id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06126v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06126v3 | Learn To be Efficient: Build Structured Sparsity in Large Language Models | 2024-02-09T01:18:16 | 2024-06-03T18:28:58 | Haizhong Zheng, Xiaoyan Bai, Xueshen Liu, Z. Morley Mao, Beidi Chen, Fan Lai, Atul Prakash | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success with their
billion-level parameters, yet they incur high inference overheads. The
emergence of activation sparsity in LLMs provides a natural approach to reduce
this cost by involving only parts of the parameters for inference. However,
existing methods only focus on utilizing this naturally formed activation
sparsity in a post-training setting, overlooking the potential for further
amplifying this inherent sparsity. In this paper, we hypothesize that LLMs can
learn to be efficient by achieving more structured activation sparsity. To
achieve this, we introduce a novel training algorithm, Learn-To-be-Efficient
(LTE), designed to train efficiency-aware LLMs to learn to activate fewer
neurons and achieve a better trade-off between sparsity and performance.
Furthermore, unlike SOTA MoEfication methods, which mainly focus on ReLU-based
models, LTE can also be applied to LLMs like LLaMA using non-ReLU activations.
Extensive evaluation on language understanding, language generation, and
instruction tuning tasks show that LTE consistently outperforms SOTA baselines.
Along with our hardware-aware custom kernel implementation, LTE reduces
LLaMA2-7B inference latency by 25% at 50% sparsity. | [
0.0226290319,
0.0931861773,
0.0193560813,
0.0601378419,
0.0033974154,
-0.0106262304,
0.0095186802,
-0.0079016248,
-0.0037079456,
-0.009267549,
-0.0537421554,
-0.0109252566,
0.0025838616,
0.020287618,
0.0170791391,
-0.002681314,
0.0505469814,
-0.0456047915,
-0.007773893,
-0.0282394625,
-0.0026683093,
0.0316971801,
-0.0193790514,
0.0038732805,
0.0078423778,
-0.0119646927,
-0.0126485042,
0.0354479477,
-0.0215406567,
-0.0372028127,
0.0240649953,
0.0271965936,
0.0190801863,
0.0354236811,
0.000002011,
-0.0150177525,
0.0220351983,
-0.0239021331,
-0.0464496203,
0.075276956,
0.0291771684,
-0.0227381531,
0.0037017933,
0.0130963773,
0.0019711156,
-0.0196352061,
0.073021926,
0.0238206834,
0.0211428665,
0.0694341585,
-0.006308666,
-0.0265305135,
0.012066748,
-0.0623242557,
0.0104770381,
-0.0337509215,
-0.0054547368,
-0.0204338077,
-0.0233022049,
0.0221261811,
-0.0290974695,
0.0318324342,
0.0391621813,
0.0394502692,
-0.0073282225,
0.0613507815,
-0.0112570999,
-0.0217131898,
0.0135245863,
0.058360707,
-0.0404009745,
-0.0260289647,
0.0138560701,
-0.0107609732,
-0.032571163,
-0.0626443923,
-0.0160573237,
0.0132700559,
0.0036473505,
0.0528524034,
0.031106906,
-0.0033313185,
0.0781620368,
0.0471880324,
-0.0249300506,
0.0395791344,
0.0210199691,
0.0070132259,
-0.0275119394,
-0.0032554464,
-0.0433959067,
-0.0197035838,
-0.0375678316,
0.031009106,
-0.0287381746,
0.0149371559,
-0.0643319786,
-0.0123431124,
0.0116549246,
-0.0346485935,
0.0709560737,
0.0749456286,
-0.0077688461,
0.024675943,
-0.0782334879,
-0.0087522091,
-0.0397104882,
0.0284304731,
-0.0371914655,
0.0066398024,
0.0246628895,
0.0098917615,
-0.0182983372,
0.0269312561,
-0.0486334413,
-0.0150002828,
-0.0368707627,
0.0301742852,
-0.0104088727,
-0.023070531,
-0.0271829925,
0.0141272675,
-0.0248562768,
-0.0289176255,
-0.035780739,
0.0218311343,
-0.0249047838,
0.0491860248,
-0.0222435221,
-0.0501431972,
-0.0206556991,
0.0405127555,
0.0347083248,
-0.0162123982,
0.059679985,
0.0435123853,
-0.0450202152,
-0.0427967086,
-0.0823717639,
-0.0061949291,
0.0245536789,
-0.0780853853,
0.0279318783,
-0.0771579072,
0.0513808131,
-0.0003415401,
-0.0129622845,
-0.0538189895,
0.0285083093,
0.0217106659,
-0.0349070542,
0.0475847721,
-0.0066720261,
-0.0040163575,
0.0265437458,
0.012127405,
0.0081630973,
0.0846409053,
0.02376955,
0.0431152843,
-0.0146938879,
0.0106019964,
-0.0659944266,
0.0158020556,
0.0676021725,
0.0187173747,
-0.0246147476,
-0.025306616,
-0.0550932698,
0.033916764,
0.1152403802,
0.0720988363,
-0.0515012555,
-0.0218962748,
0.0417696461,
0.0360108539,
0.0120100826,
0.0288067535,
0.0383693837,
0.0022524423,
0.0001758836,
-0.0011046432,
-0.0530747548,
0.0637914911,
0.0079091461,
0.0034591267,
0.0599182844,
0.0339130573,
-0.049708616,
-0.0334899426,
-0.006750281,
-0.0273724254,
-0.025572814,
0.0391057134,
0.00629939,
0.0076418687,
-0.0515280813,
0.1048382968,
0.0405798443,
-0.018682193,
-0.0117716948,
-0.0762074068,
0.0468308106,
0.0372693688,
0.0121867713,
0.0200764555,
-0.0124651743,
0.0337723345,
0.0075117247,
0.0337247215,
0.0090294862,
0.0055478509,
0.040318273,
-0.0667941272,
0.0049285749,
-0.0553771444,
0.0278436188,
0.0033470972,
0.0432400331,
-0.0094697466,
0.0488302596,
-0.0003292254,
-0.0012352505,
0.0309712011,
-0.0189086106,
-0.0319749042,
0.0225627366,
0.0033708056,
0.0301076081,
-0.0480527133,
-0.0046590855,
0.0125280805,
0.0095767323,
-0.0661724508,
0.0180832297,
-0.0201836769,
-0.0644847676,
-0.0498764217,
0.0195616651,
0.0489740558,
0.034660235,
0.0488181897,
-0.0532495901,
-0.048785571,
0.038920708,
-0.0398946181,
0.0439269543,
-0.0657525212,
-0.0025301268,
0.0428066552,
0.043569725,
-0.0139874406,
0.0485476069,
-0.0261733737,
0.0171930864,
0.0419857986,
0.0035675173,
0.0181235578,
-0.0046086176,
-0.005365306,
-0.0230093449,
-0.0132028908,
0.0335862301,
-0.0300913416,
0.0002765188,
0.0138384746,
-0.0270096902,
-0.0619154498,
0.0113943443,
-0.039747294,
0.0212424602,
0.0316970833,
0.0329989381,
0.0406421013,
-0.0024148675,
-0.018159695,
0.0427117832,
0.0075891269,
0.0291453674,
0.0019054412,
-0.009443067,
-0.0497510768,
-0.0385636203,
-0.0272764843,
0.0210901499,
0.030880589,
-0.0455245487,
-0.0276577529,
-0.0290991701,
-0.0052983095,
-0.007717446,
0.0446586795,
-0.0159390345,
-0.0514322445,
-0.0144611187,
-0.0034225467,
0.0223464034,
0.059750326,
-0.0283793826,
0.015189508,
0.0466232151,
0.0540859476,
-0.019825602,
0.0340170488,
-0.0010122336,
-0.0225552898,
-0.0198628027,
-0.01667176,
-0.0285062529,
0.0759439245,
0.0039346698,
-0.0080394167,
-0.0444351472,
-0.0410115346,
0.0123903956,
-0.0420732647,
-0.0198130906,
0.0209184941,
-0.0051661516,
0.0366825983,
-0.0509727523,
-0.0514170341,
0.0334648266,
-0.0267940536,
-0.0180117823,
-0.0095289489,
-0.0122711118,
-0.0376981832,
0.0515272729,
0.0490854867,
0.0566073358,
-0.0219578519,
-0.01892915,
-0.0431408249,
0.0005323902,
-0.0181335974,
-0.0040875608,
0.0812949985,
-0.023472324,
0.020362366,
-0.02563099,
-0.0514538884,
-0.0265391264,
-0.0003892142,
-0.0168243553,
0.0436316468,
0.0206364188,
-0.0226763468,
-0.0136397909,
-0.0188737549,
-0.0183735639,
0.0908300877,
0.0125679784,
-0.0028314167,
-0.0367160514,
0.0327448733,
0.0435702242,
0.0211031698,
0.0037759263,
-0.0391002893,
-0.0114768157,
0.0457433537,
-0.0167432819,
-0.0008594829,
-0.0609745793,
0.0129711358,
0.0293893628,
0.0100696199,
-0.0069484035,
0.0284988154,
0.0409451276,
-0.0571760125,
-0.0081452215,
0.07983426,
-0.0063751396,
-0.0281134397,
0.0292973258,
0.0201561153,
0.0808765516,
0.0347232483,
0.0299877394,
-0.073519595,
-0.0412992761,
-0.0196273066,
0.003196728,
0.0104780281,
0.022538757,
-0.0151534649,
-0.0547936931,
0.0071963263,
0.004537072,
-0.0275670234,
-0.0265234374,
-0.0294407811,
-0.032484863,
0.016532708,
0.0099518606,
0.0229982492,
-0.0167997591,
-0.0324612185,
0.0268078689,
0.0024538422,
-0.0411765575,
0.0307782274,
0.0146576185,
0.0263030417,
0.0073492872,
-0.0167476647,
-0.0056380634,
-0.0428172089,
0.0314930789,
-0.0129002258,
0.0168785695,
-0.0147496564,
0.0268781967,
0.0364982113,
-0.0423152111,
-0.0004079675,
0.0059804758,
-0.0271139387,
-0.010643566,
-0.0425594933,
0.0563927218,
-0.0080891196,
0.0123220263,
0.0169509593,
-0.0240901895,
-0.0149479387,
0.0365466848,
0.0365867577,
-0.002023014,
-0.0397949964,
0.004589994,
-0.0327245891,
-0.0748089477,
-0.0049791373,
0.0201116204,
0.0021038058,
-0.04523357,
-0.0301772729,
0.0063509545,
-0.0316341594,
0.0334034003,
-0.0280124843,
0.0112426607,
-0.0019316288,
-0.0141730774,
-0.0732703134,
0.0363090895,
-0.0372960977,
0.0249401629,
-0.0635793805,
-0.0266916435,
0.028628204,
0.0004188469,
-0.0004266492,
0.0106409267,
-0.1289460808,
-0.0825364366,
-0.0327463746,
0.0304689407,
0.0126101477,
0.0257024765,
0.0220189709,
-0.0393267274,
0.0615387671,
0.0283252932,
-0.0400394835,
0.0706467181,
0.0347888023,
-0.0262340065,
-0.0095082624,
0.0666673481,
-0.0131900255,
0.0326554663,
0.0098733008,
0.0358735807,
-0.0072247931,
0.0051142648,
-0.0076520881,
-0.0135684935,
0.0029273005,
-0.0255597215,
0.0112791779,
-0.040856231,
0.0352214612,
0.0314146206,
0.0218881126,
-0.0523081198,
-0.0289803352,
0.0384852216,
0.0218976382,
-0.0186529066,
-0.0252159964,
0.0569135956,
0.0287659746,
0.0252607688,
0.0094341412,
-0.0188861787,
-0.0102620553,
0.0280796457,
-0.0003191218,
-0.0551407859,
0.024830034,
-0.0156842079,
0.0265380517,
-0.0456630662,
0.0271438938,
-0.002840108,
0.0139257004,
-0.0921356156,
0.0149954576,
-0.0191025827,
-0.067775093,
-0.0126468185,
0.0045468039,
0.0833783373,
0.0035376309,
0.0633027032,
-0.0301371049,
-0.0131896501,
-0.0198002402,
0.0220059901,
-0.0416440703,
-0.0219545811,
0.0615400225,
0.0345437229,
0.0188079402,
-0.0224415306,
0.0749545991,
0.0338376239,
0.0475716591,
-0.0039295419,
0.0362441577,
-0.006527449,
-0.0616913885,
0.0121661536,
0.0271086749,
-0.0351000242,
0.0101336427,
0.0180326402,
-0.0723001063,
-0.0006324081,
-0.0205987412,
-0.0143974954,
-0.0354964174,
0.0330293104,
0.0484149158,
0.0104783969,
-0.0427831635,
-0.0342919603,
-0.0341542438,
0.0069278022,
-0.0185944326,
-0.0002125911,
-6.996897228e-33,
-0.0040577487,
-0.0146596814,
0.030469941,
0.0123959407,
-0.0356166288,
0.0396281369,
-0.0582355447,
0.0141710788,
-0.0525271371,
0.0140425758,
0.0030436614,
0.0072382735,
0.0082120765,
0.0499138944,
-0.0222129188,
-0.0041657626,
0.066735588,
0.0006825094,
-0.0018348161,
0.0237801019,
0.0301713683,
0.0071057635,
0.0293749962,
-0.0219320916,
-0.0626607612,
0.0134755839,
0.0018258825,
-0.0035089185,
-0.0169200413,
0.0336658582,
-0.051212471,
0.0582413636,
0.0289085843,
-0.0058983616,
0.0097383419,
-0.0292590652,
-0.0859841779,
-0.0320783556,
0.0345496796,
0.0010023681,
-0.0355763212,
-0.0391778275,
0.0419462249,
0.0186899602,
-0.0047951858,
-0.0279190503,
-0.0240869783,
-0.0043828934,
-0.0708298832,
-0.008621213,
-0.0736428276,
0.0223329775,
0.0361998752,
-0.013618663,
0.0341245383,
-0.0002593179,
-0.0244910922,
-0.0077028982,
-0.0458916575,
-0.0430012383,
-0.0165653788,
0.0958848372,
0.0429306366,
0.0602341257,
0.0036743376,
0.0240502451,
0.0096253389,
0.0169354863,
-0.0284142718,
0.0459372476,
0.0523344688,
0.0484329201,
0.0060591982,
0.0126312012,
0.0640802681,
-0.0137692885,
-0.1153989583,
-0.032387536,
0.0078368085,
0.0561561212,
0.0255117863,
0.0244574826,
-0.0289356112,
-0.0403865799,
-0.0285767075,
0.0180864353,
-0.0538812131,
-0.0208986793,
0.0010644599,
0.0579395629,
-0.0019855062,
-0.0368983783,
0.0183547474,
-0.0146708433,
0.0072476254,
0.0259071868,
0.0144337658,
0.0147484541,
-0.0079637971,
0.0166497082,
-0.0768703595,
-0.0620517284,
-0.0134138605,
-0.0249576699,
0.0244240891,
-0.0063316342,
0.041874662,
0.0486393273,
-0.0726984218,
-0.0253090262,
-0.0640527755,
-0.0021382631,
0.0117518175,
0.0533184558,
0.0314664394,
-0.0092377616,
-0.0042380393,
0.0622196123,
-0.0311757382,
0.004885742,
-0.0211129896,
-0.0296181161,
0.0182966273,
0.0561060384,
-0.0426448211,
-0.0014496718,
-0.0613323636,
-0.0038856512,
0.0054473239,
-0.0925371274,
-0.037876945,
0.0173780955,
2.69e-7,
0.0035589535,
-0.0117571428,
-0.0238640569,
0.0669008717,
0.0083603105,
0.0162211843,
0.0389412753,
0.0029389216,
-0.0296707973,
-0.0386995152,
0.0289020147,
0.0425972417,
0.0535306409,
0.0083553949,
-0.0403929725,
0.043500822,
-0.05513338,
0.0210599583,
-0.0330692306,
-0.0687379465,
0.0243412405,
0.0966032371,
-0.0109072467,
-0.053490404,
0.0512275919,
-0.0080839982,
0.0642160997,
0.0344747752,
0.0063579134,
0.0187238622,
0.0427678637,
0.0108919227,
-0.0210061204,
-0.0227675736,
-0.0131617002,
-0.0017395584,
-0.0523568392,
0.083756946,
0.0004429861,
-0.0584210642,
0.032763809,
-0.0186109263,
-0.0131350067,
-0.0371190719,
0.0599873178,
-0.0159960911,
-0.0277520344,
-0.0333912857,
0.036125131,
0.0190118738,
-0.0053176344,
-0.0225123428,
-0.0166725051,
0.0085894372,
0.0262691267,
-0.0421330631,
-0.038023334,
-0.0835341811,
-0.0303136595,
0.0030547141,
-0.0312336851,
-0.0316183232,
-0.0831503421,
0.0136954794,
0.0384360105,
-0.011414621,
0.0042116824,
2.47039528e-34,
0.020078212,
-0.0631198958,
0.0173536167,
0.0473434031,
0.0304689687,
-0.032781072,
-0.001865573,
0.0069585079,
0.0086270273,
-0.0619993322,
-0.0312969014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06125v1 | Language Model Sentence Completion with a Parser-Driven Rhetorical Control Method | 2024-02-09T01:15:42 | 2024-02-09T01:15:42 | Joshua Zingale, Jugal Kalita | cs.CL | cs.CL | Controlled text generation (CTG) seeks to guide large language model (LLM)
output to produce text that conforms to desired criteria. The current study
presents a novel CTG algorithm that enforces adherence toward specific
rhetorical relations in an LLM sentence-completion context by a parser-driven
decoding scheme that requires no model fine-tuning. The method is validated
both with automatic and human evaluation. The code is accessible on GitHub. | [
0.0350342318,
0.0768224746,
-0.0193118248,
0.0249369368,
-0.0562056191,
-0.0026609425,
-0.0453069732,
0.0028285526,
0.0029599725,
-0.0489538386,
0.0407234505,
-0.0032862239,
0.002987243,
0.0146650737,
0.0152682578,
-0.0377043299,
0.0540610068,
-0.0093710721,
0.0486607552,
-0.018635327,
-0.0065313019,
0.0346659459,
0.0447081104,
0.046756722,
0.0018518709,
-0.0370724648,
-0.0115362247,
0.0127414009,
-0.0367946289,
-0.0245407429,
0.0153950807,
0.0039801151,
-0.0252260119,
-0.0130076343,
0.0000020169,
-0.0702309906,
-0.0400059335,
-0.0301902872,
0.027696915,
0.012996763,
0.120780997,
-0.0106954174,
0.0007274143,
0.045985803,
-0.0135426354,
0.0707613826,
0.0196648743,
0.0581047907,
0.0416432098,
0.0520870239,
0.0014456252,
-0.0354616717,
0.0355148539,
0.0073596709,
-0.0316264145,
-0.0324165858,
0.0199992247,
0.047574766,
0.0698698908,
0.012167735,
-0.0149275046,
0.0479805097,
-0.0276230406,
0.012365628,
-0.0136371152,
0.0117863463,
0.0206361245,
-0.0263229702,
-0.024213789,
0.0006064808,
0.0371831693,
-0.053569857,
0.0290235244,
-0.0056872438,
-0.0157739539,
-0.0391731486,
-0.0398334935,
0.0494043529,
-0.0344300494,
0.0319378152,
0.0720846131,
-0.0278273281,
-0.0130702686,
0.0162274502,
-0.0284978338,
0.0839864761,
0.0327740014,
-0.0354242623,
-0.0501388758,
0.0096594952,
-0.0324752852,
-0.0874696374,
0.0379497334,
0.0374752693,
-0.0818531066,
0.0121738035,
-0.0834339112,
-0.0690608099,
0.0387656577,
-0.0394944623,
0.0176900215,
0.0401956439,
0.0253446922,
-0.0187338553,
-0.0138124824,
0.041088257,
-0.0303444341,
-0.0061706672,
-0.0647331104,
0.0010108028,
-0.0033632338,
-0.0471851975,
-0.0757661983,
0.043726813,
-0.041334521,
-0.0216551106,
-0.0428365134,
0.0203857161,
0.0368184559,
0.0106331902,
0.0089549888,
0.0128607908,
-0.052175045,
0.0089172591,
0.0068793711,
0.0228550714,
-0.0025167773,
-0.0082484661,
-0.0088836262,
0.0088652503,
0.0026177124,
0.026591219,
0.0388743989,
-0.016579235,
-0.0057607638,
0.0518236011,
-0.0307506919,
0.0034637442,
-0.0165945012,
-0.0581368804,
-0.0251165684,
-0.0311831944,
-0.0477982722,
-0.0670020655,
-0.0107882936,
0.038934052,
0.0035885745,
-0.0412412584,
0.023801282,
0.0438614711,
-0.0446021035,
0.001199155,
-0.0184811912,
0.0051710275,
0.0424170904,
-0.0190859511,
0.0535056144,
0.0544544756,
0.0570192374,
0.0356915742,
0.0262419675,
0.0239593294,
0.0175789036,
0.0275497641,
0.0129921595,
-0.0238409806,
-0.0461426489,
-0.0021876257,
0.0183175839,
0.0225424264,
0.0297919028,
0.0814962089,
-0.0002175708,
0.0488190763,
0.0231144857,
-0.0038593172,
0.0132979155,
0.009096805,
0.0749869421,
0.0207776427,
-0.0099803014,
0.0521046445,
-0.0004577166,
-0.0030011944,
-0.0401210003,
0.0501428656,
-0.0046989252,
0.06355647,
0.0105386181,
-0.0520592816,
0.0038597235,
-0.0058739581,
-0.0049453066,
-0.0428584479,
0.0181285273,
0.043495845,
-0.0872852951,
0.0169715583,
0.0361746065,
-0.041618485,
0.0226800274,
-0.0035679529,
0.0285115875,
0.0377884544,
0.0631996244,
0.0282703564,
-0.0013506104,
-0.0067884321,
0.0101571605,
0.0659910515,
-0.0223694686,
0.013949858,
-0.0371567272,
-0.0338159911,
-0.000872533,
-0.0063955183,
0.0321537517,
0.0107952831,
-0.0168344527,
0.0212838426,
0.0279571936,
-0.0017523468,
-0.0329768173,
0.0502968393,
-0.0292439032,
-0.0160018206,
0.009093089,
-0.0093919374,
0.0210132189,
-0.0044703172,
-0.0126155363,
0.0408494473,
-0.006860218,
-0.0356614962,
-0.050391037,
0.0313274786,
-0.0451478362,
-0.0471782945,
0.0489019342,
-0.0276614167,
-0.0046448582,
0.0139123918,
0.0285118576,
-0.0653150529,
0.0514763072,
-0.0511152744,
0.042295631,
-0.047604274,
0.0364138447,
-0.005573336,
-0.0227066949,
-0.0481357388,
0.0687144101,
0.0212203283,
-0.0021724752,
0.0262339674,
0.0239652339,
-0.0036814534,
-0.0045937174,
-0.005979429,
0.0297803972,
-0.0134526221,
0.0072808531,
0.0491015762,
0.0272628553,
-0.0149113135,
-0.0868881792,
-0.0673740655,
-0.0137088206,
-0.0008545431,
0.0095490031,
0.0190570001,
-0.0013282294,
-0.0074599879,
0.0317177847,
-0.0045726281,
-0.0363501757,
0.0507851243,
-0.0183700118,
0.0522590466,
-0.0205807332,
-0.0624190904,
-0.0510870107,
0.0213903673,
-0.0221757684,
0.0383326598,
0.0475231521,
-0.0256854612,
-0.0638986677,
0.0880902559,
-0.0193551462,
-0.0046982225,
0.0116515299,
-0.0649217293,
0.0198465232,
-0.0180087648,
0.0652608573,
0.0314948745,
0.0232624318,
-0.0270416178,
0.0302987136,
-0.0036326833,
-0.0452041477,
0.0017815008,
-0.030531982,
-0.0500135534,
-0.0391857512,
-0.0292594712,
0.0411492251,
0.0739722922,
0.0550470389,
0.0083954139,
-0.0608040765,
0.0242610946,
-0.0366572663,
-0.0153070074,
0.0084235212,
-0.0162149891,
-0.0394724384,
0.0303246398,
-0.0183362868,
-0.0089378171,
0.048728358,
-0.0578142591,
-0.013671753,
-0.0396320894,
0.0204179399,
-0.0394707359,
0.0342796482,
0.0143889887,
0.0352090038,
0.0424518622,
-0.0554484501,
-0.0276770201,
-0.034578573,
0.012234129,
-0.0005619998,
0.0122827804,
-0.0403594971,
0.0037591502,
0.0226618946,
-0.0041636177,
-0.0449547656,
-0.0244238526,
-0.0527270883,
-0.0107941525,
0.0418627933,
0.0222359709,
0.0240345672,
-0.0172762312,
0.0100856312,
-0.0125181256,
-0.0257481113,
0.0037714958,
-0.0551039651,
0.0388111621,
0.0728684813,
-0.0228842422,
-0.0159440432,
-0.0272023678,
0.0332692154,
0.0494885109,
-0.0046279421,
0.0317280293,
-0.018327957,
0.0063673849,
0.0289293434,
-0.0352088213,
-0.0431234017,
0.0161680486,
0.0289501082,
-0.0327417068,
-0.0334309116,
0.1259673238,
0.0390685946,
-0.0073190746,
0.0132557768,
-0.0199304074,
0.0594353564,
0.0183114111,
0.0381262191,
-0.0617081672,
0.002760089,
0.0410704874,
0.0159731209,
-0.0278095305,
-0.0024888986,
-0.0277570039,
-0.1010747254,
0.025669422,
0.0308434833,
0.0261234753,
0.0047083865,
0.0069986563,
-0.0294014923,
0.0232652519,
-0.0075465585,
0.0569495708,
-0.0265624784,
0.0213537961,
0.0055800439,
-0.0525802411,
-0.0081990641,
-0.0415005274,
-0.0349026658,
0.0394783989,
0.0621825345,
0.0273094401,
-0.0101355752,
0.008135166,
0.0274003725,
-0.037690565,
0.0110949827,
-0.0529112965,
0.0012544129,
-0.0243668575,
0.0064375121,
-0.0272393245,
0.0256491434,
0.0057534929,
-0.0026337833,
0.0424200147,
0.0555007271,
-0.021261869,
-0.0121010505,
-0.0191775803,
0.0379214212,
0.0081818486,
0.0603940748,
0.0462336093,
-0.0662066638,
-0.0652923584,
-0.0632029399,
-0.013042273,
-0.0951489583,
-0.0149031598,
-0.0234911945,
-0.0152487177,
0.0224392749,
-0.083830148,
-0.0262855776,
0.0315851122,
0.0114036752,
0.0004515383,
0.0426792242,
0.0256230012,
-0.0435037613,
-0.0279146284,
-0.0543290973,
-0.0320550539,
-0.0012462769,
-0.0637671426,
0.0065330216,
0.0397521779,
-0.0681613311,
-0.0089904591,
-0.0004960506,
-0.0500349142,
-0.067997992,
0.0100008463,
0.012199101,
0.0151685765,
0.0306231529,
-0.0212641712,
-0.0446841456,
0.005824137,
0.042189341,
-0.0714162737,
0.0816951618,
0.0199957341,
0.0599319749,
-0.0069084438,
0.0333259404,
-0.0090455171,
0.0316359289,
0.0057360083,
0.0692708865,
0.004025117,
0.0020232794,
0.0563412048,
0.0667819157,
-0.0126475263,
-0.0531382784,
0.006762295,
-0.0055235298,
-0.015888745,
-0.0651337877,
-0.042266272,
-0.0631800964,
0.022848621,
-0.0059491666,
0.0014555291,
-0.0120583819,
-0.0854008645,
-0.0648767576,
0.0433402471,
0.0093774367,
0.0262443069,
-0.0417652465,
0.0128914602,
0.038050469,
0.0003702797,
-0.0199633185,
0.0026943982,
-0.0241916385,
0.0378589481,
-0.0155128296,
0.0140722925,
0.0195863359,
0.0150604546,
-0.0612849742,
-0.0141227795,
-0.0203340426,
0.0263440628,
-0.0047369888,
-0.0126889031,
0.0664364994,
0.0193183105,
0.0772146806,
-0.0400294773,
0.0023258994,
0.0166787058,
0.0696408674,
0.0367242135,
-0.0444936715,
-0.0135978926,
-0.0193466637,
-0.0520180874,
-0.0405355096,
0.0604012385,
0.0279306751,
-0.0007962373,
0.0107669989,
0.012155313,
-0.0375721678,
-0.0288352035,
-0.0237342976,
-0.0212193541,
-0.0022011951,
-0.015235302,
-0.0250009336,
-0.0394944027,
0.0383683033,
0.0146999573,
-0.0066321166,
-0.036009524,
0.0082555311,
0.0206506718,
-0.0041652494,
-0.0468713045,
-0.0553176291,
0.0201041214,
0.0128757684,
-0.0253243707,
-0.0376424491,
-6.261382332e-33,
-0.0828164816,
-0.0388949588,
0.0106509998,
0.0061799255,
-0.026199786,
-0.0219527353,
-0.0555717945,
0.0256651901,
0.0522816926,
0.008554332,
-0.0250330325,
0.0110137947,
-0.0061730458,
0.0437098145,
0.0251673348,
0.0344547778,
0.0686824694,
-0.0162627418,
-0.0177699272,
0.0027501304,
0.0300161578,
0.0496591628,
-0.0152159613,
-0.0497924797,
0.0017204038,
-0.0310197901,
-0.0311160237,
-0.013877904,
-0.0085614333,
0.045965746,
-0.0107785743,
0.032319095,
0.0019472215,
0.0180005394,
-0.0478200689,
0.0432931185,
-0.0599088222,
-0.0167430062,
0.0429606959,
-0.0215727463,
0.0051891007,
-0.0769125298,
0.0233745426,
-0.0426619723,
-0.0402452499,
0.0236059185,
0.0183320064,
-0.0226687286,
-0.001676477,
-0.01367498,
-0.0688373893,
0.0120629668,
0.017919261,
0.0405879542,
0.0139587363,
0.0376922823,
-0.0104404343,
0.0429080762,
0.0341430157,
0.0182962138,
-0.0008319521,
0.0510928854,
0.0125213666,
0.0227531847,
0.0092503671,
0.0389240757,
-0.0240091253,
-0.0041401852,
-0.0543389916,
0.0567330532,
-0.0007053229,
0.0200610161,
0.0192819498,
0.053452678,
-0.0510825552,
-0.0582303442,
-0.0248896591,
-0.008912622,
-0.0138633708,
0.0301534962,
0.0003766824,
0.001743577,
-0.0129770413,
-0.0441251248,
-0.0384978093,
-0.006827977,
-0.0218207315,
-0.0033080478,
0.0266050305,
0.0184665099,
-0.0632308722,
-0.065384157,
0.0017275298,
-0.0416126437,
-0.0132230362,
0.0239604805,
-0.0391200371,
0.0408552364,
-0.0099697802,
0.0377312601,
0.0024605123,
-0.0153347338,
0.0042524603,
0.0003791033,
0.0018451592,
-0.0031277917,
-0.030839527,
-0.0038881202,
-0.0486834161,
0.0360876955,
-0.0161492936,
0.0116277868,
-0.0150237074,
-0.027755877,
0.0225512907,
-0.0013036371,
0.0099647082,
0.0139511405,
0.0073363176,
-0.029823821,
-0.0437205248,
-0.0323466323,
0.0141293611,
0.0623865426,
-0.0325974561,
0.0010096178,
-0.0418259539,
0.0588188656,
0.0566817969,
-0.0280629899,
-0.0049093892,
-0.0032316453,
2.745e-7,
0.0277479701,
0.0837272778,
0.0368274637,
0.0575571582,
-0.0118606491,
0.0065413071,
0.0285921395,
0.029194504,
0.0322206616,
0.0162203927,
-0.0171046779,
-0.0347015932,
0.0515499935,
-0.0086727543,
-0.094734937,
0.026652243,
-0.0390060395,
0.0231773853,
-0.0563610904,
-0.0149090821,
0.0730202794,
0.0051604817,
-0.0132484837,
0.0385175198,
-0.0196415186,
-0.0288637187,
0.0426312871,
-0.0111671165,
-0.0205077194,
0.0507711582,
-0.007577138,
-0.0270589925,
0.0359274149,
-0.0258470811,
0.0022205608,
0.0159993954,
-0.0056715622,
0.0822203234,
0.0405625813,
0.001826506,
-0.0012809401,
0.0121742804,
-0.0198172312,
-0.0532935299,
0.0433776453,
-0.0527378097,
0.0132486066,
-0.0250950996,
-0.0547124296,
-0.0029754753,
-0.0598995425,
-0.0132637629,
-0.0081484802,
0.0096040107,
0.0138548929,
0.0273022875,
0.0038466272,
-0.025090009,
-0.0445992462,
0.0178017523,
-0.0460213087,
-0.0324969515,
-0.0197301041,
0.0393702611,
0.0137683749,
-0.0788877904,
-0.0143885296,
2.696278458e-34,
0.0686848462,
-0.0328488201,
0.0314385109,
0.0121384207,
0.0350097455,
0.0155962529,
0.0259201881,
0.0627122596,
0.026881326,
-0.0738843903,
-0.0197603982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06120v1 | Exploring Group and Symmetry Principles in Large Language Models | 2024-02-09T01:10:25 | 2024-02-09T01:10:25 | Shima Imani, Hamid Palangi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance across
a wide range of applications; however, assessing their reasoning capabilities
remains a significant challenge. In this paper, we introduce a framework
grounded in group and symmetry principles, which have played a crucial role in
fields such as physics and mathematics, and offer another way to evaluate their
capabilities. While the proposed framework is general, to showcase the benefits
of employing these properties, we focus on arithmetic reasoning and investigate
the performance of these models on four group properties: closure, identity,
inverse, and associativity. Our findings reveal that LLMs studied in this work
struggle to preserve group properties across different test regimes. In the
closure test, we observe biases towards specific outputs and an abrupt
degradation in their performance from 100% to 0% after a specific sequence
length. They also perform poorly in the identity test, which represents adding
irrelevant information in the context, and show sensitivity when subjected to
inverse test, which examines the robustness of the model with respect to
negation. In addition, we demonstrate that breaking down problems into smaller
steps helps LLMs in the associativity test that we have conducted. To support
these tests we have developed a synthetic dataset which will be released. | [
0.0070911129,
0.126562506,
-0.0044538146,
0.058939673,
-0.0711233616,
0.0063805906,
0.0339836441,
0.0125702964,
-0.0356172919,
-0.0479874276,
-0.0098313913,
-0.0805027857,
0.0038362301,
-0.0124806082,
0.0480898693,
-0.0070929648,
0.0505028069,
-0.0621853806,
0.0102609899,
-0.0390855148,
-0.0363278985,
-0.037453413,
-0.0186027493,
-0.0099447919,
0.0216129757,
-0.0234129746,
0.0242758784,
-0.0568806641,
0.0075947293,
-0.0150453877,
-0.0513005555,
0.0497781746,
-0.0034283826,
0.0710529834,
0.0000021141,
-0.0616914965,
0.0050355308,
0.0225175768,
-0.0505153127,
0.0669011325,
-0.0025082282,
-0.0099206446,
-0.0026381924,
0.0328006148,
-0.0144267026,
0.0051668426,
0.0444356836,
0.0000437567,
0.0442965068,
0.0536780842,
-0.0030001886,
-0.0603117868,
0.0219599046,
-0.0481650308,
0.0340803526,
-0.0374608338,
0.0377937406,
0.0252204705,
0.0366887562,
-0.0252303127,
-0.0053345119,
0.0184476469,
0.0578196011,
0.0354328677,
-0.0526965,
0.0392755233,
-0.0366039611,
0.0052815326,
0.0135024348,
0.0507726707,
-0.0035749516,
0.0029565783,
-0.0221670177,
-0.0057672588,
-0.0125759104,
0.0066429069,
-0.0600721575,
0.06198553,
0.019086834,
0.0012162133,
0.0033281078,
0.0307953916,
0.0316944979,
0.0275140796,
-0.0796460435,
0.1108908281,
0.039372962,
-0.015618247,
-0.0509582683,
-0.0216720309,
-0.0998127237,
-0.0402022153,
-0.0372345932,
0.0441612937,
0.0102714142,
0.0222304314,
0.0087641459,
-0.0062538418,
0.0285690743,
-0.0453612357,
0.0213706419,
0.0677056685,
0.0294322632,
0.0545515232,
-0.035138607,
0.078962326,
-0.0251305867,
0.0287777223,
-0.0098894238,
0.0323369615,
0.0016461905,
-0.0216378924,
0.014539659,
0.0407437049,
-0.0121862283,
-0.0086038215,
-0.0340029038,
0.0162872244,
-0.0284243207,
0.0152595034,
-0.0036899659,
-0.0415871888,
0.0433700085,
-0.0416934043,
0.0016160069,
0.0114623019,
-0.0165696144,
0.0471000336,
-0.0070256204,
-0.0382900536,
-0.0017615764,
-0.0065934891,
-0.0280346461,
-0.005425442,
0.0170391053,
0.0702276081,
0.020596467,
-0.0289424881,
-0.0160822999,
0.0050387108,
-0.0276746396,
-0.1041752845,
0.0117809735,
-0.065269649,
0.0300077628,
0.0827907696,
-0.0098084193,
-0.0371058658,
0.0186233614,
-0.0097373147,
-0.0079797804,
0.062470831,
0.0976251811,
0.0311278347,
-0.0367064811,
-0.0014135733,
0.0027259896,
0.0527911633,
0.0413752198,
-0.0251441449,
0.019704422,
-0.0132189766,
-0.0039890618,
0.0381312221,
0.0158696976,
0.0286975875,
-0.0405639559,
0.0114290453,
0.0192988031,
0.0050754249,
-0.0272681396,
0.0992313996,
-0.0305401292,
-0.0445212387,
0.0558690131,
0.024165038,
-0.0269088745,
0.0438929796,
-0.0116661983,
-0.0502005443,
0.0159962382,
-0.0030654985,
-0.0661451072,
0.0156724975,
-0.0348340869,
0.0400055461,
0.0242193248,
0.0275728051,
-0.0211620033,
-0.0231716409,
-0.0610317774,
0.0051440317,
0.059303239,
0.0152905071,
0.0840081796,
-0.0512473732,
-0.0321018845,
0.0318671986,
0.0012773859,
-0.080574289,
-0.0212035831,
-0.0629332513,
0.0425792076,
-0.0159445815,
0.0514265187,
-0.0149222184,
-0.0136674047,
0.0031072726,
-0.0104998536,
-0.002202024,
0.0205154382,
0.0210790057,
-0.0299732666,
-0.0301220492,
0.0242006127,
0.0139723001,
0.0267572962,
-0.0034901409,
0.008417422,
-0.0279486887,
0.0208763722,
-0.0139911314,
0.0256302711,
-0.0043973033,
-0.0404894985,
-0.0117595522,
-0.0026598996,
-0.0113661941,
0.0167332627,
-0.0004341921,
0.0065235444,
0.060830351,
0.0251001418,
-0.0416557193,
-0.0146940341,
-0.0006892926,
-0.0406314842,
-0.0103335474,
0.0318111107,
0.0364722721,
0.012954846,
0.0486207567,
-0.0071282042,
-0.0099608861,
0.0797022432,
-0.0322848447,
0.0394915901,
-0.0257416964,
0.0641561523,
-0.0173522271,
0.0074587357,
-0.0267225541,
0.0944936201,
-0.0355352834,
0.0636263788,
-0.0329966061,
0.0103301536,
0.0318619087,
-0.0322979428,
-0.0340357609,
0.0357001424,
-0.0134557551,
0.0012092763,
0.009607018,
-0.0441849791,
-0.0041471794,
-0.0375347771,
-0.0299005061,
-0.0305492282,
-0.0302275456,
0.0607753769,
-0.0062373802,
-0.0052886866,
0.0014664821,
0.0057876278,
0.0112095084,
-0.0008274693,
0.0500356443,
0.0440455638,
0.0292443372,
-0.006059594,
-0.0697298124,
-0.0187026225,
-0.0468917824,
-0.0529361106,
0.0663381889,
0.0055309683,
0.0628952309,
-0.0243215188,
0.0200898387,
-0.0522249006,
0.0097554969,
-0.0308615845,
-0.0042426297,
0.0225462392,
-0.0147646526,
0.0251741502,
0.0704370439,
-0.019612113,
0.0143077122,
0.0358246788,
-0.0075690267,
0.0002277025,
-0.0142772058,
-0.027910348,
0.0105484677,
0.006197799,
-0.0273653828,
-0.0569170006,
0.098202683,
-0.003511891,
-0.05011563,
-0.0275302064,
0.0133712953,
-0.0504272953,
0.0256355256,
-0.0288687889,
-0.0215085745,
-0.003068916,
0.0367281251,
-0.0343989097,
-0.0317073278,
0.040301498,
0.0025723265,
-0.0214126576,
-0.0623117574,
0.0182399377,
-0.0743782669,
0.1121388227,
0.0089818733,
-0.0105524343,
0.0038293216,
-0.0033914011,
-0.0217659101,
-0.0461764671,
0.0160003025,
-0.0327532887,
0.0582749471,
-0.0501457192,
0.0373324789,
-0.0158613343,
-0.0561478175,
-0.0444410406,
-0.0254875273,
0.0039458293,
0.0351122543,
0.0038578846,
-0.0551892631,
-0.0470273234,
0.0614230223,
0.0328914486,
0.0163889267,
-0.0374151506,
0.0117015308,
-0.0079072742,
0.0120769367,
-0.006132144,
-0.0144820046,
0.0554480776,
-0.0645681918,
0.0164985638,
0.0253838319,
0.0507633537,
0.0493793897,
-0.0171357375,
0.0098299142,
0.0298486054,
-0.0002219108,
-0.0414197445,
0.0391242839,
-0.0020904497,
-0.0465198494,
-0.0031406833,
0.1205672175,
0.0487174056,
0.0094445832,
0.0422131531,
-0.0234584045,
0.0012618133,
0.0390225612,
-0.0037986988,
-0.0276896376,
0.0034902585,
-0.0053659794,
-0.0546927825,
-0.0029150287,
-0.0470576324,
0.0043320875,
-0.0876250938,
0.0018000271,
0.0127146021,
-0.0607641079,
-0.0550854318,
-0.0526703186,
0.0267919023,
-0.0361824483,
0.0274257679,
0.0592410043,
-0.0095740883,
-0.0208300184,
0.0100550232,
-0.0044544567,
-0.0049959789,
0.054840669,
-0.020363614,
0.0156614371,
0.0542014465,
0.0102365967,
-0.0206828881,
-0.0865617618,
0.0387239568,
0.0194408409,
-0.0285956673,
0.0237944275,
-0.0167472661,
0.0411957391,
-0.0022299262,
-0.0143599641,
0.0299960021,
-0.036094252,
-0.0260088276,
-0.0256087091,
0.0632725582,
0.0146538252,
-0.029977262,
0.0037566388,
-0.0062150648,
-0.0217436627,
0.0894795135,
0.0056658117,
-0.0083811274,
-0.0371039808,
-0.0276263077,
-0.0295725595,
-0.0040011359,
-0.0314525105,
0.0029324419,
0.0641776323,
-0.0145044457,
-0.0222677868,
0.0008858697,
0.0184771828,
0.012862022,
-0.0263302457,
-0.0220401883,
0.0195991024,
-0.0227124244,
-0.0312794521,
-0.0012383398,
-0.0210790969,
0.0509298928,
-0.0654029846,
0.0411976352,
0.0289351493,
-0.0144668845,
-0.0459720455,
0.0033829636,
-0.1108420417,
-0.060944166,
0.0066679665,
-0.0184432156,
0.0267978758,
-0.0216632187,
0.0188997649,
-0.0269176643,
-0.026291253,
0.0110158641,
-0.0483626202,
0.0469059758,
0.0094037447,
0.0016753366,
0.0284157377,
0.0144942906,
0.0052166302,
0.0411495157,
0.0129493456,
0.0457899794,
-0.0514136516,
-0.0278650727,
0.0195370298,
0.0509195812,
0.0058374014,
0.0199423004,
-0.0007747416,
0.0342654735,
0.0360598303,
-0.0520504005,
0.0033812583,
-0.0214633625,
-0.0108621512,
0.0320181958,
-0.0019474622,
-0.0294054225,
-0.0294054858,
0.0318124816,
0.0387101471,
0.0069422475,
0.0474236161,
-0.0555718839,
0.0173941609,
0.039083764,
-0.012292563,
0.0199198071,
-0.0218874607,
-0.0365585908,
0.0360067412,
-0.0000881951,
0.0346270651,
0.0255111977,
0.0116316108,
-0.0623565949,
-0.0061098263,
-0.0610996783,
-0.04476,
0.0075632753,
-0.0039915545,
-0.0153269209,
0.007833642,
-0.0120003782,
-0.0847217068,
0.0043210215,
-0.0379663967,
-0.0045021558,
0.002491527,
-0.0291909855,
0.0047209566,
0.0400450118,
0.0206584223,
0.0097235395,
0.044945661,
0.0010261826,
0.0373774283,
0.0007810058,
0.02934663,
-0.0328205451,
-0.03431575,
0.0035953852,
0.0061751259,
-0.0219601151,
0.0374441408,
-0.0941317752,
-0.0695442185,
-0.0319822542,
0.0181135759,
0.0340274386,
-0.003569142,
-0.0046119094,
0.0896097198,
-0.0432677381,
-0.015823951,
-0.0114648947,
0.0066248402,
-0.016085567,
-0.0062544718,
-0.0544970073,
-6.263562139e-33,
-0.0128847919,
-0.0208334886,
0.0391855389,
-0.0192965697,
0.0131260008,
-0.0236831699,
-0.046051912,
0.0516610891,
-0.033351019,
-0.0258277729,
0.0031175581,
0.0036259305,
-0.0090684108,
0.0347799957,
-0.0044072689,
-0.0164690837,
0.0155372964,
0.0176415462,
-0.0233359933,
-0.0199735947,
0.0252853278,
-0.0468146428,
0.0295356624,
-0.0340405554,
0.0192299746,
-0.0250678919,
-0.0126150949,
0.0016952609,
-0.0878048688,
0.0585566424,
-0.021401966,
0.0015459334,
0.0021341539,
-0.0518811904,
-0.0036049162,
-0.0192542356,
-0.0332131125,
-0.021095559,
0.0252954569,
-0.0076922821,
-0.003036926,
-0.0285256971,
0.0392483622,
0.0070270314,
-0.0433558486,
-0.0211543813,
-0.0137979323,
-0.0067362054,
-0.0173141826,
0.0468375646,
-0.057449162,
0.0283691622,
-0.002519903,
-0.0278184023,
-0.0004837172,
-0.029244706,
-0.0257785991,
0.0064862645,
-0.0125886425,
0.0484866202,
0.0093235634,
0.0337465927,
0.0324958898,
0.0287567247,
0.0156988483,
0.0219721179,
0.0261869077,
0.0101982811,
-0.0421494879,
0.0074471291,
0.0491201058,
0.041400075,
0.0724741966,
0.0087909447,
0.0502128825,
0.0158553012,
-0.0534636974,
-0.0351388007,
0.0166744404,
0.0324996524,
0.0479491092,
0.0219806973,
-0.0784466043,
-0.0269052275,
-0.0312374309,
0.0021754939,
-0.0615025386,
-0.0016757817,
0.0021371427,
-0.0139577314,
-0.028148137,
0.0150458077,
0.0535249971,
-0.06018278,
-0.0358451903,
0.0626468286,
0.0103926715,
0.0417534932,
-0.0021493097,
-0.0065936889,
-0.0492821597,
-0.0262248423,
-0.0281431992,
0.0064984239,
-0.0042962101,
-0.0055220905,
-0.0025827517,
0.0425410941,
-0.0491471104,
-0.0400068499,
-0.0292475149,
-0.0164668243,
0.0371955223,
-0.0117718372,
0.0359836929,
0.0405338705,
0.0115172733,
0.0421294309,
0.0037927998,
-0.0298596825,
-0.0110769197,
0.0220770873,
-0.0176790394,
0.0455611423,
0.0253971312,
-0.0307618268,
-0.0212424602,
-0.0031741052,
0.0524860546,
-0.0169176366,
-0.0118955569,
0.009701631,
2.829e-7,
0.0534845777,
0.0413557999,
0.0126385167,
0.060789831,
0.024622703,
0.022668764,
-0.02622029,
-0.0459363908,
0.0047111074,
0.0044775046,
0.0011472122,
0.0582216792,
0.0009528592,
0.0071563004,
0.0035636439,
0.05439936,
-0.0671044737,
0.0017809396,
-0.0266067255,
0.0345670283,
0.0150969801,
0.0651769936,
0.0380604006,
0.009641923,
-0.0203343201,
-0.0457259901,
0.0218021106,
-0.0069464599,
-0.0008649645,
0.0269576441,
-0.0145208128,
-0.0407942608,
0.0196936931,
0.0396232344,
0.0177382734,
0.0454699621,
-0.0081597203,
0.0234788768,
0.0058130189,
0.0123886485,
-0.0366390273,
-0.0650667995,
-0.0075089778,
-0.0669397935,
0.0807664022,
-0.0197146107,
-0.0532432497,
-0.0016364314,
0.0142847188,
0.0368515551,
0.0347732306,
0.0191491395,
0.0116100991,
-0.0018255473,
0.0081941495,
-0.0337611474,
0.0117177898,
-0.0633960962,
-0.0308720898,
0.0127115333,
-0.0617843904,
-0.0621793084,
-0.032684993,
0.013436594,
0.0251204539,
-0.0611074008,
-0.0329004861,
3.092205389e-34,
0.0395862348,
-0.0119155403,
-0.0074973148,
0.0404688902,
0.0337489098,
-0.0279811732,
-0.0618487746,
0.0385717377,
0.0341163464,
-0.0764568895,
-0.0113447579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06094v1 | Rethinking Data Selection for Supervised Fine-Tuning | 2024-02-08T23:02:04 | 2024-02-08T23:02:04 | Ming Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although supervised finetuning (SFT) has emerged as an essential technique to
align large language models with humans, it is considered superficial, with
style learning being its nature. At the same time, recent works indicate the
importance of data selection for SFT, showing that finetuning with high-quality
and diverse subsets of the original dataset leads to superior downstream
performance. In this work, we rethink the intuition behind data selection for
SFT. Considering SFT is superficial, we propose that essential demonstrations
for SFT should focus on reflecting human-like interactions instead of data
quality or diversity. However, it is not straightforward to directly assess to
what extent a demonstration reflects human styles. Towards an initial attempt
in this direction, we find selecting instances with long responses is
surprisingly more effective for SFT than utilizing full datasets or instances
selected based on quality and diversity. We hypothesize that such a simple
heuristic implicitly mimics a crucial aspect of human-style conversation:
detailed responses are usually more helpful. | [
0.0505576544,
0.065453805,
-0.0512923338,
0.029128911,
-0.0049707079,
0.0284987167,
-0.0093776695,
-0.0044255755,
-0.0595738254,
-0.0289537832,
-0.0722132474,
-0.0172252525,
0.0368274301,
0.0034581567,
0.0755784363,
-0.0707307234,
0.0179907158,
-0.0198273659,
0.0143962009,
-0.0106808655,
0.0338518173,
0.0133280186,
0.0039758519,
0.0430677645,
-0.0061155194,
0.0227926187,
-0.0153107112,
0.0176272616,
0.0196800604,
0.0176096223,
0.0452189967,
0.0778953359,
0.0020563845,
-0.0088702999,
0.0000017718,
-0.0226574261,
0.0530023947,
-0.0232855771,
-0.0206962433,
0.0012146173,
0.0112451836,
-0.0020547439,
0.0152719002,
-0.0062262523,
-0.0572053306,
-0.0086278664,
0.0495688207,
0.052799888,
0.0408700779,
0.0665452406,
0.0139824105,
-0.0307712406,
0.0064985361,
-0.0566994697,
-0.0194245875,
-0.0336431637,
0.0211682227,
-0.0288339313,
0.0166399367,
0.0066979965,
-0.0360025056,
0.0160172153,
-0.0071528414,
0.003096092,
0.0216144081,
0.0152444914,
-0.1129843146,
-0.0086396728,
0.019058913,
0.1083005145,
0.0266917106,
-0.0010600347,
0.0245489031,
-0.0122349858,
0.0359755717,
0.0089249741,
-0.0434616953,
-0.0326593183,
0.0136636803,
0.0268428698,
-0.0269113537,
-0.0012814839,
0.0278703365,
0.0247186609,
-0.0028969112,
0.0192813221,
-0.0431707576,
-0.0415416546,
0.0041406848,
-0.0005875094,
-0.0212500505,
-0.0504167639,
-0.0301747918,
-0.0143836252,
-0.0525574237,
-0.0157021116,
-0.0654515699,
0.0030378066,
0.0043539484,
0.0376578383,
0.0329893641,
0.0148348808,
0.0093710544,
0.0320025347,
0.0154613424,
0.0199023429,
0.0175794289,
0.0387946516,
-0.0314948037,
0.0083369482,
-0.0432184525,
-0.0051805247,
-0.0273348354,
0.0002783845,
-0.0271152388,
-0.0270710345,
0.0026253737,
-0.0220856965,
-0.0219375547,
-0.0078112083,
-0.0142019764,
-0.0097059673,
-0.0537598543,
0.0133667486,
-0.0005300433,
0.014751371,
-0.0677432939,
0.0356756821,
0.0310120992,
-0.0859809816,
-0.0306820218,
0.0264517721,
0.0168778356,
-0.0423221663,
0.004978152,
0.0066976855,
-0.0087711466,
-0.0462476015,
-0.0023945456,
0.0080468487,
-0.0415186323,
-0.0826623589,
0.0060908943,
-0.0460987724,
0.0454756841,
0.0018720333,
-0.0019548931,
-0.0288161039,
-0.0174441077,
-0.0126780495,
-0.0627160743,
0.0456481054,
-0.0189981107,
0.026252294,
-0.007093681,
-0.0175553095,
0.0211865027,
0.0675055385,
0.0315647423,
0.0010086059,
0.0207788292,
-0.0402808972,
0.0276039671,
0.0412320308,
0.0316974521,
0.0216967128,
-0.0296253562,
0.0102126272,
-0.0096995337,
0.0466353409,
0.0496598594,
0.0263470169,
-0.0517674237,
-0.0032068847,
0.0686365515,
0.0283747241,
0.0049396036,
0.0098154582,
0.0088305818,
0.0623225495,
0.0189775694,
0.0777604431,
-0.0707075298,
0.0373034067,
-0.0119276885,
0.0089006964,
0.0497389324,
0.0156455282,
-0.0463089943,
-0.027622167,
0.0048132739,
0.0147951851,
0.0199402496,
0.0267507453,
0.0005429888,
0.0458863266,
-0.0073447945,
0.0094596613,
0.0712748542,
-0.0202051718,
-0.0285264812,
-0.0550181195,
0.010882712,
0.0608492456,
0.0171158034,
0.0004093499,
0.0061409073,
-0.0331103317,
0.0573035292,
0.0165176168,
0.0895363167,
-0.0166707244,
0.0365521647,
-0.0534256734,
0.0115150446,
-0.0179750286,
0.0260701384,
-0.0106959306,
0.0180517491,
-0.006830907,
-0.0085351998,
-0.0292060748,
-0.0307777878,
0.048970826,
-0.0089420918,
-0.0205672998,
-0.0019791622,
0.0233026482,
0.0083807865,
-0.0317688771,
-0.0325874873,
-0.0161297303,
-0.0162055325,
0.0168681834,
0.0549414568,
-0.0117614157,
-0.0419359356,
-0.0301563032,
0.0011773043,
-0.0338865146,
-0.051193852,
0.0248016566,
-0.0398163609,
-0.0450603589,
-0.0094597572,
-0.0409138724,
-0.0067218905,
-0.0270690508,
-0.0054502441,
-0.0359806046,
0.0514728874,
-0.049423039,
0.0217637978,
0.0162633602,
0.00290677,
0.0081628552,
-0.003744784,
-0.0176969375,
-0.0711102709,
-0.0315138809,
0.0237308834,
0.0022907108,
0.0294508692,
0.0124051981,
0.0259302203,
-0.0623896606,
-0.0356231108,
-0.0910351947,
-0.010979143,
-0.0449632071,
-0.0081665711,
0.0007941169,
-0.0094309701,
-0.037533965,
-0.0220481213,
-0.040602304,
0.0029833401,
-0.021000674,
0.0177049171,
0.0515923202,
0.0148582598,
-0.0052167079,
-0.0519368574,
-0.0053298976,
0.0227719564,
0.0417325683,
-0.0248554591,
0.0156214312,
-0.0391848497,
-0.0066638896,
-0.0150158629,
0.0013384257,
-0.0336084738,
-0.0655045658,
0.0134747354,
0.0086733717,
0.0047138631,
0.0986972526,
0.0392108448,
0.0326088257,
0.002471152,
0.0142678544,
-0.0425987951,
0.0236764606,
-0.0220626537,
-0.0238580331,
-0.0580725223,
-0.0123357931,
0.0254621431,
0.0251314249,
-0.0003302282,
0.0218946394,
-0.0805726051,
0.060991101,
0.0452906862,
-0.0312151499,
0.0136802802,
0.0201158337,
-0.0403317399,
0.039476268,
-0.0236182567,
-0.0687046275,
0.0961240605,
-0.0115685482,
-0.0131137632,
0.0090168342,
-0.0077080941,
-0.0033241794,
0.0355923213,
-0.0005794897,
-0.0050498359,
0.000744687,
-0.0043128571,
-0.0655494779,
-0.0347733758,
0.049225457,
-0.022196807,
0.0529368185,
-0.0436835103,
-0.0073865317,
0.0094266227,
-0.0681888685,
-0.0134850219,
-0.0513497479,
-0.0301974956,
0.0040770397,
0.0327537544,
-0.0187250078,
-0.0196264312,
-0.017725816,
0.0133867189,
0.0284472238,
-0.0611272268,
0.0109007368,
-0.0207920764,
0.0100166034,
0.0662476271,
0.0541412607,
0.0206862297,
-0.0364986546,
0.0052105794,
0.0021014104,
0.0077453679,
0.0500717573,
-0.0042894478,
0.00839628,
0.0269133598,
0.0176356975,
-0.0342432931,
0.0277319364,
0.1093739122,
-0.0357628688,
-0.024811225,
0.0866887197,
0.000369284,
-0.0344675779,
0.0143931108,
0.0160566829,
0.0376753546,
0.0181571543,
0.0519884862,
-0.033216048,
-0.0514685288,
0.0183983408,
0.0433463007,
-0.0023172579,
-0.0161061697,
-0.0033013367,
-0.095840767,
0.0811221153,
0.0222639441,
-0.0912642702,
-0.0285414979,
-0.031953644,
0.0535362586,
-0.0234373771,
0.0367441438,
0.0025158084,
-0.0083163269,
0.004426768,
0.0286963899,
0.005343297,
-0.0993098393,
0.0220979415,
-0.0348681472,
0.0646342412,
0.0615888275,
0.0580202639,
0.0035620029,
-0.0478125922,
0.0215140395,
-0.0164758042,
0.0306291543,
-0.0150920656,
0.087072134,
0.0105283232,
-0.0345827416,
-0.0100333244,
0.0730007365,
0.0136000551,
0.0249295458,
-0.0238651708,
0.0164489336,
-0.0286445785,
-0.0157022551,
0.019432053,
0.0011502848,
0.0393444598,
0.0527321473,
0.0736643896,
-0.0687000453,
-0.0116349403,
-0.0277525876,
-0.0105417222,
-0.0236360244,
-0.0403044559,
0.0160637219,
0.0208665952,
-0.0111418562,
-0.0543715246,
-0.0641794652,
0.0511351898,
0.0221767426,
-0.007248838,
-0.0163550284,
-0.0017227287,
0.0037915208,
0.006266179,
0.0710526779,
-0.0345233418,
0.0327300057,
-0.0498401672,
-0.0618397146,
0.0272715315,
-0.0740432218,
0.0061700568,
0.01330919,
-0.0588896088,
-0.08470276,
0.0193023738,
0.0514254533,
0.0208499543,
0.0715098381,
0.0107675903,
-0.1009337679,
0.0054643662,
0.0874188021,
-0.032788083,
0.0282456968,
0.0297618657,
-0.0459705405,
-0.0244640447,
0.0744806007,
0.0055652494,
0.0420433991,
0.0390164778,
0.0039999513,
-0.0039488208,
-0.0463496819,
0.0011945796,
0.0144489007,
0.0708260611,
-0.0026331318,
-0.0352766886,
-0.0069683217,
-0.0114567215,
0.0501891114,
-0.019056106,
-0.0499020144,
-0.0613012277,
-0.0074470998,
0.0215730797,
-0.0065964586,
-0.0379728936,
-0.0106735965,
0.0360236093,
-0.0767862946,
0.0003003425,
0.0068485173,
-0.0059835119,
0.0485024638,
0.0274685305,
-0.0017422767,
0.0623547994,
0.0035511882,
0.0567907169,
0.0043977797,
0.0303511471,
0.0580824539,
0.0111087477,
-0.0114701455,
0.0147473617,
-0.0679187551,
-0.0699357912,
-0.0233275648,
0.0035542995,
0.0122877453,
-0.0531739518,
0.054091692,
0.0065089497,
-0.0144881774,
-0.0069805388,
0.0419835448,
-0.0101216389,
-0.0040760967,
0.0182635952,
0.0378317349,
-0.0480289757,
-0.0020175301,
0.0644766092,
-0.0240701362,
0.00565942,
-0.0117599657,
0.032223355,
-0.0242247432,
-0.0342974737,
0.0187412985,
0.0154614039,
0.0163122062,
0.0113822799,
-0.0265487581,
-0.0516944937,
-0.0471136384,
-0.0001077555,
-0.0074771279,
-0.0433836952,
0.0676929578,
0.0512202419,
-0.0371661335,
-0.0008705248,
-0.0450891517,
-0.0203600693,
0.0390955247,
-0.0060296729,
-0.0285739396,
-6.276796736e-33,
-0.0261809863,
-0.0027549583,
-0.0092531228,
0.0452799611,
-0.0299001988,
-0.0432323962,
-0.043225307,
0.0281385649,
-0.0653778389,
0.0419451296,
-0.045788005,
0.0140430797,
0.014742177,
0.0194235798,
-0.0006561149,
-0.0209260825,
0.0571214966,
-0.0135415029,
-0.0558029525,
0.0266375709,
-0.0053926026,
0.0072696107,
0.0545194782,
-0.0622175708,
0.0076229512,
-0.0032674766,
-0.0193467904,
0.011883527,
-0.0227515604,
0.0313880108,
0.0185705367,
0.0397942923,
0.00407437,
-0.0054868748,
-0.0268147402,
0.0054842671,
-0.0621661432,
-0.0193768088,
0.0291442145,
0.0311446637,
-0.0110048568,
-0.0145407496,
0.0685770512,
-0.0476059616,
-0.0111824451,
-0.0084021809,
0.0293921418,
-0.0319363326,
-0.0401905142,
-0.0327391624,
-0.0396052971,
0.0212612655,
-0.0193287805,
-0.0703757629,
0.0365138613,
0.0095431237,
-0.0268181693,
0.0040940535,
-0.0199125595,
0.019417733,
0.0296196137,
0.0264447965,
0.0262132026,
0.0266454667,
0.0189515818,
0.0524177812,
0.0178181659,
0.0719948709,
0.0266566891,
-0.0446579605,
0.0556185134,
0.0635738894,
-0.0122131081,
0.0476769395,
0.0316148698,
-0.038734775,
-0.0024408342,
-0.0171741787,
-0.0099027706,
-0.0028154501,
0.0028743916,
0.0088971183,
-0.0643307492,
-0.0604138859,
-0.0518484414,
-0.009794713,
-0.0110036694,
0.0155688794,
-0.0003360966,
0.0152326757,
-0.0239290558,
-0.0014752343,
0.016262643,
-0.0382922366,
-0.0175163634,
-0.0114422431,
-0.0538661741,
0.0059802625,
0.0016732353,
-0.0399418138,
-0.0398023315,
-0.0452300943,
0.0190155338,
0.0158722885,
0.02899253,
0.0193636641,
0.0879213139,
0.0093570119,
-0.0412517674,
0.0003106005,
0.0002729877,
0.0415245481,
0.0038849299,
-0.0206119865,
0.0250864048,
0.0268119052,
-0.0199524686,
0.0548538305,
0.0006625251,
-0.0463832095,
-0.0405605361,
-0.0138303507,
-0.0005113372,
0.0023536079,
-0.0253549013,
-0.0098987808,
-0.0349101275,
-0.0375900231,
0.0294639096,
-0.0214343891,
-0.0239292718,
0.0157625973,
2.526e-7,
-0.0131214634,
0.0389955267,
0.0109509407,
0.0240172204,
0.0357702635,
0.0535839386,
-0.0096767684,
0.0021517526,
0.0104433624,
-0.014799173,
0.0111292591,
0.0369293429,
0.0953099877,
0.0111644622,
-0.0912149325,
0.0137716355,
-0.0780668408,
0.0097639523,
-0.0118837059,
-0.0367812887,
-0.0096003264,
0.069467552,
0.0142431464,
-0.0028162678,
0.0273202993,
-0.0166897085,
0.0599435829,
-0.051497627,
0.0229623746,
0.0548201241,
-0.0181307588,
0.0145015894,
-0.023405619,
0.053183049,
0.003238468,
0.0277884174,
-0.007483793,
0.0713479817,
0.0023943065,
0.0022758648,
-0.0059430641,
0.0076262942,
0.0105791371,
-0.0338416621,
0.057521943,
-0.1005485579,
-0.0413385071,
-0.0218857825,
0.0323280059,
-0.0203816518,
0.016032774,
-0.0146988956,
0.0145979654,
0.0575890094,
0.0360968187,
-0.0014334961,
-0.0118753826,
-0.0654785335,
-0.0357458368,
0.0431979559,
-0.0595377535,
-0.0444820374,
-0.0173934549,
-0.0263239294,
0.0199399386,
-0.0199284144,
0.020954594,
1.759392127e-34,
0.0310959984,
0.0113940891,
0.0260645021,
0.0064367917,
0.0361875221,
-0.0023222049,
0.0210995954,
0.0094131334,
0.0494969338,
-0.0628174543,
-0.0045418162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06073v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06073v2 | LightCAM: A Fast and Light Implementation of Context-Aware Masking based D-TDNN for Speaker Verification | 2024-02-08T21:47:16 | 2024-02-12T15:28:38 | Di Cao, Xianchen Wang, Junfeng Zhou, Jiakai Zhang, Yanjing Lei, Wenpeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Traditional Time Delay Neural Networks (TDNN) have achieved state-of-the-art
performance at the cost of high computational complexity and slower inference
speed, making them difficult to implement in an industrial environment. The
Densely Connected Time Delay Neural Network (D-TDNN) with Context Aware Masking
(CAM) module has proven to be an efficient structure to reduce complexity while
maintaining system performance. In this paper, we propose a fast and
lightweight model, LightCAM, which further adopts a depthwise separable
convolution module (DSM) and uses multi-scale feature aggregation (MFA) for
feature fusion at different levels. Extensive experiments are conducted on
VoxCeleb dataset, the comparative results show that it has achieved an EER of
0.83 and MinDCF of 0.0891 in VoxCeleb1-O, which outperforms the other
mainstream speaker verification methods. In addition, complexity analysis
further demonstrates that the proposed architecture has lower computational
cost and faster inference speed. | [
-0.0390831903,
0.0289280396,
0.0269109253,
0.0694303513,
-0.0304480046,
-0.0002371754,
0.0936029777,
-0.046042107,
0.0000837038,
0.0105119571,
0.0124972267,
-0.0545991622,
0.0510955118,
0.0262598023,
0.0232262071,
-0.0301727448,
-0.0016763193,
0.0388325602,
-0.0371528529,
-0.0188629124,
0.0033912368,
0.0032231261,
-0.0466409028,
0.0171437375,
-0.0406496599,
0.0211083759,
0.0089419447,
0.009095313,
0.0757110491,
0.0159049556,
-0.0045843343,
0.013487597,
0.0243227482,
0.068886362,
0.0000021959,
-0.0008044266,
-0.0304621048,
0.0069470434,
-0.0771505237,
-0.0314400569,
-0.0134762023,
0.0602185056,
-0.0730292723,
0.0432502441,
-0.0154976677,
-0.0336633697,
0.0193009414,
0.0394872762,
0.0088627478,
0.01436421,
-0.0094435448,
-0.0510519966,
0.0275692251,
-0.0080568288,
-0.0353832729,
-0.0459321104,
0.0099839382,
-0.056547638,
-0.0247907154,
-0.0541917272,
0.0306201093,
0.0518549792,
0.0497055873,
0.0388410576,
0.0429760702,
0.0328059904,
-0.0205416251,
-0.0071209981,
-0.0025103523,
0.0652440265,
-0.0363880061,
0.0050722924,
0.039874807,
0.0219744612,
-0.0283148549,
-0.0226235874,
0.006120027,
-0.040011283,
0.0059764301,
-0.0456027649,
-0.0776789933,
0.0226605218,
0.0334462859,
0.0131821148,
-0.0220902041,
-0.0336218253,
0.0083483607,
0.0186700411,
-0.008404634,
-0.0349462219,
0.002221422,
-0.0711865276,
-0.0130830193,
0.0229155663,
0.0001811408,
-0.0288957655,
-0.0314168371,
-0.0258523859,
-0.0407293327,
-0.0507790186,
-0.048551321,
0.030171087,
-0.0555333495,
0.0212394912,
-0.027517207,
0.0537919551,
-0.0450188443,
-0.0190873016,
0.0081587303,
-0.0514699034,
0.0125625832,
0.0105906986,
-0.0286451671,
-0.0000113084,
0.0318943113,
-0.0081735086,
-0.0536042154,
-0.0118383989,
-0.0561279953,
0.005970635,
-0.0262567885,
0.0288606621,
0.0111859143,
0.0009709953,
-0.0084389951,
0.0174258891,
0.0461026281,
0.0319112688,
-0.0463254005,
-0.0617396608,
0.0058762562,
-0.0075586522,
0.0494077951,
-0.0006651463,
0.0404553376,
0.0159723908,
-0.0126716327,
-0.039291665,
-0.0145863835,
0.0472447611,
-0.0344836488,
-0.0063137827,
0.0293469392,
-0.0908230394,
0.0521862321,
-0.021426525,
-0.005678325,
-0.0079753436,
-0.0054006218,
0.0090024937,
0.0422349758,
0.0480740927,
-0.0133473435,
0.0210445374,
0.0853509754,
-0.00133545,
-0.0094944835,
-0.0143039906,
0.0473191328,
0.0085357092,
-0.0321578868,
-0.0013470626,
-0.0197865851,
0.0410513915,
0.0003019303,
-0.036614649,
-0.0523320399,
-0.0228019096,
-0.0455250666,
-0.0007351044,
-0.0187986866,
-0.0051125363,
-0.0093405433,
-0.014528418,
0.0136211719,
0.0211101547,
0.0000946302,
-0.0643007383,
0.0287053548,
-0.0124421613,
0.0106782801,
-0.0372026376,
-0.0303495768,
0.0448990427,
0.0012025766,
-0.0268155038,
0.0288646817,
0.0930923969,
-0.0299259517,
0.0093563255,
0.0132928761,
-0.002581978,
0.0368610732,
0.0769046992,
-0.016911298,
-0.0501197129,
-0.0060551194,
0.0313965902,
-0.0009909645,
-0.0232967287,
-0.0465437137,
-0.0509869568,
-0.0309951808,
-0.0059701698,
0.0165046472,
0.0244381707,
-0.0036190168,
0.0002261473,
0.015971899,
0.0007632573,
0.0172471553,
-0.0193454809,
0.0376746319,
-0.0235699918,
-0.0636142343,
0.030872805,
-0.0444567241,
0.052007433,
0.0089540631,
0.0126780849,
0.060384661,
0.036206048,
0.0525761954,
-0.0112247178,
-0.012209422,
-0.0260697287,
-0.003994213,
0.0555003658,
0.0680650026,
0.0516809411,
-0.0149492929,
-0.0438727401,
0.0204096716,
-0.0250945464,
0.006465964,
-0.0049721338,
-0.0708242431,
-0.067605257,
0.0479046777,
-0.020789979,
-0.0414431021,
0.0927711129,
-0.0044564824,
-0.067495808,
0.0051468369,
-0.0221716333,
0.0307402648,
-0.0223737676,
0.0341277346,
-0.0060746553,
0.0082015982,
0.0101701384,
0.0467809588,
-0.0038996525,
-0.0172330625,
-0.0002202946,
0.0209871884,
0.043982029,
-0.0427173078,
-0.0232939962,
-0.0156515781,
-0.0134740425,
-0.0092073921,
-0.0030632268,
0.006037158,
0.0023753438,
-0.0186733026,
-0.0874907225,
-0.0243284721,
-0.0129885618,
-0.0493517667,
-0.0569388643,
0.0137254316,
0.035686601,
-0.0530641675,
-0.0566437617,
0.0067828721,
-0.0016466116,
-0.0195341725,
-0.0352213569,
0.0226749089,
-0.0806590244,
-0.0048683011,
-0.0273444969,
-0.0156816039,
0.0155524798,
-0.0251971744,
-0.0738700256,
0.0815699473,
-0.0092040505,
-0.0114315022,
0.0548867509,
-0.0003327327,
0.041670721,
-0.0102453222,
0.0403488763,
0.0182574615,
0.0159481615,
0.0346098579,
-0.0651887655,
-0.0167246815,
-0.0051116091,
-0.0136891911,
0.0392205082,
0.0190951098,
0.0762537792,
0.0379482917,
0.0081493035,
-0.0487921499,
-0.008002704,
-0.0273598786,
0.0302234273,
-0.012732219,
0.0072783427,
0.0277913716,
-0.0301778987,
-0.0081295343,
-0.031818103,
-0.0071901595,
-0.0388584659,
-0.0442004427,
-0.0383260995,
0.0144292125,
-0.0852548629,
-0.0312213544,
-0.0097660152,
-0.0783329457,
-0.0313164741,
0.016104158,
0.0479307249,
0.0294817276,
-0.0310806837,
-0.0213448238,
-0.0282790326,
0.0091739483,
-0.0118122548,
-0.0537424088,
0.0624579564,
0.0259516072,
0.0200590938,
-0.0527527742,
-0.0351131521,
-0.0524727926,
-0.024089843,
-0.02940646,
0.0007108556,
-0.0006413684,
-0.0544007272,
-0.0170376841,
0.0149718551,
0.0523611978,
0.0182554163,
0.0295734741,
0.0277108625,
-0.0245040413,
0.0674474388,
0.0058087297,
0.0652826652,
0.0191756226,
0.0109181777,
0.0260713454,
-0.0226562582,
0.0451836586,
0.0265574604,
-0.0775507838,
-0.0292132217,
0.0173805598,
0.0457427688,
-0.0045600799,
0.0309313107,
0.0082988786,
-0.0181106161,
0.05079538,
0.0761626363,
-0.0229098685,
-0.0422202758,
-0.0526305065,
0.0326210931,
-0.0238069557,
-0.014104058,
-0.0103949094,
-0.015751075,
-0.0351088457,
0.0805451721,
0.0041906824,
0.0119077368,
0.0300877579,
-0.0354135782,
-0.0497744121,
0.0208566543,
-0.0004537003,
-0.0346709341,
-0.0325567797,
-0.0006646298,
-0.0082232673,
0.0112008443,
0.0891403705,
-0.0075232387,
0.0081096413,
-0.0438233428,
0.0365915895,
-0.0479724742,
-0.0362327397,
0.0484035797,
-0.0005385018,
0.0106072128,
0.0149776582,
0.02392051,
-0.0121118156,
-0.0550553165,
-0.0115112746,
0.0154422019,
-0.0223324802,
0.0000824106,
0.0194939692,
-0.0077453251,
-0.0249991883,
0.0145229343,
0.0142750498,
0.0304144379,
-0.0014475796,
-0.0382121541,
0.0097596301,
0.0213294569,
0.0397006422,
-0.0358321518,
0.0422006175,
-0.0217127297,
0.0418454073,
-0.0066740769,
0.0116665969,
-0.000831173,
0.0879325569,
-0.007750073,
0.0008264609,
-0.0075875716,
0.0221214425,
-0.0138897048,
-0.0367404483,
0.014166126,
0.0011257908,
-0.0191774834,
0.0158539303,
0.00758497,
-0.0127523923,
-0.0399124362,
0.0432477072,
-0.0640187189,
0.0498054214,
0.0016029289,
0.0901889279,
-0.0539607182,
0.063378647,
0.0190416556,
-0.0362173505,
-0.0102229845,
0.0515109934,
-0.0614521094,
-0.0267706625,
0.0200168751,
-0.0441538207,
-0.0005159159,
0.0213339347,
-0.0152942641,
-0.0156755727,
0.0564393774,
0.0042243851,
-0.0015428357,
0.0633124188,
0.0238811001,
-0.0312287156,
-0.0221045204,
0.0045067314,
-0.0612071268,
0.0704278275,
-0.0216737241,
-0.0626505017,
-0.0532964282,
-0.0424789004,
-0.0323377587,
0.0099998452,
0.0274258666,
0.0050731553,
0.0652485192,
-0.0482887067,
0.0474901907,
0.0117043797,
0.0321374312,
-0.0291472431,
-0.0443649441,
-0.0465910025,
0.0215717349,
0.0300943404,
0.0507266968,
0.064662829,
-0.0255841874,
0.0114271147,
0.0230756346,
-0.0236485209,
-0.0151628815,
-0.027516285,
0.0105530294,
0.0030951435,
0.0083917538,
0.0308578368,
-0.0160431899,
-0.0033558712,
0.0042046318,
-0.0147424564,
-0.0338350907,
-0.0224037152,
0.0498159155,
-0.0079045249,
-0.0359984674,
-0.0046840152,
-0.0305681881,
0.070460394,
0.0076882807,
0.0151825268,
0.0028139839,
0.0145622529,
-0.018350644,
-0.0205867141,
-0.0389675908,
0.0228726156,
0.0400824584,
0.0142700113,
-0.0096079139,
0.0223817173,
0.0170420352,
0.0456922688,
-0.0256912503,
-0.0167127978,
0.0376538634,
0.0002343242,
0.0061035044,
0.0500164516,
0.0268832911,
-0.0206901655,
-0.0474455059,
-0.0112612564,
-0.0109999459,
0.0465187058,
-0.0289155673,
0.0190757383,
0.0468696281,
0.0200580098,
-0.0184011422,
0.0037444127,
-0.0392254554,
0.0371822976,
-0.0398946628,
0.0129663674,
-0.0096597662,
0.0583735332,
-6.100816783e-33,
-0.0249705706,
0.0125170453,
-0.0061489055,
-0.02108505,
-0.0079124253,
0.0596554689,
0.016442474,
-0.0011392437,
-0.0142465224,
-0.0390979126,
-0.0230535548,
0.0345624611,
0.0265129097,
0.0306751728,
-0.0558053516,
0.0271488428,
0.1038543582,
0.0013439435,
0.0965697989,
-0.0044085756,
0.0320218019,
-0.0025905147,
-0.0279767402,
-0.0674571991,
-0.077566579,
0.007018378,
0.0066635762,
-0.0234670434,
-0.0247359965,
-0.0041785915,
-0.019075945,
-0.0330897309,
-0.0199968535,
-0.0323128551,
-0.0055656699,
0.0919906497,
-0.044112429,
0.0116875647,
-0.0859216452,
0.0681983605,
-0.0090159271,
-0.0052539171,
0.0421176478,
0.0033427742,
-0.0341138765,
-0.01867087,
0.0179823581,
0.0174754523,
-0.0225216206,
-0.0699195042,
0.0434328131,
0.0526090935,
0.0091863563,
-0.0470711216,
0.0284697339,
0.0096174246,
0.0095172254,
-0.0298256241,
-0.0991054103,
0.0102231614,
0.0194803812,
-0.004022731,
0.0266247448,
0.0797902122,
0.0148705281,
0.0616377965,
0.0844650492,
-0.0502709635,
-0.0036895862,
-0.0056017549,
0.0251874067,
0.0542584285,
0.060214296,
0.028508937,
0.0634411275,
-0.0218062308,
-0.0969770104,
0.0570937693,
-0.0052187578,
0.0060281828,
-0.0224505868,
0.0191967096,
-0.0433588661,
0.0006233899,
-0.0180416722,
0.0105265025,
-0.0166025553,
-0.0003305028,
0.0115053486,
-0.001835577,
-0.0112569127,
-0.0214399416,
0.0366119482,
-0.0471716039,
0.0526396371,
0.0067529758,
-0.0012153414,
0.0125210285,
0.0336298682,
-0.0017737949,
-0.0225531477,
-0.026755752,
0.0346399322,
0.0189682748,
0.0067498214,
0.0009491748,
0.0011087899,
0.0817744434,
-0.0333743617,
-0.0261205491,
0.0055058086,
0.0147403032,
0.0124613326,
0.0480826795,
0.0387778506,
-0.0236867275,
0.0390740298,
0.0169000905,
0.0169637091,
-0.0172280353,
0.0007107727,
-0.0052230777,
0.0079932902,
0.0147482166,
-0.0097589698,
0.0470380001,
-0.0259561539,
0.0056766244,
0.0673731416,
-0.0214676484,
0.0279065184,
0.0026184884,
3.069e-7,
-0.1256228983,
-0.0371699855,
0.0303451326,
-0.0474665165,
0.013329058,
0.0122801866,
0.0430692062,
0.0492324457,
-0.0339374505,
-0.0117253028,
0.0117289349,
0.0055330936,
0.0461464077,
0.059870027,
-0.049329225,
-0.018723065,
-0.0427230597,
0.0145436423,
-0.0280072112,
0.0420685448,
-0.0168880671,
0.0733730122,
0.0297958571,
-0.0542295091,
0.0569599718,
-0.0138776321,
0.0198518373,
0.0236809701,
0.0008801233,
-0.0363061652,
0.0799328312,
0.0134929167,
0.0063530533,
0.0215058196,
-0.0104991021,
0.0746429265,
0.0190349631,
0.032049045,
-0.0248131361,
-0.0354298353,
-0.0405332483,
-0.0009229387,
-0.0471132249,
0.0144111849,
0.0707524121,
0.0136785237,
-0.0576746427,
-0.0445150137,
-0.0015407134,
0.0014655729,
0.0422810055,
0.0348565839,
0.0019059412,
-0.0100510046,
0.0074987318,
-0.1032387093,
-0.0348778889,
-0.0915734768,
-0.0042051845,
0.0312876776,
-0.0447947048,
-0.0117615676,
-0.0058919955,
-0.0390036888,
0.0417670868,
0.0140171843,
-0.0474504903,
2.286356257e-34,
-0.0467240512,
-0.0060885171,
0.0045413044,
-0.0243897103,
-0.0132923517,
-0.023604583,
-0.0235407278,
-0.0137280505,
0.0002762973,
-0.0469455756,
-0.0094360616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16877v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16877v1 | Large Language Model Augmented Exercise Retrieval for Personalized Language Learning | 2024-02-08T20:35:31 | 2024-02-08T20:35:31 | Austin Xu, Will Monroe, Klinton Bicknell | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | We study the problem of zero-shot exercise retrieval in the context of online
language learning, to give learners the ability to explicitly request
personalized exercises via natural language. Using real-world data collected
from language learners, we observe that vector similarity approaches poorly
capture the relationship between exercise content and the language that
learners use to express what they want to learn. This semantic gap between
queries and content dramatically reduces the effectiveness of general-purpose
retrieval models pretrained on large scale information retrieval datasets like
MS MARCO. We leverage the generative capabilities of large language models to
bridge the gap by synthesizing hypothetical exercises based on the learner's
input, which are then used to search for relevant exercises. Our approach,
which we call mHyER, overcomes three challenges: (1) lack of relevance labels
for training, (2) unrestricted learner input content, and (3) low semantic
similarity between input and retrieval candidates. mHyER outperforms several
strong baselines on two novel benchmarks created from crowdsourced data and
publicly available data. | [
0.0400302485,
0.0331139676,
-0.0082893455,
0.0260897242,
-0.0076947976,
-0.0113694202,
0.0082199397,
0.0252652057,
0.0305949599,
-0.0471114777,
-0.039721325,
-0.0047019506,
-0.0658832118,
-0.0506614186,
0.0074100858,
-0.06218509,
0.0075429585,
-0.016852634,
0.0145912776,
-0.0137377512,
0.0256263558,
0.0100423777,
0.0050888998,
0.0389902107,
0.0347956456,
0.0137747312,
-0.0134523809,
0.0161145255,
-0.0337472856,
-0.0550025925,
0.0134884398,
0.0288398787,
0.0418642163,
-0.0126368068,
0.0000018638,
-0.0374169759,
-0.0413158275,
0.0069070347,
-0.0196241792,
-0.0107347071,
0.052056171,
0.0719634742,
0.0391254872,
-0.0058183908,
-0.0450321995,
-0.0098237554,
0.0373859182,
-0.0015807495,
0.0761651471,
0.095200412,
0.0135291023,
0.0248529408,
-0.0210091528,
0.0082142754,
0.0932709053,
-0.0269939341,
0.0107684163,
0.0273410566,
0.0712672397,
0.0793582425,
-0.0148087405,
-0.0022627639,
-0.0020710018,
0.0339726731,
0.0095583415,
0.0094213597,
-0.0147870332,
0.0308798552,
0.0390183963,
0.0521227904,
-0.0077636582,
-0.0055180872,
-0.003839968,
-0.0093366876,
0.0275903363,
0.0341548845,
-0.0717909634,
0.0326167494,
0.0099802967,
0.025187565,
-0.016484566,
0.0066608167,
0.010203056,
0.0251487102,
-0.0032278448,
0.0337446034,
0.023962874,
-0.033823818,
-0.0044657285,
-0.0073681581,
-0.0186588764,
-0.008641555,
-0.0103220167,
0.0181927048,
-0.0272144303,
0.0086938823,
-0.016780708,
-0.0504029244,
0.0351491682,
-0.0283629913,
0.071133323,
0.0239342097,
0.0131511297,
0.0349486805,
0.0211915132,
0.0292755086,
0.0205623731,
0.0246848408,
-0.1100603417,
-0.0043182033,
-0.083660081,
0.0060674101,
-0.0834833011,
0.0846273974,
-0.0459102318,
-0.005448706,
-0.0562860519,
0.0161982253,
-0.0076329345,
-0.017758511,
-0.0012775594,
0.0269533265,
-0.0384593233,
-0.0136793535,
-0.048381649,
-0.0135071566,
-0.0428532809,
0.0093814461,
-0.0079815937,
-0.0523444414,
0.0177119244,
0.0066178227,
0.016842708,
-0.0643758252,
0.0585231446,
-0.0002893766,
-0.010331817,
-0.0756503567,
-0.0220601819,
-0.0265095923,
0.000047762,
-0.0372349098,
-0.0077438145,
-0.0746907294,
0.0234106146,
-0.0321362801,
0.0088947061,
-0.0157866217,
0.015766602,
0.0591654889,
-0.0306274351,
0.0717774183,
0.0442602374,
0.0157074016,
0.0286563132,
0.006949977,
0.0387957133,
0.0658017471,
0.0084217731,
-0.0207204018,
0.0610276423,
-0.0047752848,
-0.0114194555,
0.0157576166,
0.0267511606,
0.0076021557,
-0.0027091568,
0.0349424072,
0.0170868766,
0.040581584,
-0.0177651457,
0.0294161998,
-0.0395276211,
-0.0048109377,
0.0556341782,
0.0774830729,
-0.0029387011,
-0.0080045871,
0.0260789637,
0.0373748876,
-0.0154183088,
-0.034191139,
-0.0338619091,
-0.0078049814,
-0.0162758529,
0.0038468491,
0.0458190069,
-0.0001090787,
-0.0469729416,
-0.0456242636,
-0.0054529384,
-0.0170743875,
0.0211946145,
0.0508486256,
0.0831240788,
0.0086171497,
-0.0126354899,
0.0682587549,
0.0245320145,
-0.0688679516,
0.0473761521,
-0.0256206617,
0.0058733667,
0.0201443937,
0.0538596101,
-0.0567429289,
-0.0204256661,
0.018253509,
0.0319095142,
0.0015717321,
0.0391175635,
-0.0073765158,
-0.0296853445,
-0.0615767315,
-0.0422343612,
-0.0074197203,
-0.0071973773,
-0.0448696017,
0.0214580502,
0.0167336315,
0.0144544877,
-0.0596467741,
-0.0655502081,
0.0368037745,
-0.0428980067,
-0.0553359464,
0.0234473813,
-0.0066591194,
-0.0047208993,
0.0333625935,
0.0124826645,
0.0200816691,
0.0331309177,
-0.0404300578,
-0.0299286228,
-0.0378188677,
-0.0031842382,
0.0161353517,
0.0509069264,
-0.0527781434,
0.0280741751,
0.0192914251,
-0.0020623263,
-0.0363117531,
-0.0073004239,
-0.0081573576,
0.0379818641,
-0.0405855663,
-0.000898512,
0.0245059226,
-0.0410959907,
-0.0481313691,
0.0313623063,
0.0351298042,
0.0585279763,
0.0474197492,
-0.0057865703,
0.0137670226,
-0.0876975283,
-0.0770526305,
0.0269802772,
-0.0139229586,
0.0378862731,
0.0518969968,
0.0274459105,
-0.0523802452,
-0.0042838319,
-0.0850493312,
0.0316952989,
0.0032605985,
0.0132545661,
0.0110758729,
0.0170040391,
-0.0102821756,
-0.0394305848,
-0.0569007508,
-0.0439627096,
-0.0180379637,
0.0438294299,
0.0012587832,
0.0134645849,
0.0207627174,
-0.0496226698,
-0.0196360201,
0.0013604155,
0.0308517087,
0.034449663,
0.0713705048,
-0.0096213138,
0.0274096914,
-0.0472995155,
0.0338056795,
0.0232130866,
-0.0262126774,
0.0134745687,
-0.0675517097,
0.0171397366,
0.038928885,
0.0311029088,
-0.0079362588,
0.0614561364,
-0.0122559201,
-0.0911401659,
0.0365067758,
-0.0724066943,
-0.0595779717,
-0.0518322662,
-0.0560902171,
0.0293720271,
0.0116546098,
0.0186290964,
-0.0152372038,
-0.0860766023,
0.0060280468,
-0.0288643725,
0.0452155583,
-0.0800433904,
0.0394955613,
0.0111135421,
-0.0002485024,
-0.0102549121,
-0.0193976369,
0.0533099696,
-0.0070566651,
-0.0245411582,
-0.03371346,
-0.008062141,
-0.0352921225,
0.0379528999,
0.003737815,
0.0416878276,
0.0021161821,
0.0268659517,
-0.0362693444,
0.0122198435,
0.0666169673,
-0.0730448961,
-0.005210422,
-0.0077084475,
0.0197589602,
0.0267329309,
-0.0354710147,
-0.0260444246,
-0.0093695158,
0.0041774423,
-0.0287286546,
-0.034204457,
-0.0015879694,
-0.0177051052,
-0.0349583887,
-0.0031857812,
-0.0191522799,
-0.0171970986,
-0.0211200379,
0.0059574014,
0.0467689112,
0.0663068071,
0.0105815306,
-0.0528268479,
-0.0266883448,
-0.0267510973,
0.0515398793,
0.0483742058,
-0.0149812587,
0.0081130052,
-0.0004689984,
0.0548348278,
-0.0664743781,
0.0081426827,
0.0613708086,
0.0315859765,
-0.0227225535,
-0.0525414534,
0.0774783865,
0.0281007607,
-0.0229282249,
-0.0185436234,
-0.0013340698,
0.0331455916,
0.0322600491,
0.0445241481,
-0.0720627904,
-0.0240515824,
-0.0111156991,
0.0620553717,
-0.018792076,
-0.0170989651,
0.0042117988,
-0.1527940333,
0.003944417,
0.0105761187,
-0.0334686935,
-0.0118322549,
-0.0489865318,
-0.0210888498,
-0.0311575327,
-0.0123401079,
-0.0021461511,
-0.0237928554,
0.0532801785,
-0.0041845622,
0.0029671628,
-0.0461304449,
0.0178879872,
-0.0262138434,
0.0477057695,
0.0220853984,
-0.00522264,
-0.0179210287,
-0.0648334473,
0.0194353592,
-0.0325613543,
-0.0410854407,
-0.019626148,
0.0675116256,
-0.0097712092,
0.0053549837,
-0.0350744724,
0.0679253638,
-0.0140677169,
-0.0208857078,
0.0207483843,
0.0950101763,
0.0152717791,
0.0199337006,
-0.0557792708,
-0.019501036,
0.019935539,
0.0933158472,
0.0083367089,
-0.0662157312,
0.0208715312,
-0.0298108608,
0.0232962538,
-0.0219002739,
-0.0594082437,
0.0293209516,
-0.0209689606,
0.0607148893,
-0.0500770509,
-0.0594475418,
0.0274301395,
0.0183306374,
-0.0199117176,
0.0260364618,
-0.0008018225,
0.001148785,
-0.0535450727,
0.0754457563,
-0.0280953851,
-0.011643297,
-0.0578555316,
-0.0409145765,
0.02509843,
-0.0334422737,
-0.0180569477,
-0.0200350899,
-0.0680349246,
-0.0288887341,
-0.0347920544,
0.062626496,
0.0096762208,
0.0439592749,
0.003416779,
-0.0407213196,
-0.003447924,
0.0340549685,
-0.0561445914,
-0.0141160749,
0.0011226668,
0.0044714264,
0.0191691518,
0.0255757645,
-0.0356799364,
-0.0000315427,
0.0252021868,
0.0650014207,
-0.0461156219,
-0.0439326465,
0.060234528,
0.0240080822,
0.04038449,
0.0216416288,
-0.0261533372,
-0.0386595204,
0.0003802753,
0.0006450643,
-0.0406779423,
-0.050757546,
-0.0354247577,
0.023442708,
-0.0116741266,
-0.0020323263,
0.0276071094,
-0.0261728764,
0.068259865,
-0.022758089,
0.0189176295,
0.0109585598,
0.0101698739,
0.0173959006,
0.0037934128,
0.0218379162,
0.0138602359,
-0.025996631,
0.0306798164,
-0.0272646658,
0.054885406,
0.0117898546,
-0.0080161579,
-0.0082600387,
-0.0224416777,
-0.0104236156,
-0.0145033281,
-0.0089223171,
0.0262627658,
0.0236916393,
-0.0338961408,
-0.0074051535,
0.0124987541,
-0.0163039602,
-0.0068753618,
0.0138280392,
-0.0205423869,
-0.0366947986,
0.0387702584,
0.0384273902,
0.0192911066,
0.0155185154,
0.0504020825,
-0.0112236869,
0.0501672402,
0.0046284832,
-0.042243544,
-0.0271741021,
-0.0173992142,
0.0646401495,
0.0585215203,
-0.0385908224,
-0.0206070375,
-0.0383152254,
-0.0401337184,
-0.0049303006,
0.0201336201,
-0.0372868516,
0.0124006923,
0.074868165,
0.0399151631,
-0.0733027458,
-0.0369293205,
-0.0402960368,
0.0284347907,
-0.0152586205,
-0.0325261019,
-0.0275504142,
-5.545016972e-33,
-0.0037648301,
-0.012921338,
0.0659034327,
0.0061401622,
0.0014411189,
0.0002057028,
-0.0241838116,
0.0127964653,
0.0008788235,
-0.0057104067,
0.0117470557,
-0.0251311548,
-0.0195768457,
0.0407590829,
0.0261034276,
0.0119622601,
0.0359049626,
-0.0248204526,
-0.0021633764,
0.0193607975,
0.0212520324,
0.0193158239,
0.0289559942,
-0.0520758554,
0.0365481861,
-0.0384524986,
0.0144389719,
0.0365884267,
0.0243576895,
0.0735188052,
-0.0190493613,
0.036579974,
0.0044284342,
-0.0391388796,
0.0118890516,
-0.0365635939,
-0.0324879177,
-0.0427906737,
-0.0281667113,
-0.0134471441,
-0.0401445478,
-0.0181627758,
0.0338547789,
-0.0085226782,
-0.0249736737,
-0.0113236904,
0.0713914558,
-0.0031781842,
-0.0098315729,
0.0081805866,
0.0023848352,
0.0037994273,
-0.0248030815,
0.0109838909,
0.0339177549,
0.0132588269,
-0.0088597778,
0.0306937788,
-0.0185788739,
0.0637498796,
-0.0047231708,
0.0506826602,
0.008053232,
-0.0012756984,
-0.0128813107,
0.0232594945,
0.020102527,
-0.0176291876,
0.0160598606,
0.0183357187,
0.0690011382,
0.0299532153,
0.0320019089,
0.0775540844,
0.0403879993,
0.0445788801,
-0.0360529833,
0.0505504161,
-0.0150753949,
0.0019667833,
-0.0084956819,
0.0126604373,
-0.0316157527,
0.0011489228,
-0.0444485247,
0.0006097087,
-0.0636686087,
-0.0215434767,
0.0561910085,
0.0179896448,
-0.0295520686,
-0.0324423164,
0.0161406454,
-0.01525818,
-0.0541038848,
0.0073061986,
0.0100105135,
-0.0042658313,
-0.01950524,
0.0150915077,
-0.0550400168,
-0.032283742,
0.0020252266,
-0.0609770976,
-0.0317219347,
0.0213293359,
0.0160945822,
0.0214204732,
-0.0510180928,
-0.0028692945,
0.0013766602,
-0.0488965623,
-0.0070115048,
-0.0110904854,
0.0244210102,
0.0544883721,
-0.0254128762,
0.116990529,
0.0239555761,
-0.0225879885,
-0.0577659532,
-0.0566114932,
0.0317613855,
-0.038526427,
0.0193440411,
0.0225516576,
-0.0469143577,
0.0414224938,
0.0295055322,
-0.0377164818,
0.004092026,
0.0200385097,
2.5e-7,
0.0297081489,
0.0252937712,
-0.0360434353,
0.0253373813,
-0.0453554727,
0.0419494659,
-0.002183866,
0.0176464487,
0.0280688927,
0.0421677046,
0.0156098465,
0.0509485118,
-0.0093321251,
0.0309263039,
-0.0627174899,
0.0170079768,
-0.0123628769,
-0.0061488762,
-0.0646476373,
-0.0051408838,
0.057471659,
0.0543061048,
0.0497559644,
0.0226876624,
0.0064737126,
-0.071241729,
0.0733015761,
-0.034449812,
-0.0243086033,
0.0362398811,
0.0139595447,
0.0217457525,
-0.0024973135,
-0.0460235849,
-0.0191187896,
-0.0112738488,
0.0237956289,
0.0472475737,
0.0105212564,
-0.0288758129,
0.0012604137,
0.0127767827,
-0.0421962366,
-0.0278938357,
0.0424463712,
-0.0533007123,
0.0099002654,
-0.0124997059,
-0.0465657748,
-0.0084125372,
0.0078423396,
-0.0263779555,
-0.0219808556,
0.0094376411,
0.0202593207,
-0.0023402011,
0.0028368903,
-0.0534499921,
-0.0143848257,
-0.0296991616,
-0.0527671389,
0.0223599207,
-0.0664402246,
0.0461415276,
-0.0381151959,
-0.0525391959,
0.0186619274,
2.009378793e-34,
-0.0200576317,
0.0335589088,
0.0286097359,
-0.0063141775,
0.0033549699,
0.0176654961,
-0.0091032833,
0.0241265539,
0.0366305783,
-0.0916454643,
-0.029187208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06044v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06044v3 | OpenToM: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Theory-of-Mind Reasoning Capabilities of Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T20:35:06 | 2024-06-03T10:48:16 | Hainiu Xu, Runcong Zhao, Lixing Zhu, Jinhua Du, Yulan He | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Neural Theory-of-Mind (N-ToM), machine's ability to understand and keep track
of the mental states of others, is pivotal in developing socially intelligent
agents. However, prevalent N-ToM benchmarks have several shortcomings,
including the presence of ambiguous and artificial narratives, absence of
personality traits and preferences, a lack of questions addressing characters'
psychological mental states, and limited diversity in the questions posed. In
response to these issues, we construct OpenToM, a new benchmark for assessing
N-ToM with (1) longer and clearer narrative stories, (2) characters with
explicit personality traits, (3) actions that are triggered by character
intentions, and (4) questions designed to challenge LLMs' capabilities of
modeling characters' mental states of both the physical and psychological
world. Using OpenToM, we reveal that state-of-the-art LLMs thrive at modeling
certain aspects of mental states in the physical world but fall short when
tracking characters' mental states in the psychological world. | [
0.0213427749,
0.0597741157,
-0.0316323191,
0.0581031963,
-0.035395626,
0.0253698807,
0.0020961172,
0.0015430485,
0.0477857329,
0.0031283929,
-0.0344619229,
-0.0472950339,
0.0173438732,
0.0346462838,
0.0358524583,
-0.0183436312,
0.0148313912,
-0.0151907494,
0.0226767473,
-0.0006642272,
-0.0414682627,
0.0543946587,
-0.0224935915,
0.0192260724,
0.0176652763,
-0.0151176387,
-0.0356497951,
-0.0082408609,
0.0594195761,
-0.0547802225,
-0.0140332496,
0.0018968299,
0.0235459618,
0.0270365663,
0.0000020109,
-0.0760532245,
0.0077951537,
-0.0003201419,
0.0143408198,
-0.0148402154,
0.0421900712,
0.031632591,
0.0276573617,
0.0126988441,
-0.0422518551,
0.0295570642,
0.0014681,
0.0783484504,
0.028139824,
0.0778930932,
-0.0149970818,
-0.0167623814,
0.0045338031,
-0.0225065146,
0.0260044169,
-0.0496149026,
-0.0048902244,
-0.0572936125,
0.0390012041,
-0.0540636405,
-0.0009066325,
0.0045812721,
0.009251019,
0.0142493257,
-0.0202025231,
0.0361982659,
0.0071556913,
0.0157346092,
-0.0155605879,
0.10898678,
0.0689236894,
0.0372423083,
-0.0044245096,
0.0063706799,
0.0151845785,
-0.0013439934,
-0.003814118,
0.0286639687,
-0.0093257809,
0.0149727724,
0.0171949398,
0.0250640083,
0.0182246603,
0.0242766105,
-0.0368774608,
0.0677404329,
-0.0098231044,
-0.0084947003,
0.0171850063,
-0.0177937392,
-0.0117222825,
-0.0529116578,
-0.0141774574,
0.055148907,
-0.0259979311,
0.0085952953,
-0.0194430389,
0.033835806,
-0.0194804613,
-0.0587348491,
0.0786268935,
0.0445410758,
-0.0179087594,
0.0257433876,
0.0289161336,
0.051437933,
-0.0063177948,
0.0522906035,
-0.0215947498,
0.0132989408,
-0.0336812176,
0.0056551546,
-0.0259242803,
0.0584168881,
0.0120053086,
-0.024642257,
-0.0030171222,
-0.0003215302,
-0.0182628073,
-0.0220343992,
-0.0173932407,
0.0315189511,
0.0094196266,
-0.004212806,
-0.0792777315,
0.0117592542,
-0.0549806394,
-0.0032478282,
0.0197602883,
-0.0231931526,
-0.0121742822,
-0.0294848867,
0.0236296151,
-0.007335708,
0.0345672145,
0.0805318207,
0.0146510378,
-0.0494743772,
-0.0553929694,
-0.0291975792,
-0.0120698456,
-0.0920991227,
-0.0066122739,
-0.0100701423,
0.0260340311,
-0.0156101761,
-0.0193035956,
-0.0510567129,
0.0185347088,
0.0087206857,
-0.0466116443,
0.0584424287,
-0.0093733324,
-0.0210701078,
-0.014047672,
0.0305146705,
0.0147901466,
0.0075196545,
0.0487731956,
0.0076538986,
0.0013578823,
0.0351626351,
0.0177574176,
0.0234550294,
-0.0178383086,
-0.0222792774,
-0.0316498093,
-0.0014415865,
0.0012513135,
0.0846275389,
0.0209615342,
0.0620209984,
-0.0230137091,
-0.0251708664,
0.0622716062,
0.0960334539,
-0.0111923851,
-0.0171702001,
0.0487883165,
0.0328357741,
0.0226398371,
0.0004718399,
-0.0641509891,
0.0507801771,
-0.0317140222,
-0.0439272039,
-0.0154553289,
0.0186838992,
-0.0223094132,
-0.0059890244,
-0.0258154329,
0.0001631462,
0.0359949805,
0.0021323154,
0.0006966387,
-0.0409414321,
-0.0179570094,
0.0273181926,
0.0303457435,
-0.0409070514,
-0.0130582144,
-0.0720540211,
0.021460101,
0.0568090118,
0.0409726575,
-0.026074715,
-0.0716297925,
-0.0237128939,
-0.0389330275,
0.0571125299,
0.0508212484,
-0.0131292371,
0.0198739022,
-0.0439212285,
0.0341719724,
-0.0420029871,
0.0076029697,
0.0507472195,
-0.0385038853,
0.0259105265,
-0.0122182276,
-0.003995216,
0.004562329,
0.0175846145,
-0.0412955135,
-0.0202887449,
-0.0554121956,
0.0234916881,
0.044545304,
0.0239300281,
-0.0041972133,
-0.0222280845,
0.0110250385,
-0.0030701575,
-0.0143444799,
0.0313329808,
-0.0254431963,
-0.0001354257,
0.0570090003,
-0.0285808221,
-0.060701821,
0.0863784924,
-0.0066231373,
-0.0133014899,
-0.0033000645,
-0.0544843785,
0.0220054742,
-0.0260541979,
0.00262679,
-0.031500943,
0.0157126728,
-0.0134183979,
0.0547934882,
-0.030601589,
-0.0087348437,
0.0289469268,
-0.0295519643,
0.0414680429,
-0.0306269545,
-0.0237490311,
0.0215020515,
0.0223896839,
-0.0020637242,
0.0010896748,
0.0034475443,
-0.0544863306,
-0.0535127223,
-0.0798957497,
-0.0177872349,
0.0220717583,
-0.0228497908,
0.0145214926,
-0.0142654004,
-0.0325193107,
0.0357572995,
-0.0579702631,
0.0594749525,
0.0239705611,
-0.0169222262,
0.0500190705,
-0.0102704847,
-0.0229146387,
-0.0287393462,
0.0348577164,
-0.0662326887,
0.0240385998,
-0.0065614106,
0.0197891742,
-0.026795581,
0.0452888831,
-0.0829573125,
0.0310749002,
-0.0330523141,
-0.0718742833,
0.0556293055,
-0.0219271611,
-0.0088414997,
0.0869079009,
-0.0057011219,
0.0064533711,
0.0678274706,
-0.0302802864,
-0.0424477793,
0.0383369476,
0.0362045728,
0.0259072352,
-0.0648387,
-0.0536289439,
-0.0026177722,
0.0667048767,
0.0075450097,
0.0034677361,
-0.0657316521,
0.0252033826,
0.0104727885,
-0.0330015235,
0.0158914682,
0.0214401148,
-0.0264821146,
0.039870277,
0.0016837318,
-0.0147214737,
0.0898105204,
-0.0340834595,
0.0064465138,
-0.0375145525,
0.0161296558,
-0.0613285042,
0.1019351408,
0.0052174092,
0.0297056492,
0.0579720475,
-0.0169549976,
-0.065302521,
-0.0373559371,
-0.0307472255,
-0.0154524846,
0.0118882386,
-0.0253416225,
-0.0178048313,
0.0203702394,
0.0074910764,
-0.0269499049,
-0.0376319699,
-0.0692419186,
-0.0052758302,
-0.0088915965,
-0.0429276302,
-0.0271581579,
-0.034089569,
0.0239574555,
-0.0074194609,
-0.0057927375,
-0.0260587335,
-0.0194640309,
-0.0084065944,
0.0526511297,
0.0357411616,
0.0366084278,
-0.0385040455,
0.0407491699,
0.0428443663,
-0.0352389067,
0.0373578705,
-0.0200746506,
0.0276959334,
0.0235019084,
0.0213383213,
0.0059952512,
0.024516819,
0.0748023763,
-0.0204096008,
-0.0060981535,
0.1427424699,
0.0269234069,
-0.0094070015,
0.0120010879,
-0.017639799,
0.0161174182,
0.0257207602,
0.0133686885,
-0.0224628914,
-0.0136515833,
0.0092086764,
0.0074277436,
-0.0211511739,
-0.0793621689,
-0.0242003277,
-0.0868827701,
0.0327673964,
-0.0111092879,
-0.0201427154,
-0.0125980042,
0.0170319099,
0.0249722414,
0.0042790677,
0.0038581633,
0.0147995641,
0.0301082395,
-0.0068601463,
-0.042254772,
-0.0209915657,
0.0042273798,
0.085684523,
-0.0611027256,
0.0856214687,
0.0089887371,
0.0879698321,
-0.0083568888,
-0.0498053841,
-0.000116435,
0.058703322,
0.0170167889,
-0.0110389395,
0.0511836149,
-0.0073552663,
-0.0011634335,
-0.0605172962,
0.0336252265,
-0.0177426059,
-0.0048450804,
-0.0303507838,
0.0681446642,
-0.0223193262,
-0.0219028909,
-0.003631141,
0.0507102646,
-0.0346973874,
0.081367068,
0.0059673805,
-0.0658027828,
-0.0018136823,
-0.0073391884,
-0.0403947905,
-0.0186185706,
-0.0457433835,
0.0052371351,
0.0075493725,
-0.0038057764,
-0.0522779338,
-0.083809115,
0.0164559223,
0.0264852662,
0.0155590847,
-0.0423957147,
0.0251769647,
0.0134585472,
-0.0093317255,
0.017564429,
-0.0445666984,
0.0123902364,
-0.0051285974,
0.0238318183,
0.0482085645,
-0.0501973405,
-0.0015501168,
0.0077755991,
-0.0319458954,
-0.0694448501,
0.0085551664,
0.0177348424,
0.0257668644,
0.0197079778,
0.0026648634,
-0.0438515358,
0.0365429446,
-0.052745007,
-0.0254199803,
0.0757430941,
-0.0046893745,
0.0735368878,
0.0002837513,
0.0477089062,
-0.0218405966,
-0.002508458,
-0.0144323632,
-0.0080398321,
-0.005141777,
-0.0176190287,
0.0125298565,
0.0174204987,
-0.0069752471,
0.0114180557,
0.0024198988,
-0.0482105576,
-0.0230508447,
-0.0451516435,
0.0029376328,
-0.0558289662,
-0.0184447691,
0.0598192401,
0.0356989317,
-0.0437925607,
-0.0868281499,
-0.0383342765,
0.0253788736,
-0.0078150742,
-0.0203302521,
0.0054187845,
0.0237384755,
-0.0109138889,
0.021597214,
-0.0248005297,
-0.0099071702,
-0.0749417618,
0.0401787497,
0.002474952,
0.0963962376,
0.0288034752,
-0.0127570983,
-0.0155660454,
0.0306664761,
-0.0598136261,
-0.0700273663,
0.0574251488,
-0.0055036913,
0.0011277063,
0.0125176888,
0.003520601,
-0.0395673625,
0.0245371945,
0.0353760347,
0.016903609,
0.0015703926,
-0.0138872126,
0.0003613081,
0.0101561714,
0.0016876291,
-0.0026965691,
0.0126031823,
-0.0232681781,
0.0404500663,
0.0209951568,
-0.0133702327,
-0.0408668704,
0.0168547705,
-0.0056173443,
0.0620475486,
0.0016353677,
0.0082265399,
-0.0923757032,
-0.0325093195,
0.0868072063,
0.0168276187,
-0.0196461547,
-0.0269440655,
0.0274275988,
0.0309209935,
0.0036138175,
-0.0168455169,
0.0070875771,
-0.0221099947,
-0.0289717242,
-0.0290021803,
0.0012556093,
-5.818545324e-33,
-0.0289405137,
0.0132977301,
0.0225535557,
0.0268737879,
-0.0882765651,
-0.0089297891,
-0.0560603067,
0.0092981625,
-0.0303915162,
0.0105287498,
-0.0113849947,
0.0437071398,
-0.0125404438,
-0.0113279326,
-0.0155022228,
-0.0331296772,
-0.0013088593,
-0.0287553295,
-0.0305718165,
-0.0116099557,
0.01578396,
0.0222515687,
0.0333271287,
-0.068862319,
0.0193711463,
0.0038395112,
-0.0094705559,
0.0140407085,
-0.0128674274,
-0.0066454983,
-0.017941555,
0.014930184,
0.0249368455,
-0.0037585956,
0.0241784714,
-0.0024092519,
-0.0242860951,
-0.0678065866,
0.0206594672,
-0.0286590699,
-0.0212051384,
-0.0540671498,
-0.0160908438,
-0.0153527176,
-0.0195382927,
-0.0399404205,
0.0268827397,
0.0054146145,
0.079933174,
0.047892794,
-0.0543866269,
-0.020771509,
-0.0152073931,
-0.0316904336,
-0.0309547186,
0.0236706845,
0.0034348173,
-0.0066177896,
-0.051058542,
0.0020498801,
0.0116922641,
-0.0297506917,
0.0088173635,
-0.0216508564,
-0.0086663179,
0.0896417052,
0.0852110833,
0.0259526782,
-0.0592062175,
0.0046954886,
0.0312635712,
0.0594517216,
0.052731365,
0.037982557,
-0.0154578062,
-0.0130219497,
-0.0670983046,
0.0281645358,
0.0305270571,
0.0216902401,
0.047998853,
-0.0156922136,
-0.0204897989,
-0.013563809,
-0.0474085547,
-0.0405634418,
-0.0307121556,
0.0030111566,
0.0102957999,
-0.0249256045,
0.0061002993,
-0.0748062134,
0.0376475044,
-0.0404120088,
0.0374319889,
0.004009801,
-0.0231760759,
0.0278386399,
0.0065857745,
0.0364985317,
-0.0281097833,
-0.0100114252,
-0.0081842449,
0.0282240435,
0.0734383389,
0.0079743154,
-0.0214627851,
0.0337336361,
-0.0083870087,
-0.0237658732,
-0.0422057286,
-0.0025022062,
-0.0122237345,
0.0024836431,
0.0012329808,
0.010720999,
-0.0176568907,
-0.0118366219,
-0.0210525431,
-0.0135875577,
-0.0497460328,
0.035613209,
0.0033293155,
-0.0143548939,
-0.0254645664,
0.0138529064,
-0.0085951742,
0.021853419,
0.0341373794,
-0.049387496,
-0.0015210011,
-0.0010157995,
2.79e-7,
-0.0241774637,
0.0495417118,
0.0066439845,
0.0127248289,
0.0088297268,
0.0574046336,
-0.0238776263,
0.0500566103,
0.0061353245,
-0.0485363007,
-0.0109044649,
0.0491446927,
0.0506423078,
0.0493101701,
-0.0677608848,
0.004642514,
0.0301244147,
-0.0435321182,
-0.0351118594,
-0.0019185706,
0.0625495762,
0.0238196366,
0.0515877046,
-0.0250516254,
0.0310568735,
-0.0253772121,
0.0357521921,
-0.0443378799,
0.0024504166,
0.0147214364,
0.018759843,
-0.0153430784,
-0.0032140566,
0.0045339842,
0.0469842926,
0.0333742388,
-0.017706193,
0.0122137219,
-0.0347409844,
-0.0657377094,
-0.0077615036,
-0.0164125916,
-0.0438076816,
-0.0397746526,
0.0586845204,
-0.0424751453,
-0.0883468613,
0.0208121315,
0.038099438,
-0.0159749333,
0.022181822,
0.0195636023,
-0.0011684647,
0.0115806945,
0.0028918663,
-0.0388425328,
0.0061397348,
-0.1027061865,
0.0137013216,
-0.0169456843,
-0.0083686486,
-0.0621825047,
-0.0267083216,
0.0003245009,
0.0411589183,
-0.0804097429,
0.0204446781,
2.245896752e-34,
-0.0003581176,
-0.0014829943,
0.0046403776,
0.0008911673,
0.0763001442,
0.012513102,
-0.006361851,
-0.0003972416,
0.0464587286,
-0.1210529357,
-0.0085850451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06041v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06041v1 | A Prompt Response to the Demand for Automatic Gender-Neutral Translation | 2024-02-08T20:24:44 | 2024-02-08T20:24:44 | Beatrice Savoldi, Andrea Piergentili, Dennis Fucci, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Gender-neutral translation (GNT) that avoids biased and undue binary
assumptions is a pivotal challenge for the creation of more inclusive
translation technologies. Advancements for this task in Machine Translation
(MT), however, are hindered by the lack of dedicated parallel data, which are
necessary to adapt MT systems to satisfy neutral constraints. For such a
scenario, large language models offer hitherto unforeseen possibilities, as
they come with the distinct advantage of being versatile in various (sub)tasks
when provided with explicit instructions. In this paper, we explore this
potential to automate GNT by comparing MT with the popular GPT-4 model. Through
extensive manual analyses, our study empirically reveals the inherent
limitations of current MT systems in generating GNTs and provides valuable
insights into the potential and challenges associated with prompting for
neutrality. | [
0.0437520072,
0.0600628629,
-0.0227583218,
0.0273329467,
-0.0636029318,
0.0117943957,
0.0429753177,
-0.0339273438,
-0.0152685484,
-0.0644529909,
0.0188413169,
-0.0841965526,
0.0058047413,
-0.0003119397,
0.0010825536,
-0.0159839839,
0.0174410027,
0.0123098064,
-0.0115080159,
-0.0352298953,
0.0078697903,
0.0355110168,
0.0318380557,
0.0241452865,
0.0144640571,
0.0053437846,
0.0027902825,
0.0726017132,
0.0039532701,
0.0268891621,
0.0322283208,
0.0673518777,
-0.0119570261,
0.0596282333,
0.0000021798,
-0.0622964799,
-0.0248964746,
0.0311067291,
0.0222079679,
-0.0013666733,
0.0277509987,
-0.0457517356,
-0.0355005972,
0.0346646123,
-0.0169226751,
-0.0226935297,
0.0774295926,
-0.0147649217,
0.0494490489,
0.0343535207,
-0.0275531448,
0.003340557,
-0.054412704,
-0.0589940175,
-0.0336150303,
-0.0290402789,
0.0106894393,
-0.0562008806,
-0.0358496159,
0.0231453087,
-0.0088511808,
0.0547553711,
0.004687211,
-0.000128732,
-0.0318703912,
0.0021136452,
-0.0258658975,
-0.0591809452,
-0.0171790197,
0.0419259518,
-0.0038546873,
-0.0132077942,
0.0105753727,
-0.0218189564,
0.0013429283,
0.0052348902,
-0.0335451849,
0.0302624013,
-0.021113487,
-0.0103205135,
0.0115969107,
-0.007126248,
0.0200863704,
0.0225846041,
-0.0639350861,
0.0609358139,
0.0466393121,
-0.0678878129,
0.0144614521,
0.0223746337,
-0.0309137367,
-0.0266030747,
0.0486360081,
-0.0182031747,
0.0331275277,
0.0102256993,
-0.0091385692,
-0.0421579704,
0.0365704671,
-0.057614658,
0.0110972282,
0.0882705972,
0.019872779,
0.0177005008,
-0.0012490506,
0.0115968511,
-0.0236224663,
-0.0133884707,
-0.0546178333,
-0.027660517,
0.0085862642,
0.0095959203,
-0.0504355878,
-0.0333471633,
-0.0603910759,
0.0443567112,
0.004135021,
0.0118601248,
-0.0255901534,
-0.0046163909,
0.0613863952,
-0.0197031908,
-0.0634453148,
-0.0207698215,
0.0092157358,
0.0390424617,
-0.0411572419,
-0.0036672987,
-0.051383201,
-0.08604379,
-0.0301156621,
0.0161499884,
-0.0124026602,
-0.0344354697,
-0.0238200147,
0.0501840375,
-0.0165563338,
-0.0326796435,
0.0124361031,
0.0035231321,
-0.025034301,
-0.0832781419,
-0.0024964572,
-0.0609103814,
0.035538964,
0.0711473525,
0.0276876632,
-0.0338543393,
0.0006086999,
0.0148676746,
-0.0147246746,
0.0598203205,
0.0333557613,
0.0110692307,
0.045707766,
0.0037474886,
-0.0235587787,
0.0942665562,
0.0295117162,
-0.0010346732,
0.0249577146,
0.0218731724,
-0.0220805369,
0.0678520426,
0.0214129351,
0.0654485971,
-0.0252888128,
0.0282657258,
-0.0052839988,
0.0346125215,
0.0322291367,
0.0362229757,
0.029229736,
-0.0096263867,
0.0406683646,
0.0343594253,
-0.0140795065,
0.0603127293,
0.0687599108,
0.0082469247,
-0.0226809252,
0.0230298154,
-0.05550877,
0.0052162264,
-0.0167785455,
-0.0121807465,
0.0184140597,
0.0431987643,
-0.0047943871,
-0.0264974367,
0.0005388886,
-0.0022903665,
0.0503758192,
-0.0161014404,
0.0443050861,
-0.0071325991,
-0.0452426597,
0.0387505554,
-0.014717374,
-0.0934050977,
-0.0084348451,
-0.0390288085,
-0.0150252441,
0.0346692428,
0.0179496948,
-0.0232178941,
-0.0627000704,
-0.019512672,
-0.026375737,
0.071246095,
0.0807765946,
0.0458484143,
0.0085519096,
-0.0901192278,
-0.0229219086,
0.0592644699,
0.0353047997,
0.0462750718,
0.0361590162,
0.0516649708,
0.0690873861,
0.0167501643,
-0.0585593693,
0.0132635608,
-0.0061357087,
-0.0335379317,
0.0571712926,
0.0043029599,
0.0359524339,
0.0249825865,
-0.0176680163,
0.0082298378,
0.029004585,
-0.0239384435,
-0.0317001417,
0.0585800298,
-0.0215195939,
0.0263896734,
0.0137867546,
-0.0409284532,
-0.038615752,
0.0551869161,
-0.031687852,
-0.0447798483,
0.0321859978,
-0.0125339553,
-0.0184352547,
-0.0414597429,
0.0444468111,
0.0153682251,
-0.0069995625,
-0.0273417383,
0.0050635138,
-0.0177725647,
-0.0341983251,
0.0172741544,
-0.0423222594,
0.0280908179,
-0.0560774244,
-0.0490137748,
0.0469952375,
0.0465849377,
0.0223076176,
0.052078221,
0.0106134536,
0.0072302008,
-0.0393635482,
-0.0796563029,
0.0130524207,
-0.0249426495,
0.0272086151,
0.0270601194,
0.0600794926,
-0.0283920597,
0.0156693235,
-0.027254317,
0.0019584461,
0.0178139769,
0.0274359118,
0.0279678069,
-0.0288546458,
-0.0031417264,
-0.0055318242,
-0.0131859174,
-0.0256966334,
-0.0040547107,
0.061275091,
0.0137975486,
-0.0488052256,
-0.0117710959,
-0.0120711932,
-0.0073679881,
0.0131117599,
-0.0478271507,
-0.0063138166,
-0.0323037393,
0.0422258824,
0.0423816293,
-0.0043399781,
-0.005425381,
0.0446817242,
0.0072507709,
-0.0404748581,
0.024946453,
-0.0121110287,
-0.0254473146,
0.0514787994,
-0.098096028,
-0.0105851898,
0.0186859183,
0.0022011457,
-0.0520706773,
-0.0926953405,
0.0175665412,
-0.0356099866,
-0.0179244913,
-0.0032144943,
0.0022708504,
0.0172236525,
0.0304353423,
-0.0259902123,
-0.0487633012,
0.0397188067,
-0.0279771741,
-0.0273422971,
-0.0560492091,
0.0158616137,
-0.0613230616,
0.0569301434,
-0.0310522933,
0.0166092366,
-0.0120344795,
0.0135371508,
-0.033482451,
-0.0076800827,
0.0198887121,
-0.0136319334,
0.0538869202,
-0.0635790601,
0.0354202539,
-0.0329302587,
-0.0041237473,
-0.0195891671,
-0.0253257118,
0.0114695933,
0.0038636774,
0.0367110334,
-0.0124520008,
0.0015684288,
0.0645583719,
-0.0246373154,
0.0730433539,
-0.0292139277,
0.0112012178,
-0.0295649096,
-0.0147897862,
-0.0110883163,
-0.0197015647,
-0.0091975713,
-0.0246101394,
-0.0172581133,
0.0197840054,
-0.0230571963,
0.0176932905,
0.0067782775,
-0.0147567336,
0.0436876379,
-0.0380987674,
-0.0225032009,
-0.0560188554,
0.0079741394,
-0.0585026518,
0.0090361256,
0.1019326299,
0.0203238986,
-0.0905654207,
-0.0184392091,
-0.0096041244,
0.0142530072,
0.020380225,
0.0246106423,
-0.0680928305,
0.0024547232,
0.0332900733,
0.0363374688,
-0.005824598,
-0.0185961146,
-0.0369182751,
-0.0876758322,
0.0196084119,
0.0482404158,
-0.0475748479,
-0.0538515709,
-0.0042800526,
-0.0145817315,
-0.0561749488,
0.0033317746,
0.0161862634,
0.0156753659,
0.0075958711,
-0.0362377167,
0.0325986445,
-0.0364614204,
-0.0068775136,
-0.0670650303,
0.0266062412,
0.0392154939,
0.0465986617,
-0.0365282446,
-0.0017296432,
0.0354262814,
-0.0202292316,
-0.0390982926,
-0.0406576246,
-0.0234708171,
-0.0044389865,
-0.003263931,
-0.0092897927,
0.0237991419,
0.0141502637,
0.0555926636,
0.0519522876,
0.0309235603,
0.0155515494,
-0.0231979769,
-0.0228253677,
-0.006659931,
0.0543605983,
0.0791012943,
-0.0004734276,
-0.032174468,
-0.0407972336,
-0.0420890562,
-0.0024915261,
-0.041351907,
-0.0092713125,
-0.0467371009,
-0.0068260296,
-0.055146955,
-0.0483689867,
-0.0620505847,
0.0244459491,
0.0189165566,
0.0409509018,
-0.0347582996,
0.0143173067,
0.0228695683,
-0.0640345961,
0.0346984118,
-0.0041133524,
0.0275704563,
-0.0295520872,
-0.0311951861,
-0.0214304347,
-0.0346110463,
0.0004285854,
0.0715107471,
-0.0112737678,
-0.0753062814,
-0.0064666765,
0.0537008755,
0.0327666365,
0.0239081644,
-0.0263224263,
-0.0134130539,
-0.0210062768,
0.0545017868,
-0.0283210147,
0.0135838334,
0.0527914129,
0.0099886395,
-0.0085255615,
0.0621969849,
0.0022655178,
0.0051021148,
-0.0358698107,
0.0603841841,
0.0149222557,
-0.070845671,
0.0279952791,
0.0348889604,
-0.0138540156,
-0.0580417886,
-0.0013959748,
-0.038987916,
0.0232782308,
-0.0481920689,
-0.0210142378,
-0.0403934494,
0.0028431339,
0.0205690488,
0.0087962365,
-0.0248028841,
-0.0313666984,
-0.0499885082,
-0.0285523348,
-0.0065087308,
-0.0076657939,
-0.0293447785,
0.0576226003,
0.0095639313,
-0.0067875953,
-0.0137713049,
0.0032614756,
-0.0131512396,
0.0080163544,
-0.0284713339,
0.0381652936,
0.0058801686,
0.0416384563,
-0.024397824,
0.037492834,
-0.0136302337,
-0.0055733426,
-0.0194285288,
0.019537583,
0.0664121658,
-0.0197854079,
0.113224186,
-0.0306282993,
-0.0213683788,
-0.0058017955,
0.0037467447,
0.0428460278,
0.0372865684,
-0.0095155025,
0.0003338685,
0.0198754072,
0.0129896337,
0.0313013084,
0.0268368535,
0.0455876887,
-0.018183602,
-0.0330342762,
-0.0125183593,
-0.0573886968,
0.0211299285,
-0.0374328271,
-0.0326953344,
-0.0110952528,
-0.0871706381,
-0.0505091064,
-0.0297601297,
0.0105026038,
0.0247720014,
-0.0244496129,
-0.014457087,
0.0879554749,
-0.0429496765,
-0.036174491,
-0.0456061698,
0.0300497264,
-0.0161025263,
-0.0108632362,
-0.0506573617,
-6.660563315e-33,
-0.0191676691,
-0.0030623381,
-0.0043480811,
-0.0067846053,
-0.005020957,
-0.0277428329,
-0.0203376282,
-0.0245346725,
0.027356606,
0.0009076164,
-0.0149978865,
0.0134705342,
0.0238878001,
-0.0178430658,
0.0302256625,
0.0441649146,
0.0761138052,
0.0249532163,
-0.0389673226,
0.0032169144,
0.0099600283,
0.0020089014,
0.0335249528,
-0.0551462732,
0.1045196056,
-0.0505861752,
-0.0355626531,
0.0109830126,
-0.0801887065,
-0.0271532312,
0.0048840032,
0.0247685816,
0.0199739709,
-0.0073553286,
0.0068172053,
0.017937351,
-0.0667054132,
0.009431907,
0.0410495736,
0.0197373591,
-0.0029130683,
-0.0294208527,
0.0257597156,
-0.013061326,
-0.0548358001,
-0.0107624959,
-0.0031783353,
0.0141909206,
0.0482517518,
0.0314890482,
-0.0585804693,
0.0179982558,
-0.015031484,
-0.0075631291,
0.0352250449,
0.0448050126,
-0.0136809889,
-0.01137779,
-0.0452354774,
0.0330574661,
0.0282674544,
-0.0022309911,
0.0674787238,
-0.0163609888,
0.0086096264,
-0.0536174402,
0.0343012922,
0.0064137043,
-0.0233066734,
-0.0357960798,
0.017498821,
-0.070119746,
0.0527289622,
0.0271925535,
0.0665451139,
-0.0145205315,
-0.0471524857,
0.0091251573,
0.0181572102,
0.0116914343,
0.0128735723,
-0.0199350193,
-0.0782041922,
-0.0355370492,
-0.0277450588,
-0.0939681828,
-0.0322373882,
-0.0225342624,
0.0263839718,
0.0120229525,
-0.0899779722,
0.0289640874,
0.0324316546,
-0.0267222021,
0.0051555363,
0.0177839026,
-0.0037366599,
-0.0377878174,
0.016525941,
0.0550418273,
-0.0052313474,
0.0134528372,
-0.0010998762,
0.030428445,
-0.0061591719,
0.0149759268,
-0.0224445164,
0.0467520878,
-0.0606215149,
0.0000144616,
-0.0575002506,
0.0335185714,
-0.0185607821,
0.0232657399,
-0.0068762144,
0.0361693278,
0.030033974,
0.0197794475,
0.08521308,
0.0234386232,
-0.0603577904,
0.0279288199,
0.0034179441,
0.0265869182,
-0.0170284435,
0.0206142142,
0.0219091773,
0.0112877106,
0.0553967543,
-0.0445838608,
-0.0130569274,
-0.0255664513,
2.865e-7,
0.02279949,
0.0404636934,
0.0194299072,
0.0161629263,
0.0040056738,
0.0203763973,
-0.0218964741,
0.0403016768,
0.0373414606,
0.0763525888,
0.0090189893,
0.0426319204,
0.0185674727,
0.0277541876,
-0.0672746077,
-0.0028931701,
-0.0098882169,
0.0423618704,
-0.0392413288,
0.0260210335,
0.0419792198,
0.0553372465,
0.0152758239,
0.0131044853,
-0.0359322131,
-0.0106257685,
0.0461480431,
-0.0064124698,
0.0224445108,
0.0235001184,
0.0406730548,
0.0016679423,
-0.0315545388,
0.0138739916,
0.0242985003,
0.0076371878,
0.0214714985,
0.1068909541,
-0.0065407436,
0.0461398661,
0.0131772347,
-0.029352434,
-0.0128439832,
-0.0658983141,
0.0762922764,
-0.0099821817,
0.0069454359,
0.0290245358,
-0.0165856648,
0.0315668397,
0.0495887771,
-0.0328116789,
-0.0608578697,
0.0252691209,
0.0299316552,
-0.0039496562,
-0.0127906296,
-0.0449543595,
-0.0252181906,
-0.0505488068,
-0.0206152536,
-0.050638672,
-0.0123870084,
0.0553666577,
0.0174494907,
-0.0292378832,
0.015827762,
2.773510962e-34,
0.0393739492,
0.0114073036,
0.0059727286,
-0.0228222851,
0.0178059153,
-0.0208419804,
-0.0025574453,
0.0302517209,
0.0135508552,
-0.0156066194,
-0.0497894213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06025v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06025v6 | Doing Experiments and Revising Rules with Natural Language and Probabilistic Reasoning | 2024-02-08T19:57:29 | 2024-05-22T21:24:19 | Wasu Top Piriyakulkij, Cassidy Langenfeld, Tuan Anh Le, Kevin Ellis | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We give a model of how to infer natural language rules by doing experiments.
The model integrates Large Language Models (LLMs) with Monte Carlo algorithms
for probabilistic inference, interleaving online belief updates with experiment
design under information-theoretic criteria. We conduct a human-model
comparison on a Zendo-style task, finding that a critical ingredient for
modeling the human data is to assume that humans also consider fuzzy,
probabilistic rules, in addition to assuming that humans perform
approximately-Bayesian belief updates. We also compare with recent algorithms
for using LLMs to generate and revise hypotheses, finding that our online
inference method yields higher accuracy at recovering the true underlying rule,
and provides better support for designing optimal experiments. | [
0.0496108048,
0.0765365884,
-0.0236648079,
0.0154339047,
-0.0854394436,
-0.0196339935,
0.0011443932,
0.0245932303,
0.0065350463,
-0.0619620048,
0.0257027466,
-0.0457773693,
0.0223480705,
0.0148171913,
0.0135833947,
-0.0484724678,
-0.0027066353,
-0.0503602475,
0.0713283792,
0.0025712217,
0.0068788151,
-0.0152282389,
-0.031154599,
0.0191272739,
0.0257838182,
0.0317043476,
-0.0104942527,
-0.0476008356,
-0.0238681622,
-0.0027864375,
-0.0201062374,
0.0574979,
0.0173078496,
0.0251059663,
0.0000017058,
-0.0725777745,
0.0016746114,
-0.0025120112,
0.0070451684,
0.0205869433,
0.0374690108,
0.0143543519,
0.0020080411,
0.0271732807,
-0.0201019328,
0.0094019314,
0.0541499779,
0.0189877246,
0.0219352115,
0.0489013493,
0.0080887489,
-0.0337639898,
0.0062795673,
0.0190765671,
0.0618649609,
-0.050087288,
0.0646491721,
0.036443416,
0.0208040643,
-0.0353269801,
-0.0007316475,
-0.0050779283,
0.0078786444,
-0.0139295161,
-0.0220405012,
0.0283614546,
-0.0123931915,
0.0057051885,
-0.00604368,
0.034166038,
-0.0193446986,
-0.0162049439,
0.0073780054,
-0.0012010662,
-0.0204159226,
0.0533969216,
-0.0413660258,
0.0702461526,
-0.0496671833,
0.0259503685,
0.0306554977,
-0.0133016473,
0.0442246944,
0.0438243113,
-0.0337361135,
0.1105251163,
0.0028704042,
-0.0112812575,
-0.0185663048,
0.0063872649,
-0.0251122098,
-0.0809952691,
0.0195229333,
0.0023284969,
-0.022709284,
0.0232810751,
-0.0079392558,
0.0219274946,
0.0262936112,
-0.0178404674,
0.0390361585,
0.0318573117,
0.0578231961,
0.0476705097,
-0.0017657515,
-0.0080435472,
0.0067201336,
-0.0310311653,
-0.016703913,
0.0215446912,
-0.0735171586,
0.0112670725,
0.0119489506,
0.0370368063,
-0.0178416967,
-0.0172385443,
-0.0364971124,
0.0182031151,
-0.0036834078,
0.0035978484,
-0.0205206908,
-0.0339527838,
-0.0264130533,
-0.0137010394,
-0.0889258012,
-0.0227911863,
-0.0255115591,
0.0536169745,
0.0082351929,
-0.0259254333,
0.0126646003,
-0.0264104065,
-0.0029147938,
0.0076785567,
0.0010935805,
0.0671092793,
0.0083554657,
-0.0266428422,
-0.0269548129,
-0.0693801418,
-0.0282408912,
-0.0306254197,
0.0057515092,
-0.0763055831,
0.0007392447,
-0.0126664331,
-0.0012162116,
-0.0234867781,
0.0100125028,
0.0284093358,
-0.0531147532,
0.1087836847,
-0.009905247,
-0.0014502216,
0.0068580406,
-0.0152302105,
-0.0228701085,
0.0514647961,
0.0221883189,
-0.004538612,
0.028441513,
0.0423886329,
0.0578959957,
0.0361546092,
-0.0016673892,
0.0022377409,
0.0074823522,
-0.0228321888,
0.0014236192,
0.0534874164,
0.0013091118,
0.0526062772,
-0.0565334074,
0.0338761285,
0.0923168361,
0.0300695598,
0.002447143,
-0.0189028997,
0.0403601974,
-0.0029444622,
0.0345125496,
-0.0045051589,
-0.0569527484,
-0.0123973871,
-0.0453591123,
0.0341872424,
0.0158185903,
0.02185449,
-0.0054141199,
-0.0636491925,
-0.0150007969,
-0.0065502776,
0.0041834475,
-0.0013936954,
0.0897313133,
-0.0214287806,
0.0197978187,
-0.0224426668,
0.0384913161,
0.0000837696,
-0.0073218541,
-0.0686207265,
0.0679973885,
0.0892465562,
0.0660085678,
-0.0359841362,
0.031196855,
-0.010812046,
0.0046535474,
0.0057117171,
0.0212466959,
0.0053672772,
-0.0050961347,
-0.0271307826,
-0.0068033338,
0.0214724168,
0.0328658782,
-0.0094122998,
0.0366116166,
-0.0313711204,
-0.0112304026,
-0.0211934112,
-0.0023904771,
0.0485897437,
0.0281632915,
0.0177027602,
0.0047879415,
-0.0452912189,
0.0378110521,
-0.0220763907,
-0.0248221066,
0.0345831588,
0.0069123427,
0.0133487182,
-0.0419539325,
-0.0010026467,
0.0333424695,
-0.0526493043,
0.0461338535,
-0.0383698903,
-0.0070503028,
-0.0668235123,
-0.0187153798,
0.0043964372,
-0.0166592486,
-0.0457594879,
0.0337202325,
-0.0416106731,
0.0128789926,
0.014570279,
-0.0345769674,
-0.0351168625,
0.0438443758,
0.0036347411,
0.0096421586,
0.019564053,
-0.0418325476,
-0.0015828478,
-0.0670355186,
0.0102547528,
0.0017619892,
-0.010307678,
-0.0115507497,
0.0497739278,
0.0032534902,
-0.0157226175,
-0.013535399,
-0.0401849039,
0.0013083211,
0.0112828882,
0.0134268533,
-0.0252884366,
-0.0192641914,
-0.0325612091,
-0.0098382989,
0.017748449,
-0.0101705436,
-0.0192997791,
0.0474636629,
0.0277008098,
-0.0224070977,
-0.043208316,
-0.0260956064,
-0.0219038948,
-0.0254070181,
0.0422615334,
0.0376752429,
-0.0052604917,
-0.1052820832,
-0.0173895396,
-0.0554415919,
0.0241105855,
0.0054509351,
-0.0053826733,
0.0205592494,
-0.0137994848,
0.0508766733,
0.0588962436,
-0.0112460433,
-0.0070761102,
0.1009309068,
-0.0224093292,
-0.0243229512,
-0.0279237926,
-0.0283329468,
-0.0394669101,
-0.018087972,
-0.0652035177,
-0.002013257,
0.0069033196,
0.0017320254,
-0.0204755776,
-0.0377579741,
0.0773663744,
-0.0078816637,
-0.0474383496,
-0.036869254,
-0.0354194157,
-0.0061838524,
0.0499855652,
-0.0029746967,
-0.0660812035,
0.0893383697,
0.0121411169,
0.0370084979,
-0.0814216137,
0.022741124,
0.0093815681,
0.0391522758,
0.0336867683,
0.0343548581,
0.035922803,
0.0106906593,
-0.0099646645,
0.0029630503,
0.0536611006,
-0.0291085448,
-0.0115355384,
-0.1569054276,
0.0261649415,
0.0383499227,
-0.029060768,
-0.0222174972,
-0.0391570963,
-0.0530993156,
-0.0245601051,
0.0124963084,
-0.0083769159,
-0.001821116,
0.0136007452,
0.0369685665,
0.0111925034,
0.0150597459,
-0.046302475,
-0.0158132557,
-0.0093875816,
0.0394181162,
-0.0216420628,
0.0024100887,
-0.0030430844,
-0.0132803628,
0.0537498184,
0.0376188159,
0.0205080565,
-0.0167621989,
0.0143961161,
0.0004297891,
-0.0321703777,
-0.0029611106,
0.0920033827,
0.0136407353,
-0.0261002537,
0.0080576129,
0.1037479714,
0.051378198,
-0.0077571142,
0.0094639957,
-0.0082384562,
-0.048925437,
-0.0251472797,
0.0364096314,
-0.0927314982,
-0.041260317,
0.0423578769,
0.0015373848,
-0.0536910556,
-0.0639040843,
0.0046065003,
-0.0972755849,
0.0185779557,
0.0006017697,
-0.0046678539,
-0.016729854,
-0.0981159583,
0.0141796814,
-0.0405014083,
-0.0287966896,
0.0240891781,
0.0072976775,
0.0352855064,
-0.0215315316,
-0.0335041508,
-0.0447138213,
0.0232585259,
-0.0589743629,
0.0713926554,
0.0438255481,
-0.0057794848,
0.0103922365,
-0.0270051062,
-0.0063313041,
0.0212611426,
0.0037833885,
-0.0245683938,
0.0350236669,
0.0372455455,
0.0241184104,
-0.0625345558,
0.0595061518,
-0.019801084,
-0.0528940372,
0.0274538361,
0.0597241297,
-0.0255233236,
-0.0614141151,
-0.0083905645,
0.0048932023,
0.026759332,
0.0773636997,
-0.0220463574,
-0.0405810289,
-0.0199786294,
-0.0493424796,
-0.0287863966,
0.0167484134,
-0.0264014248,
-0.0355757996,
-0.0276082009,
-0.0109930085,
-0.0880682394,
0.0144132683,
0.023949692,
0.0293145664,
0.0308205169,
0.025125362,
0.0781149417,
0.0232462827,
-0.0015589737,
0.01355551,
-0.0440464839,
0.0339489169,
0.0175552685,
0.0097975582,
0.0474130549,
-0.026224548,
-0.0129309595,
0.0331287161,
-0.0279121436,
-0.0826274082,
0.0131908478,
0.0379879661,
0.0298767164,
0.017702315,
-0.0129123144,
-0.0435526296,
-0.0143315298,
0.0011183721,
-0.0291145854,
0.0083686318,
0.0122903725,
0.02455654,
0.0222647432,
0.0156843103,
-0.016523391,
0.00874878,
0.0105508389,
0.042441655,
-0.0537947565,
-0.064834401,
0.0568808056,
0.0314150192,
0.0465556644,
-0.0192652084,
-0.0513881445,
0.0039267763,
-0.0056744544,
-0.0347359516,
-0.0326243304,
0.0105815986,
-0.0123999957,
0.0067427591,
0.0125673655,
-0.0270122699,
0.0168112069,
-0.022254603,
0.0046035796,
0.0229999516,
-0.0715725571,
0.0409887284,
0.0067798966,
0.033617571,
-0.0431144238,
0.019869037,
0.027063014,
-0.0238348078,
0.0452913456,
-0.0001579507,
0.0416438468,
0.0344669297,
-0.0624910481,
-0.0757459775,
-0.0286731366,
-0.0528322123,
-0.0383101329,
-0.0026877753,
0.066168651,
0.044834923,
0.0145115657,
0.0002572952,
-0.0697741434,
-0.0036999774,
-0.0055244649,
0.0221512653,
-0.0067693344,
0.031925261,
0.0526924767,
0.0092950333,
-0.0400077887,
-0.0172643382,
0.0531370156,
0.0177117269,
0.032238394,
-0.0279659815,
-0.0578649007,
-0.0102081485,
-0.0081153978,
-0.0135951927,
0.065077655,
-0.0260009766,
-0.0212443117,
-0.0268539358,
-0.0220292713,
-0.0377659947,
0.0538567118,
0.0144898519,
-0.022990346,
0.0309753753,
0.0851880684,
-0.0045450632,
-0.0315402895,
-0.0240273345,
0.0263328403,
-0.0088316444,
-0.0097417058,
-0.0353739671,
-6.021772869e-33,
0.0141668217,
-0.0341166183,
0.0441964231,
0.0220318567,
0.0257528555,
-0.0592636652,
-0.0185711198,
0.0259738211,
0.02561008,
0.0255739801,
-0.0001496162,
0.0066162916,
0.0223169513,
-0.0263242833,
0.0241292045,
-0.0040419488,
0.0265592933,
-0.0034634687,
-0.0257131718,
-0.0507007912,
0.0234262161,
-0.0304873567,
0.0111749396,
-0.0643364862,
0.0345167033,
0.0456660725,
-0.0119812125,
0.0614724346,
-0.0330567062,
0.0177797303,
-0.0056782002,
0.0413548052,
0.0183684137,
-0.0278485715,
0.0063131754,
0.0084711108,
-0.0310542695,
-0.0220079012,
0.0100631714,
-0.0032995231,
0.0078200726,
-0.0306782927,
0.0439355299,
0.0138737466,
-0.0493553728,
0.041478768,
0.0305463765,
-0.0379412323,
0.0109453788,
0.0127559621,
-0.0441965871,
0.0363052599,
0.0163502749,
-0.0116073908,
-0.020387385,
-0.0540289469,
-0.019235529,
-0.0214739591,
-0.0269617587,
0.0535065494,
0.0296114478,
0.0173588619,
0.0465078354,
-0.0128900064,
0.0097714141,
0.0456321053,
0.0022425118,
0.0113696344,
-0.0256135464,
-0.0154205859,
0.0124798007,
0.0158268511,
0.0309982672,
0.0605905764,
0.0526139066,
0.0517372079,
-0.0802412033,
0.0288773626,
0.0596181154,
0.0290254336,
0.0400398746,
0.0427468754,
-0.0528390221,
-0.0253771767,
-0.0362638123,
0.0269771982,
-0.0118910735,
-0.0230568703,
0.0050826045,
0.0083455648,
0.0073713497,
-0.0198742859,
0.0010593347,
-0.0127930185,
-0.0285644941,
-0.065062061,
0.0177083332,
0.0084232101,
-0.0180969313,
-0.0000785868,
-0.0666617453,
-0.0243737176,
0.0080016758,
-0.0112614948,
-0.018728368,
0.0035628306,
-0.0150036179,
0.0156146958,
-0.0468671136,
0.0011727348,
-0.0227678418,
-0.03461238,
0.0417866297,
-0.0290509053,
0.0253037456,
0.0318549983,
0.0083262222,
-0.0121322935,
0.0352158099,
-0.0191826932,
-0.018363297,
-0.0041904734,
0.0073605408,
-0.0176908113,
-0.0005960314,
0.0044573443,
-0.0259705558,
-0.0077983225,
-0.0147270234,
-0.0227788091,
-0.0270300694,
0.0423570089,
2.583e-7,
0.0633695945,
0.070627518,
-0.0291509312,
0.0459874123,
0.032078404,
0.0237090979,
-0.0246971305,
-0.0286953356,
0.0565390289,
-0.0016640733,
0.0141587816,
0.0295928102,
0.0024782124,
0.0384621546,
-0.0628415495,
-0.0759940073,
0.0042190501,
-0.0065529114,
-0.0420176536,
-0.0276071671,
0.0454724133,
0.082125783,
0.0307136327,
0.0162857082,
0.0038387703,
-0.0735508502,
0.0514425747,
-0.0217268765,
-0.0211611502,
0.0432650521,
0.040590968,
-0.0157078672,
0.0045130001,
0.0567220002,
-0.0008645895,
-0.0216210634,
-0.0082149692,
0.0408084057,
-0.0180671532,
0.0514466055,
-0.0319066197,
-0.0623130128,
0.0280379299,
-0.0454683974,
0.0798131749,
-0.069793433,
-0.0118032396,
0.0053425133,
0.0008732881,
-0.0801967829,
-0.004397959,
-0.0179094616,
-0.0193718895,
0.0090161851,
-0.010370383,
0.0591968819,
0.0012020597,
-0.0315151662,
-0.0175354723,
0.0099450732,
-0.0416747816,
-0.0868092924,
-0.0100250524,
-0.0245681219,
0.0168417171,
-0.1086648703,
0.0251538977,
2.268850345e-34,
0.0187832862,
0.0236069411,
-0.0268548913,
0.0281205289,
0.035445109,
0.0102391355,
-0.0147803817,
0.0187983271,
0.0452455916,
-0.1077785492,
-0.0077597951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06015v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06015v2 | Exploring Visual Culture Awareness in GPT-4V: A Comprehensive Probing | 2024-02-08T19:25:40 | 2024-02-15T10:39:19 | Yong Cao, Wenyan Li, Jiaang Li, Yifei Yuan, Antonia Karamolegkou, Daniel Hershcovich | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Pretrained large Vision-Language models have drawn considerable interest in
recent years due to their remarkable performance. Despite considerable efforts
to assess these models from diverse perspectives, the extent of visual cultural
awareness in the state-of-the-art GPT-4V model remains unexplored. To tackle
this gap, we extensively probed GPT-4V using the MaRVL benchmark dataset,
aiming to investigate its capabilities and limitations in visual understanding
with a focus on cultural aspects. Specifically, we introduced three visual
related tasks, i.e. caption classification, pairwise captioning, and culture
tag selection, to systematically delve into fine-grained visual cultural
evaluation. Experimental results indicate that GPT-4V excels at identifying
cultural concepts but still exhibits weaker performance in low-resource
languages, such as Tamil and Swahili. Notably, through human evaluation, GPT-4V
proves to be more culturally relevant in image captioning tasks than the
original MaRVL human annotations, suggesting a promising solution for future
visual cultural benchmark construction. | [
0.0215074494,
0.0629932433,
-0.0141731137,
0.054895781,
0.0165735353,
0.0627135932,
0.0321611576,
-0.0327211991,
0.0177908018,
-0.0511449054,
-0.0682073236,
-0.0802951679,
0.0077417241,
0.0342779569,
0.0125773652,
-0.08318609,
0.019668851,
0.0011722448,
-0.0056883469,
0.0025495309,
-0.0009503925,
0.0178215653,
0.0329956599,
0.036073789,
-0.024335945,
-0.0161958225,
0.0349191539,
-0.0010619377,
0.0476482548,
-0.0412747711,
-0.0073879431,
0.0538665205,
0.0358156003,
0.0362087227,
0.000001896,
-0.0078514349,
0.0450571962,
-0.0247002374,
0.0455631465,
0.0614343658,
0.0556389131,
-0.0428148173,
-0.0093385745,
-0.028368881,
-0.0544951111,
-0.0461104922,
0.0747320279,
0.0395239592,
0.0443027467,
0.0317505896,
-0.0162765142,
-0.0424547978,
-0.0349170715,
-0.0652828366,
-0.035456188,
-0.0559999645,
0.0178355649,
0.0840290934,
-0.0169971678,
-0.0080437921,
-0.0527936146,
0.033340659,
0.0285428502,
-0.0018419792,
-0.0204939339,
0.0379490405,
-0.0715764165,
-0.0370233133,
0.0035142873,
0.073830463,
0.0555808768,
0.0346582495,
-0.0165160894,
0.005494542,
-0.0406225435,
-0.0366808102,
-0.0296284258,
0.0313318111,
0.0188018624,
0.0228668042,
-0.0226362757,
0.027548125,
0.0253996942,
0.0251220688,
0.0253706519,
-0.0110830786,
-0.000116943,
0.0469180793,
-0.0275968034,
0.0192227233,
-0.0860761255,
-0.0131521327,
-0.0053421496,
-0.0343011804,
0.0345813371,
-0.0218258686,
-0.0298121385,
0.0089831445,
-0.0036917448,
-0.0427896716,
0.0155905848,
0.0492528081,
-0.0909739658,
0.0679173246,
-0.0060300366,
0.0758847296,
-0.0371942371,
0.0192219503,
-0.0222370699,
-0.024431048,
-0.0237939805,
-0.0070296153,
0.0201241132,
-0.034033075,
-0.0542648919,
-0.0207666624,
-0.0781554356,
-0.0134613635,
-0.0476312041,
-0.0207176022,
-0.03417008,
-0.0135158105,
-0.0169568788,
-0.0003452137,
-0.0296691395,
0.0443990454,
-0.0168123022,
-0.0375375934,
-0.0617544241,
-0.0902333856,
0.0148898549,
0.0428452902,
-0.0417213216,
-0.0406835675,
0.0045459378,
0.0194108486,
-0.0300608147,
-0.0407088175,
-0.0584241413,
0.0270384997,
-0.0299045425,
-0.0473781489,
0.04145642,
-0.0465856232,
-0.0030758136,
-0.0201797709,
0.0344520845,
-0.0335612185,
-0.0133914687,
0.0034475478,
0.0170152765,
0.0838537961,
0.0255210176,
-0.009640269,
0.034644518,
0.0188957639,
-0.0124464165,
0.0854864717,
0.0109281447,
0.0306461304,
0.0378375873,
-0.0134759275,
0.0039873896,
0.0359934643,
-0.0064279488,
0.0238177478,
-0.0579462387,
0.0124633415,
0.0241683498,
0.0027248494,
0.0776155666,
0.0253302753,
0.0029754683,
-0.0105107976,
0.0611414015,
0.0510960817,
-0.0443996154,
0.0479079783,
0.0572535954,
-0.0177577864,
-0.008964763,
0.0146729071,
-0.0516926199,
0.0595352612,
0.0284084585,
-0.0308610108,
-0.001989251,
0.0486406684,
-0.0505826175,
-0.0157346874,
-0.0087323319,
0.0071855518,
0.0297092665,
-0.0008996265,
0.034193065,
-0.0369562916,
0.0199424028,
-0.008390571,
0.0346747898,
-0.0211876705,
-0.009415091,
-0.049735859,
0.0065388372,
0.0340663679,
0.0054405089,
0.011707129,
0.0087186396,
0.0018111084,
0.0543848872,
0.0516368523,
0.0644014552,
0.0247844774,
0.0257282909,
-0.0442178398,
-0.0289664436,
-0.0272654574,
-0.0073832669,
0.0584561788,
0.0205212887,
0.0264148917,
0.0445726924,
-0.0036007608,
-0.062378969,
0.0108222347,
0.0190663002,
0.0009328135,
-0.0005972392,
0.0173242278,
0.0200586151,
0.024924919,
-0.0262798406,
-0.0439994521,
-0.0307893176,
-0.0212822147,
0.0291670654,
0.0418040864,
-0.0825602114,
-0.0166955646,
0.0340353549,
-0.066027917,
-0.0127599314,
0.0365561359,
-0.0196659435,
-0.024581477,
0.0328985266,
0.0037626065,
-0.0422519334,
-0.0875924453,
-0.0473609306,
-0.0089088259,
0.0564051867,
0.0110518513,
0.0538788885,
-0.0070816055,
-0.0367101505,
-0.0063773398,
-0.0200175438,
0.0374650657,
-0.0263158511,
-0.0647196174,
0.0414312333,
0.0384058803,
-0.0029410312,
0.0110840155,
0.048661489,
-0.0377209261,
0.0353693254,
-0.1398049891,
-0.0232528895,
-0.05355113,
-0.0306630433,
-0.0201688204,
0.0017082526,
-0.0194316916,
-0.056702707,
-0.0561835095,
-0.0140245669,
0.0105030099,
0.0285915155,
0.0271757357,
0.0206741337,
0.0170147717,
0.0104639065,
-0.0124735013,
0.0170817319,
0.0484573171,
0.0159349218,
-0.0450029783,
-0.0061428235,
-0.0494393706,
-0.0273489542,
0.0023266191,
-0.0281444453,
-0.0524759144,
-0.0042877523,
0.0246614702,
0.0100200744,
0.0225961264,
-0.0014022168,
0.0312375557,
0.0271849483,
-0.0048225154,
0.0360318385,
0.0030833913,
0.0121188583,
-0.0379123352,
0.0211463589,
-0.0377680808,
-0.0345193595,
0.028331738,
-0.0442217477,
0.0160841215,
-0.0785588101,
0.017916603,
-0.0367009751,
-0.0481118299,
-0.0237945467,
0.0316595472,
-0.0056722728,
0.0560452566,
-0.0368542261,
-0.0668230504,
0.0469039232,
-0.0300482009,
-0.048366338,
-0.0009658509,
0.0094979834,
-0.0477953218,
0.0828763768,
0.0104506779,
0.0289557725,
-0.0290332008,
-0.025352994,
-0.0167939272,
-0.0176131595,
0.0150947208,
-0.0208613202,
0.0804767832,
-0.0653279275,
-0.0201018713,
-0.056264583,
-0.0120023498,
-0.0313792415,
0.0159673188,
-0.022275893,
0.0214412324,
-0.016225785,
0.014382123,
0.0060842587,
0.0389811546,
0.0324277952,
0.0131603433,
-0.0093895225,
0.0374078602,
0.0280763973,
0.0097235516,
0.0175957996,
0.0241236351,
-0.0185380131,
-0.0347787514,
-0.0051227021,
0.0017901933,
0.0440291204,
-0.0141864792,
-0.0375530794,
0.0627249777,
0.0402941741,
0.0599987693,
-0.0200707316,
-0.0228708088,
0.0731394589,
-0.0255078729,
0.0319747962,
0.0666249543,
0.0002833585,
-0.082754001,
-0.0310324226,
0.0096347583,
0.0179988053,
0.0345601514,
0.0250036288,
-0.0983620286,
-0.0229844544,
-0.0315441713,
0.0059573879,
0.0138640981,
0.0035766042,
-0.0432982892,
-0.0663846582,
0.056128975,
0.0187184066,
-0.0616271421,
-0.0520754792,
0.0326734446,
-0.0233299304,
-0.039068047,
0.0192434285,
-0.0320484228,
0.0038315437,
0.0040821424,
0.0109204194,
-0.0052120257,
-0.0579115339,
0.0542699918,
-0.0336537361,
0.0179395732,
0.0638755932,
0.0181212351,
-0.0053002313,
-0.0653882995,
-0.0131235672,
-0.0421395041,
-0.0002094397,
-0.0083936471,
0.0481380187,
-0.0107098371,
-0.076371491,
0.0508345254,
-0.0066732955,
-0.005740942,
-0.013990825,
-0.0130213834,
0.0102902874,
0.0090834657,
0.0013422591,
0.0072106589,
0.0185121503,
-0.0164289922,
0.0331089161,
0.047570575,
-0.0075883577,
-0.0185246114,
-0.0179165434,
0.0129826954,
-0.0509366654,
-0.0396630578,
0.0142989168,
-0.0110519072,
-0.0565979257,
-0.0382523499,
-0.0492009968,
0.0177183896,
0.0037423088,
0.019555131,
-0.0301156621,
-0.0278530009,
0.0534341522,
-0.0470713899,
0.0936819389,
-0.0361010768,
0.0128213074,
-0.0273653585,
-0.0319540538,
0.0430704728,
-0.0553426445,
-0.0025913324,
0.0380432867,
-0.0493729934,
-0.0106141688,
-0.0071523129,
0.057160072,
0.0057827183,
0.0193299614,
0.0499818325,
-0.0494826101,
-0.0114123384,
0.0089257965,
0.0432804711,
0.0161678549,
0.0065495088,
0.0095355054,
-0.0385486968,
0.0290894993,
0.0022917229,
0.0560839958,
0.021591831,
0.0277226865,
-0.0073138135,
0.0241482258,
-0.0201479755,
0.0073404997,
0.048237171,
-0.0823768228,
-0.0010348606,
-0.0312750973,
-0.0315632671,
0.0188713204,
0.0045361621,
-0.0536153577,
-0.0390338525,
0.0296480563,
0.0192563199,
-0.0068155094,
-0.0083931861,
0.0108964248,
-0.0125693455,
-0.0202148557,
0.0178771168,
0.0450280085,
-0.0102113318,
-0.0453978591,
0.0457822122,
-0.0182978194,
0.0123844547,
-0.0013311261,
0.0303751733,
-0.0157707613,
0.0977484807,
0.0164186675,
-0.0081792185,
0.0398251638,
0.0506505109,
0.0149730304,
-0.0129083097,
-0.0045208782,
0.0310480557,
0.0975988135,
-0.0434965901,
0.043692898,
0.0019662685,
-0.0051717069,
-0.0220645964,
0.0319206081,
0.0067038755,
-0.0140736764,
0.0214634333,
0.0071224058,
-0.0223293845,
0.0070473365,
0.0484881774,
0.0013559177,
-0.0132038686,
0.020080857,
-0.0455509573,
-0.0158870425,
-0.0417237543,
0.0316823609,
-0.0269815754,
-0.0179242678,
0.0523706004,
-0.0546430238,
-0.0491316877,
-0.0198551677,
-0.0144842835,
-0.0041447454,
0.0438985042,
0.0442592278,
0.0586750284,
0.002965644,
-0.0222089402,
-0.0561226346,
-0.0582037941,
-0.0153325982,
0.0478958413,
0.0338393264,
-5.92183087e-33,
-0.0494395643,
0.0093414849,
0.0073670847,
0.0104541574,
-0.0228568502,
0.0067067584,
-0.0362540297,
0.01292744,
-0.0273779724,
0.0183358118,
0.02590557,
-0.0071718814,
0.0283230972,
0.0519942492,
0.0208998453,
0.0056861141,
0.0084175579,
0.0097912028,
-0.0131121585,
0.0243166983,
0.0143424664,
0.0030944501,
0.0835728571,
-0.0442985483,
-0.0058283098,
0.0200259797,
0.0100268871,
-0.0155079393,
0.0502170734,
0.057707198,
-0.0736742467,
0.0298389327,
0.0228858646,
-0.0101910299,
-0.0017366196,
-0.0238296241,
-0.0561440662,
-0.0086493641,
0.0270203818,
0.063876383,
-0.0228449553,
-0.0260012187,
-0.0024052316,
-0.0404569879,
-0.0315767452,
-0.0100291502,
0.0554059297,
-0.0238325018,
0.0055668107,
-0.0071387836,
-0.016919706,
0.0468962304,
0.0139498236,
0.0119435061,
0.0637574345,
0.0283194128,
0.0105172284,
0.0382104255,
-0.042616915,
0.0264332239,
0.0081488537,
0.0101430081,
0.0878451765,
0.0689659268,
0.0154677397,
0.0498291701,
0.031374,
-0.008593726,
-0.0025748464,
-0.025999384,
0.029615676,
-0.0127671612,
0.0209160522,
0.0681368262,
0.020168433,
0.0299855731,
-0.0254410785,
-0.0013423847,
-0.0175719019,
0.0053002886,
0.0087290518,
-0.0099526457,
-0.0049343891,
0.0048178537,
-0.0049722404,
-0.0214740876,
-0.0455516092,
-0.0327091552,
0.0629218146,
-0.0026438085,
-0.0113191633,
0.0604091883,
0.0747375637,
-0.0338766389,
0.0121525703,
-0.0149045605,
-0.0155261932,
0.0125309555,
0.0377646536,
0.0009474599,
-0.0286194421,
-0.0272655189,
0.017085854,
0.0144840516,
-0.0018093747,
-0.0293263514,
0.0444247015,
0.0241404399,
-0.0329357311,
0.0048440667,
-0.0325700827,
-0.0023704502,
-0.05386848,
0.02045759,
0.019804379,
-0.0046831495,
-0.0548034571,
-0.0119085135,
0.0129340524,
0.0006717724,
-0.0117651746,
-0.0756225735,
0.0031750153,
0.0480658785,
-0.0292532425,
0.0187845323,
-0.003714809,
0.0104694832,
-0.0043895706,
-0.0258674268,
-0.0197205469,
0.0294399653,
2.525e-7,
0.0149621572,
0.0058764885,
0.0136123821,
-0.0039389185,
0.0133160586,
0.03935574,
-0.0518454984,
0.0032051476,
-0.0106541375,
-0.0230743233,
0.0448180512,
0.047119692,
0.0675153881,
-0.0022982948,
-0.0319742411,
0.0329290405,
-0.0182288308,
0.0274477657,
-0.0292566102,
-0.0177879799,
0.0172898844,
0.0750002265,
-0.0058976635,
-0.0310266539,
0.007744594,
-0.0790399611,
0.1035080031,
-0.043605864,
-0.0102942744,
-0.0214698259,
-0.0006476244,
0.0417650901,
-0.0433070175,
0.0083738267,
-0.0136183398,
-0.0206618235,
0.0805226415,
0.0507633425,
-0.0141319484,
0.0096348599,
-0.023209095,
0.090174295,
-0.0310323536,
-0.0801817998,
0.0622165427,
-0.0202516913,
-0.0380962268,
-0.000417237,
-0.0238678996,
-0.0234127101,
0.0576015413,
-0.01369044,
-0.0310323928,
0.0265600104,
0.0203457847,
-0.0464403592,
-0.0313681662,
-0.0666821748,
0.0196205117,
-0.0218964573,
-0.0275247749,
-0.0169059746,
-0.0580845289,
-0.0206997674,
0.0002480694,
0.0393768772,
-0.0182581507,
1.635075678e-34,
0.0401129015,
-0.0323383212,
-0.001344839,
-0.0161966737,
-0.0029861063,
-0.0054908958,
-0.0217484497,
-0.0184089374,
-0.0101166442,
-0.0138161378,
0.009913967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05935v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05935v2 | SPHINX-X: Scaling Data and Parameters for a Family of Multi-modal Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T18:59:48 | 2024-06-26T07:59:03 | Dongyang Liu, Renrui Zhang, Longtian Qiu, Siyuan Huang, Weifeng Lin, Shitian Zhao, Shijie Geng, Ziyi Lin, Peng Jin, Kaipeng Zhang, Wenqi Shao, Chao Xu, Conghui He, Junjun He, Hao Shao, Pan Lu, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao, Peng Gao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | We propose SPHINX-X, an extensive Multimodality Large Language Model (MLLM)
series developed upon SPHINX. To improve the architecture and training
efficiency, we modify the SPHINX framework by removing redundant visual
encoders, bypassing fully-padded sub-images with skip tokens, and simplifying
multi-stage training into a one-stage all-in-one paradigm. To fully unleash the
potential of MLLMs, we assemble a comprehensive multi-domain and multimodal
dataset covering publicly available resources in language, vision, and
vision-language tasks. We further enrich this collection with our curated OCR
intensive and Set-of-Mark datasets, extending the diversity and generality. By
training over different base LLMs including TinyLlama1.1B, InternLM2-7B,
LLaMA2-13B, and Mixtral8x7B, we obtain a spectrum of MLLMs that vary in
parameter size and multilingual capabilities. Comprehensive benchmarking
reveals a strong correlation between the multi-modal performance with the data
and parameter scales. Code and models are released at
https://github.com/Alpha-VLLM/LLaMA2-Accessory | [
-0.0073501272,
0.0639786124,
0.0117661953,
0.0581502691,
-0.0217342377,
0.0168024693,
0.0317405425,
0.0039107595,
0.0004743705,
-0.0701900795,
-0.0835542083,
-0.0282710344,
0.034993615,
0.0214466434,
0.0297434386,
-0.0486937165,
0.0066726864,
-0.0963522941,
-0.0563752726,
-0.0010863562,
0.0197806079,
0.0078038182,
-0.0249666516,
0.0244556647,
0.0119091524,
-0.023523571,
-0.0099282227,
0.0336204618,
0.0141589716,
-0.0406761095,
-0.0357799493,
0.0413541608,
0.0547025464,
0.0356579199,
0.0000019222,
-0.0274856612,
0.0328839198,
-0.0054804995,
0.0346891098,
0.0121558215,
0.0554245785,
-0.0574209094,
0.0025698326,
0.0130848326,
-0.0079831732,
-0.0664574653,
0.0630491376,
0.0542737916,
0.0230425354,
0.0654967874,
-0.0158612747,
-0.0379330218,
0.0321246237,
-0.0244117472,
-0.0291971285,
-0.0347514413,
0.0388601571,
0.0078284536,
-0.0237555318,
0.0134994537,
-0.0446565785,
0.0425578132,
0.010870154,
-0.043220669,
-0.0396497622,
0.0385736562,
0.0535884239,
-0.0565307029,
-0.0121802343,
0.0627079234,
-0.0184225291,
-0.0028119828,
-0.0373176374,
0.007201666,
-0.0264875907,
0.0034272471,
-0.0466826819,
0.057887651,
0.0047671143,
0.0178369693,
-0.0185322147,
0.0025968917,
0.0216719508,
0.0088138776,
-0.0112391226,
-0.021035824,
0.0321749114,
0.0216082372,
-0.0070199077,
-0.013661488,
-0.0077768359,
-0.0290079825,
0.0001567081,
0.0359565951,
0.002600169,
-0.0019412522,
-0.0435581803,
-0.0394786894,
0.0241847485,
0.0010164906,
0.0586464554,
0.0184346326,
-0.0705173165,
0.0455871597,
-0.0384187922,
0.0705523938,
-0.0411298983,
0.0734106749,
-0.0369168334,
-0.03901048,
0.0083945794,
0.0096199159,
-0.0137168849,
-0.0214458518,
-0.037865974,
-0.0207665954,
-0.0270478968,
-0.0088982582,
0.0082225399,
-0.0175384842,
0.0125455819,
-0.0157673638,
-0.0222062226,
-0.0399686769,
0.0135933496,
0.0591520332,
0.0047789081,
0.0476454161,
-0.0149530424,
-0.0614496842,
0.0088893455,
0.0602538064,
0.0069833896,
-0.0192118287,
-0.0009610024,
0.1018027812,
-0.0472155139,
-0.0585893914,
-0.041661337,
0.0336181372,
-0.0232557226,
-0.0764642581,
0.0317442864,
-0.0656459332,
0.0257347114,
-0.00541656,
0.0339007862,
0.0177943259,
0.0076028709,
0.009830921,
0.0155418664,
0.0969345793,
0.0036477922,
-0.0084106755,
0.0325682499,
0.0025409879,
0.0431575887,
0.1029854268,
0.0539003424,
0.0374343991,
0.0152525827,
-0.0054783076,
-0.0102399699,
0.0714669377,
-0.0231410116,
0.0203457698,
-0.0253202952,
-0.0168604963,
0.0694891065,
0.0541555285,
0.0513145961,
0.0694554299,
-0.041186776,
-0.0183722749,
0.0874108002,
0.0256066527,
0.025935445,
-0.0049432432,
0.0142429937,
-0.031493526,
0.0230860598,
-0.0211186241,
-0.0449855886,
0.0210732408,
0.0180802885,
0.0083705215,
-0.0041767173,
0.0813107267,
-0.0324332677,
-0.004429684,
-0.015070783,
-0.0333200693,
-0.0206234455,
-0.0027086248,
0.0893532112,
0.005765385,
-0.0481686369,
0.0011769182,
0.0178567879,
-0.0143980868,
0.0157930888,
-0.0382597595,
-0.0068259449,
0.037550021,
0.0405324548,
-0.0064728544,
-0.0011075613,
0.005522301,
0.0357141681,
0.0739152431,
-0.0002287128,
-0.005278178,
0.023496218,
-0.1175930947,
-0.0238151904,
0.014131791,
-0.0168274119,
0.0106212832,
0.0063238423,
0.0249889027,
-0.0101462184,
-0.0403938033,
0.026848875,
0.0493319258,
-0.0121884765,
0.0017741623,
-0.0383838303,
0.0014775812,
0.0199621059,
-0.0074645397,
-0.0125468289,
-0.0195936654,
0.0218573622,
-0.0725997463,
0.0272222664,
-0.0081699667,
-0.043462228,
-0.0380723476,
0.049860701,
-0.0190691967,
0.024355717,
0.0766588077,
-0.0198929384,
-0.0291798804,
-0.0287041832,
-0.0310838409,
0.0319309644,
-0.0588241741,
-0.0059094047,
0.0021537247,
0.0355312563,
-0.0496325903,
0.0118200146,
-0.0220023748,
-0.0200803876,
0.0353178047,
-0.0133516248,
-0.0084860632,
-0.0133758979,
-0.0327985212,
0.0457750969,
0.0014976141,
0.0226797368,
-0.0373219736,
0.0347800143,
-0.0051871315,
-0.0474341251,
-0.0965608731,
-0.0185175072,
-0.0300270412,
0.0053541292,
0.008663361,
0.0005157457,
0.001703233,
-0.041110713,
-0.0001833229,
0.0146873631,
0.0061830683,
0.018775193,
0.0040424764,
-0.0040736501,
-0.0399703234,
0.0051486581,
-0.0290792957,
0.0089659002,
0.0613499396,
0.0123587372,
-0.0410212316,
-0.0451191738,
0.0060278289,
-0.0043891985,
0.0229009949,
-0.0327607356,
-0.0330376811,
0.003392115,
-0.0213189162,
0.0386134125,
0.0577706359,
0.0227274485,
0.0292494651,
0.0626682267,
-0.0068647247,
-0.0142748151,
-0.0262794532,
0.0091921007,
-0.0523921996,
-0.0599519797,
-0.006162026,
-0.0463544764,
0.0430722237,
-0.0260109976,
0.0324353948,
-0.0321269855,
-0.0236521382,
-0.0146060335,
-0.0497126877,
-0.022396395,
0.0177914724,
-0.0186863169,
0.0194980651,
-0.0156934001,
-0.0683372021,
-0.0011708755,
-0.0758272633,
-0.0342791863,
0.0116529334,
0.0118554756,
-0.0548380017,
0.0699517131,
0.0192589182,
0.027607074,
-0.002821784,
-0.0341744013,
-0.0454883054,
-0.0099022891,
-0.0139785334,
-0.0192258917,
0.0457165167,
-0.0582008101,
0.0394526385,
-0.0588237494,
-0.0165354218,
0.0103715528,
0.0258923452,
-0.0417850837,
0.0004295437,
-0.0354503542,
-0.0241018049,
-0.0561755821,
0.0369999222,
0.0317879915,
0.0605439171,
-0.0204385296,
0.0147263939,
-0.0212134738,
0.0646851361,
0.0503927357,
0.0679191947,
0.0068475991,
-0.0845635459,
-0.0010175526,
0.029354509,
0.0169126987,
-0.0089960201,
-0.0468761213,
0.0124496827,
0.0614568405,
0.0302450154,
0.0138467262,
0.0009480701,
0.0459055714,
-0.0455100238,
0.0034531173,
0.0640157759,
-0.0166213419,
-0.069192335,
-0.0446393825,
0.0028693043,
0.0503181964,
0.0041443147,
-0.0130824037,
-0.0699037835,
-0.0499452613,
0.0084960051,
0.0203435551,
0.0382369198,
0.0146944765,
0.0036916884,
-0.0845210999,
0.0445859917,
0.0097177448,
-0.0471311919,
-0.0426382497,
-0.036232736,
-0.0129646249,
-0.0286895465,
0.011555519,
-0.0024744561,
-0.0330996029,
-0.0477818884,
0.020028716,
0.0252294708,
-0.0424299054,
0.0052394499,
-0.0340406112,
0.0310351364,
0.0061641554,
0.0253557954,
-0.0107647935,
-0.0397416018,
0.0521250032,
-0.0171911381,
-0.0102264723,
-0.0162406154,
0.0469568856,
-0.0203428231,
-0.0338192321,
-0.0034973314,
0.0297666341,
-0.0406267829,
-0.0112727098,
-0.0140523771,
0.0287332349,
-0.0069693574,
0.0030910848,
-0.0281761345,
-0.0287618712,
-0.0518082455,
0.0462693535,
0.0137998322,
-0.0333034061,
-0.0096429326,
-0.004902028,
0.0189728495,
-0.0429659225,
-0.0252413228,
0.0029143691,
-0.0201562177,
-0.0093299244,
-0.0261393562,
-0.0107822614,
0.029726997,
0.057872232,
-0.0055094673,
-0.0200261492,
-0.002825856,
0.0190864839,
-0.039226301,
0.0449396297,
-0.049823612,
0.0162681174,
-0.0842372626,
-0.0029430811,
0.0473404154,
-0.0288934745,
0.0022728033,
0.0053218012,
-0.1180931032,
-0.0280441847,
-0.0148795443,
0.0527581051,
0.0168409962,
0.0292816646,
0.0299906656,
-0.0606593415,
0.0527237579,
0.0128087634,
0.0104498975,
0.0390039012,
-0.0052822246,
-0.0166040696,
-0.0150740072,
0.0393639989,
-0.0280968081,
-0.0077194888,
0.0007660131,
0.0352569371,
0.0162250586,
-0.0241750106,
-0.017405767,
-0.0133072687,
0.0124960355,
-0.031313926,
0.0062353713,
-0.0673258826,
0.0351105668,
-0.0079061501,
0.0320568644,
-0.0578857362,
0.0161397606,
0.0278123897,
0.0270297471,
0.0156824514,
0.0194754787,
0.0516073033,
0.0037910582,
-0.0211680606,
0.0522364937,
-0.0044959686,
-0.0201677643,
0.0197222587,
0.0156834275,
-0.0173977353,
0.0365675204,
-0.0313527547,
0.0174371563,
-0.0113854557,
0.0436983034,
0.0160817485,
-0.0056145578,
-0.0205767136,
0.0483661592,
0.0010453707,
-0.0368836336,
-0.0586728156,
0.0411312394,
0.0642856732,
0.0220330078,
0.0582676008,
-0.0012039911,
-0.0128138764,
-0.0369551405,
0.0349145234,
-0.0168508794,
-0.0201512165,
0.0331389681,
0.0212263074,
0.004769925,
0.0064862645,
0.0855413675,
0.0294332411,
0.0392637812,
0.0057823947,
0.0471315831,
-0.0348008685,
-0.0427936725,
0.0345857069,
0.0050482922,
-0.0308671687,
-0.0254305117,
0.0173491668,
-0.0439492315,
0.0074017486,
0.0030046124,
-0.0350335538,
0.0055256276,
0.0275903847,
0.0314634144,
0.0025943802,
-0.0100283641,
-0.0153982677,
-0.0139338337,
0.0263686422,
-0.0127592804,
0.0220066011,
-5.674837099e-33,
-0.0342279784,
-0.0191293601,
0.0359823108,
-0.0056201783,
-0.0119995726,
0.0359504372,
-0.0067338427,
0.0071923244,
-0.0256832521,
0.0063549071,
0.0369994305,
-0.0406512022,
0.0251255054,
0.0575190149,
0.0011083997,
0.0177804716,
0.0314622149,
-0.0245594811,
0.0006124848,
0.0098786568,
0.0170457736,
0.0266407002,
0.0564461574,
-0.0477425456,
-0.0313408598,
0.0000909874,
-0.0401737876,
0.0358726978,
0.0002651328,
0.0860597268,
-0.0461385064,
0.0287983883,
0.014301219,
-0.0038759778,
-0.0106898304,
0.0343028978,
-0.0701020285,
0.0295142382,
-0.0120985471,
0.0699303076,
-0.0474572256,
-0.0092554111,
0.0239007119,
-0.0136710703,
-0.0043967669,
-0.0197556056,
0.0493337922,
-0.0171426497,
-0.0208322499,
-0.0027594217,
-0.0506469421,
0.0160384122,
0.0086840317,
-0.0275592823,
0.0384032167,
0.0109205479,
0.0017526228,
0.03440772,
0.002163073,
0.0289231613,
0.0076123187,
0.043324355,
0.0832897276,
0.0837760791,
-0.0138351806,
0.049776867,
0.029954154,
-0.0322592184,
0.0120271808,
-0.0169191491,
0.0703753382,
0.0250094291,
0.0307562705,
0.0727943406,
-0.0499665737,
0.0334675163,
-0.0663735792,
0.0091963261,
0.005570061,
0.0448238514,
0.0239524897,
0.0259968787,
0.0340570174,
0.0187139623,
-0.045321513,
0.0122643188,
-0.0370246507,
0.0290709883,
0.0487906933,
0.0401412733,
-0.0034968453,
-0.0079526501,
0.0785699934,
-0.0332667567,
-0.0500054397,
-0.0134642646,
0.016448535,
0.0628179759,
-0.0154084675,
0.0107627008,
-0.0572774261,
-0.0518523157,
0.0307569318,
-0.0289379228,
0.0104544694,
-0.0041674776,
0.0160563365,
0.0202930868,
-0.0686026961,
-0.0097603761,
-0.0336405784,
-0.0207617525,
0.0400679596,
0.0652943924,
0.055116158,
-0.0464273654,
-0.0378802381,
0.0483118519,
0.0043416298,
0.0068324758,
-0.0201393608,
-0.0302371103,
0.0014952361,
0.0358080082,
-0.0320503227,
0.0236896183,
-0.0518707186,
-0.0498056971,
0.0303395893,
-0.0353631489,
-0.0042609959,
0.0481402501,
2.495e-7,
0.0454987139,
0.0484890826,
0.0125958389,
0.0058845677,
0.0199312698,
0.0440554805,
-0.0176257584,
0.03599995,
-0.0159470532,
-0.0358452424,
-0.0194563568,
0.0291835293,
0.045245856,
0.0066995574,
-0.0535122417,
0.0199987832,
-0.0024663089,
0.0147783207,
-0.0472059771,
-0.0115579208,
-0.0026437077,
0.0948932245,
-0.0399741195,
-0.0370613411,
0.0101492619,
-0.0655443743,
0.0900175646,
-0.0341336653,
-0.0256248768,
-0.0026526216,
0.0217037573,
0.0241910852,
-0.029944744,
0.0152480733,
0.0200040117,
-0.0051902733,
0.0466808379,
0.0436424352,
-0.0217890609,
-0.0261136442,
0.0324911214,
0.0154286269,
-0.0595466383,
-0.0702237263,
0.0373317301,
-0.00865997,
-0.0156496055,
-0.054766193,
-0.0158644877,
-0.0060762274,
0.022997437,
-0.0387300178,
-0.0190440975,
0.055539038,
0.0355103202,
-0.0386311524,
-0.0447117798,
-0.0598977804,
-0.0164885633,
-0.0480984934,
-0.0577600077,
-0.0242537968,
-0.0739558041,
-0.026787011,
0.0270455908,
-0.0583302081,
-0.0308912899,
2.096515297e-34,
0.0305349194,
-0.0305319577,
-0.0019698616,
0.0431288853,
-0.0109796487,
-0.0319689922,
-0.0373151228,
-0.0031301922,
-0.0640979111,
-0.1045186743,
-0.0002860588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05932v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05932v2 | Driving Everywhere with Large Language Model Policy Adaptation | 2024-02-08T18:59:03 | 2024-04-10T23:29:18 | Boyi Li, Yue Wang, Jiageng Mao, Boris Ivanovic, Sushant Veer, Karen Leung, Marco Pavone | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | Adapting driving behavior to new environments, customs, and laws is a
long-standing problem in autonomous driving, precluding the widespread
deployment of autonomous vehicles (AVs). In this paper, we present LLaDA, a
simple yet powerful tool that enables human drivers and autonomous vehicles
alike to drive everywhere by adapting their tasks and motion plans to traffic
rules in new locations. LLaDA achieves this by leveraging the impressive
zero-shot generalizability of large language models (LLMs) in interpreting the
traffic rules in the local driver handbook. Through an extensive user study, we
show that LLaDA's instructions are useful in disambiguating in-the-wild
unexpected situations. We also demonstrate LLaDA's ability to adapt AV motion
planning policies in real-world datasets; LLaDA outperforms baseline planning
approaches on all our metrics. Please check our website for more details:
https://boyiliee.github.io/llada. | [
0.0150457677,
0.0123573747,
-0.0104913255,
0.0284326579,
-0.015663635,
0.0163373295,
0.0265808366,
-0.0059676371,
0.0069157099,
-0.0031882336,
0.0268603452,
-0.0060491646,
-0.0439499244,
0.0357745253,
0.0210080892,
-0.054734204,
0.0078046564,
-0.0974057615,
-0.0112622697,
0.0014392431,
-0.0096615348,
0.005615551,
0.0086176218,
0.0138253104,
-0.0161810629,
0.0254363734,
-0.0148162125,
0.0326273404,
0.0635719299,
0.0032459444,
-0.0125272935,
0.0137905972,
0.1039335206,
-0.0227046497,
0.0000021079,
-0.0339695551,
0.0161154233,
-0.0202240013,
0.0195670202,
-0.018051222,
0.0109358979,
-0.005854229,
0.0026463019,
0.0343801267,
-0.0345830545,
-0.014561465,
0.0087169968,
-0.017382795,
0.0532551147,
0.08914233,
-0.012549106,
-0.038816411,
-0.0412619077,
0.0100128073,
0.0280704554,
-0.034179233,
0.0376330987,
0.0229940563,
0.0215532016,
-0.0197451897,
-0.0223764386,
0.0106210494,
0.0481836945,
-0.0193031337,
-0.025661137,
0.0292283352,
-0.0183508527,
-0.004081184,
-0.0036304563,
0.0759131387,
-0.0399318263,
-0.0833964571,
0.0511583239,
0.0162542649,
-0.0425358787,
-0.0366964228,
-0.0509865098,
-0.0040945816,
0.0300371386,
0.0240637083,
-0.0282997694,
-0.0251957662,
0.014783062,
0.0106039103,
-0.0777654946,
0.0869383588,
0.0051325853,
-0.0001372845,
0.0051996564,
0.0057488815,
0.0243511833,
-0.0728531107,
0.0289382804,
0.0605182201,
-0.0321394615,
-0.006311384,
-0.0272294749,
0.0537718497,
-0.0042685876,
-0.0506539941,
0.0686210617,
0.0379571617,
-0.0406071767,
0.0668357983,
-0.0103426185,
0.0304081943,
0.0252453387,
0.013500669,
-0.011723334,
-0.0351359025,
-0.0305236299,
0.037488535,
-0.0284202695,
-0.0190101862,
-0.0592696033,
-0.0052086711,
0.017022403,
0.0548880398,
-0.0048774537,
0.0359625928,
-0.0439460166,
0.0071050096,
-0.0137587953,
-0.0498878062,
0.0310019739,
-0.0304767378,
-0.0443462022,
0.0209860392,
-0.0148367453,
-0.0181815214,
0.0222044922,
0.0161048863,
-0.0179478005,
0.0011039438,
0.0140171219,
0.1115011126,
-0.0076025696,
-0.0117024221,
-0.0447613224,
-0.002765327,
0.0081449812,
-0.0325501263,
-0.0193442386,
-0.091680795,
0.0365118682,
-0.0000645399,
-0.0312435515,
-0.0498537645,
-0.0165973306,
-0.0101778861,
-0.0088958377,
0.0451930054,
-0.0033590102,
0.0281138215,
0.0229157321,
0.0130425273,
0.0474054478,
0.0703903064,
0.0304544941,
0.0447917767,
0.0224820562,
0.0553298779,
0.0219986122,
0.0375054665,
-0.0075395084,
0.0588726699,
-0.0184275638,
0.0229913145,
-0.0012886848,
0.011487741,
0.0298417248,
0.0207975116,
-0.0240148902,
-0.0172670111,
0.011063912,
0.0294179115,
-0.0398950092,
-0.0010455956,
0.0605744682,
0.0509656928,
-0.0354280435,
-0.0580232702,
-0.0550032221,
-0.0150240371,
-0.0431720689,
-0.0113665648,
-0.0311328657,
0.07497821,
-0.04522283,
-0.0155319534,
0.0200315043,
-0.0013580256,
0.0252495222,
-0.0054874076,
0.0328137875,
-0.0435183346,
0.0100097954,
-0.0031608755,
-0.0035364644,
0.0002102266,
0.0103165889,
-0.035415642,
0.0156030655,
0.0714617297,
-0.0056429985,
0.0003440211,
-0.0506580956,
0.0069951084,
0.0581279881,
0.011578992,
-0.0147932237,
-0.0097203571,
0.0331781097,
-0.0624721013,
-0.043802198,
0.0803620443,
0.0166781005,
-0.0160035435,
0.0444465652,
0.0332611725,
0.0289690625,
-0.0660871565,
-0.0147462096,
0.0208891481,
-0.0040756511,
-0.0245860275,
-0.0061716349,
0.0124553982,
0.0067031314,
-0.0383179449,
-0.0317519419,
-0.0120825367,
0.0319650769,
0.0008101841,
0.0122445961,
0.0403866097,
-0.0123993875,
0.0319920629,
0.057482101,
-0.0720827654,
-0.0151264826,
0.0160974506,
-0.0418541059,
-0.0374722891,
-0.0616828948,
-0.0000317187,
0.015959464,
0.0452505983,
-0.0026610291,
0.0476702303,
-0.0002729063,
0.0025693758,
-0.0033729135,
0.0373951532,
-0.0156744514,
0.057151325,
-0.0117825093,
0.0182642192,
-0.0155569389,
-0.0371638797,
0.0170483608,
-0.0276377834,
-0.0134809501,
0.0066833817,
0.0584577583,
-0.0154492371,
-0.003778887,
-0.0257414635,
0.0039357548,
-0.0331827514,
-0.0028401099,
0.0200444553,
0.0112803923,
-0.0291701239,
-0.0297752358,
-0.0055088312,
0.0313496813,
-0.0130170705,
-0.0271414295,
-0.0108364793,
-0.0204326548,
-0.0681869015,
-0.0074953036,
-0.0088228593,
-0.0362560973,
-0.0278620068,
-0.0147208516,
-0.0324572325,
-0.0633327588,
0.0105486382,
-0.0271548647,
0.0506901518,
-0.0238788575,
-0.0462761894,
0.0067323996,
0.0110997744,
0.0392036587,
0.095736146,
-0.0000508778,
-0.0596138351,
0.057620842,
-0.025759127,
-0.067670241,
-0.0038171788,
-0.0157117285,
-0.0266592819,
-0.086925596,
-0.0535093732,
-0.0193894971,
0.0183301996,
-0.0176680703,
0.0219023097,
-0.0450985879,
-0.0488258041,
-0.0470128283,
-0.0596757419,
-0.055011861,
0.0437319577,
-0.0140746757,
0.0617658086,
-0.0069768718,
-0.0389031358,
0.0188531652,
-0.0037155792,
0.0087074945,
-0.0041534537,
-0.019922575,
-0.0119296182,
0.0561815202,
0.038052056,
0.0257240087,
-0.0073538031,
0.0218655653,
0.0170807205,
-0.0257926397,
-0.0461076796,
0.0174753666,
0.082512252,
-0.0905867293,
0.0194167495,
-0.0162345581,
-0.0645171627,
-0.0108969007,
-0.0195316374,
-0.0372408666,
0.0248422772,
-0.0516542271,
-0.0550920255,
0.0129494099,
0.0036426724,
0.0436940156,
0.0809679031,
0.0009812183,
-0.0057892594,
-0.0242311973,
-0.0742744058,
0.0970991328,
0.0235217102,
-0.0456433743,
-0.0069123311,
-0.0041956617,
0.0137541657,
0.0533019863,
-0.0139107248,
-0.0316105969,
0.0166579485,
0.0390543565,
-0.0141702546,
-0.0106172999,
0.1015302092,
0.056137763,
-0.0567272753,
-0.0494728759,
0.0557898805,
0.0306473207,
-0.0269967318,
0.0169395432,
-0.0370718576,
0.0349739119,
0.0023276743,
0.0494333953,
-0.1070824564,
-0.0325623155,
0.0097859548,
-0.0091018649,
0.0084327478,
-0.0023100313,
0.0281835087,
-0.0533012934,
0.0332581326,
0.0297868457,
-0.0665980875,
0.0100510819,
-0.0250665285,
-0.0156737119,
-0.0446220003,
0.0294505414,
-0.0015333422,
-0.0198999178,
-0.0321525522,
0.0221130494,
-0.0211385507,
-0.0363262445,
0.0001700235,
-0.0176958423,
0.066202417,
0.0517894737,
-0.0212451369,
0.0032187833,
-0.0222533382,
0.0138682071,
0.0431902036,
-0.0015507531,
-0.0507371537,
-0.0219202861,
-0.0235493742,
-0.0027835171,
0.0216311682,
0.0493364185,
-0.0533195697,
-0.0487821512,
0.0117042055,
0.0678147674,
-0.026195772,
-0.0144913793,
-0.0443191379,
0.0002141768,
0.0192768965,
0.0528892167,
-0.0266122837,
-0.0132238511,
-0.0423035733,
-0.0494200625,
-0.0884072557,
-0.0457816124,
-0.0677727535,
-0.0379041098,
-0.0492213517,
-0.0397994332,
-0.0032051003,
-0.0367727466,
0.0447152071,
0.0294713993,
0.0228088722,
-0.0193483662,
0.0414276309,
-0.0106605049,
-0.0208831914,
-0.0382083505,
-0.0427656882,
0.0139718577,
-0.0083838524,
0.0147241326,
0.0117575731,
0.0190367885,
-0.0467480235,
0.016307665,
-0.0151754254,
-0.0707593709,
0.0778049678,
0.0202185865,
0.0184977408,
0.0273393951,
-0.0491870046,
-0.0612192415,
0.0817648917,
0.0152147869,
0.0429653414,
0.063496165,
0.0182754565,
0.0143192364,
0.022888422,
0.0643327162,
-0.0664008856,
0.0302134044,
0.0173428077,
-0.0228247121,
-0.0831221566,
-0.0069066631,
0.0117992321,
0.023828702,
-0.0255034193,
0.0064232876,
0.0318495333,
0.0287456252,
0.0202205721,
0.0084407218,
0.0123997601,
-0.0301808268,
0.0271842033,
0.0145544074,
-0.0087985285,
0.0035191611,
0.0552755147,
0.0098750992,
-0.0380743854,
0.0004475414,
0.0107609164,
0.0658955425,
0.0212167986,
0.0194109213,
-0.0314309113,
0.0024257642,
0.0026195208,
0.0081893103,
0.050276123,
-0.0020920197,
0.0314698517,
0.0268783458,
-0.0107237389,
-0.017692484,
0.0042718207,
-0.0318336412,
-0.0856300369,
-0.0101946415,
0.0535115786,
0.0752615556,
0.0013938971,
0.0459385514,
-0.0702098086,
0.0065701357,
-0.0098916339,
0.0148933437,
0.0233684573,
0.0005503861,
0.0390983038,
-0.0189048331,
-0.024122823,
-0.0094962716,
0.0539414696,
0.0303057134,
0.0703911334,
0.0328353494,
-0.0025563573,
-0.0473446324,
-0.0173123926,
0.0502414852,
-0.0273739379,
-0.0100546954,
-0.0246856175,
-0.0115749231,
-0.0259692892,
-0.0397916809,
0.0595324412,
-0.0096058631,
-0.0354866572,
0.0006760522,
-0.0146920532,
0.0002936145,
-0.0717231482,
0.0020975261,
-0.0239069741,
-0.0058514532,
-0.0355748832,
-0.0122479815,
-6.367904895e-33,
-0.0379878283,
0.0201212987,
0.0561888032,
-0.0364771672,
-0.0061403299,
-0.0558170602,
-0.0280795768,
-0.0007389041,
-0.0142983273,
0.0181890335,
-0.0215523914,
0.0522064678,
0.0349163078,
0.001449112,
0.0215462707,
-0.036072433,
0.026068721,
0.0102878204,
-0.016934095,
0.0208950862,
0.042580951,
-0.0052232575,
0.0122456457,
-0.0510880202,
0.0193418842,
-0.0136048337,
-0.03884371,
0.0425752774,
-0.0089517338,
0.0427555777,
0.0124498978,
0.0155749815,
0.0127380611,
0.0065632416,
-0.0540973134,
0.0200521667,
-0.0062927171,
-0.0045213038,
0.0374788344,
0.0312339105,
-0.0383609757,
-0.0462285355,
0.06474749,
-0.0140720177,
-0.027874317,
0.0257046185,
0.0338023081,
-0.0256727971,
-0.0148184365,
0.0240984783,
-0.047511816,
0.0101940064,
0.0103895124,
-0.0157283079,
0.0067198947,
0.0145614324,
-0.0189505685,
-0.0319111757,
-0.029553039,
0.0032041362,
0.0061354586,
0.053730946,
0.0635530204,
-0.016726641,
0.0352174528,
0.01162952,
-0.0175569858,
-0.0621992275,
-0.0142813418,
-0.0062397853,
0.0307614263,
0.0523349829,
-0.0578323901,
0.0820661634,
-0.0057387576,
-0.0135693895,
-0.0755628571,
0.0294073801,
-0.0221434589,
0.0405326225,
0.0182098541,
0.0025549594,
-0.0817470849,
0.0058613815,
-0.0166327618,
0.0237062536,
0.0063620489,
-0.0503774025,
0.0570152439,
0.0189565998,
-0.029603174,
-0.0269165132,
0.0544911288,
-0.0736021549,
-0.0150153125,
0.0008053957,
-0.0237288568,
-0.0089525692,
0.0142139653,
0.0278774332,
-0.1140437275,
-0.0479294285,
-0.0290820189,
0.0019183828,
0.0239570141,
0.0178598668,
0.0046731979,
0.0446179248,
-0.0521266609,
0.0051948153,
-0.0484449267,
-0.016012108,
0.0551265553,
0.0149678653,
0.0500398129,
0.0135520576,
0.005902811,
0.0142707042,
-0.0246425476,
-0.0968898982,
-0.0020520953,
-0.0091563966,
0.0180818327,
0.0323336534,
-0.0276238434,
0.0408331379,
-0.0288765784,
0.0102563947,
0.0255908147,
-0.0180405322,
0.0127342679,
0.0107125333,
2.693e-7,
0.0052131172,
0.0166119523,
-0.0429890566,
0.0484632403,
0.0159279779,
0.043450769,
-0.0045530349,
0.0455089733,
-0.0324571729,
0.0314229019,
-0.0058604241,
0.0534401238,
0.0113140987,
-0.0055750348,
-0.0546599589,
0.0425622091,
0.0136402603,
0.0084299324,
-0.0497025661,
0.0186711531,
0.0403695814,
0.097659491,
-0.0252781585,
0.0123581402,
0.0751259848,
-0.0132340603,
0.0291889813,
-0.0692949295,
-0.0046903528,
0.0072080917,
0.0139379045,
0.0454397686,
0.0045444737,
-0.0002436207,
0.0045598876,
0.0163284447,
-0.0683112517,
0.1212604865,
-0.009450498,
-0.0136938263,
-0.0034353067,
-0.0861932561,
-0.0011912442,
-0.060974136,
0.0337448493,
0.0121468594,
0.0311309826,
-0.0020479898,
0.0054946458,
-0.0212440137,
-0.0191125069,
0.017929161,
0.0143743977,
-0.0258167759,
0.0404288471,
-0.0197594315,
-0.0043925499,
-0.0432905927,
0.0123496279,
0.0152836097,
0.0046577589,
0.0019269924,
-0.0117573002,
0.0618251748,
-0.0146897873,
-0.0153392348,
-0.0215246864,
1.955084041e-34,
0.0021908635,
0.0118236449,
0.0007989346,
0.0016490126,
-0.0177125707,
0.0253093801,
-0.0438869521,
0.0226497259,
-0.007689314,
-0.0371060856,
-0.0260287523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05930v1 | WebLINX: Real-World Website Navigation with Multi-Turn Dialogue | 2024-02-08T18:58:02 | 2024-02-08T18:58:02 | Xing Han Lù, Zdeněk Kasner, Siva Reddy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | We propose the problem of conversational web navigation, where a digital
agent controls a web browser and follows user instructions to solve real-world
tasks in a multi-turn dialogue fashion. To support this problem, we introduce
WEBLINX - a large-scale benchmark of 100K interactions across 2300 expert
demonstrations of conversational web navigation. Our benchmark covers a broad
range of patterns on over 150 real-world websites and can be used to train and
evaluate agents in diverse scenarios. Due to the magnitude of information
present, Large Language Models (LLMs) cannot process entire web pages in
real-time. To solve this bottleneck, we design a retrieval-inspired model that
efficiently prunes HTML pages by ranking relevant elements. We use the selected
elements, along with screenshots and action history, to assess a variety of
models for their ability to replicate human behavior when navigating the web.
Our experiments span from small text-only to proprietary multimodal LLMs. We
find that smaller finetuned decoders surpass the best zero-shot LLMs (including
GPT-4V), but also larger finetuned multimodal models which were explicitly
pretrained on screenshots. However, all finetuned models struggle to generalize
to unseen websites. Our findings highlight the need for large multimodal models
that can generalize to novel settings. Our code, data and models are available
for research: https://mcgill-nlp.github.io/weblinx | [
0.0344220214,
0.0478948839,
-0.0222284067,
0.0317713954,
-0.0015796213,
0.0297345705,
0.0109873563,
0.0167420544,
0.0335204862,
-0.0755936503,
-0.0372948982,
-0.0417457558,
-0.019630827,
0.0364649557,
0.0221067406,
-0.0835038871,
0.0131905889,
-0.0275412202,
-0.0017536609,
0.0231772885,
0.0203075781,
-0.0079565179,
-0.0449666344,
0.0542993769,
0.0139414603,
-0.0084678261,
-0.0491513275,
0.0269839205,
0.0271641593,
-0.0451057926,
0.0338524394,
0.0341133773,
0.0552144013,
0.0224934109,
0.0000018238,
0.0155641884,
0.0218077246,
-0.0366521142,
-0.0202501528,
-0.0089879017,
0.0024557256,
0.0106288074,
-0.0242136233,
0.0177740604,
-0.0382924601,
-0.0199808422,
0.0126872081,
0.0613406971,
0.0675394312,
0.1016172096,
-0.003305414,
-0.0104699163,
0.0170525741,
0.0038311505,
0.0073778648,
-0.0741327554,
-0.0098631103,
0.0146046113,
0.0014955222,
0.0178577397,
-0.0374939404,
0.0194435734,
-0.0061943177,
0.0093260882,
-0.0233010333,
0.0553721376,
-0.0251067393,
-0.0352342874,
-0.0122883068,
0.1218841597,
-0.025332775,
0.0133696608,
0.0247609187,
0.0230660178,
-0.0121640004,
-0.0156688094,
-0.0721450448,
0.0301444214,
-0.0237411056,
0.0054367934,
-0.0574598089,
-0.0073137097,
-0.0011576584,
0.0060589709,
-0.0283608027,
0.0016445343,
0.0022865583,
-0.0290910769,
0.0132094827,
0.0123476284,
0.0110425809,
-0.0196917839,
0.0389095582,
0.0355842076,
-0.0560919978,
0.0417513214,
-0.0233568233,
0.0318310261,
0.0100644566,
-0.0328070745,
0.0309034903,
0.032556124,
-0.0131577514,
0.0770412236,
-0.0148616834,
0.0367543846,
-0.0235360358,
0.0137640694,
-0.0259812996,
0.0175296683,
-0.0532260388,
0.0166417696,
-0.0168134682,
0.0165863931,
-0.0462552719,
-0.0547333024,
0.0259679686,
0.0684739426,
0.0093784733,
0.0304905307,
-0.0017384979,
0.0308260582,
-0.0268165506,
0.0158206746,
-0.0184625294,
0.0387217999,
-0.03386572,
0.0026262153,
0.0176321771,
-0.0814710632,
-0.0070239236,
0.0240461081,
0.0273074154,
-0.046190653,
-0.0313579366,
0.0995462611,
-0.0550061651,
-0.057931412,
-0.006743276,
-0.0145287262,
-0.0044692927,
-0.0399984866,
0.019380318,
-0.0187827758,
0.0824477449,
0.0160554498,
0.0127362004,
-0.0283886883,
0.0045496733,
0.04879665,
-0.0033123232,
0.0573065244,
0.0352338292,
0.0074154409,
0.0198384672,
0.0042364034,
-0.0148278764,
0.0537428446,
0.0112438174,
0.0843684077,
0.0455450527,
0.0056789499,
0.0296134409,
0.0407690443,
0.0047287229,
0.008374786,
0.0419355445,
0.0011394996,
0.0040665511,
0.041485671,
0.0437311456,
0.0617803372,
-0.069805935,
-0.021664476,
0.0853229389,
0.0245949812,
-0.0200338885,
-0.0003199656,
0.0157944802,
0.0270057246,
0.0193831827,
0.0117740678,
-0.0598725677,
0.0344611667,
-0.0380871557,
-0.0203963537,
0.0449274965,
0.0168140493,
-0.0423518941,
-0.0237082541,
0.0204325058,
0.0009947004,
0.0403082632,
0.0071578738,
0.058946833,
-0.0067501967,
-0.0747133493,
-0.006390709,
0.0033249671,
-0.0473396331,
-0.0090102144,
-0.0340763591,
-0.0075961216,
0.1007615402,
0.0697708875,
0.0021632125,
-0.0512221418,
-0.0164175499,
0.0265670717,
0.0137521569,
0.0432541892,
-0.0225755218,
0.0105414335,
-0.0370981917,
-0.0631309599,
0.0107707148,
-0.0087121716,
0.020671811,
0.0089073256,
-0.0036592665,
0.0188218746,
-0.024730321,
0.005373742,
0.0350008868,
0.0065226005,
-0.0279811528,
-0.0386396125,
0.0107252253,
0.0122938575,
-0.0025400079,
-0.0212411303,
-0.0212549921,
0.0301986821,
-0.014278803,
-0.0111490153,
-0.0030594163,
-0.018929949,
-0.071583502,
0.0371646136,
-0.0835617706,
-0.0067047239,
0.0842989683,
-0.046962887,
-0.025885243,
0.0178653821,
-0.0494435765,
-0.0017315416,
-0.0190251153,
0.0048970026,
0.0664070845,
0.0228572097,
-0.0287950449,
0.0376327373,
0.0021312076,
-0.0052265157,
0.0240988024,
0.0035533526,
-0.019711569,
-0.054383982,
-0.0443060845,
0.0181716029,
-0.0337262824,
0.0406592004,
0.0497775301,
0.0108818486,
-0.0697635263,
-0.0240540896,
-0.1046311632,
-0.003627084,
-0.0239064004,
-0.0029654757,
0.0104017202,
-0.0019614671,
0.0082703745,
-0.0437412374,
-0.0270988252,
0.010759864,
0.0176720135,
0.0336575769,
0.0162426401,
0.0112479171,
-0.0241465904,
-0.0617160909,
-0.018776007,
0.0233795177,
0.0345005505,
-0.0313334614,
-0.0225530919,
-0.0194459073,
-0.0047211754,
-0.0138380378,
0.0575330406,
-0.058032643,
-0.0604570471,
0.0404894389,
-0.0414105281,
-0.0205552671,
0.0982613042,
0.032198593,
0.0570109189,
0.0120888632,
-0.0381230302,
-0.0835025832,
0.0168849528,
-0.0022192521,
-0.0228409898,
-0.0993174762,
0.0026940419,
0.0226701107,
0.0516158566,
-0.0069105318,
0.036111705,
-0.0465912446,
-0.0012883438,
0.0139084449,
-0.0340195224,
-0.0190444048,
0.0453175642,
-0.038987387,
0.043846678,
-0.0162506849,
-0.0170422476,
0.0388486423,
-0.0120929554,
-0.0323479734,
0.0196356848,
0.01786796,
-0.0029072349,
0.0505092032,
0.0101806121,
0.0355578996,
-0.0179810133,
-0.0313311331,
-0.0497426912,
0.020603627,
0.0487201139,
-0.0412044525,
0.0521248095,
-0.042860914,
0.0258034952,
-0.0357430466,
-0.0588535853,
-0.0598057918,
-0.0233667567,
-0.00929581,
-0.0404107273,
-0.0099015227,
-0.0158394296,
-0.0644074529,
0.0067070643,
0.0426595695,
0.038111452,
0.000267879,
-0.0277960636,
-0.0322601944,
0.029613547,
0.0618634261,
0.0204060264,
-0.0455311835,
-0.0304843392,
0.0323570371,
0.0786961988,
0.0410260111,
-0.0112977065,
-0.0324286707,
-0.0045063556,
0.0323542096,
-0.0238814745,
-0.0067714206,
0.034932781,
0.018281579,
-0.0386776514,
-0.0113044474,
0.1188126653,
0.0318227224,
-0.0567240566,
-0.0323966555,
0.0117792692,
-0.0013735895,
0.0151207885,
0.0267408118,
-0.0501953214,
-0.0470288992,
0.0142080728,
0.0113893524,
0.0324859768,
0.0020630094,
0.018050367,
-0.0968584567,
0.0074423845,
0.0061430656,
0.0202307701,
0.0002171638,
-0.0305689815,
0.017180983,
-0.0172214005,
0.0256407354,
0.0500973053,
-0.009273503,
-0.0129391504,
0.0059513734,
0.0061496547,
-0.0378407054,
0.0284103565,
-0.0045798263,
0.0281190872,
0.0459348969,
0.0557654127,
0.0220312085,
-0.0295606032,
0.0123210475,
-0.0337056778,
0.0053319992,
-0.0057789679,
0.0819593146,
-0.0555315092,
-0.0045270291,
-0.0083623715,
0.0148942098,
-0.025119679,
0.0010057569,
-0.0007249127,
0.0253726523,
-0.0547918789,
-0.0126646319,
-0.0289105475,
-0.0292187706,
-0.0160248671,
0.046787899,
0.0194374565,
-0.0274996944,
-0.0921581686,
-0.0389234163,
-0.0091494471,
-0.0538095944,
-0.0241346881,
-0.0023706788,
0.0385913402,
-0.0232636817,
-0.1017919928,
-0.052888535,
0.0219458677,
0.0328609087,
-0.0112374509,
-0.0531514622,
0.0372872315,
0.0301438328,
-0.0281415246,
0.013871083,
-0.0573208109,
0.0199890621,
-0.0570978038,
0.0022677728,
0.0543736555,
-0.058404658,
-0.0144030601,
0.0322188325,
-0.0538686477,
-0.0459206142,
-0.0236961823,
0.0513961278,
0.0184664782,
0.0471071228,
-0.0245165937,
-0.0474356338,
-0.0082994336,
-0.0125014791,
-0.0529731549,
-0.0246942453,
0.0495218262,
0.0317195319,
-0.0230631977,
0.0198916383,
-0.071995154,
0.0076392917,
-0.0425683446,
0.0359103866,
-0.0429387763,
-0.0363033004,
0.0372308418,
-0.0142492671,
0.0561889485,
0.0178203192,
0.0121659115,
0.0112388106,
0.0270190723,
0.0192762818,
-0.0119164363,
-0.0474453904,
-0.0054972749,
0.0202742461,
-0.0000062771,
0.020701535,
-0.0063392292,
0.0036044554,
0.0060146642,
-0.0454218127,
-0.0294217858,
0.0275735129,
-0.0228512716,
0.007556452,
0.0074935332,
-0.0205706507,
0.0223867539,
0.0320162773,
0.0272535998,
-0.0095355175,
0.049268771,
0.0425444618,
-0.0340004973,
-0.0045810966,
0.0480768047,
-0.0532839261,
-0.0272840913,
-0.0282166898,
0.0022602805,
0.0634032264,
0.0309936479,
0.0604740344,
-0.0055696578,
0.0220658705,
-0.0323700979,
0.0298233423,
-0.0085086524,
-0.0227475557,
0.0222840328,
0.0400202721,
0.0193841383,
-0.0006488429,
0.0742514059,
0.0020255221,
0.0136028593,
0.0110149626,
-0.0101388078,
-0.056870617,
-0.0374981537,
-0.0133701507,
0.0447454304,
0.0011750226,
-0.0239369012,
0.0025995269,
-0.0316908285,
-0.0348051116,
0.0031722852,
-0.013550153,
-0.0341200195,
0.0580445752,
0.0509573743,
0.0169842709,
0.0008681957,
-0.0367626846,
-0.0206805933,
-0.0071697268,
-0.0104654869,
-0.0426590703,
-5.843703842e-33,
-0.0141237648,
-0.0319506191,
0.043345578,
-0.0002939767,
-0.0391614176,
-0.0362773947,
-0.0652258918,
0.0112635354,
-0.0393810868,
-0.0185776334,
-0.0161287952,
0.0062038279,
0.0221893359,
0.0641469881,
-0.0218425114,
-0.0242743511,
0.0593562573,
-0.0044364049,
-0.0377255641,
0.0524616502,
0.0233385824,
0.0257784314,
0.0238866396,
-0.0270361975,
-0.0182719901,
-0.0278531276,
-0.0329044834,
-0.0074178083,
0.0075064907,
0.0658196434,
-0.0517149232,
0.0436630994,
0.022895867,
-0.0149768954,
-0.0013895443,
0.0112325102,
-0.0924821794,
-0.0139447013,
-0.024426233,
0.0560580269,
-0.013862987,
0.0268214755,
0.0207772255,
-0.0138625093,
-0.0052710902,
0.006007378,
0.0392158106,
-0.0129145859,
-0.0417731367,
-0.0125060771,
-0.0492613986,
0.0214133151,
-0.0257142689,
-0.07007882,
0.0354605317,
0.0915489718,
0.0224840697,
-0.0055643809,
-0.0400167853,
0.0222563297,
-0.0119602364,
0.0171893314,
0.0723365545,
0.0063561667,
0.0049784565,
0.0838940591,
0.0204479899,
0.016352741,
-0.0188761111,
-0.0063660387,
0.0368696935,
0.0664397106,
-0.0249522999,
0.0372445658,
-0.004241928,
-0.0015084804,
-0.0068892012,
0.0553374216,
0.0545299686,
0.0660556555,
0.0117577426,
0.0308063366,
-0.0214643236,
0.0054042619,
-0.0363315977,
-0.0001983158,
-0.0282973442,
-0.0328005962,
0.0617464669,
0.0540101789,
-0.0039616735,
-0.0386689343,
0.0742677823,
-0.0495066158,
-0.0303022079,
0.0493006073,
-0.029484069,
0.0508918352,
-0.0089744413,
-0.0223215204,
0.0046339338,
-0.0788986087,
0.0439089984,
-0.0210814979,
-0.0107128583,
0.0022639036,
-0.0236877687,
0.0193290431,
-0.0476005338,
-0.0131821223,
-0.0569415502,
0.0160213541,
-0.007909582,
0.0325785726,
0.0467637107,
-0.0208251905,
-0.0651634112,
0.0498165712,
-0.0203285068,
-0.0197547078,
-0.0376983881,
-0.0644614846,
0.005707934,
-0.0076544536,
-0.0444191657,
-0.0097637149,
-0.0384594351,
0.0366409533,
0.0110456282,
-0.0574164838,
-0.0097484337,
0.0446598567,
2.605e-7,
-0.0183173548,
0.0499349423,
0.0182775259,
0.02391693,
0.0303197391,
0.0410102196,
-0.0268284921,
0.0387952253,
0.0125377746,
-0.0555376746,
0.0089435158,
0.054948654,
0.0294478387,
0.0128739337,
-0.048737783,
-0.0201576445,
-0.0222802311,
-0.0275216922,
-0.0383437611,
-0.025182033,
0.0440972969,
0.0744614825,
-0.0215246659,
-0.0139166238,
0.0396833085,
-0.0003111973,
0.0544199012,
-0.0090620611,
-0.0145688877,
-0.0005204168,
0.0124478238,
0.0277252868,
-0.0094407275,
-0.0043511461,
-0.0042622699,
-0.005526986,
0.0309000928,
0.0559796505,
-0.0062810979,
-0.0636532232,
0.001724437,
-0.0170349553,
0.0189610049,
-0.034634728,
0.0765883997,
-0.0119785601,
0.0066672727,
0.0153693408,
-0.0458778404,
-0.0365035422,
-0.0218762904,
-0.0358332358,
-0.0111533981,
0.0145434085,
-0.0080740945,
0.0009158599,
-0.0091668256,
-0.1201356128,
-0.009405111,
-0.0030283425,
-0.0476486869,
-0.0365653187,
-0.03634822,
-0.0080400705,
0.0273346007,
-0.0069550686,
-0.0284632556,
1.870781237e-34,
0.0300612357,
0.0043927026,
0.0125682233,
0.0225166604,
0.0322332457,
0.0264430977,
-0.0132467179,
0.0037358706,
0.0227895416,
-0.0665657297,
-0.0256152451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05926v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05926v3 | On the Convergence of Zeroth-Order Federated Tuning for Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T18:56:40 | 2024-06-17T16:00:59 | Zhenqing Ling, Daoyuan Chen, Liuyi Yao, Yaliang Li, Ying Shen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The confluence of Federated Learning (FL) and Large Language Models (LLMs) is
ushering in a new era in privacy-preserving natural language processing.
However, the intensive memory requirements for fine-tuning LLMs pose
significant challenges, especially when deploying on clients with limited
computational resources. To circumvent this, we explore the novel integration
of Memory-efficient Zeroth-Order Optimization within a federated setting, a
synergy we term as FedMeZO. Our study is the first to examine the theoretical
underpinnings of FedMeZO in the context of LLMs, tackling key questions
regarding the influence of large parameter spaces on optimization behavior, the
establishment of convergence properties, and the identification of critical
parameters for convergence to inform personalized federated strategies. Our
extensive empirical evidence supports the theory, showing that FedMeZO not only
converges faster than traditional first-order methods such as FedAvg but also
significantly reduces GPU memory usage during training to levels comparable to
those during inference. Moreover, the proposed personalized FL strategy that is
built upon the theoretical insights to customize the client-wise learning rate
can effectively accelerate loss reduction. We hope our work can help to bridge
theoretical and practical aspects of federated fine-tuning for LLMs, thereby
stimulating further advancements and research in this area. | [
0.0138837881,
0.1061683372,
-0.0126705775,
0.0582923815,
-0.0356483832,
-0.007044049,
0.0504814722,
-0.0129852239,
0.0151304267,
-0.0090115825,
-0.0702624172,
-0.0771670491,
0.0287563782,
0.0055502062,
-0.0066968156,
0.0091989944,
0.0092439679,
-0.0346369892,
-0.0152085777,
-0.0367650427,
-0.0405309163,
-0.0046716686,
0.0169658307,
0.0163281411,
0.0216977969,
-0.0504181422,
-0.0084255822,
0.0053035407,
0.0070784218,
0.0091172149,
0.0166198444,
0.0553276464,
0.0219450016,
0.1024195701,
0.000002031,
-0.0289995391,
-0.0277864467,
0.0153002758,
-0.008960668,
0.0772237256,
0.0045714211,
-0.0159243718,
0.0089010503,
0.0164243188,
-0.0302899033,
-0.0334783271,
0.0285421181,
-0.0137200896,
0.040794149,
0.1061362699,
0.0031307868,
-0.0361275598,
0.0131839551,
-0.0601303279,
-0.106390357,
-0.0524131469,
0.0077564735,
-0.0561423115,
-0.0462788753,
-0.0235048831,
-0.0050692731,
0.016910078,
0.0069368598,
0.036644876,
0.0046292595,
0.0193468966,
-0.0448777191,
-0.0276873019,
-0.043373365,
0.0407459289,
-0.014198971,
0.0114664417,
0.0157618355,
-0.0228264183,
-0.0030180397,
0.0174897164,
0.0016167893,
0.0412298851,
-0.0113924472,
0.0269340724,
0.0162901599,
-0.0385323837,
0.0422550328,
0.0155828763,
-0.0188869238,
0.1050273925,
-0.0172128566,
0.0121091669,
-0.0094279842,
-0.0439630561,
-0.0646860898,
-0.0457575619,
0.0282830577,
0.0238996465,
-0.0081369281,
-0.0272712689,
-0.0612821057,
-0.0799707025,
0.0129340682,
-0.0073956526,
0.0577472933,
-0.0147772674,
0.0550179593,
0.0495547205,
-0.004698379,
0.0030277905,
-0.0177576095,
0.0140246507,
-0.0149220061,
0.0440983027,
-0.0264132489,
0.001706915,
-0.0045098984,
0.0603232048,
-0.0739647225,
-0.0061796219,
0.0054705678,
0.0282681771,
-0.0171094276,
0.0196432211,
-0.0093666613,
0.0096850768,
-0.0276523288,
-0.024268901,
0.0184388217,
0.0165572427,
-0.0305507537,
0.0216880534,
0.0007841776,
-0.0317765549,
-0.0223289542,
0.0002563467,
-0.0012518212,
-0.0054530185,
-0.0129368538,
0.0438118055,
-0.0007562296,
-0.0176214408,
0.0176814888,
-0.0536943153,
0.0456813946,
-0.0650448501,
0.0083312979,
-0.0399746783,
0.0049734097,
-0.0005421043,
0.0182327181,
-0.0405477807,
-0.0083277747,
-0.0074429824,
-0.0381368063,
0.0749998763,
-0.0121079898,
-0.0015234469,
-0.0284668338,
-0.0073753595,
0.0443238243,
0.0927840248,
0.0199909508,
0.0105967252,
0.0587675348,
-0.0000544057,
-0.0293437093,
-0.000691159,
0.0418235958,
0.0693773627,
0.0003351468,
-0.0106752841,
-0.011859186,
0.0334242545,
0.0083751623,
0.0218452029,
-0.0160663854,
-0.0540636964,
0.0405717604,
0.0788892433,
0.061351601,
0.0149817355,
-0.0626623407,
0.0249997526,
0.0181302037,
0.0339430682,
-0.0450028703,
-0.021651553,
-0.0580204912,
-0.0216111355,
0.0095350491,
0.0713924319,
-0.0130566955,
-0.024721818,
-0.0108640855,
-0.0462708734,
-0.0109639755,
-0.0063271914,
0.0070445989,
-0.0200547315,
-0.0087906774,
0.0188567769,
-0.0012862977,
-0.0196577366,
-0.0265754778,
-0.0306149106,
-0.0168916322,
0.0587942265,
0.0592631809,
-0.0406661704,
-0.0197071191,
-0.0203724522,
0.0162047334,
-0.0049421163,
-0.0367487893,
0.0242837761,
0.0797587261,
-0.0207030475,
-0.0370295197,
0.0294632688,
0.0138828102,
0.0119107123,
-0.0330853462,
-0.0075053945,
-0.018741563,
0.0159955267,
-0.0072433301,
0.0125846695,
0.0110085309,
-0.0435448736,
0.043995671,
0.0189795978,
0.0470193438,
-0.0114182355,
-0.0316644274,
0.0015975485,
0.0088175815,
0.0008972647,
-0.0142934788,
-0.0504045077,
-0.0087646805,
0.002010179,
-0.0010095795,
-0.0097156484,
0.0440130159,
0.0535080731,
-0.0488389917,
-0.0178426728,
-0.0154147632,
0.0140805626,
0.067335166,
-0.026320586,
0.0289005861,
-0.0243234355,
0.0573183633,
-0.024666667,
-0.0010654419,
-0.0781513825,
-0.0259352997,
-0.0247729942,
-0.0323643014,
-0.0062401528,
-0.0078440895,
0.0336070806,
0.0112547716,
0.0311622713,
0.0360950492,
0.0093392618,
0.0169439651,
0.0174929947,
-0.0001761299,
-0.0190944299,
0.0409160182,
-0.0478896499,
0.0359025188,
0.0104791485,
-0.0024150938,
-0.0151580665,
-0.0150026502,
0.022572292,
0.0326921046,
-0.0410102792,
0.0361468717,
0.0059831515,
0.0203144271,
-0.0581321605,
0.0248673018,
-0.0441329107,
0.00994597,
0.0454097912,
-0.034984421,
-0.0290705711,
-0.0480915494,
0.0275820661,
-0.019404212,
0.0422015637,
0.002121943,
-0.0147805661,
-0.0154812122,
0.0218674242,
-0.0292934049,
0.0803897232,
-0.0096803652,
0.0249023046,
0.0415974297,
0.0343596004,
0.0028645184,
-0.0069119274,
-0.0386426523,
-0.0398873389,
-0.0298640803,
0.0529475398,
0.0627475828,
0.0394875668,
-0.0285429768,
-0.0442877747,
-0.0222450737,
0.0769043639,
0.0086667724,
-0.0269865878,
-0.0285270475,
0.0281904247,
0.0093335509,
0.0305437669,
0.0125495316,
-0.088392958,
0.0707248822,
-0.0220458731,
0.0305812787,
-0.0223316606,
-0.0229276549,
-0.0611107349,
0.0309867114,
0.0132670728,
0.0385068022,
0.0155495526,
-0.040744625,
0.0035099296,
0.0296356417,
0.0469105393,
-0.0279914569,
0.0175308976,
-0.0039123292,
-0.0066890717,
-0.0119070252,
-0.0500178039,
0.0203367304,
-0.0806319341,
-0.0137128979,
0.0121731916,
0.0039566695,
-0.0297135711,
-0.0094531337,
0.0033604775,
-0.0126367426,
0.0169665646,
-0.0157422628,
0.0089240102,
-0.020355681,
0.0208689682,
0.0105196545,
-0.0090317558,
0.0005262959,
-0.0268524848,
-0.0003554939,
0.0524064079,
0.0584051684,
0.0032559307,
0.0596301854,
-0.0418731123,
0.0443691202,
-0.0263141766,
-0.0414049141,
0.0015487284,
0.0349646136,
-0.0331055224,
0.0162854623,
0.0590875149,
0.0014777662,
-0.0632062703,
0.0050481753,
-0.0044916989,
0.0844994336,
0.0094126165,
0.011238046,
-0.0815813243,
-0.0199212525,
0.0118793994,
0.0555601344,
-0.0010107555,
-0.0473812297,
-0.0409058183,
-0.0899872407,
-0.0125063034,
0.0385287702,
-0.0182323083,
-0.0398753844,
-0.0396803021,
0.0152727365,
0.0067457412,
0.0109138247,
-0.0019807988,
-0.0019382718,
-0.0281032026,
-0.0010796388,
-0.0083896173,
-0.0382313877,
-0.0321197473,
-0.0150344735,
0.0438428856,
-0.0033180008,
-0.0032652451,
0.0049073822,
-0.0806202888,
-0.000814715,
0.0396597497,
-0.0158081725,
-0.0358074792,
0.006161503,
-0.0412752554,
0.0094105024,
0.0124699427,
0.0527864285,
-0.0026398648,
0.0049058916,
0.0159356985,
0.040199317,
-0.014310617,
-0.0121771963,
0.0189951267,
-0.0307011623,
0.0452007949,
0.0379840322,
0.0074213771,
-0.0369424149,
-0.0312215257,
-0.0073170387,
0.0121627636,
0.0046625626,
0.0045436602,
0.0130039817,
0.0178512502,
-0.0045601856,
-0.0046607251,
0.0504361652,
-0.0208830331,
0.0484742485,
0.0156236235,
0.0334445052,
0.0417409949,
0.0055974061,
-0.0150177991,
0.0488851145,
-0.0553900637,
0.0143536357,
-0.08646705,
-0.0266251285,
0.0230672229,
0.0050384006,
-0.0273041446,
0.0410264693,
-0.0890698284,
-0.0689579248,
0.0084084002,
0.0059918109,
0.0144732175,
0.0498646349,
-0.0083944211,
-0.0926057026,
0.0456902497,
0.0539300404,
-0.0579320379,
0.0489357375,
0.0727500021,
-0.0642599761,
0.0097295474,
0.0671549067,
-0.0002696369,
-0.0136075458,
0.052613873,
-0.0120931165,
0.0295970645,
-0.0720994547,
-0.0320863351,
0.0426307693,
0.071472235,
-0.0097142113,
0.0187067296,
-0.0290843006,
0.0573986024,
-0.0193972979,
0.0062056924,
-0.0132868988,
-0.0287363939,
0.016207533,
-0.0119159753,
-0.0105141141,
-0.0276813563,
0.0559328385,
-0.0076667173,
-0.0201278757,
0.0056453566,
0.0209967308,
-0.072228156,
0.0732253417,
0.0033053544,
0.0010925769,
0.0778171867,
0.0186631195,
0.0666176677,
-0.0228372719,
0.0344647318,
-0.0122403577,
0.0268530399,
-0.0819366947,
0.0479548611,
-0.0382282175,
-0.1459070593,
-0.0117217349,
0.01759547,
0.0317545459,
-0.0025175207,
0.002393604,
-0.0183016434,
-0.0141244605,
-0.0289469063,
0.0114053311,
-0.0351638086,
-0.018963933,
-0.0030445915,
-0.0182181094,
-0.0041206903,
0.0961220413,
0.0958948731,
0.0350827873,
0.00903056,
-0.0379214138,
-0.0149113862,
-0.047199171,
-0.0273700524,
-0.0046190238,
0.0590376928,
-0.0188899729,
0.0180146676,
-0.0441164039,
-0.0564153194,
-0.0085838893,
-0.0288899336,
0.000432493,
-0.0217418429,
0.0210378077,
0.0118663423,
-0.0231839754,
-0.0214886945,
-0.0581925698,
0.0114503521,
0.0173689183,
0.0028100326,
0.0215186868,
-6.633151522e-33,
-0.0137390299,
-0.0093131149,
-0.0259688385,
0.041463308,
0.0048216577,
0.0287235286,
0.017545633,
0.0207819436,
0.0109143192,
-0.0250213146,
-0.054498598,
0.0034339565,
0.014104411,
0.0412911065,
-0.0318681151,
0.0100947721,
0.0394580103,
-0.0580120832,
-0.042777542,
0.0292197447,
0.0450806245,
0.0281081516,
0.020166371,
-0.027777534,
-0.0033630396,
-0.0003601716,
-0.0059047388,
0.0524396747,
-0.0379254967,
0.0251689497,
-0.0299947616,
0.0358267426,
0.0113975843,
-0.0368909761,
0.0026077738,
0.0093976781,
-0.029111661,
0.0048059663,
-0.0021214418,
-0.0075277658,
-0.0355951414,
-0.0566677228,
0.0453161299,
0.0103805345,
-0.0176973082,
-0.0347482748,
-0.0134595595,
0.0100343712,
-0.0534028783,
-0.0371789001,
-0.0134697231,
0.0141996555,
0.0102612618,
0.0105610853,
0.0482091904,
0.0009258668,
-0.0156055978,
-0.0159899238,
-0.0435281545,
-0.0057723988,
0.0524107628,
0.0266469456,
0.056083262,
0.0463305041,
0.0190200135,
0.0360614434,
0.0673989728,
0.0346522406,
-0.0400366113,
0.0295997243,
0.0042041047,
0.0012452954,
-0.0333854929,
-0.0145542873,
-0.0004954863,
-0.056736961,
-0.0551154427,
-0.0359938629,
0.012425554,
-0.0140851364,
0.0403783172,
0.0310889985,
-0.0227017906,
-0.0171453431,
-0.0295094997,
-0.0103726443,
-0.0195648167,
0.0452638529,
-0.0190791693,
0.0289811008,
-0.0546641983,
-0.0539754555,
0.0409027748,
-0.0311419033,
-0.0094847558,
0.013439483,
0.06877473,
0.0046611633,
0.0031275472,
0.0247671343,
-0.0700405911,
-0.0169873908,
-0.0465821177,
-0.0224956349,
0.0339868553,
-0.0150437988,
0.060644716,
0.0212521926,
-0.0592239648,
-0.0212556887,
-0.0248662941,
0.0332035422,
0.0209688768,
0.0642874613,
0.0671885461,
-0.0321188569,
0.0116851125,
0.0438194796,
0.0233007316,
0.0067619486,
-0.039839495,
-0.0058859168,
0.0030256039,
-0.0063075144,
0.0100153927,
-0.0063210232,
-0.0116939256,
0.0016659506,
0.0750652626,
-0.0324145183,
-0.0100012822,
-0.0365441851,
2.857e-7,
-0.0067433999,
0.0269305408,
-0.0406177714,
-0.0518727154,
0.0446351469,
0.0356694311,
-0.0176778156,
0.0267264321,
-0.0115287825,
0.0166713744,
-0.0044090599,
0.0062778429,
0.0248416346,
-0.0229367204,
-0.0598201267,
-0.0167517215,
-0.0143777458,
0.085251689,
-0.0590577684,
-0.0505889915,
-0.0526184216,
0.092936188,
0.0118269278,
-0.0285400711,
0.002924093,
-0.024315469,
0.0515510514,
-0.0256621819,
-0.0302061737,
0.0047084652,
0.0395059474,
0.1026617661,
-0.0218768567,
-0.0159128103,
0.0082047349,
0.0521939769,
-0.0433136076,
0.1037724391,
0.0171164218,
0.0095273983,
0.0185760502,
-0.0303604435,
-0.0373588242,
0.0133808171,
0.0674703717,
-0.031206917,
-0.0409543589,
-0.0254981611,
0.0689284205,
-0.0692190677,
0.0598366894,
-0.0134218717,
-0.0058264043,
0.0239367224,
-0.0019036907,
-0.0222855955,
-0.0146544958,
-0.066419974,
0.0015097894,
0.0073509291,
-0.0424907915,
-0.0532962829,
-0.0170580335,
0.0271578785,
0.0102231996,
-0.0441958643,
0.0033865103,
2.76249782e-34,
0.0349472389,
-0.0441199727,
0.0411491618,
0.0070703002,
0.0172727294,
-0.0370718203,
0.0100930231,
0.0044517796,
0.0279133543,
-0.0759044588,
0.0021828385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05913v1 | Efficient Stagewise Pretraining via Progressive Subnetworks | 2024-02-08T18:49:09 | 2024-02-08T18:49:09 | Abhishek Panigrahi, Nikunj Saunshi, Kaifeng Lyu, Sobhan Miryoosefi, Sashank Reddi, Satyen Kale, Sanjiv Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent developments in large language models have sparked interest in
efficient pretraining methods. A recent effective paradigm is to perform
stage-wise training, where the size of the model is gradually increased over
the course of training (e.g. gradual stacking (Reddi et al., 2023)). While the
resource and wall-time savings are appealing, it has limitations, particularly
the inability to evaluate the full model during earlier stages, and degradation
in model quality due to smaller model capacity in the initial stages. In this
work, we propose an alternative framework, progressive subnetwork training,
that maintains the full model throughout training, but only trains subnetworks
within the model in each step. We focus on a simple instantiation of this
framework, Random Path Training (RaPTr) that only trains a sub-path of layers
in each step, progressively increasing the path lengths in stages. RaPTr
achieves better pre-training loss for BERT and UL2 language models while
requiring 20-33% fewer FLOPs compared to standard training, and is competitive
or better than other efficient training methods. Furthermore, RaPTr shows
better downstream performance on UL2, improving QA tasks and SuperGLUE by 1-5%
compared to standard training and stacking. Finally, we provide a theoretical
basis for RaPTr to justify (a) the increasing complexity of subnetworks in
stages, and (b) the stability in loss across stage transitions due to residual
connections and layer norm. | [
-0.0156663302,
0.0707443506,
-0.0005245768,
0.0239923447,
-0.0238460731,
0.0045681619,
0.0376336835,
-0.0339842811,
-0.0301896594,
0.0063449,
-0.0414280221,
-0.0619279556,
-0.0284846649,
0.0013597594,
0.0457521603,
-0.0611168593,
0.0361879505,
-0.036571227,
-0.0273793284,
-0.0257498436,
0.0057721315,
0.0062831487,
-0.0310476143,
0.030319076,
-0.0063490458,
-0.01219586,
-0.0356456973,
0.0338706225,
0.0202883594,
-0.0383018591,
0.0177200288,
0.0386419818,
0.0438612662,
0.0297390576,
0.0000022918,
0.0032000623,
0.0213066749,
0.0098921172,
-0.0315809064,
0.0853706673,
0.014628483,
0.0437646881,
-0.0620820075,
0.0244483668,
0.0080605084,
-0.0166197345,
0.0742933974,
0.0336753838,
0.054230731,
0.0524800494,
-0.0105786119,
-0.0377098061,
0.0277948938,
-0.0471994802,
-0.0458056107,
-0.0547549166,
0.0149192363,
-0.0148947518,
-0.0355971158,
-0.0769417733,
-0.0012942426,
0.0000179009,
0.0523610078,
0.0201754197,
-0.0095943641,
0.0501912385,
-0.0310137141,
-0.0276215486,
-0.0194744151,
0.067079708,
-0.0832976252,
-0.0114772553,
-0.0279110428,
-0.0148841869,
-0.0420438126,
-0.0255470667,
-0.014960506,
0.0139377108,
0.0138121294,
0.0154824881,
-0.0308304019,
-0.0077134278,
0.0553151295,
-0.0043792925,
-0.0545279197,
0.024594048,
0.0338563435,
-0.039603658,
0.0293587502,
0.0141279474,
-0.0319342241,
-0.0359433629,
0.0127656022,
-0.0034184137,
0.0128335943,
0.0196475033,
-0.0409064293,
-0.0182263516,
-0.0183589794,
-0.0503762737,
0.0730040669,
0.0402325168,
-0.0287107825,
0.0182574335,
-0.0524530895,
-0.0028151709,
-0.0396503955,
0.0376165286,
-0.0317477994,
0.0216023177,
0.017564455,
0.0017498177,
-0.1047539935,
0.0224834345,
-0.043133799,
-0.0326196887,
-0.0397591963,
0.0205155313,
-0.0010721548,
-0.0281622261,
0.0122253131,
0.0036096596,
-0.0279591717,
-0.0217010248,
0.037810076,
0.025563905,
-0.0219863504,
0.0435318947,
-0.0007612231,
-0.0471442491,
-0.0255547874,
0.0081979623,
-0.0113847209,
-0.0112898229,
0.0231877249,
0.0570878536,
-0.0284792334,
-0.0372902267,
-0.0965662599,
0.0057113748,
0.0140374098,
-0.0671343803,
0.0116038341,
-0.0532478653,
0.0124064069,
-0.0303534232,
0.0033305918,
0.0047898055,
0.0000034126,
0.0137457997,
-0.0062413672,
0.0150502967,
-0.0209739786,
-0.0202013329,
0.0155694112,
0.006474182,
0.0339437649,
0.0491280071,
0.0466473512,
0.0238278024,
0.004502648,
-0.0215741973,
-0.051320143,
0.0634934679,
0.0706701353,
0.0077235512,
-0.0226323474,
-0.0182315093,
0.0392886177,
0.0167288277,
0.0661823824,
0.0267973673,
-0.081891492,
0.0062085339,
0.0399523079,
0.0438422784,
0.023956947,
0.0761910379,
0.0303585976,
-0.0045894636,
0.0465787947,
-0.0017749151,
-0.0408047028,
-0.0037446024,
0.0142385811,
0.0066287424,
0.0078182705,
0.0422811657,
-0.0608098209,
-0.0293346476,
0.0028514445,
-0.0106646931,
-0.0020650583,
-0.0053823143,
0.0330049023,
0.0013304392,
-0.0691422448,
0.0763258338,
0.0599092469,
-0.067441605,
-0.0055458085,
-0.0558223538,
-0.0284395702,
0.0480276905,
0.0055960077,
-0.0130410241,
-0.0353233144,
0.0250997134,
0.0349405073,
0.0007516417,
0.0319759808,
0.0012826296,
0.0418668054,
-0.0497114733,
-0.0242889859,
0.004986072,
-0.0005248857,
0.0496660098,
0.0087758675,
-0.0044272295,
-0.0142752025,
-0.0467510819,
-0.0052905758,
0.0282342546,
-0.0611387827,
-0.0057805185,
0.005393785,
0.0070725619,
0.0315335542,
0.0025872695,
-0.062874265,
-0.0116535434,
0.0334606208,
-0.0237973463,
-0.0253444593,
0.0021569391,
-0.0711934194,
-0.0267727878,
0.014174806,
0.0516411252,
0.0037618892,
0.0572221912,
-0.048051741,
-0.0278842729,
0.0252512656,
0.0017884002,
0.1002530828,
-0.0455115885,
0.0066446979,
0.0134592783,
0.0034849639,
-0.0188196488,
0.0329918824,
-0.0202751458,
-0.0180146284,
0.0095324293,
0.0119241988,
0.0119621893,
-0.0550153032,
-0.0235109422,
0.0048212539,
-0.0097948397,
0.0290608164,
-0.0212409943,
0.0120171485,
-0.0183315556,
-0.0176750422,
-0.0908401832,
0.0175834522,
-0.0525034368,
0.0619416423,
0.0086632743,
0.0008169989,
-0.0136779696,
-0.0288962591,
0.0030567825,
-0.006639549,
-0.036281649,
-0.0095742121,
-0.0366322435,
0.0123797981,
-0.0325432867,
-0.0334620662,
-0.0612367541,
0.0237766337,
0.0644224137,
-0.0263998453,
-0.0297943205,
-0.0153935477,
-0.0193516389,
-0.005595691,
0.051679723,
0.0008064669,
-0.0683651865,
-0.0212314036,
-0.0013164539,
0.0110388286,
0.0511350296,
-0.0110141784,
0.0116487266,
0.0058866395,
0.0163757876,
0.0060025854,
0.0391365476,
-0.030354796,
-0.0430371985,
-0.0522882454,
0.0173261557,
-0.0062193451,
0.0862757042,
-0.0020767639,
0.0144209405,
-0.0411366895,
-0.0564859621,
-0.0100133661,
-0.0178676397,
-0.0140791275,
-0.0351000838,
-0.0194698796,
-0.0119814491,
-0.0152954049,
-0.0337052941,
0.0384570137,
-0.0480566062,
-0.0173350871,
-0.0556994453,
-0.0273208581,
0.0060341125,
0.0289991256,
0.0389169715,
0.0444914363,
-0.0191142987,
-0.0344017632,
-0.0303539634,
0.004072669,
-0.0114162639,
0.0115461126,
-0.005558582,
-0.0326125324,
0.0364573225,
-0.0202562492,
-0.0758701563,
-0.0244198274,
-0.0152367409,
-0.0072710267,
0.0335632823,
0.000814157,
-0.0504705682,
0.01146439,
0.0173872113,
-0.0090750847,
0.0836414322,
0.0005070192,
0.0128607666,
-0.0086984653,
0.0679272711,
-0.0050880946,
-0.0105349179,
0.0160499439,
-0.0289763473,
0.0335990377,
0.0280636195,
0.0584300645,
0.0183275789,
-0.056291014,
0.0106692789,
0.0137820402,
-0.0239429679,
-0.0280717034,
0.0242305696,
0.0581843369,
-0.066000551,
0.0030860717,
0.057426177,
0.0185607504,
-0.0195974018,
0.0074107316,
0.046261996,
0.0744788721,
0.0016216419,
0.0185908694,
-0.052295696,
-0.0282746926,
0.0074863494,
0.0302533116,
0.0527865626,
0.0205931794,
0.0090758055,
-0.0937589705,
0.0327155814,
0.0135196466,
-0.0330237262,
0.0252371952,
-0.0546873771,
-0.0247125234,
-0.013569708,
0.0577002242,
0.016747918,
-0.0177455489,
-0.0227059759,
0.0637956262,
-0.0312615745,
-0.0568799488,
0.0306036081,
-0.0448253155,
0.0125070363,
0.0467802659,
-0.0155522553,
0.0000632322,
-0.024385035,
0.1129475906,
-0.048229672,
0.0186919551,
0.0145018175,
0.0378692523,
0.0100165708,
-0.0210380107,
-0.0047065113,
0.0028674204,
0.015626682,
-0.0150465211,
-0.024417486,
0.0519255958,
0.0043343743,
-0.0024707739,
0.0070783063,
0.001689134,
-0.0147033073,
0.0331942663,
0.006956805,
-0.0376822948,
-0.0308474451,
0.0016986211,
0.0323769562,
-0.0685776472,
-0.0131103471,
0.0345570371,
-0.0191355478,
-0.0276521798,
-0.018980436,
0.0046648826,
-0.0060861167,
0.0847565383,
-0.0124462349,
-0.0402481295,
0.0375628248,
0.039029412,
-0.0696837381,
0.0477186926,
-0.0171475075,
0.0190372188,
-0.0649295449,
-0.0365071595,
0.0201152582,
-0.0001172584,
-0.0368756987,
-0.0212954581,
-0.0881500989,
-0.0577359609,
0.0113482773,
0.0419978499,
0.0162400641,
0.0666758567,
0.0245323256,
-0.0470451228,
0.0756766871,
-0.0129384194,
-0.0030208447,
0.0403194502,
0.071336247,
-0.0556563102,
-0.0127303591,
0.0272413474,
-0.0264799073,
0.0367367528,
0.0259802714,
0.031606935,
0.0030408592,
0.006878247,
-0.0062948335,
-0.0292932708,
0.0532230474,
0.0250712018,
0.0126122283,
-0.0476829037,
0.0743489042,
0.0204024408,
0.0350882895,
-0.0504531525,
-0.0064446027,
0.0177572388,
0.0114844358,
0.0136188166,
0.0193978548,
0.0543921404,
0.0232638344,
-0.0179059971,
0.0205261502,
0.0151376305,
0.0122175179,
0.0497934744,
0.0033102429,
-0.0279776622,
-0.0158582944,
-0.0094450042,
-0.0058882693,
-0.0398662835,
0.0039482564,
0.0214152895,
0.0130906617,
-0.0368113331,
0.0268866289,
-0.0444262736,
-0.0723435283,
-0.057035286,
0.0232388806,
0.0761684105,
-0.0092198458,
0.0145957749,
-0.0304561015,
-0.0135829793,
0.005948625,
-0.0007621417,
-0.0245367866,
-0.0281749703,
0.0364231393,
0.006772629,
-0.008151941,
-0.0121891629,
0.0484975167,
0.0396662094,
0.0757929981,
-0.0070341765,
0.0276968628,
-0.0296399482,
-0.0460198,
0.0367690623,
0.0578164011,
-0.0196966585,
-0.005556169,
-0.017066652,
-0.0710474774,
-0.0252455138,
0.0250181686,
0.0245200936,
-0.0162082464,
0.074338384,
0.0461984277,
-0.01258412,
-0.0099277068,
0.0216969624,
-0.0433886088,
0.010008147,
-0.0021823479,
0.0143449316,
-6.722068119e-33,
-0.00351185,
0.0562528893,
0.0395913497,
-0.0050239018,
-0.0436790697,
0.0352830328,
-0.0283117257,
-0.0052411519,
-0.0203175861,
0.0223061889,
-0.0195725448,
-0.0008928509,
0.0306506902,
0.0281148944,
-0.0511397161,
0.0090268981,
0.1155305728,
-0.0246900413,
-0.0022948477,
0.0412322097,
-0.0064354641,
0.0270636026,
0.0635667741,
0.0134659428,
-0.061256472,
-0.0068374765,
-0.0283027943,
0.0194515251,
0.0057716714,
0.0114189433,
-0.0318324156,
0.0324446633,
-0.0187715013,
-0.0453949273,
-0.0006573728,
0.0139278341,
-0.0928738713,
-0.0194757711,
-0.0149093838,
0.0269352328,
-0.0620388426,
0.0247114282,
0.0300194528,
0.0204372387,
-0.0339580961,
0.0184210762,
0.0023541553,
0.015329916,
-0.0459670536,
-0.0299558546,
-0.0376572832,
0.0285168905,
0.0223263875,
-0.0258927587,
0.0177674629,
-0.0276086926,
-0.010514209,
-0.0396259651,
-0.073172085,
-0.030813152,
0.0215148106,
0.0557472259,
0.0215955749,
0.0340338461,
0.0218153298,
0.0321137346,
0.0634971485,
0.019392103,
0.0013457561,
0.0272065103,
0.057832472,
0.0252442006,
0.0105772009,
-0.0476686694,
0.0507465638,
-0.0092818057,
-0.077385135,
-0.0380966365,
0.0341125503,
0.0168932788,
-0.0038600159,
0.0211963989,
0.0007758283,
-0.0281745903,
-0.0494176373,
-0.0228609294,
-0.0063358606,
-0.016968986,
0.0234368201,
0.0432687961,
0.0020559912,
-0.0125579489,
0.030383531,
-0.0005348955,
-0.0095233088,
0.0359101035,
-0.0043975734,
0.0350283943,
-0.0097953891,
0.0347285606,
-0.0856167898,
-0.0343213305,
-0.0261653308,
0.0050899214,
0.0154866371,
-0.0023609009,
0.0523166992,
0.0723539218,
-0.0629160777,
-0.0011929057,
-0.0347571857,
0.0299888663,
0.0576957725,
0.0823728964,
0.0569668785,
0.0103278542,
0.0120274648,
0.0615142807,
-0.0213106442,
0.0026372692,
0.0002139972,
0.0269984268,
0.0086569553,
0.0404419303,
-0.0152869448,
0.0128417201,
-0.0810420439,
0.030622093,
0.0023200864,
-0.1147722602,
-0.0430267341,
0.0224941336,
2.944e-7,
0.0002148292,
0.0159221385,
0.0312578157,
0.0336234942,
0.0144434087,
0.0092595611,
-0.024108015,
-0.0025055576,
-0.0097719301,
0.030420946,
0.0106402906,
0.0333397202,
0.0152829317,
0.0145998523,
-0.0824991092,
-0.0080141099,
-0.0950877368,
0.0448285975,
-0.0355222635,
-0.0148073891,
0.004874391,
0.0982069075,
0.0151265813,
-0.0472659804,
0.0290633217,
-0.0313534513,
0.0539983511,
0.0182908997,
0.0147798564,
0.009032852,
-0.0026034468,
0.0385972261,
-0.0255759731,
0.0122626582,
-0.035254281,
0.0105994567,
-0.0351031534,
0.0518535674,
-0.0224547964,
-0.02790685,
0.0452499799,
0.0302459486,
-0.0158522613,
-0.0229537226,
0.0606479309,
-0.0369464792,
-0.0078818351,
-0.0210954975,
0.0006166981,
-0.0188322961,
0.0132900896,
-0.0269698426,
-0.0229099505,
0.0321700163,
0.0322302021,
-0.0080993082,
-0.0181921143,
-0.0880884081,
-0.0047703343,
0.0333171412,
-0.0231444445,
-0.0443612151,
-0.0529700257,
-0.0063917488,
0.0575323477,
-0.0542621277,
-0.0103199426,
2.889549704e-34,
0.0752895102,
-0.0342426375,
0.022614399,
0.0157042183,
0.0041985316,
-0.0178622883,
0.0438710153,
-0.0178481527,
-0.0453768745,
-0.07382866,
-0.0301090907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05904v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05904v1 | FACT-GPT: Fact-Checking Augmentation via Claim Matching with LLMs | 2024-02-08T18:43:05 | 2024-02-08T18:43:05 | Eun Cheol Choi, Emilio Ferrara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.SI | Our society is facing rampant misinformation harming public health and trust.
To address the societal challenge, we introduce FACT-GPT, a system leveraging
Large Language Models (LLMs) to automate the claim matching stage of
fact-checking. FACT-GPT, trained on a synthetic dataset, identifies social
media content that aligns with, contradicts, or is irrelevant to previously
debunked claims. Our evaluation shows that our specialized LLMs can match the
accuracy of larger models in identifying related claims, closely mirroring
human judgment. This research provides an automated solution for efficient
claim matching, demonstrates the potential of LLMs in supporting fact-checkers,
and offers valuable resources for further research in the field. | [
0.0398642942,
0.067586191,
0.0200231485,
0.0335124955,
-0.0568721481,
0.0054080859,
-0.0029149626,
-0.0045714779,
0.0415662229,
-0.0510283336,
0.0143233594,
-0.0145860286,
0.0034379354,
0.0201636739,
0.0120789949,
-0.0008217264,
0.0517699122,
0.0385246091,
0.0692551881,
-0.0110011455,
0.011804658,
0.0695426911,
-0.0215529446,
0.031137323,
-0.0349332914,
-0.0053957729,
0.0805438161,
-0.0062736045,
0.0598269328,
-0.049201943,
0.0092405211,
0.0324974358,
0.0173888206,
0.1136379912,
0.0000014862,
-0.0401413217,
0.0171200372,
0.0250997152,
-0.0393042527,
0.0399318933,
0.0071713659,
-0.012916238,
-0.0247828495,
0.0302481055,
-0.0072255367,
-0.013561625,
0.0488730222,
0.050005395,
0.089031674,
0.089070946,
-0.0210814569,
-0.0246694572,
0.0229612738,
-0.0097555658,
-0.0170737654,
-0.0315450579,
0.0858177394,
0.0157320965,
-0.0119120702,
0.0101860119,
0.0527229644,
0.0349925645,
-0.0217576977,
-0.0166398492,
-0.0324640982,
0.0251449738,
-0.0430115424,
-0.0077212807,
0.0115831643,
0.0469899736,
-0.0063112369,
-0.0744128674,
0.0156287756,
-0.0209225435,
-0.0082096895,
0.0507581122,
-0.0140598165,
0.0501412749,
-0.0401350558,
0.0293881632,
0.010232578,
-0.0411100388,
0.0483223721,
0.0666653588,
0.0331973024,
0.0641588569,
0.0113302479,
-0.0569536649,
0.014313167,
0.0136507815,
0.0011451966,
-0.0631931722,
0.0388942994,
-0.001188624,
-0.0013240726,
0.017970223,
-0.031542588,
-0.0173184238,
0.0745860413,
-0.0774144828,
-0.0265576281,
0.0041799154,
-0.0407149121,
0.0712235793,
-0.0318819582,
-0.0032056526,
-0.0305029005,
-0.0240845624,
0.0141580915,
-0.0219526328,
-0.0112453001,
0.0184510015,
-0.0021186187,
-0.0048097274,
-0.025796229,
0.0357376188,
-0.0433556065,
-0.0203963108,
-0.0137495445,
0.029578479,
0.0156037947,
-0.0086731939,
0.0086863535,
-0.0536022969,
-0.052164387,
0.0661007389,
0.0161307305,
0.0559592694,
-0.0327263549,
-0.0250106882,
-0.0029262376,
0.0221928228,
0.0134096639,
-0.010697647,
0.0126676457,
-0.0171904974,
0.0065629967,
0.0042601321,
-0.0507810749,
-0.0127998507,
-0.0181665979,
-0.0441467836,
-0.029150309,
-0.0681418851,
0.0242915731,
-0.0148867313,
-0.0053926511,
-0.0320838615,
0.0132614672,
0.0427793153,
-0.0664777011,
0.0212518815,
-0.028839143,
0.0181907807,
0.0648341849,
0.0079227388,
0.0192132667,
0.031658534,
0.0293643605,
0.0415211953,
0.0327801257,
0.0223785602,
0.0047948575,
0.020132903,
0.0419170745,
0.0318866409,
0.0553097464,
-0.0023619456,
0.0157134719,
0.0084825121,
0.0061753192,
0.0560386181,
-0.0113766482,
-0.0382290892,
0.1044303179,
0.0142714949,
-0.0377872176,
-0.0024981976,
0.0298356749,
0.0053203064,
0.0319820531,
-0.0325611643,
-0.0506067015,
0.0122549767,
-0.0484049879,
-0.0348693132,
0.0244491678,
0.0770160034,
-0.0013240895,
0.0036809465,
-0.0294324644,
0.0145910811,
0.0089207795,
0.0100702019,
-0.0310984198,
0.0073125088,
-0.0276169684,
0.0444786772,
0.0372692756,
-0.0207562298,
-0.0333992839,
-0.0630414039,
0.0261741877,
0.0001155318,
0.0335365944,
0.0034907393,
-0.011862251,
-0.0303458087,
0.026794631,
0.0509116277,
0.0630526394,
-0.01399267,
-0.016351657,
0.0126219885,
-0.0070598191,
-0.0037474474,
0.0186929591,
-0.0135686221,
0.081782788,
0.0152191697,
0.0067945286,
-0.0125885392,
-0.0615688451,
0.0284421444,
0.0060306769,
0.0038357042,
0.0061054975,
0.011911531,
0.0170568191,
0.0056233229,
0.0096354857,
-0.008341697,
0.0200567506,
0.0121947126,
-0.031246746,
0.0141668748,
0.0379906446,
0.0028541978,
0.0393841676,
-0.0242408458,
-0.0712881386,
0.0434274748,
-0.054337807,
0.0082230149,
-0.0299854446,
-0.0311167892,
0.0010195186,
-0.0291009732,
-0.004228191,
0.0026686371,
0.0024480652,
0.0187773202,
0.0615438558,
-0.0186203793,
-0.018684011,
-0.0407405943,
-0.0157724321,
0.0092324689,
-0.0154430568,
-0.0127025992,
0.0142834131,
0.0189947449,
0.0186541528,
0.0341134667,
-0.0420448966,
-0.0209141616,
0.0142591316,
-0.0715030953,
0.0093473671,
0.0045782947,
0.0091865091,
0.025526857,
-0.0170986131,
-0.0121433996,
-0.0041728206,
-0.0365319401,
-0.0287328362,
0.0473151729,
0.0236121733,
0.0233223159,
-0.0192154031,
-0.0013358603,
-0.041838102,
0.0295877047,
-0.0401331112,
-0.0028831044,
0.0424820744,
-0.0658830032,
-0.0593165644,
0.0010239956,
-0.0519022383,
0.0160354562,
-0.0035025298,
-0.0085195294,
0.0124554001,
0.0462490655,
-0.0091846408,
0.0164502095,
0.0244814437,
-0.0265283398,
0.0632910654,
0.0436185598,
-0.0251013972,
-0.0061316425,
-0.021989448,
-0.0224365387,
-0.0111670205,
-0.0591091961,
0.025554575,
0.0476376079,
0.008001036,
-0.0161126498,
-0.0157908723,
0.025853578,
0.0038320813,
-0.0009684796,
0.0347474739,
-0.0437912494,
-0.0104777608,
0.0218686517,
-0.0419977568,
-0.0392981581,
0.0897737518,
-0.0364799164,
0.0524543747,
-0.0343178324,
-0.0253742132,
-0.0172429401,
-0.0184615012,
0.0038400707,
0.0401080661,
-0.0062359348,
0.0166092329,
0.0372720286,
-0.0354222767,
0.0377758779,
-0.013285161,
0.032416679,
-0.0614534095,
0.0512035675,
0.0282846615,
-0.0462023877,
-0.0344936997,
-0.1053782925,
-0.0477592833,
-0.041815266,
-0.0619188137,
-0.0231832732,
-0.1238805428,
-0.0378187969,
0.0538234077,
0.0442122295,
0.0296192933,
0.0065355781,
0.027368607,
-0.0062996298,
0.0234794524,
0.0162212625,
0.037135087,
0.0129514737,
-0.0256783925,
0.0663223118,
-0.0234731436,
0.0247838814,
-0.0197674818,
-0.0601620562,
-0.0251857378,
-0.0372575112,
0.0229558796,
-0.031853009,
0.0253389459,
-0.0230493564,
0.037657842,
0.0784808397,
-0.0037975244,
0.0044271033,
-0.003175843,
0.0151631525,
-0.0301852785,
0.0284004174,
-0.0063652713,
-0.1061811894,
-0.0006705422,
-0.038106665,
-0.0289897285,
-0.0273294132,
-0.0162955541,
-0.0309156738,
-0.0843289196,
0.0325442553,
0.0150001328,
0.0314253867,
-0.051559262,
-0.0602339469,
0.0239527132,
-0.0131252082,
0.0051966393,
-0.0055997237,
0.0265728943,
-0.0434852205,
-0.0202378351,
-0.0379935913,
-0.0382166989,
0.0468607396,
-0.0386135355,
0.0402069576,
0.0259805601,
0.058366254,
-0.00133528,
-0.0407139845,
0.0006102128,
0.0372929387,
-0.0680185035,
0.008984399,
0.0500160195,
-0.0252176877,
0.0025440159,
-0.0369106457,
0.0299801882,
0.0247231945,
-0.0419195667,
-0.0046790163,
0.0754817799,
0.0077683171,
-0.0486639924,
-0.0224262122,
0.0353818499,
0.0223866776,
0.0676266029,
-0.0137967616,
0.0358265676,
0.0116080819,
-0.0243782252,
-0.0480422936,
-0.0030375898,
-0.0489971749,
0.0613145083,
-0.0160223022,
-0.0338693559,
-0.070123449,
0.03340514,
0.0021945515,
-0.0309200939,
-0.0125368377,
-0.016604621,
0.0506985337,
0.0016125119,
-0.0117158918,
0.0545876287,
-0.051324416,
0.0606545471,
-0.004997028,
0.0036075332,
0.0395528078,
-0.0109399771,
0.0056580589,
0.0502300337,
-0.068345651,
-0.07373707,
-0.0116293374,
-0.0359361842,
0.018297296,
0.0586039238,
-0.0221735593,
-0.0320770219,
0.0043335017,
0.0564772412,
-0.0278532114,
0.0211456995,
-0.0191570725,
-0.0123931728,
0.0038569507,
-0.000400665,
-0.0078664413,
0.0251944978,
0.0078630522,
0.0082054883,
-0.0556080937,
-0.0431745872,
0.0615525842,
0.0500029661,
0.0498360135,
-0.0144154048,
0.0340184681,
-0.0430240482,
-0.0167251453,
-0.010147878,
-0.0340451077,
0.0174797904,
0.0214408562,
0.0222208984,
-0.0304967128,
-0.0307768192,
-0.0200217292,
-0.0418187417,
0.0120452335,
-0.043149963,
-0.0098811481,
-0.0396820493,
0.0184720177,
0.0199232344,
-0.042619206,
-0.0273397453,
0.0097221946,
-0.0080685755,
0.0303628519,
-0.0052607819,
0.0030073004,
0.0054527,
0.0072954013,
0.0174579322,
-0.0405731052,
-0.044069685,
-0.0415878743,
-0.0593793355,
-0.0090930825,
0.0347595327,
-0.0195073355,
0.0435626209,
-0.0325882733,
-0.0610587634,
0.0096408678,
-0.0333691686,
-0.0347514153,
0.0088194301,
0.0312915929,
-0.001900552,
-0.033047881,
0.0421431959,
0.0311777219,
0.0246285871,
0.0793259069,
0.0266467892,
-0.0707583278,
-0.0169280246,
-0.0853052959,
-0.0506175682,
0.0115684094,
-0.0201662555,
-0.0200552382,
-0.0513737611,
-0.0544822067,
0.0149928881,
0.0122100515,
0.0104434518,
0.0065573724,
-0.02634947,
0.0643983185,
0.0231144149,
-0.0230092779,
-0.0168058351,
0.0270451847,
0.002884978,
-0.0159810241,
-0.021937523,
-5.915198511e-33,
-0.0017596944,
-0.0624235943,
0.0027602562,
0.0006757636,
-0.0061481888,
0.0043029934,
-0.0097483844,
-0.0355705619,
-0.0398207754,
0.0685776919,
0.0278757308,
0.0612651631,
0.0053663859,
-0.0189382806,
-0.0214926526,
0.0200228207,
0.050547339,
0.0104225874,
-0.0291035771,
0.0108987866,
0.0338419825,
-0.0296005532,
0.0406352989,
-0.10701368,
0.0512537993,
-0.0082312068,
-0.0438179597,
0.0074413144,
-0.0412560366,
0.039043121,
-0.0101624243,
0.0490838997,
0.0355870314,
-0.0134039847,
0.0190480016,
0.0393154137,
-0.0483801849,
0.0226137936,
0.0670396909,
-0.0406878665,
0.0021002661,
0.0065606986,
0.0265735351,
-0.0067774234,
-0.0295827035,
0.0125689004,
0.0097637968,
-0.0392113402,
0.0347400941,
-0.0027710632,
-0.0645415187,
0.0314633362,
0.0211175848,
0.0241246708,
-0.0335667022,
0.0067295111,
-0.0060276235,
0.0569779389,
-0.0693864599,
0.0349090248,
-0.0378729105,
0.0044301124,
0.0239306819,
-0.0663149431,
-0.0452095903,
0.0559529513,
-0.0446888283,
0.0118284337,
-0.0526068285,
0.0279316083,
-0.0439529046,
0.0229972582,
0.0464725457,
0.1103544235,
0.0220939219,
-0.0462973751,
-0.0948414207,
0.0307930447,
0.020105904,
-0.0012930114,
0.0002387991,
-0.0282766074,
0.0011076347,
0.0195817184,
-0.0394512266,
0.024153851,
-0.0364504196,
0.0323199779,
-0.0271875709,
0.0363368206,
0.002961138,
0.0558026396,
-0.0218355283,
-0.0334893875,
0.0233951993,
0.0108076679,
-0.016473813,
-0.0302345417,
0.0082512992,
0.0322801173,
-0.0734774992,
0.0438955985,
-0.0079424586,
0.0226377081,
0.015204546,
-0.0002976148,
0.0600778162,
-0.0246896669,
-0.065038085,
0.0392102487,
-0.021722246,
0.018309582,
-0.0135630155,
-0.0343312621,
0.0307465438,
0.0206812974,
0.0180554837,
-0.0007212128,
-0.0012905578,
0.0146704158,
-0.0255351905,
-0.0157684907,
-0.0128620304,
0.0315027982,
-0.011447276,
-0.000557536,
-0.0220377836,
0.0134250578,
0.0099751977,
-0.0866656825,
0.0173111558,
0.0114869466,
2.433e-7,
0.0384264812,
0.0656759515,
-0.0104801059,
-0.0067097764,
0.0338485353,
0.0267532952,
0.0128127541,
0.0097671384,
0.018656997,
-0.0848293751,
-0.0277036522,
0.0328180045,
0.0298230015,
0.031129688,
-0.0259564351,
-0.0004661349,
-0.0740422085,
-0.0374119021,
-0.0729162917,
-0.0185603611,
-0.0191505607,
0.0360000022,
0.031875927,
-0.0196813084,
-0.011729626,
-0.022382196,
0.0780830607,
0.0311018229,
-0.0492891781,
0.0107612396,
0.0505266674,
-0.0073759356,
-0.0063309264,
0.0348668322,
-0.0420913026,
0.0180134289,
-0.006615561,
0.0619033091,
-0.0037424963,
0.0169895329,
-0.0533387586,
-0.0300751962,
0.0233884305,
-0.0474859737,
0.0279993713,
-0.0232135542,
-0.0372135341,
-0.0676988661,
-0.0268014316,
0.023869006,
0.0142725036,
-0.0220066849,
-0.0208708886,
0.0055884533,
-0.0062178602,
0.0320963375,
-0.0154559985,
-0.0535767861,
-0.0093720434,
0.0292228032,
-0.0640287846,
-0.055891607,
0.0345585197,
-0.0065803085,
0.028729694,
-0.0644144341,
0.0581661686,
1.903685321e-34,
0.0184070915,
0.0017469728,
0.0013999145,
-0.059730716,
0.0592025928,
0.0507546328,
-0.0236697905,
0.0172592998,
-0.0038623889,
-0.0377024263,
0.0242741294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05889v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05889v2 | CREMA: Generalizable and Efficient Video-Language Reasoning via Multimodal Modular Fusion | 2024-02-08T18:27:22 | 2024-06-12T21:03:33 | Shoubin Yu, Jaehong Yoon, Mohit Bansal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite impressive advancements in recent multimodal reasoning approaches,
they are still limited in flexibility and efficiency, as these models typically
process only a few fixed modality inputs and require updates to numerous
parameters. This paper tackles these critical challenges and proposes CREMA, a
generalizable, highly efficient, and modular modality-fusion framework that can
incorporate any new modality to enhance video reasoning. We first augment
multiple informative modalities (such as optical flow, 3D point cloud, audio,
thermal heatmap, and touch map) from given videos without extra human
annotation by leveraging sensors or existing pre-trained models. Next, we
introduce a query transformer with multiple parameter-efficient modules
associated with each accessible modality. It projects diverse modality features
to the LLM token embedding space, allowing the model to integrate different
data types for response generation. Furthermore, we propose a novel progressive
multimodal fusion design supported by a lightweight fusion module and
modality-sequential training strategy. It helps compress information across
various assisting modalities, maintaining computational efficiency in the LLM
while improving performance. We validate our method on 7 video-language
reasoning tasks assisted by diverse modalities, including conventional VideoQA
and Video-Audio/3D/Touch/Thermal QA, and achieve better/equivalent performance
against strong multimodal LLMs, including OneLLM, BLIP-2, and SeViLA while
reducing over 90% trainable parameters. We provide extensive analyses of CREMA,
including the impact of each modality on reasoning domains, the design of the
fusion module, and example visualizations. | [
0.0032343827,
0.0394863822,
0.0074899797,
0.0513664372,
-0.0204675589,
0.0104747601,
0.0066469535,
-0.0088135311,
-0.0440107957,
-0.0909394175,
-0.0197906792,
0.007223512,
0.0025745342,
0.0274289139,
0.0300888065,
-0.0654551759,
0.0330977291,
-0.038678132,
-0.0189488288,
0.0014695828,
0.025072813,
0.0016817977,
-0.0389752463,
0.0299712773,
-0.0719252005,
0.0123541607,
-0.04305581,
0.0058132657,
0.049994953,
-0.0243127774,
-0.0388535149,
0.0232693851,
0.0866889209,
-0.0230422895,
0.0000020048,
-0.0362418108,
0.004945334,
-0.0021467451,
0.0114681609,
-0.0396660082,
-0.0109776128,
-0.0160459857,
0.0293003041,
0.049421683,
-0.0601620823,
-0.0027128642,
0.0740558282,
0.0112902243,
0.0345710404,
0.0280806404,
-0.0335667841,
-0.0575566441,
0.0107720224,
0.014847408,
0.0643529594,
-0.0042180866,
-0.0339789316,
-0.0128313815,
0.0709666833,
-0.0090996288,
-0.0323527753,
0.0236869641,
0.0256017689,
-0.0301145762,
0.0108358357,
0.0441052876,
-0.0110781649,
-0.0380323045,
-0.0183107574,
0.0655883402,
0.0122704869,
0.0338319242,
-0.0082081491,
0.0355818495,
0.0006905753,
0.0048538917,
-0.0438492931,
0.0282413941,
-0.0089829983,
-0.004109093,
-0.0520402268,
-0.0011753374,
0.0406125262,
0.0109691797,
-0.0042030704,
0.0717050731,
0.0240805298,
0.0456571393,
0.0006748122,
-0.0084761651,
-0.0088069458,
-0.0487687439,
-0.0282576326,
0.0543968603,
-0.0394675657,
0.0018842757,
-0.0189906657,
0.0211680532,
-0.0176669694,
-0.0221934859,
0.0507167056,
0.0380919613,
-0.0348613299,
0.0537492223,
-0.0262815785,
0.0197781939,
-0.0354371406,
0.060915783,
-0.015196871,
-0.0498117283,
-0.0655677244,
-0.0079281861,
-0.0112963058,
0.0161937028,
-0.0278417021,
-0.0053317994,
-0.0180185344,
0.0343652219,
-0.0340004191,
0.0058319317,
-0.0315163471,
0.0547495261,
0.0222888216,
-0.0262367763,
-0.050790865,
0.0278114974,
-0.0565709136,
0.0722362846,
-0.0052534072,
-0.0547030531,
0.0098588597,
0.029676592,
-0.0033549755,
-0.0249274597,
0.0263636895,
0.0701516122,
-0.058988858,
-0.0412379093,
-0.0276159458,
-0.0235716179,
-0.0159127619,
-0.0507574417,
0.0768488199,
-0.0659785643,
0.0359799154,
-0.0004895377,
-0.027783988,
0.0282385126,
0.0094995676,
0.0003418326,
-0.0194968022,
0.1024789289,
-0.0046773045,
0.0128576746,
0.0254045445,
0.0303840209,
-0.0216193367,
0.058061067,
0.0437885374,
-0.0041888771,
0.0070650014,
0.0122387735,
0.0310839675,
0.0049438658,
-0.0383241288,
0.0035272413,
-0.0739465877,
0.0141601209,
-0.0308716744,
0.0232680161,
0.0142515684,
0.0218342245,
-0.0217798427,
-0.050208807,
0.0112299602,
0.0239255074,
-0.0103367353,
-0.0634923503,
0.0160846617,
-0.0340814218,
-0.0026066157,
-0.015796477,
-0.04807638,
0.1117527932,
-0.0192130003,
-0.0111532966,
0.0263499133,
0.0513524972,
-0.0463034958,
-0.0454558469,
-0.0367258266,
-0.0043367129,
0.0223968793,
0.0387751497,
0.0407394581,
-0.0211012233,
0.0032345832,
0.0345836468,
-0.0123540619,
-0.033799313,
0.0061261868,
-0.0306502767,
0.013387166,
0.0427682176,
0.0094649121,
-0.0214775354,
-0.0537318215,
0.0200457871,
0.0125128673,
0.0024148456,
-0.0072892797,
-0.0083860941,
0.0555164181,
-0.0478897654,
-0.0639252141,
-0.035074383,
0.0183131881,
0.032849554,
-0.0153634958,
-0.0351535194,
0.0140588311,
-0.0532991514,
0.0799587667,
0.0285370219,
0.0350246094,
0.0134488484,
-0.0159927122,
0.0212193057,
0.033835195,
-0.0160224345,
0.0351456888,
0.0004122884,
0.0301993564,
-0.0294301752,
-0.0090453932,
0.052490674,
-0.0412422456,
-0.0208830647,
0.0326400213,
-0.0648647919,
0.0038227611,
0.0193124712,
-0.0710648075,
-0.0422739312,
0.0486171432,
0.0240178946,
0.0120058646,
-0.0375077613,
-0.0362198353,
0.0488913357,
-0.0084000761,
-0.0012080721,
0.0332379974,
-0.0364470445,
-0.0120443432,
0.0337185375,
0.0262563322,
0.033275947,
0.0155752823,
0.0093000066,
0.0030308834,
-0.0190247707,
0.004352964,
-0.0252940878,
-0.0319311507,
-0.0445885472,
-0.0198789481,
-0.1037206575,
-0.0104929525,
0.0040079635,
-0.0224627256,
-0.0168140661,
0.0061344132,
0.0172526352,
-0.0262458734,
-0.0213435963,
0.0112713659,
0.0149448402,
0.0219931565,
0.0085851438,
0.0262462813,
0.0207474437,
-0.0087881749,
-0.0019874072,
0.0062435474,
0.0480575487,
0.0124237444,
0.0153243616,
0.027992392,
-0.0631290525,
-0.0605359674,
0.0420645736,
-0.0419915989,
-0.0239779633,
0.0416095108,
-0.042731896,
0.0072935219,
0.0321011916,
0.0147091188,
-0.013375123,
0.0365650356,
-0.0582084917,
-0.0101164375,
0.0363133736,
-0.0110685294,
-0.0061955522,
-0.0224430412,
-0.0039167926,
-0.0449784137,
-0.0087904762,
-0.031007804,
0.0195255131,
-0.0328046493,
0.0008924534,
0.0458773449,
-0.0551706031,
-0.0384453461,
-0.0046377648,
0.0076759197,
0.0200543143,
-0.0332525223,
-0.0325584188,
0.0418036468,
-0.0497171134,
-0.0038906455,
0.018162122,
0.0091378354,
-0.0283832289,
0.0635920539,
-0.0020662711,
0.007900781,
-0.0251989495,
-0.0131754838,
-0.0472562127,
-0.0390907824,
0.0249514598,
0.0078906287,
0.0415596738,
-0.0738067254,
0.0026738625,
-0.0196453203,
-0.0255732536,
-0.0421704948,
0.0165832024,
-0.0456601344,
0.0121882036,
-0.0511021838,
-0.0347544849,
-0.0184088722,
0.0078671398,
0.0340308249,
0.0164007582,
0.0013004958,
-0.0037839895,
-0.0226280224,
0.0258098952,
0.0236536078,
0.0885573998,
-0.0472767763,
-0.0268738456,
0.0160780046,
0.0562749207,
0.0414303206,
-0.0609942302,
-0.0570843183,
0.0690798014,
0.0449347869,
0.0585267358,
-0.0312004406,
0.0366325416,
0.0518061593,
-0.0744906217,
0.0243905038,
0.0505674258,
0.0095055318,
-0.018411627,
-0.0026765801,
-0.0032891103,
0.0217646901,
0.0411407053,
0.0118911071,
-0.0855235159,
-0.0806142539,
0.0192534011,
0.006579916,
0.023550421,
0.0134686716,
-0.0265186299,
-0.0686833337,
0.0769814327,
-0.0012576327,
-0.0140752932,
-0.0287571196,
-0.0140545936,
0.0131349778,
0.0177528057,
-0.0165276732,
-0.0197005942,
0.0157899223,
0.0163969863,
0.0118744578,
0.0312579647,
-0.0285276696,
0.0367568508,
-0.0144058438,
-0.0043628304,
0.0118589392,
0.0049566403,
-0.0040525389,
-0.0931857452,
0.0285101887,
0.014031657,
0.0357037596,
-0.044485148,
0.0144761754,
-0.0112221073,
-0.0104302727,
0.0196522512,
0.044640623,
0.0271432232,
-0.053896226,
-0.0272249095,
0.091653727,
-0.0568661876,
0.0369188376,
-0.0643780306,
0.0026468311,
-0.0155299352,
0.0446318462,
-0.0378459506,
0.0223165713,
-0.0192722306,
0.0048654913,
-0.0583623759,
-0.0104034049,
-0.0067807846,
-0.0163189173,
0.0219228491,
-0.0143519333,
-0.0291389935,
0.0206453074,
0.0477099642,
0.073886171,
-0.0283907708,
-0.0100849234,
-0.0340303332,
0.0509465896,
-0.0613253303,
0.0657078326,
-0.0049584261,
0.0150304157,
-0.0305351634,
0.0429075658,
0.0467099808,
-0.0458605066,
0.0071586031,
0.0044227852,
-0.0448397137,
-0.0604662709,
-0.0573627502,
0.0731722265,
0.0202691406,
0.07333529,
0.0027787387,
-0.0068632145,
-0.0073958761,
0.0309193358,
-0.0239504743,
0.0116799213,
0.0325225666,
-0.028455317,
-0.0107787428,
0.0078992471,
-0.0518953875,
-0.0000335329,
-0.0138416588,
0.0158752017,
-0.0507014543,
-0.0066884528,
0.0160388295,
-0.0415264964,
0.0637448877,
-0.0015411761,
-0.0060533863,
-0.0381561369,
0.0205360353,
0.0084741674,
0.014536798,
-0.0828211755,
0.0547900535,
-0.0090636238,
0.013071632,
0.0324357376,
-0.0059769186,
0.0192203056,
0.0097597409,
0.0090664709,
0.0078970771,
0.020494381,
-0.0203382969,
-0.0277046058,
0.0211320464,
0.0404293165,
0.0432845019,
-0.0210343581,
0.017069893,
-0.0094931396,
0.0714345202,
0.0176765583,
-0.0336859897,
-0.0268819667,
0.0334249213,
-0.0407060683,
-0.0278756209,
0.0248351078,
0.039987836,
0.0365793779,
0.0219385885,
-0.0414051227,
-0.00798978,
-0.004048733,
0.0114179468,
0.0676874816,
0.0133455666,
-0.047869347,
0.097185798,
0.0341039412,
0.0010922179,
-0.0201727282,
0.0374581255,
-0.0253104363,
0.0283323638,
-0.026568722,
-0.0062799486,
-0.016345989,
-0.032997597,
0.0574033856,
0.0345373228,
-0.0175129753,
0.0156290531,
-0.0480201952,
-0.0503478833,
-0.0185038224,
0.0053065671,
-0.0290641189,
0.0299011339,
0.0415132791,
0.0485613085,
0.017501045,
-0.0646756887,
0.0085694715,
-0.0365715027,
-0.0005686374,
0.0025062496,
0.0329388976,
-6.299736508e-33,
-0.0100622606,
-0.0355181247,
0.0692475513,
-0.0430442393,
-0.0109299375,
-0.0059000449,
0.005431023,
0.0132643785,
-0.045463983,
0.003897832,
0.0104500707,
0.0090614138,
0.0014338661,
0.0179417878,
0.0250308793,
-0.0392494872,
0.0184698589,
0.0081957495,
-0.0271786377,
-0.0103505682,
0.0670046583,
-0.0141736837,
0.0527904779,
-0.0737430751,
-0.0263677463,
0.0518255122,
-0.0626045018,
0.067501761,
-0.0491922945,
0.0431020409,
0.0048784986,
-0.0278011486,
0.0158298761,
-0.0063384008,
-0.0115934853,
0.0223419107,
-0.0532763451,
-0.0177322552,
0.0320594832,
0.0164473783,
-0.0897849649,
-0.0186048616,
0.0330583379,
0.0144317411,
0.0316626318,
-0.0473677777,
0.0185912121,
-0.0229913797,
0.0234558284,
0.0086723277,
0.0009486253,
0.0183420628,
-0.0174475815,
-0.0390900187,
0.0050042234,
0.0503654294,
0.0337302089,
-0.0061627426,
-0.0343525894,
0.0117628034,
-0.0196435358,
0.0143775856,
0.0876472816,
0.0314575545,
-0.0046732663,
0.0526772812,
-0.009701035,
-0.0776201487,
-0.0372145735,
-0.0057705175,
0.0162169021,
0.1201471984,
0.0546037257,
0.067045331,
0.0293700192,
0.0137776034,
-0.0151732769,
0.0171744525,
-0.0489591919,
0.0858173072,
-0.0296771321,
0.0242249575,
0.0418966562,
0.0012569627,
-0.0309009347,
0.0261304881,
-0.0332675576,
-0.0117820799,
0.0280394237,
0.0234741699,
0.0118981628,
-0.0132351033,
0.0590568669,
-0.0073944451,
0.0324749276,
0.0122591909,
0.0184339173,
0.0356784761,
0.0266520046,
0.0161126517,
-0.0221901946,
-0.0090115294,
0.0576106943,
-0.0462549217,
-0.0176151544,
0.0018824002,
-0.0034646746,
0.0864758715,
0.008481591,
-0.0299170502,
-0.0282941815,
0.0010955292,
0.0119318552,
0.0126773752,
0.034790244,
0.020991642,
-0.0422552675,
0.0253599659,
-0.0616773441,
0.0213171039,
-0.0394605473,
-0.0352374539,
-0.0283558425,
0.0412035249,
-0.0063599721,
0.0228214022,
-0.0561364666,
-0.0910714418,
0.0131086139,
-0.0577922538,
-0.0147860479,
0.0554549098,
2.879e-7,
0.0132884933,
-0.0085193226,
-0.0449659228,
-0.0313882828,
-0.0172787737,
0.0737472549,
-0.0174319204,
0.0222812425,
0.0302358139,
-0.0480694361,
0.0006621758,
0.0594484657,
0.0286553092,
0.0351227894,
-0.0064629139,
-0.0262787268,
0.010430404,
-0.0557366498,
-0.0366190076,
0.008817479,
0.0556574613,
0.0757268518,
0.0305559598,
-0.0089436164,
0.0295587778,
-0.033768218,
0.0491496921,
-0.0125049539,
-0.0182227176,
-0.0318168178,
0.0536892228,
-0.0067755315,
0.0084200855,
0.0084109362,
-0.0244655348,
-0.022200143,
-0.0200251769,
0.0241132081,
-0.018532671,
-0.0945882425,
-0.0281862859,
0.0001582908,
-0.0153066758,
-0.049592115,
0.079394348,
0.0046905824,
-0.0090000443,
-0.0243529715,
-0.017735254,
0.019119544,
-0.0220901687,
0.02494663,
-0.0294615217,
-0.0029344386,
0.0051603429,
-0.040618062,
-0.0376546495,
-0.1120625809,
-0.0123306289,
-0.0188384093,
-0.0392456539,
0.0102281896,
-0.0126130721,
-0.0209664833,
0.0605534278,
-0.0126669593,
-0.108236827,
2.290743009e-34,
0.0073231971,
-0.0144388163,
-0.0005067066,
-0.0129247569,
0.0030405382,
0.0049178367,
-0.0498603024,
0.0102791246,
0.0140752178,
-0.0444881134,
-0.0152999386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05880v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05880v2 | Generative Echo Chamber? Effects of LLM-Powered Search Systems on Diverse Information Seeking | 2024-02-08T18:14:33 | 2024-02-10T17:03:58 | Nikhil Sharma, Q. Vera Liao, Ziang Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Large language models (LLMs) powered conversational search systems have
already been used by hundreds of millions of people, and are believed to bring
many benefits over conventional search. However, while decades of research and
public discourse interrogated the risk of search systems in increasing
selective exposure and creating echo chambers -- limiting exposure to diverse
opinions and leading to opinion polarization, little is known about such a risk
of LLM-powered conversational search. We conduct two experiments to
investigate: 1) whether and how LLM-powered conversational search increases
selective exposure compared to conventional search; 2) whether and how LLMs
with opinion biases that either reinforce or challenge the user's view change
the effect. Overall, we found that participants engaged in more biased
information querying with LLM-powered conversational search, and an opinionated
LLM reinforcing their views exacerbated this bias. These results present
critical implications for the development of LLMs and conversational search
systems, and the policy governing these technologies. | [
0.0562008582,
0.0399453752,
-0.0431804135,
0.0009050412,
-0.0177617725,
-0.0488290228,
0.0422854088,
0.0088712415,
0.0125727626,
-0.0251815543,
-0.0320770405,
-0.0215792581,
-0.0181099176,
-0.019213412,
-0.0025576614,
-0.0335833691,
0.0283826813,
0.0228472818,
0.0517756566,
-0.012696147,
0.0463875346,
0.0254297312,
0.0283822995,
0.056752298,
0.0355245061,
-0.0016503972,
0.0348408334,
0.0237114374,
-0.0007443068,
-0.0342095494,
0.0099407919,
0.0335377678,
0.0039022702,
0.0478125624,
0.0000018667,
-0.0277942643,
-0.0052145724,
-0.0027911868,
-0.0280608237,
0.0035098263,
0.0704295039,
0.0890140235,
0.0332899056,
0.0317533538,
-0.0519761257,
0.009017434,
0.0159753133,
-0.0061639785,
0.0257719029,
0.0156568848,
0.0235718489,
-0.0147955958,
-0.04069544,
-0.0017213156,
0.0423196889,
-0.0031016027,
0.0039292127,
-0.0387020893,
0.0107338559,
0.0553921834,
0.0194965247,
0.0425443687,
-0.040901605,
-0.0188641045,
-0.003433499,
0.005836003,
-0.0263834,
-0.0372856557,
0.0306331404,
0.0691664964,
0.0578480624,
-0.0142119182,
-0.00111329,
-0.014545464,
0.0246151797,
0.0408253931,
-0.0628334656,
0.0633538812,
-0.0372892171,
0.0016771663,
-0.0380598754,
-0.0004367056,
0.0464776754,
0.019905325,
0.0080798073,
0.0746120065,
-0.0164017342,
-0.0471406803,
0.0121781081,
-0.0241810381,
0.0520786196,
-0.0193600729,
0.001811172,
0.0080969315,
-0.0346457288,
0.0360350795,
0.0285169911,
-0.0094159534,
0.0498181805,
-0.0516295582,
-0.0147790946,
0.0196916182,
-0.0170061458,
0.0354189724,
0.0567554645,
-0.0386331044,
-0.0269786417,
0.0203192364,
-0.0052117039,
-0.0038140102,
0.0057647834,
-0.0349443257,
0.0216560457,
0.0064683715,
-0.0321581364,
0.0030496849,
0.0107410606,
0.0037314193,
-0.0077484986,
-0.0453183837,
-0.0442443974,
0.0170714986,
0.026027564,
0.0057724612,
-0.0585856885,
0.022026835,
-0.0233521964,
0.0289980341,
0.0087840911,
-0.0761112645,
0.0248277877,
0.0442479104,
-0.0029939052,
-0.0114287743,
0.0032905478,
0.0284344573,
0.0344481319,
-0.0405135192,
0.0013021062,
-0.0158301629,
0.0139103197,
-0.0158815533,
0.0054315398,
-0.033577729,
0.0245543122,
0.0215937644,
-0.0030448735,
-0.0048396876,
0.003674878,
0.0429174155,
-0.0419876017,
0.0536653176,
-0.0145368725,
0.0390303805,
0.0887488872,
0.0620242618,
0.0202812981,
0.0836694241,
-0.0268409457,
0.0008297327,
0.0425047055,
0.0023035987,
0.0383452475,
0.0172629654,
-0.0229010396,
0.0270664785,
-0.0063688108,
0.0457341522,
-0.0519465543,
-0.0009224616,
-0.0010544572,
0.078952387,
-0.0414751954,
-0.0038260259,
0.0750078484,
0.0689542741,
-0.0212132391,
0.00882643,
-0.006956832,
0.0195435099,
-0.0181026421,
-0.0055647762,
-0.0121697718,
0.0065457365,
-0.0254408438,
-0.0389822088,
0.0532442331,
0.0044810432,
-0.0318801813,
-0.0102483872,
-0.0248954892,
0.0291364603,
0.0525614843,
0.0360894091,
-0.0053601498,
-0.0219615716,
-0.0041447077,
0.0521848164,
0.0274381805,
-0.0468654595,
-0.0067205732,
-0.060327094,
0.0333421603,
0.0682210848,
0.035752371,
-0.0193213001,
-0.001258122,
-0.0315661654,
0.0023798121,
0.0943286195,
0.0607167743,
0.0251859557,
-0.0501222908,
-0.0207512751,
-0.0271504447,
0.0193542168,
-0.0060833814,
0.0072199954,
0.0336642638,
0.0344149023,
0.0009450887,
-0.0121442974,
-0.0263415687,
0.0089330757,
0.0069631874,
-0.0215202533,
-0.0564220212,
0.0296184644,
0.0012736554,
0.0169188716,
-0.012451645,
0.0125701716,
0.0105823735,
0.0136877112,
-0.0468778946,
-0.0016505987,
-0.0303459559,
0.0817255974,
-0.0054639853,
-0.0555456728,
-0.0282975547,
-0.025666913,
0.0398337469,
0.0211349707,
0.0251016151,
-0.02615886,
0.0564020425,
0.0158070177,
-0.0084073571,
-0.061285913,
-0.0017563414,
-0.0726183951,
0.017607918,
-0.0128508452,
0.0098704193,
-0.0043432647,
-0.0276733804,
-0.0171489697,
-0.0284138005,
-0.0506056994,
-0.001905283,
0.0329228714,
-0.0010456367,
0.032092087,
-0.0469139665,
-0.028968282,
-0.0019233269,
-0.0990566313,
-0.0131508745,
-0.0173059143,
-0.0041119829,
0.0088887941,
0.0101550417,
-0.0225834101,
0.0243678559,
-0.0411041938,
-0.035538245,
0.0070532537,
0.0557810366,
-0.0026635523,
0.0151486648,
-0.0128876809,
-0.0618629977,
-0.0090804799,
0.003798946,
0.0106412815,
0.0409435146,
-0.0065547298,
-0.0310716014,
0.0163123421,
-0.0586563312,
-0.0073991367,
-0.0309220422,
-0.0044017797,
0.0658114105,
0.0067812097,
-0.0172589272,
0.0347296968,
0.0650005862,
0.0220306516,
0.0523734502,
0.0309067648,
-0.0618222505,
-0.021590177,
-0.0222008601,
0.0096231038,
-0.0107651241,
-0.0704450011,
0.0511810742,
-0.0188906435,
0.0244856048,
0.0510083437,
-0.0296440553,
0.0531293452,
-0.0279117469,
-0.0480100326,
-0.0274136867,
-0.0420679152,
-0.0257773027,
0.0268453155,
-0.0027683603,
-0.041901242,
0.0108652525,
0.0077356379,
0.033298865,
-0.0127758933,
-0.0284595564,
-0.0140769249,
0.0168950483,
-0.0247143749,
0.0340445191,
0.0267473441,
-0.0220796764,
-0.0442855842,
-0.0522768125,
0.052955199,
-0.057238441,
0.0514109731,
-0.0199043714,
-0.0184166431,
0.0401814915,
-0.0434063263,
-0.0287200511,
-0.0631839857,
-0.025749011,
-0.0282523371,
0.1107860208,
-0.0164759047,
-0.0215565059,
0.020698484,
0.0680087656,
-0.0313256532,
0.0063560526,
-0.0285784025,
0.0200825315,
0.005195586,
0.0104834037,
0.0002900245,
0.0875858217,
0.0083349636,
0.0236405618,
0.0349402539,
0.0355170555,
-0.0368641913,
0.0034211071,
-0.0817558989,
0.0418085866,
-0.0114941644,
-0.0522554964,
-0.0175386183,
0.031984102,
-0.0190303233,
0.028166784,
0.048866991,
0.0318371579,
-0.0735528618,
-0.0385218784,
-0.0687613711,
0.0078018331,
0.0398464352,
0.0066151056,
-0.0655470118,
0.0314467773,
0.0066877045,
0.0374164879,
-0.0614019036,
-0.0281226691,
-0.0207716879,
-0.1451616436,
-0.0035373284,
-0.0211900901,
0.0171226822,
0.0138368113,
-0.0428350046,
0.0124838799,
0.0090523083,
0.0302939191,
0.0185445342,
-0.0199020933,
0.0077819689,
-0.017062502,
-0.061194431,
0.0144769065,
0.0059551457,
-0.0490948074,
0.032229986,
0.068177104,
0.0231138915,
-0.0268480256,
-0.0083348481,
0.0748619661,
0.0184046905,
0.0037147324,
-0.0213335771,
0.0247230344,
-0.0309817065,
0.0229802225,
-0.0563332811,
-0.0200286042,
0.0324924998,
0.0358453244,
0.0097847553,
-0.0021199465,
0.000467777,
-0.0141061628,
-0.0362160057,
0.0242176633,
0.0424833596,
0.0672883987,
0.0305676498,
-0.0453555286,
0.0101848496,
-0.0590264164,
0.0080729378,
0.0107309576,
-0.0849834383,
0.0005494233,
0.0049614855,
0.061110232,
-0.0349238776,
-0.0197130851,
-0.044538185,
-0.0225170143,
0.018749008,
0.0206049494,
0.0028218601,
0.0089199701,
0.0454442836,
0.0048438371,
-0.0162722077,
-0.0057982351,
-0.0191306453,
-0.0070534269,
0.0035283382,
-0.0394299887,
0.0054355385,
0.0047339667,
0.0193959195,
-0.0582020245,
0.0078279302,
0.0319457501,
0.0339856334,
0.0300972965,
0.0086555369,
-0.0458388738,
0.0401457027,
0.0559595488,
-0.0079830224,
0.0077981842,
-0.0188265778,
0.0431644134,
0.0304386411,
-0.0035617326,
-0.0341156833,
-0.012033416,
0.0225817114,
-0.0293530896,
-0.043746829,
-0.0515268557,
0.0241341703,
0.0140350247,
0.0504495502,
0.0099716652,
0.0321849994,
-0.0056029106,
-0.0267340336,
-0.0493451618,
-0.0303196367,
0.0395301059,
-0.0224381611,
-0.013444283,
-0.0129681043,
0.0083033368,
0.0597521439,
-0.038582392,
0.0652066916,
-0.0343545452,
0.0798367038,
-0.0419024639,
-0.0405679643,
0.0140176807,
0.0007972654,
-0.005472966,
0.0749661699,
-0.023701366,
0.0247764904,
0.0234117117,
0.0254808441,
-0.0098750973,
-0.025187403,
0.0327153131,
0.001125914,
-0.0444112793,
-0.1237395555,
0.0252272096,
0.0214871969,
-0.0221397281,
-0.0007562694,
0.0004238007,
0.0013310994,
0.0078619141,
0.0002295,
-0.0367084481,
-0.0063212169,
0.0084726615,
0.0391791835,
0.0165438764,
-0.0452826619,
-0.0250945538,
0.0459806509,
0.0080488482,
0.0410775021,
-0.0167106725,
-0.0586102158,
-0.0166041944,
-0.0268054549,
0.0218174681,
0.0371737927,
-0.0279650576,
-0.018260546,
-0.074896127,
-0.0069820229,
-0.0372354276,
-0.0047211819,
0.028717,
-0.0577466637,
0.0156422984,
0.0829474702,
0.0064787506,
-0.0101293707,
-0.019500507,
0.0580256321,
-0.0832376182,
0.0260990094,
-0.0073133274,
-6.164540699e-33,
0.0132238045,
-0.0534023121,
-0.0035200021,
-0.0277301949,
-0.0208716746,
-0.0252564251,
0.0021872993,
0.0657849237,
-0.037818566,
-0.0089455014,
-0.007144724,
0.0346176289,
0.0117159188,
-0.0282863062,
-0.0122122308,
-0.0125837987,
0.0472043827,
-0.0217641741,
-0.0269326922,
-0.0028582774,
0.0373090655,
-0.009067677,
-0.0488940068,
-0.0741836429,
0.0361878499,
-0.0290932097,
0.0089960555,
0.0144503778,
-0.019954605,
0.0318522304,
0.0094246808,
0.066573754,
0.0106356107,
-0.0323430523,
0.0060367393,
0.0889499113,
-0.0005345735,
0.0064508342,
0.0559955351,
-0.0132756131,
0.0259791929,
-0.008888863,
0.0281823445,
0.0094170775,
-0.059663672,
0.0657026693,
0.0192427002,
-0.0199500881,
-0.006535436,
-0.0222820137,
-0.0078812828,
0.0065748719,
0.0063962168,
0.0222134013,
-0.0526029207,
0.0515054986,
0.0154892365,
0.0781240761,
-0.0527039804,
0.051972989,
-0.025866041,
0.0084906649,
0.0389642119,
0.0213166401,
0.0269361306,
0.06984476,
0.0529854931,
0.0460901707,
-0.0626092106,
-0.0734752417,
-0.008773135,
0.0070885937,
0.016399771,
0.0616928041,
-0.0197076201,
-0.0829868913,
-0.012447183,
-0.0227194261,
0.0131452866,
-0.0135237128,
0.0762307197,
0.0221893489,
-0.0540373065,
-0.0338715613,
-0.0192728098,
-0.0430015139,
-0.0557457879,
-0.0291725639,
0.008924976,
0.0346829966,
-0.0142391184,
-0.0633555204,
0.007894502,
-0.0125882532,
-0.0170490239,
0.024717208,
-0.0362320729,
-0.0274567138,
0.0058233007,
-0.023689596,
-0.0622947514,
0.0298123788,
-0.0465004817,
0.0224454366,
-0.0285072606,
0.0082412064,
-0.0297331549,
-0.0104088206,
-0.0696926787,
-0.0174545832,
0.0049069631,
0.0044775512,
0.0049689524,
-0.0248902366,
0.0414650552,
0.0247532614,
0.0151518006,
-0.0123134963,
0.0619395338,
0.0230575129,
-0.045311749,
-0.0425306708,
-0.0683008432,
0.0064002723,
-0.0206706766,
-0.0096906424,
-0.0255562849,
0.0396194793,
0.022876244,
-0.0730909556,
-0.0228846706,
-0.0383010954,
2.535e-7,
0.0351747982,
0.0701199695,
-0.0454227068,
0.0182734709,
0.0405590497,
0.031457562,
0.0409536436,
-0.0037615956,
0.0278215408,
-0.072509788,
-0.0402366109,
0.0190833416,
0.0052041709,
0.0259665269,
-0.0634139478,
-0.0329252519,
-0.0552084967,
0.0208849534,
-0.0260283574,
0.0061497311,
0.007749666,
0.0336431861,
0.0002140178,
0.0175583437,
-0.0651397631,
-0.0397436991,
0.0623696223,
-0.0435069427,
-0.0112889847,
0.0250687599,
0.0430024005,
0.0065722922,
0.0133615956,
-0.0033896158,
0.0127961896,
0.0049769711,
-0.006935636,
0.0036569184,
0.0438169092,
-0.0584307052,
0.0058136173,
-0.0011692358,
-0.0078537073,
-0.0817498341,
0.0478815734,
-0.0208747517,
0.0189873967,
-0.0694936588,
-0.0154032176,
-0.0255827382,
0.0404305644,
-0.0417920053,
-0.0513096526,
-0.0214962997,
-0.0265930258,
0.0099199209,
0.0011614807,
-0.0660616308,
-0.0102377441,
-0.0368060134,
-0.0758340731,
-0.1030656695,
-0.0282867514,
0.0238581896,
-0.0375332795,
0.020172881,
0.0504439622,
1.929427729e-34,
0.0482793078,
0.0161636863,
0.0076122712,
-0.0230205338,
0.0402457677,
0.0495170653,
-0.0281820577,
-0.0238650795,
0.0303767696,
-0.0671038479,
0.0090782754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05868v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05868v2 | EmojiCrypt: Prompt Encryption for Secure Communication with Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T17:57:11 | 2024-02-12T16:26:14 | Guo Lin, Wenyue Hua, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.IR, cs.LG | Cloud-based large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have increasingly
become integral to daily operations, serving as vital tools across various
applications. While these models offer substantial benefits in terms of
accessibility and functionality, they also introduce significant privacy
concerns: the transmission and storage of user data in cloud infrastructures
pose substantial risks of data breaches and unauthorized access to sensitive
information; even if the transmission and storage of data is encrypted, the LLM
service provider itself still knows the real contents of the data, preventing
individuals or entities from confidently using such LLM services. To address
these concerns, this paper proposes a simple yet effective mechanism EmojiCrypt
to protect user privacy. It uses Emoji to encrypt the user inputs before
sending them to LLM, effectively rendering them indecipherable to human or
LLM's examination while retaining the original intent of the prompt, thus
ensuring the model's performance remains unaffected. We conduct experiments on
three tasks, personalized recommendation, sentiment analysis, and tabular data
analysis. Experiment results reveal that EmojiCrypt can encrypt personal
information within prompts in such a manner that not only prevents the
discernment of sensitive data by humans or LLM itself, but also maintains or
even improves the precision without further tuning, achieving comparable or
even better task accuracy than directly prompting the LLM without prompt
encryption. These results highlight the practicality of adopting encryption
measures that safeguard user privacy without compromising the functional
integrity and performance of LLMs. Code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/agiresearch/EmojiCrypt. | [
0.0556418151,
0.0809895098,
-0.012253521,
0.0443337932,
-0.0247844178,
0.0155822579,
0.042714335,
-0.0034201348,
0.0725821257,
0.0137999859,
-0.0085636564,
0.0102446973,
0.0003827812,
0.02730041,
0.0269820429,
0.0074433219,
0.0156615209,
-0.0154179409,
0.0093220808,
-0.0470624007,
0.0107476534,
0.0283927508,
0.0160437543,
0.0302565135,
0.0218500402,
-0.0192869417,
-0.0394313261,
-0.0289898068,
-0.0286451057,
0.0013294253,
-0.0069604069,
0.0491635203,
-0.0304422379,
0.0530620441,
0.0000022248,
-0.0236186143,
-0.039926365,
0.0154003464,
-0.0910828486,
0.0089889634,
0.0819412917,
-0.0257014316,
-0.021302484,
0.0317149535,
-0.0068791094,
0.0199744143,
0.0492237918,
0.0293738209,
0.0802868456,
0.0280733518,
-0.0119915027,
-0.0121975373,
0.0000403869,
0.001197424,
0.0281455088,
-0.0104192747,
-0.0126942853,
-0.0856503174,
-0.0185714513,
0.0371791869,
0.0132847503,
0.022248175,
0.0202309918,
0.0115481829,
-0.0085917506,
0.0211481508,
-0.0154007031,
-0.0472220518,
-0.021170808,
0.0390986912,
0.0036827405,
0.0049130996,
0.0131147681,
0.0235299524,
0.0244037211,
0.0341011211,
-0.0182316676,
0.0021131011,
-0.027694948,
-0.0271839015,
-0.0204029735,
0.0092220195,
0.0264672227,
0.0214886814,
0.0093431538,
0.0511058345,
0.0274800882,
-0.0231331941,
-0.0205807313,
-0.0454236194,
0.0191286318,
-0.0518066175,
0.053473819,
0.0063371379,
-0.014374611,
-0.007268942,
-0.0590385906,
-0.065000765,
0.0280463099,
-0.0573880561,
0.0037559911,
0.0535089709,
-0.0008819425,
0.0329779349,
-0.0102385376,
0.0658224151,
-0.0025346205,
0.0066094352,
0.0513173714,
-0.0348847322,
0.0051907259,
-0.013577831,
-0.0159700401,
0.0504058227,
-0.0058354759,
0.0228182767,
-0.0607294366,
0.0711014345,
0.0066739661,
0.0444515459,
-0.0124982577,
-0.0178808626,
0.0152158299,
0.0121360142,
-0.0080911359,
-0.039038986,
-0.0537396371,
-0.0049975957,
-0.0044481419,
-0.041057691,
-0.0011523153,
0.0015098436,
0.0042755767,
0.0213684905,
0.0082858866,
0.0799259469,
0.0469760112,
0.0045165289,
-0.0009755377,
-0.0717016906,
0.0137016131,
-0.0119102187,
-0.023148248,
-0.0538086593,
0.0352850147,
0.0337910913,
-0.0024445085,
-0.0132039422,
-0.0133979581,
0.0262077656,
-0.0717235282,
0.0511104241,
-0.037396349,
-0.0081269881,
-0.0240616724,
0.0396299027,
-0.0286758766,
0.0065395222,
0.0117758494,
0.0438916683,
0.0629439428,
-0.0351514779,
0.061996337,
0.0245809201,
0.0051447749,
-0.0028196557,
-0.0162943508,
0.034207236,
0.0158808883,
-0.0319017619,
-0.0274550337,
0.0494364388,
0.0084296549,
-0.0476465784,
0.0993262306,
0.0999001861,
-0.0485313535,
0.044907093,
-0.063089706,
0.0344105326,
0.0077110152,
-0.0478190146,
-0.0572241656,
0.0256617796,
-0.0566178858,
-0.0479241982,
0.0366737992,
-0.0185947362,
-0.0166360624,
0.0115558282,
0.0488903895,
-0.076347135,
0.042242527,
0.007126342,
-0.0418609791,
0.0157257318,
-0.0143481717,
0.0392826498,
0.0053346264,
-0.0763147771,
-0.0506069511,
-0.0289625134,
0.0470452644,
0.0938821733,
0.0363620706,
0.0532066189,
0.0317748338,
-0.0283166729,
-0.0014704023,
0.0074194097,
-0.0030635318,
0.033375036,
0.037884891,
-0.0279115718,
-0.023224527,
0.0386136845,
0.0152446628,
-0.0420774035,
-0.0016974446,
0.0476259142,
-0.0059182029,
0.0176363699,
0.02783533,
-0.0136948982,
0.0025914807,
0.0040832991,
0.0186464395,
0.0030377689,
0.0130870957,
0.0464529321,
0.012367798,
0.0117158685,
-0.0045981547,
0.0247820597,
-0.0071816109,
-0.0099956309,
-0.0251517911,
0.0190821346,
-0.0184568856,
-0.0031644446,
0.0007773119,
0.0199001711,
-0.0394801982,
0.0204577986,
0.0205828883,
0.0043484834,
0.0300735794,
-0.0036929101,
-0.0066955155,
-0.0228631962,
0.0266742092,
0.0061694435,
-0.0153846322,
-0.0246811379,
0.0236861948,
-0.0642589331,
0.0016294161,
0.0083849514,
0.0125757735,
-0.0198259242,
0.0234213416,
0.0061030961,
0.0177733097,
0.0095691364,
0.0193338059,
-0.0538741499,
-0.0025151903,
-0.1040738225,
0.0088845752,
-0.0081853317,
0.038016241,
0.0119682467,
0.0722382963,
-0.0379557125,
-0.0581631139,
-0.0589889362,
-0.0190823954,
-0.02414109,
0.0338083394,
0.0385401994,
-0.019115774,
-0.0283600334,
0.0127843227,
-0.0041711456,
0.0016663687,
0.0295893904,
-0.0365727134,
-0.0246932525,
0.0069510052,
0.0004677042,
-0.0014848898,
-0.0399372056,
0.0088330312,
-0.0317271724,
-0.0025846974,
0.0119533651,
-0.001931421,
0.0166106764,
0.040500693,
0.0105318194,
-0.0096054794,
-0.00444972,
-0.0239984784,
-0.0212338138,
-0.0200252458,
-0.0275190286,
-0.0286431368,
0.0177806672,
0.011831454,
-0.015917208,
0.0111251865,
-0.0137311844,
-0.050676886,
0.0558817685,
-0.0020498901,
0.0162772536,
-0.0755723044,
0.0101187704,
0.0081280908,
-0.0025378272,
0.0014498343,
-0.0550429001,
0.0389101058,
-0.0078785457,
-0.0073357238,
-0.0344511643,
-0.0420860909,
0.0098609133,
0.0499465205,
-0.0291498546,
0.0278392695,
-0.0006740138,
-0.0234403089,
-0.0123018045,
0.0196498167,
-0.0048782066,
-0.0668642744,
-0.0524750873,
0.0155789703,
-0.031719178,
0.0221507736,
-0.0397854224,
-0.0225667208,
-0.0843500942,
-0.0517308451,
-0.031410113,
-0.0129722273,
-0.0544175655,
0.0104403701,
-0.0149231367,
0.0173072107,
-0.0050068256,
-0.0463667475,
-0.0001316641,
-0.0312763266,
-0.0537064336,
-0.0334038772,
-0.0312507264,
-0.0344579555,
-0.015439718,
0.023652507,
0.1227160096,
0.0328352936,
-0.0374504365,
0.0002280819,
-0.0091887778,
0.0257741474,
-0.0225383118,
-0.030429069,
0.0333227776,
0.0382001661,
-0.0214984659,
0.0448209234,
0.0722623542,
0.0121407555,
-0.0770132169,
-0.0102070263,
0.0270936098,
-0.0025474776,
-0.0199616142,
0.0023154598,
-0.1131218672,
-0.0195620582,
0.0266215149,
0.0725186393,
-0.033804711,
-0.0087746475,
-0.0318343826,
-0.0881467983,
0.0310971029,
0.0059062894,
0.0448514745,
-0.0447383076,
-0.0591118261,
0.0086844368,
0.0232777968,
-0.007655547,
-0.0428133868,
0.0219238419,
0.0172690172,
-0.0239487812,
-0.0514710285,
0.0062905224,
0.0114408741,
-0.0598530285,
0.0313990489,
0.0472265221,
0.0262872223,
-0.0055652652,
-0.0347524025,
0.0182599705,
0.0649920106,
-0.0811679289,
0.0036921857,
0.0355504751,
0.0200509913,
-0.0100769196,
-0.0243565142,
0.0473444201,
-0.0298395623,
0.006691643,
0.0340270996,
-0.0043225172,
-0.0443892851,
0.0145219453,
-0.0100154299,
0.0057076416,
0.0336433612,
0.0710041299,
0.0012715237,
-0.07821621,
-0.0237356648,
-0.0729830191,
0.0391351804,
-0.0225045346,
-0.0130065084,
-0.0085391859,
0.0435976163,
-0.0244034603,
-0.0099120466,
0.0101082679,
-0.0365244597,
-0.0263222549,
0.0162256341,
0.014799607,
0.0283510648,
-0.0262728333,
0.0156829283,
-0.0115084983,
-0.0751476809,
0.0475347638,
-0.0263104551,
0.0409064293,
-0.0218443777,
0.0050490382,
-0.0113412347,
0.0000909123,
-0.0569314137,
-0.0149862999,
0.0356524363,
0.0620718189,
0.019290179,
-0.0002357427,
-0.0711278319,
-0.0779999942,
0.0775859579,
0.066484794,
-0.1061355397,
-0.0146384882,
0.0318635143,
-0.0064720088,
0.0037032082,
-0.0044846144,
-0.0383142717,
-0.0364743844,
-0.0021949837,
-0.0524874069,
-0.0276979487,
-0.0395542011,
-0.0244727302,
0.0595091842,
0.0071838647,
0.0323745385,
0.0355844907,
-0.0066732359,
0.0247962661,
-0.0079611223,
-0.0193041898,
-0.0108983507,
-0.0052027395,
0.0060762423,
0.0005530374,
0.0409632549,
-0.0479265116,
0.0344593897,
-0.0327765234,
-0.0182965342,
0.0326960608,
0.006922822,
0.0579984784,
0.0402537249,
-0.0117424382,
-0.0385144837,
0.0639385432,
0.040864747,
0.0204521958,
-0.0534601882,
0.0235645343,
-0.0073099672,
-0.0050728912,
-0.031735383,
0.0747862533,
-0.0437026173,
-0.0913901776,
0.0218380056,
0.0506049134,
-0.0305255353,
0.0322472192,
-0.0258760527,
-0.0566461049,
0.0056216638,
-0.0499872342,
-0.0085186325,
-0.0013634838,
-0.0104346285,
-0.0237338375,
-0.0186805036,
-0.0238136593,
0.0025095092,
0.0461372994,
-0.035555277,
0.0393018425,
-0.0146484431,
-0.0311107598,
-0.0565742627,
0.0288984682,
0.0077130906,
0.047795292,
-0.0483514145,
-0.0181801766,
-0.0191624686,
-0.0401653461,
0.0027268706,
-0.0410730764,
0.0116654411,
-0.0092933187,
0.0072389995,
0.0269959942,
0.0006124052,
0.0041070334,
-0.090036273,
0.0172502808,
-0.0014603811,
-0.0520924926,
0.0018985749,
-5.648178724e-33,
0.0464249924,
-0.0231250599,
-0.0266407598,
0.0225703344,
0.0509276018,
0.0233779084,
-0.0041801748,
0.0333987288,
0.0088223787,
-0.0028761043,
-0.0270793252,
0.0217901599,
0.0304948781,
0.0249724537,
-0.0027593614,
-0.0355796441,
0.0137732336,
-0.0099012414,
0.0109062139,
0.0566744804,
0.0506494045,
0.0093216039,
-0.002932091,
-0.1059029475,
0.0688903779,
-0.019316433,
-0.047440812,
-0.0328329504,
-0.0353492871,
0.0568583198,
-0.0214727167,
0.0340867117,
-0.0153195513,
-0.0454868674,
0.0031421653,
0.0750131011,
-0.0139446501,
-0.0368284546,
0.0049047335,
0.006338581,
-0.0315753929,
-0.0764281973,
0.0072243693,
-0.0023353233,
-0.0393857844,
0.0291283801,
-0.0373007916,
0.0091342553,
-0.0059162984,
-0.0387098119,
0.0469634868,
0.0090304054,
-0.0290558357,
0.0130584063,
0.0618225448,
0.0302596446,
0.0001326799,
0.0219090786,
-0.0207018647,
0.0528193675,
-0.0173860453,
-0.0369237848,
-0.0239852127,
-0.0064664916,
-0.0396762267,
0.0280035678,
0.0527488999,
-0.032595668,
-0.0043850723,
0.004008106,
-0.0206796322,
-0.0014637386,
0.0254950803,
0.0492312722,
0.0353995785,
-0.0591767952,
-0.0159699172,
0.0209141653,
0.0581055097,
-0.0259630848,
0.0730159953,
-0.0034926373,
-0.0719965696,
-0.0300774425,
-0.0263332017,
-0.0053410078,
-0.0439759158,
-0.0066720778,
-0.0329674818,
0.005027852,
-0.0245976988,
-0.0167949758,
0.0142237712,
-0.0506853722,
-0.0215365738,
0.0156659465,
0.0072316104,
-0.0353142954,
0.0145071317,
0.0321109891,
0.0285022445,
0.018519016,
-0.0318791196,
-0.0899191126,
0.0073673376,
0.0176100917,
0.0232109837,
-0.0031537341,
-0.0766634345,
-0.0357119292,
0.0288850889,
0.0476509593,
0.010924669,
0.0015640112,
0.0304415338,
0.0006996474,
0.0174931921,
0.0278698877,
0.0207678583,
0.0373224728,
-0.0211917497,
-0.0060766698,
-0.0133522525,
-0.0065769758,
0.0285967588,
-0.0135611873,
-0.0146901598,
-0.0168464165,
0.0349183269,
0.0182185117,
0.0086285761,
-0.034625195,
2.948e-7,
0.0230050888,
0.0220898818,
-0.0084635466,
0.002208971,
0.0508395657,
0.0825959295,
0.0180409215,
0.0527421534,
-0.0101817846,
0.0106026512,
-0.0368532538,
-0.0059332903,
0.0959800184,
0.0317546465,
-0.0880717635,
-0.0179600231,
-0.0554604642,
0.0001892982,
-0.0679519475,
0.0755800605,
0.0586505085,
0.0953106657,
0.0397442691,
-0.0002604666,
-0.0315207578,
-0.0134483427,
0.0107393125,
-0.0662656724,
-0.0147840325,
-0.0431273058,
0.0376733355,
0.0369378142,
0.0351835713,
0.0236827713,
-0.0183516145,
-0.0179460775,
-0.0078927185,
0.0628314614,
0.0635155365,
0.0225648116,
0.0135776801,
-0.037132252,
0.0011043665,
-0.0365634561,
0.051247064,
0.0322795324,
-0.0568207018,
-0.0313650854,
0.0219512638,
-0.0426901169,
0.0805529058,
-0.0086352546,
-0.0449570939,
0.0212385599,
0.0163478758,
0.004574087,
-0.0094166538,
-0.0617529526,
-0.0123991882,
-0.0382152423,
-0.0114742173,
-0.0049667684,
-0.0198151562,
0.0505857654,
0.0327047929,
-0.0032429898,
0.0823487192,
2.781334888e-34,
0.0046284609,
-0.0250682794,
-0.0084011434,
0.0330085307,
0.0299935825,
-0.0067114546,
0.088285096,
0.0086350525,
0.048940707,
-0.0210261829,
-0.0108438656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05864v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05864v1 | Permute-and-Flip: An optimally robust and watermarkable decoder for LLMs | 2024-02-08T17:54:23 | 2024-02-08T17:54:23 | Xuandong Zhao, Lei Li, Yu-Xiang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose a new decoding method called Permute-and-Flip (PF)
decoder. It enjoys robustness properties similar to the standard sampling
decoder, but is provably up to 2x better in its quality-robustness tradeoff
than sampling and never worse than any other decoder. We also design a
cryptographic watermarking scheme analogous to Aaronson's Gumbel watermark, but
naturally tailored for PF decoder. The watermarking scheme does not change the
distribution to sample, while allowing arbitrarily low false positive rate and
high recall whenever the generated text has high entropy. Our experiments show
that the PF decoder (and its watermarked counterpart) significantly
outperform(s) naive sampling (and it's Gumbel watermarked counterpart) in terms
of perplexity, while retaining the same robustness (and detectability), hence
making it a promising new approach for LLM decoding. The code is available at
https://github.com/XuandongZhao/pf-decoding | [
-0.0099764457,
0.0233818162,
0.0290792529,
0.0528883487,
-0.0382404514,
0.022407556,
-0.0272867437,
0.0464125536,
-0.0164627023,
-0.0083141811,
-0.025067322,
0.0410768464,
-0.002144071,
-0.0181024801,
0.043446444,
-0.0032669033,
-0.0181073677,
-0.0058939224,
-0.0067336103,
-0.0197330546,
-0.0319117233,
-0.005160111,
0.0156289935,
-0.0417909548,
0.0414821431,
-0.0244061984,
-0.0413791426,
0.0362608656,
0.0119197061,
-0.0445260331,
-0.056729544,
0.0180567168,
-0.003831611,
0.0549934767,
0.0000022699,
-0.0109550785,
-0.0353994444,
0.0235594325,
-0.0622735545,
0.0181821287,
0.0313653722,
-0.0177771952,
-0.0493786335,
0.0184666831,
-0.0537127182,
0.0299269799,
0.0149436789,
0.0784010887,
0.0369375423,
0.0775265843,
-0.0026919963,
-0.0353351869,
0.0440293178,
-0.0048884992,
0.0463291183,
-0.0509535,
-0.0033179249,
-0.012324092,
-0.0401675664,
0.0129912328,
-0.0431464873,
0.0224805921,
0.0078129582,
0.0131600443,
-0.0399868302,
-0.0104508931,
0.0373355709,
0.0120220855,
-0.0418987721,
0.0298857968,
-0.0299877319,
-0.0288351662,
0.0136556271,
-0.0086483583,
0.0287585016,
-0.0077329469,
-0.0151648307,
0.0197140295,
-0.0083511751,
0.0535201691,
0.0007176528,
0.0023690925,
0.0443232432,
-0.0309004821,
-0.0386877693,
0.0676332191,
0.0296208356,
-0.0022155493,
-0.0315775648,
0.0065603787,
0.0191925,
0.003211681,
0.0028928567,
-0.0093974154,
0.0573971532,
-0.0178638995,
-0.0926903337,
-0.0486600772,
-0.0004470855,
-0.0459278822,
0.0496016592,
0.0025475831,
0.0190505981,
0.0269529819,
-0.0507633574,
0.0199046209,
-0.0398021564,
0.0779699311,
0.0221912544,
0.0134541653,
0.0345525779,
-0.0174352974,
0.0009172412,
0.0575293936,
-0.0014277791,
0.0349556245,
-0.0245632846,
0.0399652161,
0.043796882,
0.019124737,
0.0041253436,
-0.0303897168,
-0.0089148609,
-0.0238680486,
0.0435969718,
-0.0300661922,
0.0442943051,
0.0185695309,
-0.0181859508,
-0.0215810388,
-0.0182613693,
0.0511732027,
-0.0023159978,
0.0234686267,
-0.0257469416,
0.0810768753,
0.0125419749,
-0.0465702042,
-0.0373560041,
-0.0163766388,
0.0169447921,
0.0215082429,
0.0073127351,
-0.0377157293,
0.0021537351,
-0.0107302302,
0.015270344,
-0.0473238789,
0.025600763,
0.0069460548,
0.0188836046,
0.0490389578,
-0.0286847856,
-0.0392756201,
-0.0200402327,
0.0206898078,
-0.0086403545,
0.0695965588,
0.0497444384,
0.0068187378,
0.0375446863,
0.0244368985,
0.0220423676,
0.0387536213,
0.0205837991,
-0.0132091204,
0.0252347309,
-0.0299890637,
0.0341328047,
-0.0397906154,
0.0435480289,
0.0239827745,
-0.0206783004,
-0.0501678847,
0.0103631113,
0.0375519618,
0.0000631948,
-0.0136879561,
-0.0670581609,
0.0190992802,
0.0298652761,
0.009096982,
0.0082130861,
0.0274963211,
-0.0368047766,
-0.0180919934,
0.0488445312,
-0.0104023283,
-0.0144348582,
0.0070480327,
-0.0021076135,
-0.0431352668,
-0.0057417718,
-0.0170117021,
0.0238928925,
0.0142823448,
-0.0378751196,
0.0728212446,
-0.030995477,
-0.0534745418,
-0.0172636099,
-0.05275378,
-0.0017656269,
0.0434497409,
0.0666186064,
-0.0009897933,
0.0802546367,
0.006807887,
-0.0635676384,
0.0263901986,
-0.0577200875,
0.049636092,
0.0541241169,
-0.0334865153,
-0.0246550329,
0.0077412529,
0.0194688011,
0.0267978925,
0.0132261515,
0.0514576435,
0.0034350993,
-0.0642152503,
0.0417360067,
-0.0073214355,
0.0154373478,
-0.0589232333,
0.0424276516,
-0.0239038691,
0.0376339033,
0.0358634219,
0.0098914448,
0.0437068492,
0.0315216444,
-0.0604234114,
-0.0111226831,
-0.0253735986,
0.0203092918,
-0.0809988081,
0.019410165,
-0.0748671964,
0.0010401739,
0.0449431241,
-0.0313863046,
-0.0125545627,
0.0042003542,
-0.0275906175,
0.0462794043,
-0.0386062004,
0.0146446154,
0.0127016753,
0.0313178524,
-0.0449126624,
-0.0015982985,
-0.0457226969,
0.006337136,
-0.0506464541,
0.0246364642,
0.018455008,
-0.0390685834,
-0.0328601003,
0.0297296345,
-0.0234139655,
0.0013144921,
-0.0505448841,
0.0387889519,
0.0211806018,
-0.051907625,
0.0267086532,
-0.0077745467,
-0.022294933,
0.0477722287,
0.0031172091,
-0.0272602085,
0.0148994913,
-0.0433436036,
-0.0524465777,
-0.0271427575,
-0.0112476954,
-0.0452457592,
0.0147706885,
-0.0221163034,
-0.0171176996,
0.0651459098,
0.0297762137,
0.0374324471,
0.034027122,
-0.0387107879,
-0.0466595143,
-0.1166840345,
0.0638887361,
0.0369874761,
-0.045236133,
0.0040629883,
0.0123916185,
0.0001250758,
-0.0124005117,
-0.0302252937,
0.0275012366,
-0.0010590903,
-0.0132208159,
-0.0270986576,
0.0417118222,
-0.0282201562,
-0.0416322351,
0.0050227363,
-0.0293472186,
-0.042707812,
-0.0332225598,
0.0304727517,
-0.0344705768,
0.0137998592,
0.0099604093,
0.0070715165,
-0.0064322962,
0.0637467355,
-0.0244989228,
0.0122127291,
0.0215565786,
-0.0228173193,
0.0137785431,
0.0023725654,
-0.0316980891,
-0.0241958871,
-0.0459514707,
0.0039231614,
-0.0187432207,
-0.0106691057,
-0.0223586578,
0.0242902134,
-0.0455474518,
0.0170134082,
-0.0291515309,
-0.0529533513,
-0.0057240506,
-0.0160358157,
0.060672611,
-0.070231311,
-0.0237531047,
-0.0110566402,
-0.0353029668,
-0.0424364433,
-0.011427572,
-0.0207282547,
-0.0124880616,
-0.014227557,
-0.0471399948,
0.008036484,
-0.0068852315,
0.0025852672,
-0.0000435491,
0.0329345576,
-0.0273443982,
-0.0099962624,
0.0143912314,
-0.0375875086,
0.0316244811,
-0.0573859997,
-0.0218043961,
0.0442526788,
-0.0054034973,
0.0149011565,
0.1071814001,
-0.003756281,
0.0167162046,
0.0298451874,
0.0187778063,
0.0562081188,
0.0046501537,
-0.0090663973,
0.024713248,
0.003069025,
0.0289032925,
0.0270454213,
0.0258796252,
0.0001601367,
-0.0662867203,
-0.0088580344,
0.0006968593,
-0.014769217,
-0.0005761499,
-0.0367998742,
-0.0783108324,
-0.0278855097,
0.0358165205,
0.0882933587,
-0.0094450992,
0.0186043195,
-0.0443888046,
-0.059222348,
0.0268241297,
0.0474723652,
0.0250790343,
-0.085888654,
-0.0381132327,
-0.0426265784,
0.0636646152,
0.0143777514,
-0.002135718,
0.0615736395,
-0.0150045846,
0.0157313813,
-0.0111796614,
-0.0366866142,
-0.0467768796,
0.0090036588,
0.0277609695,
0.0799404904,
0.0168297794,
0.0103845196,
-0.0376028828,
-0.002194209,
-0.0044915541,
-0.0759843662,
-0.0194326043,
0.0144951157,
0.0154337864,
-0.0086419601,
-0.0113057196,
0.0173037983,
0.0121436585,
-0.0259391926,
-0.0211788416,
0.0221753512,
-0.0170128122,
0.0027173543,
0.0319844373,
-0.0268140696,
0.029964257,
0.0527328029,
-0.0059280335,
0.0046693236,
-0.0178786572,
-0.0812036544,
0.066506438,
-0.0778815374,
-0.0399725474,
0.0044975691,
-0.0119865956,
-0.0197595097,
0.0004131197,
0.0693737119,
-0.0425131992,
0.0177566838,
0.0061306329,
0.0639621168,
0.0134415757,
-0.0335957482,
-0.0684589073,
-0.0983194858,
-0.0885650814,
0.0254510771,
-0.0741075501,
-0.0221969727,
0.0375451855,
-0.0056421435,
0.0000145206,
0.0257943701,
-0.0823516697,
-0.0118351029,
0.0158403572,
-0.0083996244,
0.0155112278,
-0.0263169799,
-0.0097856922,
-0.0137695428,
0.0444734246,
0.0640798509,
0.0050810524,
0.0494199023,
0.0482697859,
0.0351875797,
0.0139035322,
0.0295591075,
-0.0561149679,
-0.059480153,
0.0557739809,
-0.000054221,
-0.0341091901,
-0.0407851115,
0.0097715175,
0.073458083,
-0.0197711606,
-0.0310398005,
0.0514771976,
0.0617098883,
0.0875934958,
-0.0307265297,
0.0059891245,
-0.0146240201,
0.0314501524,
0.0247916076,
-0.0645368472,
0.0139499381,
-0.0064296531,
0.0103684599,
0.0130567504,
0.009176679,
0.0422508381,
-0.0595163964,
-0.0221914575,
0.0034277714,
-0.0017702436,
-0.0046186415,
0.048584044,
0.0647657439,
-0.0000442344,
0.0258105528,
-0.0121902749,
0.0121107148,
0.0012509436,
-0.0189400017,
0.0374821499,
-0.0805281922,
-0.0137087973,
-0.0074833254,
0.0280448832,
0.0423170961,
0.0916704386,
0.0060958164,
-0.0273438003,
0.0168204363,
-0.0426500887,
0.0255420897,
-0.0442470014,
0.0084715951,
0.0014302428,
-0.0382376499,
-0.0121519305,
0.0148237534,
0.0212459676,
0.0213512611,
0.0298262239,
-0.0096477922,
0.0057889167,
-0.0392688662,
-0.02818322,
0.0441803709,
0.0154776331,
-0.0164824594,
-0.0139645524,
-0.027949743,
0.003139378,
0.0401122645,
-0.0159874614,
0.0440027155,
0.0109842932,
-0.0330356769,
-0.0067141759,
-0.023066001,
0.01286685,
-0.0312100183,
0.0076937145,
0.0717631429,
-0.0654030889,
0.0061505381,
-5.501729393e-33,
-0.0202822555,
-0.0203737542,
-0.0419289693,
-0.0140463663,
0.0478651747,
-0.0190090723,
0.0049936883,
-0.0011718264,
0.0459672622,
-0.0172626879,
0.0076185968,
-0.007933436,
0.0300332457,
0.0183655806,
-0.0542838983,
-0.037481647,
-0.003705852,
-0.0307679474,
-0.0092314845,
-0.0153400321,
0.0384757295,
0.0156418849,
0.0402427241,
-0.0412787721,
0.0108693046,
-0.0180659126,
-0.0730539411,
-0.0370746031,
-0.0349518657,
0.0259898342,
0.014397121,
-0.0123297926,
-0.0079301484,
0.0211345516,
-0.0314123705,
0.0080202091,
-0.0103855599,
-0.0178311691,
-0.0033104594,
0.0574634038,
0.0498223118,
-0.0898150876,
-0.0186756682,
-0.0102148373,
-0.0531257764,
0.0252671614,
-0.0478065796,
-0.0154227316,
-0.0175419431,
-0.0576893315,
0.0778750852,
0.036885675,
-0.0198901948,
0.0235688183,
0.020218078,
-0.0326940417,
-0.0197496172,
0.0023863222,
-0.0815011188,
0.0536106229,
0.0276755095,
-0.0061656614,
0.0029012619,
-0.0142241791,
-0.0148066655,
0.0162134599,
0.0153917391,
-0.03755771,
-0.0098222066,
-0.0217047352,
-0.0016723326,
0.0047830995,
0.0291095115,
0.0764057413,
0.0936840549,
-0.0127870152,
-0.0126515552,
0.0568607673,
-0.0283754412,
-0.0389668383,
0.0376127474,
0.0297501124,
-0.0404015444,
-0.0324967429,
-0.0205822401,
-0.0463924594,
0.0103801889,
0.0058891559,
0.0189145319,
0.0138568161,
-0.0252541099,
-0.0413029306,
0.0331589952,
-0.0584069565,
-0.0433681495,
-0.0257914327,
0.0299597569,
0.0302976519,
-0.0222892947,
-0.0003882164,
0.066688478,
0.0132694049,
0.0367380306,
-0.072026886,
0.0173156075,
-0.0379800871,
0.030743897,
0.0066012149,
-0.0977958366,
-0.0195538718,
0.0270827264,
-0.0118139461,
0.0555948094,
-0.0249907617,
-0.0159282237,
-0.0661448985,
0.0132848239,
-0.0361428633,
-0.0137751093,
-0.0357758291,
0.0123275751,
0.001270261,
-0.0099103656,
0.0648367181,
0.004542795,
0.0542284995,
-0.0055114916,
0.0311098974,
0.0413159207,
-0.0019212238,
-0.0131617626,
0.0166450497,
2.888e-7,
0.0492756292,
-0.0103504956,
0.0533752106,
0.0171448942,
0.0259602144,
0.0226002466,
-0.0134680606,
0.0233130641,
-0.0766724795,
-0.0043416438,
-0.0459242314,
0.0148442956,
0.0626865774,
-0.0393329896,
-0.0606808327,
0.014691934,
0.054824762,
-0.0106021911,
-0.0025115414,
0.0132351136,
0.0637740418,
0.0617321916,
-0.004878683,
-0.0002839191,
0.0130773392,
-0.0338744894,
0.0101179937,
-0.0234105587,
0.0320083238,
-0.0439276807,
0.0085262842,
-0.0327318311,
0.0279293619,
0.0120715238,
-0.0290998612,
-0.0457919873,
-0.0018188342,
0.0687540472,
0.0231311675,
-0.079677552,
-0.0234169494,
-0.0092239091,
-0.0051523433,
0.0181542672,
0.0317092575,
0.1184620783,
-0.0116827972,
-0.0129345218,
-0.0596407019,
0.006950059,
0.0343458839,
-0.0034273255,
0.0024288108,
-0.0036398889,
0.0130948629,
0.0206367914,
0.0026731596,
-0.0153643703,
-0.0201383848,
-0.0898046941,
-0.0151024954,
-0.0401498005,
-0.0290741865,
0.0508437045,
0.0874562263,
-0.0576280095,
0.0046355696,
2.962724686e-34,
0.0146316458,
-0.0560709052,
-0.0025667343,
0.1207831278,
0.0184754189,
0.0034272263,
0.0255675167,
0.0209728647,
0.0102205602,
-0.0381330997,
0.0123827327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05863v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05863v1 | How Well Can LLMs Negotiate? NegotiationArena Platform and Analysis | 2024-02-08T17:51:48 | 2024-02-08T17:51:48 | Federico Bianchi, Patrick John Chia, Mert Yuksekgonul, Jacopo Tagliabue, Dan Jurafsky, James Zou | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT | Negotiation is the basis of social interactions; humans negotiate everything
from the price of cars to how to share common resources. With rapidly growing
interest in using large language models (LLMs) to act as agents on behalf of
human users, such LLM agents would also need to be able to negotiate. In this
paper, we study how well LLMs can negotiate with each other. We develop
NegotiationArena: a flexible framework for evaluating and probing the
negotiation abilities of LLM agents. We implemented three types of scenarios in
NegotiationArena to assess LLM's behaviors in allocating shared resources
(ultimatum games), aggregate resources (trading games) and buy/sell goods
(price negotiations). Each scenario allows for multiple turns of flexible
dialogues between LLM agents to allow for more complex negotiations.
Interestingly, LLM agents can significantly boost their negotiation outcomes by
employing certain behavioral tactics. For example, by pretending to be desolate
and desperate, LLMs can improve their payoffs by 20\% when negotiating against
the standard GPT-4. We also quantify irrational negotiation behaviors exhibited
by the LLM agents, many of which also appear in humans. Together,
\NegotiationArena offers a new environment to investigate LLM interactions,
enabling new insights into LLM's theory of mind, irrationality, and reasoning
abilities. | [
0.06513796,
0.0715891793,
-0.0372529291,
0.0439950116,
-0.0348949395,
-0.0170755144,
0.0134728719,
0.0245119538,
0.0054488652,
-0.0125000011,
-0.0613499209,
-0.0390169807,
0.0240584873,
0.02576508,
0.028319316,
-0.0593040213,
-0.0040388349,
-0.0255813822,
0.0729107037,
-0.0167571865,
-0.0058055762,
-0.0026355104,
-0.005914594,
0.0318892896,
-0.0026649027,
-0.0021245652,
-0.0345143639,
-0.0134158125,
0.0275864713,
-0.03924492,
-0.0194563214,
0.0580263026,
0.0126297399,
0.0281646792,
0.0000020786,
-0.0785851255,
0.0141895935,
-0.0321377702,
-0.0172864534,
0.0282218959,
0.0769361928,
-0.0089140702,
0.0131840007,
0.0167837236,
-0.1016427502,
-0.0106697986,
0.0205375943,
0.0908724815,
0.0569189638,
0.0524971336,
-0.0040328139,
0.0275226254,
0.0060019731,
-0.0299207605,
0.0051414431,
-0.0753934532,
0.0345824286,
-0.0174394287,
0.0356674306,
-0.002831927,
0.011791938,
-0.008246839,
0.0059238607,
-0.0216529947,
-0.0837695003,
0.0438868068,
-0.0578597784,
-0.0290496349,
-0.0089765349,
0.0706062987,
0.0266981851,
0.0089496998,
0.0290890504,
-0.0063891513,
0.0156347435,
-0.0053624953,
-0.0256351456,
0.0455279499,
0.009689902,
0.0195010602,
-0.0006755406,
0.0209196378,
0.0250852183,
0.0175453313,
-0.0058407285,
0.0825620815,
-0.0390442125,
-0.0128932949,
0.0105586508,
-0.0293746721,
-0.0391395614,
-0.0936664864,
-0.0302746315,
0.0329798758,
-0.064503409,
0.0182442944,
-0.0343026817,
0.0405246355,
0.0352822617,
-0.0517228954,
0.0072371424,
0.0205667876,
0.0363371,
0.0402671248,
0.0613876507,
0.0131814843,
-0.0202995241,
0.0148595357,
-0.0064979354,
0.029581992,
-0.0005479508,
-0.020347381,
-0.0349916071,
0.0019956781,
-0.0346572436,
-0.0251658317,
-0.0209535696,
0.0305034202,
-0.0598281249,
0.0136327585,
-0.0181660559,
0.0222015213,
0.0383287109,
-0.0011086575,
-0.0652540028,
-0.0385615528,
-0.0481442995,
0.016745545,
0.0383875519,
-0.0653504431,
0.0129329069,
-0.0111823892,
-0.0064761657,
-0.0303399842,
0.0028189197,
0.0872314796,
-0.003011124,
0.0105053661,
-0.0097721405,
-0.034401346,
0.0377672911,
-0.0785809383,
-0.0228340086,
-0.0475303642,
0.0325981937,
0.0045843343,
-0.0485618934,
-0.0471979938,
0.0254189447,
0.0038704793,
-0.0410006605,
0.0834787488,
0.0088083912,
0.0190043561,
0.0433782786,
0.032369975,
-0.0438847877,
0.0476100743,
0.06214156,
0.0053219777,
0.0443670005,
0.0115446383,
0.0399196967,
0.0478506424,
-0.0135484505,
0.0081514446,
0.0199064035,
-0.0055111875,
-0.007260202,
0.0411567204,
0.0077855983,
0.0549376644,
-0.053975936,
-0.0514766723,
0.1105616167,
0.0989887714,
-0.0179634038,
0.0303300284,
-0.0173906498,
0.0705653355,
0.002252209,
-0.0415843576,
-0.0400792174,
0.0505326204,
-0.0155739682,
-0.0208657645,
0.0195550881,
0.0123241367,
-0.0217738301,
-0.0106298029,
-0.0084794788,
-0.0096400576,
0.070272401,
0.0227876995,
-0.0316135883,
-0.0523974299,
-0.0285570566,
0.0043472424,
0.0003723327,
-0.0122446371,
-0.0226012804,
-0.0504112281,
0.0200217403,
0.0476007946,
0.0333215296,
0.0058629499,
0.0316491537,
-0.0090221716,
-0.0390838906,
0.057299383,
0.0524144545,
-0.0004250963,
-0.0246516149,
-0.0438689552,
0.0059358124,
-0.0121778548,
0.002697245,
0.0211717542,
-0.0068465918,
0.0116448412,
-0.012777484,
-0.0222542472,
0.0324019156,
-0.0036766645,
0.0031380544,
-0.0258246306,
-0.0495466366,
0.0145679982,
0.0344422348,
-0.0214121565,
0.0030150907,
0.0037144087,
0.0120548857,
0.0123831984,
-0.0338129476,
0.0564870201,
-0.004323096,
0.0463819392,
0.0210611876,
0.0008768507,
-0.0217749309,
-0.0159721691,
0.0107572749,
-0.005159446,
0.0301257819,
-0.0173077602,
0.0451496914,
-0.0289535932,
0.0035494294,
-0.0088056745,
0.0335554965,
0.0175985117,
0.0412875079,
0.0176174566,
-0.0168150067,
0.0113524534,
-0.0394530483,
0.0069835894,
-0.0500633493,
0.0318527296,
0.0093916086,
0.01281182,
0.0424529612,
0.0086822985,
0.0285717919,
-0.0277984999,
-0.0247793179,
-0.0728785172,
-0.0420737341,
0.0230215769,
0.0007744745,
0.0112039503,
-0.0257179867,
-0.0160485711,
0.0404057838,
-0.0207477398,
0.0283781514,
0.0387318656,
0.0372503102,
0.0194687583,
-0.0144381886,
-0.0210335068,
-0.0423541516,
0.0295597166,
-0.0205309764,
0.0264427904,
0.0036004898,
0.0220697988,
-0.0306656882,
0.0057639903,
-0.0359723717,
0.038035702,
-0.0306202285,
-0.0686254501,
0.0355654918,
0.014523915,
-0.0171200112,
0.0594008081,
0.0130209345,
0.0444390625,
0.0231575333,
-0.0386297703,
-0.077011779,
0.0152624436,
-0.0071461434,
0.0396017171,
-0.0947232693,
-0.0628084168,
-0.0181137752,
0.0863916799,
-0.0121094957,
0.0328886621,
-0.0213949997,
0.0642362311,
0.033275187,
-0.0648019388,
-0.008608928,
0.0045930874,
-0.0356304161,
0.096301131,
-0.0018467574,
-0.0238266699,
0.0782026649,
-0.0200703535,
-0.0184655301,
0.0279431585,
0.0150680775,
-0.03903725,
0.0830496326,
-0.0389029235,
-0.0193629991,
0.0028955375,
0.0023301358,
-0.0212015267,
-0.0562886596,
0.0195192154,
-0.0207953621,
0.048142191,
-0.0618381537,
-0.0128362598,
-0.0004912783,
-0.0091308989,
-0.0289573185,
-0.0364654548,
-0.0558587685,
0.0210889652,
0.0267398227,
-0.0416811742,
-0.0693666413,
-0.0110412324,
0.0301114731,
-0.0007985294,
0.0228807479,
-0.0093064141,
-0.0120392935,
-0.0468361862,
0.0518496633,
0.070010379,
0.0282633286,
-0.0245980471,
0.0200909991,
0.0534585454,
-0.0250540804,
-0.0077989521,
0.0191708524,
0.0166947637,
0.0175810028,
0.0187471565,
0.0177347437,
0.0343574695,
0.0095946891,
-0.0310175549,
0.0087527344,
0.0746681914,
0.032238625,
-0.011267636,
0.0325598307,
-0.0694786012,
0.0385649204,
0.0120396549,
0.0292881262,
-0.0701282471,
0.0066538244,
-0.0108599635,
0.0085430853,
-0.0353837796,
-0.05255007,
-0.0017315889,
-0.109067969,
0.0125415456,
-0.0007727825,
-0.0100564929,
0.063111037,
-0.0046154028,
0.0114105903,
-0.0042397263,
0.0484790653,
-0.0021351255,
0.0324483365,
-0.0244933013,
-0.0368522219,
0.0032000754,
0.0347504281,
0.0499703102,
-0.0245708134,
0.0626667291,
0.0098249028,
0.0667665228,
-0.0098489858,
-0.0563389808,
0.0029728201,
0.0382297374,
-0.0191051513,
-0.0043146997,
0.0011889047,
0.0127583724,
0.0168085024,
-0.005024923,
0.0418685749,
-0.0452228598,
-0.028350858,
0.0329175517,
0.0600881279,
-0.0150618246,
-0.0432314537,
0.0329295248,
0.0094825551,
0.0314553715,
0.0429067872,
0.0024435956,
-0.0589805655,
-0.0555946603,
-0.0306821689,
-0.0667198226,
-0.0154444752,
-0.0782072023,
-0.0024504557,
0.0492202714,
-0.0018478411,
-0.0382219516,
-0.0772120953,
0.0097138956,
-0.0016100791,
0.0055911397,
-0.0130127156,
0.0496634319,
0.0068562841,
0.0181463063,
0.0070389756,
-0.0136942761,
0.0187151302,
-0.0171263441,
0.0061052102,
-0.0094457539,
-0.0803582445,
-0.0105105452,
-0.0144450422,
-0.0080879005,
-0.0559857972,
-0.0138936937,
0.0216036122,
0.0343179889,
-0.0132677611,
0.007073869,
-0.0467055179,
-0.0495245308,
0.0032042968,
-0.0233141389,
0.0536041074,
0.0251865536,
0.0512541197,
0.0083574262,
0.0455019362,
-0.0128005994,
0.0322084352,
0.0036808564,
0.0323393568,
-0.0592458881,
-0.0606374741,
0.008758653,
-0.0236111805,
-0.0375186875,
0.0220321938,
-0.0075523234,
-0.0010557428,
0.0066727828,
-0.0462130606,
0.0044019357,
-0.0284243673,
-0.0787324607,
0.006709198,
0.0127184466,
0.0156831034,
-0.0336579382,
-0.0339896977,
0.0098078633,
0.0574629344,
0.0212890506,
-0.0174977053,
-0.0061780815,
0.019913435,
0.0054597193,
0.0332287438,
0.0312063415,
-0.0497478098,
0.0507870689,
0.0227481779,
0.0769214481,
0.0101660499,
-0.0554650947,
0.0007738208,
0.0327800661,
-0.0134155508,
-0.1059783995,
0.0852140859,
0.0123287998,
-0.0046290429,
-0.0017410653,
0.0446657948,
-0.0588816106,
0.0174233746,
-0.0125479391,
0.0038699897,
-0.0324465297,
-0.0608002804,
0.0229912978,
0.0200928245,
-0.03214854,
0.0116648739,
0.0255152192,
-0.0262297653,
0.010286239,
-0.020423051,
-0.0154278977,
-0.0171389915,
-0.0379510596,
-0.0266175866,
-0.0132868215,
-0.02987005,
0.0012869017,
-0.0763199851,
-0.0368703119,
-0.0030509694,
0.03082815,
-0.0433199592,
-0.033709649,
0.0092271948,
0.0329132602,
-0.0082147606,
0.0077988524,
-0.0212629158,
0.0109536676,
-0.0530873276,
-0.0246751681,
-0.0574558638,
-6.135793617e-33,
0.0177073739,
-0.0631282926,
0.0407676399,
0.0224627759,
-0.0111747431,
-0.0503260307,
-0.0437489785,
0.0388594866,
-0.0172636341,
0.0055485382,
-0.0343613923,
-0.0089875758,
0.0262199603,
-0.0285103191,
0.0209303759,
-0.0054412521,
-0.0107129505,
-0.0138814114,
-0.0356770381,
-0.0287549123,
-0.002390638,
-0.0129086953,
0.0326881446,
-0.0758142322,
0.0354341716,
-0.011601299,
-0.0181828011,
0.0224337392,
-0.0302697551,
0.0337860622,
-0.0099617187,
0.0049546389,
0.0189226288,
-0.0012281229,
0.0080549587,
0.0300889574,
0.0034725284,
-0.0056884079,
0.0565463677,
-0.0201430004,
-0.0253255218,
-0.038919799,
-0.002627366,
-0.0043464135,
-0.036729075,
0.0015860988,
0.0162285026,
-0.0032736801,
0.0103640929,
0.0618491732,
-0.0511793792,
-0.0013548572,
-0.0411760323,
-0.001784677,
-0.0024764847,
0.0104912454,
-0.0316923559,
-0.0229633804,
-0.0780068934,
0.0569275133,
-0.0299155153,
0.001094628,
0.0315302648,
-0.0256573837,
0.0516313612,
0.0765641481,
0.0136185102,
0.0404669046,
-0.0120610362,
-0.0308512878,
0.0409456082,
0.0885116979,
0.019112397,
0.0675076321,
-0.0433732644,
-0.0309825707,
0.0171963219,
-0.0003147465,
0.0709802508,
0.0163720157,
0.0382970832,
0.0366834849,
0.0063515529,
-0.0209178831,
-0.023676008,
-0.0010281831,
-0.0453300588,
-0.0524601042,
0.0168539155,
0.0122292442,
0.0268291067,
-0.0092481226,
0.0354772173,
-0.0363565348,
-0.0580914393,
-0.0080697937,
0.019679822,
0.0490279235,
-0.0069321636,
-0.0094770128,
-0.0365469642,
-0.0159023982,
-0.0041079358,
-0.001614388,
0.055031091,
0.0277808551,
-0.0253310651,
-0.0035848385,
-0.0088518625,
-0.0047783256,
-0.0182370543,
0.049111288,
-0.0253187008,
-0.0056064394,
0.0075065033,
-0.0151015678,
-0.0133245951,
-0.0528514758,
-0.0318676531,
-0.0494178385,
-0.0727236569,
0.0518426932,
-0.0153474566,
0.0081140269,
-0.020775171,
0.0128227761,
-0.0555819944,
0.0260323938,
0.0277031623,
-0.0182458516,
0.0026693011,
-0.0334266163,
2.786e-7,
-0.0245065577,
0.0648688972,
-0.0251033884,
0.0239251386,
0.0225875396,
0.0968045741,
-0.0349799171,
0.0235589202,
0.025436556,
-0.0721516833,
0.0216351245,
0.0325023271,
0.0632040128,
0.0505005457,
-0.0612576567,
0.0282578189,
-0.0361150727,
-0.058977101,
-0.0248564407,
-0.025375938,
0.0543335788,
0.021487955,
0.0333810113,
0.0032840387,
-0.0208116192,
-0.0202354416,
0.0260641742,
-0.0843737125,
-0.0109351119,
0.0222800151,
-0.0255009718,
-0.0431054197,
0.0133329723,
-0.0054529458,
0.0112260086,
0.0113657871,
-0.0533459373,
0.0537082888,
-0.0057253973,
-0.0727781206,
-0.000355986,
-0.0431618318,
-0.019969184,
-0.0556280352,
0.0184433814,
-0.0432727337,
-0.0570522435,
0.0247333478,
0.0453655012,
-0.035383597,
-0.0183691047,
-0.0234236643,
0.0143413758,
0.0113057327,
0.0132398512,
-0.0063407044,
0.0449324735,
-0.0391772985,
-0.0201690085,
-0.0149787841,
-0.0488829389,
-0.0469285026,
-0.0370218977,
0.0484352708,
0.0042285719,
-0.016584564,
0.0070644892,
2.007216297e-34,
0.0187997222,
0.0298933145,
0.0174069572,
0.0510052592,
0.0676303729,
0.0391641743,
0.01440203,
0.0468961,
0.0247701071,
-0.0563086085,
-0.0094055478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06690v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06690v1 | Neural Models for Source Code Synthesis and Completion | 2024-02-08T17:10:12 | 2024-02-08T17:10:12 | Mitodru Niyogi | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL | Natural language (NL) to code suggestion systems assist developers in
Integrated Development Environments (IDEs) by translating NL utterances into
compilable code snippet. The current approaches mainly involve hard-coded,
rule-based systems based on semantic parsing. These systems make heavy use of
hand-crafted rules that map patterns in NL or elements in its syntax parse tree
to various query constructs and can only work on a limited subset of NL with a
restricted NL syntax. These systems are unable to extract semantic information
from the coding intents of the developer, and often fail to infer types, names,
and the context of the source code to get accurate system-level code
suggestions. In this master thesis, we present sequence-to-sequence deep
learning models and training paradigms to map NL to general-purpose programming
languages that can assist users with suggestions of source code snippets, given
a NL intent, and also extend auto-completion functionality of the source code
to users while they are writing source code. The developed architecture
incorporates contextual awareness into neural models which generate source code
tokens directly instead of generating parse trees/abstract meaning
representations from the source code and converting them back to source code.
The proposed pretraining strategy and the data augmentation techniques improve
the performance of the proposed architecture. The proposed architecture has
been found to exceed the performance of a neural semantic parser, TranX, based
on the BLEU-4 metric by 10.82%. Thereafter, a finer analysis for the parsable
code translations from the NL intent for CoNaLA challenge was introduced. The
proposed system is bidirectional as it can be also used to generate NL code
documentation given source code. Lastly, a RoBERTa masked language model for
Python was proposed to extend the developed system for code completion. | [
0.0259040464,
0.0482201278,
-0.026152242,
0.0118729444,
-0.0024180375,
-0.0087733706,
-0.0353291258,
-0.020682279,
-0.0146812918,
-0.0172899719,
-0.0020118323,
0.0386393107,
-0.011788019,
0.0768675953,
0.0295538399,
-0.0214094892,
0.0152308298,
-0.0056227185,
-0.0133398902,
0.0478815511,
-0.011919436,
0.0458492227,
0.0300774127,
0.0992350057,
-0.0059749112,
-0.0381176621,
0.0055408473,
0.0095709125,
-0.0487618223,
-0.022724878,
0.0145721799,
0.0158877671,
0.0217187777,
0.0162041225,
0.0000022982,
-0.0157412682,
0.0027855772,
-0.024855461,
-0.0277364198,
-0.0186220463,
-0.0016785535,
-0.0185278133,
0.0233445838,
0.0103613567,
-0.0622489899,
-0.0322198309,
0.0550212972,
-0.0155703099,
0.0656427965,
0.023184346,
0.0081837969,
-0.0105614588,
0.0356203392,
-0.0013104009,
0.0365066975,
-0.0191828366,
-0.0165443979,
0.0090987394,
0.0282126553,
0.0035514352,
0.0110460809,
0.0296726897,
0.0430252478,
-0.0204184335,
0.0764223337,
0.0339185521,
-0.0295255873,
-0.0290114619,
0.0104264934,
0.0611892641,
-0.0693603009,
-0.0343534835,
0.0105493451,
-0.0271542631,
-0.0157478061,
-0.0702501908,
-0.0160658881,
0.0106773432,
0.0009971055,
-0.016073307,
0.0003259631,
-0.0299938098,
0.0088044805,
-0.0031113508,
-0.0154069206,
0.0347348452,
-0.0034453797,
0.0124784028,
-0.0232056025,
-0.0273793098,
0.034780018,
-0.0722026974,
0.0224442687,
0.0697207078,
-0.0290057678,
0.0159882512,
-0.0551083162,
-0.0397439823,
-0.0005315106,
-0.0394492075,
-0.0377266929,
0.0484744422,
-0.0633684471,
0.0161342397,
-0.0585813373,
0.0324817225,
-0.0223858282,
-0.0045566252,
-0.0498401485,
-0.0195372943,
-0.0481705442,
0.0070224707,
-0.0532098264,
0.0542696305,
-0.0451937951,
0.0073524574,
-0.0133017031,
0.0691990107,
0.0327307731,
0.0396843068,
-0.0028844681,
0.0185450483,
-0.0459238216,
0.0129447086,
0.0066604475,
-0.0058323168,
-0.016130764,
-0.0409066565,
-0.013455607,
-0.0602979548,
-0.0019999391,
0.0191001724,
-0.0200294182,
-0.0378589891,
0.0425751582,
0.0748155639,
0.0371574573,
0.0091332234,
-0.0666051432,
-0.0344041698,
0.024736343,
0.0241639186,
-0.0016703079,
-0.0879914686,
-0.0365779698,
0.0144165298,
-0.0336682461,
-0.0990401804,
-0.0004997168,
0.0392355695,
0.0305422768,
0.0248591695,
-0.0976433381,
-0.0189360864,
0.0435522981,
-0.0060927826,
-0.0099651599,
0.0105425892,
0.0500096865,
0.0418883674,
0.0026443915,
-0.066298984,
0.0262665432,
-0.0117664561,
-0.0191558842,
-0.0290719178,
0.0027970017,
0.0238363259,
0.0066761151,
-0.0033027784,
0.0399277359,
0.0170111489,
0.0022465417,
-0.0267813336,
-0.0213278234,
0.0310703479,
0.0397078544,
0.0383954868,
0.1041087583,
0.0273586344,
-0.0400280058,
-0.0446877368,
-0.0421370454,
0.0807792693,
0.0087357853,
0.0072834129,
-0.0176707488,
0.043525435,
-0.0110161174,
-0.0598727427,
0.0273382012,
-0.0388391912,
0.0155341076,
0.0014892988,
0.0248145852,
0.0032053266,
-0.0519517437,
0.0048550451,
0.024692608,
-0.0286333561,
0.0034827129,
-0.0230699722,
0.031621851,
0.0511219539,
0.0491426177,
-0.0424919464,
-0.0285266675,
-0.0464755669,
-0.0193121303,
-0.0214669239,
-0.0060573835,
-0.0092651658,
0.0130933328,
-0.0643224046,
-0.0211422723,
-0.058307413,
-0.0322484002,
0.0524556674,
-0.0254447032,
-0.0327740349,
0.0310332235,
0.0132515328,
-0.0578397699,
0.0577708483,
0.0130035738,
-0.021355398,
0.02262103,
-0.0002690543,
0.0168314278,
0.0119909327,
-0.0040253261,
0.0188578665,
0.0417862646,
-0.0410075784,
-0.0570078455,
-0.0049471036,
-0.0514370352,
-0.0416309536,
0.0256156512,
-0.0434161648,
-0.0386619195,
0.0253514722,
-0.016576333,
-0.0122038759,
0.0637952089,
-0.0472520888,
0.0197603535,
0.0005801671,
-0.032691028,
0.020218445,
0.0119684469,
-0.0337123983,
0.0473068021,
0.029715376,
0.0261025447,
0.0341618918,
0.0398360305,
0.0629529282,
-0.0037278947,
-0.0197751913,
-0.0049016965,
-0.0410126783,
0.0092151882,
0.0236132573,
0.0610898174,
-0.0030022631,
0.0085908063,
-0.0494245403,
0.0039668437,
-0.0206486601,
-0.0039229733,
-0.0104213953,
0.0488042347,
0.0320241973,
-0.0417596251,
-0.0269259121,
-0.0214398131,
-0.0552033186,
-0.0258875564,
0.040606156,
0.0077107451,
-0.045648165,
-0.0344167612,
-0.0181709118,
-0.0440039635,
0.0398232378,
-0.0030903879,
-0.0250608176,
-0.0432845429,
0.0216904189,
-0.002866941,
0.0446855091,
-0.00380906,
-0.0487650372,
-0.0143801756,
-0.027452644,
0.0383985676,
0.0598536283,
-0.0081638927,
-0.0417195372,
0.0444668345,
0.0293105133,
-0.0491962917,
0.053305693,
0.0173352994,
-0.0109960437,
0.0078871511,
-0.0278823022,
0.0650025681,
0.0413162373,
0.0207983907,
-0.0039196941,
-0.0315942466,
0.0134398947,
0.0230454672,
0.0073728478,
0.0043063695,
-0.0369908847,
0.0166847873,
0.03478311,
-0.011335656,
-0.0658659488,
0.0897978172,
-0.027417386,
-0.0650524125,
-0.0500119999,
-0.0415159315,
-0.061427515,
0.053998895,
0.0106863761,
0.0127442563,
0.0111274542,
-0.0504425503,
-0.0196918231,
0.02509786,
-0.0535248928,
0.0186330341,
0.025534749,
-0.0234760586,
0.0058045285,
0.0005937018,
0.0121226376,
-0.0415102951,
-0.0047394712,
-0.0284843985,
0.006819638,
0.0639955923,
0.0053724386,
0.0709656477,
0.0101727787,
0.0212925747,
0.0582820028,
0.0609897375,
-0.0298810638,
-0.0468534119,
-0.0511906557,
0.0031617484,
-0.0307359323,
-0.0231390446,
0.0446541421,
-0.0168304853,
-0.014216871,
0.0470140651,
0.0638855398,
-0.0969634503,
-0.0098622339,
0.0457682721,
-0.0231854469,
-0.0405653454,
0.060610652,
0.0087073827,
-0.0416976102,
-0.0063339565,
0.0938774571,
0.032276772,
-0.0438105352,
0.0064322352,
-0.0193652809,
0.0028937096,
0.0805198774,
0.0542395562,
-0.0616945401,
-0.0411075689,
-0.026902644,
-0.0037212993,
0.0031065217,
0.0119301975,
-0.0192222334,
-0.0648259968,
0.0150181018,
-0.0276583619,
-0.0432004184,
-0.0464217514,
-0.0022073137,
-0.028262889,
-0.0003783012,
-0.0408447422,
0.007349262,
0.0103464676,
0.0009275696,
0.0044309706,
-0.0556768104,
0.0260739103,
0.0297823139,
-0.0500055142,
0.0402320512,
0.1400092691,
0.0303106643,
0.0033657493,
0.0019208333,
0.0376392491,
-0.0357507579,
0.0253980439,
-0.0268966779,
0.0410278328,
-0.0249213055,
-0.0145183522,
0.0533541888,
0.0073655304,
-0.0754713565,
0.0118855499,
0.0360618941,
0.0560520105,
-0.0152003579,
0.0138409277,
-0.0571481101,
0.0063902554,
-0.0060292059,
0.0187084638,
0.075356327,
-0.0281803589,
-0.0115054809,
-0.06881392,
0.0177764539,
-0.0614482053,
0.027609,
-0.0268585421,
-0.0068008495,
-0.0030921486,
-0.0691520348,
-0.0228727683,
0.0427266769,
0.0156681016,
0.0339781083,
-0.0041019232,
0.0321824774,
-0.0183301736,
-0.040693488,
0.0269900542,
0.0126082376,
0.0186293814,
-0.0242944211,
-0.0113841956,
0.0294714961,
-0.064620994,
-0.0230541695,
0.0179677699,
-0.0418592729,
-0.0086492859,
-0.0462952293,
0.0692406967,
0.007549176,
0.0189554226,
-0.0618612692,
-0.0874814764,
-0.0545664728,
0.0188961364,
-0.0374434069,
-0.030243082,
0.0280767232,
0.0330102369,
0.0120554436,
-0.0050268038,
-0.081592828,
0.005466098,
0.0012638053,
-0.020833632,
-0.0011030055,
-0.0134031614,
0.0505235344,
-0.0010833837,
0.0055184448,
0.0537958667,
-0.0082754334,
-0.0211483557,
0.0137337148,
0.0181818195,
-0.008328869,
-0.054911565,
0.0160709787,
0.0217172615,
0.0244325902,
0.0580876246,
0.0042712297,
-0.0441209637,
0.0356854014,
0.0011253625,
0.0589300543,
0.0210832562,
0.0777468085,
0.0159735996,
0.0103130471,
-0.0220453888,
0.0004605862,
-0.0194814224,
0.0303778518,
-0.0328224264,
0.022697147,
0.0233619958,
0.0223775785,
0.0299597047,
0.0207137968,
-0.0480619818,
-0.0610312894,
-0.0179563668,
-0.0255341027,
0.0263731852,
0.0445127748,
-0.0111260619,
0.0009393028,
0.0375074744,
-0.0108922515,
0.0632046536,
-0.0156358834,
-0.0789625347,
0.0017090368,
0.023193758,
-0.0199715383,
-0.0631595924,
0.0750986636,
-0.0258944407,
0.0021944295,
-0.0052268757,
-0.0093858,
-0.0376839824,
0.0341469683,
0.0353602208,
0.034960486,
-0.0329525471,
-0.0166320093,
0.0137244351,
-0.0412416048,
0.0225563664,
0.0302370712,
0.0205016881,
0.0154927494,
0.0637697577,
0.0910245553,
-0.0005747104,
-0.053358499,
-0.0023321679,
0.0276100766,
0.0020226168,
-0.0475657433,
-0.0851541311,
-5.651809532e-33,
-0.0247456562,
-0.0183339417,
0.0283331778,
0.0422882102,
0.0094029997,
-0.0327833481,
-0.0379252955,
-0.0235161278,
-0.0437544696,
-0.0505756624,
0.0251022298,
0.0270854905,
-0.0136361346,
0.0006947822,
0.0473879166,
0.0090960255,
0.059669178,
0.0559596568,
-0.0020280723,
0.0659772679,
-0.0323058851,
0.0477665178,
0.0359515324,
-0.0505766869,
-0.0419693775,
0.0022390217,
0.0713905767,
-0.0078728525,
0.0226865653,
0.0469273813,
-0.0034420323,
0.0051979166,
-0.0074218051,
-0.0155950859,
-0.0329212509,
-0.0297262017,
-0.0113295875,
-0.0536106862,
0.0012341625,
0.0052876142,
-0.0209266134,
-0.0499304123,
0.1320115924,
-0.0307431687,
0.0237631295,
0.0375119746,
0.0672958493,
0.0335130505,
-0.0026675037,
-0.0327491462,
-0.05626316,
0.0174915623,
-0.0413689055,
-0.0184640326,
-0.0270559415,
0.0476299301,
-0.0137083093,
0.0300847031,
-0.0090921083,
-0.0288450737,
-0.0114381723,
0.0724209845,
0.0501882471,
0.0052405787,
-0.0019341779,
0.0049761524,
0.0616986193,
-0.0231092684,
-0.0266322903,
0.0360710062,
0.0575037412,
0.036205925,
0.0426795669,
0.0019214947,
0.0215507839,
0.0054541654,
-0.0168989021,
0.0180479921,
-0.0063780202,
0.0527406037,
-0.0026239452,
0.0522418581,
-0.0286784563,
-0.0123518286,
-0.0301085655,
-0.0265454408,
-0.0304216053,
-0.0531530231,
0.0336634852,
-0.0081779379,
0.017020978,
0.0225303862,
0.0024054688,
-0.0089407954,
0.0441168733,
0.017261507,
-0.0285946596,
0.0319411568,
0.009133528,
0.021245582,
-0.0230944529,
0.0096217934,
0.0259088725,
-0.0363121778,
0.0742865279,
0.020266708,
0.0002202405,
0.0382302366,
-0.0208879914,
-0.0133975362,
-0.0581815131,
-0.0275166612,
-0.0347076915,
0.0110135032,
0.0041282582,
0.0170802046,
-0.0253369156,
0.0169900171,
-0.023045063,
-0.0219859742,
-0.0633947849,
-0.0291921645,
0.0301156566,
0.0028605685,
-0.0516553856,
-0.0457342453,
-0.0208655782,
0.0597802959,
0.041174829,
-0.0334260911,
-0.0516808815,
0.0241920874,
2.945e-7,
0.0016146,
0.016270915,
0.0184658486,
0.0466019586,
-0.0329583623,
0.0200164896,
0.0089352755,
0.031108981,
0.0310029164,
0.0131009603,
-0.0451163724,
-0.0233957898,
0.0009209703,
0.0270145722,
-0.0829016194,
0.0131933698,
0.0087452158,
0.0093739117,
-0.0646794662,
0.0061016916,
0.0406805016,
0.0758686811,
0.0210282188,
0.0107890442,
0.0355813727,
-0.033379402,
-0.017517861,
-0.0138559313,
0.045331534,
0.0413618796,
-0.0191745162,
0.0545938797,
-0.0116070872,
-0.0174701102,
0.0031400495,
-0.0158828199,
0.027722517,
0.0099721439,
-0.0219910797,
0.037647754,
0.0123489024,
-0.0092019159,
-0.0040794862,
-0.045567926,
0.0051076789,
-0.0533134416,
0.0063175112,
0.0141132791,
-0.0220347587,
0.0375353098,
-0.0130531583,
-0.0158081148,
0.0229245033,
-0.0253246762,
0.0086483099,
-0.0475965291,
-0.0428174101,
-0.0501403287,
-0.0129043991,
-0.0076865084,
-0.0125892339,
-0.0036859673,
-0.085741207,
0.0203666482,
0.0368902236,
0.005772606,
0.0202450491,
2.807174182e-34,
-0.0015807367,
-0.0297368634,
-0.0018876239,
0.0367024317,
0.0279948842,
-0.0036399853,
-0.0026998359,
0.0308375638,
0.0037313199,
-0.0433635786,
-0.0551500097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05827v1 | Is it Possible to Edit Large Language Models Robustly? | 2024-02-08T17:06:45 | 2024-02-08T17:06:45 | Xinbei Ma, Tianjie Ju, Jiyang Qiu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao, Lifeng Liu, Yulong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have played a pivotal role in building
communicative AI to imitate human behaviors but face the challenge of efficient
customization. To tackle this challenge, recent studies have delved into the
realm of model editing, which manipulates specific memories of language models
and changes the related language generation. However, the robustness of model
editing remains an open question. This work seeks to understand the strengths
and limitations of editing methods, thus facilitating robust, realistic
applications of communicative AI. Concretely, we conduct extensive analysis to
address the three key research questions. Q1: Can edited LLMs behave
consistently resembling communicative AI in realistic situations? Q2: To what
extent does the rephrasing of prompts lead LLMs to deviate from the edited
knowledge memory? Q3: Which knowledge features are correlated with the
performance and robustness of editing? Our experimental results uncover a
substantial disparity between existing editing methods and the practical
application of LLMs. On rephrased prompts that are complex and flexible but
common in realistic applications, the performance of editing experiences a
significant decline. Further analysis shows that more popular knowledge is
memorized better, easier to recall, and more challenging to edit effectively. | [
0.0892652571,
0.0136917094,
-0.0562808812,
0.0214987807,
-0.0367808789,
-0.0050612786,
-0.0152167464,
-0.0126943653,
-0.000332677,
-0.0342332944,
-0.0568811446,
-0.0313159153,
0.0212138556,
0.0311707743,
0.0305393804,
-0.0732560828,
0.0601373836,
-0.0457564257,
0.0058704079,
-0.009865569,
0.0055000801,
-0.0208298173,
0.0121977571,
0.0270624664,
-0.0173041634,
0.004377888,
-0.0482562818,
0.006271102,
-0.0055975262,
0.0195863452,
-0.0257111732,
0.0602730848,
0.0005914075,
0.0201384686,
0.0000020528,
-0.0542921945,
-0.0033264495,
-0.0347825922,
-0.0514953434,
0.0476870574,
0.0439376831,
-0.006648195,
-0.0446908437,
-0.0078919437,
-0.0340332538,
0.0403470136,
0.0715202317,
0.001902831,
0.062904425,
0.0770316944,
0.0016154979,
0.0207793936,
0.0208480041,
-0.0152525287,
-0.0101051768,
-0.0387309492,
0.0207641777,
0.0075233639,
0.0039295368,
0.0023014355,
-0.0228369031,
0.0562516116,
0.0244366508,
-0.0447950624,
-0.0134933004,
0.0042291442,
-0.0150168575,
-0.0178726371,
-0.0219553653,
0.0464983359,
0.0286166854,
-0.0254057311,
-0.0024808331,
0.0025441449,
0.039855659,
0.0146156903,
-0.0365458801,
0.0164851993,
0.0218010526,
-0.0139956214,
-0.0115038306,
-0.0456925407,
0.0237830523,
0.0071122777,
-0.0071180798,
0.0451747365,
0.0251878556,
-0.0379034802,
-0.028824985,
-0.0296093263,
-0.0050611738,
-0.0843985155,
0.004954163,
0.0450692959,
-0.0490549095,
0.044603318,
-0.0711675286,
0.0101966364,
0.0110985683,
-0.0279934555,
0.0691777915,
0.0384196267,
0.0067358762,
0.0276917331,
-0.0068345894,
0.0749617815,
0.0044755177,
0.0024594811,
-0.0131332437,
0.0090305312,
-0.0647369549,
-0.0389196537,
-0.0590800978,
0.0387023576,
-0.0106705343,
0.0137214921,
-0.0365433022,
0.0690104961,
-0.0034698416,
0.0346879289,
-0.0346718058,
-0.0060027419,
-0.0307468064,
-0.0276029911,
-0.0254450347,
-0.0049835015,
-0.0287897829,
0.0184525158,
0.0422362238,
-0.0649084821,
0.0032121479,
-0.0139518362,
-0.0079709971,
-0.0187449399,
-0.0175452139,
0.0560078844,
-0.027389016,
-0.0280990358,
-0.0325033069,
-0.0445441119,
-0.0168500394,
-0.0606758967,
-0.004702162,
-0.0320489071,
0.0580684543,
-0.0101859309,
-0.0339119732,
-0.0838733912,
-0.0076474026,
-0.0214012228,
-0.0419200547,
0.0515714549,
-0.0086440323,
0.0437890925,
0.0614451915,
0.01564488,
-0.0280401539,
0.0424220562,
0.0607403554,
0.0284531713,
0.0577059463,
-0.0004025007,
0.0333174057,
0.0477194414,
-0.0001086578,
0.0145301912,
-0.0212220158,
0.0041889558,
0.0018524793,
0.0259548426,
0.0127807492,
0.066329509,
-0.0220993739,
-0.0230952129,
0.1093850657,
0.0202877689,
-0.0245514885,
0.031010475,
0.0495150089,
-0.0095284097,
0.0403657071,
0.0339668021,
-0.0491665974,
0.0052927448,
-0.0379553027,
0.0311245471,
-0.0237399805,
-0.0111214304,
-0.033550445,
-0.0343907028,
-0.0003188408,
0.0128543442,
0.031072421,
0.0012184727,
0.003441764,
0.0327976421,
-0.020136226,
0.0403654687,
0.0189070087,
-0.0448788069,
-0.0166813228,
-0.0749793649,
0.0042891428,
0.0736339837,
0.03743672,
-0.0218674392,
-0.030021634,
0.0074184826,
-0.0056387899,
0.0380196273,
0.0923543945,
-0.0282518324,
-0.0058326568,
-0.0261291023,
0.0354043394,
-0.0315951258,
0.02835989,
0.0260893311,
0.032200478,
0.0004008515,
0.0119645158,
0.0121631697,
-0.0101005342,
-0.0017260553,
-0.0442965887,
-0.0117619755,
-0.0253933221,
0.0039506219,
-0.0041778903,
0.002918853,
-0.0301563907,
0.0021619375,
-0.0153940907,
0.0100075677,
-0.0021547088,
0.032895226,
-0.0524629205,
0.0195905399,
0.0338181518,
0.0272931177,
-0.0303418282,
0.0120881749,
-0.0053587379,
-0.0316837691,
0.0244844537,
-0.0691764578,
0.0582512952,
-0.0292629302,
0.0687888488,
-0.0179661456,
-0.0214080792,
-0.0127374148,
0.0267309994,
-0.011223346,
-0.0659789219,
0.0442110188,
0.0241064914,
-0.0288411826,
-0.0632314682,
-0.0206816848,
0.0356915444,
0.0067279804,
-0.0128814969,
0.0094564119,
-0.0197977219,
-0.0433432534,
-0.0685845241,
-0.0911105648,
-0.0287577529,
-0.0188587382,
-0.0254018437,
0.0336304866,
0.0150279002,
-0.0305650849,
0.0202828571,
-0.0354434066,
0.0109558394,
-0.0001729585,
0.0490944013,
0.030735597,
0.0270474982,
-0.0516828671,
-0.0618003607,
0.0183802675,
0.0161343701,
0.0287674312,
0.0028933524,
-0.0348973647,
-0.0649187267,
0.0548833236,
-0.0651132613,
0.0120092994,
-0.0092061125,
-0.043628417,
0.0092096822,
0.0139450589,
0.0974111855,
0.0666498095,
0.0145943193,
0.0421605855,
0.0640726388,
-0.0322781615,
-0.0295675863,
0.0113883857,
-0.011315708,
-0.0495691001,
-0.0293790083,
-0.0598645322,
0.0171277039,
0.0624374337,
0.0215760004,
0.0211016852,
-0.0455593951,
0.0515685678,
0.0184825528,
-0.08602608,
-0.0248404369,
-0.0470347442,
-0.0397542752,
0.0456974171,
-0.0270492658,
-0.0530940965,
0.074509263,
-0.0218634605,
0.0155868307,
0.0063425489,
-0.011801309,
0.0065621543,
0.0774872825,
-0.0158737879,
0.0351302251,
0.0102383737,
-0.0180307832,
-0.0707608238,
-0.0416772813,
0.0174580123,
-0.030777555,
0.0175748616,
-0.0938970149,
-0.0120912241,
0.0375474393,
-0.0405729599,
-0.046120178,
0.0133718355,
-0.0476225317,
0.029165769,
0.0316193737,
-0.0333414115,
-0.0074375211,
-0.0091652293,
0.0462920815,
0.0446745902,
-0.0001534699,
0.0059178383,
-0.0170817114,
-0.0220563486,
0.0735417008,
0.0375245139,
0.016406808,
-0.0389142781,
0.0478680879,
0.0267065577,
0.0169475153,
-0.0353937075,
-0.0046513174,
-0.01290261,
-0.0063130972,
-0.0541075394,
-0.0315554664,
0.0334589705,
0.0538485944,
-0.0349795595,
-0.0313379467,
0.0916845575,
0.042142164,
-0.0272342265,
0.0388521031,
-0.0493449979,
0.0340927616,
0.0277479142,
0.0371535346,
-0.0693338588,
-0.010221838,
0.0441749357,
-0.001392663,
-0.0463248678,
-0.0287244078,
-0.0335802808,
-0.1099014804,
0.0298609808,
0.0024961105,
-0.048107855,
-0.045045685,
-0.0005699874,
-0.0033963709,
0.0301183071,
0.0408499651,
0.0337305702,
0.0048934259,
-0.0168518052,
-0.0133795785,
-0.0248024706,
-0.0361608081,
-0.0000769195,
-0.0125872549,
0.0812597945,
0.0581972972,
0.005685519,
0.024202833,
-0.0242209509,
0.0327471457,
0.0627440289,
0.051569581,
-0.0032822185,
0.0100379083,
0.0148759857,
0.0095363175,
-0.0073397807,
0.018549256,
0.0295795463,
-0.0273587611,
0.0470735878,
0.058855854,
-0.0459029935,
0.003648272,
0.0181476045,
-0.000135987,
-0.0042533479,
0.0691111684,
0.069536984,
-0.0504054502,
-0.013764387,
-0.030991029,
-0.021772515,
-0.0118332244,
-0.0387771167,
-0.0037739424,
-0.0176958144,
0.0005869121,
-0.0930027291,
-0.0637939796,
0.0224108957,
-0.0075838468,
0.0550796241,
-0.0276371706,
0.0140314996,
-0.0040542586,
0.008236154,
-0.0138454838,
-0.0557467975,
-0.0057147141,
-0.0655166581,
-0.0358457118,
-0.001573006,
-0.0744313151,
0.0092186313,
-0.0000878508,
-0.0407424122,
-0.0899936706,
0.0392467044,
0.0572577603,
0.0347418152,
0.0432265475,
0.0238469038,
-0.0732392892,
-0.0136101702,
-0.0040193587,
-0.0151624046,
0.0723034665,
0.0237655938,
0.0084715113,
-0.0000263102,
0.0590539202,
-0.0398639962,
0.0050065038,
0.0374757759,
0.0385650881,
-0.0089641744,
-0.0662124604,
0.0246693175,
0.0463861264,
-0.0143141793,
0.0068148524,
-0.0106657688,
-0.0149507569,
0.0469214618,
-0.0403035954,
-0.0113169141,
-0.0216829441,
0.0063314415,
-0.0035429401,
0.0263619702,
0.0032122028,
-0.0393825993,
-0.0459612347,
0.0554008223,
0.0087656658,
-0.0203685258,
-0.0311399512,
0.009520256,
0.0384387448,
0.0402993746,
-0.0271939114,
0.0808565021,
-0.011346397,
0.032132294,
0.0286793634,
0.0754990131,
-0.0030712045,
-0.0521496609,
-0.0642341673,
0.0423752926,
-0.0740828738,
-0.0681770369,
0.0291793756,
0.0433649868,
0.0408763811,
0.0078761429,
0.0230606515,
-0.0825158507,
-0.0058154226,
-0.0229394678,
0.0123610534,
0.0509558655,
-0.0630942136,
0.0133502269,
0.0094714314,
-0.0177182704,
0.0267411843,
0.0389282294,
-0.0379358381,
0.0843386278,
-0.0253833663,
0.004355235,
-0.0376951844,
-0.0476087481,
0.010493313,
-0.0236790087,
-0.0435201675,
-0.0315154083,
-0.0830976442,
-0.0596112497,
0.0130753592,
0.0087050498,
0.0244122483,
-0.0320834443,
0.0369882993,
0.0473542772,
-0.0179744288,
0.0169445854,
-0.0234700833,
0.0263810027,
-0.0165001154,
-0.0032914726,
-0.0148081165,
-5.860675409e-33,
-0.0153522724,
0.0062809521,
0.0256368238,
-0.0161312874,
-0.0131471083,
-0.0163591467,
-0.0590203628,
0.040104568,
-0.0014409949,
-0.0080731614,
-0.0519184768,
-0.0086332737,
0.0148843909,
-0.0040023117,
0.0013643582,
0.0073599559,
0.0662205368,
0.021279024,
-0.0524655059,
0.011277427,
0.0210125986,
0.0105092144,
0.0209007338,
-0.0514505841,
0.0425532348,
0.0104078697,
-0.0247715898,
0.0107295513,
-0.027571464,
0.0519913808,
-0.0064119333,
0.0216963831,
0.0036877065,
-0.0228282455,
-0.037919309,
0.0142638218,
0.0017902736,
0.0051922817,
0.0555092767,
0.0151872495,
-0.0087205181,
-0.0711010993,
0.0075119226,
-0.0287541095,
-0.0502247736,
0.028278254,
-0.0100995554,
-0.0410417058,
0.0061337715,
0.0150549691,
-0.0753273517,
-0.0036513088,
0.0006196783,
-0.0264884494,
-0.0192053784,
0.0172007512,
-0.0102479542,
-0.0072671673,
-0.0353181846,
0.0453736261,
0.0584803186,
0.0177353919,
0.0608625412,
0.0075865979,
0.0100786369,
0.0503692515,
0.0546970405,
0.0667627826,
-0.013425353,
0.0057842466,
0.0022859441,
0.0178808905,
0.0271700639,
0.0658683479,
-0.0310999174,
-0.0278682914,
0.0132416943,
-0.0343005769,
-0.0205669198,
0.0127204806,
0.0153421676,
0.0163303223,
-0.0283095688,
-0.0010960586,
-0.0579906367,
0.0556008071,
-0.0325964428,
-0.0475281365,
0.0379026867,
0.0131283635,
-0.0098300064,
-0.033112485,
0.0163195226,
-0.0112415887,
-0.0046201642,
-0.0069461381,
-0.0309913326,
0.0520409048,
-0.0099760192,
-0.0127480719,
-0.0170757696,
0.0005107053,
0.020158086,
-0.0077407947,
-0.0007908465,
0.0321458876,
0.0217878688,
0.0496462211,
-0.03297076,
0.0193276629,
-0.0115620345,
0.0431020558,
0.0062607252,
-0.0499281436,
0.0084638018,
0.0003162465,
-0.03372081,
0.0177388601,
0.0283769071,
-0.0254709106,
-0.0445247442,
0.0168054681,
-0.0159062985,
0.0158825908,
-0.0538462251,
0.0035255114,
-0.0287214704,
0.0436064824,
0.0250879321,
-0.0255819894,
0.0038841469,
-0.0213480573,
2.853e-7,
-0.0039815754,
0.0539576188,
0.0241201743,
0.0163546186,
0.0328472108,
0.0300784204,
-0.0151536195,
0.014678522,
0.01707335,
-0.0218865462,
0.0118437614,
0.0269716904,
0.0406451598,
0.000567987,
-0.0660374314,
0.0007085797,
-0.0547225028,
-0.0014051849,
-0.0456374288,
-0.0043726768,
0.0327630378,
0.0593579113,
0.0236148238,
-0.0055989888,
-0.0181928445,
-0.0346145928,
0.0477883145,
-0.0653948709,
-0.0205671061,
0.0090761352,
0.0336387865,
-0.0031488193,
0.0062971618,
0.0191499181,
-0.0148689654,
-0.0161129944,
-0.0242423192,
0.0848631784,
-0.0075109354,
0.010895675,
0.0076987171,
-0.0064556631,
-0.0253072698,
-0.0440155268,
0.0428525321,
-0.0476253778,
-0.0060132872,
-0.0105992407,
0.0173607562,
0.0116899805,
-0.0032008477,
-0.0498645604,
0.0021270539,
0.0147398598,
-0.0052769617,
0.0472695194,
0.0189291295,
-0.0357443243,
-0.019886015,
-0.005847197,
-0.0201781355,
-0.0669587627,
-0.0606699325,
-0.024934195,
0.0208872575,
-0.0810471326,
0.0188250542,
2.266315685e-34,
0.0199850835,
0.0185644068,
0.0456668809,
0.0475387126,
0.0572994128,
-0.0033530197,
0.0304594673,
0.0389153734,
0.0421271808,
-0.0614307858,
-0.0442172028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05819v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05819v1 | Integrating Self-supervised Speech Model with Pseudo Word-level Targets from Visually-grounded Speech Model | 2024-02-08T16:55:21 | 2024-02-08T16:55:21 | Hung-Chieh Fang, Nai-Xuan Ye, Yi-Jen Shih, Puyuan Peng, Hsuan-Fu Wang, Layne Berry, Hung-yi Lee, David Harwath | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in self-supervised speech models have shown significant
improvement in many downstream tasks. However, these models predominantly
centered on frame-level training objectives, which can fall short in spoken
language understanding tasks that require semantic comprehension. Existing
works often rely on additional speech-text data as intermediate targets, which
is costly in the real-world setting. To address this challenge, we propose
Pseudo-Word HuBERT (PW-HuBERT), a framework that integrates pseudo word-level
targets into the training process, where the targets are derived from a
visually-ground speech model, notably eliminating the need for speech-text
paired data. Our experimental results on four spoken language understanding
(SLU) benchmarks suggest the superiority of our model in capturing semantic
information. | [
0.0217025392,
0.0464618653,
0.036104437,
0.0415018909,
0.0050736517,
-0.0100053977,
0.0320030227,
-0.0314046219,
-0.0457210578,
-0.0493414253,
-0.0775606781,
0.0005693117,
0.024208406,
0.0264206473,
0.0273643974,
-0.0472260863,
0.0420440286,
-0.0676204488,
-0.0511604175,
0.0006955538,
0.0148362322,
0.0255865399,
-0.0390741378,
0.0032423639,
-0.031474743,
-0.0394194461,
-0.0225051679,
0.0510595664,
-0.018249901,
-0.0030410851,
-0.0580202676,
0.0408292152,
0.074542731,
0.0313908011,
0.0000016186,
-0.025341507,
-0.0031113364,
-0.0037404636,
-0.07521981,
0.0254387725,
0.0244285408,
-0.0546137802,
0.0096875867,
0.0288562495,
0.000152042,
-0.0581202023,
-0.0011934855,
0.0763880312,
0.0593984574,
0.0226390082,
0.0023249488,
-0.0170317814,
0.0104144718,
-0.0426205285,
-0.0054142321,
-0.0657186732,
-0.0024584511,
0.0308986232,
-0.0232516099,
-0.0107953241,
-0.0330079943,
0.06176465,
-0.0095709004,
-0.017397631,
0.0048163827,
0.033242885,
-0.0254953206,
-0.0321859419,
-0.0308746267,
0.0764967054,
0.0284372885,
-0.0086107925,
0.0099551799,
0.0056220023,
-0.0183386952,
0.0241352879,
-0.025520904,
-0.0218651332,
0.0159869064,
-0.0076871263,
-0.0045361547,
0.0445736907,
0.0280705076,
0.01014667,
-0.0234692357,
0.0327008292,
-0.0145192519,
-0.0112893702,
0.0291559491,
-0.0301979724,
-0.0179929491,
-0.0156696327,
-0.0079985345,
0.0086860415,
0.0028595545,
0.0336619839,
-0.0480774753,
0.017209677,
-0.0206432752,
-0.0367247835,
0.04667468,
0.0598660633,
-0.0593366101,
0.0548397601,
0.0092301313,
0.0564378463,
-0.0145540787,
0.0163078383,
-0.0455349386,
-0.0023776209,
-0.0423023142,
0.0004115329,
-0.0866550729,
0.0251907725,
-0.0783562064,
-0.0409756303,
0.0118706245,
0.0010430962,
0.0014273047,
-0.0131522054,
0.0378861688,
0.0097817164,
-0.0760639682,
-0.0095974226,
-0.0039835344,
0.0355134048,
0.0010923852,
0.0112587307,
-0.0311897695,
-0.0195209291,
-0.022991797,
0.0154417055,
0.0379242338,
-0.022805484,
-0.0046012765,
0.0813064054,
-0.0020947475,
-0.0370985046,
-0.0108301202,
0.009335245,
-0.0102710957,
-0.0338711403,
-0.0199621823,
-0.0095016882,
0.0125157349,
-0.0391325839,
0.0006707492,
-0.0238931626,
0.0108927432,
-0.011541429,
0.0139451949,
0.110558711,
-0.0095031569,
0.0105618481,
0.0275879521,
0.0188648179,
0.0035823211,
0.0840986669,
-0.0040982286,
0.0196673535,
0.0235612504,
-0.0145028373,
-0.0075543798,
0.0393305346,
0.0336424708,
-0.0212483164,
-0.0518379994,
0.0157539248,
0.0043253056,
0.0416939445,
0.0765416175,
0.0437176935,
-0.0358207002,
-0.0434187762,
0.0657031611,
0.0593592301,
0.0263015628,
0.0051541906,
0.0331437513,
0.0488229468,
-0.0158432722,
0.0165904295,
-0.0380528271,
-0.0160456654,
-0.0447992496,
0.0233255345,
-0.0234983657,
-0.0186564699,
-0.060643781,
-0.0449269079,
-0.0273756925,
-0.0090943342,
-0.0042092325,
0.0269557908,
0.0559556335,
0.0493817702,
-0.0547396727,
0.0282327291,
0.0165398885,
-0.0396861546,
0.036370948,
-0.0112479236,
0.0238214061,
0.0624810681,
0.0314081311,
-0.011998021,
-0.0090381838,
-0.0200024284,
0.0103727793,
0.0588649847,
-0.0042995764,
-0.0188196804,
0.0507756732,
-0.0479211733,
-0.0285431761,
-0.0006565224,
-0.0217412598,
0.0040535587,
-0.0374833569,
-0.0183648914,
-0.0164633244,
-0.068274349,
0.019576095,
0.0399573855,
-0.0155980727,
-0.0106223561,
-0.035277959,
0.0270750392,
0.0107952207,
0.0184653196,
-0.0184046011,
-0.02551567,
0.0269168802,
-0.0261933152,
0.0258425288,
0.0177262723,
-0.0568414517,
-0.0670928732,
0.0191968624,
-0.0216701031,
0.0020850478,
0.0590079837,
-0.0088932784,
-0.0515644588,
0.0206795502,
-0.0086035952,
0.0483705737,
-0.0881213546,
0.0131432833,
0.0423648767,
0.035084065,
-0.0193710364,
0.014919254,
-0.0053563695,
-0.0152479606,
0.0085227052,
0.0468382351,
0.0186779592,
-0.0377211124,
0.0010203868,
0.0382291414,
-0.0210678913,
0.0164361931,
-0.0459133387,
-0.0024491295,
-0.0473522432,
0.0054522171,
-0.0856858566,
-0.018566601,
-0.0280949771,
-0.0166678783,
0.0421852246,
-0.0009988298,
-0.0215602834,
-0.0376724042,
0.0111628696,
-0.0136038931,
-0.0260668807,
-0.0486876145,
-0.0048662541,
0.0147201763,
0.0011523152,
-0.0509692207,
0.0119742891,
0.0327868238,
0.0415406302,
-0.0041685537,
-0.0231782179,
-0.0377934501,
0.0231169648,
-0.0178948455,
0.0509460568,
-0.0165199693,
-0.0257691406,
-0.0348114483,
0.0038865602,
0.0145912198,
0.0273041222,
0.0040147002,
0.0536979809,
-0.0092376387,
-0.0368795954,
-0.0427123494,
0.0135922488,
0.0093071209,
0.0164912343,
-0.0138854133,
0.0281398669,
-0.0422760397,
0.0668321401,
0.0298543405,
0.0267305691,
-0.044415161,
-0.0254693013,
-0.0193105061,
-0.0500516705,
-0.0674837977,
0.0050631706,
-0.0016503501,
-0.0024388384,
-0.0512522869,
-0.0282324012,
0.0549279936,
-0.1180543527,
-0.0358098783,
-0.0255280957,
-0.0448722653,
-0.0209147781,
0.0567535274,
-0.016234668,
0.0041224998,
-0.0329291858,
-0.0395354033,
-0.0435615964,
-0.0321017131,
0.0015990053,
-0.0201876294,
0.0748598352,
-0.0310583413,
0.036515642,
-0.0157008003,
0.0122307353,
-0.0662264898,
-0.0627499521,
-0.0608868524,
-0.024924757,
-0.0647208616,
-0.0116922809,
-0.0093232524,
0.0553486794,
-0.0073788241,
0.0766417682,
0.0082246391,
0.0128281135,
-0.0310755521,
0.0512657128,
0.0363711752,
0.0358143635,
-0.0332478508,
0.027754711,
0.0660188049,
0.0253646635,
0.0598948859,
-0.0161580592,
-0.0453502126,
0.0253493395,
0.0200449694,
0.0092508486,
-0.0187040884,
0.0034324585,
0.0232379604,
-0.0570901483,
-0.0227356162,
0.1083678082,
0.0096600186,
0.0345676392,
-0.0124204615,
-0.0035878967,
0.0339746699,
0.0515692532,
0.0221678019,
-0.0139320577,
-0.0635065883,
0.0294561032,
0.0067374478,
0.0458577201,
0.0349811874,
-0.0288487207,
-0.07694076,
0.0422536246,
0.0063104709,
-0.029571088,
-0.018964665,
-0.0094611496,
0.0149869863,
-0.0089655779,
0.025681166,
0.0132230269,
-0.0249898769,
-0.0208665095,
0.0348917991,
-0.0369950719,
-0.0181296803,
0.0319517702,
-0.0226679146,
0.0469078049,
0.0416372083,
0.0267755408,
-0.0108072627,
-0.0275641959,
0.0383788086,
-0.0461025722,
0.018907316,
-0.0313746482,
0.0549274944,
-0.0420907885,
-0.0123460284,
0.0281986613,
0.0539899431,
-0.0298258997,
-0.0125565408,
-0.0191713292,
0.0427983999,
-0.0169630554,
0.0251437258,
-0.0065035229,
0.0551630259,
-0.003710568,
0.0841175914,
0.0454692915,
-0.0209224522,
-0.0128861992,
0.0096868267,
0.01891388,
-0.0029197985,
-0.0328250267,
0.0169588272,
0.0102081224,
-0.0320236459,
-0.0347043537,
-0.0474324673,
0.0344802439,
0.0865592435,
-0.0075600147,
0.0211310238,
-0.0041526398,
0.0199882612,
-0.0609250143,
0.083300598,
-0.0149402516,
0.0144264167,
-0.0385435298,
-0.0279223435,
0.0804906562,
-0.0652477145,
-0.0239728559,
0.0258420669,
-0.0335162766,
-0.0248570424,
0.0023476125,
0.0157286432,
0.0256666876,
0.0967859626,
-0.0201793704,
-0.0289728288,
0.0550771393,
0.0009013852,
-0.0254246686,
0.0290318672,
0.0602078438,
0.0003677815,
-0.0181974843,
0.0259134118,
-0.0115946438,
0.0372230262,
-0.0209356714,
0.0204503573,
-0.0050984127,
0.0351229422,
0.0128742876,
-0.0091404524,
0.0887156203,
-0.0011535947,
0.0031924164,
-0.0659833923,
0.0421879254,
0.0002400954,
0.0169454385,
-0.0561236851,
-0.0049104551,
0.0009830856,
-0.0297904033,
-0.0136634782,
-0.048837848,
-0.0677374005,
0.0108734677,
-0.0064536086,
0.0031711271,
-0.025047306,
0.0149690295,
-0.0407587364,
0.0146910083,
0.0085901432,
0.0327653773,
0.0262368433,
0.0376763344,
0.0098104775,
0.0522360764,
-0.0096656093,
0.0077223182,
0.0025890791,
0.014171253,
-0.0329999663,
-0.0034277614,
-0.0458679497,
0.0304187983,
0.0006537415,
-0.0150808031,
-0.0192906745,
0.0343797281,
-0.000882154,
0.0058583077,
0.0166446064,
-0.0476893783,
-0.0286774002,
0.0670653433,
0.0177326072,
-0.0125556476,
0.0000212435,
0.0256978534,
0.0500436462,
0.0175356232,
0.0003382398,
0.0592073053,
-0.0528908111,
-0.0281586628,
0.0128693189,
0.0182589982,
-0.0271309987,
0.0152493427,
-0.0351892449,
-0.0892621353,
0.0582711287,
0.0245945454,
-0.0265211966,
0.0041423012,
0.0307948142,
0.0063199135,
-0.0238232762,
0.0183402039,
0.0009978404,
-0.0057626804,
0.0147752995,
0.0211254135,
0.0528040454,
-5.960567817e-33,
-0.0842167363,
0.002184811,
0.012496111,
0.0076165413,
-0.0284805857,
0.0368055627,
-0.0149473231,
0.0063897423,
0.0329043828,
-0.0017897137,
-0.0149539672,
0.035464298,
0.0245694574,
0.0535794124,
-0.0755454823,
-0.033904776,
0.0797607526,
-0.0157815609,
-0.0044727833,
-0.015518357,
-0.002471871,
0.063096337,
0.0502709337,
-0.0502936095,
-0.0417156778,
0.0003876358,
0.0144949453,
0.0227764491,
0.0344913565,
0.0561212525,
-0.0346804671,
0.0243066587,
-0.0205083881,
0.0071343603,
-0.043425858,
0.0400844514,
-0.1248258874,
-0.0040585394,
0.0520349666,
0.0497661941,
-0.0521902479,
0.0581473708,
0.016092455,
-0.0085921688,
0.000069787,
-0.0277491547,
0.012663682,
-0.0241442062,
-0.0456668846,
0.0324701779,
-0.0080933394,
0.0147414077,
-0.0066045979,
-0.013923442,
0.0763748884,
0.0159924682,
0.0303334892,
-0.0079242736,
-0.0614412576,
-0.0104561392,
-0.0298785158,
0.0202607401,
0.0900395289,
0.0540796556,
-0.0046480699,
0.0560484268,
0.0517238639,
-0.0841348693,
0.0102568874,
-0.0494029112,
0.0506514162,
0.032712236,
-0.0070657199,
0.0121921832,
0.0181928985,
-0.0107742557,
-0.0151098762,
0.0209286492,
-0.0254126228,
0.0054173185,
-0.0048891567,
0.0291862395,
-0.0371277742,
0.0099949613,
-0.0780256912,
-0.0442648456,
-0.0299328845,
0.0131907612,
0.0602135807,
0.0315609835,
-0.035578344,
0.0466803983,
0.0577010699,
-0.0332245529,
0.0021649092,
0.0303831827,
0.0070954906,
0.0058098086,
-0.0260011852,
0.0767341331,
-0.0399802774,
-0.0250012409,
0.0357166789,
0.0412171595,
0.0055280258,
-0.0477304421,
-0.0116269756,
0.0134308357,
-0.045909673,
-0.0212497525,
-0.0352712534,
0.0178933945,
-0.0652951151,
-0.019904349,
0.0468969308,
0.0041615693,
-0.0410624668,
0.0631988794,
-0.0166258533,
-0.0586245321,
-0.032656353,
0.0153209995,
-0.0076209507,
0.0373153314,
-0.0156492647,
-0.0123773227,
0.0251072925,
-0.0703541562,
0.057343021,
-0.0721994191,
0.0133821843,
0.0316326804,
2.41e-7,
0.0040586963,
0.0023076306,
0.0382665209,
-0.0185837075,
0.0003839978,
0.0160519667,
-0.0270874649,
0.0015324276,
-0.0111867534,
-0.0759716779,
0.0360146239,
0.0489637032,
0.0360454582,
-0.0112240203,
-0.0381007008,
0.0334930383,
-0.0135142701,
0.0086341435,
-0.0395777747,
-0.0177036673,
-0.0184160136,
0.101396881,
-0.0186303388,
-0.025757065,
0.0257738028,
-0.0111586535,
0.0494471677,
-0.014619776,
-0.0069060884,
-0.0191109516,
0.0049911276,
0.0209860709,
-0.0086447215,
0.0391199216,
-0.0002219777,
0.0482372977,
0.0591609627,
0.0366589911,
-0.0286497623,
-0.0351445526,
-0.0478661247,
0.0254717078,
-0.0169999264,
0.0208289754,
0.0543350503,
-0.0476916283,
-0.0051556244,
-0.0197418518,
-0.0242921226,
-0.0017893678,
0.0119446088,
0.0110916169,
0.0064366674,
0.0584917665,
0.0399898626,
-0.0439119749,
-0.0311499722,
-0.092271477,
-0.0016508098,
-0.0195078701,
-0.0633595809,
0.0250336956,
-0.0349650234,
-0.0050068344,
0.0185108948,
-0.026505148,
-0.0465418883,
1.723522559e-34,
0.0398484692,
0.0075585023,
-0.0263825525,
-0.0148694851,
0.0023848277,
-0.0252747536,
0.0107442075,
-0.0158683769,
0.0505747758,
-0.0581752919,
-0.0076147993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05813v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05813v1 | Selective Forgetting: Advancing Machine Unlearning Techniques and Evaluation in Language Models | 2024-02-08T16:50:01 | 2024-02-08T16:50:01 | Lingzhi Wang, Xingshan Zeng, Jinsong Guo, Kam-Fai Wong, Georg Gottlob | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The aim of this study is to investigate Machine Unlearning (MU), a burgeoning
field focused on addressing concerns related to neural models inadvertently
retaining personal or sensitive data. Here, a novel approach is introduced to
achieve precise and selective forgetting within language models. Unlike
previous methodologies that adopt completely opposing training objectives, this
approach aims to mitigate adverse effects on language model performance,
particularly in generation tasks. Furthermore, two innovative evaluation
metrics are proposed: Sensitive Information Extraction Likelihood (S-EL) and
Sensitive Information Memory Accuracy (S-MA), designed to gauge the
effectiveness of sensitive information elimination. To reinforce the forgetting
framework, an effective method for annotating sensitive scopes is presented,
involving both online and offline strategies. The online selection mechanism
leverages language probability scores to ensure computational efficiency, while
the offline annotation entails a robust two-stage process based on Large
Language Models (LLMs). | [
0.0202629808,
0.0947857797,
-0.0235413834,
0.0176703744,
-0.0451969914,
0.0307924133,
0.0441532806,
-0.0201589186,
-0.0250598118,
-0.0358278602,
-0.0468711704,
-0.0580964535,
-0.0022575243,
0.0106575564,
0.0263060816,
0.0083013242,
0.0420861244,
-0.021744987,
0.0234801583,
0.0015779787,
-0.0173937231,
0.0126292398,
0.0093086753,
0.0157651864,
0.0004029184,
-0.0334567018,
0.0028410044,
0.0006685597,
0.0018477204,
-0.0040199561,
0.0183156822,
0.0449212044,
-0.0059437747,
0.0437680595,
0.0000023439,
-0.0481658094,
-0.0638271794,
-0.0019127517,
-0.0333052017,
0.037584383,
0.0354736373,
-0.0122524342,
0.0026392292,
0.006960433,
-0.0178974345,
-0.0144232884,
0.0690336302,
-0.0033991917,
0.0191513784,
0.0708313659,
0.0058851335,
0.012748831,
0.0123650534,
-0.0423788391,
0.0163141191,
-0.0242200755,
0.0433970653,
-0.0525421686,
-0.0911444947,
-0.0301981177,
0.0003104488,
0.0649981201,
0.0114486385,
0.009139332,
0.0039048472,
0.0476632304,
-0.0155538293,
-0.0507901236,
-0.0015275571,
0.0309914444,
-0.0144156199,
0.0061910083,
0.038031064,
-0.0294322241,
-0.0201489758,
-0.0153936651,
-0.0459001549,
0.0377632901,
-0.0006600861,
0.0136955716,
-0.007928865,
-0.0404995568,
0.0492575839,
0.0325844809,
0.0173986293,
0.0215438586,
0.0339179188,
-0.0071445028,
0.0066557475,
-0.0284799859,
-0.0261276364,
-0.0468599238,
0.0525781289,
0.0369813554,
0.0216888953,
0.0431125723,
-0.0170374997,
-0.0159076136,
0.0298354793,
-0.0517541915,
0.0632874593,
0.0007516683,
0.009527375,
0.0142731536,
-0.0357653908,
0.0610499084,
0.031597171,
0.0161551088,
-0.0207928922,
0.0241686348,
-0.0174412839,
-0.0314858109,
0.0219347682,
0.0518355109,
0.004547176,
0.0257649738,
-0.0279635582,
-0.0017741661,
-0.0353322588,
-0.0023557891,
-0.0135925263,
0.0244024768,
-0.0788156837,
-0.0034478167,
-0.0259467587,
0.0122628594,
0.0004367965,
0.0091281785,
0.0444461145,
-0.0730106533,
-0.0127784275,
-0.0137570668,
0.0240045935,
-0.0261139236,
0.0165098906,
0.0714442879,
-0.0110371504,
-0.0480848663,
-0.04144153,
-0.0438197479,
-0.0116670923,
-0.081809476,
0.0463732816,
-0.0314679556,
0.0302537885,
-0.0400913693,
-0.0255835932,
-0.0983484089,
0.0171406753,
0.0428664163,
-0.0260009225,
0.0068670767,
0.0044092778,
-0.0197488517,
0.0473000109,
0.0294645578,
0.0037322962,
0.0517713986,
-0.0035152195,
0.0603267923,
0.0271377061,
-0.012322423,
0.0447623134,
0.0248335693,
0.0283734743,
-0.0279606432,
-0.0486008003,
-0.0405373834,
0.0375702307,
-0.0203246698,
0.050927788,
0.0667029992,
-0.0409088545,
-0.0176832546,
0.0858947262,
-0.0112417806,
-0.0002286347,
0.0311938263,
0.0141562046,
-0.0115265064,
0.0025373227,
0.0288251285,
-0.0546329096,
-0.0039265295,
-0.0463573448,
0.018366009,
-0.0060445662,
0.0280796308,
-0.02490215,
-0.040937636,
0.009584561,
-0.0499344915,
0.0414250493,
0.0119485548,
0.0608355738,
0.0398173481,
-0.0355001315,
0.0847791061,
0.0376645364,
-0.0561950952,
0.0474032238,
-0.0423247106,
0.0268375576,
0.0397372097,
0.0559700467,
-0.0306986552,
-0.0393060446,
-0.0094176084,
-0.0362826698,
0.0055639781,
0.0094140144,
-0.0097751766,
0.0758436918,
-0.0753365234,
-0.0114526926,
0.007681103,
0.0338655934,
0.0124429464,
0.0346975327,
-0.0435814634,
0.0560568981,
-0.0419535376,
-0.0382782742,
0.0466824695,
-0.0617826767,
-0.0688985959,
0.0134374956,
-0.0096398788,
0.0087026795,
0.0126851108,
0.0059301439,
0.0180254038,
0.0577648282,
-0.0108532906,
0.0102495095,
-0.0611386411,
-0.082096085,
0.013539454,
0.0120478831,
0.0209053587,
0.0351495855,
0.0303086042,
-0.0129259406,
-0.0110846665,
0.0045413249,
-0.0219291635,
0.021111697,
-0.0593619384,
0.0303161107,
-0.016604865,
-0.002675978,
-0.0348692425,
0.0850458592,
-0.050019376,
0.0089516779,
-0.0016977279,
-0.0276110265,
-0.0426509827,
-0.0659637973,
-0.0414372161,
0.0067774914,
-0.0159986299,
0.0179733466,
0.03145051,
-0.0036148098,
-0.0496343859,
-0.0363044515,
-0.0626508966,
0.0056611612,
-0.0070468984,
0.0106785335,
0.0022422699,
-0.012615894,
-0.0050812559,
-0.0060448796,
-0.006163863,
0.0078155352,
-0.0347198844,
0.0444805287,
0.0105586899,
0.0150458543,
-0.0094859898,
-0.0267422479,
-0.0207743961,
0.0136437435,
0.0583195537,
-0.0211810339,
-0.0084974868,
-0.0089798989,
0.0543486774,
-0.0879860818,
0.009177966,
0.0025229717,
-0.0143876662,
-0.0059133708,
-0.0105714919,
0.0175885241,
0.0555979051,
-0.0021485256,
0.0449209586,
0.0778683349,
-0.0359453522,
-0.0195816979,
-0.0049277819,
-0.057254713,
-0.0364337228,
0.028518809,
-0.0144480746,
-0.020022301,
0.013260969,
0.0226983801,
0.0091411229,
-0.0018958218,
0.0462490022,
-0.034758836,
-0.0457876995,
-0.0167358425,
-0.0153521206,
-0.0487249419,
0.0424932726,
-0.0267303176,
-0.0788997337,
0.0430828817,
-0.0009322827,
0.0397337154,
-0.0213611629,
0.007894733,
0.0338998102,
0.0662821531,
0.0123505844,
0.0494373143,
0.059236493,
-0.0487379991,
-0.0462156534,
-0.0217648502,
0.0143386489,
-0.0637280867,
-0.0149156079,
-0.0704666674,
-0.0343916081,
0.0196115989,
-0.0123108765,
-0.0520293824,
-0.0180769023,
0.0330068357,
0.011690164,
-0.0256222263,
0.0054867007,
-0.0125469714,
-0.0307790823,
0.0198627822,
0.0250745751,
0.0021594418,
0.0181354359,
-0.0106230723,
0.0457159653,
0.0405616909,
-0.0209815484,
0.012730673,
-0.0370181687,
-0.0034859807,
0.0714937374,
0.0312674083,
0.033086434,
0.0299554747,
0.010957011,
0.0042691198,
-0.0239618216,
-0.0244936161,
0.0469556823,
0.0318266228,
-0.0795715153,
-0.0632071942,
0.1032893732,
0.0174027514,
-0.0423606858,
-0.0115259122,
0.0515784025,
0.0214899257,
-0.006571468,
-0.0064787511,
-0.0614368245,
0.0086830035,
0.0238237362,
0.0396436974,
-0.0353382193,
-0.0338503495,
-0.0286013894,
-0.1085512266,
-0.0030148081,
0.0268904231,
-0.0542916618,
-0.0412564836,
-0.0343512408,
-0.0104738241,
0.0044164606,
0.0651800632,
0.0241249464,
-0.0013089434,
-0.0127321109,
0.0244605299,
-0.0337166823,
-0.0824541971,
0.0106358351,
-0.0289217811,
0.0473033302,
0.0517065264,
0.0413192697,
-0.0024536413,
-0.0331404619,
0.0568736978,
-0.0121829221,
0.0230077039,
-0.0179568455,
0.0606655441,
0.0013537621,
0.0078340154,
-0.0198394787,
0.0385139398,
0.0210377742,
-0.038917616,
-0.0185694452,
0.0308270175,
-0.0123672457,
-0.0078689316,
0.0412692837,
-0.0193206929,
-0.0048019267,
0.0703986436,
0.0407891646,
-0.0432063155,
-0.0092195552,
-0.0114372047,
0.037961185,
-0.0071133072,
0.0432726257,
0.0043143556,
-0.0162663385,
-0.0493745953,
-0.0812097862,
-0.0295743216,
0.0146913845,
0.0179689229,
0.0178116336,
0.0048311548,
0.0228076167,
0.0024472056,
-0.0473333821,
0.0137424404,
-0.0446939096,
-0.0450342894,
-0.007250899,
0.0053629563,
-0.0132309766,
-0.0257292613,
-0.0164865851,
0.0463198349,
-0.107301712,
-0.0761742443,
0.0551967844,
0.0512419343,
0.0268739853,
0.0358454622,
0.0175031237,
-0.0666180626,
0.0664610565,
0.034803763,
-0.0260048043,
0.009367859,
0.0338329859,
-0.0126878303,
-0.0228531044,
0.0355929732,
-0.0207807776,
0.0002415169,
0.0634635463,
0.0383108817,
0.019191524,
0.0010533368,
0.0177494902,
0.0138852224,
0.0360780694,
-0.006777266,
-0.0583729967,
-0.0608714409,
-0.0064973426,
-0.0099891173,
-0.0170886144,
0.0029508905,
-0.0084659001,
0.0482420661,
0.0451375991,
-0.0161350835,
-0.0387053341,
0.015685387,
0.0355696045,
-0.0201846771,
-0.0456173159,
0.0382692106,
0.0235627294,
-0.0011869448,
0.0128327589,
-0.04613363,
0.0476970971,
-0.0370105579,
0.0308971405,
-0.0411935002,
0.0676566437,
-0.0087201782,
0.0091270721,
-0.0466817766,
0.0024908879,
-0.0100222146,
-0.0272285584,
-0.0708645806,
0.007198724,
0.0231254343,
-0.0154189123,
0.0308734439,
-0.01507439,
-0.014382571,
-0.0423904583,
0.0116963917,
0.0310780089,
-0.0358677879,
-0.0119314706,
-0.0029261329,
-0.0247257687,
0.0355264321,
0.0664509013,
-0.0077106776,
0.0396176167,
-0.0342991203,
0.0074008955,
-0.0331505165,
-0.0103103397,
-0.0111564258,
0.0400405526,
-0.0332670547,
-0.0269257464,
-0.0374353975,
-0.0663517267,
0.011421808,
-0.0072626863,
0.0197026972,
-0.0057618329,
0.0434525348,
0.0415076166,
-0.0482706726,
0.0057759513,
-0.0683938041,
-0.0040827431,
0.0234969314,
0.013855367,
-0.0348223858,
-7.306415911e-33,
-0.0043378486,
-0.0267386734,
0.0040894132,
0.0208750665,
-0.0209127963,
0.0344698206,
-0.0286780801,
-0.0047537722,
0.0105236629,
-0.033420343,
-0.0089112967,
-0.0154098943,
0.0080190515,
0.0291939657,
-0.0092709782,
-0.004888271,
0.0418590903,
-0.0117498348,
-0.0324682593,
0.0534550734,
0.0688923001,
0.0606084242,
0.0587089621,
-0.0663972721,
0.0435565598,
0.0097582173,
-0.0520113558,
0.0095679527,
-0.0074965097,
0.0444215015,
-0.050825119,
0.007617529,
0.0106501449,
-0.0268074889,
-0.0181240495,
0.013289527,
-0.0783654004,
-0.0075458488,
-0.0181968492,
-0.0365682505,
0.0148980627,
-0.0721929297,
0.0454816222,
-0.0286330283,
-0.0034628296,
-0.027542362,
-0.0053716218,
-0.0138725294,
-0.0626652911,
-0.0393402204,
-0.0461904742,
-0.0006738743,
0.0177187566,
-0.0052789287,
0.0257627778,
0.0020749324,
-0.0284120422,
-0.0253694989,
-0.0794527158,
-0.0115955072,
0.028513059,
0.03305576,
0.0626614317,
0.0504568256,
-0.0048244605,
0.102033779,
0.0732770935,
0.0155833028,
0.0357065462,
-0.006292663,
0.0687495843,
0.0103995558,
0.0285644121,
0.0035407359,
0.0459229834,
-0.04431656,
-0.0677711666,
0.0036302789,
-0.0096063986,
0.0346815139,
0.0716721043,
0.0210578479,
-0.0118646435,
-0.025256671,
-0.0576523319,
-0.0150229931,
-0.0504548065,
0.0012343122,
0.0345943123,
0.0228202511,
-0.0654322878,
0.0008389859,
0.0053775436,
-0.001900573,
0.0077053793,
0.028478289,
0.0211960245,
0.0079725133,
-0.0196009539,
0.0007186609,
-0.0515675098,
-0.037091203,
0.0205560755,
-0.0122791389,
0.0126118092,
-0.0015128145,
0.0327249058,
0.0464675948,
-0.053022258,
0.004658353,
-0.0626694858,
0.0228310563,
0.0446846224,
0.034842182,
0.0501362719,
0.0055347621,
-0.0206645336,
0.0126897423,
0.0614788905,
0.0382345915,
-0.0489146821,
0.0128899347,
0.0169289839,
0.0085870316,
-0.0134391962,
-0.012147285,
0.028629018,
0.0103856223,
0.052847743,
-0.0152620599,
0.0228854567,
0.0090643186,
3.008e-7,
0.0293830521,
0.0261384156,
0.0217416584,
-0.0235706829,
0.024956163,
0.0171668828,
-0.0052365167,
0.00452124,
0.0206400976,
0.0408872254,
0.0173373725,
0.0064624297,
0.0735986531,
0.0260143597,
-0.0634215176,
0.0081633506,
-0.0375489667,
-0.0110783074,
-0.0463846363,
-0.0140565708,
-0.0066071399,
0.0864219368,
0.0144421384,
-0.0307331961,
-0.003501771,
-0.0325316526,
0.0552688241,
-0.0614753142,
-0.0165305473,
-0.0062297336,
0.0486282483,
0.0769575462,
0.0052993614,
-0.0032290134,
-0.0294058286,
-0.020237254,
0.0168314707,
0.0848523155,
0.026858123,
-0.0640679747,
0.0198510364,
0.0298571121,
0.0031488712,
-0.0419850014,
0.0633156821,
-0.0335095115,
-0.0172335729,
0.0026035111,
-0.0073158634,
0.0080139721,
0.0363231301,
-0.0272536706,
-0.0403597169,
0.0432446711,
-0.0258503053,
0.0446632318,
-0.0230701379,
-0.0549827628,
-0.0276862886,
0.0051187873,
-0.0478010476,
-0.0627295896,
-0.0060366127,
-0.0205116365,
-0.0242783651,
-0.0977582484,
0.0509909913,
2.837654613e-34,
-0.0137491366,
-0.0367951058,
-0.0209785551,
0.0334745049,
0.0288217999,
0.0115621202,
-0.0076059354,
0.0296456255,
-0.0192607511,
-0.0666873306,
-0.0145783117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05812v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05812v3 | FAQ-Gen: An automated system to generate domain-specific FAQs to aid content comprehension | 2024-02-08T16:49:41 | 2024-05-09T10:29:16 | Sahil Kale, Gautam Khaire, Jay Patankar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) refer to the most common inquiries about
specific content. They serve as content comprehension aids by simplifying
topics and enhancing understanding through succinct presentation of
information. In this paper, we address FAQ generation as a well-defined Natural
Language Processing task through the development of an end-to-end system
leveraging text-to-text transformation models. We present a literature review
covering traditional question-answering systems, highlighting their limitations
when applied directly to the FAQ generation task. We propose a system capable
of building FAQs from textual content tailored to specific domains, enhancing
their accuracy and relevance. We utilise self-curated algorithms to obtain an
optimal representation of information to be provided as input and also to rank
the question-answer pairs to maximise human comprehension. Qualitative human
evaluation showcases the generated FAQs as well-constructed and readable while
also utilising domain-specific constructs to highlight domain-based nuances and
jargon in the original content. | [
0.0859217495,
-0.0645455793,
-0.0253170412,
0.0032382624,
-0.0251300335,
0.0130820824,
-0.003126702,
-0.0125808856,
0.0157740172,
-0.0485604666,
-0.0076043322,
-0.0120057594,
0.0107925385,
0.0364782922,
-0.0029426629,
-0.0433900431,
0.01960079,
-0.0110965306,
-0.0305969249,
0.0197322425,
0.0048948075,
0.0380348787,
-0.014403942,
0.0150585975,
0.0064891414,
0.0028739972,
0.0011614588,
0.0132190986,
0.0038451287,
-0.0194891784,
0.046463035,
0.0351848863,
0.0017180078,
-0.0596960522,
0.0000019677,
-0.0571909063,
-0.022626387,
0.0019763408,
-0.0118294787,
-0.0053400272,
0.0366770811,
0.0192426145,
0.0472240858,
0.0483406559,
-0.044094909,
0.0124361934,
-0.018102536,
0.0182893742,
0.1123866141,
0.0400210507,
-0.0172458198,
-0.0706464574,
-0.0094390688,
0.0141514661,
0.01877914,
-0.0600674748,
-0.0168901216,
0.0513141416,
0.0293932278,
0.0360033922,
0.0324937887,
-0.0019057452,
0.010612946,
-0.0303327292,
0.0712475181,
-0.000679287,
-0.0008346142,
-0.0247798525,
-0.0057226084,
0.0963397399,
0.0466793217,
-0.0160032623,
0.0413835719,
0.0158645771,
0.0473894849,
0.0297621991,
-0.0127615649,
0.0134755895,
-0.0151875727,
-0.0473176688,
0.0253544282,
0.0191755537,
-0.0328251906,
0.0033736869,
0.0030209071,
0.0057197558,
0.0200908016,
-0.0202952512,
-0.0450617671,
-0.0179572646,
-0.0030186519,
-0.0751332864,
0.0620325394,
0.0894669294,
-0.0182040948,
-0.0065332097,
-0.0244452115,
-0.0203243867,
0.0424555205,
-0.0526600219,
-0.0182742719,
0.0002638919,
0.0022009781,
0.0256026015,
-0.0005335005,
0.0303744413,
-0.0000157665,
-0.0436181389,
-0.0717106611,
-0.0166525878,
-0.0926611423,
-0.0287453756,
-0.0370054655,
0.0618501268,
-0.0461850017,
-0.0243023261,
-0.0085183429,
0.0285065733,
0.0558611006,
0.009843233,
0.0315719359,
0.0301404893,
-0.0364926271,
-0.0086470703,
-0.0303563513,
-0.0171324983,
-0.0857822746,
0.0184600614,
0.0078138504,
0.0035445357,
0.0222156942,
0.0178388823,
0.0138619207,
0.0012110804,
-0.0091384584,
0.0328713804,
-0.0118000582,
0.0101669962,
-0.0423954725,
-0.060934566,
-0.0137816379,
0.0129497703,
-0.0134885143,
-0.0294766016,
-0.0037157813,
0.0210111421,
-0.0317733549,
-0.015692044,
0.0245902259,
0.0676301494,
-0.0297981277,
0.0335690677,
-0.0254929531,
0.0177816171,
0.1322664917,
0.0028156941,
0.0282954331,
0.000680181,
0.0212467648,
0.0196933933,
0.0439959876,
0.0144823091,
0.0323818326,
-0.0329570919,
-0.0066857422,
-0.0316496715,
0.019447891,
0.0856526792,
-0.04648114,
0.0171995815,
-0.0307113845,
0.079946138,
0.0110267252,
0.0210856386,
0.0315275826,
0.0227458831,
0.0150963487,
0.0630152598,
0.0271033719,
0.0577045418,
0.0227827895,
0.0148499496,
-0.0063845566,
0.0546496436,
-0.0125904707,
0.0039486126,
0.0256683994,
0.0259696748,
-0.0302910246,
-0.056705635,
-0.001099215,
0.009419986,
0.0138483113,
0.013455214,
0.0163018033,
0.047017891,
-0.044449389,
0.0152394492,
-0.0318189226,
-0.0335832648,
0.0301358066,
-0.0255825501,
0.0393375009,
0.0448548123,
0.041991841,
-0.000049798,
-0.0287798196,
-0.0195406433,
0.0188556463,
0.039066501,
0.0464176424,
-0.0124151492,
-0.0194174424,
-0.0422510728,
0.0047233235,
-0.0223309491,
-0.0070515131,
-0.0426164232,
0.0138668418,
0.0131926853,
0.0707595944,
-0.0758263245,
-0.0555628128,
0.0462008193,
0.0098841349,
-0.0404693857,
0.0417473949,
0.0055915206,
-0.0466341674,
0.092564024,
-0.005352987,
0.0286664143,
-0.0017571943,
-0.0191884954,
-0.0186537933,
0.0054064794,
-0.0212384686,
-0.0284898318,
0.0011438358,
-0.0686716959,
-0.0065664663,
0.0419761837,
-0.0434298366,
-0.046303872,
-0.0235030446,
-0.0647766367,
-0.021015143,
-0.0566691123,
-0.0276832059,
0.0390970223,
-0.0227140747,
-0.0385879762,
0.0772403851,
0.0402351879,
-0.0301645026,
0.0221523438,
-0.0130434977,
0.0191757847,
-0.0352619551,
0.0339618362,
-0.0543050654,
-0.0338702165,
0.000295338,
0.0310838036,
0.0252620447,
-0.0610889234,
-0.0012979436,
-0.0731798485,
0.0112440661,
-0.0177324992,
0.0057732891,
0.0585418679,
-0.0000586558,
-0.0097445026,
-0.0184627417,
-0.087250717,
-0.0146368891,
0.0010508473,
-0.017575074,
0.090291284,
0.0227393638,
0.0134283192,
-0.0295363721,
0.0095361145,
-0.011654594,
0.014878517,
0.0639504641,
0.0214570742,
-0.0626177937,
0.0156230545,
-0.0560152195,
-0.0388843194,
0.0618733615,
-0.010824373,
-0.0125540728,
0.0153366718,
0.0232794546,
0.0482497886,
0.0936617851,
0.0030744916,
-0.0181467813,
0.0142540988,
0.0004565101,
-0.0000506745,
-0.0328298137,
-0.0031528813,
0.038338434,
-0.0612627305,
0.0717449337,
0.018446492,
0.0224781875,
0.001357317,
-0.0333566256,
0.0507620536,
-0.0188844968,
0.0001675981,
-0.0528542995,
-0.0293719918,
-0.0003228314,
0.054420229,
0.0028958905,
0.0078593427,
0.075923793,
-0.009815855,
0.0137690548,
-0.0920905769,
-0.000880752,
-0.0614397638,
0.0316915736,
-0.0390318371,
0.0576998517,
0.0282625686,
-0.0283239037,
-0.0322908536,
-0.0137552312,
0.0317719616,
-0.0368636586,
-0.0124341976,
-0.0393859521,
-0.0012675372,
-0.0043115979,
-0.0436782949,
-0.0216781739,
-0.0056529823,
0.0098796571,
-0.023794787,
0.009516268,
0.0059375726,
0.012556945,
0.016222015,
0.018908767,
0.0166611765,
-0.0196469892,
-0.0373751335,
0.0171036515,
0.0886919722,
0.0729948133,
0.0039345208,
0.0184421502,
-0.0153275579,
0.0288703535,
0.0295268651,
-0.0166136473,
0.0020797299,
0.0237929467,
-0.0243522227,
-0.0184872802,
-0.0595316961,
-0.0075718402,
0.0106989453,
0.0414962135,
-0.0463050082,
-0.0245316587,
0.1144713685,
0.0853350163,
-0.0012867664,
-0.009584331,
-0.020592235,
-0.0089947945,
0.0075583467,
0.0630911514,
-0.060997203,
-0.0255861655,
-0.0092056952,
0.0575900674,
0.013491381,
0.0057948329,
0.0055840844,
-0.0636821166,
0.0281835422,
-0.0258073565,
-0.0120346546,
-0.0481313989,
-0.0159383286,
-0.027891567,
0.0061408137,
-0.0399324335,
0.0182885099,
-0.0307373833,
0.0253534615,
0.0152779799,
-0.0358408876,
0.0004488737,
0.0183820259,
0.0195597969,
0.031303864,
0.0554307438,
0.026657261,
0.0238251556,
-0.0112189725,
-0.0050398433,
-0.0324898846,
0.0248825457,
-0.0082263332,
0.036990609,
-0.0078962892,
0.0059798216,
-0.0538301431,
0.0505776182,
-0.0286644995,
-0.000678485,
0.0698533058,
-0.01071171,
-0.0235709194,
-0.0173777156,
-0.0546420403,
0.0286652446,
0.0021684093,
0.1048781425,
0.0215453971,
-0.0422561802,
-0.0031342288,
-0.0264260881,
0.0307591632,
-0.0586897694,
-0.0635456145,
-0.0048718122,
0.0110362805,
0.0173873939,
-0.1105730757,
-0.0308949463,
0.0443238392,
0.0130495662,
0.0152702993,
-0.0222312994,
-0.0006537083,
0.0235824622,
-0.0413006358,
-0.0188690145,
0.0089516863,
-0.0146605186,
-0.0599788614,
-0.0208876412,
0.0456143171,
-0.0506309718,
-0.0387493931,
0.0214574579,
-0.0110675227,
-0.0066811237,
-0.0153025063,
0.0260888971,
0.0135898208,
-0.0377464592,
0.0046910057,
-0.0052412027,
0.0481986925,
0.0139632076,
-0.0811124742,
-0.0164357349,
-0.0371632129,
0.0236669146,
-0.0072848112,
0.029048251,
-0.0597514659,
0.0467937216,
-0.0814649612,
0.0512513779,
-0.0054243961,
-0.0920848325,
0.0471662991,
0.014561519,
-0.043200735,
-0.0073954673,
0.0114508187,
-0.0129891504,
0.0192177761,
-0.0168983527,
-0.0198978055,
-0.0253210161,
0.0499535911,
0.0049995249,
-0.0164277591,
0.021805726,
-0.0057088737,
-0.0554041937,
0.0439931564,
-0.0004471275,
-0.0165620819,
0.0112170754,
0.0382390395,
-0.0417051055,
-0.0320235714,
-0.039801579,
-0.0234890413,
-0.0060308711,
0.0454112031,
0.0257010832,
0.0655633062,
-0.0070210104,
-0.0063191568,
-0.0348429233,
0.038947735,
-0.0440347865,
-0.0564937852,
-0.038269233,
-0.0276544392,
-0.0196041614,
0.0067499056,
0.0080983415,
-0.0213391613,
-0.0259498581,
0.0033527194,
0.0388004929,
0.0123984888,
-0.007492736,
0.0142042162,
0.015698282,
-0.0224357266,
-0.0271329954,
0.045047015,
-0.0035561284,
-0.020495085,
0.017475076,
-0.0327587426,
-0.0501244627,
-0.0298625864,
-0.0053133201,
0.0047733211,
0.0010398062,
0.0136693092,
-0.0696551204,
-0.0613437034,
-0.0042220047,
0.0076508871,
0.0343982354,
0.0007912362,
0.0597544089,
0.0510927476,
0.0242049526,
-0.0716441125,
-0.0705370083,
0.0456421822,
-0.0691162422,
-0.0277907904,
0.003477812,
-6.365864678e-33,
-0.0311691742,
-0.0485164821,
-0.0037383779,
0.0023056057,
0.0389182158,
-0.0005888437,
-0.0375794545,
-0.0074202619,
-0.0150592914,
0.0099031907,
0.0120641431,
0.0096881408,
-0.0075645284,
0.0125830397,
-0.0442888997,
-0.0204497576,
0.0490242727,
-0.0227063186,
-0.0230127424,
0.0589213595,
0.0213227235,
0.0175173935,
-0.018629346,
-0.0280323867,
0.0148256626,
-0.0463641621,
-0.0204173699,
0.0447621085,
0.0458771586,
0.0533840507,
0.0062102014,
-0.0015130017,
0.047770571,
-0.0204137042,
0.0378180221,
0.0704371482,
-0.0778635442,
-0.0207094718,
0.0210481696,
-0.0737745315,
-0.0458268039,
-0.016895052,
0.0140174925,
-0.019171875,
0.0575795695,
-0.011977911,
0.0717790648,
-0.0113570886,
0.0356515013,
-0.038988132,
-0.031044241,
0.0030898382,
-0.0514829494,
-0.0222193841,
-0.0397709161,
0.0949232876,
-0.0114543289,
-0.009925657,
-0.0334147215,
0.0305709019,
0.0173709039,
0.0374850444,
0.0331059769,
-0.0176161006,
-0.0186169706,
-0.0158962384,
-0.0433942005,
0.0189266577,
-0.0176611897,
0.0256434865,
-0.0668075159,
0.0131550208,
0.0189805273,
0.0689855888,
0.0204283781,
-0.0143831419,
-0.0517061427,
0.0793466344,
-0.034504924,
0.0112100746,
-0.0167863443,
-0.050898809,
-0.0051557552,
0.0277327802,
-0.0498217791,
0.0889319703,
-0.0373854116,
-0.039628122,
0.0616409592,
-0.0042729359,
-0.082805939,
-0.0414353423,
-0.0169166718,
0.015520284,
0.006022865,
-0.017907802,
-0.0238988865,
0.0113412188,
0.0084337704,
0.0238815211,
-0.0149479387,
0.0346691534,
0.0092916647,
0.0274530407,
0.0184008069,
0.0172819495,
-0.0171152577,
0.0005922451,
-0.0319708064,
0.0117569761,
0.0227160603,
0.0271372013,
-0.0591103919,
-0.0184834041,
-0.0195111744,
0.0364319682,
-0.0265517533,
0.0244326033,
-0.018448934,
0.0035931284,
-0.0500270836,
-0.0324954353,
0.0343891717,
0.0515429266,
-0.0296877865,
-0.0068044984,
-0.0180761833,
0.0534648634,
0.0241691712,
-0.0283646863,
-0.0040765819,
-0.0160963312,
2.668e-7,
0.0580943115,
0.0402169786,
0.0261965822,
0.033153791,
-0.0085324552,
0.0287113842,
0.0598406866,
0.0329289325,
0.0297744758,
-0.0012167057,
0.0380475484,
0.0486017242,
0.0042678425,
0.0126786493,
-0.0644581169,
-0.0256650373,
-0.0063577848,
0.0028203137,
-0.0482704751,
0.0143246008,
0.0865855962,
0.0039164168,
-0.0457680933,
-0.0049397275,
-0.0372196399,
-0.0293340459,
0.0380067341,
0.0103280321,
0.0201619118,
0.0425157696,
0.0173896402,
-0.0010734758,
-0.0150080528,
0.0179771893,
-0.041588787,
0.0113415476,
0.0227379128,
0.020293748,
0.0009550924,
-0.0520088673,
-0.0284860581,
-0.0100325914,
0.049452085,
-0.0912499949,
0.0579989962,
-0.0647387728,
-0.0106003219,
-0.0012696955,
-0.0431486703,
0.0019862363,
-0.0174945313,
-0.0068657417,
-0.0250812899,
0.0370082706,
-0.0002531721,
0.0081388168,
0.0366825573,
-0.0304831248,
-0.0126009686,
0.0141038159,
-0.0103388736,
0.0074772476,
-0.0732071996,
-0.0063855019,
-0.0306131486,
0.0009878022,
0.0195354093,
1.939028671e-34,
0.009359424,
0.0080441395,
-0.0073926905,
0.0201450493,
0.0200878177,
0.0052960385,
-0.0391942896,
-0.0001587851,
0.027297847,
-0.0531899929,
0.0170654431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05808v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05808v2 | Training Large Language Models for Reasoning through Reverse Curriculum Reinforcement Learning | 2024-02-08T16:46:26 | 2024-03-17T09:02:02 | Zhiheng Xi, Wenxiang Chen, Boyang Hong, Senjie Jin, Rui Zheng, Wei He, Yiwen Ding, Shichun Liu, Xin Guo, Junzhe Wang, Honglin Guo, Wei Shen, Xiaoran Fan, Yuhao Zhou, Shihan Dou, Xiao Wang, Xinbo Zhang, Peng Sun, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose R$^3$: Learning Reasoning through Reverse
Curriculum Reinforcement Learning (RL), a novel method that employs only
outcome supervision to achieve the benefits of process supervision for large
language models. The core challenge in applying RL to complex reasoning is to
identify a sequence of actions that result in positive rewards and provide
appropriate supervision for optimization. Outcome supervision provides sparse
rewards for final results without identifying error locations, whereas process
supervision offers step-wise rewards but requires extensive manual annotation.
R$^3$ overcomes these limitations by learning from correct demonstrations.
Specifically, R$^3$ progressively slides the start state of reasoning from a
demonstration's end to its beginning, facilitating easier model exploration at
all stages. Thus, R$^3$ establishes a step-wise curriculum, allowing outcome
supervision to offer step-level signals and precisely pinpoint errors. Using
Llama2-7B, our method surpasses RL baseline on eight reasoning tasks by $4.1$
points on average. Notebaly, in program-based reasoning on GSM8K, it exceeds
the baseline by $4.2$ points across three backbone models, and without any
extra data, Codellama-7B + R$^3$ performs comparable to larger models or
closed-source models. | [
0.040167056,
0.0273855254,
-0.0067636529,
0.0176918153,
-0.0375927016,
0.0299860537,
-0.0171533432,
-0.0195223521,
-0.005463351,
-0.018803712,
-0.0160224941,
0.0249408428,
-0.018057989,
-0.0056294673,
0.028407244,
-0.0613141656,
0.0585849844,
-0.0867177099,
0.0492046624,
0.0070411628,
-0.0266888868,
0.0030352809,
-0.0205805935,
0.0220323764,
-0.0146896373,
-0.0345197693,
-0.0299839787,
-0.0174246393,
0.0247083884,
-0.0512530841,
0.0035060663,
0.0373228379,
0.0553099886,
0.0120310988,
0.0000022597,
-0.0540649444,
-0.0093478905,
-0.0130871795,
-0.0516515523,
-0.0083477069,
-0.0207097288,
0.0195172001,
-0.0005088077,
0.0296842624,
-0.0070856558,
0.0368081704,
0.0099246912,
0.0360929035,
0.0811400786,
0.0656121969,
0.0258081984,
-0.031798169,
0.0192925036,
-0.0333300009,
0.0173587874,
-0.0226440895,
0.0090696597,
0.0677447617,
0.061061658,
0.0070876018,
-0.0191126112,
0.0143385772,
0.0669294223,
-0.0205543153,
-0.0756246224,
0.0526131988,
0.0005059804,
-0.0259884559,
0.0010249362,
0.0467473567,
0.0001011631,
-0.0417605266,
0.0050372877,
-0.0081128404,
0.0057219714,
-0.0632757246,
-0.0516828485,
0.062023744,
-0.0070413519,
0.0273103733,
0.0317540132,
-0.0216819383,
0.0094820671,
0.0056932918,
-0.0182611216,
0.0925979689,
-0.014883358,
-0.0488673151,
0.0379929207,
0.0159890242,
-0.0261209868,
-0.0357226729,
-0.0097784027,
0.0569023751,
-0.0642443299,
0.0358371735,
0.0001899579,
0.0018281967,
0.0101799574,
-0.0052613015,
0.0364367589,
0.0490148552,
-0.00404617,
0.065914847,
-0.0499684401,
0.080597423,
-0.0418198593,
0.0963200778,
-0.0140927648,
0.0112124579,
-0.0404509753,
-0.0020776861,
-0.0313330591,
0.0465986989,
-0.0335716642,
-0.0051989788,
-0.0344198458,
0.0370226838,
-0.0155887725,
0.0597593598,
0.0230061468,
0.0095541589,
-0.0254309662,
-0.0216157474,
-0.0266809762,
0.0118623646,
-0.0355311967,
0.0246994216,
0.0254430436,
0.0054979776,
-0.0328990221,
-0.0061770217,
-0.0243368484,
-0.0182055291,
0.0366392955,
0.0717844367,
-0.0169251524,
-0.0137701342,
-0.0432237461,
-0.038331449,
0.0144944033,
-0.1095496342,
0.0325904191,
-0.0837033913,
0.0020723699,
-0.0025713153,
-0.0071840333,
-0.012410013,
0.0299108513,
0.0089106476,
-0.0042240866,
0.0589341857,
0.0304626171,
-0.0032822762,
-0.0076373569,
0.0210875496,
-0.0383152962,
0.0682783127,
0.0168320611,
0.0191775057,
-0.0166387167,
0.0316444784,
0.0098125739,
0.0130776679,
0.0432189628,
-0.0002336234,
-0.0430963263,
0.0018616297,
0.0228502564,
0.03053445,
0.0347740091,
0.0310545489,
-0.0332603231,
0.0001378746,
0.0160507262,
0.0541646928,
-0.0283902865,
-0.0283867046,
0.0563660674,
-0.018836759,
0.0382054523,
-0.0199119188,
-0.0947944447,
0.0394672267,
-0.0120746493,
0.0168843661,
-0.0269916859,
-0.0379987508,
-0.0255165026,
-0.0570396893,
-0.0088529503,
0.0204573832,
-0.0119572245,
0.0279525984,
0.048104573,
0.0148146115,
-0.0530332066,
-0.0165222585,
0.0294497218,
-0.011839658,
-0.0084633622,
-0.0746147484,
0.0690631196,
0.039095927,
0.024781812,
-0.0519085154,
-0.0457472093,
-0.0104526868,
0.0491668433,
0.031645827,
-0.0152896931,
-0.0210139193,
-0.0197059903,
-0.02531223,
-0.0336372778,
-0.0406104326,
0.0174109526,
0.0110494243,
0.0590412132,
-0.0231274348,
-0.0265077502,
-0.0183079746,
0.0089628194,
0.0394571647,
-0.0372086279,
-0.0302938633,
-0.0364810079,
0.0083737532,
0.0128303198,
-0.0232206471,
0.0069389534,
0.0022708189,
0.031657584,
-0.0164089091,
-0.0057040215,
-0.0025935636,
-0.0509119891,
-0.0827014446,
0.0339535438,
0.0242884587,
-0.0350885242,
0.0232734028,
-0.0468372926,
-0.0238254257,
0.0380222984,
0.0024170168,
0.059914913,
-0.0037936927,
0.0221590195,
0.0391113795,
-0.0467417501,
-0.0319000557,
0.0780733079,
-0.0392239392,
0.0069806622,
0.0420853905,
0.0001935185,
-0.0129496967,
-0.0445979796,
0.0109638395,
0.0069548702,
-0.0172941294,
0.0131561905,
-0.0151347108,
0.0326007232,
-0.0626490936,
-0.0176600758,
-0.0357811712,
0.0210611299,
-0.0265500154,
0.0289483611,
0.0114062903,
-0.025325017,
0.0056802644,
-0.0317267254,
-0.0099455295,
-0.0144250905,
0.0220746025,
0.0130842105,
0.004131848,
0.0304891244,
-0.042749472,
-0.0424767174,
-0.016360309,
-0.0354496129,
0.0348747931,
-0.0191859063,
0.0430475585,
-0.0572884008,
-0.0065451721,
-0.0029572519,
0.0330323614,
-0.0338973403,
-0.0122989174,
0.0485457517,
-0.0318529382,
-0.0128895026,
0.0847020671,
-0.047358375,
0.0341318808,
0.0269713774,
-0.0066885855,
-0.0651637241,
0.0424027517,
-0.0091798697,
-0.0395107009,
-0.0193187408,
0.00263796,
-0.0282268114,
0.0810766816,
-0.0085365567,
0.0318927914,
-0.0485327095,
-0.0251698103,
0.0011987317,
-0.0194128081,
-0.0294665713,
-0.0324280262,
-0.0246496461,
0.0345130451,
-0.062247891,
-0.0155574009,
0.0903156996,
-0.0068181171,
-0.011978304,
-0.032800667,
0.0085305888,
-0.0021520702,
0.0794776902,
-0.0163193792,
0.0112477671,
-0.0202969443,
-0.0271918662,
-0.0516568124,
-0.0514861308,
0.019005768,
-0.0192758571,
0.0331307799,
-0.0799532756,
0.0034390297,
0.0005760703,
-0.0368821993,
-0.07805641,
0.0343051441,
-0.0223599188,
0.0437384509,
-0.0445925668,
-0.0052396064,
-0.0109310765,
-0.018730063,
0.0242575128,
0.0240680184,
-0.0134010594,
-0.0140152285,
-0.0504151694,
-0.0206629075,
0.0072655384,
-0.0165461116,
-0.0024045352,
-0.0443823598,
0.0396754406,
0.0379572436,
0.0879292861,
-0.021564845,
-0.0269935671,
0.0456999019,
0.0108978534,
-0.025960356,
-0.0063756425,
0.0375378728,
0.056712348,
-0.1003919616,
-0.0387403928,
0.0880434588,
0.0354789644,
-0.0230179969,
-0.0142423697,
-0.0220632944,
0.0034144705,
0.0479487665,
0.0556453168,
-0.0237800777,
-0.0174856,
0.0184808504,
0.0267889109,
0.0263234396,
-0.0240092315,
-0.0024437027,
-0.1236173883,
0.0389614701,
-0.0127658667,
-0.0025295692,
-0.0163819995,
-0.0383903235,
0.0066817813,
0.0070136911,
-0.0168721396,
0.044565212,
-0.0019746469,
-0.0123504773,
0.0409203358,
0.0275016781,
-0.0022863285,
0.0583234765,
-0.0097582806,
0.0254094396,
0.0597891584,
-0.0029395532,
0.0237593409,
-0.0487977788,
0.0528137609,
-0.011198232,
0.0012855381,
-0.0085426988,
-0.0032011771,
0.0102623012,
-0.0271271523,
-0.0108046718,
0.0764916912,
-0.013856017,
-0.0602285564,
-0.0206976347,
0.1144486368,
-0.0228573754,
-0.0016465208,
-0.0161102135,
0.0081168804,
-0.0042098304,
0.0380443707,
0.015475058,
-0.0233171284,
-0.0597587973,
-0.0355521105,
-0.0333584733,
-0.0195656382,
-0.009751102,
-0.0118305795,
0.0312580913,
0.0135168862,
-0.0202517938,
-0.0221602675,
0.0654238835,
0.0721760839,
-0.0098485341,
-0.0166593846,
-0.0062303212,
0.0007328647,
-0.056089811,
0.0255903006,
-0.0463890992,
0.0312416162,
-0.0677574575,
0.0061187204,
-0.009666292,
-0.0182126965,
-0.0468512215,
-0.0132613992,
-0.0817389861,
-0.0597219989,
-0.033766754,
0.0869451463,
0.0255454127,
0.081020005,
-0.0129557699,
0.0025133237,
0.0188257173,
-0.0043319645,
-0.0148682185,
0.0073245312,
0.04792808,
0.0057338239,
-0.0004768363,
0.0256266389,
-0.0442345738,
0.0207612421,
0.0212412067,
0.0656509995,
-0.0062760436,
0.0218023155,
0.0483845882,
-0.0320367143,
0.0565075092,
0.0047510699,
-0.0211624224,
-0.0461644717,
0.0336437896,
-0.0175040346,
-0.023785647,
-0.0169439949,
0.0245541353,
0.0178869814,
-0.0275451895,
0.0137160141,
-0.0356989093,
0.0065498627,
0.0227446761,
0.0005929498,
0.0087535344,
0.0209812634,
0.0300713666,
0.0191754755,
-0.0015186233,
-0.0248002466,
0.0046337787,
0.0153898858,
0.0495760776,
-0.031834688,
0.0723638609,
0.0379106253,
0.0245387852,
-0.0432479195,
-0.0089298515,
-0.0408637039,
-0.038884677,
0.0079637635,
0.0252267178,
0.0529443957,
0.0141424444,
-0.0087886341,
-0.0515115298,
-0.0030335884,
0.0210091565,
0.0277026389,
-0.0229977425,
-0.0429918654,
0.0501732714,
0.0397537276,
0.0437734313,
-0.0275639407,
0.0292574186,
0.0024564303,
0.0867511332,
-0.0202398058,
0.0101175504,
-0.0318828896,
-0.0617399216,
-0.0014802316,
-0.0069112489,
0.0022189899,
0.0115531245,
-0.0342209116,
-0.0976189375,
-0.0498185158,
0.0519943908,
-0.0218585692,
-0.0172829367,
0.0277076345,
0.030192215,
0.0073433435,
-0.0613579936,
-0.0055269715,
-0.0267185085,
0.0197169483,
-0.0372717306,
-0.0121502718,
-6.580418111e-33,
-0.0425489359,
-0.0148860076,
0.0687793642,
-0.0134097356,
-0.0088337939,
-0.0361818448,
-0.0623725541,
0.0006791031,
-0.001196752,
0.0422276706,
-0.0058351671,
0.0059369486,
0.0044149486,
-0.0083160317,
0.0353528187,
0.009341402,
0.0421277061,
-0.0016017888,
-0.0406360477,
0.0248741359,
0.0206778031,
0.0085830363,
0.0583078116,
-0.0293864999,
0.010321538,
0.0430766977,
-0.033144284,
0.0541926734,
-0.0744841173,
0.0664726198,
0.0021736505,
-0.0140115926,
0.0062098461,
-0.0478095599,
-0.0165230334,
-0.0081275972,
-0.1101543382,
-0.0483521372,
0.0347597525,
0.0098687597,
-0.0707822293,
-0.0257997308,
0.0276041068,
0.0057006204,
0.0016811329,
0.0044384482,
-0.0040143188,
-0.0059818737,
-0.0029233778,
0.0308979321,
-0.0520144254,
-0.0061092773,
-0.0093713421,
-0.0573087558,
0.0135802031,
0.0019936706,
-0.0099065788,
-0.0156447142,
0.0031440556,
-0.0101067666,
0.009050292,
0.0124057066,
0.0616003051,
0.0463006496,
-0.0037650971,
0.0401570462,
-0.0206500608,
-0.0227716696,
-0.0102073783,
-0.005258576,
0.0283025932,
0.0766379982,
0.0139127672,
-0.0154156731,
-0.0061180466,
0.0218072161,
-0.0796344131,
-0.0228002667,
-0.0107063791,
0.1041882336,
0.0260118954,
-0.0021478648,
-0.0387657508,
-0.0204272028,
-0.0739578009,
0.0007775161,
-0.0337713361,
-0.0140665909,
0.0621306747,
0.0414419435,
-0.0334522165,
-0.0262974706,
0.0024652244,
-0.0308996886,
-0.0119397622,
0.0667201653,
-0.0265594367,
0.0319815427,
-0.0201638509,
0.0351788029,
-0.0625216588,
-0.0379664302,
0.0192473754,
-0.0251547657,
0.0110584842,
0.015161193,
0.0541833527,
0.0446905568,
-0.0552567691,
0.011611809,
-0.0658877939,
0.0428860672,
0.0277200397,
0.0152898105,
0.0470769778,
0.005999322,
-0.006480536,
0.0438607968,
-0.0223419033,
-0.0289683081,
-0.0183617976,
0.0171412136,
-0.0228598155,
0.0306441281,
-0.0360580385,
-0.0176870786,
-0.0546376146,
0.0385365337,
-0.0068787346,
-0.0427782461,
0.0086475844,
0.0454729162,
2.969e-7,
0.0131499721,
0.0273797289,
0.0278002266,
0.0754905418,
0.0070812446,
0.0284784436,
-0.0446220599,
-0.012197786,
0.0419827439,
-0.0358498804,
-0.0071086842,
0.0549185909,
0.0119965598,
0.0216432158,
-0.0447116271,
-0.009891279,
-0.030949844,
-0.0196926035,
-0.0532737635,
-0.0303597189,
0.0534024686,
0.0887825266,
0.0449274369,
-0.0131550469,
-0.000688856,
0.0151171964,
0.0541830696,
0.0146409515,
0.0180982817,
-0.0089826453,
-0.0036379274,
0.025891332,
0.0116213383,
0.005452618,
0.0167303458,
0.0105887344,
-0.0643365756,
0.0750900134,
-0.0021777111,
-0.010798227,
-0.023231905,
-0.0115187056,
0.0246961247,
-0.0290304441,
0.0601045229,
-0.0618635304,
0.0129244691,
0.002256261,
0.0274269842,
-0.0472136512,
-0.0166467596,
-0.0155987069,
0.0238316227,
0.0087877382,
-0.006242157,
-0.0042850659,
0.0022861399,
-0.0912829787,
-0.0294262879,
0.0312676318,
-0.0098779853,
-0.0172146298,
-0.0311626755,
0.0254635457,
-0.0106807267,
-0.0659469888,
0.0022135191,
2.936645242e-34,
0.0278377291,
-0.0262467992,
0.0119536892,
0.0091423271,
0.0225324687,
0.0043480466,
0.0063351314,
0.024091512,
0.0500934236,
-0.0504828095,
-0.0363589674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05794v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05794v1 | Phonetically rich corpus construction for a low-resourced language | 2024-02-08T16:36:11 | 2024-02-08T16:36:11 | Marcellus Amadeus, William Alberto Cruz Castañeda, Wilmer Lobato, Niasche Aquino | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Speech technologies rely on capturing a speaker's voice variability while
obtaining comprehensive language information. Textual prompts and sentence
selection methods have been proposed in the literature to comprise such
adequate phonetic data, referred to as a phonetically rich \textit{corpus}.
However, they are still insufficient for acoustic modeling, especially critical
for languages with limited resources. Hence, this paper proposes a novel
approach and outlines the methodological aspects required to create a
\textit{corpus} with broad phonetic coverage for a low-resourced language,
Brazilian Portuguese. Our methodology includes text dataset collection up to a
sentence selection algorithm based on triphone distribution. Furthermore, we
propose a new phonemic classification according to acoustic-articulatory speech
features since the absolute number of distinct triphones, or low-probability
triphones, does not guarantee an adequate representation of every possible
combination. Using our algorithm, we achieve a 55.8\% higher percentage of
distinct triphones -- for samples of similar size -- while the currently
available phonetic-rich corpus, CETUC and TTS-Portuguese, 12.6\% and 12.3\% in
comparison to a non-phonetically rich dataset. | [
-0.0005902962,
0.039546486,
-0.0394832492,
0.0040526171,
-0.0389289781,
-0.0109263249,
0.021800369,
-0.0102309296,
-0.0132898334,
-0.0246167555,
-0.0227808226,
-0.075080663,
0.0552491732,
-0.049194172,
0.0240741819,
-0.068194434,
0.0035782652,
-0.0441730767,
-0.0349491127,
-0.0377890505,
0.0036557561,
0.0353505462,
-0.0282524247,
0.0204163808,
0.0218797456,
0.0261023939,
0.0022126201,
-0.0230249204,
-0.0029413332,
-0.0103826206,
-0.0469462872,
0.0341056995,
-0.0116811516,
0.0175456703,
0.0000018523,
-0.0728986934,
-0.0432995148,
-0.0091600036,
-0.0256935135,
-0.0194083862,
0.0230794456,
0.0930236429,
-0.0302761439,
0.0376427099,
-0.0092926733,
-0.0075154188,
0.0713160113,
-0.0215141643,
0.01331311,
0.0425351448,
-0.0206320994,
-0.0312123951,
-0.0298971049,
-0.0132615045,
0.0243003871,
0.027069727,
0.0042234981,
-0.0359328687,
0.0458073169,
-0.029410664,
0.0234517474,
-0.0036992466,
-0.0428433307,
-0.0219805017,
-0.0062098489,
-0.0171574093,
-0.0967154279,
-0.075291805,
0.013466577,
0.0107289888,
0.0219974518,
-0.0387039296,
0.0439317673,
0.0411662608,
-0.0167054944,
-0.0111526176,
-0.0501842499,
-0.006015074,
-0.0206900742,
0.0227766819,
0.0334016681,
0.0613609292,
-0.0062383888,
0.0106905894,
-0.0035918737,
-0.0288388319,
0.0188975278,
-0.0466691479,
0.0237466656,
0.0044628242,
-0.0009673021,
-0.0056553492,
0.0426276326,
-0.0023611756,
0.0062758098,
0.0056597074,
0.0452492721,
-0.0643845126,
0.0481469333,
-0.0466928743,
0.0187313929,
-0.0294985753,
-0.0564693846,
0.0097614415,
0.0134247048,
-0.0422205329,
0.0143286614,
-0.0588903502,
-0.0083970437,
-0.0094325747,
-0.0247838534,
-0.0013618163,
-0.0601345524,
0.0339714624,
0.0066409344,
0.0542526618,
-0.0484109856,
-0.0220279265,
0.0094900122,
-0.0417246819,
0.0318556353,
-0.0253725555,
-0.0348214805,
0.0067078946,
0.0072018942,
-0.0168682747,
-0.012625833,
0.0476142168,
-0.0662941784,
-0.0886532962,
0.0291930083,
0.0291704275,
0.0490627252,
-0.0058521386,
0.0154155083,
0.0061967541,
-0.0006776035,
-0.0346735306,
-0.0175954551,
-0.0172654465,
-0.0678281784,
-0.0758697316,
-0.0498619638,
-0.0506700948,
0.0409014858,
-0.0105683142,
0.0202250462,
0.0383077338,
-0.0021730936,
0.0132918814,
0.0534472689,
0.0141069451,
0.0067734309,
0.0230041575,
0.0437329188,
-0.0337098166,
0.0155534912,
0.0315622203,
0.0334346481,
-0.0422570556,
0.0479953773,
-0.0150203342,
-0.043491859,
0.0474650487,
0.0106253298,
-0.0023708772,
0.0262879524,
-0.0089175496,
-0.0141022392,
-0.0091319606,
0.0168608688,
0.0548615493,
-0.0095173195,
0.0485002436,
0.046453096,
0.0364528559,
0.0270834938,
0.0549549907,
0.0239985753,
-0.0169830117,
0.0190474689,
-0.0071860966,
0.0608591326,
-0.0526453778,
0.0113407904,
0.0009962389,
0.0157527477,
0.0552455224,
-0.037309736,
0.0056782393,
0.0153388735,
-0.0318295434,
-0.0269529093,
-0.0005992802,
0.0465731137,
-0.0084745688,
-0.0006620465,
0.0281882398,
0.0033207715,
-0.081688337,
-0.0185056012,
-0.0109827425,
0.0197711475,
-0.0098985862,
0.0291928034,
-0.0067300168,
0.0402544998,
-0.031023046,
0.0234565679,
0.0497596934,
-0.0019731612,
-0.016344415,
0.037329793,
-0.0992289484,
-0.0138852224,
0.0764647424,
-0.014783673,
0.0354229845,
-0.0406283848,
0.0505616814,
0.0171778761,
-0.0731318519,
0.0195550583,
-0.0043486315,
0.0170121789,
-0.0159778167,
0.035254579,
0.0223572161,
0.0521383993,
0.0663526878,
-0.0119488006,
-0.0091212513,
0.0077338442,
-0.0423020907,
0.0653525814,
0.0503167436,
-0.0146400565,
-0.0167434812,
0.0017648112,
-0.0629938021,
-0.0137462532,
0.039371565,
0.0751547515,
-0.090993315,
0.0072865169,
-0.0478194207,
0.0536793284,
-0.0472733229,
0.0512995347,
-0.0170421135,
0.0559376329,
0.002518804,
0.0328314155,
0.0563474186,
-0.0114619499,
0.0025031327,
-0.0052141631,
0.0170318447,
-0.1156873405,
-0.033547122,
0.0216898918,
-0.004357839,
0.0157836061,
0.0109234899,
0.0134156309,
0.0112994919,
-0.0225598644,
-0.1084931642,
-0.0110546788,
-0.0074776546,
0.0191456601,
-0.0294420663,
0.048274558,
-0.0017534539,
-0.0163049567,
0.0034431459,
-0.0169434361,
-0.0067646778,
-0.0304593947,
-0.0163540207,
-0.0196641702,
-0.0161734615,
-0.0075741904,
0.0203280095,
0.0416261964,
0.0314690284,
0.0352948308,
-0.0668777227,
-0.0452688672,
0.0527228341,
-0.0138344709,
-0.0076150903,
0.0305982288,
-0.0179134533,
-0.0238433462,
0.01001726,
0.0466187373,
-0.0288852472,
-0.0028638793,
-0.0337188281,
0.0355120786,
0.0135093732,
-0.0106029166,
-0.0294764396,
-0.0102891801,
0.0526316166,
-0.0273251571,
-0.0061400612,
0.0217503048,
-0.0010395178,
0.0465633348,
-0.000244325,
0.0040663336,
-0.0400427803,
-0.018702209,
0.0044627218,
0.0244783834,
-0.013262976,
-0.0674473643,
0.0323891416,
0.0004267214,
-0.009409911,
0.0565455817,
-0.0618669242,
-0.0335629359,
-0.1285868436,
-0.0257832296,
-0.0406688973,
0.0310941003,
-0.0133848414,
-0.004142886,
-0.0065772976,
-0.0310475137,
-0.0215356424,
0.031071214,
0.043976713,
-0.0237188805,
0.0172442347,
-0.0242587719,
0.0066382713,
0.0130228819,
-0.0752930567,
0.0080079297,
-0.0217742994,
-0.0305359177,
0.006733261,
0.0575744882,
0.0268979855,
0.0185493827,
0.0326347761,
0.0227194186,
0.0483919829,
0.0115740849,
0.0158036221,
-0.0032022998,
0.0649320409,
0.0042456384,
0.0490628257,
-0.0270742625,
-0.0195831768,
0.0587726906,
-0.0395645387,
0.0403893664,
0.0391030163,
0.021995075,
-0.0066083563,
0.0044189473,
0.003340641,
-0.0808794722,
-0.0008203418,
0.0216275789,
0.0059465677,
-0.0075441953,
0.069360815,
-0.0046035014,
-0.0392574295,
-0.0147533063,
-0.0156070571,
0.0457181558,
-0.0255563296,
0.0376281403,
-0.0483739115,
0.01085262,
0.0305458158,
0.0414491631,
-0.0565208681,
0.0239680205,
-0.0296870079,
-0.1175976247,
0.0570674017,
0.0064138956,
0.0089495601,
0.0277668964,
-0.0561630875,
0.0107335439,
-0.0164233278,
-0.0179375261,
-0.0017050867,
0.0032110426,
-0.0391303822,
0.0592365302,
-0.0942387655,
-0.0798370019,
0.001093596,
-0.011673945,
0.0142227365,
0.054403495,
0.0282332115,
-0.0277937893,
0.0124984095,
0.0318935439,
-0.0111266794,
-0.0128258113,
-0.0138534317,
0.024839323,
0.0505833924,
-0.0280164424,
-0.027395172,
0.0572491959,
0.0175929777,
0.0305711664,
0.0543760434,
0.0801964328,
-0.0454835892,
0.0552736185,
0.0176311396,
0.0364479795,
0.0234275255,
0.0175423939,
0.0347733758,
-0.0777096152,
0.0032842318,
0.0446099006,
0.0119921183,
-0.0530078188,
0.0169747397,
0.0558646284,
0.0158766601,
-0.0873507559,
-0.0493931845,
-0.018252084,
-0.0153684225,
0.0441591181,
0.0414334685,
0.0409506895,
0.0072459704,
0.052824717,
-0.0153617281,
-0.0236554835,
0.0226852223,
0.0180080496,
-0.0597778894,
-0.0389054976,
-0.0112942606,
-0.0694695339,
-0.0197721645,
-0.0418170094,
-0.0468835793,
-0.0701762885,
0.0477225818,
-0.0284080096,
0.0290532019,
0.0188520011,
-0.0291748531,
-0.0712356344,
0.0532071963,
0.0422900096,
-0.0179516859,
0.0252461117,
0.0446577594,
-0.0290141124,
-0.025368195,
0.0295237396,
-0.0083495798,
0.0334816501,
-0.0133108804,
0.0138353333,
-0.0458134003,
-0.0279837903,
-0.0186583083,
0.0179954302,
0.0682460666,
-0.0435217395,
0.0277621876,
-0.0335679762,
0.0330209956,
0.0385516249,
0.0557228178,
0.0004590951,
0.0092857368,
0.0191825069,
0.0146214869,
-0.0204573832,
-0.0464795753,
-0.0628769323,
0.0070265066,
0.0135430945,
0.0667927638,
0.0365415439,
0.0158647317,
0.0243685376,
0.0110237347,
-0.0136586986,
0.0401059091,
0.0080871163,
0.0301918648,
-0.009838732,
0.0039086961,
0.0010589425,
-0.0138113257,
0.0146432323,
0.0109058814,
0.0028235742,
0.0446941368,
-0.0328722596,
0.0010435337,
0.0302974861,
-0.0228492282,
0.0652975366,
-0.0027282245,
0.0215318929,
-0.021440981,
0.0318784043,
0.0045453813,
0.0081410883,
-0.0097744297,
0.0113156782,
-0.0442927554,
0.0474641733,
0.044993598,
-0.0259079877,
-0.0113215558,
-0.0134166451,
0.0137080429,
-0.0394779295,
-0.0096012708,
0.0067479028,
0.0070000882,
-0.029114252,
-0.0281903353,
-0.0710462406,
-0.0348550305,
0.0303422343,
-0.0168530755,
0.0001468223,
-0.0239998214,
0.0258403346,
0.0271504782,
-0.0294777788,
0.0542436987,
-0.0169450603,
-0.0078045549,
-0.0103007276,
0.0388785079,
0.0007335178,
-5.212480641e-33,
-0.0051018945,
0.0054611401,
-0.0455714688,
0.0266210921,
0.0130427806,
0.0143464338,
-0.0124028511,
0.0062231836,
-0.0155905858,
-0.0174918622,
-0.0008200272,
-0.0341402255,
0.0327201784,
0.0062967646,
0.0005411798,
0.0419188663,
0.0415544249,
-0.012997359,
-0.0049859039,
-0.002892687,
0.043430768,
0.0614896044,
0.0174380038,
-0.0135501111,
-0.0110560125,
-0.0384358428,
-0.0045869648,
0.0021648831,
0.0359513238,
0.0650462657,
0.0118608736,
0.0424117185,
-0.0130265616,
-0.0226767212,
-0.0138701387,
0.0259055104,
-0.0603344999,
-0.0663636997,
0.0257226583,
0.0605797209,
0.0768595859,
0.0063280668,
-0.011712783,
0.0018311604,
0.0056242193,
0.0114763817,
0.0332530215,
-0.0633579716,
-0.019193206,
-0.0586154014,
0.0167057067,
0.0584314428,
0.0215719324,
-0.0339255594,
0.0581546798,
0.0841234326,
-0.0774309188,
-0.0253768303,
-0.0097508309,
0.0510043167,
0.002584043,
0.0159791261,
-0.0039275773,
0.008894477,
0.0070977951,
0.0366273448,
0.0586285144,
-0.0593812913,
-0.0058460999,
0.0092629762,
0.0146698346,
0.0110687464,
-0.0260870364,
0.0659815669,
0.0206728056,
0.011686122,
-0.0513520092,
-0.0171661992,
0.0689042807,
-0.0405535735,
0.0101315193,
-0.0051585478,
-0.0779274851,
-0.0190965831,
-0.0016396708,
-0.0445589013,
0.0007131047,
-0.0042293011,
0.0148213636,
-0.0269362349,
-0.0270193052,
0.0222403668,
0.0350357033,
0.0118258791,
-0.0218255967,
-0.0307106357,
-0.0369248353,
0.0123613328,
-0.0034838524,
-0.0116955126,
-0.0381498113,
-0.0223607272,
0.0245004445,
0.0572857596,
0.0281800069,
-0.0099710384,
0.0057108458,
0.0263701901,
-0.0604348555,
0.0201707091,
0.002936864,
0.0001094104,
-0.0265314598,
0.0804218352,
0.0105349207,
-0.0009996593,
0.0318619087,
0.0273113381,
0.0088920817,
-0.0025303233,
0.0016057463,
-0.0091367103,
-0.0220483001,
0.0318372436,
-0.0313771106,
-0.0124097858,
0.0093610035,
0.0105960909,
0.0280632693,
0.0007306235,
0.0043042209,
-0.0431023613,
2.634e-7,
-0.0193811171,
0.0048158262,
0.0038944229,
-0.0192359742,
0.0345525779,
-0.0074547241,
-0.0218237881,
-0.012726414,
-0.014378326,
0.0217584949,
0.0289898571,
-0.0429657847,
0.1232129857,
0.0410114676,
-0.1287245899,
-0.0097446041,
-0.058255624,
-0.030795306,
-0.0719669685,
-0.0252394825,
0.0292003304,
0.0864045694,
0.0242794286,
-0.0694972277,
-0.0309977122,
-0.0031032176,
0.0139345555,
-0.0169426315,
-0.0081219934,
-0.0403221399,
0.0425511859,
-0.0154465158,
-0.0236520022,
0.0273573902,
-0.0515992418,
0.0632944182,
0.0102305515,
0.0269961543,
-0.0057958658,
0.0145220505,
0.0641992763,
0.017558245,
-0.0821027458,
-0.0210139677,
0.0468503572,
0.0170532782,
-0.015225363,
-0.0013388193,
0.0002377206,
-0.0380618721,
0.0017121616,
-0.0195769109,
-0.0263004247,
0.0072918893,
0.0085534249,
-0.0610686876,
-0.0251318607,
-0.0170469601,
0.0007171885,
0.0336174145,
-0.0590795279,
-0.0511427037,
-0.0034904575,
0.0059258477,
0.0531760715,
-0.0357196666,
0.0460071675,
2.172730034e-34,
0.0287430584,
-0.0406216681,
-0.0121940356,
-0.0350979641,
-0.0203127172,
-0.0387213007,
0.0870836303,
0.0202757828,
0.01730882,
-0.0163063537,
-0.0216303915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05785v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05785v3 | Limits of Transformer Language Models on Learning to Compose Algorithms | 2024-02-08T16:23:29 | 2024-05-25T11:09:28 | Jonathan Thomm, Aleksandar Terzic, Giacomo Camposampiero, Michael Hersche, Bernhard Schölkopf, Abbas Rahimi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We analyze the capabilities of Transformer language models in learning
compositional discrete tasks. To this end, we evaluate training LLaMA models
and prompting GPT-4 and Gemini on four tasks demanding to learn a composition
of several discrete sub-tasks. On both training LLaMA models from scratch and
prompting on GPT-4 and Gemini, we measure how well these models can reuse
primitives observable in the sub-tasks to learn the composition task. Our
results indicate that compositional learning in state-of-the-art Transformer
language models is highly sample inefficient: LLaMA requires more data samples
than relearning all sub-tasks from scratch to learn the compositional task;
in-context prompting with few samples is unreliable and fails at executing the
sub-tasks or correcting the errors in multi-round code generation. Further, by
leveraging complexity theory, we support these findings with a theoretical
analysis focused on the sample inefficiency of gradient descent in memorizing
feedforward models. | [
0.0127718542,
0.064220719,
-0.0170601569,
-0.0098180454,
-0.0312785804,
0.021852687,
-0.0279600322,
-0.0312713534,
-0.0368001349,
-0.0255431533,
-0.0282757618,
-0.0495818555,
0.0258148033,
-0.0037936573,
0.0241066758,
-0.0425394811,
0.0286026876,
-0.0666016936,
-0.0761885121,
-0.0161366407,
-0.0394419655,
-0.0080587091,
-0.0167147033,
0.0576005019,
0.0121680759,
-0.0183862559,
-0.0434213616,
-0.0211639367,
-0.0332127437,
0.0023323717,
0.0045050504,
0.0325911529,
0.0366164297,
0.0479447767,
0.0000019886,
-0.0325331353,
-0.009722013,
-0.0223611835,
-0.0238469709,
-0.0286593884,
0.033343181,
-0.0264127254,
-0.0166691579,
0.0397623815,
-0.0142596588,
-0.028683478,
0.0766602531,
0.0351824798,
0.0647206008,
0.0589752048,
0.0124814771,
-0.0073185666,
0.0237885155,
-0.0202885754,
0.0157666616,
0.0290230252,
0.0082341349,
-0.0194115881,
0.0277678389,
-0.013927374,
-0.0305785295,
0.0173488818,
0.0451016761,
0.0354411714,
-0.0425197072,
0.0577992387,
-0.0157784056,
-0.0091853319,
-0.0138988225,
0.0185496863,
-0.0319502652,
-0.0489921309,
0.002676157,
0.0047938116,
0.0017768102,
-0.0055298796,
-0.0490417518,
0.0557071008,
-0.0303074978,
0.0166155025,
0.0096546728,
-0.0142871663,
0.0239704661,
-0.0320637673,
-0.0371262841,
0.0669812113,
0.0026468488,
-0.0427280106,
-0.0053014597,
0.0034410472,
0.0408462845,
-0.0432279184,
-0.0141387023,
0.0699653774,
-0.0406111591,
0.0100742504,
-0.0524334908,
-0.0415620059,
-0.002814742,
0.0062116287,
0.0671686977,
0.0650898069,
-0.0019663849,
0.0070674731,
-0.0455321409,
0.0660799295,
-0.0044749081,
0.0012077828,
-0.0500845201,
0.0027956434,
-0.0721998215,
-0.0306439865,
-0.0645464361,
0.0828831717,
-0.0210437942,
0.0067135184,
-0.021243114,
0.0574677289,
-0.0027034525,
0.0323861316,
0.0285986569,
-0.0345798992,
-0.0916704908,
-0.0106047262,
0.0074705584,
-0.0060123676,
0.021161858,
0.0134073691,
0.0357440971,
-0.0525814146,
-0.0110131782,
-0.0149170421,
-0.0210368428,
-0.003796746,
0.0171274357,
0.0737469196,
-0.038123183,
-0.0247332118,
-0.0178199485,
-0.0073803491,
0.024892278,
-0.0554265939,
0.0350912921,
-0.0976706594,
0.0315927751,
-0.0109188631,
0.0142072411,
-0.0237411354,
0.0325996801,
0.0190941431,
0.0122243557,
0.0821296871,
0.0236424673,
0.0035153509,
0.0052513378,
0.0031639389,
-0.033756692,
0.103435792,
0.040789213,
0.0149432346,
-0.0345848426,
0.0009634722,
0.0302543528,
0.0373663232,
-0.0041989856,
-0.0010574262,
0.0309191477,
-0.0306537803,
0.0194096845,
0.0134609025,
0.0349291675,
0.0788838491,
-0.010526618,
0.0375930183,
0.0487421378,
0.0240718555,
0.0516180657,
0.0406999923,
0.0802364573,
0.0007608347,
0.0050004586,
0.0430147946,
-0.0611071289,
0.061772868,
-0.013324297,
0.0153864566,
-0.0316304378,
0.0450669602,
-0.0423224531,
-0.058033023,
0.0131782331,
-0.0361200459,
0.0105573637,
-0.0251044761,
0.0413346291,
0.0449958481,
-0.0931030512,
0.0446998253,
0.0023006529,
-0.0696757361,
-0.0197260417,
-0.0513243787,
0.0171846971,
0.013745415,
0.0167910103,
-0.0293290224,
-0.0245073065,
-0.0183144901,
0.0322668701,
-0.0028567542,
0.0028491807,
-0.0163506214,
0.0117480326,
-0.0463077128,
-0.0113654938,
-0.0276775155,
0.0259412825,
0.0171597209,
0.0259742029,
-0.041956719,
0.0038055333,
-0.0054341401,
-0.0189543106,
0.0406761654,
-0.0112472521,
-0.0386848412,
0.0038755219,
0.0262574125,
0.0305972751,
-0.0553598441,
0.0162692312,
0.0293937661,
0.0163427088,
-0.0481626503,
-0.0489230715,
0.0081723947,
-0.042589765,
-0.0727949962,
0.0053711645,
-0.0241809599,
0.02356603,
0.0354792401,
-0.0349384136,
-0.0497607663,
0.0219965857,
-0.0893860981,
0.0283503961,
0.0047118864,
0.0291119106,
0.0232290253,
-0.029205123,
0.0108884741,
0.0395530798,
-0.026919201,
0.0086064581,
-0.0020999028,
0.0133060068,
-0.00361559,
-0.0358743221,
-0.0289430451,
0.0108596859,
-0.0429462083,
0.0243037697,
-0.0289524086,
0.0027866215,
-0.012913459,
-0.0743858293,
-0.0607982688,
0.0042311144,
-0.0268282909,
0.0290455557,
-0.0079520997,
0.0520275868,
0.0228522792,
0.0126727354,
-0.023512857,
-0.0072822073,
-0.021807164,
0.0315492228,
0.022678839,
-0.0022882719,
-0.0550610572,
-0.0190358143,
-0.0183268227,
-0.0347593017,
0.0362058319,
-0.0351244211,
-0.0045975656,
-0.0504520833,
0.022375783,
0.0198086742,
0.023882024,
-0.0417304598,
-0.0366171263,
0.0242347624,
-0.0116291726,
0.1096512526,
0.0667999461,
-0.0209111683,
0.021034725,
0.0384412147,
-0.0086449301,
-0.0084903575,
0.0300042368,
-0.0388405025,
-0.0727888569,
-0.0019788896,
-0.0215201117,
0.0244131908,
0.103764154,
-0.0262585077,
0.0023275253,
-0.0706425607,
0.0065804594,
-0.0203823168,
0.0175884664,
0.0134752337,
-0.0110697094,
-0.0408479013,
0.0160771441,
-0.0294912364,
-0.0475979336,
0.0628439784,
-0.0287636518,
-0.0154487137,
-0.0371793248,
-0.0062049464,
-0.0456710868,
0.0456481688,
0.0194322746,
0.021501068,
0.0441491492,
-0.0354579873,
-0.10330154,
0.0402979925,
0.0085032806,
-0.0275943242,
0.0555909798,
-0.0406124517,
0.0045219916,
-0.0210662596,
-0.0578267537,
-0.03610342,
0.0543511994,
0.0076184105,
0.0486127958,
0.0208409298,
-0.0094296345,
-0.0181943122,
0.0146216489,
0.0240405835,
0.038924098,
0.0197016131,
-0.0374417268,
-0.0138483718,
-0.0014970839,
-0.0139082391,
0.0083211772,
-0.0138273453,
-0.0512998737,
0.0236547366,
-0.0063097416,
0.0778574124,
0.0253804214,
-0.0377065316,
0.0175515469,
0.0218525361,
-0.0290676933,
-0.0169473253,
0.0499978811,
0.0552566834,
-0.0608166903,
-0.023684999,
0.0599788912,
0.0196639579,
-0.0429318957,
0.0162887331,
-0.0026405,
-0.017437784,
0.0366913266,
0.0443992727,
-0.0724476948,
-0.0029096422,
0.0252968911,
0.0130144153,
-0.0276998077,
-0.0061435676,
-0.0202703457,
-0.1255530715,
0.0286292974,
0.0022399302,
-0.0508654267,
-0.026895741,
-0.037768092,
-0.0165949035,
-0.0056429636,
-0.0439420678,
0.0281133987,
-0.0287125316,
-0.0047003678,
0.0379381552,
-0.0252101831,
-0.0395457484,
-0.0134440549,
-0.0109614227,
0.0174253825,
0.0622477606,
0.0063173133,
-0.0101799509,
-0.0383197479,
0.0254762024,
-0.0270393491,
0.0101865474,
0.015343219,
0.0098707248,
0.0154320952,
-0.018269578,
0.0254790243,
0.0488437861,
-0.0486113802,
-0.0122157661,
-0.016158469,
0.0818290859,
0.0081370464,
-0.0276190508,
0.0065557682,
-0.0018191043,
0.0374695621,
0.0435993671,
0.033082772,
-0.0227408838,
-0.0138428425,
-0.0583432131,
0.0081450697,
-0.0626336709,
0.0092746913,
0.0149597535,
0.0387560166,
0.0036138021,
-0.0559234582,
-0.0006498265,
0.0326037407,
0.0571123958,
0.0198717229,
0.0096741375,
0.0330876932,
-0.0063931923,
-0.0801317841,
-0.0364642963,
-0.034666203,
0.0457506813,
-0.0619961433,
-0.027315747,
0.0240013041,
-0.0360530801,
-0.0143613974,
-0.0382807292,
-0.1513759792,
-0.0267343763,
-0.0088799102,
0.0905373916,
0.0236719027,
0.0096652675,
0.0086362474,
-0.0100151328,
0.0208864305,
0.0357022807,
-0.0111801205,
0.0292863119,
0.0625238344,
-0.0081808139,
0.0178883225,
0.0152548235,
-0.058300104,
0.003420803,
0.0136098582,
0.0296490528,
0.0157855395,
0.0424218662,
0.0728109851,
-0.0289983675,
-0.0078186085,
-0.0102929762,
0.0241382439,
-0.0047873417,
0.0351645723,
0.0418840013,
0.0021095194,
-0.0647129118,
0.0063570431,
0.0189393722,
0.0405026153,
0.0531957559,
-0.0144130029,
0.0135766529,
0.0407835469,
-0.0017067248,
0.0501587167,
0.0223947633,
0.0019899914,
0.0667115077,
0.0255558454,
-0.0294495896,
-0.0045166183,
0.0212420505,
0.015739616,
0.0111038433,
0.0432890356,
0.0169805847,
0.0504090153,
-0.0517852977,
0.0176460315,
-0.0469172783,
-0.0419219434,
-0.02375485,
-0.0146479802,
0.0445644855,
0.0043323254,
-0.0277905855,
-0.0532497838,
0.0231560972,
-0.0098256785,
0.0204572286,
-0.0362776257,
-0.0057440493,
0.0576088391,
0.0358942784,
0.0437584706,
-0.0129164681,
0.1255062521,
-0.0103289587,
0.0819794461,
-0.0004548886,
0.0569075905,
-0.0402799845,
-0.030385118,
0.031244589,
0.0151030058,
-0.0155616375,
-0.0359730795,
-0.026391102,
-0.0370504074,
0.0133264689,
-0.0085237706,
0.0199728552,
-0.0501959212,
0.0662823915,
0.0578501821,
0.0083290255,
0.0204289854,
-0.0148718422,
-0.0372716635,
0.0394253805,
-0.0100861853,
-0.0076132035,
-6.043465515e-33,
-0.0533994362,
-0.0208577458,
0.0455548614,
0.0529167056,
-0.0217250455,
-0.0011163293,
-0.0374222733,
-0.0024240208,
0.0107886139,
-0.0119330287,
-0.0004393633,
0.0069636148,
-0.0028449972,
0.0209131856,
0.0353632607,
0.0157637689,
0.0720583424,
-0.0254769195,
-0.0523974188,
0.0067760814,
-0.0098383296,
0.019598946,
0.0247861631,
-0.0076531102,
-0.0081878481,
0.0077761412,
0.0000810875,
0.0000732401,
-0.0247810688,
0.0711322501,
0.0051926612,
0.025689736,
0.0216377694,
-0.0571590737,
-0.0256352052,
0.0216788389,
-0.0507830121,
-0.0364375301,
0.028057849,
0.0024067517,
-0.0279611237,
-0.0713399425,
0.0429558568,
-0.0091618523,
-0.0321767405,
-0.041600056,
0.0026601073,
-0.0109946048,
-0.0390823334,
-0.0684580728,
-0.0870534331,
-0.0186620355,
0.0210345313,
-0.062999703,
0.0064288387,
0.0223964695,
-0.0281081125,
0.0015968803,
-0.0163663775,
0.0341670737,
0.0050035268,
0.0507121943,
0.0364549942,
0.0204050057,
0.0045628063,
-0.0023930429,
0.0293457042,
0.015014464,
-0.0412837416,
0.0239723846,
0.0142743094,
0.0482075214,
0.0243386701,
-0.0002902529,
0.0424304903,
0.0233163442,
-0.0254520867,
0.0121670421,
-0.0149603672,
0.0438954681,
0.027518807,
0.0172727052,
-0.0143418536,
-0.0340508185,
-0.0475379191,
-0.0148465149,
-0.0038048767,
-0.0218558833,
0.0341657102,
0.0474442802,
-0.0021244637,
-0.0285807867,
0.0243179128,
-0.0303946156,
0.0094797099,
-0.0163997281,
-0.0293591414,
0.0357203372,
-0.0128993439,
0.0052692932,
-0.0588896051,
-0.027314188,
0.0274491329,
0.0339522287,
0.0310175009,
0.0289930385,
0.0594383627,
0.0751445591,
-0.0765519813,
-0.0207103286,
-0.0648257062,
0.013533134,
0.012592786,
0.0760118663,
0.053492181,
-0.0067902245,
-0.0114398785,
-0.0013884928,
-0.0533375777,
-0.0749046504,
-0.0394019671,
0.040284358,
-0.0322004259,
0.0272582173,
-0.0275587942,
-0.0276667029,
-0.0618813783,
0.0353874229,
0.0252348576,
-0.0304043256,
-0.0358084813,
0.0226343777,
2.756e-7,
-0.008045461,
0.0151811577,
0.0052585346,
0.0225452445,
0.0108631551,
0.0080713816,
-0.0487931557,
0.0043059783,
-0.025903577,
0.0335889906,
0.0089916177,
0.0086515006,
0.0432613604,
0.0143575436,
-0.078731373,
-0.0109620141,
-0.0323006734,
0.0128601389,
-0.0410860889,
-0.0341622271,
0.0363850147,
0.0847579986,
-0.0054382808,
-0.0084757702,
-0.0008699243,
-0.0019942813,
0.0830943137,
-0.0040156557,
0.0232314486,
0.0042511839,
-0.0186331086,
0.0587012805,
-0.0194644891,
-0.0149301756,
-0.0149242459,
0.0009080999,
0.0052799964,
0.0415876731,
0.0211117342,
0.0059756874,
0.0574659519,
-0.0009225184,
-0.0176744442,
-0.0254301932,
0.0284493025,
-0.0904449001,
0.0010926137,
0.0062714596,
0.011071912,
0.0208508503,
-0.0279402509,
-0.0094754407,
0.0224368032,
-0.0014520122,
0.001073811,
0.0272477735,
0.0064674909,
-0.0442649089,
-0.0177713614,
0.0062037581,
-0.0123574557,
-0.0328913964,
-0.0591830574,
0.011862617,
0.0196614154,
-0.0368721634,
-0.0191349927,
2.814128425e-34,
0.0122606242,
-0.0368835591,
0.0368367545,
0.0544365384,
-0.0071565439,
-0.0355636664,
0.0000244033,
0.0426430032,
0.0082343481,
-0.0392281301,
-0.0201079082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05783v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05783v2 | Text-to-Code Generation with Modality-relative Pre-training | 2024-02-08T16:17:24 | 2024-02-12T10:44:18 | Fenia Christopoulou, Guchun Zhang, Gerasimos Lampouras | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large pre-trained language models have recently been expanded and applied to
programming language tasks with great success, often through further
pre-training of a strictly-natural language model--where training sequences
typically contain both natural and (linearised) programming language. Such
approaches effectively map both modalities of the sequence into the same
embedding space. However, programming language keywords (e.g. "while") often
have very strictly defined semantics. As such, transfer learning from their
natural language usage may not necessarily be beneficial to their code
application and vise versa. Assuming an already pre-trained language model, in
this work we investigate how sequence tokens can be adapted and represented
differently, depending on which modality they belong to, and to the ultimate
benefit of the downstream task. We experiment with separating embedding spaces
between modalities during further model pre-training with modality-relative
training objectives. We focus on text-to-code generation and observe consistent
improvements across two backbone models and two test sets, measuring pass@$k$
and a novel incremental variation. | [
0.0002261262,
0.107965529,
-0.0045556719,
-0.009832534,
-0.0063393833,
0.0065243263,
-0.036600776,
0.0018182492,
-0.0211994629,
-0.0470095687,
-0.0361748748,
0.0279424582,
-0.0111181969,
0.0546136163,
0.0758109242,
-0.0486597568,
0.0447374135,
-0.0275085624,
-0.0108208545,
0.0292594638,
0.0033117344,
0.0096514588,
0.018077258,
0.0637381822,
0.0176717602,
-0.0201071315,
-0.0236087423,
-0.0156450495,
-0.0025075423,
-0.0324619822,
-0.0016977584,
0.0430907123,
0.0249215178,
-0.0475470871,
0.0000019149,
-0.0157970134,
-0.0243530963,
-0.0010568094,
0.0218996983,
-0.0073418366,
0.0268696845,
0.0059905131,
-0.0050038691,
0.0283879526,
-0.0457357801,
-0.0216873828,
0.0680756494,
-0.0030529979,
0.0925011933,
0.0833982602,
0.0053408756,
0.032409966,
-0.0008859395,
-0.0149438363,
0.0396162234,
0.0042598508,
-0.0041093007,
0.0414454639,
0.0206592493,
-0.0002114576,
-0.0122107444,
0.0221250728,
0.0224751756,
-0.0038678588,
0.016372161,
0.0639355034,
-0.0002799642,
-0.0020238808,
-0.0282767471,
0.0494659171,
-0.0909819007,
-0.0526085347,
0.0369707122,
-0.0153939072,
0.0061088074,
-0.0319119804,
-0.0171935502,
0.0390353985,
0.0161312856,
0.0158657283,
0.0038301151,
-0.0135859326,
0.0172084495,
-0.0207674298,
-0.0380898602,
-0.0049340273,
0.0219107252,
-0.0355618633,
-0.0237748362,
0.0008952487,
-0.0137413843,
-0.0870334581,
0.0204977617,
0.051154796,
-0.0044986121,
0.0157655701,
-0.0898391306,
-0.0200470593,
0.0094656767,
-0.0320536457,
0.058924593,
0.0599620007,
-0.0176167879,
-0.0240922868,
-0.0529100746,
0.0281288754,
0.00626302,
0.0282859057,
-0.0531301759,
0.0553564988,
-0.0884444416,
-0.0112206554,
-0.0534324124,
0.0646659061,
-0.0269167367,
-0.0179768614,
-0.023778528,
0.0528341904,
0.0493375361,
0.0121426927,
-0.0029827172,
-0.0034414758,
-0.0837088823,
0.0213681962,
0.0331163593,
-0.0425244346,
-0.008624197,
-0.0086018983,
0.0133576961,
-0.0328722484,
-0.0163792856,
0.031315878,
-0.0231559947,
-0.0283214524,
-0.0027251493,
0.054440476,
-0.0345242657,
-0.0024469132,
-0.0301636774,
-0.04204835,
-0.0173647758,
-0.0169697721,
-0.0115115587,
-0.0557633229,
-0.0306248516,
0.0217899922,
-0.02020666,
-0.0563443825,
0.0040493668,
0.0037489815,
0.0121501824,
0.064692691,
-0.0183412321,
-0.0180035736,
-0.0211704802,
0.0017339099,
-0.0104139363,
0.040381074,
0.0413962305,
0.0088530844,
0.0008962381,
-0.0379171036,
-0.006664597,
0.0185092017,
0.0221425612,
-0.0285644848,
-0.0265987031,
0.0286439322,
0.0348627642,
0.003778894,
0.0510791354,
0.0209338218,
-0.0204857923,
0.0341761187,
0.0030147615,
0.054454919,
0.0513133854,
0.0747506618,
0.1106464341,
0.0162154995,
-0.0062889177,
0.0083203949,
-0.0644833669,
0.002248938,
-0.0094979052,
0.0577247217,
0.0043350053,
0.0469380617,
-0.0084175691,
-0.0494188927,
-0.0016375813,
-0.0253674164,
-0.0068305046,
-0.0558699369,
0.0101093436,
0.0270354375,
-0.0660889223,
0.0403718911,
-0.0109365415,
-0.0795731097,
0.0289862342,
-0.0427792408,
-0.0231589489,
0.0291436855,
-0.0028694582,
-0.0434730388,
-0.045235917,
-0.0074671279,
-0.0048586335,
-0.0084325066,
0.0079920245,
-0.0192873646,
0.0057782787,
-0.0361192599,
-0.0254538208,
-0.0394574441,
-0.0046319216,
0.0267760213,
-0.0100748288,
0.0151221724,
0.0543800071,
-0.0315125845,
-0.0137109375,
0.0613131486,
-0.0546687134,
0.0120823747,
-0.0015192454,
-0.0052373675,
0.0224385746,
-0.0314662196,
-0.0532695241,
0.0522000752,
0.0272583086,
-0.0257263817,
-0.0107765477,
0.0208930485,
-0.0888552442,
-0.0578137636,
0.0222615134,
-0.0237509757,
0.0235097893,
-0.0145589896,
-0.0261530932,
-0.0264864769,
0.0429049842,
-0.0158526599,
0.0448213965,
-0.0022359823,
0.0159318522,
0.0346710533,
-0.0196695384,
-0.0045680464,
0.0354036167,
-0.0113564879,
0.0077965721,
0.0312050357,
0.0202762894,
-0.0123012401,
-0.0141084613,
0.0281040519,
0.0309316386,
-0.0385741442,
0.0340921842,
0.0265048761,
0.0701774359,
-0.0275911875,
-0.0386733487,
-0.1053880006,
0.0139719034,
-0.015278752,
0.0466080271,
0.0363629833,
0.0177348778,
0.0028942532,
-0.0212261491,
-0.0572045296,
-0.0180593953,
0.0133575229,
-0.0112098167,
0.0344451629,
0.0055139582,
-0.0509158671,
-0.0422819294,
-0.0040845932,
-0.0223030075,
0.0634593368,
-0.0138394311,
-0.0123347854,
-0.0538795628,
0.0274847243,
-0.0145578152,
0.0087315664,
-0.0086387256,
-0.040267881,
0.0173889082,
-0.0290367659,
0.0720791295,
0.0309501495,
0.0209981371,
0.0204941966,
0.0321858376,
-0.0112131899,
-0.049942378,
0.008902506,
0.0041266186,
-0.0206752419,
-0.0110462187,
-0.0388725922,
0.0591727197,
0.1076878458,
0.0140575524,
0.0039457241,
-0.0724076182,
0.0131562157,
-0.0010427209,
-0.0230948348,
-0.0082890345,
-0.0114697972,
-0.0107898591,
0.0402186662,
-0.0213650167,
-0.0678543597,
0.0734756216,
-0.0278202202,
-0.0118560251,
-0.0297604091,
-0.018950142,
-0.0324681476,
0.015932478,
0.0025589222,
0.0264211074,
0.0402500071,
-0.0446108095,
-0.0532591008,
-0.0234698206,
-0.0238279495,
-0.0211611092,
0.0517254286,
-0.039324116,
0.0202654116,
-0.0020354339,
-0.0273382235,
-0.0520293154,
-0.0253297985,
0.0174986664,
0.0098394994,
0.022412939,
-0.0063491613,
0.0421704948,
0.0179781057,
-0.0277521461,
0.0584160201,
0.0009287178,
-0.0214749761,
-0.0257685911,
0.0080584632,
-0.0430423692,
-0.026086593,
-0.0337388217,
-0.0106437877,
-0.0051944656,
-0.0018713702,
0.0696396232,
0.0144874202,
-0.0581839569,
0.0227371026,
0.0159051437,
-0.0482638367,
-0.055474367,
0.0650505796,
0.0518293008,
-0.0452456065,
-0.0432101414,
0.0973204896,
0.03179067,
-0.0060721124,
0.0414682031,
0.0156918224,
0.0566172265,
0.0298593622,
0.0328021422,
-0.0517574437,
-0.0373983011,
-0.0059955837,
0.037781179,
0.005127267,
-0.0198391899,
-0.0458207317,
-0.0894184038,
-0.0124309864,
0.0087450659,
-0.0276008956,
-0.0142186861,
-0.0214522053,
-0.0354611538,
0.0135663636,
-0.038625598,
0.0112484889,
-0.0416553132,
0.0356093459,
0.0187538657,
0.003766973,
-0.0293125212,
-0.0093503231,
-0.0090282783,
0.0358151719,
0.085575141,
0.0197127871,
0.0174830239,
0.0057199849,
0.0314124376,
0.0112512484,
0.0334643722,
-0.0167076103,
0.0069107427,
-0.0080092764,
-0.0099575371,
0.0391539,
0.0396075211,
-0.0441749506,
-0.0343365893,
0.0183612984,
0.053413257,
0.0091968961,
-0.0182997491,
-0.030097032,
0.0108626494,
0.0353703983,
0.0307405405,
0.0552064255,
-0.0455337204,
-0.0400488041,
-0.0614941865,
0.0162639879,
-0.0401758105,
-0.0533802956,
-0.0291254297,
-0.0187693778,
-0.0030964406,
-0.0884178802,
-0.0405556522,
0.025047563,
0.0697770864,
0.0098215379,
-0.0092948247,
0.0096635856,
-0.0276068319,
-0.0748570412,
0.0370057896,
-0.0216357913,
-0.0108714886,
-0.0687820837,
-0.0206526555,
0.001717388,
-0.0645819381,
-0.0354993716,
-0.0442513339,
-0.0744938776,
-0.0461643152,
-0.0425754078,
0.098528266,
0.0131884217,
0.0623198301,
-0.0030811678,
-0.0071722986,
0.0232707895,
0.0622252934,
-0.0570707358,
-0.0258612148,
0.0744907334,
-0.0077209589,
0.0200400408,
0.0069767199,
-0.0586876981,
-0.00595024,
0.034139622,
0.0264715143,
0.0255253464,
-0.0137588587,
0.0437303297,
0.0032874129,
0.0241715349,
0.0026308626,
-0.0366926454,
-0.0050099278,
-0.0212077759,
0.0129467677,
-0.0308338609,
-0.0686519817,
0.0394641683,
0.0226677768,
0.0264635738,
0.0406372063,
0.0261587929,
-0.0429730378,
0.0571312308,
0.016647514,
0.0594187789,
0.018212134,
0.0592759438,
0.0557053499,
-0.0047620796,
-0.0290186703,
0.0131615065,
-0.0079712886,
0.0244502369,
-0.0535374843,
0.0354831442,
0.0144791091,
0.0415351689,
-0.0014684546,
0.0386511311,
-0.0517343245,
-0.0163313597,
-0.0572705418,
-0.0018186721,
0.0246010423,
0.0249704383,
0.0358352475,
-0.0362590551,
0.0384881757,
-0.0107888496,
0.0863767639,
0.0145087354,
-0.0427634753,
0.0229830705,
0.0050128708,
-0.0112075377,
-0.0351099521,
0.0847200826,
-0.0010236254,
0.0083891321,
0.0081006121,
-0.0227670036,
-0.0543876253,
-0.0015906695,
0.0765505508,
-0.016710056,
-0.0195995681,
-0.0024480852,
-0.0231706668,
-0.0673128068,
0.0034869483,
0.0237877574,
-0.0020129229,
0.0044510094,
0.031157475,
0.0661068186,
-0.0120519716,
0.0009835246,
-0.0178028867,
0.0295354091,
0.0425927602,
-0.0480132215,
-0.033884909,
-5.600493694e-33,
-0.0457883105,
-0.0133386608,
-0.0014148022,
-0.0352900289,
-0.0087573938,
0.0029349683,
-0.0457531139,
0.0030760709,
0.0343443081,
-0.0457872935,
0.0140539231,
-0.0050520771,
-0.0014500573,
0.0025108524,
0.014584925,
0.0211453326,
0.0614108033,
0.0024344728,
-0.0611888841,
0.0563309826,
-0.0312007442,
0.0352306552,
0.0554787479,
-0.0358034447,
0.0105241816,
0.0079314616,
0.0088997902,
-0.0239980891,
0.0363019332,
0.0520348959,
-0.005806658,
-0.0023444814,
-0.0028698165,
-0.0246879533,
-0.0800572559,
0.0068978909,
-0.0261895005,
-0.0307179689,
0.0397287309,
-0.0137760052,
-0.0164900832,
-0.0612750091,
0.0607028268,
-0.0396297835,
-0.0215283763,
0.0050417073,
0.0414494574,
0.008625892,
-0.0074672629,
-0.016961934,
-0.085240528,
0.0233417302,
-0.0474529415,
-0.0323474482,
0.0138692046,
0.0322814211,
-0.0150102153,
0.0061520939,
0.0327768102,
0.0077324901,
0.0278362725,
0.0703294277,
0.0615057759,
0.0419454724,
0.0137707628,
0.02283944,
0.0377777815,
-0.0229201447,
-0.013039168,
0.0395937078,
0.0405488275,
0.0411201604,
0.0135354493,
0.0210640114,
0.0591829121,
0.0170065649,
-0.0097355405,
-0.0028801875,
-0.0203781296,
0.0067642047,
0.0177547168,
0.0322474577,
0.0097465552,
-0.0114436336,
-0.06379316,
-0.0518752337,
-0.0091066165,
-0.0677563548,
0.068252109,
-0.0044631767,
-0.0322720483,
0.0040740329,
0.0438358597,
-0.0055057169,
-0.0334005766,
0.0503529832,
-0.0400823876,
0.0248277001,
-0.024003597,
0.0374492705,
-0.0696006417,
-0.0419264138,
0.0628950149,
-0.0272132866,
0.0626161546,
0.012944188,
0.0144761233,
0.034684673,
-0.0463250019,
-0.0015058642,
-0.0252615269,
-0.011536099,
0.0157717112,
0.0552976876,
0.0677627996,
-0.0220312588,
-0.0152826896,
0.0635564923,
-0.0152427293,
-0.0571303256,
-0.0352319591,
-0.0066218991,
0.0157016534,
0.0526920073,
-0.0258111339,
-0.0083755106,
-0.0605848879,
0.0271354523,
0.0189465042,
-0.0362027138,
-0.0407554284,
0.0205456372,
2.607e-7,
0.0267092567,
0.0044938195,
0.0337299444,
0.0367621854,
-0.0190557279,
0.0391430072,
-0.0403504297,
0.040804673,
0.0228334889,
-0.0066539939,
-0.0213449281,
0.0063509862,
0.013938725,
0.0165327024,
-0.0412359685,
0.0067533525,
-0.0270760935,
0.0372632593,
-0.0486698151,
0.0036857978,
0.0700365156,
0.0765388086,
-0.0374973603,
0.0296766292,
0.0153540224,
-0.0635994226,
0.0368937477,
-0.0162211079,
0.0075493325,
0.0217987001,
-0.0382882841,
0.0039726389,
-0.0177542605,
-0.0118525792,
-0.0203817543,
-0.017723009,
0.0380255058,
0.0723738372,
0.0054808781,
0.0361501053,
0.0188731235,
0.0036162576,
0.0058431937,
-0.0058980845,
0.0491180308,
-0.0721464083,
0.002607431,
-0.032051865,
-0.0242740083,
0.0111716781,
-0.0150946071,
-0.0302179996,
0.0006556405,
0.0315807797,
0.026707286,
0.0160636306,
-0.0264130384,
-0.0360540748,
-0.0423727185,
0.0060879551,
-0.0194671247,
-0.0256298352,
-0.0839977264,
0.041753415,
0.0234523546,
-0.0452566408,
-0.0165648721,
2.921454962e-34,
0.0066548926,
-0.0398317873,
0.0259798244,
0.0165575016,
0.0323138684,
-0.0200641956,
0.0178944282,
0.0256050825,
0.0355323777,
-0.0474377871,
-0.0565232858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05779v1 | Examining Gender and Racial Bias in Large Vision-Language Models Using a Novel Dataset of Parallel Images | 2024-02-08T16:11:23 | 2024-02-08T16:11:23 | Kathleen C. Fraser, Svetlana Kiritchenko | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.CV | Following on recent advances in large language models (LLMs) and subsequent
chat models, a new wave of large vision-language models (LVLMs) has emerged.
Such models can incorporate images as input in addition to text, and perform
tasks such as visual question answering, image captioning, story generation,
etc. Here, we examine potential gender and racial biases in such systems, based
on the perceived characteristics of the people in the input images. To
accomplish this, we present a new dataset PAIRS (PArallel Images for eveRyday
Scenarios). The PAIRS dataset contains sets of AI-generated images of people,
such that the images are highly similar in terms of background and visual
content, but differ along the dimensions of gender (man, woman) and race
(Black, white). By querying the LVLMs with such images, we observe significant
differences in the responses according to the perceived gender or race of the
person depicted. | [
0.0382892936,
0.0710491613,
-0.0390896536,
0.0564983748,
-0.0141359251,
0.0502765216,
0.0703866631,
-0.0102607235,
0.0256437529,
-0.0803618208,
-0.0340798348,
-0.0747846738,
0.0347519852,
0.018685434,
0.0258797202,
-0.0694945455,
-0.0016214653,
0.0032504089,
0.0089704897,
-0.0419258587,
0.0069192909,
0.0361210853,
0.0352312103,
0.0394053124,
-0.0323580243,
-0.0348603353,
0.0259028003,
0.0299830548,
0.0142496992,
0.0177885108,
-0.0043370584,
0.0434695855,
0.027538633,
0.0101523735,
0.000001612,
-0.0459187329,
0.0614927262,
0.0021850492,
0.0234825853,
-0.0240773875,
0.0315086842,
-0.0029064314,
-0.0143592898,
0.0073219277,
-0.0479227044,
-0.0145261381,
0.0643911287,
0.0452166423,
0.0556190424,
0.0179683268,
-0.0202282481,
-0.0170861147,
-0.0556323901,
-0.0048542824,
0.020378001,
-0.0122609101,
0.0428852066,
0.0046374975,
-0.0115307095,
-0.0362051725,
-0.0299825091,
0.0219830088,
0.017372068,
-0.000354724,
0.0058732643,
0.0566975698,
-0.0386169441,
-0.0781621486,
0.0011768637,
0.0879580453,
-0.0161449034,
0.0078170123,
-0.0102434373,
0.0092833927,
0.0065732854,
0.0093482872,
-0.0498722866,
0.0612401739,
0.0017972393,
0.013294532,
-0.0712863952,
-0.0274823438,
0.0189439841,
0.0398167297,
0.0011850182,
0.0215227921,
0.0203594957,
-0.0076382384,
-0.0262791347,
0.0237781666,
-0.0168497469,
-0.0741685554,
-0.00722695,
0.0020346823,
0.0140664298,
0.0087865358,
-0.0453087464,
-0.0126567921,
0.0022515841,
-0.0797099173,
0.0365985557,
0.024308756,
-0.0272033419,
0.040463306,
0.0104233725,
0.0768599361,
0.0105623864,
0.0123694241,
-0.030085491,
-0.0484906174,
0.0037321523,
-0.0112518463,
-0.0198508129,
-0.0194450039,
-0.0404404812,
-0.012711538,
-0.0447127596,
0.008075702,
-0.0638265461,
0.0079201218,
0.0055759959,
0.0473779961,
-0.0217036903,
0.0033746343,
-0.0359112024,
-0.0141034583,
-0.0065082996,
-0.0000289541,
-0.0436324552,
-0.1055829078,
0.0116742393,
0.0158523377,
0.0106335878,
-0.0370214097,
-0.0116027892,
0.0383799635,
-0.0027364455,
-0.0258213338,
-0.0205173343,
-0.0171545651,
0.0021496057,
-0.0708720535,
0.0322797149,
-0.0736736208,
0.0357253067,
0.0050606383,
0.0210802313,
-0.0240716916,
-0.011021154,
0.0486380123,
-0.0524790287,
0.1029270738,
0.0461620875,
0.0094850799,
0.0545228906,
0.0172855146,
0.0009145612,
0.0936630294,
0.0313917883,
0.0326900333,
0.0610942356,
-0.0070788404,
0.0105052739,
0.0419323333,
-0.0056490446,
0.0131354379,
-0.0628048405,
0.032254789,
-0.0061587128,
0.0303773899,
0.0548490807,
0.0389744863,
-0.001673078,
-0.0497519001,
0.0742543787,
0.1011998132,
0.0033917155,
0.0252582077,
0.052746959,
-0.0156140467,
0.0168165788,
0.0175522733,
-0.0733761936,
0.0576764829,
0.0098721804,
-0.0254026875,
-0.0168961007,
0.0766276121,
-0.0581078343,
-0.006518024,
-0.0000703691,
-0.0162372589,
0.0224853642,
0.0326982662,
0.0146018751,
0.0030320382,
0.0049985969,
0.0055085639,
0.0161709785,
-0.0475210883,
-0.018743949,
-0.0595050305,
0.0200567804,
0.0587562099,
-0.0126100779,
0.0213355068,
0.0219226293,
-0.0103577962,
0.0097793899,
0.0411201753,
0.0266222786,
0.0192256849,
0.0284200832,
-0.0495572612,
-0.0122216828,
0.0214224569,
0.0027764998,
0.0215152483,
0.0406635478,
0.034077201,
0.0326420069,
0.0273419768,
-0.0486832745,
0.0252644382,
-0.0108060231,
0.0206290223,
0.0146041522,
0.0208998583,
0.0053274026,
0.0048923446,
-0.0336045362,
-0.0123620732,
-0.002065768,
-0.0009103054,
-0.0010361008,
0.0539473295,
-0.0464108214,
-0.0192240179,
0.0345832333,
-0.0849644691,
-0.0599269718,
0.0548019148,
-0.0141879488,
0.0004536734,
0.0415478908,
-0.0266666189,
-0.0198807325,
-0.0416131467,
-0.0005126013,
0.0026552356,
0.04643609,
-0.0061394922,
0.030149458,
-0.0225722026,
-0.0299957376,
0.0134332553,
-0.0039664079,
-0.0218831301,
-0.0696004778,
-0.0342298448,
0.0198100582,
0.0327996612,
0.0094521157,
0.0001180319,
0.002833497,
-0.0455900542,
0.0273395851,
-0.0947846472,
-0.0317819454,
-0.0216550827,
-0.0634819418,
-0.0140792271,
0.0108407317,
-0.0246542152,
-0.0356157869,
-0.0403226055,
0.0485753231,
0.0104926424,
0.0437905006,
0.0267686304,
-0.0185517296,
0.0017753887,
-0.0291701667,
-0.0412047096,
0.0023396723,
0.091346994,
0.0426056534,
-0.0022119998,
-0.0266881771,
0.0277618896,
-0.0383959487,
0.0612131394,
-0.0014906065,
-0.0391275696,
0.0226474367,
0.009166711,
0.0489523932,
0.097858794,
0.0289733205,
0.0272987578,
0.0279042926,
0.0004662276,
-0.0233050641,
-0.0149239842,
0.0324229933,
0.0211368501,
0.0239504054,
-0.0979855508,
-0.0410938859,
0.0061228713,
-0.0060266731,
0.0010549688,
-0.059546791,
0.0643560663,
-0.0099901659,
-0.0876923054,
-0.0448591486,
-0.0085587977,
0.0074036843,
0.0420280434,
-0.0588472001,
-0.0844051018,
0.0405070819,
0.0031807083,
-0.0089236377,
0.03593475,
0.0084243603,
-0.0484863818,
0.0725308359,
0.0276475213,
0.0348179042,
-0.0200251564,
0.026735004,
-0.0618897527,
-0.0288821626,
-0.0032585284,
-0.0335005969,
0.0624841563,
-0.0402803198,
-0.0087857312,
-0.0185296349,
-0.0515676737,
-0.034227334,
-0.0289225262,
-0.0274966303,
-0.0172597282,
-0.0387388133,
-0.023177525,
-0.0143302726,
0.0198470671,
0.0056298128,
-0.0178335309,
-0.0214337111,
0.012714277,
0.0070065097,
0.0286575388,
0.0943594128,
0.0167275313,
0.0005301664,
-0.0378509834,
0.0191714186,
0.0460092202,
-0.0015230662,
0.0173330493,
-0.0415835157,
0.0181470644,
0.0243444312,
0.0409965739,
-0.0114215547,
-0.0032861235,
0.0485857353,
-0.0116202105,
0.0236290898,
0.1030310467,
0.0094523998,
-0.0779737979,
-0.0154820019,
-0.0017008346,
-0.0169691704,
0.02956146,
0.0059698592,
-0.0784286708,
0.0014980981,
-0.0030784328,
-0.0274211336,
-0.0347424038,
-0.0401368961,
-0.0526842028,
-0.1104503721,
0.0440209247,
0.0060840664,
-0.0231659096,
-0.0351374112,
0.0120595461,
-0.0024585819,
-0.0175747145,
0.0286285318,
-0.0199228562,
0.0022065761,
0.0018119054,
-0.0260515027,
0.0005987157,
-0.0090789162,
0.0481604859,
-0.0632939339,
0.0252669789,
0.032594759,
0.0497020707,
-0.0059484569,
-0.0412846506,
0.0163291879,
-0.0024715506,
0.0248092283,
-0.017426027,
0.0359874368,
-0.0603340529,
-0.0406925716,
-0.0345043689,
0.0295885019,
0.0245642588,
0.0005032957,
-0.0084951958,
-0.0038952983,
-0.0060876948,
-0.0288625471,
-0.0583378784,
0.0014564329,
-0.0000538929,
0.0673171133,
0.02217949,
-0.0508115776,
-0.0385138094,
-0.0319292434,
-0.0081087714,
-0.0055992017,
-0.0564496554,
0.0107305944,
0.0141955595,
-0.0088066114,
-0.0379534736,
-0.0443030298,
0.0322452821,
0.0045762784,
-0.0252042469,
-0.061047297,
0.016935356,
0.033481352,
-0.0663723275,
0.0500987731,
-0.0350292623,
0.050475806,
0.0201222096,
-0.0157626998,
0.0009955859,
-0.0480378196,
-0.0027966255,
0.0154745597,
-0.0982052013,
-0.0346433036,
0.0021435397,
0.0536693297,
0.0205853488,
0.0356983468,
0.0281837825,
-0.0809134766,
-0.0022900049,
0.0239554457,
0.0165708289,
0.038545873,
-0.0194778573,
0.0360669754,
-0.0023414744,
0.0434726402,
-0.0134971794,
0.0275854953,
0.0102553358,
-0.0426524729,
-0.0389699712,
-0.0517178029,
-0.0293120332,
0.0221252069,
0.005708931,
-0.019678086,
0.0190987047,
-0.0269679613,
-0.0108092902,
-0.0258283634,
-0.0077381781,
-0.0493384413,
-0.0404523499,
0.0134268934,
0.021441672,
-0.0209747087,
-0.02271327,
-0.0339427479,
0.0050109252,
-0.0466833636,
0.0012971216,
0.0312193632,
0.0143556278,
0.0056524803,
0.0215182342,
0.0106461579,
0.0299923997,
-0.0483758263,
0.0197122414,
0.0425033346,
0.0335641019,
0.0186896473,
-0.0194167309,
-0.0250450447,
0.0328210294,
-0.030807225,
-0.0422360301,
-0.0010828055,
0.0326464511,
0.0562823974,
-0.0124444626,
0.0372675881,
0.0110954987,
-0.0101261036,
0.0011117775,
0.002273564,
0.028770633,
-0.0103638135,
0.0828986391,
0.0113948602,
0.011640151,
0.0123157417,
0.0663734227,
0.0351758115,
0.019515397,
-0.0025979895,
-0.0594847426,
-0.013503137,
-0.0077455458,
0.0516435355,
-0.0328479148,
0.0077156648,
0.0223652348,
-0.047963798,
-0.0690059289,
-0.0081930151,
-0.0057785558,
0.0287919994,
0.0328250043,
0.0459756777,
0.0431025364,
-0.0035019065,
-0.0249221865,
-0.0110104401,
-0.0131034544,
-0.0470166244,
-0.0262810681,
0.0004495038,
-5.565625592e-33,
-0.0226547886,
-0.0421302915,
0.0020021596,
-0.0114169884,
-0.0393487252,
0.0036936889,
-0.0007901659,
-0.0216167159,
-0.0244266968,
0.0079322653,
0.0011727841,
0.0445070267,
0.0167935733,
0.0285493825,
-0.0142011838,
0.0186250787,
0.0521467216,
-0.0142405303,
0.0009518733,
-0.021512961,
-0.0127211474,
0.0122979116,
0.0149197467,
-0.0448733456,
0.0227365326,
-0.0194476135,
-0.0062764431,
0.0017054756,
0.0094103841,
0.0509891212,
-0.0421700291,
0.0556127764,
0.0452749319,
0.0118561285,
-0.0234660208,
0.0822044164,
-0.0450577624,
-0.01107476,
0.0109957857,
0.0547820888,
-0.0503866524,
-0.0078432811,
0.0163209792,
-0.0104531376,
-0.0217625685,
-0.0639242306,
0.0683979839,
-0.0194676351,
0.0343994796,
0.0450645015,
-0.0058941799,
-0.0006402943,
-0.0210896861,
0.0018248713,
0.0241870042,
0.0218123607,
-0.0100436239,
0.0288380701,
-0.0481388792,
0.0475152917,
0.0014941433,
-0.0323704518,
0.075118266,
0.0556885488,
0.0623919442,
0.0357342474,
0.0939271525,
0.0030654601,
-0.045146849,
-0.078809917,
0.0048506367,
0.0191078503,
0.0191727299,
0.0921775401,
0.0164914224,
0.0034457287,
-0.0594432577,
-0.0191424284,
-0.0127401035,
0.0421008058,
0.0288917758,
-0.0089657158,
-0.022493653,
-0.0090343626,
-0.0331624858,
-0.042500522,
-0.0413254909,
-0.0205533486,
0.030609997,
-0.0040477035,
-0.0046782256,
0.0407982692,
0.0361371562,
-0.0737533718,
-0.0054426007,
-0.0158514325,
-0.0171852168,
0.0085785035,
0.0321611017,
0.0069947676,
-0.0428232141,
0.0178303588,
0.047132995,
0.0417830013,
0.0130873136,
0.0250160303,
0.0052256263,
0.0112177664,
-0.0530960225,
-0.0092278766,
-0.0399843901,
0.0008112098,
-0.0030747461,
0.0247788504,
0.0113549801,
0.0267454106,
-0.0439446568,
0.0042503676,
0.0026474199,
-0.0185851194,
-0.0384128913,
-0.039918106,
-0.008738094,
0.0224159006,
-0.0390146337,
0.0064014867,
-0.0328794532,
0.0084368195,
0.0572496466,
-0.0483022183,
-0.013144155,
-0.0015295354,
2.199e-7,
-0.0324786939,
0.0216834731,
0.0165024344,
0.0416518673,
0.0485066921,
0.039876312,
0.0058009266,
0.0558613427,
0.0496356413,
-0.0147483526,
-0.0155486362,
0.0637528598,
0.0120069226,
-0.0012328689,
-0.0192216076,
0.0266802423,
-0.0781985968,
-0.0092272507,
-0.0189915765,
0.0106129115,
0.0347099937,
0.0824735984,
0.0232922379,
-0.0271553919,
0.0035047741,
-0.0389114842,
0.0702942908,
-0.0445112176,
-0.0086151846,
-0.0351680145,
-0.0267610997,
0.0242504999,
0.0046467786,
0.0584478676,
0.0126051996,
0.0034337612,
0.0303964484,
0.0049497047,
-0.0322298743,
0.0156549811,
-0.0214332454,
0.0209875666,
-0.0504901819,
-0.0736059994,
0.0869188309,
-0.0123769706,
-0.0648036525,
-0.056838531,
-0.0003715952,
-0.0105304522,
0.0730632842,
-0.0213658176,
-0.0270556137,
0.0113782603,
0.0445573144,
-0.0277805217,
-0.0137803769,
-0.0775811896,
-0.0056775352,
-0.0513651185,
-0.030331878,
-0.0551719777,
-0.0515184812,
0.0135873845,
0.0454359837,
-0.0127995554,
0.0043154587,
1.235976635e-34,
0.0031389587,
0.0331778228,
0.003566636,
-0.0144972038,
-0.0043401765,
-0.01402268,
-0.0406018682,
-0.0194134973,
0.0371060297,
-0.0545455031,
-0.002916408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07939v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07939v5 | UFO: A UI-Focused Agent for Windows OS Interaction | 2024-02-08T15:40:35 | 2024-05-23T05:18:58 | Chaoyun Zhang, Liqun Li, Shilin He, Xu Zhang, Bo Qiao, Si Qin, Minghua Ma, Yu Kang, Qingwei Lin, Saravan Rajmohan, Dongmei Zhang, Qi Zhang | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce UFO, an innovative UI-Focused agent to fulfill user requests
tailored to applications on Windows OS, harnessing the capabilities of
GPT-Vision. UFO employs a dual-agent framework to meticulously observe and
analyze the graphical user interface (GUI) and control information of Windows
applications. This enables the agent to seamlessly navigate and operate within
individual applications and across them to fulfill user requests, even when
spanning multiple applications. The framework incorporates a control
interaction module, facilitating action grounding without human intervention
and enabling fully automated execution. Consequently, UFO transforms arduous
and time-consuming processes into simple tasks achievable solely through
natural language commands. We conducted testing of UFO across 9 popular Windows
applications, encompassing a variety of scenarios reflective of users' daily
usage. The results, derived from both quantitative metrics and real-case
studies, underscore the superior effectiveness of UFO in fulfilling user
requests. To the best of our knowledge, UFO stands as the first UI agent
specifically tailored for task completion within the Windows OS environment.
The open-source code for UFO is available on https://github.com/microsoft/UFO. | [
0.0020111271,
0.0289674979,
-0.0048550987,
-0.0242060106,
-0.0349298604,
0.0098017771,
-0.0023984881,
0.0174649768,
0.0726166889,
-0.016148001,
-0.0185610782,
0.0012603505,
0.0219619647,
0.0218586475,
-0.0310777742,
-0.0988882408,
0.037122447,
-0.027062688,
-0.0260808188,
0.0484140478,
0.0052569932,
-0.010574772,
-0.034107931,
0.057657022,
-0.0358656347,
-0.0621612184,
-0.0413003899,
0.0472468734,
-0.0035141674,
0.048887223,
-0.0295838602,
0.0391698815,
0.0054800771,
0.0244176984,
0.0000020643,
-0.0673821792,
0.0444161296,
-0.0202711783,
0.0005289464,
0.0484387949,
0.0278861541,
0.0439202785,
-0.0078881821,
-0.0027700851,
-0.0141426222,
0.0581935793,
0.0418754667,
0.0577088892,
0.0412885919,
-0.0267454293,
-0.0121755637,
0.0823547468,
-0.0034824971,
0.0349363051,
0.0763959289,
-0.0259807594,
0.0101913363,
-0.0141010629,
0.0568461306,
-0.0569654256,
0.0122492788,
-0.0026939618,
-0.0057513546,
0.0069715441,
-0.0439470597,
0.0469005182,
-0.0221580435,
-0.0747812837,
-0.0470471829,
0.023421675,
-0.044293087,
0.0348166414,
0.0540251844,
0.0197511744,
-0.0078222863,
0.024114579,
-0.0222157519,
-0.0579223819,
-0.0307495147,
-0.0390093997,
-0.0331620909,
0.0095248502,
0.0045285104,
0.0157092698,
-0.0326642133,
0.0406247526,
0.0081180502,
-0.0227902476,
0.0363604017,
0.0270667616,
0.0256827679,
-0.0306549761,
0.0000688131,
0.0381161757,
-0.1279852688,
0.0006776611,
-0.0205618702,
0.0123431953,
0.0033018561,
0.0013131879,
0.0140580228,
0.0308647659,
-0.0384862125,
0.0248763803,
0.0318780839,
0.088859275,
-0.0248219799,
-0.0697375461,
-0.0045422027,
0.0075217495,
-0.0469597466,
-0.0166840684,
-0.0547078475,
0.0057566138,
-0.0433441624,
-0.0218422338,
0.0104818316,
0.0612021573,
-0.0128973685,
0.0340854153,
-0.0075648185,
0.0387998335,
-0.0393499769,
0.0088078268,
-0.0168417282,
-0.0270232204,
-0.0593968369,
-0.0122433174,
0.0210373569,
-0.0168808959,
0.0090219835,
0.0153410481,
0.0019763734,
0.0075747077,
-0.0056955409,
0.0406348035,
0.0069732075,
0.0249241889,
-0.0266526919,
-0.0619303435,
0.0376669243,
-0.0344140232,
-0.0643511415,
-0.0302687865,
0.0413630307,
-0.0036149109,
-0.0368513763,
0.0062768082,
-0.0123077128,
0.0456522778,
-0.0003920236,
0.0710860193,
0.0108275693,
0.005794866,
0.0377872698,
0.0307361446,
-0.0475651957,
-0.0007117103,
-0.0223743878,
0.1310457438,
0.0512417071,
-0.0048365286,
0.0800261647,
0.0337366909,
-0.0470941924,
-0.0016755511,
0.0617607124,
-0.0038143545,
-0.0132758701,
-0.0008007091,
-0.0360259376,
0.0134372171,
0.0141317658,
0.0367521457,
0.0548316166,
0.0765996054,
-0.0479960106,
-0.0249676649,
-0.0080392631,
0.0281998757,
-0.0167417359,
0.0148182828,
-0.0269204602,
0.0754522234,
0.020380903,
-0.0036798446,
-0.0134480204,
-0.0096966904,
-0.0331628695,
-0.0157369766,
0.0208093822,
-0.0097800968,
0.0292298496,
-0.0052502244,
0.0290681105,
-0.0083121378,
-0.0188339502,
-0.0254142992,
0.0009917101,
-0.0072058155,
-0.0483218618,
-0.0973005593,
0.0085648494,
0.0839500278,
0.0031467364,
-0.0117108366,
-0.0142390644,
-0.0076319552,
0.0209653005,
-0.0158400126,
0.0420123711,
-0.0137536423,
0.013306167,
0.0409208536,
-0.0248754956,
-0.0033620838,
0.0109899947,
0.0701524615,
-0.0215742122,
-0.0030525778,
-0.0101185534,
-0.0384526215,
0.0235270187,
0.0172606073,
0.0628851876,
-0.053023506,
-0.0012706236,
0.0440848432,
0.0081185577,
0.0142014157,
0.0160461329,
-0.0144051965,
0.0284490865,
0.0068968083,
0.0083638597,
0.0066947038,
0.0294862501,
0.0660309568,
0.0108347386,
0.0119357165,
-0.0062081115,
0.0444009975,
-0.0148922121,
-0.0316330492,
0.02709122,
0.0250740815,
0.0245455708,
-0.0096821627,
0.0030923653,
-0.0157401599,
-0.0431027301,
-0.0083063636,
0.0360602774,
0.0455193631,
-0.0275767446,
0.0618714057,
-0.0204765406,
0.0299900789,
-0.0073729698,
0.0171905197,
-0.0232734699,
-0.0203514379,
0.0019474439,
-0.0071115131,
-0.0125294067,
0.0072952011,
0.0067825611,
-0.1062285155,
0.0174250901,
-0.0466473289,
-0.0074715558,
0.0295738485,
0.0811304376,
-0.0220163651,
-0.0279647969,
0.0162578877,
0.0109454701,
0.0154807596,
-0.0173797198,
0.0386675708,
-0.013676865,
0.0097933905,
-0.0453929603,
0.0175231043,
-0.0162829533,
-0.0585434772,
0.0430104807,
-0.0445187986,
-0.04450804,
0.0014891002,
0.0169803593,
0.0331522264,
-0.0224759746,
0.0043714116,
0.0451399349,
-0.018695103,
0.0159885064,
0.0851785243,
-0.0257623512,
0.0355219133,
0.0552338958,
0.0007193016,
-0.0267251618,
0.0259320382,
0.0325231887,
0.012156127,
0.0043165563,
0.0111219734,
0.0930606127,
0.0252612177,
0.0042511527,
0.0156433582,
-0.0122446157,
0.0099258246,
-0.0194456298,
-0.0159408096,
-0.039484255,
0.0042321165,
-0.0562706254,
0.0438636988,
-0.0341757871,
-0.0681362003,
0.0421963967,
-0.0572929718,
-0.047436934,
0.0669977143,
-0.0447385721,
0.0073260712,
0.0592262931,
-0.0117612407,
-0.035182979,
0.0070598326,
-0.0694626346,
-0.0039728107,
0.0244225487,
0.0148584386,
-0.0191482175,
-0.0132806804,
-0.068513073,
0.0153604615,
-0.0142502869,
0.0021285887,
-0.0007521893,
-0.0156446993,
0.0047651567,
-0.0477234088,
-0.049799636,
-0.0281739831,
-0.0436750688,
0.0120592397,
0.0326436274,
0.0539517328,
-0.0010596152,
-0.0493851528,
-0.0018115293,
-0.0837696567,
0.0503731593,
0.036124602,
-0.1097629666,
0.0155495396,
-0.0051925303,
0.0389336087,
0.0423932262,
-0.0194849316,
0.0059882915,
-0.0020276301,
0.019833317,
-0.0204162057,
-0.0231108572,
0.0272594541,
0.0119702984,
-0.0387213938,
0.0473840311,
0.0680956542,
0.0625448227,
-0.031344831,
0.0019121958,
-0.0398863181,
0.0059023821,
0.0492779538,
0.0354399867,
-0.0506698005,
-0.0248863269,
-0.0140747419,
0.0445583761,
0.0356373154,
-0.0369562842,
0.0253815297,
0.0245735142,
0.0153184477,
-0.0284646172,
0.0302910395,
0.0157547258,
-0.0360939018,
0.0536910482,
-0.0050237342,
-0.0483012423,
0.0205465294,
-0.0110009648,
-0.0194058251,
-0.0212228019,
0.0082587451,
0.0193793699,
0.0467922948,
-0.0173477493,
-0.0520165637,
0.0960834324,
0.0137018804,
0.0076288725,
-0.0478057489,
-0.0463182442,
0.0401287749,
0.0189071689,
-0.0489081666,
0.0409072153,
-0.0127461553,
0.0042648762,
-0.0340392664,
0.0530484468,
-0.0520702079,
-0.0069237975,
0.0430537201,
0.0658594221,
-0.0418061912,
-0.0308705997,
-0.0362201184,
-0.0693308264,
0.0432458818,
0.0165333431,
-0.0358631909,
-0.0318790004,
-0.080671832,
-0.0289420933,
-0.0088836486,
0.0314794108,
-0.0725573748,
0.0170113053,
0.0165183842,
-0.0516775474,
-0.0316834822,
-0.0442318507,
0.0662767217,
0.0512742661,
-0.0123325316,
-0.025964357,
-0.0299011841,
0.0401014909,
-0.017915871,
0.0048894905,
0.031142557,
0.0216457322,
0.0281630345,
0.0128032342,
-0.0067479815,
-0.008782357,
0.0216140058,
0.0121518029,
0.0405196883,
-0.0238728318,
-0.0309212953,
0.0481404737,
0.0204872563,
0.0241697691,
-0.0031696428,
0.0248283129,
-0.0240224805,
-0.0269925334,
0.0034740111,
-0.0004507937,
0.0152317099,
-0.0391185507,
-0.0336166807,
-0.0076655345,
-0.0831458718,
-0.0403532274,
-0.0409466699,
-0.000186438,
-0.0129416538,
-0.0032299263,
0.0445240214,
0.0194776505,
0.0015982583,
-0.0428722054,
0.0493317582,
0.0074620377,
0.0173437912,
0.0335281342,
0.0052012047,
-0.0327263288,
0.0291651711,
-0.0632724985,
-0.0160605926,
0.0371157452,
-0.0185367987,
-0.050703194,
-0.0246161334,
-0.0660133734,
-0.0078908131,
-0.0608420037,
0.012346724,
0.0327100903,
0.0045574517,
0.0049102325,
0.0245418958,
0.0479561314,
0.0870983228,
-0.040515177,
0.019485563,
-0.0078415843,
0.0102585545,
-0.0149103934,
0.0251933001,
-0.0336843319,
-0.0281008985,
0.051590953,
0.0243763998,
0.0212469026,
0.0029542684,
-0.008105834,
-0.0467904434,
0.011773115,
-0.0279728435,
-0.0146410028,
0.0193149876,
-0.0023730733,
-0.0672480389,
0.0193908885,
0.0242664851,
-0.0395863801,
0.0300405994,
-0.052339863,
-0.0089935977,
-0.0124626225,
-0.0488748923,
-0.0727621317,
-0.0277039688,
-0.0088575268,
0.0197945237,
-0.0185114238,
-0.0334295593,
-0.0431583598,
-0.0299423318,
-0.04467199,
0.0166648999,
-0.0594512448,
-0.0775177926,
0.0391893275,
0.0607971363,
0.016904192,
-0.0025925573,
-0.0020045284,
-0.0386120901,
-0.0428291708,
0.0419718213,
-0.0519381575,
-5.185822633e-33,
-0.0044136327,
-0.0230794251,
0.024516942,
0.0768902823,
0.0232160278,
-0.0664053783,
-0.0030271513,
0.006636593,
0.0150312446,
-0.0132562062,
-0.024568487,
-0.0131103862,
0.0257798918,
-0.0543304533,
0.0210302398,
0.0626251176,
0.0287821032,
-0.0063736993,
-0.0402446054,
0.0308454838,
-0.0035761234,
-0.0063523529,
-0.0188565962,
-0.0982340276,
0.0353335105,
-0.0234440472,
0.0365152508,
0.0051208078,
-0.0104069067,
-0.0061971494,
-0.0091961501,
0.0407138355,
0.0212470312,
0.0333986208,
-0.0090568857,
0.0794795752,
-0.0230552088,
-0.0622854158,
0.0118426224,
0.0340691805,
-0.0417789407,
0.0111205541,
-0.0265456624,
0.0385360308,
0.0076222261,
0.0376921482,
0.0262455735,
0.0194734111,
-0.0048476327,
0.0230164267,
-0.0843302161,
-0.0107782464,
0.0389951877,
-0.0330528729,
-0.0019430582,
0.0623071343,
-0.0144259101,
-0.0233590193,
-0.0190111585,
-0.0351762474,
0.0014897136,
0.0108729461,
0.0354362167,
0.0548693761,
0.0192884076,
0.0005602797,
-0.0093038995,
0.0193244144,
-0.0108367745,
0.0168049671,
-0.0083913757,
0.0705780685,
-0.0034576273,
-0.0298441835,
-0.0204433035,
-0.0497641191,
0.0175557081,
0.0529199056,
0.0464519709,
0.0250445232,
-0.0218169093,
0.0186366402,
-0.0192673579,
0.0167895239,
0.0537454672,
0.0245353915,
-0.0334269702,
-0.0620331354,
0.0447384492,
0.0367490463,
-0.0184608959,
-0.050660383,
-0.0439366214,
0.0204607286,
0.027151376,
-0.0657415912,
0.0053629391,
0.0023873311,
-0.0211864989,
-0.032053683,
0.0364829823,
0.0014218733,
-0.03145504,
0.0268747676,
0.0680512637,
0.0004946448,
-0.0745597854,
0.044629328,
-0.0085532479,
0.0005672031,
-0.0062457067,
0.0179704521,
-0.014725388,
-0.0482556075,
0.024173595,
-0.0323393717,
-0.0121200439,
0.0236518364,
-0.0422982201,
-0.0921889096,
-0.044020962,
-0.0208687298,
-0.0094195958,
-0.0202786401,
-0.0546086617,
-0.0516071729,
-0.0526820794,
0.0151592623,
0.0433268249,
-0.0035476538,
-0.0006614017,
0.0156760123,
2.873e-7,
-0.037604101,
-0.0010835581,
-0.0052706571,
0.039199844,
-0.0027744754,
0.0368291587,
-0.01357341,
0.0525947884,
0.0071932431,
-0.0659331754,
0.0228066463,
-0.0295565184,
0.0136691239,
0.0399287492,
-0.06356024,
-0.0138757695,
0.0687754005,
0.0033668685,
-0.0510053895,
0.0269713476,
0.0581376739,
0.0208083,
0.0011043607,
-0.0146111362,
0.0881321728,
-0.0221329983,
-0.0239407737,
-0.0300907083,
0.0288451631,
-0.0333576761,
-0.0202534031,
0.0240905397,
0.0073643499,
0.0241643712,
-0.0487414077,
0.0150619149,
-0.047786396,
0.0492866859,
-0.0496169999,
-0.0428108983,
-0.0139793716,
-0.0232259277,
0.0391795598,
-0.0039707967,
0.0332429931,
-0.038815219,
-0.0000772491,
0.0310523324,
0.022857843,
0.0031563304,
-0.0567925535,
0.0092100576,
0.0041042664,
-0.0197316241,
-0.007512318,
0.0068139848,
-0.0279926918,
-0.0244760048,
0.0150830364,
0.0177609567,
-0.0247238036,
-0.0408744924,
-0.0391819552,
-0.0340724587,
-0.0099390494,
0.0115505271,
-0.02995372,
2.388424294e-34,
-0.0090288585,
0.0183957703,
0.0311305597,
0.023017982,
-0.006666916,
0.0740675405,
-0.0359040648,
0.0498145483,
0.0809486136,
0.0062893643,
-0.0230059698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05755v1 | SpiRit-LM: Interleaved Spoken and Written Language Model | 2024-02-08T15:39:32 | 2024-02-08T15:39:32 | Tu Anh Nguyen, Benjamin Muller, Bokai Yu, Marta R. Costa-jussa, Maha Elbayad, Sravya Popuri, Paul-Ambroise Duquenne, Robin Algayres, Ruslan Mavlyutov, Itai Gat, Gabriel Synnaeve, Juan Pino, Benoit Sagot, Emmanuel Dupoux | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | We introduce SPIRIT-LM, a foundation multimodal language model that freely
mixes text and speech. Our model is based on a pretrained text language model
that we extend to the speech modality by continuously training it on text and
speech units. Speech and text sequences are concatenated as a single set of
tokens, and trained with a word-level interleaving method using a small
automatically-curated speech-text parallel corpus. SPIRIT-LM comes in two
versions: a BASE version that uses speech semantic units and an EXPRESSIVE
version that models expressivity using pitch and style units in addition to the
semantic units. For both versions, the text is encoded with subword BPE tokens.
The resulting model displays both the semantic abilities of text models and the
expressive abilities of speech models. Additionally, we demonstrate that
SPIRIT-LM is able to learn new tasks in a few-shot fashion across modalities
(i.e. ASR, TTS, Speech Classification). | [
-0.0170925334,
0.0674188212,
-0.0016423524,
0.0238474067,
-0.0387185253,
0.0010972951,
-0.0091235349,
-0.0188346449,
-0.0560691506,
-0.0724341497,
-0.0779218823,
-0.0344476439,
0.0185410753,
0.0716229454,
0.0518661588,
-0.0717855692,
0.0292811096,
-0.0328761451,
0.0264097489,
0.0070683756,
0.0496111065,
0.0365193188,
-0.0302708857,
0.0261718929,
-0.0499137007,
-0.0139075452,
-0.0344232321,
0.0236411951,
-0.0126269571,
-0.0061679147,
-0.0138035221,
0.0149777681,
0.0854942724,
0.0046558594,
0.0000019478,
-0.0035327612,
0.0059543732,
-0.0022545834,
0.0039142752,
-0.0147654451,
0.087972872,
-0.027708983,
0.0094397254,
0.0425519906,
-0.0383886956,
-0.0523621775,
0.0388557576,
0.0552409329,
0.0530463308,
0.07819058,
-0.0170719121,
-0.0246632621,
0.0425096266,
-0.0296498016,
-0.0015897544,
0.0259114895,
-0.0237813573,
-0.0147994859,
-0.0092645595,
0.0075251278,
-0.035218671,
0.0559824854,
-0.0029342768,
0.0001352241,
-0.0082230931,
0.0224874672,
-0.0222189743,
-0.0209425874,
-0.0407461338,
0.0691414699,
-0.0156150926,
-0.0173615608,
0.0301447678,
-0.0036522306,
-0.0303804707,
-0.0187797043,
-0.0360468514,
0.041137863,
0.034098953,
0.0085250456,
-0.0166143533,
0.0399694741,
0.0418697074,
-0.0046268487,
0.021735698,
-0.0043860013,
0.0133541068,
-0.0121673364,
-0.0162728522,
-0.0413240716,
-0.0035202461,
-0.0397204012,
-0.0137679949,
0.0084939478,
-0.0056369989,
0.0304334089,
-0.0765644163,
-0.0330965482,
-0.0054253191,
-0.0101964567,
0.0453910306,
0.0197036881,
-0.0156288408,
0.018146826,
0.0073405779,
0.0255940165,
0.0132294549,
0.0248266011,
-0.0233172998,
0.001248217,
-0.0248171911,
-0.0367518291,
-0.0138134575,
0.0127455285,
-0.0590277091,
-0.0808597654,
-0.0023947491,
0.0255865771,
-0.0048598074,
-0.0110997763,
0.0269047227,
-0.0181640815,
-0.0252978969,
-0.0103453277,
-0.0066388254,
0.018827986,
0.0480129123,
0.0603059977,
0.0212478507,
-0.0317922086,
0.012971025,
0.0481884181,
0.009637624,
-0.0216676313,
0.0140933041,
0.0985385031,
-0.0408901609,
-0.0476696156,
-0.017598236,
-0.0400865264,
-0.0202305894,
-0.0653001145,
0.0056562135,
-0.0616864488,
0.0573053956,
-0.0094985645,
0.0046583219,
-0.0148784108,
0.022613585,
0.0141872764,
0.0252712835,
0.0879668072,
-0.013651018,
0.0228137169,
0.0203929227,
-0.0037016915,
0.0394164994,
0.0792998746,
0.0596457347,
0.017115172,
0.0185808465,
-0.0100299884,
-0.0271293707,
0.0449904911,
-0.0025227054,
-0.0104865069,
-0.0524684712,
-0.0480376668,
0.0482132211,
0.0306510925,
0.0419016741,
0.090925537,
-0.0183472484,
-0.0051681385,
0.0531969182,
0.0336514339,
0.0099462774,
-0.0158487111,
0.072472848,
0.0563809387,
0.013979055,
-0.0063303071,
-0.0297472328,
0.0137917893,
0.0184217077,
0.0117482999,
0.0647945479,
0.0297626406,
-0.0402433574,
-0.0333797485,
-0.0372036472,
-0.0589638315,
0.0243323185,
-0.0090496037,
0.0286768228,
0.0495090149,
-0.0735193565,
0.0483527333,
0.015776068,
-0.0511621125,
0.0240461528,
-0.0074169203,
0.0071710814,
0.0554262213,
0.0240941457,
-0.0245095976,
0.0441388264,
-0.0232046898,
0.0106263729,
0.0612554476,
0.0155823026,
-0.0027195897,
0.049986057,
-0.0713143945,
-0.0041209683,
-0.0197216142,
0.0007418427,
0.0071784481,
-0.0496921167,
0.0055251936,
0.0050016651,
-0.0224641301,
0.0027890005,
0.0337563828,
-0.0008537283,
-0.0093844524,
-0.0073166611,
-0.017225951,
0.0299894288,
0.0027089508,
-0.030884251,
0.022912059,
0.0494087003,
-0.0378243104,
-0.0439236946,
0.0459350273,
-0.060717307,
-0.056363795,
0.0237189922,
0.0021976789,
0.043941386,
0.0072436994,
-0.0080496185,
-0.0629971623,
0.0285034757,
-0.0486744866,
0.0559571125,
-0.0512978509,
0.0223015975,
0.0345585831,
-0.0014644695,
-0.0102732275,
0.0130783273,
-0.0061261412,
-0.0097273625,
-0.0069528008,
0.0062606935,
0.0078582838,
-0.0304347072,
-0.0350381769,
0.0338731743,
-0.0015796289,
0.0358703732,
-0.0248033591,
-0.021784056,
0.0200195853,
-0.0205212459,
-0.1394395977,
-0.0102145104,
-0.0001788882,
-0.00409623,
-0.0139685106,
0.0111932708,
0.015037802,
-0.0092795398,
-0.0324321277,
-0.0131170936,
0.0206636135,
-0.0023954173,
0.0107775647,
0.0112386718,
0.008390395,
-0.0280194636,
-0.0173268318,
-0.0104834875,
0.0637805611,
-0.0320589282,
0.0116323922,
-0.0094361724,
-0.0035528005,
-0.0076170866,
0.0346573517,
-0.0198766906,
-0.0530697443,
0.0000500805,
-0.0368751213,
0.0710291266,
0.0237752609,
0.0440765396,
0.0035298348,
0.0222958457,
-0.0021408945,
-0.0416580476,
0.0174692068,
0.0153600173,
0.0462656319,
-0.007054456,
-0.0077766958,
0.0143986419,
0.0760543272,
0.0542525873,
0.0473205931,
-0.0326350294,
0.0152088422,
-0.0036910956,
-0.0404100716,
0.0059768101,
0.0038583267,
-0.0493886024,
-0.0223156642,
-0.0252746493,
-0.042071119,
0.0228103232,
-0.0817115009,
-0.0353260413,
-0.0133266179,
-0.035338968,
-0.0543020219,
0.0570220053,
-0.013442602,
0.0203629304,
-0.0271451231,
-0.0181109775,
-0.0330550484,
0.0017962814,
0.0114608295,
-0.0313157961,
0.0261093602,
-0.0297903959,
0.0021596688,
-0.0005399265,
-0.0294009373,
-0.0118772862,
-0.0502175093,
-0.0385719948,
0.0167670213,
-0.0014178312,
-0.014613485,
-0.0106550772,
0.0134144668,
0.0297202524,
0.039105732,
-0.0156702269,
0.0295487121,
-0.035155233,
0.0124927452,
0.0455232635,
0.0227889698,
-0.0910082161,
-0.0329907648,
0.01538797,
0.0037691118,
0.0081870873,
0.0296178367,
-0.0443707332,
0.0099215098,
-0.0056556975,
0.0384662375,
-0.0366935097,
0.0126326624,
0.0386201255,
-0.0572741106,
0.0182886552,
0.1127317771,
0.0035279887,
0.0016387957,
-0.0182414781,
0.0265166517,
0.0287756212,
0.0288863219,
0.0047797509,
-0.0547195673,
-0.0732003525,
0.0251479875,
-0.0133795217,
0.0272052605,
0.0383794904,
-0.0286611952,
-0.0694809705,
-0.0081573008,
0.0217555221,
-0.0605326854,
-0.0211112965,
-0.0076099355,
-0.0315819234,
0.0024215051,
-0.0204735678,
0.0128750447,
-0.044746656,
-0.0188534819,
0.0151031706,
-0.0372774526,
-0.0367255136,
-0.0136015126,
-0.02760409,
0.0248960163,
0.0661341622,
0.0427912511,
-0.0250876527,
-0.0738387629,
0.0328837,
0.0046362472,
0.0125029385,
-0.012697855,
0.034679912,
-0.0500063114,
-0.019612059,
0.0131627014,
0.0372258052,
-0.0067520575,
-0.0222949442,
-0.0160658285,
0.045735985,
-0.0291962977,
0.0056435852,
-0.0343072265,
0.0173648931,
0.0337265097,
0.0546059571,
-0.0001091561,
-0.0921416357,
-0.0255287774,
-0.0047229119,
0.0233034045,
-0.0120166894,
-0.0318541229,
-0.010991226,
-0.0019413526,
0.0090372013,
-0.0718333423,
0.0173627399,
-0.0201179422,
0.0595599338,
0.0153370118,
0.0169719551,
-0.019830443,
-0.0272037107,
-0.0882909596,
0.0011685754,
0.0040408829,
0.0542368181,
-0.073508583,
-0.0233730935,
0.0500110611,
-0.0518365204,
-0.0065449518,
0.0014482468,
-0.0775367245,
-0.0469557978,
-0.0204905681,
0.0482160635,
0.012910963,
0.0387610942,
-0.0123120435,
-0.0476314463,
0.0303694904,
0.0271952804,
-0.0557450987,
0.0218898933,
0.0526211448,
0.0040056454,
-0.0195189677,
0.0098286588,
-0.0293510612,
0.0002616548,
-0.0056221946,
0.0216774698,
0.019825248,
0.0063915951,
-0.0053379927,
-0.0140036726,
0.0430310592,
0.0064290194,
-0.0126386276,
-0.042203173,
-0.0082133887,
-0.009808653,
-0.0036570323,
-0.075126633,
0.0151028233,
0.00068814,
0.0560065806,
-0.0051444564,
-0.0008846407,
-0.0051591774,
0.0154779218,
0.0247479361,
0.0294987801,
0.0319865197,
0.0173948482,
-0.0057594692,
0.0329619497,
-0.0065213921,
0.0409678705,
-0.0202194601,
-0.0131290797,
-0.0062702163,
0.0273238905,
-0.0142700793,
-0.0234767962,
-0.012836826,
0.0370275415,
-0.0343090035,
0.0077036209,
-0.022723807,
0.0161518641,
0.0156648196,
0.0285002552,
0.0127310166,
-0.0102455355,
0.010391864,
-0.0327519663,
0.0846282691,
-0.0200516731,
-0.0405860618,
0.0618219562,
0.0152057018,
-0.0487779602,
-0.0015972705,
0.0555751137,
0.0279058348,
0.0238327496,
-0.0136197433,
0.0286908597,
-0.0441403538,
-0.008601767,
0.065296337,
0.0622719936,
0.0003098,
0.0028684367,
-0.0263675265,
-0.0721224323,
0.0786081776,
0.0259180572,
-0.0265469346,
-0.0175692681,
0.0419282652,
0.0365687907,
-0.0113767656,
0.0155410115,
-0.0351822823,
-0.0251203068,
0.0205629729,
-0.0026949339,
0.0059981355,
-5.938768274e-33,
-0.0300769471,
-0.0051822346,
0.0146721592,
0.0080176275,
-0.0603091642,
0.0310303681,
-0.0061276844,
0.0060943775,
0.0261824895,
-0.0117750363,
0.0048530134,
0.0028118652,
0.0024759895,
0.0463503301,
-0.0115574803,
0.0315058976,
0.0539020337,
-0.0170655996,
-0.0069769961,
-0.0073816511,
0.0322840214,
0.0395049639,
0.0232770294,
-0.060434781,
-0.0244917162,
0.0116115231,
-0.0283291917,
-0.0027265886,
0.0024426456,
0.0779661834,
-0.0280851051,
0.0392832756,
-0.0070646573,
0.0175672546,
-0.0453033745,
0.0659903809,
-0.0490023308,
-0.002337575,
0.0365471393,
0.0347822271,
-0.0665085688,
-0.0169266202,
0.0328821577,
-0.055912219,
-0.006590805,
-0.0129848262,
0.0398022309,
-0.0041165007,
-0.0112544391,
-0.0586250611,
-0.0398272574,
0.020392498,
0.0226027407,
-0.0345769934,
0.0310855154,
0.0341857076,
0.0008848818,
-0.0129517075,
-0.0494802669,
0.0336077251,
-0.0595152304,
0.020018084,
0.0402724519,
0.0453954525,
-0.0039417185,
0.0784078538,
0.0234697871,
-0.0389499702,
0.0240067858,
0.0425656959,
0.0732002258,
0.0457666442,
-0.0045754691,
0.0520583913,
-0.0230628699,
-0.0134316357,
0.008143818,
-0.0075358483,
0.0506679974,
-0.0033964699,
0.0085339472,
0.0590213351,
-0.0139526604,
-0.0139740529,
-0.0719844326,
-0.0574983656,
-0.0168146342,
-0.0233166721,
0.0503614359,
0.0344578139,
0.019872915,
0.0095669804,
0.0610242747,
-0.0111284694,
-0.0245102178,
0.0050443853,
-0.0257669762,
0.0333420634,
-0.0209269933,
0.0316632688,
-0.0501995496,
-0.0564555712,
0.084208414,
0.0171026457,
0.0110297585,
-0.0042488733,
0.0173442699,
0.0803930983,
-0.0599534288,
-0.0102960514,
0.0098664286,
0.0156684108,
-0.0063761501,
0.0182351694,
0.0504117571,
-0.0004722401,
-0.049291797,
0.0394581892,
-0.053731408,
-0.0417439044,
-0.041113425,
-0.0586694889,
-0.0259911977,
0.0562845394,
-0.0370927677,
0.021910673,
-0.0233200509,
-0.067310296,
0.0093473997,
-0.0528452136,
0.0097823553,
0.0563250743,
2.666e-7,
-0.0086386949,
-0.0165242683,
0.0187392458,
0.0229255967,
0.0424431078,
0.0282726828,
-0.0422669463,
0.0405206569,
-0.0200259387,
-0.0010017864,
-0.0254968926,
-0.0042276285,
0.0909943059,
-0.0316667408,
-0.0992444828,
0.0151035488,
-0.0520403348,
0.0177778434,
-0.0596672185,
-0.0087038316,
0.0366097204,
0.1181272045,
0.0173084233,
-0.0110045811,
-0.0091829197,
-0.0259076841,
0.0742224976,
-0.0113647273,
-0.0450027324,
-0.0360359587,
-0.0588853434,
0.023784874,
-0.0240884647,
-0.0031921621,
-0.052385021,
0.0161557943,
0.0733852684,
0.0903044567,
-0.0102980835,
-0.0511933081,
0.0094904127,
0.0449501984,
-0.0652292296,
0.0408600904,
0.0829636082,
0.0056807334,
-0.0228018034,
-0.0470934026,
-0.019992765,
0.0058997516,
0.0014983237,
-0.0162859634,
-0.0696756393,
0.0335031711,
0.0397927612,
-0.0295054335,
-0.0265368372,
-0.0820595473,
-0.0329537913,
-0.0204738677,
-0.0637668222,
-0.0005345564,
-0.0547966734,
0.0017067114,
0.0156865753,
-0.0484271534,
-0.0300715566,
2.46644842e-34,
0.0448160842,
-0.0287372321,
0.0152268354,
0.0064459518,
0.0082739489,
-0.0004864336,
0.0297714695,
0.0170439817,
0.0256184731,
-0.0627671033,
-0.0194325447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05733v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05733v1 | TimeArena: Shaping Efficient Multitasking Language Agents in a Time-Aware Simulation | 2024-02-08T15:08:57 | 2024-02-08T15:08:57 | Yikai Zhang, Siyu Yuan, Caiyu Hu, Kyle Richardson, Yanghua Xiao, Jiangjie Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite remarkable advancements in emulating human-like behavior through
Large Language Models (LLMs), current textual simulations do not adequately
address the notion of time. To this end, we introduce TimeArena, a novel
textual simulated environment that incorporates complex temporal dynamics and
constraints that better reflect real-life planning scenarios. In TimeArena,
agents are asked to complete multiple tasks as soon as possible, allowing for
parallel processing to save time. We implement the dependency between actions,
the time duration for each action, and the occupancy of the agent and the
objects in the environment. TimeArena grounds to 30 real-world tasks in
cooking, household activities, and laboratory work. We conduct extensive
experiments with various state-of-the-art LLMs using TimeArena. Our findings
reveal that even the most powerful models, e.g., GPT-4, still lag behind humans
in effective multitasking, underscoring the need for enhanced temporal
awareness in the development of language agents. | [
0.029166935,
0.0032942176,
-0.0440033823,
-0.0064825616,
-0.0418682694,
-0.0055152057,
0.0475337692,
0.0143969087,
0.0165375695,
-0.0192857385,
-0.0146803865,
-0.0344500467,
-0.0192388296,
0.0098068761,
-0.0166056026,
-0.0399018899,
0.0602480806,
-0.0547673404,
0.0143075669,
0.011683411,
-0.0046262345,
-0.0027435711,
-0.0491257869,
0.0577728525,
-0.007375048,
-0.0509263985,
-0.0424917378,
-0.0388213247,
0.0397829972,
-0.0299736857,
0.0035530655,
0.0441762395,
0.0366382077,
0.0382568017,
0.0000021633,
-0.0042967056,
0.0275690798,
-0.0227650236,
-0.0111494595,
0.0177132245,
0.0779670626,
0.0256254245,
-0.0026557308,
0.0127774216,
-0.0572334602,
0.0217342377,
0.0300256293,
0.0019707589,
0.0241805818,
0.044576671,
-0.0212534294,
0.0648011118,
-0.0170831792,
-0.0046227528,
0.0240561645,
-0.0536526851,
-0.0077063679,
0.0197083615,
0.0914708972,
-0.0153157404,
0.0138502838,
0.0390595905,
0.0506428443,
-0.014916732,
-0.0275437217,
0.059023045,
-0.0266106762,
-0.0116219129,
-0.0520260781,
0.0421410725,
-0.0099578882,
-0.0419339575,
0.0120597566,
0.0004875086,
-0.0237703566,
-0.0099409651,
-0.048083622,
0.0058493265,
0.0110520553,
-0.0092413975,
0.018414652,
0.0498744398,
0.0126071386,
-0.0107096015,
0.0398166217,
0.0581545569,
0.0147848334,
-0.0374868326,
-0.0447783098,
0.0077146557,
0.0251431856,
-0.0607466027,
0.0296187568,
0.0622078441,
-0.0781345963,
0.0014657518,
-0.0664870515,
-0.0123585975,
0.024643762,
-0.0494798422,
0.0162318498,
0.0511645116,
0.0205012728,
0.0210596062,
0.0235184096,
0.0573279671,
-0.0300175492,
-0.0355950929,
-0.059219718,
-0.0035308425,
-0.0630499348,
-0.0190916248,
-0.0394575596,
-0.0156692322,
-0.0539769642,
-0.0462472029,
-0.0065185493,
0.0618983582,
-0.016674079,
-0.0288684666,
0.0137357917,
0.0076533793,
-0.0233252272,
0.0107839834,
-0.0432620086,
-0.0183218662,
-0.0370977111,
0.0222766399,
-0.0137060657,
-0.0571522601,
-0.0156028597,
-0.0009483675,
-0.0097913491,
-0.0391298719,
-0.0204214007,
0.0585927591,
-0.0441875495,
-0.0115062054,
-0.0091225412,
-0.0292033143,
-0.0018001419,
-0.0402380489,
-0.006148302,
-0.0480263643,
0.041161254,
-0.0162049625,
-0.0151135838,
0.0255426597,
-0.0069305198,
0.0091204196,
0.0185986385,
0.0539556444,
0.0360110104,
0.0442543514,
0.0358382985,
0.0107986797,
0.0267337933,
0.0568239316,
0.0623517931,
-0.0072358381,
-0.0232873857,
0.0273926705,
0.0356968828,
0.0840550587,
-0.0346924737,
0.0184951704,
-0.0066214926,
-0.0106463619,
-0.0003008378,
0.0479156971,
0.0330367312,
0.0330460742,
-0.0297284294,
0.0540525205,
0.0862129629,
0.0499648638,
-0.0401500314,
0.0130715771,
0.0770945624,
0.0238034669,
-0.0005181231,
-0.0260689426,
-0.039230898,
0.0741654113,
0.0099829789,
-0.0037678906,
-0.0615186617,
0.039403066,
-0.0268194117,
-0.003702698,
0.0163865648,
0.0137099959,
0.0550983697,
-0.0011699431,
0.015135943,
-0.0238846522,
-0.0671598762,
0.0261572599,
-0.0148753831,
-0.0192727055,
-0.0291390661,
-0.0336279757,
0.0145392036,
0.1531369537,
0.0231714826,
-0.0517576896,
-0.053500466,
0.0130320191,
0.0584504865,
0.058301378,
0.063983418,
-0.0171017684,
0.0008899097,
-0.0069412095,
-0.00659349,
-0.0184642393,
0.002665326,
0.0313590169,
0.0320543721,
0.0356255732,
-0.0247549769,
0.0352945887,
-0.0020272376,
0.0214629155,
-0.050635621,
-0.0161201339,
-0.0450896583,
-0.0068811625,
0.0021518313,
-0.0071052327,
-0.0308471192,
0.0004394084,
0.0206133872,
-0.0356663167,
0.0112494305,
0.0759470314,
-0.0552899949,
0.0118033998,
0.0250764191,
0.0243569054,
-0.0453921929,
0.0448139533,
0.0245287493,
-0.023683738,
0.0067179324,
0.0027987577,
0.060981255,
0.0184310321,
0.033705879,
-0.0367317572,
-0.0018540502,
-0.000934983,
0.0660385266,
0.0001757744,
-0.0078926729,
0.0361663848,
0.0340636969,
-0.0212027766,
-0.0379234813,
0.017386876,
-0.0007648746,
0.0238417815,
0.0134996111,
0.0073695779,
0.0405984595,
-0.0559850112,
-0.0468916968,
-0.11888735,
-0.0160520021,
0.0041381479,
0.0069344486,
0.0089409743,
-0.0161332749,
-0.0162160583,
0.0166544765,
-0.0125427665,
0.0431187712,
-0.0315503776,
0.0131925475,
0.0193041172,
-0.0229069963,
-0.0389493071,
-0.0623233058,
-0.0023823746,
-0.0317084901,
-0.0023089221,
0.002254395,
-0.0186134875,
0.0078905979,
0.0091868015,
0.0184019394,
0.0307609458,
0.012535423,
-0.0132676028,
0.0403841138,
-0.0097970236,
0.0900967866,
0.0321545936,
-0.0303777028,
0.0348211415,
0.0940612704,
-0.0653504878,
-0.0492052548,
0.0587451123,
0.0014305569,
0.0223695654,
-0.0433078259,
-0.0350855365,
-0.0090215895,
0.0644185394,
-0.005878971,
0.0262956079,
-0.0545359738,
0.0087508624,
-0.0447366908,
-0.0732377991,
0.0238914918,
0.0045850114,
-0.0705328435,
0.0069944388,
-0.0415547118,
-0.0002083762,
0.0337309353,
0.0120492866,
-0.0198514666,
-0.0139006544,
-0.0068082819,
0.0075422111,
0.1005116627,
-0.0046121725,
-0.0049759652,
0.0070899008,
0.0003333298,
-0.0341863781,
0.025818713,
0.0066994461,
-0.0125448601,
0.0382346064,
-0.0748260841,
-0.003588516,
-0.00421065,
-0.0261221528,
-0.0230425112,
-0.0272712763,
-0.044986818,
0.0097499266,
-0.0197426938,
-0.0230754074,
-0.0805980265,
-0.0105970437,
0.0035266085,
0.0586118698,
-0.0309510846,
-0.026913872,
-0.0296242498,
0.0024228627,
0.0733919814,
0.0230708402,
-0.0504223257,
-0.0240666885,
0.0356644168,
0.0224328823,
0.0651769787,
-0.013059983,
-0.026935773,
0.0119620375,
0.0176032279,
-0.007232096,
-0.0287292916,
0.0452699549,
0.0165041666,
-0.0482260287,
-0.0329953283,
0.1174422726,
0.039408043,
-0.0274110902,
0.0350127183,
-0.0723870099,
0.0085537136,
0.0275977347,
0.0410521254,
-0.0275517255,
-0.0209052395,
0.000091914,
-0.0440406688,
-0.0248837024,
-0.0296004042,
-0.0005465791,
-0.0678512007,
0.0108399745,
-0.0122750066,
-0.0540563799,
0.0582819879,
0.0099737979,
-0.0191004779,
-0.0121379932,
0.0412086062,
-0.0132180555,
0.0414167084,
-0.0165995844,
-0.0014153358,
-0.0168799218,
-0.0138798635,
0.0863459855,
-0.0078400802,
0.0803453773,
0.0197772272,
0.059980128,
-0.0347220339,
-0.0489652641,
-0.0078887315,
0.050866399,
0.0193638839,
-0.0064892918,
-0.0260917898,
-0.0000965201,
-0.0015309383,
-0.0074236444,
-0.0101418998,
-0.0266664028,
-0.0403417461,
0.0320786461,
0.1162397489,
-0.001919963,
-0.0225123093,
-0.0268357061,
-0.0236358102,
0.0549733192,
0.040499825,
-0.0270426702,
-0.0777535811,
-0.054016836,
-0.006139874,
-0.0681213737,
-0.0821884796,
-0.048624672,
-0.0361567363,
0.0031697704,
-0.001935167,
-0.0483994149,
-0.0511110723,
0.0394070186,
0.0097002313,
0.0159267671,
0.0123329582,
0.0171753876,
0.0088970633,
-0.025628075,
-0.0323879346,
0.0041959961,
0.0364752486,
0.0098944465,
-0.0349698327,
0.0189802926,
-0.0043507172,
0.0283371322,
0.0903549269,
-0.0971628353,
-0.0418476462,
-0.0014511094,
0.0316641368,
0.0205331687,
0.0058361329,
-0.0114266463,
-0.0089487107,
-0.0080466988,
-0.008789191,
-0.0525786132,
0.0384043641,
-0.0121058794,
0.0030896266,
0.0346664302,
0.0142942108,
-0.0505168997,
0.0289261658,
-0.0571219064,
0.0368235782,
-0.0593926534,
-0.0211363919,
0.0082182111,
-0.0174445286,
-0.0130386669,
-0.0050383722,
-0.0153572299,
-0.0256137624,
-0.0033117905,
-0.0669325218,
-0.0050112647,
-0.0355831496,
0.0035631792,
0.0050510922,
-0.0150506943,
0.0255937055,
0.0145994965,
0.0188284256,
-0.0329138599,
-0.0044434099,
-0.0132396761,
0.0012584504,
0.0228408426,
0.0180737805,
0.0428462848,
-0.0139255626,
-0.013061313,
-0.0219362527,
-0.0063324189,
0.0065045133,
0.029226575,
-0.0256693996,
-0.0069478424,
-0.0387568437,
0.0060414998,
-0.0561402291,
-0.0166540034,
0.0360242091,
0.0051874123,
0.0400593914,
-0.0158388168,
0.0898261368,
-0.0558535755,
0.0103159035,
-0.0154881692,
0.0218046978,
0.0110758077,
-0.0196944699,
-0.0146155264,
0.0287265014,
0.0031513672,
-0.0106034772,
0.0703530014,
-0.0032914663,
0.0567466579,
0.0514947623,
-0.0280490089,
-0.0389711633,
-0.0390397124,
-0.0250308271,
0.0046835854,
-0.0157497525,
-0.0399515294,
-0.0621567257,
-0.0197401997,
0.0148163391,
0.0434552915,
-0.0129514495,
-0.0643702075,
0.0283678062,
0.0279609598,
-0.0047349897,
-0.0418334827,
-0.0328692906,
-0.0097249178,
0.023791315,
-0.0170723442,
-0.0333188474,
-5.676041246e-33,
-0.0262187216,
-0.039988257,
0.0956888273,
-0.0148181291,
-0.0318246596,
-0.0051599117,
-0.0636443496,
-0.0069691418,
-0.005697534,
-0.0008912013,
-0.022316264,
0.0330119096,
0.0203969255,
-0.0414338857,
0.0620252341,
0.0157732777,
0.0238056574,
-0.0366856903,
-0.0017543858,
0.0065346477,
0.019984547,
-0.0160755832,
0.0136142308,
-0.0179435257,
0.0000362659,
-0.0010200236,
-0.0203663781,
-0.0039747357,
-0.0261062365,
0.0512580313,
-0.0500259474,
0.0386505276,
0.0197822694,
-0.0308595989,
-0.0150328213,
0.0520654991,
-0.0519840829,
-0.0538615212,
0.0059160297,
-0.000997675,
-0.0456877947,
-0.0516973995,
-0.0274658948,
0.0444680043,
-0.0310566779,
0.0122183701,
0.026180299,
-0.0095079644,
-0.0261678826,
0.0228887722,
-0.1051853523,
-0.0088544544,
-0.018528169,
-0.0400289036,
0.049182009,
0.0542776249,
0.0005840224,
-0.0678070411,
-0.0434995666,
0.0309801605,
-0.0169568639,
-0.0176959541,
0.0552485511,
0.0150785809,
0.0333820172,
0.0584184118,
0.0094999894,
0.0550041832,
-0.0031457772,
0.02668605,
0.0368542708,
0.0292911008,
-0.0024694125,
0.0204068217,
-0.001602113,
-0.0264415517,
-0.0015205627,
0.0151856858,
0.0569666363,
0.005691173,
0.0405016802,
0.0302973799,
-0.021615779,
0.0082528424,
0.0013899284,
0.0822040439,
-0.0145013975,
-0.0166722555,
0.028407814,
-0.0019429509,
0.0393922664,
-0.0163036659,
0.0209452864,
0.0160854124,
0.0113621503,
0.0057566124,
-0.031076381,
0.0371212512,
0.0035498529,
0.0250733737,
-0.0540171228,
-0.0347459055,
-0.0084259911,
0.0434242971,
0.0521558635,
0.0432402343,
0.0009515907,
0.0503795408,
-0.0340418443,
-0.0300322641,
-0.0254388303,
0.0239945799,
0.0691071749,
-0.0033117617,
0.0220445637,
-0.0564330481,
-0.0142386258,
0.0036781703,
0.0124496911,
-0.0923056901,
-0.0044872952,
0.0265085995,
-0.0004565294,
-0.0434764586,
0.0015307653,
0.0071562021,
-0.0926528871,
0.0606222935,
0.0482027456,
-0.0490782559,
-0.0188654158,
-0.0068754042,
2.775e-7,
-0.0118953148,
0.0513941646,
0.0031832838,
0.0456532352,
0.0554838404,
0.0100526791,
-0.0064462353,
0.0491963103,
-0.0478387512,
0.0194019098,
0.0500031635,
0.0395856462,
0.0395926423,
0.0166641381,
-0.0525116995,
-0.0289223809,
-0.0404238887,
0.0105690202,
-0.0470556878,
0.0014340243,
0.0230787974,
0.0260644201,
0.0485791229,
0.0037946906,
-0.0101914434,
-0.0353746489,
0.0386865512,
-0.0368453227,
0.0142879905,
0.0224205144,
-0.033839792,
-0.0036703832,
-0.0384347886,
-0.0024904807,
-0.0074163908,
-0.024452718,
-0.0097654797,
0.0670652688,
-0.0372282229,
-0.0107093789,
0.0116758607,
-0.0420363918,
-0.0275186487,
-0.0212945547,
0.0476056151,
-0.0131464303,
0.0007342789,
0.0207956266,
0.0459512882,
0.0008690489,
-0.0315922461,
-0.0060554924,
-0.0016620412,
-0.0084647452,
-0.0187494382,
-0.0067365994,
-0.0225396603,
-0.0347034968,
-0.0157593079,
0.0328423232,
-0.070542559,
-0.0379182585,
-0.0526323617,
0.0004006446,
0.0050994558,
-0.0564141534,
-0.001288521,
2.267722376e-34,
0.0051068435,
0.0331983082,
0.0188701637,
0.0659571961,
0.0163092203,
0.0267594401,
0.004970632,
0.0217799023,
0.0459510423,
-0.0466180183,
-0.0675191879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05706v1 | Unified Speech-Text Pretraining for Spoken Dialog Modeling | 2024-02-08T14:35:09 | 2024-02-08T14:35:09 | Heeseung Kim, Soonshin Seo, Kyeongseok Jeong, Ohsung Kwon, Jungwhan Kim, Jaehong Lee, Eunwoo Song, Myungwoo Oh, Sungroh Yoon, Kang Min Yoo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | While recent work shows promising results in expanding the capabilities of
large language models (LLM) to directly understand and synthesize speech, an
LLM-based strategy for modeling spoken dialogs remains elusive and calls for
further investigation. This work proposes an extensive speech-text LLM
framework, named the Unified Spoken Dialog Model (USDM), to generate coherent
spoken responses with organic prosodic features relevant to the given input
speech without relying on automatic speech recognition (ASR) or text-to-speech
(TTS) solutions. Our approach employs a multi-step speech-text inference scheme
that leverages chain-of-reasoning capabilities exhibited by the underlying LLM.
We also propose a generalized speech-text pretraining scheme that helps with
capturing cross-modal semantics. Automatic and human evaluations show that the
proposed approach is effective in generating natural-sounding spoken responses,
outperforming both prior and cascaded baselines. Detailed comparative studies
reveal that, despite the cascaded approach being stronger in individual
components, the joint speech-text modeling improves robustness against
recognition errors and speech quality. Demo is available at
https://unifiedsdm.github.io. | [
0.0218577553,
0.0963238031,
0.0152732683,
0.030928107,
-0.0084848134,
-0.0162410066,
0.0259030182,
-0.0197574291,
0.0071719131,
-0.0738545284,
-0.0499875881,
-0.033155486,
-0.012896874,
0.0622734725,
0.0188389327,
-0.0511448309,
0.0377292112,
-0.0982832387,
0.0001344506,
-0.0160144959,
0.0098564075,
0.0367165618,
-0.0345703773,
0.0186459366,
-0.0168226305,
-0.009775185,
-0.0235985275,
0.0124975722,
-0.0053146342,
-0.0125249671,
0.0044156718,
0.0214562491,
0.0418445431,
0.0218556672,
0.000002091,
-0.0443487614,
0.0148359556,
-0.0105376318,
-0.0324909687,
0.0110852029,
0.0147669706,
0.0276743341,
0.0090120286,
0.050528042,
-0.0106563363,
0.0026678764,
0.0076665957,
0.0615342408,
0.0467162393,
0.0796018243,
-0.0108725782,
-0.0307134222,
0.0350922123,
-0.0246433988,
-0.0323350318,
-0.0295565128,
-0.0236685686,
0.0018103664,
0.0080733616,
0.0140197724,
0.0288823023,
0.0329025574,
0.006081393,
-0.0167227536,
-0.0107270097,
0.0043062991,
-0.0137934079,
-0.0179255027,
-0.0467556752,
0.0915077701,
0.0371324643,
0.0117063532,
0.0284889787,
-0.0155383032,
-0.0401046649,
-0.0436672792,
-0.0261604246,
0.0472787917,
0.0090277437,
0.0125824027,
-0.001258969,
0.0425287448,
-0.004418612,
0.0163939241,
-0.0412044376,
0.0352981649,
0.0092285443,
-0.0145184612,
0.0195414145,
-0.015780367,
0.012996763,
-0.072390005,
0.0411520898,
0.037911877,
-0.0454876088,
0.0033911038,
-0.042211771,
0.0168303531,
-0.012551602,
-0.0292843264,
0.0157480501,
0.0384389125,
-0.0454843901,
0.0193267092,
0.0036934747,
0.0522321947,
-0.0311083458,
0.009127425,
-0.0291976798,
0.0022155484,
-0.0243986249,
0.0117958132,
-0.0180987306,
0.033867687,
-0.0622426234,
-0.0319210254,
-0.0087649589,
0.0275272541,
0.0295733102,
-0.0236733463,
0.0358490981,
0.0347754434,
-0.0289532635,
-0.0430190228,
-0.0440243892,
0.0542293936,
0.0008582216,
0.0550402924,
0.0192804709,
-0.049754072,
-0.0042684101,
0.0558911413,
0.0212577041,
-0.0086430116,
0.0379059725,
0.0652586445,
-0.0369508974,
0.0040526893,
-0.0365259834,
-0.0381447002,
-0.0425366461,
-0.0806769654,
-0.0053547868,
-0.0306271501,
0.0375346057,
-0.0098212725,
-0.0128998021,
-0.0065800305,
0.0213445164,
0.0014314081,
-0.0142500773,
0.0354626067,
-0.0144171659,
0.0184942335,
0.0326652229,
-0.001254949,
0.0022971984,
0.02987561,
0.0555058159,
0.0285831261,
0.0031380635,
-0.0059589562,
-0.0091753202,
0.0392175913,
0.0150380731,
-0.0029231729,
-0.0049887449,
0.0499293283,
-0.0512060672,
0.0287325662,
0.0514264964,
0.0554078408,
-0.042026218,
-0.0038925682,
0.0706702769,
0.0661524087,
0.0249712896,
0.0139715821,
0.0319304205,
0.0484179109,
0.0317447744,
-0.0189034157,
-0.0333050936,
-0.0078065316,
-0.0151727032,
0.0359980352,
0.0489660278,
0.0297808014,
-0.0440853722,
-0.0392468609,
0.0326373056,
-0.0299010444,
-0.0237178709,
0.0251742732,
0.0369215123,
0.0151772471,
-0.0587340631,
0.0363624319,
0.0128291929,
-0.0610346757,
0.0006468762,
-0.0395887047,
0.0192976613,
0.0569397248,
0.0296667255,
-0.0178136192,
-0.0551379174,
-0.0425177403,
0.0152409729,
0.0855164528,
0.0061319745,
0.0034968946,
0.0612103902,
-0.0618095733,
-0.0069829891,
-0.0143579124,
-0.0122466767,
0.0546123795,
-0.0298950225,
-0.0038778193,
0.0327126943,
0.0054240762,
0.0376534984,
0.0009418984,
-0.0199302081,
-0.0098706242,
0.0560792722,
-0.0100558624,
0.0665521473,
0.0451009534,
-0.0418881923,
0.0150976684,
0.0136312563,
-0.0249373112,
-0.018410068,
0.03513496,
-0.0866130292,
-0.0587492175,
0.0392672531,
0.0106727108,
0.0021960104,
0.0074456334,
-0.0229399372,
-0.0815408975,
0.0280298237,
-0.0131817525,
0.0204155669,
-0.0764887556,
0.0064289249,
0.0631741732,
-0.0057477816,
-0.0009500692,
0.0339770615,
0.0261042248,
-0.0345748365,
0.0596986227,
0.067388311,
0.0313801877,
-0.0611133203,
-0.0019607269,
0.0131853689,
-0.0321781263,
0.0289961565,
0.0012490313,
0.0110516828,
-0.0154332016,
-0.0278624967,
-0.0992273837,
0.0075205094,
0.004591709,
0.0240879394,
0.0114727728,
-0.0056966958,
-0.0183013771,
-0.0452754609,
-0.0386626273,
-0.0196663626,
0.0531540401,
-0.0374884605,
-0.0108284317,
-0.0074995016,
-0.0007016794,
-0.0326020941,
0.0383703895,
-0.004882881,
0.0290889591,
-0.0226090197,
0.0064475532,
-0.0591322482,
0.0084661487,
-0.0213997345,
0.0475509502,
-0.0143564213,
-0.0472321175,
0.0012580798,
0.0147965886,
0.0522950999,
0.0590520799,
0.0363661982,
-0.0304022785,
-0.0015670446,
-0.0312525406,
-0.0547809899,
0.0380335413,
-0.0019581963,
0.0124518424,
-0.0242215265,
-0.0083870394,
0.0188340899,
0.0630862787,
0.0339974947,
0.0453332476,
-0.0414823666,
-0.0077274092,
0.0407787338,
-0.0376784839,
-0.0037401076,
-0.0506669655,
-0.0445910133,
0.0417869873,
0.0022036727,
-0.0132040456,
0.0625516549,
-0.1090787277,
-0.0334639288,
-0.0534562841,
-0.0336177014,
-0.0393876657,
0.0462746434,
-0.0249283798,
-0.0009068443,
0.0269745234,
-0.0218373798,
-0.0302374233,
-0.0155859627,
0.0028484422,
-0.0504639745,
0.038552247,
-0.0369233862,
0.0057353773,
-0.0216819383,
-0.0397180207,
-0.0357036442,
-0.040705584,
-0.0620712154,
0.0043758471,
-0.0172907002,
-0.0158515461,
-0.0046842764,
0.0276926681,
0.0077509638,
0.0355490856,
-0.0123231541,
0.0312679857,
-0.0350128636,
0.0746959895,
0.0389413051,
0.0295415483,
-0.0156484656,
-0.0172638521,
0.0831403583,
0.010957893,
0.0504895002,
0.018307887,
-0.0395631008,
-0.0144993244,
0.0061310125,
0.0421673022,
-0.0136058358,
0.0196347833,
0.0424961299,
-0.0530565046,
-0.0027815804,
0.1231523901,
-0.0046525872,
0.0104995538,
-0.0291543659,
0.001837826,
0.0439864881,
0.0031464323,
0.0145991426,
-0.0736128837,
-0.0656450093,
0.0279478002,
0.0116164992,
0.0046367976,
0.0206349436,
-0.0057506976,
-0.0829676613,
0.0456988215,
0.0021481703,
-0.0212015919,
-0.0161966458,
-0.0115452399,
-0.0065906127,
0.0030007644,
0.0150254741,
0.008591447,
-0.022367673,
-0.0100625316,
0.0398825184,
-0.0546389632,
-0.0100458907,
0.036752522,
-0.0351717472,
0.0617454574,
0.0598368421,
0.0293349121,
0.030424593,
-0.0190962292,
0.0439768024,
-0.0279881582,
0.017458044,
0.0066981707,
0.0253688302,
-0.0110880099,
-0.0143622821,
-0.0195867661,
0.0468684137,
-0.0157158654,
-0.0289438386,
0.0250891615,
0.0266801342,
-0.0454698466,
-0.0104351668,
-0.0112632187,
0.0516884215,
0.0127942041,
0.0692538992,
0.0099588819,
-0.051880613,
-0.0583756678,
-0.0117710968,
0.0104372865,
-0.0380813293,
-0.0403632559,
0.0065848003,
0.0131612848,
-0.0087076845,
-0.0444008261,
-0.0260059312,
-0.0115644792,
0.0247743949,
-0.008476845,
-0.0063877129,
0.0235151015,
0.0035047722,
-0.0087435404,
0.0604166016,
-0.0281128548,
0.0375228673,
-0.0580873154,
0.0172089841,
0.0573478676,
-0.0599719025,
-0.0387810953,
0.0382799581,
-0.0506555066,
-0.0567834303,
-0.0442733727,
0.0445446484,
0.0178942401,
0.0643946454,
-0.0057432582,
-0.0172258373,
0.045737844,
0.0050996393,
-0.053855855,
-0.0120972684,
0.0743284449,
0.0564020872,
-0.0328640901,
0.0227391962,
-0.0324528068,
0.0445119031,
-0.0146019263,
0.0437939465,
-0.0124955699,
-0.110555388,
-0.0108831124,
0.0002476332,
0.052615948,
0.0214563683,
-0.0066032666,
-0.0510533266,
0.0536275394,
-0.012662081,
-0.0041965633,
-0.0734214336,
0.0063053635,
0.013462564,
-0.0191496331,
0.0058843633,
-0.0205124654,
-0.0461757109,
0.055698581,
0.0189090874,
0.0102938497,
0.0344665349,
0.0454788581,
-0.0055373739,
-0.0411435887,
-0.0305066891,
0.0245210417,
0.0074017704,
0.0242527854,
-0.0156562291,
0.0941151977,
-0.0043510781,
-0.0590654463,
0.0050881952,
-0.0013541873,
-0.0725936592,
-0.0417943038,
-0.0348971225,
0.0069906162,
0.0049462975,
0.0132936938,
0.0463065505,
-0.0083318278,
0.0198468883,
-0.0120342905,
0.0630648807,
-0.0152896829,
0.0005951852,
0.0316677392,
-0.0034988772,
-0.0285538137,
0.0140570058,
0.037559025,
0.0351459868,
0.0179309957,
0.0136425905,
0.0260415114,
-0.0470405705,
-0.0776877925,
-0.0017790361,
0.0170133058,
-0.0278014075,
-0.0191015378,
-0.0393226929,
-0.0419875905,
0.0096341455,
0.0273161568,
-0.0150200808,
-0.014862651,
0.0248994846,
0.039236404,
-0.0118285166,
0.0031717462,
0.0008646786,
-0.0008221126,
-0.0147230038,
-0.0119685885,
-0.017746903,
-6.387836136e-33,
-0.0363965742,
0.0040122508,
0.0146229668,
-0.0074926121,
-0.0626837462,
-0.0302319471,
-0.0435030125,
-0.013088325,
-0.0054346966,
-0.0245364755,
-0.0276062693,
0.0001649937,
0.0199786127,
0.0650510639,
-0.0514173098,
0.0091657927,
0.0633735955,
-0.0294505525,
-0.0107863788,
0.0336323753,
0.0039425264,
0.0276054423,
0.0125604514,
-0.067745842,
-0.0223105215,
-0.0222946145,
-0.0135422768,
0.0208001304,
0.0041659363,
0.0454677232,
-0.0347165614,
0.0113150822,
-0.0049596434,
-0.0039384775,
-0.0309708733,
0.0914196149,
-0.0593609996,
-0.0002573618,
0.0355794542,
-0.0051198481,
-0.0160950087,
-0.0018036453,
-0.0225468352,
-0.0056199054,
0.0177792832,
-0.0244121552,
0.0075165858,
-0.021123318,
0.0193507615,
-0.036739476,
-0.0362981297,
0.0379350111,
-0.0190563425,
-0.0481059253,
0.0084661236,
0.0875046998,
0.0097194603,
-0.0081142159,
-0.0018321635,
0.0231350586,
0.0079732258,
-0.0108528566,
0.0426544175,
0.0345004424,
-0.0170681011,
0.0581591129,
0.0241693407,
-0.0329691693,
-0.0525051318,
-0.042577222,
-0.0070268139,
0.05281974,
0.0141134933,
0.0769375786,
-0.0049645454,
0.0152340094,
-0.0701259971,
0.0060334723,
0.00822022,
0.0076463036,
0.0158788096,
0.01186019,
0.0154991858,
0.0070055206,
-0.0730050877,
-0.0060928962,
-0.0247778185,
-0.0224386882,
0.0590790622,
0.0286908019,
-0.0186380856,
-0.0385488309,
0.0666685551,
-0.0220315084,
0.0076734209,
0.0076330788,
-0.0091383383,
0.0111105479,
-0.0322603546,
0.0663163513,
-0.0474272333,
-0.0346004069,
0.0880344659,
0.0169273056,
0.0073264092,
-0.0187417176,
-0.025670344,
0.0084864451,
-0.0591320582,
0.0105007123,
-0.0264175478,
0.0431211814,
-0.0434500612,
0.0286975987,
0.0184280816,
0.0069081648,
-0.0127867805,
0.0744893998,
-0.0532810129,
-0.0040891883,
-0.0351131782,
-0.0465688519,
0.0305705648,
0.0471363962,
-0.0285788141,
0.0218490809,
-0.0099875145,
-0.0425250158,
0.0165152811,
-0.0295719262,
-0.0017834788,
0.0161768664,
2.766e-7,
-0.0156473257,
0.0082860645,
0.0484708883,
-0.0060580513,
0.0247401781,
0.0421330519,
-0.0158047993,
-0.0073873866,
0.0508348122,
-0.0310041904,
0.024675848,
0.002656176,
0.1093801111,
0.016190242,
-0.0987891108,
-0.0060388916,
-0.0876995549,
-0.0201738104,
-0.0540209897,
-0.0352026001,
0.0531041846,
0.0838591754,
-0.03737358,
-0.0179920848,
-0.0123159252,
-0.0261156503,
0.05366081,
-0.0368069895,
-0.0162641071,
0.0268092379,
0.0116862608,
-0.0400377139,
-0.0101959063,
0.0042186552,
-0.0242317226,
0.0535992831,
-0.0037162488,
0.0876846984,
0.0150893796,
-0.0698207915,
-0.0249171518,
0.0040159952,
0.0073720063,
-0.0251602735,
0.0740662664,
-0.0358600505,
0.0044610491,
-0.0544629619,
-0.0584212244,
-0.0167371444,
-0.0081151035,
-0.0261754654,
0.0011753771,
0.0214830507,
0.0176479537,
-0.0155226188,
0.0007926034,
-0.0820970163,
-0.0260586906,
0.0113122324,
-0.0792848617,
-0.0213958807,
-0.0637857467,
0.0121669034,
0.0496999063,
-0.0469682403,
0.0055733421,
2.307144369e-34,
0.0371661708,
-0.0277046207,
-0.0004259981,
0.0128912674,
0.0348924994,
-0.0111768181,
0.0130890245,
-0.0119055687,
0.038791161,
-0.0842339396,
-0.0163153056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05699v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05699v3 | Self-Alignment of Large Language Models via Monopolylogue-based Social Scene Simulation | 2024-02-08T14:21:03 | 2024-06-08T06:13:55 | Xianghe Pang, Shuo Tang, Rui Ye, Yuxin Xiong, Bolun Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Siheng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human values is imperative to
mitigate potential adverse effects resulting from their misuse. Drawing from
the sociological insight that acknowledging all parties' concerns is a key
factor in shaping human values, this paper proposes a novel direction to align
LLMs by themselves: social scene simulation. To achieve this, we present
MATRIX, a novel social scene simulator that emulates realistic scenes around a
user's input query, enabling the LLM to take social consequences into account
before responding. MATRIX serves as a virtual rehearsal space, akin to a
Monopolylogue, where the LLM performs diverse roles related to the query and
practice by itself. To inject this alignment, we fine-tune the LLM with
MATRIX-simulated data, ensuring adherence to human values without compromising
inference speed. We theoretically show that the LLM with MATRIX outperforms
Constitutional AI under mild assumptions. Finally, extensive experiments
validate that our method outperforms over 10 baselines across 4 benchmarks. As
evidenced by 875 user ratings, our tuned 13B-size LLM exceeds GPT-4 in aligning
with human values. See our project page at
https://shuotang123.github.io/MATRIX. | [
0.0534617268,
0.0821963251,
-0.0290437043,
0.0423187725,
-0.0480747521,
-0.0249555595,
-0.0100196516,
-0.00648596,
0.0299887918,
-0.0088259177,
-0.0411824882,
-0.0381084345,
-0.0307905953,
0.0240395311,
-0.0030647821,
-0.0302596018,
0.0524134524,
-0.0098281773,
0.0078145405,
-0.03441808,
0.0350341164,
0.0315266103,
0.0159767661,
0.0243484229,
-0.0366659202,
0.0317888744,
-0.0319111943,
0.0152095165,
0.038175948,
0.0166223738,
0.00765457,
0.0857759789,
0.0247901082,
0.0335943103,
0.0000020482,
-0.0493358597,
0.0046230527,
-0.0233040769,
0.0225447975,
0.0146264974,
0.0966575965,
0.0144208875,
-0.0043900688,
0.0220982656,
-0.0911262557,
0.0494641699,
0.0216536019,
0.0204709526,
0.064325735,
0.051476676,
-0.0061635505,
-0.0102741076,
-0.0201005898,
-0.0290613379,
-0.0359689705,
-0.0654536635,
0.0291453209,
0.0343864746,
0.0177961383,
0.0059040096,
-0.0087346993,
0.0362261869,
0.0044549294,
-0.02995109,
0.000412842,
0.0190416127,
-0.0719971284,
-0.0047110603,
-0.0007118226,
0.0923086256,
0.0316847824,
-0.0453527495,
0.034056779,
0.0008257564,
0.0362001769,
0.0187033657,
-0.0036968568,
0.0030929218,
0.0193844493,
0.0397030599,
0.0108452793,
0.0261659883,
0.0237530582,
0.0448790155,
-0.002186595,
0.0584059209,
0.0014763579,
-0.0438275374,
-0.0268013366,
-0.0205072928,
-0.0099897841,
-0.040645197,
0.0253525376,
0.0173377767,
-0.0643894672,
0.0373924859,
-0.0670876801,
0.0234562457,
0.0283929482,
-0.0664521307,
0.0097786859,
0.0349352434,
0.0508229285,
0.0667432249,
0.038573388,
0.0387297943,
-0.0238930546,
0.0433566533,
-0.0268918127,
-0.0141078485,
-0.000513933,
-0.0132521614,
-0.0489896573,
0.0131494757,
-0.0543217659,
-0.0202974193,
-0.0062560504,
0.0136146229,
-0.0460732318,
0.0177334994,
0.0025710876,
0.0293580201,
-0.0264656711,
-0.0330336951,
-0.0452282019,
0.0111161526,
-0.0480143428,
-0.0079209656,
-0.0044558193,
-0.0416504778,
0.0162705015,
-0.0217335653,
0.0095711416,
-0.0065274951,
0.0144355707,
0.0498839803,
-0.0193085521,
-0.0174245723,
0.0065391771,
-0.0133467903,
-0.0144972112,
-0.0700524226,
-0.0387342423,
-0.0635079965,
0.0769308507,
-0.0093082469,
-0.0486798696,
-0.0590022504,
0.0058663269,
0.0417585373,
-0.0262700152,
0.0768039152,
0.0082486626,
0.0467681848,
0.0341512039,
0.021939287,
0.0253555197,
0.0838991404,
0.0186648071,
0.0326800533,
0.0315965042,
-0.0211491007,
0.0437749922,
0.0738700926,
0.0108267441,
0.0245234966,
-0.0525629148,
0.0291336738,
0.0044102198,
0.0745415166,
0.0256712623,
0.0781410038,
-0.0157518741,
-0.0468161777,
0.0855848864,
0.0784247145,
-0.0296443887,
0.0219785385,
-0.0045415335,
0.0423721261,
-0.011498468,
-0.0014447168,
-0.0719842762,
0.0402762815,
-0.0082893055,
-0.0096295634,
-0.0019543427,
0.0451215468,
-0.0035869661,
-0.0203525051,
0.0172172785,
0.0160036236,
0.0381612331,
0.0137459077,
-0.0017462381,
-0.0278625302,
-0.0549022704,
0.006948093,
0.0256557651,
-0.0528368391,
-0.0077225482,
-0.035472773,
0.029132653,
0.1026046723,
0.0682303309,
-0.003872819,
-0.0043729898,
-0.0192579273,
0.0096541941,
0.0503846556,
0.0756901428,
-0.0179386754,
-0.0392497554,
-0.0686474368,
-0.0126853883,
0.0217090622,
0.0068259938,
0.0226480179,
0.0503117293,
-0.0082580606,
0.0060994388,
-0.0232221037,
-0.0098365527,
0.0158867985,
-0.047636766,
-0.0195369329,
-0.0503487624,
0.0084130103,
0.0227942336,
-0.0017758698,
-0.0021485775,
-0.0143282963,
0.0143738231,
0.016337378,
-0.0003057229,
-0.0162517466,
-0.0782783851,
0.0138541386,
0.0417417176,
-0.0145234605,
-0.0384438485,
0.0515945852,
-0.0271109957,
-0.0063590449,
0.0192405321,
-0.0124599542,
0.0119879721,
-0.0514930896,
-0.0014145238,
-0.0434372984,
0.0149674844,
-0.052212242,
0.0502565093,
0.0021928151,
-0.0338059105,
0.0103874439,
-0.0041460888,
0.0014544948,
-0.0427487977,
-0.0217684265,
-0.0087120486,
0.0020713753,
0.0506720282,
0.0479809381,
-0.0014284785,
-0.0341743603,
-0.0462727696,
-0.1086553261,
-0.020322701,
-0.0333499908,
-0.0290603973,
0.0199209657,
0.0020648097,
-0.0407934859,
-0.008264482,
-0.0466069505,
0.0037443889,
0.0188317038,
0.0031372847,
0.0420319401,
-0.0244380422,
-0.0457044803,
-0.0550917871,
0.0018268736,
-0.0390132144,
0.0074354694,
-0.0182382762,
0.0021024612,
-0.0016142533,
-0.001000993,
-0.0245158877,
0.0512123294,
-0.022576455,
-0.0394747481,
0.01689394,
-0.0028078319,
0.0539909452,
0.0742927566,
0.0475919321,
0.0333316624,
0.0468677729,
0.0191595592,
-0.0985448658,
0.0066611627,
-0.0289851613,
-0.0148473149,
-0.0642288625,
-0.0478643849,
0.0131889563,
0.0543017425,
-0.0030156937,
0.0119738253,
-0.0716508627,
0.0331761241,
-0.0043420885,
-0.0589618981,
-0.0242042784,
-0.023371242,
-0.0393815041,
0.0143529009,
-0.0244728979,
-0.0191790368,
0.0706206858,
-0.0080141593,
0.0271722674,
-0.0031766454,
-0.0109371915,
-0.0269659124,
0.0924854726,
0.0003607761,
0.0334715284,
-0.0324029326,
-0.027215844,
-0.0612431206,
-0.037586458,
0.0417160578,
-0.0565107465,
0.0610312484,
-0.0333930552,
0.0127587039,
0.010309645,
-0.0507736467,
-0.0265347548,
-0.0859361291,
-0.035538502,
-0.0014678359,
0.0142888166,
-0.0189179797,
0.0087510813,
-0.0087647215,
-0.0056103515,
0.0051867794,
-0.0240870155,
0.01093134,
-0.028714383,
-0.0077978498,
0.0856612772,
0.0216203667,
-0.0172298867,
-0.0000339452,
0.0164490901,
0.025737131,
0.0286569148,
-0.0193522107,
-0.033224903,
-0.0145811196,
0.0297879633,
-0.0008492679,
0.0131638777,
0.0189779419,
0.022115523,
-0.0141457422,
0.0061803125,
0.1163152456,
0.0132866958,
-0.0227972567,
0.0054634418,
-0.0328471921,
0.0544488579,
0.0342436694,
0.0508400537,
-0.070877552,
-0.0011358784,
-0.0008836226,
0.0125410557,
0.0138977692,
-0.0677336976,
0.017362114,
-0.1403143406,
0.0454196595,
0.0077802637,
-0.0158899575,
-0.032407973,
-0.0112801045,
0.0054269154,
-0.0508668907,
0.0467907079,
0.0182932578,
0.0114180148,
-0.0257308073,
-0.0022066806,
-0.0005065796,
-0.0104883276,
0.0330363438,
-0.0621749461,
0.0912981182,
0.0344378278,
0.0562748872,
-0.0107408734,
-0.0327048786,
0.0053355256,
0.0481030978,
-0.0229787268,
0.0339813866,
0.0081415828,
-0.0289950538,
-0.0136559932,
-0.0208077617,
0.0254168995,
-0.0000730481,
-0.0190082584,
-0.0150687909,
0.04892404,
-0.019516075,
-0.0263982601,
-0.0401396118,
0.0318796858,
0.0185824297,
0.0782795474,
0.0213397648,
-0.0341281481,
-0.0233807955,
-0.0058280164,
-0.0317677595,
-0.027818162,
-0.0680568218,
-0.01631267,
0.0183891058,
-0.0023671882,
-0.0217221398,
-0.0555853695,
0.0075215651,
0.0383373648,
0.0148656433,
-0.0373851284,
0.0167059805,
-0.0161865,
-0.012674056,
-0.0071781175,
-0.0814660937,
0.0277334638,
0.0148416031,
0.0216960423,
0.0229695495,
-0.024105968,
-0.0066479039,
0.0002636074,
-0.0154338656,
-0.0700562224,
0.0442271754,
0.0449848883,
0.0189196896,
0.0529534072,
-0.0192906596,
-0.0324036665,
0.0274895262,
0.0436357446,
-0.0300822333,
0.035363052,
-0.0257197712,
-0.0122374324,
-0.0111355539,
0.0383258052,
-0.0028543556,
0.015750045,
-0.0115099186,
0.0437940694,
-0.073679693,
-0.0489931181,
0.0392575599,
0.0094289593,
0.0180838816,
-0.0042272485,
0.0096496148,
-0.0317512862,
-0.0424065664,
-0.0508394763,
-0.0391762443,
0.0016872775,
-0.0346515253,
0.0436771251,
-0.0012417316,
-0.0064630867,
-0.0341704898,
-0.0294982214,
0.0314784981,
-0.0019547374,
-0.0323335491,
-0.0091592772,
-0.0018087862,
0.027297046,
-0.0087846406,
-0.0116412286,
0.0583918765,
0.0052213008,
0.0604675487,
-0.0095870113,
0.0374855995,
0.0324225686,
-0.0337970331,
-0.0099786473,
0.042596627,
-0.0248728823,
-0.0550538003,
-0.0307055656,
0.0388826244,
0.0188891031,
-0.0085932892,
0.0058395984,
-0.04214691,
-0.0001288232,
0.0058047385,
0.008467257,
-0.006113729,
-0.0623369068,
0.0474519916,
0.0301009901,
-0.0315379277,
0.0308633912,
0.0195464715,
0.0187531468,
0.0100091649,
0.0214442555,
-0.0132361082,
-0.0115128355,
-0.0413357988,
0.0160619505,
0.002702594,
-0.0319301598,
-0.040932592,
-0.0756574646,
-0.0445285887,
-0.0287246425,
0.0537865534,
-0.0206589755,
-0.0218227673,
0.0352929495,
0.0747541487,
-0.0198319405,
0.0130721675,
-0.0493654348,
0.0178484581,
-0.0397126935,
-0.0246021878,
-0.0337204337,
-6.354677645e-33,
-0.0388162881,
-0.0397346057,
0.0561926067,
-0.0289953034,
-0.0554743484,
-0.0480674841,
-0.0282533653,
0.0189338885,
-0.0231324863,
0.0204118453,
-0.0336186923,
0.0344689637,
0.0036377162,
-0.0094622876,
0.0133550782,
-0.0582446121,
0.0102384286,
-0.011256922,
-0.0299195852,
-0.0052165599,
-0.0072959503,
0.0029887368,
0.0096272994,
-0.0864697173,
-0.0144785745,
0.0044100937,
-0.0445640199,
0.0147120785,
-0.0322117805,
0.0360314138,
-0.0001760159,
0.0469371378,
0.0034443843,
-0.0169823095,
0.0145950606,
0.0622392111,
-0.0308959,
0.001466795,
0.0350768976,
0.0025492993,
-0.0175481401,
-0.0224406943,
0.0217080414,
-0.0346785001,
-0.0597766414,
0.0213468447,
0.0291697308,
-0.0126348203,
-0.0080178836,
0.0180473551,
-0.0608433001,
0.0171891656,
-0.0252876822,
-0.0136492793,
0.0002396067,
0.0130479969,
0.0177906901,
0.011632788,
-0.0348581709,
0.0257923435,
-0.0109887887,
0.0076183015,
0.0886814222,
0.0156913493,
0.0288201813,
0.0730029941,
0.0138155976,
0.0315532871,
-0.0413578339,
-0.0494844541,
0.0488082133,
0.0492820255,
0.0193327963,
0.0797888711,
-0.0434559733,
-0.0314620622,
-0.0129212812,
0.0128592951,
0.0045932946,
-0.0034361854,
0.0063639735,
0.021430986,
-0.0635365844,
-0.0344586596,
-0.035562925,
0.0051959399,
-0.017661877,
-0.0320615135,
0.0266667362,
-0.0073691877,
-0.0375184491,
0.0203382894,
0.0227860473,
-0.0594286434,
-0.0329474621,
0.0181873199,
-0.0187066998,
0.0063588228,
0.0052771168,
0.0507310033,
-0.0479376167,
-0.0216927174,
-0.0137541126,
-0.0024903466,
0.0045037968,
0.0444772914,
-0.0152237369,
0.0321125835,
-0.0490877591,
-0.0093682455,
-0.0065990109,
0.0258133374,
-0.0297607891,
-0.0538287982,
0.0253941901,
0.006355538,
0.0033890211,
0.0154815735,
0.0502423085,
0.0058237296,
-0.0142022073,
-0.0055930605,
-0.0175599363,
-0.0049389368,
0.0041442681,
0.0220693238,
-0.0563851818,
0.0288114548,
0.0437087715,
-0.0194823872,
-0.0060681626,
0.004876934,
2.739e-7,
0.0246624853,
0.0526853055,
0.0293465983,
0.0232433025,
-0.0219849832,
0.0725357831,
0.0183395445,
0.0890373439,
-0.0024459742,
-0.0556507446,
0.0720072091,
0.0557010174,
0.0377165675,
0.0234735403,
-0.0898460373,
0.0316107124,
-0.0862902105,
-0.0285985582,
-0.0576196238,
-0.0024144037,
0.0038076567,
0.0692848191,
0.0377640761,
0.0102176648,
-0.0066434206,
-0.0176750999,
0.0563473627,
-0.0528492481,
-0.051707156,
0.0469823405,
0.0118566304,
-0.0386566073,
-0.0092082089,
0.0079332655,
0.0081882048,
0.0415593497,
0.0058136769,
0.0803381652,
-0.0087749837,
-0.021006126,
-0.0198446903,
-0.0574211366,
-0.0106215104,
-0.0688132867,
0.0503555797,
-0.0255279895,
-0.0216240119,
-0.0337463617,
-0.0271865055,
-0.0042652492,
0.0058990046,
-0.0208613239,
-0.0364656486,
-0.0058662528,
0.0252444968,
0.005004351,
-0.0101340553,
-0.0517228171,
0.0033505594,
-0.0301913768,
-0.0326251723,
-0.0310807377,
-0.0075290217,
0.0510206632,
0.0135132689,
-0.0261015054,
0.0225403626,
2.413828977e-34,
0.0477816053,
0.0098027736,
0.0242799204,
-0.0013249425,
0.0558613949,
0.0305130035,
-0.0085738041,
0.030900564,
0.0413345583,
-0.0685935467,
0.0010262363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05672v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05672v1 | Multilingual E5 Text Embeddings: A Technical Report | 2024-02-08T13:47:50 | 2024-02-08T13:47:50 | Liang Wang, Nan Yang, Xiaolong Huang, Linjun Yang, Rangan Majumder, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | This technical report presents the training methodology and evaluation
results of the open-source multilingual E5 text embedding models, released in
mid-2023. Three embedding models of different sizes (small / base / large) are
provided, offering a balance between the inference efficiency and embedding
quality. The training procedure adheres to the English E5 model recipe,
involving contrastive pre-training on 1 billion multilingual text pairs,
followed by fine-tuning on a combination of labeled datasets. Additionally, we
introduce a new instruction-tuned embedding model, whose performance is on par
with state-of-the-art, English-only models of similar sizes. Information
regarding the model release can be found at
https://github.com/microsoft/unilm/tree/master/e5 . | [
0.0166970342,
0.022695357,
0.0097339535,
0.0835532174,
0.0025074694,
0.0169325415,
0.0195704121,
-0.0403230041,
0.0228153002,
-0.0422844291,
-0.0368182398,
-0.0095616737,
-0.0108002508,
0.0132313538,
0.0545145608,
-0.0557841547,
0.0382836014,
0.02073255,
-0.043369025,
-0.0254745539,
0.0179978199,
0.0190976113,
0.046202898,
0.0290865693,
0.0030166958,
-0.0057497579,
0.0026705363,
0.0201083943,
0.0080385935,
-0.0163468029,
0.0216760114,
0.0578093082,
0.0643254742,
0.0353230499,
0.0000020274,
0.012695997,
-0.0091090808,
0.0123480642,
0.0150068207,
0.0403520241,
0.0431808122,
-0.0559850298,
0.0261628088,
0.0175531935,
0.007371672,
-0.0192231741,
0.0556243174,
0.0468257554,
0.0400649793,
0.0759014264,
-0.0164020769,
-0.0757213458,
-0.010331342,
-0.0484208949,
-0.0325595178,
-0.0077243708,
-0.000301926,
-0.0337127447,
-0.0166132487,
0.0774603114,
-0.0331654027,
-0.0066808495,
0.0427114666,
0.0398952477,
-0.0329191387,
0.0462779962,
0.0270090364,
-0.0075423149,
-0.0008088781,
0.0686501414,
-0.0050313431,
0.0149849728,
-0.0143481102,
-0.0055269683,
-0.030633999,
-0.0373364389,
-0.0060509075,
-0.012195739,
0.0547112189,
0.0429291092,
0.063294068,
-0.0006232077,
0.0596782975,
0.0273436494,
-0.0013932817,
-0.0075478852,
0.0249414612,
-0.0398024619,
0.0221886467,
0.0049751922,
-0.0219611693,
0.0238139946,
0.021468496,
-0.0231627766,
0.0189297479,
0.0051756268,
-0.0627167448,
-0.0308000389,
0.0402869843,
-0.0600357987,
0.0040344135,
0.0471619628,
-0.0092973802,
0.055606965,
-0.0376426391,
0.0105485367,
-0.0294059254,
0.0083447918,
-0.0395648591,
-0.0260333866,
-0.008488155,
-0.0045955926,
0.003707651,
-0.0274710227,
-0.0326152295,
-0.041432444,
-0.0140879955,
0.0131052537,
0.0023061652,
0.0209846832,
-0.013406625,
-0.0136737684,
-0.0047526737,
0.0007310458,
0.0205314457,
0.0376774929,
-0.0525288358,
-0.0094011044,
-0.0487327315,
-0.0287725069,
-0.0292182602,
0.0334795192,
-0.0307475477,
-0.0313696079,
0.024506757,
0.0101717608,
0.008551375,
-0.04239114,
-0.0257849991,
-0.0087063797,
-0.0351337306,
-0.0402652137,
0.0187358521,
-0.0802452639,
0.0381386802,
-0.0199202951,
0.0179445483,
-0.0046311095,
0.0120212249,
0.013413148,
-0.0299273264,
0.0579820834,
0.0007069828,
-0.0323349759,
0.015739182,
0.0034344832,
0.0112378895,
0.0893664062,
0.0018696715,
-0.0064514717,
0.0409041271,
-0.0149031607,
-0.084554106,
0.047907792,
0.0188108925,
0.0241700839,
-0.0005020812,
-0.0061302735,
-0.0198232662,
0.0210083779,
0.0473541655,
0.0184452999,
-0.0189546011,
-0.0645155236,
0.040241234,
0.046191629,
0.035672076,
0.0152866729,
0.0396366641,
-0.0005811783,
-0.0244558696,
-0.0101905027,
-0.0085607721,
0.0190316122,
-0.0035583561,
-0.015401301,
0.0502370484,
0.0361418463,
-0.048459895,
-0.0074548107,
0.0034659149,
-0.0505314544,
0.0387087539,
-0.0039443979,
0.0601579361,
-0.0576758534,
-0.0392752737,
0.0145097952,
0.0578206405,
-0.0201638825,
0.0020195507,
0.0133423414,
0.0230628047,
0.0632594079,
0.0130311437,
0.0028689706,
-0.0166702438,
-0.0180542916,
0.0085557215,
0.0676762387,
0.0586626194,
-0.0171771888,
0.0312653221,
-0.0706552491,
-0.041518677,
-0.0480991676,
-0.0018212303,
0.0236069523,
-0.024321774,
0.0335488617,
0.026535416,
-0.009122394,
-0.0114032505,
0.0427910611,
-0.0513128191,
0.0470260642,
0.0081625516,
0.0274285004,
-0.0012606104,
0.0293205939,
-0.0088686692,
-0.0135279242,
0.0452170484,
-0.0425048172,
0.0192437749,
-0.02411809,
-0.0607747957,
-0.0528767034,
0.0397447385,
-0.0564704016,
0.0074575567,
0.0358279422,
-0.065015696,
-0.0276587903,
0.0081810514,
-0.0047528832,
0.00211997,
-0.0552321449,
-0.0259531979,
-0.0192690119,
0.0344292819,
0.0039191213,
0.0686212555,
-0.0444484241,
0.0606251955,
0.0156815536,
-0.0159049369,
0.0414821841,
-0.0181794353,
-0.0761973411,
0.0243260637,
0.0357881673,
-0.0095142089,
-0.0112093054,
0.0297557712,
-0.0246074386,
-0.0185995363,
-0.095724009,
0.0103657302,
-0.0443128906,
0.0160288997,
0.0036938866,
-0.0001803342,
0.007961249,
-0.0121943047,
-0.0182259902,
-0.0448814556,
-0.0411561653,
0.0329775438,
-0.0045574447,
-0.0245098304,
0.0218413956,
-0.0079258308,
-0.0196208153,
-0.0196253248,
0.059487585,
-0.0271645263,
-0.0372129381,
-0.0347795486,
0.0226669852,
-0.0221935567,
-0.007462434,
-0.0142282313,
-0.0360451788,
-0.0227332003,
0.0257188231,
0.0825930089,
0.0419824384,
-0.0204440951,
0.0366824605,
0.0327817351,
0.0291661154,
-0.0275010113,
0.0292042587,
0.0002952236,
0.0653829724,
-0.0351318792,
-0.0395787619,
-0.0344050899,
0.0306518786,
-0.0125451917,
0.0014949914,
-0.0718864352,
-0.0031521653,
-0.0130356774,
-0.0158398002,
-0.0010755805,
0.0377744734,
0.0092601217,
-0.0071957386,
-0.0358721875,
-0.0170505326,
0.0781581849,
-0.0244551953,
-0.0105247367,
-0.0557255112,
-0.0371871144,
-0.0208126232,
0.0105469888,
0.0267292224,
0.0348244086,
-0.0205480568,
0.0095504094,
-0.0221868884,
0.0271595195,
0.0186937265,
-0.0108714756,
0.0313415788,
0.0042038062,
-0.0230570827,
-0.0307818521,
-0.0393485427,
-0.0005687451,
-0.0461707599,
-0.0258080363,
0.031382218,
0.0392608978,
-0.0248537455,
-0.0199807771,
-0.0121102063,
0.0270054433,
0.0503687263,
0.0135408668,
0.0104911402,
-0.0024888595,
0.0243739523,
0.0406052992,
-0.0016581961,
-0.006777517,
-0.0803505853,
0.0111467605,
0.0096082203,
-0.0237719249,
-0.0213115234,
-0.0264635365,
0.000802845,
0.0260455329,
-0.004726436,
-0.0575467013,
-0.0096377553,
0.0050208285,
-0.0332677737,
0.0177829508,
0.085770227,
0.008862189,
-0.0463256948,
0.0149722928,
-0.0619860217,
0.0410597324,
0.0218141451,
-0.0022228272,
-0.1004901677,
-0.0438904017,
-0.0023637738,
-0.0207808074,
0.0445002727,
-0.0054305163,
-0.0056545078,
-0.0868298262,
0.0383240581,
0.0093610864,
-0.0337056667,
-0.0424031317,
-0.0623202324,
-0.024115786,
-0.0088092303,
0.0051636035,
-0.0372611918,
0.0337554254,
-0.0224896297,
0.0189636797,
-0.0378376469,
-0.0998430476,
0.0360701568,
-0.0629367083,
0.0158732999,
0.0281158835,
0.0332574509,
-0.0276398137,
-0.0344182439,
-0.0174111817,
-0.0301358625,
-0.0399595201,
-0.0431977995,
0.0792520121,
-0.0360754915,
-0.0148112904,
-0.0043729064,
0.0079726232,
-0.0035456205,
0.0119600669,
-0.0227716211,
0.1151844636,
0.0183744766,
-0.0115477908,
-0.0118658366,
0.0048659113,
0.0004453915,
0.073719874,
0.0110847931,
-0.0710017756,
-0.0170593243,
-0.0203034841,
0.0404470935,
-0.0516347922,
-0.0316352174,
0.0513565801,
-0.0138127152,
-0.0624919124,
-0.0453588031,
-0.0701318085,
0.0298780315,
0.0164829195,
0.0014259501,
0.0080584968,
-0.0378168933,
-0.0503117256,
-0.0183988009,
0.0210573543,
0.0089176102,
0.0484136865,
-0.0353311934,
0.0358197913,
0.0568154715,
0.0136152906,
-0.0215392858,
0.0159858093,
-0.0430151895,
-0.054025434,
-0.0408812836,
0.0414003953,
-0.005030931,
0.014170697,
-0.0180724952,
-0.0455826707,
0.0647432655,
-0.0046681599,
-0.0147202723,
-0.0182891805,
0.0562184714,
-0.0148752686,
0.0094430996,
0.0493777841,
-0.0438154899,
-0.0023100446,
-0.0146636069,
0.0472383648,
-0.0104516279,
-0.039639011,
-0.0192614775,
-0.0383229442,
-0.0017778145,
-0.026799202,
-0.0117055969,
-0.0581328422,
0.0130340829,
-0.0398774408,
-0.0338843167,
-0.035184212,
0.0079053715,
0.0347241126,
-0.0012575652,
-0.0021657804,
0.012599241,
0.0328735225,
0.0161561482,
-0.0007176254,
0.0332489498,
0.0663266778,
0.018932553,
-0.0034536603,
0.0488253981,
-0.0358149894,
-0.0375832357,
-0.026807135,
0.0305604171,
-0.0454177,
0.0523776859,
0.0047072563,
-0.0215469114,
-0.03288408,
0.0238009896,
-0.0049652061,
0.0269507784,
-0.016995905,
-0.026217686,
0.0818159804,
-0.014861729,
0.0763998553,
-0.0138453301,
-0.028972486,
-0.0308687631,
0.0177618135,
-0.0352819711,
-0.0453779399,
0.0556945764,
-0.0056181024,
-0.0205273479,
0.0274205413,
0.082971938,
-0.0117909107,
0.0416950546,
0.0320928283,
0.0000374672,
-0.0342237502,
-0.0031669699,
0.0551350787,
0.0393321626,
-0.0472096875,
0.0019267438,
0.0054524499,
-0.057864964,
0.0354867615,
-0.0115210619,
-0.0600038692,
0.0430033803,
0.0039931438,
0.0495399311,
-0.0180270541,
-0.0194698013,
-0.0395196043,
0.0057218531,
0.0210104585,
-0.0521438196,
-0.0367807671,
-6.369834175e-33,
0.0024894332,
0.0184774231,
-0.0104961582,
-0.0040550339,
-0.0113869878,
0.0024193844,
-0.0136886407,
-0.0094636399,
-0.0501416959,
0.0309426766,
0.0205819272,
-0.0087679382,
0.0047255857,
0.0365249962,
-0.0132230083,
-0.0114367828,
0.0215601474,
-0.01116163,
0.0038042162,
0.017405238,
0.0417386964,
0.0220066942,
0.1056089327,
-0.0343698226,
0.033929348,
0.0125341285,
0.0105606588,
0.01250959,
0.0179791171,
0.0564870276,
-0.0305031613,
0.0433255732,
0.0214621723,
-0.0140145458,
-0.0378651768,
-0.0037107039,
-0.0712905079,
-0.0269185454,
-0.0047309087,
0.0296226777,
-0.0489006899,
-0.0359118804,
0.0240544919,
-0.0007643849,
0.0504633822,
-0.0188248102,
0.0520417355,
0.0097106295,
-0.0373215564,
0.0037007299,
-0.0282655284,
0.043706134,
-0.0244569387,
-0.0013984414,
0.0308967959,
0.0889931321,
0.0506863184,
0.0639262646,
-0.0997508168,
0.0040612337,
-0.0446434282,
-0.0080411369,
0.0341710523,
-0.0097603071,
0.0190618541,
0.0561749041,
0.0144579904,
0.0052812607,
0.0088513903,
-0.0347306021,
0.0709101111,
0.0186970402,
0.06292025,
0.0544024035,
0.000862773,
0.0047948407,
-0.1011418551,
0.0261856616,
0.0259370524,
0.0128475167,
0.0304644331,
0.0096346987,
-0.050571233,
-0.0318965651,
-0.0111075407,
-0.0570006408,
-0.0250896458,
-0.066235438,
0.0114395786,
-0.0044066142,
0.0008490413,
0.014799485,
0.0564911589,
-0.0336805098,
0.0066465493,
0.0467679128,
-0.0073059737,
0.0114817144,
0.003012856,
0.050525941,
-0.0804689229,
-0.0282037258,
0.0120502673,
-0.0262976252,
-0.0055949246,
-0.0353679843,
0.0540607758,
0.0277167875,
-0.0653893724,
-0.0034404453,
-0.0063685253,
-0.06105984,
-0.0032633119,
0.034301538,
0.0231698621,
-0.001246271,
-0.0091799228,
0.0448576882,
0.0547854751,
-0.0023679205,
0.0062926691,
-0.0819803178,
0.0308316685,
0.0365265198,
0.0110613126,
0.0025741614,
-0.0347490162,
0.0055606822,
0.0169966593,
-0.0342065319,
-0.015157707,
0.0118800318,
2.57e-7,
0.0590174459,
0.0056334264,
-0.0104858298,
-0.0043845116,
-0.0070004077,
0.0545586087,
-0.0094872769,
0.0438149832,
-0.0145487469,
0.0298373941,
0.0235968493,
0.0146870092,
0.0763588697,
0.0206931084,
-0.0643000081,
0.0171495304,
-0.0961184502,
0.0102068661,
-0.0229285024,
-0.0190383345,
0.0411326811,
0.1459980756,
0.0342119001,
0.0329460986,
-0.0391769484,
-0.0306166336,
0.0947124735,
-0.0631596968,
-0.0483318903,
-0.0193651468,
-0.0262721963,
0.0320628397,
-0.0264971238,
-0.0064776945,
-0.0470952764,
0.0671261549,
0.0369801372,
0.0628475994,
-0.0084896293,
-0.0012602262,
0.0000735647,
-0.0205841456,
-0.0431364253,
-0.0336930305,
0.0488717034,
-0.0100248056,
-0.0351894349,
0.0006683706,
-0.0245301127,
0.008988319,
0.1035086811,
-0.0335493647,
-0.0609986112,
0.0161346681,
0.02742384,
-0.0374130122,
-0.0165361892,
-0.0674191266,
-0.0054581724,
0.0329907238,
-0.0519737862,
0.0257457942,
-0.0058325431,
-0.0089256875,
0.0514385328,
-0.0110196136,
0.0387640782,
2.245732136e-34,
0.0124261742,
-0.0371289365,
-0.0003452919,
0.0286657717,
0.0160136111,
-0.0306102242,
-0.0099857599,
-0.0375251323,
0.0208221972,
-0.0579201765,
-0.015795026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05668v1 | Comprehensive Assessment of Jailbreak Attacks Against LLMs | 2024-02-08T13:42:50 | 2024-02-08T13:42:50 | Junjie Chu, Yugeng Liu, Ziqing Yang, Xinyue Shen, Michael Backes, Yang Zhang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Misuse of the Large Language Models (LLMs) has raised widespread concern. To
address this issue, safeguards have been taken to ensure that LLMs align with
social ethics. However, recent findings have revealed an unsettling
vulnerability bypassing the safeguards of LLMs, known as jailbreak attacks. By
applying techniques, such as employing role-playing scenarios, adversarial
examples, or subtle subversion of safety objectives as a prompt, LLMs can
produce an inappropriate or even harmful response. While researchers have
studied several categories of jailbreak attacks, they have done so in
isolation. To fill this gap, we present the first large-scale measurement of
various jailbreak attack methods. We concentrate on 13 cutting-edge jailbreak
methods from four categories, 160 questions from 16 violation categories, and
six popular LLMs. Our extensive experimental results demonstrate that the
optimized jailbreak prompts consistently achieve the highest attack success
rates, as well as exhibit robustness across different LLMs. Some jailbreak
prompt datasets, available from the Internet, can also achieve high attack
success rates on many LLMs, such as ChatGLM3, GPT-3.5, and PaLM2. Despite the
claims from many organizations regarding the coverage of violation categories
in their policies, the attack success rates from these categories remain high,
indicating the challenges of effectively aligning LLM policies and the ability
to counter jailbreak attacks. We also discuss the trade-off between the attack
performance and efficiency, as well as show that the transferability of the
jailbreak prompts is still viable, becoming an option for black-box models.
Overall, our research highlights the necessity of evaluating different
jailbreak methods. We hope our study can provide insights for future research
on jailbreak attacks and serve as a benchmark tool for evaluating them for
practitioners. | [
0.0826463029,
0.0535432063,
-0.0178756099,
0.034140151,
-0.047777012,
-0.0154419383,
0.0458555892,
0.0168120563,
0.0555618517,
-0.0249412525,
0.0008074396,
-0.04724323,
0.0214293245,
-0.0036588325,
0.0464719422,
-0.001293706,
0.0362649262,
-0.0320261158,
-0.0007831132,
-0.002683524,
0.0297513604,
-0.0072107464,
0.037314415,
0.0300620906,
0.0210260805,
-0.0091523807,
-0.0034584838,
0.0114279408,
0.0361884311,
-0.0553519353,
0.0044748574,
0.0293584261,
-0.0128641771,
0.0383782722,
0.0000023269,
-0.0523663498,
-0.0101015456,
0.0253098607,
-0.009387658,
0.0547183901,
0.017589353,
-0.0334648751,
-0.0187973417,
0.024673406,
-0.0410806537,
0.0031433268,
0.023239335,
0.0341482423,
0.0726336613,
0.0783931762,
-0.0071215737,
0.0050236676,
0.0382628813,
-0.0070913872,
0.0180325992,
-0.0403244682,
0.0217644311,
-0.0372664183,
0.0099792844,
0.0337077156,
0.0220481511,
-0.01216783,
0.0421167687,
0.0024923412,
-0.0712628663,
-0.0185676869,
-0.0499819517,
-0.0178434141,
0.0145366471,
0.0530693941,
-0.0118940761,
-0.0074116345,
0.0294784345,
0.0091923159,
0.0362147801,
0.0485617295,
-0.0192382615,
0.0405444093,
-0.0226526242,
-0.0421075635,
0.0039414871,
-0.0033475761,
0.0649377555,
0.0121485787,
0.0067384318,
0.0142860916,
0.005762584,
-0.0339895859,
-0.0021345429,
-0.0485998243,
-0.0137560805,
-0.0423572287,
0.005109306,
-0.0154666826,
0.0052371211,
0.0120007917,
-0.0670460388,
0.005942889,
0.058863245,
-0.057664644,
-0.0216729529,
0.0280607697,
-0.0048318952,
-0.0054552411,
0.0360773355,
-0.0022582079,
-0.0214527044,
0.0143242925,
0.0076907608,
0.0282144491,
0.0161523055,
-0.0013852122,
-0.0024145439,
0.0133405682,
-0.001529498,
0.0417491198,
-0.0273302644,
0.0206523221,
-0.0459612124,
0.0264474023,
-0.050699681,
0.0064164642,
0.0101626702,
0.0125114955,
0.0396725759,
-0.0312559009,
-0.0457349271,
-0.0213785693,
0.021225594,
-0.0819587782,
-0.0102284076,
-0.0181794353,
-0.0669174492,
-0.007008139,
0.0042282245,
0.1260890961,
0.0403116234,
-0.0159982312,
-0.0666086003,
-0.0998001918,
-0.0441614613,
-0.035027951,
0.001625914,
-0.0972223207,
-0.0091050072,
-0.0101378141,
-0.0078540388,
-0.0397621505,
0.0103358962,
0.007029694,
-0.0321912169,
0.0402874053,
0.0307995714,
-0.0207398906,
0.0110283541,
0.0761009753,
0.0121140834,
0.0631989762,
-0.0098937815,
0.0592705198,
0.0553409643,
-0.0293832868,
0.055455368,
0.0612758994,
-0.0170193557,
0.0335193425,
0.0039626448,
0.0030583979,
0.0341571309,
0.0092180753,
-0.0351217762,
0.0325503126,
-0.031684678,
-0.0483380817,
0.1028620452,
0.0687480867,
-0.0749286413,
0.0530666001,
-0.0342431031,
-0.015886778,
0.0420372449,
-0.0028446433,
-0.0511720665,
-0.0083151795,
-0.08133398,
-0.034350127,
-0.049723804,
0.0487421453,
-0.0157682691,
0.0090526333,
0.0082596056,
-0.0006611379,
0.0037572957,
0.0351507217,
-0.0144952061,
0.0108762812,
0.0101496102,
0.0426880643,
0.0296355952,
-0.028346967,
-0.0278275479,
-0.0563532561,
-0.0110143125,
0.0397123918,
0.0607930422,
0.0001478054,
0.0110270064,
-0.0426178053,
0.0146490214,
0.0171189196,
0.0335470252,
0.0100455368,
-0.0077448781,
-0.0097363582,
-0.0068447292,
-0.0388801061,
0.0107281012,
0.0289382618,
-0.0020592194,
-0.0027188705,
-0.0050382479,
-0.0132862702,
-0.0356682464,
0.0050437017,
0.008211039,
-0.0195338055,
-0.0040401365,
0.0303681847,
0.019487286,
0.013147451,
-0.0146169607,
-0.0063328221,
0.0472912975,
0.0105969692,
0.0413632728,
-0.0070423856,
-0.0462271497,
-0.0131625924,
0.0212193076,
-0.0486108102,
-0.0200364254,
0.0918190777,
-0.0232904926,
0.0254457928,
0.0337957814,
-0.0246717613,
0.0285445992,
0.006409063,
0.007361725,
-0.0311507545,
-0.0043007187,
-0.0434327014,
-0.0017977679,
-0.0256103911,
0.0074772546,
-0.0147373294,
0.0155818844,
0.0139401974,
0.0046283402,
-0.062642768,
0.0420946255,
-0.0731981546,
0.0300398711,
0.0191345718,
-0.0069984808,
-0.033856865,
-0.0200122409,
-0.0673585087,
-0.0285196099,
-0.0219856724,
0.0144971618,
0.0532583259,
0.0436450504,
-0.0306401234,
-0.0022365181,
-0.0312202182,
-0.0329298005,
-0.0026389246,
0.045329079,
-0.0109758843,
-0.0230183546,
-0.0220379718,
-0.0133574363,
-0.0028100281,
-0.0102441637,
0.0512154624,
-0.0247399081,
-0.0026512183,
0.0179918855,
-0.0022644112,
-0.0276968051,
-0.0044142841,
-0.0336984955,
-0.0468627773,
0.0504679978,
0.0200985949,
-0.0004233703,
0.0608944707,
0.0409764275,
0.0669291094,
0.0572196767,
0.008771874,
-0.0428777561,
-0.0464071073,
0.0533002838,
-0.054309275,
-0.0326321982,
-0.0995369479,
0.0313600339,
0.0390538238,
0.0459562801,
0.0370852165,
-0.009628362,
0.0375741683,
-0.0398001634,
-0.0451844409,
-0.0036258581,
-0.0059962478,
-0.0516460612,
-0.0222455356,
-0.0191520043,
-0.0497496873,
0.0629001409,
-0.0309822913,
0.0203167405,
-0.0015545656,
-0.0351713374,
0.0145956492,
0.0669066757,
-0.0364060216,
0.0196583457,
0.0654084161,
-0.0310061183,
-0.0325527787,
-0.0418811254,
0.0390674397,
-0.029048698,
0.037779592,
-0.0319266841,
-0.0094320597,
0.0008033821,
-0.0227001738,
-0.033781752,
-0.1063457504,
-0.0122046424,
-0.0412113555,
0.0281608496,
-0.0361772701,
0.0071988329,
-0.0396892577,
0.0339696705,
-0.0054639513,
-0.0122377742,
-0.0140176769,
-0.0136004314,
0.0071096327,
0.0294495784,
-0.0615148656,
0.0185567774,
-0.0094199767,
0.0539993122,
0.0936194509,
0.043470636,
0.0002317083,
0.0136396009,
0.0237741061,
0.0129564162,
-0.0026976147,
-0.0213031359,
0.0455653556,
0.079283759,
-0.0613441728,
-0.0169427209,
0.0291589219,
0.012296577,
-0.0048249853,
0.0384625196,
0.0008911899,
0.0157319456,
0.0130850552,
0.0237120427,
-0.0555170402,
-0.0222503599,
-0.0018824018,
0.0707693174,
-0.0454047918,
-0.0251148455,
-0.0243454222,
-0.0911430866,
0.0091096638,
0.0356999412,
-0.0244532395,
0.0453688204,
-0.036993321,
-0.0211246591,
0.0155820008,
0.0347239636,
-0.0199883226,
-0.0234975982,
-0.0200652517,
0.0000567286,
-0.067568779,
-0.0009666212,
0.0324634314,
-0.0389099643,
0.0629927441,
0.0651522651,
-0.0148012564,
-0.0559204407,
0.0238911454,
0.0466322787,
0.0108899428,
-0.0286857076,
0.0116652073,
0.0166029781,
0.0173304472,
0.0002788694,
-0.0053213378,
0.0311814994,
0.004470862,
-0.0400170609,
0.0570212789,
0.0498169474,
-0.0065967995,
-0.0473860018,
-0.0152544435,
-0.013156523,
0.0207184963,
0.0288869701,
0.0208715852,
-0.0474833064,
-0.0137010105,
-0.0876437649,
-0.0573412925,
-0.0261387769,
-0.0250407979,
-0.010616892,
0.0509531423,
-0.0081376033,
-0.0366706997,
-0.0249781106,
-0.0248681158,
0.0364908725,
0.0328450501,
-0.0007942253,
-0.0361190587,
0.0238315668,
0.0027322536,
-0.0068257055,
-0.0078598587,
0.047504928,
-0.0458585583,
0.0515506193,
-0.0258379672,
-0.0172592774,
0.0183297843,
-0.0017570535,
-0.0246571302,
-0.0687332749,
0.0228856932,
0.0617512316,
0.0230046641,
-0.0018549046,
-0.0171664413,
-0.0534194931,
0.034037631,
0.0881793797,
-0.0645644367,
0.0398651883,
0.0712123141,
-0.0136325732,
0.0106046693,
0.0068062628,
-0.0162328668,
-0.0276176929,
0.0739461407,
0.000218312,
-0.0733377188,
0.0062351297,
0.0084411371,
0.0289307553,
-0.0033871406,
-0.000905815,
-0.0013571262,
0.0477999263,
-0.0112368548,
-0.0078566801,
-0.0377509482,
0.0216070227,
-0.009791851,
0.0088955769,
-0.0118285622,
0.0306003094,
0.0295959041,
-0.0196080282,
-0.0018575321,
-0.0255151503,
0.0464149639,
0.0233090576,
0.0723040402,
0.0539362878,
0.0156203313,
-0.0335073657,
0.0450700335,
-0.0102918213,
0.0263061468,
0.0086531211,
0.0512019582,
-0.0251136646,
-0.0184340477,
0.0035253519,
0.0460083298,
-0.0724951476,
-0.0572410785,
0.0308619887,
0.0751898512,
-0.0305106435,
0.0158120859,
-0.011438272,
0.0125504276,
0.0077023082,
-0.0378191359,
-0.0396528803,
-0.0093103023,
-0.0877863318,
0.025754232,
0.0051635685,
-0.0214102417,
0.0278632138,
0.0499754697,
0.0181198847,
0.0433758795,
0.0286622979,
-0.0094129322,
-0.0189961046,
-0.0036871124,
0.0969807506,
0.0291963182,
-0.0517619699,
-0.0742685571,
-0.0875861719,
-0.069374159,
-0.0392591208,
-0.0062578986,
0.0321441479,
-0.0013148094,
-0.0297699459,
0.0421192534,
0.0134317642,
0.056094747,
-0.0465214327,
0.0307399016,
-0.0366302505,
-0.0583311543,
0.0164989941,
-6.152509147e-33,
0.0454637669,
-0.0518761501,
-0.0508288033,
-0.0399790369,
-0.0122206975,
-0.001212917,
-0.0286236778,
0.020428963,
-0.0369361043,
-0.0333776996,
-0.0235395301,
-0.0155322179,
-0.0038500025,
-0.0048523964,
-0.0431220829,
-0.0654415116,
-0.0042101485,
0.0165782962,
-0.0391143262,
0.030787196,
0.0432966985,
0.0166120734,
0.0049864152,
-0.0387422219,
0.0709492564,
-0.0454231128,
-0.0288723372,
0.0056772018,
-0.0254246239,
0.0499155112,
0.0177647248,
0.0427581668,
0.002632909,
-0.0305489898,
0.0032306931,
0.0866646618,
0.0134907141,
-0.0120685166,
0.0274650287,
-0.0027512745,
0.0111690816,
-0.0495214798,
0.0103004249,
-0.0158501919,
-0.0051212688,
-0.0292384624,
-0.0089750746,
-0.008334632,
-0.0202745181,
-0.0132180853,
-0.0053405697,
-0.0171273779,
-0.0361699983,
0.0030167771,
-0.0518284515,
0.0374311805,
-0.008191416,
-0.0097911162,
-0.0215298403,
0.0258261133,
0.0235009193,
-0.0289821029,
0.03046887,
0.0072443429,
0.001912548,
0.0784303322,
-0.0500602201,
0.0101518687,
-0.0006449502,
-0.0216237456,
0.0071798391,
0.0581327714,
0.0613220707,
0.0964901373,
0.0407743417,
-0.0305032432,
-0.07386484,
-0.0078760684,
0.0357578658,
0.0176639874,
0.0293055307,
-0.0336077362,
-0.0565976277,
-0.0235754922,
-0.0057676532,
-0.0100732613,
-0.0216506496,
-0.0612655096,
0.031644132,
-0.030116111,
-0.0467238054,
-0.0334655344,
0.0091627948,
-0.0697847381,
0.0089880405,
0.0109678507,
0.008262638,
-0.0111969924,
0.0052480455,
0.0188375581,
-0.0173887033,
0.0292302016,
-0.0007456891,
-0.0649492443,
0.0407904573,
0.0084357513,
0.0275270995,
0.0268887058,
-0.046270892,
-0.0239120908,
-0.0088649914,
0.0387356542,
0.0024004516,
0.0029836234,
0.0193256885,
-0.0064935521,
-0.0001495661,
-0.0190278199,
0.0445794016,
-0.0169399101,
-0.0740697905,
0.0228067786,
-0.0561556555,
0.0349099748,
0.0064107962,
0.005863457,
-0.0158947874,
0.0206052326,
0.0525384694,
-0.0444199927,
-0.0156691764,
-0.026351897,
3.046e-7,
-0.052747786,
-0.023327034,
-0.0179991871,
-0.0226146039,
0.0110191656,
0.080951713,
0.005789428,
0.0888767168,
0.0209652614,
-0.0564450845,
-0.0249880627,
-0.0219315235,
0.0676122531,
0.0477637164,
-0.059610825,
0.0126593001,
-0.0587040372,
-0.0021724964,
-0.0617778786,
0.0076961969,
0.0258120801,
0.0454521216,
0.0114305159,
-0.0354135521,
-0.0048717037,
-0.0349865519,
0.018542368,
-0.0338157266,
-0.0187592935,
-0.0117481379,
0.0226768758,
0.035879679,
0.0268331617,
0.0168483239,
-0.015351099,
-0.0349333063,
-0.0408927947,
0.036694359,
0.0348594822,
0.0082413387,
-0.031694144,
-0.0495796651,
0.0111347679,
-0.0773565099,
0.0588749237,
-0.0114403656,
-0.0234444924,
0.0027413075,
0.0106987944,
-0.0735004321,
0.0089043593,
-0.0255576633,
-0.0058944067,
-0.0223023128,
0.0192514118,
0.0097816391,
0.0391104557,
-0.0290580988,
-0.001741827,
0.0038561274,
0.0222309921,
-0.0567293242,
-0.0133975353,
0.0371544473,
0.0145266168,
-0.0185383223,
0.0223344378,
3.074430169e-34,
-0.0156262722,
-0.0375439227,
0.0303255711,
-0.0221840851,
0.0392991491,
0.0372769088,
0.0542673953,
0.0272945929,
0.0073217535,
-0.0166700725,
-0.0085098688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14579v1 | Text Role Classification in Scientific Charts Using Multimodal Transformers | 2024-02-08T13:21:44 | 2024-02-08T13:21:44 | Hye Jin Kim, Nicolas Lell, Ansgar Scherp | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Text role classification involves classifying the semantic role of textual
elements within scientific charts. For this task, we propose to finetune two
pretrained multimodal document layout analysis models, LayoutLMv3 and UDOP, on
chart datasets. The transformers utilize the three modalities of text, image,
and layout as input. We further investigate whether data augmentation and
balancing methods help the performance of the models. The models are evaluated
on various chart datasets, and results show that LayoutLMv3 outperforms UDOP in
all experiments. LayoutLMv3 achieves the highest F1-macro score of 82.87 on the
ICPR22 test dataset, beating the best-performing model from the ICPR22
CHART-Infographics challenge. Moreover, the robustness of the models is tested
on a synthetic noisy dataset ICPR22-N. Finally, the generalizability of the
models is evaluated on three chart datasets, CHIME-R, DeGruyter, and EconBiz,
for which we added labels for the text roles. Findings indicate that even in
cases where there is limited training data, transformers can be used with the
help of data augmentation and balancing methods. The source code and datasets
are available on GitHub under
https://github.com/hjkimk/text-role-classification | [
0.0391014963,
0.009347219,
0.010456915,
0.0189289376,
-0.0174795631,
0.0094656749,
0.0094473967,
0.0142732263,
0.0012904411,
-0.0344393849,
-0.0722144172,
-0.0138340648,
0.0012915233,
0.0362916142,
0.0097320806,
-0.0819224492,
-0.0208960306,
0.0079833567,
0.0198986474,
0.0266602971,
0.0040791091,
-0.0230775233,
-0.0387079976,
0.0098313112,
-0.0468477756,
-0.0072420673,
0.0161554832,
0.0492496789,
0.0238697436,
-0.0441535115,
-0.0057061245,
0.0138530964,
0.0366847999,
0.0169174448,
0.000002187,
-0.0273390524,
-0.0112907989,
0.0288657546,
0.0401743017,
-0.0371523015,
0.0742823556,
-0.0778554156,
0.0364726298,
-0.0522369966,
-0.0120492969,
0.0203402955,
0.0769578367,
0.0597210303,
0.040907979,
0.0436224788,
-0.023491282,
-0.019127775,
-0.0238885731,
-0.0323116742,
0.0414773524,
-0.0021830758,
0.0087329037,
0.0264124852,
0.0089608748,
0.0584118702,
-0.0780647099,
0.0283654556,
-0.0157477017,
-0.0198785104,
0.0037993644,
0.0399022922,
0.0103897601,
-0.0495338067,
-0.0023045102,
0.0807453766,
-0.0065205884,
0.0031711911,
0.0069139665,
-0.0438589789,
-0.0334275141,
0.0852585658,
-0.0475568324,
-0.0273494292,
-0.0179200172,
-0.0444203541,
-0.0288400948,
0.0602688938,
-0.0084783435,
-0.0312800109,
-0.0265371092,
0.0138019994,
-0.0220836531,
-0.0195161253,
0.0153089091,
-0.0113221789,
-0.0009101529,
-0.0050831251,
0.0245022643,
0.0083408635,
0.0406143479,
0.0154856276,
-0.0391276516,
-0.0618031174,
0.0484162532,
-0.0069600367,
-0.0060673743,
-0.037097007,
-0.0440698527,
0.0522950552,
0.0134392669,
0.0375592001,
-0.0143886907,
0.0678523406,
-0.0121843657,
0.0239519551,
-0.0049197096,
-0.0103080273,
0.0093958173,
-0.0491990857,
0.0018011695,
-0.057221733,
-0.0155519908,
-0.0257068854,
0.0104056522,
0.0468445532,
0.0384316482,
0.0190478098,
-0.0743131265,
0.0093625626,
0.0131251002,
0.0662590116,
0.0208268594,
-0.0010348458,
-0.0397322774,
0.0200428534,
0.0316271707,
0.0695270896,
0.0111279078,
-0.0284813792,
-0.0167302769,
0.0704071075,
0.0139548453,
-0.0307610538,
0.0227028057,
-0.0498780124,
-0.0531322844,
-0.0356877409,
0.0570392087,
0.0066458769,
0.0250116121,
-0.022544492,
0.0269193873,
0.0165989939,
0.012883815,
0.016295094,
-0.0143806534,
0.0834031105,
0.0063843303,
-0.0174593627,
0.0374427028,
0.0065444354,
-0.0231376402,
0.0476661809,
0.0513647161,
0.0282521807,
0.0425439775,
-0.0547567308,
0.012841492,
0.039111495,
-0.0191320889,
-0.0363343656,
0.0468007885,
0.0070418944,
-0.0368531831,
0.021642169,
-0.0008070688,
-0.0326301642,
-0.0147913666,
-0.0501504391,
0.0642326102,
0.0341789238,
0.0500991084,
-0.0228394177,
-0.0157688353,
0.0077863038,
0.0247632861,
-0.0054375292,
-0.0173643027,
0.034114752,
0.0530212075,
0.0345215127,
-0.0360451452,
-0.0149916783,
0.011871621,
-0.0314885378,
-0.0221577603,
-0.009569793,
-0.0055668443,
-0.0548592843,
0.0825034082,
-0.0072592576,
-0.0467933565,
0.0179675855,
-0.0027707575,
-0.0453788824,
-0.0118462993,
0.0556741692,
-0.0198462438,
0.0184736326,
0.0554657988,
-0.0914814994,
-0.0464277342,
-0.0318216793,
0.0096923094,
0.0192688983,
0.0192114711,
0.0063311881,
-0.0178551972,
-0.0591937415,
-0.0602153093,
-0.0155132078,
-0.0098756673,
0.0289697498,
-0.0206367373,
-0.0105581461,
-0.0227157082,
-0.0742105246,
-0.0126717845,
0.0275986008,
0.041904863,
-0.0240299813,
0.0068589007,
0.0318242684,
0.023761332,
0.0202330202,
-0.0247191656,
0.0078859758,
0.0421747267,
-0.0274777226,
0.0235007256,
0.0371550396,
-0.0295510218,
-0.0516556948,
0.0079518724,
-0.0423270203,
-0.0065569663,
0.0268466882,
-0.0478704274,
-0.0387527496,
0.008260469,
-0.0392328203,
-0.0503093824,
0.0256446712,
-0.0544952825,
0.0098785022,
0.0128122801,
-0.0701492876,
0.0401587561,
-0.009952317,
0.027803164,
-0.0181936547,
0.0573778637,
0.0560065657,
-0.0101346774,
-0.0157280285,
0.0072041736,
-0.0033539471,
-0.0091250744,
0.0210123844,
-0.0194433182,
0.0122173447,
-0.0080803111,
-0.0453203991,
-0.0230447315,
0.0054470231,
0.0221417975,
0.0187732894,
-0.0572858378,
-0.0042663142,
-0.0425324477,
-0.0330275521,
0.0191283002,
-0.0382831879,
-0.0516115278,
0.0397488549,
-0.0332872681,
0.0319862962,
0.0201865789,
0.015156161,
-0.0436949618,
0.0357801542,
0.0929214433,
-0.024248464,
0.0039300774,
-0.0184978582,
0.0132391136,
-0.0331783891,
0.0077141989,
-0.0012760558,
0.0020540927,
0.0226502474,
0.0011630403,
0.0654252842,
-0.0128537687,
0.057123296,
-0.0177307911,
0.0056650895,
-0.0035614453,
0.0185498539,
-0.0127915833,
0.0563943945,
0.0127063403,
-0.0147225512,
-0.0011474605,
0.0641916543,
0.000183864,
0.0074325972,
0.0028623971,
-0.0377024934,
-0.0133201899,
0.0214983523,
-0.0343497731,
0.0116563169,
-0.0224579182,
0.0201686043,
-0.0332842842,
-0.0319176167,
0.0200601518,
-0.0507382415,
-0.0433216952,
-0.069693312,
-0.0122400783,
-0.0445526913,
0.0784085095,
0.0448839329,
0.0181936305,
0.0093765054,
-0.0265068151,
-0.0315960012,
0.0183593854,
0.0389745124,
-0.02819754,
-0.0420344435,
-0.023301404,
0.02656742,
-0.050843481,
-0.011539124,
0.0100960676,
-0.0307689849,
0.0185579062,
-0.0273746625,
0.0102085099,
-0.0314526036,
-0.0750956088,
0.0374525264,
0.0110243782,
0.045461718,
-0.000849569,
0.0071613444,
-0.0101575255,
0.0856706053,
-0.0214841105,
0.0122154336,
-0.0607895628,
-0.0456455387,
-0.0288868062,
0.0324626602,
-0.0707639232,
0.009810417,
-0.0260713808,
0.0087343212,
-0.0162608437,
0.0402087718,
-0.0014635953,
-0.0224488266,
0.0371370874,
-0.0221385323,
0.0280585364,
0.0448119007,
0.0251626931,
-0.0652910173,
-0.0330618918,
0.0390512086,
-0.0028927634,
0.005089764,
-0.0046218126,
-0.0833956674,
-0.0252575204,
-0.0145322941,
0.0087637501,
0.0067533851,
0.0088692978,
-0.0166125838,
-0.0534383617,
0.0675524622,
0.0109237954,
-0.0622809827,
0.0053603812,
-0.062594153,
0.0177573357,
-0.0406821333,
-0.0646320209,
-0.0626389384,
0.0036919524,
-0.0398372635,
0.0345674269,
-0.0842550099,
-0.0612857528,
-0.0569035821,
0.0218329411,
-0.0536627918,
0.0242611784,
0.0647359937,
-0.0002264679,
-0.0282133222,
0.0264222678,
0.0479898714,
0.0032234122,
-0.0149423629,
0.0947806388,
0.0066968077,
-0.0099705635,
-0.0118240751,
0.055529017,
0.0037606566,
-0.0265417229,
-0.004510703,
0.0336040258,
-0.0143095599,
0.0014454847,
-0.0731438324,
0.0253119133,
0.0199954957,
0.004731596,
0.0539468415,
-0.0246009417,
-0.0588669665,
-0.0465472937,
0.0693868399,
-0.0694128722,
0.0018122753,
0.0061083836,
-0.0431951992,
-0.0665324405,
-0.0391290747,
0.0237965006,
0.0017275043,
0.055181805,
0.0178835187,
-0.0211563613,
-0.0096380077,
-0.0199138466,
-0.07686764,
0.0256910436,
0.0080875559,
0.0476399027,
-0.0039611286,
-0.0494625382,
0.0552964807,
-0.0202722419,
-0.0433474854,
-0.01436939,
-0.0513829105,
-0.006319161,
-0.0266123544,
0.0473918505,
0.015329483,
-0.0060862242,
-0.0024349464,
-0.0188617315,
0.0683113188,
0.0832726732,
-0.0334801264,
-0.028423721,
-0.004762304,
-0.0107649034,
-0.0469017103,
-0.0558014289,
-0.031792894,
0.056624271,
0.0218431968,
-0.0160652194,
-0.0184916928,
0.0130564887,
-0.022352675,
0.0129211964,
0.0315367915,
-0.0255311411,
-0.0044102231,
-0.0168161057,
-0.0155349532,
0.0114672352,
-0.0366469212,
-0.0137955947,
0.00269913,
0.035268873,
0.0037386243,
0.0011012334,
0.0007242642,
0.0375947692,
0.0104882205,
-0.0547194667,
0.064656429,
0.0341325179,
-0.0106940595,
0.0005924615,
0.0480654575,
-0.010439558,
0.0165125355,
-0.0055592577,
0.0132736191,
0.0535870083,
0.0116404807,
0.0181534626,
-0.0046097408,
-0.0361037031,
0.0535244569,
-0.0779639632,
0.0314820483,
-0.0303848404,
-0.0074578938,
0.0255853143,
-0.0237844177,
0.0136730243,
-0.0394547284,
-0.0043013073,
0.0188428033,
0.0331313647,
0.0389825329,
0.0432117656,
0.0652772263,
-0.0051270635,
0.0253790561,
-0.0361537486,
0.0861541778,
0.0274503157,
-0.0076536783,
-0.011863362,
-0.0418477878,
-0.0620489344,
0.0340583026,
0.0379204378,
0.0325406939,
0.0033356,
0.0070458106,
-0.0441740789,
-0.0079689659,
0.0340411216,
-0.0006503843,
-0.0022952869,
0.0234867204,
0.020799296,
0.0228247326,
0.036604967,
-0.0014898526,
-0.0027752116,
-0.0192149747,
0.0040535713,
-0.0053356914,
-0.0086548068,
-5.248396034e-33,
0.0024737522,
-0.0678551123,
-0.0175993126,
0.0191179942,
-0.0304852445,
0.0212031286,
-0.0211222991,
-0.015171838,
0.057250388,
0.0282310937,
0.0400777832,
-0.0634723827,
0.0191188902,
0.0154089378,
-0.0110346619,
0.0144480933,
0.034123525,
0.0092060575,
-0.0478262976,
0.0136812748,
0.0309691075,
0.0413305983,
0.0181063619,
-0.1142610833,
0.0073175565,
0.0249124244,
0.013254446,
-0.0346097946,
-0.0118458355,
0.0472306348,
-0.00414016,
0.0067617232,
0.0304530691,
-0.043080274,
-0.0206154902,
0.1095662192,
-0.0832627863,
-0.026233552,
-0.012732585,
0.064625442,
-0.009980198,
0.0004220975,
0.0652720928,
-0.0150711406,
0.0056688138,
-0.0540111661,
0.0710536242,
-0.0172020923,
0.0142515572,
-0.011780967,
-0.0337480307,
0.0499625877,
-0.0351383276,
-0.0145967202,
0.0308134481,
0.0412391685,
0.0288515482,
0.0709272474,
-0.0772124156,
0.0402874164,
-0.0274440162,
-0.0315404311,
0.0309715047,
0.0636320785,
0.0195571035,
0.0581607483,
-0.0063660466,
0.044970613,
-0.038365379,
-0.0182017982,
0.0247467458,
0.0664300621,
0.0595313832,
0.0098804543,
0.0536895469,
0.0167425331,
-0.033504732,
0.0739686191,
-0.0225212686,
-0.0120172305,
0.0213592388,
0.0172898546,
-0.0219870005,
-0.0262241978,
0.0234014001,
0.0142814042,
-0.0367008895,
-0.0009540042,
0.0367158167,
0.0115704155,
-0.0242560077,
0.0619592145,
0.0195932146,
-0.0306083057,
-0.0177489147,
-0.0103282006,
0.0264530294,
0.0667579919,
-0.0360168479,
-0.0862240121,
-0.0249557681,
-0.0590288378,
0.0562386326,
0.001306414,
0.0177770946,
-0.0335973911,
0.0389196724,
0.0242918953,
-0.0275249891,
-0.0146299591,
0.0177741721,
-0.0790745318,
0.0367913507,
0.0628229454,
0.0272575617,
-0.0316006504,
-0.0364222713,
0.014975844,
0.0244609937,
0.0296427254,
0.0027168463,
-0.0569408536,
-0.0477810055,
0.0132927299,
0.0114175975,
-0.0369806178,
0.0034650106,
-0.0656280965,
-0.0074988264,
-0.0336858854,
0.000113956,
-0.0110923313,
2.742e-7,
0.0809886977,
0.0438205749,
0.0458752662,
-0.0683109388,
0.0224227682,
0.0132127944,
-0.0816741735,
-0.0097254682,
-0.048173856,
0.0106182313,
0.0237192977,
-0.0151512809,
0.0448793657,
0.0504388288,
-0.0454516038,
-0.0194035899,
-0.0375322737,
-0.0327626057,
-0.0530937649,
0.0523103178,
0.0688994005,
0.0316973142,
-0.0133622615,
-0.039395161,
0.0159916468,
-0.0397212021,
0.0354689844,
-0.012335239,
0.0397548266,
-0.0111439712,
0.0206445642,
0.0297575053,
-0.0297928434,
0.0438733697,
-0.0127358856,
0.0052094362,
0.0271643233,
-0.011297049,
-0.0238091405,
0.0520328656,
0.0251046233,
0.0527511463,
0.0129896216,
-0.0433095098,
0.0152517809,
-0.0774304941,
-0.0616488904,
-0.0053536445,
-0.0225085095,
0.0165324975,
0.0297779515,
0.0061286758,
-0.0145478677,
0.0253532305,
0.0172365867,
-0.0168332309,
-0.004417337,
-0.0483588502,
-0.0210612565,
0.0341604389,
-0.0247363392,
0.0080497349,
-0.0090861227,
-0.0049157981,
0.0081387674,
-0.019585235,
-0.0448929444,
2.914421052e-34,
0.0400339179,
-0.0156103512,
-0.0229069125,
0.0091701793,
0.0327241048,
-0.0176732615,
0.0120017854,
0.0006715314,
-0.0091704968,
-0.0564723462,
0.0154036488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10943v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10943v1 | Advances and Limitations in Open Source Arabic-Script OCR: A Case Study | 2024-02-08T12:51:36 | 2024-02-08T12:51:36 | Benjamin Kiessling, Gennady Kurin, Matthew Thomas Miller, Kader Smail | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | This work presents an accuracy study of the open source OCR engine, Kraken,
on the leading Arabic scholarly journal, al-Abhath. In contrast with other
commercially available OCR engines, Kraken is shown to be capable of producing
highly accurate Arabic-script OCR. The study also assesses the relative
accuracy of typeface-specific and generalized models on the al-Abhath data and
provides a microanalysis of the ``error instances'' and the contextual features
that may have contributed to OCR misrecognition. Building on this analysis, the
paper argues that Arabic-script OCR can be significantly improved through (1) a
more systematic approach to training data production, and (2) the development
of key technological components, especially multi-language models and improved
line segmentation and layout analysis.
Cet article pr{\'e}sente une {\'e}tude d'exactitude du moteur ROC open
source, Krakan, sur la revue acad{\'e}mique arabe de premier rang, al-Abhath.
Contrairement {\`a} d'autres moteurs ROC disponibles sur le march{\'e}, Kraken
se r{\'e}v{\`e}le {\^e}tre capable de produire de la ROC extr{\^e}mement exacte
de l'{\'e}criture arabe. L'{\'e}tude {\'e}value aussi l'exactitude relative des
mod{\`e}les sp{\'e}cifiquement configur{\'e}s {\`a} des polices et celle des
mod{\`e}les g{\'e}n{\'e}ralis{\'e}s sur les donn{\'e}es d'al-Abhath et fournit
une microanalyse des "occurrences d'erreurs", ainsi qu'une microanalyse des
{\'e}l{\'e}ments contextuels qui pourraient avoir contribu{\'e} {\`a} la
m{\'e}reconnaissance ROC. S'appuyant sur cette analyse, cet article fait valoir
que la ROC de l'{\'e}criture arabe peut {\^e}tre consid{\'e}rablement
am{\'e}lior{\'e}e gr{\^a}ce {\`a} (1) une approche plus syst{\'e}matique
d'entra{\^i}nement de la production de donn{\'e}es et (2) gr{\^a}ce au
d{\'e}veloppement de composants technologiques fondamentaux,
notammentl'am{\'e}lioration des mod{\`e}les multilingues, de la segmentation de
ligne et de l'analyse de la mise en page. | [
-0.014595326,
0.0339000411,
0.010236566,
0.0593021773,
-0.0608853884,
0.0182974003,
0.0507417358,
0.041496221,
-0.0364964195,
-0.0292159393,
0.0127906231,
-0.0174592659,
0.109878175,
0.0377339609,
-0.0166946091,
0.0094940346,
-0.0100391544,
-0.0815603733,
-0.0256176684,
-0.0000818655,
0.0478024893,
0.0264531374,
-0.0144412341,
0.0046077515,
0.0244004298,
-0.0342760421,
-0.0233766064,
-0.0206717923,
-0.00444591,
0.0411511473,
-0.0116155753,
0.038708251,
-0.0195459574,
0.0473634638,
0.0000022015,
-0.0961264372,
-0.078063719,
-0.0055201445,
-0.0238185823,
-0.0074733468,
0.0574883372,
-0.062690571,
-0.0753042772,
-0.0213233214,
0.0317998342,
-0.0000148595,
0.0476559587,
0.0510406569,
-0.0202720799,
0.0266430117,
-0.0046195989,
-0.0688671991,
0.0116490638,
0.052083876,
-0.0203157589,
0.0094044777,
-0.0018590426,
-0.0064945207,
0.0007230286,
0.0183369089,
-0.0205477495,
0.0077207717,
-0.0276050866,
-0.0805162713,
-0.0046693441,
-0.0057669026,
-0.0342412703,
-0.0141717251,
0.0228018221,
0.0018680531,
-0.0048911422,
-0.0213619918,
0.0025397185,
0.0088528777,
-0.0251918621,
0.0289150588,
-0.0091969632,
0.0473571941,
-0.0949600935,
-0.0027553507,
0.0185762327,
0.0212331917,
-0.0301753636,
0.0007934119,
-0.0551337488,
0.0404553637,
-0.0066438653,
-0.0665499195,
0.0417009778,
0.0137775848,
0.0093871225,
0.0032203963,
0.0188535396,
0.0098041194,
0.063762486,
-0.0090018874,
-0.0566918701,
-0.053965725,
0.0281380415,
-0.0440008193,
0.035239879,
0.0902607813,
-0.0027858452,
0.0056830901,
-0.0407578908,
0.0649340451,
0.0039855731,
0.052864857,
-0.020659985,
0.0423135683,
-0.0258417241,
0.0075729312,
-0.0474959053,
-0.0139348097,
-0.0338951871,
-0.0096415821,
-0.0264585111,
-0.0014946812,
0.0288591217,
0.039601244,
-0.0034006748,
-0.0674160644,
-0.0204401407,
-0.0378216095,
-0.0054124808,
-0.0413295142,
0.0473286323,
-0.0159215424,
-0.0760558546,
-0.0671488568,
0.0358618535,
0.0162339918,
0.0491281189,
0.0207472816,
-0.0109253386,
0.0514193214,
-0.0496329144,
-0.0284551568,
-0.0040978622,
0.0607082509,
-0.0339231789,
-0.0157836284,
-0.0245761741,
-0.0569728874,
0.0020544915,
0.0231011789,
-0.0137587888,
0.0295861978,
-0.000817432,
0.0268326234,
0.0100348871,
0.0345391817,
-0.0022378322,
-0.0001350939,
0.0785759762,
-0.0210385993,
0.0384387448,
0.011610792,
0.0210213717,
0.0048891371,
0.006335502,
-0.0036962377,
0.0147283776,
0.0533211753,
-0.0231417362,
-0.0341419391,
-0.0162181761,
-0.0269057117,
0.0581065826,
0.0613669418,
0.0091409078,
0.0315529145,
-0.0280327369,
-0.0076125641,
0.0411690995,
0.0052504339,
0.0243271794,
0.0427687019,
-0.0469438508,
0.0221778769,
0.0805655569,
0.0119978599,
0.0198983401,
-0.0194366015,
0.0377504975,
0.0291403793,
-0.0099101737,
0.0812405199,
0.0220839046,
-0.0214125589,
-0.0413765237,
-0.0071432288,
-0.0386479571,
-0.0308693144,
0.1336628199,
-0.0152242025,
-0.0794287622,
-0.0583060011,
0.0078217518,
-0.0078567099,
-0.0400798693,
-0.0400910228,
0.0178087633,
0.0501468778,
0.1094648018,
-0.0536105335,
0.024762895,
0.0045212642,
-0.0628349632,
0.0179894138,
0.0020675445,
-0.0090299472,
-0.005078115,
-0.0509515814,
-0.0249606855,
0.036341358,
-0.0059734397,
0.0208805762,
-0.0038802088,
0.0689963177,
-0.0114483414,
0.0035951051,
-0.055209659,
0.0300647952,
-0.0032176622,
0.0356119759,
-0.0603686087,
0.0215734299,
-0.0066352133,
0.0225154683,
-0.0324222036,
0.005070237,
-0.0001763651,
-0.056682352,
0.0239716936,
-0.0069373497,
0.0036906598,
0.0591828451,
0.0674758554,
-0.0010480094,
0.0303585641,
0.0099997297,
0.0357848406,
-0.0142286858,
0.0299094971,
-0.0172457825,
0.0316138342,
-0.0153286485,
0.055759728,
-0.0666422173,
-0.0319838747,
-0.0083446661,
0.0436937772,
-0.0154201528,
-0.0269914102,
-0.0128982347,
-0.0974756032,
0.0368385129,
0.0276411772,
0.0041697538,
0.0204346552,
-0.0077706864,
0.0077955881,
0.0156657174,
0.0097537255,
0.0040346915,
-0.0841483399,
0.0016183598,
-0.0300190989,
-0.0013216579,
0.035057839,
0.0075442581,
-0.0090344111,
0.0070460816,
-0.0115014492,
0.0353625268,
-0.053465616,
-0.0257598534,
-0.0365282074,
0.0534410812,
-0.0259009171,
0.0014083814,
-0.0077176415,
-0.0142670348,
0.0200103112,
0.0527979732,
0.0523341745,
-0.0877814814,
-0.0160080623,
-0.0068084113,
0.0199238453,
-0.0073953061,
-0.0211584978,
0.0002999522,
0.0127593344,
-0.0192893129,
-0.010345513,
0.0241895802,
0.0032445502,
-0.0151285995,
0.0246919487,
-0.007744696,
-0.012977723,
-0.0231917333,
0.0267418548,
-0.0160650592,
-0.0070538251,
-0.0697515234,
-0.04160624,
-0.0242879689,
-0.0558392033,
0.054962568,
-0.0093185939,
-0.0346969292,
-0.0203139931,
0.0160584804,
-0.0308401715,
-0.0233089421,
-0.0068547786,
0.0629066899,
-0.0027471378,
-0.0233751554,
-0.0169980247,
-0.0358031355,
-0.0129970675,
-0.0177293643,
0.0421815142,
-0.039252907,
-0.0449911356,
-0.0362767242,
0.0178686734,
0.0323911943,
-0.0549489297,
0.0114403637,
0.0168252531,
0.0549001023,
-0.024506297,
0.0299317893,
-0.0039304718,
0.0760787874,
-0.0364224762,
0.0039669662,
0.0147246774,
0.0141457925,
-0.0186718833,
-0.0530330017,
0.0126093123,
-0.0131557751,
-0.0193952248,
0.0730521083,
0.040821407,
0.0930146575,
-0.0115676606,
0.0274599008,
-0.0070363409,
0.0358068682,
-0.002449716,
-0.0499061719,
0.0120269787,
-0.0635249093,
-0.0038289193,
-0.0023905574,
-0.0379116274,
-0.0424702093,
-0.0280962586,
-0.0134613952,
0.0344024822,
-0.0190985519,
-0.0424986072,
-0.0540240034,
-0.0426695459,
-0.0557573773,
0.0089150043,
0.0522069372,
0.0038121045,
-0.059495315,
-0.0618660562,
-0.0405556783,
-0.0197022427,
-0.040733818,
-0.0217178985,
-0.0868463442,
0.0448970906,
0.0462596528,
0.0834699646,
-0.0147343911,
0.0186839849,
0.0314149447,
-0.0344797298,
0.0064522475,
0.0062892986,
-0.0816267803,
-0.0546428375,
-0.0196801629,
0.0127371652,
-0.0114291171,
-0.0658968017,
-0.0026801676,
-0.0140806241,
0.0186718609,
0.0298128687,
-0.0469427258,
-0.0216850508,
-0.025564393,
0.0129342107,
-0.0246799439,
0.0280521605,
0.0083182137,
-0.0210609622,
-0.0357110761,
-0.0084840041,
-0.0343095474,
-0.0081654442,
-0.0387194976,
0.0427639782,
0.0269902982,
-0.0107222237,
-0.0442839861,
-0.0107094273,
-0.0339879654,
0.0163110569,
-0.0205931757,
-0.0217356645,
-0.0099228276,
0.0475030094,
0.0192207899,
-0.0353249311,
-0.0532511659,
-0.0470480695,
-0.0399386659,
-0.0116115334,
-0.0786393657,
-0.0063597793,
0.0238311272,
-0.0496893711,
-0.0016233254,
-0.0044780136,
-0.0117728272,
-0.0820327029,
-0.0234070271,
0.003052409,
-0.0048031076,
0.0342942327,
0.0189652313,
0.0001372281,
0.0372346006,
0.03740431,
-0.0305750277,
-0.0996462554,
-0.0082919709,
-0.0056265309,
-0.0815236717,
0.0172688141,
-0.039278768,
-0.0666186064,
0.0154079003,
-0.0501305871,
-0.0030987698,
-0.0086090704,
0.0871066824,
0.0170228984,
0.0172354206,
-0.018444404,
0.0061186305,
-0.0356664844,
0.0340615176,
-0.0056270757,
0.0638611093,
0.0109729646,
-0.0084634088,
0.0026914058,
-0.0537081435,
0.0151507845,
0.0214344189,
-0.0180725176,
-0.0202062111,
-0.0906420127,
0.0079843113,
-0.0441192687,
-0.0008199217,
-0.0248008817,
-0.0188548565,
-0.0364718027,
-0.0092265159,
-0.0348105282,
0.0337248035,
-0.0149231926,
0.0246494412,
-0.0118809296,
0.0213467106,
0.0026367302,
0.0172277316,
0.0259638075,
-0.0016407287,
0.0047476082,
0.0021131602,
-0.02298842,
0.0570931137,
0.0089767827,
0.082239978,
0.0125208264,
0.0057797758,
0.0102643156,
-0.0149754221,
-0.0308878534,
0.0340653621,
0.0067330105,
0.0202084538,
-0.0064269165,
0.0071159005,
0.0506186485,
0.0546736494,
-0.003779379,
0.0266828202,
-0.0377072804,
0.0583096594,
0.0533874333,
-0.014878911,
0.0235737506,
0.0153859612,
-0.0100217173,
-0.0125212483,
-0.0030800025,
0.0384792238,
0.0002210525,
-0.070059754,
0.0198940914,
0.0102929631,
0.0013496217,
0.0688648149,
0.0066917641,
-0.0332357138,
0.0318425521,
-0.0250832271,
-0.0221538413,
0.0025321995,
0.0448349863,
-0.0246476438,
-0.0683557391,
-0.0197016746,
-0.0328938924,
0.0087205805,
0.0671788901,
0.0389734544,
-0.0090710083,
-0.0074808393,
-0.0217716601,
0.035476055,
0.0040539037,
0.0141860051,
-0.0249320827,
0.031498298,
-0.031821426,
-0.0269208774,
0.0242229849,
-5.28073021e-33,
0.0320798978,
-0.0309829582,
-0.0073585049,
0.0066192211,
-0.0013260874,
0.0258008186,
0.0067332,
-0.0241796169,
-0.0043790289,
-0.0064616166,
-0.036675185,
-0.0178306308,
0.0439687148,
-0.0111647453,
0.0384435654,
-0.0022560088,
0.009958813,
-0.0155404918,
-0.0494291484,
-0.0165634565,
0.0606179647,
0.029041009,
0.0632887036,
-0.0528378189,
0.0462848321,
-0.0734266043,
-0.0249037873,
-0.0159204751,
0.019949371,
0.0361271389,
0.011856135,
0.0098136952,
0.0230773482,
-0.0078023002,
0.0453342386,
-0.0081877047,
-0.055065833,
0.0556444339,
-0.018030785,
0.108645156,
0.0172698945,
0.0035969715,
-0.0442265533,
0.0000706608,
-0.0566642284,
0.0197561067,
0.0081937555,
-0.0328935869,
-0.038187623,
0.0004156352,
-0.0599079318,
0.0455255099,
0.0069252681,
-0.0060703815,
0.0798587427,
0.0301994402,
0.0047390894,
-0.0140573783,
-0.01503227,
-0.000258502,
0.0144365449,
0.0029064449,
0.0493799709,
0.0267334096,
-0.0519808009,
-0.0389211774,
-0.032194443,
0.002875509,
0.0306279212,
0.0011755328,
0.022429293,
-0.0683239102,
0.0094312113,
0.0729665235,
0.0631536394,
-0.0076335398,
-0.0121817105,
0.0342528261,
-0.0485630371,
0.0344360322,
0.0056942878,
-0.0016548786,
-0.0416208357,
0.009515129,
0.0346774682,
-0.0290027298,
0.0030302897,
0.0422318727,
-0.0099576889,
0.0212911405,
0.0144854235,
0.0236068666,
-0.025466565,
0.0013025736,
0.0441129878,
-0.0399037972,
-0.0195867904,
0.0524388179,
-0.0502374917,
-0.0221948214,
-0.0551473647,
-0.0433092713,
-0.0039918302,
0.0153168477,
-0.0046461457,
0.0137930093,
0.029040046,
0.0291675031,
-0.054470256,
0.0183091443,
0.0125935357,
0.02468119,
0.0642996132,
0.0796485767,
0.00810357,
-0.0543255061,
0.0559137613,
0.0089086471,
0.0673955977,
0.0102435872,
0.0032815128,
-0.0145087298,
-0.0036417278,
-0.0378037803,
-0.0102545628,
0.0281972494,
-0.0125400824,
-0.0000250807,
-0.055035498,
-0.0028107967,
0.0045761075,
0.0248234719,
2.713e-7,
0.0606733933,
0.0313778445,
0.0572008826,
-0.0191157274,
0.0180294942,
-0.0021698785,
-0.0097546428,
0.0478638299,
-0.006301254,
0.0207001474,
0.0562185682,
-0.0337896347,
0.0859770253,
-0.0200501829,
-0.023861507,
-0.0326932482,
0.0139785269,
0.0312585868,
-0.0502913669,
0.037558455,
0.0129586272,
0.0159321725,
-0.0683210567,
-0.0318012089,
-0.013568908,
0.003881233,
0.0244203694,
0.021075014,
0.025389649,
0.0042101247,
0.0533522964,
-0.0308349058,
-0.0326023847,
0.0576233789,
0.0073720706,
0.0070850574,
0.0553630851,
0.0153526375,
-0.0152062215,
0.0613462739,
0.0200207252,
-0.0210306663,
-0.0008279037,
-0.0911852717,
0.040611621,
0.1056609824,
0.022687668,
-0.0417879894,
-0.0280416943,
-0.0124489889,
0.0371516794,
-0.0121524679,
0.0054188096,
0.0267045684,
0.0537974425,
-0.0087354472,
0.0130584845,
0.0023002035,
0.0121208513,
-0.0374728553,
0.0574634708,
0.0016502385,
-0.0146055501,
-0.0275348425,
0.0509671532,
-0.0119728902,
0.0056119855,
2.43419786e-34,
0.0111982077,
-0.0096893348,
-0.0100137936,
0.0286273565,
-0.0044210809,
-0.0216082744,
-0.0112597151,
0.0119292326,
-0.0424028262,
0.0057953917,
0.027737854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05629v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05629v4 | Merging Facts, Crafting Fallacies: Evaluating the Contradictory Nature of Aggregated Factual Claims in Long-Form Generations | 2024-02-08T12:36:29 | 2024-06-07T02:28:40 | Cheng-Han Chiang, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long-form generations from large language models (LLMs) contain a mix of
factual and non-factual claims, making evaluating factuality difficult. Prior
works evaluate the factuality of a long paragraph by decomposing it into
multiple facts, verifying those facts independently, and aggregating the
results. Such methods assume that combining factual claims forms a factual
paragraph. The above assumption can be violated: we show that strong
open-source models like Llama-chat can generate paragraphs that contain
verifiable facts, but the facts are combined into a non-factual paragraph due
to entity ambiguity. We further reveal that existing factuality metrics,
including FActScore and citation recall, cannot properly evaluate these
non-factual paragraphs and overestimate their factuality. To address this, we
introduce an enhanced metric, D-FActScore, specifically designed for content
with ambiguous entities. We evaluate the D-FActScores of people biographies
generated by retrieval-augmented LLMs. We show that D-FActScore can better
assess the factuality of paragraphs with entity ambiguity than FActScore. We
also find that four widely used open-source LLMs tend to mix information of
distinct entities to form non-factual paragraphs, making their D-FActScore much
lower than FActScore by over 10%. | [
0.034479782,
0.058623895,
-0.0101183932,
0.0353434049,
-0.0415390283,
0.0097253071,
0.00225428,
-0.0072226617,
0.0072254525,
-0.0584133491,
0.0678032637,
-0.05863427,
0.0537057966,
0.0021103227,
0.0030065838,
-0.0144491084,
0.0589109473,
0.0303497352,
0.0578940846,
-0.0171078295,
-0.0057824152,
0.0240673963,
-0.0176702291,
0.0217974894,
-0.0312767476,
-0.0234182607,
0.0051780608,
0.0047118803,
0.0461305119,
0.008630516,
-0.0077203824,
0.0386911258,
-0.0240241252,
0.0719416887,
0.0000017646,
-0.0689631253,
0.0048709153,
0.0190102644,
-0.0628918856,
0.0313944481,
0.0579654835,
0.0423528999,
-0.0275631174,
0.0029153202,
-0.0086554587,
-0.0273846295,
0.0006484581,
0.0604519993,
0.0638905317,
0.0865570009,
0.0208818763,
-0.0354538262,
0.0519554988,
-0.0159143731,
0.0058866683,
0.0082811769,
0.0294031873,
0.0046074539,
-0.0400400646,
0.0235064067,
0.0335536972,
0.0280780457,
-0.0033595087,
-0.0275259987,
0.0327401906,
0.0253711715,
-0.0235145129,
-0.0101460107,
0.03410298,
0.0123065049,
0.0575891919,
-0.009255195,
0.0421249568,
0.0059549315,
0.0321520641,
0.0277506374,
-0.0186055899,
0.061620649,
-0.0426621325,
-0.0168348812,
0.0154186552,
-0.0320935138,
0.0244005043,
0.0148687847,
0.0154998256,
0.0236666519,
0.0105631799,
-0.0283887628,
-0.0092568062,
-0.0129213259,
0.0271975026,
-0.0766030252,
-0.0039028253,
0.0214033071,
-0.0119424621,
0.0198383462,
-0.039570462,
-0.0034572934,
0.0645691454,
-0.0825505257,
0.0029468478,
-0.0041433466,
-0.0186677855,
0.0503171682,
-0.0142727224,
0.0288500842,
-0.0087501099,
-0.0393792056,
0.001435327,
0.0018224106,
-0.0213830397,
-0.0127880303,
0.0271513686,
0.0423222929,
-0.0116886282,
0.0083817476,
-0.0533981845,
-0.0259540863,
-0.0277367923,
0.0152689787,
-0.0133764213,
0.0097974082,
-0.0037781089,
0.0003765499,
-0.0858664066,
0.0453187414,
-0.0163716376,
0.0233324785,
0.0052395929,
-0.0435687527,
-0.0048477687,
0.0090222582,
-0.0044384315,
0.0097878939,
-0.0096494239,
-0.0072954907,
-0.0028723029,
-0.0104204314,
-0.0611234419,
-0.0480802916,
-0.032779716,
-0.0795991346,
-0.0085669989,
-0.077075161,
0.0320041217,
-0.0177479926,
-0.0149252238,
-0.0553939305,
0.0148842689,
0.0424114689,
-0.0541918278,
0.0035756328,
0.0128267445,
0.0105684083,
0.0604643896,
0.0087447818,
0.0129943043,
0.0533807017,
0.0465989709,
0.0148903932,
0.0414408408,
0.0696853474,
-0.0012852019,
-0.0063301465,
0.018389944,
0.0340382271,
0.0634425059,
-0.015076017,
-0.0166238789,
0.0147876227,
0.0258580688,
0.066628933,
-0.0052318401,
-0.0269226525,
0.0780059695,
-0.0109506752,
-0.0046129329,
0.0052723428,
0.0478959158,
0.007702006,
0.0581373982,
0.0332917497,
-0.0291657094,
-0.0057774363,
-0.0278363843,
-0.0042333519,
0.0418460555,
0.0867574587,
0.010049561,
-0.039417401,
-0.0106096258,
-0.0054368745,
-0.0053563197,
-0.0080929687,
0.0015957081,
0.0145821488,
-0.0406417102,
0.0829128474,
0.0302315895,
-0.0868685693,
0.0082825096,
-0.0237942562,
0.0356531031,
0.0265733041,
0.042051591,
0.0128581738,
-0.0302302148,
-0.0202258453,
0.0073998496,
0.0469459556,
0.044688452,
-0.0104612391,
-0.0122183627,
-0.0056062969,
-0.0110960305,
-0.008586037,
0.0533414222,
-0.0068139089,
0.0467518829,
-0.0126462504,
0.0402355641,
-0.0224020276,
-0.0123461634,
0.0289989021,
-0.0361958742,
0.0353208706,
-0.0153836804,
-0.0071013351,
0.0152557613,
0.0413037166,
-0.0005251558,
-0.0079643792,
0.023139935,
0.0056500109,
-0.052552022,
-0.012214507,
0.004391484,
-0.0068318164,
0.0373331234,
-0.0215362739,
-0.0370343886,
-0.0198689681,
-0.0097133545,
-0.0109234788,
-0.0090847416,
-0.0634074807,
0.0137743559,
-0.020876009,
0.0319036506,
-0.0147311166,
-0.0214584451,
-0.0088973818,
0.1378261894,
-0.0180753525,
0.0149900969,
-0.0157877803,
-0.01823695,
0.0178193338,
-0.063918218,
-0.0189841837,
-0.0185856596,
0.0047832499,
-0.0022296268,
0.0288587436,
-0.0399119258,
-0.0566130877,
-0.021775974,
-0.0771474466,
0.0640055835,
-0.0182673763,
0.0268638674,
-0.0022957786,
-0.0272259209,
-0.004088304,
0.0294350628,
-0.0165300388,
-0.0543143116,
-0.0189182851,
0.0175362471,
0.0365736149,
0.0082124472,
-0.0108128013,
-0.0129541205,
0.0116412193,
-0.0326366015,
0.0354460068,
0.029696906,
-0.0035024416,
-0.0341546461,
0.047829017,
-0.0824988186,
-0.008746692,
-0.0217455104,
-0.0038613335,
0.0094473902,
0.0413862281,
0.0770138353,
0.0707293749,
0.0374919996,
0.0173957851,
0.0010415919,
-0.000664999,
-0.0020230301,
-0.0088402191,
-0.0269406252,
0.0062829005,
0.007728335,
-0.0632605776,
0.0020711105,
-0.0065249419,
0.0107302172,
-0.0202591512,
-0.0421330109,
0.0299503375,
-0.0437952839,
0.0042699664,
0.0262369215,
-0.0317986757,
-0.0203040168,
0.0147958016,
-0.029890649,
-0.0169626791,
0.044916708,
-0.0395847186,
0.0545171052,
0.0030786465,
0.0000228872,
-0.0205530021,
0.0433923565,
0.0071765203,
0.0032720368,
0.0240856614,
-0.0086981775,
-0.0371287838,
0.0263106022,
0.0438434891,
-0.0621144846,
0.0583814122,
-0.0372022912,
0.0104221487,
0.0122830691,
-0.0236757658,
-0.0447022766,
-0.0507992581,
0.0158849154,
-0.0099348444,
-0.0189986322,
-0.0380623564,
-0.0760370046,
-0.0606828295,
0.0674426705,
-0.0137454709,
-0.022238275,
-0.0014214008,
-0.0055337506,
0.0114925234,
0.0252972115,
0.0051401812,
0.0649957433,
-0.037613593,
-0.0203030538,
0.0639621913,
-0.0025662766,
0.0132636484,
0.0166640505,
-0.0669730976,
-0.0347544663,
-0.0281235129,
-0.0497178398,
0.0135454983,
0.04973929,
-0.0699030012,
0.0081236092,
0.090044044,
0.0264134016,
0.0456943847,
-0.0326986201,
-0.0026798756,
0.0014531588,
0.0103314156,
-0.0275352746,
-0.0855287164,
0.0186780151,
0.004310641,
-0.001264077,
-0.052766636,
-0.0328865312,
-0.0159967467,
-0.1311923265,
0.0345831849,
0.0010123722,
0.0222827718,
-0.0163322762,
-0.0692556351,
0.016634034,
-0.0097866394,
-0.0039235181,
0.0273249391,
-0.0102241831,
-0.0061430563,
-0.0114127835,
-0.0169961583,
-0.0289736781,
0.0039993259,
-0.0260961112,
0.036161948,
0.0005804285,
0.0694651902,
0.0020111606,
-0.0391351879,
-0.0065157181,
-0.0393219925,
-0.0554097928,
0.0124544203,
0.062557295,
0.0080162669,
0.0197129156,
-0.0565253459,
0.0103909504,
0.0675813258,
-0.0281046219,
-0.0285029821,
0.0268696956,
-0.0032705101,
-0.0146682123,
-0.0157555137,
0.0236271489,
0.0083406046,
0.1001225486,
0.0088688061,
0.0269922018,
-0.0102153253,
-0.0424365699,
0.0182632059,
-0.0199001543,
-0.0286531895,
0.0586654618,
-0.0472431108,
-0.0415196829,
-0.0792096853,
-0.0416412726,
-0.0369673073,
0.0025533328,
0.008202753,
0.0099695288,
0.0622171648,
-0.0102451174,
-0.0378893837,
0.0188668501,
-0.0516436994,
0.0143481102,
-0.0100125372,
0.0018714005,
0.0185846128,
0.0161323883,
-0.0058339615,
0.0032071273,
-0.065887779,
-0.0490764678,
0.0400357768,
-0.0188501794,
0.0248761326,
0.0277085677,
-0.0213133506,
-0.0375254527,
0.0742786676,
0.0703174472,
-0.0205941219,
0.0497591794,
-0.0060857753,
-0.0057542017,
0.0037976836,
0.0080489898,
-0.0346708857,
-0.0002404273,
-0.026954934,
0.002877109,
-0.0326035023,
-0.0445403419,
0.0036754939,
0.0324338153,
0.0202374533,
-0.0136494413,
-0.00491211,
-0.0225307923,
-0.0169098396,
-0.0514809787,
-0.0319683217,
0.0185677987,
-0.0096775396,
-0.0081309639,
0.0271476917,
0.0016343525,
0.0328155905,
-0.0299640112,
0.0692065656,
-0.0363228507,
-0.0286992956,
-0.013286151,
0.0070295502,
0.00029072,
-0.038897451,
-0.0336598158,
0.0001821877,
-0.0328251906,
0.0504228584,
0.0067425827,
0.0282215215,
0.0083157727,
0.0110460026,
0.0095511312,
-0.0312218498,
-0.0758739859,
0.0062863925,
-0.0073568132,
0.0226104036,
0.0279520303,
0.019221684,
0.0787148327,
0.0009500851,
-0.0194538999,
-0.0121112764,
-0.0037745782,
0.0078902012,
-0.0441829674,
0.0206462871,
0.0087631447,
-0.0287484676,
0.04974024,
0.0362606794,
-0.0093742767,
0.0547569692,
-0.011852717,
-0.0295546073,
-0.0198392607,
-0.0861419439,
-0.049437236,
-0.000782591,
0.0054471907,
-0.0449697711,
-0.1190317497,
-0.0292270519,
0.057255812,
0.0441845693,
0.0333193801,
-0.009048285,
0.0005701489,
0.0484497026,
-0.0090517169,
-0.0599933676,
-0.0660519302,
0.0274749883,
-0.0088048,
0.012461138,
0.007401824,
-6.429773367e-33,
-0.0405412838,
-0.0648902655,
-0.0068733259,
0.0012870852,
-0.0630340502,
0.0315863937,
-0.0172384512,
-0.0047206054,
-0.0466719195,
0.0488020703,
0.0100190956,
0.0498152003,
0.0166245587,
-0.0029966165,
-0.0232499223,
-0.01267506,
0.0600764528,
0.0203996804,
-0.048484806,
0.0350301117,
0.0573766679,
-0.0266688783,
0.0073871319,
-0.067572929,
0.0874582678,
-0.0314578302,
-0.0275939237,
0.0134122483,
-0.0212147906,
0.0536960401,
0.014225062,
0.0250045191,
0.0160424244,
-0.0406293869,
0.015139373,
0.0246260483,
-0.0709402263,
-0.0025602158,
0.0662192851,
-0.0224770829,
0.0117208986,
-0.0362255387,
0.0517152101,
0.022704903,
-0.0151576363,
-0.0472888537,
0.0583360605,
-0.0234241448,
0.0062961164,
-0.0490147844,
-0.0404827558,
0.0300505813,
0.024271097,
0.0028863417,
-0.0630489364,
-0.0026487412,
0.0287584737,
0.0128828855,
-0.0899726599,
0.0124496045,
-0.0218196344,
0.0225730296,
0.0089282375,
-0.0420414358,
-0.0082824724,
0.0772266537,
-0.0259253923,
0.0428498685,
-0.0900997818,
-0.0072069275,
0.0102626262,
0.0237999763,
0.0423104391,
0.1141101718,
-0.002066951,
-0.0073926328,
-0.0886763185,
0.0247820467,
0.036329072,
0.0309147537,
-0.0019316286,
-0.0239775311,
-0.038135726,
-0.0107534695,
-0.0353040993,
0.0138133597,
-0.0209723376,
0.0027059077,
-0.0131914923,
0.0121776862,
-0.0295697898,
-0.0137252975,
-0.0043478091,
-0.0142257111,
0.0052976282,
0.0330069661,
-0.0340153761,
0.0092694648,
-0.0111491196,
0.0120277461,
-0.0286994427,
0.0129714925,
0.0308824554,
0.022675259,
0.0309481658,
0.0007178251,
0.052648399,
-0.0242486093,
-0.0647551641,
0.0100248968,
-0.0090086441,
0.0143924532,
-0.0243381895,
-0.0526629798,
0.0481286682,
0.0352527425,
-0.0021655152,
0.0071508121,
0.0586501509,
0.0622870177,
-0.0514298081,
-0.0057054255,
-0.0050859982,
0.003994497,
-0.0107260533,
0.0188211538,
-0.0274562296,
0.0507915467,
-0.0053592273,
-0.056661889,
-0.012098317,
-0.0122020645,
2.541e-7,
0.015587192,
0.0588772148,
-0.005102485,
0.0315421522,
0.0050720372,
0.0509314314,
0.0128624365,
0.0007868183,
0.0137858568,
-0.0541384444,
-0.0457052328,
0.020008022,
0.0352981426,
0.0489554033,
-0.0746714324,
-0.0012693543,
-0.0583394505,
-0.0496527888,
-0.0634989291,
0.00523671,
0.0612251423,
0.0240449365,
0.065857254,
-0.0139026847,
-0.0188147333,
-0.0220720544,
0.0659009218,
0.0386861488,
-0.0948825628,
0.0314427838,
0.0748487115,
-0.0049114251,
0.0054402389,
0.015450133,
-0.0182872042,
0.0218889378,
-0.0044845082,
0.0632501021,
0.0315913819,
-0.003067865,
-0.0064664925,
-0.0278558154,
-0.0156518817,
-0.0260936785,
0.0532554835,
0.0202462468,
-0.0246040095,
-0.0572616123,
-0.0598259494,
0.03956585,
0.0138585148,
0.0211551096,
-0.0418169908,
0.018903574,
-0.0293351039,
-0.0000715731,
0.0023350189,
-0.0387353562,
-0.0319776088,
0.0352199152,
-0.0369231477,
-0.0829174817,
0.0254984628,
-0.0192298703,
0.0120989326,
-0.0809969828,
0.0318770744,
2.288038913e-34,
0.018328581,
-0.0070708385,
0.0166585278,
-0.0556203946,
0.051355511,
0.022658173,
-0.0048152311,
-0.0062994198,
-0.0026634398,
-0.0271359216,
0.0233454313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05624v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05624v1 | Efficient Models for the Detection of Hate, Abuse and Profanity | 2024-02-08T12:28:18 | 2024-02-08T12:28:18 | Christoph Tillmann, Aashka Trivedi, Bishwaranjan Bhattacharjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Large Language Models (LLMs) are the cornerstone for many Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks like sentiment analysis, document classification, named
entity recognition, question answering, summarization, etc. LLMs are often
trained on data which originates from the web. This data is prone to having
content with Hate, Abuse and Profanity (HAP). For a detailed definition of HAP,
please refer to the Appendix. Due to the LLMs being exposed to HAP content
during training, the models learn it and may then generate hateful or profane
content. For example, when the open-source RoBERTa model (specifically, the
RoBERTA base model) from the HuggingFace (HF) Transformers library is prompted
to replace the mask token in `I do not know that Persian people are that MASK`
it returns the word `stupid` with the highest score. This is unacceptable in
civil discourse.The detection of Hate, Abuse and Profanity in text is a vital
component of creating civil and unbiased LLMs, which is needed not only for
English, but for all languages. In this article, we briefly describe the
creation of HAP detectors and various ways of using them to make models civil
and acceptable in the output they generate. | [
0.0861809924,
0.0607064925,
-0.0248574968,
0.049405206,
-0.0097571099,
0.0423520766,
0.0158057269,
0.0356029831,
0.0415478982,
-0.0835898519,
0.0021192573,
-0.0187917538,
-0.0279536881,
0.0321074277,
-0.0122141587,
-0.0600322522,
0.0400000811,
0.0460115522,
0.0194024909,
-0.0139344223,
0.0590974353,
0.0046749944,
0.0067138509,
0.0331267416,
-0.0727928728,
0.0280241985,
0.0331911072,
0.0037904568,
0.0170809627,
0.0159643665,
0.0364146456,
0.0305406507,
-0.0194031298,
0.0516695715,
0.000001854,
-0.032186538,
0.0036165281,
-0.0055734133,
0.0123601649,
-0.0546646342,
0.1505548805,
-0.0157999434,
-0.0379501618,
0.037414711,
-0.0265511107,
-0.0039430829,
0.0552276485,
0.0585643239,
0.0782233402,
0.0600371361,
-0.0057551428,
-0.0452998169,
-0.0016961977,
0.0398975983,
-0.013146488,
0.0455000363,
0.0681269467,
-0.0393841267,
-0.0773052052,
-0.0040714014,
-0.0149728777,
0.015815679,
-0.0060726074,
0.0194542073,
0.0294285454,
-0.0346166641,
-0.0326216184,
-0.0500044376,
-0.0015419247,
0.0139924977,
-0.0626999587,
-0.0354704857,
0.010533561,
0.006987087,
-0.0402019285,
-0.0255401265,
0.0163100567,
0.0177606475,
-0.0264509842,
0.0266840644,
0.0232908186,
-0.0107768262,
0.0304295197,
0.0758190826,
0.0055490267,
0.0250397567,
0.001887794,
-0.0407028124,
0.0211323742,
-0.0134507352,
-0.0181562621,
-0.000279194,
0.0367115214,
0.0235680416,
0.0157690551,
0.0281890072,
-0.0553022102,
-0.0467648506,
0.0237820502,
-0.1039744765,
0.0078102062,
0.0414019227,
-0.026874641,
-0.0018367402,
-0.0018198162,
0.0231423322,
0.0053809923,
0.0186179634,
-0.0019423655,
-0.0049298601,
0.0151167987,
0.0189741775,
-0.0150830001,
0.0154122291,
-0.0418018103,
0.050318189,
-0.0554599501,
0.0072299875,
-0.0385695472,
-0.0062649515,
0.0115599297,
-0.004681963,
0.0009511926,
0.0249256101,
-0.034129139,
-0.0296213217,
-0.025957698,
-0.0000646944,
-0.0754555985,
-0.079858616,
0.0447992906,
0.026193006,
-0.0365464129,
-0.0083714686,
0.0563684665,
0.0822341517,
0.041525051,
-0.0465926342,
-0.0433999822,
-0.0176854879,
-0.0323522836,
-0.0391252488,
0.0237629376,
-0.0296878554,
0.0161754508,
-0.0305332821,
-0.0460523218,
-0.0602588616,
0.0152207287,
0.0108110989,
-0.0739389509,
0.0639328659,
-0.0408941433,
-0.0086228205,
0.0579224266,
0.0098317554,
-0.0044217496,
0.0401393063,
-0.0025287066,
0.0075187786,
0.0581818707,
0.0006902668,
-0.0069533684,
0.0580954626,
0.0276402291,
0.0098044453,
-0.0494801812,
0.003646984,
-0.0402956046,
-0.0352203362,
0.0029918775,
0.0877310708,
0.0000733265,
-0.0640246421,
0.031026125,
0.0581395701,
-0.0615435801,
0.02777794,
0.053971082,
0.0182256121,
-0.0120089669,
-0.005112662,
-0.0559588447,
-0.0507839471,
-0.0428807959,
-0.0519486144,
0.0147700077,
0.0673767254,
-0.0049858959,
-0.0589577034,
-0.0357278027,
-0.0175683834,
0.0461061709,
-0.0338635743,
0.0484779105,
0.0181333236,
-0.0187643375,
-0.0305159576,
0.0654922649,
-0.0340428762,
0.0222613979,
-0.0614063293,
0.0307130385,
0.0887959227,
0.0287888832,
-0.0058520129,
-0.0039945752,
-0.0720341429,
-0.0407619439,
0.0329952165,
-0.015310064,
-0.0048861667,
-0.0198293775,
-0.0340892188,
-0.0051945858,
0.0602314621,
0.0154645611,
-0.0070901518,
0.0392873995,
0.01129888,
0.0024645226,
0.0848411694,
-0.0337850638,
0.0387560241,
0.0373984091,
-0.0155353565,
-0.0429196395,
0.029853886,
0.0702101067,
0.022144625,
-0.0187128577,
-0.0563417375,
0.0252245869,
-0.0148850475,
-0.0427210629,
-0.0091736196,
-0.0121610751,
0.0113152973,
0.031517148,
-0.0642700866,
0.0072568916,
0.064570412,
0.0159097258,
0.0367465019,
0.0272895768,
-0.0384041667,
-0.0000563354,
-0.0375395268,
-0.0009283616,
-0.0629493222,
0.021001067,
-0.0214844625,
0.0702501759,
-0.0416023619,
0.0156251676,
0.0089121489,
-0.0623509325,
0.0235579722,
0.0251172036,
-0.0889007822,
-0.0119374665,
-0.0333661847,
0.0170012899,
0.0122782243,
0.026837565,
0.0015267645,
0.0062682759,
-0.0501115657,
-0.0084215757,
-0.0075673843,
-0.0068684919,
0.0096812891,
-0.0116201853,
-0.0264809951,
0.0204836149,
0.0007477307,
-0.0433713906,
0.0655081347,
0.0200337395,
0.0104265148,
-0.069934994,
-0.0408316106,
-0.0185096022,
-0.0167547856,
-0.0205140617,
0.0214076862,
0.0169945862,
-0.0471733771,
0.0320231691,
0.0059706853,
-0.0444535278,
0.0475171283,
-0.0002253827,
-0.0825422928,
0.0164482482,
0.0144205699,
-0.0239473749,
0.0658915192,
0.05804573,
0.0779596418,
0.0169613715,
-0.001404858,
-0.0034668106,
-0.0037050275,
-0.02150058,
0.0131903412,
-0.0160474237,
-0.0480613299,
0.0060261372,
0.0731852651,
0.049339924,
-0.0260500051,
-0.0642036572,
0.0423237607,
-0.075477466,
-0.0376371592,
-0.0081791123,
-0.0984020308,
-0.027626235,
-0.0171572529,
-0.0160641111,
-0.052702345,
0.037457563,
0.0091124875,
0.0240755882,
-0.049809318,
-0.0032884835,
0.0116961179,
0.0258913431,
0.0248774122,
0.0697001219,
-0.0252157804,
-0.0162694585,
0.01912353,
-0.0279709529,
0.017082544,
-0.0374619663,
-0.0207144972,
-0.0012904606,
-0.0135950446,
-0.0043049259,
-0.0406710245,
-0.0753058866,
-0.0373674035,
-0.0516852848,
-0.0589567646,
0.0503827259,
0.0142848175,
0.010371089,
0.0278819837,
0.0047200574,
-0.0262158271,
0.0073331106,
0.0151409376,
0.0195240173,
-0.0541947894,
-0.0083136158,
-0.0442641675,
0.0230633114,
0.0256875362,
-0.0475594439,
0.0695476308,
-0.0057979007,
-0.0013359195,
-0.0054643098,
0.0228463914,
0.0321990661,
-0.0000638777,
-0.0041437736,
-0.0164366029,
-0.0094540641,
-0.0141947251,
0.0130668702,
0.089350462,
0.0194265507,
-0.0000550917,
0.0031187185,
-0.0094908671,
-0.0151978917,
0.0128721604,
-0.0280928593,
-0.0863656774,
0.0172141325,
0.0050154058,
0.0030313067,
-0.106881313,
-0.0367040336,
0.0391377062,
-0.0458958782,
0.009486381,
-0.0002938738,
-0.0510887317,
-0.0305374339,
0.0017019402,
0.0126669444,
-0.0025879676,
0.0121371802,
-0.0198206715,
0.0063653179,
0.0011570014,
0.0274200831,
-0.0323290452,
-0.0019115076,
0.0012286135,
-0.0354086235,
0.0334431343,
0.0445226915,
0.0628791079,
-0.0450094491,
-0.047470618,
0.0121457214,
-0.005267058,
-0.0124388412,
-0.0724951997,
0.0478877202,
-0.0196888112,
-0.0398126841,
-0.0442927964,
0.0198604241,
-0.0088630384,
0.0222377162,
-0.0100109912,
0.037107192,
0.0377338938,
0.0181353856,
-0.061975088,
0.0387871377,
-0.0137558319,
0.0725738257,
0.0169342589,
-0.050273288,
-0.0011619629,
-0.0446234345,
-0.0082349833,
-0.0179702081,
-0.0810347721,
0.0042370167,
-0.0236210022,
-0.0445492305,
-0.0573307574,
-0.0100553446,
0.0392140448,
0.0095713828,
0.0447587296,
-0.0287098158,
0.0020701543,
0.0104624135,
-0.0446565449,
-0.0367090292,
0.0076613505,
0.0220524594,
-0.0334774368,
-0.0061617177,
-0.0007744836,
-0.0050815283,
-0.031934835,
0.020123817,
-0.0070467456,
-0.0475386381,
0.1168396398,
0.0708134919,
0.0230272692,
-0.0157242026,
-0.0114833554,
-0.0533371344,
0.0081334515,
0.0490610227,
-0.0441456847,
-0.0097625181,
0.0488009304,
0.0077324584,
0.0123479469,
0.000505418,
0.0091017988,
0.0371509679,
0.0327442549,
-0.0548925921,
-0.0451440215,
-0.032514669,
-0.0145706739,
0.0230049938,
0.0362187028,
-0.0086510396,
-0.0723538324,
-0.0260395724,
-0.014687757,
0.001576922,
-0.0197661892,
0.0015300985,
0.0375323333,
-0.0171558559,
0.0353054628,
-0.0596260056,
-0.0351017118,
-0.0680268183,
0.033232145,
-0.0086141238,
0.0169285666,
0.0419527479,
0.0273588244,
0.0153141189,
0.0196046326,
-0.0262326617,
0.013855679,
0.0269138478,
-0.0361307375,
-0.0028433795,
0.0139346328,
0.0107165929,
-0.0071158041,
0.0146682374,
-0.0021996221,
0.0125547936,
0.014352941,
-0.0616010316,
-0.0173852853,
-0.006339442,
-0.0003553146,
0.0043634819,
-0.004389612,
-0.018663425,
-0.0077100722,
0.0070472546,
-0.0070176371,
-0.046196606,
0.0359884351,
0.0060586715,
-0.0391765274,
-0.0269171204,
0.0145287896,
0.0113929845,
0.0534293167,
0.0701405481,
-0.0440310501,
-0.0337428823,
0.0018876946,
0.0496304333,
-0.0043378728,
-0.0179523248,
0.0454585217,
-0.0582820363,
-0.0406874754,
0.0068155066,
-0.0202819332,
0.0413886681,
-0.0095249517,
0.0221929718,
0.0615633428,
0.0164524559,
0.0073302058,
-0.0245396588,
0.0343687795,
0.0098457541,
-0.0513896756,
0.0168631747,
-5.648704023e-33,
-0.0326030441,
-0.0286176857,
-0.0215785448,
0.0291065108,
-0.0260210913,
-0.053779088,
0.0545960292,
0.0139277205,
-0.0205594972,
0.0167329852,
0.0042371466,
0.0015216969,
0.0119594419,
-0.0091635156,
0.000103492,
-0.0242572799,
0.047236532,
-0.0240058657,
0.0005927641,
-0.0047500548,
0.0513298735,
0.025169652,
0.0437295847,
-0.0488831736,
0.0335327275,
-0.0142633645,
-0.0471386425,
0.0443210267,
-0.0049266177,
0.0678709224,
-0.0238018166,
0.0605132468,
0.0278363358,
0.0298938397,
0.0121673224,
0.0445816852,
-0.051130902,
0.0078274347,
0.037280567,
0.0472495705,
0.017816361,
-0.020342065,
0.0662246123,
0.0076917619,
-0.0792520866,
0.0014476153,
0.0317979939,
-0.0471541211,
0.0035733688,
-0.0516349375,
-0.0747841671,
0.0166415442,
-0.0155129982,
0.002848912,
-0.0067558638,
-0.0046943068,
0.0261887386,
0.0039662262,
-0.0385368951,
0.0082515562,
0.0273191612,
-0.021585051,
-0.0165893286,
0.0013554088,
0.025828572,
0.0670138672,
0.0361301638,
-0.0136599494,
-0.0007108783,
0.0323910043,
0.0573435836,
0.0173111632,
0.035725154,
0.0577938333,
0.0168777462,
-0.0718239471,
-0.0477435105,
-0.007854457,
0.0366015472,
0.0477700196,
0.0194477662,
-0.0363635421,
-0.0744099766,
-0.0225996375,
-0.0001538148,
-0.0623145849,
-0.0139645096,
-0.0307817142,
0.0165900756,
-0.0170050487,
-0.0325076915,
0.0105082365,
-0.00335503,
-0.039127253,
0.0247949138,
0.0208191555,
-0.0046056588,
-0.0115601197,
0.0213141199,
0.0361563899,
-0.0270988625,
-0.0187730026,
-0.0136903152,
-0.0459422618,
0.0268598236,
-0.0094802957,
0.0511833243,
0.0432410799,
-0.0782596618,
0.0215756912,
0.0025933129,
0.0759983882,
0.0078371288,
0.0814281702,
0.0036329993,
0.0337633379,
-0.0117785204,
-0.0267342459,
0.0245026518,
-0.0133231999,
-0.0402471721,
0.0277979951,
-0.018247813,
-0.0007000907,
-0.0080981674,
-0.0083953543,
0.0007391879,
0.0224099979,
0.0285384916,
-0.0960028172,
0.006021901,
-0.0371805243,
2.536e-7,
0.0200572424,
0.0427230597,
0.0074068815,
-0.007902056,
0.0172926225,
0.0356105268,
0.0212774295,
0.0237388257,
0.0064991168,
0.0307226963,
-0.0200300869,
0.0153955286,
0.0068083163,
0.0340413228,
-0.0296673197,
-0.0167495552,
-0.0512758307,
-0.0251825079,
-0.0207209028,
0.0163705219,
0.0086968392,
0.0838674307,
0.0523518063,
-0.0486195385,
-0.02523393,
-0.0103469742,
-0.0071135424,
-0.0422530621,
-0.008900417,
-0.0036719865,
0.0521324426,
0.0196613371,
0.0182329454,
0.0062713251,
0.0094518941,
0.0016959547,
0.027885424,
0.0509904847,
0.0072267489,
0.0247363448,
0.0149127645,
-0.034558244,
-0.0236813091,
-0.0392291062,
0.0510790423,
0.0523197465,
0.0167723633,
-0.0432026424,
-0.0309397429,
-0.0196575951,
0.0245255586,
-0.0512746312,
-0.0087321252,
0.000921584,
0.0329467058,
-0.0186400693,
0.01603771,
-0.0529548749,
0.0234535392,
-0.0295807049,
-0.0032672109,
-0.0467274487,
0.0109821474,
0.0133684333,
0.0224800259,
0.0332856216,
0.0186538678,
2.224209799e-34,
0.023575997,
-0.0257437471,
-0.0114365453,
-0.0003227547,
0.0344237611,
0.0343588479,
-0.0044119912,
0.0004633157,
0.0115698064,
-0.0150344623,
-0.0042148624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05617v1 | Deep Learning-based Computational Job Market Analysis: A Survey on Skill Extraction and Classification from Job Postings | 2024-02-08T12:20:28 | 2024-02-08T12:20:28 | Elena Senger, Mike Zhang, Rob van der Goot, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent years have brought significant advances to Natural Language Processing
(NLP), which enabled fast progress in the field of computational job market
analysis. Core tasks in this application domain are skill extraction and
classification from job postings. Because of its quick growth and its
interdisciplinary nature, there is no exhaustive assessment of this emerging
field. This survey aims to fill this gap by providing a comprehensive overview
of deep learning methodologies, datasets, and terminologies specific to
NLP-driven skill extraction and classification. Our comprehensive cataloging of
publicly available datasets addresses the lack of consolidated information on
dataset creation and characteristics. Finally, the focus on terminology
addresses the current lack of consistent definitions for important concepts,
such as hard and soft skills, and terms relating to skill extraction and
classification. | [
0.0343924388,
0.0390355438,
-0.0175999552,
-0.0229630321,
-0.012636032,
-0.0146641973,
0.0180677772,
-0.0196400862,
0.0123910438,
-0.0346304178,
0.015079191,
-0.0297566075,
0.0005827313,
0.0155676557,
0.0169274546,
0.008277907,
-0.0088032316,
0.0457541011,
-0.0156992152,
0.0334699117,
-0.0228226054,
0.0665186942,
-0.0160539243,
0.0799804181,
-0.0122455778,
-0.0342671387,
0.0301892757,
-0.037800137,
0.0392223969,
0.0035126889,
0.0311098881,
-0.0097335782,
0.0245187413,
-0.0014375371,
0.0000018486,
0.0074867597,
-0.0051283552,
-0.0153209008,
-0.0415141396,
-0.0634350777,
0.0381812267,
-0.0305123627,
0.0191779677,
0.0481287576,
-0.0442390256,
-0.0441730879,
0.0537836887,
-0.0023355489,
0.0249763317,
0.0252808779,
0.0161344483,
-0.0239976197,
0.0031601186,
-0.0355748273,
-0.0011034007,
-0.0335836485,
0.0475839488,
-0.0842911005,
-0.0130760819,
-0.0230303705,
0.0211942717,
0.0004276066,
0.0075123082,
-0.0589668453,
-0.0201613959,
-0.0039585955,
-0.0193280205,
0.0129100988,
0.0122630876,
0.0473018661,
-0.0353018306,
-0.0135330809,
-0.0405035019,
-0.0472029783,
0.0192179941,
0.0335133299,
0.0044169491,
0.0256103463,
-0.0157888327,
0.0001531368,
-0.0113258138,
0.030526001,
0.0071649151,
-0.0079442598,
0.0086569106,
0.0896710008,
-0.03786394,
-0.0408874527,
0.0606182404,
-0.0088757668,
0.058430098,
-0.0253525749,
0.0416928865,
-0.022503987,
-0.0044323131,
0.0129692266,
-0.0006616139,
0.000897589,
-0.0028355592,
-0.047164198,
-0.0141510712,
-0.0143156741,
-0.0344200656,
0.0349666439,
0.0105290478,
-0.011528179,
0.0139400596,
-0.0160367824,
-0.009328478,
-0.0337186418,
-0.096446164,
-0.0381592624,
-0.0029016021,
-0.0130711431,
-0.000322719,
0.0515180267,
-0.0571809858,
-0.0174483042,
-0.0697033256,
-0.0027715378,
0.0268996228,
0.0590340868,
-0.0214065816,
0.072202757,
-0.0761590451,
0.0082129091,
0.0335997045,
0.0095905177,
-0.0063470034,
-0.0301315654,
0.0453942679,
0.0194680169,
0.0551287755,
-0.0467571318,
0.0386847183,
0.0118002016,
0.0378329568,
0.0086947065,
-0.0249809269,
-0.0279058702,
0.0132551752,
-0.0239485316,
-0.0123810973,
-0.0269228853,
0.06746912,
-0.0674934536,
-0.0334041826,
-0.0744768083,
0.0218308158,
0.0463564955,
-0.0347341225,
0.042457182,
-0.0237645395,
0.0016612153,
0.0472191609,
-0.0472565442,
-0.0011402027,
0.0201291721,
0.0188730434,
0.0556377657,
0.0295724832,
-0.0574595332,
0.0650055259,
0.0468130969,
-0.020702038,
-0.0802158937,
0.0058359923,
0.026109213,
-0.0085574873,
0.0173880942,
0.0401896164,
-0.0595241524,
-0.0074164569,
0.0167125985,
0.0126049053,
0.0761417747,
0.0451962762,
0.0023295134,
0.094171904,
0.0533225276,
0.019650545,
-0.0419991426,
-0.0196543653,
0.0033503028,
0.0385573134,
-0.020440666,
-0.0576511584,
0.0098840836,
-0.0478633232,
-0.0111046974,
0.0096667856,
-0.0127358595,
-0.0113284905,
0.0369735733,
0.0386245549,
-0.0007110459,
-0.0195351373,
0.0388444848,
0.033338137,
0.014941765,
0.0220385417,
-0.0091761686,
-0.0607044883,
0.0666355267,
0.0122313248,
-0.0378577411,
-0.0149843721,
-0.0455448404,
-0.0078931563,
0.0278944541,
0.03141886,
-0.0290747471,
0.032183703,
-0.0292369295,
-0.0076368181,
-0.0275816116,
-0.0046963757,
0.0119932592,
-0.0209854729,
0.019653488,
0.0193410013,
0.029152764,
-0.0481534451,
0.0374558829,
0.0095475148,
-0.0527764671,
0.0436223634,
0.0414300375,
-0.0115211513,
0.0351598784,
0.0034941768,
-0.0072015296,
0.0049563055,
-0.0029781701,
-0.0032674023,
0.0141236186,
-0.0145958802,
0.0016303699,
-0.0061860532,
-0.0339237563,
-0.0558516048,
0.0416649692,
-0.0613951124,
0.0153331403,
-0.006239864,
0.0217540469,
-0.0201402456,
-0.005232601,
-0.0134351989,
-0.0140556535,
0.023301376,
-0.0020708519,
0.0714524835,
0.0591465272,
0.024891356,
-0.0202619229,
-0.0278629679,
0.0034947307,
-0.1080275998,
-0.0080954423,
-0.0321622416,
-0.0337331705,
0.049782142,
0.0221449398,
0.0397706702,
-0.027915515,
0.0191794112,
-0.0382442176,
0.0605923906,
0.0157001782,
0.0176609792,
0.0120530045,
-0.0366604961,
0.0032089406,
-0.0186169669,
-0.0524731651,
-0.0228357539,
0.0134381521,
-0.0171667375,
0.054621283,
-0.0099398047,
0.0009065882,
-0.0066690627,
-0.0352366865,
-0.0317791291,
0.0350646339,
0.0217013732,
0.0297831502,
-0.0291109085,
0.0082880119,
-0.0307860114,
0.0442805849,
0.0211398508,
-0.0169389285,
-0.0263997577,
0.0083597647,
-0.0687421113,
0.0534179285,
-0.0248605888,
0.0395497605,
0.0205652751,
0.0288528949,
0.0171347875,
0.0367233902,
-0.0465084836,
0.0278815497,
-0.0117210066,
-0.0204714816,
-0.0129944282,
0.0291059148,
0.0303264912,
-0.0131317722,
-0.0085954908,
0.028650729,
0.0112606315,
-0.0130029758,
-0.0433038957,
0.054804787,
0.0018111479,
0.0082207192,
-0.0305900052,
-0.0135793081,
0.0141318683,
0.0009441032,
0.0224568322,
-0.0253804233,
-0.094287388,
-0.0381909832,
0.0418273844,
-0.0129527822,
-0.0026098089,
-0.0255970955,
-0.0491190106,
-0.0249438658,
0.0013516172,
-0.023584025,
-0.0228495076,
-0.0431777164,
0.001211515,
-0.0168388709,
0.00344106,
-0.0187919717,
-0.0494194031,
-0.010768814,
-0.0069831903,
0.043314822,
0.0529820547,
0.0025940246,
-0.0428028926,
-0.0201343242,
-0.025620902,
0.0427936576,
0.0063120918,
-0.0041875774,
-0.0265279021,
0.0324630439,
0.0672713742,
0.0729890317,
-0.032539513,
0.0200606603,
-0.0420739874,
0.0082108006,
-0.0210907869,
0.0382110737,
-0.0252203718,
-0.0104545457,
0.0133321844,
-0.0903066322,
0.0269079208,
0.0044285352,
-0.0277442522,
-0.0816875845,
0.0133661851,
0.0710427016,
-0.00410973,
-0.0284715071,
0.0220571868,
0.0557470806,
-0.1007167846,
0.0361012742,
0.0541060157,
-0.0592242852,
-0.0088905878,
-0.0170712806,
0.0345397778,
-0.0063476316,
-0.0370202623,
-0.0040941248,
-0.1086939648,
0.0633905604,
-0.0670528039,
-0.021163566,
-0.0582704432,
-0.0559582077,
-0.0092646088,
-0.0520600043,
0.0107502975,
-0.0689868927,
-0.0146207353,
-0.0232748985,
0.0639849678,
-0.0294771176,
-0.0771157816,
0.0686353222,
-0.0486474223,
0.0381926447,
0.0240736417,
0.0553847589,
-0.0296163801,
-0.0059657437,
-0.016330272,
-0.0028056444,
-0.0104096811,
0.0257375445,
0.0646065697,
-0.0437017009,
-0.0359955095,
0.0216542408,
-0.0055956542,
-0.0541506745,
0.0413273275,
0.0312806144,
0.0635581836,
-0.018589044,
-0.0099372854,
-0.0031446523,
-0.0081512751,
0.0171383657,
0.0881374329,
-0.0306716822,
-0.0762509033,
-0.0176437553,
-0.0329041705,
0.0013390452,
-0.0471812859,
-0.0589185469,
0.0416602232,
-0.020117756,
0.010224768,
0.0077120708,
-0.0735268444,
0.0628887489,
-0.0237985868,
-0.0017124881,
0.0073426692,
0.0161584597,
-0.0034105023,
-0.0799944773,
0.0421109311,
-0.0013943189,
0.0443518572,
-0.0142405126,
-0.0205417182,
-0.0172027033,
-0.0427357927,
-0.0615417175,
-0.0135051077,
-0.0757978261,
0.0231957529,
-0.0378770828,
-0.0197581463,
0.0044954624,
0.0253690258,
-0.0069792881,
-0.0666210055,
0.0221616123,
0.0694989711,
-0.0301340874,
-0.0468435846,
0.0096037267,
-0.0091230813,
-0.0286720712,
0.0051999567,
-0.0444589481,
0.000005458,
0.0238844678,
-0.0393060073,
0.0165225752,
0.0155528244,
-0.0061093443,
-0.016685389,
0.0069451099,
0.0474161841,
-0.0419235267,
-0.0996676758,
-0.0127128819,
0.0328442454,
-0.0249795672,
-0.0390014574,
-0.0186540317,
0.0682971552,
0.0023236894,
0.0292833243,
0.0273184758,
0.0470107459,
0.0239531193,
-0.0518481024,
0.0589182861,
0.0023857604,
0.0613082387,
-0.0570438914,
0.0104233371,
-0.0246959683,
-0.0069003832,
-0.0043252637,
0.0477438718,
0.0250619631,
-0.0462001897,
-0.0040595098,
0.0299598351,
0.0019055037,
0.0338691734,
-0.0165974796,
-0.0409784541,
-0.0196200367,
0.028763514,
0.0699702874,
-0.0937419981,
-0.0028732414,
0.016330272,
-0.0120518366,
0.0018185558,
0.0017290522,
0.0297519937,
0.0166007113,
0.0038832435,
0.0007588017,
-0.0142215714,
-0.0108615924,
0.0177052282,
0.0366595909,
0.0368089117,
-0.0170852672,
-0.0537510142,
-0.0297526941,
0.0213416908,
0.0645725653,
0.040332038,
-0.0247150492,
0.0145709207,
-0.0267492924,
-0.0605891682,
0.0195250157,
-0.0254050922,
-0.0086785415,
0.0164997429,
0.0298187993,
0.0599661767,
0.0116654513,
-0.0143441688,
-0.0394290239,
-0.0184627455,
0.0039407439,
0.0145374089,
-0.0692070648,
-5.540065937e-33,
-0.0029391726,
-0.0372102857,
0.0396848209,
0.0265868492,
0.0125198904,
0.0437596738,
0.0725383162,
-0.0698196515,
-0.0314021073,
0.0023802565,
0.0026510304,
0.0090387538,
0.0111112632,
0.0295553599,
0.0275923461,
0.0039057008,
0.0349859968,
-0.0074976045,
0.0270932093,
0.0241469387,
0.0232469458,
0.0321039893,
0.1085784659,
-0.0505906008,
0.0279942472,
0.0147305969,
0.0063108196,
0.0446391441,
0.0205929,
0.0664054528,
-0.0201573558,
0.0378168598,
0.0303345062,
-0.0667777508,
0.0330436565,
0.009925806,
-0.0459039509,
-0.0279519893,
-0.0028242234,
0.015358787,
0.0092028864,
-0.0150372703,
0.0219301321,
0.0162223894,
0.0036941473,
-0.0218532104,
0.1030662507,
-0.0058335643,
0.0420091413,
-0.01224289,
0.0018365704,
0.0201883223,
-0.0510594994,
-0.0005973445,
0.0122082308,
0.0250449348,
0.0076333266,
0.0193937365,
-0.1689367294,
-0.016628705,
-0.0013335048,
0.0338027887,
0.0143470559,
-0.0055391672,
0.0046445802,
0.0130008934,
0.0566935614,
0.0301202051,
0.0435172059,
0.0031199469,
0.0183831602,
0.0583025068,
-0.0245950054,
-0.005018875,
0.0636791438,
-0.0365579985,
-0.0581145771,
0.0153088579,
0.0303183664,
0.0047883703,
-0.0161389839,
-0.0170275513,
-0.034133926,
-0.0006387482,
-0.0084431386,
-0.0060154609,
0.0148850922,
0.0095773842,
0.0277501419,
0.008457101,
0.0226385426,
0.0569188595,
-0.0216117818,
-0.0432609841,
0.0181595273,
0.0077388603,
-0.0435443297,
0.009938457,
0.0341141149,
-0.0252348483,
-0.0785667598,
-0.0468321666,
-0.0308702812,
-0.0172999911,
0.0480944291,
0.0676924735,
0.0231464207,
0.0448961854,
-0.0189756583,
0.0016024034,
-0.0099427402,
0.0323637947,
-0.0477063097,
0.0687897503,
0.0106562413,
0.0041871234,
0.0316296853,
0.0011917979,
0.0381176472,
0.0218145493,
0.0191916451,
-0.0154126594,
0.0348110087,
0.0119434791,
0.0095419036,
-0.0258628931,
-0.0333419368,
-0.0157560837,
0.0010154911,
-0.040163897,
0.0068427892,
-0.0302221738,
2.289e-7,
0.0363365225,
0.0046197572,
-0.029528819,
0.0541365296,
0.0167373307,
-0.0020004013,
0.0132074663,
0.0265425351,
-0.0041326941,
0.0215209592,
0.0158957206,
0.0130422367,
0.0178303085,
-0.0158404466,
-0.091169484,
-0.0029211002,
-0.0309997331,
-0.0164627116,
-0.0452899933,
0.0018401607,
0.0472700894,
0.0977569371,
0.0627961829,
-0.0326142125,
-0.0099527091,
-0.0300063808,
-0.0000265878,
-0.0015001942,
0.0171810519,
0.0532407276,
0.0077227028,
0.0462162122,
-0.0339993984,
0.0257612746,
-0.0311109107,
0.0658066943,
0.0449562967,
0.0226408616,
-0.0461421125,
0.0307812728,
0.0005545253,
-0.0198665112,
-0.0327246189,
-0.0019614354,
0.0420842804,
-0.0616228916,
-0.035230197,
-0.0595507436,
-0.0207218993,
0.0177035667,
0.0032169258,
0.0178114232,
0.0117432261,
-0.0331320502,
0.0278950837,
-0.0481426567,
-0.0860531405,
-0.0234711189,
0.0362012759,
0.0234149396,
-0.0124075925,
-0.0368075334,
0.0287705157,
-0.022065185,
0.0179164559,
-0.027778754,
0.0233436786,
1.840619016e-34,
0.009911539,
0.0689293519,
-0.0066530695,
-0.0200490877,
0.0245019794,
0.0083540631,
0.0166177042,
-0.0067744087,
-0.0297121964,
0.0007375704,
-0.0180928987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05616v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05616v1 | Pretrained Generative Language Models as General Learning Frameworks for Sequence-Based Tasks | 2024-02-08T12:19:32 | 2024-02-08T12:19:32 | Ben Fauber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We propose that small pretrained foundational generative language models with
millions of parameters can be utilized as a general learning framework for
sequence-based tasks. Our proposal overcomes the computational resource, skill
set, and timeline challenges associated with training neural networks and
language models from scratch. Further, our approach focuses on creating small
and highly specialized models that can accurately execute a challenging task of
which the base model is incapable of performing. We demonstrate that 125M,
350M, and 1.3B parameter pretrained foundational language models can be
instruction fine-tuned with 10,000-to-1,000,000 instruction examples to achieve
near state-of-the-art results on challenging cheminformatics tasks. We also
demonstrate the role of successive language model fine-tuning epochs on
improved outcomes, as well as the importance of both data formatting and
pretrained foundational language model selection for instruction fine-tuning
success. | [
0.0160413515,
0.1301034689,
0.0159699321,
-0.0271652862,
-0.0224041399,
0.0178352948,
0.0476744175,
0.0140617127,
-0.0281898007,
-0.0179262422,
0.0349681228,
-0.0537324436,
-0.0110821128,
0.0411074981,
0.0402800106,
-0.0137916412,
0.0159236267,
-0.0000016013,
0.0119811092,
-0.0077269315,
-0.0034588764,
0.0052931523,
0.0194296967,
0.01924132,
-0.0085988222,
-0.0129650952,
-0.0171266608,
-0.0251966417,
0.0277743135,
-0.0208799113,
0.0000515298,
0.0651126727,
0.0645911023,
0.0413995646,
0.0000020836,
-0.0318021141,
-0.0062581096,
0.010585661,
-0.0250053238,
0.0237966161,
0.0268164184,
0.0220052432,
-0.0138352998,
0.0084934998,
-0.03503602,
-0.0204366874,
0.0722912177,
0.0033812977,
0.0153882196,
0.0493858084,
0.0029157195,
-0.0262701418,
0.009423092,
-0.0614043772,
0.0540562458,
-0.0070300279,
0.0078411028,
0.0127545707,
0.0215295497,
0.0330591798,
-0.0006159271,
0.0381759256,
-0.0082633272,
0.0016576734,
-0.0068972558,
0.0107737752,
-0.0317148305,
-0.0464811027,
0.0001167039,
0.0530859604,
-0.090336293,
-0.0435414873,
-0.0459957384,
-0.0228127092,
-0.0378299691,
-0.0430408828,
-0.038767118,
0.0261581708,
0.0050817407,
0.0396846794,
0.008928258,
-0.028866997,
0.0310715176,
-0.0249801278,
-0.0189897213,
0.0184006654,
-0.0073918239,
-0.008877947,
-0.0092741689,
0.0024028027,
-0.0337920822,
0.0056982613,
-0.0291235205,
0.0039046244,
0.0167643651,
-0.0061634686,
-0.0272439755,
0.013232274,
0.0546186827,
-0.0084450729,
0.0829754695,
0.0117002223,
0.0015509237,
-0.0026773119,
-0.021670429,
0.0053755124,
0.0166417453,
0.0158877745,
-0.0367180109,
0.0056425356,
-0.0402377248,
0.0343709886,
-0.0255017728,
-0.0027425352,
-0.0308620464,
0.0058095963,
-0.0629342273,
0.0040479931,
0.0514436997,
0.012345382,
0.0296654701,
0.038465362,
-0.0473925732,
0.0316938311,
0.0061188582,
0.0024748994,
-0.0101432102,
0.0056311474,
0.0248654094,
-0.0651830882,
-0.068317242,
-0.0170186888,
0.0313016362,
-0.0143090263,
0.0118849799,
0.0688797385,
-0.0128186857,
-0.0404774025,
-0.0435865894,
-0.0312619917,
0.0275933053,
-0.038284421,
0.0047853887,
-0.0317332186,
0.0627551898,
0.0414471701,
0.000260309,
-0.0598453395,
0.0357658714,
-0.0183032826,
-0.0137532195,
0.11284592,
0.021544788,
-0.0577267334,
-0.0002858791,
0.0053025908,
0.0490503497,
-0.0030661155,
0.0202591345,
0.0342824645,
-0.0031487737,
-0.0316721499,
-0.0001490778,
0.0190794524,
0.0246587731,
-0.0415582992,
-0.0145027069,
-0.0193149522,
0.0087486543,
0.038511645,
0.0415739939,
-0.0078662904,
0.017738007,
-0.0139391562,
0.0533214025,
0.0527701825,
0.0436640978,
0.0325086936,
0.0524205081,
0.0291068796,
-0.0225356203,
-0.0260466561,
-0.0126429079,
0.0139069697,
-0.0180211738,
0.0303203482,
0.0353451185,
0.0399049185,
-0.0264910311,
-0.0282381512,
0.0012809079,
-0.0104548959,
0.007404278,
-0.0376278907,
0.0340422504,
-0.0118674887,
-0.095098488,
0.0178438928,
0.0372633263,
-0.0705605522,
-0.0188519116,
-0.0109427823,
0.0272398889,
0.0543583222,
0.0461829379,
-0.0479313619,
-0.0475086793,
-0.0192431435,
-0.0063575977,
0.0122176679,
0.0041851155,
-0.0065034162,
0.0269503873,
-0.0501327701,
-0.0341041386,
-0.0137011688,
-0.0061929608,
0.0156443231,
-0.0074263155,
-0.0329690613,
0.0408724807,
-0.0233448856,
-0.0511568934,
0.0131742116,
-0.023540955,
-0.0827041492,
-0.0035048358,
-0.0017406575,
0.0464396328,
0.0117567368,
-0.0402919054,
0.0175481122,
0.087688379,
-0.0315346979,
0.0082206801,
-0.0756422132,
-0.0379311629,
-0.0514825098,
0.0167863555,
0.0178525224,
0.0427128337,
-0.0342321917,
-0.0698392019,
-0.041827593,
0.0186045598,
0.0051640016,
0.0009837461,
-0.0309296753,
0.0044394271,
0.0388536267,
0.0770762563,
-0.0497681722,
0.0091941524,
-0.03685591,
0.030277716,
-0.0148100108,
0.021045709,
-0.0013761196,
-0.07168331,
0.022654755,
-0.0236334801,
0.0483269915,
0.0314309895,
0.0114522092,
0.0048838533,
-0.0193229392,
0.0144676045,
-0.0275350027,
-0.0174383037,
-0.0132153342,
0.0053802542,
0.0052938974,
0.004288096,
0.006844928,
-0.0135178808,
-0.0255986564,
-0.0113628684,
-0.0229610875,
-0.0535397083,
0.0362367555,
0.0008732203,
-0.0298443604,
-0.0580479205,
-0.0452427045,
-0.0024847102,
0.0621390492,
-0.0062686796,
-0.00572418,
-0.0316390023,
-0.0155093297,
0.0086442493,
0.0613289513,
-0.0057771858,
-0.06608776,
0.0138855549,
-0.0279649775,
0.0160882026,
0.0577100068,
0.0164509099,
0.0280575752,
0.046305418,
0.0147824073,
-0.0144355958,
-0.0100027593,
-0.0503172092,
0.0080858767,
0.0375709236,
-0.0146479923,
-0.0223276746,
0.0699342042,
-0.0379248895,
0.0140912449,
-0.0647041425,
0.063711077,
0.0420015417,
-0.0300969649,
-0.0200099479,
0.0334975682,
-0.0030538405,
-0.0016344823,
0.002293977,
-0.0446503498,
0.0501327328,
-0.0437947586,
-0.0100114755,
-0.036759451,
-0.0136108678,
0.0192965139,
0.0242079068,
0.0515735298,
0.0312465429,
0.0417792685,
0.0186189562,
-0.0329468288,
0.0280619301,
0.0040914449,
-0.0324114375,
0.0116160018,
-0.0478377193,
0.0067279455,
0.0174033139,
-0.0190096349,
-0.0261481702,
0.0381087251,
0.017530486,
0.0386780463,
0.0672189072,
-0.0322336257,
-0.0367945023,
0.0467722826,
0.0146426307,
0.042171523,
0.0063239266,
0.0293725524,
-0.0404306389,
0.0321144685,
0.0251520015,
-0.0518798269,
0.0061208513,
-0.0185573436,
0.0281423945,
0.0373379886,
0.0181416478,
-0.0081963921,
-0.0130354678,
0.0164689571,
0.0093050543,
-0.0006496901,
-0.0088906549,
0.0444306508,
-0.0108721489,
-0.0586398132,
-0.0526584908,
0.1055138558,
0.0279424991,
-0.0219712462,
0.0104700439,
0.0599046797,
0.0058151763,
-0.0180533901,
0.0297261085,
-0.0846477076,
-0.0156313423,
-0.037668094,
0.0340775326,
-0.0201936066,
-0.0028464291,
-0.0279770754,
-0.0850807577,
0.0403996445,
0.0350132063,
-0.051823426,
-0.0273706969,
-0.054689955,
-0.0645983592,
-0.0282696765,
0.0125098806,
0.0468029119,
-0.0218085088,
-0.004254546,
0.0471141525,
0.0098439883,
-0.0962086916,
0.0264167935,
0.0142616266,
0.0088753626,
0.072004281,
-0.0322816893,
0.0228424948,
-0.0007095297,
0.0356947966,
0.0199481733,
0.0415825024,
-0.0358834229,
0.0597916692,
0.0426179655,
-0.0370165221,
0.0259731766,
0.0448430218,
-0.0352624133,
-0.0375408567,
-0.0441883914,
0.0834247693,
-0.0245455019,
-0.0020230685,
-0.0124877896,
0.0122919027,
0.0401615165,
0.0354844406,
0.0495378375,
-0.031556949,
-0.0500028655,
-0.0290287919,
0.048277989,
-0.093294166,
-0.0162151344,
-0.0111372126,
-0.0152829196,
-0.0182808414,
-0.0435638614,
-0.0245660804,
0.0289482698,
0.0244592428,
0.0010606996,
0.0028071816,
0.0336549878,
-0.0478079394,
-0.0626913831,
0.0357448235,
0.0309686996,
-0.0215933919,
-0.1104135811,
-0.1025836617,
0.0332646444,
-0.005532335,
-0.0488567203,
0.0552415513,
-0.0852872804,
-0.0812577605,
0.0253052022,
0.0859076604,
0.0142144915,
0.0011378903,
0.0322927423,
-0.0607338361,
0.0786633566,
0.0347713158,
-0.0016822331,
-0.0207070541,
0.0271525923,
-0.0327805839,
-0.0326495841,
-0.0035618097,
0.0092341071,
0.0659632459,
0.0046422994,
0.0323070288,
-0.0036268407,
-0.0222153794,
0.0356102996,
0.0031111143,
0.0664872602,
-0.0089351991,
0.0218999237,
-0.0234892722,
0.02119717,
0.0072246147,
0.0056057815,
-0.0474267267,
-0.0234654117,
0.0164387729,
-0.0076632034,
-0.0203696806,
-0.0226840004,
-0.0382800996,
0.0207471568,
-0.053686332,
0.0348975249,
-0.0076095033,
0.0173563994,
0.0968437344,
-0.0414942577,
-0.0041777482,
0.0453312211,
-0.0247323234,
0.0307386238,
-0.0230502542,
0.0158406943,
-0.0054117036,
0.0999257863,
-0.0597648434,
0.0546380319,
-0.0148173412,
-0.0024263626,
-0.0749320462,
0.0112751219,
0.0707550421,
-0.0335598215,
0.0511641093,
0.0048438357,
-0.0127791669,
-0.0182646047,
0.0623917803,
0.0066352384,
-0.0098911459,
0.022412328,
0.0364263579,
-0.0230866671,
-0.0188703444,
0.0932591259,
0.0321357325,
0.0489123091,
-0.0304449555,
-0.0409894064,
-0.0268014688,
-0.0415750705,
-0.0211752504,
-0.0311585087,
-0.0057538785,
-0.0051628184,
-0.0042844312,
-0.0503513142,
-0.0022016596,
0.0287776161,
0.0033968892,
0.0287221055,
0.0630344748,
0.0207174607,
-0.0138093708,
-0.0263339877,
-0.0131231062,
0.0015386561,
0.0362194553,
-0.0593522042,
0.0120946458,
-6.444764593e-33,
-0.0004617815,
0.0122907665,
-0.0108891744,
-0.0100893937,
0.0039050565,
-0.0349873491,
-0.0655973032,
-0.0220574699,
0.0613394305,
0.0288363956,
-0.0096704131,
-0.02624676,
0.0187577177,
0.0109417876,
0.0282166433,
0.0539893508,
0.0653581023,
0.0047435141,
-0.0109212641,
0.0349193588,
0.0761317611,
0.0605795979,
0.0633709654,
-0.0250365548,
-0.0393920317,
0.0481498018,
0.0028743963,
-0.0531452335,
-0.0177793596,
0.0258545466,
0.0050796326,
0.0390787646,
-0.0386619642,
-0.0345666632,
-0.0524430051,
-0.018148711,
-0.0573388301,
-0.0060218195,
-0.0059898458,
0.0014959566,
0.0007453065,
-0.0115904612,
0.0073418496,
-0.0281650592,
-0.0250379276,
0.0233825352,
0.0359998941,
-0.0148334019,
-0.0288686045,
-0.0472355261,
-0.0672945827,
-0.0031404011,
0.019194413,
-0.0067212903,
0.0344317853,
0.0001929054,
-0.0120563935,
-0.0028967797,
-0.0209423546,
0.0526640005,
0.0715802461,
0.0707248226,
0.0590325259,
0.0494833924,
0.0283271503,
-0.0049003558,
-0.0210488029,
-0.015169546,
0.012590358,
0.0578752309,
-0.0050167292,
0.0219884776,
0.0250300597,
-0.015138438,
0.0348215476,
-0.0185020398,
-0.1066418514,
0.0152764749,
-0.0242456831,
0.0184987858,
0.0081574293,
0.0205147564,
0.0187341999,
-0.031034952,
-0.0329276808,
-0.0135688782,
0.0073597431,
-0.0285782963,
0.0059612901,
-0.0230351202,
-0.0420580655,
-0.0117928032,
0.0172887016,
-0.0205002539,
-0.0398396887,
0.0361200273,
-0.0295086615,
-0.0308561809,
-0.021725703,
-0.0110783214,
-0.0725215971,
-0.0678723603,
0.0527009964,
-0.0338135213,
0.0105280783,
-0.0359656103,
0.0244785007,
0.042642843,
-0.0369720906,
0.0083967503,
-0.0687587485,
0.0104340808,
0.0336498208,
0.0191326551,
0.0035830571,
0.0032537666,
-0.0208900571,
0.0505492724,
-0.0004170935,
-0.0503292941,
0.0586948283,
-0.0197631419,
0.0252611265,
0.0589507595,
-0.0596725307,
0.0035687191,
-0.0461553968,
-0.012892589,
0.0293344222,
-0.0455760434,
-0.0218550935,
0.007474788,
2.792e-7,
0.0478803478,
0.0354120359,
0.0591692626,
0.004591214,
-0.0352729559,
-0.0075295959,
-0.0152749876,
0.025290776,
-0.0724560618,
0.0090907738,
0.0485363156,
-0.0115889162,
0.0173572768,
0.00924672,
-0.011330693,
-0.0002829473,
-0.047543183,
0.0311004668,
-0.0501051769,
-0.0187240783,
0.0062329965,
0.1150963455,
-0.004212887,
-0.0102402614,
0.0440809205,
-0.0043666097,
0.0236431584,
-0.013035777,
-0.0052392888,
0.0343400575,
-0.0325703882,
-0.0085365502,
-0.0327872336,
0.0400829762,
-0.0532412753,
-0.0060003949,
-0.0129763717,
0.0480930433,
-0.0274307337,
-0.0508566424,
0.046350725,
0.0029694133,
0.027526658,
-0.0236431565,
0.0165006518,
-0.0448840484,
0.0053322883,
-0.0087455055,
-0.0077216486,
0.0138528598,
0.0432582386,
-0.0326861739,
0.0260304455,
0.0237136949,
0.010633681,
0.0138308639,
-0.0009454542,
-0.0594727658,
-0.0213562325,
0.0374908634,
-0.0115793366,
0.0031764815,
-0.0523834154,
-0.0175145827,
-0.0104920557,
0.0212653391,
-0.0189004093,
2.868788683e-34,
0.0383577198,
-0.0276076347,
0.007792213,
-0.0056721736,
0.0279043224,
-0.0293229688,
-0.0163004138,
0.0266842935,
0.000762422,
-0.086443454,
-0.035735976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05602v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05602v2 | AttnLRP: Attention-Aware Layer-Wise Relevance Propagation for Transformers | 2024-02-08T12:01:24 | 2024-06-10T09:58:55 | Reduan Achtibat, Sayed Mohammad Vakilzadeh Hatefi, Maximilian Dreyer, Aakriti Jain, Thomas Wiegand, Sebastian Lapuschkin, Wojciech Samek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Large Language Models are prone to biased predictions and hallucinations,
underlining the paramount importance of understanding their model-internal
reasoning process. However, achieving faithful attributions for the entirety of
a black-box transformer model and maintaining computational efficiency is an
unsolved challenge. By extending the Layer-wise Relevance Propagation
attribution method to handle attention layers, we address these challenges
effectively. While partial solutions exist, our method is the first to
faithfully and holistically attribute not only input but also latent
representations of transformer models with the computational efficiency similar
to a single backward pass. Through extensive evaluations against existing
methods on LLaMa 2, Mixtral 8x7b, Flan-T5 and vision transformer architectures,
we demonstrate that our proposed approach surpasses alternative methods in
terms of faithfulness and enables the understanding of latent representations,
opening up the door for concept-based explanations. We provide an LRP library
at https://github.com/rachtibat/LRP-eXplains-Transformers. | [
0.0228264593,
0.0417890586,
0.0022355225,
0.0480313674,
0.0051383167,
-0.00489278,
0.0111957882,
-0.0248409025,
-0.0507334284,
-0.0098602977,
-0.039043963,
-0.0335938521,
0.033837378,
-0.0020738759,
0.0403610691,
-0.0246061515,
0.0057107196,
-0.008938645,
-0.0169652607,
0.0070243417,
0.0044094617,
-0.0042865542,
0.02042857,
0.0740645751,
0.0067246277,
-0.0077524479,
0.0010744063,
-0.0142107997,
0.0325661115,
0.0159524642,
-0.0118798753,
0.0118208891,
0.0092069805,
0.0432565175,
0.0000020036,
0.0062926929,
-0.008857714,
-0.000934577,
-0.0248500202,
0.0057068351,
0.0169743355,
-0.0040972712,
-0.0058409101,
0.0187095813,
-0.0055402555,
-0.0064460519,
0.0966842249,
0.0837907419,
0.0764321014,
0.0372811742,
-0.0061937086,
-0.0349087901,
0.0210404955,
-0.0261570364,
0.0295240395,
-0.013077097,
-0.0038098467,
-0.0606517084,
-0.0248071589,
-0.0171909202,
-0.029443955,
0.0557704233,
0.0332327597,
-0.0303678606,
0.0315593965,
0.0256730113,
-0.036812637,
-0.0219916962,
0.0086691603,
0.0631825551,
-0.0232378766,
-0.0362014435,
-0.0147197256,
0.0060273996,
-0.0617775917,
-0.0074677449,
-0.0567378476,
0.0210846104,
0.0095517505,
0.0030511986,
0.0088302745,
-0.0015021317,
0.0493121706,
-0.012276914,
-0.0347560123,
0.0691341907,
0.0323588029,
-0.0077174418,
-0.0274927039,
0.0003837122,
0.0081916051,
-0.0536552295,
-0.0008421497,
0.0423927121,
0.0060686497,
0.0155053232,
-0.000304921,
-0.013647628,
-0.0124927154,
-0.0406266674,
0.0632576793,
0.0635786951,
-0.0472198017,
0.036942821,
-0.0349561051,
0.0787972808,
-0.0782424435,
0.0476099625,
-0.027359454,
-0.0333326235,
-0.0132474974,
-0.0251331963,
-0.0286167897,
-0.005806027,
-0.0045298114,
-0.0407559536,
-0.0283790678,
0.024204066,
-0.0089406064,
-0.0650358796,
0.0143668242,
0.037314862,
-0.0488705486,
-0.0024144214,
-0.0048631849,
0.0612175651,
0.0127121089,
-0.0093339961,
-0.0018154867,
-0.0649724752,
-0.0664784536,
0.032628037,
-0.004840001,
-0.038698554,
0.0041922056,
0.0654226542,
0.0082880557,
-0.0505916551,
-0.0150703695,
0.0018331925,
-0.024513511,
-0.0492137335,
0.0329073071,
-0.0221680868,
0.0029784162,
0.0058161211,
-0.0179093461,
-0.0204026736,
0.0122236712,
0.0381459966,
-0.0304261539,
0.0725467429,
0.0334688872,
-0.0006930755,
-0.0045546228,
0.0130746821,
-0.0203922559,
0.0378348455,
0.0228785444,
0.0428699926,
-0.0221038703,
-0.0228686947,
0.0434297957,
0.0290189758,
0.0315559618,
-0.0196567066,
-0.0165661257,
-0.0029521065,
-0.0531670898,
0.007311394,
0.0485958159,
0.0234738607,
-0.0260327626,
0.0002671047,
0.0498727411,
0.018516358,
0.0664313659,
0.036273744,
0.0166146122,
-0.0237616003,
-0.0219210703,
-0.0122641288,
-0.0930636153,
0.1129746512,
-0.0068018162,
-0.0106457081,
0.0322831757,
0.0399054103,
-0.0337783657,
-0.0102381986,
0.0010824468,
0.022371985,
-0.0207109209,
0.0229234379,
0.0360379517,
0.028121762,
-0.0323391743,
0.1341073662,
0.025630353,
-0.0312512256,
-0.0188435614,
-0.0787847713,
0.0098506957,
0.0301216543,
0.0557202399,
0.002009968,
-0.0105057117,
-0.011882429,
0.0176846068,
0.0525270291,
-0.0195527151,
0.0139324591,
-0.0029698394,
-0.0412800759,
-0.0298539493,
-0.0146033624,
0.0315548927,
0.0110482853,
-0.0067990567,
-0.0319955423,
0.0263968837,
-0.064922601,
0.007829505,
0.0283143595,
0.0139967939,
-0.032365147,
-0.0028847163,
0.0171965361,
0.0207765587,
0.0121103656,
0.0148389097,
0.0175675526,
0.0254649874,
-0.047727,
-0.002905152,
0.0243529696,
-0.0439169519,
0.0181477144,
0.0269200616,
-0.0503536984,
0.0124368798,
0.0744689032,
-0.0073037967,
-0.0519884452,
0.054576084,
-0.0923931003,
0.0584913343,
-0.0216549654,
0.0141713852,
-0.0033236707,
0.065391846,
-0.0004032252,
0.047638759,
-0.0176718123,
-0.0026201869,
0.0403395407,
-0.014524065,
0.0197997708,
0.0037401612,
-0.0137446746,
0.0033796104,
-0.0255156718,
-0.0038566364,
0.0163226575,
-0.0340934806,
-0.0099597974,
-0.0051208367,
-0.0116715292,
-0.0102185216,
-0.0549051799,
0.0102652889,
0.0292366352,
0.0384086929,
0.0488133803,
-0.0144562852,
-0.0137853818,
0.0098206587,
-0.0185771678,
0.0273420513,
0.0020152426,
-0.0135593694,
-0.0608073585,
-0.0495236926,
-0.0292886011,
-0.0074401139,
0.0677493215,
0.0097742397,
-0.0068461127,
-0.0698599294,
-0.0382449776,
-0.0037692897,
-0.0025406228,
-0.0386035778,
-0.043400079,
0.0196242779,
-0.0107085463,
0.0202280562,
0.0483013503,
0.0105553539,
0.0331184678,
0.0669600889,
-0.0104451664,
-0.047896415,
0.0018373976,
-0.0352533981,
-0.0142060481,
-0.0293573923,
-0.0313438103,
-0.0223905798,
0.089960061,
-0.0312986635,
0.0034332424,
-0.0824507251,
-0.0022212511,
0.0070149568,
-0.007864194,
0.0217325147,
-0.0171974264,
-0.0183782466,
0.0313050523,
-0.0151178148,
-0.0466183238,
0.0802178904,
-0.0469020344,
-0.0274982397,
-0.0010191714,
0.0022888223,
-0.042988956,
0.041977182,
-0.0058266139,
0.0131275598,
0.0062887315,
-0.0177723747,
-0.0386354662,
0.0203331299,
0.0293145981,
-0.0084821461,
0.102137804,
0.0071916236,
0.0044112946,
-0.0045032613,
-0.0164772943,
-0.0513265096,
-0.0068904832,
-0.0350073166,
0.0137959337,
0.0066804313,
-0.0361406654,
-0.1021425277,
0.0222653728,
0.044924885,
0.0204801224,
0.0083414614,
-0.0134002399,
-0.0095686456,
-0.0056424597,
0.033228714,
0.0307161342,
0.0865766332,
-0.0107462471,
0.0024803728,
0.0354945511,
0.0484837629,
0.0045949384,
-0.0425280109,
0.0031588385,
0.0541861393,
0.0001878725,
-0.0043681143,
0.0040141572,
0.057264559,
-0.0633911192,
-0.0269345548,
0.0731051639,
0.0111275753,
-0.0920293257,
0.009161002,
-0.0434266031,
0.0057475213,
0.0314433202,
0.0391820408,
-0.051885955,
-0.0349375643,
-0.0016573186,
0.0362731963,
0.0269310176,
0.0016329603,
-0.0049778484,
-0.0543387383,
0.0408035778,
-0.0134630566,
0.0080516981,
-0.0449158475,
-0.0486981869,
0.0117831463,
-0.0328506902,
0.0144150453,
0.0119387377,
-0.0000367428,
-0.0174718704,
0.0086891213,
0.0095049869,
-0.0158126019,
0.0607569553,
-0.004611956,
0.0196547601,
0.0807236508,
0.0016211171,
0.0087384824,
-0.0706032664,
-0.0083053438,
-0.0456247702,
-0.004935944,
0.0024581957,
0.0342747718,
0.0051306868,
-0.0123447198,
-0.0272630304,
0.0116917649,
-0.0450237691,
-0.0115690958,
-0.0709974095,
0.0742793009,
-0.0190721247,
-0.0338117555,
-0.0143090272,
-0.0009450691,
-0.012487215,
0.0524636582,
0.0423410647,
-0.0104297437,
-0.0478683375,
-0.04534062,
0.0146313235,
-0.0075172638,
-0.0791219696,
0.015462135,
0.0539150834,
-0.0721261278,
-0.0193842743,
-0.0093020601,
-0.0020284986,
-0.0032135744,
-0.0003989278,
-0.0462612435,
-0.0067478041,
-0.0264468081,
-0.0392592587,
0.0435531661,
-0.0125182988,
0.0191163179,
-0.0550519638,
0.0045433617,
0.0266389418,
-0.0664416924,
-0.0177885816,
0.0346004479,
-0.1100642681,
-0.0463989824,
0.0428428501,
0.0328851901,
0.0242685396,
0.056637872,
-0.0386233479,
-0.052798897,
0.0546053872,
0.010439707,
-0.0331586674,
0.0209793523,
0.0297744647,
-0.0589001626,
0.0061475821,
0.0444117486,
-0.0575992092,
0.0339533538,
0.0458590649,
0.0540865064,
0.0013236506,
-0.0180273131,
0.0480814949,
-0.0237997659,
0.0732300431,
-0.0154987657,
-0.0036280218,
-0.0139892874,
0.0393184386,
0.0134048555,
0.0114303883,
-0.0583262406,
0.0053952648,
0.0007288855,
-0.0081789112,
0.0133472895,
0.000975706,
-0.0002293307,
-0.0078331763,
-0.001375771,
0.0340481289,
0.019900959,
-0.0384739228,
0.0148192886,
0.0138862589,
0.0072955186,
0.0058642258,
0.0007403613,
0.0540517531,
-0.0110387588,
0.0289295278,
0.0200779308,
-0.0034780209,
-0.0392466299,
0.0142397117,
-0.0942801312,
-0.0534968562,
-0.0230292846,
-0.0217415262,
0.0393548198,
-0.0123502854,
0.0535777137,
-0.0043794159,
-0.0056574913,
0.0053165527,
0.0391988754,
0.0099188108,
-0.0186098833,
0.0331949592,
0.0210037231,
0.008455405,
-0.0085201496,
0.0469035022,
-0.0057203854,
0.025072949,
-0.0331395753,
-0.0121149328,
-0.0096916072,
-0.0565615073,
-0.0362361483,
0.0134399412,
-0.0135059915,
-0.0086149713,
-0.0434723571,
-0.075020656,
0.0346686244,
-0.0404226035,
-0.01535255,
-0.0408866666,
0.0119253173,
0.0794476047,
0.0271128565,
-0.0323728137,
0.0034163881,
-0.034902472,
-0.0085373679,
0.0103236316,
0.0023515339,
-6.713630273e-33,
-0.0150345843,
-0.0212589707,
0.0109484605,
-0.0003985938,
-0.0169708226,
0.0135619938,
-0.0675172061,
-0.0244176704,
-0.0443299226,
0.0227229521,
-0.0218646545,
0.0417378396,
0.0105481185,
0.0308690481,
0.0124148121,
-0.0338006392,
0.0622117221,
0.0349569358,
-0.0326134488,
0.0507534258,
0.0219610203,
0.0199424066,
0.0742740557,
-0.0273944251,
0.012148398,
0.0104783289,
-0.0023533655,
0.0067531983,
-0.0234785322,
0.0956095904,
-0.0546206012,
0.0365954489,
0.0047476362,
-0.0723685697,
-0.0206387285,
0.0095568039,
-0.0689354241,
0.0075457008,
-0.0012182586,
0.0263351668,
-0.0415113904,
-0.0287402049,
0.0622018762,
0.0143709779,
0.0191931631,
-0.07174135,
0.0435284711,
0.0031963065,
-0.0198650882,
0.0037908934,
-0.0354462117,
0.0101254545,
-0.0046423986,
-0.0256031416,
0.0406861268,
0.0200861841,
-0.0060652592,
0.0547011122,
-0.0843629912,
0.0047540176,
-0.0211979002,
0.0180019811,
0.0740711614,
0.0363410637,
-0.0098734358,
0.033563666,
0.0055632545,
-0.0302088745,
-0.066329971,
-0.0703735948,
0.0110878097,
0.0466513857,
0.0562441237,
0.0004798009,
0.0288496166,
0.0300574619,
-0.0505165048,
-0.0209861118,
-0.0142061589,
0.0855604634,
0.0662572011,
0.0198732484,
-0.0200234205,
-0.0062391846,
-0.0135168089,
0.0050669401,
-0.0609310046,
-0.0338297263,
0.0203208476,
0.0224969238,
-0.028913701,
-0.0099688824,
0.0403245352,
-0.0651827306,
0.0387270376,
0.0157960951,
0.0056139613,
0.0236373711,
0.0152159249,
0.022992583,
-0.0183883272,
0.0236024261,
0.0173294917,
-0.0037171859,
0.0138002783,
0.0058281198,
0.02593592,
0.0568965971,
-0.0403706841,
-0.0205135141,
-0.0694912747,
-0.0134012923,
-0.0169634447,
0.0227383543,
0.0103218826,
0.0185841452,
-0.0222894978,
0.0116116125,
-0.0030216926,
0.0508666001,
0.0006593473,
0.0407538079,
0.0146260913,
0.0273146909,
-0.0576850288,
-0.0171701498,
-0.061800316,
0.0175594538,
0.0236584451,
-0.073399283,
-0.0463812873,
0.0312564299,
2.771e-7,
0.0594470575,
0.0194914974,
0.0047449269,
0.0276613925,
0.0150898099,
0.0107002221,
0.0212491583,
0.0350087397,
0.0170328468,
-0.0129422322,
-0.0067872871,
0.0275641624,
0.0361486971,
0.0037873534,
-0.0578801706,
-0.0144144464,
-0.0774725527,
-0.0020087915,
0.006963734,
-0.056379158,
0.0201318171,
0.1258275658,
0.0109206447,
-0.0137406979,
0.0017691607,
-0.0062314486,
0.0703447908,
-0.0007836707,
0.0365350135,
0.0122940978,
0.0427640639,
-0.00711268,
-0.0236047357,
-0.016030265,
-0.0011784526,
0.0112818023,
0.0066668424,
0.0271063223,
-0.0140664689,
-0.0845534429,
-0.0252326,
-0.0068475762,
0.0190959852,
-0.0731564313,
0.0347480439,
-0.0473411083,
-0.0478615724,
-0.007619834,
-0.0258626845,
-0.0060339877,
-0.014153148,
0.0043877787,
0.0335758142,
0.0009056912,
-0.006514681,
-0.0221663937,
-0.0139428033,
-0.1180330366,
-0.0539710857,
-0.035626024,
-0.0377906226,
0.0007382528,
-0.0633897036,
-0.0703455806,
0.0708216727,
-0.0140859541,
-0.0076954234,
2.613396005e-34,
0.0132803228,
0.0124678258,
-0.0095500015,
0.0278055519,
0.0211877283,
-0.023199277,
0.0442873687,
0.0017689777,
0.0296131689,
-0.1084485501,
-0.0357069895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05591v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05591v1 | SoftEDA: Rethinking Rule-Based Data Augmentation with Soft Labels | 2024-02-08T11:44:25 | 2024-02-08T11:44:25 | Juhwan Choi, Kyohoon Jin, Junho Lee, Sangmin Song, Youngbin Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Rule-based text data augmentation is widely used for NLP tasks due to its
simplicity. However, this method can potentially damage the original meaning of
the text, ultimately hurting the performance of the model. To overcome this
limitation, we propose a straightforward technique for applying soft labels to
augmented data. We conducted experiments across seven different classification
tasks and empirically demonstrated the effectiveness of our proposed approach.
We have publicly opened our source code for reproducibility. | [
0.0363510065,
0.0375267304,
-0.0097480463,
0.0177948941,
0.020140389,
0.000463521,
-0.0186522361,
-0.0123717142,
0.0089847026,
-0.0682480782,
-0.0232662372,
0.0451502204,
-0.0087216077,
0.0534040146,
0.0349570177,
-0.0453568809,
0.039942652,
0.0304271355,
0.0250757281,
0.0308637172,
0.057483878,
0.0195472762,
-0.0046362695,
0.0324825607,
-0.030341655,
0.0229513515,
0.0079361042,
0.006865195,
0.0255738404,
-0.0143740373,
0.0403204486,
0.051048629,
0.0179322921,
0.038540367,
0.0000018085,
-0.0502241626,
-0.0222798884,
0.0145794582,
-0.0305809919,
0.0257421006,
0.0069361599,
-0.0912304297,
0.0203110185,
-0.0226778071,
-0.03098033,
-0.034768492,
0.0608097389,
0.0706270933,
0.0890402794,
0.0783963203,
-0.016946692,
-0.0032819307,
0.0163344666,
-0.0283664335,
-0.0015992809,
-0.0229219738,
0.0452670194,
-0.0005495102,
-0.0217065271,
0.0459923483,
-0.011958845,
0.0390572958,
0.0300022662,
-0.0260996427,
0.0735684112,
0.0266047474,
-0.0356936492,
-0.002501701,
-0.009039022,
0.0692537427,
0.0045025134,
-0.0205370355,
-0.0234865043,
-0.0318629704,
0.018895736,
-0.0305650327,
-0.0031867323,
-0.0444327593,
0.0420973524,
0.0121941613,
0.0129672922,
-0.0138455154,
0.0517704971,
0.0396008268,
0.027289439,
0.0687792525,
-0.0168704186,
-0.0379714705,
-0.0083773937,
0.0343743376,
-0.0048758583,
-0.0209873412,
0.0092704166,
0.0386696868,
0.0218625106,
0.0081895944,
-0.0483229458,
-0.0493115298,
0.0547873825,
-0.0389139652,
0.0376423858,
0.0064988099,
-0.0315963216,
0.047822725,
-0.0598290823,
-0.0552965291,
0.0323859192,
0.0363066196,
-0.0396550037,
0.001577253,
-0.0163788423,
-0.0110112764,
-0.0521903783,
0.0278372541,
-0.0215413403,
-0.0117268767,
-0.0595162213,
-0.0246569272,
-0.0368622392,
0.000662871,
0.0057476196,
-0.0107954731,
-0.0427861474,
0.0198194925,
-0.0301796813,
0.0286100712,
-0.0616633184,
0.0741603673,
0.0004615649,
-0.0222416967,
-0.0218708869,
-0.0261336342,
0.036445789,
-0.0044088243,
-0.0069952738,
0.0450350866,
0.0172985308,
-0.061656218,
-0.0295286011,
-0.0519884042,
-0.0383764654,
0.0016809667,
-0.020314442,
-0.0272918623,
0.0212884694,
-0.049430225,
0.0142104141,
-0.035300523,
0.0210065115,
-0.0025039206,
0.0035430249,
0.1120311022,
-0.0981292725,
-0.0458252877,
-0.0130999805,
-0.0068116565,
-0.0465146191,
0.0649398193,
0.0023449967,
-0.0037677642,
0.0251107067,
0.0029696964,
0.0412792414,
0.0327279679,
0.0364018567,
0.0064762789,
0.0201020837,
-0.0367691442,
-0.0029811454,
0.0107729435,
-0.0288735982,
-0.0106248381,
-0.0188411828,
0.0141352424,
0.0532461517,
-0.0457690917,
0.0587491505,
0.0196882244,
0.001954834,
-0.0151355183,
0.0203654543,
-0.0210867543,
-0.0401486978,
-0.004774007,
-0.0359677263,
0.0089118183,
-0.0076362956,
0.0065958295,
-0.0118530979,
-0.0673817918,
0.0095693935,
-0.0469370522,
0.061380472,
-0.0023303579,
0.0551682077,
0.0624816045,
0.0428372361,
0.0022661232,
0.0764551088,
0.0034426639,
0.0413666368,
-0.0220577586,
0.0157016385,
0.033512827,
0.0372558869,
-0.064438574,
-0.035990987,
-0.0169464797,
0.0139283473,
0.0073490399,
0.0741509721,
-0.0109924031,
0.0167351663,
-0.0593972765,
-0.0249601938,
-0.0254032183,
0.0587926544,
-0.0082082376,
0.0145816924,
-0.002616978,
0.0522008725,
0.0031393566,
-0.0576577038,
0.0370958373,
0.031957522,
-0.0266751274,
0.0441623814,
0.0010355525,
-0.0308421031,
0.0540042557,
0.0186432116,
-0.0041883355,
0.0182824209,
-0.0121528767,
-0.0505699068,
-0.026985174,
-0.0101105813,
-0.0315433107,
0.0282093175,
-0.009162467,
-0.0308634769,
0.0004041471,
-0.0523230024,
-0.0280346461,
-0.0270880405,
-0.0490895435,
-0.0106566092,
-0.0451449007,
-0.0116860056,
0.039358858,
0.0606666021,
-0.0559968315,
0.0429033078,
0.0556205697,
-0.0058010165,
-0.0123863779,
-0.0235586464,
0.0114745544,
0.0183147769,
-0.0164133627,
-0.0221909564,
-0.0078627439,
-0.0006188359,
0.0286349431,
-0.0044052708,
-0.0865877494,
0.001746774,
-0.0345311984,
0.0035702512,
0.0157382693,
-0.0370260552,
0.0206224993,
0.0321713835,
0.0089480272,
-0.0340414792,
-0.0316644758,
-0.0193314794,
-0.0173796564,
0.0117365513,
0.0253503304,
0.0163378213,
-0.0181552488,
0.0024739758,
-0.0106801856,
-0.0444524251,
0.0157734603,
0.0278744232,
-0.02812461,
-0.0379457846,
-0.0552471504,
-0.0336465165,
0.0092295706,
0.0165353734,
0.0047082021,
-0.0305212792,
0.0043062731,
-0.0042336248,
0.0350969471,
-0.0175398495,
-0.0024153197,
0.028463468,
0.0069066682,
-0.0252057873,
0.0257874206,
-0.0363162495,
-0.0013659891,
0.01006498,
-0.0193168242,
-0.0160988979,
0.0214992929,
-0.038803,
-0.0405008309,
-0.0510591902,
0.0285641477,
-0.0172490105,
-0.0254815836,
-0.0185929127,
-0.0088983588,
-0.0075003612,
0.0095432876,
-0.0243733767,
-0.0414826013,
0.0986873731,
-0.0222725309,
-0.0099642817,
-0.0526837744,
-0.0515976176,
-0.0628903285,
0.0228309073,
0.0126933586,
0.0137734441,
0.0290333033,
-0.0148754753,
0.0366474688,
-0.0165734235,
-0.0091637,
-0.0314470269,
0.0778715685,
-0.0436004065,
0.0096861739,
-0.0069916691,
-0.042500142,
-0.0096804984,
-0.0426241383,
0.0075235334,
0.0038645579,
-0.0190145224,
-0.009619019,
-0.0239467807,
-0.0399887748,
0.0148839355,
0.0478191972,
-0.00328217,
-0.0106920581,
-0.0443843566,
0.0146186976,
0.079281114,
0.0535428561,
-0.0430919752,
0.0088269431,
-0.0325239673,
0.0135477586,
-0.0250500869,
-0.0077455943,
-0.0273691304,
0.0275110304,
0.0192006603,
-0.00729527,
-0.0053001083,
0.0004888675,
0.0587202795,
-0.0633124039,
-0.0044952133,
0.0972997621,
0.0413873009,
-0.047010392,
0.0259650499,
-0.0147024896,
0.0043706819,
0.0220013615,
0.0016284528,
-0.0748218596,
-0.0793870166,
-0.0032373609,
0.0127828717,
-0.015935909,
-0.0109475041,
0.0050258809,
-0.0691481084,
-0.0300300326,
-0.0051026614,
-0.0424382575,
-0.0345692597,
-0.0347079448,
0.0318874381,
-0.0249565262,
-0.0070592696,
-0.0548636951,
0.0405264348,
0.0093867471,
0.0073585794,
0.0057758614,
-0.0450108834,
-0.0204884149,
-0.0530076511,
0.0692095011,
0.0562413819,
0.0318505056,
-0.0394482724,
-0.0281790365,
0.0183186457,
0.0042154994,
-0.017488746,
-0.0088069877,
0.0558329523,
-0.0051691313,
-0.0255454816,
0.0068004415,
0.036855299,
-0.004204704,
-0.0164244808,
0.0115532726,
0.0670275837,
0.0344658718,
-0.0145050148,
-0.0367241688,
-0.0093976175,
-0.0086590918,
0.0409521423,
0.0105348518,
-0.0213699564,
0.0483678244,
-0.0499942191,
-0.0056893737,
-0.0066559389,
-0.0359329507,
0.0090075443,
-0.0430724062,
-0.0362284072,
-0.0698900744,
-0.086345762,
0.051039353,
0.0090414565,
0.0581839867,
0.0181247331,
-0.0147435199,
-0.028259933,
-0.0288077611,
0.0633195713,
-0.0413693786,
0.0311185401,
0.0252657719,
-0.0451763272,
0.037713401,
-0.0196809601,
-0.0074537275,
0.0683421269,
0.0097028017,
-0.0529524684,
0.0284837987,
0.0268178117,
0.0146202641,
0.0551377535,
-0.0488100499,
-0.0545016862,
0.0416589305,
0.0906836614,
-0.0294076931,
0.0030456507,
0.0352210142,
-0.0602070205,
0.0156257413,
0.0080439337,
-0.0460154638,
0.0153409513,
-0.0253737308,
0.0384296328,
-0.0253860373,
-0.0474335067,
0.0311730113,
-0.0002447999,
0.0597444475,
0.0047395341,
-0.0218735281,
-0.0080648307,
0.0187046956,
-0.0264843442,
-0.0561771318,
-0.008207635,
-0.025922209,
0.0372618623,
0.0156756602,
-0.0092451274,
0.017326802,
-0.0004842377,
0.0501516014,
-0.011982305,
-0.0381299369,
0.0348410942,
0.0070951506,
-0.0050164214,
0.0116386414,
0.0066788415,
0.0442212559,
0.0148341581,
0.0267079398,
-0.0258927308,
0.0104492996,
0.0282830913,
-0.0106232222,
-0.0234785322,
0.021814188,
-0.0444304533,
0.0618573427,
-0.0406282581,
0.0125750592,
0.0197166,
-0.0609113127,
0.0431788601,
-0.0237346068,
-0.0277412422,
0.0092446627,
0.0276062321,
-0.0183703266,
-0.0439054854,
0.0243010297,
0.0065150131,
-0.0200955309,
-0.0159944054,
0.0314116031,
-0.0367569588,
0.0701294914,
-0.0369420871,
0.0069998507,
-0.0164635014,
-0.0096038133,
0.0506094955,
0.0467758738,
-0.0411162153,
0.0230454654,
-0.0048569902,
-0.0588349476,
0.0047714687,
-0.0272935461,
0.0028137867,
0.0172773972,
0.0076950812,
0.0098180007,
-0.0026480146,
-0.045901157,
-0.0453066714,
-0.0213648397,
0.0449479669,
0.0053204531,
-0.0063392203,
-6.409894288e-33,
-0.0268530156,
-0.0001293658,
-0.0016589015,
0.0000980735,
-0.0066103353,
0.0581226684,
0.0129259098,
-0.0012303779,
-0.0044992683,
0.0217092428,
0.0123240054,
0.0189428702,
0.012464148,
0.0283916201,
-0.0159293283,
-0.0257840343,
0.0355744697,
0.0356004611,
0.0029244963,
0.0063278968,
-0.0330174156,
0.0083402144,
0.0623942018,
-0.1057673842,
0.0791481808,
0.0602146313,
-0.0535831451,
-0.0035534087,
-0.0251157954,
0.0530948564,
-0.0123753566,
0.0656296462,
0.0168135371,
-0.0260788668,
0.0119663011,
0.0275764987,
-0.0925370082,
-0.0013075288,
-0.0093396641,
0.0409610681,
-0.0490388907,
-0.0125573734,
0.0472234003,
-0.0047233277,
0.0386410356,
0.0103660859,
0.0456631593,
-0.0640070811,
0.0019296191,
-0.0258106943,
-0.0441610217,
0.0199388228,
-0.0105112465,
-0.0085978312,
0.0155864209,
-0.0106083686,
0.0305880345,
0.0414495394,
-0.1016826332,
0.0090193404,
0.0361380801,
0.048345793,
0.0045798551,
-0.001541696,
-0.0322339796,
0.0275374744,
-0.0155512448,
0.0122773927,
-0.0464572646,
-0.0045199809,
0.0450046882,
0.0000677157,
0.0774543881,
0.0468239672,
0.0713603348,
0.0151117742,
-0.0315369442,
0.0446488298,
-0.0005515179,
-0.0221476499,
-0.0223153587,
0.0160817243,
-0.0572413392,
0.014458254,
-0.0465481356,
0.0512440465,
-0.0427430309,
-0.0211664792,
-0.0200969968,
0.0463309698,
-0.0315768085,
0.078114666,
-0.0463797562,
-0.0451954566,
-0.0286436286,
-0.0333808623,
0.0080708107,
0.0093707042,
-0.0156162474,
-0.01921672,
-0.0365937762,
-0.0420477875,
0.077166751,
-0.0037512328,
0.0236584805,
-0.0055474434,
0.1168735325,
0.01486794,
-0.0735084787,
0.0111164842,
-0.0057270597,
0.0072628018,
0.0054961303,
-0.0202142447,
0.0191319063,
0.0344645642,
-0.0339619257,
0.0430780761,
0.0905008242,
0.0421629101,
-0.0175698269,
-0.0373742022,
-0.00205098,
-0.0093886508,
-0.0229968727,
-0.006965843,
0.0088592935,
-0.027416585,
0.0134366974,
-0.0748896748,
-0.0184134748,
-0.0280040279,
2.595e-7,
0.0476144589,
0.0392597392,
0.0158518292,
0.0224242862,
-0.0055758841,
0.0667224005,
-0.0209402964,
0.0411324389,
0.0141205024,
-0.003268433,
0.0116634937,
0.0019157903,
0.0122677227,
0.0008390343,
-0.0609575249,
-0.0409220196,
-0.0265606903,
-0.0036520874,
-0.0483585075,
0.0220916402,
0.064260751,
0.1273060143,
0.0586679429,
-0.0128671555,
0.0185340587,
-0.0535125956,
0.0372775495,
0.0037439116,
-0.0055153053,
0.0183010604,
0.0815442279,
0.0226777177,
-0.0086598853,
0.0499678962,
-0.0533326603,
0.0214610342,
0.0272085331,
0.0170017611,
-0.0249406323,
0.0042819944,
-0.0167091358,
0.0027844722,
0.0226371177,
0.011202924,
0.0784694701,
-0.046587389,
-0.0353983343,
-0.0062904656,
-0.0662130266,
0.0276170354,
0.019220544,
-0.0457985662,
-0.0385633782,
0.0098455185,
0.0185783543,
0.0298535749,
-0.0607820153,
-0.1059183031,
-0.0518452302,
0.010979048,
0.006537613,
0.0017374066,
-0.02536707,
0.0092549957,
-0.0148256971,
-0.115035072,
0.0244322754,
2.250355365e-34,
0.0099171959,
-0.010795529,
0.0072717825,
0.0271968283,
0.0566128045,
-0.0004824392,
0.0001043829,
0.0108360359,
-0.0026566575,
-0.0720805377,
-0.0001907237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05584v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05584v1 | AutoAugment Is What You Need: Enhancing Rule-based Augmentation Methods in Low-resource Regimes | 2024-02-08T11:36:23 | 2024-02-08T11:36:23 | Juhwan Choi, Kyohoon Jin, Junho Lee, Sangmin Song, Youngbin Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text data augmentation is a complex problem due to the discrete nature of
sentences. Although rule-based augmentation methods are widely adopted in
real-world applications because of their simplicity, they suffer from potential
semantic damage. Previous researchers have suggested easy data augmentation
with soft labels (softEDA), employing label smoothing to mitigate this problem.
However, finding the best factor for each model and dataset is challenging;
therefore, using softEDA in real-world applications is still difficult. In this
paper, we propose adapting AutoAugment to solve this problem. The experimental
results suggest that the proposed method can boost existing augmentation
methods and that rule-based methods can enhance cutting-edge pre-trained
language models. We offer the source code. | [
0.0184326395,
0.064056538,
-0.0123082073,
0.0344453566,
0.0012437195,
-0.0029849829,
0.0039213537,
-0.0212860014,
0.0051338039,
-0.057066597,
-0.0181802958,
0.0217948947,
0.0103007071,
0.0352749713,
0.0369086713,
-0.0496488921,
0.0601183474,
-0.0181801226,
0.0507488996,
0.0103899632,
0.045322746,
-0.0042288639,
0.0058326568,
0.0256236028,
-0.0408601388,
0.0146682281,
0.0125596337,
0.0044984901,
0.0295484066,
0.0065671047,
0.0237289723,
0.0588450693,
0.0004177447,
0.0248127412,
0.0000020681,
-0.0532077476,
-0.0266309287,
-0.0018242043,
-0.0245748106,
0.0575571433,
0.0515572317,
-0.065280214,
-0.0038646092,
0.0031755038,
-0.0430604964,
-0.0464890786,
0.0675433055,
0.0251181163,
0.0850392506,
0.0828204826,
-0.0303091165,
-0.0266552567,
0.0404417887,
-0.036976818,
-0.0127895745,
-0.0407761335,
0.0456635691,
-0.0033880828,
-0.031496983,
0.0096093612,
-0.0210682414,
0.0434558243,
0.0040806513,
-0.0080761751,
0.0831815004,
0.0222606435,
-0.0443873405,
-0.0236624647,
-0.0144572817,
0.0608746558,
-0.0245918371,
-0.02370378,
-0.0074624983,
-0.0266026873,
0.0152188158,
-0.0264151525,
-0.0128652565,
-0.0290080607,
0.0547743961,
0.0285530351,
0.0242264494,
-0.0079093939,
0.0340521522,
0.0248194672,
-0.0243314095,
0.0799481571,
0.0085260989,
-0.031969253,
-0.0413514897,
0.013182248,
-0.0213884003,
-0.0301128887,
0.0278503597,
0.0332818292,
0.0304041207,
0.0038791471,
-0.0954004526,
-0.0598133989,
0.0240222476,
-0.0020527956,
0.0442583188,
0.0321543515,
-0.0582595915,
0.0365920439,
-0.0493927039,
-0.0269388892,
0.0267537236,
0.0457619019,
-0.0621412359,
0.024979569,
0.0218082573,
0.0006696412,
-0.0953396633,
0.017473055,
-0.0360843167,
-0.0403534807,
-0.0555893481,
-0.0182494335,
0.0027107841,
-0.0232833307,
0.0037010142,
-0.0469223708,
-0.0454761721,
-0.016622927,
0.0206935592,
0.026162494,
-0.0307519957,
0.0548366196,
0.0034481739,
-0.0448187292,
-0.0092326552,
-0.0272999816,
0.0881030113,
0.0050344267,
-0.0141669456,
0.0392176583,
-0.0101647386,
-0.0648661256,
-0.0578505844,
-0.0042537632,
-0.0176103991,
-0.0103235384,
-0.0640224144,
-0.0498924777,
0.0020219698,
-0.0311257262,
0.0136504723,
-0.0445594005,
0.0260059368,
-0.0261818003,
-0.0237314031,
0.0850149766,
-0.1019867286,
0.0118964221,
0.0266718809,
-0.0221419521,
0.0286864806,
0.0513503104,
0.026146302,
-0.0181073677,
0.0596316978,
0.0155054517,
0.0526064076,
0.0720266476,
0.0073280293,
0.0051028309,
-0.0003666988,
-0.0477192774,
-0.023552157,
-0.0075351275,
0.0334529728,
0.0091784624,
-0.0329608358,
0.007407228,
0.048683621,
-0.0398392193,
0.053835962,
0.0223285984,
-0.0002076561,
0.0009577852,
0.0195756685,
-0.0039893268,
-0.0126087815,
-0.0176871773,
-0.0382481441,
0.0280134138,
0.0422981605,
0.0225922745,
-0.0224237535,
-0.0785596892,
0.0216700975,
-0.0508036986,
0.054858651,
-0.022267662,
0.0587105043,
0.0686123148,
0.0042900266,
-0.0050917668,
0.0588315167,
-0.0334094092,
0.0334476307,
-0.0276029836,
0.0243634861,
0.0253011379,
0.050136555,
-0.0666046292,
-0.0238158293,
0.0047749383,
0.0168533679,
0.0164664648,
0.0303994268,
0.009361879,
0.029434653,
-0.0895207375,
-0.0255243704,
-0.0114710135,
0.052532047,
0.0058510113,
0.0043751891,
0.005050208,
0.0613496155,
-0.0080360025,
-0.0586059839,
0.0392863192,
0.0240374729,
-0.0135787725,
0.0409069918,
-0.0014294875,
-0.0204748735,
0.0276565887,
-0.0114581026,
0.0161323752,
0.0128326751,
-0.0360394344,
-0.0070319567,
-0.0079319561,
-0.0389823914,
-0.049900841,
0.0287670568,
-0.0024289219,
-0.0091865603,
0.0152333127,
-0.0428515188,
-0.0527281277,
-0.0155976508,
-0.0334239192,
0.0309479795,
-0.043964684,
0.0550328307,
0.0221003424,
0.05967848,
-0.0399242677,
0.0364341885,
0.0308279786,
-0.0202050786,
-0.0421984605,
0.0020568573,
0.023003811,
-0.0113724275,
-0.0185816679,
-0.0404550433,
-0.0328496806,
-0.0011741682,
0.0114489682,
-0.019793734,
-0.0463991053,
0.0243188459,
-0.0400921367,
-0.0266344491,
-0.0179370604,
-0.0212142896,
0.0051446776,
0.0806916952,
-0.0140746525,
-0.0451999046,
-0.0076919813,
0.0075045815,
-0.0244600791,
0.015747238,
0.0327896103,
0.0237784293,
-0.0139768664,
-0.0466820039,
-0.0046570688,
0.0015545266,
-0.0058241468,
0.0122775827,
-0.0574852526,
-0.0485408716,
-0.0080605866,
-0.010650469,
0.0199355837,
0.003236132,
-0.043495778,
-0.0482787117,
-0.0153415576,
0.0708643794,
0.0660491511,
0.0024567454,
-0.0272207018,
0.0398506336,
0.0052460246,
-0.0170882773,
0.0176328234,
-0.027977353,
0.0139248287,
-0.0105945505,
0.0016310811,
0.0294569731,
0.0500151217,
-0.0279630516,
-0.0231016725,
-0.0296398047,
-0.0033589434,
-0.0399177261,
-0.017577121,
-0.0072004753,
-0.0202830024,
-0.0316799246,
0.034777198,
-0.0179748312,
-0.0549567193,
0.0691572502,
-0.0567541458,
-0.0310353618,
-0.0610981584,
-0.0278623719,
-0.0380715802,
0.0052945032,
0.0603467897,
0.0194969438,
-0.0107653458,
-0.0254469458,
-0.0006436106,
0.0107057597,
0.0212449692,
-0.0158661678,
0.0521124788,
-0.042695757,
0.0125788553,
-0.0188754797,
-0.032676585,
-0.0107495366,
-0.0600728095,
-0.016311029,
-0.0248345118,
0.0173500087,
-0.0067343744,
-0.0180366412,
-0.0050144894,
0.005571147,
0.1144571602,
-0.0163116716,
0.0129775368,
-0.0468853749,
0.0512310751,
0.0683665499,
0.0201688986,
-0.0274188053,
-0.0037826065,
-0.0180641972,
-0.004477005,
0.0191756245,
-0.0262585096,
-0.0338698886,
0.0211852212,
0.0321532376,
-0.0093286335,
-0.0297303237,
-0.001776002,
0.0675324351,
-0.0489206053,
0.0071808188,
0.1015972272,
0.0321699046,
-0.0424487628,
0.0332025439,
-0.0144802853,
0.0088824211,
-0.005767412,
-0.0037229804,
-0.0996739343,
-0.0475641079,
-0.0007450437,
0.0044812188,
-0.0146539127,
0.002837484,
-0.0011249374,
-0.0905161723,
0.020308679,
0.0228033401,
-0.01377228,
-0.0016825808,
0.0011746504,
0.0401927792,
-0.025479069,
0.0015002475,
-0.0231936481,
0.006247249,
0.003039842,
0.0075823995,
-0.0336200967,
-0.0614194125,
-0.063179858,
-0.0233685169,
0.0954364091,
0.056518048,
0.0227807872,
-0.0250659194,
-0.0355728716,
0.0659843162,
0.0119337933,
-0.0147553179,
-0.0204745028,
0.0370283946,
-0.0009722126,
-0.014515087,
0.0332874097,
0.0369667374,
0.0325495675,
-0.0263053793,
0.0259584021,
0.0268731005,
0.0244956948,
0.0057162903,
-0.0100787953,
-0.0299935676,
-0.0146788321,
0.0318367109,
0.017297864,
-0.0187314935,
0.0128766168,
-0.0422605053,
0.005578124,
-0.0268828291,
-0.0321731828,
0.0095966794,
-0.0535385199,
-0.0718579218,
-0.0692279562,
-0.0424538963,
0.0347870849,
0.012446628,
0.0105322357,
0.0054761604,
0.0041790078,
-0.0019696979,
-0.0017792343,
0.020862231,
-0.0503469743,
0.0146978982,
-0.0153376292,
-0.0446065888,
0.0172618665,
-0.0365997367,
-0.0024677201,
0.0145340953,
-0.0189834014,
-0.0530996621,
0.0444937386,
0.0377075523,
0.0212505721,
0.080629535,
-0.0628964677,
-0.0806540027,
0.0716478229,
0.076227352,
-0.0594738349,
0.0288629197,
0.0576598495,
-0.0430338643,
0.0058643897,
0.0249274578,
-0.0439806841,
0.0437688529,
-0.014688964,
0.0372093022,
-0.0282053873,
-0.0706794858,
0.01806481,
0.0216286816,
0.0557741225,
-0.0201057009,
0.0189789105,
-0.0535858795,
0.0253479555,
-0.0300242081,
-0.0214135684,
-0.0589451864,
0.0114780106,
0.0484873392,
0.0298316907,
-0.0084723048,
-0.0115060816,
-0.0134195676,
0.0146486759,
-0.0302085951,
-0.0011726189,
0.014321778,
0.021605799,
0.0275492966,
-0.0052294312,
0.0070237862,
0.0249908119,
0.0075249835,
0.0079148067,
-0.0352749489,
-0.0035945612,
0.0109208282,
-0.0204093009,
-0.0675239116,
0.0483755209,
-0.0405000374,
0.041884955,
-0.0579220504,
0.0228621699,
0.019930413,
-0.0450742617,
0.0864093676,
-0.0213493742,
-0.0206059497,
-0.0117447758,
0.0253341608,
-0.0050773574,
-0.0317924432,
-0.0051205959,
-0.0038613719,
-0.0360412374,
0.0174564254,
0.0718798786,
0.0021002884,
0.0342041589,
-0.0024823679,
0.0086720977,
-0.0300438758,
-0.0147232125,
0.0159838535,
0.0532927662,
-0.0495660715,
-0.0002020988,
-0.0048486311,
-0.0538288057,
-0.0360289887,
-0.0239386391,
-0.0353537612,
-0.0074211149,
-0.0017804672,
0.0016647349,
-0.0148265269,
-0.017884288,
-0.0411569066,
-0.0308570918,
0.0178259499,
0.0109361652,
0.0323621891,
-6.476374371e-33,
-0.0243223812,
0.0172571782,
-0.0201563872,
-0.0054553687,
-0.0241233632,
0.03016885,
-0.0135744503,
0.0018454465,
0.0023117426,
0.0100543732,
0.0004385909,
-0.0008706136,
0.0402592234,
0.0393130295,
-0.013611204,
0.00772569,
0.0654412434,
0.0219739415,
-0.0060428884,
0.0147360135,
-0.0862426832,
0.0245559979,
0.0223601721,
-0.0849451944,
0.0082507189,
0.0243119895,
-0.0422376022,
-0.0106916381,
0.0114578838,
0.0523451418,
0.0015056271,
0.0628657714,
0.0030575944,
-0.0004516301,
-0.0301950201,
0.0264787283,
-0.1074667424,
-0.0125525482,
0.001138143,
0.0390843041,
-0.0478230454,
-0.0091387546,
0.0379178375,
-0.0104845213,
0.0267243106,
0.045278009,
0.0415080674,
-0.0693316385,
0.004641715,
-0.0111878747,
-0.0588791221,
0.0505352467,
-0.0059675793,
-0.0159589928,
0.0439437144,
0.0083374344,
0.0139220301,
0.0044089127,
-0.087502256,
0.0294133127,
0.0653492585,
0.0601169765,
0.017294541,
0.0177938826,
-0.0143108536,
0.0072688567,
-0.0112106511,
-0.0012512146,
-0.0055147111,
0.0249352157,
0.0616667569,
0.0280167479,
0.027155064,
0.0279271919,
0.0610126555,
-0.0117571605,
-0.0156064238,
0.0383024365,
-0.0116482489,
-0.0038391463,
-0.0210656058,
0.0505812094,
-0.0320912674,
-0.0019413104,
-0.006409104,
0.0108612878,
-0.0306691248,
-0.0177915785,
-0.0034904955,
0.0602101386,
-0.0605457015,
0.0397303477,
-0.0114328051,
-0.0300608929,
-0.0205605216,
-0.0212782267,
-0.008306927,
0.0338281691,
-0.0295116473,
0.0070849583,
-0.0473872237,
-0.0324137509,
0.0488006696,
0.0021402666,
-0.0081333295,
0.0022385784,
0.0563269556,
0.0292666387,
-0.0806040317,
0.0095957732,
0.0131877409,
0.0020139171,
0.0249929577,
0.0082936818,
0.0169610288,
0.0169082563,
-0.0302163232,
0.0454251654,
0.0643082559,
0.0240161065,
-0.0225623213,
-0.0262380466,
0.0230361242,
0.0036314181,
-0.0318245925,
-0.0104539096,
-0.0069328919,
0.0047873608,
0.0257338993,
-0.0530496538,
-0.0240746737,
-0.0174442455,
2.677e-7,
0.0491645783,
0.0274199415,
0.0413393341,
-0.0452797189,
0.0053714956,
0.0287595931,
-0.0173156466,
0.0259136222,
0.0067401021,
0.0283135474,
0.0389132388,
0.0125314509,
0.0403355248,
-0.0215946995,
-0.0563932247,
0.0008733714,
-0.0298954211,
-0.0049201525,
-0.0549613051,
-0.0213050619,
0.025967367,
0.1180094555,
0.0425669737,
-0.0049278657,
0.0002633035,
-0.0566882007,
0.0188464299,
0.0034840053,
-0.0100858891,
0.0540200807,
0.0678829551,
0.0664461032,
-0.0154878674,
0.0148975188,
-0.0471294671,
0.0439304188,
0.0159786753,
0.0498405024,
-0.0414162204,
0.0461823493,
0.0039112978,
0.0277449265,
0.0144429784,
-0.0183416456,
0.0776453391,
-0.0398081914,
-0.001956641,
0.000607116,
-0.0547137856,
0.0332792252,
0.0009105415,
-0.0266305879,
-0.0561000407,
0.0077075772,
0.0635373369,
0.0038983645,
-0.0621014982,
-0.0859420821,
-0.0499477275,
-0.0020728267,
0.0006862831,
-0.0249030348,
-0.0437701643,
0.0239401236,
0.0123852687,
-0.0778913051,
0.033444643,
2.609562332e-34,
0.0320103504,
-0.0310408995,
0.0064268922,
0.0415766798,
0.0237157494,
-0.0183420442,
0.0088822851,
0.04266252,
-0.0158362817,
-0.0791882202,
-0.0031519271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05581v1 | Establishing degrees of closeness between audio recordings along different dimensions using large-scale cross-lingual models | 2024-02-08T11:31:23 | 2024-02-08T11:31:23 | Maxime Fily, Guillaume Wisniewski, Severine Guillaume, Gilles Adda, Alexis Michaud | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In the highly constrained context of low-resource language studies, we
explore vector representations of speech from a pretrained model to determine
their level of abstraction with regard to the audio signal. We propose a new
unsupervised method using ABX tests on audio recordings with carefully curated
metadata to shed light on the type of information present in the
representations. ABX tests determine whether the representations computed by a
multilingual speech model encode a given characteristic. Three experiments are
devised: one on room acoustics aspects, one on linguistic genre, and one on
phonetic aspects. The results confirm that the representations extracted from
recordings with different linguistic/extra-linguistic characteristics differ
along the same lines. Embedding more audio signal in one vector better
discriminates extra-linguistic characteristics, whereas shorter snippets are
better to distinguish segmental information. The method is fully unsupervised,
potentially opening new research avenues for comparative work on
under-documented languages. | [
-0.0643432364,
0.0565779917,
-0.0413192175,
0.0558702685,
-0.0486605465,
-0.0062579717,
0.0080234492,
0.025554277,
-0.0767298639,
-0.0213889983,
-0.105084613,
-0.0386000238,
0.0377663001,
0.0091171656,
0.0358720683,
-0.0307837166,
0.0303983428,
-0.0241973177,
0.0107850675,
-0.016335953,
0.0060336459,
-0.035484653,
-0.0046330732,
0.0268191397,
-0.0033847825,
0.016068818,
-0.0212335568,
-0.0292470232,
0.0183384269,
0.0265920255,
-0.0447159223,
0.0205495227,
0.0331536978,
0.0322828479,
0.0000017992,
-0.0466603898,
-0.0052146898,
-0.004119053,
-0.0177163798,
-0.0246201251,
-0.0226700865,
0.003967273,
-0.0291237645,
-0.0378092416,
-0.0127038304,
-0.0747289434,
0.0461836457,
0.0058719022,
0.0003056343,
0.0240019262,
-0.0198801663,
-0.0486671142,
-0.0124114072,
-0.0018434776,
0.0229712278,
0.034496285,
-0.0077275266,
0.0150071383,
0.0009537538,
-0.020401461,
-0.0648641437,
0.0261844695,
-0.0048947311,
0.0513238795,
-0.0098522389,
0.0304998811,
-0.0514259115,
-0.0133001506,
0.0403657183,
0.0674288943,
0.0065828618,
-0.0332461819,
0.0190807898,
0.0225601792,
-0.0514829345,
-0.0274180882,
-0.0270735696,
0.0104031116,
0.0263753459,
0.0057941289,
-0.0098766526,
0.0535862483,
0.030472897,
-0.0445591323,
0.0051138597,
0.0274557211,
0.0037878719,
-0.0507847108,
0.0124357594,
-0.0271591377,
0.0425462686,
-0.011298053,
-0.0092062075,
-0.0339192338,
0.0170140993,
-0.0023091324,
0.016746711,
-0.0208581537,
0.0145999547,
-0.0266675968,
0.0204315353,
0.0292586163,
-0.0854958966,
0.0426025689,
-0.0202418063,
0.0260641649,
-0.0225887597,
0.0222517867,
-0.0392764062,
0.0053056129,
-0.0338544063,
-0.0020204301,
-0.0040251389,
0.0049593542,
0.0310215466,
-0.0139119281,
-0.0152247036,
-0.0242573917,
-0.0382778682,
0.0489747338,
-0.0705456585,
-0.0377152748,
0.0266767275,
0.0151949069,
0.0060367072,
-0.0005446122,
-0.067824617,
0.0507366471,
-0.0656027645,
-0.021428721,
0.0232169144,
0.0390119404,
0.0332982838,
-0.0156213436,
0.0073802783,
0.019868426,
0.0316448733,
-0.0068333568,
0.0046798787,
-0.0407766588,
0.0007276366,
-0.051001437,
0.0085221641,
-0.0803758204,
0.0778452232,
-0.021995008,
-0.0149218887,
-0.0061157946,
-0.0306034107,
-0.0454880521,
-0.0012340319,
0.0538537987,
0.0273017529,
0.0509336591,
0.0104187867,
0.0127501842,
0.0139423879,
0.0108670481,
0.0305940751,
-0.0644838139,
0.0589088351,
-0.0579119585,
-0.0103782397,
0.046182286,
0.0055645155,
-0.0065395706,
-0.0361132994,
-0.0124492673,
0.004042618,
0.0234073736,
0.0462841988,
0.0314889513,
-0.0456616804,
-0.070234336,
0.0302846041,
0.102819927,
-0.0173083059,
0.0187169816,
0.0501808748,
0.0068459883,
-0.0029902344,
0.0764733553,
0.0215912554,
-0.006150749,
0.0272613727,
0.0292418581,
0.0799889714,
-0.0032042279,
-0.0365482941,
0.0208877381,
-0.0023974706,
-0.0346208476,
0.0141088609,
-0.0191186089,
0.0300038829,
0.004900225,
0.0121539356,
0.0640891865,
0.0034250887,
-0.0168678071,
-0.0156668443,
-0.0149460714,
0.0454853252,
-0.0208361484,
-0.0240277778,
-0.0473173186,
0.049929332,
-0.0299654789,
0.0092032505,
0.0479957946,
0.0195086058,
-0.0158997681,
0.0597747862,
-0.0154525246,
-0.0004182046,
-0.0039369762,
0.0302943215,
0.0457804948,
-0.057857208,
0.0155057888,
-0.0023418402,
-0.0734787136,
0.0165808536,
-0.0164942648,
-0.0350264981,
-0.0300456975,
0.013604071,
0.0435822085,
0.0566709414,
0.0610419065,
-0.0666607916,
0.0174141861,
0.0166266486,
-0.0581661537,
0.0298568755,
0.0464141592,
-0.0496248417,
0.0131435189,
0.0271337982,
-0.0375744142,
0.0297681466,
0.0059443959,
0.0243495777,
-0.0271862186,
0.0779392943,
-0.0353825502,
0.1123228222,
-0.0579806305,
0.0120940339,
-0.0453356802,
0.0304768607,
0.0509266704,
0.0050774445,
0.021303216,
0.0502529889,
0.008788106,
-0.0184637792,
0.0621352717,
-0.0244236924,
-0.0305691473,
0.0708571523,
-0.0239071324,
0.01620779,
0.0032397148,
-0.0587858744,
-0.0159243438,
0.0497579575,
-0.071266152,
-0.0123645598,
-0.0440555774,
0.0115964301,
-0.0168922804,
-0.0077875555,
0.0116736991,
0.0080087334,
-0.0465676859,
-0.0484988801,
0.0064017791,
0.0449425094,
-0.0363455079,
-0.0103659378,
-0.0501915403,
-0.0225778893,
-0.0256819576,
0.0146795698,
0.033039473,
-0.0564052053,
-0.0128235901,
-0.0072828317,
-0.0325063989,
-0.0372034349,
-0.0016577381,
0.0068288753,
-0.0148033164,
-0.0238436982,
-0.018455822,
0.0385921784,
-0.006564491,
-0.0567447841,
-0.0190191343,
0.0937136412,
-0.0099321483,
-0.0523144864,
-0.0220399015,
-0.0036396668,
0.0402471125,
-0.0468622185,
0.0139034819,
-0.0241425019,
0.0485284589,
0.0515096076,
-0.0087593133,
-0.0090874331,
-0.0097231735,
-0.0481480807,
-0.0282208454,
-0.0387684405,
-0.0519831628,
-0.0372700244,
0.0785028711,
-0.006715945,
-0.0235186387,
0.0391184799,
-0.0695390031,
-0.0209026635,
-0.0210872833,
-0.0557889082,
-0.0129119288,
0.0433104225,
0.0076738126,
0.0275119152,
0.005382596,
-0.0202623252,
-0.036833562,
0.0281070303,
0.0218973942,
-0.025289448,
0.012300157,
-0.0028550385,
-0.014946416,
0.0043260115,
-0.0040099798,
-0.0171641726,
0.0034163499,
0.007204026,
0.0342718288,
-0.0227002688,
0.0011971026,
-0.0115474276,
0.0498270281,
0.0379267782,
0.0157634802,
-0.0011680584,
0.0242163558,
-0.0067094378,
0.1003105342,
0.0084493766,
0.0413257293,
0.0089635635,
-0.0153392563,
0.0225806739,
-0.0195669942,
0.0038748784,
0.0393376946,
-0.0272017773,
0.03544949,
-0.013631775,
0.0288145617,
-0.0510610938,
0.0059263404,
0.0158494823,
-0.0239746291,
-0.0043041939,
0.0891685784,
0.0018637739,
-0.0245616566,
0.0293828845,
-0.01849504,
-0.0162134115,
0.0058706556,
0.0139522348,
-0.0418913737,
0.0246386193,
0.0262067076,
0.018566126,
0.0031475697,
0.0278960019,
0.0097610643,
-0.0883143246,
0.0421681441,
-0.0062897974,
-0.0745596439,
-0.0442454778,
-0.0621717647,
0.0254062545,
-0.0021851808,
0.0467090681,
-0.0485662259,
0.004459627,
-0.0404390618,
-0.0113462396,
-0.1018503457,
-0.0473667867,
0.0436691195,
-0.0359915644,
0.0786957666,
0.0235597882,
0.0564441085,
-0.0558139533,
-0.0434110984,
-0.0087819677,
-0.0409961604,
-0.0180621017,
0.0237620864,
0.0487399846,
0.0503528789,
-0.0094253952,
0.0691458657,
0.0221114904,
0.0387750715,
-0.015621027,
-0.0245226398,
0.0638650879,
-0.0218961705,
-0.0068120928,
0.0064925943,
0.0333847813,
-0.001036205,
0.0704142004,
0.058087457,
-0.0208256748,
0.0232408959,
0.0160761196,
0.0320560522,
0.006497859,
-0.0355789773,
-0.0000970004,
-0.0328945145,
-0.0589714386,
-0.0529195368,
-0.0142632416,
-0.0219504368,
0.0127486046,
0.0159942321,
0.0050723781,
0.0145029845,
-0.0232135002,
-0.0425958,
0.0230714269,
0.0207809675,
0.051877778,
0.0175880808,
-0.037485335,
0.0210280027,
-0.0335897356,
-0.0378948152,
-0.0045230803,
-0.0193461999,
-0.0520826504,
0.0214183293,
-0.004942413,
0.0110159377,
0.0630448759,
0.0081846481,
-0.0124397809,
0.0545133352,
-0.0353186205,
-0.0502730608,
0.0475794189,
0.0476470403,
-0.0049756719,
-0.0086193075,
0.0494450592,
-0.0570017211,
0.0528109968,
-0.0090745129,
-0.0136626363,
-0.030344367,
-0.0075089098,
-0.0106773237,
-0.0191257317,
0.0211500004,
0.0096512949,
-0.0047674445,
-0.0300209895,
-0.0027468666,
0.0061066481,
0.0327141099,
-0.0060106027,
-0.0416669026,
0.026725702,
0.0412164181,
-0.0181202721,
0.0559350997,
-0.036242269,
0.0139323259,
-0.0093999328,
0.035670612,
-0.0065222234,
-0.0033131519,
-0.013888061,
0.044094719,
-0.0044030435,
0.0227186065,
0.0031252629,
0.0286896843,
-0.0167278554,
0.0103614768,
0.0040644715,
0.0092563694,
-0.0049374723,
0.0277984869,
-0.0283382814,
-0.0058198799,
0.0287282765,
-0.0185091626,
0.0232872758,
-0.0699839741,
0.0401664451,
-0.0207141135,
0.0265863761,
-0.0150258364,
0.0169549771,
-0.0236594807,
-0.008677844,
0.0087733949,
0.0153624639,
-0.0345196836,
0.0481030494,
0.0425828286,
-0.023377033,
0.0159984902,
-0.0463063754,
0.0430994704,
-0.0149918776,
-0.0019112026,
0.0147118466,
0.0339327566,
-0.0574995093,
-0.0325445458,
-0.0203934256,
-0.0735426471,
-0.0062103639,
-0.008004128,
-0.0142048365,
0.0161757059,
-0.0014951421,
0.0168232825,
0.0034916531,
0.0348116234,
0.0327036567,
-0.0736640766,
-0.0256551225,
0.0202451628,
0.0416561514,
-5.79936493e-33,
0.0081266314,
0.0057106679,
-0.0458424538,
0.0066957269,
-0.0074228756,
0.029050909,
-0.0558318198,
0.0078671798,
0.0057508089,
-0.0158384349,
0.0386519097,
-0.0118326023,
0.0126256002,
-0.0251094252,
0.0228924882,
0.0105633615,
0.049634885,
-0.0203380175,
0.0199064799,
0.0046283663,
0.0327286758,
0.006287389,
0.0334721468,
-0.1058295071,
0.00472847,
-0.0209344868,
0.0361357033,
0.0008239819,
0.0405444875,
0.0840951577,
-0.063128449,
0.0384592377,
-0.0075979782,
-0.0384677425,
-0.0384775549,
0.0171423927,
-0.0672579706,
-0.030179821,
0.0088276751,
0.0560928285,
0.012710575,
0.0219873786,
-0.0059893336,
0.009433941,
-0.0063707856,
-0.0057846843,
0.0437234789,
-0.0261971802,
0.0101031354,
-0.0394567288,
-0.0663595647,
-0.0038329007,
-0.0287338085,
-0.0001592622,
0.1492688209,
0.0511284024,
-0.0154828345,
-0.041792199,
-0.0586904474,
0.0488727242,
-0.0240845587,
0.0213936791,
0.0677705258,
-0.007120301,
0.0090488903,
0.0508959293,
0.1037525758,
-0.0691291317,
0.0388516337,
-0.0024463993,
0.0463764146,
0.032653939,
-0.0463926345,
0.0484832413,
0.0396619029,
0.0125647495,
-0.003618188,
-0.0252949037,
0.0292256251,
-0.0052645323,
0.0083816303,
0.0257612728,
-0.0148289939,
0.0011500511,
-0.0366895311,
-0.0388144627,
-0.0220051575,
-0.0260000266,
0.0283366907,
-0.0385516025,
0.0328317098,
-0.0184883829,
0.071296379,
-0.0410102569,
-0.0121216113,
-0.0209247377,
-0.0089382017,
0.0148908114,
0.0341378711,
-0.0065010102,
-0.0200577937,
-0.016656952,
0.043028865,
-0.0114542358,
0.0695820898,
-0.0285157897,
0.0127617614,
0.0353492573,
-0.0474827364,
0.0163136497,
0.0255783591,
-0.0754252225,
-0.008340124,
0.0001835895,
0.0277323592,
0.0476285517,
-0.0082788877,
0.039822448,
0.0263876393,
0.0233599488,
-0.0020985801,
-0.0241471808,
-0.040000394,
0.0476654246,
-0.0448907912,
-0.0288091097,
-0.0229521953,
-0.0422428846,
0.0922014713,
0.003878969,
-0.0076747513,
0.0053001996,
2.754e-7,
-0.0421993323,
0.013912702,
0.0234657545,
-0.0314465687,
0.0252759866,
0.0045948555,
-0.0771183744,
0.0143054202,
-0.0410868414,
-0.0423164815,
0.0274328664,
-0.002709659,
0.105665423,
0.0798147246,
-0.0841170847,
0.0311628412,
-0.0675813034,
-0.0098212762,
-0.0778794214,
0.0094124405,
0.0287050027,
0.0885118097,
-0.0313322209,
-0.0219667442,
0.0133287571,
-0.0223126337,
0.0143726701,
-0.056717325,
0.0096948529,
-0.0247027241,
-0.020462634,
0.0039471923,
-0.0254912227,
0.0058913231,
-0.0083861388,
0.0568121076,
0.0305839125,
0.0259076543,
0.0186181087,
-0.0469389968,
-0.0163616464,
0.0508732051,
-0.035957545,
-0.0101121822,
0.0438805446,
0.0215850547,
-0.036233522,
-0.010649059,
-0.0354731977,
0.0360482819,
0.0380162895,
0.0168070141,
-0.003887288,
0.0026706103,
0.0274307616,
-0.009288853,
-0.0247530807,
-0.027145803,
-0.0005466845,
0.0797408298,
-0.0697232261,
-0.0581802875,
0.0181472953,
-0.0270675328,
0.0516553223,
-0.0516136587,
-0.0141781205,
2.047057061e-34,
0.0223093443,
-0.0157695524,
0.0086532068,
-0.0010577043,
-0.0144250225,
-0.0711872205,
0.020337427,
0.0128970128,
-0.0002232256,
-0.0318644345,
-0.0087753944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05571v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05571v1 | Traditional Machine Learning Models and Bidirectional Encoder Representations From Transformer (BERT)-Based Automatic Classification of Tweets About Eating Disorders: Algorithm Development and Validation Study | 2024-02-08T11:16:13 | 2024-02-08T11:16:13 | José Alberto Benítez-Andrades, José-Manuel Alija-Pérez, Maria-Esther Vidal, Rafael Pastor-Vargas, María Teresa García-Ordás | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Background: Eating disorders are increasingly prevalent, and social networks
offer valuable information.
Objective: Our goal was to identify efficient machine learning models for
categorizing tweets related to eating disorders.
Methods: Over three months, we collected tweets about eating disorders. A
2,000-tweet subset was labeled for: (1) being written by individuals with
eating disorders, (2) promoting eating disorders, (3) informativeness, and (4)
scientific content. Both traditional machine learning and deep learning models
were employed for classification, assessing accuracy, F1 score, and
computational time.
Results: From 1,058,957 collected tweets, transformer-based bidirectional
encoder representations achieved the highest F1 scores (71.1%-86.4%) across all
four categories.
Conclusions: Transformer-based models outperform traditional techniques in
classifying eating disorder-related tweets, though they require more
computational resources. | [
0.0605188049,
0.0483179241,
0.000870985,
-0.0118314289,
0.0014735777,
0.064486891,
0.0103171533,
0.0146815814,
0.0446896553,
-0.057046067,
0.0300259981,
-0.0329783037,
-0.0596305244,
0.0652151331,
-0.0298604164,
-0.02911276,
-0.0057073133,
0.0329481885,
0.0193902124,
-0.0000485305,
-0.008172988,
0.0161902234,
0.0097475732,
0.0277093537,
0.0049322625,
0.0094776712,
0.0549804494,
-0.0008252269,
0.0208171029,
-0.0352600738,
0.0633712709,
0.0281035136,
0.0008496562,
0.0424510166,
0.0000020743,
0.0269345026,
-0.0228034556,
-0.0024770889,
-0.0145449936,
-0.0302561019,
0.0383982845,
-0.0976101831,
0.0199492127,
0.0352366753,
-0.0166815575,
-0.0157656558,
0.0745792687,
0.0848106295,
0.0505935065,
0.0578857772,
-0.0246385988,
-0.0621873252,
0.0064457506,
0.0173334517,
-0.0103027364,
0.0203177277,
0.0511450395,
-0.0595831573,
-0.0138529809,
0.0134583954,
-0.0009467602,
0.0629464164,
0.0312144812,
0.0142980311,
0.0370605215,
0.013648564,
-0.0311769135,
-0.0554771647,
0.0369856693,
0.0445642397,
-0.0047346395,
-0.028551111,
0.0214754771,
0.0035042197,
-0.0255735461,
0.0471794941,
0.0024007985,
-0.0077733248,
-0.011078815,
0.0403404534,
-0.0077903206,
0.0165095776,
0.0378655642,
0.0431097932,
-0.0128498627,
0.0222472716,
-0.0099820457,
-0.03377885,
-0.0048497878,
0.0024586257,
-0.0205002949,
-0.0488124639,
0.0444341488,
0.0033307842,
0.0075934445,
-0.0054716798,
-0.0197535865,
-0.0602445453,
0.0153108248,
-0.067527093,
-0.0164012797,
0.0216586962,
-0.0401565991,
-0.0430299491,
-0.0049672555,
0.0039583431,
-0.0366544724,
0.0600723885,
-0.0048190681,
0.0181576312,
-0.0611333735,
0.0048965709,
-0.0051479819,
0.0074359369,
-0.0300511066,
-0.030241685,
-0.0397373587,
0.0006604554,
-0.040499799,
-0.0444480814,
0.0207001846,
0.0633291528,
0.0255944561,
0.0281288009,
0.0363739133,
0.0476811528,
0.0185563676,
0.0187401231,
-0.0255209822,
0.0190633349,
0.0415065661,
-0.0163884703,
0.0358152799,
-0.0320771933,
0.0209890362,
0.0327534713,
0.0217990614,
-0.0649740919,
-0.0373240858,
0.0144586591,
-0.0483600199,
-0.0180298742,
0.0186725426,
-0.034048155,
0.0020706467,
0.0404013023,
0.019303441,
-0.0133242244,
0.019211797,
-0.0022464241,
-0.0210563019,
0.0346456505,
0.0066071148,
0.0223575141,
0.0673671439,
0.0283177476,
0.0213199072,
0.0597860664,
0.0586182885,
0.0644648895,
0.0222264379,
-0.0603862852,
-0.0116616264,
0.0048419298,
0.0074501513,
-0.0185329169,
0.0227492247,
-0.0168912653,
-0.0648613349,
0.0139892614,
-0.0488101579,
0.0567430109,
0.0057697836,
0.004546633,
0.0486364476,
0.0355334245,
0.0346085876,
0.078302905,
0.0168637633,
0.0452341996,
-0.010763769,
-0.0436470471,
-0.0089562079,
0.0204811599,
-0.0044943439,
-0.0396705754,
0.0080466457,
0.0231452938,
-0.0443530381,
-0.014737648,
-0.017285794,
-0.0376606397,
0.0550633334,
-0.0237703007,
0.0192169938,
-0.0253180936,
-0.0531929657,
0.0446485206,
0.00984836,
-0.0311610773,
-0.0160738397,
-0.0492122918,
0.0079574799,
0.0611099824,
-0.0007982106,
-0.0134193022,
-0.0057508294,
-0.0467783473,
0.0247072801,
0.0197066106,
-0.0226558279,
0.0242568851,
-0.0269887,
-0.0103563499,
-0.0174938627,
0.0018985416,
0.0171055179,
-0.0407061465,
-0.0188203994,
0.0484962948,
-0.022306148,
0.0442453735,
-0.0511327833,
0.0094106188,
-0.0161537174,
-0.0311389677,
0.039794594,
0.0218413156,
0.0243825708,
0.0485588647,
0.0110332491,
-0.0173662771,
-0.0050061261,
-0.0133179072,
-0.0823457614,
-0.0036763535,
0.0054730121,
0.0059884111,
-0.0233440064,
-0.0387043804,
-0.00374629,
0.0798505098,
-0.0407399237,
-0.0094499113,
0.0429158583,
-0.0716694966,
0.0325879082,
-0.0171191413,
-0.013807469,
-0.0460734144,
0.0067888703,
0.0348603874,
0.0494055636,
-0.0440921672,
0.0085963989,
-0.0275505595,
-0.0946075469,
-0.0274326466,
0.014147656,
-0.0266224518,
-0.0273077209,
-0.0130295474,
0.0082301637,
0.0275262576,
-0.0079007037,
0.0064122495,
-0.0294416137,
-0.0857590511,
0.0019151992,
-0.0576359369,
-0.0099823195,
-0.0252522118,
-0.0113787446,
0.0141387396,
0.0211349521,
-0.0029686231,
0.0046755364,
0.0182380732,
0.0352934897,
-0.0028703082,
-0.0108200265,
0.0016133647,
-0.0118132103,
-0.0185917411,
-0.0459887534,
0.0485197082,
0.0251628794,
-0.061704345,
-0.0085642096,
-0.045883555,
-0.0131953508,
-0.0302259084,
0.0264118109,
-0.0659869388,
-0.0215361509,
0.0378933772,
-0.015919188,
0.0035984337,
0.0496915057,
0.0842636749,
-0.0067868829,
0.0585141666,
-0.0061679604,
0.0016802516,
-0.0315603837,
-0.0245860945,
-0.035173934,
-0.0584376417,
0.0178893097,
0.0447648689,
0.0134138418,
0.0112685561,
-0.0464412682,
-0.00450393,
0.0146787567,
0.0065382803,
-0.0214485303,
-0.0304024611,
0.0038835704,
-0.0072990921,
-0.0128513323,
-0.0240367763,
0.0545798875,
0.015329551,
0.0090885321,
-0.0180786103,
-0.0565549582,
-0.0181415454,
0.00073221,
0.0424163267,
0.0694627613,
-0.0093496991,
-0.0136754569,
0.0734500885,
-0.0028904639,
-0.0299983155,
-0.0356450826,
0.0412132554,
0.018158488,
-0.0111391842,
0.0115197515,
-0.0294197518,
-0.03384386,
-0.0596242398,
-0.0204818193,
-0.0283771679,
-0.0018654735,
-0.031016646,
-0.0697953999,
0.0246243291,
-0.0154214194,
0.0342503861,
-0.0040382305,
-0.0185803175,
0.0089650201,
0.0075243795,
0.0268823616,
-0.0461693965,
-0.0175138097,
-0.0054554362,
0.0136296498,
0.0457913913,
-0.0568384714,
0.0340699777,
-0.0417822376,
0.0015208741,
0.0097685568,
-0.037454579,
0.0139936469,
-0.0194591284,
0.0260543972,
-0.0090518892,
-0.0078685265,
0.093648918,
0.0177536476,
-0.050205145,
0.0079992302,
0.0255158991,
-0.0483164601,
-0.0130498316,
0.0003017711,
-0.0674630031,
-0.0292873457,
-0.0577418432,
0.0319970883,
-0.0532960258,
-0.02845213,
0.0442466401,
-0.0182779748,
0.0069118496,
-0.0125739891,
0.0245655514,
-0.0651964322,
-0.057723701,
-0.0095858919,
-0.0269320812,
0.0076410994,
-0.048066359,
-0.0185648799,
-0.0078081749,
0.0185890477,
-0.065366976,
-0.0627387166,
0.0288347397,
-0.0243852641,
0.0055114781,
-0.0013262598,
0.0561317764,
-0.0237727836,
-0.0538200438,
-0.0026851702,
0.0326875299,
-0.0028725569,
-0.001148722,
0.0528868474,
-0.0123812202,
0.002999038,
-0.0255641136,
0.0124705378,
-0.0672143698,
-0.0180092622,
-0.0548639931,
0.1081217676,
-0.0248869378,
-0.0529250205,
-0.0468878448,
-0.0171156209,
0.0211327691,
0.0704107583,
0.0411531813,
-0.0352874994,
-0.0161746331,
-0.0364840329,
0.0150143513,
-0.0210046861,
-0.0165500492,
0.0288591851,
-0.0143491635,
-0.0852791891,
-0.0254426152,
0.0183919687,
0.0251465291,
-0.0574656054,
-0.007254099,
-0.0464126021,
0.0342885107,
-0.0312977359,
-0.0695603713,
0.0249242391,
0.0267266203,
0.0338756107,
-0.0148918265,
-0.0499405935,
0.0656610727,
0.016842775,
-0.0110819079,
-0.0044327816,
-0.0169520117,
-0.028562732,
0.0215964522,
0.0183886234,
0.0136222355,
-0.0322472006,
0.0114356969,
-0.0414914526,
0.0290137138,
0.0966621563,
-0.030551495,
-0.0500236489,
0.0077367024,
-0.0291973259,
-0.0077799615,
0.0175714716,
-0.0147467609,
0.0274464265,
-0.0296851229,
-0.0393148847,
-0.0791934356,
-0.0266433209,
-0.0292800292,
-0.0088192103,
0.0581653081,
0.0123621048,
-0.0866507068,
-0.0043799547,
-0.0389418006,
0.022855429,
0.0145843178,
-0.020606475,
-0.0180859789,
0.0837870836,
0.0187509544,
-0.0461331159,
0.0101757031,
-0.0333682932,
-0.012322247,
-0.0639512315,
0.0782787725,
0.0087348046,
0.0327310115,
-0.0156757031,
0.0209996272,
-0.0359709784,
-0.0121008744,
0.0483616553,
-0.0235988982,
-0.0105432933,
0.0480809435,
-0.0059214281,
0.0683700368,
0.0023347843,
0.0508615412,
-0.0369748138,
-0.0165083818,
-0.046587117,
-0.0823111758,
0.0089930156,
-0.0308497921,
0.0415296108,
0.0109653994,
-0.0261189919,
-0.0088405926,
0.0373056121,
-0.0513410084,
-0.0306086056,
0.037187878,
-0.0194536541,
-0.0133160995,
0.0054210168,
0.0421361849,
-0.0160126463,
0.0115881618,
0.0698726624,
-0.0395079665,
-0.0097474661,
0.0132242646,
0.0293807629,
-0.0037262111,
-0.0050715706,
0.0357431062,
0.0017836326,
-0.0533493906,
0.0559138954,
-0.0828806907,
0.0084969513,
-0.0297989044,
0.0359477773,
0.0352844968,
0.0277900752,
-0.009807623,
-0.0302069169,
-0.0071422942,
0.0090154028,
-0.0236029755,
-0.0373319536,
-6.249734652e-33,
0.0487396121,
-0.0360453576,
-0.0151232164,
-0.0041171568,
-0.0256423708,
0.0105259474,
-0.0170270447,
0.0045185499,
0.0339382254,
0.0164203495,
0.0344478823,
0.0354304761,
-0.0111473631,
0.0490954146,
0.0058857249,
-0.0560351722,
0.0367082432,
0.0012577454,
-0.0083321044,
0.0400865972,
0.0264179185,
0.0364624597,
0.015466989,
-0.088396281,
0.0186762419,
0.0170157962,
0.0305627771,
0.0005618996,
0.0575678162,
0.0314414166,
-0.0342469104,
0.0957851931,
0.0389315858,
-0.0277633686,
0.0401897766,
0.0714363977,
-0.0422163382,
-0.0161889941,
-0.0462262593,
-0.0306825936,
-0.0167217832,
-0.0415322594,
0.0670964569,
0.0339068994,
-0.0279577747,
-0.0179043561,
0.0608838424,
-0.0031541886,
0.0516708121,
-0.0071610427,
-0.0034131396,
-0.0064093764,
-0.0459853783,
-0.0101868697,
0.0330611207,
0.0574736819,
-0.0060218987,
0.0289288685,
-0.0799697489,
-0.0037737978,
-0.0004761124,
-0.0337770656,
0.0102974651,
-0.046038039,
-0.0157191623,
0.0347549506,
0.0026136225,
-0.012397117,
-0.0505036265,
0.0328685306,
-0.0384486914,
0.0640493259,
0.0662648305,
0.0189953614,
0.0417132378,
-0.0491219275,
-0.0424012989,
0.0456777588,
-0.0071159555,
-0.000247148,
0.0011949936,
-0.0270170756,
0.0094586331,
-0.0244833492,
0.0278298184,
-0.0407751463,
-0.0113424622,
-0.0199009106,
-0.0397747159,
-0.0094879931,
-0.0291119944,
0.0661807731,
-0.0017517321,
-0.036615584,
-0.0137585904,
0.0356546193,
0.0366626084,
0.0422152691,
0.0202487614,
0.0120497616,
-0.0398377143,
0.0087599289,
0.0080735832,
0.0355476402,
0.0368282869,
0.0054377159,
0.0307353586,
0.0265314337,
-0.0116277747,
-0.0047442177,
0.0085233143,
0.0003464016,
-0.0328728333,
0.0621677972,
-0.0452241562,
0.0464344732,
0.0121012302,
0.0300246235,
0.0185720399,
0.0671535805,
-0.0342783481,
-0.003703492,
-0.0031708127,
-0.0133815249,
0.0135974986,
-0.0271635801,
-0.0470823906,
0.064181678,
0.0239733011,
-0.123948276,
0.0108058117,
-0.0309001524,
2.812e-7,
0.0748314187,
0.069163762,
-0.0029195906,
-0.015046576,
0.042922128,
0.0296418648,
0.0434419252,
0.0531717278,
0.0329736136,
-0.0097740619,
-0.0138847781,
0.0462833345,
-0.0044389572,
0.0517756008,
0.0063557001,
-0.0165510401,
-0.1124046892,
0.0311064199,
-0.0425466858,
0.023593707,
0.0375789665,
0.0554156378,
0.0125705842,
-0.032401368,
0.0186045729,
-0.01149798,
0.0589817017,
-0.0388472974,
0.0369976163,
0.0163790341,
0.0327195488,
0.0217609722,
0.045776926,
-0.0383533686,
-0.0352297351,
-0.0177481472,
0.0167665202,
0.016504867,
-0.0357140079,
-0.023439467,
0.0205398183,
0.0054480713,
-0.010872798,
-0.0279555358,
0.0530735999,
-0.1076974273,
-0.0571383312,
0.0243706163,
-0.0215215869,
-0.0019682075,
0.0313956365,
-0.0212709401,
-0.0166685414,
0.0457496531,
0.0400295705,
-0.019269377,
0.0283631012,
-0.0881865248,
0.0206438974,
-0.0141289113,
-0.0420735441,
0.0295718517,
-0.012498782,
-0.0286648367,
0.0405828133,
-0.0349257402,
0.0510289222,
2.221791311e-34,
0.0317826159,
0.0125288619,
0.0016642011,
-0.0094070453,
-0.0286428444,
0.0246500466,
0.0223470666,
-0.0309600215,
-0.0302415956,
-0.0853393525,
0.0025331648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05547v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05547v2 | Benchmarking Large Language Models on Communicative Medical Coaching: a Novel System and Dataset | 2024-02-08T10:32:06 | 2024-06-08T16:36:56 | Hengguan Huang, Songtao Wang, Hongfu Liu, Hao Wang, Ye Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Traditional applications of natural language processing (NLP) in healthcare
have predominantly focused on patient-centered services, enhancing patient
interactions and care delivery, such as through medical dialogue systems.
However, the potential of NLP to benefit inexperienced doctors, particularly in
areas such as communicative medical coaching, remains largely unexplored. We
introduce "ChatCoach", a human-AI cooperative framework designed to assist
medical learners in practicing their communication skills during patient
consultations. ChatCoach (Our data and code are available online:
https://github.com/zerowst/Chatcoach)differentiates itself from conventional
dialogue systems by offering a simulated environment where medical learners can
practice dialogues with a patient agent, while a coach agent provides
immediate, structured feedback. This is facilitated by our proposed Generalized
Chain-of-Thought (GCoT) approach, which fosters the generation of structured
feedback and enhances the utilization of external knowledge sources.
Additionally, we have developed a dataset specifically for evaluating Large
Language Models (LLMs) within the ChatCoach framework on communicative medical
coaching tasks. Our empirical results validate the effectiveness of ChatCoach. | [
0.0940176621,
0.0279059112,
-0.0243981052,
0.0128814848,
-0.0478777215,
0.0164933149,
-0.0055999276,
-0.0024757162,
0.0619512089,
-0.0228475612,
-0.0399781205,
-0.064018555,
0.0258705262,
0.0122066,
0.0221291296,
-0.0756493583,
0.0261159409,
-0.0095910104,
0.047631897,
0.0132080801,
0.0158083215,
0.0090814317,
-0.0916633159,
0.0711822137,
-0.0054632039,
-0.0266980492,
-0.0081254449,
-0.0140500152,
0.007580237,
-0.0652410835,
-0.0017330223,
0.0201299079,
-0.0256345794,
-0.0168741811,
0.0000019097,
-0.0280089825,
0.0295889843,
-0.0033848404,
-0.0382861197,
-0.0385520309,
0.0604539849,
-0.0176555179,
-0.010206528,
0.0309079699,
-0.038691517,
0.0027124933,
0.0209086761,
0.0333364569,
0.0808601528,
0.0707414001,
0.0007358363,
0.011660737,
0.000862365,
0.0020596848,
-0.0183197912,
-0.0531155467,
0.0008608064,
0.0391879156,
0.048582539,
-0.0085257581,
-0.0105053969,
0.0312899686,
-0.0176835079,
-0.0208163671,
0.0045908056,
0.0355199911,
-0.0463075079,
-0.0275706109,
-0.0199513976,
0.0688407198,
0.0293772891,
0.0152972378,
0.0159173273,
0.0095822839,
0.0323553309,
-0.0116374269,
-0.038146168,
-0.0082405135,
-0.0176064633,
-0.000085332,
0.0064700404,
-0.0150002372,
0.0044687828,
0.0045473482,
0.0177764148,
-0.0191663392,
-0.011855456,
-0.0211364385,
0.0333520472,
-0.0036522308,
-0.0036758559,
-0.0542609468,
0.0192636065,
0.0488816611,
-0.0976421535,
0.0271146391,
-0.0198711883,
-0.0199498665,
0.0454583056,
-0.0397936366,
0.0339989476,
0.0181275643,
0.0098100193,
0.0303915665,
0.0332659893,
0.0209930558,
0.0150822746,
0.0281246509,
-0.0268482156,
0.003132557,
-0.0913107097,
-0.0206327625,
-0.0321452655,
0.0328893289,
-0.003943875,
-0.020744415,
-0.0621827878,
-0.0143796643,
-0.0240351819,
0.0428806432,
0.0018891083,
0.0158568732,
0.0057548471,
0.0214288644,
-0.028644735,
0.0405532233,
-0.0012138003,
0.0182464961,
0.017343916,
-0.0781089365,
0.0146123562,
0.0043814597,
-0.0171349198,
0.0184075721,
0.0029682454,
0.0475540273,
-0.0242525637,
-0.0213896018,
0.0187910497,
-0.0257105846,
-0.0346795693,
-0.0466173664,
0.0031724272,
-0.0650392175,
0.0308005139,
-0.0159045942,
0.0307720639,
-0.0416115746,
0.0372108966,
0.0273022745,
-0.0542236865,
0.0685824454,
-0.0445130691,
0.0333776027,
0.0432006158,
0.0397730209,
0.0027473629,
0.0352700353,
0.0324048325,
-0.0535086021,
0.0145331491,
-0.0219094269,
0.0191574506,
0.002713898,
0.0154426983,
-0.0495000631,
0.0256746095,
0.0244257879,
0.0036167463,
0.1068441868,
-0.0622122213,
0.085183166,
-0.0185066238,
0.0218535773,
0.0296665002,
0.083708778,
0.0023256259,
-0.0001311225,
0.034364447,
0.0130050294,
0.0287101492,
-0.0188581347,
0.0010102877,
-0.0164554603,
0.0210270658,
-0.0232337844,
-0.0096864244,
-0.0116563439,
-0.0427606255,
-0.0648111776,
-0.0358833522,
-0.014495478,
-0.0187829882,
-0.0184399504,
0.0220365617,
0.0080929929,
-0.0238145217,
0.0406429954,
0.0421673171,
-0.0582960546,
-0.0244513322,
-0.0536984392,
-0.0072614085,
0.087810047,
0.0629909262,
-0.0342158601,
-0.0565647259,
-0.0192404632,
0.0151845692,
0.0383062921,
0.0561763719,
-0.0282607172,
-0.0005980912,
-0.0470084995,
0.0112530831,
0.0380063206,
-0.0005030137,
-0.0438723154,
0.0017028392,
0.0118854493,
-0.0291662104,
0.0328432471,
-0.0445009023,
0.0357607007,
-0.0397140346,
-0.000526798,
0.009487791,
-0.0298344772,
0.0484062843,
0.0551596358,
-0.0231949259,
0.0223762821,
0.0267580282,
-0.0103873704,
-0.0280410405,
0.038069658,
-0.0478161797,
-0.0576137155,
0.0268242266,
-0.0448952429,
-0.0227123275,
-0.0028121579,
-0.0097529218,
-0.0336605236,
-0.0087726228,
-0.0651910231,
0.029377576,
0.0296488777,
0.0367864482,
0.029197013,
0.0072249584,
-0.0057173469,
-0.003338425,
-0.0142968828,
0.0100318361,
0.0181093477,
0.0128559303,
-0.0200640745,
-0.0479707159,
0.0017151631,
0.0283175725,
-0.0008480518,
0.014237579,
0.010383537,
0.0492826477,
-0.0466806404,
-0.0446982384,
-0.1666184664,
-0.0155269103,
0.0140729919,
-0.0208326112,
0.0025183614,
0.0084031802,
-0.0060662688,
-0.0081780134,
-0.040295437,
0.0192054939,
0.0367481783,
0.0027514731,
0.0198342502,
0.0292982776,
-0.0171905849,
-0.0400309414,
0.013349738,
-0.0453446396,
0.0128169544,
0.0134185608,
-0.0191261582,
-0.0030313646,
0.0043787109,
-0.0331325978,
0.0042175814,
-0.0303713679,
-0.0414238349,
0.043921385,
0.0091803409,
0.0164363477,
0.0407812111,
0.0228724014,
0.038104225,
0.0137484372,
-0.0183821358,
-0.037885718,
0.0298546813,
-0.0017207285,
-0.0546765327,
-0.0450123064,
-0.0418612659,
0.0063388427,
0.0788262933,
0.0193320736,
0.0183390807,
-0.0460235439,
-0.0067978897,
-0.0225875694,
0.0159970485,
-0.0498939417,
-0.0006545144,
-0.0231029149,
0.0254221596,
0.0125543531,
-0.0055853734,
0.0866815969,
-0.0216137469,
0.0089706909,
-0.0937649682,
-0.0357175805,
-0.0538286045,
0.0315518826,
-0.0194512289,
0.0069722664,
0.0222454891,
-0.0082098655,
0.0080129365,
0.0321803987,
-0.0207345709,
-0.0630269051,
0.0142220194,
-0.058760643,
0.0085389884,
0.039812535,
-0.037156973,
-0.0489389747,
0.0100261169,
-0.0540544726,
0.00772424,
0.0695642605,
0.0127006248,
-0.0497695506,
-0.0072578676,
0.0164957102,
0.0598538257,
0.0384185761,
-0.0223745611,
-0.0080703339,
-0.0091199316,
0.0141288191,
0.0159099717,
0.0085027898,
-0.0073034908,
0.0763366744,
0.0632329658,
0.0337343924,
0.0148098459,
-0.0057904967,
-0.0248671621,
0.0009502168,
-0.0018136307,
0.0014654255,
0.0345718302,
0.0373393148,
-0.0293428618,
-0.0467379689,
0.1097814068,
0.0451811925,
-0.0636207387,
0.0324172825,
-0.0158612374,
-0.0117715718,
-0.0037140804,
0.0085424073,
-0.0820346922,
-0.0367511697,
-0.0184660126,
0.0223231222,
-0.0216398649,
-0.0281984136,
0.0131298332,
-0.0977361575,
0.0223094448,
-0.0017505797,
-0.0055072764,
-0.0392302275,
-0.0187204387,
0.0003285259,
0.0105903232,
-0.018095104,
-0.0063422527,
-0.0061620022,
-0.0131436642,
-0.0081909942,
-0.0666518956,
-0.0628926307,
0.0215154104,
-0.0162815992,
0.09609586,
0.0717056617,
0.0585386418,
0.0206017457,
-0.0047739665,
0.0187406801,
0.0525416546,
0.0043534576,
-0.0124156754,
0.0665035024,
-0.0004030786,
0.0044200048,
-0.03113712,
0.0540808029,
-0.0544789806,
-0.0074984697,
0.0433067642,
0.052627027,
-0.0387932099,
-0.0069187339,
-0.0156851746,
0.0885809958,
0.0484808609,
0.0420195386,
0.007120871,
-0.0143603636,
-0.0131679075,
0.0012047755,
0.0245615989,
0.0437618457,
-0.0578890517,
0.0227368064,
0.0164881516,
0.0436710753,
-0.0599787273,
-0.0490759499,
0.0425584801,
-0.0069509321,
0.0087644281,
0.0200229455,
0.0270552747,
0.0410626121,
0.0045774519,
0.0210751146,
0.01370137,
0.0344921909,
-0.0733761415,
-0.0555247068,
0.0318442993,
-0.0121729383,
-0.0164045803,
0.0481303334,
-0.0348668061,
-0.0306596681,
-0.016074378,
0.0565719604,
0.0165083632,
0.0288307965,
0.0084024193,
-0.0285183396,
-0.038723968,
0.0276772603,
-0.0769061819,
-0.0063226144,
-0.0039238217,
0.0537658781,
0.015731534,
0.0300184451,
0.0075350888,
-0.0017150693,
-0.0118554141,
0.0520485528,
-0.0179845523,
-0.0459147505,
0.0063303052,
0.0197149646,
0.0215111747,
0.0063030985,
-0.0011925761,
-0.0144001273,
0.0338214636,
-0.0391121767,
-0.0119694434,
-0.0551131926,
-0.0032457551,
0.0004133036,
-0.028722534,
0.0163954291,
-0.0280572716,
-0.0612919554,
-0.0066747949,
0.002565349,
0.0342407785,
0.0244339369,
-0.0122343479,
0.0299555454,
-0.0164762028,
0.006922367,
0.0264436733,
0.0043355701,
0.0199712012,
0.0170112643,
0.1088221297,
0.0114618409,
-0.0175277255,
0.0332258046,
0.0256746337,
-0.0291622225,
-0.0800974518,
0.0032234956,
0.0466775708,
0.0531499535,
0.0308733396,
0.0097839162,
-0.0614654943,
0.0342918932,
0.0032504343,
0.0396748297,
-0.0412148014,
-0.0236395188,
0.0451569781,
-0.0034623956,
0.0138720367,
-0.0117010241,
0.0866600871,
-0.0155420527,
0.0324107148,
0.0052448865,
-0.0204308815,
-0.0676885098,
-0.0074468553,
0.0246445257,
0.0248517375,
-0.0464774407,
0.0438150689,
-0.0599882863,
-0.046396967,
-0.0050931964,
-0.0045605316,
-0.008998015,
-0.0412253141,
0.0738985911,
0.0223461911,
-0.0044380557,
-0.0093687708,
-0.0401871465,
0.0516820811,
-0.0068476931,
-0.0251945779,
-0.0212924164,
-5.292105322e-33,
-0.0237684902,
-0.0427980609,
0.0503868423,
0.0327058323,
-0.0035900348,
0.0066742641,
-0.0232607294,
0.0252414215,
-0.0030926585,
0.0287890956,
-0.0160506554,
0.0281688832,
-0.0073119593,
0.0443249419,
0.0078441938,
-0.0330578163,
0.0279491879,
0.0026570598,
-0.0111641195,
0.0199975781,
-0.0428992584,
0.0507499725,
0.0277568512,
-0.1055460498,
0.0319828428,
0.0001642365,
0.018858768,
0.0254555196,
-0.0063100629,
0.0373513103,
-0.0259490311,
0.0385109857,
0.033719752,
-0.0268021431,
-0.0019629728,
0.0021581654,
-0.0399156325,
-0.0283299461,
0.0249281097,
-0.0164593793,
-0.0730085596,
-0.0203025211,
0.0075639589,
-0.0125643732,
-0.0415090621,
0.0048863795,
0.0113695553,
-0.0212654546,
0.0090792691,
-0.0003523872,
-0.0497576706,
0.0377723351,
-0.0442024358,
-0.0559217855,
-0.0363824219,
0.0315829292,
-0.0486510769,
-0.0087609468,
-0.0194491893,
0.0248462036,
0.0411899574,
0.0165788922,
0.018016763,
-0.0441284105,
-0.0192039423,
0.0555774868,
0.0291553959,
-0.0038592995,
-0.0593558252,
-0.0051814611,
-0.0456583574,
0.0292844325,
0.0529093556,
0.021338515,
-0.0444594175,
-0.0033854377,
-0.0545971319,
-0.0009513424,
-0.010015022,
0.0440801121,
-0.0039181416,
-0.0004277107,
-0.0706939548,
-0.0087939631,
-0.0419741347,
-0.0197230298,
0.0024773448,
-0.0334190391,
0.0341841951,
0.019443946,
0.0265736524,
-0.0171051528,
-0.0108557176,
-0.0103365546,
0.0156817026,
-0.0135214832,
0.012024859,
0.0405600965,
-0.0387641639,
-0.0122417435,
-0.0960471854,
-0.0126853893,
0.0165570192,
-0.000592947,
0.0669249892,
0.0206125472,
0.0070574358,
-0.0250023026,
-0.0295742285,
-0.013421474,
-0.0042219465,
0.0250515137,
-0.0115191815,
0.0066194502,
0.01460471,
0.023827631,
-0.0500753559,
0.1071143076,
-0.0134471469,
-0.0237085335,
-0.054394871,
-0.0487290137,
-0.0085724844,
-0.0414212085,
-0.0707114413,
0.0059329672,
-0.0602087639,
0.0466190688,
0.0431833081,
-0.0400070585,
0.0030924543,
-0.0075871255,
2.712e-7,
0.0352402963,
0.0702641606,
0.0009793031,
-0.0047501368,
0.0322771631,
0.0187035855,
-0.01450272,
0.013429096,
-0.0163058527,
-0.0174034741,
0.0013108185,
0.0120273698,
0.0462192483,
0.0284779761,
-0.0820686147,
-0.0573489033,
-0.0866300687,
-0.0404506586,
-0.0363854915,
-0.0292724464,
0.0716113225,
0.0666973814,
-0.029350182,
-0.0224249773,
-0.0259254482,
0.0121815894,
0.033893019,
-0.0414553769,
-0.0286116768,
0.0557927899,
0.0464392826,
-0.0154348137,
0.0130808372,
0.0481887162,
-0.0030365214,
0.0081408983,
0.0110905031,
0.0765644982,
-0.0470240675,
0.0196741782,
0.0346083306,
0.0298547186,
-0.0217017476,
-0.0213617198,
0.0213177763,
-0.0872414634,
-0.050407175,
-0.015255942,
0.0191282164,
-0.0295792297,
0.0564730205,
-0.029980056,
-0.0185698029,
0.0367777944,
0.0121421134,
0.0083520878,
0.0029231294,
-0.0511439331,
-0.0081372568,
-0.0080361115,
-0.0421701223,
-0.0128381727,
0.0230710469,
-0.0253124014,
-0.0387840271,
-0.0583941974,
0.0159108005,
2.091100217e-34,
0.0197170638,
-0.001006354,
0.0264236014,
0.0449120589,
0.0675220713,
-0.0055733365,
0.0220321957,
0.044528123,
0.033382576,
-0.0487598367,
-0.0200551637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05545v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05545v1 | Named Entity Recognition for Address Extraction in Speech-to-Text Transcriptions Using Synthetic Data | 2024-02-08T10:29:11 | 2024-02-08T10:29:11 | Bibiána Lajčinová, Patrik Valábek, Michal Spišiak | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | This paper introduces an approach for building a Named Entity Recognition
(NER) model built upon a Bidirectional Encoder Representations from
Transformers (BERT) architecture, specifically utilizing the SlovakBERT model.
This NER model extracts address parts from data acquired from speech-to-text
transcriptions. Due to scarcity of real data, a synthetic dataset using GPT API
was generated. The importance of mimicking spoken language variability in this
artificial data is emphasized. The performance of our NER model, trained solely
on synthetic data, is evaluated using small real test dataset. | [
0.0290970616,
0.013098876,
0.0177133549,
0.0327826105,
0.0305696223,
0.0285186581,
-0.0020506266,
-0.0229363088,
0.0105850445,
-0.0233512037,
-0.0158524495,
-0.0193999894,
0.0204643998,
0.0019256094,
0.0504116677,
-0.02823334,
0.0183573458,
-0.0265615676,
-0.0196592305,
0.0040760543,
-0.0174435433,
0.0076277852,
-0.0391876437,
0.0132434266,
0.0359066986,
0.0429652631,
-0.0182408243,
0.0061064563,
0.0397253223,
-0.0291190837,
0.0216487143,
0.005294024,
0.0062685106,
0.0213079192,
0.0000017503,
-0.0168280285,
-0.0514982231,
0.0205481704,
-0.0463800877,
-0.050138738,
-0.0071661682,
0.0020792393,
-0.0311748777,
0.039486371,
0.0234129895,
-0.0733484253,
0.0444471054,
0.0605273806,
0.0084574446,
0.0598819144,
-0.0287067201,
-0.0579792671,
0.0427391976,
0.0110745244,
-0.0093798013,
-0.0018079331,
0.0278733019,
-0.0351536088,
0.0029248602,
-0.0093730148,
0.0325429179,
0.0070918072,
-0.006462316,
0.0435640775,
0.0335604325,
0.0431657135,
-0.0738094151,
0.0196652729,
-0.0219969358,
0.0572580583,
-0.0117207952,
-0.0121444901,
0.0454201363,
0.0147936996,
0.0058379131,
-0.0113846576,
0.0178227164,
-0.0452680588,
-0.0249469951,
-0.007830441,
-0.0145857548,
0.0189113505,
-0.0023843118,
-0.0504618436,
-0.0335089974,
0.0140240202,
0.0354355611,
-0.0639372617,
-0.0080880495,
-0.0066795382,
0.0175514594,
0.0031736307,
0.0483143888,
0.0114871254,
0.0502290167,
-0.0026041239,
0.0054326924,
-0.0442177691,
-0.0301624276,
-0.0425621308,
-0.0003085963,
0.0311049372,
-0.030573694,
-0.0277304817,
-0.0505866893,
0.0604609773,
-0.0336806662,
0.0384562388,
0.0186313055,
-0.0685060099,
-0.0378049873,
-0.0005604858,
-0.0530373529,
0.0514634252,
-0.0256079342,
0.0262854192,
0.0084918924,
0.0094282106,
0.0226032417,
0.0355613157,
0.0473619401,
-0.0176367033,
-0.0163691211,
0.0025660808,
-0.0098211467,
0.0070663006,
-0.0275866315,
-0.0062218406,
-0.0352969393,
-0.0391408838,
0.0102319987,
-0.0208389014,
0.0573548675,
-0.0367074311,
0.0061712055,
0.0717684105,
0.0181182306,
-0.0506758727,
-0.0508970954,
0.0451458618,
0.0115542337,
-0.0296128839,
0.0257086121,
-0.0276576113,
0.0481149182,
0.0157658756,
-0.0167855788,
-0.0200305674,
0.0080846529,
-0.0115685286,
-0.0077912649,
0.0585928299,
-0.0468259864,
0.0134909442,
0.0683177784,
-0.0385475717,
0.0562071055,
0.0036764883,
0.0498244949,
0.0016850985,
-0.0096874628,
-0.0214128029,
0.0210794378,
0.0600817949,
0.0043258863,
-0.0364528708,
0.0357090607,
0.0429641269,
-0.0134995421,
-0.0127390055,
0.0197507273,
0.053252317,
-0.0193380732,
0.0135982092,
0.0366838016,
0.0296438038,
0.0121693267,
0.0459248871,
0.0143530834,
0.0431523621,
0.0006575558,
-0.0447766967,
-0.0052230642,
0.0017035683,
0.0184075888,
0.0250319596,
0.0093858484,
0.0171338879,
-0.0167840831,
0.0478499122,
0.0221340824,
-0.0099796504,
-0.0443947352,
0.008725944,
0.031241864,
-0.0060471338,
-0.0961015597,
0.076458618,
0.0028391164,
-0.0319847651,
0.0096558118,
0.0280164722,
-0.0211725272,
0.0420718193,
0.0396707505,
-0.0234665368,
-0.042225834,
-0.0650960132,
-0.0984989107,
0.0373884439,
-0.0070689688,
-0.007306024,
0.0273855403,
-0.0270129517,
-0.0042575393,
0.0419536233,
-0.0204085223,
0.0490174294,
0.0086520752,
0.0101293186,
0.0274367556,
-0.0440690815,
0.0304814782,
0.0156178419,
-0.0324046314,
-0.0274350215,
0.0108743291,
0.0317133404,
0.0191261284,
0.0591727756,
-0.0272980053,
-0.0134658357,
0.0424068719,
-0.019276768,
0.0396190099,
0.011756096,
-0.00738926,
-0.0312467366,
-0.0207872149,
-0.0661187172,
0.0065272609,
0.050317619,
0.01514511,
-0.0660560429,
-0.0935650319,
-0.0273034405,
0.0622247867,
-0.041816581,
0.0157707743,
0.0254384149,
0.0261326712,
0.0033867564,
0.0019268348,
-0.003273532,
0.0265074167,
0.05028788,
0.045584783,
-0.0003821431,
-0.0531689115,
-0.0257834401,
0.0058983592,
-0.0261403378,
-0.0283425804,
-0.0036945259,
-0.0087030027,
0.0072924187,
-0.0525179878,
-0.0692256093,
-0.0263113566,
-0.0218644869,
0.0332223028,
0.0302246381,
0.0169429425,
-0.0182959456,
-0.0078634629,
-0.0290832575,
-0.0506920964,
-0.016890157,
-0.0417976677,
0.0149984248,
0.0014385156,
-0.0407818444,
0.0062415395,
0.0282293521,
-0.0283481628,
-0.0074738534,
-0.004867028,
-0.0230071824,
-0.0923234448,
0.0024171206,
0.0206841845,
0.0427204631,
-0.004838557,
-0.0270880219,
-0.0313271284,
0.0323876627,
0.0643068776,
-0.0039599095,
0.0041273804,
-0.0130062262,
-0.0605744943,
-0.0167315453,
-0.0136664482,
0.0306854993,
-0.0127683729,
0.0556952581,
-0.0419882461,
-0.0393395089,
0.0111727221,
0.0209949203,
-0.0174311008,
0.0495304689,
-0.0344081521,
-0.0453695282,
0.0330846272,
-0.0245453194,
0.0179711301,
0.0105579495,
-0.0539920703,
-0.0026815897,
-0.0008800506,
0.0204949882,
0.0261714663,
-0.1082811579,
-0.0518208332,
-0.0272498876,
0.0085617099,
-0.0114372829,
0.0139555,
0.0127054797,
-0.00759276,
-0.0006711145,
-0.1025557294,
0.0245615672,
0.0282112956,
-0.0371850133,
-0.034575291,
0.0238655563,
0.0354803354,
0.0159566291,
-0.0114875399,
-0.0471808948,
-0.0615820847,
-0.0076776049,
-0.0076375939,
0.0317464694,
0.0337928422,
-0.042319797,
-0.0027181031,
0.0696986318,
0.0063360659,
0.0941356495,
0.0145617425,
0.0191223249,
-0.04107517,
0.0530280732,
0.0382048227,
0.0335824192,
-0.0335264131,
-0.0053534801,
-0.0024997499,
-0.0512998216,
0.0043979404,
0.0106499745,
0.0212432705,
-0.01626404,
0.0187157262,
-0.0450503491,
0.0117093101,
0.0047761598,
0.0200127698,
0.013511477,
-0.0433295518,
0.11717958,
-0.0042267861,
-0.0215725563,
-0.0586310476,
-0.0067474516,
0.0090797246,
0.0091916658,
0.0477607548,
-0.0507429987,
-0.012201421,
0.0427031033,
0.0359476395,
-0.0078445114,
-0.0301890559,
0.0207805242,
-0.1334543675,
-0.0056215958,
-0.030378975,
-0.0503454357,
-0.0651545897,
-0.0419290587,
-0.0227616448,
-0.0191121604,
0.0015908717,
0.0093872743,
-0.0373199582,
-0.0380739681,
0.0398251601,
-0.0360604227,
-0.0497258939,
0.0129321553,
-0.0328054465,
0.0780759379,
0.0309435669,
0.0388154685,
-0.0419115871,
0.0134874098,
-0.0494095087,
-0.0151105113,
-0.0365608521,
0.0111364434,
0.0478487238,
-0.0437190793,
-0.025850568,
-0.0162190013,
0.00720486,
-0.0120554054,
0.0033386473,
0.0128902346,
0.0372418873,
-0.0172108933,
0.0436387695,
0.0291964859,
0.0010135623,
0.0073866989,
0.0570741594,
0.0169717632,
-0.0024774971,
-0.0188280102,
0.0056199352,
0.0411606357,
-0.0219415072,
0.0016731548,
0.044573199,
-0.0109177157,
-0.0594949313,
-0.0085320482,
-0.0467793196,
0.0351422988,
0.0175541081,
0.0500838608,
-0.0166506767,
0.0746482685,
0.0291624572,
-0.0495580547,
0.0103898058,
-0.0187535398,
0.0170044079,
-0.069919534,
-0.0323255211,
0.0429301858,
-0.0536325686,
-0.0440205485,
0.0056600217,
0.0109954691,
-0.0357682593,
0.0318863802,
0.0549853928,
0.0121604968,
0.0343590118,
-0.0402685925,
0.0057396046,
0.0299936514,
0.0062085087,
-0.0216598753,
-0.0383929834,
0.0349029228,
0.0057259421,
-0.0180063024,
-0.019171685,
-0.0093581602,
0.0259222221,
0.0061647836,
0.011780614,
-0.0128546935,
-0.0208947062,
-0.0012531044,
0.0253496785,
0.0751613602,
0.0129935527,
0.0298080761,
-0.0711655766,
0.0456509814,
0.0129968747,
0.0818959847,
-0.0066475407,
-0.0249711052,
0.0013421818,
0.0185189713,
-0.0132112559,
0.0337424576,
-0.0448715277,
-0.0368861668,
0.0003754172,
0.0302752852,
-0.0145152174,
0.0721271336,
0.0169477127,
-0.0428941138,
-0.0181257017,
0.0353115276,
0.0608209819,
0.0498286225,
-0.0004707667,
0.0214894526,
-0.0187226627,
-0.0086339014,
0.007775024,
0.0089530963,
-0.0191116389,
0.0165695213,
-0.0821639076,
0.0679164901,
0.0302508529,
0.0134650702,
0.0328423902,
-0.0098577477,
0.0222232137,
-0.01203903,
-0.0086894333,
-0.0369624048,
0.0053578541,
0.009482421,
0.0047140052,
-0.024206195,
-0.0252710842,
-0.0068600345,
0.0632516965,
0.0331884921,
-0.0268360581,
0.0205323789,
-0.0582675561,
-0.0328676589,
0.0312817357,
-0.0419188924,
-0.0312677771,
-0.0128176128,
-0.0136798332,
-0.0534121022,
0.0463445671,
-0.0025265808,
0.0032454347,
-0.0397963785,
0.0110383462,
-0.0525555797,
-0.0430739708,
-0.0074148015,
-0.004850938,
0.0042909477,
0.0228528194,
-0.0308769569,
-0.0123980762,
-5.765886116e-33,
-0.0439935066,
0.0104393139,
0.0208929908,
0.0050224564,
-0.0613411888,
-0.0073155565,
-0.0159479957,
-0.0049708318,
-0.0144250868,
-0.0420532078,
-0.0124485847,
-0.0237059388,
0.0348733515,
0.0385748222,
-0.0461704172,
-0.0578984432,
0.0643578917,
0.0247502197,
0.0110401195,
0.0053794081,
0.034302514,
0.0892010853,
0.1002315283,
-0.0413413495,
-0.0186264161,
-0.0766554326,
0.0302407611,
-0.0099375648,
0.0755292848,
0.0325435512,
-0.0320092551,
-0.001586585,
-0.0151359672,
-0.0710264891,
0.0364490636,
0.0669704974,
-0.1407235861,
0.0077336757,
0.0026007011,
0.0621952415,
0.0469901748,
-0.0245772488,
0.0034401082,
-0.0140346568,
-0.022726858,
0.0367517695,
0.0406287201,
-0.0002689261,
-0.0012220773,
-0.0189164281,
-0.02895022,
0.0118516237,
0.0080603939,
0.0061092391,
0.0673986003,
0.0235379506,
0.0466142371,
-0.0249161124,
-0.0803140253,
-0.0321967006,
0.0509996451,
-0.0112205017,
0.0185588915,
0.0505715124,
0.0151575506,
0.0203948338,
0.0476035513,
-0.0228148606,
-0.0281664301,
-0.0521810949,
-0.0101707848,
0.0085818274,
-0.0070152921,
0.022513045,
0.017046947,
-0.0498410836,
-0.037775442,
0.0258737728,
-0.0076123257,
-0.0387168825,
0.0236227922,
-0.0458768196,
-0.0375601202,
0.0402639173,
-0.0136854434,
-0.0463654622,
0.0007732784,
0.010637193,
0.0484386161,
0.0031899626,
-0.032002531,
0.0614608824,
0.0588934608,
-0.0068168626,
0.0005620767,
-0.0095469775,
0.0140380664,
0.0109867407,
-0.0370902419,
0.0489990823,
-0.0165144783,
-0.0762296245,
0.0337713547,
0.0375201032,
0.0054799216,
-0.0127472309,
0.0039747856,
-0.0103526786,
-0.0569625087,
0.0032570781,
0.0064156768,
0.0635120273,
-0.068019636,
0.0375009105,
-0.004717967,
-0.0008916812,
0.0252976846,
0.0196477678,
0.028089093,
0.0233106557,
0.0068768221,
0.0335740037,
0.0435363129,
0.0298506394,
0.0063688904,
0.0271913595,
-0.022785712,
0.0210480839,
-0.0173463207,
-0.0189379696,
0.0190341137,
-0.0030165934,
2.467e-7,
0.0096738162,
0.0029930784,
0.06858138,
-0.0353865363,
-0.0105829528,
-0.0234782062,
0.0306614991,
0.0628992915,
0.0244615451,
-0.0061951298,
0.023872491,
-0.0506090298,
0.041652143,
0.0144905541,
-0.1667300761,
-0.0244827662,
-0.0712004974,
-0.0017618818,
-0.0622847304,
0.0734156296,
0.012150283,
0.0788857341,
-0.0308923908,
-0.0081789261,
-0.0145343654,
0.0508461222,
0.0173690412,
-0.0139945811,
0.0542932488,
0.0281110145,
0.0077352109,
0.0472510569,
-0.0292722303,
0.0187145974,
-0.0296030007,
0.0625293478,
0.0122929746,
0.0596747659,
-0.0256617721,
-0.0496232994,
0.0334341116,
-0.0356229059,
-0.020771591,
-0.0085051125,
0.0594107695,
-0.0646812543,
-0.0232089236,
0.0558325909,
-0.062320888,
0.0284140725,
-0.0416670255,
-0.0152498828,
-0.0178731754,
-0.0052810651,
0.0421076231,
-0.038638372,
0.0175217856,
-0.0310056359,
0.0399365649,
0.0215249155,
-0.0274661165,
-0.0213392209,
-0.0260748137,
-0.0782760903,
0.0394542329,
-0.0118470006,
0.0186076481,
1.790163332e-34,
-0.0264121871,
0.0174119677,
-0.0401070751,
0.0271624923,
0.0065111285,
-0.0336269289,
0.0335681401,
0.0074259201,
-0.0321558006,
-0.0415919833,
-0.0337550677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05536v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05536v1 | Empowering machine learning models with contextual knowledge for enhancing the detection of eating disorders in social media posts | 2024-02-08T10:15:41 | 2024-02-08T10:15:41 | José Alberto Benítez-Andrades, María Teresa García-Ordás, Mayra Russo, Ahmad Sakor, Luis Daniel Fernandes Rotger, Maria-Esther Vidal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Social networks are vital for information sharing, especially in the health
sector for discussing diseases and treatments. These platforms, however, often
feature posts as brief texts, posing challenges for Artificial Intelligence
(AI) in understanding context. We introduce a novel hybrid approach combining
community-maintained knowledge graphs (like Wikidata) with deep learning to
enhance the categorization of social media posts. This method uses advanced
entity recognizers and linkers (like Falcon 2.0) to connect short post entities
to knowledge graphs. Knowledge graph embeddings (KGEs) and contextualized word
embeddings (like BERT) are then employed to create rich, context-based
representations of these posts.
Our focus is on the health domain, particularly in identifying posts related
to eating disorders (e.g., anorexia, bulimia) to aid healthcare providers in
early diagnosis. We tested our approach on a dataset of 2,000 tweets about
eating disorders, finding that merging word embeddings with knowledge graph
information enhances the predictive models' reliability. This methodology aims
to assist health experts in spotting patterns indicative of mental disorders,
thereby improving early detection and accurate diagnosis for personalized
medicine. | [
0.0463120453,
0.055465281,
0.0148994112,
-0.0131646916,
0.0113286013,
0.0415613316,
-0.0087046213,
0.0312683024,
0.0969714001,
-0.0308630094,
0.0165108778,
-0.0121907042,
-0.0367662981,
0.0522370115,
0.0083413618,
-0.0180555433,
0.0036323599,
0.0455119051,
0.0241183173,
0.0199997183,
0.0223645885,
0.0256532226,
0.0120126121,
0.0408816226,
-0.0042470051,
0.0035322809,
0.0722015202,
-0.0077667651,
0.0189361386,
-0.0749056041,
0.0395930558,
0.0250387304,
-0.005689906,
0.0384261794,
0.0000017549,
0.0188530535,
0.0063233674,
-0.0118478127,
-0.0408054516,
-0.0200224612,
0.0194210727,
-0.0885005668,
0.0368518829,
-0.0153494803,
-0.0370878167,
-0.0122505957,
0.0621824972,
0.0634410232,
0.0422412716,
0.043621067,
-0.0197457746,
-0.0564252622,
0.0233505275,
0.0168738458,
0.0114804944,
-0.0238182042,
0.0637081116,
-0.0497212335,
0.0266893916,
0.0006477738,
-0.0058482625,
0.0584181324,
0.0041077756,
0.0148868393,
0.0418120436,
0.0334626697,
0.0077493698,
-0.0161277298,
0.0202174298,
0.107725814,
-0.0080409981,
-0.0151029434,
0.0162010938,
-0.0072348281,
-0.0249694195,
0.0391567647,
0.004522644,
-0.0377108008,
-0.0218637567,
0.0383403711,
0.0056819469,
-0.0149333226,
0.0813023895,
0.0230506938,
0.0064852145,
0.0570051149,
-0.0153757306,
-0.0184610318,
-0.0005672506,
-0.0142841786,
-0.0329466723,
-0.0665015131,
0.0273304731,
0.0204806272,
-0.0146599738,
0.0176536981,
-0.0295763556,
-0.042123206,
0.0380646996,
-0.0426838808,
-0.0457139239,
-0.0173839722,
-0.0374328643,
0.0070204507,
-0.0150428601,
-0.0273418687,
-0.0246767737,
0.0240149386,
-0.0101375757,
0.0213895738,
-0.0681156665,
-0.0002449848,
-0.0046479693,
-0.0140443286,
-0.0142696798,
-0.044756338,
-0.0334757231,
0.0035010942,
-0.0581700802,
0.0215606876,
-0.0017460953,
0.0823611468,
0.0224965829,
0.0128069175,
0.0210189633,
0.0404457264,
0.0134991407,
0.0134108197,
-0.0276502799,
0.0519893393,
0.022224972,
-0.0436395556,
0.0619547963,
-0.0262726005,
0.0191814564,
0.0236794669,
0.0734124407,
-0.019244628,
-0.0259448383,
-0.0349014737,
-0.0473994389,
0.0067010289,
0.0210456718,
-0.0507929958,
0.0254185889,
0.0165703967,
0.0106554618,
-0.0242681559,
0.0282545537,
-0.0018890043,
-0.0750615671,
0.0785675794,
-0.0333464555,
0.0010157238,
0.0439811386,
0.0432641171,
0.0200470872,
0.0478911549,
0.0309466589,
0.0074498993,
0.0366254114,
-0.0289028864,
-0.0270731654,
-0.0091554737,
0.048793558,
-0.0029777549,
0.0284874626,
-0.0156283285,
-0.0370214172,
0.026167959,
-0.0520372987,
0.047403153,
-0.0012650928,
0.0006136961,
0.0168206785,
0.0485569648,
0.0375642665,
0.036867518,
0.0315701514,
0.0306013413,
-0.0243390147,
-0.0340513214,
-0.0265972093,
0.0028123842,
-0.0235470962,
-0.0144973239,
0.0165505335,
0.0030099999,
-0.021302959,
0.0242747273,
-0.0316562615,
-0.0257505924,
0.0382536091,
-0.0102712372,
0.0004036248,
-0.0238540284,
-0.0379665494,
0.0289490707,
0.050452441,
0.0034460411,
0.0028289636,
-0.023978116,
0.010351629,
0.0819680765,
0.009924409,
-0.028590329,
-0.0099919094,
-0.0134620452,
0.0260808151,
-0.0069220723,
0.0073406119,
-0.0200549085,
0.002388946,
-0.0072031301,
-0.0210086536,
0.0046664667,
0.0267830528,
-0.0659881979,
-0.0004742477,
0.0633417889,
-0.0228911135,
0.0071564522,
-0.0278709084,
0.0193073098,
-0.0012254532,
-0.0239908416,
0.0068474459,
0.0309148282,
-0.002469914,
0.0518907681,
0.0232839156,
0.0165340118,
-0.0154745514,
-0.0145611474,
-0.066706486,
-0.0012510105,
-0.0247322619,
-0.0371871032,
0.0216194261,
-0.0250807889,
-0.0068245609,
-0.0024748223,
-0.0541544668,
-0.0416858718,
0.0385441221,
-0.0531261377,
0.0513597131,
-0.0056926082,
-0.0614418499,
-0.0021376992,
0.0111548286,
0.0110657383,
0.0435940139,
-0.0390308499,
0.0175736956,
-0.0181407407,
-0.0614722855,
-0.0347187817,
0.011094315,
-0.0489277393,
-0.0552528426,
0.0212199762,
-0.0048050359,
0.0042445827,
0.0093737198,
-0.0218218956,
0.0224879272,
-0.1462418884,
0.019435823,
-0.0286875106,
-0.0192748271,
-0.0180596169,
-0.0012964396,
0.0238661971,
-0.0085801706,
-0.0359156765,
0.0280738045,
0.0151508413,
0.0513880104,
0.0208833274,
0.027043771,
0.0142235672,
-0.0332381763,
-0.0351708643,
-0.0511767715,
0.0314615853,
0.0440680794,
-0.0463129021,
0.0074612494,
-0.0275280531,
-0.049801711,
-0.0166999754,
0.0220195446,
-0.0222367328,
-0.0120680919,
0.0065923398,
-0.022023309,
0.0292608961,
-0.0157225002,
0.0623466484,
0.0041828486,
0.0237707123,
-0.0125014735,
0.013641201,
-0.0350369886,
0.0084688747,
-0.0587696247,
-0.037277814,
0.0131547023,
0.0414221473,
0.0265073981,
-0.01402013,
-0.0573401116,
-0.0003446398,
0.0162063465,
0.0386743359,
-0.0369678698,
-0.0215395354,
0.0323166177,
-0.0219945852,
-0.0382237472,
-0.0056892456,
0.0736692324,
0.0234227553,
0.0268097222,
0.0154635543,
-0.0400397852,
-0.024083009,
-0.0302597601,
0.0375966541,
0.0617789216,
-0.0170076415,
0.0099607455,
0.0542013608,
0.0129981441,
-0.030356504,
-0.0355345048,
0.0292449445,
-0.0110933529,
0.0078981183,
0.0243308898,
-0.0283717681,
-0.0330656134,
-0.0068528992,
-0.0714684501,
-0.019719867,
-0.0035130747,
-0.0328299478,
-0.0266379304,
0.017730521,
-0.0183726326,
0.0375075787,
0.0330796242,
-0.0236186683,
0.0146273291,
0.0214363057,
0.0588870868,
-0.0316110402,
0.0101902317,
-0.0139330365,
0.0124535933,
0.039382223,
-0.0101979189,
0.0212591924,
-0.0292156618,
0.0030496707,
-0.0158234034,
-0.0347442552,
0.0001598399,
-0.0244216397,
0.0122339884,
-0.0402027108,
0.001109576,
0.0861961767,
0.0096952319,
-0.0480445623,
0.0271291975,
0.0248176698,
-0.0325204544,
-0.0200646315,
-0.0131616192,
-0.0896849483,
-0.0437662341,
-0.0500125587,
0.0027358588,
-0.0293826964,
-0.0597218461,
0.021381855,
-0.0316166393,
-0.0093565984,
-0.018890176,
-0.0083177425,
-0.0488000624,
-0.0574070923,
0.0281186402,
-0.0137688629,
-0.0040897559,
-0.0642026439,
0.0021478627,
0.0028105411,
-0.0088134808,
-0.0774081275,
-0.0732055455,
0.0381356962,
-0.0419874713,
0.0563663766,
-0.0123823071,
0.0687403306,
0.0131642008,
-0.0440529548,
-0.0117157996,
0.0404480547,
-0.0185988918,
-0.0049837055,
0.0552269109,
-0.0311763622,
-0.0004036012,
-0.0303714648,
0.0268748626,
-0.0729974657,
-0.0434493646,
-0.0418930724,
0.113632001,
-0.013695078,
-0.0557037294,
-0.0422431417,
-0.0261594355,
0.049667649,
0.0572613589,
0.018832203,
-0.0173385609,
-0.0149273723,
-0.0157421678,
0.0014437081,
-0.0233110934,
0.0006570006,
0.0393678509,
-0.0275497716,
-0.0005659952,
-0.0556057245,
-0.0025026207,
0.0381211899,
-0.0546806343,
0.0055172537,
-0.0215035528,
0.0013357198,
-0.0266072508,
-0.0915376171,
0.0418133512,
0.0161825214,
0.0251336284,
-0.0177871753,
-0.0082783736,
0.0525819287,
0.0083474172,
-0.0122239431,
0.0211081319,
-0.0576892495,
-0.0317747593,
0.0033646533,
-0.0089207664,
0.0053189583,
0.005348627,
-0.02052176,
-0.0541058742,
0.0556596629,
0.0723191276,
-0.052727934,
-0.0335063934,
-0.0197187308,
-0.0220610294,
0.0194185209,
0.0547282919,
-0.0246580094,
-0.001960682,
-0.0022775221,
-0.0305782892,
-0.0604249202,
-0.0463838726,
-0.0546364859,
-0.0071935467,
-0.0004756837,
-0.0090912469,
-0.0508812144,
-0.0387565233,
-0.0572585613,
0.0455254577,
0.0266684182,
-0.0127710514,
-0.0199926496,
0.0522044972,
-0.0127470959,
-0.0333224237,
-0.0056737335,
0.0087211849,
-0.0061814697,
-0.0713460892,
0.0383288376,
0.0428951532,
0.0177776888,
0.0195183475,
0.0011781617,
-0.0129047791,
0.0225309543,
-0.0077024894,
-0.0135804145,
-0.0316279456,
0.0129947858,
0.0000908392,
0.0075311055,
0.0046344455,
0.0256185699,
-0.0594065934,
-0.0319924578,
-0.0249217339,
-0.0561771728,
0.0413494371,
-0.0525763296,
0.0393979885,
-0.0005584434,
-0.0316225253,
-0.0066588852,
0.0254687853,
-0.0687052011,
-0.030980818,
0.0527907684,
0.0122384923,
-0.0076984228,
0.0385366082,
0.0396263525,
0.02141634,
0.0511747003,
0.0424799062,
-0.0408478603,
-0.0256294683,
-0.000101023,
0.0323795229,
0.0649543479,
-0.0412463285,
0.0278700124,
-0.0194358788,
-0.0851901099,
0.0673229396,
-0.0476446524,
-0.0513789356,
0.0312620178,
0.043141555,
0.0138269365,
0.0485895947,
-0.0131891444,
-0.0168813691,
0.0165489931,
-0.0235582758,
-0.0354143307,
-0.0258136354,
-5.698946488e-33,
0.0399510786,
-0.0453224778,
-0.0063495818,
-0.0099932188,
-0.006423743,
0.0114665823,
-0.0161513295,
-0.0149744265,
0.0190484244,
0.0357386991,
0.0235077888,
0.0460701063,
-0.0247562397,
0.0347814448,
-0.011074218,
-0.0413448885,
0.0291393865,
0.0129363053,
0.0122951604,
0.0604173094,
0.0204273127,
0.0716542527,
0.0370021388,
-0.0750726163,
0.0423671938,
0.031292472,
0.0436403118,
0.0180977006,
0.0462262221,
0.0352195613,
-0.0629699975,
0.0884403959,
0.0485656485,
0.0219836086,
0.0131427068,
0.060009256,
-0.0641239658,
-0.035658583,
-0.0273149181,
-0.0521689616,
-0.0448154099,
-0.0371257551,
0.0687885135,
0.0105111739,
0.0469042473,
-0.021186037,
0.0691891164,
0.0074781631,
0.0100076767,
0.0131054027,
0.0113710519,
0.0204984285,
-0.0194197092,
0.0352542661,
0.0175771564,
-0.0332079642,
0.0166871976,
0.0081090359,
-0.0766033754,
-0.0149036963,
0.0035495188,
-0.0363523401,
0.0007533384,
-0.0413798988,
-0.0173200238,
0.057967592,
-0.009264743,
-0.0261467323,
-0.0365579054,
0.0505062304,
-0.0277182851,
0.086837858,
0.0381466113,
0.007928079,
0.0155880125,
-0.0469137169,
-0.0594381616,
0.0195616707,
-0.0484445244,
0.0123059629,
-0.0088536376,
-0.0129728289,
-0.0129706291,
-0.0101574054,
-0.0184874441,
-0.0256598853,
-0.0270966422,
-0.0082343686,
-0.0355385207,
0.0047430368,
-0.0091638975,
0.069156073,
-0.0305781327,
-0.0417631343,
-0.0297451448,
0.0534967259,
0.0578254797,
0.0054898979,
0.0154215936,
0.0074963858,
-0.0440587364,
0.0277460366,
0.0117751183,
0.0103475619,
0.0299665686,
0.0015411925,
0.0484245978,
-0.0073200692,
0.0009164987,
-0.0213137344,
0.0140117239,
-0.0236643702,
-0.0239922069,
0.0410154276,
0.0053618569,
0.0594495796,
0.0072651869,
0.0355535783,
0.0384940542,
0.043495819,
-0.0419136137,
-0.0073379665,
-0.0069342125,
-0.0281495769,
-0.0124344472,
-0.0658466369,
-0.0176378377,
0.0693070367,
0.0320838019,
-0.1105145589,
0.0212450214,
-0.0254557058,
2.568e-7,
0.0918856934,
0.0369818658,
0.009530616,
-0.0003724547,
0.0385329537,
0.0102939624,
0.0632757843,
0.0453519188,
-0.0162666123,
-0.0341691449,
-0.0013480443,
0.0627742931,
-0.029822804,
0.0646659806,
0.0214174911,
-0.0018661184,
-0.0519611873,
0.0048001939,
-0.0486319885,
-0.0283570252,
0.0171334818,
0.0472801365,
0.0368289649,
-0.0452938341,
0.0333017446,
-0.0448593646,
0.0470484309,
-0.0134140039,
0.0487372242,
0.0232024193,
0.0398792513,
0.0265330952,
0.0222768821,
0.001260633,
-0.0390436165,
-0.0119065531,
0.0060589663,
0.0355798453,
-0.04342952,
-0.0179448929,
-0.0134239374,
-0.0175665971,
0.0054779388,
-0.0292665474,
0.079364568,
-0.0972080082,
-0.0079910904,
0.0101083964,
0.0292205289,
-0.0400202945,
0.0222225916,
-0.0323924758,
0.0032546106,
0.0504345596,
0.0209272616,
0.0011554942,
0.0578553863,
-0.1274009794,
-0.004284563,
0.0280066207,
-0.0386737101,
0.0224517211,
0.0014293391,
-0.043579977,
0.0194929074,
-0.051539924,
0.0392633155,
1.94762057e-34,
-0.0004980987,
0.0211601593,
-0.0007669553,
0.0030032664,
-0.0077072703,
0.0076137106,
-0.0228126012,
-0.0219710208,
0.0110412622,
-0.1072352007,
0.0090758521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05515v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05515v2 | NoisyICL: A Little Noise in Model Parameters Calibrates In-context Learning | 2024-02-08T09:48:02 | 2024-02-15T15:25:47 | Yufeng Zhao, Yoshihiro Sakai, Naoya Inoue | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-Context Learning (ICL) is suffering from unsatisfactory performance and
under-calibration due to high prior bias and unfaithful confidence. Some
previous works fine-tuned language models for better ICL performance with
enormous datasets and computing costs. In this paper, we propose NoisyICL,
simply perturbing the model parameters by random noises to strive for better
performance and calibration. Our experiments on two models and 12 downstream
datasets show that NoisyICL can help ICL produce more accurate predictions. Our
further analysis indicates that NoisyICL enables the model to provide more fair
predictions, and also with more faithful confidence. Therefore, we believe that
NoisyICL is an effective calibration of ICL. Our experimental code is uploaded
to Github. | [
-0.0121901715,
0.0855311006,
0.0152021404,
0.0710248873,
-0.008433817,
0.0259622037,
0.0052733105,
-0.0174214691,
-0.0471794046,
-0.0412706695,
-0.0676701441,
-0.0413044728,
0.0473629944,
-0.0103109563,
0.0261701103,
-0.0414735377,
0.0246847905,
-0.0400031358,
0.0226987768,
-0.0103950072,
0.0016604679,
-0.0100924671,
0.010083626,
0.0257469285,
-0.0117111718,
-0.02642278,
0.0112981657,
0.0484668799,
0.0045348327,
-0.0154457511,
0.0387727208,
0.0584769882,
0.0124143697,
0.0587837845,
0.0000019377,
-0.051940538,
-0.0034034587,
0.0150406342,
-0.0230575651,
0.0059687318,
0.0493501648,
-0.012064009,
-0.0169219617,
0.0178114101,
-0.033444602,
0.0066367006,
0.0499670245,
0.0176477525,
0.0121439993,
0.091064766,
-0.0011091387,
-0.0034072546,
-0.0072703506,
-0.0352099948,
0.0166227873,
-0.0623653345,
0.025595719,
-0.0223069806,
-0.0492836945,
-0.002670052,
-0.0148527436,
0.0254960675,
0.0160466973,
0.0002543243,
0.0076952945,
0.0261485968,
-0.0236807559,
-0.0113889938,
-0.0126018375,
0.0731055513,
-0.0430351309,
-0.0428080112,
-0.0268795807,
-0.0333330333,
0.011097407,
-0.0525605604,
-0.0384506956,
0.027492404,
-0.0010366404,
0.0237522945,
0.0015810585,
0.0233803242,
0.073281765,
-0.0049743811,
0.021553129,
0.0376838483,
0.0038144083,
-0.036332339,
-0.0335866772,
0.0168453213,
-0.020349279,
-0.0375701003,
-0.0297443699,
0.009827164,
-0.0746579245,
0.0356758721,
-0.0734092891,
-0.0098886741,
0.0067352452,
-0.0636743382,
0.009076206,
0.0312381163,
-0.0139439786,
0.0458345674,
0.0140568828,
-0.0062446208,
0.0102910595,
0.0280333031,
-0.0372996554,
-0.0206779856,
0.0048681106,
0.0435585678,
-0.0319119059,
-0.0115976352,
-0.051969938,
-0.0232267287,
-0.0534098558,
0.0309240595,
-0.0228339247,
0.0208184309,
0.0016857276,
-0.0069952672,
-0.0620887578,
-0.0160576869,
0.0248956326,
0.0045267148,
-0.0033183808,
0.0212414134,
0.0073240758,
-0.0419335589,
-0.0141944597,
0.0195694584,
0.0121654905,
-0.0122266011,
0.0160949286,
0.0700896382,
0.0225210246,
-0.0331923626,
-0.0247112047,
-0.0131342718,
-0.0029488006,
-0.0608958304,
-0.0636235252,
-0.0729678422,
-0.0149073023,
0.023922395,
0.007695213,
-0.0695168599,
-0.0076200697,
0.0157152321,
-0.0334654562,
0.0782073215,
-0.023774365,
-0.0304962527,
-0.0041913339,
-0.0012984166,
0.0088464841,
0.0868547335,
0.0199886244,
-0.0364325829,
0.0568500087,
0.0261755046,
-0.0103606647,
0.0204038695,
0.062494047,
0.0170274135,
-0.0381738804,
0.0102778161,
0.0361342542,
0.0160333645,
0.0245843865,
0.0468382947,
-0.0213863607,
0.0003009728,
0.0789936483,
-0.0023225553,
0.0205499157,
-0.0010390942,
-0.0181579124,
-0.003377463,
-0.0060873348,
-0.0307968166,
-0.0947889015,
-0.0146888783,
-0.0564927571,
0.0165914409,
0.0457546711,
0.0040027867,
-0.0359256938,
-0.0464247167,
-0.0166045204,
-0.0281322841,
0.0009408903,
0.0301344916,
0.046153672,
0.0070714615,
-0.0317144617,
0.0122929737,
0.0707660541,
-0.014605985,
-0.008226336,
-0.0182083882,
0.0329973511,
0.0419113822,
0.0136012351,
-0.0185809247,
-0.0014908483,
-0.0465575308,
0.0307347216,
0.0359355211,
0.0155518046,
-0.0183888562,
0.052035898,
-0.0406115651,
-0.0481752343,
0.0127042104,
0.0309534036,
0.0034283784,
0.0255861413,
0.0066684606,
0.0156158023,
-0.0336265936,
-0.0181661416,
0.0292791687,
-0.0017633935,
-0.0311292782,
0.0106185684,
-0.0045410637,
0.0372936763,
-0.0136768296,
-0.010550811,
-0.0080336165,
0.0098303361,
0.0041665253,
0.031923648,
0.0157228466,
-0.0772560313,
-0.0503424294,
0.0452810936,
0.0082171615,
-0.0128930975,
-0.0304118413,
-0.0431131795,
-0.0183756519,
0.0137276929,
-0.0203360599,
0.0517734885,
-0.0245293919,
0.0182312932,
-0.0366904214,
0.0233686268,
-0.0596249215,
0.0543922931,
-0.0102058956,
0.0037063668,
0.0316042751,
0.0573610291,
-0.0028315957,
-0.013201193,
-0.0276955515,
-0.0404142104,
-0.0209386181,
0.033429455,
0.0132321501,
0.0294325594,
-0.0152057391,
0.0131190615,
-0.0844693407,
-0.0267927572,
-0.0741220266,
-0.023267556,
0.0507112332,
0.0446808003,
-0.0044074436,
-0.0395101085,
-0.0210054144,
0.0016976156,
-0.0045367051,
0.0144541748,
0.0148866279,
0.0064733364,
-0.0171009209,
-0.0333651081,
-0.0190263744,
0.0006309962,
0.0551293679,
0.0157039091,
-0.0139021063,
-0.104605332,
0.0352573618,
0.0108263632,
0.055580318,
-0.0232303515,
0.024521457,
-0.006728882,
-0.0022810646,
0.0049670716,
0.0770885646,
-0.0195826013,
0.0028925156,
0.0313532874,
0.0223038457,
-0.058053948,
0.0099285943,
0.0010395132,
-0.0132289967,
-0.0520683005,
0.0121370237,
-0.0161828864,
0.0357470028,
-0.0015700173,
-0.0026615309,
-0.0235130191,
0.0481205173,
-0.0092863236,
-0.0247945935,
-0.0627631173,
-0.0102669364,
-0.0108611034,
0.0680552721,
-0.0092726657,
-0.0717209876,
0.0522776134,
-0.0281343721,
-0.0028442193,
-0.0532124229,
-0.0206572581,
-0.0085607674,
0.0076703602,
-0.0125037385,
0.0280643962,
0.0021747418,
-0.0140527012,
-0.0681264251,
-0.0408909172,
0.0358646102,
-0.006084573,
0.0501215532,
-0.0286022797,
0.0328258649,
0.0019278033,
-0.035018485,
-0.0664966926,
-0.0546516068,
-0.0199343693,
-0.00193879,
-0.0055164481,
-0.0290888455,
-0.0012384732,
0.0073082712,
-0.016455695,
0.052542951,
-0.0071414835,
-0.0205269828,
-0.0084891999,
0.0197186526,
0.0474044159,
-0.0131966295,
0.0405608453,
-0.0199143421,
-0.0088647623,
0.0328206196,
0.043887455,
0.0195163153,
-0.0484912023,
0.0181666706,
0.0222967602,
0.0146590602,
-0.0025674817,
0.0646264702,
0.0631587729,
-0.0427046046,
-0.0590441488,
0.132938832,
-0.0036285038,
-0.0977694765,
0.0003122227,
-0.0019846878,
0.0306357741,
0.016553117,
0.0158541463,
-0.0411891043,
-0.0448753051,
0.0146194259,
0.0337832794,
0.0214968063,
-0.0019128213,
0.0115155242,
-0.0940159783,
0.0217350256,
0.0160418898,
-0.0597799905,
-0.0899209157,
-0.0474159122,
0.0152858933,
-0.0319312066,
0.076445438,
0.0251834188,
0.0045104534,
-0.0091818571,
0.0307760146,
0.001539496,
-0.101898022,
0.0212163087,
-0.0509033278,
0.0596349053,
0.0773318559,
-0.0106219556,
0.0145206591,
-0.0064616562,
0.0688470379,
-0.0223194808,
-0.0212522801,
-0.0200921074,
0.041318424,
0.0084090168,
-0.0191780683,
0.0103501128,
0.0326330736,
-0.052861739,
0.0085223736,
-0.0162551589,
0.025210226,
0.0025931259,
0.0324290581,
0.0070797089,
-0.0120965187,
0.0600322187,
0.0622002371,
0.0036866462,
-0.0357071124,
-0.019359909,
-0.0493827499,
-0.0173812769,
-0.0038553954,
0.0349348821,
0.0190242026,
-0.0078172628,
-0.0486288555,
-0.0441252328,
-0.0458131842,
-0.0049663861,
0.0559675954,
0.0057519446,
0.0166331325,
0.0072271712,
0.0100108059,
-0.04998466,
0.0208089296,
-0.0339467004,
0.0495581143,
-0.0232571643,
0.0050174212,
0.0195507687,
-0.0066235242,
-0.0207967125,
0.0442866422,
-0.1227663308,
-0.0831336603,
0.0157823004,
0.0296754893,
0.0183445271,
0.1334560663,
-0.0420699976,
-0.0375548378,
0.070328027,
0.0213970058,
-0.0140005164,
0.0261327885,
0.0391829275,
-0.0081351809,
-0.0007039406,
0.0493626557,
-0.052206967,
-0.0186461881,
0.0580736771,
0.0100973127,
-0.0796563476,
-0.0198227223,
0.0206440929,
-0.0444494486,
0.0672597513,
-0.0255521219,
-0.0447554849,
-0.0031405969,
0.030937722,
-0.0073483535,
-0.035337653,
-0.0299517512,
-0.0290460866,
0.0382397287,
0.0006235733,
-0.0274804309,
0.0029953767,
0.0161571354,
0.0078437189,
-0.021344211,
-0.0055068359,
0.0249498058,
0.0471984781,
0.0482642204,
0.0164927766,
-0.0106878551,
0.0317377895,
0.0101916892,
0.0569060817,
-0.0077468525,
0.0058650896,
0.0210068151,
-0.0008808128,
-0.039999295,
0.0035982558,
-0.0664758235,
0.0014754187,
-0.0799477324,
0.0383775868,
0.0482555516,
-0.0127820633,
0.0476386547,
-0.0238123089,
0.0032837428,
-0.0363897607,
0.0287345368,
0.0037314624,
-0.0208776705,
0.0286168531,
-0.0071847215,
-0.007271118,
0.0247994252,
0.0793559402,
-0.0050849635,
0.0336729214,
0.0051164851,
0.0094608348,
-0.0398344584,
0.0127713811,
0.0246467385,
0.0556982905,
-0.0358700454,
0.0201874655,
0.0099163149,
-0.0708419681,
-0.0097090611,
0.0155822709,
0.0229430124,
0.0096802553,
0.0309173036,
0.068897523,
-0.0189671982,
0.0077670491,
-0.0255125724,
-0.0177258812,
0.0241395906,
-0.0278011542,
-0.0516723767,
-6.433501888e-33,
-0.0376172997,
-0.0020145243,
-0.0154311592,
-0.0016164391,
0.0301578473,
-0.0048300652,
-0.0297705587,
0.0335126482,
-0.0241521876,
0.0021542539,
-0.0119378166,
0.0312381536,
0.029055804,
0.0455962308,
0.0057599265,
-0.0529716164,
0.0362427607,
-0.0183964185,
-0.0175654553,
0.0193504691,
0.009570051,
0.0367396139,
0.06486056,
-0.0966195613,
0.0266533718,
-0.0132826129,
-0.0291740913,
0.0255080536,
0.0089965602,
0.0362099446,
0.004482137,
0.053306751,
-0.0005940961,
0.0319378786,
-0.045448795,
-0.0101398071,
-0.0777129158,
-0.0062482995,
0.0008947543,
0.0686418712,
-0.0082830917,
-0.0016471668,
0.0756342262,
-0.0144165251,
-0.0369428806,
-0.0233514085,
0.0358321406,
-0.0162463523,
-0.0477494746,
-0.0106365271,
-0.0523805395,
0.0285163466,
-0.0026026536,
-0.0130507853,
-0.0126268053,
-0.0043422137,
0.0035521195,
0.0180405099,
-0.0810803995,
-0.0084085306,
-0.0212930478,
0.0385032818,
0.051955495,
0.0474898219,
0.0064460333,
0.0196591299,
0.0325158462,
0.0292618014,
0.0433647223,
-0.0384431593,
0.0489912033,
0.0148203392,
0.018222902,
0.0840842575,
0.0446939468,
0.0272185616,
-0.0805053413,
0.0235459469,
0.0201255623,
0.0073339427,
0.0400820896,
0.0202203225,
-0.0754811838,
-0.0384214111,
-0.026865555,
-0.0648409352,
-0.0350265764,
-0.0002113696,
0.0237231106,
0.0317249782,
-0.017723687,
-0.0016082159,
0.0227216687,
-0.0611160547,
-0.033321891,
0.0365586132,
0.019073043,
-0.0115119116,
-0.0031764191,
0.0115096774,
-0.0308367107,
-0.024153702,
-0.0270342659,
0.0445479341,
0.0007799422,
-0.0115612242,
0.0695507526,
0.0146284858,
-0.0645558015,
0.0080892025,
-0.0307864156,
0.0331401676,
0.0223279409,
0.0404482968,
0.0444241464,
-0.0335602425,
-0.0175427664,
0.0187487733,
0.0078829946,
-0.0086760977,
-0.0013190985,
-0.0380577631,
-0.0258185416,
-0.0011973566,
-0.0369342193,
-0.0363099389,
-0.0304959305,
-0.0151232434,
0.058297269,
-0.0472935811,
-0.0001011601,
-0.0049686069,
2.542e-7,
0.0298882183,
0.0494490601,
0.0165934172,
0.018044332,
0.0408649333,
0.0430230498,
-0.0339815021,
0.0141349426,
0.0273079555,
0.0008101015,
0.0069200895,
-0.0077981795,
0.0471248552,
0.0190247539,
-0.0555214956,
-0.021416625,
-0.0660680905,
0.0407965779,
0.012296834,
0.0016727152,
-0.0278081857,
0.1277918369,
0.0271042176,
-0.0370515436,
0.0374924913,
-0.0611124896,
0.0541055873,
-0.0559846833,
0.01285611,
0.0177724976,
-0.0297772884,
0.0321964696,
0.0241580866,
0.0007568648,
-0.009121811,
0.0066220495,
-0.0273155272,
0.035138648,
-0.0211806241,
-0.0150906267,
-0.0200898983,
0.0302153975,
0.0220240913,
-0.0737415403,
0.0427455865,
-0.0321877003,
0.0107058221,
-0.0760006532,
0.0069472878,
-0.0191397741,
0.0426707007,
0.017231049,
-0.0236689653,
0.0027755187,
0.0319683291,
0.0049691489,
-0.0343842171,
-0.0679743066,
-0.0800371841,
0.0103028147,
-0.0265601911,
-0.0562681481,
0.0138103766,
0.0000597777,
0.0518786423,
-0.0316735432,
0.0265778117,
2.330694894e-34,
0.0504441448,
-0.0040880735,
0.0266782586,
0.0388475247,
-0.0148776034,
0.0030855807,
0.0036261871,
-0.0088322219,
0.0554582998,
-0.0382733569,
-0.0039755502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05512v1 | GPTs Are Multilingual Annotators for Sequence Generation Tasks | 2024-02-08T09:44:02 | 2024-02-08T09:44:02 | Juhwan Choi, Eunju Lee, Kyohoon Jin, YoungBin Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Data annotation is an essential step for constructing new datasets. However,
the conventional approach of data annotation through crowdsourcing is both
time-consuming and expensive. In addition, the complexity of this process
increases when dealing with low-resource languages owing to the difference in
the language pool of crowdworkers. To address these issues, this study proposes
an autonomous annotation method by utilizing large language models, which have
been recently demonstrated to exhibit remarkable performance. Through our
experiments, we demonstrate that the proposed method is not just cost-efficient
but also applicable for low-resource language annotation. Additionally, we
constructed an image captioning dataset using our approach and are committed to
open this dataset for future study. We have opened our source code for further
study and reproducibility. | [
0.0438105464,
0.0861220732,
0.0154480226,
0.0395440236,
-0.0167546254,
0.0270059127,
0.0193022229,
-0.0239663646,
0.0105624693,
-0.0625631213,
-0.023618931,
-0.0422261879,
0.0142778521,
-0.0079083117,
0.0448284298,
-0.0733294562,
0.0075294925,
-0.0534299389,
0.0132416952,
-0.0049036536,
0.0261491686,
0.0107249236,
0.0155909937,
0.0509617142,
-0.0211889427,
0.0343554281,
0.0005704064,
-0.0137213143,
0.0396642983,
-0.0406421833,
-0.0218454003,
0.1064161509,
0.0214713551,
0.0845661759,
0.0000015808,
-0.0184501242,
-0.0216991901,
0.0275403094,
0.0052656308,
0.0232869294,
-0.0046253297,
-0.0079077622,
-0.0313766263,
0.0088079656,
-0.0384229906,
-0.0300385877,
0.0850587115,
-0.0126852253,
0.0969602615,
0.0609348081,
-0.0045221713,
-0.0272596255,
0.000504669,
-0.034818586,
0.0287892893,
-0.0171504337,
0.0108771352,
0.0268703718,
0.0118678454,
0.0089235846,
0.0159380957,
0.0345824026,
0.0025097979,
-0.0258251168,
-0.0206533168,
0.0226272196,
-0.0582902059,
-0.050206013,
-0.0258490983,
0.0811380669,
-0.0033326489,
-0.0045007938,
0.0154924933,
0.004107587,
-0.0054147383,
-0.0159662254,
-0.0551012866,
0.0610413849,
0.0134430686,
0.0300577153,
0.000775599,
0.0244880412,
0.0196952969,
-0.0008025422,
0.0177330226,
0.0288715474,
0.0196456052,
0.0005730867,
-0.0524054803,
0.0447599478,
-0.06136401,
-0.0737237036,
0.0345868878,
-0.0121383965,
0.0102336043,
0.0132302493,
-0.0565337799,
-0.0811351314,
0.0285962299,
-0.0217910912,
0.0173493419,
-0.0019854999,
0.0000454702,
0.0610462539,
-0.0190564599,
0.0224343892,
0.0029445628,
-0.0123229371,
-0.021668734,
-0.0198787879,
-0.0502843969,
0.0146029554,
-0.0412996151,
0.0060828608,
-0.0273495708,
-0.0009917079,
-0.0432812534,
0.0094815735,
-0.0004055975,
0.0095610162,
0.0177063458,
-0.0199350789,
-0.020620266,
-0.0077290563,
0.0111314841,
0.0104154237,
-0.0189220998,
-0.0212516859,
0.0154278083,
-0.0770771801,
-0.0035871377,
0.0420807227,
0.0495648719,
-0.0132861212,
-0.0090314355,
0.0563103668,
0.0089168744,
-0.033531066,
-0.0415772907,
-0.0345557705,
-0.0132757183,
-0.0353864208,
-0.0308955852,
-0.083122775,
0.0316248536,
-0.0077644857,
0.0006722434,
-0.0272576697,
0.038439814,
0.0243964903,
-0.0117060449,
0.0995121971,
-0.0541761294,
-0.0148627609,
0.0264204517,
-0.0000416075,
0.0092515377,
0.0546295419,
0.0742390454,
0.0002326344,
0.0507927574,
-0.008493592,
0.0319662765,
0.0764226168,
-0.0127850752,
-0.0024146996,
0.0254500769,
-0.0116679817,
0.0203487966,
0.0490196049,
0.0318854153,
0.0737657174,
-0.0059268377,
0.0227094833,
0.0530837141,
0.0528506674,
-0.0572900735,
0.0227169171,
0.0432629474,
0.0301066395,
-0.0143943904,
-0.0173150096,
0.0024904727,
0.0428343713,
-0.0004813997,
0.0316430554,
0.0580186695,
0.0172450896,
-0.0161591135,
-0.0217761584,
-0.0366018079,
-0.0176779069,
0.0052443156,
-0.013119705,
0.0469056219,
0.016425496,
-0.0507528596,
0.0177314337,
0.0068922788,
-0.0966995209,
0.0232366025,
-0.0152394483,
0.017641319,
0.0588601828,
0.0495480113,
0.0076692547,
-0.0292143933,
-0.0246216096,
0.011892735,
0.0644675344,
0.0024122968,
-0.011020517,
-0.0605609007,
-0.0788974464,
-0.0567091517,
0.0421601422,
-0.0100215925,
0.0310776308,
0.0407086983,
-0.0091849156,
0.0457099117,
-0.0140004,
-0.0755066648,
0.0238679945,
-0.0122145228,
-0.0214947984,
-0.0159374475,
-0.0019973631,
0.0389754176,
0.0410461724,
-0.023526473,
0.0329943337,
0.0070711905,
-0.036366757,
-0.0086895954,
0.0303887427,
-0.0121618025,
-0.0338075459,
0.0404517166,
-0.0700149536,
-0.0349988975,
0.0142727289,
-0.0118716732,
-0.0537098721,
-0.0070588151,
-0.0492462814,
-0.000626271,
-0.0670882091,
-0.0102047892,
0.0281712562,
0.0166521221,
-0.0020333086,
0.0211807955,
0.0014220872,
0.004436377,
0.018693205,
-0.0029118909,
0.0210074205,
-0.066512607,
-0.0545807369,
0.002934834,
0.0463435538,
0.019351894,
0.0318988785,
0.0331357233,
-0.0315704942,
0.0044602412,
-0.1022155732,
0.0007394482,
-0.0058305948,
0.0472750552,
-0.0035795094,
0.0085404972,
0.0009647867,
-0.0166590959,
-0.0403547138,
0.0081429472,
0.0079677375,
0.026939081,
0.0452388562,
0.0115565239,
-0.0147697879,
-0.0370265767,
-0.0010860786,
0.0244882274,
0.0225054957,
0.0591300093,
-0.0520014018,
-0.0387409665,
-0.0232383031,
-0.0184697621,
0.0166730825,
0.0320089422,
-0.0469304621,
0.0050057997,
-0.0000893869,
0.0292217396,
-0.0133541608,
0.0065859798,
0.0011061917,
0.0184730031,
-0.0015227753,
-0.0086130183,
-0.017976474,
-0.0052905702,
-0.0383811183,
0.0200818311,
-0.048305247,
0.0050037038,
0.083899267,
-0.0240708329,
-0.0055268495,
-0.0812939927,
-0.0006934908,
-0.0300795436,
0.0029437758,
-0.0428137034,
0.0059233839,
-0.042649284,
0.0367427953,
-0.0158948544,
-0.0646003559,
0.0546056293,
-0.0588507988,
-0.0380591974,
-0.006857276,
0.0197933875,
-0.0322522707,
0.0642450526,
0.0254276358,
0.0256720036,
0.0127181569,
0.0077857394,
-0.004540008,
0.0529881604,
0.030218415,
-0.0478430316,
0.006581408,
-0.0783179998,
0.0144098876,
-0.0401181988,
-0.010723969,
-0.0130657367,
-0.0090593249,
-0.0464348011,
-0.0028721257,
0.0421340354,
-0.0468840338,
-0.0075095841,
0.0444357581,
0.0158271007,
0.0544273891,
0.0120472843,
0.0093990956,
-0.0102656269,
0.0501014516,
0.0418524072,
-0.0024269824,
-0.0319090076,
-0.0057898909,
-0.0225856435,
0.0144638531,
0.0229199175,
0.0221619252,
-0.0108686835,
-0.0033732555,
0.0259211436,
-0.0000736243,
-0.0261098649,
-0.002846244,
0.0390970409,
-0.0320422724,
0.0124486536,
0.1093511507,
0.0206609834,
-0.0553565845,
-0.0260834135,
0.0217621438,
0.0486087203,
0.0236292798,
-0.0047582006,
-0.1105646417,
-0.038639009,
-0.0007149663,
0.0446439944,
-0.0169030819,
-0.0249333847,
-0.0241430532,
-0.126094237,
0.0693087876,
0.0228938293,
-0.0740232691,
-0.0039121397,
-0.0432523228,
-0.0125194117,
-0.0341703445,
-0.0376994871,
-0.0106939832,
0.0240457915,
0.045007132,
0.0294897649,
-0.0307912864,
-0.0665454194,
-0.0227474794,
-0.0515742227,
0.0576539449,
0.0876332819,
0.0058985921,
-0.0042292424,
-0.049879387,
-0.0101956204,
0.0130649973,
-0.0390607938,
0.0028480692,
0.0305520389,
0.0011627791,
-0.0518814214,
0.0029347991,
0.0500930883,
-0.0588628277,
0.0078218291,
0.012912333,
0.0761573091,
0.0404540747,
0.0201477949,
0.0072811227,
-0.0106603969,
0.0234790295,
0.0906762034,
0.036620263,
-0.0598544292,
-0.020860469,
-0.0378400572,
0.0021909724,
-0.1002145633,
-0.0444119759,
0.005800311,
-0.0061025252,
-0.0701359436,
-0.0983415842,
-0.0446495637,
0.0629265755,
0.0144305304,
0.0208196081,
0.015788734,
-0.0010642486,
0.0225166921,
-0.0445393734,
0.0420846604,
-0.0270544477,
-0.0086982232,
-0.0862373114,
-0.0628186762,
0.0056970553,
-0.0043210657,
-0.0307951402,
0.0929916427,
-0.1004556417,
-0.043424122,
-0.0203390121,
0.0740231723,
0.0136433179,
0.0120285107,
0.0192073155,
-0.0233247057,
-0.0284922458,
0.0645154789,
0.0348811671,
-0.0090167494,
0.0089144111,
0.0327055342,
-0.038842801,
0.0318008251,
-0.0204282086,
-0.0028844974,
-0.0223465152,
0.0588530563,
-0.0192454215,
-0.0373904034,
0.0201387554,
0.039681714,
0.0358546786,
-0.0900808573,
-0.0021440759,
-0.0379745923,
-0.0379545726,
-0.0064294031,
-0.036224626,
-0.0766445845,
0.012139054,
0.0233303271,
-0.0229026396,
0.0005057193,
0.000283394,
-0.0000411321,
-0.0131208701,
-0.0160330851,
0.0336439312,
0.0406996943,
0.0032721078,
0.0013658368,
-0.0092003057,
-0.0019070283,
-0.0038773424,
-0.0293690506,
-0.006192077,
-0.0225563403,
0.004983895,
-0.0093123764,
-0.0117910421,
0.0457560197,
0.040366929,
0.0140009671,
-0.0131552005,
-0.0494880788,
0.0520627089,
0.0809095949,
0.0060078306,
0.0648826882,
-0.0296176746,
-0.0202932451,
-0.0140938722,
0.045738209,
-0.0155491624,
-0.0332548842,
0.0166096855,
0.0009171618,
-0.0204463266,
0.0049169357,
0.0993959829,
0.0109193865,
0.032395903,
-0.0078492705,
-0.0284104161,
-0.0413622484,
-0.003639166,
-0.0415619463,
-0.0294461194,
-0.0189983603,
0.0305911005,
-0.0190930031,
-0.0443207659,
-0.0144807678,
0.02687102,
-0.0024220329,
0.0572763421,
0.074776426,
0.0233662445,
-0.0559354275,
0.0091600167,
-0.043639306,
0.0144615313,
-0.0291979387,
-0.0260381941,
-0.0043515782,
-5.360882027e-33,
-0.0395610854,
-0.0698394179,
-0.0107753091,
0.0018998528,
0.0128070507,
-0.0091266287,
-0.0466264896,
0.0356087461,
0.0557597801,
-0.0244854707,
0.0231861863,
-0.0446945392,
0.0222672634,
0.0572450608,
0.0481619649,
0.0151152993,
0.0421515778,
-0.0092728166,
0.0020305791,
0.0257967617,
0.0075588161,
0.0017647728,
0.0637114644,
-0.0379783735,
0.0491066799,
-0.0431854278,
-0.020470554,
-0.0087743625,
0.0348535888,
0.0510331355,
-0.0315936729,
0.0239679459,
-0.003838571,
-0.0361106806,
-0.0401680693,
0.0104455017,
-0.0446875282,
0.0232256446,
0.0018700972,
0.0286367126,
-0.0504140183,
-0.0377067104,
0.005907489,
-0.0540443808,
-0.018389523,
0.0264580008,
0.0398090482,
-0.024766447,
0.0010908924,
0.0195913129,
-0.0271668676,
0.0465929173,
-0.0136243515,
-0.0158488266,
0.0540829971,
0.0261203982,
0.0102680083,
0.0218554176,
-0.0373464338,
0.0471076332,
0.0151014123,
0.0354918502,
0.0740205348,
0.0253749192,
0.0333727077,
0.0211284887,
-0.0040483591,
-0.014237985,
0.0020828752,
0.024112286,
-0.0390087366,
0.007201687,
0.0679285452,
0.0634235665,
0.0205895212,
0.0254356191,
-0.0032097588,
0.0480160974,
-0.0526651405,
-0.0324503481,
0.0124249142,
0.0128680766,
-0.0135596301,
0.0304328576,
-0.0287926923,
-0.0734286234,
-0.0107437512,
-0.0148391649,
0.0222514831,
0.005903386,
-0.036174126,
0.0260871258,
0.0465039611,
0.006596115,
-0.0306449793,
-0.0088150138,
0.013109046,
0.0509985164,
-0.010817199,
0.0116038732,
-0.041762881,
0.0080968486,
0.0187377036,
0.0222842526,
0.0200780854,
0.0086630592,
0.0482096635,
0.0301964413,
-0.0550531223,
0.0126377512,
-0.0431149565,
0.0378961526,
-0.0418241359,
-0.0068137799,
0.019801328,
-0.021283906,
-0.0180997755,
0.025670249,
0.0191389546,
0.0062136529,
0.0027202331,
-0.0073585142,
-0.0277156886,
-0.0083309319,
-0.0226531271,
0.0376090966,
-0.0209965333,
0.0286627132,
0.000092038,
-0.0212815665,
-0.0166953653,
0.0067035835,
2.244e-7,
0.0277697146,
0.0263213012,
0.0501715727,
0.0055555012,
0.0157336239,
0.0180573333,
-0.0335168876,
0.0083945272,
-0.0310414676,
0.0042746873,
0.0184627511,
-0.0196372867,
0.0490262434,
0.0036078519,
-0.0885054246,
-0.0050777961,
-0.067970477,
0.0382971317,
-0.0401446298,
-0.0046121092,
0.0395254567,
0.0730712563,
-0.0033000016,
-0.002185079,
-0.0023225681,
-0.0686006844,
0.0741934031,
-0.0264976863,
-0.0122021446,
-0.0033072436,
0.0203506388,
0.0526091866,
-0.0239557456,
-0.0162061658,
-0.0189565122,
-0.0172418728,
0.0649905205,
0.0256285146,
0.0058293543,
0.0079733804,
0.018507706,
0.0154458508,
-0.0098175788,
-0.0483224057,
0.0420789942,
-0.0030216693,
-0.0224433448,
-0.0200984031,
0.0091892257,
-0.0028456603,
0.0098021226,
-0.0494239964,
-0.0164976716,
0.019635193,
0.0453021452,
-0.0331213363,
-0.0371949002,
-0.0317846052,
-0.0184331909,
-0.0264579765,
-0.0475167185,
-0.0240047406,
-0.0754630044,
-0.0039331932,
-0.0199935641,
-0.0113249095,
-0.0147036817,
1.688770171e-34,
0.0272165947,
-0.0195220727,
-0.0019254718,
0.0297874156,
0.0364958905,
-0.0015219863,
-0.0129096406,
0.0140022868,
-0.0053517376,
-0.037614353,
-0.0367958806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05467v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05467v1 | Rapid Optimization for Jailbreaking LLMs via Subconscious Exploitation and Echopraxia | 2024-02-08T07:56:49 | 2024-02-08T07:56:49 | Guangyu Shen, Siyuan Cheng, Kaiyuan Zhang, Guanhong Tao, Shengwei An, Lu Yan, Zhuo Zhang, Shiqing Ma, Xiangyu Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | Large Language Models (LLMs) have become prevalent across diverse sectors,
transforming human life with their extraordinary reasoning and comprehension
abilities. As they find increased use in sensitive tasks, safety concerns have
gained widespread attention. Extensive efforts have been dedicated to aligning
LLMs with human moral principles to ensure their safe deployment. Despite their
potential, recent research indicates aligned LLMs are prone to specialized
jailbreaking prompts that bypass safety measures to elicit violent and harmful
content. The intrinsic discrete nature and substantial scale of contemporary
LLMs pose significant challenges in automatically generating diverse,
efficient, and potent jailbreaking prompts, representing a continuous obstacle.
In this paper, we introduce RIPPLE (Rapid Optimization via Subconscious
Exploitation and Echopraxia), a novel optimization-based method inspired by two
psychological concepts: subconsciousness and echopraxia, which describe the
processes of the mind that occur without conscious awareness and the
involuntary mimicry of actions, respectively. Evaluations across 6 open-source
LLMs and 4 commercial LLM APIs show RIPPLE achieves an average Attack Success
Rate of 91.5\%, outperforming five current methods by up to 47.0\% with an 8x
reduction in overhead. Furthermore, it displays significant transferability and
stealth, successfully evading established detection mechanisms. The code of our
work is available at
\url{https://github.com/SolidShen/RIPPLE_official/tree/official} | [
0.0474032685,
0.0408736095,
-0.0366607755,
0.0392934754,
-0.0553971753,
0.0081945872,
0.0340604,
0.0293778721,
0.0335050784,
-0.0211414453,
-0.0273747537,
-0.0025575806,
0.0023938771,
0.010432166,
0.0560832806,
0.0262093786,
0.0291851126,
-0.043471247,
-0.0088687846,
0.0199302286,
0.0108985575,
-0.0077018482,
-0.0044233408,
0.0197924357,
0.0064655547,
-0.0018279923,
-0.036666166,
0.0217575859,
0.0245568845,
-0.0219866931,
-0.0074643786,
0.0529823191,
0.0116065023,
0.0448231548,
0.000002341,
-0.0522343703,
-0.0059431214,
0.0030193175,
-0.0093425373,
0.051513318,
0.0300112311,
-0.0450091325,
-0.0286604874,
0.0001150304,
-0.0409607999,
0.0274958741,
0.0407787748,
0.0265827831,
0.0630860999,
0.038520094,
-0.0099389413,
0.0085358378,
0.0331786573,
-0.0038109829,
0.0313570052,
-0.0387209877,
0.0236087982,
-0.0361617208,
0.0294023193,
0.0150161339,
0.0074217818,
-0.025792826,
0.0168100819,
-0.008045245,
-0.0352062061,
-0.0416558757,
-0.0184225384,
-0.0406827554,
-0.0260437261,
0.0539602973,
-0.0504112951,
-0.0095885694,
0.0415763222,
-0.0026181857,
0.0003436978,
0.0161045846,
0.0121740196,
0.0374299139,
-0.0080967192,
-0.0293986425,
-0.0141478339,
0.0129961362,
0.0401170254,
0.0155791109,
0.0344727151,
0.0131845912,
-0.0083280895,
-0.0355807915,
0.0367074795,
-0.0779825076,
-0.0056166616,
-0.0634594485,
0.0225756522,
0.01869395,
0.000337324,
0.0061907633,
-0.0787461698,
-0.0828453228,
0.0335152447,
-0.0536187775,
0.0034731701,
0.0467997752,
0.0050990614,
0.0112727871,
-0.0222189166,
0.0373308845,
-0.0300069116,
0.0276676323,
-0.0255849846,
0.0755076185,
-0.0045017325,
-0.0093530854,
-0.0097197145,
0.0373347923,
-0.0146191698,
-0.0153340446,
-0.0599850938,
0.0269146375,
-0.0591925308,
-0.004351344,
-0.0886960179,
0.0097887646,
0.0301511846,
0.0194780286,
0.0461446941,
-0.0752164498,
-0.0040840344,
-0.0084661143,
-0.0029104655,
-0.0366419367,
-0.0049645924,
-0.0001435079,
-0.0562115498,
0.0100041823,
-0.0051035648,
0.137494415,
0.0115464348,
0.0020433387,
-0.0701720566,
-0.0622468702,
-0.0079445252,
-0.0078846952,
0.011142035,
-0.0850113854,
-0.0098658754,
-0.0254022367,
-0.0219834503,
-0.0168817528,
0.0278693084,
0.0079910401,
-0.0327402502,
0.0798699111,
0.0074306368,
-0.0100134388,
0.0157248043,
0.0475740209,
0.0035919454,
0.0850517899,
-0.0133935902,
0.0656014532,
0.0332159251,
0.013374065,
0.04061101,
0.0599941574,
-0.0070238318,
0.0189695731,
-0.0217693523,
-0.0563245788,
0.0266765878,
0.0117293829,
-0.0058459863,
0.0140196877,
-0.0228225701,
-0.0289558023,
0.0640588552,
0.0948629081,
-0.0859082937,
0.0611174256,
0.01630334,
0.000343855,
0.0028173774,
-0.0202643219,
-0.0435852073,
0.0144101102,
-0.0474512614,
-0.0216383114,
-0.0192072522,
0.0430534035,
0.0067377277,
0.0248942804,
-0.0193183385,
-0.0339210667,
-0.0032607594,
0.0089393407,
0.0063071181,
0.0295795351,
-0.0254636817,
0.0298722815,
0.0345785581,
-0.0314119756,
-0.0318270959,
-0.0643060803,
0.0149035668,
0.0664685145,
0.0202610362,
0.01126632,
0.0071301563,
-0.0123276105,
0.0055048559,
0.0482884347,
-0.0423086248,
0.0213174038,
0.0001495437,
-0.0150979012,
-0.0069498969,
-0.0031418991,
0.0096291574,
0.0341783576,
-0.0135391746,
0.0056811767,
0.0061682225,
-0.0277607609,
-0.015824819,
0.020236006,
-0.0061183115,
-0.033482831,
-0.0098865554,
0.0313916616,
0.0299652573,
0.0105788913,
-0.0190862957,
0.0168831944,
0.042819716,
-0.0526532456,
0.0114881378,
0.0045363936,
-0.0413792692,
0.0424159504,
0.0415200666,
-0.0516317934,
0.0303679258,
0.0827757195,
-0.012254619,
0.0145247206,
0.0365649126,
-0.0410443395,
0.0611088127,
-0.023964528,
0.0385872982,
-0.0269142073,
0.0038016944,
-0.010398305,
0.011859512,
-0.0291093327,
-0.0064517721,
-0.0152239706,
0.0408515558,
0.0251306463,
0.0245417282,
-0.0264461469,
-0.0184508953,
-0.0589840226,
0.0290078968,
-0.0028221335,
0.0374487191,
-0.0282444172,
-0.0424527414,
-0.041026067,
-0.029848706,
-0.0132275326,
-0.0161291324,
0.0335792638,
-0.0119375242,
-0.0432310589,
-0.0095229791,
0.0036831414,
0.0182597265,
-0.0031118807,
0.0141116204,
-0.0323289186,
-0.0469938181,
-0.0620079562,
-0.001331575,
0.0110758403,
-0.0026835664,
0.0297700074,
-0.0413787737,
-0.0421867184,
-0.0089357989,
0.0362468623,
-0.0087024039,
0.0052326019,
-0.0199009515,
-0.0595850088,
0.0369506106,
0.0046665496,
-0.0061484193,
0.0583564751,
0.0197520591,
0.0338198096,
0.0711511448,
0.0184975751,
-0.0387394428,
-0.0206227954,
0.0358194262,
-0.0271757226,
-0.009858992,
-0.0726013854,
0.012382796,
0.0649509206,
0.0585486218,
0.0425159074,
-0.0259678606,
0.0246299319,
-0.0161160436,
-0.0597535484,
-0.0366537459,
-0.0616613515,
-0.055433169,
0.0202477816,
-0.0113254255,
-0.0787524283,
0.0646880791,
-0.0298987217,
0.0229429081,
0.0078653134,
-0.0266237911,
0.0108607411,
0.0173374955,
-0.0284832716,
0.0529009141,
0.0598273799,
-0.0309392326,
0.0160532072,
-0.0352691486,
0.0068547074,
-0.0272515416,
-0.0004343948,
-0.0260341614,
-0.0140446555,
0.0188969932,
-0.0105660427,
-0.0581860766,
-0.0774985477,
-0.0286091156,
-0.0252692997,
0.0396137387,
-0.0556632802,
0.0188339427,
-0.0134850154,
0.0489738621,
-0.0072552874,
-0.0137210451,
-0.0062988326,
-0.016922446,
-0.020082349,
0.0555151626,
-0.0544671975,
0.0148904659,
0.0110717481,
0.0282968991,
0.1074086502,
0.0490400158,
0.0194466375,
-0.0091464138,
0.0606924854,
0.0253490061,
0.0189088657,
0.0157235339,
0.0454557315,
0.0369499624,
0.0073072445,
-0.0184363667,
0.046371907,
0.0396841429,
-0.0556687005,
0.0415315405,
-0.0404277295,
0.0055869953,
0.0125796692,
0.0115183406,
-0.0660984367,
-0.0190434307,
0.0121373339,
0.0699235201,
-0.063359715,
-0.0318491012,
-0.0288485996,
-0.0670657307,
0.007121494,
0.0368784219,
-0.0221451223,
0.0114919385,
-0.0142761329,
0.0031097797,
0.0436935425,
0.0194403399,
-0.0121411327,
0.0033428243,
-0.0143339969,
-0.0028846134,
-0.0394581854,
0.018791249,
0.0388931073,
-0.0289744921,
0.0623294115,
0.0675778165,
0.005594979,
-0.0375628881,
-0.0373635776,
0.0453741848,
-0.0027480586,
0.0136714466,
-0.0115989391,
-0.0118691567,
0.0036825875,
-0.0019043345,
-0.038618736,
0.0801666975,
-0.0186378658,
-0.0743488371,
0.0560168214,
0.0479655564,
0.0023841157,
-0.0111494046,
-0.0375027061,
0.0120459935,
0.0357584916,
0.0338623784,
0.0220261645,
-0.0507072136,
-0.0236362014,
-0.0398590155,
-0.039684549,
-0.0249984562,
-0.0732080489,
-0.0132934721,
0.0337059759,
-0.0353852101,
-0.033667203,
0.0234678853,
-0.0363274626,
0.0485389829,
0.0576511659,
-0.0146638723,
0.0274823885,
0.0046514603,
-0.0381397642,
-0.0665727928,
0.0128223859,
0.036430683,
-0.0147112701,
0.0269612968,
-0.0223868005,
-0.0631320626,
0.0129912915,
0.0268315095,
-0.0464538485,
-0.0682907999,
0.027095288,
0.0623878613,
0.0258779526,
-0.0177238546,
-0.0555965155,
-0.0334053263,
0.1141783372,
0.0732060522,
-0.0475989692,
0.0423350371,
0.0677412078,
0.0336265638,
0.0219446141,
0.0108169429,
0.0016042884,
-0.0149042867,
0.0861735493,
0.0012919084,
-0.0631297976,
0.0105079897,
0.0341592953,
0.042217616,
-0.0276935194,
-0.0565437786,
0.0172147732,
0.0470892526,
0.0065323086,
-0.0035051021,
-0.0016725815,
-0.0170655157,
-0.0037872535,
0.0304984339,
-0.0384865403,
0.0396661051,
-0.0422698371,
-0.0186401624,
-0.0302695688,
0.0143761253,
0.0406204015,
-0.0039352905,
0.0231714752,
0.0579254627,
0.0252620019,
-0.0361573547,
0.0486478023,
-0.0463509746,
0.0309447981,
-0.0019763932,
0.0771474987,
-0.0009502884,
-0.0262879133,
-0.026669398,
0.0636429414,
-0.0422872193,
-0.0461993963,
0.0025806881,
0.0348581448,
0.0090518547,
-0.0146864243,
-0.0004129224,
-0.036291711,
0.0071317777,
-0.0131992782,
-0.0005007184,
-0.0571908616,
-0.0590546727,
-0.0041036848,
0.0202827118,
0.0008665294,
0.0272041727,
0.0334534757,
-0.0349073298,
0.0434333235,
0.0543903336,
-0.0282432921,
-0.0393837504,
0.0262537561,
0.0618812181,
0.0703906044,
-0.0505403802,
-0.0197145473,
-0.0831866935,
-0.062423829,
-0.0126292119,
-0.0103243571,
0.0092510208,
-0.0260628462,
-0.0091269296,
0.0620304309,
-0.0137313986,
0.0183848869,
-0.0474384464,
0.0337085091,
-0.0126915807,
-0.0439843349,
0.0034063172,
-6.000743643e-33,
0.0338609554,
-0.0719307587,
-0.0654323623,
-0.0017716027,
-0.0221619308,
-0.0078505976,
-0.0246553533,
0.0453300476,
0.0065465136,
-0.0315608718,
-0.0303977579,
-0.0200439226,
-0.0001965312,
-0.0280833133,
-0.0334631316,
-0.0123431794,
-0.0268825013,
-0.0083859432,
-0.0103653874,
-0.0084858527,
0.0407572463,
0.0116542242,
-0.0049405289,
-0.080890514,
0.0437176228,
-0.0189897884,
-0.044008173,
0.0046248804,
-0.03451664,
0.0297711417,
-0.0060593849,
0.0302133318,
-0.0061127678,
-0.0050794287,
-0.0050237025,
0.069717072,
0.0421287678,
0.0058230725,
0.0322992951,
-0.0091443751,
0.0173107944,
-0.053978987,
0.0239974018,
-0.0088978549,
-0.0297676641,
-0.0096886475,
-0.0130321495,
-0.0255954321,
-0.0224738419,
-0.0163650792,
-0.0581739023,
-0.0184419584,
-0.0138501972,
-0.0225126781,
0.0053058607,
-0.0170389581,
-0.0299096387,
-0.029050665,
-0.0697229803,
0.0611592904,
0.0223142058,
-0.0108381175,
0.0415896811,
-0.0067223925,
-0.0053564226,
0.0828967765,
0.0218210537,
-0.0388637334,
-0.0094977422,
0.0363286659,
0.0397456996,
0.0591346473,
0.0498748012,
0.0672283173,
0.0429572091,
-0.0468243584,
-0.030363109,
-0.0109376963,
0.0318220034,
-0.0040516076,
0.0786888599,
-0.0040101469,
-0.0408573598,
-0.00202318,
-0.0121402387,
-0.0063350885,
-0.0291456338,
-0.0471979938,
0.0194548555,
-0.0047724675,
-0.0312643163,
-0.072481893,
-0.0045722919,
-0.0304737017,
0.0482023284,
-0.002276408,
0.0090030795,
0.0200701393,
-0.0087434547,
-0.0073836311,
0.0030731286,
0.0087075951,
-0.0022878624,
-0.0377207696,
0.0457685143,
-0.0104749724,
-0.0049351235,
0.0268653799,
-0.046435196,
-0.0295203812,
-0.0308079943,
0.0382514223,
0.0371063352,
-0.0273255873,
0.0134861264,
-0.0240341574,
-0.0254728086,
-0.0470696352,
0.0273132715,
-0.0163185056,
-0.0355096646,
0.0493776836,
-0.0644828379,
0.0463878177,
-0.026618164,
0.0109812813,
-0.0177045614,
0.0415582582,
0.0438336469,
-0.0733902752,
-0.0091679888,
-0.0045467401,
3.103e-7,
-0.0613111891,
-0.0070705079,
-0.0124236476,
0.0007127722,
0.0055302116,
0.0957190171,
-0.0004227055,
0.060897816,
0.0103178043,
-0.0910809934,
-0.0209087096,
0.0176229477,
0.0760156214,
0.0193640795,
-0.0496897101,
0.0261817686,
0.0052614352,
0.0201979596,
-0.0535053499,
0.0220235419,
0.0558456481,
0.0248752534,
0.0062353988,
-0.0481337681,
0.0152915539,
-0.0388272293,
-0.0173652954,
-0.0248161554,
0.0061812191,
-0.0246471614,
-0.0119758816,
0.0002159887,
-0.0104920659,
0.0441042632,
-0.0220414121,
-0.0623654015,
-0.0316992998,
0.0455837883,
0.0028379585,
-0.0323156156,
-0.0207181796,
-0.0086980881,
-0.0152586298,
-0.0448930748,
0.0483317412,
0.0071792775,
-0.0472483747,
-0.0010493324,
0.0035901724,
-0.0166061819,
-0.0125716701,
-0.0564966574,
0.0272459611,
-0.0045255236,
0.0302028693,
0.0254791696,
0.0213379525,
-0.0425633602,
0.0035615556,
0.0164906867,
0.0150411846,
-0.0667991564,
-0.0321957655,
0.0689448789,
0.036578171,
-0.0545413569,
0.0346167013,
3.216636287e-34,
-0.0251145083,
-0.0227085557,
0.034608081,
0.0129279038,
0.019030733,
0.0467899032,
0.0204553809,
0.0333299935,
0.0349776782,
-0.0496571511,
0.0053968602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05457v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05457v1 | It's Never Too Late: Fusing Acoustic Information into Large Language Models for Automatic Speech Recognition | 2024-02-08T07:21:45 | 2024-02-08T07:21:45 | Chen Chen, Ruizhe Li, Yuchen Hu, Sabato Marco Siniscalchi, Pin-Yu Chen, Ensiong Chng, Chao-Han Huck Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent studies have successfully shown that large language models (LLMs) can
be successfully used for generative error correction (GER) on top of the
automatic speech recognition (ASR) output. Specifically, an LLM is utilized to
carry out a direct mapping from the N-best hypotheses list generated by an ASR
system to the predicted output transcription. However, despite its
effectiveness, GER introduces extra data uncertainty since the LLM is trained
without taking into account acoustic information available in the speech
signal. In this work, we aim to overcome such a limitation by infusing acoustic
information before generating the predicted transcription through a novel late
fusion solution termed Uncertainty-Aware Dynamic Fusion (UADF). UADF is a
multimodal fusion approach implemented into an auto-regressive decoding process
and works in two stages: (i) It first analyzes and calibrates the token-level
LLM decision, and (ii) it then dynamically assimilates the information from the
acoustic modality. Experimental evidence collected from various ASR tasks shows
that UADF surpasses existing fusion mechanisms in several ways. It yields
significant improvements in word error rate (WER) while mitigating data
uncertainty issues in LLM and addressing the poor generalization relied with
sole modality during fusion. We also demonstrate that UADF seamlessly adapts to
audio-visual speech recognition. | [
-0.0028052959,
0.0834481046,
0.0238305498,
0.0074008205,
-0.00421539,
-0.005910987,
-0.0142886424,
-0.036898911,
-0.0330976471,
-0.0514792167,
-0.0308043566,
-0.0532966852,
0.0882396251,
0.023609573,
0.0507935546,
-0.0147842988,
-0.0004713474,
-0.0723496005,
0.0057954867,
-0.01686031,
-0.0061713383,
0.0251099449,
-0.036815431,
0.0636312738,
-0.0435170531,
0.0366300195,
0.0027899859,
0.0487367883,
0.0304291248,
0.009065154,
-0.0649365261,
0.0068378532,
0.0452665649,
0.044246044,
0.0000018456,
-0.0281718373,
0.0090811588,
0.0229201708,
-0.0272427648,
0.0042527011,
0.0299632791,
-0.0091095204,
-0.053963501,
0.0692095682,
0.0172123536,
-0.0581706725,
0.0575408228,
0.0041353838,
0.00887693,
0.0320336148,
-0.0151740424,
-0.0426722243,
0.0733083263,
-0.0276307762,
-0.0265089292,
-0.0151852611,
0.0084379874,
-0.0132334698,
-0.027102327,
-0.0524561256,
-0.0200494137,
0.0461039394,
-0.0301072039,
-0.0360481627,
0.0111959483,
0.0297536105,
-0.0163990911,
-0.0530861169,
-0.0531945191,
0.0338765085,
-0.0071061673,
-0.0081416238,
-0.0101063969,
0.0086079827,
-0.0238827746,
-0.0013461892,
0.0052383668,
0.0291193333,
0.0052594668,
0.0083597871,
-0.0011631812,
-0.0094662439,
0.0406866446,
-0.0057964534,
-0.0536765307,
-0.0083856322,
0.0207240526,
-0.0143752834,
-0.0230748504,
-0.0115430485,
-0.0078452826,
-0.0356185138,
0.0015682074,
0.0163062606,
-0.000159989,
-0.0082969628,
-0.057568185,
-0.0510155372,
-0.0161178168,
-0.0059991577,
0.0149635011,
0.0572284795,
-0.050927572,
0.015517693,
-0.0061707785,
0.0733380318,
-0.0103313932,
-0.004975474,
-0.0302942842,
-0.0269827861,
-0.0031579826,
0.007692412,
-0.0064175962,
0.0049125161,
-0.023322789,
-0.047656443,
-0.0641363636,
0.0248783547,
0.0015457342,
0.0287233256,
0.006753582,
-0.0051255752,
-0.0362974741,
-0.0371146314,
0.0067247138,
0.0213040002,
0.0633341819,
0.0698811337,
-0.0114171002,
-0.0626729205,
0.0156472716,
0.0261004511,
0.0230083577,
0.0025182778,
0.0095633604,
0.0944623128,
-0.0314242467,
-0.0234132055,
-0.0145119242,
0.0227779355,
-0.0373640507,
-0.0331050195,
-0.0156694222,
-0.0457330681,
0.0327399075,
0.0107914796,
0.0246247295,
-0.0110756708,
0.0069515486,
-0.0345368572,
0.0067158774,
0.1023803428,
-0.0116336094,
0.0495240055,
0.0566076338,
-0.0200511049,
0.0052617867,
0.0525717735,
0.0640236214,
-0.0155199794,
-0.0221992582,
-0.0021597028,
-0.002658295,
0.0574145541,
-0.0243866015,
0.0364989005,
-0.0552207157,
-0.0510372557,
0.0062701013,
-0.0130619816,
0.0473551489,
0.0824743286,
-0.0358327068,
0.039617721,
0.0648816302,
0.0289730541,
0.0194099434,
0.0119317435,
0.0205217022,
-0.0245257691,
-0.0050277971,
-0.0112794721,
-0.0198575817,
-0.0224774517,
-0.0283985958,
0.0357509106,
0.0799056217,
0.0842490122,
-0.0052481578,
-0.0233772546,
-0.0350123793,
-0.0412638411,
-0.0136073688,
0.0501564369,
0.0466734804,
-0.0201915521,
-0.0675072446,
0.0256652646,
-0.0177259948,
-0.0531010441,
0.0313192122,
-0.041170653,
0.0138965584,
0.0616016574,
0.0626513436,
-0.0176763535,
-0.0242787525,
-0.005258684,
-0.0752721205,
0.0446562842,
-0.0050807185,
0.0145263281,
0.0570122935,
-0.0720364302,
-0.0429887548,
0.0702976212,
-0.0088064298,
0.0604111329,
-0.0267218798,
0.0077157128,
0.0115157394,
0.0045458055,
0.0108116707,
-0.001871128,
-0.0016410007,
-0.0275834631,
0.005617531,
0.0020911261,
0.0603072494,
0.0073091541,
-0.0624902248,
0.0254495367,
0.0337279104,
-0.030434737,
-0.0260340553,
0.0335998386,
-0.0554584712,
-0.0187524687,
0.0711447224,
-0.0069241142,
0.0007060451,
-0.0139737232,
-0.0044148974,
-0.0836026743,
0.0120222094,
-0.0271530189,
0.0304716323,
-0.0632655025,
0.0465163477,
0.060009554,
0.0001248516,
0.0030920696,
0.0038175767,
-0.0361069255,
-0.0273664668,
0.030040605,
0.0085235341,
-0.0279503465,
-0.0445204712,
-0.0064236643,
0.0272098593,
-0.0133071626,
0.0372883119,
-0.0074973274,
0.001003708,
0.0123787699,
-0.035496112,
-0.094012171,
-0.0301990137,
-0.0062408308,
-0.0090460945,
-0.032416109,
0.0044092634,
0.0048686867,
-0.0245491546,
-0.0229094699,
-0.0030107878,
0.0095189251,
-0.0103140119,
-0.0271218307,
0.0141815022,
-0.0229938161,
-0.0355543159,
0.0019291862,
0.0103104394,
0.0001451875,
-0.0212905407,
-0.0151928086,
-0.0735442415,
0.0074338927,
-0.0310371704,
0.0578236654,
0.0092782052,
-0.052838739,
0.000399508,
-0.0448288545,
0.0639508367,
-0.0060796733,
-0.0069601359,
-0.0485142842,
0.0306925662,
-0.0409215316,
-0.0412564725,
0.0104321521,
0.0132970549,
-0.0071499394,
-0.019515954,
0.0113895545,
-0.0737127066,
0.0211989973,
0.0434171967,
0.0187104251,
-0.0641509742,
-0.0305869225,
0.0163598955,
-0.0462811068,
-0.0488651991,
-0.0665737242,
-0.0169318914,
0.0166509561,
-0.0146987364,
-0.0557231084,
0.044341214,
-0.1052162126,
-0.0119460514,
0.0103724357,
-0.0325854234,
-0.0165837035,
-0.0170478709,
-0.0096793175,
-0.0000609886,
-0.0356120095,
-0.0385497622,
-0.034967009,
-0.0109739993,
0.0290310513,
-0.0702345148,
0.0715165287,
-0.0503718704,
0.0183357447,
-0.0290929675,
-0.0253924113,
-0.0277578197,
-0.0249137618,
-0.0305448137,
-0.003381667,
-0.0032306495,
-0.0466495976,
-0.0406839065,
0.0219756551,
0.0178219751,
0.0566627942,
0.0229108576,
-0.0054506818,
-0.0353964157,
0.0635490566,
0.0082808472,
0.0514801964,
-0.012400589,
0.0038471466,
0.0212856214,
0.0078880256,
0.0836417452,
0.0062417444,
-0.0542174987,
-0.0010862345,
0.0848181024,
0.0768064931,
-0.0083007701,
0.0338978581,
0.0375619903,
-0.027575247,
0.0165826734,
0.0979044959,
-0.0073530134,
-0.0196144208,
-0.0642571673,
0.0098926369,
0.0281154662,
0.0009256597,
-0.0131519558,
-0.0365749337,
-0.0353614129,
0.07835152,
0.0249402989,
0.0145857781,
0.0545031242,
-0.0192045011,
-0.1121071801,
0.0547329262,
0.0554071404,
0.0196098778,
-0.0261402726,
-0.0180660151,
-0.0124483611,
-0.02527472,
0.0379009023,
-0.0009412107,
0.0107656131,
-0.0339068174,
0.0524892621,
-0.015443041,
-0.069498755,
-0.0217667371,
-0.0077770669,
0.0643664896,
0.0906339437,
0.039142143,
-0.0332105085,
-0.0411263667,
0.064915061,
0.0038201662,
0.0023594135,
0.0024760091,
-0.0024514063,
-0.0072541018,
-0.0024632732,
0.0371239409,
0.0304412674,
0.0195025876,
-0.0167165678,
-0.0160649866,
0.0553778745,
-0.0345025808,
0.0626272187,
-0.0071482817,
-0.003459455,
-0.0080979643,
0.0362422504,
-0.0099182017,
-0.0198627971,
0.0088743325,
-0.0016476057,
0.0476983972,
0.0057914122,
0.0208753869,
0.0245164912,
-0.008740942,
-0.0624882504,
-0.0306823403,
-0.0043792282,
-0.0124864699,
0.0288368352,
0.0391469784,
-0.0104275998,
-0.0238643065,
0.0387861729,
-0.0246604811,
0.0172049105,
0.0142605565,
0.0459578633,
-0.0764558762,
0.0509997495,
0.024854837,
-0.0445800275,
-0.0102536306,
0.0628793761,
-0.0348276347,
-0.0863614753,
-0.0041710031,
0.00536791,
0.0179594681,
0.0276629049,
-0.0243143309,
-0.0452788472,
0.0597215295,
0.0629437044,
-0.0091953464,
0.0277300365,
0.0352124497,
-0.0095671015,
-0.0187687762,
0.0046855602,
-0.0576254576,
0.0047762687,
-0.0345861576,
0.0069335946,
-0.0184787419,
-0.0882446542,
-0.0037166539,
0.036518462,
0.083626315,
-0.0630906969,
0.0325154886,
-0.0482651293,
0.0177410413,
0.006301146,
0.0421260111,
-0.0480597205,
0.0052664983,
0.0451079495,
-0.0003602585,
0.0064395261,
0.0233248584,
0.0196886025,
-0.0147944018,
-0.0239972919,
0.0240728892,
0.0212097336,
0.0053919414,
0.0070757428,
-0.0055558076,
-0.0072886702,
0.040705964,
0.0162680522,
-0.0258160643,
-0.0108758025,
0.0086601023,
-0.0074270056,
-0.0216487087,
0.0049447431,
0.0108152945,
-0.0251653101,
-0.0385199822,
-0.0273983646,
0.0527612865,
0.0564747155,
0.0447809547,
0.0570254587,
-0.0110732606,
0.0120323384,
-0.053141702,
0.0251513086,
-0.0305436812,
0.0019907798,
0.0430276096,
0.0114480061,
-0.0087341266,
0.0168640334,
0.0307135172,
0.006222757,
0.0237623919,
-0.0678499937,
0.0116555756,
-0.0300340671,
-0.0325073227,
0.0000030894,
-0.0182590876,
-0.0386649109,
0.0230328422,
-0.0185618941,
-0.0870210603,
0.0284911059,
0.0413337573,
0.015803298,
-0.0261101443,
-0.0249134451,
-0.0104784872,
-0.0132388063,
0.0108799934,
0.0000749325,
-0.0367734432,
0.0170624498,
0.0191059168,
0.0333389454,
-6.207822401e-33,
-0.0341377556,
-0.0139549002,
0.0125171812,
-0.0708486065,
-0.0372737832,
0.016572509,
0.0322647393,
0.0100400094,
0.0365022346,
-0.0216990132,
-0.025658967,
0.0164533351,
0.0350518413,
0.0190318245,
-0.0033608845,
0.0469579883,
0.0873001739,
-0.0010950563,
0.0202873237,
-0.038157519,
0.0442589782,
0.028196713,
-0.0111413123,
-0.0545936674,
-0.0157899763,
0.0324576087,
-0.0696044266,
0.0144102732,
0.0122258402,
0.0422320887,
-0.0137430206,
0.0243413635,
-0.0409244373,
0.0059200544,
-0.031139046,
0.0263494924,
-0.0897844434,
0.0129396804,
0.0241159461,
0.0414625369,
-0.0139213447,
-0.00098114,
0.0372417159,
0.0159069244,
-0.0301985666,
-0.0412632525,
0.0083090337,
-0.0464325957,
-0.0244132224,
-0.0596546046,
0.0069516669,
0.0434735008,
0.0039981157,
-0.0155307921,
0.0621475279,
0.0180082433,
0.0166518092,
-0.021236185,
-0.071777992,
0.0310426541,
0.0145369228,
0.0268621407,
0.0578036569,
0.0641070828,
-0.0171639603,
0.0134569323,
0.0109131439,
-0.0681360811,
-0.0259713084,
-0.0454772562,
0.0196844507,
0.0258786678,
0.0139525561,
0.0466651134,
0.0036892591,
-0.0302430708,
-0.0144875767,
0.0034683992,
-0.0035569982,
0.0349269025,
0.0464365557,
0.0626460165,
-0.039711386,
0.0068097143,
-0.0842876136,
0.0079002241,
-0.0392069928,
0.0242711809,
0.0367630273,
0.0650948733,
-0.0037888323,
-0.0121133393,
0.0550336875,
-0.0226321295,
0.0250759702,
0.0320953764,
-0.0068740062,
0.0023408777,
-0.0284703057,
0.0211651213,
-0.0214876421,
-0.0260420982,
0.0673247054,
0.0264811311,
0.0002190017,
-0.0295277722,
-0.0243988615,
0.0886215791,
-0.0730367601,
0.0059844558,
0.003135453,
0.02462456,
0.0083984947,
-0.0207673348,
0.0604111664,
-0.0032538418,
-0.0149361594,
-0.0084660705,
-0.0161180608,
0.0630946904,
0.0063719451,
0.0173510984,
-0.001315255,
0.0279360488,
-0.0184168722,
0.0198815875,
0.0158122964,
-0.0704251379,
0.0296457801,
0.0104534207,
-0.0280587096,
0.0265937243,
2.725e-7,
-0.0413802341,
0.0046812491,
0.0399549082,
-0.0086142896,
0.015494029,
0.0358032174,
-0.0318064168,
-0.0278175958,
0.036009863,
0.0056582447,
0.0273124259,
-0.006910692,
0.0784766227,
0.0380342342,
-0.02160169,
-0.0310171768,
-0.0382680111,
0.0293614324,
0.0242766626,
0.0066786781,
0.0236844141,
0.1004617736,
-0.0288201962,
-0.0436578095,
0.0125509715,
-0.0470531732,
0.0526055992,
0.0058656321,
-0.0412908085,
-0.0262203179,
0.0463308282,
0.0160283986,
-0.0037657898,
0.0096991183,
-0.0287788119,
0.0070407814,
0.0171599463,
0.0229941159,
-0.0309723411,
-0.0449236408,
-0.0120388651,
0.0430409983,
-0.0355701968,
0.0021905152,
0.0308786184,
-0.0005351451,
-0.0056124707,
-0.0330420993,
-0.0316552594,
-0.0048585334,
0.0466529541,
-0.0430888869,
0.0106521808,
0.0133131463,
0.0289243516,
0.0044976189,
-0.0521100499,
-0.0701880902,
-0.0013982631,
0.0463490747,
-0.0724819601,
-0.0079146633,
-0.0024118461,
0.0014817151,
0.0411026329,
-0.0633884892,
-0.0095821219,
2.189222771e-34,
0.0405448563,
-0.0362114683,
0.013756549,
0.0008532706,
0.0229774956,
-0.0249017254,
-0.0365845673,
0.0165317263,
0.0128418682,
-0.065545924,
-0.0449462272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05455v1 | Large Language Models for Psycholinguistic Plausibility Pretesting | 2024-02-08T07:20:02 | 2024-02-08T07:20:02 | Samuel Joseph Amouyal, Aya Meltzer-Asscher, Jonathan Berant | cs.CL | cs.CL | In psycholinguistics, the creation of controlled materials is crucial to
ensure that research outcomes are solely attributed to the intended
manipulations and not influenced by extraneous factors. To achieve this,
psycholinguists typically pretest linguistic materials, where a common pretest
is to solicit plausibility judgments from human evaluators on specific
sentences. In this work, we investigate whether Language Models (LMs) can be
used to generate these plausibility judgements. We investigate a wide range of
LMs across multiple linguistic structures and evaluate whether their
plausibility judgements correlate with human judgements. We find that GPT-4
plausibility judgements highly correlate with human judgements across the
structures we examine, whereas other LMs correlate well with humans on commonly
used syntactic structures. We then test whether this correlation implies that
LMs can be used instead of humans for pretesting. We find that when
coarse-grained plausibility judgements are needed, this works well, but when
fine-grained judgements are necessary, even GPT-4 does not provide satisfactory
discriminative power. | [
0.05471275,
0.0559639744,
-0.0288712569,
0.0313107483,
-0.0630367994,
0.0041956478,
0.0113107748,
0.0154779172,
0.0062496727,
-0.0268425941,
-0.0067942711,
-0.0501369089,
0.0015025291,
0.0116054127,
0.0489694178,
-0.0449146405,
0.0219393484,
-0.0059307837,
0.070852451,
0.0207448434,
0.0100258375,
0.0082581304,
-0.0130283525,
0.022522904,
0.006077609,
-0.0104886405,
0.0341048576,
-0.0049215872,
-0.0141838938,
-0.0408557914,
-0.0061647976,
0.069202289,
-0.0015077613,
0.0093859341,
0.0000019972,
-0.0525799394,
0.0212661941,
-0.0123754283,
-0.0079974383,
0.0679670796,
0.0655235797,
0.0128909564,
-0.0078272475,
-0.0091294991,
-0.0388720967,
-0.0049128537,
0.0491086878,
0.0470313691,
0.0065732156,
0.0368752033,
-0.0377302989,
0.0076935231,
0.0101820491,
-0.000401216,
0.0077217212,
-0.0091409003,
0.0601148419,
-0.0109340362,
0.0192292314,
-0.0086941049,
-0.0102555249,
-0.0070612482,
0.0159416124,
0.0239440519,
-0.0578400046,
-0.006496931,
-0.0313147716,
-0.0409302451,
0.0015411903,
0.0298421085,
0.029128205,
-0.0545388907,
-0.0132915387,
-0.0344995782,
-0.024590306,
0.0294859931,
0.0057596671,
0.0336532071,
-0.0076420247,
0.0019166677,
0.0417737365,
0.0157783814,
0.0273880512,
0.0476791374,
0.010677469,
0.0969538391,
0.0272657089,
-0.0470012464,
0.044325605,
0.0101793064,
-0.0463260449,
-0.0436438806,
-0.0349763967,
-0.0311657023,
-0.0065277508,
0.037278153,
-0.0106093502,
0.0351472571,
0.049740646,
-0.0401693769,
0.0197014231,
0.0120794959,
-0.0444773287,
0.035426084,
0.0028405164,
0.0625276119,
-0.0379970744,
-0.0069458047,
-0.0264461096,
0.0257061291,
-0.0472472981,
-0.0139387073,
-0.0036901229,
-0.0269352812,
-0.013301366,
-0.0187354013,
-0.0891864672,
-0.0117519991,
-0.0232491121,
-0.0419742987,
-0.0452847071,
-0.0046083252,
-0.0137011511,
-0.0100210551,
-0.0354896933,
-0.0040017362,
-0.018119758,
0.0547385104,
-0.0329277962,
-0.0691404566,
0.0169761907,
0.0590756424,
-0.0087146508,
-0.0359092094,
-0.0035939228,
-0.0011687833,
0.0132299103,
-0.0173229594,
-0.0307962447,
-0.0491166301,
-0.056973204,
-0.0556332543,
-0.0118377954,
-0.035871692,
-0.0310621765,
-0.0074344305,
-0.009850624,
-0.0564882234,
-0.00393986,
0.0007617097,
-0.0450479314,
0.0797799677,
-0.0108765094,
0.0256102104,
-0.0269243792,
0.0150638036,
-0.0349875838,
0.0176359713,
0.0480040908,
0.0093517331,
0.0237085111,
-0.0178834461,
0.0640403628,
0.0319290422,
-0.0522527918,
0.0146769444,
-0.0024376423,
-0.0240463,
-0.0123831779,
0.0066185463,
-0.012499352,
0.0771276951,
-0.0200609528,
0.007653201,
0.0928523391,
0.0617614128,
0.0042716712,
0.0252761003,
0.0804212093,
0.0455928445,
0.0367037766,
0.0277422797,
-0.0594249144,
-0.0241152421,
-0.0544232428,
-0.0013906893,
0.0015640573,
-0.000152001,
0.0035596523,
-0.0290173832,
-0.0175953582,
0.0051063653,
0.0495774746,
0.0040956764,
0.0130194798,
-0.0232017115,
-0.0530759059,
-0.0298590884,
0.0529486574,
-0.0612622201,
0.0028953166,
-0.0531834699,
0.0467801467,
0.0516106933,
0.0318081267,
0.0115412697,
0.0336164087,
0.004833024,
-0.0055925027,
0.0708409548,
0.0381479934,
0.0208962802,
0.0040458455,
-0.0329981074,
0.0126213012,
-0.0121262353,
0.0367176048,
-0.0173493959,
-0.013645852,
-0.0139900511,
0.0052400585,
-0.0534145646,
-0.0110578462,
0.033798784,
-0.0188983493,
-0.0265994705,
-0.0181172639,
0.0016743796,
0.0418568626,
0.0120609002,
-0.0031996411,
0.0288588628,
0.0203009769,
-0.006982808,
0.0208256822,
0.0339271724,
-0.0219181459,
0.0229664482,
0.0123416176,
-0.0159922708,
0.0022321912,
0.0072338642,
0.0346016884,
-0.0290998295,
0.0288311802,
-0.0523499958,
0.0353364646,
-0.0741500631,
0.0314417519,
-0.0418885574,
0.0565445125,
-0.0058635911,
0.0756218135,
0.0338718109,
0.0416901149,
-0.004781723,
-0.0015580036,
0.0294681974,
-0.0368857421,
-0.0363804363,
-0.0049036397,
0.0156167215,
0.0182310343,
-0.0000174701,
-0.0161635652,
-0.0541553199,
-0.0224327669,
-0.1044699177,
-0.0190926995,
-0.0013056862,
0.0087809181,
0.0035566723,
-0.0582318306,
-0.0349484868,
0.0339073017,
0.0072677485,
-0.0247264765,
0.0159890205,
0.0472882539,
-0.0001135375,
-0.027918363,
-0.0540239401,
-0.0251303706,
0.0012256684,
-0.0367047936,
0.043292284,
0.03542744,
-0.0043417714,
-0.0218581185,
0.0455818512,
-0.058698304,
-0.0036709676,
0.0256680213,
-0.0578462631,
0.0159371607,
0.0175617859,
0.0556846298,
0.0135595771,
-0.0235267282,
0.0077853799,
0.0467263572,
-0.0317520127,
0.0242411792,
-0.0267976578,
-0.023785105,
-0.0046706987,
-0.0275920052,
-0.0873268321,
0.0122519778,
0.0489257239,
0.0426326394,
-0.0126992352,
-0.0834301859,
0.0338552296,
-0.0444654785,
-0.0479916595,
0.0498339497,
-0.0663378984,
-0.0406393744,
0.0663427785,
-0.0167538282,
-0.0673022047,
0.0507323332,
-0.0350431837,
-0.0128743472,
-0.0083381236,
-0.0128487656,
-0.0022162749,
0.0561657585,
0.0205526482,
0.0048905951,
0.0327260345,
0.0077183335,
0.0041925516,
-0.0497399718,
0.0053961091,
-0.0210330505,
0.0326473638,
-0.101448074,
0.0104562985,
0.0529165603,
-0.0255107265,
-0.0202936903,
-0.071117565,
-0.0438345708,
0.009908041,
0.0038055803,
0.0098175276,
0.0037789154,
0.0192479771,
0.0211853683,
0.0130817704,
-0.003913817,
0.0099368477,
-0.0211583395,
-0.0176241416,
0.0106736729,
-0.017178895,
0.0329505876,
-0.0468243286,
-0.0241570827,
0.0052559874,
-0.0334694646,
0.0528943278,
-0.0530425273,
0.0613619573,
-0.0060124905,
0.0075237895,
-0.0309215263,
0.0536344536,
0.0336266011,
-0.0182498135,
0.0102341706,
0.0962752402,
0.0178935099,
-0.0408337787,
0.0302566085,
-0.0018327441,
-0.0058035813,
0.0033226411,
0.0091875708,
-0.0262782015,
-0.0131443227,
-0.0116084702,
-0.0055165589,
-0.0767730325,
-0.0211353134,
-0.0478479825,
-0.0544381738,
0.0718282685,
-0.002034876,
0.0227149744,
0.0130180446,
-0.0328467824,
0.0337286368,
0.0066239457,
0.0111681623,
0.0041538863,
0.0074684937,
-0.0017278434,
0.0174350087,
-0.0522314422,
-0.0842954144,
0.0500947908,
-0.0163792875,
0.0351298898,
0.0435739197,
0.0428838283,
-0.0362500437,
-0.1041781232,
-0.0015522937,
-0.009058157,
-0.0176474359,
0.0219953917,
-0.0051845303,
0.0431065597,
0.0053174268,
-0.0594304986,
0.040503338,
-0.0217546448,
-0.0542489178,
0.0124002211,
0.0820180252,
-0.0192583762,
-0.0682552233,
-0.0006241917,
0.0495186001,
0.013704164,
0.0893417597,
0.0400056019,
-0.0472539365,
0.0001007346,
0.0288092084,
-0.0032078191,
0.0413432196,
-0.0666569918,
-0.0031224256,
0.0081006438,
0.0290228743,
-0.0696222559,
-0.0233558454,
0.0161085129,
-0.0086258473,
0.0321459956,
0.014620766,
0.0070300712,
-0.029876465,
-0.0067108986,
0.0569457375,
-0.0024347133,
0.0159241352,
-0.0612917766,
0.0104670012,
0.0401153453,
-0.0648731589,
0.0021632123,
0.0235146433,
-0.0091582024,
-0.0545581505,
0.0307136215,
-0.0201196391,
0.0295105837,
-0.0184325892,
-0.0010461578,
-0.0566223934,
0.000823803,
-0.0122500723,
-0.0385175422,
0.0642416179,
-0.0041123219,
-0.0109393885,
0.0112461522,
0.0230070315,
0.0091526788,
0.0721572787,
0.0398136973,
0.0174905714,
-0.0061315782,
-0.0443958603,
0.071873039,
0.0309277121,
0.0465436727,
-0.0223548543,
-0.0329757482,
-0.0361760817,
-0.0495940037,
-0.0293728262,
-0.0061705234,
-0.0203305408,
-0.0254853908,
0.0508790947,
0.0170439258,
-0.0686582252,
-0.0337484218,
-0.0845339224,
0.0140253156,
0.0046855537,
0.004443292,
-0.0177471023,
-0.0038829828,
-0.0157242622,
-0.0021515789,
-0.0062353341,
-0.0046953657,
-0.0983244255,
0.0438532829,
0.0264411345,
0.069718115,
-0.0005050017,
-0.029185893,
-0.0131582385,
0.0026832623,
-0.0347707197,
-0.0157408193,
0.009487343,
-0.0403972007,
0.0053150686,
-0.0370313674,
0.0638170838,
-0.0777116567,
0.0166487414,
-0.0362061337,
0.0188188069,
0.020093305,
-0.020579109,
0.011815764,
0.0274205022,
-0.0338580683,
0.0065329145,
0.0188685395,
0.0203867778,
-0.0116886497,
0.0101621961,
-0.0379747599,
-0.0391114876,
-0.0441070423,
-0.0065838057,
0.0166900586,
-0.0284263194,
0.0153636141,
-0.0927668139,
-0.0550275892,
-0.0012832537,
0.0044307453,
0.0447670035,
-0.0291731264,
-0.0099606616,
0.1060161069,
-0.0315476581,
-0.0303992704,
-0.0093266619,
-0.032202255,
0.0292030238,
0.0447959714,
-0.0445484482,
-6.23987005e-33,
0.0139297182,
-0.0421897694,
0.0064320378,
-0.0109401979,
-0.0215041488,
0.0213349834,
-0.045748733,
0.0384876728,
0.0063641947,
0.0372581892,
-0.0042177071,
0.0163318105,
0.0298501011,
0.0080826096,
-0.0079656746,
0.0429277159,
0.0281640794,
0.0296110306,
-0.0141427023,
-0.0212235097,
0.0081033902,
-0.0303705484,
0.0638977587,
-0.0548105016,
0.0864258558,
-0.0108850189,
-0.0315822177,
-0.003072659,
-0.057359878,
0.0454593152,
-0.0546291135,
0.0425668582,
0.0487329587,
0.0106009673,
0.017273007,
0.0287843272,
-0.0071806316,
0.0094397292,
0.099734135,
-0.0327145308,
-0.0357888527,
-0.0107517,
0.0193488393,
-0.0376732871,
-0.0359919928,
0.0503521413,
0.020426454,
-0.0417132564,
0.034325026,
0.0083009973,
-0.0778489187,
0.0146401543,
0.0096276328,
-0.0106962686,
0.0215645973,
0.0177400727,
-0.0597822219,
0.007151023,
-0.0267079733,
0.0348338336,
0.0139268124,
-0.0001874065,
0.0324140154,
-0.0277258512,
0.0033738846,
0.069312185,
0.0138783045,
0.0001253524,
-0.0348288193,
-0.0225601345,
0.039555382,
0.0456959158,
0.0737917647,
0.0747629628,
0.0295469146,
-0.0136609674,
-0.0307798125,
-0.0512261279,
0.0435293987,
-0.0203725491,
0.0788012147,
0.0062711933,
-0.0663331226,
-0.0562934577,
-0.0432476401,
-0.003804093,
-0.0597339869,
-0.0308643375,
0.0404682048,
-0.0175197367,
-0.0188409314,
0.00601489,
0.0089483215,
-0.010838029,
0.0344136991,
-0.023978442,
-0.0523647852,
0.0369392037,
-0.0024751485,
0.0276754871,
-0.0148648098,
0.0152352927,
0.0330887511,
0.0009517686,
0.031127315,
0.0005971853,
-0.0142365834,
-0.0004313037,
-0.0347952656,
0.0116700158,
-0.0233004857,
-0.006636411,
0.0074380198,
-0.0229203925,
0.0430808365,
0.0529301502,
-0.022164233,
-0.0217832103,
0.0157698598,
-0.0163321234,
-0.0305232219,
0.0219539553,
-0.0417518839,
0.0404805876,
-0.0235461611,
-0.0167460423,
0.0187886022,
-0.0013519113,
0.0447829328,
-0.0223664865,
-0.0034458307,
0.0231271554,
2.79e-7,
0.0031271672,
0.0687751248,
-0.0306083392,
0.0135705844,
0.0134428069,
0.0252034832,
-0.019872088,
-0.028573595,
0.045235455,
-0.0560571291,
0.0088913888,
0.016939899,
0.0602678098,
0.0217613131,
-0.0137449047,
0.0401110761,
0.0017414687,
-0.0228275433,
-0.069642745,
0.0045851534,
0.0772853792,
0.0428998508,
0.0448977388,
-0.0148882298,
-0.0044366419,
-0.0419572555,
0.0476971008,
-0.0610544011,
-0.026702676,
0.0387538001,
0.0293764416,
-0.0120724589,
0.0201537088,
0.1001299024,
0.0126534374,
0.0071787057,
0.0295114461,
0.0317697562,
-0.0029847103,
-0.0005807354,
-0.0211377889,
-0.0104948496,
-0.0110712899,
-0.0548508316,
0.0462946258,
-0.035057418,
-0.0600988753,
0.0326998048,
-0.0448213555,
-0.0361520909,
0.0305442121,
-0.0080915624,
-0.0200682245,
-0.0094457585,
0.0088931778,
0.0085672615,
-0.0233117137,
-0.0255558286,
0.0032607189,
0.0117697483,
-0.0439407192,
-0.0307838731,
-0.022103535,
-0.0018289203,
0.0220066775,
-0.1000603735,
0.0259870831,
2.593370815e-34,
0.0331752859,
0.0227163229,
0.0548809022,
-0.0405020826,
0.0641395748,
0.0596427992,
0.0186022203,
0.0333431959,
0.0262352228,
-0.0929849669,
0.0102601945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05445v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05445v2 | Accurate LoRA-Finetuning Quantization of LLMs via Information Retention | 2024-02-08T06:53:31 | 2024-05-27T09:20:35 | Haotong Qin, Xudong Ma, Xingyu Zheng, Xiaoyang Li, Yang Zhang, Shouda Liu, Jie Luo, Xianglong Liu, Michele Magno | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The LoRA-finetuning quantization of LLMs has been extensively studied to
obtain accurate yet compact LLMs for deployment on resource-constrained
hardware. However, existing methods cause the quantized LLM to severely degrade
and even fail to benefit from the finetuning of LoRA. This paper proposes a
novel IR-QLoRA for pushing quantized LLMs with LoRA to be highly accurate
through information retention. The proposed IR-QLoRA mainly relies on two
technologies derived from the perspective of unified information: (1)
statistics-based Information Calibration Quantization allows the quantized
parameters of LLM to retain original information accurately; (2)
finetuning-based Information Elastic Connection makes LoRA utilizes elastic
representation transformation with diverse information. Comprehensive
experiments show that IR-QLoRA can significantly improve accuracy across LLaMA
and LLaMA2 families under 2-4 bit-widths, e.g., 4- bit LLaMA-7B achieves 1.4%
improvement on MMLU compared with the state-of-the-art methods. The significant
performance gain requires only a tiny 0.31% additional time consumption,
revealing the satisfactory efficiency of our IR-QLoRA. We highlight that
IR-QLoRA enjoys excellent versatility, compatible with various frameworks
(e.g., NormalFloat and Integer quantization) and brings general accuracy gains.
The code is available at https://github.com/htqin/ir-qlora. | [
-0.0353551842,
0.0289305262,
0.0113253742,
0.0602920391,
-0.0010157666,
0.0076616295,
0.007820663,
-0.0043711471,
-0.0398022495,
-0.0148264216,
-0.0286771804,
0.0118920803,
0.0146240899,
-0.0143978186,
0.0193771273,
0.0271351412,
-0.0055647553,
0.0049754013,
-0.0229651146,
-0.0145138828,
-0.0101297516,
-0.0402293727,
0.0122461068,
-0.0175822116,
0.0264182184,
-0.0053822459,
-0.0304825921,
0.0702411234,
0.0249858033,
-0.0187073238,
-0.0084524276,
-0.0110334009,
0.0260853954,
-0.0475266688,
0.0000021183,
0.0382666141,
-0.0009249922,
-0.0034395785,
-0.0346476249,
0.0538016185,
0.0069125202,
-0.0197437387,
-0.042218741,
0.0247855671,
0.0189075358,
0.0357568562,
0.0442904979,
0.0025911408,
-0.0033300465,
0.0227869768,
0.039437741,
-0.0229411032,
0.0624656342,
-0.0043956428,
0.0172725115,
-0.0137708299,
-0.0052272333,
0.0282612313,
-0.001011484,
0.006571753,
-0.0126790795,
0.0085689127,
0.024135204,
-0.027419474,
-0.0103159538,
-0.0192081723,
-0.0236003287,
0.0339641683,
-0.067561008,
0.0515160859,
-0.0528366454,
-0.0347284153,
0.015318891,
-0.0179798305,
-0.059313152,
-0.0743420795,
-0.0275108498,
-0.0365044102,
0.0389087237,
0.0496774986,
-0.0408426858,
-0.0513000078,
0.0426715948,
-0.0226508193,
-0.0476768389,
0.0616716817,
0.0477324761,
0.0300568994,
-0.00331032,
-0.0330960676,
-0.0519423224,
-0.0235668272,
-0.062275406,
0.0163941551,
-0.0075427825,
-0.0269830525,
-0.0971999839,
0.0402848795,
0.0171565786,
-0.0201976839,
0.0070537138,
0.0582458042,
-0.0018282472,
-0.0148178563,
-0.0336858779,
0.0305594541,
-0.0192874353,
0.0342903733,
-0.0717783272,
0.0014577606,
0.0874985531,
0.0024334658,
0.0457975194,
0.045944497,
-0.014397026,
-0.0058769248,
-0.0542706251,
-0.0198591668,
-0.0029950016,
0.0091899494,
-0.0325818695,
0.0089108124,
-0.0357528254,
-0.0561759472,
-0.0187754296,
-0.0096021816,
0.0361154154,
0.0182927195,
0.0247439295,
-0.0629012212,
-0.0114245815,
0.0182477441,
-0.0134664355,
0.0061576264,
0.0456803702,
0.0145993568,
0.0130473403,
-0.0677265972,
-0.0073854714,
0.0351963304,
0.0139740929,
-0.0437995084,
-0.0012015379,
-0.0236031786,
0.0463250205,
-0.0147237359,
-0.0020091066,
-0.0092261424,
0.0189762954,
0.0316959284,
0.0109825386,
0.0517572239,
-0.0184541233,
-0.0473942049,
-0.0150965881,
-0.0049970043,
0.0642110705,
0.0642978624,
0.0651761144,
0.0026795098,
-0.0229507461,
0.0138935456,
-0.0378637016,
0.0214168262,
0.0348530747,
-0.0178282093,
-0.0443421192,
0.0021505319,
-0.0096611418,
0.0177704841,
0.0651077777,
0.0334463716,
0.0089827543,
-0.0527722389,
0.0001355392,
0.0269581135,
0.0671111792,
-0.0177382249,
-0.0343119241,
0.0271396637,
0.0206554011,
-0.0312530324,
-0.0687605962,
0.0949046388,
0.0101295169,
-0.0097770831,
0.0577716902,
0.0630268976,
-0.019015871,
-0.0267827176,
-0.0570579916,
-0.024774991,
-0.066812627,
-0.0148552461,
-0.0402570143,
-0.0163027495,
0.0210218001,
0.1238484457,
0.0374508165,
-0.0466967672,
-0.0389071479,
-0.0794216469,
0.0120636541,
-0.0060999743,
0.0365663841,
-0.0233496409,
-0.0275311563,
0.0265726391,
0.0026002564,
-0.0323627964,
-0.0117558781,
0.0190616827,
-0.0024828876,
-0.0182691198,
-0.0504879616,
-0.0055772848,
-0.0204857141,
0.0127703119,
0.0172194876,
-0.0154394768,
-0.0249996651,
-0.0431320816,
0.0008060118,
-0.0099663604,
0.0453465693,
-0.0270079225,
0.0610213578,
0.0066741053,
0.0134976311,
0.0466998927,
0.0206069853,
-0.0193736423,
0.0512800142,
-0.0319128595,
0.048494041,
-0.0713905767,
-0.0255581215,
0.0134141697,
0.0436721854,
-0.025366392,
0.0661046579,
0.0112840934,
-0.049394615,
-0.0275327377,
0.0228779223,
-0.026515685,
-0.0033794467,
-0.0193101559,
0.0240894295,
0.0316833146,
0.0396714509,
-0.0297143497,
-0.0114595657,
-0.0633239299,
0.0125205461,
0.0141601209,
0.0378001779,
0.0046532741,
-0.0149450712,
-0.0116145294,
-0.0080537414,
0.0467757061,
0.0011415957,
-0.0099040112,
0.009066686,
0.0251005702,
-0.0280482564,
-0.0266870521,
0.0089454511,
-0.0273577068,
0.0348850414,
0.0321030505,
0.0236005746,
0.0200513378,
0.0025929466,
-0.0286079608,
0.0154643403,
-0.0641792044,
-0.0434963852,
0.0079314932,
-0.0059588705,
-0.0370307863,
-0.0064206775,
-0.0089405468,
0.0316022933,
-0.0186465792,
-0.063831009,
-0.014754869,
-0.0753668919,
-0.0333912186,
-0.0186532326,
0.0044266395,
-0.0129198795,
-0.0208440516,
0.0068995943,
-0.0072115893,
-0.0453737304,
0.0356679037,
-0.0266177077,
-0.0214351192,
0.0735322088,
0.0385779925,
-0.0337386765,
0.0234790388,
0.0285680909,
-0.0413538925,
0.0238716546,
0.0271420665,
-0.0431393087,
0.0261560325,
-0.0331574827,
0.0077305613,
0.067596145,
0.0070698438,
0.0497122481,
-0.0034164784,
0.0138572911,
0.0559966378,
-0.0389131941,
-0.0049855676,
-0.0175554659,
-0.0289801285,
-0.0367134362,
-0.0291611049,
0.0162919946,
0.0381848477,
-0.0242359862,
-0.0138971647,
-0.0200254899,
0.010953336,
0.0287974086,
-0.0528272465,
0.0179761816,
0.0113741346,
-0.0093985246,
-0.0293557104,
-0.0530444197,
0.0414896049,
-0.0120605677,
0.0178890452,
-0.0501199663,
-0.0151320864,
0.0505479462,
0.0462752953,
0.0190392956,
-0.0118758492,
-0.0158543698,
-0.0023783923,
0.0623765662,
0.0051592649,
0.004378817,
-0.0253670644,
0.0265671257,
-0.0210509952,
-0.0602628291,
-0.0060103037,
-0.0342352279,
0.03615297,
0.0572599806,
0.064148359,
-0.014646831,
0.0119727664,
0.0247301701,
0.0687304586,
-0.0561536476,
-0.0033464185,
0.0441731662,
0.0195405819,
-0.026640363,
0.0487396792,
0.0669127256,
0.0095409965,
0.0360279679,
-0.0341025367,
-0.0144567126,
-0.0431257039,
-0.0016408712,
0.0217331555,
0.0517626032,
0.0606262796,
0.0038040911,
-0.0728308856,
-0.0361621156,
0.0348539613,
0.0242018271,
0.0136821838,
-0.0010173726,
-0.0483133979,
-0.0140963532,
0.0131885055,
0.0300540719,
0.0767831504,
-0.0610672608,
-0.0033633364,
-0.0061340802,
0.026092574,
0.092612192,
0.0652835518,
-0.0212616958,
0.0064072381,
0.0023997761,
-0.0451386347,
-0.0118706413,
-0.0215122309,
-0.0003433944,
0.0281609986,
0.0368981808,
-0.0023390914,
-0.0124330008,
-0.0159201901,
-0.0089069046,
0.0244375952,
-0.0183231179,
0.0001816195,
-0.0666769445,
0.0464779809,
-0.0468519516,
-0.0065356684,
0.0021281675,
0.0242881645,
0.0170741454,
-0.0390841737,
0.0035346453,
-0.0386483707,
0.0268791504,
0.0544518195,
-0.0779600888,
-0.0162632652,
0.0009798927,
-0.0160566736,
0.0468928069,
-0.0399714261,
-0.045275636,
-0.0201611556,
0.0149233649,
0.0031732174,
0.0017349137,
-0.0067740073,
-0.0089064538,
0.0400317386,
0.0138815222,
-0.0069631208,
0.005982907,
0.027043622,
-0.0329368114,
0.0174690895,
-0.0349134691,
-0.0906942561,
-0.040506918,
-0.0693138912,
0.0200066641,
-0.0041837175,
0.0395492576,
0.0049832109,
-0.0211714543,
0.0275617782,
-0.0030005961,
-0.107440494,
-0.0101201283,
0.0068351091,
0.0489700846,
0.0115667321,
0.022730248,
0.0529275499,
-0.0281075519,
0.0591751747,
0.0670580566,
-0.0214734338,
0.0958214998,
-0.0446425639,
0.0472307205,
0.0149551183,
0.0185014345,
-0.0318364836,
-0.0109199854,
0.0512776338,
0.0634972453,
-0.0292341299,
-0.0777056292,
-0.0310390294,
0.0267229583,
0.0212270524,
0.0192484651,
-0.0086941132,
0.047576271,
0.0755555853,
-0.0411009863,
0.0502713397,
-0.0121413795,
-0.0286591928,
-0.0028836057,
-0.0589485951,
-0.014456409,
-0.002889744,
0.0472665727,
-0.0329399109,
0.046992071,
-0.0256151315,
-0.0675546899,
0.0318373851,
0.006686266,
-0.0267506596,
-0.0038521204,
0.0112900613,
0.0042842273,
0.0678762496,
-0.0354718566,
0.0021798245,
-0.0408015437,
0.0055365716,
-0.0383761488,
0.0375708565,
0.0436643399,
-0.0485910326,
-0.0662281662,
0.0016390159,
0.0580861941,
0.0942353085,
0.0441706218,
0.0256295912,
0.007825112,
0.0137682017,
0.0505339988,
0.0167205743,
0.0536536574,
0.03220433,
-0.030147288,
-0.0024338479,
-0.0069891289,
-0.0650206879,
-0.0350446925,
0.0218193345,
-0.0577974655,
0.0702587888,
0.0342296436,
-0.0161994621,
-0.0284568891,
-0.008004223,
0.0279575791,
-0.0531615503,
0.0164535604,
0.036200922,
0.0710388124,
0.010037289,
-0.0130203282,
-0.0756903365,
0.0086714635,
0.0258071758,
0.0157691799,
-0.022377545,
0.0158078559,
-0.0934682712,
0.0250630546,
0.0063428902,
0.0280586444,
-5.949884778e-33,
-0.0673054084,
0.0334605649,
0.0458101369,
0.0303097516,
0.0109246355,
0.0172250122,
0.034268789,
-0.0133546432,
-0.0163927581,
-0.0542601049,
0.0024235959,
-0.0160241816,
0.0218883082,
-0.0391032696,
-0.0149638122,
-0.0113351895,
0.0224308558,
-0.0077304323,
-0.0246717744,
-0.0024039026,
-0.0216815416,
0.0142690055,
0.0247619096,
-0.0021982118,
-0.0388407148,
0.0213383604,
0.0253242776,
-0.0209007319,
-0.0100064222,
-0.0092384731,
-0.0536310598,
0.0028524094,
-0.0240852833,
0.0425855219,
0.0091121746,
-0.0075699301,
-0.0677737072,
-0.0350885093,
0.0134963058,
0.00630457,
0.053517051,
-0.0614536814,
0.0472000539,
0.0727528855,
-0.1013856083,
-0.0339007191,
-0.025602527,
0.0405758806,
-0.0223525595,
-0.0583181009,
0.0309925769,
-0.0126732197,
0.0338635072,
0.0476119593,
0.0006937167,
-0.1019363105,
-0.0771043673,
-0.0058475551,
-0.0772370622,
-0.0325812288,
0.0326677933,
0.0522715598,
0.0300051551,
0.0024095792,
-0.0020076148,
0.0791428462,
0.0139224473,
-0.0229382217,
0.0117274635,
0.0607855618,
0.0007364958,
0.0178815629,
-0.0338012241,
0.0456417203,
0.0745204017,
-0.0002310679,
-0.0350968204,
0.0235360749,
0.0020814994,
0.0529600866,
-0.0104678338,
0.0218743384,
-0.0211988725,
-0.0129890088,
0.0245828461,
0.0393153504,
-0.0275350157,
-0.0348438025,
-0.0169506501,
0.022630319,
-0.0366481245,
-0.0110425847,
-0.0259702709,
-0.0152073093,
0.0040260255,
-0.0664234236,
0.0410134941,
-0.0091053378,
-0.0048964559,
0.0067239436,
0.0106229614,
-0.030909352,
-0.0149086798,
-0.0475650802,
0.0277661327,
0.0141340196,
-0.0084979441,
0.0872443542,
-0.0726834685,
-0.025045855,
-0.0197005756,
-0.0201404281,
0.0077584954,
-0.064335227,
-0.0030524707,
-0.0192145687,
0.0014162085,
0.0186528936,
-0.0648913011,
-0.0265718736,
0.0290170368,
-0.0202111192,
0.0399245434,
0.0714207962,
-0.0489452556,
0.0105883228,
-0.0179072246,
-0.0070892917,
0.0085696457,
-0.0454216376,
-0.0363183282,
0.0133405337,
3.026e-7,
0.0151124755,
0.0054989969,
0.0237149801,
0.020745812,
-0.0263101049,
-0.0345706418,
0.0145900026,
0.0334037803,
-0.0067580068,
-0.0376482457,
-0.0234791879,
0.007829532,
-0.0032589131,
-0.0511046648,
-0.0004724754,
0.0354658477,
0.067510739,
-0.0049242396,
0.0151376165,
-0.0523992181,
0.0237896126,
0.0642246827,
0.005307572,
-0.016538199,
0.0222211592,
-0.014937426,
0.0141337812,
0.0205178075,
0.0056708814,
0.0239244439,
0.0569328777,
-0.0461991616,
-0.0402334891,
-0.0101275127,
0.0545265786,
-0.0030848447,
-0.0639334172,
0.0662678778,
0.0081098778,
-0.0566288754,
-0.014899753,
-0.0347242951,
-0.0284367204,
0.0319747962,
0.0347032994,
0.0620531105,
-0.0069346065,
-0.0665386543,
-0.0217431337,
-0.021090284,
-0.0019144031,
-0.008125836,
0.0821061283,
-0.0177008659,
-0.0064501967,
-0.0085511804,
0.0209134426,
-0.0358835496,
-0.0314086564,
0.0624714047,
0.0176644213,
-0.0253115389,
0.0011292814,
-0.0151606826,
-0.0087275961,
-0.0449936204,
-0.018715376,
2.64418087e-34,
-0.0115583073,
-0.0047710836,
0.0415024497,
0.0602897182,
-0.0297510717,
-0.0157854259,
-0.0336462781,
-0.0109281745,
-0.0447987951,
-0.0247050617,
0.0142343035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05440v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05440v1 | Improving Agent Interactions in Virtual Environments with Language Models | 2024-02-08T06:34:11 | 2024-02-08T06:34:11 | Jack Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Enhancing AI systems with efficient communication skills for effective human
assistance necessitates proactive initiatives from the system side to discern
specific circumstances and interact aptly. This research focuses on a
collective building assignment in the Minecraft dataset, employing language
modeling to enhance task understanding through state-of-the-art methods. These
models focus on grounding multi-modal understanding and task-oriented dialogue
comprehension tasks, providing insights into their interpretative and
responsive capabilities. Our experimental results showcase a substantial
improvement over existing methods, indicating a promising direction for future
research in this domain. | [
0.0140928319,
-0.0070262654,
-0.0475201942,
0.038646169,
-0.0076645864,
-0.0023576911,
0.0050198226,
-0.0104198148,
-0.0061397636,
-0.0189360976,
-0.0358500779,
-0.0245808419,
-0.0123812091,
0.0338567793,
-0.0052736667,
-0.020843355,
0.0427450091,
-0.0476692021,
-0.000919165,
-0.0015362337,
-0.018609805,
0.0106508117,
-0.0459687077,
0.0721472576,
0.0285271015,
-0.0297779404,
-0.0591873191,
-0.0087882634,
0.036111597,
-0.0317950882,
-0.0492624082,
-0.0054160813,
0.0464537144,
-0.0132803768,
0.0000018946,
-0.0228392482,
0.0044776225,
-0.0283393692,
-0.0325008631,
-0.0475245528,
0.0004737701,
-0.0250094309,
-0.0035751066,
-0.0053609908,
-0.055329565,
-0.0308448933,
0.0740382448,
0.0194148086,
0.0548421368,
0.0113304602,
-0.0044041728,
0.0257522669,
-0.0364588946,
0.0125370352,
0.0000826378,
-0.0603076741,
0.0105962018,
0.0763327628,
0.0399751626,
0.0070824665,
-0.0196856633,
0.0114538148,
-0.0106337257,
-0.0173717961,
-0.0035998893,
0.0322602727,
-0.009995047,
-0.0041801254,
-0.0293197148,
0.081565313,
0.0356964096,
0.0056213178,
0.0331653133,
0.0099658221,
-0.0010060458,
0.0336802229,
-0.0506486073,
0.0342826694,
-0.0400313102,
-0.0176354423,
-0.0008667524,
0.0252552256,
-0.0045700315,
0.0192689802,
0.0270009693,
0.0677626878,
-0.0356033705,
0.0023547031,
-0.0878023952,
-0.0288440771,
-0.0150523977,
-0.0395683572,
-0.0149032837,
0.0467531681,
-0.0665870085,
0.0328394845,
-0.0172987878,
0.0218548216,
-0.0031286266,
-0.0386339426,
0.0539279468,
0.058506839,
-0.0013193547,
0.0715621933,
0.0164826754,
0.0408808403,
0.0224005822,
0.0130795194,
-0.0300106853,
0.0021145463,
-0.07886222,
0.0059929043,
-0.0405792519,
0.0217605513,
-0.0525348596,
-0.0077122711,
0.0328822061,
0.0616845973,
-0.0342964679,
0.0171647035,
-0.0193069652,
-0.0049678339,
-0.0592868514,
-0.006711618,
-0.018884033,
-0.0121054333,
-0.0410968959,
0.0341345742,
-0.0439121947,
-0.0842806846,
-0.0090706078,
0.0291406959,
0.0119914403,
-0.0028795304,
-0.0278881676,
0.065128468,
0.0285853967,
-0.0115806423,
0.0117316227,
-0.0300032832,
0.0281453803,
-0.0420638472,
-0.0110364901,
-0.0341842584,
0.0276360773,
-0.0020067838,
-0.0093670059,
-0.0023335179,
0.0126502477,
-0.0195485912,
-0.0275515039,
0.104178533,
-0.0395997539,
0.0479507595,
0.0316845812,
0.0283297189,
0.0003829594,
0.0536426157,
0.0222951453,
0.0092335064,
0.004905507,
0.0190333799,
0.0353997275,
0.0101244403,
-0.0367248319,
-0.0210774578,
0.0194353051,
0.001529736,
-0.0098003699,
0.030495083,
0.0010118758,
0.0177353844,
-0.0136318477,
0.0053139911,
0.0716305152,
0.0575602502,
-0.0519130006,
0.0195709299,
0.0696680993,
0.0816061124,
-0.0241663847,
-0.037005987,
-0.0402813517,
0.0341788121,
0.0299670137,
-0.0329871364,
-0.022431355,
0.0316913389,
-0.0048903101,
-0.0590794906,
0.0031989187,
0.0001121127,
0.0567260087,
0.0200894773,
0.0395943634,
-0.0129617909,
-0.0330923162,
-0.0198794771,
0.0106041878,
-0.0398035124,
0.0076536979,
-0.0689993948,
0.0371152051,
0.069059968,
0.0295134969,
-0.0340296105,
-0.047699783,
-0.0205137301,
0.0288730171,
0.0112233097,
0.0136615625,
-0.0289588235,
0.058012791,
-0.0259155463,
-0.0403568856,
-0.0061277533,
0.0095101651,
0.0684778318,
-0.0411096998,
-0.0625469685,
-0.0109766731,
-0.0357475244,
0.0011572241,
0.0272051599,
0.0293693617,
0.0222660266,
-0.0657506734,
0.0128937354,
0.0067990343,
0.0139513817,
-0.022068182,
-0.0454053022,
0.0266542379,
-0.0141039034,
-0.0219209064,
0.0747687593,
-0.0107685579,
-0.037794359,
0.0213443078,
-0.0048563005,
0.0064932276,
0.0150804296,
-0.0054692123,
-0.0133110303,
0.0440426618,
-0.0422665365,
0.036397703,
0.001367011,
0.000993701,
-0.0318553932,
-0.0028533782,
-0.0497718006,
0.0464172997,
-0.01124465,
-0.0163984913,
0.0378864557,
0.0043179309,
0.0322797298,
-0.0311303921,
0.0295338612,
0.040315859,
-0.0135332057,
0.004616234,
0.0375909097,
0.0095967473,
-0.0368569419,
0.022928616,
-0.0867313892,
-0.0627549961,
-0.0292000584,
0.0097923018,
0.0293838512,
-0.0252184402,
-0.016673848,
-0.0081745507,
0.0077927876,
0.0353121497,
0.0299682636,
-0.012852611,
0.043413952,
0.0183914602,
-0.048125647,
-0.0243656971,
0.0157579053,
-0.0209866818,
0.0030360448,
0.0370884202,
-0.0268817432,
-0.0616859086,
0.0506344065,
-0.0199522804,
0.0053323046,
-0.0417059921,
-0.0620936528,
0.0268043559,
-0.0114495018,
0.0438819863,
0.0360220373,
-0.0358016901,
0.0640997291,
0.0693053082,
-0.0418368243,
-0.0493298732,
0.0328885429,
0.0064351242,
-0.0018106882,
-0.059432622,
-0.029800456,
0.0202405248,
0.0775159746,
-0.0061931219,
-0.0011945553,
-0.0514170118,
0.0462637171,
0.0031046683,
-0.0486346222,
0.0178212132,
-0.0292391777,
-0.0016248754,
0.0632356107,
-0.0386169851,
-0.0061206813,
0.0660458878,
-0.0209957678,
-0.0590319075,
-0.0307106059,
0.0029630484,
-0.0011182829,
0.0638426244,
0.0129304202,
0.0287854299,
0.0274154432,
-0.0108297421,
-0.0369926691,
-0.0321939923,
0.0161965527,
-0.0058601503,
0.0151061052,
-0.0873950496,
-0.0021993283,
0.0093726078,
-0.0110568209,
-0.0217517391,
0.0268044677,
-0.0082588531,
0.0097004203,
-0.0050552902,
-0.0186414532,
-0.0389949866,
0.0325029045,
0.0476025753,
-0.0171413217,
0.0092174234,
-0.030284794,
-0.059698768,
-0.021468142,
0.0437142588,
0.0844068006,
-0.0117672868,
-0.0170737784,
0.069667764,
0.0444726795,
0.0316190831,
-0.0334570669,
-0.012359946,
0.0119851287,
0.0358679891,
0.0021040717,
-0.0090782233,
0.0501284972,
0.0538432784,
-0.0507658981,
-0.0278670471,
0.0619651414,
0.0222472884,
-0.0024480743,
0.005929695,
-0.0618957803,
-0.0046158601,
0.0330282263,
0.0097477296,
-0.0020648586,
-0.023698952,
0.0081461994,
-0.0138371671,
0.0002995856,
-0.0593872257,
0.0146816233,
-0.0780921355,
0.0504329167,
-0.0341400839,
-0.0358357169,
-0.0345986672,
-0.0195644274,
0.0494337678,
-0.0056403498,
-0.0358755626,
-0.0371709429,
0.047613427,
0.0063070166,
0.0323903337,
0.0017426872,
-0.0173358545,
0.0243795738,
-0.0650839508,
0.1406477094,
0.069155097,
0.0608659275,
0.0047293999,
-0.0087775281,
-0.0371144041,
0.0476326682,
0.0174504295,
-0.0214112718,
0.0088691637,
0.00166592,
0.0098198624,
0.0369057246,
-0.0185040776,
-0.0446727276,
-0.0240391493,
0.0211516004,
0.0452564582,
-0.0466223732,
0.0315661505,
-0.0130163981,
0.0620582104,
0.0711737797,
0.0489823967,
0.0217396915,
-0.0170254204,
-0.0171594154,
-0.0400855802,
-0.0081913183,
-0.0203741714,
-0.0478959717,
-0.0265313145,
-0.0021458431,
0.0121798562,
-0.0580680706,
-0.104444325,
0.0360690169,
0.0273616519,
0.0023294457,
-0.0006346687,
-0.0007569522,
0.0361675024,
0.0018843745,
0.0293889064,
-0.0144212758,
0.0268019494,
-0.003727793,
-0.0142181236,
0.0221521892,
-0.0885639563,
0.0027824452,
0.0286948532,
-0.0370852947,
-0.0300282557,
0.0295347385,
0.0480992198,
0.0180450249,
0.0301587246,
0.0095392214,
-0.0169674065,
-0.0449381545,
-0.03105882,
-0.0569905862,
-0.0062246695,
0.0238609761,
0.0485738702,
0.025548296,
0.0286201481,
-0.0191719308,
0.0686277598,
0.017067628,
0.0751793161,
-0.0501862951,
-0.0436374843,
0.0241459087,
-0.0225649364,
0.0111641912,
0.0176221244,
-0.0147201912,
-0.004159675,
-0.0043699904,
-0.0376353823,
0.0020202829,
-0.0652389899,
0.025116615,
-0.0203937702,
-0.0164962746,
0.0508668832,
0.037156038,
-0.043738056,
0.0285218693,
0.0390878394,
0.0464938432,
-0.0244272202,
-0.0030192889,
-0.0017760346,
0.0474645272,
0.0272967592,
0.0252221525,
0.0237613339,
0.059103407,
0.0351051912,
0.0565628484,
0.0260699634,
-0.0609037355,
-0.0373796038,
0.0519526117,
-0.0285485871,
-0.0673387721,
0.0647356063,
0.0372662395,
0.0383995585,
0.0370989665,
0.038681861,
-0.022496881,
0.0451882035,
0.0076144864,
0.0270080492,
0.0602673888,
-0.0590627901,
0.0211446732,
0.0629595444,
-0.0270394757,
-0.0232235044,
0.0215617083,
-0.005780363,
0.0254040156,
-0.0157472994,
-0.0232546516,
-0.0365418717,
-0.0021883834,
0.0137004601,
0.0501602516,
-0.0520465784,
0.0478819236,
-0.0596118607,
-0.0292137135,
-0.034384992,
0.0663835928,
0.0170127954,
-0.0569574013,
0.018328784,
0.0660312548,
0.010973922,
-0.0603954159,
-0.0613334589,
-0.0269234274,
-0.0312582627,
0.0292780586,
-0.0598920323,
-5.024264159e-33,
-0.0509834923,
-0.0568117425,
0.0543599091,
-0.0072835181,
-0.0037246936,
-0.0150587689,
-0.0561485514,
0.0170828607,
-0.0480988808,
-0.0012260554,
-0.0030994648,
0.0363737009,
0.0107550034,
-0.0083665214,
0.0077749169,
-0.0022160944,
0.0471335426,
0.0055111288,
-0.0342925638,
0.0203904305,
-0.0033158697,
-0.0107942838,
0.0412435122,
-0.0921421871,
0.0433671251,
0.0172555801,
-0.0035381045,
0.0238955375,
0.0138471555,
0.0183635224,
-0.0210083295,
0.0191936046,
0.0492136143,
-0.0365831219,
-0.0113689611,
-0.0062365001,
-0.0440432169,
0.0231863298,
0.0243557319,
0.0005250952,
-0.0298575647,
-0.0173457377,
-0.023511285,
0.012477668,
0.0029948135,
-0.0036599722,
0.0657979026,
-0.0274715945,
-0.0086876079,
0.0611958131,
-0.1112122461,
0.0103623299,
-0.0616991036,
-0.0626586005,
0.0476369336,
0.0524988994,
-0.0024909154,
0.0059341257,
-0.0694766715,
0.0345636979,
-0.0257498864,
-0.02263036,
0.0570418127,
0.0427566208,
-0.0058011762,
0.0293217152,
0.0423950329,
0.0432065316,
-0.0437636748,
-0.0193960872,
0.0116734803,
0.057264924,
-0.0181327164,
0.0709422752,
-0.019377457,
0.0508266836,
-0.0326019749,
0.0384754241,
0.0137006864,
0.0653022304,
0.0431235656,
0.0180112049,
-0.0575454868,
0.0090527683,
-0.0263838749,
-0.0116995834,
0.0048431484,
-0.0408955477,
0.0134964362,
-0.0208952483,
-0.0278607719,
-0.0418212898,
0.0581751503,
-0.0467400886,
-0.001047757,
0.0073565468,
-0.0224919338,
0.0172167476,
-0.0266663861,
0.0273834858,
-0.0164885279,
-0.0218363889,
0.0159161352,
0.0267177317,
0.0166771878,
-0.0054155686,
-0.0447681285,
0.036742758,
0.0085453708,
-0.0240682568,
-0.0364693478,
-0.0140403379,
-0.0115317814,
0.0202972274,
0.0284178052,
-0.0490916073,
-0.0215141084,
0.0048034764,
0.030002242,
-0.0751067474,
-0.012218737,
-0.0273603387,
-0.0571321212,
-0.0025884705,
-0.0493626818,
-0.0438007824,
-0.07274542,
-0.025882395,
0.0424191877,
-0.0202796012,
-0.0344149731,
-0.02755481,
2.734e-7,
-0.0223352108,
0.0422255136,
0.0066579655,
0.0093076415,
-0.0250834581,
0.066820465,
-0.0230853334,
0.0144078359,
-0.0009957788,
-0.0248908363,
0.0440430567,
0.0606806502,
0.0245137848,
-0.0295283832,
-0.0512225032,
0.0180091951,
-0.0001693697,
-0.0201236997,
-0.0483067743,
0.0334086753,
0.0555379055,
0.0126863709,
-0.0056870207,
0.0122449286,
0.013559428,
-0.0306266714,
-0.0162824057,
-0.0614616498,
0.0011089257,
0.0531212464,
0.0155743463,
-0.0176318362,
-0.0413720794,
0.0021084836,
0.0229201354,
0.0126891835,
0.0107469829,
0.0309465155,
-0.0246614106,
0.0158687904,
-0.0296593644,
-0.0340657756,
0.0191524066,
-0.0097569572,
0.0179928597,
-0.0674637631,
-0.054590527,
0.0048917425,
0.0178037826,
-0.0039970302,
-0.0792310983,
0.015860375,
-0.0329858884,
-0.0171455238,
-0.0082987826,
-0.0378632359,
-0.0178729557,
-0.0527697578,
0.0061928337,
-0.0256081875,
-0.074783735,
-0.0479837693,
-0.0184127111,
-0.040623568,
0.0040611443,
-0.0016748101,
-0.0078842416,
2.043546419e-34,
-0.0259054136,
0.0225047786,
-0.0071444483,
0.0611569211,
0.0552064702,
0.0014901294,
-0.0128366444,
0.0167949274,
0.0260427054,
-0.0522340797,
0.0037143268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05435v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05435v1 | GPT-4 Generated Narratives of Life Events using a Structured Narrative Prompt: A Validation Study | 2024-02-08T06:20:01 | 2024-02-08T06:20:01 | Christopher J. Lynch, Erik Jensen, Madison H. Munro, Virginia Zamponi, Joseph Martinez, Kevin O'Brien, Brandon Feldhaus, Katherine Smith, Ann Marie Reinhold, Ross Gore | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.6.4 | Large Language Models (LLMs) play a pivotal role in generating vast arrays of
narratives, facilitating a systematic exploration of their effectiveness for
communicating life events in narrative form. In this study, we employ a
zero-shot structured narrative prompt to generate 24,000 narratives using
OpenAI's GPT-4. From this dataset, we manually classify 2,880 narratives and
evaluate their validity in conveying birth, death, hiring, and firing events.
Remarkably, 87.43% of the narratives sufficiently convey the intention of the
structured prompt. To automate the identification of valid and invalid
narratives, we train and validate nine Machine Learning models on the
classified datasets. Leveraging these models, we extend our analysis to predict
the classifications of the remaining 21,120 narratives. All the ML models
excelled at classifying valid narratives as valid, but experienced challenges
at simultaneously classifying invalid narratives as invalid. Our findings not
only advance the study of LLM capabilities, limitations, and validity but also
offer practical insights for narrative generation and natural language
processing applications. | [
0.0392211452,
0.0817229152,
-0.0367442518,
-0.0028716498,
-0.0406505354,
-0.0042878995,
0.0365292318,
-0.0073265135,
0.0171703175,
-0.0136523228,
0.0650945157,
-0.0365179218,
0.0100649949,
0.0739490986,
-0.0622724034,
-0.0941789374,
0.0085021704,
0.01667789,
0.0637063012,
0.0356657691,
-0.0451778807,
0.0974415615,
-0.007880955,
0.0698507577,
-0.0353742912,
-0.0172604993,
0.0006020262,
0.0166566893,
0.0411977544,
-0.0414975174,
0.0071668392,
0.0203289092,
0.0319158472,
0.0324840583,
0.0000020333,
-0.0425077379,
0.0322761498,
-0.0323570184,
-0.0233461466,
-0.0143845454,
0.0422009118,
-0.025619803,
-0.0001500819,
-0.0037983188,
-0.0120836888,
-0.0443471707,
0.0440665148,
0.0834587514,
0.0090329675,
0.0885187835,
-0.0231916849,
-0.0678159818,
0.0327130966,
-0.0210759882,
0.0101666497,
0.0100760031,
-0.0003318811,
-0.0145716835,
0.0365061872,
-0.0364507623,
-0.0128262406,
0.0126406206,
0.0205529016,
0.01982948,
-0.008330158,
0.0899351165,
0.0165771358,
-0.0084745931,
-0.0075811236,
0.0377054997,
0.0231913868,
-0.0138606075,
0.0082940906,
-0.039913293,
0.0069166864,
-0.0273688585,
-0.032506533,
0.0692874491,
-0.0125995325,
0.0204379726,
0.0093561653,
0.0429153107,
0.0110037914,
0.0111396499,
0.0345357843,
0.018417079,
0.0191519968,
0.0040189372,
-0.0340164229,
-0.0173228383,
0.0220502876,
-0.0783038214,
0.0131602138,
0.0299011748,
-0.0031435592,
0.0203823391,
-0.0740405992,
0.0570498295,
-0.0010076736,
-0.0541457534,
0.0393917747,
0.0310899802,
-0.0178032648,
-0.002092741,
0.0075405613,
0.0073403842,
0.040801622,
-0.0346855558,
-0.0220318604,
0.0356239453,
-0.0457751639,
0.01484947,
-0.0343115479,
0.0250927191,
-0.0231220219,
-0.0322877765,
-0.0328862593,
0.0120562129,
0.0203504171,
-0.0111208633,
-0.0296530928,
0.0163474008,
-0.0315276422,
0.0100030825,
-0.0633537024,
0.010169656,
-0.0524412282,
-0.0133032156,
0.0040384838,
-0.0269671176,
0.0170494523,
0.0150749637,
0.026787255,
-0.0163116995,
-0.0040544053,
0.0307687726,
0.0157627501,
-0.008300826,
-0.1013853103,
-0.0432288088,
-0.0079680132,
-0.0750896633,
-0.0468619838,
-0.0251607373,
0.0325626954,
-0.0113585014,
0.0181886721,
-0.0527449101,
0.0442427173,
0.0044262148,
-0.0246165525,
0.0263717677,
-0.0114925066,
0.0267402977,
0.0288097244,
0.0129817212,
0.0354565755,
0.0212112032,
0.0874236077,
0.0456018634,
0.0276535321,
-0.0051490767,
0.0559623614,
0.0067621781,
-0.038167391,
-0.0119472882,
0.001071,
-0.021976579,
-0.0099008009,
0.0850452781,
0.0087618344,
0.0212628804,
-0.0086532524,
0.0286578014,
0.0646186769,
0.080571495,
-0.0147128785,
0.0154316137,
0.0847787783,
0.0066455267,
0.0112055736,
0.0085976738,
-0.0341756754,
-0.0058400342,
0.0169659629,
-0.0062038777,
-0.0256417673,
-0.0057450933,
-0.0352546684,
-0.0285924058,
-0.0136139188,
-0.0280750245,
0.0017955955,
-0.0165435225,
0.0041565886,
-0.0055189561,
-0.0544227138,
0.0176257882,
0.0147224385,
-0.1090921462,
-0.0039582909,
-0.0080979336,
0.0381926522,
0.107366465,
0.0463298,
-0.0112361703,
-0.0612441339,
-0.0365387872,
0.0145486817,
0.0302306172,
0.0295926239,
0.0152847907,
0.018947931,
-0.0447997078,
0.032325536,
0.0042537646,
0.0313878022,
0.0096986387,
0.0139411539,
0.0120485062,
0.0188003983,
0.0264750179,
-0.0581941828,
0.0428189784,
-0.060995996,
-0.0732548013,
0.0244231168,
0.0065573738,
-0.0178167075,
-0.0085777976,
-0.0042853709,
-0.0262230355,
0.0361228362,
-0.0025378182,
-0.0070129572,
0.0761553869,
-0.0891404971,
-0.0186671726,
-0.0116062257,
-0.029256247,
-0.0421989374,
-0.0077483519,
-0.0150404647,
-0.0442099683,
0.0001601991,
-0.0217949171,
0.0042355368,
-0.0335214399,
-0.0009665294,
-0.000662786,
-0.0217668433,
-0.0067096525,
0.0798406303,
0.0221479982,
-0.0049303244,
-0.044396311,
0.000484375,
0.0155121274,
-0.0891747251,
0.0031259093,
0.0183887649,
0.0188323762,
0.0011696703,
0.0192019511,
-0.0134447273,
-0.0106799761,
-0.026549397,
-0.1220607087,
0.0266925115,
-0.0044028964,
-0.0143696759,
0.0158036724,
-0.0109894266,
-0.0439673886,
-0.0048741926,
-0.0652045608,
0.0013323965,
0.0312056225,
-0.0299662258,
0.0141373994,
0.0213518701,
-0.0088585196,
-0.0259749778,
0.0158085283,
-0.0615867227,
0.056593772,
0.0600616932,
0.0019138602,
-0.0448584743,
0.022472756,
-0.0175622944,
0.0128578115,
0.003964968,
0.0042891768,
0.0241944324,
-0.0010370681,
0.0511991493,
0.034141995,
-0.007843378,
0.0644792467,
0.0263253152,
-0.0190974977,
0.0154523021,
0.0159450434,
-0.025682427,
0.0134492414,
-0.0227244124,
-0.0533583611,
-0.0252202153,
0.0259312745,
0.0318722837,
-0.0002110335,
-0.0718884468,
0.0043183179,
-0.006850733,
0.0343758874,
0.0182557628,
-0.033140406,
-0.0211008526,
0.0586323626,
0.0030259974,
-0.0258625001,
0.0571058355,
0.0069506359,
0.0161360949,
-0.0013951526,
-0.0200805366,
-0.0484151579,
0.1424911618,
0.0022296377,
0.0303787533,
0.0488399528,
-0.0186326336,
-0.0129783489,
0.010894197,
-0.0166084282,
-0.0154114384,
0.0326707512,
-0.0839909986,
-0.0315597244,
0.0270001553,
-0.0154242469,
-0.0665626898,
-0.0554323718,
-0.0241348054,
0.0109019978,
-0.0171463471,
0.0034905006,
-0.0447932258,
-0.0124877645,
-0.0302194301,
0.0279692393,
-0.0190902092,
-0.0211597644,
-0.0456544235,
0.0398442633,
0.0776187107,
-0.0311144441,
-0.0020530731,
-0.0201129653,
0.0437342376,
-0.0104561606,
-0.0014929178,
0.0601774268,
-0.0086654294,
-0.0131479418,
0.012135285,
-0.0539237075,
0.0059097083,
0.0462185964,
0.0158442315,
-0.0610530116,
-0.0128469821,
0.1274743527,
0.0292644128,
-0.0293349512,
0.018678762,
0.0180122443,
-0.0164783597,
0.0075955261,
0.0102783749,
-0.0903897285,
-0.0037957462,
-0.0013715094,
0.0048030228,
-0.0275941975,
-0.0296098422,
-0.0022232968,
-0.0986400694,
0.0621372685,
0.0151722478,
-0.0074512647,
-0.0286034029,
0.0005764329,
-0.0353431329,
-0.0026813089,
0.0068988628,
-0.0017131749,
-0.0351740643,
-0.018849168,
-0.0287404787,
-0.0386449732,
-0.0649333224,
0.0633363202,
-0.0406167805,
0.0574215353,
0.046276927,
0.0725096613,
-0.0028634283,
-0.0093400022,
-0.0275951494,
0.0225931518,
-0.0042659957,
0.0323760211,
0.0415429026,
-0.0184085108,
0.0001378083,
-0.0629039705,
0.0632889718,
-0.0008400913,
-0.0269420333,
0.0297871251,
0.0802562237,
-0.0200165324,
-0.0693735555,
-0.0025122943,
0.0151200565,
0.0160021037,
0.0778819993,
0.0099445079,
-0.067730695,
-0.0349228978,
-0.0074928557,
0.0415879823,
-0.0109590087,
-0.0301825926,
0.010738221,
-0.0316745378,
-0.006595429,
-0.0429936983,
-0.0708346516,
0.0243126247,
0.0101269521,
0.0522443876,
-0.0363724455,
0.0114878025,
0.0076952833,
-0.0620065741,
0.0350873396,
-0.0631550252,
0.0199198686,
-0.0296512824,
-0.012210492,
0.0210999567,
-0.0374832861,
0.0159682073,
0.0266472474,
-0.0548744611,
-0.0270887557,
-0.0033752248,
0.0123846009,
0.0247303564,
0.0183702484,
-0.0019892461,
-0.0338220857,
0.008669165,
0.0175829045,
-0.0248051081,
0.0145688932,
-0.0229254644,
0.0600821041,
0.0028930169,
-0.006676164,
-0.0137934545,
0.0097655039,
-0.0303914305,
0.015671378,
-0.0056823967,
-0.0451584384,
0.0023827029,
0.001572267,
0.0108013069,
-0.0529862456,
-0.0456129126,
-0.0708870143,
-0.0262580812,
-0.0386335514,
-0.0108399726,
-0.0138341216,
-0.0033793997,
0.070911929,
0.0433027223,
-0.0284981001,
-0.0572096705,
-0.0580156036,
-0.014415984,
-0.0866514221,
-0.0396956541,
0.039502874,
0.0242964979,
-0.006650276,
-0.0058053331,
-0.0421320423,
0.0290219393,
-0.0417447798,
0.0258102864,
-0.0199682433,
0.0435506776,
-0.0070291427,
0.0078228209,
0.0209090877,
-0.0060726088,
-0.0308118425,
-0.0124398125,
-0.0268711727,
0.0119101033,
0.0683876127,
-0.041461125,
0.0156551506,
-0.0648671389,
0.0288095623,
-0.0019501654,
0.0144633669,
0.0477178246,
-0.0044232151,
-0.042022258,
0.0042336741,
-0.0377900042,
0.0005298692,
0.0272254497,
0.0233574342,
0.0749545097,
0.0324947238,
-0.016502047,
-0.0201232694,
-0.015209768,
0.0397021174,
0.0402063914,
-0.0171188116,
-0.0147071062,
-0.0926370025,
0.0087383129,
0.0405008979,
0.0224347729,
0.0195426811,
-0.0350751691,
0.0125891883,
0.0003709045,
-0.0097779827,
-0.0217437074,
-0.0603757687,
0.003531442,
-0.0046390565,
-0.0050200159,
-0.0524121411,
-5.806853931e-33,
-0.0434489474,
-0.0293050148,
-0.0062309839,
0.0304859132,
-0.0454305708,
0.00521946,
-0.0419183411,
0.0077162758,
0.0154196154,
0.0369316861,
0.0137906671,
-0.0021106785,
0.0119546913,
0.0157022104,
0.0317419693,
0.0047471696,
0.0300424416,
0.0067365649,
-0.0266666617,
0.0367475934,
0.023103131,
0.0169338379,
0.0254621468,
-0.0639510229,
0.0429645889,
-0.029496761,
-0.0367021374,
0.0066390126,
-0.0055858153,
0.0290837064,
-0.0437949859,
0.040327087,
0.0249076877,
0.0028831069,
0.0058733001,
0.0049377452,
-0.0600233153,
-0.0076396372,
0.0430318788,
-0.0063068205,
-0.0334045999,
-0.0862621292,
0.0070772874,
-0.0244484879,
-0.0218440406,
0.0033831964,
0.0607665181,
-0.0146952271,
0.0282622669,
-0.0199476089,
-0.0807373896,
-0.0038839451,
0.0071014208,
-0.0555314347,
-0.0174540747,
0.0111248381,
0.005601659,
0.0147449179,
-0.0388706215,
0.0052166353,
0.002083987,
0.004586142,
-0.0290506873,
-0.027872311,
-0.0152122835,
0.0691614598,
0.0332397968,
0.0173641723,
-0.1028222963,
0.0393797681,
0.0123782251,
0.0386373624,
0.0470434353,
0.0569470227,
0.0021529358,
-0.0389103219,
-0.05615234,
0.0406267829,
0.0072394139,
-0.0297427811,
0.041671548,
-0.003118118,
-0.0126037039,
-0.0056714714,
-0.0388819575,
-0.0340329446,
-0.0090746926,
0.0090121292,
0.0149833104,
-0.0063951737,
0.0059615457,
0.006985669,
-0.0030584193,
-0.027228836,
0.0030164742,
0.0182731915,
-0.0257715918,
0.0238122419,
-0.0092472071,
0.0378701612,
-0.0157869626,
-0.0282483771,
0.0383306704,
-0.0024805027,
0.0633998886,
0.0199941043,
0.0278326664,
0.0343464166,
-0.0497177802,
0.0050445902,
-0.0162551608,
-0.0068510678,
0.0160636455,
-0.0316133983,
0.0031793755,
0.0084873075,
0.0139758391,
-0.0031896818,
0.0197896156,
0.0209858138,
-0.0304104723,
-0.0479548648,
-0.0231351964,
0.0071299481,
-0.0183215085,
0.0316480324,
-0.0185356066,
0.038645234,
0.0363907404,
-0.0045749005,
-0.0006650885,
0.0220013559,
2.618e-7,
-0.011843361,
0.0479205512,
0.0351671465,
0.0264598783,
0.0116000492,
0.0359988138,
0.0098477835,
0.0321848392,
0.0199768841,
-0.0101320399,
0.033825133,
0.0139221167,
0.0569814183,
0.0220753681,
-0.0903719515,
0.0217110477,
-0.0385428667,
-0.0019147909,
-0.1062158719,
0.0087586856,
0.12846376,
0.0530606359,
0.0757154897,
0.0100422977,
0.0476986617,
0.0098243179,
0.0524886847,
-0.0293648113,
-0.0301603749,
0.0338715278,
-0.0254828893,
0.00015872,
-0.0460017212,
-0.0203263741,
0.0152675686,
-0.0190152265,
0.0138357729,
0.0825075358,
-0.0330150016,
0.0077704922,
0.0325094536,
0.0188030861,
-0.0207313206,
-0.0398618095,
0.0589631088,
-0.0013962829,
-0.0188355539,
-0.0177970268,
0.0149282198,
0.0032308581,
0.0190772805,
0.0017104725,
-0.0351828337,
0.0296469536,
0.004267734,
0.0135774156,
-0.0038449652,
-0.0572605282,
-0.0127792712,
0.0446782149,
-0.0153894164,
-0.0229737218,
-0.0031136146,
-0.0289398674,
0.0093142148,
-0.0914102048,
0.0337465629,
2.400379668e-34,
0.0033520875,
0.045807831,
-0.0164822061,
-0.0072292564,
0.0623624399,
0.0200779513,
0.0115958489,
0.008006,
0.0207281727,
-0.0295992978,
-0.0240136702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05406v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05406v2 | Everybody Prune Now: Structured Pruning of LLMs with only Forward Passes | 2024-02-08T04:48:26 | 2024-02-09T19:53:56 | Lucio Dery, Steven Kolawole, Jean-François Kagy, Virginia Smith, Graham Neubig, Ameet Talwalkar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Given the generational gap in available hardware between lay practitioners
and the most endowed institutions, LLMs are becoming increasingly inaccessible
as they grow in size. Whilst many approaches have been proposed to compress
LLMs to make their resource consumption manageable, these methods themselves
tend to be resource intensive, putting them out of the reach of the very user
groups they target. In this work, we explore the problem of structured pruning
of LLMs using only forward passes. We seek to empower practitioners to prune
models so large that their available hardware has just enough memory to run
inference. We develop Bonsai, a gradient-free, perturbative pruning method
capable of delivering small, fast, and accurate pruned models.
We observe that Bonsai outputs pruned models that (i) outperform those
generated by more expensive gradient-based structured pruning methods, and (ii)
are twice as fast (with comparable accuracy) as those generated by
semi-structured pruning methods requiring comparable resources as Bonsai. We
also leverage Bonsai to produce a new sub-2B model using a single A6000 that
yields state-of-the-art performance on 4/6 tasks on the Huggingface Open LLM
leaderboard. | [
-0.0429689623,
0.0500632562,
-0.0084871072,
0.0765024349,
-0.0380635224,
-0.0256180167,
0.0279700868,
0.0464923643,
0.0059374282,
0.0399991348,
-0.014910846,
-0.013485224,
-0.0212184452,
-0.0111959307,
-0.016043691,
-0.0429960862,
0.0237258449,
-0.0422580093,
-0.0328708254,
-0.0586314984,
-0.0231225695,
-0.0210590251,
-0.005269072,
-0.0127973882,
0.0003482321,
-0.0029862588,
-0.024349317,
0.0582046248,
0.0148956412,
0.022546893,
-0.0111466581,
0.0337585509,
0.0097177746,
0.0062518679,
0.0000024325,
-0.0092980312,
-0.0020225588,
0.0518053174,
-0.0411092937,
0.0954546928,
0.0258558467,
0.0473510474,
-0.0299106259,
-0.0234596524,
0.0126453079,
0.0352460667,
0.0036118294,
-0.0221577175,
0.0583131388,
0.0435605422,
0.0396696702,
-0.0247474443,
-0.0002465975,
-0.0237659514,
-0.0034210426,
-0.050602667,
0.0173890442,
-0.0425704718,
0.0116627812,
-0.0233947225,
-0.0129530346,
0.0287483167,
0.0520440117,
-0.0002545433,
-0.0035986227,
0.0304027069,
-0.0042470251,
-0.0034554675,
-0.0169742797,
0.03013587,
-0.0498080365,
-0.0294364896,
0.0367017873,
-0.0323921815,
-0.0374766067,
-0.034316387,
-0.0431495942,
0.0316489711,
-0.0397122465,
-0.0088981641,
-0.0402059481,
-0.0533984825,
0.0493049622,
0.0034134702,
-0.0029919893,
0.0518877469,
0.0399705395,
0.0227462593,
-0.0059219617,
0.0069758072,
0.0059287804,
-0.0353964418,
0.0052224509,
0.0138660315,
-0.0207085405,
-0.0210574232,
-0.0485167503,
0.0354722925,
-0.0110780308,
0.0254122335,
0.0746402293,
0.0060240175,
0.0392095074,
0.0482826121,
-0.0388856046,
-0.018260723,
-0.0499729104,
0.0052656503,
-0.0212584864,
0.0321250223,
0.0327742025,
0.0186649207,
-0.0039959732,
0.0464490615,
-0.0857288986,
0.014658872,
-0.0492787249,
-0.0213555694,
-0.0189526565,
-0.0400673412,
0.0187085941,
0.0269696228,
-0.0053325146,
-0.0201757103,
-0.0301925354,
-0.0236342773,
-0.0315602124,
-0.0079396153,
0.0092844563,
-0.0378508531,
-0.0222832169,
0.0011682549,
-0.0484705791,
-0.0207877643,
0.0422621965,
0.0522725098,
0.0073622656,
-0.0397515297,
-0.0589345992,
-0.0246040393,
0.0133953523,
-0.0649679452,
0.0323257558,
-0.0513288416,
0.0403241031,
-0.0480060168,
-0.0027510913,
-0.0398150422,
-0.0003224452,
-0.0010609176,
-0.0296420865,
0.0446771309,
0.0097225364,
-0.0125691481,
0.0220627282,
0.0430883132,
-0.0181300044,
0.053566765,
0.0050825523,
0.0566832311,
0.0041075381,
0.0032718009,
-0.0114975888,
0.0449206606,
0.0573563166,
-0.0007740906,
-0.0367233977,
-0.0231476817,
-0.0217127074,
0.0288129617,
0.0369185135,
0.052278623,
-0.044453755,
-0.0433461517,
0.032982558,
0.0407179631,
0.0356477164,
0.0593396313,
0.0103990277,
-0.0355072804,
0.0328204408,
-0.0302002411,
-0.0514403693,
0.0468609184,
-0.0279327575,
-0.0079150638,
0.0166647565,
0.0506517366,
-0.0433630869,
-0.032403823,
0.0012765834,
-0.0014222878,
-0.0390479192,
0.0225621965,
0.0502941869,
-0.0237181038,
-0.0167751908,
0.0678960755,
0.0372664072,
-0.0805813074,
-0.0457603298,
-0.0823330358,
-0.0078970799,
0.0160911586,
0.0357200466,
-0.0424709059,
-0.0179660134,
0.0328960866,
0.0511319749,
0.0057774214,
0.0540625565,
0.0222292226,
0.0442194007,
-0.0199452043,
0.0247895736,
-0.0208104961,
0.0110023124,
0.0262749884,
0.067417033,
-0.0257129148,
-0.0263915416,
-0.022305347,
0.0050810082,
0.0121595059,
-0.0682545975,
-0.0239277463,
0.0377143025,
-0.010800981,
0.0212678257,
0.0148967039,
-0.0104553318,
-0.0304106921,
0.0865459442,
-0.0324683115,
0.0451163016,
-0.0844022483,
0.0059475591,
0.0115723535,
0.0420907363,
-0.0120094838,
-0.0055702152,
0.0265435334,
-0.0557771325,
-0.0254916307,
0.0053129052,
-0.0095594302,
0.0223545283,
-0.0196283069,
0.0040060245,
-0.0118764592,
0.0072329184,
0.0097674653,
0.051635135,
-0.0324074067,
0.0079964474,
0.0570215099,
-0.0241883565,
-0.0184227098,
-0.069576785,
-0.0519844517,
-0.0074617905,
0.0251798164,
-0.0090338076,
-0.0336236656,
0.0127807744,
0.0289505012,
0.0149906371,
-0.0457245633,
0.0300986115,
-0.0165907908,
0.0426563025,
0.0213671848,
0.0070653753,
0.0087911626,
0.0116486205,
0.072093904,
0.0222497061,
-0.0213465467,
0.0167734548,
-0.0000934207,
-0.0096729938,
-0.0690876618,
-0.0080095306,
-0.0570416413,
0.0227628909,
0.0029380161,
-0.0298896339,
-0.0159123894,
-0.0059815138,
0.0484546907,
-0.0178895965,
0.0328930467,
-0.0279806517,
0.0206390843,
0.0185900535,
-0.0212070476,
-0.0219758656,
0.1228857413,
-0.0381920859,
0.0679859221,
0.0283521488,
0.0101272389,
-0.02498555,
0.028082801,
-0.0031801783,
-0.0243385434,
0.0001552335,
-0.0359340124,
-0.0167090427,
0.0539527424,
-0.0273641907,
-0.0001166696,
-0.0212799087,
0.0068877679,
0.0330390967,
-0.085463129,
0.0019061493,
0.0406565741,
-0.0462571084,
-0.0028534674,
-0.009849879,
-0.0461313613,
0.0295040272,
-0.0241786465,
0.0021533847,
0.0464383364,
-0.0323870368,
-0.0187827274,
0.053090211,
0.0106646521,
-0.0013979633,
-0.0480924919,
0.0206739474,
-0.0111036133,
0.0055307755,
0.0222071186,
-0.0221904386,
0.0188627262,
-0.0743450224,
0.0265559088,
-0.0183003657,
-0.0453779101,
0.0225278605,
0.0191608332,
-0.0121410368,
0.0073753581,
-0.0253297687,
-0.0493100882,
-0.0165635888,
-0.004723039,
0.0434192345,
0.0021960894,
-0.0130893588,
0.0125212045,
-0.0108610447,
-0.010066418,
-0.0003395219,
-0.0132973036,
0.0414865799,
-0.0678792894,
0.036170274,
0.0746669322,
0.0616231151,
0.0051316572,
-0.0541710965,
-0.0335607119,
0.0263934769,
-0.0218606927,
-0.0493104868,
0.0427140854,
0.0740340948,
-0.035719946,
-0.0076408698,
0.0117784953,
-0.001739622,
-0.0362630934,
0.007966429,
0.0208516512,
0.0579881184,
0.01469169,
0.0365084149,
-0.054972019,
-0.0322864354,
0.0467287302,
0.0462906957,
0.0198253505,
-0.0339960568,
0.0081006018,
-0.0788286552,
0.0738923252,
0.0124189006,
-0.0202088263,
0.0476426631,
-0.0250160731,
-0.004384838,
-0.0388776027,
-0.0223482978,
0.0431910232,
-0.0169569068,
-0.0018495234,
-0.0040949588,
-0.0149981081,
0.0265306123,
0.0095618935,
-0.0013416127,
-0.0129284598,
-0.011199547,
0.0004401979,
-0.0215178337,
-0.0454912037,
0.0956768468,
0.0096807163,
0.0056044189,
-0.0548507273,
0.0242798794,
0.0223831534,
0.0116920331,
-0.0165117551,
0.0227463171,
0.0034154353,
-0.0119486777,
-0.0182322264,
0.0849578604,
-0.0164769068,
-0.0024428465,
-0.0110210888,
-0.0449632555,
-0.050884366,
0.0523474067,
-0.0003823969,
-0.0179072171,
-0.0772024393,
-0.0525067896,
-0.0298106056,
-0.0074043698,
-0.0336683728,
-0.0044088834,
-0.018571604,
-0.014005811,
0.0309821833,
0.0618444681,
0.0008774268,
0.0399261527,
-0.0208646674,
-0.0453765392,
-0.0227668379,
0.0232887436,
-0.073236905,
0.0130434409,
-0.0416092873,
0.0297772866,
-0.0597048961,
0.0187656321,
0.0299225431,
0.0203489382,
-0.0172111839,
0.0229568724,
-0.0876837969,
-0.0616491586,
-0.0341775231,
0.0998839661,
0.0380189084,
0.0386003703,
0.0230507664,
-0.0261150561,
0.0278119389,
0.0728031844,
-0.0120662665,
0.0950236768,
0.0200475436,
-0.0196304452,
-0.0114233708,
0.0323337317,
-0.0105249826,
-0.0078755813,
0.0674140528,
0.0312785655,
-0.0119474046,
-0.0350987129,
-0.0507558361,
0.0296980701,
0.0266386922,
0.0147352517,
-0.0371591039,
-0.0003102274,
0.0413622148,
0.0078550652,
0.0348105729,
-0.0438673533,
-0.0031940567,
-0.0005303759,
-0.0079785017,
0.0066777514,
0.0285835527,
0.0710869208,
0.0200478602,
-0.071174711,
0.0313893519,
-0.0060109165,
-0.018565001,
0.0461232029,
-0.0240024719,
-0.0048577152,
0.0099398308,
-0.0187749807,
0.0341967866,
-0.0020458025,
-0.0261428263,
-0.0030027609,
0.0405477397,
-0.074415125,
0.0063994783,
-0.0475213118,
-0.1399133354,
-0.0534980185,
0.0458018258,
0.0605093464,
0.069623284,
0.0048569064,
-0.0033345947,
-0.030709194,
-0.0356346667,
0.0208537541,
0.0312066283,
0.0170456618,
0.0281542987,
0.0001994727,
0.0146790529,
-0.0295400303,
0.040014118,
0.0097436719,
0.0481188372,
0.0245411005,
0.0183878355,
-0.0522350892,
-0.1081786379,
-0.0043140319,
0.0175550785,
0.0283584595,
-0.0569796748,
-0.0566382855,
-0.0340699553,
0.0354839712,
0.0217885096,
-0.0180350263,
-0.0382554978,
0.0583718196,
0.0284182169,
0.0126790004,
-0.0330800377,
0.0284338836,
-0.016239211,
-0.0173793081,
-0.0435273834,
0.0271876175,
-6.559948346e-33,
-0.0208841953,
0.0244703311,
0.0356444828,
0.0471182503,
-0.0338909514,
-0.0018527422,
-0.0202228464,
-0.0225608628,
0.0096780742,
-0.0004738302,
-0.0426219329,
0.0015523419,
0.006674306,
-0.0163757503,
-0.0080871601,
-0.0162923168,
0.0432954207,
-0.0072889468,
-0.0300832968,
0.0446978249,
-0.0147425812,
0.049294766,
0.0282571353,
-0.0069908253,
-0.0666439086,
0.0180093478,
-0.0137007488,
-0.0093577942,
-0.0683585405,
0.0066897999,
-0.0272792056,
0.0127563449,
-0.0318357572,
-0.0345784053,
0.0158265084,
-0.0006943055,
-0.0736947209,
0.0235065091,
0.0277941935,
-0.0209695306,
-0.02439305,
-0.0252049994,
0.0238282569,
0.0810438171,
-0.0670155138,
-0.0443061963,
-0.0081606274,
-0.0187472478,
-0.036446698,
-0.032278873,
0.025415644,
0.03510914,
0.0483952314,
0.0136873433,
0.0172674507,
-0.0308168177,
-0.0597610287,
0.0015839426,
-0.023209054,
0.0085512204,
0.0302049052,
0.033230789,
0.0707315803,
0.0220856275,
0.0363227203,
0.067968823,
0.0541796163,
-0.0008269055,
-0.014839937,
-0.0064464398,
0.0027606315,
0.0690122545,
0.0208972003,
0.0081066834,
0.054235857,
0.0056898012,
-0.099415265,
-0.0167843681,
0.0282748081,
0.0538334474,
0.0098404093,
0.0256471299,
0.0210206266,
-0.0221415069,
0.0206620507,
-0.004494553,
-0.0063518272,
-0.0037663276,
0.0054595303,
0.0187821835,
-0.0623873174,
-0.0005024603,
0.0035542415,
-0.0383967385,
0.0194812659,
-0.0175370127,
0.0590930842,
0.0122993374,
0.040214289,
0.0175490938,
-0.0451332144,
-0.0420162268,
-0.0646078363,
-0.0466383398,
0.0478862002,
-0.0148071889,
-0.0349464752,
0.0112654204,
-0.035510987,
0.0011817527,
-0.0725969002,
0.0180697124,
0.037882138,
0.0564876646,
0.0345738381,
-0.0042695566,
0.027736906,
0.0463616475,
-0.0337542109,
-0.0143313482,
-0.0247845147,
0.0458294377,
0.0064966665,
0.0348407626,
-0.0179332439,
-0.0171803553,
-0.0199942254,
0.0234383531,
0.0100212637,
-0.0982985198,
-0.0384156965,
0.0535463206,
3.003e-7,
-0.0053840126,
0.0178995784,
-0.006225978,
0.0319574624,
0.0179072693,
-0.0029756927,
0.0094148042,
-0.0185181815,
-0.0167605337,
-0.0396954864,
0.0122885555,
0.0559248812,
0.0634950697,
-0.0143384272,
-0.0476298034,
0.0040653376,
-0.016036272,
0.000718328,
-0.0390966535,
-0.0608347207,
-0.0506765172,
0.0251736213,
0.0333201997,
-0.0253198612,
0.0041352599,
-0.0118727675,
0.0289150551,
-0.0405791216,
0.0277807768,
-0.0096221538,
0.0075268596,
-0.0427206643,
-0.0316880085,
0.0075612934,
0.009949645,
-0.0222937241,
-0.0296339467,
0.118591316,
0.0275350772,
-0.0330763534,
0.0316601992,
-0.0047844951,
-0.0084298458,
0.0124514559,
0.0598381571,
0.0544156879,
0.0213130675,
-0.0252523422,
0.0029060133,
-0.0541429631,
0.0089172218,
-0.0043258918,
0.0507359467,
-0.0005430674,
-0.0018402693,
-0.0252811611,
-0.0044374811,
-0.0419890955,
-0.0250868946,
-0.0013793972,
-0.0873641297,
-0.0667365193,
-0.0263854619,
0.0608723462,
0.0061970069,
-0.061824467,
-0.0541015379,
3.265028772e-34,
0.0428990684,
-0.0162083898,
0.0195940658,
0.0811811835,
-0.0071533471,
0.0118920803,
-0.0129708787,
-0.0133580696,
-0.0211490318,
-0.036324732,
-0.0391606949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05403v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05403v2 | In-Context Principle Learning from Mistakes | 2024-02-08T04:42:29 | 2024-02-09T19:09:52 | Tianjun Zhang, Aman Madaan, Luyu Gao, Steven Zheng, Swaroop Mishra, Yiming Yang, Niket Tandon, Uri Alon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-context learning (ICL, also known as few-shot prompting) has been the
standard method of adapting LLMs to downstream tasks, by learning from a few
input-output examples. Nonetheless, all ICL-based approaches only learn from
correct input-output pairs. In this paper, we revisit this paradigm, by
learning more from the few given input-output examples. We introduce Learning
Principles (LEAP): First, we intentionally induce the model to make mistakes on
these few examples; then we reflect on these mistakes, and learn explicit
task-specific "principles" from them, which help solve similar problems and
avoid common mistakes; finally, we prompt the model to answer unseen test
questions using the original few-shot examples and these learned general
principles. We evaluate LEAP on a wide range of benchmarks, including multi-hop
question answering (Hotpot QA), textual QA (DROP), Big-Bench Hard reasoning,
and math problems (GSM8K and MATH); in all these benchmarks, LEAP improves the
strongest available LLMs such as GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4, GPT-4 turbo and
Claude-2.1. For example, LEAP improves over the standard few-shot prompting
using GPT-4 by 7.5% in DROP, and by 3.3% in HotpotQA. Importantly, LEAP does
not require any more input or examples than the standard few-shot prompting
settings. | [
-0.0198381096,
0.0151746795,
0.0238890834,
0.0327998623,
-0.0424923562,
0.0442313477,
-0.0102116512,
0.0004696192,
-0.0044835135,
-0.0388146602,
-0.0236170776,
-0.0216433275,
-0.0417204611,
-0.0329719856,
0.0411683321,
-0.0052790213,
0.059088923,
-0.0443625972,
-0.0087010367,
-0.0095772864,
-0.0190599505,
-0.0110788662,
-0.0288504027,
-0.0289816689,
0.005269825,
-0.0576346666,
-0.0386903137,
0.0243173987,
0.0276603624,
-0.0348246731,
0.0144386403,
0.0172957238,
0.0221047532,
0.0141809797,
0.0000019525,
-0.0422604084,
-0.0240446739,
-0.0215938017,
-0.0487072878,
-0.0264968537,
-0.0611150563,
0.021653071,
0.0141481413,
0.0231720395,
-0.0570094511,
0.0251214784,
0.0072707809,
0.0734270364,
0.0708162785,
0.1026647016,
0.024723947,
-0.0288766492,
0.0025923827,
-0.0143231461,
0.0573864505,
-0.0857727751,
0.0105731077,
0.0035567279,
0.0364167579,
0.0135953575,
-0.0169069301,
0.0256550424,
0.0477101021,
0.0288574025,
-0.0448852852,
0.0381786861,
-0.0251233429,
0.0272802636,
-0.0190647673,
0.0783098415,
-0.0038178985,
-0.0017298879,
-0.0377658457,
-0.0131274583,
0.0225634333,
-0.0489948839,
-0.0919728056,
0.0176149029,
-0.0281644594,
0.0220592041,
-0.0099122841,
-0.0252281558,
0.0274775922,
0.0009477354,
0.0101475697,
0.0751336291,
-0.0094803479,
-0.0643473789,
0.0149677023,
0.0208598208,
-0.0067246514,
-0.0171312839,
-0.0385500751,
0.0823600292,
-0.0566160195,
0.0286347121,
0.0201240741,
0.0237326175,
0.0205053743,
0.0188562665,
0.0452692881,
0.0571784005,
-0.0094792899,
0.0536065511,
-0.0464818701,
0.0326755494,
-0.0009396241,
0.0360367075,
-0.0431332402,
-0.0148295797,
-0.0533256866,
-0.0030876731,
-0.0379962735,
0.0704621598,
-0.0050940327,
0.0199739486,
-0.0614035018,
0.0717165321,
-0.02106959,
0.0238417424,
0.0181337632,
0.0012618088,
-0.022909211,
-0.0081311511,
-0.0397153459,
0.0259397589,
-0.0503152609,
0.0218343008,
0.0254795458,
-0.0582614727,
-0.0569834635,
-0.0009463023,
-0.0164977089,
-0.0125789111,
0.029538678,
0.0862009078,
-0.0234424341,
-0.0204687379,
-0.052366294,
-0.0030537178,
0.0330024958,
-0.0559219569,
0.0053021177,
-0.0578784011,
0.0190562494,
-0.0154432254,
-0.0120140146,
-0.0049302895,
-0.0060730097,
0.0350786075,
-0.0015708763,
0.0868316516,
0.0061875051,
-0.0104086315,
0.0264225528,
0.0348012894,
-0.0750622749,
0.097029157,
-0.0235995669,
-0.0068665552,
0.0230817087,
0.0169212595,
0.0374991819,
0.0304653142,
0.0445418321,
0.0305733792,
0.0063689435,
0.0254540145,
0.00889639,
0.0379367843,
0.0184154734,
0.0331953838,
-0.044392325,
0.0042873924,
0.0185677502,
0.0474746265,
0.0282821674,
-0.0150716146,
0.0309155472,
-0.018358767,
0.0208783317,
0.0049912161,
-0.0914726555,
0.0599128976,
-0.0292214639,
0.0327566043,
0.0015757434,
-0.0192228723,
-0.05760305,
-0.0187664554,
0.0037422183,
0.0111666415,
-0.0239281245,
0.0316038765,
0.0325909443,
0.026064923,
-0.044429753,
0.0430371314,
0.0087076109,
0.0006562067,
-0.0289663188,
-0.0555694252,
0.0483409613,
0.0386478864,
0.0302104689,
-0.0413126647,
-0.0561664551,
-0.0183009431,
0.0212015994,
0.0058638835,
0.0139199542,
-0.0298112426,
0.0190267973,
-0.017353531,
0.0059644729,
-0.0493112057,
0.0034036054,
0.0063834973,
0.0324710011,
0.0207442157,
0.0069976733,
-0.0177355893,
0.0661305711,
0.0132568395,
-0.0397739485,
-0.0654484928,
-0.0019079427,
-0.0123671601,
0.0165909082,
-0.0035890201,
0.0316417888,
0.0174100399,
0.0199376829,
0.0073981024,
-0.0126338061,
-0.0063544908,
-0.0477101542,
-0.0728350058,
0.048076354,
-0.0193521809,
-0.032436084,
0.0107230796,
-0.0955428407,
-0.0313625559,
-0.0123700071,
-0.012734063,
0.001954007,
-0.0374121256,
-0.0029205445,
0.0311480686,
-0.0252583809,
-0.0542251617,
0.0944568962,
-0.0046860999,
0.0122504542,
0.0251861103,
0.0622907691,
-0.0037540963,
-0.0578403883,
0.041993618,
-0.0284695998,
0.0023149389,
0.0097020483,
-0.0268488452,
0.0435586609,
-0.0926465988,
-0.0002048054,
-0.0587953068,
0.0369065776,
-0.0185692795,
0.0547907203,
0.0044347499,
-0.0021574367,
-0.0194719806,
-0.038059257,
-0.0659792349,
0.0211427491,
0.0107988603,
0.0236956384,
0.0471560024,
-0.0002026648,
0.0136213535,
-0.007183535,
0.0041916133,
-0.0117212012,
0.0113695003,
-0.0471516475,
0.0182349831,
-0.0544988513,
0.0141220083,
-0.0343409367,
0.022865925,
-0.0024127853,
0.0221256372,
0.0348712094,
-0.0267065093,
0.0167638529,
0.0592313707,
-0.0240329336,
-0.0052858866,
0.0094654551,
-0.012121344,
-0.0527324267,
0.0566046499,
-0.0190714505,
-0.0090684192,
-0.0060232412,
0.0319102556,
0.0113863265,
0.0339653865,
-0.0251160208,
-0.016589405,
-0.0162174515,
0.0444226377,
0.0478786714,
-0.0111570731,
-0.0371190235,
0.0107019749,
-0.0257569775,
-0.0093175573,
-0.0200526454,
-0.0135795753,
0.0803934336,
0.0076969028,
-0.0103465272,
-0.0480939001,
-0.0101310126,
-0.0625604242,
0.0209673792,
-0.0344315171,
-0.0204722956,
-0.0237147491,
-0.0257152189,
-0.0708969757,
-0.0360494256,
0.0194599219,
-0.018637564,
0.0728944093,
-0.0338446535,
0.0129381912,
-0.0375399105,
-0.0655143559,
-0.0706676096,
-0.0062939292,
-0.035651844,
0.0383960381,
-0.0754144341,
0.0045093051,
0.015336209,
-0.0327045545,
0.0251000952,
0.0190750305,
-0.0139385443,
-0.0252305754,
-0.0312188212,
0.0302281342,
0.0247516092,
0.0279434212,
0.0343252495,
-0.0243893079,
0.0554301664,
0.0622253492,
0.0829009488,
-0.0184796881,
-0.0071936189,
0.0319365524,
0.0152644329,
-0.0508116297,
-0.0189020485,
0.0343365297,
0.0441189036,
-0.0533806086,
-0.0172067638,
0.0917043015,
0.0127543379,
-0.0304833557,
-0.0093164733,
-0.04710247,
-0.0053275675,
0.029381562,
0.0405398123,
-0.0850877166,
-0.0645100847,
0.0061246753,
0.0294589344,
0.0084231906,
-0.0235836133,
0.0021395313,
-0.1108760908,
0.0242323019,
0.0182967931,
-0.0599595644,
-0.007350157,
-0.0273494329,
-0.0023904839,
0.0029887948,
0.0335309431,
0.0384897701,
-0.0148623642,
-0.0034623758,
0.0461985022,
0.0394213423,
-0.0589198805,
0.0305793639,
-0.0456520841,
0.0271949451,
0.0283698887,
-0.005742948,
-0.0075749895,
-0.0522455722,
0.0503347591,
-0.0489425361,
0.0336386971,
-0.0249436125,
-0.004012926,
-0.0163631532,
-0.0192013439,
-0.0186540391,
0.0521184392,
-0.0261167139,
-0.0480885021,
0.024524577,
0.1091312617,
-0.0466120765,
-0.0116884895,
-0.0163545869,
-0.0060300049,
0.0042063673,
0.0447213277,
0.0198690668,
0.0070308787,
-0.0577117093,
-0.0317316167,
-0.0426575802,
-0.0404720083,
0.0164174885,
0.0275454428,
0.0045630964,
0.0415546373,
-0.0483482704,
-0.0410563499,
0.0300003346,
0.0913540721,
-0.022729937,
0.0360001698,
-0.0560346022,
0.0294147767,
-0.0120630581,
0.0198039897,
-0.0575361513,
-0.0071505131,
-0.0202036221,
0.019348776,
0.0585166328,
-0.0158678908,
0.0069645527,
0.0027077778,
-0.0953600705,
-0.05412063,
-0.0335605852,
0.0449396856,
0.0193658136,
0.0838125497,
-0.0150620304,
-0.016238004,
0.0480212942,
0.0221828241,
0.0079802461,
0.0325606726,
0.0327431448,
0.0086907493,
0.0041787378,
0.0219298843,
-0.0708578154,
0.0085450038,
0.0199957881,
0.0685780495,
-0.0467791483,
-0.0000496139,
0.0470403954,
0.0152391829,
0.0053120391,
0.0200495645,
0.0010845296,
0.012534773,
0.0609533451,
0.0006630613,
-0.0056668185,
-0.0113862474,
0.0121320803,
-0.0136351567,
-0.0506765582,
0.0031915745,
-0.0461442731,
-0.0095229624,
0.040572606,
-0.0235572048,
-0.0187407266,
0.031762179,
0.0082951039,
0.0194698125,
-0.0072616455,
-0.0285109598,
-0.0065825381,
0.0224213563,
0.0544372201,
-0.0005268462,
0.0659853891,
0.0552164204,
-0.000111847,
-0.0539104231,
0.0166715067,
-0.0799150392,
-0.041440092,
-0.0107946349,
0.0537471585,
0.0522136204,
0.0398916863,
-0.0300637316,
-0.0135714924,
-0.016068045,
0.0052352073,
-0.0045961356,
-0.0146823647,
-0.0072987932,
0.0630197003,
0.0539765768,
0.0381361805,
-0.0010412217,
0.0398211293,
-0.0338453799,
0.039124541,
0.0059972522,
0.0534561872,
-0.034949854,
-0.023426177,
0.0308774821,
0.0090370635,
0.0212671719,
-0.0035592117,
-0.041252736,
-0.0512964949,
-0.00658157,
0.0422303043,
-0.0095518306,
-0.014900336,
0.0300753899,
0.0599459559,
0.0392582491,
-0.0362118185,
0.0021799633,
0.0007799165,
-0.0146386763,
-0.0285811946,
0.0193471033,
-5.957258066e-33,
-0.0230093021,
-0.0262480043,
0.0819652081,
0.0058891927,
-0.0230952613,
-0.0306263138,
-0.0127463369,
-0.0295867957,
-0.0257843304,
-0.0047302702,
-0.0522887632,
0.0033086415,
0.0035272606,
0.0103119556,
0.0262812655,
-0.0637025535,
0.0018224996,
-0.0135692395,
-0.032527566,
0.003598457,
0.0011659554,
0.0206266157,
0.0515735932,
0.0218728837,
0.0114636207,
-0.0299509857,
-0.0378914289,
0.0643345118,
-0.0645567626,
0.0413144119,
-0.0002223319,
0.0052240309,
0.0323607661,
-0.0498725399,
-0.0126876924,
0.020940505,
-0.0782270357,
-0.0689456165,
0.0084829498,
-0.0079251984,
-0.070403941,
-0.0293683056,
0.0053249532,
-0.009956019,
0.0185771175,
-0.0139277391,
-0.0255614594,
-0.0274794381,
-0.0266902596,
-0.0090807611,
-0.006081867,
-0.0024390444,
-0.0082280505,
-0.0099825291,
-0.0310845412,
0.0603415482,
-0.0206516087,
0.0269511491,
-0.0370852016,
-0.025980439,
0.0197429974,
-0.0051664375,
0.0524183735,
0.011424385,
-0.0045672902,
0.0316278711,
0.0099925939,
-0.0196464546,
-0.0026655742,
-0.0523043275,
0.0034105519,
0.0435645021,
0.0560035631,
0.0504077412,
0.0389393196,
0.0243107099,
-0.0870743021,
0.0511015393,
0.0387455411,
0.0432301462,
-0.0062613701,
0.0115581192,
-0.0377939567,
-0.0263164807,
-0.0428276397,
0.0588102005,
-0.0339958668,
-0.0354639292,
0.0411486365,
0.0154511891,
0.016501952,
0.0015089421,
0.0305162016,
-0.0206983667,
0.0114365835,
0.0128013082,
-0.0038795874,
0.0129756154,
0.0029831182,
0.0203579664,
-0.0399753973,
-0.0449143574,
-0.0043236911,
0.0123233832,
0.0134898741,
-0.0033817338,
0.0316575691,
0.0288624205,
-0.0479360931,
-0.0262679663,
-0.0305071399,
0.0312546641,
0.0185451061,
0.0004172459,
-0.0173585396,
0.0060986164,
-0.0014483912,
0.0452692136,
-0.0122223152,
-0.054105442,
0.0159248393,
0.0159974732,
-0.0149592524,
0.0063775736,
-0.0073638349,
0.017358046,
0.0031796072,
0.0348242745,
-0.0019232391,
-0.063573584,
0.0010370103,
0.0633170977,
2.704e-7,
0.0089113833,
-0.0149103319,
0.0319174044,
0.0352642611,
0.0268876944,
0.0452242121,
-0.0640901327,
0.0151555957,
0.0175030902,
0.0037865434,
0.0286683049,
0.0581309013,
0.0204771012,
0.0542687066,
-0.0932836384,
0.0022818283,
-0.0250758417,
-0.0266491063,
-0.013269959,
-0.015275104,
0.0161285382,
0.0673145503,
0.0032574984,
-0.042488005,
0.001207393,
-0.0121705383,
0.0630720854,
-0.0094619058,
-0.0138295349,
0.0012755282,
0.002204309,
-0.0226269271,
0.0290358998,
0.0458731987,
-0.0041071032,
0.0105466144,
-0.0246380568,
0.0279816873,
0.0079532517,
-0.0883229822,
-0.0169890877,
-0.0307695772,
0.0705214143,
-0.0395033956,
0.071493797,
-0.0532316826,
-0.0196372047,
-0.0196953416,
-0.0078679668,
-0.0445513763,
-0.0015859236,
-0.0091014151,
-0.001593011,
-0.0004731176,
-0.0047495919,
0.0017259687,
-0.024757646,
-0.0857753158,
0.0021344086,
0.0200304575,
0.0097023947,
-0.0432208553,
-0.0104351826,
0.0183484927,
0.0381652899,
-0.0538855009,
-0.0247864593,
2.182364726e-34,
0.0184341744,
-0.0496263616,
0.0489483997,
0.0989874378,
-0.022839183,
0.0019721061,
-0.0228789896,
0.0077099358,
0.0644505247,
-0.0359292515,
-0.0175909717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10941v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10941v1 | Text2Data: Low-Resource Data Generation with Textual Control | 2024-02-08T03:41:39 | 2024-02-08T03:41:39 | Shiyu Wang, Yihao Feng, Tian Lan, Ning Yu, Yu Bai, Ran Xu, Huan Wang, Caiming Xiong, Silvio Savarese | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Natural language serves as a common and straightforward control signal for
humans to interact seamlessly with machines. Recognizing the importance of this
interface, the machine learning community is investing considerable effort in
generating data that is semantically coherent with textual instructions. While
strides have been made in text-to-data generation spanning image editing, audio
synthesis, video creation, and beyond, low-resource areas characterized by
expensive annotations or complex data structures, such as molecules, motion
dynamics, and time series, often lack textual labels. This deficiency impedes
supervised learning, thereby constraining the application of advanced
generative models for text-to-data tasks. In response to these challenges in
the low-resource scenario, we propose Text2Data, a novel approach that utilizes
unlabeled data to understand the underlying data distribution through an
unsupervised diffusion model. Subsequently, it undergoes controllable
finetuning via a novel constraint optimization-based learning objective that
ensures controllability and effectively counteracts catastrophic forgetting.
Comprehensive experiments demonstrate that Text2Data is able to achieve
enhanced performance regarding controllability across various modalities,
including molecules, motions and time series, when compared to existing
baselines. | [
-0.0035430333,
0.1082062572,
0.0119679924,
0.0005190328,
0.0108765839,
0.0082825692,
0.0191280395,
0.0118735339,
-0.0037719042,
0.0129766073,
-0.0042149425,
-0.0196970981,
0.0025879047,
0.0381091945,
0.0354798026,
-0.0696313009,
0.0041339314,
-0.0284738801,
-0.0096754143,
-0.0094997128,
0.0271959957,
-0.0173133239,
0.0123489676,
-0.0099485908,
-0.0471300557,
0.0032358323,
-0.001127667,
0.0272578932,
0.0505347885,
-0.0201258734,
-0.0137014911,
0.0608811975,
0.0725915506,
0.0203246027,
0.0000021012,
-0.0155932168,
-0.0155783156,
0.0189943109,
0.0132383043,
-0.0171682741,
0.0910280198,
-0.0509370454,
-0.0249317233,
-0.0159451012,
-0.0241233129,
0.0270942822,
0.0860261768,
0.0250790436,
0.0671963543,
0.0603467263,
-0.026570119,
-0.0239457171,
0.0060309926,
-0.0523281246,
0.1025212407,
-0.0073329881,
0.0225313995,
0.0144149074,
0.0353975967,
0.0040946449,
-0.0384153314,
0.0542558283,
-0.000835583,
-0.0231806431,
0.0420048684,
0.0743425712,
-0.025621973,
-0.0489538796,
-0.0055262181,
0.1073558182,
-0.0076127038,
-0.0421667583,
0.0371176898,
-0.036767479,
-0.039456103,
0.0302700046,
-0.0368948355,
-0.0094177444,
0.004727345,
0.0346082821,
-0.0507599004,
-0.007609243,
0.0272647906,
-0.0367612094,
0.0082848407,
-0.0095572369,
0.0111213047,
-0.0068463176,
-0.0036102678,
0.0078157792,
-0.0290258639,
-0.0290709771,
-0.0061718514,
-0.0020392668,
0.0033757547,
-0.0048938361,
-0.0589980856,
-0.0754060745,
-0.0124464566,
-0.0215545148,
0.0507843122,
-0.0144377574,
0.0267884731,
0.0342339724,
-0.0121801849,
-0.0066206842,
-0.037222892,
0.0147349751,
-0.022883499,
0.0188628901,
-0.0552239046,
0.0037197557,
-0.024494756,
0.0132216569,
-0.0415165015,
-0.0075061973,
-0.0335746072,
-0.0028097522,
-0.0157820731,
0.0057907361,
0.0054531707,
0.0386713669,
-0.0470405705,
0.0150736999,
-0.0312152784,
-0.0152850039,
-0.003952838,
0.0193942972,
0.0469024479,
0.0027051959,
-0.0256727934,
0.0224650577,
0.0347657427,
-0.0083917724,
0.007817979,
0.0864335597,
-0.0390781425,
0.0186545439,
-0.0351389125,
-0.0321852192,
-0.0112022003,
-0.031421449,
0.0439792089,
-0.0382005125,
0.063901633,
0.0017636734,
-0.0169105455,
-0.0779116973,
0.0349679776,
0.0054458836,
-0.0441421531,
0.1057472602,
-0.0178250801,
-0.0351280831,
0.0486879721,
-0.0089673465,
0.0119757941,
0.0315252393,
0.070481807,
0.0349902846,
-0.0275759455,
0.0281786192,
0.0369786769,
0.0147866542,
0.0590304695,
-0.012682003,
-0.0385349728,
-0.0319258124,
0.0039734468,
0.0375771485,
0.0617935918,
0.0319802873,
-0.0199674163,
0.034476988,
0.0609527379,
0.0146436142,
0.0046163774,
0.0254062563,
0.0308153648,
0.0166038182,
-0.0488095321,
-0.026964562,
0.0190231223,
0.0731790215,
0.0452222526,
0.0020260022,
0.0342929326,
-0.0131707983,
-0.0288545545,
-0.0613196157,
0.0161953866,
-0.0099086594,
0.0274705533,
-0.0359310582,
0.0438831337,
0.01077573,
-0.0629751533,
0.0106400177,
0.0143721644,
-0.0451222919,
0.0017142963,
0.0140620964,
0.0134600708,
0.0626043007,
0.0164757278,
-0.0427712165,
0.0049165688,
-0.0227983445,
0.0519266427,
0.0442005768,
0.0019680392,
0.0099075502,
0.0177401993,
-0.0443030447,
-0.0499977134,
-0.0117721548,
0.00508019,
-0.001982416,
-0.04532893,
0.0164226424,
0.0096035488,
-0.0274080951,
-0.0489307046,
0.0173331089,
-0.0065802438,
-0.0610241443,
0.0172624048,
0.0100324331,
0.0239078477,
-0.0275982544,
-0.0312659256,
0.00926797,
0.0294841714,
-0.0426066816,
-0.0308314301,
-0.0171815362,
-0.0213293228,
-0.008056758,
-0.0144313024,
-0.0665955842,
-0.0028735197,
-0.0337231122,
-0.0497595966,
-0.081640698,
0.0316796191,
-0.0153889675,
-0.028501397,
-0.0215082187,
-0.0415130109,
0.0468573496,
0.0326291509,
-0.0050349287,
0.0646655411,
-0.008166302,
0.0076016402,
0.00548454,
0.040079616,
-0.0045475718,
-0.0191772394,
0.0140898759,
-0.0231046807,
0.0349282511,
0.0193831678,
0.0531823114,
-0.0116592012,
-0.0408571661,
-0.0181633756,
-0.0044790646,
-0.0110170078,
0.0097757485,
0.0046605603,
0.0002267676,
0.0135303363,
0.0005837957,
0.0019555169,
-0.0506126359,
0.0342883654,
-0.0295603611,
-0.0368037969,
0.0538974032,
0.0225594155,
0.005840112,
-0.0477326289,
-0.0005718493,
0.0087929219,
0.0081495494,
0.0393831618,
-0.0395389572,
0.0050008786,
0.0247018095,
-0.0123700825,
0.0316791683,
-0.0135543766,
-0.005913421,
0.017304156,
-0.0135636143,
0.0431432575,
0.0653964579,
-0.0098081268,
0.0330429412,
0.0198046863,
-0.0097117461,
-0.0228508152,
0.0229565352,
-0.055430349,
0.0045491811,
0.0041249064,
-0.0217902642,
0.0028498811,
0.0623173192,
0.0036560448,
0.0094906008,
-0.0549942441,
0.0279652774,
-0.0124833267,
-0.0025544704,
-0.0224195942,
0.0554367453,
-0.0252227485,
-0.0107791107,
-0.0460074395,
-0.0584722534,
0.0594864041,
0.0001307572,
0.0013410597,
0.0034683624,
-0.0093082217,
0.0081639653,
0.0139514832,
0.022461202,
0.0075015165,
0.0399398617,
0.0135536687,
-0.0481282361,
0.0109042637,
0.0502667837,
0.0023042888,
-0.0136533519,
-0.0473509058,
0.0266567823,
-0.0128446799,
-0.0305559672,
-0.0055143316,
-0.0097378353,
0.0333354212,
0.0110113723,
0.0389577635,
-0.0474649221,
-0.0277190842,
-0.0360129923,
0.0248971321,
0.0438230336,
-0.010613543,
-0.0324586928,
-0.0503837615,
0.0462958999,
0.0546510778,
-0.016675815,
-0.04096191,
-0.0525467657,
-0.0027153287,
0.0313865356,
0.0119452449,
-0.0169029552,
-0.0295781866,
0.0414956585,
-0.0262356307,
0.04459095,
-0.0059383148,
0.0057356856,
0.0435149297,
-0.0292669609,
-0.0468554758,
0.0544073023,
0.015748756,
-0.0241819434,
-0.0003489625,
0.0493255109,
0.0534426868,
0.0143545168,
0.0304785091,
-0.0669263154,
-0.0374618471,
-0.0214106031,
0.080063045,
0.0093322303,
-0.0382589214,
-0.0041052606,
-0.047677204,
0.0758613646,
0.0352837667,
-0.050234817,
-0.0162308235,
-0.0704337955,
-0.0017687025,
-0.0358332545,
-0.0223066658,
-0.0119686769,
0.0033112033,
0.0172628984,
0.0432211198,
0.0079278247,
-0.082240127,
-0.012615541,
0.0039566858,
0.012911791,
0.075452581,
0.019084068,
-0.0073100617,
-0.0170946047,
0.026822621,
0.0009213705,
-0.0174059458,
-0.0255576745,
0.0382723883,
0.0460261218,
-0.0181696322,
0.0021792774,
0.1240882725,
-0.0026758628,
-0.02921414,
-0.0351059139,
0.0889115557,
-0.0042899391,
-0.0345961154,
-0.039329797,
-0.0332844332,
0.0654645711,
0.0558153801,
0.0365905613,
-0.0501783863,
-0.0722311437,
-0.0378723294,
0.0267241001,
-0.0666052476,
-0.0129619706,
-0.0311086066,
-0.0126654962,
-0.0543566495,
-0.103203088,
-0.009461618,
0.0244379714,
0.0554758534,
-0.0071808649,
0.0332558788,
0.0278737359,
-0.0426526591,
-0.070080258,
-0.0062296446,
-0.0276523456,
-0.0006907727,
-0.0411385074,
-0.086922735,
0.0120847197,
-0.0345124006,
-0.0343855135,
0.0766220242,
-0.1080147177,
-0.0624829829,
-0.0324623138,
0.0457732752,
0.0210738145,
0.0404512584,
0.0043684244,
-0.0323719531,
0.0995383635,
0.0988888368,
-0.0036888132,
0.012438166,
0.0031360057,
0.0060047465,
-0.008269676,
0.0042530713,
-0.0540818535,
0.0295251105,
0.0114022559,
0.0235507526,
-0.0189341456,
0.0109401289,
0.0104465242,
-0.0296370368,
0.0369873755,
-0.0175283495,
0.0082931304,
-0.0465633161,
-0.0216427073,
0.0111507094,
0.0006101432,
-0.096848391,
-0.0168045498,
0.0444219597,
-0.0013363472,
-0.0172082111,
-0.001300663,
0.0150112845,
0.003995216,
-0.0276380517,
-0.0084694354,
0.0266000535,
0.0501832031,
0.036488913,
0.0119565399,
0.0334732607,
0.0295184646,
-0.0335056596,
0.0409687608,
0.0001649876,
0.0218711477,
0.044080548,
0.0467496477,
-0.0360618494,
0.0077482918,
-0.0409407616,
0.0050857896,
-0.0575597882,
0.0313142501,
0.0342146233,
-0.0221556146,
0.0599510707,
-0.049401775,
-0.0080586849,
-0.0172821283,
0.0703412667,
0.010172803,
-0.0228125062,
0.0518301167,
-0.00681306,
0.0124825062,
0.0096240016,
0.1056790128,
0.0300604049,
0.017212715,
-0.0294217989,
-0.0254101381,
-0.0528565384,
0.0195986088,
-0.0245474763,
-0.0454780422,
0.0240123738,
0.0074647837,
-0.0259110872,
-0.0673817918,
0.012545255,
0.0191523712,
-0.0099091223,
0.0125055518,
0.0663347095,
0.0038184121,
-0.0394597352,
-0.0075783473,
-0.0320948996,
0.0145578068,
0.0021794008,
-0.0565070473,
-0.0277780611,
-6.654201687e-33,
-0.0288506318,
-0.0296666715,
-0.0043102563,
0.0080730049,
-0.023871325,
-0.0058006099,
-0.0733498558,
-0.0209940393,
0.0522355773,
0.0460405685,
0.0031653598,
0.0035344169,
0.0042807534,
0.0263541657,
0.0107969483,
-0.0112668183,
0.0268451869,
-0.043540962,
-0.0210017692,
0.074180603,
0.0738142729,
0.0383731797,
0.0245339908,
-0.0484342128,
0.021635823,
0.0043261754,
-0.0250838902,
-0.0216177255,
0.0198066756,
0.0029613879,
-0.0273556896,
0.0283637587,
-0.0276408661,
-0.0206404794,
-0.080619581,
0.027475154,
-0.0877063796,
-0.0377401002,
-0.0381274074,
-0.0470011383,
-0.046837125,
-0.0481711701,
0.0460930131,
-0.0203943942,
-0.0173353907,
-0.0078974646,
0.0574725829,
-0.0289983153,
-0.0169550683,
-0.0509735942,
-0.0580141656,
0.0144014908,
-0.0340991281,
-0.0256302804,
0.0405284949,
0.001533869,
0.0034746791,
-0.0088663222,
-0.0654220507,
0.0224610735,
0.0181104764,
0.034601856,
0.0603140444,
0.0312752686,
0.0474319309,
0.049907241,
0.0151774446,
-0.0019533332,
-0.016728051,
0.0294708684,
0.0029611611,
0.0477161482,
0.0184823014,
0.0171776079,
0.0350180976,
-0.0222757496,
-0.069954209,
0.0393048227,
-0.1020417511,
0.0039517982,
-0.0169095006,
0.0357369296,
0.0013847068,
-0.0362154767,
-0.0288771335,
0.0112182023,
-0.0056497622,
0.0102536054,
0.0085342284,
0.0071945074,
-0.0233806707,
-0.0253887065,
0.0175839346,
-0.0004448336,
-0.018764155,
-0.0120494869,
-0.0198618155,
0.036593657,
0.027512325,
-0.0347857326,
-0.0674069524,
-0.0292739086,
0.0645117909,
0.0415815599,
0.0237518847,
0.0075579868,
0.0150803598,
0.0511254035,
-0.0176579859,
-0.0104559362,
-0.0570122302,
0.0338438898,
0.0063494523,
-0.0071136141,
0.0136478664,
-0.0130388588,
-0.0124939801,
0.047834672,
-0.0169727094,
0.0025432992,
0.0278788954,
0.0157846119,
-0.012621209,
0.0251808465,
-0.0408959687,
0.0001786701,
-0.0338003524,
0.0297386665,
0.0592087246,
-0.083307527,
-0.0137033751,
0.0356286615,
2.89e-7,
0.0451590866,
0.0186073426,
0.0363811515,
0.0078611877,
0.0133953253,
0.0362378843,
-0.0353261903,
0.0160940364,
-0.0495078601,
-0.0516871735,
0.0363464355,
0.0209689662,
0.0553845167,
0.0067907614,
-0.0537712388,
0.0100629041,
-0.0248324219,
0.0304081589,
-0.0288996007,
-0.0350302383,
0.0511315428,
0.0660035834,
-0.0154667953,
-0.004295032,
0.0595953502,
-0.0080459146,
0.0944300741,
-0.0362927541,
0.06391792,
0.0040612854,
-0.0042628022,
-0.0167596266,
-0.0397891067,
0.0105173131,
-0.0615579896,
-0.0272582956,
0.0201737359,
0.045574002,
-0.0175131541,
-0.0334389433,
0.0136802876,
0.0230282806,
0.0162585378,
0.0001587399,
0.0431826115,
-0.0626499206,
0.0019657204,
0.0213014949,
-0.0176851302,
0.0423613042,
0.0135367615,
0.0032109348,
-0.0377888791,
-0.0024616052,
0.0030168877,
0.0318360701,
-0.001131039,
-0.0230267458,
-0.0061086416,
0.0068804836,
-0.0511014387,
-0.0074475734,
-0.0839566439,
0.0236955434,
0.0015398189,
-0.0035341983,
-0.0382347591,
2.642389159e-34,
0.0286218375,
-0.0494920425,
-0.0243011285,
-0.0390322283,
0.024145117,
0.0054891594,
0.002635055,
0.0245089438,
-0.003957456,
-0.0536846258,
-0.035346102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05376v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05376v1 | Zero-Shot Chain-of-Thought Reasoning Guided by Evolutionary Algorithms in Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T03:17:38 | 2024-02-08T03:17:38 | Feihu Jin, Yifan Liu, Ying Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance across
diverse tasks and exhibited impressive reasoning abilities by applying
zero-shot Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting. However, due to the evolving nature
of sentence prefixes during the pre-training phase, existing zero-shot CoT
prompting methods that employ identical CoT prompting across all task instances
may not be optimal. In this paper, we introduce a novel zero-shot prompting
method that leverages evolutionary algorithms to generate diverse promptings
for LLMs dynamically. Our approach involves initializing two CoT promptings,
performing evolutionary operations based on LLMs to create a varied set, and
utilizing the LLMs to select a suitable CoT prompting for a given problem.
Additionally, a rewriting operation, guided by the selected CoT prompting,
enhances the understanding of the LLMs about the problem. Extensive experiments
conducted across ten reasoning datasets demonstrate the superior performance of
our proposed method compared to current zero-shot CoT prompting methods on
GPT-3.5-turbo and GPT-4. Moreover, in-depth analytical experiments underscore
the adaptability and effectiveness of our method in various reasoning tasks. | [
0.0249439534,
0.0248203147,
-0.0154258013,
0.0358015709,
-0.0773409605,
0.0325587988,
0.0098743839,
0.003727013,
-0.0184727143,
-0.0542811491,
-0.0164086297,
-0.0274031796,
-0.0233616158,
0.0041300566,
0.0160191227,
-0.0300701335,
0.0704062432,
-0.0602234118,
-0.0105564548,
-0.010905629,
-0.012501061,
0.021048734,
-0.0086629149,
0.0219550971,
0.0270939562,
-0.0354358442,
-0.0452447832,
-0.0065632835,
0.0307346042,
-0.0425511822,
-0.0081214868,
0.0811315179,
0.0330821089,
0.0858336762,
0.0000022245,
-0.055771023,
-0.0369819663,
-0.0108565111,
-0.0734109953,
-0.02878993,
0.012771666,
0.0461807325,
-0.0015060243,
0.02443498,
-0.0285871699,
0.0124473274,
0.0074134553,
0.0215708017,
0.0557604469,
0.0636139661,
0.007248193,
-0.0291222464,
0.0035863828,
-0.0128500974,
0.045651339,
-0.0260534752,
0.0280311573,
0.0038528743,
0.0393721201,
0.0305518024,
-0.0063435179,
0.0207809228,
0.0296717174,
0.008375315,
-0.0111891031,
0.0376567543,
-0.0613940023,
-0.0047567072,
-0.0168064497,
0.0782671422,
-0.0373473428,
-0.0343637355,
-0.0130348559,
0.0033498427,
0.0046606911,
-0.032705456,
-0.0482909568,
0.0309343748,
-0.0067619979,
0.0186986197,
0.0289263614,
-0.014178643,
0.0029611145,
0.0069207284,
-0.0510306992,
0.0871030763,
0.0278209709,
-0.0513621904,
-0.0135617619,
-0.0168182366,
-0.0271955263,
-0.0792599842,
-0.0178377517,
0.0460851453,
-0.0365599096,
0.0265356097,
-0.0460693054,
-0.0484230295,
-0.0057868343,
0.0193956923,
0.04680847,
0.0536630191,
0.005507946,
0.0497081056,
-0.0727144703,
0.0425483435,
-0.0144457845,
-0.022693919,
-0.0447174273,
-0.0022055076,
-0.1017817482,
-0.0179948118,
-0.0323063359,
0.0668826476,
-0.0288204998,
-0.0148849301,
-0.0328453816,
0.0484706387,
0.0394007266,
0.0030717708,
0.0170930568,
-0.0078156758,
0.0044810274,
-0.039157223,
-0.0343660302,
0.0284935962,
-0.0306083467,
0.0187720452,
0.0121803526,
-0.0280983299,
-0.010349228,
-0.0039934935,
0.0203310791,
-0.0309947394,
0.0093674073,
0.0483984835,
-0.0131310914,
-0.0445510484,
-0.0613732524,
-0.0130705666,
-0.015052909,
-0.0574226566,
0.0062263943,
-0.0583407953,
0.0177138466,
-0.00146081,
-0.0317266881,
0.0276343767,
0.0094950525,
0.0250500981,
-0.0189558025,
0.0555940866,
-0.0263667516,
0.019942997,
0.0019843196,
-0.0063691353,
-0.0211863555,
0.0813530236,
0.0011443027,
-0.0057815611,
-0.0009622629,
0.0355662815,
-0.0134191839,
0.0055213198,
0.0032420782,
0.0182420351,
0.0062854476,
0.0182325933,
0.0283640232,
0.0427292548,
-0.0027328478,
0.0230630096,
-0.0449367613,
0.0028363867,
0.0496296063,
0.0471735857,
0.0319427438,
0.032347519,
0.0837735757,
0.0049245772,
-0.0337636806,
0.0016273898,
-0.0561907999,
0.0196095109,
-0.073374629,
0.0125896437,
0.0061313361,
0.0272023678,
-0.022435965,
-0.0322975367,
-0.0049117105,
0.0428203605,
-0.0295226909,
0.0159403104,
0.0288260598,
-0.0003051217,
-0.0460080244,
0.0099922875,
0.016860785,
-0.0122733479,
-0.0546280891,
-0.0697931275,
0.0536975078,
0.0816857666,
0.0417883918,
0.0081459908,
-0.0939244553,
-0.0077266693,
0.0136650447,
0.0235584248,
0.0014255424,
0.0006932776,
-0.0361931734,
-0.0616123751,
-0.0363476612,
-0.0064524487,
0.0068179048,
0.0198405497,
0.0302775688,
0.0217476357,
0.0380346254,
0.0050532655,
0.030921597,
0.0234841444,
-0.0153775923,
-0.0068516191,
0.0188937094,
-0.0060269572,
0.0168599598,
0.0046299319,
-0.0041974634,
0.0069803563,
-0.0125804022,
-0.0199567266,
-0.0362361446,
0.0065989261,
-0.0531995371,
-0.066646263,
0.0494800247,
-0.0040484336,
-0.0306665096,
-0.0436954647,
-0.0408257805,
-0.0403009951,
0.0053131669,
0.0034015866,
0.0352576487,
-0.047717981,
0.0421798155,
-0.005242628,
-0.0171795804,
-0.0454821959,
0.1088050827,
0.0150769548,
-0.0153537113,
0.0494513251,
0.0155527005,
0.0325259939,
-0.0595163703,
-0.0206614044,
-0.0044278586,
0.0010411467,
-0.0405820608,
-0.0198824592,
0.0609483458,
-0.0675678998,
-0.0254299566,
-0.1016349941,
0.0446036495,
-0.0046220771,
0.0387492925,
0.0231128074,
-0.0011790418,
-0.0310902894,
0.0229028556,
-0.0505360626,
0.0268348064,
0.0021947941,
0.0077559231,
0.0298941042,
-0.0236665737,
-0.02137517,
0.024006458,
-0.008079675,
-0.0485134348,
0.0461845174,
-0.0129383514,
0.0178475641,
-0.0474540517,
0.0319506489,
-0.047893282,
0.0195674039,
0.0162979104,
0.0110736936,
0.0153782796,
-0.0172860343,
0.0799708292,
0.0583082028,
-0.0167412218,
-0.0371043086,
0.0631392896,
-0.0042185737,
-0.0227408241,
0.0253642797,
-0.0040585808,
-0.008845821,
0.015856795,
0.0021564721,
-0.0281329062,
0.0661746114,
-0.0226753503,
-0.0420085452,
-0.0723237768,
0.0255531874,
-0.0068187336,
0.000682271,
-0.0490704179,
-0.0152551308,
0.0010472656,
0.0492021292,
-0.0240214877,
-0.0062815668,
0.0906600282,
0.0001570955,
0.0041307635,
-0.0818761066,
0.0302019883,
-0.0491818227,
0.0641427562,
-0.0168480463,
0.0013508465,
0.0577394143,
0.0138572566,
-0.0741293803,
-0.0015244803,
0.0018761698,
-0.0071834424,
0.031132035,
-0.0634003133,
0.0218201261,
-0.004870553,
-0.0513309017,
-0.042549964,
-0.0116087291,
-0.0387419388,
0.0179587081,
-0.0208157822,
0.0037509764,
-0.006246205,
-0.007135178,
0.0308183543,
0.0509221666,
-0.0332605243,
-0.0053643798,
-0.038100373,
0.0381182022,
0.0598750859,
0.0050731883,
0.0264945347,
-0.006326512,
0.0616335683,
0.0204121098,
0.0470492318,
0.0101411939,
-0.0339287482,
0.0315089822,
-0.0098652756,
-0.0396203324,
-0.039800141,
0.0156416688,
0.0142756598,
-0.0729222372,
0.0138891311,
0.1106306463,
0.0437897183,
-0.0531741083,
-0.0129472287,
-0.0488199219,
0.0433897488,
0.0282942019,
0.0538506843,
-0.123548992,
-0.0573079735,
0.0269436277,
-0.031214036,
-0.0300818067,
-0.0438335836,
-0.0024694277,
-0.141211614,
0.0283836182,
-0.0110205757,
0.0012429543,
0.0479791425,
-0.003856855,
0.0111774029,
0.0293888748,
-0.0106488159,
0.0393618234,
0.012062598,
0.000610001,
0.0126070837,
0.0437441468,
-0.0598995537,
0.053975407,
-0.0093374467,
0.0308159683,
0.0517622083,
-0.0050533386,
0.0383326411,
-0.0526190773,
0.042941343,
-0.0104889851,
0.0137711931,
-0.0275413673,
-0.0049036439,
-0.0088180248,
0.0120798908,
-0.0373868123,
0.0509894788,
-0.0104761757,
-0.0091108978,
0.0304461103,
0.1199778244,
-0.0141962497,
-0.0284915231,
-0.022608757,
-0.0144793233,
-0.0143935829,
0.0561974347,
0.0299479552,
-0.035312064,
-0.0346896499,
-0.0164839625,
-0.058100991,
-0.0472171977,
-0.0166335758,
0.0141113196,
0.0106084747,
-0.0051691169,
-0.054633107,
0.0003615034,
0.0695875585,
0.0611779429,
0.0207035486,
0.0184615608,
-0.0212998353,
0.0131439874,
-0.0152018191,
0.0191794913,
-0.0592026263,
-0.0021710305,
-0.0546661131,
0.0255587939,
0.0284111314,
-0.0353530869,
-0.0253452938,
0.0121076042,
-0.0787427872,
-0.0614505522,
-0.0463947356,
0.0414252728,
0.0295219347,
0.0450940132,
-0.0166850295,
-0.0411932021,
0.0519100167,
0.0160097666,
0.0235394221,
-0.0000946377,
-0.0141962664,
0.0247091949,
0.0064952052,
0.0343186706,
-0.017461041,
0.019077329,
0.0177872572,
0.0600404404,
-0.0139711918,
0.020198375,
0.0347776338,
0.0361335091,
-0.0034765853,
-0.0343209691,
-0.0016686972,
-0.021673644,
0.055192668,
-0.0210176725,
-0.0389148258,
-0.0205350146,
0.0299653485,
0.0067743547,
-0.0302724522,
0.0150308665,
-0.0493480526,
-0.0163544007,
0.0171802733,
-0.0161293149,
-0.0079382965,
0.0093044154,
0.0338289849,
0.0508321151,
-0.0214375556,
-0.0006976315,
0.018555861,
0.0207345877,
0.0189753789,
-0.0440901257,
0.0933501273,
0.0481717624,
-0.0065260991,
-0.0599383451,
0.0457895845,
-0.0593031831,
-0.0229951665,
0.0170238931,
0.0650851354,
0.0614524968,
0.0278254896,
-0.0135326413,
-0.0307440404,
-0.0350954011,
0.0192136765,
0.0246991254,
0.0081988564,
-0.0348049961,
0.0167519432,
0.0304350182,
-0.0066260435,
-0.0145643447,
0.0557207055,
-0.0163807422,
0.0252036992,
0.028627621,
0.0128346616,
-0.0330879129,
-0.0045378041,
-0.016211912,
-0.0085371668,
-0.000022466,
0.0514727011,
-0.074892208,
-0.0599198639,
-0.0078279274,
0.0154318288,
0.0155739319,
0.0029847559,
0.0453520045,
0.0599095747,
-0.017552454,
-0.051692605,
0.0071016653,
-0.0035630276,
0.0073535014,
-0.0550448671,
-0.0405321233,
-6.621587596e-33,
-0.0087203383,
-0.0066521079,
0.0665139407,
-0.0138228843,
-0.0329281054,
-0.0063091712,
-0.0321497992,
0.0129731614,
-0.02538619,
-0.0204841197,
-0.0385723375,
-0.0103034806,
-0.0050061867,
0.0013812655,
0.0106813647,
-0.0317704119,
-0.0026786372,
-0.0165511463,
-0.0158285499,
0.0178741813,
0.017341489,
0.0149546415,
0.0241830852,
0.0158268325,
-0.0070007113,
0.008981321,
0.0087365415,
0.0436946414,
-0.0498220436,
0.042637717,
-0.0245093945,
0.0128912022,
0.0316421688,
-0.0428144634,
-0.0030592014,
0.0005460936,
-0.0417933017,
-0.0503872074,
0.0334569439,
-0.0381371044,
-0.0467859767,
-0.0561654493,
0.001609585,
0.022858819,
-0.0159325413,
-0.0193293728,
0.0115720639,
-0.0205821358,
-0.0037976482,
-0.0034732618,
-0.0487920158,
0.0230291523,
-0.0001922344,
-0.0439436287,
0.0094721606,
0.0468854867,
-0.0089306226,
0.0178354662,
0.0108809695,
0.0357789807,
0.053773202,
0.0160753708,
0.0613084808,
0.0036715106,
0.0112340366,
0.0058421777,
-0.029140465,
-0.0071889488,
-0.0428701267,
-0.0079129711,
0.0208852366,
0.037476752,
0.0422757305,
0.0083103916,
0.0366424285,
0.047154244,
-0.0702584907,
0.000455902,
0.0398073383,
0.0080400063,
0.040698532,
0.0048741512,
0.0037603644,
-0.008233401,
-0.0431678742,
-0.011886619,
-0.0652925521,
-0.0237957258,
0.0481415465,
-0.0034210454,
-0.0206959285,
-0.0171900447,
0.047862161,
-0.0192471687,
-0.0037110273,
0.0193433817,
-0.0291383043,
0.0165280811,
0.0113262823,
0.0545923524,
-0.0294884034,
-0.0256145354,
0.0133739756,
0.0236717127,
0.0131139467,
-0.013744236,
0.0298926514,
0.0038572154,
-0.0317783579,
-0.0097746998,
-0.057381466,
0.0273834318,
-0.0128864124,
0.0128449956,
0.0142907742,
0.0559614487,
0.0226088446,
0.0235322621,
0.0427848734,
-0.0184891187,
-0.033371456,
0.0325823575,
-0.0109028574,
0.0242607016,
-0.018984681,
0.0286219195,
-0.0044001234,
0.0108639384,
-0.0029179368,
-0.0592103712,
-0.0248228572,
0.058635205,
3.045e-7,
0.0265603233,
0.0601540282,
-0.0040499154,
-0.0065324828,
0.0240575485,
0.033613909,
-0.0190327615,
-0.0195252392,
0.0269158762,
-0.0252783485,
0.01996883,
0.0394464694,
0.016510902,
0.0045246319,
-0.1088935956,
-0.0123537257,
-0.0330078639,
-0.0059684748,
-0.0974987969,
0.0140170576,
0.07298664,
0.0948130414,
0.0131547721,
-0.0210731383,
0.0343541615,
-0.0057196296,
0.0279840454,
0.021146778,
0.0186417326,
0.0118754171,
-0.0226244405,
-0.0101099983,
-0.0055576004,
0.0444137864,
0.0192018654,
0.0359304026,
-0.0286911651,
0.0443700589,
-0.0002668863,
0.0024482524,
0.0182710588,
-0.010608335,
-0.0125568453,
-0.0817862675,
0.1239449158,
-0.0477720052,
-0.0202278607,
-0.0031900904,
-0.0098151825,
-0.0211995412,
-0.0227566212,
-0.0174606424,
-0.0061571803,
0.0255149454,
0.0050902311,
-0.0115002962,
-0.0114510721,
-0.0789092705,
0.017871365,
0.0097263856,
-0.0539308935,
-0.031085398,
-0.0536090583,
0.0081558172,
0.044515729,
-0.0403751358,
-0.0094442954,
3.166530841e-34,
0.017025141,
-0.0273797605,
0.0378642865,
0.027534781,
0.0281552766,
0.0047220355,
-0.0362367481,
0.0004058394,
0.0309503581,
-0.1126713008,
-0.0399042629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05374v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05374v2 | CIC: A framework for Culturally-aware Image Captioning | 2024-02-08T03:12:25 | 2024-05-02T02:41:50 | Youngsik Yun, Jihie Kim | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Image Captioning generates descriptive sentences from images using
Vision-Language Pre-trained models (VLPs) such as BLIP, which has improved
greatly. However, current methods lack the generation of detailed descriptive
captions for the cultural elements depicted in the images, such as the
traditional clothing worn by people from Asian cultural groups. In this paper,
we propose a new framework, \textbf{Culturally-aware Image Captioning (CIC)},
that generates captions and describes cultural elements extracted from cultural
visual elements in images representing cultures. Inspired by methods combining
visual modality and Large Language Models (LLMs) through appropriate prompts,
our framework (1) generates questions based on cultural categories from images,
(2) extracts cultural visual elements from Visual Question Answering (VQA)
using generated questions, and (3) generates culturally-aware captions using
LLMs with the prompts. Our human evaluation conducted on 45 participants from 4
different cultural groups with a high understanding of the corresponding
culture shows that our proposed framework generates more culturally descriptive
captions when compared to the image captioning baseline based on VLPs. Our code
and dataset will be made publicly available upon acceptance. | [
0.0406037159,
0.0507521667,
-0.0068173944,
0.03932634,
0.0000622816,
0.0365170166,
0.0241240487,
-0.0296021085,
0.0216082726,
-0.0545541756,
-0.0359806605,
-0.0426636375,
-0.0020032825,
0.0588279851,
0.002379694,
-0.0843060911,
0.0090132393,
-0.0329362638,
0.019225413,
-0.0062248157,
0.0285857674,
0.0226172879,
0.0245066695,
0.0239098128,
-0.0122048631,
-0.0211099461,
0.0257006418,
-0.0041538165,
0.0156217525,
-0.0221891049,
0.0045647309,
0.0500648133,
0.0499056466,
-0.0222787224,
0.0000016851,
-0.0238715261,
0.066982843,
-0.0190963354,
0.0618403368,
0.0196161829,
0.0610893779,
-0.00403438,
0.0265985485,
0.0021379769,
-0.0484730229,
-0.0350604393,
0.0735547543,
0.0724827573,
0.080136992,
0.0118864775,
-0.0138561614,
-0.0614695363,
-0.0679588243,
-0.0167297348,
-0.0038925831,
0.0063790516,
0.0014359785,
0.0790588707,
0.0102837086,
-0.0108723799,
-0.0291847195,
0.0415430553,
-0.0032498145,
-0.0246555433,
-0.0194414109,
0.0211294498,
-0.0472143292,
-0.0388309248,
-0.0190293193,
0.1095280722,
0.056514129,
0.0177506488,
-0.0134952022,
0.0306799915,
-0.0178426411,
-0.0223895032,
-0.050315842,
0.0581187531,
0.0171305332,
0.0064814775,
-0.0253382567,
0.0272584502,
0.0044582943,
0.0491461419,
0.024738783,
-0.0094749918,
0.0129370373,
0.0320405066,
-0.0953477249,
-0.0135783721,
-0.0415313691,
-0.0540572628,
0.0023651719,
0.0247702319,
0.0077809929,
0.0029659714,
-0.0246608984,
0.0318303443,
-0.0025690554,
-0.0088770371,
0.0043737423,
0.0196877308,
-0.0756761208,
0.0696415082,
0.006658663,
0.0637479275,
-0.0177954454,
0.0137016103,
-0.0640729293,
-0.0197654087,
-0.0062536332,
-0.0035734631,
-0.0042272764,
-0.0050197411,
-0.0548169464,
-0.0313118435,
-0.0432861932,
0.0043180543,
-0.0273848455,
-0.0066123833,
-0.0247466099,
0.0121192783,
-0.0097315926,
0.0089703426,
-0.0308904108,
0.0264246892,
-0.0086909486,
-0.0126233259,
-0.0357494131,
-0.0329704508,
0.0249399431,
0.0332759693,
0.007320073,
-0.0179724358,
-0.0032586125,
0.021448046,
-0.031697616,
0.0060639218,
-0.026567772,
-0.0105076069,
-0.027400665,
-0.0190986991,
0.0270769447,
-0.0693465844,
0.0230438393,
-0.010615414,
0.0111209322,
-0.023953801,
0.02461881,
0.0332416855,
-0.0266588442,
0.0829494372,
0.0091733756,
0.0285270866,
0.0601739883,
0.0226943363,
0.0158124492,
0.0695089325,
0.026327936,
0.031517677,
0.0882073641,
-0.0292885378,
0.0211477485,
0.0320963487,
-0.0236529149,
-0.015028974,
-0.0570448451,
0.0274193566,
0.0254214667,
-0.0013898157,
0.0428623445,
0.0585700311,
0.0097746607,
0.0359199122,
0.0726875439,
0.0428514779,
-0.0261819307,
0.0484681055,
0.0638794601,
0.000381087,
0.0019245122,
0.0132264998,
-0.0538641065,
0.0527140424,
0.0125504369,
0.0048320396,
-0.0207839403,
0.0598311312,
-0.0507133044,
-0.0310040172,
0.0014609031,
-0.0090338718,
0.0383368284,
0.0343135446,
0.0174864419,
0.0049258368,
0.0060631754,
0.015423595,
0.009253799,
-0.049783498,
0.0058656773,
-0.0229889192,
0.0407919511,
0.0528041311,
0.009171213,
-0.005996062,
0.0188444015,
-0.0046494631,
0.0755651966,
0.0337201208,
0.0238373186,
0.0102790147,
-0.0004067845,
-0.0369319059,
-0.0271222852,
-0.0225446653,
-0.0306326356,
0.0026093379,
0.0177062973,
0.0073426492,
0.0515709184,
0.0337937139,
-0.0520585179,
0.0129651465,
0.0385614932,
-0.0244455747,
0.0059324256,
0.0091862995,
-0.0119478228,
0.0350907333,
-0.0357949734,
-0.0009852116,
-0.006671703,
-0.0374639481,
-0.0057621105,
0.0675661862,
-0.0886764526,
-0.0548222438,
0.0312373266,
-0.0676669255,
-0.0175509602,
-0.0040615746,
-0.0301401652,
-0.0442705415,
0.0159453824,
-0.0269790608,
-0.0366432332,
-0.096268706,
-0.0322168544,
0.0017855483,
0.0378819034,
-0.014805221,
0.0530778654,
0.0010075379,
-0.0378427282,
0.0210733041,
-0.0114034554,
-0.0122975502,
-0.0240084175,
-0.0548055954,
0.0407405794,
0.0120407818,
0.0198247302,
0.0262981839,
0.0693554655,
-0.0379935168,
0.0137603572,
-0.1332627237,
-0.0153146246,
-0.0223493706,
-0.0335595012,
-0.0157655086,
0.0068364912,
-0.0236898661,
-0.0553602055,
-0.0678585619,
-0.0036670018,
0.0191197358,
0.0262085274,
0.05791777,
0.0179155096,
-0.0152151315,
-0.0017436759,
-0.0200939588,
0.0381595306,
0.0831616372,
0.0172985252,
-0.0086909244,
-0.0315220617,
-0.0274131354,
-0.0498946346,
0.0084440457,
0.0232431404,
-0.0589025393,
-0.0187602174,
0.0102020102,
0.0450421721,
0.0317785479,
0.0393043421,
-0.0053758081,
0.007692066,
-0.0188900586,
0.0132184168,
-0.0183549058,
0.0080820546,
-0.0475567803,
0.061765831,
-0.060451474,
-0.009950297,
0.0163826346,
-0.0067807729,
0.0138913644,
-0.035417702,
0.0321228057,
-0.0089101112,
-0.0637300238,
-0.0541403331,
0.0099519463,
-0.0047918814,
0.0501276255,
-0.0379699655,
-0.0511291139,
0.0423001237,
-0.0329282582,
-0.0517715886,
0.0193673354,
-0.0075196815,
-0.0576524287,
0.0709934384,
-0.0002097873,
0.0399768054,
-0.0115990816,
-0.0268750899,
-0.0056036119,
-0.0529900976,
0.0113376183,
-0.0429158472,
0.0466559231,
-0.0726820976,
-0.0414151885,
-0.0251064189,
-0.0317931958,
-0.0463609733,
-0.0234576873,
-0.0180464163,
0.0115910238,
-0.0409018509,
0.0307672843,
0.0253267139,
0.0496320464,
0.0314860903,
-0.0105685126,
-0.0215202682,
0.0363236256,
0.0055668978,
0.0543006398,
0.0662107542,
0.0410274826,
-0.0348169394,
0.0042027053,
0.0293645933,
0.0055050142,
0.0042508347,
0.0026660117,
-0.0280371904,
0.0398976244,
0.0274584759,
0.0339998044,
-0.0023142588,
0.0070926221,
0.0877413303,
-0.035772182,
0.0167684015,
0.1155523881,
0.020429099,
-0.0456213467,
-0.03838256,
0.0105587738,
0.0035506829,
0.0397831239,
0.0329451114,
-0.0871551633,
-0.0109878806,
-0.0291760918,
-0.0033555364,
0.0056844666,
0.0251779445,
-0.030134514,
-0.0728194788,
0.0311964583,
0.0172519516,
-0.0288803112,
-0.0629139021,
0.0292248875,
-0.037924733,
0.004972382,
-0.007741922,
-0.0282717366,
-0.0216956139,
0.01701097,
-0.0114820739,
-0.0267084427,
-0.0224906653,
0.0303370208,
-0.0500234924,
0.0150239849,
0.0668554977,
0.0220213234,
-0.0197472852,
-0.0574658066,
-0.0223379228,
-0.0397045426,
-0.0025353311,
-0.0214681011,
0.0125510497,
0.001952238,
-0.0622949079,
0.0066390573,
0.0290907901,
0.0104758544,
-0.0204439946,
0.0382568054,
-0.0074538216,
0.0156836789,
-0.0088151265,
-0.0319407322,
0.0452724844,
0.0144319115,
0.068509765,
0.0510456339,
-0.0581249185,
0.0019729992,
-0.0374185145,
-0.0386617109,
-0.0350325815,
-0.0530170649,
0.0138605433,
-0.0166528691,
0.0085957823,
-0.0869761854,
-0.0136983469,
0.040981058,
0.009435528,
0.0234070402,
-0.0368754007,
-0.0189414695,
0.0669078082,
-0.0627396256,
0.0602615811,
-0.0597977266,
0.0115790721,
-0.0199625753,
-0.0024355876,
0.046309229,
-0.0590874664,
-0.0047871354,
0.0245482661,
-0.0378911346,
-0.0073247235,
-0.0044854842,
0.0700321048,
-0.0020419799,
-0.0048678317,
0.0392667018,
-0.0559921227,
0.0039724782,
0.0110120187,
0.0523756817,
-0.0191995855,
-0.019914249,
0.0042720372,
-0.0132676708,
0.0213314015,
-0.0177845769,
0.0400900878,
0.0083413469,
0.0381717458,
-0.0085427072,
-0.0351647139,
-0.0093263797,
0.0205332432,
-0.003204617,
-0.0481302999,
0.0094460119,
-0.0181334503,
-0.0257728137,
-0.0034494377,
-0.0337967277,
-0.0535456203,
0.0187971313,
-0.0032011836,
0.0295101628,
0.008344885,
-0.0104115857,
-0.0084850006,
0.0018142554,
-0.030807836,
0.027500486,
0.0417973734,
-0.0025184255,
-0.0401978232,
0.0135016823,
-0.031902805,
0.0309521519,
-0.0262602884,
0.016547488,
-0.0157976132,
0.105092451,
-0.015543865,
-0.0218769666,
-0.0233998485,
0.045260746,
0.0237383321,
-0.0177956037,
-0.0023027207,
0.0556675158,
0.0823659599,
-0.0356914699,
-0.0122858305,
0.0273332316,
-0.0206607915,
-0.0023732337,
0.0568647832,
0.0129868658,
-0.0543428212,
0.0637188107,
0.0133841345,
-0.0222978909,
-0.008450144,
0.0353162289,
-0.0193491615,
-0.0127448449,
0.0379373655,
-0.058987163,
-0.0354049914,
-0.0051197587,
0.0262695402,
-0.0253212247,
-0.01725954,
0.0610162392,
-0.0226641018,
-0.0537875332,
0.0072065736,
0.0036364915,
0.0009302596,
0.0533500277,
0.048510585,
0.0484843031,
0.0220473055,
-0.0204304177,
-0.044884447,
-0.003955747,
-0.0483213849,
0.0278573148,
-0.0110559948,
-5.663371254e-33,
-0.0577267557,
-0.0426881574,
0.0050835782,
0.0028787421,
-0.0415991955,
0.0022311441,
-0.0435654037,
0.0113987876,
-0.0094627831,
0.0068761008,
0.0048914994,
-0.0306278225,
0.0186441224,
0.0626262426,
0.0043502101,
0.0035924278,
0.0203171503,
0.0274613481,
-0.0189130139,
0.0059587122,
0.0114362529,
0.0019781752,
0.0169819556,
-0.068951413,
-0.0041407449,
-0.0241766535,
-0.0177766941,
0.0230644885,
0.0661568344,
0.0691484511,
-0.0485895872,
0.0307231508,
0.0243904274,
0.0187984258,
-0.0127944797,
0.0518296249,
-0.0667657778,
0.0137863755,
0.0484684929,
0.0293212384,
-0.0127693936,
-0.0311929192,
-0.0221100915,
-0.0658109188,
0.0104628019,
0.0041230689,
0.0743657872,
-0.0422752574,
0.0240228362,
-0.0064688399,
-0.0239778962,
-0.0031904872,
-0.0090704914,
-0.0032083918,
0.0142728379,
0.0496689267,
0.0081908014,
0.0227073394,
-0.0128266579,
0.055381272,
0.0275119189,
-0.0015506285,
0.0806487128,
0.0713815764,
0.0266269594,
0.0211452283,
-0.0025101344,
-0.0120570725,
-0.032773409,
-0.0073907319,
0.0096445438,
0.0177968424,
0.0206445027,
0.0898469165,
0.0000122995,
0.029034378,
-0.0169979092,
0.0023171427,
-0.0371846519,
0.0139212869,
0.0184963644,
-0.0032152599,
0.0050561675,
0.0298183039,
-0.0523219034,
0.0090668872,
-0.045813024,
-0.0364214145,
0.0300874114,
0.0135121131,
-0.0571472533,
0.0481899455,
0.0669300184,
-0.0444241837,
0.0161879752,
-0.0208649002,
-0.0055945492,
0.0064024264,
0.0058844965,
-0.0006252967,
-0.0053292159,
-0.0150907366,
0.0463540368,
-0.0150965229,
-0.014910006,
-0.0047965213,
0.0309283771,
0.0268384591,
-0.0384373628,
-0.0064877989,
-0.009393896,
-0.0049197054,
-0.0649608821,
0.0160279367,
0.007672302,
0.0231659263,
-0.0908082724,
-0.0266547985,
-0.0036785356,
-0.0168690812,
-0.0195248313,
-0.0928947851,
0.0023076991,
0.0555789508,
-0.0578993335,
0.0338460393,
-0.0293154474,
0.0126498193,
-0.0146754878,
-0.0301380251,
-0.0237723365,
0.026580153,
2.279e-7,
0.0017085605,
-0.0063410117,
0.0009731043,
0.0578451157,
0.0132138161,
0.0153040616,
0.0026087125,
-0.0037038797,
0.0240184087,
-0.0187846385,
0.0450385474,
0.0379146375,
0.0510995872,
-0.0337376595,
-0.059417326,
-0.0148543026,
-0.0162997283,
0.0087082675,
-0.0289351586,
-0.0228063185,
0.0443561822,
0.0756905675,
-0.0216528438,
-0.009016661,
-0.0093169101,
-0.1045039073,
0.0809054375,
-0.049939841,
-0.0183591954,
-0.0068548904,
-0.0023491338,
0.0167994481,
-0.0237080269,
-0.0248240959,
0.0038490142,
0.0071671414,
0.0850948617,
0.049531471,
0.0130668879,
0.0099136112,
-0.0520120598,
0.0803336203,
-0.0120740421,
-0.0658225045,
0.0782405138,
-0.0475690477,
-0.0279872306,
-0.0603980049,
-0.0033541671,
-0.0156351142,
0.040350683,
-0.0517511293,
-0.0365891345,
0.024983434,
0.0427277759,
-0.0400652289,
-0.0136653241,
-0.0505208112,
-0.0135682318,
-0.0134134237,
-0.0166759323,
-0.0116878664,
-0.0348604359,
-0.0335275978,
-0.0174583178,
0.0251251012,
-0.0060647908,
1.536329905e-34,
0.0526137762,
-0.0141092604,
-0.0212590005,
0.0086403498,
0.0395869389,
-0.0082105584,
-0.0117770331,
-0.0237843096,
0.0092133833,
-0.0590172932,
-0.0004145675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05369v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05369v2 | Noise Contrastive Alignment of Language Models with Explicit Rewards | 2024-02-08T02:58:47 | 2024-07-03T13:53:06 | Huayu Chen, Guande He, Lifan Yuan, Ganqu Cui, Hang Su, Jun Zhu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | User intentions are typically formalized as evaluation rewards to be
maximized when fine-tuning language models (LMs). Existing alignment methods,
such as Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), are mainly tailored for pairwise
preference data where rewards are implicitly defined rather than explicitly
given. In this paper, we introduce a general framework for LM alignment,
leveraging Noise Contrastive Estimation (NCE) to bridge the gap in handling
reward datasets explicitly annotated with scalar evaluations. Our framework
comprises two parallel algorithms, NCA and InfoNCA, both enabling the direct
extraction of an LM policy from reward data as well as preference data.
Notably, we show that the DPO loss is a special case of our proposed InfoNCA
objective under pairwise preference settings, thereby integrating and extending
current alignment theories. By comparing NCA and InfoNCA, we demonstrate that
the well-observed decreasing-likelihood trend of DPO/InfoNCA is caused by their
focus on adjusting relative likelihood across different responses. In contrast,
NCA optimizes the absolute likelihood for each response, thereby effectively
preventing the chosen likelihood from decreasing. We evaluate our methods in
both reward and preference settings with Mistral-8*7B and 7B models.
Experiments suggest that InfoNCA/NCA surpasses various preference baselines
when reward datasets are available. We also find NCA significantly outperforms
DPO in complex reasoning tasks like math and coding. | [
0.0166362654,
0.0897458494,
0.0052649612,
0.0462664552,
-0.0371416397,
0.0104360487,
-0.0081044016,
-0.0323083363,
-0.0440233909,
-0.0016342959,
-0.0743491501,
-0.0419462956,
0.0240093954,
-0.0193275269,
0.0136164473,
-0.0737235695,
0.0288698152,
-0.0493979752,
0.0395444036,
-0.0164971184,
0.0172280073,
0.0083687836,
0.0008324215,
0.035887491,
0.0670654774,
-0.0281724278,
0.019040823,
0.0058953147,
0.0342976488,
-0.0380400009,
0.0384147428,
0.0571757741,
0.0322587043,
0.0214216411,
0.0000023272,
-0.0690101087,
-0.00941524,
0.0093346564,
-0.0233379416,
0.0361150429,
0.015486367,
0.0279840436,
0.0002430806,
0.0160988998,
-0.0131931687,
0.0040961141,
0.0813318044,
0.0120243654,
0.0232996903,
0.0199342985,
-0.0034673633,
-0.0367355756,
0.0006992229,
-0.0352078564,
0.0235068537,
-0.0247030538,
0.0064420151,
-0.0169086345,
-0.0335211232,
0.0028492222,
0.0034655284,
0.036614228,
-0.0069341464,
0.0154203428,
-0.0010529513,
0.0330288783,
0.0406045057,
-0.0081860116,
-0.0349937901,
0.0492772497,
0.0057054483,
-0.0166112836,
-0.0070538009,
-0.0384024233,
-0.0103734685,
-0.0058137788,
-0.0165493954,
-0.0217827242,
0.0095702689,
0.0227564834,
0.0810121745,
0.0370770842,
0.0343277976,
0.0134105152,
-0.01756409,
0.0303690284,
0.0216760896,
-0.0423049703,
0.0002191611,
-0.0063060885,
-0.0420180336,
-0.0506914258,
-0.0071239737,
-0.0146397138,
-0.0555670187,
0.0277657062,
-0.0424895547,
-0.0139731951,
0.0026793417,
-0.0415153205,
0.0691636726,
0.0766450912,
0.0036313883,
0.0463606417,
0.0128071234,
0.0664912015,
-0.0194466989,
0.0038961533,
-0.0370099805,
0.0290393103,
0.0158644896,
-0.0066518285,
0.0017197797,
0.0064128968,
-0.0365130417,
-0.0167040192,
-0.0401796103,
0.0486562811,
-0.0150830653,
0.0457281731,
0.0334697887,
-0.01041805,
-0.0493746363,
0.0022691961,
-0.0534405671,
0.0364633724,
-0.0179248285,
0.0291552115,
0.0434811935,
-0.0067662946,
-0.002516696,
0.0119516207,
-0.0174346864,
-0.0415523797,
0.0072629494,
0.102782093,
0.0076970602,
-0.0008970703,
-0.0065739071,
-0.0273804069,
-0.0257805288,
-0.0342272148,
-0.0372708701,
-0.080870457,
0.0195337869,
0.0108435126,
-0.0111045195,
-0.0528651997,
-0.015334961,
-0.0029548022,
-0.0152309323,
0.0924708173,
-0.0018990517,
-0.0080913547,
-0.0092641786,
-0.0228222962,
-0.0171643905,
0.0623141937,
0.0438855141,
0.0246489681,
0.0213198308,
-0.0263567772,
-0.0320121795,
0.03959148,
0.0173747949,
0.0140305199,
-0.0337730683,
0.0115841962,
0.0257407613,
0.024069896,
0.0620250963,
0.0471024886,
-0.0111867003,
0.0024327319,
0.080461584,
0.0468220674,
0.0463663898,
-0.0498381369,
0.0002525384,
-0.0070439032,
-0.0371007957,
0.0235587861,
-0.0461127423,
0.0383675732,
-0.0298674311,
0.0478052385,
0.0921332538,
0.0187530126,
-0.0109596336,
-0.0598498993,
-0.0280821063,
0.0038698192,
0.0206063278,
0.0532487221,
0.0571126305,
-0.0181034263,
-0.0575095192,
0.0157541893,
0.0607979484,
-0.0346269123,
-0.0092067728,
-0.0554802231,
0.056654755,
0.0912708491,
0.0290703215,
-0.0006565413,
-0.016216971,
0.0045789713,
-0.0483683534,
0.049764812,
0.0449635126,
0.0031054246,
0.0257492121,
-0.0555830598,
-0.0517770126,
-0.0023330059,
0.0004726162,
0.0153671624,
0.022282457,
-0.0255592242,
-0.008137471,
-0.0141836023,
-0.0579553246,
0.0221237708,
-0.0178553555,
-0.0283621345,
-0.0020400118,
0.0106122922,
0.0510615893,
-0.0027028809,
0.0059318109,
0.0048171002,
0.0164413042,
-0.0094165774,
0.0614331439,
0.0126986708,
-0.0533837527,
-0.0335716009,
0.049185995,
-0.0088826809,
-0.0030609572,
0.0427629016,
-0.0131948516,
-0.0272502825,
0.0267546978,
-0.0067951493,
0.0505730137,
-0.0018239813,
0.0332447439,
-0.0165501162,
-0.0256914105,
-0.0512570329,
0.0496496074,
-0.0334641859,
0.0268491283,
0.024704732,
-0.0102211768,
-0.0184073076,
-0.0362155475,
-0.0381080545,
0.0133702913,
0.003581444,
0.0276630633,
0.0390509106,
0.0185321607,
-0.0285467412,
-0.0277753528,
-0.0391102061,
0.0172855984,
-0.0134876315,
0.0494070724,
0.0546119697,
0.0365438163,
0.0043032733,
0.0105229393,
-0.025459487,
-0.0072871074,
-0.0320390575,
0.0208114833,
0.013723217,
0.019325804,
-0.0340144336,
-0.065166831,
-0.0181065835,
-0.0192363895,
-0.0164555982,
-0.0113685569,
0.0227126013,
-0.0549630299,
0.0626884401,
-0.0339344256,
0.0145953307,
-0.0358430482,
-0.024953071,
0.0321172625,
-0.0104858764,
0.0385352932,
0.0649384707,
-0.0080772769,
0.0309865251,
0.0509226918,
-0.0099775745,
-0.0994704217,
0.0053209132,
-0.0329652689,
-0.020166643,
-0.0322849564,
-0.0588144474,
0.0144371297,
0.1167773828,
0.0049055014,
0.0204152223,
-0.0664523318,
-0.0092928335,
-0.0047736056,
-0.0142802391,
-0.0231936518,
0.0195850469,
-0.0317483246,
0.0545764752,
-0.0294235069,
-0.0766571984,
0.0989047959,
-0.0416653976,
0.0138215693,
-0.0423404239,
-0.0232832376,
-0.0175822061,
0.0092206299,
-0.0321444422,
0.0268060602,
0.0036519447,
-0.0235850457,
-0.0538541824,
-0.0339315198,
0.0569958352,
-0.0505488664,
0.0599687435,
-0.0338466093,
0.0098968381,
0.0014881863,
-0.0512165911,
-0.0236549787,
-0.0443124212,
-0.0088156816,
-0.0137920668,
0.0344234779,
-0.036898803,
0.0038187965,
0.0317912251,
0.0366514586,
0.0271043312,
0.0007399285,
-0.0092414813,
-0.0273940116,
-0.0025640109,
0.0996186212,
-0.0017170943,
0.0067752232,
-0.0563785583,
-0.0091508608,
-0.0010727659,
0.0434004329,
0.001334152,
-0.0111992909,
-0.0192748271,
0.0840662941,
-0.006654338,
-0.0077577457,
0.0599784441,
0.0788700581,
-0.0325209163,
-0.0142940721,
0.1096691936,
0.012582791,
-0.0608436726,
-0.0112850843,
-0.0271772332,
0.0744274706,
0.0001062457,
0.0056046383,
-0.0475018024,
-0.0404865816,
0.0046365201,
0.0630230606,
0.0031903426,
0.0236689299,
-0.0032973501,
-0.0996091738,
-0.0231354721,
0.0205741338,
-0.0461465195,
-0.0190763101,
-0.0384951942,
0.0223444682,
-0.0335468091,
0.0591282845,
0.0020565465,
0.0170428101,
-0.0022583359,
0.0209058356,
0.0133049255,
-0.0457329005,
-0.0059338235,
-0.0393151902,
0.0766049847,
0.0997582451,
-0.0156045211,
-0.0055734268,
-0.0734729767,
0.0144404089,
-0.0102135018,
-0.0306149591,
-0.0128323957,
-0.0061922986,
-0.0111610545,
-0.0051591541,
-0.0191699024,
0.0465131886,
-0.0294896476,
-0.0080757691,
-0.003594809,
0.0309630241,
0.0091321226,
0.0236959029,
-0.0080309846,
0.00340451,
0.0338578708,
0.0769866854,
0.0143316947,
-0.074127458,
0.0103947753,
-0.0479817651,
-0.0387630835,
-0.0307524223,
-0.0056949304,
-0.0373512544,
-0.0044621844,
-0.0209516119,
-0.0403008163,
-0.0411356874,
-0.0150708277,
0.0279186573,
0.0064069387,
0.0097233411,
-0.0042845132,
-0.0376900211,
-0.0357310176,
0.0390730202,
-0.0251925904,
0.0183658339,
-0.068870455,
-0.0205070712,
-0.0102640549,
-0.0403932482,
-0.012034134,
0.0204838645,
-0.0523856804,
-0.0957642719,
-0.0211222246,
0.0676360503,
0.0186628643,
0.0718364939,
-0.0007338948,
-0.0369002372,
0.0226945281,
0.0336447991,
-0.0023620713,
0.0118990242,
0.0222786721,
0.0140742222,
0.0032869177,
0.0184745342,
-0.0374957547,
-0.0344769992,
0.0356078856,
0.0426365249,
-0.0080473069,
-0.0372194313,
0.037571352,
0.0073324526,
0.0623495243,
-0.0365600064,
-0.0217659287,
-0.0305273347,
-0.0058969739,
-0.0055968291,
-0.0371682942,
-0.0148533583,
-0.0541926585,
0.0321281329,
-0.01348342,
0.0069220308,
0.0015347201,
-0.0043877158,
-0.0085403826,
-0.0631170869,
0.0210007727,
0.0105928583,
0.0353641994,
0.0436344966,
0.0070385314,
-0.0095256241,
0.0203001723,
-0.0058565061,
0.0643288642,
0.01067835,
0.053293664,
0.03033741,
0.0170491505,
0.0192703791,
0.029266648,
-0.0155570786,
-0.0482269526,
-0.0384256318,
-0.0521961637,
0.0363897197,
-0.0147658251,
0.0841769725,
-0.0118650617,
0.000740654,
-0.0205425564,
0.0341872051,
-0.0114869205,
-0.0101066697,
0.0384177491,
0.0272909906,
0.0018706861,
-0.0298565235,
0.0585940443,
-0.0338091329,
0.0210014284,
-0.037829034,
0.0056721945,
-0.0236285534,
-0.0133400438,
0.0151413623,
0.0714491904,
-0.0418954119,
-0.0349461325,
-0.0256469417,
-0.0594719127,
-0.0409985147,
0.0450644605,
-0.0124716554,
-0.0106319683,
0.0382599458,
0.0510118753,
-0.0459044203,
-0.02372998,
-0.0211228896,
-0.0166885629,
-0.0315304548,
-0.0314477757,
-0.065105319,
-7.040972389e-33,
-0.0458723158,
-0.0056496873,
0.0095529677,
-0.0075841476,
-0.0180541631,
-0.0065304535,
-0.0307498183,
0.0094430121,
-0.0273114126,
-0.0277383979,
0.008213778,
-0.0157315936,
0.0137736024,
0.0059915334,
0.0222352464,
-0.0121473148,
0.0330594704,
0.0066887117,
-0.0710424632,
-0.0127528952,
0.0240266211,
-0.0323643163,
0.0678144768,
-0.0821865201,
0.064422138,
0.022871444,
-0.0325669572,
0.0046056849,
-0.0145607106,
0.0711537302,
-0.0058040209,
0.0115964618,
-0.0144718848,
-0.045239307,
-0.0269231331,
-0.0156087894,
-0.0158591513,
-0.01146557,
0.0730251223,
0.0065824743,
-0.0661146194,
-0.0619270094,
0.0511338711,
0.0024829421,
-0.0631108359,
-0.0092776278,
0.0234123096,
0.0046174298,
0.0005751998,
0.0426720604,
-0.0476395674,
0.0118889436,
-0.0188320279,
-0.0265038311,
0.0351532213,
0.0214506593,
-0.0076076668,
0.0369999334,
-0.0668749288,
0.0668249056,
0.0269801021,
0.0482520871,
0.1006322727,
0.065328896,
0.0180412568,
0.0197446588,
0.0225191526,
-0.0418924764,
0.0518233627,
-0.0111870496,
0.0332065411,
-0.0005434426,
0.0214372464,
0.0158632081,
0.0482742041,
-0.0000200588,
0.0013065925,
0.0356534123,
0.0000389896,
-0.0050797211,
0.0622573048,
0.0623129494,
-0.0754307583,
-0.0357419997,
-0.0438642614,
-0.0347453877,
-0.0473000258,
-0.0455160961,
0.0265664291,
-0.0043745274,
-0.0203121156,
-0.0396278948,
0.0300851334,
-0.0400951467,
-0.0219006035,
0.016298281,
-0.0248576552,
0.0261508245,
-0.0138096046,
0.0005076388,
-0.0840857252,
-0.0099941315,
-0.0143858502,
0.0316894241,
0.0045562549,
0.0522765219,
-0.0079018632,
-0.000017765,
-0.0429647304,
0.0093052071,
-0.0423465595,
-0.022935899,
-0.0111978203,
-0.0278470144,
0.0875536501,
-0.0261397026,
-0.0055120317,
0.0325155929,
0.0237181224,
-0.0319689624,
-0.041805692,
-0.0305781569,
-0.0378520563,
0.0103576966,
-0.0134713026,
0.0008432678,
-0.0182587672,
-0.0108689358,
0.0055991597,
0.0080879638,
-0.0385188907,
0.0105304383,
2.988e-7,
0.0190810263,
0.0303961691,
-0.0206033178,
0.0569186807,
-0.0281356648,
0.0584093519,
0.0068959775,
-0.004885308,
0.0573799908,
-0.0079847006,
-0.0006028775,
0.0068072006,
0.0261028185,
-0.0054417248,
-0.0560128689,
-0.0037728634,
-0.0643768609,
0.0432332158,
-0.0031891575,
0.0161345117,
0.0507137328,
0.0793096125,
0.0165240467,
0.0273226257,
-0.0024143057,
0.0148991505,
0.0240994729,
-0.0723523945,
-0.021777913,
0.0105843088,
-0.0201010201,
-0.0068819351,
-0.0287552606,
-0.0192960165,
-0.0041676513,
0.0320787057,
-0.0344468616,
0.0563452058,
0.0057542338,
-0.0397477597,
-0.0394091755,
0.023306679,
0.0047797114,
-0.0654040799,
0.0519777201,
-0.0197666548,
-0.0372023173,
-0.0207780488,
-0.0090106837,
-0.0060919705,
0.0039099036,
-0.0229366068,
-0.0178443547,
-0.0204313118,
0.0068662809,
0.0237002075,
-0.0462879017,
-0.0381401367,
-0.0437535495,
0.0422755331,
-0.0026185191,
-0.0508597679,
-0.0395716131,
0.0375300422,
-0.0076371511,
-0.0820785165,
0.0183639638,
2.878131567e-34,
0.0181568023,
-0.0113334535,
0.0430551767,
0.003251265,
0.0132801142,
0.0200166889,
-0.0091361087,
0.0296032894,
0.0558342002,
-0.0841930211,
-0.012306029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05359v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05359v6 | An Examination on the Effectiveness of Divide-and-Conquer Prompting in Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T02:37:30 | 2024-07-02T18:18:18 | Yizhou Zhang, Lun Du, Defu Cao, Qiang Fu, Yan Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Foundation models, such as Large language Models (LLMs), have attracted
significant amount of interest due to their large number of applications.
However, when handling tasks involving repetitive sub-tasks and/or deceptive
contents, such as arithmetic calculation and article-level fake news detection,
simple instructional prompts suffer from inaccurate responses. Existing works
show that more complicated prompting strategies, such as Chain-of-Thoughts and
Least-to-Most, can unlock LLM's powerful capacity in diverse areas. Recent
researches reveal that simple divide-and-conquer prompting strategy, i.e.
simply dividing the input sequence to multiple sub-inputs, can also
substantially improve LLM's performance in some specific tasks such as
misinformation detection. In this paper, we aim at examining the utility of
divide-and-conquer prompting strategy and answer on which kind of tasks this
strategy gets advantages. Specifically, we provide a theoretic analysis to
divide-and-conquer prompting strategy and help us identify the specific tasks
where DaC prompting can bring performance boost with theoretic guarantee. We
then present two cases (large integer arithmetic and fact verification) where
experimental results aligns with our theoretic analysis. | [
0.0400945619,
0.0248008464,
-0.0247504413,
0.0538790077,
-0.0719015077,
0.0117390705,
0.0275307242,
-0.0035273719,
-0.014029759,
-0.0511319749,
0.0191646516,
-0.0902777761,
0.0106498469,
0.0041377228,
0.0194945186,
-0.0370289944,
0.0750739053,
-0.0887162983,
0.0356682651,
-0.0193270799,
-0.0005293719,
-0.0352752618,
-0.0046610511,
0.0087858625,
-0.0130513944,
-0.0314317495,
-0.0055839755,
-0.0157609433,
-0.0206356663,
-0.0304730218,
-0.0157650057,
0.0699853972,
0.0180561934,
0.0841754228,
0.0000023321,
-0.0329229385,
0.0086066145,
0.0043938719,
-0.0832524449,
0.0774235576,
0.0391920134,
0.0024375874,
-0.0142753934,
0.0295186583,
-0.0273058824,
-0.0086818691,
0.0278079491,
0.0649583712,
0.0598280951,
0.1023189649,
0.0084898798,
-0.0137255574,
0.0429621227,
-0.0174894705,
0.0053902781,
-0.0197730865,
0.0507689714,
0.0078640711,
0.0168825723,
0.0357263125,
-0.009288515,
0.0171929393,
0.0475553088,
-0.0050859693,
-0.025560528,
0.0252080951,
-0.0001507159,
-0.0365154818,
-0.0296421293,
0.0281845406,
-0.0354043022,
-0.0194552857,
-0.0054696575,
0.0022593928,
0.0237744227,
0.0370439775,
-0.061199598,
0.0379032567,
-0.0148906261,
-0.0137596438,
0.043406222,
-0.0009401445,
0.0270403754,
0.0198500082,
-0.0308492929,
0.0471568704,
0.0001219444,
-0.0685655996,
-0.0034090625,
0.0073052617,
0.0052232221,
-0.1067532077,
0.0001229063,
0.0343716703,
-0.0362477452,
0.0227760337,
-0.0598149709,
-0.0174937658,
0.0193898622,
-0.070450902,
0.0439588018,
0.0446426719,
-0.041886922,
0.0204158127,
-0.0244939812,
0.034036424,
-0.0442049913,
0.0008188801,
-0.0119155459,
0.058611013,
0.001011707,
-0.0117567554,
-0.0172902271,
0.0577214397,
-0.0161301289,
-0.0239842106,
-0.0362477787,
0.0226696376,
-0.0274205711,
0.0392146856,
-0.0148008261,
-0.0414333344,
0.0155290188,
-0.0076945969,
-0.0166414063,
0.0303432588,
-0.0326328166,
0.0151047036,
0.015932506,
-0.0964474902,
-0.0227902178,
-0.0064285281,
-0.0173661113,
-0.0066801175,
0.0037454662,
0.0247131549,
0.0005471462,
-0.0291609485,
-0.0610685125,
-0.0509434864,
-0.0050153835,
-0.0770275369,
0.010883064,
-0.0725746006,
-0.013228952,
0.0021374272,
-0.0084924754,
0.0228637978,
0.0131411487,
0.0442714132,
-0.01858381,
0.046028018,
0.0429947227,
0.0160956196,
0.0298842527,
0.0333540626,
-0.0215281062,
0.0850514099,
0.0020604988,
0.0226463303,
0.0296026394,
0.008102512,
0.0219631083,
0.0395269021,
0.0207768921,
0.0192635003,
-0.0121001275,
-0.0175187252,
0.0044541019,
0.0036322253,
-0.0113399923,
0.0797690749,
-0.0485635549,
-0.0042535579,
0.0904182866,
0.0068604117,
0.0005248817,
-0.010125841,
0.0568117946,
0.0135375187,
0.0317835175,
0.0658257157,
-0.0660995394,
0.0125578111,
-0.0629208088,
0.0254075993,
0.0417659134,
0.0375547931,
-0.008954782,
-0.0296932999,
-0.0274988711,
0.0159806255,
-0.0121995844,
0.0455897115,
0.0503701568,
-0.0131850354,
-0.0435480401,
0.0244017038,
0.0144710429,
-0.0461742096,
-0.0133984713,
-0.0777671412,
0.0249228589,
0.0226017237,
0.0635802597,
-0.0081538446,
0.0096503645,
-0.0302948561,
0.0208953619,
0.0337683186,
0.053192649,
0.0014139111,
-0.056203533,
-0.0338436402,
-0.0028659622,
-0.0199168138,
0.0128744002,
-0.005335934,
0.0458192453,
0.0202957522,
0.0002680237,
-0.0018633747,
-0.0247937646,
0.022277886,
0.0076638111,
-0.0330181979,
-0.0514883064,
0.0230253115,
0.0122906845,
0.0274860784,
-0.022022862,
0.0298074484,
0.0407312103,
-0.0171155613,
-0.0082690455,
-0.0746332407,
-0.0712381825,
-0.0326715112,
0.0442763977,
0.0004475632,
-0.0133772241,
0.018983312,
0.0034449552,
-0.029601723,
0.003790684,
-0.0675398037,
0.0250001773,
-0.0171383526,
0.0523223206,
-0.0195927192,
0.0047669695,
0.0035138323,
0.0780712739,
-0.0364060663,
0.0149509236,
0.0376227461,
0.0008909877,
-0.0101804733,
-0.0376370326,
-0.0246665776,
0.0061816075,
-0.0117966523,
-0.0142910723,
0.0207651053,
-0.0156986602,
-0.0124807712,
-0.0398167968,
-0.0528274253,
-0.0388061963,
-0.0394457057,
0.0154268369,
0.0060021002,
-0.0204573255,
-0.0003004702,
0.0155855417,
-0.0208384581,
-0.0066294638,
0.0280575808,
0.0532606579,
-0.008832532,
0.0023356781,
-0.0508551523,
0.0072710495,
-0.0135433804,
-0.0084489519,
0.0575876497,
-0.0045979815,
-0.0503669083,
-0.0644140765,
0.022332849,
-0.0134965936,
0.0405808911,
-0.0222057663,
0.0013784051,
0.0190602802,
-0.0124535132,
0.0646903291,
0.0589961372,
0.0121797733,
0.0709616914,
0.049778413,
-0.0059286049,
-0.0182883479,
0.0025174089,
-0.0009428555,
0.0282941014,
-0.0205391422,
-0.0496315993,
-0.0033542374,
0.0902229622,
0.0121603701,
-0.0143751167,
-0.0199066736,
-0.0103186611,
-0.0277384166,
-0.0436153598,
0.0024425043,
-0.0753415748,
-0.0378926024,
0.0474651381,
-0.0235927794,
-0.0472915471,
0.0804737583,
-0.0405354016,
-0.0083742421,
-0.0324757509,
0.000813589,
-0.0043037469,
0.0312982872,
0.005668859,
0.0087216431,
0.0316858552,
-0.0078516426,
-0.04416769,
-0.0120414235,
0.0276032854,
-0.0501499102,
0.0821441337,
-0.0462286063,
0.0126534617,
-0.005916663,
-0.0309067667,
-0.0662320405,
-0.0269528776,
-0.0149174603,
0.0085958624,
-0.0042010625,
-0.0197666679,
-0.0491127782,
-0.0066841831,
0.0581306964,
0.0431382209,
-0.0303630829,
0.0100937625,
0.0027906934,
0.041517809,
0.0383930355,
-0.0202055182,
0.0532283671,
-0.0603325181,
0.0476160683,
0.0555888154,
0.0606389418,
0.0291027222,
0.0023771734,
-0.0197573286,
0.0416049659,
-0.0247988757,
-0.0315170065,
0.0628121346,
0.0074981037,
-0.073830843,
-0.0176320877,
0.1076911017,
0.0181117784,
-0.0246129371,
0.0033661786,
-0.0264724791,
0.0090248138,
0.0255726222,
-0.0084992517,
-0.0886997655,
-0.0143424338,
0.0251167789,
-0.0294100046,
-0.0316734351,
-0.0115259094,
-0.0189131703,
-0.13419649,
0.0360201634,
0.0032042342,
-0.0224411208,
-0.0263838768,
-0.0349620618,
-0.0159744546,
0.0597633794,
0.0276500229,
0.0203175433,
-0.0034841322,
-0.0215578414,
0.0224763099,
-0.0013532586,
-0.0506329611,
0.0066255787,
-0.005154931,
0.0453020446,
0.0533343963,
-0.0128586777,
-0.0122778369,
-0.0659208447,
0.0454608239,
-0.0012356032,
-0.0142710255,
-0.0067575597,
0.0289834999,
-0.0106668044,
0.0151425283,
-0.0024154512,
0.0080101006,
0.0162691809,
-0.0141701,
0.0199585333,
0.1131336242,
-0.0034658434,
-0.0457940809,
-0.0331586935,
0.0111036273,
0.0382792763,
0.0815871432,
0.0391878113,
-0.0273207426,
-0.0033020142,
-0.0237003881,
-0.0294891167,
-0.0081749633,
-0.0291823987,
0.0252402108,
0.0039965394,
-0.0349017456,
-0.0246120337,
-0.0232584979,
0.0002012787,
0.0613769554,
0.0028126079,
0.0219787192,
0.0340891257,
0.0046748738,
-0.005692821,
0.0049126237,
-0.0521737859,
0.0551954024,
-0.0803418308,
0.0099566663,
-0.0294073075,
-0.0411126465,
-0.0047017247,
0.0264356639,
-0.0980076641,
-0.0826265737,
-0.0060221441,
0.0223765355,
0.036128819,
0.0180600919,
0.0152480826,
-0.0632631481,
0.035452459,
-0.0096238609,
-0.0451493487,
0.0419951081,
0.0135481972,
-0.0288359225,
0.0215748921,
0.0147139989,
-0.017169822,
0.0124881053,
0.0310596749,
0.0321878158,
-0.0465352982,
-0.0185594596,
0.0233980566,
0.0396721251,
0.0391927771,
0.0108561628,
0.0613274351,
-0.0160013419,
0.0370695405,
-0.0372888893,
-0.0217230394,
-0.0219637584,
0.0029386552,
0.0233230088,
0.0050957212,
0.0109344646,
-0.0145437308,
-0.0221981052,
0.011319655,
-0.0077289338,
0.0022011041,
-0.0070404545,
0.0424527675,
0.0695307329,
-0.0326865986,
-0.0305303801,
0.0024312609,
0.0052715088,
0.0188444573,
0.0164268836,
0.0676067695,
0.0203363132,
-0.0180857778,
-0.0186282825,
-0.0002110995,
-0.0582736097,
-0.0545670576,
0.0054354086,
0.0492017642,
0.0314180516,
0.0115067111,
0.0219100285,
-0.0410902053,
-0.0037823704,
-0.0266545434,
-0.0179511365,
0.0303354654,
-0.064954862,
0.0301305763,
0.0321470536,
0.0112602133,
0.0004412907,
0.0550882071,
-0.0307169184,
0.0241136942,
0.0093341973,
-0.0332054533,
-0.0225626584,
-0.0546667725,
-0.0033258772,
0.0268750302,
-0.035212595,
0.0124333538,
-0.1240072697,
-0.053139437,
-0.010934745,
0.010403486,
0.0234842058,
-0.024936799,
0.0210679695,
0.0767080337,
-0.0065659769,
-0.01855978,
-0.0353331864,
0.0229991414,
-0.0097354995,
-0.04288508,
-0.0144374957,
-6.591716815e-33,
-0.0036373525,
-0.0337790549,
0.0183170829,
-0.0410471,
-0.0051934351,
0.0371761508,
-0.0162510686,
0.025146028,
-0.017707061,
0.0178875588,
-0.0209892057,
0.0213907529,
0.0209899452,
0.0092185875,
-0.0242895652,
0.0035424186,
0.0531983376,
-0.0278540328,
-0.0341324322,
0.0067577343,
0.0152774649,
-0.0283460077,
0.0295234453,
-0.0286195334,
0.0693765134,
-0.0095121851,
0.0027914755,
0.0075966609,
-0.0533411428,
0.0621012077,
-0.0026930454,
0.0690318868,
0.0238194447,
-0.0540998429,
-0.0155855389,
0.0560574271,
-0.0211387239,
-0.0310605019,
0.0668400377,
0.0112405075,
-0.0252418984,
-0.0127216857,
0.0306176934,
0.0069403821,
-0.0284469277,
-0.0011917144,
-0.0102092428,
-0.0195493326,
-0.0395532995,
-0.0001566922,
-0.0626247749,
0.0153545234,
0.0176011473,
-0.0230898988,
0.0229734033,
0.0493220687,
-0.0110984547,
-0.0252888929,
-0.0515619442,
0.0448175818,
0.0731525496,
0.0417811945,
0.0497545041,
0.0161655955,
-0.0228068531,
0.038501475,
0.0359076262,
0.0152183129,
-0.0246054176,
-0.0308733284,
0.0158617422,
0.0011937654,
0.0684997812,
0.0285875145,
0.0595212281,
-0.0015649572,
-0.0509634688,
-0.009318714,
0.0603598393,
0.0202516541,
0.0467199124,
-0.0227963161,
-0.0718030334,
-0.0245432444,
-0.0221098978,
0.0361654907,
-0.0496867858,
-0.0241631623,
0.0451356098,
0.0307976194,
0.003362213,
-0.0031692549,
0.0337188691,
-0.019306263,
-0.0350664966,
0.0292947236,
-0.0086113559,
0.0409183465,
-0.0116014984,
0.0242114849,
-0.0743057206,
0.0013510338,
0.020291673,
-0.0231903233,
-0.0275547095,
0.0134322383,
0.0195802599,
0.0195025038,
-0.0602969266,
-0.0142681906,
-0.0341311283,
0.0359146446,
0.0443386547,
-0.0173345152,
0.0682502538,
-0.0220904313,
-0.0056099044,
0.0218686648,
-0.0142517462,
-0.0660030767,
-0.039950341,
0.0397487432,
-0.0367180184,
0.0374319814,
-0.0300953612,
-0.0042708577,
-0.0625107437,
0.0241886713,
0.0171598103,
-0.0744123906,
-0.0179493576,
0.0009257579,
2.995e-7,
-0.0226740744,
0.0405167378,
0.0070114741,
0.0294174738,
0.0065756729,
0.0329910927,
-0.0031834105,
-0.0029014891,
0.0085457042,
-0.0583644621,
-0.028645426,
0.0443341658,
0.0181878246,
0.0261925254,
-0.0626846626,
-0.0260858554,
-0.042148497,
0.0165410358,
-0.0580353253,
0.0028865165,
0.0327886976,
0.0658017471,
0.0269533899,
-0.0174586698,
0.0092148874,
-0.0398849957,
0.0266705435,
0.0241686907,
-0.012188727,
-0.0068896394,
0.036987301,
-0.0362265334,
0.0054415246,
0.0471858568,
0.010560465,
0.0137963789,
-0.0220326893,
0.0499897376,
0.0140599608,
0.0408736318,
-0.0205049887,
-0.0427699313,
-0.0404717624,
-0.0636445954,
0.070638366,
-0.0179608818,
-0.0060033747,
-0.0491789952,
0.0167957135,
-0.037329305,
-0.0026781713,
-0.011196509,
-0.0000384941,
0.0115212016,
0.0053526862,
0.001094441,
0.0143534411,
-0.0293012578,
-0.0027561574,
0.0240894482,
-0.0381933488,
-0.0809201002,
-0.0470542759,
0.0169834029,
0.0286673643,
-0.0521826781,
-0.0189380012,
3.207691969e-34,
0.0346623808,
-0.0476125479,
0.0417340286,
0.0426448248,
0.0170537923,
0.0081881257,
-0.0805619508,
0.0161417574,
0.0263131987,
-0.0602308251,
-0.0420190357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14590v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14590v1 | Scaling Up LLM Reviews for Google Ads Content Moderation | 2024-02-07T23:47:02 | 2024-02-07T23:47:02 | Wei Qiao, Tushar Dogra, Otilia Stretcu, Yu-Han Lyu, Tiantian Fang, Dongjin Kwon, Chun-Ta Lu, Enming Luo, Yuan Wang, Chih-Chun Chia, Ariel Fuxman, Fangzhou Wang, Ranjay Krishna, Mehmet Tek | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are powerful tools for content moderation, but
their inference costs and latency make them prohibitive for casual use on large
datasets, such as the Google Ads repository. This study proposes a method for
scaling up LLM reviews for content moderation in Google Ads. First, we use
heuristics to select candidates via filtering and duplicate removal, and create
clusters of ads for which we select one representative ad per cluster. We then
use LLMs to review only the representative ads. Finally, we propagate the LLM
decisions for the representative ads back to their clusters. This method
reduces the number of reviews by more than 3 orders of magnitude while
achieving a 2x recall compared to a baseline non-LLM model. The success of this
approach is a strong function of the representations used in clustering and
label propagation; we found that cross-modal similarity representations yield
better results than uni-modal representations. | [
0.0593248978,
0.0324911363,
-0.0012670512,
-0.0308328811,
-0.0062022428,
-0.0191322137,
0.0424639396,
0.0162888579,
0.0388788544,
-0.0646079183,
-0.0520471372,
-0.0623403452,
-0.0465895236,
0.0436628684,
-0.0405042656,
-0.0472458601,
0.0148208933,
-0.0417770036,
0.0543070249,
-0.0108906664,
0.0277581271,
0.0185130481,
0.0378755331,
0.02762153,
0.0214102417,
-0.0407470465,
0.0355777517,
-0.0395499207,
-0.0022039225,
-0.0119467722,
-0.0229650773,
0.0664305314,
0.0211190488,
0.0611812808,
0.0000018803,
-0.0300204922,
-0.0131331636,
-0.0131338313,
0.0279817991,
0.0463148542,
0.0859081,
0.0115390597,
0.000948317,
0.0136517109,
-0.0145655042,
0.0101276115,
0.0162462443,
0.0576174892,
0.0347979292,
0.037244875,
-0.0232315417,
-0.0177830327,
-0.0456562787,
-0.0451577343,
0.000660254,
-0.0231135022,
0.0273670983,
0.0210159626,
-0.0021801195,
0.0335693881,
-0.0068579274,
0.0376955457,
-0.0213986654,
-0.0670174211,
-0.0125692608,
-0.0140692601,
0.0219064523,
0.0027703922,
0.0138655994,
0.0411768556,
0.0399505533,
-0.0434080847,
0.018569136,
-0.0002118509,
0.0146364011,
0.0588398278,
-0.0738162845,
0.0044216136,
0.0268345233,
0.0532412566,
-0.0244842861,
-0.0417456776,
0.0388168953,
0.0050813761,
0.0345012024,
0.0274916496,
0.0189519506,
-0.0400861427,
0.0047600055,
0.0358244181,
0.0335298367,
-0.025169991,
0.0414449349,
-0.0332268253,
-0.0115317842,
-0.0261684489,
0.0116230147,
0.0267792102,
0.0314383358,
-0.0784483403,
0.047740642,
-0.0096059795,
0.0037783794,
0.0692095533,
0.0009650883,
0.0239127818,
-0.0219601076,
0.0311850067,
-0.0272424389,
0.0293713324,
-0.0706302971,
0.0053998204,
0.012636832,
0.0171360951,
0.0009473891,
0.0239768885,
-0.0709697232,
0.0451668352,
-0.0318768807,
-0.0242122617,
0.063578032,
0.0011142299,
0.0587083846,
-0.0078768842,
-0.0287456568,
0.0227073114,
-0.0188104883,
0.0430115238,
-0.0324415639,
0.0352168493,
0.0320571512,
0.0576916449,
0.0075290729,
-0.0270414725,
0.0243845992,
0.0406798273,
0.0254007429,
0.0163080525,
-0.0366016068,
0.0025834697,
-0.0465770587,
-0.024498025,
-0.0699741989,
-0.062246453,
-0.0039818934,
-0.0052589071,
-0.00827666,
-0.0582945347,
-0.0406822748,
-0.0149012674,
-0.0335528255,
0.0086253975,
0.0347995162,
0.0198547598,
0.0025787596,
0.0273115952,
-0.0266243964,
0.0437481217,
-0.0200917106,
0.0517785326,
0.0629588589,
-0.0230779909,
0.0074724345,
0.0083952239,
-0.0003654247,
0.0302370153,
-0.0535019636,
-0.0186884739,
-0.0327202231,
-0.0385376811,
0.0570407808,
0.051483687,
-0.0331671163,
-0.0089857541,
0.0932804346,
0.0171618741,
-0.0148189217,
0.0122406296,
0.0088585857,
0.0122939143,
-0.0304170121,
-0.0171087328,
-0.0343440771,
0.040638499,
0.0021578593,
-0.0617062375,
0.0734843761,
0.0453645289,
-0.0667239428,
-0.0159726609,
0.020974474,
0.0177770033,
0.0410556793,
0.019354552,
0.0182191133,
-0.0206679609,
0.0133640738,
0.0521534793,
0.0174351037,
0.0092761181,
0.0287795477,
-0.0347104967,
0.0486246124,
0.0305577293,
0.0535114668,
-0.0227970108,
-0.0005149528,
-0.025295103,
0.0006193997,
-0.0342210419,
0.0841504186,
-0.0298685636,
-0.0499957539,
-0.0299894605,
-0.0638613626,
0.009746233,
0.0325782932,
0.0250677653,
-0.0115419729,
0.0382126682,
-0.0004688729,
-0.0364921875,
-0.0207876787,
-0.0204101782,
0.1058480889,
-0.0068223011,
0.0082400143,
0.010503782,
0.0774408132,
0.038191434,
0.0190950576,
-0.0137501173,
0.0189676881,
0.0024178268,
-0.0495730713,
-0.0231251642,
0.0074634552,
0.0085129961,
0.0607086048,
-0.0264032986,
-0.0339874141,
0.0211611241,
0.0013331119,
-0.0263117589,
0.0375771224,
0.0095443465,
0.0252149981,
-0.0274334084,
0.0102144871,
-0.0301965736,
-0.0244686622,
-0.0131463381,
0.0355625004,
0.0179396868,
0.0054329699,
0.0065790028,
-0.044421453,
-0.0072899451,
-0.0185606852,
0.0036776911,
-0.0098704826,
-0.0014841491,
0.0135986283,
0.0655073747,
-0.0074047991,
-0.0103131328,
-0.0328263566,
-0.0639063418,
-0.0517241359,
-0.003423936,
0.0357005,
0.0336722769,
-0.0015762193,
0.038643878,
0.0098109674,
-0.0512091704,
-0.0151193468,
0.0254644901,
0.045378238,
-0.0055139302,
-0.0140357129,
-0.0179256946,
-0.0171937235,
-0.0134698227,
0.0115793152,
0.0284491181,
0.0008825646,
-0.0248669963,
-0.0389898531,
0.0508203581,
-0.0754596367,
-0.0172244757,
-0.0132986465,
-0.0146508068,
0.0147523126,
-0.0143623762,
0.0269036274,
-0.0298086461,
-0.0249279793,
-0.0056603611,
0.0721397549,
-0.00926854,
-0.0634165704,
-0.0426167622,
0.0016937759,
0.0123876268,
-0.0448055603,
0.0247821491,
0.0504770055,
0.0477434993,
0.0174003243,
0.0078365169,
-0.0030216731,
0.034437079,
-0.0164391845,
-0.0306235421,
-0.0480725579,
-0.0378723405,
-0.0055686114,
0.0460331999,
-0.0042949831,
-0.0377711989,
0.0730919465,
0.008068284,
0.0250736009,
-0.0013105406,
-0.0302273408,
-0.0315014981,
0.0177800003,
-0.0295253433,
0.0440317728,
-0.0773982033,
-0.0088688685,
-0.0160738099,
0.0043567885,
0.0578992367,
-0.0233754385,
0.0584744439,
-0.0181765016,
0.0230003484,
0.0133229215,
-0.0353476964,
0.0055501568,
-0.0236425735,
-0.0014007798,
-0.0025351164,
0.0482546575,
0.0216767881,
-0.1192738339,
0.1019300893,
0.0110170329,
0.0326130651,
0.0047977711,
-0.0023599239,
0.031932611,
0.0279409699,
0.0060911477,
-0.0160782132,
-0.0311792511,
-0.0081558218,
0.0253081731,
0.056678988,
0.0248495303,
-0.0088185389,
-0.0075676134,
-0.0114173731,
0.0259726532,
-0.0282007437,
-0.0047563058,
-0.0100251213,
0.043070145,
-0.0240349304,
0.0264566969,
0.0814446881,
0.0125470152,
-0.1287694573,
-0.0296539143,
0.0044315136,
0.0016934911,
-0.0028213051,
0.0152425496,
-0.040560469,
-0.0103470264,
0.0367765315,
0.0033540935,
0.0106871249,
-0.0232097842,
0.0043881652,
-0.0634222999,
0.0398947001,
0.01792375,
-0.0427223518,
-0.0548705533,
-0.0918589607,
-0.0014225813,
-0.0577086136,
-0.0019930687,
-0.0097479103,
-0.005249273,
-0.0007303257,
-0.020387046,
0.0167464949,
-0.0420712903,
0.0252955705,
-0.0294761136,
0.0428004339,
-0.0011110735,
0.0160261244,
0.0179870669,
0.0016344647,
0.0658113435,
0.0116969589,
-0.0230837073,
-0.0289592315,
0.0159761254,
0.0022697637,
0.0206704084,
-0.021536354,
0.0317472555,
-0.0097970646,
0.024338508,
0.0065592071,
0.107724458,
-0.012260939,
-0.0345831737,
-0.0112989983,
-0.0011172894,
0.0095234364,
0.0837625638,
0.0230746865,
-0.0562060662,
0.0028287522,
-0.0282958876,
-0.016819153,
0.0136241494,
-0.0343195572,
-0.0348335505,
-0.0037100206,
0.0538914129,
-0.0365998037,
0.0109668961,
0.0184313264,
0.014062739,
0.0386256687,
0.0440741964,
-0.0157199018,
-0.0338381678,
0.0321886875,
-0.0026838745,
-0.0636632442,
0.0019098901,
-0.0515124239,
-0.0022315055,
0.0396929011,
0.0005704687,
-0.0588855781,
-0.0103286719,
-0.0498092547,
-0.0643628165,
-0.0141014783,
0.0362716168,
0.0186889339,
0.0320809111,
-0.0259298682,
-0.0742304325,
0.033360742,
0.0375795811,
-0.0187640414,
-0.0347085185,
-0.0112928543,
0.0334790275,
-0.0095808106,
0.0364636704,
-0.0755345002,
0.0612796545,
0.035944853,
-0.0290434267,
-0.0518308319,
-0.0127503797,
-0.0013801751,
0.0509975813,
0.0077456948,
0.0221077148,
0.0329982266,
-0.0663469806,
0.0099842455,
-0.0168302283,
-0.0208247956,
-0.02110455,
0.058250457,
0.0243911743,
-0.0232269373,
-0.0172590502,
0.0485097803,
-0.0089027826,
0.0294012036,
-0.0602887273,
0.0648557618,
0.0104283364,
0.027162876,
0.0176206417,
0.0100154169,
-0.0066528558,
0.0527833402,
0.0434407517,
-0.0159114357,
-0.0361029916,
-0.0161929615,
-0.0104134176,
0.0309682954,
-0.0257190224,
0.0248458665,
-0.0486596785,
-0.046795059,
-0.0132657569,
0.0090713771,
0.0288235415,
-0.0134773413,
0.0601240061,
-0.0071922373,
-0.0251002945,
-0.0110440534,
-0.0051047811,
0.0119234547,
0.0460457839,
0.0109082591,
0.0389743596,
-0.0133537939,
0.036003314,
0.0605653971,
-0.0604373962,
-0.0064337086,
-0.0290077589,
-0.0803935006,
-0.0516551919,
-0.0526872948,
0.0018236815,
0.0275504645,
-0.0244010072,
-0.0204123296,
-0.0229488928,
-0.0267791301,
-0.0293448791,
-0.0512809157,
0.0292995982,
-0.0061716079,
0.0190464314,
0.0546909198,
0.0296059884,
0.068307668,
-0.0406436361,
-0.0405909829,
-0.0120856659,
-0.0345367007,
-0.0369826145,
-6.309460051e-33,
0.0210169572,
-0.0117239747,
-0.0342809521,
-0.0336175188,
-0.0052710418,
-0.0182281695,
-0.0155968806,
-0.0166851524,
0.0489936545,
0.0131494161,
-0.0104023814,
0.0019870629,
0.0045188311,
-0.0004525634,
0.0322935469,
0.0142248962,
0.0989547223,
-0.0138305342,
-0.028844893,
0.0738254786,
0.0283482186,
0.0159284975,
-0.0099245925,
-0.0390940346,
0.0223062057,
0.0495524332,
-0.0322171338,
0.0006399429,
0.0318319798,
0.085253641,
-0.019161677,
0.0343136638,
0.0541780889,
-0.0402276777,
-0.0078267893,
-0.0059040091,
-0.0523962714,
0.0123506533,
0.0270694345,
-0.0045964355,
0.0305607822,
-0.0236966647,
0.0325705558,
-0.0052575809,
-0.042923294,
0.0226830114,
0.0123142116,
-0.021631442,
-0.0448621251,
-0.0369679667,
0.0107247522,
0.0149738593,
-0.0223838538,
0.0470445082,
0.0261910055,
0.0156617109,
-0.0199922919,
0.1077611893,
-0.0559902079,
0.0354748182,
-0.0458116457,
0.0474466383,
0.0058519393,
-0.0362467766,
-0.0129198376,
0.0666403323,
-0.0510135517,
-0.0014612909,
-0.0158084892,
-0.0142344879,
-0.0310489479,
0.0167327281,
-0.0154936519,
0.0414556339,
0.0427221172,
-0.0458200946,
-0.0734716058,
0.0265614912,
0.0143290106,
0.0079604257,
0.0520918854,
0.0243378468,
-0.0056822537,
-0.0067370497,
-0.0137623474,
-0.0864759535,
-0.0603981949,
-0.0507020392,
0.0231648758,
0.0264435187,
-0.0518661104,
-0.0393576361,
0.0224085376,
-0.0588343181,
-0.0309804641,
0.0319708884,
0.0046849996,
-0.0013584935,
0.0503706932,
-0.0353983827,
-0.062622495,
-0.0283178128,
0.0040751835,
-0.0202634372,
-0.0331975706,
-0.0469656587,
0.0286305565,
0.0206727237,
-0.0805560201,
0.0253452752,
0.0123652695,
-0.0141011858,
0.014479585,
0.0598415732,
-0.0123619512,
-0.0423069894,
0.0154818259,
0.020309303,
0.0324894413,
0.0297501851,
0.0431208611,
-0.021301372,
-0.027519485,
0.0151182311,
-0.0222856924,
-0.0379849374,
-0.0208250862,
-0.0481259711,
0.0465751961,
-0.0609518178,
-0.0210252423,
-0.0451530777,
2.692e-7,
0.0226176977,
0.0443778895,
-0.0338230766,
-0.0601993687,
0.0708323121,
0.0165904202,
-0.0061143967,
0.0239630491,
0.0173828863,
0.013543522,
0.0298196729,
0.0195535719,
0.0038890224,
0.0263422616,
-0.0514944531,
0.0817414075,
-0.0925019458,
-0.0125236409,
-0.0154259037,
0.0029064715,
-0.0550210886,
0.0728685558,
0.0275615714,
-0.0357884504,
-0.0014752182,
-0.0602347068,
0.051785931,
-0.0228048321,
-0.0330837108,
0.0265153367,
0.0574814901,
-0.0331961028,
-0.0323848501,
-0.0585848168,
-0.0049201436,
-0.0025266143,
-0.0035674926,
0.0464665256,
0.0401685275,
-0.0027279954,
-0.0054744883,
-0.0177929737,
0.0136102559,
-0.0120613724,
0.0697065815,
-0.0126034496,
-0.0179247465,
-0.0625040531,
-0.0139418906,
-0.0410817116,
0.0269125216,
-0.0079282448,
-0.0091948006,
0.0119072217,
-0.0194721967,
0.0090056108,
-0.0269904621,
-0.0354271047,
0.0046599437,
-0.0179908071,
-0.0365374498,
-0.0657969266,
-0.0039140931,
0.0066981898,
0.0145624969,
-0.0089119459,
0.0343274847,
2.248768677e-34,
0.08826188,
-0.021484809,
-0.0146514969,
-0.0391227938,
-0.0217445511,
0.0099460389,
-0.0556790493,
-0.0288058762,
0.0382713675,
-0.0933873504,
-0.0025800036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05318v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05318v1 | Navigating the Knowledge Sea: Planet-scale answer retrieval using LLMs | 2024-02-07T23:39:40 | 2024-02-07T23:39:40 | Dipankar Sarkar | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Information retrieval is a rapidly evolving field of information retrieval,
which is characterized by a continuous refinement of techniques and
technologies, from basic hyperlink-based navigation to sophisticated
algorithm-driven search engines. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive
overview of the evolution of Information Retrieval Technology, with a
particular focus on the role of Large Language Models (LLMs) in bridging the
gap between traditional search methods and the emerging paradigm of answer
retrieval. The integration of LLMs in the realms of response retrieval and
indexing signifies a paradigm shift in how users interact with information
systems. This paradigm shift is driven by the integration of large language
models (LLMs) like GPT-4, which are capable of understanding and generating
human-like text, thus enabling them to provide more direct and contextually
relevant answers to user queries. Through this exploration, we seek to
illuminate the technological milestones that have shaped this journey and the
potential future directions in this rapidly changing field. | [
0.0795525536,
-0.0025408359,
-0.0335339196,
0.0372612253,
-0.0161863249,
-0.0123893972,
-0.0328331217,
0.0489448607,
0.0537193827,
-0.0572535917,
-0.0348140784,
-0.0193093456,
-0.0582792647,
-0.0101597104,
0.0120187765,
-0.0313802771,
0.0439573824,
0.0021223556,
0.0109504322,
0.0017389677,
0.0071115401,
0.0332619324,
0.0421838984,
0.0229460616,
0.0375264958,
0.001104443,
-0.0148480618,
0.0055565531,
-0.0161922853,
-0.0399300493,
0.0269597117,
0.0134167885,
0.0251600146,
0.0595966987,
0.0000017259,
-0.036498785,
-0.0180320144,
0.0070191268,
-0.0163097773,
0.0121519268,
0.0084728617,
0.0384567752,
0.0483490638,
0.0210338924,
-0.0653255582,
-0.0227282029,
0.0175782256,
0.0377213061,
0.0744601637,
0.0256156884,
0.0077226241,
-0.0647244379,
0.0355696045,
0.0032025597,
0.0243451931,
-0.0432367511,
0.0376396887,
0.014087419,
0.0517901704,
0.0724761263,
0.031793803,
0.0378741883,
-0.012920985,
0.0004360055,
0.0096197817,
0.0108027318,
-0.0278683249,
0.0068969242,
-0.0019465287,
0.0421765968,
0.0397741571,
-0.0210249126,
-0.0173983704,
0.0228791703,
-0.0113802906,
0.0606439151,
-0.0582596809,
-0.0144177163,
-0.023645876,
0.0096882666,
0.0105053177,
-0.0202497616,
-0.0018994728,
0.0377363637,
-0.0378528088,
0.0911772549,
0.0096848933,
-0.0362075679,
-0.0010031172,
-0.006973526,
0.0109594697,
-0.0217526387,
0.0302487053,
0.0852993652,
0.0164319947,
-0.0003317341,
0.0291998461,
-0.0055125272,
0.0745960101,
-0.0691093057,
-0.0070170034,
0.0176080987,
0.0031725545,
0.0649436861,
-0.0255085416,
0.0437192172,
-0.0511311516,
-0.050944455,
-0.0612522066,
-0.0531448387,
-0.0539705567,
-0.0745247751,
-0.0324076228,
0.0668401644,
-0.0538273267,
-0.0009514299,
-0.0014016503,
0.0459393561,
0.0372335166,
-0.0224430561,
0.0028700731,
0.0105094695,
-0.0168596059,
-0.0018147636,
-0.0808129683,
0.0349943861,
-0.018707931,
-0.0173827223,
-0.005762463,
-0.0344306603,
0.0325877033,
0.0066044144,
0.00447297,
-0.0349292755,
0.0307828393,
0.05243247,
0.0191243179,
0.0005008827,
-0.0181660559,
-0.0644141734,
0.0142163076,
-0.0418873839,
-0.027634928,
-0.0670790672,
-0.0098148175,
0.0395314954,
-0.0143489055,
0.01079462,
0.0336576626,
0.0581938662,
-0.0527653135,
0.0144006256,
-0.0337160379,
0.0037028184,
0.0707751215,
-0.0018364827,
0.0598209649,
0.0303687993,
-0.0225094203,
0.0110093206,
0.0643111393,
-0.0051075118,
0.0419549346,
0.0073260707,
-0.0082206018,
0.0057898774,
0.0283132009,
0.0755751058,
-0.0042916089,
-0.0048239543,
-0.0232311636,
0.0630055889,
-0.0338000841,
-0.0277689267,
0.0530204736,
0.0502931625,
0.0242429152,
0.0330685899,
-0.0010480217,
0.0134122847,
0.0194888543,
-0.0061205048,
0.0066910107,
0.0125089455,
-0.0484860502,
-0.0065650851,
0.0436186567,
0.0180714186,
-0.02388083,
-0.0281407684,
-0.0042600594,
0.0511794761,
-0.0279825479,
0.0259385742,
0.0304331165,
-0.0615350083,
-0.0046091336,
0.0307258815,
0.0018034137,
-0.0414927304,
0.0232255347,
-0.0719956979,
0.041124858,
0.0525234975,
0.0519911498,
-0.0341555998,
-0.0010870529,
0.0123928525,
-0.0176583044,
0.0390876643,
0.0087230643,
-0.0040926705,
-0.0609133393,
0.0015485387,
-0.0087520387,
0.0337618664,
-0.0227736421,
-0.0165832918,
0.0203367956,
0.0260861311,
0.0278260056,
-0.0487227291,
-0.004908754,
0.0073880455,
0.0394260548,
-0.0226832367,
-0.0136828404,
-0.002301059,
0.0038984329,
0.0633389577,
-0.0130798342,
0.0195016228,
0.0429538786,
-0.0014081987,
-0.0415541381,
-0.0630906522,
0.0120027671,
0.0239819475,
0.0462911837,
-0.0192291029,
0.0443301387,
0.0324269049,
0.0182802621,
-0.026841158,
-0.0284064319,
-0.0211134776,
0.0459155664,
-0.0662030205,
-0.0177066196,
0.0079042166,
-0.0164702218,
-0.0972969308,
0.0609269291,
0.0328611881,
0.0367365181,
0.0057998234,
-0.002838545,
0.0266956668,
-0.0619305819,
-0.0165976919,
0.0657286718,
0.0119106453,
0.031000983,
0.0538131148,
-0.0022979514,
-0.0455237329,
-0.0131033408,
-0.0887685791,
0.0022722918,
-0.0087437341,
0.0289796237,
0.0218751319,
0.0100931302,
0.0019112821,
-0.0214116573,
-0.0612728484,
-0.0002617564,
0.0647142231,
0.0279908981,
0.0327710733,
0.0206104517,
-0.0056720134,
-0.054005418,
-0.0402585305,
0.0016406282,
0.0183357429,
0.0216189995,
-0.012532644,
-0.0600153804,
-0.028308291,
-0.0597119369,
0.0100274049,
0.0092010237,
-0.0063605639,
-0.0042581153,
-0.0629022643,
-0.0114372699,
0.0000393297,
0.0508055575,
0.0075154509,
0.007293296,
-0.0028058703,
-0.0686352625,
0.0220083576,
-0.0677909553,
-0.0565914921,
-0.0198928881,
-0.0125586353,
0.0435618386,
-0.0211921949,
-0.0036298197,
-0.0114673441,
-0.0411703177,
0.0231234785,
0.0047506006,
0.0230040755,
-0.0587759353,
-0.0086330585,
-0.0131160179,
0.0498614646,
0.0148030594,
-0.0523485579,
0.0324387774,
-0.0043533188,
0.0163116492,
-0.0561380237,
-0.0349841118,
-0.0318230614,
0.0508879721,
-0.019896118,
0.0363215096,
-0.0166468937,
-0.0125830872,
-0.0055536944,
0.0001185555,
0.017426433,
-0.080394052,
0.0552356727,
0.002483563,
0.0347592086,
-0.0120195644,
-0.0358088017,
-0.0131949065,
-0.0468459427,
-0.0284152403,
0.0079446947,
0.0021920498,
-0.0267194379,
-0.0123634767,
0.027938826,
0.046806965,
-0.0164280795,
-0.0280095097,
-0.0329305828,
-0.0123157753,
0.0843943879,
0.0471304953,
0.0016909402,
0.0119949793,
0.029647233,
0.0135684591,
0.0704820603,
0.043131873,
-0.0330211781,
0.0261036288,
-0.0336972587,
0.0775582194,
-0.0430272408,
-0.031915538,
-0.0033546742,
0.0004428242,
-0.0273665171,
0.0145985782,
0.0805654153,
0.0483768135,
-0.0583675355,
-0.0499056764,
-0.0138418935,
-0.0018363938,
0.0305801034,
0.0808255374,
-0.0568774007,
0.002421539,
-0.0181480162,
0.0275969841,
-0.0046620118,
0.0127494866,
0.0150451753,
-0.1036394984,
0.0561740883,
-0.023022281,
-0.0213448461,
-0.0585236624,
-0.0599103533,
0.0022924757,
0.0408305526,
-0.0312362574,
0.0695539564,
-0.029372571,
-0.0036429386,
0.0077308738,
-0.0083260294,
0.039236322,
0.0267519522,
-0.0206907392,
-0.0048536356,
0.0686400533,
0.0168449804,
-0.0188585427,
-0.0299751163,
-0.004610402,
-0.0830931216,
0.015490422,
-0.0382389091,
0.0220583528,
-0.0240241177,
0.0233690329,
-0.0507456437,
-0.0232566893,
-0.0213619936,
0.0393679291,
0.0227879379,
0.095340468,
-0.0157802068,
0.0214783791,
-0.0710663795,
-0.0210184138,
-0.0326191336,
0.0504000671,
-0.0272552464,
-0.0041892594,
-0.0512179323,
-0.0494469181,
0.0160378125,
0.0348841995,
-0.0572512001,
-0.0010387878,
-0.023142457,
0.0450005941,
-0.0417877249,
-0.0167063791,
0.0038486607,
0.0015585585,
-0.0115387188,
0.0354579501,
-0.0318751894,
0.0187926944,
-0.0278024636,
-0.0094928443,
-0.0196632016,
0.0110469786,
-0.0514197312,
-0.0031682004,
0.0477279797,
-0.0677536502,
-0.0158719216,
-0.0168051887,
-0.0063854321,
-0.0329831839,
-0.0390435457,
0.0164460689,
0.0195304006,
-0.0058719655,
-0.0021509593,
-0.0372265279,
0.0526469313,
0.0225398,
-0.0287445057,
-0.0019779217,
-0.0162618756,
0.0320723914,
-0.0209542327,
0.0144839427,
-0.0750681832,
0.0102456007,
-0.0115243318,
0.0467091538,
-0.0149737308,
-0.0816409662,
0.0545480438,
0.048661679,
0.0201573297,
0.0349478163,
0.0003551739,
0.0131277638,
0.0004767097,
-0.0265446883,
-0.0227605496,
-0.023108121,
-0.0147237629,
0.0052009323,
-0.0266174134,
0.0062490916,
0.0101729035,
-0.0093191853,
0.0542047843,
-0.0615665913,
0.0182167273,
0.0052371011,
-0.0188837741,
0.0007008099,
-0.002974825,
-0.0280471202,
-0.0312894844,
0.0021680996,
0.0434352234,
-0.020196164,
0.071774669,
0.0109370127,
-0.0581791401,
-0.0042552012,
0.0211342424,
-0.1240575016,
-0.0818082988,
-0.0323651768,
0.0022645851,
0.0437343568,
0.0082918499,
0.0118323416,
-0.030393092,
-0.0384312086,
-0.0133575331,
-0.0442763716,
0.0412012078,
0.0165670384,
0.0239381846,
0.0388917252,
-0.0251032803,
0.0236258525,
0.0554054938,
-0.0000323856,
-0.0022742671,
-0.006224873,
-0.074393183,
0.0035706095,
-0.0074825049,
0.0161602776,
0.0309536532,
-0.0054299086,
-0.007578861,
-0.0254545659,
-0.0221867766,
-0.0014972236,
0.0237031877,
-0.008537869,
-0.042649366,
0.0444105528,
0.098846592,
0.0333221257,
-0.0715375543,
-0.0628945976,
0.0467746742,
-0.0841280594,
0.0121116843,
-0.0110797808,
-6.311794876e-33,
-0.003823644,
-0.0290713441,
0.0215820652,
0.015906252,
-0.0361451767,
-0.0145529397,
0.0195752326,
-0.0107826469,
-0.0492594317,
-0.020271888,
-0.0227535535,
0.0183600709,
-0.0017108679,
0.0057870853,
0.0072672996,
-0.0106369639,
0.005472206,
-0.022033589,
0.0027282548,
0.037126638,
0.032977622,
0.0059632459,
0.0163745377,
-0.0343433693,
0.0028824136,
-0.02131317,
0.0110957399,
0.0689922497,
-0.0211679097,
0.0598748177,
-0.0234075077,
0.0647859946,
0.0379649922,
-0.0355080105,
0.0338274054,
0.0185048841,
-0.0782372057,
-0.0158603247,
0.0115225399,
-0.0440587737,
-0.0271447469,
-0.0124259489,
0.0223825667,
-0.0179967452,
-0.0165804587,
0.0141377486,
0.0402850136,
-0.0032152361,
-0.0120665161,
-0.043758329,
-0.0097644823,
0.0203234851,
0.0076513379,
0.0473392569,
0.0028029962,
0.0403602794,
-0.0087171104,
0.0591855273,
-0.0291986633,
0.034003295,
0.0197052527,
0.0625366122,
0.013733536,
0.0398129076,
0.0087424135,
0.0325382613,
0.0206228942,
-0.0176826641,
-0.0288189203,
-0.0308296122,
-0.0448346175,
-0.0009837117,
0.0367952958,
0.0463089459,
-0.0196244437,
0.0233849417,
-0.0534781441,
0.0349951535,
0.0018758014,
0.0321920626,
0.044726979,
0.0254667569,
-0.0290079191,
0.0041166274,
-0.0202114265,
0.0208674595,
-0.0546783097,
-0.0229335725,
0.0146289608,
0.0006107569,
-0.0174834002,
-0.0068531618,
0.0519818142,
-0.0330257267,
-0.0325575583,
0.0356446095,
-0.0251512993,
0.0008328462,
0.0084971189,
0.0305890627,
-0.0198125467,
0.0094516361,
-0.0258792341,
-0.0314341076,
-0.0705239996,
-0.0184927508,
-0.0683101639,
-0.005443973,
-0.0504546762,
0.0007601398,
0.0100931777,
-0.0051581929,
-0.0339603536,
-0.0435819142,
0.0186236389,
0.0170923956,
0.0451746956,
0.0386685394,
0.0202053729,
0.0065271603,
-0.0336104743,
-0.0535811521,
0.0101941414,
-0.0265374929,
0.0144647975,
0.0698491186,
-0.0241764542,
0.0482496098,
-0.0202376805,
-0.0561067387,
-0.0004654547,
0.0436053947,
2.481e-7,
0.0495266281,
0.0389182605,
0.0138868401,
0.0288227741,
0.0247774273,
0.0001423072,
0.0455910936,
0.0032554055,
0.0833116025,
0.0018457685,
-0.0036233033,
0.0196658336,
0.0036251757,
0.0423794687,
-0.052452866,
0.0041133869,
-0.0382181257,
-0.0517081358,
-0.0644943863,
-0.0074055158,
0.0847392082,
0.0645107925,
-0.0432432443,
0.0019065385,
-0.0495869592,
-0.0439404175,
0.0394166224,
-0.01271802,
0.0026643861,
-0.0061522345,
0.0194608606,
0.0234244484,
0.0330975801,
0.0178500805,
0.0067725987,
0.0102721322,
0.0182124265,
0.0259064119,
0.0003158694,
-0.0297248568,
-0.0062844348,
-0.0329836085,
0.0440219045,
-0.1027131602,
0.0931670293,
0.0083710616,
0.0178687777,
0.021641463,
-0.0219723266,
-0.0504518934,
-0.0345235541,
-0.0529562943,
-0.0552017279,
0.0271516852,
-0.0234572757,
0.031767562,
0.0194653217,
-0.0587552153,
-0.0026505138,
0.0199553519,
-0.0639732331,
-0.0451875292,
-0.0349536613,
0.0071568224,
-0.0112361973,
-0.0102287531,
0.0129538756,
2.087586132e-34,
0.0199166518,
0.0003136939,
0.0131377205,
0.0278810877,
0.0198453739,
0.0342550948,
-0.0200093873,
0.0250631031,
0.0400446057,
-0.129845947,
-0.0073280688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05294v1 | Examining Modality Incongruity in Multimodal Federated Learning for Medical Vision and Language-based Disease Detection | 2024-02-07T22:16:53 | 2024-02-07T22:16:53 | Pramit Saha, Divyanshu Mishra, Felix Wagner, Konstantinos Kamnitsas, J. Alison Noble | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Multimodal Federated Learning (MMFL) utilizes multiple modalities in each
client to build a more powerful Federated Learning (FL) model than its unimodal
counterpart. However, the impact of missing modality in different clients, also
called modality incongruity, has been greatly overlooked. This paper, for the
first time, analyses the impact of modality incongruity and reveals its
connection with data heterogeneity across participating clients. We
particularly inspect whether incongruent MMFL with unimodal and multimodal
clients is more beneficial than unimodal FL. Furthermore, we examine three
potential routes of addressing this issue. Firstly, we study the effectiveness
of various self-attention mechanisms towards incongruity-agnostic information
fusion in MMFL. Secondly, we introduce a modality imputation network (MIN)
pre-trained in a multimodal client for modality translation in unimodal clients
and investigate its potential towards mitigating the missing modality problem.
Thirdly, we assess the capability of client-level and server-level
regularization techniques towards mitigating modality incongruity effects.
Experiments are conducted under several MMFL settings on two publicly available
real-world datasets, MIMIC-CXR and Open-I, with Chest X-Ray and radiology
reports. | [
0.000019722,
0.1165604517,
-0.0110735307,
0.0065274774,
-0.0015040247,
0.0243960917,
0.0621729828,
0.0137403002,
-0.0145897232,
-0.0216136035,
-0.0806614012,
-0.0288460869,
0.0463471413,
0.0280746184,
0.0204885751,
-0.0461667217,
0.0508456193,
0.0541488267,
-0.0382343829,
-0.0302026607,
-0.0080180326,
0.0024595712,
-0.0050974675,
0.0559321903,
-0.0050537512,
-0.026666604,
0.0074996892,
0.0243211053,
0.0216507725,
-0.0022540435,
0.0241369251,
0.0357802548,
0.0019180103,
0.0294013545,
0.0000023375,
-0.0098910425,
0.0016897141,
-0.0094401985,
0.0101418067,
-0.0152370417,
0.0215878431,
-0.0399209261,
0.0221303459,
-0.0053686951,
-0.0033332154,
-0.0656077415,
0.043786332,
0.0385536812,
0.0203925949,
0.0492689535,
-0.0162263233,
0.0206276532,
0.0207054745,
-0.0197828636,
-0.0517832786,
-0.0226466171,
-0.0016100405,
0.0079961857,
0.0013677567,
-0.0272960793,
-0.0330149382,
0.0592818446,
0.0182788093,
0.0563053414,
0.0175631531,
0.0286964811,
-0.0006900423,
-0.0114493808,
-0.0448549651,
0.08704108,
-0.0164769981,
0.0291642528,
-0.0080519104,
-0.0400872938,
-0.0066857026,
0.0398873426,
-0.0073311664,
-0.0310772769,
-0.0137292258,
0.0233368371,
-0.0306791645,
-0.0037010363,
0.0456886664,
-0.0163015909,
-0.0107523976,
0.0055349101,
-0.0154646644,
0.0357697606,
-0.0309111122,
-0.0104154302,
-0.016187543,
-0.0519048423,
0.0244702436,
0.0249269679,
-0.0489226878,
-0.0369912051,
-0.0620923862,
-0.0771524981,
0.04026521,
0.006055695,
0.0239229091,
0.00191892,
-0.0947541669,
0.043839626,
-0.0087620122,
-0.0364934169,
-0.0775952861,
0.106599614,
-0.0409804136,
0.0295520872,
-0.0475968346,
-0.0000695993,
0.031480629,
-0.0068498901,
-0.0055155703,
-0.0329138786,
-0.0019640788,
0.008346458,
-0.0261341929,
-0.0084878067,
-0.0182054285,
0.0431395285,
-0.0534735732,
-0.0082592461,
-0.0089131584,
0.0978618041,
0.0300995503,
0.010421901,
-0.0107139507,
-0.0515592173,
0.0093926433,
0.0320488885,
-0.0098884031,
-0.0213573985,
0.0030123992,
0.0521425009,
-0.0096435407,
-0.0118930899,
-0.0051929569,
-0.0394300334,
-0.0188108739,
-0.0213359371,
0.0355797336,
-0.0395404287,
0.0164624844,
0.0009047008,
0.0180045404,
-0.0128518399,
-0.0006346371,
-0.0191590693,
-0.0414781868,
0.100870207,
-0.0476008505,
-0.0302912258,
0.0146186035,
-0.0048223981,
0.025367137,
0.0978167951,
-0.0158728901,
-0.0380208604,
0.0142417438,
-0.0018292421,
-0.0314512439,
-0.0048946273,
0.0244041421,
0.0137479268,
-0.0317316204,
-0.0384592675,
-0.032951057,
0.0652659759,
0.0286032204,
0.0036525126,
0.013557069,
-0.047316961,
0.0271006133,
-0.0033048948,
0.0803193152,
-0.0149006853,
-0.0060853991,
-0.0382609591,
-0.0372472182,
0.0793104842,
-0.0394365378,
0.0309049617,
-0.0251298044,
-0.03501416,
-0.0236550514,
0.0768165737,
-0.0239437409,
-0.0483822525,
-0.0283305552,
-0.0239505507,
-0.0258021988,
0.0028994444,
0.05365628,
0.003176182,
-0.0037795878,
0.0109249325,
0.0387170613,
0.0143423304,
-0.0166693553,
-0.0245803241,
-0.0484810844,
0.0345184617,
0.0525143333,
-0.0620008297,
-0.063058801,
-0.0083257509,
0.0188940968,
0.0147331292,
-0.0024801579,
0.0205381624,
0.0633799657,
-0.0429959483,
-0.0872130468,
0.0433517359,
0.0136005729,
-0.0274436269,
-0.0977406129,
0.015880106,
-0.0198134277,
-0.0418261662,
0.0444707386,
0.0285516456,
0.0216535162,
0.0324472152,
-0.0030300817,
0.0323963575,
0.0326522179,
-0.0225484483,
-0.0133888023,
0.0218865667,
-0.004162461,
-0.0213689636,
-0.0801734254,
0.0465211831,
-0.0717110336,
-0.0372380204,
0.0290611144,
-0.048299361,
-0.016591128,
0.0124480445,
-0.0508107878,
0.0009339689,
0.0029853836,
-0.0347048789,
0.0198149215,
-0.0047719507,
0.0199747607,
0.0498174131,
0.0373023227,
0.010947302,
0.0244224537,
-0.0743061379,
-0.0066097486,
0.0296664741,
-0.047915969,
0.0331044048,
-0.0185735226,
0.0340283439,
0.0367351323,
-0.0108150747,
0.0001926896,
-0.0368690751,
-0.0169785433,
-0.0106042009,
0.0295554567,
-0.0710579753,
-0.0008430923,
-0.0141280182,
-0.0168968029,
0.0108861439,
0.0550725684,
0.0017398086,
-0.0659122244,
-0.0144233899,
0.0570496544,
0.0201986078,
0.0402667075,
0.0308550354,
0.0047213291,
-0.004155363,
-0.0054585938,
-0.0074409912,
-0.0352421179,
0.0247214567,
-0.0102811558,
-0.0232105609,
-0.0266470257,
-0.0411544964,
-0.0617517792,
0.0384776592,
0.0024782228,
-0.0149839288,
-0.0102121336,
-0.0063200379,
-0.0205125175,
0.0344314426,
-0.0024794284,
0.0212462246,
0.0458425917,
0.0030875728,
-0.0194295216,
0.0196670126,
0.0014628299,
-0.0142400246,
0.0013049098,
-0.0244149622,
0.0122970333,
0.0706589296,
0.009461523,
-0.0022404266,
-0.0250920728,
0.0324852392,
-0.0148449447,
-0.0334125981,
-0.0684520379,
0.053077627,
0.0026086143,
0.0154766487,
-0.0130789112,
-0.0614546388,
0.0643198118,
0.0178768914,
0.0172013436,
-0.0451717414,
-0.0081162462,
-0.0261580478,
-0.0110278949,
0.00065304,
0.0582530685,
0.0120126596,
-0.0427900553,
-0.057745643,
0.0166488439,
0.0060225958,
-0.0058184722,
0.0200257134,
-0.020939948,
-0.0064913561,
-0.0217459947,
-0.0096868584,
-0.0100632431,
-0.0595959201,
-0.0229228344,
-0.0171896648,
-0.0345205069,
0.0344074108,
-0.0602452941,
-0.0043877447,
-0.0100484928,
0.0425668806,
0.0140115842,
-0.0203644186,
-0.0098605454,
0.0548171103,
-0.0029955166,
0.0480310209,
-0.009960467,
-0.0257701036,
-0.0069893878,
0.0667815506,
0.0384426489,
0.0069152205,
-0.0071492027,
0.001970463,
-0.0085156839,
0.0543163978,
-0.0354192592,
-0.0049927342,
0.0608024597,
-0.0434527211,
0.0556926504,
0.0289623421,
-0.0016857227,
-0.0592919402,
-0.0051883454,
-0.035164468,
0.0116329463,
-0.0133914733,
-0.0313664973,
-0.0601397976,
-0.0633366853,
0.0025366615,
0.0184659977,
0.0111585679,
0.0016521745,
0.0097079687,
-0.0112130558,
0.0524261072,
0.0280856043,
-0.0311852377,
-0.0512126647,
0.0220089443,
0.0203281138,
0.0026627937,
0.0188724957,
-0.0297051128,
0.0011630394,
-0.0397564285,
0.0195235144,
-0.0334020294,
-0.082743898,
-0.0461701974,
-0.0093540065,
0.0393771827,
-0.0008211345,
0.0102444403,
-0.0102556776,
-0.090046376,
-0.0160967633,
0.0585619248,
0.0267316774,
-0.0252198931,
0.0705205128,
-0.0272526238,
-0.0293154176,
-0.0245000888,
0.0185041036,
0.001363988,
-0.0377966315,
-0.0404212587,
0.0628670305,
-0.035181284,
0.0071849884,
-0.0808917359,
0.0297691897,
0.0532768779,
0.0224561132,
-0.0100188116,
-0.0239017904,
-0.0097881313,
0.0371563062,
0.0748610124,
0.031158451,
0.0103007145,
0.0686317161,
-0.0270147119,
-0.0510419607,
-0.0371863246,
-0.0362244472,
-0.0200027376,
0.0186490119,
0.0045390585,
-0.0020517106,
-0.0176254604,
-0.0073694172,
-0.0269831028,
0.0742814764,
-0.0009759883,
0.0344295539,
-0.0364916213,
0.007388927,
-0.0228890069,
-0.0406023636,
-0.0132091828,
0.0369579718,
-0.0605539754,
-0.0053072781,
-0.0250898618,
-0.0030909493,
0.0044673155,
0.0290069692,
-0.0026498926,
-0.0206870511,
0.0500295758,
0.0367564149,
-0.0474074297,
0.0224478915,
0.0699249655,
-0.0933264196,
-0.0265993215,
0.0218323972,
-0.0064371657,
-0.0047392659,
0.0203073584,
0.0121204341,
0.0294953678,
-0.0361785404,
0.0059607043,
0.0003953952,
0.0896676555,
-0.0436554216,
0.0279911738,
-0.0031242273,
0.0117533281,
0.0300010163,
0.0263908226,
-0.0240282211,
-0.0099465474,
0.0004271231,
0.0029388743,
0.0062159225,
0.0056996965,
-0.0263952687,
-0.0285987817,
-0.012762581,
0.0454358719,
0.0370689221,
-0.051337678,
0.0203825254,
0.0075300159,
0.0101155974,
0.0225189067,
0.0212969705,
0.0304347239,
0.0008817586,
0.0868760124,
0.0052935183,
0.0136894062,
-0.0382230356,
0.0409544595,
-0.0142512992,
-0.0460082479,
-0.013184892,
0.0246836543,
0.0494530164,
-0.0038210719,
-0.0081792315,
0.031721361,
0.0080861002,
-0.0331198201,
0.0187539179,
-0.0223012175,
0.0077504339,
0.0553171337,
-0.0210188478,
0.0154533265,
0.0349789113,
0.1098138466,
-0.0393329747,
0.036371775,
-0.0671812445,
-0.0137774218,
-0.0508783311,
0.0063627665,
0.1047634929,
0.0566635914,
-0.0620133653,
0.0127463834,
-0.0291453116,
-0.0670300871,
0.0194381867,
-0.0208098926,
-0.0190070812,
0.0006276303,
0.0225399788,
0.0377639942,
0.0068893102,
-0.0499167182,
-0.0231853947,
0.0493147112,
0.0158998035,
0.0229401942,
0.0562932678,
-6.919965531e-33,
-0.0257990286,
-0.01272697,
-0.0046524238,
-0.0505595841,
0.0130175855,
0.0650409162,
-0.0065090465,
-0.0132322628,
0.0308936555,
0.0263114888,
-0.0016560932,
0.0057526701,
0.0080645569,
0.0261676945,
0.0172070712,
-0.0157668944,
0.0287457407,
0.0242400505,
-0.0097282361,
-0.0187268294,
0.0210614372,
0.0236977022,
0.0669904649,
-0.1177933142,
-0.0082782321,
0.0293899179,
-0.0115444707,
0.0152216405,
-0.0136429276,
0.031914562,
-0.0378377289,
0.0683685094,
0.0335964225,
0.015874872,
-0.0332069546,
-0.0038139657,
-0.0432159007,
-0.0036761139,
-0.0003667748,
0.036109861,
-0.0795938,
-0.0066884342,
0.0664678738,
-0.0344207399,
0.0291420128,
-0.0474040247,
0.0544924773,
-0.0192919448,
-0.0145433601,
0.051394891,
-0.0374501869,
0.0354006439,
0.0029834765,
-0.0109556103,
-0.0320876613,
0.0371700972,
0.0162680577,
-0.0201318562,
-0.0505923927,
0.0049585486,
-0.0046830084,
-0.0120620057,
0.0542029105,
0.0279066451,
-0.0256380718,
0.0609834865,
0.0654122904,
-0.0578721091,
-0.0410986692,
0.0007914871,
0.00333878,
0.0415096283,
0.0210013818,
0.0530375354,
0.0019783166,
0.0083519537,
-0.017947359,
0.0217949413,
-0.0307869427,
0.0130907195,
-0.0132388696,
0.049164366,
-0.0056257374,
0.0040567336,
0.0346312895,
-0.0067964224,
-0.0072367047,
-0.031216599,
0.0196542088,
0.0070761559,
-0.0051386845,
0.0299695898,
0.0432364009,
-0.0217213314,
-0.0237068236,
-0.0156354252,
0.0773104355,
0.0451088957,
-0.0039501251,
0.0009229952,
-0.0254141614,
0.0091426065,
0.0618701242,
-0.0123238051,
0.043393787,
-0.0044868379,
0.0484783724,
0.0204399303,
-0.0325700268,
-0.044287812,
-0.0092184972,
-0.0355915129,
-0.0234613456,
0.0259218905,
0.0923067182,
0.0002373072,
-0.0546585806,
0.0190744177,
0.0161995832,
0.0172949433,
-0.0945242122,
-0.0629554018,
-0.0360939242,
0.0355308242,
-0.0170615688,
-0.0151650272,
-0.0621462688,
-0.0585586168,
0.0399419181,
-0.0417839289,
-0.0298564117,
-0.0198708065,
3.136e-7,
0.0532979369,
-0.0214710981,
-0.0190652329,
-0.0764922872,
0.0249542333,
0.0391057432,
-0.0533074476,
0.0474545769,
-0.0003992672,
-0.0214004628,
0.0350762047,
0.001504375,
0.0064964606,
0.0249249339,
0.0229658093,
0.0110142538,
-0.0128863575,
0.0328421444,
-0.0146424714,
-0.0397164077,
-0.0000663457,
0.0429161005,
-0.0111123947,
-0.07980299,
0.0598779619,
-0.0075339344,
0.0258157998,
-0.0210217405,
-0.0317993797,
-0.0338343494,
0.0320170298,
0.0504249856,
0.0178094655,
0.0170627087,
-0.001564251,
-0.0261036158,
0.0520721599,
0.0134180523,
-0.0627379417,
0.0098517602,
-0.0419111215,
0.0345626287,
-0.0164600071,
0.0036966209,
0.0649459362,
-0.0425285883,
-0.0344840698,
-0.0288401712,
-0.0080300439,
0.0104265353,
0.0866682231,
0.0171928871,
-0.0736028031,
0.0290775765,
0.0209780801,
0.0127080288,
-0.0715699494,
-0.0702520683,
-0.0134706665,
0.0176841486,
-0.0541729964,
-0.027021138,
-0.0056760632,
0.0130026992,
0.0492774807,
-0.0776994452,
-0.0576649792,
2.627217247e-34,
0.0142851537,
0.0069611552,
0.0316479355,
-0.0516252927,
-0.0066038258,
-0.038517952,
-0.0048572738,
0.0158115681,
0.0082862992,
0.0170580558,
0.0073336815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05282v1 | TreeForm: End-to-end Annotation and Evaluation for Form Document Parsing | 2024-02-07T21:54:53 | 2024-02-07T21:54:53 | Ran Zmigrod, Zhiqiang Ma, Armineh Nourbakhsh, Sameena Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Visually Rich Form Understanding (VRFU) poses a complex research problem due
to the documents' highly structured nature and yet highly variable style and
content. Current annotation schemes decompose form understanding and omit key
hierarchical structure, making development and evaluation of end-to-end models
difficult. In this paper, we propose a novel F1 metric to evaluate form parsers
and describe a new content-agnostic, tree-based annotation scheme for VRFU:
TreeForm. We provide methods to convert previous annotation schemes into
TreeForm structures and evaluate TreeForm predictions using a modified version
of the normalized tree-edit distance. We present initial baselines for our
end-to-end performance metric and the TreeForm edit distance, averaged over the
FUNSD and XFUND datasets, of 61.5 and 26.4 respectively. We hope that TreeForm
encourages deeper research in annotating, modeling, and evaluating the
complexities of form-like documents. | [
0.007864547,
-0.023877034,
0.0245717205,
0.0292794444,
0.0133769698,
0.0171702933,
-0.0538638048,
-0.0085816011,
-0.022994468,
-0.0599845499,
-0.0379550382,
-0.045007024,
0.0236586016,
0.0398430452,
-0.0317838527,
-0.1029816791,
0.0210178923,
-0.0076411976,
0.0173582863,
0.0749227181,
0.0416042097,
-0.0115334811,
0.0093778037,
0.0332302824,
-0.0463496931,
-0.0739354864,
-0.0475038178,
0.0401474871,
-0.0075961608,
-0.0596205369,
-0.0009166923,
0.034242969,
-0.0063491534,
0.066854313,
0.0000019311,
-0.0151321068,
-0.0426606573,
0.0548201427,
-0.0314029045,
0.0089768097,
0.0393538661,
-0.0356879309,
-0.0245943591,
-0.0196328424,
-0.0116168223,
-0.0187085792,
0.0441186056,
0.0428190678,
0.0859127641,
0.0715653747,
-0.0203910861,
-0.0317574553,
0.0743668675,
-0.0113982763,
0.0266919993,
-0.0306293033,
-0.0340452716,
0.001647535,
-0.0239677224,
-0.0021300325,
-0.0052370853,
-0.0048576999,
0.012840664,
-0.0529479012,
0.0421924852,
0.0102386605,
-0.0335749947,
-0.0132322321,
-0.0090315957,
0.0626906753,
0.0001060306,
0.0298621655,
0.0001288641,
-0.0162068978,
-0.0071638268,
0.0031652909,
-0.0572311357,
0.0194244664,
-0.0418760926,
-0.0116542736,
0.0502857268,
-0.0111292778,
0.0126620764,
-0.0179963578,
0.050911922,
0.073515147,
-0.0118478052,
-0.0525019281,
0.0233192071,
0.014720194,
-0.0280882996,
-0.0617505796,
0.0188175067,
-0.0142536201,
-0.0112729706,
-0.0143196611,
-0.0355875008,
-0.0758556649,
0.0231666472,
-0.060150113,
0.0630599856,
-0.0209792089,
-0.0246908348,
0.0486705191,
-0.0079235835,
0.0380248576,
0.0031891603,
0.0212205946,
-0.0205318015,
0.0227245949,
-0.074380368,
-0.011691168,
-0.042009946,
0.0101323398,
-0.0658674315,
-0.0298325028,
0.0221383125,
0.0089433352,
-0.0146417869,
0.0190051701,
0.0529619902,
-0.0269557741,
-0.0092863748,
0.0071570734,
0.002717098,
0.0534392484,
-0.0225308537,
-0.0246492233,
0.0393062681,
0.0052096369,
0.0072934334,
0.0291010346,
0.0250759088,
-0.0378705114,
-0.0382083282,
0.0039273431,
0.0084309196,
0.0140057439,
-0.0216578227,
-0.0164658483,
0.03454189,
0.0138721997,
0.0571967177,
-0.0405692421,
-0.0054250248,
-0.017349055,
0.0072709601,
0.0086196186,
-0.007987285,
0.0209252536,
0.0134993643,
0.0611599833,
-0.0306558758,
-0.015797507,
0.0424091145,
-0.0137794092,
-0.0144436127,
0.0520593338,
0.0113282977,
0.0338045917,
0.0398969799,
-0.00275798,
0.018179765,
0.0331689604,
-0.0309607778,
-0.0238904245,
0.0383093134,
0.0093844589,
-0.0359211341,
0.0094900979,
0.0321320258,
-0.0137091875,
-0.0351946354,
-0.0176958628,
0.0014356085,
0.0092395293,
0.0518151149,
-0.0391642749,
0.0242780019,
0.0262995046,
0.0218943898,
0.0108244978,
-0.0519914664,
0.0002777717,
-0.0329473354,
0.0301735401,
-0.047515206,
-0.0571518727,
0.0196132045,
-0.0123992236,
-0.0268544611,
0.0037048261,
0.0035727844,
-0.0450122245,
0.0286496263,
0.0325705558,
-0.0253822114,
0.0199657045,
-0.0032569941,
-0.0610089414,
-0.0299227275,
0.0101255486,
0.003731335,
0.0368929282,
0.0229644794,
-0.0731517896,
-0.0138046248,
-0.0094510298,
0.012913716,
0.007299298,
0.0480230525,
-0.0488043688,
0.0388795324,
-0.0125613715,
-0.0367629677,
-0.0110627571,
0.0229740776,
-0.0228336062,
-0.0614981055,
-0.0601954944,
0.0137812924,
-0.0443823226,
-0.0209854189,
0.0566401482,
0.0500107892,
-0.0148447743,
-0.019394407,
0.0150828129,
0.0157775432,
0.0357117578,
-0.008547591,
0.0289385524,
-0.0132704852,
-0.0104115354,
0.0336045995,
-0.0504274853,
-0.0206931699,
-0.0406728834,
0.0123416958,
-0.0194222983,
-0.0364211686,
0.0036355145,
-0.0632434487,
-0.0353488475,
-0.0496544875,
-0.0319237486,
0.0418073125,
-0.0418210737,
0.0222525243,
0.0092798695,
-0.0478659384,
-0.0308059417,
0.0725391954,
0.0027185825,
-0.0091709513,
-0.0360803232,
0.0073615578,
0.0467122607,
-0.0119767068,
-0.0271641351,
-0.014986516,
-0.0133604929,
-0.0312374402,
-0.0011676972,
0.031120168,
-0.0773918554,
-0.0046507362,
-0.0555013493,
-0.0018789541,
-0.0350272171,
0.0803888589,
0.0465557911,
0.0019395322,
0.0155258179,
-0.0315989964,
-0.0418511145,
-0.0195386335,
-0.030502947,
0.0053900937,
0.0451325811,
0.0068820752,
-0.0140103782,
-0.0389047973,
-0.020234406,
-0.0322038829,
0.0389976837,
0.0537254289,
-0.0621063411,
-0.0029914146,
0.0009708281,
0.0144666396,
0.0124463243,
0.0266384315,
-0.0011737226,
0.0120017054,
-0.0597483218,
-0.0127752451,
0.0811309442,
-0.0075608133,
-0.0012403245,
-0.0111001879,
0.0017844861,
-0.0167333186,
-0.0003012943,
0.026467815,
0.0711444765,
-0.0538031198,
-0.0407429487,
0.0330449715,
0.0987591818,
-0.0565650836,
0.0332024544,
-0.0042905579,
-0.0199917872,
-0.0137826335,
-0.0018314365,
-0.0101569621,
-0.0274319705,
-0.0074750273,
0.0337131657,
-0.0356590971,
-0.0355753452,
0.0454186201,
-0.0802524909,
-0.0423335619,
0.0097861504,
0.0393925905,
-0.0364854224,
0.0972886756,
0.0335644484,
-0.014686428,
0.0174288359,
-0.075035952,
-0.0067304913,
0.0662589818,
0.0714802593,
-0.0152028129,
0.0125663206,
-0.0192908291,
0.031252943,
-0.0504494756,
-0.0045486991,
0.0120286299,
-0.0189865567,
0.0019123866,
0.0284837801,
-0.0267318264,
-0.0210249182,
0.0077945064,
0.0360828526,
-0.0188016258,
0.0823498666,
-0.0037426206,
-0.0199269168,
0.0018792741,
0.0635262951,
0.0261254311,
-0.0001662115,
0.015638208,
-0.0298286136,
0.0496423431,
0.03984477,
-0.0151763065,
0.0158299282,
-0.0056187869,
-0.0037157335,
-0.0314983353,
-0.040504884,
-0.0507543571,
-0.0048911897,
0.0443588421,
-0.1195521578,
-0.0033763146,
0.0802633166,
0.0549887232,
-0.0244103894,
-0.0252977815,
-0.0596195012,
0.0576266423,
0.0348972119,
0.0126046771,
-0.0822289884,
-0.0103195608,
0.0498024039,
0.030747233,
0.0159556847,
-0.0616106391,
0.0598955713,
-0.0673842803,
0.0431870855,
-0.0170985851,
-0.0310782325,
0.01251298,
-0.0177147947,
-0.0036670512,
0.0169800334,
-0.0278927367,
0.0200240146,
-0.025478106,
-0.0160045028,
0.0175847039,
-0.0836675093,
0.0086742761,
-0.0023729147,
-0.0232619364,
-0.007263754,
0.1053775325,
0.011957068,
0.0303604323,
-0.0160789471,
0.0563820899,
-0.0050173141,
0.0015747448,
-0.0344265103,
0.0315053351,
0.022823995,
0.0039352877,
0.0005639836,
-0.0008900782,
0.0073409565,
0.0016086961,
0.0099868998,
0.0430997126,
-0.0354837179,
0.0118438127,
0.0030942012,
-0.0512219258,
0.0074483282,
0.0405142047,
0.0611979514,
0.0080488035,
-0.0763780847,
-0.0897142142,
0.0230349246,
-0.0347438827,
-0.0116019472,
0.0629636273,
-0.0251372568,
4.938e-7,
-0.0749765858,
-0.0562762395,
0.0147499563,
0.0203967541,
-0.0369633213,
-0.0274628419,
0.0130937845,
-0.0250024423,
0.0100840116,
0.0515125915,
0.0250068251,
0.0220654365,
-0.0086351112,
-0.0031225511,
-0.0366763063,
0.0238330141,
-0.049018126,
-0.0159010459,
-0.0401118696,
0.0260051955,
0.0040897811,
0.0385649912,
0.0131118,
0.0260469392,
-0.0229284018,
-0.0471746027,
-0.0494220108,
-0.0251335334,
-0.0154429208,
-0.0329955928,
0.0316770487,
-0.0224638693,
0.0004883846,
0.0172939301,
-0.0305683594,
0.0144254491,
-0.0016572918,
0.0806323886,
0.0258005522,
0.0401604213,
0.0335363597,
0.0490252078,
0.0320006013,
0.0212022532,
0.0204176195,
-0.0152161773,
0.0245424528,
-0.04519042,
-0.0241429899,
-0.053567715,
0.0265761539,
0.0003628634,
-0.0075325863,
0.0189151801,
0.0394794606,
0.0047717267,
0.0600456633,
-0.06949462,
0.0658978745,
0.090061903,
0.0538699813,
-0.0330162086,
-0.004612946,
0.0127197215,
-0.0438470803,
0.0382154733,
0.0465018414,
-0.007933489,
0.0608902387,
0.0053593754,
0.0099056521,
-0.0081466576,
0.0066352151,
-0.0411197171,
-0.0242060721,
-0.0528735183,
-0.012636086,
0.0003254501,
-0.0138621265,
0.0737239122,
-0.0087163374,
-0.0030698769,
-0.0048036901,
0.0263679549,
0.05731472,
-0.0457141064,
0.0204914454,
0.0174660552,
-0.0071836212,
-0.0283155236,
0.0538325347,
0.0152140558,
0.0021986454,
-0.0315951928,
-0.0285385735,
-0.0419153608,
-0.0082397107,
-0.0320785008,
0.037684653,
-0.0191088952,
-0.0121557852,
-0.0388547964,
-0.0055248863,
0.0349317901,
0.0214491524,
0.0071793841,
0.0530370399,
0.0366846137,
0.0201040711,
-0.0234365407,
-0.0601121783,
-0.0119432118,
-0.0069276667,
-0.0188727565,
-0.0099744713,
-0.0387213901,
-5.412315415e-33,
-0.0459007658,
0.0166980438,
-0.0213763379,
0.0373887159,
-0.0514101349,
0.0397821479,
-0.0740772635,
-0.005157717,
0.0165627357,
0.0419878103,
-0.0020213665,
-0.0074822102,
0.0219114851,
0.0447168946,
0.0306050889,
-0.0137358597,
0.0291986875,
-0.0255769584,
-0.0329027213,
0.00549783,
0.0082749669,
0.0303353798,
0.0668977648,
-0.0983771831,
0.0406773426,
0.0090197986,
-0.0268329773,
0.0253790822,
0.0343638361,
0.0650292337,
0.0295916814,
-0.0384655893,
0.0226059966,
-0.0444886908,
-0.0304508321,
0.032553032,
-0.1015910134,
0.0388259813,
-0.0282964483,
-0.0009690907,
-0.0577071309,
0.0177262928,
0.0187750347,
-0.0099525461,
0.0521824099,
-0.0309482682,
0.0380107462,
-0.042872373,
-0.0118888533,
-0.0347309746,
-0.0553072803,
0.0483456291,
-0.0205154866,
0.0055043488,
0.0281206686,
0.0365413763,
0.0259456858,
0.0117995413,
-0.0287787765,
-0.0251106471,
-0.0169585254,
0.0398034081,
0.022528844,
0.0244758651,
0.0326851942,
0.0501922704,
0.0424928516,
0.0048198309,
-0.0228446368,
0.0386802964,
0.0173599441,
0.0569356605,
0.00727406,
0.0002667977,
0.0225045327,
0.0348644406,
-0.0356067978,
0.0302952938,
-0.0003958039,
0.0468856096,
-0.0602211691,
0.0083321305,
0.0079161916,
0.0098506315,
-0.0299863294,
-0.0456645228,
-0.0186640043,
0.011348526,
0.0130945295,
0.0023976816,
0.0249787271,
0.0185267404,
0.0315728746,
0.0010020802,
-0.0140389418,
-0.0010169355,
0.0024884613,
0.1011505276,
-0.0145424232,
-0.0290713366,
0.0195674356,
-0.0113891326,
0.0105892196,
-0.0132704759,
0.0295625031,
-0.0249494202,
0.0690516233,
-0.0105151339,
-0.0451206639,
0.0102157099,
-0.0246260688,
-0.0139751118,
-0.0489975847,
0.0862714648,
0.0500651784,
-0.0352152176,
-0.0369383991,
0.0569807068,
-0.0028542986,
0.0499372333,
-0.0411343239,
-0.0431890078,
0.0086096814,
0.0060397116,
-0.0233727042,
-0.0243437309,
0.0004818538,
-0.0545075275,
0.0421551429,
-0.0150915068,
0.0268655345,
0.0168135688,
2.32e-7,
0.0881016403,
0.0394739546,
0.0598943457,
-0.0334858038,
0.0477928333,
0.0201838054,
-0.0099932877,
-0.0087064784,
-0.0221601613,
-0.0389918201,
0.0045579891,
-0.0586924851,
0.0508907139,
0.0331723168,
-0.0779753253,
-0.0201042686,
-0.1129094884,
-0.023199087,
-0.0394205526,
-0.0045441575,
0.015525504,
0.0605753176,
-0.0432332419,
-0.0232548956,
0.0130658355,
0.000577636,
0.0225200746,
0.0000208829,
0.0485389978,
0.0183353871,
-0.0106619885,
-0.0426495224,
0.0037314452,
0.0007252018,
-0.0222947206,
0.0038444467,
0.0351736024,
0.0747661889,
-0.0338205025,
0.0324422531,
0.0134000946,
-0.0277669579,
0.0316270031,
-0.0157883,
0.0162029844,
0.0205175783,
-0.0007305921,
-0.0378761068,
-0.0544779599,
0.0243931152,
-0.0170066822,
0.0281501357,
0.0214734524,
0.055109296,
0.0083845789,
-0.0527870134,
-0.0014790472,
-0.0382308699,
-0.0837025642,
0.0169138964,
0.0128565431,
-0.0084324488,
-0.037790101,
0.0376588888,
-0.0067474693,
-0.005098816,
-0.0628296733,
2.243128371e-34,
0.0215776265,
-0.0209058914,
0.025214009,
0.0494019613,
0.0371569991,
0.0089701945,
0.0209006201,
0.0062368093,
-0.0109320385,
-0.0740666762,
0.0146905342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07938v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07938v2 | Large Language User Interfaces: Voice Interactive User Interfaces powered by LLMs | 2024-02-07T21:08:49 | 2024-04-16T07:39:05 | Syed Mekael Wasti, Ken Q. Pu, Ali Neshati | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.1 | The evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs) has showcased remarkable
capacities for logical reasoning and natural language comprehension. These
capabilities can be leveraged in solutions that semantically and textually
model complex problems. In this paper, we present our efforts toward
constructing a framework that can serve as an intermediary between a user and
their user interface (UI), enabling dynamic and real-time interactions. We
employ a system that stands upon textual semantic mappings of UI components, in
the form of annotations. These mappings are stored, parsed, and scaled in a
custom data structure, supplementary to an agent-based prompting backend
engine. Employing textual semantic mappings allows each component to not only
explain its role to the engine but also provide expectations. By comprehending
the needs of both the user and the components, our LLM engine can classify the
most appropriate application, extract relevant parameters, and subsequently
execute precise predictions of the user's expected actions. Such an integration
evolves static user interfaces into highly dynamic and adaptable solutions,
introducing a new frontier of intelligent and responsive user experiences. | [
0.0345244482,
-0.0204933584,
-0.0505174436,
0.0429382436,
-0.014805655,
0.0020407557,
0.0119651183,
0.0084457779,
0.0770716518,
-0.058745034,
-0.0268966127,
-0.002571173,
-0.0137865581,
0.0314412341,
-0.0231710337,
-0.0638838261,
0.0266202372,
-0.057580363,
-0.0152057568,
0.0280169006,
0.003443382,
0.0340752639,
-0.0382086448,
0.0580842644,
-0.0172653049,
-0.0322981738,
-0.0309546217,
0.0014466906,
-0.0214056931,
-0.0363338031,
-0.0660288036,
0.0175155029,
0.0206302796,
0.0298037138,
0.0000021296,
-0.0762389377,
0.0227650292,
-0.0088378396,
-0.0359661356,
-0.0220501479,
0.0362570211,
0.0647685379,
-0.0235485081,
-0.0004776049,
-0.0276253894,
0.0131613929,
0.0370273367,
0.0010562569,
0.0745711103,
-0.0016015864,
-0.0129097467,
0.0030450816,
0.0116535695,
0.037193846,
0.0374347791,
-0.0220588036,
0.0026922477,
-0.004032589,
0.0714568645,
-0.006529998,
0.0515504628,
0.01671765,
0.0033538407,
-0.0294981375,
-0.0077810572,
0.013320202,
-0.0212919004,
-0.039270822,
-0.0282544792,
0.0502876118,
0.0414149053,
0.0174167883,
0.0281111635,
0.0157224759,
0.0176364612,
0.0530687608,
-0.0185453966,
-0.0120057529,
-0.0318035111,
-0.0425551198,
0.0242631026,
0.006592256,
0.0189080499,
0.0137177557,
-0.0005971313,
0.0745621324,
0.0118002659,
-0.0102680372,
0.004755456,
-0.0336873643,
-0.0017002292,
-0.0649249852,
0.0243607629,
0.0805994794,
-0.0635700598,
0.0425903648,
-0.0286204554,
-0.0095732473,
0.0123109277,
-0.072434999,
0.0209767558,
0.0600498356,
-0.0134498728,
0.0513042174,
-0.0038749683,
0.0406023338,
-0.0115105389,
-0.020733377,
-0.0274788123,
-0.0337849259,
-0.0381053537,
-0.0297746193,
-0.0501495078,
0.0204926692,
-0.0561982319,
0.0022197396,
-0.0189397838,
0.0938150436,
0.007851352,
0.0443559103,
0.0005507335,
-0.0105707338,
-0.027090542,
-0.0046976758,
-0.0626674369,
-0.0113387695,
-0.0413385816,
-0.0001208055,
-0.0014543037,
-0.0558065772,
0.0550229475,
0.0116205765,
-0.0034919609,
0.0058888658,
-0.0407186449,
0.103797853,
0.0001848629,
0.042539008,
-0.0573906042,
-0.0568108894,
-0.0017888036,
-0.0151526593,
-0.0476535633,
-0.0681460053,
0.0199619569,
0.0338295586,
-0.0269090235,
-0.0344892889,
0.0194422957,
0.0466873199,
0.0221214704,
0.0736838877,
-0.0243112687,
0.0145707326,
0.0585192405,
0.0180964898,
-0.0401537754,
0.0175092686,
0.066012226,
0.0572279394,
0.0241037607,
-0.008862732,
0.0080756349,
0.0526435822,
-0.0696981549,
-0.0185559839,
-0.0214675684,
0.0098054232,
0.0130101554,
0.0142535409,
-0.0679915026,
0.0054521775,
-0.0065595568,
0.0272806175,
0.050658565,
0.1101955026,
0.003792329,
0.0215051007,
0.0198535305,
0.0086531537,
-0.0222737473,
-0.02930847,
-0.0241035633,
0.0377977528,
-0.0066068922,
-0.0136887608,
-0.0084442152,
0.014955448,
0.0110716093,
-0.0670003146,
-0.0130431466,
0.0126713905,
0.0030519653,
0.0017721818,
0.0178787056,
-0.0046657971,
0.013858391,
0.0252251197,
0.0163724255,
-0.0347915515,
-0.0116205523,
-0.0589297302,
0.0328615904,
0.1486413628,
0.0341925099,
-0.0367469713,
-0.0214565955,
0.0042640492,
0.0094485832,
0.0413558744,
0.0150471264,
-0.0183377974,
-0.0223320369,
-0.0102179833,
-0.0231837537,
0.0172530282,
-0.0061367149,
0.0485927202,
-0.0577459186,
-0.0174795724,
-0.0099102333,
-0.0029035546,
-0.0166236851,
0.009039022,
-0.0230142865,
-0.0546725839,
-0.0082624573,
0.0434798338,
0.0125209671,
0.0202948581,
0.0174265467,
-0.0136375679,
0.0153566794,
-0.0353676639,
-0.0030432332,
0.0155555429,
-0.0029262342,
0.0307655782,
0.0361902192,
0.0126248822,
-0.0060711182,
-0.0139586274,
-0.0084701879,
-0.0269771293,
0.0003898648,
-0.0042178477,
0.0258211084,
-0.0163291562,
0.0059841126,
0.0010402204,
-0.037250679,
-0.0311260782,
0.0516153425,
0.0199865904,
-0.0314260013,
0.0459507033,
0.0175440963,
0.022827005,
-0.0333540253,
-0.0033168052,
0.0101370346,
0.0143609149,
0.0094393734,
0.0056705019,
0.0081668906,
0.0021676286,
-0.003205172,
-0.0914296806,
0.0046993247,
-0.0099282591,
-0.0006300767,
0.0288331471,
0.0484852158,
-0.0237194002,
-0.042328652,
-0.0154788177,
0.01947085,
0.0167705826,
0.002896914,
0.0514092296,
0.0284236092,
-0.0275753215,
-0.0192982443,
0.0226390418,
-0.0437404029,
-0.0081132865,
0.0163728856,
-0.0379700437,
-0.0780479237,
-0.0172032118,
-0.0243659113,
0.0244898666,
0.0042813569,
-0.0166701712,
0.0253942721,
-0.0141441822,
0.0154131949,
0.0537593812,
-0.0149339801,
0.0276067629,
0.0481621884,
-0.0310166851,
-0.0616995394,
0.0292609949,
0.0026660475,
0.0114017688,
-0.0540737696,
-0.0144410515,
0.0467917547,
0.0539260507,
-0.0015034335,
0.0295083597,
-0.032618463,
0.0241959356,
-0.0085647758,
-0.0105697466,
-0.0157920048,
-0.0276122205,
-0.0364175886,
0.0975714996,
0.0018584146,
-0.0315785483,
0.0705415457,
-0.0463857539,
-0.0007910355,
-0.0074678729,
-0.064672552,
-0.0289652385,
0.0770424306,
-0.0322936177,
0.014436855,
-0.0112868678,
-0.0343701877,
-0.025906112,
0.0119663645,
0.0119489245,
-0.0344818011,
0.0135095371,
-0.0665879995,
-0.0013474224,
0.0148205953,
-0.0405870639,
-0.025546886,
0.0044755396,
-0.0513039865,
-0.0444418192,
-0.0190967433,
-0.0057590189,
-0.0277311616,
0.0218197871,
-0.0020856315,
0.0554752052,
0.0135431346,
-0.0291692857,
-0.0288354587,
-0.0336034484,
0.0156736691,
0.0676911771,
-0.0522062257,
0.0249116588,
0.0676220134,
0.0264206771,
0.0010217216,
-0.0369475745,
-0.0169380121,
-0.0125894751,
0.0622404143,
-0.0484466106,
-0.0216579288,
0.0451277122,
-0.0019690022,
-0.0788797066,
0.0148093812,
0.1257939488,
0.0327896588,
-0.0419517569,
0.0076603466,
-0.0538011864,
0.0170083418,
0.047921285,
0.0723060519,
-0.0917931721,
-0.0462780222,
0.0025483801,
0.0127769625,
0.0223881137,
-0.0196630415,
-0.0115230288,
-0.0734544992,
0.0276196674,
-0.0119571732,
-0.0027131299,
0.0405803025,
-0.0294281971,
0.0280105975,
0.0134684397,
-0.007787121,
-0.0055268849,
-0.0046466929,
-0.024385076,
-0.0032871987,
-0.0188493766,
0.0016460762,
0.0073252767,
0.0020203532,
0.0282042343,
0.0645310581,
0.059180785,
0.0344745256,
-0.0424609482,
0.0126999728,
0.0403456576,
0.0381831564,
-0.0467918888,
0.001053691,
-0.0063005937,
0.0145811774,
-0.0422428697,
0.0376602858,
-0.0281957127,
-0.0221467912,
0.0529092178,
0.0907949582,
-0.0546158589,
0.0648745,
-0.0369531959,
-0.0234885048,
0.0184003394,
0.0439210162,
-0.0038683871,
-0.0555057935,
-0.0407549962,
-0.0806630924,
-0.0368269794,
0.0178328864,
-0.0632129461,
0.026566796,
-0.0332498141,
-0.0388826691,
-0.046982754,
-0.0254289787,
0.0293276198,
0.0425472856,
0.0555493906,
0.0055841655,
0.0161755309,
0.0264482442,
-0.0001484177,
0.0062763309,
-0.0260001551,
0.0314477161,
-0.0091448221,
0.0106844865,
0.0404094271,
-0.082485497,
0.0021909825,
0.0042689084,
0.0231700018,
-0.0505137891,
-0.0139075089,
0.0421257578,
0.0274750311,
0.0431440398,
-0.0213443525,
-0.0564266518,
-0.00391356,
0.0088699898,
-0.0661348403,
-0.0389107279,
-0.0173443574,
0.0763204619,
0.0091743618,
0.011185253,
-0.0988408774,
-0.0006274455,
-0.0556837171,
0.0054910285,
-0.0651128739,
-0.048950877,
0.0309840087,
0.0556908064,
0.0239813346,
-0.0124802208,
-0.0031196501,
-0.0100503825,
0.0532406345,
-0.0142429732,
-0.0520214401,
-0.0271664876,
0.0328342877,
-0.0348273963,
-0.0214461349,
0.0416853987,
-0.0059708962,
-0.0060793646,
0.0173993185,
-0.0285259001,
0.0327282622,
0.015434036,
0.0158484112,
-0.0009466096,
0.0410966203,
-0.0089189569,
0.0393106639,
0.0275906529,
0.0608803481,
-0.021950217,
0.0678788945,
0.0048757945,
-0.0213549584,
-0.014227096,
0.0269900411,
-0.0452420935,
-0.0704814717,
0.0435783528,
0.0336533785,
-0.0117004635,
0.0210089013,
0.0102848141,
-0.0506879389,
0.01841042,
0.0027474172,
0.0074199899,
0.0332496241,
-0.0251008142,
-0.007957533,
0.0064053722,
0.0029015574,
-0.0494303331,
0.0165992063,
-0.0542028286,
0.0064894459,
-0.0049580722,
-0.0758783519,
-0.046244815,
-0.0300048664,
0.0029219475,
0.0370748751,
-0.0374468565,
-0.0516170897,
-0.0779282972,
-0.0228402615,
-0.0364188179,
0.0335218012,
-0.0348600037,
-0.0648041889,
0.0418860279,
0.0367497951,
0.0373731591,
-0.0410954468,
-0.031508185,
0.0005812797,
-0.0791367888,
-0.0031354211,
-0.0180064775,
-5.157313222e-33,
-0.0380845144,
-0.0326136351,
0.0455088466,
0.0341367088,
0.005915035,
-0.0616800673,
-0.0039232443,
0.0109284092,
0.0055598794,
-0.0330010988,
0.0058394009,
-0.0378057137,
0.0132760014,
-0.0057885507,
0.0108784009,
-0.0032592078,
0.0399031118,
0.0205907542,
-0.0397410803,
0.0299876705,
0.0522811525,
-0.0022850167,
-0.004177792,
-0.093893677,
0.0171062257,
0.005141669,
0.0257036816,
0.0476250872,
-0.0050338181,
0.0441915989,
-0.0262796879,
0.061500717,
0.0094432151,
-0.0053768456,
0.0206444189,
0.073658593,
-0.0315693952,
-0.0484772213,
0.039300628,
0.0503567159,
-0.0108593414,
-0.0295329094,
0.0098746447,
0.0137783643,
-0.0212871488,
0.0506266914,
0.0515490249,
-0.0255524907,
-0.0168178156,
-0.0186401624,
-0.0684815645,
0.0160945095,
-0.0150591312,
-0.0289667323,
-0.003317124,
0.0557239763,
-0.0017622258,
0.0055147647,
-0.0343077481,
-0.0082297716,
-0.011206842,
-0.0083362507,
0.088625215,
0.0542385094,
0.0028178426,
0.0404119641,
0.0111529222,
0.0308180507,
-0.0491177104,
0.0210009404,
-0.0124150347,
0.0514629818,
0.0065641808,
0.0245671812,
-0.0000292241,
-0.0137281567,
-0.0216570031,
0.0501597151,
0.0632541329,
0.0260882936,
0.0124816876,
0.0493827797,
-0.021706365,
0.017033264,
-0.0480719171,
0.0422131978,
-0.0250696614,
-0.0559812114,
0.0390163064,
-0.0341552161,
0.000872154,
-0.0291732289,
-0.0078048864,
0.007195625,
-0.034473002,
-0.0414130464,
0.0102104386,
0.004141896,
-0.0112516163,
0.0229879394,
0.0138202943,
-0.0038397021,
-0.0353943855,
-0.0171303805,
0.0512403548,
0.0174472183,
-0.0448704138,
0.0291417576,
-0.0351010859,
0.007217668,
-0.0310520157,
0.0116410293,
0.0009130526,
0.0137366466,
0.0505280159,
-0.0374780633,
-0.0212879553,
0.0463355891,
-0.0220748745,
-0.0312018003,
-0.007443273,
-0.0431354009,
0.002032456,
-0.0466081947,
-0.0435846858,
-0.0308966786,
-0.0380497873,
0.0371358171,
0.0252896789,
-0.0299702585,
-0.0008396482,
0.0273326598,
2.872e-7,
-0.0012104802,
0.0233914349,
-0.0127527034,
0.0220588688,
0.0284450259,
0.0358930752,
0.009602556,
0.0129551673,
0.0044476609,
-0.025499329,
-0.0029953464,
0.0141201131,
0.0478082895,
0.0487102047,
-0.0918320566,
-0.0339370482,
-0.0032056703,
0.0081005478,
-0.094395332,
0.0693888664,
0.0775690526,
0.0313907079,
0.0051811798,
0.0139964232,
0.0117345043,
-0.0474358946,
-0.0133793382,
-0.0537667461,
0.0338898487,
0.0146413203,
0.0100365924,
0.0253765881,
-0.0005587919,
0.0199834574,
-0.0033116364,
0.0243783519,
-0.0324820429,
0.0382209718,
-0.0192353223,
-0.0047393553,
-0.0024101126,
-0.0356653519,
0.0191310868,
-0.0245686304,
0.0358984694,
-0.030203538,
-0.0283359624,
0.0020855849,
0.0168179739,
-0.0320741683,
-0.0583170131,
-0.0178563166,
-0.0054178629,
0.0083716046,
-0.0033940934,
-0.0261390246,
-0.0203961711,
-0.0417616516,
-0.0020966043,
0.0173140951,
-0.0537658893,
-0.0326157399,
-0.0840796381,
0.0271145497,
0.0099288048,
-0.0479444265,
0.0074573806,
2.457521321e-34,
-0.029023461,
0.0137642417,
-0.0056801955,
0.0721783936,
0.0626291931,
0.0524889193,
0.0209538806,
0.0380121954,
0.0843004063,
-0.0743080974,
-0.0282098297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10940v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10940v1 | Neural machine translation of clinical procedure codes for medical diagnosis and uncertainty quantification | 2024-02-07T20:11:56 | 2024-02-07T20:11:56 | Pei-Hung Chung, Shuhan He, Norawit Kijpaisalratana, Abdel-badih el Ariss, Byung-Jun Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A Clinical Decision Support System (CDSS) is designed to enhance clinician
decision-making by combining system-generated recommendations with medical
expertise. Given the high costs, intensive labor, and time-sensitive nature of
medical treatments, there is a pressing need for efficient decision support,
especially in complex emergency scenarios. In these scenarios, where
information can be limited, an advanced CDSS framework that leverages AI
(artificial intelligence) models to effectively reduce diagnostic uncertainty
has utility. Such an AI-enabled CDSS framework with quantified uncertainty
promises to be practical and beneficial in the demanding context of real-world
medical care. In this study, we introduce the concept of Medical Entropy,
quantifying uncertainties in patient outcomes predicted by neural machine
translation based on the ICD-9 code of procedures. Our experimental results not
only show strong correlations between procedure and diagnosis sequences based
on the simple ICD-9 code but also demonstrate the promising capacity to model
trends of uncertainties during hospitalizations through a data-driven approach. | [
0.0181507375,
0.0566054061,
-0.0247708764,
-0.0581621341,
-0.0122216092,
0.0024004476,
-0.0002361561,
0.0462409183,
-0.044353839,
0.0315726846,
0.0467245951,
-0.065525651,
0.0498499759,
0.0544695929,
-0.0123518109,
-0.0378717892,
0.0150452061,
0.0107950009,
0.0369972512,
0.0166963227,
-0.0580719598,
-0.0401582532,
-0.0258433819,
0.0593666807,
-0.0204122011,
0.0460032187,
0.0314997733,
0.007347926,
0.0378645547,
-0.0865535662,
-0.0255855713,
-0.0029680084,
-0.009920394,
-0.0197033063,
0.0000020146,
-0.0558824651,
-0.0053772954,
-0.0011546214,
-0.0483080298,
-0.0847392604,
0.0006223442,
-0.064739123,
-0.0009573844,
-0.0000381243,
-0.0354230069,
-0.0267687533,
0.0412232541,
0.019852126,
0.0209103469,
0.0282955915,
-0.014381391,
-0.0014654201,
0.0298508871,
-0.0413519554,
0.0123630324,
-0.0449334383,
0.0146277603,
-0.0351614915,
0.0126878247,
-0.0395191796,
0.0180633906,
0.0503123365,
0.0459718592,
0.0256576706,
0.0009884221,
0.0524743162,
0.016509477,
-0.0383807942,
-0.0306683388,
0.0284601599,
-0.0295906607,
-0.0020133622,
-0.0162977558,
-0.0071282843,
0.0071182586,
-0.056251362,
-0.0091647496,
-0.014720764,
-0.026582215,
-0.011858522,
-0.0087188818,
0.0495653339,
0.0486307442,
-0.0267148018,
-0.0172517467,
-0.0052563963,
-0.0209371056,
-0.0327397212,
-0.0071014604,
0.0032063562,
-0.0216483008,
-0.013171969,
0.0062088994,
0.0560178049,
-0.0654593185,
0.0045853611,
0.0121390102,
-0.027704278,
0.0419080034,
-0.0623744652,
0.006482332,
0.0038473934,
0.033802662,
-0.0170219429,
-0.0077066426,
0.0043156627,
-0.02382393,
0.0543921031,
-0.0722480193,
0.016404286,
-0.0223062187,
0.011536357,
-0.0191503763,
0.0027628462,
0.0548084825,
0.0264803525,
-0.0674768612,
-0.0201208871,
-0.0298390798,
0.03968798,
0.0493484363,
0.0655566081,
-0.0120861176,
0.0132191889,
-0.0557627529,
-0.014032769,
-0.0092021078,
0.0000216425,
-0.0024739229,
0.0112874387,
0.0381045304,
0.0097562503,
-0.045914162,
0.024108151,
-0.0008254595,
0.0605627373,
0.0220119879,
0.0071177036,
-0.0101063885,
-0.0312982686,
-0.0439713933,
-0.0021993762,
0.0329377577,
-0.0293562859,
0.0069780308,
0.0196772963,
0.0356980711,
-0.0621624663,
0.0190160461,
-0.0409962907,
-0.0088359928,
0.0507254936,
-0.0500472821,
0.0041047623,
0.0131670525,
0.0304416511,
0.0059853909,
-0.0045959665,
0.0462899096,
-0.0107030738,
0.0075828708,
-0.0375848152,
0.0029339823,
-0.0335717537,
0.0010120351,
-0.0451631881,
-0.0584330186,
-0.0128531493,
-0.0240720995,
0.0813603252,
-0.0330048464,
0.0364985429,
0.0408612974,
-0.04401806,
0.0450445525,
0.0438507162,
0.0382164009,
0.0115807094,
0.0307193454,
-0.0805951357,
-0.0221792497,
-0.014018341,
0.0080922013,
0.0295053832,
0.0426287577,
-0.0077356976,
-0.016595548,
-0.021599466,
-0.0180007331,
-0.0987526923,
-0.0507527404,
-0.0361604616,
-0.0366837904,
0.0055239364,
0.0228800885,
-0.0417340994,
0.0125466064,
0.004380615,
0.0111005334,
0.0227712318,
-0.0509451479,
-0.0662146583,
-0.0254435912,
0.1031954288,
0.0235155188,
-0.0491716787,
-0.0322539806,
-0.0408866405,
-0.0191244129,
-0.0259732418,
0.0366979167,
0.0119170947,
0.0244908072,
-0.0109569514,
0.0017121641,
0.070587188,
0.0303645004,
-0.0303572118,
-0.0257190485,
0.0152169913,
-0.0227274653,
0.0059050438,
-0.0500177853,
0.0238440447,
-0.0211069584,
-0.0058503505,
0.0567601323,
-0.0103091542,
0.0569675304,
0.0065787015,
-0.0285705775,
0.0265013408,
0.0281029344,
-0.0337017924,
-0.0868815705,
0.0243363921,
-0.0305195712,
0.0126478476,
0.010822379,
-0.0027839753,
-0.0106536094,
-0.0512883328,
-0.0440141894,
-0.039955914,
-0.0014105205,
-0.0433180295,
-0.0192978811,
0.0316786282,
0.0159516092,
0.0460765362,
-0.0099923704,
-0.0635769516,
-0.0069163861,
-0.0462156832,
0.0099986261,
-0.0113013731,
-0.0179588906,
0.0350887254,
0.0174817797,
0.0114692822,
-0.0111444872,
-0.0186735764,
0.0151357148,
-0.0020905344,
0.0006234574,
0.0192503072,
-0.0082797818,
-0.0574344844,
-0.0119200116,
0.0384988971,
-0.0227548257,
0.0213949624,
0.0184200238,
0.0155094983,
-0.0118920654,
-0.0123875029,
0.0489472672,
0.0131654525,
-0.0138511322,
0.0419508033,
0.0647783056,
-0.0214595515,
-0.0242504608,
-0.0235275067,
-0.0447183028,
0.0261470899,
0.0421851687,
0.016694719,
-0.0312236436,
0.0117339473,
-0.0205457676,
0.0150321182,
-0.0021821896,
-0.0503771827,
0.0138053978,
-0.0370802395,
-0.0488373227,
0.0338322595,
0.0081761722,
-0.0171235595,
0.0358660556,
-0.0068695978,
-0.0133085381,
0.006372672,
-0.0627041906,
-0.0143485609,
0.0250859018,
-0.069338508,
-0.0093604261,
0.0324961729,
0.0347029343,
-0.0166226719,
-0.0318707936,
-0.0045975163,
-0.0006726365,
0.0008921713,
-0.0531879961,
0.026261311,
-0.0058571161,
0.0981635824,
0.0152117396,
-0.0479433276,
0.1067468449,
0.0196737163,
0.0543537512,
-0.0523981787,
-0.0440002792,
-0.0334409401,
-0.0186137296,
-0.0084388657,
0.0390172079,
0.025617918,
0.0284911022,
-0.0179524757,
0.0130422469,
-0.0248584561,
-0.0532712527,
0.0084021185,
-0.0357321538,
0.0097272499,
0.0351786204,
-0.0231243633,
-0.0329662263,
-0.0024737103,
0.0217421167,
-0.0064357058,
0.0101391813,
-0.0168344676,
0.009998301,
0.0334293768,
-0.0163784213,
0.0605496094,
0.0089274487,
-0.0488928482,
0.0050302907,
-0.0215015877,
-0.0179277305,
0.0073721739,
0.0622190423,
-0.0021062805,
0.0397117212,
0.0064730495,
-0.0023140693,
0.0374509059,
-0.0530821383,
-0.0028527293,
-0.0333602838,
-0.0038410688,
0.0016554045,
0.0603451394,
-0.0155790076,
-0.0161909498,
-0.0077293948,
0.0831413493,
0.041235853,
-0.0805796087,
0.0118039027,
-0.04977284,
-0.026726108,
-0.0214382913,
0.0031367412,
-0.0206737965,
-0.0122870393,
-0.0020369431,
0.0569751784,
-0.0313122198,
-0.0222796369,
0.0411461107,
0.0177006554,
0.0274416115,
0.0077691502,
-0.0454696007,
-0.0609125048,
-0.064466469,
-0.021226706,
-0.0176155567,
-0.011999622,
-0.0447337627,
0.0260082297,
-0.0216877647,
-0.0108401449,
-0.0644276813,
-0.0773276612,
0.0224099737,
-0.0225906167,
0.0458388999,
0.0931136161,
0.0124484887,
-0.0321272388,
0.004584576,
-0.0182758179,
0.0114344582,
0.0272272602,
0.0008616003,
0.0536785275,
0.0651537925,
-0.0092923958,
-0.0240143854,
-0.0141280983,
-0.0381956957,
0.0302410405,
-0.0113930404,
0.0827763677,
-0.0636687428,
-0.0365789011,
-0.0552183464,
0.0090581886,
0.0527982116,
0.0387528501,
-0.0026352042,
-0.0050843172,
-0.0312567428,
-0.0028408975,
0.0789156109,
-0.0001267235,
0.0274617262,
0.0166270323,
-0.0265664291,
-0.0894261524,
-0.0608333945,
-0.0165797602,
-0.0259649996,
0.0002313049,
0.029183602,
-0.0015065434,
0.059425015,
-0.0014091742,
-0.0679853112,
0.0110342633,
0.0710993633,
0.0394858159,
-0.0509062186,
0.0132693704,
0.0469982661,
0.0369934291,
0.0023841076,
0.0351797603,
0.0144678839,
0.0168989785,
0.0081442604,
0.111437276,
0.027686825,
-0.0329871923,
-0.069524534,
-0.0208265334,
0.0199055802,
0.0366216972,
-0.0224304982,
-0.0382808112,
0.0040226025,
-0.0088982824,
-0.0136060584,
-0.001379717,
0.0119952653,
0.0433768369,
-0.0342661142,
0.0083383797,
-0.0563846119,
-0.0790581182,
0.0213812944,
0.0167008806,
0.0295728818,
-0.0320422053,
-0.0582271665,
0.0141354036,
0.0283753909,
0.0204437822,
0.0366021208,
0.0039356463,
-0.027105663,
0.0494461097,
-0.0018925096,
0.0113726854,
0.0165264774,
-0.0138114989,
-0.1090647057,
0.008193546,
0.008918412,
0.0140554551,
0.0624849275,
0.0388543792,
0.0168294907,
0.0266033728,
0.0231442116,
-0.0015822117,
0.0253213551,
0.0204022117,
0.0317041352,
-0.0043643443,
0.0430051163,
0.0063362331,
0.0553751774,
-0.0405132882,
-0.0863146856,
0.0203030594,
-0.0408900045,
0.0338237956,
0.0601961315,
-0.0080912076,
-0.0377562121,
0.0435095355,
-0.0366569236,
0.0176899768,
-0.0173522625,
0.070302397,
0.0223671738,
-0.0145761417,
0.0059379456,
0.0032029869,
0.0942015201,
-0.0517216213,
0.0159043819,
-0.0457974151,
-0.0482617654,
-0.0219820458,
-0.0110252555,
0.0019933055,
0.0183971394,
-0.0355678685,
0.0000508876,
-0.048376482,
-0.0263538845,
0.0148396324,
0.0086236307,
0.0015536937,
-0.0382449254,
0.0470840149,
0.0315755866,
-0.0164378341,
0.0190872848,
-0.0076301773,
0.0306623541,
-0.013619869,
-0.0000434483,
-0.0262853,
-5.390241101e-33,
0.0160271637,
-0.0272630323,
0.0122381747,
-0.0253307819,
0.0409183353,
0.0138649223,
-0.0544860624,
0.0056721759,
0.0235418137,
0.0231316052,
-0.018010661,
0.0087516885,
-0.0052085207,
0.0240098815,
0.0502201505,
-0.0494863838,
0.024598524,
0.0109244343,
-0.0026031418,
0.0121802054,
0.0198433008,
0.0258887876,
0.021044353,
-0.0789922923,
-0.0179356802,
0.0405295342,
0.0304262377,
0.0009618669,
-0.0085333493,
-0.0244650114,
0.0031553335,
0.0176641811,
0.0319875367,
-0.0300318431,
-0.0172450934,
-0.0327686816,
-0.0351053998,
-0.041218888,
-0.0080459742,
-0.00510721,
-0.000596875,
-0.036909882,
0.0800779611,
-0.0138344038,
-0.0237693023,
0.04218347,
0.0064411215,
-0.0340781249,
0.0111808591,
-0.0975266472,
0.0311625041,
0.0575167798,
-0.0379766002,
-0.0210295971,
-0.0185129885,
0.0311244484,
-0.0553799495,
-0.0108592901,
-0.0389525034,
-0.0019990492,
-0.0036444506,
0.0081322286,
-0.0020181146,
-0.070042327,
-0.0309568029,
0.0222227629,
0.0490626134,
-0.0253121164,
-0.059699893,
0.040407382,
-0.0479215272,
0.0204360243,
0.101614669,
0.0201840959,
0.0320649147,
-0.0381426625,
-0.0879978612,
0.0925743207,
-0.0484269671,
0.0538609549,
0.0365524516,
-0.021107683,
-0.063006483,
-0.0013870489,
0.0083509814,
-0.0369130969,
-0.0079382611,
-0.0276057348,
0.0328399166,
-0.0100989128,
0.0202055052,
0.0445908234,
0.033186987,
-0.0239090733,
0.0681738406,
-0.0120094661,
0.0819724426,
0.0335407518,
0.008317098,
-0.0039112889,
-0.0058358093,
-0.0137889571,
0.0248213336,
0.002620433,
0.045425538,
0.0209708884,
0.0167627092,
-0.0166940484,
0.020088207,
0.0011955338,
0.0412555262,
-0.0226050746,
-0.0078423684,
-0.0237580892,
0.0280252509,
0.015329876,
0.0057841749,
0.0052466099,
0.0021050412,
0.0323562324,
-0.0216028299,
0.0037362024,
0.0059689018,
0.0200193767,
-0.0192446057,
-0.0519156083,
-0.0666412413,
0.008275751,
0.0157234427,
-0.0330878459,
-0.0146115907,
0.0087695057,
2.903e-7,
0.0780186206,
0.0369249247,
-0.0092416247,
0.0032635476,
0.0565760396,
0.0270763375,
-0.0004900139,
-0.0331450477,
-0.0079258494,
-0.034638904,
0.058351133,
-0.0148261376,
0.0070357057,
0.0433709547,
0.0007768377,
-0.1069348007,
-0.0041046408,
0.0376852117,
0.018424863,
-0.0231782589,
0.0608162805,
0.0756257921,
-0.0125659844,
-0.0376274325,
0.0330324396,
0.0144117493,
0.0139931375,
-0.0597610809,
0.0477106236,
0.035817869,
0.0582148731,
0.0134266214,
0.0181124248,
0.0552621335,
-0.0021775325,
-0.0405818596,
-0.02327222,
0.0693290457,
-0.0388436429,
-0.0077796914,
0.0086058099,
-0.0168583374,
0.0697574317,
-0.0562334768,
0.0405122302,
-0.050257083,
-0.0462411232,
0.0084315008,
0.0080638109,
-0.0046084342,
0.103952527,
-0.0400751717,
-0.0216370393,
0.0245535504,
0.0100063905,
0.019444244,
-0.0081490064,
-0.0676112771,
-0.0298607964,
0.0793368742,
-0.0163865071,
-0.0082279155,
0.0306339096,
0.0108598713,
0.0373064578,
-0.0801962614,
0.0276474208,
2.374690525e-34,
0.0381333195,
0.0082964655,
-0.015499399,
0.0039014884,
0.0172918905,
-0.0131645743,
-0.0339499563,
-0.0076439269,
0.0356153548,
-0.0270222463,
-0.0136215519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05224v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05224v2 | VerAs: Verify then Assess STEM Lab Reports | 2024-02-07T20:02:09 | 2024-04-25T16:16:36 | Berk Atil, Mahsa Sheikhi Karizaki, Rebecca J. Passonneau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With an increasing focus in STEM education on critical thinking skills,
science writing plays an ever more important role in curricula that stress
inquiry skills. A recently published dataset of two sets of college level lab
reports from an inquiry-based physics curriculum relies on analytic assessment
rubrics that utilize multiple dimensions, specifying subject matter knowledge
and general components of good explanations. Each analytic dimension is
assessed on a 6-point scale, to provide detailed feedback to students that can
help them improve their science writing skills. Manual assessment can be slow,
and difficult to calibrate for consistency across all students in large
classes. While much work exists on automated assessment of open-ended questions
in STEM subjects, there has been far less work on long-form writing such as lab
reports. We present an end-to-end neural architecture that has separate
verifier and assessment modules, inspired by approaches to Open Domain Question
Answering (OpenQA). VerAs first verifies whether a report contains any content
relevant to a given rubric dimension, and if so, assesses the relevant
sentences. On the lab reports, VerAs outperforms multiple baselines based on
OpenQA systems or Automated Essay Scoring (AES). VerAs also performs well on an
analytic rubric for middle school physics essays. | [
-0.0148029272,
0.0040455312,
0.0119815646,
-0.0306967329,
-0.0083970185,
-0.0197183248,
0.0196432527,
-0.0106719555,
-0.0043136096,
-0.0114721851,
-0.0093616936,
-0.0156367421,
-0.014962743,
0.0706779659,
0.0118222153,
0.0135419611,
0.045063097,
0.0122224689,
0.0343942158,
0.0142965503,
-0.0051689688,
-0.0047613396,
-0.0401653945,
0.0003712996,
-0.0006503624,
-0.0640824437,
0.0216589924,
-0.0182086062,
0.0474892892,
-0.0279921591,
0.057676468,
0.078558594,
0.0023247383,
0.0316968299,
0.000001871,
-0.0605247766,
-0.0144039802,
0.0281980764,
-0.0399317257,
0.0356568992,
0.0149556994,
0.0239290707,
0.016735401,
0.0309237428,
-0.0108596412,
-0.0215915274,
0.0601900481,
-0.0091155907,
0.0503286719,
0.0157235395,
0.0147964926,
0.0216275342,
0.0447314233,
-0.0086142179,
0.0506366938,
0.0086877551,
0.0286813099,
0.0358913764,
0.0150904953,
0.0152352089,
-0.0258487444,
0.0529855378,
0.0716418251,
-0.0808621272,
0.0189799014,
0.0367031619,
-0.024478158,
0.0401162021,
0.014382829,
0.0699629858,
0.010337716,
-0.0426831469,
-0.0302154925,
-0.0097313775,
-0.0084616859,
0.0169717539,
-0.0740516037,
0.0307847988,
-0.0342900977,
-0.0611388199,
-0.0150215644,
0.0076230075,
-0.000219519,
0.0341514163,
0.0303806495,
0.0183922462,
0.0142663484,
-0.0560015664,
-0.0031021968,
0.0270178411,
0.0554622039,
-0.0424376577,
0.0493630059,
0.0300344527,
-0.0271203779,
0.0027380327,
-0.0116738817,
-0.0200103279,
0.037431024,
0.0031448707,
0.0453271754,
0.0282095987,
-0.0146660116,
-0.0000941798,
-0.0117874602,
0.0903246403,
0.0255337954,
0.0475146994,
-0.0270520542,
0.0034720884,
-0.0410563834,
-0.0486384034,
0.0112107666,
0.018240802,
0.0023790335,
0.0063869953,
-0.0325717479,
-0.0371795259,
-0.0263484214,
0.0089787971,
0.001235845,
0.0432037562,
-0.0097904867,
0.0454363078,
-0.0450622402,
0.0878031775,
-0.0276917387,
0.0025541852,
0.0339992903,
0.0047267545,
-0.0699203685,
0.0239030197,
-0.0168200154,
0.0230645612,
0.0053645382,
0.0146423485,
0.0177843999,
-0.0069124633,
0.0292979702,
-0.0554070733,
0.0074393344,
-0.0523221232,
0.0600268245,
-0.0352556258,
0.020627344,
0.0237231702,
-0.020582594,
-0.0338397324,
0.0131754288,
0.0367064551,
0.0381985456,
0.0165755749,
0.0092453705,
-0.0403549895,
0.0171039421,
0.0253731366,
0.0302303471,
-0.0146655273,
0.0323672779,
-0.0001840505,
0.0026868139,
-0.0124981795,
0.06144787,
-0.0305455271,
0.0193230473,
-0.0351013951,
0.0030730928,
0.0200024899,
0.0019214005,
0.0846037492,
-0.0160362255,
0.0101240231,
-0.0021882306,
0.0217729341,
0.0171549022,
0.0497622527,
0.0101302946,
0.033684805,
0.0343567617,
-0.0223310366,
0.0478944778,
0.0095845666,
-0.0470786616,
0.1045508534,
0.0018360019,
0.0007962617,
0.0133946789,
0.001398219,
-0.0279780403,
-0.0855622664,
-0.0436598547,
0.0508890972,
-0.031379167,
0.0219484977,
0.0229038205,
-0.0001061905,
-0.0152885942,
0.0204909965,
0.0035895649,
-0.0605209656,
0.0534909517,
-0.0179302339,
0.0931156576,
0.0419425629,
0.0598497465,
-0.0324317664,
-0.0526198931,
-0.0264179185,
0.0285429731,
0.047562059,
0.0692379698,
-0.0496477485,
0.0019778246,
-0.0319132879,
-0.0389623791,
-0.0599394999,
0.0039597345,
-0.0083278604,
0.0117610842,
0.0015872185,
-0.0094634937,
-0.0284334291,
-0.0813472718,
0.0337841548,
-0.0281527229,
-0.0552460849,
0.0007995064,
-0.0339956358,
-0.0161223337,
-0.0011931243,
-0.0216349419,
0.0511977226,
0.0127386916,
-0.0086802365,
-0.0276252273,
-0.049036935,
-0.0308444444,
-0.0077825137,
0.036424879,
-0.0672656223,
-0.0097949188,
0.0228267014,
-0.0117339874,
-0.0145892343,
0.0158668663,
-0.0199091043,
-0.0825485885,
-0.0220132861,
-0.0300187729,
-0.0255521443,
-0.0085989218,
-0.0301445145,
-0.0028972474,
0.0358789749,
0.0872569755,
-0.0230251625,
-0.0163115151,
0.02180936,
0.0161157586,
-0.0354478918,
-0.0436098129,
-0.0147558339,
0.0165775921,
0.0049604001,
-0.0173563305,
-0.0745971352,
0.0122825233,
0.0037797093,
0.0280082449,
0.020345008,
0.0214210879,
0.0357191972,
-0.0331527516,
0.0140616195,
0.0240081772,
-0.0269072223,
-0.0048933052,
0.0347214863,
-0.0354894288,
0.0454564877,
-0.0115790339,
0.0039617638,
-0.0328565165,
-0.0122487042,
-0.0862443224,
0.0551134869,
0.0592049211,
0.0514661558,
-0.0566207729,
0.0143683609,
-0.0274085235,
-0.0106109157,
0.0302523486,
-0.0629563183,
0.0490900278,
-0.0232671853,
0.0094405469,
0.0975856408,
-0.001505525,
-0.0137942089,
0.0474112555,
0.0031443427,
-0.0318442956,
0.0081638005,
-0.0314660855,
0.0403038561,
0.0406950898,
-0.0000304211,
0.0159294941,
0.0175448544,
-0.0065831235,
-0.0420696177,
-0.0031885887,
0.0498088896,
-0.0379258618,
0.0128385164,
0.0028493521,
0.0154960463,
-0.00674011,
0.0238994695,
-0.005853714,
-0.0096100094,
0.0773462281,
-0.0032577009,
-0.0180730131,
-0.0960657522,
0.0403703004,
-0.0188925229,
0.0344048142,
-0.0253296439,
-0.0161360297,
0.0246175155,
0.0362799838,
-0.0329929702,
-0.0121486476,
-0.0073775286,
-0.016060099,
-0.0025211263,
-0.065821059,
-0.0086772991,
0.0253495667,
0.0002066277,
-0.0322587416,
0.0191944987,
0.0356834605,
0.0551241189,
-0.0558547266,
-0.0604774989,
-0.049167335,
-0.0282006711,
0.0697147325,
0.0603320971,
-0.1056420878,
-0.0159961693,
-0.0255259387,
0.0292748623,
0.0121889114,
-0.0246465784,
0.0463909693,
-0.0542188585,
0.0152195189,
0.0585013032,
-0.0082183266,
0.0590627156,
-0.0074893264,
-0.0302562155,
-0.0094410516,
-0.0340516679,
0.0575389341,
0.0114134811,
0.0323356017,
-0.0512628704,
-0.054456342,
0.0599463768,
0.0049495217,
0.0076301876,
-0.0193539914,
-0.0265508704,
-0.0140973637,
0.038325455,
0.0710282102,
-0.0418763421,
0.0186703,
-0.0284728892,
0.0427609421,
-0.0015518127,
-0.0461112149,
-0.0306950156,
-0.079957895,
0.0274182502,
-0.0102419043,
-0.0328704007,
-0.0377906747,
-0.0383042581,
-0.0074489904,
-0.0014837122,
-0.0229648035,
-0.0069029219,
0.0192419849,
0.0117311291,
0.0440112539,
0.0108857155,
-0.0421587341,
0.032121215,
-0.0495538265,
0.0064536501,
0.0087245554,
0.0036502846,
-0.0284007434,
-0.0381973423,
0.0179366451,
-0.0107149538,
-0.0163921397,
0.0087001678,
0.0269846506,
0.0104084294,
0.0032185733,
-0.0465568863,
0.0376461558,
-0.0224954765,
-0.018477872,
0.0189295392,
0.1119420528,
-0.0120365024,
-0.012088012,
-0.0641858727,
0.0208174866,
-0.0097426428,
0.0749308318,
0.0637203231,
-0.0127202766,
-0.031402681,
-0.0549051985,
-0.0084047168,
-0.0685380623,
-0.0315045901,
0.0167782139,
-0.0177325904,
0.0292957202,
-0.0144304009,
-0.0290377885,
0.0755876079,
0.0021558015,
0.0011829794,
-0.0299976058,
-0.0110909641,
-0.0306688026,
-0.062025249,
0.0559237972,
-0.012421757,
0.0041917814,
-0.0267999955,
-0.0110995285,
0.0084989825,
-0.0184911527,
-0.0599118769,
0.0058390098,
-0.0022453377,
-0.0195236094,
-0.0070076161,
0.0428221263,
0.0124212196,
-0.0482067168,
-0.0175848901,
-0.0594517849,
0.0436254181,
0.0012855408,
-0.0487487279,
-0.0082346806,
-0.0087513654,
-0.0180725344,
0.003166808,
-0.0405984595,
0.0106103048,
0.0159084629,
0.0206604116,
0.0226576962,
0.0054048495,
-0.0445452593,
0.0237832237,
0.0457005277,
0.0374512151,
0.02313927,
-0.0087643797,
-0.0629304126,
0.0111781806,
0.0066762003,
-0.0209755562,
-0.004067312,
0.0150090214,
0.040551167,
-0.0244875699,
-0.0131966788,
0.0462094508,
-0.0403816439,
0.0741152391,
-0.0510579236,
0.0410415456,
0.0081694052,
0.0473991893,
0.0118226958,
-0.0129476236,
-0.0425418541,
-0.0322859697,
-0.0158571005,
0.06955681,
-0.0103182988,
0.0301928986,
0.0382921174,
0.036600098,
0.0041272612,
0.0114862546,
-0.0986148044,
-0.0211176127,
-0.0323978476,
0.0557707325,
-0.0450790189,
0.0635675043,
-0.0115594473,
-0.001837345,
-0.0281562209,
-0.0171101317,
0.0303473324,
-0.0048666,
0.0083903,
0.0781428218,
0.0306244474,
0.0382063352,
-0.0723035783,
0.0188655127,
-0.0105771171,
0.0485338792,
-0.0176542234,
-0.0163617991,
-0.0431752838,
-0.0159671251,
-0.0428441539,
-0.0165450163,
0.0294666234,
-0.0275454223,
-0.0612824969,
-0.0293405261,
0.0514621697,
0.068557784,
0.0082783028,
-0.0235438664,
0.0131687196,
0.0231531356,
-0.0410564318,
-0.0607148558,
0.0350539722,
0.0102562914,
-0.0442816205,
-0.0580120906,
-0.0006131402,
-5.414861095e-33,
-0.0048692212,
-0.0495868586,
0.0136591671,
-0.0135561079,
0.0019368032,
0.0653650239,
-0.0536929183,
-0.0406574123,
-0.0017707584,
0.0390306413,
0.0095735574,
0.0338829719,
-0.0037237017,
0.0050946679,
0.0285414699,
-0.0042967303,
0.050430201,
-0.0008258839,
-0.0491708703,
0.0215233564,
0.0058837109,
0.0029237326,
0.0719005316,
-0.035453815,
0.0430751108,
-0.0208710022,
0.0006422475,
0.0308639072,
-0.100915283,
0.0458712243,
-0.0259642694,
0.0246738046,
0.0122758579,
-0.0438978449,
0.0061543901,
0.0209184662,
-0.077364929,
-0.0707079694,
-0.0296103992,
-0.0446848758,
-0.0535707511,
-0.022757221,
0.0233713351,
0.020118149,
-0.0283188429,
-0.0543823093,
0.0536834113,
0.0080766035,
0.0287615024,
-0.0455037169,
-0.0271641333,
-0.0067980876,
-0.0231073387,
-0.0432308242,
-0.0359247997,
0.0609757528,
0.003577346,
-0.0093515357,
0.0053437296,
0.0334517099,
-0.029548334,
0.023485627,
0.0210942142,
-0.0130433971,
-0.0308792852,
0.0609897077,
0.0531692244,
-0.0366169214,
-0.0313254744,
-0.0258509219,
0.0067276442,
-0.0350395478,
0.1336406469,
0.0768811032,
0.017177185,
0.0198922288,
-0.0941380113,
0.0418447852,
0.0224959422,
0.0455563739,
0.0051109805,
-0.0601827465,
-0.0042357156,
-0.0386768244,
-0.0493806005,
-0.0157474522,
-0.050886862,
-0.0025396855,
0.0438378975,
-0.0585071519,
-0.0334594436,
-0.0011955543,
0.0166750122,
-0.0324500762,
0.0450357944,
0.0336444378,
0.0199658088,
0.044677943,
0.0211918335,
0.0034882438,
-0.0763778463,
0.0434063151,
0.0023722562,
0.017509209,
0.0240481924,
0.0126792882,
0.0161036998,
0.0337332375,
0.0139957741,
0.0044837636,
-0.0368593484,
-0.012712786,
0.0386291333,
0.0668112487,
0.000827703,
0.0478350148,
0.0043505062,
0.0462823585,
0.0014918006,
0.0261546485,
0.0245060418,
-0.0117611717,
0.0124552101,
0.0489617847,
-0.0233110227,
-0.0229314771,
-0.0224994272,
-0.020338431,
-0.034057416,
-0.0762619376,
0.0126514491,
0.0211542211,
2.512e-7,
0.0470924787,
0.0403785929,
0.0465580821,
0.0108490996,
-0.0195686892,
-0.0248405971,
-0.0160378665,
-0.0138128139,
0.0137051838,
0.020928001,
-0.0187511351,
0.0060941279,
0.0267121289,
0.0332375169,
-0.0672461987,
-0.0495412052,
-0.0338497385,
-0.0155578153,
-0.0486332104,
0.0159986895,
0.0735684559,
-0.0309642125,
0.0185242835,
-0.0295448434,
-0.0133749051,
-0.0286492445,
0.0198931228,
0.0372841917,
0.0418680608,
0.038592279,
-0.0196726527,
-0.012303059,
0.0300463438,
0.0533492863,
-0.0046034809,
-0.0033652808,
-0.0045591732,
0.0285141412,
0.0317868069,
-0.0567586534,
0.0344891921,
0.0107920906,
0.025300242,
-0.065274328,
0.0251790937,
-0.0330053233,
0.0059215645,
0.0103664985,
0.0171604473,
-0.0108249271,
0.0165375862,
-0.0243629757,
0.0332338884,
-0.0171818696,
-0.0245633051,
-0.0004632164,
0.0043856162,
-0.021550335,
-0.0272716731,
-0.0189656597,
-0.0036709909,
-0.0356250517,
-0.0376831964,
-0.0536061116,
0.032848198,
-0.0556719974,
-0.0366466567,
2.489429105e-34,
0.0244326591,
-0.0315508693,
0.0239697117,
-0.0264495052,
0.0131024737,
0.0132094724,
0.0510661453,
-0.0005557751,
0.0158461593,
-0.0529230982,
-0.045363389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05201v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05201v2 | The Effect of Sampling Temperature on Problem Solving in Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T19:11:23 | 2024-06-14T18:41:51 | Matthew Renze, Erhan Guven | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this research study, we empirically investigate the effect of sampling
temperature on the performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) on various
problem-solving tasks. We created a multiple-choice question-and-answer (MCQA)
exam by randomly sampling problems from standard LLM benchmarks. Then, we used
nine popular LLMs with five prompt-engineering techniques to solve the MCQA
problems while increasing the sampling temperature from 0.0 to 1.6. Despite
anecdotal reports to the contrary, our empirical results indicate that changes
in temperature from 0.0 to 1.0 do not have a statistically significant impact
on LLM performance for problem-solving tasks. In addition, these results appear
to generalize across LLMs, prompt-engineering techniques, and problem domains.
All code, data, and supplemental materials are available on GitHub at:
https://github.com/matthewrenze/jhu-llm-temperature | [
-0.0110315923,
-0.0282682329,
-0.034576457,
0.0283536855,
-0.0532552302,
0.0139809083,
0.0102530532,
0.0314926542,
0.017467143,
-0.0190817323,
-0.0197379347,
-0.0012452566,
-0.0085146762,
-0.022395974,
-0.0013979006,
-0.0518508516,
0.0210199989,
-0.0943607762,
0.0029183782,
-0.0136536267,
-0.019336449,
-0.0147836599,
-0.023333909,
0.0036509763,
0.012552022,
-0.0381884687,
-0.015379562,
-0.0176700465,
-0.0186978728,
-0.0416526534,
-0.0191745125,
0.0743706077,
0.0186185539,
-0.0207127128,
0.0000021353,
-0.0597315691,
0.0083928984,
-0.010518509,
-0.020422291,
0.0321874171,
0.0452161282,
0.0177526791,
0.0159764476,
0.0611736439,
-0.0422868878,
0.0078165028,
0.0368896462,
0.0274337549,
0.0231803935,
0.0018367325,
0.0163426045,
0.0165328514,
-0.0015376286,
0.0298999771,
0.0111421356,
-0.0353099629,
0.0029516679,
0.0432734564,
0.0973744541,
0.0079863332,
-0.0250706878,
0.0185191724,
0.043200478,
0.0204969514,
-0.0401149057,
0.0373146236,
-0.0091279158,
0.013807293,
-0.0005635143,
0.0531068891,
-0.0128749963,
0.0288442168,
-0.0204106811,
0.0062036975,
0.0082439659,
0.0171754993,
-0.082541354,
0.0337769203,
0.0007036508,
-0.0173833035,
-0.0082398467,
-0.0234433226,
0.0164161306,
-0.0106698126,
0.0151587836,
0.1483005583,
0.0013375903,
-0.0424319804,
0.0246147085,
-0.0015003899,
-0.021607656,
-0.0627031401,
0.0117832944,
0.0383652188,
-0.0665922314,
0.0189248174,
-0.027697714,
-0.0113942046,
0.0037226102,
0.0152214942,
0.0663609505,
0.0527428128,
0.0335285217,
0.0148927663,
-0.0099177351,
0.0448241793,
0.0065536392,
0.0129273646,
-0.0694540069,
-0.0048358734,
-0.0340337381,
-0.022882795,
-0.032125771,
0.0094027612,
-0.010433441,
0.0115588969,
-0.068296589,
0.0179437809,
0.0341219679,
-0.0080443854,
-0.026847519,
-0.0031147788,
0.0149932504,
0.0285694785,
-0.0286265556,
0.0099242004,
-0.0940528288,
0.0231231507,
0.0208500009,
-0.0484399125,
-0.0129489722,
-0.0117233768,
-0.0062391604,
-0.0420106091,
0.0200088657,
0.0748357922,
-0.0210590698,
0.0100305276,
-0.0493075848,
-0.0391493812,
0.0167904794,
-0.069368884,
0.0344007313,
-0.0718594566,
-0.002251667,
0.0331757702,
-0.0180725176,
0.0043037361,
0.0066924202,
0.0180982221,
-0.0026239485,
0.0351353288,
0.0151362121,
0.0165959932,
0.0470760912,
0.0349202752,
-0.0058747092,
0.0821156204,
0.0593909733,
0.0026535834,
0.0173421521,
-0.0653653294,
0.0347656459,
0.0630646423,
-0.0020280888,
0.0098337745,
-0.0033760765,
0.0103204604,
0.0364658833,
0.0413199738,
0.0016402222,
0.0677460954,
-0.0091398228,
0.0045811799,
0.0696984306,
0.0583287477,
-0.0191859938,
-0.013523424,
-0.0120625431,
-0.0042463532,
0.0306289177,
0.0126567623,
-0.056475766,
0.0526850596,
-0.0517711863,
0.0268735066,
-0.0114786718,
0.0144722881,
-0.0359678902,
-0.0540880002,
-0.0455803685,
0.0078471778,
-0.0280547831,
0.028930556,
0.0390602387,
-0.0431838147,
-0.0162043907,
0.0120182438,
-0.0038014669,
-0.0283368155,
-0.0064241104,
-0.0119423168,
0.0148348873,
0.0644885451,
-0.0006447331,
-0.0368766263,
-0.054865852,
-0.004753903,
0.0419209115,
-0.0298426598,
0.080591768,
0.0212857351,
-0.0007812127,
-0.0353176817,
-0.0171932839,
-0.0417624563,
-0.0189640708,
-0.0039920867,
0.0249390434,
0.02011686,
0.008783821,
-0.0068242201,
-0.006771591,
0.0092596551,
-0.0966729596,
-0.0650995895,
-0.0130669884,
-0.0150052011,
0.0110495454,
-0.0185087603,
-0.0233875327,
0.0146770431,
0.020534955,
-0.0523924045,
-0.0055175805,
0.0468089804,
-0.0591244996,
0.0004354519,
0.030758705,
-0.0143688945,
-0.0231189542,
0.0233643055,
-0.0218102969,
-0.0344258063,
0.0661491901,
-0.006498232,
0.0059006289,
0.0141007211,
0.0038432474,
-0.0412480831,
-0.0035032043,
-0.0379417278,
0.0434599034,
0.0023187604,
0.0385485068,
0.0321312472,
0.0258140527,
-0.0342371091,
-0.0428783931,
-0.0257138051,
-0.0058422312,
0.0206838716,
-0.0043129711,
-0.0132153863,
0.0068188957,
-0.0741749331,
-0.0305674225,
-0.0634927675,
0.0478204452,
0.0101008425,
0.0199861061,
0.0022743042,
-0.0040434524,
-0.0504997075,
0.0182022583,
-0.0453954972,
-0.0464016609,
0.0240746867,
0.0258375611,
0.0121325105,
0.0022193326,
-0.01962444,
-0.023510389,
-0.0387206562,
-0.0250483099,
0.0400861241,
0.0119481133,
0.0169413462,
-0.0152056348,
0.0935918614,
-0.0285300054,
0.0060996548,
-0.0080248965,
-0.0012642301,
0.0168252271,
-0.0035341885,
0.0752939433,
0.065578647,
-0.0187224485,
0.0065126596,
0.0536164641,
-0.0559265167,
-0.0405605137,
0.0124738477,
0.0120501369,
-0.0034756679,
0.0011688084,
-0.0875861123,
-0.0296863001,
0.0636871606,
-0.0060323658,
0.0175549425,
0.0351380073,
0.0866388679,
-0.0518534742,
-0.0427662432,
-0.0502111018,
0.0112727378,
-0.0256515779,
0.0610795543,
-0.01699619,
-0.064651221,
0.0726193041,
-0.0214381684,
0.0037582407,
-0.0478118882,
-0.0056764097,
-0.0173686799,
0.0491286628,
-0.0391102396,
-0.0053951368,
-0.0154435178,
-0.028548887,
-0.0482142717,
-0.0473335199,
0.0253036749,
-0.0360193849,
0.0141284214,
-0.0433656722,
-0.030713357,
-0.0104495091,
-0.0406705178,
-0.0232266262,
0.0079955626,
-0.0286176931,
0.0343312845,
0.0292378031,
-0.0121594295,
-0.024847066,
-0.0052348324,
0.0543392599,
-0.0126902908,
-0.0250299573,
0.004023436,
-0.0139512261,
0.0089918738,
0.0353639051,
0.0533448644,
0.0401995592,
-0.0627607554,
0.0289445892,
0.0190217141,
0.1021943763,
0.0024745485,
-0.0245859735,
0.0335089974,
0.0274424646,
-0.0328697003,
-0.0385513902,
0.0451252535,
0.044248715,
-0.0611314811,
0.008190685,
0.1090127751,
0.0443902984,
0.0003109798,
0.0040107514,
-0.0540378727,
0.062500149,
0.0225319006,
0.0247802995,
-0.080586493,
-0.0198092014,
0.0541822128,
0.0553922951,
-0.0362509228,
-0.051813215,
0.0246745478,
-0.1009254307,
0.0152949682,
0.0018021358,
-0.0599341244,
0.0216070078,
-0.0704700798,
0.0059377393,
0.0335165597,
0.0445839614,
-0.0028196054,
-0.0167365596,
0.0122073712,
0.049964305,
-0.0449345261,
-0.0296052974,
0.0549083166,
-0.0310457703,
0.038835004,
0.0535254888,
-0.0170314293,
-0.0666422322,
-0.0084058801,
0.0645466,
0.0215309784,
0.0159625262,
-0.0362694338,
-0.0249329694,
0.0320311338,
0.0019012388,
-0.0374715663,
0.0256682262,
-0.0450436249,
-0.0026679435,
0.0459604487,
0.1058360711,
0.0060900552,
-0.0220338609,
-0.0150682619,
-0.0118378708,
-0.0038624541,
0.0545752048,
0.0308356993,
-0.0367919616,
-0.0534180216,
-0.0383136906,
-0.021260282,
-0.0324710943,
-0.0231165718,
0.0018539552,
-0.0096413605,
0.022523826,
0.0000200331,
-0.0185952317,
0.0797970667,
0.0479264073,
0.0110921059,
0.0051065902,
0.0169076174,
0.0233260076,
-0.0150343226,
0.0257961322,
-0.0239265095,
0.0586175285,
-0.0589764789,
0.0158020556,
0.0111478111,
-0.0099599883,
-0.0113207521,
0.0164622553,
-0.0426902585,
-0.0525900088,
0.0253550317,
0.0553674661,
0.0298715215,
0.0132003967,
0.020721579,
-0.0586212315,
-0.0384760462,
0.0175799988,
-0.0094990591,
0.0671698675,
-0.0267170593,
0.0194214843,
0.0391774289,
-0.0214621667,
-0.0190078299,
0.0142082945,
0.0318237133,
0.0469280556,
0.0065345224,
-0.060429845,
-0.0022095831,
0.0570972674,
-0.0223125294,
0.0488303602,
-0.0013167788,
-0.0151739344,
0.0103710284,
-0.0039969031,
-0.0232539531,
-0.0361281671,
-0.0260624904,
0.0081007183,
0.0049814242,
0.036909949,
0.0030024988,
-0.0023303132,
0.0437175743,
-0.0294707213,
0.0658780783,
0.0047752801,
0.0476886407,
0.040860083,
0.0073355967,
-0.0198367126,
0.046164453,
0.0002807094,
0.0455008186,
0.0238550603,
0.0582030788,
-0.0058490303,
0.0086902985,
-0.0577832349,
-0.0235383455,
-0.0766287744,
-0.0702823177,
0.006434463,
0.0252309535,
0.0195145551,
-0.0066685448,
-0.0309701432,
-0.0256429836,
0.033250235,
-0.020289721,
0.0027351973,
0.010099926,
-0.0129775601,
0.071767047,
0.0334528685,
0.007447321,
-0.0165215209,
0.0388127156,
0.0074081984,
0.0465115793,
0.0452709086,
-0.0225543808,
-0.0043178699,
-0.0012328038,
0.0024704135,
-0.0144787012,
-0.0171063561,
-0.0155031169,
-0.0659121126,
-0.0475177765,
-0.0038774291,
0.0047382433,
0.0031476873,
-0.0319642909,
0.0384298265,
0.0507715419,
-0.009954839,
-0.0550413691,
0.0191800557,
0.0519765653,
-0.0171295758,
-0.0551050641,
0.0079653831,
-5.852182095e-33,
-0.0311370231,
-0.0275350939,
0.054075323,
-0.0084089814,
-0.0273072161,
-0.0279449541,
-0.0255371947,
0.0624679737,
-0.0346357487,
-0.0302288365,
-0.0442782342,
-0.0184075292,
0.0254127327,
-0.0232220609,
0.0204523597,
-0.0431900769,
0.0180043578,
-0.0094302967,
-0.0239628814,
-0.0062450459,
0.0126309423,
-0.0044793235,
0.0311721917,
-0.0360920019,
0.0041250442,
-0.0461399108,
0.0483782925,
0.0065823654,
0.0014307818,
0.0431964323,
0.0079401052,
0.0335801989,
0.0178117696,
-0.0394862592,
-0.0202454217,
0.0193037596,
-0.030956367,
-0.0424318835,
0.0280506182,
0.0132624274,
-0.0075483397,
-0.0566243604,
0.0257809609,
0.0361711308,
-0.0260363128,
0.005311355,
0.0034040727,
-0.0279361699,
-0.0488783196,
-0.0137032373,
-0.0213147551,
0.016807355,
-0.0368654989,
-0.0093563106,
-0.0013059985,
0.0223487634,
-0.0196031854,
0.0122071989,
-0.0063365353,
0.0051266965,
0.0908200964,
0.0364533998,
0.0647873878,
0.0114688147,
0.0187991727,
0.0218112841,
0.0337378792,
0.0211435854,
-0.0207702592,
-0.06351275,
0.0575659461,
0.0546305552,
0.0483330004,
0.0336806327,
0.0352014825,
-0.0295446608,
-0.0582045056,
0.008423999,
0.0565503612,
-0.0006561817,
0.0165512767,
-0.0198988561,
-0.0032720258,
-0.057129465,
-0.0760164931,
0.0584240966,
-0.0540584885,
-0.0216704533,
0.0558080189,
-0.0521887913,
0.0133070238,
-0.0549189709,
0.0400381424,
-0.005722818,
0.0026444711,
-0.0209169928,
-0.007499272,
0.0815082863,
-0.0164664909,
0.0361300483,
-0.0915694386,
-0.0355496332,
-0.0457129218,
0.0021122517,
0.0254189614,
0.0069727139,
-0.0145546217,
0.0025508993,
-0.0371096879,
-0.0110197235,
-0.0185974352,
0.0191175453,
0.0652946904,
-0.0188593026,
0.0170068964,
-0.0379028246,
0.0125829559,
-0.0069284714,
-0.0027478475,
-0.0350610651,
-0.0409755744,
0.011655855,
-0.0233135279,
-0.020888729,
0.0056183455,
-0.0152906291,
-0.0401995517,
0.0252707358,
0.0191667639,
-0.0366529338,
-0.0194007177,
-0.0046586264,
2.724e-7,
0.0365561619,
0.0812565237,
-0.0251673143,
0.0217980277,
-0.0156056881,
0.0145876417,
-0.039086692,
-0.0289004818,
0.0438929647,
0.0095176846,
-0.032787066,
0.0329372436,
0.0163054559,
0.0895298868,
-0.060601484,
-0.0459240861,
-0.02225996,
0.0361519195,
-0.0493213311,
0.0271049533,
0.0227364283,
0.0293754265,
0.0193031486,
0.0157943461,
-0.0273522176,
-0.0404558294,
0.0252728108,
-0.0769740567,
0.0023031808,
0.0218643844,
0.0228705723,
-0.0239374768,
0.0352805927,
0.0398530699,
0.0291535929,
-0.0256027617,
0.0109596634,
0.0286119413,
0.0509993285,
-0.016358586,
0.0314042196,
-0.0148401568,
-0.0223957542,
-0.0761127621,
0.0729120299,
-0.0597411469,
-0.0378353335,
-0.0124510014,
-0.0199834891,
-0.0754523352,
0.0194380525,
-0.0313668028,
0.0483672842,
0.0128173241,
0.006120692,
-0.0261624325,
-0.0223503616,
-0.0252691414,
-0.0112907197,
0.0051616305,
-0.0083061736,
-0.0791067779,
-0.0596447214,
-0.0139272483,
0.0137223462,
-0.0379743464,
-0.0151387444,
2.615352101e-34,
0.0470496826,
-0.0094076302,
0.0306376871,
0.0624519549,
-0.0031899128,
0.0034599928,
0.0064521106,
0.0025608998,
0.0162168071,
-0.0809103847,
-0.0231423806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05200v1 | Are LLMs Ready for Real-World Materials Discovery? | 2024-02-07T19:10:36 | 2024-02-07T19:10:36 | Santiago Miret, N M Anoop Krishnan | cond-mat.mtrl-sci | cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) create exciting possibilities for powerful
language processing tools to accelerate research in materials science. While
LLMs have great potential to accelerate materials understanding and discovery,
they currently fall short in being practical materials science tools. In this
position paper, we show relevant failure cases of LLMs in materials science
that reveal current limitations of LLMs related to comprehending and reasoning
over complex, interconnected materials science knowledge. Given those
shortcomings, we outline a framework for developing Materials Science LLMs
(MatSci-LLMs) that are grounded in materials science knowledge and hypothesis
generation followed by hypothesis testing. The path to attaining performant
MatSci-LLMs rests in large part on building high-quality, multi-modal datasets
sourced from scientific literature where various information extraction
challenges persist. As such, we describe key materials science information
extraction challenges which need to be overcome in order to build large-scale,
multi-modal datasets that capture valuable materials science knowledge.
Finally, we outline a roadmap for applying future MatSci-LLMs for real-world
materials discovery via: 1. Automated Knowledge Base Generation; 2. Automated
In-Silico Material Design; and 3. MatSci-LLM Integrated Self-Driving Materials
Laboratories. | [
-0.0039237533,
0.0634207949,
-0.0362759046,
0.0779650211,
-0.0246038716,
-0.008612684,
0.0064051603,
0.0252436921,
0.0201908369,
0.0067178537,
-0.0362441018,
0.0317549892,
-0.0417112596,
0.0387461707,
-0.008888822,
0.037976101,
0.0479054898,
-0.0479944684,
0.0435260721,
-0.0057043373,
0.0059836297,
-0.0162897743,
-0.0203709509,
-0.011198164,
0.0018474495,
0.001704274,
-0.0109106647,
-0.0258422233,
0.0119698532,
-0.0374588408,
-0.0002104171,
0.0332100578,
0.0061422931,
0.0273298267,
0.0000022114,
-0.0631354675,
-0.0034673405,
0.0341108069,
0.0058177221,
0.0118411053,
0.0292584524,
-0.0655468926,
-0.0193267595,
-0.0322886966,
-0.0191150848,
0.0280014016,
0.0067741927,
-0.0047791325,
-0.0049260496,
-0.0149785746,
-0.0078317178,
-0.0012867413,
0.0430236459,
-0.0055707428,
0.0476263948,
-0.0149408635,
0.0365236327,
0.0557665452,
0.0869376883,
0.0277418885,
0.0421995893,
0.0759009719,
-0.0243022088,
-0.0268019307,
0.0373658054,
0.0240593888,
-0.0212087594,
-0.0014854852,
-0.0118053118,
0.0878380239,
0.0479994901,
-0.015104848,
-0.0025819938,
-0.0314298421,
-0.0610522144,
0.0490164943,
-0.0184983667,
0.0249763969,
-0.0247555617,
0.0105735939,
0.0290714465,
-0.0103691053,
0.0290141981,
0.0236608088,
-0.0385665037,
0.0759257078,
-0.0120191425,
-0.0270431582,
-0.0106774187,
0.0089986837,
-0.0019560475,
-0.0054960446,
0.003425756,
0.0018132292,
0.0390255861,
0.0302901957,
0.0321251936,
0.0069417916,
0.0562923923,
-0.0505000055,
0.0083297146,
0.0251639057,
-0.0157478563,
0.0464553088,
-0.0436488427,
-0.0085986136,
0.0108954338,
-0.0002307531,
-0.0498688705,
-0.0391758457,
-0.0377675295,
-0.0574469678,
-0.0216305666,
-0.0052824519,
-0.0355984271,
-0.0421025977,
0.0383205526,
0.0422694497,
-0.000483536,
0.0293548759,
-0.0337683894,
-0.0440391004,
-0.0254967641,
-0.0336629599,
-0.037677452,
0.0145995244,
0.0105965016,
0.0160911232,
-0.0066083763,
-0.0292144828,
-0.0283857286,
0.0007346615,
0.0022227243,
0.0139753213,
-0.0031417876,
0.0907161981,
-0.0215337873,
-0.0281188302,
-0.022371253,
-0.0504834689,
0.0142598581,
-0.0315404013,
0.0183338653,
-0.0073683714,
0.0837923437,
0.058457952,
-0.0132736014,
-0.0682648495,
0.010075694,
-0.0466593392,
0.000589182,
0.0774592534,
-0.0177435577,
-0.0425675474,
0.0224807933,
0.0159911755,
0.0519816726,
0.0398640856,
0.0034785226,
0.0440458208,
-0.0068036551,
0.0093535725,
-0.0149687892,
0.0326925404,
0.0130938897,
-0.026941305,
-0.0492813699,
-0.0142576918,
0.0087779723,
0.0187871866,
0.0047457856,
-0.0138320792,
0.0149674295,
0.023487322,
0.0506402031,
0.0265317466,
0.0144558279,
0.0367949158,
-0.0047813733,
0.0399978645,
0.0560986884,
-0.0615381002,
0.0273657795,
0.0207290016,
-0.0223326702,
-0.0208124164,
0.0385169946,
0.0199865513,
0.0243506078,
-0.0525673442,
-0.0698829815,
-0.0074617639,
-0.0046573714,
-0.028845923,
0.0762583837,
-0.028568197,
-0.0241993554,
0.0550680347,
0.0359758958,
-0.043255467,
-0.039644286,
-0.0078719901,
0.0662189201,
0.0554304272,
0.0329827927,
-0.0909333229,
-0.0536387861,
0.0583430342,
-0.0177489761,
0.035737142,
-0.0148485228,
-0.037419688,
0.0101170484,
-0.0108521227,
-0.0374649577,
-0.0282830559,
0.0196519066,
-0.0130022923,
-0.0230419151,
-0.0490166359,
-0.0179677941,
-0.0382917598,
-0.0337131582,
0.030507315,
-0.0429063141,
-0.0035124824,
0.0165745188,
-0.0031401161,
0.0281403717,
0.0231085476,
0.0361718349,
0.0122643346,
0.090980798,
-0.0469282083,
-0.0044038477,
-0.0183959771,
0.0003443614,
-0.0199592076,
0.028219685,
-0.0302822217,
0.0502566583,
-0.0496661998,
-0.0130567849,
-0.0145229474,
0.0280858614,
0.020196693,
0.005520165,
-0.0002597174,
-0.0066794036,
0.0060403058,
0.0474508591,
-0.0533421375,
0.0459944978,
-0.0010096007,
-0.0011032009,
0.0107273171,
0.0140911387,
0.0275832955,
-0.0148729058,
0.0138727417,
0.0343893804,
0.0235747434,
0.0022625485,
0.0260885879,
-0.0305322893,
0.0008138375,
-0.0251212493,
0.0048972145,
0.0030397768,
0.0246341079,
0.0096367905,
0.0364066958,
-0.0177017655,
-0.0304400604,
-0.0057112938,
0.0723081976,
0.0228334181,
-0.0275653526,
-0.0767654926,
0.0668974221,
0.0306621008,
-0.0287971217,
-0.0099028628,
-0.0338811912,
-0.0452732258,
0.0485034324,
0.0033783449,
0.0170449764,
-0.0590419024,
0.0197764914,
0.009688559,
0.0220695883,
-0.0457977317,
-0.0227042064,
0.0151543152,
-0.0409375317,
0.0129096741,
0.0139964623,
-0.0127118519,
0.0509326793,
0.0484157987,
-0.0500049926,
-0.0097362995,
-0.0166990999,
-0.0048145042,
0.0750379041,
0.0310518425,
0.0014982679,
0.0313116163,
0.050296247,
-0.0305049699,
0.0318795443,
0.0083009731,
0.044634793,
0.0049030469,
-0.0346858948,
0.017162649,
0.0232325643,
0.0395703949,
0.014324408,
0.0280632582,
-0.0037728767,
0.0689152852,
-0.061864946,
0.0014356155,
-0.0705311373,
-0.0263511483,
-0.0148599064,
0.0294000134,
-0.0100785801,
0.0153016401,
0.0319617689,
0.0253198817,
0.0151517754,
-0.0150361955,
0.0137193557,
-0.006965213,
-0.0076428805,
-0.0711951032,
0.0682941228,
0.0239564795,
-0.0286933072,
-0.0278423149,
0.0401111878,
-0.0102896476,
0.0313187689,
0.0121400254,
-0.0321710482,
-0.0034359277,
0.0479550399,
0.0757607073,
-0.0131819788,
0.0103242239,
0.0054698978,
-0.0733203441,
0.0565763377,
0.016365489,
-0.0393515378,
0.0474809594,
0.0178239755,
0.0355850123,
0.0584897362,
-0.0005334686,
-0.0030308999,
-0.0705391616,
-0.0069293408,
0.0313195325,
0.0196674746,
0.0198548976,
-0.0125256116,
-0.0186587088,
-0.053410463,
-0.0137322154,
0.0355283134,
0.0254578888,
-0.0277833026,
0.0191139393,
0.0394989401,
-0.0031725944,
-0.0188454986,
-0.0026394103,
-0.1069693267,
-0.0144580305,
-0.001389376,
0.0094581544,
0.004040943,
-0.0101199895,
-0.0259263627,
-0.0752471536,
0.0651744902,
-0.0117568746,
-0.0609394237,
-0.0633865893,
-0.067287758,
-0.0111455806,
0.0110598654,
-0.0062278286,
0.0662447587,
-0.0489085428,
-0.0310917851,
0.0112907067,
-0.0327510089,
-0.1076891273,
0.0335345268,
0.0135000069,
-0.0037148714,
0.0008871421,
0.0233249012,
-0.0422122553,
-0.0037300757,
0.0352870263,
-0.0250935983,
0.0033226339,
-0.0974888876,
-0.0327169299,
0.0307697877,
-0.0143276248,
-0.0073810248,
0.0472987778,
-0.0200381987,
-0.062804006,
-0.0079367235,
0.107312426,
-0.0388152227,
0.0259122457,
-0.0414029881,
-0.0301915538,
0.0368560106,
0.0640743896,
-0.0377373658,
-0.0151676275,
-0.0777852237,
-0.0007894278,
-0.0215229671,
0.0081358878,
-0.0117421076,
0.0057471697,
-0.0278430823,
0.0194863752,
0.0017463858,
-0.0047539496,
0.0073077986,
-0.0130835818,
-0.0242566839,
-0.0075832475,
-0.0098872054,
0.0082469899,
-0.0812113285,
0.0386276096,
-0.0339016207,
-0.0019368537,
-0.0165139474,
-0.0181303453,
0.0349657536,
-0.0605409965,
-0.0238641668,
0.0422892831,
-0.0288301166,
-0.0573399551,
0.0149368271,
0.0136596635,
0.0179451257,
0.0270551126,
-0.0227581039,
-0.0652275458,
0.086315915,
0.0054018516,
-0.0794940591,
-0.0206635706,
-0.0168950986,
-0.0045203925,
-0.0175586268,
-0.019007979,
0.0080829114,
0.043810606,
-0.0115127396,
0.0101039233,
-0.0149917128,
-0.0938209519,
0.010814853,
0.0379157998,
0.0153719895,
0.029656034,
0.0066948705,
-0.0452454723,
-0.0015672725,
0.0275391061,
0.0039830031,
-0.0332828835,
0.0248186868,
0.0212688353,
-0.0678010732,
-0.0143067958,
-0.0215430111,
-0.0025392252,
0.0538632572,
-0.0142162265,
0.0527640171,
-0.0006062128,
0.0215090383,
0.0852530003,
-0.0181192551,
0.0095321266,
0.0169178285,
-0.0575915277,
0.0655196756,
-0.0491297133,
0.0504433811,
0.0187713765,
0.0235743616,
-0.048409529,
0.0464976057,
-0.0341766663,
-0.06385234,
-0.0513082854,
-0.0009709427,
0.0297866538,
0.0355902724,
0.0710889176,
-0.0474664867,
-0.0209640209,
0.003874206,
0.0431272686,
-0.0092734797,
0.0144453254,
0.0380359814,
0.0169828646,
-0.0074097975,
-0.0345546752,
0.026730448,
0.0323852263,
-0.0300875828,
-0.0270822961,
-0.022311734,
-0.0355694219,
-0.0101102814,
-0.0033718424,
-0.0032460114,
-0.0418495312,
-0.0318194591,
-0.0515927933,
-0.0016944761,
0.0113759106,
0.0820917487,
-0.0426432267,
-0.0223706737,
0.0007070649,
0.1247685105,
0.0162242353,
-0.0409210995,
-0.022582287,
-0.0134743955,
-0.0105186114,
-0.0166156385,
0.0253048241,
-6.223560801e-33,
-0.0187387746,
0.0324299484,
0.0187020004,
0.0284470804,
0.0122459484,
-0.0392942578,
-0.0620162413,
-0.0379809551,
0.0177432392,
0.0386957861,
0.0002695319,
-0.0091833184,
0.009543485,
-0.0211024024,
0.0623849444,
0.0409748033,
0.0068076393,
0.0449219346,
-0.022960471,
0.0009865428,
0.0475759134,
0.0315872915,
0.05670904,
-0.068800509,
0.0245209895,
0.0141041419,
0.0375451632,
-0.0350853465,
-0.0396855734,
0.0542304441,
-0.0786873624,
0.0371403582,
0.0005507326,
-0.0159510039,
-0.0194513183,
-0.0146676227,
-0.090191856,
-0.0105034867,
-0.0173782911,
0.0030590016,
0.0182270966,
-0.0006550836,
0.0071482626,
-0.008238296,
-0.0477639623,
0.0064202445,
0.0333028659,
-0.040892031,
0.0238030218,
-0.0232803971,
-0.090729408,
0.0107899988,
0.0288559757,
0.0349636599,
0.0449858606,
-0.0193044133,
-0.0063999244,
0.021118924,
-0.038130831,
0.0543916859,
0.0193633083,
0.0212554019,
0.0609630831,
0.0274058357,
0.0107304389,
-0.0089205131,
0.0133502856,
0.0156623125,
0.0504853055,
0.0058236877,
0.0093009342,
0.0994714946,
0.0400911085,
0.0259661656,
0.0117403409,
0.0020183434,
-0.1183797643,
-0.0276736878,
0.0071991319,
0.0221255887,
0.0398452096,
0.0430892855,
0.0127608953,
-0.0135487197,
-0.013024332,
0.0246077925,
0.0255725496,
-0.0173489656,
-0.0273580384,
0.0049374141,
-0.1034960076,
0.003481915,
0.0250021257,
-0.0469709821,
-0.0425246656,
0.0417420566,
-0.0204775482,
-0.009905112,
-0.0254658815,
0.0056064022,
-0.1032453775,
-0.0560032837,
-0.0454327352,
-0.0126322862,
0.0317699201,
0.004665792,
-0.0524152778,
0.0195747763,
0.0143900104,
0.0033948421,
-0.0564057268,
-0.039736852,
0.0118232081,
0.0022808625,
0.0080401273,
0.013154624,
0.0017721353,
-0.0093944585,
0.006502484,
0.0057319989,
0.0184047185,
0.0290780477,
-0.0131902853,
-0.0052823108,
-0.0041596307,
-0.0234319102,
-0.0832528695,
-0.0118395835,
0.0538717099,
-0.0275326557,
0.0333267823,
0.0361866355,
2.967e-7,
0.0550018437,
0.0504776835,
0.0366414338,
0.0363125615,
-0.0246245284,
0.0061090891,
-0.0355092548,
-0.0261560287,
-0.0006098652,
-0.0181703083,
0.0222436972,
0.0327560715,
0.0261592325,
0.0325634666,
-0.0536048971,
-0.0090160286,
0.015928017,
-0.0434610657,
-0.0842054263,
-0.0011314554,
0.0029044326,
0.0334694386,
-0.0170099027,
-0.0421165116,
0.0023967738,
-0.0526333377,
0.0389276557,
-0.0312017705,
0.0168914013,
0.0954304785,
0.0237632021,
-0.0555186048,
-0.0352316983,
0.0607334934,
-0.0062050349,
0.0128401257,
-0.0290720351,
0.0290091485,
0.0239957273,
0.0097812349,
0.006722352,
-0.0549492687,
0.030216692,
-0.0143217761,
0.0335099585,
-0.0117669962,
0.0010326249,
-0.0088029187,
0.0210990366,
-0.0318094827,
-0.0404897518,
-0.0118814735,
0.0078918971,
-0.0143487919,
-0.0283292476,
0.0198503807,
-0.0117997797,
-0.0629989132,
-0.0081948759,
0.0409431197,
-0.0477081761,
-0.0256290454,
-0.002934708,
-0.0405928269,
0.0204054136,
-0.0358696803,
0.0114318021,
2.842584572e-34,
0.0288846325,
0.0029864109,
-0.0138729177,
0.0396386236,
0.0268626697,
-0.0082470533,
-0.0397806428,
0.0363106728,
-0.0251486506,
-0.0903539732,
0.0236058142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05195v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05195v2 | $λ$-ECLIPSE: Multi-Concept Personalized Text-to-Image Diffusion Models by Leveraging CLIP Latent Space | 2024-02-07T19:07:10 | 2024-04-09T22:14:37 | Maitreya Patel, Sangmin Jung, Chitta Baral, Yezhou Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Despite the recent advances in personalized text-to-image (P-T2I) generative
models, it remains challenging to perform finetuning-free multi-subject-driven
T2I in a resource-efficient manner. Predominantly, contemporary approaches,
involving the training of Hypernetworks and Multimodal Large Language Models
(MLLMs), require heavy computing resources that range from 600 to 12300 GPU
hours of training. These subject-driven T2I methods hinge on Latent Diffusion
Models (LDMs), which facilitate T2I mapping through cross-attention layers.
While LDMs offer distinct advantages, P-T2I methods' reliance on the latent
space of these diffusion models significantly escalates resource demands,
leading to inconsistent results and necessitating numerous iterations for a
single desired image. In this paper, we present $\lambda$-ECLIPSE, an
alternative prior-training strategy that works in the latent space of a
pre-trained CLIP model without relying on the diffusion UNet models.
$\lambda$-ECLIPSE leverages the image-text interleaved pre-training for fast
and effective multi-subject-driven P-T2I. Through extensive experiments, we
establish that $\lambda$-ECLIPSE surpasses existing baselines in composition
alignment while preserving concept alignment performance, even with
significantly lower resource utilization. $\lambda$-ECLIPSE performs
multi-subject driven P-T2I with just 34M parameters and is trained on a mere 74
GPU hours. Additionally, $\lambda$-ECLIPSE demonstrates the unique ability to
perform multi-concept interpolations. | [
0.0227159914,
0.0730316639,
0.0085736318,
0.0264173429,
-0.0071846223,
-0.0211135335,
0.0300957467,
-0.0215989146,
-0.0718294978,
0.0119009428,
-0.0610350296,
-0.0466506779,
0.0211784728,
0.0176060237,
0.0498308241,
-0.0649297014,
0.0136209177,
-0.0035506138,
-0.0464551412,
0.0001743683,
0.0288272463,
0.0192249808,
0.017469706,
0.018191658,
-0.0164455399,
-0.0361158587,
-0.0117276469,
0.0032375914,
0.0658501312,
-0.0072607077,
-0.0184793882,
0.0626418591,
0.0614097528,
0.0033527969,
0.0000020924,
0.0179366693,
-0.0083895102,
0.0254709981,
0.0284647159,
0.0303238872,
0.0868497714,
-0.0200412981,
0.0205449685,
-0.0398544818,
-0.0246110894,
-0.0204589404,
0.0891426876,
0.0586207174,
0.0798025057,
0.0670206919,
-0.0383415483,
-0.0344246104,
0.0254966654,
-0.0622431599,
0.0424331985,
-0.0367441922,
0.0275595021,
-0.0073464746,
-0.0426661037,
-0.0068036802,
-0.0389868915,
0.0357577577,
0.0162900481,
0.0119662303,
0.0398146994,
0.0546675511,
-0.0185487643,
-0.0439521149,
0.0081505086,
0.092307277,
-0.0256531984,
-0.0108557511,
-0.0159088075,
0.0014523058,
-0.0475776047,
0.0121296132,
-0.0182441473,
-0.0228438638,
0.0183651894,
0.027360227,
-0.0397285931,
-0.0012139051,
0.0179138053,
-0.0089273341,
-0.0307016652,
-0.0064402465,
0.0378927588,
0.0111898342,
-0.0088859797,
0.0305522643,
-0.0545983873,
-0.0366804861,
0.0353796259,
0.0062091858,
0.0152700637,
0.0112009179,
-0.0836009085,
-0.0811631233,
-0.0141589837,
-0.0179247577,
0.0617140159,
0.0242887698,
0.010577172,
0.0348699316,
-0.0162666813,
0.000674293,
-0.0491628498,
0.0060945502,
-0.0682777166,
-0.0301073622,
0.0077413176,
0.0052521336,
-0.0464856401,
-0.0092789857,
-0.0162394512,
-0.0600040182,
-0.0302700382,
0.0108421687,
-0.015483385,
-0.0218985379,
0.0129489284,
0.0320790038,
-0.0935060307,
-0.0223680418,
0.0255909991,
0.0300533418,
-0.0225946121,
0.0269699022,
0.0122746136,
-0.0087170852,
-0.0277239699,
0.0364381336,
0.0346561819,
-0.0277961846,
-0.0143033266,
0.0253384449,
-0.070343785,
-0.0434644297,
-0.0330838785,
0.0002364135,
-0.0326691084,
-0.0599170588,
0.0344632939,
-0.085732162,
0.050365217,
-0.0191239826,
-0.0147782313,
-0.0481701866,
0.0064708884,
0.0156051824,
-0.0285553392,
0.0865021273,
0.0079218596,
0.0091020875,
0.0203307029,
0.0125815626,
0.008654112,
0.0541442558,
0.0477996282,
0.0507341065,
-0.017639745,
0.0197344907,
-0.0261356644,
0.0513334721,
0.0489759892,
0.034686435,
-0.0320167467,
0.0001443342,
0.012451577,
0.0404281281,
0.0778729245,
0.0403477922,
-0.048731897,
0.0040947217,
0.076209493,
0.0501859076,
-0.0207896847,
0.0181073453,
0.0655330569,
0.0302830823,
-0.0300568026,
-0.0172123909,
-0.0174076743,
0.0499760918,
0.0442857072,
0.0043401639,
0.0670501813,
0.0237831715,
-0.0464949571,
-0.0021836287,
0.0312470477,
-0.0091857053,
-0.0084910505,
-0.0265137069,
0.0358748063,
0.0177158434,
-0.0122777838,
0.0695041046,
0.019993918,
-0.0290071648,
-0.0013585058,
0.0058814981,
0.0076781637,
0.0614168644,
0.0082800239,
0.0107851354,
-0.0272340383,
0.0272341967,
0.0373430811,
0.0743504986,
-0.0117445467,
0.021281993,
0.006310137,
-0.062527068,
-0.000208302,
0.0013287305,
-0.0105139483,
0.0523719266,
0.0048483326,
0.0319845676,
-0.0005476525,
-0.0196475387,
0.0050071105,
0.0303030144,
-0.0238255765,
0.0031427459,
-0.0375714637,
0.0176896155,
0.0273111239,
-0.0337284096,
-0.0334763415,
-0.0100292927,
-0.0027295572,
-0.0357730389,
-0.0305557251,
-0.016345391,
-0.0085300123,
-0.024280468,
0.0072794226,
-0.0967021435,
-0.0240683015,
0.0163791124,
-0.0391966701,
-0.04885111,
0.0104375184,
-0.0162317455,
0.0251166858,
-0.0202368889,
-0.0093681607,
0.039604079,
0.0347522236,
-0.0194212887,
0.0206244998,
-0.0262957625,
-0.0185273401,
0.005071932,
0.0069038905,
-0.0056811594,
-0.0098071853,
-0.0311494544,
-0.0023829553,
0.0311097447,
-0.0019014021,
-0.0285541788,
0.0268984847,
-0.0265060421,
-0.0017304355,
-0.0798363611,
0.0372416973,
-0.0161905102,
-0.0069502164,
0.0080283936,
0.0023061752,
0.0108096022,
0.0104510607,
-0.0406828225,
0.0013547873,
-0.0402038023,
0.0036703474,
0.0329539739,
0.0099670552,
0.0483429059,
-0.0457142666,
-0.0187908523,
0.0112633035,
0.0520974472,
-0.0240398161,
-0.0231240075,
-0.0056725792,
0.0333883688,
-0.0247774143,
0.0234052315,
-0.0170713738,
-0.0168860462,
0.0006523603,
-0.0157795101,
0.1015342101,
0.0676300749,
0.0146814445,
-0.0110938912,
0.0100010168,
-0.0058847959,
-0.0318287835,
0.0039557642,
-0.0194232576,
-0.0109162517,
0.00438593,
-0.0222962275,
-0.0249463506,
0.0428493097,
-0.019830497,
-0.0024118649,
-0.1009794399,
0.021113323,
0.0049717035,
-0.0224551242,
-0.0219187867,
0.0370188616,
-0.0160495024,
-0.0108328676,
-0.0694469139,
-0.0384723991,
0.0630111396,
-0.0381466262,
-0.0120410435,
-0.0298083425,
0.0158479996,
0.0011447797,
0.0291698389,
0.0350444242,
0.0367883742,
-0.0122439554,
0.0177153982,
-0.049420204,
0.0374288708,
0.0184966009,
-0.0003383222,
0.0518624783,
-0.0064271512,
0.0109864092,
-0.0452598929,
-0.0185730923,
0.0045925383,
-0.0442974828,
0.0250774026,
-0.0308023896,
0.0140304556,
-0.0294818413,
-0.010219303,
0.0203574244,
0.0002590762,
0.0253497958,
-0.0199086461,
-0.0051276679,
-0.0173463039,
0.043726936,
0.0836975724,
-0.0147710759,
-0.0277239904,
-0.0452850945,
-0.0320059098,
0.0587176755,
0.0244465284,
-0.0113520306,
-0.0479458794,
0.0008732309,
-0.0027440509,
0.0263020471,
0.0184775367,
-0.013098645,
0.0900701135,
-0.0292006172,
-0.0133371148,
0.0530871227,
0.0054825116,
-0.0855137557,
-0.038503468,
0.0543932319,
0.0458705649,
0.0003447731,
0.004084941,
-0.0675811023,
-0.0303739998,
-0.0357723609,
-0.0050791185,
0.0306087714,
0.0060610222,
-0.0354793072,
-0.0777775496,
0.0359063111,
0.0288342088,
-0.0225037485,
0.0103391893,
-0.0003662827,
0.0214794818,
0.0044979006,
-0.0159409419,
-0.0328727365,
0.0283881612,
0.0003955938,
0.0001952437,
0.0369561352,
-0.0724735931,
-0.0126929339,
-0.0348382033,
0.0207617357,
0.0318197496,
0.0366051719,
-0.0023398164,
-0.064104706,
0.0260282233,
-0.010048056,
-0.0196927842,
0.0073141041,
0.0747152716,
-0.0369136706,
-0.0124378409,
-0.0159669202,
0.060696777,
-0.0257915314,
-0.0143528702,
-0.0278005097,
0.0687576234,
-0.0047207819,
-0.0265714936,
-0.0598779842,
0.015555203,
0.0314365253,
0.0513315238,
0.0257695317,
-0.0914985612,
-0.011861369,
-0.0020843917,
-0.000818848,
-0.0540121906,
-0.0305680837,
-0.0192600321,
-0.0277853906,
-0.0468495712,
-0.0452383943,
-0.0168815292,
0.0224014297,
0.0417220332,
-0.0040861503,
-0.0210934523,
-0.0118823191,
-0.0348558873,
-0.0364154391,
0.0853195712,
-0.0386956967,
0.0317759588,
-0.0250663459,
-0.0196385868,
0.0365815945,
-0.0293428935,
-0.0193126369,
0.0304464698,
-0.1291826963,
-0.046553541,
-0.0195301734,
0.0612525381,
0.0069684065,
0.0686293021,
-0.005768985,
-0.0330936536,
0.0652141273,
0.0083656581,
0.0306446869,
0.0231681354,
0.0180758052,
-0.0247184224,
-0.0059080729,
0.0340901352,
-0.0189092532,
0.0514802411,
0.0142504871,
0.0051675788,
0.0090485075,
-0.0212357994,
-0.0121393912,
-0.040441364,
0.06887348,
-0.0050563025,
0.0335655697,
-0.0445108488,
-0.0084453952,
0.0026322666,
-0.0183759816,
-0.0711083859,
-0.0443364419,
0.0282209497,
0.0273313783,
-0.0356760882,
-0.0153766787,
0.0492842607,
0.0015849767,
-0.031048255,
-0.0212834738,
0.0158326812,
0.0230527278,
0.024544267,
0.0415716656,
-0.0253401566,
0.0182321128,
-0.0357745476,
0.0090629598,
-0.013955229,
0.049024798,
0.0424701795,
-0.0032501484,
-0.0307613965,
0.0399672687,
-0.0117178177,
-0.000748851,
-0.0506572612,
0.0108401403,
0.0685780048,
0.0063151792,
0.0622769371,
-0.0146441897,
-0.0269879736,
-0.0124328565,
0.019171739,
-0.0381900072,
-0.0183116887,
0.042908825,
-0.0257591587,
0.0107157668,
0.012842657,
0.0733957514,
-0.0232668035,
0.0170066934,
-0.0145931114,
-0.0044204118,
-0.0219667815,
-0.0111706378,
-0.0215001367,
0.0050599077,
0.0089600896,
-0.0149047989,
-0.0183197744,
-0.0596011952,
0.0091284085,
0.0193323158,
-0.0691535696,
0.0199272335,
0.0571487695,
0.0385975018,
-0.0274458602,
-0.0221506823,
-0.0007106556,
0.0137006538,
-0.0147128031,
-0.0183324721,
-0.0186565686,
-6.510485748e-33,
-0.0731127709,
-0.0007478687,
0.0253033247,
0.0421818085,
-0.0714781582,
-0.0011777768,
-0.044610329,
0.015971655,
0.009926822,
0.0321468413,
0.0062040961,
-0.0030329106,
0.0130081791,
0.0364837684,
-0.0027261227,
0.0412887782,
0.0529925972,
-0.0132947154,
-0.0120825227,
0.0368550904,
0.0086863078,
0.0136219123,
0.05984281,
-0.0255882423,
-0.0164886285,
-0.004377814,
-0.0086584315,
-0.009200451,
0.0299218036,
0.0297687501,
-0.0220085159,
0.0274360515,
0.0013121064,
-0.0116514871,
-0.0340102725,
0.0169152562,
-0.0647035018,
-0.0273294039,
-0.0004752899,
-0.0075592441,
-0.0671946779,
-0.0598886758,
0.060639061,
-0.000947241,
0.021882195,
-0.0295895375,
0.0602703579,
-0.0002339576,
-0.0065624914,
-0.0423682295,
-0.0489910804,
0.0094516566,
-0.0055255033,
-0.0100187575,
0.0193725862,
0.0171544682,
0.007087097,
0.0331799313,
-0.1140663773,
-0.0146355946,
-0.0220998637,
0.0123344073,
0.052391503,
0.0446054712,
0.0273704566,
0.0293386374,
0.0218688156,
-0.0037147347,
0.0202298425,
-0.0059035369,
0.0507847294,
0.0429571867,
0.0195357315,
0.0198907629,
0.0070532775,
0.008818428,
-0.0332545526,
0.0199177004,
-0.0665393025,
-0.0102791954,
0.0393582992,
0.0287285633,
0.0353429839,
0.0171896815,
-0.0280807186,
-0.036886476,
-0.0270703547,
-0.0366621874,
0.0242888108,
0.0115920315,
-0.0019396839,
0.0216005407,
0.0837394595,
0.0032814578,
-0.0011830505,
-0.0318580344,
-0.0293956678,
0.0650249049,
-0.0140129784,
0.0585993305,
-0.0756508932,
-0.0226982888,
0.0261653364,
-0.0060867863,
-0.0093187569,
0.0359798595,
0.0503530838,
-0.004994066,
-0.036193639,
-0.0231938381,
-0.0255250223,
-0.0248322971,
-0.0349792615,
0.0778145567,
0.0411642529,
0.0113154538,
-0.0279326327,
0.0355474018,
0.0034008222,
0.0299411565,
-0.0226833262,
-0.0235123169,
0.0178771038,
-0.0050853319,
-0.0133782672,
0.0377344899,
-0.0617394596,
-0.012643625,
0.0492577218,
-0.0679096058,
-0.024089871,
0.0607966781,
2.76e-7,
0.0531555749,
0.0135722961,
0.0108345402,
0.0080558937,
0.0259497147,
0.0288271662,
-0.0181117393,
0.0545780957,
-0.0067635407,
-0.0116526159,
0.0365910903,
0.0704317614,
0.0268525742,
-0.0086214934,
-0.0581263974,
-0.0073945401,
-0.0255696177,
0.0224933047,
-0.0546670482,
-0.0222233292,
0.0128227444,
0.1096948683,
0.0107373111,
0.0132544329,
0.0481595099,
0.0108995382,
0.1225456297,
-0.0130274482,
-0.013572894,
0.0338898562,
-0.0124976067,
-0.004267327,
-0.0618411414,
0.0208598543,
-0.0145441042,
0.003055464,
0.0574960075,
0.0770614222,
-0.034650106,
-0.0308270305,
-0.0162169915,
0.0308063086,
-0.0278054737,
-0.0455052443,
0.0652624965,
-0.0951016843,
-0.0396315493,
-0.0341544598,
-0.0318719111,
0.0108703906,
0.0402345322,
-0.0112172281,
-0.0132462606,
0.0295156278,
0.0417619832,
0.0045519085,
-0.0504791662,
-0.0973955542,
-0.0109990034,
-0.0198748503,
-0.0589590073,
-0.0096313478,
-0.0794600546,
-0.0286848079,
0.0466682799,
-0.0191711634,
-0.0385716483,
2.27530133e-34,
0.0188020412,
-0.0228022691,
0.0182632897,
-0.0357577316,
0.0088865971,
-0.0047861901,
-0.0491481759,
-0.0056864331,
-0.0103183519,
-0.0812417492,
-0.0343917869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05188v1 | InCoRo: In-Context Learning for Robotics Control with Feedback Loops | 2024-02-07T19:01:11 | 2024-02-07T19:01:11 | Jiaqiang Ye Zhu, Carla Gomez Cano, David Vazquez Bermudez, Michal Drozdzal | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | One of the challenges in robotics is to enable robotic units with the
reasoning capability that would be robust enough to execute complex tasks in
dynamic environments. Recent advances in LLMs have positioned them as go-to
tools for simple reasoning tasks, motivating the pioneering work of Liang et
al. [35] that uses an LLM to translate natural language commands into low-level
static execution plans for robotic units. Using LLMs inside robotics systems
brings their generalization to a new level, enabling zero-shot generalization
to new tasks. This paper extends this prior work to dynamic environments. We
propose InCoRo, a system that uses a classical robotic feedback loop composed
of an LLM controller, a scene understanding unit, and a robot. Our system
continuously analyzes the state of the environment and provides adapted
execution commands, enabling the robot to adjust to changing environmental
conditions and correcting for controller errors. Our system does not require
any iterative optimization to learn to accomplish a task as it leverages
in-context learning with an off-the-shelf LLM model. Through an extensive
validation process involving two standardized industrial robotic units -- SCARA
and DELTA types -- we contribute knowledge about these robots, not popular in
the community, thereby enriching it. We highlight the generalization
capabilities of our system and show that (1) in-context learning in combination
with the current state-of-the-art LLMs is an effective way to implement a
robotic controller; (2) in static environments, InCoRo surpasses the prior art
in terms of the success rate; (3) in dynamic environments, we establish new
state-of-the-art for the SCARA and DELTA units, respectively. This research
paves the way towards building reliable, efficient, intelligent autonomous
systems that adapt to dynamic environments. | [
0.0014229396,
0.0024744424,
0.0238821562,
0.006759793,
-0.0026518719,
0.0400684662,
-0.0181360971,
-0.043940749,
-0.0061976779,
-0.0324655175,
-0.0225486923,
0.0145847499,
-0.0247120578,
0.0552508198,
-0.0040899087,
-0.0355480313,
0.0635384992,
-0.0301270485,
-0.0175937023,
0.0030554638,
-0.0239942968,
-0.0149445375,
-0.0280171409,
0.0162053052,
-0.0184852555,
0.0164963733,
-0.0539071225,
0.022149764,
0.0364439115,
-0.0346621312,
0.0017601587,
-0.0417901799,
0.1131690592,
0.0122388927,
0.0000020667,
-0.0616169572,
-0.0362025537,
-0.0369600877,
-0.0032316046,
-0.0716365725,
0.0066053933,
-0.0026282598,
0.0107949488,
0.0460556112,
-0.0380943567,
0.0339140147,
0.0278860964,
0.0011720603,
0.0209376253,
0.064450413,
0.0206750017,
-0.0162492767,
0.0035163208,
0.0078140302,
0.0126666632,
-0.0411056168,
0.018519314,
0.0445055179,
0.0622673519,
-0.0410141535,
-0.0275037456,
-0.0288488995,
0.0347303636,
-0.0163552817,
-0.0136403339,
0.0351194218,
0.0155763049,
-0.033275459,
-0.0234104507,
0.0333006792,
-0.0322325602,
-0.0153300995,
0.01844294,
0.0263085533,
0.0012070251,
-0.0397586226,
-0.0295704976,
0.007510093,
-0.0213938225,
0.0003448932,
-0.0528810024,
-0.0341001712,
0.0147639913,
0.0009653635,
-0.0436831303,
0.1113573015,
-0.0299376342,
0.01862216,
0.0217462908,
-0.0184852295,
-0.0052301413,
-0.0524755754,
-0.0011017605,
0.106396623,
-0.058739502,
0.0345930271,
-0.0242814012,
0.023362834,
-0.0270600766,
-0.0260863323,
-0.0292669144,
0.0409042612,
-0.0157261435,
0.0283326562,
-0.0541254282,
0.069305338,
-0.0166532956,
0.0668975711,
-0.0046391697,
-0.0006037778,
-0.0807541609,
0.0305354912,
-0.0218931884,
0.0578867123,
0.0198092498,
0.0048253736,
-0.0203901641,
0.0756018087,
-0.0312783569,
0.053469751,
-0.0488913804,
0.0216647256,
-0.0162220169,
-0.0076354844,
-0.053023614,
-0.0142873628,
-0.0214179978,
0.0435557067,
0.0014734562,
0.0004621256,
-0.0021154562,
0.0251407512,
0.006560341,
0.0316523872,
0.0253155623,
0.1304435134,
0.0023303516,
-0.0423229411,
-0.0255915951,
-0.0006818019,
0.0293801799,
-0.0626060814,
0.0452066846,
-0.0292461924,
0.0012066804,
0.0018887365,
-0.0137778362,
-0.0099225305,
0.0160870459,
-0.0011669777,
0.0128169246,
0.0889700502,
-0.0346800461,
-0.005311063,
0.017634429,
0.0093659433,
-0.0493272208,
0.0566884652,
0.0487084463,
0.0357743725,
-0.0084802201,
0.0360062085,
0.0186423883,
0.0221629255,
-0.0413163528,
0.0003596848,
-0.0442401469,
-0.0124215465,
-0.0095173866,
0.0301204547,
-0.0033988713,
-0.0240393337,
-0.000236476,
0.0436641946,
0.00460365,
0.0164512135,
-0.0635847002,
0.017854495,
0.0224808473,
0.0018970851,
-0.0283018295,
-0.0584906191,
-0.0485430211,
0.0467982367,
-0.032797683,
0.0078422204,
-0.0512209237,
-0.0197278839,
-0.0044104825,
-0.0529343411,
-0.0032484815,
0.0109259207,
0.0177895185,
0.0269514024,
0.0548199043,
0.0155403391,
-0.0629879013,
-0.0155378738,
0.0008827876,
-0.0163405612,
-0.0378574878,
-0.0382948034,
0.0499731936,
0.0616974495,
0.0234478135,
-0.0667195916,
-0.0561315604,
-0.0324224792,
-0.0041420348,
0.0351226181,
-0.0661348179,
-0.0151288575,
0.0448252633,
-0.0023383105,
-0.051867675,
-0.0093446253,
-0.0082252668,
0.0712626353,
0.0297663957,
0.0050395778,
-0.0391836874,
-0.0269930717,
0.0214114375,
0.0469700284,
0.0032166741,
-0.0219730847,
0.0127703361,
0.0056711468,
0.0397331752,
-0.0128461635,
0.0048269616,
-0.0375754163,
0.0484030135,
-0.0217119437,
-0.0468541384,
0.0279958416,
-0.0305335224,
-0.0227378272,
0.0562602356,
-0.0184864029,
-0.0376880206,
0.0341518857,
-0.0660222098,
-0.0427240692,
0.0226463284,
0.0016628789,
0.0349202678,
0.0272679292,
-0.0164662004,
0.0013929814,
-0.0341497324,
-0.0111550735,
0.0270190388,
-0.0251987092,
-0.0147227021,
0.024509605,
0.0341636539,
0.011203507,
-0.0301131643,
0.0161575265,
-0.0186044909,
-0.0155811403,
-0.0193510335,
0.0120150289,
0.0534363315,
-0.0069062989,
0.0111798951,
-0.0358895883,
-0.0187746417,
-0.0133693758,
-0.0225776732,
0.0148818074,
-0.0498934984,
0.0009954843,
-0.0404653251,
0.0454097614,
0.0506100133,
-0.0130790994,
-0.0185075756,
0.0303395595,
0.0234616958,
-0.0535339341,
-0.0401099883,
0.0404844582,
-0.0102553284,
-0.0175320618,
0.0136837866,
-0.0260747243,
-0.0547617227,
0.0519234203,
-0.0377363302,
0.0403031185,
-0.0240583234,
0.0034261909,
0.06105325,
-0.0517148226,
-0.0083835563,
0.0813121796,
-0.0382602401,
0.008273269,
0.0859462619,
0.021834068,
-0.049556192,
0.0424818769,
-0.0269848052,
-0.0428330302,
-0.0270853434,
0.0312906429,
-0.016312426,
0.029902501,
-0.0089399219,
0.0162281245,
-0.0379836746,
-0.0256792177,
0.011020246,
-0.0533931814,
-0.07182239,
0.0108141806,
-0.0380597934,
0.020465415,
-0.0396802574,
-0.040721111,
0.0307584144,
0.02232516,
0.0022434222,
0.0178115461,
-0.0190853439,
-0.007560757,
0.0392504223,
0.0137744872,
-0.0054869214,
-0.0051076291,
-0.0288374964,
-0.0160791297,
-0.0011966048,
-0.0159216449,
0.0072799176,
0.0370956287,
-0.0853591412,
0.0309610032,
0.0271081775,
-0.0415340178,
-0.0481183156,
0.0783346072,
-0.0541634597,
0.0211885553,
-0.1007464007,
-0.0480991453,
0.0075851651,
-0.0403156281,
0.0322012827,
0.0477383398,
-0.0122817326,
-0.0311029907,
-0.052838888,
-0.0269382801,
0.0190638918,
0.0471885018,
-0.0330914147,
-0.0316447914,
-0.0251347404,
0.01709277,
0.0473769009,
-0.0538091809,
-0.0778130367,
0.032994654,
0.0087756114,
-0.0004029008,
0.0420372002,
0.0374626406,
0.0331024602,
-0.0611418448,
-0.0637010783,
0.055321347,
0.0135173146,
-0.0203930903,
0.0022572221,
-0.0377698205,
0.0057256706,
0.0779049397,
0.0366126113,
-0.0085858405,
-0.0619733445,
0.0265820213,
0.0249471348,
0.03062311,
-0.0250210185,
-0.0139531195,
-0.0923656523,
0.0089597302,
-0.001386505,
-0.0698056147,
-0.0715689808,
-0.0087250005,
0.0028729073,
-0.0104748616,
-0.0158851705,
0.0319377035,
0.0034431566,
-0.0269631166,
0.0292241704,
0.0068640308,
-0.028354127,
0.0059038852,
-0.0142539861,
-0.0316443145,
0.0804819241,
0.008385933,
-0.0065756403,
0.0138985133,
0.0675347298,
0.0532318354,
0.0359330364,
-0.0401327908,
-0.0463764034,
-0.0260190275,
-0.0052402564,
0.021613583,
0.043689061,
-0.0310861208,
-0.0441891812,
-0.0144088771,
0.064013429,
-0.0268347021,
0.0251197442,
-0.016449688,
-0.0330055356,
0.0183460489,
0.0335350633,
-0.018314518,
-0.0063722222,
-0.0415462069,
-0.0503100604,
-0.0503206328,
-0.0000409523,
0.0020102246,
-0.0304350518,
-0.038647972,
-0.0069776615,
-0.0404457524,
0.0079961391,
0.0415561534,
0.0376790948,
0.0098595396,
-0.0852018893,
-0.0054508708,
0.037793342,
-0.0671910942,
-0.0199748259,
-0.0128522422,
-0.0049935142,
0.0005314889,
0.0252854284,
0.0309234168,
-0.0248896666,
-0.0234773569,
0.0076947976,
-0.0374478959,
-0.050301075,
0.0282535758,
0.0746536478,
0.0192544647,
0.0394892916,
0.0080799256,
0.0064571858,
0.0939934254,
-0.0067275329,
0.0493815131,
0.0345284194,
0.0305720512,
0.0869250894,
0.0131530138,
0.0202267691,
-0.1174492314,
0.005996271,
0.0183277801,
0.0035435699,
-0.0468160175,
0.0158554092,
0.0217260364,
-0.041308634,
-0.0035430496,
0.006113294,
0.0062460406,
-0.0337657891,
0.0404007733,
0.0059949216,
0.006063744,
-0.0556556918,
0.0460420474,
-0.0051939655,
-0.0145685347,
0.0393965468,
0.0007938212,
0.0396599285,
0.0466181412,
0.0153671252,
-0.0300998352,
0.0377269238,
0.0297894273,
-0.0055267406,
0.0118758967,
-0.0004900903,
0.0245902464,
-0.0038273425,
0.0418880358,
-0.0069996798,
0.0692737997,
0.0358639471,
0.0093559735,
-0.0505892001,
0.0145151457,
-0.0484912433,
-0.0707347468,
0.006372652,
0.0422425903,
0.0516713224,
0.0207608268,
-0.0071237884,
-0.0875584558,
0.0166317821,
0.003282404,
0.0413213298,
-0.0108745536,
-0.0300263222,
0.0570147634,
0.0295680538,
0.0306612365,
0.0323762037,
0.0423707627,
-0.0077964524,
0.0645526052,
-0.0146344798,
0.0200387686,
-0.0528892651,
-0.0020082055,
0.0350458696,
0.0105323195,
0.0441180803,
-0.0091267182,
-0.0083663203,
-0.037222974,
-0.0134967389,
0.0393510424,
-0.0003515967,
-0.0212266985,
0.0351705588,
0.0110371429,
0.0202535782,
-0.0696590096,
0.0233061593,
-0.0337394476,
0.0221712869,
0.0156585574,
-0.0268538371,
-5.565366616e-33,
-0.0253626965,
-0.0524056852,
0.0273715556,
-0.0160072483,
0.0012352574,
-0.0454908423,
-0.0150176147,
-0.0187856313,
-0.00788208,
0.0159881376,
-0.0097688129,
0.0192080624,
-0.000004481,
-0.006303465,
0.0326108746,
-0.0292711034,
0.0102302246,
-0.0091161421,
-0.0231053699,
-0.0158654451,
0.0642096624,
0.0352867283,
0.029972693,
-0.0364844985,
0.0014129763,
0.0268846564,
-0.0435740836,
0.0785498992,
-0.0241696071,
-0.0260792952,
0.0202403367,
-0.0099852188,
0.007591127,
0.0082079582,
-0.0365475863,
0.0375951082,
-0.0672838911,
-0.0513296612,
-0.0468929522,
0.0197061189,
-0.0552913696,
-0.0112587847,
0.0844170526,
0.0074892188,
-0.0146407587,
0.0119335754,
0.0063089291,
-0.026283551,
0.0049690465,
-0.0320503302,
-0.0018483924,
-0.0083908578,
0.0002064713,
-0.0404701903,
-0.0118472343,
0.0428778641,
-0.005904505,
0.0170243755,
-0.0440548323,
-0.0061526243,
-0.0297563244,
-0.0211653635,
0.0652709901,
0.0100505026,
0.0335883051,
0.0405738838,
0.0091658989,
-0.0156023549,
0.0124965906,
-0.0129132867,
0.0031412961,
0.0586874783,
0.0133627513,
0.0334860533,
0.0268337484,
0.0311748628,
-0.0515674017,
0.034428481,
-0.0453316122,
0.1230498403,
0.0096607553,
0.0202136375,
-0.0332557335,
0.0160454419,
0.0130892303,
0.0384612828,
0.010163174,
-0.0084343823,
0.0489706695,
0.0278923996,
0.0004798397,
-0.0579886585,
0.0103537124,
-0.0319676027,
0.0277439263,
0.0090312846,
-0.0234113261,
0.0219256729,
0.0282606296,
-0.0047042319,
-0.0563960932,
-0.0412185825,
-0.0273159686,
-0.0219959598,
0.0119772209,
-0.0228899121,
-0.0379003696,
0.10656932,
-0.0197611935,
0.0031295887,
-0.0523940772,
0.0126727493,
0.0354732648,
0.0026569539,
0.0539018847,
0.0081853606,
-0.0154423891,
0.0715783834,
-0.0361023992,
-0.0375492871,
0.0080889212,
0.0002355703,
-0.0393952653,
0.0435775369,
-0.0496259816,
-0.0325226896,
-0.0077815056,
0.0246536303,
-0.019014189,
-0.0564704239,
0.0223170519,
0.02867111,
2.833e-7,
-0.0184834041,
0.0217840727,
0.0131105622,
0.0259913057,
0.0205790922,
0.0632696226,
-0.0298211239,
0.0431750938,
-0.0296136774,
-0.0355232134,
0.01888966,
0.0559784621,
-0.0024739888,
-0.0275342092,
-0.0623627752,
-0.0180680342,
0.0375199169,
-0.0160271022,
-0.0238491334,
-0.0070393574,
0.0468417667,
0.0700146407,
0.0091530597,
-0.0177443475,
0.0438209139,
-0.0681498423,
0.0502467193,
-0.0231535584,
0.0282168537,
-0.0295382179,
0.0154670784,
0.0088363383,
-0.0071958597,
-0.0237937011,
0.0019581313,
0.0383612551,
-0.0494467132,
0.0591054559,
-0.0068906685,
-0.0705743879,
0.0018336131,
0.0283204708,
0.0243025329,
-0.0278486218,
0.0542616509,
-0.0636413991,
0.0524460115,
-0.0016354426,
0.0340789296,
-0.0137324957,
-0.0535579883,
0.0216865167,
-0.0075247595,
-0.0239120685,
-0.020282615,
0.00043379,
-0.0393390469,
-0.0633895621,
0.0091205426,
-0.0020337845,
-0.07929793,
0.0055395095,
0.0040293681,
0.0022267494,
0.00577003,
-0.0119224852,
-0.0238389038,
2.283407649e-34,
-0.0111445729,
-0.0410523266,
-0.0164823551,
0.078935571,
-0.0233006123,
0.0058787814,
-0.0344035216,
0.0022933104,
0.0665531904,
0.0233740229,
-0.01754044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05111v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05111v1 | Edu-ConvoKit: An Open-Source Library for Education Conversation Data | 2024-02-07T18:59:31 | 2024-02-07T18:59:31 | Rose E. Wang, Dorottya Demszky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce Edu-ConvoKit, an open-source library designed to handle
pre-processing, annotation and analysis of conversation data in education.
Resources for analyzing education conversation data are scarce, making the
research challenging to perform and therefore hard to access. We address these
challenges with Edu-ConvoKit. Edu-ConvoKit is open-source
(https://github.com/stanfordnlp/edu-convokit ), pip-installable
(https://pypi.org/project/edu-convokit/ ), with comprehensive documentation
(https://edu-convokit.readthedocs.io/en/latest/ ). Our demo video is available
at: https://youtu.be/zdcI839vAko?si=h9qlnl76ucSuXb8- . We include additional
resources, such as Colab applications of Edu-ConvoKit to three diverse
education datasets and a repository of Edu-ConvoKit related papers, that can be
found in our GitHub repository. | [
0.0610248595,
-0.0079600224,
-0.0072863307,
0.0244308356,
0.0073776124,
0.0241780672,
0.0256017391,
-0.055577036,
-0.009891592,
-0.0621518083,
0.019685857,
0.0393405668,
0.0104098748,
0.026666943,
-0.0060020643,
-0.0560527518,
0.0051351679,
0.0168677904,
0.0286448915,
0.0367079563,
0.0175234508,
0.0303550623,
-0.0609633699,
0.0530188419,
0.0092935897,
-0.0459614284,
-0.0357416235,
-0.0012183603,
0.0244265459,
-0.0096917879,
0.0721985325,
0.0802558437,
-0.0357750952,
0.0183172785,
0.0000026351,
-0.0463220179,
-0.0207888391,
-0.047303658,
-0.0068158032,
0.0057850541,
0.0159083735,
0.0474151559,
-0.0078723449,
0.0146838706,
-0.0770288631,
0.0460012183,
0.0247549526,
0.0186449774,
0.0569760092,
0.0353911631,
-0.0015829875,
-0.0408185162,
-0.0137727074,
0.020240996,
-0.0218789112,
0.0008730286,
0.0148062343,
0.0293362383,
-0.0043524373,
0.0186324716,
-0.0110375006,
0.0171318185,
-0.0311434362,
-0.0767742246,
0.0491437465,
-0.0071547697,
-0.053311035,
-0.0692734346,
0.0152834961,
0.0925111547,
0.0570047721,
0.0143361511,
0.0193396918,
0.0152125154,
0.0280995276,
-0.0031969245,
-0.0959297717,
-0.0157566462,
-0.0076653641,
-0.0051219114,
-0.0565709099,
-0.0105649112,
-0.0426331051,
0.0100848367,
0.0391046666,
0.0313207954,
-0.029950045,
0.0192996785,
-0.0063711433,
0.0066024582,
0.0261317696,
-0.0443795547,
0.0150088081,
0.0333997495,
0.0131502477,
0.0211954955,
0.0068971203,
-0.0388234034,
0.0198195409,
-0.0227779243,
-0.0475470275,
0.0542139597,
-0.0226332266,
0.0122579802,
0.0535951704,
-0.0180580486,
0.0273760241,
0.0213872883,
-0.0039998009,
0.0130770979,
-0.050746534,
0.016972268,
-0.0202864632,
0.0275795162,
-0.0163494572,
-0.0039145392,
-0.0366469584,
0.0259506833,
-0.0304617789,
0.0376936868,
-0.0575645976,
0.0005768452,
-0.0006513832,
0.0331745632,
-0.0205031708,
0.0791041702,
-0.018454235,
-0.0007038527,
0.0048402618,
-0.0154620996,
0.042404566,
-0.0036242125,
0.0003392393,
-0.0241306424,
-0.0343489647,
-0.0224871393,
0.005929586,
-0.0178947132,
0.0297094639,
-0.0535556972,
0.00241262,
-0.0145650906,
0.044979997,
-0.056472037,
0.0112612518,
0.0388298407,
0.016513383,
-0.021702962,
0.0029556646,
0.0330679528,
-0.0348000564,
0.0229964238,
-0.0367365256,
-0.0177551322,
0.0890367553,
0.0618785545,
0.0479331724,
0.0134715121,
0.0262054969,
-0.0092302412,
0.0669630393,
-0.0520179309,
-0.022135729,
0.0218211953,
0.0399126038,
-0.041782137,
0.0352001004,
0.0304147583,
-0.0198105481,
0.0077713309,
-0.060392417,
-0.0154078016,
-0.0081857201,
0.000699743,
-0.0212861933,
0.0660750568,
-0.0145749813,
0.0062117712,
-0.0171309114,
0.0758041441,
0.0652623475,
-0.0112199103,
-0.0219287928,
0.022688156,
-0.0160534233,
-0.0107510872,
0.0420436449,
0.0078065195,
0.0160901304,
-0.0790219828,
-0.0201318208,
-0.0167641137,
0.0076404614,
0.019694278,
0.0112026939,
-0.0267453548,
-0.0169182997,
0.022526186,
0.0519920401,
-0.08488442,
-0.0229768641,
-0.0312348716,
0.0704708472,
0.0965670645,
0.0577476472,
-0.0155968703,
-0.0506037176,
-0.0396253243,
0.0623099394,
0.0070526013,
0.0387076549,
-0.0292417612,
-0.0095017552,
-0.0270646084,
-0.0021986095,
-0.0380736887,
0.0031631384,
-0.0333975963,
0.0211091079,
0.0058204154,
0.002323139,
0.0381665789,
-0.0409771204,
0.0079397876,
-0.0186708681,
-0.0069335783,
-0.0234903954,
0.0047377301,
0.0064529986,
0.0646594241,
0.0080657387,
-0.0107463375,
0.0231026039,
0.0624103956,
0.0322593525,
0.0067583532,
-0.0178040992,
-0.0405633412,
0.0517951287,
-0.0569558963,
-0.0123959435,
0.0163942743,
-0.0264474899,
-0.015055446,
0.0399064906,
-0.0088151498,
0.082275942,
0.0413435772,
0.001086061,
-0.0173255485,
0.0094183423,
-0.0012556912,
-0.0172089078,
0.0296364799,
-0.0027278799,
0.0167433973,
0.0126448693,
0.0441529825,
0.0098758051,
0.0032074875,
0.0009220224,
-0.0220227614,
-0.0200188775,
0.0168649945,
-0.0233617797,
-0.1015738621,
0.017972989,
-0.1269118488,
-0.0164131168,
0.0044511165,
-0.0098430607,
-0.0008115901,
0.0011749808,
-0.019740738,
-0.0428841226,
0.007376431,
0.0374486744,
-0.0158267505,
-0.0255786702,
0.0314494483,
0.0303465538,
0.0072228536,
-0.064849779,
-0.0191869494,
-0.0257908031,
0.0414261855,
0.0490786545,
-0.0291179512,
0.0122310398,
-0.0088319033,
-0.0671269447,
-0.008669666,
-0.0148797175,
-0.0374958701,
0.0069454769,
0.009159483,
0.0557184443,
0.0340848453,
0.0454083607,
0.0707438067,
0.0106140263,
-0.0624049418,
-0.0267347731,
0.0008264504,
-0.0070332177,
-0.0024808403,
-0.0325401574,
-0.0250964984,
-0.0286797583,
0.0383138247,
-0.0096659027,
-0.0352293923,
0.0047802301,
0.0064411219,
0.0136405742,
0.0219857823,
-0.0621642284,
-0.0222185384,
0.0024560653,
0.0158690643,
0.0029587366,
0.0043248162,
0.0253762919,
0.0124525893,
0.0013470162,
-0.062999405,
-0.0239962693,
-0.0208343994,
0.0568777956,
-0.0378893912,
-0.0341731571,
0.0062799095,
-0.0053512398,
-0.0018478582,
0.0021739264,
0.0276788138,
-0.0630628169,
0.017348744,
-0.0484958477,
-0.0135228196,
-0.0103644524,
0.0520427153,
-0.0333590172,
0.0025863298,
-0.0411403663,
-0.0390840583,
-0.0109434361,
-0.0265375674,
-0.0113060335,
-0.07239452,
-0.0127996821,
0.0302646328,
-0.0115000261,
-0.0036089781,
0.0022818346,
0.0319048911,
0.0388270169,
-0.0058749886,
0.0059282547,
0.0034088995,
0.0881636292,
0.0892197341,
0.0097571369,
-0.0053530848,
0.0140470956,
-0.0576583147,
0.0278108083,
-0.0047606705,
0.0176882576,
-0.0249203965,
0.0427299477,
-0.0755363405,
-0.0069846134,
0.1144513413,
0.0193718504,
-0.0329317898,
-0.0020513742,
-0.0485177971,
0.0195562225,
-0.0126771722,
0.0023008736,
-0.1119162142,
-0.0170023274,
-0.0394408219,
0.0315342247,
-0.0322431661,
-0.045262862,
0.0000096288,
-0.0319002047,
-0.0016245095,
0.0116038006,
0.0046013035,
0.0070640678,
-0.0265663117,
0.0027368208,
-0.0026950371,
-0.0034533048,
-0.0592394695,
0.0132897347,
0.0344819278,
0.0180245601,
-0.02891583,
-0.0292542335,
-0.003737875,
0.0212583337,
0.0467611216,
0.0103434296,
0.0769949406,
0.0082373908,
-0.0117459083,
0.0709041134,
0.0192868747,
-0.0436164625,
-0.0043653003,
0.0655243769,
-0.0154605601,
0.0047408626,
-0.0431738421,
0.0433138013,
-0.0085282316,
-0.0417720303,
0.0647289008,
0.0250517726,
-0.0402982123,
0.0020136279,
-0.0606279634,
0.050246343,
0.0162668768,
0.0646100342,
0.0279476214,
-0.0448022336,
0.027268067,
-0.040496733,
0.0134638362,
-0.0116759799,
-0.0303207561,
-0.0205848794,
0.01209551,
0.0116116032,
-0.0249359142,
-0.0469527692,
0.0567482598,
-0.0450130627,
-0.0305284373,
-0.0216191877,
0.0237284396,
0.0205410551,
-0.0579482093,
0.035154961,
0.0068876292,
0.0201134477,
-0.0671882629,
-0.0693823025,
-0.015809413,
0.0137232002,
-0.0252014343,
0.026323095,
-0.0861339271,
-0.0602439456,
0.0147849396,
0.0037382538,
0.0112765767,
0.0341409072,
0.0329442136,
0.0088888779,
0.0105681932,
0.0250601117,
-0.0254453253,
-0.0154853323,
-0.001186671,
0.0156853329,
0.0048202216,
0.0040329355,
0.0148392776,
0.0103611778,
-0.0231289379,
-0.0261898339,
-0.0488811135,
-0.074929066,
-0.0180789083,
-0.0236075595,
0.0580678023,
0.0180041511,
-0.0785995796,
-0.042868346,
0.0337589793,
-0.0322806612,
-0.029997522,
-0.008689316,
-0.0352018736,
-0.0083462084,
-0.029723566,
-0.0006602288,
0.0211413894,
-0.011187233,
0.051055409,
-0.0396117456,
0.0691939145,
-0.009750234,
0.002450591,
0.0254256465,
-0.037327081,
-0.0148223666,
0.0219528638,
0.0160466749,
0.0460642949,
0.0106166126,
0.0714572072,
0.012087849,
-0.0387142263,
0.1058045775,
0.0096547306,
-0.0366884172,
-0.0126836365,
-0.0195986647,
0.0285686851,
-0.0243101697,
0.0168223549,
0.0683886781,
-0.026348412,
0.0038890492,
-0.0156985912,
0.0320378914,
-0.0594872944,
-0.0374760069,
0.01221825,
-0.0307859499,
0.020356372,
0.0300112087,
0.0141549241,
-0.0652242377,
0.034516491,
0.0156615227,
-0.0036526402,
-0.0514106862,
0.0128846373,
0.006666048,
0.0680793151,
0.0091157528,
0.0507556312,
-0.0202822909,
-0.0212787539,
-0.0101961,
-0.0123307733,
-0.0151966056,
-0.0237031411,
0.0445079356,
0.0362364687,
-0.0117354775,
-0.0059622666,
-0.0333206542,
0.0358056203,
-0.0254887976,
-0.0589490533,
-0.0202625878,
-6.640458689e-33,
-0.0458183475,
-0.0716639161,
0.0035607009,
0.0801428407,
-0.0242848452,
-0.0199731365,
-0.0176248383,
0.0511807054,
-0.0320145786,
0.0235353522,
0.0062462231,
0.0504477732,
-0.0152735366,
0.0626931861,
0.0330130272,
0.0047544995,
0.0301475637,
0.0135106258,
0.0012495045,
0.0765164047,
0.0514529794,
0.0191726144,
0.0520741381,
-0.0965624079,
0.072106123,
-0.018032182,
0.0325562879,
-0.0195312146,
0.0199815165,
0.0167488363,
-0.0302033201,
0.0352865867,
0.0050039981,
0.0149813928,
-0.0095385015,
0.0568393245,
-0.0509795211,
-0.0535944924,
-0.0128772678,
0.0036115672,
-0.0284267869,
-0.0355886444,
0.0197774544,
0.0035234822,
0.0055041076,
-0.0588187762,
0.0773167834,
-0.0083679212,
0.0480017662,
0.0322032049,
-0.072696507,
0.03085378,
-0.1000745296,
-0.0221368764,
-0.0006279545,
0.0783430561,
0.0409922339,
-0.0099509824,
-0.0551192984,
0.0915596411,
-0.0164996888,
0.0065535465,
0.0504502952,
-0.04222003,
-0.0076931785,
0.0654931217,
0.0153796459,
0.0205665492,
-0.0281450488,
0.0139390267,
0.0202411562,
0.0396933071,
0.0454311781,
0.0197821353,
-0.0447218642,
-0.0396342352,
-0.0594449341,
-0.0022233122,
0.0591311008,
-0.0464295559,
-0.0574076846,
-0.0258086175,
-0.035423886,
-0.0042312997,
-0.0029857981,
0.0143701341,
0.0378868021,
-0.0189896561,
-0.0140962601,
-0.0728121623,
-0.0393648632,
0.0426691286,
-0.0173908733,
-0.0282923914,
-0.0263879187,
0.0173817649,
-0.0057391697,
0.0074318689,
-0.0279394034,
-0.0051183049,
-0.0536123328,
-0.0051008873,
0.0174029004,
-0.0355481505,
0.0311829895,
0.0415931232,
0.0303447247,
-0.0094760424,
-0.0179717466,
-0.0154963462,
-0.0108178295,
0.0188095421,
-0.0142651368,
-0.0249357671,
-0.0069072689,
0.047426831,
-0.015410034,
0.0512644574,
0.0252937488,
0.0476634353,
-0.0326282531,
-0.0825201273,
0.0018334341,
-0.0169031695,
-0.0288699083,
-0.0236972459,
-0.0427348167,
0.0112534333,
0.0324313678,
-0.0239698999,
0.0099381087,
-0.0512431338,
3.048e-7,
0.033370506,
0.0677826852,
0.0290943384,
-0.039696198,
-0.000839443,
-0.0124518415,
0.0212717131,
0.0015154976,
0.0574742593,
-0.0241292305,
-0.0101706851,
-0.0051213219,
0.0208620448,
0.0323070846,
-0.0932843909,
-0.0694828779,
-0.0237618499,
-0.0657267347,
-0.0567296967,
0.0345423557,
0.0761596113,
-0.0022885206,
0.0538554192,
0.0242650621,
-0.0515991524,
0.0342354067,
-0.0187700465,
-0.0375545658,
-0.0043242476,
0.0366428867,
0.0178722199,
-0.0202285293,
0.0181442164,
0.0029755116,
-0.0210811328,
0.012893565,
0.0243676566,
0.0122199049,
0.0101065058,
-0.0114962682,
0.0318351798,
-0.0025657353,
0.0206484105,
-0.0397621132,
0.0417764932,
-0.0457987525,
-0.0004336579,
0.010395674,
-0.0183264576,
-0.0086812302,
0.0155997956,
0.0148564279,
0.0036268337,
-0.0119238831,
0.013325301,
-0.0396660939,
0.0268723369,
-0.0629698336,
0.002431676,
-0.0137439705,
-0.026214296,
-0.0808767453,
-0.0096323406,
-0.0700253397,
-0.0032080885,
-0.0033456939,
0.0007031382,
2.364930019e-34,
0.0183685385,
-0.0082393242,
0.0132180257,
0.0339247659,
0.0148157505,
-0.0212388653,
0.0381729715,
-0.0076266397,
0.0371807404,
-0.0310151726,
-0.0202406961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05106v1 | Image captioning for Brazilian Portuguese using GRIT model | 2024-02-07T18:57:37 | 2024-02-07T18:57:37 | Rafael Silva de Alencar, William Alberto Cruz Castañeda, Marcellus Amadeus | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | This work presents the early development of a model of image captioning for
the Brazilian Portuguese language. We used the GRIT (Grid - and Region-based
Image captioning Transformer) model to accomplish this work. GRIT is a
Transformer-only neural architecture that effectively utilizes two visual
features to generate better captions. The GRIT method emerged as a proposal to
be a more efficient way to generate image captioning. In this work, we adapt
the GRIT model to be trained in a Brazilian Portuguese dataset to have an image
captioning method for the Brazilian Portuguese Language. | [
0.0329055078,
0.0340500921,
-0.017403001,
0.0559856817,
0.030717764,
0.0262443218,
-0.0287775882,
-0.0230605882,
-0.0225389842,
-0.0327306129,
-0.032817848,
-0.0165980626,
0.0224722102,
0.0193354283,
0.0388804972,
-0.1005300879,
0.0091770245,
-0.0206992198,
-0.0566816963,
-0.0073013129,
-0.003794712,
0.0012321089,
0.0123159569,
0.0142090051,
-0.0339413434,
0.0091748685,
0.0221597683,
-0.0093642129,
-0.033907529,
-0.002930826,
-0.0139598781,
0.0816829205,
0.0399199799,
0.0094337203,
0.000001895,
0.0246376675,
0.0182925388,
-0.0027261754,
0.0615204051,
-0.0161723141,
0.0360698923,
-0.0605838336,
-0.006072606,
0.0023850212,
-0.0501905195,
-0.0556340218,
0.083370015,
0.0635289103,
0.0834310874,
0.0373208635,
-0.0387291871,
-0.1327142715,
0.003943787,
-0.0510756075,
-0.0454730578,
0.0057663261,
-0.0163092501,
0.0472017303,
-0.0316402055,
-0.0067567504,
-0.0214317609,
0.0592928864,
0.0029347457,
-0.046906177,
0.000648557,
0.0326955542,
0.0034323626,
-0.0294836033,
-0.0235060286,
0.0623543896,
-0.0028926758,
0.0292901099,
-0.044347968,
0.0226353481,
-0.0085443603,
-0.0368723795,
-0.0729547814,
0.0441958159,
0.0191272125,
0.0232036114,
-0.0649501532,
0.0294052567,
0.0116151581,
0.0330629013,
0.0132500203,
-0.0281812567,
-0.0018881967,
0.0147452932,
-0.0521753058,
0.0029696713,
0.0198598281,
-0.0333106965,
0.035166055,
0.022963576,
0.0184888337,
-0.0035245183,
0.0060540042,
0.000587829,
0.0201819073,
-0.038091477,
-0.0482476838,
-0.0415780321,
-0.0126307542,
0.0740719661,
-0.0510812402,
0.0477491803,
-0.0211422518,
0.0363463685,
-0.0538398549,
-0.029958088,
-0.03850412,
-0.0331162177,
-0.0659865141,
0.0370052196,
-0.0483745784,
-0.0377315171,
-0.0470368974,
-0.0144127272,
-0.0255916007,
-0.0064585879,
0.0126752779,
0.0477201007,
-0.0139478007,
0.0022098827,
-0.0396491922,
0.0219449047,
0.006299234,
-0.0108806035,
-0.027009977,
-0.0101983938,
-0.0018415422,
0.0240342878,
-0.0054788883,
-0.0180652235,
-0.0146299498,
0.0273562633,
-0.0288105216,
-0.0249556638,
-0.0245719738,
-0.0102373967,
-0.0515078679,
-0.0276382957,
-0.0011157185,
-0.0318827741,
0.0097746393,
-0.0097252661,
0.0230817869,
-0.0489208885,
0.0023442709,
0.0169451386,
0.0107653653,
0.0843000934,
-0.0443816483,
-0.0137616005,
0.0412229672,
0.0065324865,
0.0178321283,
0.0543162338,
0.0345949233,
0.0536539517,
0.027563408,
-0.0051366072,
-0.0084987283,
0.0321931168,
0.0020665743,
-0.0325762369,
-0.0254600924,
-0.0077800006,
0.0109079685,
0.0095660398,
0.0711632073,
0.0788898095,
-0.0053478698,
0.0396650359,
0.0846977308,
0.0381743535,
-0.0047267168,
0.1007239744,
0.0604727417,
-0.0021778501,
0.0059093256,
0.0015396996,
-0.0210697278,
0.0530218072,
0.0810077339,
0.0260337032,
-0.0068600439,
0.0589367338,
-0.0657623485,
-0.0353247896,
0.0173529238,
-0.0075944359,
0.0259974133,
-0.0317515768,
0.0325316191,
0.0396348909,
-0.0619496368,
0.0114878183,
-0.0166125987,
-0.0298178252,
-0.0260219891,
-0.0514755249,
-0.0074035367,
0.0260316506,
0.0182485133,
0.0096474495,
-0.0180568993,
-0.0202137083,
0.0387502536,
0.0378895327,
0.0171067733,
0.003453295,
-0.0324684978,
-0.0538760833,
-0.0383633077,
-0.0201184787,
-0.0034482244,
0.039250616,
-0.0309864599,
0.0206933245,
0.0406739525,
0.0661972836,
-0.1000115946,
0.0399001464,
0.0679194629,
-0.037269149,
0.0010528456,
0.022475427,
-0.0174233969,
0.0249707196,
-0.026649788,
-0.0005518377,
0.0094340788,
0.0055597271,
-0.0003879884,
0.0692771003,
-0.0225309841,
-0.0402041189,
0.0031439636,
-0.0620149672,
-0.0270101987,
0.0103600929,
0.0020471704,
-0.0359934755,
-0.0040465556,
-0.047382053,
-0.0005120056,
-0.0705000684,
0.0172554236,
-0.0341076069,
0.0600414984,
-0.0029787591,
0.0402357914,
0.0008039968,
-0.029714603,
0.0370341763,
-0.0454045311,
0.0035631061,
-0.0558835752,
-0.05810358,
0.0276319589,
-0.0021677329,
0.0168125723,
-0.0085761789,
0.0693924055,
-0.004389212,
0.0002639727,
-0.0611421652,
-0.0106435604,
-0.0072709215,
-0.0239182301,
0.0100602591,
-0.0155437393,
0.0257224347,
-0.042632211,
-0.0260494687,
0.0133604249,
0.007078738,
-0.0142866774,
0.0565527119,
0.030620398,
-0.0163695365,
-0.0169035699,
0.009689915,
0.0295814034,
0.0688837916,
0.0370268449,
-0.0335958786,
-0.0459770858,
0.0214223973,
0.0099765081,
-0.0043491963,
0.0212794468,
-0.0616756342,
-0.0151834702,
0.0374139026,
0.0008480553,
0.0179630145,
0.0166366529,
0.0205811299,
0.0265601352,
-0.0022486115,
0.0206065904,
0.0063212807,
-0.0255873259,
-0.0231163595,
0.0316463485,
-0.0509291328,
0.0242040642,
0.052068051,
-0.0127664721,
0.0433791764,
-0.0478277542,
0.0207034722,
-0.0180175323,
-0.0296296533,
-0.0113561396,
0.0212078262,
-0.0080997217,
0.0042270035,
-0.0395468622,
-0.0411991328,
0.0241322964,
-0.0469110534,
-0.0368878655,
-0.0282509252,
-0.0028969026,
-0.0300257951,
0.0444048271,
-0.009077793,
0.0242672618,
0.0106112296,
-0.0287437644,
-0.0003396562,
-0.0546530224,
0.0191937201,
-0.0015438239,
0.050298553,
-0.0498660281,
-0.0050016809,
-0.0428862721,
-0.0330883563,
-0.0028248257,
-0.0426490568,
0.0076316288,
0.0244314726,
0.0179379005,
0.007321436,
0.0072319764,
0.0807443783,
0.0181456786,
0.0372626819,
-0.0365469232,
-0.0158008598,
0.0135639971,
0.0270812437,
0.0392259471,
0.0293589253,
-0.0370801501,
0.0074584377,
0.0490590371,
-0.0111286761,
-0.010574339,
-0.0007238664,
-0.0750068277,
0.0120517556,
0.0215854123,
0.0170555245,
-0.0209151264,
-0.0333323888,
0.0422044992,
-0.0053201779,
-0.004424111,
0.0793944672,
-0.0010896859,
-0.0272598751,
-0.0315618254,
0.0081831375,
-0.0023009435,
0.0419305526,
0.0227193721,
-0.009413721,
-0.0132799186,
-0.0390115045,
-0.0102493893,
0.04417805,
0.0490912758,
-0.0416507795,
-0.0429698005,
0.0598269887,
0.0056291432,
-0.0720114857,
-0.0708720759,
0.0310552381,
-0.0465864949,
-0.0176112466,
-0.0023249695,
-0.0411121212,
-0.0089016128,
-0.0141225113,
0.0402449295,
0.036572881,
-0.0769783705,
-0.0463222191,
-0.0415051207,
-0.0022289497,
0.0147128394,
0.0343881287,
-0.0275303386,
-0.0150897289,
0.0018146527,
0.0212892648,
0.0336241834,
-0.0366045348,
0.0844867006,
0.0061689457,
-0.0494438894,
-0.0211215783,
-0.0239210967,
0.0102721434,
0.0032851219,
0.0110462075,
0.0296476949,
0.0119314548,
0.0266557038,
-0.0229018051,
0.0070147412,
-0.0037021514,
0.012722346,
0.0375175886,
-0.0111740464,
-0.0136634195,
-0.007790694,
-0.0145431105,
-0.0572058298,
-0.0338917263,
-0.002281941,
-0.0623886511,
-0.0456270464,
-0.0764120817,
-0.0339284763,
0.061030183,
-0.0036382652,
0.0575841926,
-0.0334537439,
0.0084699001,
0.0177858919,
-0.0583333001,
0.0221856777,
-0.0175664667,
0.0239514448,
-0.016020719,
-0.0372240394,
0.0696675032,
-0.0092472043,
-0.0131439306,
-0.0026945597,
-0.0404385887,
0.0168001596,
-0.0364349596,
0.0657706782,
0.0136845428,
0.0005590533,
0.0096279345,
-0.0548360683,
0.0128500955,
0.0171763394,
0.0121819368,
-0.0113106808,
0.021966055,
-0.0198258851,
-0.0305224191,
0.0179319568,
0.0059367423,
-0.0022155496,
-0.0171114765,
0.0340914913,
-0.0406134762,
-0.0141252298,
-0.0137893017,
-0.0537941679,
0.0278887376,
-0.0233957842,
-0.0127261914,
-0.0467775837,
0.0181511119,
0.0064602671,
0.0152731314,
-0.0170345996,
0.0218308102,
0.0373746306,
0.0496920496,
-0.0045306426,
-0.0238429308,
-0.0342037231,
-0.0366935767,
-0.0023515895,
0.0080429027,
0.0317192264,
-0.039204374,
-0.040975634,
0.0474255048,
-0.0300096124,
-0.0127085354,
0.0230576415,
0.0089894086,
-0.0228950474,
0.0365362652,
-0.0000068684,
-0.0307567324,
-0.0226877294,
0.0745382309,
0.0417192057,
0.0196712315,
-0.0757809058,
-0.0103384098,
0.0759209618,
-0.0301668197,
0.0387071893,
0.0194522459,
-0.0037491445,
0.033686731,
0.0268114991,
-0.0174055211,
-0.0308041107,
0.0504262857,
-0.0009326582,
0.0055690268,
-0.013593778,
0.0515611209,
-0.006082437,
-0.0106187547,
0.012390892,
-0.0538537093,
-0.0254561417,
0.0123005565,
0.0236509852,
-0.020163564,
-0.0378376245,
0.0320424624,
-0.0204928406,
-0.0563237444,
-0.0172048304,
-0.0063632294,
0.011519569,
0.0516203642,
0.0553946234,
0.011738074,
0.0302747525,
0.0015655753,
-0.0386208519,
0.0151254842,
-0.0339575633,
0.0581379086,
-0.0566894077,
-5.233294238e-33,
-0.0495095737,
-0.0449415967,
0.0150408838,
0.0549280159,
-0.0394509993,
0.0011063996,
-0.0336887278,
0.0201080553,
-0.0140940426,
0.0218922161,
0.0265052039,
-0.0279408582,
0.0208510198,
0.0365131758,
0.0115621565,
0.0325567089,
0.041644346,
-0.012390594,
0.0306707304,
0.0008105385,
-0.0185882933,
-0.0007579498,
0.071818687,
-0.0422937796,
-0.0258633699,
-0.0141447606,
-0.0399260484,
0.0094247004,
0.0496287122,
0.0526113324,
-0.0142926145,
0.0035485181,
0.0292194821,
-0.0463497415,
-0.0088288179,
-0.0007213814,
-0.0607791543,
-0.018696297,
0.0710897893,
0.0952693745,
0.0354217887,
-0.0239982028,
0.0361493193,
-0.0387860164,
-0.0018313236,
-0.0085286731,
0.0802904889,
-0.0350838974,
0.0160999559,
-0.0076217288,
-0.035367921,
0.0036810033,
-0.001598436,
-0.0438684113,
0.0679759979,
0.021234341,
-0.0017831501,
-0.0184377134,
-0.0347970612,
0.0267478433,
0.0345948711,
0.0474757589,
0.100680165,
0.0545956343,
-0.0135666439,
0.0080687087,
0.0456546731,
-0.0225442704,
-0.018872872,
0.0236407425,
0.0261508971,
0.0424060971,
0.051621858,
0.068520762,
0.0295897927,
0.0076501062,
-0.0224114433,
0.0373653434,
-0.0888685808,
0.0855176523,
0.0403156616,
-0.0308135934,
0.0298159737,
0.0185430814,
-0.0457528122,
-0.0411883667,
-0.028808387,
-0.006609282,
0.0215199552,
-0.0048466339,
-0.0390113071,
0.0897969306,
0.0285256691,
-0.0366284847,
0.0194016434,
-0.0205186028,
-0.0133587718,
0.0663034245,
-0.0142437648,
-0.0293952636,
0.0015991881,
-0.060980048,
0.0173279177,
0.0857045799,
0.0359443277,
0.0026069209,
0.0636231005,
0.0157154277,
-0.024040645,
0.0134768952,
-0.0245354231,
0.00520497,
-0.0440317728,
0.0475116335,
-0.0265851784,
0.019795239,
-0.0866698027,
-0.0067301677,
-0.0229309015,
0.0073918626,
-0.0289090034,
-0.0457619652,
0.0471244566,
0.0526086204,
-0.043378111,
0.0343110785,
-0.0235966165,
0.0258486681,
0.0096974066,
-0.0337585956,
-0.054701075,
0.0202912185,
2.473e-7,
0.0109143499,
0.049277693,
0.0413405038,
0.0074405372,
0.031422779,
0.0157789607,
-0.0244480483,
-0.0059569725,
-0.0090468014,
0.021562865,
0.0579872169,
0.0022373099,
0.039621003,
-0.0228064787,
-0.0952943414,
0.0153574338,
-0.0229061302,
-0.0164804123,
-0.0037182623,
-0.020497771,
0.037851654,
0.0879500508,
-0.0156752337,
-0.0337587632,
-0.0253591575,
-0.0807579234,
0.0787209794,
-0.0247848369,
0.0495373309,
-0.0189663917,
-0.001598311,
0.0630384758,
-0.063153103,
0.0275011621,
-0.0185933914,
0.0129742194,
0.0364473723,
0.0306277461,
-0.0467285961,
0.0551833436,
0.0043782894,
0.0383783281,
-0.0336736776,
-0.0921822637,
0.0364373289,
-0.0737708136,
-0.0268324595,
-0.0212330278,
0.0182192847,
0.0118758846,
0.0096324943,
-0.0772111192,
-0.0449588448,
0.0001241388,
0.0407755002,
-0.0287929811,
-0.0417222045,
-0.0445042104,
-0.0036120873,
0.0043033059,
-0.0196261257,
-0.00511458,
-0.0646461695,
-0.0566615723,
0.0266179498,
0.0174275767,
0.0179928895,
1.77576961e-34,
0.0130931912,
-0.0307160728,
0.0172017161,
0.0257455818,
-0.0030708476,
0.0119355544,
0.001045616,
-0.008308582,
0.0026359477,
-0.0384990796,
-0.0193870775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05162v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05162v3 | Assessing the Brittleness of Safety Alignment via Pruning and Low-Rank Modifications | 2024-02-07T18:34:38 | 2024-07-01T07:11:17 | Boyi Wei, Kaixuan Huang, Yangsibo Huang, Tinghao Xie, Xiangyu Qi, Mengzhou Xia, Prateek Mittal, Mengdi Wang, Peter Henderson | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) show inherent brittleness in their safety
mechanisms, as evidenced by their susceptibility to jailbreaking and even
non-malicious fine-tuning. This study explores this brittleness of safety
alignment by leveraging pruning and low-rank modifications. We develop methods
to identify critical regions that are vital for safety guardrails, and that are
disentangled from utility-relevant regions at both the neuron and rank levels.
Surprisingly, the isolated regions we find are sparse, comprising about $3\%$
at the parameter level and $2.5\%$ at the rank level. Removing these regions
compromises safety without significantly impacting utility, corroborating the
inherent brittleness of the model's safety mechanisms. Moreover, we show that
LLMs remain vulnerable to low-cost fine-tuning attacks even when modifications
to the safety-critical regions are restricted. These findings underscore the
urgent need for more robust safety strategies in LLMs. | [
-0.0013623076,
0.0758882314,
-0.0136757428,
0.0411941409,
-0.0261277556,
-0.0039565759,
-0.0217634421,
-0.0227659345,
-0.012645321,
0.006296319,
-0.0293349698,
-0.036580693,
0.0205611959,
0.0008483411,
0.0569147989,
-0.000262631,
0.0885247439,
-0.0645797253,
-0.0086929966,
0.0001078279,
0.0109420912,
-0.0256776027,
0.0274236966,
0.0066350694,
0.0388095416,
-0.007157654,
-0.0231564641,
0.0274536926,
0.0399220027,
0.0052227895,
0.0006385454,
0.0573717244,
-0.0116463909,
0.0740934685,
0.000002039,
-0.0193075705,
-0.012591471,
0.0437213592,
-0.0158547144,
0.066580385,
-0.0082310755,
-0.0483364612,
-0.0456752107,
0.0000512158,
0.0158097669,
0.0152825173,
0.0800437555,
0.0097790314,
0.0554615892,
0.0849353969,
0.0205339193,
0.0217068419,
0.0357138328,
-0.0321360938,
-0.0239360705,
-0.0665045604,
0.036589954,
-0.0398345776,
-0.0352591723,
0.0237182006,
-0.0377715006,
-0.0058065737,
0.0018592866,
-0.0126368646,
-0.0466269366,
-0.0030240749,
-0.0589830726,
-0.0252548028,
-0.0042451816,
0.052679792,
-0.0678040758,
-0.0175345708,
0.0152381007,
-0.0106715849,
0.0105449632,
-0.0378692672,
-0.003965864,
0.0143191852,
0.0269161817,
0.0042675179,
0.0202104002,
0.0003028113,
0.0722801834,
-0.01375206,
0.0149668446,
0.0565029234,
0.0274704192,
-0.0323904119,
-0.0109777479,
-0.0344929211,
-0.0236280579,
-0.023641726,
-0.0344696604,
-0.0292472169,
0.0022122893,
0.0326219797,
-0.0624572448,
0.0062677641,
0.046102725,
-0.0585142039,
0.0126537448,
0.0357660539,
0.0427232012,
0.0069139814,
-0.0000865556,
-0.0044046976,
-0.0403583795,
0.0576570407,
0.0164959002,
0.0659331754,
0.0232825205,
-0.0271161068,
0.0342622176,
0.0149114728,
-0.0042000455,
0.0058389963,
-0.0311988238,
0.0103198048,
-0.0381772183,
0.0186674055,
-0.0470011085,
-0.0055146106,
-0.0086814752,
0.0172190405,
0.0359270349,
-0.0066226362,
-0.0139547093,
-0.0092576025,
-0.0087986076,
-0.03712143,
-0.0457969643,
0.0024779136,
-0.0519090965,
-0.0636471063,
-0.0187560208,
0.0983288139,
0.0101030795,
-0.0232335459,
-0.0546859875,
-0.0420352146,
-0.0756382495,
-0.019129863,
0.0045134411,
-0.0522955358,
-0.0144568877,
-0.0146162016,
-0.0311913919,
-0.0851873383,
0.016082352,
-0.0028160897,
-0.0816970542,
0.0372402035,
-0.0015443643,
-0.01546303,
-0.0338621996,
0.030420389,
0.0308630131,
0.0594554581,
0.0451959036,
0.0342974961,
0.0542800874,
-0.0054301517,
0.0062717889,
0.0426449589,
0.017885644,
0.0502863862,
-0.0474298969,
-0.0298994891,
0.0358067155,
-0.0218927786,
0.0018930724,
0.0692966655,
-0.019832002,
-0.0624624304,
0.0951417387,
0.0175121557,
-0.001655027,
0.0666342601,
-0.0327889957,
-0.0326382257,
-0.01346712,
0.0148216309,
-0.0908972993,
0.0050727297,
-0.0836900696,
0.0061382544,
-0.0037149217,
0.0299441144,
-0.0159006882,
0.0015281828,
-0.0165977739,
0.000994431,
0.0604178719,
-0.0073717847,
0.0101606362,
-0.0094636148,
-0.0111421263,
0.0482316427,
0.0414977744,
-0.0578414537,
-0.0198242702,
-0.063256219,
-0.0284243189,
0.062785022,
0.0413451158,
-0.0144114718,
-0.0204512738,
0.0199904479,
-0.0050844229,
0.0287603196,
0.0036717886,
0.0306025762,
0.0781425759,
-0.0345109999,
0.0017484649,
-0.0165698007,
0.0449802428,
0.000132573,
0.0256621428,
-0.0203024298,
-0.0149726858,
-0.0268813968,
-0.0469538085,
0.0214127544,
0.0074421517,
-0.0016708202,
-0.0137345176,
0.0080938991,
0.0053893384,
-0.0332056619,
-0.0654298514,
0.0284191761,
0.0344967358,
0.0152120376,
0.0530715249,
-0.0239501353,
-0.0565321371,
0.021103764,
0.05784145,
-0.0061786147,
0.0040039066,
0.0634800866,
-0.0309925731,
-0.0153109748,
0.0466048121,
-0.0431229398,
-0.0145026622,
0.0054949578,
0.0447760522,
-0.0374884829,
0.0263609868,
-0.0369637087,
0.0555759855,
-0.0025699064,
0.0020652292,
-0.0245104767,
-0.018138431,
0.0263278801,
-0.0421536826,
-0.0815514699,
-0.0042176642,
-0.0366732404,
0.0479329713,
0.0126883304,
0.0065347361,
0.0007951059,
-0.0346293896,
-0.018507652,
-0.0090041962,
-0.0063293362,
0.0327772647,
0.0395037234,
-0.0170150064,
-0.0160280261,
0.0057706111,
0.0403485037,
0.0079265991,
-0.0439560115,
0.0243949983,
0.0311034638,
-0.0162741207,
-0.0594852231,
-0.0586977713,
-0.0509346388,
-0.0129797161,
0.0564051121,
-0.0497065708,
-0.0191161688,
-0.0391694531,
0.0558598153,
-0.0107773831,
0.0279074963,
0.0003641578,
-0.0743614882,
0.0097433766,
0.0303657465,
-0.0101224976,
0.0751406327,
-0.0038914026,
0.0409810841,
0.0682736486,
0.0118968962,
-0.0028687194,
-0.0135665704,
0.0078808162,
-0.0248196088,
-0.0378769524,
-0.0238766503,
-0.0153405406,
0.0788592622,
0.0167606249,
-0.0389596894,
-0.0678943545,
-0.0009349901,
-0.0041206554,
-0.0358243138,
0.0015984279,
-0.02598463,
-0.0566820018,
0.0423403755,
-0.0417056307,
-0.066536203,
0.0628554672,
-0.0324664749,
0.0405610427,
0.0035504901,
-0.0328517072,
0.0052730753,
0.0424171798,
-0.0035750277,
0.0432144701,
0.0279751271,
-0.0198998563,
-0.0788430199,
-0.0368274003,
0.0298226606,
-0.0103320936,
0.0524600893,
-0.0495309867,
0.0068552634,
-0.026373595,
-0.0670566559,
0.0085065058,
-0.0642757788,
0.0109102083,
0.0096326647,
0.0740961283,
-0.049767863,
0.0037067889,
-0.0099885743,
0.0428233892,
0.015180449,
-0.0384733826,
0.0154895624,
-0.0380533189,
-0.0017141466,
0.0632129759,
-0.043840006,
0.0645765737,
-0.0504733995,
0.0299380459,
0.0659364909,
0.0288898349,
0.0600895844,
-0.0468391143,
0.0087080775,
0.0209835246,
0.005766443,
-0.0133546647,
0.0327885114,
0.0566016622,
-0.0096570412,
-0.0199063551,
0.0308988504,
0.0011459624,
-0.0057098325,
0.0542494431,
-0.0129697481,
0.0604244061,
0.0119502908,
0.0301664695,
-0.0235547163,
0.0009641334,
0.0206749663,
0.0357563719,
0.0138213048,
-0.0235296506,
0.0182702523,
-0.0823020563,
-0.0089549096,
0.0498836748,
-0.0174674559,
-0.0162123274,
-0.0038532333,
0.003937311,
-0.020347463,
0.0672116205,
0.0415477566,
-0.0150990915,
-0.0364337936,
0.0044439621,
-0.0190684684,
-0.0403673127,
0.018935008,
-0.0236102883,
0.0727019086,
0.0691103563,
-0.013288944,
-0.0436846241,
-0.014145853,
0.0463020802,
-0.0031661256,
0.0011795465,
0.0224077571,
0.023680076,
0.0370294116,
-0.0264726449,
-0.017612502,
0.0108964862,
0.0367850251,
-0.0322524905,
-0.0124907987,
0.0340223052,
-0.0079077659,
-0.0260407273,
-0.0015028708,
0.0138008334,
-0.0199046154,
0.0392165259,
0.0266426187,
-0.0420968719,
-0.0483786911,
-0.0390200503,
-0.0028490168,
-0.0518817231,
-0.0618615188,
0.027894998,
0.0270535201,
-0.0381364785,
-0.0382135883,
0.0402052142,
-0.025777474,
0.038060274,
0.0311682858,
-0.0275268704,
0.0156718511,
-0.0034464658,
-0.0212840941,
0.0053110872,
-0.0247005243,
0.021499889,
-0.0525859073,
0.0562167726,
-0.0159766972,
0.0018823395,
-0.0207534861,
0.0038318255,
-0.0419013724,
-0.1199810803,
0.017948186,
0.0727344528,
0.0307117812,
-0.0263610613,
-0.0118874805,
-0.0635851771,
0.0429956578,
0.0478782579,
-0.0273250751,
0.0558432527,
0.0447339676,
-0.0684911087,
0.0060648834,
0.0314018093,
-0.0297713671,
-0.0538141429,
0.0696415827,
0.055978667,
-0.0268767588,
0.0020398863,
-0.0010979023,
0.0257970877,
0.0303532034,
-0.0037776416,
0.0143626388,
0.0049228799,
0.0302314535,
-0.0086759776,
-0.0017020925,
-0.0058285086,
-0.0049489504,
0.0568716377,
-0.0088555915,
-0.0087017165,
0.0096257897,
0.0543782786,
0.0365466066,
-0.0177217685,
-0.0144363698,
-0.0142041249,
-0.0046626991,
0.0507919416,
0.025708776,
-0.0408463664,
0.0836318508,
-0.0381313302,
0.0264011975,
0.0112437624,
-0.0056546926,
0.0108812256,
0.0177522637,
-0.0581959188,
0.0575254112,
-0.0616199151,
-0.0667798519,
-0.0271978285,
-0.0015696679,
0.0031277097,
0.0188053213,
0.0514433011,
0.0053530727,
-0.0179695748,
-0.0595189407,
-0.0112164635,
0.007433116,
-0.052336935,
0.0166039094,
0.0189788491,
-0.0037532111,
-0.006143555,
0.0552354045,
0.0424393564,
0.0523333177,
-0.0126357004,
-0.0091950707,
-0.0023381752,
-0.0364941359,
0.0237166528,
-0.0031504855,
-0.0601649508,
-0.0517993793,
-0.0849459767,
-0.0959080011,
-0.0274633542,
0.023763936,
0.0305247195,
0.011281305,
-0.0188453719,
0.0195403118,
0.0201080572,
0.027670363,
-0.0053409492,
-0.0693366602,
0.0418076254,
-0.017332295,
-0.005892097,
-6.597312168e-33,
0.0079699093,
0.0050293026,
-0.0426430665,
-0.0193612035,
0.0072124256,
-0.0227667112,
-0.0413745381,
0.0424663238,
-0.0325809047,
-0.0393029042,
-0.0053483853,
0.0000866953,
0.0014755575,
0.0211031046,
-0.0099818343,
-0.0313133672,
-0.0085205147,
0.014136794,
-0.0363239013,
0.009028797,
0.0380131043,
-0.0009658923,
0.0485403202,
-0.0477274284,
0.0157391429,
0.0230624732,
-0.0550512485,
0.0184661578,
-0.074086681,
0.0451163687,
0.0244314447,
0.0065439162,
-0.0093741193,
-0.0129834479,
0.0028827209,
0.0139803151,
-0.0085899802,
0.0009141687,
0.0379797369,
-0.0380048007,
-0.0121409921,
-0.068988055,
0.050435055,
0.0005541854,
-0.0005580897,
-0.0509805791,
-0.0113600912,
-0.0113469558,
-0.0281046908,
-0.0119265392,
-0.0439595506,
0.0067724953,
-0.016983375,
-0.0169885196,
-0.0216573142,
-0.029595634,
-0.004338827,
-0.0116251921,
-0.0377669595,
0.0113260578,
0.0423980318,
0.0632736534,
0.0577247404,
0.0251671784,
-0.0028206855,
0.0731489956,
-0.016106626,
0.018639883,
0.0232678168,
-0.0240289681,
0.0336178765,
0.056833975,
0.0360804275,
0.0355810076,
0.0322283879,
-0.0130243739,
-0.0841533393,
-0.0096988613,
0.0015973442,
0.0457017459,
0.0472066589,
0.0300203431,
-0.0452080891,
-0.0154926423,
-0.0424778238,
0.0004304419,
-0.0327433757,
-0.0330096036,
0.0067855986,
0.0012403501,
-0.0525815934,
-0.0003946294,
0.0139324125,
-0.0280187037,
0.0110758292,
0.0331915319,
-0.0020270366,
-0.0046020397,
-0.0143359248,
0.0131924329,
-0.0026970934,
-0.0345258005,
-0.0128924996,
-0.0421838798,
0.0365180187,
-0.0106411669,
0.0469694175,
0.0607918464,
-0.0460421816,
0.0036131593,
-0.0189901721,
0.0240163412,
0.0348547585,
0.0542268902,
0.0290036853,
-0.0328718759,
-0.0099252043,
0.0059034587,
0.0496877171,
0.0458608679,
-0.0329146944,
0.0517546944,
-0.0273635127,
0.0298098288,
0.0273660924,
-0.0008986691,
-0.0067404751,
0.0631134808,
0.047692325,
-0.074626483,
-0.0194268543,
0.0157965906,
2.918e-7,
0.0407058783,
0.0280968584,
0.0229169205,
0.0199187081,
0.034854345,
0.0613817982,
-0.0442726612,
0.0532500632,
-0.0305663589,
-0.0272886474,
-0.0058495402,
-0.0025495871,
0.0642285645,
0.0367165133,
-0.0138820205,
0.0432344154,
-0.1053605154,
0.0116115417,
-0.0353725255,
-0.0508182123,
0.0171128344,
0.0827540606,
-0.0009910378,
-0.0028553267,
0.004569747,
-0.0755645037,
0.0255319979,
-0.0239761397,
0.0182209834,
-0.0122088408,
-0.0155001003,
0.0144483661,
-0.0120032877,
0.0007453623,
-0.0112817893,
0.0091589289,
-0.0540779047,
0.0873509571,
-0.0157441311,
-0.0067446679,
-0.0123027284,
-0.0318907015,
-0.0256558172,
-0.0364775434,
0.0419289358,
-0.0258824416,
-0.042235028,
-0.0033621022,
0.02246801,
-0.0066772024,
0.0237133596,
-0.03846021,
0.0023273439,
0.002480461,
-0.0104064504,
0.0196455549,
0.007458786,
-0.0364266336,
-0.0351141542,
0.0213741623,
-0.0286257658,
-0.0622466616,
-0.011218979,
0.0319215469,
0.0183547605,
-0.054102838,
-0.0064086989,
2.964996237e-34,
0.0105312327,
-0.0679815933,
0.0086552426,
-0.0066077132,
0.06297943,
-0.0111879576,
0.0006585104,
0.0169103965,
-0.0068289097,
-0.0274075791,
-0.05904302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05070v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05070v1 | A Roadmap to Pluralistic Alignment | 2024-02-07T18:21:17 | 2024-02-07T18:21:17 | Taylor Sorensen, Jared Moore, Jillian Fisher, Mitchell Gordon, Niloofar Mireshghallah, Christopher Michael Rytting, Andre Ye, Liwei Jiang, Ximing Lu, Nouha Dziri, Tim Althoff, Yejin Choi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | With increased power and prevalence of AI systems, it is ever more critical
that AI systems are designed to serve all, i.e., people with diverse values and
perspectives. However, aligning models to serve pluralistic human values
remains an open research question. In this piece, we propose a roadmap to
pluralistic alignment, specifically using language models as a test bed. We
identify and formalize three possible ways to define and operationalize
pluralism in AI systems: 1) Overton pluralistic models that present a spectrum
of reasonable responses; 2) Steerably pluralistic models that can steer to
reflect certain perspectives; and 3) Distributionally pluralistic models that
are well-calibrated to a given population in distribution. We also propose and
formalize three possible classes of pluralistic benchmarks: 1) Multi-objective
benchmarks, 2) Trade-off steerable benchmarks, which incentivize models to
steer to arbitrary trade-offs, and 3) Jury-pluralistic benchmarks which
explicitly model diverse human ratings. We use this framework to argue that
current alignment techniques may be fundamentally limited for pluralistic AI;
indeed, we highlight empirical evidence, both from our own experiments and from
other work, that standard alignment procedures might reduce distributional
pluralism in models, motivating the need for further research on pluralistic
alignment. | [
0.0056905616,
0.0748222172,
-0.035643667,
0.0197366495,
-0.0352103785,
-0.0211364813,
0.0076625007,
-0.0420712084,
-0.0305757597,
-0.0037324461,
-0.0365476459,
-0.0453377739,
0.0050899773,
0.0009765402,
-0.0230751764,
-0.0563693196,
0.0654520467,
0.0323400758,
0.0582747534,
-0.0387148485,
0.0326483548,
0.0265230555,
0.0049121231,
0.0469401889,
-0.0278671309,
0.0131265866,
0.0035712665,
-0.0018440731,
0.0677885115,
0.0347680189,
0.0118579129,
0.0430352278,
0.0002178172,
0.0335298255,
0.0000018365,
-0.0561211407,
0.0066877031,
0.0002073404,
-0.0062167533,
-0.037751276,
0.0233856365,
0.0101783751,
0.0005531576,
0.0051931296,
-0.0386495143,
0.0495928191,
0.0483400784,
0.0071028853,
0.046807602,
0.0399919301,
0.0115385316,
-0.0145504102,
0.0024694647,
0.0095897969,
-0.0390599258,
-0.0172109026,
-0.0125762094,
0.0056181685,
-0.0286826119,
-0.012805135,
-0.0056168893,
0.0181048475,
0.0100240093,
0.0067435005,
0.0356439278,
-0.0047683516,
-0.0407063439,
-0.0631447583,
0.0072118719,
0.0808396339,
0.0454827994,
-0.0010924443,
-0.0208230373,
-0.0218560658,
0.031339094,
-0.0145831862,
-0.0052582072,
0.0254915953,
-0.0163120218,
0.0225843415,
0.0211092811,
0.0230525415,
0.0194117092,
0.019934684,
-0.0224574469,
0.092952311,
-0.0063033509,
-0.0234771743,
-0.0035739809,
0.0232064128,
0.0010173577,
-0.026240427,
-0.0036600414,
0.0315590911,
-0.062100973,
0.0217731036,
-0.0533288643,
-0.0072072395,
0.0314655527,
-0.0240363218,
0.0301507171,
0.0680863038,
0.0200847276,
0.0290409811,
0.04869809,
0.0267407987,
0.0028074149,
0.027230151,
-0.0449004732,
-0.0246507656,
-0.0187576599,
-0.0126840984,
0.0211699177,
0.0085887937,
-0.0160111226,
0.0285857748,
-0.0252371207,
0.0142591968,
-0.0802542567,
0.0262809824,
-0.000363418,
-0.0078386692,
-0.0126852766,
-0.0134348674,
-0.031326104,
0.0836192816,
-0.1029395312,
0.0281980634,
0.0115751196,
-0.0529392436,
0.0087609887,
0.0037478316,
-0.0247265175,
-0.0350556895,
-0.0000104194,
0.0143129686,
0.0103458846,
0.0151269296,
0.0043826737,
-0.0320729762,
-0.0010673283,
-0.0603238344,
-0.0195504613,
-0.0537314415,
0.0745785385,
0.0199911315,
-0.0059437715,
-0.0618332662,
-0.0090990551,
-0.0024460352,
-0.0140485419,
0.059881445,
0.0135454722,
0.0328462832,
0.0360289291,
0.0056483634,
-0.0050724167,
0.0669990927,
0.0317339189,
0.0039639706,
0.0445815176,
-0.0163570791,
0.0241797306,
0.0180809814,
-0.019721251,
0.009029693,
-0.0248933062,
0.0273601953,
-0.0188092608,
0.0384323038,
0.0405544899,
0.0875918344,
0.0070446669,
-0.0496462025,
0.067090705,
0.0650919229,
-0.0071455962,
0.0117769009,
0.0224351343,
-0.0205520242,
-0.0080020949,
0.014262178,
-0.0610756464,
0.0332449526,
-0.0354425311,
0.0048812404,
0.0117725153,
0.035556864,
-0.0331674889,
-0.0564858131,
-0.0186027344,
-0.0011976471,
0.0595680512,
-0.0028229787,
0.0066202795,
-0.0659509897,
0.0075136791,
-0.0324370377,
0.0120406765,
-0.0855028406,
-0.0032348006,
-0.0613550618,
0.0461377427,
0.044234585,
0.0071028881,
-0.028279921,
-0.0425322875,
-0.008823094,
-0.0562592,
0.0370504074,
0.105879344,
-0.0255647916,
-0.0010921508,
-0.0477082804,
-0.0300156809,
0.011176141,
-0.0002224954,
0.0581823885,
0.0057195225,
-0.0083075231,
-0.0392251275,
-0.0160459541,
-0.0317049623,
0.0373446345,
0.0047796387,
0.0302285869,
-0.0413051024,
0.0161493402,
0.0543752462,
0.0331670828,
-0.0035388425,
0.0163867865,
-0.012352067,
0.0316903405,
-0.0226107016,
-0.0006039366,
-0.0520933419,
0.040829774,
0.0218410473,
-0.04830705,
-0.0125658149,
0.0363912247,
0.0138479704,
-0.0086604422,
0.0052075437,
-0.0022455005,
-0.057569284,
0.0094017796,
0.0341614857,
-0.0485078953,
-0.0074626128,
-0.0526336133,
0.0426222272,
-0.0194983706,
-0.0185701866,
-0.0438140742,
-0.0498653203,
0.0286384486,
-0.0465112366,
-0.0625042096,
0.0111680664,
0.0052718678,
0.051588688,
0.0585001931,
-0.0461102836,
-0.0224743932,
-0.0141859232,
-0.097802192,
-0.0038573346,
-0.0204891935,
-0.0109507721,
-0.0091898562,
-0.015873706,
0.0062568625,
0.0314956792,
-0.0570597574,
0.0007101511,
0.0265278481,
0.0270777252,
0.0321587734,
-0.0247693993,
-0.0082013756,
-0.0460829437,
-0.0218738392,
-0.0542164706,
-0.0017280611,
0.0005679168,
0.0141429128,
-0.0532249175,
-0.026363384,
-0.0895849988,
0.0102024013,
-0.0240888316,
-0.0015656007,
0.0415104926,
0.0627788752,
0.0541245192,
0.0640829876,
0.0404574163,
0.0393383726,
0.0591876283,
0.0533492528,
-0.0572936945,
0.0043623275,
-0.0121704154,
-0.0028009911,
-0.0164492279,
-0.0745681897,
0.0231578071,
0.0594715774,
0.0129391868,
-0.0010438919,
-0.0933794454,
0.0524841622,
-0.0376144834,
-0.0779739097,
-0.0221673734,
-0.0369920172,
0.0030633332,
0.0427755378,
-0.0152007956,
-0.0437132865,
0.0867840424,
0.0251500104,
0.0406757928,
-0.013871829,
0.0017916777,
-0.0454222932,
0.0260418784,
-0.0267007351,
0.0293165315,
0.0281600412,
0.0241026301,
-0.0778326094,
-0.0123546096,
0.0410744473,
-0.0519765988,
0.1254765391,
-0.0109124137,
-0.0163992401,
-0.0305315945,
-0.0642637089,
-0.0318077765,
-0.0261974856,
-0.0034802624,
0.0456017181,
0.0572222285,
-0.0031678625,
-0.0767654553,
-0.0015282674,
0.0460203774,
-0.0297629107,
-0.0041196058,
0.0116793793,
0.0092320452,
-0.0528618284,
0.0389751643,
0.0524186902,
0.0538840294,
-0.0420843437,
-0.0037071595,
0.0182336047,
0.0258010142,
-0.0106790513,
0.0098121893,
-0.0506306179,
0.0458158478,
-0.0328355618,
-0.0080227898,
0.0033143989,
0.0974693969,
-0.0072429352,
0.032281138,
0.0855784565,
0.0138827637,
-0.0500200652,
-0.0043943278,
-0.0588328987,
0.0344513506,
0.0132617606,
0.0075410316,
-0.0638780594,
0.0257983487,
-0.0034161599,
0.0151184406,
-0.0524469018,
-0.0445349887,
-0.0044246358,
-0.0862994343,
-0.0094968509,
0.0431787334,
-0.0568757951,
-0.0205215737,
0.0192699544,
0.0157187097,
-0.043529585,
0.0551790334,
0.0088012265,
0.0416817479,
-0.0113115264,
0.0040576137,
0.0084203444,
-0.0142151499,
-0.0016456321,
-0.0700808093,
0.0903500393,
0.0344233289,
0.048394084,
-0.0260451157,
-0.0498952605,
-0.0372744687,
0.0060503567,
-0.0112395464,
0.0429765768,
-0.0064339838,
-0.0316986218,
0.014118935,
-0.0369336493,
0.0072771595,
0.0106752021,
-0.0087556876,
0.0171930026,
0.0107422741,
-0.0287094675,
-0.0404040925,
-0.0646823272,
-0.0014377875,
-0.008534532,
0.0912032053,
-0.0087063229,
-0.0619910173,
-0.0125892265,
-0.0378095098,
-0.0285916962,
0.0091841221,
-0.0561987422,
0.0220850054,
-0.0008814086,
-0.0290984102,
-0.0314688087,
-0.0737479702,
-0.0325643197,
0.0112207672,
0.0120865926,
-0.0646403357,
0.0394358858,
-0.0033144061,
0.0078082862,
0.0122506367,
-0.0212054309,
0.0210948493,
-0.0471258722,
-0.0047758124,
-0.0321093015,
-0.0433783717,
0.01197128,
-0.0304369032,
-0.0029462781,
-0.0606477,
0.0415864773,
0.0348371342,
0.0216111708,
0.0108930562,
0.0143164862,
-0.032746125,
0.0206426512,
0.0459382236,
0.0277774688,
0.0329177268,
0.0233570412,
0.0263558235,
-0.0164686833,
0.0229135137,
-0.0283647068,
0.0367670693,
0.0230701473,
0.0262617003,
-0.0357456319,
-0.0184741262,
0.0224100817,
0.0081840185,
-0.0152694182,
-0.0074653253,
-0.0243781377,
-0.012034622,
-0.0575815476,
-0.0227557961,
-0.0562997423,
0.0107646845,
-0.0554198846,
0.0276733115,
0.0014049556,
-0.0101973489,
0.0081725949,
0.0167381,
0.0214637443,
-0.0523523316,
0.0029421847,
0.0325970873,
0.0104184505,
-0.0185777284,
-0.0046571582,
-0.0429231152,
0.0445996262,
-0.0297692828,
0.0482552238,
0.0325480476,
0.0687474236,
0.033684466,
0.0133269485,
-0.0050621233,
0.030702645,
-0.0466773286,
-0.0336256549,
0.0065995264,
-0.0079401592,
-0.0022134171,
0.0262495242,
0.0163888838,
0.0071444232,
0.0004288124,
-0.0360032283,
0.007548742,
0.025418777,
0.0065719001,
0.0296513606,
0.0384220928,
-0.0051962342,
-0.0357086882,
0.0227174498,
-0.0647803769,
-0.0150119746,
-0.0402731113,
-0.0154216178,
-0.0281056259,
-0.0495742634,
-0.0229024198,
0.0001742622,
-0.0285276454,
-0.0258502197,
-0.0797548071,
-0.0202752221,
0.0064734379,
0.0458934978,
0.0107054915,
-0.0225736294,
0.0026850163,
0.0775413513,
-0.0429756083,
-0.0160541646,
-0.0237654168,
-0.0184629671,
-0.0709629208,
0.0319692045,
-0.0181689393,
-5.853344733e-33,
-0.0284828525,
0.0082290694,
0.0150112621,
-0.0421016179,
-0.0309128929,
-0.0294550844,
0.0229046028,
0.0644459873,
-0.0887043253,
0.0230840035,
0.0024099436,
0.0037155843,
-0.0013356344,
-0.0443689637,
0.0285079293,
-0.0335949734,
0.0285355523,
0.007280943,
-0.068855457,
-0.0459768735,
0.0028722195,
-0.0490754582,
0.0363252386,
-0.0663516,
0.070157066,
0.0116997352,
-0.0199488215,
0.0052086185,
-0.0218941793,
0.0569259301,
0.0234867707,
0.0816835463,
0.0468313992,
-0.0031222824,
0.0164368972,
0.0371198878,
0.0082653137,
-0.0299801752,
0.0359240137,
-0.0052204072,
-0.0197490249,
-0.0304053258,
0.0368252136,
0.0035729907,
-0.0671801865,
-0.0053132977,
0.0460461341,
-0.0041631144,
0.0367784463,
0.0132165784,
-0.0869668797,
-0.0059518884,
-0.0213012639,
0.0027718171,
-0.0342374071,
0.0417182483,
0.0207440443,
0.0397651307,
-0.0596858561,
0.0209255926,
-0.0183142759,
-0.0329617746,
0.0839024335,
0.0188246444,
-0.0120639233,
0.0446080156,
0.036002446,
0.0364681594,
-0.0710015669,
-0.0785612315,
0.0292010382,
0.0208830163,
0.0616427213,
0.0786800236,
-0.0179304834,
-0.0177462101,
-0.0081145745,
0.0259512737,
0.0311496668,
-0.0048442422,
0.0444947965,
0.0287745204,
-0.0898846388,
-0.0083709406,
-0.0246876534,
-0.0619142018,
-0.0419608876,
0.0021601345,
0.0053412444,
-0.0219485536,
-0.0135579007,
0.0102262255,
0.0418619402,
-0.0397865027,
0.0148813128,
0.0411197245,
-0.010769465,
0.0030397482,
0.0141087975,
0.0014007115,
-0.0251003448,
-0.0075273993,
-0.0149354404,
0.0208333246,
0.0236279964,
0.0267162248,
0.0187689885,
0.0029729151,
-0.0379105248,
-0.0257107653,
-0.0128287598,
0.0012566705,
0.0010964782,
-0.0085915076,
0.0685271993,
0.0288468227,
0.0092720501,
0.0279579405,
0.0157767031,
-0.0022289644,
-0.0539152063,
0.0003458502,
-0.0290487707,
-0.0109760975,
-0.0093712173,
-0.0025110694,
-0.002494205,
-0.0166159235,
0.019212842,
-0.0022047178,
-0.0302929971,
-0.0024586057,
2.409e-7,
0.0269196704,
0.0277419612,
-0.0077662291,
0.0011697134,
-0.0095069716,
0.0675831065,
0.007269735,
0.0477787033,
-0.0209128857,
-0.016490452,
0.0380076841,
0.0338098481,
0.020368062,
0.0397377089,
-0.0269143544,
-0.0121054128,
-0.0323288925,
0.0410954989,
-0.0312958024,
0.0651750043,
0.0405363552,
0.0460513085,
0.0355800614,
0.0279407017,
0.0053231302,
0.0445095338,
0.0400006585,
-0.0446347855,
0.0027792521,
0.0641361997,
0.0145299006,
-0.0324844941,
0.0273969993,
0.0212015864,
0.0535329767,
0.0391094387,
0.0220732111,
0.0940177366,
-0.0463589393,
-0.0254010074,
-0.0186812468,
0.0066278325,
-0.007120355,
-0.0629747957,
0.0371394902,
-0.0155500444,
-0.0626133531,
-0.067890659,
-0.0172279589,
0.0204125661,
0.0545398667,
0.0111369751,
0.0006107361,
0.0120851155,
0.0231176689,
0.0220306981,
-0.0114241987,
-0.049017407,
-0.0091222506,
-0.0204056092,
-0.0367836654,
-0.061864458,
0.0108857984,
0.0278467089,
0.0050895959,
-0.0457111336,
0.0162047334,
1.990998378e-34,
0.0122806253,
-0.0266498886,
0.0274403729,
-0.0033212174,
0.0324023888,
0.0140180849,
-0.0524625741,
-0.00120883,
0.0336159877,
-0.031031318,
-0.0061811255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05044v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05044v4 | SALAD-Bench: A Hierarchical and Comprehensive Safety Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T17:33:54 | 2024-06-07T12:05:46 | Lijun Li, Bowen Dong, Ruohui Wang, Xuhao Hu, Wangmeng Zuo, Dahua Lin, Yu Qiao, Jing Shao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | In the rapidly evolving landscape of Large Language Models (LLMs), ensuring
robust safety measures is paramount. To meet this crucial need, we propose
\emph{SALAD-Bench}, a safety benchmark specifically designed for evaluating
LLMs, attack, and defense methods. Distinguished by its breadth, SALAD-Bench
transcends conventional benchmarks through its large scale, rich diversity,
intricate taxonomy spanning three levels, and versatile
functionalities.SALAD-Bench is crafted with a meticulous array of questions,
from standard queries to complex ones enriched with attack, defense
modifications and multiple-choice. To effectively manage the inherent
complexity, we introduce an innovative evaluators: the LLM-based MD-Judge for
QA pairs with a particular focus on attack-enhanced queries, ensuring a
seamless, and reliable evaluation. Above components extend SALAD-Bench from
standard LLM safety evaluation to both LLM attack and defense methods
evaluation, ensuring the joint-purpose utility. Our extensive experiments shed
light on the resilience of LLMs against emerging threats and the efficacy of
contemporary defense tactics. Data and evaluator are released under
https://github.com/OpenSafetyLab/SALAD-BENCH. | [
-0.0017306182,
0.1036664173,
-0.0036310889,
0.0443492346,
-0.05712872,
-0.0203995928,
0.0011671368,
0.0062601026,
0.0042416984,
-0.0443093218,
0.0061408845,
-0.0400008708,
-0.0218978953,
0.0387494713,
0.0621943064,
0.0233222209,
0.0610028803,
-0.0757599697,
-0.0187486261,
0.0048644827,
0.0098636644,
-0.0280956328,
-0.0260034837,
0.0360543393,
0.0062569529,
0.0003282619,
-0.014925533,
-0.0027192787,
0.0271611232,
-0.0557215624,
0.0040909867,
0.0332290567,
-0.0262271278,
0.0340050459,
0.0000020282,
-0.0442524031,
-0.0278070793,
0.049475953,
-0.0404780023,
0.0591239631,
0.0112471022,
-0.0040528867,
-0.0319963954,
0.0404402651,
-0.0061950805,
-0.0273817815,
0.020628918,
0.020089956,
0.0757063329,
0.1027385667,
0.0095126852,
-0.023407748,
0.0336258188,
-0.0132559575,
-0.0361936688,
-0.0742368922,
0.0462810807,
-0.0018049261,
0.0399951637,
0.0261124261,
0.0209994353,
-0.0202362537,
-0.0050176634,
-0.0278042518,
-0.0805247799,
-0.0021918323,
-0.024574073,
0.0256031286,
0.006432469,
0.0367872864,
0.0057162233,
-0.0008747938,
-0.0058551352,
0.00204062,
-0.005251667,
-0.0003043764,
-0.0244142283,
0.0015783412,
0.0114122583,
-0.0196681172,
0.022089975,
0.0195437241,
0.0545762666,
0.000130484,
-0.0071352059,
0.0878938586,
0.0380051546,
-0.0127361109,
0.0085661402,
-0.0689122751,
-0.0206358843,
-0.0566039979,
-0.012967363,
0.0317443796,
-0.0395774916,
0.0145796454,
-0.04018379,
-0.0449133441,
0.0793416649,
-0.0596811175,
0.022069877,
0.0306555126,
-0.0030528358,
0.0296889469,
0.0274901297,
0.0651813522,
-0.0086291218,
0.0012108359,
0.0007457657,
0.0070037646,
-0.0077450951,
0.0034281674,
0.0048290193,
0.0305169504,
0.0264501274,
0.0186842307,
-0.0454996228,
0.0256666839,
-0.0414727852,
0.0489109717,
-0.011669849,
-0.0297184177,
0.017768627,
0.003033913,
0.0109055396,
-0.0267499816,
-0.0213366374,
-0.0020082665,
0.0116498582,
-0.1032287106,
-0.0165365804,
-0.0041865972,
-0.0371958725,
-0.0574953966,
-0.0013355905,
0.1205106527,
0.0251672119,
-0.0234260019,
-0.0370601676,
-0.0566538833,
-0.0288816132,
-0.016238464,
-0.0129385851,
-0.0705925748,
-0.0232487749,
-0.0124571566,
-0.008212762,
-0.0666590929,
0.0068589426,
0.0142697142,
-0.0137096243,
0.0482662208,
0.0277473908,
-0.0055162776,
-0.0178200938,
0.0333061591,
-0.0166808814,
0.0732606724,
0.0037704327,
0.0141092092,
0.0298307184,
0.0041800393,
0.0355328694,
0.0602895841,
-0.0270427987,
0.0526644178,
-0.0588389486,
0.0613575429,
0.0413578749,
-0.0190347303,
-0.048931133,
0.0830632299,
-0.0095177451,
-0.0525490306,
0.076816529,
0.0288502369,
-0.034111172,
0.0235141497,
0.0103743775,
0.0027657941,
0.0345313251,
-0.0292830188,
-0.0439867936,
-0.0267194919,
-0.0888886154,
-0.0186086483,
-0.0202927403,
0.0265202224,
-0.0098013803,
-0.0148086371,
-0.0402062163,
0.0087291421,
0.0000059556,
0.0045730323,
0.0118431384,
0.0023792773,
-0.0266340654,
0.0199720673,
-0.0058206692,
-0.0610677302,
-0.0119410139,
-0.0706667081,
-0.0359042548,
0.0298275482,
0.0650595054,
-0.0543021485,
-0.0642325431,
0.0094927652,
-0.0156962462,
0.0022488872,
0.0302997641,
0.005033799,
0.0149301188,
-0.0095298765,
-0.0106247943,
-0.0062018298,
0.0573485494,
-0.0006326314,
0.0313559137,
0.0108389771,
-0.0152069535,
-0.0381778404,
-0.0637430996,
0.0247051679,
0.0169235617,
-0.0370538421,
-0.0141945137,
-0.0132874213,
0.0347477756,
0.0066531468,
-0.0354538187,
0.0436190367,
0.0407514349,
0.0210535862,
-0.0074920291,
0.0001544949,
0.0305884965,
0.0337567702,
0.0425281227,
0.0055003082,
0.0139623778,
0.0513023138,
-0.0295895375,
-0.0184118636,
0.0464983173,
-0.0556499995,
-0.0354605913,
0.0040183566,
0.0304522756,
-0.0198246986,
0.0089453608,
-0.03100596,
0.0321309827,
-0.0163542815,
-0.0139343338,
-0.0476297922,
0.0129803419,
0.0246098954,
-0.0255657174,
-0.0772133619,
0.0228356663,
-0.0542832427,
0.045549456,
0.0107766651,
0.0249760076,
-0.0452686064,
-0.0211475417,
-0.0407302901,
0.0267150905,
-0.0219570845,
0.0523318313,
0.0250707101,
0.0007316555,
-0.0266913176,
0.0130518861,
-0.0078640282,
-0.0090250988,
-0.0254465993,
0.0330997966,
-0.0021612269,
0.006116481,
-0.0535630509,
-0.0346504338,
-0.0122352839,
-0.0247414466,
0.0832364336,
-0.0478928313,
0.0152870826,
0.0249223318,
0.0045837937,
-0.0301483516,
0.0267208908,
-0.0302163232,
-0.0640772209,
0.0250871219,
-0.0182813052,
0.0179956295,
0.0242458973,
0.0130326636,
0.0099769868,
0.0827910081,
-0.0226342194,
-0.0292371381,
-0.0166169424,
0.0225173924,
-0.0408266,
-0.0452522077,
-0.0349448323,
-0.0043744859,
0.0509520285,
0.0033114704,
-0.0220964886,
-0.0377245881,
-0.0037689339,
-0.017632626,
0.0001449436,
-0.0371330269,
-0.0417618267,
-0.0136474315,
0.0381940007,
0.0174309704,
-0.0322616734,
0.0640256852,
-0.0384747125,
0.0429632962,
-0.0476595908,
-0.0228701495,
-0.0172454882,
0.0552574657,
-0.0334694684,
0.0200046804,
0.0272450373,
-0.0244341251,
-0.0286532585,
-0.0509650186,
0.0234661475,
-0.0619995706,
0.0365672335,
-0.0490305126,
0.0189642794,
0.0027460344,
-0.0163596328,
-0.0588455722,
-0.0047710999,
-0.0563571416,
0.0075608282,
0.0270138308,
-0.0239458811,
-0.0156906638,
0.0054158987,
0.0232598353,
0.0118228626,
-0.0252225194,
0.0013818634,
-0.002660773,
0.0077911597,
0.0231320355,
-0.0483157039,
0.0202708635,
0.0000765642,
0.0624615625,
0.0959976986,
0.0595311113,
-0.0237752516,
-0.0390382744,
-0.0001723414,
0.0297788102,
-0.0444300547,
-0.0113023845,
0.0479110219,
0.0092594679,
-0.0586099923,
-0.0227245968,
0.0604971834,
0.0412291884,
0.0014736486,
0.0320012942,
-0.0151106659,
0.0169514474,
0.0319654383,
0.0503012612,
-0.0831404999,
-0.0024832888,
0.0126258293,
0.0311453268,
-0.0142604616,
-0.0395402312,
-0.0051902789,
-0.1112771258,
0.0233199876,
0.0028733581,
-0.0542856082,
0.0135104815,
-0.0440101251,
0.0065582362,
0.0023641638,
0.0447636656,
0.0433827043,
0.0074836616,
-0.0282972325,
0.0275082719,
-0.0199078731,
-0.0434563346,
0.0364307016,
-0.0532597564,
0.0390558131,
0.0414828211,
0.0107009318,
-0.026800096,
-0.0015251109,
0.0750627592,
-0.012055343,
-0.0199429318,
0.0079386914,
0.0295963325,
0.0336683951,
-0.0212874226,
0.0271583963,
0.0014392282,
0.0024707958,
-0.0190456752,
0.0462475866,
0.046839565,
-0.024990838,
0.0128965368,
-0.0428676307,
-0.006159123,
0.0011701657,
0.0526206754,
0.0294575486,
-0.0105444826,
-0.0349219888,
-0.052894406,
-0.0312589854,
-0.0631453693,
-0.0481503904,
0.034397278,
0.0179870836,
-0.0395521149,
-0.0469847135,
0.0031330164,
-0.0136188418,
0.0264837667,
0.0258582886,
-0.0080585657,
-0.0195007361,
0.026418373,
-0.0291934982,
-0.0212400239,
-0.0279356111,
0.0470947772,
-0.0543739982,
0.0733299851,
0.0193984583,
0.0129807424,
-0.0386381038,
0.0145498123,
-0.075424917,
-0.1001147553,
0.0198740121,
0.0617082343,
0.0256512817,
-0.0567326248,
-0.0563564561,
-0.0837635323,
0.0451319441,
0.0292368364,
-0.0200055856,
-0.0050025107,
0.0589035898,
-0.0711337551,
0.0185676366,
0.0231357552,
-0.0498188883,
-0.0056188111,
0.0110585373,
0.0267201625,
-0.0211919937,
-0.0217964109,
0.0160540864,
0.0703401566,
0.0150298858,
-0.0014310325,
0.0018760766,
0.0393375494,
0.0280884691,
-0.0598847456,
-0.0475675613,
0.0230646431,
0.021498492,
0.0220022891,
-0.0068390239,
0.001923885,
0.0202992111,
-0.010736892,
0.0399243273,
0.006173105,
0.0199657921,
0.0430498421,
0.0203845743,
0.0536769778,
-0.017093895,
-0.0097793918,
-0.0040738662,
-0.0012904229,
0.0473680981,
0.0021601766,
0.0137566179,
-0.0203003939,
-0.012911059,
-0.0159854405,
0.0355557986,
-0.0721205324,
-0.0520589948,
0.0273493025,
0.030568447,
0.0296337176,
0.0250494964,
0.0532678217,
-0.0139093697,
0.0066684615,
-0.0404728204,
-0.0278746169,
-0.0202305987,
-0.0427705497,
0.0452585854,
0.0272888523,
0.0182044916,
0.0497085713,
0.088705793,
0.0296084713,
0.050489407,
0.0469653532,
-0.0085869879,
-0.0275854077,
-0.0455879644,
0.0088739004,
0.0487076975,
-0.0489779636,
-0.0554128848,
-0.0906178355,
-0.0843636319,
-0.0003748234,
0.04171215,
0.0435546339,
0.0437690318,
0.0080525251,
0.0388126038,
0.0256524701,
0.0329184346,
-0.0705297068,
0.0140139237,
-0.0263155531,
-0.0387226492,
0.0385403633,
-6.148228878e-33,
0.030051481,
-0.0247559268,
0.014721348,
-0.0502818786,
-0.0062620784,
0.0060870741,
-0.0402572975,
0.0144863119,
-0.04079739,
-0.0134934802,
-0.0151424212,
0.0223659761,
0.0034142449,
0.0123170884,
-0.0307236407,
-0.0311876759,
-0.02279968,
0.0083335303,
-0.0162133761,
0.0180747099,
0.041610077,
-0.0268990435,
0.0188751388,
-0.048185762,
0.0319733806,
-0.003448206,
-0.0475145429,
0.0264162757,
-0.0625229627,
0.0626472384,
0.0065132333,
0.0278455596,
-0.0199342538,
-0.000790543,
0.0172514301,
-0.0332383513,
0.0000545342,
-0.0167628955,
-0.0015424353,
-0.033894252,
0.0129913259,
-0.0438267477,
0.0062378314,
0.0170587301,
-0.0212941542,
-0.0204663314,
-0.0208565928,
-0.022900546,
-0.0149440886,
-0.0145866135,
0.0120511148,
0.0269096009,
-0.0522272922,
0.0101907849,
-0.0151242642,
0.0121904016,
0.0463656411,
0.0253124982,
-0.0180752706,
0.0423124209,
0.0175495204,
0.0152180027,
0.0582494214,
0.0091126226,
-0.023602169,
0.0410761014,
-0.0448004715,
0.0025865545,
0.0491875969,
0.0002030105,
0.0147659369,
0.0627759397,
0.0826402828,
0.0721033514,
0.0253779553,
0.007243325,
-0.1103096008,
0.0517872535,
0.0329481475,
0.0613706447,
0.0198387746,
0.0017006826,
-0.0781192034,
-0.011533591,
-0.0352686644,
0.0160905756,
-0.0433541425,
-0.0026911432,
0.0115400897,
-0.0241223369,
-0.0547362715,
-0.0073324642,
0.0089289779,
-0.0294450969,
0.012582466,
0.0413083956,
-0.0477059968,
-0.0020027994,
-0.023046378,
0.0471748337,
0.0203844272,
-0.004230848,
0.0037744632,
-0.0391894393,
0.0156971999,
-0.0173151437,
0.0113072116,
0.0428013839,
-0.0634223297,
-0.0313282274,
-0.0162155665,
0.0414469466,
0.0071534403,
0.0122651421,
0.0205987655,
0.0086155226,
0.0167772286,
0.0074582119,
0.0619211532,
-0.0136972964,
-0.0324467048,
0.0350748822,
-0.010209891,
0.0090159997,
0.0162502564,
0.006762736,
-0.0057068504,
0.0480206758,
0.0362562202,
-0.0630928501,
-0.0140134161,
-0.0125205088,
2.841e-7,
0.0450414531,
0.0342320427,
0.0318820216,
0.0482956059,
0.0067742765,
0.0570625812,
-0.0404241085,
0.0628398582,
0.0010757798,
0.0033869946,
-0.0031226,
0.0029424056,
0.0410684273,
0.0643635616,
-0.0136494702,
-0.007614329,
-0.1026638672,
-0.0251160357,
-0.0712373108,
-0.029101612,
0.048834037,
0.0717637837,
0.0177431144,
-0.0145341782,
-0.0306149591,
-0.0599311069,
0.0136787146,
0.0036519852,
-0.0120221265,
0.025250392,
0.0418167301,
0.0363179334,
0.0321939439,
0.0474421829,
-0.0312550925,
0.0057835039,
-0.015997747,
0.0574348979,
0.0311097279,
-0.0133161731,
-0.0257827099,
-0.0583180301,
-0.0003812484,
-0.05983321,
0.0799831748,
0.0240071062,
-0.0253112204,
-0.0010129982,
-0.049034033,
-0.0245978404,
0.0233725682,
-0.0309121571,
-0.0198330823,
0.0111872125,
0.0025785659,
-0.0046536098,
0.0186217315,
-0.0304350946,
-0.0333741866,
0.0000395106,
-0.0085923905,
-0.057898622,
0.0094092786,
0.0235177614,
-0.0243616533,
-0.0118150478,
-0.0044603995,
2.938524655e-34,
0.009372782,
-0.0385202244,
0.0012803368,
-0.016143389,
0.0716158897,
0.0204001311,
-0.0276671201,
0.0146742743,
-0.0124857351,
-0.0530556329,
-0.0454484783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05034v1 | How BERT Speaks Shakespearean English? Evaluating Historical Bias in Contextual Language Models | 2024-02-07T17:07:53 | 2024-02-07T17:07:53 | Miriam Cuscito, Alfio Ferrara, Martin Ruskov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7; J.5 | In this paper, we explore the idea of analysing the historical bias of
contextual language models based on BERT by measuring their adequacy with
respect to Early Modern (EME) and Modern (ME) English. In our preliminary
experiments, we perform fill-in-the-blank tests with 60 masked sentences (20
EME-specific, 20 ME-specific and 20 generic) and three different models (i.e.,
BERT Base, MacBERTh, English HLM). We then rate the model predictions according
to a 5-point bipolar scale between the two language varieties and derive a
weighted score to measure the adequacy of each model to EME and ME varieties of
English. | [
0.020356359,
0.0376404524,
-0.0297260098,
0.0388518982,
-0.0717659593,
-0.017872436,
0.0216340255,
0.0127632348,
-0.0080959564,
-0.0770706758,
-0.011558881,
-0.0270711277,
0.0396379791,
-0.0340168253,
0.0198111497,
-0.0719436184,
0.0269794967,
0.0110586453,
0.0096351169,
0.0046098894,
0.0029392282,
-0.0164403841,
-0.0004046169,
0.035734944,
-0.0120050553,
0.0076827747,
-0.0084187863,
0.033519458,
0.0331796557,
-0.0064516482,
0.0141637679,
0.0526800454,
0.0071529774,
0.0368889086,
0.0000014979,
-0.0642478094,
0.0141413053,
-0.0277217086,
0.0273101572,
0.0335100368,
0.0187988151,
0.0653586313,
-0.0375852324,
0.0096664745,
-0.0242364947,
0.0636273324,
0.0244235788,
0.0103925522,
0.0066490821,
0.0472391732,
-0.0179395545,
-0.0560456924,
0.0135960085,
-0.0229510795,
0.0195160974,
-0.0199254323,
0.0463311337,
-0.0149296205,
-0.0020541844,
-0.030580217,
-0.0249220952,
0.0362697132,
-0.0075348685,
0.0174486618,
-0.0522388518,
0.0105951047,
-0.0520537458,
0.0334240422,
-0.0065881354,
0.0018590555,
0.0432734117,
-0.030608017,
0.0101206703,
0.0325772315,
0.0163517185,
0.0256114732,
0.0004664749,
-0.0077381013,
0.0065442063,
-0.0091059441,
0.0588297397,
-0.0146970237,
-0.0097291945,
0.0186079964,
-0.0269209798,
0.0555413067,
0.0467920452,
-0.0520628914,
-0.0061615128,
-0.0048747207,
-0.0318521969,
-0.0537392199,
0.0042591766,
0.0156238507,
0.0274629798,
0.0170041639,
0.0040602903,
-0.0183657911,
0.0054623629,
-0.0729476884,
-0.0269707087,
0.0169494376,
-0.0673319623,
0.0079732826,
-0.0129298689,
0.0670098141,
-0.0141305709,
-0.0057309642,
-0.0418475755,
-0.0007905014,
-0.0358087048,
0.0244346093,
-0.058964137,
0.0010656411,
-0.0351934247,
-0.0049174312,
-0.0461175367,
-0.0111892233,
0.0150962062,
-0.009331624,
0.0011771646,
0.001444615,
0.0036228413,
0.0256855581,
-0.015634805,
0.0247411821,
-0.038946081,
0.0361619107,
-0.0678573102,
-0.0734725669,
0.019141987,
0.0163280275,
0.0142537281,
-0.091334261,
0.0068564061,
0.0120667908,
0.007160272,
-0.0061858329,
-0.0342778787,
0.0131324399,
-0.0842552185,
-0.0299097672,
-0.0405807309,
-0.0218889099,
-0.0212723557,
-0.0085865743,
0.0299023613,
0.0160813797,
-0.0227953922,
0.0135546783,
-0.0478638299,
0.0187825896,
0.0250275154,
0.0269562695,
0.0147728333,
-0.0219577681,
0.0057696137,
0.025377037,
0.0655780211,
-0.0440329686,
0.0273078401,
-0.0037434669,
-0.0155652678,
0.0595507212,
0.0028470054,
-0.0140131349,
-0.0682192445,
-0.0189857222,
-0.0239455737,
0.0491626188,
-0.0007918421,
0.0620637052,
-0.0024651124,
0.0040098107,
0.0623993278,
0.0269499347,
0.0468915924,
-0.0148804216,
0.0477068536,
-0.0012812498,
0.0716557726,
0.0404128656,
-0.031268362,
-0.0698113814,
-0.0100535164,
0.0030592361,
-0.050387416,
-0.005360208,
-0.0010913337,
0.0104797985,
-0.0278670359,
0.0072973301,
-0.017739132,
-0.0122164758,
0.0258053876,
-0.0120903775,
-0.0302990209,
0.0593833774,
-0.0024072225,
-0.0730062053,
0.035198912,
-0.0376954824,
0.0064412896,
0.0669554844,
0.0227189604,
-0.0307289436,
0.0053314739,
0.0195043348,
-0.0277404245,
0.0359646641,
0.019852642,
-0.0366380811,
0.0539640822,
-0.0178363435,
0.0012182237,
-0.001623059,
0.0312016401,
-0.0148269832,
-0.0397597104,
0.0238463785,
-0.0261477567,
-0.0758780688,
0.0304526128,
0.0287635084,
-0.0529917851,
-0.0251866728,
-0.0449014567,
0.0098727178,
0.0243441798,
0.0425955281,
-0.0609337129,
0.0173718557,
0.0513259433,
-0.0269033015,
0.0303851794,
0.0727018341,
-0.0614164397,
-0.0523771532,
0.0321994126,
-0.0602331087,
0.0447823815,
0.0291916374,
0.0089803794,
-0.059115041,
0.022864271,
-0.060966026,
0.1342678964,
-0.0153793208,
0.0384666771,
-0.0599233322,
-0.0245576557,
-0.0473098494,
0.0654459149,
-0.0015227146,
0.0294971205,
0.0373041593,
0.0130887711,
0.0211098082,
-0.0564035848,
-0.0753129423,
-0.0389272012,
0.0122621106,
0.0171275772,
0.0721195862,
-0.0153391333,
-0.0381591544,
-0.0388247706,
-0.1452346891,
-0.0161347296,
-0.0388023593,
0.0178729352,
0.0523148999,
0.010062607,
-0.0407657735,
0.003293294,
-0.0219088383,
-0.0381756537,
-0.0227542929,
0.0250337776,
0.0199844539,
0.0130031789,
-0.0282412842,
-0.0459259599,
-0.0096072238,
-0.0331582949,
0.0628460348,
0.0130198579,
0.0156497303,
-0.0042619822,
-0.012173499,
-0.0008016409,
0.0233120993,
-0.0146962907,
-0.0079462267,
0.0085544726,
-0.013517431,
0.0569256134,
0.0193184484,
0.0102154966,
0.0255519412,
0.0155629031,
-0.0566867851,
-0.0408439189,
0.0025540376,
-0.0017708325,
-0.0321183279,
-0.0772543177,
-0.1012043953,
0.0239159111,
0.0737199709,
0.0260685477,
0.0245605689,
-0.0413769819,
0.0146780536,
0.0129762888,
-0.0266307145,
-0.0090263132,
-0.0303499252,
-0.0477690995,
0.0553074814,
-0.0059640706,
-0.0127000688,
0.0164025426,
-0.0443020575,
0.0190152321,
-0.0527055226,
0.0337807015,
-0.0265290905,
0.0438167453,
-0.0113261184,
0.0330151841,
0.0046905205,
-0.0613825135,
-0.0215629917,
-0.0192422401,
0.0473563299,
-0.0326020829,
0.0109455939,
-0.0331041515,
0.0112376958,
0.028369911,
-0.0129444636,
-0.0254673827,
-0.0549517311,
-0.0345868953,
0.0330428295,
0.0105916671,
-0.0259811971,
-0.0028838969,
0.0013528247,
-0.0179334395,
0.0303515531,
0.0057507437,
0.0148795685,
-0.0188505854,
0.0737864301,
-0.0031467262,
0.0275996793,
-0.0026693896,
0.0163740069,
0.0333716422,
-0.031545423,
0.0418967381,
0.045609083,
-0.0378631167,
-0.004975724,
0.0344904698,
-0.0482845902,
-0.0470115803,
0.0197089966,
0.0188283902,
-0.0172762629,
0.0000038896,
0.1296759397,
0.0281626824,
-0.0064711501,
0.007773458,
-0.0302897654,
0.0215810612,
-0.0133043611,
-0.0123591162,
-0.0578015298,
-0.0098008793,
0.0169282481,
0.011320252,
-0.0029231079,
-0.0389253013,
-0.0043417336,
-0.1398151815,
0.0088725267,
-0.0366801247,
-0.0112720123,
-0.0063793161,
-0.0085443789,
0.0191136356,
-0.0305276606,
0.0462468304,
0.0308667645,
-0.0122596901,
-0.0012609428,
0.0366830006,
-0.0092408396,
-0.0676529929,
0.017712608,
-0.0586788617,
0.0283385497,
0.0428534411,
0.0640365034,
-0.0713024959,
-0.0474073403,
0.0150900176,
-0.0620819516,
-0.0094091743,
-0.0069695483,
0.0543451607,
-0.0135527197,
-0.001967127,
-0.0356640741,
-0.0098448116,
0.0676794499,
-0.0174305215,
0.0331501886,
0.0343576111,
-0.0086833406,
-0.0073213582,
0.0148588847,
0.0287884437,
-0.0028175712,
0.1097188964,
0.0195569228,
-0.0620667674,
-0.0065978002,
-0.0001353674,
0.0344844349,
-0.0058649695,
-0.005042416,
0.0039605582,
-0.0125963949,
-0.0151748983,
-0.097644642,
-0.0146918762,
-0.0047278157,
0.041508846,
0.0770676732,
0.0124437474,
0.0072226198,
0.0019671873,
-0.0471405126,
0.0182584766,
0.034943372,
0.0377078131,
-0.0765454546,
0.0057578664,
0.0527657792,
-0.0454646349,
-0.0109173274,
-0.0193352494,
-0.0156044671,
-0.0583560504,
0.0550065935,
0.0109133096,
0.0319523551,
0.0585056096,
-0.0230836663,
-0.0417798758,
0.0518097244,
-0.0088731702,
0.0236530025,
0.0425345041,
0.0117150992,
0.024940446,
-0.0229171179,
0.0322260149,
-0.0467706583,
-0.0017962464,
-0.0052542128,
0.0589867048,
-0.0228291173,
-0.0275660902,
0.0191723388,
-0.0082012666,
0.0260386337,
-0.0456804633,
0.0190341808,
0.0077968487,
-0.016530009,
-0.0364112295,
-0.0076487982,
-0.0109034516,
-0.0064052925,
0.0084177647,
0.0224879701,
-0.0316470899,
0.0220352393,
-0.0664257854,
-0.0090286741,
-0.0760107636,
0.0531320944,
0.0179716181,
0.0357907079,
-0.0023323761,
0.0202556755,
-0.0025062936,
-0.0096175876,
-0.0187037643,
0.0793571845,
0.0133447284,
0.0092781931,
0.010466096,
-0.0360109285,
0.0111851124,
0.0194935855,
-0.0894397497,
0.0297163036,
-9.152e-7,
0.0094399322,
0.0325916149,
-0.0207082182,
0.0994144529,
-0.0197215993,
0.0101903602,
-0.0108021349,
0.0060922978,
0.0698295608,
-0.0106810341,
0.0219247919,
-0.0081464024,
-0.0145812323,
0.045411516,
0.0447765626,
-0.000689966,
0.0305821504,
-0.0008320127,
-0.0517533235,
-0.0276770182,
-0.0223798081,
0.0469731465,
-0.0236078221,
-0.0305323377,
-0.0101537872,
-0.0773683563,
-0.0536914021,
0.0515191741,
-0.0027560918,
0.0389083028,
-0.0364704579,
0.0058883359,
0.0377518311,
-0.0068381089,
-0.0168371238,
-0.046129629,
0.0539165735,
-0.0051587257,
-0.023904331,
-0.0520596616,
-5.229040418e-33,
-0.040350914,
0.0295477696,
-0.0266688447,
-0.0437269136,
-0.0104082013,
0.0283664111,
-0.0655673444,
-0.0071075829,
-0.0379800647,
0.0141126532,
-0.0118474774,
-0.0021377413,
0.0162495468,
-0.0053760558,
-0.0112059088,
-0.0174584296,
0.0302169882,
0.0252601635,
-0.0246459693,
-0.0241784528,
0.0494520031,
0.0325504802,
0.0637492239,
-0.0270990413,
0.0325362347,
-0.0226718057,
-0.04828218,
0.0600315481,
-0.0101910084,
0.0250831153,
-0.008317735,
0.023824716,
0.0174123198,
0.0225211959,
0.002197254,
0.043394547,
-0.0417242423,
-0.0143092796,
0.0631595254,
0.0429875888,
0.0251246542,
0.0143699562,
0.0129273748,
0.002234614,
-0.098846063,
0.0408289209,
0.0451312996,
0.0079035768,
0.0162347388,
-0.0229176525,
-0.0324598365,
0.0036599636,
-0.0263771284,
-0.0188255068,
0.0011483603,
0.0438275933,
0.0110060554,
-0.0106957387,
-0.0178253055,
0.0132269496,
0.0169655904,
-0.0205906704,
0.0218124706,
0.0330307521,
-0.0019887595,
0.0612620637,
0.0476283319,
0.0099550728,
-0.0063635833,
-0.0035693997,
0.0590584166,
0.0295192152,
0.0405375734,
0.0356301293,
-0.0022175151,
0.0328633003,
-0.0053659496,
-0.0089837732,
0.0866534337,
0.0341334268,
-0.007780184,
-0.0168721452,
-0.0246950202,
-0.0462455004,
-0.0450367741,
-0.0463001616,
0.0009686846,
0.0350906365,
0.0235013813,
-0.0304563213,
0.0281310175,
0.0021709925,
0.0366478041,
-0.0447182506,
-0.0337610692,
0.0138320141,
-0.047370635,
0.0353726372,
0.0044986196,
0.066557847,
-0.0257326923,
0.0100548649,
0.0610505678,
0.0470716767,
0.005627329,
-0.0041996147,
0.0103072589,
0.0243661273,
-0.0549189262,
-0.0101113115,
-0.0194990914,
-0.0124138603,
-0.0325433314,
-0.0246831626,
0.0330814905,
0.0130262179,
-0.0007711621,
-0.0040509365,
0.0449650176,
0.0014108027,
-0.014548447,
0.0029401956,
0.0198778417,
0.0337108858,
-0.0095109399,
-0.0110417409,
0.0076393345,
0.0793559849,
0.0410018675,
-0.0335296653,
-0.0112851039,
-0.0254911091,
2.379e-7,
0.0428850166,
-0.0044453382,
0.0477995537,
-0.032472875,
0.0322156772,
0.0222433861,
-0.0264814515,
0.0360038504,
0.0036877429,
0.0295515694,
0.0144359861,
-0.0515434369,
0.0500935763,
0.0119233271,
-0.0353528373,
-0.078014791,
-0.1102354228,
-0.0100348238,
-0.0405854434,
0.0784522742,
0.0260956436,
0.0518690385,
0.0233395938,
-0.0266262311,
0.0041229934,
-0.047491543,
0.0193693005,
-0.047719866,
-0.0047543412,
0.034867771,
-0.0067129252,
-0.0054577123,
0.0489800237,
0.0548133329,
-0.0017138608,
0.0480424315,
-0.0099264728,
0.0208089929,
-0.0140274996,
0.0059957649,
-0.0283731688,
-0.0123628182,
-0.0132072456,
-0.0452880152,
0.0506436266,
0.0441948585,
0.0046182405,
0.0119719272,
-0.0592886731,
0.0228921603,
0.0187274031,
-0.0240423698,
-0.0358455963,
0.0159465726,
0.035567563,
0.0042854599,
-0.0258036871,
-0.0498639308,
-0.0426657014,
0.0210241191,
-0.062774837,
-0.060750965,
0.03411768,
0.0086114407,
-0.0166087393,
-0.0882609561,
0.0257893186,
1.702399936e-34,
0.0354554951,
-0.0013266723,
0.0133414743,
0.0231988747,
0.0173279606,
0.0080953827,
0.0621889569,
0.0013244216,
0.0143644977,
-0.0426495783,
-0.0128230192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05000v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05000v1 | Pedagogical Alignment of Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T16:15:59 | 2024-02-07T16:15:59 | Shashank Sonkar, Kangqi Ni, Sapana Chaudhary, Richard G. Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce the novel concept of pedagogically aligned Large
Language Models (LLMs) that signifies a transformative shift in the application
of LLMs within educational contexts. Rather than providing direct responses to
user queries, pedagogically-aligned LLMs function as scaffolding tools,
breaking complex problems into manageable subproblems and guiding students
towards the final answer through constructive feedback and hints. The objective
is to equip learners with problem-solving strategies that deepen their
understanding and internalization of the subject matter. Previous research in
this field has primarily applied the supervised finetuning approach without
framing the objective as an alignment problem, hence not employing
reinforcement learning through human feedback (RLHF) methods. This study
reinterprets the narrative by viewing the task through the lens of alignment
and demonstrates how RLHF methods emerge naturally as a superior alternative
for aligning LLM behaviour. Building on this perspective, we propose a novel
approach for constructing a reward dataset specifically designed for the
pedagogical alignment of LLMs. We apply three state-of-the-art RLHF algorithms
and find that they outperform SFT significantly. Our qualitative analyses
across model differences and hyperparameter sensitivity further validate the
superiority of RLHF over SFT. Also, our study sheds light on the potential of
online feedback for enhancing the performance of pedagogically-aligned LLMs,
thus providing valuable insights for the advancement of these models in
educational settings. | [
0.0220238827,
0.0111817354,
-0.0295877717,
0.0096919592,
-0.0662766099,
0.0088884216,
-0.0154207451,
-0.054030817,
-0.0225642622,
-0.0104271034,
-0.0155888302,
-0.0212681666,
0.0063224379,
-0.0197126865,
0.0031365135,
-0.0661010295,
0.0271636657,
-0.0399680994,
-0.0061731236,
0.0021008293,
0.0141105391,
0.0008348979,
-0.040655572,
0.0333736017,
0.0328405462,
-0.0386293344,
-0.0222165175,
-0.0032936924,
0.0276771486,
-0.0220296159,
0.0361207202,
0.0478034839,
0.0443673022,
0.0735126138,
0.0000022204,
-0.0912895054,
-0.0166236069,
-0.0076664928,
-0.0253454987,
0.0403206646,
0.0147156622,
0.0247602146,
-0.0214512721,
-0.0004221022,
-0.0339114182,
0.0357093178,
0.071909517,
0.0309696309,
0.0562779047,
0.0491490513,
0.0258426107,
-0.0188099146,
0.0459207259,
0.0047466867,
0.0045745345,
-0.0135507751,
0.0304694623,
0.0456464365,
0.014082172,
-0.0114942128,
-0.0513839424,
0.0101288594,
0.0081708031,
-0.009864796,
0.0141582955,
0.0151586439,
-0.0218187273,
-0.0106447255,
-0.0041085402,
0.0594484769,
-0.01613429,
-0.0179921333,
-0.0037563706,
-0.0189264286,
0.0052936557,
0.0512061864,
-0.0680922866,
0.0190139748,
-0.0002013229,
0.0429000221,
0.0275525805,
-0.0504709519,
0.0125839952,
0.047576841,
0.0170572232,
0.0454809889,
0.0084538059,
-0.0471417569,
-0.0158445518,
0.0333955176,
-0.0276701171,
-0.0194417462,
-0.0198713467,
0.0521463342,
-0.0379364118,
0.0302496888,
-0.0280750785,
-0.0065419767,
0.0000117813,
-0.0256612562,
0.0487912446,
0.0440634154,
0.0267977715,
0.0344468802,
0.0052406294,
0.0766232684,
-0.024915332,
0.035312403,
-0.0331901163,
0.0412937328,
-0.0494155772,
-0.0203251205,
-0.0183100272,
0.027535772,
0.0228931699,
-0.006003086,
-0.0532691255,
0.0125559922,
-0.0378809273,
0.050137233,
-0.0172533393,
-0.0194888301,
-0.0264241956,
-0.0041903225,
-0.0374014378,
0.0754825845,
-0.0247726925,
0.0094702244,
-0.0085225329,
-0.0048705838,
-0.0054454445,
0.0077162432,
-0.026342243,
-0.0272013899,
0.0058976882,
0.0482106321,
-0.022783516,
-0.0113209458,
-0.0171842277,
-0.0366417691,
-0.0025173847,
-0.0546599664,
-0.0169899315,
-0.0955634564,
0.0127255442,
-0.0026005553,
-0.0308552589,
-0.0320772827,
-0.0050469697,
-0.0099936649,
0.0238556545,
0.0440362394,
-0.0098854937,
0.0267280936,
0.0609587245,
-0.0176110063,
0.0142247677,
0.0722907186,
0.0566744767,
0.0062630447,
0.0075830901,
-0.0624701381,
-0.0178070534,
0.033648923,
0.0071550128,
0.0296593457,
-0.0397430211,
0.0043809884,
0.0403096005,
0.0807535127,
0.0000233954,
0.0074805813,
-0.0099434033,
0.0537044033,
0.046956908,
0.0526550189,
0.0095739029,
-0.003866903,
-0.008714838,
0.0304868426,
0.0047599073,
0.0259391759,
-0.0463823751,
0.01799394,
-0.0308709554,
0.0242366623,
0.0154960211,
0.0209609345,
0.0044896826,
-0.0534472354,
-0.0218296107,
0.0227497239,
0.0075445333,
0.0539728403,
0.0781756416,
-0.0309678316,
-0.0193722956,
0.0120851845,
0.047195971,
-0.0093486654,
0.0323202796,
-0.0316017792,
0.0653409287,
0.0663188696,
0.0604332276,
-0.05307623,
-0.0748992115,
-0.0085308021,
0.0162244514,
0.043851912,
0.0458371304,
-0.0071797012,
-0.0764278397,
-0.0421621874,
-0.0435254686,
-0.0178282708,
-0.0127599109,
-0.0117455199,
0.0286716595,
-0.0157546643,
-0.0150758717,
0.0127251698,
-0.0867821947,
0.0237622093,
-0.064695321,
-0.0569539107,
-0.0573827326,
0.0175615996,
0.0102791069,
0.0040129405,
-0.0019387853,
0.0098608015,
0.0151553852,
0.0117771272,
0.0200300757,
-0.0535093173,
-0.0294462182,
0.0308563281,
0.073979415,
-0.0167239178,
-0.0154335191,
0.0193080697,
-0.0393397436,
-0.0153040048,
0.0238518137,
-0.0206975434,
0.0133230733,
-0.0029357665,
0.0408176593,
-0.046966102,
-0.0162562039,
-0.0698083192,
0.0216963943,
0.0432941169,
0.0462406576,
-0.007546484,
-0.0207105353,
0.0134759741,
-0.0121746538,
-0.020279035,
0.0111247124,
-0.0113382004,
0.0368214734,
0.0257652402,
0.0119795017,
-0.0660409927,
-0.033482112,
-0.0274621863,
0.0108910864,
0.0103814565,
0.0472262502,
0.010940671,
-0.0167757533,
-0.0379480869,
0.0111578107,
-0.0503304563,
-0.0260615405,
0.0058069858,
-0.0092521692,
0.0274618827,
0.001462375,
-0.0247058962,
-0.0790454224,
-0.0279964935,
-0.0558697321,
-0.0146569274,
0.0187602267,
0.0191653427,
-0.0734870434,
0.0288894195,
-0.0225830581,
0.0225987732,
-0.0023712486,
-0.0421572998,
0.0168006364,
-0.0165812671,
0.0418652147,
0.1111560389,
0.008283997,
0.0429479256,
0.0535622388,
-0.008347461,
-0.0899681821,
0.021554796,
-0.0437707566,
-0.064014934,
-0.0538552478,
-0.02884477,
-0.0213374402,
0.0793898553,
0.016278401,
-0.0122259315,
-0.0571637452,
0.057327237,
-0.0304142702,
0.0238258597,
-0.036212232,
-0.0293038562,
-0.0291706827,
0.01432666,
-0.027135225,
-0.058814235,
0.1110341027,
0.0015317277,
0.0327221416,
-0.0380764604,
0.0095327348,
-0.0304912273,
0.0204125382,
-0.0095599294,
0.0125283916,
-0.0072025773,
-0.017670881,
-0.0752326921,
-0.0229280572,
0.0726836622,
-0.0628418624,
0.0753450543,
-0.0320254155,
-0.0210764855,
-0.0355637968,
0.0004540623,
-0.0357303806,
-0.0130502228,
-0.0184981171,
-0.0128872562,
-0.0111802267,
-0.0202634502,
-0.0305198543,
-0.0154574364,
0.0545888953,
-0.0120229078,
-0.044941023,
-0.0022944754,
-0.0144699439,
-0.0103639485,
0.0731228963,
0.0202702545,
0.0146352956,
-0.060077168,
0.0626163706,
0.0001815837,
0.0493603796,
0.0109408805,
0.0014125424,
-0.00820057,
0.0670405105,
-0.0465473421,
0.0336563773,
0.0305925123,
0.0536433831,
-0.0673237443,
-0.0039188955,
0.1004733145,
0.049540747,
-0.0305924565,
-0.0076830103,
-0.0410275906,
0.046993535,
0.0166309718,
0.0350765996,
-0.0421268195,
-0.0156689789,
-0.0227122344,
0.0320691764,
0.0097573269,
-0.0143651254,
0.0082088327,
-0.1344709545,
0.0024264315,
0.0481453463,
-0.0297554117,
-0.008023724,
-0.0189092979,
0.0060027894,
-0.0030847867,
0.0145622818,
0.0238348022,
-0.012053133,
0.001602321,
0.0636602342,
0.0096511412,
-0.0333123282,
-0.0017141987,
-0.0421102867,
0.0464629531,
0.0640900061,
0.00088619,
-0.0311919935,
-0.0334610343,
0.0063008647,
0.0283970777,
-0.0312265959,
0.0189913083,
0.0010093489,
-0.0180009156,
0.0128305824,
-0.029747881,
0.0491259843,
0.0005669185,
-0.001197214,
0.0338255987,
0.1114618182,
0.0106042419,
0.0302611589,
-0.0236856826,
0.0111558735,
-0.0139520233,
0.0610703565,
0.005779909,
-0.0679337606,
0.0225307606,
-0.0207280423,
-0.0343534537,
0.0137202023,
-0.044130113,
0.0124285538,
-0.0135951322,
0.0436292402,
-0.0002160503,
-0.035808593,
0.0459844768,
0.0007255918,
0.0277021881,
0.01487308,
0.0151599022,
-0.0223852694,
-0.0370662734,
0.067339398,
-0.0245464109,
0.0232682303,
-0.0714942142,
-0.0005436577,
-0.0131647037,
-0.0740005076,
0.0025716352,
0.0080221454,
-0.0802291036,
-0.1006444171,
-0.029862389,
0.003910088,
0.0144314868,
0.0204095896,
0.0274894964,
-0.0497837849,
-0.0204565804,
0.0032073851,
-0.0232866872,
-0.0037712951,
-0.0285643078,
0.0071823751,
0.0036359255,
-0.0004740461,
-0.026050508,
-0.0238065235,
0.0459549539,
0.0446312279,
-0.0106532443,
-0.0370893478,
0.054166384,
0.0113638062,
0.0736966208,
-0.0307136513,
-0.0322727636,
-0.0378934592,
-0.0114956219,
-0.0006286317,
-0.0510925315,
0.0240197908,
-0.0499292649,
0.0488023907,
-0.0102350675,
0.0125523685,
0.0138273723,
0.0098478468,
0.0246903393,
-0.0406757966,
0.0384939201,
-0.0175016318,
-0.0200975854,
0.0378862135,
0.0266738813,
0.001114027,
0.0084920274,
-0.0015467848,
0.0509549454,
0.0203829277,
0.1037335619,
0.039783556,
0.0633273348,
0.0216560885,
-0.0159951225,
0.0024532874,
-0.0670682415,
-0.031429477,
-0.0148964459,
0.0352653228,
-0.0161071029,
0.0267368499,
-0.0310386736,
-0.0008330771,
-0.0099137584,
0.020783145,
-0.0575741343,
-0.0021740284,
0.0604641698,
0.0437998325,
0.008633255,
-0.0100977495,
0.0121166967,
-0.0183266308,
0.0118820807,
-0.0147754541,
0.0084835179,
-0.0071652276,
-0.0221243296,
0.0600840412,
0.0038613766,
-0.0091466671,
-0.0008589965,
-0.051481925,
-0.0332033411,
-0.0349645913,
0.0443857349,
-0.029481763,
-0.0354776718,
0.0447394438,
0.0320502184,
-0.0801025182,
-0.0177678112,
-0.0072310874,
0.0078588827,
-0.0216283835,
-0.0485898592,
-0.0389716998,
-6.204111512e-33,
-0.0466009565,
-0.0267620943,
0.0453448705,
0.0463216528,
-0.0682144687,
-0.0309332889,
-0.0148769859,
0.0460850373,
-0.0044229128,
-0.0064878226,
0.0184039157,
-0.0078983484,
-0.014015954,
0.0131160468,
0.0341959521,
-0.0146756489,
-0.0097675864,
0.0112249414,
-0.0331380405,
-0.0019120779,
0.0034076849,
-0.0175356474,
0.0800370276,
-0.038709227,
0.0463043675,
-0.0139633259,
-0.0083273984,
0.0285180528,
-0.0451122262,
0.055298008,
-0.0008167231,
0.0359542221,
-0.0006743902,
-0.026795432,
0.0120552033,
0.0345579572,
-0.0165768359,
-0.0416618921,
0.0542874597,
0.0152956722,
-0.0253172275,
-0.0634371936,
0.0510898456,
-0.0033467344,
-0.0592996106,
-0.0086744828,
0.0543022342,
-0.022903109,
-0.0189526994,
0.0161342975,
-0.0865618512,
0.0150237232,
-0.0502213053,
-0.0445595197,
0.0185997467,
0.0394362062,
0.0123520102,
0.0221824646,
-0.0341493376,
0.0534898229,
0.081538111,
0.0599297099,
0.116641812,
0.0566679575,
0.0050871172,
0.0237434916,
-0.0102161029,
-0.0085859383,
0.0031247216,
-0.0004713012,
0.053376887,
-0.0051807342,
0.0705494583,
0.0400714912,
0.0013375862,
0.0084090745,
-0.0375322662,
0.0182929933,
-0.0138316024,
0.0245046616,
0.0359294489,
-0.0085130855,
-0.063933216,
-0.015340128,
-0.0813478678,
0.0319666527,
-0.0068703173,
-0.0232245363,
0.0205271486,
-0.044396881,
0.0122044804,
-0.0337891281,
-0.0077039939,
-0.0288138241,
-0.0239858255,
0.0088436026,
-0.013767329,
0.032421235,
-0.0282193609,
0.0077260691,
-0.0596409626,
-0.0228290278,
-0.0347928256,
-0.0282942727,
0.0092546716,
0.0283360109,
0.0113037759,
0.0154542932,
-0.042822849,
0.0235934127,
-0.0370272808,
-0.0008407448,
0.0210648458,
-0.0202311408,
0.0585177764,
0.003998192,
-0.0052911099,
0.0590788648,
0.0320917554,
-0.0670062676,
-0.0105158724,
-0.0163660422,
-0.0291424803,
-0.0171104725,
0.0001438197,
0.0151034473,
-0.0247529261,
0.028730128,
0.0140923746,
-0.0500533953,
-0.008216613,
0.0212057065,
2.919e-7,
0.0140683278,
0.0593661666,
0.0333857723,
0.0087565063,
-0.0165210776,
0.043243289,
-0.0366141908,
-0.010313089,
0.0413272232,
-0.0242259745,
0.0237289593,
0.0354825035,
0.0604694299,
-0.0108629381,
-0.0433704071,
-0.0059371684,
-0.0532596335,
0.0263098069,
-0.0545723215,
0.038672965,
0.0406849571,
0.0381503589,
0.0348576978,
0.0170382317,
-0.0247401427,
-0.0020717853,
0.045228757,
-0.051146552,
-0.02618335,
0.0596018508,
-0.0288050566,
-0.0098971641,
-0.0193524901,
-0.0165171325,
0.0162801035,
0.0301881842,
-0.0211942215,
0.0446893089,
-0.0022639413,
0.0055618584,
-0.0250695087,
-0.0033381491,
-0.0087136598,
-0.0825253725,
0.0001898372,
-0.0765787363,
-0.0223784596,
0.0060459501,
0.0048846095,
-0.0448685326,
0.0300567336,
-0.0387351923,
0.0227100383,
0.004128641,
0.0227042343,
-0.007233839,
-0.008354146,
-0.0141429277,
-0.03494763,
0.0575272329,
-0.0342843197,
-0.0151909292,
-0.029952392,
0.0045257662,
-0.0075287344,
-0.0467614792,
0.014468289,
2.473872172e-34,
0.0204020943,
-0.0428406,
0.0501297936,
-0.0034126255,
0.0045564775,
0.0040949048,
-0.0335426517,
0.032851167,
0.0549599826,
-0.0650551543,
-0.0128049878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04978v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04978v2 | An Enhanced Prompt-Based LLM Reasoning Scheme via Knowledge Graph-Integrated Collaboration | 2024-02-07T15:56:17 | 2024-06-12T16:03:31 | Yihao Li, Ru Zhang, Jianyi Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional performance in a
multitude of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, they encounter challenges
in practical applications, including issues with hallucinations, inadequate
knowledge updating, and limited transparency in the reasoning process. To
overcome these limitations, this study innovatively proposes a collaborative
training-free reasoning scheme involving tight cooperation between Knowledge
Graph (KG) and LLMs. This scheme first involves using LLMs to iteratively
explore KG, selectively retrieving a task-relevant knowledge subgraph to
support reasoning. The LLMs are then guided to further combine inherent
implicit knowledge to reason on the subgraph while explicitly elucidating the
reasoning process. Through such a cooperative approach, our scheme achieves
more reliable knowledge-based reasoning and facilitates the tracing of the
reasoning results. Experimental results show that our scheme significantly
progressed across multiple datasets, notably achieving over a 10% improvement
on the QALD10 dataset compared to the best baseline and the fine-tuned
state-of-the-art (SOTA) work. Building on this success, this study hopes to
offer a valuable reference for future research in the fusion of KG and LLMs,
thereby enhancing LLMs' proficiency in solving complex issues. | [
0.0706526935,
0.0015071725,
0.0045985673,
0.064881824,
-0.1067729145,
0.0222786088,
0.0099369558,
-0.0031744854,
0.0743046701,
-0.0563141331,
-0.0053005554,
0.0064769103,
-0.0117843319,
0.0052724271,
0.0058824318,
-0.0174756646,
0.0349353962,
-0.049488645,
0.0127025535,
-0.0282892939,
-0.020414941,
0.0403680727,
-0.0439787917,
0.0155555541,
-0.0221014842,
-0.0165783204,
-0.0134815341,
-0.0098350979,
-0.004113181,
0.0024394628,
-0.0245728847,
0.035953965,
0.0312955081,
0.0106115956,
0.000002186,
-0.0637784526,
-0.0157402959,
-0.0019720371,
-0.0709935427,
-0.0286941007,
-0.017625818,
0.02329004,
0.0165166147,
0.0139014525,
-0.0544820689,
0.0288361982,
-0.0059531047,
0.0546711348,
0.0587942339,
0.0597267225,
0.0046522617,
-0.0468731932,
0.0023328464,
0.0069962651,
0.0244928915,
-0.0386456586,
0.0445503555,
0.0405188911,
0.0517247319,
-0.0240882281,
0.0008108305,
0.0542298034,
0.0270928107,
-0.0361111239,
0.0197736174,
0.0370462276,
-0.0307231974,
-0.0205136277,
-0.008232017,
0.0863182917,
0.004779418,
0.0064066374,
-0.016415881,
-0.0038708467,
-0.0108741559,
0.060087923,
-0.0339369699,
0.0251379572,
-0.0487816595,
0.0121674128,
-0.0061393562,
-0.0307713822,
0.0426382571,
0.0292220786,
-0.0368817709,
0.1314700991,
-0.0109715778,
-0.0303168297,
0.0563591011,
0.0096630296,
-0.0446071513,
-0.0405025072,
0.0248916186,
0.064006798,
-0.0306279343,
0.0453394614,
0.0238165278,
0.0156537909,
0.0138533236,
-0.042769935,
-0.0012624562,
0.0219200701,
0.0095549114,
0.075846754,
-0.0589697659,
0.0131885251,
0.0111074923,
0.0516307615,
-0.0151525941,
-0.0231440272,
-0.1096462309,
-0.0428278074,
-0.0174774956,
0.0421680845,
-0.025946239,
-0.0219390821,
-0.0105749918,
0.0512596965,
-0.0097972834,
0.0410739109,
0.062851131,
0.0490522385,
0.0579756685,
-0.045064345,
-0.0740672499,
0.0165636092,
0.0014497875,
0.0308481641,
-0.0002329377,
-0.0215839446,
-0.0089908913,
-0.0079919435,
-0.005622711,
-0.01084729,
-0.0046210489,
0.0527326204,
0.0195683278,
-0.0078188572,
-0.0462421998,
-0.0658114925,
-0.0253107119,
-0.0657457709,
0.0077484241,
-0.0630066469,
0.0397116318,
0.020097997,
-0.0096092662,
-0.0216321629,
0.0366211049,
-0.0033520106,
-0.0500091575,
0.1238413081,
-0.0454438701,
0.0209279992,
0.0208844189,
0.0374129899,
-0.0464009009,
0.0437568203,
0.0119375559,
0.01047571,
0.0171770956,
0.0217742603,
-0.0132356929,
-0.0061318562,
-0.0122564724,
-0.0202157106,
-0.0097705862,
-0.0013590712,
-0.0137831494,
0.032331571,
-0.009548693,
0.0312611721,
-0.0138823586,
-0.0050335201,
0.0452562347,
0.0476803072,
0.0270600431,
-0.0069561088,
0.0196474791,
0.0231535975,
0.0002614989,
-0.0132977748,
-0.0448314808,
0.0180797651,
-0.047647059,
0.0074396753,
-0.0002203532,
-0.0115726357,
-0.0012284194,
-0.0321217626,
-0.0284598134,
0.0139452033,
0.0301056094,
0.0438197143,
0.0527086295,
0.0068772621,
-0.0363769084,
0.0273962989,
0.0190012641,
-0.0148323914,
-0.0104645761,
-0.0434229113,
0.0377890579,
0.1009878963,
0.0679858178,
-0.0233444404,
-0.0284633413,
-0.0024458428,
-0.0144614363,
0.0268972851,
0.0100235045,
-0.0185768995,
-0.0276526958,
-0.0649682656,
-0.0585640483,
-0.0024729986,
-0.0175988115,
0.0070567699,
0.0144953942,
-0.0251679253,
0.0188858733,
-0.0201908033,
-0.0175236855,
0.0046178247,
-0.0299367085,
0.0020920553,
-0.0067291977,
0.0063283183,
0.0071702488,
0.0389490388,
0.0014225881,
0.0434871949,
0.0159269087,
-0.0231761802,
-0.0642862916,
0.0208906494,
-0.0441956408,
-0.088029705,
0.0404821523,
0.009893178,
-0.0139083639,
-0.0406803526,
-0.0425417721,
-0.0437371135,
-0.009286914,
-0.0029830418,
0.0361861847,
-0.0511125028,
0.0045327004,
0.0302212052,
-0.0501606129,
-0.0338103585,
0.0961952731,
0.0005192881,
-0.0059211655,
0.0192700326,
0.0234996956,
-0.0052658762,
-0.0016252361,
0.0107888458,
0.0276049171,
0.0356224254,
-0.0056128544,
-0.019812068,
-0.0320705585,
-0.0735388175,
0.0060750712,
-0.0894872397,
-0.0002403694,
0.0066421418,
0.0197302122,
-0.0114972219,
-0.0265448727,
-0.0089758588,
-0.0135421921,
-0.0229887012,
0.0180454794,
0.0325782783,
0.0096095335,
0.0149599882,
0.0098595163,
0.0035609966,
0.0140990363,
-0.001150289,
-0.0258254781,
0.0153421946,
0.0268637482,
-0.0275401119,
-0.0394804068,
0.0655908436,
-0.0603926443,
0.0153647261,
-0.0089474507,
0.0182016287,
0.0138230184,
-0.0230067261,
-0.0013332606,
0.0482209362,
-0.0138207804,
-0.017740339,
0.055594977,
-0.05056113,
-0.068472676,
0.0176027995,
-0.0184993632,
-0.0161705539,
-0.0188159831,
-0.0010223433,
-0.0314586423,
0.0320599452,
0.0253701676,
-0.0285027288,
-0.0480306484,
-0.0098804915,
0.0093707815,
0.0021377488,
-0.0458832085,
-0.039236065,
0.0092764581,
0.0197758693,
-0.0460185744,
-0.0340214632,
0.1071748585,
-0.0070606731,
0.0119084315,
-0.0279531609,
-0.0074382522,
-0.0488320626,
0.0679039285,
-0.0289880503,
-0.0047856839,
-0.0066005923,
-0.0260650497,
-0.0143161211,
-0.0254087262,
0.015988132,
-0.0294899587,
0.0334091932,
-0.0528522357,
0.0289294086,
0.0161182191,
0.0141369179,
-0.0541319251,
-0.0077638691,
-0.0515128113,
0.0345943607,
-0.0180439316,
0.0092241261,
0.0100130253,
0.0020518787,
0.020776106,
0.0017647598,
0.006465659,
-0.0201611463,
-0.0262010582,
0.0096221361,
0.0050960435,
0.0120812943,
0.019769609,
0.0001272326,
0.0570582077,
0.0603991561,
0.0333583243,
-0.0109573537,
0.0045157298,
0.006650554,
-0.0131514836,
-0.0376909748,
-0.0026868042,
-0.0100542801,
0.0408066176,
-0.083702594,
0.021572154,
0.1178219765,
0.061177928,
-0.0248964429,
-0.0262120534,
-0.0279475879,
-0.0023263905,
0.0455873385,
0.0190829225,
-0.0829635486,
-0.0446215309,
0.0156721119,
0.0178133249,
0.0007564705,
-0.075202778,
-0.0182781219,
-0.1108320877,
0.0343679562,
0.0176501088,
0.0340668261,
-0.0192266311,
-0.0548808761,
-0.0000646694,
0.0302462988,
-0.0098205898,
-0.0003946323,
0.0037511231,
-0.0112524871,
0.0333589725,
-0.0079807453,
-0.0180182178,
0.0322132073,
-0.025913192,
0.053159032,
0.025662113,
0.0261574704,
0.0404092558,
-0.0329255499,
0.0103957579,
0.0153628727,
0.0520188101,
-0.0392677002,
0.0132069215,
0.0027328099,
0.0156854391,
-0.0329693258,
0.007878921,
-0.0707991198,
-0.0259042885,
0.0092404243,
0.1110338941,
-0.0608502142,
-0.0202032998,
0.0019840065,
0.0357200578,
-0.0046107168,
0.071387738,
0.0131016634,
0.0490063243,
-0.0274067316,
-0.0149134453,
-0.0219046883,
-0.019392509,
-0.0296457298,
0.040234372,
-0.0003772221,
0.0384590328,
-0.0425015874,
-0.0104322657,
0.0779314339,
0.0307531897,
0.0102390898,
0.0415379629,
-0.0031517388,
-0.0040585855,
-0.0311918892,
0.0537726916,
-0.0521362461,
0.038126938,
-0.0247080103,
0.0112791881,
0.0189024303,
-0.026856605,
-0.0012511661,
0.0294506792,
-0.0400719307,
-0.0992062837,
-0.025547659,
0.012327224,
0.0217252858,
0.0643227249,
-0.0268086269,
-0.0427147262,
0.0606940575,
0.0431591049,
-0.0385681465,
-0.018029049,
-0.0064503253,
0.006517652,
-0.0042439573,
0.024926981,
-0.0286797918,
-0.0236524101,
0.0117453085,
0.0606203638,
-0.0529275239,
-0.0427253582,
0.0249231216,
0.0463269353,
0.0034482854,
0.0028790741,
-0.0018166549,
-0.0564449243,
0.0347036198,
-0.0148437982,
-0.0328628868,
-0.0290617608,
0.0106094563,
0.0138420183,
-0.0520661511,
0.0248460844,
-0.0150006441,
-0.0120695569,
0.0263112895,
-0.005787746,
0.0020555663,
0.0194702819,
-0.0151117453,
0.0279579069,
-0.0112286936,
0.0035152289,
0.0108485539,
0.017270593,
0.0201288927,
0.00143538,
0.08784464,
0.0196846612,
-0.0237077344,
-0.0463070199,
-0.0021026856,
-0.0397632085,
-0.1134257466,
0.0503144935,
0.0369082354,
0.0498678088,
0.0076121981,
-0.0095663033,
-0.0508629084,
0.0061036455,
0.0037151361,
0.0313060395,
0.0204593167,
-0.0254877862,
0.0636901855,
0.0396790691,
-0.0162047483,
0.0036781402,
0.0391652323,
-0.0298080165,
0.0479269661,
-0.0223059114,
-0.0593649484,
-0.0336152799,
-0.0512482151,
0.0255796798,
0.0369128697,
-0.0414217822,
0.0290464871,
-0.0424270555,
-0.0898655951,
-0.0059900982,
-0.0116155632,
-0.0262777228,
-0.000068382,
0.0347122103,
0.0410384983,
0.0216525327,
-0.0501402207,
-0.0328728259,
0.0158860311,
0.0057947934,
-0.0017988118,
0.0160441175,
-6.541955201e-33,
-0.0207650345,
-0.0641612634,
0.0434812158,
0.0004597502,
-0.0264213737,
-0.0118977996,
-0.023208674,
-0.0090630818,
-0.0177364796,
0.016291976,
-0.0221238565,
0.0134325475,
0.0167239644,
-0.0168349463,
0.0047416566,
-0.0202342123,
0.0018000575,
0.0096776485,
0.0149599584,
0.0025875603,
0.0549824722,
0.0326521024,
0.0457275771,
-0.0607026666,
0.0606413484,
0.0110916328,
-0.0044303029,
0.0680611655,
-0.05283935,
0.0255011693,
-0.0119411694,
0.0330857262,
0.0326237455,
-0.041802343,
-0.0041711414,
0.0140969204,
-0.0715067759,
-0.012306992,
0.0563579947,
0.0048698909,
-0.0461532921,
-0.0178814419,
0.048123803,
0.0202289186,
0.0403786041,
-0.0133738145,
0.0274091996,
-0.0327384733,
-0.0322197601,
0.0104263127,
-0.0072764261,
0.0263112336,
-0.0170292966,
-0.0231594555,
0.0401616804,
0.0083003528,
-0.0124709439,
-0.0153423119,
-0.0703792274,
0.0197233036,
-0.0002611633,
-0.0126105174,
0.0752221495,
-0.0176678468,
0.0166714434,
0.0430362225,
-0.0118768178,
-0.0161618907,
-0.0660296977,
-0.0116446605,
-0.0190680474,
0.0975726321,
0.0154548353,
-0.0255391784,
-0.0187811758,
0.0034943421,
-0.0706788003,
0.004647986,
0.0249390751,
0.0431956463,
0.0238087624,
0.0255876556,
-0.0462853312,
-0.0445395447,
-0.0377204195,
0.0326525196,
-0.0401752777,
-0.0323156044,
0.010205592,
0.0072887647,
-0.0073064929,
-0.0189126097,
-0.0165755209,
-0.0417602174,
0.0172514748,
0.0175408088,
0.0298741814,
-0.0033754052,
-0.0226554517,
0.020347232,
-0.0672378317,
-0.0039544785,
0.0180556905,
-0.0325115882,
0.0015794816,
0.0165777896,
0.0195093546,
0.0051816851,
-0.0304984245,
-0.0078878384,
-0.0748823062,
0.0189395528,
0.0151055492,
0.0013699565,
0.0444584899,
0.0373185277,
-0.0211163014,
0.0323245712,
0.0050948998,
0.0207586251,
0.0057631871,
0.0322115049,
-0.0222488567,
-0.0054672626,
-0.0168351475,
-0.0085307909,
0.0008724262,
-0.020626964,
0.0198302902,
-0.0090929214,
-0.0187568106,
0.0162763447,
3.032e-7,
0.0392460972,
0.0435580164,
-0.0060988883,
0.0418986268,
0.0087885056,
0.0225056913,
-0.0323547944,
-0.0337418467,
0.0408568718,
-0.0453768,
0.0205273312,
0.0708014742,
0.0135455774,
0.0551291332,
-0.0677573383,
-0.0120891286,
-0.0045817504,
-0.043535307,
-0.0711760446,
-0.006958982,
0.0762748048,
0.0112656849,
0.0382220075,
-0.0251333471,
-0.0085584363,
-0.0869241953,
0.0284332503,
-0.0029965842,
-0.0280204657,
0.0029414336,
0.0883598626,
-0.0047141858,
-0.000444904,
0.0879606605,
0.0099308649,
-0.0040924875,
-0.0163656212,
0.0454849564,
-0.0198635533,
-0.0514499918,
-0.0264595039,
-0.0502922311,
0.031103665,
-0.0484212339,
0.0994702652,
-0.0311644878,
-0.0336925685,
0.0235620122,
0.0172521826,
-0.0675161406,
0.0041042264,
0.0086455783,
0.0226642545,
0.0121891368,
0.0027373906,
-0.0127089247,
-0.0179975033,
-0.1063282937,
-0.0020633279,
-0.01098831,
-0.0558071956,
-0.0201695655,
-0.0093449634,
0.0201997086,
0.0243385322,
-0.0489108115,
0.0169216227,
2.932939221e-34,
-0.0041788034,
0.0382613726,
0.0001233454,
0.0493805073,
0.0461943075,
0.008889732,
-0.015041898,
0.0136617161,
0.0186012685,
-0.1048985049,
-0.0204671081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04967v1 | Text or Image? What is More Important in Cross-Domain Generalization Capabilities of Hate Meme Detection Models? | 2024-02-07T15:44:55 | 2024-02-07T15:44:55 | Piush Aggarwal, Jawar Mehrabanian, Weigang Huang, Özge Alacam, Torsten Zesch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | This paper delves into the formidable challenge of cross-domain
generalization in multimodal hate meme detection, presenting compelling
findings. We provide enough pieces of evidence supporting the hypothesis that
only the textual component of hateful memes enables the existing multimodal
classifier to generalize across different domains, while the image component
proves highly sensitive to a specific training dataset. The evidence includes
demonstrations showing that hate-text classifiers perform similarly to
hate-meme classifiers in a zero-shot setting. Simultaneously, the introduction
of captions generated from images of memes to the hate-meme classifier worsens
performance by an average F1 of 0.02. Through blackbox explanations, we
identify a substantial contribution of the text modality (average of 83%),
which diminishes with the introduction of meme's image captions (52%).
Additionally, our evaluation on a newly created confounder dataset reveals
higher performance on text confounders as compared to image confounders with an
average $\Delta$F1 of 0.18. | [
0.0364253782,
0.0458347574,
-0.0504814684,
0.0236865543,
0.0084455591,
0.0660854056,
0.0481362045,
0.0485610813,
0.0020631461,
-0.0886043906,
-0.0171581637,
-0.0263881404,
-0.03369423,
0.0386922956,
0.0280264504,
-0.0726743564,
0.0036793381,
0.0516308472,
-0.0013117598,
-0.0414641835,
0.0585000329,
-0.0026268067,
0.0088199554,
0.0271166954,
-0.0853622928,
0.0009217081,
0.040978238,
0.0235899352,
0.0209392048,
-0.0061464608,
0.0275473893,
0.0114701074,
0.0296611581,
0.0263200868,
0.0000020096,
-0.0323565304,
0.0084530497,
-0.0248542503,
0.0223123357,
-0.0283159576,
0.0812914148,
-0.0618069954,
0.019856384,
0.0197879225,
0.0009272128,
0.0146784429,
0.0814594477,
0.0806966573,
0.0415772833,
0.072396256,
-0.0268526729,
-0.0488058254,
-0.0169492085,
-0.0077728322,
0.0412580483,
0.0072675995,
-0.0084935529,
-0.0342331231,
-0.07027895,
0.006414989,
-0.0345754512,
0.0140011022,
0.0124338949,
0.050798662,
-0.0007579784,
-0.0055065299,
-0.0275776833,
-0.0431277901,
0.0058133211,
0.0436653234,
0.0020157024,
0.0030272475,
0.002008453,
0.0078849448,
0.0203059725,
-0.0084549198,
-0.050903853,
0.0026276615,
-0.0089134621,
0.0107920896,
-0.0443622023,
-0.004614091,
0.047501225,
0.0315142125,
-0.0063086967,
-0.0024411869,
0.0002734618,
-0.0036391502,
0.0129895788,
0.0250797402,
-0.068867363,
0.0134414267,
0.0199328344,
-0.0066974149,
0.0286969524,
0.001577966,
-0.0866049156,
-0.0664271191,
0.0036295,
-0.0620377325,
0.020111898,
-0.0086432742,
-0.0546419546,
0.0176057015,
0.0071779923,
0.0294045452,
-0.0204764921,
0.0250580981,
-0.0075635798,
-0.004451416,
-0.0319263674,
-0.0132451579,
0.0454738587,
0.0089627793,
0.0200390574,
0.0026857348,
-0.0675723404,
0.0093760761,
-0.0279916953,
-0.0287239961,
-0.0406002253,
0.01002461,
0.0171308015,
-0.0003742358,
-0.033394672,
0.0206559002,
-0.0276753157,
0.0242240261,
-0.0290843509,
-0.0707285181,
0.0006800773,
0.0328298174,
0.0143206818,
-0.0186492037,
0.0466178656,
0.1060848981,
0.0441341139,
-0.024065258,
-0.026616741,
-0.0356703959,
-0.0519853048,
-0.0480978303,
0.076698035,
-0.0350739881,
0.0068901619,
0.0011895354,
0.012428158,
-0.0418556817,
-0.018161254,
0.0036140888,
-0.0400023907,
0.0682549924,
0.023462167,
-0.0360337943,
0.0183008276,
0.0420787521,
-0.0240452476,
0.0664117858,
-0.023652235,
0.039459575,
0.0666082725,
-0.0292806886,
-0.0196601972,
0.0484070666,
0.0532731265,
0.0056374534,
-0.0332645178,
0.0169078074,
-0.0249217004,
-0.0257309861,
0.0223712455,
0.0069755726,
-0.0265225768,
-0.0400260761,
0.0564054288,
0.0306607969,
-0.0423433781,
0.0297722705,
0.0266204905,
0.0069576432,
-0.0084453505,
-0.0046324111,
-0.0638196021,
0.0041032704,
-0.0384696461,
-0.0357797854,
0.0289584827,
0.0480126403,
-0.0458824337,
-0.0399233475,
-0.0271054246,
-0.0447584763,
0.0232954342,
-0.0465320423,
0.0449695364,
0.0179357938,
-0.0309532154,
0.0134987812,
0.0418049842,
-0.0280650407,
-0.013231311,
-0.0196201745,
0.0078775985,
0.029791249,
0.0129395192,
-0.0053048651,
0.0025155728,
-0.0326100066,
0.0046622232,
0.0237954408,
-0.0145212784,
0.0259639677,
0.0119976606,
-0.0311315916,
-0.0211720075,
-0.0325100571,
0.0212553274,
0.0420308001,
0.035466861,
0.0473526679,
0.0154307252,
0.0267157555,
-0.0113365939,
0.0094566979,
0.0527345575,
-0.0253860168,
-0.0144642899,
0.0470580943,
0.0427403115,
0.0091009857,
-0.0292576887,
-0.0533400625,
-0.0070595308,
-0.0249268543,
-0.0547333919,
0.032735642,
-0.0435490757,
-0.0089359302,
0.0251571033,
-0.0953452736,
-0.0002945115,
0.0901322067,
0.0180665441,
0.0395634957,
0.0975289494,
-0.0214654692,
0.0144273266,
-0.0014729244,
-0.0329999737,
-0.0472748876,
0.0354195312,
0.0193398409,
0.0437271819,
-0.0187428277,
-0.0278138891,
0.0054740561,
-0.0468804985,
0.0449585952,
0.0645674169,
-0.0554501154,
-0.0371808149,
-0.0274390578,
0.0021009101,
-0.0313870534,
-0.0129232835,
-0.0384624898,
0.0293392856,
-0.0924877003,
-0.0275826287,
-0.0397264734,
-0.0425111949,
0.0105751585,
-0.0321964957,
0.002579479,
-0.0092524802,
-0.0312730856,
0.0123186093,
0.0206466466,
0.0447985977,
-0.0125653967,
-0.0256807841,
-0.0057373806,
-0.0381648317,
-0.0052809422,
0.0033096008,
0.0515235737,
0.0137497187,
-0.0172579642,
0.0250468031,
0.0193198808,
-0.0318905041,
0.0047701388,
-0.0244048424,
-0.0280478243,
0.0225885008,
0.0279252827,
-0.020020159,
0.0539000072,
0.016193429,
0.0969091058,
-0.0153318765,
0.0342517458,
-0.0199919082,
-0.0102710743,
0.004819653,
0.0178541094,
-0.0372122861,
-0.069112353,
-0.0070843804,
0.0756789893,
-0.0050202701,
0.0104166502,
-0.0552976951,
0.0594132021,
-0.0341973528,
-0.0483392403,
-0.0378873833,
-0.0275050327,
0.0398229323,
-0.0077139195,
-0.0293428339,
-0.0870954394,
0.039959982,
-0.0100955358,
-0.0075936625,
0.0159126893,
-0.0102893747,
0.0045326832,
0.0815282613,
0.0185084157,
0.033413399,
0.0363298878,
0.0162600875,
0.0241447482,
-0.0395460315,
0.0301025826,
-0.000537595,
-0.0100471228,
-0.0026101191,
-0.0237380266,
0.004945673,
-0.0422080755,
-0.0355459787,
-0.0605670512,
-0.0279122647,
-0.0630393624,
0.0167706329,
-0.0143477526,
-0.0193126202,
0.0001127395,
0.0151431933,
-0.0636161938,
-0.0081263119,
-0.0165719669,
0.0498923995,
0.0043905634,
0.0255408026,
-0.0307021681,
0.0156289339,
-0.0292237923,
-0.0478613414,
0.0443401448,
-0.0148152374,
-0.0123688439,
-0.0353611782,
0.0088714575,
0.0111794127,
0.0767631978,
-0.0387638621,
-0.0459441617,
0.0448336154,
0.0048354659,
0.0332437754,
0.0720056593,
-0.014694416,
-0.0133674908,
-0.0014971892,
0.0407235101,
0.0027467639,
0.0095951948,
-0.0366706625,
-0.036579188,
-0.054108724,
-0.0482953452,
0.0027648658,
-0.0468421802,
0.0185512006,
-0.0024377031,
-0.0673479736,
0.0143584581,
0.0054828813,
-0.0260971878,
-0.0128412833,
0.0206531864,
-0.015564872,
-0.018474929,
0.0070513026,
-0.0496593677,
0.0222805161,
0.0067652478,
0.0014244714,
-0.0097298669,
-0.023684863,
-0.0389274396,
-0.0493551157,
-0.0036762301,
0.0522048213,
0.0287253372,
-0.017057782,
-0.0430659801,
0.0434080586,
0.0189300962,
0.0133164842,
-0.0699829981,
0.1062517539,
-0.0203305539,
-0.0386441126,
-0.0198855195,
0.0119788367,
-0.0261109043,
0.0369007215,
-0.0046354197,
0.0349818282,
0.0097540002,
-0.0032813423,
-0.0828517601,
0.0164316911,
-0.0196055025,
0.0433201939,
0.0135738561,
-0.0644742996,
-0.0012066783,
-0.0358737186,
-0.0138209583,
-0.0465098545,
-0.0680937544,
-0.034222126,
-0.0337294862,
-0.0219050776,
-0.022186147,
-0.0278141554,
0.0027679508,
0.0522340015,
0.0285392776,
-0.0273453537,
-0.0865210444,
-0.0093639176,
-0.0418735482,
0.0462548882,
-0.0026704441,
0.0115291346,
0.0108835883,
-0.0285482425,
0.0073258453,
-0.0345000997,
-0.0163083766,
0.0243376363,
-0.0682874024,
-0.0426337607,
0.0055921706,
0.0642597973,
0.017236704,
0.0347261392,
0.037730325,
-0.0314136222,
0.0647071674,
0.0481415763,
0.0198545121,
0.022264462,
0.0687267557,
-0.0171902757,
0.0247993711,
0.0205597002,
-0.0144782951,
0.0415815972,
0.0556057096,
-0.0956085026,
-0.0338317752,
0.031221183,
-0.0301844161,
-0.0273859948,
0.0486676916,
-0.0142669976,
-0.0299644656,
0.0272367056,
0.0111876987,
-0.0089221196,
-0.0069506993,
-0.0271621682,
-0.0148291904,
0.0169093553,
0.0174378958,
-0.0437292978,
-0.0058767805,
-0.0307804961,
0.0333740264,
-0.0420017019,
0.0272864476,
0.0724730268,
0.0262154825,
0.0012904195,
0.0105697783,
0.0162628349,
0.0267755464,
0.0346290097,
-0.0275729597,
0.0002038311,
0.0348202623,
-0.0204591453,
-0.0008317502,
0.0031804675,
-0.0056898776,
0.0325189866,
0.017672373,
-0.0106479814,
-0.026154859,
0.0144284442,
-0.0574641116,
0.0180411246,
-0.0062371222,
-0.0088931406,
-0.0072380775,
-0.0022550737,
-0.0265869088,
-0.0262460094,
0.0362361372,
0.004501543,
-0.0096797198,
-0.0108057661,
0.0584989302,
0.0022806979,
0.0350731798,
0.0185655709,
-0.0466105603,
-0.0122475345,
0.0305352472,
0.0822549164,
0.0339680798,
0.0207412709,
0.024263192,
-0.0430697948,
-0.0527974926,
0.0182312615,
-0.0518505201,
0.0452649482,
0.0413259864,
0.0098564671,
0.080548279,
0.0092433114,
0.0211311225,
0.0197659787,
0.0066621006,
-0.0289904848,
-0.005321647,
0.0111190081,
-6.272593609e-33,
-0.0065792482,
-0.0136674009,
-0.0344443507,
-0.0358767249,
-0.0009329849,
0.0057095313,
0.0330267139,
0.0292554908,
0.0352850035,
0.0106919548,
0.027828807,
0.0162684303,
-0.0065694544,
-0.0135132773,
-0.0120025482,
-0.0417506061,
0.018174123,
-0.0077821137,
-0.0099935504,
-0.0241137091,
0.050371401,
0.0231393818,
0.009743128,
-0.0716289133,
0.0270106755,
-0.0244540442,
-0.0276817791,
-0.0299737453,
0.0546841994,
0.0632956475,
-0.0131178116,
0.067048572,
0.0469178148,
0.0056946711,
-0.0088423556,
0.0544645488,
-0.0396935418,
0.0094506517,
0.0262272544,
0.024809787,
0.0139123686,
-0.0454320386,
0.0653632805,
-0.0165707823,
-0.033374995,
-0.023786068,
0.0395194292,
-0.0234228391,
0.052018173,
-0.0045821704,
-0.0635922328,
0.0110836355,
-0.022870196,
0.0001240259,
-0.0048820013,
0.0462821051,
0.0620955937,
0.047965873,
-0.0156281516,
0.0729443878,
-0.0238204468,
-0.0526746064,
0.0420435816,
0.0012585983,
0.0184711907,
0.0875450075,
0.0292790681,
0.0363148078,
-0.0259962808,
-0.0029561028,
0.0265075751,
0.0328958854,
0.0707955733,
0.079866536,
0.0648815632,
-0.0690937489,
-0.0606052056,
0.0109132184,
-0.0458181649,
-0.0456739962,
0.0106777791,
-0.0012184716,
-0.0511525758,
0.0083957687,
-0.000823937,
-0.0490866937,
-0.0329567343,
-0.0641178414,
0.0166678242,
-0.028262347,
-0.0333664902,
-0.0091712214,
0.0338092484,
-0.0155138643,
-0.0027959417,
0.0079925321,
-0.0150513109,
0.0208471585,
0.0116185863,
-0.0087951021,
-0.0104790637,
0.0031942839,
0.0498972572,
-0.0127150258,
0.0517855212,
-0.003914129,
0.0864772275,
0.0230860785,
-0.06691733,
-0.0222460944,
-0.0352236815,
0.009874884,
-0.0051113656,
0.0417223126,
0.0153586231,
0.0570014529,
-0.030728912,
-0.0386725701,
0.0020067617,
-0.0180140529,
-0.0444834046,
0.0003626148,
-0.0434401669,
0.0180016588,
-0.0125957476,
-0.0520721264,
-0.006788217,
-0.0431245416,
0.0227885097,
-0.117716603,
-0.0011578645,
-0.0572936982,
2.645e-7,
-0.0115058273,
0.0212876368,
0.014898926,
-0.0024633608,
0.0520227924,
0.080540739,
0.0024058355,
0.0076181437,
-0.0184417032,
-0.0097186146,
0.0045202449,
0.0323722586,
0.0079148253,
0.0282429568,
0.0176487174,
-0.0167669002,
0.0156506952,
-0.0066578365,
-0.0433761105,
0.0345618986,
0.0144729195,
0.085735023,
0.0587328263,
-0.0519075878,
0.0046845414,
-0.0323896222,
0.0780140758,
-0.0655685738,
0.0089359637,
-0.0655270368,
0.0013430184,
0.0198910125,
-0.002118259,
0.0107383858,
0.0017839461,
-0.0263557043,
0.0260171965,
0.0240821149,
0.0281754378,
-0.0095842313,
0.0040877112,
0.023129316,
-0.0166412834,
-0.0137664145,
0.0515939444,
-0.0066829431,
-0.0282969791,
-0.0612550452,
-0.0159901455,
-0.0186534747,
0.0786352754,
0.0044385856,
0.0104053384,
-0.0221578088,
0.0217283126,
-0.0156832449,
0.0076277768,
-0.1043165997,
-0.0039308639,
0.0249526799,
-0.0293404516,
-0.01432072,
-0.0532299541,
-0.0237530842,
0.0816837996,
0.0394254103,
0.0079433182,
1.951579598e-34,
0.0273950584,
-0.0511670262,
0.0177979209,
-0.0391007923,
0.0196403358,
-0.0069423392,
-0.0293754227,
-0.0400809385,
0.0331209414,
-0.0119911665,
0.0237976573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04957v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04957v2 | Reconfidencing LLMs from the Grouping Loss Perspective | 2024-02-07T15:40:22 | 2024-06-18T20:31:56 | Lihu Chen, Alexandre Perez-Lebel, Fabian M. Suchanek, Gaël Varoquaux | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs), including ChatGPT and LLaMA, are susceptible to
generating hallucinated answers in a confident tone. While efforts to elicit
and calibrate confidence scores have proven useful, recent findings show that
controlling uncertainty must go beyond calibration: predicted scores may
deviate significantly from the actual posterior probabilities due to the impact
of grouping loss. In this work, we construct a new evaluation dataset derived
from a knowledge base to assess confidence scores given to answers of Mistral
and LLaMA. Experiments show that they tend to be overconfident. Further, we
show that they are more overconfident on some answers than others, \emph{eg}
depending on the nationality of the person in the query. In
uncertainty-quantification theory, this is grouping loss. To address this, we
propose a solution to reconfidence LLMs, canceling not only calibration but
also grouping loss. The LLMs, after the reconfidencing process, indicate
improved confidence alignment with the accuracy of their responses. | [
0.0278514717,
0.0962237865,
-0.0232795626,
0.0341391005,
-0.0419065952,
-0.0019401636,
-0.0286684986,
-0.0103237433,
-0.0044336715,
-0.0315545797,
-0.0430379696,
-0.084592849,
0.0439260416,
-0.0217165016,
0.0437222607,
-0.0203127451,
0.0314145759,
-0.0089684371,
0.0318670273,
-0.0560840592,
0.0049843253,
-0.0117323846,
-0.0291412305,
0.0157280844,
0.0295319371,
-0.0056339544,
0.0092109311,
-0.0297225695,
0.0025815023,
-0.0308510959,
0.0510946773,
0.0865094215,
-0.0153626027,
0.0315281637,
0.0000019125,
-0.0447013713,
-0.0100848852,
-0.0254459046,
-0.0411722958,
0.0371980332,
0.0118327485,
0.0553615093,
0.0087202061,
0.046043925,
-0.0621049926,
-0.0034191885,
0.0265202094,
0.0084736291,
0.0354226269,
0.0454369001,
0.0167646911,
0.0065066591,
0.0135514457,
-0.0116301253,
0.0255970415,
-0.0522212982,
0.0361708179,
0.0278813094,
-0.0463139601,
-0.0003279258,
-0.0042923931,
0.0459967293,
-0.0167497881,
-0.0156445224,
-0.021290889,
0.0045946636,
-0.0553762689,
-0.0247221906,
-0.0133547951,
-0.0008738084,
0.0458036996,
-0.0349003263,
-0.0448900163,
0.0092406413,
0.0140583506,
0.0194071569,
-0.0517474227,
0.0202216748,
-0.0074855383,
-0.0007500788,
0.0041986522,
0.0206830818,
0.0245538969,
0.0023031838,
-0.0085014394,
0.1137510017,
0.0060176058,
-0.0069029639,
-0.004650299,
0.0273306333,
-0.0258597545,
-0.0473041646,
-0.0125040188,
0.0374060608,
-0.0185545553,
0.0376353189,
0.0150293009,
0.0373177007,
0.0469116494,
-0.0517830886,
-0.0255003478,
0.0321017504,
-0.0059796739,
0.0304223318,
-0.0067645693,
0.0546586812,
0.012101884,
0.0127557963,
-0.0117389029,
-0.0165179074,
-0.012226833,
-0.0233656075,
0.0173685327,
0.0045644408,
0.0046960642,
0.0421533063,
-0.0876982734,
-0.005017349,
-0.0253283288,
0.0210099258,
-0.0089329816,
0.0327082723,
0.0013254985,
-0.0408417843,
-0.0582836829,
0.0632515848,
0.0117215244,
0.0429657139,
0.0187449176,
-0.1255825758,
0.0178283844,
0.0072394041,
-0.0297328308,
0.0109772617,
-0.0033787536,
0.0561386608,
-0.0115030278,
-0.0115307998,
-0.0219616946,
-0.0353262126,
-0.0367665067,
-0.0639685765,
-0.0104548149,
-0.069391191,
0.0348382927,
0.020787634,
-0.0036845745,
-0.0242229458,
0.0070025423,
0.0100294771,
-0.0104299663,
0.0553875118,
-0.0139368568,
0.0490712859,
0.0483290069,
0.0168631263,
-0.0343811512,
0.0539292693,
0.0340022445,
0.0126016513,
0.0466041565,
-0.0118218567,
0.0516469255,
0.0156564154,
0.0182253886,
0.0149786407,
0.0199934654,
0.0211032443,
0.0015503203,
-0.0025427062,
0.0305109043,
0.0618388504,
-0.0344514139,
-0.0093065044,
0.0904434174,
0.0278884564,
0.0027358376,
-0.0069606206,
-0.0275005586,
-0.0106960451,
0.0425725058,
0.0291073825,
-0.078247875,
0.0163388271,
-0.0436787196,
0.0225135367,
0.0494473018,
0.0136997849,
-0.0105683897,
-0.050050348,
-0.0148820002,
0.0134489397,
-0.0135134775,
0.0468330607,
0.0283064134,
-0.0334092751,
-0.0148646198,
0.046552252,
0.0254742447,
-0.0454356894,
0.0054677553,
-0.0662479773,
0.0226028431,
-0.0039917869,
0.0033063935,
0.0051098582,
-0.0245444458,
-0.0005896877,
-0.0093179243,
0.0132557955,
0.0513510108,
-0.013006594,
-0.00579884,
-0.0325850323,
-0.0051165977,
0.0231338255,
0.0224169977,
0.0007477616,
0.0444146283,
0.0201400649,
-0.0029626554,
-0.0342879407,
0.007601779,
0.0058722422,
-0.0006050796,
-0.0204265229,
-0.0250823777,
-0.0342339464,
0.0403066278,
-0.0012188602,
0.0116576729,
0.0497149602,
0.0219837613,
0.0232129116,
-0.0502896234,
-0.0168555416,
-0.0217003599,
-0.0331410356,
0.0532468036,
-0.0095110172,
-0.0094716083,
-0.0546770841,
-0.0257561542,
-0.0348705649,
-0.0135009447,
-0.016045453,
0.0198094975,
-0.0363394842,
0.0510734543,
-0.0331741646,
0.0053230161,
-0.0616781265,
0.0697574541,
-0.0324751362,
0.0526789501,
-0.0112030273,
-0.0340037271,
0.0202475321,
-0.046709314,
-0.0351473056,
-0.0004367195,
-0.000997488,
0.0344819464,
0.0572181642,
-0.0511081032,
-0.0537891015,
-0.0210415069,
-0.0767168328,
0.0075211264,
-0.0023626215,
0.0518598482,
0.0214967262,
-0.0031037733,
-0.0149887903,
-0.0035844129,
-0.0834490284,
-0.0073199216,
0.0217551105,
0.0468339846,
0.0326628722,
-0.0181252323,
0.0143948393,
-0.0420216098,
-0.0191393699,
-0.0341994055,
0.0076266443,
-0.0003603589,
-0.0279937591,
-0.0822672322,
0.0534201637,
-0.0812456608,
-0.0028220755,
-0.0295215305,
-0.0560063981,
0.0008044946,
0.004843154,
0.0005939356,
0.0421147123,
0.0209139865,
-0.0290172882,
0.0547657497,
-0.0003062454,
-0.0269264691,
-0.0181264188,
-0.0533658639,
-0.0737762898,
-0.0140308486,
-0.0914448202,
-0.0090505164,
0.0575181767,
0.0379252471,
0.0046059694,
-0.0346459672,
0.0055757025,
-0.0372437052,
-0.0190110076,
-0.0296837855,
0.0092673777,
0.0027286236,
0.0806144327,
-0.0182694718,
-0.0747089013,
0.0719183311,
-0.0116254026,
-0.00058521,
-0.015084683,
0.0009481849,
-0.0100073097,
0.0098722689,
-0.0023224377,
-0.0104277991,
0.0134572871,
-0.0200159829,
-0.1047632396,
-0.0563895963,
0.0241823457,
-0.0835521147,
0.0234842878,
-0.035095308,
-0.0364993326,
-0.0037105361,
-0.01768291,
-0.0374885947,
-0.0052599213,
-0.0328684002,
-0.024976762,
0.0259005148,
-0.0304104872,
-0.0136418557,
-0.0152174979,
0.0231555384,
-0.0396770723,
-0.0596934743,
-0.0077224458,
0.0162381455,
0.0345229544,
0.0471204333,
0.0246878099,
0.0823624954,
-0.0599979013,
-0.008754123,
0.0776950717,
0.0601321943,
0.035794165,
0.0170435328,
-0.0384564735,
0.0613926537,
0.0026766458,
-0.0478949025,
0.0413057879,
0.0779334828,
-0.008951542,
0.0239992868,
0.113660574,
0.0212690216,
-0.0145670883,
-0.0248913784,
-0.041275315,
0.0607266016,
0.0213218424,
0.0198472776,
-0.0610619597,
0.0083661564,
-0.0027973715,
0.0171642881,
-0.030741334,
-0.014066116,
-0.0181030612,
-0.1140601858,
0.0180051513,
0.0130289216,
-0.0241763126,
0.0011837624,
-0.0382159352,
0.0231139194,
-0.0192075837,
0.0498556793,
0.0390203744,
0.0196796563,
0.0072251195,
0.0354422107,
-0.0744767711,
-0.0282627735,
0.0048229145,
-0.0374826491,
0.0798466355,
0.0062511237,
0.0304664038,
0.0122247767,
-0.0582645535,
-0.0215449203,
-0.0552174151,
-0.0399094895,
0.0109856632,
0.054032173,
0.0007044073,
0.0135340057,
-0.0032439134,
0.0079442607,
-0.0357641988,
0.0258890912,
-0.0018218321,
0.0503595173,
-0.0114044417,
-0.0293656942,
-0.0086983703,
0.0201450735,
0.0039630821,
0.0538333058,
0.0021202678,
-0.0009449854,
-0.0109729376,
-0.0243704468,
0.0226880442,
0.0483017117,
-0.0269752648,
0.0696309283,
0.0228648037,
-0.0008881305,
-0.0664458796,
-0.0377583839,
0.0051806448,
0.0042744963,
-0.0108636208,
0.0326672271,
-0.0030469268,
-0.0020228769,
-0.044438228,
0.004353866,
-0.0445826426,
0.0303263962,
-0.045701284,
0.0656151995,
0.0165802669,
-0.0087451907,
0.0048431414,
-0.0149726868,
-0.1140182838,
-0.0923761129,
0.0031919656,
0.0400410667,
0.0336543918,
-0.0237825196,
0.0022136087,
-0.0672017932,
0.0462974124,
0.0056260852,
0.00673737,
0.0269352049,
0.0222890452,
0.0612305813,
-0.0063056089,
0.037932694,
-0.0145551106,
-0.0089201862,
0.0146147488,
0.0062466254,
-0.0280713048,
-0.0706541762,
0.0280241631,
0.0118058408,
0.0499124154,
-0.0142567586,
0.0127108311,
0.0053876489,
0.0127278045,
-0.0272089001,
-0.0113701615,
0.0204324443,
-0.0363246389,
0.043319881,
-0.0390976146,
-0.0055951127,
-0.0374783464,
-0.012153863,
-0.0038792852,
-0.0231259204,
0.0098085962,
0.0462230071,
-0.0099299923,
0.0267133489,
0.0049518491,
-0.0022177678,
-0.0113824205,
0.0060740416,
0.0635781661,
0.0341279469,
0.0451583192,
-0.0017151923,
-0.0492728092,
0.0019124747,
0.0034540263,
-0.0712401271,
-0.0785347,
-0.0009069987,
0.0343951732,
0.0152163086,
0.0153789204,
0.0448159799,
-0.0033049202,
0.0047466727,
-0.0204616152,
0.0167693719,
0.0115074031,
0.0075347112,
0.0741742924,
0.0040094317,
-0.0247771572,
0.0358694978,
0.0801459998,
-0.0155081525,
0.0351379588,
-0.0313008092,
-0.0423778966,
-0.0160376076,
-0.0295601487,
0.0116704805,
0.005959162,
-0.0228170063,
-0.020627223,
-0.0410947502,
-0.0800051391,
0.0150017813,
0.0334173851,
0.0053493446,
-0.0306186005,
0.0040069991,
0.0736553818,
-0.0150331473,
-0.0236254111,
-0.0460839644,
-0.0029184539,
-0.016015904,
0.0269474257,
-0.0267806146,
-6.825254482e-33,
-0.0064954553,
-0.0566551089,
0.0075563779,
-0.0028743877,
-0.0168641619,
0.000654458,
-0.0172577631,
0.0300172716,
-0.0388426334,
0.0365746543,
-0.0318032354,
0.0246627517,
0.0260652751,
0.0135521134,
0.0384716764,
-0.0171223078,
0.0092260148,
0.0057317778,
-0.0169914868,
-0.0155464401,
0.0247059893,
-0.0072845449,
0.0890059397,
-0.1105455235,
0.0876804441,
-0.0228039641,
-0.0340645947,
0.0642226562,
-0.0098733241,
0.0274299029,
-0.0143861268,
0.0432446375,
0.0101287887,
-0.0186653193,
-0.0075127948,
-0.0086547527,
-0.0181584433,
-0.040437758,
0.0231377371,
0.0336461626,
-0.0017917358,
-0.0122594377,
0.0182033647,
-0.0248649549,
-0.0247454494,
-0.0034429503,
0.0123802107,
-0.0212866291,
-0.0400590003,
0.0104926005,
-0.0136690503,
0.0198307969,
0.0338694192,
0.001897244,
-0.0299458075,
0.067313835,
-0.0080515565,
-0.037564259,
-0.0477636345,
0.0297899693,
0.0136977276,
0.0555583164,
0.0679620355,
0.0300002415,
0.005437965,
0.0428546183,
0.0579157323,
0.0322879292,
-0.005736365,
-0.0273267739,
0.0067087221,
-0.0144002335,
0.0622362383,
0.0657677874,
0.029242957,
-0.004749618,
-0.0517282002,
0.0201733764,
0.0259623006,
0.0385907665,
0.0416282639,
0.0361533985,
-0.0732024163,
-0.056593895,
-0.0284772962,
-0.0279654991,
-0.025732344,
-0.0315605216,
-0.0132975252,
-0.0074741468,
-0.0079419771,
-0.0244826749,
0.0311254449,
-0.0436497703,
-0.0464584976,
-0.0119853653,
-0.0019772688,
0.0310402941,
-0.002360937,
0.045841001,
-0.0309279878,
0.0000076767,
-0.0191988368,
0.0128582064,
-0.0101045948,
0.0402154662,
0.0051979683,
0.0129821971,
-0.0798124224,
-0.0029937881,
-0.0178774651,
-0.0180168189,
0.036997471,
-0.0107952198,
0.0347605199,
-0.0063652894,
-0.0108203152,
0.0045463298,
0.0177448392,
0.0237192865,
-0.0024207847,
0.0049074907,
-0.0115596689,
0.0093352571,
-0.0384846181,
-0.0134768803,
-0.006360379,
0.0122730127,
-0.0092552258,
-0.0224959794,
-0.0244726948,
-0.0305545889,
2.813e-7,
0.0590990894,
0.0498208106,
-0.0141274044,
0.0369538553,
0.0266408846,
0.032960169,
-0.0000588757,
-0.0139906406,
0.0746745244,
-0.0675693452,
0.0087273847,
-0.0167639498,
0.040703889,
0.0536697879,
-0.057204932,
-0.0603782535,
-0.0378532335,
-0.0020400824,
0.0207670741,
0.0017539375,
0.068380408,
0.0842259973,
0.0055169472,
-0.0050895121,
-0.0520597026,
-0.008617688,
0.0634648129,
-0.0103298165,
-0.0443035178,
0.0710995048,
0.0957583189,
0.012591524,
0.0170540493,
0.051512029,
-0.010485013,
-0.0050024171,
-0.0071172984,
0.0070935246,
0.0041736891,
-0.0240761749,
-0.0081328694,
-0.0292878859,
0.0182680991,
-0.0583087541,
0.0414367132,
-0.0613388196,
-0.0446454883,
-0.036447268,
0.0005579547,
-0.0506818295,
0.0809876025,
-0.0207693093,
-0.0173490588,
0.0295330435,
0.0101628415,
0.0323661268,
-0.0279637147,
-0.0611144193,
-0.0448904224,
-0.0056984271,
-0.012779519,
-0.0593872927,
0.019717373,
-0.007300681,
-0.0207880866,
-0.0709852427,
0.0337333269,
2.420529524e-34,
0.0228806753,
0.0040251403,
0.0065157865,
0.0441254787,
0.0537390932,
-0.0260401759,
0.0426405706,
0.0211850386,
0.0284772199,
-0.0459395722,
-0.0099396585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04918v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04918v1 | Prompting Implicit Discourse Relation Annotation | 2024-02-07T14:44:42 | 2024-02-07T14:44:42 | Frances Yung, Mansoor Ahmad, Merel Scholman, Vera Demberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained large language models, such as ChatGPT, archive outstanding
performance in various reasoning tasks without supervised training and were
found to have outperformed crowdsourcing workers. Nonetheless, ChatGPT's
performance in the task of implicit discourse relation classification, prompted
by a standard multiple-choice question, is still far from satisfactory and
considerably inferior to state-of-the-art supervised approaches. This work
investigates several proven prompting techniques to improve ChatGPT's
recognition of discourse relations. In particular, we experimented with
breaking down the classification task that involves numerous abstract labels
into smaller subtasks. Nonetheless, experiment results show that the inference
accuracy hardly changes even with sophisticated prompt engineering, suggesting
that implicit discourse relation classification is not yet resolvable under
zero-shot or few-shot settings. | [
0.0576827265,
0.0120699489,
0.0104345083,
0.0353880934,
-0.0261174962,
0.029708311,
0.0397971869,
-0.0011218898,
0.0515264496,
-0.1013878658,
-0.0354466848,
0.0023359971,
-0.023248475,
-0.0063444641,
-0.0168148708,
-0.0286256094,
0.0463609248,
-0.0330950245,
0.0439236313,
-0.0148182055,
-0.0042297458,
0.0047383052,
-0.0378793105,
0.0253113471,
-0.0285309479,
-0.0418846123,
-0.0217675176,
-0.0195144676,
-0.0079509448,
-0.0511841215,
0.0335681587,
0.1093026102,
0.0013230152,
0.0667708144,
0.0000018633,
-0.0728933066,
0.0076135923,
-0.0213211402,
-0.0535517707,
0.0280210841,
-0.0093868719,
0.0462242067,
0.0416926108,
0.0060112383,
-0.0340073146,
-0.0423199683,
0.0180887766,
0.1122287437,
0.0610469356,
0.0196534712,
-0.0088580586,
-0.001164014,
-0.01600473,
-0.0034827045,
-0.0198413022,
-0.0480754301,
0.018185569,
0.0257389303,
-0.0220637191,
0.0843182057,
0.00554635,
0.0408939198,
0.0262571741,
-0.0316527635,
0.0002560954,
0.0606467612,
-0.0789073408,
-0.0175970662,
-0.0190589204,
0.0843004435,
0.0887558833,
-0.0296265241,
-0.0163988899,
0.0011163004,
0.0133456038,
0.0264803246,
-0.0104163047,
-0.0000336262,
-0.0125447428,
-0.0091448547,
0.0360753275,
0.0158448424,
-0.0046110563,
0.0261745416,
0.0543310978,
0.0389262512,
-0.0063208593,
-0.0117831007,
0.0373247042,
0.0445421897,
-0.0614659488,
-0.0851641074,
-0.0200125966,
0.0147240851,
-0.0406554639,
0.0049707405,
-0.0217270795,
-0.01121205,
0.024372587,
-0.0626361296,
0.0236975234,
0.0309466999,
-0.044177264,
0.0615903065,
-0.0381295905,
0.0375984609,
-0.0187546182,
-0.0303864907,
-0.011236784,
-0.0119539369,
-0.0295762867,
-0.0208585132,
-0.0698866174,
0.0468039513,
-0.056891609,
-0.002430656,
-0.0366004221,
0.0158516448,
0.0104378918,
-0.0110868355,
0.012533146,
0.0209341142,
-0.0337481573,
0.020186929,
-0.0498496033,
-0.0013702423,
-0.0449909978,
0.0383124575,
-0.0354663767,
-0.0408728272,
-0.0107220355,
0.0032865701,
-0.0006878121,
-0.0052003236,
-0.0152713452,
0.0659353137,
-0.0296863113,
-0.0129039465,
0.0016023695,
-0.0244925376,
-0.0000164518,
-0.0204047505,
-0.0012242229,
-0.0311653335,
-0.0079976972,
0.015032826,
-0.0029916503,
0.0197918322,
0.0458752662,
0.0076737287,
-0.02112104,
0.0773855671,
0.0177903716,
-0.0105174845,
0.0592243224,
0.0144919464,
-0.0295152236,
0.06256634,
0.0095499167,
-0.0193111971,
0.0243789759,
0.0159459431,
-0.0056626406,
-0.0026870242,
0.0232486483,
0.0097076176,
0.0434929244,
0.0293481555,
0.0138199069,
0.0188501235,
0.0061531859,
0.0548455864,
-0.0200479236,
-0.0501145609,
0.0323805921,
0.0742399246,
-0.0552162081,
0.0201957989,
0.0556136519,
0.0200398508,
0.0256928205,
0.0318296961,
-0.0343103185,
0.0062691662,
-0.027044747,
-0.0444444939,
0.0215287358,
-0.031275373,
-0.0311618038,
-0.039358329,
0.0008432578,
0.0089358948,
0.0210668445,
0.0048384671,
0.0325654857,
0.0219668057,
-0.0425007567,
0.0228118692,
0.0610890724,
-0.0112202577,
-0.0516511574,
-0.0645419061,
0.0485400967,
-0.0189080704,
0.0204418749,
-0.0147463763,
-0.0439979881,
-0.0297392271,
0.0760326907,
0.0599848665,
0.0564589389,
-0.0530267805,
-0.0059295576,
-0.0132549144,
-0.0192382913,
-0.002085245,
0.018200431,
0.0462238304,
0.041949518,
-0.0266630929,
0.0028227845,
0.0261841547,
-0.0265877731,
0.017006617,
-0.040638987,
-0.0450816229,
0.0368544459,
-0.0060585681,
0.0176803675,
0.012510214,
-0.0030156493,
-0.0166305229,
0.0215101521,
-0.042129077,
-0.0351874866,
0.0051786914,
-0.0805689991,
-0.0564525761,
0.0167862792,
0.0015290128,
-0.0436476544,
-0.0426780619,
-0.0234660115,
-0.0199506823,
-0.0102664959,
-0.0042430456,
0.0337548219,
-0.0580915846,
-0.0340732634,
0.0065829991,
-0.0216607787,
-0.0342324376,
0.0595554933,
0.0219143517,
0.0230682511,
0.0472213291,
-0.0079202754,
0.0325891152,
-0.0060346494,
-0.0076665431,
-0.0156700145,
0.0254842937,
-0.0064448742,
0.0276990365,
0.0147342943,
-0.0637960806,
-0.0004630236,
-0.1571926922,
-0.0148534207,
-0.000861637,
0.0010476093,
0.0123654753,
-0.0056765699,
-0.0026403067,
-0.0402153134,
-0.0169443041,
-0.016732553,
-0.0308412779,
0.0270669162,
0.0663517937,
-0.0094331745,
0.0533903763,
-0.0209036972,
0.018924972,
-0.0487299003,
0.0479903556,
0.0587975234,
0.0068992605,
-0.029749915,
0.0211664382,
-0.0233069528,
0.0285843574,
-0.0074315565,
-0.042432785,
0.0396000147,
0.0244193245,
0.0727283135,
0.0536806025,
-0.0011491833,
0.0366712324,
0.0117481714,
-0.0179900248,
-0.064213492,
0.040232338,
-0.0190430544,
-0.0185683817,
-0.0046633892,
0.0329904929,
-0.0517295003,
0.0926405564,
0.0120677855,
-0.0143114803,
-0.0570501164,
0.0420598648,
-0.0393454917,
-0.0081611881,
-0.0494420305,
-0.0170679241,
0.0062333983,
0.0286432784,
-0.0229468718,
0.0003330997,
0.0660487786,
-0.0242974497,
-0.0026076687,
-0.0441655479,
-0.0222042259,
-0.0173226967,
0.0852578729,
-0.0083280224,
-0.0180949811,
0.054719694,
-0.0331879295,
-0.0490161851,
-0.0153778996,
0.0406638384,
-0.0215381868,
0.0326429941,
-0.0269994978,
0.0249927528,
-0.0064539528,
-0.0511923917,
-0.0859330818,
-0.0939449072,
-0.014722785,
0.0046661738,
-0.0440914594,
0.0057065226,
0.0312290061,
0.023027882,
0.004825647,
0.0449736379,
-0.0140938777,
-0.0155172786,
-0.0221704897,
0.0673714876,
0.022297984,
0.0163522363,
-0.0101709077,
-0.0077281208,
0.0467440598,
0.0495016612,
-0.0261506028,
0.0117739588,
-0.0377713367,
0.0020554399,
-0.0229997858,
-0.0374982804,
-0.0043495065,
-0.0224131327,
0.0710549951,
-0.0390893482,
0.0003761673,
0.1342849284,
0.0226589851,
-0.0342691168,
-0.0100458767,
-0.0165989511,
0.0096396599,
0.0472812317,
0.014361389,
-0.0815590471,
-0.0328923017,
-0.0059960247,
-0.0285054278,
-0.0375791974,
-0.0648468733,
0.0063574552,
-0.0997193754,
0.0039539537,
-0.0474688075,
0.0016011036,
0.0397856273,
-0.0535163172,
0.045193173,
0.0052260538,
-0.0088103432,
-0.0183135439,
0.0049958299,
0.0120038697,
0.0386081524,
0.009797208,
0.0112273302,
0.0504535064,
-0.0031788282,
0.050956998,
-0.0060693533,
0.0419061966,
0.0011805361,
0.0331196375,
0.0801190212,
-0.0236254316,
-0.0119402483,
-0.0290368516,
0.0448921435,
-0.0068701906,
-0.0041940776,
-0.0362472087,
0.0362736098,
-0.0057794424,
-0.0182717778,
0.0282208268,
0.0478856601,
-0.0282640606,
-0.0018302777,
-0.0086507304,
0.0254123975,
0.0155291865,
0.0682837069,
0.0246451739,
-0.0165484399,
-0.0185148735,
-0.0434381515,
0.0114167975,
0.0099081593,
-0.0207310747,
-0.0079864636,
0.0095525077,
-0.0021269654,
-0.0581041649,
-0.0692471117,
0.0444605872,
0.0009393564,
0.0074564451,
0.0032669383,
0.0237304345,
0.0383639149,
-0.0246304553,
0.0399647057,
-0.0330634415,
-0.0325577445,
-0.007440398,
-0.0346369632,
0.050717622,
-0.0149270482,
-0.053476885,
0.0162238423,
-0.047268454,
-0.0401415154,
-0.0212092046,
0.0256819949,
0.0122466432,
0.0603685454,
-0.0305599198,
0.0202012695,
0.051269576,
0.0567827672,
-0.0368202515,
0.0116958413,
0.0300604869,
0.0430495664,
-0.0060126614,
0.0338561758,
-0.0056547332,
0.0385071002,
-0.0115827378,
0.0194573421,
-0.0406534486,
-0.0245166495,
0.0216124635,
0.0131119285,
0.0741280988,
0.0063461452,
0.0042562122,
-0.0515006259,
0.0219303668,
-0.0270244777,
-0.0510161333,
-0.0267345011,
0.0196904521,
-0.0142421005,
-0.0256663151,
-0.0331467576,
-0.0683462247,
-0.0304050799,
0.0782604814,
-0.0151192108,
-0.0132260062,
0.0741382912,
0.0272362642,
0.0027753769,
-0.0278413594,
-0.0360326208,
0.0158735644,
0.0230170004,
0.0394861139,
-0.0216379762,
0.0714072287,
0.0350735858,
0.0096982792,
0.0246269554,
-0.0122553902,
-0.0545842238,
0.0004740657,
-0.0016690176,
0.0583449565,
0.0515740439,
-0.0336932167,
0.0248050466,
-0.0174789112,
-0.0054979841,
0.007776781,
0.0667391568,
-0.0011932574,
-0.0108224312,
0.0276065841,
0.0031400109,
-0.0263222773,
0.0608371608,
0.0421895273,
-0.0359009132,
0.0488519557,
0.0675471649,
0.0034110891,
-0.0516003929,
-0.0349519812,
-0.0327442065,
-0.0056600124,
0.0146002881,
0.0799918473,
-0.0120370006,
-0.0297035743,
0.0039102794,
-0.0234351624,
-0.0396935605,
-0.0082471669,
0.0173765514,
0.0460187271,
0.0133540938,
-0.0479352474,
-0.0621625818,
0.0015162987,
-0.034975186,
-0.0181290507,
-0.0571862012,
-6.31980587e-33,
-0.0818307698,
-0.0480899736,
0.0071884529,
0.0313488767,
-0.0245161522,
0.0536916479,
-0.0669141486,
0.0097735217,
0.0098879598,
0.0581957027,
-0.0107135447,
0.0203096196,
0.0063404334,
-0.0053892368,
0.0235379003,
-0.0611173175,
0.0388940088,
-0.0250773244,
-0.0149675356,
0.0352669246,
0.0365493931,
-0.0015138099,
0.0427616015,
-0.0479227453,
0.025784729,
-0.0148636438,
0.031355124,
0.0333455354,
-0.0140197873,
0.0502498075,
-0.0463490821,
0.0110149365,
0.0368721075,
0.0207680035,
0.036363095,
0.0448310934,
-0.1019829065,
-0.0688527599,
0.0254260004,
-0.0096598994,
-0.0640930906,
-0.0054969196,
-0.0226180088,
-0.0039010306,
0.0086944969,
-0.0282435864,
0.0421347804,
0.0037098615,
0.0129711842,
-0.0213383846,
-0.0248364676,
0.0101908557,
-0.014307878,
-0.0302701797,
0.0026342252,
0.0655056685,
0.0246599466,
-0.0239939373,
-0.0204191674,
-0.0111268312,
-0.0214823727,
0.0045207799,
0.0042353654,
-0.0139327394,
0.0164516959,
0.0590625405,
-0.0316844955,
0.007815551,
-0.0311048049,
-0.0089885136,
-0.0031938776,
-0.0111345062,
-0.0045202305,
-0.007232083,
0.0084265042,
0.0399515368,
-0.0659241527,
-0.0113387406,
0.047890313,
0.0075329896,
0.0300290231,
-0.0440630391,
-0.0245489273,
-0.0198660288,
-0.0666331872,
-0.0343167,
-0.0303818565,
-0.0290453285,
0.0232495405,
-0.0277826544,
-0.0091259275,
0.0005117526,
0.0287800413,
-0.0218656175,
-0.0418000408,
0.0033175831,
-0.0045720083,
-0.0023561977,
-0.0004597974,
0.0387692973,
-0.0351928547,
-0.0029266316,
0.0013411432,
-0.0078091798,
0.0299110282,
0.0181828216,
0.019509038,
-0.016920004,
-0.0614844635,
-0.0364811346,
-0.0261320565,
0.0116152819,
-0.0521843247,
0.0543939732,
0.01035765,
0.0648802444,
-0.0074064769,
0.0562631935,
0.0018541558,
0.0151403807,
-0.0440927967,
-0.0023051624,
-0.0263008531,
0.0040912419,
-0.018888548,
-0.0164723005,
0.0009525341,
0.0098005515,
-0.0176131781,
-0.0542749204,
-0.0143753719,
0.0099965725,
2.44e-7,
0.0136466846,
0.0739454851,
0.0210904479,
0.0127642117,
-0.0085465303,
0.0349365547,
0.0319148004,
0.0123733878,
0.0351539105,
-0.0317709222,
-0.0023612615,
0.0364462361,
0.0387071669,
0.0424973927,
-0.103840366,
-0.0595684089,
-0.0838810131,
-0.0293638632,
-0.0271184575,
0.0040766122,
0.0760095194,
0.0515139028,
0.0261362568,
0.0154221514,
-0.044571694,
-0.0125070829,
0.0515585802,
-0.0140838884,
-0.0177640785,
0.0317007825,
-0.0058297762,
0.0089745121,
0.0102331806,
0.0609614365,
0.014831664,
0.0103060957,
-0.0011912999,
0.0472204201,
0.0007861725,
-0.0178151,
-0.0270591881,
0.0081787612,
0.0273420904,
0.0071997084,
0.0556447841,
-0.0841793567,
-0.0362008885,
-0.0103954962,
-0.0174995493,
-0.0174167696,
0.0373822637,
0.026407944,
-0.0056789448,
0.0129106343,
0.00710392,
-0.0221281108,
0.0000497541,
-0.0568447374,
-0.0075935139,
0.0040191798,
-0.0146144442,
-0.0426954068,
0.0108437119,
-0.0197631009,
0.0072144424,
-0.0190667007,
0.0153026441,
2.120404694e-34,
0.0180000868,
-0.0174614992,
0.013495151,
0.051673837,
0.0387419425,
0.0025727509,
0.019505525,
-0.0184486024,
0.0536750816,
-0.0757575855,
0.0140429353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04914v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04914v1 | Personalized Text Generation with Fine-Grained Linguistic Control | 2024-02-07T14:41:08 | 2024-02-07T14:41:08 | Bashar Alhafni, Vivek Kulkarni, Dhruv Kumar, Vipul Raheja | cs.CL | cs.CL | As the text generation capabilities of large language models become
increasingly prominent, recent studies have focused on controlling particular
aspects of the generated text to make it more personalized. However, most
research on controllable text generation focuses on controlling the content or
modeling specific high-level/coarse-grained attributes that reflect authors'
writing styles, such as formality, domain, or sentiment. In this paper, we
focus on controlling fine-grained attributes spanning multiple linguistic
dimensions, such as lexical and syntactic attributes. We introduce a novel
benchmark to train generative models and evaluate their ability to generate
personalized text based on multiple fine-grained linguistic attributes. We
systematically investigate the performance of various large language models on
our benchmark and draw insights from the factors that impact their performance.
We make our code, data, and pretrained models publicly available. | [
0.0512204543,
0.0424995534,
0.0057617761,
0.0037470774,
-0.0215451755,
-0.0061498783,
0.0365373231,
0.0055466699,
-0.013142149,
-0.0342460051,
-0.0162722114,
-0.0230165087,
-0.0217300542,
0.055990383,
0.0310514458,
-0.0560022965,
0.0023210708,
0.0280431006,
0.0403155684,
-0.01716768,
0.0385906771,
0.0385078974,
0.0259121265,
0.0284588169,
-0.0050659887,
-0.0233092364,
0.0329984762,
0.0233776961,
0.0294611882,
-0.0048681027,
0.0549515299,
0.0625070557,
0.0011863288,
0.0288345814,
0.0000018289,
-0.0038778975,
-0.0017283537,
-0.0049025272,
0.0384232402,
0.0366671756,
0.0940667465,
0.0162586179,
-0.0217365902,
0.0229542274,
-0.0330068246,
-0.0111620165,
0.0278676283,
0.0621005148,
0.0362200066,
0.0919576511,
-0.0243397038,
-0.0279582851,
-0.0094172675,
-0.0449376516,
0.0145152742,
-0.0145219648,
-0.0167426616,
-0.0127439098,
-0.0168002378,
0.0334073156,
-0.0132556697,
-0.0064539211,
0.0106607564,
-0.0004135355,
0.0570919141,
0.0386472493,
0.0031754056,
0.0178170037,
0.0095390538,
0.0410296731,
0.0023563723,
-0.0365752019,
0.0207643639,
-0.0258190371,
-0.0080733029,
-0.0359030664,
-0.0124693075,
0.0328770541,
-0.0184344891,
0.0167682469,
0.0106187472,
0.0452649556,
0.0039815977,
0.0399100967,
0.0001753609,
0.0206114445,
0.0312442947,
-0.0152379721,
-0.0225881431,
0.0353840776,
0.010640746,
-0.0859370232,
0.0165530909,
-0.0073382482,
-0.0174253341,
-0.0322180353,
-0.0942558944,
-0.0466431342,
0.0107489647,
-0.0274518188,
0.0499689393,
-0.010901832,
0.0295509659,
-0.0031551297,
-0.0125820134,
-0.0049341531,
-0.022933796,
-0.0077088564,
-0.0024109054,
0.0230588801,
-0.0281887967,
-0.0087038781,
-0.0320427045,
0.0175594985,
-0.0262023117,
-0.0302207954,
-0.0568732955,
0.0174493305,
0.0133886328,
0.0306862555,
0.0017801382,
0.0442835428,
-0.0511653498,
-0.0160521958,
0.0024283137,
-0.0226360187,
-0.0951181203,
-0.0006688863,
0.0645731837,
-0.0053522126,
0.0171640497,
0.0371904001,
0.0502753556,
-0.034627486,
-0.0091089103,
0.0109625692,
-0.0333641805,
-0.0167696234,
-0.0206569377,
-0.0667963773,
-0.0097273886,
-0.0719550774,
-0.0334597863,
-0.061469838,
0.0042407718,
0.0019257867,
-0.000895443,
-0.0554637238,
-0.000034988,
0.014964967,
-0.00491544,
0.0069122929,
0.0016581679,
-0.0361998975,
0.0322969779,
0.0026272826,
0.0454007015,
0.0231910497,
0.0315879434,
0.0974368453,
0.0217251685,
-0.0044357982,
0.0151371397,
0.0073447851,
0.0147321839,
0.023671791,
-0.0294894557,
-0.0193586741,
-0.0065174177,
0.0446389541,
0.0287710037,
0.0601390973,
-0.0214607213,
0.0076494976,
0.097399272,
0.0022616631,
0.0275339317,
0.0750495493,
0.0815695301,
0.0329529308,
-0.0071133417,
0.0094608935,
-0.0081819762,
0.0223263614,
-0.0270447824,
0.0331324898,
0.0478164591,
0.0167817287,
-0.0189953204,
-0.0401462987,
0.0066187931,
-0.0115230046,
0.0068646637,
-0.0264008213,
0.0156444646,
0.0277210027,
-0.0446703993,
-0.0102703674,
0.0331750438,
-0.0889071524,
0.0325912125,
-0.0095541375,
0.0303962845,
0.1078531966,
0.0395195261,
0.0398529246,
-0.0030598531,
-0.0261901282,
-0.0021821384,
0.0587261803,
0.0445490852,
0.0094024716,
0.008749485,
-0.0573577769,
-0.0065310211,
-0.045659475,
0.0069900118,
0.0336318985,
0.004360822,
0.0356693156,
0.038261313,
-0.0080070645,
-0.0498104021,
0.0248217843,
-0.0308514982,
-0.0401413366,
0.0566013977,
0.0040943967,
0.007616783,
0.0110247042,
-0.0273718238,
0.00698849,
-0.0067509054,
-0.0429183431,
-0.0401760675,
0.0037190968,
-0.0223103426,
-0.0181236248,
-0.0398465507,
-0.0307986848,
0.0205133017,
-0.0144388834,
-0.0304253623,
-0.0548563935,
0.0244164281,
-0.0395765789,
0.0127879037,
-0.0484716333,
0.0045098201,
0.0321851224,
0.0240279678,
-0.0236444101,
0.0534173325,
0.0061463052,
-0.0040164315,
-0.0143701099,
0.035867624,
0.0004914954,
-0.0206075832,
-0.0065201833,
-0.0281760748,
0.0086662984,
0.0115249809,
0.0437567197,
0.0052655502,
-0.0219883993,
-0.0648441836,
-0.0430878773,
0.0080705388,
-0.0170815103,
0.0036114461,
0.0148633095,
0.0234701894,
0.0063818996,
0.0134617472,
-0.0712486878,
0.00335066,
0.0059548323,
-0.0104800658,
0.0334870592,
0.0173183978,
0.0177194141,
-0.0532255806,
0.0101723922,
0.0178458821,
0.0262112599,
0.0448838398,
0.0462046564,
-0.0292552579,
0.007138073,
-0.0579225495,
-0.0009796526,
0.0218052529,
-0.0521813855,
-0.0031740984,
-0.0258630756,
0.0451819785,
0.0543264225,
0.0384194255,
0.0494014099,
0.0084881643,
0.0151656587,
-0.0336265713,
0.0034443645,
-0.0512006991,
0.0361695252,
-0.0014632306,
-0.040640723,
0.0236416887,
0.0643086359,
0.0320338421,
-0.0085250931,
-0.0713102892,
0.0563066863,
0.013667441,
-0.024605507,
0.0332223289,
0.0339106321,
0.0026388161,
0.0170934778,
-0.0168333482,
-0.0477457792,
0.0355491079,
-0.0204498749,
0.0088217445,
-0.0008339934,
0.0045376294,
-0.0198610667,
0.0458966307,
0.0219926722,
0.0367076509,
0.0312223919,
0.0066148178,
-0.0262246262,
0.0179621466,
0.0581423342,
-0.0002974372,
0.002261058,
-0.0015680228,
0.0086646983,
-0.0111599015,
-0.0525271669,
-0.0238393284,
-0.0456915386,
0.0091903629,
-0.0135033103,
0.0677561089,
-0.0551080965,
0.0008776048,
-0.0425986461,
-0.0026562065,
0.0125126392,
-0.052101355,
-0.0276404675,
-0.0320513956,
0.0487378985,
0.0659115091,
-0.0440757535,
-0.035856951,
-0.043874301,
-0.0358643122,
0.0483867154,
-0.0164833274,
0.0169033799,
-0.0224404503,
-0.0097283898,
0.0255767703,
-0.0421442948,
-0.0311392918,
0.0244690049,
0.0719626769,
-0.0392789543,
-0.042454809,
0.1158553734,
0.0273982864,
-0.0246391259,
0.0149409715,
0.0347780697,
0.0638568774,
0.0054293326,
0.0342315212,
-0.0644614324,
-0.0215504281,
-0.0165382288,
0.031639047,
-0.0332665294,
-0.0143153863,
-0.0314157568,
-0.0989011452,
0.0106300749,
0.0136292195,
-0.030473575,
-0.0151082808,
0.03282905,
-0.0520892404,
-0.0005658084,
-0.0298503004,
-0.0093263863,
-0.0160661619,
0.0161887053,
0.0079482505,
-0.0118533885,
-0.0456921645,
-0.0270251688,
-0.0315067358,
0.0482255667,
0.0700307414,
0.0413977988,
0.0049620741,
0.0010024739,
-0.0121547459,
0.0187186059,
0.0100987079,
-0.0278696381,
0.060960263,
-0.0256125368,
-0.0072926651,
-0.0346936025,
0.0613604523,
0.0179852471,
0.0233350955,
0.019785868,
-0.0014734163,
-0.0010940853,
-0.0475480668,
-0.0250055939,
0.0262453109,
0.0294492431,
0.0665445402,
0.0401046127,
-0.0992840976,
-0.0564772859,
-0.0524554662,
0.0191127062,
-0.1065463275,
-0.0205614865,
-0.0342399999,
0.0021261924,
-0.0397476107,
-0.1180813313,
-0.043098487,
0.0014235036,
0.0170387235,
0.0023415408,
-0.0147052845,
-0.0107063521,
-0.0503978655,
-0.0364226401,
-0.0144261401,
-0.0263905805,
0.0131421536,
-0.0681372508,
-0.062665984,
0.0319504328,
-0.0797574297,
-0.0076829502,
0.0257295705,
-0.078810215,
-0.0742488429,
-0.0020849106,
0.0495045856,
0.0048008012,
0.0448389649,
-0.0180642232,
-0.1085862517,
0.0349569172,
0.0559339039,
-0.0225062147,
0.0187503174,
0.0237630755,
0.0249371398,
-0.0007587656,
0.0424319282,
-0.0133545147,
0.0616123676,
0.0504733883,
0.0155534847,
0.0159525555,
-0.0488161631,
-0.0033512772,
-0.0088632936,
-0.0124020977,
-0.058036074,
0.0088345418,
-0.0300279818,
-0.0173659138,
-0.0569408163,
-0.0185368247,
-0.0510052145,
-0.0340877473,
0.0234525744,
0.0155291017,
-0.0324687809,
0.0145519953,
-0.0158851705,
0.0552064329,
-0.0780451149,
0.000377309,
-0.0569080412,
0.0304825623,
0.0421337076,
0.0084975408,
-0.0390222184,
0.0248017907,
-0.0092961574,
0.0321040452,
-0.0225346889,
0.0447586142,
0.0197049659,
0.0209913105,
-0.0164290275,
0.0174630433,
-0.0236187167,
0.0353679582,
-0.0347023979,
0.0233814474,
0.0199204441,
-0.0042483206,
0.0710579455,
-0.0418944843,
0.0016552428,
-0.0139036719,
0.0787499472,
0.0125750387,
-0.0524473861,
-0.022160951,
-0.0318233222,
-0.0259177759,
-0.0323612355,
0.092023924,
0.0289865285,
0.005276823,
0.0155083025,
0.0118658729,
-0.0585209392,
-0.0136242341,
0.0108343912,
-0.0010173875,
0.0353917629,
0.0201039612,
-0.0565514751,
-0.0271982979,
0.0462055877,
-0.0094317561,
0.0205633789,
-0.0160230175,
0.0406143852,
0.0205959324,
-0.0441805273,
0.0058307759,
-0.061106015,
0.0074322894,
-0.007857115,
-0.0038000124,
-0.0258018635,
-6.100734131e-33,
-0.0217667166,
-0.0225298796,
-0.0221539997,
0.0229678415,
-0.013012371,
-0.0236593541,
-0.0381425284,
0.0121518904,
0.0482257269,
0.0148514491,
-0.0244867001,
-0.0277279988,
-0.0016737719,
0.090832904,
0.0014826985,
0.0440905243,
0.0849836096,
-0.0050962009,
-0.0564190112,
0.0741965026,
0.0565685742,
0.0168391615,
0.0178792179,
-0.0441881977,
0.0100188637,
-0.0549053997,
-0.0446950272,
-0.0301148649,
0.0141328936,
0.0392061286,
-0.0095658088,
0.0077687888,
0.0032367727,
-0.0148478113,
-0.0233943667,
0.0180922914,
-0.0372886397,
-0.0284540076,
-0.0013212695,
-0.0155873271,
-0.0166712962,
-0.0912866965,
0.0287166815,
-0.020326497,
-0.0218175668,
-0.0045883991,
0.0523570217,
-0.0082630478,
-0.0364740379,
-0.1236658543,
-0.0853224322,
0.0376854651,
-0.0078886664,
-0.0046548122,
-0.0147700906,
-0.0075904974,
0.0000104162,
0.0225664247,
-0.0117413169,
0.0240410939,
0.013091919,
0.027089281,
-0.0039306344,
0.0187334754,
0.0007300325,
0.0401524045,
0.0138039896,
0.0593885295,
-0.023958249,
0.0479735471,
0.0087451907,
0.0290652514,
0.0276277345,
0.0979832262,
0.0167265423,
-0.0340807475,
-0.0335537232,
0.0467654616,
-0.0086024795,
-0.0504139327,
0.0628124923,
-0.0067036618,
-0.0308046192,
-0.0152400313,
-0.0322482996,
-0.0208947621,
-0.020588588,
-0.0073989052,
0.012371107,
0.0453268476,
-0.0510148369,
-0.0442165993,
-0.0114971325,
-0.0161819365,
-0.0132073043,
0.0063988599,
-0.0658337623,
0.0377566032,
-0.0144875366,
-0.0058475235,
-0.0466740653,
-0.0236295052,
0.0356978104,
-0.0120726759,
-0.0064641587,
0.0186271314,
0.0678446516,
0.0109762335,
-0.0748322085,
0.0229558237,
-0.0259474237,
0.0562100261,
-0.0055054906,
0.0046794163,
0.0279134084,
-0.0115503957,
-0.023284493,
0.0444797464,
0.0154383155,
0.017114995,
-0.0105138086,
-0.0352543853,
0.0560322404,
0.0104407221,
-0.0388840511,
0.0286049284,
-0.0375579856,
-0.0231610183,
0.0435274094,
-0.0110212136,
-0.0060507534,
-0.0197660103,
2.438e-7,
-0.005823167,
0.0442314856,
0.0126599083,
0.03123454,
0.0090418914,
0.0467909239,
0.040325474,
0.067719169,
-0.0189964324,
0.0334318019,
0.0068410337,
0.0171494428,
0.0652629733,
-0.0151745416,
-0.0673108622,
0.0618626811,
-0.0576416142,
0.0516733006,
-0.0253050048,
-0.0380418412,
0.0483770855,
0.032228034,
0.0261678062,
0.0129610011,
0.0516341813,
-0.0103725856,
0.1046243608,
-0.0205343291,
-0.0019937819,
0.0375136435,
0.0097935218,
0.0066070603,
-0.040313188,
-0.0430900902,
-0.0476447344,
-0.0146826357,
-0.0214489251,
0.0962339342,
0.0169004798,
-0.011625763,
0.0375714749,
-0.008419686,
0.0019427375,
-0.0272111818,
0.050902646,
-0.0366300792,
-0.0277756006,
-0.0252658799,
0.010153831,
0.0045849993,
0.006852028,
-0.0625050664,
-0.029119039,
0.0131628606,
0.0140344687,
-0.0128900604,
-0.0178355351,
-0.0492888242,
-0.0387021676,
-0.0192490797,
-0.0281315167,
-0.0270102974,
-0.0585695095,
0.0212625153,
0.0018578732,
-0.0307673961,
-0.0077839051,
2.166790574e-34,
0.0437027402,
-0.0013003031,
-0.0032550797,
-0.0495468155,
0.0128701469,
0.0228306223,
0.0020154845,
0.0092328666,
0.0377475731,
-0.0677314773,
-0.013903508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04902v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04902v3 | L4Q: Parameter Efficient Quantization-Aware Fine-Tuning on Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T14:35:05 | 2024-05-22T20:23:54 | Hyesung Jeon, Yulhwa Kim, Jae-joon Kim | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Due to the high memory and computational costs associated with Large Language
Models, model compression via quantization and parameter-efficient fine-tuning
(PEFT) methods, such as low-rank adaptation (LoRA), are gaining popularity.
This has led to active research on quantization-aware PEFT techniques, which
aim to create models with high accuracy and low memory overhead. Among
quantization methods, post-training quantization (PTQ) is more commonly used in
previous works than quantization-aware training (QAT), despite QAT's potential
for higher accuracy. This preference is due to PTQ's low training overhead.
However, PTQ-based PEFT methods often utilize high-precision parameters, making
it difficult to fully exploit the efficiency of quantization. Additionally,
they have limited adaptation ability due to a reduced and constrained LoRA
parameter structure. To overcome these challenges, we propose L4Q, which
leverages joint quantization and fine-tuning to reduce QAT's memory overhead
and produce models that consist entirely of quantized weights while achieving
effective adaptation to downstream tasks. By design, L4Q allows quantization
parameters to reflect weight updates, while weight updates reduce quantization
errors. Our experiments demonstrate that this coupled quantization and
fine-tuning approach yields superior accuracy compared to decoupled fine-tuning
schemes in sub-4-bit quantization. Using the LLaMA model families and
instructional datasets, we showcase L4Q's capabilities in language tasks and
few-shot in-context learning. | [
-0.0012211464,
0.0825365707,
-0.0099522881,
0.0573204607,
0.0379917286,
0.0220965315,
-0.0122694746,
0.0052746274,
-0.042367585,
-0.0530549027,
-0.0525143892,
-0.0274616834,
-0.0298344325,
-0.0176940188,
0.0482670628,
-0.0473755002,
0.0551671274,
-0.0378514156,
0.0161452275,
-0.0139400642,
-0.0143010989,
-0.0068801986,
0.0059151049,
0.0060744379,
0.0653471202,
-0.0059935725,
-0.0238691811,
0.0356087759,
0.0130425254,
0.0051431181,
0.0158939511,
0.0913125873,
0.0381847098,
0.0147605361,
0.0000021635,
-0.0296771191,
-0.0155188767,
-0.0252009816,
-0.0423202217,
0.0454480648,
0.0191834476,
0.0037943986,
-0.0425204486,
0.0014985582,
-0.0104928557,
-0.015835261,
0.0708125234,
-0.0040152785,
0.0642037839,
0.0612011291,
-0.0029511352,
-0.021587925,
0.0391184092,
-0.0464146361,
-0.0012814216,
-0.0264124721,
0.0115324371,
0.0149220247,
-0.0310072545,
-0.0014418897,
-0.0685832277,
0.0096888123,
0.0090050492,
0.0274650361,
-0.0150318136,
0.0038218314,
-0.0737705752,
-0.0060297144,
-0.0082685519,
0.0615159087,
-0.0951411277,
-0.0357669443,
-0.0106118172,
0.004942629,
-0.0173677914,
-0.0909455791,
-0.0477952659,
0.0190493111,
0.0272796452,
0.0214127451,
-0.0076929806,
-0.0246281289,
0.0446333848,
0.023378944,
-0.0309313703,
-0.0103274006,
0.0296315346,
-0.0092591094,
-0.0207228344,
-0.0329786316,
-0.0931744128,
-0.0295096338,
-0.0251033865,
0.0088240989,
-0.0020970765,
-0.0018565208,
-0.0727034211,
-0.0278520919,
-0.0051051066,
0.0017244783,
0.0559470244,
0.078218393,
-0.0185507946,
0.0138727985,
-0.0442847051,
0.0595189147,
-0.005095561,
0.0399779044,
-0.0442664251,
0.0283526089,
-0.0280269049,
0.0209122188,
-0.0614937656,
0.0216571204,
-0.0304512028,
0.0114748133,
-0.0612875931,
0.005207994,
-0.0139363976,
-0.0071176812,
0.0165394191,
-0.0105594601,
-0.0621327944,
0.004029125,
0.0244407896,
0.054663647,
-0.0039109024,
0.0301971287,
0.0044613681,
-0.0356341787,
-0.0211473573,
0.0060420027,
0.0170295443,
-0.0386352651,
0.0392783768,
0.0084140496,
-0.0068070665,
-0.0521879308,
-0.0232835468,
0.0206434913,
-0.0041255029,
-0.068492502,
-0.0173707418,
-0.0512884557,
-0.0055548721,
-0.0368340202,
0.04410965,
-0.0330092311,
0.0094450517,
-0.00362687,
-0.0106481984,
0.065974161,
-0.0157006029,
-0.0167325698,
0.0214347541,
0.0217974652,
0.0219035726,
0.0931574851,
0.0455705151,
0.039223209,
-0.0039650332,
-0.0146402698,
-0.0488937274,
0.0425594188,
0.037184298,
0.0124212652,
-0.0370117575,
-0.0228813887,
-0.0126134735,
0.0461516269,
0.0849565268,
0.0367824323,
-0.0598362237,
-0.0071791657,
0.0425121151,
0.0342104211,
0.0646975935,
0.0196918454,
0.0015946294,
-0.0108085172,
0.0189515576,
-0.0014916031,
-0.0570142046,
0.0410318859,
-0.0072240089,
0.0115145333,
0.0339644104,
0.0499574728,
-0.0341679752,
-0.0518308058,
-0.0197127536,
0.0058021415,
-0.0054022805,
0.0231831409,
0.0328557268,
0.0339018367,
-0.0047025732,
0.0854880586,
0.0458288938,
-0.0493065193,
-0.0058561326,
-0.085189417,
-0.0161946993,
0.0637954697,
0.0228863023,
-0.0056964979,
-0.0242259782,
0.0119807636,
0.0374824256,
0.008337032,
0.0110890241,
0.0068321023,
0.013732004,
-0.0646251291,
-0.0208002198,
-0.0219481643,
0.0095798513,
-0.0075956676,
0.0100900717,
0.0136628961,
-0.0164396781,
-0.031329751,
-0.0169834103,
0.0100568393,
0.0036236341,
-0.0642707646,
0.0314582102,
0.0013390111,
0.0118611529,
0.0027198505,
-0.007743536,
-0.0115077775,
0.0322272852,
-0.0301533472,
0.0555812456,
-0.0492114611,
-0.0192584414,
-0.0424417183,
0.0479090847,
0.0292007644,
0.0571401641,
0.0550559163,
-0.0574915595,
-0.0489221178,
0.0324539952,
-0.0063430769,
0.0221818648,
-0.0376002416,
0.0072742682,
-0.019268496,
0.0492882803,
-0.0453199781,
0.0230481494,
-0.0078958422,
-0.01248438,
0.0355816111,
0.0407940336,
-0.0198250636,
-0.0535375737,
-0.0495781526,
0.0243760087,
0.0102843987,
0.0434048213,
-0.0185198095,
0.0139528485,
-0.0186962467,
-0.0160574205,
-0.0989469737,
0.0375298038,
-0.0485765077,
0.0334054008,
0.0314648002,
0.0180310793,
-0.0005118123,
-0.0145547371,
-0.0250006597,
0.0023635726,
-0.0363175087,
0.012276547,
-0.0105085475,
0.0071789515,
-0.0201302692,
-0.0505985953,
-0.0387574136,
0.0122293234,
0.0200886074,
-0.0705240741,
-0.0307307653,
-0.0592693612,
0.001064992,
-0.0320722908,
0.0348928273,
-0.0072204368,
-0.0427177623,
-0.0177434478,
-0.0044531105,
0.0103891622,
0.0817033648,
-0.007864167,
0.0266918372,
0.0974563211,
0.0199888498,
-0.0182026811,
0.0462302081,
0.0003395812,
-0.0836055577,
-0.0236208644,
-0.0128401741,
-0.0413731635,
0.0665244237,
-0.0321656056,
-0.0145909842,
-0.0739522651,
0.0243087858,
-0.023599999,
-0.0060739191,
-0.0407340974,
0.0069362475,
-0.0107446294,
0.0341849253,
-0.0084684128,
-0.0298892371,
0.0369616672,
-0.0179475639,
0.0038847206,
-0.0152146872,
-0.0140972789,
-0.0299778916,
0.0245254133,
0.0302352421,
0.0410707705,
0.0040369956,
0.0080861868,
-0.0762505829,
-0.0180067681,
0.0059187468,
-0.0374443866,
0.0238196794,
-0.0309103802,
0.010146277,
-0.0648422688,
-0.0230833981,
0.0253075622,
0.0256314799,
0.0050891154,
0.0458846875,
-0.0083905794,
-0.0361978151,
0.0524141602,
0.0402251072,
-0.0133164087,
0.0563041531,
-0.037669789,
0.0038152859,
-0.030846322,
0.037397489,
0.0547600836,
0.0211599134,
0.0373167805,
-0.0200821925,
-0.0011509086,
0.0063301432,
0.048800882,
0.0215000082,
-0.0362690352,
0.0415012538,
0.0327822492,
0.016469745,
-0.00762332,
0.0195586793,
0.0622416362,
-0.0541699007,
-0.0176853631,
0.0618689656,
0.0138064548,
-0.0480397157,
0.0089947516,
0.0005930882,
0.0430325642,
0.0118925329,
0.0343939364,
-0.0902936831,
-0.0439121872,
0.0105959773,
0.0281825643,
0.0237725824,
0.0046879374,
-0.0173277948,
-0.0559321828,
0.0240464527,
0.0458735153,
0.0030984175,
-0.008337399,
-0.0013375995,
0.0018784615,
-0.0478391945,
0.0541864075,
0.0225461237,
-0.0213086624,
0.0135194687,
0.0413327888,
0.0250871927,
-0.0587189421,
0.0323616751,
0.0026883765,
0.0354360864,
0.037637569,
0.0048315614,
-0.0071422476,
-0.004569591,
0.0036787305,
-0.0168066323,
-0.0136051001,
-0.000741002,
0.000521124,
0.0094031151,
-0.0205924474,
0.0497067273,
0.022043772,
0.0227142237,
-0.0279374868,
-0.0065524867,
0.0508835576,
0.0008832738,
-0.00381545,
0.0147845717,
-0.0529324189,
-0.0325604491,
0.0325831622,
0.0408844091,
-0.0139799314,
-0.0238315593,
-0.0147277713,
-0.0087587452,
-0.0486896187,
-0.0221272502,
-0.0199914016,
-0.0245340578,
-0.0421347581,
-0.0333665088,
0.0039218967,
0.0184557755,
0.0040631881,
-0.0235092733,
-0.0062701702,
0.0038238817,
0.008777706,
-0.0951683298,
0.0213795956,
-0.0418997966,
0.0085186725,
-0.0462292507,
-0.0252640173,
0.0390455537,
-0.0094281277,
-0.0063765347,
-0.0231134798,
-0.1344862133,
-0.0513336062,
0.0113071613,
0.0553876311,
0.0090005705,
0.0441426337,
0.0201384444,
-0.0866769627,
0.050113,
0.0504463278,
0.0154490434,
0.0759660229,
0.0405599214,
-0.0263801999,
-0.016468266,
0.045169428,
-0.0489197001,
0.0368744209,
0.0092978673,
0.0535501279,
-0.0351326652,
-0.0404761098,
-0.0092796776,
-0.0147625627,
0.0610374361,
-0.0125155644,
-0.0430541448,
0.003032187,
0.0548063703,
0.0043896534,
0.023443656,
-0.039066799,
-0.0347195342,
0.0189732537,
-0.0066701206,
0.0009502778,
-0.0114368536,
0.0370960571,
-0.012092039,
-0.0042791935,
0.0232589263,
-0.0577855334,
0.013364803,
0.0406051427,
0.0080324747,
-0.016759336,
0.0130680678,
0.0267325193,
0.0414531529,
-0.0398842916,
0.0106331976,
-0.0028904511,
0.0205843076,
-0.0590614192,
0.0600295365,
-0.0223930608,
-0.0529038422,
-0.080253765,
-0.0164966378,
0.069014661,
0.0257242396,
0.0451074839,
0.024357928,
-0.0314374603,
-0.0037896689,
-0.0055688471,
0.0148554733,
0.0010580918,
0.0626678467,
0.0211657938,
0.010169019,
-0.0039356519,
0.0587962866,
0.0360856727,
0.0353992321,
-0.0049352907,
0.0263596773,
-0.0172200035,
-0.0408124216,
-0.0303244833,
0.019041948,
-0.0003211357,
-0.0234651435,
0.0074031493,
-0.0410420075,
-0.0104590515,
-0.0045377361,
-0.0184345506,
-0.0348779708,
0.0323891006,
0.0143157244,
-0.0120345196,
-0.0450241864,
-0.0175278448,
-0.053113535,
0.0265548062,
0.0051633529,
0.0162596535,
-6.600962813e-33,
-0.0518179387,
0.0321255811,
0.0402616523,
-0.0031976828,
-0.0050738854,
0.0020918299,
-0.0239223316,
-0.0070703798,
-0.0395827182,
-0.0236362033,
-0.0096281832,
0.0128890648,
0.0166634973,
0.0073404503,
-0.005813627,
0.0208246112,
0.0872080773,
-0.0136193307,
-0.018483581,
0.040197596,
-0.0053931996,
0.0129044689,
0.0632520765,
0.0546299629,
-0.0386902355,
0.0361712463,
-0.0254911892,
-0.0006336065,
-0.007944474,
0.0450091809,
-0.0343640372,
0.0399551243,
-0.0122333756,
0.0059518931,
-0.0376403444,
-0.0066102939,
-0.0707682297,
-0.0174512733,
0.0018411791,
0.0155385081,
0.0033919448,
-0.048895143,
0.0633418709,
0.0340143628,
-0.0353531688,
-0.0459746458,
-0.0104815923,
-0.04082755,
-0.0273806714,
-0.0713502839,
-0.0264412761,
0.0140722506,
0.0062884688,
0.0005933284,
0.0622367337,
0.0006745997,
-0.0241682976,
0.0111522861,
-0.0689746439,
-0.0152543783,
0.0371481366,
0.0999532789,
0.0711510777,
0.0461855605,
-0.0067720534,
0.0109455064,
0.0316609778,
-0.0125985071,
0.0348847508,
0.0477456488,
0.0669291243,
0.0331741981,
0.0582604483,
0.0415786915,
0.0847220719,
-0.0020693494,
-0.0780292079,
-0.0265204813,
-0.0197097082,
0.0435318314,
0.0170488637,
0.0627636462,
-0.0094842333,
-0.0224824008,
-0.055459369,
0.0017151159,
-0.055051107,
-0.0290674139,
0.014389067,
0.0150584811,
-0.0265815407,
-0.0045054127,
0.0255736429,
-0.0525381751,
-0.0053727091,
-0.0112963999,
-0.0303570256,
0.0209514722,
0.0072793816,
0.0317362733,
-0.0344067104,
-0.0386616252,
0.0426070914,
-0.0090293549,
0.0102896197,
-0.0161301978,
0.0589915887,
0.0565200225,
-0.0713185593,
-0.0087215323,
-0.0276552364,
0.0038043871,
0.0119909598,
0.0665201768,
-0.0004481903,
0.0163002051,
0.0091513945,
0.052559793,
0.010192439,
-0.0080021229,
-0.0292236209,
0.006501833,
0.0084727071,
0.0494924188,
-0.0322276577,
0.0075546289,
-0.0406604558,
0.0470361337,
0.0433487855,
-0.072822094,
-0.043156255,
0.0385632627,
2.85e-7,
0.0273726732,
0.0353435315,
-0.0183971096,
-0.0411208868,
-0.0045653395,
0.0084315548,
-0.0144893844,
0.0352989137,
0.0119855236,
0.0088428808,
0.0206492469,
0.0431233235,
0.015650237,
0.0140741114,
-0.0413993932,
0.0308613069,
-0.038990099,
0.0273172576,
-0.0525627807,
-0.0396343321,
0.012226969,
0.119487755,
-0.0064713382,
-0.01130962,
0.0393206403,
0.0014088587,
0.039634198,
-0.010909521,
0.0002455857,
0.0431394167,
0.0137879606,
0.0385439098,
-0.0211794898,
-0.0368442237,
-0.017846087,
0.015916856,
-0.0520559438,
0.0822595879,
-0.0432860069,
-0.0088597946,
0.0096156579,
0.0329096615,
-0.0168822166,
-0.044964876,
0.0635416135,
-0.0655492246,
0.0056419545,
-0.0747773647,
-0.0084357578,
-0.0128686177,
0.0216326974,
-0.0397729799,
-0.0038970786,
0.0231730696,
0.0260417312,
0.020633664,
-0.0329705179,
-0.0906829089,
-0.02667314,
0.0380462036,
-0.0072794966,
-0.0386199765,
-0.071069777,
-0.0435066782,
0.0075073713,
-0.0608037598,
0.0184255559,
2.608230258e-34,
0.0352055877,
-0.0238572266,
0.0381923914,
0.0074105659,
-0.0110457717,
-0.0107894232,
-0.035602469,
0.0246732794,
-0.0006612107,
-0.0679977462,
-0.0317387916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04889v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04889v2 | Detecting Generated Native Ads in Conversational Search | 2024-02-07T14:22:51 | 2024-04-30T09:15:42 | Sebastian Schmidt, Ines Zelch, Janek Bevendorff, Benno Stein, Matthias Hagen, Martin Potthast | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Conversational search engines such as YouChat and Microsoft Copilot use large
language models (LLMs) to generate responses to queries. It is only a small
step to also let the same technology insert ads within the generated responses
- instead of separately placing ads next to a response. Inserted ads would be
reminiscent of native advertising and product placement, both of which are very
effective forms of subtle and manipulative advertising. Considering the high
computational costs associated with LLMs, for which providers need to develop
sustainable business models, users of conversational search engines may very
well be confronted with generated native ads in the near future. In this paper,
we thus take a first step to investigate whether LLMs can also be used as a
countermeasure, i.e., to block generated native ads. We compile the Webis
Generated Native Ads 2024 dataset of queries and generated responses with
automatically inserted ads, and evaluate whether LLMs or fine-tuned sentence
transformers can detect the ads. In our experiments, the investigated LLMs
struggle with the task but sentence transformers achieve precision and recall
values above 0.9. | [
0.0877062082,
0.0710677877,
-0.0222822782,
0.0201794878,
-0.0280062836,
-0.0350132026,
0.0294250567,
-0.0010291955,
0.0720189139,
-0.0880959257,
-0.0308145527,
-0.0483719856,
-0.0239750482,
0.0441661328,
0.00692373,
-0.0218237508,
0.0114046941,
-0.0344405323,
0.0327568538,
0.0177739691,
0.0199241582,
-0.0089215497,
0.0132663567,
0.051649835,
0.0261708107,
-0.057032153,
0.005398911,
-0.0061268494,
-0.0236158241,
-0.0172515102,
0.0540405028,
0.0405935086,
-0.0091157844,
0.064584136,
0.0000015355,
-0.0847607031,
-0.0167195685,
-0.0080009466,
-0.0191044807,
0.0591320917,
0.0331387669,
0.0418893509,
-0.0065879687,
0.0579061881,
-0.0574379526,
0.061982844,
0.0300126355,
0.0593714043,
0.0373415276,
0.0766635239,
-0.0243075471,
0.0166069455,
0.007117542,
-0.0187847726,
0.0001106219,
-0.0337576941,
-0.0018742584,
-0.0569268465,
-0.0240985118,
-0.0032034812,
0.0397394672,
0.0368717089,
-0.0341074578,
-0.0427584201,
-0.0268894155,
-0.0007196658,
-0.042900987,
-0.0173074864,
-0.0289672241,
0.0191351213,
-0.0264921561,
0.0055499878,
0.0311081465,
0.0266696848,
0.0185066368,
-0.0029466175,
-0.0580483936,
0.0523137748,
-0.003747582,
0.0209713578,
-0.0133774914,
-0.0300530735,
0.0256602596,
0.014802332,
-0.0291753802,
0.0507444218,
0.0287047978,
-0.0547335409,
-0.0006117215,
-0.0178898089,
0.0190868434,
-0.009444735,
0.0482259877,
-0.0075261542,
-0.0315664634,
0.0179120991,
-0.0267711096,
-0.0162501596,
0.0174555704,
-0.095281288,
0.0120012872,
0.0140034519,
-0.0295566376,
0.0398125611,
-0.0455903672,
0.057478983,
-0.0266258176,
0.0051904139,
-0.0245894566,
0.0247047767,
-0.0017587742,
-0.042188704,
-0.0337333903,
0.0388476029,
-0.0205088221,
-0.0369190015,
-0.042480845,
0.0713299587,
0.0279589184,
0.0063804812,
0.0024994588,
0.0089314375,
0.0107236719,
-0.0092132157,
-0.0029439407,
0.0096502313,
0.0275896266,
-0.0035394235,
0.0065658423,
-0.0746688172,
0.0167424921,
0.0726565719,
0.0045967805,
-0.0461893715,
-0.0370066054,
0.0499391071,
0.0094844978,
-0.0379211307,
-0.0506906286,
-0.0622076243,
-0.0394706465,
-0.0162480213,
-0.0050233663,
-0.0382678211,
-0.0160565563,
0.0219735689,
-0.0141887423,
-0.0403725952,
0.0055990824,
0.0234695394,
-0.0510647707,
0.0320010372,
0.018464338,
0.0259419214,
-0.0312396362,
0.0014063111,
0.0677637309,
0.0605394654,
0.0334984176,
0.0740073174,
0.0903919488,
-0.0103742201,
0.0091339881,
0.0668304339,
-0.0050359746,
-0.0086589595,
-0.0249301959,
0.0061245239,
0.0196241159,
-0.0175138656,
0.0011343699,
0.0404639728,
0.0352882072,
0.0141301593,
0.0891002119,
0.0354695618,
-0.0094014723,
-0.0122753987,
0.0113058155,
0.0156575684,
-0.0193802956,
0.0180861,
-0.0440667197,
-0.0222897697,
-0.0453770198,
-0.0463619307,
0.0801962391,
0.0126738399,
-0.0233950336,
-0.0076517351,
-0.0014127926,
-0.0083154039,
-0.0016016071,
0.0291354135,
0.0301546529,
-0.0163899194,
-0.0306206215,
0.0641248599,
-0.0192923788,
-0.0258417334,
0.0187387858,
-0.0510014594,
0.0343861878,
0.0777971372,
0.061412327,
-0.0025539258,
0.018973086,
-0.0138838347,
-0.0479310602,
0.062911354,
0.0427648053,
0.0105019268,
0.0048565362,
0.0015802773,
-0.0497697219,
-0.0071218838,
0.0194464754,
-0.0186826661,
0.0262414292,
0.0331148505,
0.0382869355,
-0.0300732348,
0.0124361115,
-0.0201616883,
0.0258467011,
-0.0288653802,
0.0161938537,
0.0118726697,
0.0263535306,
0.0285515469,
0.0175642036,
0.012479499,
0.0158956908,
-0.025541069,
-0.0363405049,
0.0210427679,
0.0037525506,
0.0101229707,
0.0603290014,
-0.0406250209,
-0.0031460642,
0.0591584295,
-0.0076343757,
-0.0267135557,
0.0391987227,
-0.0441642292,
0.0654069781,
-0.0198069438,
-0.0031313901,
0.0199255161,
0.0583044924,
-0.0241101962,
0.0209355932,
0.0118014729,
-0.001771058,
-0.0077092866,
-0.0304426719,
0.0100065684,
-0.0482182465,
-0.0162757859,
0.0025858083,
-0.035939794,
0.0227566902,
0.0436377451,
-0.006076036,
-0.0258572679,
-0.0053123706,
-0.1005824059,
0.0257755257,
-0.0007766495,
0.0392337441,
0.0248005558,
0.0624817535,
0.0048694327,
-0.0149500677,
-0.0581753366,
-0.0354412906,
0.0358599573,
0.0463405252,
0.0160272121,
-0.0150496727,
-0.0286709145,
-0.0119907232,
-0.0025348396,
0.0111204199,
0.0349787064,
0.0081059644,
-0.0282366518,
-0.068229951,
0.0229539499,
-0.0045399349,
0.0084949899,
-0.0063530114,
-0.0486902855,
-0.0101785604,
-0.0040524434,
0.0374029428,
0.0464626029,
0.0534848832,
0.0105254911,
-0.0086511895,
0.0165697411,
-0.0561607555,
-0.0229796059,
-0.0190741308,
-0.0009033941,
-0.0419641733,
-0.0411084555,
0.0753435418,
0.0643839762,
0.0045335246,
0.0144404192,
0.0108977007,
0.03150497,
0.0145999528,
-0.0120439036,
-0.0514221974,
0.0274399649,
-0.0426625721,
0.0464976132,
0.0163638331,
-0.0572136119,
0.0191120282,
-0.0170406569,
0.0081595946,
-0.0098048719,
-0.0378285125,
-0.0143796727,
-0.0022031071,
-0.0181832239,
0.0341476128,
-0.013839948,
-0.0565912575,
-0.0243869647,
0.0092694387,
0.0411394015,
-0.0500631407,
0.0597400777,
0.0151536949,
0.0042836471,
-0.0217858069,
-0.0369956754,
-0.0888622627,
-0.0865741596,
-0.0191309489,
-0.0061131706,
0.0549574941,
-0.044599656,
-0.0688711628,
0.0536617748,
0.0085643204,
0.0297011547,
-0.0406413078,
-0.0041584335,
-0.0040786196,
0.0933060274,
0.0614483953,
-0.0068647633,
-0.0073530427,
0.0355592109,
0.0160943419,
0.066352576,
0.0322370306,
0.0076242005,
-0.0056617158,
-0.0386199951,
0.0504198335,
-0.0234111063,
0.0008175487,
0.0193632431,
-0.0065629445,
0.0004463061,
-0.0019074756,
0.0929806903,
0.0358450972,
-0.0350041017,
-0.0167878959,
-0.0051675211,
-0.0064636339,
0.0188102126,
0.007683096,
-0.0907311663,
-0.0117550408,
0.021034712,
0.0138144447,
-0.0055583967,
0.0111616626,
-0.0136002246,
-0.1190079823,
0.0198091175,
0.0106921131,
-0.0100632589,
0.0340112709,
-0.0593828186,
-0.0279995315,
0.0085254647,
0.0335425697,
-0.0131008709,
-0.0445629358,
0.0011090651,
-0.0073545859,
-0.0117617548,
-0.0260474514,
-0.0330779664,
-0.0266758576,
0.02771133,
0.0650522783,
0.0261098389,
-0.001759609,
-0.0066056335,
0.039791327,
-0.0181481075,
-0.0028336432,
-0.0025012696,
0.0408753641,
-0.0019929928,
0.0061047603,
-0.0168824829,
0.0159743614,
-0.0420832671,
0.026624592,
0.0274064261,
0.0584390014,
-0.0008577895,
-0.023352731,
-0.0170700774,
-0.0066092173,
0.0109680919,
0.0878595114,
0.0080594979,
-0.0569550283,
-0.0398126766,
-0.052196376,
0.0012480986,
-0.0284614731,
-0.0402994454,
-0.0013952889,
0.0151134664,
0.00039769,
-0.0757468268,
-0.0130326813,
-0.0209960118,
-0.02100721,
0.0254597366,
0.0045147152,
-0.0412470214,
0.0229413696,
-0.0221650824,
-0.0071189608,
-0.0805126876,
0.0093818167,
-0.075148128,
0.0371135846,
0.0290247332,
-0.0714686066,
-0.0236183051,
-0.0236987248,
-0.0639767274,
-0.0533244163,
-0.0301902629,
0.0405883379,
0.022121815,
0.0235853139,
-0.0338310674,
-0.0442280173,
0.0204103794,
0.0948450193,
-0.022562122,
-0.0378819667,
0.0309608132,
0.0417767093,
-0.0044078678,
0.0261077173,
-0.0582000092,
-0.0092991013,
0.008775658,
-0.0180379115,
0.0211365838,
-0.0700395554,
0.0367921293,
0.0741735771,
0.0607060827,
-0.0239368211,
0.0346848629,
-0.0046344646,
0.0440415666,
-0.0071647591,
-0.0313228369,
-0.0502031818,
0.023313012,
-0.0246697273,
0.0324382074,
0.0227228496,
0.042368494,
-0.0558793657,
0.0014193804,
-0.0339896046,
0.005388632,
-0.0008801576,
0.0030452956,
0.0356168374,
0.0308129638,
-0.0106492639,
0.0684764534,
0.0617249757,
0.0279358737,
-0.0254251026,
0.0071927644,
0.0002917,
-0.0154587859,
0.0272504613,
0.0280542541,
-0.0512724891,
-0.0364153609,
-0.0192421526,
0.0231019761,
0.068439573,
-0.0207980424,
0.0403977707,
-0.0214711316,
0.0303270817,
-0.0007612451,
0.0032274954,
0.013917312,
-0.0270154066,
-0.0105933947,
0.0106516527,
-0.022571858,
0.0117134582,
0.0910811052,
-0.0145734921,
0.0128586963,
0.0118000917,
-0.059815269,
-0.0517505258,
-0.0551801361,
0.0348078571,
0.0212523527,
-0.0264716484,
-0.0114761693,
-0.0143294539,
-0.0541157462,
-0.0300120711,
-0.0521965846,
0.0240844395,
-0.0090839835,
0.0121264784,
0.0699301064,
-0.0130533688,
-0.0095459837,
-0.0310716275,
0.0330382511,
-0.042676352,
-0.0148529019,
-0.0366803035,
-5.831671188e-33,
0.0326763988,
-0.0461629145,
-0.0230077729,
-0.0233934354,
0.0158033762,
-0.0092269713,
0.001261152,
-0.012574343,
0.0213833097,
-0.030643452,
-0.0320346504,
0.020610556,
0.0313422009,
0.0569875687,
-0.0252640583,
-0.0232538469,
0.0736057386,
-0.0226128902,
-0.0379069783,
0.0486728661,
0.0479644649,
-0.0000323373,
0.0110508641,
-0.0428465195,
0.0061797858,
-0.0403288156,
-0.0560258739,
0.0266258884,
0.0317027718,
0.0516176336,
-0.0208327584,
0.0474890843,
0.0237400625,
0.0092333676,
0.0264129732,
0.0441756137,
-0.0309082158,
-0.0024561032,
0.0583044998,
0.0483795516,
0.0356320217,
-0.0530790463,
0.0383672602,
-0.0259753466,
-0.0266034827,
0.0187295601,
0.0263884887,
-0.0341985673,
-0.0099998061,
-0.0490141027,
-0.0309842359,
-0.0120674232,
-0.0065384991,
0.0254082885,
0.0067826072,
0.0775425285,
0.0094920993,
0.0450837202,
-0.0095512783,
0.0469997376,
-0.0116815036,
0.0471410826,
0.041808866,
0.0029444704,
-0.0254015084,
0.0330613256,
0.0086828331,
0.0099222446,
0.0399518162,
-0.0491796136,
-0.01818786,
0.0286428817,
0.0014932759,
0.0449363552,
0.0322111808,
0.0027499618,
-0.0139609035,
0.0363416597,
0.0559577011,
-0.0451176465,
0.0449606963,
-0.0191363432,
-0.0303870812,
-0.0079923989,
-0.0073479605,
-0.0119686844,
-0.0663688406,
-0.0462020524,
0.0554297678,
0.043998722,
-0.0137895439,
-0.0296724923,
0.0343867801,
-0.0677942485,
-0.0137291318,
0.0133291297,
0.018729087,
-0.0236081276,
-0.0121302018,
-0.0079716397,
0.0033957763,
-0.0154909631,
-0.0093443161,
-0.0132829007,
-0.0323763527,
-0.0022044794,
-0.0000569859,
0.017705977,
-0.0653300956,
0.0133864917,
-0.016727468,
0.0122848246,
-0.0191874728,
-0.0217289515,
0.0144817727,
-0.0337793827,
-0.0332313366,
0.0097957235,
0.0321452022,
0.007638752,
-0.0150226709,
-0.0511690341,
-0.0102035543,
0.0353394561,
-0.0307217762,
-0.0149040995,
-0.0372329019,
-0.0163009483,
0.0135217085,
-0.0912781134,
-0.0228394568,
-0.0599467494,
2.422e-7,
-0.0419669114,
0.0391856097,
-0.0027376909,
-0.0097557185,
0.0533362702,
0.0303975157,
0.0249447804,
0.0388415381,
0.0218390711,
0.0248232596,
-0.017057687,
-0.0360818021,
0.0229053982,
0.0038789518,
-0.1166037321,
0.0169748403,
-0.0881950408,
-0.0186909754,
-0.0493603572,
0.0175810978,
0.01545416,
0.0832732171,
0.0101046124,
-0.01627535,
-0.0109807923,
-0.0945672616,
0.0447895303,
-0.0002545675,
-0.0156639535,
0.0074154814,
0.009775864,
0.0175369922,
0.0084433854,
-0.0412676558,
-0.020660203,
0.0245682131,
0.0223354436,
0.0827120245,
0.0475732386,
-0.0124551291,
-0.04904145,
-0.0662030652,
0.0015691924,
-0.0468152277,
0.070811756,
-0.0045216749,
-0.0249250121,
-0.0359266922,
0.0004603595,
-0.0856443346,
-0.0341268219,
-0.0486853532,
0.0086841416,
0.0032542669,
-0.0119123217,
0.0184639543,
0.0129845105,
-0.0490866974,
-0.0251810532,
-0.0085570281,
-0.0408319235,
-0.0404478386,
-0.0371576138,
0.0252197236,
0.0167627707,
-0.0313630626,
0.0368002355,
2.133531889e-34,
0.0388008282,
0.0200246796,
-0.0038096714,
0.0238841381,
0.0049098083,
0.0064758235,
0.0304932855,
0.009711978,
0.0738682076,
-0.0712019205,
-0.0014711801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04875v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04875v3 | On Provable Length and Compositional Generalization | 2024-02-07T14:16:28 | 2024-06-07T20:25:05 | Kartik Ahuja, Amin Mansouri | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Out-of-distribution generalization capabilities of sequence-to-sequence
models can be studied from the lens of two crucial forms of generalization:
length generalization -- the ability to generalize to longer sequences than
ones seen during training, and compositional generalization: the ability to
generalize to token combinations not seen during training. In this work, we
provide first provable guarantees on length and compositional generalization
for common sequence-to-sequence models -- deep sets, transformers, state space
models, and recurrent neural nets -- trained to minimize the prediction error.
Taking a first principles perspective, we study the realizable case, i.e., the
labeling function is realizable on the architecture. We show that limited
capacity versions of these different architectures achieve both length and
compositional generalization. Across different architectures, we also find that
a linear relationship between the learned representation and the representation
in the labeling function is necessary for length and compositional
generalization. | [
0.0179075431,
0.0633533448,
-0.0013781101,
-0.0128359227,
-0.0066115209,
0.0121510187,
-0.0111813387,
-0.005597658,
-0.0609227084,
0.0436466001,
-0.0029688925,
-0.1021981239,
0.0382194668,
0.0560659431,
0.0623372309,
-0.0648841113,
0.0364735313,
-0.0102006905,
-0.0236787684,
0.0006853781,
-0.0177596007,
-0.0509099551,
0.0008604987,
0.0469135828,
-0.0003407022,
0.0138400327,
-0.0394722782,
-0.0517266579,
-0.0276738722,
-0.0411654152,
-0.0151294963,
0.0054701823,
0.0157368928,
0.0145328762,
0.0000016687,
-0.0288241357,
-0.024466861,
-0.0127245532,
-0.0031598008,
-0.0162199661,
-0.0183799248,
-0.0404506065,
0.02116579,
0.0135248061,
0.0095460722,
-0.0362506583,
0.0732810199,
0.0676719025,
0.01614259,
0.1032134518,
-0.0075421142,
-0.0671947151,
0.0759554952,
-0.0851897895,
0.0303704385,
-0.0030086334,
0.0105558485,
-0.0401535928,
0.0252430756,
-0.0474280156,
-0.0356253572,
0.0311577842,
0.0661408529,
0.0445678644,
0.0097194547,
0.0268547125,
0.0042883861,
-0.0321268849,
0.0347602814,
0.0567918941,
-0.0616848171,
0.009679555,
0.0112976674,
-0.0239043962,
0.0318331905,
-0.0260174107,
-0.0104081575,
0.0282612909,
0.013995545,
0.0169457402,
-0.0561947748,
0.0120573612,
0.0667793602,
-0.0595350415,
-0.0399175584,
0.058377035,
0.0007729223,
-0.0067212745,
-0.0379277132,
-0.0219999254,
-0.0150916884,
-0.0387958176,
-0.0206182357,
0.0591332689,
-0.0112091862,
0.02952585,
-0.0404671989,
-0.0262547135,
-0.0200847369,
-0.0281362161,
0.0498622395,
0.0232865959,
0.001696982,
-0.0160857085,
-0.0197986271,
0.0720674023,
-0.039125856,
0.0506754667,
-0.0556372516,
0.0074750348,
-0.0429900438,
-0.0030148595,
-0.0360026322,
0.0588306412,
0.0339398943,
-0.0123552801,
-0.0670404136,
0.0238536987,
0.0144965583,
0.0520337597,
0.0014168756,
-0.0056239101,
-0.0819259435,
-0.0038510943,
-0.0378844701,
-0.0046006544,
-0.0202846024,
0.0011052538,
0.0423582345,
-0.0148050934,
-0.0297646988,
0.01298525,
0.0072985524,
0.003755233,
-0.0094480682,
0.0871889666,
0.0008681859,
-0.0408590958,
-0.027263578,
-0.007437489,
-0.0260378048,
-0.0655941516,
0.0427409224,
-0.0470686741,
0.0149745094,
-0.018756466,
-0.0005753412,
-0.0518439896,
0.0056922315,
-0.0015043311,
0.0030601777,
0.0494021773,
0.0319067314,
-0.0345863998,
0.0095723746,
0.0179927088,
0.0165167619,
0.0202757996,
0.0333453454,
0.0221423861,
0.0246672686,
-0.0121414699,
0.0461206697,
0.026349945,
0.0261811838,
-0.0309476815,
-0.0272661205,
-0.0200872775,
0.0519692712,
0.0121527892,
-0.0228931177,
0.0465905555,
-0.021215355,
-0.0776155889,
0.0165184606,
0.0269976556,
0.0432592034,
0.0537719838,
0.0624878146,
-0.0368864536,
0.0059192325,
0.0567954518,
-0.0316467807,
0.0176531952,
0.0579982102,
0.0494787171,
0.02057858,
0.0093952119,
-0.0627153292,
-0.0614052787,
-0.0292668641,
-0.0460574962,
-0.012195047,
-0.0749819428,
0.0575075559,
0.0273423381,
-0.0375061519,
0.0585065037,
-0.031880632,
-0.0216481779,
0.0450564474,
0.00633216,
0.0141756525,
0.0060018813,
-0.0056342259,
-0.070687905,
-0.0140997367,
-0.0402766578,
-0.0037181242,
0.0244381968,
-0.0033764886,
-0.0016332412,
0.0424484611,
-0.023871107,
-0.0008952069,
0.0080348104,
0.0074692629,
-0.0084589906,
0.0069418945,
-0.0028791411,
0.0423659347,
-0.0470876545,
-0.028677322,
0.017854536,
-0.0192151126,
-0.0601540767,
-0.0035289596,
0.044150576,
0.0673000142,
-0.0021374561,
0.0111761745,
0.0450540297,
0.0236363113,
-0.0306617972,
-0.0398007669,
-0.00388341,
-0.0839162171,
-0.0019071157,
0.0303220693,
-0.0449607447,
0.0338158235,
0.0332708098,
-0.0501245856,
-0.0728911385,
0.0405558832,
-0.065835923,
0.0417246222,
0.0184674747,
0.0172827877,
0.0263852794,
0.0167497601,
0.0350713134,
0.0299715959,
-0.0682902634,
0.0129088834,
-0.0337019451,
0.0008928739,
-0.0080404608,
-0.0314502567,
-0.0568597652,
0.0571004711,
-0.0040277313,
-0.0059891078,
0.0174726881,
-0.066113241,
-0.024278909,
-0.0155073376,
0.0008112969,
-0.0190391112,
-0.0141672278,
0.0335383564,
-0.0268823355,
0.004873035,
0.0531998836,
-0.008204041,
-0.0861191899,
0.0076960749,
0.0152962627,
-0.0141902035,
0.0777650252,
0.0366969705,
-0.093824476,
0.002555687,
-0.0331087634,
0.0099619878,
0.0798501521,
-0.0547214784,
-0.0134585174,
-0.0185117833,
-0.0219786335,
-0.0137388324,
0.0566721894,
-0.0641917661,
-0.0255103633,
-0.0030835557,
-0.0074136886,
-0.0113791786,
0.047213655,
0.0204916559,
0.0004181061,
0.0091968486,
0.0328944996,
0.0349001139,
-0.0057681333,
-0.0704807341,
-0.0232610889,
-0.020861363,
-0.0175026208,
0.0105589563,
0.1036602408,
-0.0492282361,
-0.0236795042,
-0.0660363212,
-0.0379738919,
0.0132013224,
-0.0092960522,
0.0223645307,
-0.0139397569,
-0.0253915675,
-0.0067910152,
-0.0234734938,
-0.0599815249,
0.0350155085,
-0.0264332704,
0.0093242312,
-0.0136899538,
-0.0296698119,
-0.0315973051,
0.0714057013,
0.0574898235,
0.008082361,
0.029292604,
-0.0201838706,
-0.0499959253,
-0.016079165,
0.0043162936,
-0.0029381728,
0.0393607765,
-0.0168125667,
-0.0046155788,
-0.0324980132,
-0.0169006679,
-0.0180843901,
0.0230652001,
0.0268713329,
0.0281751752,
0.0254697371,
-0.0664101392,
-0.0470109694,
0.0124368435,
0.0308062304,
0.0559185706,
0.0094877416,
0.0167777631,
-0.0177253708,
0.025219474,
0.0087490603,
-0.0100769335,
0.0004603251,
-0.0394456349,
-0.018110292,
0.0009415957,
0.0019913688,
0.0263045114,
-0.0488526002,
0.0072454894,
-0.0190397892,
-0.0013145295,
-0.05885664,
0.0624538362,
0.0160126593,
-0.0372553915,
-0.0253708903,
0.0457257889,
-0.0341544524,
-0.040783897,
0.0304202437,
0.0503171831,
-0.001607582,
0.0257482901,
-0.0172606036,
-0.0552100912,
0.0096522188,
-0.0032302001,
-0.0028100803,
-0.0225531459,
-0.0407003611,
-0.0423252583,
-0.101707384,
-0.0400037579,
0.0148039805,
-0.0917935371,
-0.0756094456,
0.0087274713,
-0.0206948705,
0.0112156477,
-0.0003561157,
0.0009086085,
-0.0038249199,
-0.0174866244,
0.0495180897,
-0.0308063738,
-0.0265345816,
-0.0393586606,
-0.0170190241,
0.0234641526,
0.0586294383,
-0.0101419594,
0.0088534942,
-0.0625178516,
0.0264547132,
0.0223092977,
0.0092537785,
0.0562126338,
0.0155927157,
0.0095261475,
-0.0225381218,
0.0422456227,
0.0535636917,
-0.0014901808,
0.01352074,
-0.0175607465,
0.0650135726,
0.0348545946,
-0.0324941203,
-0.0027778267,
-0.0422316976,
0.0043261359,
0.0298975371,
0.0393639654,
-0.0178443398,
-0.0174192041,
-0.0241761226,
0.0185374003,
-0.037949644,
0.0157214776,
0.0086581698,
0.0096487943,
-0.0732942149,
-0.0772883743,
-0.0178076308,
-0.0254710205,
0.0858512744,
-0.0099325096,
-0.019487258,
0.0399104469,
0.0028030088,
-0.0389685929,
-0.011485857,
-0.0127796214,
0.0133862598,
-0.0549956523,
0.0157979317,
0.0118674813,
-0.0054518376,
-0.0445372574,
-0.0355010889,
-0.07894627,
-0.0444101803,
-0.0049666283,
0.040965952,
0.0212283581,
0.012324186,
0.0403033718,
-0.0291689336,
0.0854690894,
0.0271999352,
0.0264889728,
-0.0205365196,
0.0920857415,
-0.0091793127,
0.0187353939,
0.0377187058,
-0.0421636626,
0.0187714528,
0.0232430566,
-0.0212345533,
0.0175253339,
0.0274316017,
0.0016921435,
-0.0096580219,
0.0149313845,
0.0278928578,
0.0128581254,
0.0101093045,
0.0496841893,
0.0258463472,
0.0105928062,
-0.0595727041,
0.0331931934,
0.0432174131,
0.0445782393,
0.0289618876,
-0.0251592435,
0.0500119589,
0.0100381486,
0.0400089324,
0.0037345882,
0.0291546956,
-0.0028500173,
0.0368865207,
0.0204007253,
-0.0283329282,
0.0076040034,
-0.0225144345,
0.0086067682,
0.0161605291,
-0.0080398936,
0.0477652103,
0.085129194,
-0.0339410529,
-0.0009748552,
-0.0602302589,
-0.0130410707,
-0.0450086221,
0.0266370736,
0.0154030323,
0.0067250282,
-0.0541294254,
0.009748634,
0.0161083918,
-0.008665923,
0.0256551784,
-0.0303155873,
-0.0317401625,
0.0173063967,
0.0249694977,
-0.0153234508,
-0.021653628,
0.1107221097,
0.0212457795,
0.0470187552,
-0.0467586853,
0.02358431,
-0.0204798952,
-0.0165452287,
-0.0095920144,
0.0296633858,
0.0128575386,
-0.011171937,
-0.0089141121,
-0.0827820376,
0.0413533337,
0.0178836472,
0.0664704964,
0.0155909974,
0.0177336596,
0.0572285354,
0.0110823028,
0.0087889889,
0.0101521043,
-0.0471009836,
0.0628766119,
-0.0115166362,
0.0033767335,
-5.422988537e-33,
-0.0140211424,
-0.0126669109,
-0.0029514891,
-0.0291410498,
-0.0198608674,
0.0168172494,
-0.0269048214,
-0.0148002459,
0.0152212176,
-0.0217884239,
-0.0227318015,
0.0137574235,
-0.0138787106,
0.0621408336,
0.0196188595,
-0.042875953,
0.0546904169,
0.016505925,
-0.0373682305,
0.0066044885,
0.0306613296,
0.0152926948,
0.0653749928,
0.0166173968,
0.0303458758,
-0.0129279932,
0.002681491,
0.0303739086,
-0.0149624292,
0.042298086,
0.0033466101,
0.0355142914,
0.0349027663,
-0.080618754,
-0.0396316461,
0.0013085752,
-0.0616720431,
-0.0325740874,
0.011251403,
-0.0058048908,
-0.0417018421,
-0.0284377635,
0.0758929774,
-0.0257868841,
-0.0058486369,
-0.0344007947,
0.0231553055,
-0.0214500744,
-0.0315438434,
-0.0523826554,
-0.0183275621,
0.0109707778,
0.0075581069,
0.0173568744,
0.0108812349,
0.047769215,
-0.0036499852,
0.0019820302,
-0.0440994203,
-0.0136916609,
0.014617539,
0.0499433987,
0.0233637299,
0.0338117033,
0.0288253706,
0.0213083196,
0.0287280325,
-0.0138202617,
-0.0567224547,
-0.0172766596,
-0.0143723553,
0.0146128125,
0.0437836461,
0.0029521505,
0.0555161424,
-0.0389936976,
-0.0631051436,
-0.0298991576,
-0.0313995294,
0.0340781398,
0.0034790298,
0.0292230044,
-0.019022204,
-0.0221052896,
-0.0282247122,
-0.0401830785,
-0.0012724564,
-0.0037835632,
0.0296479221,
0.0453555398,
0.0269968621,
0.0282893386,
0.0173919927,
-0.006280221,
0.0010389582,
-0.0008082423,
0.0222022887,
0.0336668827,
0.0060548279,
-0.0110548818,
-0.0693945512,
-0.0308053568,
-0.0142798815,
0.0197274946,
0.0098268278,
-0.0116598131,
0.0569590367,
0.0325393826,
-0.0359190516,
-0.0381151363,
-0.0300739091,
0.013780361,
-0.0037087169,
0.0451172963,
0.0890782103,
-0.0125489943,
-0.0189436283,
0.0608519539,
-0.0554070659,
0.006735696,
0.0048513217,
0.0416343883,
0.0183373298,
0.0305541791,
-0.0199623555,
-0.0318439007,
-0.0119908759,
0.0131633915,
0.0690859631,
-0.0342833102,
-0.0004544312,
0.0186101124,
2.521e-7,
-0.0002075022,
-0.0416416414,
0.0788759068,
0.0061425003,
0.028297076,
0.0267685205,
-0.0117857167,
0.0481291264,
-0.0672832206,
-0.0228228811,
0.0355759859,
-0.0170843173,
0.0236086715,
-0.0159732308,
-0.0514500886,
-0.0102618868,
-0.0771913826,
0.0440051183,
0.0058101024,
0.0109974016,
-0.0046364362,
0.1295656264,
0.0409876294,
0.0104947025,
0.0063154912,
-0.050426878,
0.0085310098,
-0.0133020068,
0.0505884625,
-0.0270134415,
0.0333840884,
0.0255878847,
0.0067362501,
0.0175754726,
-0.0055933618,
0.0586998835,
0.0292079896,
0.0196970552,
0.0243777111,
-0.0034786963,
-0.0063984599,
-0.0030545637,
-0.0217330009,
-0.0044254325,
0.0436451435,
-0.0767290816,
-0.0280224141,
-0.0164063834,
-0.0141578214,
0.0001053189,
0.0042140954,
0.0460977331,
0.0390160084,
0.0087548252,
-0.0017736582,
-0.0124459742,
0.0672737584,
-0.0561470203,
0.0153312655,
0.009284839,
-0.0395894274,
-0.0111755468,
-0.0723098293,
-0.0019667675,
0.0349970199,
-0.0279233493,
-0.0225729328,
2.016941906e-34,
0.0329971276,
-0.0441240929,
0.0179093517,
-0.0312858634,
0.0230038241,
-0.0751330853,
-0.0408429429,
-0.0166437309,
0.023436306,
-0.0398568846,
-0.0427376442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04858v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04858v2 | CodeIt: Self-Improving Language Models with Prioritized Hindsight Replay | 2024-02-07T13:55:27 | 2024-07-01T10:03:33 | Natasha Butt, Blazej Manczak, Auke Wiggers, Corrado Rainone, David W. Zhang, Michaël Defferrard, Taco Cohen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models are increasingly solving tasks that are commonly
believed to require human-level reasoning ability. However, these models still
perform very poorly on benchmarks of general intelligence such as the
Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (ARC). In this paper, we approach ARC as a
programming-by-examples problem, and introduce a novel and scalable method for
language model self-improvement called Code Iteration (CodeIt). Our method
iterates between 1) program sampling and hindsight relabeling, and 2) learning
from prioritized experience replay. By relabeling the goal of an episode (i.e.,
the target program output given input) to the realized output produced by the
sampled program, our method effectively deals with the extreme sparsity of
rewards in program synthesis. Applying CodeIt to the ARC dataset, we
demonstrate that prioritized hindsight replay, along with pre-training and
data-augmentation, leads to successful inter-task generalization. CodeIt is the
first neuro-symbolic approach that scales to the full ARC evaluation dataset.
Our method solves 15% of ARC evaluation tasks, achieving state-of-the-art
performance and outperforming existing neural and symbolic baselines. Our code
is available at https://github.com/Qualcomm-AI-research/codeit . | [
-0.0021908283,
0.069286406,
-0.035749469,
0.0114334403,
-0.0159089714,
0.0148386201,
-0.0152989328,
-0.0059185997,
0.0242284946,
-0.0041501359,
-0.0170231964,
0.0048887227,
-0.0120663187,
0.0643183216,
0.0321125947,
-0.010234098,
0.0418521315,
-0.0545254983,
0.0238278694,
-0.0182179641,
-0.0259003099,
0.0146727515,
-0.0199985988,
0.04510561,
-0.0102888057,
-0.0298645832,
-0.0046292506,
-0.0323010162,
-0.0124866422,
-0.0290606879,
0.0093701091,
0.0273263846,
0.0407570191,
-0.0199454408,
0.000002343,
-0.039882008,
0.0141153196,
-0.0421485342,
-0.0257942937,
-0.0082574766,
0.0177861061,
0.0103114545,
-0.0049161674,
0.0256516896,
-0.038273111,
-0.0152210193,
0.0243362002,
-0.0033472807,
0.0813686699,
0.0456211045,
0.0108012119,
-0.0029931762,
0.0141205825,
-0.0346365124,
0.0040862309,
-0.0108507909,
-0.0138201974,
0.0416318588,
-0.0245098621,
-0.0108398534,
-0.0004771401,
0.0417820513,
0.0748684779,
-0.0156142889,
0.0129499556,
0.0459593497,
0.0017413078,
0.0027085319,
-0.0267710947,
0.0288906321,
-0.0510725342,
-0.0480480604,
-0.0330956876,
-0.0120173544,
0.0260312017,
-0.0867810398,
-0.0340024009,
-0.0150453467,
0.0321279094,
0.0192710795,
0.0301540475,
-0.0105859861,
0.0463632718,
0.0128444592,
-0.0444478579,
0.0780462772,
-0.0027678946,
-0.0204399843,
-0.0017721552,
-0.0158233643,
-0.0115724057,
-0.0410390794,
0.0077163656,
0.040597599,
-0.0295015778,
0.0194571633,
-0.0405238047,
-0.0247082617,
-0.0466523543,
0.0054213251,
0.0662060231,
0.0431941189,
0.0227682814,
0.0486423038,
-0.0561821796,
0.0638098791,
0.0254045613,
0.0369827934,
-0.0210652426,
0.0140176918,
-0.0695197582,
-0.0165661592,
-0.0796929896,
0.0895314813,
-0.0097447429,
0.0155536775,
-0.0236340556,
0.0253174584,
-0.0163166504,
0.01987404,
0.0136890411,
0.0174911451,
-0.0543037392,
-0.0182235111,
-0.0064730002,
-0.0090679564,
-0.0387274437,
-0.0116123417,
0.0359892957,
-0.0347403958,
-0.0360300168,
-0.0157342516,
-0.0483346097,
-0.0217981841,
0.0316831395,
0.0897615924,
-0.0120364167,
-0.0187390279,
-0.0362155102,
-0.0172024276,
0.0130161364,
-0.0453615859,
-0.0083780754,
-0.0779387429,
0.0199107435,
-0.0226422343,
-0.0043965271,
-0.0609100722,
0.0011550369,
-0.0185717605,
0.0160006341,
0.0852069408,
-0.0053355647,
0.0017322222,
0.0389895514,
0.0112499902,
-0.0162245464,
0.0557409897,
0.0786083639,
0.0424346626,
-0.0118592409,
0.0064644418,
0.0309946686,
0.0476348549,
0.0277573392,
0.0065581659,
-0.034239497,
-0.017770322,
-0.0510904267,
0.0597099289,
0.0176029019,
0.0167038348,
-0.0256414022,
0.0191132687,
0.0335349664,
0.0483864024,
-0.0006989741,
0.0188682545,
0.0576252565,
-0.0025240534,
0.0066553568,
-0.0443774946,
-0.07317397,
0.074656032,
0.0183827449,
0.003920537,
-0.0070505249,
-0.0090620797,
-0.0321969241,
-0.0876969695,
0.0141127994,
0.0029653828,
0.0029216225,
0.0208040308,
0.0622198619,
0.0400524512,
-0.0498050004,
0.0250413138,
0.0054224632,
-0.0413985066,
0.0033568735,
-0.0791466087,
0.044265233,
0.0554755181,
0.0612807162,
-0.0451266989,
-0.0402228981,
-0.0027832077,
-0.012760113,
-0.0038835646,
0.0108071873,
-0.0150083099,
0.0474299639,
-0.0198746305,
-0.0174886938,
-0.0313583948,
0.0000142736,
0.0358406603,
0.0190275181,
-0.0234730579,
0.0051801028,
-0.0562539622,
-0.0495650172,
0.0334778354,
-0.0604073629,
-0.0435572341,
0.0279533025,
-0.0040320014,
0.0215842314,
-0.0290773455,
-0.0047423197,
0.0331131779,
0.0214473642,
-0.0425262712,
-0.0335471667,
0.016876271,
-0.0838072971,
-0.0480425172,
0.0506217517,
-0.0290927663,
-0.0070766667,
0.0608627088,
-0.0497279279,
-0.0312020127,
0.0994630009,
-0.0279003493,
0.0270191617,
-0.0151514318,
0.0478063412,
0.0015052051,
-0.0332545936,
-0.0284295678,
0.0425922088,
-0.0209768172,
-0.0082558412,
-0.0225979779,
0.0354085341,
0.0114763677,
-0.0259819087,
0.0027574468,
-0.0129458876,
-0.0333160236,
0.0152593302,
0.0103323897,
0.0254491828,
-0.0389737599,
-0.0134528615,
-0.0647839233,
0.0049550105,
-0.0233123954,
-0.0106330253,
0.0022195391,
0.0040825005,
0.0094351461,
-0.028750414,
-0.012178435,
-0.0146814501,
-0.0059951227,
-0.0037995183,
0.0239891112,
0.01655766,
-0.0183507688,
-0.0468890406,
-0.0157898664,
-0.024301799,
0.0163020436,
-0.0324278884,
0.0267901402,
-0.0531025231,
0.0189239848,
-0.0041214852,
0.0467740744,
-0.0336779878,
-0.0298227184,
0.0337615386,
-0.0348178819,
0.0179008897,
0.066538848,
-0.01076046,
0.0104396129,
0.0455894098,
0.0130019747,
-0.0877002701,
0.0383689851,
0.0148652913,
-0.010319558,
-0.0014832799,
-0.0231184531,
0.023331482,
0.0953129679,
-0.0063088443,
-0.0001101185,
-0.0668248087,
0.056254629,
-0.0192719046,
-0.0648029,
-0.0429642238,
-0.0414372869,
-0.0162388775,
0.0169829391,
-0.0497927032,
-0.057427533,
0.094426997,
-0.0079290466,
0.0130460402,
-0.0535638183,
0.0050186738,
0.0043345247,
0.1046406999,
-0.0073193847,
0.0063890312,
0.008792324,
-0.0303756036,
-0.0544378869,
0.001315224,
-0.028091589,
-0.0284627564,
0.0564396828,
-0.07142023,
0.0158145595,
0.0347507633,
-0.0749501437,
-0.0471477434,
0.0106667615,
-0.0015396826,
0.0049666464,
0.0237714034,
0.0033220407,
0.0094883125,
-0.0116375433,
-0.0045476044,
0.0800604522,
-0.0099136587,
-0.0276146773,
-0.0034812605,
-0.0443185121,
0.0234749299,
-0.0269335639,
0.0232707448,
-0.0142058544,
0.0194702018,
0.0105930232,
0.0885789171,
-0.0135081047,
-0.0756931454,
0.028048832,
0.0107554952,
-0.0414538719,
-0.0273743663,
0.0258438382,
0.043842379,
-0.0826246217,
-0.0580517799,
0.1065215915,
0.04466426,
-0.0414255746,
0.0341554955,
-0.0223321076,
0.0122942682,
0.0496837981,
0.0362060554,
-0.0557285957,
-0.0313124508,
0.0173324775,
0.015559081,
0.0243449155,
-0.0371785834,
-0.0025157665,
-0.1234920397,
0.0052215117,
0.0217407551,
-0.048136346,
-0.0129127372,
-0.0116270278,
-0.0343563743,
-0.0213270895,
-0.0296122562,
0.0373640917,
0.0017569247,
0.0148307104,
0.0037913537,
-0.0073081274,
-0.0069970652,
0.0639385805,
-0.0264846981,
0.0693728253,
0.0724264458,
0.0175806247,
0.0189791508,
-0.0065662507,
0.0726832151,
-0.0117844837,
0.0146611379,
-0.0005579573,
0.0308524296,
-0.0058114207,
-0.0138940914,
0.030537907,
0.0354844891,
-0.0268868841,
-0.0212668628,
0.0069600162,
0.0356848724,
-0.0335536711,
-0.0015417716,
-0.013536443,
-0.0277950242,
-0.0139717907,
0.0328317024,
0.0332131125,
-0.0240776781,
-0.0533391237,
-0.0351305529,
0.0046749413,
-0.089110665,
-0.0109252529,
-0.0157641713,
0.0350535512,
0.0302762259,
-0.0480853841,
-0.0474870503,
0.0318752155,
0.0376550891,
0.0164420232,
-0.0410009921,
-0.00772725,
-0.0091859214,
-0.0673326626,
0.0185592584,
-0.0414045155,
0.0049542659,
-0.0414897241,
0.0096126003,
-0.0052797762,
-0.0437798761,
-0.0115305409,
0.0311692357,
-0.0818628147,
-0.036432568,
0.0013768337,
0.1044227108,
0.0160658155,
0.0738770217,
-0.0576742217,
-0.0582903847,
0.0392037928,
0.0040782467,
-0.0068092784,
-0.0068735429,
0.0258308705,
0.0009066032,
0.0182090458,
0.0439112484,
-0.0416690856,
0.053403616,
0.0262264982,
0.0351316519,
0.0148862749,
0.0368526466,
0.0298326798,
0.022948917,
0.0084144305,
-0.0217884649,
0.0222550035,
-0.0320751704,
0.0084284423,
-0.0098276446,
-0.0090470165,
-0.0417033769,
0.0520916134,
0.0277308878,
-0.0171614792,
0.0161753539,
-0.0310627092,
-0.02021157,
0.0098682186,
-0.0105198761,
-0.0306861177,
-0.0073223156,
0.0381208137,
0.0413367786,
0.0029723744,
-0.0146343941,
0.018735202,
0.0061826166,
0.0436768048,
-0.0353978053,
0.0296940859,
0.0238255598,
0.0316579267,
-0.0387332737,
0.0400531851,
-0.0494669117,
-0.0706015006,
-0.0288125034,
-0.0062775603,
0.0622396432,
0.0217217989,
0.0322641991,
-0.0184302609,
0.0242825169,
-0.0080109509,
0.0013310622,
-0.0054686363,
-0.0480319075,
0.0101097049,
0.0342858657,
0.0254012458,
-0.0014951237,
0.0593454503,
-0.0383560546,
0.0602141358,
0.0196573753,
0.0347036608,
-0.0530718267,
-0.0168849044,
0.0021846965,
-0.0129376762,
-0.0140615581,
-0.0147020807,
-0.0055423309,
-0.0935938805,
-0.0098813856,
0.0782731101,
0.0124434568,
-0.00017423,
0.0255681518,
0.0710641742,
-0.0126637341,
-0.0145449275,
-0.022172248,
-0.0029981113,
0.0209723841,
-0.0454979017,
-0.0322537124,
-6.414964342e-33,
-0.0215579942,
0.0264031682,
0.0502345525,
-0.0305562001,
-0.0183066092,
-0.015814336,
-0.0746788308,
0.007211695,
-0.0055228295,
0.0053604865,
-0.0243060533,
0.029199155,
-0.0019288224,
0.0171245039,
0.0597406104,
0.0204330049,
0.049757164,
-0.0153750833,
-0.0809297338,
0.0158672798,
-0.0016326796,
0.0227566995,
0.0523513407,
-0.0469429269,
-0.005287861,
0.0440630428,
-0.0204658862,
0.042729672,
-0.0059313006,
0.0417341888,
0.0210824534,
0.0075239316,
0.0255322419,
-0.0614789873,
-0.0317270905,
-0.0558101386,
-0.0540759899,
-0.0658040643,
0.0250247568,
-0.0249837413,
-0.0667403936,
-0.0299959704,
0.042316623,
-0.0009208134,
-0.0555399656,
0.0039705718,
0.0114454096,
-0.0141311008,
-0.0045730141,
0.0052541648,
-0.0475404039,
-0.0072552538,
-0.0227655768,
-0.0343012698,
0.0062586637,
0.0119139664,
-0.0284018088,
0.0094096782,
-0.066830866,
0.0069269952,
0.0033991768,
0.0406935513,
0.0843097642,
-0.003831058,
0.0311459638,
0.0395080522,
0.0488688909,
0.003249594,
-0.0103851762,
0.0065931114,
0.0608646274,
0.0302735977,
0.0378819667,
-0.0147102065,
0.040866062,
-0.0257385429,
-0.0348511189,
0.0057337568,
0.0002556693,
0.0697674975,
0.0123800701,
0.0201302953,
-0.027666837,
-0.0086459806,
-0.0807799548,
-0.025972221,
-0.0277913958,
-0.0473693535,
0.042231299,
0.0319825523,
-0.0104329083,
-0.0276632719,
0.0135602551,
-0.0250623468,
0.0102155674,
0.0106556723,
-0.0401249863,
0.0330846831,
0.0121987183,
0.0507153273,
-0.0521070249,
-0.0099454951,
0.0212325975,
0.0256045032,
0.0642932206,
0.0071462272,
0.0374029838,
0.0472463816,
-0.0427854322,
-0.0114304069,
-0.0539314859,
0.0237040315,
0.0124275964,
0.0225204434,
0.0238185003,
0.0294661615,
-0.0104949959,
0.0301178619,
-0.0069430145,
-0.039895542,
-0.0480391346,
0.0393779799,
0.0254698042,
0.0212840773,
-0.0316548795,
-0.014808313,
-0.0538883358,
0.008490243,
0.0266611315,
-0.0668624789,
-0.0386190787,
0.0166347828,
2.969e-7,
-0.0098951487,
0.0327138864,
0.037483234,
0.0525496528,
0.0168823209,
0.0467439033,
-0.0293350331,
0.0156285148,
0.0161104426,
0.022095751,
-0.0082845995,
0.0535909794,
0.0271079969,
-0.000320039,
-0.0504012182,
0.0087242899,
-0.0414836518,
0.020138396,
-0.032916218,
-0.0428239033,
0.0055351956,
0.0932320058,
0.0477705561,
-0.01897051,
0.0160045568,
-0.0167510062,
0.0422075205,
-0.0044927201,
-0.0152102439,
0.03618031,
-0.0367489681,
0.0801493302,
-0.0010651604,
0.0017936408,
-0.0289929602,
0.0012075695,
-0.0287247282,
0.0326054804,
-0.0268001426,
-0.0152632734,
-0.0014665524,
0.0127700288,
0.0289078467,
-0.0417469218,
0.0570092462,
-0.0794619694,
-0.0009134065,
-0.0159658343,
-0.0094461748,
0.0182866082,
0.0186267179,
-0.0189446229,
-0.0169618018,
0.0196695272,
0.0171253178,
0.0277968999,
-0.0033392333,
-0.0881976485,
-0.0345850661,
0.0235453434,
-0.011327154,
0.0091310162,
-0.0532557517,
0.0262287222,
0.0205221754,
-0.0890130028,
0.0169522148,
2.698059608e-34,
0.0258082431,
-0.0346689858,
0.0268980041,
0.0210126378,
0.0391531624,
-0.0055788415,
-0.0057316357,
0.0088785868,
0.0209069271,
0.002725089,
-0.0454506427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04854v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04854v4 | Hierarchical Tree-structured Knowledge Graph For Academic Insight Survey | 2024-02-07T13:54:06 | 2024-07-03T01:34:52 | Jinghong Li, Huy Phan, Wen Gu, Koichi Ota, Shinobu Hasegawa | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.LG | Research surveys have always posed a challenge for beginner researchers who
lack of research training. These researchers struggle to understand the
directions within their research topic, and the discovery of new research
findings within a short time. One way to provide intuitive assistance to
beginner researchers is by offering relevant knowledge graphs(KG) and
recommending related academic papers. However, existing navigation knowledge
graphs primarily rely on keywords in the research field and often fail to
present the logical hierarchy among multiple related papers clearly. Moreover,
most recommendation systems for academic papers simply rely on high text
similarity, which can leave researchers confused as to why a particular article
is being recommended. They may lack of grasp important information about the
insight connection between "Issue resolved" and "Issue finding" that they hope
to obtain. To address these issues, this study aims to support research insight
surveys for beginner researchers by establishing a hierarchical tree-structured
knowledge graph that reflects the inheritance insight of research topics and
the relevance insight among the academic papers. | [
0.0500882417,
-0.0353013352,
-0.0203853603,
-0.0220610537,
-0.0129781561,
-0.0178821236,
0.0184088722,
0.0070850849,
0.0499759428,
-0.0122772735,
-0.0229724497,
0.0982609689,
0.004635754,
0.0309122484,
-0.0290206857,
-0.0588008128,
0.0110288393,
0.0147395059,
0.0615875833,
-0.0113146193,
0.0240121912,
0.003204403,
-0.0227726847,
-0.0043848502,
0.0442742668,
-0.0293285213,
-0.0096937511,
0.0039011713,
0.0155074494,
-0.0572514609,
0.020622937,
0.0172128212,
-0.0117076468,
0.0262659565,
0.0000021367,
-0.0201422181,
-0.0426283479,
0.0030471075,
0.004691571,
0.0099310782,
0.0655866489,
0.03324816,
0.0460881814,
-0.0169460587,
0.0138305044,
0.0173846148,
-0.013882813,
0.0548483022,
-0.0354121849,
-0.008166559,
0.0150742363,
-0.0331461802,
0.0275032874,
0.022841325,
0.0593731441,
-0.0011542074,
0.0055163126,
0.0323565714,
0.0240855981,
0.0675334781,
0.0125222597,
-0.0088332081,
-0.0563471355,
-0.0608192869,
0.1137341112,
0.0362648927,
0.0266824756,
-0.0198684633,
0.0318600461,
0.0337875187,
0.0168120693,
0.0036538714,
0.0136804888,
-0.0354001038,
-0.0037069062,
0.1067623422,
-0.0525575094,
-0.0461699963,
-0.0300156269,
-0.0495843217,
0.0226831865,
0.0033787452,
0.0152111789,
0.0097922338,
0.0221031997,
0.0744476393,
0.0038798929,
-0.0245128255,
0.0315891095,
-0.0139323231,
0.0551579446,
-0.0335342102,
0.0167078208,
0.0150919594,
-0.0177662447,
0.002727798,
0.0617827661,
0.0006610173,
0.0443013832,
-0.0025833042,
0.0017366225,
-0.012492693,
0.0319121778,
0.0191719886,
0.0168353152,
-0.0229921266,
-0.0339265056,
-0.0345745422,
0.0077938163,
0.0161987543,
-0.0920853391,
-0.0154260462,
-0.0201170035,
0.0208877288,
0.0150549402,
-0.0267041326,
-0.0074933576,
0.0081277555,
-0.0021060631,
0.0177187137,
-0.0224836897,
0.0370373726,
-0.002629441,
-0.0083792042,
-0.0549631305,
0.0540919676,
-0.0300478227,
0.0300374627,
-0.0369598791,
0.088818036,
0.0305023007,
0.0207207482,
0.029961355,
0.0025743931,
0.0108886724,
-0.0663983747,
0.0264392477,
-0.0413760059,
-0.0359960161,
-0.0663978606,
0.0246643368,
0.0070974776,
0.025618853,
-0.0506029353,
-0.0015241004,
0.0168465301,
0.0200312771,
0.0120657869,
-0.0004641254,
0.0070338696,
-0.0417750627,
0.0110856816,
-0.0706864893,
-0.0131798945,
0.037334431,
0.0307951551,
-0.0068250443,
-0.0198579878,
-0.0445088595,
0.0052149831,
0.0416912474,
0.0092817023,
-0.0365606584,
-0.0693337545,
0.0004141823,
-0.0118575767,
0.0711544827,
0.0159899779,
-0.1010681689,
0.0465248078,
-0.0276330896,
-0.0382511579,
-0.0215387382,
0.048368264,
0.0093472786,
0.0503436103,
0.0339198448,
0.0431261249,
-0.0197429415,
0.0481630974,
0.010195069,
-0.0298298374,
0.0459381714,
0.049706921,
-0.0131427748,
-0.0011208977,
-0.0298362114,
0.0164865684,
0.0009992869,
-0.0069460883,
-0.0120783169,
0.0715528578,
-0.0388841741,
0.0065904311,
0.0489629805,
0.0101568075,
0.0400880873,
-0.0328914896,
0.0032569799,
0.007298633,
-0.0003868256,
0.0692524463,
0.0343680382,
0.0348249748,
0.0406051949,
-0.0233935416,
-0.0349726453,
0.0178268701,
-0.0335901938,
-0.0057545933,
0.0102241859,
-0.0184299685,
-0.053919632,
-0.0075978721,
-0.0636467338,
0.0079950914,
-0.020417979,
0.0022284857,
-0.0299875196,
0.0431869812,
-0.0166733246,
-0.0878378004,
0.0082959952,
0.0087807337,
-0.0048546889,
0.0861403793,
0.023118265,
-0.0349370316,
0.0452746339,
0.0818220749,
0.024946643,
0.0283867531,
0.0450393781,
-0.0188661814,
-0.0218973234,
-0.0091811502,
0.0288136527,
0.0323925354,
-0.0029000682,
-0.1159213185,
0.026233105,
-0.0286792926,
0.0348178707,
-0.0283821989,
0.0068689398,
-0.0037132115,
0.0313551128,
0.0470386632,
-0.0053357072,
-0.0511193983,
-0.0644936785,
-0.010414972,
0.0760452747,
0.009246463,
0.0484156795,
0.041198723,
-0.0657731891,
0.0151386727,
0.0086505525,
-0.0053216876,
-0.0114691043,
0.0188018531,
-0.0116207125,
0.0455359481,
-0.0335839093,
-0.0605709702,
0.0449615978,
-0.0268818866,
0.0128325252,
0.0252949279,
0.0415242799,
-0.0037639835,
-0.0270368904,
0.0099125504,
-0.0365213566,
-0.0117729399,
0.0317826457,
-0.0426229201,
-0.0641734228,
0.024946712,
0.0357496776,
0.0322472416,
-0.0192945898,
-0.0140179843,
-0.0356161334,
-0.0018100715,
0.061535228,
-0.0185162835,
-0.0007390701,
0.0308581572,
-0.0168750025,
-0.0299920589,
-0.0165181626,
0.0453091525,
0.0008521634,
0.028753588,
-0.0362932831,
0.0051199012,
-0.0183240138,
0.044657927,
0.0400569849,
-0.0262113642,
-0.0498476774,
-0.0149645591,
-0.0259418841,
0.0682699904,
-0.0203206111,
-0.017629873,
0.0371676534,
-0.026729079,
0.0296412278,
-0.0122282458,
-0.007077083,
0.0027424044,
-0.0113098379,
0.0603047535,
-0.0452910475,
-0.0308204386,
0.0589023307,
0.053836558,
0.021203706,
0.0241635982,
0.0171331204,
-0.0218310356,
0.0358670019,
-0.0849128887,
0.0060735922,
-0.029277062,
0.0183903985,
0.0031802182,
0.0069718179,
0.0110262232,
0.0014126111,
-0.0297330022,
0.0295944754,
0.0576757379,
0.0030975095,
-0.0272993185,
-0.0016968882,
-0.0347325429,
0.0144260926,
0.0443057604,
0.0060920538,
0.0076679597,
0.0093757771,
0.0293059871,
0.0845040604,
-0.0632282197,
-0.0257774536,
0.0130461119,
0.0894126594,
-0.0211335104,
-0.0039084968,
-0.0651396289,
-0.0018066717,
0.0367456973,
0.0387906395,
-0.0783150196,
0.0402937308,
0.0331827253,
0.047085423,
0.0463963114,
-0.0287319198,
-0.0074121999,
-0.0340330712,
-0.0387146138,
-0.0152604505,
-0.0912466794,
-0.029578859,
-0.0282872319,
-0.0247492362,
-0.0180337969,
0.0322843231,
0.0464772098,
0.071775876,
-0.1041761488,
-0.0281682927,
-0.0705465227,
0.0113789085,
0.0399944521,
0.0194608308,
-0.0734893307,
0.0536207892,
-0.0137262773,
0.0377009511,
-0.0465962961,
-0.0400078595,
0.0234430898,
-0.016061822,
0.021022873,
-0.0335538797,
0.0045205769,
-0.0252472796,
-0.0459992737,
0.0307253804,
0.0286683571,
-0.0824251026,
0.0106189717,
-0.038102109,
-0.0064612217,
0.0237961039,
-0.0545048155,
-0.0309607144,
0.0081235347,
-0.0006139522,
-0.011058649,
-0.0222150665,
0.0397388339,
0.0038609472,
0.0359850749,
-0.0727427378,
-0.0363533013,
0.0247309972,
-0.0083040744,
0.0025846409,
-0.0212410837,
0.0399636179,
-0.0620016567,
0.0242787004,
-0.017849246,
0.0083469413,
0.0768014044,
0.0557712764,
-0.0255339127,
-0.0196983293,
-0.0800728351,
-0.0085535878,
-0.0307506658,
0.0036793042,
0.0059040538,
0.0111616738,
0.0348134115,
0.0071990592,
0.0723566487,
0.0467557386,
-0.0211713072,
0.0561899208,
-0.0509310178,
0.0294045489,
-0.0347552784,
-0.004400488,
-0.0098272804,
0.0014494979,
-0.0089316471,
0.036259912,
0.0164366066,
-0.042732656,
-0.0314863697,
-0.0038133517,
0.0122130821,
-0.0082718292,
0.0226687901,
-0.0206149165,
0.0383171029,
-0.0291611552,
-0.0228065532,
-0.0453388356,
0.0135263037,
0.0081396857,
-0.0637405217,
-0.0072570452,
0.0137401689,
0.0312926583,
-0.044248309,
-0.0404748097,
0.0400935821,
0.0193947442,
-0.0152259953,
-0.0727329627,
-0.0440912843,
-0.0302805547,
-0.0153989717,
-0.0226258244,
-0.0579699278,
0.0150076617,
-0.034704756,
0.0011963613,
-0.0639974996,
-0.0870520845,
0.0013595981,
0.0198156685,
0.019095948,
0.0181883052,
0.025057774,
0.0005059617,
0.0133397728,
0.0121064382,
-0.0027733643,
0.0128892493,
0.0108003197,
0.0008101327,
-0.0417284928,
0.0252035726,
0.017972732,
0.0030301767,
-0.0011729337,
-0.0346080512,
0.0383174941,
0.0228783991,
0.0290942211,
0.0131896641,
-0.0167430341,
-0.0298092123,
-0.0279375799,
-0.0330403075,
0.0065134405,
0.0114262737,
0.0523553863,
0.0057926951,
-0.0637376532,
-0.0171178263,
-0.0244773962,
-0.071400933,
-0.0745523721,
-0.0064812014,
-0.008137187,
0.0261840504,
0.0306328945,
0.000789738,
-0.0514923297,
0.0016543482,
0.0155244395,
0.0423615091,
0.0011044098,
-0.0057099997,
0.0489037596,
0.0458073206,
0.0116810715,
0.0066500329,
0.0431806445,
0.0089905979,
-0.0390108787,
-0.0049920338,
-0.0795372203,
-0.0029640421,
0.0183468424,
0.0530426539,
0.1106981486,
-0.009414589,
-0.0042341975,
-0.0402001552,
0.0018578911,
0.0180632528,
-0.0315141566,
0.0247672424,
-0.0311350469,
0.045210842,
0.0239420012,
0.0241054855,
-0.0602902547,
-0.0173366033,
0.0169450641,
-0.118806228,
-0.0209471211,
-0.0115066916,
-6.482243026e-33,
0.0073716575,
-0.0768649578,
-0.0237218104,
-0.0146096125,
-0.0099015459,
-0.0007270117,
-0.0113438554,
-0.0131961657,
-0.0476105697,
0.0348622575,
-0.031440936,
0.0097749634,
-0.0097191809,
-0.0108949952,
0.0673952624,
0.0547722466,
0.0193087608,
0.0287613049,
-0.0036790613,
0.0673112348,
0.0327075869,
-0.0173863266,
0.0020828887,
-0.0277430993,
0.0355422087,
-0.0598324314,
0.0222188067,
-0.0122786881,
0.0127037819,
0.0610461049,
-0.0140967965,
0.0187120903,
0.0159065612,
-0.0411192328,
0.0138592357,
-0.0195452161,
-0.0655869097,
-0.0606006086,
0.0264799576,
-0.00574482,
-0.0234275423,
-0.0071414798,
0.0197543986,
0.0157441478,
0.0392076485,
-0.0165061615,
0.0982543603,
0.0157816056,
-0.0577483438,
-0.0574876815,
-0.0053215395,
-0.0033705903,
-0.0577672832,
0.064918071,
-0.0276978873,
0.0397608206,
-0.003481359,
0.0200602226,
-0.0324610509,
0.0179680679,
-0.0228180606,
0.0029271932,
-0.0032166513,
-0.0475728177,
-0.0010907087,
0.0049763597,
-0.0564006232,
0.0122901313,
0.0520142987,
-0.0026280584,
0.0025841803,
0.0292307548,
0.0161625389,
0.0220565517,
0.015579504,
-0.0102237128,
-0.0187769812,
0.0109295556,
0.0503932722,
0.0313378796,
0.0260219332,
0.0056367801,
0.0029606686,
-0.0255485568,
0.0104865767,
-0.0619902611,
-0.0271542035,
-0.0627482384,
-0.0160559211,
-0.0362270959,
-0.0149225974,
-0.0239058416,
-0.0391212255,
-0.0001342513,
-0.0028551628,
0.0599612407,
0.0131969312,
0.0653279573,
-0.0174017753,
0.0144089768,
-0.0731220841,
-0.0123114418,
-0.0249119736,
-0.0298171565,
-0.0038892762,
0.0119582526,
-0.0007848301,
-0.0559705682,
0.0040962365,
-0.0447545014,
0.0235922225,
-0.0375836529,
-0.0317479745,
-0.0203798618,
-0.018984925,
0.059112858,
0.0154490964,
0.0378298536,
0.0490393639,
0.0708319545,
0.0229098089,
0.0010057087,
-0.0295780096,
-0.0161070842,
0.0322442316,
-0.0231096596,
-0.012765578,
0.0141854445,
-0.0129752606,
-0.0148739461,
-0.016767567,
-0.0089535546,
3.01e-7,
0.035806179,
0.0325137526,
-0.0189497452,
0.0174140576,
0.047079429,
-0.0062623173,
0.0381606966,
0.0064002499,
0.0275565386,
0.0292669237,
0.0451278575,
-0.0403309576,
-0.0433751456,
0.0591398105,
-0.0762321949,
-0.0940743461,
-0.0181462336,
-0.0534267612,
-0.0531934425,
0.0188652035,
0.0275360402,
-0.0347984172,
0.0068763369,
0.0346261673,
-0.0443438068,
-0.0053964723,
-0.0078173839,
0.0132741919,
0.0576574951,
0.0319090523,
0.0314166136,
-0.0058938181,
-0.0243305471,
0.0684287772,
0.0243057907,
0.0068999561,
-0.0328702405,
-0.057055708,
-0.0039780457,
0.0251227375,
0.0411566272,
0.0051767579,
0.0347364321,
-0.0864375532,
0.0162262116,
-0.0461396687,
-0.0134496102,
0.013439293,
-0.0333873928,
-0.0436195508,
0.0195561871,
-0.0117563885,
0.0048911329,
0.0151171172,
-0.0427430347,
-0.0153869204,
-0.015851019,
-0.0061889817,
0.0279855169,
0.0612411201,
0.0170057919,
-0.0453310274,
-0.0088803871,
-0.0283583626,
0.0067561851,
-0.0036711923,
0.0254394915,
2.44750115e-34,
0.0136616156,
0.0012730989,
-0.0448688045,
-0.0178018324,
0.017975213,
-0.0228428096,
-0.0613394864,
0.0020390539,
0.0485611893,
-0.0446446724,
-0.0040348317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15391v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15391v1 | CapsF: Capsule Fusion for Extracting psychiatric stressors for suicide from twitter | 2024-02-07T13:41:22 | 2024-02-07T13:41:22 | Mohammad Ali Dadgostarnia, Ramin Mousa, Saba Hesaraki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Along with factors such as cancer, blood pressure, street accidents and
stroke, suicide has been one of Iran main causes of death. One of the main
reasons for suicide is psychological stressors. Identifying psychological
stressors in an at risk population can help in the early prevention of suicidal
and suicidal behaviours. In recent years, the widespread popularity and flow of
real time information sharing of social media have allowed for potential early
intervention in large scale and even small scale populations. However, some
automated approaches to extract psychiatric stressors from Twitter have been
presented, but most of this research has been for non Persian languages. This
study aims to investigate the techniques of detecting psychological stress
related to suicide from Persian tweets using learning based methods. The
proposed capsule based approach achieved a binary classification accuracy of
0.83. | [
0.0555040352,
0.0248409975,
-0.0258434359,
-0.0429345146,
-0.0147303976,
0.0519667976,
0.0300346091,
0.0258346554,
0.0929803401,
-0.0053047556,
0.0659748688,
0.0184746515,
-0.0380341671,
0.0306039434,
-0.051585786,
-0.0365199745,
-0.0149334688,
0.0251207277,
0.0366260298,
-0.0086440397,
0.007871422,
0.0462582633,
-0.0389863178,
0.0289926771,
-0.0169451702,
0.0047832648,
0.0281825159,
-0.0372870639,
0.0617490299,
-0.0348666869,
-0.016153099,
0.0274023432,
-0.0425802656,
0.0011864681,
0.0000021486,
-0.0355072692,
-0.0530695841,
-0.0255774707,
0.0129731977,
-0.107461296,
0.0430240519,
-0.0793958902,
-0.0144572975,
0.0234919824,
-0.0334371068,
-0.023295762,
0.0764138252,
0.0698021576,
0.0452478491,
0.0692197457,
-0.0391738899,
-0.0301724374,
0.0205173921,
0.0017038598,
0.0012045037,
-0.0062367599,
0.0525875203,
-0.0201448239,
0.0089397766,
-0.0252858605,
-0.0082089594,
0.0203626156,
-0.0436362922,
0.0419753417,
-0.0456444547,
0.0130725559,
-0.0388588011,
-0.0700684115,
0.0357596464,
0.0175395701,
-0.0088222316,
0.0176975355,
0.0519909412,
-0.0115769068,
-0.0192742757,
-0.018684648,
0.0097609553,
-0.0146212783,
-0.0470585525,
0.0129163051,
0.0531431399,
0.0658985674,
-0.0447290391,
-0.0050196564,
0.0134406267,
0.0058322442,
-0.0049466854,
-0.0199352521,
0.0597636886,
0.0119629465,
-0.06481646,
-0.0081088869,
0.0487078838,
0.0114726173,
-0.0620690919,
0.0078943437,
-0.0373234339,
-0.0948417932,
0.0298087727,
-0.0574060604,
0.0320381857,
0.0413632169,
0.0046843076,
-0.0054878616,
0.026940953,
-0.0213538148,
0.0511439145,
-0.0415353216,
-0.0336786695,
0.0245250482,
-0.0746286139,
0.0471982323,
-0.0198234357,
0.0364334919,
0.0300131626,
0.0075281369,
-0.1094144732,
0.0137717053,
-0.0074299201,
-0.0026118883,
-0.0022631031,
-0.0246459767,
-0.0022865075,
0.0424203388,
0.0688502342,
0.0144838989,
-0.0190209728,
0.0048617753,
-0.0406641327,
-0.0410874225,
0.0789536536,
0.0048712855,
0.0156280287,
-0.017872747,
0.0190011431,
0.0133538442,
0.0037444206,
-0.018151775,
-0.0631686002,
-0.0018591436,
-0.0466098338,
-0.0077898498,
-0.0069771432,
-0.004281383,
0.0365093872,
0.0164372083,
-0.0281852875,
-0.020437533,
0.0394597612,
-0.0352454819,
0.0053171958,
0.051105015,
-0.0509597957,
0.0134248175,
0.0379650183,
-0.0116561381,
0.0121150082,
0.0585979037,
-0.0020884038,
0.0714883581,
0.0420302078,
-0.0347945355,
0.0079468377,
-0.0005726123,
-0.0188190993,
-0.0326044559,
0.0097481431,
-0.0467728823,
-0.0632750764,
0.0074014771,
-0.0408580415,
-0.0000236128,
0.0202719774,
0.0560508035,
0.0386935845,
0.0461896174,
0.039405711,
0.0381404012,
-0.0415923819,
0.0413381718,
-0.0203276481,
-0.0253943577,
-0.0056424215,
-0.0161831304,
-0.0061076544,
0.0069778338,
0.0264741797,
0.0533561632,
-0.0132784862,
-0.0726963058,
-0.037325535,
-0.018564323,
-0.0092947828,
-0.0036157379,
0.039689336,
-0.026675662,
0.0006937569,
0.0207403582,
0.0450786687,
-0.0343402326,
-0.0323094316,
-0.0201032497,
-0.0118538374,
0.0271792971,
-0.0173797868,
-0.047696773,
0.0211534929,
0.0072105876,
0.0226030312,
-0.0001016234,
-0.0345751941,
0.0116322078,
-0.0032145786,
-0.0117269186,
0.0047141765,
0.0809615329,
-0.0008743248,
-0.0363715068,
-0.0165354665,
0.0727900565,
-0.0317390971,
0.0216394812,
-0.0205085855,
0.0247512311,
0.0179081224,
-0.056598112,
0.0057077156,
0.025926562,
0.0184368994,
0.0241378359,
-0.0144256176,
-0.010203559,
0.0316809453,
-0.0415773839,
-0.0542326495,
0.0009343026,
-0.0185348708,
-0.0122010186,
0.0095913112,
-0.055374898,
-0.0056343474,
0.0609193668,
-0.0491422936,
-0.0472159013,
0.0530786887,
-0.0482478403,
0.0042275032,
-0.0093592834,
-0.0084348144,
-0.0217882581,
0.0249005519,
0.003418318,
0.0560234115,
-0.0164203718,
0.0234564599,
-0.1050090343,
-0.0670333132,
-0.0117661599,
0.011050811,
-0.0294821672,
-0.0119365454,
-0.0245071817,
0.0182382241,
-0.0137931444,
0.0113309789,
-0.0210227743,
-0.0257997643,
-0.0953478664,
0.0106766894,
-0.0169213507,
-0.0024699657,
-0.0199489351,
0.023723267,
-0.0334544815,
-0.012270581,
-0.0014557691,
0.0267801117,
0.0140145142,
0.0134079056,
0.0032629871,
-0.0075921812,
0.0490838513,
-0.0342822,
-0.0087410118,
-0.0438972674,
-0.0014531501,
0.026600495,
-0.0877134576,
0.0250511412,
0.005557246,
0.0014021023,
0.0225702114,
0.0184433386,
-0.0498436503,
0.0264214911,
-0.023310177,
0.0532002002,
0.0213540625,
0.026855398,
0.0489226654,
0.035495244,
0.018997509,
0.0353862271,
0.0363010652,
-0.0704883412,
-0.0418274999,
-0.0109423725,
-0.0343848839,
-0.0285138395,
0.0177648552,
0.0045309337,
-0.0110984128,
-0.0564032011,
-0.0441980958,
-0.0307105817,
0.0455792248,
-0.0115084453,
0.011196252,
0.0053719077,
0.0096819149,
0.0332438052,
0.0036746766,
0.009892256,
0.0329538397,
0.0341182649,
-0.0341398567,
-0.0599237047,
-0.0362365916,
0.0097024785,
0.0166658778,
0.0280318055,
0.0782171339,
-0.0012682345,
0.0616673529,
-0.0103982836,
-0.0289801899,
-0.031863343,
-0.0386232398,
0.001535863,
-0.0053901672,
0.0084099425,
-0.012361832,
-0.0258429311,
-0.0109104346,
-0.0572530478,
-0.0260934774,
0.001862475,
-0.0071134521,
-0.0013412508,
0.0041548368,
-0.0136355674,
-0.0034719119,
-0.0063243029,
-0.0093409112,
0.0066230143,
-0.0075091454,
0.0736046508,
-0.0718528479,
0.0108784558,
0.0095216976,
0.0422667861,
0.0736704692,
-0.0246181078,
0.0284686442,
-0.0232511759,
0.0009699224,
-0.0147700813,
-0.0136700431,
0.0028996707,
-0.0271420237,
-0.002251538,
0.025860304,
0.0139495917,
0.0884523168,
-0.0085824737,
-0.0548165292,
0.0104674939,
-0.0222922415,
-0.033290565,
-0.0027748656,
-0.0167259984,
0.0056731664,
-0.0173642747,
-0.0383552648,
0.0362501889,
-0.0381108411,
-0.0328836329,
0.0341624245,
-0.0317020491,
0.0362950303,
-0.0126920007,
-0.0231704246,
0.0138527844,
-0.0346348286,
0.0375380106,
-0.0413211808,
-0.053114716,
-0.0769607648,
0.0001562566,
-0.0003371909,
0.0424224287,
-0.1177269369,
-0.0330647267,
-0.0031853341,
-0.0003844951,
0.0077731479,
-0.0575977042,
0.0729213804,
-0.0133427326,
-0.0750471056,
-0.0217333995,
-0.0170016773,
-0.0192345288,
-0.0175683722,
0.0916148499,
0.0255330317,
-0.0123662511,
-0.041280102,
0.0391692296,
-0.0728691369,
0.0043691392,
-0.0143707963,
0.0481052063,
-0.0136056785,
-0.0355686955,
-0.0449439995,
0.0799375102,
0.0373933464,
0.0160359237,
0.0148123754,
-0.0361242667,
-0.0160655845,
0.0269047301,
-0.0100776553,
-0.0151547622,
-0.0477526002,
0.0054431432,
-0.0207194816,
-0.0866407678,
-0.0445576906,
-0.024982648,
0.0134896552,
0.0117841447,
-0.0401960053,
0.003994491,
0.0041545588,
0.0338871516,
-0.0556052923,
-0.0100717647,
0.0667464808,
0.0178004727,
0.0224982407,
0.0510281548,
0.0392983779,
0.0359981954,
0.0028091471,
0.0240286328,
-0.0675093606,
-0.0297708735,
0.0709705129,
-0.0258725602,
0.012637984,
-0.078554675,
-0.0027206438,
-0.049341999,
0.0582630448,
0.0046663405,
0.0357516035,
-0.0407773294,
0.0134597411,
0.0239090119,
-0.0131702349,
0.0082604215,
0.024221871,
0.0577269904,
-0.0010984173,
-0.0423382521,
-0.0842656344,
0.0345959961,
-0.0247000847,
0.0121558458,
0.0331774168,
-0.0090135299,
-0.0584744588,
0.0065083955,
-0.0330783762,
0.0169878937,
-0.0038431794,
0.026209211,
-0.0298551843,
0.0423123315,
0.0380931459,
-0.0169114918,
-0.0479420088,
-0.0099548195,
-0.05980625,
-0.040184509,
0.0148033844,
0.0648008958,
0.039803531,
0.0008124972,
0.0020924178,
-0.0199437123,
-0.0037504453,
0.0185888801,
0.032132078,
-0.0249844138,
0.019905705,
-0.0111478325,
0.0118496707,
0.0867873058,
0.0585362241,
-0.029631732,
-0.0346713327,
-0.0319690257,
-0.0304368846,
0.0600890815,
-0.0384585783,
0.0692018867,
-0.0218010619,
0.0078026606,
-0.000170092,
0.0221953336,
-0.039817296,
0.0035671354,
-0.0031148095,
-0.0376260057,
-0.014545761,
0.0046218685,
0.0398546085,
0.005551504,
-0.0195095539,
0.0314851739,
-0.0224214979,
-0.0061666453,
0.0416056961,
-0.0086537423,
0.0277364552,
-0.0242729131,
0.0062018079,
-0.0194850694,
-0.0656430647,
0.0914650932,
-0.0472024195,
-0.0216301102,
-0.0004597468,
0.0215343386,
0.0240465086,
0.0407143347,
0.0011096034,
-0.0839024484,
0.0092091151,
-0.0194209777,
-0.0199230853,
-0.0003642809,
-6.102878673e-33,
0.0275906902,
0.0007445568,
-0.03681501,
0.0805374011,
-0.0107138744,
-0.0168197919,
0.0168553349,
0.0298116822,
-0.0031152251,
0.0311513525,
-0.003548166,
0.0464789309,
0.010080575,
0.0161882881,
0.0472339913,
0.0142132863,
-0.0232793801,
0.0031829178,
0.0209144354,
0.0321382545,
0.0400664844,
0.0597359948,
0.0460136756,
-0.1145753264,
0.0293915793,
0.0131749874,
-0.026122937,
0.0138301775,
0.0779914632,
0.0114021366,
-0.03363638,
0.0835806057,
0.0146554587,
-0.0114961937,
0.0130505664,
0.0259653442,
-0.0208536964,
-0.0361688398,
-0.0261289999,
-0.0059404499,
-0.0042920471,
-0.0175596718,
-0.0016589031,
-0.0061620586,
-0.0148376599,
-0.051109761,
0.0314391479,
-0.0127246995,
0.0384376086,
-0.0571949035,
-0.0195577536,
0.0142704854,
-0.0179988109,
0.050293047,
0.0072744312,
0.0727703497,
-0.0033479389,
0.0113543486,
-0.0205046162,
0.0074541657,
-0.0162024591,
-0.0014259013,
-0.0129652554,
-0.0676165447,
-0.0448053107,
0.0284574591,
-0.0541868806,
-0.0372794755,
-0.0081900395,
0.0342682973,
0.001508079,
0.055139184,
0.0814355165,
0.0523426197,
0.015418035,
-0.0451949313,
-0.0519422293,
0.0393191092,
0.0195847899,
0.0020378223,
0.0173570123,
0.009739303,
-0.0141010862,
0.0122039877,
0.0491217859,
-0.0327987857,
0.0027993072,
-0.0159316268,
-0.034962602,
-0.0112778423,
-0.0261739083,
0.0028811647,
-0.0321969315,
-0.0196492225,
0.0547699407,
-0.0440531,
0.0078906743,
0.0761091411,
0.0041977763,
-0.0174554735,
-0.0295386948,
-0.0259450413,
-0.0000555414,
0.0206426233,
0.053121496,
-0.0146124391,
0.0418784358,
-0.0048778346,
-0.0313353613,
-0.007188092,
0.03856254,
0.0423143655,
0.0053371037,
0.031803064,
-0.0373717025,
-0.0026523881,
-0.0119574545,
-0.0163699947,
0.0575905405,
0.053489279,
-0.0275299754,
-0.0262479316,
-0.0239487551,
-0.0223909263,
0.0086526256,
-0.0439979993,
-0.0289007202,
0.0409421958,
0.0421046242,
-0.0227604769,
-0.0037860107,
-0.0396455824,
2.918e-7,
0.0388736501,
0.0497691259,
-0.048719734,
-0.0337811485,
-0.0102598239,
0.0295412894,
0.0322388634,
0.0496885329,
0.026850028,
0.002152903,
0.0189996101,
0.0064213551,
0.0681707785,
0.0882645324,
-0.0298487581,
-0.0804610401,
-0.0005306731,
-0.0221896246,
-0.0648846701,
0.0457382537,
0.1067778766,
0.0519069545,
0.0053254738,
-0.0408909544,
-0.0154834725,
0.0051970254,
-0.0001255798,
-0.0249435809,
0.0005505445,
0.0195239969,
0.012922694,
0.012565068,
-0.0138827348,
0.0057251193,
-0.0180787034,
-0.0469210371,
0.0179650579,
-0.0042820987,
-0.0070624254,
-0.0058662212,
0.0393680148,
0.0375969447,
0.0475246459,
-0.0217555799,
0.0469740182,
-0.0247730985,
-0.0282525383,
-0.0823107138,
0.0141691267,
-0.0199978538,
0.0624708161,
-0.0032502599,
-0.0155396657,
0.0443024412,
0.0222467929,
0.0105595179,
0.0030330494,
-0.0631747171,
0.0030342517,
0.0293935742,
0.0103561617,
-0.0200272612,
0.0263238829,
-0.0059812753,
0.0153235327,
-0.0087512312,
0.0241655875,
2.160745502e-34,
-0.0178166404,
0.0565062985,
0.0318553895,
-0.0251780543,
0.0039581731,
0.0161054991,
-0.0506029092,
0.0172061231,
-0.0352521427,
-0.0595801249,
0.0036957089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04838v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04838v4 | PaDeLLM-NER: Parallel Decoding in Large Language Models for Named Entity Recognition | 2024-02-07T13:39:38 | 2024-02-15T01:52:16 | Jinghui Lu, Ziwei Yang, Yanjie Wang, Xuejing Liu, Brian Mac Namee, Can Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we aim to reduce generation latency for Named Entity
Recognition (NER) with Large Language Models (LLMs). The main cause of high
latency in LLMs is the sequential decoding process, which autoregressively
generates all labels and mentions for NER, significantly increase the sequence
length. To this end, we introduce Parallel Decoding in LLM for NE}
(PaDeLLM-NER), a approach that integrates seamlessly into existing generative
model frameworks without necessitating additional modules or architectural
modifications. PaDeLLM-NER allows for the simultaneous decoding of all
mentions, thereby reducing generation latency. Experiments reveal that
PaDeLLM-NER significantly increases inference speed that is 1.76 to 10.22 times
faster than the autoregressive approach for both English and Chinese.
Simultaneously it maintains the quality of predictions as evidenced by the
performance that is on par with the state-of-the-art across various datasets. | [
0.0332693644,
0.0865957886,
0.0205313116,
0.0184990764,
0.0213034358,
0.0566504151,
0.0321831554,
-0.0079097459,
-0.0102916993,
-0.0058832634,
-0.0045415675,
-0.0298094731,
0.0125540746,
-0.0033895564,
0.0201798771,
-0.0066315029,
0.0314345621,
-0.014498706,
0.0228991508,
-0.0031581002,
-0.0312914066,
0.0123053323,
-0.0048639048,
0.0163099449,
0.0416241214,
-0.0034188742,
-0.0275416709,
0.0090766894,
0.0381239615,
-0.0883470252,
-0.0081548225,
0.0358455107,
-0.0341885388,
0.0510180704,
0.0000020528,
-0.0267557167,
-0.031958539,
0.0235869773,
-0.0059920186,
0.052013699,
0.035094481,
-0.0165729877,
-0.0115928659,
0.0314878635,
-0.0095951743,
-0.0793984905,
0.0252719559,
0.0575055778,
-0.0200795401,
0.0533416532,
-0.0046630902,
-0.0148145007,
0.0553209707,
-0.0573803969,
-0.0381466262,
-0.0718041807,
0.0158663616,
-0.0185392853,
-0.0180744957,
0.0221084245,
-0.0225572027,
0.0542780533,
0.001778646,
0.0210295375,
0.0292398054,
0.0559444539,
-0.0002432873,
0.0024247626,
-0.0024571929,
0.0407637469,
-0.0030115629,
-0.0050254404,
0.0437161587,
-0.0032019464,
-0.0245753471,
-0.0342649482,
-0.0100710131,
0.0280396417,
-0.0570487417,
0.0374107994,
0.0538023897,
-0.0160332061,
0.0309575088,
-0.0063146236,
-0.006461293,
0.0224381778,
0.0508572459,
-0.0131351035,
-0.0208724793,
0.0364594162,
0.0111342678,
-0.050923951,
0.0357515141,
0.0111655258,
-0.0311506689,
0.0197860915,
-0.0216765739,
-0.0370744653,
0.0228034779,
-0.061683502,
0.007212257,
0.0281176791,
0.0132980542,
0.0147823207,
-0.073442243,
0.0358544327,
-0.0177459158,
-0.0760581866,
-0.0062217815,
-0.0346576571,
-0.0260541495,
-0.0036966524,
-0.026969729,
0.0376444533,
-0.0573058687,
-0.0334610716,
-0.0437108837,
0.0358094126,
0.0157072619,
0.0057806047,
0.0305148698,
-0.0084275445,
-0.0129751656,
-0.0145002306,
-0.0145962546,
0.0423096977,
-0.0162728224,
-0.0161972158,
-0.0311170332,
-0.0513231531,
-0.0006333512,
-0.0350970812,
0.0317971669,
-0.0260751992,
0.0033752904,
0.0492474698,
0.0008201322,
-0.0537432022,
-0.0564143881,
0.0042911139,
0.0128714936,
-0.0388609916,
0.0124114212,
-0.036972072,
0.0382863209,
0.0345943198,
0.0183566622,
-0.0543899164,
0.0261983965,
0.0097621335,
-0.0217254087,
0.045920331,
-0.0236422457,
-0.0050830087,
0.0102514941,
0.0049305484,
0.0671546683,
0.0627394244,
0.0185383521,
0.0209811032,
0.011676834,
-0.0092926156,
-0.0271957088,
0.0449320488,
0.0332322344,
-0.0038626881,
0.000937369,
-0.0072633936,
-0.0053139748,
0.0090902438,
0.0739413127,
0.0430164635,
-0.0072487029,
0.0062152897,
0.0507038757,
0.0257005319,
-0.0034089915,
0.0008506724,
0.0304826908,
-0.0077654365,
-0.0171435624,
-0.0326413028,
0.0113033503,
0.0265202951,
0.0044005243,
0.0327316001,
0.0615796782,
0.0847550333,
-0.0085563911,
0.00095484,
0.00794343,
0.0091416724,
-0.0181396678,
0.0323712677,
0.0494988151,
0.0112967379,
-0.0678118393,
0.069889687,
0.036920201,
-0.0134708667,
0.0053714467,
-0.0209782906,
0.0089292014,
0.0820899904,
0.0578406081,
0.0498098694,
-0.0447380282,
-0.0064736367,
-0.0470206402,
0.0769815668,
-0.0122191366,
-0.0138782486,
0.0289394446,
-0.0303523764,
-0.0119591039,
0.052189365,
0.0153134735,
0.063189894,
0.0596976504,
0.0453754887,
0.0317190997,
0.0114682931,
-0.0444743335,
0.0210026465,
-0.0872732326,
-0.0589152463,
0.0287018921,
0.0088531701,
0.014804271,
0.030523112,
-0.0142991776,
-0.0207903758,
0.0274745449,
-0.0424678065,
-0.0142203746,
0.0073054889,
-0.0056058895,
-0.0759287402,
0.0077990149,
-0.012816594,
-0.0032363404,
0.0030538351,
-0.031257093,
-0.0702695623,
-0.020308366,
0.0034514281,
0.0648380518,
-0.0481732339,
0.0458562523,
0.0285765249,
0.0270518381,
-0.0076743523,
0.0315307602,
-0.05094219,
0.0203007124,
0.0389027745,
0.0484869964,
-0.0127052832,
-0.0085498933,
-0.0551587157,
0.028238751,
0.019483041,
-0.0378151722,
0.0202930439,
-0.0198738817,
-0.0160041973,
-0.0155373542,
-0.1035501212,
0.0122034987,
-0.0180640239,
0.0385186747,
0.004054762,
0.0429449305,
-0.0209814683,
-0.0208019149,
0.0099683441,
0.0137680247,
-0.0037800174,
0.0158932265,
-0.0161441918,
-0.0087376013,
-0.0463493094,
0.0062941224,
0.0119640287,
0.0090346225,
0.0207108483,
0.0092662862,
-0.0509353764,
-0.0837375075,
0.0207533464,
-0.0147393411,
0.0053540724,
0.0023342529,
-0.0020154153,
-0.024073679,
0.0092930514,
0.0439910181,
0.0024953687,
-0.0007837841,
0.0367671512,
-0.0196459275,
-0.0251946282,
-0.0344062857,
0.0159561727,
-0.0179399326,
0.0122150565,
-0.0235739369,
-0.0693098009,
0.0028113234,
0.097613655,
-0.0279379021,
-0.0053469162,
-0.0301593505,
-0.0367541276,
-0.0107466541,
-0.0290956721,
-0.0030386825,
0.0289520193,
-0.0249990076,
0.0110124703,
-0.0224204287,
-0.041080296,
0.035241995,
-0.0720445663,
-0.0160603356,
0.0048507266,
0.0018585796,
-0.0435328558,
0.0623209327,
0.0347199664,
0.0030461599,
0.0007134488,
-0.089999482,
0.0337890908,
0.0921418443,
-0.0054892278,
-0.0274717081,
0.0363984257,
0.0214498434,
0.0111350669,
-0.0333167613,
-0.021877557,
-0.0434394032,
-0.0064886487,
-0.0609381758,
0.0096372934,
0.0429274663,
-0.0444985665,
-0.0071920962,
0.0358502902,
-0.0475009419,
0.0371285565,
-0.0192808527,
-0.0007815139,
-0.0243012793,
0.0359008126,
0.0582222864,
-0.0416516773,
-0.001947069,
-0.0116658108,
-0.0106704794,
0.0366717689,
-0.0041010734,
0.0139196236,
-0.0213461686,
-0.031596899,
0.0456228256,
-0.0359276943,
0.004619468,
0.0003545286,
0.013069137,
-0.041587349,
-0.0185434837,
0.1242990494,
-0.0093566757,
-0.0444055274,
-0.0235384107,
0.0232854802,
0.0479118265,
0.0115099745,
0.0225077402,
-0.0700243488,
-0.0299363527,
0.0284488704,
0.0072179995,
0.0087209735,
-0.0454762205,
-0.0228532348,
-0.1405274123,
0.0204401221,
-0.0099917129,
-0.0676198602,
-0.0101945698,
-0.0531339981,
-0.0372175351,
-0.0036926751,
0.013635478,
0.0237772707,
-0.0152215622,
0.0109493462,
0.0139515391,
-0.0015603421,
-0.0420708172,
0.0009686152,
-0.0452255867,
0.0958865583,
0.0451861359,
0.0299172103,
0.0088856155,
-0.0195089001,
-0.0007748773,
-0.01626339,
-0.0263782255,
-0.0408574454,
0.0154467821,
-0.0404152982,
-0.0119053442,
-0.0373485014,
-0.0189754106,
-0.0158115234,
0.0067922659,
0.0079261521,
0.026885936,
-0.0077626882,
-0.0076879268,
-0.008921735,
-0.0146044074,
0.0148682231,
0.0736204237,
0.0281366818,
-0.0324957483,
-0.0175940972,
-0.0099672992,
-0.0265101958,
-0.0539850965,
0.0292896051,
0.0091010081,
-0.0398025699,
-0.0701924786,
-0.0424262621,
-0.0351974368,
0.0363537259,
0.008703989,
0.014233876,
0.0766025558,
0.0416436009,
0.001409259,
-0.0670151412,
-0.0140343895,
-0.0078064092,
-0.0211535953,
-0.0625213087,
-0.0180897247,
0.0316899568,
0.0047193812,
-0.0306238122,
0.0396878347,
-0.0944947526,
-0.0645654723,
-0.0150175551,
0.0078745792,
0.0042928546,
0.0442583226,
0.0097210631,
-0.0414478146,
0.0283227134,
0.0422608778,
-0.0167726036,
0.014676895,
-0.0120302783,
0.0163217466,
-0.0163221657,
0.0223215874,
-0.0233588666,
0.0320672989,
0.0029654328,
0.0507476963,
0.0001708421,
-0.0295296758,
-0.0295761246,
0.0320275128,
0.0452383906,
-0.0542591922,
-0.0124689173,
-0.0478930995,
0.0436755009,
-0.0126209175,
0.0247619562,
-0.0313567631,
-0.0000914494,
0.0388770141,
-0.0200025309,
-0.0277375989,
0.0434911624,
0.0362530276,
0.0245039631,
-0.0261101872,
-0.002788157,
-0.025797762,
0.0367421992,
0.0243272651,
-0.0273204502,
-0.0040082303,
0.013121048,
0.0560106076,
0.0295960288,
-0.0387688912,
-0.0053013987,
0.008150286,
0.0332145914,
-0.0038313875,
-0.0162548218,
-0.0283551849,
0.0014539781,
-0.0377833247,
0.0290450174,
0.0716640353,
0.037659876,
0.1055569649,
-0.023848014,
0.0038375761,
-0.0247028228,
0.0228301007,
-0.0310443323,
-0.0163241047,
0.006388416,
0.0070523676,
-0.0274385214,
-0.0131227449,
0.0713103637,
0.0638865605,
0.0279393345,
0.0277073756,
-0.0346377417,
-0.0361876898,
-0.0287428405,
-0.0113311941,
-0.0062759314,
-0.033235807,
0.0150699029,
0.0093086381,
-0.0574730746,
0.0102123311,
-0.0089020552,
-0.0156305525,
-0.0206373055,
0.0075390204,
0.0025192588,
0.0105633857,
-0.0448338613,
-0.0634427965,
0.0201330967,
-0.0143507086,
-0.0354874879,
-0.0047636386,
-6.600616777e-33,
-0.0522687472,
-0.0526770838,
0.0488376431,
-0.0376884602,
-0.0380397514,
0.0236614123,
-0.0397172831,
-0.0132697765,
0.0448028184,
-0.0090815434,
-0.0220993795,
0.0165677592,
0.024904618,
0.0432830639,
0.0166869424,
0.009495548,
0.0931773931,
0.0164816361,
0.0078326445,
0.0469982326,
0.0512220971,
0.0956969708,
0.0406048186,
-0.0190094542,
0.0119270282,
-0.0222211387,
0.0254212692,
-0.0483549498,
0.0663621202,
0.0345541835,
-0.0463424064,
0.0055940221,
0.0075472752,
-0.0705356896,
-0.0143613871,
-0.0008412749,
-0.1784395874,
0.0175949782,
0.0048062587,
0.0450779982,
-0.0017235399,
-0.0237628855,
-0.011595373,
0.0158846322,
0.0076426556,
-0.0142522613,
0.0062115747,
-0.018474482,
-0.0384421833,
-0.0789527074,
-0.0585566983,
0.0501116887,
0.0227166712,
0.0712706447,
0.0769779235,
-0.0276789833,
0.0074848938,
0.0228999853,
-0.0617978163,
-0.0143326409,
0.0352788866,
0.0261037592,
0.051103916,
0.0627972707,
0.0327645876,
0.0248383302,
0.0475834422,
-0.0202356689,
-0.0348146185,
0.0089619095,
0.0169586912,
0.0160894785,
-0.020854868,
0.0177114476,
0.0803498551,
-0.0464515164,
-0.0645433515,
0.0204193909,
0.0192615651,
-0.0052537867,
0.045649454,
-0.0112932548,
-0.0337093435,
-0.016218368,
-0.0202098414,
-0.0218625702,
-0.0372988358,
-0.0145608541,
0.0495818704,
0.0518607423,
-0.0320024416,
0.0172408596,
0.0575398505,
-0.03256521,
-0.0582940616,
0.0309161264,
0.0292211343,
-0.0012353379,
-0.0250577722,
0.0183061175,
-0.0392688662,
-0.0391152911,
-0.0079641016,
-0.0265213344,
-0.0038390041,
-0.0271745417,
0.0280116946,
-0.0349770188,
-0.0849258155,
-0.00238005,
-0.0223457459,
0.0463917591,
-0.0031977834,
0.0121574476,
0.0329970494,
-0.0398713946,
0.0149696628,
0.0126971239,
0.0430634692,
0.0199087784,
-0.0022985185,
-0.002644517,
0.0317689553,
0.0138283735,
-0.0096949078,
0.0250468235,
-0.0238004532,
0.0268750507,
0.0273452941,
-0.0737764463,
-0.0139280222,
0.0173833054,
2.675e-7,
0.0030873474,
0.0349274687,
0.0246477742,
0.0209975746,
0.0064210356,
-0.0279835202,
0.0303700734,
0.0477828309,
0.0040701749,
0.0396465547,
-0.0006998223,
0.0140850563,
0.0517767034,
0.012272195,
-0.1027745008,
-0.0220038276,
-0.0575716943,
0.031045191,
-0.0577630848,
0.004550097,
-0.0218825061,
0.0606327616,
-0.0384953618,
-0.0135603445,
0.0306887385,
-0.011848934,
0.0523249544,
0.0061659566,
0.0214850232,
0.0278993528,
0.0287989676,
0.0460198522,
-0.0230899025,
0.0121123074,
-0.020598013,
0.0084295394,
-0.0181682687,
0.0668739453,
0.0227137525,
-0.0314666182,
0.023548482,
-0.0340803489,
0.0076398426,
-0.022403283,
0.0777482912,
-0.0114760427,
-0.0133439247,
-0.0290739499,
-0.0267452952,
-0.0098773837,
-0.0068414523,
0.002500613,
0.0147417299,
0.0125078578,
0.019529473,
-0.0581492111,
-0.0200805385,
-0.0754800513,
-0.0057094228,
0.0222950969,
-0.036089249,
-0.0538565107,
-0.0407244377,
-0.0192124192,
0.0086670667,
-0.0496653467,
0.0144926785,
2.630847963e-34,
0.0132856611,
0.0055628242,
-0.0310036726,
0.0751742646,
0.017045442,
-0.0354467183,
-0.0466495305,
0.0283902045,
-0.0264981464,
-0.100549899,
-0.0230770353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10938v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10938v1 | News Source Credibility Assessment: A Reddit Case Study | 2024-02-07T13:39:24 | 2024-02-07T13:39:24 | Arash Amini, Yigit Ege Bayiz, Ashwin Ram, Radu Marculescu, Ufuk Topcu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | In the era of social media platforms, identifying the credibility of online
content is crucial to combat misinformation. We present the CREDiBERT
(CREDibility assessment using Bi-directional Encoder Representations from
Transformers), a source credibility assessment model fine-tuned for Reddit
submissions focusing on political discourse as the main contribution. We adopt
a semi-supervised training approach for CREDiBERT, leveraging Reddit's
community-based structure. By encoding submission content using CREDiBERT and
integrating it into a Siamese neural network, we significantly improve the
binary classification of submission credibility, achieving a 9% increase in F1
score compared to existing methods. Additionally, we introduce a new version of
the post-to-post network in Reddit that efficiently encodes user interactions
to enhance the binary classification task by nearly 8% in F1 score. Finally, we
employ CREDiBERT to evaluate the susceptibility of subreddits with respect to
different topics. | [
0.0516502708,
0.0722313747,
0.0125413043,
0.0360828675,
-0.0144269755,
0.001184768,
0.0097447615,
-0.0018127655,
-0.0250756908,
-0.0522114038,
-0.0279030595,
-0.0186702386,
0.0199825242,
0.0564523079,
0.0064544608,
-0.0052390038,
0.0420520864,
0.0592941009,
0.0071079461,
-0.0074991086,
0.0116664711,
0.0319812484,
-0.0383448079,
0.0433878079,
-0.0217615552,
-0.0096296584,
0.0313019902,
0.0024746051,
0.0211810563,
-0.0188429672,
0.0005010274,
0.0606336929,
0.0328226238,
0.059831094,
0.0000016777,
-0.0092287688,
0.0032561941,
0.0049420255,
-0.0450265706,
-0.0279491004,
0.0220964234,
-0.0400650017,
0.0057007959,
0.0627117604,
-0.0192833375,
-0.0279054735,
0.0621882752,
0.0541314855,
0.0835317746,
0.0697317645,
-0.0287175588,
-0.0110536134,
0.0563882105,
-0.0418242998,
-0.0195108596,
0.0133224772,
0.0256108791,
0.0107072946,
-0.0539562106,
0.0528717861,
0.0120886369,
-0.0284863245,
0.0559171624,
-0.0510421284,
0.0279533155,
0.0194140915,
-0.0090186372,
-0.0181234125,
0.0132392226,
0.0359725617,
0.0017693938,
-0.0362607725,
0.0013213995,
0.0228302162,
-0.0279262848,
0.0311764032,
-0.0385702178,
0.0016563341,
-0.0017500944,
0.0318588279,
-0.0291431453,
0.027074378,
0.0351517797,
0.0079479972,
0.0399526656,
0.0090548331,
-0.0105577046,
0.0006952201,
0.0149907013,
0.0223473068,
0.0084705288,
-0.0535015464,
0.022654267,
-0.014227191,
0.0126514295,
-0.0031401338,
-0.0010791172,
0.0005287501,
0.0235331059,
-0.110637702,
-0.0314203016,
-0.0061414922,
0.0005181068,
0.0707337186,
-0.0196629986,
-0.0024326439,
-0.0421576574,
0.0371070988,
0.0103025781,
-0.0148461871,
-0.0649312884,
0.0301860459,
-0.0123191793,
0.0234060753,
-0.0005675654,
-0.004097274,
-0.0509007536,
-0.0065796394,
-0.0199779104,
0.0037144932,
0.0226299316,
0.023971824,
0.0035055007,
-0.0002532671,
-0.0319007747,
0.068225123,
-0.0366382599,
0.0313328058,
0.0076037603,
-0.020582309,
-0.0066489144,
0.0281706341,
0.0112814577,
-0.0263992827,
-0.0058013476,
0.0032141218,
0.0089589609,
-0.0133755421,
-0.0139967846,
-0.0201781262,
-0.0143188694,
-0.0477032103,
0.0329302512,
-0.0811358541,
0.030642949,
-0.0119193252,
-0.0267851371,
-0.0237430725,
-0.0249029864,
0.0150974123,
-0.0145057887,
0.0545870401,
-0.0089851543,
-0.0221731011,
0.0386111848,
0.0158802997,
-0.0233400855,
0.0539510548,
0.0058709127,
0.0797545388,
0.0281114969,
0.015688695,
-0.0114175919,
-0.0185391381,
0.0431113541,
-0.0122039942,
0.0221065562,
0.0111214099,
-0.0392053984,
-0.013685694,
0.0022146238,
0.0330990069,
-0.0384800695,
-0.0560293198,
0.0517788492,
-0.007839663,
-0.0238841474,
0.0312088784,
-0.0086512817,
0.0271412581,
-0.0080786915,
-0.0112068988,
-0.0391119383,
0.0564163178,
-0.0037670538,
-0.059975218,
0.0163962506,
0.0453965627,
-0.0257652104,
-0.0238369368,
0.0139765628,
-0.0308756921,
-0.0026815217,
-0.0244910289,
0.0242322572,
-0.0038687594,
-0.0270029902,
0.0632144883,
0.0188773945,
-0.0140291108,
0.0104811499,
-0.0537959002,
0.0225521624,
-0.0392884687,
-0.0092181405,
-0.0084731299,
0.0296720136,
-0.0615425482,
0.0444864929,
0.0579847321,
0.0432984568,
-0.016769791,
-0.0232245978,
-0.0161444619,
-0.0252594538,
-0.0334556475,
0.0166568346,
0.0313982293,
0.0261559505,
0.0199130382,
-0.0019390071,
0.0401306003,
-0.0006089468,
0.0012013768,
0.0467772745,
0.0186701622,
0.0012916231,
0.017211115,
0.0396768898,
0.0288384221,
-0.0094111413,
-0.0178244412,
0.0423905067,
-0.0073171691,
-0.0630145893,
-0.020079501,
-0.0334687941,
-0.0061953487,
0.0219124481,
-0.0596559383,
-0.0446237586,
0.0739650875,
-0.0183809549,
0.0004613164,
0.0446796827,
-0.0292178821,
0.0084764827,
-0.0459599011,
-0.0639958531,
-0.0339918174,
0.0209533107,
0.0180649534,
0.0404702723,
-0.0440414734,
0.0033707398,
0.0158849955,
-0.0532291085,
0.0232091974,
0.0269809794,
0.0019949174,
0.0080599878,
-0.028656194,
0.0176727641,
0.0500167869,
-0.0612562411,
-0.0062292023,
-0.0538603701,
-0.0180708282,
-0.0168904345,
-0.0370109193,
0.0147469686,
0.0382510424,
-0.0260013882,
0.0550664887,
-0.0006258,
-0.0505665839,
-0.01471054,
-0.007543839,
0.02318695,
0.0071590296,
-0.0046125012,
0.0217093211,
0.0082428167,
-0.023734685,
-0.0127583984,
0.0724232718,
0.0477620549,
-0.0196666326,
-0.0198304597,
-0.0202897601,
-0.0539797284,
-0.0112877944,
-0.0380826965,
-0.0477281474,
0.0113124633,
0.0276366826,
-0.0257564411,
0.0077534816,
0.0449205376,
0.018790558,
0.0151231866,
0.0746340305,
-0.0331386924,
-0.0480579138,
-0.0706875771,
0.0093866158,
-0.03719946,
-0.0372475162,
0.019343283,
0.0225949995,
0.0033927562,
0.012004504,
-0.0290275514,
0.0442439616,
0.0224391948,
-0.0133521426,
0.0049598203,
-0.0560266413,
0.0192381404,
0.0295101646,
-0.0402526408,
-0.0235054009,
0.0662579834,
-0.0164365862,
0.0427375585,
0.0083991336,
-0.0236996245,
-0.0153246084,
0.0096011683,
0.0236407351,
0.0051379758,
0.0123642795,
0.0017341513,
0.0220725983,
-0.0096552428,
0.0422582142,
-0.0336486623,
-0.0027776258,
0.0550862029,
0.0176443495,
0.0065443669,
-0.0341271013,
-0.054483287,
-0.0654842034,
0.0139975538,
-0.0008216869,
0.0039060935,
-0.0290710628,
-0.0781036392,
-0.0075470544,
0.0138278957,
0.0157548487,
-0.0288277976,
0.0008859545,
0.0236285571,
0.0560409017,
0.0156548824,
0.0360526592,
0.0648142919,
-0.0134711675,
-0.0210878421,
0.0734638199,
-0.0429195054,
0.0073002898,
-0.0484184846,
-0.0706464127,
-0.0303993206,
-0.0221239664,
0.0394785218,
-0.0428471789,
-0.0158820692,
-0.0114965849,
0.0062525575,
0.0939631313,
0.0145655833,
-0.0512448475,
-0.0318907797,
-0.007603135,
-0.0138160409,
0.0466772467,
0.0059234016,
-0.0821241811,
0.01317262,
-0.0320090801,
-0.0013364378,
-0.0091789234,
-0.0289075691,
-0.0090267509,
-0.0774294287,
0.0294130445,
-0.0382134803,
-0.0324733183,
-0.0515430756,
-0.1065476909,
-0.0002127849,
-0.0131388316,
-0.0062188092,
-0.0162346251,
0.0551911779,
-0.0056800358,
0.0266840234,
-0.0408364683,
-0.0413153656,
0.0187344924,
-0.0203032028,
0.0295886584,
0.0094743343,
0.0300466008,
-0.0201753434,
-0.0388616696,
-0.0107070068,
-0.0017680944,
-0.0580397248,
0.0078540593,
0.1380764693,
-0.0446772203,
0.0165132433,
-0.00211559,
0.0061203623,
-0.0263130683,
-0.0232551582,
-0.0257163905,
0.0552217886,
-0.0037689125,
-0.0476073883,
-0.017300427,
-0.0082785096,
0.0394854173,
0.0444567092,
0.0335087739,
0.0199340582,
0.0257541928,
-0.0157049056,
0.0128059015,
-0.0232034624,
-0.041481737,
0.0005653768,
0.0578742251,
-0.0743173435,
-0.0667824224,
0.0113163255,
-0.0538918227,
-0.0068765553,
-0.0567677915,
-0.0623382255,
0.0827817246,
-0.0267348439,
-0.0349519253,
0.0245816689,
-0.0264769625,
0.0179332476,
-0.0244049169,
0.0116025358,
0.0484808311,
-0.0028408335,
-0.0328738689,
0.0026553387,
-0.0644693747,
-0.0296032541,
-0.0140525363,
0.0344794467,
0.0201959386,
0.0308427643,
-0.0391323939,
-0.0147851501,
0.0222757738,
0.0324833728,
-0.0256217401,
-0.0237478539,
0.0304297078,
-0.0319890566,
0.0068806033,
0.0019995251,
0.0048698587,
0.069493413,
-0.0126935486,
-0.0343650989,
-0.0523868799,
-0.0181693248,
0.023106385,
0.0159869734,
0.0803293511,
0.0461141132,
0.0203162022,
-0.0480644703,
-0.0175594892,
-0.0163429435,
0.0196224507,
-0.0102032879,
0.0050848457,
0.0239229742,
-0.0143154254,
-0.0191807617,
0.001965526,
-0.0202913545,
0.0283087678,
-0.0209530275,
-0.0074767685,
0.0059377658,
0.0357191861,
-0.0179056153,
0.032790754,
-0.0461676568,
-0.0184964314,
0.0372453667,
0.0177598447,
-0.0204295833,
0.0235206243,
0.0196587536,
-0.0168406237,
0.0508208275,
0.005285006,
-0.0929963663,
0.0089816758,
-0.0330953933,
0.0134770283,
0.0274389181,
0.0134077687,
0.0187525228,
-0.025254285,
-0.0224425029,
-0.0043786587,
0.0245281886,
0.0256097037,
-0.022919666,
0.0297811888,
0.01428652,
-0.0476627089,
0.0363587476,
0.0369489454,
-0.0561339334,
0.0042829877,
0.010244268,
-0.0680465624,
-0.0235484354,
-0.0420971587,
-0.0516878106,
0.0331950709,
-0.0087864092,
-0.0163176805,
-0.0090916352,
-0.0596141443,
0.0431260504,
0.014246433,
0.0414077528,
0.0238729734,
0.0096901907,
0.0425300263,
0.0322367363,
0.0561507344,
-0.0295945667,
-0.0136105409,
-0.0335904658,
-0.0174687691,
-0.0094887139,
-6.347942797e-33,
0.0396599174,
-0.0459055677,
-0.0415643752,
0.0445576236,
-0.0116673922,
0.0454574637,
-0.0294589028,
-0.0141001465,
-0.0470473804,
0.0323644429,
0.0366246216,
0.0405913927,
-0.0066491333,
0.0113158496,
-0.0561004169,
-0.0130615095,
0.0475148298,
-0.0036289641,
-0.0095711583,
0.0147233419,
0.0362000056,
-0.025190156,
0.0248247832,
-0.088766627,
0.0127567388,
0.0033553138,
-0.0091741597,
0.0264716484,
0.0139217013,
0.062728174,
-0.0293685794,
0.0694486499,
0.0514098741,
-0.0461581349,
0.0379632041,
0.0418528393,
-0.0821213797,
-0.0199050773,
-0.0325847901,
-0.0256636031,
-0.0463360697,
0.0040713539,
0.0441325456,
0.0053407839,
0.0083302213,
-0.0334458016,
0.0368645489,
-0.001345852,
0.0117632393,
-0.0189558491,
-0.0242797248,
0.0141664045,
-0.0065859659,
-0.0136188995,
-0.0476460755,
0.0770675987,
0.0532861948,
0.038418822,
-0.0757211968,
0.0000562136,
-0.0802110881,
0.0164560974,
0.023169633,
-0.0499457642,
-0.0414416008,
0.0579669513,
-0.0125541668,
0.0399609841,
-0.0645533949,
-0.0160563271,
0.0042882292,
0.0252502766,
0.1105034128,
0.1026195362,
0.0452549346,
-0.0653018355,
-0.1390112042,
0.0225279126,
0.0599655956,
0.0259863231,
0.0394079834,
-0.0359019041,
0.0279537458,
0.0153815756,
-0.0195958018,
-0.0243246332,
-0.0464020483,
-0.0399003364,
-0.0548038669,
0.0170659758,
-0.0242882408,
0.0511901006,
0.0195515975,
-0.0629309788,
-0.0067910701,
0.067190282,
-0.0050692381,
0.0165405329,
0.0248376541,
0.0380285382,
-0.0450225882,
0.0551224276,
0.0081893541,
0.0245756377,
0.0238225255,
0.0057709091,
0.0933107138,
-0.0020776913,
-0.0380719379,
0.0102580953,
-0.0579671934,
0.0370321274,
-0.0350753516,
0.0451625362,
0.0155533049,
0.0269146077,
-0.0068889381,
0.0243631825,
-0.0277864281,
0.0500467308,
0.0084794573,
0.0026100152,
0.0112071326,
0.013649906,
-0.0319018289,
-0.0185409989,
-0.0262209047,
0.0249804314,
-0.0101717832,
-0.063942194,
0.0120489132,
-0.002862755,
2.64e-7,
0.023521876,
0.0491655059,
0.0142539954,
-0.0116865737,
0.0431390852,
0.0043644127,
0.0222367421,
0.0431318171,
0.0021210057,
-0.0830893889,
-0.025431186,
0.0440768339,
0.0243884157,
0.041686058,
-0.0580026247,
-0.0229714978,
-0.1017152295,
0.003000899,
-0.015243534,
0.0192593541,
0.0265220664,
0.0783402175,
0.0190071035,
-0.0061194133,
-0.0052432474,
0.0144451167,
0.0800070465,
0.011709135,
-0.0149585139,
-0.0109802186,
0.0211587735,
-0.0344261341,
0.0071313139,
0.0001366149,
-0.0260577202,
-0.0026190784,
-0.0083455071,
0.0350040086,
0.0126992585,
-0.0388790481,
0.0170411766,
-0.0069228243,
0.043902114,
-0.0120393429,
0.0433275662,
-0.0917510018,
-0.0424179547,
-0.0858948454,
-0.0702920035,
-0.0007881261,
0.0878190324,
0.0138449483,
-0.0191356726,
0.0240314193,
-0.0165340006,
0.011769142,
0.027518779,
-0.0675431564,
0.0077425493,
-0.0291642603,
-0.0536075868,
-0.0260454267,
0.0200703125,
-0.045066759,
0.0589060411,
0.0258974191,
0.0579400212,
1.804241828e-34,
0.0402928181,
-0.0120043354,
0.0052206866,
-0.0493332483,
0.0511573702,
0.0108720278,
-0.0176156368,
-0.0367624946,
0.0266691856,
-0.0305445455,
-0.0039748233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06988v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06988v1 | Guiding LLMs The Right Way: Fast, Non-Invasive Constrained Generation | 2024-02-07T13:36:02 | 2024-02-07T13:36:02 | Luca Beurer-Kellner, Marc Fischer, Martin Vechev | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | To ensure that text generated by large language models (LLMs) is in an
expected format, constrained decoding proposes to enforce strict formal
language constraints during generation. However, as we show in this work, not
only do such methods incur performance overhead during generation, but many of
them also significantly impair task accuracy, if they do not correctly align
the underlying LLM sub-word vocabularies with external constraints. To address
this, we present a novel decoding algorithm, DOMINO, that can enforce
constraints in a fully subword-aligned fashion, while leveraging
pre-computation and speculative decoding to achieve virtually no overhead and
in some cases even almost 2$\times$ speedup over unconstrained decoding --
thereby outperforming existing approaches by a wide margin. | [
0.0194048882,
0.105268389,
0.016917143,
0.0338559076,
-0.0088402526,
-0.016933253,
-0.0231300443,
0.0286793765,
-0.0141638964,
-0.0355530046,
-0.0024103792,
-0.056373518,
-0.0068365512,
0.0309298895,
0.014680176,
-0.0134920664,
0.0307616405,
-0.0365128405,
-0.0009308897,
-0.004315231,
0.0032435232,
0.0257426351,
0.0219606627,
0.0210540406,
-0.0088666398,
-0.0233566966,
-0.0235219281,
0.0173706058,
-0.0112902252,
-0.0065472079,
0.003134646,
0.0534521118,
0.0157306772,
0.047419697,
0.0000021938,
-0.0289730038,
-0.0573534966,
-0.0069185644,
-0.0057125674,
0.0588600673,
0.0379500613,
-0.0700961128,
-0.0354554579,
0.0281213988,
-0.0294777639,
-0.0165959969,
0.0412255712,
-0.0234648436,
0.0586578064,
0.0768729597,
-0.0262915175,
0.0068613174,
0.0023803222,
-0.0080297543,
-0.0116122561,
-0.0331487842,
-0.0044143577,
0.0336714014,
-0.0010373589,
-0.0000858816,
0.0053188815,
0.0149811534,
0.0007574734,
0.005762761,
-0.0094397077,
0.0271038562,
0.0023733012,
-0.0385169163,
-0.0469360799,
0.0595805794,
0.0086300215,
-0.0569822565,
0.0120312702,
-0.0112069165,
-0.0273684282,
-0.0105211511,
-0.0205225963,
0.0837309361,
-0.0199072808,
0.0400162563,
0.0464189425,
0.0251144096,
0.049491778,
0.0038524824,
-0.0413484462,
0.0526266545,
0.0357913896,
-0.0509146526,
-0.0278753582,
0.0067148111,
-0.0014090537,
-0.044252634,
0.0243669376,
0.0194185246,
-0.0351153463,
0.0135490494,
-0.0947760418,
-0.0541272536,
0.021003712,
-0.0317142047,
0.0523542278,
0.0553139783,
0.0404775292,
-0.0013936406,
-0.0139681837,
0.0420082286,
-0.0409377888,
-0.0205998886,
-0.0564860478,
0.0142913107,
0.0083796233,
-0.0277636088,
-0.0676517338,
0.020114148,
-0.0593105294,
-0.0460097976,
0.002661976,
0.0560515039,
0.0426972508,
0.020610502,
0.0021096892,
0.0023495101,
-0.030155817,
-0.0274163671,
0.0467259623,
-0.0147012388,
-0.0116017461,
-0.0204825681,
0.010103914,
-0.0237452891,
-0.0160236191,
0.0535609424,
0.0131753478,
-0.0029518057,
-0.0312976949,
0.0721037462,
-0.0173517801,
-0.0017852428,
-0.014521569,
-0.0453920886,
-0.0040674955,
-0.029778501,
-0.0127907004,
-0.0674885139,
0.0071230214,
0.001313189,
-0.0000565746,
-0.0414756052,
0.0402203724,
0.0095879827,
-0.0049419762,
0.0484878086,
-0.0489001498,
0.0022508795,
0.0120896567,
0.0182813052,
0.0375952087,
0.0778979063,
0.050475806,
0.0452040844,
0.0262038354,
0.0129718222,
0.0009202952,
0.0918527097,
0.0283252075,
0.0118641937,
-0.0460427925,
-0.0272924863,
0.0379144326,
0.0294110309,
0.0681912377,
0.0679167509,
-0.027481107,
0.0349042155,
0.0321360901,
0.0262800138,
-0.0115713049,
0.0406380482,
0.039784696,
0.0327008665,
-0.0083313677,
0.020126272,
-0.0147032272,
-0.0148478188,
-0.0204246081,
0.0223013163,
0.0418585613,
0.0190560333,
-0.005269194,
-0.0033094459,
-0.0216952711,
-0.0183909833,
0.0298749357,
-0.0265279058,
0.0234149192,
0.023831347,
-0.0812682286,
0.0962380469,
0.0150434989,
-0.0688158199,
0.0035472065,
-0.0283675138,
0.008580761,
0.0799184889,
0.0724905953,
0.0065730345,
-0.015593145,
0.029522175,
-0.0057921163,
0.1024133191,
0.0232094452,
0.004491922,
0.0002137415,
-0.0741345212,
-0.0181903131,
0.0343352817,
0.0130128004,
0.0206665006,
0.0483587161,
-0.0072452771,
0.0301869884,
-0.0363433026,
-0.0527299494,
0.0402819738,
-0.063068144,
-0.0631154627,
0.0056543625,
-0.0088889729,
-0.0111206919,
0.0154371615,
-0.0274796523,
0.0366827622,
0.0339039378,
-0.0564360507,
0.0057592606,
-0.0189214647,
-0.0589862131,
-0.0163140502,
0.0307214316,
-0.0094993254,
0.0040916428,
0.0314814597,
0.0119206803,
-0.0358031318,
-0.0118014282,
-0.035656862,
0.0737620816,
-0.0379871503,
0.0274905041,
0.0223590247,
-0.0047473027,
-0.0313123539,
0.0300062653,
-0.0311079007,
-0.0098745832,
0.0365286134,
-0.0174539704,
-0.0075972355,
-0.0155471032,
0.006231091,
0.0156368185,
0.0057317032,
0.0297150798,
0.0089930175,
0.0725023896,
-0.0046450659,
-0.0376676321,
-0.0581524409,
0.0209834035,
-0.0200412814,
0.0290477946,
0.0146607561,
0.0214680769,
-0.0170392636,
0.0206140075,
-0.0397223867,
-0.0083430149,
0.0111736609,
-0.0221915096,
0.0033001911,
0.0154609885,
-0.0256291274,
-0.0096820565,
0.0072692242,
0.0137547953,
0.0200602189,
0.0171662159,
-0.0251778085,
-0.069205001,
0.0565088987,
-0.0002358415,
0.0138499402,
0.0084358202,
-0.0229457617,
0.0121713439,
-0.0286109913,
0.0444411188,
-0.0217555985,
-0.0012114106,
0.0010695248,
0.0570818447,
-0.002159006,
-0.0471373722,
0.0049576564,
-0.0096212113,
-0.0174026601,
-0.0197902806,
-0.0660214052,
0.0332202762,
0.0746080577,
0.0136289326,
0.0210156981,
-0.0888600871,
0.0029981423,
-0.0047566351,
-0.0250585321,
-0.0218121521,
-0.0181516036,
-0.0330157019,
0.0539864823,
-0.0365697742,
-0.0659226477,
0.0262285564,
-0.0753363445,
0.0071163289,
0.0031847544,
0.0100519117,
-0.0411174633,
0.0524756834,
0.0009165131,
0.0438389704,
0.015768338,
-0.0190602057,
-0.0114532029,
0.0521937236,
0.001711912,
-0.051411476,
0.0210667327,
-0.0461346395,
0.0242956989,
-0.0274140481,
-0.0381498933,
-0.0647219419,
-0.0218191613,
-0.0016647609,
-0.0000958025,
0.0667378083,
-0.0650137067,
0.0026071977,
0.0081935013,
-0.0219712351,
0.0400361829,
0.0014118827,
0.0000726322,
-0.0360634215,
0.0492282957,
0.0537495092,
-0.0005658384,
0.0042624949,
-0.0484476015,
0.0150410198,
0.0555448197,
0.0164655056,
0.0163906645,
-0.0041152453,
0.0074079703,
0.0529481843,
0.0160443336,
0.0077442406,
0.0384942554,
0.0370889716,
-0.0311390329,
-0.0402361639,
0.1159633622,
0.0582617037,
-0.0539191887,
0.0021631136,
-0.0385051221,
0.0745375231,
0.0115637966,
0.0242006425,
-0.1084995717,
-0.0285740178,
0.035870336,
0.0563612357,
0.0047241268,
-0.0011308105,
-0.0433690548,
-0.1085303277,
0.0260014199,
0.0604144037,
-0.0234367494,
0.0131606394,
-0.0148242833,
-0.0613854341,
0.0341394469,
0.0063365498,
0.035458874,
0.0030187266,
-0.0029251082,
0.0286068339,
-0.0130584138,
-0.0166565534,
-0.0259711184,
-0.0148637993,
0.0635210276,
0.0532011054,
0.0072810496,
0.0079499064,
-0.0124243042,
0.0363793522,
0.0180100016,
-0.0160657559,
-0.0391075276,
-0.0267211888,
-0.0049605868,
-0.0092685996,
-0.0164848436,
0.0225339904,
-0.0672312602,
-0.0329194404,
0.0072488114,
0.0792680457,
-0.0148097575,
0.002273794,
-0.0145868715,
-0.0194597431,
0.0449447334,
0.0812638104,
0.0291191358,
-0.044120755,
-0.0170289371,
-0.0612731352,
0.0073395981,
-0.0957722962,
-0.027240755,
0.0028780922,
0.0021379443,
-0.0296307188,
-0.086490564,
0.0000701594,
0.0033749966,
0.0083909295,
0.0098169884,
-0.0083433883,
0.0154616041,
-0.0553324632,
-0.0884821415,
-0.0170099176,
-0.0389152467,
-0.0100053735,
-0.087590158,
-0.0454626121,
-0.0029507305,
-0.0411037505,
0.0145514281,
0.0677611828,
-0.0695945024,
-0.059414953,
-0.0333153903,
0.0391884483,
0.0222649127,
0.0401338786,
-0.0206274576,
-0.0290365703,
0.0182312261,
0.0672759041,
-0.0374898948,
0.0223601479,
0.0262537114,
-0.0210235137,
-0.0019220582,
0.028150253,
-0.0423275828,
-0.0164304078,
-0.0244324934,
0.0645024106,
0.0062056947,
-0.0562628806,
0.048265107,
0.0294852909,
-0.0133384811,
-0.0806896016,
-0.0034033584,
0.0053576566,
0.0018930412,
-0.0384808742,
-0.0142398225,
-0.0414935462,
0.0225274656,
0.0359355472,
-0.0365408994,
0.0181550011,
0.0141058341,
-0.005037975,
0.0223514438,
0.0057009794,
0.0079163732,
-0.0270399861,
0.0071915798,
0.071620971,
-0.0285082906,
-0.0213574022,
0.0646519139,
-0.0328338183,
0.009906359,
-0.0336850695,
-0.0125317238,
0.0088941548,
0.024880223,
-0.0481391698,
0.0125168571,
0.0077371066,
-0.0258826613,
-0.0407754444,
0.0255831927,
0.0537531339,
0.0068756486,
0.0611302108,
-0.0504513532,
0.0108126365,
-0.0254166964,
0.0226843879,
0.0164755937,
-0.0399856158,
0.0006442642,
0.0192635395,
-0.0203379653,
-0.0087328209,
0.0800644904,
0.0544418022,
0.0373353325,
0.00000518,
-0.0118351877,
-0.0625095069,
-0.0425411724,
-0.0103386845,
0.012239038,
-0.0572431087,
0.0034270335,
-0.0547873452,
-0.0535052121,
0.022645548,
0.0382899083,
-0.0086786831,
-0.0040883957,
0.0132052787,
0.0109302271,
-0.0431884192,
-0.0109188156,
-0.0333151296,
0.0146508981,
-0.0236753598,
-0.0380003378,
-0.0075701205,
-6.480102892e-33,
-0.0329889059,
-0.0480510481,
0.0169911887,
-0.0180694703,
-0.0173299834,
0.0180883631,
-0.0529449098,
-0.0052654981,
0.0816034675,
-0.0226821471,
-0.0194191709,
-0.017540101,
0.0121901967,
0.0289170332,
-0.0256019812,
0.041202873,
0.0321770981,
-0.0180009548,
-0.050030116,
0.0071423594,
0.0332971327,
0.0282920189,
-0.0020225788,
-0.0134510659,
0.0049175713,
-0.0436738245,
-0.04079381,
-0.0002755644,
-0.0031045724,
0.0355214924,
-0.0552469641,
0.0280266143,
0.0081969937,
-0.00446859,
-0.0373933017,
0.0539144464,
-0.0618583038,
0.016963087,
0.0225535799,
-0.0077683651,
-0.0336840898,
-0.0723295063,
0.006451793,
0.0136950398,
-0.047825627,
0.0305585004,
-0.015421045,
-0.0388263315,
-0.0289840903,
-0.0681123659,
-0.0620801523,
0.0319292769,
0.0133228749,
-0.0147393895,
0.0431055389,
0.012160969,
-0.0137128169,
0.0020051312,
-0.0056332783,
0.0352275819,
0.0467239656,
0.051475428,
0.0682919845,
0.0404160954,
0.0050435308,
0.0427806228,
-0.0158588775,
-0.0282312054,
-0.035252206,
0.0184531864,
0.0247978792,
0.011109964,
-0.0200511888,
0.0388773419,
0.0502976812,
-0.0308252219,
-0.061146941,
0.0470819846,
-0.0475148335,
-0.0162006896,
0.0298146959,
0.004440411,
-0.0418590009,
-0.0239940006,
-0.0343634002,
0.003191584,
-0.0278334003,
-0.0047550811,
0.0456240326,
0.0453199819,
-0.0454078466,
-0.0448846705,
0.0263222549,
-0.0239333566,
-0.0047013871,
0.0318562835,
-0.0191220976,
0.0015599792,
-0.0476664491,
0.0369448476,
-0.016245503,
-0.0404677279,
0.0275420863,
-0.0184627324,
0.0252435356,
0.0244823582,
-0.0122245634,
0.0334304087,
-0.0601970702,
0.012469789,
-0.0500359498,
0.0421752259,
0.0218693167,
0.0347809643,
0.053647723,
-0.0294305775,
0.0106402952,
0.0268276092,
0.0037409654,
0.0026398636,
-0.016498981,
-0.0042046015,
0.0007078316,
0.0457385816,
-0.032375291,
0.0288036689,
-0.0323779099,
0.0237973556,
0.0215526447,
-0.0400538482,
-0.020363491,
0.0114261732,
2.697e-7,
0.027846761,
0.0767522603,
0.0783194527,
0.0122749703,
0.0278726015,
0.0051453579,
-0.0155662475,
0.0364812724,
-0.0585200638,
-0.0267661382,
0.0159937609,
0.0292336103,
0.0758241639,
0.014867832,
-0.0933409482,
0.0533961616,
-0.0351771191,
0.0205471627,
-0.0474838167,
-0.0143634565,
0.0745685697,
0.0641884953,
-0.043902725,
-0.0152333118,
0.0281168427,
-0.0475590676,
0.0587717518,
-0.0225095674,
-0.0062279957,
0.0062483172,
-0.0167116635,
0.0140689015,
-0.033629667,
-0.0229065344,
-0.0163027085,
-0.0008168142,
-0.0049527362,
0.0951628238,
0.0164528266,
0.0129001075,
0.0298873577,
-0.0260685571,
-0.0187192578,
-0.0112623293,
0.0342577957,
0.0215873681,
-0.0000228444,
-0.0281358678,
0.0058136382,
0.0040535191,
-0.032757096,
-0.0351332426,
-0.011696673,
0.027048761,
0.0229138806,
0.0095207533,
-0.0098489681,
-0.0398403518,
-0.0626459643,
-0.0392617024,
-0.0572615638,
-0.0315707438,
-0.0530851372,
0.0408536457,
0.029879516,
-0.0570010766,
0.0210724715,
3.038329636e-34,
0.0152502311,
0.0018171356,
-0.0028436065,
0.0547300018,
0.0164929051,
-0.0085043097,
-0.0105441939,
0.0307466704,
-0.002669475,
-0.0777039975,
-0.0121075753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04833v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04833v2 | Long Is More for Alignment: A Simple but Tough-to-Beat Baseline for Instruction Fine-Tuning | 2024-02-07T13:32:11 | 2024-06-04T17:20:01 | Hao Zhao, Maksym Andriushchenko, Francesco Croce, Nicolas Flammarion | cs.CL | cs.CL | There is a consensus that instruction fine-tuning of LLMs requires
high-quality data, but what are they? LIMA (NeurIPS 2023) and AlpaGasus (ICLR
2024) are state-of-the-art methods for selecting such high-quality examples,
either via manual curation or using GPT-3.5-Turbo as a quality scorer. We show
that the extremely simple baseline of selecting the 1,000 instructions with
longest responses -- that intuitively contain more learnable information and
are harder to overfit -- from standard datasets can consistently outperform
these sophisticated methods according to GPT-4 and PaLM-2 as judges, while
remaining competitive on the Open LLM benchmarks that test factual knowledge.
We demonstrate this for several LLMs (Llama-2-7B, Llama-2-13B, Mistral-7B-v0.1)
and datasets (Alpaca-52k, Evol-Instruct-70k). In addition, a lightweight
refinement of such long instructions can further improve the abilities of the
fine-tuned LLMs, and allows us to obtain competitive results on MT-Bench and
the 2nd highest-ranked Llama-2-7B-based model on AlpacaEval 2.0, while training
on only 1,000 examples and no extra preference data. We also conduct a thorough
analysis of our models to ensure that their enhanced performance is not simply
due to GPT-4's preference for longer responses. Overall, our findings suggest
that fine-tuning on the longest responses should be the default baseline for
any work on instruction fine-tuning. We provide our code at
https://github.com/tml-epfl/long-is-more-for-alignment. | [
0.0044862661,
0.0378734805,
0.0124201113,
0.0386408791,
-0.0103865657,
0.0223354716,
-0.0038878669,
0.0120641226,
-0.0323611163,
-0.0367604308,
-0.0520776324,
-0.0055812178,
0.0159113109,
-0.0261936635,
0.0227668472,
-0.0108282715,
0.0491887964,
-0.0219040085,
-0.0174801536,
0.0011559902,
-0.013361685,
-0.0033548165,
-0.0088091241,
0.0023374895,
0.025053177,
-0.0110643189,
-0.0276721157,
0.0186532922,
0.0389465168,
-0.0277968459,
0.0337724015,
0.0332474262,
0.0094005838,
0.0202623941,
0.0000020865,
-0.0466282889,
-0.0093184458,
0.0096964603,
-0.0402815603,
0.0377932079,
-0.019008249,
-0.0047012293,
-0.0109513346,
0.0155893862,
-0.0153617067,
0.0258151721,
0.0467424914,
0.021807557,
0.0514416248,
0.1245738938,
0.0185395479,
-0.0462408289,
0.0455490574,
-0.0298482403,
0.046407856,
-0.0225370992,
0.008211392,
-0.0233760457,
-0.0067700045,
0.0280546192,
-0.0153178237,
-0.0097506857,
0.0279399939,
0.0356510766,
-0.0060857702,
0.0182806049,
-0.0196560398,
-0.0152286123,
0.0045367386,
0.0734265819,
-0.0016904752,
0.0164859481,
-0.003230853,
-0.0231195129,
0.0036914055,
-0.0459068641,
-0.0229525678,
0.0197183248,
-0.0147058815,
0.0373832174,
0.0135655729,
-0.0140590109,
0.027072873,
-0.0244604778,
-0.0029800518,
0.0695816576,
0.0079999836,
-0.036890205,
0.0144993039,
-0.0087713385,
0.004200235,
-0.0190780237,
-0.0479337871,
0.0509347096,
-0.0183250699,
0.0182537064,
-0.0505308583,
0.0390392207,
0.0492772311,
-0.0034676641,
0.0831672475,
0.0490729809,
-0.0215656552,
0.0182295796,
-0.0631199703,
0.0637157336,
-0.0108746281,
0.0858696327,
-0.0338803641,
0.0359163359,
-0.0505452231,
0.0496648103,
0.0279465858,
0.0377008393,
-0.0488463193,
0.0233821962,
-0.0722986534,
0.0050830892,
-0.005175163,
0.041506473,
0.0229053088,
-0.0177857727,
-0.0359977409,
0.0251507927,
-0.0632473379,
0.023085285,
-0.0364712551,
0.0076446319,
-0.0035039731,
-0.0590231866,
-0.0362904966,
0.0166120231,
-0.0417894311,
-0.0313675851,
0.0562812537,
0.0746063963,
-0.0177753121,
-0.0488768704,
-0.0559851378,
-0.0138781238,
-0.009462527,
-0.1008733809,
0.0618331619,
-0.0568857417,
0.0539221093,
-0.0115255723,
0.0027685771,
-0.0153875304,
0.0256769955,
0.0156760216,
-0.0088206222,
0.059800528,
0.0115597611,
-0.0151757719,
-0.0181001183,
0.0137369372,
-0.0148845892,
0.0556086302,
0.032400839,
0.0304897167,
0.0189739633,
-0.0133761028,
-0.0031717564,
0.0221560895,
0.0177645124,
0.012435751,
0.0287583731,
0.0309082326,
0.0121670496,
0.0338726342,
0.0667829961,
0.0039177579,
-0.004649288,
-0.047921136,
0.0385487303,
0.0039638528,
0.0287039336,
0.0014065383,
0.0461923704,
-0.0059355758,
0.0189810153,
0.0334640034,
-0.0920231268,
0.0501904003,
-0.0187051091,
0.0474034138,
0.0196526106,
0.0522649102,
-0.0296985041,
-0.0664106309,
-0.0123833707,
-0.0209257156,
-0.0362507701,
0.0138876755,
0.004056857,
-0.0463151261,
-0.0689211339,
0.0452135988,
0.0489367917,
-0.0110522434,
-0.0461458713,
-0.075291723,
0.0408562608,
0.040784467,
0.0052914652,
-0.0301320776,
-0.0652778298,
-0.017605681,
-0.0066097439,
0.0294323638,
0.0217764117,
0.0061726877,
0.0478298664,
-0.0643802136,
-0.0327033214,
-0.0482978374,
0.0042814785,
0.0128909834,
0.0517333932,
-0.0004070057,
0.0200685784,
-0.0133638317,
-0.0262103286,
0.053910926,
-0.0146771064,
-0.0824074745,
-0.0414576605,
0.0210667942,
0.0448003151,
0.0011085928,
0.0029949385,
-0.0088816024,
0.0540804975,
0.0019654301,
0.0415570624,
-0.0791273266,
-0.0621722341,
-0.0373139046,
0.0572504438,
-0.0211309791,
-0.0174923372,
0.0153548513,
-0.0766313747,
-0.0427671783,
-0.0525476001,
-0.0294173583,
-0.0014972091,
0.0028429935,
0.0273629334,
0.0001735334,
-0.0022068941,
-0.0499524772,
0.0354839303,
-0.022716485,
0.0168848224,
0.0100122122,
-0.0141644925,
0.0123009169,
-0.040194124,
-0.003641343,
0.0126764979,
0.0025170969,
0.0095483838,
-0.0069286488,
0.0553730056,
-0.0577462055,
-0.0563176796,
-0.0564863943,
0.0426925495,
-0.0167239308,
0.0417943336,
0.0293737371,
-0.0315846652,
-0.0232275091,
0.0128042875,
-0.0304370299,
-0.0082345977,
-0.0192085747,
0.0079874909,
0.0417899638,
0.0278604608,
-0.0455666035,
-0.0568694398,
-0.0145190973,
-0.0009662933,
-0.0170837268,
-0.0274482947,
0.0195002407,
-0.0438184403,
0.0264481381,
-0.0384524763,
0.0094229272,
-0.0265844632,
-0.0719863176,
0.0244184695,
0.0159620885,
-0.0189070143,
0.0933633074,
-0.0212651305,
0.0227133948,
0.0375081785,
0.0209448468,
-0.0647243485,
0.0403244495,
-0.0288940091,
-0.0602261797,
-0.0554400682,
-0.0303629655,
-0.0082903607,
0.070073016,
-0.0109639931,
0.0097732339,
-0.0567260869,
-0.0167845022,
0.0436313525,
-0.0043895259,
0.0483478606,
0.0343356468,
-0.0366689935,
0.0005770235,
-0.0377574451,
-0.0878263637,
0.0744434744,
-0.0291983783,
0.0026688983,
-0.0420804508,
-0.0112366593,
-0.0468561277,
0.0090772491,
0.0134054404,
0.0007371277,
-0.0195059273,
0.0066308943,
-0.058503598,
-0.0069445991,
0.0214755982,
-0.0385103114,
0.0772866011,
-0.0303010922,
-0.0238368567,
-0.0418924429,
-0.0427230634,
-0.0262970012,
0.022645643,
0.0108166644,
0.009976577,
0.0163065922,
-0.0364720672,
-0.0441546515,
-0.0475098416,
0.0322396494,
0.0115371691,
-0.039906472,
0.0033866928,
-0.0499912687,
-0.0284388941,
0.0328749046,
0.0057694665,
0.0106122419,
-0.0412763394,
0.0109144431,
0.044186838,
0.0210515969,
-0.0232203975,
-0.0400491469,
0.0124652404,
0.0229912605,
-0.0594660752,
-0.0252354611,
0.0591164157,
0.1017672271,
-0.0422857217,
0.0121554006,
0.0970808864,
0.0063184341,
-0.0218003895,
-0.0059486586,
0.025778152,
0.0349176303,
0.0339303687,
0.0250637159,
-0.0480112396,
-0.0386813208,
-0.0137539096,
0.0568286777,
-0.0007705615,
-0.0049923803,
0.0024190845,
-0.1012789011,
0.0211449433,
0.0389198549,
-0.0376345553,
-0.0513301156,
-0.0389785804,
0.0047192057,
-0.0172169879,
0.0293086711,
0.0150567126,
-0.0432939567,
-0.0019285224,
0.0241183601,
0.0017022296,
-0.0376971327,
0.0489435457,
-0.0182597712,
0.0632440224,
0.0566364489,
-0.0049610855,
0.0160082653,
-0.060897328,
0.0366456695,
-0.0327266306,
0.0348909758,
-0.0064917044,
0.0627788529,
0.0011459653,
0.006750592,
-0.0039356453,
0.035574764,
0.0006164651,
0.0156610087,
0.0072504655,
0.0617979541,
-0.0161819365,
0.0189277548,
-0.0205736086,
-0.0217956528,
-0.0102275657,
0.0431679413,
0.0305098351,
0.0004303312,
-0.0481991842,
-0.0288368203,
-0.0248277318,
-0.0586727969,
0.0085521378,
0.0387963802,
-0.051890891,
0.0125291506,
-0.0476456285,
-0.0635055229,
0.0184728149,
0.039642293,
-0.002314186,
-0.03447631,
-0.0199261233,
-0.0107861031,
-0.0321966186,
0.0575593375,
-0.0285845995,
0.0153044229,
-0.1137375236,
-0.0366099663,
0.0218370426,
0.0088825822,
-0.0034667801,
0.0257903021,
-0.0792740285,
-0.0719650835,
-0.0079143532,
0.0941977277,
0.0229178108,
0.073004514,
0.0175602604,
0.0064849108,
0.0357077233,
0.0251501109,
-0.0161436144,
0.0316999443,
0.049988851,
0.0086650597,
-0.0137337744,
0.009602163,
-0.0294329934,
0.0210423488,
0.0359655395,
0.0190739539,
-0.0286041629,
-0.0477055535,
0.0141436886,
0.0260344073,
0.0566582121,
-0.0264127702,
-0.000420235,
0.0108262319,
0.0437275656,
-0.0001586719,
0.0383137502,
-0.0165295955,
-0.0216062032,
0.0178694278,
-0.028815886,
0.0136305606,
-0.0105729485,
-0.0115147661,
0.0451216064,
-0.055952765,
0.049409844,
-0.0215447284,
-0.0067152572,
0.0086537972,
0.0190504212,
-0.0330095291,
0.0350165963,
0.0173128787,
0.047652591,
0.0245774258,
0.0582554117,
0.0063050673,
0.0658642873,
-0.0282734428,
0.0320243575,
-0.0298015103,
-0.0070333355,
-0.0619626865,
0.0098231919,
0.0563733466,
-0.0082709026,
0.0265321713,
0.0122395689,
-0.0163623821,
-0.0189536884,
0.0306454077,
-0.0378430001,
0.0166504811,
0.042512279,
0.0525904968,
0.0012407772,
-0.0242712963,
0.075387612,
-0.0014791898,
0.0638488233,
-0.0007591544,
0.0307993945,
-0.052208975,
-0.0556199066,
0.0162059385,
-0.0097100502,
0.0113134235,
-0.0247697663,
-0.0343592651,
-0.0392714441,
0.0036576912,
0.0284967255,
-0.0092552742,
-0.0216454025,
0.0522391498,
0.0144028729,
-0.0179937854,
-0.0495004952,
-0.0070342678,
-0.0369829945,
0.014134109,
-0.0197122861,
-0.0089075435,
-6.466689032e-33,
-0.0495861769,
-0.0046552327,
0.0433855169,
0.0080631301,
-0.049206946,
-0.0107636349,
-0.0084580351,
-0.0209452752,
-0.0297304355,
-0.0038904159,
-0.0041408069,
-0.0203795731,
0.0204388071,
-0.0104292175,
0.0196527522,
-0.0520125516,
0.0302962009,
-0.015334852,
-0.0423590951,
0.0034568566,
0.0018733158,
-0.0114905713,
0.0584919117,
-0.0507009886,
0.0124177355,
0.0172523558,
-0.0104437582,
-0.0012582147,
-0.0740892962,
0.0942121223,
0.0176838208,
0.0231612939,
0.0026665097,
-0.0249643512,
-0.013889675,
-0.0446698628,
-0.0521592125,
-0.0402068198,
0.0184716228,
0.0033854716,
-0.0155912871,
-0.0798480213,
0.0478625335,
-0.0002784003,
-0.053499382,
-0.0667095929,
0.0222145319,
-0.035607107,
-0.0278962124,
-0.0286160223,
-0.0380118228,
0.0109772906,
0.0049870284,
-0.0277752616,
0.0067874971,
0.0188284609,
0.0330807976,
0.0305146202,
-0.0590538383,
0.0060370322,
0.0273865331,
0.0671607405,
0.0677281544,
0.0206845514,
0.0116811879,
0.0200472027,
-0.0073067169,
-0.0133699849,
0.0135439122,
-0.0076536699,
-0.0061005172,
0.0797563568,
0.0332849436,
0.0149455853,
0.039526578,
0.0101727881,
-0.0832194984,
0.0457500033,
-0.0033628773,
0.0426846743,
-0.0169971362,
0.0085166218,
-0.0694593862,
0.0080891345,
-0.0314224325,
0.0260739345,
-0.0105160726,
-0.0239737928,
0.027457526,
0.0244276803,
0.0143395616,
-0.0014398011,
0.0205568299,
0.0026575844,
0.0149745103,
-0.0161958393,
-0.0213531703,
0.0153927794,
0.0050642537,
-0.0039061161,
-0.0372897796,
-0.0677690282,
0.0193261057,
-0.0326805785,
0.0545114391,
-0.0137106096,
0.0331730843,
0.0326719023,
-0.0746050179,
-0.0011402098,
-0.0400399528,
0.033737354,
0.0141274789,
-0.0282415003,
0.0161899887,
-0.0208621211,
0.0021713986,
0.0734242052,
-0.0244527794,
-0.0038356602,
-0.0136288637,
-0.0318986587,
0.0084020365,
0.0506883636,
-0.0160438009,
0.0430633388,
-0.0014818889,
0.0109107187,
-0.0354981758,
-0.0352783538,
-0.0207795277,
0.0416594036,
2.736e-7,
0.0198008567,
0.0361734889,
0.0457094498,
0.0491868816,
-0.0091707697,
0.0378423072,
-0.0311993156,
0.0079875169,
-0.0142339198,
-0.0447590463,
0.0204065852,
0.0401452258,
0.0499994941,
0.0114711663,
-0.0524395071,
0.0176123902,
-0.0176858772,
0.0198241975,
-0.0701267943,
-0.0052509923,
0.0452680625,
0.0887458101,
0.0071052117,
-0.0033314202,
0.0153974183,
0.017103985,
0.0381425731,
-0.0391256064,
-0.0099282041,
0.0274278447,
0.045884572,
-0.011587223,
-0.0185009968,
0.00291589,
-0.0150986258,
0.0120332586,
-0.0418755636,
0.1126093343,
0.0104784621,
-0.0668649152,
0.0319454968,
-0.0239703152,
0.0197838005,
-0.0371354185,
0.0674815848,
-0.0260715745,
-0.0042117424,
0.015076193,
-0.029749997,
-0.0266900733,
0.0378353111,
-0.0155458357,
0.0322008543,
0.0286157727,
-0.0014103808,
-0.0369780585,
-0.0175012536,
-0.0594514422,
-0.025452612,
0.0384237692,
-0.0334737636,
-0.0557832569,
-0.0518336855,
0.0190507229,
0.0209442619,
-0.0596647374,
-0.0468930826,
2.713709295e-34,
0.0027298471,
-0.0693109855,
0.0409447923,
0.0240180567,
0.0146580748,
-0.003933324,
-0.0388028249,
0.0216191709,
0.0122192744,
-0.043683093,
-0.011728649
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.