-0.0124784913,
0.0195638109,
-0.0125668831,
-0.0183698125,
-0.0284913294,
-0.0577990338,
0.0140130734,
0.0316418074,
0.0289649181,
-0.0435847901,
0.0293801166,
-0.0004857075,
0.0168007053,
0.0197181404,
0.0302751902,
0.0962242037,
-0.0102065764,
-0.0269310456,
0.0625999495,
-0.0271531176,
0.0180776753,
0.0526515618,
-0.0125889769,
-0.0344156399,
0.0214604735,
-0.002023235,
-0.0130954916,
0.0277499873,
-0.0032784806,
-0.0374828167,
0.0739235133,
-0.0133147985,
0.026799608,
-0.0373615883,
-0.0159708969,
-0.0001178464,
-0.0159975644,
-0.0202857032,
-0.0541525185,
-0.0162717104,
0.0542212985,
-0.0512503423,
-0.0329524353,
0.0717987716,
-0.0120158996,
-0.0032787854,
-0.0053970269,
-0.0084684994,
0.0445386507,
0.0279825367,
-0.0342191458,
-0.0093919737,
-0.0264577307,
-0.0045318129,
-0.0251829084,
-0.0289780684,
0.0505798198,
-0.0242910422,
-0.0019368038,
-0.074160561,
-0.0147201279,
0.0020376923,
-0.0439389125,
-0.0635246038,
0.039202746,
-0.0292451642,
0.0286219995,
-0.0295187701,
-0.0078028296,
0.0039527756,
-0.0105906008,
0.0515586399,
0.0398147441,
-0.0032023203,
-0.0613606684,
-0.0214208663,
-0.0482155643,
-0.0291634407,
-0.0178272109,
0.0313188992,
-0.0829277113,
0.0516650751,
0.0492696911,
0.0886677131,
-0.0224954449,
-0.0635320321,
0.0176256727,
-0.0021060344,
-0.0339070782,
-0.0218207389,
0.040729139,
0.0563607626,
-0.0755672976,
-0.0128627392,
0.0698642209,
0.022556873,
-0.0031864264,
-0.0074020494,
-0.0284159146,
-0.0510458685,
0.038654983,
0.0450434051,
-0.0352022871,
0.0034217217,
0.0182034373,
0.024422897,
-0.0060360958,
-0.0330812,
0.015588237,
-0.0953020379,
0.0437547527,
0.0178234484,
-0.0061616558,
-0.0037561506,
-0.0278383195,
-0.0069394466,
0.0147000086,
-0.0248044934,
-0.0025100186,
0.0163530782,
0.0032847973,
0.048572693,
0.0015034189,
-0.0090735257,
0.0293797851,
-0.0262281094,
-0.0293685962,
0.0501168817,
-0.0420560054,
0.0233787373,
-0.0610957183,
0.0640652031,
0.0088161482,
0.0329933055,
-0.012990742,
0.0182940904,
-0.0074911085,
0.0083032576,
-0.0084139267,
0.0228371788,
-0.0195013322,
-0.0188625902,
0.0358335562,
0.133588478,
-0.0232273173,
-0.0102002798,
-0.0268835593,
-0.0151218567,
-0.0132443681,
0.0104953423,
0.028626522,
-0.0153072579,
-0.0562347509,
-0.0203044191,
-0.0063553955,
0.0059015374,
0.0359585844,
0.0236539096,
-0.0131846517,
-0.024816446,
-0.0239448268,
-0.0553770661,
0.0806868225,
0.1151819751,
-0.0083092302,
-0.0534164868,
0.0507465564,
0.0245651957,
-0.0190873835,
0.0051893615,
-0.0250249393,
0.0605215952,
-0.0334435515,
0.0249161925,
-0.0476136915,
-0.0038184689,
-0.0032946437,
-0.022432657,
-0.0424215607,
-0.0301165711,
-0.0530537963,
0.0739444792,
0.0325984731,
0.0195523221,
-0.0379004441,
-0.004389016,
-0.0211597495,
-0.0517898463,
-0.035051886,
-0.0041356804,
0.0433498658,
-0.0377814882,
0.0077715763,
-0.0318698324,
-0.0113315359,
0.0255064722,
0.0161753576,
0.0013627666,
-0.0567214414,
-0.0488848276,
0.0230614059,
0.0288543031,
0.0616036654,
0.0098680072,
0.0166168753,
-0.0348130949,
0.01924715,
-0.017623568,
-0.0040652608,
-0.0264772642,
0.0265597198,
-0.0059464839,
0.0195843335,
0.0346392915,
-0.0360775031,
0.0111463219,
0.001431888,
0.0178932436,
-0.0041943262,
0.0003567898,
0.0419894792,
-0.0032534725,
0.0015179814,
-0.0212509278,
0.0000124481,
0.0397934765,
0.0329325497,
0.0137425046,
0.0745167583,
0.0206096582,
0.0514734164,
-0.041109331,
-0.02279469,
-0.0583889261,
-0.0675940961,
-0.0074691437,
0.0262287408,
0.0468172021,
-0.0072076842,
-0.0389782265,
-0.0144467726,
0.0088094594,
-0.0036600123,
0.0053943782,
0.0081311585,
0.0141030056,
0.0099257072,
0.0428440832,
0.0363589339,
-0.0700490028,
0.0210259017,
-0.036741849,
0.0524287559,
-0.0458804592,
-0.0390946791,
-0.0394668207,
-0.052505888,
-0.0200756192,
0.0342455283,
0.0028264772,
-0.032893952,
-0.0373725928,
-0.0805022642,
-0.0307468325,
0.0541858114,
-0.0044867592,
-0.0182846002,
0.0261845402,
0.0572606362,
-0.0042678867,
-0.0229585208,
0.0192815289,
-0.0629880503,
0.0461741686,
0.0065776291,
-0.0218428243,
-5.75606633e-33,
-0.0318353288,
-0.0509876013,
0.0464263558,
0.0133903939,
0.0138756661,
-0.040464431,
-0.0497535132,
0.0345242769,
0.0115187587,
0.0542081669,
-0.0325039439,
0.007231331,
0.0215183031,
-0.048606962,
0.0818071887,
0.0111830244,
0.0534306914,
-0.0217043385,
-0.0499290451,
-0.0055178511,
0.0340529606,
-0.0005032975,
0.0256920196,
-0.0812744275,
0.0027963861,
0.0217518825,
-0.0208135508,
0.0184375066,
-0.0662654191,
0.0505730771,
0.030154597,
-0.0070484593,
0.0317585915,
-0.0373382494,
-0.0273957141,
0.0069579524,
-0.0749221593,
-0.0399875008,
0.0023871071,
0.0124259926,
-0.0472704582,
-0.0084971283,
0.044521641,
-0.011029968,
-0.0454855077,
-0.0103351409,
0.0277942251,
-0.0248656515,
-0.0015162568,
-0.0309626814,
-0.0263811164,
-0.0032810981,
-0.0162227359,
-0.0453152508,
0.0312807672,
0.0388002507,
-0.0379783809,
-0.1013252512,
-0.0115154497,
0.0152793722,
0.0090077436,
-0.0289092585,
0.053442508,
0.0130930245,
-0.0113950064,
0.0233685654,
0.0289591923,
-0.0140804462,
-0.027125448,
-0.0128977336,
0.0164083298,
0.0842743665,
0.0713860244,
-0.0202910583,
0.0383889675,
-0.0113031873,
-0.0434018746,
0.0440912545,
-0.0233427659,
0.0697874725,
-0.0100537529,
0.0025811647,
-0.0636265501,
-0.0183231067,
-0.0332642645,
0.016929917,
-0.0206942447,
-0.0203423146,
0.0268643405,
0.0268502757,
-0.0036927224,
0.0122326557,
0.0158866104,
-0.0216662176,
0.0371540636,
-0.0241431445,
0.004547955,
0.03892681,
-0.0070312731,
-0.0206720624,
-0.0628457442,
-0.0156922955,
0.0228745919,
0.0164445937,
0.0503522642,
0.0457511842,
0.0223080106,
-0.001295365,
-0.0412720367,
0.0070275692,
-0.0491996929,
0.0167573038,
0.0592919663,
0.0063142469,
0.0568228178,
-0.0013274587,
-0.0013788501,
0.0418796241,
-0.0602231547,
0.008384198,
-0.0296026058,
0.0539272055,
0.0051181028,
0.0202715993,
0.0173858386,
-0.0224470906,
-0.0500355586,
0.0149422232,
0.0154597778,
-0.0315820277,
0.0096422825,
0.0329703987,
3.026e-7,
-0.0249365345,
-0.0121469852,
0.0344891027,
0.0120148594,
0.018315224,
0.0521443225,
0.001489998,
-0.0669364184,
0.0288376678,
-0.0657631308,
0.0070810812,
0.0458552092,
0.0398353152,
0.0509798191,
0.0135436729,
-0.0910925493,
-0.0018556205,
0.0192385707,
-0.0260584839,
0.0652836263,
0.065495722,
0.0093160709,
0.0522477329,
-0.0158452988,
0.0296527687,
-0.0001899675,
0.0546647646,
0.0203502867,
0.0418163724,
-0.0139053315,
0.0660266057,
-0.0031857346,
0.0268344209,
0.0590036735,
-0.0027319728,
0.0083431993,
-0.0312792957,
0.0463590287,
-0.0050816853,
0.0549310818,
0.0051032305,
-0.0138231218,
0.0082387906,
-0.0144637851,
0.0455196463,
-0.0400017947,
-0.0009466267,
-0.0161645487,
-0.0156104732,
-0.074377194,
-0.0066438373,
0.0187427886,
0.0544106327,
-0.0105267931,
-0.0283919331,
-0.001189806,
-0.0146566629,
-0.0378137454,
-0.0031042336,
0.0311934687,
-0.0078535052,
-0.03448008,
0.0012612967,
-0.0295916498,
0.052816838,
-0.0157092232,
-0.027737543,
2.614031506e-34,
-0.0097744633,
-0.0073818373,
0.0687790513,
0.0253308993,
0.0409383215,
0.0056761736,
-0.0113108912,
0.0083628949,
0.038414225,
-0.0168249309,
-0.0273891129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02656v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02656v1 | RACER: An LLM-powered Methodology for Scalable Analysis of Semi-structured Mental Health Interviews | 2024-02-05T00:56:30 | 2024-02-05T00:56:30 | Satpreet Harcharan Singh, Kevin Jiang, Kanchan Bhasin, Ashutosh Sabharwal, Nidal Moukaddam, Ankit B Patel | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.QM | Semi-structured interviews (SSIs) are a commonly employed data-collection
method in healthcare research, offering in-depth qualitative insights into
subject experiences. Despite their value, the manual analysis of SSIs is
notoriously time-consuming and labor-intensive, in part due to the difficulty
of extracting and categorizing emotional responses, and challenges in scaling
human evaluation for large populations. In this study, we develop RACER, a
Large Language Model (LLM) based expert-guided automated pipeline that
efficiently converts raw interview transcripts into insightful domain-relevant
themes and sub-themes. We used RACER to analyze SSIs conducted with 93
healthcare professionals and trainees to assess the broad personal and
professional mental health impacts of the COVID-19 crisis. RACER achieves
moderately high agreement with two human evaluators (72%), which approaches the
human inter-rater agreement (77%). Interestingly, LLMs and humans struggle with
similar content involving nuanced emotional, ambivalent/dialectical, and
psychological statements. Our study highlights the opportunities and challenges
in using LLMs to improve research efficiency and opens new avenues for scalable
analysis of SSIs in healthcare research. | [
0.0321931541,
0.0838238075,
-0.0214955229,
-0.0006311231,
-0.021821605,
0.0155574046,
-0.0021708261,
-0.0156603046,
0.0439756885,
-0.0181477126,
-0.0066522509,
0.0166370589,
-0.0364380963,
0.0571727492,
-0.0054339608,
-0.0440892838,
-0.0095864879,
0.0165525265,
0.0665962473,
0.0274840947,
-0.0042452142,
0.0294092372,
-0.0093080914,
0.0178841911,
0.0248163659,
-0.0387072861,
0.0026053844,
0.0408575051,
0.0329328105,
-0.0663750097,
-0.0078750001,
0.0158140194,
0.0168043021,
-0.0292237885,
0.000002644,
-0.0206478108,
-0.034724582,
-0.0052338215,
-0.0001434341,
-0.0306120031,
0.0256788954,
-0.0350361504,
-0.0089842658,
0.0197193641,
-0.0131536881,
-0.0577891506,
0.0205114689,
0.0451398976,
0.0765444487,
0.0602767207,
-0.0324957892,
-0.021534903,
-0.0243938435,
0.0016861375,
-0.0852435157,
-0.0025753679,
0.0116024036,
-0.0095159179,
0.0137101561,
-0.0189337842,
0.002103108,
0.0300966445,
-0.0366878957,
-0.0189096481,
0.0090763746,
-0.008419916,
-0.0393802747,
-0.0464726575,
0.0215615425,
0.0694006011,
0.0288301576,
0.0522522777,
0.0280800387,
-0.0337918922,
0.0206644498,
0.0178714208,
-0.0382482857,
0.0329940841,
-0.011215277,
-0.022964783,
-0.0250021964,
0.029740734,
-0.0070587806,
-0.0293953903,
-0.0211126134,
0.0508540235,
-0.0144629525,
-0.0363650285,
0.0079709813,
-0.0148177352,
0.0138205932,
-0.0480414703,
0.0237752236,
0.005916656,
-0.064648293,
0.0334245563,
0.0259910952,
-0.0161791053,
0.0373141468,
-0.0465241484,
-0.0389856845,
0.020509636,
-0.0316344276,
-0.0373138748,
0.079820849,
-0.0010060287,
0.0016066236,
0.0038694225,
-0.0545886606,
0.0302340575,
-0.0564377569,
0.0188802592,
-0.0046900278,
0.0007745372,
-0.0174651612,
0.0062922253,
-0.0449976027,
-0.0315469801,
-0.0181149058,
0.0247550402,
-0.0412726812,
-0.0207948945,
-0.0023553299,
0.0591693521,
0.0306871068,
0.036459323,
-0.0398936495,
0.0225611981,
-0.0009350157,
-0.0262912102,
0.042223908,
0.0194414407,
-0.0000759203,
-0.0161012169,
0.0019879723,
0.0114036184,
0.0137929656,
0.0125607196,
-0.0217147898,
-0.0432198904,
-0.0325215682,
-0.0316871963,
0.0203790162,
-0.0550585017,
0.0586716533,
0.0329378843,
0.0040235207,
-0.0592623949,
0.0143122785,
-0.0058679124,
-0.0555463247,
0.0051233768,
-0.0331020691,
0.0211288761,
0.0122756157,
0.040714059,
0.0614871085,
-0.0183296818,
0.0095310267,
0.0366599299,
0.0117509877,
-0.0633505359,
0.0153412055,
0.0144140804,
-0.0023590673,
-0.0222669952,
-0.0069523058,
0.0091040209,
0.0036228669,
0.0834502578,
0.0114786755,
0.053805545,
-0.0148589779,
0.0198149476,
0.0128776887,
0.1048377231,
-0.0316565558,
0.0331144147,
0.0130653409,
0.0810577944,
0.0173494183,
0.0119187264,
-0.0189092495,
-0.0273100995,
0.0513680466,
-0.0372686908,
0.0236388296,
0.0223948918,
-0.0167135913,
-0.0291243661,
-0.0324858204,
0.0127255628,
-0.0154232495,
0.075150229,
-0.0270992927,
-0.0483436026,
-0.0277686864,
0.0303053278,
0.0032864264,
-0.0556607544,
-0.0131304655,
-0.0496697798,
-0.0155040482,
0.078168802,
0.016460944,
-0.0207610726,
-0.0146912392,
-0.0568699092,
0.0253305081,
0.0343000479,
0.01129911,
0.0109362938,
-0.0116100516,
-0.0052095177,
0.0214289483,
0.0101453681,
0.0065307426,
0.0077084983,
-0.0540296771,
-0.0066628461,
-0.0269381423,
-0.0037310377,
-0.0689177886,
0.0340778306,
-0.0428540595,
-0.0498088561,
0.014428407,
-0.0328606181,
0.0402029604,
0.0425079763,
-0.0148019325,
0.0477922335,
0.0335020572,
-0.0214544069,
-0.0109521216,
0.0432208143,
0.0061481223,
0.020305017,
-0.0041008522,
-0.0203567799,
-0.0158345159,
0.0151989451,
-0.0341338664,
0.0182834305,
0.0322333388,
0.0090274541,
0.0009690688,
0.029723268,
0.0048867655,
0.0187219884,
0.0507563539,
-0.0285447985,
-0.0088655418,
-0.0113992915,
-0.0031270995,
-0.0361153558,
-0.0892209262,
-0.0139817437,
-0.0311923847,
-0.0081466641,
0.043148607,
-0.0011858116,
-0.005728866,
-0.0122685265,
-0.0311028007,
-0.0545494668,
-0.0349875689,
-0.1612955183,
0.0188141596,
0.0009363225,
0.0149298301,
0.0056039849,
-0.0101597812,
-0.0231371373,
0.0185202062,
-0.026712222,
-0.0612756796,
0.0476163775,
0.0265000761,
-0.0116326502,
0.0241308436,
-0.0032069031,
-0.0464283079,
-0.011393589,
-0.0622157566,
0.0354980417,
0.0115721272,
0.02698051,
-0.0108824903,
0.0051224739,
-0.0511436425,
-0.0478306599,
0.0019288039,
-0.0632158443,
0.0056115682,
0.0303300265,
0.0280334465,
0.0291746575,
-0.0003277957,
0.0439989977,
0.0258709472,
-0.0277193468,
-0.0175461974,
-0.0101126181,
0.0378008336,
-0.0393972732,
-0.0214913152,
-0.1018456221,
0.024394365,
0.0548475869,
0.0333356559,
0.0179702006,
0.0027822033,
0.0098882057,
-0.0176175628,
0.0142258164,
-0.0084830439,
-0.0395202897,
-0.0203368142,
0.0462443158,
0.0168360807,
-0.0062995618,
-0.0119256126,
0.0075588399,
0.0599364787,
-0.0736302584,
-0.04289205,
-0.0770245567,
0.027586218,
-0.0211113263,
0.0087551428,
0.0045924182,
0.0173429623,
0.0215439815,
-0.0954784453,
-0.0412198678,
-0.0527505651,
0.0220859982,
-0.0888671428,
-0.0047483156,
0.0045919004,
-0.0100086592,
-0.0201312806,
-0.0432929993,
-0.0549753904,
0.0032213232,
0.0616243072,
0.014922577,
-0.0359901451,
-0.0464979373,
0.0543308817,
0.0250174012,
0.0203632228,
-0.0063106725,
0.025778411,
0.0180368498,
0.0328871123,
-0.0258969739,
0.0527946912,
-0.0113531668,
0.062330965,
0.0538760424,
0.0237055421,
0.0496973842,
0.0020445869,
-0.0257191285,
-0.0128318192,
-0.0032091478,
-0.0245183948,
0.0194861945,
0.0484035313,
-0.0341974758,
0.0032317934,
0.1187790409,
0.0039721788,
-0.0248062909,
0.0236001145,
-0.0784846768,
-0.0387708396,
0.0105304113,
0.039628122,
-0.043766249,
0.0103333462,
-0.0191757623,
0.041777771,
-0.0369703695,
-0.0222224109,
0.0070424168,
-0.0245669764,
0.0615021959,
-0.0175237767,
-0.0118077761,
0.0215733889,
-0.0116600627,
0.0161198899,
0.00523098,
-0.0135719171,
-0.0217632707,
-0.0105577046,
0.0080238674,
0.0056776991,
-0.0921290219,
-0.022408234,
0.0704678148,
-0.0279654711,
0.0515951365,
0.0039699385,
0.0825358853,
-0.0270597897,
-0.0364893861,
0.0239472706,
0.0325134583,
-0.0179415811,
0.026475396,
0.0525453128,
0.0030215874,
0.0298945513,
-0.0307789762,
0.0624776818,
-0.0541649982,
-0.0073543894,
0.0424397215,
0.0859341621,
-0.0300336014,
-0.0283067171,
-0.0328157619,
0.0594989397,
0.0244573392,
0.0515949503,
0.0172692928,
-0.0269226804,
0.0238617007,
0.0286721829,
0.0449746512,
0.0049089054,
-0.0931898355,
0.0322255455,
-0.019629648,
0.02171476,
-0.0128524648,
-0.0551543422,
0.0537338667,
-0.0361049846,
-0.0233053919,
-0.0484977253,
0.055344712,
-0.0167492013,
-0.0597153269,
0.0592084751,
0.0265634563,
0.0622623488,
-0.0060267271,
-0.0015140199,
0.056921225,
0.0280378833,
0.0090609975,
0.0140755763,
-0.0348350443,
0.0029153414,
0.0706467405,
-0.0083507486,
0.0053063771,
-0.0114080096,
0.0810020864,
0.0127639771,
-0.012197759,
0.0088239051,
-0.0722414702,
0.000701388,
-0.0187329333,
0.076328963,
-0.0260870419,
0.0010471038,
0.0009280714,
0.0270109139,
0.0117269028,
0.0083125904,
-0.0324368142,
-0.0396371111,
0.0057766116,
0.0292038471,
0.0086299423,
-0.0098222299,
-0.0208101273,
-0.0172565989,
-0.0541418083,
-0.034408506,
-0.0161757879,
-0.0393440947,
-0.0122153908,
-0.0088232663,
-0.014782045,
-0.0405738093,
-0.0262767952,
-0.084348537,
0.0100081991,
-0.0422487333,
0.0926850587,
-0.0092597455,
-0.0514993295,
0.0014559572,
-0.0272798873,
0.0050281878,
0.0395429768,
-0.0160592645,
0.0548821725,
0.036445614,
0.0387861617,
-0.022446692,
0.0223436356,
0.0160504952,
0.0163101591,
-0.0177897997,
-0.1271606535,
-0.0083290422,
-0.0244941656,
0.0182415806,
-0.0108287977,
0.0250046439,
0.0107716564,
0.0082854703,
-0.0130162686,
-0.005398985,
-0.017157739,
0.0171649978,
0.0544284508,
0.0103761563,
-0.0392531753,
-0.0245120171,
0.0264970586,
0.0000545971,
0.0268775802,
0.0242014509,
-0.0355308391,
-0.0149867041,
-0.0318401977,
0.0465710722,
0.0055424101,
-0.036385294,
-0.000183145,
-0.0902822763,
-0.0329090953,
0.03000094,
-0.0341097377,
-0.033206813,
-0.059774939,
-0.0059433188,
0.0357963815,
0.0242796596,
-0.0229403991,
-0.0580024458,
0.0442611873,
-0.0419013426,
-0.0392477699,
0.0466578119,
-7.025805573e-33,
-0.0015755226,
-0.0543090887,
0.0065612928,
-0.0174779352,
-0.0493502766,
0.0256801527,
-0.0051961662,
0.0178921241,
-0.009074145,
0.0155178364,
-0.0227295775,
0.0267059617,
-0.0018241053,
0.031379208,
0.0423746482,
0.0046920911,
0.0442863293,
-0.0051696785,
-0.0058846218,
0.0186622534,
-0.0408905521,
0.0271926895,
0.0149424942,
-0.1105417758,
0.0564869456,
0.0042529758,
0.020840086,
-0.014730392,
0.0350464843,
0.0066088769,
-0.0206256602,
0.0316342935,
0.0303611718,
-0.0356977656,
0.0259765219,
0.0036771365,
-0.0057390081,
0.0125668906,
0.0353338569,
-0.0048668431,
-0.0471265912,
-0.0370200239,
0.0225344524,
-0.0140601378,
0.0000701331,
-0.0268584471,
0.0046246527,
-0.047035668,
0.02759392,
-0.060130842,
-0.0192571953,
0.0206865147,
-0.0528164543,
0.0330440737,
-0.0403328128,
0.065435946,
-0.0595573783,
0.0428990833,
-0.0478710346,
-0.038199462,
0.0037657882,
-0.0014569466,
0.0173972286,
-0.0395863205,
-0.0018358498,
0.0468276702,
0.0190851428,
-0.0173418596,
-0.0396973826,
0.0201996975,
-0.013980411,
0.0267308336,
0.0157246627,
0.0387259237,
-0.0048966454,
-0.0151467388,
-0.0410750955,
0.003496164,
-0.0080697639,
0.0352360867,
0.0393505655,
0.0340874307,
0.0056440388,
-0.0300997682,
-0.0538978279,
-0.0359288454,
-0.0001186468,
-0.0201385636,
0.0108738681,
-0.0229791682,
-0.0249800123,
-0.0017464253,
0.0395308696,
0.0039783828,
0.0180861801,
-0.0002527361,
-0.0127283176,
0.016885601,
-0.0084695173,
0.050582666,
-0.0584941059,
0.047435265,
-0.0092575112,
0.0043768664,
0.0945260003,
0.0107047288,
-0.0078515969,
-0.0442921408,
-0.0439612716,
-0.0085938657,
0.0164276883,
0.0119176405,
-0.0188674834,
0.0502130799,
-0.0250401758,
0.0273829866,
0.0117597114,
0.0280742906,
0.0246550888,
0.0140667791,
-0.0250677262,
-0.0170730446,
-0.0184628982,
0.0007636514,
-0.0359127074,
0.0121016847,
-0.0091707101,
0.0037194777,
0.0648246631,
-0.0504497029,
-0.0023337337,
-0.0193225145,
3.321e-7,
0.0194335151,
0.0833565518,
-0.024900157,
-0.0098526441,
0.0153049557,
0.0256877895,
0.0089482144,
0.0098286029,
0.0633325577,
-0.019303035,
0.0204534195,
0.0342261419,
0.0222641639,
0.0546453036,
-0.0353158638,
-0.0196443927,
-0.0138837071,
-0.0081232563,
-0.0743193775,
0.0262979455,
0.088559486,
0.0769647732,
-0.037291795,
0.0031421136,
-0.0229686629,
0.0586925894,
0.009234393,
-0.0222868286,
-0.0475629866,
0.0751080737,
0.001719862,
0.0016608044,
-0.0211591031,
0.0543541312,
-0.0119179329,
-0.0156513005,
0.0211547054,
0.0875465199,
-0.0177693479,
0.0142348735,
0.0201755483,
0.0111371316,
-0.0029907385,
-0.0255828816,
0.045345448,
-0.0933241546,
-0.0510083735,
-0.039885819,
-0.0611589253,
-0.0302462038,
0.0697871223,
-0.0271891467,
-0.0308785662,
0.0752556399,
0.0222547073,
-0.0209313761,
-0.0113268541,
-0.0157338195,
-0.0169632062,
0.0371843837,
-0.0504211336,
-0.021135781,
0.0132208494,
0.0122812772,
-0.0112063708,
-0.0458549634,
0.0506782308,
2.983976568e-34,
0.0596100204,
0.0660786778,
-0.0439086519,
0.0104974695,
0.0610385835,
-0.0027048357,
-0.0668622255,
0.0221985504,
-0.0216498543,
-0.0584974289,
0.02167348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02655v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02655v2 | VlogQA: Task, Dataset, and Baseline Models for Vietnamese Spoken-Based Machine Reading Comprehension | 2024-02-05T00:54:40 | 2024-04-06T04:29:58 | Thinh Phuoc Ngo, Khoa Tran Anh Dang, Son T. Luu, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu-Thuy Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the development process of a Vietnamese spoken language
corpus for machine reading comprehension (MRC) tasks and provides insights into
the challenges and opportunities associated with using real-world data for
machine reading comprehension tasks. The existing MRC corpora in Vietnamese
mainly focus on formal written documents such as Wikipedia articles, online
newspapers, or textbooks. In contrast, the VlogQA consists of 10,076
question-answer pairs based on 1,230 transcript documents sourced from YouTube
-- an extensive source of user-uploaded content, covering the topics of food
and travel. By capturing the spoken language of native Vietnamese speakers in
natural settings, an obscure corner overlooked in Vietnamese research, the
corpus provides a valuable resource for future research in reading
comprehension tasks for the Vietnamese language. Regarding performance
evaluation, our deep-learning models achieved the highest F1 score of 75.34% on
the test set, indicating significant progress in machine reading comprehension
for Vietnamese spoken language data. In terms of EM, the highest score we
accomplished is 53.97%, which reflects the challenge in processing spoken-based
content and highlights the need for further improvement. | [
0.038944602,
0.026247086,
-0.0013680094,
0.0295375921,
-0.0379392281,
0.035324268,
0.0102959778,
-0.0383218303,
0.0413507111,
-0.0133977653,
-0.0000072143,
-0.0418780446,
-0.0041685104,
0.0495078675,
-0.0200886112,
-0.0457150303,
0.0331429839,
-0.0262932964,
-0.0006388268,
0.0106666107,
0.0103972461,
0.0128493384,
-0.0281344969,
0.0032482271,
0.0681749508,
-0.0356315672,
-0.0219212957,
0.0260948129,
0.0280122496,
-0.0263286997,
-0.0074231792,
0.0316976979,
-0.0185150225,
0.0472543314,
0.0000015959,
-0.0116970614,
-0.0178755037,
-0.0374783017,
-0.0340906493,
0.0380001739,
0.058680702,
-0.0530156456,
0.0438621491,
0.0252985712,
-0.0089190025,
-0.0604273789,
0.0023274818,
0.0201997161,
0.0759870633,
0.0503587015,
-0.0207385197,
-0.0229612309,
0.0173839014,
-0.0045975773,
0.0494743884,
-0.0449635088,
0.0340035371,
0.0497021303,
0.0300734974,
-0.0191098358,
-0.03452098,
0.0758738518,
0.0358225778,
-0.0049830424,
0.0058082668,
0.0062319841,
0.0051391921,
-0.0294518191,
-0.0174794029,
0.1140860021,
0.0218287539,
-0.0155571289,
-0.0135000143,
0.0202672705,
-0.0093326485,
0.0136040132,
-0.0310895592,
-0.0200813096,
-0.0290827211,
0.0048496341,
0.0340764187,
-0.0184449907,
0.0347291082,
0.0215017572,
-0.0003094894,
-0.0019635058,
-0.0073681264,
-0.0241717044,
0.0006525176,
0.0060707354,
-0.0338916667,
0.0223238338,
0.0634739548,
0.0406937897,
-0.0091204485,
0.02030682,
0.0002567222,
-0.0182669945,
0.0178158022,
-0.0468695015,
-0.0012926224,
0.0553313605,
-0.0562742129,
0.0567126833,
-0.0046002702,
0.0474298745,
-0.0397062637,
0.041452948,
-0.0742215514,
-0.0261443984,
0.0002494907,
-0.0056403992,
-0.0193515141,
0.0282627754,
-0.0505720973,
-0.0399737768,
-0.0036331443,
0.0217647385,
0.0340742506,
-0.0135106668,
0.0051519996,
0.0152346464,
-0.0652608126,
-0.0012525452,
-0.0092139561,
0.0329912864,
-0.0350693762,
0.0564267039,
-0.000650827,
-0.0397385731,
0.0263456553,
0.0022245059,
0.0134578478,
-0.0224361978,
-0.0031359824,
0.0241829026,
-0.0344684906,
0.0039367378,
-0.014324056,
0.0195060186,
0.0303252507,
-0.0280452669,
0.0234245267,
-0.0342868008,
0.044743225,
0.0120952772,
0.0304197464,
0.0235400833,
-0.0153240105,
0.0256081764,
-0.0163750928,
0.0969025567,
0.0220790282,
-0.0018556382,
0.0684423596,
0.0414702222,
-0.0154666863,
0.0374470465,
0.0155601073,
0.0030755925,
0.0642872751,
-0.0155351292,
-0.017549092,
0.0215312187,
-0.0268329177,
-0.0039506662,
0.0172516778,
0.0521758869,
-0.0605177395,
0.0415802561,
0.0022375179,
0.0614507645,
-0.0323939882,
-0.0338814929,
0.0315031148,
0.0175974537,
0.0152671281,
0.0042294702,
0.033921551,
0.0464849025,
0.0383017324,
0.0341575108,
-0.0283557232,
-0.0026717368,
-0.0039576469,
0.0240611527,
0.0376669839,
-0.0246727094,
-0.0282678474,
-0.0581860989,
0.0221412107,
0.0075286585,
0.0089097582,
0.0303608961,
0.0432817563,
0.0112949423,
-0.0548055544,
-0.0020045573,
0.0029993425,
0.0122446436,
0.0450580232,
-0.0077728182,
0.0322816297,
0.0306175835,
0.0433684587,
-0.0099420287,
-0.0123150526,
-0.0062083588,
0.0145304604,
0.0180755034,
0.0301582552,
-0.0310005695,
0.0394644178,
-0.0427585095,
0.0261420663,
0.033865761,
-0.0079959529,
0.0273089092,
0.0066981255,
0.0235483833,
-0.0016697908,
-0.0495237187,
-0.026320314,
0.0261132382,
-0.0193183497,
-0.0298295468,
0.0025397968,
0.0239243321,
0.017686272,
0.0433645099,
0.0039544371,
-0.0229614899,
0.0356142372,
-0.0359792411,
0.031697493,
-0.0164026823,
-0.0245002769,
-0.0345218554,
0.010772842,
-0.0945351198,
-0.003332718,
0.0892150626,
-0.0102959424,
-0.0356103294,
-0.0128898798,
-0.0112157064,
-0.0305780787,
-0.101654999,
0.0050695995,
-0.0243708063,
0.0558487698,
-0.0162444543,
0.0180937834,
-0.0242506135,
0.020618489,
0.0486072153,
0.020847993,
0.0123634459,
-0.0191603787,
-0.0242118612,
0.0200646166,
-0.0033005655,
0.0194224399,
-0.0175435673,
0.0195047874,
-0.0645408407,
-0.0103823999,
-0.0880096182,
0.0392672829,
-0.0170288458,
0.0095045818,
0.037239328,
0.0019575292,
-0.0321426094,
-0.0402767174,
0.0335745625,
0.0053676423,
0.0131954243,
-0.0024820417,
0.0012948741,
0.0439344496,
0.0338016115,
-0.0423777811,
-0.0568616502,
0.0087867836,
0.0184745155,
0.0184452087,
-0.0214245841,
-0.024590373,
-0.0298199616,
0.003574868,
-0.0390153788,
-0.006121248,
-0.0505003333,
-0.0288511179,
-0.0335754864,
0.0005682055,
0.0501206405,
-0.0051659751,
0.0453703627,
0.0023468921,
-0.0021104806,
-0.0295838155,
0.0101871928,
-0.0116092842,
0.0075458148,
-0.0574302934,
-0.0069448561,
-0.0717611685,
0.0418146774,
0.0141786067,
0.019464206,
-0.0051891743,
-0.0169077553,
-0.0256525483,
-0.0284445249,
-0.0457981154,
0.039015118,
-0.0222279076,
0.0450591668,
-0.0545139313,
-0.0118784122,
0.1094031706,
-0.0107024368,
-0.0383166485,
-0.071937941,
0.0117363157,
-0.0273968913,
0.0392888002,
0.0031420118,
-0.0145952515,
-0.0355398953,
-0.0752839819,
-0.0148852924,
0.0298631154,
-0.0144326231,
-0.0353719853,
0.0508597568,
-0.019002514,
-0.0166236293,
-0.0023203832,
0.0044950093,
-0.0584732443,
-0.0045033093,
-0.0425027236,
-0.0226172414,
-0.0060643028,
0.0090829488,
-0.0311175529,
0.0353646763,
0.014029678,
0.0097580943,
-0.007541697,
0.0040696822,
-0.0390992761,
0.1129664779,
0.0556082688,
0.0104063703,
0.0066809077,
-0.0259610675,
0.0724163353,
-0.0042204824,
0.0295480266,
0.0063032876,
0.0116427951,
0.0389402211,
0.0228850991,
-0.0267095994,
0.03843005,
-0.0235533398,
0.0084213223,
-0.0670060441,
0.0049276114,
0.0762481093,
0.0187814999,
-0.0492528081,
-0.0279524382,
-0.013539861,
0.0197156221,
0.0054051853,
0.0371723697,
-0.0995257348,
-0.0261688475,
0.0042037945,
-0.0012689809,
0.0277419332,
-0.0022581774,
-0.0232117251,
-0.0782492533,
0.0075684064,
-0.0158184227,
-0.0161597375,
-0.0452770256,
-0.0433629155,
-0.0028718144,
-0.0243334677,
0.057511799,
0.018678939,
-0.0072348746,
-0.0259424318,
0.0061667818,
0.0010515893,
-0.0167275202,
0.0393449292,
-0.0125854528,
-0.0088903001,
0.0254822522,
0.0276846942,
-0.0134835215,
-0.0002349384,
0.0255708806,
-0.0681428835,
-0.0364787765,
0.0090182284,
0.044723209,
-0.0173855126,
-0.0222963393,
-0.0395268239,
0.0641366243,
-0.0472725779,
0.0229403917,
0.0128418012,
0.0640159622,
0.0004027636,
-0.0472490378,
-0.040545918,
0.0339259394,
0.0137465205,
0.0629304722,
0.0276454091,
-0.0536880307,
-0.0535057411,
-0.0028101564,
-0.0361147486,
-0.0638261586,
-0.0202981886,
0.0229349546,
0.0198710579,
-0.0150481658,
-0.0360447057,
-0.1066669524,
0.0020728763,
0.004811205,
0.0146973133,
0.0343024246,
0.0319001004,
0.0204187445,
-0.0551225394,
0.0364601426,
-0.0193060171,
0.0168157481,
-0.0207227934,
-0.0024384107,
-0.0071333633,
-0.0594499893,
-0.0084507558,
0.0209906232,
-0.0779247656,
-0.0168193001,
0.0196715891,
-0.0027450121,
0.0225868281,
0.071778886,
-0.0324355438,
-0.0401439033,
0.0196387842,
0.0034437783,
-0.0571907945,
-0.0318931118,
-0.0170676541,
-0.0131300027,
-0.0226130355,
0.0402274914,
0.0051207887,
0.0070559136,
-0.0559102371,
0.0238574371,
-0.0147345234,
-0.0340815261,
-0.0171541348,
-0.0171674285,
0.0241937172,
0.0027168938,
0.0091055259,
-0.0759486929,
0.011225489,
0.0002013408,
0.0120159518,
0.0050509511,
-0.0070845122,
0.0618730672,
-0.0467283204,
-0.0462679379,
0.0082860608,
-0.0178873651,
0.0063635856,
0.0251627173,
0.036181692,
0.0247767549,
0.0584448874,
0.0029192187,
-0.025644768,
-0.011377953,
0.011037237,
-0.01638305,
0.0604791194,
0.017201338,
0.0806814283,
0.0020076169,
-0.0110035734,
0.0160266273,
0.0086525427,
-0.0482755601,
-0.0131632145,
-0.0071408362,
0.0336605422,
0.0388312377,
-0.0344914645,
0.0068113627,
-0.0121735185,
-0.0198504515,
-0.0500419475,
0.0024766917,
-0.0247198474,
-0.0212388467,
0.0313949026,
0.0238470733,
0.0261161942,
0.0626329333,
0.0545388758,
0.0250345897,
0.0224363152,
0.052281104,
0.009612564,
-0.0403261706,
-0.0184773859,
-0.0164175294,
0.0625294968,
-0.0496673957,
0.0043087602,
-0.0196669362,
-0.0781512558,
0.0345858447,
-0.0006151731,
0.0192981269,
0.0084872944,
-0.0553011224,
0.065835841,
0.0028210462,
-0.0145984795,
-0.0673634857,
0.0308057684,
-0.0971883535,
-0.0080224955,
0.0283835065,
-5.862157634e-33,
-0.0288906023,
-0.0036702179,
-0.0075699198,
-0.0205478501,
0.0086857108,
0.0243511032,
-0.0324296206,
0.0045460989,
-0.0526179671,
0.0040951408,
-0.0240880139,
0.0383167304,
0.0318366922,
0.0434496514,
-0.0248243846,
-0.0280426815,
0.0118319644,
-0.00328554,
0.0122508202,
0.0304737352,
-0.0072048218,
0.0763969868,
0.0209113881,
-0.0547723323,
0.0552341118,
-0.0408078544,
0.0094789797,
0.0181927569,
0.0298432391,
0.0523136556,
-0.080411382,
0.0347196311,
0.0493674465,
0.0119419228,
0.0007167484,
0.0459159017,
-0.1584806442,
0.0011137386,
0.0182699896,
0.0696245134,
-0.0914376676,
-0.009217347,
0.0017129343,
-0.0025410878,
0.0590064526,
-0.0401472375,
0.0379653573,
-0.0268881954,
0.0071083,
0.0573413484,
-0.0337366201,
-0.005053747,
-0.0256416388,
-0.0261765234,
0.0264781732,
0.0790825188,
-0.0068084938,
0.0424201973,
-0.0978205726,
-0.0168184675,
-0.0256919395,
-0.0036843289,
0.0280161481,
0.0298986975,
-0.0164129641,
0.0148949455,
0.0201029647,
-0.073767826,
-0.0158283673,
-0.002545519,
0.0360902213,
0.0049105142,
-0.0082034376,
0.0604773313,
0.0940413401,
-0.0058701569,
-0.0497584902,
0.0136703383,
-0.0101199634,
0.0068188077,
0.010523418,
-0.0412980318,
-0.0383610874,
0.0289625432,
-0.0429500863,
-0.0497401245,
-0.0501446016,
-0.041565422,
0.0274351146,
-0.0195024703,
-0.0551499315,
0.0177053493,
0.0971790627,
-0.0692624971,
0.0000860481,
0.0362045057,
-0.0141194221,
0.0029599732,
-0.0312992558,
0.1051888019,
-0.0384042189,
0.0047023282,
-0.014234555,
0.0125004668,
-0.014815174,
-0.0037061223,
-0.0086511606,
-0.0129571129,
-0.0157568157,
-0.0103119621,
-0.0043483516,
0.0020973494,
-0.0476229005,
0.1021464542,
0.0281602219,
0.0406572819,
-0.0168315768,
0.0517755486,
-0.0094336495,
0.0369933359,
-0.0314491019,
-0.0270409808,
-0.0069188955,
0.0038203164,
-0.0405775309,
-0.0125745004,
-0.0453113057,
0.0062559051,
-0.0094158696,
-0.0549301058,
0.0482971668,
0.0426550396,
2.29e-7,
0.0340786316,
-0.0100912442,
0.0863329247,
0.0049743503,
-0.0046968767,
0.0008318974,
0.0207013488,
0.0048461999,
0.0303859748,
-0.0530210845,
0.0337311178,
0.0586170927,
0.0617518574,
-0.0216729082,
-0.0839072317,
-0.0418410636,
-0.0207426231,
0.0373283662,
-0.0473375358,
-0.0439313464,
0.0503992066,
0.0838934407,
-0.0387662277,
-0.0344191529,
-0.0023025761,
-0.025205411,
0.0317209847,
0.0188293029,
-0.0087996321,
0.0466368906,
0.0517334342,
0.0294879023,
-0.0028634293,
-0.015444654,
0.0041305008,
-0.0119092194,
0.0558860265,
0.0591867119,
0.0514623821,
-0.0505623892,
-0.041437678,
0.0058082882,
0.0052110823,
-0.0482606106,
0.067960389,
-0.0175633896,
-0.0211373437,
0.0111125065,
-0.0388222784,
-0.0009380021,
0.0169373024,
0.0037002808,
-0.027559774,
0.0508330464,
0.0362357311,
-0.0690350905,
-0.0128675029,
-0.0287673026,
-0.0538138896,
-0.0329397693,
-0.0360289887,
0.0300048571,
-0.0248585977,
-0.0250030477,
0.0392170288,
-0.0522637255,
0.0121242628,
1.375119809e-34,
0.0284390766,
-0.0031784945,
-0.0047980528,
-0.0008602867,
0.0248281676,
-0.0337440036,
-0.0209916905,
-0.0075373235,
-0.0012929339,
-0.0713992938,
0.0013617327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02648v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02648v2 | Recursive Chain-of-Feedback Prevents Performance Degradation from Redundant Prompting | 2024-02-05T00:44:28 | 2024-03-01T10:46:01 | Jinwoo Ahn, Kyuseung Shin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) frequently struggle with complex reasoning
tasks, failing to construct logically sound steps towards the solution. In
response to this behavior, users often try prompting the LLMs repeatedly in
hopes of reaching a better response. This paper studies such repetitive
behavior and its effect by defining a novel setting, Chain-of-Feedback (CoF).
The setting takes questions that require multi-step reasoning as an input. Upon
response, we repetitively prompt meaningless feedback (e.g. 'make another
attempt') requesting additional trials. Surprisingly, our preliminary results
show that repeated meaningless feedback gradually decreases the quality of the
responses, eventually leading to a larger deviation from the intended outcome.
To alleviate these troubles, we propose a novel method, Recursive
Chain-of-Feedback (R-CoF). Following the logic of recursion in computer
science, R-CoF recursively revises the initially incorrect response by breaking
down each incorrect reasoning step into smaller individual problems. Our
preliminary results show that majority of questions that LLMs fail to respond
correctly can be answered using R-CoF without any sample data outlining the
logical process. | [
0.0558004081,
0.0068671368,
-0.0251057148,
0.0118761677,
-0.0492198318,
0.0133010494,
-0.0162533727,
0.014796488,
0.0276887789,
-0.0219075456,
0.0426466912,
-0.0049344422,
0.0251060911,
-0.0041120723,
0.0212045107,
-0.0649009496,
0.0319780409,
-0.0605023354,
0.0218658336,
-0.0522727631,
-0.0163860954,
-0.0387959443,
-0.0260067154,
0.0333859175,
0.0170029532,
-0.0411112197,
-0.0432498418,
-0.0137344263,
-0.051116854,
-0.0794062316,
-0.00593078,
0.045094464,
-0.0110393204,
0.043279957,
0.0000024594,
-0.0759039521,
0.0321772806,
-0.0118495291,
-0.0519307815,
0.033985354,
-0.0159951709,
0.0440490991,
0.0299935769,
0.0580500029,
0.0002212126,
-0.0058740843,
0.0239221901,
0.0464217775,
0.055351451,
0.0144332815,
0.0196663346,
-0.0094566429,
-0.0094533414,
0.0032187267,
0.0466868356,
-0.026771538,
-0.0019120077,
0.0456922837,
0.0653781071,
0.0262698941,
-0.0288560558,
0.0195070561,
0.0282873716,
-0.0088626277,
-0.0372996107,
0.0162924007,
0.0134106399,
-0.0341606811,
0.0070231776,
0.039265804,
0.0145908939,
-0.0095821563,
-0.0248736255,
-0.0143870953,
0.0125761433,
0.0463862717,
-0.0656401441,
0.0171722919,
-0.0392992757,
-0.0592579283,
-0.0173028968,
-0.0052359956,
0.0169618912,
-0.0165317655,
-0.0058985213,
0.063590169,
-0.0081365863,
-0.0532584228,
0.0128596285,
0.0256021693,
0.0301633701,
-0.0588260405,
0.0041708141,
0.0671902075,
-0.0940639228,
0.0221341196,
0.039641846,
0.0109912409,
0.0477323607,
-0.020794129,
0.0430086926,
0.0321017057,
-0.0224922728,
0.0220789146,
-0.0151104499,
0.0170747302,
-0.0291668698,
0.0015117819,
-0.0137382234,
0.0413076803,
-0.0602867827,
-0.0236255582,
-0.0003590758,
0.0786549523,
0.0407180227,
0.014279508,
-0.0156675391,
0.0489480123,
-0.0312529355,
0.0589308925,
-0.0421564206,
0.0023379438,
0.0163542796,
-0.0084994407,
-0.0723063275,
0.0392790474,
-0.0397236869,
0.0038994101,
0.0157590974,
-0.0303703174,
-0.013299535,
-0.0429137237,
-0.0186637621,
0.0404689759,
0.004637803,
0.0383434296,
0.0048720157,
0.0126416218,
-0.0434575602,
-0.0485077873,
0.024477046,
-0.0298809018,
-0.0253103096,
-0.0716727898,
-0.0091214422,
0.0362554267,
-0.0210967772,
0.040333569,
-0.0008071925,
0.0299888365,
-0.0377151892,
0.0747425705,
-0.0141094234,
0.0291331299,
0.0558824539,
0.0376858376,
-0.0284900088,
0.0342903771,
0.0236962494,
0.0090874601,
0.024894828,
-0.0286473632,
0.0803732276,
0.0119741652,
-0.0098829512,
0.0077317832,
0.017941324,
0.016864093,
-0.0303751938,
0.0549545549,
-0.0360922627,
0.0491743498,
-0.0372639373,
0.0597250834,
0.0176828876,
0.0588105507,
-0.012911913,
0.0157659501,
0.0069521423,
-0.0221091062,
0.0030894198,
0.0583678037,
-0.0630395785,
0.0485117696,
-0.0468382575,
0.0270155873,
0.0209775195,
-0.0387547165,
-0.0325550176,
-0.0561962351,
-0.0113992374,
0.0384407267,
0.0311663467,
0.06621176,
0.0638090968,
0.0257481206,
-0.0236125439,
-0.0068323128,
0.0207434185,
-0.0398379378,
-0.0236731153,
-0.0936108902,
0.0742169693,
0.07774546,
0.0612570383,
-0.0284684636,
-0.0096317017,
-0.0161101148,
0.0308740493,
0.0049935863,
0.0462790579,
-0.0221214741,
-0.0480455533,
-0.0068877861,
-0.0460256338,
0.0106919846,
-0.015126233,
0.0131464666,
0.0078348098,
-0.0317772552,
0.0015556156,
0.0255335383,
-0.0195800699,
0.0117516266,
-0.0031039685,
-0.0240786746,
-0.0170895439,
-0.0091958661,
0.0094095366,
0.002692854,
0.0381592549,
0.0303049646,
0.024494363,
-0.007317449,
-0.0469769612,
-0.022720756,
-0.0563000999,
-0.0329911001,
0.0240668692,
0.0143837873,
-0.0415267088,
0.015992092,
-0.0303521231,
-0.0159194972,
0.0515644625,
-0.0368296653,
0.0507570356,
0.0166876744,
0.0403799713,
-0.0342675224,
-0.0655503944,
-0.0391450003,
0.0357858539,
-0.0091234865,
0.0490106381,
0.0047700419,
0.0227411464,
-0.0199001338,
-0.0324262083,
-0.0142061403,
-0.0081887105,
-0.0164284259,
0.0093530789,
0.0427617095,
0.0071188621,
-0.0462225527,
-0.0066663553,
-0.0390068255,
-0.0256960951,
0.001103042,
0.0120223658,
-0.0193902161,
0.0277325679,
0.0090450598,
-0.0352861769,
-0.0314393491,
-0.0004921409,
0.0297468565,
0.0554827824,
0.0294275098,
-0.0202622842,
-0.0568816699,
-0.0093201641,
-0.0262163524,
-0.0335567519,
0.0049000825,
0.0017061345,
0.0112948343,
-0.0820163563,
0.0269660018,
-0.0038452998,
0.017950559,
-0.0198354144,
0.0353422053,
0.0632672384,
-0.0056429342,
0.042268917,
0.0839388818,
0.0101114931,
0.0265036225,
0.0387402624,
-0.0041833278,
-0.0977400914,
0.0293843914,
-0.0168638751,
-0.0777622089,
0.0313342623,
-0.0486241393,
0.0107909823,
0.0302028265,
0.013443727,
0.013168212,
-0.035836,
0.0191183295,
-0.0365545824,
0.0013377303,
-0.0613657385,
-0.056042999,
-0.023755854,
0.0612971373,
-0.0051055648,
-0.0519663468,
0.0701693222,
-0.0031696358,
-0.012768128,
-0.0099735446,
0.0389564335,
0.010367508,
0.0819574744,
-0.0017641347,
-0.0172949657,
0.0604197644,
-0.0159770213,
-0.0133106839,
-0.0346502401,
0.0169759449,
-0.0735971779,
0.0618621893,
-0.0345238596,
-0.0120237786,
0.007457064,
-0.0342240594,
-0.069997035,
-0.0027471792,
-0.02158086,
-0.0535545386,
-0.0466609709,
0.0042591831,
0.0098144198,
-0.0425686836,
0.083010219,
0.0276052747,
-0.0313799568,
-0.0617377311,
0.0114715984,
0.0078609372,
0.0215128884,
0.0081047863,
0.0445104912,
-0.0538268648,
0.0259879921,
0.0497197323,
0.0498160012,
0.0154988794,
-0.0287961308,
-0.0000122362,
0.0236167386,
-0.0055437018,
-0.0358016863,
0.0556713678,
0.0406570882,
-0.0759883821,
-0.0271385536,
0.1048441529,
0.0420891382,
-0.0530760698,
0.0267499443,
-0.078076072,
0.0476020388,
0.0400329046,
0.0293858591,
-0.0623546876,
-0.021455491,
0.0434779562,
0.0223529506,
-0.01818089,
-0.0125889387,
0.0111924633,
-0.1460859478,
0.0088169239,
-0.0192650296,
0.0253119394,
-0.010624947,
-0.0600520708,
-0.0178918783,
0.0375629477,
0.0005702334,
0.0653088912,
0.0025454892,
-0.0012476873,
0.054031264,
-0.0437920764,
-0.0100943055,
0.0388581455,
-0.0215739738,
0.0364366136,
0.0543936938,
-0.0382339247,
-0.0238399655,
-0.0417368412,
0.0486324318,
-0.0164324511,
-0.0036500588,
-0.0368691199,
-0.0032786827,
0.0357835069,
0.0121586062,
-0.0422494225,
0.0133616887,
-0.0252135955,
-0.0036993271,
0.1037266403,
0.0720371231,
-0.0099799791,
-0.0263145808,
-0.0332359523,
0.0082096038,
-0.0115577914,
0.0512789562,
0.0198500473,
-0.060786128,
0.0052093528,
-0.0512374416,
-0.0313713476,
-0.0327539742,
-0.0307306536,
0.0041386718,
0.0233967658,
0.0683308169,
-0.0193550065,
-0.0438157134,
0.0222106967,
0.0111693675,
0.0076156734,
-0.0026998143,
0.0059328564,
0.0210821126,
0.015769681,
0.0062531522,
-0.0082224226,
0.019017607,
-0.0508521684,
0.0411274508,
-0.0255451985,
0.012263176,
0.0095805647,
-0.0050740717,
-0.0441793799,
-0.0448726825,
-0.0129082594,
0.0738926083,
0.0296829827,
0.0103570884,
0.0196786392,
-0.0476546623,
-0.0236966182,
-0.0395331457,
-0.0000979462,
0.0068792221,
0.0111345844,
0.032457564,
0.0049927258,
-0.006521808,
-0.0295822769,
0.0068197558,
0.0135969613,
0.0466842353,
-0.0301229972,
-0.0416464694,
0.034656141,
0.0529993959,
0.0192334615,
-0.0054283314,
0.0039031035,
0.0071710148,
0.0275080968,
-0.0163510684,
-0.0326018631,
-0.0137810735,
0.0445238166,
-0.0390672646,
-0.0478559472,
0.0121062137,
-0.0808675885,
-0.0270522051,
0.0177835654,
-0.0083112288,
0.032541845,
-0.0085516702,
0.0248358082,
0.0468331501,
-0.0084498636,
-0.0333906934,
0.0007440678,
0.0301158559,
0.0398152582,
-0.0051621734,
0.0766623169,
0.0336727723,
0.0274734069,
-0.0095150899,
-0.0215586014,
-0.017372122,
-0.0793023407,
0.0445162281,
0.0025645206,
-0.0115993526,
0.0320602432,
0.0145590547,
-0.0050028008,
0.0148959942,
-0.0234240014,
-0.0005955375,
0.0011902117,
-0.0349410996,
0.0171094462,
0.0388932191,
0.0008059051,
-0.0103811761,
0.050831262,
-0.0546531565,
-0.0099399136,
-0.020994693,
0.0219032224,
-0.0353563577,
-0.0207962543,
-0.0125529319,
0.0055735116,
-0.0130908927,
-0.0192948598,
-0.0635847449,
-0.0527614914,
-0.0442572273,
0.0306602046,
0.0373172425,
-0.0307522379,
0.0244827308,
0.0530905314,
0.027943207,
-0.0362000838,
0.0046328451,
0.0331539176,
-0.006938152,
-0.0420115925,
-0.0316548906,
-6.366761727e-33,
-0.0086323069,
-0.0432111807,
0.0502885506,
0.0285087898,
-0.0017903679,
-0.0399805419,
-0.0583321527,
0.0490823984,
0.0078481324,
0.0042512231,
-0.0396480076,
-0.0164054073,
-0.002036819,
0.0000972023,
0.0889906734,
0.0061335219,
0.0470136032,
0.0074471002,
-0.0555483997,
0.0244202837,
0.0313628875,
-0.0147601012,
-0.0215963181,
-0.0384721048,
0.0333653204,
-0.0194036216,
-0.0077535328,
0.0218551792,
-0.047156401,
0.0312358066,
-0.0071060136,
0.0461071655,
0.0184736606,
-0.0531389527,
-0.017504802,
0.0575210378,
-0.0516052097,
-0.0421985388,
0.0112336753,
0.0084423544,
-0.0766398832,
0.0122961737,
0.0367580503,
0.0095298961,
-0.0206809863,
-0.002523887,
0.0100198863,
-0.00165246,
-0.0518947542,
0.0302272942,
-0.0605921447,
0.0056085885,
-0.0115358774,
-0.0495878793,
-0.0423339643,
0.0986382291,
-0.0437085479,
-0.0289126337,
-0.0287001077,
0.0186029058,
0.0455869511,
0.032656882,
0.0354830921,
0.0215659402,
-0.0040060468,
-0.000629395,
0.0098204948,
0.0187294632,
-0.0394352004,
-0.0014955745,
0.0174912531,
-0.0230061803,
0.0756029487,
-0.0047258791,
0.0567648821,
-0.043367859,
-0.0333123989,
0.0097953361,
0.0075163855,
0.0347682051,
0.0423627421,
-0.0119420048,
-0.0415528901,
-0.0446319208,
-0.0560927801,
0.0403727666,
-0.0359565206,
-0.0550361425,
0.0395520553,
0.013328894,
0.0073779938,
-0.0425343178,
-0.0185378119,
0.0055765039,
-0.0506487899,
-0.035220515,
0.0143620986,
0.0184439346,
-0.0259669404,
0.0105293812,
-0.0299448483,
-0.0149049591,
-0.0591372214,
0.0138396723,
0.0310397856,
0.0229369085,
0.0093273846,
0.010164693,
-0.0792754665,
-0.0181715284,
-0.0402740985,
0.0254755449,
0.0164739899,
-0.0130232787,
0.0401418135,
0.009731872,
0.0076528266,
0.0602457374,
-0.0144644575,
-0.0638174862,
-0.0860567465,
0.0223605186,
0.0070294859,
0.0164273512,
-0.0356382877,
-0.0371128358,
-0.0465701669,
0.0324858017,
0.0367337763,
-0.0570524372,
-0.0315420367,
-0.0000841701,
3.036e-7,
-0.0366608649,
0.0710908473,
-0.0015050638,
0.0470412485,
0.0180142336,
0.0601996481,
0.0074729458,
-0.0283480771,
0.0483699627,
-0.034569066,
-0.0218010321,
0.0001712406,
0.0170898493,
0.0314635001,
-0.0641035661,
-0.0322401859,
-0.0619956516,
0.0269224681,
-0.005432473,
0.0242416449,
0.0438610353,
0.030734973,
0.0342056081,
-0.0052490048,
-0.0206202045,
-0.0190224703,
0.037208546,
0.0091782045,
-0.001986095,
-0.0082986383,
0.0003346736,
0.0124382628,
0.0533229262,
0.0362341478,
0.0216807202,
-0.0513281934,
-0.0708474368,
0.0090222815,
-0.0024324756,
-0.008937424,
-0.0067983675,
-0.0029160965,
0.016254317,
-0.0399802849,
0.0370597839,
-0.0546404682,
0.0116502345,
-0.0115044601,
0.0483203307,
-0.0558829792,
0.0291025843,
-0.0006638775,
-0.0283493195,
0.0003766196,
0.0155937048,
0.0115303826,
-0.0067913923,
-0.0439000465,
0.0065703304,
0.0182480533,
-0.0130839646,
-0.0288427602,
-0.0204197653,
0.0041964054,
-0.005084157,
-0.0475672968,
-0.0135034453,
2.831383167e-34,
0.0375873558,
-0.0309420209,
0.081636034,
0.0273720101,
0.0175965,
0.0114346705,
-0.0105396817,
0.0376069918,
0.0497311018,
-0.0359170958,
-0.0526805334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05125v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05125v3 | Zero-Shot Clinical Trial Patient Matching with LLMs | 2024-02-05T00:06:08 | 2024-04-10T05:37:26 | Michael Wornow, Alejandro Lozano, Dev Dash, Jenelle Jindal, Kenneth W. Mahaffey, Nigam H. Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Matching patients to clinical trials is a key unsolved challenge in bringing
new drugs to market. Today, identifying patients who meet a trial's eligibility
criteria is highly manual, taking up to 1 hour per patient. Automated screening
is challenging, however, as it requires understanding unstructured clinical
text. Large language models (LLMs) offer a promising solution. In this work, we
explore their application to trial matching. First, we design an LLM-based
system which, given a patient's medical history as unstructured clinical text,
evaluates whether that patient meets a set of inclusion criteria (also
specified as free text). Our zero-shot system achieves state-of-the-art scores
on the n2c2 2018 cohort selection benchmark. Second, we improve the data and
cost efficiency of our method by identifying a prompting strategy which matches
patients an order of magnitude faster and more cheaply than the status quo, and
develop a two-stage retrieval pipeline that reduces the number of tokens
processed by up to a third while retaining high performance. Third, we evaluate
the interpretability of our system by having clinicians evaluate the natural
language justifications generated by the LLM for each eligibility decision, and
show that it can output coherent explanations for 97% of its correct decisions
and 75% of its incorrect ones. Our results establish the feasibility of using
LLMs to accelerate clinical trial operations. | [
0.0547633469,
0.0789467841,
-0.0154441837,
-0.0054791193,
-0.0552520826,
0.0118027208,
0.0069844248,
0.0229330808,
0.0274112336,
-0.0385885574,
0.0370029919,
-0.062139947,
-0.0180503391,
0.0604580715,
-0.0151608298,
-0.0192607101,
0.0120019251,
0.0236359015,
0.0717726722,
0.0239212457,
-0.012695618,
0.0374824777,
-0.021318417,
0.0512846857,
0.0531025752,
-0.007805666,
0.0403065495,
-0.0108080748,
-0.009597769,
-0.079247646,
-0.0358976014,
0.0194517002,
-0.0066617085,
0.0310955085,
0.0000018043,
-0.0941029862,
-0.0381512009,
0.0226293895,
-0.0804848149,
-0.0465977378,
0.0679796413,
-0.0099873617,
0.0150444852,
0.012963959,
-0.0051232534,
-0.013487801,
0.0486051664,
0.0187986139,
0.0150538869,
0.067113854,
-0.0192473158,
0.0159143265,
0.0114662964,
-0.0230272692,
0.0486002639,
-0.0510014594,
0.0476982072,
-0.0573217906,
0.0730248019,
0.0037967931,
0.0414211191,
0.0237470996,
-0.0545326769,
-0.0300247688,
0.041994568,
0.0254884474,
-0.0705383718,
-0.0220632982,
-0.0154531375,
0.0656695589,
0.0165466331,
-0.0120652402,
0.0416777432,
-0.0191914197,
-0.0385131501,
-0.0040020063,
-0.0355091617,
0.0192428231,
-0.0267083701,
0.0173417032,
0.0092875781,
-0.0009545624,
0.0473343246,
0.0041611088,
-0.0278908163,
0.0369291715,
-0.008067674,
-0.0117953261,
0.0175058674,
-0.0048913741,
0.0015585137,
-0.0830977783,
0.0495935939,
0.0399636105,
-0.0567920804,
0.0119234389,
-0.0165313762,
-0.0176352616,
0.0737762153,
-0.0424024984,
0.0087547144,
-0.0019665507,
0.0085234642,
0.0832921267,
-0.0148047712,
-0.0051273527,
-0.0055596526,
0.0081203412,
-0.0429611132,
-0.0014843001,
-0.0497326031,
-0.0192565899,
-0.0319919214,
0.0441131741,
-0.0301678888,
0.004017977,
-0.0649808869,
0.0025027699,
-0.0211227704,
0.0186476856,
0.0232230984,
0.029649172,
-0.0172441155,
0.0056881942,
-0.0502692126,
-0.0085940519,
-0.0043826024,
-0.0064980318,
-0.0200250801,
-0.0607321337,
0.0196931511,
0.0139683224,
0.0340546966,
-0.0327206179,
0.0279674716,
0.076084137,
0.0268128328,
-0.0227782726,
-0.0190060418,
-0.0601456761,
-0.0218962468,
-0.0285839066,
-0.0148832835,
-0.0402776562,
0.0356828161,
0.0308394507,
-0.0088200774,
-0.0441882722,
-0.0051610279,
0.0254766326,
-0.0690827519,
0.0713092014,
-0.0236938372,
0.0011518071,
-0.0127939442,
-0.0026782805,
0.003366875,
-0.0046340143,
0.0173945203,
-0.0321245752,
0.0128141483,
-0.0148492763,
0.0200382341,
0.0051217354,
0.0182234515,
-0.0425312482,
-0.0096338838,
0.0494613983,
0.0125575922,
0.0786925629,
-0.030354917,
0.0279446505,
-0.0067444947,
-0.0138799446,
0.0287891421,
0.109268792,
0.0270082504,
-0.0170327649,
-0.0030320324,
-0.0005250393,
-0.0291093383,
-0.0639714748,
-0.0107527124,
0.0022759351,
-0.0077945762,
-0.0237169322,
0.0118636321,
-0.0177773312,
-0.0298709348,
-0.0096660797,
-0.0313282236,
-0.0113926921,
0.0047322195,
0.0082806861,
0.0289767142,
-0.0441379324,
-0.0383017026,
0.030038191,
0.0348846614,
-0.015511496,
-0.0217863806,
-0.0508427881,
-0.0102829244,
0.0889054686,
0.0675179735,
-0.0313203447,
-0.0001647664,
-0.0249365941,
-0.0003254007,
-0.0024227262,
0.0081841173,
-0.0128217572,
-0.0047820518,
-0.0237638559,
-0.0236424021,
0.0467744954,
-0.0055421828,
-0.0085448241,
-0.0048307595,
0.0240542218,
-0.0376054496,
-0.0351697914,
-0.0130757317,
0.048859641,
-0.0346195325,
-0.0564882234,
0.0270146597,
0.000072649,
0.0515070073,
0.0308879912,
0.0144745661,
0.0362855494,
0.0357005447,
-0.0553109236,
-0.0125132054,
-0.0244360585,
0.0201268923,
-0.0096935742,
-0.0077706315,
-0.0133264605,
-0.0172451045,
-0.0265201256,
-0.0335162915,
-0.0199950673,
0.0077544921,
-0.0165898763,
0.0147814555,
0.0073386286,
0.0274238903,
0.0127214827,
-0.0313146748,
-0.0705204383,
0.0357996523,
0.0330845974,
0.0072745169,
0.0238113496,
-0.0947879404,
0.020802835,
-0.0565549284,
0.0161563475,
0.033195883,
-0.0050927228,
0.0051981951,
0.0001748378,
-0.0283534024,
-0.0084802229,
-0.0026368962,
-0.0780974254,
0.0275405031,
0.0343633257,
0.0161794182,
-0.0125747658,
0.0246579628,
0.0029931567,
-0.0302590784,
-0.0479902923,
-0.0080598136,
0.0557758473,
-0.0057963873,
0.0385882705,
0.0453724898,
-0.0317342803,
-0.0328294821,
-0.0174330827,
-0.052360341,
0.052675359,
0.0218260866,
-0.0375109911,
-0.0048882947,
0.0080383522,
-0.0256617181,
-0.0003044805,
-0.0022341483,
0.0240606535,
0.0166785978,
-0.0116750132,
-0.0538952127,
0.0476184525,
-0.0132633522,
-0.0069332016,
0.0372766741,
0.0134623358,
-0.0293914042,
0.0085142283,
-0.0201305058,
-0.0344153531,
0.02663479,
-0.0390306637,
0.0293426532,
0.0701516718,
0.0129275611,
-0.0114707099,
-0.0379283875,
0.0048047686,
-0.0103612226,
0.0385592505,
-0.0752137676,
-0.0009613366,
-0.0145327784,
0.0479350202,
-0.0191656519,
-0.0458934307,
0.1169889495,
-0.0239344742,
0.0402389131,
-0.0695626512,
-0.0140332282,
-0.0516996458,
0.0054645063,
0.0225839075,
0.019475678,
0.0316547416,
0.0091440082,
0.0412152372,
-0.046741683,
0.007878812,
-0.0358949825,
0.0886635259,
-0.0212968402,
0.068837963,
-0.0044714473,
-0.029499067,
-0.0306712519,
-0.0658738017,
-0.047790505,
-0.0258578658,
0.0225758106,
0.0165469795,
-0.0841086656,
0.026389787,
-0.0102813253,
0.0644872561,
0.0126074497,
-0.0162460096,
-0.0085335458,
-0.0267651081,
0.0220554695,
-0.033938963,
0.0060114348,
-0.0098742442,
0.0375372283,
0.0520341955,
0.0224598274,
0.0442760885,
-0.0039536972,
0.0309631843,
0.0061205965,
-0.0595361777,
-0.0018270551,
0.0424691811,
0.0229437277,
-0.0448329858,
0.0348650254,
0.1057652012,
0.0299443398,
-0.0485150702,
0.012842847,
-0.007210427,
-0.0575173609,
-0.0081773801,
0.0310509857,
-0.0825204477,
-0.0447105207,
0.0015739643,
0.0357504375,
-0.0438691527,
-0.0430571362,
-0.0219843555,
-0.0432553962,
0.0473807044,
0.0154054137,
-0.0226185154,
0.0167056359,
-0.0599801131,
-0.015267441,
-0.0279787835,
-0.0293179303,
0.0090513583,
-0.008461806,
-0.0231148917,
-0.0253263228,
-0.0487500988,
-0.0558461286,
0.0483633019,
-0.0356509574,
0.0464862436,
0.0390424021,
0.0439069383,
0.0153598357,
-0.0127796587,
-0.0216369741,
-0.0045004925,
-0.0193036497,
-0.0048315879,
0.0852138177,
0.0342770703,
0.017961327,
-0.0728153288,
0.0269100368,
-0.0632174835,
-0.0305675138,
-0.0085476637,
0.1035647467,
-0.044295717,
-0.0223249644,
-0.0603658073,
0.0119195217,
0.0067298939,
0.0827501267,
-0.0037141484,
-0.0080265524,
-0.0189064369,
-0.0067067472,
0.0169629585,
-0.0348525532,
-0.0272204168,
0.02912689,
-0.0222500283,
0.0169427022,
-0.0365088917,
-0.0098885056,
0.0608751699,
0.0177677535,
0.0063914103,
0.056354478,
0.0034353219,
-0.0207035597,
-0.0316627994,
0.0808286592,
0.0019059958,
0.0333890617,
-0.073172085,
-0.0194529761,
0.0007143546,
-0.0062822592,
-0.0219502989,
0.014148647,
-0.0094148098,
-0.0210873894,
-0.0207086336,
-0.0160520263,
0.0382521786,
-0.0041132476,
-0.0018641945,
-0.0358445086,
0.0333433412,
0.0329101644,
-0.0017132184,
-0.0405365974,
-0.0729901493,
0.0022328373,
-0.0295557007,
-0.0020007724,
-0.0239671543,
0.0244758241,
-0.0072432212,
0.0172871761,
-0.0163103603,
-0.0133264465,
0.0610514469,
0.0525784232,
0.0472371913,
0.0091455989,
0.0018651077,
-0.0215445831,
0.0177271646,
-0.0234322771,
0.0019996401,
-0.0175575987,
-0.0417168289,
0.0165270846,
-0.0326353498,
-0.0088755433,
-0.0218301173,
-0.1029761136,
-0.0060670893,
-0.0289871395,
0.0343722999,
0.0239593033,
0.0047791661,
0.0721796751,
-0.0221062973,
0.0208541118,
0.0265301596,
-0.0376035981,
0.0469578542,
-0.0436484143,
0.033242844,
-0.0004920005,
0.0492489226,
-0.0166281033,
0.0211692303,
-0.0353197455,
-0.0637480915,
0.0169088747,
0.0109164342,
0.0421433412,
-0.0239119139,
0.0356553197,
-0.0067395703,
0.0004815269,
-0.0503208414,
0.0147890104,
0.0249438453,
-0.002985554,
0.0405093208,
0.0371323042,
-0.0328933634,
-0.0483181998,
0.0765417293,
0.0269216094,
0.0312093869,
-0.0195452832,
-0.0475822985,
-0.0280164592,
-0.0063602258,
0.0422408581,
0.0261104945,
-0.0361350775,
-0.0010388718,
-0.0610724054,
-0.010367265,
0.0304001309,
-0.0147978077,
-0.0301269758,
-0.0121671492,
0.0233198944,
0.0547507033,
0.0313345119,
-0.0572441705,
-0.0433822908,
0.0589923859,
-0.0288777594,
-0.037764892,
-0.0236676987,
-5.709196799e-33,
0.019416498,
-0.0313604586,
0.0019461517,
-0.0247094985,
0.0333298706,
0.0100793932,
-0.049077481,
-0.0203465056,
0.0415223241,
0.0147210341,
-0.020060325,
0.0055366121,
0.0103644785,
0.0228668228,
-0.0080634821,
-0.0203865413,
0.0289171785,
0.024549963,
-0.0228079427,
0.0078203175,
0.01054944,
0.0268584937,
-0.0155242495,
-0.0282354131,
0.0445012376,
0.0181019362,
0.0498133861,
0.0312179886,
0.0184171218,
0.0859567076,
-0.016159188,
0.0355339237,
0.0403948128,
-0.0262680631,
0.0168049242,
0.0112484265,
-0.049053859,
0.0003208801,
-0.0080284495,
-0.0254105255,
-0.0215117577,
-0.0246014223,
0.0619745106,
-0.0189431235,
-0.0355527438,
0.0187612008,
0.0292432066,
-0.0266727787,
-0.0324125811,
-0.0084940568,
-0.0196099766,
0.0471172966,
-0.0153218079,
0.0086877774,
-0.0065668961,
0.0260311738,
-0.0269745272,
0.0898329169,
-0.0237177741,
0.0168971624,
-0.014652567,
0.0237749945,
0.0011187537,
-0.0258914623,
-0.0369820148,
0.0812390372,
-0.0147990603,
-0.0076390272,
-0.0302377008,
0.0158855896,
-0.0453665555,
0.0125745414,
0.0268792808,
0.0156263597,
0.0669615269,
0.0188650731,
-0.1085406169,
0.0583165959,
-0.0517803058,
0.0241600852,
0.0330218486,
0.001508586,
-0.0399551094,
-0.0372600816,
-0.0408890322,
-0.0000562558,
-0.048834946,
-0.0133431535,
0.0408683941,
-0.0065839295,
-0.0186418314,
-0.0136383912,
0.0225446709,
-0.0230534896,
-0.0428680852,
-0.0167338606,
0.0444113314,
0.0043285624,
-0.0197273325,
0.0118268533,
-0.0502522364,
0.0012729416,
0.0138653209,
-0.0377019905,
0.0496059135,
0.0277291499,
-0.0009242361,
-0.0499640331,
-0.0619939752,
-0.0014508705,
0.0069517964,
0.0037848537,
-0.0281855259,
0.033057116,
0.0484626554,
0.0551491305,
0.0431331098,
0.0694811344,
0.0025588912,
-0.0424573496,
-0.0290560964,
-0.031353198,
-0.0126474602,
0.0004382142,
-0.0367345475,
0.0245280731,
-0.0345455371,
0.0456713177,
0.0470279194,
-0.0629970208,
0.0020367007,
-0.0122576794,
2.666e-7,
0.0769631937,
0.0561046489,
0.0013768738,
-0.0099398969,
0.0326364748,
0.0379909985,
-0.0101978788,
0.0030112432,
-0.0092845969,
-0.0222739689,
0.02287063,
-0.0046419678,
0.035729859,
0.0305520464,
-0.0588473529,
-0.0120593794,
-0.0535218865,
-0.0293910578,
-0.0599268228,
-0.0092001194,
0.0740811527,
0.0615378767,
-0.008064284,
-0.0197613258,
0.0171464123,
-0.0555107743,
0.0205924474,
-0.0248462409,
-0.0057927635,
0.0535164811,
0.0266742706,
-0.0293560717,
0.0057903365,
0.0649742037,
-0.0182718728,
0.0083208671,
-0.041546382,
0.0959403813,
-0.0717612579,
0.0371450633,
-0.0043045953,
-0.0408599526,
0.0197551567,
-0.0040560514,
0.0623664074,
-0.0378450938,
-0.0593692809,
-0.0216396581,
0.0048426664,
-0.0377311744,
0.0596703775,
0.0451332629,
-0.0279600024,
0.0310966428,
0.0322474204,
0.0119698318,
-0.0129427509,
-0.0805016756,
0.0060597206,
0.0355422348,
-0.0524783097,
0.010437238,
0.0118067348,
0.0230897926,
0.0339714959,
-0.0739053413,
0.0331854224,
2.478505732e-34,
0.0343360044,
0.0306460299,
0.0172218289,
-0.0145407682,
0.0408065617,
0.0105438251,
-0.0047473167,
0.0048974426,
0.0151301101,
-0.0851704627,
0.0207305867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02643v1 | LLM-Enhanced Data Management | 2024-02-04T23:42:02 | 2024-02-04T23:42:02 | Xuanhe Zhou, Xinyang Zhao, Guoliang Li | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Machine learning (ML) techniques for optimizing data management problems have
been extensively studied and widely deployed in recent five years. However
traditional ML methods have limitations on generalizability (adapting to
different scenarios) and inference ability (understanding the context).
Fortunately, large language models (LLMs) have shown high generalizability and
human-competitive abilities in understanding context, which are promising for
data management tasks (e.g., database diagnosis, database tuning). However,
existing LLMs have several limitations: hallucination, high cost, and low
accuracy for complicated tasks. To address these challenges, we design LLMDB,
an LLM-enhanced data management paradigm which has generalizability and high
inference ability while avoiding hallucination, reducing LLM cost, and
achieving high accuracy. LLMDB embeds domain-specific knowledge to avoid
hallucination by LLM fine-tuning and prompt engineering. LLMDB reduces the high
cost of LLMs by vector databases which provide semantic search and caching
abilities. LLMDB improves the task accuracy by LLM agent which provides
multiple-round inference and pipeline executions. We showcase three real-world
scenarios that LLMDB can well support, including query rewrite, database
diagnosis and data analytics. We also summarize the open research challenges of
LLMDB. | [
0.0282945894,
0.0648810267,
-0.0093883332,
0.0213931333,
-0.0495095141,
0.0202524066,
-0.0137362164,
0.0249410942,
0.0202069338,
-0.0077970903,
0.0150395837,
-0.0250627287,
-0.0558043197,
0.0193206444,
0.003224493,
-0.0177670848,
0.0462366901,
-0.0205333102,
-0.0090378178,
-0.0041191005,
-0.0338240229,
0.0143491011,
0.0427313559,
-0.020755738,
-0.0269527379,
0.0096406704,
-0.0357177965,
0.0313266739,
-0.0226459187,
0.001007042,
0.0027602352,
0.0433289595,
0.030997714,
0.0354147926,
0.0000026051,
-0.0665313378,
-0.0534232147,
0.0137446914,
-0.0765215456,
-0.0032605575,
0.0221007392,
-0.0444051251,
0.0107063306,
0.0439666063,
-0.0174522437,
-0.0104482183,
0.0438836664,
0.0284210425,
0.046250727,
0.0352897272,
-0.0069079218,
-0.0516173467,
-0.0019974909,
-0.0063474104,
0.0419159681,
-0.0768985674,
0.0325259604,
0.0024252713,
0.0473945327,
-0.0143993916,
-0.0118292235,
0.033951506,
0.0008824421,
0.0115070939,
-0.0111894161,
0.0083933715,
-0.0091495207,
0.0033960403,
-0.0069576614,
0.0172389671,
-0.0016242932,
-0.0263747815,
0.0475588106,
0.0034444048,
-0.0419578999,
-0.001571784,
-0.0039577847,
0.0415089056,
-0.0083170449,
-0.0068109706,
0.0018640653,
-0.0487189516,
0.0421651863,
0.0195881147,
-0.0842542872,
0.068084158,
-0.0086214542,
-0.0160358809,
-0.0123215504,
-0.0414942764,
0.0203652214,
-0.0519545265,
0.0164786503,
0.0653086156,
-0.0912130103,
0.0307818688,
-0.0336738564,
0.0083142091,
0.0434368625,
-0.075874716,
0.0142843379,
0.0211079735,
-0.0049134237,
0.0717465803,
0.0121443598,
0.0288299453,
-0.0377470739,
0.0287803095,
-0.0329313502,
-0.052481737,
-0.0496412665,
0.0041514551,
-0.0145787299,
0.032575205,
-0.0126626175,
-0.0023837031,
-0.0520906709,
0.091829434,
0.011348309,
0.0401171669,
-0.0463771522,
-0.0074720099,
0.0116598448,
-0.0031355841,
-0.0755430311,
-0.0293710418,
-0.0165958144,
-0.0086363843,
-0.0269918498,
-0.0593422391,
-0.0093698241,
0.0102951992,
0.0075929081,
0.001950542,
0.0494621024,
0.0714732185,
0.0384723619,
0.0119468989,
-0.1099046245,
-0.0603216551,
0.0351039171,
-0.048194807,
-0.0360328481,
-0.0394091085,
0.0350289233,
0.027651215,
-0.0482264683,
-0.0401113816,
-0.0274156407,
-0.0041418863,
-0.0314866826,
0.0464567207,
-0.0232299734,
0.0560503267,
0.0525106378,
0.0170620549,
-0.0113771642,
0.0688475147,
-0.0250590984,
0.0066895196,
0.0097742574,
-0.0011941862,
0.0531929545,
0.0024536045,
0.0121629983,
-0.0063712858,
-0.0298844967,
0.0457994118,
0.0114009958,
0.0349668339,
-0.0230964664,
0.0431466959,
0.015154656,
-0.0249559674,
0.0331497453,
0.0240808111,
0.0152254375,
0.0038020762,
0.0235480741,
0.0011482624,
-0.0299532693,
-0.0217688736,
-0.037419036,
0.0265348889,
-0.0279852748,
-0.0349297933,
0.0035440852,
-0.0041282675,
-0.0432485715,
-0.0690903962,
-0.0307789426,
-0.0128188897,
-0.0358419754,
0.0225231498,
0.0487103872,
-0.0151302451,
-0.0171026457,
0.0565656722,
-0.0025910814,
0.0001252132,
-0.0420073383,
-0.0529394895,
0.0183631554,
0.0791845322,
0.0511551946,
-0.0942900404,
-0.0318657048,
-0.0089994324,
0.0438938625,
-0.0172106642,
0.0204740949,
-0.0043353541,
-0.0039378335,
-0.0250645373,
-0.0397734307,
0.0439028777,
0.0447814576,
0.007881253,
-0.0182610787,
-0.0056029852,
0.006280574,
-0.0317145959,
-0.0524622463,
0.0443744101,
-0.0314932689,
-0.0344026573,
0.0252743922,
0.0183851421,
0.0435870029,
-0.0107338354,
-0.0010856995,
0.0015960179,
0.0716991052,
-0.0069670691,
-0.0631263256,
-0.018245928,
0.0171045363,
0.0354256891,
0.0098075941,
0.0424239598,
0.0011136679,
-0.0393745862,
-0.06179934,
-0.0246094149,
0.0047108452,
-0.0248730257,
0.0219729301,
-0.0398305133,
0.0419603325,
-0.0353839435,
-0.0017108324,
-0.0403985791,
0.0640610605,
-0.0035122242,
-0.0124992495,
0.028033359,
-0.0038753329,
0.0079166954,
-0.0096680839,
-0.0048429468,
0.023882268,
0.0091600781,
0.0725259632,
0.003445433,
-0.0386142246,
-0.0396620072,
0.0231116675,
-0.0580622256,
0.0261208732,
-0.014582403,
0.0190041214,
0.0054819169,
0.0290819015,
-0.0127474628,
-0.0204200279,
-0.0331899524,
-0.0117273619,
0.0232710894,
0.0334439091,
0.0272803307,
0.0236009788,
-0.0337955095,
0.0103199538,
-0.0244302861,
-0.026712887,
0.0363314003,
-0.0270591732,
-0.038611304,
-0.0448865891,
0.0148885949,
-0.0486358665,
0.0148576275,
-0.028836403,
0.0626166016,
-0.0403072052,
-0.0678438172,
-0.00422421,
0.0482081659,
-0.0259287059,
-0.0110934582,
0.0301392004,
0.0095732762,
-0.0532926247,
-0.010298986,
-0.0095952591,
-0.0206818283,
-0.0061169248,
-0.0001788037,
0.017874483,
-0.0111553958,
-0.0053851493,
-0.0041813976,
-0.0075463662,
0.0389396586,
0.0351622142,
-0.0191729683,
-0.0595894493,
-0.0032662281,
0.0055032223,
0.0580354147,
0.0046124966,
-0.0608906858,
0.0782202706,
0.0115774414,
0.0097879767,
-0.022911761,
-0.0820749253,
-0.0679761842,
0.0409400053,
0.0046601584,
0.0347161815,
-0.0540221334,
-0.0241784658,
-0.0301593971,
0.0010448762,
-0.0181340761,
-0.0472538285,
0.0559201166,
-0.0391042493,
0.0124297207,
0.0139037194,
0.0010798972,
-0.0701594651,
-0.0173561852,
-0.0391954221,
-0.0075724437,
-0.0144929597,
0.0193197299,
-0.0379453488,
0.0155520691,
-0.0114765521,
0.0305029154,
0.020139128,
-0.0249844659,
-0.0043002041,
-0.0603202693,
-0.0233450681,
-0.0049343887,
0.0097412951,
-0.0194514915,
0.0297993477,
0.0579439402,
0.0141621083,
-0.0725791752,
-0.0141788432,
0.0195785947,
0.0121698529,
-0.0353811197,
0.0126424693,
0.0127949603,
-0.0565183125,
-0.0827794299,
-0.0161400996,
0.0957528055,
0.0311159641,
-0.0535054728,
-0.0030043679,
-0.0256765932,
0.0018003932,
0.0128486101,
0.0564166419,
-0.1064227596,
-0.0234417934,
0.0126200104,
0.0367066041,
0.0163758211,
-0.039183829,
0.0017637532,
-0.0707154647,
0.0468209088,
-0.0188332889,
0.0020070125,
-0.0337602049,
-0.0803612843,
-0.0079325503,
-0.0357767157,
0.0274201911,
0.0349563025,
0.0040336414,
-0.0246883333,
0.0119786039,
0.0041299118,
-0.0430345833,
0.0324944817,
-0.0669791698,
0.029882079,
0.060715884,
0.000406286,
0.032345362,
-0.0287152287,
0.0076695527,
0.0249657631,
0.0237515364,
-0.0663778111,
0.0727860853,
0.0029875541,
-0.0042565083,
0.0215639304,
0.0165532064,
-0.0373755358,
0.0170370154,
0.0233943984,
0.1484341919,
-0.0696214586,
0.0023041582,
-0.016700441,
-0.0449573733,
-0.0237106439,
0.091201894,
-0.0107233021,
-0.0346804224,
-0.0428972468,
-0.0008325755,
-0.0053346185,
-0.002016657,
-0.000100606,
0.0181202423,
-0.0452017635,
-0.0349503756,
-0.0022514688,
-0.0139316423,
0.0528761409,
0.0076267603,
0.0075346995,
0.0460568815,
-0.001985773,
-0.0209011659,
-0.0915667564,
-0.0129991546,
-0.0485208072,
0.0459818207,
-0.0315091908,
0.0134704709,
0.0387082733,
0.0006528853,
-0.0177009925,
-0.0025461912,
-0.0504808687,
-0.0745630339,
0.0332302339,
0.0303580891,
0.0242505223,
0.0421427265,
0.020399062,
-0.0610879809,
0.0143836597,
0.0445860028,
-0.0368959904,
0.0000079801,
-0.0100451428,
0.0064872378,
-0.0004395008,
0.0194043554,
-0.0574816093,
0.0066342321,
-0.0104795918,
-0.0323674828,
-0.046439264,
-0.0085421177,
0.0270462073,
0.0419573896,
0.0091334442,
0.0457583144,
-0.0801827535,
0.0062499531,
0.0556226,
-0.0200245306,
-0.0316076614,
-0.0175489802,
0.0416244566,
0.0045491848,
0.0011900249,
0.0013441459,
-0.0188110024,
0.0265539475,
-0.0445396565,
-0.032911256,
0.0091490662,
0.0020668483,
-0.0169524513,
0.0552837439,
0.0168375019,
-0.0012409852,
0.0073375725,
0.0561587289,
0.0632864609,
-0.0235536825,
0.0382390022,
0.0186805502,
0.0432286933,
-0.0596198775,
0.0060405461,
-0.0469997972,
-0.071409747,
0.0516153611,
0.0305742081,
0.0598279051,
-0.0055443966,
-0.0144189475,
-0.0321517214,
-0.0070208288,
-0.0117632318,
-0.0039215018,
0.0258414112,
0.0102538206,
0.0120716337,
0.0159205608,
-0.0418601632,
-0.0069194734,
0.0663760304,
0.0021669576,
0.0517964289,
-0.0534137264,
-0.0516267307,
-0.0436226279,
-0.0035242578,
0.0278505143,
0.0066680978,
-0.0283075329,
-0.0363318436,
-0.0771919563,
-0.0270287748,
0.0362007543,
0.0270569716,
-0.0393373221,
-0.0736519024,
0.0012922453,
0.0926713124,
0.0791417956,
0.0278054792,
-0.034390159,
0.0053008837,
-0.024967216,
-0.0284664258,
-0.0010408948,
-6.737616235e-33,
-0.0004285347,
-0.0540665798,
0.0355485827,
-0.0140577555,
0.0203627776,
-0.0109386975,
-0.0301209558,
-0.0201593861,
0.0051476834,
-0.0348705947,
-0.0317242034,
0.0512868837,
0.0177440252,
-0.0029741197,
0.050774496,
-0.0251458101,
0.0456374511,
0.0099928379,
-0.001466991,
0.0022920852,
0.0432655551,
0.0551560894,
0.0005181498,
-0.0527020134,
-0.0170796476,
-0.0135352639,
0.0222777259,
0.0432295129,
-0.0353195481,
0.026376497,
-0.0109953647,
0.0206328258,
0.0142426286,
-0.0329554975,
-0.0272617266,
-0.0182897579,
-0.0406490974,
0.001826303,
-0.0072446377,
0.0152974688,
0.0117037864,
-0.0104200253,
0.052614484,
-0.0041787825,
-0.0047013387,
0.0370618403,
0.0088602593,
-0.0439196043,
-0.0421215519,
-0.029344501,
-0.0007827964,
0.0384092033,
0.0154480366,
0.0297510941,
0.0835272372,
-0.0091478378,
0.0216323938,
0.051497288,
-0.0753002316,
0.0411625318,
-0.015686702,
0.0021324819,
0.053451404,
0.0415667631,
0.0063693016,
0.0184229538,
0.0568289496,
0.014630408,
-0.0033153996,
0.0563863665,
-0.0091675706,
0.0954726115,
0.0147565976,
0.0146970348,
0.0071923085,
-0.0164048504,
-0.060038913,
0.0570067018,
0.0094482256,
0.0193516277,
0.0380805433,
0.0353994258,
-0.0442038737,
-0.0620366149,
-0.0387441181,
0.0562913232,
-0.0494463891,
0.0268237833,
0.0057315161,
0.0229650866,
-0.0310001466,
0.0027705887,
0.0431876034,
-0.0492927991,
-0.0503676794,
0.0348184779,
0.0053294525,
-0.0567960963,
0.0165943671,
0.0169875454,
-0.022920575,
-0.0294319242,
-0.0330309086,
-0.0028919966,
0.0247815531,
0.0194742661,
0.0139220161,
0.0195474308,
-0.0601672456,
0.0259056743,
-0.0412973501,
0.0041363523,
-0.0363473594,
-0.0025621355,
0.0092338929,
0.0047321902,
0.0384770371,
0.0534242988,
0.0623781458,
-0.0152011802,
-0.0053431843,
0.0189662501,
-0.0003318187,
-0.0183564089,
0.0065011885,
-0.0169641953,
-0.0160195623,
0.0027877076,
0.0762500465,
-0.0585145727,
0.0115322396,
0.0296817068,
3.291e-7,
0.055591099,
0.0543984137,
0.0013592478,
0.0406906009,
0.0189698674,
0.0435727388,
-0.0151936198,
-0.040437758,
-0.003299559,
0.0077601322,
0.0625641644,
-0.0018255898,
0.0564607829,
0.0073952535,
-0.0599149168,
-0.0092902556,
-0.0128942728,
0.0030866216,
-0.0824465305,
-0.018493725,
0.0328927226,
0.0969705582,
0.0086135194,
-0.0277717412,
0.0225030929,
-0.0446323045,
0.0053273449,
-0.0307849236,
0.0157168955,
0.0432094187,
0.0526469834,
0.0280313734,
0.015348563,
0.0147353141,
-0.0059303627,
0.0282275956,
-0.0566225611,
0.0757149756,
0.0173292663,
0.0076288078,
0.0159937497,
-0.0544991009,
-0.0049524275,
-0.0133341523,
0.0791776329,
-0.0156691223,
-0.0017578377,
0.0283715818,
0.0052544856,
-0.0268959142,
0.025851218,
0.0152186928,
-0.0255083628,
0.0160890948,
-0.0050627221,
-0.0093031777,
-0.0060389284,
-0.082808353,
-0.0315797143,
0.0285078008,
-0.0432562009,
0.0042436537,
-0.0093127815,
0.0247570295,
0.0053135362,
-0.0443352908,
0.0079215318,
3.59995696e-34,
0.0419693664,
0.026509583,
-0.0176592246,
0.0378347263,
0.0195456725,
0.014651183,
-0.0004065003,
0.0371741503,
0.005988522,
-0.0811535195,
-0.0054510175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02639v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02639v2 | "It's how you do things that matters": Attending to Process to Better Serve Indigenous Communities with Language Technologies | 2024-02-04T23:23:51 | 2024-02-06T02:50:48 | Ned Cooper, Courtney Heldreth, Ben Hutchinson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Indigenous languages are historically under-served by Natural Language
Processing (NLP) technologies, but this is changing for some languages with the
recent scaling of large multilingual models and an increased focus by the NLP
community on endangered languages. This position paper explores ethical
considerations in building NLP technologies for Indigenous languages, based on
the premise that such projects should primarily serve Indigenous communities.
We report on interviews with 17 researchers working in or with Aboriginal
and/or Torres Strait Islander communities on language technology projects in
Australia. Drawing on insights from the interviews, we recommend practices for
NLP researchers to increase attention to the process of engagements with
Indigenous communities, rather than focusing only on decontextualised
artefacts. | [
0.0233228467,
0.0990754887,
-0.0341326892,
0.0321819782,
-0.0601877533,
0.0202343594,
-0.005964824,
-0.0202951469,
-0.0099358996,
-0.0149017544,
0.0571362004,
0.0175154097,
0.0219832938,
0.0208817217,
-0.0155395195,
-0.0301986206,
-0.021511171,
-0.0152520686,
0.0591321737,
0.030070886,
0.0032550853,
0.0836731121,
0.0095447423,
0.0802235529,
-0.0575577058,
-0.0066381297,
0.0082787126,
-0.0397076011,
0.0231369156,
-0.003456211,
-0.0109139178,
0.0251477044,
-0.0344616808,
0.0489157885,
0.0000018983,
-0.0355062671,
0.0045497194,
-0.0031078001,
-0.0342179164,
-0.0143137146,
0.0683892369,
-0.002570417,
-0.0017351912,
0.0104708746,
-0.0687199011,
0.0285963528,
0.0989621133,
-0.0371324383,
0.0186823197,
0.0270225666,
0.0034166961,
-0.0137248579,
-0.0022887187,
-0.0241553131,
-0.0200203955,
0.02358355,
0.0080119949,
-0.0078320047,
0.0261583328,
-0.0224991851,
-0.0034004431,
0.0858899429,
0.0063790311,
-0.0358456001,
-0.0570230559,
-0.0261788573,
-0.0279061068,
-0.0817732736,
0.0407629237,
-0.0147423791,
0.0229873378,
0.0167330075,
-0.0429080725,
0.019435389,
-0.0336185955,
-0.020333048,
-0.0048932722,
0.0398370512,
-0.031011546,
0.0157123245,
0.0033771968,
-0.0100635178,
-0.0010713912,
0.0342004597,
0.0105869742,
0.0475768819,
-0.022850791,
0.0474424139,
-0.0157106407,
0.0108919758,
0.0599329397,
0.0121805761,
0.027548505,
0.0186030194,
-0.0227282364,
0.0811526477,
0.0233470183,
0.0080159502,
0.0401284546,
0.0025243079,
0.0092843175,
0.0112472232,
-0.0481561422,
-0.012215957,
0.0066749332,
-0.009704046,
0.0062141572,
-0.0060581458,
-0.0105332071,
-0.0164245348,
-0.0059681716,
-0.0470717959,
-0.0114381704,
-0.0167926233,
-0.0647234321,
0.0536008179,
0.0552439727,
0.0056175189,
-0.0474472903,
0.0264460873,
-0.0211999789,
0.0014856727,
-0.0322803184,
-0.0104075419,
0.0339781567,
0.0624485388,
-0.0190998651,
0.0321708247,
-0.0518160611,
-0.0905397311,
0.0536329187,
-0.0130818402,
-0.0203622337,
-0.0068598683,
-0.0201398116,
0.0412167795,
0.0078497976,
-0.0405792147,
-0.0849549174,
-0.0233538877,
0.0269927699,
-0.0220051892,
0.0077931485,
-0.0311052874,
0.0282111783,
0.0258654244,
-0.0028379166,
-0.0881087855,
0.0206776261,
0.0020083615,
-0.0252838172,
0.0503931083,
0.0211884361,
-0.0043575433,
0.0662341565,
0.037808612,
0.0711925998,
0.0289084446,
0.0440009721,
0.0064374655,
0.0549970977,
-0.0366719216,
-0.0499407202,
0.0098720929,
-0.046613615,
-0.0000794823,
-0.0318364389,
0.0375490673,
-0.0145840673,
-0.0030905828,
0.040501684,
0.0698331818,
0.0139388833,
0.0261439029,
-0.0157614686,
0.0929668918,
-0.0542683862,
-0.006447996,
0.0171490852,
0.0046169683,
-0.056074217,
-0.0128314765,
-0.0158514511,
0.0205272716,
0.0609655678,
-0.0443638526,
-0.0010248437,
0.024013903,
0.0198713392,
-0.007711817,
-0.0147798797,
0.0011295194,
0.0456380993,
0.0332355164,
-0.0346136503,
-0.0071510063,
0.0121196136,
-0.0319002308,
0.0200047977,
-0.0395720191,
0.0380391479,
-0.0235036425,
-0.0041760281,
0.0415518209,
-0.0185287613,
-0.0111103626,
0.0457795151,
-0.051742509,
-0.0299451146,
0.1020742878,
0.0032635741,
-0.029796809,
-0.0445966236,
0.0173705872,
-0.0135993613,
-0.0027588308,
-0.0246492196,
-0.002149347,
-0.0028636425,
0.0824172869,
0.0308979098,
0.0338947214,
-0.0768594816,
0.0255091544,
-0.0429069661,
-0.0587490462,
-0.0283680726,
-0.0183637198,
0.0148185557,
0.0648280159,
-0.0258319601,
-0.000486307,
0.0016130815,
0.0050459686,
0.0329992995,
0.0400108807,
0.0251446031,
0.0290733594,
0.0291415807,
-0.1179553121,
-0.0157310776,
0.0226652995,
-0.004919582,
0.0256508812,
0.0302249137,
0.0033600428,
0.0422521792,
-0.0266593788,
-0.0595659614,
-0.0226423349,
-0.0440638363,
-0.0553736947,
-0.0380265489,
-0.0325449258,
-0.0178882238,
-0.044949647,
-0.0762445033,
0.0203423705,
-0.0078985961,
-0.0423912182,
0.0785712525,
0.0403764099,
0.0076830653,
0.0148012051,
0.0257962998,
0.0128321396,
0.000721497,
-0.0845811889,
-0.070625037,
-0.0166688021,
-0.0056959898,
-0.0335779041,
0.0222613197,
-0.0274412818,
-0.02122931,
0.0409377962,
-0.0803948864,
-0.0269611888,
0.0224226154,
0.0091705779,
0.0043157353,
0.0196918864,
-0.0075433473,
-0.0419330746,
0.0388525128,
0.0541594587,
0.0281599201,
-0.1086321324,
-0.0389865339,
-0.0638761818,
-0.0367497727,
-0.0414124839,
0.0162285157,
-0.0097329197,
0.0156246265,
0.0441628546,
-0.027267836,
0.0123099284,
0.0245713443,
0.0223010033,
0.0277962219,
-0.0151915736,
0.0025480115,
-0.0060960501,
0.0294355527,
0.0254951399,
0.0182118285,
-0.0350353606,
0.0191387907,
-0.0073193233,
0.0090884948,
-0.0002273877,
0.0193818118,
0.0175638273,
-0.0764015391,
-0.0559690669,
-0.017479077,
-0.0782612264,
-0.038410265,
0.0097689461,
-0.0227752179,
-0.0623941235,
0.0542335212,
0.0294723138,
-0.0078325523,
-0.0960160047,
0.0029551787,
-0.0115701891,
0.092605494,
-0.0318511799,
0.0610747598,
0.0284574218,
-0.0684179142,
0.0160736162,
-0.0018561097,
0.0179288946,
-0.0609208606,
-0.0066772071,
-0.042082414,
0.0436132811,
-0.0298275556,
0.0016173477,
-0.0505144708,
0.0450457633,
-0.0188004859,
0.0131997811,
0.0364277922,
0.0283353478,
0.0187814757,
-0.0042468635,
0.0810812712,
-0.010072832,
0.0708094686,
0.0133070499,
0.0341419801,
0.0191716868,
-0.0186775941,
-0.0079159858,
0.0468522385,
0.084860988,
0.0025404245,
-0.0362251103,
0.0104705244,
-0.0110071693,
0.0841723531,
0.0285316091,
0.0283596683,
-0.0042123897,
-0.0418143421,
0.0034957901,
0.0480244868,
-0.0326027721,
-0.0124893654,
0.0314359814,
0.0162383839,
0.0067240959,
0.015432531,
-0.0420470983,
-0.0492217578,
0.0078694019,
0.0149681848,
-0.0933186263,
0.0376558267,
-0.0182635691,
0.0077959094,
-0.0422416031,
-0.0226266701,
-0.0089970352,
-0.0477419533,
0.0307823513,
-0.0054185754,
-0.0239417348,
0.0133570051,
-0.0237576161,
-0.036582388,
0.0056789126,
0.0443855822,
0.0203859881,
-0.0061116605,
0.0210536886,
0.0351600498,
-0.0101167392,
0.0168683194,
-0.0508623868,
0.0088665113,
0.0409886315,
0.0537189431,
0.0295998305,
-0.0281253029,
-0.0160636995,
-0.0021159828,
0.0040241838,
-0.0229741596,
0.010296368,
-0.0454607159,
0.0352831408,
-0.0457231738,
-0.0161834825,
0.0133925825,
-0.0273487903,
-0.0231935009,
0.0125697125,
0.0585561171,
-0.0124347135,
-0.024433624,
0.0232985727,
-0.0196276568,
0.0390828699,
0.0080808662,
0.0059664678,
0.0053169029,
-0.0016938838,
-0.0568319224,
-0.0251784641,
0.0326974615,
-0.0955979154,
0.0468632281,
0.0495400988,
0.0155026447,
-0.0627931431,
-0.098777391,
0.0563715734,
0.0082490658,
0.0437314622,
-0.0035627515,
0.0243462771,
-0.0289118849,
-0.065007247,
0.0746175051,
-0.0120188147,
0.0200365838,
-0.0231751706,
-0.0067061605,
-0.0043087732,
0.0290301815,
0.0340750255,
-0.000168144,
0.0205553491,
-0.0259120055,
0.0506723188,
0.0108083012,
0.0159862619,
-0.0130296713,
0.0176276211,
-0.0714931935,
-0.0348425545,
0.0341184251,
-0.0181224793,
-0.0053031677,
-0.0023641605,
0.0015106831,
-0.0043813628,
0.0114748301,
0.0383115411,
0.0032303403,
0.0093452875,
-0.0007398097,
-0.0292477999,
-0.0341548137,
-0.0042613479,
0.0020572287,
-0.0354194865,
-0.0875992253,
0.0024368048,
-0.0443275459,
-0.0684979856,
0.0449598506,
-0.0198020786,
-0.0255392194,
0.0001139198,
0.0046943426,
0.0447417796,
-0.0117512736,
0.013157527,
-0.029198762,
0.0183190163,
-0.0061744843,
0.0901458189,
0.0332414471,
0.0449737348,
-0.0152452784,
0.019427713,
-0.0127493059,
0.070486255,
-0.0662828386,
0.0432118028,
0.0132631101,
0.0239940546,
-0.0081173945,
-0.019602146,
0.0655310899,
-0.0036059429,
0.0548516773,
-0.0837175995,
-0.0090977456,
-0.0002449427,
0.0341403112,
-0.0028815912,
0.0113848932,
0.0250665359,
0.0180511326,
-0.0144334929,
-0.0114817526,
0.0112842657,
-0.0516523086,
-0.0165819936,
-0.0001907178,
-0.0342213474,
-0.0306732114,
0.0137087423,
-0.0574359633,
0.0443206877,
0.0098814778,
0.036455743,
0.0247047413,
-0.0726225153,
0.0092646684,
-0.0190473292,
-0.0056039421,
0.0234833434,
-0.0584803596,
-0.0442184992,
-0.0160684083,
-0.0533054359,
-0.0089903912,
0.0026447789,
0.0073380703,
-0.0199160092,
0.0192468222,
0.0017954935,
-0.0401298888,
0.003689582,
-0.0208716784,
0.0081025697,
-0.0014473929,
-5.387222284e-33,
-0.0164721962,
-0.048035156,
0.008538628,
-0.0074510067,
0.0143441726,
-0.0137527883,
0.0084560784,
0.006722989,
-0.0365613587,
0.0110443216,
-0.0064454414,
-0.0196668953,
0.0141215743,
0.0080950782,
0.0284644309,
0.038570337,
0.0245302245,
0.0335858613,
0.0305517185,
-0.0110143293,
0.0171331652,
-0.029759733,
0.0661314726,
-0.0820331722,
0.0948589817,
0.0511710085,
-0.0097958297,
0.0397997275,
0.0167167448,
-0.013833778,
-0.0471450165,
0.0432842895,
-0.0133919949,
-0.0175473187,
-0.0038009365,
0.0396420807,
-0.0359886959,
0.0046438579,
0.0303861592,
0.0229260549,
0.0249309428,
-0.0202586018,
0.040338248,
-0.0306973234,
-0.0138966925,
0.0388907678,
-0.0180766732,
-0.0229228977,
0.0426227488,
0.0157020781,
-0.0631684214,
0.0264775194,
-0.0518120043,
0.0511055142,
0.0077950801,
-0.0019561294,
-0.0186769031,
-0.0823670328,
-0.0625473931,
-0.013018324,
-0.0440023765,
-0.0011406837,
0.0821876898,
-0.0108440388,
-0.049007833,
0.0266030952,
0.0094247013,
0.0052832831,
0.0607079677,
0.0603234582,
0.022851618,
0.0205834843,
0.0329871885,
0.0056214039,
-0.0676642954,
-0.0422558561,
0.0365632214,
-0.0184780844,
0.0188864581,
0.0079171536,
-0.0097699044,
0.0090162167,
-0.0040040486,
-0.0333085917,
-0.0303412415,
-0.0747913197,
0.0203118734,
0.0000161792,
-0.0018260893,
-0.0332561992,
-0.0365863852,
0.0684703737,
0.019099839,
-0.0016335244,
0.0036227659,
-0.0137964161,
0.0068958797,
-0.0116391238,
0.0177178495,
0.0233253986,
0.0090098837,
0.0354424939,
-0.0045683957,
-0.0128559964,
0.0205871426,
-0.0230242386,
-0.0237715039,
-0.0079781665,
-0.0486284159,
0.0122544374,
-0.0173580404,
0.0694091767,
0.0080264146,
0.0414574444,
0.0183208231,
-0.0231461637,
-0.0003746044,
-0.0476398133,
0.0440275259,
-0.0343296342,
-0.0072895526,
-0.0031009978,
-0.0549557842,
-0.018809421,
-0.076433599,
-0.0095267128,
0.0065228133,
0.0873621553,
0.0372747965,
0.0463827997,
-0.0071740309,
-0.0213932823,
2.627e-7,
0.041845236,
0.0111821489,
0.0264795758,
-0.0553322919,
-0.0147117488,
-0.0247754958,
0.0207314827,
0.0455905534,
-0.0153852673,
-0.0228548292,
-0.0005332522,
-0.0175693668,
0.0224347971,
0.0718491003,
-0.0780104995,
-0.0441218168,
-0.0044890847,
-0.0352712758,
-0.0812287927,
0.00589344,
-0.0217697229,
0.0146010472,
0.0112420199,
-0.0083364118,
-0.0547502823,
-0.0314135253,
-0.0521784723,
-0.0218996815,
0.0484432317,
-0.0218680371,
0.007763335,
-0.0124499127,
0.045495294,
-0.0596028715,
0.0119803883,
-0.0028434803,
0.0098865889,
0.0590995662,
-0.0262800008,
-0.0147692068,
-0.0220105499,
0.0086648446,
-0.006014145,
-0.0237662308,
0.0015172757,
0.0748259872,
-0.0294921938,
0.0161778126,
0.0495493151,
-0.0283501092,
0.0111538237,
-0.0134247253,
-0.0137927392,
0.0333842859,
0.0307358671,
-0.0368718058,
0.001072384,
-0.0389690399,
-0.003261412,
0.0086092884,
-0.0038833991,
-0.0203350931,
0.0055426145,
0.0103384573,
-0.0362972617,
0.0003486559,
0.0475735702,
1.839264901e-34,
-0.0214770008,
0.0194203146,
-0.0144140078,
0.0500477068,
0.0240844898,
0.0504537374,
0.0165072232,
-0.01474771,
0.0240747966,
0.0179263037,
0.0333676115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02636v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02636v1 | Can Large Language Models Learn Independent Causal Mechanisms? | 2024-02-04T23:04:02 | 2024-02-04T23:04:02 | Gaël Gendron, Bao Trung Nguyen, Alex Yuxuan Peng, Michael Witbrock, Gillian Dobbie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT, I.2.3; I.2.6; I.2.7; G.3 | Despite impressive performance on language modelling and complex reasoning
tasks, Large Language Models (LLMs) fall short on the same tasks in uncommon
settings or with distribution shifts, exhibiting some lack of generalisation
ability. This issue has usually been alleviated by feeding more training data
into the LLM. However, this method is brittle, as the scope of tasks may not be
readily predictable or may evolve, and updating the model with new data
generally requires extensive additional training. By contrast, systems, such as
causal models, that learn abstract variables and causal relationships can
demonstrate increased robustness against changes in the distribution. One
reason for this success is the existence and use of Independent Causal
Mechanisms (ICMs) representing high-level concepts that only sparsely interact.
In this work, we apply two concepts from causality to learn ICMs within LLMs.
We develop a new LLM architecture composed of multiple sparsely interacting
language modelling modules. We introduce a routing scheme to induce
specialisation of the network into domain-specific modules. We also present a
Mutual Information minimisation objective that trains a separate module to
learn abstraction and domain-invariant mechanisms. We show that such causal
constraints can improve out-of-distribution performance on abstract and causal
reasoning tasks. | [
0.0240612011,
0.0578005202,
-0.0266162269,
0.0315894037,
-0.0410708301,
0.0137366531,
0.0163147841,
-0.024822453,
-0.0029435696,
-0.0366429277,
-0.0143913552,
-0.0055373907,
-0.0361842662,
0.0080791982,
0.0489077456,
-0.0247582849,
0.0292138737,
-0.0455017537,
-0.0022668673,
-0.0274771899,
-0.0366359167,
-0.0210201703,
-0.0158096198,
0.0108361971,
-0.0127184689,
0.008295727,
-0.013443538,
-0.0083556809,
-0.0080698337,
-0.0048792483,
-0.0126384599,
0.0239874367,
0.0523163565,
0.0463015251,
0.0000021517,
-0.0238200016,
0.0137197999,
-0.0270550586,
-0.0089378469,
-0.0212940648,
-0.0307725314,
-0.0020878825,
0.0023414835,
-0.003146064,
-0.0271707494,
-0.0170273837,
0.0720321238,
0.0462779589,
0.0085942531,
0.1049163789,
-0.0114339981,
-0.0627431646,
0.0122880777,
-0.0380352251,
0.0245647673,
-0.0050315964,
0.0339737311,
0.0407412685,
-0.0080531817,
-0.0054491684,
-0.0600886792,
0.0144157968,
0.0653493777,
-0.0018624502,
0.0328212455,
0.0501938462,
0.0315940529,
-0.0435954817,
0.014342146,
0.0755729824,
-0.0152921742,
-0.0352753513,
-0.0119285285,
-0.0260309353,
-0.000480564,
0.0535090268,
-0.0469070598,
0.0015317389,
0.0136953425,
0.0193920601,
0.0493478589,
-0.0154096205,
0.0785896927,
0.0469613299,
-0.0871511996,
0.052894257,
0.0313383639,
-0.0198529456,
-0.0028052174,
0.0193235129,
-0.0125509407,
-0.0100561064,
-0.0324630812,
0.0481032878,
-0.0406434722,
0.0452993624,
0.0111494847,
0.0033239531,
-0.0127150901,
-0.0432548337,
0.0159428399,
0.0313877873,
0.0239972398,
0.0421781205,
-0.0350691751,
0.0464313254,
-0.0610684641,
0.0733843669,
-0.0092925765,
0.0183465108,
-0.0524336323,
-0.0240467973,
0.0118542193,
0.0549624786,
-0.013282897,
-0.0001817919,
-0.016003076,
0.0513171144,
-0.0138303367,
-0.0091305804,
-0.0052559734,
-0.0015509012,
-0.020388009,
-0.0355806015,
-0.0279213749,
0.0213552229,
-0.0457412489,
0.0586184487,
-0.0020837607,
-0.0076266075,
-0.0183352008,
0.0135608651,
0.0139602665,
-0.0196072236,
0.0163747799,
0.1095549986,
-0.0224414356,
-0.0236649923,
-0.0458186418,
-0.0012593624,
0.0210857149,
-0.076166518,
0.0261361748,
-0.0742802843,
-0.0001525783,
0.0177586004,
-0.0053159553,
-0.0632144883,
0.0157472808,
-0.0333429724,
-0.0921073481,
0.0581015348,
0.0403409414,
0.0050285016,
0.0217601284,
-0.003215604,
0.0139376316,
0.0481413193,
0.0263356641,
-0.0368932523,
-0.0161504336,
0.0061301361,
0.0271378849,
0.0357947014,
-0.0072009228,
0.0190684516,
-0.003727654,
-0.0469098985,
0.0058441972,
0.0153978225,
0.0272051729,
0.0177826602,
-0.0320765786,
0.0086618662,
0.0489471816,
0.0062868502,
0.0016086434,
0.0051688375,
0.067003198,
-0.0375183225,
-0.021317834,
0.0486653298,
-0.0904835016,
0.029264845,
0.0078029027,
-0.0145298671,
-0.0085073709,
-0.0379202254,
-0.0543967783,
-0.0557670146,
0.0088770613,
-0.0168919284,
0.0017476574,
0.0080099087,
0.1056586727,
0.0192874856,
-0.0154808816,
0.0181998219,
0.0486424044,
0.0050270571,
0.0178815611,
-0.0211006831,
0.0283591039,
0.0391080044,
0.0322005264,
-0.0572867058,
-0.0209929999,
0.0005582885,
0.0083812214,
0.0575505868,
0.0091335531,
-0.0143756289,
-0.007253937,
-0.0333345197,
-0.0255692676,
0.0005693233,
0.030508928,
0.0432479382,
-0.0094825206,
-0.0339597464,
-0.0036526287,
0.0027751916,
-0.0152808577,
0.0403034166,
-0.0615807734,
-0.0284201074,
0.003581397,
0.0139706088,
0.0618169159,
0.0026488567,
-0.0415302403,
0.007514481,
-0.0044251215,
-0.0671178177,
-0.0575971939,
0.0457448177,
-0.0488921329,
-0.0186508168,
0.0106029911,
-0.0166938826,
-0.0017622344,
0.023200918,
-0.0229913611,
-0.061854627,
0.1050888672,
-0.0092085712,
0.0366661102,
-0.0205732156,
0.0083666546,
0.0122504123,
-0.014708153,
-0.0439532772,
0.0878919363,
-0.0025165987,
0.0084017096,
-0.0112204086,
0.0528291911,
0.0122516127,
-0.0139286686,
0.0126570966,
-0.0102878399,
-0.0084523689,
0.0144329565,
0.0283514559,
-0.0214308351,
-0.0049187164,
-0.0348114371,
-0.0193136334,
-0.0046887468,
-0.0150481733,
0.0001438061,
0.0147202872,
0.0255882181,
0.0260368325,
-0.0156351794,
-0.0187975299,
0.0252940338,
-0.0006330083,
0.0070288805,
0.0052755829,
-0.0061543006,
-0.0443596728,
-0.0494184233,
-0.0207511466,
-0.0390959047,
0.0402516499,
0.0167980399,
-0.0208057854,
-0.0389020182,
0.0193569083,
-0.0123278461,
0.0562627688,
-0.0446871147,
-0.0418534502,
-0.0004392762,
-0.0461639687,
0.0210384633,
0.0571532212,
-0.035691075,
0.0025471502,
0.0670966879,
0.0177396983,
-0.0547729135,
0.0112532889,
-0.0522235781,
-0.006250537,
-0.0558566228,
0.0025996002,
-0.0416794755,
0.0945858955,
-0.005057089,
-0.0172374696,
-0.0342494845,
-0.0093578789,
0.0011164538,
-0.0383743532,
-0.035601072,
-0.0258512404,
-0.0107759368,
0.0107897324,
-0.0416004248,
-0.056227088,
0.0538266674,
0.0254914332,
0.002566433,
-0.0217051953,
-0.0018280976,
-0.0249895435,
0.060787838,
0.0370147452,
0.0028120694,
0.0328481793,
-0.0422364101,
-0.0820186809,
-0.0170510542,
0.0314133652,
0.0380181558,
0.03740789,
-0.0741715431,
0.0436054282,
0.0064987009,
-0.0452585891,
-0.038511429,
-0.0499329232,
-0.0039528878,
0.0367239453,
-0.0227611531,
-0.0108978786,
-0.057334356,
-0.0054889875,
0.0218656026,
0.0342122801,
-0.0102963913,
0.0043466506,
-0.0461268611,
-0.0058578583,
0.0218771566,
-0.0175526459,
0.0021389758,
-0.0479514636,
0.0216796752,
-0.0268763397,
-0.0024108125,
-0.0341496095,
-0.0182485301,
0.0363097154,
-0.0195630006,
-0.009514668,
-0.0059013651,
-0.0181141458,
0.0176941231,
-0.0319191664,
-0.0227111243,
0.0997164547,
0.0168972109,
-0.0358405747,
0.0056638517,
-0.0037490251,
0.0267843995,
0.0544617586,
0.0242452677,
-0.0693360642,
-0.0054767025,
0.0052451389,
-0.0231747702,
-0.0096301921,
-0.0411320478,
0.0274041779,
-0.0906606838,
0.0152505897,
0.0343778282,
-0.0418801606,
-0.0202002209,
-0.0381098501,
-0.0111686168,
-0.0081543718,
-0.000092325,
-0.0153773902,
0.0226982441,
-0.038247209,
0.0187881794,
0.0091385748,
-0.046460513,
-0.0143162766,
-0.0090788789,
0.039572902,
0.0205595363,
-0.0156552922,
-0.0405714028,
0.0277087316,
0.0576625988,
-0.0126229944,
0.0158933066,
-0.0194269586,
0.0167622194,
0.0351994112,
-0.0302035138,
0.0101933824,
0.0365507603,
-0.0406741053,
-0.0096741654,
-0.0324785635,
0.0973324105,
-0.0543471538,
-0.0258121565,
0.0205114204,
-0.0382860452,
-0.0044403472,
0.0404735245,
0.0057473453,
-0.0232519694,
-0.0560191981,
-0.0175706334,
-0.0841256306,
-0.0233065169,
-0.0210373253,
-0.0156282242,
-0.0023833972,
-0.0494817235,
-0.049072288,
-0.0241598114,
0.0163332317,
0.0367969237,
0.0351743251,
0.0294771716,
0.0333229527,
-0.021614518,
-0.0299457442,
0.01821406,
-0.047210522,
0.000243471,
-0.0097185392,
-0.0445168838,
0.0185631458,
-0.0410126708,
-0.0095997825,
0.007675943,
-0.0060511311,
-0.0959219486,
-0.0182296094,
0.0697060078,
0.0280703101,
0.0876704007,
-0.0413302779,
-0.0638418496,
0.0460030101,
-0.0234667249,
-0.015975168,
0.0191470068,
0.0226628482,
-0.0391077921,
0.0054121832,
0.0446794778,
-0.0500943586,
0.0417046174,
0.0654876456,
0.0385852307,
-0.0209353138,
0.0624764711,
0.0204510819,
-0.0341113247,
0.0220677815,
-0.0154891638,
-0.0173720848,
-0.0598182268,
0.0266427938,
-0.0232173856,
-0.0367967784,
-0.0275772065,
0.0154561922,
0.0535101406,
0.0441825762,
-0.0034920117,
-0.040382091,
0.0252756272,
0.0482282192,
0.0064849169,
0.0161680505,
0.0047277603,
0.0119090965,
0.021255428,
0.0230302233,
0.0038472286,
0.0122948568,
-0.0056776842,
0.0204547495,
-0.0078407349,
0.0388726667,
0.0335563123,
0.0125175416,
-0.0703465268,
-0.0560818091,
-0.0898577273,
-0.0287267379,
0.0420951061,
0.017943684,
0.1117115691,
-0.0112875234,
0.016318813,
-0.0385444835,
-0.0073787114,
0.0060058632,
0.0346980803,
0.0448383838,
0.0000998564,
0.0487637483,
0.037774235,
-0.0017477229,
0.013017646,
0.0640063435,
0.0318217613,
0.060151875,
-0.0406660698,
0.0273587257,
-0.0303589851,
-0.0060581882,
0.0068950327,
0.0374634862,
-0.0379607864,
0.0452396497,
-0.0313523673,
-0.0686313957,
-0.0335964523,
-0.0050482713,
0.014339475,
-0.0166643672,
0.0212593284,
0.025060745,
-0.0125575457,
0.0055399495,
-0.0085768932,
0.0072255116,
-0.026535688,
-0.0202593226,
-0.0221146848,
-6.886276598e-33,
-0.0228282847,
-0.0067705256,
0.0337548554,
0.0346702747,
0.0007029134,
0.0111946175,
-0.0791977718,
0.0288818609,
-0.0311742984,
0.0371509939,
0.0146716069,
0.0132766534,
0.0108475573,
0.0034973419,
0.0359991901,
-0.0032063378,
0.0244709589,
0.0049657044,
0.0031496575,
0.0300589763,
0.0333323888,
0.0176107362,
0.0454966538,
-0.0953820497,
-0.0022228747,
-0.0104594659,
0.0147417821,
0.0642144457,
-0.0275823046,
0.0578555204,
-0.0148270866,
0.0240827277,
0.0527061,
-0.0251280982,
-0.0124835456,
0.0314583555,
-0.0753784329,
-0.0369843617,
0.0504690297,
0.0016452258,
-0.0150248539,
-0.0788946673,
0.0716091543,
0.0003403224,
-0.0013051174,
-0.0173513182,
0.0298920553,
-0.0182463024,
-0.0205660295,
0.0263559408,
-0.1076836735,
0.0076518776,
-0.0018709496,
-0.0002951934,
-0.0201786626,
-0.0164997708,
-0.0181071274,
-0.0095002521,
0.0220269691,
-0.0021455558,
-0.0176133439,
0.0381425396,
0.0352105163,
0.0831567571,
0.0159459431,
0.0604882389,
0.0076178093,
-0.0033368657,
-0.046943631,
-0.0147084314,
0.0409136973,
0.0427124016,
0.0350697562,
0.0125913098,
0.0030403486,
0.0277395658,
-0.1137949601,
-0.033881411,
0.020248156,
0.0351577438,
0.039697919,
0.0265635103,
-0.0022462755,
-0.0206430331,
-0.047976438,
0.0166546702,
-0.0357001871,
-0.0252736919,
0.0282413121,
0.0204762574,
0.0160085279,
-0.040647693,
0.011708918,
-0.0607012771,
-0.0086663673,
0.0507039875,
0.003950282,
0.0371365733,
-0.0078065838,
-0.0150188878,
-0.0704019815,
-0.0432763249,
-0.0158092938,
0.0101451734,
0.009285327,
0.0390252843,
0.058444906,
0.0187096577,
-0.0293798409,
-0.032537017,
-0.0552379861,
-0.0400377177,
0.0202417485,
0.0724009201,
0.0331310704,
0.0456159785,
-0.0232677162,
0.0055145663,
0.0115283914,
0.0017950302,
0.023504803,
0.0072584772,
-0.0294256452,
0.041080337,
-0.0437436029,
-0.0281068347,
-0.0380646475,
0.0143237691,
0.0218010042,
-0.0602514669,
-0.0197821092,
0.0096825538,
2.876e-7,
0.0531139001,
0.0374439284,
-0.0024859703,
0.0295927245,
0.0470938794,
-0.0020694444,
-0.0370084085,
-0.0124026481,
0.0122044645,
-0.0133138476,
0.0378538929,
0.0574710183,
0.0388145149,
-0.0419996306,
-0.1059717536,
0.0183905531,
0.0113242446,
-0.0117080025,
-0.0206638779,
-0.0105406689,
0.0333318338,
0.0994394943,
0.0351551026,
-0.0010671628,
0.0058059101,
-0.0598434433,
0.0576648414,
0.0000936424,
0.0212967079,
0.001718587,
-0.0494561605,
0.0254730619,
-0.009380362,
0.062384028,
-0.0002892124,
0.0455143303,
-0.0587757826,
0.057766024,
-0.0416953713,
0.0059301993,
-0.0198216233,
-0.0204048604,
0.0254819151,
-0.0235060714,
0.0504654832,
-0.0587085709,
-0.0569177456,
0.0560255572,
-0.0102651641,
0.0281804837,
-0.017838385,
0.0112827998,
-0.0220142361,
-0.0054944162,
0.0129981814,
-0.0009856124,
0.0168830268,
-0.0723741427,
-0.0218860451,
0.0480384454,
-0.0347171389,
-0.0684736744,
-0.00185797,
-0.019372195,
0.0264670495,
-0.0435963608,
0.0049037691,
2.789395519e-34,
0.0269304905,
0.0086177737,
0.0212405249,
0.0408292115,
0.0247951411,
-0.0288581792,
-0.0645987466,
0.0312526003,
0.0482470468,
-0.0977586284,
0.0169910677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02633v1 | Predicting Machine Translation Performance on Low-Resource Languages: The Role of Domain Similarity | 2024-02-04T22:56:56 | 2024-02-04T22:56:56 | Eric Khiu, Hasti Toossi, David Anugraha, Jinyu Liu, Jiaxu Li, Juan Armando Parra Flores, Leandro Acros Roman, A. Seza Doğruöz, En-Shiun Annie Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Fine-tuning and testing a multilingual large language model is expensive and
challenging for low-resource languages (LRLs). While previous studies have
predicted the performance of natural language processing (NLP) tasks using
machine learning methods, they primarily focus on high-resource languages,
overlooking LRLs and shifts across domains. Focusing on LRLs, we investigate
three factors: the size of the fine-tuning corpus, the domain similarity
between fine-tuning and testing corpora, and the language similarity between
source and target languages. We employ classical regression models to assess
how these factors impact the model's performance. Our results indicate that
domain similarity has the most critical impact on predicting the performance of
Machine Translation models. | [
0.0233367309,
0.0346063972,
-0.0307196174,
0.0354058221,
-0.04421838,
0.011133723,
0.0601660088,
0.0015565224,
-0.0514451005,
-0.0544998161,
-0.0410223715,
-0.0155676315,
0.0513119847,
-0.0256916769,
0.0301704109,
-0.0398922153,
0.0299819447,
-0.0124731259,
-0.0314821675,
0.002340605,
-0.015330065,
0.0249838345,
0.0280448962,
0.0461806469,
0.025889501,
0.0199617483,
0.0414389521,
0.0472851209,
0.0064968476,
0.009573333,
-0.0146235898,
0.0324561559,
0.0172607116,
0.058078479,
0.0000016762,
-0.0714166909,
-0.0279887319,
0.0292239431,
0.0081081614,
0.0064497371,
0.0744072199,
-0.0804622397,
-0.014365131,
0.0403644145,
-0.0179844834,
-0.0358861312,
0.0496043786,
-0.0070914216,
0.0347727239,
0.0860665441,
-0.0098617142,
-0.0198440347,
-0.0154137705,
-0.0548833199,
-0.0385786742,
-0.0775436684,
-0.0265451297,
0.0214695353,
-0.054570768,
-0.0103586372,
-0.0235726833,
0.0381675698,
-0.0252934247,
0.042257797,
-0.0434238985,
-0.0210482404,
-0.045115035,
-0.041596327,
0.0117706656,
0.0236652475,
-0.069562763,
-0.0441434719,
-0.0148924924,
0.0038266885,
-0.0015935366,
0.0186181124,
-0.0150180478,
0.0125193717,
0.0001713969,
-0.0047604539,
0.039086435,
0.0286270864,
0.0241932273,
-0.0002941286,
-0.0332357287,
-0.0062928703,
0.0291566085,
-0.0142605742,
-0.0129749225,
0.0290307831,
-0.0374294706,
-0.0000962638,
-0.0069816173,
-0.0414351523,
-0.0280632433,
0.0016108582,
-0.0477643386,
-0.0669079199,
0.0268945582,
-0.0056503601,
0.0383738689,
0.0402133018,
0.0026450946,
0.037102025,
-0.0375376232,
0.0527370386,
-0.0206079502,
-0.0150470193,
-0.0507220514,
-0.0312644504,
-0.0417625643,
0.0374828614,
-0.0342313424,
-0.0159103889,
-0.0447704084,
0.0137223396,
-0.0257806275,
0.0001788393,
0.0272095744,
-0.0172234159,
0.0093795191,
-0.0488384627,
-0.0683970749,
0.0038490039,
0.0049381992,
0.0671089068,
-0.0378040969,
-0.0031882674,
-0.0053918553,
-0.0738634616,
-0.0032850041,
0.0041952021,
0.0035974737,
-0.0578024015,
0.0132040633,
0.0985717699,
0.0190564767,
-0.0132446336,
-0.0279826429,
0.0061381664,
-0.0034385643,
-0.0822691098,
-0.00377832,
-0.0726289675,
0.0341384523,
0.0511476956,
0.0342303962,
-0.0600762777,
-0.0234472807,
0.0010337299,
-0.0426948108,
0.0564518534,
0.0220377501,
0.0252812244,
0.0014352959,
-0.0409488678,
-0.0237284899,
0.0803636611,
0.0261873137,
-0.0121109113,
0.0468440987,
-0.0234363452,
-0.0443714969,
0.0617653318,
-0.0127636278,
0.0394742005,
0.0003252943,
-0.0211404786,
-0.0077778581,
0.0178029928,
0.0341416076,
0.0132874111,
0.0002021968,
0.0446280688,
0.0619447865,
0.0629287809,
0.0268621817,
0.0462524444,
0.0367488004,
0.0142176468,
-0.0359008871,
-0.0067929421,
-0.037354473,
-0.0066160494,
0.0053282771,
0.0009104406,
0.0403725468,
0.0776709318,
-0.0095082736,
-0.0086168712,
-0.0097867819,
-0.0271202158,
0.0026676438,
-0.0231277496,
0.0752553195,
0.0087156054,
-0.0347415283,
0.052081801,
0.0166121237,
-0.0333310142,
-0.0056518661,
-0.0275872014,
-0.0407866053,
0.018582698,
0.027941674,
0.0099393763,
0.0062825456,
-0.027043581,
0.0471747182,
0.0367769077,
0.0935624763,
0.0300203003,
0.0147218276,
-0.019708598,
-0.0164791122,
0.0249028467,
0.0374445654,
0.0145107564,
0.0256947726,
0.0408050008,
0.0355686955,
-0.0685834289,
-0.0861884132,
0.0160062313,
-0.0560734272,
-0.0043148668,
0.0040084501,
0.0238409042,
0.0259546638,
0.0010047556,
-0.0204776768,
0.0023018601,
-0.0172281414,
-0.036324583,
-0.0130149378,
0.0137979733,
0.0101000005,
-0.0166458935,
0.0050582672,
-0.0379872657,
0.0079770945,
0.0353591442,
-0.0343871415,
-0.0247027408,
0.0376132019,
-0.0168431662,
0.0072142086,
-0.0191149879,
0.0563499741,
-0.0443970636,
0.0068886229,
-0.068023704,
0.0077229361,
0.0323809683,
0.050138671,
-0.0120155653,
-0.0121108489,
0.0450098813,
-0.004015597,
-0.0154666537,
-0.0055932309,
-0.0120572317,
0.0534772761,
0.0572750866,
0.0189862046,
0.0006612219,
-0.0084821535,
-0.0338884667,
0.0070314556,
-0.0443765037,
0.0201616623,
0.0396470726,
0.0389380418,
0.0054278639,
-0.0019098286,
-0.0015339454,
-0.0002095418,
0.0323273987,
0.0361240692,
-0.0007705743,
-0.0133115407,
-0.0079929503,
-0.0474927574,
-0.0161845926,
0.0358260199,
0.0632371902,
0.0149688637,
-0.0228599012,
-0.0504198372,
0.0590944551,
-0.0069351802,
0.0101187974,
0.000925011,
-0.06149932,
-0.0203953851,
0.014706403,
0.0112015856,
0.02462974,
-0.0289732181,
-0.014337563,
0.0294532496,
0.0226245075,
-0.0712300166,
-0.0214275327,
-0.0100058522,
-0.0812491998,
-0.0397374034,
-0.0396776833,
0.039158769,
0.0295806266,
0.0086851437,
-0.0174046326,
-0.040504422,
0.0207621232,
-0.0465434454,
0.0040648943,
-0.0006394802,
0.0459382534,
0.0218215156,
0.0721212626,
-0.0122842779,
-0.0840744227,
0.0512872487,
-0.0282524843,
0.0195341799,
-0.0692099631,
-0.0055710478,
-0.0457254574,
0.014595069,
-0.0246920194,
0.0246467125,
0.0051832646,
-0.0193347055,
-0.0424620323,
0.0636111051,
0.0469069965,
-0.0059687695,
0.0628600344,
-0.0404438078,
0.0053405729,
-0.0304143764,
-0.0252385084,
-0.0038481173,
-0.0418197177,
-0.0155600617,
0.008973565,
0.0325194001,
-0.0359783918,
-0.0610533059,
0.0301536657,
0.0018228476,
0.0313525535,
-0.0059590419,
-0.0033043642,
-0.0057753762,
0.011247403,
0.002649162,
-0.0115839196,
0.0130293854,
-0.0483684801,
0.0147430385,
-0.0426687673,
0.0030000012,
0.0095451213,
-0.0365132391,
-0.0261144638,
0.0353285074,
0.007164103,
-0.0120213954,
0.0170961116,
0.0620411001,
-0.0348771624,
-0.0196758416,
0.1160613373,
0.0125142457,
-0.0211470537,
0.0085979514,
-0.0077567245,
0.0631145313,
0.0465467758,
0.030124845,
-0.0316627398,
-0.0388304815,
0.0145209888,
0.0525484383,
0.026546102,
0.0008411008,
-0.0097484104,
-0.1210430488,
0.0025029439,
0.0133882333,
-0.0568157546,
-0.0692042038,
-0.0491589569,
-0.0254520308,
-0.0415741093,
0.0271747746,
-0.0372552127,
-0.0121719791,
-0.0109890662,
0.0074298321,
-0.014668542,
-0.0948409364,
0.0179208405,
-0.0741185993,
0.0216732249,
0.095449999,
0.0336902626,
-0.0254264269,
0.0243260209,
0.0525011234,
-0.0025454117,
0.0174763985,
-0.014264836,
0.0292532332,
0.0364695042,
-0.0277323443,
0.0349522643,
0.0034711985,
-0.0412914902,
0.0415997915,
0.023054745,
0.0428171642,
-0.0035263707,
-0.0184131097,
0.0409454964,
-0.0262076035,
-0.0062095071,
0.0635253415,
0.0340362936,
-0.057481125,
-0.0206579026,
0.0072328337,
-0.0402140729,
-0.027786376,
-0.0508849658,
0.0007441659,
-0.0600047708,
-0.0281958356,
-0.0781710297,
-0.0377705283,
0.02092213,
0.0358305909,
0.0230058599,
0.0452074818,
0.0249653589,
-0.0037886535,
-0.0223067887,
0.0563961081,
-0.0297418591,
0.0228549726,
-0.0659846291,
0.0180189312,
0.0308578555,
-0.0142755695,
-0.0094838068,
-0.0137292184,
-0.0917915031,
-0.0632677302,
-0.0328567475,
0.0230194386,
0.0242025126,
0.0158613846,
-0.0332287624,
-0.0347589701,
-0.0049039931,
0.0233871937,
-0.0260093808,
0.0184450131,
0.0042650746,
-0.0415187888,
-0.0261613224,
0.0484075807,
-0.0277524274,
0.0200000294,
0.0083523421,
0.0288404953,
0.0057341675,
-0.0551440381,
-0.0014564989,
0.0244646072,
0.0613933653,
-0.0327904932,
-0.0569517128,
-0.0119695207,
-0.0159219038,
0.0232125632,
-0.003627372,
-0.0322267562,
-0.058938086,
0.0457358584,
0.0224381182,
-0.0071416544,
0.0162943099,
-0.008500848,
0.0005323967,
-0.0354526192,
0.0322102122,
-0.0167714898,
0.0353161618,
0.0258658193,
0.0304878522,
-0.016154157,
-0.0006384404,
-0.0232281107,
0.0072735171,
-0.0481854565,
0.0334041528,
-0.0029281732,
0.0501123182,
0.0114679188,
0.0301241986,
0.0008207667,
-0.0491077118,
0.0075950599,
-0.0273889564,
0.0851546302,
-0.0601424016,
0.1245850846,
0.0026432266,
0.0017940893,
-0.046978984,
0.0356275365,
0.0069397087,
0.0196313113,
0.022027472,
-0.0054153628,
-0.0244642869,
0.0317430869,
0.0825253278,
0.0313873664,
-0.0074750031,
-0.0028199216,
-0.0333649293,
0.0040950826,
-0.0141326105,
-0.0020546131,
-0.0322227031,
-0.0153212147,
0.0013747164,
-0.0478691794,
-0.0658757463,
-0.0050876811,
-0.0295813307,
0.0192330536,
-0.0031210717,
0.000100027,
0.1068196595,
-0.0415376052,
0.0382275619,
-0.065664947,
-0.0261063557,
-0.0119121047,
-0.0263253842,
-0.0038293151,
-5.862180409e-33,
-0.0112995142,
-0.0063903197,
0.0072780964,
-0.047029499,
0.0149091501,
-0.002953975,
-0.0190938581,
0.0002602701,
-0.0450049154,
-0.0049989275,
-0.0106806522,
-0.0145525923,
0.0210766494,
0.0106232753,
0.0308764242,
0.0273354836,
0.056589514,
0.0196355265,
-0.0335119255,
-0.0243104994,
0.0162386838,
0.0134223253,
0.0452735871,
-0.0541112088,
0.0087320469,
-0.0101948706,
0.0110012069,
-0.005295347,
0.0292628538,
0.0189019721,
0.0297445823,
0.0305207372,
0.0369343162,
-0.0591954328,
-0.028588539,
-0.0123436293,
-0.0708775744,
0.0067617991,
0.0478602163,
0.020890709,
0.0520936586,
-0.0105653526,
0.0418399423,
-0.0262689926,
-0.0104378229,
-0.0252776109,
0.0299613997,
-0.036926005,
-0.0408807956,
-0.0036654263,
-0.1016614437,
0.0440446027,
0.0121264579,
-0.0136166606,
0.0351039469,
0.0872351378,
-0.0320862979,
0.0214331467,
-0.0423345491,
-0.0073621529,
-0.0443625003,
0.0828650817,
0.0705316737,
-0.0141769452,
-0.039653372,
0.0146172764,
-0.0029344398,
0.0163679942,
0.0669579953,
0.0238421243,
0.0654382929,
0.0236631297,
0.038199015,
0.0616573989,
0.0419132113,
-0.0122725368,
-0.0605904274,
0.0255611725,
-0.034077391,
0.0265835747,
0.0500649735,
-0.0069287657,
-0.0390859582,
-0.0243845116,
-0.0736665502,
0.0092413239,
-0.0272133239,
-0.012497331,
0.0268347282,
0.0192750245,
-0.0140549932,
0.0009363509,
0.0922292694,
-0.0283250008,
-0.0050610323,
0.001171727,
-0.0238594562,
0.0012867502,
-0.0268010832,
0.0409166589,
-0.0194729455,
-0.0501586907,
-0.024947308,
0.0189572126,
0.0253320858,
-0.0304880422,
0.0510241501,
-0.0199766271,
-0.0719016194,
0.0054867375,
-0.0357578173,
-0.002584059,
-0.0291309934,
0.0474849939,
0.0155253494,
-0.0088140285,
0.0003874844,
0.0424652286,
0.0302801915,
-0.0546845458,
0.0005672314,
0.0379326604,
0.0156829003,
0.0150350425,
-0.0480316393,
-0.0073862546,
-0.0464353748,
0.0518035665,
0.0480495319,
-0.0246352591,
-0.0479235426,
-0.0409424938,
2.501e-7,
0.044559598,
0.065316841,
-0.0277903844,
0.0447155945,
0.0035830485,
0.0422470719,
-0.0324757546,
0.0161525253,
0.0103177587,
0.0416523777,
-0.0037477701,
-0.0044962,
0.0958549902,
0.0166085958,
-0.0829755589,
-0.0298794322,
-0.0096536493,
0.029379826,
-0.0586519055,
0.0023347787,
0.0064740051,
0.0928552374,
0.0031195257,
-0.0035650469,
-0.014559119,
-0.0389786251,
0.0552676357,
-0.0275415815,
-0.0235666297,
0.0024408582,
0.0058719805,
0.03956303,
-0.0126908282,
0.0129529135,
-0.0476275124,
0.0201453008,
0.0354282968,
0.0543629453,
0.00873126,
0.0224730913,
0.0239871815,
-0.0231112223,
-0.0349537767,
-0.0133192977,
0.0301507562,
-0.0348754898,
-0.011950518,
-0.0004994571,
0.0139514245,
0.0328068808,
0.0316710994,
-0.0324287042,
-0.0336971283,
0.0286597479,
0.0562791489,
-0.0130659183,
-0.0304887351,
-0.0232340898,
-0.0200859662,
0.0331051163,
-0.00697699,
-0.0443170331,
-0.0061522895,
0.0030471853,
0.0442968719,
-0.0232178774,
0.0165843535,
2.300925499e-34,
0.0495538265,
-0.0006324625,
0.0327452123,
-0.0271826703,
0.039933037,
-0.0205158312,
0.0031293156,
0.0143248411,
-0.0278073493,
-0.030565612,
0.0156648196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02632v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02632v2 | GIRT-Model: Automated Generation of Issue Report Templates | 2024-02-04T22:53:38 | 2024-02-08T14:24:40 | Nafiseh Nikeghbal, Amir Hossein Kargaran, Abbas Heydarnoori | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Platforms such as GitHub and GitLab introduce Issue Report Templates (IRTs)
to enable more effective issue management and better alignment with developer
expectations. However, these templates are not widely adopted in most
repositories, and there is currently no tool available to aid developers in
generating them. In this work, we introduce GIRT-Model, an assistant language
model that automatically generates IRTs based on the developer's instructions
regarding the structure and necessary fields. We create GIRT-Instruct, a
dataset comprising pairs of instructions and IRTs, with the IRTs sourced from
GitHub repositories. We use GIRT-Instruct to instruction-tune a T5-base model
to create the GIRT-Model. In our experiments, GIRT-Model outperforms general
language models (T5 and Flan-T5 with different parameter sizes) in IRT
generation by achieving significantly higher scores in ROUGE, BLEU, METEOR, and
human evaluation. Additionally, we analyze the effectiveness of GIRT-Model in a
user study in which participants wrote short IRTs with GIRT-Model. Our results
show that the participants find GIRT-Model useful in the automated generation
of templates. We hope that through the use of GIRT-Model, we can encourage more
developers to adopt IRTs in their repositories. We publicly release our code,
dataset, and model at https://github.com/ISE-Research/girt-model. | [
0.0578368418,
0.0096330447,
-0.041580461,
-0.0519546755,
-0.0188545175,
-0.0054894458,
0.0049280897,
0.0087354705,
-0.0080006896,
-0.0411585532,
0.0224947892,
0.042793531,
0.0039653322,
0.0512477458,
-0.0153354816,
-0.0535192676,
0.0139637692,
-0.0075844945,
0.0639584213,
0.0514973253,
0.0303777922,
0.0516596474,
-0.0012941896,
0.041493129,
0.0033535643,
-0.0287570544,
0.0101642068,
0.0170252901,
0.0043722829,
-0.0037197175,
0.035794355,
0.0411336571,
-0.0242829323,
-0.0022688732,
0.0000023089,
-0.0199896414,
0.0027106709,
0.0129475426,
0.0357840396,
0.0422189422,
0.0221154001,
-0.0332868584,
-0.011862468,
0.0218926147,
-0.0129226949,
0.010392,
0.0097849388,
0.0274464712,
0.0821435452,
0.0263067447,
0.0023129892,
0.0002659816,
-0.011610345,
0.0076953485,
0.0726003274,
-0.0014305209,
-0.0665170476,
0.043203216,
0.0345340297,
0.062541604,
0.0565347783,
-0.001299782,
0.0244164802,
0.0064583947,
0.0241507962,
0.0497880653,
0.0158071406,
-0.0559591018,
0.0113097895,
0.0190209132,
-0.0171569362,
-0.0364058241,
0.0208274182,
-0.0355918296,
-0.0286737438,
0.0366089866,
-0.0464801379,
0.0114615504,
-0.0108818691,
-0.040214397,
0.0125078,
-0.0535534956,
-0.0201211553,
-0.0169669557,
0.0156214908,
0.0250790864,
0.0039462554,
0.0167698786,
-0.0352927186,
-0.0396438241,
-0.0021230793,
-0.0863986611,
0.0001313127,
0.0461795256,
0.0049442579,
-0.0142647885,
0.0104287891,
-0.034638267,
0.0828737468,
-0.0306193791,
-0.0696769133,
0.0306689329,
-0.0345547237,
-0.0257288329,
-0.0063067125,
0.0714644045,
-0.0061688498,
0.0165470522,
0.0080244113,
0.0183579214,
-0.0597831868,
0.0089414408,
-0.0360946953,
0.0006587649,
0.0073032961,
0.0210338458,
0.0315614343,
0.0497194566,
0.0414345637,
0.0429951139,
0.0199903399,
-0.0067032422,
-0.0695615262,
-0.0120660793,
0.0126573667,
-0.0091150766,
-0.0601129569,
-0.0090008099,
-0.0167266484,
0.0093803322,
0.0065972148,
-0.0185196549,
-0.0238540135,
-0.0315804034,
-0.0292704348,
-0.0130160442,
0.0346022248,
0.0365506113,
-0.0146943703,
-0.0267096516,
0.0263899323,
-0.0019006354,
-0.0355589762,
-0.0985280648,
-0.023711279,
0.0461080447,
0.0058522252,
-0.0726292282,
-0.0239729248,
0.0229765195,
-0.0025779209,
-0.0178575106,
-0.1034695581,
0.0276969839,
0.0721826851,
0.0276685692,
0.0149855427,
0.0138843581,
0.0169577319,
0.0307391118,
0.0268939547,
-0.030528035,
0.0712486729,
0.0091814166,
-0.0147066303,
0.0285009276,
0.0725327954,
0.0390268713,
0.0072849798,
-0.0193518177,
-0.0074777813,
0.0425204299,
-0.0019585758,
0.0140516628,
0.0250741299,
0.0126731806,
0.0705647916,
0.0196602009,
0.0227291007,
0.051804591,
-0.000625943,
-0.0313071273,
-0.0026736767,
0.0653144494,
0.0091502611,
-0.0042397189,
-0.0412144437,
0.0221188534,
-0.0322306342,
-0.0065872096,
-0.0398811735,
-0.0010796112,
-0.07181862,
-0.0051066275,
0.0035675529,
0.0137368636,
-0.0116363624,
0.0416380018,
0.0222286414,
-0.0201098155,
-0.0378024615,
0.0084461654,
0.0736979693,
0.0300718769,
0.0739470571,
-0.0344072543,
-0.055127807,
-0.0469418392,
0.0034185813,
-0.0235527158,
0.0659226328,
-0.0159505922,
-0.0412781835,
-0.0432856232,
-0.0452031419,
-0.0613535568,
-0.011998998,
0.0116701405,
0.0138410497,
-0.0059717125,
0.0108736493,
-0.0542437173,
-0.0640464798,
0.0322571136,
-0.0001954242,
0.0057062889,
0.0028501984,
-0.0352979749,
0.0130876563,
0.0200894419,
-0.0008572218,
0.010181779,
0.0236577094,
0.0102738403,
-0.0266607497,
0.0337000117,
0.0417708606,
0.029665336,
0.0075753862,
-0.046666503,
-0.0052812975,
-0.0105314236,
-0.0503909327,
0.0265510399,
0.0190785732,
-0.0227044951,
-0.01589383,
0.0129443677,
-0.0090542734,
-0.0248009413,
-0.0315527134,
-0.0037322135,
0.0342894159,
0.0153250564,
0.007307441,
0.0043566921,
0.0380749479,
0.0221670531,
-0.0151052549,
-0.0171509162,
0.0399188176,
-0.019968953,
0.0006755589,
0.0417973548,
0.0524079651,
-0.032959763,
-0.0503975153,
-0.0689380169,
-0.0349872112,
-0.0216377247,
0.0086363116,
0.0381744653,
0.0059596761,
-0.0044430979,
0.0216580778,
-0.0127212824,
-0.0900796652,
-0.0145440632,
0.0077979113,
0.0298755709,
0.015708575,
-0.0123256762,
-0.0396877341,
-0.0144371288,
-0.0467379354,
0.0103109628,
0.0561009012,
-0.0200902019,
-0.0731032863,
0.0399405509,
-0.011167638,
-0.0054668579,
-0.0048117209,
-0.0435230359,
0.0068124407,
-0.0196817294,
0.0798222497,
-0.0270627998,
0.0281972233,
0.0222180579,
0.025039155,
0.0045246352,
-0.0506241061,
0.0027933882,
0.0200117957,
-0.0426985808,
0.0422148444,
-0.1024471596,
0.0593739189,
0.0138140358,
0.0023051184,
0.0314260386,
-0.0700920075,
0.0232559498,
-0.0291411616,
0.030696597,
0.0714387968,
-0.0077868714,
0.0268229879,
0.0658140033,
-0.0271401722,
-0.0595409609,
0.0245368481,
-0.0384832621,
-0.0111772595,
-0.0753049031,
0.0060087484,
-0.0861338526,
0.0448190793,
-0.007034482,
-0.0051557152,
0.0120522166,
0.015687177,
-0.0003816592,
-0.0151581662,
0.0039259898,
0.0128741665,
-0.0393900611,
-0.02706258,
0.0078115431,
-0.0097756619,
0.0206221528,
0.0427083112,
-0.0291853771,
0.002175113,
-0.0048012924,
0.0092477929,
0.013938345,
0.0252302885,
0.0533836745,
0.0431020223,
0.043116983,
0.061365217,
-0.030146962,
-0.0082593858,
-0.0574415326,
0.0076522506,
-0.0569339506,
-0.0289607216,
-0.0170938279,
-0.0036388384,
0.0252468232,
0.1276833564,
0.0405508578,
-0.038117107,
-0.0304018017,
-0.0046009053,
-0.0312765911,
-0.0389669277,
0.0309646707,
0.0074690776,
-0.0082032736,
-0.0013308453,
0.0978340879,
0.0748301744,
-0.0473024063,
-0.002983928,
-0.0223004781,
0.0659666732,
0.057259351,
0.029414326,
-0.1071117073,
0.0065722824,
-0.0098438524,
0.0157819595,
-0.0266681351,
-0.0091790436,
-0.0121740699,
-0.0248547066,
0.0205371678,
-0.0173475202,
0.0089594582,
-0.0176555887,
-0.04159493,
0.0148739535,
0.0044055432,
-0.0619052574,
0.0253854189,
-0.005518645,
0.0369456634,
0.0041358843,
-0.125632599,
-0.0272584073,
0.0253459569,
-0.0429120027,
-0.0030280002,
0.101724118,
0.0031129909,
0.0070396974,
0.0381250232,
0.0002670802,
-0.0159425046,
0.0011514559,
-0.0362537093,
0.0549428314,
-0.023837788,
-0.0043323776,
0.034921281,
0.0120728454,
-0.0414408669,
-0.0154066999,
0.0198692158,
0.0447042696,
-0.0358415283,
-0.0099699153,
-0.0254750904,
-0.0020594138,
0.0109488619,
0.0129464529,
0.0661909655,
-0.0054705259,
-0.0246536154,
-0.0326506086,
0.0257033017,
-0.0434710085,
-0.0124638155,
-0.0375304222,
-0.0154486839,
-0.0321325324,
-0.0962749496,
-0.0705338791,
0.0409055613,
0.0020670453,
0.0466046967,
-0.0339536928,
-0.0068327575,
0.0017479132,
0.0020859777,
0.0333895683,
0.0417841561,
0.0044761333,
-0.0710152462,
-0.0641054735,
0.0127069699,
0.000067876,
-0.0096934792,
0.0561767556,
-0.0211743582,
-0.0117970873,
-0.0036143446,
0.0305166878,
0.02006202,
-0.0286764558,
-0.0332964398,
-0.0717898309,
-0.0312129129,
0.0220357589,
-0.0675733909,
-0.0279088691,
0.0043058544,
-0.0088289035,
-0.0095742373,
-0.0177447796,
-0.0600732155,
-0.022299787,
-0.0320367292,
0.0136595136,
-0.0041345707,
-0.0049734572,
0.0465631671,
0.0070417589,
0.0143324398,
0.0610397309,
-0.0077106887,
-0.0225934219,
-0.0237648115,
0.0062821382,
-0.0264489874,
-0.0205911305,
0.0556478612,
-0.0379806161,
-0.0581616946,
0.0292624757,
0.0738727152,
-0.0831417292,
0.0244816877,
-0.0203017946,
0.0401040688,
-0.0103940405,
0.0632643923,
-0.0055921762,
-0.0264563002,
-0.038556546,
-0.0431956239,
-0.0459946021,
-0.0022865955,
-0.0095888488,
0.0620534308,
-0.0012977795,
0.019877106,
0.0306683127,
0.0055927555,
-0.0292669162,
-0.0697926059,
0.0016674851,
-0.0192364939,
-0.0111700268,
0.0486729033,
0.0504397638,
-0.0431114286,
-0.0140736718,
-0.0404388942,
0.0510501117,
0.0103005664,
0.0040818411,
0.0292725954,
0.0143061737,
-0.0193240922,
-0.0900948271,
0.0614740774,
-0.0037372117,
-0.0027474335,
-0.0402476788,
-0.0221733898,
-0.0208812952,
0.0098727569,
0.0144559722,
-0.0310436003,
-0.0137423696,
-0.0504397377,
-0.0475562476,
-0.0207157116,
0.0155366901,
0.0061780596,
0.0183424931,
0.0025811689,
0.0163008738,
0.1070638821,
-0.0161825716,
-0.0401659198,
-0.0108410846,
-0.02811848,
-0.0418004431,
-0.0360687375,
-0.0399988517,
-5.60666357e-33,
-0.0218424574,
-0.0085957255,
0.0131835137,
0.0219111312,
0.0592403933,
-0.020243708,
-0.0571753718,
-0.0021602691,
-0.0145848095,
-0.0110533368,
-0.0077047097,
-0.0001725392,
0.0017085377,
-0.0787499622,
0.0785173476,
0.0502589308,
0.0730597973,
0.0367245041,
-0.051781293,
0.0748734251,
-0.030264549,
-0.0051500276,
0.0037389374,
-0.0421550833,
0.0068448116,
-0.033033248,
0.010558486,
-0.0222699866,
0.0500580706,
0.0599859394,
0.0092224898,
-0.0269725583,
0.0277452599,
-0.0179717001,
-0.0287781339,
-0.0303539168,
-0.0125036929,
-0.0315981582,
0.0161027014,
-0.0127288988,
0.0102871899,
-0.035099756,
0.0379834846,
-0.0091509381,
0.0050270339,
-0.0036912872,
0.0479630046,
0.0352236144,
0.0361868478,
-0.006613364,
-0.0359486081,
0.0545747653,
-0.0291863438,
-0.0036827235,
-0.0260779019,
0.0616020784,
0.0252846405,
0.0433481149,
0.0170930102,
-0.0155668762,
0.0258677341,
0.0259761456,
0.0610730946,
-0.0539717674,
-0.0577665605,
-0.0233040862,
-0.025446156,
0.0278818961,
-0.0062903352,
0.0429436304,
0.0042171888,
0.0497009493,
0.0489547364,
0.0326415747,
-0.018685868,
-0.0134224081,
0.0189237855,
0.0659615248,
-0.0119335614,
0.0853795111,
0.016302567,
0.0052201082,
-0.026538888,
-0.0022635246,
-0.0068750498,
-0.003987981,
-0.0252523758,
-0.0533462204,
0.0270584095,
0.0030733333,
-0.0015080369,
0.0216350928,
0.0146635305,
0.0146833919,
0.0295346659,
0.0527034961,
-0.078347154,
0.0533690713,
-0.0297723953,
0.0068328781,
-0.0296310931,
0.0244693942,
0.0194997117,
0.0458739549,
0.0647659749,
0.0056750444,
0.0207880698,
0.0082889404,
-0.0532209426,
0.0073855198,
-0.0374132581,
0.015392147,
-0.0612037703,
-0.0016361203,
-0.0448544212,
0.0025212411,
-0.0032904097,
0.02108711,
-0.0244951285,
-0.042849984,
-0.0882255808,
0.0437839702,
0.0125865852,
0.0260747001,
-0.0095560877,
-0.0300812256,
-0.0249294825,
0.026261773,
0.0488761254,
0.0363567658,
-0.0426601656,
0.0224528722,
2.832e-7,
0.0257796943,
0.0403810777,
0.0271026473,
0.000639863,
0.0227344651,
0.0326624997,
-0.0181059614,
0.0195587091,
0.0400836691,
0.0202461649,
-0.0209805518,
-0.008731775,
0.0090823211,
0.0705406666,
-0.009723776,
-0.039270252,
-0.0326463468,
0.0022814728,
-0.0972642004,
0.0203960184,
0.0211990792,
-0.0061700828,
0.0297234021,
0.029117018,
-0.0128600849,
-0.0028650837,
-0.0127387075,
-0.0005178842,
0.0116245132,
0.122038655,
-0.047267247,
0.0242949016,
-0.0277572088,
-0.0514043309,
-0.0200557373,
-0.0754845217,
-0.0230924487,
0.0265966803,
0.0051336461,
0.0093121873,
0.0345422253,
0.0223519504,
-0.0081608454,
-0.1054319441,
0.0113353888,
-0.0385280885,
-0.0155711295,
0.0062310933,
-0.0109878043,
-0.0177765861,
0.0071468074,
-0.0022686163,
-0.0071658855,
-0.0193155874,
-0.0355984159,
-0.01193232,
-0.0280310828,
-0.0409634821,
-0.0054857559,
0.020861173,
-0.0136546027,
-0.0234376937,
-0.0323645771,
0.0220164713,
-0.0147782722,
-0.0011042259,
0.0665463582,
2.435091649e-34,
0.0114323618,
-0.0240238067,
-0.0211035348,
0.0178490076,
0.0657185912,
-0.01575079,
-0.0101260031,
0.0147632025,
-0.0070842337,
0.033059448,
-0.0333835036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03396v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03396v1 | UniTSyn: A Large-Scale Dataset Capable of Enhancing the Prowess of Large Language Models for Program Testing | 2024-02-04T22:48:05 | 2024-02-04T22:48:05 | Yifeng He, Jiabo Huang, Yuyang Rong, Yiwen Guo, Ethan Wang, Hao Chen | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | The remarkable capability of large language models (LLMs) in generating
high-quality code has drawn increasing attention in the software testing
community. However, existing code LLMs often demonstrate unsatisfactory
capabilities in generating accurate and complete tests since they were trained
on code snippets collected without differentiating between code for testing
purposes and other code. In this paper, we present a large-scale dataset
UniTSyn, which is capable of enhancing the prowess of LLMs for Unit Test
Synthesis. Associating tests with the tested functions is crucial for LLMs to
infer the expected behavior and the logic paths to be verified. By leveraging
Language Server Protocol, UniTSyn achieves the challenging goal of collecting
focal-test pairs without per-project execution setups or per-language
heuristics that tend to be fragile and difficult to scale. It contains 2.7
million focal-test pairs across five mainstream programming languages, making
it possible to be utilized for enhancing the test generation ability of LLMs.
The details of UniTSyn can be found in Table 1. Our experiments demonstrate
that, by building an autoregressive model based on UniTSyn, we can achieve
significant benefits in learning and understanding unit test representations,
resulting in improved generation accuracy and code coverage across all
evaluated programming languages. Code and data will be publicly available. | [
-0.0311254635,
0.1118202806,
-0.0258191824,
0.038153749,
-0.033911895,
-0.0145492116,
0.0192697085,
0.0225781891,
0.0178147033,
-0.0141126635,
0.0223235991,
0.011880572,
-0.0100917751,
0.0328731388,
0.0236158837,
-0.0072449646,
0.0543071479,
-0.0411414467,
-0.095287703,
-0.0019313903,
-0.0361547545,
0.0252978355,
-0.0068883793,
0.0340652987,
0.002110217,
-0.0343375094,
-0.0182048716,
0.0452108085,
-0.0267448742,
-0.0297500938,
-0.0107465936,
0.0134676415,
0.0120412745,
0.0413781442,
0.0000022506,
-0.0380409472,
0.0160252918,
0.0077330889,
0.0009010585,
0.071024321,
0.0123153785,
0.0149140516,
0.0169783533,
0.0454982258,
-0.0172552392,
-0.0061537628,
0.0053062364,
-0.0487822071,
0.0595949739,
0.082743682,
0.0299009401,
0.0063865054,
-0.0061116721,
-0.0051945234,
0.0250558816,
-0.020320408,
-0.0091585396,
0.0428149328,
0.0414587893,
-0.0141693885,
0.0064212927,
-0.0276469421,
0.0461078286,
0.0062061078,
-0.0580846965,
0.0360304266,
-0.0478016771,
0.0211695246,
0.0141453706,
-0.008741349,
-0.048541598,
-0.0802236199,
0.0104491226,
0.0097805215,
-0.0590901114,
0.0339177325,
0.0200794879,
0.0100630047,
0.0166721176,
-0.0136297476,
0.0294310711,
-0.0338773914,
0.022932414,
-0.0256162863,
-0.0303554162,
0.0365899988,
0.019842403,
-0.0115291737,
-0.0184775535,
-0.0337152556,
0.0103553589,
-0.0317237712,
-0.0423381031,
0.0174601264,
-0.0225341488,
-0.0257666837,
-0.0399116576,
-0.0030623903,
0.0902323499,
-0.0266734511,
-0.0088864127,
-0.0126596242,
-0.0317572318,
0.0074937106,
-0.0895435661,
0.0856037065,
0.0105427587,
-0.0435489416,
-0.0234797671,
0.0197933577,
-0.0089966636,
0.0244817324,
-0.0093557024,
0.0125009138,
0.0307410713,
0.0407787822,
-0.027866127,
0.0413640514,
-0.0176778324,
0.0982616916,
-0.0593767576,
-0.021415228,
-0.0154644186,
0.01230154,
0.0326993838,
-0.0091169085,
-0.0321785733,
-0.048517663,
-0.0296356026,
-0.0585142188,
-0.0112649165,
0.0177474022,
-0.0360321775,
-0.0163462833,
0.0475580506,
0.0676309243,
0.031668406,
0.0200826116,
-0.0070597357,
-0.0434340239,
0.0480991974,
-0.0126004172,
0.0159993079,
-0.1021045893,
-0.0385722592,
0.0196469836,
-0.0030227001,
-0.0291834585,
-0.0283032246,
-0.0062715239,
0.0319008008,
0.0342955925,
0.0194061827,
0.0260844845,
-0.0005957594,
0.0127700623,
0.0412330367,
0.0576923862,
0.0113230832,
0.0102458717,
0.0098256953,
-0.0376840346,
0.0218209177,
0.0351953581,
-0.0026024687,
0.0429146998,
-0.0230506975,
0.0394492596,
0.0243714061,
-0.0164632518,
0.0248706769,
0.0269716196,
0.0109512033,
-0.0281496402,
-0.0301530156,
0.0279499367,
-0.0051743728,
0.022409942,
0.058903493,
0.0136409216,
0.0052487077,
-0.0202355776,
-0.0243528616,
0.0283883344,
-0.0031938916,
0.0307957996,
-0.0226068087,
0.055934377,
-0.0246384833,
-0.033058662,
-0.0187766552,
-0.0119979577,
-0.0341736786,
0.0288232695,
0.04658309,
-0.0089606708,
-0.0449597538,
0.083412528,
0.0342541672,
-0.0678607598,
-0.0091090947,
-0.0391602702,
0.0591109544,
0.0226238742,
0.0574180111,
-0.0865202397,
-0.0330635794,
0.0026892885,
-0.0066760043,
0.0203131605,
0.0290678628,
-0.0066716215,
-0.0329510458,
-0.0304571092,
-0.0139018064,
-0.0145804258,
0.0262638889,
0.0363248624,
-0.0023543811,
-0.0309233982,
0.0571963936,
-0.0710395649,
-0.0586518571,
0.037224099,
-0.0301393587,
-0.024319008,
0.0304005258,
-0.008061287,
0.0216968488,
-0.0180364978,
-0.0487368405,
-0.0239165965,
0.0435712785,
0.011158146,
0.0121939955,
0.0079852566,
-0.0206212588,
-0.0276064184,
-0.0110656694,
-0.0530733615,
-0.0586323217,
0.0533803366,
-0.0884292349,
-0.026270669,
0.0381823443,
-0.0043277242,
-0.0208112858,
-0.0016521747,
-0.0044315429,
-0.0171615947,
0.0217461549,
0.0044135568,
0.0247298162,
0.0123159783,
0.0280455798,
-0.038634181,
0.067468062,
0.0607492141,
0.0191412754,
-0.0369112194,
0.0158188362,
-0.046126429,
0.0270449016,
-0.0094198612,
0.0901151225,
-0.0176804829,
-0.0287698489,
-0.0951332375,
0.0553117916,
-0.0168861933,
0.056403067,
0.0298276246,
0.0334887058,
0.0182193499,
0.0002168959,
-0.0181107316,
-0.0080106594,
0.018351933,
0.0051659918,
0.0217080936,
-0.0650829747,
-0.0470208377,
-0.0083095562,
-0.0099631706,
-0.0715411454,
0.0872293338,
-0.0477360971,
0.0491716079,
-0.0644279793,
0.0607974753,
0.0273081958,
0.0154974954,
-0.0304799397,
-0.0598355904,
0.0053286832,
-0.031782873,
0.0115662208,
0.071077846,
0.0106100217,
-0.0247372314,
0.00469172,
0.0246156659,
-0.0586655997,
0.0000895734,
0.0558117293,
-0.0385834798,
0.0057228659,
-0.0454540215,
0.0162288919,
0.0291937608,
-0.0467242561,
-0.0175457243,
-0.0150762955,
-0.005747817,
-0.0256898869,
0.040229924,
0.0161812417,
0.0102195712,
-0.0048478525,
-0.0209991448,
-0.0093424954,
-0.0634349883,
0.0300405659,
-0.0485308133,
0.0084581766,
-0.0651415065,
-0.0119400173,
-0.0752114281,
0.0677868426,
0.0061768913,
0.0065296949,
-0.0717495829,
-0.0270368084,
-0.0084835989,
0.0133726578,
-0.0157124363,
-0.0280901808,
0.0797373056,
-0.0498476401,
0.013047616,
-0.0035235486,
-0.0254236218,
-0.0493521877,
0.0054794541,
-0.0070443591,
0.0279403366,
-0.0530295298,
0.0214726347,
0.0350076966,
0.0014798101,
-0.0312339887,
0.0415169373,
0.0341179334,
0.0056550093,
-0.0142298527,
-0.0606901385,
-0.0150050242,
-0.0607409924,
-0.0074882885,
-0.0323634595,
-0.0173962191,
0.0000716595,
0.0658933595,
0.0779049173,
-0.0849279314,
-0.0096042901,
-0.0146298986,
-0.0479329005,
0.0266962517,
0.0376687199,
0.0263925288,
-0.0693955943,
-0.0432056598,
0.0738913342,
0.0354415141,
-0.0104864622,
0.025656322,
0.0076043801,
0.0444684103,
0.0675498471,
0.0642891824,
-0.0951349959,
-0.0178993996,
-0.0062302994,
0.0048996545,
0.007336664,
0.0219232179,
0.0038603565,
-0.1291157603,
0.0213266574,
0.0292474143,
-0.0003682159,
-0.0329869054,
-0.0451779068,
-0.0192491636,
-0.0302933566,
0.0267508123,
0.06485679,
-0.0003372376,
0.0024216028,
0.0024284518,
-0.0452118628,
-0.0229613762,
0.0828927308,
-0.0463861711,
0.0091832178,
0.0785096362,
0.0213596988,
-0.0309436824,
-0.0200683251,
0.0537993498,
-0.0012853639,
0.0308489185,
-0.0367764011,
0.0131171951,
0.0539012775,
-0.030396793,
0.0824266374,
0.0443484411,
-0.0792888477,
0.0059525887,
0.0519492701,
0.0123743303,
-0.0057342239,
-0.0430036709,
-0.0247709285,
0.0089197522,
-0.0078575006,
0.0157724451,
0.0406944156,
-0.0231947023,
-0.0333058834,
-0.0360245407,
-0.0335224085,
-0.0414402783,
-0.0292676669,
0.0036922074,
-0.0176393557,
0.0354920551,
-0.01502846,
-0.0036739004,
0.0531129017,
0.0252158679,
0.0267972723,
-0.0766522586,
-0.0250133928,
-0.0371552333,
-0.014847694,
0.0364874117,
-0.0144532518,
0.0413975269,
-0.013549529,
-0.0005101285,
0.0112955766,
-0.0135694277,
-0.0294334795,
0.0361877047,
-0.0708345547,
-0.0470386371,
0.0240889266,
0.0772059113,
0.0100861005,
0.0218915474,
-0.0329377353,
-0.0243490078,
0.0008744919,
0.0093339877,
-0.0113812825,
0.0087588942,
0.0155285848,
-0.0365213677,
-0.00685632,
0.0050224112,
-0.0800364316,
0.0340522602,
-0.0041133696,
-0.0260615777,
0.0319291204,
0.004631496,
0.0090718921,
0.0201660339,
0.0428705513,
0.0433047786,
-0.0136727206,
-0.0009813796,
0.0381463356,
-0.0134721827,
-0.0260278899,
-0.0034659395,
0.0725495964,
-0.0016329724,
-0.0220576692,
0.0147329066,
-0.0366380885,
-0.0126682883,
0.0495400056,
0.0213539582,
0.0379888788,
-0.0008804681,
0.0210692249,
0.0465044789,
-0.0227520373,
-0.0205727238,
0.0010964684,
-0.0104195392,
0.0452963114,
-0.0090403492,
0.0496814661,
0.0142305419,
0.0559500568,
-0.0087201688,
0.0041982941,
-0.0112225534,
-0.03145127,
-0.0051221764,
-0.0266160946,
0.0363301821,
0.0093140192,
0.0320958234,
-0.0569439046,
0.0452994257,
-0.0071639605,
0.030472504,
-0.0467003137,
-0.017530743,
0.0195617024,
0.0268983152,
-0.0183276851,
-0.0369348191,
0.0780789703,
0.0092713721,
0.0167925265,
0.0047838776,
0.0367747433,
-0.0420493968,
0.0188164357,
0.0384489745,
-0.0307368934,
-0.0233084708,
-0.0594577231,
-0.0107606705,
-0.0836498961,
-0.0066076852,
0.0544204824,
0.0479016043,
0.0041638534,
0.0019455026,
0.0894139037,
0.0214662049,
0.0232254844,
0.0101295719,
-0.0116426749,
-0.003538558,
-0.0514325649,
-0.0187387466,
-6.177798806e-33,
0.0007186873,
-0.0079157557,
0.0136591485,
-0.028524179,
0.0252290722,
0.0076311873,
-0.0052532847,
-0.0166140236,
0.0125958109,
-0.0287437495,
0.0067331507,
0.0359161086,
-0.0007919309,
-0.0067860838,
0.0280326493,
0.0131401792,
0.0582941212,
0.018373128,
-0.0421371385,
0.0358035229,
-0.0072296099,
0.0020121662,
0.0336243771,
-0.0362041444,
-0.042973794,
-0.0171733145,
0.0244470797,
-0.0195128862,
-0.029321216,
0.0318618678,
0.0366120301,
0.0256892927,
-0.0090883086,
-0.0079496047,
-0.0039729592,
-0.0535288788,
-0.0133718261,
-0.045148503,
-0.0047270469,
-0.0103034694,
-0.0108557809,
-0.0137499655,
0.0349179171,
-0.0147800464,
0.0080440091,
0.0212186165,
0.0003211078,
0.0131195337,
0.0069518969,
-0.0297541786,
-0.0216390379,
0.0274367109,
-0.0466233343,
0.0022000677,
-0.0388242118,
0.0400548279,
-0.0080732182,
-0.0081278682,
0.0390211865,
-0.0081374058,
0.013968681,
0.0392093286,
0.0528292134,
-0.0027576326,
0.0072179004,
0.0354749337,
0.0105765322,
0.0463175252,
0.0207451098,
0.0176607408,
0.0702132881,
0.0237092376,
0.0499561541,
0.0319844559,
0.0143901585,
-0.0382833742,
-0.0411914848,
0.0227244291,
0.0565128885,
-0.0014716596,
0.0259913635,
-0.00826413,
-0.0593851805,
0.0097328415,
-0.063856639,
-0.0110731982,
-0.019342795,
-0.0579157434,
0.0408044308,
0.0014955439,
-0.0349975266,
0.0212573539,
0.0239440482,
-0.0495885685,
-0.0120195644,
0.0219473857,
-0.0493956469,
-0.0179065969,
-0.0283589046,
0.0099793924,
0.0284368992,
-0.0777671635,
-0.0065868059,
-0.0245290697,
0.0730063692,
-0.0004708808,
0.0280882046,
-0.0021155293,
-0.0591093972,
0.026709782,
-0.053297542,
-0.0138842342,
-0.0347625092,
0.0078581581,
0.0064116549,
0.0470230915,
0.0421144329,
0.0006574158,
0.0284313932,
-0.1054793075,
-0.0623373054,
0.0279913545,
0.0004708487,
0.0331646577,
-0.0269420296,
-0.0170309804,
-0.0466265343,
0.0277492665,
0.0221571065,
-0.0450740568,
-0.0495672971,
0.0467177331,
3e-7,
-0.0052056541,
0.0701864064,
-0.0264315233,
0.0905430242,
0.0075462,
0.0215195697,
-0.0396207795,
0.0206084494,
0.0513033085,
0.0071026729,
-0.032539051,
-0.0135794394,
0.0536894724,
0.0387274288,
-0.0618388131,
0.0647764429,
-0.0146734612,
-0.0136164445,
-0.0731053352,
-0.0240667686,
-0.0008193713,
0.0311892405,
-0.0109236166,
-0.0042085415,
0.0197838936,
-0.0615658872,
-0.0139854457,
-0.0130467927,
-0.0371488221,
0.0690077543,
-0.0623024479,
-0.0068402314,
0.0282051638,
0.0186350662,
-0.0364284627,
-0.0173477661,
-0.0231018141,
0.0267226249,
0.0068845637,
-0.0052444288,
0.0297168046,
-0.0426269285,
0.0169624127,
-0.0728050247,
0.0560351908,
0.0300928261,
0.0026438783,
-0.0432503447,
-0.012490131,
-0.0272900462,
-0.0173676535,
-0.0250782277,
0.0080205323,
0.0297108609,
-0.0247362163,
-0.0174092595,
-0.0199226364,
-0.0000167494,
-0.0575542115,
0.0277475398,
-0.0310647823,
-0.0275389701,
-0.0114586214,
0.0290294252,
-0.0451321937,
0.0045351805,
0.0379943959,
3.254335906e-34,
0.0208009295,
-0.0162869655,
0.016945323,
0.0078283167,
0.029697476,
-0.031278979,
-0.0324017927,
0.0432607457,
-0.0163566004,
0.0396607146,
-0.0149776684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02625v1 | Enhancing Transformer RNNs with Multiple Temporal Perspectives | 2024-02-04T22:12:29 | 2024-02-04T22:12:29 | Razvan-Gabriel Dumitru, Darius Peteleaza, Mihai Surdeanu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.0; I.2.7 | We introduce the concept of multiple temporal perspectives, a novel approach
applicable to Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) architectures for enhancing their
understanding of sequential data. This method involves maintaining diverse
temporal views of previously encountered text, significantly enriching the
language models' capacity to interpret context. To show the efficacy of this
approach, we incorporate it into the Receptance Weighted Key Value (RWKV)
architecture, addressing its inherent challenge of retaining all historical
information within a single hidden state. Notably, this improvement is achieved
with a minimal increase in the number of parameters --even as little as
$0.04\%$ of the original number of parameters. Further, the additional
parameters necessary for the multiple temporal perspectives are fine-tuned with
minimal computational overhead, avoiding the need for a full pre-training. The
resulting model maintains linear computational complexity during prompt
inference, ensuring consistent efficiency across various sequence lengths. The
empirical results and ablation studies included in our research validate the
effectiveness of our approach, showcasing improved performance across multiple
benchmarks. The code, model weights and datasets are open-sourced at:
https://github.com/RazvanDu/TemporalRNNs. | [
0.0037097214,
0.084317565,
0.0070756865,
0.0088241743,
-0.0458436795,
-0.0224454105,
0.0005857891,
-0.0037588752,
-0.0487716012,
-0.03295286,
-0.0083235297,
-0.0664154515,
0.0594526976,
0.0543326549,
-0.0201781448,
-0.0718652979,
0.0411038958,
-0.0065637068,
-0.0267185345,
0.0243740957,
-0.0288667772,
0.0010198483,
-0.0354474112,
0.0414684974,
-0.0008988861,
-0.0333851688,
-0.0384439304,
-0.0063935448,
0.0453665368,
-0.0669806227,
-0.0057037012,
0.0331268534,
0.0157414172,
0.0432367735,
0.0000023996,
0.0094570583,
0.0073099234,
-0.0166202411,
-0.0113452515,
0.0452004448,
0.0307001024,
0.0082536358,
0.0090512568,
0.0133680189,
-0.0406154804,
-0.0407859311,
0.0317228027,
0.0689129382,
0.0285565984,
0.0864153728,
-0.0007290249,
-0.0194778498,
0.0102368873,
-0.0521936864,
0.0072229165,
-0.0345470719,
0.0066469428,
-0.0501667708,
0.0191599149,
0.0046390435,
-0.0284538269,
0.0643181875,
0.0630537048,
0.0028366058,
-0.0126609495,
0.0496170484,
0.0270917732,
0.0016297407,
-0.0315231383,
0.0474903546,
-0.0344271548,
-0.0242152736,
0.0069142925,
-0.0176189225,
-0.0172737874,
-0.0569824763,
-0.0159943327,
0.0078362422,
0.023494849,
0.0212822203,
0.0026094443,
0.0705103055,
0.0479184948,
0.0234837923,
-0.0385997556,
0.0090275416,
0.0216150656,
0.0022604151,
-0.0519224256,
-0.0231574196,
0.0352387242,
-0.0595514551,
0.0102831852,
0.0757636204,
0.0304254591,
0.0300014745,
-0.0131809106,
0.0090250839,
0.0050050248,
-0.058228001,
0.0215642024,
0.0565422773,
-0.0467251986,
0.0051021972,
-0.0216454789,
0.0445198417,
-0.0238455385,
-0.0474168994,
-0.0362269133,
0.0249108989,
-0.0502804406,
-0.0098912204,
-0.0020581773,
0.0144538665,
-0.0273755193,
-0.000618824,
-0.0518305376,
0.0445232689,
0.0199371092,
-0.0520050041,
0.0012662084,
0.0428423211,
-0.0432022139,
0.0089872321,
0.00655175,
0.0612783767,
-0.0080413427,
-0.0178778525,
0.0027251276,
-0.0733463541,
-0.0400466174,
0.0140655497,
0.0364965051,
-0.0292378068,
-0.0424035601,
0.0203336664,
0.0013430787,
-0.0332733579,
-0.0391309671,
-0.0085407319,
-0.0369806513,
-0.0266303066,
0.0151686473,
-0.0308830179,
0.0332889669,
-0.0356419198,
-0.0383535996,
-0.0229565464,
0.0056964885,
0.0234285183,
-0.0120430226,
0.0482816845,
0.0244968738,
-0.0247202758,
-0.0040753386,
0.0179399066,
0.0605690107,
0.0387948491,
0.0388391912,
0.0139351133,
-0.0244148895,
-0.0034190512,
-0.0291026589,
0.0118160918,
0.0176501386,
-0.0380404964,
-0.0639821589,
-0.0315417312,
0.0044762823,
0.0510664843,
0.0220479611,
0.0057791141,
-0.024831146,
-0.0042070099,
0.0597258136,
0.0006161517,
0.0065525714,
0.0387063846,
0.0404136218,
0.0006347001,
0.0188268367,
-0.0199698117,
-0.0412688665,
0.0546448082,
0.0226576235,
0.0132368403,
-0.0341012329,
0.045522023,
-0.0234811753,
-0.0337805897,
0.0030971668,
-0.0151054934,
0.0113738235,
0.0020171977,
0.0413347669,
0.0104701128,
-0.0806690678,
0.0626112893,
0.0127572063,
-0.0429730713,
-0.0024705301,
0.01224057,
-0.0136819044,
0.0498621352,
0.0353686213,
-0.0180444662,
-0.0521884933,
0.006600033,
-0.0045916564,
0.0030580517,
0.0614755861,
0.0054830769,
0.0387187116,
-0.0487889946,
-0.0487654954,
0.0068783527,
-0.0050056088,
0.0731000677,
0.0129565662,
0.0423722342,
0.0299984869,
0.0088093616,
0.0036621541,
0.0252200775,
-0.048373647,
-0.0163065586,
0.0299082752,
0.0155198453,
0.0335908681,
0.0299946237,
0.021170767,
0.0076062507,
0.0560947582,
-0.0475459285,
0.0184764862,
0.0633345991,
-0.1245079339,
-0.0361840054,
0.0130849993,
0.0101144994,
0.0109428279,
0.056187328,
-0.0334616937,
-0.0569458306,
0.0583553538,
0.0028770743,
0.0725117773,
-0.0304192472,
-0.0075920527,
0.0124855991,
0.0458821319,
-0.015735304,
0.0398566015,
-0.024693124,
-0.0032792191,
0.0078967614,
-0.0454252511,
-0.0160793308,
-0.0315730944,
-0.030592721,
0.0009454747,
-0.0241401456,
-0.0119277239,
-0.0026423151,
-0.0141625721,
-0.0190203469,
-0.0305249598,
-0.0663065314,
-0.0282624494,
-0.015681209,
0.0016935703,
0.0236758012,
0.0341012664,
0.0295078903,
-0.0232188161,
-0.0525424853,
-0.026578594,
-0.0235088356,
0.0139307445,
0.0431717597,
0.0421368778,
-0.0340760797,
-0.008333982,
-0.0166498385,
-0.0249437615,
0.0821186602,
0.0009483573,
-0.0397296697,
-0.010062323,
-0.0284302812,
0.0151528958,
0.0178945474,
-0.0307653081,
-0.0216946993,
-0.0065702084,
-0.0109280515,
0.0628307015,
0.0310584251,
0.0336951315,
0.0345050953,
0.0523088872,
-0.0530338772,
-0.0552200787,
0.0362921208,
-0.0422257856,
0.0348994359,
0.0083691142,
-0.0004875465,
-0.0206355043,
0.0887190551,
-0.0324567407,
0.0066477354,
-0.0507039353,
-0.0138377752,
-0.0057873209,
-0.0243512969,
-0.0028058025,
-0.0156131471,
-0.0420978107,
-0.0012357895,
-0.0230670776,
0.0079128779,
0.035549257,
-0.0342316739,
-0.00895942,
-0.0169764347,
-0.0040784767,
-0.0370432474,
0.0623133928,
0.0240780618,
-0.0176057126,
0.031087447,
-0.0193322878,
-0.0224212706,
0.0009805679,
-0.0150786266,
-0.0119428951,
0.0530409887,
-0.0229208879,
-0.0113514988,
-0.0094918218,
-0.0183959473,
-0.064922303,
-0.0254835375,
0.004374932,
-0.0323271342,
-0.0255335048,
-0.0057240026,
-0.0536315329,
0.0010433461,
-0.0103888512,
0.0815492421,
-0.018778814,
0.0026263453,
-0.0039336705,
0.0263132304,
0.0132174762,
0.0197339039,
0.0437625647,
-0.0051016565,
0.0203319397,
0.047417596,
0.0687777698,
-0.014900553,
-0.0632672235,
-0.0076961368,
0.0199962128,
-0.0449800976,
0.0062286993,
0.0364273563,
0.0079971617,
-0.1036104411,
-0.026836222,
0.0988569781,
0.0045247283,
-0.043977242,
0.0117280576,
0.0056281327,
0.0099055804,
0.007265327,
0.0209680088,
-0.0748087019,
-0.0056747091,
-0.0002134258,
0.0212123338,
0.002440888,
-0.0399278253,
-0.0352470614,
-0.066770263,
-0.0200817641,
-0.0146747362,
-0.0408760607,
-0.0016760902,
-0.0120637808,
-0.0359451063,
0.005089812,
0.0199714322,
0.0269000251,
-0.0022993304,
-0.0199113395,
0.0121115856,
-0.0422750451,
-0.0549570359,
0.0470694527,
0.0168684572,
0.0278827269,
0.0108955996,
0.0238045305,
-0.0120126326,
-0.0482544042,
0.0045256917,
0.0019408388,
0.0179747101,
0.0154596213,
0.0067829266,
0.0024711357,
-0.02851592,
0.0089056529,
0.0045595868,
-0.0425631851,
-0.0388967283,
-0.0324643813,
0.0765087754,
-0.0148347495,
-0.0244998522,
-0.0089600822,
-0.014070061,
0.0101206368,
0.0551684238,
0.0438882262,
-0.0337254256,
-0.024115622,
0.0226153377,
0.0047347751,
-0.1062486395,
-0.0477183424,
-0.0165788289,
0.0183308627,
-0.0429508947,
-0.0786724314,
-0.0392536409,
-0.0439928547,
0.0315086581,
0.0129888775,
-0.0157238636,
0.0394354537,
-0.0048147766,
-0.0651893169,
0.0311909318,
-0.0138537688,
0.0000809521,
-0.0437454358,
0.0066906898,
0.0285031646,
-0.03315733,
-0.0148070026,
0.0334107503,
-0.102599822,
-0.0211353675,
0.0586523525,
0.0077603781,
0.0115878787,
0.0915480256,
-0.0176236872,
-0.0063916361,
0.0884134397,
-0.024488939,
0.0208012275,
0.004603175,
0.0434632823,
0.0270741414,
-0.0055943481,
0.0265605189,
-0.0531986617,
0.0068654539,
-0.0108533651,
0.0152855106,
-0.0160007309,
-0.0188978948,
-0.0174592901,
-0.0577886328,
0.0566137396,
0.0247799456,
0.0162715781,
0.00795596,
0.0129401097,
-0.0386291035,
0.0419576094,
-0.041781418,
0.0327475034,
0.0236384403,
0.0213854443,
-0.0106681027,
0.0101884417,
0.0617623813,
-0.0186360832,
-0.0128416475,
0.0380421542,
0.0238361564,
0.0227686204,
-0.0123821618,
0.028749479,
-0.0287855677,
0.0125517789,
-0.0292887837,
0.0284892581,
-0.0515459292,
0.0317570753,
0.0225741453,
0.0066210809,
-0.0378454104,
0.019198535,
-0.1168674752,
0.0303532518,
-0.0050912164,
-0.0231931992,
0.0612711683,
-0.0115372073,
0.0552891679,
-0.0051983898,
0.0212189462,
-0.0192087013,
0.0374537185,
0.0309042111,
-0.0399170518,
0.0070964526,
0.0193417259,
-0.0110722398,
0.0350316241,
0.0623867549,
0.0012836418,
0.0631985441,
0.032067012,
0.0328577459,
-0.0240698773,
-0.0120277721,
-0.0208967105,
0.0190857165,
-0.0237660017,
-0.0112178354,
-0.035488572,
-0.0352524333,
0.1013553739,
-0.0254411064,
-0.0026016769,
-0.0095012235,
0.0256566051,
-0.0040765703,
0.0154138105,
0.004721567,
-0.005444882,
0.0206679683,
0.0273887068,
-0.0422418676,
-0.0310260355,
-7.095554265e-33,
0.0153556829,
0.009819461,
-0.0125413481,
-0.0100096259,
-0.03942395,
0.0401154943,
-0.0646316558,
-0.0266921185,
-0.0204620454,
-0.014361823,
-0.0168416277,
0.0064915367,
0.0265966542,
0.02995608,
0.0173835047,
-0.0115299169,
0.0552975796,
0.008444217,
0.0126383752,
0.0237082969,
0.0509947389,
0.0590809509,
0.0849419162,
-0.0347704291,
-0.0039802403,
0.0105117094,
0.0191090181,
0.0078646205,
0.0092276884,
0.0471613929,
-0.0314451717,
0.0284379907,
0.0231857561,
-0.0773196146,
-0.0451259799,
0.0114259562,
-0.1076293886,
-0.0548861362,
-0.0128946863,
0.0471674986,
-0.0286819991,
-0.0453167595,
0.031341631,
-0.0084442291,
0.0334101543,
-0.0216637198,
0.0056311782,
-0.0094559528,
-0.0474304669,
-0.0822444186,
-0.0156246852,
0.0235348772,
-0.0176465046,
-0.011966493,
0.0249454882,
0.0319635011,
0.013496805,
-0.0037189729,
-0.1133673564,
-0.0113684852,
0.0032160643,
0.043075569,
0.0294814706,
0.0327844061,
-0.0102365194,
0.0300177839,
0.0301043969,
-0.0190452114,
-0.0429217108,
0.0368639231,
0.0430020802,
-0.032138411,
0.0345030911,
0.0045271786,
0.0593000278,
-0.0422792733,
-0.0520515442,
-0.0174556524,
0.0406161286,
0.045564469,
0.0300317276,
-0.0096972892,
-0.0022075241,
0.0067569092,
-0.0250054616,
-0.0335794464,
-0.045290906,
0.0074893632,
0.0274997409,
0.0462455675,
0.0064260419,
0.0302679278,
0.0318784378,
-0.03163312,
0.0118678864,
0.0353173055,
0.0100357523,
0.0139717357,
0.0052526961,
0.0287175458,
-0.014495438,
0.0138597395,
0.036930386,
0.0011913504,
0.0197485089,
-0.0278544687,
0.0268449914,
0.0520735942,
-0.0467540063,
-0.0333018191,
-0.0133301709,
0.0216601361,
0.0186788365,
0.0388261639,
0.0604509749,
-0.0153328516,
-0.0111180749,
0.0624878518,
0.0071915067,
0.0354767554,
-0.0133744897,
0.0124779176,
0.0411244519,
0.0442685038,
-0.0200121105,
-0.0191142131,
-0.0144582074,
0.0143564204,
0.0208529141,
-0.0228002146,
-0.0201337151,
0.0667975992,
3.103e-7,
0.0281226467,
0.0126546817,
0.0825101808,
-0.0118256155,
0.0217853468,
-0.0049848612,
-0.0030493678,
-0.0049093259,
-0.0434527807,
0.0382190831,
0.0127025321,
0.0085309865,
0.0458015166,
-0.000468109,
-0.0936461464,
-0.0768445954,
-0.0873692855,
0.0121437935,
-0.0277911853,
-0.0131369103,
0.0489131249,
0.1156665161,
0.0160561688,
0.0037586852,
0.0094329687,
0.0190833341,
0.0448580533,
-0.0154020116,
0.0045058033,
-0.0019221945,
0.0434167683,
-0.0166519471,
-0.0241194423,
-0.0469011627,
-0.0368537195,
0.030392278,
-0.0621083453,
0.0686960444,
-0.0004403659,
-0.0996333137,
0.0097091934,
0.026529802,
-0.0313248895,
-0.0163818877,
0.0779576004,
-0.0844983682,
-0.0237242952,
0.0126571162,
-0.0209468585,
0.0245607384,
0.0143273724,
0.0298029184,
-0.0295401607,
0.0212601218,
-0.0079519637,
-0.0238767806,
-0.0372608304,
-0.1339243799,
-0.0223608669,
-0.022007212,
-0.0428310558,
0.0325909927,
-0.0657647401,
-0.0553124808,
0.0656017289,
-0.0200516172,
-0.0207014456,
2.915152751e-34,
0.0271037016,
-0.0477748103,
0.0012510293,
0.0291062612,
-0.0023930455,
-0.0006297544,
-0.0051317099,
-0.0069198045,
0.0328176431,
-0.074320741,
-0.0395898893
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.